Theory U
This page intentionally left blank
Theory U Leading From the Future as it Emerges T H E
S O C I A L O F
T E C H N O L O G Y
P R E S E N C I N G
C. OTTO SCHARMER
Theory U Copyright © 2009 by C. Otto Scharmer All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, distributed, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including photocopying, recording, or other electronic or mechanical methods, without the prior written permission of the publisher, except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical reviews and certain other noncommercial uses permitted by copyright law. For permission requests, write to the publisher, addressed “Attention: Permissions Coordinator,” at the address below. Berrett-Koehler Publishers, Inc. 235 Montgomery Street, Suite 650 San Francisco, California 94104-2916 Tel: (415) 288-0260, Fax: (415) 362-2512 www.bkconnection.com Ordering information for print editions Quantity sales. Special discounts are available on quantity purchases by corporations, associations, and others. For details, contact the “Special Sales Department” at the Berrett-Koehler address above. Individual sales. Berrett-Koehler publications are available through most bookstores. They can also be ordered directly from Berrett-Koehler: Tel: (800) 929-2929; Fax: (802) 864-7626; www.bkconnection.com Orders for college textbook/course adoption use. Please contact Berrett-Koehler: Tel: (800) 929-2929; Fax: (802) 864-7626. Orders by U.S. trade bookstores and wholesalers. Please contact Ingram Publisher Services, Tel: (800) 509-4887; Fax: (800) 838-1149; E-mail: customer
[email protected]; or visit www.ingrampublisherservices.com/ Ordering for details about electronic ordering. Berrett-Koehler and the BK logo are registered trademarks of Berrett-Koehler Publishers, Inc. First Edition Paperback print edition ISBN 978-1-57675-763-5 PDF e-book ISBN 978-1-57675-866-3 2008-1
Dedicated to Katrin Käufer
This page intentionally left blank
Man knows himself only to the extent that he knows the world; he becomes aware of himself only within the world, and aware of the world only within himself. Every object, well contemplated, opens up a new organ of perception within us.
– Johann Wolfgang v. Goethe
This page intentionally left blank
Contents
Foreword by Peter Senge
vii
Acknowledgments
xv
Introduction
1
Part 1 Bumping into Our Blind Spot Chapter 1
Facing the Fire
23
Chapter 2
The Journey to “U”
27
Chapter 3
Fourfold Learning and Change
49
Chapter 4
Organizational Complexity
59
Chapter 5
Shifts in Society
81
Chapter 6
Philosophical Grounding
Chapter 7
On the Threshold
105 111
Part II
Entering the U Field Chapter 8
Downloading
119
Chapter 9
Seeing
129
Chapter 10
Sensing
143
Chapter 11
Presencing
163
Chapter 12
Crystallizing
191
Chapter 13
Prototyping
203
Chapter 14
Performing
215
Part III Presencing: A Social Technology for Leading Profound Innovation and Change Chapter 15
The Grammar of the Social Field
231
Chapter 16
Individual Actions
261
Chapter 17
Conversational Actions
271
Chapter 18
Organizational Actions
301
Chapter 19
Global Actions
327
Chapter 20 Catching Social Reality Creation in Flight Chapter 21
355
Principles and Practices of Presencing for Leading Profound Innovation and Change
Epilogue:
377
Birthing a Global Presencing-in-Action University
443
Glossary
463
Notes
471
Bibliography
487
Index
511
About the Author
531
About the Organizations
533
Foreword P e t er M . S e nge
A
longtime mentor of mine once said that the greatest of all human inventions is the creative process, how we bring forth new realities. Understanding the creative process is the foundation of genuine
mastery in all fields. This knowledge is deeply embedded in the creative arts and, though rarely spoken of, defines those moments “where there is magic in the air” in theater, music, dance, and sports. It pervades the mysterious state of surrender whereby, in Michelangelo’s words, the sculptor “releases the hand from the marble that holds it prisoner” or, in Picasso’s statement, “the mind finds its way to the crystallization of its dream.” It plays no lesser role in science; as the economist W. Brian Arthur states: “all great discoveries come from a deep inner journey.” Against this backdrop of deeply shared but largely esoteric knowledge, Otto Scharmer suggests that the key to addressing the multiple unfolding crises of our time—and the future course of human development—lies in learning how to access this source of mastery collectively. xi
xii
THEORY U
Two predominant strategies characterize reactions to the unfolding environmental and social breakdowns evident in climate change, political paralysis and corruption, spreading poverty, and the failures of mainstream institutions of education, health care, government, and business: “muddling through” and “fighting back.” Muddling through is the strategy that characterizes most of us in the rich northern countries. It embraces a combination of working to preserve the status quo combined with an almost hypnotic fascination with wondrous new technologies that, so the belief goes, will solve our problems. Fighting back, as is evident in the vocal protests of millions of people around the world opposed to the “Washington consensus” view of globalization, combines a longing for an earlier social and moral order with anger at having lost control over our future. But beyond surface differences, the two strategies and their adherents are not as dissimilar as they may first appear. Many—perhaps most—of the “muddlers” share a pervasive uneasiness. This is evident in anxiety about the future, growing dissatisfaction with and distrust of virtually all social institutions, and withdrawal from public discourse and civic engagement. Even those who say little about it sense that deep imbalances exist in the global industrialization process and that these threaten to worsen. But there is little hope that anything can be done about them; hence we “carry on carrying on.” Perhaps the ultimate irony is that even the most ardent technological optimists feel deep down that the course of technology development shapes itself and that there is little that can be done about it. Likewise, many of those fighting back share similar fatalistic feelings of trying to stop immutable forces, as evidenced by the anger and violence of their actions. As a dear friend and recognized leader in the environmental movement recently confided, “I am becoming convinced that many of the most aggressive environmentalists believe that the human species is deeply flawed and does not deserve to survive.” Last, both strategies are anchored in the past: advocates of the status quo future basically extrapolate what they regard as positive trends from the past; opponents fight these trends. Otto Scharmer’s Theory U embodies a third view, one that I believe is growing around the world. This view holds that the future will, inevitably, be
Theory U
very different from the past, simply because the predominant trends that have shaped global industrial development cannot continue. We cannot continue to concentrate wealth in a world of growing interdependence. We cannot continue to expand the “take, make, waste” industrial model in a world where there is, increasingly, no “away” to throw our waste and toxins to. We cannot continue to put more and more carbon into the atmosphere, when carbon dioxide concentration is already 30 percent higher than at any time in the past 450,000 years and carbon dioxide emissions are already at three to five times the rate at which the substance is being removed from the atmosphere. Second, this view holds that we are not powerless to alter the dominant trends of the industrial age. These trends are based not on the laws of physics but on human habits, albeit habits on a large scale. These habitual ways of thinking and acting become embedded over time in social structures we enact, but alternative social structures can also be created. Achieving the changes needed means nothing less than “creating the world anew,” based on a radically different view, as you will see below, of our collective capacity to, as Martin Buber put it, “Listen to the course of being in the world . . . and bring it to reality as it desires.” As a friend and partner of Otto Scharmer for more than ten years now in developing this work, I have been waiting for this book, as have many of our colleagues. Without question, we regard Otto as the premier theorist of the “U methodology.” Moreover, his extensive practical experience, especially in long-term systemic change projects, gives him a unique depth of understanding of the challenges and possibilities of applying the methodology. Those of us involved with this work also have come to appreciate that understanding and gaining proficiency as a practitioner with the U methodology take time. I think this learning starts with thinking seriously about a few basic ideas, and I think the book will help a great deal with this. First, in every setting, from working teams to organizations to larger social systems, there is much more going on than meets the eye. Many of us have known firsthand the excitement and energy of a team that is deeply engaged in its work, where there are trust, openness, and a pervasive sense of possibility. Conversely, we also have seen the opposite, where fear and distrust
xiii
xiv
THEORY U
pervade and where each statement has thick political overtones of defending one’s position or attacking others’. Scharmer calls this the “social field” and has, to my mind, unique insights into how it arises and can evolve. Sadly, mostly it does not evolve. The social field of most families, teams, organizations, and societies remains largely unchanged because our level of attention renders it invisible. We do not attend to the subtle forces shaping what happens because we are too busy reacting to these forces. We see problems, then “download” our established mental models to both define the problems and come up with solutions. For example, when we listen, we usually hear very little other than what we have heard before. “There she goes again,” calls out the voice in our heads. From that point onward, we selectively hear only what we recognize, interpret what we hear based on our past views and feelings, and draw conclusions much like those we have drawn before. So long as this level of listening prevails, actions tend to preserve the status quo, even though the actors may sincerely espouse an intention to change. Change efforts that arise from this level of attention usually focus on making changes in “them” or in “the system” or on “implementing” a predetermined “change process,” or in fixing some other externalized object— rarely on how “I” and “we” must change in order to allow the larger system to change. When the “structure of attention” moves deeper, so too does the ensuing change process. Here Scharmer identifies three levels of deeper awareness and the related dynamics of change. “Seeing our seeing,” so to speak, requires the intelligences of the open mind, the open heart, and the open will. The first opening arises when people truly start to recognize their own taken-for-granted assumptions and start to hear and see things that were not evident before. This is the beginning of all real learning and a key, for example, for a business attempting to decipher significant changes in its environment. Still, recognizing something new does not necessarily lead to acting differently. For that to happen, we need a deeper level of attention, one that allows people to step outside their traditional experience and truly feel beyond the mind. For example, countless businesses have been unable to change in
Theory U
response to changes in their environments even though they recognize those changes intellectually. Why? As Arie de Geus, author and former planning coordinator at Royal Dutch Shell, says, “the signals of a new reality simply could not penetrate the corporate immune system.” Conversely, when people living inside a shifting reality begin to “see” what was previously unseen and see their own part in maintaining the old and inhibiting or denying the new, the dam starts to break. This can happen in a company or a country. For example, in my experience, this deeper seeing began to occur widely in South Africa in the mid- to late 1980s and is happening in many parts of the world today. This requires people from many different parts of a society, including many within the power establishment, to “wake up” to the threats they face if the future continues the trends of the past. In South Africa, enough people started to see that the country simply had no future if the apartheid system stayed in place and that they were part of that system. When this sort of waking up starts to happen, it is crucial that people also “see” that the future could be different, lest they either be paralyzed by the new awareness or react in ways that still preserve the essence of the old system. By this “seeing into the future,” I do not mean they are convinced intellectually that something can change. We all know what it means to nod our heads and then go right back to doing what we have always done. Rather, a third level of “seeing” can unfold that unlocks our deepest levels of commitment. This open will is the most difficult of the three shifts to explain in abstract terms, but it can be powerful and self-evident in concrete terms. For South Africans twenty years ago, I believe it unfolded in whites’ and blacks’ discovering their love for their country—not for their government or established systems, but for their country itself. I heard this expressed first in many conversations with white South Africans, who, to my surprise, declared that they were “Africans,” that they felt deeply connected to the land, and the place, and the people of the country. This deep connection to place existed for most black South Africans as well, despite their oppression. I truly believe that the new South Africa was forged through this common connection, this deep sense that it was an almost sacred duty to create a country that could survive and thrive in the future—and only together could this be done.
xv
xvi
THEORY U
The open will often manifests in the sense that “This is something that I (or we) must do, even though the ‘how’ may be far from clear.” I have often heard people say, ‘This is something I cannot not do.’” As our colleague Joseph Jaworski says, “We surrender” into this sort of commitment. This is similar to what others have termed “recognizing a calling,” although many times I have heard people speak of this without the parallel understanding of the open mind and the open heart. When responding to a “calling” is not coupled with the continual opening of the mind and heart, commitment easily becomes fanatical obsession and the creative process becomes a distorted exercise in willpower. A key feature of Theory U is the connection of all three openings—mind, heart and will—as an inseparable whole. When all three levels of opening occur, there is a profound shift in the nature of learning. Virtually all well-known theories of learning focus on learning from the past: how we can learn from what has already happened. Though this type of learning is always important, it is not enough when we are moving into a future that differs profoundly from the past. Then a second, much less well recognized, type of learning must come into play. This is what Scharmer calls “learning from the future as it emerges.” Learning from the future is vital to innovation. Learning from the future involves intuition. It involves embracing high levels of ambiguity, uncertainty, and willingness to fail. It involves opening ourselves to the unthinkable and sometimes attempting to do the impossible. But the fears and risks are balanced by feeling ourselves part of something important that is emerging that will truly make a difference. Finally, the theory and methodology of the U have a great deal to say about the nature of leadership, especially leadership in times of great turbulence and systemic change. This leadership comes from all levels, not only from “the top,” because significant innovation is about doing things differently, not just talking about new ideas. This leadership arises from people and groups who are capable of letting go of established ideas, practices, and even identities. Most of all, this leadership comes as people start to connect deeply with who they really are and their part in both creating what is and realizing a future that embodies what they care most deeply about.
Theory U
Though these ideas are critical elements of Theory U, what is especially important is that they are not just theory. They have arisen from extensive practical experience with the U methodology. Woven throughout the following chapters are stories about and reflections on long-term change initiatives in business, health care, and education. For example, the largest systemic change project I have yet seen, the Sustainable Food Laboratory, today involves more than fifty businesses and nongovernmental and governmental organizations working together to address the forces driving global food systems in a “race to the bottom” and to create prototypes of alternative, sustainable food systems. You’ll also find here other examples that cover health care, education, and business innovation. While practical know-how in implementing Theory U is still in its infancy, these projects demonstrate clearly that these principles can be translated into practice and that, when this is done, they reveal immense capacities for changing social systems that previously appeared to many to be unchangeable. There are many encouraging systemic change initiatives in the world today. Yet what is largely missing is a way to develop the capacity to develop collective wisdom across diverse settings and involving diverse organizations and actors, especially in the context of confronting multisector, multistakeholder challenges. What do you do when confronting such a problem? Theory U suggests that the basic procedure to shift social fields is the same across all levels, from teams to organizations to larger social systems, even to global systems—laid out in a summary of 24 principles and practices in the last chapter of this book. I see these not so much as the “final word” but as an extraordinary protocol to engage many of us who are active in forging a social technology for real leadership. Finally, a word to the reader. This is an unusual book because it lays out theory and method in equal proportions. Although many academic books expound theories, they usually represent their authors’ thinking but not their lived experience. On the other hand, most management books are full of purported practical ideas but very light on where these ideas come from—the presumption apparently being that most practical people are too busy fixing
xvii
xviii
THEORY U
problems to have much interest in serious thinking. In the pages that follow, Otto Scharmer shares his autobiography with us. And his blind spots. He encourages us to look at the problems we each face, and learn to recognize that they arise from systematic blind spots in our thinking and ways of doing things. When that is the case, new tools and techniques applied from within the same mental models and ways of operating are not likely to produce much real change. As he illustrates, we all need alternative ways forward, and the U model is one. Integrating theory and method places real demands on the reader, and this undoubtedly is why such books are rare. They require us to be both open to a challenging intellectual journey and to be willing to form our critical understanding based on testing the ideas in practice. Too many books continue the “downloading” of unexamined assumptions and beliefs, even while challenging us intellectually with new ideas. The question is always one of practice—of doing, not just thinking. So consider yourself warned. To truly benefit from this book on Theory U, you must be prepared to undertake your own journey of sensing, presencing, and realizing. In this sense, this is a book for those whom my MIT colleague, Donald Schön, called “reflective practitioners,” managers, principals, team leaders, government officials, and community organizers who are far too committed to practical results and dissatisfied with their current capabilities to rest on past habits; pragmatic, engaged people who are open to challenging their own assumptions and listening to their deepest inner voice. For it is only through this listening that we will unlock our collective capacity to create the world anew.
Acknowledgments
D
ad, will you ever be finished with that book?” I completed the first draft of Theory U when our nine-year-old daughter, Hannah
Magdalena, was born. She and her younger brother, Johan Caspar,
have lived with it all their lives. In the meantime, they have both produced numerous handwritten “books,” graciously reminding me of my own uncompleted project. Now that it’s completed, my first and foremost thanks go to Katrin and our children, Hannah and Johan Caspar, who, all three, have never given up on me over the past ten years. I want to express my deepest appreciation to a unique circle of colleagues and friends with whom I have had the privilege to work over the past couple of years and who helped me to become aware of and clarify the various key elements of the theory that is outlined throughout this book. This circle includes: Joseph Jaworski, who coined the notion and practice of sensing and who taught me many things on the journey, including what it takes as an individual to connect and operate from source; xix
xx
THEORY U
Peter Senge, who inspired my thinking about a deeper view on social systems, namely, that the real issue of systems change is the split between matter and mind that we collectively enact in the various social systems. Peter encouraged me to stick to the term “presencing,” even though I got a lot of negative feedback when I first started using it. In my joint work with Joseph and Peter, we refined and sharpened many of the initial core ideas that underlie the U process, as we documented in our book Presence: An Exploration of Profound Change in People, Organizations, and Society, which we co-authored with Betty Sue Flowers. Peter’s work brought me to the United States, and his partnership and friendship have been crucial to the work that led to this book; Ikujiro Nonaka, who has inspired my thinking by his work on ba, the Japanese word for “place,” which represents the quality of a social field in which the split between matter and mind on a collective level does not apply, and his continued integration of deep philosophical and management thought (as exemplified in his concepts of tacit knowledge and phronesis). Jiro has supported my work through personal encouragement and friendship over many years; Edgar Schein, who, with his living, teaching, and embodying of his Process Consultation philosophy, has not only provided the backbone for all of my consulting work but also, particularly through his principles of process consultation, has created a real parent discipline for the U process of presencing that continues to inspire and influence my work; Katrin Käufer, who has been a major thinking partner in the process of articulating Theory U and has greatly contributed to clarifying the core concepts that underlie this work. Among others, she made me aware of the fire story and how it exemplifies the two types of learning. Katrin has also provided much of the leadership in various research projects that now have led to the formation of the Presencing Institute, which we have founded to function as a vehicle for investigating and developing the foundations of presencing and leading profound change; Ursula Versteegen, who has been my close colleague in various significant projects of presencing-based systems transformation and leadership capacity
Theory U
building programs and who co-developed with me the practice of deep-listening and dialogue interviews; Judith Flick and Martin Kalungu-Banda, who are my colleagues in using the U process approach in a multistakeholder project on beating HIV/AIDS in Zambia and to whom I owe much of my understanding of profound multistakeholder innovation under the conditions of pandemic challenges, systemic breakdowns, and social disintegration; Dayna Cunningham, who leads and co-creates with me and others the global ELIAS project and who has helped me understand and refine the use of the U process in the context of marginality and massive structural and cultural violence; Beth Jandernoa and the Circle of Seven, who are described in Chapters 10 and 11 in detail and to whom I owe a lot of my understanding on the collective dimension of operating from source—presencing—and what practices it takes to cultivate the collective holding space. They practice this discipline faithfully, and I am grateful that they have held me and this writing project over the past two years; Charles and Elizabeth Handy, who always encouraged me to keep going and who suggested I use the term “blind spot” as a key phrase as well as an anchor concept of the book; Ken Wilber, who made me aware of the distinction between states of consciousness and developmental stages and who suggested that the different levels of the U coincide with different states of consciousness that he has found across all cultures and wisdom traditions; Nicanor Perlas, to whom I owe the concept of threefold and trisector collaboration among the three sectors of business, government, and civil society; Ekkehard Kappler, to whom I owe nearly all my insights and practices about the university of the future and who pioneered the concept of higher education as the “praxis of freedom” in which studying does not mean “to fill a barrel” but “to light a flame”; Arthur Zajonc, to whom I owe the deepening of my understanding of the Goetheanic method of science and how it evolved in the work of Rudolf Steiner and Francisco Varela;
xxi
xxii
THEORY U
Francisco Varela, to whom I owe the three folds of the core process of becoming aware: suspension, redirection, and letting go (which mark the left-hand side of the U); Eleanor Rosch, to whom I owe the concept of primary knowing (as the type of knowledge that arises from the bottom of the U) and the idea that “science needs to be performed with the mind of wisdom”; Johan Galtung, whose concept of trilateral science (integrating data, theory, and values) has inspired my path to action research and whose global analysis of direct, cultural, and structural violence has shaped my thinking about global social issues today; Bill Torbert, who clarified for me the concept of developmental thinking in organizations and leadership as well as his approach of action inquiry by integrating first-, second-, and third-person knowledge; Seija Kulkki, to whom I owe the encouragement to blend my European and my American intellectual roots, that is, to combine the practical action research work (that I only learned when I came to the East Coast in the U.S.) with the deep epistemological inquiry into the first foundations of science and philosophy (that reflects the European intellectual roots in the tradition of phenomenology and Goetheanic science); Brian Arthur, who helped me articulate the three-step version of the U: observe, observe, observe; retreat and reflect: allow the inner knowing to emerge; act in an instant; Master Nan Huai-Chin, to whom I owe the seven meditative stages of leadership as a Confucian-Buddhist-Daoist articulation of the U; Fritjof Capra, to whom I owe many great insights on the evolution of systems theory and systems thinking throughout the twentieth century in our time; Bill Isaacs, with whom I worked during the 1990s in the MIT Dialogue Project and whose own work inspired my thinking and development of the four-quadrant model that is represented in Part III of the book and that was later reframed according to the four different levels of the U (Chapter 17); Sara Niese, Ralf Schneider, Ikujiro Nonaka, and Arndt Zeitz, who helped refine the concepts and methods at issue here in ways that have made them
Theory U
accessible to top management audiences at DaimlerChrysler, Fujitsu, and PricewaterhouseCoopers throughout the past five years; Adam Kahane, who helped me refine many of the practical applications of the U approach to change and who suggested referring to the deep state of presencing as “regenerating”; Steven Piersanti, who suggested the title of the book: Theory U; Tom Callanan and the Fetzer Institute for funding the meetings that led to founding the Presencing Institute; Michael Jung, whose dream helped me launch the Global Dialogue Interview Project about eleven years ago; it created the real foundation for the whole line of research that is documented throughout this book—so without Michael, probably none of this would have happened; and last, but not least, my parents and the farm community at Hof Dannwisch in Germany to whom I owe the basic inspiration of this book: the relationship between the field of the earth and the living social field. I also wish to express my appreciation to the 150 interviewees of the Global Dialogue Interview Project who met with me and, on occasion, with Joseph Jaworski, in order to dialogue about the deepest question that underlies their work. Much inspiration grew out of these conversations, and they greatly influenced and shaped the line of inquiry that is presented throughout this book. I also greatly appreciate all my colleagues and friends who commented on the earlier drafts of the manuscript. While I assume full responsibility for mistakes that still may be found, many ideas and improvements must be credited to the valuable comments I received from the reviewers of the draft. They include (in addition to the individuals mentioned above): Arawana Hayashi, David Rome, Hinrich Mercker, Joel Yanowitz, John Heller, Margaret O’Bryon, Michael Milad, Ricardo Young, Sheryl Erickson, Tracy Huston, Tobias Scheytt, Claudia Mesiter-Scheytt, Andre Glavas, Claus Jakobs, and Walther Dreher. I have been blessed to work with great editors who helped me with this manuscript: Nina Kruschwitz, who worked on an early draft; Janet Mowery, who edited the second iteration; and Karen Speerstra, who shaped the final draft and helped me incorporate the feedback from the readers listed above.
xxiii
xxiv
THEORY U
My special thanks go also to Sherry Immediato, Nina Kruschwitz, and Arthur Klebanoff for leading, managing, and advising the design and production of this book through SoL Press. My final thanks go to my colleague Janice Spadafore, who orchestrates and steers the whole project ecology that has been emerging around the Presencing Institute, and whose organizing genius has worked as a hidden factor that enabled the completion of this book. Thank you all! Cambridge, Massachusetts, March, 2007
Introduction • The Blind Spot • Entering the Field • The Archimedean Point • Shifting the Structure of Our Attention • Theory U • A New Science • Facing the Crisis and Call of Our Time
Our Field Journey: This Book
W
e live in an era of intense conflict and massive institutional failures, a time of painful endings and of hopeful beginnings. It is a time that feels as if something profound is shifting and dying
while something else, as the playwright and Czech president, Václav Havel, put it, wants to be born: “I think there are good reasons for suggesting that the modern age has ended. Today, many things indicate that we are going through a transitional period, when it seems that something is on the way out and something else is painfully being born. It is as if something were crumbling, decaying, and exhausting itself—while something else, still indistinct, were rising from the rubble.”1
Facing the Crisis and Call of Our Time Because our thin crust of order and stability could blow up at any time, now is the moment to pause and become aware of what’s rising from the rubble. 1
2
INTRODUCTION
The crisis of our time isn’t just a crisis of a single leader, organization, country, or conflict. The crisis of our time reveals the dying of an old social structure and way of thinking, an old way of institutionalizing and enacting collective social forms. Frontline practitioners—managers, teachers, nurses, physicians, laborers, mayors, entrepreneurs, farmers, and business and government leaders— share a sense of the current reality. They can feel the heat of an ever-increasing workload and pressure to do even more. Many describe this as running on a treadmill or spinning in a hamster wheel. Recently I participated in a leadership workshop with one hundred leaders of a well known U.S. Fortune 500 company. The speaker before me had a great opening. He reminded us that only twenty years ago we were having serious discussions about what we should do with all of the extra free time that we would soon gain through the use of new communication technologies. Laughter erupted around the room. Painful laughter—for the reality that has come to pass is very different. As we perceive our own rising pressures and diminishing freedoms, we cross the street to meet the other side of the same system in which several billions of people are born and raised in conditions that will never, ever give them a chance to participate in our global socioeconomic system in a meaningful and fair way. One of the primary issues is and remains that our current global system works for only a relatively small, elite minority of us, while in many parts of the world it doesn’t work at all for the vast majority of the population. We all know the basic facts and figures that prove this point: • We have created a thriving global economy that yet leaves 850 million people suffering from hunger and 3 billion people living in poverty (on less than two dollars per day). The poor of the world—about 80 percent of mankind—live on 15 percent of the world’s total GNP.2 • We invest significant resources on our agriculture and food systems only to create nonsustainable mass production of low-quality junk food that pollutes both our bodies and our environment, resulting in topsoil
Theory U
degradation of a territory as large as India (the equivalent of 21 percent of the present arable land in the world).3 • We spend enormous resources on health care systems that merely tinker with symptoms and are unable to address the root causes of health and sickness in our society. Our health outcomes aren’t any better than those in many societies that spend far less. • We also pour considerable amounts of money into our educational systems, but we haven’t been able to create schools and institutions of higher education that develop people’s innate capacity to sense and shape their future, which I view as the single most important core capability for this century’s knowledge and co-creation economy. • In spite of alarming scientific and experiential evidence for an accelerating climate change, we, as a global system, continue to operate the old way—as if nothing much has happened. • More than half of the world’s children today suffer conditions of deprivation such as poverty, war, and HIV/AIDS.4 As a result, 40,000 children die of preventable diseases every day. Across the board, we collectively create outcomes (and side effects) that nobody wants. Yet the key decision makers do not feel capable of redirecting this course of events in any significant way. They feel just as trapped as the rest of us in what often seems to be a race to the bottom. The same problem affects our massive institutional failure: we haven’t learned to mold, bend, and transform our centuries-old collective patterns of thinking, conversing, and institutionalizing to fit the realities of today. The social structures that we see decaying and crumbling—locally, regionally, and globally—are built on two different sources: premodern traditional and modern industrial structures or forms of thinking and operating. Both of them have been successful in the past. But in our current age, each disintegrates and crumbles. The rise of fundamentalist movements in both Western and non-Western countries is a symptom of this disintegration and deeper transformation process. Fundamentalists say: “Look, this modern Western materialism
3
4
INTRODUCTION
doesn’t work. It takes away our dignity, our livelihood, and our soul. So let’s go back to the old order.” This reaction is understandable, as it relates to two key defining characteristics of today’s social decay that the peace researcher Johan Galtung calls anomie, the loss of norms and values, and atomie, the breakdown of social structures.5 The resulting loss of culture and structure leads to eruptions of violence, hate, terrorism, and civil war, along with partly self-inflicted natural catastrophes in both the southern and northern hemispheres. It is, as Václav Havel put it, as if something is decaying and exhausting itself. What, then, is arising from the rubble? How can we cope with these shifts? What I see rising is a new form of presence and power that starts to grow spontaneously from and through small groups and networks of people. It’s a different quality of connection, a different way of being present with one another and with what wants to emerge. When groups begin to operate from a real future possibility, they start to tap into a different social field from the one they normally experience. It manifests through a shift in the quality of thinking, conversing, and collective action. When that shift happens, people can connect with a deeper source of creativity and knowing and move beyond the patterns of the past. They step into their real power, the power of their authentic self. I call this change a shift in the social field because that term designates the totality and type of connections through which the participants of a given system relate, converse, think, and act. When a group succeeds in operating in this zone once, it is easier to do so a second time. It is as if an unseen, but permanent, communal connection or bond has been created. It tends to stay on even when new members are added to the group. The following chapters explain what happens when such shifts occur and how change then manifests in significantly different ways. The shift of a social field is more than a memorable moment. When it happens, it tends to result in outcomes that include a heightened level of individual energy and awareness, a sustained deepening of one’s authenticity and personal presence, and a clarified sense of direction, as well as significant professional and personal accomplishments.
Theory U
As the debate on the crisis and call of our time begins to unfold, proponents of three distinct positions can be heard: 1. Retromovement activists: “Let’s return to the order of the past.” Some retromovements have a fundamentalist bent, but not all of them. Often, this position comes with the revival of an old form of religion and faithbased spirituality. 2. Defenders of the status quo: “Just keep going. Focus on doing more of
the same by muddling through. Same old same old.” This position is grounded in the mainstream of contemporary scientific materialism. 3. Advocates of individual and collective transformational change: “Isn’t there a way to break the patterns of the past and tune into our highest future possibility—and to begin to operate from that place?” I personally believe that the current global situation yearns for a shift of the third kind, which in many ways is already in the making. We need to let go of the old body of institutionalized collective behavior in order to meet and connect with the presence of our highest future possibility. The purpose of this book, and of the research and actions that have led to it, is to delineate a social technology of transformational change that will allow leaders in all segments of our society, including in our individual lives, to meet their existing challenges. In order to rise to the occasion, leaders often have to learn how to operate from the highest possible future, rather than being stuck in the patterns of our past experiences. Incidentally, when I use the word “leader,” I refer to all people who engage in creating change or shaping their future, regardless of their formal positions in institutional structures. This book is written for leaders and change activists in corporations, governments, not-for-profit organizations, and communities. I have been often struck by how creators and master practitioners operate from a deeper process, one I call the “U Process.” This process pulls us into an emerging possibility and allows us to operate from that altered state rather than simply reflecting on and reacting to past experiences. But in order to do that, we have to become aware of a profound blind spot in leadership and in everyday life.
5
6
INTRODUCTION
The Blind Spot The blind spot is the place within or around us where our attention and intention originates. It’s the place from where we operate when we do something. The reason it’s blind, is that it is an invisible dimension of our social field, of our everyday experience in social interactions. This invisible dimension of the social field concerns the sources from which a given social field arises and manifests. It can be likened to how we look at the work of an artist. At least three perspectives are possible: • We can focus on the thing that results from the creative process; say, a painting. • We can focus on the process of painting. • Or we can observe the artist as she stands in front of a blank canvas. In other words, we can look at the work of art after it has been created (the thing), during its creation (the process), or before creation begins (the blank canvas or source dimension). If we apply this artist analogy to leadership, we can look at the leader’s work from three different angles. First, we can look at what leaders do. Tons of books have been written from that point of view. Second, we can look at the how, the processes leaders use. That’s the perspective we’ve used in management and leadership research over the past fifteen or twenty years. We
results they produce
processes they use
sources from which leaders operate (blank canvas)
F i g u r e 1 . 1 Th r e e P e r s p e c t i v e s o n a L e a de r’ s Wor k
Theory U
have analyzed all aspects and functional areas of managers’ and leaders’ work from the process point of view. Numerous useful insights have resulted from that line of work. Yet we have never systematically looked at the leaders’ work from the third, or blank-canvas, perspective. The question we have left unasked is: “What sources are leaders actually operating from?” I first began noticing this blind spot when talking with the late CEO of Hanover Insurance, Bill O’Brien. He told me that his greatest insight after years of conducting organizational learning projects and facilitating corporate change is that the success of an intervention depends on the interior condition of the intervener. That observation struck a chord. Bill helped me understand that what counts is not only what leaders do and how they do it but their “interior condition,” the inner place from which they operate or the source from which all of their actions originate. The blind spot at issue here is a fundamental factor in leadership and the social sciences. It also affects our everyday social experience. In the process of conducting our daily business and social lives, we are usually well aware of what we do and what others do; we also have some understanding of how we do things, the processes we and others use when we act. Yet if we were to ask the question “From what source does our action come?” most of us would be unable to provide an answer. We can’t see the source from which we operate; we aren’t aware of the place from which our attention and intention originate. Having spent the last ten years of my professional career in the field of organizational learning, my most important insight has been that there are two different sources of learning: learning from the experiences of the past and learning from the future as it emerges. The first type of learning, learning from the past, is well known and well developed. It underlies all our major learning methodologies, best practices and approaches to organizational learning.6 By contrast, the second type of learning, learning from the future as it emerges, is still by and large unknown. A number of people to whom I proposed the idea of a second source of learning considered it wrongheaded. The only way to learn, they argued, is from the past. “Otto, learning from the future is not possible. Don’t waste
7
8
INTRODUCTION
your time!” But in working with leadership teams across many sectors and industries, I realized that leaders cannot meet their existing challenges by operating only on the basis of past experience, for various reasons. Sometimes the experiences of the past aren’t very helpful in dealing with the current issues. Sometimes you work with teams in which the experiences of the past are actually the biggest problem with and obstacle to coming up with a creative response to the challenge at hand. When I started realizing that the most impressive leaders and master practitioners seem to operate from a different core process, one that pulls them into future possibilities, I asked myself: How can we learn to better sense and connect with a future possibility that is seeking to emerge?7 I began to call this operating from the future as it emerges “presencing.”8 Presencing is a blending of the words “presence” and “sensing.” It means to sense, tune in, and act from one’s highest future potential—the future that depends on us to bring it into being. This book describes the process and the result of a ten-year journey that was made possible only through the support and collaboration of a unique constellation of inspirational colleagues and friends.9 The question that underlies that journey is “How can we act from the future that is seeking to emerge, and how can we access, activate, and enact the deeper layers of the social field?”
Entering the Field A field, as every farmer knows, is a complex living system—just as the earth is a living organism. I grew up on a farm near Hamburg, Germany. One of the first things my father, one of the pioneers of biodynamic farming in Europe, taught me was that the living quality of the soil is the most important thing in organic agriculture. Each field, he explained to me, has two aspects: the visible, what we see above the surface, and the invisible, or what is below the surface. The quality of the yield—the visible result—is a function of the quality of the soil, of those elements of the field that are mostly invisible to the eye. My thinking about social fields starts exactly at that point: that [social]
Theory U
fields are the grounding condition, the living soil, from which grows that which only later becomes visible to the eye. And just as every good farmer focuses attention on sustaining and enhancing the quality of the soil, every good organizational leader focuses attention on sustaining and enhancing the quality of the social field—the “farm” in which every responsible leader works day in and day out. Every Sunday my parents took me and my brothers and our sister on a Feldgang—a field walk—across all the fields on our farm. Once in a while my father would stop and pick up a clump of soil from a furrow so that we could investigate and learn to see its different types and structures. The quality of the soil, he explained, depended on a whole host of living entities—millions of organisms living in every cubic centimeter of soil—whose work is necessary for the earth to breathe and to evolve as a living system. This book invites you to take a field walk across the social landscape of our contemporary global society. And just as we did during the Feldgang, once in a while we will stop at a furrow and pick up a little piece of data we want to investigate in order to better understand the subtle territory of social fields. As McKinsey & Company’s Jonathan Day once noted about his experience helping global corporations through the process of transformational change, “What’s most important is invisible to the eye.”10 But how can we begin to see, more consciously and clearly, this hidden territory?
The Archimedean Point What is the strategic leverage point for intentionally shifting the structure of a social field? What could function as the Archimedean point—the enabling condition—that will allow the global social field to evolve and shift? For my father, the answer was quite clear. Where do you put your “lever”? On the soil. You concentrate on constantly improving the quality of your topsoil. Every day. The fertile topsoil is a very thin layer of a living substance that evolves through the intertwined connection of two worlds: the visible realm above the surface and the invisible realm below. The words “culture” and
9
10
INTRODUCTION
“cultivation” both originate from the concept of this very activity. Farmers cultivate the topsoil by deepening the connection between both worlds—that is, by plowing, harrowing, and so forth. So where is the leverage point in the case of a social field? At precisely the same place: the interface and connection between the visible and invisible dimensions of the social field. An organization’s fertile “topsoil” exists where these two worlds meet, connect, and intertwine. What, then, in the case of social fields, is the visible matter? It’s what we do, say and see. It’s the social action that could be captured and recorded with a camera. And what is the invisible realm? It’s the interior condition from which the participants of a situation operate. It’s the originating source of all we do, say, and see. According to Bill O’Brien, that’s what matters most if you want to be an effective leader; that is, if you want to shape a future that is different from the past. It’s the blind spot, or the place from which our attention and intention is happening. In Part I of this book, “Bumping Into Our Blind Spot,” I will argue that across all levels, systems, and sectors we face basically the same problem: the challenges we face require us to become aware and change the inner place from which we operate. As a consequence, we need to learn to attend to both dimensions simultaneously: what we say, see, and do (our visible realm) and the inner place from which we operate (our invisible realm, in which our sources of attention and intention reside and from which they operate). I call the intermediate sphere that links both dimensions the field structure of attention. It’s the functional equivalent of the topsoil in agriculture; it links both dimensions of the field. Collectively seeing our field structure of attention—that is, collectively becoming aware of our inner places from which we operate in real time—may well be the single most important leverage point for shifting the social field in this century and beyond, for it represents the only part of our common consciousness that we can control completely. Each of us creates the structure of attention ourselves, so we can’t blame a lack of it on someone else. Hence, when we can see this place, we can begin to use it as the lever for practical change. It enables us to act differently. To the degree that we see our attention and its
Theory U
source, we can change the system. But to do so, we have to shift the inner place from which we operate.
Shifting the Structure of Our Attention The essence of leadership is to shift the inner place from which we operate both individually and collectively. The soil in my father’s fields ranges from shallow to deep. Likewise, in our social fields, there are fundamentally different layers (field structures) of attention, also varying from shallow to deep. The field structure of attention concerns the relationship between observer and observed. It concerns the quality of how we attend to the world. That quality differs depending on the place or position from which our attention originates relative to the organizational boundary of the observer and the observed. In my research that led to this book, I found that there are four different places or positions that each gives rise to a different quality or field structure of attention. They are: (1) I-in-me: what I perceive based on my habitual ways of seeing and thinking, (2) I-in-it: what I perceive with my senses and mind wide open, (3) I-in-you: what I tune in to and sense from within with my heart wide open, and (4) I-in-now: what I understand from the source or the bottom of my being, that is, from attending with my open will. The four field structures differ in the place from which attention (and intention) originates: habits, open mind, open heart, and open will, respectively. Every action by a person, a leader, a group, an organization, or a community can be enacted in these four different ways. To clarify this distinction, let’s take the example of listening. In my years of working with groups and organizations, I have identified four basic types of listening: “Yeah, I know that already.” The first type of listening is downloading: listening by reconfirming habitual judgments. When you are in a situation where everything that happens confirms what you already know, you are listening by downloading.
11
12
INTRODUCTION
“Ooh, look at that!” The second type of listening is object-focused or factual listening: listening by paying attention to facts and to novel or disconfirming data. In this type of attending, you focus on what differs from what you already know. Your listening has to switch from attending to your inner voice of judgment to attending to the data right in front of you. You begin to focus on information that differs from what you already know.
Object-focused or factual listening is the basic mode of
good science. You ask questions, and you carefully observe the responses that nature (data) gives you. “Oh, yes, I know how you feel.” The third, yet deeper level of listening is empathic listening. When we are engaged in real dialogue, we can, when paying attention, become aware of a profound shift in the place from which our listening originates. As long as we operate from the first two types of listening, our listening originates from within the boundaries of our own mental-cognitive organization. But when we listen empathically, our perception shifts. We move from staring at the objective world of things, figures, and facts into the story of a living being, a living system, and self. To do so, we have to activate and tune a special instrument: the open heart, that is, the empathic capacity to connect directly with another person or living system. If that happens, we feel a profound switch; we forget about our own agenda and begin to see how the world unfolds through someone else’s eyes. When operating in this mode, we usually feel what another person wants to say before the words take form. And then we may recognize whether a person chooses the right word or the wrong one to express something. That judgment is possible only when we have a direct sense of what someone wants to say before we analyze what she actually says. Empathic listening is a skill that can be cultivated and developed, just like any other human relations skill. It’s a skill that requires us to activate a different source of intelligence: the intelligence of the heart. “I can’t express what I experience in words. My whole being has slowed down. I feel more quiet and present and more my real self. I am connected to something larger than myself.” This is the fourth level of listening. It moves
Theory U
beyond the current field and connects to a still deeper realm of emergence. I call this level of listening generative listening, or listening from the emerging field of the future. This level of listening requires us to access our open heart and open will—our capacity to connect to the highest future possibility that wants to emerge. On this level our work focuses on getting our (old) self out of the way in order to open a space, a clearing, that allows for a different sense of presence to manifest. We no longer look for something outside. We no longer empathize with someone in front of us. We are in an altered state—maybe “communion” or “grace” is the word that comes closest to the texture of this experience that refuses to be dragged onto the surface of words. You’ll notice that this fourth level of listening differs in texture and outcomes from the others. You know that you have been operating on the fourth level when, at the end of the conversation, you realize that you are no longer the same person you were when you started the conversation. You have gone through a subtle but profound change. You have connected to a deeper source—to the source of who you really are and to a sense of why you are here—a connection that links you with a profound field of coming into being, with your emerging authentic Self.
Theory U: Leading from the Highest Future Possibility Each of us uses, in any action we take, one of these four different ways of paying attention. We access one of these layers of consciousness whether we act alone or in a large group. I suggest we call these ways of acting our field structures of attention. The same activities can result in radically different outcomes depending on the structure of attention from which a particular activity is performed. Put differently, “I attend [this way]—therefore it emerges [that way].” This is the hidden dimension of our common social process, not easily or readily understood, and it may be the most underutilized lever for profound change today. Therefore, I have devised Theory U to help us better understand these sources from which all social action constantly comes into being. Theory U addresses the core question that underlies this book: What is
13
14
INTRODUCTION
required in order to learn and act from the future as it emerges? In Chapter 2, we will follow this key question in order to learn to deepen our leading, learning, and acting from Levels 1 and 2 (reacting and quick fixes) to Levels 3 and 4 (profound renewal and change). The turbulent challenges of our time force all institutions and communities to renew and reinvent themselves. To do that, we must ask: Who are we? What are we here for? What do we want to create together? The answers to these questions differ according to the structure of attention (and consciousness) that we use to respond to them. They can be given from a purely materialistic-deterministic point of view (when operating on Levels 1 and 2), or they can be given from a more holistic perspective that also includes the more subtle mental and intentional spiritual sources of social reality creation (Levels 3 and 4).
A New Science This book is intended to do more than just illuminate a blind spot of leadership. Rather, it seeks to uncover a hidden dimension in the social process that each of us encounters in our everyday life, moment to moment. To do this, we need to advance our current form of science. As the psychologist Eleanor Rosch from the University of California at Berkeley likes to put it, “Science needs to be performed with the mind of wisdom.” Science as we know it today may still be in its very infancy. In 1609 Galileo Galilei devised a telescope that allowed him to observe the moons of Jupiter. His observations suggested strong evidence in support of the heretic Copernican view of the heliocentric universe. Sixty-six years prior, Nicolaus Copernicus had published a treatise that put forth his revolutionary idea that the sun was at the center of the universe, and not— according to the view by Ptolemy—the earth. In the half century since its publication, however, Copernicus’ theory had been met with skepticism, particularly by the Catholic Church. When Galilei looked through his telescope, he knew that Copernicus was right. But when he put forth his views, first in private conversations and later in writing, like Copernicus, he met
Theory U
his strongest opposition from the Catholic Church, which claimed his view was heresy and summoned an inquisition. In his attempts to defend his view, Galilei urged his Catholic counterparts to take a look through the telescope and convince themselves of the evidence with their own eyes. But although some in the Catholic leadership supported Galileo’s position, the main Church leaders refused to take that daunting look. They didn’t dare to go beyond the dogma of Scripture. Although the Church succeeded in intimidating the seventy-year-old Galileo during the inquisition trial (forcing him to renounce his views), the real victory was his, and today he is considered the father of modern experimental physics. Galileo Galilei helped pioneer modern science by not backing off, by looking through the telescope, and by letting the data that emerged from his observations teach him what was true and what was not. And now, four hundred years later, we may again be writing another breakthrough story. Galileo transformed science by encouraging us to use our eyes, our senses, to gather external data. Now we are asked to broaden and deepen that method by gathering a much more subtle set of data and experiences from within. To do that, we have to invent another type of telescope: not one that helps us to observe only what is far out—the moons of Jupiter—but one that enables us to observe the observer’s blind spot by bending the beam of observation back upon its source: the self that is performing the scientific activity. The instruments that we need to utilize in order to bend the beam of observation back upon its source include not only an open mind, the normal mode of inquiry and investigation, but also an open heart and open will. These more subtle aspects of observation and knowing will be discussed in more detail below. This transformation of science is no less revolutionary than Galileo Galilei’s. And the resistance from the incumbent knowledge holders will be no less fierce than the one that Galilei met in the Catholic Church. Yet, when looking at the global challenges of our time, we can recognize the call of our time to come up with a new synthesis among science, social change, and the evolution of self (or consciousness). While it has been a common practice for social scientists and management scholars to borrow their methods and par-
15
16
INTRODUCTION
adigms from natural sciences such as physics, I think it is now time for social scientists to step out of the shadow and to establish an advanced social sciences methodology that integrates science (third-person view), social transformation (second-person view) and the evolution of self (first-person view) into a coherent framework of consciousness-based action research. Such a framework is already emerging from two major turns in the field of social sciences over the period of the last half century. The first one is usually referred to as the “action turn” and was pioneered by Kurt Lewin and his followers in a variety of approaches to action science throughout the second half of the twentieth century.11 The second one followed in the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries and is often called the “reflective turn”; however, it would probably be better referred to as a self-reflective turn toward patterns of attention and consciousness. This new synthesis in the making links all three of these angles: science (let the data speak), action research (you can’t understand a system unless you change it), and the evolution of consciousness and self (illuminating the blind spot). Twenty-three hundred years ago Aristotle, arguably the greatest pioneer and innovator of Western inquiry and thought, wrote in Book VI of his Nicomachean Ethics that there are five different ways, faculties, or capacities in the human soul to grasp the truth. Only one of them is science (episteme).12 Science (episteme), according to Aristotle, is limited to the things that cannot be otherwise than they are (in other words, things that are determined by necessity). By contrast, the other four ways and capacities of grasping the truth apply to all the other contexts of reality and life. They are: art or producing (techne), practical wisdom (phronesis), theoretical wisdom (sophia), and intuition or the capacity to grasp first principles or sources (nous). So far the primary focus of our modern sciences has been, by and large, limited to episteme. But now we need to broaden our view of science to include the other capacities to grasp the truth, including applied technologies (techne), practical wisdom (phronesis), theoretical wisdom (sophia), and the capacity to intuit the sources of awareness and intention (nous).
Theory U
Our Field Journey: This Book Organization After Part I, “Bumping into Our Blind Spot,” we move on to Part II, “Entering the U Field,” followed by Part III, “Presencing: A Social Technology for Leading Profound Innovation and Change.” The first part of this field walk deals with different aspects of the blind spot. I argue that the central issue of our time deals with hitting our blind spot—the inner place from which we operate—across all system levels. On all these levels we are confronted with the same issue: we cannot meet the challenges at hand if we do not change our interior condition and illuminate our blind spot—the source of our attention and action. In Part II we will explore the core process of illuminating the blind spot— how is it possible to do this? The third part of our field walk focuses on summarizing this core process in terms of an evolutionary grammar that is then spelled out in two forms: as a new social field theory (Theory U) and as a new social technology (24 Principles and Practices of Presencing). The book concludes with an Epilogue, “Birthing a Global Action University.” In it are ideas about and a broad plan for a global action university that puts the above principles into practice by integrating science, consciousness, and profound social change. The following twenty-one chapters integrate the insights from dialogue interviews with 150 eminent thinkers and practitioners in strategy, knowledge, innovation, and leadership around the world. You should know that this book is also based on my own life story—recognizably that of a white male European now living in the United States—together with my research at MIT and the results of numerous reflection workshops among colleagues and co-researchers. In addition, I have based Theory U on the results of consulting and “action research” projects with leaders of grassroots movements and global companies and NGOs, among them Fujitsu, DaimlerChrysler, GlaxoSmithKline, Hewlett-Packard, Federal Express, McKinsey & Company, Nissan, Oxfam, PricewaterhouseCoopers, and Shell Oil. I have always found major sources of inspiration in working with close
17
18
INTRODUCTION
colleagues from the field of the creative arts, for example, with Arawana Hayashi, who developed the embodied presence practices and who leads a project in which we work on co-creating a new art form called Social Presencing Theater.13 I also chose to include a number of illustrations throughout the book based on my own hand-drawn figures, along with many more professionally rendered figures, which illustrate and bring alive some of the concepts much better than words can. It is my hope that by including them, some of the more challenging ideas of this book will be made a bit more accessible.
Purpose This book sets out to do three things. It provides a social grammar of the social field that illuminates the blind spot (Chapters 15, 20). Second, it exemplifies this grammar by revealing four fundamental metaprocesses that underlie the collective process of social reality creation, moment to moment. They are: thinking, conversing, structuring, and globally connecting (global governance) (Chapters 16–19). And last, it outlines a social technology of freedom that puts this approach onto its feet and into practice through a set of principles and practices of presencing (Chapter 21). The set of 24 principles works as a matrix and constitutes a whole. That said, they can also be presented as five movements that follow the path of the U (see Figure 1.2). These five movements are: • Co-initiating: listen to what life calls you to do, connect with people and contexts related to that call, and convene constellations of core players that co-inspire common intention. • Co-sensing: go to the places of most potential; observe, observe, observe; listen with your mind and heart wide open. • Co-presencing: go to the place of individual and collective stillness, open up to the deeper source of knowing, and connect to the future that wants to emerge through you. • Co-creating: build landing strips of the future by prototyping living microcosms in order to explore the future by doing.
Theory U
1. co-initiating
5. co-evolving
Listen to others and to what life calls you to do
Grow innovation ecosystems by seeing and acting from the emerging whole
2. co-sensing
4. co-creating
Go to the places of most potential and listen with your mind and heart wide open
Prototype a microcosm of the new to explore the future by doing
3. co-presencing Retreat and reflect, allow the inner knowing to emerge
F i g ur e 1 . 2 F i v e M ov e m e n t s of t h e U P ro ce s s
• Co-evolving: co-develop a larger innovation ecosystem and hold the space that connects people across boundaries through seeing and acting from the whole.
Method Our field walk incorporates three methods: phenomenology, dialogue, and collaborative action research. All three address the same key issue: the intertwined constitution of knowledge, reality, and self. And all of them follow the dictum of Kurt Lewin, the founder of action research, who observed, “You cannot understand a system unless you change it.” But each method has a different emphasis: phenomenology focuses on the first-person point of view (individual consciousness); dialogue on the second-person point of view (fields of conversation); and action research on the third-person point of view (enactment of institutional patterns and structures). You will notice that I don’t refer in this book primarily to individual leaders but to our distributed or collective leadership. All people effect change, regardless of their formal positions or titles. Leadership in this century means shifting the structure of collective attention—our listening—at all levels.
19
20
INTRODUCTION
As Jeffrey Hollender, the founder and CEO of Seventh Generation, put it, “Leadership is about being better able to listen to the whole than anyone else can.” Look around you. What do you see? We are now engaged in global leadership, and this means we extend our attention and listening from the individual (micro) and group interaction (meso) to the institutional (macro) and global (mundo) systems levels. It is all interconnected and present all the time. The good news is that the hidden inflection points for transforming the field structure of attention are the same at all these levels. These turning or inflection points, which I discuss throughout this book, apply to systems at all levels. But here comes the caveat: There is a price to be paid. Operating from the fourth field of emergence requires a commitment: a commitment to letting go of everything that isn’t essential and to living according to the “letting go/letting come” principle that Goethe described as the essence of the human journey: “And if you don’t know this dying and birth, you are merely a dreary guest on earth.”14 The real battle in the world today is not among civilizations or cultures but among the different evolutionary futures that are possible for us and our species right now. What is at stake is nothing less than the choice of who we are, who we want to be, and where we want to take the world we live in. The real question, then, is “What are we here for?” Our old leadership is crumbling similar to the way the Berlin Wall crumbled in 1989. What’s necessary today is not only a new approach to leadership. We need to go beyond the concept of leadership. We must discover a more profound and practical integration of the head, heart, and hand—of the intelligences of the open mind, open heart, and open will—at both an individual and a collective level. I invite you to join me on this journey of discovery.
Part I
Bumping into Our Blind Spot
W
e all recognize social acts when we see them: people talking, laughing, crying, clashing, playing, dancing, praying. But where do our actions come from? From
what place deep within (or around) us do our actions originate? To answer this question, it is helpful to look at the creative work of an artist in three ways. First, we can look at the result of her work, the thing, the finished painting. Or we can
observe her while she is painting: we can watch the process of her colorful brushstrokes creating the work of art. Or we can observe her standing in front of the empty canvas. It is this third perspective that creates the guiding questions of this book: What happens in front of the completely white canvas? What prompts the artist to make that first stroke? 21
22
BUMPING INTO OUR BLIND SPOT
Th is b o o k is written for leaders, the individuals or groups who initiate innovation or change—The “artists.” All leaders and innovators, whether in business, communities, government, or nonprofit organizations, do what artists do: they create something new and bring it into the world. The open question is: Where do their actions come from? We can observe what leaders do. We also can observe how they do it, what strategies and processes they deploy. But we can’t see the inner place, the source from which people act when, for example, they operate at their highest possible level or, alternatively, when they act without engagement or commitment. That brings us to the territory of what I call our “blind spot.” The blind spot concerns that part of our seeing that we usually don’t see. It’s the inner place or source from which a person or a social system operates. That blind spot is present every day in all systems. But it is hidden. It is our task, as leaders, and as creators, to notice how the blind spot shows up. For instance, Francisco J. Varela, a professor of cognitive science and epistemology in Paris, told me that “the blind spot of contemporary science is experience.” This blind spot shows up in many different ways. We will learn about them as we continue this “field walk,” this “learning journey,” together. The following seven chapters offer seven perspectives from which we can explore the different ways the blind spot shows up in society, in science, and in systems thinking as a defining feature of our time. Blind spots appear in individuals, groups, institutions, societies, and systems, and they reveal themselves in our theories and concepts in the form of deep epistemological and ontological assumptions. I invite you to explore, with me, several different areas of the blind spot. We start from the view of the self and move through the team, the organization, society, the social sciences, and, finally, philosophy.
Chapter 1
Facing the Fire
W
hen I left my German farmhouse that morning for school, I had no idea it was the last time I would see my home, a large 350year-old farmhouse thirty miles north of Hamburg. It was just
another ordinary day at school until about one o’clock, when the teacher called me out of class. “You should go home now, Otto.” I noticed that her eyes were slightly red. She did not tell me why I needed to hurry home, but I was concerned enough to try to call home from the train station. There was no ring. The line was obviously dead. I had no idea what might have happened, but by then I knew it probably wasn’t good. After the usual one-hour train ride I ran to the entrance of the station and jumped into a cab. Something told me I didn’t have time to wait for my usual bus. Long before we arrived, I saw huge gray and black clouds of smoke billowing up into the air. My heart was pounding as the cab approached our long driveway. I recognized hundreds of our neighbors, area firefighters and policemen along with people I’d never seen before. I jumped from the cab and ran down 23
24
FACING THE FIRE
through the crowd, the last half mile of our chestnut-lined driveway. When I reached the courtyard, I could not believe my eyes. The world I had lived in all my life was gone. Vanished. All up in smoke. There was nothing—absolutely nothing—left except the raging flames. As the reality of the fire in front of my eyes began to sink in, I felt as if somebody had ripped away the ground from under my feet. The place of my birth, childhood, and youth was gone. I just stood there, taking in the heat of the fire and feeling time slowing down. As my gaze sank deeper and deeper into the flames, the flames also seemed to sink into me. Suddenly I realized how attached I had been to all the things destroyed by the fire. Everything I thought I was had dissolved into nothing. Everything? No, perhaps not everything, for I felt that a tiny element of my self still existed. Somebody was still there, watching all this. Who? At that moment I realized there was a whole other dimension of my self that I hadn’t previously been aware of, a dimension that related not to my past—the world that had just dissolved in front of my eyes—but to my future, a world that I could bring into reality with my life. At that moment time slowed down to stillness and I felt drawn in a direction above my physical body and began watching the scene from that unknown place. I felt my mind quieting and expanding in a moment of unparalleled clarity of awareness. I realized that I was not the person I had thought I was. My real self was not attached to all the material possessions smoldering inside the ruins. I suddenly knew that I, my true Self, was still alive! It was this “I” that was the seer. And this seer was more alive, more awake, more acutely present than the “I” I had known before. I was no longer weighted down by all the material possessions the fire had just consumed. With everything gone, I was lighter and free, released to encounter the other part of my self, the part that drew me into the future––into my future—into a world waiting for me, that I might bring into reality with my forward journey. The next day my eighty-seven-year old grandfather arrived for what would be his last visit to the farm. He had lived in that house all his life, beginning in 1890. Because of medical treatments, he had been away the week before the fire, and when he arrived at the courtyard the day after the fire, he sum-
Theory U
moned his last energy, got out of the car, and went straight to where my father was working on the cleanup. He did not even once turn his head to the smoking ruins. Without seeming to notice the small fires still burning around the property, he went up to my father, took his hand, and said, “Kopf hoch, mein Junge, blick nach vorn!” “Keep your head up, my boy, look forward!” Then he turned, walked directly back to the waiting car, and left. A few days later he died quietly. Only years later did I realize that my experience in front of the fire was the beginning of a journey. My journey began with the recognition that I am not just one self but two selves. One self is connected to the past, and the second self connects to who I could become in the future. In front of the fire I experienced how these two selves started to connect to each other. Today, twentyyears later and several thousand miles away in Boston, Massachusetts, the question “Who is my true self?” still lingers. I still ask, how does this self relate to that other stream of time—the one that seemed to draw me from the future that is wanting to emerge—rather than extending and reenacting the patterns of my past? And how does this self that connects to the future connect to my work? I believe these questions eventually prompted me to leave Germany for the United States in 1994 to continue my research at what was then the MIT Organizational Learning Center. And these same questions motivated the writing of the following chapters of this book.
25
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 2
The Journey to “U” • Interview with Brian Arthur at Xerox PARC • Francisco Varela on the Blind Spot in Cognition Sciences • Theory U
The Inner Territory of Leadership
Theory U: Beginnings
A
s just discussed, the blind spot concerns the structure and source of our attention. I first began noticing this blind spot in organizations when I spoke with Bill O’Brien, the former CEO of Hanover
Insurance. He told me that his greatest insight after years of conducting organizational learning projects and facilitating corporate change was that “the success of an intervention depends on the interior condition of the intervener.” That struck a chord! So it’s not only what leaders do and how they do it but their “interior condition,” that is, the inner place from which they operate—the source and quality of their attention. So what this suggests is that the same person in the same situation doing the same thing can effect a totally different outcome depending on the inner place from where that action is coming. When I realized that, I asked myself: What do we know about that inner place? We know everything about the what and the how, the actions and the 27
28
THE JOURNEY TO “U”
processes that leaders and managers use. But what do we know about that inner place? Nothing! I wasn’t even sure whether there were only one or many of these inner places. Do we have two? Ten? We don’t know because it’s in our blind spot. Yet, what I have heard time and time gain from very experienced leaders and creative people is that it is exactly that kind of blind spot that matters most. It is that blind spot that sets apart master practitioners and leaders from average performers. Which is why Aristotle 2300 years ago made a distinction between the normal scientific “what” knowledge (episteme) and the practical and technical “how” knowledge (phronesis, techne) on the one hand and the inner primary knowing of first principles and sources of awareness (nous) and wisdom (sophia), on the other.1 Shortly after I came to MIT in 1994, I watched a live broadcast on organizational learning. In response to a question from the audience, Rick Ross, coauthor of The Fifth Discipline Fieldbook, went to the whiteboard and drew the following figure:
— structure — — process — — thought —
F i g ur e 2 . 1 L e v e l s of O rga n i z at iona l C h a nge
Seeing that simple drawing made me realize that organizational change happens on different layers. In a flash I began mentally seeing these layers. Diagramming them helped because the changes from structure to process to thoughts present more and more subtle shifts. When I completed the drawing in my mind, I had added two more levels—above structure and below thought—as well as a horizontal dimension of change as we move from perceiving something to actually acting on it. This is how it began to look:
Theory U
RE-ACTING CHALLENGE
SOLUTION
RE-STRUCTURING FOCUSING:
CREATING
surfacing current reality
new structures and practices
RE-DESIGNING BROADENING:
CREATING
perceiving other perceptions
new core activities and processes
DEEPENING:
RE-FRAMING CREATING
dialogue— surfacing deep assumptions
new thinking and principles
RE-GENERATING PURPOSE:
SHARED PERCEPTION: uncovering common will
Where does our commitment come from?
COLLECTIVE ACTION: putting purpose into practice
F i g ur e 2 . 2 F i v e L e v e l s of C h a nge
I began calling the state at the bottom of the U “Presencing.” We will learn much more about this in Part III, but for now, we can call it “seeing from our deepest source.” That is, sensing and operating from one’s highest future potential. It is the state each of us can experience when we open not just our minds but our hearts and our wills—our impetus to act—in order to deal with what is emerging all around us as new realities. Whenever I used this framework in presentations and in my work with groups, organizations, or communities, I noticed how deeply it resonated with experienced practitioners. As they worked with this U image, people began to understand its two key dimensions. One is the distinction between perception and action that defines the horizontal axis, as we work from deeply connecting and sensing toward enacting and realizing. The vertical axis then
29
30
THE JOURNEY TO “U”
shows us the different levels of change from the shallowest response: from “Re-acting” down through the deepest, “Re-generating.”2 Most change and learning methods are based on the Kolb Learning Cycle, which suggests a version of the following sequence: observe, reflect, plan, act. By grounding the learning process this way, the learning cycles are based on learning from the experiences of the past.3 The distinction of Harvard and MIT’s Chris Argyris and Don Schön between single-loop and double-loop learning refers to learning from experiences of the past.4 Single-loop learning is reflected in the levels of reacting and restructuring, while reframing is an example of double-loop learning (which includes a reflection of one’s deep assumptions and governing variables). However, the deepest level of the U graphic—referred to as regenerating—goes beyond double-loop learning. It accesses a different stream of time—the future that wants to emerge—and is what in this book I will refer to as presencing or “the U process.” The concept of the U, of course, didn’t spring from nothing. It emerged from many years of change work in a variety of contexts and movements and some study, that are documented in two of my earlier books.5 Important sources that informed my early thinking about social development and change include a global learning journey across all the major global cultural spheres to study the dynamics of peace and conflict. This led me to India to study Gandhi’s approach of nonviolent conflict transformation, and to China, Vietnam, and Japan to study Buddhism, Confuscianism, and Daoism as different approaches to development and life. I also had the fortune to work with unique academic teachers, Ekkehard Kappler and Johan Galtung, who taught me that critical thinking and science can function as a powerful force for social transformation and change. Other sources that influenced my thinking include the work of the avant-garde artist Joseph Beuys, and the writings of Henry David Thoreau, Martin Buber, Friedrich Nietzsche, Edmund Husserl, Martin Heidegger, Jürgen Habermas, as well as some of the old masters like Hegel, Fichte, Aristotle, and Plato. Among the philosophical sources, perhaps most influential was the work of the educator and social innovator Rudolf Steiner, whose synthesis of science, philosophy, consciousness and social innovation
Theory U
continues to inspire my work and whose methodological grounding in Goethe’s phenomenological view of science has left signicant imprints on Theory U. The key insight that I got from reading Steiner’s foundational book, The Philosophy of Freedom, is the same insight that I walked away with from completing my first research project at MIT with Edgar Schein. In that project we looked at all the different theories of change that researchers at MIT’s Sloan School of Management had come up with. When trying to summarize and conclude our findings from all these different theories and frameworks, Ed reflected on our result, a pretty complex integration of frameworks of various sorts, and said, “Perhaps we have to go back to data and to start all over again. Maybe we have to take our own experience in dealing with change more seriously.” To paraphrase Steiner, we have to investigate our own experience and our own thought process in a clearer, more transparent and rigorous way. In other words, trust your senses, trust your observations, trust your own perception as the fundamental starting point of any investigation—but then follow that train of your observation all the way back to its source, exactly the same way that Husserl and Varela advocated in their work on the phenomenological method. Steiner’s The Philosophy of Freedom focuses on individual consciousness. In Theory U, we will explore the field structures of collective attention.6
Interview with Brian Arthur at Xerox PARC In 1999, I started a project with Joseph Jaworski, author of Synchronicity: The Inner Path of Leadership. Our task was to create a learning environment to help a group of line leaders in an organization formed by the recent merger of Shell Oil and Texaco learn faster and develop the capacity to innovate in the changing business environment. To do so, we interviewed practitioners and thought leaders on innovation, including W. Brian Arthur, the founding head of the Economics Program at the Santa Fe Institute. He is best known for his pathbreaking contributions to understanding high-tech markets. As Joseph and I walked up to the Xerox
31
32
THE JOURNEY TO “U”
PARC building in Palo Alto, California, I couldn’t help but think about all the revolutions that had begun in this very spot. Ever since the 1970s the original Xerox PARC team has been considered probably the most productive research and development team ever. It invented the Macintosh-type interface found on almost every desktop on Earth; it also invented the mouse, as well as numerous core ideas and technologies used by many successful companies today, including Apple Computer and Adobe Systems. The irony is that all these inventions and breakthrough ideas did not help the parent company, Xerox, which did not capitalize on these breakthrough ideas. Instead, these ideas were taken and developed further by people and organizations who were not distracted by the running of a once-successful copy machine company. Arthur met us, and we immediately started talking about the changing economic foundations of today’s business world. “You know,” Arthur said, “the real power comes from recognizing patterns that are forming and fitting with them.” He went on to discuss two different levels of cognition. “Most tend to be the standard cognitive kind that you can work with in your conscious mind. But there is a deeper level. Instead of an understanding, I would call this deeper level a ‘knowing.’” “Suppose,” he said, “that I was parachuted into some situation in Silicon Valley—not a real problem, just a complicated, dynamic situation that I’m trying to figure out. I would observe and observe and observe and then simply retreat. If I were lucky, I would be able to get in touch with some deep inner place and allow knowing to emerge.” He continued, “You wait and wait and let your experience well up into something appropriate. In a sense, there is no decision making. What to do becomes obvious. You can’t rush it. Much of it depends on where you’re coming from and who you are as a person. This has a lot of implications for management. I am basically saying that what counts is where you’re coming from inside yourself.”7 What Joseph and I heard that day resonated deeply with what we had heard from other leading practitioners we had worked with across many sectors and industries. Leaders need to deal with their blind spot and shift the inner place from which they operate. Arthur asked us to imagine what would happen if Apple Computer, for
Theory U
instance, decided to hire a CEO from, say Pepsi-Cola? That leader would bring one sort of cognition: cost down, quality up, whatever the mantra is. And it wouldn’t work. But now imagine a Steve Jobs coming in—someone who can distance himself from the problem and think differently. “When he came back to Apple, the Internet was just beginning. No one knew what that might mean. Now look at him: he turned Apple around.” Top-notch scientists do the same thing, Arthur continued. “Good, but not quite first-rate scientists are able to take existing frameworks and overlay them onto some situation. The first-rate ones just sit back and allow the appropriate structure to form. My observation is that they have no more intelligence than the good scientists do, but they have this other ability and that makes all the difference.” This “other way of knowing” shows up in Chinese and Japanese artists as well. Arthur said, “They’ll sit on a ledge with lanterns for a whole week, just looking, and then suddenly they’ll say, ‘Ooohh’ and paint something very quickly.” On the return trip we realized that the conversation with Arthur had furnished two principal insights. First, that there is a distinction between types of cognition: normal (downloading mental frames) versus a deeper level of knowing. And second, that in order to activate the deeper level of knowing, one has to go through a three-step process similar to Arthur’s parachute example: observe deeply, connect to what wants to emerge, and then act on
DOWNLOADING
OBSERVE, OBSERVE, OBSERVE
ACT IN AN INSTANT
RETREAT AND REFLECT allow the inner knowing to emerge
F i g ur e 2 . 3 Th r e e M ov e m e n t s of t h e U
33
34
THE JOURNEY TO “U”
it instantly. It was obvious to connect this conversation with my earlier work on the U. So I drew a U figure on a piece of paper and mapped the key points of the conversation with Brian Arthur onto it and showed it to Joseph. We realized we were onto something very significant. What followed was an intense period of spelling out, crystallizing, and refining the framework. My joint work with Joseph on these issues has taught me much about operating from one’s deeper source of knowing. His life story, which he shares in his book Synchronicity, is itself a great illustration of how an individual can tap into this deeper source of creativity. The next question that came to mind was: What would it take for a group, an organization, or an institution to operate on a similar level? Finding the answer became our quest.8
Francisco Varela on the Blind Spot in Cognition Sciences After that trip, I shared the drawing of Brian Arthur’s three movements through the U with many people. When they followed the pattern of “observe, retreat and reflect, then act in an instant,” many said, “I know this. I have seen this in highly creative people. I have seen this in highly creative moments of my own life.” But then when I asked them, “Okay, and what do work and life actually look like in your current context and organization?” they usually responded, “Not like this, it’s different. It’s more like this downloading thing.” What remained puzzling was that most people know this deeper place of creativity, yet in our everyday work and life, particularly in the context of larger institutions, we seem unable to access it. We remain locked in the old patterns of downloading. Why? I believe we have trouble navigating this deeper territory because we lack a higher-resolution map. We need more than just those three steps. We need a map that shows the archetypal folds and thresholds in between, as well as the stumbling blocks where the process of “observe, observe” is hitting the wall. What would that higher-resolution map look like? Holding that question, I left for Paris to interview the famous cognitive scientist Francisco Varela. At the time I was working on a parallel research project sponsored by Michael Jung of McKinsey & Company. When I first met Varela in 1996, he told me about the blind spot of cognition research.
Theory U
“There is an irreducible core to the quality of experience that needs to be explored with a method. In other words, the problem is not that we don’t know enough about the brain or about biology. The problem is that we don’t know enough about experience. . . . We have had a blind spot in the West for that kind of methodical approach. Everybody thinks they know about experience. I claim we don’t.” Little did I know as I sat in his office in January 2000, it would be our last meeting. One of the most outstanding and promising cognitive scientists of our time, he passed away in 2001. In the course of our conversation, he explained that his current work entailed a triangulation of approaches to the how: psychological introspection, phenomenology, and contemplative practices. “What is common in all of them? What is it that all human beings have?” Varela mused. “. . . So that Germans in the 1880s could do their creative kind of introspection or the inheritors of the Buddha Shakyamuni in the fifth or fourth centuries before Christ could create the techniques of samatha or that somebody like Husserl could create a whole new school of thinking about phenomenology? What is common to these three practices of pragmatics about human experience?” “The key is how will you become aware?” For three years Varela had been working on a book called On Becoming Aware.9 In it he posed the question “Can this core process be cultivated as an ability?” “By looking at these three traditions as practices, you first have to distinguish for lack of a better term, the purely first-person point of view and what one does as an individual at the interface between the first and second person. When it comes to the first person what seems to happen is better seen in terms of three gestures of becoming aware. They are: suspension, redirection, letting-go.”
The Three Gestures On the Left-Hand Side of the U This is something everyone knows instinctively, he said, “But just as a runner must train to become a marathoner, understanding and mastering this process requires study and coaching.” We walked together through the three
35
36
THE JOURNEY TO “U”
gestures. Varela explained. “By suspension I mean the suspension of habitual patterns. In Buddhist meditation, you put your butt on the cushion and move one level above your habitual engagement and see from a more aerial perspective.” We went on to discuss how many people sitting in meditation claim that nothing happens. Why? “Because the whole point is that after suspension you have to tolerate that nothing is happening. Suspension is a very funny procedure. Staying with that is the key.” Then he explained his second and third gestures: redirection and letting go. Redirection is about redirecting your attention from the “exterior” to the “interior” by turning the attention toward the source of the mental process rather than the object. Letting go has to be done with a light touch, he cautioned. As he wrote with his co-authors Natalie Depraz and Pierre Vermersch, it means “to accept our experience.”10 What strikes me about Varela’s description is that the three gestures or turning points in transforming one’s quality of attention match my own experiences in groups. Varela was talking about the deep folds in the structure of our attention that begin to unfold as we progress through the cycle of becoming aware: suspending habitual judgment; redirecting attention from perceived objects to the process of collectively co-creating them; and finally, changing the quality of our attention by letting go of old identities and intentions and allowing something new to come in some emerging future identity and purpose. When I walked out of Varela’s office, I knew I had been handed a gift. Now all I had to do was figure out how to unpack it. As have other facilitators, I had seen these “folds” many times in team processes and workshops as I tried to usher a group through turning points so they could access some deeper place of creativity. First, you help the group suspend judgments in order to see the objective reality they are up against, including the basic figures and facts. Second, you help them redirect their attention from the object to the process in order to help them view the system from a perspective that allows them to see how their own actions contribute to the problem at hand. It is at that point when people begin to see themselves as part of the issue, they begin to see how they collectively create a pattern that at first seemed to
Theory U
DOWNLOADING patterns of the past
suspending SEEING with fresh eyes
redirecting SENSING from the field
letting go PRESENCING connecting to Source
F i g ur e 2 . 4 Th e O p e n i ng P ro ce s s of t h e U
be caused by purely exterior forces. And then, if you are lucky, you can bring them to a deeper place of stillness where they let go of the old and start to connect with their higher-order intentions. I could see in an instant how these folds could be mapped onto the U (Figure 2.4). But I still had more questions. If Varela’s core process of becoming aware illustrates the journey down one side of the U, what about the other part of this journey? What is moving up the right-hand side? It seemed to me that most researchers, educators, and cultivators of cognition and mindfulness were occupied primarily with the “opening process”—the left-hand side of the U—and paid little or no attention to the drama of collective creation that happens when we enter the right-hand side of the U. As every practitioner, innovator, and leader knows, there is a whole other dimension to the collective creativity process that happens on the right-hand side of the U and that deals with intentionally bringing the new into reality. How does something new manifest? How does the new come into being?
37
38
THE JOURNEY TO “U”
The Inner Territory of Leadership Mapping the Right-Hand Side of the U Going down the U moves us through the cognitive spaces of downloading, seeing, sensing, and presencing. But to successfully enter these deeper cognitive spaces, we have to cross the thresholds that Varela was talking about: suspension, redirection, and letting go. I realized that going up the U may be the same journey, except that you cross the thresholds coming from the opposite direction (Figure 2.5). Accordingly, the threshold of letting go (on your way down) turns into the threshold of letting come (on your way up), leading you to the space of crystallizing vision and intention. The threshold of redirecting from the exterior to the inner way of seeing (on your way down) turns into the threshold of redirecting from the inner vision to the exterior action in order to enact a rapid-cycle prototype (on your way up). And finally, the threshold of suspending habits and routines (on your way down) turns into the threshold of institutionalizing by embodying the new in actions, infrastructures, and practices (on your way up). So in each of these cases the same threshold is crossed, but from the other side. DOWNLOADING
PERFORMING
patterns of the past
achieve results through practices, infrastructures
suspending
embodying
SEEING
PROTOTYPING
with fresh eyes
co-create strategic microcosms
redirecting
enacting
SENSING
CRYSTALLIZING
from the field
vision and intention
letting come
letting go PRESENCING connecting to Source
F i g ur e 2 . 5 Th e C om p l e t e U : S i x I n f l e c t ion Poi n t s
Theory U
I have seen groups moving across these thresholds various times. When such a process of profound innovation and change happens, you can watch a group going through some version of the following subtle shifts of the social field (see Figure 2.5): • Downloading: reenacting patterns of the past—viewing the world through one’s habits of thought • Seeing: suspending judgment and seeing reality with fresh eyes—the observed system is separate from those who observe • Sensing: connecting to the field and attending to the situation from the whole—the boundary between observer and observed collapses, the system begins to see itself • Presencing: connecting to the deepest source, from which the field of the future begins to arise—viewing from source • Crystallizing vision and intention—envisioning the new from the future that wants to emerge • Prototyping living microcosms in order to explore the future by doing— enacting the new through “being in dialogue with the universe” • Performing and embodying the new in practices and infrastructures— embedding the new in the context of the larger co-evolving ecosystems If we look at the whole set of these seven cognitive spaces, we can think of it in terms of a house with seven distinct rooms or spaces. Each room represents one of the seven spaces of attention (see Figure 2.5). The problem with most organizations and institutions today is that they use only a few of these rooms— usually the spaces at the upper half of Figure 2.5—while the other ones are rarely used or seldom leveraged. Part II of this book, “Entering the U Field” shows us in much more detail what each of these “rooms” represents and how we can enjoy and leverage being in them and grow from that experience. The rest of my journey toward uncovering Theory U can be best summarized in terms of five key insights or propositions that are introduced here and will be discussed in more detail throughout the remainder of the book.
39
40
THE JOURNEY TO “U”
1. We Need a New Social Technology That Is Based on Tuning Three Instruments While participating in numerous profound innovation and change projects and initiatives, I realized that while most experienced leaders actually do know these deeper levels of the U from their own experience, most organizations, institutions, and larger systems are firmly stuck in Levels 1 or 2. Why? I believe it is because we lack a new social leadership technology. Without a new leadership technology, leaders don’t really shift fields but end up with more of the same. We call these attempts “restructuring,” “redesigning,” or “re-engineering” and more often than not they serve only to deepen our frustration and cynicism. What I am suggesting as an alternative is to develop a new type of social technology that is based on three instruments that each of us already has— an open mind, an open heart, and an open will—and to cultivate these capacities not only on an individual level but also on a collective level.
DOWNLOADING patterns of the past
ACCESS YOUR...
suspending SEEING with fresh eyes
embodying OPEN MIND
redirecting SENSING
PROTOTYPING co-create strategic microcosms
enacting OPEN HEART
from the field
letting go
PERFORMING achieve results through practices, infrastructures
CRYSTALLIZING vision and intention
OPEN WILL
letting come
PRESENCING connecting to Source
who is my self? what is my work?
F i g ur e 2 . 6 Th r e e I ns t r u m e n t s : O p e n M i nd, O p e n H e a r t , O p e n Wil l
Theory U
The first instrument, or capacity, the open mind, is based on our ability to access our intellectual, or IQ, type of intelligence. This allows us to see with fresh eyes, to deal with the objective figures and facts around us. As the saying goes: the mind works like a parachute: it only functions when it is open. The second capacity, the open heart, relates to our ability to access our emotional intelligence, or EQ; that is, our capacity to empathize with others, to tune in to different contexts, and to put ourselves into someone else’s shoes. The third capacity, the open will, relates to our ability to access our authentic purpose and self. This type of intelligence is also sometimes referred to as intention or as SQ (spiritual intelligence). It deals with the fundamental happening of the letting go and letting come. We can tune each of these three instruments on an individual (subjective) as well as on a collective (intersubjective) level. 2. The Most Important Leadership Tool Is Your Self The second insight deals with the evolving nature of every human being and the recognition that we are not “one” but “two.” One self is the person or community we have become as a result of a journey that took place in the past. The other self is the person or community we can become as we journey into the future. It is our highest future possibility. People sometimes refer to the first self using a lowercase “s” and to the second self with a capital “S.” When these two “selves” talk to each other, you experience the essence of presencing. How does this happen? Later we will take this up in more detail, but for now let’s describe it this way. At the bottom of the U is a fundamental threshold one must pass. We might call it going through the eye of the needle. If the process of going through falls short, all our change efforts will remain somewhat superficial. They won’t touch our essential core, our best future Self. We must learn to drop our ego and our habitual “self” in order for the Self to emerge. When our “self” and our “Self” begin to communicate, we establish a subtle but very real link to our highest future possibility that can then begin to help and guide us in situations in which the past can’t offer us useful advice (Figure 2.7).
41
42
THE JOURNEY TO “U”
DOWNLOADING patterns of the past
ACCESS YOUR...
PERFORMING achieve results through practices, infrastructures
suspending SEEING with fresh eyes
embodying OPEN MIND
PROTOTYPING co-create strategic microcosms
redirecting SENSING
enacting OPEN HEART
from the field
letting go
CRYSTALLIZING vision and intention
OPEN WILL
letting come
PRESENCING connecting to Source
who is my self? what is my work?
F i g u r e 2 . 7 Th e M o s t I m p or t a n t To o l : yo u r S e l f
Thus, the most important tool in such a new leadership technology is the leader’s self—your Self. 3. The Leader’s Interior Work Deals with Meeting and Mastering Three Enemies The third insight deals with this puzzle: Why is the journey to the deeper levels of the U always the road less traveled? Because it requires difficult inner work. To go “through the eye of the needle” requires that we face and deal with at least three inner voices of resistance, three enemies that can block the entrance to one of the deeper territories. The first enemy blocks the gate to the open mind. Michael Ray calls this enemy the Voice of Judgment (VOJ). Unless we succeed in shutting down our Voice of Judgment, we will be unable to make progress in accessing our real creativity and presence. The second enemy blocks the gate to the open heart. Let us call this the Voice of Cynicism (VOC)—that is, all types of emotional acts of distancing.
Theory U
DOWNLOADING patterns of the past
ACCESS YOUR...
PERFORMING achieve results through practices, infrastructures
suspending VOJ
embodying OPEN MIND
SEEING with fresh eyes
PROTOTYPING co-create strategic microcosm
redirecting VOC
SENSING
enacting OPEN HEART
from the field
CRYSTALLIZING vision and intention
OPEN WILL
letting go VOF
letting come
PRESENCING connecting to Source
who is my self? what is my work?
F i g u r e 2 . 8 Fa c i n g T h r e e E n e m i e s : V O J , V O C , V O F
What is at stake when we begin to access the open heart? We must first put ourselves into a position of vulnerability, which distancing usually prevents. I am not saying you should never follow your VOC. I am saying that if you want to get to the bottom of the U—to your authentic Self—then your VOC is dysfunctional because it blocks your progress on that journey. The third enemy blocks the gate to the open will. This is the Voice of Fear (VOF). It seeks to prevent us from letting go of what we have and who we are. It can show up as fear of losing economic security. Or fear of being ostracized. Or fear of being ridiculed. And fear of death. And yet meeting and dealing with that voice of fear is the very essence of leadership: to facilitate the letting go of the old “self” and letting come the new “Self.” Then we can step into another world that only begins to take shape once we overcome the fear of stepping into the unknown. 4. The U Is a Living Field Theory—Not a Linear Mechanical Process. The fourth insight concerns an observation that puzzled me when I noticed
43
44
THE JOURNEY TO “U”
that some of the early adopters of the U process applied the principles of this theory in a rather mechanical, linear manner. What this brings to mind is that the essence of Theory U is just the opposite: it works as a matrix, that is, it works as an integral whole, not as a linear process. When you watch Bruce Lee, or Muhammad Ali, or Michael Jordan, you’ll notice that their actions do not follow a linear process. Rather, they dance with the situation they are dealing with—they constantly observe and sense (connect), allow the inner knowing or intuition to emerge, and then act in an instant. And they do it all the time. It’s not three different stages enacted sequentially. You can’t plan to do one each week, with a few days of break in between. Instead, you dance with what surrounds you and with what emerges from within all the time. You dance to all three movements of the U simultaneously, not sequentially. Yet, for practical purposes there is also a real benefit to breaking it down this way: During the co-sensing movement, focus primarily on sensing; during the co-presencing movement, focus on inner knowing; during the co-creation movement, focus on enacting. But keep in mind that all the other movements and capacities are always present. You could think of the U as a holographic theory: each component reflects the whole, yet in a very specific and particular way. In order to enhance their resonance with the deeper fields of emergence, organizations need to establish three different kinds of infrastructures and places: • Places and infrastructures that facilitate a shared seeing and sense-making of what is actually going on in the larger surrounding ecosystem (cosensing) • Places and cocoons of deep reflection and silence that facilitate deep listening and connection to the source of authentic presence and creativity, both individually and collectively (co-presencing) • Places and infrastructures for hands-on prototyping of new forms of operating in order to explore the future by doing (co-creating)
Theory U
PERFORMING
DOWNLOADING
ACCESS YOUR...
patterns of the past
achieve results through practices, infrastructures
suspending
embodying OPEN MIND
VOJ SEEING
PROTOTYPING co-create strategic microcosm
with fresh eyes
redirecting
enacting OPEN HEART
VOC SENSING
CRYSTALLIZING
from the field
vision and intention
letting go VOF
OPEN WILL
letting come
CO-SENSING:
PRESENCING
CO-CREATING:
Places and practices of connecting and seeing
connecting to Source
Places and practices of prototyping
who is my self? what is my work? CO-PRESENCING: Places and practices of stillness and presence
F i g ur e 2 . 9 C r e at i ng Th r e e I n f r a s t r uc t ur e s
5. The Rise of the Social Space of Emergence and Creation (Cycle of Presencing) Is Connected to the Dying and Transformation of Social Space of Destruction (Cycle of Absencing) Our final insight concerns the observation of the massive rise of destruction, violence, and fundamentalism at the same time that we also see an opening to the deeper layers of the social field. That double movement, the opening to the deeper levels of emergence, on the one hand, and the enhanced power of the forces of destruction, on the other, is a defining feature of our time. This proposition tries to shed some light on how these two forces—those of presencing and absencing—relate to each other. It suggests that both are aspects of a single evolutionary movement. Often we see how people in the face of the utmost destruction have the ability to wake up to a higher level of awareness and consciousness. Throughout this book I will share several of these stories, including the story of my colleague Adam Kahane with a group in Guatemala and the story of the women of the Rosenstrasse in Berlin in
45
46
THE JOURNEY TO “U”
1943. These and other stories illustrate that all of us around the world participate in two different social types of connection, two different bodies of the social field. One of them is governed by the dynamics of antiemergence and destruction; it’s the collective social body that is about to die. The other is governed by the dynamics of emergence and collective creativity; it’s the emerging new social body that is about to be born. What happens in numerous social situations of violence and connection today is that we are torn between these two worlds. We can switch from one space (the space of collective creativity) to the other (the space of collective destruction) in an instant and almost any time and anywhere, and our noticing this switch depends on how awake we are to one another. In the remaining chapters of Part I we will go on a learning journey in which we will see that in all these system levels basically the same thing happens: we increasingly bump into our own blind spot. That is, time and again, we are thrown into empty-canvas situations that require us to look at ourselves, at our collective patterns of behavior; to reinvent ourselves, who we are, and where we want to go as an institution, as an individual, and as a community. In Part II we will uncover the core process of illuminating this blind spot. And in Part III we will investigate in much more detail how this profound transformation of the global field is playing out across all systems levels from the individual (micro) to groups (meso), institutions (macro), and the world (mundo). As you go through the journey of this book—if you choose to do so—you will notice that at times I share with you some frameworks that at first may seem a little complex (for example, Table 20.1). But what you will also notice is that all these frameworks and distinctions are derived from the examples and stories discussed throughout the book. When you look at them all together, you may realize that what you see is something that could be called the footprints of our collective evolutionary process. It’s the evolutionary grammar that we enact collectively across all systems levels. Every day. It’s our own story. So seeing, recognizing, and attending to these patterns is not
Theory U
just a theoretical exercise—it gives us a whole different way to act as change agents who can collectively bring forth a world that is profoundly different from that of the past. How to do this, how to begin to operate from the future as it emerges, is the question that underlies and organizes this book. With this question in mind, let us now turn our attention to how a team learns.
47
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 3
Fourfold Learning and Change • Thought Leader Interview Project • The Split Between Matter and Mind • Two Sources and Types of Learning • Organizational Learning’s Blind Spot
Levels of Learning and Change
Levels of Learning and Change
I
n Chapter 1, “Facing the Fire,” I recounted how, as a young boy in Germany, I was literally shaken into a new level of experience or being by our family farm’s fire. In retrospect, I see that experience as a gift life
handed me: the gift of experiencing a profound shift in my attention field, in the way I attend to the world. That’s the easy part. The difficult part is to perform this shift in the context of groups and organizations. How can we as a group shift our attention field so that we connect to our best future potential instead of continuing to operate from the experiences of our past? And how can we perform this shift of attention without having our family farm burning down every day? That is exactly the challenge that brought me to the MIT Organizational Learning Center in the mid-1990s. When I arrived in Boston in the fall of 1994, I had just completed my Ph.D. in economics and management. My thesis, “Reflective Modernization 49
50
FOURFOLD LEARNING AND CHANGE
of Capitalism: A Revolution from Within,” argued that in order to cope with the challenges of our time, societies need to develop the capacity to learn across institutional boundaries. In all of the key areas of society, we collectively produce results that few people (if anyone) want: schools that prevent our children from unfolding their capacity for deeper learning; health care systems that fight symptoms rather than address the root causes of health problems; industrial production systems that are out of sync with the principles and laws of our planetary ecosystem; an approach to world politics that focuses on issues such as terrorism by reacting to the symptoms rather than addressing the systemic causes. In each example the fundamental problem is the same: How can we approach problems in ways that don’t repeat the (failing) patterns of the past? One of my first insights after arriving at that MIT Organizational Learning Center was this: there are several different dimensions for how to approach change, some more visible than others. The most common one and the most visible: a crisis or a need for change occurs and we “react.” Four levels of responding to change are pictured in Figure 3.1. Level 1 is
1. REACTING
Manifest action
Process, structure
Thinking
Sources of intention and creativity
dynamic complexity
social complexity
emerging complexity
2. REDESIGNING
3. REFRAMING
4. PRESENCING
F i g ur e 3 . 1 Four L e v e l s of L e a r n ing a nd C h a nge
Theory U
reacting, to respond by operating on existing habits and routines. Level 2 is redesigning: changing the underlying structure and process. Level 3 is reframing: changing the underlying pattern of thought. Most time and resources in our current organizations and institutions are spent on Levels 1 and 2, reacting to issues and reorganizing structure and process. While in some cases this type of reaction is perfectly appropriate, in others it is not. According to some studies, about 70 percent of business reengineering projects undertaken during the 1990s failed.1 Why? Because reengineering usually operates at the first two levels only. The people involved do not deeply rethink or “reframe” the problem. By contrast, organizational learning methods approach the task of managing change by addressing not only the first two levels but also the third, the level of rethinking and reframing one’s fundamental assumptions about the situation at issue. Harvard and MIT researchers Chris Argyris and Donald Schön suggest a terminology where we can refer to Level 2 as single-loop learning and to Level 3 as double-loop learning. Single-loop learning means that we reflect on our actions. Double-loop goes one step further and includes a reflection on the deep, taken-for-granted assumptions. Until now, organizational learning has been concerned primarily with how to build, nurture, and sustain the learning process based on single- and double-loop learning, on learning from past experience. There are many fine examples, good research, and great books that demonstrate how to put these learning cycles into practice.2 Today, we know a lot about what it takes to build environments that sustain and foster processes of learning that correspond with Levels 2 and 3 of Figure 3.1. However, in working with companies in various cultures and sectors, I found that leadership teams are wrestling with challenges that cannot be adequately addressed by reflecting only on the past (Level 3). Companies are struggling to succeed in an unprecedentedly turbulent, complex, and rapidly changing global context. Their executives realize that simply reflecting on what has happened in the past will not be adequate to help them figure out what to do next. By watching leadership teams analyze and address such challenges, we began to recognize a fourth level of learning and knowing:
51
52
FOURFOLD LEARNING AND CHANGE
learning from the future as it emerges (see Figure 3.1). I have named this discipline “presencing” because it involves a particular way of being aware of and experiencing the present moment. Presencing denotes the ability of individuals and collective entities to link directly with their highest future potential. When they are able to do this, they begin to operate from a more generative and more authentic presence in the moment—in the now.
Thought Leader Interview Project: What Is the Source of Our Collective Action? When I first met Michael Jung in 1994, he was the head of McKinsey & Co.’s office in Vienna and of a worldwide research initiative on leadership. In Munich, we began an intriguing conversation about leading and organizing. At the end of that conversation, Jung asked whether I would be interested in conducting a global interview project with the world’s leading thinkers on the topic of leadership, organization, and strategy. “All of the interviews will be made public. You can use them for your postdoc research, and I can use them in my work at McKinsey. Furthermore, anyone else who’s interested can download them from a Web site. It is our hope that people will use them to stimulate their own thinking and creativity.” Of course I was interested, so after returning to Boston I asked several people for their input and help, and within a few days we had developed a list of people we considered to be among the most interesting and innovative thought leaders, including academics, entrepreneurs, businesspeople, inventors, scientists, educators, artists, and others.3 One of the first interviews I conducted was with Peter Senge, who was then head of the Center for Organizational Learning at MIT. Senge’s book The Fifth Discipline was one of the main reasons I had wanted to join the Center. I started the interview the same way I often did, by asking “What underlying question does your work address?” Senge said that his deepest interest concerned the conscious evolution of human systems. He then told me about his recent encounter with KarlHenrik Robèrt, a Swedish physician and founder of the worldwide environ-
Theory U
mental organization The Natural Step. “Something in his story really struck me,” Senge explained. “And I realized there is a direct parallel to my own experience. Robert’s been doing research on cancer for most of his professional career and has dealt with hundreds of families facing the cancer of a parent, a child, or a spouse. He said, ‘What’s always amazed me are human beings’ incredible reserves of strength. You know what a strong force denial is, but you tell people incredibly difficult things—[such as] your three-yearold has cancer—and stand amazed at how weak those forces are compared to people’s capacity to face the truth and work together as families, as loved ones facing the most horrible situations you can imagine.’” Senge said he too had come to recognize the great power of facing reality from years of leading a well-known personal growth course called “Leadership and Mastery.” One overarching question, he told me, governs his work: “How does one help people collectively tap into the real reserves that exist for profound change, for facing things which seem insoluble, impossible to alter?” He continued: “Many people would say that human beings are basically self-centered and fundamentally materialistic, and that’s why society is the way it is. That’s just the way things are. “But, of course,” he continued, “the way things are is just a mental model, and in the right setting, people confront that and they experience real generosity. So how do you begin to release that kind of energy collectively?” As Peter continued to tell his story, I listened and started to feel time slowing down. I began to attend from a deeper level. “I had an interesting conversation a year ago with Master Nan, the Chinese Zen master who lives in Hong Kong,” Peter said. “In China he’s a very revered figure. He’s considered an extraordinary scholar because of his integration of Buddhism, Taoism, and Confucianism. I asked him, ‘Do you think that the industrial age will create such environmental problems that we will destroy ourselves and that we must find a way to understand these problems and change industrial institutions?’” Master Nan paused and shook his head in response. “He didn’t completely agree with that. It wasn’t the way he saw it. He saw it at a deeper level, and he said, ‘There’s only one issue in the world. It’s the reintegration of matter and
53
54
FOURFOLD LEARNING AND CHANGE
mind.’ That’s exactly what he said to me, the reintegration of matter and mind.” Those words hit on something that resonated deeply with my own question: What does the split between matter and mind mean to our social world as a whole, to the social body that we collectively enact? I was reminded of my parents’ work. The visible result of farming, the harvest, depends on the invisible quality of the field itself. So I wondered: What if the quality of the visible social worlds is a function of this invisible field that resides in our blind spot of perception? The quality of this invisible field—our blind spot—defines the quality of our visible social action. Master Nan said our primary issue is the reintegration of matter and mind. That implies that if we want to increase the quality of our action as a group or a team, we need to pay attention to the invisible dimension of its source: the place from where we operate.
The Split Between Matter and Mind I asked Senge how he saw the separation of mind and matter relating to our world of groups and organizations. “We basically create organizations which are like matter in the sense that they obtain an apparently independent existence outside ourselves,” he replied, “and then we become prisoners of those organizations.” Organizations work the way human beings create them. They maintain that it is “the system” that causes their problems. It’s always something external, some thing that imposes itself on them. So the reality might actually be: “Thought creates organizations, and then organizations hold human beings prisoner,” or, as the quantum physicist, David Bohm, used to say, “Thought creates the world and then says ‘I didn’t do it!’” “To me,” continued Senge, “here’s the essence of what systems thinking is about: People begin to consciously discover and account for how their own patterns of thought and interaction manifest on a large scale and create the very forces by which the organization then ‘is doing it to me.’ And then they complete that feedback loop. The most profound experiences I’ve ever seen in consulting have always been when people suddenly say things like, ‘Holy
Theory U
cow! Look what we are doing to ourselves!’ . . . or ‘Given the way we operate, no wonder we can’t win!’ And what is always significant to me, in those moments, is the we. Not ‘you,’ not ‘them,’ but we. . . . A true systems philosophy closes the feedback loop between the human being, their experience of reality, and their sense of participation in that whole cycle of awareness and enactment.” I had read a lot about organizational learning and systems thinking, but it had never occurred to me this clearly and simply. The essence of systems thinking is to help people close the feedback loop between the enactment of systems on a behavioral level and its invisible source of awareness and thought. To that comment Senge responded quietly, “Yes, I don’t think I’ve ever thought about it quite this way anytime before.” I left that conversation feeling as if I had somehow encountered an essential aspect of my own question. I couldn’t verbalize the question, but I could feel it. It was physical—a distinct bodily sensation that lasted for a week or two.4 When it faded away, I started to think about it in terms of seeing the deeper aspects of social reality, the deeper conditions from which social action arises moment by moment. I realized that that deeper territory—the sources or the deeper field conditions from which we operate—is what we so often miss. It may be the most important blind spot in contemporary social systems theory.
Two Sources and Types of Learning When I first arrived at MIT, I was a rather conventional white male European academic: strong on intellectual reflection, weak on practical experience and useful knowledge. What attracted me to MIT was the opportunity to learn the craft of advanced action research from some of its outstanding representatives, such as Edgar Schein, the co-founder of process consultation and organizational psychology. According to the founder of action research, Kurt Lewin (1890–1947), who was born in Germany and emigrated to the United States when Hitler came to power, the starting point for action research is the knowledge that in order to really understand the social process, researchers
55
56
FOURFOLD LEARNING AND CHANGE
must not just study but also work and participate in practical and real settings. But how does one know whether a particular piece of “knowledge” is true? When does an action researcher know he knows? When I posed this question to Ed Schein, he replied, “When my knowledge is helpful to the various practitioners in the field—that is the moment when I know that I know.”5 This idea continues to be a guiding principle for my own research. In numerous action research projects I have worked to help leadership teams go through deep processes of change. While I have gained some firsthand knowledge about the world of companies and the issues their leaders face, I have also gone down a path that took me far from established institutions and into the world of grassroots activists, entrepreneurs, and revolutionary innovators. What I learned in these different worlds of inquiry and action can be summed up in a single sentence: There are two sources of learning: the past and the emerging future. How to learn from the past is well known: its sequence is action-observation-reflection-design-action.6 But how can one learn from the future? That is the subject and goal of this book.7
Organizational Learning’s Blind Spot Teams and organizational units that try to follow this new trail of learning often give up in frustration. They realize that it is not possible to effect deep change of the type discussed above by applying the conventional methods of learning and change that they have used before. Learning from the past doesn’t work. It’s not as simple as saying, “Let’s just add ‘learning from the emerging future’ as the final step of this process.” It doesn’t work that way. We need to do on a collective level what happened to me when I was standing in front of the burning farmhouse. We have to drop all our old tools and attend to the situation with fresh eyes.8 We have to abandon our conventional ways of reacting and operating. We have to deepen our attention to and wonder about the world. We have to bend our habituated beam of attending
Theory U
to the world and redirect it onto its source—the blind spot from which we operate moment by moment. We have to connect to this source in order to tune in to the future that is seeking to emerge. It is a quest. But we have what I have come to call the subtle, invisible dimension—the underlying source to help us. The deep structures of the social field determine the quality of our actions just as the field of the farmer determines the quality of the yield. We can shift the quality of this underlying field in such a way that it opens our horizon to higher future possibilities. It is then when we begin to accomplish profound social renewal and change.
57
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 4
Organizational Complexity • Social Complexity • Emerging Complexity • The Manager’s Job • From Product to Process to Source • Leading with a Blank Canvas • The Co-Evolving Context of Organizations • The Institutional Blind Spot
Dynamic Complexity
Dynamic Complexity
L
eaders in all organizations and institutions face new levels of complexity and change. I decided to take a closer look at where that complexity originates. Inspired by the work of Senge and Roth and their
distinction between dynamic and behavior complexity, I found three different types of complexity that impact the challenges that leaders have to deal with: dynamic, social, and emerging complexity. Of the three, dynamic complexity is more often used and most often easily recognized. Dynamic complexity means that there is a systematic distance or delay between cause and effect in space or time. Take, for example, the dynamic complexities of global warming. Our emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2)—one cause—will have a long-term impact on the future of our planet. The greenhouse effects that we observe today are caused mainly by emissions from (and up to) the 1970s. If my organization decides to reduce its emissions of CO2, we will reduce our impact on the global climate. But what if 59
60
ORGANIZATIONAL COMPLEXITY
DYNAMIC COMPLEXITY: cause and effect are distant in space and time
EMERGING COMPLEXITY:
whole-system approach
disruptive patterns of innovation and change
sensing and presencing approach
SOCIAL COMPLEXITY: actors have different views and interests
multistakeholder approach
F i g ur e 4 . 1 Th r e e Ty p e s of C om p l e x i t y
our products are a part of a larger product that increases the emission of CO2? Or what about emissions produced by the transportation of our goods? The longer and more complex this chain of cause and effect, the higher the dynamic complexity of the problem. If the dynamic complexity is low, it can be dealt with piece by piece. If the dynamic complexity is high, a “whole-systems” approach that pays sufficient attention to cross-system interdependencies is the appropriate approach. The managerial implications of dynamic complexity are straightforward: the greater the dynamic complexity, the higher the interdependence among the subcomponents of a system, and, therefore, using a whole-systems approach to problem solving becomes even more important.
Theory U
Social Complexity Once the dynamic complexity of an issue is addressed, the more likely it is that a second type of complexity will move to the foreground: social complexity. Social complexity is a product of diverse interests and worldviews among stakeholders. For example, the Kyoto protocols on climate change and the reduction of CO2 emissions have been agreed upon and supported by most international experts. However, these protocols are of limited use because three of the most polluting countries—the United States, India, and Brazil— have not signed the treaty. This issue clearly illustrates diverse interests, worldviews and values. The lower the social complexity, the more we can rely on experts to guide decision and policy making.1 The greater the social complexity, the more important it is that a multistakeholder approach to real problem solving that includes all of the relevant stakeholders’ voices be employed.
Emerging Complexity Emerging complexity is characterized by disruptive change. Challenges of this type can usually be recognized by these three characteristics: 1.The solution to the problem is unknown. 2. The problem statement itself is still unfolding. 3. Who the key stakeholders are is not clear. When the future cannot be predicted by the trends and trajectories of the past, we must deal with situations as they evolve. The greater the emerging complexity, the less we can rely on past experiences. We need a new approach—one that builds on sensing, presencing, and prototyping emerging opportunities. These three will be described more fully in Chapters 10, 11, and 13. But for now, we should describe sensing as the view from “within”—a perception that begins to take shape when we begin to feel and sense the whole field. It is usually accompanied by increased energy and a shift to a
61
62
ORGANIZATIONAL COMPLEXITY
“deeper place.” Presencing, as we have already briefly touched upon, is the state we experience when we have opened our minds, our hearts and our intentions or wills and can, as a result, view things from the source. It allows us to connect and move with emerging new realities and rapid change that cannot be addressed by reflecting on past experiences. Prototyping follows the crystallizing stage, or the stage when we actually develop a sense of the future that wants to emerge. Prototyping means to explore the future by doing, and builds on a practical integration of the head, heart, and hand. It very quickly creates practical results that can then generate feedback and suggestions for improvement by all key stakeholders of the system at issue. The rise of generative complexity in many important leadership challenges is due to the increasingly turbulent environment in which business, civic, and public-sector organizations operate. That change in context is the principle driver of the need to learn and lead from the right side of the “U”: from the emerging future.
The Manager’s Job When it comes right down to it, the only “job” we have as managers is to mobilize action and produce results. To do this, we must integrate goals, strategies, personalities, and processes. Over the past several decades, we have seen two major shifts in how we approach our work. First, we have shifted from an emphasis on the what to the how. Second, we have shifted the how to the where; from process (how) to the inner place from which managers and systems operate and act (who). I first noticed this shift of focus in 1996, when I asked Richard LeVitt of Hewlett-Packard in Palo Alto, then the company-wide director of quality, about HP’s quality concerns. “First, we used to focus mainly on product outcomes and concrete results like product reliability.” LeVitt paused. “Though these are still important, we realized we could achieve more by shifting our focus upstream and thinking about the processes that produce these results. This stage of managing quality was the heart of the TQM [total quality management] movement in the eighties. But once we got the
Theory U
processes right, we asked—what next? What will be the next basis for competitive advantage?” LeVitt went on to describe what he saw as the next performance threshold: “For us, one critical new focus area has been how managers can improve their quality of thought and their deep perception of customers and the experiences customers should have with us.”
From Product to Process to Source HP’s shift from product to process and from process to source can be observed in all of the functional areas of management. Figure 4.2 depicts twelve different management areas. The upper half features the more tangible functions (manufacturing, HR, R&D, finance, accounting, strategy, marketing, and sales) and the lower half the less tangible functions (quality, knowledge, leadership, change, and communication). finance hr
accounting Financial capital Traditional accounting
HR planning
strategy r&d Positioning of products
First generation corporate driven
manufacturing
Mass marketing productdriven
Mass production vertical integration
marketing
PR one-way
Measuring results
communication quality K1 IT
knowledge
DOWNSTREAM:
Redesigning
DYNAMIC COMPLEXITY
change
MBO
leadership
F i g u r e 4 . 2 Tw e l v e m a na ge m e n t F u n c t i o n s : D o w n s t r e a m Vi e w
63
64
ORGANIZATIONAL COMPLEXITY
Over the past couple of decades, similar developmental shifts and story lines have unfolded in all functional areas: we notice a shift of focus from product to process and from process to source in all of the functional areas of management.
The First Shift: Moving from a Focus on Tangible Results to a Focus on Process (Downstream to Midstream) In the initial stage, the focus is on the downstream functions such as measuring the results of product reliability, as depicted in the outer ring in Figure 4.2. One key characteristic of this stage is functional differentiation which means that the management tasks are split up into a set of subtasks— finance, strategy, human resources, manufacturing, and so on. A second characteristic of this phase is what I call a downstream focus. Each separate managerial area puts its main focus on functional performance metrics such as costs, parts delivered on time, product reliability, and so forth. The various management areas are integrated through the mechanism of hierarchy. finance hr
accounting
strategy r&d
Corporate universities
IC ABC
Second generation project driven
manufacturing
Core competence Masscustomized service-driven
Lean supply chain
marketing
CSR two-way
TQM
K2 MIDSTREAM: CoP Reframing
SOCIAL COMPLEXITY quality
communication
MBWA
change
knowledge leadership
F i g u r e 4 . 3 Tw e l v e M a na ge m e n t F u n c t i o n s : M i d s t r e a m Vi e w
Theory U
During the 1980s and 1990s, the mainstream focus of management shifted toward processes. This change, depicted in Figure 4.3, shows movement from the outer circle toward the middle circle, that is, to a more processbased view. Examples are process-based philosophies such as total quality management (TQM), knowledge management processes, organizational learning, lean production, and activity-based costing (ABC). In all these examples, the focus is on how to improve the process; in other words, how to approach, organize, and optimize certain activities and managerial tasks. For example, in the case of organizational learning, the experiential learning cycle functions as a basic framework for designing learning infrastructures that support organizational learning processes. Another aspect of this shifting of managerial attention is the issue of cross-functional integration. In order to integrate and coordinate work across functional and organizational boundaries, people need to learn how to handle social complexity in the context of increasingly interdependent ways of organizing and performing. The leaders of each subtask or function have their own interests, networks, and goals, so they need different management skills in order to handle the social complexity of cross-functional integration in the core processes of value creation.
The Second Shift: Moving from a Focus on Process to a Focus on Source (Midstream to Upstream) The third stage, which started during the 1990s and continues today, shifts the focus from process to sources of innovation and change (see Figure 4.4). As Richard LeVitt put it, once you have your processes right, what is your next leverage point to enhance the stream of value creation? The third stage, represented by the center of the management wheel, deals with the issue of emerging complexity and is characterized by a collapse of boundaries between functions. Each function may enter through a different door, but they all arrive at essentially the same place. As Michael Jung put it, “Everybody is climbing the same mountain, but each views it from a different angle and believes that it is an entirely different mountain.” In spite of all the different labels, names, and discourses, in the center of the wheel all
65
66
ORGANIZATIONAL COMPLEXITY
finance hr
accounting
strategy r&d Risk Management TBL ELIAS Third gen: Revolution co-creation
UPSTREAM:
manufacturing
MPM Personal, EMERGINGcreation-driven v-constellation
marketing
COMPLEXITY
Customer experience K3 Ba
Coinspiring
Tri-sector innovation Reinventing
communication quality
change
knowledge leadership
F i g u r e 4 . 4 Tw e l v e M a na ge m e n t F u n c t i o n s : U p s t r e a m Vi e w
twelve functions deal with the same fundamental realities: how to access and sustain the source for resilience, profound innovation, renewal and change—that is, how to deal effectively with emerging complexity.2 The wheel of management depicts an organic breathing process. The completeness of that breathing determines the health and wholeness of an organizational field. Breathing in moves attention from execution toward the sources of attention and intention, while whatever emerges from the center is breathed out and enacted in the downstream areas of managing and organizing. The point is not to argue for an upstream point of view of leadership at the expense of processes, capabilities (midstream), and execution (downstream), but to conceive of the whole field of leading and organizing as a single living entity, one that is grounded in and constantly renewed from the source of attention and intention at the center. In this view the whole of an organization or field is dependent on and emerges only from the relationship of all its parts. The center does not exist without the periphery, and vice versa.
Theory U
Underlying the wheel of management are two axes: the more tangible functions are on the upper half; the exterior-oriented functions are on the right side of the wheel and the interior-oriented functions show up on the left. Good management has to do with balancing and integrating all twelve aspects—a job that, as Henry Mintzberg once pointed out, researchers usually tend to leave to practitioners. The nature of successful managing and organizing has to do with seeing, appreciating, and integrating a diverse range of perspectives. For example, in strategy, this development is evident in the shift from core competence to sources of industry revolution. First there were the conventional approaches to strategizing that revolved around positioning in terms of product–market combinations.3 Such approaches dealt with well-defined products in well-defined markets. Then, in 1990, along came a Harvard Business Review (HBR) article by Gary Hamel and C. K. Prahalad entitled “The Core Competence of the Organization,” which shifted the focus of attention from downstream to midstream, from product to core competence.4 Real strategy work, the authors argued, must revolve around the clarification of core competencies that generate the downstream product–market combinations. When I first met and interviewed Gary Hamel in 1996, I was surprised to learn that he hadn’t given a single speech on core competencies for the previous five years. He was already working on the next shift of focus, which he subsequently articulated in his 1996 HBR article “Strategy as Revolution” and his 2002 book Leading the Revolution. His main point in these publications was that reinventing industries requires a capacity different from that required to sustain existing core competencies. Future business success requires the capacity to sense tomorrow’s core competencies and opportunities. While the mainstream approach of the 1990s tapped into then-current best practices, Hamel thought that, in the upstream approach to strategy, the source of knowing comes from tapping the resources of dormant innovations and ideas that reside on the periphery of a company, thereby extending the scope of strategizing beyond organizational boundaries by involving customers, partners, and frontline employees.
67
68
ORGANIZATIONAL COMPLEXITY
In their book Competition for the Future, Hamel and Prahalad compare this upstream shift of focus to pregnancy. “Like competition for the future, pregnancy has three stages—conception, gestation, and delivery,” they wrote. “It is the last stage of competition that is the focus of strategy textbooks and strategic planning exercises. Typically, the assumption is that the product or service concept is well established, the dimensions of competition are well defined, and the boundaries of the industry have stabilized. But focusing on the last stage of market-based competition, without a deep understanding of pre-market competition, is like trying to make sense of the process of childbirth without any insight into conception and gestation.”5 The question for managers to ask themselves at this point, they argue, is “Which stage receives the bulk of our time and attention: conception, gestation, or labor and delivery? Our experience suggests that most managers spend a disproportionate amount of time in the delivery room, waiting for the miracle of birth . . . But as we all know, the miracle of birth is most unlikely unless there’s been some activity nine months previously.” Our current decade brought a shift of context for managing innovation from high growth to massive market turbulence and resulted in a higher emphasis on capabilities such as resilience and deep values such as ethical integrity.6 The rise and fall of Enron, a company featured frequently in Hamel’s Leading the Revolution, has been a wake-up call for many. Enron has proved that revolutionary strategy and innovation are not values in themselves but must be embedded and grounded in a shared sense and real connection with the larger social context or whole. That connection to the larger social context can function as a strategic entry point for rethinking and reinventing one’s strategy towards serving the needs of the 3 billion people that live on less than $2 a day, as C.K. Prahalad argues in his 2005 book The Fortune at the Bottom of the Pyramid: Eradicating Poverty Through Profits (2005). What it takes to radically rethink one’s approach to strategy based on serving the needs of the people whose needs in the current system are unmet, is a capacity to operate from the blank canvas. As depicted in Figure 4.4’s core or inner circle, managers and leaders today stand more and more in front of chal-
Theory U
lenges that require them to operate from the blank canvas, to sense and actualize emerging opportunities as they arise. Let us now look at two other examples.
Example 1: Knowledge Management Like any artistic creation, each stage of management requires a different type of knowledge. For instance, when managers measure the outcomes of the production process, they usually operate with explicit knowledge. Explicit knowledge is knowledge that can be expressed in spreadsheets and e-mails. In the first stage of knowledge management, people relied on IT to manage knowledge systems and databanks. After several years (and several billion dollars) it has become obvious that IT is but one part of a larger puzzle. Many say, the easy part. Managers soon realized the challenge lies in moving beyond information management to knowledge management. In the second stage of knowledge management, people focused on process improvements, such as TQM; here we find embodied or tacit knowledge; this is knowledge that is simply “known” and carried out in everyday actions. However, when managers move into the upstream realm of innovation, as they do in the third phase of knowledge management, they find, like an artist standing in front of a blank canvas or like Michelangelo carving David, they have to first see it. In Figure 4.5, above the arch, we have explicit knowledge, corresponding with the outer ring in the management wheel (Figure 4.2); below the wave lies our tacitly embodied knowledge, corresponding to the middle ring in the management wheel (Figure 4.3) and our self-transcending knowledge, corresponding to the inner hub of the management wheel (Figure 4.4). Johnson & Johnson’s Michael Burtha portrays the movement of knowledge management from explicit to tacit when explaining that the real challenge lies in creating spaces for peers to share complex knowledge across units, functions, and organizations that will enable high-performance teams to operate effectively. From this perspective, knowledge is not a thing but something living, situated and embedded in work practices.7 Knowledge without context is not knowledge; it’s just information.8 Real knowledge, argue
69
70
ORGANIZATIONAL COMPLEXITY
explicit knowledge
tacit knowledge [embodied]
self-transcending knowledge [not-yet-embodied]
F i g ur e 4 . 5 Th r e e For m s of K now l e d ge
Ikujiro Nonaka and Hirotaka Takeuchi in their groundbreaking book, The Knowledge-Creating Company, is a “situational living process that evolves in a spiraling movement between explicit and tacit dimensions of knowledge held by individuals, teams, and the organization.”9 This new definition of knowledge as a living process was embraced in the 1990s. The late 1990s and early 2000s saw a further shift, one that deals with the conditions and sources of profound innovation and change. We now wish to learn how to respond to turbulence and disruptive change with resilience and flexibility, how to sense and seize emerging future opportunities, how to tune in to the sources of “not-yet-embodied” knowledge.10 This most recent stage is reflected in Nonaka’s concept of phronesis, practical wisdom, and ba, the Japanese word for “place,” which refers to the physical, social, and mental context of knowledge creation. Ba is “context in motion,” according to Nonaka. I call it “not-yet-embodied” or “self-transcending” knowledge.11 Many people agree with Nonaka’s assessment that knowledge cannot be managed. Why? Because it’s a living process, not a dead body. Instead of managing or controlling knowledge, Nonaka says, we need to create the conditions that will allow all three aspects of knowledge management to emerge: IT systems, a knowledge creation process, and places that are conducive to this kind of work.
Theory U
Example 2: Manufacturing Tom Johnson, the co-author of Relevance Lost: The Rise and Fall of Management Accounting and Profit Beyond Measure, told me in an interview the following story of how car manufacturing moved from mass to lean production. He used this example of what is probably the world’s most famous auto factory, located near Detroit. “Coming out of World War II, Ford and Toyota looked at Henry Ford’s River Rouge plant. The plant was built during World War I and ran in the 1920s building the Model Ts. That was the classic model of mass production, and every automaker knew it by heart. It was a useful model if you were going to mass-produce one car, one color, one way. “Following the war, the big question then was how to a make a variety of cars without building a separate plant for each variety. Ford Motor Company came up with a solution by building something to massive scale and then
finance hr
accounting
strategy r&d Positioning of products Core competence Revolution
manufacturing
Mass production vertical integration
Lean MPM supply chain v-constellation
marketing
K3 Ba K2 CoP
communication quality K1 IT
change
knowledge leadership
F i g ur e 4 . 6 S h if t s of Fo c us f rom D ow ns t r e a m to u p s t r e a m
71
72
ORGANIZATIONAL COMPLEXITY
running it at the highest possible throughput rate you could. Always keeping it up and running meant your cost would be as low as possible. . . . “The problem was, you couldn’t produce variety in a continuous line flow like Henry Ford was running, because to make two different varieties along the same line means you’ve got to stop and change over somehow, somewhere. Their solution was to decouple the line. Break up the continuous flow that Ford had, and put your paint shop in one place, your stamping plant in another place, do your welding or your riveting somewhere else. . . . “So economies-of-scale thinking grew at the heart of Ford’s, and GM’s, and other American manufacturing thinking in all those years.” By contrast, the development of the next manufacturing stage, later referred to as “lean production,” began as a different way of seeing reality—in fact, in a different way of looking at Henry Ford’s River Rouge plant. When the Toyota engineers looked at the River Rouge plant, according to Johnson, they concluded that its costs were low because of the continuous flow. They went back to Japan, and since they didn’t have any factories left after the war, they decided they’d do it all in one plant in one continuous flow. “By the 1970s,” continued Tom Johnson, “when we first started to become aware of what was going on, changeover rates were down to minute fractions of what we took for granted over here. We had stamping presses that took eight hours to change, but the Japanese changed them in twenty or thirty minutes. Eventually, by the early eighties, they were getting it down in the range of six, eight, ten minutes. Having done that, they were able to build what they called the Mixed Model Line. Now you could have a continuously flowing line, and for a certain period you could see red ones come through, followed by blue ones, and whatever the model mix that was required by the customers for that day would flow along. They had enormous variety at very low cost because they had a system where they were able to build one order at a time, to fill one order at a time. A wholly different conception of the world is lying behind this.” The stunning success of the Toyota production system became widely known through an MIT study that described the process principles behind this way of manufacturing as lean production.12 It uses less capital and labor
Theory U
while reengineering the manufacturing process as a synchronized single flow.13 In the time it took the Western auto industry to move from mass production (stage one) to lean production (stage two), Toyota had already started moving toward a stage-three production system. The downside of the lean production approach was a lack of synergy and integration across projects and platforms. By contrast, the new system, which MIT’s Michael A. Cusumano and Kentaro Nobeoka call “multiproject management,” simultaneously links and coordinates engineering efforts in different projects and platforms. According to Toyota sources, the new system helped reduce development costs on the average project by 30 percent and the number of testing prototypes by 40 percent. It relies on huge increases in component sharing and intensive communication and coordination between engineering and testing functions, creating communication infrastructures that facilitate simultaneous innovations across projects and platforms. Manufacturing has shifted from vertical integration (stage one) to more horizontally integrated supply chain management (stage two) and webshaped “value constellations” that focus on innovating and optimizing the whole system (stage three).14 Whereas supply chains presuppose a linear stream of value creation that follows the flow of material from suppliers to customers, web-shaped value constellations conceive of customers not only as end-of-the-pipe recipients of products but as active co-creators of the economic value rendered by a web-shaped network of collaboration. For example, when Mercedes-Benz customers fetch their new cars in Germany, they do not simply pick up a new vehicle. They can get an inside view of the factory, which allows to become real witnesses to and participants of the manufacturing process that created their car.
Leading with a Blank Canvas While management is about “getting things done,” leadership is about creating and cultivating the larger context—the fertile common ground and soil— in which things can happen.15
73
74
ORGANIZATIONAL COMPLEXITY
First, business leaders embraced a directive approach: command-and-control. They set clear agendas and objectives designed to mobilize and guide an entire company. While no one would say this type of leadership is obsolete, it has become increasingly clear that something more is needed in order to succeed in our complex, dynamic and unstable work environments. How can you “command” and “control” when the most important goals, objectives, issues, and opportunities are not known up front but tend to emerge over time? In response, organizations moved to more local adaptation, participation, learning and process styles of leadership. Tom Peters and Robert Waterman popularized principles of “management by walking around.”16 Leaders in this second phase had to learn to balance setting goals and direction with enhancing the degree of participation of people throughout the entire organization. We now find ourselves in a third phase, which is concerned with creating the conditions that inspire people and collective entities to operate from a “different place”—from that inner circle of our management wheel (see Figure 4.4). As Saatchi & Saatchi’s Kevin Roberts put it, “We’ve already moved from management to leadership—and we’re about to go beyond leadership to inspiration. In the 21st century, organizations have to achieve peak performance by creating conditions that allow them to unleash the power of their people—not leading them, not by managing them, but by co-inspiring them.”17 For high performance organizations to evolve, leaders have to extend their focus of attention from processes to using the “blank canvas” dimensions of leadership. They must help people access their sources of inspiration, intuition, and imagination. Just like the artist standing in front of the blank canvas, leaders in current business environments must develop a capacity to shift their organization so that its members can sense and articulate emerging futures, both individually and collectively. I once asked one of the most successful leaders of the telecom industry what she considered to be the essence of her leadership work. She responded, “I am facilitating the opening process so my team can sense and seize emerging opportunities as they arise from the fast paced business environment we are operating in.”
Theory U
But, you might say, that canvas is so incomplete! It is, and that is precisely its genius. I first became aware of this incompleteness when I joined the MIT Organizational Learning Center in Cambridge. I was sitting in the midst of a large audience listening to Peter Senge speak. I noticed that the people sitting around me were engaged differently—more fully—by his presentation than by others I had witnessed. Rather than delivering a set piece, with foregone assumptions, bullet points, and PowerPoint summaries, he seemed to be doing not only less but also something quite different. His presentation seemed to grow organically, as if he were just talking to us. He created a real-time connection, making us feel as if we were participating in the presentation as it unfolded. It seemed to be more of a story than the type of academic presentation I was familiar with. The European intellectual in me had some misgivings, but I realized that while it may not work for everyone, Senge had opened a space for a different type of “seeing”—for a different “music” to be heard. I sat there thinking that Senge’s presentation was more like a modern painting than classical art. We weren’t presented with a completed picture. It was more like a Mark Rothko, with simple blue that covers a canvas. Or like John Cage’s composition “4’33” Tacet for Large Orchestra,” with its four and a half minutes of silence. What is the impact, I wondered, of silence on listeners? Of a completely blue canvas on a viewer? I now realize that Senge was not really doing less but rather making a presentation from a different place. It’s a place from which he can access and operate in front of a blank canvas, and he invites the audience to become co-creators with him. They bring their own meanings, experiences and beliefs to interpreting what they see or hear. The real skillfulness of leading in front of a blank canvas, then, is based as much on the art of not doing things as it is on doing things. It demands the courage to say less in order to create a gateway by bending the collective beam of attention back toward its source. What would it take for teams and organizations to operate from that different place? Is there a communal space they can access? And what kind of collective leadership could activate that kind of white-canvas space?
75
76
ORGANIZATIONAL COMPLEXITY
The Co-Evolving Context of Organizations Jim Collins decided to study high-performing companies. He and his team selected eleven companies from more than 1,400 that had been listed in the Fortune 500 for thirty years, from 1965 to 1995. Each of the eleven companies had had mediocre results for fifteen of those years and then had gone through a transition. From that point on, they outperformed the market by at least three to one. Furthermore, they sustained that level of performance for at least fifteen years. When compared with like-industry companies of about the same size, Collins identified one single key factor: leadership. But leadership that paradoxically blended personal humility and professional will. Characteristics of what Collins terms “level 5 leadership” include seeing reality or “being brutally realistic in determining what the company can be best at in the world.” They must also have egoless selves by “channeling their ego needs away from themselves toward building a great company—often by sacrificing their own gain for the gain of the company.” And, finally, they must be willing to assume responsibility for poor results while at the same time giving credit for successes to others.18 Performing with humility or a selfless self seems to be a precondition for the collective field to advance to a higher level. Since the dot-com bubble burst, CEOs with swollen egos, together with their companies, have crumbled like the Berlin Wall. Everyone seems to agree that a different, more responsible leadership is needed now, not just in the business sector but also in the public (and civic) one. We know of individuals, teams, and even organizations who, for a certain period of time, have operated with a higher quality of “primary knowing,” as UC Berkeley’s Eleanor Rosch calls it. But we still know very little about how to enable larger cross-institutional systems to operate from this place, let alone sustain it over time. The shift of focus in how managers approach their work mirrors a larger shift in our economy. We have moved from a product-driven economy to a service-driven economy and are now shifting to an experience-, knowledgeand innovation-driven economy.
Theory U
77
Table 4.1 The Changing Economic Context Goods
Services
Innovation
Focus of value creation
Make standardized products
Deliver customized services
Stage and co-create personalized experiences
Customer as
Target for mass marketing
Target for mass customization
Partner for cocreation
Economics
Economies of scale
Economies of scope
Economies of presencing
Organizational model
Functional, single sphere: mass production
Divisional, two spheres: production; customer interface
Networked, three spheres: production; customer interface; innovation
Locus of entrepreneurial impulse
Center of one’s own Periphery of one’s own organization (product organization (customer focus) focus)
Surrounding sphere of one’s own organization (cocreation focus)
Relationship logic with customers
Product-driven (push) Service driven (pull)
Co-creation driven (presence)
Primary class
Working class
Service class
Creative class
Managerial mind-set
The world is as it is (self = onlooker)
The world evolves as people interact (self = participant)
The world arises as we choose to attend (self = source of cocreation)
As you can see in this table, most organizations today are not one but three. And each of their three spheres functions according to a different set of principles. In production, the primary principle is economies of scale; in customer interface, it is economies of scope; and for those who innovate, it is the economies of presencing, that is, the capacity to sense and shape emerging future possibilities. To see these patterns accurately, one must look beyond a single organization and begin to view larger economic contexts in
78
ORGANIZATIONAL COMPLEXITY
which companies co-evolve. Each column of this table traces one dimension of this larger contextual shift, but it leaves some footprints we can track, in order to determine where the larger context is heading. As the focus of value creation has shifted from making standardized products to delivering customized services and creating personalized experiences, the firm’s relationship to the customer has evolved from push (product driven) to pull (service driven) to co-creating (presencing.) Unfortunately, I have witnessed many organizations struggling with trying to fit their work from one sphere (for example, push marketing) into another (experiencedriven co-creation) only to find out that it doesn’t work. Each relational mode—push, pull or presence—requires a different managerial mind-set and relationship competence, as each mode is based on a different worldview. For instance, push-oriented relationships are based on a traditional worldview that assumes things are only outside of us. That they are separate from us and not influenced by our thoughts or our behaviors. By contrast, in a customer-driven, pull-through organization, the worldview is still an external one. It is all about the customer, multi-stakeholder dialogues, and social complexity. As companies evolve into this next stage, they begin to see the increased need to develop their presence-based relational skills. In order to deal with disruptive stakeholder situations, managers must be able to tap into their inner sources of creativity and operate from the “bull’s-eye” of the management wheel—not just individually but as part of a larger organizational field. They must learn to function within emerging complexity.
The Institutional Blind Spot Organizations are often blind to emerging complexity, characterized by unexpected opportunities and disruptive change. Together, we, the global community of management practitioners, consultants, and researchers, are struggling to discover a reliable response to this challenge. We have learned how to deal with dynamic and social complexity, with interdependency issues and conflicting stakeholder views. But we don’t yet have a reliable problem-solv-
Theory U
ing methodology for dealing with emerging complex challenges. We may recognize all three types of complexity in today’s institutions, but we continue to deal with them inappropriately. Formerly, centralized and vertically integrated institutions responded first by decentralizing and reorganizing in smaller, more focused, and more flexible units that, then, realigned horizontally according to different streams of value creation. But decentralization leads to the next challenge: how to reintegrate the whole. What methods will work to align the different parts of an organizational whole when the nature of that whole keeps changing? What do you do when you realize that you have outsourced core competencies that are vital to the future of your organization? Institutions around the world and across all sectors are struggling to find solutions to these challenges. Some focus on recentralizing functions, some bet on more networked integration, and some put their chips on the traditional matrix type of organizational structure. But the underlying issue is not organizational structure. Rather, the question is: How may we best differentiate and reintegrate the three spheres of value creation in the context of the larger ecosystem? This ecosystem incorporates not only the economies of scale and scope but also those of presencing. Organizations that wish to succeed must develop and apply all the different sets of relational principles (push, pull, and presence) that apply to each sphere. Institutional blind spots encompass both leadership and structure. We must face the sobering fact that we, as leaders and managers, do not have a methodology for approaching the key challenges that surface in emerging complexity. We just do not know what it takes to lead effectively from “in front of the blank canvas” when the ground under our feet erodes and pulls away. From a structural point of view, the blind spot concerns the fact that most of the key issues of institutional development cannot be solved at the level of the organization. Today’s organizations are often too big to deal with the small problems that are better solved locally, and too small to adequately address the big problems that must be considered in the context of the larger ecosystem of value creation.
79
80
ORGANIZATIONAL COMPLEXITY
What’s missing? The “cross-institutional places” in which we could enable productive conversations among all key stakeholders, including supply-chain members, customers, the community, investors, innovators, and the stakeholders that are marginalized or voiceless in the current system. That’s the institutional blind spot today. We must find room for all the key players in any given ecosystem if we are to gather and co-create our futures. It is time for us, as I describe throughout our field walk, to begin to lead from the emerging future.
Chapter 5
Shifts in Society • The Rise of a Global Economy • The Rise of a Network Society • The Rise of a Cultural-Spiritual Shift • Three Movements, One Stream • Arenas of our Social World • Society’s Blind Spot The Genesis of a New World
The Genesis of a New World
A
t the end of Chapter 4, we came to the conclusion that because our institutional blind spots permeate both our institutional leadership and structure, we are met with a challenge: How can we produce
productive conversations among all key stakeholders? How might we gather together the key players in order to co-create our future? To better understand how we might do that, we first turn our attention to some major shifts in society—major enough to be called the genesis of a new world. When the Berlin Wall collapsed in 1989, followed by a ripple of disintegrating socialist systems in Central and Eastern Europe as well as the Soviet Union, many people felt the world was entering a new era. Nobody expressed this sense of anticipation more eloquently than the playwright and Czech President Václav Havel, who said in a speech in Philadelphia, “It is as if something were crumbling, decaying and exhausting itself—while something else, still indistinct, were rising from the rubble.”1 81
82
SHIFTS IN SOCIETY
Our task is to notice what’s rising from the rubble. We are in the midst of three axial shifts that are redefining the coordinates of our global system. They are: • The rise of the global economy: a technological-economic shift • The rise of the network society: a relational shift • The rise of a new consciousness: a cultural-spiritual shift These shifts have created many good things, but also three types of poverty that define our age: economic poverty (three billion people living on less than two dollars a day), sociocultural poverty (a loss of inner values in a culture of materialism), and a spiritual poverty (a loss of connection to the collective body of humankind).2 The deepening of these three poverties results in a backlash from three fundamentalisms that characterize our age: cultural-religious fundamentalisms, which are blind to the beliefs and values of those who are different; economic fundamentalisms, which are blind to the social, ecological, and cultural side effects of our global economy; and geopolitical fundamentalisms, which are blind to the multipolar and multicultural reality of today’s global community. The sociologist Manuel Castells of the University of California at Berkeley, in his book End of Millennium, argues that our current situation was formed from three independent processes in the late 1960s and early 1970s: the information technology revolution; the structural crisis and restructuring of socialism (perestroika) and capitalism (Reaganism, Thatcherism); and the blooming of cultural social movements such as libertarianism, human rights, feminism, and environmentalism. 3 What arose from this, according to Castells, is a new informational global economy, the network society, and a new culture of “real virtuality.” For a new society to emerge, it will come from new relationships of production, power, and experience.4
The Rise of a Global Economy A world economy is an economy in which “capital accumulation proceeds throughout the world.” By contrast, a global economy is an economy with the
Theory U
capacity to work as a single unit “in real time on a planetary order.” While a world economy has existed in the West since the sixteenth century, only in the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries has the world economy become truly global on the basis of new infrastructures provided by information and communication technologies.5 Three driving forces continue to reshape today’s global economy: the globalization of capital; net-shaped, globally extended enterprises; and technology.
The Globalization of Capital Since the collapse of the socialist economies in 1989–90, for the first time the whole planet is organized around a largely common set of economic institutions and rules. Even though there are significant differences among the U.S., Japanese, and European economies, they share some of the same socioeconomic transformations: • Downsizing of government • Dismantling of the social contract between capital and labor • Deregulation and privatization of state-owned industries (particularly in the telecommunications sector) • Liberalization of financial markets • Restructuring of corporations from relatively stable, domestically oriented and vertically integrated entities to dynamic, globally extended powerhouses that collaborate, dissolve, and reconfigure continuously according to the horizontal flows of value creation Global financial markets and their networks of management are now the nerve centers of capitalism.6 Because the flow of goods and services tends to produce random patterns of informational turbulence, we have seen severe crises and crashes in recent years: in Mexico (1994), the Asian Pacific (1997), Russia (1998), Brazil (1999), and Argentina (2002). These financial market crashes threw more than 40 percent of the world’s population into deep recession.7 As Castells summarizes it, “Money has become almost entirely
83
84
SHIFTS IN SOCIETY
independent of production and services by escaping into the virtual reality of electronic networks. At its core, capital is global. As a rule, labor is local.”8
Net-Shaped, Globally Extended Enterprises As industries have morphed into more open, fluid, and net-shaped constellations, the internal structure of companies has often done so, too. When I interviewed the strategy guru Gary Hamel, he emphasized that radical innovation requires the full diversity of the intellectual “gene pool.” I asked him, “Where in the context of a larger company is there less diversity and more investment in the status quo?” Without a moment’s hesitation, he replied, “At the top!” Teams at the top are least likely to come up with something really new. Yet executives generally have a monopoly on strategy making. Therefore Hamel focuses on seeding a team for innovation by selecting people who are young, located far from corporate headquarters, and recently hired.9 As organizations and strategists began looking outward rather than inward, the locus of innovation shifted as well. Traditional R&D groups focused on funding research staff in centralized corporate settings. New patterns, however, replicate Hamel’s. They show movement from the center to the periphery. In the 1990s and early 2000s, the greater Boston area became a biotech research hub outside of corporate headquarters. As a result, a dynamic innovation ecosystem was created by loosely connecting university institutes, research entities, and corporate R&D departments.10
Technology as the Driving Force of Innovation The innovations that gave rise to the information and communication technologies (ICT) revolution were seeded twenty years earlier with the invention of the microchip, the development of the personal computer, and innovations in telecommunications infrastructures. In less than three decades the World Wide Web grew from a small network serving a dozen research institutions into an interconnected system linking millions (soon to be billions) of users, computers, and networks around the world. The revolution continues into biotechnology.
Theory U
The challenge is to sense the next wave of (discontinuous) change and then to make it happen. The economist Brian Arthur calls this sensing capability “precognition.” It is similar to presencing—and tuning in to the future that is about to emerge.11 Another issue concerns the ethical dimension of emerging technologies. The integration of robotics, genetic engineering, and nanotechnology confronts mankind with a future in which Matrix-type machines will control the evolution of the human species and in which the future won’t need us any longer.12 Is that Matrix type of future the inevitable trajectory we are on, or are we going to consciously choose a different collective evolutionary path? The author Daniel Pinchbeck discusses the speed at which our technology moves this way: “The Stone Age lasted many thousands of years, the Bronze Age lasted a few thousand years, the Industrial Age took three hundred years, the Chemical Age or Plastic Age began a little more than a century ago, the Information Age began thirty years ago, the Biotechnology Age geared up in the last decade. By this calculus, it is conceivable that the Nanotechnology Age could last all of eight minutes. At that point, human intelligence might have complete control of the planetary environment, on a cellular and molecular level. This could lead to utopian creativity or dystopian insanity—perhaps both would arrive at the same moment.”13 But the choice is ours.
The Rise of a Network Society Globalization of Governance For the first time in history, the world economy is governed largely by the same set of institutions, including the United Nations, the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund, and the World Trade Organization. Each has its critics. Take the World Trade Organization, established in 1994, for instance. The WTO’s Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights criminalizes some traditional practices of seed saving and seed sharing by farmers in India and other countries. According to Vandana Shiva, a world-renowned environmental thinker and activist, “The
85
86
SHIFTS IN SOCIETY
Agreement on agriculture legalizes dumping of genetically engineered foods on countries and criminalizes actions to protect the biological and cultural diversity on which diverse food systems are based.” The key issue with today’s globalization, says Shiva, is that the “resources move from the poor to the rich and pollution moves from the rich to the poor.”14 There is indeed tension between supranational institutions on the one hand and national sovereignty on the other. Furthermore, the mechanisms that exist to provide valuable feedback to institutions of global governance are partial, distorted, or missing. The criticism of the World Bank and the IMF centers on the social, cultural, and ecological side effects of their structural adjustment programs (SAPs), first developed in the 1970s and since then implemented more than five hundred times.15 These programs often result in a social and environmental race to the bottom rather than producing the intended prosperity for all. In his book Confessions of an Economic Hit Man, John Perkins tells of his life as an insider in the global economic institutions. He describes how, time and time again, he intentionally participated in delivering inflated economic growth forecasts for various developing countries, which then, funded through the World Bank, got talked into oversized energy infrastructure investments. These investments benefited U.S. companies such as Halliburton but for the country at issue resulted in significant long-term debts and dependencies on the global North.16 While one part of the global South is moving into even deeper dependency, another group of countries has emerged as a set of dynamically evolving economies that are pushing the center of gravity of the global economic system from the North and the West toward the East and the South. The prime examples of these rapidly growing economic powerhouses are the five countries of the BRICS group: Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Aftrica. The BRICS group is changing the global geometry of power from a primarily mono-centric system (with the OECD and particularly the United States in the center) to a more multipolar and multiregional world. Each country in the group functions as a driving force and anchor in the development of its region: South America (Brazil), the former Soviet Union (Russis), South Asia
Theory U
(India), East Asia (China), and Africa (South Africa). Vis-à-vis these newly emerging countries, the countries of the triad European Union, United States, and Japan are also sometimes referred to as newly declining countries (NDCs), because their relative power and share of the whole keep going down.
The Network Society In the network society, argues Castells, political institutions are bargaining agencies rather than sites of power. Power, however, does not disappear. It resides in the networked relationships and cultural codes through which people and institutions communicate. The global city is less a place than “a process by which centers of production and consumption of advanced services . . . are connected in a global network, while simultaneously downplaying the linkages with their hinterlands, on the basis of information flows.”17 This brings us to the darker side of the network society—those who are not equipped with the right kinds of knowledge, skills, and networks are socially excluded and polarized. The loss of lifetime employment and social security and the weakened bargaining power of many workers have led to a higher incidence of family disruption. Castells calls these personal crises, loss of assets, and loss of credit the “black holes of informational capitalism.” It is difficult to escape from these spiraling vortexes.
Perpetual Individualization Robert Putnam, the author of Bowling Alone, uses the decline of bowling leagues as a metaphor for the steady drop in our civic engagement. He claims that by every conceivable measure, social capital has eroded steadily— and sometimes dramatically—over the past two generations. Living without social capital is not easy. Social capital, he says, is a strong predictor of life satisfaction. How can we replenish our lost social capital? And will our perpetual individualization continue to drive human history? Today we are confronted with more choices about how to live our lives and develop our careers than ever before. Again and again, we are thrown into sit-
87
88
SHIFTS IN SOCIETY
uations where we have to reinvent our professional, personal, and relationship lives—redefining who we are and where we want to go.18
The Rise of a Cultural-Spiritual Shift There is a new revolution afoot. I call it the revolution from within. This subtle shift in personal and public perception may well have a profound significance in the twenty-first century for both individuals and businesses. Several forces seem to be driving this global shift: the birth of civil society as a global force, the rise of the creative class, and the emergence of a new spirituality.
The Birth of Civil Society as a Global Force While Putnam was collecting his evidence about the decline of civic engagement in America, almost unnoticed—and exactly in the blind spot of his data gathering—civil society and millions of fast-growing nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) emerged as a major force in the world. NGOs such as the Red Cross have existed for more than a hundred years, but in the past couple of decades their number has exploded. They’ve grown not only in number but also in their prominence, and ability to precipitate change, according to the Worldwatch Institute. “They have cajoled, forced, joined in with, or forged ahead of governments and corporations on an array of actions as disparate as the decommissioning of nuclear reactors, brokering cease-fires in civil wars, and publicizing the human rights abuses of repressive regimes.”19 NGOs and civil society, using the Gandhi-inspired strategy of nonviolence, emerged as major actors and driving forces in the four pivotal historic events that shaped the last four decades of the twentieth century: • The rise of the civil rights movement in the 1960s • The rise of the environmental movement in the 1970s • The rise of the peace and human rights movement and the collapse of the Cold War system and of communism in Eastern Europe in the 1980s • The dismantling of apartheid in South Africa in the 1990s
Theory U
Each of these four major events marked the spirit of that decade. In each, the underlying driving forces were the same: the power of civil society combined with a disciplined strategy of nonviolent transformation. The globalization of governance was first created through the UN organizations at the end of World War II. The globalization of business and companies emerged only in the last couple decades of the twentieth century. It is just since the 1990s that NGOs and civil society have emerged as global actors.20
The Rise of the Creative Class Another driving force of the revolution from within is described by Richard Florida of Carnegie Mellon University as “the rise of the creative class.” It has created much of today’s economic development. Some 38 million Americans, or 30 percent of all employed people, belong to this new class, whose core includes people in science, engineering, architecture, design, education, arts, music, and entertainment together with professionals in business, finance, law, health care, and other related fields. What do all these people have in common? Florida says it’s a shared creative ethos that values creativity, individuality, difference, and merit. The key difference between people in the creative class and other classes lies primarily in what they are paid to do. Those in the working class and the service class are paid primarily to execute according to plan, while those in the creative class are paid to create and have considerably more autonomy and flexibility than other people.21 What led him to these conclusions? In 1998, while he was studying the locations of high-tech industry clusters, Florida met with a doctoral student who had been looking into the location patterns of gay people. When they put their studies together, they matched. “Though most experts continued to point to technology as the driving force for broad social change, I became convinced that the truly fundamental changes of our time had to do with subtler alterations in the way we live and work.” Florida saw a common thread: the role of creativity as the fundamental source of economic growth and the rise of the creative class.22 What we are learning through studies like Florida’s is that creativity can’t be bought, sold, or turned on or off at will. But geographic patterns do
89
90
SHIFTS IN SOCIETY
emerge. Companies, particularly in the area of high tech, gravitate to the same areas and clusters where the people of the creative class settle. Because creativity requires an environment that nurtures its sources and many forms, people who rely on their creative capacities gravitate to areas that provide that stimulus and context. Florida believes that all attempts to rebuild the old forms of social capital are doomed to fail: “They fly in the face of today’s economic realities.”23 This may explain why Novartis, the global pharmaceutical company, is following other European pharmaceuticals and moving its main R&D operations from Europe to the medical high-tech belt between Boston, New York, and Washington, D.C. Just as competition in the creative economy changes, so do the fundamental social forms. The decline in the strength of our ties to people and institutions is a product of the increasing number of ties we have. We see more people in one day than many of our parents or grandparents saw in a month. As a result, we have to build and rebuild our own identities. We exist in a constant creation and re-creation of the self, often in ways that reflect our creativity.
The Emergence of a New Spirituality Spirituality can be defined as the source of our creativity. It is distinct from religion, for it concerns experience and not belief systems. According to Business Week, a journal not known for its coverage of spirituality, a spiritual revival is sweeping across corporate America “as executives of all stripes incorporate mysticism into their management, importing into office corridors the lessons usually doled out in churches, temples and mosques.” But spiritual events aren’t happening only in exclusive executive circles. A case in point: “For the past six years 300 Xerox Corp. employees—from senior managers to clerks—have participated in ‘vision quests’ as part of the struggling copier company’s $400 million project to revolutionize product development.”24 Once, on a spiritual retreat in northern New Mexico, a dozen Xerox engineers saw a lone, fading Xerox paper carton bobbing in a swamp of old motor oil at the bottom of a pit. They vowed then and there to build a machine that
Theory U
would never end up polluting another dump. The eventual result: the design and production of the 265DC, a 97 percent recyclable machine. Those engineers went beyond their blind spot. A McKinsey & Company study found that employee programs that include a spiritual component have led to significant productivity improvements and reductions in the turnover rate. “We have seen,” reports a senior partner at McKinsey, “that change processes which include the dimension of personal mastery can lead to overcoming significant performance thresholds . . . not only for individuals, but for the team as a whole.”25 At the same time, such a finding, of course, also creates a problem: Will we now begin to misuse spirituality for the sake of increasing profit margins? But the emergence of spirituality is not confined to the world of business. The sociologist Robert Wuthnow of Princeton University reports that 40 percent of all Americans claim to be currently involved in a small group that meets regularly and provides support or cares for its participants. Roughly half of these groups are church-related. It’s a “quiet revolution” in American society that is redefining community in a more fluid way.26 This “quiet revolution” shows a ballooning interest in topics such as personal mastery, dialogue, and flow. The power of attention and the experience of flow, as described by Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi,27 have long been cultivated in the practice of dialogue. At its essence, dialogue involves a collective shift of attention from politeness to conflict, from conflict to inquiry, and from inquiry to generative flow.28 My colleague Bill Isaacs, the founder of the MIT Dialogue Project, has used dialogue as a change method in a steel mill, in a local health care system, and as a way to build leadership capacity in multinational companies.29 Is the rise of spirituality just an epiphenomenon of the baby-boom generation’s growing more reflective, or is it related to a cultural shift in society at large? When I met with Francisco Varela, at one point he reached for an issue of the Journal of Consciousness Studies. It dealt with methods of accessing first-person experience—including meditation. “This would have been unthinkable three or four years ago,” he said. And I concur. But now medi-
91
92
SHIFTS IN SOCIETY
tation practices are widely accepted, not only in my leadership seminars but in many other unlikely places. The sociologist Paul Ray’s study of more than 100,000 people in the United States points to a profound shift in our culture. He divided society into moderns, traditionals, and cultural creatives. While the “creatives” represent only 26 percent of the population, it is the fastestgrowing segment. Across Europe, cultural creatives account for 30 to 35 percent of the population. Characteristic of this group is their values of simplicity, sustainability, spirituality, and social consciousness.30 Yet, recent survey data have shown that the value shift toward the cultural creatives is countered by a backlash into a narrow, self-centered, reactive view, particularly (but not only) in the United States. According to a survey of 1,500 Americans by the market research firm Environics, the number of Americans who agree with the statement “To preserve people’s jobs in this country, we must accept higher levels of pollution in the future,” increased from 17 percent in 1996 to 26 percent in 2000. The number of Americans who agreed that “Most of the people actively involved in environmental groups are extremists, not reasonable people,” leapt from 32 percent in 1996 to 41 percent in 2000.31
Three Movements, One Stream When I met Fritjof Capra at a study group on systems thinking in the social sciences, we discussed countercultural movements and he said he thought they should always incorporate three aspects: the ecological, the social, and the spiritual. “The issue is that these movements tend to dissociate what in reality belongs together. When I realized that the New Age movement did not truly embrace the ecological, social, and political aspects of transformational change, I decided to dissociate myself from it.” This made perfect sense to me. A couple of months later I happened to be in Oxford, England, in a dialogue workshop with leaders from various cultures and sectors. The gathering was framed as an inquiry into the emerging patterns of our time, particularly the widespread spiritual renewal evident to many of the participants from corporations, government, and NGOs. In sharing why we were there, I
Theory U
found myself talking about my own involvement with the three movements Capra had talked about. I was sixteen years old, I told them, when I first “woke up” and started to think about political issues. Together with about 100,000 people from all over Germany, I went to the atomic power plant construction site at Brokdorf, one of the most famous European battlefields of the antinuclear movement of the 1970s. Brokdorf is a small village in northern Germany, close to my family’s farm near Hamburg. We were protesting against the unhealthy alliance of the atomic industry and big state-owned electrical utility monopolies that sucked up tens of billions of dollars of taxpayers’ money to subsidize a technology that carried more risks than opportunities in the eyes of the majority of the population. In retrospect we know that the massive subsidies and focus on the nuclear technology contributed to the fact that Germany missed the train on a much more important technological revolution: the ICT revolution, which began to take shape in the Silicon Valley area in California and the Route 128 area in Massachusetts at just about the same time. The march in Brokdorf was not legal and the site was guarded by a massive police force, but things went peacefully until it was almost over. We had just started retreating from the main site to walk back to our buses and cars located a couple of miles away, when suddenly we heard a deep, rhythmic drumming and loud shouting. We turned to see hundreds, perhaps a thousand, heavily armed police drumming their batons on their battle shields and running toward us with a deep rumbling cry of attack. Everybody knew what to do next: run. They chased us over the fields like chickens. As the distance between us and the police closed, I first heard and then saw a swarm of helicopters approaching. They flew so low that people to my right and left were pushed down by the wind pressure. Without stopping, I looked back to see what had happened to them. Each was surrounded by batonswinging cops. Half an hour later, those of us who had escaped were walking quickly and quietly, tightly bunched together, on a broad highway back to our buses and cars. A deep red setting sun bathed the whole scene in cinematic light. When
93
94
SHIFTS IN SOCIETY
the sun had set, just before we reached our vehicles, the police attacked again, erupting from the woods to our left—out of total darkness—batons in hand and voices raised. As they approached us, something strange happened: everyone stopped walking and stood in absolute silence, body by body, as if the whole of us were one big collective form. Nobody ran. Everything stopped for a moment of total silence. Then the next moment they reached us. They began beating the people within reach of their batons. Still the crowd did not move. Their truncheons cut into our collective body like a knife through butter. After a little while they realized that no one was fighting back. The collective body remained still. Surprised by that, they stopped and soon retreated from their attack. When I returned that night, my physical body was unharmed. But I came home a different person. Our collective body—the living body I became “one with” during that event—had been attacked and wounded, that is: opened. I felt that I had seen the enemy—an oppressive system that used physical force to push the agenda of a small special interest group against the vast majority of people in our country. I knew then that my future work would involve transforming that system. In 1983 I moved to West Berlin to study at the Free University. The Cold War still divided Berlin, yet powerful grassroots human rights and peace movements grew and flourished. I was surrounded by people who felt a sense of what was possible for themselves and society and who chose to live from that deeper sense of possibility and awareness. Whenever you crossed into Central Europe in those days, you could feel instantly connected to circles and networks of people whose openness to an emerging future was palpable. Later, I sometimes wondered where all those people had gone. Then, during the mid-1990s, while I was attending the first semi-annual meeting of the MIT Learning Center, a nationwide gathering of advanced organizational learning practitioners, it hit me: all those people I missed from my Berlin days were now wearing business suits and operating in networks like this one at the Learning Center. The bond that connected us wasn’t primarily an environmental or social agenda but a consciousness-raising and institutional change agenda. These people were interested in enhancing their access to
Theory U
sources of creativity, both individually and collectively. I had “come home” to a circle of people I had never met or even heard of before. The telling of this story in Oxford helped me clarify why single-issue movements hold so little appeal. Like Capra, I want to associate with people who work to reintegrate all three roots: the ecological, the social, and the spiritual. And like him, I am interested in doing this based on a new blending between science and consciousness, by going not backward into the past but forward.
Three Clashes and Root Questions The three revolutions described above are patterns of a larger transformation process. Something is coming to an end. But what is the new structure that is currently arising from the rubble? We don’t know. What we do know is that each of the three revolutionary shifts comes with a major backlash. The cultural-spiritual shift comes with a rise of cultural fundamentalism, leading to a clash of premodern, modern, and postmodern cultures. The shift toward a global economy comes with the shadow of an economic apartheid that excludes billions of people from having their basic needs met. The rise of the network society and of global multilateral institutions comes with a backlash of empire building that backfires and prevents new multilateral regimes like the Kyoto Protocol on climate change from working effectively. At the root of these three conflicts—the socioeconomic, the geopolitical, and the cultural—we as a global society are confronted with three root questions. I find these root questions alive in the hearts and minds of people across various cultures and civilizations. They are: 1. How can we create a more equitable global economy that would serve the needs of all, including today’s have-nots and the future generations? 2. How can we deepen democracy and evolve our political institutions so that all people can increasingly directly participate in the decision-making processes that shape their context and future? 3. How can we renew our culture so that every human being is considered a carrier of a sacred project—the journey of becoming one’s authentic self?
95
96
SHIFTS IN SOCIETY
In order even to ask these questions, we enter a common force field that drives the rise of civil society today. This common field incorporates: • A deeply felt social sense that all of humankind is connected through a tacit, invisible bond or field • A deeply felt democratic sense that eventually all legitimacy flows from structures that enable inclusive participation • A deeply felt cultural-spiritual sense that we are on a journey of becoming who we really are—both individually and collectively The common ground of these felt senses is a view of the human being as a being of freedom—as a being that is defined by the capacity to make the choice between acting in habitual ways and connecting with one’s deepest source of creativity, ethical action, and freedom.
Arenas of Our Social World The clashes and backlash that the transformation described above generates play out in three arenas of social life. They are (1) objective structures and systems, (2) enacted structures and processes, and (3) deep sources of enactment.
The First Arena: Objective Structures and Systems The main focus of the founding fathers of sociology, Auguste Comte, Émile Durkheim, and Max Weber, centered around the first arena. They conceived of the social world as something that can be studied and described in terms of unchangeable laws, across space, time, and consciousness.32 Comte, who coined the term “sociology,” lived in the early nineteenth century and believed that history evolved in a linear sequence of successive stages from theology to metaphysics to positivism. Like Comte and the Catholic counterrevolutionaries, Émile Durkheim, who lived from 1858 to 1917, disliked social disorder. He studied the forces and structures that are external to and coercive of the individual. Max Weber, who died in 1920, emphasized rationaliza-
Theory U
tion as the foundation of a more or less linear development. He saw people trapped in an “iron cage” in which material goods have “increasing and finally unavoidable power over people.”33
The Second Arena: Enacted Structures and Systems The Chilean biologist Humberto Maturana noted that “all things said are said by somebody,” so we can also say that all systems and structures are enacted “by somebody.” Max Weber’s social iron cage exists only insofar as people enact it in their everyday behavior and practice. Anthony Giddens claims that agency and structure must be seen as two sides of the same coin. Structure is reproduced in and through a succession of situated practices that in turn are organized by it. Jürgen Habermas, arguably the most important living philosopher and sociologist, sees society as the “systems-world” and the “life-world.” Our relationship between the two, he says, is like colonization. “The imperatives of decoupled subsystems penetrate into the lifeworld—just as the colonists did into a tribe—and enforce their assimilation.”34 But both of these perspectives fall short of taking us to a deeper ontological point of view—the one Master Nan had in mind.
The Third Arena: Deep Sources of Enactment None of our sociological scholars fully considered what Bill O’Brien called “the interior condition of the intervener.” But we are at a stage now where we can begin to understand that our awareness and our consciousness determine the qualities of our actions and results. Habermas’s notion of the Husserlian concept of life-world comes closest, but in Habermas’s writings they capture only the rational dimension of discourse, not the deeper aesthetic-spiritual aspects of generative dialogue and flow.35 In order to transcend these views, we may have to “go back to the data and to start all over again,” as Ed Schein, the grand old man of organizational culture and change at MIT, put it. While the standard social science method tends to be based on observational data, Kurt Lewin and his successors, action science scholars such as Chris Argyris, Ed Schein, Peter Senge, and Bill Torbert, claimed that we have to use more than just third-person views. We need, as Bill Torbert
97
98
SHIFTS IN SOCIETY
has said, to access third-, second- and first-person knowledge. That is, we should incorporate observational, conversational, and first-person experiential data. But, of course, questions continue to pop up: How do you know that you know? What criteria help you to validate your knowledge? “I know that I know when my knowledge is actionable—that is, when I can produce it.” (Chris Argyris) “I know that I know when my knowledge is helpful to the various clients and practitioners in the field.” (Ed Schein) “I know that I know when I develop the capacity to create the results I really care about—when what you know allows you to create.” (Peter Senge) Each of these arenas stages a set of clashing forces. The left-hand column lists three arenas where social reality comes into existence. Each arena offers a distinct perspective on those three core issue areas Capra described: ecological, social-economic, and cultural-spiritual. Each issue has its own community of scholars and practitioners. The first view or arena is governed by the philosophical metacategory of objectivity. This is the world of quasi-objective facts and things. Accordingly, the issues in this arena include the social divide: the gap and clashes between the haves and the have-nots (social justice); the ecological divide: the gap and clashes between civilization and nature (environmental protection); and the cultural divide: the gap and clashes between Western and non-Western civilizations (geo-politics).36 The second arena, intersubjectivity, is where the life-world is situated in a web of collectively evolving relationships. Here the same core issues are viewed through a different lens. From this perspective the social divide shows up as a clash between systemic imperatives and social living worlds (as discussed at length by Habermas).37 The ecological divide shows up as a collision between linear industrial system designs and new, more ecologically intelligent design and systems (“cradle-to-cradle design”).38 The cultural divide shows up as a gap between the worldview of Western
Theory U
99
Table 5.1 Issue Matrix Core Divides Arenas of Clashing Forces
Social-economic Issues
Ecological Issues
Cultural-spiritual Issues
Arena I: Systems A 19th-century view: Primacy of objectivity
Gap and clash between haves and have-nots (social justice)
Gap and clash between civilization and nature (environmental protection)
Gap and clash between cultures or civilizations (development)
Arena II: Agency A 20th-century view: Primacy of intersubjectivity
Clash ofsystemic imperatives vs. life-world (critical theory)
Clash of old industrial designs versus ecosystemic design (cradle to cradle)
Clash of materialism versus antimaterialism (value shift)
Arena III: Sources A 21st-century view: Primacy of transsubjectivity
Separation of self from the other ˚ I-Thou (dialogue)
Separation of self from the senses ˚ awakening through our senses (sensing)
Separation of self from Self ˚ self-Self = connecting the current with the best future Self (presencing)
materialism, on the one hand, and various forms of antimaterialism, on the other. We often see both an overlay of Western materialism and consumerism across cultures and civilizations (the colonization of culture) and simultaneously the growing public resentment of such Western materialism. That cultural clash, however, also plays out within Western societies. For example, the strategic value method-based research from Ted Nordhaus and Michael Shellenberger gives an excellent example of tracking this cultural clash as a conflict between more traditional, more material and more postmaterial sets of needs and value orientations that shape the political discourse and create conflict within the United States and other Western societies.39 The third arena is governed by transsubjectivity. This is the most upstream perspective. It’s the world of “living presence,” as Husserl put it. This arena
100
SHIFTS IN SOCIETY
shows a new battlefield, where the most significant battle of our time is currently being fought: the arena of Self. What is new here is how all of this is interlinked and grounded in the emerging arena of sources and self. If what you see in Table 5.1 were a tree, the first two arenas would be the leaves, branches, and trunk, but the third arena would be the root system—that part of the living system that is invisible to the eye. At this deeper level, the root of the social divide is not outside but within. It is the self. To be more precise: it is the separation between self and other, which materializes in social conflicts (meso level, or midlevel), and in the social divide (macro level). As long as we aren’t ready to face and confront this inner abyss, we are probably still stuck in premodern patterns, which will do nothing really useful to facilitate crossing the current abyss. At the root of the ecological divide is the separation between the senses and the self. Here we enter the aesthetic dimension of ecological crises. The term “aesthetics” comes from the Greek word, aistesis, “sensual sensing”; it means activating all our senses. Unless we rediscover our senses as gateways to the living field around us, we will never resolve the environmental crisis. Just as the social divide reflects the loss of the other on an interpersonal level, the ecological crisis reflects the loss of the senses as gateways into the living field of nature. People often fill the void left by the loss of the senses with consumption—which in turn deepens the exterior manifestation of the ecological crisis. Finally, investigating the spiritual question at this deeper level leads to perhaps the most significant clash: the clash between the self and the Self. It is the clash between one’s old self, the person one has always been, and one’s emerging higher self, the self that embodies one’s highest future possibility—the Self that I first encountered when watching the fire that destroyed my family’s home. On one side of that clash are all of one’s accumulated accomplishments and ego forces, good and bad. On the other side is a source of possibility that, in order to come into presence, to be activated, requires one to let go of the old and open up to the now. The living connection between these two selves—self and Self—in the now is what I refer to as presencing.
Theory U
Institutions rarely cross the boundaries of this issue matrix divide. Each field has professional graduate programs, training courses, research programs, funding mechanisms, international gatherings of experts, journals, and communities of practice. What’s missing is the discourse in between. What’s needed is for pioneering intellectuals to focus on all nine boxes at once. Some have begun doing this. Manuel Castells’s work, for instance, presents an integrative view of society involving the domains of production, power, and experience, although his work is stronger in the first two arenas, than in the third. His work describes the world that has taken shape over the past thirty years. As we’ve already mentioned, Fritjof Capra integrates the biological, cognitive, and social dimensions of life. “Living systems,” he says, “are self-generating networks that are organizationally closed within boundaries but open to continual flows of energy and matter.”40 Starting as a physicist, he applied the findings of twentieth-century systems science not only to biological life and cognition but also to social life. He described six life-sustaining principles of ecology that also pertain to economic systems and business ecologies: • Networks: living systems communicate with one another and share resources across boundaries. • Cycles: ecosystems generate no waste; matter cycles continually through the web of life. • Solar energy: through photosynthesis, solar energy drives the ecological cycles. • Partnership: life took over the planet not by combat but by cooperation. • Diversity: ecosystems achieve stability through diversity—the more diverse, the more resilient. • Dynamic balance: an ecosystem is an ever-fluctuating network: all variables fluctuate around their optimal values; no single variable is maximized. He pointed out, however, that the crucial difference between the ecological networks of nature and the corporate networks of human society is this: in
101
102
SHIFTS IN SOCIETY
an ecosystem no being is excluded from the network. By contrast, many segments of our population are excluded from corporate networks. While his work offers a brilliant analysis of the networked nature of our current system, it offers less about what individuals acting alone or collectively can do to shape the new world or drill down into the third level of social reality. The philosopher Ken Wilber’s integral approach is probably the most comprehensive integrative framework developed to date. His “all-quadrants, all-levels” (AQAL) approach embraces the significant truths of premodernity, modernity, and postmodernity and integrates them in a synthesizing holistic framework. His framework is based on two sets of distinctions. The first one, built on Jürgen Habermas and Karl Popper’s work, differentiates between three (or four) dimensions of the world: the It-world (objectivity); the Weworld (intersubjectivity); the I-world (subjectivity); and a collective version of the It-world that Wilber calls “interobjectivity.” The second set of distinctions differentiates among the developmental stages of the self, which Wilber found to be the same in wisdom traditions across cultures and ages. Different traditions may use different terms, but the levels themselves are universal. One popular example of a developmental view that Wilber cites in his recent writings is exemplified in the influential work of Don Beck and Christopher Cowan, who distinguish among levels of consciousness in the preconventional, conventional, and postconventional stages of development and self.41 Wilber’s “all-quadrants, all-levels” approach integrates all three dimensions of the world (I, We, It) and all nine developmental levels of consciousness. Wilber’s integral view creates a framework and synthesis of diverse perspectives and intellectual traditions not described by any earlier philosopher. One of his major contributions is that his framework makes it legitimate to include the transpersonal or spiritual dimension in scientific, academic, and educational discourse. His definition of an integral approach— all quadrants, all levels—opens the door to a more comprehensive discourse that includes the more subtle aspects of reality that otherwise tend to be marginalized or left out. Wilber’s integral framework continues to evolve and now includes “all quadrants, all levels, all lines, all states, all types.”
Theory U
Reading his work gives us a bird’s-eye view of the “battlefield” of human and social development.42 A follow-on question that relates to this perspective is: What would a mapping of the battlefield look like if it were mapped from the perspective of the evolving self in the midst of battle on that field? We will return to this question later on this journey.
Society’s Blind Spot In November 1999, I was invited to join Master Nan and some of his students for dinner. Master Nan has written more than thirty books and is a revered teacher in China, but few have been translated or made available outside China. We discussed the rise of spiritual awareness and how it relates to the global issues of our time. “What has been lacking in the twentieth century is a central cultural thought that would unify all these things—economy, technology, ecology, society, matter, mind, and spirituality,” he said. This decline in integrative awareness and thinking, we concluded, has been replaced by a focus on business and making money as the default common aim. Through his translator, Master Nan said, “It will definitely go this way— in a spiritual direction. But this route will be a different spiritual route from that of the past, either in the East or West. It will be a new spiritual path. It will be a combination of natural science and philosophy.” “The way I understand it,” I responded to Master Nan, “is that the blind spot concerns our inability to see the process of the coming into being of social reality. We perceive our reality as a thing, as something that is separate from and outside us—something that happens to us. We don’t see the process through which we bring forth social reality in the first place. And then I understood you to say that in order to illuminate this blind spot, you have to practice seven meditational stages of leadership that you talk about in your new book. Is that right?” Master Nan replied, “This understanding is right.” Our blind spot, from a person or people point of view, keeps us from seeing that we do indeed have greatly enhanced direct access to the deeper
103
104
SHIFTS IN SOCIETY
sources of creativity and commitment, both as individuals and as communities. It is one of our most hopeful sources of confidence because we can access a deeper presence, power, and purpose from within. From a structural point of view, the societal blind spot deals with the lack of these cross-sector action groups that intentionally operate from a future that wants to emerge. Instead, we see only special interest groups and three types of fundamentalism, each trying to solve our current mess in a single-minded way. This blind spot also keeps us from viewing the issue matrix as a whole. Castells, Capra, and Wilber have all been pioneers in moving toward integrating it, each from a different vantage point. But none fully meets Argyris’s criterion for action research: that real knowledge enables you to create the reality it talks about. To discover this type of knowledge, we must trust our own senses, experiences, and insights—without having a clue as to where that journey will lead next.
Chapter 6
Philosophical Grounding Our Field Walk
• Ontological and Epistemological Grounding
Our Field Walk
L
et’s pause for a moment to reflect on where our field walk or learning journey has taken us up to this point. First, we investigated how the blind spot shows up on the level of individual experience—as in my
story about the fire. It was then that my own journey began, as I felt my old world going up in flames and the ground pulled out from under me. At that point I connected to that other part of my self that I didn’t even know existed. We spent a fair amount of time becoming acquainted with the U and started to identify with its parts. Then we investigated how the blind spot pops up in the experience of teams and how they learn. Teams face new challenges that cannot be addressed by relying on learning from the past. So we have to let go of the past, let it “go up in flames” and open up to the future that wants to emerge through us. This we call Level 4 leading and learning. Next we investigated how the blind spot takes shape in the context of institutional experience. Leaders face new types of challenges that cannot be 105
106
PHILOSOPHICAL GROUNDING
successfully addressed by conventional problem-solving methodologies. In order to deal with emerging complexity, we have to learn to drop our old tools in order to attend to and operate from the perspective of the blank canvas— that is, the source where organizational value is created. Following that, we looked at ways the blind spot shows up in society, in the guise of the third revolution. That revolution, a beginning shift in consciousness, could help us to reframe the core societal issues more from a root or source perspective rather than just looking at the visible part of the “tree.” And finally, we took our field walk into social sciences, where the source of the blind spot concerns the inability to catch the process of social reality creation in flight. At each stage, we realize that we are thrown into situations calling for new attention and awareness. What does all this mean for us as “action scientists”?
Ontological and Epistemological Grounding In 2000, I had another occasion to have a further in-depth conversation with Fritjof Capra. He and I walked together in a wooded area near the University of California, Berkeley, one September afternoon, discussing the new book he was writing. In it, he planned to apply his idea about systems theory and systems thinking to the world of social relationships.1 I asked, “What do you consider to be the most important developments in systems theory and systems thinking over the course of the past century?” He responded by saying he thought they all boiled down to two key developments: first, the welcoming by modern systems thinkers of the phenomenon of emergence, and second, the acceptance of the idea of embeddedness—that all systems and knowledge are situated in context. On the flight back to Boston, I drew this little table that captured the two dimensions we had just talked about. In the upper left-hand corner we have the old mainstream systems theory (S1), grounded in linear systems and explicit knowledge (K1). From that corner, we can progress in two directions: from S1 (linear systems) to S2 (nonlinear systems) accounting for the phenomenon of emergence; and from K1
Theory U
107
Table 6.1: Twentieth-Century Systems Theory: Epistemological and Ontological Grounding K1
K2
K3
Explicit Knowledge:
Tacit Embodied Knowledge:
Self-transcending “Primary Knowing”:
Situated in Context
Not Yet Embodied
Independent of Context S1 Linear systems Simple systems
S2 Nonlinear, dynamic systems Autopoietic systems
S3 Sources of deep emergence Self-transcending systems
“Old mainstream”: Conventional systems theory
Situated action: All knowing happens in a context.
Nonlinear, dynamic systems theory: Accounts for the phenomenon of emergence.
“New mainstream”: Accounts for both emergence and being situated in context.
Blind spot: sources of knowing
Blind spot: sources of emergence
(explicit knowledge) to K2 (tacit knowledge), accounting for the fact that all knowledge is situated and embedded in context. Etienne Wenger’s and Jean Lave’s concepts of situated learning and communities of practice, along with John Brown, Alan Collins, and Paul Duguid’s concept of situated cognition2 are examples of how the main focus of social systems theory has moved from (S1, K1) to (S2, K2). Like Capra’s dimensions, these frameworks account for both phenomena: emergence and embeddedness. In analyzing this table further, it became clear to me that my own investigation had drawn me closer to the interface between the light gray shaded and dark gray shaded squares. It is here that we face and encounter the extreme boundaries of human existence. Here we enter the uncharted terri-
108
PHILOSOPHICAL GROUNDING
tory that evolves at the edges of human consciousness. And it is here where we find ourselves grounded in the deeper philosophical assumptions about being (ontology) and knowing (epistemology). Nietzsche once said that the highest goal would be to view science from the viewpoint of the artist and art from the viewpoint of life. To view science from the viewpoint of the artist means to apply scientific investigation not only to the object in front of us but also to the creative process and the scientist/artist who is performing that activity. Or in the words of Aristotle, science not only as episteme but also as applied art (techne) and practical wisdom (phronesis). To view art from the viewpoint of life means to perform the scientific activity in order to serve a deeper intention, to serve the larger evolutionary whole. That is, in the words of Aristotle, a scientific activity that would advance the frontiers of science toward including both wisdom (sophia) and the awareness or intuition of first principles and the sources of intention (nous). Other philosophers who pushed my thinking deeper in those directions were Edmund Husserl and Martin Heidegger. By reading the work of Husserl, I came to better understand the epistemological boundary from the normal state of K1 awareness, which he called “natural attitude,” to a K2 awareness, which he called “phenomenological attitude.” By contrast, the work of Heidegger can be read as pushing the ontological boundary from a depiction of the world as an abstract set of things to a concrete being in the world that always happens from the background of a concrete context. Reality as viewed by Heidegger is not a “thing.” Rather, it is a process of coming into being—a process of emerging from concealment into the open clearing of being. It represents a shift in perspective from S1 to S2. Reading the late Husserl and Heidegger leaves one with a much more meditative sentiment along with the feeling that both were struggling with yet another boundary shift that would eventually turn the philosophical investigation to the source level on both dimensions: the epistemological (K3) and the ontological (S3). The epistemological question is: Where do our attention and knowing originate? This is Husserl’s struggle with the issue of a transcendental self. And the ontological question is: What is the source of our collectively enacted social structures and processes? In other words, who
Theory U
is becoming present and acting through us when we engage in deep social or collective processes? Yet Husserl and Heidegger both leave the impression that perhaps the most important aspect of their work is yet to be done—that is, to push the boundary of the philosophical investigation from the “what” (K1, S1) and “process” (K2, S2) levels to the “source” on both dimensions, epistemology and ontology (K3, S3). This is the work that these giants left for our generation and our century. We are to extend the philosophical and the scientific investigation from the upper left four boxes (representing the discourse of the twentieth century in philosophy and systems thinking) to the whole matrix of nine fields. The implication for such an extension of the philosophical investigation in the twenty-first century is that philosophers and systems thinkers must leave their reading rooms and immerse themselves in the real world in order to actively participate in its unfolding. Such an action-science philosophy would engage in a different kind of knowing—the knowing of the heart. As the Japanese philosopher Kitaro Nishida has put it: “Knowledge and love are the same mental activity; to know a thing we must love it, to love a thing we must know it.” Love, he continues, “is the power by which we grasp ultimate reality. Love is the deepest knowledge of things.”3 When we learn to access that deepest part of the U, we begin to realize that love takes no position, as the author David Hawkins says. Love is global, he believes, and it rises above separation. “Love is unconditional, unchanging and permanent. It doesn’t fluctuate—its source isn’t dependent on external factors. Loving is a state of being. . . . Love isn’t intellectual and doesn’t proceed from the mind. Love emanates from the heart. It has the capacity to lift others and accomplish great feats because of its purity of motive.”4 Our field walk is now about to take us for a close-up look at how we can lift ourselves and others across the threshold that has been at issue up to this point. We will review the threshold and the blind spot that we investigated so far and get poised for diving deeply into the bottom of the U and surfacing up the other side.
109
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 7
On the Threshold Crossing the Threshold
• The Signature of Our Time
A
t the beginning of our journey, we posed the question: Where does our action come from? To answer that question, we took a walk through the social field. We found that there is an invisible shift
going on in the world. It’s as if we were standing on a threshold, about to cross through a new doorway into rooms we could never before access. But something is keeping us from moving into these rooms and seeing the world from them. That hidden barrier is our blind spot, as well as our teacher. You will remember that we tracked the emergence of that blind spot across systems at all levels: • At the individual level, we met the blind spot metaphorically described as flames, capable of destroying my old identity and clearing a space in which to encounter previously unknown aspects of my self. • At the group level, we faced the blind spot as a team; our old approaches to learning—learning from the past—aren’t getting us anywhere, and 111
112
ON THE THRESHOLD
thus we raise the questions: What would it take to connect to the subtle fields of future possibility? How can we learn from the future as it emerges? • At the organizational level, we saw the blind spot as a new type of leadership challenge. Leaders face pressing issues that are high in emerging complexity and cannot be solved by using conventional problem-solving techniques. We raised the questions: How can we operate effectively in a blank-canvas situation, in which the world we are used to is crumbling? How do we reinvent our institutions as the ground under our feet is pulled away? • At the societal level, we encountered the blind spot in the guise of three simultaneous global revolutions that are culminating at the beginning of this century: the rise of the global economy, the emergence of the networked society, and the development of new forms of individual and collective consciousness. As these revolutions transform the geometry of power across systems and cultures, we witness the crumbling and accelerating breakdowns and failure of the old institutional systems and structures, calling for radical new approaches to how to address the pressing issues and fundamental challenges of our time. • In the social sciences, the blind spot shifted our focus from objective structures to the process view of enacted systems, and from there to the sources from which social reality formation originates. While the mainstream of nineteenth- and twentieth-century social sciences has been guided by the primacy of the meta-category of objectivity and intersubjectivity, the social sciences that are needed in this century and that might be helpful in dealing with the most pressing issues of our time have to include a third metacategory: the metacategory of transsubjectivity, which differentiates among structures of individual and collective attention as a defining feature of any social field. • At the meta level of systems theory, we saw how the blind spot in systems thinking and philosophy shifts from entities to processes and from processes to incipient sources of emergence and knowing—that is, to the ontological and epistemological grounding of the situation we are operating in (our sources for both action and thought).
Theory U
On each level we encountered the same fundamental shift of attention, a shift that extends the depths of reality perception to include the formerly invisible condition of the blank canvas—that is, the source of attention, intention and collective action. As the challenges at work, at home, and in our communities increasingly force us to deal with the manifestations of the blind spot in one way or another, we confront and encounter a fundamental threshold. We face that threshold as individuals, teams, organizations, and global social systems. In order to enter deeper territory and cross the threshold, we must confront the source level of the situation we are dealing with— we must learn to face our Self.
Crossing the Threshold The word threshold comes from the age-old process of threshing—beating the husks away from the grain. So threshold literally means “sitting on the gold.” Goethe’s fairy tale of “The Green Snake and the Beautiful Lily” comes to mind here, when we think of thresholds and gold. In that story, we meet a green snake, beautifully illuminated by the gold she has swallowed. As the story goes, she finds four kings in a subterranean temple. One of the kings questions her about her ability to come to where they were. “How did you get here?” he asks her, and she replies, “Out of the clefts where gold dwells.” Then the question is posed: “What is more glorious than gold?” and the answer is “Light.” Then they ask her, “What is more quickening than light?” and she answers, “Conversation.” We can cross the threshold when we begin to function as a vehicle for something even more precious than gold or light. What we soon discover is that this threshold challenge is consistent across all systems. When we realize that our habitual way of seeing and acting is not getting us anywhere, we have to redirect and bend our beam of our (individual or collective) attention and redirect the edges of perception back upon its source, back upon the one who is performing the activity. When this shift happens, we begin to attend to the situation from a different place. The field structure of attention describes the realm between the visible world (what we see) as it meets the
113
114
ON THE THRESHOLD
invisible world (the source or place from which we perceive it). When we change the way we attend, a different world is going to come forth. When the fire burned my home to ashes, my field structure of attention changed from seeing the world through my habits of sitting in the class during the first part of the day (1), to suddenly seeing it: the smoke and the fire far off through a taxi window (2), to seeing the fire and the current self: experiencing a collapse of the boundary between observer and observed by standing in front of the fire and feeling the flames sinking into my mind and realizing that everything I thought I was, was gone (3). When time slowed down, I was at that threshold, about to cross over into “gold.” A door was about to open between my old self and my emerging future self—that was my threshold moment. In that moment I began to cross it (4). Threshold situations at the collective level display the same characteristics. They confront us with experiences that require us to bend, redirect, and transform our collective field of attention. When the Berlin Wall crumbled in 1989 and the World Trade Center towers collapsed twelve years later, we were confronted with two situations that invited us to deepen our perceptions and to open the boundary between the observer and the observed. In those fractured moments, some of us began to see how what is “out there” relates to our actions and identities “in here.” Of course, not everyone crossed this threshold. For many, the collapse of the twin towers in New York City triggered nothing but the oldest and most tired habits of reaction: “An evil empire struck us from outside, so we must strike back in kind.” The result of responding in that way (Level 1) to such a situation is predictable: it will create and magnify the problem that it claims to solve. Any Level 1 response is structurally blind to how one’s own actions co-create the system (world) one lives in. A military superpower may be able to get away with such a lowlevel response for a few years, but sooner or later it will inevitably fail. Unlike forceful nations, companies or NGOs in highly dynamic environments have to be much more responsive to the changes around them, to the “golden” opportunities that life is presenting to them. Like the green snake, they already glow. That is, they also have to learn how to harness the gold that their interaction with local contexts has offered to them. Some of them are
Theory U
agile enough to quickly reconfigure, reinvent, and realign themselves as needed. “Golden” organizations function as a bridge between two worlds, linking the current operational environment with the sensing and seizing of emerging opportunities. Crossing that bridge is the hallmark of organizational excellence and the key to high performance in rapidly changing environments. Being stuck on one side (current reality) or the other (emerging future) usually means mediocre organizational quality in stable environments—or going out of business really quickly in the case of fast changing environments.
The Signature of Our Time Our professional and personal experiences require us to reach that lower subterranean level Goethe wrote: about the deep underground cavern where the green snake met the kings. It is the same level that we earlier referred to as the root system of the tree—that part of the field that usually remains invisible to the eye. We must confront these deeper levels of social reality creation by being willing to step over the thresholds of our time. So how do we know whether we are getting there? Those thresholds or doorways usually begin to appear when our conventional ways of operating no longer work, when we hit a wall. We have to drop our old tools and redirect and bend the beam of our attention to the field unfolding around and within us. It’s like a crack in our reality: suddenly that crack is right there, right in your face. Then you have the choice: brush over it, or stop. If you stop: drop your tools, attend to the crack that is opening up in front of you, tune in to that crack, redirect your attention into it. And then, go with the flow. The capacity to see the crack—to stop and then to tune right in to it—is a key discipline of our time. It’s a discipline without which we cannot deliver high performance when it matters. It’s a discipline that needs attention and cultivation just as the soil of any farm needs attention and cultivation. It’s the discipline of tuning in to the U. While the methods and tools farmers use to cultivate and improve the quality of their fields are well known, we often lack a similar body of meth-
115
116
ON THE THRESHOLD
ods and tools for cultivating the inner conditions of the social field in order to become more skillful at seeing, stopping, and tuning in to the crack. Part II, “Entering the U Field,” will help us access those tools. Look around. Something is happening. We might call it the signature of our time written large. It is inviting us to look beyond our blind spots and to open our eyes to the images that are beginning to take shape on our blank canvases. The challenges we face right now are pressuring us to look differently, to sharpen and deepen our attention. We need to cultivate the collective capacity to shift the inner place from where we operate. I believe that all systems and all levels use the same fundamental shifting procedure or process. Whether you are a great leader, educator, artist, athlete, physician, writer, or coach, whether you work alone or belong to a team or organization, you cross the threshold by transforming the structure of your attention, by seeing and tuning in to the crack. The Indo-European root of the word “lead” and “leadership,” *leith, means “to go forth,” “to cross the threshold,” or “to die.”1 Sometimes letting go feels like dying. But what we’ve learned about the deeper process of the U is that something has to change—a threshold must be crossed—before something new can come. The journey ahead of us entails uncovering and deciphering the principles and practices of that fundamental process so they can serve as a language that will help to illuminate the invisible leadership realm of the blind spot.
Part II
Entering the U Field
I
n the Introduction, we discussed how my family went on a Feldgang, a field walk, every Sunday. It was the opportunity for my parents to connect with and investigate the current state of the fields across the farm. We
stopped every now and then, bent over, looked more closely, and picked up bits with our hands. This book is our Feldgang— our chance to look at our blind spots with greater precision and clarity. One conclusion of the first part of the book is that in order to deal with the challenges of our time, we need to learn to shift the way we attend, the field structure of our attention. The way we pay attention—the place from which we operate—is the blind spot on all levels of the society.
117
118
ENTERING THE U FIELD
I n Pa r t I I , we focus on the core process that allows us to shift the field structure of attention. That core process will help us to discern the different folds, turns, and territories of the blind spot. The body of knowledge resulting from this investigation is the basis of Theory U. Theory U, at its core, makes a distinction between different levels of emergence, meaning different qualities of how action comes into the world. Theory U is grounded in the observation that any social entity or living system can operate from more than one inner place. The challenge lies in our not seeing and not activating the other places. By mapping the topography of the blind spot, Theory U offers a language and a road map for crossing the threshold to authentic renewal and change. To accomplish this, we have to shift the place from which we and our systems operate. This is an enormous task, but it is, I believe, what leadership in our time is all about.
Chapter 8
Downloading • The Field Structure of Downloading • GlobalHealthCompany • Four Barriers to Organizational
Patterns of the Past
Learning and Change
Patterns of the Past
W
hat we do is often based on habitual patterns of action and thought. A familiar stimulus triggers a familiar response. Moving toward a future possibility requires us to become aware
of—and abandon—the dominant mode of downloading that causes us to continuously reproduce the patterns of the past. When the Berlin Wall collapsed in the fall of 1989—followed by a ripple of collapsing socialist systems throughout Central and Eastern Europe, and the Soviet Union shortly thereafter—Western governments were quick to announce that this event had come out of the blue and that nobody could have anticipated such a geopolitical shift. Was that true? Just two weeks earlier, I had been with an international student group on a study trip around the world, including through Central and Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union. During that trip, we talked with representatives of the official system as well as grassroots activists in civil rights movements. In 119
120
DOWNLOADING
many of these conversations, especially with the activists in Central Europe, we sensed that they anticipated a profound change. It was in the air. A pattern of the past was about to shift dramatically. During our stay in East Berlin, a week prior to the collapse, the peace researcher Johan Galtung offered a public wager in his speeches that the Berlin Wall would collapse by the end of 1989. I vividly remember that no expert or analyst, on either side, had ever predicted anything like it before. I heard his statement with ambivalence. On the one hand, what Galtung predicted fully resonated with what we had seen in Eastern Europe. But then my mind reverted to old habits of thinking: Hasn’t this system existed for half a century? And haven’t these same problems, issues, and civic countermovements always existed? Budapest 1956, Prague 1968. People had tried to bring socialist regimes to their knees, but their efforts had amounted to nothing. Red Army tanks just kept rolling over people. The bottom line remained the same: the old system prevailed. So there I was, twenty-seven years old and exposed to fresh evidence that the Eastern European socialist system was about to collapse. Yet in my mind I was unable to recognize what I had seen with my own eyes. I thought that Galtung’s prediction was maybe a little off or far-fetched. It was not. He was dead on. Having seen the Berlin Wall collapse on schedule (according to his prediction), I had to ask myself what had kept me from accepting the “truth” I had seen with my own eyes? Why did Galtung, who was exposed to the same data as we all had been during the trip, emerge with a clear conclusion, while I developed a murky “on the one hand, on the other” view? The primary difference between me, the student, and Galtung, the master researcher, wasn’t the amount of knowledge accumulated but a different way of seeing. He had a more disciplined way of paying attention to the world. He was able to suspend his habitual judgment and pay undistorted attention to the reality in front of him.
The Field Structure of Downloading When we truly pay attention, we stop our habitual mode of downloading and open up to the reality in front of us. As long as our mental mechanism’s
Theory U
F i g ur e 8 . 1 Th e F i e l d S t r uc t ur e of D ow n l oa di ng
attention is guided by habitual patterns, the source of our attention originates from the center of our own organization. Figure 8.1 shows the mechanical structure of this field by depicting the source of attention and action (represented by the white dot) in the center of the boundaries of its own organization (represented by the blue circle). Meetings and habitual conversations in organizations, for example, are often based on downloading past patterns. We collectively reproduce existing patterns of behavior and thought. When operating from the place of downloading—that is, from within the closed boundaries of our own organization—we are captured in our old world like a prisoner in a cell: there is no way out. We see only the mental constructs that we project onto the world. The philosopher Paul Watzlawick gives a wonderful example of this type of operating: A man wants to hang a picture. He has a nail, but no hammer. The neighbor has one so our man decides to borrow it. But then a doubt occurs to him. “What if the neighbor won’t let me have it? Yesterday he
121
122
DOWNLOADING
barely nodded when I greeted him. Perhaps he was in a hurry. But perhaps he pretended to be in a hurry because he does not like me. And why would he not like me? I have always been nice to him; he obviously imagines something. If someone wanted to borrow one of my tools, I would of course give it to him. So why doesn’t he want to lend me his hammer? How can one refuse such a simple request? People like him really poison one’s life. He probably even imagines that I depend on him just because he has a hammer. I’ll give him a piece of my mind.” And so our man storms over to the neighbor’s apartment and rings the bell. The neighbor opens the door, but before he can even say “Good morning,” our man shouts. “And you can keep your damned hammer, you oaf!”1
GlobalHealthCompany Institutions and systems habitually download past patterns. Consider the example of the GlobalHealthCompany (a fictitious name), one of the biggest and most successful companies in its industry.2 A European branch of this company experienced a major breakdown after introducing a new product in the 1990s. The company hired a huge sales force to launch the product, only to find that the more effort it put into selling the product, the less successful it was. Eventually, a television program aired a report on the side effects of the product. The program investigators asked to speak with the managers, but the company declined. A year later, one customer who had been using the product died. In retrospect, it seemed obvious that there had been warning signs about both the side effects and the fact that this product needed a specialized marketing approach. The question is: Why did the managers fail to see and recognize these early-warning signals?
The Manufacturing of a Corporate Virus The answer to this question is deeply connected to both the culture and the history of the company. In Organizational Culture and Leadership (1992) Schein describes two principles that are essential to understanding what the
Theory U
company did wrong.3 First, the role of the founder is always critical to understanding an organizational culture. And second, today’s organizational cultures are based on assumptions that are related to practices that have been successful in the past. Because all companies in existence today have, in one way or another, succeeded in the past, the current culture is always based on assumptions that have a long record of success. Here is how these two principles show up in the case of the GlobalHealthCompany.
Four CEOs CEO I: 1960s “The first general manager of GlobalHealthCompany came to us in the 1960s,” says one of the senior managers who was with the company then. “His first job was to sell. He had very fixed ideas about the company. He ruled in a very authoritarian way. He built up a sales force, but he always maintained that our country was a special place—you could not sell the same way here in this country.” Some of that same dogmatism could be seen in the person of the pathbreaking research figure at the headquarters as well. Says an employee of GlobalHealthCompany, “He would forbid anyone to talk to regulatory authorities about such side effects, because if there were a problem, it could not be from the product itself.” CEO II: 1980s In the 1980s, a second CEO replaced the founding CEO. He moved the headquarters to a large city. “He was a ruinous leader,” recalls another GlobalHealthCompany manager. “He sacked people outright if they did not agree with him. You were sacked if you said something about the company that you should not say—your job was to protect the company.” He was aloof, and people rarely saw him in the organization. For all the first CEO’s authoritarianism, you could say what you thought, even if you disagreed with him. Says the manager, “He might throw a tantrum, but you could speak out.”
123
124
DOWNLOADING
CEO III: Early 1990s The second CEO lasted for three years and was followed by