TRANSPORT PHENOMENA IN FUEL CELLS
WIT Press publishes leading books in Science and Technology. Visit our website for the current list of titles. www.witpress.com
WITeLibrary Home of the Transactions of the Wessex Institute, the WIT electronic-library provides the international scientific community with immediate and permanent access to individual papers presented at WIT conferences. Visit the WIT eLibrary at www.witpress.com
International Series on Developments in Heat Transfer Objectives The Developments in Heat Transfer book Series publishes state-of-the-art books and provides valuable contributions to the literature in the field of heat transfer. The overall aim of the Series is to bring to the attention of the international community recent advances in heat transfer by authors in academic research and the engineering industry. Research and development in heat transfer is of significant importance to many branches of technology, not least in energy technology. Developments include new, efficient heat exchangers, novel heat transfer equipment as well as the introduction of systems of heat exchangers in industrial processes. Application areas include heat recovery in the chemical and process industries, and buildings and dwelling houses where heat transfer plays a major role. Heat exchange combined with heat storage is also a methodology for improving the energy efficiency in industry, while cooling in gas turbine systems and combustion engines is another important area of heat transfer research. To progress developments within the field both basic and applied research is needed. Advances in numerical solution methods of partial differential equations, high-speed, efficient and cheap computers, advanced experimental methods using LDV (laser-doppler-velocimetry), PIV (particleimage-velocimetry) and image processing of thermal pictures of liquid crystals, have all led to dramatic advances during recent years in the solution and investigation of complex problems within the field. The aims of the Series are achieved by contributions to the volumes from invited authors only. This is backed by an internationally recognised Editorial Board for the Series who represent much of the active research worldwide. Volumes planned for the series include the following topics: Compact Heat Exchangers, Engineering Heat Transfer Phenomena, Fins and Fin Systems, Condensation, Materials Processing, Gas Turbine Cooling, Electronics Cooling, Combustion-Related Heat Transfer, Heat Transfer in Gas-Solid Flows, Thermal Radiation, the Boundary Element Method in Heat Transfer, Phase Change Problems, Heat Transfer in Micro-Devices, Plateand-Frame Heat Exchangers, Turbulent Convective Heat Transfer in Ducts, Enhancement of Heat Transfer and other selected topics.
Series Editor B. Sundén Lund Institute of Technology Box 118 22100 Lund Sweden
Associate Editors C.I. Adderley Rolls Royce and Associates Limited UK
S. del Guidice University of Udine Italy
E. Blums Latvian Academy of Sciences Latvia
M. Faghri The University of Rhode Island USA
C.A. Brebbia Wessex Institute of Technology UK
P.J. Heggs UMIST UK
G. Comini University of Udine Italy
C. Herman John Hopkins University USA
R.M. Cotta COPPE/UFRJ, Brazil
D.B. Ingham University of Leeds UK
L. De Biase University of Milan Italy
Y. Jaluria Rutgers University USA
G. De Mey University of Ghent Belgium
S. Kotake University of Tokyo Japan
G. de Vahl Davies University of New South Wales Australia
P.S. Larsen Technical University of Denmark Denmark
D.B. Murray Trinity College Dublin Ireland
A.C.M. Sousa University of New Brunswick Canada
A.J. Nowak Silesian University of Technology Poland
D.B. Spalding CHAM UK
K. Onishi Ibaraki University Japan
J. Szmyd University of Mining and Metallurgy Poland
P.H. Oosthuizen Queen’s University Kingston Canada
E. Van den Bulck Katholieke Universiteit Leuven Belgium
W. Roetzel Universtaet der Bundeswehr Germany
S. Yanniotis Agricultural University of Athens Greece
B. Sarler University of Ljubljana Slovenia
TRANSPORT PHENOMENA IN FUEL CELLS
Editors B. Sundén Lund Institute of Technology, Sweden.
M. Faghri University of Rhode Island, USA.
TRANSPORT PHENOMENA IN FUEL CELLS Series: Developments in Heat Transfer, Vol. 19 Editors: B. Sundén and M. Faghri
Published by
WIT Press Ashurst Lodge, Ashurst, Southampton, SO40 7AA, UK Tel: 44 (0) 238 029 3223; Fax: 44 (0) 238 029 2853 E-Mail:
[email protected] http://www.witpress.com For USA, Canada and Mexico WIT Press 25 Bridge Street, Billerica, MA 01821, USA Tel: 978 667 5841; Fax: 978 667 7582 E-Mail:
[email protected] http://www.witpress.com British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A Catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN: 1-85312-840-6 ISSN: 1369-7331 Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 2004116358 No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher, the Editors and Authors for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. © WIT Press 2005. Printed in Great Britain by Athenaeum Press Ltd. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the Publisher.
Contents Preface Chapter 1: Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells P.-W. Li, L. Schaefer & M.K. Chyu 1 2
3
4
5
Introduction......................................................................................... Thermodynamic and electrochemical fundamentals for solid oxide fuel cells ........................................................................... 2.1 Operation with hydrogen fuel ..................................................... 2.2 Operation with methane through internal reforming and shift reactions.............................................................................. Electrical potential losses .................................................................... 3.1 Activation polarization................................................................ 3.2 Ohmic loss ................................................................................. 3.3 Mass transport and concentration polarization ........................... Computer modeling of a tubular SOFC............................................... 4.1 Outline of a computation domain................................................ 4.2 Governing equations and boundary conditions ........................... 4.3 Numerical computation............................................................... 4.4 Typical results from numerical computation for tubular SOFCs.. 4.4.1 The SOFC terminal voltage ............................................. 4.4.2 Cell temperature distribution ........................................... 4.4.3 Flow, temperature and concentration fields ..................... Concluding remarks ............................................................................
Chapter 2: Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells S.B. Beale 1
Introduction......................................................................................... 1.1 History and types of solid oxide fuel cell ................................... 1.2 Survey of modeling techniques ................................................... 1.3 Thermodynamics of solid oxide fuel cells...................................
xv 1 1 3 4 8 11 12 14 18 19 21 22 26 27 27 30 31 34 43 44 44 45 46
2
3 4
1.4 Cell voltage and current .............................................................. 1.5 Activation losses ......................................................................... 1.6 Diffusion losses........................................................................... 1.7 Basic computational algorithm................................................... Computer schemes .............................................................................. 2.1 General scalar equation............................................................... 2.2 Continuity ................................................................................... 2.3 Momentum ................................................................................. 2.4 Heat transfer................................................................................ 2.5 Mass transfer............................................................................... 2.6 Numerical integration schemes ................................................... 2.7 Iterative procedure...................................................................... 2.8 Additional chemistry and electrochemistry................................. 2.9 Porous media flow ...................................................................... 2.10 Current and voltage distribution.................................................. 2.11 Advanced diffusion models ........................................................ 2.12 Thermal radiation........................................................................ Stack models ....................................................................................... Closure................................................................................................
Chapter 3: Electrochemical and thermo-fluid modeling of a tubular solid oxide fuel cell with accompanying indirect internal fuel reforming K. Suzuki, H. Iwai & T. Nishino 1 2
3
Introduction......................................................................................... General remarks on the mechanism of IIR-T-SOFC ........................... 2.1 Tubular cell................................................................................. 2.2 Internal reforming process .......................................................... 2.3 Electrochemical process.............................................................. 2.4 Purpose and key points of the analysis........................................ Numerical modeling............................................................................ 3.1 Computational domain and general assumptions for heat and mass transfer ................................................................ 3.2 Model for electrochemical reactions ........................................... 3.3 Model for internal fuel reforming ............................................... 3.4 Governing equations of velocity, temperature and concentration fields and boundary conditions ............................. 3.5 Discretization scheme................................................................. 3.6 Equations for electric potential and electric circuit .................... 3.7 Mass production or consumption rate of each chemical species through electrochemical and reforming reactions............. 3.8 Model for thermodynamic heat generation rates ......................... 3.9 Ohmic heat generation ................................................................
49 52 54 57 58 59 60 60 62 64 64 65 66 67 68 70 71 73 75
83 84 86 86 88 88 90 91 91 93 95 95 98 101 102 103 104
4
5
3.10 Radiation model.......................................................................... 3.11 Overall picture of the model ....................................................... Results and discussion......................................................................... 4.1 Results for a cathode-supported tubular SOFC without accompanying indirect internal reforming [16,43,44].................................................................................. 4.2 Results for the Base case with accompanying indirect internal reforming ....................................................................... 4.2.1 Thermal and concentration fields..................................... 4.2.2 Electric potential and current fields ................................. 4.2.3 Power generation characteristics...................................... 4.3 Strategies for the ideal thermal field ........................................... 4.3.1 Effect of gas inlet temperature ......................................... 4.3.2 Effect of air flow rate....................................................... 4.3.3 Effect of density distribution of catalyst ......................... Conclusions.........................................................................................
Chapter 4: On heat and mass transfer phenomena in PEMFC and SOFC and modeling approaches J. Yuan, M. Faghri & B. Sundén 1 2
3
4
5
Introduction......................................................................................... Fuel cell modeling development......................................................... 2.1 Basics of SOFCs and PEMFCs................................................... 2.2 Modeling development............................................................... 2.2.1 Modeling approaches....................................................... 2.2.2 Various existing models ................................................... Main processes in SOFCs and PEMFCs ............................................. 3.1 Gas transport............................................................................... 3.2 Electrochemical reactions ........................................................... 3.3 Heat transfer ............................................................................... 3.4 Various transport processes in the electrodes (porous layers) ............................................................................ 3.5 Other processes appearing in fuel cell components..................... Processes and issues in SOFC and PEMFC ........................................ 4.1 Water management in PEMFCs .................................................. 4.2 Fuel reforming issues in SOFC................................................... Modeling methodologies for transport processes in SOFC and PEMFC.............................................................................. 5.1 General considerations................................................................ 5.2 Assumptions................................................................................ 5.3 Governing equations ................................................................... 5.4 Boundary and interfacial conditions............................................ 5.5 Additional equations ...................................................................
104 107 108
108 113 115 116 119 121 121 123 123 125
133 133 135 135 137 137 138 141 142 142 143 143 144 144 144 145 146 146 147 147 149 150
6
7
5.6 Solution methodology................................................................. Results and discussions ....................................................................... 6.1 Mass transfer effects on the gas flow and heat transfer ............... 6.2 Porous layer effects on the transport processes ........................... 6.2.1 Transport processes in PEMFCs ...................................... 6.2.2 Transport processes in SOFCs ......................................... 6.3 Two-phase flow and its effects on the cell performance ............. Conclusions.........................................................................................
Chapter 5: Two-phase transport in porous gas diffusion electrodes S. Litster & N. Djilali 1
2
3
4
5
Introduction......................................................................................... 1.1 PEM fuel cells ............................................................................ 1.2 Porous media .............................................................................. 1.3 Porous media in PEMFC electrodes ........................................... Single-phase transport......................................................................... 2.1 Transport of a single-phase with a single component ................. 2.1.1 Permeability .................................................................... 2.2 Transport of a single-phase with two components ...................... 2.2.1 Effective diffusivity in porous media............................... 2.2.2 Determination of the binary diffusion coefficient .............. 2.2.3 Transport of a single-phase with more than two components...................................................................... 2.3 Knudsen diffusion....................................................................... 2.4 Determination of Knudsen diffusivity........................................ 2.5 Knudsen transition regime .......................................................... 2.5.1 Comparison of the diffusivities ........................................ Two-phase systems.............................................................................. 3.1 Two-phase regimes ..................................................................... 3.2 Hydrodynamics and capillarity in two-phase systems................. 3.2.1 Capillary pressure curves ................................................. 3.3 Relative permeability.................................................................. Multiphase flow models...................................................................... 4.1 Multi-fluid model ....................................................................... 4.1.1 Phase change.................................................................... 4.1.2 Application ...................................................................... 4.2 Mixture model ............................................................................ 4.3 Moisture diffusion model............................................................ 4.4 Porosity correction model ........................................................... 4.5 Evaluation of the multiphase models in the literature ................ Outstanding issues and conclusions ....................................................
151 152 152 155 155 160 163 168 175 175 175 177 178 181 181 181 182 183 185 185 186 187 187 187 188 189 191 195 197 200 200 201 203 205 207 208 208 208
Chapter 6: Numerical simulation of proton exchange membrane fuel cell T.C. Jen, T.Z. Yan & Q.H. Chen 1 2
Introduction......................................................................................... One-dimensional (1-D) model ............................................................ 2.1 General 1-D model ..................................................................... 2.1.1 Model description ........................................................... 2.1.2 Model assumptions .......................................................... 2.1.3 Governing equations........................................................ 2.1.4 Catalyst layers ................................................................. 2.1.5 Membrane........................................................................ 2.1.6 Boundary conditions........................................................ 2.1.7 Results and discussion ..................................................... 2.1.8 Summary.......................................................................... 2.2 General 2-D model ..................................................................... 2.2.1 Model description and assumptions................................. 2.2.2 Mathematical model ........................................................ 2.2.3 Boundary conditions........................................................ 2.2.4 Numerical procedures ..................................................... 2.2.5 Results and discussion ..................................................... 2.2.6 Concluding remarks......................................................... 2.3 Three-dimensional (3-D) model.................................................. 2.3.1 Model development ......................................................... 2.3.2 Mathematical model ........................................................ 2.3.3 Boundary conditions........................................................ 2.3.4 Discretization strategies................................................... 2.3.5 Solution algorithms ......................................................... 2.3.6 Results and discussion ..................................................... 2.4 Summary and conclusion ...........................................................
Chapter 7: Mathematical modeling of fuel cells: from analysis to numerics M. Vynnycky & E. Birgersson 1 2
Introduction ........................................................................................ PEFC................................................................................................... 2.1 Mathematical formulation for flow in the cathode ...................... 2.1.1 Channel............................................................................ 2.1.2 Porous backing ................................................................ 2.1.3 Boundary conditions........................................................ 2.2 Nondimensionalization ............................................................... 2.3 Parameters .................................................................................. 2.4 Narrow-gap approximation......................................................... 2.5 Further simplifications and observations ....................................
215 216 216 217 217 218 218 219 220 221 223 223 224 227 227 230 230 230 232 233 233 234 238 238 238 239 244
247 247 250 251 251 253 254 256 258 258 261
3
4
2.6 Numerics and results .................................................................. 2.6.1 Effect of A and Q ............................................................ 2.6.2 'Polarization surfaces' ...................................................... DMFC ................................................................................................. 3.1 Mathematical formulation for flow in the anode......................... 3.1.1 Channel............................................................................ 3.1.2 Porous backing ................................................................ 3.1.3 Boundary conditions........................................................ 3.2 Nondimensionalization ............................................................... 3.3 Parameters .................................................................................. 3.4 Narrow-gap approximation ......................................................... 3.5 Further simplifications and observations..................................... 3.6 Numerics and results................................................................... Conclusions.........................................................................................
Chapter 8: Modeling of PEM fuel cell stacks with hydraulic network approach J.J. Baschuk & X. Li 1 2
3
4 5
Introduction......................................................................................... Model formulation .............................................................................. 2.1 Stack flow model ........................................................................ 2.2 Manifold pressure loss ................................................................ 2.3 Cell pressure loss ........................................................................ 2.4 Mass consumed in the catalyst layers.......................................... 2.5 Boundary conditions ................................................................... Numerical procedure .......................................................................... 3.1 Outer iteration............................................................................. 3.2 Inner iteration ............................................................................. 3.3 Numerical procedure summary .................................................. Results and discussion......................................................................... Conclusions.........................................................................................
Chapter 9: Two-phase microfluidics, heat and mass transport in direct methanol fuel cells G. Lu & C.-Y. Wang 1 2
3
Introduction......................................................................................... Fundamentals of DMFC...................................................................... 2.1 Cell components and polarization curve .................................... 2.2 Thermodynamics......................................................................... 2.3 Methanol oxidation and oxygen reduction kinetics..................... Two-phase flow phenomena................................................................ 3.1 Bubble dynamics in anode .........................................................
264 264 268 270 271 271 271 272 272 273 273 273 277 278 283 284 285 288 290 292 293 294 294 295 297 298 298 309
317 317 320 320 322 324 325 325
4 5 6
7 8
3.1.1 Flow visualization................................................................ 3.1.2 Bubble diameter and drift velocity....................................... 3.1.3 Pressure drop ....................................................................... 3.2 Liquid water transport in cathode............................................... 3.2.1 Flooding in the cathode........................................................ 3.2.2 Flooding visualization.......................................................... Mass transport phenomena ................................................................. 4.1 Methanol crossover ........................................................................ 4.2 Water management in portable DMFC systems.............................. Heat transport.......................................................................................... Mathematical modeling and experimental diagnostics ............................ 6.1 Mathematical modeling .................................................................. 6.2 Experimental diagnostics ................................................................ 6.3 Model validation............................................................................. Application: micro DMFC ...................................................................... Summary and outlook .............................................................................
325 328 329 329 329 331 333 333 335 337 339 340 341 343 344 350
This page intentionally left blank
Preface Fuel cells are expected to play a significant role in the next generation of energy systems and road vehicles for transportation. However, substantial progress is required in reducing manufacturing costs and improving the performance. Solid Oxide fuel cells (SOFC), Proton Exchange Membrane fuel cells (PEMFC) and Direct Methanol fuel cells (DMFC) are of current interest. Many of the associated heat and mass transport processes are not well understood and include multidimensional flow and heat transfer in multi phase flows, multicomponent transport of gaseous species in porous media and electrochemical reactions including heat generation. Depending on the fuel being used, modifications in the design of the next generation of fuel cells are needed. Therefore, additional transport processes even at micro scale level need to be investigated. Other important considerations are air management system for oxygen supply, water management and recovery or rejection of heat of exhaust products. Currently an extensive amount of research and development activities are carried out for fuel cells worldwide. The dissemination of results is through various generic and specialized journals and conference proceedings. There is no comprehensive book available to address the analysis of transport phenomena in fuel cells. This book aims to contribute to the understanding of the transport processes in SOFC, PEMFC and DMFC fuel cells. The nine chapters cover a wide range of topics and are invited contributions from some prominent scientists in the field. The first chapter presents the thermodynamic and electrochemical fundamentals of SOFC. Efficiency, energy distribution, chemical equilibrium, losses of electrical potential, ohmic losses and losses due to mass transfer resistance are discussed. Modeling and numerical simulations of the coupled transport processes which determine the local and overall electromotive force in a SOFC are provided. Chapter 2 discusses various numerical techniques to model single-cells and stacks of planar SOFC. In chapter 3 a numerical model for analysis of a tubular SOFC including indirect internal reforming is presented. Fundamental results and strategies to reduce the maximum temperature and temperature gradient of the cell are discussed. Chapter 4 provides numerical analysis of heat, mass transfer (species flow), two-phase transport and effects on the performance in SOFC and PEMFC. In chapter 5 information on transport
phenomena in the electrodes of PEMFC is provided. The physical characteristics of such electrodes are also discussed. The focus is on two-phase flow in porous media, with a discussion of driving forces and various flow regimes. Also, the mathematical models are summarized. Chapter 6 presents mathematical models and numerical simulations of PEMFC to evaluate effects of various designs and operating parameters on the fuel cell performance. The three-dimensional model can be used for optimisation of design and operation and serve as a building block for modeling and understanding of PEMFC stacks and systems. In chapter 7 scaling analysis, nondimensionalization and asymptotic techniques are used to identify the governing parameters in order to obtain a simplified model. Illustrations are provided for PEMFC and DMFC. In chapter 8 a mathematical model for a PEMFC stack is formulated. Distributions of pressure, fuel and oxidant mass flow rates in the stack are determined by a hydraulic network analysis. Finally chapter 9 provides an overview of the latest developments in the DMFC technology. Experimental and modeling works to elucidate critical transport phenomena, including two-phase mierofluidics, heat and mass transport are presented. All of the chapters follow a unified outline and presentation to aid accessibility and the book provides invaluable information for both graduate research and R & D engineers at industry and consultancy. We are grateful to the authors and reviewers for their excellent contributions. We also appreciate the cooperation and patience provided by the staff of WIT Press and for their encouragement and assistance in producing this volume. The editors would also like to thank the Wenner-Gren Center Foundation in Sweden for financial support. B. Sundén and M. Faghri 2005
CHAPTER 1 Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells P.-W. Li, L. Schaefer & M.K.. Chyu Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Pittsburgh, USA.
Abstract In this topic, three important issues are discussed which concern the theoretical fundamentals and practical operation of a solid oxide fuel cell. The thermodynamic and electrochemical fundamentals of a fuel cell are reviewed in the Section 2. These fundamentals concern the ideal efficiency and energy distribution of a fuel cell’s conversion of chemical energy directly into electrical energy through the oxidation of a fuel. Issues of the chemical equilibrium for a solid oxide fuel cell with internal reforming and shift reactions (in case of methane or natural gas being used as the fuel), are also discussed in detail in this section. The losses of electrical potential in the practical operation of a fuel cell are elucidated in the third section, which includes a discussion about activation polarization, Ohmic loss, and the losses due to mass transport resistance. In the fourth section, the coupled processes of flow, heat/mass transfer, chemical reaction, and electrochemistry, which influence the performance of a fuel cell, are analyzed, and modeling and numerical computation for the fields of flow, temperature, and species concentration, which collectively determine the local and overall electromotive force in a solid oxide fuel cell, are examined in detail.
1 Introduction A fuel cell is a device that converts the chemical energy of a fuel oxidation reaction directly into electricity. It is substantially different from a conventional thermal power plant, where the fuel is oxidized in a combustion process and a thermalmechanical-electrical energy conversion process is employed. Therefore, unlike heat engines that are subjected to the Carnot cycle efficiency limitation, fuel cells can have energy conversion efficiencies generally higher than that of heat engines [1].
2 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 1: Principle of operation of a SOFC. Ideally, the Gibbs free energy change of fuel oxidation is directly converted into electricity [1, 2] in a fuel cell. As is common in many kinds of fuel cells, the core component of a solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) is a thin gas-tight ion conducting electrolyte layer sandwiched by a porous anode and cathode, as shown in Fig. 1. For a SOFC, this electrolyte is a solid oxide material that only allows the passage of charge-carrying oxide ions. To produce useful electrical work, free electrons released in the oxidation of a fuel at the anode must travel to the cathode through an external load/circuit. Therefore, the electrolyte must conduct ions while preventing electrons released at the anode from returning back to the cathode by the same route. The oxide ions are driven across the electrolyte by the chemical potential difference on the two sides of the electrolyte, which is due to the oxidation of fuel at the anode. This difference in the chemical potential is proportional to the electromotive force across the electrolyte, which, therefore, sets up a terminal voltage across the external load/circuit. The solid oxide electrolyte has sufficient ion conductivity only at high temperatures (from 600–1000 ◦ C). The high operating temperature of a SOFC also ensures rapid fuel-side reaction kinetics without requiring an expensive catalyst. In addition, the high temperature exhaust from a SOFC can be directed to a gas turbine (GT); thus, using a SOFC-GT hybrid system, one can achieve an efficiency of at least 66.3% based on the lower heating value (LHV, which means that the electrochemical product, water, is in a gaseous state) of the SOFC [3–6]. Since it operates via transport of oxide ions rather than that of fuel-derived ions, in principle, a SOFC can be used to oxidize a number of gaseous fuels. In particular, a SOFC can consume CO as well as hydrogen as its fuel, and therefore can be fueled with reformer gas containing a mix of CO and H2 [7, 8]. Recently, ammonia has also been reported as a fuel for SOFCs [9]. Since a SOFC operates under high temperatures, its energy conversion efficiency and component safety are both of concern to industry. In the following sections, the issues to be discussed will include: (1) the thermodynamic and electrochemical fundamentals of the energy conversion and species variation, (2) the potential losses in practical operation, (3) the influence of fluid flow and heat and mass transfer on operational efficiency and safety, and (4) the creation of a numerical model to simulate the performance and the fields of flow, temperature, and species concentration.
3
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
2 Thermodynamic and electrochemical fundamentals for solid oxide fuel cells To study the energy conversion efficiency and distribution of the conversion processes in a fuel cell, one must understand the basic principles. The chemical potential and, thereof, electromotive force across the electrolyte involve the interrelation of thermodynamics, electrochemistry, ion/electron conduction, and heat/mass transfer. In this section, the fundamentals of thermodynamics and the electrochemistry for a solid oxide fuel cell system are reviewed. The isothermal oxidation of a fuel A with oxidant B can be expressed by the following equation: aA + bB + · · · → xX + yY + · · ·.
(1)
The systematic changes of enthalpy, Gibbs free energy, and entropy production in the reaction are related by H = T S + G.
(2)
In a solid oxide fuel cell, the operating temperature is from 600 ◦ C to 1000 ◦ C and the pressure of gases is relatively not high. Thus, the gas species of reactants and products can be treated as ideal gases, which allows the chemical enthalpy change to be expressed as: H = (xhX + yhY + · · ·) − (ahA + bhB + · · ·),
(3)
where the h is the specific enthalpy. When a gas is pure, ideal, and at 1 atm, it is said to be in its standard state. The standard state is designated by writing a superscript 0 after the symbol of interest [10]. The Gibbs free energy which pertains to one mole of a chemical species is called the chemical potential. For an ideal gas at temperature of T and pressure of p, the chemical potential is expressed as: g = g 0 + RT ln
p , p0
(4)
where R is the gas constant and p0 is the standard pressure of 1 atm. One may omit the p0 in the denominator of the logarithm in eqn (4), but in such a case, the pressure p must be measured in atm. The systematic change of the Gibbs free energy in eqn (1) can be expressed in terms of the standard state Gibbs free energy and the partial pressures of the reactants and products: G = (xgX + ygY + · · ·) − (agA + bgB + · · ·) = [xgX0 + ygY0 + · · ·] − [agA0 + bgB0 + · · ·] + RT ln = G 0 + RT ln
(pX /p0 )x (pY /p0 )y · · · , (pA /p0 )a (pB /p0 )b · · ·
(pX /p0 )x (pY /p0 )y · · · (pA /p0 )a (pB /p0 )b · · · (5)
4 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells where G 0 = (xgX0 + ygY0 + · · ·) − (agA0 + bgB0 + · · ·),
(6)
which is the Gibbs free energy change of the standard reaction at temperature T (i.e., with each reactant supplied and each product removed at the standard atmospheric pressure, p0 = 1 atm). The theoretical electromotive force (EMF) induced from the chemical potential (G) is the Nernst potential: E=
−G −G0 RT (pA /p0 )a (pB /p0 )b · · · , = + ln ne F ne F ne F (pX /p0 )x (pY /p0 )y · · ·
(7)
where F(=96486.7 C/mol) is Faraday’s constant. The first part of the righthand side of the standard reaction is also called the ideal potential, which is denoted by: −G0 E0 = , (8) ne F where ne is the number of electrons derived from a molecules of the fuel, when the fuel is oxidized in the reaction of eqn (1). While the Gibbs free energy change, −G, converts to electrical power, the entropy production, −T S, is the thermal energy that is released in the electrochemical oxidation of the fuel. Both the h and g 0 are solely functions of temperature for ideal gases, which are given in Tables 1(a) and 1(b) for the gas species involved in the reactions of a SOFC. While the electromotive force in a fuel cell is determinable from the chemical potentials as discussed above, the current to be withdrawn from a fuel cell, denoted by I , is directly related to the molar consumption rate of fuel and oxidant through the following expressions: mfuel =
I nfuel e F
;
mO2 =
I 2 nO e F
,
(9)
2 where nO e is for oxygen, and is the number of electrons per b molecules of oxygen is the number of obtained in the electrochemical reaction (in eqn (1)), and nfuel e electrons derived per a molecules of the fuel.
2.1 Operation with hydrogen fuel If a SOFC operates on hydrogen gas, the oxidation of hydrogen is the only electrochemical reaction in the fuel cell, which may be expressed by the following chemical equation: 1 H2 + O2 = H2 O (gas). (10) 2
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
5
Table 1(a): Enthalpy and standard state Gibbs free energy of species. Formula weight
CO 28.01
CO2 44.01
H2 2.016
T (K)
h (kJ/k mol)
g◦ (kJ/k mol)
h (kJ/k mol)
g◦ (kJ/k mol)
h (kJ/k mol)
g◦ (kJ/k mol)
298.15 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 550 600 650 700 750 800 850 900 950 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600 1700 1800 1900
−110530 −110476 −109892 −109309 −108725 −108141 −107555 −106967 −106377 −105887 −105195 −104599 −103102 −101588 −100053 −98507 −96938 −95353 −93749 −92129 −90499 −88840 −85495 −82100 −78662 −75187 −71680 −68145 −64585 −61004 −57404
−169474 −169816 −173796 −177819 −181877 −185927 −190035 −194201 −198337 −202671 −206763 −210999 −221737 −232568 −243573 −254677 −265838 −277193 −288569 −300119 −311659 −323340 −346965 −370940 −395082 −419587 −444280 −469265 −494515 −519824 −545324
−393510 −393441 −392687 −391916 −391128 −390326 −389507 −388675 −387827 −386966 −386094 −385205 −382938 −380603 −378207 −375756 −373250 −370704 −368112 −365480 −362821 −360113 −354626 −349037 −343362 −337614 −331805 −325941 −320030 −314079 −308091
−457254 −457641 −461967 −466308 −470688 −475142 −479627 −484141 −488719 −493318 −497982 −502655 −514498 −526583 −538822 −551316 −564800 −576704 −589622 −602720 −615996 −629413 −656576 −684317 −712432 −741094 −770105 −799541 −829350 −859479 −889871
0 53 630 1209 1791 2373 2959 3544 4131 4715 5298 5882 6760 8811 10278 11749 13223 14702 16186 17676 19175 20680 23719 26797 29918 33082 36290 39541 42835 46169 49541
−38968 −39217 −41866 −44521 −47241 −49953 −52721 −55508 −58305 −61157 −64062 −66968 −74970 −81849 −89432 −97171 −104977 −112898 −121004 −129114 −137290 −145520 −162291 −179363 −196672 −214158 −231910 −249899 −268095 −286471 −305189
The Nernst potential from this electrochemical reaction will be: E(H2 +1/2O2 =H2 O) =
RT ln( pH2 /p0 )anode 2F 2F 0 + ln( pO2 /p0 )0.5 cathode − ln( pH2 O /p )anode . 0 −G(H 2 +1/2O
2 =H2 O)
+
(11)
The ideal chemical potentials at the temperature T (K) can be calculated from the data given by handbooks [11]. As a convenient reference, Table 1(c) gives the
6 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells Table 1(b): Enthalpy and standard state Gibbs free energy of species. O2 31.999
Formula weight T (K) 298.15 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 550 600 650 700 750 800 850 900 950 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600 1700 1800 1900
H2 O (Gas) 18.015
CH4 16.043
h (kJ/k mol)
g◦ (kJ/k mol)
h (kJ/k mol)
g◦ (kJ/k mol)
h (kJ/k mol)
g◦ (kJ/k mol)
0 54 643 1234 1828 2425 3025 3629 4236 4847 5463 6084 7653 9244 10859 12499 14158 15835 17531 19241 20965 22703 26212 29761 33344 36957 40599 44266 47958 51673 55413
−61151 −61536 −65661 −69826 −74024 −78325 −82495 −86797 −91112 −95433 −99849 −104266 −115382 −126656 −138056 −149551 −161117 −172885 −184684 −196669 −208745 −220897 −245378 −270239 −295426 −320883 −346551 −372374 −398632 −424967 −451507
−241814 −241752 −241079 −240404 −239726 −239045 −238362 −237675 −236985 −236291 −235592 −234889 −233115 −231313 −229493 −227622 −225732 −223812 −221860 −219876 −217860 −215814 −211623 −207308 −202872 −198321 −193663 −188906 −184056 −179121 −174108
−298105 −298452 −302263 −306126 −309998 −313943 −317882 −321885 −325865 −329947 −334040 −338139 −348890 −359173 −369828 −380712 −391707 −402852 −414130 −425526 −436930 −448514 −471993 −495908 −520072 −544681 −569563 −594826 −620276 −646221 −672288
– −74448 −73718 −72974 −72213 −71432 −70631 −69808 −68962 −68094 −67202 −66287 −63892 −61356 −58671 −55853 −52897 −49818 −46613 −43296 −39866 −36336 −28981 −21274 −13254 −4956 3587 12347 21295 30406 39658
– −130398 −134166 −137948 −141801 −145684 −149591 −153598 −157578 −161658 −165698 −169837 −180327 −191016 −201899 −213073 −224347 −235898 −247638 −259566 −271666 −283936 −309041 −334834 −361264 −388416 −416113 −444293 −473235 −502574 −532432
ideal chemical potentials and enthalpies for the gas species that are typically utilized in a SOFC. Recognizing the electrochemical equilibrium in the anode gas mixture: 0 + RT ln( pH2 /p0 )anode + ln( pO2 /p0 )0.5 G = −G(H anode 2 +1/2O2 =H2 O) (12) − ln( pH2 O /p0 )anode = 0.
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
7
Table 1(c): Change of enthalpy and standard state Gibbs free energy of reactions. Reaction T (K) 298.15 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 550 600 650 700 750 800 850 900 950 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600 1700 1800 1900
H2 + 1/2O2 = H2 O (gas)
CH4 + H2 O = 3H2 + CO
CO + H2 O = H2 + CO2
H (kJ/mol)
G 0 (kJ/mol)
E0 (V)
H (kJ/mol)
G 0 (kJ/mol)
H (kJ/mol)
G 0 (kJ/mol)
−241.814 −241.832 −242.031 −242.230 −242.431 −242.631 −242.834 −243.034 −243.234 −243.430 −243.622 −243.813 −243.702 −244.746 −245.201 −245.621 −246.034 −246.432 −246.812 −247.173 −247.518 −247.846 −248.448 −248.986 −249.462 −249.882 −250.253 −250.580 −250.870 −251.127 −251.356
−228.561 −228.467 −227.567 −226.692 −225.745 −224.828 −223.914 −222.979 −222.004 −221.074 −220.054 −219.038 −216.229 −213.996 −211.368 −208.766 −206.172 −203.512 −200.784 −198.078 −195.268 −192.546 −187.013 −181.426 −175.687 −170.082 −164.378 −158.740 −152.865 −147.267 −141.346
1.184 1.184 1.179 1.175 1.170 1.165 1.160 1.155 1.150 1.146 1.140 1.135 1.121 1.109 1.095 1.082 1.068 1.055 1.040 1.026 1.012 0.998 0.969 0.940 0.910 0.881 0.852 0.823 0.792 0.763 0.732
– 205.883 206.795 207.696 208.587 209.455 210.315 211.148 211.963 212.643 213.493 214.223 214.185 217.514 218.945 220.215 221.360 222.383 223.282 224.071 224.752 225.350 226.266 226.873 227.218 227.336 227.266 227.037 226.681 226.218 225.669
– 141.383 137.035 132.692 128.199 123.841 119.275 114.758 110.191 105.463 100.789 96.073 82.570 72.074 59.858 47.595 35.285 22.863 10.187 −2.369 −14.934 −27.450 −52.804 −78.287 −103.762 −128.964 −154.334 −179.843 −205.289 −230.442 −256.171
– −41.160 −41.086 −40.994 −40.886 −40.767 −40.631 −40.489 −40.334 −40.073 −40.009 −39.835 −39.961 −38.891 −38.383 −37.878 −37.357 −36.837 −36.317 −35.799 −35.287 −34.779 −33.789 −32.832 −31.910 −31.024 −30.172 −29.349 −28.554 −27.785 −27.038
– −28.590 −27.774 −26.884 −26.054 −25.225 −24.431 −23.563 −22.822 −21.857 −21.241 −20.485 −18.841 −16.691 −14.853 −13.098 −12.232 −9.557 −7.927 −6.189 −4.697 −3.079 0.091 3.168 6.050 9.016 11.828 14.651 17.346 20.095 22.552
Substituting eqn (12) into eqn (11), the Nernst potential in another form for the electrochemical reaction of eqn (10) is obtained: RT 0 0.5 E(H2 +1/2O2 =H2 O) = (13) ln( pO2 /p0 )0.5 cathode − ln( pO2 /p )anode . 2F Since the oxygen partial pressure at the anode is very low (on the order of 10−22 bar) due to the anode reaction [2], it does not cause an appreciable effect on the partial pressures of the other major species in the anode flow. Therefore, when calculating the partial pressures of hydrogen and water vapor for determining the Nernst potential of the electrochemical reaction of eqn (10), the oxygen partial pressure in anode flow stream is ignorable. Hereafter, for an electrochemical reaction
8 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells as in eqn (1), the common practice in determining the Nernst potential will be to use eqn (7), in which the partial pressure of oxygen on the cathode side and those of the fuel and product species on the anode side are used. The molar consumption rate of hydrogen and oxygen in the electrochemical reaction of eqn (10) can be easily derived from eqn (9) as: mH2 =
I ; 2F
mO2 =
I . 4F
(14)
2.2 Operation with methane through internal reforming and shift reactions As previously mentioned, it is necessary to have a high operating temperature in a solid oxide fuel cell in order to maintain sufficient ionic conductivity for the solid oxide electrolyte [2, 4]. This provides a favorable environment for the reforming of hydrocarbon fuels like methane. In fact, since a solid oxide fuel cell operates based on the transport of oxide ions through the electrolyte layer from the cathode side to the anode side, the reforming products of hydrogen and carbon monoxide in the fuel channel can both serve as fuels. Given this advantage, solid oxide fuel cells can directly utilize hydrocarbon fuels or, at least, methane as a pre-reformed or partly reformed gas with components of CH4 , CO, CO2 , H2 and H2 O. Therefore, the fuel reforming and shift reactions will occur in the fuel channel in a solid oxide fuel cell. The anode is, in fact, a good material to serve as the catalyst for such chemical reactions, since the high temperature in a SOFC means that no noble metals are needed for a catalyst [12]. If there are five gas species, CH4 , CO, CO2 , H2 , and H2 O, in the fuel channel, the solid oxide fuel cell will operate with internal reforming and shift reactions. Therefore, the electrochemical reaction and the coexisting chemical reactions of reforming and shift need to be considered for determining the species’mole fractions (which are crucial to the electromotive forces in the fuel cell). Reforming :
Shift :
CH 4 + H2 O ↔ CO + 3H2 . CO + H2 O ↔ CO2 + H2 .
(15)
(16)
Since the high operating temperature of a SOFC ensures rapid fuel reaction kinetics, it is a common practice to assume that the reforming and shift reactions are in chemical equilibrium [4] when determining the mole fractions of the species, which makes the computation significantly convenient. From the concept of chemical equilibrium, the reactants and products must satisfy the condition of G = 0. Therefore, the mole fractions or partial pressures of the five gas species in the fuel stream are related through the following two simultaneous equations [13]: p 3
KPR =
pCO p0 p p CH4 H2 O p0 p0 H2 p0
= exp −
0 Greforming
RT
,
(17)
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
p
KPS
CO2 p0
p H2
0 Gshift p = exp − = H2 O pCO RT p0
p0
9
.
(18)
p0
The dominant electrochemical reaction has been reported to be the oxidation of H2 [12], which is primarily responsible for the electromotive force. However, at the same time, the electrochemical oxidation of the CO is also possible, and likely occurs to some extent in the solid oxide fuel cell. It has been reported that fuel cells operated by using mixtures of CO and CO2 have shown that the electrochemical oxidation of CO is an order of magnitude slower than that of hydrogen [14]. Nevertheless, there is no necessity to distinguish whether the electrochemical oxidation process involves H2 or CO in order to formulate the electromotive force. The following discussion will clarify this point. When the shift reaction of eqn (16) in the anodic gas is in chemical equilibrium, there is
pCO2 pH 2 0 0 G = gCO2 + RT ln + gH2 + RT ln p0 p0
pCO pH2 O 0 0 + g = 0. (19) + RT ln + RT ln − gCO H2 O p0 p0 Rearranging this equation gives:
pCO2 pCO 0 0 gCO − g + RT ln + RT ln CO 2 p0 p0
pH2 O pH2 0 0 = gH2 O + RT ln − gH2 + RT ln . p0 p0
(20)
1/2
Subtracting a term of [(1/2)gO0 2 +RT ln( pO2 /p0 )cathode ] from both sides of eqn (20), results in: pCO pO2 1/2 1 0 pCO2 0 0 − RT ln − RT ln gCO2 − gCO − gO2 + RT ln 2 p0 p0 p0 cathode 1 pH 2 O = gH0 2 O − gH0 2 − gO0 2 + RT ln 2 p0 pO2 1/2 pH2 − RT ln − RT ln . (21) p0 p0 cathode It is easy to see that the left-hand side of eqn (17) is the Gibbs free energy change of the electrochemical oxidation of CO, and the right-hand side is that for H2 . Dividing by (2F) on both sides, eqn (17) is further reduced to: E(H2 +1/2O2 =H2 O) = E(CO+1/2O2 =CO2 ) ,
(22)
10 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells where E(H2 +1/2O2 =H2 O) is given in eqn (11), while the Nernst potential for the electrochemical oxidation of CO is E(CO+1/2O2 =CO2 ) =
RT ln (pCO /p0 )anode 2F 2F 0 + ln (pO2 /p0 )0.5 cathode − ln (pCO2 /p )anode . 0 −G(CO+1/2O 2 =CO2 )
+
(23)
It is preferable that the EMF of an internal reforming SOFC be calculated from the electrochemical oxidation of H2 ; however, the species’consumption and production are the results collectively determined from the reactions of eqns (10), (15) and (16). The above discussion clearly indicates that the electrochemical reaction can be assumed to be driven by the hydrogen, and the electrochemical fuel value of CO is readily exchanged for hydrogen by the shift reaction under chemical equilibrium. Therefore, only H2 is considered as the electrochemical fuel in the following analysis, and CO only takes part in the shift reaction. For convenience, the mole flow rates of CH4 , CO and H2 are denoted by their formulae. Assuming that, x¯ , y¯ , and z¯ are the mole flow rates, respectively, for the CH4 , CO, and H2 that are consumed in the three reactions given by eqns (15), (16) and (10) in the fuel channel, the coupled variations of the five species between the inlet and the outlet of an interested section of fuel channel are in the following forms [8, 15]: CH4 out = CH4 in − x¯ ,
(24)
COout = COin + x¯ − y¯ ,
(25)
= CO2 + y¯ , in
(26)
H2 out = H2 in + 3¯x + y¯ − z¯ ,
(27)
H2 Oout = H2 Oin − x¯ − y¯ + z¯ .
(28)
CO2
out
The overall mole flow rate of fuel, denoted by Mf , will vary from the inlet to the outlet of the section of interest in the fuel channel in the form of Mfout = Mfin + 2¯x.
(29)
Meanwhile, the partial pressures of the species, proportional to the mole fractions, must satisfy eqns (15) and (16) at the outlet of the section, which thus gives: KPR =
COin +¯x−¯y Mfin +2¯x
CH4 in −¯x Mfin +2¯x
H2 in +3¯x+¯y−¯z Mfin +2¯x
3 2
H2 Oin −¯x−¯y+¯z Mfin +2¯x
p p0
,
(30)
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
KPS =
H2 in +3¯x+¯y−¯z Mfin +2¯x
COin +¯x−¯y Mfin +2¯x
CO2 in +¯y Mfin +2¯x
11
H2 Oin −¯x−¯y+¯z Mfin +2¯x
,
(31)
where the p is the overall pressure of the fuel flow in the section of interest. Since, as discussed in the preceding section, the oxidation of H2 is responsible for the electrochemical reaction, the consumption of hydrogen is directly related to the charge transfer rate, or current, I , across the electrolyte layer: z¯ = I /(2F).
(32)
From the electrochemical reaction, the molar consumption of oxygen on the cathode side can be calculated by using eqn (14). By finding a simultaneous solution for eqns (30)–(32), the species variations, x¯ , y¯ and z¯ , can be determined. Finally, with the reacted mole numbers of CH4 and CO determined, the heat absorbed in the reforming reaction and released from the shift reaction can be obtained: QReforming = H Reforming · x¯ ,
(33)
Q Shift = H Shift · y¯ .
(34)
Nevertheless, prior to finding a solution for eqns (30) and (31), the electric current of the fuel cell in eqn (32) must be known. This demonstrates that the processes in a SOFC feature a strong coupling of the species molar variation and the electromotive force, as well as interdependency of the ion conduction and current flow. The ion transfer rate or current conduction in a SOFC will be discussed in Section 3.
3 Electrical potential losses The ideal efficiency is never attained in practical operation for any fuel cell. In fact, there are three potential drops in a fuel cell that cause the actual output potential to be lower than the ideal electromotive forces of the electrochemical reaction. The nature of the fuel cell performance in response to loading condition can be realized by its polarization curve, typically shown as in Fig. 2. With an increase in current density, the cell potential experiences three kinds of potential losses due to different dominant resistances. The potential drop due to the activation resistance, which is the activation polarization, is associated with the electrochemical reactions in the system. Another potential drop comes from the ohmic resistance in the fuel cell components, when the ions and electrons are conducted in the electrolyte and electrodes, respectively. The third drop, which can be sharp at high current densities, is attributable to the mass transport resistance, or concentration polarization, in the flow of the fuel and oxidant. It is known from observing the Nernst equation that the electromotive force of a fuel cell is a function of the temperature and the gas species’ partial pressures at the electrolyte/electrode
12 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 2: Over-potential in the operation of a fuel cell.
interfaces, which are directly proportional to their mole fractions. It is important to note that, in the fuel stream, fuel must be transported or diffused from the core region of the stream to the anode surface, and, also, the product of the electrochemical reaction must conversely be transported or diffused from the reaction site to the core region of the fuel flow. On the cathode side, oxygen must be transported and diffused from the core region of airflow to the cathode surface. Along with the fuel and air streams, the consumption of reactants or development of products will make the mole fractions of reactants decrease and those of the product increase. Due to these resistances in the mass transport process, the feeding of reactants and removing of products to/from the reaction site can only proceed under a large concentration gradient between the bulk flow and the electrode surface when the current density is high, which therefore induces a sharp drop in the fuel cell potential. As a consequence of all the above-mentioned potential drops, extra thermal energy will be released together with the heat (−T S) from systematic entropy production. The heat transfer issues in a solid oxide fuel cell will be considered later in Section 4. 3.1 Activation polarization The activation polarization is the electronic barrier that must be overcome prior to current and ion flow in the fuel cell. Chemical reactions, including electrochemical reactions, also involve energy barriers, which must be overcome by the reacting species. The activation polarization may also be viewed as the extra potential necessary to overcome the energy barrier of the rate-determining step of the reaction to a value such that the electrode reaction proceeds at a desired rate [16–18].
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
13
The Butler-Volmer equation is a well-known expression for the activation polarization, ηAct :
ne FηAct ne FηAct − exp −(1 − β) , (35) i = i0 exp β RT RT where β, which is usually 0.5 for the fuel cell application [16], is the transfer coefficient; i is the actual current density in the fuel cell; and i0 is the exchange current density. The transfer coefficient is considered to be the fraction of the change in polarization that leads to a change in the reaction-rate constant. The exchange current density, i0 , is the forward and reverse electrode reaction rate at the equilibrium potential. A high exchange current density means that a high electrochemical reaction rate and good fuel cell performance can be expected. The ne in eqn (35) is the number of electrons transferred per reaction, which is 2 for the reaction of eqn (10). Substituting the value of β = 0.5 into eqn (35), one can obtain a new expression as follows: ne FηAct (36) i = 2i0 sinh 2RT from which the activation polarization can be expressed as: 2 i i 2RT 2RT i or ηAct = + + 1. ηAct = sinh−1 ln ne F 2i0 ne F 2i0 2i0 (37) For a high activation polarization, eqn (37) can be approximated as the simple and well-known Tafel equation [16]: 2RT i ηAct = . (38) ln ne F i0 On the other hand, if the activation polarization is small, eqn (37) can be approximated as the linear current-potential expression [16]: ηAct =
2RT i . ne F i0
(39)
Nevertheless, eqn (37) is recommended for its integrity and accuracy in calculating the activation polarization. The value of the exchange current density (i0 ) is different for the anode and cathode, and is also dependent on the electrochemical reaction temperature, the partial pressures of the gases [18, 19], and the electrode materials. The determination for i0 shows diversity in different literature [16–22]. There are formulations available in the literature [18–20], but some parameters used in the formulation are not well documented. On the other hand, empirical estimation of i0 is also
14 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells made in literature, like the work of Chan et al. [16]. An i0 of 5300 A/m2 for the anode and 2000 A/m2 for the cathode for a SOFC were used; however there was no comment on the selection methodology for setting these values in the paper [16]. Keegan et al. [17] also adjusted the i0 so as to obtain a simulation result to satisfy their experimental data; no report, however, is given about the adjusted i0 values in their paper. The present authors used a slightly higher value of 6300 A/m2 and 3000 A/m2 [23, 24], respectively, for the i0 of the anode and cathode, which resulted in very good agreement between the numerical simulated cell terminal voltage and experimental results from different researchers [25–28]. Nevertheless, i0 varies according to the temperature and pressures of the electrochemical reaction. For SOFCs working at temperature from 800 ◦ C–1000 ◦ C and pressures up to 15 atm, an i0 of 5300–6300 A/m2 for the anode and 2000–3000 A/m2 for the cathode are recommended from the study by the present authors [23]. 3.2 Ohmic loss The ohmic loss comes from the electric resistances of the electrodes and the current collecting components, as well as the ionic conduction resistance of the electrolyte layer. Therefore, the conductivity of the materials for the cell components and the current collecting pathway are the two factors most influential to the overall ohmic loss of a SOFC. In state-of-the-art SOFC technology, lanthanum manganite suitably doped with alkaline and rare earth elements is used for the cathode (air electrode) [20, 27], yttria stabilized zirconia (YSZ) has been most successfully employed for electrolyte, and nickel/YSZ is applied over the electrolyte to form the anode. Temperature could significantly affect the conductivity of SOFC materials. Especially for the electrolyte, for example, the resistivity could be two orders of magnitude smaller if its temperature increases from 600 ◦ C to 1000 ◦ C. The equations of resistivity for SOFC components suggested in literature are collected in Table 2.
Table 2: Data and equations for resistivity of SOFC components. Cathode ( · cm) Bessette et al. [29] Ahmed et al. [30] Nagata et al. [18] Ferguson et al. [31]
Electrolyte ( · cm)
Anode ( · cm)
Interconnect ( · cm)
0.008114e500/T
0.00294e10350/T
0.00298e−1392/T
–
∗ 0.0014
0.3685 + 0.002838e10300/T
∗ 0.0186
∗ 0.5
∗ 0.1
10.0e[10092(1/T −1/1273)]
∗ 0.013
∗ 0.5
T e1200/T 4.2×105
1 e10300/T 3.34×102
T e1150/T 9.5×105
T e1100/T 9.3×104
∗At temperature of 1000 ◦ C.
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
15
A careful check for the equations in Table 2 was conducted. The expressions by Bessette et al. [29] were found to be reliable, and to give nearly identical predictions as those by Ahmed et al. [30] and Nagata et al. [18]. The predicted data for anode resistivity by the equation of Ferguson et al. [31] shows significant discrepancies with the predictions by other equations. It is rational to assume that the passage of the charge-carrying species through the electrolyte, or the ion conduction through the electrolyte, is a charge transfer, like a current flow. In a planar type SOFC, as shown in Fig. 3, the current collects through the channel walls, also called ribs, after it moves perpendicularly across the electrolyte layer. The network circuit for current flow modeled by Iwata et al. [19] considers the channel walls as current collection pathways in a planar SOFC. However, the height and the width of the gas channel are both small (less than 3 mm), and the electric resistance through the channel wall might be negligible [30]. This simplification leads to the consideration that the current is almost exclusively perpendicularly collected, which means that the current flows normally to the trilayer of the cathode, electrolyte and anode. When calculating the local current density, the ohmic loss is thus simply accounted for in the following way [30]: I = A ·
(E − ηaAct − ηcAct ) − Vcell , (δa ρea + δe ρee + δc ρec )
(40)
where A is a unit area on the anode/electrolyte/cathode tri-layer, through which the current I passes; δ is the thickness of the individual layers; ρe is the resistivity of the electrodes and electrolyte; Vcell is the cell terminal voltage; and the denominator of the right-hand side term is the summation of the resistance of the tri-layer. The Joule heating due to current flow in the volume of A×δ is expressed for the anode in the form of a QOhmic = I 2 · (δa ρea /A). (41) This is also applicable to the electrolyte and cathode by replacing the thickness and resistivity accordingly.
Figure 3: Schematic of a planar type SOFC.
16 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 4: Schematic of a tubular SOFC.
Figure 5: Ion/electron conduction network in a tubular SOFC. In case the current pathway is relatively long in a fuel cell, as, for example, in a tubular type SOFC (shown in Fig. 4), the current collects circumferentially, which leads to a much longer pathway [32] compared to that of a planar type SOFC. In order to account for the ohmic loss and the Joule heating of the current flow in the circumferential pathway, a network circuit [23, 25, 33, 34] for current flow may be adopted, as shown in Fig. 5. Because the current collection is symmetric in the peripheral direction in the cell components, only half of the tube shell is deployed with a mesh in the analysis. The local current routing from the anode to cathode through the electrolyte is determinable based on the local electromotive force, EMF, the local potentials in the anode and cathode, and the ionic resistance of the electrolyte layer, which yields the expression: I=
E − ηaAct − ηcAct − (V c − V a ) , Re
(42)
where V a and V c are the potentials in the anode and cathode, respectively. Re is the ionic resistance of the electrolyte layer given a thickness of δe and a unit
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
17
area of A: Re = ρee · δe /A,
(43)
ρee
where the is the ionic resistivity of the electrolyte. In order to obtain the local current across the electrolyte by using eqn (35), supplemental equations for V a and V c are necessary. Applying Kirchhoff’s law of current to any grid located in the anode, the equation associating the potential of the central grid point P with the potentials of its neighboring points (east, west, north, south) and the corresponding grid P in the cathode can be obtained:
a VSa − VPa VN − VPa VWa − VPa VEa − VPa + + + Rae Raw Ran Ras VPc − VPa − (EP − ηPAct ) + = 0. ReP
(44)
In the same way for a grid point P in the cathode:
c VSc − VPc VEc − VPc VN − VPc VWc − VPc + + + Rce Rcw Rcn Rcs VPa − VPc + (EP − ηPAct ) + = 0, ReP
(45)
where Ra and Rc are the discretized resistances in the anode and cathode respectively, which are determined according to the resistivity, the length of the current path, and the area upon which the current acts; ηPAct is the total activation polarization, including from both the anode side and the cathode side. With all of the equations for the discretized grids in both the cathode and anode given, a matrix representing the pair of eqns (37) and (38) can be created. When finding a solution for such a matrix equation for the potentials, the following approximations are useful: 1. At the two ends of the cell tube there is no longitudinal current flow, and, therefore, an insulation condition is applicable. 2. At the symmetric plane A–A, as shown in Figs 4 and 5, there is no peripheral current in the cathode and anode, unless the cathode or anode is in contact with nickel felt, through which the current flows in or out. 3. The potentials of the nickel felts are assumed to be uniform due to their high electric conductivities. 4. Since the potential difference between the two nickel felts is the cell terminal voltage, the potential at the nickel felt in contact with the anode layer can be assumed to be zero. Thus, the potential at the nickel felt in contact with the cathode will be the terminal voltage of the fuel cell. Once all the local electromotive forces are obtained, the only unknown condition for the equation matrix is either the total current flowing out from the cell or
18 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells the potential at the nickel felt in contact with the cathode. This highlights two approaches that can be taken when predicting the performance of a SOFC. If the total current taken out from the cell is prescribed as the initial condition, the terminal voltage can be predicted. On the other hand, one can prescribe the terminal voltage and predict the total current, i.e., the summation of the local current I across the entire electrolyte layer. Once the potentials are obtained in the electrode layer, the volumetric Joule heating in the electrode for a volume centered about P will be: (VWa − VPa )2 (VNa − VPa )2 1 (VEa − VPa )2 a + + q˙ P = 2 Rae Raw Ran (V a − V a )2 (xP · r a · θP · δa ), + S a P (46) Rs (VWc − VPc )2 (VNc − VPc )2 1 (VEc − VPc )2 c + + q˙ P = 2 Rce Rcw Rcn (VSc − VPc )2 (xP · r c · θP · δc ), + (47) Rcs P − V c + V a )2 − η (E P P P Act q˙ Pe = (xP · r e · θP · δe ), (48) ReP where the r and δ with the corresponding superscripts of a , c , and e are the average, radius and thickness, respectively, for the anode, cathode and electrolyte, and xP and θP are the P-controlled mesh size in the axial and peripheral directions, as shown in Fig. 5. The volumetric heat induced from the activation polarization in the anode and cathode is: P,a a a q˙ Act = IP · ηP,a Act /(xP · r · θP · δ ),
(49)
P,c c c = IP · ηP,c q˙ Act Act /(xP · r · θP · δ ).
(50)
The thermodynamic heat generation occurring at the anode/electrolyte interface in the area around P is: QPR = (H − G) · IP /(2F).
(51)
3.3 Mass transport and concentration polarization Due to their gradual consumption, the fractions of the reactants and oxidant will decrease, in the fuel and air streams, respectively, which will cause the electromotive force to decrease gradually along the flow stream. On the other hand, due to the mass transport resistance, the concentration of the gas species will encounter polarization in between the core flow region and the electrode surface, which will result in lower partial pressures for the reactants, but higher partial pressures for the products at the
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
19
Figure 6: The interrelation amongst concentration and other parameters. electrode surfaces. Therefore, the fuel cell terminal voltage will be lower than the ideal value that is indicated by the Nernst equation. At high cell current density, the increased requirements for the feeding of the reactants and removal of the products can make the concentration polarization higher, and, thus, the cell output potential will sharply decrease. In order to take the concentration polarization into account when calculating the electromotive force, the local partial pressures of the reactants and products at the electrode surface are used. However, this requires the solution of the concentration fields for the gas species in the fuel and oxidizer channels, which might be either simply based on a one-dimensional [35–37] or else based on a complicated twoor three-dimensional solution for the mass conservation governing equations [23, 38–40]. In fact, the concentration fields are strongly coupled with the gas flow, temperature, and the distribution of the electromotive force in the ways indicated in Fig. 6. First, the gas species mass fraction determines the gas properties in the flow field, while the flow fields affect the gas species concentration distribution and temperature. Second, the gas species concentration field and temperature distribution determines the electromotive forces, while the ion/electron conduction due to the electromotive force determines the mass variation and heat generations in the fuel cell. The inter-dependency of these parameters will be discussed in detail in the following section when modeling a SOFC in order to predict both the fuel cell performance and the detailed distributions of the temperature, gas species concentration, and flow fields.
4 Computer modeling of a tubular SOFC An operation curve for a SOFC that characterizes the average current density versus the terminal voltage is very important when designing a SOFC system or a hybrid
20 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells SOFC/GT system [41–44]. Other information, like the temperature and concentration fields in a SOFC, is also of high concern for the safe operation of both the SOFC itself and the downstream facilities if a hybrid system is under consideration. Although there have been some experimental data generated about the operational performance and temperature of SOFCs [25–28], rigorous experimental testing for a SOFC is still rather tough because of its high operating temperature. Therefore, numerical modeling of SOFCs is very necessary. The purpose of computer simulation for a SOFC is to predict the operational characteristics in terms of the average current density versus the terminal voltage (based on prescribed operating conditions). The operating conditions of a SOFC are solely determined by fixing the flow rates and the thermodynamic state of the fuel and oxidant, as well as a load condition such as terminal voltage, the current being withdrawn, and external load [45]. The flow rates and thermodynamic conditions of the fuel and oxidant may be called internal conditions, and the terminal voltage, current to be withdrawn, and external load may be designated external conditions. Like any kind of “battery,” the external load condition of a SOFC determines the consumption of the fuel/oxidant and the generation of products in the electrochemical reaction [46]; the only difference in a fuel cell is its continuous feeding of fuel/oxidant and removal of products and waste species. According to the different ways of prescribing the external parameters, the following three schemes might be designed in order to predict the other unknown parameters when constructing a numerical model for a SOFC: (1) Use the internal conditions and terminal voltage to predict the total current to be withdrawn. (2) Use the internal conditions and current to be withdrawn to predict the terminal voltage. (3) Use the internal conditions and external load to predict the terminal voltage and current density. The cost of iterative computation using the three schemes is quite different. In the first scheme, the cell terminal voltage is known, and thus the local current can be obtained, for example, by using eqn (42) and solving eqns (44) and (45), for a planar and tubular type SOFC, respectively, once the temperature and partial pressure fields of the gas species are available. The integrated value from the local current will be the total current to be withdrawn from the SOFC. In the second scheme, however, the terminal voltage needs to be assumed, and then checked by integrating the total current from the local current until the calculated total current agrees with the prescribed value. In this computation process, a proper method is needed to find the best-fit terminal voltage iteratively. The third scheme resembles the second scheme, in that one needs to assume a terminal voltage to find the total current. The computation will be stopped only when the voltage-current ratio equals the prescribed load. With an understanding of the principles of the energy conversion, chemical equilibrium, potential loss, and the operation of a SOFC, a computer model for a SOFC can now be constructed. Generally speaking, the modeling and computation for a tubular SOFC and a planar SOFC share rather common features except for the Ohmic losses and Joule heating, for which differences result from the different structures variation in the current pathway in the electrodes. Relatively speaking,
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
21
the tubular SOFC has a more complex current pathway in the electrodes [27] and will be discussed in the following analysis. Modeling works on planar type SOFCs are available in both the current author’s work and in the literature [17, 19, 30, 31, 39, 47–49]. In the following subsections, there are three issues that address the construction of a numerical model. 4.1 Outline of a computation domain In a practical tubular SOFC stack, multiple tubular cells are mounted in a container to form a cell bundle, as shown in Fig. 7. A pre-reformer might be put adjacent to the cell bundles [50, 51]. In order to conduct a modeling study with relatively less complexity, it is assumed that most of the single tubular SOFCs operate under the same environment of temperature and concentrations of gas species. This allows the definition of a controllable domain in the cross-section, which pertains to one single cell, as outlined by the dashed-line square in Fig. 7. It is then specified that there must be no flow velocity and fluxes of heat and mass across the outline. This will significantly simplify the analysis for a cell stack. Through analysis of the heat/mass transfer and the chemical/electrochemical performance for the single cell and its controllable area, one can obtain results very useful for evaluating the performance of an entire cell stack. Also considering the longitudinal direction, the heat and mass transfer in the above outlined square area enclosing the tubular SOFC are three-dimensional in nature. For a solution of the three-dimensional governing equations of momentum, energy, and species conservation, a large number of discretized mesh points are necessary, which results in an unacceptably heavy computational load. In order to reduce computational cost, the square area enclosing the tubular SOFC is approximated to be an equivalent circular area; therefore, the domain enclosing the single tubular SOFC is viewed as a 2-dimensional axi-symmetric one, as seen in Fig. 7.
Figure 7: Schematic of a tubular SOFC in a cell stack.
22 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 8: Computation domain for a tubular SOFC.
It should be noted, though, that the zero-flux, or insulation of heat and mass transfer at the boundary remains unchanged, even given this geometric approximation. From the preceding discussions, an axi-symmetrical two-dimensional (x − r) computation domain is profiled as shown in Fig. 8, which includes two flow streams and a solid area of the cell tube and air-inducing tube. 4.2 Governing equations and boundary conditions Since the mass fractions of the species vary in the flow field, all of the thermal and transport properties of the fluids are functions of the local species concentration, temperature, and pressure; therefore, the governing equations for momentum, energy, and species conservation (based on mass fraction) have variable thermal and transport properties: ∂(ρu) 1 ∂(rρv) + = 0, ∂x r ∂r
∂(ρuu) 1 ∂(rρvu) ∂p ∂ ∂u 1 ∂ ∂u + =− + µ + rµ ∂x r ∂r ∂x ∂x ∂x r ∂r ∂r ∂ ∂u 1 ∂ ∂v + µ + rµ , ∂x ∂x r ∂r ∂x ∂(ρuv) 1 ∂(rρvv) ∂p ∂ ∂v 1 ∂ ∂v + =− + µ + rµ ∂x r ∂r ∂r ∂x ∂x r ∂r ∂r ∂ ∂u 1 ∂ ∂v 2µv + µ + rµ − 2 , ∂x ∂r r ∂r ∂r r ∂ ∂T 1 ∂ ∂T ∂(ρCpuT ) 1 ∂(rρCpvT ) + = λ + rλ + q˙ , ∂x r ∂r ∂x ∂x r ∂r ∂r
(52)
(53)
(54)
(55)
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
∂(ρuYJ ) 1 ∂(rρvYJ ) ∂YJ ∂ + = ρDJ ,m ∂x r ∂r ∂x ∂x
+
1 ∂ r ∂r
rρDJ ,m
∂YJ ∂r
23
+ SJ . (56)
These equations are applied universally to the entire computation domain; however, zero velocities will be assigned to the solid area in the numerical computation. In the energy conservation equation, thermal energy from the chemical and electrochemical reactions (expressed by eqns (33), (34), (51)) and the Joule heating in electrodes and electrolyte (expressed by eqns (46)–(50)), represented by q˙ , are introduced as source terms in the proper locations in the fuel cell. Some terms due to energy diffusion driven by the concentration diffusion of the gas species are very small, and thus neglected [52, 53]. The boundary conditions for the momentum, heat and mass conservation equations are as follows: 1. On the symmetrical axis, or at r = 0: v = 0, and ∂φ/∂r = 0, where φ represents general variables except for v. 2. At the outmost boundary of r = rfo : there are thermally adiabatic conditions; impermeability for species and non-chemical reaction are also assumed, which gives v = 0, and ∂φ/∂r = 0, where φ represents general variables except for v. 3. At x = 0: the fuel inlet has a prescribed uniform velocity, temperature, and species mass fraction; the solid part has u = 0, v = 0, ∂T /∂x = 0, and ∂YJ /∂x = 0. 4. At x = L: the air inlet has a prescribed uniform velocity, temperature and species mass fraction; the gas exit has v = 0, ∂u/∂x = 0, ∂T /∂x = 0, and ∂YJ /∂x = 0; the tube-end solid part has u = 0, v = 0, ∂T /∂x = 0, and ∂YJ /∂x = 0. 5. At the interfaces of the air/solid, r = rair , and fuel/anode, r = rf : u = 0 is assumed. In the fuel flow passage, the mass flow rate increases along the x direction due to the transferring in of oxide ions. Similarly, a reduction of the air flow rate occurs in the air flow passage, due to the ionization of oxygen and the transferring of the oxide ions to the fuel side. Therefore, radial velocities at r = rair and r = rf are: fuel,species m ˙x (57) vf = r=rf , fuel ρx air,species m ˙x r=r , vair = (58) air air ρx where m ˙ [kg/(m2 s)] is mass flux of the gas species at the interface of the electrodes and fluid, which arises from the electrochemical reaction in the fuel cell. The mass fractions of all participating chemical components at the boundaries of r = rair and r = rf are calculated with consideration of both diffusion and convection effects [54, 55]: ∂YJ (59) + ρxair YJ vair , m ˙ Jx ,air = −DJ ,air ρxair ∂r ∂YJ + ρxfuel YJ vf . m ˙ Jx , fuel = −DJ , fuel ρxfuel (60) ∂r
24 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells Table 3: Properties of SOFC materials. Thermal conductivity (W/(m K)) Cathode Electrolyte Anode Support tube Air-inducing tube Interconnector aAhmed
Cp (J/(kg K))
Density (kg/m3 )
d 11; c 2.0; b 2.0
b 623
a 4930
d 2.7; c 2.7; b 2.0
b 623
a 5710
c 11.0; d 6.0; b 2.0
b 623
a 4460
b 800
a 6320; b 7700
c 1.0 c 1.0 b 13; c 2.0; d 6.0
et al. [30]; b Recknagle et al. [39]; c Nagata et al. [18]; d Iwata et al. [19].
It is worth noting that the mass fluxes for the species in the above equations, eqns (57)–(60), strongly relate to the ion/electron conduction; the determination of mass variation and related mass flux that arise from the electrochemical reaction has been discussed (as expressed by eqns (30)–(32)) in Section 2. As a consequence, the mass/mole fraction at the solid/fluid interface, derived from eqns (59) and (60), will be used for the determination of the partial pressures and, thereof, the local electromotive forces by eqn (11). The properties of solid materials in a SOFC are given in Table 3, which show some variation based on the different literature sources. The single gas properties are available from references [11] and [56]. For gas mixtures, equations from references [11, 57] are available, and some selected equations from reference [11] for calculating the properties are listed in the following section. The mixing rule for the viscosity is: 1/2 1/4 2 n Mj µi Xi µ i Mi −1/2 1 n µm = 1+ ; φij = 1/2 1 + , M µ Mi X φ 8 j ij j j j=1 i=1
(61) where µm (Pa · sec) is the viscosity for the mixture, and µi or µj are the viscosities of individual species (Pa · sec); Mi or Mj is the molecular weight of a species; Xi or Xj is the mole fraction; and when i = j, φij = 1. The mixing rule for the thermal conductivity of gases at atmospheric pressure or less is: n Xi ki n km = ; j=1 Xj Aij i=1 (62) 1/2 2 3/4 T + Sij T + Si 1 µi Mj , Aij = 1+ T + Si 4 µj Mi T + Sj
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
25
where km [W/(m · K)] and ki [W/(m · K)] are the thermal conductivities of the mixture and species; Sij = C(Si Sj )1/2 , and C = 1.0, but when either or both components i and j are very polar, C = 0.73; for helium, hydrogen, and neon, Si or Sj is 79 K; otherwise, Si = 1.5Tbi and Sj = 1.5Tbj , where Tb is the boiling point temperature of species; and the unit of T is K. When the gas mixture is above atmospheric pressure, the following correction is applied to the km obtained above: k = k +
A × 10−4 (eBρr + C) , 1/6 Tc M 1/2 5 Z 2/3 c
(63)
Pc
ρr < 0.5, 0.5 < ρr < 2.0, 2.0 < ρr < 2.8,
A = 2.702, A = 2.528, A = 0.574,
B = 0.535, B = 0.670, B = 1.155,
C = −1.000, C = −1.069, C = 2.016,
where k [W/(m · K)] is the gas thermal conductivity at the temperature T (K) and pressure P of interest in the mixture; k [W/(m · K)] is the thermal conductivity at T and atmospheric pressure obtained by eqn (62); ρr = Vc /V is the reduced density; Vc (m3 /kmol) is the critical molar volume; V (m3 /kmol) is the molar volume at T and P; Tc (K) is the critical temperature; M is the molecular weight; Pc (MPa) is the critical pressure; Zc = Pc Vc /(RTc ) is the critical compressibility factor; and R is the gas constant, which is 0.008314 MPa · m3 /(kmol · K). The mixture critical properties are obtained via the following equations: n
Tcm − Tpc Pcm = Ppc + Ppc 5.808 + 4.93 , (64) Xi ωi Tpc i=1
Tcm =
n j=1
Vcm =
Xj Vcj n Tcj , i=1 Xi Vci
i
(65)
φi φj vij (i = j),
(66)
j
where 2/3
Xj Vcj φj = ; 2/3 n i=1 Xi Vci
vij =
Vij (Vci + Vcj ) ; 2.0
Vci − Vcj + C, Vij = −1.4684 V +V ci
cj
and C is zero for hydrocarbon systems and is 0.1559 for systems containing a non-hydrocarbon gas. In all the above equations, Xi or Xj is the mole fraction of a species in the mixture; ωi is the acentric factor of a species; Pcm , Tcm and Vcm are the mixture critical properties; and Ppc and Tpc are the pseudocritical properties of the mixture, which are expressed as: Tpc =
n i=1
Xi Tci ;
Ppc =
n i=1
Xi Pci .
(67)
26 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells Table 4: Atomic diffusion volumes for use in eqn (68). Atomic and structural diffusion-volume increments v [11] C H O N Aromatic ring Heterocyclic ring
16.50 1.98 5.481 5.69 −20.2 −20.2
H2 N2 O2 CO CO2 H2 O
7.07 17.9 16.6 18.9 26.9 12.7
The gas diffusivity of one species against the remaining species of a mixture is expressed in the form of:
Dim
1 − Xi = , jj=i Xj /Dij
0.5 0.01013T 1.75 M1i + M1j Dij = , P[( vi )1/3 + ( vj )1/3 ]2
(68)
where units of T , P, and D are K, Pa, and m2 /sec, respectively; Mi or Mj is the molecular weight; and all vi or vj are group contribution values for the subscript component summed over atoms, groups and structural features, which are listed in Table 4. 4.3 Numerical computation In order to conduct a numerical computation for flow, temperature, and concentration fields in a SOFC, a mesh system with a sufficient grid number both in the r and x directions must be deployed at the computational domain. All the governing equations may be discretized by using the finite volume approach, and the SIMPLE algorithm can be adopted to treat the coupling of the velocity and pressure fields [58, 59]. The temperature difference between the cell tube and the air-inducing tube might be large enough to have radiation heat transfer; therefore, a numerical treatment based on the method introduced in the literature [60] can be used to consider the radiation heat exchange. As has been discussed at the beginning of Section 4, the computation may be based on the internal conditions and the current to be withdrawn; and, as a consequence of the simulation, the terminal voltage will be given as an output along with other operational details. The convenience of using this procedure in the simulation is discussed next. It is quite common in practice that the total current is prescribed in terms of the average current density of the fuel cell. Also, instead of the flow rates of fuel and air, the stoichiometric data are prescribed in terms of the utilization percentage of hydrogen and oxygen. This kind of designation of the operating conditions results in a convenient comparison of the fuel cell performance based on the same level of
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
27
average current density and the hydrogen and oxygen utilization percentage. The inlet velocities of fuel and air are, then, obtainable in the forms of: RTf Acell icell ufuel = , (69) 2FUH2 XH2 Afuel Pf Acell icell RTair , (70) uair = 4FUO2 XO2 Aair Pair where icell is the cell current density; Acell is the outside surface area of the fuel cell; Afuel and Aair are the cross-sectional inlet areas of the fuel and air; Pf , Pair and Tf , Tair are the inlet pressure and temperature of the fuel and air flows respectively; XH2 and XO2 are the mole fractions of hydrogen in the fuel and oxygen in the air, respectively; and UH2 and UO2 are the utilization percentage for hydrogen and oxygen. The computation process is highly iterative and coupled in nature. As the first step, the latest local temperature, pressure, and species’ mass fractions are used in the network circuit analysis to obtain the cell terminal voltage and local current across the electrolyte, and thus the local species’ transfer fluxes and local heat sources. In the second step, the local temperature, pressure and species’ mass fractions are, in turn, obtained through solution of the governing equations under the new boundary conditions determined by the latest-available species’fluxes and heat sources. The two steps iterate until convergence is obtained. 4.4 Typical results from numerical computation for tubular SOFCs The present authors have conducted numerical computations for three different single tubular SOFCs [23], which have been tested by Hagiwara et al. [26], Hirano et al. [25], Singhal [27], and Tomlins et al. [28]. The fuel tested by Hirano et al. [25] had components of H2 , H2 O, CO and CO2 ; therefore, there is a water-shift reaction of the carbon monoxide in the fuel cell to be considered together with the electrochemical reaction. The fuel used by the other researchers [26–28] had components of H2 and H2 O, where there is no chemical reaction except for the electrochemical reaction in the fuel channel. The dimensions of the three different solid oxide fuel cells tested in their studies are summarized in Table 5, in which the mesh size adopted in our numerical computation is also given. The operating conditions are listed in Table 6, including the species mole fractions and the temperature of the fuel and air in those tests, which are the prescribed conditions for the numerical computation. In the experimental work by Singhal [27], a test of the pressure effect was also conducted by varying the fuel and air pressure from 1 atm to 15 atm. It is expected that the experimental data for these SOFCs in different dimensions and operating conditions will facilitate a wide benchmark range for validation of the numerical modeling work. 4.4.1 The SOFC terminal voltage The computer calculated and the experimentally obtained cell terminal voltages under different cell current densities are shown in Fig. 9. The relative deviation of
28 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells Table 5: Example SOFCs with test data available. Data sequence: Outer diameter (mm)/Thickness (mm)/Length (mm) Singhal [27] Hagiwara et al. [26] Hirano et al. [25] Tomlins et al. [28] Air-inducing tube Support tube Cathode Electrolyte Anode Fuel boundary Grid number (r × x)
7.00/1.00/485 – 15.72/2.20/500 15.80/0.04/500 16.00/0.10/500 18.10/ – /500 66×602
6.00/1.00/290 13.00/1.50/300 14.40/0.70/300 14.48/0.04/300 14.68/0.10/300 16.61/ – /300 66×602
12.00/1.00/1450 – 21.72/2.20/1500 21.80/0.04/1500 22.00/0.10/1500 24.87/ – /1500 66×1602
Table 6: Species’ mole fractions, utilization percentages, and temperatures. Air O2 %−UO2 /N2 %/T (◦ C) I II III
fuel H2 %–UH2 /H2 O%/CH4 %/CO%/CO2 %/T (◦ C)
21.00–17.00/79.00/600.0
98.64–85.00/1.36 /0/ 0 /0 /900.0 55.70–80.00/27.70/0/10.80/5.80/800.0 ∗∗ 21.00–25.00/79.00/400.0 55.70–80.00/27.70/0/10.80/5.80/800.0 21.00–17.00/79.00/600.0 98.64–85.00/1.36 /0/ 0 /0 /800.0 ∗ 21.00–25.00/79.00/600.0
∗ Current
density = 185 mA/cm2 ; ∗∗ Current density = 370 mA/cm2 . I: Tested by Hagiwara et al. [26]. II: Tested by Hirano et al. [25]. III: Tested by Singhal [27] and Tomlins et al.[28]. the model-predicted data from the experimental data is no larger than 1.0% for the SOFC tested by Hirano et al. [25], 5.6% for that by Hagiwara et al. [26], and 6.0% for that by Tomlins et al. [28]. It is interesting to observe from Fig. 9 that, under the same cell current density, the cell voltage of the SOFC tested by Hagiwara et al. [26] is the highest and that by Hirano et al. [25] is the lowest. The mole fraction of hydrogen in the fuel for the SOFC tested by Hirano et al. [25] is low, which might be the major reason that this cell has the lowest cell voltage. Because the current must be collected circumferentially in a tubular type fuel cell, the large diameter of the cell tube investigated by Singhal [27] and Tomlins et al. [28] will lead to a longer current pathway. Thus, the cell voltages of these cells are lower than those found by Hagiwara et al. [26], even though the former investigators tested the SOFCs at a pressurized operation of 5 atm, which, in fact, helps to improve the cell voltage. Under a current density of 300 mA/cm2 , the cell voltage and power increase with the increasing operating pressure, as seen in Fig. 10. The agreement between our
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
29
Figure 9: Results of prediction and testing for cell voltage versus current density. (The operating pressure of the cell tested by Hagiwara et al. [26] and Hirano et al. [25] is 1.0 atm, and that by Tomlins et al. [28] is 5 atm.)
Figure 10: Effect of operating pressure on the terminal voltage and power. model-predicted results and the experimental ones by Singhal [27] is quite good, showing a maximum deviation of 7.4% at a low operating pressure. When the operating pressure increases from 1 atm to 5 atm, the cell output power shows a significant improvement of 9%. However, raising the operating pressure becomes less effective for improving the output power when the operating pressure is high. For example, the cell output power shows an increase of only 6% when the operating pressure increases from 5 atm to 15 atm. The reason for this is that the operating pressure contributes to the cell voltage in a logarithmic manner. Nevertheless,
30 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells pressurized operation of the fuel cell can improve the output power significantly. For example, when increasing the operating pressure from 1 atm to 15 atm, the cell output power can have an increment of 15.8%. There is no doubt from the above investigation that the investigators can satisfactorily predict the overall performance of a SOFC through numerical modeling and computation. On the basis of this good agreement with the overall fuel cell performance, the internal details of the flow, temperature, and concentration fields from numerical prediction can also be reliably presented. 4.4.2 Cell temperature distribution Because the measurement of temperature in a SOFC is very difficult, only three experimental data points, the temperature at the two ends and in the middle of the cell tube, were available from the work on Hirano et al. [25]. Figure 11 shows the simulated cell temperature distribution for the SOFC, for which Hirano et al. [25] provided the test data. The agreement of the simulated data and the experimental results is good in the middle, where the hotspot is located; relatively larger deviations between the predicted and experimental values appear at the two ends of the cell. Nevertheless, such a discrepancy is acceptable when designing a SOFC with respect to concerns about the prevention of excessive heat in the cell materials. The predicted temperature distributions for the fuel cells tested by Hagiwara et al. [26] and Tomlins et al. [28] are given in Fig. 12. Unfortunately, there was no experimental data on the cell temperature. Generally, the two ends of the cell tube have lower temperatures than the middle of the cell tube. However, at low current densities, the hotspot is located closer to the closed end of the cell. With an increase in current density, the hotspot shifts to the open-end side, and the hotspot temperature also decreases, which improves the uniformity of the temperature distribution along the fuel cell. It should be observed that the heat transfer between the cooling air and the cell tube at the closed-end region is dominated by laminar jet impingement, since the exit velocity from the air-inducing tube is quite low. However, the velocity of the exit air from the air-inducing tube affects the heat
Figure 11: Longitudinal temperature distribution in the fuel cell.
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
31
Figure 12: Predicted longitudinal temperature distribution for two SOFCs. transfer coefficient significantly. For the high current density case, the flow rate of air also becomes large accordingly. Thus, the heat transfer coefficient between the air and the fuel cell closed-end region is increased. This can suppress the temperature level of the closed-end region of the fuel cell significantly. Since the air receives a large amount of heat at the closed-end region, its cooling to the fuel cell in the downstream region becomes weak, and the uniformity of the cell temperature distribution becomes much better when the fuel cell operates at high current densities. 4.4.3 Flow, temperature and concentration fields Figure 13 shows the flow and temperature fields for the SOFC tested by Hirano et al. [25] at a current density of 185 mA/cm2 . The air speed in the air-inducing tube has a slight acceleration because the air absorbs heat and expands in this flow passage. After leaving the air-inducing tube, the air impinges on the closed end of the fuel cell, and then flows backwards to the outside. In this pathway, the air obtains heat from the heat-generating fuel cell tube and transfers the heat to the cold air in the air-feeding tube. It is easy to understand that the electrochemical reaction at the closed end of the fuel cell is strong because the concentrations of fuel and air are both high there. Therefore, the heat generation due to Joule heating and the entropy change of the electrochemical reaction is high at the upstream area of the fuel path. However, it is known from both experiments and computation that the closed-end region of the fuel cell does not demonstrate the highest temperature; therefore, it is believed that the cooling of the air in the closed-end area of the fuel cell is responsible for this. After being heated at the closed-end region, air exhibits a higher temperature, and its cooling ability to the cell tube is low when it is in the annulus between the air-inducing tube and the cell tube. At the cell open-end region, the air in the annulus can transfer heat to the incoming cold fresh air in the air-inducing tube, and this will help it to cool the fuel cell tube.
32 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 13: Predicted flow and temperature fields for the SOFC reported by Hirano et al. [25] at a current density of 185 mA/cm2 .
From this airflow arrangement, the hotspot temperature of the cell tube may mostly occur in the center region in the longitudinal direction of the cell tube. The airflow has two passes, incoming in the air-inducing tube and outgoing in the annulus between the air-inducing tube and the cell tube. The heat exchange in between the two passes allows the air to mitigate its temperature fluctuation in the whole air path, and thus the temperature field in the fuel cell might be maintained as relatively uniform. Nevertheless, the heat generation, air and fuel temperature, and air-cooling to the fuel cell will collectively affect the temperature field in the fuel cell. Therefore, the hot spot position in a cell tube might shift more or less away from the center region depending on the operating condition of the fuel cell. Figure 14 shows the gas species’mole fraction contours for the same SOFC under the same operating conditions as discussed with respect to Fig. 13. In the air path, oxygen consumption at the closed-end region is relatively large, which leads to more densely distributed contour lines. The contour shape of oxygen also indicates a relatively larger difference of the mole fraction between the bulk flow and the wall of the cathode/air interface. This implies that the mass transport resistance on the air side might be dominant in lowering the cell performance if the stoichiometry of the oxygen is low. Feeding more air than is needed is already well applied in operational fuel cell technology.
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
33
Figure 14: Predicted fields of the mole fraction of the species for the SOFC reported by Hirano et al. [25] at a current density of 185 mA/cm2 . The hydrogen budget is collectively determined by the consumption by the electrochemical reaction and the generation from the water-shift reaction of CO. Since the consumption dominates, the hydrogen mole fraction decreases along the fuel stream. Corresponding to this hydrogen variation, consumption due to the water-shift reaction and production due to the electrochemical reaction cause the water vapor to increase gradually along the fuel stream. The water-shift of CO proceeds gradually in the fuel path, and thus the mole fraction of CO decreases but the CO2 increases. The shape of the contour lines of the species in the fuel path is
34 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 15: Predicted streamwise molar flow rate variation for species in the fuel channel for the SOFC reported by Hirano et al. [25]. relatively flat from the cell wall to the bulk flow. This indicates that mass diffusion in the fuel channel is relatively stronger than that in the airflow. For a further illustration of the variation of the gas species, Fig. 15 shows the molar flow rate variation along the fuel path. In one third of the length from the fuel inlet, the hydrogen flow rate shows a faster decrease and the water flow rate shows a faster increase, indicating a strong reaction in the upstream region. The flow rate of CO and CO2 vary roughly in a linear style, and a small amount of CO still exists in the waste gas.
5 Concluding remarks Fuel cell technology is currently under rapid development. To improve SOFC performance, for high power density and efficiency, efforts have been made to reduce the three over-potentials: activation polarization, ohmic loss, and concentration polarization. Better understanding of these three over-potentials is also very important in developing accurate computer models for predicting the overall performance and internal details of a SOFC. The activation polarization relates to the porous structure of the electrode and electrocatalyst materials. The state-of-the-art in material and manufacturing processes for the electrodes and electrolyte has been reported by Singhal [27]. The reduction of ohmic losses also heavily relies on the reduction of electronic and ionic resistances in the electrodes and electrolyte. A shorter current collection pathway also helps to reduce ohmic loss. A new design, referred to as a high power density solid oxide fuel cell (HPD-SOFC), has been developed by Siemens Westinghouse Power Corporation [27, 32], and has a significantly shorter current pathway, and
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
35
thus improves the power density significantly. A planar structure also promises to have a shorter current pathway and thus a higher power density, and measures for reducing the ohmic loss in a planar type SOFC have been reported by Tanner and Virkar [61]. The reduction of mass transport resistance, or the concentration polarization, has not been given much attention. Mass transfer enhancement has been reported to be effective in polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cells (PEMFCs) for obtaining a higher cell current density [62] before a sharp drop in cell voltage (which is due to excessive concentration polarization). It might also be possible for SOFCs to obtain a higher current density by means of mass transfer enhancement. In a numerical model of a SOFC, the precise calculation of the over-potentials is very important in order to accurately predict the overall current-voltage performance. The heat generation from the over-potentials is also significant in computing the temperature, flow, and species concentration fields. With respect to the activation polarization, studies elucidating the data and equations for the exchange current density are still needed. For the prediction of ohmic losses, reliable property data for electrodes are required. Additionally, a method for analyzing a complex network circuit in a SOFC needs to be developed. The concentration polarization is considered in the numerical computation by using the local mole fractions of the species at the interface of the electrode and fluid when calculating the electromotive force by the Nernst equation. Because the porous electrodes also serve as the reaction site, there is no well-described model for the mass transport resistance in the electrodes. Adopting a lower exchange current density, which induces a larger over-potential of the activation polarization, may be a way to incorporate the mass transport resistance in the electrodes into the activation polarization. The method given by Hirano et al. [25] for the consideration of mass transport resistances in the electrodes is convenient, but may be too simple and needs more investigation. With the progress being made in computer modeling of SOFCs, it is expected that costs for research and development of SOFCs will be significantly reduced by using computer simulations in the future.
References [1]
Srinivasan, S., Mosdale, R., Stevens, P. & Yang, C., Fuel cells: reaching the era of clear and efficient power generation in the twenty-first century. Annual Review Energy Environment, 24, pp. 281–328, 1999. [2] Gardner, F.J., Thermodynamic processes in solid oxide and other fuel cells. Proc. Instn. Mech. Engrs., 211, Part A, pp. 367–380, 1997. [3] Suzuki, K., Iwai, H., Kim, J.H., Li, P.W. & Teshima, K., Solid oxide fuel cell and micro gas turbine hybrid cycle and related fluid flow and heat transfer. The 12th International Heat Transfer Conference, Grenoble, August 18–23, 1, pp. 403–414, 2002. [4] Harvey, S.P. & Richter, H.J., Gas turbine cycles with solid oxide fuel cells, Part I: Improved gas turbine power plant efficiency by use of recycled exhaust gases and fuel cell technology. ASME Journal of Energy Resources Technology, 116, pp. 305–311, 1994.
36 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells [5]
[6]
[7] [8]
[9]
[10] [11] [12]
[13]
[14]
[15]
[16]
[17]
[18]
Layne,A., Samuelsen, S., Williams, M. & Hoffman, P., Developmental status of hybrids. International Gas Turbine & Aeroengine Congress & Exhibition, Indianapolis, Indiana, USA, No. 99-GT-400, 1999. Ali, S.A. & Moritz, R.R., The hybrid cycle: integration of turbomachinery with a fuel cell. International Gas Turbine & Aeroengine Congress & Exhibition, Indianapolis, Indiana, USA, No. 99-GT-361, 1999. Bevc, F., Advances in solid oxide fuel cells and integrated power plants. Proc. Instn. Mech. Engrs., 211, Part A, pp. 359–366, 1997. Freni, S. & Maggio, G., Energy balance of different internal reforming MCFC configurations. International Journal of Energy Research, 21, pp. 253–264, 1997. Wojcik, A., Middleton, H., Damopoulos, I. & Herle, J.V., Ammonia as a fuel in solid oxide fuel cells. Journal of Power Sources, 118, pp. 342–348, 2003. Wark, K., Thermodynamics, Second Edition, McGraw-Hill Book Company: New York, pp. 536–561, 1971. Perry, R.H. & Green, D.W., Perry’s Chemical Engineer’s Handbook, Seventh Edition, McGraw-Hill: New York, 1986. Onuma, S., Kaimai,A., Kawamura, K., Nigara, Y., Kawada, T., Mizusaki, J. & Tagawa, H., Influence of the coexisting gases on the electrochemical reaction rates between 873 and 1173 K in a CH4 -H2 O/Pt/YSZ system. Solid State Ionics, 132, pp. 309–331, 2000. Li, P.W., Schaefer, L., Wang, Q.M. & Chyu, M.K., Computation of the conjugating heat transfer of fuel and oxidant separated by a heat-generating cell tube in a solid oxide fuel cell, Paper No. IMECE2002-32564. Proc. of ASME International Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition, Nov. 17–22, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA, 2002. Hartvigsen, J., Khandkar, A. & Elangovan, S., Development of an SOFC stack performance map for natural gas operation. Proc. of the Sixth International Symposium on Solid Oxide Fuel Cells. Honolulu, Hawaii, USA, 1999; on Web site www.mtiresearch.com/pubs.html No. MTI00-07. Massardo, A.F. & Lubelli, F., Internal reforming solid oxide fuel cell-gas turbine combined cycles (IRSOFC-GT), Part A: Cell model and cycle thermodynamic analysis. International Gas Turbine & Aeroengine Congress & Exhibition, Stockholm, Sweden, No. 98-GT-577, 1998. Chan, S.H., Khor, K.A. & Xia, Z.T., A complete polarization model of a solid oxide fuel cell and its sensitivity to the change of cell component thickness. Journal of Power Sources, 93, pp. 130–140, 2001. Keegan, K., Khaleel, M., Chick, L., Recknagle, K., Simner, S. & Deibler, J., Analysis of a planar solid oxide fuel cell based automotive auxiliary power unit. SAE 2002 World Congress, Detroit, Michigan, No. 2002-010413, 2002. Nagata, S., Momma, A., Kato, T. & Kasuga, Y., Numerical analysis of output characteristics of tubular SOFC with internal reformer. Journal of Power Resources, 101, pp. 60–71, 2001.
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
[19]
[20] [21]
[22]
[23]
[24]
[25]
[26]
[27] [28]
[29] [30] [31]
[32] [33]
[34]
37
Iwata, M., Hikosaka, T., Morita, M., Iwanari, T., Ito, K., Onda, K., Esaki, Y., Sakaki, Y. & Nagata, S., Performance analysis of planar-type unit SOFC considering current and temperature distributions. Solid State Ionics, 132, pp. 297–308, 2000. Minh, N.Q. & Takahashi, T., Science and Technology of Ceramic Fuel Cells, Elsevier: New York, 1995. Ota, T., Koyama, M., Wen, C.J., Yamada, K. & Takahashi, H., Object-based modeling of SOFC system: dynamic behavior of micro-tube SOFC. Journal of Power Sources, 118, pp. 430–439, 2003. Srikar, V.T., Turner, K.T., Andrew Ie, T.Y. & Spearing, S.M., Structural design consideration for micromachined solid-oxide fuel cells. Journal of Power Sources, 125, pp. 62–69, 2004. Li, P.W. & Chyu, M.K., Simulation of the chemical/electrochemical reaction and heat/mass transfer for a tubular SOFC working in a stack. Journal of Power Sources, 124, pp. 487–498, 2003. Li, P.W., Schaefer, L. & Chyu, M.K., Investigation of the energy budget in an internal reforming tubular type solid oxide fuel cell through numerical computation, Paper No. IJPGC2003-40126. Proc. of the International Joint Power Conference, June 16–19, Atlanta, Georgia, USA, 2003. Hirano, A., Suzuki, M. & Ippommatsu, M., Evaluation of a new solid oxide fuel cell system by non-isothermal modeling. J. Electrochem. Soc., 139(10), pp. 2744–2751, 1992. Hagiwara, A., Michibata, H., Kimura, A., Jaszcar, M.P., Tomlins, G.W. & Veyo, S.E., Tubular solid oxide fuel cell life tests. Proc. of the Third International Fuel Cell Conference, Nagoya, Japan, pp. 365–368, 1999. Singhal, S.C.,Advances in solid oxide fuel cell technology. Solid State Ionics, 135, pp. 305–313, 2000. Tomlins, G.W. & Jaszcar, M.P., Elevated pressure testing of the Simens Westinghouse tubular solid oxide fuel cell. Proc. of the Third International Fuel Cell Conference, Nagoya, Japan, pp. 369–372, 1999. Bessette N.F., Modeling and simulation for solid oxide fuel cell power system, Georgia Institute of Technology, Ph.D Thesis, 1994. Ahmed, S., McPheeters, C. & Kumar, R., Thermal-hydraulic model of a monolithic solid oxide fuel cell. J. Electrochem. Soc., 138, pp. 2712–2718, 1991. Ferguson, J.R., Fiard J.M. & Herbin, R., Three-dimensional numerical simulation for various geometries of solid oxide fuel cells. Journal of Power Sources, 58, pp. 109–122, 1996. Singhal, S.C., Progress in tubular solid oxide fuel cell technology. Electrochemical Society Proceedings, 99–19, pp. 40–50, 2001. Sverdrup, E.F., Warde, C.J. & Eback, R.L., Design of high temperature solidelectrolyte fuel cell batteries for maximum power output per unit volume. Energy Conversion, 13, pp. 129–136, 1973. Li, P.W., Suzuki, K., Komori, H. & Kim, J.H., Numerical simulation of heat and mass transfer in a tubular solid oxide fuel cell. Thermal Science & Engineering, 9(4), pp. 13–14, 2001.
38 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells [35] Aguiar, P., Chadwick, D. & Kershenbaum, L., Modeling of an indirect internal reforming solid oxide fuel cell. Chemical Engineering Science, 57, pp. 1665–1677, 2002. [36] Bessette, N.F. & Wepfer W.J., A mathematical model of a tubular solid oxide fuel cell. Journal of Energy Resources Technology, 117, pp. 43–49, 1995. [37] Campanari, S., Thermodynamic model and parametric analysis of a tubular SOFC module. Journal of Power Sources, 92, pp. 26–34, 2001. [38] Haynes, C. & Wepfer, W.J., Characterizing heat transfer within a commercialgrade tubular solid oxide fuel cell for enhanced thermal management. Int. J. of Hydrogen Energy, 26, pp. 369–379, 2001. [39] Recknagle, K.P., Williford, R.E., Chick, L.A., Rector, D.R. & Khaleel, M.A., Three-dimensional thermo-fluid electrochemical modeling of planar SOFC stacks. Journal of Power Sources, 113, pp. 109–114, 2003. [40] Li, P.W., Schaefer, L. & Chyu, M.K., Interdigitated heat/mass transfer and chemical/electrochemical reactions in a planar type solid oxide fuel cell. Proc. of ASME 2003 Summer Heat Transfer Conference, Las Vegas, Paper No. HT2003-47436, 2003. [41] Joon, K., Fuel cells – a 21st century power system. Journal of Power Sources, 71, pp. 12–18, 1998. [42] Watanabe, T., Fuel cell power system applications in Japan. Proc. Instn. Mech. Engrs., 211, Part A, pp. 113–119, 1997. [43] Veyo, S.E. & Lundberg, W.L., Solid oxide fuel cell power system cycles. Proc. of the International Gas Turbine & Aeroengine Congress & Exhibition, Indianapolis, Indiana, USA, Paper No. 99-GT-365, 1999. [44] White, D.J., Hybrid gas turbine and fuel cell systems in perspective review. Proc. of the International Gas Turbine & Aeroengine Congress & Exhibition, Indianapolis, Indiana, USA, Paper No. 99-GT-419, 1999. [45] Li, P.W., Schaefer, L., Wang, Q.M., Zhang, T. & Chyu, M.K., Multi-gas transportation and electrochemical performance of a polymer electrolyte fuel cell with complex flow channels. Journal of Power Sources, 115 pp. 90–100, 2003. [46] Cahoon, N.C. & Weise, G. (eds) The Primary Battery, Vol. II, John Wiley & Sons: New York, 1976. [47] Li, P.W., Schaefer, L. & Chyu, M.K., Three-dimensional model for the conjugate processes of heat and gas species transportation in a flat plate solid oxide fuel cell. 14th International Symposium of Transport Phenomenon, Bali, Indonesia, June 6–9, pp. 305–312, 2003. [48] Li, P.W., Schaefer, L. & Chyu, M.K., The energy budget in tubular and planar type solid oxide fuel cells studied through numerical simulation. International Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition 2003, (IMECE2003-42426), Washington, D.C., Nov. 16–21, 2003. [49] Burt, A.C., Celik, I.B., Gemmen, R.S. & Smirnov, A.V., A numerical study of cell-to-cell variations in a SOFC stack. Journal of Power Sources, 126, pp. 76–87, 2004.
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
[50]
[51]
[52] [53] [54]
[55] [56] [57]
[58] [59]
[60]
[61] [62]
39
George, R.A. & Bessette, N.F., Reducing the manufacturing cost of tubular SOFC technology. Journal of Power Sources, 71, pp. 131–137, 1998. Krumdieck, S., Page, S. & Round S., Solid oxide fuel cell architecture and system design for secure power on an unstable grid. Journal of Power Sources, 125, pp. 189–198, 2004. Bird, R.B., Stewart, W.E. & Lightfoot, E.N., Transport Phenomena, John Wiley & Sons: New York, 1960. Williams, F.A., Combustion Theory, Benjamin/Cummings Publishing Co., 1985. Eckert, E.R.G. & Drake, R.M., Heat and Mass Transfer, 2nd Edition of Introduction to the Transfer of Heat and Mass, McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc., 1966. Turns, S.R., Introduction to Combustion: Concept and Application, Second Edition, McGraw-Hill Higher Education: New York, 1999. Incropera, F.P. & DeWitt, D.P., Introduction to Heat Transfer, Third Edition, John Wiley & Sons, 1996. Todd, B. & Young, J.B., Thermodynamic and transport properties of gases for use in solid oxide fuel cell modeling. Journal of Power Sources, 110, pp. 186–200, 2002. Patankar, S.V., Numerical Heat Transfer and Fluid Flow, McGraw-Hill, 1980. Karki, K.C. & Patankar, S.H., Pressure based calculation procedure for viscous flows at all speed in arbitrary configurations. AIAA Journal, 27(9), pp. 1167–1174, 1989. Beckermann, C. & Smith, T.F., Incorporation of internal surface radiation exchange in the finite-volume method. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part B, 23, pp. 127–133, 1993. Tanner, C.W. & Virkar A.V., A simple model for interconnect design of planar solid oxide fuel cells. Journal of Power Sources, 113, pp. 44–56, 2003. Nguyen T.V., A gas distributor design for proton-exchange-membrane fuel cells. J. Electrochem. Soc., 413(5), pp. L103–L105, 1996.
Nomenclature a A Acell Aair , Afuel b B C Cp DJ ,m
Stoichiometric coefficient of chemical species. Chemical species. Area (m2 ). General variable. Outer surface area of fuel cell (m2 ). Inlet flow area of air and fuel, respectively (m2 ). Stoichiometric coefficient of chemical species. Chemical species. General variable. General variable. Specific heat capacity at constant pressure [J/(kg K)]. Diffusion coefficient of jth species into the left gases of a mixture (m2 /s).
40 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells E F g h H i i0 I k KPR , KPS L m m ˙ M Mf ne p, P q˙ Q r r a , rc , re R Ra , Rc , Re S T u U v V Vcell V a, V c W x X x¯ , y¯ , z¯ y Y z Z
Electromotive force or electric potential (V). Faraday’s constant [96486.7 (C/mol)]. Gibbs free energy (J/mol). Chemical enthalpy (kJ/kmol) or (J/mol). Height (m). Current density (A/m2 ). Exchange current density (A/m2 ). Current (A). Thermal conductivity (W/m K). Chemical equilibrium constant for reforming and shift reactions, respectively. Length (m). Mass transfer rate or mass consumption/production rate (mol/s). Mass flux [mol/(m2 s)]. Molecular weight (g/mol). Total mole rate of fuel flow (mol/s). Number of electrons involved in per fuel molecule in oxidation reaction. Pressure (Pa) or position. Volumetric heat source ( W/m3 ). Heat energy (W). Radial coordinate (m). Average radius of anode, cathode, and electrolyte layers (m). Universal gas constant [8.31434 J/(mol K)]. Discretized resistance in anode, cathode, and electrolyte (). Source term of gas species (kg/m3 ); General variable. Temperature (K). Velocity in axial direction (m/s). Utilization percentage (0–1). Velocity in radial direction (m/s); Diffusion volume in eqn (68). Specific volume (m3 /kmol). Cell terminal voltage (V). Potentials in anode and cathode, respectively (V). Width (m). Stoichiometric coefficient of chemical species; Axial coordinate (m). Chemical species. Mole fraction. Reacted mole rate of CH4 , CO and H2 , respectively in a section of interest in flow channel (mol/s). Stoichiometric coefficient of chemical species; Coordinate (m). Chemical species. Mass fraction. Coordinate (m). Compressibility factor.
Multiple transport processes in solid oxide fuel cells
41
Greek symbols θ δ G G 0 H S x λ µ ρ ρea , ρec ρee ρr ηAct
Circumferential position. Angle. Thickness of electrodes and electrolyte layers (m). Gibbs free energy change of a chemical reaction (J/mol). Standard state Gibbs free energy change of a chemical reaction (J/mol). Enthalpy change of a chemical reaction (J/mol). Entropy production [J/(mol K)]. One axial section of fuel cell centered at x position (m). Thermal conductivity [W/(m ◦ C)]. Dynamic viscosity (Pa s). Density (kg/m3 ). Electronic resistivity of anode and cathode respectively ( · cm). Ionic resistivity of electrolyte ( · cm). Reduced density. Activation polarization (V ).
Subscripts a c cell e, w, n, s E, W , N , S f i j m P R x X,Y x
Anode. Cathode. Overall parameter of fuel cell. East, west, north, and south interfaces between grid P and it neighboring grids. East, west, north, and south neighboring grids of grid P. Fuel. Subscript variable. Gas species; Subscript variable. Mixture. Variables at grid P. Electrochemical reaction. Axial position. Chemical species. Variation in the channel section of x.
Superscripts a b c e in out P R x
Anode. Sequence. Sequence. Cathode. Sequence. Electrolyte. Inlet of a channel section of interest. Outlet of a channel section of interest. Variables at grid P. Reaction. Axial position.
This page intentionally left blank
CHAPTER 2 Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells S.B. Beale National Research Council, Ottawa, Canada.
Abstract This article discusses various numerical techniques used to model single-cells and stacks of planar solid oxide fuel cells. A brief history of the solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC), and a survey of modeling efforts to-date are presented. The fundamental thermodynamics of the SOFC are introduced, together with the equations governing the ideal (Nernst) potential. Factors affecting operating cell voltages are then discussed. A simple iterative calculation procedure is described, whereby inlet mass factions, flow rates, and cell voltage are known, but outlet values, and current are required. This provides a paradigm for more complex algorithms set out in the remainder of the text. The next level of complexity is provided for by numerical integration schemes based on ‘presumed-flow’ methodologies, where the inlet flow rates of oxidant and fuel are assumed to be uniform. Local mass sources and sinks are computed from Faraday’s equation. These are then used to correct the continuity and mass transfer equations. Temperature variations are also computed; because heat and mass transfer effects affect the output of SOFCs, significantly. Some more advanced chemistry, heat and mass transfer issues are further detailed. The most detailed cell models are obtained using computational fluid dynamics codes, based on finite-volume and other techniques. Additional improvements to these (and other) codes involve the detailed modeling of the electric potential (in place of the Nernst equation formulation), and the analysis of the combined kinetics and mass transfer problem in the porous electrode media. Finally stack models are introduced. These may be full-scale computational fluid dynamics models or simpler models based on volume-averaging techniques.
44 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 1: Schematic of typical planar SOFC.
1 Introduction 1.1 History and types of solid oxide fuel cell There are many types of fuel cell under development. Most popular among these are the proton exchange membrane fuel cell (PEMFC) and the solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) [1–3]. The SOFC is a solid-state device that utilizes the oxygen ion conducting property of the ceramic zirconia. The operation of a SOFC differs from that of a PEMFC or a conventional battery, in that both electronic and ionic circuits are due to the flux of negatively charged particles; electrons and O2− ions. The positive ions or ‘holes’are immobilised in the solid matrix, at the time of fabrication. The book by Williams [4] details developments in SOFC technology prior to the 1960’s. A SOFC consists of an anode or fuel electrode, an electrolyte, and a cathode or air electrode. The anode is typically a porous cermet, for example the combination of NiO and Yttria-stabilised Zirconia (YSZ). A typical material for the cathode is Sr doped LaMnO3 , a perovskite. The electrolyte consists of a layer of YSZ, and is fabricated as thin as possible in order to reduce Ohmic losses. Fuel and air passages are required to supply the products and remove the reactants; the gas passages are typically rectangular micro-channels, though planar channels may also be utilized occasionally. In addition, porous media inserted between the fluid passages and electrodes may serve as gas diffusion layers. Both planar and cylindrical SOFC geometries are to be found; the latter avoid mechanical sealing problems, whereas the former allow for relatively large electrical power densities to be achieved. The discussion in this paper focuses on the planar design. In order to reach the necessary operating voltage, fuel cells are connected together in a stack by situating a metallic or ceramic interconnect between each cell. These are often made of stainless steel. Cells are connected electrically
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
45
Figure 2: Planar SOFC stack. Courtesy Global Thermoelectric Inc. in series, but hydraulically in parallel. The interconnects also function as a housing for the flow channels for the air and fuel which are supplied via manifolds. The balance-of-plant makes sure that the working fluids are supplied under the desired operating conditions. Fuel cells may be operated in co-flow, counter-flow and cross-flow. The industrial SOFC designs encountered by the present author were for cross-flow. Hydrogen is normally provided by reforming methane or methanol in a reactor. The electrical efficiency of a system running on natural gas can exceed 50%. The remaining energy is released as heat. The basic operation of a SOFC is as follows: reduction takes place at the cathode. O2 + 4e− → 2O2− .
(1)
At the anode, if the fuel is H2 , the oxygen ion combines with hydrogen to form water, electricity and heat. H2 + O2− → H2 O + 2e− .
(2)
Thus the overall reaction is H2 + 12 O2 → H2 O. 1 kg + 8 kg
9 kg
(3)
1.2 Survey of modeling techniques Mathematical models of heat and mass transfer and electrochemistry provide tools for performance prediction of single-cells and stacks of fuel cells. Thermo-fluid simulations can predict the thermal and electrochemical performance, and structural analysis models can predict the mechanical behavior. Our concern here is
46 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells with the former. Among the first to perform calculations on SOFC performance were Vayenas and Hegedus [5]. Since then, the scope and detail of modeling have increased. Models have been developed at various scales: micro-scale or nano-scale studies aim at the development of better electrodes through mathematical analysis. Single-cell models are often the first consideration for fuel cell manufacturers embarking on a new product design, and are currently a target application for the vendors of commercial CFD codes. Stack modeling is necessary for the overall design and often involves parametric studies. Among the most salient issues that need to be addressed are the electric potential field, porous media transport phenomena, and chemical kinetics (shift reactions, internal reforming). The development of a model for conservation of heat, mass, and charge in SOFCs is detailed in [6–8]. Such models have been applied to SOFC stacks [9–12]. Shift and reforming reactions have also been considered [13, 14] as well as heat and mass transfer issues [15, 16]. The size and complexity of SOFC stacks requires the use of very large computers, if a conventional CFD code is employed. Because of this, simpler models based on engineering assumptions have sometimes been devised [10, 12, 17, 18] in order that personal computers may perform such calculations. The speed and memory requirements of a computer code will be limited by the application. For detailed SOFC design large-scale CFD codes will be required, whereas for real-time control, rapid response will preclude all but the simplest of schemes from being employed. 1.3 Thermodynamics of solid oxide fuel cells Newman [19] states that thermodynamics, kinetics, and transport phenomena are fundamental to understanding electrochemical systems. It is important to realise that transport phenomena are affected by thermodynamic properties and chemical kinetics. Physicochemical hydrodynamics [20, 21] is the study of such mutual interactions. It is timely to start with the thermodynamics of fuel cells. Figure 3 illustrates the notion of the fuel cell as a thermodynamic device. It is postulated
Figure 3: Fuel cell as a thermodynamic system.
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
47
that the fundamental relation [22] for the internal energy, U , may be expressed as U = U (S, V , Nj , Q),
(4)
where S is entropy, V is volume, Nj is mole number of species j, and Q is charge number. Conservation of energy requires that, dU = dWHeat + dWMech + dWChem + dWElec , µj dNj + EdQ, dU = TdS − PdV +
(5) (6)
j
where T = (∂U /∂S)V ,Nj ,Q , P = − (∂U /∂V )S,Nj ,Q , µj = (∂U /∂Ni )S,V ,Q , and E = (∂U /∂Q)S,V ,Nj are temperature, pressure, chemical potential, and electric potential, respectively. Texts in physical chemistry invariably introduce Gibbs free energy, G, which for a chemical reaction which does not involve charge transfer may be written: dG = dU − TdS + PdV =
µj dNj .
(7)
j
The free energy is useful for analysis of situations where temperature and pressure are constant (e.g. at ambient). Note that for the situation under consideration dU − TdS + PdV = j µj dNj . For an electrochemical process, where temperature and pressure are maintained constant and there is no change in internal energy, chemical energy is converted to electrical energy: µj dNj = −EdQ, (8) j
where it is understood that Nj is positive for inflow and negative for outflow, i.e., the sum of chemical energy of the reactants less that of the products. The molar enthalpy of formation of the chemical reaction defined by eqn (3) is H 0 = −247.3 kJ/mol at 1000 ◦ C, whereas the molar Gibbs energy of formation (i.e. the chemical energy of formation) is G 0 = −177.4 kJ/mol, the negative sign indicating that heat will be released at a rate of 69.9 kJ/mol. The electrochemical reaction is thus exothermic. The difference between these terms H 0 −G 0 is frequently referred to in a somewhat cavalier fashion as the TS 0 term. However there are other heat sources in a fuel cell, which can change the entropy (and internal energy) of the system. It is also worth noting that a fuel cell is not open to the atmosphere, so pressure and temperature can and do vary. It is therefore prudent to appreciate that eqn (8) is just a simplified form of eqn (6). Nonetheless it is eqn (8) that is invariably the point of departure for a fuel cell analysis, with irreversibilities being added to modify the basic postulate that ideally all chemical energy would be converted to electrical energy.
48 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells Since the air and fuel in a SOFC are high-temperature gases, we may treat them as multi-component perfect gases, such that PV = NRT ,
(9)
where R = 8.3144 × 103 J/mol.K is the gas constant, and N=
Nj
(10)
j
for the air-side and fuel-side gases. The chemical potentials are given by [22]:
where
µj = µ0j (T ) + RT ln P + RT ln xj = µ0j (T ) + RT ln Pj ,
(11)
xj = Nj /N = Nj Nk
(12)
k
is mole fraction and Pj = xj P is the partial pressure of species j. Faraday’s law gives the number of moles of oxygen consumed by the electrochemical reaction as Q , (13) N˜ = nF where F = 96 485 Coulomb/mol is Faraday’s constant and n = 2 is the valence of oxygen. Thus the change in chemical energy is µj Nj = (14) νj µj Products − νj µj Reactants N˜ and νi are stoichiometric coefficients. For example,
ν1 A1 + ν2 A2 → ν3 A3 , µi Ni = (ν1 µ1 + ν2 µ2 − ν3 µ3 )N˜ = (G 0 + RT ln Kp )N˜ ,
(15) (16)
where G 0 = [(νj µj )Products − (νj µj )Reactants ] is referred to as the molar Gibbs free energy for the chemical reaction. (NB: The author denotes G = G/N˜ J/mol for consistency with the literature). The equilibrium constant, KP , is given by Kp =
P1ν1 P2ν2 . ν P3 3
(17)
This may be re-written in terms of mole fractions, xj , e.g., for a SOFC with hydrogen as fuel: 0.5 xH2 xO 1 0 2 µi Ni = G + RT ln Pa + RT ln N˜ , (18) 2 xH2 O
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
49
where Pa is air pressure. Substituting molar flow rate for current using Faraday’s law we immediately obtain µi Ni . (19) E=− nF Since the valence of oxygen is 2, we have, 0.5 xH2 xO RT RT 0 2 + E=E + ln ln Pa 2F xH2 O 4F
(20)
which is the Nernst equation for a solid oxide fuel cell. The quantity E is the reversible or Nernst potential. In what follows below, we make the assumption that we may associate the thermodynamic pressure with the hydrodynamic pressure, and the thermodynamic potential with the electrostatic potential. For practical reasons, E 0 is redefined such that Pa is gauge (relative) pressure rather than absolute air pressure, in which case the latter term in eqn (20) is replaced by the form (RT /4F) ln (1+Pgauge /P0 ), and P0 is a reference operating pressure. The latter form is more useful when considering detailed transport models where values of pressure and temperature vary. Generally speaking Pgauge /P0 is very small so changes in E are largely due to variations in mole fraction and temperature. Values of E 0 are typically enumerated as polynomials, e.g., E 0 = a − bT .
(21)
Typical values would be a = 1.214 V and b = 3.2668 V/K. Higher order polynomials may also be found. The physical significance of the terms on the rightside of eqn (21) are a ≈ G 0 /nF and b ≈ T S 0 /nF. Although these terms are themselves temperature dependent, this is a quite reasonable approximation in many situations. The process illustrated in Fig. 3 is an open thermodynamic cycle. Thus ˙ flows. Under these circumstances when a load is connected, a finite current i = Q there will be irreversible changes, and the actual cell voltage will be lower than the reversible Nernst potential. 1.4 Cell voltage and current The conduction mechanism in the ionic electrolyte differs fundamentally from that in the neighbouring electrodes and interconnects (electronic conduction). Therefore the electrolyte polarises at the edges and a double charge layer is established at the interfaces. The change in chemical potential across the interface, µj , is balanced by the opposing change in the electric potential for electrochemical equilibrium, nFφ. The sum of these terms is referred to as the electrochemical potential. Figure 4 illustrates the double charge layer in a fuel cell, while Fig. 5 shows the potential distribution. The Nernst potential is just the sum of the anodic and cathodic potentials, E=φa +φc . It is not possible to measure the potential, φ, at a single electrode, though it is possible to measure changes from equilibrium, η = δφ,
50 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 4: Double charge layer.
Figure 5: Electric potential at open circuit and with a current flowing. when a current is drawn. The double-layer is just a few nanometres thick. There is no net change in potential, in the absence of an electric current, within the bulk of the electrolyte. In other words, there are step changes in potential at the anode and the cathode, but zero change within the electrolyte, as shown in Fig. 5. Whenever a current, i, is drawn, the voltage drops and the actual cell voltage, V , is given by (22) V = E − ηe − ηa − ηc = iRl , where the terms ηe , ηa and ηc are electrolytic, anodic, and cathodic losses, respectively. These have often been referred to as overpotentials or polarisations in the electrochemistry and chemical engineering literature. Rl is the resistance of the external load. The potential difference across the electrolyte ηe = iRe = E − ηa − ηc − V
(23)
is sometimes referred to as the Ohmic overpotential. Here Re is the internal resistance of the electrolyte. The resistivity of the electrolyte is highly temperature dependent, and decreases with increasing temperature. There will also be a similar (usually smaller) Ohmic loss associated with metallic interconnect(s), and for
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
51
convenience that latter will be ignored for now. Thus work is being done by the electric field on the ions in the electrolyte and interconnects, whereas work is being done against the field in crossing the electrodes. Although the anodic and cathodic overpotentials are themselves a function of the current, it is sometimes convenient for numerical purposes to lump all the losses into a single linearised internal resistance, R¯ ¯ (24) ηe + ηa + ηc = iR, ¯ where it is understood that R¯ = R(i), i.e. the slope of the V-i curve is not constant. The V-i curve or, more often the voltage-current-density, V-i , curve is the single most important characteristic to the electrochemical scientist. N.B. The reader will note that in this text, a ‘dot’ is used to denote a time derivative, and a ‘dash’ to denote a length derivative. Thus if q has units [J], then q˙ has units [W/m2 ]. While mole fractions are often found in electrochemical texts, in engineering problems it is much more common to utilize mass fractions, mj , which may be converted to/from molar fractions, xj , as follows: mj = xj
Mj , M
(25)
where the mixture molecular weight is just M =
x j Mj =
j
1
mj j Mj
.
(26)
The reactions at the electrode surfaces lead to continuity and species sources/sinks in the working fluids. The mass fluxes, m ˙ j (in kg/m2 s), are related to the current density, i = i/A, by Faraday’s law m ˙ j = ±
Mj i , 1000nj F
(27)
where Mj is the molecular weight of chemical species j (in g/mol), and n is the valence. It is trivial to re-write the Nernst equation in terms of mass fractions. 0.5 m m H 1 RT RT 2 O 2 + ln (Ma ) + 0.4643 + E = E0 + (28) ln ln Pa , 2F mH2 O 2 4F where Ma is the mixture molecular weight, eqn (26), for air, and MH2 O ln ≈ ln (18) − ln (2) − 12 ln (32) = 0.4643. MH2 MO0.5 2
(29)
In electrochemistry, molar-based units are frequently encountered, but in transport phenomena, for a variety of reasons, mass-based units are preferred. This duality is a fact-of-life when dealing with fuel cells. Both have their uses and limitations.
52 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells 1.5 Activation losses Electrochemical reactions can only occur at finite rates. For a charged particle to pass across a double charge layer, it must possess more free energy than a certain minimum. From an engineering perspective the activation energy is similar to bulk-to-interphase energy, required for example in multi-phase systems involving phase-change. Figure 6 illustrates the basic principle for a single-step singleelectron electrochemical reaction A → B. The sharp sign, #, indicates the activated state. Eyring’s analysis [23] is useful for such rate-limiting situations. The analysis proceeds as follows: the probability density function for ions crossing the electrode boundary follows a Boltzmann distribution, and it can readily be shown that the forward rate constant, kf mol/sec, is given by kf = k0 exp (−Gf /RT ).
(30)
A backward rate constant, kb , is similarly defined. For an open circuit (equilibrium), kf = kb = k0 . If a current flows, the potential difference deviates from the open circuit value, and the required free energy will also change as a result of the electric field: G = Gf − βFφ, (31) where β is a symmetry coefficient, 0 ≤ β ≤ 1, which is a measure by which a change in electric potential affects the required activation energy, see Fig. 6. Under this condition, the forward rate will not equal the backward rate. The former is given by, if = FNA k0 exp (−Gf /RT ) exp (−ηFφ/RT ) = i0 exp (−βFη/RT ),
(32)
where xA is the mole fraction of compound A, and M is the mixture molecular weight. The quantity η = δφ = φ − φ0 is the so-called activation overpotential. Similarly, for the backwards reaction B → A the charge flux of charge is ib = i0 exp (−(1 − β)Fη/RT )
(33)
Figure 6: Schematic of concept of activation energy for a single-step single-electron transfer reaction.
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
53
and the form of the Butler-Volmer equation, appropriate for a single-step singleelectron transfer process, is obtained, i = i0 [ exp (−βnFη/RT ) − exp ((1 − β)nFη/RT )].
(34)
The quantity i0 is the exchange current. In general i0 will be a function of molar concentration. That dependence can be theoretically determined by ensuring compatibility with the thermodynamic requirement E = E 0 + (RT /F) log (PB /PA ) for equilibrium, where PA and PB are partial pressures. Setting if = ib = i0 it follows 1−β β that the exchange current density is just i0 = Fk0 PA PB . The two terms in eqn (34) are essentially similar to Arrhenius-type expressions occurring in chemically reacting systems. The following points are noted: for small currents, eqn (34) reduces to a linear form, obtained by expanding it in a Taylor series about η = 0. At higher overpotentials (currents) an exponential form is obtained; for the latter situation one of the two terms in eqn (34) is negligibly small, depending on the direction of flux of charged particles. The exponential form is referred to as a Tafel equation. The ratio i/i0 determines if one is in the linear or Tafel regions. For a multi-step electrochemical reaction, the Butler-Volmer equation is generally written, i = i0 exp (nβf Fη/RT ) − exp (−nβb Fη/RT ) . (35) The quantities βf and βb are referred to as transfer coefficients. In deriving eqn (35) for a multi-step reaction [24, 25] it is generally assumed that at any electrode there is only one rate limiting step, with all other steps being considered at equilibrium. In view of these restrictions, it is probably wise to regard eqn (35) as being a semi-empirical formulation, for which βf and βb are determined experimentally. Equation (35) may be considered as an implicit form of the relationship of η = η(i, T ) which must be solved iteratively, for any given i0 and β. Typical values for planar SOFCs are i0 = 1 − 5 000 A/m2 . In general two sets of eqn (35) must be solved at both the anode and cathode to yield ηa and ηc for use in eqn (22), i.e. there are two values of i0 and four of β (N.B. β is often assumed to be ½). The overpotential at one electrode may be negligible compared to the other. Following the argument above for a single-step reaction for two electrodes, and imposing the requirement that for equilibrium, the sum of the potentials must equal the thermodynamic Nernst potential, eqn (20), and with the additional assumption that βf = βb = 1/2, it may be reasonably concluded that the concentration dependence at the cathode and i0 ∝ PH0.5 PH0.5 at the anode of the exchange current is i0 ∝ PO0.25 2 2 2O for a SOFC. Simplifying the Butler-Volmer equation has the advantage of rendering an explicit solution for η(i, T ); however the calculation procedure for the cell/stack is iterative by nature, and therefore there is little problem in using the implicit form, above. Charge transfer losses are particularly important at low current densities. The SOFC is a high-temperature device, and thus activation losses are generally less significant than in other fuel cells such as proton exchange membrane fuel cells, due to the presence of the exponent (RT )−1 . The subject of electrode kinetics, or electrodics, is an important one and the reader interested in more than the brief overview
54 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells provided here is referred to specialised texts such as Gileadi [24], Bockris et al. [25] and Bard and Falkner [26]. 1.6 Diffusion losses Mass transfer losses are due to diffusion becoming a rate limiting factor in providing O2 and H2 to the cathode and anode, and removing H2 O at the anode. Thus transport phenomena in the fuel and air channels can and do affect the electrical performance of the fuel cell. This becomes increasingly important at high current densities where concentration gradients are high. Mass transfer effects are sometimes handled in an analogous manner to charge transfer (activation) by introducing a concentration overpotential, also known as a concentration polarisation. The origin of these terms is historical. They may be written in terms of either molar or mass fractions. The latter is adopted here, namely RT mb η=± (36) ln nF mw for inclusion in eqn (22). The symbols mb and mw denote bulk and wall values of mass fraction (in the interests of readability the indicial notation mj,b etc., is dropped) and the sign is positive for products and negative for reactants. There is no real advantage to defining overpotentials in the form of eqn (22). Rather, all that is necessary is the recognition that the Nernst equation be based on wall values, instead of those in the bulk of the fluid. Some authors [3, 27] suggest that diffusion effects in fuel cells be modelled using so-called equivalent film theory, introducing a Nernst length scale. That approach is not recommended here. The suggested approach for mass transfer calculations in SOFCs is outlined in Beale [28] and follows standard approaches [29–32] to the generalized engineering mass transfer problem. In fuel cells, heterogeneous chemical reactions on the electrode surfaces lead to sources and sinks in the continuity and species (mass fraction) equations. Let it be supposed that the mass flux, m ˙ , is given by m ˙ = gB,
(37)
where m ˙ = ±Mi /1000nF is negative for O2 and H2 and positive for H2 O, and g is a mass transfer conductance. For historical reasons the symbol g is used to represent a generalised conductance, whereas the symbols h (Europe) and α (N. America) are reserved for heat transfer, with temperature as independent variable. There is clearly an element of redundancy in this convention. The driving force, B, is defined by B=
mb − mw . mw − m t
(38)
By convention, both m ˙ and B are positive for injection (H2 O at the anode) and negative for suction (O2 and H2 at the cathode and anode, respectively),
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
55
while the conductance g is always positive. The subscript, t, refers to the so-called transferred-substance state (T-state) [29, 32, 33]. For multi-component mixtures, T-state values are given by, m ˙ j mj ,t = , (39) m ˙ where m ˙ = j m ˙ j . Thus it can be seen from the stoichiometry of eqn (3) that for the air-side mt = 1 for O2 , whereas mt = −1/8 for H2 and mt = +9/8 for H2 O on the fuel-side. Equation (37) may be conveniently rewritten in dimensionless form B=
g∗ b, g
(40)
˙ → 0, and the blowing parameter, where g ∗ denotes the value of g in the limit m b, is given by m ˙ (41) b= ∗. g Equation (38) may be rearranged to obtain the required form 1 + mmbt B mw . = mb 1+B
(42)
Ideally actual mass transfer data for B(b) for the particular channel geometry under consideration are available; if not, the solution to the 1-D convectiondiffusion equation, B = exp (b) − 1 (43) may be used as an approximation. Figure 7 shows data from numerical simulations of fully-developed mass transfer in ducts of various geometries [34]. It can be
Figure 7: Mass transfer driving force as a function of blowing parameter, from [28].
56 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells seen that data normalized in the form of B vs. b (or equivalent) conforms well to the curve corresponding to eqn (43). The choice of non-dimensional number is important; for example use of a wall Reynolds number, Re, or Sherwood number, Sh, for the abscissa in place of the normalised convection flux, b, will not result in the data reducing to (roughly) a single curve. Equations (42) and (43) or equivalent, are sufficient to compute mass transfer losses in the form of eqn (22) in a manner which is reasonably rigorous while at the same time being reasonably simple to implement. Thus knowledge of g ∗ for air-side and fuel-side geometries together with experimental data or an analytical expression for B(b) is sufficient to obtain a reasonable estimate of diffusion losses in a fuel cell. Some deviations from Fig. 7 are to be anticipated for a variety of reasons (entry-length considerations, Schmidt number variations, etc.). If experimental data are available, these should always be used. It is to be noted that for many situations the mass flow rates are small, and under the circumstances g = g ∗ and B = b. Values of g ∗ may be obtained from the zero-mass flux Sherwood number, Sh∗ , g ∗ Dh . (44) Sh∗ = Note that diffusion control is important in fuel cells at high current densities/mass fluxes, not in the limit Sh → Sh∗ . Figure 8 shows values of Sh∗ for fully-developed mass flow and scalar transport in rectangular ducts of various aspect ratios, as given in Table 43 of ref. [35]. It is to be noted that suction (e.g. at the cathode) reduces mass transfer, i.e. g/g ∗ < 1, whereas blowing (e.g. at the anode) has the opposite effect g/g ∗ > 1. Knowledge of the T-state value is also useful when performing detailed CFD simulations. These may be used to prescribe boundary conditions in the species equations (see Section 2.5). Although this introductory analysis is
Figure 8: Sh∗ (Nu∗ ) for rectangular ducts in the limit of zero blowing. From [34], data of Schmidt [35].
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
57
Figure 9: Schematic representation of a SOFC with hydrogen as fuel. appropriate for mass transfer in the gas channels, Section 2.9 shows that it may be readily extended to consideration of more complex geometries involving combined mass transfer in channels and porous diffusion layers. Section 2.11 discusses some further considerations for mass transfer analysis in fuel cells. 1.7 Basic computational algorithm We are now in a position to construct a simple algorithm for computation of the performance for a fuel cell. Assume the following are known: cell voltage, V , ˙ a,in , m ˙ f ,in , and temperature, T , air pressure Pa , inlet flow rates for air and fuel, m mass fractions of the component species in the air, mO2 ,in , mN2 ,in , and the fuel, mH2 ,in , mH2 O,in , respectively. 1. Guess an initial value for the current i. 2. Calculate mass sources/sinks, s˙O2 , s˙H2 , s˙ H2 O , from Faraday’s law. Compute ˙ f ,out , and mass fractions, mO2 ,out , air and fuel outlet mass flow rates, m ˙ a,out , m mH2 ,out , mH2 O,out , mN2 ,out . 3. Calculate average of inlet and outlet bulk mass fractions and then compute wall mass fractions, using eqn (42). 4. Compute the anode and cathode overpotentials, ηa , ηc , from the Butler-Volmer equation eqn (35), based on wall values. 5. Compute the Nernst potential, E, from eqn (20), based on wall values. 6. Compute the current, i, from i=
E − ηa − ηc − V . Re
(45)
7. Repeat steps 2–6 until convergence is obtained. This simple procedure will form the basis for subsequent more complex procedures described further below. The continuity relationships in step (5) are easily ˙ a,in + s˙O2 and m ˙ f ,out = m ˙ f ,in + s˙H2 + s˙H2 O computed. For example; m ˙ a,out = m while the mass fraction equations are just mk,out = mk,in + s˙k /(˙sk + m ˙ k,in ), where k = O2 , H2 , H2 O, as appropriate.
58 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells One important note regards the requirement of prescribed current vs. prescribed voltage. Traditionally physicists work with prescribed voltage, and electrochemists with prescribed current, i (or current density, i ). If it is required that the galvanostatic condition, as opposed to the potentiostatic condition, be prescribed, then it is necessary to adjust the prescribed voltage until the required current is obtained. This is straightforward and two methods for achieving the same end are discussed in Section 2.7.
2 Computer schemes The numerical scheme described above is of limited practical utility, though it does set the stage for what follows. Numerical schemes vary from very simple schemes requiring a few seconds to run on a personal computer, to complex models which require large computers and long run times. The latter might be used for detailed cell design whereas the former could be employed in a system model including balance-of-plant or for real-time control. If a SOFC or stack is well-designed, the inlet flow streams will be uniform. However, there may be very substantial variations of mass fraction, temperature, and current density across the fuel cell. Also the flow velocities along the cell passages vary due to mass sources/sinks, and as a result, the pressure may also change in a non-linear fashion. Thus there are many circumstances where it is necessary to solve only the continuity and scalar transport equations, employing the previously-described algorithm, and not involve the pressure-corrected momentum equations in the solution. In other situations, for example when investigating a particular configuration of flow channels, solutions to the momentum equations are required. It is important to distinguish between situations where the domain is tessellated so finely that diffusive components (viscous effects, heat conduction, and gas diffusion) are captured, and situations where it is necessary to invoke a rate equation for the diffusion flux of some general field variable, . −
∂ = g. ∂y w
(46)
The local gradient of at the wall is thus replaced by the bulk-to-wall (or in some cases bulk-to-bulk) difference, , thus invoking the concept of a conductance, g, discussed in detail above in Section 1.6. This notion is central to the classical subject of convective heat and mass transfer [36]. In general, when discretising a SOFC, a mesh will be constructed. It may be structured or unstructured, and it may or may not be boundary fitted (so that each cell corresponds to a given fluid/solid material). For detailed simulations where the diffusion terms are evaluated directly, a fine mesh, concentrated in the nearwall fluid boundaries, will be required as shown in Fig. 10(a). If a rate-equation assumption is invoked, a coarse body-fitted mesh, (b), may be employed, or (c) the mesh may be arbitrary corresponding to local volume averaging. In this case no
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
59
Figure 10: Some possible grids used to discretise a planar SOFC (a) Detailed boundary-fitted (b) Boundary-fitted rate-based formulation (c) Volumeaveraged (non-boundary-fitted).
spatial distinction is made between the different materials in the fuel cell. All of these schemes have their advantages and disadvantages. For the latter case storage allocation may be required for more than one phase at each computational cell, whereas for case (b) it is necessary to keep track of all material properties and inter-phase coefficients (conductances), which may be numerous. For case (a), the grid may be so large as to render calculations intractable for large SOFC stacks. Thus there is a trade-off between detail and speed. The code designer is obliged to make some decisions at the outset regarding the nature of the mesh and the corresponding numerical scheme. Let it be supposed that the SOFC is composed of four distinct media: (1) air, (2) fuel, (3) electrolyte, and (4) interconnect. Let it further be assumed that the electrodes are sufficiently thin that they may be considered as forming the electrolyte surfaces. We shall relax these assumptions in due course. In the next section, we shall consider how to solve such a system using a finite-volume procedure [37]. 2.1 General scalar equation Let is be proposed that a prototype equation having the form ∂(ρj εj j ) αjk (k − j ) + ∇ · (εj ∇j ) + εj s˙ + ∇ · ρεj u j j = εj ∂t j
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
(47)
60 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells be adopted, where is a generic scalar (continuity, mass fraction, enthalpy, etc.) α is a volumetric inter-phase transfer coefficient and is an exchange coefficient. Let the terms in eqn (47) be referred to as, from left to right: (i) transient, (ii) convection, (iii) inter-phase transfer, (iv) diffusion or within phase transfer, and (v) source. If the volume fractions, εj , are constant they make no contribution to the overall balance, and can be eliminated prior to integrating the equations. Moreover, if a boundary-fitted mesh is employed, εj = 0 for all but one ‘phase’ for which εj = 1. For simplicity they will therefore be removed in the analysis. Generally-speaking, terms (iii) and (iv) are mutually exclusive. Also, although (iii) is listed here as a distinct term, it is almost always coded in the form of a linearised source term (v). For steady co-flow, counter-flow and cross-flow, the equations simplify further and in some situations, reduce to ordinary differential equations. Equation (47) may readily be converted to linear algebraic equations having the form, aW (W − P ) + aE (E − P ) + aS (S − P ) + aN (N − P ) (48) + CP (VP − P ) + SP = 0, where in the interests of brevity, the steady 2-D form has been adopted. Equation (48) is the form appropriate to the finite-volume method. The compass notation E = East, W = West, S = South, N = North, T = Previous time step, etc. has been adopted [37]. The terms SP and CP (VP − P ) are referred to as fixed source and linearised source terms, respectively. 2.2 Continuity It is usual to solve the phase continuity equations ∂ρj
· ρj u j = m ˙ +∇ j . ∂t
(49)
The source terms in the air and fuel passages are due to the electrochemical reactions at the electrodes, namely: m ˙ j = ± Mk i /1000nF, (50) k
where Mk is the molecular weight of chemical element k (O2 , H2 , H2 O) in fluid j, (air or fuel). Since the continuum equations are integrated, it is equivalent to prescribe source terms as being per unit volume or per unit area. 2.3 Momentum The decision to solve the momentum equations depends on the problem at hand. For single SOFCs where it is known, a priori, that the inlet flows are uniform
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
61
and steady, there is little point to adding additional complexity to the code. For a 3-D SOFC stack problem, or for a single cell which has yet to be designed, the flow may vary substantially, and it is therefore necessary to solve a generic equation of the form: ∂(ρj u j )
j − Fj εj u j + ∇
· (µ∇
u j ),
· (ρj u j ; u j ) = −∇P +∇ ∂t
(51)
where the subscript j refers to either air or fuel as distinct phases. Since the phases do not intermingle, the inter-phase terms are of the form Fj εj (0 − u j ). The second term on the right-side of eqn (51) is normally absent for a detailed numerical analysis, Fig. 10(a). Conversely, for cases Figs 10(b) and (c), it is assumed that if transient and inertial effects were negligible, the overall pressure drop would be entirely due to fluid drag or resistance,
j = −Fj U
j = −εj Fj u j , ∇P
(52)
is a local bulk superficial velocity, u is a local bulk interstitial velocity, where U and the quantity Fj has been referred to as a ‘distributed resistance’[38], which for a homogeneous porous media of permeability, kDarcy , has the significance Fj = µ/kDarcy .
(53)
Generally-speaking the dependent variable for case Fig. 10(a) is the actual local velocity, u ; for (b) u is the local bulk interstitial velocity, and for (c) it may be
For fully-developed laminar duct flows with negligible chosen to be either u or U. mass transfer, τw C f∗= 1 = . (54) 2 Re 2 ρu Shah and London [35] suggest that for rectangular ducts, dimensions L × H : C = 24(1−1.3553α∗ +1.9467α∗2 −1.7012α∗3 +0.9564α∗4 −0.2537α∗5 ), (55) where α∗ = H /L or L/H , whichever is a minimum. The Reynolds number, Re = Dh ρu/µ, is based on a hydraulic diameter Dh = 4A/P, where A is the flow area and P is the wetted perimeter. It can readily be shown that Fj =
2C µ . ε Dh2
(56)
For a detailed numerical simulation, Fig. 10(a), knowledge of eqns (52) to (56) is irrelevant. The drag is directly obtained from the viscous term in eqn (51). Conversely, for a rate-based formulation, the viscous term is discarded in favour of eqns (52) to (56). In reality, F will also vary due to mass transfer effects, f/f ∗ = 1, as τ = µ|∂u/∂y| is a function of the shape of the velocity profile which depends on the rate of mass transfer. This profile is not necessarily similar to the scalar mass fraction profile [39]; eqn (43) or Fig. 7 cannot be used to correct F. Detailed experimental
62 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells or numerical data of f/f ∗ as a function of the momentum blowing parameter are required for the particular geometry under consideration. At present, this consideration is often simply ignored. Reference [18] contains a comparison of a distributed resistance formulation with a detailed CFD methodology for a SOFC stack including heat and mass transfer effects. 2.4 Heat transfer Equation (47) is considered appropriate for the analysis of heat transfer, with the solved-for variable generally being written in terms of temperature (not enthalpy or internal energy) as ∂ ρj cj Tj
· (k ∇T
j) + ∇
· q ˙ + q˙ . (57) + ∇¯ · (ρcj u j Tj ) = αjk (Tk − Tj ) + ∇ ∂t j
A volumetric heat source occurs in the electrolyte due to irreversible Joule heating. This is given by i (E − V ) , (58) q˙ = He where He is the thickness of the electrolyte. For thin electrodes the energy of activation at the electrodes may be prescribed as per unit area with a magnitude q˙ = i η
(59)
normal to the electrode surface. An additional heat source is due to the entropy change as discussed in Section 1.3 and can be expressed as q˙ =
i (G0 − H 0 ). 2F
(60)
Technically this should be split into anodic and cathodic components. For SOFCs this source term is usually prescribed at the anode. Convective sources exist also by virtue of mass transfer at the walls and these must also be accounted for (see below). The reader will note that there is inter-phase heat transfer between solids and fluids. At the same time there is within-phase metallic conduction, for example in the metallic interconnects. This is one case where both terms (iii) or (iv) in eqn (47) are present. The volumetric heat transfer coefficients are computed as αV = U¯ A,
(61)
where A is the area for heat transfer, V is cell volume, and U¯ is an overall heat transfer coefficient, obtained using harmonic averaging, for example; H 1 1 , + = hA kAS cond U¯ A
(62)
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
63
Figure 11: Shape factor for square ducts for the case, L/H = Lchannel /Hchannel = 2.
where Scond is a conduction shape factor. (N.B. the standard definition in heat transfer texts includes the term H /A, where A is the maximum surface area for heat transfer and H is the thickness of the solid region). Figure 11 shows an example of Scond for square geometry. These data were obtained by the present author by means of numerical simulation. The fuel cell designer should obtain Scond from a numerical simulation for the Laplacian system, ∇ 2 φ = 0, for the actual geometry under consideration. Fin theory may be employed, if there are significant temperature variations within the interconnects. Conduction shape factors may also be used when considering the potential distribution in the interconnects where the electric resistance is given by H r= . (63) σAScond It is to be noted that for both electric and thermal conduction, the shape function will vary as a function of the direction of the local current density or heat flux vector. It is thus an engineering approximation. Temperature variations in fuel cells are inevitable, even when the heat sources are entirely uniform (corresponding to uniform current density and resistance). Figure 12 shows typical simulated temperature variations for a cross-flow SOFC; Achenbach [10] compares the performance for co-flow and counter-flow as well. Temperature variations impact in a number of ways; in particular the electrolyte resistance, re , is extremely temperature dependent. This in turn influences the current density and hence the internal power dissipation. Temperature also affects the local Nernst potential, E0 . Generally speaking lower temperatures are required for mechanical stability, however if methane is used as fuel, higher temperatures are needed to assist the reforming reaction. The thermally conducting interconnect is beneficial; were it not present, the temperature gradients in Fig. 12 would be much greater.
64 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 12: Temperature variation, deg. C, in a SOFC for cross-flow. 2.5 Mass transfer Treatment for mass transfer within the gas phases is particularly simple, namely: ∂(ρmk )
· (ρ uj mk ) = ∇ · (∇mk ) + ∇
· j , +∇ k ∂t
(64)
where the diffusion term is absent for cases Fig. 10(b)(c). The reader will note that there are no inter-phase mass transfer terms. Mass sources/sinks at the wall are of the form ˙ mk ,t . (65) jk = m Thus mass transfer values are just the T-state values. The wall values, needed for the Nernst equation, are obtained directly by the calculation procedure, for case Fig. 10(a). For cases Fig. 10(b) and (c) these must be computed using eqns (42)– (43), or equivalent, from the local bulk mass fractions. This is particularly simple with the mass-based formulation, given above. 2.6 Numerical integration schemes The generalised coupled system of equations is quite complex, and we shall illustrate by considering the simplified case of the energy equation for the case of steady 2-D cross-flow, for which numerous terms may be eliminated. Specifically, in the fluids the inter-phase terms (Fig. 10(a)), and/or diffusion terms (Figs 10(b) and (c)) are absent or negligible; in the solids terms (i) and (ii) are absent. Thus we can write eqn (47) for the air and electrolyte in the following reduced forms, dTa = αae (Te − Ta ) + αai (Ti − Ta ), dx
· ke ∇T
e + αae (Ta − Te ) + αfe (Tf − Te ) + q˙ , 0=∇ (ρuc)a
(66) (67)
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
65
where the subscripts a, f , e, i refer to air, fuel, electrolyte, and interconnect phases. Similar expressions may easily be written for the fuel and interconnect. These may readily be discretised as follows: ∗ − TaP ) = 0, c˙ a (TaW − TaP ) + αae V (TeP − TaP ) + αai V (TfP − TaP ) + aF (TaP (68)
dew (TeW − TeP ) + dee (TeE − TeP ) + des (TeS − TeP ) + den (TeN − TeP ) ∗ − TeP ) + q˙ P = 0, + αae V (TaP − TeP ) + αfe V (TfP − TeP ) + aF (TeP
(69)
where c˙ = mc ˙ = ρuAc and de = kA/|P − E| etc., are convection and diffusion terms, respectively. This is a set of simplified 2-D finite-volume equations (eqn (48)) with = T . For air: convection dominates and the linear coefficients are aW = c˙ a , aE = aS = aN = 0; the inter-phase terms may be linearised with coefficients Ce = αae V , Ci = αai V , and values Ve = TeP , Vi = TiP , and there are no internal sources of heat S = 0. For the electrolyte: the linkages are diffusive, aE = dew , etc., and the inter-phase terms are as above, namely Ca = αae V , Cf = αfe V , and ˙ P . Thus Va = TaP , Vf = tfP . This time, however, there is a heat source S = Q by careful consideration of the governing equations, it is possible to effect great savings in computer resources, when generating source code in-house. The symbol TP∗ denotes the value of TP at the previous iteration, and aF is an inertial or false time step coefficient. This mechanism is used to relax the scheme in order to procure convergence. 2.7 Iterative procedure The calculation proceeds precisely as in Section 1.7, except that calculations are performed on a per-unit-cell basis rather than at the mean of the inlet and outlet values. A local Nernst potential may be computed: E(x, y) = V + i r + ηa + ηc = V + ri i ,
(70)
¯ current where ri is a local internal resistance. Average values of Nernst potential, E, ¯ density, i , electrolyte resistance, r¯e etc. are obtained by summation. The galvanostatic (constant current) condition is usually implemented for stack models to ensure overall charge conservation. When the overall current or mean current density, ¯i , is prescribed, some form of ‘voltage correction’, V , is required. For example a correction may be applied in the form V = −ri ¯i ,
(71)
where V = V ∗ + V is the desired cell voltage, and V ∗ is the value of V at the previous iteration; similarly ¯i = ¯i + ¯i∗ is the desired value and ¯i∗ is the previous computed value. Thus the mean current density, ¯i ∗ , is computed at the end of each iterative cycle compared to the desired value ¯i, and the voltage is corrected
66 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells accordingly. r¯i need not be exact; any reasonable value will procure conversion. An alternative approach taken in many codes is to directly set V = E¯ − r¯i ¯i .
(72)
If eqn (72) is employed, r¯i must be carefully computed using numerical integration over the surface of the SOFC. Because very small changes in V can effect large changes in i , relaxation is generally employed. We have used both eqns (71) and (72) with success in our numerical codes and schemes. The reader will note that if the full potential field is solved-for as a scalar variable, as discussed below in Section 2.10, there is no need to adjust the voltage. Another adjustment often made while performing fuel cell calculations is to change the inlet flow rates until particular values of the utilisation for fuel and air are obtained. This is straightforward. 2.8 Additional chemistry and electrochemistry One advantage of the SOFC is that CO and CH4 may be used as fuels in addition to pure H2 . This introduces additional kinetics and further complicates mass transfer calculations. If CO is employed as fuel, the anode surface reaction is CO + O2− → CO2 + 2e− .
(73)
If both CO and H2 are present, the two reactions at the anode are considered to be in parallel, but the net anode and cathode reactions are in series, so that = iH + iCO . i = iO 2 2
(74)
The Nernst potentials are not the same, ECO/O2 = EH2 /O2 , however charge transfer (activation) and mass transfer mechanisms will ensure that the two parallel reac and i ) adjust until a single cell potential, V , is obtained, such that tion rates (iH CO 2 V = ECO/O2 − ηCO,a − ηc − i R = EH2 /O2 − ηH2 ,a − ηc − i R,
(75)
where ηCO,a and ηH2 ,a are evaluated iteratively so that ECO/O2 − ηCO,a = EH2 /O2 − , and η ηH2 ,a where ηCO,a is a function of iCO H2 ,a is a function of iH2 such that eqn (74) is identically satisfied.Although this adds complexity, nothing fundamental has changed in the basic algorithm. No further assumption need be made regarding the reaction kinetics, other than estimates for i0 and β for each anodic reaction, as discussed in Section 1.5. The CO and H2 may be produced by reforming methane CH4 + H2 O → CO + 3H2 .
(76)
The rate of reaction is considered to be kinetically controlled [10]. The water-gas shift-reaction is (77) H2 O + CO → CO2 + H2 . This process is generally considered to be thermodynamically controlled.
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
67
Figure 13: Detail of gas diffusion layer.
2.9 Porous media flow Up to the present point, the electrodes have been assumed to be sufficiently thin as to be treated as 2-D objects. There are many situations where this is not true, and these should be treated as electro-chemically reacting porous media. Moreover, SOFCs are usually designed with gas diffusion layers, in the form of porous media, as illustrated in Fig. 13. Lchannel and Lrib are the length of the gas channel and the solid ‘rib’. Under the circumstances, Darcy’s law may be used to compute the flow field, as detailed in Section 2.3. Here is a situation where the volume fraction, ε, should be retained in eqn (47). Reynolds number based on a pore diameter is used to evaluate whether the Forcheimer-modified form [40] is required to account for inertial effects. Many codes compute within-phase mass transfer by assuming an effective diffusion coefficient eff = , (78) τ where τ is a ‘tortuosity’ factor, which is a measure of the mean interstitial path length of the flow lanes per unit overall length. In general, it is to be noted that the rib design of SOFCs is one of competing interests [41]: a high ratio of Lchannel /Lrib , will increase Ohmic losses in the narrow ribs, whereas a low aspect ratio may result in non-uniform concentrations along the widely spaced gas diffusion layer. This is, of course, a function of the diffusivity (and permeability) of the gas diffusion layer as well as the current density. Recent work [34] has shown that the analysis developed in Section 1.6 may be extended to the combined or conjugate problem of simultaneous mass transfer in both the channels and diffusion layers, provided the driving force, b, is based on the overall or average conductance for the entire geometry, g¯ ∗ , obtained by harmonic averaging of the combined conductances of the gas channel and diffusion layer. The relative magnitude of mass transfer in the channels and diffusion layers is determined not only by the values Sh for the gas channel and diffusion layer, but also by the ratio eff /.
68 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells It is to be noted that within the electrodes the mean bulk mass fractions must differ from the mean wall values for a current to flow. Since it is not feasible to discretise the actual porous matrix for any practical geometry, the rate of mass transfer will need to be estimated, again using the methodology outlined in Section 1.6, in order that the Nernst equation be correctly prescribed. This will in general require knowledge of Sh∗ , for the particular porous media employed. Such data are rarely available. However bulk-to-wall mass transfer will be important at high current densities when the so-called ‘diffusion limit’ is reached, and should therefore be considered in future codes and methodologies. Heat transfer in porous media is often analyzed by assuming thermal equilibrium between the two phases, with algebraic averaging employed to compute an effective thermal conductivity keff = εkg + (1 − ε)ks , (79) where kg and ks are the gas-phase and solid-phase conductivities of the medium. When modeling fluid flow, heat and mass transfer in porous media, certain closure assumptions are made by virtue of the local volume-averaging procedure. These closures are quite reasonable and may be considered reliable. The question remains: is it possible to lump the analyses to develop a simpler, less computationally complex model? The answer would appear to be in the affirmative: certainly the techniques applied to heat and mass transfer predictions may readily be applied to the electric field, with volumetric sources and sinks of potential being applied across phase boundaries. Moreover, mass transfer in gas diffusion layers may be amenable to closed form analytic solutions. 2.10 Current and voltage distribution For planar geometries it is generally sufficient to compute the potential field using the Nernst equation (eqn (20)). This is a local 1-D model. Moreover it is often sufficient to neglect Ohmic losses in the metallic interconnects. We shall now relax these assumptions. The Nernst potential may be considered to be the sum of the potential differences across the anode and cathode, E = φa + φc , where RTf 2F RTa φc =φc0 − 4F
φa =φa0 +
ln xH2 − ln xH2 O − ηa ,
ln Pa + ln xO2 − ηc ,
(80) (81)
where Tf and Ta are the fuel-side and air-side temperatures (not necessarily the same). As has been discussed, there is an element of arbitrariness in the choice of φa0 and φc0 . A number of codes now involve the solution of the Poisson equations for the electric field over the entire region (both ionic and electronic)
· (σ ∇φ)
= s˙ , ∇
(82)
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
69
where σ is the ionic conductivity in the electrolyte or the electronic conductivity in the interconnects. Equation (82) is to be considered a statement of the principle
This is a simplified version of the scalar of conservation of charge, i = −σ ∇φ. equation, eqn (47), and presents no difficulty. If the electrodes are sufficiently thin, source terms prescribed according to eqn (80) and (81) account for step changes in potential across the anode and cathode. These may be applied as sources of equal and opposite magnitude on either side of the electrode boundary (a ‘planar’ dipole). Elsewhere in the interconnect and the electrolyte s˙ is zero, i.e., the Poisson system reduces to Laplace’s equation. Since this is a conjugate diffusion problem, harmonic averaging of the conductance, σ, should be employed. When the electrodes are of finite thickness, some care is required as electronic and ionic conduction zones overlap. Under the circumstances, storage is generally assigned for two different scalar potentials. The principle of superposition can be applied to the electric field potential, and other definitions of potential may be encountered. A variety of external boundary conditions may be applied to obtain the solution for the electric field potential. For example, (i) two voltages, V1 , and V2 may be applied at the boundaries of the interconnects (Dirichlet problem), alternatively (ii) a uniform current density may be prescribed at both boundaries (Von Neumann problem), with a single point within the assembly fixed to a reference potential, or (iii) the current density may be fixed at one interconnect and the voltage at the other (mixed boundary value problem). Figure 14 shows flux lines of current density computed from the electric potential. In this case the field is quite uniform, though in situations where mass fractions of the products/reactants vary substantially at high i , the iso-galvanic lines can be highly non-uniform. The additional effort required to obtain a solution for the electric potential should only be undertaken if significant non-uniformities in the current distribution are anticipated. This approach is generally combined with an analysis of flow and mass transfer in the porous gas diffusion layers on either side of the electrodes.
Figure 14: Particle traces along galvanostatic lines. From [34].
70 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells It is worthy of note that the Poisson system, eqn (82), can be considered to be a simplified version of the Nernst-Planck equation,
i = 2F (ρ u − ∇m)
− (σ ∇φ),
M
(83)
where for convenience we assume the presence of only a single charge carrier, O2− , in the electrolyte. Diffusion and convection are generally considered subordinate to migration in the SOFC electrolyte. 2.11 Advanced diffusion models The development derived in Section 1.6 is appropriate to so-called ‘ordinary’ diffusion, for which the diffusion flux is given by Fick’s law:
j = −ρD∇m.
(84)
Such an analysis is appropriate [42] for non-dilute, multi-component mixtures only if (85) D12 = D13 = · · · Djk = D = . ρ Kays et al. [31] suggest that this is indeed approximately the case for high temperature gases, as occur in SOFCs. If it is not the case, the simplest procedure is to calculate an effective diffusion component according to Wilkes [43] as 1 − xk Dk ,eff = xj
(86)
j =k Djk
which is exact, only for dilute mixtures in a concentrated carrier fluid. A more complete analysis involves the solution of the Stefan-Maxwell equations [44] for the diffusion fluxes n 2 mk jj − mj jk
kM ) = M . ∇(m ρ Mj Djk
(87)
j=1
The set of eqns (87) may be regarded as implicit expressions for the diffusion fluxes, jk . These may then be substituted into eqn (64) in the usual fashion, to obtain the mass fractions, mk . Typically, the linear coefficients in the finite-volume equation (eqn (48)) are caste in the same form as for ‘ordinary’ diffusion and an additional source term added [45]. This has the effect of preserving the correct form of non-linearity in the transport equations, for the case of binary diffusion. If the pore size is sufficiently small that it approaches the mean free path of the colliding particles, Knudsen diffusion must also be considered. Finally surface diffusion may also occur. Multi-component diffusion in reacting porous media is a highly complex subject, considered beyond the scope of this brief introduction.
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
71
2.12 Thermal radiation A SOFC is a high temperature device, and even though temperature differences within the passages may be small, they may nonetheless be such that radiative heat transfer is present. The relative importance of radiation in SOFCs is currently the subject of debate. Radiation may be important within the gas channels, within the electrolyte-electrode assembly, and also when thermal insulation layers are employed. Reference [46] reviews some of these issues. Surface-to-surface radiation in the micro-channels may be accounted-for by the network method [47], q0j − q0k σTk4 − q0k = , (1 − εk )/εk Ak 1/Fk−j Ak N
q˙ k =
(88)
j=1
where εk and Ak are the emissivity and area of the kth element, q0k is the radiosity (the total of emitted and reflected radiation), Fk−j is a configuration factor [48], and σ = 5.67 × 10−8 W · m 2 K4 is the Stefan-Boltzmann constant. The terms (1 − εk )/εk Ak and 1/Fk−j Ak in the denominators are referred to as ‘surface’ and ‘space’ resistances respectively. By the construction a network of resistances, the unknown radiosities may be eliminated and the system of equations solved. Since the micro-channels are very narrow, only a few immediate neighbours (opposite and sides) in any given channel will be of any consequence, and the computation can then be much simplified. The additional work involved in computing surfaceto-surface radiation along the length of the channel is probably not justified. Yakabe et al. [49] describe a procedure for calculating surface-to-surface radiation in gas micro-channels, which differed from the standard analysis, eqn (88). VanderSteen et al. [50] suggest that surface-to-surface radiation could affect the temperature by as much as 25–50 K. Although the gas channels are amenable to a simplified analysis, the electrolyte, and possibly the electrodes of a SOFC constitute radiatively participating media. Murthy and Fedorov [51] suggest the exclusion of radiation effects in the participating electrolyte could result in the over-prediction of temperatures by as much as 100–200K for the case of an electrolyte-supported SOFC. By contrast, refs. [52, 53] suggest very modest differences in electrolyte temperature; less than 1 K. These disparities indicate that the need to include radiation effects is, at present, still a moot point. Reference [51] suggests that the electrolyte may be treated as being optically thin, while the electrodes may be considered as optically thick. A very limited amount of experimental data has been gathered in support of this, to date; however [52, 53] suggest that in fact, the electrodes are so optically thick as to be entirely opaque for all practical purposes. The general radiation heat transfer problem in a participating medium involves heat transfer ‘at a distance’; described mathematically by an integro-differential equation, referred to as the radiative transfer equation (RTE). For a grey
72 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells isotropically-scattering medium, this may be written in the simplified form, eb σs di = −(a + σs ) i + a + ds π 4π
!4π i d ω.
(89)
ω=0
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
In this section only, the symbol i denotes radiant intensity (not electrical current), a and σs are absorption and scattering coefficients, s is displacement, ω is solid angle, and eb = σT 4 is black-body emissive power. The terms in eqn (89) represent (i) changes in intensity, i, due to: (ii) absorption and out-scattering, (iii) emission, and (iv) in-scattering, respectively. Detailed numerical solutions to the RTE are typically conducted using a discrete ordinate method or a Monte Carlo method. The former is more popular, at the present time, but suffers from ‘ray effects’ which can lead to numerical errors. The RTE solution results in a field of values for the radiation intensity from which a radiant flux vector, q ˙ , can be calculated for substitution in the energy equation. However, both the discrete ordinate, and Monte Carlo methods are very compute-intensive. Therefore some additional engineering assumptions are required if it is possible to invoke simpler radiation models within multi-channel fuel cells and stacks. For optically thin regions a multi-flux model may be considered, for which the 1-D two-flux model is the simplest. It is referred to, in the literature, as the SchusterSchwarzschild approximation. If it is assumed that the intensity is composed of two homogeneous components such that q˙ + = πi+ and q˙ − = πi− in the +x and −x directions, then it can readily be shown that eqn (89) may be written as, 1 d q¯ d (90) = 4a q¯ − eb , dx a + σs dx where q¯ = q˙ + + q˙ − /2, and for which (the x-component of ) the radiant flux vector, q˙ = q˙ + − q˙ − , may be computed as q˙ = −
1 d q¯ . a + σs dx
(91)
Equation (90) is a diffusion-source equation, and is thus suitable for discretisation in the form eqn (48). It has been presented in the form developed by Spalding [54], from which it differs slightly mathematically, being consistent with the formulation in Siegel and Howell [48]. A six-flux model may similarly be constructed in terms of three field variables, q¯ x , q¯ y , q¯ z in 3-D, and has the advantage of being in the same form as the general scalar equation (eqn (47)). However for thin plane layers, a two-flux model may be sufficient. The discrete ordinate method may be regarded as a generalised multi-flux method [48]. For optically thick regions, a diffusion approximation is considered appropriate, with radiative conductivity defined by, kR =
16n2 σT 3 , 3a
(92)
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
73
a is a (Rosseland mean) absorption coefficient. The term, kR , may simply be added to the normal conduction term, k, in eqn (57), i.e., keff = k +kR . There are however difficulties associated with use of the diffusion approximation near boundaries. This may be remedied by the use of a temperature modified slip boundary condition [48]. Thermal radiation is one mechanism by which it may be possible to actually control stack temperature and temperature gradients, by manipulating the optical properties of the component materials or employing radiation shields. Spinnler et al. [55, 56] propose the use of highly-reflective thermal insulation to control fuel cell temperatures by minimising losses to the environment. The above analysis adds considerably to the complexity of the calculation procedure, even so for situations where radiation is important; it is probably oversimplistic: In reality, the electrolyte assembly is a porous media with nonhomogeneous optical properties, including dependent scattering, while the interconnect is typically metallic and hence there may be both specular and diffuse components to the surface radiosity. The spectral nature of the radiative properties of the SOFC components also need to be determined. The subject has received little attention to-date and should be considered a topic for future research by scientists and engineers seeking to design high-temperature fuel cells. The four outstanding technical issues in numerical analysis of themo-fluids are; chemical kinetics multi-phase flow, radiative heat transfer and turbulence. For SOFCs, the chemical kinetics is a complex issue that needs to be addressed; multiphase flow is superficially not a problem, but the presence of porous media and the need for volume-averaging raises many of the same issues. Thermal radiation may be a matter for concern, as discussed above. Turbulence is not generally generated at the Reynolds numbers encountered within the passages of planar SOFCs, however turbulence may be encountered within the inlets and outlets and manifold passages of SOFC stacks.
3 Stack models SOFCs are stacked to increase the working voltage to a reasonable value. Fuel and air are typically introduced via manifolds (risers and downcomers). Various design configurations are possible. The main concerns of the stack designer are uniformity of flow and pressure gradients. If SOFCs were not operated in stacks, it probably would be feasible to conduct detailed numerical analysis using CFD codes without invoking a rate equation assumption, at least for simple geometries. The presence of numerous fuel cells, each with multiple channels, renders this situation unlikely for large stacks for the foreseeable future. A rough estimate of the relative magnitude of parasitic losses in the cells and manifolds can be made by assuming the flow is uniform, then analysing to see if this is a reasonable assumption. It may readily be shown from eqns (54) and (55), that for planar passages neglecting injection/suction that the pressure drop across the stack is just, ˙ 48LµQ 48Lµ¯u = , (93) P¯ = 2 H nfc WH 3
74 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 15: Pressure (Pa) in a 50-cell SOFC stack assembly. From [57]. where nfc is the number of fuel cells in the stack, 2H is the height of the (air or fuel) channels, W is the width of the cell, L is the length of the fuel cells in the ˙ = nfc BH u¯ is the volumetric discharge, assuming uniform flow flow direction, and Q conditions. A similar, though more complex, expression may be readily derived for rectangular passages. The basic principle of stack design is that the losses across the cells should be large in comparison to those in the inlet manifolds. Large changes in pressure drop are effected by changing the height of the passages, since ¯p ∝ 1/H 3 . Equation (93) is to be considered only approximate. Mass transfer will increase or decrease pressure for the cases of injection and suction, respectively. This purely inertial effect is in addition to the frictional f/f ∗ effects discussed earlier (recall Bernoulli’s law P + 12 ρu2 = constant). In the manifolds suction/blowing leads to all fluid being entirely evacuated over the stack height, H , and the latter must be considered. Berman [58] was the first to derive an analytical solution for the pressure distribution for a plane duct with mass transfer at both walls; analyses for suction/blowing at only one wall also exist [59, 60]. For rectangular geometry it is simple to utilize a numerical calculation (CFD) procedure. Figure 15 shows the pressure distribution in a 50-cell stack assembly; it can be seen that (1) in the inlet manifold the pressure gradient decreases due to suction, (2) there is relatively uniform pressure within the stack, and (3) an increasing pressure gradient is observed in the outlet manifold due to side-injection. The reader will note that different contour scales have been used in the stack and manifold regions and that the overall (parasitic) pressure losses are much larger in the former than the latter. As the stack height increases, the pressure difference between the manifolds at the top of the stack becomes much less than at the bottom and flow maldistributions may occur. Another interesting feature of fuel cell stacks is that secondary temperature distributions in the vertical direction arise, even when the flow and heat source term (due to Joule heating) are entirely uniform. Figure 16 shows the temperature distribution in a 10-cell stack obtained using a detailed numerical simulation. The oscillations in the temperature contours are due to the finite differences in temperature between
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
75
Figure 16: Temperature distribution (deg. C) in a 10-cell SOFC stack with uniform heat sources. Adapted from [34].
the air, fuel, electrolyte and interconnects for each cell in the stack. The secondary temperature gradients are caused by these materials being ordered, creating a net heat flux in the vertical direction. The stack designer cannot necessarily presume that thermo-mechanical behavior is the same for a stack as for a single cell, as has been presumed by many researchers in the past.
4 Closure Transport phenomena in SOFCs influence every aspect of their design and operation. Fluid flow, heat conduction, convection, and radiation, mass transfer, electrochemistry, charge transfer kinetics and thermodynamics are all important mechanisms. In the last 5–10 years much progress has been made in the development of robust engineering computer codes to model transport phenomena and physico-chemical hydrodynamics in these devices. This is significant progress, however further developments are needed both in models and on input data of properties. Although it is currently fashionable to state that growth in this area is ‘rapid’, it remains to be seen whether recent events will continue to be sustainable. On the one hand, design methodologies may continue to evolve exponentially, as the product unfolds and becomes commercially viable in the years to come. On the other, it could be that analysis tools will plateau and languish, if the technology proves to be uncompetitive, and promises of economic viability prove to be a ‘bubble’. The author’s hope is that the former will prove to be the case, and that years from now, we will see improvements, not only in analysis methods, but also as a result, in the products. It is clear that if SOFCs, or indeed any other new technologies, are to supplant existing products and processes, they must be designed properly. Every available analysis tool and advanced scientific method needs to be brought to bear upon the problem, if good engineering is to replace good will and sway the public to buy new and untested products over established and functioning ones, in a competitive market place. In many ways the success or failure of fuel cells will ultimately depend on factors completely unrelated to the thermodynamic efficiency of the electrode-electrolyte assembly, so popular among research proposals. Probably reliability and safety
76 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells rank even higher than cost-per-unit energy, and while mathematical modeling alone cannot safeguard these attributes, careful engineering using established techniques such as those described in the chapters in this book (and already widely employed in design of conventional power-generation equipment) will likely prove a good investment, and aid in better understanding of equipment performance. To be competitive, fuel cells need to be at least as well or better designed than existing products. Finally, for a variety of reasons, numerical models of physico-chemical processes can now be developed in much shorter time-scales (months), and for much less cost than it takes to build complex experimental test rigs (years). While this situation cannot be blamed upon those who seek to construct models and codes, it is nonetheless an unhealthy situation; a balanced program of research should always involve the continuous feedback of experimental data to analysis tools, as well as the abstraction of that which is being modelled to the pragmatist. It is therefore imperative to establish reliable data bases of empirical data for code evaluation purposes.
Acknowledgements There are many people who have assisted the author in this endeavour, both directly and indirectly. Thanks are due to (in alphabetical order): Katherine Cook, Kyle Daun, Wei Dong, Eliezer Gileadi, Ron Jerome, Yongming Lin, Fengshan Liu, and Rod McMillan.
References [1] Appleby, A.J. & Foulkes, F.R., Fuel Cell Handbook, Van Nostrand Reinhold: New York, 1989. [2] Kordesh, K. & Simader, G., Fuel Cells and their Applications, VCH: New York, 1996. [3] Larminie, J. & Dicks, A., Fuel Cell Systems Explained, Wiley: Chichester, 2000. [4] Williams, K.R., An Introduction to Fuel Cells, Elsevier: Amsterdam, 1966. [5] Vayenas, C.G. & Hegedus, L.L., Cross-flow, solid-state electrochemical reactors: A steady-state analysis. Ind. & Eng. Chem. Fundamentals, 24, pp. 316–314, 1985. [6] Fiard, J.M. & Herbin, R., Comparison between finite volume and finite element methods for the numerical simulation of an elliptic problem arising in electrochemical engineering. Computational Methods in Applied Mechanical Engineering, 115, pp. 315–338, 1994. [7] Ferguson, J.R., Analysis of temperature and current distributions in planar SOFC designs. Proceedings Second International Symposium on Solid Oxide Fuel Cells, Athens, Greece, pp. 273–280, 1991. [8] Herbin, R., Fiard, J.M. & Ferguson, J.R., Three-dimensional numerical simulation of the temperature, potential and concentration distributions of a unit
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
[9]
[10]
[11]
[12]
[13]
[14]
[15] [16] [17]
[18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23]
[24] [25]
77
cell for various geometries of SOFCs. Proceedings, European Solid Oxide Fuel Cell Forum l, Luzern, Switzerland, 1994. Karoliussen, H., Nisancioglu, K., Solheim, A., Odegard, R., Singhal, S.C. & Iwahara, H., Mathematical modeling of cross plane SOFC with internal reforming. Proceedings, Third International Symposium on Solid Oxide Fuel Cells, Honolulu, Hawaii, 1993. Achenbach, E., Three-dimensional modeling and time-dependent simulation of a planar solid oxide fuel cell stack. Journal of Power Sources, 73, pp. 333– 348, 1994. Bessette, N.F. & Wepfer, W.J., Electochemical and thermal simulation of a solid oxide fuel cell. Chemical Engineering Communications, 147, pp. 1–15, 1996. Bernier, M., Ferguson, J. & Herbin, R., A 3-dimensional planar SOFC stack model. Proceedings, Third European Solid Oxide Fuel Cell Forum, Nantes, France, pp. 483–495, 1998. Ahmed, S., McPheeters, C. & Kumar, R., Thermal-Hydraulic model of a monolithic solid oxide fuel cell. Journal of the Electrochemical Society, 138, pp. 2712–2718, 1991. Sira, T. & Ostenstad, M., Temperature and flow distributions in planar SOFC stacks. Third International Symposium on Solid Oxide Fuel Cells, Honolulu, Hawaii, pp. 851–860, 1993. Costamagna, P. & Honegger, K., J. Electrochem. Soc., 145(11), pp. 2712– 2718, 1998. Chan, S.H., Khor, K.A. & Xia, Z.T., Journal of Power Sources, 93, pp. 130–140, 2001. Beale, S.B., Lin, Y., Zhubrin, S.V. & Dong, W., Computer Methods for Performance Prediction in Fuel Cells. Journal of Power Sources, 11(1–2), pp. 79–85, 2003. Beale, S.B. & Zhubrin, S.V., A distributed resistance analogy for solid oxide fuel cells. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part B, in press. Newman, J.S., Electrochemical Systems, Prentice-Hall Inc.: Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1973. Levich, V.G., Physicochemical Hydrodynamics, Prentice-Hall: Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1962. Probstein, R.F., Physicochemical Hydrodynamics: An Introduction, Butterworths: Boston, 1989. Callen, Thermodynamics, John Wiley & Sons Inc.: New York, 1960. Glasstone, S., Laidler, K.J. & Eyring, H., The Theory of Rate Processes: The Kinetics of Chemical Reactions, Viscosity, Diffusion and Electrochemical Phenomena. International Chemical Series, McGraw-Hill: New York, 1941. Gileadi, E., Electrode Kinetics for Chemists, Chemical Engineers, and Material Scientists, Wiley-VCH: New York, 1993. Bockris, J.O.M., Reddy, A.K.N. & Gamboa-Aldeco, M., Modern Electrochemistry. Vol. 2, Plenum: New York, 2000.
78 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells [26] [27] [28] [29] [30]
[31] [32] [33] [34]
[35]
[36] [37] [38]
[39] [40]
[41]
[42] [43] [44]
Bard, A.J. & Faulkner, L.R., Electrochemical Methods, 2nd edn, John Wiley & Sons: New York, 2001. Fuel Cell Handbook, 5th edn, U.S. Department of Energy, National Energy Technology Laboratory: Morgantown/Pittsburgh, 2000. Beale, S.B., Calculation procedure for mass transfer in fuel cells. Journal of Power Sources, 128(2), pp. 185–192, 2004. Spalding, D.B., Convective Mass Transfer: An Introduction, Edward Arnold: London, 1963. Spalding, D.B., A standard formulation of the steady convective mass transfer problem. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 1, pp. 192– 207, 1960. Kays, W.M., Crawford, M.E. & Weigand, B., Convective Heat and Mass Transfer, 4th edn, McGraw-Hill: New York, 2005. Mills, A.F., Mass Transfer, Prentice Hall: Upper Saddle River, N.J., 2001. Kays, W.M. & Crawford, M.E., Convective Heat and Mass Transfer, 2nd edn, McGraw-Hill: New York, 1980. Beale, S.B., Conjugate mass transfer in gas channels and diffusion layers of fuel Cells. Proceedings 3rd International Conference on Fuel Cell Science, Engineering and Technology, eds R.K. Shah & S.G. Kandlikar, ASME: Ypsilanti, Michigan, 2005. Shah, R.K. & London, A.L., Laminar flow forced convection in ducts. Advances in Heat Transfer, eds T.F. Irvine & J.P. Hartnett, Academic Press: New York, 1978. Jacob, M., Heat Transfer, Wiley: New York, 1949. Patankar, S.V., Numerical Heat Transfer and Fluid Flow, Hemisphere: New York, 1980. Patankar, S.V. & Spalding, D.B., A Calculation Procedure for the Transient and Steady-state Behavior of Shell-and-tube Heat Exchangers. Heat Exchangers: Design and Therory Sourcebook, eds N. Afgan & E.U. Schlünder, Scripta Book Company: Washington, D.C., 1974. Beale, S.B., Mass transfer in plane and square ducts. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, in press. Vafai, K. & Tien, C.L., Boundary and Inertia Effects on Flow and Heat Transfer in Porous Media. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 24(2), pp. 195–203, 1981. Ferguson, J.R., Fiard, J.M. & Herbin, R., Three-dimensional numerical simulation for various geometries of solid oxide fuel cells. Journal of Power Sources, 58, pp. 109–122, 1996. Knuth, E.L., Multicomponent diffusion and Fick’s law. Physics of Fluids, 2, pp. 339–340, 1959. Wilke, C.R., Diffusional properties of multicomponent gases. Chemical Engineering Progress, 46(2), pp. 95–104, 1950. Taylor, R. & Krishna, R., Multicomponent Mass Transfer, Wiley-Interscience: New York, 1993.
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
[45]
[46] [47] [48] [49] [50]
[51] [52]
[53]
[54]
[55]
[56]
[57]
[58] [59] [60]
79
Kleijn, C.R., van der Meer, T.H. & Hoogendoorn, C.J., A mathematical model for LPCVD in a single wafer reactor. Journal of the Electrochemical Society, 136(11), pp. 3423–3433, 1989. Damm, D.L. & Fedorov, A.G., Radiation heat transfer in SOFC materials and components. Journal of Power Sources, in press. Oppenheim, A.K., Radiation analysis by the network method. Transactions of the ASME, 78, pp. 725–735, 1956. Siegel, R. & Howell, J.R., Thermal Radiation Heat Transfer, 4th edn, Hemisphere: Washington, 2002. Yakabe, H., Ogiwara, T., Hishinuma, I. & Yasuda, I., 3-D model calculation for planar SOFC. Journal of Power Sources, 102, pp. 144–154, 2001. VanderSteen, J.D.J., Austin, M.E. & Pharaoh, J.G., The role of radiative heat transfer with participating gases on the temperature distribution in solid oxide fuel cells. Proceedings 2nd International Conference on Fuel Cell Science, Engineering and Technology, eds R.K. Shah & S.G. Kandlikar, Rochester, NY, 2004. Murthy, S. & Federov, A.G., Radiation heat transfer analysis of the monolith type solid oxide fuel cell. Journal of Power Sources, 124, pp. 453–458, 2003. Damm, D.L. & Fedorov, A.G., Spectral radiative heat transfer of the planar SOFC. Proceedings International Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition, ASME: Anaheim, California, 2004. Daun, K., J., Beale, S.B., Liu, G. & Smallwood, G.J., Radiation heat transfer in solid oxide fuel cells. Proceedings of 2005 Summer Heat Transfer Conference, ASME: San Francisco, California, 2005. Spalding, D.B., Mathematical Modelling of Fluid-mechanics, Heat-transfer and Chemical-reaction Processes: A Lecture Course. 1980, Computational Fluid Dynamics Unit, Imperial College, University of London: London. Spinnler, M., Winter, E.R.F. & Viskanta, R., Studies on high-temperature multilayer thermal insulations. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 47, pp. 1305–1312, 2004. Spinnler, M., Winter, E.R.F., Viskanta, R. & Sattelmayer, T., Theoretical studies of high-temperature multilayer thermal insulations using radiation scaling. Journal of Quantitative Spectroscopy and Radiative Transfer, 84, pp. 477–491, 2004. Beale, S.B., Ginolin, A., Jerome, R., Perry, M. & Ghosh, D., Towards a virtual reality prototype for fuel cells. PHOENICS Journal of Computational Fluid Dynamics and its Applications, 13(3), pp. 287–295, 2000. Berman, A.S., Laminar flow in channels with porous walls. Journal of Applied Physics, 24(9), pp. 1232–1235, 1953. Jorne, J., Mass transfer in laminar flow channel with porous wall. Journal of the Electrochemical Society, 129(8), pp. 1727–1733, 1982. Lessner, P. & Newman, J.S., Hydrodynamics and Mass-Transfer in a PorousWall Channel. Journal of The Electrochemical Society, 131(8), pp. 1828– 1831, 1984.
80 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Nomenclature A a B b c D Dh E eb F
G g H h i j KP k kDarcy k kr L M m N n nfc P Q ˙ Q q q0 R r S Scond s T U U¯
Area (m2 ) Absorption coefficient (m−1 ), coefficient in finite-volume equations, length (m) Width (m) Length (m) Specific heat (J/kgK) Diffusion coefficient (m2 /s) Hydraulic diameter (m) Nernst potential (V), electric potential (V) Black-body emissive power (W/m2 ) Distributed resistance (kg/m2 s), Faraday’s constant, 96.48 (Coulomb/mol), Radiation configuration factor () Gibbs free energy (J) Mass transfer conductance (kg/s) Height (m), enthalpy (J) Heat transfer coefficient (W/m2 K), Planck constant 6.626 × 10−34 (J.s) Current (A), radiant intensity (W/sr.m2 ) Diffusion source Equilibrium constant Thermal conductivity (W/mK), rate constant (mol/m2 ) Permeability (m2 ) Thermal conductivity (W/mK) Radiative conductance (W/mK) Length (m) Molecular weight (kg/mol) Mass fraction (kg/kg), mass (kg) Number of cells in stack (), mole number Charge number (), valence () Number of fuel cells in SOFC stack Pressure (Pa), partial pressure (Pa) Charge (Coulomb) Volumetric discharge (m3 /s) Heat source term (W) Radiosity (W) Gas constant, 8.314 × 103 (J/molK), resistance (Ohm) Resistance (Ohm/m2 ) Entropy (J/K) Conduction shape factor () Source term, specific heat (J/kgK) Temperature (◦ C) Internal energy (J), superficial velocity (m/s) Overall heat transfer coefficient (W/m2 K)
Numerical models for planar solid oxide fuel cells
u V W T xi
Interstitial velocity (m/s) Volume (m3 ), voltage (V) Work (J) Temperature (K) Mole fraction (mol/mol)
Greek symbols α α∗ β ε φ η ν ρ µ σ σS τ
Volumetric transfer coefficient (W/m3 K) Aspect ratio () Transfer coefficient, symmetry coefficient (), Blockage factor () Volume fraction, void fraction (), emmissivity (m−1 ) Exchange coefficient (kg/ms) General scalar General scalar, electric field potential (V) Overpotential, polarisation (V) Stoichiometric coefficient Density (kg/m3 ) Chemical potential (J/mol), viscosity (W/mK) Electric conductivity (Ohm−1 m), Stefan-Boltzmann constant 5.67 × 10−8 (W/m2 K4 ) Scattering coefficient (m−1 ) Shear stress (N/m2 ), tortuosity ()
Non-dimensional numbers B b f Nu Sh Sc Re
Driving force Blowing parameter Friction coefficient Nusselt number Sherwood number Schmidt number Reynolds number
Subscripts 0 a b c e f i
Reference state Air, anode Bulk, backward Cathode Electrolyte Fuel, forward Interconnect, internal
81
82 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells l t w
Load total, transferred substance state Wall
Superscripts 0 ∗ . ’ + −
Reference state, equilibrium state Zero mass transfer Per unit time Per unit length Positive direction Negative direction
CHAPTER 3 Electrochemical and thermo-fluid modeling of a tubular solid oxide fuel cell with accompanying indirect internal fuel reforming K. Suzuki1 , H. Iwai2 & T. Nishino2 1 Department
of Machinery and Control Systems, Shibaura Institute of Technology, Japan. 2 Department of Mechanical Engineering, Kyoto University, Japan.
Abstract Development of fuel cells has been boosted by global and regional environmental issues. Among others, the solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) has been drawing much attention as a unit for distributed energy generation. Numerical analysis is used as a powerful tool in research and development of fuel cells, especially of the SOFC for which important and necessary thermal management information has scarcely been supplied experimentally. A central issue for achieving maximum benefit from the numerical analysis is how to properly model the complex phenomena occurring in the fuel cells. This chapter presents a numerical model for a tubular SOFC including a case with indirect internal reforming. In this model, the velocity field in the air and fuel passages and heat and mass transfer in and around a tubular cell are calculated with a two-dimensional cylindrical coordinate system adopting the axisymmetric assumption. Internal reforming and electro-chemical reactions are both taken into account in the model. Electric potential field and electric current in the cell are also calculated simultaneously allowing their nonuniformity in the peripheral direction. A previously developed quasi-two-dimensional model was adopted to combine the assumed axisymmetry of velocity, heat and mass transfer fields and the peripheral nonuniformity of electric potential field and electric current. Details of those numerical procedures are described and examples of the calculated results are discussed. After presenting a few fundamental results, several strategies to reduce the maximum temperature and temperature gradient of the cell are examined for a case with indirect internal fuel reforming.
84 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
1 Introduction One of the most important global issues in the present world is the suppression of global warming. Global warming is proceeding related to the increase of atmospheric concentration of carbon dioxide. Discharge of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere occurs in the eruption of volcanoes but the largest emission rate of carbon dioxide originates from power plants and from vehicles both of which support the modern world. Since drastic depression of energy demand and usage of automobiles cannot be accepted easily by people living in the modern society, development of energy conversion systems being free from the emission of carbon dioxide or, at least, of a system having a lower emission rate of carbon dioxide is important. Fuel cells are one of the prospective power generation systems for this purpose. There are five types of fuel cells characterized by the difference in materials for the electrolyte and in this relation by the difference in operation temperature. They are alkaline fuel cells, phosphoric acid fuel cells, polymer electrolyte fuel cells, molten carbonate fuel cells and solid oxide fuel cells (SOFCs). In this chapter, attention is paid to the last one, the SOFC. Solid oxide fuel cells (SOFCs) have an advantage in that not only hydrogen but also a variety of hydrocarbons can be used as fuels. This is because solid oxides used for the electrolyte, are oxygen-ion conducting materials. In the case of fuel cells using hydrogen-ion conducting or proton conducting materials as the electrolyte, the fuel should in principle be hydrogen only but, in the case of the SOFC, a variety of fuels including carbon monoxide in addition to hydrocarbons can react with oxygenions conducted across the electrolyte. High operation temperature provides another advantage of SOFCs. No catalyst is needed for the electrochemical reaction if they are operated at a reasonably high temperature except in the case of low temperature SOFCs [1]. In addition to this, high quality thermal energy of the effluent from the SOFCs can be recovered in various ways. Construction of a hybrid system that fuses the SOFC to a gas turbine to obtain high electricity generation efficiency is one of them [2–4]. In addition, steam reforming of hydrocarbon fuels is possible in or around the cells with the aid of high operation temperature. A variety of commercial materials can be used as a catalyst for the reforming reaction. Fuel reforming supplies hydrogen and carbon monoxide from methane as fuel, which makes the fuel cell operation simpler and additionally provides a means to cool and therefore to control the high temperature fuel cell. When the reforming reaction takes place on the anode with heat supplied directly from the electrochemical reaction, it is referred to as direct internal reforming (DIR). In this case, the cell structure is simple because no additional catalyst except the anode is needed. However, there are still difficulties in proper control both of reforming and electrochemical reactions within the anode itself [5–7]. On the other hand, the case in which the reforming reaction takes place on catalysts that are positioned apart from the anode is referred to as indirect internal reforming (IIR). This is the case treated in this chapter as will be discussed later. Another advantage of SOFCs is that the electrolyte is solid. This results in geometrical flexibility of the cell design. Several types of SOFCs having different geometry have been proposed, tested and developed so far. They are tubular SOFCs, planar
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
85
Figure 1: Schematics of three types of SOFC having different geometry.
SOFCs and disk type SOFCs. Schematics of the three types of SOFC are illustrated in Fig. 1. Planar SOFCs and disk type SOFCs are prospective in a point that they can be stacked in a compact way and that they can have higher electric power density. Therefore, they are the subject of keen research and development activities [8–11]. On the other hand, tubular SOFCs are one of the most developed towards practical use. The two major advantages of the tubular cells are that they have relatively good thermal shock resistance and that there is no need for special sealing treatment. Owing to these advantages, a thousands-hour-long operation test of an atmospheric pressure 100-kW tubular SOFC system has successfully been performed [12]. In this system, cathode-supported SOFCs are used, in which air flows inside the tubular cell structure and fuel flows around the tubular cell along its axis. Natural gas is used as fuel and it is fully reformed in “in-stack reformers”, which are placed between the rows of cell bundles composed of many tubular cells. Reformers are heated indirectly by the cells. The cell structure is simpler in this case but the stack structure is rather complicated. On the other hand, in the case of anode-supported SOFCs, fuel flows inside the tubular cell and air flows outside the tubular cell. In this case, a fuel feed tube mounted inside the tubular cell, through which fuel is injected into the tubular cell, can be used as a reformer. The feed tube is filled with the catalyst material and indirect but internal fuel reforming (IIR) proceeds while fuel flows through it. This is the concept of indirect internal reforming type tubular SOFCs (IIR-T-SOFCs) to be discussed in this chapter. In this
86 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells case, although the cell structure is a little more complicated due to the catalyst to be embedded in it, the stack structure becomes fairly simple. There is no in-stack reformer so that the size and geometry of the stack can be designed more easily and more flexibly for various SOFC electricity generation systems having different power output capacity. In addition, there is a chance to control the local thermal field in the cell by adjusting the distribution density of the fuel reforming catalyst. This is one of the achievements of earlier numerical analyses [13, 14]. At present, development of this type of SOFC is just in a conceptual design stage. So it is meaningful to study its feasibility right now and numerical simulation is considered to be an effective tool for this purpose. Numerical simulation has become a useful means in research and development in various engineering fields. Fuel cells are no exception and various numerical simulations of fuel cells have been conducted by several research groups. Numerical modeling of fuel cells is complicated due to a variety of phenomena occurring in the cells such as multi-component gas flows with heat and mass transfer, electrochemical reactions between fuel and air, and electric potential field and ionic and electric current in the cell. Numerical simulation is especially important for SOFCs. They need good thermal management because the operation temperature is high. However, the detailed information necessary for management is not easily supplied from measurement. Numerical simulation is a sole means to supply such information. There are two types of numerical simulations applied to SOFCs. One is for a single cell [15–20] and another for a stacked-cell module [21–24]. In this chapter, the former type of numerical simulation is treated and in particular description is given to a numerical model developed for a tubular SOFC including a case of IIR-T-SOFC based on the model for the cathode-supported tubular SOFC reported in [15, 16]. Finally, some results are also presented as examples of the simulations made with the described model.
2 General remarks on the mechanism of IIR-T-SOFC Prior to describing the numerical modeling and simulated results, general remarks will be given to the phenomena in the indirect internal reforming tubular solid oxide fuel cells, the IIR-T-SOFCs, in this section. Except for the part related to internal fuel reforming, description to follow can be applied to a general case without internal fuel reforming including the case of a conventional cathode-supported tubular solid oxide fuel cell.
2.1 Tubular cell Figure 2 shows schematic views of two types of a tubular SOFC. One is a conventional Siemens-Westinghouse type cathode-supported tubular cell [25] and another is a single cell to be used in the IIR-T-SOFC stack. The latter type of fuel cell consists of a tubular cell and a feed tube inserted in it, basically similar to a design of
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
87
Figure 2: Schematic view of a conventional tubular SOFC and IIR-T-SOFC.
Figure 3: Schematic view of a cell stack. conventional tubular SOFCs. The cell tube is composed of two electrodes sandwiching an electrolyte layer. Electrochemical reactions take place at both these electrodes, anode and cathode. The difference between the two cases illustrated in Fig. 2 is that the hydrocarbon to be used as fuel flows inside the feed tube and that the feed tube is filled with porous catalysts in the case of the IIR-T-SOFC. So fuel is reformed “indirectly” in each tubular cell. That is to say, fuel is reformed inside the feed tube, changes flow direction at the closed end of the cell tube, reacts electrochemically on the anode and then flows out of the cell. On the other hand, air flows outside the cell tube and reacts on the cathode. One drawback of this cell design is that the interconnects are exposed to the high-temperature air so that serious oxidization of the interconnects may occur. However, this problem is being resolved due to the development of new interconnect materials such as the doped-lanthanum chromite series in recent years [26, 27]. The tubular cell can be stacked either electrically in series or electrically in parallel as shown in Fig. 3. The number of the tubular cells in the stack is adjusted so
88 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells as to fit the required electricity capacity. When the number of the cells is sufficiently large, most of the cells in the core region of the stack should be in the same thermal and operating conditions. Therefore, attention is paid in the present study to a single representative tubular cell in the core region of the stack. 2.2 Internal reforming process One of the important phenomena occurring in the IIR-T-SOFCs is the internal reforming of fuel and it takes place, as mentioned above, inside the feed tube. Although a variety of hydrocarbons can be used as fuel, description is given here as an example for the case where methane, a major component of natural gas, is used as fuel. For methane, the steam reforming process is widely known as a conventional process for producing hydrogen [28, 29] and it proceeds on catalysts such as nickelalumina through the following two chemical reactions: Reforming reaction: CH4 + H2 O ←→ 3H2 + CO.
(1)
CO + H2 O ←→ H2 + CO2 .
(2)
Shift Reaction:
The equilibrium constant of the steam reforming reaction described by eqn (1) is reasonably large so that methane can almost totally be reformed if the system is kept at the operation temperature 700 ◦ C or higher. However, a supply of thermal energy is needed for the reforming reaction to proceed since it is strongly endothermic. Therefore, how methane is reformed inside the feed tube is highly dependent on the local conditions including not only temperature but also partial pressure of each chemical species and density of the catalysts. On the other hand, the water-gas shift reaction described by eqn (2) is a weak exothermic reaction. The important point is that the shift reaction is almost in equilibrium in the entire fuel passage because its reaction rate is much faster than that of the steam reforming reaction. 2.3 Electrochemical process The most important phenomenon occurring in the tubular cell is a series of events associated with the electrochemical reaction. In the case where methane is used as fuel and is totally reformed inside the feed tube, the electrochemical processes on the anode and cathode can be described by the following reactions: H2 + O2− → H2 O + 2e−
(anode),
(3)
CO + O2− → CO2 + 2e−
(anode),
(4)
(cathode).
(5)
1 2 O2
+ 2e− → O2−
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
89
Figure 4: Basic concept of the electrochemical process.
Overall reactions are equivalent to the following: H2 + 12 O2 → H2 O,
(6)
CO + 12 O2 → CO2 .
(7)
Figure 4 illustrates the mechanism of the electrochemical processes in the tubular cell. On the cathode side, oxygen ions are produced by the combination of oxygen molecules in the air flow with electrons. The produced oxygen ions move through the electrolyte to the anode side. Electrons are released from the oxygen ions at the anode and the produced oxygen molecules react with hydrogen or carbon monoxide molecules there. The electrons released through the anode reactions move to the cathode of the neighbouring cell through the interconnect or return to the original cathode via an external circuit – i.e. electric current is generated through the tubular cells. The magnitude of the electric current directly relates to the rates of the electrochemical reactions and depends on a variety of factors. These factors can be classified into three groups: electromotive force, internal resistance, and external load of the cell. The electromotive force is an ideal cell terminal voltage to be achieved at zero electric current or when the electrochemical reaction proceeds very slowly. The internal resistance causes the loss of terminal voltage and includes three different types of overpotentials; namely ohmic overpotential, activation overpotential and concentration overpotential. Finally, the external load of the cell regulates the electric current to be realized with the fuel cell under operation and is actually equal to the cell terminal voltage divided by the magnitude of electric current.
90 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells The electromotive force is largely determined by the concentration of fuel. In general, it decreases as hydrogen and carbon monoxide are consumed and therefore as their concentrations become lower. As for the ohmic overpotential, ionic conductivity of the electrolyte is one of the important factors. It has a tendency to decrease as the temperature rises. This is the main reason why operation temperature must be high in the case of SOFCs. Electric conductivity of the electrodes also affects the magnitude of the ohmic loss of terminal voltage. Electric current flows through the electrodes basically in the circumferential direction as shown in Fig. 4. Activation overpotential occurs related to the sluggishness of electrochemical reaction and tends to decrease as the cell temperature rises. Concentration overpotential is also an important factor affecting the cell performance and is related to the radial concentration nonuniformity of participating chemical species, i.e. fuel and oxygen. At the reaction sites, their concentrations are lower so that the real electromotive force to be attained under such concentrations is lower than the counterpart that would be achieved using the concentration in the core flow regions. This difference is the concentration overpotential. These electromotive forces and internal resistances vary from place to place because temperature and gas composition are not uniform in the cell. Finally, as for the external load, electric current becomes larger and terminal voltage becomes lower as it decreases. Therefore, the output power of the cell, which is the product of the electric current and the terminal voltage, reaches a peak at a certain value of the electric current or of the external load. 2.4 Purpose and key points of the analysis In the development of good SOFCs, in particular, good IIR-T-SOFCs, there are three fundamental problems to be solved: how to improve the power generation performance, how to prevent thermal crack failure, and how to reduce the cost of production. Numerical analysis is expected to contribute to the solution of these issues. Among them, the thermal crack issue is an especially suitable one to be tackled with numerical analysis. Thermal crack failure is caused by a combination of several thermal conditions including the appearance of a hot spot or of excessively high temperature, the generation of excessively large spatial temperature gradients, the time changing rate of temperature in start-up of the fuel cells and the frequency of load change or of thermal conditions in practical operation. Cell temperature or electrochemical and other chemical reactions governing the cell temperature cannot be measured and such detailed information can only be supplied from numerical analysis. The thermal field in the cell is determined by the balance of several fundamental phenomena: heat generation accompanied with the electric current and the electrochemical processes, heat transfer among different parts of the cell having different temperature, heat absorption by the endothermic internal fuel reforming process, and heat removal by the air flow. Therefore, we must integrate all of the calculation for the gas flow fields, temperature fields both in gas flow passages and solid parts, electrochemical and fuel reforming processes and related mass transfer fields of participating chemical species, and ionic and electric current fields. This must be done with some assumptions to keep the computation load within the reach of engineering workstations but certainly must be done as accurately as possible in
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
91
order to establish reasonable databases for the thermal field of the cell. As for the gas flow velocity, temperature and mass transfer fields, at least two-dimensional axisymmetric analysis would be required to study heat and mass transfer at a reasonably accurate level. Meanwhile, consideration of peripheral nonuniformity is requisite for the electric potential field. This is because, although ionic current occurs in radial direction across the electrolyte, electric current flows basically in the circumferential direction in the electrodes as shown in Fig. 4. Of course it is better if three-dimensionality is taken into account for all related fields, but it requires an extremely large CPU time. Hence what to assume and how to integrate those calculations are the key points of the numerical analysis on tubular SOFCs including the IIR-T-SOFCs. In this study, a previously developed quasi-two dimensional treatment [15, 16] is adopted as a base to develop the new model. This quasi-two dimensional model combines the assumed axisymmetry of the velocity, heat and mass transfer fields with the peripheral nonuniformity of the electric potential and electric current fields.
3 Numerical modeling This section presents the details of the numerical modeling of a tubular SOFC, particularly of an IIR-T-SOFC. This model is based on a previously developed model for a cathode-supported tubular SOFC to be operated with reformed fuel or especially with hydrogen [15, 16]. Therefore, the main parts of the model are common to both cases with and without accompanying internal fuel reforming. However, some general parts common to both cases will be outlined for simplicity referring to the references and other parts specific to the case with indirect internal reforming will be emphasized. As mentioned in the preceding section, various phenomena occur in the tubular cell such as gas flows, heat and mass transfer, internal reforming, electrochemical reaction, non-uniform electric potential field and ionic and electric currents and generation of heat and electricity. These phenomena are closely related to one another, thus they should be considered simultaneously in the numerical analysis. For the sake of the reader’s convenience, geometry of the cell and general assumptions adopted in the present model are described as a preparation to read the following parts. After this, modeling for the most basic phenomena in fuel cells, i.e. electrochemical reactions, will be described first. Next, reforming and shift reactions are described. Then, the modeling for the velocity, temperature and concentration fields will be discussed. Description will be made of the modeling for electric potential fields, electric current and ohmic heating. Finally, an overall picture of the model is given at the end of the section. 3.1 Computational domain and general assumptions for heat and mass transfer A longitudinal sectional view of the tubular cell is shown in Fig. 5 with the dimensions and the chemical reaction equations to be considered in this study. In the examples for IIR-T-SOFCs, of which results will be discussed later, the cell tube
92 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 5: Longitudinal cross sectional view of a tubular fuel cell. geometry is assumed to be 500 mm long and to have a 6.9 mm inner radius and a 9.6 mm outer radius. For computational convenience, air is taken to flow through an annular space between a tubular fuel cell outer surface and a co-axial confining cylindrical wall of which the radius is 14.6 mm. A square drawn with a fine dotted line in Fig. 3 illustrates the average air flow space in a stack. The surface of this artificial confining wall is assumed to be thermally adiabatic and the area of the annular space is equated with the average air flow space for a single cell in a stack. This treatment is reasonable for a tubular cell located in the core of stack. The hemi-spherical tube end is replaced by a flat end in the model and the computational domain is indicated by the broken line in Fig. 5. The cell tube and fuel feed tube are solid and the feed tube is assumed to be filled with porous catalytic material, and the other areas are gas flow passages. In this study, except in a case of a hydrogen-fuelled cathode-supported tubular SOFC, fuel is assumed to be a mixture of fresh methane and recirculated effluent exhausted from the fuel cell, namely a mixture of hydrogen, steam, CO, CO2 and methane, and air is treated as a mixture of oxygen and nitrogen. All gas components are treated as ideal gases in the calculation of density and electromotive force. In the calculation of thermal fields, temperature is adopted as a variable to solve but the thermodynamic properties like specific heat at constant pressure, enthalpy and Gibb’s free energy and transport properties like viscosity and heat conductivity are treated variable with temperature. Their local values are evaluated at local temperature by consulting the tables of properties included in the program [30, 31]. Properties of mixture are evaluated with mixing laws by making use of the partial pressure of each chemical species [32]. Gaseous fluids are treated to be Newtonian and Reynolds number is lower than two hundred so that both air and fuel flows
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
93
are assumed to be laminar, steady and axisymmetric. The effect of gravity is not considered. 3.2 Model for electrochemical reactions The most basic phenomena in the fuel cell are the electrochemical processes by which chemical energy of the fuel is directly converted into electricity. In this relation, consumption of fuel and oxygen occurs. In addition to electricity generation, heat is generated as an ineffective part of the used chemical energy of the fuel. Here it is first discussed how they are modelled. As mentioned in the preceding section and shown in Fig. 5, the electro-chemical reactions of hydrogen and CO, described by eqns (6) and (7), are considered in this study. The local electromotive forces to be generated by these reactions are calculated based on the following Nernst equation: PH2 O R0 T 0 ln , (8) EH2 /O2 = EH2 /O2 − 0.5 2F PH2 PO 2 P T R 0 CO 2 0 ln ECO/O2 = ECO/O , (9) − 2 0.5 2F PCO2 PO 2
where EH0 2 /O2
0 −GH 2 /O2
=
2F
0 = ECO/O 2
0 −GCO/O 2
2F
,
(10)
.
(11)
The subscripts “H2 /O2 ” and “CO/O2 ” indicate the reactions of eqns (6) and (7), 0 0 respectively. GH and GCO/O are the changes of the standard Gibbs free 2 /O2 2 energy accompanied with the reactions, and F is the Faraday constant. It is noted here that the local partial pressures of chemical species at the surface of each electrode are assigned to the partial pressures in the above equations. This means that the concentration overpotential related to the concentration non-uniformity existing in the fuel and air flow passages is automatically taken into account in the electromotive forces described by eqns (8) and (9). The overall electrochemical reactions described by eqns (6) and (7) can be divided into the electrode reactions described by eqns (3), (4) and (5). It is necessary to consider the activation overpotential for each electrode reaction. In this study, the following equations suggested by Achenbach [18] are used to describe the activation overpotentials: ηH2 = iH2 /O2
−1 2F PH2 0.25 Aa kH exp − , R0 T 2 Pfuel R0 T
(12)
94 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells ηCO = iCO/O2
−1 2F PCO 0.25 Aa exp − , kCO R0 T Pfuel R0 T
−1 PO2 0.25 4F Ac kO =i exp − , R0 T 2 Pair R0 T
(13)
ηO 2
(14)
where kH2 , kCO and kO2 are the coefficients of each equation: kH2 = 2.13 × 108 , kCO = 2.98 × 108 and kO2 = 1.49 × 1010 A/m2 . Aa and Ac are the activation energy: Aa = 1.1 × 105 and Ac = 1.6 × 105 J/mol. In addition, iH2 /O2 and iCO/O2 are the current densities in the electrolyte arising from the reactions of eqns (6) and (7), respectively, which are related to the consumption rates of hydrogen and carbon monoxide as will be discussed later. They are also related to the local current density i as follows: i = iH2 /O2 + iCO/O2 . (15) Here the following relations exist between the electromotive force, activation overpotential, ionic current density across the electrolyte, and the electric potential of the anode and cathode, Va and Vc : EH2 /O2 − (ηH2 + ηO2 ) − iRe he = Vc − Va ,
(16)
ECO/O2 − (ηCO + ηO2 ) − iRe he = Vc − Va ,
(17)
where Re is the ionic resistivity of the electrolyte, which can be estimated considering temperature dependency as suggested by Bessette et al. [19], and he is the thickness of the electrolyte. From the above relationships, the local current density i is obtained if the local potential difference Vc − Va is given, or vice versa. In the present model, interconnects are assumed to work ideally and potential difference Vc − Va is therefore assumed to be constant along the tube axis. It is therefore equal to the cell terminal voltage. As will be explained later, the cell terminal voltage is given to start the computation and both the current density and potential fields are calculated by making use of an equivalent electrical circuit model, details of which will be discussed later. In eqns (16) and (17), note that concentration overpotential to occur in relation with the nonuniform distributions of participating chemical species in air and fuel flow passages has been taken into account in eqns (8) and (9). However, the concentration overpotential to be generated by the diffusion resistance of participating chemical species inside thin anode and cathode layers has been ignored. An approximate method to treat this type of concentration overpotential has been proposed in [33]. However, microstructure of the porous electrodes, or more specifically tortuosity as well as porosity and permeability of the porous electrodes, is not normally available. The authors found that the magnitude of the ignored concentration overpotential is not large for a case without the indirect internal fuel reforming but in future this must be revisited more carefully when appropriate data for the structure of the cell supporting material and porous electrodes become available.
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
95
3.3 Model for internal fuel reforming Steam reforming of methane proceeds in the fuel feed tube preceding the electrochemical reactions at the electrodes in the case of the IIR-T-SOFC. Therefore the modeling of internal fuel reforming is now discussed. As shown in Fig. 5, the steam reforming reaction described by eqn (1) and water-gas shift reaction described by eqn (2) are considered inside the feed tube, and the shift reaction is considered to further proceed outside the feed tube too. In this study, the reaction rates of the two reactions, Rst and Rsh , are locally calculated as follows: −57840 1.2 W exp , (18) Rst = 1.75PCH cat 4 R0 T + − PCO PH2 O − ksh PH2 PCO2 . Rsh = ksh
(19)
Equation (18) is based on an empirical formula suggested by Odegard et al. which is referred to in reference [34]. Wcat is the filling mass density of the catalyst for the steam reforming and it is an important parameter in a sense that control of its distribution can be used as a means to change the distribution pattern of cell temperature. In some examples to be discussed later, it is actually demonstrated + − and ksh denote how this control is effective. R0 is the universal gas constant. ksh the rate constants of forward and backward water-gas shift reactions and the value of Rsh is determined following the method suggested by Lehnert et al. [35]. Their values vary from one place to another because of the nonuniform distribution of cell temperature. An important point is that these constants are so large that the shift reaction is always close to its equilibrium. Chemical equilibrium is represented by the equilibrium constant which is a function of temperature and is equal to the ratio between the reactant partial pressures and the product partial pressures as follows: + 0 ksh −Gsh pCO2 pH2 Ksh = − = = exp , (20) pCO PH2 O R0 T ksh 0 is the change of the standard Gibbs free energy accompanied with the where Gsh shift reaction. This equilibrium constant is introduced into eqn (19) to calculate the rate of the shift reaction.
3.4 Governing equations of velocity, temperature and concentration fields and boundary conditions Air and fuel are continuously supplied to a fuel cell to keep its appropriate operation and they flow through their respective flow passages in and around the fuel cell. Electrochemical reactions are supplied by diffusion of the participating chemical species from the core flow region toward the reaction sites. Generated heat in the cell is partly used as a source to supply the energy to support the endothermic reforming reaction proceeding in the fuel feed tube but its main portion is transferred to and removed by fuel and air flows. Heat generation is an ineffective part of chemical
96 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells energy converted in the fuel cell and therefore occurs at a rate related to the rate of electricity generation. Electricity generation results from the electrochemical reaction of the fuel. The fuel consumption rate is related to the electric charge or ionic transfer rate across the electrolyte. Electric current occurs in the electrodes where the transferred electric charge is collected. Electric current occurs in a pattern consistent with the electric potential fields to be established in the electrodes. Ohmic heat generation occurs in accordance with the electric current in the electrodes and ionic current across the electrolyte. All these phenomena are interrelated to each other in a complicated manner. Therefore, all of the equations governing the phenomena must be integrated in a consistent manner and must be solved simultaneously in an iterative procedure. The most basic governing equations to be solved in the numerical model are the ones for the velocity field, temperature field and concentration field in the fuel cell. They are different among the three kinds of areas: gas area, solid area and porous area. For the gas area, the following two-dimensional continuity, momentum, energy and mass transfer equations for laminar flows apply: 1 ∂rρUr ∂ρUx + = 0, ∂x r ∂r ∂Ux ∂Ux ∂P ∂ ∂Ux 1 ∂ ∂Ux ρUx + ρUr =− + µ + rµ , ∂x ∂r ∂x ∂x ∂x r ∂r ∂r ∂Ur ∂Ur ∂P ∂ ∂Ur 1 ∂ ∂Ur µUr ρUx + ρUr =− + µ + rµ − 2 , ∂x ∂r ∂r ∂x ∂x r ∂r ∂r r ∂ ∂T 1 ∂ ∂T ∂T ∂T + ρCp Ur = λ + rλ + Q, ρCp Ux ∂x ∂r ∂x ∂x r ∂r ∂r ∂Yj ∂Yj ∂Yj ∂Yj ∂ 1 ∂ ρUx + ρUr = ρDjm + rρDjm + Sj . ∂x ∂r ∂x ∂x r ∂r ∂r
(21) (22) (23) (24) (25)
In the above equations, Ux and Ur are the x- and r-components of the velocity and T is the temperature. Yj is the mass fraction of chemical species j and Djm is the mass diffusivity of species j in the multicomponent mixture of gases. As described above, all of the thermodynamic and transport properties of each chemical species are treated as local variables varying with temperature and the properties of the mixture are evaluated based on mixing laws by making use of the mass fraction of each chemical species. The terms Q and Sj in eqns (24) and (25) denote the source terms to be described later. The effects of the electrochemical and reforming reactions on the thermal and concentration fields are included in these source terms. The effect of radiative heat transfer appears in the matching conditions at gassolid interfaces. However, viscous dissipation in the energy equation is neglected. Thermal diffusion in mass transfer and enthalpy transfer due to species mass transfer are not considered either in the present model.
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
97
Table 1: Thermal conductivity of the solid area.
λs [W/mK]
Anode
Cathode
Electrolyte
Support tube
Feed tube
11.0
6.23
2.7
1.1
1.1
For the solid part, the governing equation to be solved is the following heat conduction equation: ∂T ∂T 1 ∂ ∂ λs + rλs + Q, (26) 0= ∂x ∂x r ∂r ∂r where λs is the thermal conductivity of the solid. Values of λs of each material are treated to be constant and specific values used in the present study are shown in Table 1 [34]. For the porous area, the governing equations derived by the method of volumeaveraging are applied because the microstructure of porous media is generally too complicated to be considered directly in computations. In the adopted method, physical values are locally-averaged for a representative elementary volume, which is sufficiently larger than the scale of the fine structure of the porous medium and is sufficiently smaller than the scale of the porous body itself [36]. Consequently, the following transport equations of the averaged physical values are used in the present model: ∂ρUx 1 ∂rρUr + = 0, (27) ∂x r ∂r ∂Ux ∂Ux ∂P 1 ∂ ∂Ux 1 ∂ ∂Ux 1 + ρUr =− + µ + rµ ρUx ε2 ∂x ∂r ∂x ε ∂x ∂x r ∂r ∂r " µ ρf − Ux − √ Ux Ux2 + Ur2 , (28) K K ∂P 1 ∂ ∂Ur 1 ∂ ∂Ur µUr ∂Ur ∂Ur 1 + ρU = − + µ + rµ − ρU x r ∂x ∂r ∂r ε ∂x ∂x r ∂r ∂r ε2 r2 " ρf µ (29) − Ur − √ Ur Ux2 + Ur2 , K K ∂ 1 ∂ ∂T ∂T ∂T ∂T ρCp Ux + ρCp Ur = λeff + rλeff + Q, (30) ∂x ∂r ∂x ∂x r ∂r ∂r ∂Yj ∂Yj ∂Yj ∂Yj ∂ 1 ∂ ρUx + ρUr = ρDjm,eff + rρDjm,eff + Sj . ∂x ∂r ∂x ∂x r ∂r ∂r (31)
In principle, the physical values in the above equations represent the local “intrinsic” phase average of the gas (average over the gas volume, rather than the
98 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells Table 2: Parameters of the porous area. ε [–]
K [m2 ]
f [–]
λs [W/mK]
λeff [W/mK]
0.9
1.0 × 10−7
0.088
10.0
ελ + (1 − ε)λs
Djm,eff [m2 /s] √ (1 − 1 − ε)Djm
total volume). This is the case for Ux and Ur which denote the gas phase average of the local gas velocity components. However, this is not the case for temperature. A two-equation model for the thermal field [37] is not adopted in this study so that local thermal equilibrium between the two phases is assumed. Therefore, T denotes the local average both over the gas and solid phases. In addition, ε and K are the porosity and permeability of the porous medium, respectively. f is the inertia coefficient that depends on the Reynolds number and the microstructure of the porous medium [38], while λeff and Djm,eff are the effective thermal conductivity and the effective mass diffusivity of species j, respectively. Values of these parameters used in this study are shown in Table 2. The above three pairs of governing equations are properly conjugated to match at the boundaries between different areas. No-slip condition is applied for the velocity field at solid surfaces and gas-electrode interfaces. Impermeable condition is also applied to the artificial confining wall of air flow and the inner and outer surfaces of the fuel feed tube. At the gas-electrode interfaces, the normal velocity component is set equal to a value incurred by non-zero mass flow rate at the electrode due to the electrochemical reaction [16]. The artificial air-flow-confining wall is assumed to be thermally adiabatic and continuity of heat flux is applied at all of other solid surfaces and gas-electrode interfaces. At the gas-electrode interfaces, mass production or consumption rate of each chemical species is equated to a value regulated by the electrochemical reaction, which will be briefly discussed later. Other solid surfaces are treated as unreactive. In starting computation, inlet conditions must be given for air and fuel flows. In addition, the cell terminal voltage is given as an external condition to start the computation and electric current density to be achieved under the given terminal voltage is calculated. Through iteration, velocity, temperature and concentration fields are determined as their converged solutions. 3.5 Discretization scheme All the above governing equations can be solved only numerically and introduction of some sort of discretization is indispensable. So, a short description is given here about the discretization scheme adopted in the present model just as a hint for some readers who may want to develop their own home-made program. However, it may be worth noting that a number of commercial codes available for general use in a variety of thermo-fluid problems may be transformed into one applicable for fuel cell simulation. All the above governing equationsl listed in section 3.4, eqn (21) through eqn (31), and eqns (38) and (39) to appear in section 3.6 also can be expressed in
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
99
Table 3: Variables and coefficients of each governing equation. Sˆ
Eqn
φ
ρˆ
(22)
Ux
ρ
µ
(23)
Ur
ρ
µ
(24)
T
ρCp
λ
∂P ∂x ∂P µUr − − 2 ∂r r Q
(25)
Yj
ρ
ρDjm
Sj
(26)
T
0
λs
Q
(28)
Ux
(29)
Ur
(30)
T
ρ ε2 ρ ε2 ρCp
µ ε µ ε λeff
" ρf ∂P µ − Ux − √ Ux Ux2 + Ur2 ∂x K K " µ ρf ∂P µUr − − 2 − Ur − √ Ur Ux2 + Ur2 ∂r εr K K Q
(31)
Yj
ρ
ρDjm,eff
Sj
−
−
the following general form: ∂φ ∂φ ∂ ∂φ 1 ∂ ∂φ ˆ + ρU ˆ r = + r + S, ρU ˆ x ∂x ∂r ∂x ∂x r ∂r ∂r
(32)
where φ represents the variable of interest. ρˆ and are the coefficients of the convection term and the diffusion term, respectively, while Sˆ denotes the source term. Specific values of these factors are summarized in Table 3 for several equations. Although there are a variety of discretization schemes available, the finite volume method is adopted in the present model with the staggered grid system. In the staggered grid system, two types of grid arrangements are provided: the velocity grids to store the velocity components and the normal grids for the other scalars such as pressure, temperature and concentrations. The velocity grids are shifted in position from the normal grids as illustrated in Fig. 6 to stably couple the velocity and pressure fields [39]. Integrating over each control volume for the normal grids, painted grey in Fig. 6, eqn (32) can be discretized into the following form: {(ρU ˆ x φ)e − (ρU ˆ x φ)w }rm r + {(r ρU ˆ r φ)n − (r ρU ˆ r φ)s }x ∂φ ∂φ ∂φ ∂φ rm r + x + Sˆ · rm rx − r − r = ∂x e ∂x w ∂r n ∂r s (33)
100 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 6: Staggered grid for the Finite Volume Method.
in which the subscripts e, w, n and s indicate the positions of four faces of the control volume under consideration, and rm denotes the arithmetic mean of rn and rs . Note that the control volume for velocity components is different from the counterpart for a scalar because the staggered grids are employed. In order to interpolate the fluxes of convection and diffusion at the interfaces expressed by e, w, n and s, the Power-Law scheme suggested by Patankar [39] is adopted here. As a result, the fluxes on the interfaces can be represented by the values on the grid points as follows: ∂φ rm r = aE (φP − φE ), (34) ρU ˆ xφ − ∂x e where aE is a coefficient determined by the Power-Law scheme. This is an example for the interface e, and similar expression can be adopted on the other interfaces. Consequently, eqn (33) can be transformed into the following algebraic equation: aP φP = aE φE + aW φW + aN φN + aS φS + b,
(35)
aP = aE + aW + aN + aS ,
(36)
where
b = Sˆ · rm rx.
(37)
The above discretized equations for velocity, temperature and concentration have to be solved simultaneously since gas properties are dependent on temperature and concentration of each gas component. To solve for velocity, the pressure field must be determined because the pressure gradient is included in the momentum equations. In order to solve both the velocity and pressure fields concurrently,
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
101
the SIMPLE algorithm put forward by Patankar et al. [39] is adopted in this model. Other details of discretization may be found in [39]. 3.6 Equations for electric potential and electric circuit Here is described the method to calculate the electric potential fields to be generated in electrodes and accompanying flow of electric current. The mathematical description in this section is given directly in discretized form for the reader’s convenience. In the present model, it is assumed that ionic current flows only radially across the electrolyte but electric current through electrode layers only in the circumferential (θ) direction as shown in Fig. 4 based on the fact that the electric resistivities of the electrodes are much smaller than the ionic resistivity of the electrolyte. In addition, the interconnect is treated to act ideally so that the potential difference between its position attaching the anode, θ = 0◦ , and its position attaching the cathode, θ = 180◦ , is taken to be equal to the cell terminal voltage. Figure 7 illustrates the grid system adopted in the calculation of the electric potential field in the cell tube and accompanying electric current. According to Kirchhoff’s law, the following discretized equations can be derived for both of the two electrodes: (iu − id )ha − iPP · re θ = 0,
(38)
(iu − id )hc + iPP · re θ = 0,
(39)
where iPP is the current density given by eqn (15) along a particular line connecting the grid points P and P located across the electrolyte as illustrated in Fig. 7. iu , id , iu and id are the values of current density to occur respectively along the four lines connecting the two grid points separated in the circumferential direction, U and P and P and D in the anode layer and U and P and P and D in the cathode layer. re is the radius of the mid surface of the cylindrical electrolyte shell layer.
Figure 7: Grid for the equivalent electrical circuit.
102 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells According to Ohm’s law, the electric current in the electrodes can be related to the difference in the electric potential between the related grid points: iu h a =
ha (VU − VP ), Ra ra δθu
iu hc =
hc (VU − VP ), Rc rc δθu
id ha =
ha (VP − VD ), Ra ra δθd
id hc =
hc (VP − VD ), Rc rc δθd
(40) (41)
where Ra and Rc are the electric resistivities of the anode and cathode, respectively. They are estimated by the empirical formula suggested by Bessette et al. [19] in this model. Rewriting eqn (15) with E˜ defined by the following equation: E˜ = EH2 /O2 − (ηH2 + ηO2 ) = ECO/O2 − (ηCO + ηO2 ),
(42)
the electric current across the electrolyte iPP can be represented by the potential difference and E˜ as follows: iPP re θ =
re θ ˜ {EPP − (VP − VP )}. Re he
(43)
Hence eqns (40) through (43) can be rewritten into the following algebraic equations: aP VP = aU VU + aD VD + aPP VP − b,
(44)
aP VP = aU VU + aD VD + aPP VP + b,
(45)
where aU =
ha , Ra ra δθu
aD =
ha , Ra ra δθd
aPP =
aU =
re θ , Re h e
b=
hc , Rc rc δθu re θ ˜ E, Re h e
aD =
hc , Rc rc δθd
(46)
(47)
aP = aU + aD + aPP ,
(48)
aP = aU + aD + aPP ,
(49)
eqns (44) and (45) can be solved numerically with a scheme similar to the one to solve momentum, heat and mass transfer equations described in the Section 3.5. 3.7 Mass production or consumption rate of each chemical species through electrochemical and reforming reactions The mass production rate of each chemical species by the electrochemical reactions is directly related to the electric current density caused by each of the electrochemical reactions, eqns (6) and (7), and its value, s˙j , is tabulated in Table 4. For example, the mass consumption rate of hydrogen, s˙ H2 , is equal to the product of the molecular
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
103
Table 4: Mass production or consumption rate of each species by the reactions (6) and (7). s˙ H2
Eqn (6) (7)
−
iH2 /O2 MH2 2F 0
s˙H2 O
s˙CO
s˙CO2
iH2 /O2 MH2 O 2F
0
0
0
−
iCO/O2 MCO 2F
iCO/O2 MCO2 2F
s˙O2 iH2 /O2 MO2 4F iH /O − 2 2 MO2 4F
−
Table 5: Mass production or consumption rate of each species by the reactions (1) and (2). Eqn
SH2
SH2 O
SCO
SCO2
SCH4
(1) (2)
3Rst MH2 Rsh MH2
−Rst MH2 O −Rsh MH2 O
Rst MCO −Rsh MCO
0 Rsh MCO2
−Rst MCH4 0
iH
/O
2 2 weight MH2 and the molar consumption rate of hydrogen 2F , where the Faraday constant F designates the electric charge of one mole of electrons. It must be noted here that two moles of electrons participate into the electrochemical reaction of one mole of hydrogen as seen in Fig. 5. These species mass production rates have nonuniform distributions in the circumferential direction because the current density is nonuniform in that direction. In the present quasi-two-dimensional model, therefore, they are peripherally averaged before being introduced into axisymmetric two dimensional mass transfer equations for the concentration fields. The production or consumption rate of each chemical species by the reforming and shift reactions is also calculated as shown in Table 5. The value of mass production or consumption rate for each chemical species is introduced into the species mass transfer equation as a part of its source term.
3.8 Model for thermodynamic heat generation rates The thermodynamic heat generation rates related to the electrochemical reactions are equal to the generation rate of the ineffective part of the input energy, which cannot be converted into electricity, and are calculated as follows: (−HH2 /O2 ) (50) q˙ H2 /O2 = − E˜ iH2 /O2 , 2F (−HCO/O2 ) q˙ CO/O2 = (51) − E˜ iCO/O2 . 2F These heat generation rates are included in the calculations of the energy equation as a part of its source term. The thermodynamic heat generation rate by the reforming
104 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells reactions, are calculated based on the reaction rates discussed in the Sections 3.3 and 3.7, as follows: Qst = −Hst Rst ,
(52)
Qsh = −Hsh Rsh ,
(53)
where Hst and Hsh are the enthalpy change accompanied with each reaction. 3.9 Ohmic heat generation With the current density and electric potential fields obtained in Section 3.6, ohmic heat generation rates in the electrodes and electrolyte are calculated as follows: QP =
iu2 δθu + id2 δθd Ra , δθu + δθd
QP =
2 QPP = iPP Re .
iu2 δθu + id2 δθd Rc , δθu + δθd
(54) (55)
These heat generation rates are nonuniform in the θ-direction. In the present quasitwo-dimensional method, they are peripherally averaged before they are introduced into the source term of the axisymmetric two-dimensional energy equation for the thermal field [15, 16]. Averaged results for the heat generation rates read as follows: π π qP θ θ=0 qP θ Qa = , Qc = θ=0 , (56) π π π qPP θ . (57) Qe = θ=0 π 3.10 Radiation model Now modeling of radiation heat transfer will be discussed. In the present model, the radiation heat transfer between the inner surface of the cell tube and the outer surface of the feed tube is considered. In the case of the IIR-T-SOFC, this plays an important role in transferring the heat generated by the electrochemical reactions at the tubular cell to the feed tube, and therefore, to the reaction site of endothermic fuel reforming. In the case of a tubular SOFC, the cell tube is slender in geometry. For example, in the case of a tubular IIR-T-SOFC to be studied in this chapter, the fuel flow passage is an annular space between two cylindrical surfaces facing to each other, i.e. anode surface and fuel feed tube outer surface. The width of the annular space is 2.4 mm. This is quite small compared to the cell tube length, 500 mm. This slenderness of the tubular cell has important implications for thermal radiation. The first of the implications to note here is that the optical length of the gas media flowing through the annular space is small. Emittance of the gas layer is given as the product of the optical length and absorption coefficient of gas which is an increasing function of the partial pressure of each chemical species participating
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
105
in radiation. So absorption into or emission from gaseous media can be neglected or the annular space can be treated transparent to radiation so long as the operation pressure is not very high. Description of the modeling of radiation heat transfer will begin with an explanation about the computation method of radiation heat transfer for general use. Certainly, the first feature of thermal radiation in a tubular fuel cell just noted above is taken into account. For more details of this part of discussion, refer to the reference [40]. Now consideration is given to an enclosure covered by the inner surface of the anode and the outer surface of the fuel feed tube and this enclosure is considered to consist of N diffusely emitting and diffusely reflecting gray surfaces. The surfaces are each isothermal. Surface j has temperature Tj and emittance εj . The net rate of heat loss flux qi from a surface i is equal to the difference between the emitted radiation and absorbed portion of the incident radiation. Therefore, it is given as: qi = εi σTi4 − εi Ii , (58) where Ii is the radiation incident on surface i per unit time and unit area and absorptance of the surface i is replaced by the emittance εi taking into account Kirchhoff’s law of radiation. Here is introduced the radiosity Bj of a surface j. The radiosity is the sum of the reflected and emitted radiant fluxes. So the following relationship holds: Bj = εj σTj4 + (1 − εj )Ij .
(59)
A fraction of Bj is directed to the surface i and contributes to the incident radiation on the surface i. Such contribution from the surface j to the incident radiation on surface i per unit area is now calculated as: Iji = Fji Bj Aj /Ai = Fij Bj ,
(60)
where Fji and Fij are the shape factors and the reciprocity rule Aj Fji = Ai Fij has been used. Now similar contributions come from every surface so that Ii is finally expressed as follows: Ii =
N j=1
Fij Bj =
N
Fij (εj σTj4 + (1 − εj )Ij ).
(61)
j=1
Iterative calculation is needed to determine the value of Ii or the value of qi with the determined value of Ii . However, this iterative procedure needs a large computational load if a large number is assigned to N . Actually the computation is excessively large for the present purpose of using the result for optimum design or thermal management of a tubular SOFC. Therefore, introduction of a certain degree of approximation into the modeling is desirable. The procedure followed is to reduce the number of surfaces considered in the computation. The approximation adopted in the present model is again based on the slenderness of the tubular cell. For just an example, attention is paid to a geometrical situation
106 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 8: Geometry of two facing surfaces. illustrated in Fig. 8. Two small elementary surfaces having 20 mm length, surfaces 1 and 2, are positioned in parallel to each other at a distance of 2.4 mm in this figure. An angle viewing one of them, say surface 1, from a point M on another surface 2 is about 153 degrees. The viewing angle of other parts, say surface 3, outside the surface 1 from the point M is only 27 degrees. So, the value of F21 is close to 1 and both of F23 and F32 are close to zero. Naming the surfaces situated on both sides of the surface 2 as surface 4, F24 = 0 and F22 = 0 hold. From the same reasoning as above both of F14 and F41 are close to zero too. So, based on the slender geometry of the tubular cell, radiation heat transfer between the two surfaces 1 and 2, directly facing each other, is considered. Then, it can be assumed that only two shape factors F21 and F12 take a non-zero value. Under this treatment, eqn (61) can be very much simplified. Certainly, by increasing the number of the surfaces, a better approximation is obtained but at the cost of computational time. Now assigning the suffix 1 to the anode inner surface and 2 to the fuel feed tube outer surface, F21 = 1, F12 = A2 /A1 and F11 = 1 − A2 /A1 hold under the adopted assumption. Thus eqn (61) can be approximated as: I1 =
2
F1j Bj = F11 B1 + F12 B2 ,
(62)
F2j Bj = F21 B1
(63)
B1 = ε1 σT14 + (1 − ε1 )I1 ,
(64)
B2 = ε2 σT24 + (1 − ε2 )I2 .
(65)
j=1
I2 =
2 j=1
and eqn (60) as:
Similarly, eqn (58) can finally be approximated as: q1 = ε1 σT14 − ε1 I1 ,
(66)
q2 = ε2 σT24 − ε2 I2 .
(67)
In the present model, these equations are locally used at each axial position and these radiant fluxes are included in the calculation of heat transfer as a part of the heat flux both at the inner surface of the anode and at the outer surface of the fuel feed tube.
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
107
Monochromatic radiation properties of ceramics are highly dependent on wavelength [41, 42]. Pore size of the electrodes and support materials is close to the wavelength of thermal radiation. Thinning the electrodes creates a similar situation that the electrode thickness comes closer to the wavelength too. This situation makes the problem complicated. Pore microstructure affects the wavelength dependency of the radiation properties of the fuel cell element materials and thin element layer can become semi-opaque. Therefore, sophisticated treatment of the radiation properties of the electrode and support materials is desirable. However, radiation properties of such materials have not been thoroughly studied yet. Therefore, for simplicity, the absorption coefficient of the solid materials of the fuel cell is assumed to be constant in the present model. This assumption however must be revisited when the micro structure and radiation properties of the fuel cell element materials have been thoroughly studied. Radiation heat transfer among the tubular cells in the module can be another factor affecting the performance of the fuel cell. This is very true in the case of the module having an “in-stack reformer”. However, in the case of the present IIRT-SOFC or a tubular SOFC using fuel reformed outside the module, every single tubular fuel cell located in the core of the module is surrounded by other tubular fuel cells similar in conditions including the temperature distribution on the outer surface of the cell tube. Again, the space between neighbouring tubular cells is small since tubular cells are stacked in a compact way in the module. So neglecting radiation heat transfer between the outer surfaces of neighbouring tubular cells is less serious in such cases of a tubular SOFC. However, it must be studied more seriously in the case of the module having an in-stack reformer and this heat transfer is a problem to be carefully studied in the modeling of cell stack modules. 3.11 Overall picture of the model In closing this section, an overall picture of the model is presented in Fig. 9. One of the main parts of this computation is the calculation of the temperature and concentration fields assuming their two-dimensionality. Based on the calculated temperature and species concentrations, the electromotive force and several resistances are calculated for the calculation of electric current and potential fields allowing their circumferential nonuniformity, which is another main part of this model. Based on the results of the electric fields, the peripheral average of the ohmic heat generation is calculated. Local current density is related to the mass production rate of participating chemical species. The heat generation rates and species mass production rates thus calculated are fed back to the calculation of the temperature and concentration. The gas properties and the reforming reaction rate are also interrelated with the temperature and concentration fields. Therefore, all of the above calculations are iterated simultaneously. As a result of iteration, all of the temperature, concentration and electric fields of the cell are obtained. Finally the cell performance, such as average current density, output power or energy conversion efficiency, is obtained. A more detailed description of this overall scheme can be found in the references [8, 15, 16].
108 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 9: Overall picture of the IIR-T-SOFC model.
4 Results and discussion In this section, some calculation results obtained by making use of the numerical model described in the preceding sections are discussed. In section 4.1, discussion is first given to some results of the model applied to a conventional hydrogenfuelled tubular SOFC and its validation is presented by comparing some results with published experimental data. How this model is powerful as a tool for optimum design and thermal management of a tubular SOFC is also demonstrated in this section. In sections 4.2 and 4.3, discussion will be given to some results obtained by applying the model to an IIR-T-SOFC. In section 4.2, the results for a “Base case” will be presented so as to illustrate the essence of the phenomena in a tubular cell accompanying the indirect internal fuel reforming. Then, methods to lower and/or to make more uniform the temperature of the cell will be discussed along with other results in section 4.3. 4.1 Results for a cathode-supported tubular SOFC without accompanying indirect internal reforming [16, 43, 44] In this type of tubular SOFC, as shown in Fig. 2, air is supplied inside the tubular cell through the air feed tube and fuel flows around the tubular cell in the axial direction. So the innermost layer of the cell is the cathode and outermost layer is the anode. Electrolyte material is assumed to be Yttrium-stabilized Zirconia (YSZ) and the fuel is pure hydrogen. So the parts of the present model concerning fuel reforming and electrochemical reaction of carbon monoxide are inactivated. In this case, heat absorption by the fuel reforming does not exist either and heat transfer from the cathode inner surface to the outer surface of the air feed tube is less important. For this reason, radiation heat transfer between the two surfaces is ignored in this
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
109
Table 6: (a) Inlet conditions. Inlet species and their weight concentrations Fuel side Air side
H2 H2 O O2 N2
Inlet temperature
Inlet pressures
870 ◦ C 870 ◦ C 600 ◦ C 600 ◦ C
1.013 × 105 Pa 1.013 × 105 Pa 1.013 × 105 Pa 1.013 × 105 Pa
89% 11% 21% 79%
Table 6: (b) Geometry of cathode supported cell. Components’
Thickness
Supporting tube Cathode Electrolyte Anode
1500 µm 1000 µm 50 µm 150 µm Diameter
Inner side of air-inducing tube Outer side of air-inducing tube Inner side of supporting tube Outer side of anode Outer diameter of fuel channel Length of cell unit
8.0 mm 9.0 mm 13.8 mm 19.2 mm 29.2 mmφ 500 mm
particular example. Inlet conditions of air and fuel flows are tabulated in Table 6(a). Geometry of a tubular cell is kept to be the one given in Table 6(b) unless otherwise stated. Fuel and air utilization factors are set to be 0.85 and 0.167 respectively. Illustration of local quantities shown in Figs 14–16 is for the case of an electric current density of 3500 A/m2 . Other details are found in reference [16]. Figure 10 illustrates the current-voltage (I-V) diagram of the studied tubular SOFC. Calculated results agree fairly well with the experiments performed by Hagiwara et al. [45]. For small current density conditions, simulated results are a little higher than the experiments. This over-prediction may be related to a simple treatment of activation overpotential. It is assumed in this particular computation that the activation polarization is proportional to current density and the value of the proportionality constant is adjusted at an optimum current density around 3000 A/m2 . However, at smaller current density, the cell temperature is lower, and a larger activation overpotential or a larger proportionality constant should have been adopted. In the examples to be discussed in the Section 4.2 and 4.3, more sophisticated treatment of activation overpotential is adopted as already discussed
110 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 10: Cell voltage-current density diagram.
Figure 11: Conversion efficiency and output power.
in Section 3.2. Except for this point, obtained results look reasonable and the present model is basically validated. Figure 11 illustrates the cell electricity generation efficiency and the power to be achieved with a single tubular cell. With an increase of current density, power to be obtained increases up to a certain value but efficiency decreases. This is the normal tendency and optimum current density is determined by a trade-off between the two quantities having opposite tendency. Figure 12 shows the cell terminal voltage for four cases of tubular SOFCs having different tube length. All the calculated results almost overlap. In this computation, the fuel utilization factor is kept constant. This means that both air and fuel are supplied at a rate proportional to the cell tube length. Larger air flow rates enhance the cooling of the cell but this is countered by larger ohmic heating at lower temperatures. Under the same electric current density, therefore, both the concentrations of fuel and oxygen decrease at a rate proportional to the tube length almost keeping similarity
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
111
Figure 12: Effect of cell length on output voltage at constant fuel utilization factor.
Figure 13: Effects of tube diameter on energy efficiency. in the temperature field among the three cases. This results in such a condition that both electrochemical reaction and heat generation proceed similarly or in a manner proportional to the cell tube length. Figure 13 shows the effects of the cell tube diameter. In the case of a cell tube having larger diameter, the length not only of electrolyte but also of electrodes is larger. Then larger ohmic loss occurs, reducing the terminal voltage, and ohmic heat generation also becomes larger because of the larger collection of electric current per unit length of interconnect. Therefore, a thinner tubular cell can have a higher performance. Figure 14 shows the axial distributions of the local EMF and current density. Both quantities show the same tendency to decrease in the downstream direction. Concentrations of hydrogen and oxygen in the first half of the cell are still high so that the EMF in that region is high too. Similarity between the current density distribution and the EMF distribution indicates that the axial electric current is minor compared to the peripheral one or that interconnect works well.
112 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 14: Distribution of EMF and current density.
Figure 15: Temperature distribution in a cell.
Figure 15 shows the temperature distribution in the tubular SOFC unit. As for the fuel flow temperature, it rises downstream of the inlet and approaches 1000 ◦ C, then keeps an almost uniform value in the middle part of the cell and slightly decreases toward the exit end. In the air feed tube, air is heated after it flows into the tube. A noticeable transverse gradient of air temperature is found to exist in the annular space over the whole length of the air feed tube. This gradient drives heat transfer from the cell structure, where heat generation occurs, to the air flow in the annular space. This ensures effective cooling of the cell. Radiative heat transfer, ignored in the present computation, may flatten the streamwise temperature non-uniformity but is not expected to change the trend of the temperature distribution significantly. This is because the convective heat transfer considered in the present study is effective already to reduce the differences in surface temperature among various parts of the cell. So air acts as a coolant of the cell. One point related to the convective heat transfer should be noted here. In various numerical models proposed so far, a constant value for the Nusselt number is used in evaluating the local heat removal rate to the air flow. However, this is not a good assumption and actually the heat transfer coefficient is significantly nonuniform along the axial direction [46]. In relation to the discussion of the concentration polarization, distributions of hydrogen and oxygen concentrations are presented in Fig. 16. In the fuel passage, the concentration of hydrogen decreases downstream, especially steeply in the first part after the inlet. However, the radial non-uniformity of the hydrogen concentration is not significant
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
113
Figure 16: Hydrogen and oxygen concentrations. so that the related concentration polarization is judged to be minor. In contrast to this, radial non-uniformity of oxygen concentration is noticeable. This difference is attributed to the difference in the diffusivity, i.e. the diffusivity of hydrogen is much higher than that of oxygen. Therefore, concentration polarization induced by the nonuniform distribution of species concentration in the flow space is not negligible at the cathode side but it can be ignored on the anode side. 4.2 Results for the Base case with accompanying indirect internal reforming In the examples for which results will be discussed here, cell tube geometry is assumed as is shown in Fig. 5 to be of 500 mm length, 6.9 mm inner radius and 9.6 mm outer radius. An adiabatic cylindrical wall artificially introduced to confine air flow for computational convenience has 14.6 mm in radius. Other details of cell geometry are tabulated in Table 7. The inlet and outlet conditions of the fuel and air are summarized in Table 8 and computational conditions for the Base case are shown in Table 9. In the present study, fuel mean velocity at the inlet is set equal to such a value that the limiting value of the average current density is about 5000 A/m2 (e.g. 0.923 m/s when the inlet temperature is 800 ◦ C). In contrast, the air mean velocity at the inlet is set to be 2.0 m/s except for some special cases to be specified later. The fuel and air temperatures at the inlets are changed from one case to another as will be described in a later section but unless otherwise stated they are the values given in the table. The temperature at the closed end of the cell tube is set equal to the air inlet temperature. Catalyst distribution “U-20” means that the catalyst mass density, Wcat , is set at 2.0 × 106 g/m3 uniformly inside the feed tube. This is such a value that the supplied methane fuel can be fully reformed even when the electrical circuit is open. In this case, fuel reforming is thermally supported just by the heat transferred from hot air and fuel flows. The case number for the Base case 2-800U20 indicates that the inlet velocity of the air is 2 m/s, the inlet temperature of the fuel and air is 800 ◦ C, and the catalyst distribution is the pattern U-20. “Neuman” appearing in the table means that zero axial gradient is assumed at the outlet for the variable under concern as its boundary condition. As mentioned before, the cell terminal voltage is given at the start of the computation as a condition to calculate the electric current and potential fields in
114 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells Table 7: Size of fuel cell elements. Components’
Thickness
Supporting tube Anode Electrolyte Cathode
1500 µm 150 µm 50 µm 1000 µm Diameter
Inner side of feed tube Outer side of feed tube Inner side of supporting tube Outer side of cathode Outer diameter of fuel channel Length of cell unit
8.0 mm 9.0 mm 13.8 mm 19.2 mm 29.2 mm 500 mm
Table 8: Gas inlet and outlet conditions. Velocity
Temperature
Fuel inlet
Poiseuille flow
Constant
Air inlet
Plug flow
Constant
Outlet
Neuman
Neuman
Molar fraction [−]
Total pressure [Pa]
H2 0.200 0.500 H2 O CO 0.020 CO2 0.030 0.250 CH4 O2 0.209 N2 0.791 Neuman
110000
110000 Neuman
Table 9: Computational conditions of the Base case.
Base case 2-800U20
Velocity (Fuel inlet) [m/s]
Velocity (Air inlet) [m/s]
Temperature (Fuel inlet) [◦ C]
Temperature (Air inlet) [◦ C]
Catalyst distribution
0.923
2.0
800
800
U-20
order to identify the given external load of the cell. Unless otherwise stated, the results of the Base case are shown with particular emphasis on the condition in which the cell terminal voltage is set at 0.55 V and accordingly the average current density becomes 3926 A/m2 .
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
115
4.2.1 Thermal and concentration fields Figure 17 shows velocity vectors inside and outside the cell tube. Note that this figure is not to scale: the radial (r) direction is magnified ten times larger than the axial (x) direction. The fuel flow is accelerated inside the feed tube due to an increase in the total number of moles caused by the steam reforming. Fuel flows into the cell tube from the open end of feed tube and flows back to the tube outlet through annular fuel flow passage. Fuel flow inside the tube is almost in a stagnant condition at the bottom end. Temperature contours for the same case are shown in Fig. 18. Note that the darker tone corresponds to the higher local temperature. The temperature in and around the cell basically becomes higher downstream in relation to the air flow because of the heat generation accompanying the electrochemical process. However, the temperature is noticeably lower near the inlet of the fuel due to the endothermic effect of the steam reforming reaction. Here the x-direction distributions of the temperature inside the electrolyte and the feed tube are shown in Fig. 19. Conspicuous non-uniformity of temperature exists as seen in the figure. This is not the case of Siemens-Westinghouse type hydrogenfuelled tubular fuel cell [16] and must be avoided because it can lead to thermal crack failures of the cell. Furthermore, the maximum temperature of the electrolyte
Figure 17: Velocity vectors around the cell for an average current density of 3926 A/m2 in the Base case (2-800U20).
Figure 18: Temperature field in and around the cell for an average current density of 3926 A/m2 (2-800U20).
116 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 19: Local temperature of the electrolyte and the feed tube for an average current density of 3926 A/m2 (2-800U20) and that in a similar case but not considering the effect of radiation. reaches about 1050 ◦ C, which is the hot spot temperature to be avoided from the material view point. By the way, the broken lines in Fig. 19 show the result in which the effect of radiation described in section 3.4 is excluded. From this result, it is confirmed that the radiation contributes noticeably to the heat transfer between the cell tube and the feed tube in this case with accompanying indirect internal fuel reforming. Figure 20 shows mole fraction contours of hydrogen, steam, CO, CO2 , methane and O2 , respectively. Note that the grey tone levels differ among each chemical species. Inside the feed tube, hydrogen and CO are produced while steam and methane are consumed by the steam reforming. Methane is rapidly reformed near the feed tube inlet because the amount of the catalyst is excessive for the operating condition of the cell under study. Meanwhile, outside the feed tube, hydrogen and CO are consumed while steam and CO2 are produced mainly by the electrochemical reactions. The reason for the considerable change of the mole fraction occurring at the bottom of the cell is that the fuel flow stagnates while the electrochemical reactions take place there. As for the air side, oxygen is consumed by the electrochemical reaction. However, variation of its mole fraction is not so large because the flow rate of air is adjusted so as to effectively remove the generated heat and is normally in excess of that required to complete the electrochemical reactions. In other words, the oxygen utilization factor is set normally as low as 0.2 or 0.3. The molar flow rates of each chemical species inside and outside the feed tube are shown in Figs 21(a) and (b), respectively. Characteristics of the electrochemical and reforming reaction described above can be confirmed in these figures. 4.2.2 Electric potential and current fields Distribution of electromotive force (EMF) is shown in Fig. 21. Although two different values of EMF, EH2 /O2 and ECO/O2 , are calculated in this study as described
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
117
Figure 20: Mole fraction distributions of each chemical species for an average current density of 3926 A/m2 (2-800U20).
in section 3.6, these two differ very slightly from each other by the reason that the shift reaction is very close to equilibrium everywhere in the cell. Hence only EH2 /O2 is plotted here as the EMF. As seen in this figure, the EMF strongly depends on the mole fraction of hydrogen at the anode surface: the EMF has a peak near the outlet of the feed tube and becomes lower toward the cell tube outlet. However, it becomes a little higher near the cell tube outlet again due to the larger change of Gibb’s free energy, G, at lower temperature.
118 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 21: Molar flow rate of each chemical species of fuel for an average current density of 3926 A/m2 (2-800U20).
Figure 22: Electromotive force and current density distributions for an average current density of 3926 A/m2 (2-800U20). Distribution of current density is also shown in Fig. 22. Note that the distribution plotted in this figure is the peripheral average of local current density at each axial position. This figure indicates that the distribution of current density is not similar in shape to that of EMF. This is because the current density is also related to the activation overpotential and the ohmic loss which depend strongly on the temperature. As shown in Fig. 23, both the activation and ohmic overpotentials are significantly reduced around x = 0.4, where the cell temperature takes a peak value (see Figs 18 and 19). That is to say, the current density distribution depends on the thermal field as well as, or more than, on the concentration field. At the same time, it is also true that the temperature tends to become higher where the large current is generated, so that a kind of enhancement due to a mutually assisting interaction exists between the cell temperature and the electric current. Incidentally, the ohmic loss in the anode and cathode is closely related to the distribution of the current density in the θ-direction, which is essentially non-uniform. Details can be found in the references [13, 14].
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
119
Figure 23: Activation overpotential and ohmic loss in the electrolyte for an average current density of 3926 A/m2 (2-800U20).
Figure 24: Temperature of the electrolyte for several different average current densities (2-800U20). 4.2.3 Power generation characteristics Before moving into the discussion on the power generation characteristics of the fuel cell, results of the electrolyte temperature for several cases of different average current densities are given here. Figure 24(a) shows the x-direction distribution of electrolyte temperature for the cases of average current density 2191, 3081 and 3926 A/m2 . All the three distributions have similar features as those described in section 4.1.1, but temperature becomes higher on the whole as the average current density becomes larger. The relation between the average current density and the maximum and average temperatures of the electrolyte is shown in Fig. 24(b). The power generation characteristics of the cell are significantly affected by the cell temperature. Figure 25 shows the cell-averaged EMF, activation overpotential and ohmic loss in the electrolyte for various values of average current density. The cell terminal voltage, which is practically given as the external condition to start the calculation in this study, is also plotted here. From this figure, the following
120 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 25: Average EMF and overpotentials vs. average current density (2-800U20).
Figure 26: Output power and energy conversion efficiency vs. average current density (2-800U20). things are confirmed. First, the cell-averaged EMF goes down at a nearly constant rate as the average current density increases. This is largely because the local concentrations of hydrogen and CO decrease due to their larger consumption rates. The activation overpotential does not increase proportionally to the average current density countered by the rise in temperature as mentioned above. The ohmic loss in the electrolyte also does not increase for the same reason. However, the ohmic loss in the anode and cathode, which is basically larger than that in the electrolyte because the electric current flows long distances there in the θ-direction as mentioned in section 3.7, increases nearly in proportion to the average current density. From these results, the output power and energy conversion efficiency of the cell are also obtained as shown in Fig. 26. Here the efficiency is calculated based on the lower heating value (LHV) of the fuel consumed in the cell. Judging from
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
121
Table 10: Computational conditions for the additional cases.
2-750U20 4-800U20 2-800U02 2-800L02
Velocity (Fuel inlet) [m/s]
Velocity (Air inlet) [m/s]
Temperature (Fuel inlet) [◦ C]
Temperature (Air inlet) [◦ C]
Catalyst distribution
0.880 0.923 0.923 0.923
2.0 4.0 2.0 2.0
750 800 800 800
750 800 800 800
U-20 U-20 U-02 L-02
these calculated results, fairly high performance seems to be achieved under the conditions for the Base case. 4.3 Strategies for the ideal thermal field As described in section 4.1.1, the thermal field in the cell obtained for the Base case is undesirable in a sense that the thermal field is seriously non-uniform and the maximum temperature is rather high. Hence the strategies to flatten and/or lower the distribution of cell temperature are discussed here. Decreasing the inlet temperatures of the gases is a primary method to lower the cell temperature. Increasing the air flow rate also seems to be effective when the cell temperature is higher than the inlet temperature of the air. To achieve a nearuniform thermal field, controlling the density distribution of catalyst inside the feed tube should be useful. In order to examine those effects, calculations for the four cases summarized in Table 10 have been conducted. In Case 2–750U20, the inlet temperatures of the gases are decreased down to 750 ◦ C and accordingly the fuel inlet velocity is reduced to 0.880 m/s to keep its molar flow rate at the same value as the Base case. In Case 4-800U20, the air flow rate is doubled from the Base case. In Case 2-800U02 and 2-800L02, the density distribution of catalyst is changed to “U-02” and “L-02”, which are described in Fig. 27. The amounts of the catalyst in U-02 and L-02 are optimised for the conditions of average current density about 4000 A/m2 . That is, fuel is completely reformed just near the end of the feed tube under such conditions. The calculation results for the above four cases are discussed below in sequence. 4.3.1 Effect of gas inlet temperature The temperature contours obtained at the average current density 4043 A/m2 in Case 2-750U20 are shown in Fig. 28, and the electrolyte temperature distribution in the x-direction is shown in Fig. 29. Owing to the lower gas inlet temperatures, the cell temperature decreases on the whole. However, the maximum temperature is not so reduced, and thus the non-uniformity of the temperature becomes more serious. This is because the activation overpotential becomes drastically larger where the cell temperature drops below 850 ◦ C and accordingly the current density distribution
122 Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
Figure 27: Mass density distribution of the catalyst inside the feed tube.
Figure 28: Temperature field in and around the cell for an average current density of 4043 A/m2 (2-750U20).
Figure 29: Effect of the gas inlet temperature on the electrolyte temperature distribution. becomes more noticeably non-uniform as shown in Fig. 30. Additionally, electricity conversion efficiency decreases by more than 5% compared to the Base case (see Table 11) due to the increase in activation overpotential caused by the decrease in temperature.
Transport Phenomena in Fuel Cells
123
Figure 30: Effect of the gas inlet temperature on the local current density distribution. Table 11: Calculation results for the Base case and the additional cases. Case & Average current density [A/m 2 ]
Terminal voltage [V]
Output power [W]
Efficiency (LHV) [%]
Maximum temperature (electrolyte) [◦ C]
Average temperature (electrolyte) [◦ C]
2-80-U20: 3926 2-750U20: 4043 4-800U20: 3920 2-800U02: 3911 2-800L02: 4051
0.55 0.48 0.50 0.54 0.52
58.2 52.3 52.8 56.9 56.8
41.6 36.3 37.8 41.0 39.5
1047.0 1023.3 968.0 995.4 974.2
957.6 913.2 909.5 942.6 939.2
4.3.2 Effect of air flow rate The temperature contours obtained for the average current density 3920 A/m2 in Case 4-800U20 are shown in Fig. 31, and the electrolyte temperature distribution in the x-direction is shown in Fig. 32. Owing to the increased flow rate of air, the coolant, the cell temperature, especially the maximum, is fairly reduced in comparison with the Base case, and accordingly the temperature gradient is also reduced. Therefore, to increase the air flow rate is quite effective for flattening the cell temperature distribution, though often it should be adjusted so as to fulfil the requirements to optimiz