Engineering Turbulence Modelling and Experiments 6
Elsevier Internet Homepage - http://www.elsevier.com
Consult the Elsevier homepage for full catalogue information on all books, major reference works, journals, electronic products and services. Elsevier Titles of Related Interest
Satish Kandlikar Heat Transfer and Fluid Flow in Minichannels and Microchannels 2005, 0-08-044527-6 W. Rodi Engineering Turbulence Modelling and Experiments 5 2002, 0-08-044114-9 Michael Paidoussis Fluid-Structure Interactions 1 1999, 0-12-544360-9 Michael Paidoussis Fluid-Structure Interactions 2 2003, 0-12-544361-7 Related Journals:
Elsevier publishes a wide-ranging portfolio of high quality research journals, including papers detailing the research and development of engineering turbulence modelling and measurement. A sample journal issue is available online by visiting the Elsevier web site (details at the top of this page). Leading titles include: International Joumal of Heat and Mass Transfer Joumal of Non-Newtonian Fluid Mechanics International Joumal of Thermal Sciences Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science Computers and Fluids Intemational Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow International Joumal of Multiphase Flow International Journal of Engineering Science Computers and Fluids Journal of Fluids and Structures European Journal of Mechanics B/Fluids International Journal of Refrigeration Fluid Dynamics Research Journal of Sound and Vibration Applied Thermal Engineering All journals are available online via ScienceDirect: www.sciencedirect.com To contact the Publisher
Elsevier welcomes enquiries concerning publishing proposals: books, journal special issues, conference proceedings, etc. All formats and media can be considered. Should you have a publishing proposal you wish to discuss, please contact, without obligation, the publisher responsible for Elsevier's Material Science programme: Lynne Clayton Honigmann Publisher Elsevier Ltd The Boulevard, Langford Lane Kidlington, Oxford OX5 1GB, UK
Phone: Fax: E.mail:
+441865 84 3987 +44 1865 84 3931
[email protected]
General enquiries, including placing orders, should be directed to Elsevier's Regional Sales Offices - please access the Elsevier homepage for full contact details (homepage details at the top of this page).
Engineering Turbulence Modelling and Experiments 6 Procedings of the ERCOFTAC International Symposium on Engineering Turbulence Modelling and Measurements - ETMM6 Sardinia, Italy, 23-25 May, 2005
Edited by
W. RODI Instimt ftir Hydromechanik Universit~it Karlsruhe Karlsruhe, Germany
M. MULAS Computational Fluid Dynamics CRS4 Pula (Cagliari), Italy
2005
ELSEVIER Amsterdam Boston Heidelberg London New York Oxford Paris San Diego San Francisco Singapore Sydney Tokyo
ELSEVIER B . V . Radarweg 29 P.O. Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam The Netherlands
ELSEVIER Inc. 525 B Street, Suite 1900 San Diego, CA 92101-4495 USA
ELSEVIER Ltd The Boulevard, Langford Lane Kidlington, Oxford OX5 I GB UK
ELSEVIER Ltd 84 Theobalds Road London WC 1X 8RR UK
9 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. This work is protected under copyright by Elsevier Ltd, and the following terms and conditions apply to its use:
Photocopying Single photocopies of single chapters may be made for personal use as allowed by national copyright laws. Permission of the Publisher and payment of a fee is required for all other photocopying, including multiple or systematic copying, copying for advertising or promotional purposes, resale, and all forms of document delivery. Special rates are available for educational institutions that wish to make photocopies for nonprofit educational classroom use. Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier's Rights Department in Oxford, UK; phone: (+44) 1865 843830, fax: (+44) 1865 853333, e-mail:
[email protected]. Requests may also be completed on-line via the Elsevierhomepage (http://www.elsevier.com/locate/permissions). In the USA, users may clear permissions and make payments through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA; phone: (+1) (978) 7508400, fax: (+1) (978) 7504744, and in the UK through the Copyright Licensing Agency Rapid Clearance Service (CLARCS), 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P 0LP, UK; phone: (+44) 20 7631 5555; fax: (+44) 20 7631 5500. Other countries may have a local reprographic rights agency for payments. Derivative Works Tables of contents may be reproduced for internal circulation, but permission of the Publisher is required for external resale or distribution of such material. Permission of the Publisher is required for all other derivative works, including compilations and translations. Electronic Storage or Usage Permission of the Publisher is required to store or use electronically any material contained in this work, including any chapter or part of a chapter. Except as outlined above, no part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission of the Publisher. Address permissions requests to: Elsevier's Rights Department, at the fax and e-mail addresses noted above. Notice No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made. 1st edition 2005 ISBN: 0 08 044544 6 Printed in Great Britain
Working together to grow libraries in developing countries www.elscvicr.com I www-bookaid-org I www.sabre.org
SYMPOSIUM SCIENTIFIC AND ORGANIZING COMMITTEE Chairman
Co-Chairman
Professor W. Rodi Institut ftir Hydromechanik Universit~it Karlsruhe Kaiserstr. 12 76128 Karlsruhe, Germany
Dr. M. Mulas Computational Fluid Dynamics CRS4 Parco POLARIS, Edificio 1 09010 PULA (CA), Italy Members
B. Aupoix, ONERA, Toulouse, France
N. Kasagi, University of Tokyo, Japan
M. Braza, Institute de Mechanique des Fluides de Toulouse, France
B. E. Launder, University of Manchester, U.K.
I. Castro, University of Southampton, U.K.
D. Laurence, Electricit6 de France, Chatou, France and University of Manchester, U.K.
C. T. Crowe, Washington State University, Pullman, USA
M. A. Leschziner, Imperial College, London, U.K.
E. Dick, University of Gent, Belgium
F. Menter, ANSYS-CFX, Otterfing, Germany
L. Djenidi, University of Newcastle, Callaghon, Australia
O. Metais, IMG-LEGI, Grenoble, France
S. Drobniak, Czestochowa University of Technology, Poland P. A. Durbin, Stanford University, USA B. J. Geurts, University of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands
Y. Nagano, Nagoya Institute of Technology, Japan R. V. A. Oliemans, Multi-Phase Flow B.V. and TU Delft, The Netherlands P. Orlandi, University of Rome "La Sapienza", Italy N. Peters, RWTH Aachen, Germany
W. Haase, EADS Military Aircraft, Munich, Germany
A. M. Savill, Cranfield University, U.K.
K. Hanjali6, Delft University of Technology, The Netherlands
M. Sommerfeld, Martin-Luther-Universit~it HalleWittenberg, Halle, Germany
A. G. Hutton, QinetiQ, Famborough, U.K.
P. R. Spalart, Boeing Commercial Airplanes, Seattle, USA
W. P. Jones, Imperial College, London, U.K.
R. Verzicco, Polytechnic Institute of Bari, Italy
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
vii
CONTENTS
Preface
x/x
1. I n v i t e d L e c t u r e s
Rapid techniques for measuring and modeling turbulent flows in complex geometries G. laccarino and C.J. Elkins, Stanford University, Stanford, USA Large-Eddy-Simulation of complex flows using the immersed boundary method R. Verzicco, Politecnico di Bail, Bail, Italy
17
Transition modelling for general purpose CFD codes F. R. Menter, R. Langtry, ANSYS-CFX Germany, Otterfing, Germany S. V61ker, GE Global Research, Niskayuna, NY, USA P. G. Huang, University of Kentucky, Lexington, Kentucky
31
Possibilities and limitations of computer simulations of industrial turbulent multiphase flows L. M. Portela, R.V. A. Oliemans, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands
49
Turbulence Modelling
0
\
(v-7/k) - f Turbulence Model and its application to forced and natural convection K. Hanjalid, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands D. R. Laurence, UMIST, Manchester, UK and EDF-DER-LNH, Chatou, France M. Popovac, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands J. C. Uribe, UMIST, Manchester, UK
67
Calibrating the length scale equation with an explicit algebraic Reynolds stress constitutive relation H. BJzard, ONERA, Toulouse, France T. Daris, SNECMA Motors Villaroche, Moissy-Cramayel, France
77
Near-wall modification of an explicit algebraic Reynolds stress model using elliptic blending G. Karlatiras, G. Papadakis, King' s College, London, UK
87
viii
Assessment of turbulence models for predicting the interaction region in a wall jet by reference to LES solution and budgets A. Dejoan, C. Wang, M. A. Leschziner, Imperial College, London, UK
97
Eddy collision models for turbulence B. Perot, C. Chartrand, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, USA
107 A stress-strain lag eddy viscosity model for unsteady mean flow A. J. Revell, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK S. Benhamadouche, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK and EDF-DER-LNH, Chatou, France T. Craft, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK D. Laurence, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK and EDF-DER-LNH, Chatou, France K. Yaqobi, EDF-DER-LNH, Chatou, France
117
Turbulence modelling of statistically periodic flows: the case of the synthetic jet S. Carpy, R. Manceau, University of Poitiers, Poitiers, France
127
Behaviour of turbulence models near a turbulent / non-turbulent interface revisited P. Ferrey, B. Aupoix, ONERA / DMAE, Toulouse, France
137
Behaviour of nonlinear two-equation turbulence models at the free-stream edges of turbulent flows A. Hellsten, Helsinki University of Technology, Helsinki, Finland H. Bdzard, ONERA, Toulouse, France
147
Extending an analytical wall-function for turbulent flows over rough walls K. Suga, Toyota Central R & D Labs., Inc., Nagakute Aichi, Japan T. J. Craft, H. lacovides, The University of Manchester, Manchsester, UK
157
Bifurcation of second moment closures in rotating stratified flow P. A. Durbin, M. Ji, Stanford University, Stanford, USA
167
Turbulence Model for wall-bounded flow with arbitrary rotating axes H. Hattori, N. Ohiwa, Y. Nagano, Nagoya Institute of Technology, Nagoya, Japan
175
Application of a new algebraic structure-based model to rotating turbulent flows C. A. Langer, University of Cyprus, Nicosia, Cyprus S. C. Kassinos, University of Cyprus, Nicosia, Cyprus & Stanford University, Stanford, USA S. L. Haire, Lockheed Martin Space Systems Company, Sunnyvale, CA, USA
185
k-e modeling of turbulence in porous media based on a two-scale analysis F. Pinson, O. Grdgoire, CEA Saclay, Gif sur Yvette, France O. Simonin, IMFT, Toulouse, France
195
3. Direct and Large-Eddy Simulations
Effect of a 2-D rough wall on the anisotropy of a turbulent channel flow L. Djenidi, University of Newcastle, Callaghan, NSW, Australia S. Leonarcli, P. Orlandi, Universita Degli Studi di Roma "La Sapienza", Rome, Italy R. A. Antonia, University of Newcastle, Callaghan, NSW, Australia
207
Direct numerical simulation of rotating turbulent flows through concentric annuli M. Okamoto, N. Shima, Shizuoka University, Hamamatsu, Japan
217
Numerical simulation of compressible mixing layers S. Fu, Q. Li, Tsinghua University, Beijing, China
227
LES in a U-bend pipe meshed by polyhedral cells C. Moulinec, UMIST, Manchester, UK S. Benhamadouche, D. Laurence, UMIST, Manchester, UK and EDF-DER-LNH, Chatou, France M. Perik, Computational Dynamics Ltd., London, UK
237
Large eddy simulation of impinging jets in a confined flow D. J. Clayton, W. P. Jones, Imperial College, London, UK
247
LES study of turbulent boundary layer over a smooth and a rough 2D hill model T. Tamura, Tokyo Institute of Technology, Tokyo, Japan Sh. Cao, Tokyo Polytechnic University, Tokyo, Japan A. Okuno, Tokyo Institute of Technology, Tokyo, Japan
257
Flow features in a fully developed ribbed duct flow as a result of LES M. M. Loh6sz, Budapest University of Technology and Economics, Budapest, Hungary and Von Karman Institute for Fluid Dynamics, Sint-Genesius-Rode, Belgium P. Rambaud, C. Benocci, Von Karman Institute for Fluid Dynamics, Sint-Genesius-Rode, Belgium
267
Coherent structures and mass exchange processes in channel flow with spanwise obstructions A. McCoy, G. Constantinescu, L. Weber, The University of Iowa, Iowa City, USA
277
Large Eddy Simulation of natural convection boundary layer on a vertical cylinder D. G. Barhaghi, L. Davidson, Chalmers University of Technology, G6teborg, Sweden R. Karlsson, Chalmers University of Technology, G~teborg, Sweden and Vattenfall Utveckling AB, .~lvkarleby, Sweden
287
Development of the subgrid-scale models in large eddy simulation for the finite difference schemes M. Tsubokura, The University of Electro-communications, Tokyo, Japan T. Kobayashi, Japan Automobile Research Institute and University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan N. Taniguchi, University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan
297
Assessment of the digital filter approach for generating large eddy simulation inlet conditions I. Veloudis, Z. Yang, J. J. McGuirk, G. J. Page, Loughborough University, Loughborough, UK
307
4. Hybrid LES/RANS Simulations Hybrid LES-RANS : Computation of the flow around a three-dimensional hill L. Davidson, S. DahlstrOm, Chalmers University of Technology, G/3teborg, Sweden
319
Applications of a renormalization group based hybrid RANS/LES model C. De Langhe, B. Merci, E. Dick, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium
329
Application of zonal LES/ILES approaches to an unsteady complex geometry flow P. G. Tucker, Y. Liu, University of Wales, Swansea, UK
339
Interface conditions for hybrid RANS/LES calculations A. Keating, G. De Prisco, U. Piomelli, E. Balaras, University of Maryland, College Park, USA
349
Approximate near-wall treatments based on zonal and hybrid RANS-LES methods for LES at high Reynolds numbers F. Tessicini, Imperial College, London, UK L. Temmerman, Imperial College, London, UK and Numeca International s.a., Brussels, Belgium M. A. Leschziner, Imperial College, London, UK
359
LES, T-RANS and hybrid simulations of thermal convection at high RA numbers S. KenjereL K. HanjaliJ, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands
369
5.
A p p l i c a t i o n of T u r b u l e n c e M o d e l s
Industrial practice in turbulence modelling: An evaluation of QNET-CFD A. G. Hutton, QinetiQ Ltd., Famborough, UK 381 Three-dimensional flow computation with Reynolds stress and algebraic stress models G. B. Deng, P. Queutey, M. Visonneau, Ecole Centrale de Nantes, Nantes, France
389
Comparison of turbulence models in case of jet in crossflow using commercial CFD code A. Karvinen, H. Ahlstedt, Tampere University of Technology, Tampere, Finland
399
6. Experimental Techniques and Studies Time resolved PIV measurements for validating LES of the turbulent flow within a PCB enclosure model G. Usera, Universitat Rovira i Virgili, Tarragona, Spain and Universidad de la Repdblica, Montevideo, Uruguay A. Vernet, J. A. Ferrd, Universitat Rovira i Virgili, Tarragona, Spain
411
Skin friction measurements in complex turbulent flows using direct methods J. A. Schetz, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, USA
421
Reynolds number dependence of elementary vortices in turbulence K. Sassa, Kochi University, Kochi, Japan H. Makita, Toyohashi University of Technology, Toyohashi, Japan
431
Near-wake turbulence properties in the high Reynolds incompressible flow around a circular cylinder by 2C and 3C PIV R. Perrin, M. Braza, E. Cid, S. Cazin, f Moradei, A. Barthet, A. Sevrain, Y. Hoarau, Institut de M6canique des Fluides de Toulouse, Toulouse, France
441
Single- and two-point LDA measurements in the turbulent near wake of a circular cylinder A. Ducci, E. Konstantinidis, E. Balabani, M. Yianneskis, King's College, London, UK
451
Aerodynamics of a half-cylinder in ground effect X. Zhang, S. Mahon, M. Van Den-Berg, C. Williams, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK
461
xii
Turbulent wall jet interaction with a backward facing step N. Nait Bouda, U.S.T.H.B., Alger, Algeria C. Rey, Universit6 Paul C6zanne Aix-Marseille HI, Marseille, France J. M. Rosant, Ecole Centrale de Nantes, Nantes, France T. Benabid, U.S.T.H.B., Alger, Algeria
471
The role of pressure-velocity correlation in oscillatory flow between a pair of bluff bodies S. Obi, N. Tokai, K. Sakai, Keio University, Yokohama, Japan
481
Turbulent structures in a supersonic jet-mixing layer interaction E. Collin, P. Braud, J. Delville, Universit6 de Poitiers ENSMA, Poitiers, France
491
Turbulent properties of twin circular free jets with various nozzle spacing T. Harima, S. Fujita, Tokuyama College of Technology, Shunan, Japan H. Osaka, Yamaguchi University, Ube, Japan
501
LDA-masurements of the turbulence in and around a venturi R. F. Mudcle, L. Deutz, V. A. Nievaart, TU Delft, Delft, The Netherlands H. R. E. van Maanen, Shell E&P, Rijswijk, The Netherlands
511
7.
Transition
Modelling of unsteady transition with a dynamic intermittency equation K. Lodefier, E. Dick, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium
523
Transition to turbulence and control in the incompressible flow around a NACA0012 wing Y. Hoarau, M. Braza, Institut de M6canique des Fluides de Toulouse, Toulouse, France Y. Ventikos, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK D. Faghani, Euro-American Institute of Technology, Sophia Antipolis, France
533
8.
Turbulence Control
Some observations of the Coanda effect G. Han, M. D. Zhou, I. Wygnanski, The University of Arizona, Tucson, USA
545
Active control of turbulent separated flows by means of large scale vortex excitation A. Brunn, W. Nitsche, Technical University of Berlin, Berlin, Germany
555
xiii
Large-eddy simulation of a controlled flow cavity I. Mary, T.-H. L6, ONERA, Ch~tillon, France
565
Parametric study of surfactant-induced drag-reduction by DNS B. Yu, National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology, Ibaraki, Japan & National Maritime Research Institute, Tokyo, Japan Y. Kawaguchi, National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology, Ibaraki, Japan
575
Effect of non-affine viscoelasticity on turbulence generation K. Horiuti, S. Abe, Y. Takagi, Tokyo Institute of Technology, Tokyo, Japan
585
Experimental and numerical investigation of flow control on bluff bodies by passive ventilation M. Falchi, G. Provenzano, D. Pietrogiacomi, G. P. Romano, University of Rome "La Sapienza", Rome, Italy
595
9. A e r o d y n a m i c F l o w s
Application of Reynolds stress models to high-lift aerodynamics applications O. Grundestam, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden S. Wallin, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden and Swedish Defence Research Agency, Stockholm, Sweden P. Eliasson, Swedish Defence Research Agency, Stockholm, Sweden A. V. Johansson, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden
607
Turbulence modelling in application to the vortex shedding of stalled airfoils C. Mockett, U. Bunge, F. Thiele, Technische Universit~it Berlin, Berlin, Germany
617
The computational modelling of wing-tip vortices and their near-field decay T. J. Craft, B. E. Launder, C. M. E. Robinson, The University of Manchester, Manchester, UK
627
URANS computations of shock induced oscillations over 2D rigid airfoil: Influence of test section geometry M. Thiery, E. Coustols, ONERA/DMAE, Toulouse, France
637
Zonal multi-domain RANS/LES simulation of airflow over the Ahmed body F. Mathey, Fluent France SA, Montigny Le Bretonneux, France D. Cokljat, Fluent Europe Ltd, Sheffield, UK
647
xiv
Numerical simulation and experimental investigation of the side loading on a high speed train N. Paradot, SNCF (National French Railways), Paris, France B. Angel, Renuda Engineering Computation, Paris, France P.-E. Gautier, L.-M. Cldon, SNCF (National French Railways), Paris, France
657
Large-scale instabilities in a STOVL upwash fountain A. J. Sacldington, P. M. Cabrita, K. Knowles, Cranfield University, Wiltshire, UK
667
10.
Aero-Acoustics
Direct numerical simulation of large-eddy-break-up devices in a boundary layer P. R. Spalart, Boeing Commercial Airplanes, Seattle, WA, USA M. Strelets, A. Travin, Federal Scientific Center "Applied Chemistry", St. Petersburg, Russia
679
Blade tip flow and noise prediction by large-eddy simulation in horizontal axis wind turbines O. Fleig, M. licla, C. Arakawa, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan
689
A zonal RANS/LES approach for noise sources prediction M. Terracol, ONERA, Ch~tillon, France
699
Aerodynamics and acoustic sources of the exhaust jet in a car air-conditioning system A. Le Duc, N. Peller, M. Manhart, Technische Universit~it Mtinchen, Munich, Germany E.-P. Wachsmann, AUDI AG, Ingolstadt, Germany
709
Characterization of a separated turbulent boundary layer by time-frequency analyses of wall pressure fluctuations R. Camussi, G. Guj, A. Di Marco, University "Roma 3", Rome, Italy A. Ragni, CIRA - Italian Aerospace Research Centre, Capua, Italy
719
11.
Turbomachinery Flows
Study of flow and mixing in a generic GT combustor using LES B. Wegner, B. Janus, A. Sadiki, A. Dreizler, J. Janicka, Darmstadt University of Technology, Darmstadt, Germany
731
An evaluation of turbulence models for the isothermal flow in a gas turbine combustion system K. R. Menzies, Rolls-Royce plc, Bristol, UK
741
Large Eddy Simulations of heat and mass transfers in case of non isothermal blowing G. Brillant, CEA, Grenoble, France and INSA - Centre de Thermique de Lyon, Villeurbanne, France S. Husson, F. Bataille, INSA - Centre de Thermique de Lyon, Villeurbanne, France
751
Turbulence modelling and measurements in a rotor-stator system with throughflow S. Poncet, R. Schiestel, M.-P. Chauve, Univ. Aix-Marseille I & II, Marseille, France
761
12. Heat and Mass Transfer
Impinging jet cooling of wall mounted cubes M. J. Tummers, M. A. Flikweert, K. Hanjalik, R. Rodink, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands B. Moshfegh, Link~Jping Institute of Technology, Linki3ping, Sweden
773
Numerical and experimental study of turbulent processes and mixing in jet mixers E. Hassel, S. Jahnke, N. Kornev, I. Tkatchenko, V. Zhdanov, University of Rostock, Rostock, Germany
783
Effects of adverse pressure gradient on heat transfer mechanism in thermal boundary layer T. Houra, Y. Nagano, Nagoya Institute of Technology, Nagoya, Japan
793
Stochastic modelling of conjugate heat transfer in near-wall turbulence J. Pozorski, Polish Academy of Sciences, Gdafisk, Poland J.-P. Minier, Electricit6 de France, Chatou, France
803
Study of the effect of flow pulsation on the flow field and heat transfer over an inline cylinder array using LES Ch. Liang, G. Papaclakis, King's College, London, UK
813
Large eddy simulation of scalar mixing M. Dianat, Z. Yang, J. J. McGuirk, Loughborough University, Loughborough, UK
823
13.
Combustion Systems
Experimental characterization and modelling of inflow conditions for a gas turbine swirl combustor R. Palm, S. Grundmann, M. Weismiiller, S. Saric, S. Jakirli~, C. Tropea, Darmstadt University of Technology, Darmstadt, Germany 835 On the sensitivity of a free annular swirling jet to the level of swirl and a pilot jet M. Garcia-Villalba, J. Fr6hlich, University of Karlsruhe, Karlsruhe, Germany
845
Prediction of pressure oscillations in a premixed swirl combustor flow and comparison to measurements P. Habisreuther, C. Bender, O. Petsch, H. Biichner, H. Bockhorn, University of Karlsruhe, Karlsruhe, Germany
855
Interaction between thermoacoustic oscillations and spray combustion W. A. Chishty, U. Vandsburger, W. R. Saunders, W. T. Baumann, Virginia Polytechnic Institute & State University, Blacksburg, USA
865
Dynamics of lean premixed systems: Measurements for large eddy simulation D. Galley, SNECMA Moteurs, Moissy Cramayel, France and Ecole Centrale Paris, Chatenay-Malabry, France A. P. Melsi6, S. Ducruix, F. Lacas, D. Veynante, Ecole Centrale Paris, ChatenayMalabry, France Y. Sommerer, T. Poinsot, CERFACS, Toulouse, France
875
White in time scalar advection model as a tool for solving joint composition PDF equations: Derivation and application
V. Sabel'nikov, O. Soulard, ONERA, Palaiseau, France
885
The effects of micromixing on combustion extinction limits for micro combustor applications C. Dumand, V. A. Sabel'nikov, ONERA, Palaiseau, France
895
Joint RANS/LES approach to premixd flames modelling in the context of the TFC combustion model V. L. Zimont, V. Battaglia, CRS4 Research Center POLARIS, Pula, Italy
905
Optical observation and discrete vortex analysis of vortex-flame interaction in a plane premixed shear flow N. Ohiwa, Y. Ishino, Nagoya Institute of Technology, Nagoya, Japan
915
xvii
14.
T w o - P h a s e Flows
Simulation of mass-loading effects in gas-solid cyclone separators J. J. Derksen, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands
929
On Euler/Euler Modeling of turbulent particle diffusion in dispersed two-phase flows R. Groll, C. Tropea, TU Darmstadt, Darmstadt, Germany
939
Influence of the gravity field on the turbulence seen by heavy discrete particles in an inhomogeneous flow B. Arcen, A. Tanibre, B. Oesterld, Universit6 Henri Poincar6-Nancy I, Vandoeuvre-16s-Nancy, France 949 Modelling turbulent collision rates of inertial particles L. I. Zaichik, V. M. Alipchenkov, Institute for High Temperatures of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia A. R. Avetissian, All Russian Nuclear Power Engineering Research and Development Institute, Moscow, Russia
959
Large eddy simulation of the dispersion of solid particles and droplets in a turbulent boundary layer flow I. Vinkovic, C. Aguirre, S. Simo6ns, Ecole Centrale de Lyon, Ecully Cedex, France
969
Dynamic self-organization in particle-laden turbulent channel flow B. J. Geurts, University of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands and Eindhoven University of Technology, Eindhoven, The Netherlands A. W. Vreman, Vreman Research, Hengelo, The Netherlands
979
AUTHOR INDEX
989
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
xix
PREFACE These proceedings contain the papers presented at the ERCOFTAC International Symposium on Engineering Turbulence Modelling and Measurements - ETMM6 - held at Villasimius, Sardinia, Italy, in the period May 23-25, 2005. The symposium followed the previous five conferences on the topic of engineering turbulence modelling and measurements held in Dubrovnik, Yugoslavia, in 1990, Florence, Italy, in 1993, Crete, Greece, in 1996, Corsica, France, in 1999 and Mallorca, Spain, in 2002, but was held for the first time under the aegis of ERCOFTAC (European Research Community on Flow, Turbulence and Combustion). The proceedings of the previous conferences were also published by Elsevier. The purpose of this series of symposia is to provide a forum for presenting and discussing new developments in the area of turbulence modelling and measurements, with particular emphasis on engineering-related problems. Turbulence is still one of the key issues in tackling engineering flow problems. As powerful computers and accurate numerical methods are now available for solving the flow equations, and since engineering applications nearly always involve turbulence effects, the reliability of CFD analysis depends more and more on the performance of the turbulence models. Successful simulation of turbulence requires the understanding of the complex physical phenomena involved and suitable models for describing the turbulent momentum, heat and mass transfer. For the understanding of turbulence phenomena, experiments are indispensable, but they are equally important for providing data for the development and testing of turbulence models and hence for CFD software validation. Recently, Direct Numerical Simulations have become an important tool for providing supplementary detailed data. Research in the area of turbulence modelling and measurements continues to be very active worldwide, and altogether 277 abstracts were submitted to the symposium and experts in the field screened the 269 abstracts that arrived in time. 134 abstracts were accepted and 112 final papers were received and each reviewed by two experts. In the end, 90 papers were accepted, and most of these underwent some final revision before they were included in these proceedings. The papers were conveniently grouped in the following sections: - Turbulence modelling -
Direct and large-eddy simulations
- Hybrid LES/RANS simulations - Application of turbulence models -
-
- Aerodynamics flows -
Aero-Acoustics
- Turbomachinery flows -
Heat and mass transfer
Experimental techniques and studies
- Combustion systems
Transition
- Two-phase flows
- Turbulence control
The contributed papers are preceded by a section containing 4 invited papers covering LES and rapid measurement techniques for complex turbulent flows, transition modelling and simulations of multiphase flows. The conference was organised with the support and cooperation of the following institutions and companies:
- ERCOFTAC -
-
KATnet of the European Union Regione Autonoma della Sardegna
- CRS4 -
University of Karlsruhe
- ENEA - European Office of Aerospace Research and Development of the USAF - ANSYS-CFX Germany - CD- Adapco -
-
-
Electricit6 de France Fluent Numeca
We gratefully acknowledge this support and cooperation. We are also grateful to the members of the Scientific and Organizing Committee for their various efforts in making this conference a success. We also acknowledge the help of many Fluid Mechanics experts from all over the world in reviewing abstracts and full papers for the conference. Finally, we express our sincere appreciation for the good cooperation provided by Dr. Arno Schouwenburg and Vicki Wetherell of Elsevier Ltd. in the preparation of the proceedings.
W. Rodi and M. Mulas
1. Invited Lectures
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Engineering Turbulence Modellingand Experiments6 W. Rodi (Editor) 9 2005 ElsevierLtd. All rights reserved.
RAPID TECHNIQUES FOR MEASURING AND MODELING TURBULENT FLOWS IN COMPLEX GEOMETRIES G. Iaccarino and C. J. Elkins Department of Mechanical Engineering Stanford University, Stanford CA 94305
ABSTRACT An approach to measure and model turbulent flows in complex configurations is presented. It is based on the synergistic use of two novel techniques: the experiments are based on magnetic resonance velocimetry, which allows the collection of a large three-dimensional volume of three-component velocity measurements in a short period of time. The numerical predictions are based on the immersed boundary technique that enables simulations to be carried out on Cartesian grids even for realistic, industrial configurations. Computer models of realistic geometries are used without modification in the simulations, and they are accurately reproduced for the experiments using rapid prototyping manufacturing. These two techniques enable analysis of flow systems in great detail by quickly providing a wealth of experimental and numerical data. Moreover, direct comparison between these datasets gives indications of the uncertainties in the data from both methods. Results are presented for the flow in a pipe and in a ribroughened serpentine. In addition, preliminary measurements and simulations of the flow around a coral reef are included.
KEYWORDS Magnetic resonance velocimetry, immersed boundary technique, ribbed serpentine, coral reef.
INTRODUCTION
The analysis of the turbulent flow in complex, industrial configurations is of great importance for improving the design and the performance of a wide variety of engineering devices. Traditionally, such analysis is based on an experimental investigation that involves the construction of the device (typically in a reduced scale) and the direct measure of a few performance parameters. The detailed instrumentation of an industrial device can be extremely time-consuming and expensive. It is common to use only few probes for measuring pressure, flow rates, temperature, etc. and, as a consequence, their position plays a critical role in the significance of the collected data. Although these
data yield valuable information, they do not provide enough information to identify areas of separation or other problematic regions that can cause performance reduction. Several methodologies are available to collect more detailed measurements in flows. Laser Doppler anemometry (LDA) and Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) (Stanislas Kompenhans and Westerweel, 2000) are two non-invasive techniques. While LDA provides pointwise velocity measurements, PIV provides instantaneous two-dimensional velocity fields, and stereoscopic PIV provides three-component velocities in two-dimensional planes. All of these measurement techniques require optical access in the studied device and this limits their applications to simpler geometries. In addition, these measurements may be available only in selected positions or planes. In many realistic geometries, full coverage of the flow domain by LDA or PIV may be impossible or extremely time consuming. Recently, a technique has been implemented in modern Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) scanners to measure three-component velocity fields in three-dimensional complex geometries. This technique is called Magnetic Resonance Velocimetry (MRV). The method is based on the same principles used in MRI, now routinely employed in medical imaging. MRV is becoming popular in the study of blood flow in vascular medicine, and it has applications in the study of engineering flows as well. The typical fluid used in MRV experiments contains water since medical MRI scanners measure radio frequency signals from excited hydrogen nuclei in the presence of strong magnetic fields. More detailed discussion of MRV can be found in Elkins et al. (2003) and Markl et al. (2003). One advantage of MRV is that it provides detailed three-dimensional data very quickly; a typical scan of a volume of size 32x200x200mm with a resolution of about lmm can be obtained in less than 30 minutes. Another major advantage of MRV is its ability to measure data in complex geometries without the need for optical access. Flow models are typically fabricated using rapid prototyping manufacturing processes (i.e. stereo-lithography). There are several well-documented drawbacks to the MRV technique including signal dephasing due to turbulence and spatial misregistration due to strong accelerations in the flow. In addition, MRV provides only mean velocity measurements and knowledge of turbulence quantities can be important. These shortcomings are being investigated by the authors in an effort to improve MRV. The other existing approach to study and design engineering systems is Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD). Numerical flow simulations have become a common tool and several software tools are available in the industrial community. CFD calculations are carried out in two steps: the first is the geometry acquisition and mesh generation, and the second is the actual flow simulation. The geometry acquisition requires the transfer of a configuration, typically generated in a Computer-Aided-Design (CAD) environment, into a CFD mesh generation system. This process is very time consuming as the operating principles (geometry definition, tolerances, etc.) of the two software environments can be quite different. Once a watertight definition of the device to be studied is available in the mesh generator, the air-solid has to be defined. The air-solid represents the volume that is effectively occupied by the fluid (typically it is just the negative of the real device). A computational grid, i.e. a collection of small Computational Volumes (CV) covering the entire air-solid, is then generated in a semi-automatic way. Control on the resolution and the quality - the size and shape of the CVs, respectively - of the grid requires substantial user-intervention and might be very time-consuming. Once a grid is available, the solution of the equations governing the flow can be carried out. For complex applications, the use of CFD is still challenging as the first phase of the process described above can be quite difficult and time consuming. Techniques that simplify and automate the grid generation have great potential in sustaining the widespread use of CFD. The Immersed Boundary (IB) method eliminates the need for the construction of the air-solid thus simplifying substantially both the
geometry acquisition and the mesh generation phases. The IB method (Mittal and Iaccarino, 2005) uses a mesh that covers the entire computational domain (typically a large box) without the device of interest; the effect of this on the flow is then accounted for by modifying the governing equations through source terms that mimic the presence of the solid boundaries. Cartesian mesh techniques were introduced for fluid flow simulation in the 70s (Peskin, 1972) but only recently have been applied to complex, industrial flows and in the turbulent regime (Iaccarino and Verzicco, 2003). The availability of the MRV and IB techniques to study turbulent flows in realistic configurations creates an opportunity for a new paradigm in engineering design as measurements and simulations can be used together. The combined MRV-IB approach provides a wealth of information for the designer at a resolution that is well above what is usually available. The data are typically complementary as the two techniques have different strengths and weaknesses but provide enough overlap to create confidence in the results. In this paper some applications of the MRV-IB approach are presented with the objective of illustrating the advantages of the techniques. Comparisons of the results obtained using the two methods to more conventional PIV measurements are presented to evaluate their accuracy. As the two techniques are relatively new, further research is currently ongoing to fully evaluate their capabilities; this aspect is discussed at the end of the paper.
MEASURING TECHNIQUE: MAGNETIC RESONANCE VELOCIMETRY MRV is a non-invasive experimental method for measuring mean velocities using modern medical Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) systems. All of the measurements presented in this paper were made using a 1.5 T GE Signa CV/I system (Gmax=40mT/m, rise time=268 microsecs). For a discussion of the principles of MRI, the reader is referred to Stark and Bradley (1999), yon Schultess and Hennig (1998), and Haacke et al. (1999). In addition, a brief discussion of MRV principles is found in Elkins et al. (2003) where the MRV technique is described in detail. Most MRI systems image hydrogen protons which are abundant in the fluids and tissues in living things. Protons have magnetic moments (spins) that align with the direction of a strong magnetic field. If knocked out of alignment with the external magnetic field, the spins will relax back into alignment and precess about the field direction with a frequency proportional to the strength of the magnetic field. Hence, when a spatial magnetic field gradient is applied to create a continuously varying magnetic field, the spins along the direction of the gradient have different precession frequencies. This principle can be exploited to image an object. In imaging, the spins are knocked out of alignment with a strong, constant field. Then a magnetic field gradient is applied. As the spins relax back into alignment with the constant field, they broadcast RF signals, each with its own precession frequency dependent on its position in the gradient. The signals are measured with an RF coil, and the output from the coil is the combination of the signals from all of the spins. The inverse FFT of this signal is used to calculate the density and position of the spins, which is represented by the MR image of the object. Magnetic field gradients can be applied in all three dimensions to produce three-dimensional images. The MRV sequence is based on phase-contrast MRI in which velocity is encoded in the phase of the emitted RF signal. Here, too, the inverse FFT is used to convert the sampled RF signals into an object image and velocity fields. Water doped with a gadoliniumcontrast agent is used for the MRV experiments. The flow models and flow loops must be MR compatible and contain no metal. Rapid prototyping materials are typically plastic and, therefore, well suited for MR experiments. In addition, steady flow centrifugal pumps driven by induction motors are also MR compatible and can be used inside the magnet room if placed several
meters from the magnet. MRV is possible in opaque models and opaque fluids although the allowance for some visual inspection is recommended in order to purge bubbles from the model. For measurements made in large flow models or passages, MRV measurements are typically carried out usingtwo successive scans, corresponding to flow on and flow off conditions, respectively. There are inherent asymmetries and imperfections in the magnetic field in the magnet bore. The subtraction of the flow off scan from the flow on scan helps correct for errors related to these imperfections, eddy currents and other sources of off-resonance effects. A procedure to measure time-dependent flows using MRV has also been developed (Markl et al, 2003). In this case scans are phase locked to an appropriate trigger signal (an ECG signal for physiologic scans). For turbulent flows the collection of successive datasets allows more accurate mean velocity information; typically, if there is time, 3 to 10 dataset are collected and averaged.
M O D E L I N G TECHNIQUE: IMMERSED BOUNDARY A P P R O A C H The Immersed Boundary approach belongs to the family of Cartesian methods. An underlying regular grid is used and modifications to the algorithm or to the governing equations are introduced to represent boundaries that are not aligned with grid lines. There are several variants of the IB methods (Mittal and Iaccarino, 2005); the main differences are related to the way the no-slip wall conditions are enforced. In the present approach, an interpolation scheme is applied to enforce the boundary condition off the wall in the first computational cell. A least squares approach is used. The method is based on the solution of the Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) equations using a finite-volume second-order discretization. Turbulence is modeled using a linear eddy viscosity approach based on the two-equation k-g model (Iaccarino et al., 2003). This model has been specifically developed for use with the IB approach, and it does not require the computation of the wall distance or the use of complex boundary conditions at solid walls. Other models have been implemented in the present solver, but only results with the k-g models are included here (Iaccarino and Verzicco, 2003). Another remarkable aspect of the present solver is its ability to handle locally refined grids with hanging nodes. An important component of the IB approach is the grid generator. As discussed, the starting point is an STL model of the configuration of interest (an unconnected triangulation generated in a CAD environment). Initially, a uniform Cartesian mesh is generated with a resolution corresponding to the bulk resolution required by the user away from the solid walls. In the second phase, this grid is refined in the vicinity of the IB until a user-specified mesh spacing is reached everywhere on the immersed boundary. The grid refinement is based on the localization of the STL triangles on the grid. This is accomplished using a ray tracing technique. The cells are split in each Cartesian direction separately with the objective to minimize the distance between the cell center and the closest STL triangle. The resulting grid has strong non-isotropy in the regions where the IB is aligned with the Cartesian directions with obvious savings in terms of overall mesh size. Once the required resolution is reached, a final ray-tracing step is carried out to separate the computational cells in fluid, solid and interface cells. The interface cells are cut by the STL surface and have their cell center laying in the fluid part. Note that this distinction is only meaningful when the original STL file is the representation of a watertight surface. Finally, for the interface cells, the coefficients of the least-square interpolation are pre-computed and stored.
For typical applications the mesh is generated in a few minutes for a few million grid cells. The flow solution is then carried out on this grid, and given the high quality of the mesh (all the cells are hexahedral) the convergence to steady state is typically very good. Several applications of the present approach to a number of problems have been published in the literature (Iaccarino and Verzicco, 2003; Mittal and Iaccarino, 2005; Moreau et al, 2004).
APPLICATIONS Three problems are presented to show the predictive capabilities of the MRV and IB approaches. The first one is a simple, canonical flow, whereas the other two introduce substantial geometrical complexity. Flow in a pipe
The fully developed, turbulent flow in a pipe is considered. This problem has been used to evaluate the accuracy of MRV in comparison with data collected using laser Doppler anemometry. Flow in a straight, rigid pipe with a 19 mm inner diameter is imaged. The Reynolds number is Re=6,400 (based on the bulk velocity). The imaging volume with its dimensions is shown in Fig. 1.
Figure 1: Pipe flow imaging field of view (left) and immersed boundary grid (right) A long inflow tube is used to ensure that the flow is fully developed as it enters in the measurement areas. A total of 256x32x256 measurement points were collected. Three complete datasets were acquired in 26 minutes; the final results are averaged to reduce the errors. Three velocity profiles have been measured at different locations inside the pipe, and the comparisons to LDA show reasonable agreement (Elkins et al, 2003). Simulations have been carried out on the same geometrical model. Periodicity is enforced in the streamwise direction and the flow rate is specified. A view of the computational grid in a cross section of the pipe is reported in Fig. 1. The grid consists of 300,000 cells with a wall-normal resolution at the boundary of 0.1mm; it was generated in less than a minute on a SGI workstation. Calculations were carried out using the k-g turbulence model and steady-state was achieved after ~500 iterations in ~25 minutes.
Figure 2: Mean velocity profile for the flow in the pipe The comparisons of the velocity profiles as a function of the radius are reported in Fig. 2. Three sets of MRV data are reported at different streamwise locations (numerical results show negligible variability in the streamwise direction and only one profile is shown). The overall agreement is within 6%.
Flow serpentine with oblique ribs The second example is the flow in a serpentine duct; this configuration is typical of the cooling flow passages within turbine blades. A sketch of the geometry is reported in Fig. 3.
Figure 3: Ribbed serpentine model. The model was drawn in SolidWorks and fabricated using a stereo-lithography machine. The serpentine has a square cross section height of H = 20mm and ten staggered oblique ribs on the top and bottom walls. The rib height is 0.1H and the pitch (distance between two successive ribs) is 0.6H; the rib angle is 45 degrees. In the experiment, fully developed pipe flow enters the first leg of the serpentine through a converging section yielding a uniform velocity profile. The flow is investigated for a Reynolds number of Re=10,000, based on the passage height and the bulk velocity. A total of 36x256x256 measurement points were collected (corresponding to a resolution of 36 x 280 x 280 mm). Six complete datasets were acquired in 27 minutes; the final results are averaged to reduce the errors.
Figure 4: Horizontal and vertical cross-sections of the immersed boundary grid for the ribbed serpentine model. The simulations have been performed using the same geometrical definition of the serpentine. A series of locally refined grids with successively increased resolution was generated; only results obtained on a grid with 3 million grid points are reported here. Two cross sections of the computational mesh are reported in Fig. 4; the resolution at solid walls is 0.005mm (H/400) and in the bulk of the duct is ~0.1mm. The mesh was generated automatically in about two minutes. Steady state flow calculations were carried out assuming a uniform velocity profile at the inflow in accordance with experimental observations. The calculations required about 3 hours of CPU time on an SGI workstation.
Figure 5: Comparison of MRV, IB and PIV in-plane velocity vectors in the U-bend (region 1 in Fig. 3). PIV: open arrows; MRV: filled arrows; IB: hollow arrows. An additional set of experimental measurements was collected using PIV to identify the overall quality of both MRV and IB data. Visual access was available in the area corresponding to the first U-bend in a plane located at mid-height of the duct. The comparison is shown in Fig. 5; the overall agreement is remarkable, given the complexity and three-dimensionality of the flow at this location. The flow approaches the bend at an angle of about 45 degrees (somewhat lower according to the MRV data) and a large separation occurs as it leaves the bend. Comparing to the PIV dataset which is the most reliable, it is
evident that both the MRV and IB results are capturing the separation correctly in terms of size and the overall speed and direction with reasonable accuracy. It is also interesting that the IB method appears to be inaccurate in predicting the flow direction after the bend whereas the MRV shows a discrepancy in the flow upstream of the bend. The flow downstream of the bend is characterized by strong turbulence non-equilibrium but otherwise low levels of turbulence intensity (Iacovides and Raisee, 1999). This situation poses a challenge to linear eddy viscosity models, and it is likely that only a Reynolds-stress model would provide better predictions in this area. On the other hand, the flow in the region approaching the bend is dominated by two strong streamwise vortices (generated by the presence of the oblique fibs) and very high levels of turbulence. In this case, uncertainty in the MRV data associated with strong turbulence and flow acceleration is the likely cause of the differences with respect to the PIV measurements.
Figure 6: Comparison of MRV and IB velocity magnitude in the plane at rib mid-height. Top: IB simulations; bottom: MRV measurements. Two additional sets of comparisons of MRV and IB results are reported in Fig. 6 and 7. In Fig. 6, a plane at rib mid-height is reported to show the level of detail that the two techniques are providing; note that the MRV resolution is -1.1mm and the IB resolution is -0.1mm. In Fig. 7, the streamwise velocity in two planes (upstream and downstream of the first U-bend) is reported. The flow approaching the bend is characterized by high speed toward the inner part of the bend and a characteristic reverse C shape; this is a result of the two strong counter-rotating streamwise vortices present in the duct. The flow leaving the bend, on the other hand, is substantially more uniform although the peak velocity is located off the center towards the outer part of the bend. This is a consequence of the presence of massive separation on the inner side of the bend (as illustrated in Fig. 5). The overall agreement between MRV and IB is remarkable in spite of the limitations observed above. A more complete set of comparisons between the MRV and IB results is reported in Iaccarino et al. 2003.
Figure 7: Comparison of MRV and IB velocity magnitude in before (left, region 2 in Fig. 3) and after the U-bend (fight, region 3 in Fig. 3). Top: IB simulations; bottom: MRV measurements. Flow around a coral colony
The final example is the flow around a coral. The study is motivated by the observation that hydrodynamics directly affects coral growth, energetics, and health (Chang et al, 2004). Understanding the flow in scales important to the coral proves difficult because of the complex geometry and the turbulent structures resulting from the interaction between the geometry and the water motion. In order to analyze such interactions using the MRV and IB methods, first a computer model of the geometry of a real coral skeleton was created. A coral skeleton has been digitized using computed tomography (CT) and converted into an STL file using a software package called Mimics (Materialise NV). This CAD model was then used to rapid-prototype a scaled-down version of the original coral; the model height is 12cm).
Figure 8: Coral skeleton (left) and rapid prototyped model (right). In Fig. 8 the original skeleton and the model are shown. The model is placed inside a channel designed to fit into the MR scanner; its main dimensions are 19cm x 17cm. In Fig. 9 the experimental set-up with the
12
coral mounted in the test section is shown. The average streamwise velocity is 5.2cm/sec corresponding to a Reynolds number (based on the coral height) of 8,000. Preliminary measurements have been carried out but only one set of MRV data has been collected so far. In Fig. 10, the MRV streamwise velocities are presented. Flow off, flow on and the actual velocity data (flow-off subtracted out of the flow-on measurements) are reported.
Figure 9: Coral experimental set-up
Figure 10: MRV measurements at 1/3 coral height. The images are scans for flow-off (left), flow on (center) and the flow off subtracted from the flow on respectively (right). Flow is from bottom to top. The color gradation is an indication of streamwise velocity (mm/s). Wakes corresponding to the single branches and the overall low-speed area downstream of the coral are clearly shown; the lack of side-to-side symmetry is an indication of the complex, three-dimensional structure of the flow. An unexpected low speed region fairly far upstream of the coral is observed in Fig. 10. This is likely due to slight differences between the flow on and flow off scans, and the MRV scans are being repeated to eliminate these errors. Initial measurements of the volumetric flow rate at different
13
streamwise sections show substantial discrepancy (more than 10%), especially in the regions downstream of the coral. This error has not been observed in previous results. Current work is devoted to the determination of the causes of the lack of strict mass conservation in the coral flow. The IB method is used to perform simulations in the same configuration. A preliminary, coarse computational grid was generated. It consists of 1 million grid cells with a resolution of 0.05cm and 0.5cm close to the coral and in the wake, respectively. Two cross sections of the mesh are reported in Fig. 10. This mesh was generated in less than a minute on a SGI workstation. Steady state calculations were carried out Reynolds numbers ranging from 5,000 to 50,000.
Figure 11: Immersed boundary grid for the coral. View of a plane in the streamwise direction (left) and plane across the coral 1/3 of the height (right). Given the somewhat low Reynolds numbers, the calculations are carried out with and without the turbulence model. The latter in particular, show strong unsteadiness and appear to be more consistent with the experimental observations. In Fig. 12 a horizontal plane at 1/3 of the coral height is shown to illustrate the flow structure in the streamwise direction. As expected, we observe the presence of small branchwakes within the overall coral wake. More interestingly, pockets of high speed are present between the branches; this can potentially have a strong effect on mass transfer (in this case nutrient transport from the water to the coral) and will be analyzed in detail when more reliable MRV measurements are available.
CONCLUSIONS AND PERSPECTIVES The use of a combined experimental and computational approach has been illustrated; the measurements are based on magnetic resonance velocimetry and the numerical simulations on the immersed boundary approach. Although relatively new, both methods appear very promising, and when combined together, offer potential for several innovative applications in the study of engineering turbulent flows. Three applications have been presented: the flow in a simple straight pipe, the flow in a complex three-legged rib-roughened serpentine and the flow around a coral. The results have been compared to "conventional" measurements obtained using PIV with satisfactory accuracy. In particular, it has been shown that the wealth of information provided by MRV allows the identification of specific areas of inadequacy of simple eddy-viscosity models used in the simulations.
Figure 12: IB predictions at 1/3 coral height. Streamwise velocity. Flow is from left to right. The grey scale gradation is an indication of streamwise velocity (m/s). Top: MRV data; middle: a snapshot of an unsteady laminar IB solution; bottom: steady state turbulent IB solution. Right column represents the same data reported in the left column without the geometry. Three major areas of application of the MRV-IB approach are envisioned: 1) validation and verification of computational tools, 2) design optimization and 3) reverse engineering. The validation of computational, predictive tools remains one of the pacing items in the use of computeraided engineering. Common practice is to perform preliminary studies on configurations that are somewhat simpler than the application of interest and for which experimental information is available. This step is necessary in building credibility in the numerical tools, but, certainly, it is not a sufficient warranty of reliability in the real-world scenario. The ability of both IB and MRV techniques to use
computer designed and rapid-prototyped models, respectively, allows for a testing mockup consistent with the device of interest and to generate data that can afterward be used to closely verify specific numerical tools or assumptions. The second area of interest is design optimization. For this problem, experiments are too expensive and time consuming and, therefore, CFD methods are the tools of choice. Conventional body-fitted CFD approaches have inherent difficulties in handling families of geometry which present large geometrical variability or have some parameters that can vary discontinuously: as an example, high-lift airfoil optimization when the number of components can be changed. The IB method represents an obvious solution for shape optimization problem from a geometrical modeling point of view. However, as discussed above, the accuracy of numerical predictions should be always verified, especially when, during an optimization procedure, unusual configurations arise. For this problem, MRV could be used as a posteriori tool that allows the investigation of a few selected configurations in more detail. By comparing MRV and IB, it is also possible to evaluate if certain configurations have been selected or discarded for the wrong reasons, i.e. due to inaccuracies in the modeling and not to lower figures of merit. The last application of the MRV-IB approach is in reverse engineering. In the third example showed in the paper, the flow around the coral, the starting point is a "device" which has certain features whose function requires further investigation. In the example presented, the construction of the RP model is based on a three-dimensional scanning of an existing coral skeleton. Once a digital representation (CAD model) is available, a rapid prototyping manufacturing process can be used to build a physical model, and the same CAD representation can be used to perform the simulations. The MRV and IB approaches are promising techniques to study flows in complex geometries: However, further work is required to fully establish their level of accuracy. Current research in MRV is related to improving the mean velocity measurements in turbulent flows and extending MRV capabilities to measure turbulent quantities (Saetran and Elkins, 2004). Another area that has received attention, although not discussed in this paper, is the use of MRV for unsteady, periodic flows (Markl et al. 2003). Current research on the numerical side has focused on the development of wall models for accurately predicting boundary layers on immersed boundaries not aligned with grid lines (Kalitzin et al. 2004). In addition, work is in progress to extend the approach for simulating conjugate heat transfer. In this case, the IB provides another direct advantage over body-fitted approaches, as the mesh within solid bodies, is automatically available. Initial results are very promising (Moreau et al. 2004).
REFERENCES Chang, S., Iaccarino G., Elkins C. J. (2004) Towards the study of hydrodynamics of coral reefs. CTR Annual Research Briefs, 121-132. Elkins, C.J, Markl, M., Pelc N., Eaton, J.K. (2003), "4D Magnetic Resonance Velocimetry for Mean Velocity Measurements in Complex Turbulent Flows," Experiments in Fluids 34:494-503. Fukushima E (1999) Nuclear magnetic resonance as a tool to study flow. Ann Rev Fluid Mech 31, 95-123 Kalitzin G., Medic G., Iaccarino G., Durbin P. (2004) Near wall behaviour of turbulence models and implications on adaptive wall functions. J. Comp. Physics, to appear. Haacke M; Brown R; Thompson M; Venkatesan R. (1999). Magnetic Resonance Imaging. New York: Wiley-Liss.
16
Iaccarino G. Kalitzin G., Elkins C. J. (2003) Numerical and experimental investigation of the turbulent flow in a fibbed serpentine passage. CTR Annual Research Briefs, 118-128. Iaccarino G., Kalitzin G., Khalighi B. (2003) Towards and immersed boundary RANS flow solver. AIAA Paper 2003-0770 Iaccarino G. and Verzicco R. (2003) Immersed boundary technique for turbulent flow simulations. Appl. Mech. Rev. 56-3, 331-347. Iacovides H. and Raisee M., (1999) Recent progress in the computation of flow and heat transfer in internal cooling passages of turbine blades. Int. J. Heat and Fluid Flow, 20, 320-328. Mittal R. and Iaccarino G. (2005) Immersed boundary method. Ann Rev Fluid Mech 37, 239-261. Markl M., Chan F., Alley M., Wedding K., Draney M., Elkins C. (2003) Time resolved three-dimensional phase contrast MRI (4D-Flow). J. Magn. Reson. Imaging 17, 499-506. Moreau S., Iaccarino G., Kalitzin G., (1004) Toward Conjugate Heat Transfer in Complex Geometries with an Immersed Boundary Cartesian Solver, ASME Paper HT-FED-2004-56834. Peskin C. S. (1972). Flow patterns around heart valves: a digital computer method for solving the equations of motion. PhD thesis. Physiol., Albert Einstein Coll. Med., Univ. Microfilms. 378:72-30 Saetran, L. and Elkins, C.J. (2004). Private communication. Stanislas M, Kompenhans J and Westerweel J. (2000) Particle Image Velocimetry, Kluwer Academic Publishers, The Nederlands. Stark D; Bradley W. (1999). Magnetic Resonance Imaging. St. Louis, Mosby-Year Book. von Schulthess G; Hennig J. (1998). Functional Imaging. Philadelphia, Lippincott-Raven; pp. 261-390.
17
Engineering TurbulenceModelling and Experiments6 W. Rodi (Editor) 9 2005 ElsevierLtd. All rights reserved.
LARGE-EDDY-SIMULATION USING THE IMMERSED
OF C O M P L E X BOUNDARY
FLOWS
METHOD.
R. Verzicco P o l i t e c n i c o di Bari, D I M e G a n d C E M e C , V i a Re D a v i d 200, 70125, Bari, Italia.
ABSTRACT
In this paper we will consider recent advances in the simulation of moderately high Reynolds number flows in complex geometric configurations. Although modern computers are experiencing an unprecedented growth in computing power, the numerical simulation of the above flows is still challenging owing to the handling of complex geometries and turbulence modeling that are the classical bottlenecks for the application of computational fluid dynamics (CFD) to industrially relevant problems. In this respect the immersed boundary (IB) method has shown to be a valid alternative for the treatment of complex geometries although additional issues must be addressed. This paper aims at describing the main techniques, showing some illustrative examples and discussing the main drawbacks and possible solutions.
KEYWORDS
Immersed boundary method, Complex geometries, Large-Eddy-Simulation, Turbulent flows, Industrial CFD.
18
INTRODUCTION In computational fluid dynamics a lot of effort is made to simulate high Reynolds number flows with the aim of understanding the dynamics of turbulence that affects countless aspects of our everyday life. This is usually done by considering simple model problems prescribed in trivial geometries since this brings to a straightforward domain discretization into a regular grid and to accurate and efficient numerical algorithms. On the other hand when a flow is bounded by a complex geometry the computation becomes more involved and less efficient. This is due to the computational overhead introduced by the body fitted mesh which leads to a trade-off between high Reynolds numbers and geometrical complexity. In fact, the generation of a body-fitted mesh requires that starting from some geometrical description of the body, a surface grid is first produced and this is used as a boundary condition for a volume grid covering the domain of interest. Although several techniques are available for the mesh generation (structured or unstructured grids) some common features are that on the regularity properties of the grid (like skewness, aspect ratio and size distribution of the cells) depend the quality of the flow solution. It must be noted, in addition, that the use of curvilinear grids introduces a significant overhead in the per-node operation count and that the generation of a grid fitted to a complex three-dimensional object requires a highly trained operator for a number of hours that can easily exceed the time needed to obtain the flow solution. Unfortunately the majority of flows encountered in practical applications involve complex geometric configurations whose adequate treatment is one of the main obstacles for the application of CFD as a standard design tool. Within this scenario the advantages of a method capable of simulating flows in complex geometries using simple non-body-conformal meshes are evident and this consideration is the main motivation for the immersed boundary method. Since the seminal work by Peskin (1972) (and a less notorious one by Vieceli, 1969) numerical simulations of flows inside or around complex geometric configurations without resorting to curvilinear body conformal grids have become feasible and a valid alternative to standard methods. The original procedure consisted of approximating the boundary of the i m m e r s e d body by a sequence of elastic fibers whose endpoints were tracked in a Lagrangian way according to the fluid velocity computed on a Cartesian grid. Given the stiffness of each element it is possible to compute the force locally exchanged between fluid and boundary and therefore the forcing term to apply to the momentum equation for the fluid. This procedure was successfully employed for the simulation of heart beating of mammals (Peskin & McQueen, 1989) and, more in general, to the flow around deformable bodies (Zhu & Peskin, 2003). The same method could be extended to flow/rigid body interactions by making the boundary elements stiffer. This extension, however, introduced additional problems like the appropriate choice of the elastic properties of the elements that, when too soft, yield anyway a deformable boundary, when too rigid, make the system of equations stiff. Since the original papers several amendments have been proposed with the aim of improving the stability and the applicability of the immersed boundary method. These improvements range from the forcing of the governing equations (Goldstein, Handler & Sirovich 1993, Saiki & Biringen 1996, Mohd-Yusof 1997, Fadlun et al. 2000, Kim, Kim & Choi 2001) to the spatial distribution of the forcing (Peskin 1972, Beyer & Leveque 1992, Lai & Peskin 2000). Detailed descriptions of the different techniques are given in Iaccarino & Verzicco (2003) and Mittal & Iaccarino (2005) here
is suffices to note that most of the techniques lead to a spatial second-order-accurate solution. An important drawback of the immersed boundary method is that, as the Reynolds number increases it becomes more difficult to fulfill the near-wall resolution requirements. In fact, while using a body conformal grid it is relatively easy to cluster grid nodes in the wall normal direction, the same clustering by a Cartesian grid requires refinements in all directions. We will show, in particular, that within the Large-Eddy-Simulation (LES) modeling this implies that if NBF and NIB are, respectively, the number of nodes needed by a three-dimensional body-fitted LES at Reynolds number Re and NIB the same quantity for the IB method it results NIB/NBp ": Re~ Although IB simulations are considerably less expensive than the body-fitted counterparts this increase of resolution can not always be accounted by "brute force" grid refinements. This brings to the need for near-wall modeling (Piomelli & Balaras, 2002) which still is an open issue for standard body-fitted-grid simulations and even less consolidated for IB methods.
LES TURBULENCE
MODELING
For moderately high Reynolds number flows the governing equations are the filtered Navier-Stokes equations that for incompressible flows read: 0--7 + V . (tiff) = - V / ~ - V . ~ +
V2fi + f,
and
V . fi = 0.
(1)
is the filtered velocity, ~ = f i ~ - tiff the sub-grid-scale (SGS) stress tensor, /~ the filtered pressure and f the forcing term needed to impose the boundary conditions at the fluid/immersed body interface (see Iaccarino & Verzicco, 2003 and Mittal & Iaccarino, 2005 for specific expressions of f). The tensor ~ must be modeled and following the Smagorinsky procedure its deviatoric part can be parametrized as - Tr(~) = 2uTS
with
~z -- C L f I ~ I
and
I s I--- (2S" ~)1/2
(2)
A is the filter width and S is the large-scale rate-of-strain tensor that can be computed from the filtered velocity S = (Vfi + v~T)/2. The trace of the sub-grid-scale stress tensor does not need to be explicitly modeled since it can be incorporated in a modified pressure ~* = ~- Tr(~). The model parameter C can be either externally assigned according to the original Smagorinsky model (Smagorinsky, 1963) or computed as part of the solution following a dynamic procedure (Germano et al., 1991). The first possibility is less expensive in terms of CPU time even if the resulting SGS model turns out to be too dissipative close to the walls and needs to be damped by a "ad hoc" function (for example the van Driest damping). The dynamic procedure, on the other hand, implies an additional filtering over a "test filter" and has a computational cost of the order of 30% of the total CPU time; it yields, however, a number of advantages highly desirable in a numerical simulation. First of all the turbulence model does not rely on user defined parameters and C is computed from the resolved field. The turbulence model automatically switches off in the near-wall region or within laminar flow patches without the need of damping functions. In addition, the dynamic determination of C allows for some energy backscatter (negative values of C) at least as long as the total viscosity (molecular + turbulent) does not become negative.
20
The computation of the coefficient C usually requires a spatial averaging before it can be used for the computation of the turbulent viscosity. In simple flows (homogeneous turbulence or plane channels) there is always one or more homogeneous directions that can be used for the averaging of C. In contrast, for flows in complex three-dimensional geometries homogeneous directions are not available and an alternative procedure is needed. One possibility is to use a filtered C instead of its raw counterpart which is equivalent to the pointwise averaging of C among the closest neighbors. This makes sense if one considers that according to the Kolmogorov hypotheses, in the inertial range turbulence is always locally homogeneous. Results obtained by this procedure are those by Verzicco et al., (2000) and Verzicco et al., (2002) which are briefly described in the successive sections. A more elegant and effective way for averaging C is by a Lagrangian algorithm. A complete discussion of the model is given in Meneveau, Lund & Cabot (1996) here we only note that since the dissipation is advected according to the fluid velocity, a natural way for averaging C (which parametrizes the dissipation) is along a streamline. This is performed by a weighting function which gives more weight to recent times, smooths out sharp fluctuations and preserves the spatially local nature of the model. This procedure has been successfully used by Balaras (2004) for the turbulent flow over a wavy wall; some of his results will be commented later in this paper.
BOUNDARY
RECONSTRUCTION
A fundamental issue of the IB method is the imposition of the forcing f at the fluid/body interface. The need for an explicit computation of f depends on the particular technique, even if every IB method eventually needs a reconstruction of the solution around the immersed surface. In fact, consider figure 1 where the shaded surface is the immersed boundary; it is immediately evident that while the boundary condition must be imposed over the surface, the flow unknowns are located somewhere in the computational cell and their position does not coincide with that of the surface; this is true for colocated methods as well as for staggered methods in which every flow variable is discretized in a different position. Simple mono- two- and full three-dimensional reconstruction schemes have been proposed (Fadlun et al. 2000, Gilmanov, Sotiropoulos & Balaras 2003, Tseng & Ferziger 2003, Kim et al. 2001) with different degrees of precision and efficiency although all of them yielding a second-order accuracy. One general procedure consists of a preliminary tagging of the computational cells which classifies the nodes into external, internal and interface points. The tagging can be performed by a ray-tracing algorithm (O'Rourke, 1998) as discussed in Iaccarino & Verzicco (2003) which is a standard in computer graphics. From each interface node (point A in figure 1) the normal to the immersed surface is drawn and the intersection W is computed. A tetrahedron is then constructed with A and the three closest external nodes (B, C and D) such that the point W is contained inside the tetrahedron. Every flow variable q (velocity component, density, temperature, scalar concentration, etc.) is then computed in A in such a way that the same variable assumes the values in B, C and D computed from the governing equations without any forcing and the prescribed boundary condition in W. Within a linear reconstruction q assumes the form: q = a x + by + cz + d
(3)
21
with a, b, c and d determined by the conditions q = qB, qc, qD and qw, respectively, at the points B, C, D and W. Once the coefficients a, b, c and d are known from the above conditions the value of q in A is simply given by qA -- aXA + byA + CZA nt- d. If, instead of Dirichlet conditions, Neumann boundary conditions (Oq/On = Cw) are to be applied the wall condition q = qw is replaced by V q . n = Oq/Oxc~ + Oq/Oy~ + O q / O z " / = ac~ + b~ + c~ = Cw, where c~, ~ and ~ are the components of the normal n in W.
Figure 1: Sketch of one possible interpolation scheme for the velocity reconstruction at the immersed boundary.
We wish to stress that according to equation (3) the solution behavior in the near-wall region is linear by definition which implies, in other words, that the first external points must be within the viscous sublayer. This is certainly true for a laminar flow or for direct numerical simulations (DNS) of turbulent flows but it is unlikely to happen even for moderately high Reynolds number LES simulations. If the immersed boundaries are largely aligned with coordinate grid lines a brute force grid refinement can be sufficient to get enough wall resolution. This was done in Verzicco et al., (2002) although this strategy can not be pursued for any three-dimensional geometry. A possible alternative was proposed by Majumdar, Iaccarino & Durbin (2001) which used a quadratic interpolation instead of the linear one of equation (3). This avoided the linear flow behavior close to the immersed boundary but, on the other hand, needed a larger stencil for the solution reconstruction. Additional difficulties are introduced by quantities whose near-wall behavior is intrinsically nonlinear even with enough wall resolution. In LES this is the case of the turbulent viscosity UT that, for equilibrium flows, decreases with (n+) a power law, being n the wall-normal direction. In this case the correct flow behavior could be recovered by using in equation (3) q = (pT) 1/3 although, as noted by Balaras (2004), the evaluation of the test-filtered quantities in the vicinity of the immersed boundary is not straightforward since it requires either modified stencils or the inclusion of internal body points. On the other hand, even if the velocity components are reconstructed from the surrounding points, the turbulent viscosity is needed to compute the viscous fluxes and inaccurate boundary values can affect the external solution. This suggests that a near-wall modeling procedure can avoid possible inaccuracies and give substantial improvements in the affordable Reynolds numbers.
22
NEAR-WALL
MODELING
One problem in the application of LES to wall-bounded flows at realistic Reynolds numbers is that, since the most energetic flow structures must be explicitly solved, the near wall resolution is comparable to that of a direct numerical simulation (DNS). In particular, if 5+ is the wall lengthscale, assuming a structured body-fitted grid covering an object of dimension L in which r/ is the wall-normal direction and X and ~ the other two directions we have A X ,.~ 5+, A~ ~ 5+ and At] ~ r/, the latter indicating that a grid stretching is performed in order to refine the near-wall region and save computational points far from the object. Following Chapman (1979) we have L/5 + ,.., Ra ~ therefore the number of points per cubic L must scale as NBF "' Re 1"~ ln Re (Pope, 2000). On the other hand, if the grid is not body-fitted there is not a wall normal coordinate line and the grid spacing must be ~ 5+ in all three directions. In other words in the IB method every direction can be normal or parallel to some part of the body and the grid must be, on average, equally fine in every direction. This implies that the number of nodes covering a cubic L now behaves as N~B ~ Re 2~4 and the ratio with the body-fitted counterpart is NxB/NBF "' Re~ Re. It must be observed that this estimate applies only to the number of nodes and not to the cost of the simulation since LES on simple Cartesian meshes is considerably less expensive than on curvilinear grids. In addition, in the IB method a fraction of the nodes (typically 10-30%) falls inside the immersed body where the flow needs not be computed, thus reducing the count of the dynamically active nodes. Nevertheless it is clear that since NIB/NBF increases with Re, LES simulations which are already challenging over body-fitted meshes become eventually unfeasible for IB methods. One way to overcome this difficulty is to replace the near wall region with an appropriate wall model feeding the LES with approximate wall boundary conditions, thus avoiding the direct computation of the near-wall region (Piomelli & Balaras, 2002). The advantages of this approach are evident if one considers that far from the wall an adequate spatial resolution for LES requires that the grid spacing A be only a fraction of the integral length scale s (Jimenez, 2003). The reason is essentially that the resolved scales are required to carry most of the flow stresses and they are produced at most at dimensions one order of magnitude smalled than s Assuming then A ~ s implies that order of thousands nodes per cubic s would be enough to adequately simulate by LES a turbulent flow. It is worth noting that the total number of nodes needed by the simulation, either NBF or NIB, depends on the ratio L/s which in turn is a problem-dependent value; nevertheless even if very large it is independent of the Reynolds number thus making feasible the simulation of industrial flows. Details and comparisons for the most popular wall models currently used in LES can be found in the review by Piomelli & Balaras (2002), in the present paper we only describe one of them which has been used in combination with IB methods. Following Balaras, Benocci & Piomelli (1996) a boundary layer equation for the tangential velocity components can be written as:
c9--~ (~ + ~T) 0rlJ = Fi
with
Fi = - ~ +
Oxj + Ox-----~'
(4)
being r/the wall normal direction. This equation can be solved within a "layer" between the solid boundary and the "external" LES solution in such a way that the external solution of equation (4) becomes the new wall boundary condition for LES.
23
Wang ~: Moin (2002) applied several versions of the above model and among them Fi = 0 yields the simplest: the equilibrium stress balance model. The eddy viscosity YT is obtained by a mixing length model with near wall damping ~T -- Pnrl+(l- e-~+/A) 2, with n --0.4 and A - 19. rl+ - U/5 + is the distance from the wall in viscous units computed from the instantaneous local friction velocity. It must be noted that the calculation of ~T needs U+ which relies on the friction velocity ur. The latter, in turn, is obtained from equation (4) which contains PT. An iterative procedure is than required that stating from a tentative value of ur (usually the value at the previous time step) solves simultaneously for equation (4) and the definition of PT. 0.3
0.25 0.2
rl 0.15 0.1 0.05 0
~
0
i
0.2
f
0.4 U
i
0.6
Figure 2: Wall velocity profile as function of wall distance. U+ - 30,
i
0.8
1
Re = 3900 first g r i d p o i n t a t
R e - 300 first g r i d p o i n t a t r/+ - 5.
One difficulty in the application of the above model to the IB method is that equation (4) is solved for the tangential velocity components along the wall normal coordinate; if from one external node (say point B in figure I) the wall normal is drawn, this will not intersect any other computational node. In addition each node will have a velocity which is neither tangential nor parallel to the wall; additional interpolations are therefore required to apply equation (4) in the IB context. This has been done by Tessicini et al., (2002) where further details of this procedure can be found. The authors report that the computational cost of this model, including the additional interpolations is about I0~ of the total CPU time. Some results obtained by this model are given in the section of the results, here we want to comment on an interesting property of this model which is summarized by figure 2. In particular, the equilibrium stress balance model yields the logarithmic law of the wall for rl+ >> 1 and a linear profile for rl+ ~ I. This implies that if the first external node is within a small multiple of 6 + (the Reynolds number is small or if the flow has locally a reduced turbulence level) the model automatically returns a linear velocity profile which is the same as if the model were absent. If instead the first external node is at tens or hundreds of wall units the model returns a logarithmic velocity profile. In other words, this model has the advantage of automatically switching off in flow regions where it is not needed similarly to the dynamic sub-grid-scale model for LES. In the original application (Tessicini et al., 2002) equations (I) were solved down to the second external node while equation (4) was used to determine the velocity components at the first external point. An improvement to this procedure is to solve equation (I) down to the first external
24
Figure 3: Flow in the IC piston-cylinder assembly at Re = 2000, and 65 x 65 x 151 (0 x r x z) grid, dynamic Smagorinsky subgrid-scale turbulence model, a) Sketch of the grid and of the geometry, b) t = 7r/2, (crank angle 90 ~ projected velocity vectors, meridional plane, c) t = 7r/2, projected velocity vectors, 15 mm below the head. nodes and use equation (4) to compute the wall stress. This is equivalent to assign a slip-velocity at the immersed boundary which provides the LES simulation with the "correct" wall shear stress. This procedure seems to give better results with respect to the previous implementation although a full validation within the IB context has not been performed yet (F. Tessicini, Personal
Communication). EXAMPLES
This part of the paper is devoted to the description of some illustrative applications of the above mentioned techniques; in the next two sections the Reynolds number of the flows is low enough to allow for sufficient spatial resolution near the wall. The successive example describes simulations where the resolution is marginal and only the large alignment of the immersed boundaries with the grid makes the flow computation possible. In the last example the Reynolds number is so large that the numerical simulation becomes unfeasible without a near-wall turbulence model.
Flow in a Model IC P i s t o n - C y l i n d e r Assembly In this section the LES of the three-dimensional flow in an axisymmetric piston/cylinder assembly with a fixed valve is illustrated. The configuration is reported in figure 3a and experimental measurements (phase averaged mean and RMS radial profiles of axial velocity) are available (Morse, Whitelaw & Yianneskis, 1978) for the validation of the numerical results. In the experiment, the piston was externally driven so that the fluid flowed into the cylinder from outside during the downward piston motion and vice-versa when the piston moved up. Since the valve was fixed and a tiny annular gap was left open between the valve and the cylinder head, the compression phase is not included in the flow dynamics. The piston was driven by a simple harmonic motion at a speed of 200rpm ~ 21rad/s which for the present geometry yields a mean piston speed of Vp = 0.4m/s
25
Figure 4: Radial profiles of averaged axial velocity components at t = 0.2x (crank angle 36~ a), b) and c), respectively at sections 10 mm, 20 mm and 30 mm below the head. Symbols: Experiments Morse et al. (1978), ~ " present LES Simulation. (when averaged over half cycle). The Reynolds number of the flow based on Vp and on the piston radius is Re = 2000 in air. It is worth noting that although the piston has an half-cycle mean velocity of only V--p- 0.4m/s the fluid driven through the valve gap has velocities up to 20Vp and for the adequate description of this flow a sub-grid-scale turbulence model is mandatory. In figure 3bc snapshots during one instant of the oscillating cycle are given and the high threedimensionality of the flow can be appreciated from the vector plots in orthogonal sections. Radial profiles of axial velocity were obtained by phase averaging the fields over four cycles and then averaged in the azimuthal direction. Three profiles at different axial locations are shown in figure 4. The comparison with the experimental data shows that the LES results are always in agreement with the experiments. In Verzicco et al. (2000) velocity profiles in additional sections and RMS profiles of axial velocity are also reported consistently showing a very good agreement with the measurements. The same flow was LES simulated by Haworth & Jansen (2000) and they used an unstructured boundary fitted, deformable mesh; the quality of the results is comparable even though the immersed boundary technique resulted much less expensive. Flow in a Wavy Channel This application (Balaras, 2004) considers the fully developed turbulent channel flow with the bottom wall having the shape of a sinusoidal wave. The problem geometry is that of figure 5a with a value of 2a/,~ = 0.1 and a spanwise dimension of the domain equal to the streamwise length. Several grids have been considered by Balaras (2004) the finest of which uses 288 • 64 • 130 nodes in the streamwise, spanwise and cross-stream directions. The Reynolds number based on the length H - ~ and the bulk velocity Ub is Re = 6760. The flow dynamics is governed by the unsteady separation downstream of the hill top and the successive reattachment in the throat. An instantaneous snapshot through a vertical plane is shown in figure 5b where the spanwise vorticity evidences the formation of the thin shear layer in the ascending part of the bottom and a recirculation in the descending half. Mean profiles of streamwise and wall-normal velocity components and resolved turbulent kinetic energy are given in figure 6 for one representative section showing a substantial agreement with reference DNS data (Maa/J & Shumann, 1996). The same kind of agreement is observed for other sections as shown by Balaras (2004) where further details on the simulation technique and
26
Figure 5: a) Sketch of~the problem. ~b) Instantaneous snapshot of spanwise vorticity through a vertical cross section (y/h = 1.2). Figures adapted from Balaras (2004) reproduced with permission.
Figure 6: Mean vertical profiles at the streamwise location x/h = 1. a) stramwise velocity, b) wall-normal velocity, c) resolved turbulent kinetic energy, o DNS by Maa# & Schumann (1996), coarse (192 x 64 x 88) LES by Balaras ( 2 0 0 4 ) , fine (288 x 64 x 130) LES by Balaras (2004). Figures adapted from Balaras (2004) reproduced with permission. flow dynamics can be found. Similar results were obtained by Tseng & Ferziger (2003) on a similar problem with slightly different geometrical parameters and turbulence modeling. Both examples demonstrate that when the near wall resolution is sufficient a LES with an IB method yields results of the same quality as the standard body-fitted methods.
Flow Around a Model Road Vehicle The objective of this study is to investigate by LES the dynamics of the wake past a model road vehicle for which experimental data are available for comparison (Khalighi et al., 2001).
Figure 7: a~ Road-Vehicle Configuration and Computational Grid in the Symmetry Plane (only one every 4 grid-points are shown), b) Averaged streamwise velocity through the symmetry mid-plane at Re- I00000.
27
!
1.5
1.0
1.ot
0.5
o.5t ,
0.0
0'~. 5 ufUinlet
0.0
0.5 U~inlet
1.0
Figure 8: Streamwise velocity profiles in the wake. o 9Experiments Khalighi et al., (2001); . . . . LES at Re = 20000; 9LES at Re = 100000. The configuration is reported in figure 7; the simulations are performed on a Cartesian grid made up of 220•215 points over a domain 13.5H • 4.2H • 3.77H in the streamwise, vertical and spanwise direction respectively, being H the height of the body. The experimental Reynolds number based on the free-stream velocity and the model height is Re = 170000. Preliminary simulations were carried out assuming that the main features of the flow and the corresponding trends in the flow dynamics at the back of the body were independent of Reynolds number if this was sufficiently high. Accordingly, the Reynolds number of the numerical simulations was fixed at Re = 20000; it was observed that indeed the numerical simulations showed all the trends and the flow features observed in the experiments. However, some quantitative differences were present. For this reason, additional simulations have been performed at Re = 100000 showing a much better quantitative agreement with the experimental data. Quantitative results are reported in figure 8 in terms of time-averaged streamwise velocity profiles in two sections downstream of the base. The measurements are compared with two LES simulations performed at Re = 20000 and Re = 100000; the high Reynolds number simulations agree well with the experiments. The defect velocity as well as the length of the recirculation region are accurately captured. The low Reynolds number simulations agree qualitatively with the measurements but strongly overpredict the thickness of the bottom-wall jet. The high Reynolds number results have also been compared to the experiments in terms of drag coefficients; a value of Co = 0.291 was computed from the LES simulations, whereas Co = 0.3 was the corresponding measurement. Additional analysis were carried out to study the unsteady dynamics of the flow and the effects of drag reduction devices; they are reported and discussed in Verzicco et al., (2002). Flow A r o u n d a Hydrofoil In the present example (Tessicini et al., 2002) is it considered the flow around a hydrofoil of chord C and maximum thickness H. The geometry is that used by Blake (1975) which investigated the flow experimentally. The Reynolds number based on the hydrofoil chord is R e c = 2.15 x 106 while based on the maximum thickness is ReH = 1.02 • 105. Following Wang & Moin (2000) the simulation is performed over the rear 38% of the hydrofoil chord (figure 9), on a domain 0.5H • 41H • 16.5H respectively in the spanwise, cross-stream and streamwise directions with
28
Y
-2
-8
0
X
8
Figure 9: Instantaneous streamwise velocity contours in the wake of the hydrofoil trailing edge.
(Au p 0.08'
H
.
Ue
Ue
:I
'
Urm U---e
Figure I0: Mean and rms U = v/u~ + u~ profiles normalized by the local external velocity Ue. Yw is the local y coordinate of the immersed surface, a) full LES on body-fitted mesh by Wang ~: Moin (2000), present IB solution without wall model. Sections at x/H - -3.125, -2.125, -1.625, -1.12, -0.625, 0. b) o experiments by Blake (1975), full LES by Wang & Moin (2000), LES with wall model by Wang & Moin (2000) present IB results with wall model. Sections as in a). c) the same as b) for the rms profiles. Sections as in a). a grid of 49 x 206 x 418 nodes. It is worth noting that although the grid is stretched around the hydrofoil surface the average wall grid spacing is about 60 wall units. This spacing does not allow the assumption of linear velocity profile in the region between the first external node and the immersed surface. Consistently, the simulation without wall model (although a dynamic sub-grid-scale model is activated) completely mispredicts the separation point and the velocity profiles (figure 10a). This test is particularly severe for the IB method since the flow separates over the curved surface in a point which is determined by the balance of the wall viscous stresses and the external pressure gradient. Since none of the coordinate lines is aligned with the hydrofoil surface the computation of the correct boundary layer dynamics is particularly challenging. In figures 10b the average velocity profiles are reported together with the experimental results and analogous data produced by body-fitted LES simulations. It can be noted that the introduction of a wall model yields a substantial improvement to the results whose agreement with the experiments is of the same quality as the body fitted results. The agreement with the experiments is less satisfactory for the rms profiles (figure 10c) although also the body fitted simulations are affected by some mismatch with experiments.
29
CONCLUSIONS The aim of the present paper was to show, by describing some illustrative examples, the recent advances in the field of LES in the context of IB methods. Owing to lack of space the paper could not discuss related topics like Cartesian Methods or applications to compressible flows. The reader is referred to the reviews by Iaccarino &: Verzicco (2003) and Mittal ~: Iaccarino (2005) for further reading. Before concluding the paper, however, we would like to shortly discuss one more point about the near-wall refinement. As shown by Iaccarino &: Verzicco (2003) some additional wall refinement can be obtained by immersed grids, i.e. by local fine grid patches applied over a coarser grid, the former being placed at the immersed body/fluid interface. This has shown to work very well in the context of RANS simulations since local near-wall refinements were possible without the node count increase typical of the structured grids. Unfortunately the same procedure could not be applied to LES simulations since preliminary tests have shown that the discontinuous grid spacing produced by the immersed grids yielded spurious stresses which in turn disrupted the turbulent viscosity computation (see figure 7 of Iaccarino ~ Verzicco, 2003). A possible solution was indicated in a recent paper by Mahesh, Costantinescu ~ MoAn (2004) who showed a conservative method for LES on unstructured grids; although this context is basically different from that of the structured grids used in the IB methods this might allow to combine immersed grids and IB methods in such a way that the conservation requirements of LES can be satisfied.
REFERENCES BALARAS, E., BENOCCI, C. AND PIOMELLI, U. (1996) Two-layer approximate boundary conditions for large-eddy simulations. AIAA J. 34, 1111-1119. BALARAS, E. (2004) Modeling complex boundaries using an external force field on fixed Cartesian grids in large-eddy simulations. Computers 8J Fluids 33, 375-404. BEYER, R.P. AND LEVEQUE, R.J. (1992) Analysis of a one-dimensional model for the immersed boundary method. SIAM, J. of Num. Anal. 29, 332-364. CHAPMAN, D.R. (1979) Computational aerodynamics development and outlook AIAA J. 17, 12931313. FADLUN, E.A., VERZICCO, R., ORLANDI, P. AND MOHD-YUSOF, J. (2000) Combined immersedboundary/finite-difference methods for three-dimensional complex flow simulations. J. Comp. Phys., 161, 35-60. GERMANO, M., PIOMELLI, U., MOIN, P. AND CABOT, W.H. (1991) A dynamic subgrid-scale eddy viscosity model. Phys. of Fluids A, 3(7), 1760-1765. COLDSTEIN, D. HANDLER R. AND SIROVICH L. (1993) Modeling no-slip flow boundary with an external force field. J. Comput. Phys., 105, 354-366. HAWORTH, D. C. AND JANSEN, K., (2000) Large-Eddy Simulation on Unstructured Deforming Meshes: Toward Reciprocating IC Engines. Computers and Fluids, 29, 493-524. KHALIGHI, B., ZHANG, S., KOROMILAS, C., BALKANYI, S.R., BERNAL, L.P., IACCARINO, G. (~ MOIN, P. (2001) Experimental and computational study of unsteady wake flow behind a bluff body with a drag reduction device. SAE Paper, 2001-01B-207. KIM, J. KIM, D. AND CHOI, H. (2001) An Immersed-Boundary finite-volume method for simulation of flow in complex geometries. J. Comput. Phys., 171, 132-150. IACCARINO, G. AND VERZICCO, R. (2003) Immersed boundary technique for turbulent flow simulations. App. Mech. Review, ASME, 56, 331-347.
30
JIMI~NEZ, J. (2003) Turbulence. Perspectives in Fluid Dynamics, Batchelor, Moffatt & Worster Eds. LAI, M.C. AND PESKIN C.S. (2000) An immersed boundary method with formal second-order accuracy and reduced numerical viscosity. J. Comput. Phys., 160, 705-719. MAA~, C. AND SCHUMANN, U. (1996) Direct numerical simulation of separated turbulent flow over a wavy boundary Flow simulations with high performance computers. Notes on numerical fluid mechanics., Hirschel Ed., 52, 227-241. MAHESH, K., COSTANTINESCU, G. AND MOIN, P. (2004) A numerical method for large-eddy simulation in complex geometries. J. Comput. Phys., 197, 215-240. MAJUMDAR, S., IACCARINO, G. AND DURBIN, P.A. (2001) RANS solver with adaptive structured non-conforming grids. Annual Res. Briefs, Center for Turbulence Research, 353-364. MCQUEEN, D.M. AND PESKIN, C.S. (1989) A three-dimensional computational method for blood flow in the heart: (II) contractile fibers. J. Comput. Phys., 82, 289-297. MENEVEAU C., LUND, T.S. AND CABOT, W.H. (1996) A Lagrangian dynamic sub-grid-scale model of turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. 319, 353-385. MITTAL, R. AND IACCARINO, G. (2005) Immersed Boundary Methods. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 37. MOHD-YOSUF J. (1997) Combined immersed-boundary/B-spline methods for Simulations of flow in complex geometries. Annual Research Briefs, Center for Turbulence Research, 317-328. MORSE, n. P., WHITELAW, J. H. ~ YIANNESKIS, M. (1978) Turbulent flow measurements by Laser Doppler Anemometry in a motored reciprocating engine. Report FS/78/24 Imperial College, Dept. Mesh. Eng. O'ROURKE, J. (1998) Computational Geometry in C Cambridge University Press. PESKIN, C.S. (1972) Flow Patterns Around Heart Valves: A Digital Computer Method for Solving the Equations of Motion. Ph.D. thesis, Physiology, Albert Einstein College of Medicine. University Microfilms 72-30, 378. PIOMELLI, U. AND BALARAS, E. (2002) Wall-layer models for Large-Eddy-Simulations. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 34, 349-374. POPE, S.B. (2000) Turbulent Flows Cambridge University Press. SAIKI, E. M. AND BIRINGEN S. (1996) Numerical Simulation of a Cylinder in Uniform flow: Application of a Virtual Boundary Method. J. Comput. Phys., 123, 450-465. SMAGORINSKY, J. (1963) General circulation experiments with the primitive equations. Monthly Weather Rev., 91 (3), 99-164. TESSICINI, F, IACCARINO, G., FATICA, M., WANG, M. AND VERZICCO R. (2002) Wall modeling for large-eddy-simulation using an immersed boundary method CTR, Ann. Res. Briefs, 2002, 181-187. TSENC, Y. H. AND FERZIGER J.H. (2003) A ghost-cell immersed boundary method for flow in complex geometry. J. Comput. Phys., 192, 593-623. VERZICCO, R., MOHD-YUSOF, J., ORLANDI, P. AND HAWORTH, D. (2000) Large-Eddy Simulation in Complex Geometric Configurations Using Boundary Body Forces. AIAA J., 38, 427-433. VERZICCO, R. FATICA, M., G. IACCARINO, P. MOIN AND B. KHALIGHI (2002) Large Eddy Simulation of a Road Vehicle with Drag Reduction Devices. AIAA J., 40, 2447-2455. VIECELI, J.A., (1969) A method for including arbitrary external boundaries in the MAC incompressible fluid computing technique. J. of Comp. Phys., 4, 543-551. WANG, M. AND MOIN, P., (2002) Dynamic wall modeling for LES of complex turbulent flows. Phys. of Fluids, 14, 2043-2051. ZHU, L. AND PESKIN, C.S., (2003) Interactions of two filaments in a flowing soap film. Phys. of Fluids, 15, 128-136.
Engineering Turbulence Modelling and Experiments6 W. Rodi (Editor) 9 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Transition Modelling for General Purpose CFD Codes
F.R. Menter l, R. Langtry l, S. V61ker2 and P.G. Huang 3 1ANSYS-CFX Germany, Software Development Dept., 83624 Otterfing, Germany 2 GE Global Research, One Research Circle, Niskayuna, NY 12309, USA 3 University of Kentucky, Lexington, Kentucky 40506-010
ABSTRACT The paper addresses modelling concepts based on the RANS equations for laminar-turbulent transition prediction in general-purpose CFD codes. Available models are reviewed, with emphasis on their compatibility with modem CFD methods. Requirements for engineering transition models suitable for industrial CFD codes are specified. A transition model, which satisfies most of the specified requirements is described, including results for a variety of different complex applications. KEYWORDS Laminar-turbulent transition, intermittency, local formulation, turbulence modelling, transport equation, SST model.
INTRODUCTION In the last decades, significant progress has been made in the development of reliable turbulence models, which allow the accurate simulation of a wide range of fully turbulent engineering flows. The efforts by different groups have resulted in a spectrum of models, which can be used for different applications, while balancing the accuracy requirements and the computational resources available to a CFD user. However, the important effect of laminar-turbulent transition is not included in the large majority of today's engineering CFD simulations. The reason is that transition modelling does not offer the same wide spectrum of CFD-compatible model formulations as available for turbulent flows, although a large body of publications is available on the subject. There are several reasons for this unsatisfactory situation. The first is that transition occurs through different mechanisms in different applications. In aerodynamic flows, transition is typically a result of a flow instability (Tollmien-Schlichting waves or cross-flow instability), where the resulting exponential growth eventually results in a non-linear breakdown to turbulence. In turbomachinery applications, the main transition mechanism is bypass transition (Morkovin, 1969, Mayle & Schulz, 1997) imposed on the boundary layer by high levels of
32 turbulence in the freestream, coming from the upstream blade rows. Another important transition mechanism is separation-induced transition (Mayle, 1996), where a laminar boundary layer separates under the influence of a pressure gradient and transition develops within the separated shear layer (which may or may not reattach). Finally, an already turbulent boundary layer can re-laminarize under a strong favourable pressure gradient (Mayle, 1991). While the importance of transition phenomena for aerodynamic and heat transfer simulations is widely accepted, it is difficult to include all of these effects in a single model. The second complication arises from the fact that the conventional (RANS) averaging procedures do not lend themselves easily to the description of transitional flows, where both, linear and non-linear effects are relevant. RANS averaging eliminates the effects of linear disturbance growth and is therefore difficult to apply to the transition process. While methods based on the stability equations, like the e n method of Smith & Camberoni (1956) and van Ingen (1956) avoid this limitation, they are not compatible with general-purpose CFD methods as typically applied in complex geometries. The reason is that these methods require a priori knowledge of the geometry and the grid topology. In addition, they involve numerous non-local operations, which are not easily implemented into today's CFD methods (Stock & Haase, 2000). This is not to argue against these models, which are an essential part of the desired "spectrum" of transition models required for the vastly different application areas and accuracy requirements. Much like in turbulence modelling, it is important to develop engineering models, which can be applied in the day-to-day operation by design engineers on varying geometries. Closer inspection shows that hardly any of the current transition models is CFD-compatible. Most formulations suffer from non-local operations, which cannot be carried out (with reasonable effort) in a general-purpose CFD code. It has to be understood that modem CFD codes do not provide the infrastructure of computing integral boundary layer parameters, or allow the integration of quantities along the direction of external streamlines. Even if structured boundary layer grids are used (typically hexahedra or prism layers), the codes are based on data structures for unstructured meshes. The information on a body-normal grid direction is therefore not easily available. In addition, most industrial CFD simulations are carried out on parallel computers using a domain decomposition methodology. This means in the most general case that boundary layers are typically split and computed on different processors, prohibiting any search or integration algorithms. Furthermore, for general purpose CFD applications, the grid topology relative to the surfaces is not known a priori, as the user has the freedom to freely choose both, geometry and grid topologies. The main requirements for a fully CFD-compatible transition model are therefore: 1. Allow the calibrated prediction of the onset and the length of transition. 2. Allow the inclusion of the different transition mechanisms. 3. Be formulated locally (no search or line-integration operations). 4. Avoid multiple solutions (same solution for initially laminar or turbulent boundary layer). 5. Do not affect the underlying turbulence model in fully turbulent regimes. 6. Allow a robust integration with similar convergence as underlying turbulence model. 7. Be formulated independent of the coordinate system. Considering the main classes of engineering transition models (stability analysis, correlation based models, low-Re models) one finds that most of these methods lack one or the other of the above requirements. The only formulations, which have historically been compatible with CFD methods, are low-Re models (Jones & Launder, 1973, Rodi & Scheuerer 1984). However, they typically suffer from the close interaction of the transition capability and the viscous sublayer modelling, which prevents an independent calibration of both phenomena (Savill 1993, 1996). In addition, low-Re models can at best
33 be expected to simulate bypass transition, which is dominated by diffusion effects. From a global perspective (without accounting for the differences between different models in the same group), standard low-Re models rely on the ability of the wall damping terms to also capture some of the effects of transition. Realistically, it would be surprising if models calibrated for viscous sublayer damping would faithfully reproduce the many effects of transitional flows. It is understandable that models using damping functions based on the turbulent Reynolds number have some transition characteristics. Nevertheless, the effect is best described as "pseudo-transition", as it was never actually built into the model. However, there are several models, where transition prediction was considered during model calibration (Wilcox, 1994, Langtry & Sjolander, 2002, Waiters & Leylek, 2002). It is interesting to note that several of these models use the vorticity (or strain-rate) Reynolds number Rev as an indicator for estimating the state of the laminar boundary layer. Nevertheless, these model formulations are based on a close connection of the sublayer and the transition calibration. Recalibration of one functionality also changes the performance of the other. It is therefore not possible to introduce additional experimental information, without a substantial re-formulation of the entire model. This operation can only be performed reliably by the model developer (or experts on model formulation). More complex models for transitional flows have been developed by Steeland & Dick (1996) and Lardeau et al. (2004). These models do however require a separate transition onset criteria, which is typically not formulated locally. The engineering alternative to low-Re models are correlation-based formulations like those of AbuGhannam & Shaw (1980), Mayle (1991) and Suzen et al. (2000). They typically correlate the transitional (momentum thickness) Reynolds number to local freestream conditions, like turbulence intensity and pressure gradient. These models allow for an easy calibration, even by non-experts in turbulence modelling and are often sufficiently accurate to capture the major effects. In addition, correlations can be developed for the different transition mechanisms, ranging from bypass to natural transition to crossflow instability to separation induced transition. The main shortcoming of these models lies in their inherently non-local formulation. They typically require information on the integral thickness of the boundary layer and the state of the flow outside the boundary layer. While these models have been used successfully in special-purpose turbomachinery codes, the non-local operations have precluded their implementation into general-purpose CFD methods. Transition simulations based on linear stability analysis, like the e n method, are the lowest closure level, where the actual instability of the flow is simulated. In the simpler models described above, the physics is introduced through the calibration of the model constants. However, even the e n method is not free of empiricism, as the n-factor is not universal and depends on the wind tunnel or freestream environment. The main obstacle to the use of the e n model is however that the required infrastructure is typically very complex. The stability analysis is often based on velocity profiles obtained from highly resolved boundary layer codes, which are coupled to the pressure distribution of the RANS solver. The output of the boundary layer method is then transferred to a stability method, which then provides information back to the turbulence model in the RANS solver. The complexity of this set-up is mainly justified for special applications where the flow is designed to remain close to the stability limit for drag reduction, like laminar airplane wing design. LES and DNS are suitable tools for transition prediction (e.g. Durbin et al. 2002), although even there, the proper specification of the external disturbance level and structure poses substantial challenges. These methods are far too costly for engineering applications, and are currently used mainly as research tools and substitutes for controlled experiments. Despite its complexity, transition should not be viewed as outside the range of RANS methods. In many applications, transition is enforced within a narrow area of the flow, by strong geometric disturbances, pressure gradients and/or flow separation. Even relatively simple models can capture these effects with sufficient engineering accuracy. The challenge to a proper engineering model is
34 therefore mainly the formulation of models, which are suitable for implementation into a general RANS environment. The present authors have recently developed a correlation-based transition model, built on transport equations, using only local variables. The central idea behind the model has been described in Menter et al. (2002). The major numerical and modelling deficiencies associated with that prototype model have been eliminated by Menter et al. (2004) and a wide range of turbomachinery-related flow problems has been computed by Langtry et al. (2004). The model has since been extended to aerodynamic flows (Langtry & Menter, 2005) and is now run within the software package CFX-5, as well as the GE in-house code Tacoma on numerous industrial applications. The model satisfies all requirements given above, except for the last o n e - coordinate independence. This is a consequence of the fact that transition correlations are based on non-Galilean invariant parameters, like the turbulence intensity Tu. As boundary layer transition is always relative to walls, this is only an issue if multiple moving walls exist in a single computational domain. Efforts are underway for eliminating this restriction. The model given in Menter et al. (2004) and Langtry et al. (2004) has been developed in a joint project between GE Global Research, ANSYS-CFX and the University of Kentucky. The model consists of two components. The first is the genetic infrastructure provided by two transport equations, which link the CFD code to experimental correlations. The second component are the correlations themselves. The innovation lies in the genetic infrastructure, which allows a direct coupling of general purpose CFD method with experimental transition data. The entire infrastructure of the formulation is given in Menter et al. (2004). The correlations were partly built on internal data and are not public domain. As the interfaces for the transitional correlations are clearly defined, other groups can use their own correlations as available for their application.
THE STRAIN
RATE
REYNOLDS
NUMBER
One of the central variables in the formulation of transport equations for transition prediction is the strain-rate (or sometimes vorticity) Reynolds number: Re v (x , y) : py2 S #
(1)
where y is the wall distance, p is the density,/t is the molecular viscosity and S is the absolute value of the strain rate. The importance of Rev lies in the relation of its maximum value inside the boundary layer to the momentum thickness Reynolds number Reo, of Blasius (or more generally Falkner-Skan) profiles (Menter et al. 2002): Re v (x,
Y)max
~"
Re o ( x )
(2)
where y is the location where Rev has its maximum. The function Re,., can be used on physical reasoning, by arguing that the combination of y2S is responsible for the growth of disturbances inside the boundary layer, whereas v : At/p is responsible for their damping. As y2S grows with the thickness of the boundary layer and v stays constant, transition will take place once a critical value of Re v is reached. The connection between the growth of disturbances and the function Re v was shown by Van Driest and Blumer (1963) in comparison with experimental data. The models proposed by Wilcox (1994), Langtry & Sjolander (2002) and Walters & Leylek, (2002) use Revin physics-based formulations of transition models. These models appear superior to conventional low-Re models, as they implicitly contain information of the thickness of the boundary layer. Nevertheless, the close integration of viscous sublayer damping and transition prediction does not allow an independent calibration of both sub-models.
35 In an alternative approach, Menter et al. (2002), Menter et al. (2004), Langtry et al. (2004) and Langtry & Menter (2005) proposed a combination of the strain-rate Reynolds number with experimental transition correlations using standard transport equations. Due to the separation of viscous sublayer damping and transition prediction, the new method has provided the flexibility for introducing additional transition effects with relative ease. Currently, the main missing extensions are cross-flow instabilities and high-speed flow correlations, which do not pose any principle obstacle. The concept of linking the transition model with experimental data, has proven an essential strength of the model, which is difficult to achieve with closures based on a physical modelling of these diverse phenomena.
THE 7-Reo MODEL As the model solves a transport equation for the intermittency, 7, and the transitional momentum thickness Reynolds number, Re| the model was named 7-Re| model. As it is described in detail in Menter et al. (2004), the equations are given here in compact form for completeness. The transport equation for the intermittency, 7; reads:
O(pr___))+ at
~(pU jr) Oxj
=
py, _ Ey, -I- ey2 -- E~,2 q- ~xj
~ q-
(a)
The transition sources are defined as follows:
eyl -- Flength Ca l P a [~tFonset ]ca;
E T1 - cel eyl ~r
(4)
where S is the strain rate magnitude. Flengthis an empirical correlation that controls the length of the transition region. The destruction/relaminarization sources are defined as follows"
Pr2 =
C a 2 P~"~ ~l~'turb "
E 7"2 = C e 2 PT2 7
(5)
where f~ is the vorticity magnitude. The transition onset is controlled by the following functions: Rev = PY2----~S; RT= pk /a /.tO m
Fonset 1 m
Re
v
.
....
2.193 9Re ec
,2 = min (max
(6) .....
.....
Fo.... 3 = m a x ( 1 - ( FRor ~\ -3~, 0 - ./.;. ~ j .... =max(Fo .... 2 - Fo.... 3,0); F,,rb = e - ( ~ l '
(8)
36 Re0c is the critical Reynolds number where the intermittency first starts to increase in the boundary layer. This occurs upstream of the transition Reynolds number, Re0~, and the difference between the two must be obtained from an empirical correlation.
Both the
Flength and
Re0c correlations are
functions of R e ~ . The constants for the intermittency equation are:
Cel : 1.0;
Ca1 = 2.0;
Ce2 :
C,~ ----0.5;
Ca2 = 0.06;
50;
Crr = 1.0;
(9)
A modification for separation-induced transition is:
/ L Re)J
Ysep = min 2. max
v 3.235 Reoc
-- 1 , 0
F r...... h ,2
/
F~" Freattach : e
(Td-;
"7"ee : max (?', ?'sep)
(lO)
The boundary condition for 7'at a wall is zero normal flux while for an inlet 7'is equal to 1.0. ,.,.,
The transport equation for the transition momentum thickness Reynolds number, R e ~ , reads:
cq~('o ~tff" e at ) +
OXg
-:Pot+
~x j
O'~ (fl "~ fit ) Ox j
(l l)
The source term is defined as follows" Pot = Cot 7P
(Re ot -P-,e ot X1 9O- Fo,);,
: minlmaxlkee''41~
o 1,,2
t =
500 /2 pU
2
1o
15 0 BL" 8 = 5 0 ~ y 98eL 0BL = Re~________~B. 8BL = -7pU
(12)
(13) (14)
U
pO)y 2 Re o) = ~ " /z
_( R% ) 2 ~.lE+5)
Fwa~e = e
(15)
era-2.0
(16)
The model constants for the Re~ equation are: ca - 0 . 0 3 "
The boundary condition for R e ~ at a wall is zero flux. The boundary condition for Reo~ at an inlet should be calculated from the empirical correlation based on the inlet turbulence intensity. The model contains three empirical correlations. Re|
is the transition onset as observed in
experiments. It is used in Eq. 12. Flength is the length of the transition zone and goes into Eq. 4. Re| the point where the model is activated in order to match both, Re|
and Flength, it goes into Eq. 7.
is
37 Reot =
f(Tu,/],);
Flength =
f(Reot ~
Re~ =
f(ff.eot )
(17)
The first empirical correlation is a function of the local turbulence intensity, Tu, and the Thwaites' pressure gradient coefficient ~,0 defined as: ~0 = (02/v)dU/ds
(18)
where dU/ds is the acceleration in the streamwise direction. The transition model interacts with the SST turbulence model (Menter, 1994), as follows: (19)
= Y~#Pk" /gk = min(max(7'~g,0.1),l.0)Dk
(20)
-(',/' Ry = ,oy~,,~ ; F3 =e /t
k~2o) . F~ -max(Florig,F3)
(21)
where Pk and Dk are the original production and destruction terms for the SST model and Florig is the original SST blending function. Note that the production term in the o~equation is not modified. The rational behind the above model formulation is given in detail by Menter et al. (2004). In order to capture the laminar and transitional boundary layers correctly, the grid must have a y+ of approximately one. All simulations have been performed using CFX-5 with a bounded second order upwind biased discretisation for the mean flow, turbulence and transition equations, except for some of the flat plate cases, which have been computed with the boundary layer code of the University of Kentucky.
TESTCASES The remaining part of the paper will give an overview of some of the public-domain testcase which have been computed with the model described above. This naturally requires a compact representation of the simulations. The cases are described in more detail in Menter et al. (2004), Langtry et al. (2004) and Langtry & Menter (2005), including grid refinement and sensitivity studies.
Flat Plate Testcases Testcases presented are the ERCOFI'AC T3 series of flat plate experiments and the Schubauer and Klebanof flat plate experiment, all of which are commonly used as benchmarks for transition models. The three cases (T3A-, T3A, and T3B) have zero pressure gradients with different freestream turbulence levels corresponding to transition in the bypass regime. The Schubauer and Klebanof (S&K) test case has a low free-stream turbulence intensity and corresponds to natural transition. The T3C4 test case consists of a flat plate with a favourable and adverse pressure gradient imposed by the opposite converging/diverging wall. It is used to demonstrates the transition models ability of
38 predicting separation induced transition and the subsequent reattachment of the turbulent boundary layer.
Figure 1: Results for flat plate test cases with different freestream turbulence levels and pressure gradients (FSTI- Freestream Turbulence Intensity). Figure 1 shows the comparison of the model prediction with experimental data for all computed cases. In all simulations, inlet turbulence levels were specified to match the experimental turbulence intensity and its decay rate. The agreement with the data is generally good, considering the diverse nature of the physical phenomena computed, ranging from bypass transition to natural transition to separationinduced transition. Turbomachinery Test Cases Zierke & Deutsch compressor cascade
For the present test case (Zierke & Deutsch, 1989), transition on the suction side occurs at the leading edge due to a small leading edge separation bubble on the suction side. On the pressure side, transition
39 occurs at about mid-chord. shown in Figure 2.
The intermittency contours and the wall shear stress (cf) distribution are
Figure 2: Intermittency contours (left) and cf-distribution against experimental data (fight for the Zierke & Deutsch compressor. There appears to be a significant amount of scatter in the experimental data, however, in principal the transition model is predicting the major flow features correctly (i.e. fully turbulent suction side, transition at mid-chord on the pressure side). One important issue to note is the effect of stream-wise grid resolution on resolving the leading edge laminar separation and subsequent transition on the suction side. If the number of stream-wise nodes clustered around the leading edge is too low, the model cannot resolve the rapid transition and a laminar boundary layer on the suction side is the result. For the present study 60 streamwise nodes where used in between the leading edge and the x/C equal to 0.1 location. Von-Karman Institute turbine cascade
The surface heat transfer for the transonic VKI MUR 241 (FSTI = 6.0%) and MUR 116 (FSTI = 1.0%) test cases (Arts et al. 1990) is shown in Figure 3. The strong acceleration on the suction side for the MUR 241 case keeps the flow laminar until a weak shock at mid chord, whereas for the MUR 116 case the flow is laminar until fight before the trailing edge. Downstream of transition there appears to be a significant amount of error between the predicted turbulent heat transfer and the measured value. It is possible that this is the result of a Mach number (inlet Mach number Mainlet=0.15, Maoutlet=l.089) effect on the transition length (Steelant and Dick, 2001). At present, no attempt has been made to account for this effect in the model. It can be incorporated in future correlations, if found consistently important. The pressure side heat transfer is of particular interest for this case. For both cases transition did not occur on the pressure side, however, the heat transfer was significantly increased for the high turbulence intensity case. This is a result of the large freestream levels of turbulence which diffuse the laminar boundary layer and increase the heat transfer and skin friction. From a modeling standpoint the effect was caused by the large freestream viscosity ratio necessary for MUR 241 to keep the turbulence intensity from decaying below 6%, which is the freestream value quoted in the experiment. The enhanced heat transfer on the pressure side was also present in the experiment and the effect appears to be physical. The model can predict this effect, as the intermittency does not multiply the eddy-viscosity but only the production term of the k-equation.
40
Figure 3: Heat transfer for the VKI MUR241 (FSTI = 6.0%) and MUR116 (FSTI = 1.0%) test cases
RGW Compressor Cascade The RGW annular compressor (Schulz and Gallus, 1988) features a fully three-dimensional flow, including sidewall boundary layers originating upstream of the blade. This flow topology poses a major challenge to standard correlation-based transition models, as complex logic would be required to distinguish between the different boundary layers. Figure 4 shows a comparison of the simulations on the suction side of the blade with an experimental oil-flow picture. For comparison, a fully turbulent flow simulation is also included. It can be seen that the transition model captures the complex flow topology of the experiments in good qualitative agreement with the data. A comparison between the transition model and the fully turbulent simulation shows the strong influence of the laminar flow separation on the sidewall boundary layer separation. The flow separation on the shroud is significantly reduced by the displacement effect of the separation bubble in the transitional simulation. As a result, the loss coefficient, Yp=0.19, in the fully turbulent simulation is much higher than the experimental value of Yp=0.097. The simulation with the transition model gives a value of Yp=0.11 in much closer agreement with the experiment.
Figure 4: Fully turbulent (left) and transitional (fight) skin friction on the suction side of the 3D RGW compressor cascade compared to experimental oil flow visualization (middle). ( Y p - loss coefficient).
41 More turbomachinery related testcases can be found in Langtry et al. (2004), including an unsteady rotor-stator interaction simulation. Wind Turbine Test Case
The testcase geometry is a 2D airfoil section, as typically used for GE wind-turbine blades. It operates in a low FSTI environment with a turbulence intensity of only around 0.1% at the leading edge. As a result, natural transition occurs on both the suction and pressure surfaces. The inlet value for the co in this application was choosen to match the experimental transition location at 0 ~ All other angles of attack have been computed with the identical settings. For a detailed discussion see Langtry et al. (2004).
Figure 5: Predicted transition location (left) and drag coefficient (fight) as a function of angle of attack for a wind turbine airfoil in comparison with experiments and the en-method used in XFOIL. The transition locations vs. angle of attack for the present transition model are shown in Figure 5 (fight). Wind tunnel results and predictions XFOIL (v6.8) based on an en method are plotted for comparison. The experimental data were obtained using a stethoscope method. The current model captures the dependence of the transition location on the angle of attack in very good agreement with the data.The effct of the transition model is clearly visible also in the drag coefficient Figure 5 (fight). Numbers could not be provided on the y-axis, due to data confidentiality. 3D NREL Wind Turbine Simulation
Simulations have been carried out for the NREL wind turbine (Simms et al., 2001). This is a notoriously difficult testcase to compute with CFD and no attempt can be made to cover the complexity of a comparison of CFD and experimental data. However, in the simulation of this flow, it turned out that substantial differences were observed between fully turbulent and transitional results at severe stall conditions. Figure 6 shows the shaft torque in comparison with experiments (left) and the flow topologies computed for fully turbulent and transitional settings.
42
Figure 6: Shaft torque at different wind speeds (left). Flow topology on suction side for fully turbulent and transitional simulations (fight)
At a wind speed of 20 m/s, the flow topology computed with the fully turbulent and the transitional approaches are very different. This results in a 80% change in output torque. The lower output torque appears to be the result of a laminar separation in the leading edge region of the suction side of the blade. The transitional simulation is in much closer agreement with the experimental data.
Aeronautical Test Cases Transition in aeronautical flows is typically a result of Tollmien-Schlichting waves or a crossflow instability. The current model does presently not include correlations for crossflow instabilities. It does however account for natural transition including pressure gradients. For more details on the testcases see Langtry and Menter (2005).
McDonald Douglas 30P-30N Flap The McDonald Douglas 30P-30N flap configuration was originally a test case for the High-Lift Workshop/CFD Challenge that was held at the NASA Langley Research Center in 1993 (Klausmeyer and Lin, 1997). It is a very complex test case for a transition model because of the large changes in pressure gradient and the local freestream turbulence intensity around the various lifting surfaces. The experiment was performed in the Langley Low Turbulence Pressure Tunnel and the transition locations were measured using hot films on the upper surface of the slat and flap and on both the upper and lower surfaces of the main element. The skin friction was also measured at various locations using a Preston tube (Klausmeyer and Lin, 1997). For the present comparison the Reynolds number Re=9xl06 and an angle of attack ct=8 ~ was selected. The freestream conditions for k and co were selected to match the transition location at the suction side of the slat. The other transition locations are an outcome of the simulation.
43
Figure 7: Contour of turbulence intensity (Tu) around the McDonald Douglas 30P-30N flap as well as the measured (Exp.) and predicted (CFD) transition locations (x/c) as a function of the cruise-airfoil chord (c = 0.5588 m). Also indicated is the relative error between the experiment and the predictions.
A contour plot of the predicted turbulence intensity around the flap is shown in Figure 7. Also indicated are the various transition locations that were measured in the experiment (Exp.) as well as the locations predicted by the present transition model (CFD). In the computations the onset of transition was judged as the location were the skin friction first started to increase due to the production of turbulent kinetic energy in the boundary layer. In general the agreement between the measured and predicted transition locations is very good. The largest error was observed on the lower surface of the main element were the predicted transition location was too far downstream by approximately 6% of the cruise-airfoil chord. DLR F-5 wing The DLR F-5 geometry is a 20 ~ swept wing with a symmetrical airfoil section that is supercritical at a freestream Mach number of 0.82. The experiment was performed at the DLR by Sobieczky (1994) and consists of a wing mounted to the tunnel sidewall (which is assumed to have transitioned far upstream of the wing). At the root the wing was designedto blend smoothly into the wall thus eliminating the horseshow vortex that usually develops there. The experimental measurements consist of wing mounted static taps at various span wise locations and flow visualization of the surface shear using a sublimation technique.
44
Figure 8:DLR-F5 wing with transition. Simulations (left); Experiment (middle and fight) The experimental flow visualization is shown in Figure 8 (fight). Based on the flow visualization and the pressure measurements a diagram of the flow field around the wing was constructed and can be seen in Figure 8 (middle). From the measurements the boundary layer is laminar until about 60% chord where a shock causes the laminar boundary layer to separate and reattach as a turbulent boundary layer. The contours of skin friction and the surface streamlines predicted by the transition model are shown in Figure 8 (left). From the skin friction the laminar separation and turbulent reattachment can be clearly seen and both appear to be in good agreement with the experimental diagram from about 20% span out to the wing tip. Near the wing-body intersection, the experiments indicate earlier transition than the simulations. This might be due to the omission of the cross-flow instability in the transition model.
Eurocopter Cabin The helicopter testcase was investigates to demonstrate the models ability of solving flows around complex geometries including multiple physical effects. There are no experimental data available in the public domain, which precludes the use of the testcase for model validation. Nevertheless, interesting transitional phenomena can be observed. In addition, the numerical performance of the transition model can be investigated. The grid for this case consisted of about 6 million nodes and each solution was run overnight in parallel on a 16 CPU Linux cluster. The convergence of lift and drag is shown in Figure 9 for the fully turbulent (top) and transitional (bottom) solutions. The transition model does not appear to have any adverse effects on the convergence and converges similar to the fully turbulent solution. This was also observed in most of the other cases. Typically the convergence is somewhat reduced in the transitional simulations, as the transition location has to settle down before convergence can be reached. The overall increase (additional equations and convergence) of the model is typically --20%. The
45 transitional flow on the fuselage and tails resulted in a 5% drag reduction compared to the fully turbulent solution.
Figure 9: Convergence of lift and drag for the fully turbulent (left) and transitional (fight) for Eurocopter simulation
Figure 1O: Contour plot of skin friction for a fully turbulent (left) and transitional (fight) for Eurocopter cabin. Isosurface indicates reverse flow.
The predicted skin friction for a fully turbulent and transitional solution is shown in Figure 10. The main differences in the transitional solution are that the front part of the fuselage, the two outside vertical tail surfaces and the outer half of the horizontal tail surface are laminar. The fact that the transition model predicted turbulent flow on the middle vertical stabilizer and the inner part of the horizontal stabilizer was unexpected. Further investigation revealed that this was caused by the turbulent wake that was shed from the fuselage upstream of the tail. This is best illustrated in Figure
46 11. The left picture shows an iso-surface of the turbulent flow. The turbulent wake is clearly visible and can be seen passing over the middle vertical stabilizer and the inner part of the horizontal stabilizer. Consequently, the transition model predicts Bypass transition on these surfaces due to the high local freestream turbulence intensity from the wake.
Figure 11: Iso-surface of turbulent flow (left) and surface value of intermittency (fight) indicating the laminar (blue) and turbulent (red) regions on the Eurocopter airframe The Eurocopter testcase demonstrates the potential of the transition model for solving complex aerodynamic flow problems, with the inclusion of 1st order transitional effects. Further model refinements are required for calibration of the model for such flows, including a model extension for crossflow instability.
CONCLUSIONS Methods for transition prediction in general purpose CFD codes have been discussed. The requirements, which a model has to satisfy to be suitable for implementation into such a code, have been listed. The main criterion is that non-local operations should be avoided. The T-Re0 transition model was built on these requirements. The model solves two transport equations and can be applied to any arbitrary geometry. Current limitations of the model are that crossflow instability is not included in the correlations and that the transition correlations are formulated nonGalilean invariant. Both limitations are currently investigated and can in principle be removed. An overview of testcases computed with the new model has been given. Due to the nature of the paper, the presentation of each individual testcase had to be brief. More details on the testcase set-up, boundary conditions grid resolutions etc. can be found in the cited papers. The purpose of the overview was to show that the model can handle a wide variety of geometries and physicaly diverse problems. The authors belief that the central concept of combining transition correlations with locally formulated transport equations has a strong potential for including 1st order transitional effects into today's industrial CFD simulations.
47 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT The model development and validation at ANSYS CFX was funded by GE Aircraft Engines and GE Global Research. Prof. G. Huang and Dr. B. Suzen from the University of Kentucky have supported the original model development with their extensive know-how and their in-house codes. REFERENCES
Abu-Ghannam, B.J. and Shaw, R., (1980), Natural Transition of Boundary Layers - the Effects of Turbulence, Pressure Gradient and Flow History. J. of Mechanical Engineering Science, Vol. 22, pp. 213 - 228. Arts, T., Lambert de Rouvroit, M. and Rutherford, A.W. (1990), Aero-thermal Investigation of a Highly Loaded Transonic Linear Turbine Guide Vane Cascade", von Karman Institute for Fluid Dynamics, Technical Note 174. Durbin, P.A., Jacobs, R.G. and Wu, X., 2002, DNS of Bypass Transition, Closure Strategies for Turbulent and Transitional Flows, edited by B.E. Launder and N.D. Sandsam, Cambridge University press, pp. 449-463. Jones, W. P., and Launder, B. E., (1973). The Calculation of Low Reynolds Number Phenomena with a Two-Equation Model of Turbulence," Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer, Vol. 15, pp. 301-314. Klausmeyer, S.M. and Lin, J.C., (1997). Comparative Results From a CFD Challenge Over a 2D Three-element High-Lift Airfoil. NASA Technical Memorandum 112858. Langtry, R.B., Menter, F.R., Likki, S.R., Suzen, Y.B., Huang, P.G., and Vrlker, S. (2004). A Correlation based Transition Model using Local Variables Part 2 - Test Cases and Industrial Applications. ASME-GT2004-53454, ASME TURBO EXPO 2004, Vienna, Austria. Langtry, R.B., and Menter, F.R., (2005). Transition Modeling for General CFD Applications in Aeronautics, AIAA Paper 2005-522, Reno, Nevada. Langtry, R.B., and Sjolander, S.A. (2002). Prediction of Transition for Attached and Separated Shear Layers in Turbomachinery", AIAA-2002-3643, 38 th AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint Propulsion Conference and Exhibit. Lardeau, S., Leschziner, M.A. and Li, N. (2004). Modelling Bypass Transition with Low-ReynoldsNumber Nonlinear Eddy-Viscosity Closure, Flow, Turbulence and Combustion, Kluwer Academic Publishers. Mayle, R.E. (1991). The Role of Laminar-Turbulent Transition in Gas Turbine Engines, Journal of Turbomachinery, Vol. 113, pp. 509-537. Mayle, R.E. and Schulz, A. (1997), The Path to Predicting Bypass Transition, ASME Journal of Turbomachinery, Vol. 119, pp. 405-411. Mayle, R.E. (1996), Transition in a Separation Bubble. Journal of Turbomachinery, Vol. 118, pp. 752759. Menter, F.R. (1994). Two-Equation Eddy-Viscosity Turbulence Models for Engineering Applications, AIAA Journal, Vol. 32, No. 8, pp. 1598-1605. Menter, F. R., Esch, T. and Kubacki, S. (2002). Transition Modelling Based on Local Variables, 5 th International Symposium on Turbulence Modeling and Measurements, Mallorca Spain. Menter, F.R., Langtry, R.B., Likki, S.R., Suzen, Y.B., Huang, P.G., and Vrlker, S., (2004). A Correlation based Transition Model using Local Variables Part 1- Model Formulation. ASMEGT2004-53452, ASME TURBO EXPO 2004, Vienna, Austria. Morkovin, M.V. (1969). On the Many Faces of Transition, Viscous Drag Reduction, C.S. Wells, ed., Plenum Press, New York, pp 1-31. Rodi, W. and Scheuerer, G. (1984). Calculation of Laminar-Turbulent Boundary Layer Transition on Turbine Blades. AGARD CP 390 on Heat transfer and colloing in gas turbines, 18-1.
48 Savill, A.M., (1993). Some Recent Progress in the Turbulence Modelling of By-pass Transition, In: R.M.C. So, C.G. Speziale and B.E. Launder, Eds.: Near-Wall Turbulent Flows, Elsevier, p. 829. Savill, A.M., (1996), One-point Closures applied to Transition. Turbulence and Transition Modelling, M. Hallbiick et al., eds., Kluwer, pp. 233-268. Schulz, H.D., Gallus, H.D., (1988), Experimental Investigation of the Three-Dimensional Flow in an Annular Compressor Cascade. ASME Journal of Turbomachinery, Vol. 110, October. Simms, D., Schreck, S., Hand, M, and Fingersh, L.J. (2001). NREL Unsteady Aerodynamics Experiment in the NASA-Ames Wind Tunnel: A Comparison of Predictions to Measurements. NREL Technical report, NREZ/FP-500-29494. Smith, A.M.O. and Gamberoni, N. (1956). Transition, Pressure Gradient and Stability Theory, Douglas Aircraft Company, Long Beach, Calif. Rep. ES 26388,. Sobieczky, H. (1994), DLR - F5: Test Wing for CFD and Applied Aerodynamics, Test Case B-5 in AGARD FDP Advisory Report AR 303: Test Cases for CFD Validation. Steelant, J., and Dick, E. (2001), Modeling of Laminar-Turbulent Transition for High Freestream Turbulence. Journal of Fluids Engineering, Vol. 123, pp. 22-30 Stock, H.W. and Haase, W. (2000). Navier-Stokes Airfoil Computations with eN Transition Prediction Including Transitional Flow Regions, AIAA Journal, Vol. 38, No. 11, pp. 2059 - 2066. Suzen, Y.B., Xiong, G., Huang, P.G. (2000), Predictions of Transitional Flows in Low-Pressure Turbines Using an Intermittency Transport Equation. AIAA-2000-2654, AIAA Fluids 2000 Conference. Van Driest, E.R. and Blumer, C.B. (1963). Boundary Layer Transition: Freestream Turbulence and Pressure Gradient Effects, AIAA Journal, Vol. 1, No. 6, pp. 1303-1306. Van Ingen, J.L., (1956). A suggested Semi-Empirical Method for the Calculation of the Boundary Layer Transition Region, Univ. of Delft, Dept. Aerospace Engineering, Delft, The Netherlands, Rep. VTH- 74. Walters, D.K and Leylek, J.H. (2002). A New Model for Boundary-Layer Transition Using a SinglePoint Rans Approach. ASME IMECE'02, IMECE2002-HT-32740. Wilcox, D.C.W. (1994), Simulation of transition with a two-equation turbulence model, AIAA J. Vol. 32, No. 2. Zierke, W.C. and Deutsch, S., (1989), The Measurement of Boundary Layers on a Compressor Blade in Cascade-Vols. 1 and 2, NASA CR 185118.
Engineering TurbulenceModelling and Experiments6 W. Rodi (Editor) 9 2005 ElsevierLtd. All rights reserved.
49
P O S S I B I L I T I E S A N D L I M I T A T I O N S OF C O M P U T E R S I M U L A T I O N S OF I N D U S T R I A L MULTIPHASE
TURBULENT
FLOWS
L. M. Portela t and R. V. A. Oliemans Kramers Laboratorium voor Fysische Technologie J. M. Burgerscentrum for Fluid Mechanics Delft University of Technology Prins Bernhardlaan 6, 2628 BW Delft, The Netherlands tCorresponding author, email:
[email protected]
ABSTRACT We give an overview on the usage of computer simulations in industrial turbulent dispersed multiphase flows. We present a few examples of industrial flows: bubble columns and bubbly pipe flows, stirred tanks, cyclones, and a fluid catalytic cracking unit. The fluid catalytic cracking unit is used to illustrate the complexity of the physical phenomena involved, and the possibilities and limitations of the different approaches used: Eulerian-Lagrangian (particle-tracking) and Eulerian-Eulerian (two-fluid). In the first approach, the continuous phase is solved using either RANS or DNS/LES, and the individual particles are tracked. In the second approach, the dispersed phase is averaged, leading to two sets equations, which are quite similar to the RANS equations of single-phase flows. The Eulerian-Eulerian approach is the most commonly used in industrial applications, however, it requires a significant amount of modelling. Eulerian-Lagrangian RANS can be simpler to use; in particular in situations involving complex boundary conditions, polydisperse flows and agglomeration/breakup. The key issue for the success of the simulations is to have good models for the complex physics involved. A major weakness is the lack of good models for: the turbulence modification promoted by the particles, the inter-particle interactions, and the near-wall effects. Eulerian-Lagrangian DNS/LES can play an important role as a research tool, in order to get a better physical understanding, and to improve the models used in the RANS simulations (either Eulerian-Eulerian or Eulerian-Lagrangian). KEYWORDS Multiphase flows, turbulent flows, industrial flows, numerical simulation, Eulerian-Lagrangian, Eulerian-Eulerian, particle tracking, two-fluid, DNS, LES, RANS, dispersed flows.
50
INTRODUCTION Turbulent multiphase flows occur in numerous industrial processes, covering a wide range of phenomena and scales. Contrary to the computation of single-phase flows, where the physics is well understood, and relatively general methods can be employed, in multiphase flows the fundamental understanding of the physical phenomena is still rather poor, and it differs significantly in different types of flows. Therefore, the appropriate simulation technique will depend on the type of flow. Multiphase flows can be divided into two categories: (i) continuous multiphase flows, and (ii) dispersed multiphase flows. In the first category, (e.g., formation of waves in the flow of air over water), each phase is treated as a continuous medium, together with a method to track the interface; the modelling and numerical issues are quite similar to single-phase flows, with the additional complexity of the interface tracking and interface resolution. In the second category (e.g., pneumatic transport of solid particles), one of the phases is considered as a continuum and the other phase is considered as composed of discrete components, the particles (the term "particles" can denote solid particles, drops or bubbles). Here we will consider only dispersed multiphase flows. In principle, the balance equations together with the constitutive equations of each phase and the interfacial conditions, can be used to obtain a fully-resolved simulation of dispersed multiphase flows (i.e., a dispersed multiphase flow is nothing more than a continuous multiphase flow with a large number of different phases). However, this is extremely costly, and is only used in fundamental studies involving a relatively small number of particles. For example, this approach has been used in fundamental studies of bubbly flows (Esmaeeli and Tryggvason, 1998 and 1999) and in the study of the interaction of colliding particles in homogeneous isotropic turbulence (Ten Care et al., 2004). In industrial simulations, or in fundamental studies involving a large number of particles, some type of model for the interaction between the continuous phase and the particles, and for the inter-particle interactions, is used. The modelling of the interactions depends strongly on the type and number of particles. In Figure 1 are shown schematically the different coupling mechanisms that can occur in dispersed multiphase flows. For very dilute flows, the influence of the particles on the continuous phase can be neglected (one-way coupling). As one progresses towards more dense flows, the turbulence modification by the particles needs to be taken into account, and both the forcing of the particles by the flow and the forcing of the flow by the particles need to be computed simultaneously (twoway coupling). For even more dense flows, inter-particle interactions need also to be taken into account. Inter-particle interactions can involve hydrodynamic coupling (i.e., the force between a particle and the surrounding fluid depends also on the velocity and position of the neighboring particles) and collisions. The collisions can lead to coalescence and breakup, which might also need to be considered. For extremely dense flows (e.g., dense fluidized beds) the continuous phase does not play a significant role, and the flow is completely dominated by the inter-particle interactions. The type of particles, and in particular their size and inertia, also plays an important role on how the interactions are modeled. Typically, for gas-solid flows the particles are small (size of the same order of the smallest turbulence scales) but their inertia is quite important, whereas for bubbly flows the size of the bubbles is of the same order of the intermediate turbulence scales, making it more difficult to model the interaction between the bubbles and the turbulence. Ideally, the simulations should be able to predict the particle-distribution, and the velocities and velocity fluctuations of both the continuous and dispersed phases. However, the interaction between the turbulence and the particles, and the presence of walls, leads to strong inhomogeneities and to the clustering of the particles. The understanding of these phenomena is still rather poor, and the success of the simulations is strongly dependent on how the physics involved is incorporated into the models. Regardless of the physical models used, there are two broad types of approaches for the com-
I BOUNDARYCONDITIONSI INITIALCONDITIONS TOKES I
~ T i P . t
~_~ ~
t
HYDRODYNAMICI COUPLING I
INITIALCONDITIONS
Figure 1: Coupling mechanisms. putation of dispersed multiphase flows: (i) Eulerian-Lagrangian, also known as particle-tracking, and (ii) Eulerian-Eulerian, also known as two-fluid. In the first approach, the continuous-phase is solved using the Navier-Stokes and continuity equations, using either DNS/LES or RANS, and the individual particles are tracked. In the second approach, the dispersed phase is averaged, leading to two sets of equations, which are quite similar to the RANS equations of single-phase flows, together with some extra coupling-terms. The Eulerian-Eulerian approach is somehow akin to the RANS approach of single-phase flows, and the computational effort is quite similar to it, therefore it is usually preferred in industrial simulations. The major inconvenient is that it requires more levels of modelling; e.g., regarding the wall boundary conditions for the dispersed phase. Also, it is not straightforward to implement more complex phenomena, like agglomeration and breakup, and can become quite cumbersome for polydisperse flows (flows with several particle sizes). Due to these problems, in numerous industrial flows Eulerian-Lagrangian RANS simulations are used, particularly when breakup and/or agglomeration are involved. Eulerian-Lagrangian DNS/LES is used mostly as a research tool, in order to improve the models used in the RANS simulations (either Eulerian-Eulerian or EulerianLagrangian). In the paper we present some examples of industrial flows, and explain briefly the EulerianEulerian and Eulerian-Lagrangian approaches, the role they play and their limitations. INDUSTRIAL FLOWS We present a few examples of industrial turbulent multiphase flows, to illustrate the wide range of situations that occur, and the major issues involved. Figure 2 shows the picture of a bubble column, which is widely used in the chemical and biochemical industries. The bubbles are injected at the bottom, and the buoyancy force induces a strong circulation in the bubble column. Even though there is no net liquid-flow-rate, the flow can be quite turbulent, with the liquid moving up in the center and down near the walls. Depending on the process, the diameter can reach a few meters, and the volume-fraction occupied by the bubbles can be quite high (up to more than 50%). The bubbles can have a wide range of sizes, from sub-millimeter to centimeter. Typically, the bubbles and their wakes can have sizes of the same order of the intermediate turbulence scales of the flow. This and the high volume-fraction make the process quite complex and challenging to model. To complicate the situation, quite often small catalyst particles, with a size of the order of 100 microns, are often added to the liquid. Due to the wake of the bubbles and their interaction with the turbulent flow, the concentration of these catalyst particles can be highly non-uniform and extremely difficult to simulate (Fan and
52 Tsuchiya, 1990).
Figure 2: Picture and schematic representation of the flow in a bubble column (Chen et al., 1994) In a bubble column there is no net liquid-flow. However, in numerous situations gas bubbles are injected in order to induce a net liquid-flow, a process known as gas-lift. This is commonly used in the oil industry (currently, about 40% of the oil production is through gas-lift). Essentially, a gas-lift oil-well consists of a long vertical pipe (diameter of the order of 10 cm and length up to more than 1 km), with gas injected at the bottom. The gas reduces the weight of the column, therefore "pumping" the oil up. Typically, one has a turbulent flow with a low Reynolds number (of the order of 10,000), with a bubble volume-fraction of the order of 10%. Similarly to the bubble column, the high volume-fraction, the complex bubble-turbulence interactions, and the occurrence of bubble breakup and coalescence, make it quite challenging to obtain accurate simulations. For example, it has been observed experimentally that the injection of smaller bubbles leads to a more uniform bubble concentration and a more efficient gas-lift (Guet et al., 2003), however, it is not possible to predict this phenomenon without the use of experimentally-fitted values for the transverse lift-force acting on the bubbles (Guet, 2004). Actually, even for a single bubble in simple laminar shear flows, the mechanisms that promote the transverse lift-force are still not well understood, and are subject of current research (e.g., Tomiyama et al., 2002). An overview of gravity-driven flows for both bubble columns and pipe flows can be found in Mudde (2005). Figure 3 shows a stirred tank. Essentially, it consists of a tank filled with liquid and an impeller to stir the liquid. This device is used in numerous processes, like crystallization and agglomeration of particles, mixing of different liquids, and chemical reactions with catalyst particles. Even in single-phase flows, the simulation is already quite challenging for RANS models, due to the strong circulation and unsteadiness involved. In multiphase flows, with the presence of particles, droplets, or bubbles, the situation is strongly complicated by the interaction of the turbulence with the dispersed phase; e.g., Hollander et al. (2001) found that the small turbulence scales can strongly affect the agglomeration/breakup of particles in crystallizers. Current industrial practice uses RANS or TRANS simulations, but due to the unsteady nature of the flow and the influence that the different turbulence scales exert on the dispersed phase, LES can be extremely useful in revealing the details of these phenomena (Derksen, 2003b). The bubble column and the stirred tank are, essentially, "mixing devices"; however, in numerous industrial processes one wants to separate the different phases. In gas-solid flows a common device is the cyclone separator. A typical design is shown schematically in Figure 4. Essentially, it consists of a conic tube, where the particle-laden gas is fed radially. Due to the centrifugal force, the particles are thrown to the wall and fall to the bottom part, where they are collected in a bin,
53
Figure 3: Schematic representation and snapshot of the LES simulation of a stirred tank filled with water and loaded with small glass beads (Derksen, 2003b); center: cross-section midway between two baffles; right: cross-section just below the impeller disk whereas the clean gas leaves the separator at the top. The basic principle is very simple, and one is mainly interested in determining the pressure drop and the separation efficiency (percentage of particles collected as a function of their size). Current industrial simulations typically use RANS for the continuous phase, together with the tracking of the particles. However, the high circulation and the presence of a precession vortex in the central region of the cyclone make it quite a challenging problem for RANS models (Hoekstra, 2000), and considerable insight can be gained using LES. For example, in Figure 4 are shown snapshots of the particles at five at five instants in time, obtained from LES simulations (Derksen, 2003a). The left-most snapshot shows the moment where the feeding of the particles to the cyclone was interrupted, and the other snapshots show the time-evolution of the particles inside the cyclone and collector bin at the bottom. One can see that the particles have a tendency to become trapped at the top of the cyclone, and might escape together with the clean gas.
Figure 4: Schematic representation and snapshots of the LES simulation of a cyclone (Derksen, 2003a), showing the time-evolution (from left to right) of the particles, after their feeding into the cyclone was interrupted, at the left-most snapshot.
54
Often, multiphase flow devices are used not separately, but as part of a complex process. A nice example is the Fluid Catalytic Cracking (FCC) unit. FCC is a trillion dollar world-wide operation and a crucial component of modern oil refineries. It converts heavy residual hydrocarbons into lower molecular-weight products, such as gasoline (world-wide, installed production capacity is more than 500 million tons per year). The basic elements of an FCC unit are shown schematically in Figure 5. Essentially, the heavy-oil feed is introduced at the bottom of the riser, together with some steam, where it meets the hot catalyst particles. The oil is vaporised by the catalyst particles, and the cracking reaction starts, breaking the heavy-oil into lighter products. At the exit of the riser, the catalyst particles are separated from the products by means of a series of cyclones. The catalyst particles are partially deactivated-activated by deposited coke, and are sent to the regenerator, which operates as a bubbling fluidized bed, where the coke is burnt by injecting air from below. The combustion products (flue gas) leave the regenerator through a series of high-efficiency cyclones, which collect the small dust resulting from the attrition of the catalyst particles. The regenerated catalyst particles are returned to the riser entrance where they join the oil feed, re-initiating the process. The whole process involves a large combination of multiphase flow devices, operating under very different conditions, from a dense fluidized bed in the regenerator to a dilute flow in the riser. The riser looks quite a simple device. Essentially, it is a tube with a height of about 50 meters and a diameter of about 1.5 meters, with a gas velocity of about 10-20 m/s and catalyst particles with a size of about 50 microns. However, the simplicity can be quite deceptive. Typically, the particle volume-fraction is of the order of 1% and the Reynolds number is quite high. Under these conditions, essentially, all the coupling mechanisms play an important role. The particle volumefraction is quite small, but it is not negligible, and since the density of the catalyst particles is much higher than the density of the gas, the particle mass-fraction can be rather high (the mass of the particles can be up to about ten times the mass of the gas), therefore the influence of the particles on the turbulence is very important. Also, due to the high mass-fraction of particles, collisions and hydrodynamic interactions play a crucial role. Another important aspect is associated with the relaxation time of the particles. Even though the particles are small, they are quite heavy, and the particle relaxation time is of the same order of the large turbulence-time-scales, therefore the particles do not behave as tracers. They are pushed by the turbulence in quite complex ways, leading to particle-clustering and non-uniform concentration, with a high particle-concentration near the wall.
Figure 5: Schematic representation of the basic elements of a FCC unit (left), and of some of the multiphase flow devices that are used (right).
55
EULERIAN-EULERIAN SIMULATIONS In this approach both phases are averaged, leading to the following equations for the conservation of mass and momentum:
O(~ p~) + b-~ 0 (~p~j)
- 0
0 -0 0 cO -~(~p~v~,)+-~j(~p~u~,v~j)~g,+-~xj(~-J~,j)--~(~p~ < v'~,v'~j>~)+
(1) < 7, >~ (2)
The index k denotes the phase (e.g., k = 1 for the continuous phase and k = 2 for the dispersed phase), and the indices i and j are associated with the usual Cartesian tensor notation. The volume-fraction is denoted by a, the density by p, the velocity by U, the stress by a, and the gravitational acceleration by g. The average stress and velocity are denoted, respectively, by and U, and the velocity fluctuation is denoted by U'. An average evaluated at the position of the phase k is denoted by < >k. The fist term on the right-hand-side of the momentum equation represents the gravitational force, the second the surface stresses, the third the kinetic stresses and the fourth the interfacial stresses. For the continuous phase, the surface stresses are the usual pressure and viscous stresses, whereas for the dispersed phase they are closely related to the inter-particle interactions. For the continuous phase, the kinetic stresses are the usual Reynolds stresses, and for the dispersed phase the interpretation is similar: the flux of momentum due to the velocity fluctuation of the particles. The interfacial stresses incorporate the transfer of momentum between both phases, due to the force between the particles and the surrounding fluid. The equations above are quite similar to the RANS equations of single-phase flows, and can be solved using the same type of numerical methods. The key issue is how to model the "closure terms" that are required for the surface stresses, kinetic stresses and interfacial stresses. Depending on the flow, this may require models for the: (i) Reynolds stresses of the continuous phase, (ii) kinetic stresses ("Reynolds stresses") of the dispersed phase, (iii) interfacial forces, (iv) interparticle interactions (collisions and hydrodynamic coupling), and (v) boundary conditions (e.g., wall-particle interaction). The interfacial stresses are usually modeled in a straightforward way, using knowledge about the force acting on a single particle immersed in an infinite homogeneous medium (e.g., Stokes drag for small particles). Depending on the situation, the model for the force may be modified to taken into account: flow inhomogeneity, the presence of other particles, the presence of walls, etc.. The modelling of the surface and kinetic stresses depends strongly on the type of flow and is less straightforward; in a way it resembles the "closure models" of single-phase RANS. The standard approach is to use a simple single-phase RANS model for the continuous phase (usually, the standard k - e model), and transport equations for the surface and kinetic stresses of the dispersed phase. For very dilute flows with small solid particles, the surface stresses of the dispersed phase, which are closely associated with the inter-particle interactions, can be neglected and the kinetic stresses of the dispersed phase can be determined using a simple "local equilibrium" model, which assumes that the kinetic stresses of the dispersed phase are determined by the Reynolds stresses of the continuous phase. In general, the "local equilibrium" model works well, except very close to walls (Portela et al., 2002), and it gives reasonably good results for dilute flows of small solid particles. For more dense flows, more sophisticated models are used for the surface and kinetic stresses of the dispersed phase, taking into account the effect of inter-particle interactions. Following previous work by Reeks (1991 and 1992), Simonin and co-workers developed a model based on the particle kinetic pdf equations, which has been quite successful in dealing with a wide range of particle concentrations (Simonin et al., 1995). For example, Wang (2001) used Simonin's approach for the
56 simulation of the flow in a riser, and obtained a good agreement with available experimental data, as shown in Figure 6. 0.10 0.08
-
0.06
-
0.04
-
0.02
-
0.00
0.0
modeling in this work, e=0.98 9 measured,Nieuwland
.j I
I
I
I
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
r/R[-]
1.0
Figure 6" Radial profile of the particle volume-fraction in a riser flow (comparison between Eulerian-Eulerian simulations using Simonin's correlated collision model and experiments), from Wang (2001). For very dense flows (e.g., fluidized beds), a model commonly used is based on the kinetic theory of granular flows (Gidaspow, 1994). However, a major problem of this model is the unrealistic highsensitivity it has to the choice of the restitution coefficient used in the inter-particle collisions (Pita and Sundaresan, 1991). Essentially, the model does not take properly into account the particleturbulence interactions, and this is "corrected" by somewhat arbitrary choices of the restitution coefficient. For very dense flows, the particle-turbulence interactions are not very relevant, and the model works reasonably well. However, for less dense flows, like risers, the results can be quite poor (Wang, 2001). The Eulerian-Eulerian approach is widely used in industrial simulations, not only in two-phase flows (gas-solid, liquid-solid, and gas-liquid) but also in more complex three-phase flows (slurries), involving bubbly flows and small catalyst particles (Oey et al. 2001); if properly used, it can give very useful information, in terms of design and prediction of the performance of multiphase flow equipment. However, a major weakness is that it strongly depends on the models used, which are based on situations far simpler than the ones to which the simulation is usually applied. In particular, the models that are commonly used for the interfacial stresses are based on the force acting on a single particle in an infinite homogeneous medium, and the situations in which they are applied can be rather different. For example, Eulerian-Eulerian simulations have been used to improve the injection system in FCC risers (Patureaux and Barthod, 2000), but in order to obtain good results, the equations for the drag force acting on the particles had to be fitted to experimental data. The major difficulty of Eulerian-Eulerian simulations is not in dealing with the complex geometries often found in industrial flows, for which they can give reasonably good qualitative results, but in dealing with the complex interactions occurring in what it may look a deceptively simple flow, which cannot be properly captured with the models currently used. A good example is the FCC riser. Due to the gradient in the turbulence intensity, the particles tend to be pushed towards the wall (turbophoresis), which can lead to very-high particle-concentrations near the wall. Due to the high particle-concentration, both the influence of the particles on the turbulence and interparticle collisions become important, and accurate models for the interplay of all these effects are needed. Also, the particles tend to cluster, and their distribution is far from uniform (Eaton and Fessler 1994); by its nature (one-point closure) this cannot be predicted with the models currently used in Eulerian-Eulerian simulations.
57 EULERIAN-LAGRANGIAN
SIMULATIONS
In this approach, the continuous phase is solved using either DNS/LES or RANS, and the individual particles are tracked. For the RANS simulations, the equations of the continuous phase are essentially the same as in the Eulerian-Eulerian approach above, but now each particle is tracked using a model for the force between the particle and the fluid, and; if needed, models for interparticle collisions and particle-wall collisions are also used. Since the particles are tracked, it is rather straightforward to deal with polydisperse flows and to consider particle rotation and wallroughness. Also, it is relatively easy to include phenomena such as breakup and agglomeration, as done, e.g., by Sommerfeld and co-workers (Ho and Sommerfeld, 2002). Two major difficulties are: (i) the large number of particles that might be needed, (ii) how to incorporate the turbulence effects on the particle trajectory and dispersion. The first difficulty is usually alleviated by introducing "representative particles" and "fictitious collisional particles" (Sommerfeld, 2001). The second issue is usually considered by adding a velocity fluctuation, using the turbulence kinetic energy and dissipation, obtained from the RANS simulation. However, in order to deal with these two issues an extra-level of modelling is introduced, which might not represent adequately the complex particle-turbulence interactions. Eulerian-Lagrangian RANS has been used in numerous industrial flows, from rather dilute, like cyclones (Hoekstra, 2000) and pneumatic conveying (Huber and Sommerfeld, 1998), to quite dense, like fluidized beds (Goldschmidt et al., 2004). Even though it is more flexible and requires less modelling, it still suffers from one of the major weaknesses of the Eulerian-Eulerian approach: the use of RANS for the continuous phase, which makes it quite difficult to predict accurately the complex interactions between the particles and the turbulence. In particular, both the EulerianEulerian and Eulerian-Lagrangian approaches do not take properly into account the modification of the turbulence promoted by the particles. Typically, a standard k - e model is used, together with an extra particle-forcing term in the k and e equations: Dk = P k - c + Tk - cp Dt De = 7)~ - V~ + T~ - 7)p Dt
(3)
(4)
where k is the turbulence kinetic energy, e is the dissipation of k, and 7)~ is the dissipation of e. 7) denotes the production and T the transport (of k and e). However, the extra particle-forcing terms, % and 7)p, are small, and do not take into account the large disruption in the turbulence dynamics promoted by the particles (Li et al. 2001, Bijlard et al. 2002). In Eulerian-Lagrangian DNS/LES simulations, the continuous phase is simulated using either DNS or LES for the continuous phase, together with the tracking of the individual particles. In this approach the particles are considered as point-particles, and the interaction between a particle and the surrounding fluid is represented through a force located at the position of the center of the particle. This approach keeps the level of modelling to a minimum, provided that the interparticle distance is large, and the particles are small when compared with the smallest relevant flow scales (Portela and Oliemans, 2001). Since the particle-concentration is small, the influence of the particles on the continuity equation can be neglected. The influence of the particles on the fluid is felt through an extra-force in the Navier-Stokes equation. The equations being solved are"
v.u=0 OU
~{-07 + ( v u ) . ~7) = - v p + ~v~O + v . ~ + ~
(5) (6)
together with the equation of motion of each particle"
dVp
Mp --~ = Fp
(7)
58
The extra term in the Navier-Stokes equations, $', is the force per unit of volume due to the particies. The force acting on a particle, Fp, is obtained using the velocity of the continuous-phase at the center of the particle, together with some model for the particle-fluid force (e.g., Stokes drag for small heavy particles). Usually, the subgrid stress-tensor, 5s, is modeled in the same way as for single-phase flow LES (PorteIa and Oliemans, 2002). Provided the particles are small and the inter-particle distance is large, Eulerian-Lagrangian DNS/LES simulations are extremely useful in getting a better fundamental understanding of the particle-turbulence interactions, and they have been used by several groups in fundamental studies of turbulent flows laden with small particles: solid particles, droplets or bubbles (e.g., Squires and Eaton 1991, Uijttewaal and Oliemans 1996, Li et al. 2001, Marchioli and Soldati 2002, Portela and Oliemans 2003, Mazzitelli et al. 2003). In particular, in our group we have been using this approach to get a better fundamental understanding of the dynamics of wall-bounded flows laden with small particles, and to provide support for the development of better models for the EulerianEulerian and Eulerian-Lagrangian RANS simulations. In Figure 7 is shown an example of how the turbulence structure can lead to the clustering of particles into elongated streamwise streaks near the wall, in a channel-flow laden with small heavy particles, and how, in turn, the particles can promote a large disruption of the turbulence structure near the wall. The disruption of the turbulence dynamics by the particles can produce large changes in the turbulence kinetic energy balance, as shown in Figure 8, where we can see that the particles promote a large reduction in the production and dissipation of turbulence kinetic energy. A topic of current research is how to incorporate these effects into the turbulence models (Bijlard et al., 2002). For example, in Figure 9 is shown how the particles change the value of the "constant" C, used in the standard k - ~ model.
Figure 7: Turbulence and particle structure very near the wall of a channel flow; left" fluid streaks for the flow without particles, center: modification of the fluid streaks promoted by the presence of small heavy particles, right" particle streaks.
59
Figure 8: Effect of the particles on the turbulence kinetic energy budget (Equation 3), obtained from the DNS simulations of a turbulent channel flow laden with small heavy particles (Reynolds number based on the wall shear-stress and channel height: Re~- = 360, particle relaxation time in wall-units: 7+ = 58, particle mass-fraction: Cm = 0.65). In order to get a better fundamental understanding and to develop physically-based models, it is very useful to isolate the different phenomena, and for this Eulerian-Lagrangian DNS/LES is an ideal tool. On purpose, for the results shown in Figures 8 and 9, inter-particle collisions were not considered. However, they can strongly affect the particle-concentration, and in turn the particle-turbulence interactions, as observed in the DNS simulations of Li et al. (2001). For example, in Figure 10 is shown how the inter-particle collisions can dramatically reduce the particle-concentration close to the wall. Note, however, that the differences between elastic and inelastic collisions are very small. All these changes can have important consequences, in terms of predicting the hydrodynamics and the particle-distribution, which in turn has large consequences in terms of designing and predicting the performance of the equipment. For example, the output of gasoline in a FCC unit can be strongly affected by the turbulence dynamics and the distribution of the catalyst particles in the riser. Actually, the particle-turbulence interaction can influence not only the turbulence, but also produce quite unexpected changes in the mean flow itself. For example, in the case of particle-laden horizontal flow, the non-uniform modification of the turbulence promoted by the particles can lead to a secondary flow, as observed in the LES simulations of Belt et a1.(2004). Another aspect that currently is not considered in Eulerian-Eulerian models, but which can have important consequences, is the effect of the wall-roughness. For example, using EulerianLagrangian RANS simulations and experimental data, Sommerfeld and co-workers found that the wall-roughness can strongly decrease the particle-concentration near the wall (Huber and Sommerfeld, 1998). The wall-roughness can also have quite unexpected effects, as observed by Van't Westende et al. (2004) using Eulerian-Lagrangian LES simulations: they found that the secondary flow due to non-uniform roughness in a pipe (as it occurs in the core region of horizontal annular flow) can lead to secondary flow, which, in turn, can strongly affect the distribution of the particles in the pipe (or of the droplets entrained in the gas core region of the annular flow).
6O
0.14
iii:t 0
,.,.,.-- ......... -;:-_o ....... 20
40
60
80
100
120
140
t
160
Z+ Figure 9: Effect of different mass-loadings and particle relaxation times on the "constant" Cu used in the standard k - ~ model, obtained from the DNS simulations of a turbulent channel flow laden with small heavy particles (Re~. = 360). CONCLUSION Compared with single-phase, multiphase flow simulations still have a long way to go. The major difficulty is the multitude of phenomena involved, and the still rather poor understanding of the physics, which sometimes can have rather unexpected and important consequences. Due to this, different approaches tend to be used for different types of flows, depending on the particular phenomena involved and the type of models needed/used. Due to the fact that it can easily deal with complex geometries, large Reynolds numbers, and a large number of particles, the Eulerian-Eulerian approach is the most commonly used in industrial applications. The structure of the equations and the computational cost is somewhat similar to single-phase RANS. However, it requires a significant amount of modelling, and EulerianLagrangian RANS simulations can be simpler to use, in particular in situations involving complex boundary conditions (e.g., rough walls), polydisperse flows, and agglomeration/breakup. Regardless of the approach, the key issue for the success of the simulations is to have good models for the phenomena involved. In particular, a major weakness is the lack of good models for: the turbulence modification promoted by the particles, the inter-particle interactions, and the near-wall effects. Eulerian-Lagrangian DNS/LES can play a very important role in developing a better physical understanding, and therefore better models. However, a major problem is the lack of well-controlled detailed experiments, where the different phenomena are isolated and the models can be tested. These experiments would play a very useful role in validating the DNS/LES simulations, which can then be used for systematic parametric studies. In terms of the industrial user, a critical need is the understanding of the different phenomena involved, when they are (or are not) important, and how they can (or cannot) be taken into account. In this respect, perhaps it would be useful to develop a "Best Practice Guidelines for Multiphase Flows", along the lines of what has been done for single-phase flows (Casey and Wintergerste, 2000).
30 0 . . . . 28
,. . . .
'~
~
,
_
50 b
..,
' .... '
",
100 .....
'
I
0 9
~ .
.
.
.
.
.
2.5
50 I
,
r "
'
2
24"
c,ot|iiion& R u n 6 collisions, R u n 3
............
too '
'
9
.... =
I
r162
- - ~
2.5
2
7
no
lg
g
I
elastic ~xdllskms, R u n 4 |Mlmmtk~ Run
22
2O
9 '
1.5
1.5
16
1o 8 6
2
-
O.b ..
, . . . , - - ,7_' "~ ~ - ~ . _ , ~ . ~ v . - _~ _T.. _ . . . _
00 . . . . . . . .
50
y
10.5
L _ . _ _ ~ - . _ ~ ~
. . . . . .
100
00
'
'
'
~'
501
,,
y
L
t ............
1001
,,
,
0
Figure 10: Influence of the inter-particle collisions on the particle-concentration profile, obtained from DNS simulations of a channel flow laden with small heavy particles (Re~ = 250); left: comparison between collisions and no-collisions; right: comparison between elastic and inelastic collisions (Li et al., 2001). Acknowledgments We would like to thank our colleagues and Ph.D. students at the Kramers Laboratory for some of the results presented here, and for the numerous discussions that we had on multiphase flows. Our work has been partially financed by the Dutch Foundation for Fundamental Research on Matter (FOM), through its program on "Dispersed Multiphase Flows", and by the Dutch Foundation for Technological Research (STW). References
Belt, R.J., Van't Westende J.M.C., Portela, L.M., Mudde, R.F. and Oliemans, R.V.A. (2004). Particle-Driven Secondary Flow in Turbulent Horizontal Pipe Flows. Proceedings of the Third International Symposium on Two-Phase Flow Modelling and Experimentation, September 2224, Pisa, Italy. Bijlard, M.J., Portela, L.M. and Oliemans, R.V.A. (2002). Effect of the Particle-Induced TurbulenceModification on Two-Equation Models for Particle-Laden Wall-Bounded Turbulent Flows. In:Rodi, W. and Fueyo, N. (eds.), Engineering Turbulence Modelling and Experiments 5, 949-958. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Casey, M. and Wintergerste, T. (2000). Best Practice Guidelines for Industrial CFD. ERCOFTAC. Chen, R.C., Reese, J. and Fan, L.S. (1994). Flow Structure in a 3-Dimensional Bubble-Column and 3-Phase Fluidized-Bed. AIChE J. 40:7, 1093-1104. Derksen, J.J. (2003a). Separation Performance Predictions of a Stairmand High-Efiqciency Cyclone. AIChE J. 49:6, 1359-1371. Derksen, J..]. (2003b). Numerical Simulation of Solids Suspension in a Stirred Tank. AIChE J. 49:11, 2700-2714. Eaton, J.K. and Fessler, J.R. (1994). Preferential Concentration of Particles by Turbulence. Int. J. Multiphase Flow 20, 169-209 (supplement). Esmaeli A. and Tryggvason, G. (1998). Direct Numerical Simulations of Bubbly Flows. Part 1. Low Reynolds Number Arrays. J. Fluid Mech. 377, 313-345.
62 gsmaeli A. and Tryggvason, G. (1999). Direct Numerical Simulations of Bubbly Flows. Part 2. Moderate Reynolds Number Arrays..]. Fluid Mech. 385, 325-358 Fan, L.S. and Tsuchiya, K. (1990). Bubble Wake Dynamics in Liquids and Liquid-Solid Suspensions. Butterworth-Heinemann, Boston. Gidaspow, D. (1994). Multiphase Flow and Fluidization. Academic Press, San Diego. Goldschmidt, M.J.V., Beetstra, R. and Kuipers J.A.M. (2004). Hydrodynamic Modelling of Dense Gas-Fluidised Beds: Comparison and Validation of 3D Discrete Particle and Continuum Models. Powder Technology 142:1, 23-47. Guet, S. (2004). Bubble Size Effect on the Gas-Lift Technique. Ph.D. Thesis, Delft University of Technology, The Netherlands. Guet, S., Ooms, G., Oliemans, R.V.A. and Mudde, R.F. (2003). Bubble Injector Effect on the Gaslift Efficiency. AIChE J. 49:9, 2242-2252. Hoekstra, A.J. (2000). Gas Flow Field and Collection Efficiency of Cyclone Separators. Ph.D. Thesis, Delft University of Technology, The Netherlands. Ho, C.A. and Sommerfeld, M. (2002). Modelling of Micro-Particle Agglomeration in Turbulent Flows. Chem. Eng. Science 57, 3073-3084. Hollander E.D., Derksen, J.J., Portela, L.M. and Van den Akker, H.E.A. (2001). Numerical ScaleUp Study for Orthokinetic Agglomeration in Stirred Vessels. AIChE J. 47:11, 2425-2440. Huber, N. and Sommerfeld, M. (1998). Modelling and Numerical Calculation of Dilute-Phase Pneumatic Conveying in Pipe Systems. Powder Technology 99, 90-101. Li, Y.M., McLaughlin, J.B., Kontomaris, K. and Portela L. (2001). Numerical Simulation of Particle-Laden Turbulent Channel Flow. Phys. Fluids 13:10, 2957-2967. Marchioli, C. and Soldati, A. (2002). Mechanisms for Particle Transfer and Segregation in a Turbulent Boundary Layer. J. Fluid Mech. 468, 283-315. Mazzitelli, I.M., Lohse, D. and Toschi, F. (2003). On the Relevance of the Lift Force in Bubbly Turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. 488, 283-313. Mudde, R.F. (2005). Gravity-Driven Bubbly Flows. Annual Rev. Fluid Mech. 37 (in press). Oey, R.S., Mudde, R.F., Portela, L.M. and Van den Akker, H.E.A. (2001). Simulation of a Slurry Airlift Using a Two-Fluid Model. Chem. Eng. Science 56:2, 673-681. Patureaux, T. and Barthod, D. (2000). Usage of CFD Modelling for Improving an FCC Riser Operation. Oil ~ Gas Science and Technology 55:2, 219-225. Pits, J.A. and Sundaresan, S. (1991). Gas-Solid Flow in Vertical Tubes. AIChE J. 37:7, 10091018. Portela, L.M., Cota, P. and Oliemans, R.V.A. (2002). Numerical Study of the Near-Wall Behaviour of Particles in Turbulent Pipe Flows. Powder Technology 125, 149-157. Portela, L.M. and Oliemans, R.V.A. (2001). Direct and Large-Eddy Simulation of Particle-Laden Flows Using the Point-Particle Approach. In: Geurts, B.J., Friedrich, R. and M~tais, O. (eds.), Di'Fect and Large-Eddy Simulation IV, 453-460. Kluwer, Dordrecht. Portela, L.M. and Oliemans, R.V.A. (2002). Subgrid Particle-Fluid Coupling Evaluation in LargeEddy Simulations of Particle-Laden Flows. Proceedings of the ASME International Mechanical Engineering Con/~rence and Exposition, November 17-22, New Orleans, USA (ASME paper IMECE2002-33113). Portela, L.M. and Oliemans, R.V.A. (2003). Eulerian-Lagrangian DNS/LES of Particle-Turbulence Interactions in Wall-Bounded Flows. Int..I. Num. Meth. Fluids 43:9, 1045-1065. Reeks, M.W. (1991). On a Kinetic Equation for the Transport of Particles in Turbulent Flows. Phys. Fluids A 3..a, 446-456. Reeks, M.W. (1992). On the Continuum Equations for Dispersed Particles in Nonuniform Flows. Phys. Fluids A 4:6, 1290-1303. Simonin, O. Deutsch, E. and Boivin, M. (1995). Large Eddy Simulation and Second-Moment Closure Model of Particle Fluctuating Motion in Two-Phase Turbulent Shear Flow. In: Durst, F.
63 (ed.), Selected Papers from the Ninth Symposium on Turbulent Shear Flows, 85-115. Springer, Berlin. Sommerfeld, M. (2001). Validation of a Stochastic Lagrangian Modelling Approach for InterParticle Collisions in Homogeneous Isotropic Turbulence. Int. J. Multiphase Flow 27', 18291858. Squires, K.D. and Eaton J.K. (1991). Measurements of Particle Dispersion Obtained from Direct Numerical Simulations of Isotropic Turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. 226, 1-35. Ten Cate, A., Derksen, J.J., Portela, L.M. and Van den Akker, H.E.A. (2004). Fully Resolved Simulations of Colliding Monodisperse Spheres in Forced Isotropic Turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. 519, 233-271. Toiniyama, A., Tamai, H., Zun, I. and Hosokawa, S. (2002). Transverse Migration of Single Bubbles in Simple Shear Flows. Chem. Eng. Science 57, 1849-1858. Uijttewaal, W.S.J. and Oliemans, R.V.A. (1996). Particle Dispersion and Deposition in Direct Numerical and Large Eddy Simulations of Vertical Pipe Flows. Phys. Fluids 8:10, 2590-2604. Van't Westende, J.M.C., Belt, R.J., Portela, L.M., Mudde, R.F. and Oliemans, R.V.A. (2004). Interaction of Particles with Secondary Flow in High Reynolds Number Horizontal Pipe Flow. Proceedings of the Third International Symposium on Two-Phase Flow Modelling and Experimentation, September 22-24, Pisa, Italy. Wang, ,!. (2001). On the Hydrodynamics of Gas-Solid Flows in Downers. Ph.D. Thesis, Twente University, The Netherlands.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
2. Turbulence Modelling
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Engineering Turbulence Modelling and Experiments 6 W. Rodi (Editor) 9 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
67
T U R B U L E N C E MODEL AND ITS APPLICATION TO F O R C ED AND NATURAL C O N V E C T I O N
(v2/k) - f
K. H a n j a l i 6 1 , D. R. L a u r e n c e z,3, M. P o p o v a c I a n d J.C. U r i b e 2, 1Delft University of Technology, Lorentzweg 1, 2628 CJ Delft, N1 2UMIST, PO Box 88, Manchester M60 1QD, UK 3 EDF-DER-LNH, 6 quai Watier, 78401 Chatou, France
ABSTRACT We present the rationale and some validation of a version of Durbin's elliptic relaxation eddy-viscosity model, which solves a transport equation for the velocity scale ratio v 2/ k instead of v 2. The new model, developed independently at TU Delft and UMIST (in two variants, shows improved robustness, faster convergence and less sensitivity to grid nonuniformities. The two variants differ insignificantly in the formulation of the v2/k and f equations: the UMIST model endeavours to remain close to Durbin's original one, while TUD variant introduces quasi-linear pressure strain formulation but with some further numerically beneficial simplifications. The model validation in a range of attached, separating and impinging flows with heat transfer, as well as in natural convection in a tall cavity, showed satisfactory predictions in all cases considered.
INTRODUCTION w
Since its appearance, the v 2 - f model of Durbin (1991) has attracted substantial interest both among academia and industry because of its simple formulation, plausible physical rationale and a range of successful applications. The introduction of an additional ("wall-normal") velocity scale 'v2 and of elliptic relaxation to sensitize v 2 to the inviscid wall blocking effect are the main features of the model. Whilst the v 2 - f model is far from providing a panacea for all situations (highly anisotropic three-dimensional flows may still need a full second-moment or higher-order nonlinear eddy-viscosity approach), it offers an interesting model option, superior to most common eddy-viscosity models. It seems especially suited for predicting near-wall phenomena - friction and heat transfer in not-so-complex flows. This has been demonstrated in successful predictions of several wall-bounded flows with heat transfer, featuring impingement, separation and buoyancy. However, the v 2 - f model poses some numerical difficulties arising from the stiffness of the boundary condition, which make it less attractive for industrial applications. The source of stiffness is associated with the wall boundary condition fw = limv~0 -20v--2u2/(ey 4), which makes the computations sensitive *Authors names are listed alphabetically
68 to the near-wall grid clustering especially when the first grid point is placed at too small y+. The problem can be obviated by solving simultaneously the v 2 and f equation, but most commercial as well as inhouse codes use more convenient segregated solvers. Alternative formulations of the v 2 and f equations have been proposed by Lien and Durbin [ 14] (hereafter LDM), which permit fw = 0, but these perform less satisfactorily than the original model [13], [9]. In order to obviate the numerical stiffness whilst still retaining the major features of the Durbin's elliptic relaxation concept, a new model formulation was recently proposed independently by Hanjalic [12] and Laurence [ 13], which solves a transport equation for the velocity scale ratio instead of the equation for v 2. The two model versions differ slightly in some details and coefficients, but their performances are very similar: both versions predict a range of generic flows with a quality comparable with - and in some cases better than - the original Durbin's model. Because of a more convenient formulation of the equation for and especially of the wall boundary condition for the elliptic function the model is less sensitive to small values of y+, what makes it more robust and less sensitive to nonuniformities and clustering of the computational grid. Other advantages of this formulation is the absence of e from the transport equation for This makes this equation uncoupled from the usually troubling e equation, what further contributes to the model robustness. It is also noted that the is nondimensional and bounded between the zero value (at a solid wall) and its isotropic value of 2/3.
et al.
v2/k
et al.
v2/k
f,
v2,/k.
v2/k
The new model has so far been validated in a boundary layer on a flat plate, fully developed channel flow at several Re numbers, pulsating channel flow, impinging jets with heat transfer at different Re numbers, flow and heat transfer behind a backward-facing step, flow in an asymmetric diffusor and over a periodic hill and natural convection in a tall cavity. We present here the rationale and a summary of the two model variants, and illustrate their performance with a series of new validations.
THE RATIONALE
vt
In Durbin's v 2 - f model, the eddy viscosity is defined as = C~, v2r (where r is the turbulence time scale), and evaluated by solving the conventional transport equations for the turbulence kinetic energy k and its dissipation rate e in the form
Dr-= p - e + ~
v+
(1)
plus the transport equations for v 2 and a Helmholz-type elliptic equation for the relaxation function f, which introduces the effects of pressure-strain correlations as in a second-moment closure.
(v2/k)
A transport equation for the ratio can be derived directly from the v 2 and k equations of Durbin (1991). The direct transformation yields:
D(v--~/k)Dt= f
(v-g/k)k"P + ~xk cO(
v+
pt)O(~;2/k) cr(~/k) Oxk
+X
(3)
where the "cross diffusion" X is a consequence of transformation
x=~
(v2/k)
2 (
~,+
vt ) O(-vS/k) Ok (7(~/k) - cOxk Oxk
(4)
The solution of the equation (3) instead of v 2 should produce the same results. However, from the computational point of view, the following advantages can be identified:
69 In the original v 2 equation, the sink is represented by ev2/k, which is difficult to reproduce correctly in the near-wall layer as e becomes large and v 2 / k tends to zero as the wall is approached; instead, in the (vg/k) the sink term contains the turbulence energy production T', which goes smoothly to zero at the wall leaving only the stable viscous diffusion as dominant near wall mechanism. Because (v2/k) c< y2 when y ~ 0, the wall boundary condition for (v2/k) deduced from the budged of (v 2/k) equation in the limit when the wall is approached, reduces to the balance of only two terms (with neglect of X) with a finite value at the wall, the elliptic relaxation function f and the viscous diffusion D"(v--~/k), whereas P(v--~/k)/k varying with ya (in fact with y4 when eddy viscosity is used) goes to zero at the wall: fw = y---,O lim
-2.(.~/k)
(5)
y2
- The above boundary condition is more convenient and easier reproducible as compared with fw in the v 2 - f model. In fact, the boundary condition for fw (eqn. 5) has the identical form as that for ew and can be treated in analogous manner in the computational procedure. The mere fact that both the nominator and the denominator of rio are proportional to y2 instead of/14 as in the original v ~- - f model (with y = 0 being a singular point in both cases), brings improved stability of the computational scheme.
THE ~ - f MODEL (UMIST) m
The first model variant, introduced in [ 13], with the new variable denoted as 99 v 2 / k - hence hereafter labelled as the ~p - f model, uses a reformulation of the elliptic function f in order to make it tend to zero at the wall: =
-
f = f +
2v(v~vk)
+ vV2qo k The corresponding ~ and f equations, to be solved together with the k and e equations (1, 2) are:
D~ ~ 2 ut Oqo Ok 0 D t = -f - "P-k -{ k a k Ox j Ox j "+" ~ L2V2f - f = ~(C~ - 1) ~ -
(6)
[ I/t O_~ ] I. ~'~J
(7)
- C2-~ - 2 u- Ocp O___k_k_ uV2cp
(8)
, L = CL max
(9)
k OZj OZj
Where ut, r and L are defined as:
ut = C.qok'r, "r = max
, C~-
v
, C,7 ~ 1
This modification ensures the correct behavior of f far from the wall in contrast to the LDM formulation of [14]. The coefficients used in this model are summarized in the table below: In Figure 1 the budgets
.~1,~
Cel
Ce2
cr~
ak
C1
C2
C~
CL
C,7
0.22
1.4['1+0.05,/!] \ V~/
1.85
1.3
1.0
1.4
0.3
6.0
0.25
110
f
of the terms in equation (7) are presented. The production of cp comes from f, while the destruction is represented by T'qD/k. The diffusion term on the right hand side of (7) compensates for the misalignment of the maximum between the production and destruction by transporting q~ this into the near-wall region.
70
Figure 1" Budgets of ~ in a channel flow
Figure 2: Friction coefficient on a flat plate
The cross-gradient term is mainly a sink term only positive in the viscous sub-region and it could be neglected if f was decreased by altering the coefficients in the equations, as discussed below. The model has been implemented in an unstructured finite-volume code [2] and tested in different configurations as reported in [13]. As an illustration of the basic model verification, we show in Fig. 2 the wall friction factor in a boundary layer on a fiat plate computed with the ~ - f model, LDM version of the v 2 - f and Menter's SST model [15], compared with the experiments of Wieghardt and Tillman [19]. It can be seen that the ~ - f model outperforms both the LDM and SST model. The computation was done with the same CFL number for all models on a mesh clustered towards the wall, with 80 cells in the wall normal direction. Other tests lead to similar conclusions: in the flow over periodic hills the results for all the formulations of the model were similar, whereas in an asymmetric diffuser the predictions were improved, as illustrated by profiles of the mean velocity and the streamwise turbulent stress at two locations in Fig. 3. Here below we present recent application of the ~ - f model to natural convection in a tall cavity.
Figure 3: Mean velocity and streamwise turbulent stress at two locations in an asymmetric diffusor. Symbols: experiments, Buice & Eaton (1997); lines: computations
THE ~ - f MODEL (TUD)
This model variant proposed in [ 12] denotes the new variable as ~ -- v 2 / k - hence hereafter denoted as - f model - differs in two features from the ~ - f model. First, in order to reduce the ~ equation to a simple source-sink-diffusion form, the term X (equation 4) is omitted. As shown in Fig. 1, this term is not significant, though close to the wall it has some influence. In order to compensate for the omission of X one can re-tune some of the coefficients. Another novelty is the application of a quasilinear pressure-strain model in the f-equation, based on the formulation of Speziale, Sarkar and Gatski (1991) (SSG), which brings additional improvements for non-equilibrium wall flows. It was shown by Wizman et al. [20] that the elliptic relaxation model based on SSG requires significantly less reduction of pressure strain than the original model based on IP. This, together with Fig. 1 explains why the cross diffusion term X could be omitted in the ~ - f model. The computations of flow and heat transfer in a plane channel, behind a backward facing step and in a round impinging jet show in all cases satisfactory agreement with experiments and direct numerical simulations. The incorporation of the quasi-linear SSG model for the pressure-scrambling tclTn 2
Hij,2 -- -C~TPaij %-C3kSij %-C4k(aikSjk + ajkSik -- -~(SijaklSkl) %"C5k(aik~jk %"ajk~ik)
(10)
into the wall normal stress component, with the neglect of 7")22(~ 0), yields the following form of the f equations in conjunction with the ~ equation (3) (with X = 0)"
L2V2/-f = ~1
(C1
--1) %"C z
( -
~
- C5
~-
(11)
Adopting the coefficients for the SSG pressure-strain model, with C~ = 0.65 and C5 = 0.2 (for arguments see [12]) and noting that the last term in equation (1 l) can be neglected as compared with the first term because ( C 4 / 3 - Cs) ~ 0.008, we arrive to the following set of model equation constituting together with the the k and ~ equations (1, 2)- the ~ - f model: (12)
vt = C , ~ k 7
1 L e v 2 f _ f -- -~ (C1 - 1.0) + C;~-
Dt = f -
o[(
T) + -~x k
u + -~<
( -
(13)
l
~
(14)
with wall boundary conditions ffw = 0 and fw = l i m y - ~ o ( - 2 ~ / Y 2) (eqn. 5 ). The equations set is completed by imposing the Kolmogorov time and length scale as the lower bounds, combined with Durbin's (1996) realizability constraints: "r = m a x
rain
, x/~CuISI~.
[ (2 L = CL m a x
rain
k~
(15)
, C~- u_e
]r ~ (_~)1/4] (16)
, x / 6 - ~ u i S l ~ ] ' Co
where a <_ 1 (recommended a = 0.6). The following coefficient are recommended:
let,
Io.22
eel
ca2
el
e;
(7k
0-6
o-~
C-r
eL
Col
1.4(1+0.012/~)
1.9
1.4
0.65
1
1.3
1.2
6.0
0.36
85 I
72 It is noted that instead of using equation (5) for f~, one can make further simplifications to satisfy zero wall boundary condition for f (in analogy with the original Jones-Launder (1972) formulation of the low-Re-number dissipation equation) by solving equation (13) but for f with JTw = 0 and getting f from:
1/2~ 2
f=
f + 2u
(0(
-~z~J
(17)
which is then used in ( equation. The viscous terms in equations (17) and (6) have the same near-wall asymptotic behaviour. However, as also experienced with the e equation, this is not necessary since the boundary condition f,,, = - 2 ( / y 2 is very robust. Basic validation and tuning of the ( - f model was performed with respect to DNS of a plane channel at several Re numbers (Re~ = 390, 590 and 800). In Fig. 4 profiles of velocity and turbulent quantities (including ( and f) are shown, nondimensionalised with the inner-wall scales for a channel flow at Re~ = 800, and compared with the DNS of Tanahashi et al. (2004). Note that results with ( - f model are obtained with the mesh with the wall-nearest cell-center at y+ -- 0.01, which corresponds to the first y+ used for DNS. The agreement for U +, k + and uv + is excellent over the whole cross-section, and so is for ( in the wall region where the elliptic effects are influential. A further DNS-based model validation is illustrated in Fig. 5 for a pulsating turbulent channel flow generated by an imposed sinusoidal pressure variation for the Stokes length scale 1~=14 (where l~ = x/2/a; +, a~+ -- wu/U~ and a~ is the forcing frequency), for which Scotti and Piomelli reported recently large eddy simulations. No special remedy was introduced to capture high-frequency unsteadiness, yet the reproduction of the cyclic variation of the wall shear stress and of velocity profiles at different phases is quite satisfactory, providing support of adequate response of the ~ model to the imposed unsteadiness and its applicability to unsteady flows.
Figure 4: Velocity and turbulent quantities in channel flow Re~ -- 800. Symbols: DNS data of Tanahashi et al. (2004). Full line: ( - f
73
symbolsi LES 2-
30-
~=
1-
20v
0-
"
lines: 44 model 0~/8 1~/8 2ff8 3d8 4~/8 5tl8 6t/8 " " 7z/8
) 10-
I~. -1' 0
'
o'.2'
~'fmodel o'.,
[
'
o'.6
'
o'.8
'
o'"0'.1
........
i
'
' 'y;'"'l'o
.......
1';o'
'
'
Figure 5: Pulsating Channel, Re~- - 350. Cycle variation of the wall shear stress (left) and velocity profiles at different phase angles. Symbols: LES of Scotti and Piomelli (2001). Lines: ~-f model SOME APPLICATIONS TO HEAT TRANSFER We present now some results for heat transfer obtained with the ~ - f and ~ - f models. First, we consider forced convection and present some results of computation of velocity fields and heat transfer in two generic test cases: a separating flow behind a backward facing step and in a round impinging jet. The temperature field was obtained by solving the RANS energy equation with constant fluid properties, using the isotropic eddy diffusivity z4/aT where ut is given by equation (12) and ~r = 0.9
Backward-facing step flow and heat transfer. Figure 6 presents the mean velocity profiles at several cross-sections, as well as the friction factor and Stanton number along the bottom wall behind a step in a backward facing step flow. Computations are performed with the standard Durbin's v 2 - f and the ~ - f models. Velocity profiles obtained with the two models at several locations within the separation bubble and around reattachment are practically indistinguishable and both in good agreement with experiments of Vogel and Eaton (1985). The same can be concluded for the friction factor and Stanton number in the recirculation bubble and a few step height downstream from reattachment, but a more significant difference appear further downstream in the recovery region, where the ( - f model captures better the trend of the friction factor, and slightly worse for the Stanton number. The difference between the two models could be attributed to the difference in the pressure strain models. The agreement with the experiments in general can be regarded as fully satisfactory for both models. Round impinging jests. Figure 7 shows the mean velocity profiles and Nusselt numbers in a normally impinging round jet issuing from a fully developed pipe flow for two Reynolds numbers, 23000 and 70000. The distance between the pipe exit and the plate is H / D = 2. The results are compared with the available experimental results of Cooper et al. [8] for the flow properties and with Baughn and Shimizu (1989) and Baughn et al. (1991) for heat transfer, as well as with the v 2 - f computations using the coefficients of Behnia et al. (1998). The velocity profiles (left) for both Re numbers are similar with some improvements retumed by the ( - f model, especially for r / D - 3.0. Similar quality of predictions has been obtained for the Nusselt number (right), especially for Re=23000, where the ( - f model shows some slight overprediction, but a more realistic shape of the curve. For Re=70000, both models show visible overpredictions in the stagnation region, though much better than reported by most other turbulence models. Here to, the ( - f model shows some improvement over the v 2 - f model. Natural convection in a tall cavity. The natural convection cavity studied by Betts and Bokhari [6] has been computed using the LDM, Launder-Sharma k-e and the qo - f model. The flow inside the cavity is driven by the temperature difference between the vertical walls creating boundary layers where the shear stress changes rapidly close to the wall, thus requiring a model capable of resolving correctly
74
Figure 6: Backward-facing step, Re = 28000. Velocity profiles, friction factor and Stanton number. Symbols: experiments of Vogel and Eaton (1985). Full line: (-f; dotted line: v2-f model
Figure 7: Impinging jets, Re=23000 and 70000. Velocity profiles and Nusselt number. Symbols" experiments of Baughn and Shimizu (1989), Baughn et al. (1991). Full line" ~-f; dotted line: v2-f the near wall region. The experiments were done at two different Rayleigh numbers, Ra - 0.86x106 and 1.43x106 in a cavity with an aspect ratio of H / W = 28.68. In Figure 8 the velocity profiles are plotted for two Rayleigh numbers at selected locations. The predictions of vertical velocity by the qD- f model are in much better agreement with the experiment than other two models, especially in the middle and the top portion of the cavity for both Rayleigh numbers considered. The LDM model over predicts the velocity peak in the middle of the cavity, with an overprediction at higher Rayleigh number of 40% and 31%. Near the horizontal walls, the ~ - f model slightly underpredicts the velocity on the decelerating side, but the slope of the velocity profile in the mid-width is closer to the experiment, compared with the LDM. The temperature profiles for the high Rayleigh number can be seen in Figure 9. In terms of temperature profiles there is not much difference between the two formulations, both give good predictions at the different stations of the cavity.
75
Figure 8" Velocity profiles at selected cavity heights for Ra = 0.86x106 (left) and Ra = 1.43x106 (right).
Figure 9: Temperature profiles at two characteristic cavity heights for Ra = 1.43x106. CONCLUSIONS
A new version of the Durbin's elliptic relaxation eddy-viscosity model, based on solving the time scale ratio v2/k instead of v 2, has brought significant improvements in the model robustness and in quality of predictions, the major features of the new model are the new boundary conditions for the elliptic relaxation function, and fixed sign source terms. Two model variants, developed independently at UMIST and TU Delft, follow the same rationale, but differ in some minor details. Each model variant has been implemented in an in-house unstructured CFD codes, both using uncoupled solvers, and tested in a variety of attached, separating, impinging and buoyant flows and heat transfer with very different grids. In all cases considered, the model confirmed the already known advantages of the elliptic relaxation approach and yielded good agreement with the available experiments and DNS data. The new model is envisaged as a prospective model for industrial CFD, especially when wall friction and heat transfer are in focus. Acknowledgement. The work at TU Delft has been supported by the EU CEC Research Directorate-General through project MinNOx, Contract No. ENK6-CT-2001-00530. The development and isothermal applications of UMIST's model has been supported by the FLOMANIA project, sponsored by EU Commission, Growth Programme, Contract No. G4RD-CT2001-00613.
76
References [1] 7th ERCOFTAC/IAHR Workshop on refined flow modelling, UMIST, Manchester, UK, 1998. www.ercoftac.org/databases [2] Archambeau F., Mechitoua N. and Sakiz M. A finite volume method for the computation of turbulent incompressible flows- industrial applications. International Journal on Finite Volumes, To appear. [3] Baughn, J. and Shimizu, S. 1989. Heat transfer measurements from a surface with uniform heat flux and an impinging jet. ASME Journal of Heat Transfer 111 1096-1098. [4] Baughn, J.W., Hechanova, A.E. and Yan, X. 1991. An Experimental Study of Entrainment Effects on the Heat Transfer From a Flat Surface to a Heated Circular Impinging Jet. Journal of Heat Transfer 113, 1023-1025. [5] Behnia, M., Parniex, S. and Durbin, P.A. 1998. Prediction of heat transfer in an axisymmetric turbulent jet impinging on a flat plate. Int. J. heat Mass Transfer 41 1845-1855. [6] Betts EL.and Bokhari H. New experiments on natural convection of air in a tall cavity. In 4th UK National conference on heat transfer, pages 213-217. IMechE Conference transactions, 1995. [7] Buice C.U. and Eaton J.K., Experimental investigation of flow through an asymmetric plane diffuser, Dept. Mech. Eng., Stanford University, TSD-107, 1997. [8] Cooper D., Jackson D.C., Launder B.E. and Liao G.X. Impinging jet studies for turbulence model assessment- I. Flow field experiments. Int./J. Heat Mass Transfer, 36(10); 2675-2684, 1993 [9] Davidson L., Nielsen P.V. and Sveningsson A. Modifications of the v 2 - f model for computing the flow in a 3d wall jet. In K. Hanjali6, Y. Nagano, and M. Tummers, editors, Turbulence, heat and mass tranfer, pages 577-584, 2003. [ 10] Durbin, P.A. 1991. Near-wall turbulence closure modelling without 'damping functions'. Theoret. Comput. Fluid Dynamics, 3, 1-13. [ 11] Durbin, P.A. 1996. On the k - r stagnation point anomaly. Int. J. Heat Fluid Flow 17 89-90. [12] Hanjali6 K., Popovac M. and Had~iabdi6 M. A robust near-wall elliptic-relaxation eddy-viscosity turbulence model for CFD. Int. J. Heat Fluid Flow, (in press, 2004) [13] Laurence D.R., Uribe J.C. and Utyuzhnikov S.V. A robust formulation of the v 2 - f model. Flow, turbulence and combustion, (in press, 2004), www.kluweronline.com/issn/1386-6164/contents, prepublication date: 04/14/2004. [ 14] Lien F.S.and Durbin P.A. Non-linear k - E - v 2 modeling with application to high-lift. Center for Turbulence Reasearch, Proceedings of the summer school program, pages 5-25, 1996. [15] Menter F.R. Two-equation eddy-viscosity turbulence models for engineering applications. AIAA Journal, pages 1598-1605, 1994. [ 16] Speziale, C.G., Sarkar, S. and Gatski, T. 1991. Modelling the pressure-strain correlation of turbulence: an invariant system dynamic approach. J. Fluid. Mech. 227, 245-272. [ 17] Tanahashi M., Kang S.-J., Miyamoto T., Shiokawa S. and Miyauchi T, 2004. Scaling law of fine scale ediiesin turbulent channel flow up to ReT = 800. Int. J. Heat Fluid Flow 25, 331-340. [18] Vogel, J.C., and J.K. Eaton, 1985. Combined Heat Transfer and Fluid Dynamic Measurements Downstream of a Backward-Facing Step, ASME, J. Heat Transfer, 107, 922-929. [ 19] Wieghardt K. and Tillman W. On the turbulent friction layer for rising pressure. Technical Report TM-1314, NACA, 1951. [20] Wizman V., Laurence D., Kanniche M., Durbin P., Demuren A. Modelling near-wall effects in second-moment closure by elliptic relaxation Int. J. Heat Fluid Flow 17, 255-266, 1996.
Engineering Turbulence Modelling and Experiments 6 W. Rodi (Editor) 9 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
77
CALIBRATING THE LENGTH SCALE EQUATION WITH AN EXPLICIT ALGEBRAIC REYNOLDS STRESS CONSTITUTIVE RELATION H. B6zard 1 and T. Daris 2 10NERA, Department of Modelling for Aerodynamics and Energetics, BP 4025, 31055 Toulouse, FRANCE E-mail:
[email protected] 9 SNECMA Motors Villaroche, Rond Point Ren6 Ravaud, 77550 Moissy-Cramayel, FRANCE E-mail: thomas.daris @snecma.fr
ABSTRACT The way of calibrating a two-equation model associated to an explicit algebraic Reynolds stress (EARSM) constitutive relation is shown. The model is first expressed in a very generic way so that any type of turbulent scale can be considered. Analytical relations involving the model constants are derived from basic physical behaviours that the model has to fulfill. A more restrictive constraint coming from the EARSM expression arises compared to a classical eddy viscosity model. As too many degrees of freedom appear, choices are made to simplify the relations. A new k - k L model is proposed that fulfills all constraints. A near-wall model is developed that gives a linear evolution of the second scale in the inner region of the boundary layer. The model is applied in simple boundary layer flows and in more complex engineering flows involving Navier-Stokes computations.
KEYWORDS Turbulence models, algebraic Reynolds stress models, EARSM, length scale, boundary layer, APG, RANS, CFD.
INTRODUCTION Explicit Algebraic Reynolds Stress Models (EARSM) need the knowledge of two turbulent scales, e.g. the turbulent kinetic energy k and a second turbulent scale which are obtained from their transport
78
equations. Usually the EARSM expression is calibrated independently considering homogeneous flows and the underlying two-equation model is taken from an existing one where the constitutive relation is changed from the linear Boussinesq expression to the non-linear EARSM expression. However modifying the constitutive relation modifies also the behaviour of the two turbulent scales and the model needs a new calibration. Moreover the choice of the two-equation model and especially of the second determining scale and of its transport equation is very important and can greatly influence the overall behaviour of the model, often more that the change of the constitutive relation itself. To calibrate a turbulence model, it is important to check that a number of basic flow characteristics can be reproduced. For example it is a well known behaviour, as seen in experiments, that the logarithmic law of the wall for a boundary layer velocity profile is not influenced by the pressure gradient. However most existing two-equation models are not able to reproduce this basic behaviour, as shown by Huang & Bradshaw (1995). Another important feature to achieve is that the computed solution of a turbulent flow should not be sensitive to the boundary conditions, e.g. to the value prescribed to the turbulent scales outside the flow. The solution should have smooth velocity and turbulence profiles at the edge of the turbulent flow, as seen in experiments. However some two-equation models are not independent to the free-stream turbulence or predict too sharp profiles at the edge, as shown by Cazalbou et al. (1994). The EARSM relation can even worsen this behaviour. The procedure to calibrate a two-equation model associated to a non-linear EARSM constitutive relation will be presented. The method is applied to provide a new k - k L model, associated to the EARSM constitutive relation of Wallin & Johansson (2000), which is able to reproduce a number of basic flow features encountered in zero (ZPG) and adverse (APG) pressure gradient flows.
GENERIC EQUATIONS We follow the approach of Catris & Aupoix (2000) extended for a non-linear constitutive relation. The two-equation model is expressed as a k - r model where the second turbulent scale r is sought as a general combination of k and e, say r = kme n, where m and n are not yet prescribed. r can represent any turbulent scale such as e, ~ = elk, L = k3/2/e, etc. Developments are made in the context of two-dimensional incompressible high Reynolds-number flows. The k - r equations are sought as:
Dt = Pk - e + div De r (Cr Pk - Cr Dt = k + Cr162162 q)
+ div
9grade + Cck
gradk grade
(1)
+ div
(
u~' r \aOk ~gradk
grade 9gradk + Ckk
) (2)
gradk, gradk
The constitutive EARSM relation from Wallin & Johansson (2000) giving the expression between the t t Reynolds stresses u~uj and the velocity gradients ~Oui reads"
2 ( Oui - ~ ' ~ + 5 k6~ = ~; o~j
OUj) Oxi
~(ex) - k'~ij
(3)
The first right hand side term of Eqn. (3) is a linear term equivalent to the classical eddy viscosity relation. The equivalent eddy viscosity reads u~ = C~kT-, with 7- = k/e, where the coefficient C~ is ~(ex) non constant and depends on the turbulent scales and the velocity gradients. The second term '~ij is a non-linear term responsible for anisotropy of the Reynolds stresses and is a complex expression of the
79
turbulent scales and the velocity gradients. The complete expression of C~ and a}~.x) will not be given here and can be found in Wallin & Johansson (2000). Eqns. (1) and (2) are generic and can represent any type of turbulent models. The Cr and Cr coefficients of the production and destruction terms of the C-equation are related to the classical C~1 and C~2 coefficients of a standard c transport equation through: Cr = n C ~ + m and C~2 = nC~ 2 + m.
CONSTRAINTS Relations between the eight model c o n s t a n t s Cdpl, Cdp2, Cdpdp, Cdpk, Ckk, ok, O'dp, O'dpIcand the constants of the EARSM expression can be obtained by forcing the model to reproduce a number of basic flow behaviours, following Catris & Aupoix (2000).
Homogeneous Flows The first flow to address is the decay of isotropic turbulence. This homogeneous flow has no velocity gradient and no diffusion. By representing the energy spectrum by two power laws and by assuming a self-similar decay of isotropic turbulence, it can be shown that the destruction coefficient of the cequation takes the form C~2 = (3s + 5)/(2s + 2) with s being the spectrum exponent, s is bounded between 1 and 4 so that C~2 lies between 1.7 and 2, see Aupoix (1987). Usually a value of 1.92 is retained, based on experiments. Another interesting flow is homogeneous shear where there is no diffusion. From the k and c transport equation, it can be deduced a transport equation for the length scale L = k3/2/c which reads: d L / d t = (3/2 - C~I)PkL/k - (3/2 - C~2)r
(4)
As the mean flow does not impose any length scale in an homogeneous flow, the first source term linked to the velocity gradient in the length scale equation should be null, e.g. C~1 = 3/2. ZPG and Weak A P G Boundary Layers
The analysis of the behaviour of turbulence models in the logarithmic region of a weak APG boundary layer is based on the work of Huang & Bradshaw (1995). To study the logarithmic region, the momentum and transport equations are written in wall variables: y+ = yu~ , u+ = u
p+ =
v dp
k+ =__k
r
e u 2m-4~
_- u'v'
where y is the wall distance, u~- the friction velocity, p the fluid density, v the fluid viscosity, dx dp the longitudinal pressure gradient and u'v' the shear stress. By neglecting the convection and the diffusion, it can be shown that: -u-7-V-Tc+ - 1 + p+y+. For a ZPG boundary layer, dimensional analysis yields the logarithmic law for the velocity profile: u + -- ln(y+)/n + C with the yon K~irm~n constant n ~ 0.41. For weak APG, i.e. at low values of p+y+, the quantities are sought as Taylor expansion of p+y+. In particular rc is sought at first order as: ~c = n0 + r;lp+y + where no is the classical value for ZPG (~o = 0.41) and eCl represents the effect of the pressure gradient on the logarithmic law slope. By developing the transport equations in terms of p+y+ and equalling the terms of same order, the values of ~0 and ~1 can be obtained as functions of the model constants. At order 0, i.e. for ZPG, it reads:
~0 =
-- 2b12o(Cr -- Cr ) n~(c~ + 1/~)
(6)
80
where b12o -- u ' v ' / k is the value of the anisotropy component in the ZPG log region. It is only a function of the EARSM model constants and experiments show that it is close to -0.15, which is the value found with Wallin & Johansson (2000) EARSM model. At order 1, i.e. for weak APG, ~1 is a complex function of all the model constants and will be not reproduced in the present paper. It can be shown from experiments that this slope does not change with the pressure gradient, even for strong APG, see Sk~re & Krogstad (1994). It means ~;1 -- 0, which provides a new relation that the model constants have to fulfill. S t r o n g A P G B o u n d a r y Layers
For strong APG, Townsend (1961) found the so-called "half-power" region located above the logarithmic region where the velocity profile evolves as the square-root of the wall distance. The analysis is performed by using the "pressure" variables: (pdp)
~=
1/3
y Up
' ~)= I/
~x
~t -- ~ ~
~ __ _k_
Up
"~" t ?.try
~) _.~ ~)~t 2pm - 4n
?_t2p
ut v!
l In
?.tp2
Assuming a strong pressure gradient (p+y+ >> 1) and assuming the Bradshaw relation - u ' v ' = k x / ~ 0.3k is valid in this region, it can be shown that:
(7) =
h
- ~ , v , = ~, ~ = 2 / ~ ,
~ = ~/~,
~ = ~+n/~o;~/~-"
(8)
The solutions of the equations are sought as power functions of the wall distance: ti = Au$ "~ , k = Ak~:TM , q~ = ACq~'~ with A ~ = 2/~, Ar = t~,"~-m/2~-'~ , ru = l / 2 , rk = l , r e = r e + n ~ 2
Ak
=
1/~-O~,
(9)
Introducing the expressions (9) into the transport equations where convection is neglected and identifying the powers of ~ leads to the correct values for the exponents ru, rk and re. However this only means the model is dimensionally correct but not that it is able to reproduce the half-power law for the velocity profile. Through the transport equations the expressions of the coefficients Au, Ak, and Ar are found as functions of the model constants, but they are too complex to be reproduced here. Specifying that these coefficients take the values presented in (9) leads to new relations that the model constants have to fulfill. E d g e o f a T u r b u l e n t Flow
The analysis of the behaviour of a turbulent model at the edge of a turbulent flow is based on the work of Cazalbou et al. (1994). The main result is that the transported turbulent scales have to go to zero in the outer flow, which ensures the independence of the inner flow to the residual turbulent values prescribed at the boundary of the computational domain outside the turbulent region. The analysis for a boundary layer is performed using the outer variables:
Y
A = 1 - ~-,
u(~)= ~-
u~-
~
'
K(~)= u--~~ k E(~)=c6 ~(~)= ' u--~~ '
r
%_2~-3"5"
(10)
where 5 is the boundary layer thickness and u~ is the outer flow velocity. The solutions of the quantities are sought as power functions of A, say:
{
u ( ~ ) = Uoa ~o , K ( a ) =
Koa ~ , E(a)=
9 (A) = (I)oA~ with (I)o = K ~ E ~
Eoa ~
and er = reek + ne~
(11)
81
The edge of the turbulent flow is approached when y ~ (5, i.e. when A --~ 0 and the quantities go to zero in a smooth way if the exponents of the power functions follow: eu > 1 , ek > 1 , er > 1. It must be pointed out that these constraints are made on the transported scales which means that all turbulent scales are not equivalent from this point of view. Introducing expressions (11) into the momentum and transport equations and identifying the same powers of A gives relations between the exponents and their expression as functions of the model constants. Particularly it can be shown that e~ = 2ek - 1, which implies er -- ek(m + 2n) - n. It can also be shown that ek = akeu. Other constraints have to be added to the previous ones as the edge problem is a convection-diffusion problem where production and dissipation are negligible. It can be shown that the convection and diffusion leading term exponent is ek - 1 and that the production leading term exponent is 2eu - 1, so that production is negligible if 2eu - 1 > ek - 1, i.e. ek < 2eu, which implies crk < 2. This is a classical constraint for linear eddy viscosity models. However associating the EARSM constitutive relation leads to a more restrictive constraint. Indeed in EARSM models, the production to dissipation ratio Pk/e is a solution of the algebraic equation for the Reynolds stress tensor. As a consequence the effective C~ is a function of Pk/c and decreases when the ratio Pk/c increases, e.g. in strong shears. However at the edge the shear goes to zero and one would expect Pk/c to go to zero as well, which implies that the effective C~ reaches asymptotically a finite value at the edge which depends only on the values of the constants of the EARSM expression. They are no strong physical argument for the behaviour of Pk/c at the edge. However it can be evidenced by the mean of DNS as in Spalart (1988) for a flat plate boundary layer. The fact that Pk/e goes to zero at the edge should thus be considered as a new constraint for an EARSM model compared to a classical linear eddy viscosity model where C~, is a constant and does not depends on Pk/c. It is straightforward to show that Pk/c has the power eu - ek, so that it goes to zero if ek < eu, which implies crk < 1. The violation of this constraint leads to a non-physical behaviour of the flow at the edge, as shown by Hellsten (2004) for a k - w EARSM model. Finally the solution for the behaviour at the edge is given through a second degree equation, which means two possible solutions. But it is not possible from the analytical expressions to know which one is the physical solution and a numerical resolution is only possible in this case. This equation reads:
{ (Cr162 [Cr r _~_~~1)-]-ek(Cck -'1---)--Cu] -+'Ckke2k'-Oo'r
(12)
with er = ek(m + 2n) - n and ek = crkeu
MODEL CALIBRATION As too many degrees of freedom appear in the previous expressions, the model is simplified by cancelling the third cross term (Ckk = 0) because it does not appear for the behaviour in the logarithmic region and the extra-diffusion term (ack = c~). In this case Eqn. (12) for the behaviour at the edge simplifies and one of the two solutions is ek = n / ( m + 2n). It is possible to set this solution unphysical and to keep the other as the physical one by choosing n < 0 and m + 2n > 0. A solution is m = 5/2 and n -- - 1 , which provides a k - kL model. The kL-scale is quite interesting as it goes naturally to zero at the wall and at the edge of the turbulent region and evolves linearly will the wall distance in the logarithmic region. Finally the model constants resulting from all constraints are: Cr
; Cr
= 0 . 5 8 ; Cr162= - 1 . 3 8
; C c k = 1.52 ; ak = 0 . 9
; ar
(13)
The values of the coefficients that characterize the different behaviours seen previously are deduced from the relations and are shown in Table 1. The new k - kL EARSM-WJ model is the only existing
82
model that fulfills almost all the prescribed constraints. Only for the half-power region an improvement could be obtained as the predicted slope Au for the velocity profile is lower than the theoretical value. However it should be pointed out that none of existing models could even predict real values for Au. Moreover all existing models predict non-zero value for ha, which means they all predict a dependence of the logarithmic law slope to the pressure gradient, which is unphysical. The exponents eu and ek for the behaviour at the edge are quite high to ensure very smooth profiles for the velocity and the kinetic energy, as it can be seen in experiments. TABLE 1 CHARACTERISTICS PREDICTED BY THE K-KL EARSM-WJ MODEL Coefficient Exp. orTheory Present model
n0 0.41 0.41
/,i;1 Au 0 4.8 (2/n) 0 3.1
Ak 3.3 ( 1 / ~ C , , ) 4.4
Ar 8.3 6.5
eu >l 21
ek >l 18
er >l l0
NEAR-WALL MODEL To be used in wall bounded-flows, a near wall model has to be developed. It is possible to build a linear length scale L from the wall to the logarithmic region. As the turbulent kinetic energy behaves as y2 close to the wall, the/eL-scale would behave also as y3, which is not recommended for grid dependency purpose. However it is possible to build directly a linear/eL-scale by adding a suitable term in the ~eL transport equation. The behaviour of the model in the near-wall region of the boundary layer is analyzed using the momentum and transport equations written in wall variables where convection is neglected, following Cousteix et al. (1997). To obtain the missing terms in the/e and ~eL transport equations to equilibrate the model at the wall, an analytical model for the velocity is used. It is based on the mixing length model of van Driest and reads:
du + dy +
v/1 + 4r12- 1 with r / = ny+ [ 1 - exp ( - ~ 6 ) 2rl2
(14)
The eddy viscosity profile is obtained by integrating the momentum equation which is simply (1 + l,/t+) du+ = 1. The diffusion of the/e-equation is equilibrated at the wall by adding the classical viscous destruction term -2u/e/y 2, which provides the y2 behaviour of/e at the wall. It is then assumed that the /eL-scale is linear and reads r = kL = n y / C y 4. The/e and ~eL equations can be solved using the van Driest analytical velocity and eddy viscosity profiles and the prescribed form of the kL-scale, so that the missing term needed to equilibrate the/eL-equation can be obtained numerically. Different analytical forms for this term have been proposed but most of them have exhibited numerical instabilities. Finally one term exhibits good robustness and reads: r - c~f~
.~y
y~
with f w - exp(-CfwRy),
Ry-
, c~
= 0.00075,
cs~ = 0.068
(15)
The fw wall damping function is necessary in the logarithmic region as the variable r behaves as ya/2 instead of going to zero. Now the equations can be solved without prescribing the eddy viscosity but using the EARSM constitutive relation. A near-wall model is also needed for the EARSM expression. It follows the model of Wallin & Johansson (2000) which is based on a bounding of the turbulent time scale and on a damping function multiplying the Reynolds stress anisotropy components calculated at equilibrium. As a consequence the equivalent eddy viscosity takes the form:
83
{ t*~ -- flC~kT" with ~- = max ({, C~X/~) , c = k5/2/r + 2 u k / y 2 , C.,- = 6 fl - 1 - e x p ( - C y t ~ / ~ - Cy~Ry) with Cul = 0.0105 and Cu2 = 0.025
(16)
Finally the k and r = k L transport equations including near-wall terms read:
D t = Pk
r
y2
Pk - Cr
t- div
u+
gradk
crk /
- C ~ fw u-)~(~ + div
u+
(17) grade
Dt
(18) + 6r162 grade 9grade + Cck--~gradr 9gradk
The boundary conditions associated to the k - k L model are simple and natural as both scales go to zero at the wall. In the outer flow a turbulence level Tu is prescribed to give the turbulent kinetic energy value koo -- ~.%o~u. 3 ~ 2 ,7-,2 The k L value in the outer flow is given through a prescribed level of the eddy viscosity: ( k L ) ~ = ut~ ~ / C ~ . Usually a value of ut~ = 0.01uoo is taken but the result is not sensitive to it.
APPLICATIONS
ZPG Boundary Layer The first flow to address is the flat plate boundary layer. As the kL-scale is built to behave linear in the near-wall region to give a relative grid independency, it is important to check the effect of the grid refinement at the wall on the predicted friction coefficient. To perform tests in boundary layers, the k - k L EARSM-WJ model has been implemented in a parabolic boundary layer code developed at ONERA. Figure 1 shows the evolution of the friction coefficient Cf with the Reynolds number based on the momentum thickness Re for different distances to the wall of the first grid point y+. 0.003
i[Oo
z
Io Cf theo
i~~ o00
--
i",~Oo_
,-
.- - -
,.:-,,~
. . . . . . .
"--...."".,,.,.
o , o.0o
y+,=0.1
l I
y,'=2Y ~ t
...... y",=5
-
/ !
0.0015-
0.001
:
0
I 25000
i I 50000
I 75000
100000
R0
Figure 1: Flat plate friction coefficient predicted by the k - kL EARSM-WJ model. Effect of the first grid point height. The calculated evolutions are compared to the K~rm~in-Schoenherr correlation. It can be seen that up to y~- -- 2 the effect is negligible with less than 1.5% variation on Cf. For y+ = 5 and y+ = 10 the Cf decreases respectively by about 4.5% and 10%, which is not so much in relation to these high values of y+. It proves that the k - k L model is not very much sensitive to the wall grid refinement, which is a consequence of the linear kL-scale.
84
I
I
I
__-~" k-kL EARSM-WJ
30-
I
4
~ / "
I
3
I
I
106
I
k-kL EARSM-WJ
"m
10'
20-
~
U§
k+2
_
kL +
10-
0
1
i 10'
10 ~
I 102
0
y"
103
104
102 y§
] 0~
Figure 2: Velocity, turbulent kinetic energy and k - k L EARSM-WJ model.
kL
I
I
10'
..............................
io2 103
10'
~
10 s
I
[ ~'k-kL EARSM-WJ // o'-I-~ .... ~y'/c. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . / .......
i
I 0~
I O'
102
y*
103
104
profiles for the fiat plate boundary layer at
Ro
105
= 105.
The velocity, turbulent kinetic energy and k L profiles are shown in Figure 2 for R o = 10 5 in semilogarithmic coordinates. The logarithmic law for the velocity is perfectly matched by the model. The k-profile exhibits a too low peak in the buffer region (k + ~ 3.4) compared to experiments or DNS which give k + ~ 4.5. However this characteristic should not be an inconvenient as the model would not need a high grid refinement to capture the peak of k. The kL-profile is very close to the theoretical profile /(-y5/4 ~fl+/~, in all the wall region, which is the expected behaviour.
APG Boundary Layer The k - k L model should exhibit a full independence of the logarithmic law to the pressure gradient as its /~1 value is null. The experiment of Sk~e & Krogstad (1994) is a good case to test the response of turbulence models to the pressure gradient. Figure 3 presents the evolution of the friction coefficient (left part) and of the velocity profile at the last experimental station (right part). The present model is compared to the experiments and to the Chien k - c, the Menter SST k - co and the Spalart-Allmaras (SA) models. !
0.003
O Exp. Skare
I
I
!
I
60-
k-kL + EARSM-WJ --0.002 -
k-~ Chien
........ k-6~ SST
~.
,
...... S/~ f - ' S ' S . . . . ~"'~ /z f , i , I , / , I / . ........... 0.001 I ; .........................
~. U" ,
I
i
I
i
J
k-kk + EARSM-WJ
~,
k-~: Chien
f~.~'
50-
---
40-
...... SA:
........ k-f#: SST
'
............ Log!law 30-
1
',, :
:8/./
/'_~//:
./ ,," ..'"/....:>'~: ............ /!.1f.'
2010-
0.0 2.8
i 3.3
318 x(m)
I 4.3
I 4.8
0 5.2
I
10 ~
l
10'
,
I
102 y+
t
t
103
0'
Figure 3" SkSre and Krogstad strong APG boundary layer experiment. Evolution of the friction coefficient (left) and velocity profile in wall variables (right). Comparison of k - k L EARSM-WJ, Chien k - e, SST k - w and Spalart-Allmaras (SA) models with experiments. The k - k L model gives good comparisons with the experiments on both the friction coefficient and the velocity profile. The best result is obtained here with the SA model, but the k - k L model gives better results than the SST model. As already known the k - e model is unable to predict adverse pressure
85
gradient flows. It can be seen on the velocity profile that the k - k L model gives the independence of the logarithmic law to the pressure gradient, as expected, on the contrary to all other models. Low Speed Airfoil Near Stall
The k - k L EARSM-WJ model has been implemented in the ONERA Navier-Stokes code ( e l s A ) and a RANS application of the model has been performed on the AIRBUS "A-airfoil" near stall conditions. This case has been experimented in ONERA F1 and F2 wind tunnel, see Gleyzes & Capbern (2003). It has been used for validation of turbulence models in ECARP and FLOMANIA European projects. The experimental conditions are U~ = 5 0 m . s -~ ( M ~ ~ 0.15), c~ = 13 ~ R e ~ = 2.1 106. In the computation the angle of attack is set to 13.3 ~ to take into account the wall interference effects. The transition is fixed at 12% chord on the upper side to simulate the natural laminar transition occurring in the experiments and at 30% chord on the lower side as in the experiments. The computations are performed with an implicit scheme in multigrid approach and the convergence for the present non-linear model is similar to what is obtained with a classical eddy viscosity model. Figure 4 shows the comparison for the pressure and friction coefficient distributions on the airfoil surface between the k - k L EARSM-WJ and SpalartAllmaras (SA) models and the experiments. _~
L
4-~, 3-
1
:
L
oExp . . . . . --k-kL
~ ....
.1.
1-
O.6
. . . . L"
EARSM:WJ SA
1 !
,xx \
0.4
:
o x o
"
i
I o ....
I Exp.
'~'!
k-kL EARSM-WJ
0.015-
-Cp
0-
-o.~
-10.0
0.2
0.4
0.6 X/C
0.8
1.0
-0.4
" ~ ,
0.6
-
. . . .
I 0.7
I
:-:-k-kL EARSI~I-~WJ
-
0.01Cf
oo
_t. . . . .
I
Exp. SA
-Cp
1-
I
oc
SA
o :x 2-
I f
I 08 X/C
i 0.9
.0
0.005
,, ,,I
o.o
~l~
-0.005
I
0.0
i
0.2
"
I
014
0.6
01.8
1.0
X/C
Figure 4" Pressure and friction coefficient distributions on A-airfoil, M ~ -- 0.15, ~ - 13.3 ~ R e = 2.1 106. Comparison of k - k L EARSM-WJ and Spalart-Allmaras models with experiments. The k - k L model underestimates the experimental velocity levels at the leading edge and on most of the upper surface, on the contrary to the SA model which overestimates them. The consequence is a lower lift coefficient predicted by the k - k L model ( C c ~ 1.44) compared to the experimental value (CL ~ 1.52) and a higher value for the SA model ( C c ~ 1.65). The pressure plateau seen on the upper surface in the trailing edge region with the k - k L model and in the experiments indicates a separation, which is confirmed by the negative Cf. Usually on this configuration most turbulence models do not succeed in predicting the trailing edge separation, as with the SA model where the flow remains attached except just at the trailing edge. However the k - k L model gives a too large separated region (~30% chord) compared to the experiments (,,~20% chord). This point is still in consideration for improvement.
CONCLUSION A new k - k L two-equation turbulence model associated with the EARSM constitutive relation of Wallin & Johansson (2000) has been developed. It fulfills a number of basic but essential flow features encountered in homogeneous flows and APG boundary layer flows. It has been shown how to translate these features into relations involving the model constants, which can be used to calibrate any other turbulence
86
model. The kL-scale is interesting as it goes naturally to zero at the wall and at the edge and is linear in the logarithmic region of a boundary layer. A near-wall model has been developed to give also a linear behaviour of the kL-scale down to the wall, which has been shown when applying the model in a boundary layer code. The new model has been calibrated to give fully independence of the logarithmic law slope to the pressure gradient, which has been demonstrated numerically in a strong APG boundary layer case. Moreover the new model is able to predict the half-power law for the velocity profile. Except the k - kL model, none of existing models is able to reproduce perfectly these features. Finally the new model has been validated in a near stall airfoil case involving RANS computations, where it has shown improvements compared to the widely used Spalart-Allmaras model. The proposed k - kL EARSM-WJ model is a promising model to be employed for CFD applications.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This work has partly been carried out within the HiAer Project (High Level Modelling of High Lift Aerodynamics). The HiAer project is a collaboration between DLR, ONERA, KTH, HUT, TUB, Alenia, EADS Airbus, QinetiQ and FOI. The project is managed by FOI and is partly funded by the European Union (project ref: G4RD-CT-2001-00448). This work is also supported by the French Ministry of Defence (DGA/SPA6/ST/STA) in collaboration with Dassault-Aviation.
REFERENCES Aupoix B. (1987). Homogeneous turbulence: Two-point closures and applications to one-point closures. In Special Course on Modern Theoretical and Experimental Approaches to Turbulent Flow Structure and its Modelling. AGARD-FDP VKI Lecture Series, AGARD Report 755. Catris S. and Aupoix B. (2000). Towards a calibration of the length-scale equation. International Journal of Heat and Fluid Flows 21:5, 606--613. Cazalbou J.B., Spalart P.R. and Bradshaw P. (1994). On the behavior of two-equation models at the edge of a turbulent region. The Physics of Fluids 6:5, 1797-1804. Cousteix J., Saint-Martin V., Messing R., B6zard H. and Aupoix B. (1997). Development of the k-~ turbulence model, 11 t h Symposium on Turbulent Shear Flows, Grenoble, France. Gleyzes C. and Capbern P. (2003). Experimental study of two AIRBUS/ONERA airfoils in near stall conditions. Part I: Boundary layers. Aerospace Science and Technology 7, 439-449. Hellsten A. (2004). New advanced k - ~ turbulence model for high lift aerodynamics. In 42 nd AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Reno, USA, AIAA paper 2004-1120. Huang P.G. and Bradshaw E (1995). The law of the wall for turbulent flows in pressure gradients. AIAA Journal 33:4, 624-632. Skgtre EE. and Krogstad E-A. (1994). A turbulent equilibrium boundary layer near separation. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 272, 319-348. Spalart ER. (1988). Direct simulation of a turbulent boundary layer up to Ro = 1410. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 187, 61-98. Townsend A.A. (1961). Equilibrium layers and wall turbulence. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 11, 97-120. Wallin S. and Johansson A.V. (2000). An explicit algebraic Reynolds stress model for incompressible and compressible turbulent flows. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 403, 89-132.
Engineering Turbulence Modelling and Experiments 6 W. Rodi (Editor) 9 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
87
NEAR-WALL MODIFICATION OF AN EXPLICIT ALGEBRAIC REYNOLDS STRESS MODEL USING ELLIPTIC BLENDING
G Karlatiras and G Papadakis Department of Mechanical Engineering, King's College London, Strand, London, WC2R 2LS, UK
ABSTRACT
The elliptic blending approach is used in order to modify an Explicit Algebraic Reynolds Stress Model so as to reproduce the correct near wall behaviour of the turbulent stresses. The modification introduces one additional equation compared to the standard k-~ model, namely the equation for the elliptic blending parameter 7. The model was used to simulate the turbulent fluid flow and heat transfer between parallel flat plates at 3 Reynolds numbers based on the friction velocity Re,=180, 395 and 590 and the flow in a backward facing step at ReH=28,000. The model does not use the distance from the wall thus it can be easily applied to complex geometries. The comparison with DNS data or experimental measurements is quite satisfactory.
KEYWORDS Eddy viscosity models, Heat transfer, Elliptic relaxation, Explicit algebraic Reynolds stress models, Wall blockage effect.
1. INTRODUCTION Two-equation, linear eddy viscosity turbulence models are still widely used for modelling industrial flow problems. However for complex flows, for example when strong streamline curvature, adverse pressure gradient, flow separation or system rotation are present, the Boussinesq approximation is not accurate and the linear models do not give satisfactory results especially for the turbulence quantities. One of the strategies to tackle this problem is to solve transport equations for each Reynolds stress component as to resolve fully the turbulence anisotropy. However there is a need to reduce the complexity of such models while retaining these features that allow the reproduction of dynamically important phenomena, such as the stress anisotropy, the near-wall blocking effect etc. This requirement has led to the development of Algebraic Reynolds Stress Models. These models are based on the assumption, proposed by Rodi (1976), that the convection minus diffusion in the dynamic equation of each Reynolds stress component is equal to the product of the same quantity for the kinetic energy k multiplied by the individual stress normalised by k. This assumption reduces the original set of partial differential equations into a set of algebraic, non-linear
88 equations, which link (implicitly) the Reynolds stresses with the mean velocity gradients. However, the resulting system is stiff and this can lead to stability and convergence problems. A way to alleviate these problems is the development of the so-called Explicit Algebraic Reynolds Stress Models (EARSM) in which the Reynolds stress components are related explicitly to the strain rate and vorticity tensors and their invariants. Various models have been developed, for example by Taulbee (1992), Gatski and Speziale (1993) and Wallin and Johansson (2000), which provide very encouraging results and significantly reduced the instability problems. These models are still under development. Their predictive accuracy for quantities like skin friction coefficient or Nusselt number (in case heat transfer simulations are also needed) will depend on their ability to reproduce the correct near wall behaviour of the Reynolds stresses. The present paper introduces a modification to account for near-wall effects on an explicit algebraic Reynolds stress model and is based on the idea of elliptic blending of Manceau and Hanjalic (2002) and Manceau (2003). The results are validated against DNS data for the flow between parallel flat plates and experiments in a backward facing step.
2. M O D E L I N G A P P R O A C H
2.1. The Explicit Algebraic Reynolds Stress Model away from the wall Following the assumption proposed by Rodi (1976), the Reynolds stress transport equations are simplified to the following equation:
u;u;
(1)
where q0~j is the redistribution term, P0 is the production term of ulu I , ~ij is the dissipation rate and Pk is the production of turbulent kinetic energy. Each one of the above terms can be written in terms r r
of the anisotropy tensor a with componentsa~j =
uiuj
2
5;j. Different models for q0~ and e~j can be k 3 used. The choices for these two terms and the coefficients are identical to the ones used by Wallin and Johansson (2000). The LRR model proposed by Launder, Reece and Rodi (1975) was used for the redistribution term q0~j far from the wall i.e.: , r --[-
2 4 9C2 + 6 =-C~eaij + oeSij + 11 ((~ikSkj q- SikOf, kj ---~-O{,klSlkSij ) 7C 2 - 1 0
11
(2) ((~ik~'-'~kj -- ~"~ikC~kj)
where S , ~ are the mean strain rate and vorticity tensors respectively scaled with the turbulent time 2 scale 1: = k/~. For the dissipation tensor e~j the isotropic assumption was used i.e. e~j = ~e60. The production P0 can be written in tensorial form as P = . 4~S. ~(aS . + S.a ) + ~(a~ ~ a ) and Pk as 3 Pk = -~" tr(aS). Substituting these expressions in equation 1 and setting the coefficient C2 - 5/9 the following simplified expression is obtained (Wallin and Johansson (2000)):
89
l C, - 1 + ~P,)a = - ~ 15S8 + -49( a K ~ - K ~ a )
(3)
In EARSM, the anisotropy tensor a is expressed explicitly in terms of a finite number of symmetric and traceless tensor bases T (i), which are formed from the strain rate (S) and vorticity (f~) tensors i.e.
M
a = '~-' 13iT(~ . The number M of tensor bases used depends on the dimensionality of the flow; 3 for 2D
i=1 flows and 10 for 3D flows. The scalar coefficients 13iare functions of the invariants of the tensors T (i). Since the present study examines only 2D flows, the anisotropy tensor a can be written as:
{1 __ ]~IS .+.]~2 (S, ~,.,~-~,~, S).+. ~3 (S 2 --~1 HsI) where
IIs
(4)
is the trace of S 2. Substituting equation 4 into 3 and equating the expressions that multiply 1
each of the basis tensors T (i) (i.e. S, S. f ~ - f ~ . S, S 2 --~IIsI ), a linear 3x3 system for the coefficients [3~, [32, [33 can be obtained. Solving the system the following expressions are obtained:
13,=
where
IIc~is the trace
6 N , 5 N 2 - 2Hn
132=-
6 1 , 5 N 2 - 2Hta
(5)
of ~22 and N is the solution of the following cubic equation:
N3-C[N 2 -127Hs + 2 / / n ] N where C[ - 9 / 4 ( G equation (6).
f~3=0
+ 2C;Hn = 0
(6)
1). Cardano's formula provides an analytic expression for the positive root of
2.2. Near Wall Treatment The coefficients [3/(i = 1,2,3)must be modified close to the wall in order to reproduce the correct asymptotic near wall behaviour. Following the ideas of Manceau and Hanjalic (2002) and Manceau (2003), an elliptic blending parameter ~, is introduced whose value is 0 at the wall and 1 away from it and thus quantifies the blockage effect of the wall. The equation for ~, is: y - L 2 g 2 y =1
(7)
I 3
3
11
where L is the turbulent length scale defined by L = 0.161. max k ~ / ~, 80- v ~ / e ~ . The above investigators developed an elliptic blending model in which they use this parameter to blend the values close to and far from the wall for the components of the redistribution term (q0~) as well as the dissipation tensor (eij). In the present investigation, this parameter is used instead to blend the values of the coefficients [3i. Wallin and Johansson (2000) modify the coefficients close to the wall as:
90
~llowRe = f i l l ,
~2lowRe = f 1 2 ~ 2
--
B2 (1 -2 max(Hs , H eq )
fl 2 ),
~3lowRe"--
3B2 - 4
(1 - 3,-2)
(8)
m a x ( I I s , H eq )
where B 2 = 1.8 and HS q ~ 5.74 f o r C1 = 1.8. Note that 133 =0 away from the wall (equation 5) but not close to it. The function fl should be equal to 0 at the wall and 1 away from it so in principle it can be evaluated as a function of 7. Wallin and Johansson (2000) use a van-Driest function of the form f~ = 1 - e -y*/26 but since this expression uses the dimensionless distance from the wall y+ it makes the model difficult to apply in complex geometries since the calculation of y+ is not a trivial task. An alternative formulation is proposed here, which is based on the elliptic blending approach and eliminates the use of the distance from the wall. For the turbulent flow between parallel plates, the coefficients 13, (i = 1,2,3) can be evaluated from the elements of the anisotropy tensor. The following relations can be easily obtained:
[31 ._. ( ~ 1 2 ,
~2
_ (~11 -- 0~22 -,
cr
4or 2
[33_._ -
3a 3_.___~3 2or 2 1
(9)
dU
The parameter cr is the non-dimensional shear rate, defined as ~ = - z where 1: is the turbulence 2 dy g
t--------'N
time scale~ = max{ k , 6 . 0 ~ v ] , which is the usual timescale with a lower viscous bound given by the \
Kolmororov scale (Durbin (1993)). It is well known that the near wall behaviour of the shear stress in wall units is u--~+ = a , u ( y +)3 +...and of turbulent kinetic energy isk § = a k ( y +)2 +...so the component ~+
uv
(112
of the anisotropy tensor varies asa12 = k §
auv y§ + .... The non-dimensional shear rate close ak
to the wall is cr w+ =-~1 r + ddY U §+ ~-2rw 1 + because U+ ~ y § and l:w § is the time scale at the wall in wall units. From equation (9), the asymptotic trend for the coefficient 131 (in wall units) is: Otuv y+ +... ot~___L= ~
= cy+
Gtk
=--2
1 --X+w 2
auv y+ +... ak Xw +
(10)
thus this coefficient should approach 0 with a rate O(y+). The asymptotic behaviour of the elliptic blending function 7 is now examined. The one-dimensional form of equation (7) is" Y L2 d27 =1 ay ~
(11)
This equation is subject to the Dirichlet boundary condition 7 = 0 at the wall and the Neumann condition d7/dy = 0 at the half height of the channel y=c. For constant L, the analytical solution of equation (9) using these boundary conditions is:
91 y __
y-2c
_(eL+e ~'=
L )
2c l+e L
+1
(12)
Using Taylor series to approximate the exponential function close to the wall (ie for small y) the following asymptotic behaviour is obtained in wall units' 7+
=
y+ L+
y+2 --+ 2L+ 2
....
(13)
In practice L + is not constant. However, this expression, using the value of L + at the wall, was checked against the numerical solution of equation (11) in which L + was evaluated using the DNS values of k +, e+ and was found to approximate it very well close to the wall. The function fl is now constructed in such a way as to reproduce the asymptotic behaviour of equation (10). Assuming that fl is a quadratic function of "f and using the DNS values of auv,ak, Vw+,/3~W,L+ the following expression is obtained: f~ = a s ( y - y : ) + y :
(14)
where the constant af is evaluated from: as =-
2auv L+ ~
(15)
The DNS values for all parameters used in equation 15 are shown in the following table 1 for 3 Reynolds numbers. TABLE 1 DNS DATA FOR THE EVALUATION OF a s 131w "iTw ~uv ~k ~;w(=2Rk) L+ ai +
Re~= 180 -0.04014 14.49 7.2* 10-4 0.08538 0.17078 20.00 0.58
Re~=395 -0.045485 12.88 9.3153"10 "4 0.10878 0.21756 18.85 0.55
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
Re~=590 -0.04697 12.50 9.71785" 10-4 0.11556 0.23113 18.50 0.53
It can be seen that the coefficient a s does depend on the Reynolds number, although not strongly. The value 0.55 for Re~=395 has been selected for the calculations reported in the following section. The described approach allows the evaluation of fl as a function of the blending parameter ~/without using the normal distance from the wall. Although there are efficient methods for computing this distance for complex geometries, it is certainly advantageous if the wall blocking effect can be accounted for without the use of this distance. Moreover, the model allows the evaluation of the turbulent viscosity as v, = C e f K r where C~sr = --~1 1 ~ ~
i.e. this coefficient instead of being constant (equal to 0.09) as
in the standard k-e model is now a function of the local flow parameters.
92 3. TEST CACES 3.1. C h a n n e l F l o w Predictions
In this section results for 2 two cases obtained using the previously described algebraic model are presented. The first part of this test case refers to turbulent flow between parallel flat plates for three different Reynolds numbers (based on the friction velocity and half width of the channel): 180, 395 and 590. The second part of this test case refers to heat transfer predictions for the same flow configuration for Prandtl numbers 0.4, 0.6, 0.71, 1 (for Re~=180), as well as Prandtl number 0.71 (for Re~=395). The predictions for both cases are compared against available DNS data (Moser et al 1999, Kawamura et al, 1998 & 1999). In figure 1, predictions of the mean velocity against DNS data for the three different Reynolds number are shown. The number of cells used in the wall normal direction was 40, 10 of which were in the area 0
fact that no optimization on the other model coefficients has been attempted. Note that the v'v' component is accurately predicted i.e. the model can capture the wall blockage effect. uK
30 u+
~95
L5
..... :w
15 10
o
5
,',
~
~"~ ~
.......
A" ~ ' = = -
~ ,. ; ;
...... ,;0 ..... 1;=00!
y,,
Figure.2" k, u'u .,.v. .v. ,. . w
Figure.l" Umean for Re~=180,395,590
,
!:=
f\l
,1
li
w , u v (Re~ = 1 8 0 )
........
.....
~ T
-~-
~00
~0:0!,
Figure.3" k,u'u .,v. v, . .w. w. ,u v' (Re~=395)
[
i
....... ~
.......
~ .... ~ U % 0
~
;00~]o0
Figure.4: k,u 'u .,v. v, . .w. w. ,u . v (Re~=590)
i
93
0:
0.4 P
0.31
0.3-
I
0 O0 ~
0.21
O
0.2
0.1]
0.1-
I
O
0 0.01
,
O
OOO-
0.1
1
y+
,
,
10
100
~
, 1000
0 0.1
0.01
1
y+
10
100
1000
Figure.6: Dissipation (Re~=590)
Figure.5" Production (Re~=590)
Figure 5 and 6 show the production and dissipation of the turbulent kinetic energy respectively for Re~=590. The predictions are satisfactory. The heat transfer calculations have been carried out using the same grid configuration. The eddy diffusivity approach was used for the turbulent heat fluxes (i.e. u~|
- v--c-~c~| ) and for all computations the turbulent Prandtl number was equal to 1. O"T ~ X i 0.901
2018 ~
0.801
16 ~
Pr=0.71
14 ~
Pr=0.6 A~n ~
1210
.. "nz .:~x%
o~,.o9"~__
0.701 0.601
Pr:0.4
0.501
!
o~/ ~/
[]
Pr=1.0
~,
Pr=0.71
0
Pr=0.4
0.401
81
0.301
61
~
0.201
4~
0.101
2 ~ 0
-VQ+
8
0.001 10
y+
100
10
1000
Figure.7" 0+ at Pr=l, 0.71, 0.6 and 0.4.
y+
100
io00
Figure.8:- v'| at Pr=l, 0.71, 0.6 and 0.4.
In figure 7, the mean temperature profiles for Re~=180 and four Prandtl numbers (from 0.4 to 1) are shown. The horizontal axis is the logarithmic scale of the distance y+ from the wall. The predictions are quite satisfactory although there is slight over prediction on | for the higher Prandtl numbers. Looking at the turbulent fluxes in the direction normal to the wall (figure 8), the agreement between the computational and the DNS data is again very satisfactory. Furthermore, in figure 9 the variation of Nusselt against the Prandtl number is presented and good agreement is obtained. 22
.......
21 .u 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 0.2
0.4
0.6
Pr
0.8
1
112
Figure.9: Nusselt against Prandtl number for Re~=180.
94
1 7 16
0.9
|
0.8 t
4
0.7
12
0.6 ]
10
o
0.5
8
0.4
6
0.3 t
4
0.2 t
2 0
, 0.1
o
,
1
10
Y+
,
t
100
1000
~
o,
i
1
0.1
10
y+
1000
at Pr=0.71.
Figure.11" - v'|
Figure. 10: 0+ at Pr=0.71.
100
For Re~=395, the results from the computations match well the DNS data for the mean temperature and the turbulent heat flux as can be seen from figures 10 and 11 respectively. Again there is slight overprediction to |
3.2. Flow in a backward Facing Step
In this section results from the flow field over backward facing step case at ReH=28,000 are presented. The experiments have been carried out by Vogel and Eaton (1985). The expansion ratio is 1.25. For the numerical simulation 16093 cells were used and the mesh was twice locally refined close and around the recirculation zone. Figures 12-14 show comparison of the mean velocity profiles against experiments at various locations X*=(X-XR)/XR with reference to the reattachment point XR. F4
4
-
() 35
3.5 ]
i
3
2!
() (
C
(
C
( ( C O
C 0 0
o
-0.5
()
v.
0
UlUref
0.5
1.51
1.5
1
Figure. 12:U/Uref at X*=-0.67
0'it
1.5 /
L
-0.5
U
5
1
Figure. 13 :U/Uref at X*=-0.55
0 I -0.5
v
.
0
UlUref 0.5
1
Figure. 14:U/Uref at X*=-0.44
The agreement of the computed velocity field against the experimental measurement is again quite satisfactory. In figures 15-17 the temperature distribution at locations X*=-0.75, 0.45 and 1.25 is presented respectively. The agreement is quite good. Furthermore, figure 18 shows comparison with experiments of the variation of the Stanton number along the flat wall boundary. The agreement is reasonably good but there is scope for improvement. The observed discrepancies can be attributed to
95
several reasons such as the details of the inlet flow velocity profile, value of the turbulent Prandtl number etc. 2.5
2.5
(X-Xr)/Xr=0.45
, 2
2
I
1.5
2.5
..........................
(X-Xr)/Xr=-0.75
g
(X-Xr)/Xr=1.25
2
C
1.5
1.5 (
1 ( (
0.5
0.5
0.5 (
0 -5
q i
o~
' T-Tre 0 5
10
Figure. 15:T-Tref at X*=-0.75
-5
I
-5
O
5
Figure. 17:T-Tref at X * = 1.25
Figure. 16:T-Tref at X*=-0.45
St
0.004 0.003 / / ~ 0
0
0.002 0"0010 I
-1
0
1
2 (X-Xr)/Xr3
4
5J
Figure.18: Stanton number. 4. CONCLUSIONS This paper presented a near wall modification of an EARSM that uses the elliptic blending model ideas to merge the near wall region with the rest of the flow. The model can capture the near wall blockage effect, without making use of the distance from the wall, thus it can be applied easily to very complex geometries. The model was used to predict the turbulent flow and heat transfer between parallel flat plates and backward facing step. The computations were compared against DNS results and experimental data and the agreement was satisfactory.
5. A C K N O W L E G E M E N T
The research work described in this publication relates to the MinNOx project, contract ENK6CT-2001-00530, which was supported by the European Community. The authors take sole responsibility for their findings and recommendations. The Community is not accountable for the outcome and future use of the publication and the opinions may not represent that of the Community.
96 6. R E F E R E N C E S
Durbin P. A. and Petterson Reif B. A. (2001), Statistical Theory and Modelling for Turbulence Flows, John Wiley and Sons, Ltd. Durbin P. A. (1993), A Reynolds stress model for the near-wall turbulence, J. Fluid Mech. 249, 465-498. Gatski T. B. and Speziale C. G. (1993) On explicit algebraic stress model for complex turbulent flows, J. Fluid Mech. 254, 59-78. Gatski T. B. and Jongen T. (2000) Nonlinear eddy viscosity and algebraic stress models for solving complex turbulent flows, Progress in Aerospace Sciences, 36 655-682. Hadzic I. (1999). Second-Moment Closure Modelling of Transitional and Unsteady Turbulent Flows, PHD Thesis Technical University of Delft Kawamura, H., Abe, H. and Matsuo, Y. (1999) DNS of turbulent heat transfer in channel flow with respect to Reynolds and Prandtl number effect. Int. J. Heat and Fluid Flow, 20, 196-207. Launder B. E., Reece G. J. and Rodi W. (1975). Progress in the development of Reynolds-stress turbulence closure. J. Fluid Mech. 68, 537-566. Manceau R. (2003) Accounting for wall-induced Reynolds stress anisotropy in Explicit Algebraic stress model. Third International Symposium on Turbulence and Shear Flow Phenomena Sendai, Japan. Manceau R. and Hanjalic K. (2002) Elliptic blending model: A new near-wall Reynolds-stress turbulence closure, Physics of Fluids, 14, 744-754. Moser, R.D., Kim, J. and Mansour, N.N. (1999) Direct numerical simulation of turbulent channel flow up to Ret=590. Physics of Fluids, 11:4, 943-945 Pope S B. (2000), Turbulent Flows, Cambridge University Press. Pope S.B. (1975) A more generalised effective-viscosity hypothesis J. Fluid Mech. 72, 331-340. Rodi W. (1976) A new algebraic relation for calculating the Reynolds stresses, ZAMM, 56, 219221. Speziale C. G., Sarkar S. and Gatski T. B. (1991). Modelling the pressure-strain correlation of turbulence:an invariant system dynamics approach, J. Fluid Mech. 227, 345-272 Taulbee D. B. (1992). An improved algebraic Reynolds stress model and corresponding nonlinear stress model, Phys. Fluids A 4 2555-2561. Vogel J. C., Eaton J. K. (1985) Combined Heat Transfer and Fluid Dynamic Measurements Downstream of a Backward-Facing Step, Journal of Heat Tansfer 107, 922-929. Wallin S., Johansson A. (2000). An explicit algebraic Reynolds stress model for incompressible and compressible turbulent flows, J. Fluid Mech. 403, 89-132.
Engineering Turbulence Modelling and Experiments 6 W. Rodi (Editor) 9 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
97
A S S E S S M E N T OF T U R B U L E N C E M O D E L S F O R PREDICTING THE INTERACTION REGION IN A W A L L J E T B Y R E F E R E N C E T O LES S O L U T I O N A N D BUDGETS A. Dejoan, C. Wang and M. A. Leschziner Department of Aeronautics, Imperial College London, London SW7 2AZ, UK
ABSTRACT
Highly-resolved LES and experimental data for a plane wall jet are used to study the characteristics of three turbulence models, two based on second-moment closure and the third being a non-linear eddy-viscosity model. The study is motivated by the observed importance of Reynoldsstress transport in the interaction region between the outer shear layer and the near-wall layer of the wall jet. Comparisons are presented for mean-flow quantities, second moments and budgets. Also included is an a-priori study of two approximations for the turbulent transport of the Reynolds stresses, a process that contributes substantially to the stress budgets. The study reveals major defects in the closure approximations for the modelled terms in the stress-transport equations, including that for stress diffusion. In particular, stress diffusion by pressure-velocity correlations, which is much more important than generally assumed, is not realistically modelled by the approximations considered.
KEYWORDS
Turbulent wall jet; LES; Reynolds-stress models; Second-moment budgets.
1
Introduction
Most fluid flows may be regarded, in principle, as consisting of a collection of interacting shear layers and regions subjected to normal straining. While these flow components may be relatively simple, when existing in isolation, it is their interaction that introduces 'complexity' and that is the main cause for predictive failures, especially with statistical models. In most circumstances, the component flows are too indistinct and the interaction too complex or ill-defined to attempt to separate the flow components and to identify the nature of the interaction among them. However, there are important exceptions, and these provide a route to a fruitful investigation of the mechanisms involved and allow questions to be answered on whether particular closure assumptions
98
represent the interaction realistically. One such flow is the wall jet, in which a near-wall shear layer interacts with an outer shear layer evolving from a separation line at the edge of the jet-discharge nozzle. This flow shares some interesting generic features with the post-reattachment region of a separated flow, which consists of a near-wall shear layer that develops from the reattachment point and a free shear layer above it, originating from the curved shear layer on the outer edge of the recirculation bubble. In both flows the two principal components have different structural features and interact strongly across an overlap region as the flow evolves. In the case of post-reattachment recovery, it may be surmised that the observed inability of most turbulence models to return correctly the recovery from separation reflects defects of the models in representing the interaction between the two sets of scales in the flow forming the post-reattachment wake. Thus, the wall jet allows some fundamental interaction mechanisms to be studied in well-defined conditions, which may then be applicable to practically more interesting separated flows.
Figure 1: Flow geometry and instantaneous U-velocity iso-contours.
The present study takes advantage of the highly-resolved LES solutions obtained by Dejoan & Leschziner [1] for a plane, statistically two-dimensional wall jet at conditions also examined experimentally by Eriksson [2]. Especially useful are budgets for second moments covering the overlap region between the near-wall and free shear layers. The budgets reveal, in particular, the important role played by Reynolds-stress transport over a broad region of the shear flow spanning major portions of the boundary layer and the outer shear layer. A further important observation relates to the migration of large scales from the outer layers towards the wall, causing a substantial elevation of the integral length scale throughout the boundary layer, right down to wall. The implication is, therefore, that any model likely to represent correctly the above processes will have to be based on second-moment closure and may, furthermore, requires significant modifications to its length-scale equation which is almost invariably calibrated by reference to relatively simple, isolated shear layers. Attention is focused in this study on the predictive characteristics of three models, two based on second-moment closure (Speziale et al. [3] and Shima [4]), the third being a non-linear eddyviscosity model (Abe et al. [5]). By its very nature, the last obviously does not account for stress transport, and its inclusion herein aims to provide a reference level against which to compare the second-moment models. The particular choice of this model was motivated by its exceptionally favourable performance, within its class, in both attached and separated flow, including postreattachment recovery (Jang et al. [6]). This model therefore provides an appropriate yardstick. The study has two strands: (i) a comparison of RANS predictions with the LES solution; and (ii) an a-priori study of alternative closure proposals for Reynolds-stress diffusion which, as noted above, is observed to be an important contributor to the budget in the interaction (overlap) region of the wall jet.
99
2
T h e g e o m e t r y and its s i m u l a t i o n
The geometry under consideration is shown in Fig. 1. The jet is discharged from a wall slot into a semi-infinite, stagnant environment. The Reynolds number, Re = Uob/u, is 9600, Uo being the maximum inlet velocity, b the slot height and u the fluid viscosity. The simulation has been performed over a domain extending from the wall to 10b above it and to 22b in the streamwise direction. The choice of the latter is based on the experimental observation of Eriksson et al. [2], for the same conditions as simulated here, that the flow essentially reaches a self-similar state at 20b. The homogeneous spanwise domain size is 5.5b. The numerical grid contains 420x208x96 (8.4 million) nodes, and has been carefully chosen to give very low subgrid-scale contributions, approximated with Germano's dynamic Smagorinski model. The ratio of cell size to the Kolmogorov length is, typically, 5-10, and spectra show the cut-off to lie in the dissipative range. The near-wall cell-aspect ratio is, typically, A y + / A x + / A z + = 1.2/24/23, the wall-nearest grid node lying at y+ = 0.6. The complete description of the simulation is given in Dejoan & Leschziner [1].
3
The models
Three models are examined herein. Two are second-moment closures, one being the model of Speziale et al. [3], extended by Chen et al. [7] to low-Re conditions, and the other the model of Shima [4]. The choice of these particular variants is somewhat arbitrary, and others are being considered in further studies in train. However, there is some rationale in preferring these two formulations. First, both models allow integration to the wall. Second, neither model involves "wall reflection corrections" to the pressure-strain approximation. Third, the former model, albeit in its high-Re form, has gained particular popularity, not only in its own right, but also as a basis for the derivation of the explicit algebraic Reynolds-stress model of Gatski & Speziale [8]. Finally, the latter model is a low-Re extension of the closure of Launder et al. [9] - another popular and influential model, as well as one that forms the basis for Wallin & Johansson's [10] explicit algebraic Reynolds-stress model. A distinctive feature of the model of Speziale et al. (denoted by SSG, henceforth) is the non-linear form of the pressure-strain approximation: 1 ~ i j -- -- (C1c + C 1 P k k ) bij + C2e(bikbkj - 5bmnbmn(~ij) + (C3 - C~*IIb/2) k S i j
2 +C4k(bikSjk + bjkSik - 5bm,~Smr~Sij) + Csk (bikWjk + bykWik)
(1)
where bij = u-~/izmum - }Sij, &j = 1/2(OUi/Oxj + OUj/Oxi), Wij = 1/2(OUi/Oxj - OUj/Oxi), Pij = -(u--j~OUi/Oxj +u-i-~OUj/Oxk) and I I = bijbji; k is the turbulence energy and e the dissipation. The above is the high-Re form. As noted earlier, its low-Re extension by Chen [7], not given herein, has actually been used in this study. The pressure-strain approximation used in Shima's model is:
C1 pc
(~ ij "--
(
-
15iju--K~) - pC2 (Pij - 1 -5 -5
) -
(ov
(
ov,
2 - 5
1 )
(2)
where Dij = -(u-Tg-ZOUk/Oxi + u-N-ZOUk/Oxj). Although this appears to be a linear proposal, the coefficients C 1 - C4 are functions of the first and second stress invariants, and this makes the model quasi-linear in the Reynolds-stress. The benefit is to obviate the need to include wall-reflection
100
fragments. The model by Jakirlic & Hanjalic [11] is the most elaborate member of the group of closures involving such quasi-linear approximations, but this has been found to give serious numerical problems in the present geometry. Both second-moment models incorporate Daly & Harlow's generalised-gradient-diffusion hypothesis [12]- see equation (3) below. The non-linear eddy-viscosity model of Abe et al. [5] (denoted later by AJL) rests on a quadratic constitutive stress-strain-vorticity equation derived from an algebraic simplification of a secondmoment closure in which the pressure-strain term is represented by the most general, tensorially linear approximation in the anisotropy tensor (Abe et al. [13]). The basic explicit algebraic approximation is then augmented by two additive fragments intended to account, respectively, for high normal straining and strong near-wall anisotropy, the latter returning correctly the asymptotic decay of all Reynolds-stresses towards the state of two-component turbulence at the wall that is observed from DNS. This decay cannot be represented solely by the use of terms combining the strain and vorticity, and the approach taken by Abe et al. has thus been to add a tensorially correct wall-related term to the constitutive stress-strain/vorticity relation, aij -- ~ k --g(~ij 2 = f ( S i j , f~ij...), which takes into account the wall orientation. In the model variant used here, the wall-direction indicator is: dij = Ni/~/NkNk (with Ni = Old/Oxi and ld = Yn, the wall distance), which is then used in the additive wall-anisotropy correction of the form: Waij = - f w (didj -- ~ d k d k ) x f(SikSkj, Sikf~kj, S k j ~ i k , S 2, f~2...), where fw is a viscosity-related damping function. Alternative wall-orientation indicators, independent of wall distance, may readily be used. In the above damping function, a composite time scale is used, which combines the macro-scale k/e with the Kolmogorov scale y/~/e. The damping function fw then provides a smooth transition between the two scales across the near-wall layer. Two variants of the model exist" one operating in conjunction with the dissipation-rate (c) equation and the other with an equation for the specific dissipation rate (w). The former variant is used herein. The model is fully described in Abe et al. [5] and Jang et al. [6]. The latter publication demonstrates that the model does indeed return the correct wall-asymptotic behaviour of the stresses both for attached and separated flows. ]
For reasons explained earlier, an a-priori examination of two approximations for the diffusion of the Reynolds stresses forms the second part of the present study. The proposals considered are those of Daly & Harlow [12] and Hanjali5 & Launder [14], respectively" dij - ~Xk
0.22--ukulc Oxz J a n d dij - ~Xk
0.1 C
~
Oxl
+ uju----[ OXl
+ UkUl OXl
(3)
These are by far the most frequently used approximations in second-moment-closure models. Although stress diffusion is usually held to be of subordinate importance, relative to other processes contributing to the budgets, this is not the case for the wall jet. Hence, the validity the above approximations is likely to reveal itself especially clearly for this flow.
4
Computational procedure
Computations were performed with a non-orthogonal, collocated, cell-centred finite-volume approach implemented in the code 'STREAM' (Lien & Leschziner [15], Apsley & Leschziner [16]). Convection of both mean-flow and turbulence quantities is approximated by the 'UMIST' scheme (Lien & Leschziner [17]) - a second-order TVD approximation of the QUICK scheme. Mass conservation is enforced indirectly by way of a pressure-correction algorithm. Within this scheme,
101
Figure 2: Left: growth rate of the wall jet. Right: evolution of the wall thickness, (~ = the streamwise direction.
p/u~, along
Figure 3: Profiles of the mean streamwise velocity, RMS of normal Reynolds stresses and turbulence energy, scaled with wall variables.
the transport and the pressure-correction equations are solved sequentially and iterated to convergence. The computational domains extends to 35b above the lower wall and 150b in the streamwise direction. The grid contains 150 x 222 non-uniformly distributed nodes, and has been carefully constructed to ensure grid-independence. At the upper boundary, fixed-pressure and zero-streamwisevelocity conditions are prescribed, allowing free entrainment normal to the boundary. In the actual flow, the inlet conditions (at the nozzle-exit plane) are essentially laminar, with the turbulence intensity being less than 2%. These are the conditions used in the RANS computations presented here. However, other inflow conditions, prescribed at locations downstream of the nozzle and taken from the LES solution, have been tested. Moreover, different levels of turbulence intensity, within the range 2% to 20%, have been tested to examine the influence on the self-similar behaviour of the wall jet. These tests yielded virtually no sensitivity of the RANS solutions far downstream to the details of the inflow conditions. The aim of using a very long domain for the RANS computations was to ensure, unequivocally, that a self-similar state would be reached - the condition on which the study focuses - and to avoid any uncertainties arising from transition.
102
5
5.1
Results
Model performance
In this first part of the presentation of results, model predictions are contrasted against experimental data and LES solutions. The global spreading rate of the jet, in terms of Yl/2/b, and the streamwise evolution of the wall friction, represented by the wall thickness, 5~ = v/u~-, along the streamwise direction are given in Fig. 2. Because of uncertainties associated with transition, the initial streamwise portion x/b < 10 needs to be ignored. Both second-moment closures, especially the SSG model, are seen to predict excessive spreading rates and very slow approach towards self-similarity, but give a broadly correct evolution of the wall-shear stress. In contrast, the AJL model returns a spreading rate closely matching the experiment, while the wall-shear stress is too high and, more importantly, diminishes too slowly. Results for velocity and second moments are given in Fig. 3. Except for the LES, all other profiles relate to x/b = 75. This location is well within the self-similar region. In contrast, the LES profile apply to x/b = 20. This is the furthest location for which comparisons with LES data is possible. Reference to the experimental and LES-predicted spreading rate (Fig. 2) suggests that the jet has effectively reached the self-similar region at this location, although some minor adjustments do occur further downstream. Hence, comparisons at this location may be taken to reflect, essentially, the ability of the models to predict the self-similar characteristics. The results in Fig. 3 show both second-moment models, especially the SSG formulation, to perform poorly. Both predict insufficient near-wall anisotropy, partly associated with inadequacies in the low-Re fragments of the models, and both give surprisingly high turbulence-energy and Reynolds-stress levels in the outer shear layer, consistent with the excessive spreading rate seen in Fig. 2. The SSG model also gives an especially poor representation of the mean velocity in the interaction region and its fringes. Because of the strong effect of the outer shear layer with the near-wall layer and the relatively low Reynolds number, there is no distinctive log-law region. In fact, the analysis of the LES data provided by Dejoan & Leschziner [1] demonstrates, on the basis of budgets, that the interaction region lies within 30 < y+ < 90. The SSG model thus performs especially poorly in this region, in which it also predicts too low levels of shear stress. The AJL model, although not accounting for anisotropy transport, gives a far better representation of both mean velocity and stress fields. This includes the near-wall anisotropy, reflecting the favourable performance of the model fragment (4). The results given in Dejoan & Leschziner [1] show that the non-alignment of the zero-stress and zero-strain locations reported by Eriksson et al. is well reproduced by the LES and is unambiguously caused by turbulent transport of the Reynolds stresses. This distinctive behaviour of the wall jet, reflecting the strong interaction between the outer and inner shear layers, can obviously not be predicted by the AJL model. However, on the basis of the results included above, this interaction, if at all realistically represented by the stress-diffusion fragments within the second-moment models, is less influential than other processes, which appear to be poorly represented by the second-moment closures examined.
5.2
Analysis of budgets
In what follows in this section, budgets for turbulence energy and, where appropriate, stresses are given in an effort to gain further insight into the characteristics given in the previous section. First, budgets for the turbulence energy derived from the AJL and SSG models are compared in Fig. 4 to that obtained from the LES at x/b = 20, with attention confined to the near-wall and interaction regions. Close similarity is observed between the AJL and the LES budgets, while the SSG budget shows a poor representation of dissipation and diffusion. Production is also too high, with the peak
103
too close to the wall. To some degree, the poor performance below y+=20 may be attributed to the low-Re extension of the basic SSG model, but the defects are clearly more deep-rooted. Budgets for the individual stress components are only applicable to second-moment closure, and comparisons between the SSG and LES budgets for v~ and ~-V are given in Fig. 5. These stresses are the most interesting, in so far as they control the mean flow and also display most clearly the substantial contribution of stress transport. In the budgets, the stress diffusion, Tij, includes the effect of the triple correlations as well as pressure diffusion, while Oij represents the pressure-strain correlation (see model approximation (1)). The comparisons reveal some major differences between the SSG and LES budgets. First, both LES budgets show that stress transport is extremely influential in the region y+ < 100. Very close to the wall, pressure-strain and pressure diffusion (which largely dominates the turbulent transport in this region) are large and of opposite sign, but this particular feature may be set aside, as it is of no significant consequence to the turbulent stresses. Away from the viscous sublayer, however, the major differences are important and influential. The SSG model gives an entirely wrong representation of the production, pressure-strain process and diffusion of the shear stress. The production is too high, as the opposing diffusion is far too low, and the pressure strain is positive, as observed in a standard boundary layer (see Mansour et al. [18]), rather than the negative value derived from the LES. An even poorer representation is provided for the wall-normal stress V~. In the LES budget, the balance is mainly between the negative pressure-strain correlation and the positive diffusion, while the SSG model implies a balance between the much too high level of dissipation, suggesting that the approximation cvv = 2/3ck is not appropriate, and positive pressure-strain, again as observed in the standard boundary layer. Thus, the implication is that closure of the stress-transport equations contains some major defects, among them the approximation of stress diffusion, which is clearly badly represented.
5.3
A-priori study of stress diffusion
A conclusion emerging from the LES results is that the turbulent transport of the stresses plays an important role in the interaction between the inner and outer shear layers. In the previous section, the LES data have been used to give a view on how the various fragments of SSG model represent the associated processes. However, this view is clouded by the interaction among these processes, which arises when the model operates within an actual computation. A better view of the realism of any one fragment can be gained by performing a-priori studies of the individual fragments by reference to the simulation data. This is done here for the stress-diffusion terms, in view of their importance in the interaction region. The particular approximations considered are those of Daly & Harlow and Hanjalid & Launder (eq. 3), the former used in both the SSG and Shima models. Results are presented in two ways in Fig. 6. First, LES-predicted and measured triple correlations are compared to corresponding RANS approximations, assuming that the latter represent these correlation and that the contribution of pressure diffusion is negligible. The alternative presentation compares the diffusive contributions to the stress budgets - i.e. the gradients of the sum of viscous, triple and pressure-velocity fragments. In the former, data for ~ extracted from the LES and measured by Eriksson et al. are compared to the model approximating the transverse diffusion of ~--~, rather than the longitudinal diffusion of ~-v. Similarly, uuv is compared to the transverse diffusion of ~-g. The comparison relating to the triple correlations suggests that both RANS approximations give reasonable representations of the LES and experimental data, except for uuu, which is the least influential term. However, it is the derivatives of the sum of these correlations and the pressurevelocity terms that enter the stress-transport equations, and Fig. 6 shows both RANS approximations to give a poor representation of the real transport. To separate the contributions arising from the triple and pressure-velocity correlations, LES-derived distributions are given for the total
104
transport and that total less the pressure-velocity contribution. As seen, pressure diffusion plays a major role in respect of ~ and ~-~. Thus, while the RANS models may be reasonable approximations of the transport associated with the triple-correlations, they do not capture pressure diffusion which is very important in the present flow. This is one reason, but by no means the only one, for the failure of the SSG model in the present flow. 0.3
I~'~0.
. . . . . . . . . . . .
0.3
............
:
0.2
I;z,':
k
'l ' t
1"-* D,,+ TkI-I
~
, ' i ,~,
~c~ /I I~Ek
r
9-
,~-0.1e,
i
_0.'z
25
§ Y
0.2
.~-0. 0
.
2
,3
1
50
I ~ 1 , t , 1 , I , 100 125 150 175 200 225 250
75
Figure 4: Turbulence-energy budgets normalized by the wall scales. Production: Pij; viscous diffusion: D~; turbulent transport including pressure diffusion:
~0.1
-
i
SSG + lowReynoldsext.
-0.2 -0"I -0.
i],
~*-* D r + Tk[/
k
~
Tij----(uiujuk ),k -- (p/p(uiSjk + UjSik ) ),k; 0
25
50
75
100
125 150 175 200 225 250 4Y
............. ~
0.1
convection: Cij.
t~v~P'~ 9
.._, D v + T v
o
-0.1
LES
SSG + lowReynoldsext.
-0o1~ lull
0 ' ~5' 5'0' ~'5' 1;0'1;5' l;O'1~5'2;0'2~'250 +
0
1
25
,
I
50
,
I
75
Y
i ............. ~ "~ 0.1 -/ ~
t
r
.
]~dv tick" ]' I*-'D:Y"T I -I t~> C
~
uv
Figure r
5:
- p/p(ui,j
,
i
25
,
i
50
,
i
75
,
i
,
I
,
I
,
I
uv
I o.,L~.
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
100 125 150 175 200 225 250 + Y
No v
J
,-.D +L,. J
-~
LES
-0.2 II
I
g uv
~-0.1
0
,
,
i
,
i
,
1
,
i
,
.0.2F
100 125 150 175 200 225 250 + Y
Reynolds-stress budgets, scaled + uj,i) is the pressure-strain.
1 0
with
25
50
wall
75
100 125 150 175 200 225 250 + Y
variables;
see
Fig.4
for
labels;
105
10 ~ t-
,'
~ IO
~~ F
nun
0'
I
'
] ~~~~~1" 9
._J[ ~ 9 x/b=2oX/b=20 (LEs)(Erikss~et al.)
" ~
9 x/b= 70 (Eriksson et al. ) Hanjalic and Launder model Daly and Harlow model
0
0
50
I 2 ]---
VVV
-,
'
y+
'I h
100
, '
150
~I - ] ' l
-
-
*
x/b=20 (Eriksson el al.) x/b=20 (LES) 9 x/b=70 ( Eriksson et al. )
'
0
Hanjalic and Launder model Daly and Harlow model
-2
0 ' UUV
50
y+
100
I
'
I
|
150 '
"
1
0
i
i
- - Dr+ T u- DPu (LES) - - Dv+ T u (LES) o--o Dr+ T u (Daly and Harlow) [o---oDr+ T u (Hanjalic and Launder)
-- -- Hanjalic and Launder model x/b=70 (Eriksson et al.) Daly and Harlow model
-2
0 2 U VV
'
50
y+
I00
1
'
1
150 '
Hanjalic and Launder model
0
x/b=70 ( Eriksson et al. )
-0"1f
Daly and Harlow model
-2
5'0
-0.20 0
50
0.06~ |
y+
'
100
150
,~o
+ Y
,;o
2~o
250
~ ,' ' ' .. . . . [ - - Ov+T - D:~ (LES) 0.1
I~ 0.04 ~ " - - - , , i
~
o--,o Dv+ r (Daly and Harlow) [o---oD + T~ (Hanjalic a n d Launder) 9 v vv
#
-0.1
- - D r + T - DPv (LES)
__ Dv+rv (LBS) -0.2
0"02
~ D v+ Tuv (DMy a n d Harlow) ,---, Dr+ T (Hanjolic a n d L a u n d e r )
-0.3 UV I
0
,
I
50
,
I
100
,
I
+ 150 Y
,
1
200
,
250
-0"40 ' 215 ' 510 ' 75 ' 100' 125' + 1}0 '175 '200' 225'250 Y
Figure 6" A - p r i o r i study of turbulent transport terms; Di% - --(P/P(Ui~jk + Uj~ik)),k
6
Conclusions
This study started from the premise that a realistic approximation of Reynolds-stress diffusion, only possible within the framework of second-moment closure, was likely to be an important element in modelling correctly the details of the interaction between the outer shear layer and the boundary layer within a wall jet. This supposition was derived from the examination of LESpredicted budgets which show that stress diffusion is a very influential process, especially for the shear stress and the cross-flow normal stress. Surprisingly, the two second-moment closures examined return predictions which are considerably inferior to that from a reference model which cannot account for stress transport. The former do not only give a poor representation in the near-wall and interaction regions, but also in the outer shear layer. Consideration of the budgets for one of the two closures indicates some major defects in the approximation of pressure-strain, stress-diffusion and dissipation terms, while the non-linear eddy-viscosity model gives, in contrast, a turbulence-energy budget that agrees well with the LES solution. Evidently, therefore, stress diffusion is not the principal mechanism dictating the overall predictive quality of a model; other, more influential mechanisms, need to be approximated well, alongside diffusion, for the model to give realistic predictions, at least for the wall jet. A detailed a-priori examination of two approximations for stress diffusion showed both to give credible representations of the processes associated with the triple correlations of velocity fluctuations, but not of the total diffusion, which includes pressure-fluctuation-driven diffusion. Other elements in the closure can obviously not perform
106
realistically within a framework in which all terms operate interactively. Acknowledgments The authors are grateful for the financial support of the research by the UK's Physical Sciences and Engineering Research Council (EPSRC)
REFERENCES
[1] A. Dejoan and M.A. Leschziner. Large eddy simulation of a plane turbulent wall jet. Phys. Fluids, To appear, 2004. [2] J. Eriksson. Experimental studies of the turbulent wall jet. PhD Thesis, KTH, 2003. [3] C.G. Speziale, S. Sakar, and T.B. Gatski. Modelling the pressure-strain correlation of turbulence: an invariant dynamical system approach. J. Fluid Mech., 227:245-272, 1991. [4] N. Shima. Low-Reynolds-number second-moment closure without wall-reflection redistribution terms. Int. J. of Heat and Fluid Flow, 19:549-555, 1998. [5] K. Abe, Y-J. Jang, and M.A. Leschziner. An investigation of wall-anisotropy expressions and lengthscale equations for non-linear eddy-viscosity models. Int. J. Heat and Fluid Flow, 24:181-198, 2003. [6] Y.J. Jang, M.A. Leschziner, K. Abe, and L. Temmerman. An investigation of anisotropy-resolving turbulence models by reference to highly-resolved les data for separated flow. Flow, Turbulence and Combustion, 69:161-203, 2002. [7] H.C. Chen, Y.-J Jang, and J.C. Han. Computation of heat transfer in rotating two-pass square channels by a second-moment closure model. Int. J. Numer. Methods Fluids, 43:1603-1616, 2000. [8] T.B. Gatski and C.G. Speziale. On explicit algebric stress models for complex turbulent flows. J. Fluid Mech., 254:59-78, 1993. [9] B.E Launder, G. J. Reece and W. Rodi. Progress in the development of a Reynolds stress model turbulence closure. J. Fluid Mech., 68:537-566, 1975. [10] S. Wallin and A.V. Johansson. An explicit algebraic Reynolds stress model for incompressible and compressible turbulent flow. J. Fluid Mech., 403:89-132, 2000. [11] S. Jakirlic and K. Hanjalid. A second-moment closure for non-equilibrium and separating high- and low-Re-number flows. Proc. 10 th Symp. On Turbulent Shear Flows, Pennsylvania State University, 23:23.25-23.30, 1995. [12] B.J. Daly and F.H. Harlow. Transport equations in turbulence. Phys. Fluids, 13:2634-2649, 1970. [13] K. Abe, T. Kondoh, and Y. Nagano. On Reynolds-stress expressions and near-wall scaling parameters for predicting wall and homogeneous turbulent shear flows. Int. J. Heat and Fluid Flow, 18:266-282, 1997. [14] K. Hanjalid and B.E Launder. A Reynolds stress model of turbulence and its application to thin shear flows. J. Fluid Mech., 74:593-610, 1972. [15] F.S. Lien and M.A. Leschziner. A general non-orthogonal collocated finite volume algorithm for turbulent flow at all speeds incorporating second-moment turbulence-transport closure, part I: Computational implementation. Comp. Meth. Appl. Mech. Eng., 114:123-148, 1994. [16] D.D. Apsley and M.A. Leschziner. A new low-Reynolds-number nonlinear two-equation turbulence model for complex flows. Int. J. Heat and Fluid Flow, 19:209-222, 1998. [17] F.S. Lien and M.A. Leschziner. Upstream monotonic interpolation for scalar transport with application to complex turbulent flows. Int. J. Num. Meths. Fluids, 19:527-548, 1994. [18] N.N. Mansour, J. Kim, and P. Moin. Reynolds-stress and dissipation-rate budgets in a turbulent channel flow. J. Fluid Mech., 194:15-44, 1988.
Engineering Turbulence Modelling and Experiments 6 W. Rodi (Editor) 9 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
107
EDDY COLLISION MODELS FOR T U R B U L E N C E Blair Perot and Chris Chartrand Department of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA 01003, USA
ABSTRACT Simple fluids such as gases and liquids are the result of collisions between molecules. More complex fluids, such as granular flows and colloidal suspensions (non-Newtonian fluids), result from the more complex collision (or interaction) behaviors of their constituent particles. In this paper it is demonstrated that collision rules can be constructed for large chunks of fluid material (eddies) such that the resulting collective system behaves like the mean (RANS) flow of a turbulent fluid. The collision model approach has a number of advantages over classic Reynolds stress transport (RST) models. For example, turbulent transport does not require a model and mathematical constraints like realizability are automatically satisfied. Using some ideas from lattice-Boltzmann methods and adaptive moving mesh algorithms for CFD it is shown that this modeling approach can be made computationally efficient and comparable in cost to classic Reynolds stress transport (RST) models. Finally, it is shown that the collisional approach to turbulence modeling can lead to some insights into turbulence and turbulence modeling that would probably not have been achieved via the traditional RST approach. KEYWORDS Turbulence, Modeling, RANS, Reynolds Stress Transport, Collision Model. INTRODUCTION The traditional approach to modeling turbulence or non-Newtonian fluids is to hypothesize equations for the unknown stress tensor (in turbulence this is the Reynolds stress tensor). Because, the eddies making up the flow are roughly the same size as the gradients in the mean flow these eddies respond on similar timescales as the mean flow. This means that algebraic models are rarely predictive, and evolution equations for the stress tensor must be hypothesized. In turbulence, these are the Reynolds stress transport (RST) equations. Simpler turbulence models, such as the k-e model or algebraic Reynolds stress models, are simplifications of the RST equations.
108
There is a strong analogy between turbulent fluid flow and Non-Newtonian or granular flows. Very similar to turbulent flows, transport equations are very often developed for non-Newtonian stress tensors (the Oldroyd-B model and FENE-P models are examples). In fact, we note that many important turbulence modeling concepts (realizability, material frame indifference, tensor consistency) actually find their origins in the non-Newtonian literature at this transport equation level. However, it has long been recognized in the non-Newtonian fluid community that transport equation models have serious limitations. An alternative approach is to model the fluid at the particle collision level rather than using a transport equation for the stress. This approach is more versatile, and in many ways, more fundamental. For example, modeling a gas as particles with binary elastic hard sphere collisions gives the Navier-Stokes equations and the perfect gas law when the density is high, as well as the correct gas behavior even when the density is low (when Navier-Stokes is not valid). In this work we investigate the possibility of modeling turbulence as a collection of interacting particles. NUMERICAL SOLUTION OF COLLISION MODELS Once a certain collision behavior has been hypothesized there are three very different ways to solve the particle system numerically and obtain a prediction of the fluid behavior. The most straightforward technique is the 'molecular dynamics' approach where one numerically tracks all the particles in the domain, and performs collisions when they occur. This approach has a computational cost equivalent to large eddy simulation (LES) and is not considered further. The other two approaches note that one does not really care what happens to individual particles but only what happens to particles on average. The quantity of interest then becomes the probability density function that describes the probability that a particle (at a certain place and time) has a certain velocity. The evolution of the probability distribution function, f obeys the exact equation
of +v, af 0-7
of
df I
(1)
-~x, + a~ --~ = --~ co,,,s,.....
where a, is the acceleration due to external forces (like gravity) and the right-hand side describes the average affect of the collisions on the PDF. It is this average collision behavior that we now wish the models to predict. There are two different ways to solve this PDF equation. One way is to assume the collision model has a Fokker-Planck form (see equations 2 through 4). Then using the equivalence between the Fokker-Planck equation and the Langevin equation (Brownian motion), it is possible to construct a Lagrangian particle method. This is the approach extensively researched by Pope (1994, 2000) and coworkers. The Lagrangian particles move like Brownian dust particles. They move with the mean flow and are randomly perturbed using a prescription given by the model. In this way each particle is independent from all the others, and simply interacts with the average of all the other particles. This is less expensive than tracking and implementing individual collisions ('molecular dynamics' approach) but is still expensive because a large statistical sample of particles is required. The numerical approach used in this project was to solve the PDF equation using a standard Eulerian mesh in physical space, x, as well as in velocity space, v. Normally, this approach would be rejected outright since 10 mesh points in each direction then requires a million mesh points (106) to mesh all six variables (x and v) and is too expensive. The resolution to this problem is to use an extremely coarse mesh in the velocity space (3 points in each direction). This means we are solving 27 equations for each point in space. For comparison, a RST model solves 3 velocity,
109
1 pressure, and 6 stress equations (10 equations) per point in space. However, since the RST equations are highly coupled and nonlinear, and the PDF equations are not, the solution times are very comparable. A very coarse mesh in velocity space is an idea borrowed from Lattice-Boltzmann methods for solving the Navier-Stokes equations. These methods solve a PDF equation with a very simple collision term that is intended to give Navier-Stokes (Newtonian) fluid behavior. The difference here is that we solve a PDF equation with a much more complex collision term, which results in RANS behavior for the fluid. The coarse mesh is acceptable in both cases because the interest is not in the PDF itself but in its lowest order moments - the mean flow and the stresses. These low order moments can be reasonably extracted from a very coarse approximation of the PDF. Note that the Langevin approach is equivalent to approximating the PDF with a random sample, and a large Collision Models sample is needed even to approximate the low order moments A..,11 reasonably well. The Langevin PDF Methods Particle Tracking approach is slower because it ..~..~ ('molecular dynamics ') provides more information (about the higher order moments). Unfortunately, we have little Coarse Discretization Langevin Equation ('lattice methods ') (Lagrangian particle methods) interest, in engineering turbulence models, in the extra information the Figure 1. Taxonomy of collision model approaches. Langevin solution method provides.
~
While the approach taken in this work is inspired by the success of lattice-Boltzmann numerical methods, the approach is significantly different. This is because the PDF governing molecular interactions (Lattice-Boltmann) has a variance (width) that is much larger than the mean and which is essentially constant (related to the speed of sound). In contrast, the PDF for turbulence has a variance which is much smaller than the mean (turbulence intensities are measured in percent), and which can vary significantly (in time or space). This is illustrated in Figure 2. To capture the turbulence PDF with only three points it is necessary to have a moving adaptive
0
0
Figure 2: Left: typical PDF for molecules. Right: typical PDF for turbulence. mesh in velocity space. In order to avoid losses due to interpolating one mesh to another as the mesh moves, we implemented a fully conservative scheme in which the mesh moves continuously in time (during the timestep). This uses technology previously developed by Perot & Nallapati (2003) for moving meshes in physical space. In actual practice the PDF is three-dimensional. An isosurface of an actual PDF (the 50% value) is shown in Figure 3. This PDF is modeling the behavior of the Le Penven et al (1985) return-to-isotropy Case III > 0 experiment. Note the fairly
110
large changes in the shape and size of the distribution even for this simple experiment. It can also be seen in this figure that a spherical PDF corresponds to isotropic turbulence.
Figure 3" Evolution of the 50% isosurface of the PDF for the return-to-isotropy experiment of Le Penven et al. (case III> 0).
T H E O R E T I C A L ANALYSIS Lundgren (1967) first derived the exact expression for the collision term in the PDF evolution equation for turbulence. As might be expected, this collision term can not be expressed solely in terms of the PDF, and solution of the PDF evolution equation requires a model for the collision term. In this work we have focused on generalizations of the Fokker-Plank collision term. In its simplest form this collision term has the form, df
I
--~ co,....... where u, =
Ivffdv
_
0
av,
a2f [~(7il, i~)f ]+bav._..7
(2)
is the mean velocity and a and b are model constants. For turbulence this needs
to be generalized. Pope and coworkers use the form,
dsI
......= o%.
,
s] + b--gS- + v Ox,2
(3)
!
where v j = vj - u j is the fluctuating velocity and the first term (the drift term) now has a matrix model parameter G,j, and a viscous term has been added for near wall
(low Re number)
calculations. The conversion of these Fokker-Planck models to a Langevin equation for numerical solution dictates that the diffusion term (with b) be isotropic and not have a tensor coefficient. In this paper we analyzed the following even more generalized Fokker Plank model.
-
"av,/
(4)
The last term on the right hand side accounts (exactly) for the mesh motion. The first three terms involve model tensors. Sometimes, these tensors are isotropic and governed by a single parameter.
111
The viscous terms account for low Reynolds number effects and strong inhomogeneity. They do not involve any additional parameters and were derived via analysis and the condition that the model be exact as it approaches a wall (in the laminar sub layer). The zeroth moment of the PDF equation (Eqn 4) is the mass conservation equation. velocity moment of the PDF equation gives the momentum equation,
ou. ~-+
O(u,u. ~,+ ~.)_a.
0 vu,,,] _-~[
The first
(5)
This implies that the acceleration is given by a, = - p , , + (flu,.,),. The viscous contribution to this acceleration is necessary only if the viscosity is not constant. Taking the moment of the modeled PDF equation with respect to v', V'm gives the Reynolds stress transport equation, ~ .
OR,,, ~_O(u,R,,r,,)+ at
ax,
OT,,,,
+(u,,,,R;,, +u,,/R,m)=(G,,,jR;, , +G,,,R,m)+(H,,r, , +Hmn )
ox,
.
-(Jm;U"J+J"jum')'
.
.
.
.
+ a [ aR~m]
(6)
0(Rm~
~~L --~--,_j-2vK,~ , O.x.j
where Tnmi -- ~V' nvlm V'i f d v and K = 89 is the turbulent kinetic energy. The tensors G,j, H,j, and J~ determine the model. Complex dissipation and pressure-strain models can be implemented via these tensors. The equation for the total resolved (or mean) kinetic energy, E r = ~-~v;v, f d v --~ t~.,, is
oE,o+--~ ~['e0x,,~ +u~(~-~,.~)]=4p.,), +u.,;R,.-~,,,(.,,, +u,,,)+~, L ~ ]
(7)
The resolved kinetic energy correctly loses energy as a result of large scale dissipation, and via turbulence production. It is completely specified and does not depend on the model coefficients. The details of these derivations can be found in Chartrand (2004). When implementing the Fokker-Planck collision model (Eqn. 4) on a coarse mesh, it is attractive to make the change of variables j~ - In(f). I f f is close to Gaussian (which is expected) then j~ will be close to parabolic. This parabola can be accurately resolved and interpolated by the three points available in our scheme. The evolution equation for j" is, C3)C+ v, Of ~-7
.+
+
a
( a, - ar,,e~,h ) ~-~: - G,, G;ff 'j Of'~ + - ~ i(J,j+vu, j)
Ov;
'
+ vK,. ~
0% J
+(jo+vu,;)
' +'-K-~,
0)]
H ,j - - ~ + H o
^ ~Of + ~ a v
Ov;
Ox;
0) 0) Ov;Ovj
(8) +v
Ox , Ox,
112
While there are more terms to compute in this version, the equation for j? is much more accurate to solve numerically. In addition, low order methods and simple (3 point) difference stencils suffice because )7 is expected to be very close to quadratic. The models for the tensors G,j, H,/, and J,; require a time scale to be dimensionally correct. For this reason an additional transport equation for the timescale must be included in the model. We have used the standard epsilon transport equation for this purpose since it is very commonly used in RST models as well. SUMMARY OF THE M O D E L The collision model used in this paper is given by,
G,j = C ~, S,j + C ,~ W ,j -F ~ C p 2 K
()()1 /
where ~ = c l+10v ~
/K
,i
'j
RnmRmn
R.
~ G4
(9a)
---K
H. = TCd R ,j
(9b)
4 =-~KC~24;
(9c)
is the modified dissipation that goes to zero in regions of
strong inhomogeneity such as near walls, and P = - R , mu,, m is the standard turbulent production rate.
1
The frame invariant strain-rate and rotation-rate tensors are respectively S,j = ~(u,,j + u),,) 1
and W,j - w(u;,j - U;,,) + c # ~ k ' where ~k is the rotation rate of a non-inertial frame of reference. 2
For comparison with classic RST models, the equivalent Reynolds stress transport equation would be, +
Ot
+
Ox; P ~R, Rm,.R,., (C;,S,,,j +C:~Wm,)R,, , +(C:,S,,, +C:;W,,)Rjm +Cpz-~Rm,,-2R, , ' 00Rmn + 4 KC*pzgm. + ~ v
Ox,
(lo)
2vOK(amnl
8x,
Oxt ~ K ),l
Note that the model constant Cj does not effect the Reynolds stress transport equation. However, it does have an effect on the higher order moments (such as T,m.) and the turbulent transport term. This constant can be related to the Kolmorgorov constant (Pope, 2000). The other model constants are actually parameters and are given by, Cp2 =
Vt
V + Vt
.2F,
_
Cp2 -
Vt
V + Vt
.4F,
Cp2 = - 0 . 2 F 2 + .006 s '~
(11)
113
where the eddy viscosity is given by v, =.12F K2 and F =-~det(R 0/k) is the standard twoe component parameter that is 1 in isotropic turbulence and 0 for two-component turbulence. The transport model for the epsilon equation is standard and is given by,
c~e
0e
o,
-fix,
--+u, where C~, = 1.43,
C , 2 --
=
~
(C,,P-Che)
+A
Ox,
0e
(v+C,3vr)
(12)
-i-gx,
11/6, C~3 = 0.83, and fairly standard values.
SUMMARY OF RESULTS The model was tested on anisotropic decaying turbulence. This is essentially a test of the models ability to correctly predict slow pressure-strain or return-to-isotropy. The eddy collision model has no model constants associated with return to isotropy. In classic RST models, return to isotropy is parameterized by at least the Rotta constant (Rotta, 1951), and quite frequently by an additional return constant to parameterize nonlinear return effects. The Sarkar & Speziale (1990) model is an example of a two parameter nonlinear return model. The derivation of the parameter-free eddy collision return model is found in Perot & Chartrand (2004). This parameter-free model is nonlinear, and strongly realizable, and was discovered as a direct result of the collisional model framework. Two different experiments (Choi & Lumley (2001) and Le Penven et al (1985)) and five different data sets were used to evaluate the performance of the model in figures 4 and 5. Except for Le Penven case III<0 (where all models show difficulty) the parameter-free model agrees well with experimental data. 0.42
r----,F---~---]
..... l---!
0.3
.... ]
E
0.056
-
--
I- - - [ ..... ' ..... I-
0.04 ~
-t
x-
"
~,
'"
0.032
0.032[-
-:--
I - -t
0.028
! -
0.024
~"%,~<~..
0.02 !-
--1--
~
" " ~ .....
-
-4
0.012
0.06 l____~ 0
(a)
I _ 4_-T~zJ 0.03
time
0.06
0.008 L 0.09
0
(b)
i
~ 0.06
L ..... t........ iL ~'_
time
0.12
O.
0.008
--~--~-: - ~ 0
0.02
0.04
time
(c)
Figure 4: Reynolds stresses for Choi and Lumley. (a) Case A, (b) Case B, (c) Case C-2. Symbols are the experimental data, lines are the Rotta model predictions (CR = 0.8), the dashed lines are the SS model predictions (CR=0.8, CN=0.8), and large dashed lines are the current model
0.06
114
Figure 5: Reynolds stresses from Le Penven, Gence and Comte-Bellot. (a) case III>0, (b) case III<0. See Figure 4 for Legend. Next the model was tested in a variety of homogeneous shear flows. They key to predicting these flows correctly is in the modeling of the fast pressure-strain. In the current model three parameters are devoted to the modeling of the fast pressure-strain. The performance of the model is shown in figure 6. In the absence of rotation, the current model performs well. The final figure shows the turbulent kinetic energy in a shear flow as a function of time at three different rotation rates. Only the zero rotation case (upper curve) is well predicted.
Figure 6: Eddy collision model applied to homogeneous shear flows. Symbols are experimental or DNS data. Lines are the model predictions.
Finally, the model was implemented and tested in fully developed channel flow at Re=590. The results are shown in figure 7. The issue in channel flow is to correctly account for inhomogeneity and low Reynolds number effects. In this situation, the modeling of the dissipation tensor requires close attention. This term dominates near the wall and balances viscous diffusion. Details of the dissipation model are found in Perot & Natu (2003). The model for the dissipation
115
tensor is exact in regions of strong inhomogeneity and involves no model parameters. The second to last term in Eqn. 4 is due to this dissipation model. The fact that the model is exact in this limit is important. It means that the diffusion is exactly balanced at the wall, and therefore that the Reynolds stresses always have the correct asymptotic limits near a wall. This means that elliptic relaxation approaches are not required. In addition, computational stability is significantly enhanced since this is the region where Reynolds stresses are close to becoming unrealizable. 24
r
r
-
r
F-+--
ss I -
21
-r-
T---,--
7-
-7--T
;
--7 ....
F--
1
'~I'~
'!
m
t
i+
o. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
0
01
'++~+~++]
. . . . . . .
02
03
04
05
06
07
oa
09
Y
(a)
~
1
o[~
0
.
.
o~
(b)
.
.
02
.
.
.
03
.
.
04
.
.
os
.
.
.
06
.
.
07
.
08
09
0
o1
(c)
Y
] 02
03
04
os
06
o?
08
09
1
Y
o o oNs~ti
i
o,
Y
(d)
Y
(e)
Y
(f)
o2
o~
o~
o~
~
o~
om
o9
Y
(g)
Figure 7: Turbulent channel flow at Re=590. Symbols are the DNS data of Moser et al., lines are the model predictions. (a) Mean velocity, (b) Turbulent kinetic energy, (c) Dissipation rate, (d) R11, (e) R22, (f) R33, (g) R12.
CONCLUSIONS This paper demonstrates that collisional models are a viable alternative to RST models. In one instance, we have even been able to remove a model parameter due to insights gained from this viewpoint. However, it is also clear that this approach, as it stands, has most of the same difficulties and limitations of RST models. In particular, the fast pressure-strain model largely dictates the model's performance in flows with mean flow gradients (most flows). Fast pressurestrain models have many constants and a great deal of predictive uncertainty associated with them. In addition, the scale (or epsilon) transport equation remains (as with RST models) a source of significant error and parameterization (many constants). Finally, although we have used LatticeBoltzmann discretization ideas, the implementation of these collision models is not as computationally efficient as classic Lattice-Boltzmann methods. A moving adaptive mesh is required making the method computationally comparable to RST models. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This work was sponsored by the Office of Naval Research under grant number N00014-99-1-0194.
116
REFERENCES
C. Chartrand (2004), Eddy collision models for turbulence, Masters Thesis, University of Massachusetts, Amherst. K. S. Choi and J. L. Lumley (2001), The return to isotropy of homogeneous turbulence, J. Fluid Mech. 436, pp 57-84. Le Penven (1985), On the Approach to Isotropy of Homogeneous Turbulence: Effect of the Partition of Kinetic Energy Among the Velocity Components, Frontiers in Fluid Mechanics, (ed. S. H. Davis & J. L. Lumley), 1-21, Springer. T. S. Lungren (1967), Distribution functions in the statistical theory of turbulence, Physics of
Fluids, 10, 5. R. D. Moser, J. Kim and N. Mansour (1999), Direct numerical simulation of turbulent channel flow up to Re=590, Phys. Fluids. 11,943-945. J. B. Perot & C. Chartrand (July, 2004), Modeling return-to-isotropy using kinetic equations, Submitted to Physics of Fluids. J. B. Perot & R. Nallapati (2003), A Moving Unstructured Staggered Mesh Method for the Simulation of Incompressible Free-Surface Flows, Journal of Computational Physics, 184, 192-214. J. B. Perot & S. Natu (May 2003), A model for the dissipation tensor in inhomogeneous and anisotropic turbulence, Submitted to Phys. of Fluids. S. B. Pope (1994), Lagrangian PDF methods for turbulent flows. Annual Rev. Fluid Mech. 26, 23-63. S. B. Pope (2000), Turbulent Flows, Cambridge University Press. J. Rotta (1951), Stastische theorie nichthomegener turbulenz I, Z fiir Physik 129, 547-572. S. Sarkar and C. G. Speziale (1990), A Simple Nonlinear Model for the Return to Isotropy inn Turbulence, Physics of Fluids, A2:l, pp. 84-93
Engineering Turbulence Modelling and Experiments 6 W. Rodi (Editor) 9 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
117
A STRESS-STRAIN LAG EDDY VISCOSITY MODEL FOR UNSTEADY MEAN FLOW A. J. R e v e l l 1, S. B e n h a m a d o u c h e 1'2, T. C r a f t 1, D . L a u r e n c e l ' 2 a n d K. Y a q o b i 2 1University of Manchester, PO Box 88, Manchester M60 1QD, UK 2 EDF-DER-LNH, 6 quai Watier, 78401 Chatou, France ABSTRACT A new eddy viscosity model is proposed to include stress-strain lag effects in the modelling of unsteady mean flows. A transport equation for the lag parameter, hereby denoted Gas is derived from a full Reynolds Stress Model (RSM), to be solved in conjunction with a standard two equation low Reynolds number Eddy Viscosity Model (EVM). The performance of the new k - c - Gas model is compared to the flow in a channel driven by a pressure gradient oscillating around a non-zero mean. Results are compared with Large Eddy Simulations (LES) of the same flow and the addition of the lag parameter equation is shown to give improved results when compared to the standard EVM.
KEYWORDS
LES, DES, URANS, EVM, Oscillating channel, Stress-strain alignment
INTRODUCTION Many everyday turbulent flows are inherently unsteady, both industrial (e.g. flows in the cylinders of internal combustion engines, in tubines, wakes of bluff bodies... ) and natural (e.g. the blood flow in arteries). These flows can be a result of imposed fluctuating boundary conditions or geometry induced oscillations, or a combination of both. The presence of such unsteadiness in a flow can significantly alter the behaviour of important parameters such as the Reynolds stresses, turbulent kinetic energy and dissipation rate. Despite the existence and derivation of progressively more complex modelling, simulation or hybrid approaches in the field of turbulence modelling, models for the Unsteady Reynolds Averaged Navier Stokes equations (URANS) are still widely used for the computation of complex flows. However the accuracy of such standard eddy viscosity models have not been carefully established and several fundamental assumptions in their derivations for steady flows in near turbulent equilibrium, no longer hold in the application to transient cases. Through the Boussinesq approximation [ 1], the EVM provides a direct link between the turbulent stress tensor uiuj in its dimensionless form (aij = uiuj/k - 2/3(5~j, where k is the turbulent kinetic energy, ~5~j is the Kronecker delta function) and the mean rate-of-strain tensor S~j, erroneously forcing them to
118
be directly in phase. The phase lag between the stress and strain tensors is essential in the case when the flow is subjected to periodic strain and the lack of this feature leads to continuous over-generation of turbulent kinetic energy [2]. It is well documented that standard EVMs significantly overpredict the production of turbulent kinetic energy in presence of strong strain. This has led to various limiters as in the v 2 - f model [3], the k - ~ SST model [4] and the Linear Production model [5] among others. The need for such bounds comes from the fact that E V M s yield a production, Pk, proportional to the square of the strain rate S~j. In contrast, the full Reynolds Stress Model calculates an exact production which is linear in the strain rate. Indeed, one can write exactly Pk = Cask []S]] where Cas = - a i j S i j / I l s I I is a non-dimensional parameter representing the degree of alignment between stresses and strains. Jakirlid, [6] solved the full stress transport equation to include stresses in Pk, as a means of improving k levels used in a E V M representation of the stresses subsequently applied to the momentum equation. The results show some good improvements for a range of testcases, but the computational cost is very high. The R S M has been shown to act like an LES Sub Grid Scale model in some inherently transient flows [7]. Indeed, in homogeneous cyclic strains, the R S M shows that turbulence intensity grows until inertial effects are large enough such that the stress tensor no longer follows the strain tensor, causing turbulence production to be blocked [2]. The use of the full R S M in combination with LES is appealing for hybrid approaches (e.g. D E S [8]), but is still often perceived as impractical for industrial applications. It is also interesting to note that the reduction of eddy diffusion coefficient in the two equation modelling, [9] calibrated on the basis of R S M modelling can lead to the appearance of unsteady vortex structures in agreement with the physical experiment. The aim of this work is therefore to develop a model for the stress-strain lag, which appears to be a key parameter in rapidly evolving flows. This is obtained by assuming an R S M model for the time derivative of the tensor aij as well as terms including the rate of change of the strain tensor Sij. The model will be derived and validated for homogenous shear and channel flows, before being applied to the oscillating channel case. Its performance will be compared to LES results for the flow in a channel driven by a pressure gradient oscillating around a nonzero mean. Recent LES calculations of this flow are repeated, and compared to the results provided by Scotti and Piomelli [10], [ 11 ] with the same parameters. The objective is to use the LES database for the validation of URANS models in the future, but the current paper is limited to an introduction of this work.
STRESS-STRAIN LAG
The tensors of both stress anisotropy aij and strain rate Sij are 3 • 3 symmetrical tensors. This is important since it can be shown that the eigenvectors of a symmetric tensor are real and orthogonal. The anisotropy tensor has zero t r a c e ctijc~ij -- 0 and is dimensionless by definition, whereas the strain rate tensor is an inverse time scale and has zero trace only in the condition of incompressibility, SijSij = O, which is assumed for this work. As previously stated, the eddy viscosity model assumes that these two tensors are aligned. DNS data from a channel flow and from a homogeneous shear flow can be used to see that even in these cases, this assumption is not true. Invariants are values of a tensor that remain constant regardless of the coordinate system and they can be used to describe the tensor. Invariants used here to characterise aij and Sij are defined in Eqn. 1.
Ila[I = x/aijaij
and
IlSl[ = v/2SijSij
(1)
The alignment of two 2 • 2 symmetric tensors is trivial since there is only one angle between the sets of orthogonal principle axes. This is important as it implies that the alignment for all 2 dimensional flows is representable with a single dimensionless scalar. For a 3 • 3 tensor, the orientation is defined
119
by the 3 Euler angles, which can be obtained through calculation of eigenvectors. The orientation of each tensor allows the misalignment to be given as the difference between each Euler angle, and so three scalar values are necessary to define the full stress-strain lag in a fully 3 dimensional flow. The calculation of the eigenvalues of both tensors, per node, per timestep, is too expensive for large calculations. A simpler approach would instead consider the inner product of the two original tensors, to give a scalar measure of alignment rather than an angle. This parameter, (i.e. C'~s = a#Sij/[]a]l ]S 1), will return a value of 1 when aij is aligned with Sij, and a value of 0 when tensors are mutually perpendicular. The alignment parameter must fit into the 2-equation modelling framework and so the term Gas is defined in Eqn. 2 which is limited by + ]Jail. The case of Ca~ = [Jail corresponds to the linear EVM, so in effect this parameter quantifies the degree of non-linearity of the relationship. C~ =
DERIVATION
OF k - e -
C~
aiySij
(2)
IIsll
MODEL
The transport equation for Gas will now be derived. This is necessary in order to capture the effects of stress-strain lag in transient flows. The aim is to correct ut in unsteady flows, whilst unaffecting E V M results in steady state. Given the definition of Cas from Eqn. 2, the time derivative is proposed using the product rule (where D e ~ D r = Or + UkOr
DOes
1
Dt
IlSll
(
Daij DSij s ~ j - - ~ + a i j - - - ~ -[- Gas
DISlI)
(3)
Dt
It is proposed that the total derivative for aij in Eqn. 3 can be calculated from the full Reynolds Stress Model (Eqn. 4) where small letters denote fluctuating quantities and large letters denote mean quantities. The terms for production Pij and viscous diffusion, DlIIij "-". . . . i..... are exact, but the remaining terms must be modelled. The production can be rewritten as shown in Eqn. 5, where the influence of the rotation tensor f2ij can be seen. The tensorial dissipation in the R S M can be linked to the dissipation equation by assuming local isotropy eij = ~2edij . This is accurate as long as the Reynolds number is high, however when the Reynolds number is lower or when approaching a wall, this is not exact. The pressure strain term 17# will be approximated using the SSG model shown in Eqn. 6, derived by Speziale et al. [ 12]. Duiuj
Dt
= P i j -f- I-Iij - s
Pij -- - k
-[-
T.. op viscous
131IIij
+ C4k
a~a~j - 5~jA~
a~kSjk + ajkS~k -- 5 a ~ & ~ 6 ~ j
u uj k
(4)
(5)
-~ ij -Jr- a i k S k j + S i k a k j -+- a i k ~ k j + ~ i k a j k
n~j = - (Cl~ + c;P~) a~j - c ~
aij =
ro turbulent -1- ~-.. l_)llIij
j 3
- C3
+ Csk (a~kfijk + a ~ k )
sij 1(o = -2 ~
C1 1.7
+
1(o + Oxi J
C63
f~ij = -~
C4
c5
0.625
0.2
Oxj
Oxi
(7)
120
Using the definition of the anisotropy tensor (Eqn. 7) and the full RSM(Eqn. 4), the transport equation for the anisotropy tensor is given in Eqn. 8, where Diff ~ij contains all required diffusion terms. ] Daij = --[Ply + II{j - cij + (Pk - c)(aij + 6ij)] + Diff a" Dt k
(8)
Rodi [13][ 14] developed the Algebraic Stress Model (ASM), in which the neglection of transport of aij is referred to as the weak equilibrium assumption (Daij/Dt - Diffusion ~'~ = 0). This is necessary to construct an algebraic approximation for the anisotropies, based on a specific RSM. In this case the anisotropy relation is implicit and a coupled, nonlinear system of equations must be solved. The approach was shown to retain some features from RSMs but numerical difficulties resulting from a lack of diffusion or viscous damping lead to problems particularly for complex flows. An alternative approach, known as Explicit Algebraic Reynolds Stress Models (EARSM e.g. [ 15]) instead aim to obtain the anisotropy relation explicitly in terms of the mean flow field. Some of these have been shown to be accurate in rotating and sheared flows, although they remain unable to incorporate history and evolution effects of the stresses into their predictions. The present approach is different from the ASM approach in that the entire RHS ofEqn. 4 is used. Given that these terms are balanced to give the advection of the stresses, this approach will be inherently able to incorporate evolution effects. To simplify the implementation, the diffusion terms from the RSM will be dropped, and their effect incorporated within a simple gradient diffusion term in the general transport equation of C~. The general transport equation for Ca~ can therefore be rewritten after substitution of Eqn. 4 into Eqn. 3 as shown.
DC~, Dt -
1
IlSll (SijPij + SijIIij + aijSij - a~jSijc)
(9)
DSij DISI) aij~ + C.~- Dt + Diffc"~
1( IlSl
The SSG variant of the full transport equation for Gas is given by Eqn. 10. The strain rate parameter is = k IlSll/~ the second invariant of anisotropy is A2 = aijaij.
,1
and
Dt
=
0.266 + 0.325
S l l - 2.7~Ca~ + 0.1
IIS co~
(10)
-k- 1.05 S i j a i k a k j - t - 0 . 7 5 SijaikSj-k nt- 1.6 S i j a i k ~ j k
,~
IlSll
__ aij J~Sij
IlSll
Gas D
IlSll
Dt
IlSll
IlSll § Diffc~ Dt
The turbulent viscosity ut is redefined using an updated value of C~ according to Eqn. 12 and the new diffusion term is defined by Eqn. 13 with the constant Ocas = 2.
]s
g-mew __ C
Chew-max
(11)
min (O.09, Cas ) ,0.01] 0
ut
(12)
(13)
If the equation is to correctly model the log-layer region, then it is a requirement that it returns the standard value of C~ in equilibrium conditions (i.e. when production to dissipation ratio is unity and
121
r/ -- 3.333). This is tested by taking equation 10, setting all time derivatives to zero, and neglecting convection and diffusion. Since for the linear EVM there is no normal anisotropy, a i i = 0, it became necessary to take C~ as zero in order to achieve the correct balance, giving a value Cas = 0.32 which is equivalent to Cu -- Cas/rl -- 0.096 and hence close to the standard value. It should be noted that future work will employ a Non-Linear Eddy Viscosity Model (NLEVM e.g. [ 16]) to provide the ai# values in Eqn. 10, which will avoid this drawback. The correctional effects of the Ca, term on the parameter Cu are expected to be even greater since normal anisotropy is non-zero and so more of the terms in Eqn. 10 are in play. For the results in this paper, the Low Reynolds number k - e model proposed by Launder and Sharma (LS) [17] is used as the baseline model, with the straightforward extention described in Eqns. 11 and 12.
NUMERICS Calculations for the present flow were performed using the EDF in-house CFD code, Code_Saturne [ 18]. It is an unstructured finite-volume code based on a collocated discretization for cells of any shape. It solves turbulent Navier-Stokes equations for Newtonian incompressible flows with a fractional step method based on a prediction-correction algorithm for pressure/velocity coupling (SIMPLEC) and a Rhie and Chow interpolation to avoid pressure oscillations. Many turbulence models are available (among them the standard and low Reynolds number version of k - e, SSG, v 2 - f, LES . . . . ). Several LES calculations have been recently computed successfully and validated with Code_Saturne[ 19], [20]. Both the standard Smagorinsky model with a constant set to 0.065 and the classical dynamic model have been used to compute the oscillating channel flow. The time advancing scheme is second order with a combination of Crank-Nicolson and Adams-Bashforth schemes. A fully centred scheme is used for the convection term without any upwinding. In the case of non-orthogonal cells, a gradient reconstruction technique is used to maintain the second order accuracy in space.
O S C I L A T I N G CHANNEL
LES results are available to describe the periodic variation of the flow field. An oscillating pressure gradient is applied as the periodic boundary conditions to a similar mesh to that used in the previous section. The flow is forced by a mean pressure gradient given in Eqn. 14 following the notations given in Scotti and Piomelli [ 10]. 71"
Pl (x,t) = APo [l + acos (f~t + -~) ] x/L~
(14)
In the following, the frequency f~ = 3.57s -1 and the amplitude a = 50, which is refered to in [10] as an intermediate frequency. This is an interesting frequency which causes the turbulent quantities to become out of phase and is therefore suitable to the present study (whereas the higher frequencies influence only the flow very close to the wall). The pressure is lagged in order to start the acceleration phase at ~2t = 27rt/T where T is the period time. The channel half height 5 and the mean pressure gradient APo/L~ are set to give a Reynolds number of 350, based on the mean friction velocity ur -- v/SAPo/2pLx. A set of 100 nodes is used to discretize the 1-D domain for the URANS calculations with a near wall refinement. The domain size in the LES calculations is 65~" x 45 x 3/25~- and the number of cells is 64 x 64 x 65 with wall refinement. The maximum Courant number in all the calculation did not exceed 1. In all the computations, a phase averaging is used to compute mean values. Phase averaging is denoted by (-). It
122
is defined for a physical variable r as follows.
(r
1 (V, t) -- --~
(r
(v, t) = -~ ~=~ ~
n=l
f
V,~+n
(15) I
~, v, z ~ + ~ eze~
(16)
RESULTS Initial work was carried out to validate the LES for the oscillating channel flow. Figure 1 shows the periodic variation of several quantities for two versions of our LES, Scotti's LES and the URANS models. Overall the agreement between the 3 LES calculations is very reasonable, although the dynamic model seems to overpredict both the velocity and kinetic energy in comparison to the other two. There is a slight discrepancy in the variation of the wall shear stress between the new results and the reference data, where a bump described between t i t = 0.6 and t i t = 0.9 is not picked up. This is mirrored by discrepancies in the periodic variation of kinetic energy, for the same time bracket, which also corresponds to deceleration region of the oscillation ( t i t = 0.25 and tiT -- 0.75). This behaviour is an indication of the strong influence of near wall phenomena on the rest of the flow.
4o
,
,
,
_ 30 - -
,
,
:
:
9
REFERENCE
! ~ t. ~-
i
0
LES smagorinsky
+
LES dynamic model
j.'/
Ucl 20 - _
.//
,
,
i
"
~
/ , t.
~ ~/ip;
10
: 10
-
_ 5
+ + + + ! ~ " ~
0 5
(Scotti)
k - v. m o d e l L S k - e m o d e l L S w i t h Cas
+++++:+
+++ 9 : :_++ ,~oOO..~,~ :-1^D.v-.--~ : qa~ i
kmax
,j,
"
~
~
--[ -t
~ ~..~..
~- '" ~
.
.
.
mnmm .mi 9
'l~wall 0 0
0.125
0.25
0.375
0.5
0.625
0.75
0.875
1
t/T Figure 1: Time series over period of oscillation for centreline velocity Uct, maximum streamwise kinetic energy kmax and wall shear stress rwau. Comparison to LES reference data [10] for validation of LES dynamic and LES Smagorinksy models. Results from Low Reynolds number k - e model [ 17], with and without C,s modified viscosity.
Given the decent agreement between the Low Reynolds number k - ~ [ 17] and the reference data, it can
123
be said the selection of a good near wall model or damping function, together with an adequate near wall refinement is enough to capture the main features of this flow. Although the reference profile of kinetic energy suffers from lack of data points, the asymmetric bump during deceleration shown by all 3 LES is a well documented feature of this flow and should not be ignored. The k - e - C~s model is in very good
Figure 2: Streamwise profiles at Ct/T for r = 0 to 7. Columns from left to right: Velocity U (scale 0 -+ 40), turbulent kinetic energy k (scale 0 -+ 12) and alignment, C~s (scale 0 ~ 0.4) vs y/3. Results shown for LES dynamic model, LES Smagofinksy model, Low Reynolds number k - ~ model [ 17], with and without Ca~ modified viscosity. For key refer to Figure 1 The same general conclusions can be drawn through cross-reference to Figure 2 which shows streamwise profiles of velocity, kinetic energy and Cas at eight different phase times, corresponding to the x-axis labels of Figure 1. It can be seen that the shape of the velocity and kinetic energy profiles are improved when using the k - c - C a s model particularly in the acceleration phase. Moving back into the deceleration region, the near wall maxima of kinetic energy and velocity fall slower than the LES while the results with the unmodified URANS model are decent, but this is only by chance i.e. because they are falling from lower maximum values. Tracing the maximum of the LES profiles of Cas reveals an elliptic path over the period, which represents the movement of the phase lag between production and dissipation of k.
124
This flow is certainly influenced to a large extent by its near wall features and there is an apparent phase switch between best predictions being offered by the k - c model and then by the k - r - Gas model. This is likely due to the fact that the terms of the C~, transport equation are not valid near the wall. Since they come directly from the high Reynolds SSG model, there is no damping of the pressure strain. The Low Reynolds k - c model has improved behaviour in the decelleration region and it is reasonable to expect that a low Reynolds number version of the k - c - C~s model, or even a version coupled with the v 2 - f , would retum similar improvements.
C O N C L U S I O N S AND F U T U R E W O R K The degree of alignment of stresses and strains is expressed as a dimensionless parameter and a transport equation is derived to account for the time evolution of this term. The equation is derived from a full RSMmodel so as to incorporate phase lag information and to automatically limit the production of kinetic energy in regions of strong strain. The eddy viscosity is globally modified so there is no discrepancy between the turbulent transport and the mean flow equation. LES results for a channel flow oscillating at an intermediate frequency are validated and used to show the improvements in the new k - c - Gas model over the standard model.
Figure 3: Preliminary results for flow around NACA0012 at max Lift at an incidence of 60 ~ using k - c - Gas model. TOP: Contour plot o f Pressure overlaid with flow streamlines. BOTTOM" Contour lines of modified C . with labels. Both at same location and time.
The motivation behind the model development stems from the observation that in rapidly varying mean flows, such as bluff body wakes or staggered tube bundles, RSMs can produce large unsteady structures similar to LES. In homogenous turbulence subject to cyclic straining it was shown that the stresses increasingly lag behind the strains until production is shut off. Therefore RSMs seem an attractive idea for DES, but is too computationally expensive. The present model is very economical since it is has almost no additional expense over a standard k - c in terms of convergence time, and only slightly
125
higher storage requirements. It is also very easy to implement in contrast with the RSM. Figure 3 shows contour plots from some early calculations on the NACA0012 airfoil at an incidence angle of 60 ~ This is a massively separated flow and provides a more suitable test for the k - c - Cas model. From Figure 3 it can be seen that C u is reduced in the regions corresponding to the shedded structures (shown by the pressure contours and flow streamlines). This behaviour is in agreement with the prediction of strongly detached flows by modified two-equation models that suggest the C , reduction based on the behaviour of the R S M modelling for the same class of flows [9], in the context of the Organised Eddy Simulation, also used to improve the R A N S length scale in D E S for the same NACA0012 configuration [21]. It appears that the response of the k - ~ - Cas model to regions of stress-strain lag could be used to automatically reduce k levels in the U R A N S ~ D E S transition when unsteady structures start to emerge, instead of the ad-hoc switch based on grid characteristics as commonly used in DES; in which mesh dependency is one of the current breakdowns. A detailed study of the k - c - C ~ model is under way using the experimental study around a circular cylinder [22].
Acknowledgements Authors are grateful to A. Scotti and U. Piomelli for fast and friendly provision of their LES data and clarifications for its use. Financial support via the FLOMANIA and DESider projects is also acknowledged. The FLOMANIA project (Flow Physics Modelling - An Integrated Approach) is a collaboration between Alenia, AEA, Bombardier, Dassault, EADS-CASA, EADS-Military Aircraft, EDF, NUMECA, DLR, FOI, IMFT, ONERA, Chalmers University, Imperial College, TU Berlin, UMIST and St. Petersburg State University. The project is funded by the European Union and administrated by the CEC, Research Directorate-General, Growth Programme, under Contract No.G4RD-CT2001-00613. The DESider project (Detached Eddy Simulation for Industrial Aerodynamics) is a collaboration between Alenia, ANSYS-AEA, Chalmers University, CNRS-Lille, Dassault, DLR, EADS Military Aircraft, EUROCOPTER Germany, EDF, FOI-FFA, IMFT, Imperial College London, NLR, NTS, NUMECA, ONERA, TU Berlin, and UMIST. The project is funded by the European Community represented by the CEC, Research Directorate-General, in the 6th Framework Programme, under Contract No. AST3-CT-2003-502842. This work was also aided in part by the Marie Curie Fellowship Program, contract number HPMT-CT-2000-00079.
References [1] J. Boussinesq. Theorie de l'6coulement tourbillant. MOm. PrOs. par div. savant a lacad, sci. Paris, 23:46, 1877.
[2] I. Had~i6, K. Hanjali6, and D. Laurence. Modeling the response of turbulence subjected to cyclic irrotational strain. Physics offluids, 13(6):1740-1747, 2001.
[3] R Durbin. Near-wall turbulence closure modelling without 'damping functions'. Theoretical and computational fluid dynamics, 3:1-13, 1991.
[4] F. R. Menter. Two-equation eddy-viscosity turbulence models for engineering applications.
AIAA J.,
32:1598-1605, 1992.
[5] V. Guimet and D. Laurence. In A linearised turbulent production in the k - E model for engineering applications, 2002. ETMM5, Mallorca, Spain.
[6] B. Basara and S. Jakirli6. A new hybrid turbulence modelling strategy for industrial cfd. Int. J. Numer. Meth. Fluids, 42:89-116, 2003.
126
[7] S. Benhamadouche and D. Laurence. Les, course les, and transient rans comparisons on the flow across a tube bundle. International Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow, 2003. [8] P. R. Spalart, W.-H. Jou, M. Strelets, and S. R. Allmaras. In C. Liu and Z. Liu, editors, Comments on the Feasability of LES for Wings, and on a Hybrid RANS/LES Approach, Rushton, LA, 1997. First AFOSR International Conference on DNS/LES 4-8 August. [9] Y. Hoarau, M. Braza, P. Rodes, G. Tzabiras, C. Allain, D. Favier, E. Berton, and M. Maresca. Turbulence modelling of unsteady flows with a pronounced periodic character around an airfoil. In Proceedings, IUTAM symposium "Unsteady Separated Flows ", Toulouse, France, 2002. [10] A. Scotti and U. Piomelli. Numerical simulation of pulsating turbulent channel flow. Physics of Fluids, 13(5):1367-1384, 2001. [11] A. Scotti and U. Piomelli. Turbulence models in pulsating flows. AIAA Paper, (2001-0729), 2001. [12] C. G. Speziale, S. Sarkar, and T. B. Gatski. Modeling the pressure strain correlation of turbulence: an invariant dynamical systems approach. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 227:245-272, 1991. [13] W. Rodi. Theprediction offree turbulent boundary layers by use of a two equation model of turbulence. PhD thesis, University of London, 1975. [ 14] W. Rodi. A new algebraic relation for calculating the Reynolds stresses. Z. A ngew. Math. Mech, 56:219-221, 1976. [15] S. Wallin and A. V. Johansson. An explicit algebraic stress model for incompressible and compressible turbulent flows. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 403:89-132, 2000. [16] T. J. Craft, B. E. Launder, and K. Suga. Development and application of cubic eddy-viscosity model of turbulence. International Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow, 17:108-115, 1996. [ 17] B.E. Launder and B. I. Sharma. Application of the energy-dissipation model of turbulence to the calculation of flow near a spinning disk. Letters in Heat and Mass Transfer, 1:131-138, 1974. [18] F. Archambeau, N. Mechitoua, and M. Sakiz. A finite volume method for the computation of turbulent incompressible flows - industrial applications. International Journal on Finite Volumes, to be published. [19] N. Jarrin, S. Benhamadouche, Y. Addad, and D. Laurence. Synthetic turbulent inflow conditions for large eddy simulation. In Turbulence, Heat and Mass Transfer, Volume 4, Beggel House, Inc., 2003. [20] S. Benhamadouche, K. Mahesh, and G. Constantinescu. Collocated finite volume schemes for les on unstructured meshes. In CTR. Proceedings of the 2002 Summer Program, Stanford, 2002. [21] M. Braza and Y. Hoarau. Prediction of the unsteady 3d flow past a naca0012 wing beyond stall by des-oes approach. In Notes on Numerical Fluid Mechanics and Interdisciplinary Design - FLOMANIA European program, 2005. [22] R. Perrin, M. Braza, E. Cid, S. Cazin, F. Moradei, A. Barthet, Y. Sevrain, and Y. Hoarau. Near-wake turbulence properties in the high reynolds incompressible flow around a circular cylinder by 2c and 3c piv. In Procs. ETMM6 Conf., 2005.
Engineering Turbulence Modelling and Experiments 6 W. Rodi (Editor) 9 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
127
TURBULENCE M O D E L L I N G OF S T A T I S T I C A L L Y P E R I O D I C FLOWS: T H E C A S E OF T H E S Y N T H E T I C JET S. Carpy and R. Manceau Laboratoire d'Etudes A~rodynamiques UMR 6609, University of Poitiers/CNRS/ENSMA, France
ABSTRACT
Computations of a synthetic jet are performed with usual RANS-equations solved in a timeaccurate mode (URANS), with the standard k-c model and the Rotta+IP second moment closure. The purpose of the present work is to investigate the ability of these standard turbulence models to close the phase-averaged Navier-Stokes equations. Results are compared with recent experiments by Yao et al. provided to the CFD Validation of Synthetic Jets and Turbulent Separation Control workshop held in 2004. Comparisons of the performance of the models with experimental data show that the models are globally able to reproduce the dynamics of the flow. However, several characteristics are not well predicted, e.g., convection velocities and spreading rates. Moreover, results suggest that second moment closure is the minimum modelling level suitable for pulsed flows: regions of negative production play a significant role, and their prediction requires to solve transport equation for the Reynolds stresses. KEYWORDS
Turbulence modelling, URANS, Synthetic Jet, Statistical Unsteadiness, Control 1
INTRODUCTION
Although statistical turbulence modelling (RANS) represents the current industrial standard, there is a considerable interest in the possibility of obtaining informations on the large-scale unsteadiness. As long as Large Eddy Simulation will remain too expensive for overnight simulations, some room exists for the development of less expensive methods able to predict the very large scales of the flow. This type of approaches have important applications in different domains: among others, aeronautics [11, 17], control [12, 15], aeroacoustics [4], power generation [7] and environment [19] can be cited. In many statistically steady flows, as soon as the time derivatives are included in the equations, unsteady RANS solutions appear naturally [6, 8, 14, 16-18, 20]. In this case, long-time-averaged solutions are often better than solutions obtained by steady-state computations [10, 16]. However, there is no clear consensus on the definition of the mean operator for this type of computations: the definition of the turbulent scales resolved by the method is not a priori known. Recent approaches, like Semi-Deterministic Modelling (SDM) [3, 4], Very-Large-Eddy Simulation (VLES) [25], Detached-Eddy Simulation (DES) [24], Limited Scales simulations (LNS) [5] or Partially-averaged Navier-Stokes modelling (PANS) [13], are designed in order to ensure unsteady solutions, but do not address the theoretical problem of the significance of the solution. In the present study, the flow belongs to the class of statistically periodic flows, i.e., flows in which the boundary conditions are periodic in time. The use of RANS models does not raise any theoretical issue in this case, since Reynolds average is equivalent to phase average. However, obtaining
128
a periodic solution is not guaranteed: some frequencies can appear that are not harmonics of the forcing frequency. Moreover, while the relative performance of the numerous turbulence models available have been investigated extensively in statistically steady flows, their ability to close successfully the phaseaveraged equations in periodic flows have received much less attention, and generally for modified versions of the models [9, 26, 27]. Therefore, a workshop dedicated to the evaluation of modelling strategies in statistically periodic flows was recently organized [28]. The present study focuses on the comparison of the performance of first and second moment closures" the standard k-e model and the R o t t a + I P second moment closure are used, without any case-specific modification. Standard wall functions are applied since near-wall regions do not play a significant role. The flow studied in the present paper is one of the test cases selected for the workshop [28]. The flow consists in an oscillatory jet with zero-net-mass flow issuing into quiescent air. This flow is of high industrial interest, in particular in the frame of turbulence control, since it is representative of MEMS piezoelectric technology, as developed by Steifert e t al. [23] and Amitay e t al. [1].The experiments used as reference in the present study were performed at NASA LaRC by Yao e t al. [29] and are available on the web site of the workshop [28]. Notation
In such a problem, it is convenient to introduce two averaging operators: long-time averaging, denoted by . and phase averaging, denoted by <. >. Instantaneous quantities are denoted by stars (u~, p*) and the following definitions are used" Long-time-averaged velocity:
Ui = u i N
Phase-averaged velocity:
(1)
*
Ui = <
ui
>
(2)
In order to avoid confusion with usual notation in RANS modelling, the phase-to-phase fluctuating velocities are denoted by u i l/.
II
*
ui = ui-
*
< ui >
(3)
Thus, in the present periodic case, the transport equations to be solved are those of the phaseaveraged velocity components Ui, those of the Reynolds stresses < u i" u j" > (or of k" = ~1 < u ittu itt > in the frame of the eddy-viscosity model), and of e", the dissipation rate of k". 2
DESCRIPTION DATA
OF THE
GEOMETRY
AND
AVAILABLE
EXPERIMENTAL
The oscillating jet of air emanates from a slot in the floor. The slot is 1.27 mm wide (h) and 28h long, in order to produce a 2-D plane jet at the central plane of the floor. The slot is at the bottom of a cubic enclosed box 480h large, at the centre of the floor and parallel to the sides of the outer walls. The geometry and the coordinate system are shown in Fig. 1. The jet flow is produced by a piezo-electric diaphragm on the side of a narrow cavity under the floor, which is driven at 444.7 Hz. The maximum jet velocity generated could reach 28 m s -1. Although the actuator operating parameters including diaphragm displacement, internal cavity pressure, and internal cavity temperature were monitored to provide boundary conditions for CFD simulations, we have chosen not to model the internal cavity: the present work focuses on the performance of turbulence models, rather than on the other difficult issue of representing a vibrating diaphragm with simple boundary conditions. Computational results in the present paper are compared with the PIV measurements performed by Yao e t al. [29]. Phase-averaged (every 5 deg) and long-time-averaged velocities and Reynoldsstresses (only components in the x - y plane) are available in the window -2.15 < x / h < 3.1, 0.1 < y / h < 6.6, z = 0.
129
Figure i: Geometry, domain size and coordinate system.
Figure 2: Measured vertical velocity over the centre of the slot as a function of phase (x=O, y=O.lmm).
Figure 3: Computational grid. 3
NUMERICAL
METHOD
AND SENSITIVITY STUDIES
Computations are performed using Code_Saturne, a finite volume solver on unstructured grids developed at EDF [2], for vectorial and parallel computing. Space discretization is based on a collocation of all the variables at the centre of gravity of the cells. Velocity/pressure coupling is ensured by the SIMPLEC algorithm, with the Rhie & Chow interpolation in the pressurecorrection step. The Poisson equation is solved using a conjugate gradient method, with diagonal preconditioning. Computations are performed using 4 processors of a PC cluster. This study is performed using usual turbulence models: the standard k-~ model [22] and the R o t t a + I P second moment closure [21].
3.1
Boundary conditions
Since the flow inside the cavity is not solved, unsteady Dirichlet boundary conditions are specified at the slot exit (Fig. 2), which are functions of x and phase: profiles at y/h = 0.08 of the I1_ I I available phase-averaged velocities Ui and Reynolds-stresses
are extracted from PIV data and used as inlet conditions. The missing component < w"2> is reconstructed by assuming w "2 ~ - - ~ u .2 ~. Concerning the dissipation rate s", prescribing an inlet value is already an issue. Indeed, 6'~ obviously varies with time, as well as all the other usual turbulent scales (time scale, length scale, eddy-viscosity). A possible way is to arbitrarily assume that one of them is constant, e.g., the length scale L. A periodic e" can thus be obtained from #' = k"3/2/L. Preliminary computations
130 (not shown here) have indicated that a value of L of the order of magnitude of what can be expected in a fully developed turbulent channel flow (typically one-tenth of the half-width of the slot) gives too much turbulent dissipation (abrupt relaminarization). Therefore, the value of the length scale prescribed in the computations presented here is half the slot width. The necessity of using such a large value is to be linked to the fact that, despite a turbulence rate of 5%, the flow issuing from the cavity is far from being a fully developed turbulent flow: the Reynolds number based on the slot width and the maximum inlet velocity is only 2400, and the geometry of the cavity does not allow the turbulence to reach a spectral equilibrium before issuing from the slot. Solid-wall boundary conditions cannot be used at the remaining boundaries of the domain, since the fluid is considered incompressible: when fluid is blown from the slot, it is necessary to enable an equivalent volume of fluid to go out of the calculation domain in order to satisfy incompressibility. Since the experimental box is huge compared to the size of the slot (480h), a smaller domain was used, as shown in Fig. 1. Outlet boundary conditions are applied at the open boundaries of the domain: as shown in section 3.3, the results are not influenced by this restriction of the domain. During the suction phase of the cycle, fluid enters the domain through these boundaries: Dirichlet boundary conditions are then used for turbulent quantities, using values identical to those used for the initial conditions described just below.
3.2
Initial conditions
Computations are started from rest state Ui = 0, with a low residual turbulence energy ( x / ~ / V m a x =0.05%) and a dissipation rate corresponding to the ratio ~t/~ = 10. Computations are performed from the beginning with central differencing with large time steps (At corresponding to 2.5 deg), which shows the stability of the code (for convenience, time steps are given in degrees throughout the paper, i.e., the value corresponds to 360fAt, where f is the frequency of the jet). When a satisfactory periodic state is reached (after about 15 cycles), the time step is reduced and the computation is run until a new periodic state is obtained. Note that periodicity was only evaluated in the region where the flow is of interest (basically the region in which the results can be compared with experiments): indeed it would take hundreds of cycles to reach a periodic solution in the entire domain.
3.3
S e n s i t i v i t y studies
In order to investigate the influence of the size of the domain, the time-step and the grid, seven different computations were performed with the standard k-c model and the Rotta+IP second moment closure. Conclusions are given below.
Influence of the domain size k"-~" computations were performed using two different domain sizes (small and large, Fig. 1) with the same grid resolution (i.e., for the large domain, cells were added around the grid used for the small domain). The grid covering the small domain is shown in Fig. 3a. Computations were carried out with the same time step corresponding to 2.5 deg. Fig. 4 clearly shows that the restriction of the domain has no effect on the solution, at least in the region of interest. Influence of the time step The influence of the time-step on the solution has been carefully investigated. First, using the coarse grid in the small domain, a progressive reduction of the time step from 2.5 deg to 0.25 deg showed that the solution becomes independent of the time step below a value of 0.5 deg. These conclusion was confirmed using the fine grid, as shows in Fig. 5.
Grid refinement Two different grids (coarse grid: 32900 cells, fine grid: 47610 cells), shown in Fig. 3, are used. Fig. 5 shows that the effect of grid refinement is relatively small: although it is clear that grid convergence is not fully achieved yet, the error is probably not significant enough to influence the
131
Figure 4: Influence of the size of the domain. Velocity Figure 5: Influence of the grid and time step. Velocity profiles in the symmetry plane, profiles in the symmetry plane. main conclusions. Computations that this is indeed the case.
4
on a finer grid will be carried out in the near future to confirm
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Figs. 6 and 7 show comparisons of the isocontours of the vertical phase-averaged velocity V from PIV measurements, k'-z" and RSM computations, for both blowing and suction phases of the cycle (see Fig. 2). It can be seen that the global topology of the phase-averaged flow is well reproduced by both models. The pair of large vortices (Fig. 6) that appears at the beginning of the blowing phase are directly inherited from Navier-Stokes dynamics: the turbulence models do not play a role in their creation. However, the models influence the evolution of these vortices, and the Reynolds-stress model produces a more realistic picture. It is seen that the turbulence models play the role that is expected in this type of flow. The resolved velocity field Vi is indeed free from turbulent eddies" Vi represents only the oscillating motion induced by the diaphragm. During the suction phase of the cycle, Fig. 7 shows that the fluid is mainly sucked from the sides. This explains why in Fig. 2, the integral of the curve is not zero: what is plotted is the velocity at the centre of the slot, at the elevation y - 0.08h. Since fluid is mainly blown at the centre of the slot and sucked from the sides, a very significant part of the fluid that enters the cavity during the suction phase is not seen at that point. Therefore, computations cannot be performed using uniform profiles (independent of x): it is necessary to base the inlet conditions on profiles extracted from the PIV velocity fields, as is done in the present study. The global mass flux in the computations are thus nearly zero. This characteristic behaviour of the flow is confirmed by Fig. 8, in which long-time-averaged velocity fields are shown. It clearly appears that the fluid tends to issue from the cavity at the centre of the slot and to enter from the sides. Both models (eddy-viscosity and Reynolds stress models) correctly reproduce this behaviour. Fig. 9 shows profiles in the symmetry plane of the phase-averaged velocity V. It appears that the k'-~" model predicts a much too rapid decrease of the peak velocity, and, in particular, is unable to reproduce the acceleration above the slot which is shown in the P IV data: the velocity at the slot exit reaches its maximum 28.3 m s -1 at phase 45 deg (see Fig. 2) and, at phase 90 deg, the peak velocity around 4 mm (3.15h) is close to 35 m s -1. The "fluid particle" with the maximum velocity at phase 90 deg has been experiencing an acceleration since it issued from the slot. Fig. 9 shows that this behaviour is reproduced, but underestimated, by the Reynolds stress model. The convection velocity of the peak is also underestimated. In order to investigate this major difference between the two models, it is convenient to focus on
132
Figure 6" Contours of phase-averaged velocity V at phase 90 (dashed lines = negative contours).
Figure 7: Contours of phase-averaged velocity V at phase 225 (dashed lines = negative contours).
Figure 8: Contours, vectors and streamlines of long-time-averaged velocity.
133
30
\ ~
i .%. 90deg 135deg 45deg ,.'." ~ ~ 180d ,, : , . , - ' , : eg
,,:
20
i
',-,, :', :./--~, J .-" ' , ,/.. ', .~270deg V'/ ',/ ", ," ,~L-, ,~l , i
~' ,, ~
~," ,^
PIV
___
-
co Im r
,
9~
315deg 0 'o 1
.
.
.
........
P/I
30000
20000 10000
o -...........
-10000 0.005 '
.
40000
~7 *,
.
5OOOO
RSM
'~ ,'', , ;, ~,(, , , , .
.
6OO0O
k'-e
0 -10
,.:
i +
0.015 '
-20000
0.o 2
y (m)
Figure 9: Comparisons of velocity profiles in the symmetry plane,
i
O.OOl
i
0.002
i
0.003
i
0.004
i
0.005
y (m)
i
0.006
i
0.007
i
0.008
i
0.009
0.01
Figure10: Production tensor and Pk" along the centreline (x=O) at phase 60, RSM.
the material derivative of the velocity in the symmetry plane x = O" dV
013
dt =
Oy + ~ OxkOx-----~
02V
0 < v "2 >
Oy
(4)
Acceleration results from a competition between pressure gradient, viscous diffusion and Reynolds stress. The main difference between the two models obviously lies in the Reynolds stress tensor. Indeed, Figs. 10 and 11 show that the Reynolds stress model predicts a region of negative production right above the slot. In the present 2-D case, using the incompressibility condition, the production of k" reduces to:
OV =<
>
v,,2 <
0V > -fly
u"v" <
(OU >
OV) +
(5)
In the symmetry plane, the last term is zero because < u"v" > = 0. Fig. 10 shows that the first term is positive and the second term is negative. This is a direct consequence of the unsteadiness of the boundary conditions. Indeed, since the velocity at the slot exit decreases rapidly after phase 45 deg, the partial derivative OV/Oy at phases > 45 deg is positive between the slot exit (y - 0 mm) and the location of the peak velocity: for instance, it is seen in Fig. 9 that at phase 90 deg, OV/Oy is positive between y = 0 mm and y ~ 4 mm. Therefore, in or close to the symmetry plane, the second term of Eq. (5) is necessarily negative, and leads to a decrease of < v ''2 >, since this term is actually ~P22. 1 On the contrary, the first term, which is 1Pll, is positive. The production of k" is negative because < v"2> is larger than < u"2> in the jet. It is thus clear that in such a flow, the combination of anisotropy in the jet and decrease of the velocity at the slot exit after the maximum necessarily implies negative production. Kinetic energy is thus transfered from turbulence to the oscillating motion through the component < v 'a >. The other components < u "2 > and < w "2 > also lose their energy via redistribution to < v ''2 >. The k"-e" model is unable to predict negative production, which has two direct consequences. Firstly, instead of providing energy to the oscillating motion, turbulence increases rapidly and changes the sign of the momentum budget Eq. (4). The previously quoted increase of the peak velocity between phases 45 deg and 90 deg is then missed" the peak velocity is much too weak, as seen in Fig. 9, which leads to too short a penetration of the jet into the quiescent air. The second consequence is a strong overestimation of the turbulence kinetic energy, as shown in Fig. 12. The RSM also predicts regions of negative production at the periphery of the large eddies (Fig. 1 la). A detailed analysis shows that production in these regions are dominated by the first two terms in Eq. (5)" < u"2> - < v"~> is negative and OV/Oy is positive. Anisotropy is transported here
134
Figure II: Contours of Pk" and velocity vectors at phase=6Odeg.
Figure
12:
Contours of
kn
at phase=6Odeg.
from the region of the symmetry plane where it is produced. The k"-c" model is of course unable to capture such a mechanism. Finally, Fig. 13 shows profiles of long-time averaged velocity V. Surprisingly, despite the strong overestimation of k", the k " - ~ '' model reproduces the spreading of the jet better than the RSM. This is a good example of the beneficial effect of the compensation of errors. 5
CONCLUSIONS
The synthetic jet studied in the present work is a very challenging test case for statistical modelling. The work was dedicated to the investigation of the relative performance of two closure levels: eddyviscosity and Reynolds-stress models. The results show that the global dynamics of the flow is reproduced: the generation of large-scale periodic contra-rotating vortices, and the fact that fluid is mainly blown close to the symmetry plane and sucked from the sides. This is not surprising, since these mechanisms are directly inherited by the phase-averaged equations from Navier-Stokes dynamics. The solutions are free from turbulent eddies (i.e.,represent only the oscillating motion),
135 i
~,
_ y=8mm
.
i~'~,~~_
+
PIV
. ..
RSM
............
__y-6~m__
.
.
y=2mm
.
.
.
.
t -0.01
-0.005
0.005
0.01
Figure 13: Long-time-averaged V-velocity profiles for different values of y.
which are completely accounted for by the models: this shows that the standard models derived for statistically steady flows are suitable for flows treated with phase averaging (at least for the present case). However, the models are far from predicting correctly all the features of the flow. The k"-#' model predicts a much too high turbulence energy, a rapid decrease of the peak velocity, and, consequently, too short a penetration of the jet into quiescent air. The Reynolds-stress model gives a much more realistic solution, but slightly underestimates the peak velocities, the convection velocity and the spreading rate of the jet. The analysis of the turbulence production mechanisms shows that the k"-# ~ model is not suitable for this type of flows (for unsteady flows?): in the region just above the slot, when the inlet velocity decreases, turbulence production is necessarily negative, which is reproduced by the Reynoldsstress model. Using the linear Boussinesq equation yields a strong positive turbulence production, which is sufficient to change the sign of the momentum budget. Moreover, regions of negative turbulence production appear at the periphery of the large-scale eddies, which are due to the transport of anisotropy from the symmetry plane to the eddies. This mechanism suggests that second moment closure is the minimum level of modelling suitable for this flow, since transport of anisotropy cannot be reproduced by nonlinear eddy-viscosity and algebraic models. However, the origin of the deficiencies of the Reynolds-stress model are not clarified yet: they could be linked to the particular form of the Rotta+IP model (redistribution, turbulent diffusion), but they could also suggest that nonequilibrium models, such as two-scale models [9, 26], are necessary. REFERENCES
[1] M. Amitay, D.R. Smith, D.E. Kibens Vand Parekh, and A. Glezer. Modification of the aerodynamics characteristics of an unconventional airfoil using synthetic jet actuators. AIAA Journal, 39:3:361370, 2001. [2] F. Archambeau, N. Mehitoua, and M. Sakiz. Code Saturne: A finite volume code for the computation of turbulent incompressible flows- Industrial applications. Int. J. on Finite Volume, Electronical edition: http ://averoes. math. univ-paris13, ff /html, ISSN 1634(0655), 2004. [3] S. Aubrun, P. L. Kao, H. Ha Minh, and H. Boisson. The semi-deterministic approach as way to study coherent structures. Case of a turbulent flow behind a backward-facing step. In Proc. fourth Int. Syrup. Engng. Turb. Modelling and Measurements, Ajaccio, Corsica, France, pages 491-499, 1999. [4] F. Bastin, P. Lafon, and S. Candel. Computation of jet mixing noise due to coherent structures: the plane jet case. J. Fluid Mech., 335:261-304, 1997. [5] P. Batten, U. Goldberg, and S. Chakravarthy. LNS-An approach towards embedded LES. AIAA paper 2002-0427, AIAA 40th Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit, Reno, Nevada, 2002. [6] S. Benhamadouche and D. Laurence. LES, coarse LES, and transient RANS comparisons on the flow across a tube bundle. In W. Rodi and N. Fueyo, editors, Proc. 5th Intl. Syrup. Engng. Turb. Modelling and Measurements, Mallorca, Spain. Elsevier, 2002.
136 [7] S. Benhamadouche and D. Laurence. LES, coarse LES, and transient RANS. Comparisons on the flow across a tube bundle. Int. J. Heat Fluid Flow, 24:470-479, 2003. [8] G. Bosch and W. Rodi. Simulation of vortex shedding past a square cylinder near a wall. Int. J.
Heat Fluid Flow, 17:267-275, 1996. [9] K. Bremhorst, T. J. Craft, and B. E. Launder. Two-time-scale turbulence modelling of a fully-pulsed axisymmetric air jet. In Proc. 3rd Int. Syrnp. Turb. Shear Flows and Phenomena, Sendai, Japan, pages 711-716, 2003. [10] P. A. Durbin. Separated flow computations with the k-e-v: model. AIAA J., 33"659-664, 1995. [11] T. B. Gatski. DNS/LES for NASA aerodynamic needs and engineering applications. In C.L. Liu, L. Sakell, and T. Beutner, editors, DNS/LES-Progress and Challenges, pages 25-34. Greyden Press, Columbus, Ohio, 2001. [12] N. Getin. Simulation nurndrique du contr6le actif par jet pulsds de l'dcoulernent turbulent autour d'un cylindre circulaire. PhD thesis, Ecole Centrale de Lyon, 2000. [13] S. S. Girimaji, R. Srinivasan, and E. Jeong. PANS turbulence model for seamless transition between RANS and LES: Fixed-point analysis and preliminary results. In Proc. 4th ASME_JSME Joint Fluids Engineering Conference, Honolulu, Hawaii, USA, 2003. [14] H. Ha Minh and A. Kourta. Semi-deterministic modelling for flows dominated by strong organized structures. In Proc. 9th Int. Syrnp. Turbulent Shear Flows, Kyoto, Japan, 1993. [15] A.A. Hassan and R.D Janakiram. Effects of zero-mass synthetic jets on the aerodynamics of the NACA-0012 airfoil. AIAA Paper 97-2326, 1997. [16] G. Iaccarino and P. Durbin. Unsteady 3D RANS simulations using the v2-f model. In Ann. Res. Briefs, pages 263-269. Center for Turbulence Research, Stanford University, 2000. [17] G. Jin and M. Braza. Two-equation turbulence model for unsteady separated flows around airfoils. AIAA J., 32(11):2316-2322, 1994. [18] S. Johansson, L. Davidson, and E. Olsson. Numerical simulation of vortex shedding past triangular cylinders at high Reynolds number using a k-e turbulence model. Intl J. Nurner. Meth. in Fluids, 16(10):859-878, 1993. [19] S. Kenjere~, K. Hanjali6, and G. Krstovi6. Combined effets of terrain orography and thermal stratification on pollutant distribution in a town valley: a T-RANS simulation. In Proc. Second Int. Syrnp. Turb. Shear Flow Phenomena, Stockholm, Sweden, volume 1, pages 103-108, 2001. [20] W. C. Lasher and D. B. Taulbee. On the computation of turbulent backstep flow. Int. J. Heat Fluid Flow, 13:30-40, 1992. [21] B. E. Launder, G. J. Reece, and W. Rodi. Progress in the development of a Reynolds-stress turbulence closure. J. Fluid Mech., 68(3):537-566, 1975. [22] B. E. Launder and D. B. Spalding. The numerical computation of turbulent flows. Cornp. Meth. Appl. Mech. Engng., 3(2):269-289, 1974. [23] A. Seifert, T. Bachar, D. Koss, M. Shepshelovich, and I. Wygnanski. Oscillatory blowing, a tool to delay boundary-layer separation. AIAA Paper 31-2052, 1993. [24] P.R. Spalart, W.-H. Jou, M. Strelets, and S.R. Allmaras. Comments on the feasibility of LES for wings, and on a hybrid RANS/LES approach. In C. Liu and Z. Liu, editors, First AFOSR International Conference on DNS/LES, 4-8 August, Ruston, LA, Advances in DNS/LES, Greyden Press, Columbus, OH, USA, 1997. [25] C. G. Speziale. Turbulence modeling for time-dependent RANS and VLES: a review. AIAA J., 36(2):173, 1998. [26] K. Stawiarski and K. Hanjalic. A two-scale second-moment one-point turbulence closure. In Proc. 5th Int. Syrnp. Engng Turb. Modelling and Measurements, Mallorca, Spain, 2002. [27] S. Tardu and P. Da Costa. Modeling of unsteady turbulent wall flows with and without adverse pressure gradient by a k-omega/rapid distorsion model. In Proc. Second Int. Syrnp. Turb. Shear Flow Phenomena, Stockholm, Sweden, volume 1, pages 205-210, 2001. [28] Workshop on CFD validation of synthetic jets and turbulent separation control. http://cfdval2004.1arc.nasa.gov/. [29] C. Yao, F.J. Chen, D. Neuhart, and J. Harris. Synthetic jet flow field database for CFD validation. AIAA Paper 2004-2218, 2004.
Engineering Turbulence Modelling and Experiments 6 W. Rodi (Editor) 9 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
137
B E H A V I O U R OF T U R B U L E N C E M O D E L S N E A R A TURBULENT/NON-TURBULENT INTERFACE REVISITED P. Ferrey a and B. Aupoix ~ aONERA/DMAE Centre d'I~tudes et de Recherches de Toulouse B.P. 4025, 2, Avenue l~douard Belin 31055 Toulouse CEDEX 4, France e-mail: [email protected]
ABSTRACT The behaviour of turbulence models near a turbulent/non-turbulent interface is investigated. The analysis holds as well for two-equation as for Reynolds stress turbulence models using Daly and Harlow diffusion model. The behaviour near the interface is shown not to be a power law, as usually considered, but a more complex parametric solution. Why previous works seemed to numerically confirm the power law solution is explained. Constraints for turbulence modelling, i.e. for ensuring that models have a good behaviour near a turbulent/non-turbulent interface so that the solution is not sensitive to small turbulence levels imposed in the irrotational flow, are drawn.
KEYWORDS Eddy viscosity models, Model constraints, Reynolds stress models, Turbulence Modelling
1
INTRODUCTION
A well-known drawback of some turbulence models such as the Wilcox (1988) k - w model, the Smith (1995) k - L model or the Baldwin and Barth (1991) one-equation model is that the solution is sensitive to the small level of transported turbulent quantities imposed outside of the turbulent regions. Indeed, for low turbulence levels outside of the boundary or free shear layers, turbulence should propagate from the turbulent regions towards the non-turbulent regions, a condition which is violated by these models. The solution thus depends upon the small level of eddy viscosity outside of the turbulent region, i.e. upon the external turbulence length scale. Such an unphysical behaviour cannot be accepted as the numerical solutions are thus unreliable. The real physical behaviour near a turbulent/non-turbulent interface is rather complex, with an
138
interface which is highly corrugated and induces fluctuations in the irrotational, non-turbulent field. Describing it is out of the capabilities of standard turbulence models which all more or less rely upon turbulence equilibrium assumptions. Therefore, all what is required is that the turbulence model correctly propagates information from the turbulent towards the non-turbulent region to avoid undesirable free-stream sensitivity.
2
STANDARD
ANALYSIS
For the sake of simplicity, only incompressible flows will be addressed. The behaviour near a turbulent/non-turbulent interface was first addressed by Saffman (1970) and deeper investigated by Cazalbou et al. (1994) for eddy-viscosity models. The analysis has been extended to Reynolds stress models by Cazalbou and Chassaing (2002). They showed that, near the interface, the problem should reduce to a convection/diffusion equilibrium and that source terms in the turbulence transport equation should be negligible. The problem is investigated in a reference frame linked to the interface. The ordinate y is along the normal to the average interface and the relevant length is )~ = Y e - y, i.e. the distance to the turbulent/non-turbulent interface. A defect form for the velocity profile is considered as W = u e - u, ue being the velocity in the non-turbulent region. In the turbulent region, the solution of the simplified transport equations for mean defect velocity W, turbulent stresses u i~u j~, turbulent kinetic energy k and e.g. turbulent dissipation rate c is sought for as power laws as: W = Au~ ~
u~u~ = Auu)~ ~k
k = Ak)~ ~k
c = A~)~ ~
The A are undetermined scaling factors and the exponents c~ should be positive for the turbulence to propagate towards the non-turbulent region and larger than unity to achieve a smooth matching with the external flow. These power-law behaviours as well as the constraints on the coefficients were validated by numerical computations. Moreover, for Reynolds stress models, Flachard (2000) and Cazalbou and Chassaing (2002) pointed out the importance of the diffusion model in the behaviour near the interface. For example, Hanjalid and Launder (1972) diffusion model induces a strong and unrealistic turbulence anisotropy near the interface while a good behaviour is obtained with Daly and Harlow (1970) model.
3 3.1
PRESENT Turbulence
ANALYSIS models
However, it turned out that the above analysis is too simple and has to be revisited. The present analysis holds as well for two-equation models, whatever the constitutive relation (eddy viscosity, non-linear eddy viscosity or explicit algebraic Reynolds stress model) as for full Reynolds stress models. For that, generic models, following Catris and Aupoix (2000), are introduced. Two-equation models solve two transport equations, generally for the turbulent kinetic energy k and an arbitrary length scale determining variable (I) = k m c n. Following Catris and Aupoix (2000), a generic model reads:
139
Dk O( Ok) D---t= Pk - e + ~ Dkkut-~z k
(1) (2)
+C,~r
O~ 0,~ ut Ok O~ ut'~ Ok Ok (~ Oxk Oxk + Cck k Oxk Oxk + C~k k 2 0 x k Oxk
This is a generic form as the transport equation for any combination of k and (I), deduced from the above equations, has the same form as equation (2), its constants being linked to those of equations (1) and (2). Compared to Catris and Aupoix (2000), a diffusion term has been dropped in the turbulent kinetic energy transport equation for the sake of simplicity. These transport equations have to be coupled with a constitutive relation, of the eddy viscosity form, either linear or non-linear. Similarly, for Reynolds stress models, the generic transport equations read:
DuiUJDt = Pij + IIij - cij + ~
Dkk~uku z Oxi
(3)
(4) O~ . .-7~_., 0 ~
+Cee 5 u2
C
1 Ok _.-v-~.., O,~
,~ 9 Ok ~
Ok
-5-~x~'~ + ~ - i - ~ x ~ ' ~ + c;~-5-~x~ Ox~
where Piy, IIij and eij respectively stand for the Reynolds stress production, redistribution and destruction terms the form of which is not of concern here. Following Cazalbou and Chassaing (2002) conclusions, the analysis is restricted to Daly and Harlow (1970) diffusion model.
3.2
E q u a t i o n s in the vicinity of the turbulent region edge
A complete derivation of the equations can be found in Ferrey (2004). Either a time evolving flow, as in Cazalbou et al. (1994) or a spatially evolving flow, as here, can be considered. For the analysis, it is more convenient to use, as length scale determining variable, the eddy viscosity ut or v'gA for Reynolds stress models. Considering a two-equation model, a two-dimensional steady E flow, neglecting viscosity and introducing g = - Dkk-~, Vo where V0 is the velocity component normal to the interface, the equation system for the momentum and transport equations reduces to:
dW d(dW) Dkk dA = d-"~ g ~
(5)
dk d(dk) d---~= d---~ g--~
D~~ = d(
(6)
dg
g~dk)
( dg) ~
g dg dk
(~ dk)
(7)
In the above equations, the problem has been assumed to reduce to an advection/diffusion equilibrium, so that source terms have been dropped in the turbulence transport equation. This has however to be checked and leads to other constraints for the model (see, e.g. Cazalbou et al. (1994)), not to be discussed here.
140
The boundary conditions at the interface are: lim W = 0 lim k = 0 limg = 0 A--~0
A--~0
(8)
A---,0
Integrating equation (6) with the above boundary conditions yields: Dkk g=--~o ut=
k dk
(9)
dA
Introducing the above relation into equation (7) leads to the following relation" ag-~+b
+c~-~ + d =
-~
(~o)
0
where the coefficients a, b, c and d are linked to the diffusions coefficients C and D as: a :
b -- --(Dut~,t + Cvtpt)
-Dutut
C :
--(Cutk
+ Dutk -- D k k )
d = -Cs
(11)
As model coefficients are interrelated when the length scale determining variable is changed, these coefficients can be expressed, referring to a k - e model form, as: a = - D~
b = D~ + C~
c = - 4 ( D ~ + C ~ ) + Dkk -- D~k -- C~k
(12)
d = 4 (D~ + C~) + 2(D~k + C~k - Dkk) + C~k The same analysis holds for a Reynolds stress model, using Daly and Harlow diffusion. This is due to the fact, pointed out by Cazalbou and Chassaing (2002) that, using this diffusion model, the anisotropy levels are constants in the turbulent region below the turbulent/non-turbulent interface. Therefore, the same expressions for the a, b, c and d coefficients are retrieved. The analysis is also similar for non-linear eddy viscosity models or explicit algebraic Reynolds stress models since they predict an isotropic state near the interface where the velocity gradient tend towards zero and reduce to a modified eddy viscosity model for the turbulent shear stress --U/V/.
It must be pointed out that, to prevent counter-gradient diffusion, a has to be negative. Moreover, writing the model balance in the logarithmic region, it is easily checked that b is positive. 3.3
Solutions
near the turbulent
r e g i o n edge
Equation (10) has two obvious solutions such that ~dA2 = 0, which correspond to a linear profile for the eddy viscosity. From relation (9), these solutions correspond to power law solutions for the turbulent kinetic energy profile. They read: A
1
u
m
(13)
ozk
~k
ct k+ -
A
g=~
c+x/'--A ~
1
2b
ak
c-
x/~
A = c 2 - 4bd
2b
The power law solution found by Cazalbou et al. (1994) is retrieved together with a second power law solution which has already been pointed out by Catris (1999) and Catris and Aupoix (2000). As the transformed eddy viscosity g is linear, it must be pointed out that the length scale deter-
141
mining variable and turbulent kinetic energy evolutions are linked, as pointed out by Daris (2002) and Aupoix et al. (2003), as: 2a~ m OL~+ --" 1 (14) The new and important point is that equation (10) has a third solution, which can only be expressed in parametric form, the parameter being rn = ~ , as"
I
l
fl+ I
a(rn)=clm--G_ with
1
il-
{ __11~-( _ ~__ff)l (
g ( m ) = Go m - -2-4
F ( x ) = Hypergeom
m - --
F
fl+ =
a
a
/3- =
v/-~a k
(15) (16)
rn
+
O~k Ot k X
/3-, 1 - fl+, 1 +/3-; a~- - a k
)
where Gauss' hypergeometric function is defined as: +~C(a+k) C(b+k) V(c) x k Hypergeom(a, b, c; z) = y~ r (a) r (b) r (c + k) k--~
(17)
k=0
i 11
Similarly, the turbulent kinetic energy profile can be expressed as: a
k(~) = Ko
(18)
1k m
a~-
The velocity profile can be linked to the turbulent kinetic energy profile. For eddy viscosity models, equations (5) and (6) can be integrated, using boundary conditions (8), as: dW D k k W = g ---d-A
dk k = g --d-f
(19)
so that, eliminating g, W = k~
(20)
For Reynolds stress models, the momentum equation reduces to: dW Vo---dA
du'v'
(21)
dA
so that, as the anisotropy levels tend towards constants near the interface:
(22)
W oc u'v' cx k 3.4
Behavior
of the parametric
solution
This parametric solution is the only relevant solution as a small perturbation of the linear solutions of equation (10) will lead to ~d)~ 2 7~ 0 and thus to the parametric solution. The boundary conditions at the interface (8) and the above solutions for k (18) or A (16) show that the interface corresponds to m = --1_. As, near the interface, V0 is negative and therefore g o~k
is positive and tends towards zero at the interface, m = ~ must be positive so that a~- must be positive.
142
14 1
3"
Vt
o,..:l.i. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . o
1
z
3
4
5
6
,,
7
oz
o4
o6
Decreasing rn
oo
1
lz
14
1.5
1B
Z
Increasing rn
Squares: a k- solution
-
Dashed-dotted line: a k+solution
Figure 1" Solutions for the eddy viscosity profile near the interface when both exponents are positive J 0 li] V t
m [] [] [] o m
vt 0Z 0
t4
--'''Z
~
....
4 ....
; ....
; ....
1'0 . . . .
1'2 . . . .
I~I""
i
-0
Increasing rn Decreasing rn Squares: c~[ solution
Dashed-dotted line: c~k+solution
Figure 2: Solutions for the eddy viscosity profile near the interface when only one exponent is positive Two cases must be considered, whether c~k+ is positive or negative, its sign being that of d. If + c~k+ is positive, it is obvious from its definition (13) t h a t c~k > c~[. Two behaviours are possible according to the sign of dd-"~m _- - ~dA 2" If it is negative, rn decreases from 1a k to ~--ff' 1 for which the transformed eddy viscosity g is infinite. As m = ~ , the g evolution asymptotes the two power law solutions (13) for )~ ~ 0 and )~ ~ co. This is the situation depicted in the left part of figure 1. If d___~ is positive, g blows out rapidly and only has an a s y m p t o t e for A ~ 0. dA Similar behaviours are observed if c~k+ is negative. If rn decreases the g profile asymptotes both power law solutions, so t h a t g rapidly becomes negative while it blows out if rn increases, as shown in figure 2. Unfortunately, no way to determine the sign of -aT dm has been found. 3.5
Numerical
solutions
The occurrence of this parametric solution have been checked using a code solving the selfsimilarity equations for various simple flows such as the outer region of the b o u n d a r y layer, the
143
wake, the mixing layer and the plane or round jets (B~zard, 2000). As self-similarity reduces the equation set to a one-dimensional problem, which is solved using a time marching technique, grid convergence is easily achieved. An example of result is provided in figure 3 where the "eddy vis-
012 011
~
--
01 0.09 0 08 007 >'006 0 05 0.04 003
-
0 02
~ ..
/
001 0 0
005
011
0.~5
n
Figure 3: Solution of the "eddy viscosity" profile in the vicinity of the interface when the exponents c~ are positive m
v12 k cosity" --7is plotted for the outer region of the boundary layer, using a Reynolds stress model for which both c~k are positive. The lower figure shows the eddy viscosity profile in self similar coordinates ( uezx ~t versus r/ = ~, where A is here the Clauser's thickness) while the upper figure shows an enlargement of the solution near the interface. The two linear solutions for the eddy viscosity are also plotted. It can be checked that the parametric solution is retrieved and that it asymptotes both linear laws, as in figure 1 (left). As the c~- solution is reached only in the very vicinity of the interface, it explains why previous works concluded that the c~k+ solution was obtained.
As in Cazalbou et al. (1994) analysis, fluid viscosity has been neglected. When it is accounted for, or when a small level of turbulence is present in the irrotational flow, the c~- solution is difficult to observe as it is superseded by the viscous effects or the free-stream condition. Moreover, the c~- solution generally extends over a very restricted (if not null) number of cells with usual grids. For models for which the cross diffusion coefficient C~k is null, which involves most of the classical models, Cazalbou's solution corresponds to the c~+ solution. The other power law solution, which gives the tangent for ~ = 0, corresponds to a ; = 0 and c~- = ~ n (e.g. c~- = 1 for standard k - e models, c~- = 1 for k - w models). Therefore, the length scale determining variable (I) = kme n smoothly tends towards zero.
4
CONSEQUENCES FOR TURBULENCE MODELS
The first important point is that not only c~k+ has to be considered, as previously done by Cazalbou et al. (1994) but also c~- and that c~- also must be positive. This explains why Cazalbou et al. (1994) were unable to apply their analysis to the Ng and Spalding model: among the models they considered, it was the only one for which c~- is negative.
144
0.14 0.13
012
0.12
011
0.11
01
0.1
0 09
0.09
008
0.08
ooOO,
007
!!!
;>" 0.07
>006 0 05
0.04
0
0.03
0 04 0 03 0 02
0.02
001
0.01 ....
i
....
0.2
i
04
.....
- i - , - , - ' - , -
0 6
i-
0.8
'-
r'"
o
'-
.
.
.
.
.
o~,5
.
.
.
.
.
o',
.
.
.
o',5
n
n Figure 4" Sensitivity to free-stream values of the eddy viscosity of a model such that all a are positive
Figure 5: Sensitivity to free-stream values of the eddy viscosity of a model such that all a are not positive
Cazalbou et al. (1994) recommended that a k+ be positive to have the correct information propagation. Among the four possible behaviours depicted in figures 1 and 2, it seems that the case where a + is positive and m is decreasing, where the g evolution asymptotes the a k+ power law, is the only acceptable case. In all other cases, g blows out and a matching with the g profile in the turbulent region, where production and destruction terms are no longer negligible, seems more problematic. Indeed, this is this behaviour that is retrieved in all the numerical simulations. Therefore, it seems that the constraint should be that both ak must be positive, i.e." 1
1
--=_ > 0
~---;>0
Ol k
Ol k
(23)
where inverses are used to discard infinite values for the ak, as suggested by Cazalbou (private communication). Numerical checks tend to support the above conclusion. As an example, "eddy viscosity" \(v'2k) E profiles are plotted for the outer region of a boundary layer, using Reynolds stress models. Different solutions are obtained, always imposing a very small turbulence level outside of the boundary layer but varying the "eddy viscosity" level. In figure 4, both a k are positive and the solution in the boundary layer is insensitive to the imposed "eddy viscosity" level outside. Turbulence propagates from the turbulent region towards the non-turbulent region so that the eddy viscosity first falls to a very small value near the interface before rising again to the value imposed in the external flow. In figure 5, a k+ is negative and the solution is deeply affected by the external "eddy viscosity" level. Turbulence propagates from the external flow into the turbulent region, which is not wanted. It should be pointed out that the above analysis can no longer be strictly applied since the "eddy viscosity" thus no longer tends towards zero at the boundary layer edge. Moreover, for each transported quantity (turbulent kinetic energy, Reynolds stress tensor component, length scale determining variable) the exponent a should be such that source terms are negligible compared to the advection and diffusion terms. This leads to very different constraints according to the constitutive relation. Provided the parametric solution is bounded by the two power law solutions, the analysis is thus similar to the one proposed by Cazalbou et al. (1994).
145
5
s
0)
kx
1
-1
-1
0
1
2
3
I-- ' ' 4
I 5
Of,k
Figure 6: Behaviours of the exponents c~ for several length-scale determining variables
A last point to be mentioned is that the generic character is in some sense lost near the interface. In other words, the choice of the length scale determining variable must be done carefully since, rewriting a model to change the length scale determining variable may affect its behaviour. Indeed, from equation (14), the exponents of the turbulent kinetic energy and the length scale determining variable are interrelated. This link between the exponents c~ is shown in figure 6 for some popular k L e(-~) If only a positive value of length scale determining variables (a~ o( g, ~ o( ~~, T (X ~, the exponents c~k and c~r for the length scale determining variable is looked for, which ensures a correct information propagation, any length scale determining variable can be used, with caution. If at least c~k+ and c~+ are imposed to be higher than unity, to ensure a smooth matching with the _ k 3/2 small external level, ~- c< k or l c< ~ E are forbidden.
5
CONCLUSIONS
The above analysis shows that the behaviour of a turbulence model near a turbulent/non-turbulent interface is more complex than previously considered and that the real solution is not given by power laws but is a parametric solution, which generally seems to asymptote the power laws. This explains why the numerical solutions were confused with the power law solutions. The above analysis holds as well for two-equation models, whatever the constitutive relation, as for Reynolds stress models. It leads to a more complex constraint, imposing that both c~k coefficients must be positive. The analysis still requires to be extended, on the one hand to be able to determine which solution, i.e. increasing or decreasing m is obtained and why and, on the other hand, to account for viscosity and small external turbulence levels.
146
5.1
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to thank DGA (French Ministry of Defence) which granted P. Ferrey's thesis. Part of this work took place within the FLOMANIA project (Flow Physics Modelling- An Integrated Approach) which is a collaboration between Alenia, Ansys-CFX, Bombardier, Dassault, EADS-CASA, EADS-Military Aircraft, EDF, NUMECA, DLR, FOI, IMFT, ONERA, Chalmers University, Imperial College, TU Berlin, UMIST and St. Petersburg State University. This project is funded by the European Union and administrated by the CEC, Research Directorate-general, Growth Programme, under Contract No. G4RD-CT2001-00613.
REFERENCES
B. Aupoix, H. B~zard, S. Catris, and T. Daris. Towards a calibration of the length-scale equation. In J. P~riaux, M. Champion, J.J. Gagnepain, O. Pironneau, B. StouiIlet, and P. Thomas, editors, Fluid Dynamics and Aeronautics New Challenges, pages 327-349. CIMNE, September 2003. B.S. Baldwin and T.J. Barth. A one-equation turbulence transport model for high Reynolds number wall-bounded flows. AIAA Paper 91-0610 29th Aerospace Science Meeting, Reno, Nevada, January 7-10 1991. H. B~zard. Optimisation of two-equation turbulence models. In C. Dopazo, editor, Advances in Turbulence - Proceedings of the Eighth European Turbulence Conference, page 978, Barcelona, June 27-30 2000. S. Catris. Etudes de Contraintes et Qualification de Moddes it Viscosit~ Turbulente. PhD thesis, SUPAERO, Toulouse, 14 Octobre 1999. S. Catris and B. Aupoix. Towards a calibration of the length-scale equation. International Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow, 21(5):606-613, October 2000. J.B. Cazalbou and P. Chassaing. The structure of the solution obtained with Reynolds-stresstransport models at the free-stream edges of turbulent flows. Physics of Fluids, 14(2):597-611, February 2002. J.B. Cazalbou, P.R. Spalart, and P. Bradshaw. On the behavior of two-equation models at the edge of a turbulent region. Physics of Fluids A, 6(5):1797-1804, May 1994. J.B. Daly and F.H. Harlow. Transport equations in turbulence. The Physics of Fluids, 13(11): 2634-2649, November 1970. T. Daris. Etude dc ModUles de Turbulence it Quatre Equations de Transport pour la Pr~vision des Ecoulements Turbulents Faiblement Chauffds. PhD thesis, SUPAERO, Toulouse, France, 12 D~cembre 2002. P. Ferrey. Moddles aux Tensions de Reynolds avec Prise en Compte de l'Intermittence de Fronti~re. PhD thesis, l~cole Nationale Sup~rieure de M~canique A~rothechnique, Poitiers, France, 6 D~cembre 2004. L. Flachard. Etude de Contraintes et Qualification de ModUles aux Tensions de Reynolds. PhD thesis, SUPAERO, Toulouse, 8 Novembre 2000. K. Hanjali5 and B.E. Launder. A Reynolds stress model of turbulence and its application to thin shear flows. Journal of Fluids Mechanics, 52(4):109-638, 1972. P.G. Saffman. A model for inhomogeneous turbulent flows. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, A 317:417-433, 1970. B.R. Smith. Prediction of hypersonic shock wave turbulent boundary layer interactions with the k - 1 two equation turbulence model. AIAA Paper 95-0232 33Td Aerospace Sciences Meeting & Exhibit, Reno, Nevada, January 9-12 1995. D.C. Wilcox. Reassessment of the scale-determining equation for advanced turbulence models. AIAA Journal, 26(11):1299-1310, November 1988.
Engineering Turbulence Modelling and Experiments 6 W. Rodi (Editor) 9 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
147
BEHAVIOUR OF NONLINEAR TWO-EQUATION TURBULENCE MODELS AT THE FREE-STREAM EDGES OF TURBULENT FLOWS A. Hellsten 1 and H. B6zard 2 1 Helsinki University of Technology, Laboratory of Aerodynamics, E O.Box 4400 FIN-02015 HUT, Finland 20NERA - Department of Modelling for Aerodynamics and Energetics B.E 4025, F-31055 Toulouse - CEDEX 4, France
ABSTRACT The behaviour of two-equation turbulence models at the outer edges of turbulent flows is studied in this paper. The focus is on nonlinear models with simple scalar-diffusivity gradient-diffusion model for turbulent transport. Conditions to obtain physically correct smooth solutions at the edge are presented and discussed. A constraint is derived for the diffusion model coefficient for turbulent kinetic energy to guarantee smooth solutions also when nonlinear constitutive models are employed. Finally, the analysis is extended to a case of a generalized gradient-diffusion model.
KEYWORDS Turbulence modelling, Nonlinear two-equation models, Free-stream edge, Turbulent/nonturbulent interface, Model constraints
INTRODUCTION Practical engineering applications of the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) are still largely based on the numerical solution of the Reynolds averaged Navier-Stokes equations (RANS). Turbulent flow problems of engineering interest often feature high Reynolds numbers and are thus difficult if not impossible to solve by means of large eddy simulation, not to mention the direct numerical simulation. Reynolds stress transport modelling is, in principle, the most sophisticated level of RANS modelling available today. In practical work, however, Reynolds stress transport closures are rather seldom used as principal tools. Two-equation eddy-viscosity modelling is still by far the most popular level of RANS
148
turbulence modelling. Two-equation models can be considered to consist of a scale-determining model and of a constitutive model. The former provides two scalar variables, e.g. k and c, solved from their modelled transport equations. The constitutive model provides the Reynolds stress tensor as a function of the turbulent scales and the mean-velocity gradient. The constitutive models range from the simple linear Boussinesq-relation up to high-order tensor-polynomial expressions which can be derived from some underlying stress-transport closure by invoking the weak-equilibrium assumption (explicit algebraic Reynolds stress models, EARSM), or it may be derived on an a d h o c basis (nonlinear eddyviscosity models). Currently, a move from standard linear eddy-viscosity modelling towards nonlinear two-equation models, especially EARSMs, seems to be going on, at least in some areas of fluids-related engineering. This paper deals with the behaviour of scale-determining models near the free-stream edges of turbulent flows especially in connection with nonlinear constitutive models. The turbulent/nonturbulent interface, or in other words the edge between vortical and irrotational fluctuations on the outer edge of turbulent flows is known to be very sharp in reality. Its thickness is determined by the viscosity. The instantaneous shape of this edge is highly irregular and evolves in time along the motion and evolution of the large turbulent structures. This motion induces irrotational potential fluctuations outside the edge (Bisset, Hunt & Rogers 2002). The fact that the real turbulent/nonturbulent interface is very thin may have led to some misinterpretations in the context of RANS-modelling. The Reynolds averaged velocity field shows no sharp edges. Instead, the mean velocity approaches smoothly its free-stream value with no sudden changes in its gradient. This is primarily because the location and position of the actual sharp edge varies in time (which also means that turbulence is observed as intermittent in a fixed-poinI measurement). Moreover, the potential fluctuations outside the actual interface also influence the Reynolds averaged velocity. Therefore, the Reynolds averaged velocity field features a smooth profile with continuous and bounded gradient around the edge. Naturally, RANS turbulence models should be designed keeping this in mind. In contrast to this, models have been proposed that provide sharp outer edges with the velocity gradient tending towards a discontinuity at the edge. Not much attention has been paid to this as the numerical dissipation tends to smear out the edge in practical computations. Some of those scale-determining models that show proper smooth outer-edge behaviour with the linear constitutive model, may predict sharp or even a highly unphysical "hook-shaped" velocity profiles when combined with a nonlinear constitutive model. The theoretical analysis is based on the work of Cazalbou, Spalart & Bradshaw (1994). They found that the model behaviour in the outer-edge region can be analysed using a simplified one-dimensional nonlinear front-propagation problem. This is arrived at by assuming that the turbulent transport governs the time evolution of fronts, while the production and destruction terms are negligible on the edge regions. Cazalbou et al. (1994) mainly analysed the k - c formulation, but they discussed also some k - k L and k - co models. In this study, we reformulated the problem as a steady convection-diffusion problem similarly as Catris & Aupoix (2000). This form can be obtained from the problem of Cazalbou et al. through a simple Galilean transformation. Kok (2000) applied Cazalbou's analysis to design a new k - co model with a cross-diffusion term, i.e. the inner product of the gradients of k and co, added to the co-equation. Cazalbou et al. (1994), Catris & Aupoix (2000) and Kok (2000) studied only linear two-equation modelling. Recently, Cazalbou & Chassaing (2002) have extended this analysis to stresstransport models. To the authors' knowledge, however, this kind of analysis has not been applied to nonlinear two-equation models by other researchers. The present authors have so far presented some special cases. Bdzard & Daris (2005) found, using the original analysis by Cazalbou et al. (1994), that in cases of nonlinear constitutive model, a much stricter constraint must be applied to the diffusion coefficient of turbulent kinetic energy k than in the case of linear constitutive model. This is to ensure that the ratio of production and dissipation of turbulent kinetic energy k remains bounded. Hellsten (2004b) extended the analysis for k - co models with a special case of variable C,. These new theoretical results were then exploited in the development of a new k - co model employing the EARSM developed
149
by Wallin & Johansson (2000) as its constitutive model (Hellsten 2004a, Hellsten 2004b), and in a new k - k L model employing the same constitutive model (B6zard & Daris 2005). In this paper, the analysis is generalized to arbitrary second scale variable r ~ kme n, and applied to a special case of variable C.-coefficient assuming that also C. follows a power function. This is because variable C. is a central feature of nonlinear constitutive models, and essentially the only difference between linear and nonlinear models that has to be taken into account in this level of approximation. The main part of the analysis assumes simple scalar-diffusivity (eddy-viscosity) gradient-diffusion model, but the analysis is also extended to the popular generalized gradient-diffusion model by Daly & Harlow (1970). A constraint is also formulated for the Daly-Harlow model coefficient. The solutions of the idealized edge problem are of a power form, and for certain values of the model coefficients, the solutions are not sufficiently differentiable on the edge. Cazalbou et al. (1994) proved that in such cases the equations have a weak solution. As Cazalbou and Chassaing stated, this (possibly weak) solution cannot be considered as unique, so that its validity must be checked by comparing with numerical solutions. Such comparisons have been made against numerical solutions of self-similar problems as well as those of the full Navier-Stokes equations. In fact, Ferrey and Aupoix found very recently that there, indeed, are two power solutions and also a third solution that generally asymptotes the power solutions (B. Aupoix, private communication 2004). The power solution of the present and the previous work has been shown to adequately follow the numerical solutions, and thus it is believed to reflect the model behaviour in real problems. However, as pointed out by Aupoix, more work must be done in order to really understand the role of the other solutions and their implications to the modelling.
THE PROBLEM FORMULATION
A generalformulation of two-equation models At this point, we restrict our attention to two-equation models employing gradient-diffusion models with scalar-diffusivities for the turbulent transport terms. This, for instance for turbulent kinetic energy k, is k 2 Ok Ok TJ k) ~ a k C . T Oz----j = gkvT 8zj
(I)
where T~k) is the turbulent flux vector of k,/iT is the eddy viscosity, and crk is a model coefficient. In the end of this section, we will extend the study to the case of the generalized gradient-diffusion model of Daly & Harlow (1970) employing tensor-valued diffusivity. The scale-determining part of arbitrary two-equation turbulence model employing the above given simple gradient-diffusion model for turbulent transport terms can be written in the following quite general form (Catris & Aupoix 2000) Dk
= P - e+
Dr
_
m
r (Cr
(2)
(u + okuT)
- Cr
+
0[
(u + o-eL,r)
0r
+ (u + cr,k~'r)
r
(3)
ok 0r r ok ok ~ 00 00 nt-OdlliT k OXj OXj --t-Crd2L/Tk20Xj OXj ~ Crd3l/Tr OXj OXj where r ~ kme ~ is an arbitrary second scale variable. In addition to (2) and (3), some constitutive model is needed for the Reynolds stress tensor and for the eddy viscosity. Most of the actual models
150
available for practical applications are much simpler than (2) and (3) not including all the inner products of the gradients in the C-equation. Also, the secondary diffusive term in the C-equation depending on the gradient of k is almost always zero. One motivation behind this general formulation is that it allows, in principle, arbitrary transformations between different choices of the definition of r i.e. the parameters m and n, without adding any further terms. This means that transformation from one second scale variable to another reduces to a change of the values of the model coefficients as noted by Catris & Aupoix (2000). See also Hellsten (2004b) for more details. It turned out, however, that retaining this full form of the generalized model complicated the analysis quite much. This problem was avoided easily by dropping the second gradient-product term, i.e. the term depending on the coefficient era2, from (3). As a matter of fact, also the secondary diffusive term could have been omitted, and still the resulting analysis would have covered most, if not all, of the interesting models. We kept that term, however, because it did not complicate our analysis considerably. We wanted to keep the other cross-gradient terms because several interesting k - co models include the oral-term, and the new k - k L model developed by B6zard & Daris (2005) utilizes also the Crd3-term.
The idealized edge problem Cazalbou et al. (1994) proposed that behaviour of turbulence models near outer edges of shear layers can be understood by studying a simplified one-dimensional problem involving only ordinary differential equations. For general two-equation models of the form of (2) and (3) (but without the cra2-term), the corresponding equations can be written as dU
d (d~yU)
Vd---y
=
dy
vdk d-y
=
dy
V~~
= dy ~162
(4)
uT
d ( d ~ )
(5)
crk uT
-~-Or163
-~-Odl
ur dk de uT (d_~) 2 k dy dy t- ~d3-~-
(6)
Note that the source and sink terms have been omitted as negligibly small in the edge region. The convective velocity V must be assumed constant around the edge. The Reynolds number is assumed high, so that viscosity can be omitted. In this problem, all the variables U, k, and r are defined as positive quantities that go to zero on the edge. Thus U can be considered either as a velocity defect of a wake-like flow or a velocity excess of a jet-like flow. Note that Cazalbou et al. (1994) and Kok (2000) formulated the problem in a moving coordinate frame to make V zero. In such a frame, the problem takes the form of an unsteady nonlinear diffusion problem. This problem may have a solution of a power form U(y)
=
Uof a
(7)
k(y)
=
kof b
(8)
r
=
r
(9)
c
where f ( y ) = max \
60
;0
(10)
and U0, k0, r and ~50are the characteristic scales of the problem. The exponents a, b, and c are functions of the a-coefficients and the parameters m and n. It is assumed that U, k, and r are zero outside the edge. Cazalbou et al. (1994) assumed that UT = C , k2,/c with constant C,. The power solution is possible
151
provided that UT ~ f , which in the generalized formulation becomes uT = C # ( ~ 2 n + m / r 1In c,,a f. Cazalbou et al. (1994) presented the necessary conditions for such solution to exist. The power functions (7) - (9) are not necessarily differentiable on the edge point (y = 50) with all values of the model coefficients. Cazalbou et al. (1994) showed that there is a corresponding weak solution in such cases. Note that all existing models do not obey this power solution as the exponents may become negative or unbounded with some calibrations.
ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION
A solution for particular case of variable Cu As stated above, the power solution is possible only if UT = C # ( k 2 n + m / r 1In "': f . Cazalbou et al. (1994) ensured this by requiting that 2b - c = 1 in the case of k - e models, and that C# must be constant. We can also allow variable C , if we assume that it follows a power function, say C , ~ C , of ~ with/3 < 1. In such cases, we must require that
(]s
1In fl-Z
:::>
m
c
n
n
(2 + - - ) b
= 1 -/3
(11)
Inserting the trials (7) - (9) into the system (4) - (6) and using the relation (11), we can solve the unknown exponents, a, b, and c and the convective velocity V. The solution reads
a -b -c
=
V
:
n(1 - / 3 ) ( G r + trek + Oda)Crk D n(1 -/3)(0-r + or + ~d3) D n(1 - / 3 ) ( c r k - Gdl ) D n(1 - / 3 ) ( a r + trek + Cra3)CrkC.o D
(12) (13) (14)
'~o
(15)
r
with V -- ( 2 n + 7Tt) (O'q~ + O'r
--[- Od3 ) -- O"k + O-dl
(16)
We must require that all the exponents are positive and that D -r 0. In many cases cr~ + trek + Od3 > 0 and crk - Odl > 0 while both n and D must have the same sign. In a majority of existing models both D and n are positive, but in some models they are both negative. Bdzard's k - kL model deviates from the main stream in that it has n / D < 0 but also ar + aek + Od3 < 0 and ok - ad~ < 0 rendering the exponents positive.
Discussion Behaviour of wide variety of different models around the outer edges of turbulent flows can be studied employing the solution (12) - (16). However, ,2 is still unknown and we must consider also the behaviour of constitutive models in this problem before proceeding. The simplest constitutive model is the linear Boussinesq model with constant C,. This equals to setting fl = 0 in the above solution. In the nonlinear constitutive models as well as in the SST-model by Menter (1994), C , is typically approximately inversely proportional to the nondimensional strain parameter S at large values of S. At smaller values of S, these models give a constant or nearly a constant distribution. Fig. 1 shows this for two constitutive models, the E A R S M by Wallin & Johansson (2000) and the SST by Menter (1994). In this
152
:zk f,..)
0.12 [ 0 . 1 |0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0 0
I
,
' ~
2
4
IEARSM: ] SST .............
6
8
10
Figure 1" C , in simple parallel flow as a function of 5' according to the E A R S M and the SST models. simplified problem, 5' is reduced to 7- dU/dy, where 7- = k/c is the turbulent time scale. Thus, the solution (12) - (16) with 0 < / 3 < 1 can be thought to asymptote the real E A R S M - or SST-model solution when 5' -+ ec. In fact, it holds quite well when 5' is larger than, say 3 or 3.5. On the other hand, the solution with/3 = 0 can be though to asymptote the real solution as 5' ~ 0. It is immediately seen from (12) - (14) that if C , decreases towards the edge as with 0 < /3 < 1, the edges in the solutions become sharper. This may lead to a situation where the velocity exponent a, originally larger than one with constant C , , now becomes less than one. The edge will be perfectly sharp with dU/dy being indefinite always when a _< 1 (a weak solution). This is an unphysical situation and may also cause numerical troubles. In practice, the numerical dissipation and the molecular viscosity may alleviate the situation to some extent, but also the numerical solutions will be qualitatively wrong at least when a < 1. Now, knowing that C , distributions decreasing towards the edge may spoil the solution even qualitatively, this kind of situation must be avoided. Fig. 1 shows that increasingly large values of S lead to decreasing C , while small values of S should keep C , roughly constant. We can now require S to approach zero towards the edge. As we are requiting S --+ 0, we may assume that = 0 as explained above. To determine the exponent of S, we assume that the dissipation-rate solution at the edge follows the same power form as before, say c ~ e0f d. From the momentum equation (4), it can be shown that the leading order terms (lowest powers of f ) are a - 1 for the convection part and 2b - d + a - 2 for the diffusion part because we assumed constant C , , i.e./3 - 0. Equaling these powers leads to d = 2b - 1. The exponent of S then becomes a - 1 + b - d = a - b, and requiting S to go to zero at the edge means that its exponent has to be positive. Using the expressions of a and b given in (12) and (13) we obtain a constraint for crk
a-b>O
~
crk> 1
(17)
An alternative route to the same conclusion is to study the behaviour of the production to dissipation ratio Pie. In E A R S M constitutive models, Pie is a solution of an algebraic equation for the Reynolds stress tensor. In the E A R S M expression of Wallin & Johansson (2000), this ratio is obtained as a solution of a third-degree equation, as a function of the velocity gradient invariants and the turbulent scales. As a consequence, the effective C~ can also be taken as a function of P/c. The shape of this curve is not much different from C~(S)-curve, shown in Fig. 1, since P/c = C~S2 in this case. At the edge, both S and P/c should go to zero, which implies that the effective Cu reaches asymptotically a finite value at the edge which depends only on the values of the constants of the E A R S M expression. These are not strong physical arguments for the behaviour of S and PIe at the edge. However, the DNS-data by Spalart (1988) for a flat-plate boundary layer enforces this, see Fig. 2. The model predicted behaviour of P/c can be analysed similarly as that of S. The turbulent production P has the power 2b - d + 2(a - 1) which becomes 2a - 1 after substitution of d = 2b - 1. The production to dissipation ratio has thus the power 2a - 1 - d which becomes 2(a - b). With (12) and (13) this again implies crk > 1.
153
1.6 " ~ '",,,........ ' ' 1.4 : : - . ~ ",,",.... 1.2 "-.'.?,.~'-,",, 1 .... .... "';~:-,"~',)::..... .......@ ~ i i " . 0.8 ~ ~ i 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9
' S Reo=300 S Re0=670 S Reo=1410 P/~ Re0=300 P/~ Reo=670 Re0 =1410
1
1.1
1.2
: ............. .............. .................. ........ .......
1.3
1.4
y/8
Figure 2: S and
P/c around the outer edge of a boundary layer from the DNS-data I
1.0
I
I
2.0
I
I
0,=1.1
,
o,=1.1
ok=1.0
0.75-
by Spalart (1988).
1.5-
........... crk=O.9
i
cr,=a .0
]
.............. a,=0.9
/
,J]
,.-..
z) ~o 0.5-
to
~- 1.0--
I
..,
',
,
II
g
N 0.25-
0.0
0.5-
I
0.0
0.5
I
1.0
"r//'r/w=o,
0.0
I
1.5
2.0
."s
I
0.0
0.5
I
1.0
i I
1.5
I
2.0
Figure 3" Numerical solutions of the velocity defect and the production to dissipation ratio of a selfsimilar wake using k - e models associated to EARSM expression. Effect of the crk value for a given edge behaviour. In addition to S and P/c, we can study the shear-stress anisotropy a12 -- u'vt/k. It is evident from several experimental and DNS-studies, e.g. Bradshaw (1967), Spalart (1988), Sk~re & Krogstad (1994), that a12 approaches zero towards the edge. This fact is yet another reason to require crk > 1, because a12 ~ fb(ok-1) As this is completely independent of/3, we do not have to assume anything about the behaviour of the constitutive model. Cazalbou et al. (1994) found also a constraint on crk for the production to go to zero more rapidly than the diffusion, which was o.k > 0.5. The constraint o.k > 1 found here for non-linear models is more restrictive. Some models, such as most k - e models, have their o.k value falling just on the limit o.k = 1. However one should give a value above the constraint to avoid the PIe ratio going to infinity and the effective C , going to zero. Violating the constraint could lead to numerical problems at the edge. This is illustrated in Figs. 3 and 4. Fig. 3 shows the computed evolution of the non-dimensional velocity defect and of the production to dissipation ratio in a self similar wake with three k - e models associated to the E A R S M expression of Wallin & Johansson (2000): the standard Launder-Sharma model with crk = 1 (dashed line) and two modifications of this model, one which fulfils the constraint ~rk = 1.1 (continuous line) and one which violates the constraint o.k = 0.9 (dotted line). The o-~ and C~ 1 constants have been recalibrated for each model to respect the same evolution at the edge for the velocity (a = 1.43) and the same log-law slope value (~c = 0.43) as given by the Launder-Sharma model, C~2 keeping its classical value of 1.92. The model with o.k -- 1 gives a constant value of PIe at the edge, which is almost found numerically. However, even a small violation of the constraint (crk = 0.9 instead of 1) gives a strong
154
0.96 -2
2
0.92 ...x-- - "
-3
0.88
-4
0.84
-5
a
..... .~... -~"
-
.
.
.
.
.
0.8 0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
1.1
0.5
y/5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
y/5
Figure 4: Left: numerical solutions of the velocity defect near the outer edge of a self-similar equilibrium boundary layer using three different k - w models. Right: corresponding velocity profiles from full Navier-Stokes solutions at Reo ~ 13,000. peak of P/c and a "hook-shaped" velocity profile close to the edge, which is unphysical. On the other hand, ok = 1.1 gives smooth and physically feasible distributions of P/~ and the velocity defect at the edge. It may also be pointed out that lower values of c~k could even lead to a complete divergence of the numerical solution. Fig. 4 (left) shows three different numerical k - w solutions near the free-stream edge of a self-similar boundary layer. The first model (Hellsten 2004a, Hellsten 2004b) gives a qualitatively correct smooth solution at the edge, the second model (Kok 2000) predicts a sharp edge, and the third case is a genetic combination of Kok's model and the EARSM, which predicts a sharp "hook-shaped" velocity profile at the edge. The qualities of these numerical solutions are as expected based on the theoretical results. It must be understood that the edge behaviour shown here for some k - c and k - w models is not a specific feature of these models, but a general property of all two-equation models equipped with nonlinear constitutive models and gradient-diffusion models similar to (1) for turbulent transport terms. We also performed a full Navier-Stokes computation of a flat-plate boundary layer using a grid that is relatively coarse around the edge. The grid resolution around the edge is considered comparable with the grids used in high-quality practical CFD-simulations. This simulation was done in order to verify that the conclusions made based on the simplified self-similar problems are valid also in full Navier-Stokes simulations. The same k - w models were tested as in Fig. 4 (left). The velocity profiles are shown in Fig. 4 (fight). Now, the numerical truncation error largely smears out the sharp solutions, but the unphysical "hook shape" is still clearly visible even though the grid spacing was Ay ~ 0.086, which is roughly eight times as large as than in the self-similar case.
Extension to a case of generalized gradient-diffusion model We have so far studied only models employing the simple scalar-diffusivity gradient-diffusion model (SGDM) given by (1) for turbulent transport terms. Are the above conclusions valid also for generalized gradient-diffusion models (GGDM) with tensor-valued diffusivities? The popular model by Daly & Harlow (1970) (DH)
T~k) ~ c k k ~
Ok ~ujuk 8x-~'
(18)
155
written here for k, is studied next to shed some light onto this question. With the assumptions made in the edge analysis, the DH-model can be written as
Ck v'v' k 2 dk dk T(k) "~ C u k Cu-~-@y = cr;UTd--y
(19)
with or; = Ckv'v'/(C,k) being an effective crk. In this case, (19) is of the same form as the SGDM except that cr~ is no more constant but a function of the velocity-gradient invariants scaled by turbulent time scale. The constraint crk > I must now be reformulated as lim o-~ >
S--,0
1
(20)
Generally, cr~ depends on the vorticity, but in simple shear flows also vorticity approaches zero with vanishing strain rate, and we obtain lima,= s~o
~2/3C k ~ 7.41Ck
(21)
thus Ck > 0.135. In cases with nonzero vorticity at the limit of vanishing shear, e.g. frame rotation, the Wallin-Johansson EARSM gives limit values higher than 7.41 for v'v'/(C,k) leading to a less restrictive constraint for Ck. Hence, it may be reasonable to require Ck > 0.135 in case of Wallin-Johansson EARSM. However, it must be remembered that the limit value of v'v'/(C,k) may be different with some other constitutive model. We checked that numerical computations support this constraint. Other generalized gradient-diffusion models can be analysed in a similar fashion.
CONCLUSIONS This paper discusses the behaviour of two-equation turbulence models at the outer edges of turbulent flows. The focus is especially on nonlinear EARSM-based models with simple scalar-diffusivity gradient-diffusion model for turbulent transport. The analysis is presented in terms of a generalized twoequation formulation with its second scale variable in a parametric form r ~ kmc '~. Owing to this, the results can easily be applied to any given two-equation model. It is shown that the solution may become unphysically sharp or "hook-shaped" if the mean shear rate scaled by the turbulent time scale does not approach zero towards the edge. A constraint is derived for the model coefficient crk of the turbulent transport model of k to avoid such anomalous solution. This is crk > 1, and it ensures physically meaningful smooth solution at the edge also when a nonlinear constitutive model is employed. In addition to the nondimensional mean-shear rate, also the ratio of turbulent production to dissipation is considered as well as the shear-stress anisotropy. All these quantities should vanish at the edge, and they will do so if the new constraint is satisfied. We extended this analysis also to the generalized gradient-diffusion model of Daly & Harlow (1970), and obtained a similar kind of constraint for its model coefficient Ck > 0.135. Similar analysis can be easily carried out also for other generalized gradient-diffusion models. The theoretical results provide understanding of why some model combinations tend to give unphysical solutions around the outer edges. Moreover, the analysis provides constraints for the model coefficients to avoid such unphysical solutions.
156
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Part of this work was carried out within the HiAer Project (High Level Modelling of High Lift Aerodynamics, 2001-2004). The HiAer project was a collaboration between DLR, ONERA, Royal Institute of Technology in Sweden, Helsinki University of Technology (HUT), Technical University of Berlin, Alenia, European Aeronautic Defence and Space Company EADS Airbus, QinetiQ and Swedish Defence Research Agency (FOI). The project was managed by FOI and partly funded by the European Union (Project Ref: G4RD-CT-2001-00448). This work was also supported by the National Technology Agency of Finland (Tekes). The support from the European Union and Tekes is gratefully acknowledged.
REFERENCES
B6zard, H. & Daris, T. (2005), Calibrating the length scale equation with an explicit algebraic Reynolds stress constitutive relation, in W. Rodi & M. Mulas, eds, 'Engineering Turbulence Modelling and Experiments 6', Elsevier. Bisset, D., Hunt, J. & Rogers, M. (2002), 'The turbulent/non-turbulent interface bounding a wake flow', Journal of Fluid Mechanics 451,383-410. Bradshaw, P. (1967), 'The turbulent structure of equilibrium turbulent boundary layers', Journal of Fluid Mechanics 29, 625-645. Catris, S. & Aupoix, B. (2000), 'Towards a calibration of the length-scale equation', International Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow 21(5), 606-613. Cazalbou, J.-B. & Chassaing, E (2002), 'The structure of the solution obtained with reynolds-stresstransport models at the free-stream edges of turbulent flows', Physics of Fluids 14(2), 597-611. Cazalbou, J.-B., Spalart, E & Bradshaw, E (1994), 'On the behavior of the two-equation models at the edge of a turbulent region', Physics of Fluids 6(5), 1797-1804. Daly, B. & Harlow, E (1970), 'Transport equations of turbulence', Physics of Fluids 13, 2634-2649. Hellsten, A. (2004a), New advanced k - cJ turbulence model for high-lift aerodynamics, in '42nd AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting', AIAA. AIAA paper 2004-1120. Hellsten, A. (2004b), New Two-Equation Turbulence Model for Aerodynamics Applications, PhD thesis, Helsinki University of Technology, Espoo, Finland. ISBN 951-22-6933-3 (print), 951-22-6934-1 (pdf, available at http://lib.hut.fi/Diss/). Kok, J. (2000), 'Resolving the dependence on freestream values for the k - cJ turbulence model', AIAA Journal 38(7), 1292-1295. Menter, E (1994), 'Two-equation eddy-viscosity turbulence models for engineering applications', AIAA Journal 32(8), 1598-1605. Skfire, E & Krogstad, E (1994), 'A turbulent equilibrium boundary layer near separation', Journal of Fluid Mechanics 272, 319-347. Spalart, E (1988), 'Direct simulation of a turbulent boundary layer up to Ro = 1410', Journal of Fluid Mechanics 187, 61-98. Wallin, S. & Johansson, A. (2000), 'A complete explicit algebraic Reynolds stress model for incompressible and compressible turbulent flows', Journal of Fluid Mechanics 403, 89-132.
Engineering TurbulenceModellingand Experiments6 W. Rodi (Editor) 6) 2005 ElsevierLtd. All rights reserved.
157
E X T E N D I N G AN ANALYTICAL WALL-FUNCTION F O R TURBULENT FLOWS O V E R R O U G H WALLS K. Suga ~, T.J. Craft 2 and H. Iacovides 3 ~Computational Physics Lab., Toyota Central R & D Labs., Inc., Nagakute, Aichi, 480-1192, Japan 2ZSchool of Mechanical, Aerospace and Civil Engineering, The University of Manchester, P.O. Box 88, Manchester, M60 1QD, U.K.
ABSTRACT This paper reports the development of a refined wall-function strategy for the modelling of turbulent flow over rough surfaces. In order to include the effects of fine-grain surface roughness, the present study extends a more fundamental work previously carried out at UMIST on the development of advanced wall functions of general applicability. The presently proposed extension is validated through comparisons with data available for internal flows through rough pipes, channels and for external flows over rough surfaces. Then, its further validation in separating flows over a sand dune and a sandroughened ramp is discussed. The validation results suggest that the presently proposed form is successfully applicable to a wide range of attached and separated turbulent flows over fine-grain rough surfaces. KEYWORDS RANS, Turbulence modelling, Eddy viscosity, Wall-function, Rough wall, Separating flow INTRODUCTION
Although many recent low-Reynolds-number (LRN) turbulence models perform satisfactorily, industrial engineers still routinely make use of classical wall-function approaches for representing near-wall turbulence. One reason for this is that, despite advances in computing power, their near-wall resolution requirements make LRN models prohibitively expensive in complex three-dimensional industrial flows. This is particularly true for flows over rough surfaces, where one cannot hope to resolve the details of small wall-roughness elements, and the wall-function approach is thus the only practical strategy for industrial applications. Despite the above comments, in contrast to many other modelling issues, wall-functions have received little attention over the last few decades. Consequently, the strategies in use have, for the most part, been those proposed in the 1970's that assume a semi-logarithmic variation of the near-wall velocity and either a constant, or at most a linearly varying, total shear stress between the wall and the near-wall node (e.g. Launder and Spalding, 1974). However, it is well known that they do not apply in flows with strong pressure gradients and separation.
158 There have been several attempts to replace the wall-function approach for rough wall turbulence. Patel and Yoon (1995) tested the rough wall extensions of the k - t o and the two-layer k-e. models. Durbin et al. (2001) and Aupoix and Spalart (2003) respectively modified the two-layer k - e model and a one-equation model. Although these extensions are rather simple and can overcome some of the defects of the classical wall-function, they require a fine grid resolution near the walls. In order to address industrial requirements, the UMIST group recently proposed an alternative wall-function strategy for flow over smooth walls which, while still semi-empirical in nature, makes assumptions at a deeper, more general level than the log-law based schemes. The approach is called the analytical wall-function (AWF) and integrates simplified mean flow equations analytically over the near-wall control volume, assuming a near-wall variation of the turbulent viscosity (Craft et al., 2002). This analytical integration then produces the value of the wall shear stress and other quantities which are required over the near wall cell. The objective of this study is to propose and validate an extension to the AWF approach that allows for the effects of fine-grain surface roughness. It will be shown that relatively simple adaptations of the method result in an approach that does reproduce many of the features of flows over rough surfaces, whilst retaining the computational efficiency associated with wall-functions. The flow test cases chosen for the validation are internal flows through rough pipes and channels, external flows over rough surfaces and separating flows over a sand dune and a sand-roughened ramp. ANALYTICAL WALL-FUNCTION STRATEGY AWF for Smooth Walls Although the detailed model expressions of the AWF can be seen in Craft et al. (2002), a brief summary is described below. In the AWF, the wall shear stress is obtained through the analytical solution of a simplified near-wall version of the transport equation for the wall-parallel momentum. The main assumption required for the analytical integration of the transport equations is a prescribed variation of the turbulent viscosity/tt over a wall-adjacent computational-cell. This is done as shown in Figure 1, using yv~ as the thickness of the viscosity dominated sub-layer, and assuming that/tt is zero for y
It, =max{0, oq.t(y*-y;)},
.LI/2 / v , a=c~%, c~=2.55 and %=0.09, and/t, v, y, and ke are respectively the molecular where y * - yKe viscosity, the kinematic viscosity, the wall normal distance and the turbulence energy at the node P. In the context of Figure 1, the near-wall simplified form of the tangential momentum equation becomes ,nnY" I-~ y
I y"
p
OAr
U
.4-
Smoo~
9~,
i ! i
Nt T
= max[O, Otla(y* - y~" )]
log(y+) y "- y
4~2"~ z
"-
v
Figure 1: Near wall cells.
Figure 2: Effects of surface roughness on near wall velocity.
159
'ay* (g't'Ixt)
=k~LOx(puu)+-g~x =c~,
(2)
where P, P, x and U are the fluid density, pressure, the tangential coordinate direction and the mean tangential velocity component, respectively. Further assumptions are that convective transport and the wall-parallel pressure gradient do not change across the wall-adjacent cell, and can thus be evaluated from nodal values. The former is evaluated using pointwise, non-conservative, discretisation. A boundary condition needs to be prescribed at the far side of the near-wall control volume, side n in Figure 1, and this is obtainedby linearly interpolating the nodal values of U on either side of the control volume face. For a uniform grid, this leads to U, = 0.5(Up + U N). Equation (2) can then be integrated analytically over the two regions 0 < y < Yv and yv < y < y,, resulting in
dU [ (Cry•+ Av)/IX' if y ' < y~ dy*=i CuY*+-~--- ,if y*>_y ~ [gll+oc(y'-y~)t
I1
. . . -~gCvy,~ +~1 Avy. +By, Ify
(3)
U= iCv y,+I ~_..~__ - Cv (1-(xy:)lln[l+(x(y*-Y;)]+/~v, if y*> y; t'~ l ~ ,~ j L
where Au , Bv , A~ and fly are integration constants which are obtained by applying the above boundary condition and ensuring that U and its derivative are continuous at yr. The wall shear stress can then be obtained using the results of the above integration:
xw=ix
=Ix
~
=
y---o
(4) V
The analytical velocity variation and prescribed turbulent viscosity also lead to an expression for the local generation rate of k, which can be integrated over the wall-adjacent cell, to produce an cell-averaged value for solving the k equation. To evaluate the cell-averaged dissipation rate, t is assumed to vary according to t=kr 3/2/(c~y), away from the wall and to be constant very close to the wall as in conventional wall-functions. The location of the interface between the two regions, y~, is, however, now determined by requiring continuity of t across the two regions. This leads to
e=kJ/21(cty~)=2vkply~.
(5)
Thus y~ = 2ct = 5.1. The value of the constant y*v is taken to be 10.7, arrived at by considering fully developed flows in straight pipes.
Extension for Rough Walls Conventional wall functions are made sensitive to the effects of fine-grain surface roughness through the introduction of the dimensionless roughness height (e.g. Cebeci and Bradshaw, 1977). If the average roughness height is denoted by h, then a dimensionless roughness height h + can be defined in terms of the friction velocity u~, by h+-huJv. The constant B in the log-law expression, U § = ~:-~In y+ + B, is then taken to be a function of h § so that as h§ increases B is reduced. This has the effect of displacing the log-law to the fight, as shown in Figure 2, which increases the wall shear stress. A more generalized approach, still within the framework of wall functions, is to replace h + with h ~ where h ~ - h kpV2/v. Nevertheless, such extensions of conventional wall functions for rough surfaces bring with them all the original assumptions of these strategies and consequently tend to suffer similar limitations to their range of applicability.
160
Figure 3: Near wall cells over a rough wall. The development of the AWF provides, perhaps for the first time, an opportunity to take into account the effects of fine-grain surface roughness using a near-wall modelling strategy that does not include the log-law assumption and all the predictive limitations that it entails. In common with conventional wall functions, the extension of the analytical strategy to flows over rough surfaces involves the use of the dimensionless height, h*. In this case, however, h ~ is used to modify the near-wall variation of the turbulent viscosity. More specifically, the dimensionless thickness of the zero-viscosity layer yv'is no longer fixed at 10.7, but instead becomes a function of h ~ The proposed expression for the dimensionless thickness of the zero-viscosity layer is
y*~ = y~, ~-(h"/70)'}
with m = max{(0.5-0.3(h"/70) ~ exp(0.287)),(1-0.7(h"/70) -0.2' exp(0.1208))} (6)
and yvs* =10.7. The function for the index, m, has been determined through a series of numerical experiments on fully-developed flows through straight pipes and comparisons with data from the Moody chart (Moody, 1944). For yv* > 0, corresponding to transitional roughness with h~ the analytical solutions derived for smooth walls can still be used, but with the above modified value foryv*. When y,,*<0, corresponding to a fully-rough surface with h*>70, the viscosity-dominated sub-layer is destroyed. The analytical solution of the mean flow then needs to be changed, since integration is performed over the single region 0
by" - ~gy" (Ix + Ix,)-~-r
kpL~x'P~)+~
(7)
where z'is the total shear stress. In a developed turbulent boundary layer over a smooth wall (where F D =0) with constant pressure gradient, the total shear stress is obtained from ~9x
v~ FSP]
~y----r= -~eL-~x_]= const.
(8)
Thus, z" varies linearly in the boundary layer. In a zero pressure gradient case, r is constant near the wall. However, measured data reported by Krogstad et al. (1992) showed that in some rough wall boundary layers, the near-wall peak value of the turbulent shear stress exceeded the wall shear stress. The measurements by Tachie et al. (2003) also show this tendency. Unlike in a sublayer over a smooth wall, r now includes the drag force from the roughness elements in the inner layer which is proportional to the local velocity squared and becomes dominant away from the wall, compared to the viscous force. This implies that the convective and pressure gradient contributions should be represented somewhat differently across the inner layer, below the roughness element height, and hence
161
the quantity Fz~ has been introduced in Eqn.(7). In the present study a simple approach has been taken, by assuming that the total shear stress remains constant across the roughness element height, which is in line with the discussions ofKrogstad et al. (1992). Consequently, one is led to 3 r / b y * = 0 ( y < h ) and ~ / Oy* = v 2 / k~,[O(pUU) / ~x - ~ P / ~x] over the rest of the wall-adjacent cell 0' > h), and thus 0 +0P Fo=~xx (pUU) ~ x ' y < h =0
(9)
, y>h.
Using this form, the momentum equation (Eqn. 7) is integrated analytically over the wall-adjacent cell. As shown in Figure 3, separate integration results are obtained for the four cases: (a)Yv < 0 , (b) 0 < Yv < h, (c) h < yv < y, and (d) y, < y~. Note that the form of the dissipation rate does not have any modification for wall roughness. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS The CFD codes used in this study are in-house finite-volume codes: TEAM (Huang and Leschziner, 1983) and STREAM (Lien and Leschziner, 1994). The former is used to compute turbulent pipe, channel and boundary layer flows and the latter is to compute turbulent separating flows. Both codes employ the SIMPLE pressure-correction algorithm. TEAM uses an orthogonal staggered grid arrangement whilst STREAM uses a non orthogonal collocated one employing Rhie and Chow's (1983) interpolation and the third order MUSCL type scheme for convection terms. The AWF has been implemented with the "standard" linear k-E and also with a cubic non-linear k-e model (CraR, Launder and Suga, 1996: CLS). For comparison, flow predictions have also been obtained using the LRN k-e model (Launder and Sharma, 1974: LS). (Note that it has been confirmed that both codes produce consistent results, at least in turbulent channel flows.) Wall Parallel F l o w s Pipe f l o w s
Figure 4 compares the presently predicted friction coefficient and the experimental correlation for turbulent pipe flows, known as the Moody chart (Moody, 1944). The turbulence is modelled by the high Reynolds number (HRN) k-e model with the AWE In the range of h / D = 0 - 0.05 (D: pipe diameter) and Re =8,000- l0 s , it is confirmed that the AWF performs reasonably well over a wide range of Reynolds numbers and roughness heights. (The number of computational grid nodes ranged from 12 to 200 across the pipe radius for Reynolds numbers ranging from 8,000 to l0 s, whilst the value of y* at the wall-adjacent node ranged from 50 to 500.) 0.1
........
9 ......
.
....
hk'D "
RL-~e. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
o 5xlO,,,,.~.,
~
'.~-"~--~"
~
~
3
o
^
,,
o~
u 2)<10-
~
,~
., I x l 0 -2,
9
v
. 5 x 1 0 -3
~
o .3,~,1u
"~3~~_ "
~
-,~.........~=
-" z x l o
. o
25 20
LRNLS
ay/n=o.o]5 ---o-. ay/o=o.o45 -.-a- a~r
~
~
"~i
.,jj~,,.- o
1. ~..../
-3-
,, l x l 0 - J , -, 5 x l 0-"
10
oo,
ooo
.
1000
I. A W F cal. ~ .
.i
.
IXlO-
~ .
.
,
0
.
.
.
,
.
1000(9 1(90(900 l e + 0 6 Re
.
.
,
.
1e+07
.
.1
.
]e+08
5
og law
i
.
lO
100
1000
]0000
y+
Figure 4: Friction factors in pipe flows (Moody chart). Figure 5: Mean velocity in channel flows.
162
o.o|" O.Oll
\ o.olo \
Cf
Profiles at R e , :
::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: ....\
o.ooe ":,\
o.~
.................
m-~ hU,/v=O.OOE+O0 ~ hO,/v,,O.12E+04 ,.-* hU,h,-O.21E+04 ~hO./~'O.30E+04. :
-
5.00E+06
:::::::::::::::::::::::::
-.
9 U"
::::::::::::::::::::::::::: ~ h = O.OE+O0 h'= 0.0 y*= 217.8 e--eh" 0.4E-03 '~", 56.1 ' ~ " 140.2 h" 0.7E-03 h " 104. ' ~,, 297.2 ~ -~-h= 0.1E-02 h'= 153 9 ' ~:= 307 9
= e~:
k
0.008 0.11~ 0.004 : 0.
i
8.0
I"............................. ~ . .
8.25
e.5
8.711
.
7.0
.!i
725 7,8 Log,(Re,)
Figure6: Predicted Cf for smooth and rough wall boundary layers; lines with symbols: AWF; broken lines: exp. correlations.
0
I
2
3
4
L,g,,O0
5
0.0
0./3
0.5
0.75
1.0
y/~
125
Figure 7: Mean velocity and turbulence energy profiles at Rex=5x 10"; lines with symbols: main grid solutions; solid lines without symbols: nearwall analytical wall-function profiles.
Channelflows Figure 5 shows mean velocity distributions in turbulent channel flows at Re=10 s. In the case of smooth walls, h / D = 0 (D: channel height), the HRN k-e model with the AWF reproduces the result of the LRN LS k-e model regardless of the near-wall cell size. The meshes used have 49, 19 and 14 nodes across the channel, resulting in near-wall cell heights of Ay1/D =0.015,0.045,0.09. In the rough wall cases with h/D=O.O1 and 0.03, it is clear that the AWF reproduces the log law distribution for rough walls:
U+ =llny+ +B-AB
(10)
K"
where AB=(1/~)lnh+-3.3 with ~c=0.42 andB=5.2.
Flat plate boundary layerflows A further test of the new AWF approach has been to apply it to a fiat plate boundary layer flow. Tests with different near-wall cell sizes again showed the present treatment to be relatively insensitive to the size of the near-wall cell. Figure 6 shows the resulting predictions of the skin friction coefficient, Cf, plotted as a function of non-dimensional downstream distance, Rex, for a number of roughness element sizes, h (nondimensionalized with the free-stream velocity Uo and kinematic viscosity v). Also shown are the correlations for smooth and fully rough boundary layers, given by
C/= 0.0271" ~e x-1/7 ,
for smooth walls
=[2.87+l.581n(x/h)~ -2"5, forroughwalls.
(11)
For the smooth plate, the predictions are seen to lie slightly below the correlation. In the rough wall cases, at lower values of Re,, the flow is still in the transitional stage, but as Rex increases the predictions do approach the fully rough correlation. Corresponding profiles of the mean velocity and turbulence energy across the boundary layers at Re x = 5• are shown in Figure 7. As in the pipe flow cases, the predicted effect of the roughness is to displace the log-law to the right, whilst the level of the normalized turbulence energy is hardly affected, except in the immediate wall vicinity.
163
Figure 8: Dune profile and computational grid. Separating Flows Sand dune flow
Figure 8 shows the geometry and a computational mesh used for a water flow over a sand dune of van Mierlo and de Ruiter (1988). Their experimental rig consisted of a row of 33 identical two-dimensional sand dunes covered with sand paper, whose averaged sand grain height was 2.5mm. Since they measured the flow field around one of the central dunes of the row, streamwise periodic boundary conditions are imposed in the computation. In the experiments, the free surface was located at y=292mm and the bulk mean velocity was Ub = 0.633m / s. Thus, the Reynolds number based on Ub and the surface height was 175,000. In this flow, a large recirculation zone appears behind the dune. Due to the flow geometry, the separation point is fixed at x=0 as in a back-step flow. Figure 9(a) compares the predicted friction velocity distribution on meshes of 330 • 50, 165 • 50 and 165 • 25. In the finest mesh, the height of the first cell facing the wall is 4mm which is still larger than the grain height of 2.5mm. The turbulence model applied is the cubic CLS k-~ model with the differential length-scale correction term for the ~ equation (Iacovides and Raisee, 1999). The lines of the predicted profiles are almost identical to one another, proving that the AWF is rather inse