This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
C). c0 , and (3CpCa) C0 , with type I error a(C0) = a , the chance of incorrectly judging an incapable process as a capable one. The calculations of p-value (rejection probability), critical value, and power of the test are provided below. Suppose the observed value of the statistic Cj = w , we then can calculate those values as follows (here 6 = 3Vn C): p - value = P{(5 7 > w | Ci < C) ^P\tn_i{8)>^
1.3 Estimating and testing Cp based on multiple samples 1.3.1
Estimation
of CP and its
properties
For cases where data are collected in the form multiple samples, Kirmani et al. (1991) consider m samples each of size n and suggest the following estimator of Cp (where af,- is the i-th sample mean, and st is the i-th sample standard deviation): ^
_
(USL-LSL)dp
16
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
Here
m(n - 1) - 1 £m(n-i)-i m(n — 1) sp
dp =
e
m(n-l)-l
= E
Xm(n-1)-1
yjm(n -1) - 1 m(n -1)
-1r m
s2 =
and
p
ra(n — 1)'
m n
(
' m(n — 1) — 1) ~ m
- 1 ) i=l
' " i=l
Recall that under the normality assumption the statistic sp / a is distributed as Xm(n-i)-i /[m(n - 1) - 1] 1/2 . Therefore, the estimator C„ is distributed as: yjm(n
- 1) - 1 e r a ( n _i)_i
Cn V^m(n-l)
Note that for m = 1 , the above estimator reduces to the ordinary estimator (UMVUE) of Cp . The estimator Cp is unbiased, and p.d.f., g(y) say, for y > 0 , can be obtained using the p.d.f. of the \2 distribution and denoting h = [m(n — 1) — 1] e^l(n_1)_1 C2V , (which can be expressed as a function of Cp ) becomes: 2flm(n-l)/2 j/-M«-i)+i] exp
2
T[m(n — 1J/2J
1_ 2
[y )
More recently, Pearn and Yang (2003) investigated some statistical properties of Cp and showed that Cp is asymptotically efficient and moreover (mnfl2(Cp — Cp) converges to N(0,Cl /2) in distribution. The variance of Cp can be calculated following (Kirmani et al. (1991)) as:
The CP Index
17
Var(C'r) = E\(C",?} - (E(C'r)f
f1}
UJ — Cp m(n - 1) - 1
2
— c„ m(n-1)-2J e -»(»-D-i Recall t h a t e m ( n _ 1 )_ 2 *s argument m(n — 1) / 2 .
a
cons
_
i _
M
2
I
,
°" 1 e2 (n-l)-2
-1
t a n t involving T functions in the
In addition to being unbiased, it can be shown t h a t Cp is consistent for Cp . For multiple samples with variable sample sizes, we can easily show t h a t the generalized estimator Cp obtained from m samples each of size n^, i = 1, • • •, m , is given by:
i/... x C, n„ — = b< P EK-l)
USL-LSL
, , where
6sv
y ^ (ni — i)si s„ = - ^ P m
1
, and
E^- )
m
r
2
l2^("i-i)
i=l / m
\
1=1
4
H
2
8= 1
»=i
This generalized estimator is unbiased.
1.3.2
Lower
confidence
bound
on
CP
Since the estimator Cp is subject to a sampling error, it is desirable to construct a confidence interval to provide a range which contains the true Cp with a desired high probability. For cases where multiple samples are available due to sampling at various times, Kirmani et al. (1991) used the lower confidence
18
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
bound corresponding to the prescribed minimum value of the capability (the precision requirement). A process is considered to be capable, if the precision requirement is greater than the lower confidence bound. The 100(1 — a) percent lower confidence bound can be expressed as:
CI = C M l
X-m(n—1),1—a
[m(n-l)-l]e2, L
1.3.3 Hypothesis
v
testing
'
n
,
' m(n—1)—1
with CP
To test whether the process meets the precision requirement, we shall consider the following testing hypothesis procedure with H0: Cp < C (the process is incapable), versus the alternative H^ Cp > C (the process is capable). Thus, we may consider the test of the form 4>'(x) = 1 if Cp > c0 , and
cr'
0
1 M
c2
= a.
Hence, given the value of precision requirement C , the critical value CQ of the a -level significance can be obtained by solving the equation 2£m(n-l)/2
Jo0_ '
2
m(n-\)/2 „
r
r
/
,y-[m(n-i)+i]exp - \
< ~
m(n-l)/2
dy = a,
19
The CP Index
where k = [m(n - 1) - 1] s^i^iyi Cp , or alternatively using Kirmani et al. (1991), to arrive at: ([mtn-l)-!]^.!).! ch=CA X-m(n—1),1—<*
Under the same conditions, the p-value (the risk of wrongly rejecting the null hypothesis H0: Cp < C ) corresponding to Cp , a specific value obtained via the sample data, denoted by cp is:
p(c; >c*p\cp = c) 2fcrn(n-l)/2
-
1
y-(m(n-l)+\]
0
" /
= P
9^-^/2
r[m(Vi-i;/2]
i"1^-1)-1]^™-!)-!C
2
dy
e x p
ly 2 1
= P
-^•m(n-l)
2 < _ •^m(n-l) — ~* Cp
Pearn and Yang (2003) developed an efficient test for Cp for the cases with multiple samples, and have shown that the proposed test is indeed the UMP test. The power of the UMP test (i.e. probability of correctly rejecting the null hypothesis Cp < C when Cp > C is true), can be computed for the alternative hypothesis, Hx: Cp = C\ > C. The power of the test, denoted as 7r(Cp) is obtained by calculating TT(Cp) = P(Cp>C*\ = p Xm(„-i) ^
Cp=C1)
S
I ° P — °i
20
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
1.4 Estimating and testing Cp based on (X, R) control chart samples For applications where the data are obtained in the form of a single sample, this problem has been discussed in an earlier work of Kane (1986). Chou et al. (1990) provide tables for lower confidence limit on Cp when a estimated by the sample standard deviation S. In this case, Pearn et al. (1998) introduced an unbiased estimator of Cp and showed that the unbiased estimator is also UMVUE. These authors also proposed an efficient test for Cp based on a single sample and showed that the test is a UMP (uniformly most powerful) test. Kirmani et al. (1991) considered the estimation of a and the precision index Cp using the data in the form of multiple samples. When a estimated by the sample range a\, Li et al. (1990) provide tables for the lower confidence limit on Cp . Pearn and Yang (2003) propose an unbiased estimator of Cp for multiple samples when a is estimated by pooled sample variance, and have shown that the unbiased estimator is the UMVUE of Cp , which is asymptotically efficient. Pearn and Yang (2003) also developed an efficient test for Cp when multiple samples are used and showed that the proposed test is indeed an UMP test. For applications where a routine-based data collection plans are implemented, a common practice for process control is to estimate the process precision by analyzing the past "in control" data. Consider m preliminary multiple samples (subgroups), each of size n taken from the control chart samples. To estimate a we usually use either the sample standard deviation or the sample range. The control chart can be used as a monitoring device or a logbook to show the effect of changes in the process performance. Observe that a process may be in control but not necessarily operating at an acceptance level. Thus, management intervention will be required either to improve the process capability, or to change the manufacturing requirements ensuring that the products
21
The CP Index
meet at least the minimum acceptable level. We emphasize again that the process must be stable in order to produce a reliable estimate of process capability. If the process is out of control in the early stages of process capability analysis, it will be undesirable and unreliable to estimate process capability. The priority action is to determine and eliminate the assignable causes in order to bring the process into an in-control state.
1.4.1 Estimation
of Cp based on (X, R)
samples
Let m samples each of size n, from a ( X , R) control chart be available, and Rin be the range of a sample of size n (i = 1, •••,m ) and Rm^n be the average range in m samples of each size n. Then the mean and variance of the relative standardized range Rm^ / a are given by Ei^/a) T/
/H
= E(R1
Var(Rm>n a) = '
Var R
( l,n)
(1.2) 4
— = — , ma m
(1.3)
where d^ and d3 are functions of n, widely tabulated in quality control books and literature based on the assumption of normality and independence (originally presented in Pearson's Table A (1932)). Thus, the estimated process capability precision using the range method can be expressed as: f, ° ^ =
USL - LSL „ 6aR .where g
J i
Rmn = — .
If m = 1, the c.d.f. of the range from a standard normal distribution is
22
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
[$(z + t) - #(*)]
-oo
where $(•) and !>(•) are the c.d.f. and the p.d.f. of the standard normal distribution JV(0,1). Using the first two moments of the average range, Patnaik (1950), over 50 years ago, has shown that Rm,n I o is distributed approximately as c\v / Vw , where xl is the chi-square distribution with v degree of freedom and c and v are constants which are functions of the first two moments of the sample average range. Specifically EiR^Ja) = ^^n^1)/^),
and
Var(Rmn/a)
= — v
[r(l±i)/r(|,
(1-4)
(1.5)
From the coefficients of the mean and variance of average range, and the values of d^ and d3 , the values of the mean (expected value) and variance in (1.2) and (1.3) are available. Equating (1.4) to (1.2) and (1.5) to (1.3), we can easily obtain the values of c and v, as unique solutions to the system of equations above. In the early days of control chart usage (the pre-computer era), the range method of estimating a was widely employed to simplify the arithmetic calculations associated with control chart operations. With the availability of modern computer software and efficient hand-held calculators for control chart operations, numerical calculations are not an issue any more, and other methods could be used. If the sample size is relatively small n < 8, the range method results in almost as good an estimator of
23
The CP Index
variance a2 as does the usual sample variance s2, which possesses attractive statistical properties. The relative efficiency (R.E.) of the range method to s2 is shown in Table 1.1 for various sample sizes (Montgomery (2001)). For moderate and large values of n, say n > 10, the range method rapidly loses its efficiency, since it ignores all the information presented in the sample between the largest and the smallest values. Nevertheless we emphasize that for the small sample sizes, which are often employed in various control charts (n = 4, 5, or 6), it is quite satisfactory (under approximate normality). Table 1.1. The relative efficiency of the range method to the sample variance S2 n
2
R.E.
1.000
1.4.2 Hypothesis
3 0.992
4
5
6
10
0.975
0.955
0.930
0.850
testing for Cp based on (X, R)
samples
When estimating the process capability precision by means of the range method from the (X, R) control chart samples, the critical value C0^ can be obtained by finding an appropriate value satisfying the following equation: P(Cm
> Cm ' _d_
~ P
\Cp=C)
= a
> C ,0(R) = P
*hn,n
..
Ofl
d
CQ{R)
3(7
xl<^c cC,0(R)
Note that d = (USL — LSL)/2 is unrelated to d^ and dP . In fact, the critical value Co(fl) f° r the range (R) method can be expressed as
24
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices ~fva\
Co(ij) = —/—^— C ) "V Xi/,a where x?,a i s the lower a -th percentile of the chi-square distribution with v degree of freedom. Under the same conditions, the p-value corresponding to c ,m , a specific value obtained from the sample data, can be calculated as: p -value = P(Cp{R) > cp{R) \Cp = C)
= P
•Km,n ~ _
P(R)
"•
xl <
3a
^-c
ccp(R)
= G
-Jva\
C
cc'p(R)
where G(-) is the c.d.f. of the chi-square distribution with v degree of freedom. When multiple samples taken from the ( X , R) control chart at various times are available, using Patnaik's (approximate) distribution of the average range, the 100 (1 — a) % lower confidence bound CL^ can be constructed (see e.g. Li et al. (1990) and Pearn et al. (2004). The lower confidence bound satisfies P(CP > CL{R)) = 1 - a = P
aR
>
CL[R) C.p(R))
= P
Jva\CL{R) \ Xv —
cC,p(R)
Consequently, we have that:
Rm,n >
cp{R)
)
The CP
^^CL(R)
_
A
2
25
Index
, or the ratio 2m.
Av,a
- _ £ _ HJ~ ,
-
cCp{R)
r-i
Cm
\j Av,a
^
Observe that the ratio values of C^R) / CP(R) depends on v, c, d^, and a . The values of v, c, d? are determined from m and n. We shall call this ratio CL(R) /Cp(i?) a lower confidence factor.
1.5
Estimating and testing Cp based on (X, S) control chart samples
1.5.1 Estimation
of Cp based on (X, S)
samples
If m samples each of size n from a ( X , S) control chart are available, Kirmani et al. (1991) suggests measuring the process precision index Cp , by its natural estimator Cp defined, analogously to the case m = 1, as follows: -
USL-LSL
.
6<75
1
F
£„_! 1/2
where i=l
and the correction factor
F
, _
—
r[n/2]
n-ir[(n-l)/2]
Here Xt and 5j represent the sample mean and the sample standard deviation of the i-th sample, and the correction en^ is usually denoted in the general quality control literature by c4 . Kirmani et al. (1991) showed that under the normality assumption, the statistic S is approximately distributed according to the normal distribution. Hence with a reasonable approximation:
26
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
S - VnTTe,n - l
•N(O,I)
(n -1)(1 - el_x) m
This approximation is particularly appropriate in the situations where adequately tight control of the process variability is desirable so that at least moderately large subgroups (n > 10) are available. In this case, the S-chart is shown to be preferred over the R-chart. We note that the expressions for the distribution of Cp(s) presented in Kirmani et al. (1991), Kocherlakota (1992), and Kotz and Lovelace (1998) ought to be adjusted. In fact, these authors address the distribution of as to be:
&s ~ N
CT
2
>
Consequently,
aP(S)
1+ N
P2
1 1
~
£
n-l
C„.
The estimator Cp(s) i s biased. Its p.d.f., g(x) say, can be expressed as follows: q(x) = -===- x
2
exp
K/x-lf 2k2
for x > 0
g(x) is a function of the constant value Cp and a variant the inverse chi-square p.d.f.. Here
The CP Index
?i
melA
and e,B
27
T(n/2) -
1 _
V n - l r[(n-l)/2]
as above.
For the cases when m > 1 multiple samples of size n are available in view of sampling from the ( X , S) control charts at various time points. Kirmani et al. (1991) have also constructed the 100 (1 — a) % lower confidence bound C^s) to be e
CL{s) - CP(S) l + *„
n-l
me„_!
where as above za is the upper a quantile of the standard normal distribution.
1.5.2 Hypotheses
testing for Cp based on (X, S)
samples
If a ( X , S) control chart is available, then the critical value Co(s) can be obtained by determining the appropriate value satisfying the equation P(CP{S) > CQ{S) \Cp = C) = a
1
_ p —i==-x Cp
exp
(Cp/x-lf 2k2
dx
In fact, the critical value C^s) c a n D e found and expressed as follows, with za representing the lower 100a % percentage point of the standard normal distribution, N( 0,1):
28
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
c
Co(5) =
msn_i
where
e
— n-l —
r>/2]
n-lT[(n-l)/2]
Under the same conditions, the p-value corresponding to S(5) ' a s P ec ifi° value calculated from the sample data, can be expressed as: p-value = P(Cp(s) = 1-
> cp{s) | Cp = C)
r cp(s) C„ _„z / ,-- x exp F J 0 V27Tfc
{Cp/x-lf 2k2
dx
where k and e„_! are as given above.
1.6
A Bayesian approach to assessment of CP
The majority of the research works for testing capability indices have been focused on using the traditional distributional frequency approaches. An alternative is to use the Bayesian approach, which essentially specifies a prior distribution for the parameter of interest to obtain the posterior distribution of the parameter and then infers about the parameter by only using its posterior distribution given the observations. Cheng and Spiring (1989) proposed a Bayesian procedure for assessing the capability index Cp with a non-informative prior, n(/i, a) = 1/CT , —oo < ^ < oo , 0 < a < oo , and obtained the posterior probability:
29
The CP Index
p = Pv{process is capable | sample} = Pr{C p > w | x} which is equivalent to finding an one-sided credible interval for a. Furthermore, Pearn and Wu (2003) adopt a non-informative reference prior chosen by Cheng and Spiring (1989), given a prespecified precision level w > 0 (preset process capability requirement), and the posterior probability, based on the index Cp , that a process is capable is given as ..a-1
xexp(-y)dy
i
_ r(a,i/0
l-G(l/t,a,l),
T(a)
with
t =
(n* \2
27 771
1
\
Efa- )
W
1
Efa- )
)
7
~
i)
i=i
77!
E E (xij -x? 7= 1 j = l
where
E (n»~~ X)5P + E ^te - x ) ^2
7= 1
7= 1
^=[2/(n)]^ 2 r[(n)/2]/r[(n-i)/2] 2_^Z_^\xii
and
EK-i)
E( n * -V4
x
7= 1 j = l 777
v
ni
l^2_^\Xij
and
Wbm
7= 1
j=i m
C
27
„2 _ S
P
»=1 j = l 777
Efa-1) 7= 1
x
i)
30
Encyclopedia
and Handbook
of Process
Capability
Indices
Weakness of Cp Most industrial companies at the time dawn of the 21-st century are no longer relying solely on CP to quantify process capability in view of the perceived weakness of the index. The major weakness of this index lies in the fact that it measures potential capability as defined by the actual process spread and does not take into account the actual mean of the process (see Figure. 1.3.). Therefore, CP provides no indication of the actual process performance. It does not reflect the impact that shifting the process mean has on process's ability to produce product within the specifications (Chen et al. (1988, 1990) and Kane (1986)). For this reason a more refined index the Cpk was developed. The indices CP and Cpk, when used together, provide a proper indication of the process capability with regard to both of the process spread and of the process location.
LSL
Nominal
USL
Figure 1.3. Various processes with t h e same value of CV
Chapter 2
The Ca Index
2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4
Process accuracy and the Ca index Estimating and testing Ca based on a single sample Estimating and testing Ca based on multiple samples Bayesian-like estimator of Ca
2.1 Process accuracy and the Ca index
While the precision index Cp discussed in Chapter 1 measures the magnitude of the process variation, the index k, to be defined below, describes the process capability in terms of departure of the process mean // from the center (mid) point m and provides a quantified measure of the extent t h a t a process is off-center. T h e index k is one of the original Japanese indices and is defined as: |/x — m | k =
USL-
LSL
|/U — m | =
d
'
2 where fi is the process mean, d = (USL — LSL) / 2 is the half specification width, USL and LSL are, as above, the upper and the lower specification limits, and m is the midpoint between the upper and lower specification limits ( m = (USL + LSL) / 2 ). This index measures the departure of process mean from the mid-point
31
32
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
of specifications. For example, k = 0 indicates that the process is centered at the target (fi = m), k = 1 means that the process mean is located at one of the specification limits. When 0 < k < 1, the process mean is located between the target and one of the specification limits. Obviously, k > 1 indicates that \i fall outside the specification limits (i.e. /i > USL or fi < LSL ), the process is severely off-center and it needs an immediate troubleshooting. The complementary index Ca = 1 — k , referred to as the accuracy index, is defined to measure the degree of process centering relative to the manufacturing tolerance (Pearn et al. (1998)). The index is expressed as \ji — m |
It measures the degrees of process centering (i.e. the ability to cluster around the center), and alerts the user if the process mean deviates from the center m (which is often the target value). Table 2.1 displays various Ca values and the corresponding ranges of the "departure" magnitude of \i. Table 2.1. Ca values and ranges of \i. Range of fj,
Ca value Ca = 1.00 0.75 < Ca < 1.00 0.50
0.75
0.25 < Ca < 0.50 0.00 < Ca < 0.25
fj, =
m
0<|/j-m|<
d/4 < | n-m
d/4
|< d/2
d/2<\n-m\<
3d/A
3 d / 4 <\ fi-m\<
d
Ca = 0.00
H = LSL or
Ca < 0.00
\i < LSL or n > USL
M
= USL
33
The Ca Index
2.2 Estimation and testing Ca based on a single sample To estimate the accuracy index Ca , Pearn et al. (1998) proposed a natural estimator Ca . Let x = 2_j _i xi /n be the conventional estimator of the process mean JJ, , obtained from a stable process, then Cn = 1
\x — m
where, as above, d = {USL - LSL)/2
and m = (USL +
LSL)/2.
This estimator can alternatively be written as: \x — m \ ; = 1
Cn=l
\x — m d^fn a J' -In
where under the normality assumption, the statistic -In | x — m | / a has a folded normal distribution as originally defined by Leone et al. (1961) with the p.d.f.
f(y) = 4~a
l
cos
HwI
(y2 + M2) , y>o. z
V 7T
2a
Thus, the p.d.f. of Ca can be expressed as /(*) = 6C7j^cosh[9nC p 2 (l - Ca)(l - x)} 2TT
x exp
or
f(x) = 6 C p J — c o s h
-9nC2p[(l-x)2+(l-Ca)2} 2 (1 - x)6 -6_ (1 - xf 1+ exp2 1-C„ (i - ca)
34
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
for —oo < x < 1. 2.2.1 The first two moments
of
Ca
Using the p.d.f. of Ca , the first two moments of Ca can be calculated to be (Pearn et al. (1998)):
B.6.) - C. - ^ ^ e x p ( ^ )
B&) = cl
+
2(1 -
C.W-JI),
+ 4(1 c M
-^?r- irMM^)
]
" " -^ '
and the variance of Ca can be obtained by calculating Var(Ca) = E{C2a) - [E(Ca)f , where 6 = 9n(Cp - Cpk f . The estimator Ca is biased, but as the sample size increases and approaches infinity, while the terms l/(3C p ) , [2 /(mr)f'2 , exp(—6/2), and $[—3Vn (C p — Cpk )] all converge to zero. Hence, the estimator Ca is asymptotically unbiased. For the percentage bias to be less than 5% (i.e. | E(Ca) - Ca \ /Ca < 0.05) , it is required that n > 30 , and to be less than 1% (| E(Ca) -Ca \/Ca < 0.01) we must have n > 650. Since by definition MSE[Ca ) = Var{Ca) + Bias[Ca ) , we have explicitly:
+ 4(1-Ca)2$(-V£). In addition, the behavior of the natural estimator Ca has investigated by Pearn and Lin (2005) under general conditions (the behavior of the corrected estimator bn_iCa is the same as that of Ca). It is shown that under general conditions, Ca is a consistent estimator, which is asymptotically unbiased. It can be
35
The Ca Index
shown that Ca is asymptotically efficient provided the process characteristic is normally distributed.
2.2.2 Confidence
interval
on Ca
Under the normality assumption, Pearn et al. (1998) have shown that the natural estimator Ca = 1— | x — m \ / d of the process accuracy index Ca , is also the maximum likelihood estimator (MLE), consistent, asymptotically efficient estimator and that Vn(C a — Ca) converges to 7V(0, l/(9Cp)) in distribution. Since the distribution of -fn(Ca — Ca) converges to N(0,l/(9C2)), the distribution of 3VnCp(Ca — Ca) converges to N(0,1) (in distribution). An approximate 100(1 — a) percent confidence interval of Ca can thus be obtained to be: A L/ a
Zg/2
A ~—,^a
3-JnCp
, ~r
Z
a/2 =— •
3VnC p
Here as above za/2 is the upper a / 2 quantile for the standard normal distribution JV(0,1), Cp = b^Cj,, T(x) = J°° t^1 e~l dt, and bn_! = (2 /(n - 1)) 1/2 x T[{n - 1 ) / 2 ] / T[(n - 2) /2] . An 100(1 — a)% lower confidence limit on Ca can be constructed using only the lower limit Ca — za /(3Vn Cp).
2.3 Estimating and testing Ca based on multiple samples The past "in control" data consisting of m subgroups, with variable sample sizes n, are collected randomly from a stable process distributed in accordance with the normal distribution, N(fi,a2) . The collected data is then analyzed to compute the manufacturing capability. Let Xt = Y^._ xi j n and St — [(rij — 1)~ z2 '=i(xy ~ X^2]1'2 be the i-th sample mean and the sample standard deviation, respectively, and total number of
36
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
observations be N = J ^ n^ . As estimators of \i and a2 , we shall use the overall sample mean and pooled variance, which are unbiased estimators, i.e. _
1
Hi
ii = x = -jjJ2^i
a n d &2
i
ni
= 4 = w^2(ni - !)*? •
We shall thus consider the following estimator Ca to estimate the accuracy index Ca: £. IX — ml a \X — m n n C„ = 1 ; l = 1 - —-T= x where ViV | X — m | / a is distributed as in accordance with the folded normal distribution with parameters ViV \ \x — ra\ j a and 1 as given in 2.2. The corresponding p.d.f. is f(x) =
ry "l — <x =l-P(Y
fy(y)dy 1
T7=Uz{-4y)
+
fz{4y)]dy,
2^Fu
where fY(-) is the p.d.f. of the folded-normal distribution.
<{D(l-x)f)
37
The C„ Index
Hence, the c.d.f. of Ca can be expressed in terms of a mixture of t h e normal distribution:
Fd (x) = l -
fbmi~X)[cj>(t
+ £VAT) + ^ t -
t^N)]dt,
for x < 1 . Differentiating with respect t o x we arrive at t h e p.d.f. of Ca: fda ( i ) = D[fz ( - £ > ( 1 - x)) + j z (D(l - x))}, for x < 1 . Furthermore, the r-th moment of Ca can directly be obtained as: E{CTa)
VF1
= E
r /r
=E
(-lyzj-'^r'/ 2 ).
j=0
Now, following Pearn ei a/. (1998) we arrive at:
£(C0) = C
0
>/2e"A/2 - ±£>VTT ^ — +
2(l-Ca)$(-|«l)..
1 9 / 9 ^ A/ 2 2V2e~ E(C2a ) = C l + ^ - ~ ~ ^ - + 4 ( 1 - Ca
and
where $(•) is as above distribution N(0,1). T h u s , Var(Ca)
Lower
confidence
bounds
t h e c.d.f.
=
)$(-\6\),
of the s t a n d a r d
E(Cl)-E2{Ca).
on Ca
T h e index Ca m a y also be rewritten in t h e form:
normal
38
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
c.-i-i^-i- d / < r ' where £ = (/j, — M) / a . In the case when Ca = C , b = d /a can be expressed as b =| £ | /(l — C ) . Hence, given a sample of size N , the confidence level 7 , the estimated value Ca, and the parameter £, the lower confidence bounds C^ can be obtained using numerical integration with iterations, to solve the basic equation
j^(i-c.)^t
+
^ ^
+
^
_^
^
= l-
7
.
(2.1)
2.4 Bayesian-like estimator of CQ Pearn et al. (1998) investigated the process accuracy index Ca to measure the degree of process centering. The investigation, however, only restricted to cases where the process mean may be assumed as an unknown constant. Pearn and Lin (2002) pointed out that in real-world applications, the production may require: (1) multiple supplies with different quality characteristics on each shipment of the raw materials, (2) multiple manufacturing lines with inconsistent precision in machine settings and engineering effort for each manufacturing line, or (3) multiple workmanship shifts with unequal performance level on each shift. Those situations certainly reflect many industrial applications more closely, covering most manufacturing industries, including the manufacturing of the microelectronics, the IC chips, wafers, computer components, PC monitors, as well as most assembly lines. In such situations, the process mean, /j,, often shifts from one constant (with probability p ) to another constant (with probability 1 — p), and the assumption made in most capability research problems that the process mean is staying as a constant
39
The Ca Index
may not satisfied in real-world situations. Consequently, using the natural estimator Ca to measure the potential and performance of such a process would be inappropriate as the resulting capability measure and testing would not be accurate. In the following, a new estimator of Ca is described assuming that the knowledge of P(n > m) = p G [0, 1] can be obtained from historical information of a process that is demonstrably stable (being in statistical control). The new estimator Ca is defined as:
Ca 1
~
d
'
where A = {n\ \i > m} , and IA(-) is the indicator function. To evaluate the estimator Ca , one needs to determine the value of the indicator which requires additionally the knowledge of P(/i > m) , or that of P(n < m). If historical information of the process shows P(/tx > m) = p , one can then determine the value /^(/i) = 1, or — 1 using available random number tables. (For example, assume p = 0.62 is given, then IA(/J) = 1 if the generated 3-digit random number is no greater than 62, and /^(/x) = —1 otherwise.) Pearn and Lin (2005) showed that if the process obeys a normal distribution N( /tx, a2) with P(/x > m) = p G [0, 1] is given, then 3VnC p (C a - Ca) is distributed as JV(0,1). Let Xl,X2,...,Xn be a random sample of measurements from a process possessing the fourth central moment /x4 and LSL < JJ, < USL . Under general conditions, if the knowledge of P(fi > m) — p , where 0 < p < 1, is available, then as n —> oo , ~fn{Ca — Ca) converges in distribution to iV(0, (9Cp)_1) . Furthermore, Pearn and Lin (2005) have also shown that Ca is the UMVUE and asymptotically efficient estimator of Ca. Since the definition of Ca involves X , then the distribution of Ca must relate to a and hence CP appears in the normalized expression 3Vn • Cp (Ca — Ca).
Chapter 3
The Cpk Index
3.1 Process capability and the Cpk index 3.2 Estimating and testing Cpk based on a single sample 3.3 Estimating and testing Cpk based on multiple samples 3.4 The Bayesian approach to Cpk 3.5 The Bayesian-like estimator of Cpk 3.1 Process capability and the Cpk index Due to the simplicity of its design the index, Cp cannot reflect the tendency of process centering (targeting) and thus gives no indication of the actual process performance. In order to account for the deviations of process mean from the target value, several indices, similar in nature to Cp , have been proposed over the years. These indices attempt to account for the magnitude of process variance as well as for the process departures from the target value. One of such indices is Cpk defined as: _
.
USL — a
a — LSL
(3.1)
where as above USL is the upper specification limit, LSL is the lower specification limit, /i is the process mean and a is the process standard deviation. Utilizing the algebraic identity min{a, b} = (a + b)— \ a — b | / 2 , the definition of the index Cpk can alternatively be written as: 40
The Cpk Index
Cpk=
41
_ d— | fi — m | 3^ '
where as above d = (USL - LSL) / 2 is half of the length of the specification interval and m = (USL + LSL) / 2 is the mid-point between the lower and the upper specification limits. The Cp and Cpk indices are directly related by the process capability indices k or Ca, i.e.: ^pfc
=
Cp x (1 — k) = Cp x Ga .
Note that if /x were outside the specification range, Cv^ would be negative, and the process would then be inadequate for controlling the values of X. The index Cpj. was developed since Cp does not adequately deal in those cases when the process mean fi is not centered. However, Cpfc by itself still cannot provide adequate measure of process centering. In fact, a large value of Cpk does not really provides any information about the location of the mean /x inside the tolerance interval. Revealing relationships between the indices Cp and Cpk are also discussed by Gensidy (1985), Barnett (1988), Coleman (1991), Kotz and Johnson (1998), and Ramakrishnan et al. (2001). Cpk and the percentage of non-conforming (%NC) The process yield is at present defined as the percentage of the processed product units which pass the inspections. Production units are inspected in accordance with specification limits placed on various key product characteristics and are sorted into two categories: passed (conforming) and rejected (defectives). Consequently, yield is one of the transparent, basic criteria for interpreting the process capability. Suppose that a proportion of conforming items is of the primary concern. In this case a most natural measure of what is the above proportion is called the yield. This proportion p is defined as:
42
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
USL
/
LsLdF(x)
=
F(USL)-F(LSL),
where F(x) is the c.d.f. of the "measured" characteristic X, USL and LSL are as above the upper and the lower specification limits, respectively. If the process characteristic X follows the normal distribution, N(fi,a2), then the fraction of the nonconforming (%NC ) [defective in the old terminology] may be expressed as:
%NC = i-*(USL;-")
+ *("
~aLSL).
See Figure 3.1.
Figure 3.1. Normal distribution and the proportion of product units outside the specification limits.
Yield assurance based on Cpk The index Cvk has been viewed as an yield-based index since it provides bounds on the process yield for a normally distributed process with a fixed value of Cv\. . The bounds are 2$(3Cpk) -l
43
The Cpk Index
rate, a Cpk level of 1.67 is required. At a Cpk level of 2.0, the likelihood of a defective part drops to 2 parts per billion (ppb).
0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2.0 Figure 3.2. The bounds on nonconforming units in PPM versus Cpk
These important bounds may be established by considering for a process with fixed Cpk the number of nonconformities (namely product items fall out the specification interval [ LSL, USL}). However the exact number of nonconformities will vary depending upon the location of the process mean and the magnitude of the process variation. Thus, we rewrite the definition of the index Cpk as follows. From (3.1) Cpk —
d— \ fj, — m\
3a 1-\S 37
1— \([i, — m)/
d
3(a/d) f 1+ 6 , LSL < fi < m 37 1-6 ,m< fj, < USL . 37
Here m = (USL + LSL) / 2 is the midpoint of the specification interval (the tolerance), d = (USL — LSL)/2 is the half-length of the specification interval, 6 = (/i — m) / d , and 7 = a / d .
44
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
For Cpk > 0 , we may obtain an exact expected proportion of nonconforming (%NCj as a function of Cpk and Ca or of Cpk and of Cp taken together to be: %NC = ${-3Cpk]
+ ${-3Cpk(2
-Ca)/Ca],
(3.2)
and %NC = ^[-3Cpk]
+ ^[~3(2Cp-Cpk)}.
(3.2)'
(under the normal assumption). As it is evident from Equation (3.2), under the normality assumption, when the process mean is located within the specification limits, i.e. 0 < Ca < 1 or Cpk > 0 , we have the two sided bounds on %NC to be $(-3C pfc ) < %NC < 2§(-3Cpk) since the standard normal c.d.f. $(•) is a non-decreasing function. This is of course equivalent to the two sided bounds on the process yield: 2<&{3Cpk) - 1 < p< $(3Cpfc) . Note that for Ca = 1.0, the process is perfectly centered (/U = m ) . For Ca = 0.0, the process mean is on the specification limits (fi = USL or /i = LSL ). For processes with fixed Cpk , the number of the nonconformities attains its maximum for a centered process (Ca = 1.0), and %NC reduces when the process mean moves away from the center (Ca decreases). Montgomery (2001) recommended some minimum capability requirements for processes runs under certain specified quality conditions. In particular, he suggests Cpk > 1.33 for existing processes, Cpk > 1.50 for new processes (to break in) ; Cpk > 1.50 also for existing processes on safety, strength, or critical parameters, and Cpk > 1.67 for new processes involving safety, strength, or critical parameters. Finley (1992) also found that the required Cpk values on all critical supplier processes should be 1.33 or higher and that Cpk values of 1.67 or higher to be preferred. Numerous companies have recently adopted criteria for
45
The Cpk Index
evaluating their processes that include process capability objectives more stringent than earlier. The widely popularized Motorola's "Six Sigma" program essentially requires the .process capability of at least 2.0 to accommodate the possible 1.5 a process shift, and that no more than 3.4 parts per million be defective. On the other hand, a process is currently called "Inadequate" if Cpk < 1.00 ; it indicates that the process is not adequate with respect to the production tolerances (specifications), and either process variation ( a 2 ) needs to be reduced or process mean (\i) needs to be shifted closer to the preset target value (often set to the mid-point m ). A process is called "Capable" if 1.00 < Cpk < 1.33 ; it indicates that some caution needs to be taken regarding to the process distribution, and certain process control is required. A process is called "Satisfactory" if 1.33 < Cpk < 1.50 ; it indicates that process quality is adequate, material substitution may be allowed, and no stringent quality control is needed. A process is called "Excellent" if 1.50 < Cpk < 2.00 ; it indicates that process quality exceeds "Satisfactory". Finally, a process is called "Super" if Cpk > 2.00. We emphasize that these designation ought to be taken with a grain of salt. They are based on the normality assumption and often are designated to attract new customers. 3.2 Estimating and testing Cpk based on a single sample The natural estimator Cpk is obtained by replacing the process mean \i and the process standard deviation a by their estimators x and s, which may be obtained from a process that is demonstrably stable (under statistical control): Cpk=
d— \ x — m\ ' ^ "M
17
L =
]
I
\x —m
_ M _ ^ I ^
!
(3 _ 3)
46
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
where x = 'Y2"=1xi In an<^ s = [X^"-i(x» — x ) 2 / ( n ~~ Vlf^2 a r e the sample mean and the sample standard deviation, respectively. We note that the terminology such as: demonstrably, very likely, etc. does not always conveys total unconditional confidence. 3.2.1 The r-th moment
of C,pk
Under the assumption of normality, Kotz, et al. (1993) derived the r-th moment of Cpk . The moment can be expressed as follows:
E(c;k) = ±E(±r)£(-i)
dr-JE(\x-m\j)
3=0
d\ln — 1 r E(xZi)J2(-iy "3a j=o
[—1 \d*Jnl
E
•fn(x
— m) a
For r = 1, we arrive at the expected value of Cpk :
Also for r = 2, we have the second moment E(Cpk) to be: \2
E(Cpk)
' dy/n — 1 E(Xn2l) 3^ ,
xE(-D and the variance is easily calculated as:
n (x — m)
47
The Cpk Index
Var(Cpk) =
2
9(n - 3)
+
a
-A/2
a
^(l-2$(-VA))] + ^ } - [ ^ p f c ) f
Here the non-centrality factor is A = n(/j, — m)2 / a2, and the correction factor is: K-i = (2/(« - 1)) 1/2 x T[(n - l ) / 2 ] / r [ ( n - 2)/2]. (See also Zhang et al. (1990), Pearn et al. (1992), and Kotz and Johnson (1993, 1998)). Kotz et al. (1993) have shown that Cpk is a biased estimator of Cpk . The resultant bias is positive when [x ^ m . When ^ = m , the bias is positive for n < 10 , but becomes negative for larger values of n. (For d/a values of 3.0 and 4.0 it is negative for all n > 20 , while for d / a = 5.0 it is negative for large n, n > 30 , and for larger rates d / a = 6.0 the negative bias starts at n > 40.) Evidently, this bias tends to zero as n approaches to infinity. Recall that large values of the ratio d/a indicate that the process has smaller relative variation. So far we don't have an intuitive explanation of the observed phenomenon that for large n the bias is negative for fi = m. Also the exact value of n for which in this case the bias is 0 seems to be not available yet. 3.2.2 Distributional
properties
of Cpk
Chou and Owen (1989) utilize the original definition given in Equation (3.1) as the starting point for deriving the distribution of Cpk . The authors express Cpk in the form Cpk = mm(Cpu,Cpi) >
48
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
where Cpu = (USL - x) /(3s) and Cpl = (x - LSL)/(Ss) The latter are natural estimators of Cpu and Cpi , respectively. The distributions of 3^/nCpu and that of 3^/nCpi are, under the normality assumption, the non-central t distribution with n — 1 degrees of freedom and the non-centrality parameters -Jn(USL — /x) / a and Vn(/Lt — LSL) /a respectively. Next, the Owen's (1965) formulas for the joint distribution of two dependent non-central t variables is used to derive the distribution of C.pk . The p.d.f. of Cpk , g^ (y) say, turns out to be rather complex
3Vn $>!;_,, «fe) 9cpk(y) =
3Vn^] n - 1 Qn+1 i=l
ify<0,
n +1 ij,^;0,i? 1
-Qn-i(ti,Si\Q,R)\
fory>0,
where ^ = —^ = 3Vny , <5i = —Z-J~nCpu , 82 = 3VnCp; , R — y/n — 1(<52 — &i)/(Pi ~ h) » a n d 9T„_1 {. (•) is the non-central t distribution with n — 1 degrees of freedom and the non-centrality parameter St. The function £?/ (t,6;0,Rj is given by eta;, Q, (t,6;0,R) = C(f)JoR\ $fe - <5J^VW
and the constant C(f) = V2^F/[r(//2)2^/ 2 - 1 ] . As above $(•) is the c.d.f. of standard normal distribution and
The Cpk Index
49
to the folded normal distribution with the parameter n 1,/2 |/u - m\/a (see e.g. Leone, et. al (1961)) Cpk becomes a mixture of the Xn-i a n d the folded normal distributions (Pearn, et. al. (1992)). The p.d.f. is given by (see Pearn, et. al (1999)): n +21
i =o xexp
fcJy) =
18a'
•(a2z2 + 9(1
-yzf)
y < o,
•dz,
AAnYJP^)B(x^fTTi'\l-yzrz^1 — 0n fi =
xexp
a
°U
• J^(aV+9(1-y*) 2 )}**
2/ > 0.
Here D = (n - l) 1 / 2 d/
W) = 5,=
(A/2/ , and > Ai — l\ 3n-12"/2r((n-l)/2)
2*r((2^ + i ) / 2 ;
Using the integration technique similar to the one suggested in Vannman (1997), Pearn and Lin (2002) obtained an exact and explicit form of the c.d.f. of the natural estimator Cpk , under the normality assumption. The c.d.f. of Cpk is expressed in terms of a mixture of the chi-square and the normal distributions:
o
G
\n-l)(bJn 9ny2
-t)
x [4>(t + £Vn) + 4>{t - £Jn)]dt
(3.4)
50
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
for y > 0, where b = d / a , £ = (fj, - m) / a , G(-) is the c.d.f. of the chi-square distribution with degree of freedom n — 1 , Xn-i > and (/>(•) as above is the standard normal p.d.f. Expression (3.4) is equivalent to the special case of the c.d.f. for the estimator Cp(u,v) with u = \ , v = 0 obtained originally by Vannman (1997). 3.2.3
Confidence
intervals
for Cpk
The construction of the exact confidence intervals for Cpj. is difficult due to the fact that the distribution of Cv^ now involves the joint distribution of a two non-central ^-distributed random variables. Chou and Owen (1989), Chou, Owen and Borrego (1990), Zhang et al. (1990), Kushler and Hurley (1992) and Nagata and Nagahata (1994) provide a through treatment of the construction of approximate confidence intervals for Cpk , which are relatively simple to calculate. Heavlin (1998) suggests the following approximation as a 100(1 — a)% confidence interval:
Cpk
| n-1 ' y9n(n-3)
Za 2
C
, Clk (, , 6 \ ' 2(n - 3)1* ' n - l j '
^ + ^ / 2 V 9 n ( n - 3 ) ' 2{n - 3)V ' n - l j
Zhang et al. (1990) obtained expressions for the mean and the variance of the sampling distribution of Cpk based on the normal approximation and determined a 100(1 — a)% confidence interval as:
51
The Cp/t Index
Franklin and Wasserman (1992) suggested an additional modification to produce remarkably accurate 100(1 — a)% lower confidence limits for n > 30 as C.pk
' 9n
2(n - 1) '
(3.5)
where za is the upper a quantile of the standard normal distribution. This approach was also proposed by Bissell (1990), who derived above formula using a Taylor series argument. Nagata and Nagahata (1994) have suggested modifying the above formulas by adding l/(30Vn) and obtained very good results for simulation experiments for the two-sided confidence intervals with this modification. Nagata and Nagahata (1992) also developed a two-sided confidence interval for CnJfe pk which is an extension of two-sided confidence intervals for Cpu and CPi developed by Nagata (1991). It is C.pk
z
a/2\
9n
ru 2
+ 2(npk-
1)
> Cpk + z, a/2
If the term l/(9n) is omitted, then an approximate lower confidence limit on Cpk can be reduced to
V^^TjJ c.
pk •
Kushler and Hurley (1992) suggested a simpler formula for the 100(1 — a)% lower confidence limit given by 1 - zn
U/2(^l)
C,pk '
52
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
Numerous investigations are available and have been presented in the literature, examining their results. Franklin and Wasserman (1992) carried out simulations to assess the properties of these limits and discovered that they are conservative, with actual coverage rate being from about 96 to 98%. Guirguis and Rodriguez (1992) have provided an explanation of why these limits are conservative. Kushler and Hurley (1992) described several methods for computing lower confidence bounds and evaluated performance of the various methods in terms of miss rate (percentage). Franklin and Wasserman (1991, 1992) proposed a nonparametric but computer-intensive bootstrap estimation to develop three types of bootstrap confidence intervals for Cpfc . The standard bootstrap interval (SB), the percentile bootstrap confidence interval (PB) and the bias-corrected percentile bootstrap confidence interval (BCPB). The results indicate that some of the bootstrap intervals provide 90% coverage when the process is normally distributed and provided 84-87% coverage when the process obeys a chi-square distribution. Practitioners, however, have to bear in mind that the practical interpretation of the index Cpk is questionable when the normality does not hold. Tang et al. (1997) developed an approximate method to derive the confidence limits for CpA. by graphically investigating the relationship between Cp , k and the percentage of nonconforming items. Hoffman (2001) obtained confidence intervals for Cv^ by using percentiles of the distribution of Cp , and compared them to bootstrap technique proposed by Franklin and Wasserman (1991, 1992) and the approximate method proposed by Tang et al. (1997) via simulation. The results indicated that Hoffman's intervals might be the preferred selection in most cases by providing the requisite coverage probability and possessing narrow interval widths.
The Cpk Index
53
Furthermore, based on the c.d.f. of Cpk expressed in Equation (3.4), Pearn and Shu (2003) developed an efficient algorithm with a Matlab computer program to obtain the lower confidence limits conveying critical information regarding the true process capability. In fact, given the sample of size n , the confidence level 7 , the estimated value Cpk and the parameter £, the lower confidence bounds Cpk can be obtained using a numerical integration technique with iterations, to solve the following equation (3.6) with bL = 3Cpk + |£|: brVn
/
G 0
(n - l)(fe£Vn - tf 9nC2pk
x[0(t + £Vn) + 0(t-£>/«)]<** = I - 7 .
(3.6)
We observe that development of a lower confidence bound on the actual process capability is essential for quality assurance. The lower confidence limit not only gives us a clue on the minimal level of the actual performance of the process which is closely related to the nonconforming units, but is also useful in making decisions for capability testing. Kotz and Johnson (2002) presented a thorough review of process capability indices during the past decade.
Approximate
sample size
determination
As noted previously, the distribution of Cpk is quite complex and rather intractable. Chou et al. (1990) derived 95% lower confidence limit and provided tables values for selected sample sizes and the Cp and Cpk values. Unfortunately, their work in obtaining the tables for Cpk values necessitated them to make certain assumptions in order to find the necessary percentile points for a bivariate non-central student's ^distribution. These
54
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
assumptions are, in general, not true for most of processes and this resulted in the 95% lower confidence limits table values actually performing at 96-98% coverage. This flaw, as well as the proposed recommended approximate formulas, have been noted and discussed by Kushler and Hurley (1992) and Franklin and Wasserman (1992). Moreover, Kushler and Hurley (1992) have noted that Bissell's approximation (1990) is equal to or superior to the five other approximate methods examined by means of numerical integration. Furthermore, Franklin and Wasserman (1992) showed that for n > 30 , Bissell's method performs at the desired 95% level for several values of Cpk in finding a 95% lower confidence limit via simulation. Bissell's approximation is given in (3.5) as
cT = c.pk
I 1
Za
i9n
,
+
Cpk
2(n-l)'
Accordingly, for n > 30 (Franklin (1999)) utilitized In - 2 ~ In and solving for n obtains 2 "I Cpk
l
(z*Y 9 n =
Cpk
i
+
r^ Lk(B) P
= (*«r
9C&
i +
2
(i-cw/c*)"
(3.7)
which is dependent on the value of C^ — Cpj, , Cpj. and a or and the value equivalent by depends on the ratio Cpl jCpk , of Cpk . For example, if we expect a 95% lower confidence limit for Cpk to be 0.80 of the Cpk (i.e. C$B)/Cpk = 0.80) and Cpk = 1.50, then the sample size recommended for estimation obtained by (3.7) is 38. (Franklin (1999) provides more details).
The Cpk Index
3.2.4 Hypothesis
testing
55
with Cpk
Remark: For completeness we shall briefly survey the basic concepts of classical hypothesis testing procedures. Critical values are usually used for making decisions in capability testing with a designated type I error a , [the risk of misjudging an incapable process (H0: Cpfc < C ) as a capable one (Hj: Cpk > C )]. The p-values are used for making decisions in capability testing, which present the actual risk of misjudging an incapable process (H0: Cpk < C) as a capable one (H^ Cpk > C). Hence, if p-value < a we then reject the null hypothesis and conclude that the process is capable with the actual type I error pvalue (rather than a). Based on the c.d.f. of Cpk , Pearn and Lin (2002) carried out the statistical theory of the hypotheses testing, and developed a practical procedure accompanied with convenient by tabulated critical values for engineers/practitioners, to be used for decision making in applications. Statistical hypothesis testing methodology used for examining whether the process capability meets the customers' demands can be stated as follows: H0: Cpk < C Hi: Cpk > C
(process is not capable), (process is capable).
As above we shall define the test (j>{x) - a decision making rule- as follows:
56
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
preassigned value), b = d/a can be expressed as b = 3C+ |£| . Given a value of C (the capability requirement), the Rvalue corresponding to c , (a specific value of Cpk , calculated from the sample data) is given by: p - value = Pr(C'pfc > c | Cpk = C)
•w. .ffc^B^I - /
o
9n(c )'
.(3.8)
J
with & = 3C+ |£| . Hence, given the values of capability requirement C , parameter £ , sample size n , and risk a , the critical value c0 can be obtained by solving the following equation:
((n-l){b^n-tf)
6Vn
G
/
o
9nco
x[>(* + £Vn) + 0(*-£Vn)]
(3.9)
Observe that we would obtain an identical equation if we substitute £ by —£ into equation (3.8) for fixed values of c , n and C . Therefore, given fixed values of n and C , the p-value corresponding to a specific value c for £ = £0 and £ = — £0 are the same. Similarly, we may obtain an identical equation if we substitute £ by —£ into equation (3.9) for fixed values of c 0 , C , n and a . Hence, given fixed values of C, n and a , the critical values c0 for £ = £0 and £ = — £0 are the same. The reader should carefully distinguish between C , C and c 0 . Critical value c0 and parameter £ Usually, the process parameters \i and a are unknown as well as the distribution characteristic parameter £ = (/i — m) / a . In real applications, these quantities are to estimated naturally by substituting fi and a by the sample mean x and the sample standard deviation s , respectively. This introduces additional
The Cpk Index
57
sampling errors from estimating £ when finding the critical values, and would render this approach to be less reliable. To avoid estimating the distribution characteristic parameter £ , Pearn and Lin (2002) carried out further examination of the behavior of the critical values CQ CLS Si function of the parameter £ . The authors performed extensive calculations to obtain the critical values c0 for the parameter values £ = 0(0.05)3.00, n = 10(50)300, C = 1.00, 1.33, 1.50, 1.67, 2.00, and a= 0.05., which cover pretty much range of applications for the process capability Cpk > 0 . The conclusion is that the critical value c0 is: (i) increasing in £, and decreasing in n (ii) attains its maximum at £ = 1.00 in all the cases, and (iii) remains constant for £> 1.00 for all C (with the accuracy up to 10~6 ). Moreover, the authors have discovered that the critical value CQ for sample sizes n > 30 reaches its maximum at £ = 0.50 and remains unchanged for £ > 0.50 (for n > 100 , £ = 0.35 with accuracy up to 10" 4 ). Hence, Pearn and Lin (2002) suggest that in practice one should solve equation (3.4) with £ = 1.00 in order to obtain the required critical values, without having to estimate directly the parameter £. This approach ensures that the decisions made based on these critical values are more reliable than other existing methods of estimating £ using only sample values. To the best of our knowledge, no work has been published which investigates the distributional properties of Cvk when a is estimated by the range coefficient R '
=
*
•
Li et al. (1990) have investigated lower confidence limits for Cph when a is used as an estimator of the standard deviation. These are similar in their structure to their lower confidence limits designed for Cp (See Chapter 1). From the definition oiCpk = mm{USL — fj,,/j, — LSL} /(3a) = mm{Cpu,Cpi}, the statement that a process is capable if
58
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
P(Cpk
> Ck) = a
is equivalent to the requirement that P\Cpu
> ck and Cpl > ck )
= P[Z-hiR<-hL
and Z + hjR > hx ) = a
where Z is the standard normal variable, h^ = (3-J~nCpk)/ a\ and hi = 3Snck . Evaluation of the last two quantities involves calculations of double integrals which calls for numerical integration. Li et al. (1990) have provided tables specifying the minimum values of Cpk for which the process is capable (i.e. Cpk > ck 95% of the time). 3.3 Estimating and testing Cpk based on multiple samples The majority of the results obtained so far related to the distributional properties of the estimated capability indices were obtained based on the assumption of having a single sample. However, as we have already mentioned a common practice is to estimate the process capability indices by using the past "incontrol data" from subsamples. To use estimators based on several small subsamples and then interpret the results as if they were based on a single sample is inappropriate and may result in incorrect conclusions. In order to use past in-control data from subsamples to make decisions regarding process capability, the distribution of the estimated capability index based on subsamples ought to be available. We have already mentioned that Kirmani et al. (1991) have studied the distribution of estimators of Cp based on the sample standard deviations of the subsamples. Almost concurrently Li et al. (1990) have studied the distribution of estimators of Cp and Cpk based on the ranges of subsamples.
59
The Cvk Index
Vannman and Hubele (2003) considered indices belonging to the class designated by Cp(u,v), alluded to in a previous section, and have derived the distribution of the estimators of Cp (u, v) , with the estimators of the parameters \i and a being based on subsamples. These authors also considered estimators that occur naturally when using an X -chart together with an S -chart in quality control. Furthermore, they apply the obtained distributions for studying the hypotheses testing procedure to assess the process capability. Numerical investigations were made to explore the effect of the size and number of subsamples on the efficiency of the hypotheses testing under consideration. Under the normality assumption we have m subsamples, with the sample size of the ith subsample being n^ . For each i , i = 1,2,..., m , let x^ , j = 1,2,..., n,, be a random sample (from a normal distribution) with mean /J, and variance a2 , measuring the characteristic under consideration. We shall assume that the process is in statistical control during the time period when the subsamples are collected. Furthermore, let the process be monitored using a X -chart with a S -chart. For each subsample, let Xj and st denote the sample mean and the sample variance, respectively, of the ith sample and let ./V denote the total number of observations, i.e:
x~i = —J2xv'
s =
i —rrZ]^' ~ ^)2
and N =
Sn» •
Furthermore, denote m
^=£(7^-1). i=l
When all the subsamples have the same size n, we have N = ran and N\ = m(n — 1) . As an estimator of \x the overall sample mean will be used; this is an unbiased estimator, i.e.:
60
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
—
1 . ,
The estimator of a2 considered by Vannman and Hubele (2003) is defined to be
- 2 =^I>-iK 2 Hence, one of the estimators of Cp(u,v) that will be studied below will be A ,
x
d- u |p - T | 3V<J2 + (/t - Tf '
The estimator a2 is not an unbiased estimator of a2 . To obtain an unbiased estimator based on the pooled variance, we define
*1
j=i
E
wnere me coernciem; g = —— — «__„,
m ._ l
Hi
.
For subsamples of the same size n we have g = n/(n — l) . Another estimator of Cp (u, v) is given by x, ,
,
d- u |p - T | 3yla2 +(p-
Tf
The distribution of Cp (u, v) can easily be derived once the distribution of Cp(u,v) is determined, since we have the simple relation
The Cpk Index
61
-P£
Cp(u,v) = CJu.
When all the subsamples are of the same size n we have n — 1 . In — 1
Vannman and Hubele (2003) observe that one can obtain X^"Li x l from Xi and sf via the relation ^ " ' {xy — xt f = 22 L, x% ~ n^1 without utilizing each individual observation x^. Thus, given the summary statistics x~t and sf , i = 1,2,...,m , an estimator of Cp(u,v) can be calculated as
c'(«,«) = pV
^-^1 A - y I 3Va'2 + (A - Tf
(310)
by using the unpooled estimator of a2 given by
,, 2 _ Z ^ i = :i 2 - o = i ( ^ V" = — "— TV
^
_ l = T T V 7 1 , y^™' -, xl - Nx N-
The estimator C*p(u, v) in (3.10) corresponds to the estimator of Cp(u,v) originally introduced by Vannmari (1995), based on a single sample of size TV and the unpooled variance estimator. Its distribution is presented in Vannman (1997).
3.4 The Bayesian approach to C,pk Cheng and Spiring (1989) proposed a Bayesian procedure for assessing the process capability index Cp . Shiau et al. (1999)
62
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
utilized the Bayesian method for testing the index Cpk under the restriction that the process mean /j, equals to the midpoint of the two specification limits m . This would seem to be a somewhat impractical assumption for many factory applications: in this case Cpk reduces to the basic index Cp . Consequently, Peam and Wu (2003) considered a Bayesian procedure for the capability index Cpk relaxing the restriction above. This yields results that are more general and practical for the real-world applications. The authors derive a Bayesian interval estimate for Cpk and propose a Bayesian procedure for testing the process capability. A 100p% credible interval is an Bayesian analogue of the classical I00p% confidence interval, where p provides the confidence level for the interval. A credible interval covers 100p% of the posterior distribution of the parameter under consideration (Berger (1980)). It is also assumed that the measures x = {xl,x2,- •-, xn} are a random sample taken from independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) N(fi, a2)observations. Therefore, given a pre-specified capability level w > 0 , the posterior probability that a process is capable utilizing index Cpk is given as p = Pr{the process is capable| x}=Pr{Cpk exp a ~ Jo T(a)y T(a)va+1
+ l3
r r
$ 3VnC„i.
pk
V ~ Jo T(a)y
+$
eX
P
x
(n - \)y
y.
* Md*k+l6)xM(n-i)y T(a)i .a+l
> w | x}
3Vn (Cpk +^<5)x
— 3Vn w - 1 dy
$ 3Vn
y,
[n ~ 1)2/
3~/nw
w
CpkX
«(n-l)y
w
dy
The Cpk Index
- f'o
V
T(a)ya+1•exp
V,
Jo
where a = (n — 1) / 2 , <S = &i(y) = 3Vn
CpkX
62(2/, <5) = 3Vn
^
+
x{$[6!(y)] + * [ M y , « ) ] - l } dy:
\x — m\
«(n-l)y
(
63
w
35)XV(n-l), — w
and <&(•) as above is the c.d.f. of the standard normal distribution. Note that the posterior probability p depends on n, w , 6 (6 = | x — m | / s) and (7pfc . It may be rather complicated to compute the posterior probability p without certain advanced computer programming skills. However, by noticing that there is an one-to-one correspondence between p and C for given n and w, and using the fact that Cpk can be calculated from the original process data, we find that the minimum value of C required to ensure that the posterior probability p reaches a certain desirable level, can be useful in assessing the process capability. Thus, the value C (p) satisfies p = Pr{Cpk > w | x} = Pr{Cpk > C*(p) \ x} Vx. A 100p% credible interval for Cpk is therefore [C (p),oo), where p is a number between 0 and 1, say 0.95, for a 95% confidence interval, which means that the posterior probability that the credible interval contains the true value of Cpk is p. The credible interval (also called a credible set) is the Bayesian analogue of the classical confidence interval. Using the Bayesian approach we say that the process is capable in the Bayesian sense if all the points in this credible interval are greater than a pre-specified value of w , say 1.00 or
64
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
1.33. When this happens, we have p — Pi{Cpk > w | x} . In other words, to check whether a process is capable (with capability level w and confidence level p) one needs only to check whether Cpk > C (p) . Pearn and Wu (2003) have provided tables of the minimal values of Cpk and C (p) , with the commonly used capability requirements. (Those tables can be used for testing whether a process meets the preset capability requirements).
3.5 The Bayesian-like estimator of Cpk Bissell (1990) proposed a new and simple estimator C'pk to calculate Cpk , the parameter under the assumption that it is known whether the process mean is /J, < m or \x > m namely, either P({i > m) — 0 or 1. The estimator was defined as C'pk = {USL-x)/(3s) or C'pk = {x - LSL)/(3s) according to whether the process mean, /i , is greater or less than m = (USL + LSL) / 2 . An alternative form for C'pk may be written in the following manner: -, _ d — (x — m) sgn(/U — m)
where sgn(/i — m) — 1 if (i — m > 0 , and sgn(/i — m) = — 1 if \x — m < 0 . As Bissell (1990) point out in either case the distribution (under the assumption of normality) of 3nll2C'vk is the noncentral t distribution with n-1 degrees of freedom and the noncentrality parameter ?>nll2Cpk. Kotz et. al (1993) showed that for the index Cpk , the natural estimator gives values for the standard deviation that smaller than those of Bissell's. In real-world applications, the production may require: (1) multiple supplies with different quality characteristics in each single shipment of the raw materials (2) multiple manufacturing lines with inconsistent
The Cpk Index
65
variable precision in machine settings and engineering effort for each manufacturing line (3) multiple workmanship shifts with unequal performance level at each shift. These situations, no doubt, reflect many industrial applications more accurately, covering most manufacturing industries, including microelectronics, the IC chips, wafers, computer components, PC monitors, as well as most of the assembly lines. Another disadvantage of Bissell's estimator is that it is biased, and the location of the process mean with regard to the specification range midpoint must be known with exactitude. To cover these situations, Pearn and Chen (1996) proposed a new estimator Cpk , which relaxes Bissell's assumption concerning the mean. Evaluation of Cpk requires only the knowledge of P(fi > m) = p , where 0 < p < 1. This estimator is given by At, _ d-(x-
m)IA(n)
where A = {/J,\/J, > m}, and the indicator function IA (/z) = 1 for H > m , /J, £ A , IA(^) = —1 for y, < m , /J, ^ A . To utilize this estimator only P(/x > m) — p or P{JJL < m) = 1 — p must be known. If P((i > m) = 0 or 1, the estimator Cpk reduces to Bissell's Cpi~ . This Bayesian-like estimator, Cpk , is unbiased by adding a correction factor bn_i and its variance is smaller than Bissell's. Pearn and Chen (1997) investigated the asymptotic properties of the estimator Cpk • If the knowledge of P(M > m) = p (and P(/i < m) = 1 — p ) is provided, the asymptotic distribution of the estimator C^ corresponds to a contamination of two normal distributions. This estimator treats the process as a mixture of two manufacturing processes. Such situations occur, for example, when the raw materials or components come from two different conditions, or there are two different groups of workmanship involved in the process.
66
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
Weakness of Cpk (see Kotz and Johnson (1998) page 63-64)- Boyles (1991) emphasizes that Cpk fails to measure effectively the effect of process centering on process capability. In fact, it makes no clear distinction between on-target and off-target processes. More importantly, Cv^ by itself provides no indication of the direction in which the process is off-target. Both process location and process spread are employed in the structure of Cpk to quantify capability.
Chapter 4
The Cnm Index
4.1 Process capability and the Cpm index 4.2 Estimating and testing Cpm based on one single sample 4.3 Estimating and testing Cpm based on multiple samples 4.4 The Bayesian approach to Cpm 4.1 Process capability and the Cpm index The Cp and Cpk indices are appropriate measures of "progress" for quality improvement paradigms in which reduction of variability is the guiding principle and process yield is the primary measure of success. However, these indices are not taking into account the cost of failing to meet customers' requirements. A world-renown Japanese quality central expert, G. Taguchi, on the other hand, focus on the loss in a product's worth when one of its characteristics departs from the customers' ideal value T . To handle this situation, Hsiang and Taguchi (1985) introduced the index Cpm , independently proposed by Chan et al. (1988). The index is based on the idea of the squared error loss and it is sometimes called the Taguchi index. It concentrates on measuring the ability of the process to cluster around the target, which reflects the degrees of process targeting (centering). The index Cpm involves the variation of production items with respect to the target value and the specification limits that are preset in the factory. It is defined as:
67
68
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
Pm
USL - LSL ~ 6V<72 + (/* - Tf
_ USL -LSL ~ 6r
_ d "3r
(4J)
where as above USL — LSL is the allowable tolerance range of the process, d = (USL — LSL) / 2 is the half length of the specification interval, and r is a measure of the average product deviation from the target value T . The term r 2 = a2 + (fi - T)2 = E[(X — T)2] incorporates two variation components: (i) variation with respect to the process mean and (ii) deviation of the process mean from the target. Since E[(X — T)2] is the expected loss, where the loss of the characteristic X missing the target is often assumed to be well approximated by a symmetric squared error loss function, loss(X) = w(X — T)2 for some positive constant w, the capability index Cpm has been also referred to as a loss-based index. From the definition of Cpm , it is easy to note that if the process variance increases (decreases) then the denominator of Cpm will increase (decrease) and Cpm will decrease (increase). Also, if the process mean moves away from (towards to) the target value, then the denominator will increase (decrease) and Cpm will be decreased (increased). Evidently, Cpm adds an additional penalty for being off-target. It is often assumed that the target lies at the midpoint of the tolerance range (a symmetric tolerance). When this is not the case, there are serious disadvantages in the uncritical use of Cpm (the situation when T •*• m is sometimes called asymmetric tolerances). Note that Cpm differs from Cp , the first-generation index, only in the measure of the process variation. Simple algebra shows that: USL-LSL 2
Cv
6V^ + (^ - T)
2
^
+
(/£^T)2
69
The C„m Index
C.pk
1+
[i — m
h^>
For the symmetric case when T = m , Parlar and Wesolowsky (1998) have shown that Cp , Cpk and Cpm are related by the formula
( c„ CpJfc — Cp
c.pm J
-i-c,-|
H —m
or, equivalently,
Cp
c = pm
Jl + 9(Cp-Cpkf
Ramberg (2002) presents the relationship:
-P + Vi + P2cpm,
C,pk
where f3 =
ti-T
which is valid for T = m .
Also, it follows from the basic definitions, Cp >
max(Cpk,Cpm).
Boyles (1991) has provided a detailed analysis of Cpm and its usefulness in measuring process centering (targeting). He notes that both Cpk and Cpm coincide with Cp when n = T and decrease as /x moves away from T . However, Cpk < 0 for [i > USL or \i < LSL , whereas Cpm for a process with \n — T\> 0 is strictly bounded above by the Cp value of the process with a = |/z — T | . Namely, USL - LSL pm
<
6\fi-T\
(4.2)
70
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
The index Cpm approaches zero asymptotically as | \i — T \ tends to infinity. On the other hand, while Cpk = (d— | pL — m |)/(3cr) increases without bound for fixed fj, as a tends to zero, Cpm is bounded above by Cpm < d / ( 3 | / x — T\) . The right-hand side of above equation is the limiting value of Cpm as a tends to zero, and is equal to the Cp value of a process with a = \\i — T\. It follows from (4.2) that a necessary condition for Cpm > 1 is \fi-T\
H —m oC„
a
1+ M
i-^-mK/r+7< 3C
m
3C,
-lei
1 +
^
2
where as above £ =| yu — T \ / a Hence the relation Cpfc < C' pnmm is valid whenever 1 .... l t 2 ... . 2 I £1I > T T £ or | £ | < 3Cn 3C/" ' 2 Equivalently, whenever |/Li — m
2
k <
or Cn > 1 - ^ r r , where as above Ca = 1 9C 9Ci
C pm and percentage of non-conforming
(%NC)
-j—
71
The C„m Index
The motivation behind the index Cpm comes not from an examination of the percentage of NC product of a process, but rather from the process' ability to meet the target values. The Cpm index attempts to ignore conformance to specifications and refocuses on the optimal product's quality attained only when critical dimensions are conform the target. However, upper bounds on the number of NC pieces per lot can nevertheless be estimated for specific values of Cpm . Under the (common in practice) assumption that T = m , the definition of Cpm index (4.1) can be rewritten as a function of 7 = a / d and 6 = {JJL — m) / d to yield: Cpm
Zyju2 +(ji-
Hence, 7 2 =
-62
+6
+8
3C.pm
\d^pm)
3C.pm
mf
3C.pm
-6
3C,pm
3V~72 or
3C,pm
3C„pm
— \6
i.e., for 1-1/(3(7.pm 1 < ca < 1 holds for 0<|<5|<1/(3Cpmj Consequently, we have the following relationship between the exact expected proportion of nonconforming and the index Cpm and Ca for l-l/(3Cpm)
%NC
+
a $
a
2-C„ (3C p m )
2
(1-CJ2
(under the normal assumption)
c„
+$ (3Cpm) 2
(1 - Caf
72
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
Johnson and Kotz (1995) carried out further investigations to establish a more exact relationship between Cpm and percentage of NC. Assuming for convenience (without loss of generality) that USL + LSL = 0 , where in this case USL = -LSL = d = (USL — LSL) J 2, these authors found that the expected proportion of NC items associated with a given value of Cpm is %NC = $
—a — \i 2 2
UA -/i J
+ 1-$
V
{W^
where A = d(->pm
In fact, Ruczinski (1996) has shown that Yield > 2&(3Cpm) — 1 , or equivalently that the fraction of nonconformiting items %NC < 2$(—SCpm) . For example, if a process has capability with Cpm > 1.25 , then the production yield would be at least 99.9823%, or equivalently, the fraction of nonconformities no more than 0.0177%. For Cpm > 1 , the production yield would be at least 99.73%, or equivalently, the fraction of nonconformities will be no more than 0.27%. For larger values of Cpm , the expected proportion of nonconforming items is the largest when the process is centered, and moreover interpretations of % NC are applicable only when the target coincides with the midpoint of the specification interval. Loss Assurance based on Cpm If the loss at the specification limits (either USL or LSL) is AQ and the distance from the specification limits to the target T is USL — T = d (symmetric case), then the process loss at the specification limit. AQ = Loss(USL) = Loss(T ± d) = wd2 . Recall that the Loss(X) = WX(X- T)2 . Thus, we obtain that AQ /WT= d21 A 2 , and the expected relative loss Le can be rewritten as _ E[Loss(X)) _ E[Loss(X)] LP — A2
& ' •
( 4
'
3 )
73
The C„m Index
which provides a unitless measure of process performance in terms of lost value of the product (for industrial applications). Since the design of Cpm is based on the average process loss relative to the manufacturing tolerance, from the definition of expected relative squared loss in (4.3), the relationship between the expected relative squared loss and Cpm can be derived directly as
r
pm
2d
=
= I -*°-
6A JE[Loss{X)}
3WTLt
Thus, the expected relative squared losses Le based on the Cpm index can be rewritten as: Loss(Cvm) k
pm)
=
i
A) ^5—-
(4.4)
9WTC2pm
V
;
From the expected relative squared loss of Cpm expressed in (4.4), we note that Cpm is a larger-the-better index and hence, small values of Cpm may be contributed by high expected loss resulting in poorer process capability. Furthermore, Loss(Cpm) will be a constant AQ /{9WTClm) and is not affected by the values of Ca . Note that each newly proposed index is motivated by possible shortcomings of the precious ones, which for some reason is being objected by a number of prominent experts. (See e.g. Burke et at. (1991)) 4.2 Estimating and testing Cpm based on a single sample 4.2.1 Estimation
and distributional
properties
of
estimators
The index Cpm involves the unknown parameters n and a , which ought to be estimated from a sample. Chan et al. (1988)
74
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
(CCS) and Boyles (1991) propose respectively the following two estimators of Cpm: d Cpm — Cpm(cCS)
STCCS
d
ri ^ pm
r< ^pm(B)
3
(4.5) a
d o~
^EL(^- T ) 2 /n
(4.5) b
3V4 +(x- Tf '
where as above x = Y^._, x, / n ,s2 = /_). , (Xi — x)2 /{n — 1) and 5„ = 2__, . , (^ — z) / n — n"s • Assuming that the process measurements are normally distributed and that T = m , CCS (1988) derive the p.d.f. of the estimator Y = Cpm
fy(y) = n / 2 - y exp 2
+ A \y
«
V
A'(*)* + '' _ 1 T-,
y > o.
where a = C2pm(l + X/n)(n - 1) and A = n(/i - T)2 /a2 c.d.f. of Y — Cpm can be expressed as
. The
My) = i - expi-DE-nfr-y/o 2 " 2 it+"le_t *' y > °The reader familiar with non central x 2 distributions will recognize that Cpm given by (4.5)a can be shown to be a function of the inverse moments of a non-central chi-square distribution. An alternative, equivalent, formula is provided in Pearn et al.
75
The Cvm Index
(1992). The distributional properties of Cpm are quite complicated for asymmetrical specifications ( T ^ m ) and may serve as a challenging and revealing problem for our readers. When T — m , Cpm is a biased estimator of Cpm , but becomes asymptotically unbiased. Detailed descriptions and proofs of the properties of Cpm are provided in CCS (1988). Boyles (1991) is of the opinion that it would perhaps be more appropriate to replace the factor n — 1 by n in the denominator of (4.5)a since the expression appearing f| = si + (x — T)2 = (xi — T)2 / n whose expectation is
EL,(=
E[r%\ = ^+(p-
Tf
(4.6)
is the uniformly minimum variance unbiased estimator (UMVUE) of the term a2 + (/x — T)2 . In fact, the two estimators, Cpm and Cpm, are asymptotical equivalent. We note that x and s„ are the maximum likelihood estimators (MLEs) of ii and a2, respectively. Hence, the estimators Cpm is also the MLE of Cpm. It is therefore reasonable, for reliability purposes, to use the estimator Cpm = Cpm(B) for evaluation of the process performance. Under the normality assumption, Kotz and Johnson (1993) derived formulas for the r-th moment of Cpm , noting that for r > n , E(Cpm) is infinite. In particular, the first two moments, the mean, and the variance of Cpm are (see also Pearn, et al. (1992)): E{Cpm) =
Pexp(-A)f(i)i£ifiL±2} V 2 exp( ^ 3\ r ( t + J)
Cp
and Var(Cpm) = nC2p e x p ( - A ) ^ i i J ±^ j \ n + 2j 3=
[E(Cpm)f
76
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
Recall that the first generation index Cp = d /(3cr) and that A = n(/x — T)2 I a2 (the non-centrality or lack of "targetness"). Furthermore, Boyles (1991) proposes an accurate approximation of E(Cpm) and developes a normal approximation for n > 100 :
E{Cpm) —
n(n + A) 2(n + 2A)
(n-l+A) 2 + ( » - ! ) 2(n+2A)
r
r
(n+A) 2 2(n+2A)
c„
Consequently, Cpm is a biased estimator of Cpm and the bias of Cpm is positive in general since TB is negatively biased (cf. (4.6)). The bias of Cpm is given by Bias(Cpm) — E{Cpm) — Cpm — C,
M iW) r(f)
Readers familiar with the non-central \2 distribution will easily confirm that the quantity nr\ / a2 has the non-central chisquare distribution with n degrees of freedom and the noncentrality parameter A = n£2 , £ = (fi — T)/a. Boyles (1991) and Pearn et al. (1992) have shown that the distributed of Cpm is USL - LSI 6a
n Xn,A
= c,
Xn,A
which can alternatively be expressed as C, myjl Cpm ~ Cp
+
A / n n
(4.7)
\Xn,\
where, as above, Xn,\ denotes the non-central chi-square distribution with n degrees of freedom and the non-centrality parameter A = n£ 2 , £ = (\i — T )/a. Boyles (1991) also presents a moment approximation to the distribution of f| / r 2 in the form xl /v > where v =
77
The C n m Index
n(l + £ 2 ) 2 / ( l + 2£ 2 ). Numerical evidence on the adequacy of this approximation can be found in Patnaik (1949) and Tukey (1957). For large v , a related approximation based on the normal distribution: f B / r ~ N(l,(2v)~1) is quite appropriate. Vannman and Kotz (1995) derived the c.d.f. of a generalized process capability index: d — u\ C*p(u,v) =
3 ^
JJ,
— m\
V(H-TY
(to be discussed in a later chapter). The special case with u = 0 and v = 1 of an estimator of Cp(u,v) reduces to Boyles' (1991) estimator Cpm. The form for the c.d.f. of Y — Cpm given in Vannman and Kotz (1995) can be rewritten as: £ 2 /(93/ 2
L
My)
G
faWdt,
9y2
where D = nl'2d/a , G(-) is the c.d.f. of Xn-i > a chi-square random variable with n — 1 degrees of freedom, and fp(-) is the p.d.f. of a XI,A > a non-central chi-square variable with the noncentrality parameter A and 1 degree of freedom. Furthermore, by rewriting Cpm^ — D /(3JK + H) , where D = nll2d/a , K = ns2n /a2 ~ XLi , and H = n(x - T)2 / a 2 . Thus, the p.d.f. of Cpm that has been obtained by Chen et al. (1999) is: nl—n/2 r\n
fc„m(y)=
o»..n i Ty +
ex
P
(XD2) i=o
Uey2]
A 2
D:2
^
i8y"J
3\T\-
+j
, y > o,
78
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
which follows a non-central chi-square distribution with 1 degree of freedom and the non-centrality parameter X = 62 (Recall A = n(/j, - T)2 I a2). This formula is equivalent to the p.d.f. of Cpm presented in Vannman and Kotz (1995). We encourage the reader to compare the derivations of Chen et al. (1999) and that of Vannman and Kotz(1995). Adapting the integration technique presented in Vannman (1997), Pearn and Lin (2003) obtained an explicit form of the c.d.f. of the natural estimator Cpm , under the normality assumption. The c.d.f. of Cpm is expressed in terms of a mixture of the chi-square distributions and a standard normal distribution FA
(y) = 1 - I Jo
C VyJ
^
G
—5- - r {9y2
x[(j)(t + (^n) + (j)(t-^Vn)}dt,
(4.8)
for y > 0, where b = d/ a , and as above £ = (// — T) /a, G(-) is the c.d.f. of the chi-square distribution with degree of freedom n — 1, Xn-i J a n d >(•) is the p.d.f. of the standard normal variable iV(0,1). It is observed by Pearn and Lin (2003) that an identical equation is obtained if we replace £ by —£ in equation (4.8) for fixed values of x and n . An outline of the derivation can be found in Vannman and Kotz (1995).
4.2.2 Confidence
intervals
for Cpm
Several methods have been suggested in the literature for constructing approximate (lower) confidence bounds of Cpm . Marcucci and Beazley (1988) propose using the (ordinary) chisquare distribution to approximate the non-central chi-square distribution. This results in the following approximate lower confidence bound, denoted as Cp^B^:
The Cvm
79
Index
CLpmMB) = Cpm]xl{\
7)
, 0 < 7 < 1,
(4.9)
where Xn (1 — 7) i s the (1 — 7) th percentile of the ordinary central chi-square variable with n degrees of freedom. When the process is on-target (i.e. \i = T), this provides an exact confidence bound; otherwise the bound is conservative. Chan et al. (1990) derive a large sample normal approximation to the distribution of Cpm . The lower bound on CPm yields: CLP£XZ) = Cpm - zaam , where o\ = f | f *'(* ~ T) 2 + (a 4 /2) pm
pm
a m ,
™
\3J
l^
-T)2}
+(%
Moreover, Boyles (1991) used a moment approximation to a non-central chi-square distribution, Xn,x > to obtain an approximate lower confidence bound. It can be using the straight forward arguments shown using straightforward arguments that the distribution of
S2n+{x-Tf
f| 1S.
(T +((1-
T
2Z , ,
where
v =
7^I = —Z Z
T)
.
xl
approximately — , V
(l + 2£2)
Since Cpm/Cpm = TB / T , an approximate 100(7)% lower confidence bound for Cpm is given by Cpm^Xv (1 — l)/v • In practice, Boyles (1991) recommends to use the approximate lower Bo) confidence bound C£l of the form: 'pm C ^ S o ) = Cpm^'^
7)
,
(4.10)
80
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
where v = -^ ?-{- , and f = (l + 2£ 2 )
. sn
On the other hand, based on the expression (4.7), the 1007% lower confidence bound Cp^H^ is given as:
C^H)
= C^f^
(4-11)
(Zimmer and Hubele (1997)). Other approximating formulas have been developed for this confidence interval, such as for log(Cpm^B)) o r vC'pm(B) > e t c Subbaiah and Taam (1993) conducted a comparative Monte Carlo study of some of these functions. Zimmer and Hubele (1997) provide tables of exact percentiles for the sampling distribution of the estimator Cpm . Zimmer et al. (2001) proposed an useful graphical procedure to obtain exact confidence intervals for Cpm, where the parameter £ = (// — T) / a is assumed to be a known constant. It is noted that when (//— T) / a = 0 , the lower confidence bounds given by expression (4.11) (Zimmer et al. (2001)) are the same as the approximate lower confidence bounds obtained in equation (4.9) by Marcucci and Beazley (1988) and equation (4.10) by Boyles (1991). Kushler and Hurley (1992) compared several methods for computing lower confidence bounds for Cpm in terms of the miss rate (percentage) via simulations. Results indicate that Boyles' method maintains the nominal level. As for the consistently and quite closely Marcucci and Beazley method, it performs well provided \x is not too far from T . The method of Chan et al. (CXZ) results in a fairly stable performance but tends to be slightly "liberal" for small n . Overall, the Boyles approximation for a lower confidence bound on Cpm performs the best. As it was mentioned above, Lin and Pearn (2002) provided an explicit form for the c.d.f. of the maximal likelihood estimator
81
The Cvm Index
(MLE) of Cpm, which can be expressed in terms of a mixture of the chi-square and normal distributions. Noting that by setting Cpm = C , the term b = d / a can be expressed as b = SCyJl + £2 . We observe that the index Cpm can be expressed as a function of the parameter | = (/i — T)/a (a distributional characteristic): pm =
d
_
3W1 + e
=
d/a
_
b
Wi + e " 3>/i + e'
Consequently, given a sample of size n, a confidence level 7 , an estimated value, Cpm, and the parameter £, the lower confidence bounds (denoted CpmPS^) can be obtained by means of a numerical integration technique with iterations, and solving Equation (4.12) given below. In practice, the parameter £ is unknown, but it can easily be estimated from the sample data as £ = (x — T) / sn . It "regular type" should be noted that the l.h.s. of Equation (4.12) is an even function of £. Thus, for both £ = £0 and £ = — £0 we are to obtain the same lower confidence bound Cpm ' : ( b2n
rbSn/(3Cpm)
Jo
FK
2
^d^'
x[0(i + £Vn) + 0 ( i - £ > / n ) ] d i = l - 7 .
(4.12)
Lower confidence bound Cpm s> and the parameter £ Since the process parameters fi and a are unknown, so is the distribution characteristic parameter, £ = (^i —T)/CT which has to be estimated. In real world applications, £ has to be naturally estimated by replacing /J, and a by the sample mean x and the estimated sample standard deviation sn respectively. Such an approach evidently introduces additional sampling errors [from estimating £] in obtaining the lower confidence bounds, and thus would render this approach to be less reliable. Consequently, the conclusions deduced would result in a smaller production yield assurance to the factories, and also provide lesser quality
82
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
protection to the customers. To avoid the need for estimating the parameter £, Pearn and Shu (2003) examined the behavior of the lower confidence bounds C$£s' against the parameter £ , using the well known and time-honored approximation formula presented presented in Equation (4.13) which is due to Wilson and Hilferty (1931). This approximation of a x 2 variable by standard normal one is quite accurate for a wide range of percentile points even with sample sizes as small as 10:
X?(l-7) = v
V 9v
(4.13)
9v
here Z is the iV(0,1) and v is degrees of freedom of the chi-squire distribution. Substituting Equation (4.13) into (4.10), the approximate lower confidence bound suggested by Boyles (1991) can be obtained as 3/2 L
C
^(1-7)J
—C
2(1 + 2
S2 \ 2+ 1 -
9n(l + £
2 ( 1 +
^
9n(l + T•2\2 )
Define now the function /(s)
=
Cpm
z ( 1 _ 7 ) ,^a + 1 9n(l + r2 \)2
2(1 + 2£2 9n(l + C22\)2
3/2
whose first derivative is 2(1 + 2£2) 2(1 + 2£2) Z{1 - 7 ) + 1 9n(l + C2 \)2 9n(l + £ 2 ) 2
-i£3C
Z(l -
7)
2 v -1/2 2(1 + 2tj2^ )
{9n(l + e?
-1
1/2
The
CvrJl
Index:
S3
It is easy to verify that /'(0) = 0 , and that the second derivative /"(£) > 0 when either £ > 0 or £ < 0 , (an even function). Thus, the function /(£) takes its absolute minimum at £ = 0 . To demonstrate that this result is valid also for noncentral chi-square distributions, Pearn and Shu (2003) carried out extensive calculations and obtained the lower confidence bounds Cffs) for £ = 0(0.05)3.00, n = 10(5)200, Cpm = 0.7(0.1)3.0, and the confidence level 7 = 0.95. Note that the parameter values under investigation, [£ = 0(0.05)3.00], cover a quite wide range of applications involving process capability index Cpm > 0 . The results obtained indicate that (i) the lower confidence bound Cpm^ i s decreasing in £ , and increasing in n , (ii) the lower confidence bound C^s'1 attains its minimum value at £ = 0 (in all cases). Hence, in practice it is sufficient to solve Equation (4.12) for £ = 0 to achieve the required lower confidence bounds for given Cpm, n , and 7 , without estimating £. Adhering to this approach, the confidence level 7 will be ensured, and the decisions carried out based on such an approach would turned out to be more reliable. Unfortunately the cover age percentage using this method is not very clear and requires further investigation.
4.2.3 Sample
size determination
for Cpm
Sample size determination is an important step since it directly related to the cost of data collection plan. Thus, based on the several methods proposed above for computing the lower confidence bound on Cpm, approximate sample size required for a given estimation precision Rpm could be obtained in an alternative manner. Marcucci and Beazley (1988) suggested approximate formula for required sample size:
the
following
84
Encyclopedia
n
and Handbook
of Process
Capability
= X " f f ( (L ) 2 7 ) - w h e r e 4m B ) = ^LMB)/Cpm
Indices
.
(4.13)a
Based on the approximate lower confidence bound Cp4 So) proposed by Boyles (1991), an approximate sample size required for a given estimation precision Rffl can be obtained by solving for v , where
" -
r,(Bo)2 "pm
±l
•
Here analogously to R^B) we have Rpi°)2 = C^o)/6pm . Now the sample size n required with a given estimation precision RpmH^ can also be obtained using the formula: _ Xn,A(l-7) 71 =
z>{ZH)2 ^pm
^'
•L*"nrn.
where Rp^
=
C^/Cpm
Furthermore, using the lower confidence limit suggested by Boyles(1991), Franklin (1999) obtained the formula for determining sample size to estimate Cpm as:
" = »/,
, ^ 2
1
.
.o/, »
(4-14)
where zQ is the a percentile of JV(0,1). This formula involves the basic quantities and, in the sprit of the Hilferty and Wilson (1931) approximation, does not contain
The CDm Index
85
X2 variables. It is evident from the above that the sample size necessary to determine a desired lower confidence limit for Cpm depends on the ratio of Cpm / Cpm , and the characteristic of the process £ = QL* — T) j a. For example, if one requires a 95% lower confidence limit for Cpm to be 80% of the value of Cpm (i.e. Cpm/Cpm = 0.80), and £ = 0 then the sample size is determined (calculating using the formula (4.14)) to be 35. Note that the sample size is always rounded up to an integer since (at least) the desired ratio needed to be achieved. Additionally, Pearn and Shu (2003) have developed an efficient algorithm to compute lower confidence bounds to determine the sample sizes required for a specified precision of the estimation of Cpm . These authors also provided tables for the engineers/practitioners to be used in factory applications. Equation (4.12) can be rewritten as:
x [4>(t + £Jn) + c/)(t - £Jn)]dt
= 1- 7 .
(4.15)
Hence, given the desired estimation precision Rp^' , the confidence level y and the parameter £, the sample size n can be obtained by means of numerical integration technique with iterations, solving Equation (4.15). It should be noted, particularly, that the l.h.s. of (4.15) is an even function of £. Consequently, for both £ = £0 and £ = — £0 we shall obtain the same sample size n. In fact Franklin (1999) claims (perhaps without proper justification) that one can provide the largest sample size with £ = 0 , which coincides with the above results. We note that to maintain a confidence level of no less than 7 , the necessary sample size n , obtained using the approach described herein, cannot be reduced.
86
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
4.2.4 Hypothesis
testing
procedure
(using
Cpm )
To test whether a given process is capable, we may consider the following statistical testing hypotheses: HQ • Cpm < C (process is not capable), H\ : Cpm > C (process is capable). Based on a given a(c0) — a , the chance of incorrectly concluding an incapable process ( Cpm < C ) as a capable one ( Cpm > C )> the corresponding decision rule is to reject H$ ( Cpm < C ) if Cpm > c0 , and not to reject HQ otherwise. For processes with the target value located in the middle of the specification limits (T = m ) , which is a rather common situation, the index Cpm may be rewritten as: Cpm — 6/[3(1 +£ 2 ) 1//2 ] • Given Cpm = C , b — d / a can be expressed as b = 3C(1 + £ 2 ) 1 / 2 . Given a value of C (the capability requirement) r , c P (C pm > I Cpm = C) — a , the p-value corresponding to c (a specific value of Cpm calculated from the sample data) is: value = I Jo
6Vn/(3c*)„f b2n
G
(9(c)
,2
2
tz [)(t + £Vn) + (j){t - £~fn)]dt,
where G(-) is the c.d.f. of Xn-i - a n d >(•), as above, is the p.d.f. of the standard normal distribution. Given values of a and C , the critical value c0 can be obtained by solving the equation Pr(C' pm > c0 | Cpm = C) = a . Hence, given values of the capability requirement C , the parameter £ , the sample size n , and the risk a , the critical value c0 can be explicitly obtained by solving the equation: ^6Vn/(3co)
Jo
bjn__t2 [9c02
[cj)(t + £Vn) + cf>(t - £~Jn)}dt = a .
87
The C„m Index
Critical values are usually used for making decisions in capability testing with a designated type I error a (the risk of misjudging an incapable process (H0: Cpm < C) as a capable one ( # 1 : Cpm > C)). The p-values are used for making decisions in capability testing, which presents the actual risk of misjudging an incapable process ( H0 : Cpm < C ) as a capable one ( H^ : Cpm > C ) . Thus, if p-value < a then we reject the null hypothesis, and conclude that the process is capable with the actual type I error p-value (rather than a). Based on the c.d.f. of Cpm, Lin and Pearn (2002) implemented the statistical theory of the hypotheses testing, and developed a simple, but practical, procedure accompanied with conveniently tabulated critical values for engineers/practitioners to be used for decisions making in their factory applications.
4.3 Estimating and testing Cpm based on multiple samples Kirmani et al. (1991) indicate that a common practice of the process capability estimation in the manufacturing industry is to first implement a routine-basis data collection program for monitoring/controlling the process stability and then to analyze the past "in control" data. Thus, manufacturing information regarding a product quality characteristic is derived from multiple samples in this case, rather than being based on one single sample. Assuming that these samples are taken from the normal distribution N(/j,,a2) , we let xt and st denote the sample mean and the sample variance, respectively, of the ith sample and let N denote the total number of observations, i.e. ~Ylxv ' si I
1= 1
=
T^2(xv I
1= 1
- *i)2 ' and TV =
V j= l
Hi
88
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
As an estimator of fj, we shall use the overall sample mean, which is an unbiased estimator, i.e.: _
1
Hi
£=z= - J ^ A pooled variance estimator defined as
*2 = s? =N:i F, l > - i t f is used as the estimator of a2. For the cases with multiple samples several estimators of Cpm are avaiable as shown below (see Zhang (2001), Vannman and Hubele (2003), and Pearn and Shu (2003)): M c* ^ pm
(N
USL -LSL \2 -l)S2p + 7V(f- T)
JV " 6
c^ Mpm -
N
USL- -LSL
rii-iysj + Nfi -T)
JE> 6 V fiM
_
\2
N USL- -LSL
When all subsamples have the same size n , we have N = mn , p, = x = ^ . _ x"j / m and S2. = ^ . _ Sf / m . If the process follows the normal distributionN(fi,a) then
89
The Cvm Index
CM = -J~N v
^ pm
•"
USL - LSI 6a
NSl
+
N(X -
M)
2
a
, N(fi - T)
-1/2
+
The 7VS2 / a2 and JV(X - n) / a2 are distributed as the central chi-square distribution with N — m and one degree of freedom, XN-m a n d Xi > respectively. Therefore, N pm
~
6a
N
= C.
XN-m+1, A
V XN-m+l, A
where x%,\ denotes the non-central chi-square distribution with TV degrees of freedom and the non-centrality parameter A — JV[(/x — T)/af . The r-th moment (about zero) can be obtained to be: E{Cfmy
=
(^NCprE(xN-m+i,xT
(JNCA
(A/2) J
~7T
exp
]
j
j=0
72
r((2j + N-m X
T((2j + N-m
+
l-r)/2)
+ l)/2)
The p.d.f. of the natural estimator of Cpm can easily be attained as follows: 2(l-N")/2(jl{N"+l) /(*)
3(JV*+1)^+2)
xexp
A 2
C"2 18x2
E
Jj=0
AC/2 36x
2
j!r
AT*+l + 2j)
, x > 0.
Hence (7' = 3>/¥C p , and N - m = N*. Using the method similar to one presented in Vannman (1997), we could obtain an exact form of the c.d.f. of Cp^ . As
90
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
above, the c.d.f. of C^ can be expressed in terms of a mixture of a central chi-square distribution and the standard normal distribution: •»6VJV/(3a;) G
F6,m(x) = 1 - JQ
b2N
{^-
*2 p ( * + ^ ) +
where as above b = d /a , £ = (/i — T)/ a , G(-) is the c.d.f. of the central chi-square distribution xli-m w^ith TV — m degrees of freedom, and >(•) is the p.d.f. of the standard normal variable N(0,1). Consequently, the critical values, lower confidence bounds, sample size determination, and the manufacturing capability calculations can be performed here using the same technique as for cases with one single sample. The distribution of Cfm (with variable sample size) can easily be derived once the distribution of C^m (with fixed sample size) is determined due to a simple relationship between them (see Vannman and Hubele (2003)). We note that for cases with one single sample, m = 1 , which is a special case of multiple samples, statistical properties of estimator of Cpm , proposed over the last 14 years by Chan et al. (1988), Boyles (1991), Pearn et al. (1992), Kotz and Johnson (1993), Vannman and Kotz (1995), Vannman (1997) and Lin and Pearn (2002), were intensively investigated.
4.4 The Bayesian approach to Cpm For a single sample, Boyles (1991) has shown that f2 = si + (x — T)2 is an unbiased estimator of a2 + (/x — T)2 . Motivated by this result, for the cases where the data are collected as multiple samples, Wu and Pearn (2003) consider m samples, each of size n.^ and recommend the following estimator of Cpm :
The Cvm
91
Index
EE^-?1)2 T12
r* -
= i=l i = l
(4.16)
m
»=1
where xt is the i-th sample mean, and st is the i-th sample standard deviation. By taking the expectation of the numerator of f'2, Wu and Pearn (2003) obtain m
= £
E
Z v L^i
+ £
Xi
J
-2T
ni
\
xE Zv Z^ ^y
EE^2
= £ > (M2 + a2) - 2T x ]>> iM + ^ T i=l m
i=l
2
»=i
= ^ns[a2+(M-r)2]. i=l
Hence, the estimator f'2 satisfying E(T'2 ) = a 2 + (fi — T)2 is a unbiased estimator of a2 + (fj, — T)2 . However, for multiple control samples, we also need to consider variations between multiple control samples. For this purpose Wu and Pearn (2003) define the ratio of the total within the sample variation (SSW) and the total sum of squares variation (SST ) as:
ssw_V^{Xl3
7 = SST
m
Xl
m
EE(^ - f ) 2 8= 1 j = l
92
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
(4.17) n x
x
E f a - 1)4 + J2 i( i ~ f i=l
i=l
where s^ = E j = i (n^ — l)s| / E™-i (n^ — 1) is the pooled variance of the samples. The total sample variation about the target value T can be decomposed as:
EEto - T? = EE(^ - ^)2 + EE(^ - *? i=l
j=l j = l m ni
j—\
i—\
j=l
+ EE(^)2 j= l j = l
= £(»*- l)*2 + i - ^ f a - ^ + E ^ P ' i
m
m
- ^ ( n ? - l ) + ^n l ( 5 2 s„ , and o = J 2
I
c
•£
-*
Thus, the sample counterpart of Cpm for multiple samples, defined in (4.15), can be rewritten as: Clm =
d
,m
•
(4-18)
E^-1) oSp
»=1
iEn» !=1
For a single sample, (m = 1, 7 = 1, and s p = s) the estimator of Cpm i Cpm = d/(3syl(n — l ) / n + <52), which can be reduced to the estimator Cpm as defined in Boyles (1991).
93
The Cvm Index
A Bayesian procedure for assessing process capability was originally proposed in Cheng and Spiring (1989) for the basic, primitive index Cp under the assumption that the process mean \x equals to the target value T . However, this restriction (fi = T) turns out not to be a practical assumption for many industrial applications. Shiau et al. (1999) proposed a Bayesian procedure for the general situation with no restriction on the process mean. But, their proposal work focused on cases with a single sample. A common practice of process capability estimation in the manufacturing industry is first to implement a daily-based or weekly-based sample data collection plans for monitoring/ controlling the process stability, and next to analyze the past "in control" data. Along these lines, Wu and Pearn (2003) developed a Bayesian approach for assessing process capability in cases with multiple samples. As we have already pointed out, it is natural to consider the quantity p = Pr{process is capable | x} when applying the Bayesian approach. In the case of using the Cpm index we are required to determine the posterior probability p = Pr{C pm > u> | x} for some fixed positive number u> . Therefore, given a pre-specified precision level UJ > 0 , the posterior probability (based on the index Cpm) that a process is capable is given by the following expression (Wu and Pearn (2003)): t
P
/
i
o T(a)y T(a)va+1
exp
x[$(h(y) + h(y)) -$(h(y) - Uv))]dy,
(4.19)
where as above $(•) is the c.d.f. of the standard normal distribution, and 7 and 6 are as defined in (4.16) and (4.17).
Here the upper limit t =
1
Efa) »=1
apm
1 Efa) !=1
E n,8= 1
+ 7<S2
94
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices m
27 E n * W(y) =
i=l
1
6,
|E(^-i>/ and
62(2/) =
't_
1/2
,y
Note that the posterior probability p depends on m , n,, 7 , w and C pm only via m , n,, 7 , 5 and (7pm / a; (see expression for t above). The quantity Cpm / UJ is often denoted by C . Expression (4.19) seems to be computationally cumbersome without some advanced computer programming skills. However, by noticing that there is a one-to-one correspondence between p and C for given m and n ; , and observing that 7 , 6 and Cpm (defined in equation (4.18)) can be calculated from the process data, we find that the minimum value of C necessary to ensure that the posterior probability p reaches a certain desirable level, can be useful for assessing the process capability. This minimum value is denoted by C (p). Thus, this value C (p) satisfies Pr{Cpm > u I x} = Pr{C pm >
apm C\p)
x}
For a single sample, the estimator of C.pm 'pm d/(3sy](n-l)/n + 52) , which can be reduced to the estimator Cpm defined in Boyles (1991) and the posterior probability (based on the index Cpm) that a process is capable is equivalent to one proposed by Shiau et al. (1999). * - " ' T17TJ
Chapter 5
The Loss Indices
5.1 Process loss and the Le index 5.2 Estimation of Lpe, Lot, and Le 5.3 Upper confidence bounds on Lpe, Lot, and Le 5.4 Testing process capability based on the process loss 5.1 Process loss and the Le index One of the most commonly understood basic primitive criterion for interpretation of the process capability is the so-called yield index, which is simply defined as the proportion of conforming items. However, the yield measure does not distinguish among the product that fall inside of the specification limits. To remedy this situation, a quadratic loss function is usually employed to distinguish between the products that fall inside of the specification limits by increasing "the penalty" as the departure from the target value increases. Hsiang and Taguchi (1985) were the first to introduce the loss function approach to quality improvement focussing on the reduction of variation around the target value. However, a quadratic loss function by itself does not provide a comparison with the specification limits and also depends on the unit of the characteristic involved. To address these issues, Johnson (1992) proposed the concept of relative expected squared error loss Le for symmetrical cases, by approaching capability in terms of loss functions. Actually, here
95
96
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
the opposite concept of worth is used. It was postulated that a characteristic achieves its maximal worth WT , when X = T , following by decreasing values of the worth as X moves away from the target value T (eventually the worth becomes zero, and then negative). The worth function can be described by WT - k(X - Tf , for WT > k(X - Tf , and becomes zero when | X-T | = (WT/kf/2 . Johnson (1992) viewed the pair (T + (WT /k)1'2, T-{WT/k)ll2) as specification limits for Cpm and defined A = (WT / kf/2 . The ratio of the worth (WT) to maximum worth is called the relative worth and can be expressed as:
w{x) = i - « x - r ' 2 = i WT
<*-2r > 2 A
'
where {X — T)2 / A 2 is the relative loss. The expected relative loss, Le = E[(X — T)2]/ A 2 , is now used to quantify capability. Effectively it is equivalent to Cpm, since Le — \TT) /Cpm • Suppose the product has zero worth outside the specifications by setting A = (USL — LSL) / 2 = d , the index Le is then defined as the ratio of the expected quadratic loss and the square of the half specification width as follows:
=L
(x - Tf d2
iF(l)
=
'-^Zll
where as above fi is the process mean, a is the process standard deviation, d = (USL — LSL) / 2 is the half specification width, USL and LSL are the upper and the lower specification limits, and T is the target value. This measure has a direct relationship with Cpm in view of Le = (3Cpm)~2 . Furthermore, defining
The Loss Index
97
Lpe =(a/ df and Lot = [(fi - T) / df , then Le can be expressed as Le = Lpe + Lot . Tsui (1997) interprets Le = Lpe + Lot , as providing an uncontaminated separation between the information concerning the potential relative expected loss ( Lpe ) and the relative off-target squared deviation (Lot). Since Lpe measures the process variation a relative to the specification tolerance ( d ) , it has been referred to as the potential relative expected loss index. On the other hand, Lot measures the relative process departure from the target value and has been referred to as the relative offtarget squared index. We note that the mathematical relationships Le = (3C p m )- 2 , Lpe = (SCpy2, and Lol = (1 - Caf can easily be established, where Cpm , Cp and Ca are the three basic process capability indices introduced by Chan et al. (1988), Kane (1986) and Peran et al. (1998), respectively. The advantage of using Le over Cpm is that the estimator of the former possesses superior statistical properties than that of the latter, as the former index does not involve a reciprocal transformation of the process mean and variance. It also provides an uncontaminated separation between the information concerning the process "precision" and process "accuracy". Process "precision" relates to product variation (uniformity). Process "accuracy" relates to the degree of process targeting (or centering). This separation provides a direction the practitioners may be considered to choose related to the process parameters in order to improve on the process quality. Some commonly used values of Le are, 1.00 (the process is incapable), 0.44 (the process is incapable), 0.11 (the process is referred as capable), 0.06 (the process is called satisfactory), 0.05 (process is classified as good), 0.04 (process is usually viewed as excellent), and 0.03 (the process is designated as super). The corresponding Cpm values are listed in Table 5.1.
98
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices Table 5.1. Some commonly used Le and equivalent Cpm . Condition
4
Incapable
1.00
n 0.33
Incapable
0.44
0.50
Capable
0.11
1.00
Satisfactory
0.06
1.33
Good
0.05
1.50
Excellent
0.04
1.67
Super
0.03
2.00
The sub-index Lot measures the relative process departure, from the target value which has already been referred to as the relative off-target loss index. In turn, the sub-index Lpe measures process variation relative to the specification tolerance, which is sometimes referred to as the relative inconsistency loss index. Note that some commonly used values of Lpe, 0.11, 0.06, 0.05, 0.04 and 0.03, are equivalent to the Cp values = 1.00, 1.33, 1.50, 1.67, and 2.00, respectively, which covers a great variety of the precision requirements that are used in the majority of real-world applications. 5.2 Estimation of Lpe, Lot, and Le 5.2.1 Estimating
the process
relative
inconsistency
loss, Lpe
To estimate the process relative inconsistency loss, a natural estimator Lpe can be suggested: f
— ^ ~n-l{r(
pe
y ^ (Xj — X) _ Sn_i d2 ~ d2 '
is t h e Here 5B_i = E " = i ( * * _ *? ^n ~~ ^ "convention^" estimator of the process standard deviation a. The estimator Lpe can be rewritten as:
99
The Loss Index j pe
_ Lpe (n — l)Lpe _ Lpe y ^ (Xj — X) ~ n- 1 Lpe ~ n-lf^ a2
(5.1)
For a process following the normal distribution, Pearn et al. (2003) have shown that the natural estimator Lpe is distributed according to the distribution [Lpe /{n — l)]x^_i, where Xn-i i s a s above a chi-squared distribution with n — 1 degrees of freedom. The p.d.f. of Lpe can be derived as (n — l)x /(*) = 2L.pe xexp
(n-l)/2
—(n — l)x n-1 xT 2L,'pe
, for x > 0 .
The r-th moment, the expected value, the variance, and the mean squared error of Lpe are straightforwardly obtained as follows (recalling the mean value and the variance of the Xn distribution),
E(4e)r = Hence
E
(
Var(Zpe) =
T Ltnf,
n-1
(£pe) =
r{[(n-l)/2] + r} ( ^Lpe \ n-1
T[(n-l)/2]
( L,pe E(x„-i) = Lpe, n-1
"\2
V a r ( x ^ i ) = 2(n - 1)
•'pe
n-1
2IJ. pe n-1
(5.2)
and MSE(Lpe) = E(Lpe - Lpef=Vav(Lpe)
+ [E(Lpe) - Lpef |2 = _
?r2 Llj
pe
n-1
Pearn et al. (2003) has shown that the natural estimator Lpe is the uniformly minimum variance unbiased estimator (UMVUE)
100
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
of Lpe , which is also consistent, and asymptotically efficient. Moreover ~fn(Lpe — Lpe) converges to N(0,2I?pe) in distribution. Thus, in real-world applications, using Lpe having all the desired statistical properties as an estimate of Lpe , should be quite appropriate. We note that by multiplying the UMVUE Lpe by the constant cn — (n — 1) / n , one obtains the maximum likelihood estimate (MLE) of Lpe. Pearn et al. (2003) has shown that the MLE Lpe is consistent, asymptotically unbiased and efficient, and that the statistic Vn(Z pe — Lpe) converges to N(0,2I?pe) in distribution. Since cn < 1 , then Lpe = cnLpe underestimate Lpe but with smaller variance. In fact, the mean square error of Lpe can be calculated as MSE(Lpe) — [(2n — 1) / n2 ]I?pe and MSE(Zpe) - MSE(I P e) = {(3n - l)/[n 2 (n - l)]}L2pe > 0 for all sample sizes n . Thus, the MLE Lpe has smaller mean squared error than the UMVUE Lpe , and consequently is more reliable, particularly by short production run applications (such as accepting a supplier which provides short production runs in QS9000 certification). To summarize, for short run applications (with n < 35 ) we recommend using the MLE Lpe rather than the UMVUE Lpe . For applications with sample sizes n > 35 , the difference between the two estimators is quite negligible (less than 0.52%). The square root of the relative mean squared error is a direct measurement which provides the expected relative error of estimation from the true value Lpe . For the UMVUE Lpe , [MSE R (Z pe )]^ = [2/(n-l)f2, and is a function of the sample size n only. Therefore, [MSE R (Z pe )]^ values are identical for all the Lpe values. For example, with n = 300 we have [MSER(jLpe)]^ = 0.0818. Thus, for n = 300 , one can expect that the average error of Lpe would be not greater than 8.18% of the true value Lpe. For the MLE Lpe , [MSE R (4e)]^ = [(2n - l)/n2f which is also a
101
The Loss Index
function of the sample size n only. Consequently, [MSE R (L pe )]^ values are also the same for all Lpe values. 5.2.2 Estimation
of a process relative the off-target
the
loss, Lot
To estimate the relative off-target loss, we consider the natural estimator Lot defined as follows: , Lot
(X - Tf ~ d*
where X — jT] _i %i In 1S the conventional estimator of the process mean /j, . The estimator Lot can be also written as a function of Lpe: ^
=
Lpe nlot ^ Lpe n(X - T) 2 JX
Liftp -'pe
fl
For a normally distributed process characteristic, Pearn et al. (2003) have shown that the estimator Lot is distributed according to the distribution [Lpe / n] Xi (<5) , where Xi (<5) i s the non-central chi-squared distribution with one degree of freedom and the noncentrality parameter 6 = n(n — T) 2 /'a 2 = nLot /Lpe . Therefore, the p.d.f. of Lot can be expressed as:
<7(z) = £
nx)/(2Lpe)f+i exp[-(nx)/(2Lpe)} xT(k + 1)
(8/2)k exp(-<5/2) T(k + 1)
for x > 0. (cf. the p.d.f. of a Xi(^) variable) The r-th moment, the expected value, the variance, and the mean squared error of Lot, can therefore be calculated as:
102
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
E(Loty=i^\rE[xU6)r 2Lot V T(k + ± + r)
E
n I
fc=0
E(Lot)
ri
Vax(Z ot ) =
T(k + ±) '
r(fc + l)
f) E ^i = (¥)<1+« = ¥ + L-
fi»,i
Var[Xl2(«5)]
n ^LpeLot n
and
(6/2fexp(-6/2)
+
=
n
(2 + 46)
2D.pe
MSE(Lot) = Var(L ot ) + [E(Lot)
(5.4)
Lot? =
^LpeLpt
3-Lpe I
1
n
n Since Lpe is a function of Sn-i only (e./. (5.1)), and Lot is a function of X only ((5.2)), then the two estimators Lpe and Lot are statistically independent under the normality assumption. Because X is the MLE of \i, by the invariance property of MLE, the natural estimator Lot is the MLE of Lot . Noting that E(4rf) = Kt +(LPeln) , and E(Lpe) = Lpe , the corrected estimator Lot = Lot — (Lpe / n) should be unbiased for Lot . Pearn et al. (2003) have also shown that Lot is an UMVUE of Lot, being consistent and asymptotically efficient, and moreover Vn(Lol — Lot) converges to N(0,4LpeLot) in distribution. Thus, analogously to Lpe in real-world applications using the UMVUE Lot, which has all the desired statistical properties, as an estimate of Lot would be suitable. The MLE Lot has a smaller variance than the UMVUE Lot as it follows by comparing (5.3) and (5.4). However, it can be shown that MSE(Z oi ) = ALFeLot /n + {2/[n(n - l)]}(Lpe)2 , and thus the MSE(Lot) - MSE(Lot) = {(3 - n)/[n2(n - l)}}(Lpe)2 , which is greater than 0 for n = 2, equals 0 for n = 3 , and is less
103
The Loss Index
than 0 for n > 4 . It means that the UMVUE Lot has a smaller mean squared error than the MLE Lot , and is more reliable for applications with n > 4 , provided, of course, the normality and other "standard" assumption are satisfied. Observe that for n < 30 , the discrepancy between the two relative errors (percentage of deviations) is significant, and hence we would recommend using the UMVUE Lot instead of MLE Lot . For n > 30 , the difference between the two estimators is negligible (being less than 0.04%), and using either one of them is equally reliable for practical purpose.
5.2.3 Estimation
of process
expected
relative
loss, Le
To estimate the process expected relative loss (the combined measure of process relative inconsistency loss and process relative off-target loss), the natural estimator Le is defined as follows: f
X)2
l f ( I , - Tf J f f t nfr(
where X = Y^i=iXi
2
d
nfrt
2
d
(X - Tf +
d2
I'l
The estimator Le can be also written as a function of Lpe: LpenLe _ Lp " n Lpe n -r^i
(Xx-T)2 a2
If the process characteristic is normally distributed, the estimator Le possesses the distribution [Lpe / n] Xn (<5)) where Xn (<5) is above a non-central chi-squared distribution with n degrees of freedom and the non-centrality parameter 8 = n(n — T)2 / a2 = nLot I Lpe. Therefore, the p.d.f. of Le can be expressed as:
104
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
fc=0
[(nx)/(2Lpe)k+("^}exp[(-nx)/(2Lpe] xY(k + {n/2))
(8 J 2)k exp(-<5 / 2)
r(fc + 1)
, for x > 0
(Recall the p.d.f. of a Xn(6) random variable). Analogously to the Section 5.2.2 the r-th moment, the expected value, the variance, and the mean squared error of Le can be evaluated to be: ( LT
E(4)r =
V
pe
=E
fc=0
E(4) =
Var(4) =
(L.pe n (L.pe
nxi(6)r (2Lpe)rF(k
n J
+ % + r)
T(A; + f)
nxim =(L,n
pe
Var[X^)] =
{8/2)kexp(-6/2)
r(fc + i)
(n+6) = Lpe + Lot = Le,
(L.pe n
or
(2n + 46) =
2L„ and MSE(4) = V a r ( 4 ) + [E(4) - Lef = —^-{Kt
n
-^(Lot+Le), + 4) •
(under the normality assumption) Under this assumption, Pearn et al. (2003) have shown that Le is the MLE, and also the UMVUE of Le . As above the estimator Le is consistent, asymptotically efficient, and the statistic -Jn(Le — Le) converges to N(0,2LpeLot + 2LpeLe) in distribution. In view of all these attractive properties, in practice using Le to estimate the process expected relative loss should be quite appropriate.
105
The Loss Index
5.3 Upper confidence bounds on lipei li0ti and Le We shall now introduce the upper confidence bounds (UCBs) of the three process loss indices Lpe , Lot , and Le , respectively, described above. Evidently f
1 A ( I , - Tf _ l f ( I , - X)2
e
~n{^
2
I
~ n ^
2
J
+
(X - Tf 2
d
f
~^
+
f
^'
where as indicated above Lpe = S2 / d2 and Lot = (X — T)2 / d are the MLE of Lpe and Lot , respectively._ Estimating the unknown parameters mean \i by sample mean, X = z2_-,Xi In > 2 2 n X X n whic and the variance a by S n = Y^ i=i( i - f l \ > is l h e maximum likelihood estimator, the relationship Le = Lpe + Lot can easily be established. This expression provides an uncontaminated separation between the calculated information about the process relative inconsistency loss (L pe ) and the process relative off-target loss (Lot). Below, we shall use the estimators ( Lpe (MLE), Lot (MLE) and Le (MLE and also UMVUE)) to construct upper confidence bounds on Lpe Lot, Le, respectively. 5.3.1 An upper confidence
bound on
Lpe
Under the normality assumption, nLpe / Lpe is distributed as xl-i, a chi-squared variable with n — 1 degrees of freedom. Let Upe = Upe(Xi,X2,---,Xn) be a statistic, calculated from the sample data, satisfying ~P{Lpe < Upe) = 1 — a , where the confidence level 1 — a does not depend on Lpe . The Upe is an 100(1 — a)% upper confidence bound on Lpe. Also: P(£ pe < Upe) = F{nLpe/Lpe
>
nLpe/Upe)
= P(Xn-i > nLpe/Upe)
= 1 - a.
Thus, the quantity nLpe/Upe = Xn-i(cx) > where x L i ( « ) is the (lower) a t h percentile of the Xn-i distribution with n — 1
106
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
degrees of freedom. A 100(1 — a ) % upper confidence bound on Lpe can explicitly be expressed, in terms of Lpe, as: Upe
= (nLpe)/
5.3.2 An upper confidence
?&-i(ot).
bound on Lot
Under the normality assumption, nLot / Lpe is distributed as Xi(<5) , a non-central chi-squared variable with one degree of freedom and the non-centrality parameter 6 = n(/z — T) 2 / a2. Let U0t — Uot(Xl,X2,...,Xn) be a statistic calculated from the sample data satisfying P(Lot < Uot) = 1 — a , where as above the confidence level 1 — a does not depend on Lot . Then, Uot is an 100(1 — a)% upper confidence bound on Lot and moreover: P ( 4 t
6Lot/Uot)
= P(xUS)>SLot/Uot)
= l-a.
Consequently under the normality assumption, an 100(1 — a)% upper confidence bound on Lot can be expressed in terms of the estimator Lot as Uot =
6Lot/x}(a,6).
where xi(ai$) i s * n e (lower) a t h percentile of the Xi(^) distribution. Now capability testing can be conducted. In practice, however, the parameter 6 is usually unknown and should be estimated from the sample data. 5.3.3 An upper confidence
bound on Le
Under the normality assumption, (n + S)Le / Le is distributed as x\ (<5)) a non-central chi-squared distribution with n degrees of
107
The Loss Index
freedom and the non-centrality parameter 6 = n(/x — T)2 / a2 = nLot J Lpe . Analogously to the previous cases, let Ue = Ue(Xi,X2,...,Xn) be a statistic calculated from the sample data satisfying P(Le < Ue) = 1 — a , where the confidence level 1 — a does not depend on Le. The statistic Ue is then an 100(1 - a)% upper confidence bound on Le. Also note that P ( 4 < Ue) = P((n + 6)LjLt
>{n +
6)Le/Ue)
= P(->&(6)>(n + 6)Le/Ue) = l - a . Consequently, (n + S)Le / Ue = Xn(a^) > where Xn(a><5) is the (lower) ath. percentile of the Xn(^) distribution. An 100(1 — a) % upper confidence limit on Le can now be expressed, in terms of Le, as Ue =(n +
8)Le/xl(a,6).
5.4 Testing process capability based on the process loss It is becoming increasingly common in industry to require a supplier to demonstrate process capability as an integral part of the contractual agreement between the vendor and consumer. Suppose a customer informed his/her supplier that, in order to qualify for business with his/her company, the supplier ought to demonstrate that the process capability Le of producing the required items is less than C (a pre-assigned constant). This problem may be formulated as a hypothesis testing problem: Ho '• Le > C (incapable), Hi : Le < C (capable).
108
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
In statistical hypothesis testing a rejection of HQ is usually a severe conclusion. The supplier would of course, be interested to reject H0 , thereby demonstrating that his process is capable. Moreover, he/she desires to assure that if the process capability is below C the process will be judged as capable with a high probability (say, 0.95). Taking a random sample of size n , calculating the value of Le, we want to claim that the process is capable for at least 100(1 — a)% of the time as long as Le < c0 (a critical value). Pearn et al. (2003) have shown that the critical value is c0 = [xl(a,6) • C]/(n + 6) , where C is the preset capability requirement. In other words, c0 = [Xn(a, <5) • C]/(n + 6) is the maximum value of the estimated expected relative loss Le so that the process will be considered capable at least 1 0 0 ( 1 - a ) % of the time. Denoting (as above) £ = (/i — T) / a , we arrive at 6 = n(/x — T) 2 / a2 = n£ 2 . The formula for calculating the critical value c0 can now be written as c0 = [xl(ain£2) • C]/[n(l + £ 2 )], which is quite easy to interpret and is straightforward to apply. Unfortunately, since the process measurements /x and a are to be estimated from the sampled data (to obtain the characteristic parameter £), a great degree of uncertainty could be introduced to the capability assessments due to the inevitable sampling errors. Johnson (1992) suggests to estimate the parameters \i and a by X and Sn , respectively, to obtain upper confidence limit [(n + n£ 2 )/Xn( a ' n £ 2 )]-4 (which is easy to see to be equivalent to our expression U = Lot + [nLe / Xn(a^)]) f° r Le (see 5.3.2 and 5.3.3). If the estimated value Le is less than the critical value c 0 , we conclude that the process meets the preset capability requirement. Such an approach, of course, introduces additional sampling errors due to estimating £ , rendering it to be less reliable. Consequently, any decisions carried out in these situations would provide a lesser quality assurance to customers. To assess the need for additional estimation of the characteristic parameter £ = (JJ, — T) / a , we should examine the
109
The Loss Index
behavior of the critical value c0 versus the parameter £ . The results show that the critical value c0 is an increasing function of £ and reaches its minimum at £ = 0 (i.e. for /i = T ) in all the cases. Hence, for practical purposes we may calculate the critical value CQ by setting | = £ = 0 for given values of Le, n, and 7 , without the need to estimate the parameter £ further. Using such an approach, the 7 confidence level is ensured and the decisions become more reliable. Furthermore, for testing the hypothesis about Le , H0 : Le > C (incapable) versus H^ : Le < C (capable) where C is a pre-assigned value, one can define a classical test as
2%
L'J
X
where as above /. (x,Le) is the likelihood function and L' is another parameter. Since for Le > Le > 0 , the ratio X(x) is an increasing function of x , {/. (x,Le) \ Le > 0} has the monotone likelihood ratio (MLR) property in Le . Therefore, the test 0* ought to be the UMP test.
Chapter 6
The Cpmk Index
6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4
Process capability and the Cpmk index Estimating and testing Cpmk based on a single sample Estimating and testing Cpmk based on multiple samples Bayesian-like estimation of Cpmk
6.1 Process capability and the Cpmk index In t h e previous Chapters we have concentrated on t h e three basic indices Cp , Cpk and Cpm . T h e indices are interrelated but each one h a s it specific properties. Under t h e normal assumption the distributional properties of estimators of this indices are established without great difficulties and we have by now rather a complete picture of their properties. P e a r n et al. (1992) proposed the process capability index Cpmk , which combines t h e merits of three earlier indices. T h e index Cpmk alerts t h e user when t h e process variance increases and t h e process mean deviates from its target value (or both). T h e index Cpmk, sometimes referred to as the "third-generation capability index", has been defined as follows: USLCpmk = m i n
n
2
n-LSL 2
3V<x + (/x - Tf ' 3Va + (M - T) 2
110
The Cpmk Index
f-\»2
m
\
3V<x + (/x - T )
111
,
(6.1)
2
where as above C/5L and LSL are the upper and the lower specification limits, respectively, \i is the process mean and u is the process standard deviation, T is the target value, d = (USL — LSL) / 2 is the half length of the specification interval, m = (USL + LSL) / 2 is the mid-point between the lower and the upper specification limits. Comparing the pair of indices (Cpmk,Cpm) , similarly to (Cpk, Cp) , we have the relation Cpmk = Cpm x Ca and hence Cpmk — (Cpm x Cpk) JCp (recall Ca ). Furthermore, Vannman (1995) proposed a superstructure Cp(u,v) of capability indices for processes with normal distributions (to be discussed below), which include Cp , Cpk , Cpm and Cpmk as particular cases. By setting u, v = 0 and 1, we obtain the four indices, Cp(0,0) = Cp , Cp(l,0) = Cpk , Cp(0,l) = Cpm , and Cp(l,l) = Cpmk . Those indices are effective tools for process capability analysis and quality assurance. Two basic process characteristics the process location in relation to its target value, and the process spread (overall process variation) are used to establish the formula of these capability indices. The main tenehe of these constructions is the following observations: The closer the process output is to the target value and the smaller the process spread, the more capable is the process. Namely, the larger the value of a process capability index, the more capable is the process. The index Cpmk has been constructed (Pearn et al. (1992)) by appropriately combining the yield-based index Cpk and the lossbased index Cpm , accounting for the process yield (meeting the manufacturing specifications) as well as the process loss (variation from the target) (see Figure 6.1 and Figure 6.2). When the process mean n departs from the target value T, the reduction in the value of Cpmk is more substantial than the decrease in Cp , Cpk ,
112
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
and Cpm . Hence, the index Cpmk responds to the departure of the process mean [i from the target value T than the other three basic indices Cp , Cpk , and Cpm , more rapidly while remaining sensitive to the changes of process variation. We note that a process meeting the capability requirement " Cpk > C " for a preassigned C may not meet the capability requirement " Cpm > C ". On the other hand, a process that meets the capability requirement " Cpm > C " may not be meeting the capability requirement " Cpk > C " either. This discrepancy between the two indices may be due to the fact that the Cpk index primarily measures the process yield, while the index Cpm focuses mainly on the process loss. However, if the process meets the capability requirement " Cpmk > C ", then the process ought to meet both capability requirements " Cpk > C " and " Cpm > C " as Cpmk < Cpk and Cpmk < Cpm . Thus, the index Cpmk evidently provides more capability assurance with respect to process yield and process loss to the customers than do the other two indices Cpk and Cpm. According to current modern quality improvement theory, this is a desired property. Actually the reduction of process loss (variation from the target) is just as important as increasing the process yield (namely adhering to the specifications). Note that, the definition (6.1) can alternatively be expressed as Cpmk = Cpk / ( l + ef2 , Z = (M - T)/CJ and also Cpmk = (1— | \x — m | / d)Cpm . Admittedly the index Cpmk is worse than Cpk being associated with a certain percentage of nonconforming items, but we must keep in mind that one should not choose this index when the proportion p is of the main interest. Cpmk (and usually Cpm) is by far more sensitive than other capability indices to the movements in the process average relative to the target T . When JJL equals T , Cpmk is equal to Cpk . When the mean of a process moves away from T , Cpmk decreases faster than Cpk does (although both indices are 0 when /i is equal to one of the specification limits). Conversely, when [i is brought closer to T , Cpmk increases much rapidly than Cpk does.
The Cpmk Index
113
-
2000 C
-
1000
\..y 0.6
0.7
\ S
i
0.8 Ct
Figure 6.1 The actual NC curves for Cpk = 1.0 (top), Cpm = 1.0 (dash), and Cpmk = 1-0 (bottom) with various allowed values of C„.
Figure 6.2 The actual NC curves for Cvk = 1.5 (top), Cvm = 1.5 (dash), and Cpmk = 1 . 0 (bottom) with various allowed values of C„.
Additionally, Cpmk reveals the most of information about the location of the process average. On the assumption that T = m (which is quite common in many practical situations), given the Cpk index of 1.0, all that can be said about /x is that it is somewhere between the bounds USL and LSL , i.e., T-d
114
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
the location of /j,. On the other hand, Cpmk provides the most information about the location of /x and the least about the proportion (probability) p . In fact that the corporation's quality philosophy will dictate us which index is more appropriate for a particular situation. The four basic indices Cp , Cpk , Cpm , and Cpmk i when ranked in terms of the sensitivity to differences between the process mean /J, and the target value T are: (1) Cpmk (the most sensitive) (2) Cpm , (3) Cpk and finally (4) Cp which is totally insensitive (Pearn and Kotz (1994)). Yield comparisons between the PCIs As we have shown in Chapter 3, for a normally distributed process, the index Cpk provides a lower bound on the process yield: p > 2$(3Cpk) - 1 , or %NC < 2$(-3Cpk) for 0 < Ca < 1 , which is equivalent to LSL
115
The Cpmk Index
Derivations of this bound are presented in the Appendix of Pearn and Lin (2005). These results conform that the three indices, Cpk , Cpm , and Cpmk provide the same lower bounds on process yield, namely, p > 2$(3Cpk) - 1 = 2$(3C pm ) - 1 . For example, given Cpk = 1.00 the only information about the process yield is available via the upper bound %NC < 2699.796 ppm. However for Cpm = 1.00 the information of the process yield is available through the upper bound %NC < 2699.796 ppm and the process centering measure 0.667 < Ca < 1.00. Finally if Cpmk = 1.00 we are having the upper bound %NC < 2699.796 ppm and the process centering measure 0.750 < Ca < 1.00. These calculations illustrate the advantage of using the index Cpmk compared to the indices Cpk and Cpm when measuring the process yield, since Cpmk provides a better customer protection in terms of the quality yield of the produced items. Table 4.1 displays the bounds on %NC {P(NCJ) and Ca for Cpk = Cpm = CPmk = C(say), respectively. Table 4.1 Bounds on P(NC) and Ca for Cpk = C pm = Cpmk = C. nw
Cpk
c
p ^pmk
pm
Bound on Ca
Bound on P(NC)
1.00 2699.796
0
2699.796
1.33 66.334
0
66.334
0.750 < Ca< 1
66.334
0.812 < Ca
1.50 6.795
0
6.795
0.778 < C 0 < 1
6.795
0.833 < Ca< 1
1.67 0.554
0
0.554
0.800 < C„< 1
0.554
0.850 < Ca< 1
2.00 0.002
0
0.002
0.833 < Ca< 1 0.002
Bound on P(NC)
Bound on Bound on Bound on P{NC) Ca ca 0.667 < Ca< 1 2699.796 0.750 < Ca<\
0.875 < Ca< 1
Observe that the rate of increase in value of the lower bound on Ca decreases (as C increases from 1 to 2) when comparing Cpm a n d Cpmk •
116
Cpmk
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices an
d the percentage of non-conforming (%NC)
Using the methodology for deriving formulas for an exact expected proportions of nonconforming items, and noting that Cpmk = Cpm x Ca , the following exact expected proportion of nonconforming expressed in terms of Cpmk and Ca are obtained:
2-<7„
%NC = $
3(7.pmk
,
+ $
-(1-Ca)2
ca
i
Observe that for Ca = 1 the %iVC becomes Cpmk and the expected
relative
squared
\ c« 1- ( 1 - -caf 2
on
2$(—3Cpmk). loss
For the index Cpmk , its relationship with the expected relative squared loss Le can directly be expressed as follows: n
—C
vC
1 AoC; 3 V WT4 '
=—
where AQ — Loss(USL) = k(USL - T)2 (if product adopts a specification limit, say USL), Le = [a2 + (fi-T)2]/d2 and WT is the worth of a product on target. Thus the expected relative squared losses based on Cpmk can be rewritten as: i AC2a Loss{Cpmk) = -ur 2 n2
(6.2)
$wTc pmk
From the expression (6.2) the expected relative squared loss °f Cpmk > Loss{Cpmk) , increases as Ca increases and reaches its
117
The Cpmk Index
maximum value for Ca = 1.00. For example, given the level of CVmk — 1-00, the Loss(Cpmk) attains a maximum value Ao/(9WT) at Ca=1.0. We have already mentioned on several occasion that according to current modern quality improvement philosophy a reduction in the process loss is as important as increasing the process yield. Although Cpk offers the most information about the yield, it provides the least insight about the location of \i. On the other hand, the index Cpmk provides the most information about the location of \x and the least about the yield. While the Cpk remains the more popular and widely used index, the index Cpmk is becoming to be an advanced and useful index for processes with two-sided specification limits. Once again, a corporation's quality philosophy will dictate us which index is more appropriate in a specific situation. 6.2 Estimating and testing Cpmk based on a single sample 6.2.1 Estimation
and the distribution
of the estimated
Cpmk
For a normally distributed process under statistical control, Pearn et al. (1992) suggested using the natural estimator of (j , defined as:
Cpmk = min
USL-x
x - LSL
3^/4 + (x - Tf ' 3V4 + (j _ Tf
\x-T\ / 2 + (j _ 3% s
Tf
where as above £ = ^ ™ £ i / n and s„ = ^T^™ (ZJ — x)2 / n are the maximum likelihood estimators (MLEs) of fi and a2 ,
118
Encyclopedia
and Handbook
of Process
Capability
Indices
respectively. Note that si + fa - T)2 = ^™_ fa - T)2 / n , which is in the denominator of Cpmk , is the uniformly minimum variance unbiased estimator (UMVUE) of a2 + (/i - T)2 = E[(X - T)2} appearing in the denominator of Cpmk . In fact, the natural a s of C.pmk can be expressed ^pmk — estimator 1 2 {D-VH)/(3yJK + H), where D = n l d/a , K = ns2n /a2 , and H = n(x — T)2 J a2 . Under the normality assumption, K is distributed as Xn-i> a chi-squared variable with n — 1 degrees of freedom, H is distributed as xi2\ a non-central chi-squared variable with one degree of freedom and the non-centrality parameter A = n(fi — T)2 / a2, and -Jll is distributed as a normal variable N(rj,l) with the mean 77 and variance 1. Here 77 = 1/2 fi — T I /(a j -Jn) . In other words, the natural estimator n Cpmk is distributed as a mixture of the chi-square and the noncentral chi-square variables expressed as: d-Jn a
C.pmk
, - Xl,A
3 ^ / X n - l + Xl 2 A
with Xn-i a n d Xi, A a r e a s defined above. In the general case (with T = m ) , Pearn et al. (1992) derived the r-th moment of Cpmk to be: -A/2 E C
( pmk)
= ~ 2= 0
00
(A\J
V I
r ( i±i
+ j) T{-^I + j)
x v i^L r(i + i) r ( ^ + ;) 3 = 0 J' Consequently for r = 1 and 2, we have
119
The Cpmk Index 3-A/2
EyCpmk)
3
oo / MJ j
(f) d m £ /=-„ r-[
n^ + j) r ( f + j)
i!r(f+ ;) r(i + J )r(^i + j)
(6.3)
and
Var(Cpmk) = E(C2pmk) -
[E(Cpmk)f
where
E(C2pmk)
9
^
d-J2n
i'i
dJnY a J ' n + 2j -2
J]T(l + j) n + 2 j - l
l + 2j + n + 2j
(6.3)
The bias and the mean square error (MSE) of Cpmk can be expressed as: BiasyCpmk) = E[Cpmk) MSE(Cpmk)
= Var{Cpmk)
— Cpmk , -
[Bias(Cpmk)}2,
Evidently Cpmk is a biased estimator of Cpmk (see (6.3) and (6.1)). Pearn et al. (1992) calculate the expected values and variances of Cpmk for d/a= 2(1)6, \n - T\ /a = 0.0(0.5)2.0 for the sample sizes n = 10(10)50. As \/J, — T\ /a increases, both the values of E(Cpmk) and Cpmk decrease for fixed d /a . Moreover, as \[i — T\/a increases, the variance of Cpmk is decreasing for a fixed sample size n and dja (see Pearn et al. (2003)). These results indicate that the bias of Cpmk is positive when fj, ^ T , i.e., Cpmk is generally overestimated by Cpmk . Furthermore, when
120
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
pi ^ T , both the bias and MSE of Cpmk decrease as |/x — T\ /a increases for a fixed sample size n and a fixed d / a . Constable and Hobbs (1992) have discovered that, even if the underlying distribution of the data is normal, small samples do not result in acceptable estimates of the mean and standard deviation of the process. A proper choice of sample sizes for capability estimation is of vital importance. The smaller the sample size, the higher Cpmk ought to be to d e m o n s t r a t e t h e t r u e process capability. However, one should keep in mind that when the sample size n is small or moderate (10 or even 50), the MSE of Cpmk is quite large as compared with the corresponding actual value of Cpmfc . For example, for |/z — T\ /a = 0 and d/a = 6, Cpmk = 2.00 while ^MSE(Cpmh) = 0.559 for n = 10 a n d •sJMSE{Cpmk) = 0.210 for n = 50. This shows that it is advisable to construct confidence intervals or carry out appropriate hypothesis tests. Chen and Hsu (1995) investigated the asymptotic sampling distribution of the estimated Cpmk as n —» oo and have shown that the estimator Cpmk is a consistent, asymptotically unbiased estimator of Cpmk and, provided the fourth moment of the distribution of the characteristic X is finite, Cpmk i s a l s o asymptotically normal. Vannman and Kotz (1995) obtained the distribution of the estimated "hyper index" Cp (u, v) for cases with T — m . By taking u = 1 and v = 1 , one arrives at the distribution of C p (1,1) = Cpmh . Vannman (1997) lateron derived a simplified form for the obtained distribution. Wright (1998) has obtained an explicit but rather complicated expression for the probability density function of the estimated Cpmk . Furthermore, Pearn et al. (1999) investigated an extension of Cpmk to handle processes with asymmetric tolerances (T ^ m). Under the normally assumption, Pearn et al. (2001) derived
121
The Cpmk Index
explicit forms of the c.d.f. and the p.d.f. of the estimator Cp'm& with asymmetric tolerances. If the manufacturing tolerance is symmetric (T = m), the c.d.f. of C ^ . reduces to
y
o,
-~r
poo
(D-JSD(y)tf
{
c
W -l-
xfn( SD(y)t)sD(y)dt, FfiAv)
y= o l-6)
+
\lFK
9y
Jo
x
$(.-D-6),
fH(SD(y)t)SD(y)dt,
y > o.
FK(-) is here the c.d.f. of a Xn-i variable. (Recall D = nl^2d/a, K = nsl/a2, H = n{x - T)2 /a2 .)
that
The corresponding p.d.f. of Cpmk becomes:
u*
9y
fa \SDW)
^-i
^ - 3 < y< °
fe Av) ''pink
]f«
9y2
x fH[sD(y)t)
SD(y)t
—$
dt
,
v > °>
122
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
where SD(y) = [D/(l + 3y)2} , FK{-) is the c.d.f. of K (a x«-i variable), fK(-) is the p.d.f. of K, and /#(•) is the probability density function of H (a non-central %2 variable). Using a variable transformation and the integration technique similar to those presented in Vannman (1997), the c.d.f. and the p.d.f. of the estimator C*pmfc may alternatively be expressed in terms of a mixture of the chi-square distribution and the normal distribution. The explicit form of the c.d.f. considerably simplifies the analysis of the statistical properties of Cpmk . The c.d.f. of Cpmj(. can be expressed as
Lpmk^'
Jo
I
9y2
x [4>{t + £Vn) + <j){t - £^n)]dt,
(6.4)
for y > 0, where b = d /a , £ = (/z — T)/ a, G(-) is the c.d.f. of a chi-squared random variable with n — 1 degrees of freedom. Xn-i and (/>(•) is the p.d.f. of the standard normal variable iV(0,1) (see Pearn and Lin (2002)). As in the case of the Cpmk p.d.f. (Chapter 4) we would obtain the same equation when we substituting £ by —£ in equation (6.4) for fixed values of x and n . Note that for it > USL or [x < LSL , the capability index Cpmk < 0 , and for li = USL or \i = LSL , it is 0. The restriction LSL < /j, < USL has been a minimum capability requirement which is valid in most of start-up engineering applications or of new processes. Jessenberger and Weihs (2000) studied the behavior of Cpmk for processes with asymmetric tolerances. Pearn et al. (2001) obtained an alternative but simpler form of the p.d.f. of Cpmk and investigated capability testing procedures in these cases. Pearn et al. (2002) studied statistical properties of the estimated Cpmj. . Pearn and Lin (2002a) have focused on a Bayesian-like estimator of Cpmk under a different manufacturing
123
The Cpmk Index
condition when the probability P(/i > m) is available. Pearn and Lin (2002b) also developed efficient SAS/Maple computer programs to calculate the critical values and the p-value for testing manufacturing capability based on Cpmk •
6.2.2 Confidence
intervals
on Cpmk
As mentioned above, Chen and Hsu (1995) examined the asymptotic sampling distribution of the estimated Cpmk and have shown that the estimator Cpmk is consistent, asymptotically unbiased estimator of Cpmk , and (provided the fourth moment of the distribution of the characteristic X is finite), Cpmk is also asymptotically normal. In particular, an asymptotic 100(1 — a)% confidence interval on Cpmk derived by Chen and Hsu (1995) is a n
^pmk
a
pmk A ~f=~i^pmk
z
a/2
pmk
z
af2
•Jn
•Jn
where
~2 Vpmk
72<52 + d
26
_
\V{l + 62)
+ 3(1 +
<52)3/2 J
C,pmk
+
ra4
2\2 72(1 + 6')
-i
r2 ^ pmk •
where a^mk is the asymptotic estimator of Var(Cpmk). za/2 is the upper a / 2 quantile of the standard normal distribution, and m4 = Y?i=Sxi
sn =Y^=i(xi
-x)4 /n , 8 = (x
~xf
-T)/sn,
/n.
Furthermore, based on the c.d.f. of Cpmk as expressed in (6.4), Pearn and Shu (2003) further developed an efficient
124
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
algorithm with a Matlab computer program to obtain the lower confidence limits that convey important information regarding the true process capability. For processes with the target value set at the mid-point of the manufacturing specifications (T = m , the symmetric case), the index Cpmk can be rewritten as _ Pmk
d-\fi-T\
_d/a - | £ |
" sja* + (M - Tf " SVTK 1 '
(
}
where the parameter £ = (/U — T) / a . For Cvmk = C , b = d / a can be expressed as & = 3Cv 1 + £2 + | £ | . Since the process parameters /J, and a are usually unknown, £ has to be estimated. Indeed for testing procedures for Cpm as presented in Cheng (1992) one can estimate £ by calculating the values of £ = (x — T) / sn from the sample. Hence, given the sample of size n , the confidence level 7 , the estimated values Cpmk and £ , the lower confidence bound Cpmk can be obtained using numerical integration technique with iterations be solving the equation bJn/(l+3C2pmk)
G
/ ,0
(ftVn - tf 9CU
2
^
x[<j>(t + t-Jn) +
=I - 7 .
(6.6)
It should be noted that the l.h.s. of the equation is an even function of £ . Consequently, for both £ = £0 and £ = —£0 we obtain the same lower confidence bounds.
6.2.3 Hypothesis
testing
with Cpmk
Using the index Cpmk engineers can access the process performance and to monitor the manufacturing processes on a
The Cpmk Index
125
routine basis. To test whether a given process is capable, we shall consider, as it was done on the previous occasions, the following statistical testing hypotheses: HQ '• Cpmk < C (process is not capable), H\ '• Cpmk > C (process is capable). where C as above is a given value of capability requirement. Based on a given a(c0) = a (explain c0 and a), the chance of incorrectly classifying an incapable process (Cpm): < C ) as a capable one ( Cpmk > C ), the decision rule is to reject H0 ( Cymk < C ) if Cpmk > c0 and not reject it otherwise. For symmetric cases with T = m , let Cpm/t = C then the b = d/a expressed in (6.5) is rewritten as b = 3C\Jl + £ 2 + | £ | . Hence, given values of the capability requirement C , parameter £ , the sample size n , and the risk a , the critical value CQ can be obtained by solving the equation P(Cpmk > c0 | Cp7n& = C) = a using standard but tedious numerical methods. In other words:
6Vn/(l+3co)
/ ,o
nx +"\2 _ {(b^n-tf t2
((h
9c 0 2
x [
(6.7)
where G(-), as above, is the c.d.f. of Xn-2 • Similarly, given values of C , n , and a , the critical values CQ for £ = £0 and £ = — £0 are the same since equation (6.7) is an even function of £ . In addition, given a value of the capability requirement C , the p-value corresponding to c , a specific value of Cpmk , calculated from the sample data, is (using equation (6.6)):
126
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
p - value = P(Cpmk > c \ Cpmk = C) 6Vn/(l+3c*)
= /,
{{b^n-tf { 9(cy
_t2
x[<£(i + £Vn) + (/>(£-£Vn)]d£.
(6.8)
[the readers ought to distinguish between the symbols C (related to Cpmk ) and CQ associated with Cpmk}. As we have already pointed out on several occasions, since the process parameters (i and a are unknown, so is £ which ought to be estimated in real-world applications. Such an approach would certainly be less reliable as the confidence level 7 may not be ensured. To eliminate the need for further estimation of the parameter £ , Peran and Lin (2002) also examined the behavior of the critical value c0 as a function of the process characteristic £ . They carried out extensive computations to calculate the critical value c0 for £ = 0(0.05)3.00, Cpmk = 0.7(0.1)3.0, and n = 5(5)200. Observe that the values £ = 0(0.05)3.00 cover a wide range of possible applications for the process capability Cpmk > 0. The results of these investigations indicate that the critical value c0 attains its maximum at either £ = 0.50 (for the most cases), or at 0.45 (in a few cases), and the difference between the two critical values is less than 5 x 10~4 . For instance, it follows from Figure 6.1., the critical value c0 first increases with £ attaining its maximum value at £ = 0.45 or 0.50, and then decreases within the range of £ G [0.5,3.0] . Hence, for practical purposes, we may solve equation (6.6) for £ = 0.50 to achieve the required critical values for given Cpmk > n a n d 7 , without the need to estimate further the parameter £ . Consequently, the confidence level 7 can be ensured and decisions carried out based on such an approach should be reliable.
127
The Cpmk Index
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
Figure 6.1. Plots of CQ versus | £ | for C = 1.00, a = 0.05, and n = 30, 50, 70, 100, 200, 300 (from top to bottom)
If the estimated value Cpmk is greater than the critical value Co ( Cpmk > cQ) or the calculated p-value is smaller than a (pvalue < a ), we conclude that the process meets the capability requirement ( Cpmfc > C ). Otherwise, there is no sufficient information to conclude that the process meets the specified capability requirement. In this case, we would tend to believe that Cpm). < C . In fact the approach described above ensures that decisions based on those critical values would be more reliable than on other available methods of estimating £ by means of the sample values only.
6.3 Estimating and testing Cpmk based on multiple samples From a practical perspective, manufacturing characteristic information about the process control may be obtained from estimating the process capability using the past in-control data which includes multiple samples (rather than a single sample) without recalculation on resampling. Many of modern manufacturing factories have implemented a daily-based production control plan for monitoring/controlling
128
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
process stability. A routine-basis data collection procedure is carried out to run the X and S control charts (for moderate sample sizes). The past "in control" data consisting of multiple samples of m groups, with variable sample sizes n^ = (xn,xi2,...,xin.), is then analyzed in order to compute the (overall) manufacturing capability. Thus, manufacturing information regarding the product quality characteristic is derived from multiple samples rather than from a single one. Under the assumption that these samples are taken from the normal distribution N(/j,,a2) , we consider the following estimators of the process mean and the process standard deviation:
for the i-th sample mean and the sample variance, respectively. Then, the overall sample mean X = ^ nj-Xj / N , n an N = ^2 •_, % d the pooled sample variance S2P = n i 2 i i 5 Ar m are the
Er=i( '- )^ /Er=i^- )=Er=i^- ) '/( - )
unbiased estimators of fi and a2 , respectively, used for calculating the manufacturing capability Cpmk . For cases with multiple samples the natural estimator of Cpmk is given below. The derivations of the sampling distribution, lower confidence bounds, and the manufacturing capability calculations for cases with multiple samples can be performed using the similar techniques for the situations with a single sample, although the derivations and calculations are usually more tedious and complicated (See e.g. Vannman and Hubele (2003) and Pearn and Shu (2003) for more details). The "natural" estimator of Cpmk is: Cpmk —
m m
USL-1
1
-LSL
2
^ 3yjS p + (X - Tf ' &Js* + ( f - T)2 '
Using the similar technique for cases with a single sample, the
129
The Cpmk Index
c.d.f. of Cpmk can be expressed in terms of a mixture of chisquared and normal distributions:
Fd, (x) = i - r
&V77/(l+3z) •if
9x2
[ # + ^v]v) + (/>(i-eVAr)]^ for x > 0 , where b = d/a , FK{.) is the c.d.f. of the (ordinary central) chi-square distribution XN-m > a n d >(•) is the p.d.f. of t h e s t a n d a r d n o r m a l d i s t r i b u t i o n 7V(0,1). As m e n t i o n e d above, under the condition with T = m , the index Cpmk may b e r e w r i t t e n a s Cpmk = (d/a— | £ | ) / ( 3 v l + £ 2 ) , w h e r e £ = (/i — T)/cr . T h a t i s , w h e n Cpmj. = C , 6 = dVer c a n be expressed as b = 3CyJl + £ 2 + | £ |. Namely, given t h e t o t a l sample size N with m subsamples, the confidence level 7 , the estimated value Cpmk , and the parameter £, the lower confidence bound Cpmk c a n be obtained using numerical i n t e g r a t i o n techniques with iterations, to solve t h e equation (6.7). We r e e m p h a s i z e t h a t t h e p a r a m e t e r £ = (// —T)/cr is usually unknown_in practice, but can be estimated from the sample data as £ = (X — T) J Sp. Again it should be noted that we have the same lower confidence bounds for both £ = £0 and £ = — £0 since t h e l.h.s. of e q u a t i o n ( 6 . 8 ) is a n even f u n c t i o n of £ : 6777/(1+3(7*pmk
/.
) •K
9CZk
[4>{t + £ V F ) +
=I - 7 .
(6.7)
Pearn and Shu (2003) also investigated the behavior of the lower confidence bound Cp^nk versus the process characteristic parameter £ based on multiple samples. The results indicate that
130
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
the lower confidence bound first decreases as £ increases, attains its minimum value at £ = 0.45 or 0.5 (with the difference of less than 0.001), and then, in all cases, increases again within the range of £ 6 [0.5, 3.0]. Hence, for practical purposes we may solve equation (6.7) with £ = 0.5 to obtain the required sample accuracy for given N , m and 7 , without the need to estimate the parameter £ . The decision making procedure just described ensures that the risk of a wrong decision will be not greater than the preset Type I error 1 — 7 .
6.4 Bayesian-like estimation of Cpmk We have always indicated that Pearn et al. (1992) proposed the capability index Cpmk , and also investigated the statistical properties of it's natural estimator Cpmk for stable normal processes with a constant mean \i. Chen and Hsu (1995) showed that under general conditions the asymptotic distribution of Cpmk is normal for /J, ^ m , and is a linear combination of the normal and the folded-normal distributions whenever \x = m , where m as is the mid-point between the upper and the lower specification limits mentioned above. In real-world applications the production may require multiple supplies with different quality characteristics in each single shipment of the raw materials, multiple manufacturing lines with sometimes inconsistent precision in the machine settings and engineering effort for each manufacturing line, or multiple workmanship shifts with variable performance level at each shift. Thus, the fundamental and common assumption that the process mean remains a constant may not be satisfied in real-world situations. Consequently, using the natural estimator Cvm-k to measure the potential and performance of such process may be inappropriate as the resulting capability measure may very well be inaccurate. For stable processes under these
131
The Cpmk Index
conditions, if we have knowledge about the process mean, P(/j, > m) — p , 0 < p < 1 , then we may consider the following novel estimator Cpmk : (Usually, the probability P([i > m) = p , 0 < p < 1 , can be obtained from historical information about a stable process.)
bn^[d-(X-m)IA(fi)] ^S2n+(X-T?
apmk
here &„_i = V2/(n - l){r[(n - l)/2]/T[(n - 2)/2]} is the correction factor, IA(-) is the indicator function defined as IA (M) = 1 f ° r M £ A, and IA (/J,) = — 1 for /i $ A , where the set A = {(i\n > m}. Observe that the new estimator Cpmk can be rewritten as: p
_ h-M ~{X - rn)IA(n)}
Lpmk
ZJSI +(Xd-(X_
m)IAM Sb^Sn
1+ t
where X = Y.',sxi
Tf
^ l l
_
Cpk
.k+ i l ^ l
I'" •*„ = E,",JX-
~ Xf
A B " *> '
And Cpk = bn_x[d — (X — m)IA(n)]/(3Sn) was introduced by Pearn and Chen (1996). If the process characteristic follows the normal distribution, N(fj,,a2) , then the new estimator Cpmk is distributed as:
132
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
bn-lt'n-l(f>)
c.pmk
3Vr 1 *i', -i(A) 1+ n n 1
where tn_x (6) is as above the non-central t distribution with n — 1 degrees of freedom and the non-centrality parameter 8 = 3VnCpfc , and iJl)„_i(A) is the non-central F distribution with (1, n —1) degrees of freedom, and the non-centrality parameter A = n((J, - Tf J a2 (Pearn and Lin (2003-Metrika)). Moreover, if the knowledge about the process mean, namely the probabilities P(fi > m) = p , and P(/x < m) = 1 — p , with 0 < p < 1 is known, then the asymptotic distribution of the new estimator Cpmk turns out to be a mixture of two normal distributions. The estimator Cpmk is consistent and asymptotically unbiased. Consequently, when either P(/x > m) = 1, or P(/j, > m) = 0 , the asymptotic distribution reduces to an (ordinary) normal distribution. Under center general conditions, namely if the fourth central moment /x4 = E(X — fj,)4 exists, the distribution of the standardized quantity Sn{Cpmk — Cpmk) converges to 2 2 in distribution, where the p • N(0,a pmkl) + (1 p) • N(0,apmk2) varmces: A2 _2
_
1+
^1
(M - Tf
( A i
3 ~ a3
a 1
A 2 "pmk2
_
^
4
a
2
,
^2 Q
<7
, 1 H4 - P <
.
A
a
A
°2 1 a
pmfcl
In (M- T2 ) <^ 1 2
2 M3
3 ~ a3
2 1 + (M - T)
-3/2
r2
i+fc^
/I
[ 1l l1
_T)2i
i i
1-2
c;pmk2
-3/2
c,pmk2
The Cpmk Index
_ 9Qz -
T)C2pmkl
133
d - ( / z - m) 2 3^/a 2 + (jz - T ) '
,
and
A
A2 =
9 ( M _ T)Cpmk2 , , ,
r
_
J-, ^pmk2
d + (/x - m) • — „ /—5
;
=75
Chapter 7
The Snh Index
7.1 Process capability and the Spk index 7.2 Estimating and testing Spk based on a single sample 7.3 Hypothesis testing with Spk 7.1 Process capability and the Spk index Process yield has for a long time been a standard criterion used in the manufacturing industry as a common measure of process performance. Process yield is currently defined as the percentage of processed product units passing inspection, which indicates that the product characteristic falls within the manufacturing tolerance. Product units that are rejected (nonconforming) result in additional costs incurred to the factory for scrapping or repairing the product. However a factory does not induce additional costs for a product that departs from the nominal specifications but is still within the tolerance. For processes with two-sided manufacturing specifications, the process yield can be calculated as p = F(USL) — F(LSL) , where USL and LSL are the upper and the lower specification limits, respectively, and F(-) is the c.d.f. of the process characteristic. If the process characteristic is normally distributed, the process yield can then also be expressed as p = $[(USL — //)/er] — $[(LSL — fj,)/ a] , where using the common notation ji is the process mean,
The S„k Index
135
As it was already mentioned in attempting to provide a common quantitative measure of process performance, Kane (1986) one of the pioneers of the process capability analysis utilized the capability index Cpk to determine process ability of reproducing items within the specified manufacturing tolerance. The index Cpk was specifically designed for processes with two-sided manufacturing specifications requiring knowledge of both USL and LSL , It is defined as: Cpk = min
USL-
n fi
-LSL
(c/. Chapter 4) We have also seen in Chapter 3 that for normally distributed processes, the relationship between the process yield p and the index Cpk is p > 2<£(3Cpfc) — 1. Thus, the index Cpk provides us with an approximate, rather than exact, measure of the actual process yield. This important observation allows us to develop the yield index Spk for normal processes, which can be interpreted as a smooth version of Cpk . This new index was proposed by Boyles (1991, 1994) allows a one-to-one transform to fraction nonconforming. The index Spk is defined as:
where $ - 1 (-) is the inverse function of standard normal c.d.f. $(•). The index Spk establishes a relationship between the manufacturing specifications and the actual process performance, which provides an exact measure of the process yield. If Spk = c, then the process yield can be expressed as p = 2<E>(3c) — 1. There is eventually a one-to-one correspondence between Spk and the process yield p . Consequently, the index Spk provides an exact (rather than approximate) measure of the process yield, (under the normal assumption).
136
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
We note that the Spk can be rewritten and expressed as a function of the basic indices Cp and Ca . Recall the index Cp defined as Cp = (USL — LSL) /(6a) which measures the overall process variation relative to the specification tolerance and reflects only the process precision (consistency). Similarly the Ca defined as Ca = 1— | ii — m | / d, measures the degree of process centering, where m = (USL + LSL) / 2 is the mid-point between the upper and the lower specification limits, and d = (USL — LSL) / 2 is the half of the length between the specification limits. The index Ca thus alerts the user if the process mean deviates from its target value. An informative mathematical relationship between 5pfc and Cv and Ca is easily derived to be: Spk =
^
V
2 $
\ [d-
+
V
m
a
¥
i.
fJ-
a
(i-
= ^-1[\^(3CpCa)
jj, — m
a/d
+
4*
LSLU a
(d+
Id)
+ £•
V a
m
' 1+ | n — m | / d a~fd
^(3Cp(2-Ca))Y
For a process where the nominal is equal to the process mean (T = m), the manufacturing tolerance is 3Spk standard deviations from the mean. For example, if Spk =1.00 , then USL = ji + 3(7 and LSL = JJ, — 3a , (this situation is sometimes called the natural tolerance). If Spk = 2.00 , we arrive at by the six-sigma principle: USL = [i + Qa and LSL = /j, — 6a , the well known 6a limits popularized, (and sometimes abused by the socalled six-sigma principle). 7.2 Estimating and testing Spk based on a single sample 7.2.1 Estimation
of Spk
In practice, the process parameters fi and a are unknown and have to be estimated from the sampled data. To estimate the
The S„t Index
137
yield measure Spk , we consider the following natural estimator involving the statistics x = ^ . _ xt / n and 'pfc 2 1 2 s = [Y^._ (XJ — S") /(n — l)] ' are the sample mean and the sample standard deviation being the conventional estimators of \i and a , respectively, obtained from a well-controlled (being definitely in statistical control) process. The estimator is evidently Spk = ~$~
2
\
+
s
l*
T5)
The exact distribution of Spk (even under the normal distribution) is mathematically intractable. Consequently, as it stands testing the process performance cannot be accomplished. On the other hand, Lee et al. (1999) obtained an approximate distribution of Spk using the Taylor expansion technique. Let Z = ~Jn(x — //) and Y = Vn (s 2 — a2), then Z and Y are independent since the first two moments of x and s2 exist, it can be shown that Z and Y converge by the Central Limit Theorem to N( 0, a2) and N(0,2a2) , respectively, as n goes to infinity. Accordingly, applying the first order Taylor expansion, the estimator o pfc can be expressed approximately as: Spk — Spk +
where
W =
\
6Vn
Op(n-1),
(7.1)
(1 Y (l + 6)
Z_ ,<7
(1 + 6
1-6
4>
7
->
7
(7.2)
and as above 6 = (fj, - m) / d and 7 = a / d . Note that the expression (7.2) can be written as W = sjn,/2[a(s2 — a2)/a2} — -Jn[b(x-^)/a}=[aY/(-/2a2)}-(bZ/a) for n < m , and W = 4^j2[a(s2 - a2)/a2} + Vn[6(z - n)/a] =[aY/(V2a2)] +(bZ/a) for \x > m , where a and b are functions of n and a (or
138
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
equivalently of 6 and 7 ) as defined below and (/>(•) is the p.d.f. of the standard normal variable N( 0,1). 1+6 d } a = y/2cr d + 6)
Here
and
b =
0
[1
+ a-s)
{ 7J
1 +
^ ) -
6
)
(7.3)
(7.4)
{ 7J
Consequently, the statistic W (by Central Limit Theorem) is asymptotically normally distributed with mean 0 and variance a2 + b2 , and the natural estimator Spk is approximately (asymptotically) distributed according to N([j,s,crg), where: E(Spk) = Ms = Spk Var(Spk) = a2 = (a2 + b2)/{36n[»(3^)]2} •
and
The asymptotic distribution of the estimate of Spk variance that decreases with n . Thus, the estimator 5 ^ is asymptotically unbiased. As the sample size increases both the sample mean and the sample variance approach to their expected values. The remaining term in (7.1), O p (n _ 1 ) , represents the error of the expansion having a leading term of order n^ 1 in probability. Hence, the approximation is also consistent. In fact, the parameters a and b expressed in (7.3) and (7.4) can also be rewritten as functions of the precision index Cp and the accuracy index Ca in the following manner: d (1 + S) a = V2cr (l + 6)
+ (!-<$)>
- ^ [ 3 C p ( 2 - Ca)4>{ZCp{2 - Ca)) +
(1 - / P
b = 4>
=
(1 + 6)}
-0 i 7 J { 7 JJ
1-6 7 3CpCa
139
The S„k Index
(The identity: 3CpCa —
1+6 7
is worth noting). Thus, the p.d.f. of the approximate distribution, N^fis,^), can easily be derived to be: (see Pearn, Lin and Wang (2004))
f{x) =
J—4a OO <
2
X <
2
+b
exp
18n(fl3S pfc ))' a2+b2
f {X
_
2 Pk)
OO .
The formula of the first-order approximation of Spk as given in (7.1), is somewhat clumsy, but it produces an adequate approximate distribution for a sample size large enough. Lee et al. (1999) indicate that the approximate and exact distributions are almost indistinguishable as the sample size n reaches 1000 or more. In fact, even for n = 100 the approximation is quite reasonable for practical purposes. However, the accuracy of the approximation is difficult to investigate since the parameters a and b are required to be further estimated from the sample, resulting in a loss of reliability. Thus, the analytical approximation would not be practically useful in practice until this difficulty has been resolved. Moreover, using rather complicated and tedious algebraic manipulations Pearn et al. (2005) have shown that also, the estimator Spk can be expressed in the form of: Spk = Spk + DXZ + D2Y + D3Z2 + D4ZY + D5Y2
+Op'
n~/n i
here Z and Y are distributed according to the joint bivariate normal distribution, and Di , i = l,2,---,5 , are functions of
140
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
6 = (fx — m) / d and 7 = a / d . (These are the basic functions for the specification bound and the mean.) Therefore, the distribution of Spk may alternatively be approximated by the following polynomial combination of the distributions of Z and Y: (Z, Y) -^—^
N((0,
0), S 2 ) , where S 2 =
0 1/2 '
with the bias approximated as: DXZ + D2Y + D3Z2 + D4ZY + D5Y2.
The formulae for the both approximations to the distribution of Spk are quite complicated, and the calculation is somewhat cumbersome. As mentioned above, since the parameters a and b in the approximate formula(s) ought also be estimated in real world applications, a substantial uncertainty may be introduced into the assessments of the performance due to the additional sampling errors resulting from the estimation of a and b . Furthermore, the accuracy of the approximation has not yet been investigated. Consequently, the approximation may not be useful in practice until these issues are successfully resolved. To analyze the actual accuracy of the natural estimator Spk, Pearn and Chuang (2003) investigate the accuracy computationally, using the simulation techniques to obtain the relative bias and the relative MSE for certain common performance requirements, where the relative bias is defined as BiasR(Spk) = [E(Spk) - Spk}/Spk = E(Spk / Spk) - 1 . It measures the average relative (percentage) deviation of Spk from the true value Spk . Moreover the relative MSE is defined as MSER(SSpk)=E[(Spk-Spk)/ Spk f =E[(Spk / Spk) - l ] 2 ; it measures the average of the squared relative deviation of Spk from the true
The S„k Index
141
value Spk . These authors have further considered the statistic [MSER(Spk)f/2 the square root of the relative MSE, which is a more direct measurement of the relative deviation (i.e. the percentage of deviation). Unfortunately either explicit or implicit mathematical formulae for BiasR(Spk) and for MSER(Spk) are analytically intractable. The simulation approach seems to be a best alternative for the accuracy assessment. For commonly used performance requirements which are Spk = 1.00, 1.33, 1.50, 1.67, and 2.00, each combination of the precision measure Cp , the accuracy measure Ca, and the (/J,, a) pair is first assigned generate random normal samples of size n . The sample data is then calculated to obtain the estimator Spk • A total of N =10000 replications are repeated for each sample size of n— 5(5)100, next the average value E(Spk) is computed and is compared with the preset true Spk to calculate the relative bias. The simulation error was also examined, and resulted in not being greater than 5 x 10~3 . These simulation results clearly indicate that the estimator Spk overestimates the true value of Spk in all cases that have been investigated. The amount of the overestimation, in terms of the relative bias, BiasR(Spk), appears to be increasing in Cp at the beginning, and then remained stable after roughly Cp = Spk + 0 . 2 . Particularly, this is valid in all cases for exceeding 15 . After the sample size n > 15 , the fluctuation of BiasR(Spk) remains less than 0.5%, and is no greater than 0.10.2% for n > 60 . This pattern is also apparent for [MSER(Spk)}1/2. Indeed in most cases, the magnitude of the deviation is increasing in Cp at the beginning and then becomes stable approximately after Cp = Spk + 0.1 , particularly, for n > 20 . (See e.g. Pearn and Chuang (2003)) The above described simulation results are useful for practitioners/engineers to measure the process performance for factory applications, especially, if the processes are controlled/monitored on a permanent routine basis.
142
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
7.2.2 Confidence
intervals
for Spk
Based on the first-order approximation as given by Lee et al. (1999-QREI), a 100(1 — a)% confidence interval can be expressed as:
, _ bpk
Za/2
Va 2 + b2
.
6^(3SpkY
bpk
JtfTb2 +Za/2
6Vncf>(3Spk)
where as usual za/2 is the upper a/2 quantile value of the standard normal distribution, and the parameters a and b are estimated from the sampled data. In addition, a 100(1 — a)% lower confidence bound of Spk can also be obtained from the lower (one-sided) confidence limit as: Spk -zax
(a2 + 6 2 ) 1 / 2 /[6Vn0(35 pfc )].
If the calculated lower confidence limit turns to be greater than the predetermined index value, the process is judged to be capable. Otherwise, the process is classified as incapable, and approximate quality improvement activities ought to be initiated. More recently, Pearn and Chen (2003) studied the natural estimator of Spk and investigated computationally its statistical properties, using the bootstrap simulation techniques to obtain the lower confidence bound in order that practitioners/engineers can utilize them to perform quality testing and to determine whether the process meets the preset quality requirements. These authors compared the four following bootstrap methods including (a) the standard bootstrap (SB), (b) the percentile bootstrap (PB), (c) the biased corrected percentile bootstrap (BCPB), and (d) the bias-corrected and accelerated (BCa) bootstrap methods based on the coverage proportion. For each one of these methods, they have calculated the proportion of the simulation runs for which the lower confidence bound is smaller than the corresponding Spk value. This "actual coverage proportion" (viewing the lower bound Spk as a one-sided confidence interval (Spk,oo)), could then be
The Sfk Index
143
compared with the expected value of 1 — a , say 0.95. The simulation results show that the SB method substantially outperforms the PB, BCPB and BCa approaches in the case of normally distributed processes, and is therefore recommended to be used when the assessing process performance Spk based on the yield. Furthermore, for the SB method the coverage fraction is greater than 0.90 in all the cases investigated when the sample size n exceeds 25, and it is also more stable than the other three methods. Therefore, the SB approach ought to be the one recommended for the Spk index, especially for sample sizes greater than 25.
7.3 Hypothesis testing with Spk Based on the asymptotic distribution of Spk derived by Lee et al. (1999-QREI), a hypothesis testing for Spk can be constructed in a straightforward manner. For example, the testing of the null hypothesis Ho : Spk < C , C is a specified value versus an alternative hypothesis Hi '• Spk > C
can be carried out by considering the test statistic: _ 6(Spk -
C)^n
where a and b are the estimates of a and b, and Cp , Ca, /i and a are replaced by Cp , Ca , x and s , respectively. The null hypothesis H0 is reject at a level if the statistic T > za , where as above za , is the upper 100a% point of the standard normal
144
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
distribution. The proposed testing procedure is quite simple to use based on the normal approximation, but a substantial uncertainty (sampling errors) could be introduced into the performance assessments since using the value of d and b calculated from the sample data could be misleading. Calculation of the critical values To assess further the accuracy of testing procedures, Pearn et al. (2003) investigated the critical values using a standard simulation technique to compare with the critical values obtained from the normal approximation as proposed by Lee et al. (1999), under the same performance requirements. The comparison of the critical values CQ calculated by means of the normal approximation and the simulation technique for various selected sample sizes from n = 5 to 150 and various Spk values = 1.00, 1.33, 1.50, 1.67, 2.00, with the risk a = 0.05 . The simulation results indicate that the critical values are more sensitive to the two indices Cp and Ca than to those that are obtained by the normal approximation. For example, given the fixed value Spk = 1.67 with n = 20 , c0 = 2.24 for Cp = 1.67 , and we have c0 = 2.30 for Cp = 1.90 . Thus, we could choose the maximal values of c0 (among these of Cp and Ca ) to obtain conservative bounds on the critical values for reliability purposes. Such an approach ensures that the decisions made based on the critical values have the risk of (wrongly) specifying an incapable process as a capable, to be not greater than the preset type I error a . It also have been noted that the normal approximation substantially under-approximates the critical values, especially, for small sample sizes n < 40 , when the amount of underestimation exceeds 0.10. Therefore, for short run applications (such as accepting a supplier that provides short production runs in the QS-9000 certification), one should definitely avoid using the normal approximation. It was also observed that the underestimation might be as large as 0.07 for n = 50 , 0.03 for n = 110 , and 0.02 for n = 150 .
The Srk Index
145
Therefore, in real-life applications we should strive towards sample sizes larger than 150. Furthermore, sample sizes which are necessary so that the normal approximation converge to 5pfc assuming the values 1.00, 1.33, 1.5, 1.67 and 2.0 within sampling errors less than 0.10, 0.09, 0.08, 0.07, 0.06, 0.05, 0.04, 0.03, 0.02, 0.01, 0.00 respectively (with the accuracy up to the second decimal point, i.e. 5 x 10~3 ). For example, for Sp^ = 1.33 with risk a = 0.05 , a sample size of n > 95909 ensures that the sampling error is no greater than 5 x 10"3, which is negligible. Thus, if Spk > 1.33 , we then may conclude that the actual performance S^ is also > 1.33 . This type of assessment investigation is not practical in applications. However, these computations illustrate the behavior and the rate of convergence using the normal approximation. [1] The comparison of the power analysis (the coverage rate) using a number of approaches (1 st order, 2nd order approximations, standard simulation, bootstrap) has not been carried out as yet. [2] For multiple samples, 1st order approximation by Taylor expansion + an accuracy analysis. [3] For multiple samples, critical values and lower (coverage rate) comparison of several approaches.
bounds
[4] For multiple samples, the MPPAC also can be applied in the same way.
Chapter 8
The CPU/CPL Index
8.1 Process capability and the index CPU/ CPL 8.2 Estimating and testing CPU/CPL: Based on single sample 8.3 Estimating and testing CPU/CPL: Based on multiple samples 8.4 Estimating and testing CPU/ CPL: Bayesian approach with single sample 8.1 Process capability and the index CPU/ CPL We hope that by now our readers are familiar with a number of process capability indices (including Cp , Cpj. , Cpm and Cpmk) that have been commonly used in the manufacturing industry to measure whether a process is capable of reproducing product items within the specified manufacturing tolerance. However the indices described earlier are appropriate measures only for processes with two-sided specifications only (which require specifying both USL and LSL). For the unilateral tolerance situation where only one specification limit is provided, Kane (1986) one of the early pioneers of process capability studies considered the following indices
Cpu
_ USL- n ~ 3a '
n CpL
146
_ fi-LSL ~ 3a
The CPUICPL Index
147
where USL and LSL are as above the upper and lower specification limits, respectively, \i is the process mean, and a is the process standard deviation. The index Cpu measures the capability of a "smaller-the-better" process with an upper specification limit USL, while the index CPL measures the capability of a "larger-the-better" process with a lower specification limit LSL. Process
yield measure
based on Cpu and Cpi
For normally distributed processes with specification limit USL, the process yield is given by
= P(Z <3CPU)=
one-sided
$(3CPU),
where the variable Z follows the standard normal distribution N(0, 1) with the c.d.f. $(z) = (2-K)1'2 P exp(-i 2 /2)dt. Similarly, J —oo
for normally distributed processes with one-sided specification limit LSL, the process yield is
P(X>LSL)=P(^<^=-^) = p(-iz
148
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
(2001)). These recommendations are summarized in Table 8.1 For existing manufacturing processes, the capability should be at least 1.25, and for new manufacturing processes, at least 1.45. For existing manufacturing processes dealing with safety, strength, or critical parameters, the capability must be no less than 1.45, whereas for new manufacturing processes dealing with the same issues, the capability ought to be no less than 1.60. In recent years, due to globalization various companies have adopted criteria for various evaluations of their processes based on capability objectives that are more stringent than the recommended minima. For instance, the popular "six-sigma" program pioneered by Motorola essentially requires that when the process mean is in control, it will not be closer than six standard deviations from the nearest specification limit. In effect, it requires that the process capability ratio will be at least 2.0. Table 8.1. Some minima capability requirements based on C/ for new and special processes. Ci Value 1.25
Production Process Type Existing Processes
1.45
New Processes; or Existing Processes involving Safety, Strength, or Critical Parameters
1.60
New Processes involving Safety, Strength, or Critical Parameters
8.2 Estimating and testing CPU/ CPL: Based on a single sample
8.2.1 Estimation
of CPU and CPL
In practice, sample data ought to be collected in order to calculate the indices CPU and CPL since the process mean fi and standard deviation a are usually unknown (as it was indicated in
The Cpu/ CPL Index
149
the previous chapters). To estimate the indices Cpy and CPL , Chou and Owen (1989) proposed Cpy and Cpi , the natural estimators of CPU and Cpi, defined as: Cpu
_ USL — x ~ 35 '
f, CpL
_x— LSL ~ 3s '
where as above x = Y^. xt / n is the sample mean, and s2 = (n — l ) - 1 ^ . _ A % i — x)2 is the sample variance, obtained from a process that is "demonstrably" stable (under statistical control). Under the normality assumption, the estimator Cpy is distributed as (3Vn) _1 tn_i(6) , where £n_i(<5) is a non-central t random variable with n — 1 degrees of freedom and the noncentrality parameter 8 = 3^/nCpu . The estimator Cpi has the same sampling distribution as Cpy with 6 = 3-fnCpi . However, both the estimators CPU and Cpi are biased. Pearn and Chen (2002) have shown that by adding the correction factor &„_! = [ 2 / ( n - l ) ] 1 / 2 r [ ( n - l ) / 2 ] / T [ ( n - 2 ) / 2 ] to CPU and CPL , one obtains unbiased estimators bn_i Cpy and hn_\ Cpi which have been denoted as Cpy and Cpi. That is, E(Cpu) = CPu , and E(Cpi) = CPL- Since 6n_! < 1, Var(CPU) < Var(CPU) and also Var{Cpi) < Var{Cpi) . The estimators CPU and Cp^ are based only on the complete and sufficient statistics (x,s2), consequently Cpy and Cp£ are the uniformly minimum variance unbiased estimators (UMVUEs) of Cpy and CPL, respectively.
8.2.2 r-th
moment
The r-th moment (about zero) and the variance of Cpy can be obtained as follows: set Z = -Jn(USL — x) / a , this variable is distributed as N(3*fnCPy,l). It is easy to verify that E(CPU) = Cpy under the normality assumption. It follows from the definitions of Z and that of Cpy that
150
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
^_(r[(n-l)/2])r-1r[(n-l-r)/2]
F(r
Var(CPU)
r[(n-l)/2] r[(n-3)/2]
=-
(r[(n-2)/2])
2
1
T
2
PU)
, 1 r[(n-l)/2] r[(n-3)/2] 9n (r[(rz-2)/2])2 The results for the r-th moment, the expected value, and the variance of the dual estimator CPL are analogous.
8.2.3
Distribution
We are changing the variables possessing the non-central t distribution with v = n — 1 degrees of freedom and the noncentrality parameter 8 = 3VnC; . Let X = Cj = 6„_i(3Vn)~ t„(6). The c.d.f. of Cj can be derived directly as: F(x) =
1 2(»-3)/2r[(n-l)/2] 2
poo
x I y Jo y
„ UlL n z 2
e
1
p3^/nxy/bn_l^/n-l
—f== | V2Wo
exp
-f(.-tf
dudy,
Here 6 = 3VnC 7 and 6n_i is the correction factor to CPu . Differentiating the equation of the c.d.f. with respect to y gives the p.d.f. of Cj to as
/(*)
3Vn/(n-l)-2-"/2 bn__l^fT[(n-l)/2]
L
(n-2)/2
x,o „
exp
2/ +
3xyfny [bn-iJn-1
dy,
The CPUICPL Index
151
where, as above, the correction factor is bn_i = 1/2 [2/(n - l)] r[(n - l)/2]/T[(n - 2)/2] and 8 = 3VnC 7 . Figures l(a)-l(b) display the p.d.f. of Ct for various CI =1.00, 1.25, 1.45, 1.60, 2.00 for n = 10 and 30, respectively. Figures 2(a)-2(b) display the c.d.f. of Cj for the same values of C/ and n.
8.2.4 Testing
hypothesis
with CPU and CPL
For processes with one-sided manufacturing specifications (requiring the existence of only one of USL or LSL, but not both), the index Cpy can be used to measure the capability of a smallerthe-better process for upper specification limit USL, whereas the index Cpi to measure the capability of a larger-the-better process with a lower specification limit LSL. To test whether a given process meets the capability requirement, we shall consider the following statistical testing hypothesis with HQ :Cj < C (the process is incapable), versus the alternative Hi :Cj > C (the process is capable). Consequently, one can utilize the test (p(x) = 1 if Cj > C0 , and ip(x) = 0 , otherwise. The test
\Cl
152
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
As above the critical value, C0, is then determined by:
p{c 7 >c 0 \cI = c)
a
= P Ci(«) >
3VnC0
Cj=C
Hence, we have 3VnC0
= tn-i,a(8)
or C0 =
fyI_id,a(tf)/(3Vn).
where, as above, tn__ia{6) is the upper a quantile of a non-central t distribution with n — 1 degrees of freedom satisfying P{tn-i(fi) > ^n-i,a(^)) = a • As indicated above, the sampling distribution of the UMVUE, (5/ , is bn^ (S^/n)"1 £„_i(6) , a noncentral t distribution with n — 1 degrees of freedom and noncentrality parameter 6 = 3VnC/ . Thus, the power of the test can be calculated as *(CI)
= P(CI
>C0\CJ)=P
1^(6)
>
3-JnC0) u
n-l
Under H0 for EC[ (ip(x)) = a , we obtain that the critical value is C0 = bn^i(3-Jn)~1tn_iQ(6), where 6 = 3~JnCj . Therefore, the test ip is a uniformly most powerful (UMP) test of size ECr(
The lot is accepted, if The lot is rejected,
Gt > ^ - t ^ 3vn otherwise.
a(6
= 3VnC 7 ).
The CPUICpL Index
8.2.5 Lower confidence
bound for
153
CPU/CPL
Critical values are used for making decisions in capability testing with designated type I error a which is the risk of misjudging an incapable process (H0 : Cj < C) as a capable one (Hi :Cj > C ). The Rvalues are used for making decisions in capability testing, which presents the actual risk of misjudging an incapable process (HQ :Cj < C) as a capable one (Hx :Cj > C). Thus, if p-value < a we then reject the null hypothesis, and conclude that the process is capable with the actual type I error pvalue (rather than a ) . Both approaches, the critical values and the p-values, do not convey any information regarding the minimal value (the lower confidence bound) of the actual process capability. Determination of the lower confidence bound on the actual process capability is essential for quality assurance. The lower confidence bound not only gives us a clue about the minimal level of the actual performance of the process which is closely related to the nonconforming units, but it is also useful for making decisions in the course of capability testing. Chou et al. (1990) established the lower confidence bounds on Cpu and Cpi based on the natural estimators Cpu and CPL. Let USL = x + kis and LSL — x — k^s , where kx = 3CPU and &2 = 3CPL • A 1007% lower confidence bound Cy for Cpu satisfies Pr (CPU > CJJ) = 7 . It can also be written as: 7 =
p r /^£> c \ =
= Pr
P r /£±^it>^
Z — 3-JnCu > -ki^n) sJa
or, equivalently, lower confidence It can be shown and in_1 (^2) a r e
= Pv(tn_i(6i) > -VnfcO,
Pr(f n _ 1 (6 1 ) < -Juki) = 7 . Similarly, a 1007% bound Ci for Cpi satisfies Pr (Cpi > Ci) = 7 . that Pr(i n _ 1 (5 2 ) < k^Vn) = 7 , where tn_i(8i) non-central t distributed random variables with
154
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
n — 1 degrees of freedom and the non-centrality 61 = 3-JnCu and 62 = 3VnCL , respectively.
parameters
Observe that these two estimators are biased. Pearn and Shu (2003) developed an algorithm (including a Matlab program) for calculating the lower confidence bounds on CPU and Cpi based on the UMVUEs and provide tables for the engineers/practitioners to be used in measuring their processes.
8.3 Estimating and testing CPU/ CPL: Based on multiple samples A common time honored practice of the process capability estimation in manufacturing industry is to implement first a routine-based data collection plans for controlling/monitoring the process stability, and then to analyze the past "in control" data. Kirmani et al. (1991) considered estimation of a and of the precision index Cp for cases where the data are given as multiple samples. Pearn and Yang (2003) proposed an unbiased estimator of Cp for multiple samples, and showed that the unbiased estimator is the UMVUE of Cp , which is asymptotically efficient. Li et al. (1990) have studied the distribution of estimators of Cp and Cpk based on ranges of multiple samples. More recently, under the assumption of normality, Vannman and Hubele (2003) investigated the distributional properties of estimators of a wide class of capability indices, containing the indices Cp , C^ , Cpm and Cpmj; based on multiple samples collected over time for an incontrol process.
8.3.1 Estimations
of CPU and CPL based on multiple
samples
Consider m preliminary multiple samples (subgroups) each of the same size n taken from control chart samples. We shall
The CPU/ CPL Index
155
assume that the sample of the characteristic under consideration, (Xii,Xi2,...,Xin) , follows a normal distribution N(/j,,a2) for i = 1,2,...,TO.The process mean is estimated by the grand average X and the process variance by the pooled sample variance S% from subsamples collected over time for an in-control process. Let x /n and Si 2 n 1 / 2 be the
* = EU v
= E"=i(*« - ^) /( -!)]
i-th sample mean and the sample standard deviation respectively. Then X = Yl™-\ %i I m and S2P = Y17=i ^ Im w i l 1 b e u n b i a s e d estimators of fi and a respectively. Pearn and Lin (2003) suggest an unbiased estimator of CPU and CPL of the following form: f,*
_ bm(n-i)(USL - X) ~ 3^ '
Cpu
^* CpL
~
_ bm(n-i){X - LSL) 35; '
where as above bg = (2 / gfl2T{g / 2)/T[(g - l ) / 2 ] is the correction factor already encountered earlier. Under the normally assumption, [3^/mn /fem(„_i)] x Cpu can be expressed as Zv /y/W Jm{n - 1) , where Zv = Z + 3JrrmCPU ~ N(6u,l) , Z ~ iV(0,l) , we have W = m{n - l)S2 /a2 ~ x ^ ^ , and Zv and W a r e independent. The estimator (3Vmn /& m ( n -i)) x Cpu is distributed as the non-central t variable with m(n — 1) degrees of freedom and the non-centrality parameter 8u — 3-JmnCPU . The estimator (3v?nn / bm(„_i)) x CPL has the same sampling distribution as {3-Jmn /6 m ( n -i)) x CPu but with the non-centrality parameter 8L = 3-Jm,nCPi . Furthermore, since CPU_a,nd CPL based solely on the complete and sufficient statistics (X,Sf,), one concludes that the estimators CPU and CPL are the UMVUEs of CPU and CPi respectively based on multiple samples. Thus, the c.d.f. of X = Cj (which denotes either Cpy or Cpi) can be derived as:
156
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
F(x) =
2^~2)l2T(g/2) poo
3Jg+mxy/bgJg
-JL
exp
yf2lrJo n Jo
-i(,-*j»
dudy.
We present a derivation in the Appendix (see Pearn and Wu (2003)). Differentiation with respect to x results in the p.d.f. of Cj given as:
m_
3y/(g + m)/g-2- (g+m)/2 bg^WT(g/2)
f °>-1)/2exPl *J 0
y+
3xy/(g + m)y bQJ~g
where as above bg = (2/g) 1/2 T{g/2)/F[(g and 6 = 3~JmnCj .
dy,
- l ) / 2 ] , 5 = m(n - 1)
From the plots of the p.d.f. of Cj for various sample sizes, we observe that (i) for fixed sample sizes m and n , the variance of Cj increases as Cj increases, (ii) for a fixed n and Cj , the variance of Cj decreases as m increases, and also (iii) for fixed m and Cj, the variance of Cj decreases as n increases. For cases with unequal sample sizes, the unbiased estimators of Cpu and Gpi can straightforwardly be generalized to be:
^PU —
T?
3S„
' ^PL —
d&r,
where X = '^2-_,iT'iXi /N is t h e grand mean of t h e overall sample, N = ]>J--i n » is the number of observations in the total sample and S% = X ^ w ( n » — ^)Sf /{N — m) is the pooled sample variance. From the representations
157
The Cpuj CPL Index
[2>^W^i/bN_m] x CpV = and where
Zu/ylW/iN-m),
[ 3 V F ^ T / bN_m] x C*PL = ZL / JW/(N - m) , Zv
and Zj, are as above Zv / yJW /(N — m) and are distributed as tv(6v) ( tv(6L) ), namely according to the non-central t distribution with v = N — m degrees of freedom and the non-centrality parameters 8u = 3VlV Cpu ( 6L = SJNCpi), respectively. We remind our readers that the process ought be stable in order to produce a reliable estimate of the process capability. If the process is being out of control in the early stages of process capability analysis, it would then be unreliable for estimating the process capability.
8.3.2 Testing
CPU and CPL based on multiple
samples
To test whether a given process meets the preset capability requirements and runs according to the desired quality condition, we can examine the following hypothesis: H0 :d
where g = N - m , bg = (2/g)ll2T{g/2)/T[(g - l)/2] , and tg^a{8) denotes the upper a -th percentile of a non-central t
158
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
variable with N — m degrees of freedom and the non-centrality parameter 6 = 3y/~NC[ . The power function may be expressed in the standard manner: (3{Cr,
=PT{C*J
>
C0\Cj}
Pv{tg(6)>3^NC0/bg}.
The size of the test is given by a(C0)=
sup P{Cj,
CreH0
Moreover, Pearn and Wu (2003) have shown that the test statistic
C*x > ^j^tN_m^a{8
= 3VJVC/).
otherwise.
The derivations of the lower confidence bounds, the p-values and the capability calculations for situations with multiple samples can be performed using the same techniques as in the cases with a single sample. However these calculations may be more involved. (See Pearn and Lin (2003), Pearn and Wu (2003) and Pearn et al. (2003) for details).
8.4 Estimating and testing CPU/ CPL: Bayesian approach with single sample 8.4.1 Bayesian approach to the assessment CPL based on single sample
of CPU and
A Bayesian procedure for assessing process capability was proposed in the early stages of process capability studies by Cheng
The CPU/ CPL Index
159
and Spiring (1989) for the initial primitive basic index Cp under the assumption that the process mean \i is equal to the target value T . However, the restriction that fi = T may not be a practical assumption for numerous industrial applications. (Bayesian approach has not been emphasized in the nineties of the 20-th century the formation and consolidation period of the PCI "technology".). In 1999 Shiau et al. suggested a Bayesian procedure for the general situation without restrictions on the process mean applied to the index Cpm. More recently, Pearn and Wu (2003) utilized a similar Bayesian approach for the capability index Cpk . For the one-sided specification limit, Pearn and Wu (2003) have derive a Bayesian interval estimate for Cpu and Cpi and proposed a Bayesian procedure for testing the process capability (relaxing the restrictions). We shall assume that the observations x = {xi,x2,- •-,£„} are random samples taken from independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) normal variables with the mean /j, and variance a2 N(^,a2). Under these assumptions, given a pre-specified capability level w > 0, the posterior probability p based on the index Cj that a process is capable can be expressed as: p = Pr{the process is capable| x}=Pr{C/ > w | x}
= /.
o
1 T(a)ya+1 exp
x $ 3Vn
' Cj %
K~\
r V,
dy V (n - l)y— w
(8.1)
where a — (n — l ) / 2 and, as above, $(•) is the c.d.f. of a standard normal variable. Note that the posterior probability p depends on n , w and Cj . When n and w are given, and since Cj can be calculated from the process data, there is a one-to-one correspondence between p and Cj. Therefore, it follows that the minimal value of Cj = C (p) , necessary to ensure that the
160
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
posterior probability p reaches a certain desirable level, can be useful for assessing process capability. In other words, to see if a process is capable (with capability level w and confidence level p), we only need to check whether Cj > C*(p). Pearn and Wu (2003) have provided tables of the minimal values of Cj , C*(p), for various confidence level p = 0.99, 0.95, 0.90, and commonly used capability requirements C / = 1.25, 1.45, 1.60.
8.4.2 A Bayesian approach to assessment CPL based on multiple samples
with CPU and
Posterior Probability for Multiple Control Chart Samples For cases where the data are collected as multiple control samples, we have considered m samples each of size nt and have suggested the unbiased estimators of Cpu and CPL , where Xj is the i-th sample mean, and St is the i-th sample standard deviation, and N = Y^Z.\ ni i s the number of items in the total sample. These estimators are: n* <^PU
_ bN-m(USL - X) a n a x,* _ bN_m(X - LSL) — w > ^PL — w >
where as above bg = (2/ g)1/2T(g /2) /T[(g - l)/2] , g = N-m, n X = Yl™- iXi IN is the overall sample mean, and S2P = ^2™- (n> ~ 1 )^' 2 IW ~ m ) *s * n e P°°l e d sample variance and with Sf = y^m_ (xtj —XifKrii —1). However, for multiple control samples, it is necessary to take into account the variations between them. To assess these variations Pearn and Wu (2003) suggest the ratio of total within sample variation ( SSW ) and total sum of squared variation (SST ) defined as:
161
The Cpu/ CPL Index
ssw _ 5 § ( ^ ^ ^ 2
7
ssr
E E (**• - ^)2 i=i j=i
2= 1
: E fo !)4 + E «ite *) i=i i=i
Similarly in these situations, the extension of the posterior probability p for multiple control samples can be expressed as: noo
1
Jo T(a)ya+1 6XP x $
3VF
27
^tf-m '^(N
dy, -m)y — w
(8.2)
where a — ()~]._ n, — 1) / 2 . Compare with (8.1) for a single sample, where the ratio 7 = 1, N — m = n — 1 , a = (n — 1) / 2 . In this case the estimator of Cj, (7/ , is reduced to the estimator Cr discussed before.
Chapter 9
Multi-Process Performance Analysis Charts (MPPAC)
9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5
Introduction The modified Cpk MPPAC The Cvm MPPAC The Spk MPPAC The Le MPPAC
9.1 Introduction In this short Chapter we shall describe a number of new practical procedures for improving the analysis of process capability based on the indices CP, Cpk, Cpm, Spk and some others. Ever since Shewhart (1944) introduced his pioneering control charts, it has become a common practice for practitioners to use various control charts for monitoring different processes on a routine basis. As an example, when dealing with a variable data, the control chart technique usually employs a chart (such as a X chart) to monitor the process center and a chart (such as an R chart or an S chart) to monitor the process spread. These charts are easy to comprehend, and they effectively communicate the critical process information without necessarily employing words and formulas. Unfortunately, they are applicable only for a single process (one process at a time). T h u s , using t h e m in multiprocess environment could be a clumsy and time-consuming task for supervisors or shop engineers since it may require to analyze each
162
Multi-Process Performance Analysis Chart (MPPAC)
163
individual chart in order to evaluate the overall status of shop process control activities. We have already pointed out that process capability index measures the ability of the process to reproduce products that meet certain specifications. When dealing with the capability of a process, there are mainly two characteristics of importance involved, the process location in relation to its target value and the process spread. The closer the process output is to the target value and the smaller is the process spread, the more capable will the process be. However, the fact that process capability indices combine information about closeness to target and the process spread, expressing the capability of a process by a single number, may in some instances be viewed as one of their major drawbacks. When a process is found to be "non-capable", the operator might be interested in knowing whether the non-capability is caused by the fact that the process output is substantially off target or that the process spread is too large, or is a result of a combination of these two factors. In order to circumvent this defect some current researchers in the last 15 years were suggesting that different graphical methods be used to ascertain the improvement initiatives aimed at generating more capable processes (see e.g. Gabel (1990), Boyles (1991), Tang et al. (1997) and Deleryd and Vannman (1999)). A Multi-process Performance Analysis Chart (MPPAC), proposed by Singhal (1990), which evaluates the performance of a multi-process product with symmetric bilateral specifications, provides priorities among multiple processes for capability improvement and reveals whether reducing the variability or the departure of the process mean should be the main task for improvement. While Cpu and Cp\ present the X-axis and Y-axis, respectively in a MPPAC, Cp is the average of Cpu and Cpi , namely, Cp = (Cpu + Cpi) / 2 . Moreover, the Cpk MPPAC provides an efficient route to process improvement by comparing the locations on the chart of the processes before and after an improvement effort has been carried out. Singhal (1991) also provides a MPPAC with several welldefined capability zones by using the process capability indices Cp
164
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
and Cpk for grouping the processes in a multiple process environment, into different performance categories on a single chart (see Figure 9.1). This is very helpful when process performance is measured in terms of capability indices. Different capability zones describe a status of each process which is easy to interpret and assist in grouping the processes into performance categories for the purpose of quality improvement operations. The American giant corporation Motorola Inc. introduced their six sigma (6-cr) program (Mikel (1988)) which is equivalent to a defect rate of 3.4 parts per million (PPM). This program corresponds to a Cp value of 2.0 or more and a Cp^ value of 1.5 or more. All this is done under an implicit normal assumption. A Cp value of 2.0 tells us that the specification width is twice as wide as the distribution of the process (with a defect rate of 0.002 PPM) as long as the process mean is equal to the target value. Under the six sigma program, the process mean is allowed to shift as much as 1.5 sigma and still obtain a Cp^ value of 1.5 or more. (See Chapter 2 for the relation between the PPM defect rate and the values of PCI's)
Figure 9.1. MPPAC with capability and six sigma zones (Reproduced from Singhal (1991))
In practical applications, when a product has several models with required different specifications needs to monitor and control,
Multi-Process Performance Analysis Chart (MPPAC)
165
it may be difficult or very time-consuming to carry out factory control activities. As it was mention above, a MPPAC not only evaluates the performance of a multi-process product with symmetric bilateral specifications but also sets the priorities among multiple processes for capability improvement and indicate whether reducing the variability, or adjusting the departure of the process mean should be the focus of improvement operations. This renders a MPPAC to be an efficient tool for communicating between product designer, manufacturers, quality engineers, and among various management departments.
9.2 The modified Cpk MPPAC Pearn and Chen (1997) proposed a modification to the Cpk MPPAC combining the more-advanced process capability indices, Cpm or Cpmk, to identify the problems causing processes' failings to center around the target value. Under this modification the performance of an entire product, composed of the-nominal-thebest, the-larger-the-better, and the-smaller-the-better characteristics, could be measured. The modified Cpk MPPAC is shown in Figure 9.2, with five capability zones corresponding to the five standard process conditions for Cpk = 1.00, 1.33, 1.67, and 2.00. We mark these process capability zones with bold lines as the critical values of individual process capabilities for the multi-process product on MPPAC chart, and the corresponding fractions of nonconformities (in PPM) are summarized in Table 9.1 (see also Montgomery (2001)) among other sources. In this modified MPPAC, Cpu and Cp\ represent the X-axis and Y-axis, respectively. Recall that Cp is the average of Cpu and Cpi > [ CP = (C pu + Cpi) / 2 ] and Cpk is the minimum value of the X- and Y-axes [ Cpk = min{C pu ,C p ;} ]. Hence, based on Cpk MPPAC, the vertical and horizontal axes of the chart are geared to evaluate the-larger-the-better and the-smaller-the-better characteristics.
166
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
Combining Singhal's MPPAC with asymmetric process capability index Cpa , and considering unilateral characteristics, Chen et al. (2001) introduced a Process Capability Analysis Chart (PCAC) to evaluate the process potential and performance for an entire product composed of the-smaller-the-better, the-larger-thebetter, symmetric and asymmetric specifications. As mentioned above, the process yield of a multi-process product is lower than of any individual process yield. Similarly, when the entire product capability is preset to satisfy the required level, the individual process capability should exceed the preset standard for the entire product. Therefore, the process capabilities are recognized to be capable if all of the individual process capability indices are located within the process capability zone. Conversely, processes must be upgraded when some of the process capability indices are located outside this zone. It is straightforward to distinguish process performance with respect to the locations of process capability indices on a modified Cpk MPPAC. Hence, the modified Cpk MPPAC not just distinguishes process capabilities, but also reveals the degree of quality accuracy for multi-process products. This makes the modified Cpk MPPAC to be an effective and efficient tool for evaluating multi-process products, composed of numerous unilateral and bilateral specifications. C, =• 0.50
C , = 0.75
--7—
/ /
/
/
/
C, = 0.875
—r
/
. /
/
/
, - • "
/ • / /
/
, - • "
•
/ / ,• / / , • • - ' . , -
, • • • • -
/
.*'••
. • • *
" " " ' , - • • - " " " "
I ///sO*
/M*< 0.50
1.00
1-33
167
i m
C„
Figure 9.2. The modified Cpk MPPAC with capability zones for Cpk = 1.00, 1.33, 1.67, and 2.00.
Multi-Process Performance Analysis Chart (MPPAC)
167
Recall (Chapter 5) that the loss function utilized in the G. Taguchi method has the property that the closer the process mean is to the process target the better quality and fewer process losses are encountered. Conversely, the farther the process mean is located from the process target the worse are process capabilities. Keeping the process on-target is crucial for smooth operation. A few subsidiary lines of Ca = 1 — |/x — M\j d can be added on a MPPAC for controlling accurately the process centering. The index Ca measures what is known to be the relative distance of the shift from process mean to the preset target. (The defmition of relative distance is (/J, — M) / d or (M — fi) / d .) Evidently, equal relative distances result in the same values of Ca . Note that the preset target value coincided with the midpoint of the specifications (i.e. T = M). Off-diagonal subsidiary lines are plotted for values of Ca 0.500, 0.750 and 0.875 in Figure 9.2. Ca < 0.875 indicates that the process is not accurate and some actions to shift the process mean closer to the process target are required. Equivalently, Ca > 0.875 indicates that a process possesses quite a good accuracy. In general, Ca should not be too small, since it would imply that the process mean shifts further away from the process target which results in a substantial process loss. Set r = | [i — M | / d , then the values of [i will be M + r x d and M — r x d for each Ca . The slope of the corresponding subsidiary line is (1 + r ) / ( l — r) when the process mean is greater than the process target, and analogously the slope of the corresponding subsidiary line is (1 — r ) / ( l + r) when the process mean is greater than the process target, and analogously the slope of the corresponding subsidiary line is (1 — r) /(l + r) when the process mean is greater than the process target, and analogously the slope of the corresponding subsidiary line is (1 — r ) / ( l + r) when the process mean is smaller than the process target. Table 9.1 displays
168
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
five values of Ca with the corresponding fx, r , and the slopes of the subsidiary lines. Table 9.1. The values of Ca with the corresponding /J,, r , and the slope of lines. Ca 1.000 0.875 0.750 0.500 0.250 0.000
M M M M M M M M
+ + + + -
P M 0.125 0.125 0.250 0.250 0.500 0.500 0.750 0.750 USL LSL
xd xef xd xd xd xd xd xd
r
Slope
0.000 0.125 0.125 0.250 0.250 0.500 0.500 0.750 0.750 1.000 1.000
1.000 1.286 0.778 1.667 0.600 3.000 0.333 7.000 0.143 00
0.000
Concerning the modified Cpk MPPAC, it is useful to observe that: [a]
The parallel and perpendicular lines through the plotted point intersecting the vertical axis (y-axis) and the horizontal axis (x-axis) at the points represented by Cpu = (USL — ^)/(3<x) and Cpi = (/i — LSL)/(3a), respectively.
[b] The 7r/4 subsidiary line (i.e. the line with the slope 1) represents the points where the process mean equal to the target (// = M = T) and the values of the indices Cpu, Cpt and Cpk are equal. [c]
For the points inside the area to the right of the 7r/4 subsidiary line (i.e. with the slope < 1) represents processes with the process mean shifted towards the lower specification limit (i.e. the process mean is lower than the target value), or Cpk = Cpi < Cpu. On the other hand, for the points inside the area to the left of the 7r/4 subsidiary line (i.e. with the slope > 1) represents processes with the process mean shifted
Multi-Process Performance Analysis Chart (MPPAC)
169
towards the upper specification limit (the process mean is higher than the target value), or Cpk = Cpu < Cv\. [d] The origin point represents a process with Cpk = Cpu = Cpi — 0 which means that the standard deviation of the process is infinite or that the process mean lies at USL or LSL. In quality improvement, reduction of variation from the target is of the same importance as increasing the process yield and reduction of the process spread. The modified Cpk MPPAC combines the two concepts - closeness to the target and narrow spread - in more efficient manner than using a process capability index alone. If the cases when exact values of \x and a are known, the modified C^ MPPAC can easily be applied. In other words, if the corresponding value of {Cpu,Cpi) is inside the capability region, the process is then defined to be capable, and if the value is outside, the process is defined as a non-capable one. In practice, however, we never know the true values of Cpu and Cv\ • Pearn and Wu (2004) developed a procedure to construct the lower confidence bounds on the indices Cpk , Cpu , and Cpi for each characteristic type. These lower confidence bounds can simultaneously be plotted on a single chart to check whether the process output is off target or that the process spread is too wide (or if a combination of these two situations takes places).
9.3 The Cpm MPPAC
Since the index c simultaneously measures process variability and centering (see Chapter 5), a Cpm MPPAC provides a convenient way to identify problems in process capability after statistical control has been established. Based on the definition, set Cpm = h , for various h values, then a set of (n,a) values satisfying the equation:
170
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices 2
a (d/3)
+
f(M-r)l
2
d/3
can be plotted on the contour (indifference curve) of Cpm = h. These contours are semicircles centered at (T, 0) of radius 1/ h . The more capable the process, the smaller is the semicircle. Six contours of the Cpm MPPAC for the six common values for Cpm = 1/3, 1/2, 1, 1.33, 1.67, and 2, are shown in Figure 9.3. Concerning the Cpm MPPAC, it is worth observing that: [a]
The parallel and perpendicular lines through the plotted point intersect the vertical and horizontal axes at the points represented by (a / (d / 3) )2 and ( 0 - T) / (d / 3) f , respectively.
[b] The distance between T and the point at which the perpendicular line through the plotted point intersects the horizontal axis, corresponds to the departure of the process mean from the target. [c]
The distance between 0 and the point at which the parallel line through the plotted point intersects the vertical axis represents the process variance.
[d] For the points inside of the semicircle of the contour (the indifference curve) Cpm = h , the corresponding Cpm values are larger than h . For the points outside of the semicircle of the contour Cpm — h the corresponding Cpm values are smaller than h. [e]
As the point gets closer to the target values the value of the Cpm becomes larger, and the process performance improves.
[f]
For processes with a fixed value of Cpm , the points within the two 7r/4 lines envelop, the process variability is due mainly to the process variance.
Multi-Process Performance Analysis Chart (MPPAC)
171
[g] For processes with a fixed value of Cpm , the points outside the two 7r/4 lines envelop, the process variability is due mainly to the process departure. (o/(d/3))2
9
Target Line
4
1
0.SS5 (U59 0.25
0,359 0.MS
(c/(d/3)f
1
4
Figure 9.3. The contours of a Cpm MPPAC.
The Cpm MPPAC conveys critical information about a multiple processes concerning the process departure and the process variability using a single chart. Current research about MPPAC is restricted to obtaining quality information from single sample of each process ignoring the sampling errors. The information provided from the existing MPPAC chart can therefore be unreliable and misleading resulting in incorrect decisions. Pearn et al. (2004) investigate the accuracy of estimation as a function of the process characteristic parameter £ = (/x — T) / a , given a group of multiple control chart samples. Data regarding the true capability values and the maximum of nonconformities (in PPM) are provided for production quality control. Suitable sample sizes are then recommended to the proposed Cpm MPPAC for multiple processes production quality control. This approach ensures that the critical information obtained from the Cpm MPPAC based on multiple control chart samples, is more reliable.
172
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
9.4 The Spk MPPAC Based on the yield index Spk (see Chapter 7), Boyles (1994) developed the so-called Spk contour plot that is a contour plot of the index Spk as a function of the process parameters (//, a), to be used for monitoring and controlling process performance. In fact, the Spk contour plot is a handy tool for evaluating multiple processes since it allows to obtain the process yield and the process departure ratio by checking the location of the index value appearing on the contour plot. For multiple processes with the same specification limits, the contour plot not only shows the process capability for multiple processes simultaneously, but also provides a quick reference about the parameters that should be targeted for process improvements. We note, however, that the Spk contour plot is applicable only for multiple processes with same specification limits on each single process which may not be appropriate for processes with multiple characteristics when the characteristic specifications are not equal. To enable the applicability of the contour plot for processes with multiple characteristics, Chen et al. (2003) applied the method developed by Deleryd and Vannman (1999) who introduced a process capability plot, called the (6,7) -plot, which is an adjustment of Boyles' (/i, <j)-plot where 6 — (/J, — T)/d , and 7 = a I d . The authors readjusted the definition of Spk in the following manner: bpk —
+ •.
M
3
12
I*"1 [5*
\
a 1 — Qr
,
Cdp
+
.
> .
LSL
^
[1 + C«*r]l ,
C
dp
J.
where Cdr = (// — T) / d , Cdp — a j d and $ is the standard normal c.d.f. Note that Cdr measures the departure ratio and Cdp measures the variation relative to the specification tolerance.
Multi-Process Performance Analysis Chart (MPPAC)
173
If /j, < T (/x > T), we have Cdr < 0 (Cdr > 0 ) , and when/i = T , Cdr = 0 (process is on target). Evidently, if zx = £SX , Cdr = — 1; and for /x = £/5X , C^ = 1. The new expression of Spk is for the case where the specification interval is two-sided with the target value T at M , a most common practical situation. Using Cdr as the x-axis and Cdp as the y-axis, Chen et al. (2003) have plotted the following point set forming the curve of Spk (bold-shape curve in Figure 9.4) on the (Cdr, Cdp) coordinates:
{cdr,cdp)\^-1
1 — Cdr
!« ,
C
dv
+
,
i + cdr
> . ,
C
dp
bpk ,
We note that the process capability plot is invariant to the value of the specification limits. Processes with multiple characteristics having different characteristic specification limits can thus be plotted simultaneously on a single chart. Chen et al. (2003) call this control chart a Multi-Characteristic Process Capability Analysis (MCPCA) chart. In Figure 9.4, the top curve is the capability plot for processes with Spk = 1.00, and the bottom one is the plot for processes with S^ = 1.33. As we have mentioned above (Chapter 7), Spk is a yieldbased index. According to the modern quality improvement theories, reduction of the variation from the target is as important a step increasing the process yield (i.e. meeting the specifications). Therefore, three pairs of control limits I1( I2, and I3 are drawn on the MCPCA chart (in Figure 9.4) to monitor the variation from the target of each one of the characteristics. Corresponding to the three pairs of control limits I1( I2, and I3, the six values of Cdr =(n-T)/d are -1.0, -0.5, -0.25, 0.25, 0.5, and 1.0 from the left to the right, respectively.
174
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
0.35-
0.30.25-
0.20.150.10.05-
0-1
-0.5
-0.25
0
_ 0.25
0.5
1
dr
Figure 9.4. A Sp^ MCPCA chart with several departure control zones.
Table 9.2. Various control regions for a process departure and improvement assessments. Control Region
C^ Value
Process Improvement Assessment
I
±0.25
characteristic departure is tolerable
I
±0.50
characteristic investigation desirable
I
± 1.00
characteristic departure is serious, the overall process should be reviewed.
departure is abnormal, and improvements are
In terms of the six-sigma quality improvement program (as formulated by Motorola, see, e.g., Noguera and Nielsen (1992)) setting d = 6cr , the three pairs of the control limits I t , I2, and I3 correspond to \ y, — T \= 1.5a, 3cr and 6
Multi-Process Performance Analysis Chart (MPPAC)
175
PPM of non-conformities, assuming that the specification limits are 6cr away from the target. Under the assumption of normality and stationarity of the process (see Chapter 2), the three pairs of control limits Il5 I2, and I3 provide various process accuracies (the degree of centering) of the control zones. Various control regions (zones) for process departure and the improvement assessments are summarized in Table 9.2. Practitioners can judge the degree of centering of the characteristic j by checking the location of the corresponding plotted point on a MCPCA chart. For example, the departure measure C^r value is equal to -0.5 for the characteristic A in Figure 9.4. This departure ratio is considered to be significant which calls for an immediate check to determine the abnormal changes of the parameter settings. Using a MCPCA chart, the practitioners can thus effectively control and monitor both the variation and the departure from its target for each single process characteristic.
0.350.30.250.20.150.10.050". -1
, -0.5
-0.25
, 0
. 0.25
. 0.5
. ~dr 1 dr
Figure 9.5. A MCPCA chart with contours of Spk = 1.00, 1.33, 1.50, 1.67, 2.00 (from top to bottom).
In a MCPCA chart (see Figure 9.5), we use standardized measures of process departure and process variation. Consequently, a MCPCA chart can be used for processes with multiple
176
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
characteristics where the individual characteristic specifications are not identical. The MCPCA chart displays all characteristic index values on one chart, and provides the characteristic yield based on the Spk contours. It can present instantly the information about the locations and spreads of all the characteristics under study by their (Cjr, Cdp) - coordinate values. The MCPCA chart also displays the relative magnitudes of the process variation and process departure in terms of the standardized measures (Crfr, C
9.5 The Le MPPAC As we have already discussed in Chapter 7 it were Hsiang and Taguchi (1985) who first introduced the loss function approach to quality improvement which focuses on reduction of variation around the target value. Johnson (1992) introduced the relative expected loss Le for symmetric cases, to provide numerical measures of process performance for industrial applications. Tsui (1997) interpret Le = Lpe + Lot , which results in an uncontaminated separation between the information concerning the process relative inconsistency loss ( Lpe ) and the process relative off-target loss (Lot). The index Le is defined as a ratio of the expected quadratic loss and the square of the half specification width as follows:
=/:
(x - Tf d2
dF(X) = r-\ + dl
ti-T \ d
2
Multi-Process Performance Analysis Chart (MPPAC)
177
where F(-) is the c.d.f. of the measured characteristic. The first term (cr / d)2 is denoted Lpe , and the second [(/i — T) I df is denoted Lot , and Le can thus be rewritten as Le = Lpe + Lot. The mathematical relationships: Le = (3C p m )" 2 , Lot = (1 - Ca)2 , and Lpe = (3C p )~ 2 can easily be established as indicated in Chapter 5. The advantage of using an equivalent index Le over Cpm is that an estimator of the former has superior statistical properties than that of the latter, since the former does not involve a reciprocal transformation of the process mean and variance. (See Chapter 4, Section 2 for a definition of Cpm.) The index Le also provides an uncontaminated separation between information concerning the process precision and the process accuracy. This separation indicates a direction practitioners may follow in modifying the process parameters to improve the process quality. Some commonly encountered values of Le are: 1.00 (a process is incapable), 0.44 (a process is incapable), 0.11 (a process is usually referred to as capable), 0.06 (process is called satisfactory), 0.05 (process is normally called good), 0.04 (process is normally called excellent), and 0.03 (process is designated as super). The corresponding Cpm values are also listed in Table 9.3. Table 9.3. Some commonly used Le values and the equivalent Cpm . Condition
Le
Cpm
Incapable
1.00
0.33
Incapable
0.44
0.50
Capable
0.11
1.00
Satisfactory
0.06
1.33
Good
0.05
1.50
Excellent
0.04
1.67
Super
0.03
2.00
The sub-index Lot measures the relative process departure, which as mentioned above, has been referred to as the relative offtarget loss index. The sub-index Lpe, as it was already pointed out,
178
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
measures process variation relative to the specification tolerance, and has been referred to as the relative inconsistency loss index. Some commonly used values of Lpe are: 0.11, 0.06, 0.05, 0.04 and 0.03. The corresponding quality conditions are indicated in Table 9.4. Evidently, theses 5 values of Lpe are equivalent to the Cp values of 1.00, 1.33, 1.50, 1.67, and 2.00, respectively, thus covering a wide range of the precision requirements needed for numerous real-world applications. Table 9.4. Some commonly used precision requirements. Quality Condition
Precision Requirement
Incapable
Lpi = 1 00
0.11 <
Lpe
Capable
0.06 < Lpe
< 0.11
Satisfactory
0.05 < Lpe
< 0.06
Good
0.04 < Lpe
< 0.05
Excellent
0.03 < Lpe
< 0.04
Super
Lpe
Target
LSL
U = 1.00 Ui = 0AA i-o,= 0.11
J
< 0.03
USL
tof=t).11
Ut = 0.AA ^ = 1.00
Figure 9.6. The Le MPPAC.
Pearn et al. (2003) using the expected loss index Le introduced a novel control chart, called the Le MPPAC. Based on the definition, Le = (// - T) 2 / d2 + a2 / d2 , we set Le = k for various k values, and then determine a set of (/i, a) values satisfying the equation: (/U - T)2 + a2 = kd2 which can be
Multi-Process Performance Analysis Chart (MPPAC)
179
plotted on the contour (a curve) of Le = k . These contours are semicircles centered at fi = T with the radius yfkd . Analogously to the situation encountered in the case of the Cpm index, the more capable is the process, the smaller is the semicircle. The seven contours on the Le MPPAC for the seven Le values listed in Table 9.3 are shown in Figure 9.6. Note a certain clustering of the semicircles for smaller values of k . A Le MPPAC has the following properties worth of mentioning: (1)
As a point gets closer to the target, the value of Le becomes smaller, and the process performance improves.
(2)
For the points inside the semicircle of the contour Le — k, the corresponding Le values are smaller than k. Analogously, for the points outside the semicircle of contour the Le = k, the corresponding Le are larger than k.
(3)
For processes with fixed values of Le, for the points within the two 7r/4 lines envelop, the variability is due mainly to the process variance.
(4)
For processes with fixed values of Le, for the points outside the two 7r/4 lines envelop, the variability is due mainly to the process departure.
(5)
The perpendicular and parallel lines passing through a plotted point intersect the horizontal and vertical axes at the points that represent its Lot and Lpe, respectively.
(6)
The distance between T and the point, at which the perpendicular line through the plotted point intersects the horizontal axis, denotes the departure of the process mean from the target.
(7)
The distance between T and the point, at which the parallel line through the plotted point intersects the vertical axis, denotes the departure of the process variance.
180
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
In addition, Pearn et al. (2003) obtained the exact upper confidence bound for the Le to provide a measure of the maximal expected loss of a process based on the sample data. The proposed decision - making procedure ensures that the risk of making a wrong decision would not exceed the preset Type I error. The Le MPPAC displays multiple processes with the mean departure and the process variability relative to the specification tolerances on a single chart, which is very appropriate for manufacturing capability control of a group of processes in a multiple process environment. Also the Le MPPAC prioritizes the order in which a further capability improvement effort should be accomplished: either to move the process mean closer to the target value or to reduce the process variation.
Chapter 10
PCIs with Asymmetric Specification Limits
10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5 10.6
Introduction The Cpk index for asymmetric tolerances The Cpm index for asymmetric tolerances The Cpn index for asymmetric tolerances The Crmk index for asymmetric tolerances The Loss index for asymmetric tolerances
10.1 Introduction
The concert of symmetric tolerance was used tacitly in this beak on numerous occasions. A process is said to have a symmetric tolerance if the target value T is set to be the mid-point of the specification interval [LSL, USL], i.e. T = M = (USL + LSL) / 2 . Most research in quality assurance literature has been focused so far on cases in which the manufacturing tolerance is symmetric. Examples include the earlier paper by Kane (1986), Chan et al. (1988), Choi and Owen (1990), Boyles (1991), Pearn et al. (1992), V a n n m a n (1995), V a n n m a n and Kotz (1995), Spiring (1997), P e a r n et al. (1998), P e a r n et al. (2003a, 2003b) among many others. Granted t h a t cases with symmetric tolerances are quite common in practical situations, cases with asymmetric tolerances ( T vt M) (see Figure 10.1) also often occur in the manufacturing industry. F r o m the customer's point of view, asymmetric tolerances reflect t h a t deviations from the target t h a t are less
181
182
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
tolerable in one direction than the other (see Boyles (1994), Vannman (1997), and Wu and Tang (1998)). Usually they are not directly related to the shape of the supplier's process distribution. Nevertheless, asymmetric tolerances can also arise in those situations where the tolerances are symmetric to start with, but the process distribution is skewed or follows a non-normal distribution. To deal with this the data are usually transformed to achieve approximate normality. A prominent example of this approach is Chou et al. (1998) who have used the well known, time - honored Johnson (1949) curves to transform the non-normal process data. Unfortunately, there has been so far comparatively few research publications dealing with asymmetric tolerances. (Exceptions are Choi and Owen (1990), Boyles (1994), Vannman (1997), Chen (1998), Pearn et al. (1998, 1999), Chen et al. (1999), and the more recent Jessenberger and Weihs (2000)).
OS
0*
Loss 04
0]
-n
t
35
Figure 10.1 Assymmetric tolerance.
10.2 The Cpk index for asymmetric tolerances To account for the asymmetry, Kane (1986) seems to be the first to modify Cp , Cpk , Cpu and Cpt indices for the situations
PCIs with Asymmetric Specification
Limits
183
where USL — T ^ T — LSL . These modifications are denoted by Cp , C*pk , Cpu and Gv\, and define to be Cp = min
USL-T 3a
Cpk -=
T - LSL ' 3a
min[C*pu,C*pi } ,
(10.1) (10.2)
where
r —
USL-T 3a
1-
I V-T\ USL-T
)
> Cpi
—
T
-LSL 3a
\H-T\ T -LSL,
respectively. Observe that the index Cp represents the relative size of the smaller (one-sided) semi-tolerance, rather than the relative size of the entire specification range involved in Cp . The semi-tolerances are, by definition, the distances between the target and the specification limits. In these cases, the potential of a process is interpreted in terms of the ability of the distribution's half-width to fit within the (smaller) semi-tolerance. These indices attain their maximum at [i = T . For example, the upper limits for Cpt a n d o pU are (T — LSL) / 3a and (USL — T) / 3a , respectively, while the original indices Cpu and Cpi do not possess upper bounds. The values (T - LSL) / 3a and (USL - T) / 3a are the arguments of the min function in Cp (equation (10.1)). As the mean deviates from the target, the value of Cp decreases linearly. When the mean shifts by a distance equal to or exceeding the corresponding semi-tolerance, the index value reduces to zero. Consequently C*pt = 0 if | ji - T \ > T - LSL , while C*pu = 0 if | /i — T | > USL — T . These properties can be used for an onesided specification limit with a target value. The index C ^ is also defined to be zero for | /x — T | > T — LSL or | \i - T \ > USL — T and can be represented as:
184
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
Cpk — Cp (1 — k J ,
where k* =\fi-T |/min{T - LSL,USL - T} . Therefore C*pk has a maximum value equal to Cp , which is attained when fj, = T corresponding to k = 0 . Also, C*pk will have zero value whenever the mean is shifted away from the target by an amount equal to or exceeding the smaller semi-tolerance (i.e. Cpk = 0 for k > 1 ). Recall that the index Cpk vanishes only when the mean is located at or outside the specification limits. The initial generalization developed for processes with asymmetric tolerances simply shifts one of the two specification limits, so that the new (shifted) specification limits become symmetric with respect to the target value (Kane (1986); Chan et al. (1988)). In other words, this generalization replaces the original specification limits (T — DhT + Du) by the new symmetric limits (on occasion admittedly unjustified) T ± d , where d = min{D u ,D,} , Du =USL - T , Dl =T - LSL , in order to apply the standard definition of Cpk . The generalization may be rewritten as:
c;k = d*~l£a~Tl.
(io.3)
Evidently, if Du = Dt , the specification tolerance becomes symmetric and the generalization as expressed by equation (10.3) reduces to the original Cpk defined in (3.1). Boyles (1994) notes that this generalization can underestimate the process capability by restricting the process to a proper subset of the actual specification range. Indeed consider a process with n = T — d / 2 and
PCIs with Asymmetric Specification
185
Limits
l_i = T - d/2 = 30, and a = d/3 = 2 0 / 3 is depicted in Figure 10.2.
Figure 10.2. An example for USL = 50, LSL = 10 , T = 40 , fi = 30 , ]and cr = 2 0 / 3 .
An alternative generalization suggested for processes with asymmetric tolerances shifts both specification limits to arrive at one that is symmetric (Franklin and Wasserman (1992), Kushler and Hurley (1992)). This modification replaces the original specification limits (T — DhT + Du) with the new symmetric limits T ± (D[ + Du)/2 (which, as in the previous situation, may sometimes be unjustified), and next applies the standard definition of Cpk . For this generalization, the index Cpfc (defined in equation (3.1)) can be rewritten as:
CL pk
d'-\n-T 3a
(10.4)
where d' = (Dt + Du) / 2. Evidently if Du = Dt , the specification tolerance becomes symmetric and C'pk defined in equation (10.4) reduces to Cp£ . Boyles (1994) also observes that this approach can
186
Encyclopedia and Handbook of Process Capability Indices
either understate or overstate the process capability, depending on the position of /x relative to T . Indeed, consider two processes A and B with fiA = T - d , aA = d/6 , fiB = T - 3d / 4 , aB=d/U and T = (3USL + LSL)/4 . For the process A we have A Cpk = 0 . While the expected proportion nonconforming is approximately 0.135%. Consequently, in this case C'pk understates the capability of the process A. In contrast, it is straightforward to be verity that for the process B, BC'pk = 1. Here however, the expected proportion nonconforming is approximately 99.865% rather than (See Fig 10.3). Obviously g C ^ overstates the process capability. To remedy the situation, Pearn and Chen (1998) proposed the index Cpk , - another