Toric Varieties David Cox John Little Hal Schenck D EPARTMENT 01002
OF
M ATHEMATICS , A MHERST C OLLEGE , A MHERST, MA
E-mail address:
[email protected] D EPARTMENT OF M ATHEMATICS AND C OMPUTER S CIENCE , C OLLEGE THE H OLY C ROSS , W ORCESTER , MA 01610
OF
E-mail address:
[email protected] D EPARTMENT OF M ATHEMATICS , U NIVERSITY C HAMPAIGN , U RBANA , IL 61801 E-mail address:
[email protected]
OF I LLINOIS AT
U RBANA -
c 2009, David Cox, John Little and Hal Schenck
Preface
The study of toric varieties is a wonderful part of algebraic geometry that has deep connections with polyhedral geometry. Our book is an introduction to this rich subject that assumes only a modest knowledge of algebraic geometry. There are elegant theorems, unexpected applications, and, as noted by Fulton [30], “toric varieties have provided a remarkably fertile testing ground for general theories.” The Current Version. The January 2009 version consists of seven chapters: Chapter 1: Affine Toric Varieties Chapter 2: Projective Toric Varieties Chapter 3: Normal Toric Varieties Chapter 4: Divisors on Toric Varieties Chapter 5: Homogeneous Coordinates Chapter 6: Line Bundles on Toric Varieties Chapter 7: Projective Toric Morphisms These are the chapters included in the version you downloaded. The book also has a list of notation, a bibliography, and an index, all of which will appear in more polished form in the published version of the book. Two versions are available on-line. We recommend using postscript version since it has superior quality. Changes to the August 2008 Version. The new version fixes some typographical errors and has improved running heads. Other additions include: Chapter 4 includes more sheaf theory. Chapter 4 has an exercise about support functions and tropical polynomials. Chapter 5 now discusses sheaves associated to a graded modules. iii
Preface
iv
The Rest of the Book. Five chapters are in various stages of completion: Chapter 8: The Canonical Divisor of a Toric Variety Chapter 9: Sheaf Cohomology of Toric Varieties Chapter 10: Toric Surfaces Chapter 11: Toric Singularities Chapter 12: The Topology of Toric Varieties When the book is completed in August 2010, there will be three final chapters: Chapter 13: The Riemann-Roch Theorem Chapter 14: Geometric Invariant Theory Chapter 15: The Toric Minimal Model Program Prerequisites. The text assumes the material covered in basic graduate courses in algebra, topology, and complex analysis. In addition, we assume that the reader has had some previous experience with algebraic geometry, at the level of any of the following texts: Ideals, Varieties and Algorithms by Cox, Little and O’Shea [17] Introduction to Algebraic Geometry by Hassett [43] Elementary Algebraic Geometry by Hulek [52] Undergraduate Algebraic Geometry by Reid [84] Computational Algebraic Geometry by Schenck [90] An Invitation to Algebraic Geometry by Smith, Kahanp¨aa¨ , Kek¨al¨ainen and Traves [94] Readers who have studied more sophisticated texts such as Harris [40], Hartshorne [41] or Shafarevich [89] certainly have the background needed to read our book. We should also mention that Chapter 9 uses some basic facts from algebraic topology. The books by Hatcher [44] and Munkres [72] are useful references. Background Sections. Since we do not assume a complete knowledge of algebraic geometry, Chapters 1–9 each begin with a background section that introduces the definitions and theorems from algebraic geometry that are needed to understand the chapter. The remaining chapters do not have background sections. For some of the chapters, no further background is necessary, while for others, the material more sophisticated and the requisite background will be provided by careful references to the literature. The Structure of the Text. We number theorems, propositions and equations based on the chapter and the section. Thus §3.2 refers to section 2 of Chapter 3, and Theorem 3.2.6 and equation (3.2.6) appear in this section. The end (or absence) of a proof is indicated by , and the end of an example is indicated by .
Preface
v
For the Instructor. We do not yet have a clear idea of how many chapters can be covered in a given course. This will depend on both the length of the course and the level of the students. One reason for posting this preliminary version on the internet is our hope that you will teach from the book and give us feedback about what worked, what didn’t, how much you covered, and how much algebraic geometry your students knew at the beginning of the course. Also let us know if the book works for students who know very little algebraic geometry. We look forward to hearing from you! For the Student. The book assumes that you will be an active reader. This means in particular that you should do tons of exercises—this is the best way to learn about toric varieties. For students with a more modest background in algebraic geometry, reading the book requires a commitment to learn both toric varieties and algebraic geometry. It will be a lot of work, but it’s worth the effort. This is a great subject. What’s Missing. Right now, we do not discuss the history of toric varieties, nor do we give detailed notes about how results in the text relate to the literature. We would be interesting in hearing from readers about whether these items should be included. Please Give Us Feedback. We urge all readers to let us know about: Typographical and mathematical errors. Unclear proofs. Omitted references. Topics not in the book that should be covered. Places where we do not give proper credit. As we said above, we look forward to hearing from you! January 2009
David Cox John Little Hal Schenck
Contents
Preface
iii
Notation
xi
Part I: Basic Theory of Toric Varieties
1
Chapter 1.
3
Affine Toric Varieties
§1.0.
Background: Affine Varieties
§1.1.
Introduction to Affine Toric Varieties
10
§1.2.
Cones and Affine Toric Varieties
22
§1.3.
Properties of Affine Toric Varieties
34
Appendix: Tensor Products of Coordinate Rings Chapter 2.
Projective Toric Varieties
3
48 49
§2.0.
Background: Projective Varieties
49
§2.1.
Lattice Points and Projective Toric Varieties
55
§2.2.
Lattice Points and Polytopes
63
§2.3.
Polytopes and Projective Toric Varieties
75
§2.4.
Properties of Projective Toric Varieties
86
Chapter 3.
Normal Toric Varieties
93
§3.0.
Background: Abstract Varieties
93
§3.1.
Fans and Normal Toric Varieties
106
§3.2.
The Orbit-Cone Correspondence
115
§3.3.
Equivariant Maps of Toric Varieties
124
§3.4.
Complete and Proper
138 vii
Contents
viii
Appendix: Nonnormal Toric Varieties Chapter 4.
Divisors on Toric Varieties
148 153
§4.0.
Background: Valuations, Divisors and Sheaves
153
§4.1.
Weil Divisors on Toric Varieties
169
§4.2.
Cartier Divisors on Toric Varieties
174
§4.3.
The Sheaf of a Torus-Invariant Divisor
187
Chapter 5.
Homogeneous Coordinates
193
§5.0.
Background: Quotients in Algebraic Geometry
193
§5.1.
Quotient Constructions of Toric Varieties
202
§5.2.
The Total Coordinate Ring
216
§5.3.
Sheaves on Toric Varieties
224
§5.4.
Homogenization and Polytopes
229
Chapter 6.
Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
243
§6.0.
Background: Sheaves and Line Bundles
243
§6.1.
Ample Divisors on Complete Toric Varieties
260
§6.2.
The Nef and Mori Cones
279
§6.3.
The Simplicial Case
289
Appendix: Quasicoherent Sheaves on Toric Varieties Chapter 7.
Projective Toric Morphisms
299 303
§7.0.
Background: Quasiprojective Varieties and Projective Morphisms
303
§7.1.
Polyhedra and Toric Varieties
307
§7.2.
Projective Morphisms and Toric Varieties
315
§7.3.
Projective Bundles and Toric Varieties
321
Appendix: More on Projective Morphisms Chapter 8.
The Canonical Divisor of a Toric Variety
332 337
§8.0.
Background: Reflexive Sheaves and Differential Forms
337
§8.1.
One-Forms on Toric Varieties
347
§8.2.
p-Forms on Toric Varieties
352
§8.3.
Fano Toric Varieties
352
Chapter 9.
Sheaf Cohomology of Toric Varieties
353
§9.0.
Background: Cohomology
353
§9.1.
Cohomology of Toric Line Bundles
365
§9.2.
Serre Duality
380
Contents
ix
§9.3.
The Bott-Steenbrink-Danilov Vanishing Theorem
385
§9.4.
Local Cohomology and the Total Coordinate Ring
385
Appendix: Introduction to Spectral Sequences
395
Topics in Toric Geometry
401
Chapter 10.
403
Toric Surfaces
§10.1.
Singularities of Toric Surfaces and Their Resolutions
403
§10.2.
Continued Fractions and Toric Surfaces
412
§10.3.
Gr¨obner Fans and McKay Correspondences
423
§10.4.
Smooth Toric Surfaces
433
§10.5.
Riemann-Roch and Lattice Polygons
441
Chapter 11.
Toric Singularities
453
§11.1.
Existence of Resolutions
453
§11.2.
Projective Resolutions
461
§11.3.
Blowing Up an Ideal Sheaf
461
§11.4.
Some Important Toric Singularities
461
Chapter 12.
The Topology of Toric Varieties
463
Chapter 13.
The Riemann-Roch Theorem
465
Chapter 14.
Geometric Invariant Theory
467
Chapter 15.
The Toric Minimal Model Program
469
Bibliography
471
Index
477
Notation
Basic Notions
! "!# $ "
integers, rational numbers, real numbers, complex numbers semigroup of nonnegative integers image and kernel direct limit inverse limit
Rings and Varieties
&% ')(*',+.&%0% ' ( *' + -0&% '21( ( *' +1 ( 3547698 :.4<;=8 &%>;&%>;-? &4<;A8 B9C D.47EF8 GHJIK 4
polynomial ring in / variables formal power series ring in / variables ring of Laurent polynomials affine or projective variety of an ideal ideal of an affine or projective variety coordinate ring of an affine or projective variety ; graded piece in degree @ when is projective ; field of rational functions when is irreducible E affine variety of coordinate ring L projective variety of graded ring ; subset of an affine variety where OQR P E L localization of at O , a multiplicative set , a prime ideal Y E integral closure of the integral domain
xi
Notation
xii
E
4<;=8
! ; ! ;
L
B 4 8
affine cone of a projective variety diagonal map singular locus of a variety
E L H U
;
E
completion of local ring local ring of a variety at a point and its maximal ideal Zariski tangent space of a variety at a point dimension of a variety and dimension at a point L Zariski closure of in a variety product of varieties tensor product of rings over fiber product of varieties
Semigroups
6
%$
Z$ 1$ 2
203 234 5 &% 2 <
#"
lattice ideal of lattice ! $ lattice generated by "')( (+* ',-'/. %$ " (0* ' R elements & with & '( $ affine semigroup generated by affine semigroup affine semigroup 687:9; 2 semigroup algebra of 2+3 Hilbert basis of when 6 is strongly convex
Cones and Fans
= I> 4
B9C+B ) 4 6 8
! 6
67
XC D 4 6 8 EFD 4 6 8 H0I H0M OQP OVP U Y
L
convex cone generated by rational convex polyhedral cone in ?A@ subspace spanned by 6 dimension of 6 dual cone of 6 relative interior of 6 BC+B )4 6 8 R ?G@ interior of 6 when set of ,. ;J@ with K , H+L R face of 6N7 dual to H !6 , equal to 687G9 H I 4R L R , ,. hyperplane in ?G@ defined by K , 4R LXW , ,. half-space in ?G@ defined by K , fan in ? @
; @TS J ;J@TS
Notation
Y 4.8
Y
3
?
? 46 8 ; 46 8 B DB 46 8 Y M 46 8 46 8
xiii
Y
-dimensional cones of minimal generator of 9 ? , Y maximal cones of 4 8 R BC+B )4 6 sublattice 6:9 ? 3 quotient lattice ? ? 4 8 dual lattice of ? 6 , equal to 6 4 8 star of 6 , a fan in ? 6 Y star subdivision of along 6 index of a simplicial cone
. YS4 8
8 9-? I 9-;
Polyhedra
= I> 4
! O O U
+
4 A8
6"! Y%$ &
$
L
convex hull of polytope or polyhedron dimension of RS L R . hyperplane in ; @ defined by K , S R L%W . half-space in ; @ defined by K , dual or polar of a polytope standard / -simplex Minkowski sum multiple of a polytope or polyhedron cone over a polytope or polyhedron cone of a face # ! normal fan of a polytope or polyhedron support function of a polytope or polyhedron
? @QS G ?G@QS
Toric Varieties
P (' ; ? )
5 ;J@ ;0/ ? @ ?2/ K, L 3 8.3 4 3 54 3 5 6 8
6 5
character lattice of a torus and character of , . ; lattice of one-parameter subgroups of a torus and one-parameter subgroup of . ? +* M R-, I..*4 ; J M 8 associated to ? and torus ? 1* ; +* vector spaces ; built from ; 1* +* vector spaces ? built from ? ? . , . ; or ; @ with ? or ?G@ pairing of $ !; affine and projective toric variety of affine toric variety of a cone 6J! ?:@ toric variety of a fan
;
Notation
xiv
$
@
3
46 8
; 4H 8 R 46 8 R 4 8
4
$ 4
projective toric variety of a lattice polytope or polyhedron toric variety of a basepoint free divisor 6 6 lattice homomorphism of a toric morphism and its real extension 4 3 distinguished point of Y orbit of 6 . Y , toric variety of B D B 4 6 8 closure of orbit of 6 . 6 of . YS4 8 torus-invariant prime divisor on $ torus-invariant prime divisor on of facet ! affine toric variety of recession cone of a polyhedron affine toric variety of a fan with convex support
6
Specific Varieties
+ + 4 + 8 M 47 M 8 + ?. ? 47 + 8 4 6 8 <
L!
affine and projective / -dimensional space weighted projective space multiplicative group of nonzero complex numbers standard / -dimensional torus rational normal + cone and curve blowup of at the origin 6 ; 4 8 Y blowup of along H , toric variety of Hirzebruch surface rational normal scroll
M 4H 8
Divisors
$
#"
V4 8 O
&%('
W ) 4 8
) )4 8 ) +*-, 4 8 = ) 4 8 = ) .*/,X4 8
6
= 4 8
6
local ring of a variety at a prime divisor discrete valuation of a prime divisor principal divisor of a rational function linear equivalence of divisors effective divisor group of principal divisors on group of Weil divisors on 6 group of torus-invariant Weil divisors on group of Cartier divisors on group of torus-invariant Cartier divisors on divisor class group of a normal variety 6
S
Notation
xv
G ! D.4 8 B C C 48
Picard group of a normal variety support of a divisor restriction of a divisor to an open set local data of a Cartier divisor on Cartier data of a torus-invariant Cartier divisor on polyhedron of a torus-invariant divisor fan associated to a basepoint free divisor Cartier divisor of a polytope or polyhedron support function of a Cartier divisor support functions integral with respect to ?
4 4 3 ' O 3' 86
,
Y
$ &
B 4 Y ? 8
6
Intersection Products
24 8
Z
( ? 4 T4 4 4 G !D.4 4 A8
8 ? ( 4 8 8 8 8 8@
Z
degree of a divisor on a curve intersection product of Cartier divisor and complete curve numerically equivalent Cartier divisors and complete curves 4 = )4 8 8N * and 4 ( 4 8 F8N * ( 4 8 cone in ? generated by nef divisors ( 4 8 cone in ? generated by complete curves 4 8 Mori cone, equal to the closure of
)
G !D.4 8 *
primitive relation of a primitive collection
Sheaves and Bundles
"
"M
#" 4 8
"
44 8
;
BC D47EF8
sheaf on
"! 4#"8
%$&('
"
structure sheaf of a variety sheaf of invertible elements of sheaf of a Weil divisor on constant sheaf of rational functions when restriction of a sheaf to an open set sections of a sheaf over an open set ideal sheaf of a subvariety !
sheaf on
6
of an
E
L of a graded
-module
;
-module L L 4#"8 sheaf on of the graded -module stalk of a sheaf at a point tensor product of sheaves of -modules
6
"
is irreducible
Notation
xvi
, $& 4 7 ; ; O M <
Y
4<; 8 4 S8
' 8
"
sheaf of homomorhisms < , 4 8 dual sheaf of , equal to vector bundle
rank vector bundle of a line bundle pullback of a line bundle ! 4 8 map to projective space determined by complete linear system of ; for R ! 4 8 fan that gives projective bundle of vector bundle or locally free sheaf
"
Quotients and Homogeneous Coordinates
E ; ; L
'
L
24 ' 8
'3
4Y 8
&4 Y 8
' P
' P
' ' P $ $ '
#4 "T8
E
ring of invariants of acting on good geometric quotient good categorical quotient 6 total coordinate ring of L YS4 8 variable in corresonding to . = 4 6 8 L graded piece of in degree . = 4 6 8 L degree in of a monomial in Y monomial generator of corresponding3 to 6 . L ' irrelevant ideal of , generated by the 354 4 Y 8*8 exceptional set, equal to I. *4 = 4 6 8 J M P 8 used in the quotient construction group , ' Laurent monomial P , ,. ; ' 9-; homogenization of , ,. facet variable of a facet ! -monomial associated to ,. 9-; 9 ; vertex monomial associated to vertex . L graded -module = 4 6)8 " shift of by .
Part I: Basic Theory of Toric Varieties
Chapters 1 to 9 introduce the theory of toric varieties. This part of the book assumes only a minimal amount of algebraic geometry, at the level of Ideals, Varieties and Algorithms [17]. Each chapter begins with a background section that develops the necessary algebraic geometry.
1
Chapter 1
Affine Toric Varieties
§1.0. Background: Affine Varieties We begin with the algebraic geometry needed for our study of affine toric varieties. Our discussion assumes Chapters 1–5 and 9 of [17].
6 ! L R F % '( *',+.- gives an affine variety 354768 R . + O 4 8 R for all O . 6 + ; and an affine variety ! gives the ideal :.4<;&8 R O . L O 4 8 R for all . ; . ; By the Hilbert Basis Theorem, an affine variety is defined by the vanishing of L 6 finitely many polynomials in , and for any ideal , the Nullstellensatz tells us that :.4 3547698*8 6 L 6 R R O . O . for some W ;since is algebraically Coordinate Rings. An ideal
closed. The most important algebraic object associated to
is its coordinate ring
A%>;S- R L :.4<;&8 &%>;- can be interpreted as the -valued polynomial functions on ; . Elements of A%>;S- is a -algebra, meaning that its vector space structure is compatible Note that with its ring structure. Here are some basic facts about coordinate rings:
A%>;S-
is an integral domain
:.4<;A8
is a prime ideal
;
; (A ; between affine variPolynomial maps (also called morphisms) F>% ; - &%>; ( - , where eties correspond to -algebra homomorphisms M M 4 98 R for . &%>; - . is irreducible.
Two affine varieties are isomorphic if and only if their coordinate rings are isomorphic -algebras. 3
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
4
A point
of an affine variety
;
gives the maximal ideal
%>; - O 4 8 R ! F%>; -<
O . F F%>; - arise this way. and all maximal ideals of
Coordinate rings of affine varieties can be characterized as follows (Exercise 1.0.1).
E
Lemma 1.0.1. A -algebra is isomorphic to the coordinate ring of an affine E variety if and only if isP a finitely generated -algebra with no nonzero nilpotents, E satisfies O R for some , W , then O R . i.e., if O .
; and &%>;- , we sometimes write ; R BC D47&%>; - 8 (1.0.1) ; with the set of maximal ideals of This can be made canonical by identifying F%>; - via the fourth bullet above. More generally, one can take any commutative BC D.47EF8 . The general definition of Spec uses E ring and define the affine scheme E all prime ideals of , not just the maximal ideals as we have done. Thus some ; BC D 47A%>;S- 8 , the maximal spectrum of A%>;S- . authors would write (1.0.1) as R To emphasize the close relation between
Readers wishing to learn more about affine schemes should consult [26] and [41].
+ ; An affine variety !
+ use. The Zariski Topology. has two topologies we will . The The first is the classical topology, induced from the usual topology on ; second is the Zariski topology,+ where the Zariski closed sets are subvarieties of contained in ; ) and the Zariski open sets are their (meaning affine varieties of complements. Since subvarieties are closed in the classical topology (polynomials are continuous), Zariski open subsets are open in the classical topology. L
;
L
Given a subset is the smallest ! L , its closureL in the Zariski topology ; L subvariety of containing . We call the Zariski closure of . It is easy to give examples where this differs from the closure in the classical topology.
Affine Open Subsets and Localization. Some Zariski open subsets of an affine ; &%>;- SX , let variety are themselves affine varieties. Given O .
;,N R . ; O 4 8 R P ! ;M ;,N is Zariski open in ; and is also an affine variety, as we now explain. Then + ; :.4<;&8 R K O ( O " L and pick . &% ' ( *' + - repreLet have ! 2 ; N R ; R 354 8 is Zariski open +in ; . Now consider a new senting O . Then 354 O ( O "
R 8 ! . Since the projection variable+ and let + R + maps bijectively onto ;VN , we can identify ;2N with the affine map . variety ! ; ;)N is easy to describe. Let F4<;=8 When is irreducible, the coordinate ring of F%>; - . Recall that elements of F4<;=8 be the field of fractions of the integral domain
§1.0. Background: Affine Varieties
give rational functions on
;
5
. Then let
A%>;S- N R O . A 4<;&8 . A %>;S-< W . (1.0.2) BC D.47A%>;S- N 8 is the affine variety ;2N In Exercise 1.0.3 you will prove that
.
Example 1.0.2. The / -dimensional + + torus is the affine open + subset
47 M 8 R S 354 ')( J',+98 ! with coordinate ring A% ' ( *' + - R A% ' 1( ( *'
+1 ( -<
Elements of this ring are called Laurent polynomials.
A%>;S- N
The ring from (1.0.2) is an example of localization. In Exercises 1.0.2 and 1.0.3 you will show how to construct this ring for all affine varieties, not just irreducible ones. The general concept of localization is discussed in standard texts in commutative algebra such as [2, Ch. 3] and [25, Ch. 2].
E
Normal Affine Varieties. Let be an integral domain with field of fractions . E Then is normal, or integrally closed, if every element of which is integral E E % ' - ) actually lies in E . over (meaning that it is a root of a monic polynomial in For example, any UFD is normal (Exercise 1.0.5). Definition 1.0.3. An irreducible affine variety F%>; - is normal.
;
is normal if its coordinate ring
+
&% '( *' +.-
For example, is normal since its coordinate ring and hence normal. Here is an example of a non-normal affine variety.
is a UFD
5 3 4 R 8 ' R ! Example 1.0.4. Let . This is an irreducible plane F% - R A% ' - K ' R L . curve with a cusp at the origin. It is easy to see that ' ' &% - respectively. This gives ' . FNow 4 8. let and be the cosets of and in ' &% - and that 4 'V 8 R ' . Consequently F% A computation shows that .
and hence
are not normal.
We will see below that
is an affine toric variety.
; has a normalization defined as follows. Let F%>; - Z R " . F 4<;=8 " is integral over &%>;- . A%>;S-!Z the integral closure of F%>;S- . One can show that A%>;S- Z is normal We call and (with more work) finitely generated as a -algebra (see [25, Cor. 13.13]). This An irreducible affine variety
gives the normal affine variety
; Z R BC D47A%>;S- Z 8 ;AZ the normalization of ; . The natural inclusion &%>;- ! F%>;S-7Z R F%>;FZ We call ;A0Z ; . This is the normalization map. corresponds to a map
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
6
! Example We saw in Example 1.0.4 that the curve defined by ' R has1.0.5. ' &% - such that ' . F% - is integral F% - . In elements . over 8 A % ' F 4 F% Exercise 1.0.6 you will show that ! is the integral closure 4 8 of and that the normalization map is the map defined by .
At first glance, the definition of normal does not seem very intuitive. Once we enter the world of toric varieties, however, we will see that normality has a very nice combinatorial interpretation and that the nicest toric varieties are the normal ones. We will also see that normality leads to a nice theory of divisors. In Exercise 1.0.7 you will prove some properties of normal domains that will be used in §1.3 when we study normal affine toric varieties. Smooth Points of Affine Varieties. In order to define a smooth point of an affine ; ; variety , we first need to define local rings and Zariski tangent spaces. When ; is irreducible, the local ring of at is
Thus
R
O
. &4<;A8 O . F%>; -
consists of all rational functions on we have the maximal ideal
24 8 R P .
that are defined at . Inside of
. 4 8 R .
R
In fact, is the unique maximal ideal of Exercises 1.0.2 and 1.0.4 explain how to define The Zariski tangent space of
;
and
;
at
X , so that ; when
is a local ring. is not irreducible.
is defined to be
4<;&8 R-, I. T 4 J8 +
! 47 + 8 R In Exercise 1.0.8 you will verify that / for every .
. According to [41, p. 32], we can compute the Zariski tangent space of a point in an affine variety as follows.
+ ; ; Lemma 1.0.6. Let and let . :.4<;&8 R K O ( O " L ! ! F % ' (bean *' affine + - . Forvariety each , let ' 4 ' 8 R O 4 8 ')( O ' 4 8 ' + @ O ' ( '+
. Also assume that
+ 4<;&8 Then the Zariski tangent 4 ( 8 R R 4 " is8 R isomorphic to the subspace
! 4<;&of8
equations
@ O
@ O
. In particular,
;
/
defined by the .
Definition 1.0.7. A point of an affine variety is smooth or nonsingular if
4<;=8 R ! ;
! ; , where maximum of the dimensions of the ; containingis the. The irreducible components of point is singular if it is not ; ; smooth. Finally, is smooth if every point of is smooth.
§1.0. Background: Affine Varieties
7
Points lying in the intersection of two or more irreducible components of are always singular ([17, + Thm. 8 of Ch. 9, §6]).+ +
! 47 8
;
R / for every . + , we see that is smooth. For an Since ; ; and :.4<;&8 R ! irreducible affine variety of dimension @ , fix . write ( ; KO O " L . Using Lemma 1.0.6, it is straightforward to show that is smooth at if and only if the Jacobian matrix
(1.0.3) has rank /
R @
'O ' 4 8 ( ' " ( +
4 ( " 8 R O O
(Exercise 1.0.9). Here is a simple example.
Example 1.0.8. As noted 1.0.4, the plane curve defined by 8 R L Ain% ' Example . : 4 ' 4 * 8 . has Jacobian R has K ! . A point R
' R
R 4 * 4R 8
so the origin is the only singular point of
4<;&8
I. 4 J 8
.
;
R , see that is smooth at when
Since ; equals the dimension of ,aswea vector space over #. In ; . terms of commutative algebra, this means that is smooth if and only if is a regular local ring. See [2, p. 123] or [25, 10.3]. We can relate smoothness and normality as follows. Proposition 1.0.9. A smooth irreducible affine variety
F%>; -
. . ;
R Proof. In §3.0 we will see that X normal once we prove that is normal for all is normal whenever is smooth. that
;
is normal.
A%>;S-
By Exercise 1.0.7, is . Hence it suffices to show
This follows from some powerful results in commutative algebra: is a ; regular local ring when is a smooth point of (see above), and every regular local ring is a UFD (see [25, Thm. 19.19]). Then we are done since every UFD is X ; is sketched in normal. A direct proof that is normal at a smooth point . Exercise 1.0.10.
The converse of Propostion 1.0.9 can fail. We will see in §1.3 that the affine 354 ' R S8 ! is normal, yet 354 ' R 8 is singular at the origin. variety
;(
;
Products of Affine Varieties. Given affine varieties , there are several ; ( P ; is an affineand variety. The most direct ways to show that the cartesian product ; ( R B9C D.47A% ')( *' P - 8 ; way Let + R is BtoC proceed D47A% ( as follows. + - 8 . Take :.4<; ( 8 ! R K O ( O " L and :.4<; 8 R K ( and ! L . Since the O ' and depend on separate sets of variables, it follows P + that
;( ; R 5 3 4 O ( O " ( 8 ! U
is an affine variety.
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
8
A fancier method is to use the mapping properties of the product. This will ; ( ; above, also give an intrinsic description of its coordinate ring. Given ;(# ; should be an affine variety with projections ' ;V( ; and ; ' as such that whenever we have a diagram
;$( ; ;
" /
;(
$
$
;
' are morphisms from an affine variety , there should be where ' a unique morphism (the dotted arrow) that makes the diagram commute, i.e., ' R ' . For the coordinate rings, this means that whenever we have a diagram
$
&%>; -
F%>;(*-
A%>;(
/
; -
%
&%>; - A% -
.
F% -
' with -algebra homomorphisms 'M , there should be a unique M algebra homomorphism (the dotted arrow) that makes the diagram commute. By A%>; ( - 1 F%>; the universal mapping property of the tensor product of -algebras, F > % ; * ( =&%>; has the mapping properties we want. Since is a finitely generated -algebra with no nilpotents (see the appendix to this chapter), it is the coordinate F > % ; (
; ring . For more on tensor products, see [2, pp. 24–27] or [25, A2.2].
;
$
Example 1.0.10. Let be an affine variety. Since ; + has product coordinate ring
+ R BC D.47A% ( + - 8 , the
A%>;S- &% ( + - R A%>;S- % ( + -< P ; :.4<;&8 R K O ( O " L ! A% ' ( *'+PX- , it follows that If is contained in with + :.4<; 8 R K O ( O " L ! A % ')( *'+PF ( +.-< ; 47 M 8 + is For later purposes, we also note that the coordinate ring of F%>; - VA% 1( ( + 1 ( - R &%>;- % (1 ( + 1 ( -< ; ( and ; , we note that the Zariski topology on ; ( ; Given affine varieties ;T( and ; . is usually not the product of the Zariski topologies on
§1.0. Background: Affine Varieties
9
R Example 1.0.11. Consider . By definition, a basis for the product 4 ( 4 4 of the Zariski topologies consists of sets where ' are Zariski open in . Such a set is the complement of a union of collections of “horizontal” and such “vertical” lines in . This makes it easy to see that Zariski closed sets in 354 R ' 8 cannot be closed in the product topology. as
Exercises for §1.0. 1.0.1. Prove Lemma 1.0.1. Hint: You will need the Nullstellensatz.
!"$#%&')(* for some + (a) Show that the usual formulas for adding and multiplying fractions induce well-defined binary operations that make into -algebra. (b) If has no nonzero nilpotents, then prove that the same is true for . For more on localization, see [2, Ch. 3] or [25, Ch. 2]. 1.0.3. Let be a finitely generated -algebra without nilpotents as in Lemma 1.0.1 and let ,-. be nonzero. Then (0/1123,23,54&26+6+7+98 is a multiplicative set. The localization : is denoted :; and is called the localization of at , . (a) Show that ; is a finitely generated -algebra without nilpotents. (b) Show that ; satisfies <>=?7@1A ; 'B(C<>=D?E@1F' ; . (c) Show that ; is given by (1.0.2) when is an integral domain. 1.0.4. Let G be an affine variety with coordinate ring IH G:J . Given a point KLMG , let %(N/7H GJPO&QRKS'U(VT W8 . (a) Show that is a multiplicative set. The localization IH G:J is denoted XZYW[ \ and is called the local ring of G at K . (b) Show that every ]%X^YW[ \ has a well-defined value ]PRK' and that _ YW[ \:(N/]%XZY>[ \O]PRKS'B(V `8 is the unique maximal ideal of XaYW[ \ . (c) When G is irreducible, show that XaY>[ \ agrees with the definition given in the text. 1.0.5. Prove that a UFD is normal. 1.0.6. In the setting of Example 1.0.5, show that HAc b d b Jef Fg' is the integral closure of H gUJ and that the normalization -hig is defined by kjhlA 4m2npo7' . 1.0.7. In this exercise, you will prove some properties of normal domains needed for §1.3. (a) Let be a normal domain with field of fractions q and let .f be a multiplicative subset. Prove that the localization is normal. (b) Let :r , stu , be normal domains with the same field of fractions q . Prove that the intersection v r`wmx yr is normal. 1.0.8. Prove that zW{}|f~ \ A')(V for all K . 1.0.2. Let be a commutative -algebra. A subset is a multipliciative subset provided , , and is closed under multiplication. The localization consists of all formal expressions , , , modulo the equivalence relation
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
10
1.0.9. Use Lemma 1.0.6 to prove the claim made in the text that smoothness is determined by the rank of the Jacobian matrix (1.0.3).
G
K%G
X^Y>[ \
( d d zW{}|VG
H H 6 2 7 + 6 + 9 + 2 } J J _ ( d 26+7+6+92 d IH}H d 27+6+7+92 d J J Since K G is smooth, [70, §1C] proves the existence of a -algebra homomorphism XZYW[ \h IH}H d 26+6+7+62 d J}J that induces isomorphisms X YW[ \ _Y>[ \ IH H d 26+7+6+72 d J}JA _ for all f . This implies that the completion [2, Ch. 10] X YW[ \ ( {}| X Y>[ \ _ YW[ \
is isomorphic to a formal power series ring, i.e., X Y>[ \ H H d 26+7+6+62 d J}J . Such an isomorphism captures the intuitive idea that at a smooth point, functions should have power series expansions in “local coordinates” d 26+7+6+92 d . If NX YW[ \ is an ideal, then ( v _ YW[ \ '9+ This theorem of Krull holds for any ideal in a Noetherian local ring u and follows from [2, Cor. 10.19] with (Vu: . Now assume that KG is smooth. (a) Use the third bullet to show that XaY>[ \ h IH}H d 26+7+6+72 d J}J is injective. (b) Suppose that 2 X YW[ \ satisfy O in IH}H d 26+7+6+72 d J}J . Prove that O in X YW[ \ . Hint: Use the second bullet to show XaY>[ \ _ Y>[ \ and then use the third bullet. (c) Prove that X^Y>[ \ is normal. Hint: Use part (b) and the first bullet. This argument can be continued to show that XaYW[ \ is a UFD. See [70, (1.28)] 1.0.11. Let G and be affine varieties and let VCG be a subset. Prove that ! " ( . # G % is irreducible. Hint: 1.0.12. Let G and be irreducible affine varieties. Prove that $ G % (( 1) ' *) ' 4 , where ' 2 ' 4 are closed. Let ,G + ( ./ - G OW./ -D/8 % '0+ 8 . Suppose & G 4 and that ,G + is closed in G . Exercise 1.0.11 will be useful. Prove that GM(CG
1.0.10. Let be irreducible and suppose that is smooth. The goal of this exercise is to prove that is normal using standard results from commutative algebra. Set and consider the ring of formal power series . This is a local ring with maximal ideal . We will use three facts: is a UFD by [102, p. 148] and hence normal by Exercise 1.0.5.
§1.1. Introduction to Affine Toric Varieties We first discuss what we mean by “torus” and then explore various constructions of affine toric varieties.
47 8 +
M is a group under component-wise The Torus. The affine variety multipli+ 7 4 8 M cation. A torus is an affine variety isomorphic to , where inherits a group structure from the isomorphism. Associated to are its characters and oneparameter subgroups. We discuss each of these briefly.
§1.1. Introduction to Affine Toric Varieties
A character of a torus phism. For example, , R defined by
4 * ( * + 8 .
is a morphism
'
11
+ M
that is a group P 47 homomor+ ' M8 M gives a character
P 4 ( + 8 ( + R + 47 8 arise this+ way (see [53, §16]). Thus the One can show that+ all characters of M 7 4 8 form a group isomorphic to . characters of M For an arbitrary torus , its characters form a free abelian group ; of rank equal P to the dimension of . It is customary to say that ,. ; gives the character ' M. '
(1.1.1)
We will need the following results concerning tori (see [53, §16] for proofs).
(
Proposition 1.1.1.
(
(a) Let and be tori and let homomorphism. Then the image of
O
(b) Let be a torus and let ! O subgroup. Then is a torus.
be a morphism that is a group is a torus and is closed in .
be an irreducible subvariety of
that is a
Now assume that a torus acts linearly on a finite dimensional vector space on . . Given , . ; , over , where the action of . is denoted we get the eigenspace P
.
If
P R P
. R
, then every . P P S=
P R
48
'
, with eigenvalue given by
48.
'
for all
. .
is a simultaneous eigenvector for all
Proposition 1.1.2. In the above situation, we have
R P
P
.
This proposition is a sophisticated way of saying that a family of commuting diagonalizable linear maps can be simultaneously diagonalized. A one-parameter subgroup of a torus 4 group homomorphism. For+ example, R ) 7 4 8 M M defined by subgroup
is a morphism+
( +98 .
)
M
that is a gives a one-parameter
8 4 8 4 R (1.1.2) 47 M 8 + arise this way All one-parameter subgroups of + (see [53, §16]). It follows+ 7 4 8 M that the group of one-parameter subgroups of is naturally isomorphic to . )
For an arbitrary torus , the one-parameter subgroups form a free abelian group ? of rank equal to the dimension of . As with the character group, an element ) M . . ? gives the one-parameter subgroup There is a natural bilinear pairing P '
K L ;
?
defined as follows. )
(Intrinsic) P Given a character and a one-parameter subgroup , the com' ) M M is character for position of M , which is given by some . . Then K , L R .
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
12
47 8 +
M with (Concrete) If R + , then one computes that
K, L R
(1.1.3)
+
, R 4 * ( * + 8 .
+ ')( (
,
R 4 ( + 8 .
* ''
i.e., the pairing is the usual dot product.
It follows that the characters and one-parameter subgroups of a torus form ? free abelian groups ; and ? of finite rank with a pairing K L ; I. * 4 ; JX8 and ; with , I. * 4 ? JX8 . In terms of tensor that identifies ? with , 2*S M via ) 4 8 . products, one obtains a canonical isomorphism ? 5 . Hence it is customary to write a torus as +
47 8
5
+ M induces dual From this point of view, picking an isomorphism + bases of ; and ? , i.e., isomorphisms ; and ? that turn characters into Laurent monomials (1.1.1), one-parameter subgroups into monomial curves (1.1.2), and the pairing into dot product (1.1.3). The Definition of Affine Toric Variety. We now define the main object of study of this chapter.
;
Definition 1.1.3. An affine 5 47 M 8 + toric variety is an irreducible affine variety contain 5 on ing a torus as a Zariski open subset such that the action of 5 ; itself extends to an action of on . Obvious examples of affine toric varieties are less trivial examples.
R 354 ' #R
Example 1.1.4. The plane curve This is an affine toric variety with torus
R R
where the isomorphism is normal toric variety.
47 M 8 +
8 !
and
+
. Here are some
has a cusp at the origin.
47 M 8 R 4 8 . M M 4 8 . Example 1.0.4 shows that 9
is a non-
; R 354 ' R 8 ! is a toric variety with torus ; 9 47 M 8 R 4 ( ( " ( 8 ' . M 47 M 8 ( 4 ( ( " 894 ( 8 . We will see later that where the isomorphism is ; is normal. ? U ( parametrized by the map Example 1.1.6. Consider the surface in R+ ? U ( 4 8 4 ? ? " ( ? " ( ? 8 . Thus is defined using all degree defined by @ monomials in .
Example 1.1.5. The variety
§1.1. Introduction to Affine Toric Varieties
?U (
' *'2?
' ' ( )' ( '
13
Let the coordinates of be and let minors ideal generated by the of the matrix
6 ! &% ' *',?-
be the
'2? " ,' ? " ( '2? " ( ', ? 6 ' ' ( R ' ' U (J' @ R L . In Exercise 1.1.1 you will verify so R K ' U 47 8 R 354768 , so that ? R 47 8 is an affine variety. You will also prove that :.4 ? 8 R 6 , so that 6 is the ideal of all polynomials vanishing on ? . It follows that 6 3547698 is irreducible by Proposition 1.1.8 below. The affine that is prime since ? surface is called the rational normal cone of degree @ and is an example of a 6 determinantal variety. We will see below that is a toric ideal. ? It is straightforward to show that is a toric variety with torus 4*47 M 8 8 R ? 9 47 M 8 ? U ( 47 M 8 We will study this example from the projective point of view in Chapter 2.
We next explore three equivalent ways of constructing affine toric varieties. Lattice Points. In this book, a lattice + is a free abelian group of5 finite rank. Thus a . For example, a torus has lattices ; (of lattice of rank / is isomorphic to characters) and ? (of one-parameter subgroups).
; , a set $ R , ( , " 5 with M . Thenlattice 5 character consider the map
Given a torus P ' gives characters
defined by
5 R "
3
(1.1.4)
! ;
4 8 R ' P 4 8 (' P 4 8 . " 3
$
Definition 1.1.7. Given a finite set ! ; , the affine toric variety 3 to be the Zariski closure of the image of the map from (1.1.4).
3
is defined
This definition is justified by the following proposition.
$
%$
Proposition 1.1.8. Given ! ; be the sublattice $ "3 ! ; as above, let generated by . Then is an affine toric variety whose torus has character %$ . In particular, the dimension of 3 is the rank of %$ . lattice Proof. The map (1.1.4) can be regarded as a map 3
5 R 47 M 8 "
4 5 8
of tori. By Proposition 1.1.1, the image R that is closed in 47 M 8F" . The latter implies that 3 9 47 M 8F" R since is3 a torus Zariski closure 3 is. the of the image. It follows that the image is Zariski open in Furthermore, is 3 . irreducible (it is a torus), so the same is true for its Zariski closure 3
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
14
"
We next consider the action of . Since and takes varieties to varieties. Then
! 74 M 8F" , an element .
acts on
R ! 3 3 is a variety containing . Hence 3 ! 3 by the definition shows that ( 3 R 3 , so that the action of " to of Zariski closure. Replacing with 3 induces an action on " 3 . We concludeleads that is an affine toric variety. 4 8 of . Since R 34 5 8 , It remains to compute the character lattice ; 3
the map
gives the commutative diagram
47 8 "
5
/ M FF O FF FF FF F" " ?
where denotes a surjective map and an injective map. This diagram of tori induces a commutative diagram of character lattices
;
" o dHH HH HH HH H2 R
; 4 8
"
(
(
, " , the image Since ; takes the standard basis 4 8 %$ " to , 3 %$ is . By the diagram, we obtain ; . Then we are done since of the dimension of a torus equals the rank of its character lattice. 3
In concrete terms, fix+ a basis of ; , so that we may assume ; R $ ! the vectors in can be regarded as the columns of an / 3
with integer entries. In this case, the dimension of matrix .
+
. Then matrix is simply the rank of the
We will see below that every affine toric variety is isomorphic to $ of a lattice. finite subset
3
for some
" R 9B C D47&% ')( *' " - 8 be the affine toric variety $ R , ( , " ! ; . We can describe the ideal :.4 3=8 ! A% ')( *' " - as follows. As in the proof of Proposition 1.1.8, (1.1.4)
Toric Ideals. Let ! coming from a finite set 3
induces a map of character lattices 3
(
" R ;
" to , that sends the standard basis map, so that we have an exact sequence
R+
R+
( , " . Let
" R+ ;
be the kernel of this
§1.1. Introduction to Affine Toric Varieties
15
4 ( " 8
In down to earth terms, elements R hence record the linear relations among the ,
R 4 ( " 8 . , set U R ' ' and R " and that U " . Note that R U ' R ' R Given
of
'.
satisfy
" R R
"
' ' R
R '
.
R
' '
' " '
3
' R '
3
since
Proposition 1.1.9. The ideal of the affine toric variety
and
. It follows easily that the binomial
vanishes on the image of (1.1.4) and hence on of the image.
:.4 3=8 R '
" & ' ( ( ' ,-' R
"H
3
. "
is the Zariski closure
" ! and
"
is
R
.
Proof. We leave it to the reader to prove equality of the two ideals on the right 6 denote this ideal and note that 6 ! :.4 3 8 . We prove (Exercise 1.1.2). Let the opposite inclusion following [97, Lem. 4.1]. Pick a monomial order on+ F% ' (*' " - and an isomorphism 5 47 M 8 + . Thus we may assume ; R + " P 7 4 8 M and the map is given by Laurent monomials in variables ( + . If 6 R P :.4 3 8 , then we . :.4 3 8 S 6 with minimal leading can pick O ' R '" ( ( ' ' . Rescaling if necessary, ' becomes the leading term monomial of O . P P
4 8
( +
Since O is identically zero as a polynomial in , there ' must be cancellation involving from . In other words, O must ' R '" ( ( the ' ' term' coming contain a monomial such that
"
4 P 8 R
'( ( "
This implies that
'( ( " R R & '" ( ( 4 * ' R ' 8 ' . so that 6 R ' ' of . It follows that O
* ',-' R
"
')( (
4P 8
" '( (
' ,-'
' R '
. . Then . : 4 3 8 also lies in leading term. This contradiction completes the proof.
6
the second description 6S byand has strictly smaller
$
finite set ! ; , there are several methods to compute the ideal :.4 3=Given 8 R 6a of Proposition 1.1.9. For simple examples, the rational implicitization >6 using a algorithm of [17, Ch. 3,§3] can be used. It is also possible to compute basis of and ideal quotients (Exercise 1.1.3). Further comments on computing 6 can be found in [97, Ch. 12]. Inspired by Proposition 1.1.9, we make the following definition.
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
16
" be a sublattice. ' R ' "H . " and "-R
Definition 1.1.10. Let ! (a) The ideal
6 R
.
is called a lattice ideal.
(b) A prime lattice ideal is called a toric ideal. Since toric varieties are irreducible, the ideals appearing in Proposition 1.1.9 are toric ideals. Examples of toric ideals include:
K' R
Example 1.1.4 Example 1.1.5 Example 1.1.6
%' L ! & % ' XL ! A K ' GR K ' ' ' U ( R ' ' U (*'
@ R ? L ! ( A% ' *',? -< ? U
(The latter is the ideal of the rational normal cone ! .) In each example, we have a prime ideal generated by binomials. As we now show, such ideals are automatically toric.
Proposition 1.1.11. An ideal and generated by binomials.
6 ! F% '( *' " -
is toric if and only if it is prime
6
Proof. One direction is obvious. So suppose that is prime and generated by ' R ' . Then observe that 354768 9 47 M 8 " is nonempty (it contains binomials 4 8 ) and is a subgroup of 47 M 8F" (easy to check). Since 354768 ! " is irre354768 9 47 M 8 " is an irreducible subvariety of 47 M 8 " that is ducible, it follows that 3547698 9 47 M 8 " is a torus. also a subgroup. By Proposition 1.1.1, we see that R
47 8F"
47 8F"X
M M, Projecting on the th coordinate of M gives P a character ' 4 8 M which by our usual convention we write as for ,'G. ; . It 5 3 7 4 6 8 3 $ R , ( , " 6 R follows easily that for , and since is prime, we 6 :.4 3 8 by the Nullstellensatz. Then 6 is toric by Proposition 1.1.9. have R
We will later see that all affine toric varieties arise from toric ideals. For more on toric ideals and lattice ideals, the reader should consult [68, Ch. 7].
2
Affine Semigroups. A semigroup is a set with an associative binary operation and an identity element. To be an affine semigroup, we further require that 2 The binary operation on is commutative. We will write the operation as $ ! 2 gives and the identity element as . Thus a finite set
1$ R & P
3
*P ,
* P . ! 2
The semigroup is finitely generated, meaning that there is a finite set #$ R 2 . such that
;+ . ! The simplest example of an affine semigroup is $ The semigroup can be embedded in a lattice
+
$ !
2
. More generally, given a lattice ; and a finite set ! ; , we get the affine semigroup $ ! ; . Up to isomorphism, all affine semigroups are of this form.
§1.1. Introduction to Affine Toric Varieties
17
F% 2 -
2
Given an affine semigroup ! ; , the semigroup algebra is the vector 2 space over with as basis and multiplication induced by the semigroup structure 2 5 of . To make this precise, we think P of ; as the character lattice of a torus , so ' that ,. ; gives the character . Then
&% 2 - R P
P ' P
.
P
with multiplication induced by
2 $ If R
'
P
$ R , ( , " for
and
P
R P
R
for all but finitely many ,
P U P
2 - R A% ' P (' P F % , then . '
'
+ ! + gives the polynomial ring A% - R F % ' ( *' + -< ' ' and ( + is the standard basis of + . where ' R ( + is a basis of a lattice ; , then ; is generated by Example 1.1.13. If $ R ( + '
as an affine semigroup. Setting ' R gives the Laurent polynomial ring F% ; - R F% 1( ( +1 ( -< F% - is the coordinate ring of the torus 5 . Using Example 1.0.2, one sees that ; Here are two basic examples.
Example 1.1.12. The affine semigroup +
Affine semigroup rings give rise to affine toric varieties as follows. Proposition 1.1.14. Let
2
!;
be an affine semigroup.
A% 2 - is an integral domain and finitely generated as a -algebra. (a) BC D.47A% 2 - 8 is an affine toric variety whose torus has character lattice 2 , and (b) 2 # $ for a finite set $ !; , then BC D47A% 2 - 8 R 3 . if R $ R , ( , " implies &% 2 - R F% ' P ( ' P - , so Proof. As noted above, F% 2 - is finitely generated. Since A% 2 - ! A% ; - follows from 2 ! ; , we see that F% 2 - is an integral domain by Example 1.1.13. $ R , ( , " , we get the -algebra homomorphism Using F% ' ( *' " N- R F% ; P ' ' . F% ; - . This corresponds to the morphism where ' 5 R " 3 4 3=8 M in the notation of §1.0. One checks that from (1.1.4), i.e., R kernel P the P - of & % ' ( ' F%is2 - the toric ideal :.4 3 8 (Exercise 1.1.4). R The image of is 3 , and then the coordinate ring of is &% 3A- R F% ' ( *' + - :.4 3 8 (1.1.5) R F% ' ( *',+.- 4 8 E 4 8 R A% 2 -<
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
18
BC D.47A% 2 - 8 R "3 . Since 2 R #$ implies 2 R %$ , the torus - 8 has the desired character lattice by Proposition 1.1.8.
This proves that 3 R BC D47A% 2 of
Here is an example of this proposition.
2
Example 1.1.15. Consider the affine semigroup ! generated by and , so 2 . To study F% 2 - , we use (1.1.5). that R the semigroup algebra If $ R , then 3 4 8 R 4 8 and the toric ideal is :.4 3 8 R K ' R L by Example 1.1.4. Hence
F% 2 - R &% - A% ' - K ' R 3 is the curve ' R . and the affine toric variety
L
Equivalence of Constructions. We can now state the main result of this section, which asserts that our various approaches to affine toric varieties all give the same class of objects. Theorem 1.1.16. Let (a)
;
(b) (c) (d)
;
be an affine variety. The following are equivalent:
;
is an affine toric variety according to Definition 1.1.3.
; R 3
for a finite set
$
in a lattice.
is an affine variety defined by a toric ideal.
; R BC D47A% 2 - 8
2
for an affine semigroup .
Proof. The implications (b) (c) (d) (a) follow from Propositions 1.1.8, ; 1.1.9 and 1.1.14. For (a) (d), let be an affine toric variety containing the torus 5 with character lattice ; . Since the coordinate ring of 5 is the semigroup A% 5 ! ; induces a map of coordinate rings algebra ; , the inclusion
5
This map is injective since A% as a subalgebra of ; . Let
2
&%>;-8R+ A % ; -<
is Zariski dense in
2 R ,.
;
'
P
;
, so that we can regard
A%>;S-
. A%>;S- 2
and note that is a semigroup. We will show that is finitely generated with F%>;- . This will complete the proof of the theorem. semigroup algebra equal to
F% 2 - ! A%>;S- is obvious. For the opposite inclusion, pick OQR P The inclusion A > % S ; & > % ; - ! F % ; - , we can write in . Using P O R P P ' where !; is finite and P R P for all ,. . Let P B C + B ) 4 ' 8 ,. R 'P ! F% ; F%>; - . If . 5 , then the action be the subspace spanned by the . Thus O . 9 F%>; - , so that we get O . A%>;S- . ; of on induces an action on the coordinate ring
§1.1. Introduction to Affine Toric Varieties
19
5
By Definition 1.1.3, this extends the usual P 4 8 of' P on , which in terms of the ' F% - is given by ' P R action coordinate ring ; that and hence 9 F%>; - are stable under the action of 5 . Since .9 ItAfollows %>;S- is finite-dimensional, A%>;S- is spanned by simultaneous eigenvectors 9 Proposition 1.1.2 implies that 5 . But this is taking place in F% ; - , where the simultaneous eigenvectors are of 9 A%>;S- is ' spanned characters. Then the above the characters! It follows that P &%>by A > % S ; . ;- for , . . It follows that expression for O . implies that 9 O . F% 2 - , proving that A%>;S- R A% 2 - .
A%>;S-
2
It remains to show that is finitely generated. Since is finitely generated, ( O " . &%>;- with &%>;- R &% O ( O " - . Expressing ' we can find O 2 each O 2 in terms of characters as above gives the desired finite generating set of . Hence is an affine semigroup. Here is one way to think about the above proof. When an irreducible affine ; 5 as a Zariski open subset, we have the inclusion variety contains a torus
A%>;S- ! F % ; -<
F%>; -
5
Thus consists of those functions on the torus that extend to polynomial ; ; functions on . Then the key insight is that is a toric variety precisely when the functions that extend are determined by the characters that extend.
;
8
354 ' R
R ! Example 1.1.17. We’ve seen that variety ' R A % ' X- . Also, the torus 47 isM 8 a toric L ( is via the map with toric ideal K ! 4 ( 8 4 ( ( " 8 . The lattice points used in this map can be represented as the columns of the matrix
(1.1.6)
2
R
! The corresponding semigroup consists of the -linear combinations of 2 the column vectors. Hence the elements of are lattice points lying in the poly pictured in Figure 1 on the next page. In this figure, the four hedral region in 2 vectors generating are shown in bold, and the boundary of the polyhedral region is partially shaded. In the terminology of §1.2, this polyhedral region is a rational 2 polyhedral cone. In Exercise 1.1.5 you will show that consists of all lattice points ; lying in the cone in Figure 1. We will use this in §1.3 to prove that is normal.
Exercises for §1.1.
$( d + d
# d + d Om #f -IH d 27+6+7+62 d J
1.1.1. As in Example 1.1.6, let
and let
g be the surface parametrized by F12nn'B(MF 23 26+7+6+92 6 2 'a +
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
20
(0,0,1)
(0,1,0)
(1,0,0)
(1,1,−1)
Figure 1. Cone containing the lattice points corresponding to
'Z( F 4 'a . Thus g ( ' . (b) Prove that g ' is homogeneous.
(c) Consider lex monomial order with d *d *d . Let ,% g ' be homogeneous of degree and let be the remainder of , on division by the generators of . Prove that can be written ( d 2 d ' . d 2 d 4 ' . d 2 d ' (a) Prove that
d # 27+6+7+6237 2n ')(C to show that I(V . (d) Use part (c) and WF 23 (e) Use parts (b), (c) and (d) to prove that $ ( g ' . Also explain why the generators of are a Gr¨obner basis for the above lex order. 1.1.2. Let - Prove that d"!$# be ad sublattice. & % # O U' ( d r # d)( OsB+2 * , ! 2 s-# * . + Note that when y. , the vectors 2 . , ! have disjoint! support (i.e., no coordinate is , with s-# *%' . positive in both), while this may fail for arbitrary sZ/2 * ' 1.1.3. Let 0 be a toric ideal and let 26+7+6+92 1 be a basis of the sublattice "! . Define 32 ( d 54# # d $4% O (L126+6+7+9/2 + Prove + 0 ( 3276 d 8pd ! . Hint: Given sZ/2 * . , ! with s-# *%. , write s# *( 9 +1 that + , + . This implies > < > < d r ( #f(;: dd $44#%? 4 : dd $ 44# % ? 4 #fm+ < 45= < 4$@ d d Show that multiplying this by ! +' A gives an element of 82 for BC . (By being where + is homogeneous of degree . Also explain why we may assume that the coefficient of + in ,+ is zero for .
more careful, one can show that this result holds for lattice ideals. See [68, Lem. 7.6].)
§1.1. Introduction to Affine Toric Varieties
21
G , 6 2 7 + 6 + 9 + 2 , f I H : G J . This gives a polynomial map 6 ! GMh ! 61H d 27+6+6+72 d ! Je#h H G:J"2 d + j#h , + + Let f ! be the Zariski closure of the image of . (a) Prove that 'B(:?7 '. (b) Explain how this applies to the proof of Proposition 1.1.14. 1.1.5. Let ( p12 `23 1'92 4 ( A 2612 1'92 o (LA 2 26E'92 (Mnm26126#&' be the columns 1.1.4. Fix an affine variety and , which on coordinate rings is given by
of the matrix in Example 1.1.17 and let
g (
+ + O +
+
o
g Uo is a semigroup generated by 2 4 2 o 2 .
be the cone in Figure 1. Prove that
1.1.6. An interesting observation is that different sets of lattice points can parametrize the same affine toric variety, even though these parametrizations behave slightly differently. In this exercise you will consider the parametrizations
4 o and F 1 n 2 n Z ' L ( F 3 2 7 3 2 7 ' 4 F12nn'B(M F o 237 2nd o ' + c o (a) Prove that and both give the affine toric variety ( % # o7'^- . 4 (b) We can regard and as maps 4 61 4 #h and 4 6m 4 #h + Prove that is surjective and that is not. 4 6W ! " . The image of In general, a finite subset gives a rational map # in ! is called a toric set in the literature. Thus A 4 ' and A 4 ' are toric sets. The 4 papers [57] and [85] study when a toric set equals the corresponding affine toric variety.
1.1.7. In Example 1.1.6 and Exercise 1.1.1 we constructed the rational normal cone g using all monomials of degree in 12n . If we drop some of the monomials, things become more complicated. For example, consider the surface parametrized by 2 o 237 o 2n ' + F 1 n 2 n ) ' ( F This gives a toric variety - . Show that the toric ideal of is given by ')( %d $ # &c 2 'c $ 4 # o 2 "d 4 # c 4 $ 2 d 4 # c o fIH d 2 c 2 2 $ J + The toric ideal for g has quadratic generators; by removing the monomial 4 4 , we now
get cubic generators. In Chapter 2 we will use this example to construct a projective curve that is normal but not projectively normal.
B G B F12n 2 S')(MF 2n 2 23,+9P2n 4 o 'a'B ) + (a) Find generators for the toric ideal ( G$'^ BQH d 2 d 2 d 2 d 2 d J . 4 o ) (b) Show that zW{}|-GM(.- . You may assume that Proposition 1.1.8 holds over B . (c) Show that $(0/ d d + d 2 d d 4 d o . o ) 4 o
1.1.8. Instead of working over , we will work over an algebraically closed field *) parametrized by characteristic ( . Consider the affine toric variety
of
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
22
G0 B
G
) has codimension two and can be defined by two equations, i.e., It follows that is a set-theoretic complete intersection. The paper [3] shows that if we replace with an algebrically closed field of characteristic ( , then the above parametrization is never a set-theoretic complete intersection.
B
K
80
f !
!
1.1.9. Prove that a lattice ideal for is a toric ideal if and only if is torsionfree. Hint: When is torsion-free, it can be regarded as the character lattice of a torus. The other direction of the proof is more challenging. If you get stuck, see [68, Thm. 7.4].
!
$( d 4 #fm2 dc # 12 &c # is the lattice ideal for the lattice t(N/> 2 2 'Z' o O 0 :|>z (W8: o +
1.1.10. Prove that
Also compute primary decomposition of to show that is not prime.
~
*~ gives an ] '( !n' ] is a group )jh ] ~ 1|S 23 ' + 1.1.12. Consider tori ~ and ~ with character lattices and . By Example 1.1.13, 4 H J and IH J . Let 6m~ 4 h ~ be a morphism the coordinate rings of ~ and ~ are I 4 4 4 that is a group homomorphism. Then induces maps
6 4 #h and 6mIH 4 Je#Sh IH J
1.1.11. Let be a torus with character lattice . Then every point
. Prove that evaluation map defined by induces a group isomorphism homomorphism and that the map
] 6 h
by composition. Prove that affine semigroups.
is the map of semigroup algebras induced by the map
of
N( ( %( - , :/E W8 t
1.1.13. A commutative semigroup is cancellative if # $ implies - $ for $ all and torsion-free if implies for all and . Prove that is affine if and only if it is finitely generated, cancellative, and torsion-free.
P2 2
Q%(
1.1.14. The requirement that an affine semigroup be finitely generated is important since lattices contain semigroups that are not finitely generated. For example, let be irrational and consider the semigroup
(N/> 2 9'Z', 4 O *8$ 4 +
Prove that is not finitely generated. (When satisfies a quadratic equation with integer coefficients, the generators of are related to continued fractions. For example, when and ( is the golden ratio, the minimal generators of are for , where is the th Fibonacci number. See [95] for further details.) (
(Mn '
nm23 1' 4 2 4 ' (Mm2 `26+7+6+ 1.1.15. Suppose that ] 6, h is a group isomorphism. Fix a finite set and and #" are equivariantly isomorphic let ! ( ]P ' . Prove that the toric varieties (meaning that the isomorphism respects the torus action).
§1.2. Cones and Affine Toric Varieties We begin with a brief discussion of rational polyhedral cones and then explain how they relate to affine toric varieties.
§1.2. Cones and Affine Toric Varieties
23
Convex Polyhedral Cones. Fix a pair of dual vector spaces ; @ and ? @ . Our discussion of cones will omit most proofs—we refer the reader to [30] for more details and [76, App. A.1] for careful statements. See also [10, 38, 87].
@
Definition 1.2.1. A convex polyhedral cone in ?
= 6 R I> 4
where
L ! ? @
U
)
is a set of the form
W
)
! ?@
L
is finite. We say that 6 is generated by . Also set
= I> 4.8 R
.
One easily checks that a convex polyhedral cone 6 is in fact convex, meaning ' . 6 ) ' 4 1R)28 . 6 for all ) , and is a cone, meaning ' . 6 ) ' . 6 for all ) W . Since we will only consider convex cones, the cones satisfying Definition 1.2.1 will be called simply “polyhedral cones.”
that
of polyhedral cones include the first quadrant in = I> 4 ( ( 8 or first octant in . Examples For another example, the cone is pictured ! in Figure 2 below. It is also possible to have cones that contain entire lines. For = I> 4 (4R ( 8 = I> 4 (4R ( 8 ' 4 ' 8 ! is the -axis, is the closed example, while W . upper half-plane
. As we will see below, these last two examples are not strongly convex. We can also create cones using polytopes, which are defined as follows. Definition 1.2.2. A polytope in ?@ is a set of the form
where
L ! ? @
R = I>)4
U
)
is finite. We say that
R ! ?@ L is the convex hull of .
)
W
)
U
z
y
x
Figure 2. Cone in generated by
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
24
Polytopes include all polygons in and bounded polyhedra in . As we will see in later chapters, polytopes play a prominent role in the theory of toric varieties. Here, however, we simply observe that a polytope !? @ gives a polyhedral cone in ?@ by taking the cone
6 R ) 4 8 . ?@
W . R = I>)4
4
If shows what this looks when
.
)
is a pentagon in the plane.
P
Figure 3. Cone over a pentagon
! cone 6 is the dimension of the smallest B9C+B )4 6 8 the span of 6 . ) 4 6 8 6 ofof?Ga@ polyhedral containing 6 . We call Dual Cones and Faces. As usual, the pairing between ; @ and ? @ is denoted K L .
The dimension R B9C+B subspace
Definition 1.2.3. Given a polyhedral cone 6J!?
6 7 R ,. ;J@ K , LXW
@
, its dual cone is defined by
for all
. 6 .
Duality has the following important properties. Proposition 1.2.4. Let 6 4 8 cone in ;J@ and 67 7 R Given ,
RP
O P PU
! ?:@
be a polyhedral cone. Then
6 7
is a polyhedral
.
in ;J@ , we get the hyperplane
O P R
and the closed half-space
Then O and
6
. ? @
O PU R . ? @
K, L R ! ? @
L W ! ?@ K, X
O PU
is a supporting hyperplane of a polyhedral cone 6 ! ? @ if 6 ! , O P is a supporting half-space. Note that is a supporting hyperplane of 6
§1.2. Cones and Affine Toric Varieties
25
if and only if , . 6N7QS . Furthermore, if straightforward to check that
U 6 R O P 9
(1.2.1)
, ( , "
generate
6N7
, then it is
U 9 O P
Thus every polyhedral cone is an intersection of finitely many closed half-spaces. We can use supporting hyperplanes and half-spaces to define faces of a cone.
OP 9 6 H RP 6
Definition 1.2.5. A face of a cone of the polyhedral cone 6 is H R some , . 6 7 . Using , R shows that 6 is a face of itself. Faces called proper faces.
for are
The faces of a polyhedral cone have the following obvious properties. Lemma 1.2.6. Let 6
R = I> 4
be a polyhedral cone. Then:
(a) Every face of 6 is a polyhedral cone.
(b) An intersection of two faces of 6 is again a face of 6 . (c) A face of a face of 6 is again a face of 6 .
You will prove the following useful property of faces in Exercise 1.2.1.
Lemma 1.2.7. Let H be a face of a polyhedral cone 6 . If . H. then
. 6
!
and
R
. H
,
H R A facet of 6 is a face H of codimension 1, i.e., 6 . An edge of 6 is a face of dimension 1. In Figure 4 we illustrate a 3-dimensional cone with shaded facets and a supporting hyperplane (a plane in this case) that cuts out the vertical edge of the cone.
σ
supporting hyperplane
Figure 4. A cone
with shaded facets and a hyperplane supporting an edge
Here are some properties of facets.
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
26
+ ! ?:@ be a polyhedral cone. Then:
! R P If 6 / and the facets of 6 are H ' R O 96 for , ' . 6 7 ,
Proposition 1.2.8. Let 6 (a)
then
U 6 R O P 9
U 9 O P
= 6 7 R I> 4 , ( , " 8 (b) Every proper face H of 6 is the intersection of the facets of 6 containing H .
! R ! @ Note how part (a) of+ the proposition refines (1.2.1) when 6 +?
,
and
When working in
.
. From , dot product allows us to identify the dual with ( , " in part (a) of the proposition are facet this point of view, the vectors , normals, i.e., perpendicular to the facets. This makes it easy to compute examples. Example 1.2.9. It easy to see that the facet normals to the cone 6 ( R ( , R , R , R ( R . Hence are ,
= 6 7 R I> 4 ( (
!
in Figure 2
%R 8 !
This is the cone of Figure 1 at the end of §1.1 whose lattice points describe the 354 ' R S8 (see Example 1.1.17). As we semigroup of the affine toric variety will see, this is part of how cones describe normal affine toric varieties.
Now consider 6N7 , which is the cone in Figure 1. The reader can check that the ( ( . Using duality and part (b) of facet normals of this cone are Proposition 1.2.8, we obtain
= 6 R 4 6 7 8 7 R I> 4 ( ( Hence we recover our original description of 6 .
8
In this example, facets of the cone correspond to edges of its dual. More generally, given a face H of a polyhedral cone 6J! ? @ , we define
H I R , . V ; @ K , L R for all . H H M R , . 6 7 K , L R for all . H R 6 7 9 HI We call H M the dual face of H because of the following proposition. Proposition 1.2.10. If H is a face of a polyhedral cone 6 and H M R 6 7 9 H0I , then: (a) H0M is a face of 6N7 . H M is a bijective inclusion-reversing correspondence between (b) The map H the faces of 6 and the faces of 687 .
! H ! H M R (c) /.
!
Here is an example of Proposition 1.2.10 when 6 ! ? @ .
§1.2. Cones and Affine Toric Varieties
27
z
z
y
y
x
x σ
σ
Figure 5. A -dimensional cone
= I> 4 ( 8
and its dual
! Example 1.2.11. Let 6 R . Figure 5 shows 6 and 687 . You should check that the maximal face of 6 , namely 6 itself, gives the minimal face 6 M of 67 , namely the -axis. Note also that
even though
6
! 6
has dimension .
! M R 6
Relative Interiors. As already noted, the span of a cone 6 ! ? @ is the smallest C D 4 6 8 , is subspace of ?G@ containing 6 . Then the relative interior of 6 , denoted C D 4 8 6 as follows: the interior of 6 in its span. Exercise 1.2.2 will characterize
. C D 4 6 8 K , L for all ,. 6 7 S 6 I EF D4 6 8 When the span equals ?G@ , the relative interior is just the interior, denoted . H For an example of how relative interiors arise naturally, let be a face of a cone 6 . This gives the dual face H M R 67Q9 H I of 67 . Furthermore, if , . 687 ,
then one easily sees that
H ! O P 9 6 , . 6 7 , then In Exercise 1.2.2, you will show that if H R O P 9 6 ,. CX D 4 H M 8 C D 4 H M 8 Thus the relative interior tells us exactly which supporting hyperplanes H of 6 cut out the face . ,. H M
Strong Convexity. Of the cones shown in Figures 1–5, all but 6 7 in Figure 5 have the nice property that the origin is a face. Such cones are called strongly convex. This condition can be stated several ways.
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
28 Proposition 1.2.12. Let 6J!
6
is strongly convex
+ ?:@ 6
be a polyhedral cone. Then:
is a face of 6
contains no positive-dimensional subspace of ?
6T9 4FR 6 8 R
7 R 6 /
@
You will prove Proposition 1.2.12 in Exercise 1.2.3. One corollary is that if a polyhedral cone 6 is strongly convex of maximal dimension, then so is 6 7 . The cones pictured in Figures 1–4 satisfy this condition.
In general, a polyhedral cone 6 always has a minimal face that is the largest subspace contained in 6 . Furthermore:
R 6T9 F4 R 6 8 . R O P 9-6
6 R 6
whenever ,.
! ? @
C D 4 6 7 8 .
is a strongly convex polyhedral cone.
See Exercise 1.2.4. Separation. When two cones intersect in a face of each, we can separate the cones with the following result, often called the Separation Lemma.
(
Lemma 1.2.13 (Separation Lemma). Let 6 6 ( meet along a common face H R 6 9 6 . Then
be polyhedral cones in
H R O P 9 6 ( R O P 9 6 XC D 4 6 (7 9 4FR 6 8 7 8 . for any ,. R * R * . ! ?G@ , we set R Proof. Given
.
? @
that
. A standard
result from cone theory tells us that
6 (7 9 F4 R 6 8 7 R 4 6 ( R 6 8 7 C D4 6 (7 9 4FR 6 8 7 8 . The above equation and Exercise 1.2.4 imply Now fix ,. O P ( R 6 , i.e., that cuts out the minimal face of 6 O P 9 46 ( R 6 8 R 46 ( R 6 8 9 46 R 6 ( 8 However, we also have
4 6 ( R 6 8 9 4 6 %R 6 ( 8 R H R H ( One inclusion is obvious since H R 6 9V6 . For the other inclusion, write . 4 6 ( R 6 8 9 4 6 %R 6 ( 8 as * ( R * R XR ( * ( ( . 6 ( * . 6 R ( * ( ( R * Then that this element lies in H R 6 9 6 . Since (* ( . 6 ( , we have * ( ( implies . H by Lemma 1.2.7, and * . H follows similarly. ( R . H R H * * R Hence , as desired.
§1.2. Cones and Affine Toric Varieties
We conclude that
29
OTP 9 4 6 ( R 6 8 R H R H ( . Intersecting with 6 , we obtain O P 9 6 ( R 4H R H 8 9 6 ( R H
where the last equality again uses Lemma 1.2.7 (Exercise 1.2.5). If instead we R intersect with 6 , we obtain and
O P 9 F4 R 6 8 R H
O P 9 F4 R 6 8 R 4 H R H 8 9 F4 R 6 8 R R H follows.
O P
In the situation of Lemma 1.2.13 we call
a separating hyperplane.
and ; be dual+ lattices with associated vector * . For we usually use the lattice + . ; + = I> 4
Rational Polyhedral Cones. Let ? * and ;J@ R spaces ? @ R ?
The cones appearing in Figures 1, 2 and 5 are rational. We note without proof that faces and duals of rational polyhedral cones are rational. Furthermore, if 6 R = I> 4
6 9 ?
/
R &
U
)
)
W
in
One new feature is that a strongly convex rational polyedral cone 6 has a canonical generating set, constructed as follows. Let be an edge of 6 . Since 6 is strongly convex, is a ray, i.e., a half-line, and since is rational, the semigroup T9J? is generated by a unique element of the intersection. We call the ray generator of . Figure 6 shows the ray generator of a rational ray in the plane. The dots are the lattice ? R and the white ones are 9 ? . ←ρ
↑ ray generator
Figure 6. A rational ray
and its unique ray generator
Lemma 1.2.15. A strongly convex rational polyhedral cone is generated by the ray generators of its edges.
It is customary to call the ray generators of the edges the minimal generators of a strongly convex rational polyhedral cone. Figures 1 and 2 show -dimensional strongly convex rational polyhedral cones and their ray generators.
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
30
In a similar way, a rational polyhedral cone 6 of maximal dimension has unique facet normals, which are the ray generators of the dual 6 7 , which is strongly convex by Proposition 1.2.12. Here are some especially important strongly convex cones. Definition 1.2.16. Let 6J! (a) (b)
6
? @
be a strongly convex rational polyhedral cone.
is smooth or regular if its minimal generators form part of a -basis of ? ,
6
is simplicial if its minimal generators are linearly independent over .
The cones pictured in Figure 5 are smooth, while those in Figures 1 and 2 are not even simplicial. Note also that the dual of a smooth (resp. simplicial) cone is again smooth (resp. simplicial). Later in the section we will give examples of simplicial cones that are not smooth. Semigroup Algebras and Affine Toric Varieties. Given a rational polyhedral cone 6J! ? @ , the lattice points
23 R 7 6 9-;
!;
form a semigroup. A key fact is that this semigroup is finitely generated. Proposition 1.2.17 (Gordan’s Lemma). hence is an affine semigroup.
2 3 R 6 7 9J;
is finitely generated and
= I> 4 8
Proof. Since 6 7 is rational polyhedral, 6 7 R for a finite set + ! ; . P P
, so that P R ,
& + Then
is a bounded region of ; @ 2 3 4 8 . Note that .
9 ; is finite since ;
9-; !
*
4
9 ; 8 generates 2+3 as a semigroup. To prove this, take R & P * )P , where )0P W . Then )+P R )0P P with . P , so that 0 ) P R P * )0P , P * P , The second sum is in 9X; (remember . ; ). It follows that is a nonnegative 4 9 ; 8. integer combination of elements of
We claim 23 and write . and
+ Theorem 1.2.18. Let 6 ! ?:@ 23
Since affine semigroups give affine toric varieties, we get the following.
R 67:9-;
. Then 4
be a rational polyhedral cone with semigroup
3 R BC D47A% 2 3 - 8 R B9C D47&% 7 6 9 ; -8
is an affine toric variety. Furthermore,
4
3 R /
the torus of
4
3
is
5 R ? *S M
6
is strongly convex
§1.2. Cones and Affine Toric Varieties
31 4
Proof. By Gordan’s Lemma and Proposition 1.1.14, 2 3 whose torus has character lattice !; . To study
3
2 3 is an affine toric variety , note that 203 R 203 R 23 R , ( R , , ( , . 23 .
+ 2 3
and ,. ; . Then , R , ( R , Now suppose that , . for some ( , . 2 3 R 6 7 9 ; . Since , ( and , lie in the convex set 6 7 , we have for , ( ( , , R , ( " , . 6 7 203 4 , 8 R , . 23 , so that ; It follows that , R , is torsion-free. Hence 5 203 R B 23 R 4 3 ; / (1.2.3) the torus of is
! 7 R Since 6 is strongly convex if and only if 6 / (Proposition 1.2.12), it remains to show that
!
4
3 R /
B 2 3 R /
7 R 6 /
The first equivalence follows since the dimension of an affine toric variety is the dimension of its torus, which is the rank of its character lattice. We leave the proof of the second equivalence to the reader (Exercise 1.2.6).
5
Since we want our affine toric varieties to contain the torus , we consider 4 3 only those affine toric varieties for which 6 !? @ is strongly convex. Our first example of Theorem 1.2.18 is an affine toric variety we know well.
= I> 4 ( (
8
Example 1.2.19. Let 6 R ! ?@ R with ? R . This is the cone pictured in Figure 2. By Example 1.2.9, 6 7 is the cone pictured in Figure 1, and by Example 1.1.17, the lattice points in this cone are generated 4 3 by columns of matrix (1.1.6). It follows from Example 1.1.17 that is the affine 5 3 4 ' R 8 . toric variety
+ / and set 6 R = >I 4 ( 8 ! = 6 7 R >I 4 ( U ( + 8
Here are two further examples of Theorem 1.2.18. Example 1.2.20. Fix
3 R BC D.47A% ')( *' * ' 1 U ( ( *' +1 ( - 8 R 5 47 M 8 + " + (Exercise 1.2.7). This implies the general fact that if 6 ! ? @ + 4 3 547 M 8 " . cone of dimension , then and the corresponding affine toric variety is 4
. Then
is a smooth
R and / R . = >I 4 % ( R 8 ! . @ Example 1.2.21. Fix a positive integer @ and let 6 R = I> 4 ( ( 8 This has dual cone 6 7 R 7 on the next page shows 6 7 L 3 @ . Figure R R when @ . The affine semigroup 6 7 9 is generated by the lattice points Figure 5 illustrates the cones in Example 1.2.20 when
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
32
Figure 7. The cone
4 8
when
"
@ . When @ R , these are the white dots in Figure 7. (You will for prove these assertions in Exercise 1.2.8.)
By §1.1, the variety 47 M 8 affine ? U ( toric map defined by
4
3
is the Zariski closure of the image of the
4 8 R 4 . ? 8
4 8 4 ? ? " ( ? " ( ? 8 This map has the same image as the map ?U ( ? 4 3 used ! in Example 1.1.6. Thus is isomorphic to the rational normal cone minors of the matrix whose ideal is generated by the ' ')( '2? " ',? " ( ')( ' '2? " ( ',? Note that the cones
6
and 6
7
are simplicial but not smooth.
We will return to this example often. One thing evident in Example 1.1.6 is the difference between cone generators and semigroup the cone 6 7 has L 3 R 6 7 9 has generators: two generators but the semigroup @ .
L 3
R 67Q9 ; When 6 ! ? @ has maximal dimension, the semigroup unique minimal generating set constructed as follows. Define an element , 23 Z , Z Z for , Z7 , Z Z . 23 implies , Z R or , to be irreducible if , R ,
Proposition 1.2.22. Let 6 23 R 6 7 9-; . Then
<
! ?:@
<
(a) (b) (c)
<
<
be strongly convex of maximal dimension and let
R , . 23 ,
has the following properties: is finite and generates
2+3
has a
R P of ZZ R .
.
is irreducible
contains the ray generators of the edges of 6
is the minimal generating set of
2 3
7
.
with respect to inclusion.
§1.2. Cones and Affine Toric Varieties
33
Proof. Proposition 1.2.12 implies that 6 element . 6 9-? S such that K , and only if , R .
7
is strongly convex, so we can find an L . for all ,. 2 3 and K , L R if
203
Now suppose that , . 3 irreducible. Then Z Z are nonzero elements ofis2 not and , . It follows that
Z K, L R K, L
K,
, R , Z
, ZZ
where
, Z
ZZ L
K , Z L K , Z Z L . SX , so that Z ZZ K , L K , L and K , L K , L 2 3 Using induction on K , L , we conclude that every element of is a sum of irre< 2 3 ducible elements, so that generates . Furthermore, using a finite generating < 203 with
set of , one easily sees that is finite. This proves part (a). The remaining parts of the proof are covered in Exercise 1.2.9.
<
203
2 3
! The set 2+is3 called the Hilbert basis of and its elements are the minimal generators of . Algorithms for computing Hilbert bases are discussed in [68, 7.3] and [97, Ch. 13]. Exercises for §1.2.
( for . 1.2.2. Here are some properties of relative interiors. Let be a cone. (a) Show that if , then ? }{ 5' if and only if 2 for all . (b) Let be a face of and fix . Prove that .? { E ' ( S+
1.2.1. Prove Lemma 1.2.7. Hint: Write
1.2.3. Prove Proposition 1.2.12. 1.2.4. Let
be a polyhedral cone.
(a) Use Proposition 1.2.10 to prove that has a unique minimal face with respect to inclusion. Let denote this minimal face.
( ' . # 5' . (d) Prove that ( p (e) Fix . Prove that ?. { & ' if and only if ( . (f) Prove that (e Q is a strongly convex polyhedral cone. 1.2.5. Let be a face of a polyhedral cone and let U# be defined as in the proof of Lemma 1.2.13. Prove that (L U# ' . Also show that # (<> = ' , i.e., y# is the smallest subspace of containing . 1.2.6. Fix a lattice and let <>= ! eFB' denote the span over of a subset .! . (a) Let ! be finite. Prove that "! $# U (*zW{ |*<>%= 5FB' . (b) Prove that (c) Prove that
is the largest subspace contained in .
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
34
z`{ | ! `? F)')(*zW{}|V<W= e )'
(b) Let ! be finite. Prove that . (c) Use parts (a) and (b) to complete the proof of Theorem 1.2.18. 1.2.7. Prove the assertions made in Example 1.2.20. 1.2.8. Prove the assertions made in Example 1.2.21. Hint: First show that when a cone is smooth, the ray generators of the cone also generate the corresponding semigroup. Then write the cone of Example 1.2.21 as a union of such cones.
/E `8 ( 1.2.10. Let V be a cone generated by a set of linearly independent vectors in .
1.2.9. Complete the proof of Proposition 1.2.22. Hint for part (b): Show that the ray generators of the edges of are irreducible in . Given an edge of , it will help to pick such that . Show that
is strongly convex and simplicial.
1.2.11. Explain the picture illustrated in Figure 8 in terms of Proposition 1.2.8.
σ ↑
σ ↑
→
↑ Figure 8. A cone
in the plane and its dual
1.2.12. Let be a polytope lying in an affine hyperplane (= translate of a hyperplane) not containing the origin. Generalize Figure 3 by showing that gives a convex polyhedral cone in . Draw a picture.
( ! `?1 - # ( 4 2 '^ 4 . (a) Describe and find generators of 4 . Draw a picture similar to Figure 7. (b) Compute the toric ideal of the affine toric variety and explain how this exercise relates to Exercise 1.1.6. 1.2.14. Consider the simplicial cone ( ! ?1 2 4 2 4 ( o '^Po . (a) Describe and find generators of o . (b) Compute the toric ideal of the affine toric variety . 1.2.15. Let be a strongly convex polyhedral cone of maximal dimension. Here is an example taken from [30, p. 132] to show that and need not have the same number of be the cone generated by ( + for all 2 , ( T . edges. Let (a) Show that has 12 edges. 9 + , and has 8 edges. (b) Show that is generated by + and # + ( 1.2.13. Consider the cone
§1.3. Properties of Affine Toric Varieties The final task of this chapter is to explore the properties of affine toric varieties. We will also study maps between affine toric varieties.
§1.3. Properties of Affine Toric Varieties
35
Points of Affine Toric Varieties. We first consider various ways to describe the points of an affine toric variety.
B9C D.47&% 2 - 8
;
R Proposition 1.3.1. Let be the affine toric variety of the affine 2 semigroup . Then there are bijective correspondences between the following: . ;
(a) Points
.
(b) Maximal ideals
! A% 2 .
2
(c) Semigroup homomorphisms under multiplication.
, where
is considered as a semigroup
Proof. The correspondence between (a) and (b) is standard (see [17, Thm. 5 of Ch. 5, §4]). The correspondence between (a) and (c) is special to the toric case. P
;
. P , define Given a point ' . A% 2 This makes sense since semigroup homomorphism.
by sending , . 2 to ' 4 8 . . A > % R ;S- . One easily checks that 2 is a
2
2
P Going 2 let the other way, F % P
is a basis of ,
be a semigroup homomorphism. Since F% 2 - which is induces a surjective linear map A% 2 - is a maximal ideal a -algebra homomorphism. The kernel of the map ; and thus gives a point . by the correspondence between (a) and (b). '
2 $ R , ( , " as follows. Let generate , so " concretely " 4 4 ( 8 4 8 * 8 , " . . Let us prove that . ; . . Let R , ! ' R ' vanishes at for all exponent By Proposition 1.1.9, it suffices to show that " R 4 * ( * " 8 4 ( * * " 8 satisfying vectors and R
; that R
We construct 3
"
This is easy, since
'( (
* ',-' R
"
' ,-' ( ' (
being a semigroup homomorphism implies that
" " " ( 4 ,-' 8 R ( * ' ,-' R ( ' ,-' R ( 4 ,-' 8 )' ( ' ( ' ( ' (
"
It is straightforward to show that this point of the previous paragraph (Exercise 1.3.1).
;
agrees with the one constructed in
;
As an application of this result, we describe the torus action on . In terms ; R "3 ! " , the proof of Proposition 1.1.8 shows that the of the embedding 5 3 is induced by the usual action of 47 M 8 " on " . But how do we action of on see the action instrinsically, without embedding into affine space? This is where 5 and . ; , and let semigroup homomorphisms prove their value. Fix . 4 , 8 . In ExerciseP 1.3.1 you will correspond to the semigroup homorphism , ' 4 8 4 , 8 . This show that is given by the semigroup homomorphism , abstract description will prove useful in Chapter 3 when we study the orbits of the torus action.
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
36
5
;
From the point of view of group actions, the action of on is given by a 5 ; ; . Since both sides are affine varieties, this should map be a morphism, meaning that it should come from a -algebra homomorphism
A% 2 - R A%>;S-NR A% 5 ; - R &% 5 - 1&A%>;S- R F % ; - 1=A% 2 -< P P P
This homomorphism is given by
'
'
'
for ,.
2
(Exercise 1.3.2).
We can also characterize those affine toric varieties for which the torus action 2 2 4FR 2 8 R , has a fixed point. We say that an affine semigroup is pointed if 9
2 i.e., if is the only element of with an inverse. This is the semigroup analog of being strongly convex. Proposition 1.3.2. Let
;
be an affine toric variety. Then:
; BC D.47F% 2 - 8 , then the torus action has a fixed point if and only (a) If we write R 2 if is pointed, in which case the unique fixed point is given by the semigroup 2 homomorphism defined by
, R R , (1.3.1) , RP ; "3 ! " for $ ! 2 S , then the torus action has a fixed (b) If we write R 3 point if and only if . , in which case the unique fixed point is . ; be represented by the semigroup Proof. For part (a), let . 2 8 4, 8 R 4, 8 . Then is fixed by the torus action if and only if ' P 4 homomorphism 2 5 4 8 for all , . and . . This equation P 4 8 is satisfied for , R4 8 since R , ' R P shows that , R . Thus, if a and if , R P , then picking with
fixed point exists, then it is unique and is given by (1.3.1). Then we are done since 2 (1.3.1) is a semigroup homomorphism if and only if is pointed.
; 3 ! " has a fixed point, in which case (b), first assume that R 2 R For $ part $ ! 2 S is pointed and the unique point is given by (1.3.1). Then " 3 . and the proof of Proposition 1.3.1 imply that is the origin in , so that . " 5 7 4 F 8 " 7 4 F 8 " M . ! The converse follows since . is fixed by M hence by ; R 4 3 When
, we can state Proposition 1.3.2 as follows (Exercise 1.3.3).
Corollary 1.3.3. Let 6J!?G@ be a strongly convex polyhedral cone. Then the torus
! R ! 4 3 action on has a fixed point if and only if 6 ?:@ , in which case the fixed point is unique and is given by the maximal ideal
K'
where as usual
203 R 67:9 ;
P
,. 2 3 S L ! &% 23 -<
.
We will see in Chapter 3 that this corollary is part of the correspondence be4 3 tween torus orbits of and faces of 6 .
§1.3. Properties of Affine Toric Varieties
37
Normality and Saturation. We next study the question of when an affine toric ; variety is normal. We need one definition before stating our normality criterion.
2
Definition 1.3.4. An affine semigroup 2 2 and ,. ; , ,. implies ,. .
! ;
is saturated if for all
. S
2 3 R For example, if 6 ! ?G@ is a strongly convex rational polyhedral cone, then 6 7 9-; is easily seen to be saturated (Exercise 1.3.4). ; 5
Theorem 1.3.5. Let are equivalent: (a)
;
be an affine toric variety with torus
. Then the following
is normal.
; R B C D47A% 2 - 8 , where 2 !; is a saturated affine semigroup. (b) ; R BC D.47&%>L 3 - 8 4 R 4 3 8 , where 203 R 6 7 9 ; and 6 ! ? @ (c) convex rational polyhedral cone.
BC D47A% 2 - 8
;
is a strongly
2
Proof. By Theorem 1.1.16, R for an affine semigroup contained ; has the character lattice in a lattice, and by Proposition 1.1.14, the torus of + 2
! ; . Also let / R , so that ; . We will use this to prove (a) ; R (b) (c).
;
F% 2 -
A%>;S-
R (a) (b): If is normal, then is integrally closed in its field 2 A < 4 & ; 8 S& and , . ; . , . of fractions . Suppose that for some . P' 5 ; Then is a polynomial function on and hence a rational function on since P 5P ! ; is Zariski open. We also have ' . P F% 2 - since , . 2 . It follows that ' R ' F% 2 - . By the is a root of the monic polynomial in P A% 2 - with2 coefficients 2 ' . definition of normal, we obtain , i.e., ,. . Thus is saturated. 2
$
2
2
(b) (c): Let rational = I> ! 4 $ 8 be a finite generating B %$ setR of . Then !lies = inI> the 4 $ 8 R / ! ; @ , and = I> 4 $ 8 / implies polyhedral cone 7 ! ? @ is a strongly convex by Exercise 1.2.6. It follows that 6 R 2 rational polyhedral cone such that ! 6 7 9; . In Exercise 1.3.4 you will prove 2 2 2 3 . that equality holds when is saturated. Hence R
F% 2 3 -
&%
-
R 6 7 9T; is normal when 6J! ?G@ (c) (a): We need to show that ( be the rays of 6 . Since is a strongly convex rational polyhedral cone. Let 6 is generated by its rays (Lemma 1.2.15), we have Intersecting with ;
gives
2 3 R
'7 ( ' (
6 7 R
(2 ')( , which easily implies
F% 23 - R F%>L 3 -
')( (
F% 2 7 -<
&% 2 -
By Exercise 1.0.7, is normal if each is normal, so it suffices to prove 2 A % that is normal when is a rational ray in ?:@ . Let . Q9V? be the ray
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
38
(
generator of . Since is primitive, i.e, . ? for all , we can find a ( + of ? with R ( (Exercise basis 1.3.5). Thus we can assume that R = I> 4 ( 8 , so that ( (
% 2 - R F% ')(*'V1 *' +1 F &% ' ( *' + - is normal (it is a UFD), so its localization by Example 1.2.20. But A% ')( *' +.- R A% ')(*' 1 ( *' +1 ( 354 ' R 8
is also normal by Exercise 1.0.7. This completes the proof.
;
Example 1.3.6. We saw in Example 1.2.19 that R is the affine toric = I> 4 ( . ( 8 4 3 R of the cone 6 variety pictured in Figure 1. Then ; Theorem 1.3.5 implies that is normal, as claimed in Example 1.1.5. ? (
? ! U
Example 1.3.7. By Example 1.2.21, the rational normal cone is the affine toric variety of a strongly convex rational polyhedral cone and hence is normal by Theorem 1.3.5. It is instructive to view this example ? ? using ? ( ? ( the parametrization
4 . 8 R 4 " " 8 3
$
from Example 1.1.6. Plotting the lattice points in for @ R white 2 gives #$ the squares in Figure 9 (a) below. These generate the semigroup R , and the = I> 4 ( 8 , which is the first quadproof of Theorem 1.3.5 gives the cone 6 7 R rant in the figure. At first glance, something seems wrong. The affine variety is normal, yet in Figure 9 (a) the semigroup generated by the white squares misses some lattice points in 6 7 . This semigroup does not look saturated. How can the affine toric variety be normal?
σ
(a)
σ
(b)
Figure 9. Lattice points for the rational normal cone
The problem is that we are using the wrong lattice! Proposition 1.1.8 tells us %$ to use the lattice , which gives the white dots and squares in Figure 9 (b). This figure shows that the white squares generate the semigroup of lattice points in 6 7 . 2 Hence is saturated and everything is fine.
§1.3. Properties of Affine Toric Varieties
39
This example points out the importance of working with the correct lattice. The Normalization of an Affine Toric Variety. The normalization of an affine toric ; BC D47&% 2 - 8 for an affine semigroup 2 , so that variety is easy to describe. Let R 2 = I> 4 2 8 ; the torus of has character lattice ; R . Let denote the cone of any 2 = I> 4 2 8 R 7 !? @ . In Exercise 1.3.6 you will finite generating set of and set 6 prove the following. Proposition 1.3.8. The above cone 6 is a strongly convex rational polyhedral cone F% 2 - ! A% 687A9 ; - induces a morphism 4 3 ; that is in ? @ and the inclusion ; the normalization map of .
3
The normalization of an affine toric variety of the form is constructed by 1$ %$ applying Proposition 1.3.8 to the affine semigroup and the lattice . Example 1.3.9.
. Then considered in Exercise 1.1.7. This is almost
$ R 4 8 4 8 4 8 4 8 ! Let 3 4 8 R 4 8 3 !
parametrizes the surface ( 4 rational the normal cone , except that we have omitted 8 4 8 , we see that 1$ is not saturated, so that
3
4 .8 R
. Using is not normal.
3
is . This Applying Proposition 1.3.8, one sees that the normalization of , and the normalization map is induced by the is an affine variety in obvious projection .
In Chapter 3 we will see that the normalization map Proposition 1.3.8 is onto but not necessarily one-to-one.
4
3
;
constructed in
Smooth Affine Toric Varieties. Our next goal is to characterize when an affine toric variety is smooth. Since smooth affine varieties are normal (Proposition 1.0.9), 4 3 we need only consider toric varieties coming from strongly convex rational polyhedral cones 6J! ?G@ .
3
We first study when 6 has maximal dimension. Then 6 7 is strongly convex, < 203 R so that 6 7 9 ; has a Hilbert basis . Furthermore, Corollary 1.3.3 tells us 3 . 4 3 4 3 that the torus action on has a unique fixed point, denoted here by . The < 3 point and the Hilbert basis are related as follows. 4
Lemma 1.3.10. Let 6 !?G@ be a strongly convex rational polyhedral cone of 4 4 3 8 be the Zariski tangent space to the affine toric maximal dimension and let 3
! 4 4 3 8 R < 4 3 variety at the above point . Then .
A%>L 3 -
Proof. 1.3.3, the maximal ideal of corresponding to P By Corollary P ,. 23 SX L . Since ' P is a basis of F%>L 3 - , we obtain K'
R ' P R P P(
%' P
irreducible
P
%' P R ' P P
reducible
3
is
R
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
40
It follows that local ring
!
R <
. To relate this to the maximal ideal , we use the natural map
in the
4 4 3 8 is the dual space which is always an isomorphism (Exercise 1.3.7). Since < 3 of . , we see that ! 4 4 8 R < L 3 gives 4 3 R ! " , where R < . This The Hilbert basis of 4 3 affine embedding is especially nice. Given any affine embedding , we
! 4 4 3 8
! 4 4 3 8 have by Lemma 1.0.6. In other words, is a lower
R
bound on the dimension of an affine embedding. Then Lemma 1.3.10 shows that 2 3 when 6 has maximal dimension, the Hilbert basis of gives the most efficient 4 3 affine embedding of .
?
Example In Example 1.2.21, we saw that the rational normal cone = I> 4 (1R 8 ? U ( is the1.3.11. and that! toric variety coming from 6 R @ ! 23 R 4 8 for @ . These generators form the 67T9 is generated by 2+3 ? Hilbert basis of? ( , so that the Zariski tangent space of . has dimension U ? @ . Hence in the smallest affine space in which we can embed .
We now come to our main result about smoothness. Recall from §1.2 that a rational polyhedral cone is smooth if it can be generated by a subset of a basis of the lattice. Theorem 1.3.12. Let 6 ! ?G@ be a strongly convex rational polyhedral cone. 4 3 is smooth if and only if 6 is smooth. Furthermore, all smooth affine toric Then varieties are of this form. Proof. If an affine toric variety is smooth, then it is normal by Proposition 1.0.9 4 3 and hence of the form . Also, Example 1.2.20 implies that if 6 is smooth as 4 3 a cone, then is smooth as a variety. It remains to prove the converse. So fix 3 3
6J! ? @ such that 4 is smooth. Let / R ! 4 R ! ? @ .
3
3
. First suppose that 6 has dimension / and let be the point studied in 3 4 3 4 4 3 8 has Lemma 1.3.10. Since is smooth in , the Zariski tangent space dimension / by Definition 1.0.7. On the other hand, Lemma 1.3.10 implies that < 2 3 R
4 4 3 8 67G9-; . Thus is the cardinality of the Hilbert basis of / R <
W
edges
4
! 6 7 W /
where the first inequality holds by Proposition 1.2.22 (each edge ! 6 7 con<
! 6 7 R / . It follows tributes an element of < ) and the second holds since that 6 has / edges and consists of the ray generators of these edges. Since+ 203 R ; by (1.2.3), the / edge generators of 6 7 generate the lattice ; 4 8 and hence form a basis of ; . Thus 6 7 is smooth, and then 6 R 6 7 7 is smooth since duality preserves smoothness.
§1.3. Properties of Affine Toric Varieties
( ?
? ? ?
!
41
6 R / . We reduce to the previous case as follows. Let Next suppose ! ( ? be the smallest saturated sublattice containing the generators of 6 . Then by Exercise is torsion-free, which B 1.3.5 implies the B existence of a sublattice ! ? with ? R ? ( ? . Note ? ( R and ? R / R0 .
4 (8
3 5
The cone 6 lies in both ? @ and ? @ . This gives affine toric varieties 4 3 5 ( R ? ? induces and and / respectively. Furthermore, ? ( of dimensions ( ;23 5 R ; ( ; 2, 3 so 5 that 6 ! 4 ? 8 @ and 6 ! ? @ give the affine semigroups ! ; and !; respectively. It is straighforward to show that
4
234 5 R 23 5
;
which in terms of semigroup algebras can be written
F% 2034 5 - F% 23 5 - 1=F% ; <- 34 5 5 43 5 + 5
The right-hand side is the coordinate ring of 4
(1.3.2)
3 5
4
4
. Thus
3 5 5 47 M 8 + " ! 4 3 5 + " +" 4 34 5 4 34 5 & Since we are assuming that it follows that is smooth 4 .8 in 4 3 5 0 547 M is8 + smooth, " . In Exercise at any point 1.3.8 you will show that +" 4 3 5 0 4 .8 R 4 34 5 is smooth at is smooth at (1.3.3) 3 . 4 3 5 ( since Letting R , the previous case implies that 6 is smooth in ?
R ! 4 ( 8 6 ? @ . Hence 6 is clearly smooth in ? R ? ( ? . ; ( ; which in turn implies that 4
3 5
4
Equivariant Maps between Affine Toric Varieties. We next study maps ;T( and ; . between affine toric varieties that respect the torus actions on
BC D.47A% 2 - 8
;
' be the affine toric varieties coming from Definition 1.3.13. Let ' R 2 ' R ;)( ; is toric if the affine semigroups , . Then a morphism 2 A% -1 &% 2 ( - is induced by a the corresponding map of coordinate rings M 2 2 ( semigroup homomorphism .
Here is our first result concerning toric morphisms.
5
be the torus of the affine toric variety ;
;)( ; (a) A morphism
Proposition 1.3.14. Let
is toric if and only if
4 5 8 ! 5
-* , 5 5 is a group homomorphism. ; ( ; is equivariant, meaning that (b) A toric morphism 4 8 R 48 4 8 5 and . ;( . for all . and
' , R
.
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
42
BC D47A% 2 - 8
;
5
2
' , so that the character lattice of ' . If Proof. Let ' R is ; ' R 2 2 ( comes from a semigroup homomorphism , then extends to a group ; ; ( and hence gives a commutative diagram homomorphism
A% 2 - R
&% ; - R BC D , we see that 4 5 8 ! Applying 5 R , I..*4 ; homomorphism since
A% 2 ( -
F% ; ( -<
, and -* , 5 Q 5 is a group ' J M 8 by Exercise 1.1.11. Conversely, if satisfies these conditions, then */, 5 : 5 induces a diagram as above ; ; ( . This, where the bottom map comes from a group homomorphism 47A% 2 - 8 ! F% 2 ( - , implies that induces a semigroup homomorcombined with M 2 2 ( phism . This proves part (a) of the proposition. ; ( ; . The action of 5 For part (b), suppose that we have a toric map 5 ; ' R+ ; ' , and equivariance means that ; on ' is given by a morphism ' we have a commutative diagram
;
5
5
5 ;V(
;V( /
5 ;
; /
* ,
/* , 5 is
If we replace ' with in the diagram, then it certainly commutes since 5 is a group homomorphism. Then the whole diagram commutes since 5 ;V( . Zariski dense in
We can also characterize toric morphisms between affine toric varieties coming from strongly convex rational polyhedral cones. First note that a homomorphism 5 5 of tori. ? ( ? of lattices a group homomorphism 5 R gives * This follows from one sees that is a morphism. Also, ? ' 4 ( 8 M , and 4 ? @ ? 8 @ . tensoring with gives @
Here is the result, whose proof we leave to the reader (Exercise 1.3.9).
Proposition 1.3.15. Suppose we have strongly convex rational polyhedral cones 5 5 6 ' ! 4 ? ' 8 @ and a homomorphism4 3 ? (X4 3 ? . Then 4 X ( 8 extends to a map of affine toric varieties if and only if @ 6 ! 6 .
In the remainder of the chapter we explore some interesting classes of toric morphisms. Faces and Affine Open Subsets. Let 6 ! ?A@ be a strongly convex rational polyhedral cone and let H ! 6 be a face. Then we can find , . 6 7 9V; such that H R OQP 9 6 . This allows us to relate semigroup algebras of 6 and H as follows.
§1.3. Properties of Affine Toric Varieties
43
H R O P 96 -
Proposition 1.3.16. Let H be a face of 6 and as above write F% 2 - R F% H 7 9 ; ,. 6 7 9Q; . Then the semigroup algebra P A% 23 - R F% 6 7 9-; - at ' . F% 23 - . In other words, of
, where is the localization
F% 2 - R F% 23 -
, and since K , L R F4 R , 8 ! 2
2 3 2
Proof. The inclusion H ! 6 implies we have , . H 7 . It follows that
2 3
. H
for all
This inclusion is actually an equality, as we now prove. Fix a finite set = I> 4
,
L ! ;
R B U K , Z L . F Z , . 2 3 . This proves that It is straightforward to show that , 23 F4 R , 8 R 2 F% 2 - R A% 23 - follows immediately. from which
This interprets nicely in terms of toric morphisms. By Proposition 1.3.15, the ? 4 4 3 identity map ? and the inclusion H ! 6 give the toric morphism 2 3 - F% 2 A % that corresponds to the inclusion . By Proposition 1.3.16, !
R BC D47&% 2 - 8 R BC D47A% 23 - 8 R B9C D47&% 23 - 8 R 4 3 8 ! 3 becomes an affine open subset of 3 when H is a face of 6 . In other words, (1.3.4)
4
4
4
4
4
This will be useful in Chapters 2 and 3 when we study the local structure of more general toric varieties. Sublattices of Finite Index and Rings of Invariants. Another interesting class of toric morphisms arises when we keep the same cone but change the lattice. Here is an example we have already seen.
= I> 4 ( 8
Example 1.3.17. In Example 1.3.7 the dual of 6 R interacts ! with the lattices shown in Figure 10 on the next page. To make this precise, let us name the lattices involved: the lattices Z
R ? ! ? R 4 * .8 * . * I Z have 6J! ? @ ! ? @ , and the dual lattices Z
R ; ; R 4 * 8 * . * I Z have 6 7 !; @ ! ;V@ . Note that duality reverses inclusions and that ; and ? are indeed dual under dot product. In Figure 10 (a), the black dots in the first quadrant 2 34 5 R Z , and in Figure 10 (b), the white dots in the 7 form the semigroup 6 9 ; 2+3 5 R first quadrant form 6 7 9-; .
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
44
σ
σ
(a)
(b)
Figure 10. Lattice points of
relative to two lattices
and
3 5
4
4
34 5
4
34 5 R
This gives the affine toric varieties . Clearly since Z 4 3 5 is smooth for ? , while Example 1.3.7 shows that is the rational normal Z !? gives a toric morphism cone . The inclusion ?
6
R
4
34 5 R
3 5 R
4
Our next task is to find a nice description of this map.
Z
Z
!? , where ? has finite index in ? , In general, suppose we have lattices ? Z and let 6 ! ? @ R ?@ be a strongly convex rational polyhedral cone. Then the Z ! ? gives the toric morphism inclusion ?
3 5 R Z ; , so that The dual lattices satisfy ; 4
4
34 5
A% 6 7 9 ; Z -
corresponds to the inclusion
&% 6 7 9 ; &% - as a ring of invariants of of semigroup algebras. The idea is to realize 6 7 9; A % Z a group action on 6 7 9-; . Z Z Proposition 1.3.18. Let ? have finite index in ? with quotient R ? ? and Z let 6 ! ? @ R ? @ be a strongly convex rational polyhedral cone. Then:
I. * 4 ; Z ; J M 8 R 4 5 5 8 A% Z - with ring of invariants acts on 6 7 9; A% 6 7 9-; Z - R A% 6 7 9 ; -<
(a) There are natural isomorphisms
(b)
(c)
4
34 5
,
acts on , and the morphism and induces a bijection 4
3 5
3 5
4
4
3 5
4
3 5
is constant on
-orbits
§1.3. Properties of Affine Toric Varieties
Proof. Since
45
5 R-, I. *V4 ; J M 8 by Exercise 1.1.11, applying , I. * 4FRSJ M 8 R+ ; R+ ; Z R ; Z ; R+
I.*4 ; Z ; J M 8XR 5 R+ 5 R I. *)F4 RSJ M 8 is left exact and M is divisible.
gives the sequence
R
,
This is exact since , ? ? Z into the picture, note that
Z ! ?! ?2/
?
;
and
!;
To bring
to
R
Z ! ;0/
; / 2 ? P/ , the map Z Z 4*% , Z -< % - 8 R+ ' ; ; ? ? R+ M I. *V4 ; Z ; J M 8 (Exercise 1.3.10). is well-defined and induces , 5 on 4 3 5 induces an action of on 4 3 5 since ! 5 . The action of 4 3 5 ( Using Exercise 1.3.1, one sees that if . and . , then is defined by 2 * 4 % 8 4 8 Z Z Z Z , , for , . 67A9-; Z . It follows the semigroup homomorphism , that the corresponding action on the coordinate ring is given by P ( P ' R V4*% , Z - 8 " ' , Z . 6 7 9-; Z Z . ; Z lies in ; if (Exercise 5.0.1 explains why we need the inverse.) Since , V4*% Z - 8 R and only if , for all . , the ring of invariants &% 6 7 9 ; Z - R O . A% 6 7 9 ; Z - O R O for all . . F% is precisely 6N7A9-; , i.e., A% 6 7 9-; Z - R A% 6 7 9 ; -< Since the pairing between
;
and ?
induces a pairing
+ When a finite group acts algebraically on Thm. 10 of Ch. 7, §4] &% '(*',+.- ! E , [17, shows that the ring of invariants gives a morphism of affine
This proves part (b).
varieties
+ R BC D47A% ' (*' + - 8XR+ BC D.47F% ' ( *',+.- 8
BC D.47&% ')( *',+.- 8
-orbits+ and induces a bijection
that is constant on
The proof extends without difficulty to the case when acts algebraically on BC D47EF8 . Here, E ! E gives a morphism of affine varieties that is constant on
; R B C D.47EF8 R B C D47E 8
-orbits and induces a bijection
;
BC D47E
8
From here, part (c) follows immediately from part (b).
; R
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
46
We will give a careful treatment of these ideas in §5.0, where we will show BC D47EF8 BC D47E M8 is a good geometric quotient. that the map Here are some examples of Proposition 1.3.18.
Example 1.3.19. In the situation of Example 1.3.17, one computes that R
acting on 4 34 5 R BC D47A% - 8 by R 4 . 8 R 4FR group Thus the rational normal cone is the quotient
R
3 5
4
4
3 5 R
. is4R the 8.
&% . - R F% - R &% - F% ' *' ( *' - K ' ' R ' ( L
We can see this explicitly as follows. The invariant ring is easily seen to be
where the last isomorphism follows from Example 1.1.6. From the point of view of invariant theory, the generators of the ring of invariants give a morphism
R 4 8 4 8
that is constant on
-orbits. This map also separates orbits, so it induces
47 8 R
where the last equality is by Example 1.1.6. But we can also think about this in give the Hilbert basis terms of semigroups, where the exponent vectors of 2+3 5 of the semigroup pictured in Figure 10 (b). Everything fits together very nicely.
In Exercise 1.3.11 you will generalize Example 1.3.19 to the case of the ratio ? for arbitrary @ . nal normal cone
+
+ a simplicial cone of dimension / with Example 1.3.20. Let 6 ! ?G@ ( + . Then ? Z R be + of finite index in & '( Z ( ' is a4 sublattice ray generators 3 5 R . It follows that ? . Furthermore, 6 is+ smooth relative to ? , so that R ? ? Z acts on with quotient
+
R
4
3 5
4
3 5
Hence the affine toric variety of a simplicial cone is the quotient of affine space by 4 34 5 a finite abelian group. In the literature, varieties like are called orbifolds and are said to be -factorial.
Exercises for §1.3.
(<>=?7@1AIH J!'
( / 27+6+6+72 ! 8
, where , and 1.3.1. Consider the affine toric variety . Let be a semigroup homomorphism. In the proof of Proposition 1.3.1 . we showed that lies in (a) Prove that the maximal ideal is the kernel of the -algebra homomorphism induced by .
( ,
6 h
K (M k '926+6+7+92 k ! ' ' /,-f H JUOe, RK'( W8 H J5h
§1.3. Properties of Affine Toric Varieties
~
47
(
% ~
and fix . As in the (b) The torus of has character lattice discussion following Proposition 1.3.1, this gives the semigroup homomorphism . Prove that this corresponds to the point
jh !n' ' 26+7+6+92 ' ' 27+6+7+92k ! 'n')( k ' 27+6+7+92 ! ' ' f ! . coming from the action of ^ ~ F '/! on K 1.3.2. Let G ( <W=D?E@1FIH >J ' with the torus ~ ( <W=D?E@mA H J!' , ( . The action ~ G h G comes from a -algebra homomorphism H > a J h I H IH >J . Prove . Hint: First showJ that this that this homomorphism is given by jh IH J that gives theformula determines the -algebra homomorphism IH J h H J group operation ~ ~ h ~. 1.3.3. Prove Corollary 1.3.3.
&
1.3.4. Let
be a finite set.
, is saturated in `?1 C'^! .
(a) Prove that the semigroup Hint: Apply (1.2.2) to
(b) Complete the proof of (b)
if and only if
,
( `?1 C'%
.
(c) from Theorem 1.3.5.
is torsion-free. Prove that there is a 4 ( 4 . (b) Let be primitive as defined in the proof of Theorem 1.3.5. Prove that has a basis 26+6+7+92 such that (V .
1.3.5. Let be a lattice. (a) Let be a sublattice such that sublattice such that
1.3.6. Prove Proposition 1.3.8.
of an irreducible affine variety G . Then K gives the maximal ideal _ ( /&,t K beH GaJ^point O`, RKS'(M_ `8 _ as well as_ the _ maximal ideal _ YW[ \ X^Y>[ \ defined in §1.0. YW[ \m 4YW[ \ is an isomorphism of -vector spaces. Prove that the natural map 4y#h
1.3.7. Let
1.3.8. Prove (1.3.3). Hint: Use Lemma 1.0.6 and Example 1.0.10. 1.3.9. Prove Proposition 1.3.15.
Dh nH J"27H J!')jh &4 [ O ( 8 be the group of th roots of unity. Then acts on 1.3.11. Let ( / d c d c 4 by 2 '( 2 ' . Adapt Example 1.3.19 to show that 4 g . Hint: Use lattices D( U4Z (N/> ` D2 6 'aO2.2 # :|>z 8 . 1.3.12. Let ' and 0 ' be strongly convex rational polyhedral cones. 4 44 This gives the cone ' . Prove that . Also explain 4 how this result applies to (1.3.2). 1.3.13. By Proposition 1.3.1, a point K of an affine toric variety G (C<>=?7@ AIH J!' is represented by a semigroup homomorphism 6 h . Prove that K lies in the torus of G if and only if never vanishes, i.e., k 'U(V T for all . 1.3.10. Prove the assertions made in the proof of Proposition 1.3.18 concerning the pairing
defined by
+ .
Chapter 1. Affine Toric Varieties
48
Appendix: Tensor Products of Coordinate Rings In this appendix, we will prove the following result used in §1.0 in our discussion of products of affine varieties.
and .
Proposition 1.A.1. If the same is true for
are finitely generated -algebras without nilpotents, then
H d 27+6+7+62 d J!
Proof. Since the tensor product is obviously a finitely generated -algebra, we need only has no nilpotents. If we write prove that , then is radical and hence has a primary decomposition + + , where each + is prime ([17, Ch. 4, §7]). This gives
( v !
IH d 26+7+6+62 d JA #Dh + ! I H d 27+6+6+72 d J!
+ where the second map is injective. Each quotient IH d 26+7+6+92 d JA + is an integral domain q + . This yields an injection and hence injects into its field of fractions 1 M#Dh + ! q + 2
and since tensoring over a field preserves exactness, we get an injection
q
h + ! q
+
+
q
q
Hence it suffices to prove that has no nilpotents when is a finitely generated field extension of . A similar argument using then reduces us to showing that has no nilpotents when and are finitely generated field extensions of . Since has characteristic , the extension has a separating transcendence basis ([56, p. 519]). This means that we can find such that are algebraically independent over and is a finite separable extension. Then
q
c c i c 26+7+6+72 c 26+7+6+92 c c ( 26+6+7+62 ' q Z' Aq I' + q N(Cq I c 62 +7+6+62 c p')(*q c 26+7+6+92 c p' is a field, so that we are reduced But gN(Cq to considering g where g and are extensions of and The latter and the is finite and separable. theorem of the primitive element imply that H JA , ' , where , ' has distinct roots in some extension of . Then g g H JA , ' gH J! , ' + Since , ' has distinct roots, this quotient ring has no nilpotents. Our result follows. A final remark is that we can replace with any perfect field since finitely generated
extensions of perfect fields have separating transcendence bases ([56, p. 519]).
Chapter 2
Projective Toric Varieties
§2.0. Background: Projective Varieties Our discussion assumes that the reader is familiar with the elementary theory of projective varieties, at the level of [17, Ch. 8].
In Chapter 1, we introduced affine toric varieties. In general, a+ toric variety over containing a torus 5 47 M 8 as a Zariski is an irreducible variety + 7 4 8 M open set such that the action of on itself extends to an action on . We will learn in Chapter 3 that the concept of “variety” is somewhat subtle. Hence we will defer the formal definition of toric variety+ until then and instead concentrate on toric varieties that live in projective space , defined by
+ R 47 + U ( S 8 M .4 * * +98 R 4 * * + 8 M + ( where M acts via homotheties, i.e., for . U 4 9 + 8 4 + 8 * + * . * * are homogeneous coordinates of a and . Thus and are well-defined up to homothety. point in
(2.0.1)
)
)
)
)
The goal of this chapter is to use lattice points and polytopes to create toric + varieties that lie in . We will use the affine semigroups and polyhedral cones introduced in Chapter 1 to describe the local structure of these varieties.
+ ; Homogeneous Coordinate Rings. A projective variety ! is defined by the vanishing of finitely many homogeneous polynomials in the polynomial ring L R F% ' *' +.- . The homogeneous coordinate ring of ; is the quotient ring A%>;S- R L :.4<;&8 :.4<;=8 is generated by all homogeneous polynomials that vanish on ; . where 49
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
50
L
,4 ' 8
' R . This gives the decomThe polynomial ring is graded by setting L V L ? L ? ? R ( position , where is the vector space of homogeneous polynomials of degree @ . Homogeneous ideals decompose similarly, and the above coordinate F%>; - inherits a grading where ring
%>; -? R VL ? :.4<;&8 ? F :.4<;&8 ! L R F% ' *' + - also defines an affine variety ; ! + U ( , The ideal ; ; called the affine cone of . The variety satisfies ; R 4 ; SX 8 M (2.0.2) ; and its coordinate ring is the homogeneous coordinate ring of , i.e., A% ;S- R F%>; -<
6 R K ' ' ' U ( R ' ' U (J' @ R L ! A% ' *',? minors of the matrix generated by the ' ')( '2? " ',? " ( ' ( ' '2? " ( ',? ? ? 6 Since is homogeneous, it defines a projective variety ! that is the image of the map ( R ? 4 . 8 4 ? ? " ( ? " ( ? 8 (see defined in homogeneous coordinates by ? Exercise 1.1.1). This shows that is a curve, called the rational normal curve of? degree @ . Furthermore, the affine cone of ? is the rational normal cone ? ! U ( discussed in Example 1.1.6. ? We know from Chapter 1 that is an affine toric surface; we will soon see ? that is a projective toric curve. 354 ' R S8 ! studied in Chapter 1 is Example 2.0.2. The affine toric variety the affine cone of the projective ( ( surface ; R 354 ' R 8 ! . Recall that this surface is isomorphic to via the Segre embedding ( ( R+ 4 8 4 8 ; ( ( Example 2.0.1. In Example 1.1.6 we encountered the ideal
given by . We will see below that projective toric variety coming from the unit square in the plane.
is the
; ! + has the classical topology, As in the affine case, a projective+ variety induced from the usual topology on , and the Zariski topology, where+ the Zariski ; contained closed sets are subvarieties of (meaning projective varieties of ; in ) and the Zariski open sets are their complements.
§2.0. Background: Projective Varieties
51
Rational Functions on Irreducible Projective Varieties. A homogeneous polynoL of degree @ does not give a function on + since mial O . ?
O 4 ) ' ) ' + 8 R
O 4 ' *' + 8 . L ? gives the well-defined However, the quotient of two such polynomials O function O + S 35 4 98 S + and say that O is a rational provided R P + . We write this as O function on . ; ! + is irreducible, and let O . F%>; - R More generally, suppose that F% ; - be homogeneous of the same degree with R P . Then O and give functions ; &4 ;A8 . By (2.0.2), this induces a on the affine cone and hence an element O . ; . Thus rational function O &4<;A8 R O . A4 ;&8 O . A%>;S- homogeneous of the same degree, R P ; is the field of rational functions on . It is customary to write the set on the left as F4 ;=8 since it consists of the degree elements of A4 ;&8 . ; ! + is a union of+ Affine Pieces of Projective Varieties. A projective variety + 4 S 354 ' ' 8 . Then 4 ' Zariski open sets that are affine. To see why, let ' R )
so that in the notation of Chapter 1, we have ' R BC D via the map
(2.0.3)
4 * * +98 R
4
;
Then+ 9 ' is a Zariski open subset of defined by the equations in 4
;
that maps via (2.0.3) to the affine variety
O R :.4<;&8 . as O varies over all homogeneous polynomials in ; 9 4 ' an affine piece of ; . These affine pieces cover ; We call+
(2.0.4)
since the cover . Using localization, we can describe the coordinate rings of the affine ' ' &%>;- , so that we get pieces as follows. The variable ' induces an element '#. the localization 4
'
F%>; - R O ' ' O . A%>;S-< W A%>;S- has a well-defined -grading as in Exercises 1.0.2 and 1.0.3. Note that
V4 ' ' 8 R V4 /8 R O O given by when O is homogeneous. Then 7 4 A > % S ; - 8 R ' & (2.0.6)
O ' . %>;- O is homogeneous of degree F%>; - consisting of all elements of degree . This gives an affine is the subring of ; piece of as follows.
(2.0.5)
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
52
Lemma 2.0.3. The affine piece
; 9
F%>; 9
'
4
of
;
has coordinate ring
' - 47A%>; - 8
4
Proof. We have an exact sequence
%>; -NR R :.4<;A8%R+ A% ' *' + -8R F ' If we localize at ' , we get the exact sequence %>;S- R (2.0.7) R :.4<;&8 R A% ' *',+.- R+ A since localization preserves exactness (Exercises 2.0.1 and 2.0.2). These sequences preserve degrees, so that taking elements of degree 0 gives the exact sequence
+R 47:.4<;&8 8 R 74 A% ' *' + - 8 R 74 &%>; - 8 R+ 47A% ' *' + - 8 R . If O . .: 4<;&8 Note that
is
47:.4<;=8 8 ' . R ' O O 8 8 maps :.4<; 9 4 ' 8 . To show that this 47:.4< ;A By (2.0.4), we conclude that to 4 . :.4<; ' 8 . For , ' ' R 9 map is onto, let ' O; 4 ' *' + 8 is homogeneous of degree . It follows easily that ' O vanishes on ; 4 ' 4 ' :.4<;A8 , since R on 9 ( ' and ' R on the complement of ' . Thus ' O . 4 ' 8 4 ' U 8 . 47:.4<;=8 8 maps to . The lemma follows immediately. and then ' O '
homogeneous of degree , then
;
; 9
' and One can also explore what happens when we intersect affine pieces 9 4 ; 4 4 ' 9 for XR P . By Exercise 2.0.3, 9 is affine with coordinate ring
(2.0.8)
F%>; 9
4
' 9
4
-
4
47&%>;- 8
We will apply this to projective toric varieties later in the chapter. We will use these results in §2.2 when we explore the structure of projective toric varieties. We will also see later in the book that Lemma 2.0.3 is related to the “Proj” construction, where Proj of a graded ring gives a projective variety, just as Spec of an ordinary ring gives an affine variety.
+ P Products of Projective Spaces. One can study the product of projective F% '! *',+ P - , where ' ' has spaces using the bigraded ring bidegree 4 8 and ' has bidegree 4 8 . Then a bihomogeneous polynomial of bidegree O 4 * 8 gives a+ well-defined + P . This allows us to define equation O R in P + using :.4<;&8 of varieties in bihomogeneous ideals. In particular, the ideal P ; is a bihomogeneous ideal. a variety ! + P Another way to study is via the Segre embedding + P R+ + P U + U P
§2.0. Background: Projective Varieties
53
4 * * + P8 to the point 4 * * ( * P * ( * ( P * + * + P 8 +P U+UP This map is studied in [17, Ex. 14 of Ch. 8, §4]. + If ' , P ! + PhasU + homogeneous U P / coordinates ' for , then 4 %8 54 , 8 matrix is defined minors of the / by the vanishing of the ' ' FP .. .. . ' /+ ' + . P This follows if it is a since an 4 / 18 4 , 8 matrix has rank if and only
product , where and are nonzero row matrices of lengths / and , . give the same notion of what it means to be a subvariety of + These P . Aapproaches 4 ' ' 8 of degree @ gives the bihomogeneous homogeneous polynomial + P U + U P lying of polynomial + P 4 ' ' 8 of bidegree 4 @ @ 8 . Hence any subvariety F% ' *' +, Pdefined by mapping
in can be defined by a bihomogeneous ideal in Going the other way takes more thought and is discussed in Exercise 2.0.5.
; ! +
We also have the following useful result proved in Exercise 2.0.6. Proposition 2.0.4. + GivenP subvarieties is a subvariety of .
and
!
P
, the product
;
.
+ is &% ' *',+.- , - + be positive
Weighted Projective Space. The graded ring associated to '
where each variable ' has degree . More generally, let .D 4 + 8 R and define integers with
4 + 8 R 47 + U ( XS 8 %
% where is the equivalence relation 4 * * + 8% 4 + 8 * ' R ' R / for some . M 4 +98 a weighted projective space. Note that + R 4 8 . We call 4 + 8 is the graded ring F% ' *' + - where The ring corresponding to ' ' now has degree ' . A polynomial O is weighted homogeneous of degree @ if ev' appearing in O satisfies " 4 +98 R @ . The O R is wellery monomial 4 + 8 when O is weighted homogeneous, so that one can define defined on 4 + 8 using weighted homogeneous ideals of F% ' *' +.- . varieties in 4 .8 in using Example 2.0.5. We can embed the weighted projective plane ( ' * ' ' * ' * ' ( of weighted degree . In other words, the map the monomials 4 .8#R
given by
)
4 * * ( * 8 R 4 * * * ( * ( * 8
)
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
54
is well-defined and injective. One can check that this map induces
where
4 .8 354 R ( 8 ! ( are homogeneous coordinates on .
Later in the book we will use toric methods to construct projective embeddings of arbitrary weighted projective spaces. Exercises for §2.0.
, t:/& W8 and an exact sequence of h 4h oh #Dh y; #h 4 y; #h o y; #Dh is also exact, where ; is the localization of at , defined in Exercises 1.0.2 and 1.0.3. has coordinate ring H GJ( FG$' , where ( 2.0.2. A projective variety G H d 26+7+6+62 d J . Let d b + be the image of d + in IH G:J . (a) Note the IH G:J is an -module. Prove that H GJ 4 IH GJ I 4 . h
2.0.1. Let be a commutative -algebra. Given -modules , prove that
(b) Use part (a) and the previous exercise to prove that (2.0.7) is exact.
2.0.3. Prove the claim made in (2.0.8).
G be a projective variety. Take , 26+7+6+723, such that the intersection G%F, 26+6+7+62 , ' is empty. Prove that the map 26+7+6+62 ')j#hlF, 26+7+6+92 '926+7+6+62 , 27+6+6+72 'n' . induces a well-defined map function 6 GMh be defined by , d +n2 c 'B(V , where , d +32 c ' is bihomogenous 2.0.5. Let G of bidegree 2 ' , t( m 26+7+6+723 . The goal of this exercise is to show that when we in via the Segre embedding described in the text, G becomes embed a subvariety of . (a) For each , pick an integer *| S/ 2 8 and consider the polynomials , [ r [ ( ( d r c ( , + d + 2 c ' where (* `27+6+6+623 and O saOm( # 2ZO *ZO ( "# . Note that , [ r [ ( is bihomogenous of bidegree 2 ' . Prove that G is defined by the vanishing of the , [ r [ ( . (b) Use part (a) to show that G is a subvariety of under the Segre embedding. 2.0.4. Let
2.0.6. Prove Proposition 2.0.4
h o d c % # 'aV
2.0.7. Consider the Segre embedding after relabeling coordi in is the variety . Show that featured in many $ nates, the affine cone of examples in Chapter 1.
o
§2.1. Lattice Points and Projective Toric Varieties
55
§2.1. Lattice Points and Projective Toric Varieties
+ We first observe that is a toric variety with torus R + S 354 ' ! ' +98 R 4 * * + 8 . + R 4 ( +98 . ( + .
+ * ! * + R P +
M 74 M 8
+ on itself clearly extends to an action on
The action of
+ , making
, we use the exact sequence aoftoric tori
R M R 47 M 8 + U ( R+ R + is coming from the definition (2.0.1) of . Hence the character lattice of + R 4 * * + 8 . + U ( +')( * ' R .
& (2.1.1) variety. To describe the lattices associated to
and the lattice of one-parameter subgroups
+ R
+U (
+ is the quotient 4 8 5
Lattice Points and Projective Toric Varieties. Let be a torus with lattices ; $ R and ? as usual. In Chapter 1, we used a finite set of lattice points of ( 3 , " ! ; to create the affine toric variety
, as the Zariski closure of the image of the map
4' P 4 8 (' P 4 8*8 3 47 M 8F" To get a projective toric variety, we regard as a map to " 47 M 8 to obtain with the homomorphism 5 R+ " R+ ! " " ( (2.1.2)
5 R+ "
3
R
$
and compose
Definition 2.1.1. Given toric variety " " ( a finite set !; , the projective 3 Zariski closure in of the image of the map from (2.1.2).
3
53
is the
Proposition 2.1.2. is a toric variety of dimension equal to the dimension of $ the smallest affine subspace of ; @ containing .
8" " (
! Proof. The proof that is a toric variety is similar to the proof given 3 ! " is a toric variety. The assertion in Propostion 1.1.8 of Chapter 1 that 3 concerning the dimension of will follow from Proposition 2.1.6 below. 3 5 R+
3
R 4' P 4 8 (' P 4 8*8 $ R , ( , " ! ; given by+ the characters coming from . In particular, if P' P and .3 is the Zariski , then is the Laurent monomial closure of ; R the image of 5 R+ " " ( R 4 P P 8 More concretely,
"" (
is the Zariski closure of the image of the map
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
56
+
$
! $ In the literature, so that the elements of
is often given as an / are the columns of .
matrix
with integer entries,
Here is a example where the lattice points themselves are matrices. be the lattice of integer matrices and let Example 2.1.3. Let ; R R permutation matrices !
Write
&% ; - R F % 1( ( 1 ( - , where the variables give the generic (
matrix
'
with nonzero entries. coordinates ' indexed by ( Also let have homogeneous L ! triples such that ' is a permutation in . Then is the Zariski closure given by the Laurent monomials ' ( of the Limage of the map 5 . . The ideal of for ' is
:.4 8 R K ' ( ' J( ' ( %R )' ( ' J( ' ( L ! &% ' ' -<
where the relation comes from the fact that the sum of three of the permutation matrices is equal to the sum of the other three (Exercise 2.1.1). Ideals of the toric varieties arising from permutation matrices have applications to sampling problems in statistics [97, p. 148].
8" " (
! The Affine Cone of a Projective Toric Variety. The projective variety 3 ! " 3 has an affine cone . How does relate to the affine toric variety 3 ! " constructed in Chapter 1? Recall from Chapter 1 that when induces an exact sequence (2.1.3)
R+
3
6 R ' R '
and that the ideal of
$ R , ( , " ! ;
, the map
' , '
" R ;
R+
is the toric ideal
"M
3
. "
and
R "
.
(Proposition 1.1.9). Then we have the following result. Proposition 2.1.4. Given (a) (b) (c)
3
,
3 3
" ! is the affine cone 6 R .: 4.3 8 . 3
6
is homogeneous.
(d) There is
. ?
and
in
and of
64 3
as above, ( the following are equivalent:
! 8 " "
such that
.
K, ' L R
for
R .
§2.1. Lattice Points and Projective Toric Varieties
Proof. The equivalence (a) (b) follows from the equalities 6 R :.4 3 8 , and the implication (b) (c) is obvious. and
57
:.4
3
8 R :.4
3
8
6 ' R ' . assume that is homogeneous ' and . 6 R :.4 3 8 for *' take " R For. (c) ' (d), then .3 If and ' had different degrees, and ' would vanish ' on . This is impossible since 4 4 8 . 3 by8 R (2.1.2). Hence . for all have the same degree, which implies that . Now tensor (2.1.3) with and take duals to obtain an exact sequence " ?2/ R+ R , I. / 4 / JX8 R+ 4 8 . " maps to zero in , I. / 4 / JX8 The above argument shows that
for all . and hence comes from an element . ? / . In other words, K ,' L R Clearing denominators gives the desired . ? and in . 6 R :.4 3 8 , it suffices to show that Finally, we prove (d) (b). Since 3 9 47 M 8 " ! 3 .3 9 47 M F8 " 3 9 3 Let . . Since is the torus of , it follows that P P R 4 ' 4 8 ( ' 4 8*8 M and . 5 . Let . ? be as in part (d). This gives a onefor some . 5 , which we write as H ) 4 H 8 for H . M . Then parameter subgroup of ) 4 H 8 . 5 maps to the point . "3 given by R ' P 4 ) 4 H 8 8 ( ' P 4 ) 4 H 8 8 R H P ' P 4 8 H P ' P 4 8 P 4 ) 4 8*8 P ' H R H since by the description of K L given in §1.1. The hypothesis
4' P 4 8 (' P 4 8*8 . 3 . This completes the proof. Using , we can choose H so that R
, for some . ? and in The condition K , ' L R , R $ means that lies in an affine hyperplane of ;/ not containing the origin. When + $ ; R and consists of the columns of an / integer matrix , this is 4 8 lying in the row space of (Exercise 2.1.2). equivalent to ? ? ! Example 2.1.5. We will examine the rational normal curve using two
of part (d) allows us to rewrite as
R H
different sets of lattice points. First let
$
consist of the columns of the
5 4 @ 8 matrix
@ R @
@ @ R ? The columns give the Laurent monomials defining the rational normal curve ? ? in Example 2.0.1. It follows that is a projective toric variety. The ideal of
R
is the homogeneous ideal given in Example 2.0.1, and the corresponding affine $ (= the columns of ) consists of all points 4 * 8 hyperplane of containing
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
58
*
R @ . It is equally easy to see that satisfying . In particular, we have
Now let
4 8
is in the row space of
.3 R ? and 3 R ? R @ R @ ! . This gives the map ? ? ( ? M R 4 " 8
?
R , but the The resulting projective variety is the rational normal curve, i.e., RP ? affine variety of is not the rational normal cone, i.e., is because :.4 8 ! A? % ' ( ? *',?? - is( not homogeneous. For example, ' ( R . This ' vanishes at 4 " 8 . U for all . M . Thus ' ( R ' . :.4 8 .
$
$
Given any way to modify so that the conditions !; , there is a $ standard
of Proposition 2.1.4 are met: use
! ; . This lattice corresponds to + M , and since the torus P 4 8 (' P 4 8 8 P 4 8 (' P 4 8*8 ' 4 4' 3 4 8 R ( R (2.1.4)
8" (
3 " . Since ( R ! it follows immediately that lies in an 3 has affine hyperplane missing the origin, + Proposition 2.1.4 implies that 3 ( R .3 . When ; R $ is represented by the columns affine cone and of an $
4
8 /
by adding the row integer matrix , we obtain to .
3
$
The Torus of a Projective Toric Variety. Our next task is to determine the torus of .3 . We will do so by identifying the character lattice. This will also tell us the 3 . Given $ R , ( , " !; , we set dimension of
Z$
Z $ R & '" ( ( * ' ,-' * ' . & '" ( ( * ' R
The rank of is the dimension of the smallest affine subspace of ; $ the set (Exercise 2.1.3). Proposition 2.1.6. Let
Z $ The lattice
3
be the projective toric variety of
$ !;
@
containing
. Then:
3 . (a) is the character lattice of the torus of 3 is the dimension of the smallest affine subspace of ; @ (b) The dimension of $ containing . In particular, B %$ R if $ satisfies the conditions of Proposition 2.1.4
! . 3 R B %$ otherwise.
4 " 8
Proof. To prove part (a), let ; be the character lattice of the torus .3 . By (2.1.2), we have the commutative diagram
5
/
EE O EE EE EE" " ?
"
/
"" (
"
of
§2.1. Lattice Points and Projective Toric Varieties
59
which induces the commutative diagram of character lattices
;
(
4 (
*" " R * by" (2.1.1). The map
since
' to ,-' . Thus
Z$
o
"
dHH HH HH HH H2 R
"(
" ; 4 8 8 . " & '" ( * ',-' R is the character lattice of " " ( ; is induced by the map " ; that sends " 8 " " (G ; ; 4
is the image of
and hence equals
by
the above diagram. assertion of part (b) follows from part (a) and the observation that B TheZ $ first $ is the dimension of the smallest affine subspace of ; @ containing . K ,-' " L ( R 8 4 * & '( '
3 R P . 3
Then
"3
3
equals the affine cone of , then there is " for all by Proposition 2.1.4. This implies that KF& ')( , which gives the exact sequence
Furthermore, if
. (0* ' ,-? ' with L R
Z R + R $ R %$ + R implies B %$6 R R B Z $ R 3 . On the other hand, if , then the ideal is not homogeneous, where is defined by + R R+ " R %$ R 6 , 4 8 R
by (2.1.3). Using the usual description of , it follows that some ,. . This implies there is such that we have a diagram
/
/
Z
$
"(
"
/
"(
9 "
/
/ "
/ /
/
/
/
/
%$ /
for
P
B %$ R B Z $ R ! .3 . $ R ( ( ( ! . One computes that Example 2.1.7. Let %$ R Z $ R 4 * 8 . * I . Thus Z $ has index in but %$ 3 R P .3 " . This means that and the map of tori with exact rows and columns. Hence
is two-to-one, i.e., its kernel has order
R
"
(Exercise 2.1.4).
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
60
Affine Pieces of a Projective Toric Variety. So far, our treatment of projective toric varieties has used lattice points and toric ideals. Where are the semigroups? " " ( There 3 are actually lots of semigroups, one ! . ( for each affine piece of
. Thus
3 4 ' ' 8 contains the torus ' R 8 " " S 5 3 9 ! .3 9 4 ' " R . .3 8" " ( , it follows that 3 9 4 ' is the " Since is the Zariski closure of ( in " in 4 ' " " . Thus 3 9 4 ' is an affine toric variety. Zariski closure of $ R , ( , " ! ;V@ (" affine semigroup associated to 3 9 4 ' Given , the " 4 is easy to determine. Recall that ' is given by 4 * ( * " 8 R 4 * ( * ' * ' " ( * ' * ' U ( * ' * " * ' 8 P ' P ' P " P ' 3 9 4 ' R Combining this and with the map (2.1.2), we see that The affine open set
4
5 R "" (
is the Zariski closure of the image of the map
given by (2.1.5) If we set
R+
$ '
P " P 4 8 P " P 4 8 P " P 4 8 P " P 4 8 R $ R , ' R , R , ' R P , it follows that 9 ' R R B9C D.47&% 2 ' - 8 '
('
.3
4
('
('
.3
$
2
' is the affine semigroup generated by where ' R the following result.
$ ' .
We have thus proved
3 ! 8" " ( $ R , ( , " ! ;J@ Proposition 2.1.8. Let for 4 3 affine piece 9 ' is the affine toric variety 3 9 4 ' R 3 R BC D74 A% 2 ' - 8 . $ $ R , ' and 2 ' R #$ ' . where ' R
. Then the
"
We also note that the results of Chapter 1 imply that the torus of %$ ' . Yet the torus is , which has character lattice character lattice %$ ' R Z $ for all . ( Proposition 2.1.6. These are consistent since
3
XZ $
has by
8" "
9 ' of Besides describing the affine pieces , we can also describe how they patch together. In other words, we can give a completely toric description of the inclusions
' P ' ' P RP ' "
when
(2.1.6)
RP RP
.3 9
.
'
4
For instance, 3 . In terms of . Thus
3
9
4
' 9
4
4
9
' 9 4
.3 9 4
' R
4
4
3
' 9
4
3
! .3 9
4
9 ' where consists of those points of BC D.47A% 2 ' - 8 , this means those points where
R B9C D F% 2 ' -
R BC D A% 2 ' -
3
4
§2.1. Lattice Points and Projective Toric Varieties
R ,
so that if we set , be written
R ,-' 3 9 , then the inclusion
BC D47A% 2 ' - 8
!
(2.1.7)
61 4
' 9 4
! .3 9
' 4
can
BC D.47F% 2 ' - 8
This looks very similar to the inclusion constructed in (1.3.4) using faces of cones. We will see in §2.3 that this is no accident.
= I> ) 4 $ 8
R ! ; @ We next say a few words about how the polytope 3 relates to . As we will learn in §2.2, the dimension of is the dimension of the smallest affine subspace of ; @ containing , which is the same as the smallest $ affine subspace of ; @ containing . It follows from Proposition 2.1.6 that
Furthermore, the vertices of
R !
3
give an especially efficient affine covering of
3
.
R , ( , " ! ; , let R = I> 4 $ 8 ! ;J@ Proposition 2.1.9. Given and set R . , is a vertex of . Then .3 R .3 9 4 $
.3 9
9 ' ! Proof. We will prove that if .
, then . . The discussion of polytopes from §2.2 below implies that
9;0/ R
&
3
4
, . 9 &
for some
4
R
Given .
, we have , ' . 9 ; , so that , ' is a convex , combination of the vertices . Clearing denominators, we get integers W such that
-linear and
,-' R & , & R R L 4, R , '8 R Thus & P' " P A% 2 ,- which implies , A' % 2 - , . ' when 2 ' - . Fix A % R . ' ' such a . Then so . By (2.1.6), 3 9 4 ' 9 4 R BC D47A% 2 ' - 8 R is invertible, 3 9 4 ' , giving 3 9 4 ' ! 3 9 4 .
;
+
Projective Normality. An+ irreducible variety ! is called projectively normal U ( ; if its affine cone is normal. A projectively normal variety is always ! normal (Exercise 2.1.5). Here is an example to show that the converse can fail. Example 2.1.10. Let
$ !
consist of the columns of the matrix
. The polytope R = I> 4 $ 8 is the giving the Laurent monomials 4 8 and 4 8 , with vertices corresponding to and . line segment connecting 3 The affine piece of corresponding to has coordinate ring F% - R A% . 4 8 4 8 - R &% -<
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
62
which is normal since it is a polynomial ring. Similarly, one sees that the coordinate F% - , also normal. These affine pieces cover 3 by ring corresponding to is 3 is normal. Proposition 2.1.9, so that
4 8
3
3
Since is in the row space of the matrix, affine cone of 3 is not normalis the by Proposition 2.1.4. The affine variety by Example 1.3.9, so .3 is normal but not projectively normal. that
The notion of normality used in this example is a bit ad-hoc since we have not formally defined normality for projective varieties. Once we define normality for abstract varieties in Chapter 3, we will see that Example 2.1.10 is fully rigorous. We will say more about projective normality when we explore the connection with polytopes suggested by the above results. Exercises for §2.1.
o o of - - permutation matrices defined in Example 2.1.3. o (a) Prove the claim made in Example 2.1.3 that three of the permutation matrices sum to the other three and use this to explain why d d d # d d d . E' . 3 4 o 4 o o 4 3 o 4 o 4 4 o (b) Show that zW{}| ( by computing . o (c) Conclude that E'B( d d d # d d d . 4 o 4 o o 4 o 4 o34 4 o 2.1.2. Let consist of the columns of an matrix u with integer entries. Prove ! that the conditions of Proposition 2.1.4 are equivalent to the assertion that nm27+6+6+626E'^' lies in the row space of u over or . 2.1.3. Given a finite set ( , prove that the rank of equals the dimension of the smallest affine subspace (over or ) containing . ' and check that it is 2.1.4. Verify the claims made in Example 2.1.7. Also compute m not homogeneous. be projectively normal. Use (2.0.6) to prove that the affine pieces 2.1.5. Let G G + of G are normal. 2.1.6. Fix a finite subset . Given , let ( ,/ * & O B N8 . 2.1.1. Consider the set
This is the translate of by . (a) Prove that and its translate .
(
give the same projective toric variety, i.e.,
"
can differ. Hint: (b) Give an example to show that the affine toric varieties and Pick so that it lies in an affine hyperplane not containing the origin. Then translate to the origin.
2.1.7. In Proposition 2.1.4, give a direct proof that (d)
g
(c).
was parametrized using the 2.1.8. In Example 2.1.5, the rational normal curve + , . Here we will consider the curve parametrized homogeneous monomials
(
by a subset of these monomials corresponding to the exponent vectors
(N/> 2 '926+6+7+62E 2 ' 8
§2.2. Lattice Points and Polytopes
8 and + ! +^( for every . This gives the projective curve . We assume ( . , explain why we can obtain the same projective curve using (a) If or
where
63
(b) Assume ( and ( . Use Proposition 2.1.8 to show that g is smooth if and only if ( #- and ( . Hint: For one direction, it helps to remember that monomials of strictly smaller degree.
smooth varieties are normal.
§2.2. Lattice Points and Polytopes Before we can begin our exploration of the rich connections between toric varieties and polytopes, we first need to study polytopes and their lattice points.
! ; @ is the convex hull of Polytopes. Recall from Chapter 1 that a polytope L R = I> 4
The dimension of a polytope ! ; @ is the dimension of the smallest affine subspace of ;J@ containing . Given a nonzero vector in the dual space ? @ and O O U . , we get the affine hyperplane and closed half-space defined by
O. R R and O U R , . ;J@ K , XL W . , . ;J@ K , L such that A subset # ! is a face of if there are . ?:@ SX and . U O 9 R . # ! O and O
We say that is a supporting affine hyperplane in this situation. Figure 1 shows
a polygon with the supporting lines of its -dimensional faces. The arrows in the figure indicate the vectors .
↑ P
→
→
↑ Figure 1. A polygon
and four of its supporting lines
We also regard as a face of itself. Every face of is again a polytope, and if R = I>)4 4
Here are some properties of faces.
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
64
(a)
be a polytope.
is the convex hull of its vertices.
R = I> 4
(b) If (c) If
!; @
Proposition 2.2.1. Let
is a face of #
, then the faces of
(d) Every proper face
#
L
lies in . are precisely the faces of
is the intersection of the facets #
containing #
lying in # . .
A polytope ! ;J@ can also be written as a finite intersection of closed halfspaces. The converse is true provided the intersection is bounded. In other words, if an intersection "
O U
R
' ( ( is bounded, then is a polytope. Here is a famous example. ?? . @ matrix ; Example 2.2.2. A @ is doubly-stochastic if? it? has nonnega as the affine tive entries columns are all . If we regard ? and its row and sum ? * space with coordinates ' , then the set of all doubly-stochastic matrices
is defined by the inequalites
*' W ? ? & '? ( ( * ' W & ? ')( ( * ' & ( ( * ' W & ( ( * '
4 all 8 4 all 8 4 all 8
(We use two inequalities to get one equality.) These inequalities easily imply that * ' for all , so that ? is bounded and hence is a polytope.
?
Birkhoff and Von Neumann proved independently that
? R 4 R 8 the vertices of ? are @ the @ permutation matrices and that . In the literature, has various names, including the Birkhoff polytope and the transportation polytope. See [103, p. 20] for more on this interesting polytope.
!
R When is full dimensional, i.e., ; @ , its presentation as an intersection of closed half-spaces has an especially nice form because each facet has a unique supporting affine hyperplane. We write the supporting affine hyperplane and corresponding closed half-space as
U R , . J ; @ K , L R R * M and O R ,. ;V@ K , LXW R * H. 4 * M 8 . ? @ is unique up to multiplication by a positive real number. where an inward-pointing facet normal of the facet . It follows that We call O U R , . ; @ K , L%W R * for all facets of =. R (2.2.1) facet
O
In Figure 1, the supporting lines plus arrows determine the supporting half-planes whose intersection is the polygon . We write (2.2.1) with minus signs in order to simplify formulas in later chapters.
§2.2. Lattice Points and Polytopes
65
Here are some important classes of polytopes.
Definition 2.2.3. Let !;@ be a polytope of dimension @ .
vertices. (a) is a simplex or d-simplex if it has @
(b) (c)
is simplicial if every facet of
is a simplex.
is simple if every vertex is the intersection of precisely
Examples include the Platonic solids in
A tetrahedron is a -simplex.
@
facets.
:
The octahedron and icosahedron are simplicial since their facets are triangles. The cube and dodecahedron are simple since three facets meet at every vertex.
(
Polytopes
and
are combinatorially equivalent if there is a bijection
faces of ( faces of
that preserves dimensions, inclusions and intersections. For example, simplices of the same dimension are combinatorially equivalent, and in the plane, the same holds for polygons with the same number of vertices.
Sums, Multiples, and Duals. Given a polytope = I> )4 LM8 is again a polytope for any W . If
R = I>)4
R
is defined by the inequalities
K , ' L W * ' .
then
is given by
K, 'L W
* '
In particular, when is full dimensional, then pointing facet normals. The Minkowski sum of subsets
(
(
!;J@
and
have the same inward-
is
R * ( * * ( . ( * . . ( R = I> 4 4 I 4
! ;J@ is full dimensional and When the dual or polar polytope
R . ? @ K , %L W R
is an interior point of for all ,.
R , . ; @ K , L1W R * facet as in (2.2.1), we is in the interior. Then is 4 the convex hull of . since ? @ (Exercise 2.2.1). We also have 8 R in this
When we write * for all have 4 * 8 the vectors situation.
, we define
! ? @
Figure 2 on the next page shows an example of this in the plane.
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
66
P
P°
Figure 2. A polygon
Lattice Polytopes. Now let ; and ? ;J@ and ? @ . A lattice polytope ! It follows easily that a polytope in ; lie in ; (Exercise 2.2.2).
@
and its dual
in the plane
be dual lattices with associated vector spaces ; @ is the convex hull of a finite set L ! ; . is a lattice polytope if and only if its vertices
+ is ( + 8 ( (
Example 2.2.4. The standard / -simplex in
Another simplex in
is
+ R = I> R = I>)4
4
8 , shown in Figure 3.
e1 + e2 + 3e3
0
e2
e1
Figure 3. The simplex
The lattice polytopes and are combinatorially equivalent but will give very different projective toric varieties.
§2.2. Lattice Points and Polytopes
67
Example 2.2.5. The Birkhoff polytope defined? in? Example 2.2.2 is a lattice polytope relative to the lattice of integer matrices since its vertices are the permu tation matrices, whose entries are all or .
One can show that faces of lattice polytopes are again lattice polytopes and that Minkowski sums and integer multiples of lattice polytopes are lattice polytopes (Exercise 2.2.2). Furthermore, every lattice is an intersection of closed " ( ( O polytope U R ' half-spaces defined over ; , i.e., where ' . ? and ' . .
When a lattice polytope is full dimensional, the facet presentation given in (2.2.1) has an especially nice form. If is a facet of , then the inward-pointing facet normals of lie on a rational ray in ?A@ . Let denote the unique ray * L R R * when , is a , generator. The corresponding is integral since K vertex of . It follows that
(2.2.2)
R ,. ; @ K , LXW R *
for all facets
is the unique facet presentation of the lattice polytope
.
R = I>)4 (
Example 2.2.6. Consider the square ( normals of are and and the facet presentation of
* Since the
R L W F K, ( X R L W F K, X
are all equal to , it follows that
lattice polytope. The polytopes
and
.
8 !
=.
of
. The facet is given by
R = I> 4 ( 8
is also a
are pictured in Figure 2.
It is rare that the dual of a lattice polytope is a lattice polytope—this is related to the reflexive polytopes that will be studied later in the book.
= I> 4 ( (
Example 2.2.7. The -simplex R in Example 2.2.4 has facet presentation
K , 4R
K, K, (R
R
L W K, X ( R LXW R LXW LXW
8 !
pictured
R
R
(Exercise 2.2.3). However, if we replace in the last inequality, we get 4 .8 , whichwith integer inequalities that define is not a lattice polytope.
The combinatorial type of a polytope is an interesting object of study. This leads to the question “Is every polytope combinatorially equivalent to a lattice polytope?” If the given polytope is simplicial, the answer is “yes”—just wiggle the vertices to make them rational and clear denominators to get a lattice polytope. The same argument works for simple polytopes by wiggling the facet normals. This will enable us to prove results about arbitrary simplicial or simple polytopes
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
68
using toric varieties. But in general, the answer is “no”—there exist polytopes in every dimension W not combinatorially equivalent to any lattice polytope. An example is described in [103, Ex. 6.21]. Normal Polytopes. The connection between lattice polytopes and toric varieties comes from the lattice points of the polytope. Unfortunately, a lattice polytope might not have enough lattice points. The -simplex from Example 2.2.7 has only four lattice points (its vertices), which implies that the projective toric variety $ * is just (Exercise 2.2.3).
We will explore two notions of what it means for a lattice polytope to “have enough lattice points.” Here is the first.
.
for all
4 A8 9 ;
.
is normal if
4 A8 9-; R 4*4
4 A 8
!; @
Definition 2.2.8. A lattice polytope
4 A8
8A8
4*4
9;
8A8
9; 9-; 4 ! 8 9-; is automatic. Thus The inclusion come from lattice points of normality means that all lattice points of and . In particular, a lattice polytope is normal if and only if
9-;
9-; R 4 A8 9 ;
times
for all integers W . In other words, normality says that has enough lattice points to generate the lattice points in all integer multiples of .
Lattice polytopes of dimension class of normal polytopes. Definition 2.2.9. A simplex R , , for vertices! , differences ,
are normal (Exercise 2.2.4). Here is another
is basic if has a vertex , such that the , of , form a subset of a -basis of ; .
;@
RP
, . is chosen. The standard This definition + + is independent of which vertex simplex is basic, and any basic simplex is normal (Exercise 2.2.5). More ! general simplicies, however, need not be normal. = I> )4 ( (
Example 2.2.10. Let R that the only lattice points ( of
(
R
4 8
8 !
. We noted earlier are its vertices. It follows easily that ( (
( 4 (8
is not the sum of lattice points of is not basic.
4 8
4 (
. This shows that
8
.
is not normal. In particular,
Here is an important result on normality. Theorem 2.2.11. Let !; @ be a full dimensional lattice polytope of dimension / W . Then is normal for all W / R .
§2.2. Lattice Points and Polytopes
69
Proof. This result was first explicitly stated in [12], though (as noted in [12]), its essential content follows from [28] and [64]. We will use ideas from [64] and [78] to show that 4 A8
8A8 9-; 9 ; 9-; R 4*4 R for all integers W / . In Exercise 2.2.6 you will prove that (2.2.3) implies that W is normal when / R . Note also that for (2.2.3), it suffices to show 4*4 8 A8 9 ; ! 4 A8 9-; 9;
(2.2.3)
since the other inclusion is obvious.
First consider the case where is a simplex with no interior lattice points. Let , + and take W / R . Then 4 8 has vertices the vertices of be , 4 8 , 4 8 , + , so that 4*4 8A8 9 ; is a convex a point , . combination
+ 4 8 + ' , ' where ' W & '( ' R ) 4 8 ' , then If we set ' R + + , R & '( ) ',-' where ) ' W & ')( ) ' R )
for some , then one easily sees that , R , ' . 4 &8 9 ; . Hence If ' W , R 4 , R ,-' 8 ,-' is the desired decomposition. On the other hand, if ) ' , R & '(
for all , then
+ / R 4 / +R 8 R & '( ) ' / R and & ')( ) ' R / . Now consider the lattice point so that R / + , R , , + 8 R , R & ')( 4 R ) ' 8 ,-' + 4 R ) 8 )
' ' R The coefficients are positive since for all , and their sum is & '(
R
0) R R , ' / / for . Hence is a lattice point in the interior of since
all . This contradicts our assumption on and completes the proof when lattice simplex containing no interior lattice points.
is a
To prove (2.2.3) for the general case, it suffices to prove that is a finite union of / -dimensional lattice simplices with no interior lattice points (Exercise 2.2.7). For this, we use Carath´eodory’s theorem (see [103, Prop. 1.15]), which asserts that $ !; @ , we have for a finite set
= I> ) 4 $ 8 R
$
= I> ) 4 8
! = I>)4 $ 8
where the union is over all subsets of affinely = I>! 4 consisting 8 is a simplex. independent elements. Thus each This enables us to write our lattice polytope as a finite union of / -dimensional lattice simplices.
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
70 If an / -dimensional lattice simplex lattice point , then +
#
R
' ' ( #
#
R = I> 4 + 8 #
has an interior
' R = I> 4 ' +2 8
is a finite union of / -dimensional lattice simplices, each of which has fewer interior lattice points than # since becomes a vertex of each # ' . By repeating this process on those # ' that still have interior lattice points, we can eventually write # and hence our original polytope as a finite union of / -dimensional lattice simplices with no interior lattice points. You will verify the details in Exercise 2.2.7.
This theorem shows that for the non-normal -simplex of Example 2.2.10, is normal. Here is another consequence of Theorem 2.2.11. its multiple Corollary 2.2.12. Every lattice polygon
!
is normal.
We can also interpret normality in terms of the cone
4 A8 R = I> 4 8 !;J@
introduced in Figure 3 of Chapter 1. The key feature of this cone is that is the 4 A8 at height , as illustrated in Figure 4. It follows that lattice points “slice” of ,. correspond to points 4 , 8 . 4 A8 9 4 ; X8 .
2P
height = 2
C(P) P
Figure 4. The cone
height = 1
sliced at heights
In Exercise 2.2.8 you will show that the semigroup 4 &8 points in relates to normality as follows.
and
4 A8 9 4 ; X8
of lattice
§2.2. Lattice Points and Polytopes
71
Lemma 2.2.13. Let ! ; @ be a lattice polytope. Then 4 9-; 8X generates the semigroup 4 A8 9 4 ; if
X8is. normal if and only ! ; X8 @ is normal if and only if 4 9 ; 8 is This lemma tells us that 4 A8 4 the Hilbert basis of . 9 ; = >I )4 ( ( Example 2.2.14. In Example 2.2.10, the simplex R 8 gives the cone 4 A8 ! . The Hilbert basis of 4 A8 9 4 ; X8 is 4 8 4 ( 8 4 8 4 ( 8 4 ( .8 4 ( .8
(Exercise 2.2.3). Since the Hilbert basis has generators of height greater than ,
Lemma 2.2.13 gives another proof that
is not normal.
+
In Exercise 2.2.9, you will generalize Lemma 2.2.13 as follows.
be a lattice polytope of dimension / W and Lemma 2.2.15. Let ! ; @ 4 &8 let be the maximum height of an element of the Hilbert basis of . Then:
(a) (b)
/ R .
is normal for any
W
.
The Hilbert basis of the simplex of Example 2.2.14 has maximum height . is normal. The paper [64] gives a Then Lemma 2.2.15 gives another proof that version of Lemma 2.2.15 that applies to Hilbert bases of more general cones. Very Ample Polytopes. Here is a slightly different notion of what it means for a polytope to have enough lattice points.
! ;@ is very ample if for every vertex Definition 2.2.16. A lattice polytope , . , the semigroup 2 $ P R &4 9J; R , 8 generated by 9J; R , R
, Z R , , Z . 9-; is saturated in ; .
This definition relates to normal polytopes as follows. Proposition 2.2.17. A normal lattice polytope
. Proof. Fix a vertex ,
is very ample.
, . ; such that , . 2 $ P for some 2 $ P
, . 2 $ P as integer W . To prove that ,. , write , R & P $ * P 4 , Z R , 8 * P . F so that @ W & P $ * P . Then Pick @ . , @ , R & P $ * P , Z @ R & P $ * P , . @ Dividing by gives , @ , . @ , which by normality implies that
and take
@ , R ' ( ? 4 R , ' & ( ( ,-' We conclude that ,
?
, ' . 9; for all ( ,-' R , 8 . 2 $ P , as desired.
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
72
+ ! ; @
Combining this with Theorem 2.2.11 and Corollary 2.2.12 gives the following. Corollary 2.2.18. Let
! W (a) If , then
! R (b) If , then
be a full dimensional lattice polytope.
is very ample for all
W / R
.
is very ample.
Part (a) was first proved in [28]. We will soon see that very ampleness is precisely the property needed to define the toric variety of a lattice polytope. The following example taken from [11, Ex. 5.1] shows that very ample polytopes need not be normal, i.e., the converse of Proposition 2.2.17 is false.
% R
Example 2.2.19. Given
in positions and elsewhere. % , letThus $ R % -< % -< % - % -< % -< %> -< %
= I> 4 $ 8
-
vector in with 4 denote the 8 . Then let - % -< % -<%
!
The lattice polytope R lies in the affine hyperplane of where the coordinates sum to . As explained in [11], this configuration can be interpreted in terms of a triangulation of the real projective plane.
$
The points of of are the only lattice points of (Exercise 2.2.10), so that ( , ( . Then $ is the set of vertices of . Number the( points of ( as ,
$
4 8 R (
'( (
( ( 4 , '8 ( '(
,-' R
4 8 . . Since is not a sum of lattice points of R % - is not in $ ), we conclude that is not a
shows that R % - . $ , the vector (when normal polytope.
4 .8 is! very ample takes more work. The first step is to prove 4 A8 9 that , is a Hilbert basis of the semigroup 4 A8 where ! is the cone over . We used the software 4ti2 [47]. 2 $ P :R ,-' Now be the semigroup generated by the , . Take fix and let 2 $ P , . such that , . . As in the proof of Proposition 2.2.17, this implies that , @ ,-' . @ for some @ . . Thus 4 , @ , ' @ 8 . 4 A8 9 . Expressing $
Showing that
(
this in terms of the above Hilbert basis easily implies that
, R * 4 R5 ,-' 8
RQ
( ( * .4 ,
2 $ P
R ,-' 8
* * . F
2 $ P
,' . If we can show that , then , . follows immediately and 2 $ P
R proves that is saturated. When , one can check that % - R % - % - % -<
which implies that
R , ( R 4 , %R , ( 8
4, R , ( 8
4,
R , ( 8 . 2 $ P
§2.2. Lattice Points and Polytopes
73
R
One obtains similar formulas for the proof that is very ample.
(Exercise 2.2.10), which completes
The polytope has further interesting properties. For example, up to affine equivalence, can be described as the convex hull of the 10 points in given by
4 8 4 8 4 8 4 4 8 4 8 4 8 4
8 4 8
8 4 8 , this polytope ( has the Of all -dimensional polytopes whose vertices lie in
R , every pair most edges, namely (see [1]). Since it has vertices and of distinct vertices is joined by an edge. Such polytopes are -neighborly.
Exercises for §2.2. 2.2.1. Let point.
be a polytope of maximal dimension with the origin as an interior
( / O 2 M# for all facets 8 . Prove that U( ! p& 'p O a facet' . (b) Prove that the dual of a simplicial polytope is simple and vice versa. (c) Prove that I ':(Lp ' for all . (a) Write and that
for all
(d) Use part (c) to construct an example of a lattice polytope whose dual is not a lattice polytope.
& be a polytope. L( L'
2.2.2. Let
(a) Prove that is a lattice polytope if and only if the vertices of lie in (b) Prove that is a lattice polytope if and only if is the convex hull of its lattice points, . i.e., (c) Prove that every face of a lattice polytope is a lattice polytope.
(d) Prove that Minkowski sums and integer multiples of lattice polytopes are again lattice polytopes.
( ! A 2 2 4 2 4 .- o ' o be the simplex studied in Exam given in Example 2.2.7. (b) Show that the only lattice points of are its vertices. (c) Show that the toric variety is o . (d) Show that the vectors given in Example 2.2.14 form the Hilbert basis of gI '
2.2.3. Let ples 2.2.4, 2.2.7, 2.2.10 and 2.2.14. (a) Verify the facet presentation of
' .
2.2.4. Prove that every one-dimensional lattice polytope is normal. 2.2.5. Recall the definition of basic simplex given in Definition 2.2.9. (a) Show that if a simplex satisfies Definition 2.2.9 for one vertex, then it satisfies the definition for all vertices.
is basic. (b) Show that the standard simplex (c) Prove that a basic simplex is normal.
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
74
2.2.6. Let & be an -dimensional lattice polytope. (a) Prove that (2.2.3) implies that
B I' * I' ( n B% 7' I' for all integers B . #f and f . Hint: When ( ( , we have BI' B I' C ( I' B% (m' I' + Apply (2.2.3) twice on the right. (b) Use part (a) to prove that B is normal when B . #- . 2.2.7. Let & be an -dimensional lattice polytope. (a) Follow the hints given in the text to give a careful proof that is a finite union of -dimensional lattice simplices with no interior lattice points. (b) In the text, we showed that (2.2.3) holds for an -dimensional lattice simplex with no interior lattice points. Use this and part (a) to show that (2.2.3) for
.
2.2.8. Prove Lemma 2.2.13.
B
2.2.9. In this exercise you will prove Lemma 2.2.15. As in the lemma, let be the maximum height of a generator of the Hilbert basis of . (a) Adapt the proof of Gordan’s Lemma (Proposition 1.2.17) to show that if is the Hilbert basis of the semigroup of lattice points in a strongly convex cone , then the lattice points in the cone can be written as the union
g I'
(b) Conclude that
, ) w
`?m C'
, m+
gI' .U'Q( ) +! + 23,+F' m2 where (,In L' /1m8&' . (c) Use part (b) to show that (2.2.3) holds for B B . C' from Example 2.2.19. 2.2.10. Consider the polytope N( (a) Prove that is the set of lattice points of (b) Complete the proof begun in the text that
. is very ample.
2.2.11. Prove that every proper face of a simplicial polytope is a simplex.
B
B N#V
2.2.12. In Corollary 2.2.18 we proved that is very ample for using Theorem 2.2.11 and Proposition 2.2.17. Give a direct proof of the weaker result that is very ample for sufficiently large. Hint: A vertex gives the cone generated by the semigroup defined in Definition 2.2.16. The cone is strongly convex since for is a vertex and hence has a Hilbert basis. Furthermore, all . Now argue that when is large, ' contains the Hilbert basis of . A picture will help.
B
B
g [ g [ C( g A [ A
g[ g [ B , B B I' # B g [ ! A 2 2 4 2 o 'a o . 2.2.13. Fix an integer and consider the - -simplex L( (a) Work out the facet presentation of and verify that the facet normals can be labeled so that (C . 4 o (b) Show that is normal. Hint: Show that yo * B I' o)( n B%*E' I' o . We will see later that the toric variety of is the weighted projective space p126126m2 W' . [
§2.3. Polytopes and Projective Toric Varieties
75
§2.3. Polytopes and Projective Toric Varieties Our next task is to define the toric variety of a lattice polytope. As noted in §2.2, we need to make sure that the polytope has enough lattice points. Hence we begin with very ample polytopes. Strongly convex rational polyhedral cones will play an important role in our development. The Very Ample Case. Let very ample polytope ! ; !@ be a full dimensional R R / . If 9J ;5 8 " , " ( ( , " , then relative to the lattice ; , and let $ is the Zariski closure of P the image ofP the map given by (
4 8 4 8 . " " R '(*' " for / " " ( . Fix homogeneous coordinates "" ( We examine the structure of using Propositions 2.1.8 and 2.1.9. ! '
('
$
For each ,'/.
9-;
consider the semigroup
2 ' R & 4 9-; R ,-' 8 1R ,-' , . 9 ; 8" " ( we have the affine open subset generated ( by , for . In 4 ' " " consisting of those points where ' ' R P . Proposition 2.1.8 showed that $ 9 4 ' of $ is the affine toric variety the affine open piece BC D.47F% 2 ' - 8 $ 9 4 '
9 ' R P . Here is our first major result about Theorem 2.3.1. Let be the projective toric variety of the very ample poly ! R /. tope !;J@ , and assume that is full dimensional with 9 ; , the affine piece 9 ' is the affine toric (a) For each vertex , ' . variety 9 ' R 3 R B9C D.47&% 6 ' 7 9 ; - 8 and Proposition 2.1.9 showed that
$
4
$
$
vertex of $
$
$
4
$
4
4
6 I>' ! 4 ? @ is R the strongly convex rational polyhedral cone dual to the
8 , ' 9 ; ! ;V@ . Furthermore, ! 6 ' R / . $ 5 . (b) The torus of has character lattice ; and hence is the torus = I> 4 , ' is a vertex, it has a supporting Proof. Let ' R 9V; O R U , ' 8 . Since O O R ,-' . It follows that O is hyperplane such that ! and 9 ' (Exercise 2.3.1), so that ' is strongly convex. a supporting hyperplane of .
! ' R ! It is also easy to see that (Exercise 2.3.1). It follows that ' and 6 ' R ' 7 are strongly convex rational polyhedral cones of dimension / . 2 ' 9V; R 6 ' 7 9V; . By hypothesis, is very ample, which We have ' ! 2 2 means that ' ! ; is saturated. Since ' and ' R 6 ' 7 are both generated by where = cone
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
76
2 R ,-' , part (a) of Exercise 1.3.4 implies ' R 6' 7 9 ;
9 ;
. (This exercise was part of the proof of the characterization of normal affine toric varieties given in Theorem 1.3.5.) Part (a) of the theorem follows immediately.
' and
For part (b), Theorem 1.2.18 implies that 4 5 ! 4 3 R $ strongly convex. Then 9 $ . the torus of
5 is the torus of 4 3 since 6 ' is 5 is also ' ! $ shows that
$
The affine pieces intersect in 9 9 9 ' 9 order to describe this intersection carefully, we need to study how the cones 6 6 fit together in ?G@ . This leads to our next topic.
$
4
$
4
4
4
'
. In and
The Normal Fan. The cones 6 ' ! ? @ appearing in Theorem 2.3.1 fit together in a remarkably nice way, giving a structure called the normal fan of . Let !; @ be a full dimensional lattice polytope, not necessarily very ample. Faces, facets and vertices of will be denoted by # , and respectively. Hence we write the facet presentation of as
R , . ;J@ K , LXW R *
(2.3.1)
A vertex
(When R containing
.
gives cones
R = I> 4 9 ; R 8 ! ;V@
and correspond bijectively to faces Q R+ Q R = I> 4 # #
(2.3.2)
Q
R+
R 4Q
#
6 R
and
, ' , these are the cones '
!
89
6 '
9-;
.
for all
R
7
! ? @
studied above.) Faces via the maps
! #
8
which are inverses of each other. These maps preserve dimensions, inclusions, and intersections (Exercise 2.3.2), as illustrated in Figure 5 on the next page. In particular, all facets of
come from facets of
R , . ;V@ K , LXW
for all
containing
By the duality results of Chapter 1, it follows that the dual cone 6
= 6 R I> 4
6"!
R = I> 4
8
contains
This construction generalizes to arbitrary faces
! #
containing , so that
.
is given by
by setting
contains
#
8
R since is the cone Thus the cone 6 is the ray generated by , and 6 generated by the empty set. Here is our main result about these cones. Theorem 2.3.2. Let
6"! # is a face of (a) For all 6
!
. Y%$
(b) The intersection
$
; @ be a full dimensional lattice polytope and set !. Then:
, each face of 6
6 ! 9 6
!
Y%$
of any two cones in Y . !
is also in
$
is a face of each.
Y
$
R
§2.3. Polytopes and Projective Toric Varieties
77
P Cv
v 0
Figure 5. The cone
of a vertex
A collection of strongly convex rational polyhedral cones satisfying conditions (a) and (b) of Theorem 2.3.2 is called a fan. General fans will be introduced in Y $ are built from the inward-pointing Chapter 3. Since the cones in the above fan % Y $ normal vectors , we call the normal fan or inner normal fan of .
The following easy lemma will be useful in the proof of Theorem 2.3.2.
O be a supporting affine hyperplane ! O 9 . ) , ) W . Then Proof. First suppose that . 6 ! and write R & ! R & ) * easily implies that ! O U and # ! .O 9 . setting R ! * come from the facet presentation (2.3.1). Recall that the integers O 9 . Take a vertex . # . Then Going the other way, suppose that # ! U U O O O . 7 R 6 , so that ! and imply that ! . Hence . R & ) ) W Let be a facet of containing but not # , and pick . # with . . Then . # ! . O imply that R K L R & ) K L R K L R & ) K L R R & ) * R * for . . These equations imply where the last equality uses K L R & ) K L R R & ) *
Lemma 2.3.3. Let # be a face of of . Then . 6"! if and only if #
and let
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
78
However, . gives K L ) R follows that whenever proof of the lemma. Corollary 2.3.4. If
#
is a face of #
, and since K AL W R * for all , it ! P . This gives . 6 and completes the . 6 if and only if ! . , then R *
!
"!
#
Proof. One direction is obvious by the definition of 6 ! , and the other direction O " follows from Lemma 2.3.3 since is a supporting affine hyperplane of " O with 9 R .
Theorem 2.3.2 is an immediate corollary of the the following proposition. Proposition 2.3.5. Let ! ; @ . Then:
!
Z
and #
if and only if 6
Z
#
!
be faces of a full dimensional lattice polytope
6"!
Z (b) If # ! # , then 6 ! is a face of 6"! , and all faces of 6 ! are of this form. ZZ Z (c) 6"!9 6 ! R 6 ! , where # is the smallest face of containing # and # . Z Z Proof. To prove part (a), note that if # ! # , then any facet containing # also (a)
#
#
!
.
contains # , which implies 6 ! ! 6! . The other direction follows easily from Corollary 2.3.4 since every face is the intersection of the facets containing it by Proposition 2.2.1.
For part (b), fix a vertex . # and note that by (2.3.2), # determines a face Q of . Using the duality of Proposition 1.2.10, Q gives the dual face
QM
of the cone obtains
6
. Then using 6
7
QI
9
R = I> 4
R = I> 4
QM
R
O
R 6 9
.
Q
.
QI
8
! O
and Q
Since . # , the inclusion Q ! is equivalent to turn is equivalent to # ! . It follows that
QM
(2.3.3)
Z
R = I> 4
#
! O
R 6 7
"
, one
, which in
8R 6
!
#
8
!
"!
arise in this way. ! 6 In particular, ! means that 6 is also a face of 6 , and since 6 by part (a), we see that 6 a face of 6 . Furthermore, every face of 6 a face for some face isZ . Using of 6 by Proposition 1.2.6 and hence is of the form 6 so that 6"! is a face of 6 , and all faces of 6 #
-#
!
!
!
part (a) again, we see that
ZZ
!
#
!
!
Z , and part (b) follows.
#
!
#
!
Z
For part (c), let # be the smallest face of containing # and # . This exists Z Z is the interbecause a face is the intersection of the facets containing it, so that # Z Z Z R ). section of all facets containing # and # (if there are no such facets, then # By part (b) 6 ! is a facet of both 6 ! and 6 ! . Thus 6 ! ! 6"!9 6 ! .
§2.3. Polytopes and Projective Toric Varieties
79
It remains to prove the opposite inclusion. If 6 ! 9V6 ! R R 6 , then Z Z R and we are done. If 6 ! 9 6 ! R P , any nonzero in the intersection # lies in both 6"! and 6 ! . The proof of Proposition 2.3.6 given below will show that O. . By Lemma 2.3.3, is a supporting affine hyperplane of for some . . 6"! and . 6 ! imply that # and # Z lie in O. 9 . The latter is a face of Z Z Z ! O. 9 since # Z Z is the smallest such face. containing # and # , so that # Applying Lemma 2.3.3 again, we see that . 6 ! .
$
Proposition 2.3.5 shows that there is a bijective correspondence between faces Y $ of and cones of the normal fan . Here are some further properties of this correspondence. Proposition 2.3.6. Let ! ; sion / and consider the cones
(a) (b)
!
? @ R
#
@
be a full dimensional lattice polytope of dimenY $ of . Then: in the normal fan
6 !
! R 6 ! / for all faces # " $ R 3 6 6! 6 vertex of
of
.
.
Proof. Let # be a face of and take a vertex of # . By (2.3.2) this gives a face Q of the cone , which has a dual face Q M of the dual cone 7 R 6 . Since QM R 6"! by (2.3.3), we have
!
#
! 6
!
R
Q
!
R /
QM
where the first equality uses Exercise 2.3.2 and the second follows from Proposition 1.2.10. This part (a). For part (b), U let . ? @ be nonzero and set K L proves = O and . O for at least one =R vertex of . Then ! vertex of , so that . 6 by Lemma 2.3.3. The final equality of part (b) follows immediately.
A fan satisfying the condition of part (b) of Proposition 2.3.6 is called complete. Thus the normal fan of a lattice polytope is always complete. We will learn more about complete fans in Chapter 3. An important observation is that the normal fan in Example 2.3.9 doesn’t de pend on the integer . In general, multiplying a polytope by a positive integer has no effect on its normal fan, and the same is true for translations by lattice points. We record these properties in the following proposition (Exercise 2.3.3). Proposition 2.3.7. Let ! ; @ be a full dimensional lattice polytope. Then for
any lattice point ,. ; and any integer W , the polytopes , and have the same normal fan as .
Examples of Normal Fans. Here are some examples of normal fans.
Example 2.3.8. Figure 6 on the next page shows a lattice hexagon in the plane ( , with corre together with its normal fan. The vertices of are labeled ( 6 in the normal fan. In the figure, is shown on the left, sponding cone 6
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
80
and at each vertex ' , we have drawn the normal vectors of the facets containing ' and shaded the cone 6 ' they generate. On the right, these cones are assembled at the origin to give the normal fan.
v5
v4 σ3
σ2
v6 v3
v1
σ4
ΣP
P
σ1 σ5
v2 Figure 6. A lattice hexagon
and its normal fan
σ6
Notice how one can read off the structure of from the normal fan. For Y $ example, two cones 6 ' and 6 share a ray in if and only if the vertices ' and lie on an edge of .
(
Example 2.3.9. The -simplex for ! has vertices Y . $Let R some positive integer . Figure 7 shows and its normal fan . At each vertex
v2 ΣP
P
v0
σ0 σ2
v1
Figure 7. The triangle
' of
σ1
and its normal fan
, we have drawn the normal vectors of the facets containing ' and shaded Y $ the cone 6 ' they generate. The reassembled cones appear on the left as .
Here is an example of the normal fan of a polytope in
.
4 8 .
Example 2.3.10. Consider the cube with vertices ( , and the ! facet presentation facet normals are of
K , ' LXW R
is
The
§2.3. Polytopes and Projective Toric Varieties
81
The origin is an interior point of . By Exercise 2.2.1, the facet normals are the vertices of the dual polytope , the octahedron pictured in Figure 8. z
z
y
y
P
P˚ x
x
Figure 8. A cube
and its dual octahedron
However, the facet normals also give the normal fan of , and one can check that in the above figure, the maximal cones of the normal fan are the octants of , which are just the cones over the facets of the dual polytope .
As noted earlier, it is rare that both and are lattice polytopes. However, !;J@ is a lattice polytope containing whenever an interior point, it is Y $ are theascones over the facets of still true that maximal cones of the normal fan ! ? @ (Exercise 2.3.4).
.
The special behavior of the polytopes and and 2.3.10 leads to the following definition.
discussed in Examples 2.2.6
Definition 2.3.11. A full dimensional lattice polytope facet presentation is
R , . ;J@ K , L W R
If is reflexive, then is a lattice point of * R for all point of (Exercise 2.3.5). Since
Thus
R = I> ) 4
! ;G@
for all facets
is reflexive if its
.
and is the only interior lattice , Exercise 2.2.1 implies that
facet of
A8
is a lattice polytope and is in fact reflexive (Exercise 2.3.5).
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
82
We will see later that reflexive polytopes lead to some very interesting toric varieties that are important for mirror symmetry.
$
The General Case. Earlier in the section, we studied the toric variety of a $ . This development very ample polytope and described the affine pieces of leaves one item of unfinished business: What is the intersection of two + of the affine pieces described in Theorem 2.3.1?
To study let !; R 9-this, ; . Then
@
be an / -dimensional very ample polytope and set
"" ( ! "" ( ' P Label the homogeneous as for ,. 9 ; . If is a vertex ( coordinates of 8 " ' " of , then ! is the affine open subset where R P , and Theorem 2.3.1
$
4
3 R B9C D47&% 7 6 9 ; -8 $ 9 4 is the affine toric variety of the cone 6 in the normal fan Y $ of So Proposition 2.3.12. Let ! ; @ be full dimensional and very ample. If R P $
tells us that
9
4
R
4
9 9 R 3 R and the inclusions 9 9 9 are vertices of
and
#
is the smallest face of 4
$
3 4
(2.3.4)
4
4
$
can be written
4
4
$
4 4 3 8
R
containing
and
BC D47A% 6 7 9; - 8 ! 4
!
3 R 4 4 3 8 4
!
, then
9 4
$
.
3
4
$
Proof. We analyzed the intersection of affine pieces of in §2.1. Translated to the notation being used here, (2.1.6) and (2.1.7) imply that
$
9 4
3 9 4 R 4 4 8
R 44 3 8
4 4 3 8 R 4 3 R . R 6 7 , so that H R O " 96 is a face of 6 . In However, we have this situation, Proposition 1.3.16 and equation (1.3.4) imply that 44 3 8 R 4 O " 9 6 R 6 ! . Thus the proposition will follow once we prove H R 6 ! , i.e., Since 6"! R 6 9 6 by Proposition 2.3.5, it suffices to prove that O " 9 6 R 6 9 6 O " 9V6 O Let . . If R P , there is . is a supporting affine O such O Thus all we need to show is that
hyperplane of . Then . 6 implies . by Lemma 2.3.3, so that . O " . Applying Lemma 2.3.3 again, we get . 6 . Going the other since .
§2.3. Polytopes and Projective Toric Varieties
83
R P , pick . as above. Then . 6 9V6 and . O , from which . O " follows easily. This
way, let . 6 9 6 . If Lemma 2.3.3 imply that completes the proof.
This proposition and Theorem 2.3.1 have the remarkable result that the normal Y $ $ $ fan completely determines the internal structure of : we build 4 3 from local pieces given by the affine toric varieties( , glued together via (2.3.4). "" for any of this—everything we We don’t need the ambient projective space need to know is contained in the normal fan.
As a consequence, we can now give the general definition of the toric variety of a polytope. Definition 2.3.13. Let define
where
! ;@
be a full dimensional lattice polytope. Then we
$ R
$
is any positive integer such that
is very ample.
Such integers exist by Corollary 2.2.18, and if and are two such integers, Y $ R then and have the same normal fan by Proposition 2.3.7, namely Y $ R Y $ $ $ . It follows that while and lie in different projective 4 3 glued together via (2.3.4). spaces, they are built from the affine toric varieties Once we develop the language of abstract varieties in Chapter 3, we will see that $ is well-defined as an abstract variety.
$
We will often speak of without regard to the projective embedding. When $ we want to use a specific embedding, we will say “ is embedded using ”, is very ample. In Chapter 6 we will use the language of where we assume that $ such that $ divisors and line bundles to restate this in terms of a divisor on $ is very ample precisely when is.
Here is a simple example to illustrate the difference between $ as sitting in a specific projective space. variety and
$
as an abstract
+
+
! Example 2.3.14. Consider the / -simplex . We can define using + + + W
for any integer since and hence very ample. The lattice U + R is normal F% ( +.- of total monomials points in correspond to the of ( + + " "
R R degree / . This gives an embedding . When , ! 9 ( , +
implies that +
R
The normal fan of ! can regard
+ in Exercise 2.3.6. 8" " is( described as the image of the map $ + R " " (
For an arbitrary
W , we
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
84
F% ' *' + -
defined using all monomials of total degree in (Exercise 2.3.6). It follows that this map is an embedding, usually called the Veronese embedding. But + when we forget the embedding, the underlying toric variety is just .
The Veronese embedding allows us to construct some interesting affine open + F% ' *' + - be nonzero and homogeneous of degree( subsets of . Let O . ' . We write the homogeneous coordinates of " " as and write O R & ( " R for . Then R & ( is a nonzero linear form in the variables " " ( /" " ( S 354 8 , so that is a copy of (Exercise 2.3.6). If follows that
+ S 5 3 4 O 8 $ 4 + 8 9 " " ( S 354 8 + has a richer supply of is an affine variety (usually not toric). This shows+ that S 354 ' ' 8 considered earlier in affine open subsets than just the open sets ' R 4
the chapter.
+ later in the + book, we will see the When we explain the construction of + Proj intrinsic reason why S 354 O 8 is an affine open subset of . + Example 2.3.15. The -dimensional analog of the rational normal curve is the L rational normal scroll , which is the toric variety of the polygon = >I 4 * ( ( 8 R !
* * and its normal fan are where . satisfy . The polygon R
pictured in Figure 9.
v2 = e2 P = P2,4 v1 = 0
σ4
v3 = 4e1 + e2
σ1
ΣP
σ3 σ2
v4 = 2e1
Figure 9. The polygon of a rational normal scroll and its normal fan
*
lattice points and gives the map 47 M 8 +R U U ( 4 8 4 8 !L R $ is the Zariski closure of the image. To describe the image, such that we rewrite the map as ( R+ U U ( 4 . )) 8 4 )) )) ) ) 8 In general, the polygon
has
§2.3. Polytopes and Projective Toric Varieties
4 ) 8
4 8
85
4 8
R , the map is , which When is the * coordinates of U U ( . In the rational normal curve mapped to the first 4 ) 8 R 4 8 gives same way, ( the rational normal curve mapped to the last
U U coordinates of . If we think of these two curves as the “edges” of a 4 )) 8 . ( vary gives scroll, then fixing gives a point on each edge, and letting the line of the scroll connecting the two points. So it really is a scroll!
important observation is that the normal fan depends only on the difference R An * , since this determines the slope of the slanted edge of . If we denote the , it follows that as abstract toric varieties, we have difference by . $ R $ R $ R
since they are all constructed from the same normal fan. In Chapter 3, we will see < that this is the Hirzebruch surface . (
L
U U
*
But if we think of the projective surface ! , then and have a unique meaning. For example, they have a strong influence defining equa U U ( ' onthe L * ' tions of . Let the homogeneous coordinates of be 4* 8 and consider the matrix
!
' ')( ' " ( ( " ( )' ( ' ' ( 624
Example 2.3.15 is another example of a determinantal variety, as is the rational + normal curve from Example 2.0.1. Note that the rational normal curve comes ( % ( from the polytope / R / , where the underlying toric variety is just .
Exercises for §2.3.
U
1[ <
2.3.1. This exercise will use the same notation as the proof of Theorem 2.3.1. (a) Let be a supporting hyperplane of a vertex "+ + porting hyperplane of
g (b) Prove that zW{}|-g + (Vz`{ | .
. Prove that
m[
is a sup-
2.3.2. Consider the maps defined in (2.3.2). (a) Show that these maps are inverses of each other and define a bijection between the faces of the cone and the faces of containing - .
g
(b) Prove that these maps preserve dimensions, inclusions, and intersections. (c) Explain how this exercise relates to Exercise 2.3.1. 2.3.3. Prove Proposition 2.3.7.
2.3.4. Let & be an -dimensional lattice polytope containing as an interior point, and let be its dual polytope. Prove that the normal fan consists of the cones over the faces of . Hint: Exercise 2.2.1 will be useful.
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
86
(b) Prove that
2.3.5. Let & be a reflexive polytope. (a) Prove that is the only interior lattice point of
.
is reflexive.
26+7+6+92 ! ` ? F ) ' C/ 2 26+7+6+92 8 (N# 9 L ( 12 `2 ! is given by the map (b) For an integer B i , show that the variety 6A #h ! defined using all monomials ofAtotal degree B in H d 26+6+7+62 d J . 2.3.7. Let be an -dimensional lattice polytope and let be a face. Prove the following intrinsic description of the cone f : (L/7 O 2 2 for all 2 8 +
2.3.6. This exercise is concerned with Example 2.3.14
be the standard basis of . Prove that the normal fan of the standard (a) Let -simplex consists of the cones for all proper subsets , where ( - . + + . Draw pictures of the normal fan for
2.3.8. Prove that all lattice rectangles in the plane with edges parallel to the coordinate axes have the same normal fan.
§2.4. Properties of Projective Toric Varieties We conclude this chapter by studying when the projective toric variety polytope is smooth or normal.
$
of a
Normality. Recall from §2.1 that a projective variety is projectively normal if its affine cone is normal. Theorem 2.4.1. Let (a) (b)
$ $
! ; @
be a full dimensional lattice polytope. Then:
is normal.
is projectively normal under the embedding given by is normal.
if and only if
$
4
3
Proof. Part (a) is immediate since is the union of affine pieces , a vertex 4 3 of , and is normal by Theorem 1.3.5. In Chapter 3 we will give an intrinsic definition of normality that will make this argument completely rigorous.
For part (b), the discussion following (2.1.4) shows that the projective em $ $ $ ( . By bedding of given by has affine cone given by 4*4 A8 9 ; 8X Theorem 1.3.5, this is normal if and only if the semigroup 4 A8 A8 * 4 4 8
is saturated in ; , and since , this is 9# ;
generates the cone 4 A8 &8 4 8
9 ;
generates the semigroup 9 4 ; MX8 . equivalent to saying that Then we are done by Lemma 2.2.13.
Smoothness. Given the results of Chapter 1, the smoothness of to determine. We need one definition.
$
is equally easy
§2.4. Properties of Projective Toric Varieties
Definition 2.4.2. Let
'
!;@
87
'
be a lattice polytope.
'
(a) Given a vertex of and an edge containing , let be the first lattice point of different from encountered as one tranverses starting at . In = I> 4 R 8 R other words, is the ray generator of the ray . (b)
! Theorem 2.4.3. Let following are equivalent:
; @
(b) (c)
R
'
is smooth if for every vertex , the vectors , where is an edge of
! R ! ; @ , containing , form a subset of a basis of ; . In particular, if R form a basis of ; . then the vectors We can now characterize when
(a)
'
$
Y
$
is smooth.
be a full dimensional lattice polytope. Then the
is a smooth projective variety.
$
is a smooth fan, meaning that every cone in Definition 1.2.16.
Y $
is smooth in the sense of
is a smooth polytope.
Proof. Smoothness is a local condition, so that a variety is smooth if and only if its $ is smooth if and only if 4 3 is smooth for every local pieces are smooth. Thus 4 3 vertex of , and is smooth if and only if 6 is smooth. Since faces of smooth Y $ consists of the 6 and their faces, the equivalence (a) cones are smooth and (b) follows immediately.
R 67 is For (b) (c), first observe that 6 is smooth if and only if its dual smooth. The discussion following (2.3.2) makes it easy to see that the ray genera R tors of are the vectors from Definition 2.4.2. It follows immediately that is smooth if and only if is smooth for every vertex , and we are done.
The theorem makes it easy to check the smoothness of simple examples such as the toric variety of the hexagon in Example 2.3.8 or the rational normal scroll L of Example 2.3.15 (Exercise 2.4.1).
We also note the following useful fact, which you will prove in Exercise 2.4.2. Proposition 2.4.4. Every smooth full dimensional lattice polytope ample.
!; @
is very
One can also ask whether every smooth lattice polytope is normal. This is an important open problem in the study of lattice polytopes. Here is an example of a smooth reflexive polytope whose dual is not smooth.
4
8 + R 4 8 ! + , where + is the standard + and have the same normal fan, so
Example 2.4.5. Let R / Proposition 2.3.7 implies that / -simplex. $ that and are smooth.
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
88
The polytope has the following interesting properties (Exercise 2.4.3). First, has the facet presentation
' ' W RF R / R' ( R R ',+ W F R
so that
is reflexive with dual
R = I> 4 ( + 8
R R ( R
The normal fan of consists of cones over the faces of Y $ corresponding to the vertex . is the cone of
6 Figure 10 shows
R = I>)4 ( +98
' R
and the cone 6 when /
R
4/
R +2
. In particular, the cone
8 '
.
v2 e2 σe0
P˚ e1
P e0
v1
Figure 10. The cone of the normal fan of
R
4
8 4 R 8
R / + ( ' + . This makes it easy For general / , observe that ' ( + 4
8 " in . Thus 6 is not smooth to see that has index / . It follows that the “dual” toric variety $ is singular for / W . when / W + $ Later we will construct as the quotient of under the action of a finite group + ( 47 4 / 8 X8 " .
(
$
is the Zariski closure of the image. If , then we have
R = I> 4 ( 8 ! . Since very ample, the ( ( give the map 47 M 8 is defined by 4 8 R+ 4 . 8
Example 2.4.6. Consider R lattice points 9 such that nates
$
R 354
R
has homogeneous coordi-
(8 ! $
Comparing this to Example 2.0.5, we see that the weighted projective space 4 .8 . Later we will learn the systematic reasonis why this is true.
§2.4. Properties of Projective Toric Varieties
89
$
The variety is not smooth. By working on the affine piece 4 8 is a singular point of $ . can check directly that
9 $
4
, one
We can also use Theorem 2.4.3 and the normal fan of , shown in Figure 11. ( Y $ One can check that the cones 6 and 6 are smooth, but 6 is not, so that is
v2 ΣP
P
v0
σ0
σ1
σ2
v1
Figure 11. The polygon giving
and its normal fan
not a smooth fan. In terms of , note that the vectors to the first lattice from points along the edges containing do not generate . Either way, Theorem 2.4.3 $ is not smooth. implies that
If you look carefully, you will see that 6 is the only nonsmooth cone of the Y $ . Once we study the correspondence between cones and orbits in normal fan Chapter 3, we will see that the non-smooth cone 6 corresponds to the singular 4
8 $ point of .
Products of Projective Toric Varieties. Our final task+ is to understand the toric 4 8 be lattice polytopes with variety of a product of polytopes. Let ' ! ; ' @
' R ' / ( for R . This gives a lattice polytope (X ! 4 ; (% ; 8 @ of / . dimension /
(
Replacing and with suitable multiples, we can assume that are very ample. This gives projective embeddings (
(
and
" " ' R ' 9-; ' is a subvariety of " " ( " " ( . Using so that by Proposition 2.0.4, the Segre embedding " " ( " " ( " " ( R (
$
$
we get an embedding (2.4.1)
$
$
- " " ( $
We can understand this projective variety as follows.
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
90
Theorem 2.4.7. If
(
and
are very ample, then
( (a) ! 4 ; ; 8 @ is a very ample polytope with lattice points 4 ( 8 9 4 ; ( ; 8 R 4 ( 9-; ( 8 54 9 ; 8 4 ( 8 9 4 ; ( ; 8 . Thus the integer defined above is R $ T $ " " ( coming from the very ample (b) The image of the embedding ( polytope equals the image of (2.4.1). $ $ $ $. (c)
(
Proof. For part (a), the assertions about lattice points are clear. The vertices of ( 2 4 ( 8 where ' is a vertex of ' (Exercise 2.4.4). consist of ordered pairs Given such a vertex, we have
4 H(
4 ( 8 R &4
8 9 4 ; ( ; 8 R 4 M( 9-; ( R ( 8X 54 9-; %R 8 ' 9 ; ' R ' 8 is saturated in ; ' . From Since ' is very ample, we know that ( here, it follows easily that is very ample.
5
$
5
For part (b), let 5 # 5 be the torus of . Since $ # it follows that is Zariski dense in combined with the Segre embedding, it follows that closure of the image of the map ( given by the characters Z and , ranges over the P 5 5 , the product ' coincides with the map
P ' P
'
'
R 5 5 1
$
"""
$
is Zariski dense in , (Exercise 2.4.4). When $ $ is the Zariski
(
(
(
, where , ranges over the elements of ; 5 8 5 9with elements of 9G; . When we identify P P P ' becomes the character , so that the above map
5 R "" (
5
(
coming from the product polytope part (c) is an immediate consequence.
( ! 4; ;
8@
. Part (b) follows, and
+ + Example 2.4.8. is the toric variety of the standard / -simplex , it + Since P + P is the toric variety of . ( follows that ( ( is the toric This also works for more than two factors. Thus Here is an obvious example.
variety of the cube pictured in Figure 8.
To have a complete theory of products, we need to know what happens to the normal fan. Here is the result, whose proof is left to the reader (Exercise 2.4.5). Proposition 2.4.9. Let
. Then
' ! 4; '8@ Y $
be full dimensional lattice polytopes for
R Y 0 1Y $
$
$
R
§2.4. Properties of Projective Toric Varieties
91
Here is an easy example. Example 2.4.10. The normal fan of an interval given by
6
(
%* - !
(
, where
*
in
, is
6
The corresponding toric variety is . The cartesian ( ( product of two such intervals by Theorem 2.4.7. If we set is a lattice rectangle whose toric variety is '6 R 6 ' 6 , then Proposition 2.4.9 gives the normal fan given in Figure 12.
σ10
σ00
σ11
σ01
Figure 12. The normal fan of a lattice rectangle giving
We will revisit this example in Chapter 3 when we construct toric varieties directly from fans.
Proposition 2.4.9 suggests a different way to think about the product. Let ' range over the vertices of ' . Then the 6 are the maximal cones in the normal fan Y$ , which implies that
R 3 R 3
(2.4.2) Thus
$
$
4
$
R
4
3 3 3 3
R
4
R
4
4
4
3
4
3
R $ $
In this sequence of equalities, the first follows from (2.4.2), the second is obvious, the third uses Exercise 1.3.12, the fourth uses Proposition 2.4.9, and the last follows 4 ( 8 ranges over all vertices of ( . since
This argument shows that we can construct cartesian products of varieties using affine open covers, which reduces to the cartesian product of affine varieties defined in Chapter 1. We will use this idea in Chapter 3 to define the cartesian product of abstract varieties.
Chapter 2. Projective Toric Varieties
92
Exercises for §2.4.
N( ! A `2 2 4 2 4 2 4 2 4 ' <[
( ( ( ( pictured 2.4.1. Show that the hexagon in Figure 6 and the trapezoid pictured in Figure 9 are smooth polygons. Also, of the polytopes shown in Figure 8, determine which ones are smooth. 2.4.2. Prove Proposition 2.4.4.
L(MA *E' #fnm27+6+6+626E' from Example 2.4.5. (a) Verify the facet presentation of given in the example. (b) What is the facet presentation of ? Hint: You know the vertices of . (c) Let - + ( A" &' + , where ( m27+6+7+62n and ( # # 8 # , and let .( - 8 - . Use the hint given in the text to prove y W! $ E' )' . This shows that the index of in is A *E' , as claimed in the text. 2.4.4. Let +) +F' 4 be lattice polytopes with zW{}| + (* + for P(L12 ( . Also let + be the set of vertices of + . (a) Use supporting hyperplanes to prove that every element of 4 is a vertex of 4. (b) Prove that 4 ( ! F 4 ' and conclude that 4 is the set of vertices of 4. 2.4.5. The goal of this exercise is to prove Proposition 2.4.9. We know from Exercise 2.4.4 that the vertices of 4 are the ordered pairs - 2 - 4 ' where - + is a vertex of + . g . (a) Adapt the argument of part (a) of Theorem 2.4.7 to show that g [ (Ng [ ( . Taking duals, we see that the maximal cones of are 4 is a (b) Given rational polyhedral cones +) + ' and faces .+k + , prove that face of and that all faces of arise this way. 4 4 . (c) Prove that ( 8 with the property that 2.4.6. Consider positive integers N(9 9 4 + O for k(V 26+6+7+92n . Set B + ( E + for (Lm26+7+6+72n and let [ [ ( F `2 B 2&B 4 4 26+6+7+92&B 'P#-pm27+6+7+626&' + [ [ is reflexive and explain how it relates to Example 2.4.5. We will prove Prove that later that the toric variety of this polytope is the weighted projective space 27+6+6+62 ' . 2.4.7. The Sylvester sequence is defined by ( ( and (N 8 . It begins A fix a positive 4 integer A $ (`2-`2>2 -`271 >27+6+7+ and is described in [93, A000058]. Now and define 27+6+6+72 by ( (i and + ( (` #L&' + for ( (`26+7+6+92 . For ( - and this gives m27m2 D 2 and m27m26 (W2 ( `2 ( . Prove that 26+7+6+62 satisfies the conditions of Exercise 2.4.6 and hence gives a reflexive simplex, denoted in [75]. This paper proves that when , has the largest volume of all -dimensional reflexive 2.4.3. Consider the polytope
simplices and conjectures that it also has the largest number of lattice points.
Chapter 3
Normal Toric Varieties
§3.0. Background: Abstract Varieties The projective toric varieties studied in Chapter 2 are unions of Zariski open sets, each of which is an affine variety. We begin with a general construction of abstract varieties obtained by gluing together affine varieties in an analogous way. The resulting varieties will be abstract in the sense that they do not come with any given ambient affine or projective space. We will see that this is exactly the idea needed to construct a toric variety using the combinatorial data contained in a fan. Sheaf theory, while important for later chapters, will make only a modest appearance here. For a more general approach to the concept of abstract variety, we recommend standard books such as [26], [41] or [89].
;
B9C D47EF8
R Regular Functions. Let be an affine variety. In §1.0, we defined V ; N R ; S 354 O 8 ! ; for O . E and showed that the Zariski open subset ;,N R B9C D.47ESN.8 , where ESN is the localization of E at O . The open sets ;)N form a ; 4 basis for the Zariski topology on in the sense that every open set is a (finite) 4 N U ; N for some L ! E (Exercise 3.0.1). union R ;
For an affine variety, a morphism is called a regular map, so that the ; ; coordinate ring of consists of all regular maps from to . We now define what ; it means to be regular on an open subset of .
;
Definition 3.0.1. Given an affine variety R 4 we say if for all ! is . regular , ; N 4 S E N . . Then define ! and
4 4S8 R
.
B9C D47EF8
4
4
;
and a Zariski open ! E such that, , there exists O .
is regular
4
. 93
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
94
O 4 8 R P , and saying . EN means * O for some * . E and / W . that R X 4 4S8 Here are some cases where is easy to compute. B C ; D 7 4 F E 8 Proposition 3.0.2. Let R be an affine variety. 4<;=8 R E . (a) 4<; N.8 R EN E . (b) If O , then . E Proof. It is clear from Definition 3.0.1 that elements of define regular functions 4<;&8 4<;=8 ; ; on , hence elements of . Conversely, if + . , then for all . + . E 2 ; N S E N 6 * O . there is O such that . and R . The ideal R K O ; E 5 3 7 4 6 8 4 8 L R since O R P for all . ; . Hence the . ! satisfies 6 . : 4 5 3 7 4 9 6 * 8 8 E R R , so there exists a finite set L ! ; Nullstellensatz implies that L such that and polynomials for . +
R U O + U O R & U * . E , as desired. Hence R & 4 4 ; ! ; ;VN be4 Zariski open. For part (b), let Then is Zariski open in , and . E ; , ; N with coordinate ring satisfies ! , we have R whenever EN R 47ESN 8 N for all W . These observations easily imply that 4 4 8 R 4 4S8 (3.0.1) 4 ;,N gives Then setting R 4<; N 8 R 4<;,N 8 R ESN ;)N R B9C D.47ESN.8 . where the last equality follows by applying part (a) to ; BC D.47EF8 is an irreducible affine variety, we can describe Local Rings. When R The condition +
. ;2N
means that
%
regular functions using the local rings in §1.0. A rational func F4<;=8 is contained in the local ring %introduced tion in precisely when it is regular in a 4 ; is open, we have neighborhood of . It follows that whenever !
4
R 4 4S8
;
Thus regular functions on are rational functions on that are defined every4 4 ; , Proposition 3.0.2 implies where on . In particular, when R that (3.0.2)
R 4<;&8 R E R F%>; -<
§3.0. Background: Abstract Varieties
95
The Structure Sheaf . Given an affine variety 4
4 4S8
4
;
, the operation
! ;
open
has the following useful properties:
When
!
4
If
4
4 8 R R
defined by
, Definition 3.0.1 shows that there is an obvious restriction map
4 S8 4 8 4
. It follows that whenever ! ; ! 4 .
is an open cover of
R+ 4 4 8 R
!
4
;
is the identity map and that
, then the sequence
4 4 8 RR
44
9
4
8
is exact. Here, the second arrow and the is defined by the restrictions 44 8 double arrow is defined by and . Exactness at means that regular functions are determined locally (that is, two regular func4 4 tions on are equal if their restrictions to all are equal), and exactness at 4 4 8 4 means that regular functions on the agreeing on the overlaps 4 9 4 patch together to give a regular function on 4 .
sheaf of In the language of sheaf theory, these properties imply that ; 4<; 8 a ringedis aspace algebras, called the structure sheaf of . We call over . 4 ) ; N Also, since (3.0.1) holds for all open sets ! , we write
R 4<;N 8 R 4<; N9 8 . In terms of ringed spaces, this means
; ( ;
Morphisms. By §1.0, a polynomial mapping between affine varieties A > %
- ; A%>;( M corresponds to the -algebra homomorphism by 4M 98 R for . A%>; - . We now extend this to open sets of affinedefined varieties.
Definition 3.0.3. Let
. A function 4 (
(G 4
4
' ; ' Zariski open subsets of affine varieties for R defines a map ! 4 isbea morphism if M 4 4 8XR+ 4 4H( 8
4
Thus is a morphism if composing with regular functions on 4( gives regular functions on . Note also that M is a -algebra homomorphism since it comes from composition of functions. 4
; ( ;
Example 3.0.4. Suppose that a morphism according to DefiniBC D47E ' 8 , then the above ismap ; M gives the -algebra homotion 3.0.3. If ' R morphism
E R 4<; 8 R 4<;V( 8 R EA(
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
96
E
EA(
By Chapter 1, the -algebra homomorphism gives a map of affine ; ; ( . In Exercise 3.0.3 you will show that this varieties is the original map ;( ; we started with.
Example 3.0.4 shows that when we apply Definition 3.0.3 to maps between affine varieties, we get the same morphisms as in Chapter 1. In Exercise 3.0.3 you will verify the following properties of morphisms: If
4
is open in an affine variety
4 4S8 R
Hence regular functions on
;
, then
4
4
is a morphism
are just morphisms from
A composition of morphisms is a morphism. An inclusion of open sets
! 4
of an affine variety
;
4
.
to .
These observations enable us to understand what it means for 4 ; ' are arbitrary open sets. Let ; ' R BC D47E a morphism when ' ! 4 ( R N U 4<; ( 8 N for L ! E ( finite. Then 4<; ( 8 N ! 4 ( and 4 ! morphism
4<;( 8 N ! H4 ( R
4
X(
is a morphism.
! ; E 74 EA( 8 N
4
;
'8
4
be and write gives the
4<;( 8 N
This is given by a -algebra homomorphism . Since the cover 4 ( , we see that locally, morphisms look like the polynomial maps introduced in Chapter 1. In particular, morphisms are continuous in the Zariski topology.
(
We say that a morphism ( 4 " its inverse function
4
H4 (
4
is an isomorphism if is also a morphism.
is bijective and
Gluing Together Affine Varieties. We now are ready to define abstract varieties by+ gluing together open subsets+ of affine varieties. The model is what happens for . Recall from §2.0 of that is covered by open sets
+ 4 ' R S 354 ' ' 8 R B9C D / . Each 4 ' is a copy of + that uses a different set of variables. For for R XR P , we “glue together” these copies as follows. We have open subsets 4 4 ' 8 ! 4 ' and 4 4 8 ! 4 (3.0.3)
' 4
and we also have the isomorphism
(3.0.4)
M '
4
' 8 R 4 4 8
+
since both give the same open set ' 9 in . The notation ' 4 '8 ' 4 ' . ' that means since the index is closest to , hence ' the level of coordinate comes from the isomorphism rings,
4
4
' was chosen so ' 4 'V8 . . At
4
§3.0. Background: Abstract Varieties
97
"
( R and + 4 ' We can turn this around and start from the affine varieties given above and glue together the open sets in (3.0.3) ( using the isomorphisms ' from (3.0.4). " ' and ' R ' wherever This gluing is consistent since ' R all three +
defined by
R+
4 R P 8
; To generalize this, suppose we have a finite collection of affine varieties "M ; ! ; and isomorphisms and for all pairs we have Zariski open sets ; ; " ( satisfying "Hthe following compatibility conditions: 4
.
%
%
the second shows that it is transitive. Hence is an equivalence relation and we with the quotient topology. For each " , let can form the quotient space R
4
Then ;
!
4
4
R %* - .
* . ; . 4 * 8 R %* -
is an open set and the map defines a homeomorphism ! . Thus locally looks like an affine variety.
Definition 3.0.5. We call
the abstract variety determined by the above data.
An abstract variety comes equipped with the Zariski topology whose open 4 sets are those sets that restrict to open sets in each Zariski closed subsets ! are called subvarieties of . We say that . The is irreducible if it is not the union of two proper subvarieties. One can show that is a finite union of T ( R " such that ' ! P for =R P . We call irreducible subvarieties the ' the irreducible components of .
Here are some examples of Definition + 3.0.5.
Example 3.0.6. We saw above that can be obtained by gluing together the+ open sets (3.0.3) using the isomorphisms ' from (3.0.4). This shows that + 4 is an abstract variety with affine open subset ' ! . More generally, given a + ; ; ; 4 projective variety ! , we can cover with affine open subset 9 ' , and the gluing implicit in equation (2.0.8). We conclude that projective varieties are also abstract varieties. P +
P 3.0.7. + P In a similar way, Example
can be viewed + P as gluing affine spaces P along suitable open subsets. Thus is an abstract variety, + ; and the same is true for subvarieties ! . 4
'
U
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
98
Example 3.0.8. Let with
; R
R BC D47A% - 8
and
;( R
R BC D.47A% A - 8 ,
;V( R ; S 354 8 R B C D47A% - 8 ; ( R ;V( S 5 3 4 8 R BC D 47A% A - 8
and gluing data
( ; ( ; ( coming from the -algebra homomorphism M ( A% A - % - defined by and F
and
( ; ( ; ( coming from the -algebra homomorphism M ( A% - ( F% A - defined by and ( R (" One checks that , and the other compatibility condition is satisfied since
; ' . It follows that we get an abstract variety . has another description. Consider the product ( 5 with The variety 4 '!*')( 8 on ( and coordinates( 4 ' 8 on . We will homogeneous coordinates with the subvariety R 35 4 !' R ' ( '8 ! , called the blowup identify 47 8 . First note that ( is covered by of at the origin, and denoted 4 R BC D47A% ' ( ' *' - 8 and 4 ( R BC D47A% ' ' (*' - 8 R 9 4 4 8 and ( R 9 4 4 ( 8 . Also, Then is covered by R 354 R 4 ')( ' 8 'V8 ! 4
there are only two
which gives the coordinate ring
A% ' ( ' *' - K R 4 ' ( ' 8 ' L &% ' * ' ( ' - via 4 ' ( ' 8 ' ( 3 5 4 ' R 4 ' ' ( 8 8 4 ( R ! Similarly, has coordinate ring &% ' ')(*' - K '-R 4 ' ')( 8 L A % *' ' ( - via ' 4 ' )' ( 8 ; You can check that these are glued together in in exactly the same way ;( are glued together in . We will generalize this example in Exercise 3.0.8. and
The Structure Sheaf of an Abstract( Variety. Let be an an open subset of an R " 4 4 9 4 8 ! ; . Then a function 4 abstract variety and set is regular if R
"
4
is regular for all . The compatibility conditions ensure that this is well-defined, so that one can define
" 4 8 R 4
4
is regular
.
§3.0. Background: Abstract Varieties
"
#"
99
#"
This gives the structure sheaf . Thus an abstract variety is really a ringed 4 8 with a finite open ofcovering 4 such that 4 4 8 is isospace
4<; 8 of the affine variety ; . (We leave the morphic to the ringed space definition of isomorphism of ringed spaces to the reader.)
4
4
Given an abstract variety and an open subset , we note that has a natural 4 , 4 9 4 is open ! structure of an abstract variety. For an affine open subset 4 4 4 4 4 8 N for a finite subset R NU in and hence can be written as a union 9 L ! F% 4 - . It follows that 4 is covered by finitely many affine open subsets and thus is an abstract The structure sheaf is simply the restriction of R variety. 4 to , i.e., .
"
"
also gives an abstract variety. For In a similar way, a closed subset !4 4 as above, 9 is closed in and hence is an affine variety. Thus is! covered by finitely many affine open subsets and thus is an abstract variety. This justifies the term “subvariety” for closed subsets of an abstract variety. The is related to as follows. Let inclusion structure sheaf 4 4S8 R 4 4 be 8 the and let M be the sheaf on defined by M 9 . Restricting M functions on to functions on gives a map of sheaves whose kernel is the subsheaf of functions vanishing on , meaning ! 4
"
"
"
4 4S8 R O . " 4 4S8 O 4 8 R
for all
4 . . 9 F
In the language of Chapter 6, we have an exact sequence of sheaves
R
R
" R+ M R
All of the types of “variety” introduced so far can be subsumed under the concept of “abstract variety.” From now on, we will usually be thinking of abstract varieties. Hence we will usually say “variety” rather than “abstract variety.”
;
Local Rings and Rational Functions. Let be a point of an affine variety . X Elements of the local ring are quotients O in a suitable localization with O . A%>;S- and V4 8 R P . It follows ; ; that is a neighborhood of in and O % ; is a regular function on . In this way, we can think of elements of as regular functions defined in a neighborhood of .
This idea extends to the abstract case. Given a point of an variety and 4 ( 4 4 ' are equivaneighborhoods of , we say that regular functions O ' ( O , if there is a neighbhorhood . 4 ! 4( 9 4 such that lent at , written O (O R O .
%
Definition 3.0.9. Let
" R
O is the local ring of at
be a point of a variety
4
.
4
. Then
is a neighborhood of
in
%
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
100
. "
#" Every
has a well-defined value is a local ring with unique maximal ideal
The local ring
"
4 8.
It is not difficult to see that
" R . " 4 8 R .
can also be defined as the direct limit
over all neighborhoods of
in
" R ! " #
" 4 8 4
(see Definition 6.0.1).
A4 8
When is irreducible, we can also define the field of rational functions 4 defined on a nonempty. A rational function on is a regular function O 4 ! , and two rational functions on are equivalent if they Zariski open set agree on a nonempty Zariski open subset. In Exercise 3.0.4 you will show that this relation is an equivalence relation and that the set of equivalence classes is a field, A4 8 . called the function field of , denoted
;
is an affine variety, the definition of a smooth point Smooth Varieties. When . ; (Definition 1.0.7) used 4<;&8 , the Zariski tangent space of ; at , and
; ; , the maximum dimension of an irreducible component of containing . 4 8
! You will show in Exercise 3.0.2 that and are well-defined for a of a general variety. point .
Definition 3.0.10. Let be a variety. A point . is smooth if
, and is smooth if every point of is smooth.
Morphisms of Varieties. Given varieties 4 4 Z and R , a function in the Zariski topology and the restrictions 4 9
! 4 8 R
R affine open covers and is awith morphism if it is continuous
" ( 4 4 Z 8 R 4
Z
are morphisms in the sense of Definition 3.0.3. One can check that this definition is independent of the affine open covers. Also, a function is a morphism 4 8 if and only if it gives an element of , i.e., is a regular function.
"
Normal Varieties. We return to the notion of normality introduced in Chapter 1.
"
Definition 3.0.11. An variety rings are normal for all
is called normal if it is irreducible and the local . .
At first glance, this appears to be different from the definition given for affine varieties in Definition 1.0.3. In fact the two notions are equivalent in the affine case.
;
Proposition 3.0.12. Let be an irreducible affine variety. Then ; . are normal for all . and only if the local rings
F%>; -
is normal if
§3.0. Background: Abstract Varieties
101
F%>; -
Proof. If is normal for all , then (3.0.2) shows that is an intersection of normal domains, all of which have the same field of fractions. Since such an F%>; - is normal. intersection is normal by Exercise 1.0.7, it follows that For the converse, suppose that (
F%>; -
4<;&8 . A * ' .
is normal and let
satisfy
' 8 R P . The product O R O ( O has * ' with O Write ' R &%>;- N and O 4 8 R P . The localization &%>;-7N is normal by * the properties that ' . % 4 8 R P . Hence " . &%>;-7N ! . since O Exercise 1.0.7 and is contained in
"
* (" " * R ' O ' . A%>;S- and O ' 4
"
This completes the proof. Here is a consequence of Proposition 3.0.12 and Definition 3.0.11.
Proposition 3.0.13. Let ; affine open sets . Then
be an irreducible variety with a cover consisting of ; is normal. is normal if and only if each
Products of Varieties. As another example of abstract varieties and gluing, we ( V of varieties ( and also has the structure indicate why the product of a variety. In §1.0 we constructed the product of affine varieties. From here, it ( is relatively routine to see that if is obtained by gluing together affine varieties 4 is obtained by gluing together 4 Z ( is obtained by and affines , then 4 4 Z ( - in the corresponding fashion. Furthermore, gluing together the has the correct universal mapping property. Namely, given a diagram
$ ( %
( #
/
' are morphisms, there is a unique morphism where ' (the dotted arrow) that makes the diagram commute. ( (
=
$
R Example 3.0.14. Let us construct the product ; R BC D.47F% - 8 and ;( R BC D47A% - 8 , with the gluing. Write given by
( Then
A% -
is constructed from 4
A%
-
(
; ;V(
where
R BC D.47A% - &&% ' - 8
H( R BC D.47A% -1A&% ' - 8 4
with gluing given by
44 8 44 ( 8
corresponding to the obvious isomorphism of coordinate rings.
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
102
Separated Varieties. From the point of view of the classical topology, arbitrary gluings can lead to varieties with some strange properties.
( Example 3.0.15. In Example 3.0.14 we saw how to construct affine vari; R BC D47&% - 8 and ;( R BC D.47F% - 8 with thefrom gluing given by eties on open sets M 4<; 8 ! ; and M 4<; ( 8 ! ; ( . This expresses ( as consisting of M plus two additional points. But now consider the abstract
variety arising from the gluing map
4<; 8 R+ 4<; ( 8
that corresponds to the map of -algebras defined by . As before, the glued M variety consists of together with two additional points. However here we ( 4* 8 " * M . have a morphism whose fiber over contains one point, ( corresponding ; and but whose fiber over consists of two points, to . ;)( . If 4H( 4 are classical open sets in with ( . 4 ( and corresponding to . . 4 4 ( 4 R , then 9 P . So the classical topology on is not Hausdorff.
Since varieties are rarely Hausdorff in the Zariski topology (Exercise 3.0.5), we need a different way to think about Example 3.0.15. Consider the product V and the diagonal mapping V defined by 4 8 R 4 8 for . . For from Example 3.0.15, there is a morphism whose 4 8 . Any Zariski closed subset of fiber over over consists of the four points ' containing one of these four points must contain all of them. The image of 4 ( ( 8 and 4 8 , but not the other two, so the the diagonal mapping contains diagonal is not Zariski closed. This example motivates the following definition.
Definition 3.0.16. We say a variety is separated if the image of the diagonal - - map is Zariski closed in .
+ is separated because the image of the diagonal in + + R B C D47A% ' ( *' +, ( +.- 8 is the affine variety 354 ' (GR (*' + R +8 . For instance,
Similarly any affine variety is separated. The connection between failure of separatedness and failure of the Hausdorff property in the classical topology seen in Example 3.0.15 is a general phenomenon. Theorem 3.0.17. A variety is separated if and only if it is Hausdorff in the classical topology. Here are some additional properties of separated varieties (Exercise 3.0.6).
are morphisms, then . O 4 8 R 24 8 is a subvariety (a) If O of . 4 ; 4 ; is also affine. are affine open subsets of , then 9 (b) If
Proposition 3.0.18. Let
be a separated variety.
§3.0. Background: Abstract Varieties
103
The requirement that be separated is often included in the definition of an abstract variety. When this is done, what we have called a variety is sometimes called a pre-variety. Fibered Products. Finally in this section, we will discuss fibered products of varieties, a construction required for the discussion of proper morphisms in §3.4. First, L and L , then the fibered product if we have mappings of sets O HU is defined to be
U R 4' 8 .
(3.0.5)
O 4 '8 R 2 4 8.
The fibered product construction gives a very flexible language for describing ordinary products, intersections of subsets, fibers of mappings, the set where two mappings agree and so forth:
L
U
. L
U R 9 If are subsets of and O are the inclusions, then ( . ! L , then U R O " 4 .8 . If R
If
is a point, then
is the ordinary product
.
The third property is the reason for the name. All are easy exercises that we leave for the reader. In analogy with the universal mapping property of the product discussed above, the fibered product has the following universal property. Whenever we have map( and such that O ( R , there is a unique pings HU that makes the following diagram commute.
$
$ HU %
UG
" /
/
N L
U
Equation (3.0.5) defines as a set. To prove that is a variety, L L L we assume for simplicity that is separated. Then O and 4 98 L L , and one easily checks that give a morphism O (
4
LV L
HU R 4 O 8 " 4 4
LV L
L
where This is closed in is separated, ! isUAthe diagonal. V and hence hassince and it follows that is closed in a natural structure UG as a variety. From here, it is straightforward to show that has the desired universal mapping property.
UN
L
Proving that is a variety when is not separated takes more work. The R BC D47E ( 8 , R B9C D47E 8 , and idea is to begin with the affine case where L R BC D47EF8 . Then HU exists as an affine variety by the previous paragraph
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
104
L
since is affine and hence separated. When is constructed by a gluing procedure.
H L
are general varieties,
XU
XU . Let R also describe the coordinate ring of BC Dwe BC DIn47EAthe( 8 ,affine R case, 47E can 8 , and L R BC D47EF8 . The morphisms O correspond E EA( M E E . Hence both E&(JE have theto ring homomorphisms O M E E ( E . This is also structure of -modules, and we have the tensor product a finitely generated -algebra, though it may have nilpotents (Exercise 3.0.9). To
get a coordinate ring, we need to take the quotient by the ideal ? Then one can prove that
HU R BC D47EA(/ E
? 8
of all nilpotents.
U
We can avoid worrying about nilpotents by constructing as the affine B C ( 8 D 7 4 E E scheme . Interested readers can learn about the construction of fiber products as schemes in [26, I.3.1] and [41, pp. 87–89]. Exercises for §3.0.
GM(<>=?7@1A'
C
3.0.1. Let be an affine variety. (a) Show that every ideal can be written in the form + . (This is the Hilbert Basis Theorem in .)
,
G
*( ,
(b) Let be a subvariety. Show that the complement of in a union of a finite collection of open affine sets of the form .
G
G;
G
27+6+6+623, ! , where can be written as
(c) Deduce that every open cover of (in the Zariski topology) has a finite subcover. (This says that affine varieties are quasicompact in the Zariski topology.)
K Wz {}| ~ \ 'I( G r %G (
zW{}| \
3.0.2. As in the affine case, we want to say a variety is smooth at if . In this exercise, you will show that this is a well-defined notion. , then the (a) Show that if is in the intersection of two affine open sets Zariski tangent spaces and are isomorphic as vector spaces over .
K* ~ Y>[ \ ~ Y [ \ (b) Show that zW{}| \ is a well-defined integer.
K
(c) Deduce that the proposed notion of smoothness at is well-defined.
K% G and set _ \( /&,%% O RK' .
3.0.3. This exercise explores some properties of the morphisms defined in Definition 3.0.3.
' _ \'
(a) Prove the claim made in Example 3.0.4. Hint: Take . Then describe in terms of
, RKS')(* `8
(b) Prove the properties of morphisms listed on page 96.
,2n
3.0.4. Let
be an irreducible abstract variety.
, - if , O (- O
M (b) Show that the set of equivalence classes of the relation in part (a) is a field. (c) Show that if M is a nonempty affine open subset of , then I ' I' . (a) Let be rational functions on . Show that open set is an equivalence relation.
for some nonempty
3.0.5. Show that a variety is Hausdorff in the Zariski topology if and only if it consists of finitely many points.
§3.0. Background: Abstract Varieties
105
3.0.6. Consider Proposition 3.0.18. (a) Prove part (a) of the proposition. Hint: that if Show first by , then ' .
6 h
is defined c ')(M , c ' 2nS c 'n' *( 'n' (b) Prove (b) of the proposition. Hint: Show first that . G can be identified with ' part G$'^ . 6eG h G G 3.0.7. Let G ( <W=D?E@mA' be an affine variety. The diagonal mapping corresponds to a -algebra homomorphism h . Which one? Hint: Consider the universal mapping property of G G. $ , the blowup of 3.0.8. In this exercise, we will study an important variety in F 4 ' from Example 3.0.8. Write the at the origin, denoted F ' . This generalizes d d as 26+7+6+92 , and the affine coordinates on as homogeneous coordinates on c 26+7+6+92 c . Let ( A ')( d + c # d c +)O> fe'^ + (3.0.6) : Let 1+ , (N126+7+6+92 , be the standard affine opens in + ( d + ' 2 k (M 1 26+7+6 +92 . (note the slightly non-standard indexing). So the + form a cover of (a) Show that for each P(Mm26+7+6+92 , + ( + ' d <W=D?E@ d + 26+7+6+62 dd ++ 4 2 d d+ + 26+7+6+72 d d + 2 c + using the equations (3.0.6) defining
d ' and % d + ' . 3.0.9. Let G ( c 4$# d ' 4 and consider the morphism 6G h given by projection onto the d -axis. We will study the fibers of . A ' ( / F `23 1' 8 can be represented as the fibered (a) As noted in the text, the fiber d d .
(b) Give the gluing data for identifying the subsets
+
/E `8 G . In terms of coordinate rings, we have /E `8( <>=D?E@mFIH J! ' , *(C<W=D?E@mA H d J ' and GM(C<W=D?E@mA H d 2 c J! c 4# d . Prove that IH d J! d H d 2 c JA c 4 # d IH c J! c 4 + Thus, the coordinate rings IH d JA d , IH d J and H d 2 c JA c 4 # d lead to a tensor product that has nilpotents and hence cannot be a coordinate ring. T in , then W')(N/> 2 W' 8 . Show that the analogous tensor product is (b) If (* H d J! d # H d 2 c JA c 4 # d H c JA c 4 # H c JA c # IH c JA c + W' . This has no nilpotents and hence is the coordinate ring of What happens in part (a) is that the two square roots coincide, so that we get only one point with “multiplicity ( .” The multiplicity information is recorded in the affine scheme <>=?7@1AIH c J! c 4 ' . This is an example of the power of schemes. product
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
106
§3.1. Fans and Normal Toric Varieties
Y
6
In this section we construct the toric variety corresponding to a fan . We will 6 to many of the examples encountered previously, and also relate the varieties we will see how properties of the fan correspond to properties such as smoothness 6 . and compactness of The Toric Variety Associated to a Fan. A toric variety continues to mean the same thing as in Chapters 1 and 2, although we now allow abstract varieties as in §3.0.
Definition + 3.1.1. A toric variety is an irreducible variety a torus 5 47 M 8 as a Zariski open subset such that the action of 5 containing on itself extends 5 on . to an action of The other ingredient in this section is a fan in the vector space
Y A fan
? @
.
in ? @ is a finite collection of cones 6 such that: Y . (a) Every 6 is a strongly convex rational polyhedral cone. Y Y . (b) For all 6 , each face of 6 is also in . ( Y , the intersection 6 ( 9 6 is a face of each (hence also in Y (c) For all 6 6 .
Definition 3.1.2.
).
It is also possible to consider infinite collections of cones with these properties, but we will not do so in this book. We have already seen some examples of fans. Theorem 2.3.2 shows that the Y $ of a full dimensional lattice polytope !; @ is a fan in the sense normal fan of Definition 3.1.2. However, there exist fans that are not equal to the normal fan of any lattice polytope. An example of such a fan will be given in Example 4.2.13. We now show how the cones in any fan give the combinatorial data necessary to glue a collection of affine toric varieties together to yield an abstract toric variety. Y By Theorem 1.2.18, each cone 6 in gives the affine toric variety
3 R BC D.47A% 23 - 8 R BC D47A% 7 6 9; - 8 Moreover, if H is a face of 6 , then by Definition 1.2.5, there is , . 6 7 such that H R 6 9 O P , where O P R . ? @ K , L R is the hyperplane defined by , . In Chapter 1, we proved two useful facts: O P is the corresponding face of 6 , then First, if , . 6 7 9 ; and H R 6-9 4
Proposition 1.3.16 implies that
2 R 23
4FR , 8 % 2 - is the localization A% 2+3 - . Hence 4 R 4 4 3 8 F This shows that ( Second, if H R 6 9 6 , then Lemma 1.2.13 implies that (3.1.2) 6 ( 9 O P R H R 6 9 O PF (3.1.1)
.
§3.1. Fans and Normal Toric Varieties where ,. (3.1.3)
107
67( 9 F4 R 6 8 A 7 9-; . This shows that 4 3 4 4 3 8 R 4 R 4 4 3 8
!
4
3
These facts were also used to study projective toric varieties in Chapter 2. The 2 3 and their semigroup following proposition gives an additional property of the rings that we will need.
(6 . Y
Proposition 3.1.3. If 6
2 3
6 (7 R 4FR 4 6 ( 98 6 8 7 , . 67 9 4FR , 8 for 6 some79 ; . 203 203 that . . 6 (7
Proof. The inclusion
R 6 ( 9 6
and H
2 R 2 3
23
, then
2 3 2 follows directly from the general fact that ! R H 7 . For the reverse inclusion, take . 2 and let ( (3.1.2). Then (3.1.1) applied to 6 gives R 20satisfy 3 . But R , . 6 7 implies R ,. 203 , so and .
This result is sometimes called the Separation Lemma and is a key ingredient 6 are separated using Definition 3.0.16. in showing that the toric varieties
(
Example 3.1.4. Let 6 R = I> 4 ( ( 8 = inI> ? 4@ ( R dual cones 6N7 in Figure 1.
= I> 4 ( 8 1.2.11), and let 6 R ( (as in Exercise = > I 4 ( 8 H R 6 9A6 R R . We show the (4R ( . Then 8 8 R = I> 4 (+R H 7 R 6(7 6 7 67 ,
, and
τ σ1
σ1 τ
σ2
σ2
Figure 1. The cones
The darkest shaded region on the right is 6 6 9 O " P , where , R R ( Z . 6(7 and R , with , . 6 equals the set of all sums , 2 R 23 23 .
and their duals
( O P R (7 have H R 6 9 9 6 7 .( We 2 R , R Z . 67 . Note that (7 9 ; and , . 6 7 9 ; . Hence
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
108
4
6 H
BC D47A% 23 - 8
3
R Now consider the collection of affine toric varieties , where ( Y runs over all cones in a fan . Let 6 and 6 be any two of these cones and let R 6 ( 9 6 . By (3.1.3), we have an isomorphism
4
3 3
4 38 4
44 38
which is the identity on . By Exercise 3.1.1, the compatibility conditions as in 4 3 4 4 3 8 are satisfied. §3.0 for gluing the affine varieties 6 along the subvarieties Y associated to the fan . Hence we obtain an abstract variety Theorem 3.1.5. Let variety.
Y
be a fan in ?
Y
@
. The variety
6
is a normal separated toric
Y
. . Proof. Since each cone in is strongly convex, 5 R BC D.47A% - 8 47 M 8 + 4 3 ! ? is a face of all 6 Hence we have for all 6 . These tori are all ; 5 6 ! identified by the gluing, so we have ! . We know from Chapter 1 that each 4 3 3 3 5 has an action of reduces to the identity 203 3 - . The gluing isomorphism & % mapping on . Hence the actions are compatible on the intersections of every pair of sets in the open affine cover, and patch together to give an action of 5 on 6 .
6
4
3
The variety is irreducible because all of the irreducible affine toric 5 . Furthermore, 4 3 is aarenormal varieties containing the torus affine variety by 6 is normal by Proposition 3.0.13. Theorem 1.3.5. Hence the variety
6
To see that is separated it will suffice to show that for each pair of cones 6 ( 6 in Y , the image of the diagonal map 4 4 3 4 3 H R ( 6 9-6 is Zariski closed (Exercise 3.1.2). But comes from the -algebra homomor-
M A% 23 - 1=F% 23 -8R+ &% 2 + ' ' ' P U + defined by . By Proposition 3.1.3, M is surjective, so that A% 2 - 74 A% 203 - &&% 23 - 8 4 M 8 ; 3 ; 3. Hence the image of is a Zariski closed subset of phism
P
6
Toric varieties were originally known as torus embeddings, and the variety 5 4 Y 8 in older references such as [76]. Other commonly would be written 4 Y 8 , or Q4 8 , if the fan is denoted by . When we want to used notations are 6 as 6 5 . emphasize the dependence on the lattice ? , we will write
Y
Every normal, separated toric variety is obtained as for some fan in ?G@ . 6 for For example, Theorem 1.3.5 implies that every normal affine toric variety is the fan consisting of a single cone 6 together with all of its faces. The construction of the projective toric variety associated to a lattice polytope in Chapter 2 shows 6 for suitable fans Y . that those varieties are also 6
§3.1. Fans and Normal Toric Varieties
Proposition 3.1.6. Let the projective toric variety
6
$
109
+ ! ; @ be an / -dimensional lattice polytope. Then Y $ is the normal fan of . , where
Proof. When is very ample, this follows immediately from the description of $ in Proposition 2.3.12 and the the intersections of the affine open pieces of Y $ definition of the normal fan . The general case follows since the normal fans of and are the same for all positive integers . The general statement is a consequence of a theorem of Sumihiro from [98].
5
Theorem 3.1.7 (Sumihiro). Let the torus act on a normal separated variety has a 5 -invariant affine open neighborhood. Then every point .
.
Corollary 3.1.8. Let be a normal separated toric variety containing the torus 5 as an affine open subset. Then there exists a fan Y in ? @ such that 6 . Proof. The proof will be sketched in Exercise 3.2.10 after we have developed some 5 -orbits on toric varieties. of the properties of Additional Examples. We now turn to some concrete examples. Many of these are toric varieties already encountered in previous chapters.
Y
Example 3.1.9. Consider the fan in ?A@ R in Figure 2, where ? R has ( standard basis . This is the same as the normal fan of each of the simplices R as in Example 2.3.9. Here we show all points in the cones inside a rectangular viewing box (all figures of fans in the plane in this chapter will be drawn using the same convention.)
σ1
σ0
σ2
Figure 2. The fan
for
From the discussion in Chapter 2, we expect , and we will show Y R = I> 4 ( 8 , this in detail. The fan has three two-dimensional cones 6 = = 6 ( R I> 4FR ( R 8 , and 6 R I> 4 (4R (R 8 , together with the three 6
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
110
rays H ' R 6 ' 9 6 for R P , and the origin. We see that the toric variety covered by the affine opens
3 R B C D47&% 2 3 - 8 BC D47A% ' 3 R BC D47&% 23 - 8 B C D47A% ' 3 R BC D47&% 23 - 8 B C D47A% '
4 4 4
6
is
-8 " ( *' " ( - 8 " ( " (-8
%' - & % ' " ( * ' " ( - M( F % ' - & %' " ( " ( - M &
Moreover, by Proposition 3.1.3, the gluing data on the coordinate rings is given by
( ( - &% ' *' " ( - M ( A% ' " *' "
It is easy to see that if we use the usual homogeneous coordinates ' and identifies the standard affine open , then 6 6 4 3 ! . Hence we have recovered as the toric variety .
+ Example 3.1.10. Generalizing Example 3.1.9, let ? @ R ( +
standard basis
. Set
Y
R R ( R % R
4 '*')(*' 8 4
, where
' !
on with
? R
+
has
R +
and let be the fan in ?G@ consisting of the cones generated by all proper subsets + + +
6 . This is the normal fan of the / -simplex of and by Example 2.3.14 and Exercise 2.3.6. (You + will check the details to verify that this gives the usual affine open cover of in Exercise 3.1.3).
To relate this example to the discussion in Chapter 2, note that we have differ+ + ent embeddings of according to which is used to construct the Veronese + Y mapping. However, is the normal fan of for all , and the varieties obtained this way for different are isomorphic.
Example 3.1.11. We classify all -dimensional normal toric varieties as follows. . The only cones are the intervals 6 R % 8 We may assume ? R and ? @ R ( 4FR - and the trivial cone H R . It follows that there are only four and 6 R
possible fans, which gives the following list of toric varieties:
H . which gives M
6 H and 6 ( H . both of( which give
6 6 ( H . (which gives
Here is a picture of the fan for
:
6 ( This is the fan of Example 3.1.10 when /
R .
6
§3.1. Fans and Normal Toric Varieties
(
111
+
4 (8
P
4 8
? with ? @ Y andY ( ? Y@ Example 3.1.12. Let ? R ? . Let Y ' be the fan in 4 ? ' 8 @ as in Example R 3.1.10. Then is a fan in ? , consisting of all cones 6 ( 6 , where+ 6 ' isP in Y ' . By Example 2.4.8, the corresponding toric variety is the product .
σ10
σ00
σ11
σ01
Figure 3. A fan
with
Y ! Z
BC B C B C B C
D.47A% 203 - 8 D.47A% 2 3 - 8 D.47A% 2 3 - 8 D.47A% 203 - 8
? @ pictured in Figure 3. as above. Then
When / R , R , we obtain the fan 6 Label the 2-dimensional cones 6 ' R 6 '
F% ' -
( F% ' " -
( ( F% ' " " ( F% ' " -<
( 3 We see that if and are the standard affine open sets in ( , then ( and it is easy to check that the gluing makes . 4
4
(
4
6
(
4
'
4
Y (
Example 3.1.13. Let ? R ? in ? ' as in the previous example. = I> 4 (Let S P 8 4 ? ( 8 @ be as above, but let Y be? the, with Y R fanYSconsisting GP Y of the cone?G@ ( together with all its faces. Then is a fan in + ( and the the cor 6 responding toric variety is . The case was studied in Example 3.0.14.
Examples 3.1.12 and 3.1.13 are special cases of the following general construction, whose proof will be left to the reader (Exercise 3.1.4). Proposition 3.1.14. Suppose we have fans is a fan in ?
(% ?
Y ( Y
and
6
Y (
R 6 ( 6
in
4? ( 8@
6 ' . Y '
- 6
6
6
and
Y
in
4 ? 8 @
. Then
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
112
(
Example 3.1.15. The two cones 6 and 6 in ? @ R from Example 3.1.4 (see Y Figure 1), together with their faces, form a fan . By comparing the descriptions ;3 it of the coordinate rings of ( what 6 given there with we did in Example 3.0.8, ! is easy to check that , where is the blowup of at the R 354 ' R ')+ (*'V8 (Exercise 3.1.5). origin, defined as
( +
and set R with standard basis Generalizing this, let ? R + Y fan in ? @ consisting of the cones generated by all .Let +, benotthecontaining +
( +, . Then the toric variety 6 is subsets of isomorphic to the blowup of at the origin (Exercise 3.0.8).
(
and consider the fan Y
.
in ? @ R
Example 3.1.16. Let consisting of the four cones 6 ' shown in Figure 4, together with all of their faces. The correσ4 (−1, r)
σ1
σ3
σ2
sponding toric variety
6
with
Figure 4. A fan
is covered by open affine subsets,
3 R BC D47A% ' - 8 4
3 R BC D47A% ' " ( - 8 4
4
3 R BC D47A% ' " ( * ' 6
and glued according to (3.1.3). We call
" (-8
3 R BC D47A% ' " ( * ' " 4
-8
the Hirzebruch surface
L
<
.
2.3.15 constructed the rational normal scroll using the polygon Example
Y " * W W with . The normal fan of fan above, so that < ( defined L < " . Note alsois the ( . We as an abstract variety, that will study smooth projective toric surfaces in Chapter 10.
+ . satisfy .D 4 ( 8 R . Consider Example 3.1.17. Let 4-+ 8 introduced in Chapter 2. Let ? R the+ weighted projective space (U 4 +98 + ( and let ' , R / be the images in ? of the standard
basis vectors in
U
, so the relation
+ + R
§3.1. Fans and Normal Toric Varieties
Y
113
holds in ? . Let be the fan made up of the cones generated by all+ the proper + . When ' R for all , we obtain 6 subsets of Exam 6 4 + 8 in general. This will be by ple 3.1.10. And indeed, + proved in Chapter 5 using a generalization of the homogeneous coordinates in .
4 .8
R ( R
R Here, we will consider the special case , where Y The fan in ? @ is pictured in Figure 5, using the plane spanned by
(
. . This
σ0 σ1
σ2
Figure 5. A fan
with
example has a different property from the others we have seen so far. Namely, = I> 4 ( 8 R = I> 4FR ( R ( 8 . We have 6 7 R consider the cone 6 R = I> 4FR ( R 8 ! ; , so the situation is similar to the case we studied in Example 1.2.21. Indeed, there is a change of coordinates defined by a matrix in 4 JX8 that takes 6 to the cone with @ R from that example. It follows that 4 3 354 ' TR 8 ! (Exercise 3.1.6). This is the there is an isomorphism rational normal cone , hence has a singular point at the origin. The toric variety 6 is singular because of the singular point in this affine open subset. We also saw $ 4 .8 a polytope such that the toric variety Y%$ coincides with the fan shown above. in Example 2.4.6, and the normal fan
Y
6
There is a dictionary between properties of and properties of that generalizes Theorem 1.3.12 and Example 1.3.20. We begin with some terminology. The first two items parallel Definition 1.2.16. Definition 3.1.18. Let (a) (b)
Y We say
Y We say Y
(c) We say
Y ! ?@
be a fan.
is smooth (or regular) if every cone 6 in
Y
is smooth (regular).
Y is simplicial if every cone 6 in is simplicial. Y R 3 6 6 is all of ? @ is complete if its support
.
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
114
Theorem 3.1.19. Let
6
be the toric variety defined by a fan
Y ! ?A@
.
Y (a) is a smooth variety if and only if the fan is smooth. 6 is an orbifold (that is, 6 has only finite quotient singularities) if and only (b) Y if the fan is simplicial. 6 is compact in the classical topology if and only if Y is complete. (c) 6
Proof. Part (a) follows from the corresponding statement for affine toric varieties, Theorem 1.3.12, because smoothness is a local property (Definition 3.0.10). In part (b), Example 1.3.20 gives one implication. The other will be proved later in the book. A proof of part (c) will be given in §3.4.
The blowup of at the origin (Example 3.1.15) is not compact, since the . The Hirzebruch support of the cones in the corresponding fan is not all of < surfaces from Example 3.1.16 are smooth and compact because every cone in . The variety the corresponding fan is smooth, and the union of the cones is 4 .8 from Example 3.1.17 is compact but not smooth. It is an orbifold (it has only finite quotient singularities) since the corresponding fan is simplicial.
Exercises for §3.1.
[ satisfy the compatibility G 3.1.2. Let be a variety obtained by gluing affine open subsets /&G r 8 along open subsets Gr ( *Gr by isomorphisms r ( 6>G r ( G ( r . Show that is separated when the image r G ( defined by RKS')(M Ke2p!r ( RKS'n' is Zariski closed for all sZ/2 * . of 6 GDr ( h GD" 3.1.3. Verify that if is the fan given in Example 3.1.10, then . 3.1.4. Prove Proposition 3.1.14. be the standard 3.1.5. Let , let 27+6+6+72 basis and let ( 8 . Let be the set of cones generated by all subsets of / 26+7+6+92 8 not containing / 26+7+6+9 2 8 . (a) Show that is a fan in .
3.1.1. Let be a fan in . Show that the isomorphisms conditions from §0 for gluing the together to create .
(b) Construct the affine open subsets covering the corresponding toric variety , and give the gluing isomorphisms. (c) Show that is isomorphic to the blowup of at the origin, earlier in described Exercise 3.0.8. Hint: The blowup is the subvariety of given by + + . Cover by affine open subsets + and compare those affines with your answer to part (b).
% d c # d 7c O5
Ne'
uM
t
(
4
(
`2+' 4 (b) Show that <>=?7@1A H 9J ' % "d # c 4E'^f o . 3.1.7. In (.P4 , consider the fan with cones /E `8 , ! ?1 ' , and ! `?1p# ' . Show that .
3.1.6. In this exercise, you will verify the claims made in Example 3.1.17. ( (a) Show that there is a matrix defining a change of coordinates that takes the cone in this example to the cone from Example 1.2.21, and find the mapping takes to the dual cone.
§3.2. The Orbit-Cone Correspondence
115
§3.2. The Orbit-Cone Correspondence
5
6
In this section, we will study the orbits for the action of on the toric variety . Our main result will show that there is a bijective correspondence between cones Y 5 -orbits in 6 . The connection comes ultimately from looking at limit in and 5 defined in §1.1. points of one-parameter subgroups of A First Example. We introduce the key features of the correspondence between orbits and cones by looking at a concrete example.
for the fan Y from Figure 2 of §3.1. We have Example 3.2.1. as the set of points 4 8 , 5 R 47 M 8 ! Consider with homogeneous coordinates R P . For each R 4 * 8 . ? R , we have the corresponding curve in :
6
)
4 8 R 4 8
)
We are abusing notation slightly; strictly speaking, the one-parameter subgroup 47 8 47 8 is a curve in M , but we view it as a curve in via the inclusion M ! .
48
We start by analyzing the limit of as . The limit point in 4 * 8 . It is easy to check that the pattern on R is as follows: )
depends
limit is (1,1,0) ↓
limit is (1,0,0) limit is (0,1,0) ← limit is (1,0,1) limit is (1,1,1)
←
a
limit is (0,0,1)
↑
b
limit is (0,1,1) Figure 6.
*
for
For instance, suppose in . These points lie in the first quadrant. ! # 4 8 R 4 8 . Next suppose that * R Here, it is obvious that in , corresponding to points on the diagonal in the third quadrant. Note that
4 8 R 4 8#% 4 " 8
R *
since we are using homogeneous coordinates in . Then implies that # 4 " 8 R 4 8 . You will check the remaining cases in Exercise 3.2.1.
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
116
Y
The regions of ? described in Figure 6 correspond to cones of the fan . C D4 6 8 , In each case, the set of giving one of the limit points equals ? 9 C D4 6 8 is the relative interior of a cone 6 . Y . In other words, we have where Y recovered the structure of the fan by considering these limits!
5
Now we relate this to the -orbits in . By considering the description 47 SF 8 M , you will see in Exercise 3.2.1 that there are exactly seven -orbits in :
5
( R 4 ' *')(*'
R 4 ' *')(*'
R 4 ' *')(*'
R 4 ' *')(*'
R 4 ' *')(*'
R 4 ' *' ( *'
R 4 ' *')(*'
' ' R P for all 54 8 ' R and ' *' ( R P 54 8 ')( R and ' *' R P 54 8 ' R and ')(*' R P 54 8 ')( R ' R and ' R P R 4 8 8 ' R ' R and ' ( R P R 4 8 8 ' R ')( R and ' R P R 4 8.
8 8 8 8 8
This list shows that each orbit contains a unique limit point. Hence we obtain a correspondence between cones 6 and orbits by
#
48 .
. CX D4 6 8 We will soon see that these observations generalize to all toric varieties 6
corresponds to
)
for all
6
.
Points and Semigroup Homomorphisms. It will be convenient to use the intrinsic 4 3 description of the points of an affine toric variety given in Proposition 1.3.1. We recall how this works and make some additional observations. 4
23
Points of
3
are in bijective correspondence with semigroup homomorphisms 2+3 R BC D47A% 23 - 8 . 4 3 . Recall that 6 7 9-; and R
For each cone 6 we have a point of
4
3
defined by
,. 23 R
,. 2 3 9 6 I R 6 I 9 ; otherwise
This is a semigroup homomorphism since 6 7 9 6 I is a face of 6 7 . Thus, if , , Z . 203 and , , Z . 203 96 I , then , , Z . 23 96 I . We denote this 3 point by and call it the distinguished point corresponding to 6 .
3
The point is fixed under the (Corollary 1.3.3). If H
! 6
is a face, then
5
-action if and only if
!
6 R ! G ? @
. 3 . This follows since 6 I ! H I 4
.
Limits of One-Parameter Subgroups. In Example 3.2.1, the limit points of oneparameter subgroups are exactly the distinguished points for the cones in the fan of (Exercise 3.2.1). We now show that this is true for all affine toric varieties.
§3.2. The Orbit-Cone Correspondence Proposition 3.2.2. Let 6J! let . ? . Then
Proof. Given
#!
)
48
. CX . ?
be a strongly convex rational polyhedral cone and
#! D4 6 8 , then ! #
Moreover, if
?:@
117
. 6
, we have
exists in
4
3
) )
4 8 exists in 4 3 48 R 3 .
P 4 ) 4 8*8 203 exists in for all ,. ! P exists in for all ,. 2+3
#!
'
#
L W for all ,. 6 7 9 ; K, % 46 7 87 R 6 .
where the first equivalence is proved in Exercise 3.2.2 and the other equivalences are clear. This proves the first assertion of the proposition. In Exercise 3.2.2 you will also show that when . point corresponding to the semigroup homomorphism
! ) 4 8 2 6:3 9 ? , # defined by
is the
P ,. 6 7 9 ; R+ # 203 X C D 4 8 SG6 I (Exercise 1.2.2), and 6 , then K , L for all , . If . 0 2 3 I ,K L R if , . 96 . Hence the limit point is precisely the distinguished 3
point
.
Y
6
Using this proposition, we can recover the fan from cone by cone as in Example 3.2.1. This is also the key observation needed for the proof of Corollary 3.1.8 from the previous section.
354 ' R S8
Let us apply Proposition 3.2.2 to a familiar example.
R Example 3.2.3. Consider the affine toric variety studied in a number of examples from Chapter 1. For instance, in Example 1.1.17, we showed that is the normal toric variety corresponding to a cone 6 whose dual cone is = 6 7 R I> 4 ( ( B C D.47F% 6 7 9-; - 8 . and R (3.2.1)
In Example 1.1.17, we introduced the torus image of (3.2.2) Given (3.2.3)
%R 8
R 74 M 8
included in
4 ( 8 4 ( ( " ( 8 R 4 * 8 . ? R , we have the one-parameter subgroup ) 4 8 R 4 U " 8
as the
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
118
contained in , and proceed to examine limit points using Proposition 3.2.2. ! # ) 4 8 weexists * W and * W . These Clearly, in if and only if conditions determine the cone 6J! ?:@ given by
= 6 R I> 4 ( (
(3.2.4)
8
One easily checks that (3.2.1) is the dual of this cone (Exercise 3.2.3). Note also CX D4 8 * * , in which case the limit and that . 3 # ) 4 8 R 4 6 means 8 , which is the distinguished point .
The Torus Orbits. Now we turn to the Y has a distinguished point 3 cone 6 .
5 .
3
6
. We saw above that each
6 ! . This gives the torus orbit 3 6 !
-orbits in 4
46 8 R 5
4 8 In order to determine the structure of 6 , we need the following lemma, which you will prove in Exercise 3.2.4. Lemma 3.2.4. Let 6 be a strongly convex rational polyhedral cone in ?Q@ . Let ? 3 4 8 be the sublattice of ? spanned by the points in 6T9 ? , and let ? 6 R ? ? .
3
(a) There is a perfect pairing
9 ; ? 4 6 8 K L 6 I ? . induced by the dual pairing K L ;
(b) The pairing of part (a) induces a natural isomorphism
I.*4 6 I 9-; J M 8 5 3 5 3 R ? 4 6 8 * M is the torus associated to ? 4 6 8 . where
4 6 8 ! 4 3 , we recall how . 5 acts on semigroup homomorTo study 2+3 , then by Exercise 1.3.1, the point 4 3 phisms. If . is represented by ,
P 48 4 8 ,
is represented by the semigroup homomorphism
(3.2.5)
, R
'
Lemma 3.2.5. Let 6 be a strongly convex rational polyhedral cone in ?Q@ . Then
where ?
46 8
4 6 8 R 23 4 , 8 R P , . 6 I 9 ; I. )4 6 I 9-; J M 8 5 3 ,
.*
is the lattice defined in Lemma 3.2.4.
Z
23 4 , 8 R P 5
R
Proof. The set is invariant under the action of
by (3.2.5).
,. 6 I 9 ;
contains
3
and
Next observe that 6 I is the largest vector subspace of ; @ contained in 6N7 . 2 3 R
Z , then restricting 7 Hence 6 I 9 ; is a subgroup of . If . 6 9 ; 203 to , . 9 6 I R 6 I 9V; yields a group homomorphism 6 I 9V; M
§3.2. The Orbit-Cone Correspondence
119
I 9 ; M is a group homomorphism , we . Z by defining 4 8 , . 6 I 9-; 4 , 8 R , if
6 (Exercise 3.2.5). Conversely, if obtain a semigroup homomorphism
It follows that
Z
,
I..*4 6 I 9-; J M 8 .
otherwise.
Now consider the exact sequence (3.2.6) Tensoring with
M
R+ ? 3 R+ ? R+ ? 4 6 8XR
and using Lemma 3.2.4, we obtain a surjection
* M R * M 5 R ? 5 3 R ? 4 6 8
I..*4 6 I 9-; J M 8
,
5 3 , I..*)4 6 I 9; J M 8 Z 5 -action, so that 5 acts transtively on Z . Then 3 . are compatible with the 5
Z 3 R 4 6 8 , as desired. R implies that The bijections
Z
The Orbit-Cone Correspondence. Our next theorem is the major result of this section. Theorem 3.2.6 (Orbit-Cone Correspondence). Let Y fan in ? @ .
6
be the toric variety of the
(a) There is a bijective correspondence
Y Q 5 6 -orbits in 4 6 8 , I..*)4 6 I 6 T 9 ; J M 8
!
Let / R ? @ . For each cone 6 . Y , 4 6 8 R / R ! 6 4 3
cones 6
(b)
in
(c) The affine open subset
.
4
is the union of orbits
3 R
is a face of
3
4H 8
4 8 4 H 8 , and (d) H is a face of 6 if and only if 6 !
4H 8 R
4 8 3 6 is a face of
4 8 where H denotes the closure in both the classical and Zariski topologies. For instance, Example 3.2.1 tells us that for , there are three types of cones and torus orbits:
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
120
4 8
4 8
5
R ! The cone R , which
! 4 8 R R corresponds
! to the orbit R satisfies . This is a face of all the other cones Y in , and hence all the other orbits are contained in the closure of this one by part (d). According to part (c), since there are no cones properly contained in 4 R 4 8 47 M 8 . ,
The three one-dimensional cones H give the torus orbits of dimension 1. Each of these is isomorphic to M . The closure ( of one of these orbits is one of the 354 ' ' 8 ! , a copy of . Note that each H is contained in coordinate axes two maximal cones.
Y ' fan correspond 4 8 4 8 4 8 6 of inthethetorus to the three fixed points action on . There are two of these in
The three maximal cones
the closure of each of the 1-dimensional torus orbits.
5 -orbit in 6 . Since 6 is covered by the 6 and 4 3 9 4 3 R 4 3 3 , there is a !
! 4 3 . We claim that R 4 6 8 . Note that
and consider those ,. 2 3 satisfying 4 , 8 R P . To prove the claim, let . In Exercise 3.2.6, you will show that these , ’s lie on a face of 6 7 . But faces of 687 are all of the form 6 7 9 H0I for some face H of 6 by Proposition 1.2.10. In other words, there is a face H of 6 such that
, . 23 4 , 8 R P R 6 7 9 H I 9 ; 4 This easily implies . (Exercise 3.2.6), and then H R 6 by the minimality of 0 2 3 4 8 R 6 I 9 ; , and then . 4 6 8 by Lemma 3.2.5. R , . , 6 . Hence
P
4 6 8 since two orbits are either equal or disjoint. This implies R
Proof of Theorem 3.2.6. Let be a 5 -invariant affine open subsets 4 3 Y with unique minimal cone 6 . part (a) follows immediately.
Part (b) follows from Lemma 3.2.5 and (3.2.6).
3
Next consider part (c). We know that is a union of orbits. If H is a face of 6 , 4 8 4 4 3 4 8 4 3 H H ! ! then implies that is an orbit contained in . Furthermore, 4 3 the analysis of part (a) easily implies that any orbit contained in must equal 4 H 8 for some face H of 6 .
4
4 8
H in the classical We now turn to part (d). We begin with the closure of 5 4 8 H topology, which we denote . This is invariant under (Exercise 3.2.6) and 4 6 8 ! 4 H 8 . Then hence is a union of orbits. Suppose that have 4 H 8 ! 4 3 , since otherwise 4 H 8 9 4 3 R , which would imply we 4 H 8 must 4 3 R 4 3 4 H 8 ! 4 3 , 9 it follows since is open in the classical topology. Once we have that H is a face of 6 by part (c). Conversely, let H be a face of 6 . To prove that 4 6 8 ! 4 H 8 , it suffices to show that 4 H 8 9 4 6 8 R P . We will do this by using limits of one-parameter subgroups as in Proposition 3.2.2.
Let point of
4
homomorphism corresponding to the distinguished ,besothe 4 semigroup , 8 R if , . H+I 9; , and otherwise. Let . CX D4 6 8 ,
§3.2. The Orbit-Cone Correspondence
121
4 8 . This semigroup homomorphism is P P 4 8 , , R ' 4 ) 4 8*8 4 , 8 R 4 8 . 4 H 8 for all . M since the orbit of is 4 H 8 . Now let . Note that CX D4 6 8 , L Since . , K if , . 6 7 SG6 4 I 3, and R if , . 6 I . It 4 8 ! 4 8 R #8 follows that exists as a point in by Proposition 3.2.2, and
4 8 4 represents a point in 6 . But it is also in the closure of H by construction, so
4 6 8 9 4 H 8 R P . This establishes the first assertion of (d), and
4H 8 R
4 8 3 6 and for each
. M
consider
48 R
)
is a face of
follows immediately for the classical topology.
It remains to show that this set is also the Zariski closure. If we intersect 4 3 with an affine open subset , parts (c) and (d) imply that
4H 8 9 3 R 3 4
3
4H 8
46 8
354768 ! 4 3 for the ideal 6 R K ' ,. H I 9 4 6 Z 8 7 9-; L ! F%04 6 Z 8 7 9; - R 2 3 (3.2.7)
4 8 6 This easily implies that the classical closure H is a subvariety of and hence
4 8 is the Zariski closure of H .
4H 8 Orbit Closures as Toric Varieties. In the example of , the orbit closures is a face of
containing
In Exercise 3.2.6, you will P show that this is the subvariety
also have the structure of toric varieties. The same is true in general. The torus that 85 from Lemma 3.2.5. The corresponding fan can be acts is the quotient torus Y described as follows. Consider the set of cones 6 in containing H as a face. For 4 8 each such 6 , let 6 be the image cone in ? H @ under the quotient map
? @ R ? 4H 8@ R
obtained from (3.2.6). Then (3.2.8) is a fan in ?
4H 8@
B DB 4H 8 R 6 ! ? 4H 8@ H
(Exercise 3.2.7).
Proposition 3.2.7. For each cone . the toric variety
H
in
Y
is a face of 6
, the orbit closure
4H 8
is isomorphic to
Proof. This follows from parts (a) and (d) of Theorem 3.2.6 (Exercise 3.2.7).
Y
Example 3.2.8. Consider the fan in ?A@ R shown in Figure 7 on the next Y Y page. The support of is the cone in Figure 2 of Chapter 1, and is obtained from
this cone by adding a new -dimensional cone H in the center and subdividing. The 4 8 H has dimension by Theorem 3.2.6. By Proposition 3.2.7, the orbit orbit 4 8 Y closure H is constructed from the cones of containing H and then collapsing
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
122
z
y τ
x
Figure 7. The fan
H
to a point in 4 8 so that H
and its -dimensional cone
? 4( H 8 @ R ( 4 ? ? 8 @ .
. This clearly gives the fan for
( (,
Final Comments. The technique of using limit points of one-parameter subgroups to study a group action is also a major tool in Geometric Invariant Theory as in [71], where the main problem is to construct varieties (or possibly more general objects) representing orbit spaces for the actions of algebraic groups on varieties. We will apply ideas from group actions and orbit spaces to the study of toric varieties in Chapters 5 and 14. We also note the observation made in part (d) of Theorem 3.2.6 that torus orbits have the same closure in the classical and Zariski topologies. For arbitrary subsets of a variety, these closures may differ. A torus orbit is an example of a constructible subset, and we will see in §3.4 that constructible subsets have the same classical and Zariski closures since we are working over . Exercises for §3.2. 3.2.1. In this exercise, you will verify the claims made in Example 3.2.1 and the following discussion. are as claimed in the (a) Show that the remaining limits of one-parameter subgroups example.
4
(b) Show that the
F 'n4 orbits in 4 are as claimed in the example.
(c) Show that the limit point equals the distinguished point in each case.
}{ |
3.2.2. Let consider
, !n' , where ,'6m h ~
of the corresponding cone
be a strongly convex rational polyhedral cone. This exercise will is an arbitrary function.
§3.2. The Orbit-Cone Correspondence
}{ |
, An'
123
(a) Prove that exists in if and only if . Hint: Consider a finite set of characters
{}|
, !n'
}{ |
{}|
F, An'n' exists in ( , .
such that
for all
exists in , prove that the limit is given by the semigroup homo(b) When morphism that maps to .
F, !n' '
3.2.3. Consider the situation of Example 3.2.3. (a) Show that the cones in (3.2.1) and (3.2.4) are dual. (b) Identify the limits of all one-parameter subgroups in this example, and describe the Orbit-Cone Correspondence in this case.
# uC( # defines an automorphism of o and the corresponding linear map on
(c) Show that the matrix
the cone
to .
(d) Deduce that the affine toric varieties tion 1.3.15.
maps
and are isomorphic. Hint: Use Proposi-
3.2.4. Prove Lemma 3.2.4. 3.2.5. Let be as defined in the proof of Lemma 3.2.5. In this exercise, you will complete the proof that is a -orbit in .
(a) Show that if , then is a group homomorphism. (b) Deduce that
~
6
h
has the structure of a group.
(c) Verify carefully that we have an isomorphism of groups
m|
2 '.
6 h be a semigroup homomorphism giving a point of . Prove that / O k 'U(*T `8U( for some face of . (b) Show ' is invariant under the action of ~ . (c) Prove that ' is the variety of the ideal defined in (3.2.7). 3.2.7. Let be a cone in a fan , and let < E ' be as defined in (3.2.8). (a) Show that < & ' is a fan in . ' . (b) Prove Proposition 3.2.7. ~ on the affine toric variety . Use parts (c) and (d) of 3.2.8. Consider the action of ~ acting on . Theorem 3.2.6 to show that 5' is the unique closed orbit of 3.2.9. In Proposition 1.3.16, we saw that if is a face of the strongly convex rational polyhedral cone in then ( <>=?7@mFIH J!' is an affine open subset of ( <>=?7@1AIH J!' . In this exercise, we will show that the converse is also true, i.e., that if % and the induced map of affine toric varieties ] 6 h is an open immersion, then is a face of . (a) Let P2n Q , and assume t Q . Show that }{}| !n' }{}| !n' W+ 3.2.6. This exercise is concerned with the proof of Theorem 3.2.6. (a) Let
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
124
}{ |
!n'
An'
{}|
(b) Show that and
of points as semigroup homomorphisms. (c) Deduce that
P2n S
are each in . Hint: Use the description
, so is a face of .
3.2.10. In this exercise, you will use Proposition 3.2.2 and Theorem 3.2.6 to deduce Corollary 3.1.8 from Theorem 3.1.7. (a) By Theorem 3.1.7, and the results of Chapter 1, a separated toric variety has an open cover consisting of affine toric varieties + for some collection of cones + . is also affine. Hint: Use the fact that is separated. Show that for all , +
(
( 4
2
(
+ . (b) Show that + is the affine toric variety corresponding to the cone Hint: Exercise 3.2.2 will be useful. ,+% , then show that is a face of both + and . Hint: Use Exercise 3.2.9. (c) If
(d) Deduce that
+ and all their faces.
for the fan consisting of the
§3.3. Equivariant Maps of Toric Varieties
Recall from §3.0 that if and are varieties with affine open covers R 4 Z is a Zariski-continuous and R , then a morphism of varieties mapping such that the restrictions (
4
9
" 4 Z 8 R 4
are regular in the sense of Definition 3.0.1 for all
When
and
"M
4
Z
4
.
are normal toric varieties, the results on mappings of affine toric varieties from Propositions 1.3.14 and 1.3.15 yield a class of morphisms whose construction comes directly from the combinatorics of the associated fans. The goal of this section is to study these special morphisms.
(
Y(
4 (8
Y
Definition 3.3.1. Let ? ? be two lattices a fan in ? @ and YS( a fan 4 8 @ . A -linear mapping ( ? with ? in ? is compatible with the fans Y if for every cone 6 ( in Y ( , there exists a cone 6 in Y such that 4 ( 8 and . @ 6 !6
(
(
Y
R Example 3.3.2. Let ? basis and let be the fan from Figure 4 < with 6 R in §3.1. By Example 3.1.16, ( is the Hirzebruch surface . Also let ? Y and consider the fan giving :
6 (
6
as in Example 3.1.11. The mapping
? (%R ? * ( R+ * Y and Y since each cone of Y is compatible with the fans
Y
. If
RP
, on the other hand, the mapping
? ( R+ ?
*( Y is not compatible with these fans since 6 .
R
maps onto a cone of
Y
does not map into a cone of .
§3.3. Equivariant Maps of Toric Varieties
125
Toric Morphisms. For our purposes, it will be convenient to take the result of part (a) of Proposition 1.3.14 as the definition of a toric morphism in this context. The discussion from §1.3 shows that this is consistent with what we did for affine toric varieties.
* ,
6
YS(
4 (8
@ Definition 3.3.3. Let , be normal toric varieties, with a fan in ? Y 4 8 6
6 and in ? is toric if maps the torus 5 ! a 6 faninto 5 @ ! . A 6morphism and is a group homomorphism.
6
The proof of part (b) of Proposition 1.3.14 generalizes easily to show that any 6 6 is an equivariant mapping for the 5 - and toric morphism 5 -actions. That is, we have a commutative diagram
5 0 6
(3.3.1)
where
(
and
/
*-,
6
/
6 5
6
give the torus actions.
( ?
Our first result in this section shows that toric morphisms are in bijective correspondence with -linear mappings ? Y( Y compatible with the fans and . Theorem 3.3.4. Let ?
(Q
( ?
6
6
that are
4 ? ' 8 @ , R . Y ( and Y , then -linear map that is compatible with Y '
be lattices, and let
(a) If ? ? is a there is a toric morphism
be a fan in
such that * , is the map ? (/ M R ? M is a toric morphism, then induces a -linear (b) Conversely, if ? ( ? that is compatible with the fans Y ( and Y . map ( Y ( YS( and Proof. To prove part (a), let 6 be a cone in . Since is compatible with 4 (8 Y Y , there is a cone 6 . with @ 6 3 3 ! 6 3 . Then Proposition 1.3.15 shows that induces a toric morphism . Using the general criterion for 3 gluing morphisms from Exercise 3.3.1, you will show in Exercise 3.3.2 that the . Moreover, is toric because glue together to give a morphism 5 5 , which is easily seen to be the group ( taking 6 R gives ? ( ? . homomorphism induced by the -linear map we show first that the toric morphism induces a -linear map ? For( part? (b), */, . This follows since is a group homomorphism. Hence, given . ? ( , the one-parameter subgroup M 5 can be composed with * , */, M 5 . This defines an to give the one-parameter subgroup 4 8 . ? . It is straightforward to show that ? ( ? is -linear. element 6
6
+*
6
+*
6
4
4
6
)
6
)
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
126
YF(
Y
It remains to show that is compatible with the fans 5 5 -orbit ( ! 6 is mappedandinto a. Because of the equivariance (3.3.1), each 5 -orbit
6 Orbit-Cone Correspondence (Theorem 3.2.6), each ( R! 4 6 (. 8 Byforthesome ( Y ( 4 6 is8 5 -orbit is R -orbit cone 6 in , and similarly each Y . Furthermore, if H ( ! 6 ( is a face, then by the same for some cone 6 in Y 4 4 H ( 8*8 ! 4 H 8 . such that reasoning, there is some cone H in
H
in this situation must be a face of 6 . This follows since
4 6 We
4 H 8 that 8 ! claim by part (d) of Theorem 3.2.6. Since is continuous in the Zariski 4 ( 8 4 8
H H . But the only orbits contained in the closure of ! topology, 4 H 8 are the orbits corresponding to cones which have H as a face. So H is a face of 6 . It follows from part (c) of Theorem 3.2.6 that also maps the affine open 3 4 3 ! 6 into 4 ! 6 , i.e., subset
4 38 ! 3 3 3 It follows that induces a toric morphism , which by Proposition 1.3.15 4 ( 8 ! 6 . Hence is compatible with the fans YS( and Y . implies that @ 6 4
(3.3.2)
4
4
4
First Examples. Here are some examples of toric morphisms defined by mappings compatible with the corresponding fans. Example 3.3.5. Let ?
( R
and ?
R
, and let
? ( R+ ? * ( R * is compatible with the fans be the first mapping in Example 3.3.2. We saw Y of the Hirzebruch surface < and Y of ( . that 3.3.4 implies that there < ( ( Theorem is a corresponding toric morphism . We will see ( later in this section < that this mapping gives the structure of a -bundle over . + , the multiplicaY Example 3.3.6. Let ? R and be a fan in ? @ . For .
tion map
Y is compatible with 6 6
? R+ ?
* R+
*
. By Theorem 3.3.4, there is a corresponding toric morphism 5 ! 6 is the group endomorphism whose restriction to
! *-, 4 ( +98 R 4 ( + 8
. R For a concrete example, let be the fan in ?A @ from Figure 2 and take R Then we obtain the morphism defined in homogeneous coordinates 4 ' *')(*' 8 R 4 ' *' ( *' 8 . by
Y
Sublattices of Finite Index. We get an interesting toric morphism when a lattice Y ? Z has finite index Zin a larger lattice ? . If Y is a fan in ? @ , then we can view Z as a fan either in ? @ or in ? @ , and the inclusion ? with the ? is compatible Y Z 6 5 6 5 fan in ? @ and ? @ . As in Chapter 1, we obtain toric varieties and
§3.3. Equivariant Maps of Toric Varieties
127
depending on which lattice we consider, and the inclusion ? morphism
5 R 5
Z
induced by the inclusion
Z
a sublattice of finite index in ? Z .beThen
and let
5 +R 5
? Z ?
induces a toric
6
6
Proposition 3.3.7. Let ? ? @ R ? @ Z . Let R ? ?
Z ?
Y
be a fan in
6
6
presents
6
5
as the quotient
6
5
.
Proof. Since ? has finite index in ? , Proposition 1.3.18 shows that the finite R ? ? Z is the kernel of 5 5 . It follows that acts on 6 5 . group 5 4 34 5 This action is compatible with the inclusion ! 4 6 34 5 for each cone 6 . Y . 4 34 5 Using Proposition 1.3.18 again, we see that , which easily implies 6 5 6 5 that .
We will revisit Proposition 3.3.7 in Chapter 5, where we will show that the 6 5 6 5 map is a good geometric quotient.
Y
5
Example 3.3.8. Let ? R , and be the fan shown in Figure 5, so is 4
. 8 Z . Let ? be the sublattice of isomorphic to the weighted projective space
? Z given by ? Z R 4 * ( 8 . ( ? I , so ? Z has index 2 in ? . Note that ? is generated by R , R and that
Z
R R ( R5 R R ( R
6
. ? Z
Let ? ? Z be6 the map. It is not difficult to see that with respect 5 inclusion to the lattice ? , (Exercise By Theorem 3.3.4, the -linear 3.3.3). 4
.8 , and by Proposition 3.3.7, it map induces a toric morphism 4
. 8 . Z follows that for R ? ?
σ2
Figure 8. The semigroups
and
The cone 6 from Figure 5 has the dual cone 6/7 shown in Figure 8. It is Z dual to ? Z . One checks instructive to consider how 6 7 interacts with the lattice ; Z 4 * .8 * . and 6 7 R = I> 4 (XR 4R 8 . In Figure 8, the that ;
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
128
Z
points in 67 9 ; are shown in white, and the points in 6/7 9 ; not in 6N7 9 ; are shown in black. Note that the picture in 6 7 9 ; is the same (up to a change 4 JX8 Figure 10 from Chapter 1. This shows again that of coordinates in 4 .8 contains the affine) as 4 3 5 open subset isomorphic to the rational normal 4 3 5 is smooth. The other affine open subsets cone . On the other hand ( in both 4 .8 . corresponding to 6 and 6 are isomorphic to and in
6
Torus Factors. A toric variety has a torus factor if it is equivariantly isomorphic to the product of a nontrivial torus and a toric variety of smaller dimension.
Proposition 3.3.9. Let equivalent: (a)
6
6
Y
be the toric variety of the fan . Then the following are
has a torus factor.
(b) There is a nonconstant morphism
M .
6
. YS4 8 , do not span ?G@ . 6 6 47 M 8 6 Proof. If for and some toric variety , then a non6 7 4 8 7 4 M8 M. trivial character of M gives a nonconstant morphism 6 M is a nonconstant If morphism, then Exercise 3.3.4 implies that 5 is ' P where . M , . ; . Multiplying by the( restriction of to P " , we may assume that *-, R ' . Then is aand toric morphism coming from M ? a surjective homomorphism . Since comes from the trivial fan, Y Y S 4
8 maps all cones of to the origin. Hence . for all . , so that the do not span ? @ . Y 4 8 S Finally, suppose that the , . span a proper subspace of ?:@ . Then B + C B Z ) 4 Y S 4
* 8 8 Z is . is proper sublattice of ? such that ? ? ? R 9 ? Y Z Z Z Z Z Z ? Y . Furthermore, with ? R ? can torsion-free, so ? has a complement ? Y Z Z Y Y Z Y Z Z R be regarded as a fan in ? @ , and then is the product fan , where Y ZZ ZZ is the trivial fan in ? @ . Then Proposition 3.1.14 gives an isomorphism 6 6 5 5 6 5 5
47 M 8 + "
!
? @ R / and ! ? @ Z R . where (c) The
,
In later chapters, torus varieties without torus factors will play an important role. Hence we state the following corollary of Proposition 3.3.9. Corollary 3.3.10. Let equivalent: (a)
6
6
Y
be the toric variety of the fan . Then the following are
has no torus factors.
6 M is constant, i.e., 4 . YS4 8 , span ? @ .
(b) Every morphism (c) The
,
6
" 8M R M.
We can also think about this from the point of view of sublattices.
§3.3. Equivariant Maps of Toric Varieties
129
? @ R / , ! ? @ Z R G @ .
Z
! ? be a sublattice with Proposition 3.3.11. Let ? Y Z Let be a fan in ? @ , which we can regard as a fan in ? (a) If ?
Z
.
is spanned by a subset of a basis of ? , then we have+ an isomorphism
5 5 5 5 5 5 47 M 8 "
6
6
(b) In general, a basis for ? 6 of finite index. Then
6
5
Z
5 6
6
? ZZ ! ?
can be extended to a basis of a sublattice is isomorphic to the quotient of+
5
5 5
ZZ by the finite abelian group ? ? .
5 547 M 8 "
6
Proof. Part (a) follows from the proof of Proposition 3.3.9, and part (b) follows from part (a) and Proposition 3.3.7.
Y Z
Y
Y
Refinements of Fans and Blowups. Given in ? @ , a fan Y Z R a Y fan Y Z Y Y refines if every cone of is contained in and . Hence every cone of is a union YZ YZ refines Y , the identity mapping on ? is automatically of cones of . When Y Z Y 6 6 . compatible with and . This yields a toric morphism
Y Z
Example 3.3.12. Consider the fan in ? in Figure 1 from §3.1. = pictured Y > I 4 ( 8 and This is a refinement of the fan consisting of its faces. The 6 6 R 354 ' RQ' ( 'V8 ! are and corresponding toric varieties ( at the origin (see Example 3.1.15). The identity map , the blowup of on( ? induces a toric morphism . This “blowdown” ( morphism maps ! to . and is injective outside of
in .
+
We can generalize this example and Example 3.1.5 as follows.
Y
= I> 4 ( + 8
Definition 3.3.13. Let be a fan in ?@ . Let 6 R Y ( + smooth cone in , so that is a basis for ? . Let R Y Z46 8 be the set of all cones generated by subsets of ( + . Then
( +
+
be a and let not containing
Y M 4 6 8 R 4 Y S 6 8 Y Z 4 6 8 Y is a fan in ? @ called the star subdivision of along 6 . = I> 4 ( 8 ! ?@ be a smooth cone. Example 3.3.14. Let 6 R Figure 9 on the next page shows the star subdivision of 6 into three cones = I> 4 ( 8 = I> 4 ( 8 = I> 4 8 Y 4 8 The fan M 6 consists of these cones, together with their faces. Y 4 8 Y Proposition 3.3.15. M 6 is a refinement of , and the induced toric morphism 6 3 R+ 6 3 6 -3 6 makes the blowup of at the distinguished point corresponding to the cone 6 .
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
130
u0
u2 u1
u3
Figure 9. The star subdivision
Y 4 8
Y
Proof. Since and M 6 are the same outside the cone 6 , without loss of generY + fan consisting of 6 and all of its faces, ality, we may reduce to the case that is the
6 4 3 and is the affine toric variety .
Under the Orbit-Cone Correspondence (Theorem 3.2.6), 6 corresponds to the 3 distinguished point , the origin (the unique fixed point of the torus action). By Theorem 3.3.4, the identity map on ? induces a toric morphism
3-
6
4
3 +
3
+ It is easy to check that the affine open sets covering are the same as for the blowup of at the origin from Exercise 3.0.8, and they are glued together in the same way by Exercise 3.1.5.
3
4 8 . In this notation, the
+ +8 The blowup at is sometimes denoted 7 4 blowup of at the origin is written . 6
6
6
The point blown up in Proposition 3.3.15 is a fixed point of the torus action. In some cases, torus-invariant subvarieties of larger dimension have equally nice+ ( + of blowups. We begin with the affine case. + The standard basis 3 = = > I 4 ( + 8 4 > I 4 ( 8 , R gives 6 R , and the face H R with / , gives the orbit closure
4 H 8 R A + "
4 8 R ( and consider the fan To construct the blowup of H , let Y M 4 H 8 R = I> 4 8 ! + . ( ! P . (3.3.3)
= I> 4 ( 8 = ( ! ? @ and H R I> 4 8 . 6 into the cones = >I 4 ( 8 = I> 4 8
Example 3.3.16. Let 6 R H The star subdivision relative to subdivides
§3.3. Equivariant Maps of Toric Varieties
as shown in Figure 10. The fan their faces.
Y M 4H 8
131
consists of these two cones, together with
e0
e2
τ e1
e3
Figure 10. The star subdivision
+" + 6 For the fan (3.3.3), the toric variety is the blowup+ of . Y 4 8 +" ! R To see why, observe that M H is a product fan. Namely, , and Y M 4 H 8 R Y ( Y Y ( .47 8 (coming from = I> 4 ( 8 ) and Y is the where + is the fan for " (coming from = I> 4 U ( + 8 ). It follows that fan for 6 R 47 8X + " " ( .47 + 8 is built by replacing . with Since follows ( +6 " R .47 8 " is built by replacing Q + " ! , + itwith " that . the 47 + 8 separates directions through the origin in , while +" intuitive idea is that 8 6 47 R the blowup normal directions to + . One can also study 47separates + 8 by working in on affine pieces given by Y 4 8 M H the maximal cones of —see [76, Prop. 1.26].
We generalize (3.3.3) as follows.
Y
+
Definition 3.3.17. Let be a fan in ?@ and assume H . Y H R & that all cones of containing are smooth. Let Y containing H , set cone 6 .
the property - ( has and for each
Y 3M 4 H 8 R = I> 4 8 ! 6 4 8 H 4 8 ! P Y Then the star subdivision of relative to H is the fan Y M 4 H 8 R 6 . Y H !P 6 Y 3 4 8 3 M H
Y
.
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
132
The fan
Y M 4H 8
4H 8.
Under the map , ; 4 8 closure H R
Y
is a refinement of 6
and hence induces a toric morphism
6
6
becomes the blowup
4 8
6
of
6
along the orbit
In Chapters 10 and 11 we will use toric morphisms coming from refinements of fans to resolve the singularities of toric varieties. Exact Sequences and Fibrations. Next, we consider some of the local structure of toric morphisms. To begin, consider a surjective -linear mapping
Z ? ? Y Y Z Z If in ? @ and in ? @ are compatible with , then we have a corresponding toric morphism R 4 8 , so that we have an exact sequence Now let ? R ? RR ? Z R (3.3.4) R+ ?
6
It is easy to check that
6
R 6 . Y 6 ! 4 ? 8 @ Y 4 8 @V! ? @ . By Proposition 3.3.11, is a subfan of whose cones lie in ? (3.3.5)
Y
Z
6
5 6 5 5
? . Furthermore, is compatible with since ? ? Z
in ? @ . This gives the toric morphism
"
,
" 4 5 8 R
6
Y
in ?@ and the trivial fan
5 5
In fact, by the reasoning to ( prove Proposition 3.3.4,
5 6 5 5 6 lying over 5 ! 6 is identified with the product In other words, the part of 5 6 5 . We say this subset of 6 is a fiber bundle of and the toric variety 5 with fiber 6 5 . over Y When the fan has a suitable structure relative to , we can make a similar 6 statement for every torus-invariant affine open subset of . Y Y Z Y Definition 3.3.18. In the situation of (3.3.4), we say is split by and if there Y Y exists a subfan ! such that: Y bijectively to a cone 6 Z . Y Z such that 6 6 Z defines (a) maps each cone 6 . Y Y Z
6
(3.3.6)
a bijection
(b)
. Y YGiven cones 6 arises this way.
.
and 6
. Y , the sum 6
6
Y
lies in , and every cone of
§3.3. Equivariant Maps of Toric Varieties
Y
Theorem 3.3.19. If is split by 6 locally trival fiber bundle over 4 open affine subsets satisfying
Y Z
133
Y
6
and as in Definition 3.3.18, then 6 5 . That is, 6 has a coverisbya with fiber
"(4 8 4
6
5
4
YS4 6 Z 8 R 6 . Y 4 6 8 ! 6 Z . Then " ( 4 4 3 8 R 6 3 6 3 6 5 .4 3 YS4 Z 8 Y 9 YS4 6 Z 8 It remains to show that . Since 6 is split by Y YS4 6 Z8 , we may assume 6 R 4 3 . In other words, we are reduced to the and 9 Y Z Z case when consists of 6 and its proper faces. ? Z ? splits the exact sequence (3.3.4) provided $ A -linear map $ Z is the identity on ? . A splitting induces an isomorphism Z ? ? ? Y such that maps 6 bijectively to 6 Z . By Definition 3.3.18, there is a cone 6 . Z Using 6 , one can find a splitting $ with the property that $ @ maps H to H for all Y H . (Exercise 3.3.5). Using Definition 3.3.18 again, we conclude that 4 ? 8 @ ? Z ?@ @ 4 Y 4 ? 8 @ 8 4 Y Z ? Z 8 4Y 8 carries the product fan @ to the fan ?G@ . By ProposiProof. Fix 6
Z
in
Y Z
and let
tion 3.1.14, we conclude that
6 6 5 - 6
6 5 4
3
and the theorem is proved. Example 3.3.20. To complete the discussion from Examples 3.3.2 and 3.3.5, con< ( sider the toric morphism induced by the mapping
Y
<
R
*(
(
Y
R+ *
R The fan of is split by the fan of and Y Y because of the subfan of consisting of the cones
= I> F4 R (
6 . Y @ 4 6 8 R
8 . = I> 94 ( 8 Y Z These cones are mapped bijectively to the cones in under @ consists of the cones = >I 4 8 . = >I F4 R 8
The fans
Y
and
Y
are shown in Figure 11.
Y
. and 6 . < As we vary over all 6 < . Hence Theorem 3.3.19 shows that with fibers isomorphic to
6 5
Y
, the sums 6
Y
. Note also that
give all cones of ( is a locally trivial fibration over ,
(
6
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
134
Σ0 ↓
〉
Σ ↓
σ4 (−1, r)
σ1
σ3
〉
←Σ σ2
↓
↓
↓
Figure 11. The Splitting of the Fan
4 8
R where ? gives the vertical axis in Figure 11. ( This( fibration is not < globally trivial when , i.e., it is not true that . There( is some " 44 3 8 “twisting” on the fibers involved when we try to glue together the ( < 4 3 to obtain .
We will give another, more precise, description of these fiber bundles and the “twisting” mentioned above using the language of sheaves in Chapter 6.
4 8
Images of Distinguished Points. Each orbit contains 6 4 in8 a toric variety 3 a distinguished point , and each orbit closure 6 is a toric variety in its own right. These structures are compatible with toric morphisms as follows.
6
6
6
Lemma 3.3.21. Let be the toric morphism coming from a map Z Y Y Z Y , let 6 Z . Y Z be the and . Given 6 . ? ? thatY Z is compatible with 4 8 minimal cone of containing @ 6 . Then:
4 3 8 R 3 , where 3 . 4 4 6 8*8 ! 4 6 Z8 and (b) 3 (c) The induced map
46 8
3 . 4 6 Z08
46 8 ! 46 Z8. 4 6 8 4 6 Z 8 is a toric morphism. Z( Z Y Z contain 4 6 8 , then so does their intersecProof. First observe that if 6 6 . @4 8 Y Z tion. Hence has a minimal cone containing @ 6 . (a)
and
are the distinguished points.
§3.3. Equivariant Maps of Toric Varieties
135
4 8 . C D4 6 Z 8 4 3 8 R ! # 4 8 R ! # 4 4 *8 8 R ! # 4 8 R 3
To prove part (a), pick Z the minimality of 6 . Then )
. C D 4 6 8
and observe that )
by
)
where the first and last equalities use Proposition 3.2.2. The first assertion of part (b) follows immediately from part (a) by the equivariance, and the second assertion follows by continuity (as usual, we get the same closure in the classical and Zariski topologies).
3- 4 8 4 Z08
For (c), observe that 6 6 is a morphism that is also a group homomorphism—this follows easily from equivariance. Since the orbit closures 3 4 6 8X 4 6 Z 8 is a toric are toric varieties by Proposition 3.2.7, the map morphism according to Definition 3.3.3.
Exercises for §3.3.
/ 8
3.3.1. Let be a variety with an affine open cover + , and let be a second variety. is + be a collection of morphisms. We say that a morphism Let + + for all . Show that there exists such a obtained by gluing the + if if and only if for every pair ,
] 6 h
] 6 h ] ] O 4 (N] ]6 h 2 ],+ O 4 *( ] O 4 + 3.3.2. Let 2 be lattices, and let in ' , in ' be fans. Let ] 6! h 4 4 4 4 be a -linear mapping that is compatible with the corresponding fans. Using Exercise 3.3.1 above, show that the induced toric morphisms ] 6 h glue together to form a morphism ] 6 h . 3.3.3. This exercise asks you to verify some of the claims made in Example 3.3.8. 4. (a) Verify that with respect to the lattice , Q[
(b) Verify carefully that the affine open subset 6[ g , the rational normal cone of 4 degree 2. , gives a morphism ~ h . Here you will determine all 3.3.4. A character , " morphisms ~ h . (a) Explain why morphisms ~ h correspond to invertible elements in the coordinate ring of ~ . r (b) Let t and s . Prove that is invertible in IH 27+6+6+72n J and that all invertible elements of IH 26+6+7+62 J are of this form. ~ are of the form for (c) Use part (a) to show that all morphisms ~ 0h on and .
3.3.5. Let and let and be cones in ] 6 h be a surjective -linear mapping
and respectively with the property that ] maps
bijectively onto . Prove that ] has a splitting 6! Dh such that maps to . 3.3.6. Let be the fan obtained from the fan for 4 in Example 3.1.9 by the following process. Subdivide the cone into two new cones and 4 4 4 4 by inserting an edge `?mp # 4 '.
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
136
explicitly and give the gluing homomorphisms. (b) Show that the resulting toric variety is smooth. (c) Show that is isomorphic to the Hirzebruch surface . (a) Construct an affine open cover for
nm2612 1'
3.3.7. Let be the fan obtained from the fan for ( in Example 3.1.17 by the following process. Subdivide the cone into two new cones and by inserting an edge . (a) Construct an affine open cover for explicitly and give the gluing homomorphisms.
`?1n# 4 '
4
(c) Construct a morphism of .
434
is smooth.
]6 h
(b) Show that the resulting toric variety
4
and determine the fiber over the singular point
(d) One of our smooth examples is isomorphic to
. Which one is it?
( / W2 o&'UO I( m8$MF 'p4 4 4 and (M/ W W26 1'ZO2' 2 - |Wz >8 < . Also let ) ( &4 + ) . (a) Let D( Prove that the map h F 'n4 defined by ` `2 6 m':jh 2 ' induces an exact ) ) sequence #Dh #Dh #h #h `+ `?1 2 4 'L ' ( ( 4 . The inclusion Qh induces a toric (b) Let ( morphism [ h [ . Prove that this is the quotient map 4 h 4
for the above action of on 4 .
on . We will ) 3.3.8. Consider the action of the group study the quotient and its resolution of singularities using toric morphisms.
4
(c) Find the Hilbert basis (i.e., the set of irreducible elements) of the semigroup Hint: The Hilbert basis has four elements.
(d) Use the Hilbert basis from part (c) to subdivide . This gives a fan with Prove that is smooth relative to and that the resulting toric morphism
Q[ h [ C(C 4
.
O :O( .
is a resolution of singularities. This is a special case of the theory to be developed in Chapter 10.
A 'p4:- 4
m 'B( d # 12 c # d o '
(e) The group gives the finite set with ideal . ) Read about the Gr¨obner fan in [18, Ch. 8,§4] and compute the Gr¨obner fan of . The answer will be identical to the fan described in part (d). This is no accident, as shown in the paper [54]. There is a lot of interesting mathematics going on here, including the McKay correspondence and the -Hilbert scheme. See also [69] for the higher dimensional case.
ko F `2 26#&'
3.3.9. Consider the fan in shown in Figure 12 on the next page. This fan has five one-dimensional cones with four “upward” ray generators and one “downward” generator . There are also nine two-dimensional cones. Figure 12 shows five of the two-dimensional cones; the remaining four are generated by the combining the downward generator with the four upward generators.
$12 26E'927F `2$126&'
c h . (b) Show that h is a locally trivial fiber bundle over with fiber nm27m2 (1' . Hint: Theorem 3.3.19 and pm23 `27E' Cp#m23 `27E' (A 2 `27#E' (V . See Example 3.1.17.
(a) Show that projection onto the -axis induces a toric morphism
§3.3. Equivariant Maps of Toric Varieties
137
z
y x
Figure 12. A fan
in
p126m2 m'
(c) Explain how you can see the splitting (in the sense of Definition 3.3.18) in Figure 12. Also explain why the figure makes it clear that the fiber is ( .
)4
3.3.10. Consider the fan in
with ray generators
( 4 2e ( 2e 4 ( 4 2 o (M# and two-dimensional cones `?1A 2 '92 `?1A 2n ' 2 ! ?1! 2 ' . 4 4 ato one point. (a) Draw a picture of and prove that is the blowup of h such that (b) Show the a toric morphism ] 6 map ! 4 jh induces ] As that ' for s * and ] A ' is a union of two copies of meeting at a F 1' gives point. Hint: Once you understand ] A 1 ' , show that the fan for ] . (c) To get a better picture of , consider the map 6F 'n4Uh o defined by F12 n'B(L F o 2 4 237 2 4 ' 2 n' + nF ' 4 'y o be the closure of the image. Prove that and Let ( o Chi to gives the toric morphism ] of that the restriction of the projection part (b). o U is defined by the equations (d) Let d 2 c 2 2 $ be coordinates on o . Prove that 'c $ # 4 (* 2 d # c 4 (C `2 %d $ # &c (V `+ FsP' for sLV , and explain how Also use these equations to describe the fibers ] this relates to part (b). Hint: The twisted cubic is relevant.
This is a semi-stable degeneration of toric varieties. See [51] for more details.
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
138
§3.4. Complete and Proper The Compactness Criterion. We begin by proving part (c) of Theorem 3.1.19. Theorem 3.4.1. The following are equivalent for a toric variety (a)
6
! #
is compact in the classical topology.
(b) The limit (c)
Y
)
48
exists in
is complete (that is,
Y
6
3 6 6 R ?@
R
. ?
for all
6
.
.
).
6
Proof. First observe that since is separated (Theorem 3.1.5), it is Hausdorff as a topological space (Theorem 3.0.17). In fact, since the classical topology on 4 3 6 is a metric topology, is compact if and only if every each affine open set 6 sequence of points in has a convergent subsequence.
(b), assume that is compact and fix . ? . Given a sequence ) 4 8 . 6 . By compactness, . For M (a)converging to , we get the sequence this sequence has a convergent subsequence. Passing to this subsequence, we can ! ) 4 8
6 6 R . assume that . Because the union of the affine 34 # 3 Y , we may assume . 4 . Nowis take ,. 6 7 9 ; . The open subsetsP for 6 . ' 4 3 character is a regular function on and hence is continuous in the classical topology. Thus 6
'
P 4 8 R
#
P 4 ) 4 8*8 R
'
#
! P
, the exponent must be nonnegative, i.e., K , L-W for all , . , . 687 , so that . 4 6N7 8 7 R 6 . Then 67 9 ; . This implies K , L!W for) all 4 8 exists in 4 3 and hence in 6 . # Proposition 3.2.2 implies that
Since
!
48
# To prove (b) (c), take . ? and consider the limit . This lies 4 3 . in some affine open , which implies 6 Y 9? by Proposition Y 3.2.2. Thus every lattice point of ?G@ is contained in a cone of . It follows that is complete.
)
?:@ . In the case / R , the We will prove (c) (a) by induction on / R Y only complete fan is the fan The correspond 6 R ( in pictured in Example L 3.1.11. ing toric variety is . This is homeomorphic to , the two-dimensional sphere, and hence is compact.
Now assume the statement is true for all complete fans + of dimension strictly Y . 6 be a less than / , and consider a complete fan in ? @ . Let sequence. We will show that has a convergent subsequence.
6
4 8
H , we may assume the seSince is the union of finitely many orbits 4 8 4 8 H H R quence . If P , then the closure of H 6 lies entirely within an orbit R in is the toric variety of dimension / Proposition 3.2.7. Since B D B 4 H 8 by Y is complete, 4 8 it is easy to check that the fan is also complete in ? H @ (Exercise 3.4.1). Then the induction hypothesis implies that there is a convergent
§3.4. Complete and Proper
139
4 8
subsequence in H . Hence, without loss of generality again, we may assume that 5 ! 6 . our sequence lies entirely in the torus Recall from the discussion following Lemma 3.2.5 that
5 . 5
,
I. *V4 ; J M 8
Moreover, when we regard as a group homomorphism Y , restriction yields a semigroup homomorphism 6 for any 6 . 4 3 hence a point in .
; M , then 7Q9 ; and
5 ? @ ;
A key ingredient of the proof will be the logarithm map 5 ; M of , consider the map as follows. Given a point by the formula
, R
I 4 , 8
4 8
. , This is a homomorphism and hence gives an element For more properties of this mapping, see Exercise 3.4.2 below. the most important property of 4 8 R 6 for some 6 . Y 5 us, . For satisfies . of
defined defined
I. *4 ; * 8 ? @
.
is the following. Suppose that a point . If , . 687:9 ; , then the definition
implies that
I 4 , 8 R K , 4 8 L 4 8 R 6 . Hence 4 , 8 . Thus we have which is since , . 6 7 and . proved that 4 , 8 4 8 . R 6 R (3.4.2) for all ,. 6 7 9-; 4 8 . ? @ . Since Y Now apply to our sequence, which gives a sequence R Y (3.4.1)
is complete, the same is true for the fan consisting of the cones Hence, by passing to a subsequence, we may assume that there is 6
4 8 . R 6 4 , 8 . By (3.4.2), we conclude that
6 for 6 . . . Y such that
for all for all ,. 6 7 9 ; . It follows that the are a sequence of mappings to the closed unit disk in . Since the closed unit disk is compact, there is a subsequence which converges to a point 4 3 . . You will check the details of this final assertion in Exercise 3.4.3.
Proper Mappings. The property of compactness also has a relative version that is used most often in the theory of complex manifolds.
Definition 3.4.2. A continuous mapping O "O ( 4 8 is compact in for every compact subset
is proper if the inverse image ! .
It is immediate that is compact if and only if the constant mapping from to the space R pt consisting of a single point is proper. This relative version of compactness may also be reformulated, for reasonably nice topological spaces, in the following way.
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
140
Proposition 3.4.3. Let O be a continuous mapping of locally compact first countable Hausdorff spaces. Then the following are equivalent: (a) (b) (c)
O
is proper.
4 4S8
is closed in for all closed subsets . , are compact. ' . 4 ' 8 . converges has a subsequence Exery sequence ' that converges in . such that O 4
O
is a closed mapping (that ( is, O ! ), and all its fibers O " 4 8 ,
Proof. A proof of (a) (a) (c).
(b) can be found in [33, Ch. 9,§4]. See Exercise 3.4.4 for
Before we can give a definition of properness that works for morphisms, we L need another criterion for properness. Recall from §3.0 that morphisms O L U and give the fibered product . Fibered products can also be defined for continuous maps between topological spaces. In Exercise 3.4.4, you will prove that properness can formulated using fibered products.
Proposition 3.4.4. Let O be a continuous map between locally compact Hausdorff spaces. Then O is proper if and only if O is universally closed, meaning
that for all spaces and all continuous mappings , the projection defined by the commutative diagram
&
/
N
/
is a closed mapping. In algebraic geometry, it is customary to use the following definition of properness for morphisms of algebraic varieties.
(
Definition 3.4.5. A morphism of varieties is proper if it is univer
sally closed in the sense that for all varieties and morphisms , the projection defined by the commutative diagram
&
/
/
is a closed mapping in the Zariski topology. A variety pt is proper. the constant morphism
is said to be complete if
§3.4. Complete and Proper
141
Example 3.4.6. The + Projective Extension Theorem [17, Thm. 6 of Ch. 8, §5] shows that for R , the mapping + P P
P ; . It follows that if ! is any affine + variety, the projection ; ; is a closed mapping in the Zariski By the gluing+ construction, it follows + topology.
pt is proper, so is a complete variety that the constant morphism is closed in the Zariski topology for all ,
(the prototypical complete variety). Moreover, any projective variety is complete (Exercise 3.4.5).
that this is not On the other hand, consider the morphism
pt . We claim J R proper, so is not complete. To see this, consider and the diagram pt
.
The closed subset ( under . Hence
/
/ pt
354 ' R 8 ! does not map to a Zariski-closed subset of ( is not a closed mapping, and is not complete.
Completeness is the algebraic version of compactness, and it can be shown that a variety is complete if and only if it is compact in the classical topology. This is proved in Serre’s famous paper G´eom´etrie alg´ebrique et g´eom´etrie analytique, called GAGA for short. See [92, Prop. 6, p. 12]. The Properness Criterion. Theorem 3.4.1 can be understood as a special case of the following statement for toric morphisms.
6
6
Theorem 3.4.7. Let be the toric morphism corresponding to a ? ? Z that is compatible with fans Y in ?A@ and Y Z in ? @ Z . homomorphism Then the following are equivalent:
is proper in the classical topology (Definition 3.4.2). is a proper morphism (Definition 3.4.5). ! # 4 8 exists in , then # 4 8 exists in and
(b)
6
(a)
6
(d)
6
(" . 4 Y? Z 8 Y R @
(c) If
6
)
)
6
6
.
.
Proof. The proof of (a)
(b) uses two fundamental results in algebraic geometry.
First, given any morphism of varieties O and a Zariski closed subset ! , a theorem of Chevalley tells us that the image O 4 4<8 ; ! is8 constructible, 4 8 R ' ' S ' , where ; ' and meaning that it can be written as a finite union O ' are Zariski closed in . A proof appears in [41, Ex. II.3.19].
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
142
Second, given any constructible subset of a variety , its closure in in the classical topology equals its closure in the Zariski topology. When is a Zariski open, a proof is given in [70, Thm. (2.33)], and when is the image of a morphism, a proof can be found in GAGA [92, Prop. 7, p. 12].
6
6
that is proper in the classical topology and let
Now suppose 6 be a morphism. This gives the commutative diagram
"
6
"
6
/
/
6
4 8
Let be Zariski closed. We need to prove that is Zariski ! closed in . First observe that is also closed in the classical topology, so that 4 =8 is closed in in the classical topology by Proposition 3.4.4. However, 4 =8 is constructible by Chevalley’s Theorem, and then, being classically closed, it is also Zariski closed by GAGA. Hence is a closed map in the Zariski topol 6 ogy for any morphism . It follows that is a proper morphism. 6
48 . ? and assume that Z R ! # ) ) 4 8 exists in 6 under the extra assumptionexists that 6 is a nontrivial one-parameter subgroup in . ) 7 4 8
6 M be the closure of ! in the classical topology.
47 8
prove (b) (c), let To ! 6 in . We first prove 4 8 R P . This means that ) #
6
M ! Let Our earlier remarks imply that this equals the Zariski Since ) 47 M 8 closure. it is closed in the Zariski topology, so that is closed in topologies. It follows that )
6
is proper, in both
47 M 8 74 M 8 ! 47 M 8 Z Hence there is . to . Thus there is a sequence of points . M such that 4 8 mapping . Then 4 8 Z R 4 8 R 4 4 8*8 R # # 4 8 48 Z ! )
)
)
)
)
# This, together with R here, the arguments used to prove (a) ! # ) 4 8 exists in 6 . that
)
)
and (b)
RP
, imply that . From (c) of Theorem 3.4.1 easily imply
4 8 assume R P , consider the map 4 For 8 the 6 general case 6 when we. Thisno longer is proper since is proper (Exercise 3.4.6). 6 and 6 are toric varieties by Proposition 3.1.14, and Furthermore, 4 *,8 ? ? Z . Then applying the corresponding map on lattices is 4
8 ! # ) 4 8 exists in 6 . We . ? the above argument to shows that leave the details to the reader (Exercise 3.4.6).
§3.4. Complete and Proper
143
(d), first observe that the inclusion (
For (c)
Y
@ " 4 Y Z 8
!
is compatible with Y and YXZ . For the opposite inclusion, take " . @ 4 Y Z 8 9 ? . Then 4 8 . YZ , which by Proposition 3.2.2 implies that 6 # ) 4 8 exists in 6 . By assumption, ! # ) 4 8 exists in . Using Y . . Proposition 3.2.2, we conclude that . Because all the 6-9 ? " ( for some 6 8 Y 4 Y Z cones are rational, this immediately implies . ! ( since is automatic
@
Finally, we prove (d)
(a). We begin with two special cases.
6
5
Special Case 1. Suppose that a toric morphism (d) 5 ? Z is onto. The fan of satisfies consists and has the additional property that ? of the trivial cone , so that (d) implies (
R @" 4 8 R Y Y Z Z 4 8 When we think of as a fan in @ 6 6
4 8
Y
(3.4.3)
@
! ?@ , (3.3.5) implies that 5 6 5 5 . The fan YZ Z is complete in Then corresponds to the projection 4 8 by (3.4.3), so that 6 is compact by Theorem 3.4.1. Thus 6 pt @ 6 5 5
is proper, which easily implies that is proper. We conclude that is proper in the classical topology. 5 5 has the Special Case 2. Suppose that a homomorphism of tori
? ? Z is injective. Then (d) is obviously satisfied. is proper is given in Exercise 3.4.7. satisfying (d). We will Now consider a general toric morphism prove that is proper in the classical topology using part (c) of Proposition 3.4.3. is a sequence such that 4 8 converges in . We Thus assume that . need to prove that a subsequence of converges in .
additional property that An elementary proof that
6
6
6
6
6
5 -orbits, we may assume that the sequence Since has only finitely many
4 6 8 . As in Lemma 3.3.21, let 6 Z be the minimal cone of YZ lies in an orbit 4 8 containing 6 . The restriction -3 4 6 8 4 6 Z 8
6
4 8
4 Z8
6 and 6 are given is a toric morphism by Lemma 3.3.21, and the fans of B D B 4 6 8 in ? 4 6 8 @ and B D B 4 6 Z8 in ? Z<4 6 Z08 @ respectively. by Furthermore, one B D B 4 6 8 Y Y Z can check that since and satisfy (d), the same is true for the fans B D B 4 Z8 (Exercise 3.4.8). It follow that we may assume that . 5 and and 4 8 . 6 5 for all .
The limit the sequence
Z R ! # 4 8 lies in an orbit 4 H Z8 for some H Z . Y Z . Thus 4 8 and its limit Z all lie in . Note that 6 . Y 4 6 8 H Z is 4
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
144
" ( 4 8 . Since (d) implies that @" ( 4 H Z 8 R 3 6 4
the fan giving
, i.e., and " ( 4 H Z8 R Y . R X5 Z . If we write as the composition
6 R 4 we can assume that
4 Z8 Z If H R , then H R
6
4
4
Z ? 4 ? 8 ? 5 factors 6 5 5
6
then . Special Cases 1 and 2 imply that these maps are proper, and since the composition of proper maps is proper, we conclude that is proper.
Z R P . When we think of Z . 4 , Lemma 3.2.5 tells us that Z 8 R for all , Z . 4 H Z 8 7 9; Z S 4 H Z 8 I 9 ; Z M converge to Z in 4 , we see that 8 4 , Z 8 R for all , Z . 4 H Z 8 7 9-; Z S 4 H Z 8 I 9 ; Z
It remains to consider the case when H Z 4 H Z 8 7G9-; a semigroup homomorphism
Z4, 4 8 ; Since the ! 4 4 Z8
#
Z
as
Since H 7 91; is finitely generated, it follows that we may pass to a subsequence and assume that (3.4.4)
5
4 8 4, Z8
for all
and all ,
Z . 4 H Z 8 7 9 ; Z S 4 H Z 8 I 9-; Z
in the proof of Theorem 3.4.1 gives maps 5 map 5 introduced The? logarithm Z @ and ? @ linked by a commutative diagram:
*, M Z
Let ; ; be dual to implies that for all , we have (3.4.5)
5 5
,
?@ /
,
5
/
? @Z
? ? Z . Then , Z . 4 H Z8 7 9; Z S 4 H !Z 8 I 9 ; Z
Z 5 Z 5 K M 4 , 8 4 8 L R K , @ 4 4 8*8 L R K , Z 5 4 4 *8 8 L R I
4 8 4, Z8
where the first equality is standard, the second follows from the above commutative diagram, the third follows from (3.4.1), and the final inequality uses (3.4.4).
§3.4. Complete and Proper
@" ( 4 H Z 8
145
Now consider the following equivalences:
.
@4 8 . HZ Z K , @ 4 8 LXW Z K M 4 , 8 LXW
Z . 4H Z8 7 Z 9 ; Z 4 Z8 Z for all , . H 7 9-; Z 4 Z8 where the first and third equivalences are obvious and the second uses H R H 77 4 Z8 Z Z and the rationality of H . But we also know that H R P , which means that H 7 4 8 Z is a cone whose maximal subspace H I is a proper subset. This implies that " ( 4H Z8 Z Z Z Z Z Z . K M 4 , 8 L%W for all , . 4 H 8 7 9; S 4 H 8 I 9 ; @ " ( 4 H Z8 5 R 4 8 . (Exercise 3.4.9). Using (3.4.5), we( conclude that for all . @ " 4 H Z08 R Y . It follows that But, as noted above, (d) means R 5 4 8 . Y
for all ,
. Y
for all . Passing to a subsequence, we may assume that there is 6
5 4 8 . R 6
such that
for all . From here, the proof of (c) (a) in Theorem 3.4.1 implies that there is a 4 3 6 . This proves that is subsequence which converges to a point . ! proper in the classical topology. The proof of the theorem is now complete. An immediate corollary of Theorem 3.4.7 is the following more complete version of Theorem 3.4.1. Corollary 3.4.8. The following are equivalent for a toric variety (a)
6 6
(b) (d)
6
.
is compact in the classical topology.
! #
is complete.
(c) The limit
Y
)
48
is complete (that is,
exists in
Y
R
6
. ?
for all
3 6 6 R ?@
.
).
We noted earlier that a variety is complete if and only if it is compact. In a similar way, a morphism O of varieties is a proper morphism if and only if it is proper in the classical topology. This is proved in [36, Prop. 3.2 of Exp. XII]. Thus the equivalences (a) (b) of Theorem 3.4.7 and Corollary 3.4.8 are specific instances of this general phenomenon. Theorem 3.4.7 and Corollary 3.4.8 show that properness and completeness can be tested using one-parameter subgroups. In the case of completeness, we can formulate Given . ? , the one-parameter subgroup gives a map 5 ) S this G as follows.
6 ! ) 4 8 6 means that # ! , and saying that exists in
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
146 )
extends to a morphism diagram
)
6
S '
)
. In other words, whenever we have a
u
u u
u
pt .
/
/ 6 u:
)
6
the dashed arrow exists. The existence of tells us that is not missing any points, which is where the term “complete” comes from. In a similar way, the properness criterion given in part (c) of Theorem 3.4.7 can be formulated as saying that whenever . ? gives a diagram,
SX '
the dashed arrow
)
u
u u
u
/ 6 u:
/
6
exists.
For general varieties, there are similar completeness and properness ) S 6 and ) criteria 6 for that replace with maps coming from discrete valuation rings, to be discussed in Chapter 4. An example of a discrete valuation E F%0% -0- , whose field of fractions is the ring is the ring of formal power series R A * 4 4 * 8 8 . By replacing with BC D47EF8 and field of formal Laurent series R SM with BC D4 8 in the above diagrams, where E is now an arbitrary discrete valuation ring, one gets the valuative criterion for properness ([41, Ex. II.4.11 and BC D47EF8 and Thm. II.4.7]). This requires the full power of scheme theory since BC D4 8 are not varieties as defined in this book. Using the valuative criterion of properness, one gets purely algebraic proofs of (d) (b) in Theorem 3.4.7 and Corollary 3.4.8 (see [30, Sec. 2.4] or [76, Sec. 1.5]).
Example 3.4.9. An important class of proper morphisms are the toric morphisms 6 6 Y Z Y induced by a refinement of . Condition (d) of Theorem 3.4.7 is obviously fulfilled since ? ? is the identity and every cone of Y is a Y Z union of cones of . In particular, the blowups
(
6
3-
6
studied in Proposition 3.3.15 are always proper. Exercises for §3.4.
3.4.1. Let be a complete fan in and let be a cone in . Show that the fan defined in (3.2.8) is a complete fan in .
6~ h
t '
<" 7 '
3.4.2. In this exercise, you will develop some additional properties of the logarithm map ping defined in the proof of Theorem 3.4.1.
§3.4. Complete and Proper
147
(a) Let be the unit circle in the complex plane, a subgroup of the multiplicative group . Show that there is an isomorphism of groups
6m #h
j#h O O 2 O O ' 2 where the operation in the second factor on the right is addition. (b) Show that the compact real -dimensional torus ' can be viewed as a subgroup of ~ and that 6`~ h induces an isomorphism ~ : `F ' . Hint: Use from part (a). (c) Let be a fan in . Show that the action of the compact real torus F ' C~ on ~ extends to an action on the toric variety and that the quotient space ' `F ' ( t 5' P2 where ( denotes homeomorphism of topological spaces, and the union is over all cones in the fan. Hint: Use the Orbit-Cone Correspondence (Theorem 3.2.6). (d) Let in 4 be the fan from Example 3.1.9, so 4 . Show that under the that action of ' 4 NA ' 4 as in part (c), 4 `F ' 4 ( , the 2-dimensional simplex. 4 We will say more about the topology of toric varieties in Chapter 12. 3.4.3. This exercise will complete the proof of Theorem 3.4.1. Let 1| 2 ' be the set of semigroup homomorphisms h . Assume that 1| 2 ' O N for all and all B . A We want to show that is a sequence such that O '6 A there is a subsequence that converges to a point m| 2 U' . A (a) The semigroup ( is generated by a finite set ,/ 27+6+6+72 8 . Use this fact ! and the compactness of / LO`O O 8 to show that there exists a subsequence A such that the sequences ' converge in for all . A (b) Deduce that the subsequence converges to a 1| 2 ' . A
3.4.4. In this exercise, you will prove some characterizations of properness stated in the text. (a) Prove (a)
(c) from Proposition 3.4.3.
,6 h / 8
(b) Prove Proposition 3.4.4. Hint: Show first that compactness of is equivalent to the statement that the mapping pt is universally closed. Then use the easy fact that any composition of universally closed mappings is universally closed. 3.4.5. Show that any projective variety is complete according to Definition 3.4.5. 3.4.6. Complete the proof of (b)
(c) of Theorem 3.4.7 begun in the text.
] 6S~ h ~ be a map of tori corresponding to an injective homomorphism ] 6! h . Also let ] 6 h be the dual map. Finally, let A ~ be a sequence such that ]P ' converges to a point of ~ . A (a) Prove that { | ] 'I has finite index. Hence we can pick an integer such that f{ | ] ' . (b) Show that $ ' converges for all t{ | ] ' . Conclude that ' converges A is as in part (a). A for all " , where 3.4.7. Let
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
148
~
F '
M( A 26+7+6+92 A 'a%A ' . Show A 26+7+6+72 ^' %F ' .
(c) Pick a basis of so that and write that converges to a point
A 62 +7+6+92 A ' (d) Show that the th roots + can be chosen so that of the sequence a subsequence . A ( A 26+7+6+92 A ' converges to a point (L 27+6+6+62 ^ ' ~ (e) Explain why this implies that ~ h ~ is proper in the classical topology. 3.4.8. Here are some details from the proof of (d) (a) of Theorem 3.4.7. Given a toric ] 6 h and a cone t , let be the smallest cone containing morphism ] 5' . (a) Prove that ] induces a homomorphism ] 6!t 5'Zh t ' . < & '6O 'B( O < & 5'7O . (b) Assume further that ] O O 'B( O :O . Prove that ] ' 3O T /E `8 be a strongly convex polyhedral cone in . Prove that 3.4.9. Let k(L 2n f for all ' y ' and then apply this to a( ] AS' to complete the argument in the text. Hint: To prove , first show that the right hand side of the equivalence implies that 2n N for all B ' ' . Then show that U( T /& W8 implies that any element of ' is a limit of elements in ' y ' .
3.4.10. Give a second argument for the implication
compact
complete
from part (c) of Theorem 3.1.19 using induction on the dimension of . Hint: If is not complete and , then there is a one-dimensional cone in the boundary of the support of . Consider the fan and the corresponding toric subvariety of .
< E ' 3.4.11. Let 2 be fans in ] 6 h
toric morphism
h
compatible with the identity map . Prove that the is proper if and only if is a refinement of .
Appendix: Nonnormal Toric Varieties In this appendix, we discuss toric varieties that are not necessarily normal and relate them to the normal toric varieties studied in this chapter. We begin with an example to show that Sumihiro’s Theorem (Theorem 3.1.7) on the existence of a torus-invariant affine open cover can fail in the nonnormal case.
c 4 ( d 14 d ' g K.( A `23 `27E' g I/3K58 K K K g To see that g is a toric variety, we begin with the standard parametrization obtained by intersecting lines c (V d with the affine curve c 4 ( d 4 d -E' . This easily leads to the parametrization d (* 4 # 12 c (-9A 4 #fE' + g g4
Example 3.A.1. Consider the nodal cubic defined by . The only singularity of is . We claim that is a toric variety with as torus. Assuming this for the moment, consider a torus-invariant neighborhood of . It contains and the torus and hence is the whole curve! We conclude that has no torusinvariant affine open neighborhood. Thus Sumihiro’s Theorem fails for .
Appendix: Nonnormal Toric Varieties
( $
149
K
The values map to the singular point . To get a parametrization that looks more like a torus, we replace with to obtain
d ( ! P# m &' 2 c ( m!9P!#f *E' E' + 4 o Then )(* 2 map to K and Z maps bijectively to g/3K58 . Using this parametrization, we get g , and the action of on itself given by multiplication extends to an action on g by making K a fixed point of the action. With
some work, one can show that this action is algebraic and hence gives a toric variety. (For readers familiar with elliptic curves, the basic idea is that the description of the group law in terms of lines connecting points on the curve reduces to multiplication in for our curve .)
g
g
In contrast, the projective toric varieties constructed in Chapter 2 satisfy Sumihiro’s Theorem by Proposition 2.1.8. Since these nonnormal toric varieties have a good local structure, it is reasonable to expect that they share some of the nice properties of normal toric varieties. In particular, they satisfy a version of the Orbit-Cone Correspondence (Theorem 3.2.6).
( / 26+7+6+62 ! 8 ! ( . `?1 C' #h induced by the inclusion of semigroup algebras H , VJe IH J"+ Recall that IH "J is the integral closure of IH , fJ in its field of fractions. We now apply standard results in commutative algebra and algebraic geometry: Since the integral closure H J is a finitely generated -algebra, it is a finitely generated module over IH , fJ (see [2, Cor. 5.8]). Thus the corresponding morphism h is finite (as defined in [41, p. 84]). A finite morphism is proper with finite fibers (see [41, Ex. II.3.5 and II.4.1]). is the identity on the torus, the image of the normalization is Zariski dense Since h
& , We begin with the affine case. Given and a finite subset we get the affine toric variety whose torus has character group (Proposi and tion 1.1.8). Assume isletthe map be dual to ( . By Proposition 1.3.8, the normalization of
in . But the image is also closed since the normalization map is proper. This proves that the normalization map is onto. Here is an example of how the normalization map can fail to be one-to-one.
( / 2 4 2 ( 4 8N 4 . This gives the parametrization F12 n'B(L m2 7 2n 4 ' , and one can check that ( % c 4 # d 4 'Z- o + 4 and ( `?1 C' ( `?1 2 4 ' . It follows easily that the Furthermore, ( normalization is given by 4 #h 12nn')j#hl 1237 2n 4 ' + #
Example 3.A.2. Let
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
150
A 2nn'hj F `2 2n346'
This map is one-to-one on the torus (the torus of is normal and hence is unchanged under normalization) but not on the -axis, since here the map is . We will soon see the intrinsic reason why this happens.
We now determine the orbit structure of Theorem 3.A.3. above. Then:
Let
.
be an affine toric variety with
(
(a) There is a bijective correspondence
$
such that a face of
"
/ faces of 8h /7~ B
-orbits in
and let
8
of dimension corresponds to an orbit of dimension
is the orbit corresponding to a face (b) If character group .
zW{}|
be as
# B.
$ % C" ' (c) The normalization h induces a bijection /7~ -orbits in D 8h /E~ -orbits in 8 such that if i and are the orbits corresponding to a face of , is the map of tori corresponding to the inclusion then the induced map h I *' of character groups. of , then
is the torus with
Proof. We will sketch the main ideas and leave the details for the reader. The proof uses the Orbit-Cone Correspondence (Theorem 3.2.6). We regard points of and as semigroup homomorphisms, so that in maps to in . Note also that is equivariant with respect to the action of . By Lemma 3.2.5, the orbit corresponding to a face of is the torus consisting of homomorphisms . Thus " "is the character group of . The normalization maps this orbit onto an orbit , where a point of maps to its restriction to . Since
h
' '
,
'
6
h
-6!
h
%
" '
O ~ 6, h
L' ( (I C' 2 it follows that I *' is the character group of " ' . This proves part (b), and the final assertion of part (c) follows easily. Since is the saturation of , , it follows that there is an integer such that , . It follows easily that % C' has finite index in , so that zW{}| 'Z(*zW{} | 'Z(CzW{}| #%zW{}| (*zW{ | #%zW{}| 2 proving the final assertion of part (a). comes from an orbit in since h is onto. If orbits Finally, every orbit in , then '92 4 ' map to the same orbit of I C')( I 4 C'9+ This easily implies % ( , so that ( . The bijections in parts (a) and (c) now 4 4 follow easily.
We leave it to the reader to work out other aspects of the Orbit-Cone Correspondence (specifically, the analogs of parts (c) and (d) of Theorem 3.2.6) for . Let us apply Theorem 3.A.3 to our previous example.
Appendix: Nonnormal Toric Varieties
151
( / 2 4 2 ( 4 8 4 as in Example A.3.A.2. The cone ( `?m C' ( `?1 2 4 ' has a face such that %t(<>=! e 4 ' . Thus $ *'B( $ ( 4 ' ( 4+ It follows that I % C' has index ( in % , which explains why the normalization map is two-to-one on the orbit corresponding to . We now turn to the projective gives the projec case. Here, l(L/ 27+6+7+92 ! 8I! tive toric variety 9 ! whose torus9 has character group (Proposition 2.1.6). Recall that ( I2 +! + (V . +! + + O + One observation is that translating by leaves the corresponding projective ( (see part (a) of Exercise 2.1.6). Thus, variety unchanged. In other words, by translating an element of to the origin, we may assume . Note that the torus has character lattice ( when . of
Example 3.A.4. Let
We defined the normalization of an affine variety in §1.0. Using a gluing construction, one can define the normalization of any variety (see [41, Ex. II.3.8]). We can describe the as follows. normalization of a projective toric variety
%
(
( ! C' , then the normalization of is the toric variety normal fan of with respect to the lattice ( 1| +2 y' . Theorem 3.A.5. Let
be a projective toric variety where
and
. If
of the
Proof. Again, we sketch the proof and leave the details to the reader. We use the local given in Propositions 2.1.8 and 2.1.9. There, we saw that has an description of affine open covering given by the affine toric varieties , where - is a vertex of and - - .
(M<>=D?E@1 , ' L( ! C' ( # ( / # O N8 For the moment, assume that is very ample. Then Theorem 2.3.1 implies that has an affine open cover given by the affine toric varieties ( <>=D?E@m "L' , where - ( ! ?1 #!-W'
is a vertex of and . One can check that . The gluings are also is the saturation of , so that is the normalization of compatible by equations (2.1.6), (2.1.7) and Proposition 2.3.12. It follows that we get a that is the normalization of . natural map
,
h
B
B
In the general case, we note that is very ample for some integer and that and have the same normal fan. Since is a maximal cone of the normal fan, the
B
above argument now applies in general, and the theorem is proved.
Combining this result with the Orbit-Cone Correspondence and Theorem 3.A.3 gives the following immediate corollary. Corollary 3.A.6. With the same hypotheses as Theorem 3.A.5, we have: (a) There is a bijective correspondence
/ cones
of
such that a cone of dimension
^
B
8
h /7~
-orbits in
8
corresponds to an orbit of dimension
(b) If is the orbit corresponding to a cone character group .
$ % C'
of
zW{}| # B .
, then is the torus with
Chapter 3. Normal Toric Varieties
152
(c) The normalization
/7~
h
-orbits in
induces a bijection
8 h /7~
-orbits in
8
such that if are the orbits corresponding to a cone of and , then the induced map is the map of tori corresponding to the inclusion of character groups.
I *'
for
h
We leave it to the reader to work out other aspects of the Orbit-Cone Correspondence . A different approach to the study of appears in [31, Ch. 5].
Chapter 4
Divisors on Toric Varieties
§4.0. Background: Valuations, Divisors and Sheaves Divisors are defined in terms of irreducible codimension one subvarieties. In this chapter, we will consider Weil divisors and Cartier divisors. These classes coincide on a smooth variety, but for a normal variety, the situation is more complicated. We will also study divisor classes, which are defined using the order of vanishing of a rational function on an irreducible divisor. We will see that normal varieties are the natural setting to develop a theory of divisors and divisor classes. First, we give a simple motivational example.
4 '8
A4 '8
Example + 4.0.1. then there is a unique / . such that O 2. 4 'V8 4 'Vis8 nonzero, 4O '8 R ' , Ifwhere A % ' ' . , are not divisible by . This is possible F % ' 4 'V8 at : if / , because The integer / describes the behavior of O 4O '8 vanishesistoa UFD. 4 V ' 8 , O has order / at , and if / a pole of order / at . F4 'V8 M to the additive group Furthermore, the map from the multiplicative group 4 V ' 8 / is easily seen to be a group homomorphism. via O This construction works in the same way if we replace with any point of .
Discrete Valuation Rings. The simple construction given in Example 4.0.1 works in far greater generality. We begin by reviewing the algebric machinery we will need. Definition 4.0.2. A discrete valuation on a field
is a group homomorphism
$ M R+ 4 ' 8 W )4 $ 4 'V8 $ 4 8*8 that is surjective and satisfies $
whenever
M R S . The corresponding discrete valuation ring is the ring E R ' . M $ 4 '8 W .
' *'
.
153
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
154
One can check that a DVR is indeed a ring. Here are some properties of DVRs. Proposition 4.0.3. Let
E
be a DVR with valuation
$ M
' E is invertible in E if and only if $ 4 'V8 R . (a) . E ' E (b) is a local ring with maximal ideal R . E (c) is normal. E (d) is a principal ideal domain (PID). E (e) is Noetherian. E (f) The only proper prime ideals of are and
$
$ 4 'V8
. Then:
.
.
is a homomorphism, we have ( 8 R 4 'V8 4 ' " $ R $ (4.0.1) ' ' E is a unit, then $ 4 'V8 $ 4 ' " ( 8 W ( since ' *' " ( . E . Thus for all . M . If . 4 'V8 R , then $ 4 ' " 8 R by (4.0.1), so that $ 4 '8 R (4.0.1). Conversely, if $ ' " ( . E . by This proves part (a). ' E $ 4 'V8 is an ideal of E (this For part (b), note that R . Proof. First observe that since
follows directly from Definition 4.0.2). Then part (a) easily implies that with maximal ideal (Exercise 4.0.1).
'+
To prove part (c), suppose
E
'
E
' +
. M R S + ( " (*' "
E
is local
satisfies
R
' + . E . Then / and $ 4 '8 . " . E (' " + 4 ' + + (J' + " ( 8 and hence R "( ( + ' RF4 + " ( + " ' " ' " 8 . E . showing that R E satisfy $ 4 8 R and let 6 R P be an ideal of E . Pick ' . 6 S Let . 4 V ' 8 minimal. Then R ' " . satisfies $ 4 8 R $ 4 '8 R $ 4 8 R , with R $ E 6 so that is invertible in . From here, one proves without difficulty that R K L . with ' . . If . , we are done,( so suppose ( ' " . E . So ' Using (4.0.1) again, we see that
This proves part (d), and part (e) follows immediately.
For part (f), it is obvious that R K NL RP also that . Now let L R paragraph, K for some give a contradiction.
and the maximal ideal are prime. Note
be a proper prime ( ideal. By the previous ( . If , then " . and " .
This shows that every DVR is a Noetherian local domain of dimension one. In
! E E general, the dimension of a Noetherian ring is one less than the length of ? E the longest chain of proper prime ideals contained in . Among Noetherian local domains of dimension one, DVRs are characterized as follows.
§4.0. Background: Valuations, Divisors and Sheaves
155
47E= =8
Theorem 4.0.4. If is a Noetherian local domain of dimension one, then the following are equivalent.
E
(a) (b) (c) (d)
is a DVR.
E
is normal. is principal.
47E= =8
is a regular local ring.
Proof. (a) (b) and (a) (c) follow from Proposition 4.0.3, and equivalence (c) (d) is covered in Exercise 4.0.2. The remaining implications can be found in [2, Prop. 9.2].
DVRs and Prime Divisors. DVRs have a natural geometric interpretation. Let ! be an irreducible variety. A prime divisor irreducible subvariety of
!
! R is an. Recall R codimension one, meaning that from §3.0 that A4 8 has a field of rational functions with field . Our goal is to define a ring F 4 8 of fractions is a DVR when This will give a &4 such 8 M that such that A4 8 M is, normal. 4 O 8 gives valuation for O . the order of vanishing of O along .
$
"
"
$
Definition 4.0.5. For a variety X and prime divisor A4 8 defined by of
" R
! , "
is the subring
. F4 8 is defined on ! open with 9 R P . " We will see below that is a ring. Intuitively, this ring is built from rational functions on that are defined somewhere on (and hence defined on most of since is irreducible). 4
4
&4 8 R F4 4S8
4
!
is irreducible, Exercise 3.0.4 implies that Since is open and nonempty. If we further assume that
(4.0.2) follows easily (Exercise 4.0.3).
E
DI
#" R
4
9
whenever is nonempty, then
BC D47EF8
R Hence we can reduce to the affine case for an integral domain . The codimension of a prime ideal Y , also called its height, is defined to be
! R ! E R 354 8 Y Y . It follows easily that Y 354 Y 8 induces a bijection
codimension one prime ideals of E& prime divisors of . 354 Y 8 , we can interpret " in terms of E as follows. Given a prime divisor R A4 8 is the field of fractions of E , and a rational The field of rational functions . E , is defined somewhere on R 354 Y 8 precisely function R O . , O :.4 8 R Y . It follows that when . " R
O . O . E= . Y .
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
156
EW
E
E
E
which is the localization of at the multiplicative subset STY (note that STY is closed under multiplication because Y is prime). This localization is a local ring EW (Exercise 4.0.3). It follows that with maximal ideal Y
" R E W
(4.0.3) when
R B9C D47EF8
and Y is a codimension one prime ideal of
E
.
Example 4.0.6. In Example 4.0.1, we constructed a discrete valuation on 4 '8 . A4 '8 M to / . , provided sending O
A4 '8
by
4O 'V8 R ' + V44 'V'8 8 2 4 '8 4 '8 . A% ' -< 24 8 4 8 R P A% ' - . It follows that the prime divisor The corresponding DVR is the localization
R 354 'V8 ! R BC D.47F% ' - 8 has the local ring R A% ' - which is a DVR.
More generally, a normal ring or variety gives a DVR as follows. Proposition 4.0.7.
E
(a) Let be a normal domain and Y E W is a DVR. the localization
"
(b) Let
be a normal variety and is a DVR.
! E
be a codimension one prime ideal. Then
!
a prime divisor. Then the local ring
Proof. By Proposition 3.0.13, part (b) follows immediately from part (a) together with (4.0.2) and (4.0.3).
E W
W
E W
R Y It remains to prove part (a). The maximal ideal of is the ideal E W generated by Y in . The localization of a Noetherian ring is Noetherian (Exercise 4.0.4), and the same is true for normality by Exercise 1.0.7. It follows that the 47E W W8 is Noetherian and normal. local domain ESW
!
! E
R We compute the dimension of as follows. Since (see [17, 5 3 4 8 R Ex. 17 and 18 of Ch. 9, §4]), our hypothesis on Y implies that there are no E prime ideals strictly between and Y in . By [2, Prop. 3.11], the same is true FW E W EW has dimension one. Then EW is a DVR by for and in . It follows that Theorem 4.0.4.
When is a prime divisor on a normal variety we have a discrete valuation
A4 8
$ &4 8 M R+
, the DVR
$ 4 8
"
means that
M , we call O the order of vanishing of O along the divisor Given O . . Thus the local ring consists of those rational functions whose order of consists of those rational W vanishing along is , and its maximal ideal
"
"
§4.0. Background: Valuations, Divisors and Sheaves
functions that vanish on order / along .
. When
157
$ 4 O 8 R / , we say that O
has a pole of
Weil Divisors. Recall that a prime divisor on an irreducible variety ducible subvariety of codimension one.
) )4 8
is an irre-
)
is the free abelian group generated by the prime divisors Definition 4.0.8. 4 8 . on . A Weil divisor is an element of
) 4 8
*
) V4 8
. Thus a Weil divisor is a finite sum R & ' ' ' . of * W , ' ' . with for all . The divisor is effective, written prime divisors * if the ' are all nonnegative. The support of is the union of the prime divisors appearing in :
B C C 4 8 R
'
(
The Divisor of a Rational Function. An important class of Weil divisors comes from rational functions. If is normal, any prime divisor on corresponds to A 4 8 A 4 8 M , the integers M a DVR with valuation . Given O . 4 O 8 tell us how O behaves on the prime divisors of . Here is an important property of these integers.
"
$
$
Lemma 4.0.9. If is normal and ! finite number of prime divisors
O . F4 8 M , then $ 4 O 8 .
is zero for all but a
A4 8
M . It follows Proof. If O is constant, then it is a nonzero constant since O . 4 8 O R for all 4. On the that other hand, if O is nonconstant, then we can find such 4 is a nonconstant morphism. that O a nonempty open subset ! ( ; 7 4 8 ; M " M Then R O . The S ; is a nonempty open subset of such that O complement is Zariski closed and hence is a union of irreducible components of dimension ( " . / . Denote the irreducible components of codimension one by
$
;
;
Now let be prime divisor in . If 9 R ; , then ! S , so that is contained in an irreducible component of S since is irreducible. ' . On the other hand, Dimension considerations then imply that R for some ; R R , which implies if 9 , then O is an invertible element of P 4O 8 R . that
$
Definition 4.0.10. Let (a)
"
be a normal variety.
F4 8 M is The divisor of O .
4 8 R O
$ 4 O +8 ! . where the sum is over all prime divisors
.
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
158
(b)
4 8 O is) called a principal 4 8 denoted .
'
divisor, and the set of all principal divisors is
% ' if their difference ) 4 8 for, some O . F4 8 M .
'
(c) Divisors and are linearly equivalent, written R R 4 O 8 . is a principal divisor, i.e.,
) )4 8 . If O . F4 8 M , then 4 O 98 R 8 valuations are group homomor) O 8 issince ) 4 8 . a subgroup of P 4 ' R * 8 P ( 4 ' R 8 * R . &% ' - be a polynomial of Example 4.0.11. Let O ( * * . are distinct. Then: , where . M and degree , R V 4 8 R & ')( ( ,-' * ' O
. When , ( 4 8 ( * #R
V4 8
. implies that (
V4 Lemma
V4 " 8 R O R 4 8O 4.0.9 V4 8 O F4 8 M and .4 . It follows that phisms on
R
, ' ' , . O R & '( A4 8 M can be written 4 O 8 R 4 O 8R 4 O 8 , where The divisor of O .
4 8 R $ 4 O +8 O N
4 8 R R $ 4 O 8+ O N
4 8 We call O the divisor of zeros of O and 4 O 8 the divisor of poles of O . When
R
,
Note that these are effective divisors.
R & Cartier Divisors. If nonempty open subset, then
is a Weil divisor on
4
'*' '
R
is a Weil divisor on
. ( * '
called the restriction of
and
4
!
is a
' 9
4
to
4
We now define a special class of Weil divisors.
.
Definition 4.0.12. A Weil divisor on a normal variety is Cartier if it is locally has an open cover 4 ' ' such that is principal principal, meaning that R 4 ' 8 4 6 6 4 4 ' O ' 8 ' in ' for every . . If for . , then we call
O the local data for .
V4 8
A principal divisor is obviously locally principal. Thus O is Cartier for all A 4 8 M . O R . One can also show that if and are Cartier divisors, then and are Cartier (Exercise 4.0.5). It follows that the Cartier divisors on form = 4 8 a group satisfying
)
'
) 4 8 ! = ) 4 8 ! ) )4 8
'
§4.0. Background: Valuations, Divisors and Sheaves
159
Divisor Classes. For Weil and Cartier divisors, linear equivalence classes form the following important groups
Definition 4.0.13. Let
be a normal variety. Its class group is
= 4 8 R ) )4 8 ) 4 8
and its Picard group is
GH!D.4 8 R = ) )4 8 ) .4 8 G !D.4 8 in Chapter 6. Note that We will give a more sophisticated definition of = ) 4 8 ) )4 8 since is a subgroup of , we get a canonical injection GH!D.4 8 = 4 8 In [41, II.6], Hartshorne writes “The divisor class group of a scheme is a very interesting invariant. In general it is not easy to calculate.” Fortunately, divisor class groups of normal toric varieties are easy to describe, as we will see in §4.1. More Algebra. Before we can derive further properties of divisors, we need to B9C D.47EF8 is learn more about normal domains. Equation (3.0.2) shows that if R irreducible, then
" E R "
E
If a point . corresponds to a maximal ideal ! , then the local ring E is the localization . Hence the above equality can be written
E R
E When
"
E
maximal
is normal, we get a similar result using codimension one prime ideals.
Theorem 4.0.14. If
E
is a Noetherian normal domain, then
E R
E W S W ( ( E E , * * Proof. Let be the field of fractions of and assume that . , . W E * lies in for all codimension one prime ideals Y . It suffices to prove that . K L . E This is obviously true when is invertible in , so we may assume that K L is a E proper ideal of . Then we have a primary decomposition (see [17, Ch. 4, §7]) ( (4.0.4) K L R 9 9 " E . In the and each prime ideal Y ' R ' is of the form Y ' R K L ' for some ' . terminology of [66, p. 38], the Y ' are the prime divisors of K L . E Since is Noetherian and normal, the Krull Principal Ideal Theorem states
that every prime divisor of K L has codimension one (see [66, Thm. 11.5] for a proof). This implies that in the primary decomposition (4.0.4), the prime divisors Y ' have codimension one and hence are distinct.
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
160
E W
*
4 8 W
EW
*
R It follows that . for all , which implies . . Since R ' for P (Exercise 4.0.6), localizing (4.0.4) at Y shows that for all , we have
Since
' E W 9 E R '
* . E W
R 'E W
(Exercise 4.0.6), we obtain
* .
'" ( ( ' R K L .
This result has the following useful corollary.
Corollary 4.0.15. Let be a normal variety and let O 4 . If S 4 has codimension defined on an open set ! to a morphism defined on all of .
E W
4
W
in
be a morphism , then O extends
B9C D47EF8
R an affine open cover, we assume that , where Proof. Since E is a Noetherianhasnormal domain. If ! is an irreducible hypersurface, then 4 R R . 9 P for dimension reasons. It follows that O , so that
O .
(4.0.5)
" R
R
SW ( (
"
E W R E=
where the final equality is Theorem 4.0.14. These results enable us to determine when the divisor of a rational function is effective.
O . F4 8 M , then:
4 8 W (a) O if and only if O is a morphism, i.e., O . " 4 8 .
4 8 R O if and only if O M is a morphism, i.e., O . " M 4 8 . (b)
Proposition 4.0.16. Let
In general,
"M
be a normal variety. If
is the sheaf on
" M 4 4S8 R
defined by
invertible elements of
" 4 S8. 4
This is a sheaf of abelian groups under multiplication.
"
Proof. If O is a morphism, then O .
V4 8 W for every prime divisor 4 8 W O . Hence O . Going the other way, , which in turn implies
V4 8 W suppose that we restrict to an affine open O . This remains true when
4 8 W subset, so we may assume that is affine. Then O implies
$
O .
"
where the intersection is over all prime divisors. By (4.0.5), we conclude that O is defined everywhere. This proves part (a), and part follows immediately since
V4 8 R
4 8 W
4 " ( 8 (b) W O if and only if O and O .
§4.0. Background: Valuations, Divisors and Sheaves
161
Singularities and Normality. The set of singular points of a variety
B 0 4 8 !
B 0 4 8
is denoted
B 4 8
We call the singular locus of . One can show that is a proper closed subvariety of (see [41, Thm. I.5.3]). When is normal, things are even nicer. Proposition 4.0.17. Let
B 4 8
(a)
(b) If
be a normal variety. Then:
has codimension
is a curve, then
W
in
.
is smooth.
Proof. You will prove part (b) in Exercise 4.0.7. A proof of part (a) can be found in [89, Vol. 2, Thm. 3 of §II.5]. Computing Divisor Classes. There are two results, one algebraic and one geometric, that enable us to compute class groups in some cases. We begin with the algebraic result. Theorem 4.0.18. Let (a) (b)
E
E
be a UFD and set
R BC D47EF8 . Then:
is normal and every codimension one prime ideal is principal.
= 4 8 R
.
Proof. For part (a), we know that a UFD is normal by Exercise 1.0.5. Let Y be a E E * codimension one prime ideal of and pick . Y1S . Since is a UFD,
* R with the ' prime and ' . Y , and since D I !
+
' )' ( (
E in . Because Y Y isR invertible
, this forces Y R K ' L .
is prime, this means some
:.4 8
! Turning to part (b), let be a prime divisor. Then Y R is a L R codimension one prime ideal and hence is principal, say Y O generates ESW , which implies 4 O 8 R K O . Then the maximal ideal of the DVR (see the proof of = 4 8 R
4 8 R Proposition 4.0.3). It follows easily that . Then O since all prime divisors are linearly equivalent to .
$
In fact, more is true: a normal Noetherian domain is a UFD if and only if every codimension one prime ideal is principal (Exercise 4.0.8). Example 4.0.19.
A% ' ( *' +.-
= 47 + 8 R is a UFD, so
by Theorem 4.0.18.
! Before stating the geometric result, we observe that if is a nonempty open subset, then the restriction map induces a well-defined map = 4 8 = 4 4 8 (Exercise 4.0.9).
4
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
162
4
Theorem 4.0.20. Let be a nonempty open subset of a normal variety and let ( " be the irreducible components of S 4 that are prime divisors. Then the sequence
"
( (
R = 4 8XR = 4 4 8XR+ " (0* = 4 8 is exact, where the first map sends & ( to its divisor class in 4
the second is induced by restriction to
Z
.
* ' 'Z . ) 4 4S8 with 'Z a prime divisor in 4 . Then the 'Z in is a prime divisor in , and R & ' * ' 'Z satisfies 8 = 4 4S8 is surjective.
R & ' Proof. Let Z Zariski closure ' of R Z . Hence = 4
and
) )4 8
Since each restricts to in , the composition of the two maps is % - . = 4 8 restricts to in trivial. To finish the proof of exactness, suppose that = 44 8 A4 4S8 M . Since F4 4 8 R . This means that is the divisor of some O . F4 8 and the divisor of O in )4 8 restricts to the divisor of O in 4 4 8 , it A4 8 M such that follows that we have O .
4
)
)
R V4 O 8 H R 4 O 8 is supported on S 4 , which means This implies that the difference
V4 8 . " ( ( R . that by the definition of the O ( R
and note that is a prime divisor on Example 4.0.21. Write (
(
( # R = 4 8XR+ = 478 R = 4 8 defined by * % * - is surjective. This map is Hence the map R V4 O 8 implies 4 O 8 R , so that O . 47S )8 M R * injective since
M by( Proposition 4.0.16. Hence O is constant, which forces * R . If follows that = 4 8 . . Then Theorem 4.0.20 and Example 4.0.21 give the exact sequence
Later in the chapter we will use similar methods to compute the class group of an arbitrary normal toric variety. Comparing Weil and Cartier Divisors. Once we understand Cartier divisors on normal toric varieties, it will be easy to give examples of Weil divisors that are not Cartier. On the other hand, there are varieties where every Weil divisor is Cartier. Theorem 4.0.22. Let (a) If the local ring is Cartier. (b) If
variety. Then: " beis aa normal UFD for every . , then every Weil divisor on
is smooth, then every Weil divisor on
is Cartier.
§4.0. Background: Valuations, Divisors and Sheaves
"
163
Proof. If is smooth, then is a regular local ring for all . . Since every regular local ring is a UFD (see §1.0), part (b) follows from part (a). For part (a), it suffices to show that prime divisors are locally principal. This B9C D47EF8 is affine. condition is obviously local on , so we may assume that R 5 3 4 8 E one prime Let R Y be a prime divisor on , where Y ! is a codimension 4 R R S since . It remains ideal. Note that is obviously principal on to show that is locally principal in a neighborhood of a point . .
E
. implies Y ! The point E corresponds to the maximal ideal ! . Thus E ! E . Since Y ! has codimension one, it follows that the prime ideal Y also has codimension one (this follows from [2, Prop. 3.11]). Then Theorem 4.0.18 E is principal since E is a UFD by hypothesis. Thus Y E R implies that Y 4 * 8 E where * . E and . . Since is invertible in E , we in fact have YE R *E . * ( *
* . YE
E
Example 4.0.23. ( 8 = Since (8 H G ! D 4 4 R that
"
(
R *E
* , so that ' R R P . If we set R ( " , 8 is a neighborhood of , and * 8 on 4 .
" L ! . Then ' suppose Y R K 4 ' Now ' 8 * , where ' '#. E and ' . , i.e., ' 4 8 E R * E follows easily. Then 4 R BC D.47E then Y
V4 from here, it is straightforward to see that R
is smooth, Theorem 4.0.22 and Example 4.0.21 imply .
Sheaves of -modules. Weil and Cartier divisors on lead to some important sheaves on . Hence we need a brief excursion into sheaf theory (we will go was defined in §3.0. The deeper into the subject in Chapter 6). The sheaf 4 ! , definition of a sheaf of -modules is similar: for each open subset 44 8 4 4S8 -module with the following properties: there is an When
"
"
"
!
4
, there is a restriction map
4 8 4
4 8 R
"
such that when is the identity and 4 4S8 Furthermore, is compatible with the restriction map If
4
is an open cover of
R
4 4S8%R+
!
4
, then the sequence
4 4 8 RR
44 9
4
98
is exact, where the second arrow is defined by the restrictions and . double arrow is defined by When
4
4 4S8
#"
satisfies just the first bullet, we say that
4 4S8
!
; ! 4 . " 4 8.
and the
is a presheaf.
Given a sheaf of -modules , elements of are called sections of 4 4 over . In practice, the module of sections of over ! is expressed in several ways:
4 4S8 R
44 8 R O 44 8
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
164
O
We will in later chapters. Traditionally, 4 8 use in this section and switch to is called the module of global sections of .
be a morphism of varieties and let be a sheaf Example 4.0.24. Let O of -modules on . The direct image sheaf O M on is defined by
"
R+ 4 O " ( 4 4S8*8
4
for ! image 4
If
M
open. Then O
M
-modules. For
is a sheaf of was mentioned in §3.0.
'
, the direct
"
#"
are sheaves of -modules, then a homomorphism of sheaves 4 4S8 consists of -module homomorphisms
' and
4 8%R+ ' 4 S8 4
such that the diagram
44 8
4<;=8
4 4S8 '
/
;
4
/
'
4<;A8
commutes whenever ! . It should be what it means for sheaves clear ' . -modules to be isomorphic, written
"
4
Example 4.0.25. Let O be a morphism of varieties. If then composition with O induces a natural map
!
4
'
of
is open,
4 4 8XR " 4 O " ( 4 4S8*8 R O " 4 4S8 M " This defines a sheaf homomorphism OM . R BC D47EF8 Over an affine variety , there is a standard way to get sheaves of " E E N such -modules. Recall that a nonzero element O . N R BC D.47ESN.8 S 354 O 8 gives the E localization; that is the open subset . Given an -module , we get " E N N =E S N R -module ; . Then there is a unique sheaf ; of -modules the ;
such that
O . E
for every nonzero
; 4 N 8 R ; N . This is proved in [41, Prop. II.5.1].
We globalize this construction as follows.
"
of on a variety is quasicoherent if Definition 4.0.26. A sheaf 4 , 4 -modules R BC D47E 8 , such that for each " , there is has an affine open cover
E -module ; satisfying ; . Furthermore, if each ; is a finitely an E -module, then we say that is coherent. generated
§4.0. Background: Valuations, Divisors and Sheaves
"
165
#"
The Sheaf of a Weil Divisor. Let be a Weil divisor on a normal variety . We 4 8 will show that determines a sheaf of -modules on . Recall that if 44 8 4 4 ! is open, then consists of all morphisms . Proposition 4.0.16 F4 8 M is a morphism on 4 tells us that an arbitrary element O . if and only if
V4 8 W . It follows that the sheaf is defined by O
"
"
4
R+
" 4 4S8 R 4 8 M 4 O 8
O . F " 48
In a similar way, we define the sheaf
W .
by
" 4 8 4 S8 R O . F4 8 M 4 4 O 8 8 W . Proposition 4.0.27. Let be a Weil divisor on a normal variety . Then the sheaf " 4 8 " defined in (4.0.6) is a coherent sheaf of -modules on . " 4 8 is a sheaf of #" -modules. Proof. In Exercise 4.0.10 you will show that
R
4
(4.0.6)
4
" 48
The proof is a nice application of the properties of valuations.
BC D.47EF8
R To show that is coherent, we may assume that . Let E be the field of fractions of . It suffices to prove the following two assertions:
4 " 4 8*8 R O . V4 O 8 W is a finitely E generated -module. 4 N " 4 8*8 R ; N for all nonzero O . E . E S such that first bullet, we will prove the existence of . the " 4For 4 * 8 8 E 4 " 4 8*8 E ! . This willE imply that is an ideal of and hence has a finite basis since is Noetherian. It will follow immediately that 4 " 4 8*8 E is a finitely generated -module. R & ')" ( +( * ' ' . Since C C 4 8 is a proper subvariety of , we can Write . E J 4 98 for every , so find on each ' . Then $ S that vanishes J 4 98 * ' for all . Since 4 98 W , it follows that there is , . with , $
V 4 98 R W . Now let O . 4 #" 4 8*8 . Then V4 O 8 W , so that ,
V 4 P 8 R , V 4 98 4 8 R , V 4 98 R 4 8 W O O O ;
R
since P a sum of effective divisors is effective. By Proposition 4.0.16, we conclude P that O . 4 8 R E . Hence R . E has the desired property.
"
To prove the second bullet, observe that ;
!
and O
. E S
imply that
4 #" 4 *8 8 , W O N 4 N " 4 8*8 For the opposite inclusion, let It is also " easy to see that ; R & '( ( * ' ' and write ! . R 6 .where ' 9 N R P for . 6 ! 354 O 8 for . . Given . 4 N9 " 4 8*8 , 4 4 8 8 " W and J4 8 W R * ' for . 6 . There is no constraint on $ 4 8 for . , implies that $ ; N R
P
.
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
166
but O vanishes on for sufficiently large such that
.
, so that
$ 4O 8
$ 4O 8 $ 4 8
. Hence we can pick
, .
P for .
V4 8 W
4 8 W on . Thus R Since O , it follows easily that P O P O . 4 " 48*8 , and then R O has the desired form. " 4 8 The sheaves are more than just coherent; they have the additional prop " 4 8 is invertible. The erty of being reflexive. Furthermore, when is Cartier, ,
"
definitions of invertible and reflexive will be given in Chapters 6 and 8 respectively. 4 8 For now, we record one property which will be crucial in proving that R BC D47EF8 E corre-is reflexive. Let , so that codimension one prime ideals Y ! W ! . Then a Weil divisor on is a sum spond to prime divisors
R
(4.0.7) where all but finitely many W will be written .
$
*W
SW ( (
* W&W
are zero. The discrete valuation coming from
W
SW ( * W W be an effective Weil divisor on 4 " 4FR 8*8 is the ideal of E given
R & ( Proposition 4.0.28. Let R BC D.47EF8 , where E is normal. Then by the intersection
4 " 4FR 8*8 R
E W Y S W ( (
V4 81R W 4 " 4FR 8*8 Proof. First note that O . implies O , so that
V4 8 W W E . O by Proposition 4.0.16, which " 4FR 8*8 is effective. Thus 4 #since E O
shows that follows from
O .
is an ideal of
4 " 4FR 8*8
. The final assertion of the proposition
V4 8 W O $ W 4O 8 W * W O . Y E W
D I ! Y R D I ! Y R for all R , Proposition 4.0.28 reduces to E R SW ( ( E W , which we When
for all
proved in Theorem 4.0.14. We thus have a nice circle of ideas: Proposition 4.0.16 M
r 5= rrrrr r r rrr rrrr Theorem 4.0.14 ks
MMM MMMM MMM M "*
Proposition 4.0.28
Linear equivalence of divisors tells us the following interesting fact about the associated sheaves.
§4.0. Background: Valuations, Divisors and Sheaves
% '
" '
167
"
Proposition 4.0.29. If are linearly equivalent Weil divisors, then 4 &8 and are isomorphic as sheaves of -modules. Proof. By assumption, we have
R '
V4 98
4 " 4 8*8
for some
. F4 8 M
" 4 8
. Then
W O .
4 8 ' 4 98 W O
4 98 ' W O . 4 " 4& ' 8*8 O 4 " 4 8*8 4 " 4'=8*8 Thus multiplication by induces an isomorphism 4 " 8 which is clearly an isomorphism of -modules.
4 8 O
4
The same argument works over any Zariski open set , and the isomorphisms are easily seen to be compatible with the restriction maps.
"
" ' "
% '
"
The converse of Proposition 4.0.29 is also true, i.e., an -module isomor 4 8 4 &8 phism implies that . The proof requires knowing more 4 8 about the sheaves and hence will be postponed until Chapter 8. Exercises for §4.0.
_
4.0.1. Complete the proof of part (b) of Proposition 4.0.3.
_ _ 4
4.0.2. Prove (c) (d) in Theorem 4.0.4. Hint: Let be the maximal ideal of . Since has dimension one, it is regular if and only if has dimension one as a vector space over . For (d) (c), use Nakayama’s Lemma (see [2, Props. 2.6 and 2.8]).
I _
4.0.3. This exercise will study the rings (a) Prove (4.0.2).
X^[
and .
(b) Let be a prime ideal of a ring and let denote the localization of with respect to the multiplicative subset . Prove that is a local ring and that its maximal ideal is the ideal generated by .
If
:
4.0.4. Let be a multiplicative subset of a Noetherian ring is Noetherian.
. Prove that the localization
4.0.5. Let and be Weil divisors on a normal variety. (a) If and are Cartier, show that and are also Cartier. (b) If
, show that
#
is Cartier if and only if
is Cartier.
4.0.6. Complete the proof of Theorem 4.0.14. 4.0.7. Prove that a normal curve is smooth. 4.0.8. Let be a Noetherian normal domain. Prove that the following are equivalent: (a) is a UFD. (b)
<>=?7@
A'n')(C .
(c) Every codimension one prime ideal of
is principal.
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
168
, > y(,S 26+7+6+72 !
i( `z { ,Q' ( ,
corresponds to . Use Theorem 4.0.14 to Hint: For (b) (c), assume that is primary in . Then show and use the Krull Principal Ideal Theorem to show and [2, Prop. 4.8] imply . For (c) (a), let be noninvertible and , + let be the codimension one irreducible components of . If + compare the divisors of and + + using Proposition 4.0.16.
!
, % W' 'B(
4<
ljh O induces a well-defined homomorphism "')h ' 4.0.10. Let be a Weil divisor on a normal variety . Prove that (4.0.6) defines a sheaf X ' of X -modules. 4.0.11. For each of the following rings , give a careful description of the field of fractions q and show that the ring is a DVR by constructing an appropriate discrete valuation on q . (a) (N/ ` O 2 U. 2 (CT `2 @6zQ &2AKS')(N8 , where K is a fixed prime number. (b) (/m/ 8m8 , the ring consisting of all power series in with coefficient in that have a positive radius of convergence. 4.0.12. The plane curve % d o:# c 4E'M 4 has coordinate ring ( IH d 2 c JA d oy# c 4 . As noted in Example 1.1.15, this is the coordinate ring of the affine toric variety given by the affine semigroup (L/E 2 (W2 -`27+6+6+38 . This semigroup is not saturated, which means that H Jk(NIH p42npo9J is not normal by Theorem 1.3.5. It follows that is not a DVR by Theorem 4.0.4. Give a direct proof of this fact using only the definition of DVR. Hint: The field of fractions of H 4m2 po J is I!n' . If IH p42 po J comes from the discrete valuation , what is !n' ?
4.0.9. Prove that the restriction map .
4.0.13. Let sequence
be a normal variety. Use Proposition 4.0.16 to prove that there is an exact
:#hlX ' #h I' #h U{ '^#h '^#h 2 where the map I ' hU{ ' is ,.jh zW{ F,Q' and { 'h ' is jh H J . Similarly, prove that there is an exact sequence y#Shl9 X ' #Dh ' #h U{ '^#Dh B{}@1'^#h `+ be a Weil divisor on a normal affine variety ( 4.0.14. Let ( <>=?7@1A' . As usual, let q be the field of fractions of . Proposition 4.0.28 describes Z 2EX $n # 'n' when . Here we will explore the general situation. (a) Let be a codimension one prime of , so that is a DVR. Hence the maximal ideal is principal. Use this to define < q for all . . (b) For arbitrary , prove that < Z 2EX ' 'B( and explain how this relates to Proposition 4.0.28. (c) If is a prime divisor, use part (b) to prove that
, )(.-
"!$# %'& )('(+*
%/
4.0.15. Let be an integral domain with field of fractions 0 . A finitely generated submodule of 0 is called a fractional ideal. If is normal and is a Weil divisor on 1*32465$78 ( , explain why 9 :!# ; )((.-<0 is a fractional ideal.
§4.1. Weil Divisors on Toric Varieties
169
§4.1. Weil Divisors on Toric Varieties
Let be the toric variety of a fan in with . Then is normal of dimension . We will use torus-invariant prime divisors and characters to give a lovely description of the class group of .
The Divisor of a Character. The order of vanishing of a character along a torusinvariant prime divisor is determined by the polyhedral geometry of the fan.
!" #$%!"
By the Orbit-Cone Correspondence (Theorem 3.2.6), -dimensional cones correspond to -dimensional -orbits in . We let denote the set of one-dimensional cones (i.e., the rays) of . Then gives codimension . The orbit closure is a -invariant prime divisor . one orbit The DVR gives the discrete valuation
&#' ,.-0/21 354
(*) &#'
+
6 ) 6 3487:9 !;=>8@
#A !" BC)DE# FG 9 ; KML 7 CN< 9 ; + Proposition 4.1.1. Let be the toric variety of a fan . If the ray #O$!" minimal generator B ) and K L is character corresponding to HIGJ , then 6 )PK L .RQHTSUBV)XWY@
Recall that the ray has a minimal generator . Also note that when , the character is a rational function in since is Zariski open in .
HIJ
B ) G
has
B ) to a basis Z:[\B ) S]Z"^_S`@`@`@"S]Z`a #Dcb\d:e2fghZ [ jilk a . By Example 1.2.20, m )ncoqprfts: 9vu w [ S wy^x [ S`@`@`@tS w aN x [ z . 9|{ 9}; aP~C[ m ) is defined by w [ N . It follows easily that the DVR is and ()F , - / 1 354 R,\ 41 4 354 9u w [tS`@`@`@"S w a zh
@ Similar to Example 4.0.6, E 9 w [ S`@`@`@tS w a ; has valuation 6 )gh+G> when w a[ S S 9vu w [ S`@`@`@tS w a zq Q w [ WY@ To relate this to 6 )PK L , note that w [ S`@`@`@"S w a are the characters of the dual basis of Z [ BV)S]Z ^ S`@`@`@S]Z a G . It follows that given any HIJ , we have U U K L w
[ L 1 w ^
L 1 `` w a
L 1 w
[ L 1 4 w ^
L 1 `` w a
L 1 @ Comparing this to the previous equation implies that 6 )gK5L8QHTSUB)XW . We next compute the divisor of a character. As above, a ray #$!" gives: A minimal generator B ) #8FO . A prime + -invariant divisor (D)8 &*#2 on . I> a
Proof. Since is primitive, we can extend of , then we can assume and the corresponding affine toric variety is
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
170
We will use this notation for the remainder of the chapter.
H J
Proposition 4.1.2. For and its divisor is given by
, the character
K L
) [
KL
is a rational function on
,
QHTSUB)XWq():@
( ) are KL , it M KML ( ) ) [ 6 354:K L q():@ K L ) [ Then we are done since 6 34:K5L8.RQHTSUB)_W by Proposition 4.1.1. Computing the Class Group. Divisors of the form ) )+() are precisely the divisors invariant under the torus action on (Exercise 4.1.1). Thus >()}i ) [ is the group of -invariant Weil divisors on . Here is the main result of this Proof. The Orbit-Cone Correspondence (Theorem 3.2.6) implies that the . Since is defined and nonzero on the irreducible components of follows that is supported on . Hence
section.
Theorem 4.1.3. The following sequence is exact:
J V < \V< b 5\y'S H < KML8 and the second sends a 5 -invariant divisor where the first map is to its divisor class in b . Furthermore, we have a short exact sequence: *< J < j< b j'@ if and only if tBy ) #$ !" spans , i.e., has no torus factors. Proof. Since the (*) are the irreducible components of C , Theorem 4.0.20
implies that we have an exact sequence
5\V< b 5\V< b \V'@ [ [ Since 9vu w [ S`@`@`@"S w a z is a UFD, the same is true for 9vu w+x[ S`@`@`@tS w ax z . This is the a coordinate ring of the torus 9 ;t , which is isomorphic to the coordinate ring 9vu J z of the torus 5 . Hence 9u J z is also a UFD, which implies b Mn by b is surjective. Theorem 4.0.18. We conclude that .< The composition J < zero since the < b is obviously maps to in first map is H < KML8 . Now suppose that ( b + . Then ( N h+ for some E 9 + ; . Since the support of ( misses + , this implies that h+ restricts to on M . When regarded as an element of
§4.1. Weil Divisors on Toric Varieties
171
9 +8 ; , has zero divisor on 5 , so that 9u J z ; by Proposition 4.0.16. Thus yK L for some 9 ; and HIJ (Exercise 3.3.4). It follows that on O , ( N h+. yK L N K L YS which proves exactness at . Finally, suppose that HIJ with K0L8 ) [ QHTSUBV)Wq() is the zero divisor. Then QHTSUBV)_WN for all #$ !" , which forces H N when the Br) span . This gives the desired exact sequence. Conversely, if the sequence is exact, then one easily sees that the Br) span , which by Corollary 3.3.10 is equivalent to having no torus factors. b is a finitely generated abelian group. In particular, we see that Zg[tS`@`@`@S]Z`a J J R> a QHTSUBCW B0[tS`@`@`@tSUBON> a UQhZ [ SU B hWYS`@`@`@S"QhZ a SUB WU
Examples. It is easy to compute examples of class groups of toric varieties. In practice, one usually picks a basis of , so that and (via the dual basis) . Then the pairing becomes dot product. We list the rays of as with corresponding ray generators . We will think of as the column vector , where the superscript denotes transpose.
N> a #[tS`@`@`@tSU# B
With this setup, the map
J <
B [ S`@`@`@tSUB
in Theorem 4.1.3 is the map 7 > a < >
represented by the matrix whose columns are the ray generators. In other words, . By Theorem 4.1.3, the class group of is the cokernel of this map, which is easily computed from the Smith normal form of .
#$ !"
When we want to think in terms of divisors, we let . prime divisor corresponding to
(
be the
%bjd:e2fg PZ [ Z ^ S]Z ^ m O B[ PZ [ Z ^ St " B ^ Z ^ 'St" 7 > ^ > ^ @ v
+
-invariant
Example 4.1.4. The affine toric surface described in Example 1.2.21 comes from the cone . For , is shown in Figure 1 on the next page. The resulting toric variety is the rational normal cone . Using the ray generators and , we get the map given by the matrix
This makes it easy to compute that
b N> g>}@
b
We can also see this in terms of divisors as follows. The class group is generated by the classes of the divisors corresponding to , subject to
( [S( ^
# [ SU# ^
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
172
ρ2
u2
u1 ρ1 Figure 1. The cone
when
RQhZ [ SUB [ Wq( [ RQhZ ^ SUB [ Wq( [ is generated by u ( [ z with u ( Thus b
the relations coming from the exact sequence of Theorem 4.1.3:
QhZ [ SUB ^ Wq( ^ ( [ QhZ ^ SUB ^ Wq( ^ R=( [ ( ^ @ [ z N , giving b N> P> . ^ Example 4.1.5. In Example 3.1.4, we saw that the blowup of 9 at the origin is ^ the toric variety : 9 given by the fan shown in Figure 2. N N
K K
ρ2
ρ0
u2
u0 ρ1
u1
Figure 2. The fan for the blowup of
at the origin
B [ Z [ SUB ^ Z ^ SUB Z [
Z^
The ray generators are corresponding to . By Theorem 4.1.3, the class group is generated by the classes divisors of the subject to the relations
(
( [S( ^S(
K K
( [ ( ( ^ ( _@
§4.1. Weil Divisors on Toric Varieties
b : 9 ^ U
>
173
u ( [ z u ( ^ z I u ( z
. This calculation Thus with generator can also be done using matrices as in the previous example. Example 4.1.6. The fan of has ray generators given by and . Thus the map can be written as
a
B+[ Z[tS`@`@`@"SUBVa Zta
J <
B v }Z [ `` Z a a
> a V > a [ [ S`@`@`@tS a V< ! [ `` a S [ S`@`@`@tS a Y@
Using the map
> a[ V < > _S`@`@`@tS a V < `` a S
one gets the exact sequence
*> a V> a [ V> 'S a which proves that bh N> , generalizing Example 4.0.21. It is easy to redo this
calculation using divisors as in the previous example. Example 4.1.7. The class group is isomorphic to
b a { L > ^ . More generally, b { cb lb Y @
You will prove this in Exercise 4.1.2.
Example 4.1.8. The Hirzebruch surfaces are described in Example 3.1.16. The fan for appears in Figure 3, along with the ray generators , , , .
B [ }Z [
B ^ cZ ^ B cZ [ B nR}Z ^
Z^
u1 = (−1, r) u2 u3 u4
Figure 3. A fan with
/
( [ S ( ^ S (_S ( , with relations N K . = ( [ ( N K . ( [ ( ^ ( @
The class group is generated by the classes of
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
174
u ( [ z and u ( ^ z . Thus ^ b tN> @ N gives b "cb [ { [ N> ^ , which is a special case of
b
It follows that In particular, Example 4.1.7.
is the free abelian group generated by
Exercises for §4.1.
4.1.1. This exercise will determine which divisors are invariant under the -action on . Given and , the -action gives . If is a prime divisor, -action gives the prime divisor . For an arbitrary Weil divisor * , the * . Then is -invariant if * for all . (a) Show that
is
-invariant.
!
(b) Conversely, show that any -invariant Weil divisor can be written as in part (a). Hint: Consider 2#" 4 4 $)( and use the Orbit-Cone Correspondence. 4.1.2. Given fans % in '& ()( and %+* in $&,*()( , we get the product fan
% .- %+* *0/1 2- 13*5461 7% 9 8 ! ;: 3< which by Proposition 3.1.14 is the fan of the toric variety . Prove that => ;: ?< => ;: => 3< / (A@ (!B ( Hint: The product fan has rays C - /D 8 and /D 8 - C * for C .7% 8 FE ( and C * G% * FE ( .
4.1.3. Redo the divisor class group calculation given in Example 4.1.5 using matrices, and redo the calculation given in Example 4.1.6 using divisors. 4.1.4. The blowup of HJI at the => origin >ML is the toric variety K in Example 3.1.15. Prove that $K $H I ((A@N .
>ML
7z $P L ! /// !QP I (
L ///
4.1.5. The weighted projective space O $P ! !QP ( , R 7 L /// I 9U fan in &1*N IT N 'P ! !QP ( . The dual lattice is
L //I /
$HJI( of the fan % described *SE , is built from a
L LX X (+7N IT 46 P YY I P I *D I L /// L /// !9Z [& denote the images of L the//standard !Q\ Let Z ! basis \ ! / I !P ( . Define maps are the ray generators of the fan giving O $P ! V A`badc a Lbg I /// !f a !9Z g ( &;^_N IT &e^ 9f !QZ ! L /// L L X I X N IT &e^_N ` ' ! ! I ( c&;^_ P Y I P I V
*W/ ' !
!Q
Show that these maps give an exact sequence
V
D 3& ^ &;^_N IT = > L /// and conclude that iO $P ! ! P ( (j@N .
8 /
I ]N IT .
The
Z
/
&e^_N<&3^hD
I
§4.2. Cartier Divisors on Toric Varieties
Let be the toric variety of a fan . We will use the same notation as in §4.1, where each gives a minimal ray generator and a -invariant prime divisor . In what follows, we write for a summation over the rays when there is no danger of confusion.
D( )i #$!"
#T !"
)
B+)
+
§4.2. Cartier Divisors on Toric Varieties
175
Computing the Picard Group. A Cartier divisor and hence
(
)( )S
)
(
on
is also a Weil divisor
) G>
) +) () is Cartier since ( is (Exercise 4.0.5). Let b \i denote the subgroup of consisting of 5 -invariant Cartier divisors. Since K L b for all H J , we get the following immediate by Theorem 4.1.3. Then
corollary of Theorem 4.1.3.
Theorem 4.2.1. The following sequence is exact:
J y< b V< s_ j'S where the first map is defined above and the second sends a -invariant divisor to its divisor class in s . Furthermore, if tBy) '#E !" spans , then we have a short exact sequence:
5\V<s5j< '@ Our next task is to determine the structure of b . In other words, which + -invariant divisors are Cartier? We begin with the affine case. Proposition 4.2.2. Let il be a strongly convex polyhedral cone. Then: m is the divisor of a character. (a) Every 5 -invariant Cartier divisor on m .N . (b) s: DV< J < b
I 9u FTJ
(
z
Proof. Let . First suppose that -invariant Cartier divisor. By Proposition 4.0.28,
+
m ) S",\ 4 !}(OU E N'S N i 9 K L L + 9 K L 3 9 K L
is an ideal
and
(
(4.2.1)
and
h+ l(
-invariant, we have
by argument used to prove (a)
(d) in Theorem 1.1.16 (Exercise 4.2.1).
#i gives an inclu#G.!" . Thus
Under the Orbit-Cone Correspondence (Theorem 3.2.6), sion of -orbits for all
+
is an effective
. Since
is
or
) 5) ()
&* 5 i &*#2ji *& #2N(D) & 5ji ()g@ )
176
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
*& 5 ( m m m m vcoqprfts g $ r N m m ; . Since ( is effective, $ by Thus ( N h+ for some 9 Proposition 4.0.16, and since is invertible on , we may assume . Then 6 34:h+q() 6 h+ 6 354:h+q()8N(@ h+ 3 4 ) ) Here, 34 denotes the sum over all prime divisors different from the (O) . The first equality is the definition of h+ , the second inequality follows since , m FT( ) for all and the final equality follows from ( I h+ since #G.!" . This shows that h+ l( , so that E . L with 9 ; and K L ( . Using (4.2.1), we can write $ XK m Restricting to , this becomes K L l h+ , which implies that K L _ m is a morphism on by Proposition 4.0.16. Then K5 L XK5L m imply that KM L _+ C for some . Hence KM L _ is nonvanishing and A m . It follows that in some open set with $ i K L h+ N( @ L and ( have support contained in ) () and every (D) meets Since K L .N( . (this follows from $NFO(*) , we have K finish the proof of (a), let ( be an arbitrary M -invariant Cartier divisor on m . To Since lJ ( is strongly convex), we can find H yF J such that QHTSUB ) W c for all #A.!" . Thus K L is a positive linear combination ( ( K L for sufficiently of the () , which implies that large. The above argument implies that ( is the divisor of a character, so that the same is true for ( . This completes the proof of part (a), and part (b) follows immediately using Theorem 4.2.1. Now fix a point . Since is Cartier, it is locally principal, and in particular is principal in a neighborhood of . Shrinking if necessary, we may , where satisfies . assume that
b\d:e fg PZ [ Z ^ S]Z ^ i|k ^ # [ SU# ^ u( [ z u( ^ z
b m > g> s: m
Example 4.2.3. The rational normal cone is the affine toric variety of the cone . We saw in Example 4.1.4 that . The edges of give prime divisors on , and the computations of Example 4.1.4 show that generates . Since by Proposition 4.2.2, it follows that the Weil divisors are not Cartier.
( [ S ( ^ m b
( [S( ^ Next consider the fan consisting of the cones #V[tSU#q^_S " . This is a subfan of the fan giving , and the corresponding toric variety is , where is the distinguished point that is the unique fixed point of the -action on . The variety is smooth since every cone in is smooth (Theorem 3.1.19).
§4.2. Cartier Divisors on Toric Varieties
177
Since and have the same one-dimensional cones, they have the same class group by Theorem 4.1.3. Thus
s: t. b t.cb cb N> P>}@ It follows that is a smooth toric surface whose Picard group has torsion. w 8 i 9 , which Example 4.2.4. One of our favorite examples is ?A is the toric variety of the cone A b\d:e2fghZ [ S]Z ^ S]Z
[ Z XS]Z ^ Z t ik . The ray generators are
B [ Z [ SMB ^ Z ^ SB} Z [ Z XSMB } Z ^ Z _@ Note that B5[ B BV^ B . Let ( i be the divisor corresponding to B
. In
[ ( [ ^ ( ^ r( +( is Cartier [ } ^ and that b T N> . Since s:T N , we see that the ( are not Cartier, and in fact no positive multiple of ( is Cartier. Exercise 4.2.2 you will verify that
Example 4.2.3 shows that the Picard group of a normal toric variety can have torsion. However, if we assume that has a cone of maximal dimension, then the torsion goes away. Here is the precise result.
? ka
Proposition 4.2.5. Let be the toric variety of a fan in contains a cone of dimension , then is a free abelian group.
s:
. If
(
Proof. By the exact sequence in Theorem 4.2.1, it suffices to show that if is a -invariant Cartier divisor and is the divisor of a character for some , then the same is true for . To prove this, write and assume that , .
( j( N K5L HIGJ Let have dimension
j(
(
) )5()
(
. Since is Cartier, its restriction to Using the Orbit-Cone Correspondence, we have
(
) [
m
is also Cartier.
)( )@
Proposition 4.2.2, so that there is H m . Thisby implies that
8cJ
This is principal on
( K L
such that
) QH SUBV)XW for all #.!"Y@ On the other hand, j( N KML implies that ) RQHTSUBV)W for all #!"Y@
Together, these equations imply
QhjH US B)XW N )nQHTSUB)XW for all #G.!"Y@ The B) span since . Then the above equation forces \HH ( N K L follows easily.
, and
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
178
This proposition does not contradict the torsion Picard group in Example 4.2.3 since the fan in that example has no maximal cone.
Comparing Weil and Cartier Divisors. Here is an application of Proposition 4.2.2. Proposition 4.2.6. Let equivalent:
be the toric variety of the fan . Then the following are
(a) Every Weil divisor on (b) (c)
s: cb . is smooth.
is Cartier.
m i b m < b m
Proof. (a) (b) is obvious, and (c) (a) follows from Theorem 4.0.22. For the converse, suppose that every Weil divisor on is Cartier and let be the affine open subset corresponding to . Since is onto by Theorem 4.0.20, it follows that every Weil divisor on is Cartier. Using from Proposition 4.2.2 and the exact sequence from Theorem 4.1.3, we conclude that induces a surjective map
s m }
H < K L J V< m .
c
) [
>()t@
.!" t # [ S`@`@`@tSU# , this map becomes J y> (4.2.2) H y< UQHTSUB)WYS`@`@`@S"QHTSUB)`WUY@ Now define 7 > < by [ S`@`@`@tS [ XB) . The dual map
; 7 J nd: C S >}.< nd: r > S >}5 > Writing
>
is easily seen to be (4.2.2). In Exercise 4.2.3 you will show that is surjective is torsion-free. is injective and (4.2.3) can be extended to a basis of
;
B) `S @`@`@"SUB) $@ The above discussion shows that ; is surjective. Then (4.2.3) implies that the B+) for #G.!" can be extended to a basis of , which implies that is smooth. Then is smooth by Theorem 3.1.19. Proposition 4.2.6 has a simplicial analog. Recall that is simplicial when every is simplicial, meaning that the minimal generators of are linearly independent over k . You will prove the following result in Exercise 4.2.3. Proposition 4.2.7. Let be the toric variety of the fan . Then the following are equivalent:
(a) Every Weil divisor on (b) (c)
has a positive integer multiple that is Cartier.
s:5 has finite index in b + . is simplicial.
§4.2. Cartier Divisors on Toric Varieties
179
In the literature, a Weil divisor is called -Cartier if some positive integer multiple is Cartier. Thus Proposition 4.2.7 characterizes those normal toric varieties for which all Weil divisors are -Cartier.
) )+() .
Describing Cartier Divisors. We can use Proposition 4.2.2 to characterize be the subset of maximal invariant Cartier divisors as follows. Let cones of , meaning cones in that are not proper subsets of another cone in .
i?
Theorem 4.2.8. Let be the toric variety of the fan Then the following are equivalent:
(
and let
(
m for all T$ . J with QH SUBV)XW ) for all #OG.!" . (c) For each T$ , there is H J with QH SUBV)XW. ) for all #G.!" . (d) For each T$ , there is H Furthermore, if ( is Cartier and tH is as in part (c), then: is unique modulo J 5.N GFJ . (1) H H Dd'J . (2) If is a face of , then H Proof. Since ( ) [ )+() , the equivalences (a) (b) (c) follow immediately from Proposition 4.2.2. The implication (c) (d) is clear, and (d) (c) works follows because every cone in is a face of some and if H for , it also works for all faces of . GJ satisfies QHTSUBV)XWR ) for all #O.!" . Then, For (1), suppose that H given H GJ , we have QH SUB ) W ) for all #OG.!" QH TH SUB ) W for all #G.!" QH TH SUBrW. for all BEG H TH G FJ J 5Y@ is unique modulo J 5 . Since H works for any face of , It follows that H H 8 Ddq*J , and (2) follows. uniqueness implies that H of part (c) of the theorem satisfy ( K ~ L for all T . The H m ~ L is local data for ( in the sense of Definition 4.0.12. We Thus P U S K call tH the Cartier data of ( . (a)
(b)
(
is Cartier.
is principal on the affine open subset
The minus signs in parts (c) and (d) of the theorem are related to the minus signs in the facet presentation of a lattice polytope given in (2.2.2), namely
t H J 2 QHTSUBW c
for all facets
of
: @
We will say more about this below. The minus signs are also related to support functions, to be discussed later in the section.
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
180
Nk a n "l V ( ) )5() J with QHTSUB)_W. ) for all #G.!" . (d) For each , there is H Part (1) of Theorem 4.2.8 shows that these H ’s are uniquely determined. in Theorem 4.2.8 is only unique modulo J 5 . Hence In general, each H we can regard H as a uniquely determined element of J J 5 . Furthermore, if
is a face of , then the canonical map J J 5.< J J sends H to H .
When is a complete fan in , part (d) of Theorem 4.2.8 can be recast as follows. Let . In Exercise 4.2.4 you will show is Cartier if and only if: that a Weil divisor
b
There are two ways to turn these observations into a complete description of . For the first, write
5
" [ S`@`@`@S
and consider the map
J J F J J jy< H y< H H @
In Exercise 4.2.5 you will prove the following. Proposition 4.2.9. There is a natural isomorphism
b f
J J <
J J FO @
For readers who know about inverse limits (see [2, p. 103]), a more sophis ticated description of comes from the directed set , where
when is a face of . We get an inverse system where each gives , and the inverse limit gives an isomorphism
J J 5 < J J
b
8S n
~ J J 5Y@
b
ka
The Toric Variety of a Polytope. In Chapter 2, we constructed the toric variety of a full dimensional lattice polytope . If , this means that . As noted above, has a canonical presentation
i J
J
tHIJ 2QHTSUB.W c for all facets of :S where > and B G is the inward-pointing facet normal that is the minimal . The normal fan consists of cones generator of the ray # b\d:e2fgB . , where indexed by proper faces Ri (4.2.4)
cb\d:e2fgB contains vY@ Proposition 2.3.6 implies that the fan Furthermore, the vertices of correspond to the maximal cones in is complete. , and the facets of correspond to the rays in \!" .
§4.2. Cartier Divisors on Toric Varieties
181
B
The ray generators of the normal fan are the facet normals . The corresponding prime divisors in will be denoted . Everything is now indexed by the facets of . The normal fan tells us the facet normals in (4.2.4), but cannot give us the integers in (4.2.4). For these, we need the divisor
(
(4.2.5)
(
( @
B
As we will see in later chapters, this divisor plays a central role in the study of projective toric varieties. For now, we give the following useful result. Proposition 4.2.10.
(
is a Cartier divisor on
and
(
N
.
#
corresponds to a maximal cone , and a ray lies in Proof. A vertex if and only if . But implies that . Note also that since is a lattice polytope. Thus we have such that for all , so that is Cartier by Theorem 4.2.8. You will prove that in Exercise 4.2.6.
! " J Q SUB .W=
N
(
# N q!"
(
In the notation of Theorem 4.2.8, described by the collection
tH
(4.2.6)
a
H
Q SUB W J
is the vertex . Thus
is a vertex of
(
is completely
:@
This is very satisfying and explains why the minus signs in (4.2.4) correspond to the minus signs in Theorem 4.2.8.
u ( z s_ ( c( K L H J H L ( N( K L .N( ~ L (Exercise 4.2.6), so that the divisor class of ( gives all translates of . The divisor ( has many more wonderful properties. We will get a glimpse of this in §4.3 and learn the full power of ( in Chapter 6 when we study ample
, also has a nice interpretation. If The divisor class then for some . In Proposition 2.3.7 we saw that and its translate have the same normal fan and hence give the same toric variety, i.e., . We also have
( (
divisors on toric varieties.
tH
5
Support Functions. The collections that describe -invariant Cartier divisors can be cumbersome to work with. Here we introduce a more efficient computational tool. Recall that the support of a fan is .
Definition 4.2.11. Let
be a fan in
.
:
il
7 g
(a) A support function is a function set of all support functions is denoted
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
182
(b) A support function
is integral with respect to the lattice if \
FEji >8@
The set of all such support functions is denoted Let
(
) )( )
(4.2.7)
tH
be Cartier and let
QH US B ) W. )
for all
o S E . be as in Theorem 4.2.8. Thus
#G.!"Y@
We now describe Cartier divisors in terms of support functions.
be a fan in . ) )+() and tH as above, the function M3 7 qV< k B V< M38Br.RQH SUBrW when BE
Theorem 4.2.12. Let (a) Given
(
is a well-defined support function that is integral with respect to (b)
M3B)_
(c) The map
)
for all
( < 0 3
#O$!" , so that ( M3B)Xq():@ )
induces an isomorphism
.
+co S TY@ is unique modulo FAJ and that Proof. Theorem 4.2.8 tells us that each H H H Dd' OF $F$J . It follows easily that 3 is well-defined. Also, M3 is linear on each since 03 Br\ QH SUBrW for BE , and it is integral with J . This proves part (a), and part (b) follows from the respect to since H definition of 03 and (4.2.7). It remains to prove part (c). First note that .3 Eo j 8S E by part (a). Since ($S $b 5 and OG> imply that M3 M3 3 M3 S the map b 5 < o S T is a homomorphism, and injectivity follows from part (b). To prove surjectivity, take |l o S T . Fix N . Since is integral with respect to , it defines a -linear map 7 OF?< > , which 7 > , where coqp e+ 5+F . Since extends to -linear map S >} J J 5YS }d: r J such that BC* QH SUBrW for B c . Then it follows that there is H ( ) M38B)_q() is a Cartier divisor that maps to . b
§4.2. Cartier Divisors on Toric Varieties
183
In terms of support functions, the exact sequence of Theorem 4.2.1 becomes (4.2.8)
H J No S E
J V< o j 8S Ej<
where
s5j< 'S
B < vQHTSUBCW and ) \B ) q ( ) z s5 . Be sure
maps to the linear support function defined by maps to the divisor class you understand the minus signs.
u
Here is an example of how to compute with support functions.
Zg[ Zt^ Z Z ^ Z
k
Example 4.2.13. The eight points are the vertices of a cube in . Taking the cones over the six faces gives a complete fan in . Modify this fan by replacing with . The resulting fan has the surprising property that . In other words, is a complete toric variety whose Cartier divisors are all principal. We will prove by showing that all support functions for are linear. Label the ray generators as follows, using coordinates for compactness:
Z[ Z^ Z Z[ s \ |
k
s
B+[\R!_S S :YS.By^}R!_St _St"YSB R!_St_St "YS.B R! _St _St" B}R!_St _Stv"YSB}R! _Stv_St"YS.B R! _St_Stv"YS.B =R! _Stv_St "Y@
The ray generators are shown in Figure 4. The figure also includes three maximal cones of :
[ cb\d:e2fgB [ SUB ^ SUB _SUB " ^ cb\d:e2fgB [ SUB XSUBSUBt }cb\d:e2fgB [ SUB ^ SUBSUB "Y@ The shading in Figure 4 indicates [ F ^ S [ F _S ^ F . Besides [ S ^ S , the fan has three other maximal cones, which we call left, down, and back. Thus the cone left has ray generators B+^XSUB SUB SUB , and similarly for the other two. u1
σ3 u6
u4
σ2
u2 u8
u7 σ1
u5 Figure 4. A fan
u3
with
/
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
184
o S > . We show that is linear as follows. Since is linear, $ H [ > such that \BrRQH [ SUBrW for B$ [ . Hence the support function B < \BC0 QH [ SUBrW vanishes identically on 5[ . Replacing with this support function, we may assume that . Once we prove everywhere, it will follow that all support functions are linear, and then s N by (4.2.8). Our hypothesis implies that \B [ \B ^ \B " \ B " since B [ SUB ^ SUB _SU B G [ . It suffices to prove \B . \B " \ B t. \ B ". .
Take there is
To do this, we use the fact that each maximal cone has four generators, which must satisfy a linear relation. Here are the cones and the corresponding relations: cone
[ ^
left down back
relation
B [ B }B ^ XB B [ B= XB B B+[ XB BV^ B B ^ B } B B B B } B B B B } B B
\B [ \ B ^ \ B " \ B" , the
Since is linear on each cone and second, third, fourth and fifth relations imply
\B". \B \B . \ B
B ". \B" B ". \ B tY@ The last two equation give \B . \ B , and substituting these into the first two shows that \BX \B Bt. \ B " N .
Since the toric variety of a polytope has the non-principal Cartier divisor of Example 4.2.13 is not the normal fan of any three , its follows that the fan dimensional lattice polytope. As we will see later, this implies that is complete but not projective.
(
A full dimensional lattice polytope function on the normal fan .
i J
Proposition 4.2.14. Assume normal fan . Then the function
i J
leads to an interesting support
is a full dimensional lattice polytope with
7 < k defined by BC.N *eCUQHTSUBCW HI
has the following properties:
§4.2. Cartier Divisors on Toric Varieties
(a)
is a support function for
and is integral with respect to
(b) The divisor corresponding to
185
is the divisor
(
.
defined in (4.2.5).
Proof. First note that minimum used in the definition of compact. Now write
exists because
is
tH J 2QHTSUBW c for all facets of :@ Then ( ( is Cartier by Proposition 4.2.10, and Theorem 4.2.12 shows that the corresponding support function maps B to . It remains to show that BCD o j and B I . Recall that maximal cones of correspond to vertices of , where the vertex gives the . Take B B , where maximal cone G bjd:e2fgB . Then HI implies QHTSUB W c @ (4.2.9) QHTSUBCW. Thus Br | . Since equality occurs in (4.2.9) when H , we
obtain
jBC.
RQ SUBCWY@
o \S E . Furthermore, when
This shows that , as desired.
Q SUB W.
, we have
jB..
We will return to support functions in Chapter 6, where we will use them to give elegant criteria for a divisor to be ample or generated by its global sections. Exercises for §4.2. 4.2.1. Prove (4.2.1) using the argument used to prove (a)
(d) in Theorem 1.1.16.
4.2.2. Prove the assertions made in Example 4.2.4. 4.2.3. Prove (4.2.3) and Proposition 4.2.7. is Cartier if and only if it satisfies 4.2.4. When % is complete, prove that * condition (d) stated in the discussion following Theorem 4.2.8.
4.2.5. Prove Proposition 4.2.9.
zWD {. Hint: The normal fan of
4.2.6. A lattice polytope gives the toric variety X a (9* (a) Prove that for any (b) Prove that
and the divisor V .
from (4.2.5).
is complete.
4.2.7. Let be a -invariant Cartier divisor on . By Theorem 4.2.8, is determined a 8 satisfying condition (2) of the theorem. Given a V , show by a collection / X a & a 8 . Be sure to explain where the ( is given by the collection / that minus sign comes from.
z`{
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
186
4.2.8. Let be the toric variety of the fan % . Prove the following consequences of the Orbit-Cone Correspondence (Theorem 3.2.6). (a)
: // /
$1 ( *
(b) Rays Z
!
.
:
!9Z 7 % 9E$( lie in a cone of % if and only if
4.2.9. Let % be a fan in &
( @
I
and assume that
(a) Fix a cone 1GG% of dimension . Prove that
{ 7,
(A@
%
Y
*
.
has a cone of dimension .
/ / ] 2 )% !Q&:( 4 4 *D 8
(b) Explain how part (a) relates to Example 4.2.13. (c) Use part (a) to give a different proof of Proposition 4.2.5.
4.2.4, but instead of using the lattice generated by \ !Q\ * !\ , 4.2.10. Let 1 be as in Example X X X N '\ X \* X \ ( , where 6! are relatively instead use &1*N7 * \ N \b* N \ * X X X is Cartier. prime positive integers with E . Prove that no multiple of * Hint: The first step will be to find the minimal generators (relative to & ) of the edges of 1 .
= \ !! \*,! \ (.-" . 4.2.11. Let be the toric variety of the octahedron * => (a) Show that (A@N$# . (j@N . (b) Use support functions and the strategy of Example 4.2.13 to show that { 78 L /// 4.2.12. In Exercise projective /// you showed that the weighted => L 4.1.5, L /// space =O > 'P ! L /!Q/P / I ( has !P ((2@ N . Prove that iO 'P ! !P ('( class group $O $P ! > L{ 7 i/O /$/ P ! !QP I ('(%I I a a !QP ( . maps to the subgroup N - N , where * 7&% $P ! I be a smooth toric variety and let 7 ' G% be a cone of dimension (*) . This 4.2.13. Let gives the orbit closure + , ' ( * -' ( - . In §3.3 we defined the blowup K > . 0/ ( . Prove that { 78$K >1. 0/ ((A@ { 7 (!BN / 43576 H;: ! /// ! < has Newton polytope 4.2.14. A nonzero polynomial 2 * 98 8 / 8 I 2 (+* == a 4 6 * D 8?> I BA iZ ( * When dimension , Proposition 4.2.14 tells us that the function @2 g ( has CA a a % { CA 9f !QZ 4 2 ('( is the support function of a divisor on . Here we interpret
as the tropicalization of 2 . The tropical semiring @ ! B%!D ( has operations BE *F%X { $ !( tropical addition( / GDE * tropical multiplication( /// A tropical polynomial in real variables : ! tropical sum ' : : 8 : H * 6 D DYD 5 B Y! 8 I B is a6JI finite D 8 DYYKD 8 I 5 8 8 I D YYMD :Z ( times). For a more compact representation, define a where 6 L and Z *ZG] DYD 5 for a * $ ! /// !Q ( ONJI . Then, using tropical monomial to be * 8 8 8I HI the tropical analog of summation notation, the tropical polynomial is H *QP I 6 D SR ! a * ' ! /// ! ( / I X 8 X H I 6 (a) Show that *F % { !T T 8 Y X I 8 I ( .
§4.3. The Sheaf of a Torus-Invariant Divisor
187
2 is the tropical polynomial / HAQ L * P D9D 8
(b) The tropicalization of our original polynomial
HA
CA
* Prove that . (The D is explained as follows. In general, the coefficients of are Puiseux series, and the tropicalization uses the order of vanishing of the coefficients. Here, the coefficients are nonzero constants, with order of vanishing D .) (c) The tropical variety ofX a tropical polynomial is the set of points in where is X * & * X * , compute the tropical Ivariety of not linear. For :* and show that it consists of the rays in the normal fan of ( . A nice introduction to tropical algebraic geometry can be found in [86].
2
2 8 ) 8
H
8 8
@2
H
HA
§4.3. The Sheaf of a Torus-Invariant Divisor
(
+ ) ") () , - /5 (
If is a -invariant divisor on the normal toric variety , we get the sheaf defined in §4.0. We will study these sheaves in detail in Chapter 6. In this section we will focus primarily on global sections.
,\-/5 (
We begin with a classic example of the sheaf . Example 4.3.1. For , the divisors correpsond to the ray generators of the usual fan for . The computation from Example 4.1.6 shows that . These linear equivalences give isomorphisms
a ( `S @`@`@"S (a a a b > ( N( [ ` ` N( a
, (", ( [ ` ` R, ( a by Proposition 4.0.29. In the literature, these sheaves are denoted , !" . Simi larly, the sheaves , h=( h , > , are denoted , h . Global Sections. Let ( be a -invariant divisor on a toric variety O . We will give two descriptions of the global sections S",.-0/ (OU . Here is the first. Proposition 4.3.2. If ( is a -invariant Weil divisor on , then S", - /5 (U. 9 K L @ 3 S",-/5 (U , then h+ ( implies h+ Proof. If since ( . Since 9u J z is the coordinate ring of M , Proposition 4.0.16 implies E 9u J z . Thus S",-/5 (Uji 9u J z @ The action of 5 on itself induces an action on 9vu J z such that if Gc0 and H J , then KLI KL PK5L , where the left-hand side of this equation is the action of on K L and the right-hand side is K L % 9 times K L . Then S",-/5 (U is invariant under this action since ( is M -invariant. Using the
argument used to prove (a)
(d) in Theorem 1.1.16, we see that
S",-/5 (U.
-/ 1 / 3
9 K L @
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
188
Since
KL S",.-0/M (U
KML8 ( l , we are done. ) )"() and HIJ , K L ( l
if and only if
The Polyhedron of a Divisor. For is equivalent to
(
QHTSUB ) W ) l
for all
#$!"YS
for all
#$!"Y@
which can be rewritten as
QHTSUBV)XW c )
(4.3.1)
This explains the minus signs! To emphasize the underlying geometry, we define (4.3.2)
We say that 3
3l t HIJ ' QHTSUB)XW
)
for all
#$ !":@
is a polyhedron since it is an intersection of finitely many closed half spaces. This looks very similar to the canonical presentation of a polytope need not (see (4.2.4), for example). However, the reader should be aware that be a polytope, and even when it is a polytope, it need not be a lattice polytope. All of this will be explained in the examples given below.
3
For now, we simply note that (4.3.1) is equivalent to our second description of the global sections. Proposition 4.3.3. If
where 3Ni J
(
HI 3$FJ
-invariant Weil divisor on S",.-0/M (OU 9 K L S L
is a
is the polyhedron defined in (4.3.2).
. This gives
, then
As noted above, a polyhedron is an intersection of finitely many closed half spaces. A polytope is a bounded polyhedron. Examples. Here are some examples to illustrate the kinds of polyhedra that can occur in Proposition 4.3.3. Example 4.3.4. The fan erators For the divisor
: 9 ^ 9 ^ H R w S w cv w c _@
for the blowup of at the origin has ray genand correponding divisors if and only if . , a point lies in
B Z [ Z ^ S0B [ |Z [ SB ^ Z ^ ( _S.( [ S.( ^ 3 ( N( ( [ (D^ QHTSUB "W c QHTSUB5[W c QHTSUB ^ W c The fan and the polyhedron 3 are shown in Figure 5 on the next page. Note that 3 is not bounded. By Proposition 4.3.3, the lattice points of 3 (the dots in ^ , (OU . Figure 5) give characters that form a basis of : 9 YS"
§4.3. The Sheaf of a Torus-Invariant Divisor
189
u2
e2
u0
Σ
PD
u1
e1
Figure 5. The fan and the polyhedron
^ for the Hirzebruch surface ^ has ray generators B [ } Z [ Z ^ S B ^ Z ^ S B RZ [ SB }Z ^ . The corresponding divisors are ( [ S.( ^ S.( _S.( , and^ Example 4.1.8 implies that the classes of ( [ and ( ^ are a b ^ N> . basis of i k ^ be the corresponding Consider the divisor ([ (D^ , G> , and let if and polyhedron, which is a polytope in this case. A point HI w S lies in
Example 4.3.5. The fan
only if
QHTSUB [ W c QHTSUB ^ W c QHTSUB W l QHTSUB W l
Figure 6 shows
^ , together with shaded areas marked SS
u1
a=1
0
u2
Σ2
[^ w ^ cv w l'@ '@
A B
u4
u3
C
− e2
Figure 6. The fan
e1 − e2
and the polyhedra
. These are related
a=2
a=3
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
190
to the polygons
R_S S
for
by the equations
[
@ } [ Notice that as we increase , the line ^ w ^ corresponding to B [ moves to the right and makes the polytope bigger. In fact, you can see that ^ is the normal for any . For , we get a lattice polytope fan of the lattice polytope ^
^
^
, but its normal fan is not —you can see how the “facet” with inward normal is not a lattice polytope since collapses to a point of . For , vector is a vertex.
^[ Z ^
B^
^
[
3
Chapter 6 will explain how the geometry of the polyhedron relates to the properties of the divisor . In particular, we will see that the divisor from Example 4.3.5 is ample if and only if since these are the only ’s for which is the normal fan .
(
^
( [
( ^
, h , h ( t ( B ( ( 3l a 'S a where DaOik is the standard -simplex. We can think of characters as Laurent monomials L [ `` a , where H R [ S`@`@`@tS a . It follows that a S", h U E 9u Y[ S`@`@`@S a z _2 f rh+ :@
Example 4.3.6. By Example 4.3.1, the sheaf can be written , where the divisor corresponds to the ray generator from Example 4.1.6. It is is straightforward to show that the polyhedron of
The homogenization of such a polynomial is
| w w [ w _S`@`@`@tS w a w tj 9vu w _S`@`@`@"S w a z @
In this way, we get an isomorphism
a S", h U
E 9u w XS`@`@`@"S w a z _
is homogeneous with
2f Vh+.c : @
The toric interpretation of homogenization will be discussed in Chapter 5.
ka
Example 4.3.7. Let be the toric variety of an -dimensional lattice polytope . The canonical presentation of gives the Cartier divisor is the polytope defined in (4.2.5), and one checks easily that the polyhedron that we began with (Exercise 4.3.1). It follows from Proposition 4.3.3 that
i J
3
\S",.- . ( .U.
L
9 K L @
(
§4.3. The Sheaf of a Torus-Invariant Divisor
K.L
Recall from Chapter 2 that the characters toric variety . We will see below that
\S",- . h ( .U.
191
j(
for
L
H F$J
give the projective , so that gives the polytope
9 K L @
KL j, - h ( .
In Chapter 2 we proved that is very ample for sufficiently large, in which is the toric variety . So the characters that realize as a case . In Chapter 6, we will projective variety come from global sections of pursue these ideas when we study ample and very ample Cartier divisors.
S",.- h ( .U
Note also that gives number of lattice points in mul tiples of . This will have important consequences in later chapters. operation sending a -invariant Weil divisor ( i to the polyhedron 3The i J defined in (4.3.2) has the following properties: 3 3 for l . 3 3 TH . 3 i 3. You will prove these in Exercise 4.3.2. The multiple 3 and Minkowski sum 3 are defined in §2.2, and H is translation.
Complete Fans. When the fan is complete, we have the following finiteness result that you will prove in Exercise 4.3.3.
Proposition 4.3.8. Let (a) (b) (c)
3
S",-/V. 9
be the toric variety of a complete fan
, so the only morphisms
5
is a polytope for any
S",-/5 (U .
< 9
-invariant Weil divisor
(
in
are the constant ones.
on
.
has finite dimension as a vector space over
divisor on
9
for any Weil
S",j-v
The assertions of parts (a) and (c) are true in greater generality: if complete variety and is a coherent sheaf on , then (see [89, Vol. 2, §VI.1.1 and §VI.3.4]).
S N
Exercises for §4.3.
4.3.1. Prove the assertion "* 4.3.2.
c Prove the properties of ^
. Then:
9
is any and
made in Example 4.3.7.
listed above.
a
* D 4.3.3. Prove g Proposition 4.3.8. Hint: For part (a), use completeness to show that V a D for all C . For part (b), assume ( * I and suppose a satisfy when f !9Z 4 4 a 4 4^ . Then consider the points on the sphere I - I .
(
S RR
4.3.4. Let % be a fan in & ( with convex support. Then V ( . cone with dual 4 %24 "-
E
4 %24 -& (
is a convex polyhedral
Chapter 4. Divisors on Toric Varieties
192
(a) Prove that 4 %24 is the polyhedron associated to the divisor
H (b) Conclude that 9 !# (9* .
P (c) Use part (b) to prove part (a) of Proposition 4.3.8.
4.3.5. Example 4.3.5 studied divisors on the X HirzebruchX surface consider the divisors * and * * * * . (a) Show that gives the same polygon as .
*D on
*
.
. This exercise will
== a (c) Show that * 41GG% * 8) (( and that * == a 461 G% * )8('( . Thus and give the same polygon but differ in how their < Cartier data relates to the # $)( is generated by global polygon. In Chapter 6 we will use this to prove that < sections while # ' ( has base points. (b) Since * is smooth, and are Cartier and hence correspond via Theorem 4.2.8 to a 8 3< * and / a 8 ?< * respectively. Compute these collections. collections /
Chapter 5
Homogeneous Coordinates
§5.0. Background: Quotients in Algebraic Geometry Projective space
where
9 ;
acts on
a
is usually defined as the quotient
9 a[
a R 9 a [ " X 9 ;S
by scalar multiplication, i.e.,
_S`@`@`@tS a R _S`@`@`@"S a Y@ a a The above representation defines as a set; making
into a variety requires the notion of abstract variety introduced in Chapter 3. The main goal of this chapter is to prove that every toric variety has a similar quotient construction as a variety.
w 7 w j? <
7 < ; 7 |<
Group Actions. Let be a group acting on a variety . We always assume that for every , the map defines a morphism . When is affine, comes from a homomorphism . We define the induced action of on by
I oqprfts: v
G ; h+ ~C[ w for all w $ . You will check for . In other words, + w \c in Exercise 5.0.1 this gives an action of on . Thus we have two objects: The set -orbits | w w . The ring of invariants T E for all
. To make into an affine variety, we need to define its coordinate ring, i.e., we $
need to determine the “polynomial” functions on if , then
. A key observation is that
0 w w
193
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
194
7 < 9
gives a well-defined function . Hence elements of polynomial functions on , which suggests that as an affine variety
give obvious
SM co'pyfts Y@
As shown by the following examples, this works in some cases but fails in others.
^ v
9 ^ o'pyfts 9u S z
D ^
act on Example 5.0.1. Let , where acts . Note that every orbit consists of two elements, with the by multiplication by exception of the orbit of the origin, which is the unique fixed point of the action. The ring of invariants gives the affine toric variety . Hence we get a map
9vu S z
A w v ^
9u ^ S S ^ z
7g9 ^ +^< oqprfts: 9u S z . A w ^ i 9 ^ ^ where the orbit ^ S` maps to S S . This is easily seen to be a bijection, 9 u S z is the perfect way to make 9 ^ ^ into an affine variety. so that oqprfts: v
This is actually an example of the toric morphism induced by changing the lattice—see Examples 1.3.17 and 1.3.19. Example 5.0.2. Let act on acts , where via In this case, the ring of invariants is
9 ; 9 oqprfts: 9vu w [ S w ^ S w _S w z [ S ^ S S .R [ S ^ S ~C[ _S ~C[ "Y@
9 ;
9vu w [ S w ^ S w S w z 9vu w [ w XS w ^ w XS w [ w S w ^ w z S
which gives the map
7P9 9 ;8V< o'pyfts 9u w [ S w ^ S w _S w z . A w 8ji 9 where the orbit 9 ; [ S ^ S _S maps to [ S ^ XS [ S ^ t . Then we have (Exercise 5.0.2): is surjective. If A w " , then ~C[ r consists of a single 9 ; -orbit which is closed in 9 . ~C[ g consists of all 9 ; -orbits contained in 9 ^ { P 'S g P 'S g {E9 ^ . ~C[ g is infinite. Thus
This looks bad until we notice one further fact (Exercise 5.0.2): The fixed point gives the unique closed orbit mapping to
* 9 'S g , then the 9 ; -orbit For example, if S` R 9 ; S S 'S g\ P S S 'S g 9 ; is not closed since
S S 'S gN . It follows that closed 9 ; -orbits A w 8Y@
under .
We will see that this is the best we can do for this group action.
§5.0. Background: Quotients in Algebraic Geometry
195
9 a [ coqprfts: 9u w S`@`@`@S w a z
9 ;
Example 5.0.3. Let act on by scalar multiplication. Then the ring of invariants consists of polynomials satsifying
w XS`@`@`@"S w a w XS`@`@`@tS w a
9 ; . Such polynomials must be constant, so that 9u w _S`@`@`@tS w a z 9 @ It follows that the “quotient” is o'pyfts 9 , which is just a point. The reason for this a[ . is that the only closed orbit is the orbit of the fixed point * 9 for all
Examples 5.0.2 and 5.0.3 show what happens when there are not enough invariant functions to separate -orbits.
co'pyftsv
The Ring of Invariants. When acts on an affine variety , a natural question concerns the structure of the ring of invariants. The coordinate ring is a ? It clearly finitely generated -algebra without nilpotents. Is the same true for has no nilpotents since . But is finitely generated as a -algebra? This is related to Hilbert’s Fourteenth Problem, which was settled by a famous example of Nagata that need not be a finitely generated -algebra! An exposition of Hilbert’s problem and Nagata’s example can be found in [23, Ch. 4].
9
i
9
9
oqprfts_
is finitely generated, then is an affine variety If we assume that that is the “best” candidate for a quotient in the following sense.
oqprftsv such that is a finitely generated 9 qo prfts_ . be the morphism of affine varieties < i . Then: (a) Given any diagram / ? AA AA AA A where is a morphism of affine varieties such that w . w for and w T , there is a unique morphism making the diagram commute, i.e., . (b) If is irreducible, then is irreducible. (c) If is normal, then is normal. oqprfts_ and that is induced by ; 7 c< . Then Proof. Suppose that ; .Di follows easily from w w for S w l . Thus ; factors uniquely as < h < @ The induced map 7 < clearly has the desired properties. 7
Lemma 5.0.4. Let act on -algebra, and let induced by the inclusion
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
196
Part (b) is immediate since is a subring of . For part (c), let be the field of fractions of . If is integral over , then it is also integral over and hence lies in since is normal. It follows that , which obviously equals since acts trivially on . Thus is normal.
coqprfts
F
This shows that has some good properties when generated, but there are still some unanswered questions, such as:
is finitely
< surjective? Does have the right topology? Ideally, we would like m i to be open if ~C[ m }il is open. (Exercise 5.0.3 explores how this works for and only if
Is
7
group actions on topological spaces.)
While is the best affine approximation of the quotient a non-affine variety that is a better approximation?
, could there be
We will see that the answers to these questions are all “yes” once we work with the correct type of group action. Good Categorical Quotients. In order to get the best properties of a quotient map, we consider the general situation where is a group acting on a variety and is a morphism that is constant on -orbits. Then we have the following definition.
7 I<
<
7
Definition 5.0.5. Let act on and let be a morphism that is constant on -orbits. Then is a good categorical quotient if:
m i (a) If
, } m 8< ,- ~C[ m U induces an , m R, - ~C[ m U @ is closed. (b) If i is closed and -invariant, then \i (c) If [ S ^ are closed, disjoint, and -invariant in , then [ and ^ is open, then the natural map isomorphism
are disjoint in
.
We often write a good categorical quotient as properties of good categorical quotients. Theorem 5.0.6. Let
7 I<
7
<
. Here are some
be a good categorical quotient. Then:
(a) Given any diagram
EE EE EE EE "
<
/
§5.0. Background: Quotients in Algebraic Geometry
where and
197
w G
w
is a morphism of varieties such that for , there is a unique morphism making the diagram commute, i.e., .
w T (b) is surjective. m ~C[ m ji (c) A subset il is open if and only if (d) Given points w S , we have w . w F @
is open.
Proof. The proof of part (a) can be found in [23, Prop. 6.2]. The proofs of the remaining parts are left to the reader (Exercise 5.0.4).
Algebraic Actions. So far, we have allowed to be an arbitrary group acting on , assuming only that for every , the map is a morphism . We now make the further assumption that is an affine variety. To define this carefully, we first note that the group of invertible matrices with entries in is the affine variety
7
w < w ay 9 {
<
9 a 9 . i5ar 9
J aPa 9 . 9 a X2f N :@ a 9 o a 9 9 ; a
A subgroup is an affine algebraic group if it is also a subvariety of . Examples include , , , and finite groups.
a 9
If is an affine algebraic group, the connected component of the identity, denoted , has the following properties (see [53, 7.3]):
is a normal subgroup of finite index in
.
is an irreducible affine algebraic group.
An affine algebraic group acts algebraically on a variety defines a morphism
Sw < w
{
< $@
if the
-action
.RiN
Examples of algebraic actions include toric varieties since the torus acts algebraically on . Examples 5.0.1, 5.0.2 and 5.0.3 are also algebraic actions. Algebraic actions have the property that -orbits are constructible sets in This has the following nice consequence for good categorical quotients.
7
Proposition 5.0.7. Let an affine algebraic group , and assume that a good categorical quotient
C~ [ r (a) If O , then (b) induces a bijection
-orbits in
act algebraically on a variety exists. Then:
<
contains a unique closed
closed
.
-orbit.
@ C~ [ C
Proof. For part (a), note that uniqueness follows immediately from part (d) of Theorem 5.0.6. To prove the existence of a closed orbit in , let be
i
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
198
C~ [ r is stable under , so we w w has minimal dimension. Note that w is irreducible since is irreducible, and since w is conm m structible, there is a nonempty Zariski open subset of w such that i w . If w is not closed, then w contains an orbit w . Thus i w w i w m @ However, w is irreducible, so that w m l w @ Hence has strictly smaller dimension, a contradiction. Thus w is closed. If [ S`@`@`@"S are coset representatives of , then w w [ shows that w is also closed. This proves part (a) of the proposition, and part (b) follows immediately from part (a) and the surjectivity of . C~ [ r
the connected component of the identity. Then can pick an orbit such that
For the rest of the section, we will always assume that group acting algebraically on a variety .
is an affine algebraic
Good Geometric Quotients. The best quotients are those where points are orbits. For good categorical quotients, this condition is captured by requiring that orbits be closed. Here is the precise result.
7
(a) All
<
Proposition 5.0.8. Let following are equivalent:
-orbits are closed in
be a good categorical quotient. Then the
.
w S , we have w . w and
(b) Given points
(c)
induces a bijection
-orbits in
(d) The image of the morphism is the fiber product
{ -
{
.
<
lie in the same
-orbit
@ {
defined by
@
S w < w S w
Proof. This follows easily from Theorem 5.0.6 and Proposition 5.0.7. We leave the details to the reader (Exercise 5.0.5).
In general, a good categorical quotient is called a good geometric quotient if it satisfies the condtions of Proposition 5.0.8. We write a good geometric quotient as since the points in the variety correspond bijectively to -orbits in .
7
<
§5.0. Background: Quotients in Algebraic Geometry
199
We have yet to give an example of a good categorical or geometric quotient. For instance, it is not clear that Examples 5.0.1, 5.0.2 and 5.0.3 satisfy Definition 5.0.5. Fortunately, once we restrict to the right kind of algebraic group, examples become abundant. Reductive Groups. An affine algebraic group is called reductive if its maximal connected solvable subgroup is a torus. Examples of reductive groups include finite groups, tori, and semisimple groups such as .
o Mar 9
For us, actions by reductive groups have the following key properties.
coqprfts:v
Proposition 5.0.9. Let be a reductive group acting algebraically on an affine variety . Then (a)
9 -algebra. < oqprfts_ . induced by i
is a finitely generated
(b) The morphism 7 quotient.
is a good categorical
In the situation of Proposition 5.0.9, we can write oqprfts_v oqprfts .
Proof. See [23, Prop. 3.1] for part (a) and [23, Thm. 6.1] for part (b).
Examples 5.0.1, 5.0.2 and 5.0.3 involve reductive groups acting on affine varieties. Hence these are good categorical quotients that have all of the properties listed in Theorem 5.0.6 and Proposition 5.0.7. Furthermore, Example 5.0.1 (the action of on ) is a good geometric quotient. This last example generalizes as follows.
^
9 ^
NiR
Example 5.0.10. Given a strongly convex rational polyhedral cone and a sublattice of finite index, part (b) of Proposition 1.3.18 implies that the acts on such that the induced map on coordinate finite group rings is
5i m 1 9vu FJ m z < 9vu F J z i 9vu FGJ z @ m It follows that 7 1 < 1 is a good categorical quotient. In fact,
is a good geometric quotient since the -orbits are finite and hence closed. This completes the proof of part (c) of Proposition 1.3.18. Constructing Quotients. Now that we can handle affine quotients in the reductive case, the next step is to handle more general quotients. Here is a useful result.
7 I< be a morphism of varieties such that 7 ~C[ j< is a good categorical quotient for every , then 7 < is a good categorical
Proposition 5.0.11. Let act on and let that is constant on -orbits. If has an open cover
quotient.
Proof. The key point is that the properties listed in Definition 5.0.5 can be checked locally. We leave the details to the reader (Exercise 5.0.6).
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
200
ni
Example 5.0.12. Consider a lattice and a sublattice and let be a fan in . This gives a toric morphism
N
of finite index,
7 1 < 1 @ By Proposition 1.3.18, the finite group R| is the kernel of < + that acts on 1 . Since ~C[ m 1 m 1
, so
T$
for , Example 5.0.10 and Propostion 5.0.11 imply that is a good geometric quotient. This strengthens the result proved in Proposition 3.3.7. It is sometimes possible to construct the quotient of by locally by taking rings of invariants for a suitable affine open cover. If the local quotients patch together to form a separated variety , then the resulting morphism is a good categorical quotient by Proposition 5.0.11. Here are two examples that illustrate the strategy.
7
<
9 ; ^ act on 9 ^ m "m by scalar multiplication, where 9 ^ 9 " [ , where oqprfts 9 u w XS w [ z m 9 ^ A w .coqprfts 9u wrx [ S w [ z m [\ 9 ^ A w [.coqprfts 9u w S w x[ [ z m F m [\ 9 ^ A w w [Y.coqprfts 9u w x [ S w x[ [ z Y@
Example 5.0.13. Let . Then
The rings of invariants are
9u wyx [ S w [ z 9u w [ w z 9u w XS wyx[ [ z 9u w w [ z 9u w x [ S w x[ [ z 9u w [ w " x [ z @ m 9 ; glue together in the usual way to create [ . Since It follows that the M 9 ; -orbits are closed in 9 ^ " , it follows that [ 9 ^ "X 9;
is a good geometric quotient.
This example generalizes to show that
a 9 a [ "X 9 ; a[ is a good geometric quotient when 9 ; acts on 9
by scalar multiplication. At the beginning of the section, we wrote this quotient as a set-theoretic construction. It is now an algebro-geometric construction. Our second example shows the importance of being separated.
§5.0. Background: Quotients in Algebraic Geometry
201
^ ~C[ Then 9 ^ " act on 9 " by S`.R S m m 9 [ ; and m F m [ are as in Example 5.0.13.` .Here, the rings of 9vu w x [ S w [ z 9u w w [ z 9vu w _S w x[ [ z 9u w w [ z 9vu w x [ S w x[ [ z 9u w w [ x [ z @ m 9 ; along m \F m [ 9 ; gives the variety obtained from Gluing together two copies of 9 by identifying all nonzero points. This is the non-separated variety m
m [
Example 5.0.14. Let , where , invariants are
constructed in Example 3.0.15.
In Exercise 5.0.7 you will draw a picture of the quotient cannot be separated in this example.
9 ; -orbits that explains why the
<
7
In this book, we usually use the word “variety” to mean “separated variety”. For example, when we say that is a good categorical or geometric quotient, we always assume that and are separated. So Example 5.0.14 is not a good categorical quotient. In algebraic geometry, most operations on varieties preserve separatedness. Quotient constructions are one of the few exceptions where care has to be taken to check that the resulting variety is separated.
2 @2
Exercises for §5.0.
8 on 8 is. Bea morphism sure you
5.0.1. Let act on an affine variety such that : 2 4 57 for all . Show that defines an action of understand why the inverse is necessary. 5.0.2. Prove the claims made in Example 5.0.2.
8
U
5.0.3. Let be a group acting on a Hausdorff topological space, and let be the set U ` ^ U by of -orbits. Define . The quotient topology on is U defined by saying that is open if and only if is open. U (a) Prove that if is Hausdorff, then the -orbits are closed subsets of .
8
is closed and -invariant, then !"# U (c) Prove that if disjoint, and -invariant in . ! * are disjoint$ in* areU closed,
(b) Prove that if
% '& )(
!
is closed. , then
% *+ )
and
,
5.0.4. Prove parts (b), (c) and (d) of Theorem 5.0.6. Hint for part (b): Part (a) of Defini UU tion 5.0.5 implies that injects into for all open sets . UU Use this to prove that is Zariski dense in . Then use part (b) of Definition 5.0.5. 5.0.5. Prove Proposition 5.0.8. 5.0.6. Prove Proposition 5.0.11.
.*
/D 8 described in Example 5.0.14. 5.0.7. Consider the H action on H (a) Show that with two exceptions, the H -orbits are the hyperbolas Also describe the two remaining H -orbits.
8 8 *
,
D
.
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
202
(b) Give an intuitive explanation, with picture, to show that the “limit” of the orbits * as ^_D consists of two distinct orbits.
8 8 (c) Explain how part (b) relates to the non-separated quotient constructed in the example.
such that has 5.0.8. Give an example of a reductive -action on an affine variety a nonempty -invariant affine open set with the property that the induced map U U ^ U U is not an inclusion.
5.0.9. Let a finite group act on such that a good categorical quotient exists. Explain why is a good geometric quotient.
` ^ UU
§5.1. Quotient Constructions of Toric Varieties
Let
be the toric variety of a fan as a good categorical quotient
in
. The goal of this section is to construct
9 for an appropriate choice of affine space 9 , exceptional set i 9 group . We will use our standard notation, where each #$!" generator By) #8F and a + -invariant prime divisor ()vi
, and reductive gives a minimal .
No Torus Factors. Toric varieties with no torus factors have the nicest quotient constructions. Recall from Proposition 3.3.9 that has no torus factors when is spanned by , , and when this happens, Theorem 4.1.3 gives the short exact sequence
By) #% !"
Dy< J y < ) >()ny< b jV< 'S L ) QHTSUBV)XWq() and b is the class group where H $J maps to KM8 defined in §4.0. We use the convention that in expressions such as ) , ) and , the index # ranges over all #O!" . ) We write the above sequence more compactly as *< J < > [ < b '@ (5.1.1) Applying }d +!S 9 ; gives [
< }d b YS 98; j< nd > S 9}; < }d hJ S 9n; \y< _S which remains a short exact sequence since nd +!S 9 ; is left exact and 9 ; is divisible. We have natural isomorphisms [ }d > S 9 ; R 9n; [ nd +hJcS 9 ; +S
and we define the group
by
nd C b YS 9 ; Y@
§5.1. Quotient Constructions of Toric Varieties
203
[ V< 9 ; V < + cV< _@
This gives the short exact sequence of affine algebraic groups
v<
(5.1.2)
The Group G. The group defined above will appear in the quotient construction of the toric variety . For the time being, we assume that has no torus factors.
[ 9 ;
The following result describes the structure of . for as a subgroup of the torus
b
Lemma 5.1.1. Let (a) (b)
Ri 9 ;` [
and gives explicit equations
be as in (5.1.2). Then:
is the character group of
.
is a torus, so that is isomorphic to a product of a torus and a finite Abelian group. In particular, is reductive.
Z:[tS`@`@`@tS]Zta of J , we have ) j 9 ;t [ ) )
L 1 4 for all HIJ )j 9 ; [ ) )
1 4 for @ is a finitely generated Abelian group, b Proof. Since b (c) Given a basis
where
is a finite Abelian group. Then
> {
,
{ S 9 ; R 9 ; { nd + S 9 ; Y@ }d r b YS 9 ; nd + > This proves part (b) since nd r S 9 ; is a finite Abelian group. For part (a), gives the map that sends nd C b YS 9 ; note that bh give characters b to E 9 ; . Thus elements of on , and the above isomorphisms make it easy to see that all characters of arise this way. [ For part (c), the first description of follows from (5.1.2) since J < > [ is defined by H lJ < UQHTSUBV)XWU > , and the second description follows immediately. a a Example 5.1.2. The ray generators of the fan for are B [ Z SUB [ a [ Z [ S`@`@`@SUB a Z a . By Lemma 5.1.1, _S`@`@`@"S a \A 9 ; lies in if and only if
L 1 ~ ~ ~
[ L 1 `` a
L 1 a for all HIJ N> . Taking H equal to Z [ S`@`@`@S]Z a , we see that is defined by ~C[ [ `` ~C[ a R_@ Thus
P S`@`@`@XS 9 ; 9 ;S a[ given by scalar multiplication. which is the action of 9 ; on 9
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
204
[ { [
Example 5.1.3. The fan for has ray generators in . By Lemma 5.1.1, only if
B [ cZ [ SUB ^ }Z [ SUB [tS !^XS S \A 9 ; lies in if and
[ L 1 ^
L 1 ~
L 1
L 1 ~ R ^ for all HIJ N> . Taking H equal to Z [ S]Z ^ , we obtain [ ^~C[ ~C[ _@ Z"^SUB }Z"^
> ^ N
Thus
P S S S S 9 ; R 9 ; ^ @ ^ Example 5.1.4. gives the rational Let b\d:e2fg qZ [ Z ^ b ]S Z ^ % i Nk >,which normal cone . Example 4.1.4 shows that
P> , so that nd > g>nS 9 ; S i 9 ; is the group of th roots of unity. To see how acts on 9 ^ , one where uses the ray generators B [ qZ [ AZ ^ and B ^ cZ ^ to compute that P S P
(Exercise 5.1.1). This shows that
can have torsion.
9 [ [ 9
The Exceptional Set. In building the quotient representation of , we have the and the affine space . All that is missing is the exceptional set group that we remove from before taking the quotient by .
i 9 [ [ observation is that and 9 depend only on !" . In order to , useful One get we need something that encodes the rest of the fan . We will do this [ using a monomial ideal in the coordinate ring of 9 . Introduce a variable w ) for each # !" and let 9vu w ) X # !" z @ [ . Then oqprfts_ 9 . We call the total coordinate ring of For each cone , define the monomial w wV) @ ) [ Thus w is the product of the variables corresponding to rays not in . Then define
the irrelvant ideal
=
RQ w
A useful observation is that w is a multiple of w if is the set of maximal cones of , then
=
RQ w
} W\i M@
whenever is a face of . Hence,
XWY@
O }
Furthermore, one sees easily that the minimal generators of are precisely the , determines uniquely.
for . Hence, once we have
w
!" O }
§5.1. Quotient Constructions of Toric Varieties
205
= A O }U i 9 [ @
Now define
=
The variety of a monomial ideal is a union of coordinate subspaces. For , the coordinate subspaces can be described in terms of primitive collections, which are defined as follows.
i !" is a primitive collection if: i .!" for all . (a) , there is with ri .!" . (b) For every proper subset
Definition 5.1.5. A subset
Proposition 5.1.6. The = as a union of irreducible components is given by = A w )_# YS
where the union is over all primitive collections
=
i !" .
A w ) S`@`@`@"S w ) =i = w = Q wV) S`@`@`@S w) `W t# [ S`@`@`@"SU# w w) # .!" A w ) tS`@`@`@tS w ) Conversely, every primitive collection gives a maximal coordinate subspace A w )# contained in = , and the proposition follows.
Proof. It suffices to determine the maximal coordinate subspaces contained in . Suppose that is such a subspace and take . and Since vanishes on is prime, the Nullstellensatz im plies is divisible by some , i.e., . It follows that
satisfies condition (a) of Definition 5.1.5, and condition (b) follows easily from the maximality of . Hence is a primitive collection.
In Exercise 5.1.2 you will show that the algebraic analog of Proposition 5.1.6 is the primary decomposition
=
Q w) _ #
WY@
Here are some easy examples. Example 5.1.7. The fan for consists of cones generated by proper subsets of , where are as in Example 5.1.2. Let generate for , and let be the corresponding variable in the total coordinate ring. We compute in two ways:
tB _S`@`@`@tSUB a
a
}
w w
w
B _S`@`@`@tSUB a
B
#
b\d: e2fgB _S`@`@`@"S B S`@`@`@"SUB a .
The maximal cones of the fan are given by Then , so that . Hence
O } RQ w S`@`@`@tS w a2W = " . The only primitive collection is t# _S`@`@`@SU# a , so = A w S`@`@`@tS w a " by Proposition 5.1.6. [ [ { has ray generators B [ cZ [ SUB ^ }Z [ SUB Example 5.1.8. The fan for for a picture of this fan. Each B gives a ray # Z"^SUB }Zt^ . See Example 3.1.12 and a variable w . We compute = in two ways:
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
206
w ^ w , and similarly the w [ w S w [ w S w ^ w . Thus = RQ w ^ w S w [ w S w [ w XS w ^ w tWYS ^ 9 ^ { " . and one checks that } " {G9 The only primitive collections are t# [ SU# ^ and t# _SU# , so that } A w [ S w ^ A w _S w " {G9 ^ 9 ^ { " by Proposition 5.1.6. Note also that = RQ w [ S w ^ WCFTQ w _S w W . [ [ A final observation is that 9 ; on 9 by diagonal matrices and = acts [ i 9 ; [ also acts . It follows that hence induces an action on 9 [ on 9 = . We are now ready to take the quotient. as a quotient, we first construct a The Quotient Construction. [ To represent !" be the standard basis toric morphism 9 . Let Zt) '# ==< [ of the lattice > . For each , define the cone cb\d:e2fghZt) X# .!"U i k [ @ b\d:e2fgB [ SUB t
gives the monomial The maximal cone other maximal cones give the monomials
It is easy to see that these cones form a fan
[ [ k . This fan has the following nice properties. in > Proposition [ 5.1.9. Let be the fan defined above. (a) 9 = is the toric variety of the fan . [ < that is compatible with (b) The map Zt) < B) defines a map of lattices > [ the fans in k and in .
7:9 [ }\V<
(c) The resulting toric morphism
is constant on
-orbits.
b\d:e2fPhZ) V# [ !"U 9
Proof. For part (a), let be the fan consisting of and its faces. Note that is a subfan of . Since is the fan of , we get the toric variety of by taking and then removing the orbits corresponding to all cones in . By the Orbit-Cone Correspondence (Theorem 3.2.6), this is equivalent to removing the orbit closures of the minimal elements of . But these minimal elements are precisely the primitive collections . Since the corresponding orbit closure is , removing these orbit closures means removing
[ 9
=
A w ) V#
A w )_#
Y@
i !"
§5.1. Quotient Constructions of Toric Varieties
207
7 > [ < hZt)X B) 5 B ) # .!" [ < C from the exact The map of tori induced by is the map 9 ; sequence i [ will check this in Exercise 5.1.3). Hence, if [ (5.1.2) (you 9 ; and w 9 = , then w w w YS where the first equality holds by equivariance and the second holds since is the [ kernel of 9 ;` < + . This proves part (c) of the proposition. . We can now give the quotient construction of be a toric variety without torus factors and consider the Theorem 5.1.10. Let [ toric morphism 7:9 =< from Proposition 5.1.9. [ Then: = , so that (a) is a good categorical quotient for the action of on 9 9 [ = @ (b) is a good geometric quotient if and only if is simplicial. given by m i , . By Proof. For part (a), we use the open cover of For part (b), define by . Since the minimal generators of are given by , , we have by the definition of . Hence is a compatible map of fans.
7 C~ [ m j < m
Proposition 5.0.11, it suffices to show that
(5.1.3)
is a good categorical quotient.
Ti m m of ~ C [ i b\d:e fghZ`) # .!"U 7 m V< m S where for simplicity we write instead of . The corresponding map ; on coordinate rings can be described as follows: For m , the cone gives the semigroup F> [ P ) G> [ ) l for all # .!":@ m is the semigroup algebra Hence the coordinate ring of 9 ) w ) 4 ) l for all # .!"_@ This is the localization , where w ) [ wV) . For m , the coordinate ring is the usual semigroup algebra 9u FJ z . To study (5.1.3), first observe that if and , then . It follows that is equivalent to
is the toric variety . Hence (5.1.3) is the toric morphism
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
208
[ [ < dualizes to the map J < > [ sending H EJ to . It follows that ; 7g9u FJ z < is given by ; K L ) w )
L 1 4 @ Note that QHTSUB ) W for all # , so that the expression on the right really lies in . m and hence As explained at the beginning of the chapter, the group acts on on its coordinate ring . Since is constant on -orbits, ; factors 9vu FJ z < i @ m < oqprfts is a good Since is reductive, Proposition 5.0.9 tells us that categorical quotient for the action of . Hence it suffices to prove that ; induces
7> QHTSUB ) W G>
The map
an isomorphism
9vu G F J z
@
m since 9 ; [ The map has Zariski dense image in by the exact sequence (5.1.2). It follows that ; is injective. To show that ; is surjective, take and write it as (5.1.4)
w ) w ) 4 satisfies ) N for all
. Then is -invariant where each w if and only if for all , we have w w @ Thus is -invariant if and only if for all whenever . is a character on and hence is an element of its character The map < group b (Lemma 5.1.1). This character is trivial when , so that by (5.1.1), the exponent vector J , i.e., must come from an element H w R Q T H U S B W
for all . But , which implies that
QHTSUB W l for all Y@ FEJ , and the desired surjectivity follows immediately. This shows that H
This completes the proof of part (a).
For part (b), first assume that is simplicial. By Proposition 5.0.8, it suffices to show that distinct -orbits map to distinct points of . Using the open cover , we are reduced to showing that distinct -orbits in map to distinct points of .
m i m
B
Since is simplicial, the ray generators , and by hypothesis, the collection of all ray generators Hence we can write as a disjoint union
B
m
[ k
, are linearly independent, , spans .
,
§5.1. Quotient Constructions of Toric Varieties
B
such that the for coordinates coming from
k [
209
form a basis of . Projection onto the gives an exact sequence
[ [ < > > < > < '@ ? ? [ Note also that since the B ,
, form a basis, the map J < > given by H < QHTSUB W [ gives an exact sequence < J < > [ < <
where the cokernel
is finite.
Combining the two above exact sequences with (5.1.1), we get a commutative diagram with exact rows and columns:
(5.1.5)
<
J <
<
J
> [
>
>
b
<
> [ < <
}d S 9 ;
}d
. Then applying Now let
right gives the exact sequence
<
<
of affine algebraic groups. Note that
The group
<
9 ; <
<
<
S9 ;
to the column on the
is finite. m acts on , which we write as m 9 [ { 9n; { 9}; { 9 ; S
{ 9 ; m and , one easily checks that Given w S (5.1.6) S S as a subset of m via the where is the usual product in 9 ; . We regard S { 9 ; . Thus f acts on . Hence we have map < a commutative diagram m / m
O
(5.1.7)
|= || | || ||
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
210
m < m
< m
where is constant on -orbits and is constant on -orbits. The induced maps on coordinate rings give a commutative diagram
9u m z II
/
9u m z
II II II I$
9u z
As shown earlier, the top line is an isomorphism. Recall that our proof used the exactness of (5.1.1), which reappears as the middle row of (5.1.5). The same argument, using the next row in (5.1.5), shows that (Exercise 5.1.4). It is a good categorical quotient for and follows that in (5.1.7), is a good categorical quotient for . But is finite, so that the -orbits are closed. Hence is a good geometric quotient, which by Proposition 5.0.8 implies that distinct -orbits map to distinct points in .
< m
m < m
{
9vu m z v9 u z m
m
< m
Consider two distinct -orbits in . Using (5.1.6), one sees that a -orbit intersects in an -orbit (Exercise 5.1.4). Since the -orbits map to distinct points in , the same is true for the -orbits by the commutativity of (5.1.7). This proves that is a good geometric quotient when is simplicial.
m
m
It remains to prove the converse. Suppose that has a non-simplicial cone . as follows. Since is non-simplicial, there We construct a non-closed orbit in is a relation where and for at least one . If we set for , then the one-parameter subgroup
N
[ B
>
. This follows easily from Lemma 5.1.1
CB
[ m i 9 The affine open subset
is nonzero for all
9n; [
is actually a one-parameter subgroup of (Exercise 5.1.4). and
consists of all points whose th coordinate . Hence the point
, where
B
B B
l
l'S
[ m B . The limit exists in since B | lies in . Now consider whenever . Furthermore, if , the th coordinate B is for B lies in m . By assumption, there is all , so that the limit B
with l . This has the following consequences: Since the th coordinate of B is nonzero, the same is true for every element in its -orbit B . Since l , the th coordinate of B B is zero.
§5.1. Quotient Constructions of Toric Varieties
m B
It follows that
B
m
211
is not closed in since its Zariski closure contains the point . This shows that is not a good geometric quotient and completes the proof of the theorem.
B
[
[ [ ;
One nice feature of the quotient is that it is compatible with the tori, meaning that we have a commutative diagram
where the isomorphism on the bottom comes from (5.1.2) and the vertical arrows are inclusions. Examples. Here are some examples of the quotient construction. has quotient representation Example 5.1.11. By Examples 5.1.2 and 5.1.7,
a
;
a
a [ " ; S
where acts by scalar multiplication. This is a good geometric quotient since is smooth and hence simplicial. Example 5.1.12. By Examples 5.1.3 and 5.1.8, has quotient representation
[ { [ " { ^ ; ^ acts via S S S XS
where geometric quotient.
[{ [ ^ { " n; ^ S S "S XS . This is again a good
:s
S`@`@`@tS `a
S`@`@`@tS `a > a [ `` `agBVa tB _S`@`@`@tSUB a _S`@`@`@"S a
Example 5.1.13. Fix positive integers and let with . The images of the standard basis in be the lattice give primitive elements satisfying . Let be the fan consisting of all cones generated by proper subsets of . . As in Example 3.1.17, the corresponding toric variety is denoted Using the quotient construction, we can now explain why this is called a weighted projective space. We have since has rays, and by the argument used in Example 5.1.7. It remains to compute . In Exercise 4.1.5, you computed the short exact sequence
> a [ X> `S`@`@`@tS a B S`@`@`@tSUBa
[
a [
B
" i ; a [
J > a [ > J QHTSUB "WYS`@`@`@S"QHTSUB a W > a[ and _S`@`@`@"S a l> a[ a[ where H ` ` a a > . This shows that the class group is > , and since Z G> maps to G> , it is easy to see that S`@`@`@S ; ; @
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
212
a [ given by B S`@`@`@SUB a BXS`@`@`@"S B a Y @ Since is simplicial (every proper subset of tB _S`@`@`@SUB a is linearly independent
This is the action of
in
;
on
), we get the good geometric quotient
_S`@`@`@tS
a
a [ " ; @ XS`@`@`@S a from §2.0 and also gives its
This gives the set-theoretic definition of structure as a variety since we have a good geometric quotient.
m cbjd:e2f Z [ S]Z ^ S]Z [ Z _S]Z ^ Z ji k
Example 5.1.14. Consider the cone find the quotient representation of , we label the ray generators as
Then
;
. To
[ B5 [ Z_[` SMBV^ "Z ^ Z SMB Z"^X SMB Z_[ Z @ and since w . To determine the group i
, note that the exact sequence (5.1.1) becomes
[ S ^ S _ S
where to show that
G>
>
>
[ ^ S S ~C[ S C~ [
m
Hence we get the quotient presentation
> 'S > . This makes it straightforward
;
;@
;X@
w
In Example 5.0.2, we gave a naive argument that the quotient was . We now see that the intrinsic meaning of Example 5.0.2 is the quotient construction of given by Theorem 5.1.10. This example is not a good geometric quotient since is not simplicial.
m
^
Example 5.1.15. Let be the blowup of shown in Figure 1. By Example 4.1.5,
b
ρ2
u2
^
origin, whose fan is ^ at the> with generator u [ z
ρ0
u0 u1
Figure 1. The fan
ρ1
for the blowup of at the origin
§5.1. Quotient Constructions of Toric Varieties
u ^z
u z.
213
;
Hence and the irrelevant ideal is gives the good geometric quotient
^
This
{ " 'S n;S ~C[ S w S . where the ; -action is given by YS w S We also have u YS w S z u w S z . Then the inclusion { "'S }i
Qw S W.
induces the map on quotients
^
{ " 'S n;
where the final isomorphism uses
8; ^ S
; coqprfts u S w S z c oqprfts u w S z Y@ In terms of homogeneous coordinates, S w S w S . This map is the toric ^ ^
b\d:e2f B [ SUB ^ given by . ^ is the blowup of The quotient representation makes it easy to see why ^ at the origin. Given a point of ^ with homogeneous coordinates YS w S , there are two possibilities: N , in which case S w S S w S . This maps to w S ^ and^ is nonzero since w S cannot both be zero. It follows that the part of where N looks like ^ "'S . , in which case 'S w S maps to the origin in ^ . Since 'S w S ^ where w S and w S cannot both be zero, it follows that the part of [ N looks like ^ . ^ by replacing the origin with a copy of is a built from This shows that ~C[ [ which is called the exceptional locus . Since 'S , we see that , ^ induces an isomorphism
^ ^ 'S :@ morphism
induced by the refinement of
Note also that is the divisor corresponding to the ray . You should be able . to look at Figure 1 and see instantly that
[
S 'S
We can also check that lines through the origin behave properly. Consider the line defined by , where . When we pull this back to
, we get the subvariety defined by
w
^
' @ This is the total transform of . It factors as w
w
. Note that defines the exceptional locus, so that once we remove this, we get the curve in
defined by . This is the proper transform of , which meets
^
w
|
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
214
'S "S
the exceptional locus at the point with homogeneous coordinates , cor responding to . In this way, we see how blowing up separates tangent directions through the origin.
[
S
The General Case. So far, we have assumed that has no torus factors. When still has a quotient construction, though it is no longer torus factors are present, canonical.
Let be a toric variety with a torus factor. By Proposition 3.3.9, the ray , span a proper subspace of generators , . Let be the intersection . of this subspace with , and pick a complement so that The cones of all lie in and hence give a fan in . As in the proof of Proposition 3.3.9. we obtain
B
{ ; > . Theorem 5.1.10 applies to since B
where span by construction. Note also that Hence
{
It follows that
[
@
,
and
, .
n; [ { n; (5.1.8) [ { ; { ; S In the last line, we use the trivial action of on ; . You will verify the last
isomorphism in Exercise 5.1.5.
; w [ `` w [ { ; [ YS { ; [ [ { and where [ { { w [ `` w Y@ as Hence we can write the quotient presentation of [ @ (5.1.9) We can rewrite (5.1.8) as follows. Using
, we obtain
This differs from Theorem 5.1.10 in two ways:
The representation (5.1.9) is non-canonical since it depends on the choice of the complement . contains and hence has codimension in . In constrast, (this follows from always has codimension in Proposition 5.1.6 since every primitive collection has at least two elements).
w [ `` w {
[
[
[
In practice, (5.1.9) is rarely used, while Theorem 5.1.10 is a common tool in toric geometry.
§5.1. Quotient Constructions of Toric Varieties
/ $
Exercises for §5.1.
%# f 8 % 9E .
5.1.1. In Example 5.1.4, verify carefully that 5.1.2. Prove that tive collections
g
4 C7
`
215
8 4
.
, where the intersection ranges over all primi-
^ & , and in the proof we use the map 5.1.3. In Proposition 5.1.9, we defined N ^ of tori 'H induced by . Show that this is the map appearing in (5.1.2).
: < ;: <
5.1.4. This exercise is concerned with the proof of part (b) of Theorem 5.1.10. @H (a) Prove that the map ^ in (5.1.7) induces an isomorphism H
(b) Prove that a -orbit intersects that the intersection is nonempty.
/ E8
in an
.
-orbit. In particular, you need to show
(c) Prove that $ when Z i D . Hint: Use Lemma 5.1.1. You can give a more conceptual proof by taking the dual of (5.1.1).
- U U @ - and / $ $ N * 4 X * 5.1.6. Consider the usual fan % for O but use the lattice & 8 , where is a positive integer. DG% (a) Prove that the ray generators are Z $ D , Z * $ D $ and L $ odd Z U U ) $ ) even 8 . V / $ U $ U +4 $ . N $ D?% (b) Prove that the dual lattice is => N BN U N . (c) Prove that
5.1.5. Let be a variety with trivial action. Prove that use this to verify the final line of (5.1.8).
(d) Compute the quotient representation of
.
5.1.7. Find the quotient representation of the Hirzeburch surface
I
-"! ) %# when the fan % is smooth. Hint: Let 1 7% 5.1.8. Prove that acts freely on H i fixes Z i Z . Show that E for C GU 1 and then use and suppose that E for all C . Lemma 5.1.1 to show that -!
5.1.9. Prove that acts with finite isotropy subgroups on H simplicial. Hint: Use the proof of part (b) of Theorem 5.1.10.
)$#&% {C% ! %#)'# 4 % F EY4 . When % )#(% ) 0{ % ! # )X #* {0!% ,+ X E , or (b) 4 % 9 E4 {0% E and )%# /bD 8 .
5.1.10. Prove that stronger result states that either (a) % *
in Example 3.1.16.
%# when the fan %
is
is a complete simplicial fan, a
This is proved in [6, Prop. 2.8]. See the next exercise for more on part (b).
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
216
P X andE , where {C% a finite group $ $ I $$ I L @O 'P $ $ P I U $ Also prove that the following are equivalent:
5.1.11. Let % be a complete fan such that thatL there is a weighted projective space O O $P P such that
4 % 9L E Y4 $P
. Prove acting on
is a weighted projective space. => (b) A@N . (c) & is generated by Z , C 7% 9E . L Z Z I . First show that % is simplicial Hint: Label the ray generators and that there L L L D E . Then are positive integers P P satisfying I P Z and R % 'P P I I consider the sublattice of & generated by the Z and use Example 5.1.13. You will also
(a)
$ $ $ $
$ $
need Proposition 3.3.7. If you get stuck, see [6, Lem. 2.11]. 5.1.12. In the proof of Theorem 5.1.10, we showed that a non-simplicial cone leads to a non-closed -orbit. Show that the non-closed -orbit exhibited in Example 5.0.2 is an example of this construction. See also Example 5.1.14. 5.1.13. Fill in the details omitted in Example 5.1.15.
*
5.1.14. Example 5.1.15 gave the quotient construction of the blowup of D H and used the quotient construction to describe the properties of the blowup. Give a similar treatment for the blowup of H [H I , using the star subdivision described in §3.3.
I
§5.2. The Total Coordinate Ring In this section we assume that coordinate ring
is a toric variety without torus factors. Its total
u w
z [ Roqprfts and contains the irrelevant was defined in §5.1. This ring gives ideal RQ w =W used in the quotient construction of . In this section we will explore how this . ring relates to the algebra and geometry of
is its grading by b [ J b . Given [ where maps to the divisor class b a monomial w , define its degree to be
w 2
f w b b , we let denote the corresponding graded piece of . For $ The grading on is closely related to the group }d b YS ; . Recall that b is the character group of , where as usual b gives The Grading. An important feature of the total coordinate ring . We have the exact sequence (5.1.1) the class group
§5.2. The Total Coordinate Ring
217
; . The action of on [ induces an action on with , we have K ~C[ ' for all
[ (5.2.1) w K ' w for all S w (Exercise 5.2.1). Thus the graded pieces of are the eigenspaces of the action of is homogeneous of degree . on . We say that a Example 5.2.1. The total coordinate ring of is u w XS "S w a z . By Exam a[ a ple 4.1.6, the map b is XS "S a `` a . This gives the grading on u w _S tS w a z where each variable w has degree , so that K
the character the property that given
“homogeneous polynomial” has the usual meaning.
In Exercise 5.2.2 you will generalize this by showing that the total coordinate , where the ring of the weighted projective space is variable now has degree . Here, “homogeneous polynomial” means weighted homogeneous polynomial. Example 5.2.2. The fan for is the product of the fans of and , and by Example 4.1.7, the class group is
w
u w S S w a z
S S `a
a { L
a
L
b a { a cb a { b L ^ The total coordinate ring is u w XS S w a S _S "S z , where L
f w S 2f ' S
(Exercise 5.2.3). For this ring, “homogeneous polynomial” means bihomogeneous polynomial.
^
^
^
Example 5.2.3. Example 5.1.15 gave the quotient representation of the blowup
of at the origin. The fan of is shown in Example 5.1.15 and has ray generators , , , corresponding to variables in the total . Since , one can check that the coordinate ring grading on is given by
[ ^ u YS w S z
f
^
b
and
S w S
2f w 2 f
(Exercise 5.2.4). Thus total coordinate rings can have some elements of positive degree and other elements of negative degree. The Toric Ideal-Variety Correspondence. For -dimensional projective space a homogeneous ideal defines a projective variety This generalizes to more general toric varieties as follows.
Ei
We first assume that
u w _S S w a z
[
vi
a
a
, .
is simplical, so that we have a good geometric quotient
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
218
~C[
w
~C[
gives homogeneous by Theorem 5.1.10. Given , we say a point coordinates for . Since is a good geometric quotient, we have . for some . Thus all homogeneous coordinates for are of the form
w
w be homogeneous Now let be the total coordinate ring of and let for the b -grading on , say . Then w K ' w by (5.2.1), so that w N for one choice of homogeneous coordinates of if and only if w for all homogeneous coordinates of . It follows that the . We can use this to define subvarieties of equation is well-defined in
as follows.
Proposition 5.2.4. Let . Then: (a) If
i
be the total coordinate ring of the simplicial toric variety
is a homogeneous ideal, then
w w N . is a closed subvariety of arise this way. (b) All closed subvarieties of
i
[ w [ is a closed -invariant subset of categorical quotient (Definition 5.0.5), Conversely, given a closed subset ~C[ ji
Proof. Given
for all
as in part (a), notice that
w for all . By part (b) of the definition of good is closed in . i , its inverse image [ is closed and -invariant. Then the same is true for the Zariski closure ~C[ i [ ~C[ Ei is a homogeneous ideal It follows without difficulty that satisfying . Example 5.2.5. The equation w gives the -invariant closed subvariety w ji which is easily seen to be the prime divisor . This shows that
always has a global equation, though it fails to have local equations when Cartier (see Example 4.2.3).
a
a
is not
Classically, the Weak Nullstellensatz gives a necessary and sufficient condition for the variety of an ideal to be empty. This applies to and as follows:
For
a : Given an ideal i
u w [ S tS w a z , in a
§5.2. The Total Coordinate Ring
219
a : Given a homogeneous ideal i u w XS S w a z , in a Q w S S w a W i for some l
For
The toric version of the weak Nullstellensatz uses the irrelevant ideal .
Qw
}W\i
Proposition 5.2.6 (The Toric Weak Nullstellensatz). Let variety with total coordinate ring and irrelevant ideal homogeneous ideal, then
Proof. Let
ji
in
[
i
i
be a simplicial toric . If is a
i
l i
for some
the affine variety defined by denote in [
. Then:
ji i for some [ l'S where the last equivalence uses the Nullstellensatz in . a and a , the irrelevant ideal is Q W i u w [ S "S w a z and Q w _S S w a Wji For u w S tS w a z respectively. Furthermore, for a , the grading on u w [tS tS w a z is trivial, so that every ideal is homogeneous. Thus the toric weak Nullstellensatz a and a . implies the classical version of the weak Nullstellensatz for both
a
a
The relation between ideals and varieties is not perfect because different ideals can define the same subvariety. In and , we avoid this by using radical ideals:
a : There is a bijective correspondence a radical ideals i u w [ S "S w a z closed subvarieties of For a : There is a bijective correspondence a homogeneous ideals closed subvarieties of i radical Q w S tS w a W\i u w S "S w a z
For
Here is the toric version of this correspondence. Proposition 5.2.7 (The Toric Ideal-Variety Correspondence). Let cial toric variety. Then there is a bijective correspondence
closed subvarieties of
Ei
i
i
radical homogeneous ideals
\i
be a simpli-
Proof. Given a closed subvariety , we can find a homogeneous ideal with by Proposition 5.2.4. Then is also homogeneous and satisfies , so we may assume that is radical. Since
Y S
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
220
$i is a radical homogeneous ideal satisfying . This proves surjectivity. To prove injectivity, suppose that S i are radical homogeneous ideals in . Then with [ [ i implies that is contained in and . However, S
we conclude that
Hence the above equality implies
so that
by the Nullstellensatz since
YS
and
are radical.
For general ideals, another way to recover injectivity is to work with closed subschemes rather than closed subvarieties. We will say more about this in the appendix to Chapter 6.
When is not simplicial, there is still a relation between ideals in the total coordinate ring and closed subvarieties of .
i
Proposition 5.2.8. Let (a) If
be the total coordinate ring of the toric variety
is a homogeneous ideal, then
there is
w
~C[
with
. arise this way. (b) All closed subvarieties of
wN
for all
. Then:
is a closed subvariety of
Proof. The proof is identical to the proof of Proposition 5.2.4.
~C[
The main difference between Propositions 5.2.4 and 5.2.8 is the phrase “there is ”. In the simplicial case, all such are related by the group , while this may fail in the non-simplicial case. One consequence is that the ideal-variety correspondence of Proposition 5.2.7 breaks down in the nonsimplicial case. Here is a simple example.
w
m
w
n;
Example 5.2.9. In Example 5.1.14 we described the quotient representation of for the cone , and in Example 5.0.2 we saw that the quotient map
b\d:e2f Z[tS]Z"^_S]Z_[
Z S]Zt^
Z i k
m w i is given by [tS ^_S S [ S ^ S [ S ^ . Note that the irrelevant u w [ S w ^ S w _S w z . ideal is
§5.2. The Total Coordinate Ring
[
The ideals contained in
221
^
Qw [ Sw ^ W
Q w _S w W m [ ^ { "^ " ^ " { "
are radical homogeneous ideals and that give the same subvariety in :
[ ^
m
m
Thus Proposition 5.2.7 fails to hold for this toric variety.
Local Coordinates. Let be an -dimensional toric variety. When smooth cone of dimension , we get an affine open set
contains a
m i with m a a are compatible with the homogeneous The usual coordinates for [ in the following sense. The cone gives the map [ coordinates for that sends [ to the point [ defined by
[
[
otherwise
Proposition 5.2.10. Let be a smooth cone of dimension and let be defined as above. Then we have a commutative diagram
[ / [ m / S
where the vertical maps are the quotient maps from Theorem 5.1.10. Furthermore, the vertical map to the left is an isomorphism.
~C[ m
m
m
Proof. We first show commutativity. In the proof of Theorem 5.1.10 we saw that . Since the image of lies in , we are reduced to the diagram
[ << << << <
m
/
m
Since everything is affine, we can consider the corresponding diagram of coordinate rings
uw
z
o
gNNN NNN NNN NN
uw
o7 ooo o o ooo ooo
u J z S
z
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
222
w L and ; [ w
L for ; , and commutativity follows. For the final assertion, note that ; is an isomorphism since the
[ It is clear that ; ;
where ;
form a basis of
by our assumption on . This completes the proof.
[
m i m
i
vJ
,
i
.
,
i
It follows that if a closed subvariety is defined by an ideal , then the affine piece is defined by the dehomogenized ideal obtained by setting , in all polynomials of . We ,
will give examples of this below, and in §5.3, we will explore the corresponding notion of homogenization.
uw
Proposition 5.2.10 can be generalized to any cone (Exercise 5.2.5).
z
w
satisfying
^
^
Example 5.2.11. In Example 5.1.15 we described the quotient construction of the blowup of at the origin. This variety can be expressed as the union are as in Example 5.1.15. , where
m
m
[ S ^ ^ ^ The map
S w S
w S
in homogeneous cois given by ordinates. Combining this with the local coordinate maps from Proposition 5.2.10, we obtain
m
i
^ S w ^ S
w S i S S YS ^ , where w S w ^ . We Consider the curve w S in the plane ^ study this on the blowup using local coordinates as follows: On m , we get w S , i.e., w ^ ^ w . Since | . defines the exceptional locus, we get the proper transform w On m , we get Y S , i.e., ^ ^ ^ , with proper ^ N . transform ^
m
YS w S
Hence the proper transform is a smooth curve in . This method of studying the blowup of a curve is explained in many elementary texts on algebraic geometry, such as [83, p. 100].
^
We relate this to the homogeneous coordinates of as follows. Using the above map , we get the curve in defined by , i.e., . Hence the proper transform is . Then: Setting gives the proper transform on .
w
^ ^ w
^
^
w S R ^ w
w N m Setting w gives the proper transform ^ N on m .
Hence the “local” proper transforms computed above are obtained from the homo geneous proper transform by setting appropriate coordinates equal to .
§5.2. The Total Coordinate Ring
223
Exercises for §5.2. 5.2.1. Prove (5.2.1).
:8 $ $ 8 I <
8
L$$PI
5.2.2. L Show that the total coordinate ring of the weighted projective space P . Hint: See Example 5.1.13. is H where R
O 'P
5.2.3. Prove the claims made about the total coordinate ring of the product O in Example 5.2.2.
I - O
made
5.2.4. Prove the claims made about the class group and the total coordinate ring of the * blowup of O at the origin made in Example 5.2.3.
5.2.5. Let be the toric variety of the fan % and assume as usual that has no torus 8 . Consider a full subfan % is full % / 1 0 % 4 1 9 E % 9 E if factors. A subfan % % % with the property that has no torus factors.
(a) Define the map given by
` H
^ H by sending $ to the point C % F E E
otherwise
-!
Prove that there is a commutative diagram H % /
H
-! %# /
$
where the vertical maps are the quotient maps from Theorem 5.1.10. (b) Explain how part (a) generalizes Proposition 5.2.10.
C{ % * # in H 5.2.6. The quintic 8 0{ %
(c) Use part (a) to give a version of Proposition 5.2.10 that applies to any cone 1 satisfying .
*
1 %
has a unique singular point at the origin. We will resolve the singularity using successive blowups.
>ML
*
(a) Show that the proper transform of this curve in K $H is defined by This uses the homogeneous coordinates from Exercise 5.2.3. : < (b) Show that the proper transform is smooth on but singular on .
$ 8 $
* 8 #
D
.
$ $8 $ , R iZ 'D E \ i E D R 9E E R FE ) 8 $ c^ $ iZ; Z * defines $ $ a toric $ $ ^_H *$ and use this (d) Show that $Z morphism 8$ $ $8 $ * * D. to show that the proper transform of the quintic in H is defined by Z3 8 # (e) Show that the proper transform is smooth by inspecting it in local coordinates. * * IT , (WE an integer. 5.2.7. Adapt the method Exercise 5.2.6 to desingularize 8 5.2.8. Given an ideal in a commutative ring , its Rees algebra is the graded ring L : < $ : <
Z (c) Subdivide 13* to obtain a smooh fan % . The toric variety =has > variables A@N * with where Z corresponds to the ray that subdivides 1e* . Show that
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
224
. There is also the extended Rees algebra : $ < 43 : $ < $ E , so that elements of where for #[D . These rings are graded by letting R $ have degree D . Seeg [13, 4.4] for more< about Rees algebras. (a) When f 8 $ H;: 8 $ < , prove that the extended Rees algebra : $ < is the polynomial ring H;: # 8 $ $ L
where is a new variable and
(b) Prove that the ring of part (a) is isomorphic to the total coordinate ring of the blowup * of H at the origin. (c) Generalize parts (a) and (b) to the case of
f 8 $ $ 8 g H;: 8 $ $ 8 < . I I
§5.3. Sheaves on Toric Varieties
Given a toric variety , we show that graded modules over the total coordinate . We continue to ring
give quasicoherent sheaves on assume that has no torus factors.
u w
z
Graded Modules. The grading on
such that
i
. for all
Definition 5.3.1. An -module
Ei
gives a direct sum decomposition
is graded if it has a decomposition
such that for all is the graded -module satisfying
for all
. Given
, the shift
.
The passage from a graded -module to a quasicoherent sheaf on requires some tools from the proof of Theorem 5.1.10. A cone gives the monomial
, and by (5.1.4), the map induces
an isomorphism where is the localization of at . Since monomials are homogeneous, is also graded by , and its elements of degree are precisely its -invariants (Exercise 5.3.1), i.e., . Hence the above isomorphism becomes
w w
(5.3.1)
;
w w
i
z w
u
; u z
These isomorphisms glue together just as we would hope.
§5.3. Sheaves on Toric Varieties
225
Lemma 5.3.2. Let
be a face of . Then and there is a commutative diagram of isomorphisms
u
/
z
/
u
z
,
, when , and is positive when
. This means that . Taking elements of degree zero commutes with localization, hence . The vertical maps in the diagram come from (5.3.1), and the horizontal maps are localization. In Exercise 5.3.2 you will chase the diagram to show that it commutes.
Proof. Since
From Modules to Sheaves. We now construct the sheaf of a graded module.
m i
Proposition 5.3.3. Let be a graded -module. Then there is a quasicoherent sheaf on such that for every , the sections of over are
m
Proof. Since is a graded -module, it is immediate that is a graded module. Hence is an -module, which induces a sheaf on . The argument of Lemma 5.3.2 applies verbatim to show that
m oqp ts u
Thus the sheaves construction.
z qo p ts
patch to give a sheaf
on
which is quasicoherent by
uw
w z
with the Example 5.3.4. The total coordinate ring of is standard grading where every variable has degree . The quasicoherent sheaf on associated to a graded -module was first described by Serre in his foundational paper Faisceaux alg´ebriques coh´erents [91], called FAC for short.
An important special case is when is a finitely generated graded -module. We will need the following finiteness result to understand the sheaf .
is a finitely generated -module for every . Proof. If " , there is nothing to prove. Otherwise, we can find a monomial w w . Consider rational polyhedral cone { k l for all i { k By Gordan’s Lemma, { is a finitely generated semigroup. Let the gener . Then the monomials ators with last coordinate equal to be w
for generate as a -module (Exercise 5.3.3).
Lemma 5.3.5.
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
226
Here are some coherent sheaves on
Proposition 5.3.6. The sheaf graded -module.
on
.
is coherent when
is a finitely generated
Proof. Because is graded, we may assume its generators are homogeneous of degrees . Given , it follows immediately that is finitely generated over with generators in the same degrees. However, we need to be careful when taking elements of degree . Multiply a generator of degree by (finitely many by the previous lemma). Doing the -module generators of
this for all gives finitely many elements in that generate as an -module (Exercise 5.3.3). It follows that is coherent.
~
Given denoted
. Then:
.
u z , then
is a Weil divisor satisfying
m
Proof. The sections of
m are over
. Since the open cover m of satisfies m
for sheaf axiom gives the exact sequence
(a) There is a natural isomorphism (b) If
, the shifted -module gives a coherent sheaf on . This is a sheaf we already know.
Proposition 5.3.7. Fix
m m , the
w
The localization of all Laurent monomials has a basis consisting of degree such that for all . Then the exact sequence implies
of degree that basis consisting of all Laurent monomials
. These are precisely the monomials in such that for all of degree , which gives the desired isomorphism .
R
w
u z
We turn to part (b). Given a Weil divisor ,
with . By the above we need to construct a sheaf isomorphism description of the sections over , it suffices to prove that for every , we have isomorphisms
m
(5.3.2) compatible with inclusions
m
m Di m
Gi
induced by
in .
§5.3. Sheaves on Toric Varieties
m
227
m
To construct this isomorphism, we apply Proposition 4.3.3 to
A lattice point
w
When
w
for
since
w
w
gives the Laurent monomial
(5.3.3)
to obtain
w
, and in fact
, this monomial lies in
u z
We claim that map induces the desired isomorphism (5.3.2). If map to the same monomial, then
for all . This
since has no torus factors. Furthermore, if implies
such that , so that there is , then is a monomial in , for ,
for all . Since hence . . Then maps to
for This defines an isomorphism (5.3.2) which is easily seen to be compatible with the inclusion of faces. Example 5.3.8. For we have the standard grading by with . Then is the sheaf associated to for . The classes of the toric divisors correspond to , so that
u
z u
``
Thus
l
Also note that when
m
uw
, we have
w w
w z
w
is a canonical model for
z
w
`` . Compare Example 4.3.1.
Thus global sections of are homogeneous polynomials in degree . Compare Example 4.3.6.
w w
of
Sheaves versus Modules. An important result is that all quasicoherent sheaves on come from graded modules. Proposition 5.3.9. Let
be a quasicoherent sheaf on
(a) There is a graded -module (b) If
is coherent, then
. Then:
such that
.
can be chosen to be finitely generated over .
The proof will be given in the appendix to Chapter 6 since it involves tensor products of sheaves from §6.0.
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
228
is surjective (up to isomorphism), it is far from Although the map injective. In particular, there are nontrivial graded modules that give the trivial sheaf. This phenomenon is well-known for , where a finitely generated graded module over gives the trivial sheaf on if and only if for (see [41, Ex. II.5.9]). This is equivalent to
N
uw
w z
w
w
for (Exercise 5.3.4). Since is the irrelevant ideal for , this suggests a toric generalization. In the smooth case, we have the following result.
w
w
be the irrelevant ideal of for a smooth toric Proposition 5.3.10. Let variety , and let be a finitely generated graded -module. Then if and only if for .
m
N
?
N
if and only if it vanishes on each affine open subset Proof. First observe that . But on an affine variety, the correspondence between quasicoherent if and only sheaves and modules is bijective (see [41, Cor. II.5.5]). Hence if for all .
N
w
First suppose that for some . Then , which easily implies that . Then follows from the previous paragraph. This part of the argument works for any toric variety.
u z ~ ~ w w
For the converse, we have for all . Given , we will show that for some , which will imply for , where since is finitely generated. Let . Since is smooth, there such that (this is part for all , we may assume that of the Cartier data for ). Replacing with and observe that . Now set
w
w w
Furthermore, w w
only w Since w involves
w w in , we can find w
for power of . Hence multiplying the above equation by some , as desired.
w l
w
w
w
has degree . Hence which by the definition of localization implies that there is
with
,
w w is a
such that implies
in
w c
for
Unfortunately, the situation is more complicated when is not smooth. Here is an example to show what can go wrong when is simplicial. Example 5.3.11. The weighted projective space has total coordinate ring , where have degree and has degree , and the irrelevant
uw
z
w
§5.4. Homogenization and Polytopes
229
w
. The graded -module ideal is has only elements of odd degree. Then since has degree , and it is clear that . It follows that , yet one easily checks that for all . Thus Proposition 5.3.10 fails for .
w
N l
Exercise 5.3.5 explores a version of Proposition 5.3.10 that applies to simpliis replaced with the weaker cial toric varieties. The condition that . condition that for all
s
N
We will say more about the relation between quasicoherent sheaves and graded -modules in the appendix to Chapter 6.
Exercises for §5.3.
: , prove 8
< , where 8
5.3.1. As described in §5.0, the action of on H induces an=action of on the total ` > j^_H . coordinate ring . Also recall that is a homomorphism (a) Given
8
(b) Show that
( 8 L
and
.
.
and that a similar result holds for the localization
5.3.2. Complete the proof of Lemma 5.3.2.
;: 8 L $ $ 8 < 8 E for all , and let be a finitely generated _D if and only if %# D for _D . 5.3.5. Let be a simplicial toric variety and generated graded D if and only if %# let D beforaallfinitely _D and { % . module. Prove that
5.3.3. Complete the proofs of Lemma 5.3.5 and Proposition 5.3.6. 5.3.4. Let H I whereD forR graded -module. Prove that
5.3.6. Let be a smooth toric variety. State and prove a version of Proposition 5.3.10 that applies to arbitrary graded -modules . Also explain what happens when is simplicial, as in Exercise 5.3.5.
§5.4. Homogenization and Polytopes
The final section of the chapter will explore the relation between torus-invariant divisors on a toric variety and its total coordinate ring. We will also see that when comes from a polytope , the quotient construction of relates nicely to the definition of projective toric variety given in Chapter 2.
Homogenization. When working with affine and projective space, one often needs to homogenize polynomials. This process generalizes nicely to the toric context. The full story involves characters, polyhedra, divisors, sheaves, and graded pieces of the total coordinate ring.
A Weil divisor
on gives the polyhedron for all
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
230
by Proposition 4.3.3, which tells us that the This is linked to the sheaf global sections of are spanned by characters coming from lattice points , i.e., of
This relates to the total coordinate ring
Given , the -homogenization of is the monomial
w
uw
w
defined in (5.3.3). The inequalities defining guarantee that Here are the basic properties of these monomials.
u z
(a) For each
w
z
as follows.
w
Proposition 5.4.1. Assume that has no torus factors. If and is the divisor class of , then:
and
lies in
.
are as above
, the monomial
(b) The map sending the character of induces an isomorphism
lies in
.
to the monomial
w
Proof. Part (a) follows from the proof of Proposition 5.3.7. As for part (b), we use the same proposition to conclude that
One easily sees that this isomorphism is given by
w
.
Here are some examples of homogenization. Example 5.4.2. The fan for has ray generators
and . This gives variables . Since for and divisors for , the character of is the Laurent monomial
.
, has polyhedron For a positive integer , the divisor where is the standard -simplex. Given , its homogenization is
w
R
w `` w
w w ~ ~ ~ w T`` w w w w `` ww with respect to w . which is the usual way to homogenize w
§5.4. Homogenization and Polytopes
231
u z
This monomial has degree , in agreement with Proposition 5.4.1. The proposition also implies the standard fact that monomials . of degree in correspond to lattice points in Example 5.4.3. For , we have ray generators with corresponding variables and divisors . Given nonnegative is the . The polyhedron integers , we get the divisor , and given rectangle with vertices , the
w
w
{
Laurent monomial homogenizes to w w ~ w w ~ w
w
w w w
w
w
which is the usual way of turning a two-variable monomial into a bihomogeneous and monomial of degree (remember that ). Thus monomials of degree correspond to . See Exercise 5.4.1. lattice points in the rectangle
w
w w
w
Example 5.4.4. The fan for is shown in Example 5.1.15, and its total coordinate ring is described in Example 5.2.3. If we pick , is defined by the inequalities then the polyhedron
u w z
l
N
is the first quadrant in and , , the monomial homogenizes to
Since form a basis of . Given
w
w w
w w
correspond to the variables . For example, the singular cubic homogenizes to , which is the equation enountered in Example 5.2.11 when resolving the singularity of this curve.
where the ray generators
N
N
One thing to keep in mind when doing toric homogenization is that characters (in general) or Laurent monomials (in specific examples) are intrinsically defined on the torus or . The homogenization process produces a “global object” relative to a divisor that lives in the total coordinate ring or, via Proposition 5.4.1, in the global sections of . from Proposition 5.4.1 is compatible The isomorphism
w
;
with linear equivalence and multiplication. Let us explain each of these separately. First suppose that and are linearly equivalent torus-invariant divisors. This means that . Proposition 4.0.29 implies for some that induces an isomorphism (5.4.1)
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
232
Turning to the associated polyhedra, we proved , then An easy calculation shows that if
w
w
in Exercise 4.3.2.
(Exercise 5.4.2). Hence (5.4.1) fits into a commutative diagram of isomorphisms
/
PPP PPP P(
(5.4.2)
u z u z
n nnn v nn n
Here, and the “diagonal” maps are the isomorphisms from Proposition 5.4.1. You will verify these claims in Exercise 5.4.2. It follows that gives a “canonical model” for , since the
latter depends on the particular choice of divisor to give a “canonical model” for the polyhedron
u z
Now consider multiplication. Let and . Then and set , in
u z
in the class . It is also possible (Exercise 5.4.3).
be torus-invariant divisors on induces a -linear map
such that the isomorphisms of Proposition 5.4.1 give a commutative diagram
(5.4.3)
/
/
where the bottom map is multiplication in the total coordinate ring (Exercise 5.4.4). Thus homogenization turns multiplication of sections into ordinary multiplication.
Polytopes. A full dimensional lattice polytope Recall that can be constructed in two ways:
As the toric variety
of the normal fan of
As the projective toric variety (Chapter 2).
gives a toric variety
(Chapter 3).
of the set of characters
.
for
We will see that both descriptions relate nicely to homogenenous coordinates and the total coordinate ring.
Given as above, set and let denote set of -dimensional consists of vertices the faces of . Thus and consists of facets. The facet presentation of given in equation (2.2.2) can be written as (5.4.4)
for all
§5.4. Homogenization and Polytopes
In terms of the normal fan
233
, we have bijections
(vertices
(facets
maximal cones)
rays)
When dealing with polytopes we index everything by facets rather than rays. Thus gives: each facet
The facet normal
, which is the ray generator of the corresponding cone.
The torus-invariant prime divisor
The variable
w
.
in the total coordinate ring . We call
We also have the divisor
w
a facet variable.
from (4.2.5). The polytope of this divisor is the polytope we began with (Exercise 4.3.1). Hence, if we set , then we get isomorphisms
u
z
In this situation, we write the homogenization of as
a
We call
w
w
-monomial.
The exponent of the variable in gives the lattice distance from to the facet . To see this, note that lies in the supporting hyperplane defined by . If the exponent of is , then to get from the sup
porting hyperplane to , we must pass through the parallel hyperplanes, namely . Here is an example. for
Example 5.4.5. Consider the toric variety
of the polygon
with vertices
Figure 2. A polygon with facets labeled by variables
, shown in Figure 2. In terms of (5.4.4),
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
234
``
we have , where the indices correspond to the facet variables give -monomials indicated in Figure 2. The 8 points of
where the position of each -monomial corresponds to the position of the lattice point . The exponents are easy to understand if you think in terms of lattice distances to facets.
The lattice-distance interpretation of the exponents in shows that lattice of correspond to those -monomials points in the interior divisible by . For example, the only -monomial in Example 5.4.5 divisible by corresponds to the unique interior lattice point.
``
We next relate the constructions of toric varieties given in Chapter 2 and in §5.1. In Chapter 2, we wrote the lattice points of as and considered the map (5.4.5)
The projective (possibly non-normal) toric variety the image of .
is the Zariski closure of
On the other hand, we have the quotient construction of
. Also, the exceptional set
can be described where we write in terms of the -monomials coming from the vertices of the polytope.
Lemma 5.4.6. The vertex monomials properties:
(a)
irrelevant ideal of . (b)
.
,
, where
a vertex of
, have the following
is the
correspond bijectively to cones Proof. We saw above that vertices . Then the lattice-distance interpretation of shows the facet variables appearing in are precisely the variables appearing in . This implies part (a), and part (b) follows immediately.
as above, then the and give a map
If we set form a basis of (5.4.6)
where
-monomials
denotes the evaluation of the monomial . This map is well-defined since for each
,
,
at the point , Lemma 5.4.6
§5.4. Homogenization and Polytopes
implies that at least one be nonzero.
235
-monomial (in fact, at least one vertex monomial) must
The maps (5.4.5) and (5.4.6) fit into a diagram /
;
; ; ;;; ;; ;; / ;; VVVV VVVV ;; VV
VVVV ;; VVVV VVVV & ;; VV*
;
is described in (5.1.2) and
Here, the map is the quotient map. This diagram has the following properties. Proposition 5.4.7. There is a morphism represented by the dotted arrow in the above diagram that makes the entire diagram commute. Furthermore, the image of is precisely the projective toric variety .
Proof. When we regard the sequence (5.1.1) tells us that
as characters on
(5.4.7)
Multiplying each side by
;
;
, the exact
, we obtain
;
If we let , and apply this to a point in , we see that and give the same point in projective space since times vector for equals the vector for . It follows that, ignoring for the moment, the rest of the above diagram commutes.
We next show that is constant on -orbits. This holds since are homogeneous of the same degree. In more detail, fix points -monomial and a evaluating at gives
where the last equality follows from the description of Arguing as in the previous paragraph, it follows that
-monomials , . Then
given in Lemma 5.1.1. and give the
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
236
same point in . This proves the existence of since is a good categorical quotient, and this choice of makes the entire diagram commute. is the Zariski The final step is to show that the image of closure of the image of . First observe that
since is continuous in the Zariski topology and by commutivity of the diagram. However, since is projective. You is Zariski closed in will give two proofs of this in Exercise 5.4.5, one topological (using constructible sets and compactness) and one algebraic (using completeness and properness). Once we know that implies is Zariski closed,
and
follows.
In Chapter 2, we used the map —construced from characters—to parametrize a big chunk of the projective toric variety . In contrast, Proposition 5.4.7 uses the map —constructed from -monomials—to parametrize all of .
If the lattice polytope is very ample, then the results of Chapter 2 imply that is the toric variety . So in the very ample case, the -monomials give an explicit construction of the quotient by mapping to projective space via the -monomials. It follows that we have two ways to take the quotient of by :
At the beginning of the chapter, we took of —to construct an affine quotient.
-invariant polynomials—elements
Here, we use -monomials—elements of —to construct a projective quo of “bad” points. tient, after removing a set
The -monomials are not -invariant but instead transform the same way under . This is why we map to projective space rather than affine space. We will explore these ideas further in Chapter 14 when we discuss geometric invariant theory. When is very ample, we have a projective embedding given by the -monomials in . If are homogeneous coordinates of , then the homogeneous coordinate ring of is
as in §2.0. We also have the cone ,affine ordinary coordinate ring of i.e.,
of
, and
Recall that
is an -graded ring since
Another -graded ring is
is a homogeneous ideal.
. This relates to
as follows.
is the
§5.4. Homogenization and Polytopes
Theorem 5.4.8. Let Then: (a)
be a very ample lattice polytope with
is normal.
(b) There is a natural inclusion normalization of .
237
such that
.
is the
(c) The following are equivalent: is projectively normal. (1) (2)
(3)
(4)
is normal.
.
is generated as a -algebra by its elements of degree .
Proof. Consider the cone
This cone is pictured in Figure 4 of §2.2. Recall that height . Since the divisor associated to is respect to induces an isomorphism
is the “slice” of at , homogenization with
is dual to , so that the semigroup algebra On the other hand,is the coordinate . Given ring of the affine toric variety , we write the corresponding character as . The algebra is graded using the last coordinate, the “height.” (this is the “slice” observation Since if and only if
made above), we have
Using (5.4.3), we obtain a graded
-algebra isomorphism
is normal. . For this, We next claim that is the normalization of the affine cone we let in the proof of Theorem 2.4.1, is . As noted . Since is very ample, one easily the affine cone of (Exercise 5.4.6). It is also checks that generates , i.e., . Hence clear that generates the cone is the normalization of This proves that
by Proposition 1.3.8. This immediately implies part (b).
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
238
For part (c), we observe that (1) (2) follows from Theorem 2.4.1, and (1) (3) follows from parts (a) and (b) since the projective normality of is (4) is obvious since is equivalent to the normality of . Also (3) generated by the images of , which have degree . Finally, you will show (2), completing the proof. in Exercise 5.4.7 that (4)
Further Examples. We begin with an example of that illustrates how many different polytopes can give the same toric variety.
Example 5.4.9. The toric surface in Example 5.4.5 was defined using the polygon shown in Figure 2. In Figure 3 we see four polygons , all
Figure 3. Four polygons
with the same normal fan
of which have the same normal fan and hence give the same toric variety. Since we are in dimension 2, these polygons are very ample (in fact, normal), so that Theorem 5.4.8 applies. These four polygons give four different projective embeddings, each of which its own coordinate ring as a projective variety. By Theorem 5.4.8, these coordinate rings all live in the total coordinate ring . This explains the “total” in “total coordinate ring.”
Our next example involves torsion in the grading of the total coordinate ring. Example 5.4.10. The fan for has ray generators and
. in for and is the normal fan of the standard simplex Another polytope with the same normal fan is is reflexive in Example 2.4.5. One checks so that . We saw that is a translate that . Since has degree of , (5.4.2) implies that the -monomials for coincide with , which are homogeneous polynomials of the homogenizations coming from . degree in
``
§5.4. Homogenization and Polytopes
Since
is reflexive, its dual
239
is also a lattice polytope. Furthermore ,
since the ray generators of the normal fan of are the vertices of by duality for reflexive polytopes (be sure you understand this—Exercise 5.4.8). The vertices of are
(5.4.8)
The generate a sublattice the map defined by
. In Exercise 5.4.8 you will show that
induces an isomorphism
(5.4.9)
is the diagonal subgroup. It follows that
where is a lattice of index
in
.
, so that
The dual toric variety is determined by the normal fan of . The ray generators of are the vectors from (5.4.8). The only possible with these ray generators is the fan whose cones are generated complete fan in by all proper subsets of . Since and the generate , the toric variety of relative to is , i.e., . (Remember that is a fan in .) Since has index , Proposition 3.3.7 implies that
``
Hence the dual toric variety
is the quotient of by a group of order .
The total coordinate ring is the polynomial ring , graded by . The notation is challenging, since by duality is the character lattice of the torus of . Thus (5.1.1) becomes the short exact sequence
where
is dualizes to
of index
. Now consider the diagram
. If we let
, then
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
240
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
with exact rows and columns. In the middle row, we use . By the snake lemma, we obtain the exact sequence
so
The polytope has only six lattice points in : the vertices the origin (Exercise 5.4.8). When we homogenize these, we get six
since
The equation
``
. Thus the class group has torsion.
and -monomials
(Exercise 5.4.8).
`` ` ` since it is built from -monomials. If we want defines a hypersurface is an irreducible hypersurface, we must have , in which case
isomorphic (via the torus action) to a hypersurface of the form
``
``
This is the quintic mirror family, which played a crucial role in the development of mirror symmetry. See [16] for an introduction to this astonishing subject. Exercises for §5.4.
{ X equivalent torus-invariant divisors with $ be V linearly , then prove that 8 8 T .
5.4.1. Verify the details of Example 5.4.3. 5.4.2. Let
a If
(a) (b) Prove (5.4.2).
.
§5.4. Homogenization and Polytopes
241
! 5.4.3. Fix a torus invariant divisor g V / a ( 4 fa Z for all C 8 . Define
and consider the polyhedron
$ ( ` V ( 3^ a Qf a Z g X +L . by $ embeds V ( as an affine subspace of . Hint: Remember that (a) Prove that
has no torus factors.
(b) Prove that induces a bijection `
4
@
V ( L
L { X . Prove that . Thus the polyhedron in
This realizes as the polyhedron obtained by intersecting the positive orthant of with an affine subspace.
(c) Let constructed in part (b) depends only on the divisor class of model” of .
5.4.4. Prove that the diagram (5.4.3) is commutative.
. This is the“canonical
`
^ O 5.4.5. In the proof of Proposition 5.4.7, we claimed that the image of ` ^ was Zariski closed. This follows from the general fact that if is a morphism of varieties and is projective, then is Zariski closed in . You will prove this two ways. (a) Give a topological proof that uses constructible sets and compactness. Hint: Remember that projective space is compact.
'
(b) Give an algebraic proof that uses completeness and properness from §3.4. Hint: Pro jective implies complete. Show that is proper and consider the graph of ^ .
V
( V be a very ample lattice polytope and letV 5.4.6. Let Prove that N - N . Hint: First show that N in the discussion preceding Proposition 2.1.6.
V - / E 8 V - N . - /D 8 , where N is defined
5.4.7. Prove of (4) (2) in part (c) of Theorem 5.4.8. Hint: (4) implies that is onto for all D.
T
(
5.4.8. This exercise is concerned with Example 5.4.10. (a) Prove that if I is reflexive, then the vertices of normal fan of .
^
are the ray generators of the
g E , where $ Z are defined in Example 5.4.10. Z $ % 3 => $ H 'H # . Use Proposition 1.3.18 to prove / L $ $ 4 7 H $ # $ L Y E 8 @H B V U V (e) Use part (e) and the quotient construction of to give another proof that V V V V O bU U . Also give an explicit description of the action of U on O . V 5.4.9. Here is another way to think about homogenization. Let \ \ be a basis of , $ $ I so that R , E $ $ , are coordinates for the torus . (b) Prove (5.4.9). (c) Prove f (d) Let
Chapter 5. Homogeneous Coordinates
242
8 R
8
(a) Adapt the proof of (5.4.7) to show that when we think of the as characters on $H . V a (b) Given , part (a) tells us that the Laurent monomial can be regarded as a Laurent monomial in the . Show that we can “clear denominators” by multiplying to obtain a monomial in the total coordinate ring . by
8
8
(c) Show that this monomial obtained in part (b) is the homogenization
8
.
5.4.10. Show that of Example 5.4.5 is the blowup of O - O at one => the toric variety point. Compute and find the classes of the four polygons appearing in Figure 3. 9E E E 5.4.11. Consider the reflexive polytope . Work out the analog of Example 5.4.10 for .
$ $ Q = $D $ #\ $ #\b* $ \ #E . 5.4.12. Fix an integer ( E and consider the -simplex In Exercise 2.2.13, we claimed that the toric variety of is the weighted projective space O FE $ E $ E $ . Prove this.
Chapter 6
Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
§6.0. Background: Sheaves and Line Bundles
Sheaves of -modules on a variety were introduced in §4.0. Recall that for , an -module an affine variety gives a sheaf on such that
for all in . Globalizing this leads to quasicoherent sheaves on . These include coherent sheaves, which locally come from finitely generated modules. In this section we develop the language of sheaf theory and discuss vector bundles and line bundles.
The Stalk of a Sheaf at a Point. Since sheaves are local in nature, we need a . This is provided by the notion of method for inspecting a sheaf at a point direct limit over a directed set. Definition 6.0.1. A partially ordered set for all there exists If
is a directed set if
such that
is a family of rings indexed by a directed set
there is a homomorphism
and
such that whenever
satisfying and , then the form a directed system. Let be the submodule of generated by the relations , for and . Then the direct limit is defined as
243
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
244
For every
the elements and generally, two elements diagram
such that
, there is a natural map
and
.
For simplicity, we often write the direct limit as such as [2] write instead of .
. Note also that references
have the same image in are identified in
RRRR R R( m6 m m mmm
such that whenever
,
. More if there is a
Example 6.0.2. Given , the definition of sheaf shows that that the rings of , form a directed system under inclusion, , indexed by neighborhoods and in this case, the direct limit is the local ring . For a quasicoherent sheaf containing of -modules, take an affine open subset so that is the corresponding , where is an -module. If maximal ideal, then is the localization and
where is the localization of
at the maximal ideal .
The term sheaf has agrarian origins: farmers harvesting their wheat tied a rope around a big bundle, and left it standing to dry. Think of the footprint of the bundle as an open set, so that increasingly smaller neighborhoods around a point on the ground pick out smaller and smaller bits of the bundle, narrowing to a single stalk. Definition 6.0.3. The stalk of a sheaf
is
at a point
.
Injective and Surjective. A homomorphism of -modules was defined in §4.0. We can also define what it means for to be injective or surjective. The definition is a bit unexpected, since we need to take into account the fact that sheaves are built to convey local data.
Definition 6.0.4. A sheaf homomorphism
is injective if for any point and open subset containing , there exists an open subset containing , with injective. Also, is surjective if for any
point and open subset containing and any , there is an open subset . containing and such that
§6.0. Background: Sheaves and Line Bundles
245
In Exercise 6.0.1 you will prove that for a sheaf homomorphism
,
defines a sheaf denoted . You will also show that is injective exactly when
. On the other hand, surjectivity of a sheaf the “naive” idea works, i.e., homomorphism need not mean that the maps are surjective for all . Here is an example. , consider the Weil divisor . Example 6.0.5. On , then If we write of with and . Since
;
it follows easily that we have global sections For any
, multiplication by
. Doing this for
gives a sheaf homomorphism gives
In Exercise 6.0.2 you will check that this sheaf homomorpism is surjective. However, when we take global sections, we get
which is clearly not surjective. There is an additional point to make here. Given
,
need not define a sheaf. Fortunately, this can be rectified. Given a presheaf there is an associated sheaf known as the sheafification of , defined by
See [41, II.1] for a proof that
for all with and
and there is for all
is a sheaf with the same stalks as
has a natural sheaf associated to it, denoted
.
. Hence
,
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
246
Exactness. We define exact sequences of sheaves as follows.
Definition 6.0.6. A sequence of sheaves is exact at
if there is an equality of sheaves
The local nature of sheaves is again highlighted by the following result, whose proof may be found in [41, II.1].
Proposition 6.0.7. The sequence in Definition 6.0.6 is exact if and only if is exact for all
.
It follows from Example 6.0.5 that if
(6.0.1)
is a short exact sequence of sheaves, the corresponding sequence of global sections may fail to be exact. However, we always have the following partial exactness, which you will prove in Exercise 6.0.3. Proposition 6.0.8. Given a short exact sequence of sheaves (6.0.1), taking global sections gives the exact sequence
In Chapter 9 we will use sheaf cohomology to extend this exact sequence.
Quasicoherent Sheaves. For an affine variety , an -module gives a quasicoherent sheaf on . This operation preserves exactness, i.e., an exact sequence of -modules
gives an exact sequence of sheaves
(see [41, Prop. II.5.2]). There is a toric version of this result that uses the sheaf from §5.3 associated to a graded -module , where is the total coordinate ring of a toric variety .
Proposition 6.0.9. An exact sequence
-modules gives an exact sequence
of quasicoherent sheaves on
.
of graded
§6.0. Background: Sheaves and Line Bundles
247
Proof. For , the restriction of to is the sheaf associated to
, the elements of degree in the localization of at . Localization preserves exactness, as does taking elements of degree . This proves the desired exactness.
Another example is the following exact sequence of sheaves from §3.0.
Example 6.0.10. A closed subvariety
The sheaf
, defined by
; These are coherent sheaves on
The direct image sheaf
;
, defined by
gives two sheaves:
for
.
.
and are related by the exact sequence
;
Operations on Sheaves of -Modules. Operations on modules over a ring have natural analogs for sheaves of -modules. In particular, given quasicoherent
sheaves , it is easy to show that defines the quasicoherent
via sheaf . We can also define
On the other hand,
In Exercise 6.0.4 you will show that
is a quasicoherent sheaf.
is only a presheaf, so the tensor
is defined to be the sheaf associated to this presheaf. This sheaf product is again quasicoherent and satisfies
whenever
is an affine open set (see [41, Prop. II.5.2]).
Global Generation. For a module over a ring, there is always a surjection from a free module onto . This is true for a sheaf of -modules when is, in a certain sense, large enough.
Definition 6.0.11. A sheaf of -modules is generated by global sections if such that at any point there exists a set , the images of the generate the stalk .
Any global section follows that if is generated by
, there is a surjection of sheaves
gives a sheaf homomorphism
. It
In the next section we will see that when is toric, there is a particularly nice way of determining when the sheaves are generated by global sections.
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
248
Locally Free Sheaves and Vector Bundles. We begin with locally free sheaves.
Definition 6.0.12. A sheaf of exists an open cover
of -modules is locally free of rank r if there such that for all , .
Locally free sheaves are closely related to vector bundles. Definition 6.0.13. A variety there is a morphism
and an open cover
of
is a vector bundle of rank over a variety
if
such that:
(a) For every , there is an isomorphism
by projection onto is . followed (b) For every pair , there is such that the diagram 5 O kk such that
kkkk kkk
SSSS SSS SS )
commutes.
satisfying properties (a) and (b) is called a trivialization. The Data map gives a chart, where for . We call the fiber over . See Figure 1 on the next page.
Since the isomorphisms
given by and are related by the linear map , the fiber has a well-defined vector space structure. Hence a vector bundle really is a “bundle” of vector spaces.
On a vector bundle, the are called transition functions and can be regarded as a family of transition matrices that vary as varies. Just as there is no preferred basis for a vector space, there is no canonical choice of basis for a particular fiber. Note also that the transition functions satisfy (6.0.2)
on on
§6.0. Background: Sheaves and Line Bundles
249
φj: π −1(p) ≅ C r
φi : π−1 (p ) ≅ C r
g ij (p)
Uj × C r
Ui × C r
p
Ui
Uj
X
Figure 1. Visualizing a vector bundle
Definition 6.0.14. A section of a vector bundle over
such that A section
for all
picks out a point
. A section
in each fiber
is a global section. , as shown in Figure 2.
π −1( p) s(p)
s(x)
X p Figure 2. For a section ,
open is a morphism
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
250
We can describe a vector bundle and it global sections purely in terms of the transition functions as follows.
, and assume Proposition 6.0.15. Let be a variety with an affine open cover satisfying the compatibility that for every , we have conditions (6.0.2). Then:
(a) There is a vector bundle whose transition functions are the
of rank , unique up to isomorphism, .
is uniquely determined by a collection of -tuples (b) A global section , such that for all
Proof. One easily checks that the satisfy the gluing conditions from §3.0. It glue together to give a variety . Furfollows that the affine varieties glue together to give a morphism thermore, the projection maps . It follows easily that the open set of corresponding to , which gives an isomorphism . Hence is a is vector bundle with transition functions . . Thus Given a section , is a section of . By Definition 6.0.13, the satisfy the desired compatibility where
condition, and since every global section arises this way, we are done.
Let denote the set of all sections of over . One easily sees that is a sheaf on and in fact is a sheaf of -modules since the fibers are vector spaces. In fact, is an especially nice sheaf.
Proposition 6.0.16. The sheaf of sections of a vector bundle is locally free.
, the proof of Proposition 6.0.15 Proof. For a trivial vector bundle shows that a section is determined by a morphism , i.e., an element of . Thus the sheaf associated to a trivial vector bundle over is . , each For a general vector bundle with trivialization
:: :: :: :
gives an isomorphism of vector bundles
/
Since isomorphic vector bundles have isomorphic sheaves of sections, it follows that if is the sheaf of sections of , then .
§6.0. Background: Sheaves and Line Bundles
251
Line Bundles and Cartier Divisors. Since a vector space of dimension one is a line, a vector bundle of rank is called a line bundle. Despite the new terminology, line bundles are actually familiar objects when is normal.
Theorem 6.0.17. The sheaf of a line bundle.
of a Cartier divisor
is the sheaf of sections
;
; by Proposition 4.0.16. which implies
We use this data to construct a line bundle as follows. Since !; the quotients may be regarded as transition functions. These satisfy . the hypotheses of Proposition 6.0.15 and hence give a line bundle satisfies , so that on , A global section
we have
This shows that
. Then
Proof. Recall from Chapter 4 that a Cartier divisor is locally principal, so that has an affine open cover with , . Thus
is local data for . Note also that
which by part (b) of Proposition 6.0.15 gives a global section of . Conversely, the proposition shows that a global section of the vector bundle gives such that functions . It follows that is independent of . One easily checks that . The same argument works when we restrict to any open subset of . It follows that is the sheaf of sections of .
We will see shortly that this process is reversible, i.e., there is a one-to-one correspondence between line bundles and sheaves coming from Cartier divisors. First, we give an important examples. Example 6.0.18. When we regard as the set of lines through the origin in , each point corresponds to a line . We assemble these lines into a line bundle as follows. Let be homogeneous coordinates on and be coordinates on . Define
as the locus where the matrix
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
252
has rank one. Thus is defined by the vanishing of . Then define the map to be projection on the first factor of . To see that is a line bundle, consider the open subset where is invertible. On the equations defining become
Thus
for all
defines an isomorphism
In other words, is a local coordinate for the line over . Switching to the coordinate system over , we have the local coordinate , which over is related to via
Hence the the transition function from
to
!;
is given by
This bundle is called the tautological bundle on . In Example 6.0.20 below, we will describe the sheaf of sections of this bundle.
Projective spaces are the simplest type of Grassmannian, and just as in this example, the construction of the Grassmannian shows that it comes equipped with a tautological vector bundle. In Exercise 6.0.5 you will determine the transition functions for the Grassmannian .
Invertible Sheaves and the Picard Group. Propositions 6.0.16 and 6.0.17 imply that the sheaf of a Cartier divisor is locally free of rank . In general, a locally free sheaf of rank is called an invertible sheaf.
The relation between Cartier divisors, line bundles and invertible sheaves is described in the following theorem. Theorem 6.0.19. Let
on
be an invertible sheaf on a normal variety
(b) There is a line bundle on (a) There is a Cartier divisor
such that
. Then:
.
whose sheaf of sections is isomorphic to
.
Proof. The part (b) of the theorem follows from part (a) and Proposition 6.0.17. It remains to prove part (a).
Since is irreducible, any nonempty open gives a domain . By Exercise 3.0.4, , so that with field of fractions defines a constant sheaf on , denoted . This sheaf is relevant since defined as a subsheaf of .
is
§6.0. Background: Sheaves and Line Bundles
253
of First assume that is a subsheaf of . Pick an open cover that for every . Over , this gives homomorphisms
Let be the image of . Then that on satisfying .
;
such
. One can show without difficulty
is local data for a Cartier divisor
For the general case, observe that on an irreducible variety, every locally constant sheaf is globally constant (Exercise 6.0.6). Now let be any invertible sheaf on . On a small enough open set , , so that
Thus
is locally constant and hence constant. This easily implies that
, and composing this with the inclusion
expresses
as a subsheaf of .
We note without proof that the line bundle corresponding to an invertible sheaf is unique up to isomorphism. Because of this result, algebraic geometers tend to use the terms line bundle and invertible sheaf interchangeably, even though strictly speaking the latter is the sheaf of sections of the former.
We next discuss some properties of invertible sheaves coming from Cartier divisors. A first result is that if and are Cartier divisors on , then
(6.0.3) This follows because
induces a sheaf homomorpism
which is clearly an isomorphism on any open set where
is trivial.
By standard properties of tensor product, the isomorphism (6.0.3) induces an isomorphism In particular, when
where
, we obtain
and
is the dual of
.
More generally, the tensor of invertible sheaves is again invertible, and if invertible, then is invertible and
This explains why locally free sheaves of rank
are called invertible.
is
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
254
Example 6.0.20. There is a nice relation between the tautological bundle on and the invertible sheaf introduced in Example 4.3.1. Recall that the are all linearly equivalent, and so define isoinvariant divisors on . The local data for the Cartier divisor morphic sheaves, usually denoted
. is easily seen to be , where is the open set where
are given by Thus the transition functions for
These are the inverses of the transition functions for the tautological bundle from Example 6.0.18. It follows that the sheaf of sections of the tautological bundle is .
We can also explain when Cartier divisors give isomorphic invertible sheaves. Proposition 6.0.21. Two Cartier divisors give isomorphic invertible sheaves
if and only if
.
Proof. By Proposition 4.0.29, linearly equivalent Cartier divisors give isomorphic sheaves. For the converse, we begin with the case where . Then
. We show
by contradiction. , so
Assume and pick an irreducible divisor that appears in with positive coefficient. The local ring is a DVR, so we can find , where is the union of all irreducible divisors with . Set with . There are only finitely many such divisors, so that with . Then , and is a nonempty open subset of since vanishes on . However, . This contradiction proves . so that
Now suppose that Cartier divisors satisfy . Tensoring each side with and applying (6.0.3), we see that . If maps to via this isomorphism, then
as subsheaves of . Thus
where the last equality follows from the proof of Proposition 4.0.29. By the
, which clearly implies that previous paragraph, we have .
In Chapter 4, the Picard group was defined as the quotient
§6.0. Background: Sheaves and Line Bundles
255
We can interpret this in terms of invertible sheaves as follows. Given invertible, Theorem 6.0.19 tells us that , which is for some Cartier divisor unique up to linear equivalence by Proposition 6.0.21. Hence we have a bijection
isomorphism classes of invertible sheaves on
The right-hand side has a group structure coming from tensor product of invertible sheaves. By (6.0.3), the above bijection is a group isomorphism. In more sophisticated treatments of algebraic geometry, the Picard group of an arbitrary variety is defined using invertible sheaves. Also, Cartier divisors can be defined on an irreducible variety in terms of local data, without assuming normality (see [41, II.6]), though one loses the connection with Weil divisors. Since most of our applications involve toric varieties coming from fans, we will continue to assume normality when discussing Cartier divisors.
Stalks, Fibers, and Sections. From here on, we will think of a line bundle on as the sheaf of sections of a rank vector bundle . Given a section , we get the following: and . Then Since is a vector bundle of rank , we have the fiber gives . Since is a locally free sheaf of rank , we have the stalk . Then . gives
In Exercise 6.0.7 you will show that these are related via the equivalences
in (6.0.4) generates as an -module
A section
vanishes at
if
in
, i.e., if
.
Basepoints. It can happen that many (sometimes all) sections of a line bundle vanish at a point , called a basepoint. This leads to the following definition.
Definition 6.0.22. A subspace free if and only if for every
As noted earlier, a global section . Thus a subspace
defined by
has no basepoints or is basepoint
. with
gives
gives a sheaf homomorphism
. Then (6.0.4) and Proposition 6.0.7 imply the following.
Proposition 6.0.23. A subspace is surjective.
, there is
has no basepoints if and only if
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
256
of a Cartier divisor For a line bundle on a normal variety, the vanishing locus of a global section has an especially nice interpretation. The local data of gives the rank vector bundle with transition . Hence we can think of a nonzero global section of functions in two ways:
A rational function
;
satisfying
.
. The relation between and is given in the proof of Theorem 6.0.17: over , the . It follows that exactly for
section looks like when . Since
, the divisor of on is given by
A morphism
whose composition with
is the identity on
These patch together in the obvious way, so that the divisor of zeros of is
Thus the divisor of zeros of a global section is an effective divisor that is linearly equivalent to . It is also easy to see that any effective divisor linearly equivalent (Exercise 6.0.8). to is the divisor of zeros of a global section of
In terms of Cartier divisors, Proposition 6.0.23 has the following corollary.
Corollary 6.0.24. The following are equivalent for a Cartier divisor
(a)
is generated by global sections. is basepoint free, meaning that
(b)
(c) For every
there is
:
is basepoint free.
with
.
The Pullback of a Line Bundle. Let be a line bundle on and the associated rank vector bundle. A morphism gives the fibered product from §3.0 that fits into the commutative diagram
;
;
;
/
It is easy to see that
is a rank
;
/
vector bundle over
Definition 6.0.25. The pullback of the sheaf the rank vector bundle defined above.
;
.
is the sheaf of sections of
Thus the pullback of a line bundle is again a line bundle. Furthermore, there is a natural map on global sections
;
;
§6.0. Background: Sheaves and Line Bundles
defined as follows. A global section
gives the commutative diagram:
/
;
"
/
$
;
257
/
;
The universal property of fibered products guarantees the existence and uniqueness of the dotted arrow that makes the diagram commute. It . follows that Example 6.0.26. Let be a projective variety. If we write the inclusion as gives the line bundle , then the line bundle
;
;
;
Thus a projective variety always comes equipped with a line bundle. However, it is not unique, since the same variety may have many projective embeddings. You will work out an example of this in Exercise 6.0.9.
In general, given a sheaf of -modules on and a morphism , one gets a sheaf of -modules on . The definition is more complicated, so we refer the reader to [41, II.5] for the details.
;
Line Bundles and Maps to Projective Space. We now reverse Example 6.0.26 by using a line bundle on to create a map to projective space. with no basepoints and let Fix a finite-dimensional subspace be its dual. The projective space of is
If
is a basis of
(6.0.5)
, then
;
gives an isomorphism
, fix To define and pick with
. For . Then the map defined , there is such that by is linear and nonzero since has no base points. Thus , and since is unique up to an element of , the same is true for . Then
defines the desired map
Lemma 6.0.27. The map
;
.
is a morphism.
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
258
. These Proof. Let be a basis of and let open sets cover since has no basepoints. Furthermore, the natural map
is easily seen to be an isomorphism. Since all sections of , it follows that for all
for form , . write
are of the , we can
The definition of uses a nonzero vector , we can . Over . Then implies . It use follows that is the morphism
(6.0.6) When has no basepoints and span , is often written (6.0.7)
. with the understanding that this means (6.0.6) on
Furthermore, when rational functions such that (6.0.8)
, we can think of the global sections as
. Then can be written may be undefined, this needs explanation. The local data Since of . Then (6.0.8) means that implies that is This is a morphism on since the global sections corresponding to have no base points.
Exercises for §6.0. 6.0.1. For a sheaf homomorphism
`
^ , show that c;^
defines a sheaf. Also prove that the following are equivalent: (a) The kernel sheaf is identically zero. (b) (c)
is injective for every open subset
.
is injective as defined in Definition 6.0.4.
% : B % : A ^ % : is surjective.
6.0.2. In Example 6.0.5, prove that Prove that
%
6.0.3. Prove Proposition 6.0.8. c^ 6.0.4. Prove that show that it is quasicoherent when
$ ) are.
$
defines a sheaf
a
$ and
§6.0. Background: Sheaves and Line Bundles
259
$ + $ ) $ $ LL * * *'H . Then define up to left multiplication by elements of + F E $ - H to consist of all pairs $ such that $ . (a) A pair gives the matrix $ LLL ** 4 & * Prove that ) is a point of + if and only if the maximal minors of vanish. This $ shows that + 9E - H is a closed subvariety. $ ` + ^ F E . Explain why the (b) Projection onto the first factor gives a morphism $ fiber over 7 9 E is the 2-dimensional subspace of H corresponding to . $ (c) Given D # # , define / F E $ 4 D 8 Prove that @H and that the give an affine open cover of 9 E . $ , let #%$ be the complementary indices, i.e., / $ 8 (d) Given D( # !" # $$ $ /D $ E $ ) $ 8 . Prove that the map $ c^ $ $ '&! gives an isomorphism );( ^ - H * (e) By part (d), + is a vector bundle over F E . Determine its transition functions. $ 6.0.5. The Grassmannian 9E is defined as the space of lines in O , or equivalently, of 2-dimensional subspaces of H . This exercise will construct the tautological bundle on FE , which assembles these 2-dimensional subspaces into a rank vector bundle over FE . A point of FE corresponds to a full rank matrix
6.0.6. Prove that a locally constant sheaf on an irreducible variety is constant. 6.0.7. Prove (6.0.4).
%
6.0.8. Prove that any effective divisor linearly equivalent to a Cartier divisor divisor of zeros of a global section of ' .
` : O ^ * * % ,+ % .
6.0.9. Let
9E
2 `!
O
is the
be the Veronese mapping from Example 2.3.14. Prove that
- 2'.-
6.0.10. Let ^ be a morphism and let be a line bundle on that is generated by global sections. Prove that the pullback line bundle is generated by global sections.
2 $
. 8 give effective divisors X { @2 . % $ b / D , 7 H .$ $ Prove that these divisors are equal if and only if 2 (b) The complete linear system of is defined to be =0/ { 4 $ ( D 8 4 G4 /
6.0.11. Let (a)
be a Cartier divisor on a complete normal variety
X
{
on
.
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
260
Thus the complete linear system of consists of all effective Cartier divisors on linearly equivalent to . Use part (a) to show that 4 G4 can be identified with the projective space of
' , i.e., there is a natural bijection
. $ % 4 4 O . $ % ' ) . $ % $ - /bD 8 U H . % ' . Then O can (c) Assume that has no basepoints and set $ be identified 4 G4 . Prove that the morphism
` with the set hyperplanes in O !" by ^hO is given / ]4 4 4 7 # ",,' 8 04 G4
§6.1. Ample Divisors on Complete Toric Varieties Our aim in this section is to determine when a Cartier divisor on a complete toric variety gives a projective embedding. We will use the key concept of ampleness.
Definition 6.1.1. Let we noted in §4.3,
be a Cartier divisor on a complete normal variety is finite-dimensional.
. As
has no (a) The divisor are very ample when and the line bundle basepoints and is a closed embedding. and is very ample for some integer . (b) are ample when
Our discussion will tie together concepts from earlier sections, including:
The very ample polytopes from Definition 2.2.16.
The polyhedra
from Proposition 4.3.3.
The support functions of Cartier divisors from Theorem 4.2.12.
We will see that support functions give a simple, elegant characterization of when is ample, as well as when is basepoint free.
of a complete fan in Basepoint Free Divisors. Consider the toric variety and let . By be a torus-invariant Cartier divisor on Propositions 4.3.3 and 4.3.8, we have the global sections
where
is the polytope defined by
We first study when being Cartier means that for every (6.1.1)
for all
is basepoint free. Recall from §4.2 that , there is with
Furthermore, is uniquely determined by the Cartier data complete. Then we have the following preliminary result.
since
is
§6.1. Ample Divisors on Complete Toric Varieties
261
Proposition 6.1.2. The following are equivalent: (a)
(b)
has no basepoints, i.e.,
for all
is generated by global sections.
.
. Proof. First suppose that is generated by global sections and take The -orbit corresponding to is a fixed point of the -action, and by the Orbit-Cone Correspondence,
By Corollary 6.0.24, there is a global section such that is not in the support of the divisor of zeros of . Since is spanned by for . The , we can assume that is given by for some discussion preceding Corollary 6.0.24 shows that the divisor of zeros of is
The point is not in the support of yet lies in for every . This
. Since is -dimensional, we conclude that forces for .
. Since For the converse, take global section whose divisor of zeros is one sees that the support of misses cover . Then we are done since the
, the character gives a . Using (6.1.1), , so that is nonvanishing on .
Later in the section we will improve this result by showing that (b) is equivalent , are the vertices of . This will to the stronger condition that the , imply in particular that is a lattice polytope when is basepoint free. We will also relate Proposition 6.1.2 to the convexity of the corresponding support function.
If is generated by global sections, we can write the corresponding map to projective space as follows. Suppose that The characters
span
(6.1.2)
, so that we can write
as
See (6.0.8) for a careful description of what this means. When we restrict to the torus , is the map (2.1.2). Hence our general theory relates nicely with the more concrete approach used in Chapter 2. Example 6.1.3. The fan for the Hirzebruch surface is shown in Figure 3 on the next page. Let be the divisor corresponding to . We will study the divisors
and
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
262
u1 = (−1,2) σ4 σ1
u2
σ3
u3 u4
Figure 3. A fan
For , let Figure 4 shows
1
σ2
< with
m2
m3
m′2
1
PD 2
2 m′4
Figure 4.
and
m′1
(left) and
Very Ample Polytopes. Let with facet presentation
and
This picture and Proposition 6.1.2 make it clear that is not.
(right)
is basepoint free while
(6.1.3)
corresponds to a maximal cone
Proposition 4.2.10 implies that when .
for all facets
a full dimensional lattice polytope
This gives the complete normal fan and the toric variety A vertex
m′3 PD′
m1 = m4
correspond to , and similarly for we have and (right) (see also Exercise 4.3.5).. and (left) and
. Write
is Cartier since
§6.1. Ample Divisors on Complete Toric Varieties
263
Recall from Definition 2.2.16 that is very ample if for every vertex , the semigroup is saturated in . The definition of given in Chapter 2 used very ample polytopes. This is no accident.
Proposition 6.1.4. Let (a)
be as above. Then:
is ample and basepoint free.
(b) If
, then
is very ample for every
is very ample if and only if
(c)
and
.
is a very ample polytope.
Proof. First observe that the polytope of the divisor is the polytope we began with. Thus is basepoint free by Proposition 6.1.2, which proves the final assertion of part (a). Furthemore, by (6.1.2), the map factors
where is the projective toric variety of understand when is an isomorphism. Fix coordinates of and let
from §2.3. We need to
be the set of in dices such that is a vertex of . Hence each gives a vertex and a corresponding maximal cone in the normal fan of . If , then for every facet containing . For all other facets , . Hence, if is the global section corresponding to , consists of those then the support of divisors missing the of . It follows that is the nonvanishing affine open toric variety locus of . Under the map maps to the affine open subset where , this . nonvanishing locus and , it Since suffices to study the maps
of affine toric varieties. By Proposition 2.1.8,
Since
by (6.1.3), we have an inclusion of semigroups
This is an equality precisely when is saturated in , we obtain the equivalences:
. Since
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
264
is an isomorphism
is an isomorphism for all is an isomorphism for all is saturated for all is very ample.
is very ample
This proves part (c) of the proposition. For part (b), recall that if and by Corollary 2.2.18. Hence is arbitrary, then is very ample when is very ample. This implies that is ample (the case is trivial), which completes the proof of part (a).
Example 6.1.5. In Example 2.2.10, we showed that
is not normal. We show that is not very ample as follows. From Chapter 2 we know that the only lattice points of are its vertices, so that . Since is singular (Exercise 6.1.1) of dimension 3, it follows that cannot and be a closed embedding. Hence and are not very ample. However, are very ample by Proposition 6.1.4.
Support Functions and Convexity. Let be a Cartier divisor on a is complete toric variety . As in Chapter 4, its support function determined by the following properties:
for all
This is where the for is given by
is linear on each cone
. .
from (6.1.1) appear naturally, since the explicit formula for all .
When is a rank two lattice, it is easy to visualize the graph of : imagine a tent, with centerpole extending from down the -axis, and tent stakes placed at positions . Here is an example. Example 6.1.6. Take and consider the divisor . This gives the support function where for the four ray generators . The graph of is shown in Figure 5 on the of the fan of next page. This should be visualized as an Egyptian pyramid, with base vertices at
and apex at the origin.
The first key concept of this section was ampleness. The second is convexity, which we now define.
§6.1. Ample Divisors on Complete Toric Varieties
265
u2 u1
u3 u4 (u2 ,−1)
(u 1,−1)
(u3 ,−1)
(u4 ,−1)
Figure 5. The graph of
Definition 6.1.7. Let
for all
and
be convex. A function
is convex if
.
is convex exactly if Continuing with the tent analogy, a support function there are unimpeded lines of sight inside the tent. It is clear that for Example 6.1.6, the support function is convex.
The following lemma will help us understand what it means for a support func , a cone is called a tion to be convex. Given a fan in , i.e, when wall when it is the intersection of two -dimensional cones
forms the wall separating and .
Lemma 6.1.8. The following are equivalent for a support function
(a)
(b) (c)
for all
is convex.
(d) For every wall
and
for all
, there is
.
. with
.
.
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
266
. Given Proof. First assume (a) and fix in the interior of
can find . By convexity, we have such that
This easily implies
, we
, proving (b). The implication (b) (c) is for , and (c) (a) follows because the immediate since minimum of a finite set of linear functions is always convex (Exercise 6.1.2).
Since (b) fix a wall
(d) is obvious, it remains to prove the converse. Assume (d) and . Then lies on one side of the wall. We claim that when are on the same side of
(6.1.4)
. If , the wall is defined by This is obvious if and then (d) implies that the side containing is defined by This proves (6.1.4).
Now take line segment in Figure 6.
,
.
. We can pick in the interior of so that the and intersects every wall of in a point. This gives the picture shown
wall
wall
wall
Figure 6. Crossing walls from to along
Using (6.1.4) repeatedly, we obtain
When we arrive at the cone containing . This proves (b).
, the pairing becomes
, so that
In terms of the tent analogy, part (b) of the lemma means that if we have a convex support function and extend one side of the tent in all directions, the rest of the tent lies below the resulting hyperplane, and part (d) means that it suffices to check this locally where two sides of the tent meet. The proof of our main result about convexity will use the following lemma that describes the polyhedron of a Cartier divisor in terms of its support function. Lemma 6.1.9. Let Then
be a fan and
be a Cartier divisor on
for all
.
§6.1. Ample Divisors on Complete Toric Varieties
Proof. Assume
for all
267
. Applying this with
so that by the definition of . For the opposite inclusion, take
. Then and . Thus , so that ,
where the inequality follows from the defining properties of .
gives
, and the last two equalities follow from
We now expand Proposition 6.1.2 to give a more complete characterization of when a divisor is basepoint free. Theorem 6.1.10. Assume Cartier divisor
(c)
(d) (e) (f) (g)
is complete and let be the support function of a . Then the following are equivalent:
on
free. is basepoint for all . . is the set of vertices of . for all . . for all
(a) (b)
is convex.
Proof. The equivalences (a) (b) and (f) (g) were proved in Proposition 6.1.2 and Lemma 6.1.8. Furthermore, Lemmas 6.1.8 and 6.1.9 imply that for all is convex
This proves (g)
for all
(b), so that (a), (b), (f) and (g) are equivalent.
and . Combining Assume (b). Then these with Lemma 6.1.9, we obtain proving (e). The implication (e) (g) follows since the minimum of a compact set of linear functions is convex (Exercise 6.1.2). So (a) (b) (e) (f) (g).
Consider (d). The implications (d) (c) (b) are clear. For (b) (d), take . Let be in the interior of and set . By Exercise 6.1.3, and is a supporting hyperplane of
(6.1.5)
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
268
This implies that is a vertex of . Conversely, let
be a supporting . This means , with hyperplane of a vertex for all . Since (b) holds, we also have (e) and (f). By (e), equality if and only if Combining this with (f), we obtain
Hence
must occur for some
.
, which forces
Example 6.1.11. In Example 6.1.3 we studied the Hirzebruch surface for and is basepoint free while showed that is not. Theorem 6.1.10 gives a different proof using support functions. Figure 7 shows the graph of the support function . In the figure, we have slightly distorted the position of
(u3 ,0) (u ,0)
(u 2,0)
4
(u 4,−1)
(u1 ,0)
Figure 7. The graph of
(which should really be closer to ) to make things easier to visualize. Notice that the portion of the “roof” containing the points and the origin lies
, and it is clear that for , there are unimpeded lines of sight in the plane within the tent. In other words, is convex.
The support function is shown in Figure 8 on the next page. Here, the line
, yet the ridgeline of the tent of sight from to lies in the plane
. Hence going from the apex at the origin to lies below the plane this line of sight does not lie inside the tent, so that is not convex.
When is basepoint free, Theorem 6.1.10 implies that the vertices of are . One caution is that in general, the need not the lattice points ,
§6.1. Ample Divisors on Complete Toric Varieties
269
(u3 ,0) (u2 ,0)
(u4 ,0)
(u2 ,−1) (u4 ,−1) (u1 ,0)
Figure 8. The graph of
<
can have be distinct, i.e., . An example is given by the divisor considered in Example 6.1.3—see Figure 4. As we will see later, this behavior illustrates the difference between basepoint free and ample.
also happen that has strictly smaller dimension than the dimension It .can of You will work out a simple example of this in Exercise 6.1.4.
The Normal Fan of a Basepoint Free Divisor. When has no base is a lattice polytope with the , , as vertices. points, Here we study the relation between and the normal fan of . Since may fail to be full dimensional, we need to explain what we mean by normal fan. Consider
struction of
. The inclusion since is saturated in .
induces a surjective
, we get a full dimensional lattice by a lattice point of is the normal fan of . The con . Then . Hereinis the key is independent of how we translate assertion.
Proposition 6.1.12. Let . If with polytope normal fan , then
with dual homomorphism
Translating polytope
be a basepoint free Cartier divisor on is a vertex and is the corresponding cone in the
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
270
Proof. We first give an alternate description of normal fans in §2.3, we saw that the vertex
whose dual in have whose dual in
is
. In the discussion of gives the cone
This has some nice consequences. First, since
(6.1.6)
and
. Since
is
, we also
is strongly convex, (6.1.6) implies that . It follows is a closed convex cone of dimension in that the proposition is equivalent to the assertion , (6.1.7) for all implies where “ ” denotes the interior (Exercise 6.1.5). satisfies A second consequence of (6.1.6) is that any
for all
for for all
We now prove (6.1.7). Assume element of the intersection. Since
In particular, basepoint free implies (6.1.8)
for some
, so that
and let , we have
be an
by convexity and part (b) of Lemma 6.1.8. Combining this with (6.1.8), we see that for all Since , proving (6.1.7). is open, this forces
This proposition has some nice geometric consequences, as we will see below.
Ampleness and Strict Convexity. We next determine when a Cartier divisor of is ample. The Cartier data satisfies on for all
Definition 6.1.13. The support function convex if it is convex and for every
of a Cartier divisor on satisfies
There are many ways to think about strict convexity.
is strictly
§6.1. Ample Divisors on Complete Toric Varieties
271
Lemma 6.1.14. The following are equivalent for the support function
(a)
is strictly convex. for all
(b)
(c) For every wall
(e) (f) (g)
, there is
and
when is convex and when is convex and for all
(d)
in
in
. with
and for all
and
.
.
is a wall.
.
.
not contained in the same
cone of .
Proof. You will prove this in Exercise 6.1.6. We now relate strict convexity to ampleness. is the support function of a Cartier divisor Theorem 6.1.15. Assume that . Then on a complete toric variety
Furthermore, if
is ample and
is strictly convex.
is ample, then
is very ample for all
.
Proof. First suppose that is very ample. Very ample divisors have no basepoints, so is convex by Theorem 6.1.10. If strict convexity fails, then Lemma 6.1.14 with
implies that has a wall
. Let . can be written Let , so that
for some . We will study as in (6.1.2). In this enumeration, . on the open subset . Theorem 6.1.10 implies that , so that the section First consider by the proof of Proposition 6.1.2. It corresponding to is nonvanishing on follows that on , is given by is the open subset where . where , the same argument works on . This gives a morphism Since q Since is a wall, are the only -dimensional cones of containing . Hence
by the Orbit-Cone Correspondence. Note also since is a wall. Since
is complete, Proposition 4.3.8 implies that all morphisms from
to affine
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
272
space are constant. Thus maps to a point, which is impossible since very ample. Hence is strictly convex when is very ample.
is
. Thus is very ample for If is ample, then strictly convex, which easily implies that is strictly convex.
must be
For the converse, assume is strictly convex. We claim that is the given fan full dimensional lattice polytope whose normal fan from Proposition 6.1.12 that the sublattice gives the dual such that is a fan in .
is a . Recall
Since is strictly convex, the are distinct by Lemma 6.1.14. Hence, given a vertex , the union of Proposition 6.1.12 reduces to when The right-hand side is strongly convex, while the left hand side contains . Hence the kernel is zero, so is full dimensional and , . Thus
when In other words, is the normal fan of , as claimed. Then , i.e., one easily sees that is the divisor associated to ample by Proposition 6.1.4.
, and . Hence is
The final assertion of the theorem also follows from Proposition 6.1.4. Here is a corollary of the proof of Theorem 6.1.15. Corollary 6.1.16. If is the normal fan of
is ample, then is a full dimensional lattice polytope, . , and is the Cartier divisor associated to
We have the following nice result in the smooth case.
Theorem 6.1.17. On a smooth complete toric variety and only if it is very ample.
, a divisor
is ample if
Proof. If is ample, then Corollary 6.1.16 shows that is the normal fan of . Since is very ample by Theoand is the divisor of is smooth, rem 2.4.3 and Proposition 2.4.4. Then we are done by Proposition 6.1.4.
Computing Ample Divisors. Given a wall
. Then a Cartier divisor (6.1.9)
, write
and pick
gives the wall inequality
Lemma 6.1.14 and Theorem 6.1.15 impy that the wall inequality (6.1.9) for every wall of .
is ample if and only if it satisfies
In terms of divisor classes, recall the map kernel consists of divisors of characters. If we fix
whose , then we have an
§6.1. Ample Divisors on Complete Toric Varieties
isomorphism
273
for all
(Exercise 6.1.7). Then (6.1.9) gives inequalities for determining when a divisor class is ample. Here is a classic example. Example 6.1.18. Let us determine the ample divisors on the Hirzebruch surface is shown in Figure 3 of Example 6.1.3, and this becomes the . The fan for . Hence we have ray generators fan for by redefining to be , then and maximal cones . If we set
(Note that every Weil divisor is Cartier since is smooth.) To determine when , we compute to be
Then (6.1.9) gives four wall inequalities which reduce to . Thus is ample (6.1.10)
For an arbitrary divisor
show that
is ample
, the relations
. Hence
Sometimes ampleness is easier to check if we think geometrically in terms of support functions. For , look back at Figure 6 and imagine moving the vertex at downwards. This gives the graph of , which is strictly convex when .
Here is an example of how to determine ampleness using support functions. as its has the eight orthants of Example 6.1.19. The fan for . Take the positive orthant maximal cones, and the ray generators are and subdivide further by adding the new ray generators
We obtain a complete fan by filling the first orthant with the cones in Figure 9 on with the plane the next page, which shows the intersection of . You will check that is smooth in Exercise 6.1.8. Let for
be a Cartier divisor on . Replacing with satisfies , we can assume that
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
274
e3
c d a
b
e1
e2
lying in
Figure 9. Cones of
Now observe that . Since and do not lie in a cone of , part (g) of Lemma 6.1.14 implies that
and generate a cone of , so that
However,
Together, these imply
. By symmetry, we obtain
an impossibility. Hence there are no strictly convex support functions. This proves that is a smooth complete nonprojective variety.
The Toric Variety of a Basepoint Free Divisor. We now return to the case of a basepoint free Cartier divisor . In on a complete toric variety the discussion leading up to Proposition 6.1.12, we defined the normal fan . The proposition explains how cones with of are combined to give the cones of . The normal fan gives the toric variety .
Before we can relate to , we need the following general fact about the pullback of a torus-invariant Cartier divisor by a toric morphism.
Proposition 6.1.20. Assume that is the toric morphism induced by , and let be a torus-invariant Cartier divisor with support . Then there is a unique torus-invariant Cartier divisor function with the following properties: on
;
(b) The support function
(a)
.
is the composition
§6.1. Ample Divisors on Complete Toric Varieties
275
now refers to an Proof. Let the local data of be , where arbitrary cone of . Recall that the minus sign comes from when
. Then the proof of Theorem 6.0.17 shows that is the sheaf of sections of a rank vector bundle with transition functions
Now take be the smallest cone satisfying and let , we set Using the dual map
;
; , one can show without difficulty that !; is the local data for a Cartier divisor
Since
.
Then straightforward to verify that
. It is on has the required properties (Exercise 6.1.9).
In the situation of Propositon 6.1.20, we say that . We now prove that a Cartier divisor on divisor pullback an ample divisor divisor on .
is the pullback of the without basepoints is the
Theorem 6.1.21. Let be a basepoint free Cartier divisor on a complete toric . Then there variety, and let be the toric variety of the polytope is a proper toric morphism such that is linearly equivalent to the pullback of an ample divisor on .
Proof. As in the discussion preceding Proposition 6.1.12, we have the sublattice so that it lies in , with dual . When we translate , the divisor changes by a linear equivalence. Then, given a vertex Proposition 6.1.12 implies
This implies that is compatible with the fans in and in and hence induces a toric morphism is proper since gives the ample, which and are complete. The polytope divisor on , and it follows that is the pullback of (Exercise 6.1.10).
, the cones and their Note that as we range over all vertices faces satisfy the conditions for being a fan, except that they may fail to be strongly convex. But they all contain the same maximal subspace, namely the kernel of . This is an example of what is called a degenerate fan. Once we mod out by the kernel, we get the genuine fan .
Here are two examples to illustrate what can happen in Theorem 6.1.21.
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
276
Example 6.1.22. While the toric variety of Example 6.1.19 has no ample divisors, it does have basepoint free divisors. The ray generators of are
with corresponding toric divisors
Then one can show that
is basepoint free (Exercise 6.1.8). Thus the support function is convex. is a union of three cones Figure 9 in Example 6.1.19 shows that
and
of . Using , one sees (Exercise 6.1.8). Hence we should combine that these three cones all have . these three cones. The same thing happens in and
e3
d
e1
e2
Figure 10. Combined cones of lying in
Thus, in the first orthant, the fan of looks like Figure 10 when intersected with . Hence is the blowup of at the point corresponding to the first orthant (Exercise 6.1.8). Note also that is a proper birational toric morphism since refines the fan of .
Example 6.1.23. Consider the divisor on the Hirzebruch surface , where we are using the notation of Example 6.1.3. For this divisor, the four cones of this fan give
is a line segment. When we combine and , Figure 3 from so that Example 6.1.3 shows that we get a degenerate fan. To get a genuine fan, we col lapse the vertical axis and obtain the fan for . Here, is the toric morphism from Example 3.3.5.
§6.1. Ample Divisors on Complete Toric Varieties
277
The Toric Chow Lemma. Recall from Chapter 3 that if is a refinement of , then there is a proper birational toric morphism . We close by proving is nonprojective (as in Example 6.1.19), then has the Toric Chow Lemma: if a refinement with projective.
Theorem 6.1.24. A complete fan
Proof. Suppose is a fan in the complete fan obtained from
has a refinement
. Let
such that
be obtained from
is projective.
by considering
So for each wall , we take the entire hyperplane spanned by the wall. This yields a subdivison with the property that
i.e., each hyperplane this way.
Choosing
by
Note that takes integer values on explains the minus sign).
is a union of walls of
so that
define the map
, and all walls of
arise
and is convex by the triangle inequality (this
Let us show that is piecewise linear with respect to . Fix and note that each cone of is contained in one of the closed half-spaces bounded by . This implies that is linear on each cone of . Hence the same is true for .
Finally, we prove that is strictly convex. Suppose that is a wall . Then . We label and so that ,
in
in The sum in is linear on , so is represented by different linear functions on each side of the wall . Since is convex, it is strictly convex by Lemma 6.1.14. Then is projective since
is ample by Theorem 6.1.15. of
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
278
In Chapter 11 we will improve this result by showing that to be smooth and projective. Exercises for §6.1. 6.1.1. Show that the toric variety
' %{
in Example 6.1.5 is singular. a ( be a compact set and define 6.1.2. Let by iZ f Explain carefully why the minimum exists and prove that is convex.
V
of the polytope
can be chosen
` & ( ^
$Z
g
.
a supporting hyperplane
is D . Then show a
6.1.3. Let be as in the proof of (b) (d). Prove that of that satisfies (6.1.5). Hint: Write Z Z , g g a a implies f Z f Z $Z .
$
$ ("
C{ %
6.1.4. As noted in the text, the polytope of a basepoint free Cartier divisor on a com plete toric variety can have dimension strictly less than . Here are some examples. (a) Let be one of the four torus-invariant prime divisors on O - O . Show that is a line segment. (b) Consider iO I and fix an integer with D . Find a basepoint free divisor on iO I such that . Hint: See Exercise 6.1.12 below.
C{ %
F
6.1.5. Prove (6.1.7). 6.1.6. This exercise is devoted to proving that the statements (a)–(g) of Lemma 6.1.14 are equivalent. Many of the implications use Lemma 6.1.8. (a) Prove (a) (b) and (c) (d). (b) Prove (b) (c) Prove (c)
(e) and (b) (f) (c). (b) by adapting the proof of (d)
(b) from Lemma 6.1.8.
(d) Prove (b) (g) and use the obvious implication (e) the lemma.
0/ { { % 0/ { .
(d) to complete the proof of
, . Prove that { % L
6.1.7. Let be = the toric % in & ( @ I and fix 1 variety of a fan the natural map induces an isomorphism j^ = L 46 D for all C 1 9E ,@
%
6.1.8. This exercise deals with Examples 6.1.19 and 6.1.22. (a) Prove that the toric variety of Example 6.1.19 is smooth.
) X ) X ) X X X X X \ $ \ * $ \ $ )\ $ )\ * $ )\ $ )\ )\ * $ )\ ) \ $ )\ * ) \ $ )\ )\ * )\ and conclude that is basepoint free.
* be the divisor defined in (b) Let Example 6.1.22. Prove that is the polytope with 10 vertices
(c) In Example 6.1.22, we asserted that certain maximal cones of % must be combined to get the maximal cones of % . Prove that this is correct. (d) Show that is the blowup of iO at the point corresponding to the first orthant.
6.1.9. Complete the proof of Proposition 6.1.20. 6.1.10. Complete the proof of Proposition 6.1.21.
§6.2. The Nef and Mori Cones
279
{ % and describe which torus* is the toric variety of the smooth complete fan % in with X % FE /4 \ $ \*$\ \*8 >
6.1.11. For the following toric varieties , compute invariant divisors are ample and which are basepoint free. (a)
(b)
is the blowup K
$O I of O I
at a fixed point of the torus action.
is the toric variety of the fan % from Exercise 3.3.9. See Figure 12 from Chapter 3. is the toric variety of the fan obtained from the fan of Figure 12 from Chapter 3 by combining the two upward pointing cones.
(c) (d)
$ $ \ I . Let X $ $ I denote I '#T T . X (a) Show that is basepoint free if and only if T ( D for all . X D for all . (b) Show that is ample if and only if T 6.1.13. Let be an ample divisor on a complete toric variety . Define = $Z 4bC G% FE &2( - 1
6.1.12. The toric variety iO I has ray generators \ the corresponding torus-invariant divisors. Consider
(a) Prove that 1 is strongly convex.
$
(b) Prove that the boundary of 1 is the graph of the support function . V (c) Prove that % is the set of cones obtained by projecting proper faces of 1 onto
(
.
§6.2. The Nef and Mori Cones In the last section, we saw that there are simple criteria which determine when a Cartier divisor is basepoint free or ample. We now study the structure of the set of basepoint free divisors and the set of ample divisors inside .
The main concept of this section is that of numerical effectivity. Roughly speaking, the goal is to define a pairing between divisors and curves, such that for a divisor and curve on a variety , the number counts the number of points of , with appropriate multiplicity. Example 6.2.1. Suppose with homogeneous coordinates , and let and and meet at the single point . Then
, where they share a common tangent. If we replace with the linearly equivalent divisor , then clearly and meet in two points. This suggests that the point should be counted twice, since it is a tangent point. Hence we should have .
Despite this encouraging example, there are several technical hurdles to overcome in order to make this precise in a general setting. Note that in , two lines may or may not meet, so to get a reasonable theory, we will work with complete curves on a normal variety . We also need to restrict to Cartier divisors on . With these assumptions, the intersection product should possess the following properties:
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
280
. when . is finite. Assume each Let be a prime divisor on that is smooth in , , andsuch and that the tangent spaces meet transversely. Then . from Note that these properties give a rigorous proof of the computation
Example 6.2.1.
The Degree of a Line Bundle. The key tool we will use is the notion of the degree of a divisor on an irreducible smooth complete curve . Such a divisor can be written as a finite sum where and .
be a divisor on an irreducible smooth complete
Definition 6.2.2. Let curve . Then the degree of
is the integer
Note the obvious property key result is proved in [41, Cor. II.6.10].
. The following
Theorem 6.2.3. Every principal divisor on an irreducible smooth complete curve has degree zero.
In other words, irreducible smooth complete curve
for all nonzero rational functions
. Thus
when
on
on an
and the degree map induces a surjective homomorphism
Note that all Weil divisors are Cartier since is smooth. is the set of isomorphism classes of line bundles In §6.0 we showed that on . Hence we can define the degree of a line bundle on . This leads immediately to the following result. Proposition 6.2.4. Let be an irreducible smooth complete curve. Then a line bundle has a degree such that has the following prop erties: . (a) (b) when . when . (c)
§6.2. The Nef and Mori Cones
281
The Normalization of a Curve. We defined the normalization of an affine variety in §1.0, and by gluing together the normalizations of affine pieces, one can define the normalization of any variety (see [41, Ex. II.3.8]). In particular, an irreducible curve has a normalization map
where
(a)
is an normal variety. Here are the key propeties of
Proposition 6.2.5. Let
(b)
.
be the normalization of an irreducible curve
is smooth. is complete whenever
is complete.
Proof. Since is a curve, Proposition 4.0.17 implies that covered by [41, Ex. II.5.8].
. Then:
is smooth. Part (b) is
One can prove that every irreducible smooth complete curve is projective. See [41, Ex. II.5.8].
The Intersection Product. We now have the tools needed to define the intersection product. Let be a normal variety. Given a Cartier divisor on and an irreducible complete curve , we have
The line bundle
The normalization
Then
;
on
. .
and
;
is a line bundle on the irreducible smooth complete curve
Definition 6.2.6. The intersection product of
is
.
.
Here are some properties of the intersection product.
Proposition 6.2.7. Let be an irreducible complete curve and sors on a normal variety . Then:
(a)
(b)
when
Cartier divi-
.
.
Proof. The pullback of line bundles is compatible with tensor product, so that part (a) follows from (6.0.3) and Proposition 6.2.4. Part (b) is an easy consequence of Propositions 6.0.21 and 6.2.4.
In Chapter 4, we defined a Weil divisor to be -Cartier if is Cartier for some integer . Given an irreducible complete curve , let
(6.2.1)
In Exercise 6.2.1 you will show that this intersection product is well-defined and satisfies Propostion 6.2.7.
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
282
Intersection Products on Toric Varieties. In the toric case, is easy to compute when and are torus-invariant in . In order for to be torus-invariant and
, where
is the wall complete, we must have , separating cones . We do not assume is complete.
In this situation, we have the sublattice and the
. Let and be the images of and in . Since quotient rays that correspond to the rays in the usual fan
is a wall, and , are is smooth, so no normalization is needed when for . In particular, computing the intersection product.
Proposition 6.2.8. Let
,
, be a complete torus-invariant corresponding to curve in . Let be a Cartier divisor with . Also pick that maps to the minimal generator of
, we can assume and is the fan Proof. Since consisting of and their faces. We also have The proof of Proposition 6.1.20 shows that the line bundle is determined . Thus by the transition function ; is the inclusion map. The pullback bundle is determined by where
the restriction of to
. Then
where
is the variety
and that
-orbit corresponding to . This is also the torus of the toric . In Lemma 3.2.5, we showed that is the dual of
;
Now comes the key observation: since the linear functions given by agree is the line bundle on
on , we have . Thus whose transition function is for .
It follows that by the data
;
;
, where
is the divisor on
Let be the torus fixed points corresponding to to the minimal generator
, we have
given
. Since
maps
§6.2. The Nef and Mori Cones
;
283
where the second equality follows from
in
Example 6.2.9. Consider the toric surface whose fan
. Hence
has ray generators
and maximal cones
The support of is the first quadrant and
complete torus-invariant curve .
are the divisors corresponding to If
is Cartier
When this condition is satisfied, we have
Also, basis of
gives the
, then
maps to the minimal generator of since . (You will check these assertions in Exercise 6.2.2.) Thus
form a
by Proposition 6.2.8. Since is -Cartier ( is simplicial), (6.2.1) shows that the formula for holds for arbitrary integers . In particular,
Later in the section we will see that these intersection products follow directly from and the fact that . the relation
Nef Divisors. We now define an important class of Cartier divisors.
Definition 6.2.10. Let be a normal variety. Then a Cartier divisor nef (short for numerically effective) if
for every irreducible complete curve
on
is
.
Any divisor linearly equivalent to a nef divisor is clearly nef. We also have the following useful result. Proposition 6.2.11. Every basepoint free divisor is nef.
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
284
Proof. The pullback of a line bundle generated by global sections is generated by global sections (Exercise 6.0.10). Thus, given and basepoint free, is generated by global sections. This allows us the line bundle for a basepoint free divisor on to write . A nonzero global
. Then gives an effective divisor section of
;
;
where the last inequality follows since
for every .
is effective if and only if
In the toric case, nef divisors are especially easy to understand.
Theorem 6.2.12. Let be a Cartier divisor on a complete toric variety following are equivalent.
(a)
is basepoint free, i.e.,
. The
is generated by global sections.
is nef.
(b) (c)
for all torus-invariant irreducible curves
.
Proof. The first item implies the second by Proposition 6.2.11, and the second
for all item implies the third by the definition of nef. So suppose that torus-invariant irreducible curves . We can replace with a linearly equivalent torus-invariant divisor. Then, by Theorem 6.1.10, it suffices to show that is convex.
Take a wall
Proposition 6.2.8, then
so that
of
and set
. If we pick
as in
Note that since the image of is nonzero in Then Lemma 6.1.8 implies that is convex.
.
A variant of the above proof leads to the following ampleness criterion, which you will prove in Exercise 6.2.3.
Theorem 6.2.13 (Toric Kleiman Criterion). Let be a Cartier divisor on a com for all torusplete toric variety . Then is ample if and only if invariant irreducible curves .
We also note that one direction of the proof follows from the general fact that
for all on any complete normal variety, an ample divisor satisfies irreducible curves (Exercise 6.2.4).
§6.2. The Nef and Mori Cones
285
Numerical Equivalence of Divisors. The intersection product leads to an important equivalence relation on Cartier divisors.
Definition 6.2.14. Let
be a normal variety.
(a) A Cartier divisor on is numerically equivalent to zero if all irreducible complete curves . (b) Cartier divisors and are numerically equivalent, written is numerically equivalent to zero.
for
What does this say in the toric case? be a Cartier divisor on a complete toric variety .
Proposition 6.2.15. Let Then if and only if
Proof. Clearly if is principal then and let converse, assume Proposition 6.2.8, then
, if
.
is numerically equivalent to zero. For the be a wall of . If we pick as in
since and . From here,
. This forces for for all , and it follows easily that is it is easy to see that
principal.
Numerical Equivalence of Curves. We also get an interesting equivalence relation on curves. Let be the free Abelian group generated by irreducible complete is called a proper -cycle. curves . An element of
be a normal variety.
(a) A proper -cycle on is numerically equivalent to zero if all Cartier divisors on . and are numerically equivalent, written (b) Proper -cycles is numerically equivalent to zero. extends naturally to a pairing The intersection product
Definition 6.2.16. Let
for
, if
between Cartier divisors and -cycles. In order to get a nondegenerate pairing, we work over and mod out by numerical equivalence.
Definition 6.2.17. For a normal variety , define and
It follows easily that we get a well-defined nondegenerate bilinear pairing A deeper fact is that and have finite dimension over . Thus and are dual vector spaces via intersection product.
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
286
The Nef and Mori Cones. The vector spaces interesting cones.
and
contain some
be a normal variety. is the cone in generated by classes of nef Cartier divisors. We (a) the nef cone. call is the cone in generated by classes of irreducible complete (b)
Definition 6.2.18. Let
curves.
(c)
is the closure of
in
. We call
the Mori cone.
Here are some easy observations about the nef and Mori cones.
are closed convex cones and are dual to each other, i.e., and
Lemma 6.2.19. (a)
(b) (c)
and
has maximal dimension in is strongly convex in
.
.
, and are convex cones, and Proof. It is obvious that
. In fact, is closed since it is defined by inequalities of the form
Then
by the definition of nef. follows easily. In general, need not be closed. However, since the closure of a convex cone is its double dual, we have
has maximal dimension since is spanned by the classes Note that . of irreducible complete curves. Hence the same is true for its closure is strongly convex since its the dual has maximal dimension. Then , then The toric case is especially nice. If we set since numerical and linear equivalence coincide by Proposition 6.2.15. Thus, in the instead of . When is complete, toric setting, we will write
the inclusion makes
a lattice in the vector space
Theorem 6.2.20. Let (a)
.
be a complete toric variety.
is a rational polyhedral cone in
.
§6.2. The Nef and Mori Cones
(b)
where
is a rational polyhedral cone in
is the class of .
287
. Furthermore,
Proof. Part (a) is an immediate consequence of part (b). For part (b), let and note that is a rational polyhedral cone contained in . Furthermore,Theorem 6.2.12 easily implies Then
where the third equality follows since
is polyhedral.
The formula from part (b) of Theorem 6.2.20
is called the Toric Cone Theorem. Although the Mori cone equals in this case, we will continue to write for consistency with the literature. Since , we get the following every irreducible curve gives a class in corollary of the Toric Cone Theorem.
Corollary 6.2.21. An irreducible curve in a complete toric variety is numeri cally equivalent to a non-negative combination of torus-invariant curves. When
is projective we can say more about the nef and Mori cones.
be a projective toric variety. Then: and are dual strongly convex rational polyhedral cones of (a) maximal dimension. lies in the (b) A Cartier divisor is ample if and only if its class in . interior of has an ample divisor . Then for every Proof. By hypothesis, irreducible curve in . This easily implies that the class of lies in the interior has maximal dimension and hence its dual of . Thus Theorem 6.2.22. Let
is strongly convex. When combined with Lemma 6.2.19, part (a) follows easily.
also shows that every irreducible curve gives The strict inequality a nonzero class in is in the interior of . Now suppose that the class of the nef cone. Then defines a supporting hyperplane of the origin of the dual
cone . Since for every irreducible curve ,
we have for all such . Hence is ample by Theorem 6.2.13.
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
288
When is not a projective variety, the ampleness criterion given in part (b) of Theorem 6.2.22 can fail. Here is an example due to Fujino [29]. with six minimal generators Example 6.2.23. Consider the complete fan in
and six maximal cones
You will draw a picture of this fan in Exercise 6.2.5 and show that the resulting complete toric variety satisfies
The maximal cones along the wall
and
meet
satisfies (Exercise 6.2.5), satisfies
However, any Cartier divisor so that the irreducible complete curve
by Proposition 6.2.8. Since this holds for all Cartier divisors on , we have . Then has no ample divisors by the Toric Kleiman Criterion, so that is nonprojective.
The nef cone of
is the half-line
gives a class in (Exercise 6.2.5). It follows that the Cartier divisor the interior of the nef cone, yet is not ample. Hence part (b) of Theorem 6.2.22 is false for . The failure is due to the existence of irreducible curves in that are numerically equivalent to zero. This shows that numerical equivalence can be badly behaved in the nonprojective case.
Exercises for §6.2.
6.2.1. Let be a normal variety. Prove that (6.2.1) gives a well-defined pairing between -Cartier divisors and irreducible complete curves. Also show that this pairing satisfies Propostion 6.2.7. 6.2.2. Derive the formulas for
a
and
a
given in Example 6.2.9.
6.2.3. Prove Theorem 6.2.13. 6.2.4. Prove that on a complete normal variety, an ample divisor all irreducible curves .
satisfies
D
for
§6.3. The Simplicial Case
289
6.2.5. Consider the fan % from Example 6.2.23. (a) Draw a picture of this fan in .
X (b) Prove that { % X j @0 /is $nef. (c) Prove that '
N
46
8
.
§6.3. The Simplicial Case
Henceforth we will assume that is a simplicial fan in . Then Proposition 4.2.7 implies that every Weil divisor is -Cartier. Since we will be working , it follows that we can drop the adjective “Cartier” when discussing in divisors.
Relations Among Minimal Generators. We begin our discussion of the simplicial case with another way to think of elements of . Recall from Theorem 4.1.3 that we have an exact sequence
(6.3.1) where
and sends the standard basis element to .
Proposition 6.3.1. Let exact sequences
where
Proof. Since
. Then there are dual
a standard basis vector of
In particular, we may interpret minimal generators of .
; ;
be a simplicial fan in
and
an irreducible complete curve
as the space of linear relations among the
is simplicial, all Weil divisors are -Cartier. Hence
Tensoring with preserves exactness, so exactness of the first sequence follows from (6.3.1). The dual of an exact sequence of finite dimensional vector spaces is still exact. Then the perfect pairings
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
290
easily imply that for
and
;
The map ducible complete curve
(6.3.2)
;
and
, we have
;
Taking the intersection product with
in Proposition 6.3.1 implies that an irregives the relation
in
This can be derived directly as follows. First observe that
. Writing this as
gives
By linearity, this holds for all we obtain
in
gives
,
Intersection Products. Our next task is to compute when is a torus invariant complete curve in . This means
, where is a wall, meaning that is the intersection of two cones in . Since we are not assuming that is complete, not every element of is a wall.
We begin with a case where
Since
is easy to compute. Fix a wall
is simplicial, we can label the minimal generators of so that
Thus is the side of “opposite” from . The intersection product of a simplicial cone is computed in terms of indices, where the index is the index of the sublattice
Lemma 6.3.2. If , and are as above, then
§6.3. The Simplicial Case
Proof. Since
291
is a basis of
, . On
such that
is the Cartier
. By (6.2.1) and Proposition 6.2.8,
. Recall that . where maps to a generator of When we combine with a basis of , we get a basis of . Thus there is a positive integer such that ,
. The minus sign is because and lie on opposite sides of . By considering the sublattices
one sees that . Thus
that such and
Pick a positive integer divisor determined by
, we can find
Since
, it follows that
Given a wall rays . Let
be a wall.
.
(6.3.3)
, our next task is to compute and write
and
Corollary 6.3.3. Let be a smooth fan in , then and generate a cone of If
for the other
This situation is pictured in Figure 11. Applying Lemma 6.3.2 to and , we obtain
(6.3.4)
To compute when
, note that the minimal generators are linearly dependent. Hence they satisfy a linear relation, which
we write as
(6.3.5)
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
292
uρ
n+1
← σ′ uρ
uρ
τ
2
n
uρ
1
← σ
Figure 11.
We may assume since and lie on opposite sides of the wall . Then (6.3.5) is unique up to multiplication by a positive constant since are linearly independent. We call (6.3.5) a wall relation.
On the other hand, setting
(6.3.6)
in (6.3.2) gives the linear relation
As we now prove, the two relations are the same up to a positive constant. Lemma 6.3.4. The relations given by (6.3.5) and (6.3.6) are equal after multiplication by a positive constant. In particular,
for all
and
for
.
Proof. First observe that if , then and never lie in the same cone of , so that by the Orbit-Cone Correspondence. This easily
(Exercise 6.3.1), which in turn implies that (6.3.6) reduces implies to the equation
§6.3. The Simplicial Case
293
The coefficients of and are positive by (6.3.4), so up to a positive constant, this must be the wall relation (6.3.5). The first assertion of the lemma follows.
for
Since the above relation equals (6.3.5) up to a nonzero constant, we obtain
. Then the desired formulas for
follow from (6.3.4).
For a simplicial toric variety, Lemmas 6.3.2 and 6.3.4 provide everything we need to compute when is a wall of .
Example 6.3.5. Consider the fan where
,
and the relation
implies
. Computing indices gives
Then Lemma 6.3.2 implies
from Example 6.2.9. We have the wall
and
in
by Lemma 6.3.4. Hence we recover the calculations of Example 6.2.9.
When is smooth, all indices are . Hence the wall relation (6.3.5) can be written uniquely as (6.3.7)
and then the intersection formula of Lemma 6.3.4 reduces to for
.
Example 6.3.6. For the Hirzebruch surface , the four curves coming from walls are also divisors. Recall that the minimal generators are
arranged clockwise around the origin (see Figure 3 from Example 6.1.3). Hence the wall generated by gives the relation
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
294
which implies
by Lemma 6.3.4. On the other hand, the wall generated by
Then the lemma implies
gives the relation
Although and are both smooth rational curves on , they intersect themselves very differently. In general, a divisor on a complete surface has . Self-intersections will play a prominent role in self-intersection Chapter 10 when we study toric surfaces.
Primitive Collections. In the projective case, there is a beautiful criterion for a Cartier divisor to be nef or ample in terms of the primitive collections introduced in Definition 5.1.5. Recall that is a primitive collection if is not contained in for some but any proper subset is. Since is simplicial, primitive means that does not generate a cone of but every proper subset does. This is the original definition given by Batyrev [5].
z
Example 6.3.7. Consider the complete fan in
shown in Figure 12.
ρ4
ρ1
ρ3 ρ2
y x ρ0
Figure 12. A fan in
One can check that
are the only primitive collections of .
§6.3. The Simplicial Case
295
Here is the promised characterization, due to Batyrev [5] in the smooth case. Theorem 6.3.8. Let
be a projective simplicial toric variety.
(a) A Cartier divisor
is nef if and only if its support function
(b) A Cartier divisor
for all primitive collections
satisfies
of .
is ample if and only if its support function
for all primitive collections
satisfies
of .
Before we discuss the proof of Theorem 6.3.8, we need to study the relations that come from primitive collections. be a primitive collection for the Definition 6.3.9. Let complete simplicial fan . Hence lies in the relative interior of a cone
. Thus there is a unique expression
Then is the primitive relation of .
" # # " " # $ " (6.3.8) ! # " #
otherwise % Then &' , so that gives an element of ( " when # ,$
In Exercise 6.3.2, you will prove that )+* The coefficient vector of this relation is
, where
" , so that
by Proposition 6.3.1. consists
of the positive coefficients in the primitive relation. The Mori cone for
has a nice description in terms of primitive relations.
Theorem 6.3.10. For a projective simplicial toric variety .- 0/
where the sum is over all primitive collections
of .
,
1 3 2 1 and a relation &4 9 8 and : ( is 1 : 2 1 ): 2
Proof. Given a Cartier divisor intersection pairing of 1 576 (6.3.9)
, the
296
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
(Exercise 6.3.3). In particular, when :
, we can rearrange terms to obtain
1 ) 2 2 ) % Since the support function of 1 satisfies &' 2 and is linear on , we can rewrite this as (6.3.10) 1 &4 &' &4 &4 % If 1 is nef, then it is basepoint free (Theorem 6.2.12), so that is convex. It
, which proves follows that 1 . Note also that is nonzero. To finish the proof, we need to show that is generated by the .
This cone is strongly convex ( is projective), which implies that it is generated by its 1-dimensional faces, which we call extremal rays. By Toric Cone Theorem,
each extremal ray is generated by the class coming from a wall. We call an extremal wall. It suffices to show that is a positive multiple of for some primitive collection . We first pause to make a useful observation about nef divisors. Any nef divisor
is linearly equivalent to a torus-invariant nef divisor 1 2 1 . Given , # " . As we have for noted above, 1 is with &4 2 basepoint free, so that # " & & 2
6 , we may hence assume that by Theorem 6.1.10. Replacing 1 with 1
# # " " (6.3.11) 1 2 1 2 and 2 %
. Consider the set Now assume we have an extremal wall and let # 1 % We will prove that is a primitive collection whose primitive relation is the class of , up to a positive constant. Our argument is taken from [19], which is based on ideas of Kresch [62]. We first prove by contradiction that " for all . Suppose " and take an ample divisor 1 (remember that is projective). Then in
particular 1 is nef, so we may assume that 1 is of the form (6.3.11). Since 2 # " for , we have
1
2 1 %
by (6.3.11), and " implies 1 for # " . It However, 2 follows that 1 , which is impossible since 1 is ample. Thus no cone of
contains all rays in
.
§6.3. The Simplicial Case
297
It follows that some subset is a primitive collection. This gives the ( , and we also have the primitive relation with coefficient vector . Let ( class
where
(
. We claim that if
# 1
(6.3.12)
is sufficiently small, then
*
# 1 *
To prove this, first observe that the definition of
%
implies
1 1 1 % . This forces 1 .
and 1 Now suppose that 1 * As noted above, 1 is the coefficent of & in the primitive relation of , # . Then implies 1
which by (6.3.8) is positive only when by the definition of . But we can clearly choose sufficiently small so that 1 1 whenever 1 % This inequality and the above equation imply 1 , which is a contradiction. We next claim that . By (6.3.12), we have # 1 #
" * 1 * where the second inclusion follows from , (6.3.4), and Lemma 6.3.4. Now let 1 be nef, and by (6.3.11) with , we may assume that # # " " 1 2 1 2 and 2 % Then
1 2 1 and 1 where the final inequality follows since 2 * can happen only # " when
. This proves that . . Thus the equation We showed earlier that
expresses as a sum of elements of . But is extremal, i.e., it lies in and a one-dimensional face of . By Lemma 1.2.7, this forces to is nonzero, it generates the face, so that is a positive lie in the face. Since multiple of . The relation corresponding to has coefficients 1 , and is the # set of ’s where 1 . But this relation is a positive multiple of , whose
positive entries correspond to
. Thus
and the proof is complete.
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
298
It is now straightforward to prove Theorem 6.3.8 using Theorem 6.3.10 and (6.3.10) (Exercise 6.3.4). We should also mention that these results hold more generally for any projective toric variety (see [19]). Example 6.3.11. Let # minimal generators of
be the fan shown in Figure 12 of Example 6.3.7. The % % % # are " " " " " " " " " & & & & & % The computations you did for part (c) of Exercise 6.1.11 imply that is # # # # # projective. Since the only primitive collections are and , The-
1 is nef if and only if
& & & &
& & & & & &
orem 6.3.8 implies that a Cartier divisor
2
(resp. and 2 1 1 is nef (resp. ample) if and only if 2 2
and ample if and only if these inequalities are strict. One can also check that
576 2 1 1
).
Exercise 6.3.5 will relate this example to the proof of Theorem 6.3.10.
These ideas will reappear in Chapter 15 when we study the toric minimal model program. Exercises for §6.3. 6.3.1. This exercise will describe a situation where is guaranteed to be zero.
(a) Let be a normal variety and assume that is a complete irreducible curve disjoint from the support of a Cartier divisor . Prove that . Hint: Consider .
,
(b) Let be a wall of a fan and pick !"#%$& such that and never lie in the same cone of . Use the Cone-Orbit Correspondence to prove that ('*),+- .0/ , and conclude that 1'2 +-3 4 .
6.3.2. In the primitive relation defined in Definition 6.3.9, prove 5 ' 6$ when (879);:<%$& . Hint: If >=?8:<%$ and 5@'@A?B6$ , then cancel CD'@A and show that CD'FEHGJIKIJI@GLCM'ON.: . 6.3.3. Let -P be a simplicial toric variety and fix a Cartier divisor QSR a relation R 'U ' C ' V . Prove that the intersection pairing of W YX[Z b c ' b U 'Jd Pfe =hg 8iY=j3 P is W YX kR ' T ' U ' .
' '
B{]\^'3(T P_a`
and and
6.3.4. Prove Theorem 6.3.8 using Theorem 6.3.10 and (6.3.10). 6.3.5. Consider the fan from Examples 6.3.7 and 6.3.11. Every wall of is of the form Jlnm8poqsr>tsCMlLGhC mK for suitable u.vxw . Let yKlzmHY|{~} denote the wall relation of Klnm . Normalize by a positive constant so that the entries of y lnmj are integers with ^\KY$ . (a) Show the nine walls give the three distinct wall relations y3 F&@Ghy3J
jOGLy3JL& . (b) Show that y F
"y L 6y F and conclude that F
and h are extremal walls whose classes generate the Mori cone of P .
Appendix: Quasicoherent Sheaves on Toric Varieties
299
(c) For each extremal wall of part (b), determine the corresponding primitive collection. You should be able to read the primitive collection directly from the wall relation.
6.3.6. Let be the toric surface obtained by changing the ray C= in the fan of the Hirzebruch surface from $^GhyH to yjGJ$& . Assume y 6$ .
(a) Prove that is singular. How many singular points are there? (b) Determine which divisors T = = T JY? T
JY
# T K are Cartier and compute Yl J m for all uFGaw . (c) Determine the primitive relations and extremal walls of
.
Appendix: Quasicoherent Sheaves on Toric Varieties Now that we know more about sheaves (specifically, tensor products and exactness), we can complete the discussion of quasicoherent sheaves on toric varieties begun in §5.3. In this appendix, P will denote a toric variety with no torus factors. The total coordinate ring of P is W M' j-!#h$ X , which is graded by o a P . Recall from §5.3 that for xo 3 P , the shifted -module ; gives the sheaf ~ satisfying ~ ( for any Weil divisor with 6 W 1X . In §6.0 we constructed a sheaf homomorphism
! " #%$ In a similar way, one can define ;' )(*%$ (6.A.1) o 31P such that if W YX and ( xW " for G( h'! " h ~! )(;
&" OI
8+(@I
X , then the diagram / c& " h /
, (;
commutes, where the vertical maps are isomorphisms.
-
From Sheaves to Modules. The main construction of §5.3 takes a graded -module and produces a quasicoherent sheaf on 1P . We now go in the reverse direction and show that every quasicoherent sheaf on (P arises in this way. We will use the following construction.
-.
0 -modules on P and !o 3 P , define /x;1/2 ~ 354 3 and then set /4 6 / ;LOI 7 d08!9 e g YP G:x 3 4 3 For example, 1 3 4 since 3 P G ~h#1 7 by Proposition 5.3.7. Using this and (6.A.1), we see that 4 / is a graded -module. 34 We want to show that / is isomorphic to the sheaf associated to 4 / when / is quasicoherent. We will need the following lemma due to Mustat¸aˇ [73]. Recall that for ; ! , we have the monomial = < ?> 'Ad @ = e =hg ' B . Let = 4tJD) = < oa P . Definition 6.A.1. For a sheaf
/
of
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
300
/ 3 = P G:/x = L such that C restricts / 3 =) < = = :/ 3 3 (b) If C! 3 P G:/4 restricts to in = G:/4 , then there is BS such that ) #= < FC6 in P G:/x = L . 3 = G:/4 . Given c , let be the Proof. For part (a), fix ; [ and take x = ; ), ) restriction of to (3.1.3), we can find such that = ) "Q s ) .t \sBy W ) kX . In terms of the total coordinate ring , by (5.3.1). Hence the coordinate ring of = ) is the we have W ) kX localization G where < > ' ' since ) . This enables us to write = ) c ^ I 3 Since is quasicoherent, is determined by its sections / / G:4 / , and then
3 = ) >G 4 / is the localization . 3 3 It follows that , where 8B and C = G:4 / 3 equals C ) G:4 / . ( = G4 / . Since , ; , we see that Hence C restricts to ) x) = < ) B (6.A.2) 3 >G x / = h restricts for . This monomial has degree = . Then C - C 3 = = = ) G:x / h . By making sufficiently large, we can find one that to < Y . works for all / = , take = GhJ9! and To study whether the C patch to give a global section of x LA~) %E , and set :8| = )J . Thus 3 (6.A.3) 44C A , C E G:x / = L 3 = ) G:x / = h . Arguing as above, this group of sections is the localrestricts3 to Y ization Gx / = h , where (: ) ; ) such that = ) c . Since 3 gives the zero element in this localization,= there is 4B with in / = 3 h . If we multiply by S < % for , we obtain = < G: x = in G:x / L h . Another way to think3 of this is that if we made in (6.A.2) big enough to begin with, then in fact c in G:x / = L for all >GL . Given 3 the definition (6.A.3) of , it follows that the C patch to give a global section C! P G:x / = L with the desired properties. 3
Lemma 6.A.2. Let be a quasicoherent sheaf on (P . (a) If 8 G 4 , then there are B4 and C, to G x L .
!$#(' )* %
"!$#&%
+
"
-
. 0/
6 .
!$#&%
=
,?>
A "
;
,?>
B
;
C
5
HG
;
EFJ=
;
@;
. 7 6
=
;
6
6
<;
!1#2% 8 3
.
5
67
!1#2% 43
3
:9
-
,
6D
EF
HGI9
8 3
!$#&%
G
=
!1#2% 3=
;
=
;
The proof of part (b) is similar and is left to the reader. K
This lemma makes it easy to prove the following result.
/
34
Proposition 6.A.3. Let be a quasicoherent sheaf on (P . Then sheaf associated to the graded -module 4 .
-
34
/
/
Proof. Let 4 and recall from §5.3 that for every is the sheaf associated to the L -module L .
=
:-
;
/
is isomorphic to the
, the restriction of
-.
to
Appendix: Quasicoherent Sheaves on Toric Varieties
301
- . $ / = < = = /3 = ) < = = G = h' 3 = G:/x = L* $ 3 = G /4 induces a homomorphism of -modules 3 - % $ = G /4OI (6.A.4) $ / that patch to give a sheaf This defines compatible sheaf homomorphisms - . homomorphism - . $ / . / is quasicoherent, it= suffices to show that (6.A.4)3 is an isomorphism for every ; SSince . First suppose that3 C < kmaps to = G /4 . It follows easily / = h . By Lemma that C restricts to zero in = 3 G x 6.A.2 applied to x / = , there is / L > = h . Then BS such that ) = < LC84 in 3 P G:x C = < C 4 in - G ) = < = < 3 which shows that (6.A.4) is injective. To / and= apply 3 prove surjectivity, take 8 = G 4 = P Lemma 6.A.2 to find B and C| 3 G x / h such that C restricts to < . It = follows immediately that C ) < 2 maps to . 3
We first construct a sheaf homomorphism . Elements of L are C / for C 3 P G x h . Since 8 is a section of over , the map
L
L
, L
/
L
3
5
, L
5
E
5
3
L
3
/
L
K
This result proves part (a) of Proposition 5.3.9. We now turn our attention to part (b) of the proposition, which applies to coherent sheaves. Proposition 6.A.4. Every coherent sheaf to a finitely generated graded -module.
/
on (P is isomorphic to the sheaf associated
=
= 3 = G:/4 ) 0= < l = 3comes 4 - /4
Proof. On the affine open subset , we can find finitely many sections l ' which generate over . By Lemma 6.A.2, we can find BS such that . Now consider the graded -module from a global section ^l of x ' generated by the l . Proposition 6.A.3 gives an isomorphism
/
=
=
=
/ =
3 4
'
-
34
/
/41/ I
-. $ /
'
Hence 4 gives a sheaf homomorphism is injective by the , we have l , which l / exactness proved in Proposition 6.0.9. Over E(x L , ' ' over , it follows that . Then we are done and since these sections generate since is clearly finitely generated. K
=
/
-
=
34
=
-. /
= = <
/
-
The proof of Proposition 6.A.4 used a submodule of 4 because the full module need not be finitely generated when is coherent. Here is an easy example.
/
4 $ ! / |isu free in T
34 / 1/ 3 " /4 6 % G /x T h 6 I d$# d$# This module is not finitely generated over [ 9W h GJIKIJI@G: X since it is nonzero in all
negative degrees.
Example 6.A.5. A point ! gives a subvariety u . The sheaf can be thought of as a copy of sitting over the point . The line bundle a neighborhood of , so that x T for all T . Thus 7
7
Chapter 6. Line Bundles on Toric Varieties
302
Subschemes and Homogeneous Ideals. For readers who know about schemes, we can apply the above results to describe subschemes of a toric variety P with no torus factors. Let be a homogeneous ideal. By Proposition 6.0.9, this gives a sheaf of ideals ?whose quotient is the structure sheaf of closed subscheme of x P . This differs from the subvarieties considered in the rest of the book since the structure sheaf
may have nilpotents.
S
Proposition 6.A.6. Every subscheme Proof. Given an ideal sheaf
53 4
P
is defined by a homogeneous ideal
, we get a homomorphism of 34 # $ 13~ 4 I
.
-modules
$
If is the image of this map, then the map factors , where the first arrow is surjective and the second injective. Applying Propositions 6.0.9 and 6.A.3, the . .. K factors as . It follows immediately that inclusion
$
In the case of , it is well-known that different graded ideals can give the same ideal sheaf. The same happens in the toric situation, and as in §5.3, we get the best answer in the smooth case. Not surprisingly, the irrelevant ideal a plays a key role.
Proposition 6.A.7. Homogeneous ideals G in the total coordinate of a smooth toric variety 1P give the same ideal sheaf of if and only if ( a . K
a , and in the exact sequence $ $ a $ ( / $ >G the quotient (a / is annihilated by a power of ( since is finitely generated. The sheaf associated to this quotient is trivial by Proposition 5.3.10. Then and (a
Proof. Since is homogeneous, the same is true for
give the same ideal sheaf by Proposition 6.0.9. This proves one direction of the proposition. For the converse, suppose that
and
give the same ideal sheaf. This means that
for all ; . Take 7 for o 3 P and fix ; . Arguing as in the proof ; h$ such of Proposition 5.3.10, we can find a monomial involving only ' for = = that implies ) < Y , which in turn easily implies = ) < for . This that ) < . Thus ( , and from here the rest of the proof is
L
L
/
D
6D
/
3
straightforward.
L 9
6D
/
43
L
K
There is a less elegant version of this result that applies to simplicial toric varieties. See [15] for a proof and more details about the relation between graded modules and sheaves. See also [68] for more on multigraded commutative algebra.
Chapter 7
Projective Toric Morphisms
§7.0. Background: Quasiprojective Varieties and Projective Morphisms Many results of Chapter 6 can be generalized, but in order to do so, we need to learn about quasiprojective varieties and projective morphisms. Quasiprojective Varieties. Besides affine and projective varieties, we also have the following important class of varieties. Definition 7.0.1. A variety is quasiprojective if it is isomorphic to an open subset of a projective variety. Here are some easy properties of quasiprojective varieties. Proposition 7.0.2. (a) Affine varieties and projective varieties are quasiprojective. (b) Every closed subvariety of a quasiprojective variety is quasiprojective. (c) A product of quasiprojective varieties is quasiprojective. Proof. You will prove this in Exercise 7.0.1. Projective Morphisms. In algebraic geometry, concepts that apply to varieties sometimes have relative versions that apply to morphisms between varieties. For example, in §3.4, we defined completeness and properness, where the former applies to varieties and the latter applies to morphisms. Sometimes we say that the 303
Chapter 7. Projective Toric Morphisms
304
relative version of a complete variety is a proper morphism. In the same way, the relative version of a projective variety is a projective morphism.
a line
.
gives a
We begin with a special case. Let be a morphism and bundle on with a basepoint free finite-dimensional subspace with the morphism Then combining that fits into a commutative diagram morphism
"!$#&% '
(
/ PPP PPP PPP PPP PPP P'
(7.0.1)
)*
+ , -. /
If is a closed embedding (meaning that its image is closed and the induced map is an isomorphism), then you will show in Exercise 7.0.2 that has the following nice properties: is proper.
1
0 +
1
43 2
2 /
For every , the fiber and hence is projective.
5
is isomorphic to a closed subvariety of
The general definition of projective morphism must include this special case. In fact, going from the special case to the general case is not that hard.
6 7 98 "!;# % ' : 8 = 3 8 9 < is a closed embedding, where ;> @? and A B is projective with respect to .
Definition 7.0.3. A morphism is projective if there is a line bundle on and an affine open cover of with the property that for each , there is a basepoint free finite-dimensional subspace such that
3
8
; > @ ? . We say that
The general case has the properties noted above in the special case. Proposition 7.0.4. Let (a)
6 7
is proper.
2 .
(b) For every
, the fiber
be projective. Then:
3 2 is a projective variety.
Here are some further properties. Proposition 7.0.5. (a) The composition of projective morphisms is projective. (b) A closed embedding is a projective morphism. (c) A variety
is projective if and only if
7 DCFE
is a projective morphism.
§7.0. Background: Quasiprojective Varieties and Projective Morphisms
305
Proof. Parts (a) and (b) are proved in [37, (5.5.5)]. For part (c), one direction follows immediately from the previous proposition. Conversely, let be that is not contained projective, and assume that is nondegenerate, " meaning " . Then in any hyperplane of . Now let
is injective since
"
is nondegenerate. In Exercise 7.0.3 you will show that
" C % % % and that if - is the image of , then F is the embedding we began with. Hence Definition 7.0.3 is satisfied for 7 DCFE and . When the domain is quasiprojective, the relation between proper and projective is especially easy to understand. Proposition 7.0.6. Let Then:
0
is proper
be a morphism where
is quasiprojective.
is projective %
Proof. One direction is obvious since projective implies proper. For the opposite direction, our hypothesis implies that there is a morphism
+ + is open and via . It to a projective variety + such that follows that the product map B A+ * (7.0.2) * , where * is closed in . induces Since B is proper, 7 + is also proper (Exercise 7.0.4). Hence the image of is closed in , + since proper morphisms are universally = , where is closed in 5 + . This proves closed. Thus that (7.0.2) is a closed embedding. . Then we get a closed embedding Now take a closed embedding + of into . From here, it is straightforward to show that is projective
(Exercise 7.0.4).
In the literature, one finds two definitions of projective morphism. In [41, II.4], a projective morphism is defined as the special case considered in (7.0.1), while [37, (5.5.2)] and [100, 5.3] give a more general definition. Proposition 7.A.5 of the appendix to this chapter shows that the general definition is equivalent to ours. Projective Bundles. Vector bundles give rise to an interesting class of projective morphisms.
Chapter 7. Projective Toric Morphisms
306
8
"
Let be a vector . Recall from §6.0 that withbundleof rank has a trivialization . Furthermore, the $ that make the diagram transition functions
3 8
8
8 8 ! > ? ? k8 k5 $ 8 O kk kkkk k 3 8 $ 8 SSS ! > @? S ? S S SSS) $ 8 8
" induces an isomorphism " F8 $ 8 3 8 $ 8 3 % a variety . It is clear that induces a morphism This gives gluing data for the trivialization * and that induces
3 8 8 3 % is a projective morphism. We call the It follows easily that F commute. Note that
projective bundle of
.
Example 7.0.7. Let be a finite dimensional vector space over dimension. Then, for any variety , the trivial bundle trivial projective bundle .
of positive gives the
There is also a version of this construction for locally free sheaves. If locally free of rank , then is the sheaf of sections of a vector bundle " , we proved this in Theorem 6.0.19. Then define of rank . When
(7.0.3)
where
is the dual vector bundle of . Here are some properties of
is
.
" is locally free of rank . when when is locally free and is a line bundle. (b) . (c) If a homomorphism locally free sheaves is surjective, then the of ofprojective induced map bundles is injective.
Lemma 7.0.8. (a)
Proof. You will prove this in . Exercise 7.0.5. The dual in (7.0.3) explains why gives
,
F %
The appearance of the dual in (7.0.3) can be explained as follows. Let be a line bundle with basepoint free of finite dimension. As in §6.0, this gives a morphism
§7.1. Polyhedra and Toric Varieties Let
307
. The corresponding vector bundle is
(7.0.4)
%
%
A
By Proposition 6.0.23, the natural map is surjective since basepoints. By Lemma 7.0.8, we get an injection of projective bundles
The lemma also implies
has no
. Using this and (7.0.4), we get an injection
%
F
, so
Projection onto the second factor gives a morphism morphism from §6.0 (Exercise 7.0.6).
, which is the
We should mention that one can define the “projective bundle” coherent sheaf on . See [41, II.7].
for any
Exercises for §7.0. 7.0.1. Prove Proposition 7.0.2.
$
7.0.2. Prove Proposition 7.0.4. Hint: First prove the special case given by (7.0.1). Recall from §3.4 that is complete, so that is proper. 7.0.3. Complete the proof of Proposition 7.0.5.
$
(
$
(
$
and be morphisms such that is 7.0.4. Let proper. Prove that is also proper. Hint: As noted in the comments following Corollary 3.4.8, being proper is equivalent to being topologically proper (Definition 3.4.2). = = Also, implies 8 # k ~ 8 #h .
$
)( #
(
7.0.5. Prove Lemma 7.0.8. Hint: Work on an open cover of involved are trivial.
where all of the bundles
$