ruSr 4!:
ri,#.qir
',*; ;fi,r
rsBN 0-521-46282-7
CANNBRIDGE UNIYERSITY
PRESS
llll llllll il|l| illilillll ilil
g 11790521u462822u
LIBRARV .GALLAGHFR ,JNlv^qlsl' ;\, r)FcA,.;AR Y t/AL(rAH y 4r. *lF ll ;-,q
CANAIJT r-ZNrN+
E,xploration Seismology E
C
O
O
N
N
R.E.SHERIFF Pro.fessor,Geostiences DePartment, University oJ Houston, Houslon,Texas
L. P.GELDART Former Coortlinator, Canudian International Development Agency Progrum Jbr Brazil
ClvrnnrDGE UNIVERSITY
PRESS
Published by the Press Syndicate of the University of Cambridge The Pitt Building, Trumpington Street, Cambridge CB2 IRP ' SA 4 0 W e s t 2 0 t h S t r e e t ,N e w Y o r k , N Y 1 0 0 1 1 - 4 2 1 I U l0 Stamford Road, Oakleigh, Melbourne 3166, Australia @ Cambridge University Press 1982, 1995 First published 1982 Second edition 1995 Printed in the United States of America Library of Congress Cataloging-in- Publicatittn Data Sheriff. Robert E. Exploration seismology / R. E. Sheriff' L P. Geldart. 2nd ed. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 0-521-46282-7.- ISBN 0-521-46826-a(pbk ) l. Seismicprospecting.
I. Geldart, L. P II. Title.
1994 TN269.S52415 622'.1592-dc20
94-4153 CIP
A catalogrecord for this book is availablefrom the British Library ISBN
Hardback 0-521-46282-7 0- 521-46826-4PaPerback
Contents
Preface Mathematical conventionsand symbols Generalrules and definitions Latin symbols Greek symbols I
2
Introduction Overview L I Outline of seismicmethods l.l.l Seismicreflectionmethod 1.1.2Seismicrefractionmethod 1.2 History of seismicexploration 1.2.I Historicalsources 1.2.2Preliminaryevents |.2.3 Early applicationsto petroleum exploration 1.2.4The GeophysicalResearch Corporation 1.2.5Other activitiesin the 1920s 1.2.6Early geophysicalcasehistory 1.2.7Developmentof the geophysicalcontractingindustry 1.2.8Evolution of reflection equipmentand methods 1.2.9Reproduciblerecording,the common-midpointmethod, and nonexplosivesources L 2 . l 0 R e c e nh t istory 1.3 Geophysicalactivity 1.3.1The future of exploration seismology 1.3.2History of seismicactivity 1 . 3 . 3D a t a f o r l 9 9 l 1.4The literatureof exploration seismology References Theory of seismicwaves Overview 2.1 Theory of elasticity 2.1.1Waveson a stretchedstrine 2 . 1 . 2S t r e s s 2 . 1 . 3S t r a i n 2.1.4Hooke'slaw 2.1.5Elasticconstants 2.1.6Strainenergy 2.2Wave equations 2.2.1Scalarwaveequation 2.2.2Yector waveequation 2.2.3Waveequationincluding source term
xi xiii xiii xiii xv I I 2 2 z J J J
J
8 9 l0 l3 l4
l8 2l z3
23 24 26 28 3l JJ JJ JJ JJ
35 36 J I
38 38 39 3 9 40 40
2.2.4 Kir chhoff's theorem 2.2.5Plane-wavesolutions 2.2.6 Spherical-wave solutions 2.3 Generalaspectsof waves 2.3.1 Harmonic waves 2.3.2Waveinterference 2.3.3Huygens'principle 2.4 Body waves 2.4.1 P-wavesand S-waves 2.4.2 Displacementand velocity potentials 2.4.3Waveequationin fluid media 2.4.4Boundary conditions 2.4.5Wavesfrom a sphericalsource 2.5 Surfacewaves 2 . 5 . 1G e n e r a l 2.5.2Rayleighwaves 2.5.3Stoneleywaves 2.5.4 Love waves 2.5.5Tube waves 2.6 Anisotropic media 2.6.I Typesof anisotropy 2.6.2Transverseisotropy 2.6.3Waveequationfor transversely isotropic media 2.7 Effectsof the medium on wave propagation 2.7.1 Energydensityand geometrical spreading 2.7.2Absorption 2.7.3Relativeimportanceof absorptionand spreading 2.7.4Dispersion;group velocity 2.7.5Reflectionand refraction; Snell'slaw 2.8 Diffraction 2.8.1Basicformulas 2.8.2 Diffraction effect of part of a plane reflector 2.8.3Time-domain solution for diffraction 2.8.4Diffraction effectof a halfplane 2.8.5Using Huygens'principle to construct diffracted wavefronts Problems References
3 Partitioning at an interface Overview 3.I Application of boundary conditions
4l 4l A 1 AL
43 43 ^ a
+J
44 44 44 46 47 41 47 49 49 49 50 52 53 55 55 56 56 57 57 59 60 60 62 63 63 64 65 66 68 68 1l It IJ
t)
CONTENTS 7.I Determining location 7 . 1 . 1L a n d s u r v e y i n g I .1.2 Marine positioning 7 .1 . 3R a d i o p o s i t i o n i n g 7.1.4Transitsatellitepositioning 7.1.5Global PositioningSystem (GPS) 7.1.6Acousticand inertial positioning 7.1.7 Locating the streamer 7.2 Impulsiveland energysources 7.2.1The desiredsource 7.2.2 Explosivesourcesin boreholes 7.2.3Largeimpulsivesurfacesources 7.2.4Small surfacesources 7.3 Nonimpulsiveenergysources 7.3.1Vibroseis /.-1..Z)OSle
7.3.3Choiceof land sources 7.4 Marine equipment 7.4.I General 7.4.2Bubble effect 7.4.3Air guns 7.4.4Implodersand other marine sources 7 . 4 . 5C h o i c eo f m a r i n es o u r c e s 7.5 Detectors 7.5.I Theory of geophones 7.5.2At-the-geophone digitization 7.5.3Hydrophones 7.5.4Streamers 7.5.5Matchinghydrophoneand geophonerecords 7.6 Recording 7.6.I Amplifier requirements 7 . 6 . 2R e c o r d i n g instruments 7.6.3Analog recording 7.6.4 Digital representation 7.6.5Digital instruments 7.6.6Display Problems References Reflectionfield methods Overview 8.I Basicconsiderations 8.1.1Data acquisition 8 .1 . 2C r e wo r g a n i z a t i o n 8.1.3Environmentaland safety considerations 8.1.4Conductof a field survey 8.2 Field operationsfor land surveys 8.2.1The program 8.2.2Permitting 8.2.3Laying out the line 8.2.4Field procedures 8.3 Field layouts 8.3.1Spreadtypes 8.3.2Singlefoldrecording 8.3.3Common-midpointmethod
vll
191 l9l 192 193 194 195 191 198 198 198 199 204
20s 206 206 210 210 2tl 211 213 214 214 217 2t8 218 223 223 225 22s 226 226 226 221 229 230 ZJJ
234 236 239 239 239 239 239 240 240 241 241 241 241 242 z+J z+J
244 244
8.3.4Practicalconstraintsand specialmethods 8.3.5Array concepts 8.3.6Uniform linear arrays 8.3.7Weighted(tapered)arrays 8.3.8Areal arrays 8.3.9Practicalconstraintson arrays 8.3.10Spatialsamplingrequirements 8.3.1I Extendedresolution 8.4 Selectionof field parameters 8.4.I Noise analysis 8.4.2Determiningfield parameters 8.4.3Field testing 8.5 Defining the near surface 8.5.1Uphole surveys 8.5.2Near-surfacerefraction 8.6 Marine methods 8.6.I Conventionalmarine operations 8.6.2Shallow-waterand obstructed operauons 8.6.3Profiling methods operations 8.7 Transition-zone 8.8 Data reduction 8.8.1Field processing 8.8.2Elevationand weatherins corrections 8.8.3Picking reflectionsand preparingcross-sections Problems References Data Processing Overview 9.1 Transforms 9.1.1Integraltransforms 9.1.2Fourieranalysisand synthesis 9.1.3Fouriertransforms 9.1.4MultidimensionalFourier transforms 9.1.5Radon (r-P) transforms 9.1.6 Implementationof transforms 9.2 Convolution 9 . 2 . 1T h e c o n v o l u t i o no P e r a t i o n 9.2.2 Sampling,interPolating,and aliasing 9.2.3Filtering by the earth 9.2.4W aterreverberationand deconvolution 9.2.5 Multidimensionalconvolution 9.3 Correlation 9.3.I Cross-correlation 9.3.2Autocorrelation 9.3.3Normalizedcorrelation 9.3.4VibroseisanalYsis 9.3.5Multichannelcoherence 9.3.6Sign-bitrecording 9.4 Phaseconsiderations 9.5 Deconvolutionand frequencY filterine
245 247 247 250 250 251 252 253 253 253 254 255 256 256 256 258 258
260 260 260 261 261 261 266 268 zt)
275 275 216 276 27'l 21'7
218 218 218 2't9 279 281 283 284 285 285 285 285 286 281 288 289 290 292
CONTENTS
viii 9 . 5 . 1G e n e r a l 9.5.2Deterministicinversefiltering 9.5.3Deghostingand recursive filtering 9.5.4 DeghostingbY combining geophoneand hYdroPhonerecords (Wiener)filtering 9.5.5 Least-squares 9.5.6Whitening 9.5.7Predictive(gaPPed)deconvolution 9.5.8Other types of deconvolution 9.5.9Waveletprocessing filtering 9.5.l0 FrequencY 9.5.1| Time-variantProcessing 9.5.I 2 Choosingdeconvolution parameters 9.5.I 3 Multichannel deconvolution 9.6 Automaticstaticsdetermination 9.6.1Interrelationof staticsand normal-moveoutcorrectlons model 9.6.2The surface-consistent the Maximizing 9.6.3 Powerof the stackedtrace 9.6.4Refractionstatics 9.7 Velocityanalysis(velocitY spectrum) 9.7.I Conventionalvelocityanalysis 9.7.2Velocitypanels 9.7.3PickingvelocitYanalYses 9.7.4Usesand limitationsof velocity analyses 9 .7.5 Horizon velocitYanalYsis 9.8 Preservationof amplitude information 9.9 Apparent-velocity(2-D) filtering 9.10Stacking 9 . 1 0 . 1G a t h e r s 9.10.2DMO (dip-moveout) correction 9 . 1 0 . 3M u t i n g 9. 10.4Common-midPointstacking 9. 10.5Weightedstacking 9.10.6Diversity stacking 9.10.7Simplanstacking 9.1I Other processingtechniques 9 . 1l . l r p t r a n s f o r mP r o c e s s i n g (slant stacking) 9.11.2IntelligentinterPolation 9.11.3AutomaticPicking analYsis 9.11.4Complex-trace to rePositiondata 9.12 Processes 9.12.1Introduction 9.I 2.2 Kirchhoff (diffraction-stack) migration 9.12.3Migration in the frequencydomain wavenumber methodof 9.12.4Finite-difference u are-equationmigration 9 . 1 2 . 5D e p t hm i g r a t i o n 9 .I 2 . 6 H y b r i d m i g r a t i o n
9.12.7Relativemerits of different migration methods 9.12.8Resolutionof migrated sections 9.12.9Other migrationconsiderations 9. l3 Data-processingProcedures sequence 9. I 3.I Typicalprocessing and 9.13.2lnteractiveProcessing workstations inversion 9.l4 Generalized Problems References
292 292 292 293 293 295 298 298 299 300 300 I0
302 303 303 303 303 305 305 306 306 309 309 3 lr 3ll 313 315 316 316 316 319 320 321 322 322 324 324 324 325 325 326 326 327 329 330 JJJ
334
Geologicinterpretationof reflectiondata Overview 10.1Basicgeologicconcepts 10.LI Generationand migrationof hydrocarbons 10.1.2Typesof traPs I 0.2 InterpretationProcedures 10.2.1 FundamentalgeoPhYsical assumPtions 10.2.2Collectionand examination of data 10.2.3Pickingreflections 10.2.4Mapping reflectinghorizons 10.2.5Deducinggeologichistory g e l ld a t a i n t o a n 1 0 . 2 . 6l n t e g r a t i n w interpretation 10.2.7Workstations from 10.2.8Drawingconclusions reflectiondata color 10.2.9Displaytechniques; 10.3Evidencesof geologicfeatures 10.3.1ConcePtsfrom structural geology I 0 . 1 . 2B a l a n c i n gs e c t i o n S 1 0 . 3 . 3F a u l t i n g 10.3.4Foldedand flow structures 1 0 . 3 . 5R e e f s 10.3.6Unconformities 10.3.7Channels 10.3.8StratigraphictraPs 10.3.9Integrationwith other geophysicaldata 10.4Modeling 10.4.1 lntroduction 10.4.2Physicalmodeling 10.4.3ComPutermodeling 10.4.4Syntheticseismograms I 0.4.5Ray-tracemodeling 10.5Lateral variationsin velocity 10.5.1Gradualchanges 10.5.2Suddenchanges I 0.6 Three-dimensional interpretationof 2-D data I 0.7 Stratigraphicinterpretation 1 0 . 7 . 1I n t r o d u c t i o n 10.7.2SequencestratigraPhY
134 334 335 335 335 340 340 343 346 349 349 350 350 351 J)J
353 353 356 357 359
359 361 JOJ
363 364 364 310 37r -r/o
182 385 386 388 389 390 390 390 391 392 392 392 392 395 398 398 398 401
CONTENTS
10.7.3Time significanceof reflections 10.7.4Depositionalmodels 10.7.5Systemtracts 10.7.6Seismic-facies analysis I 0.7.7Reflection-character analysis 10.8Hydrocarbon indicators 10.9Crustal studies Problems References 1l
Refraction methods Overview l l.l Field techniques I l.l.l In-linerefractionprofiling I 1.1.2Broadsiderefractionand fan-shooting l l . l . 3 G a r d n e r 'm s e t h o do f defining salt domes I 1.1.4Marine refraction I 1.2Refractiondata reductionand processing I L3 Basic-formulainterpretation methods I 1.3.1Using basicformulas I L3.2 Adachi'smethod I 1.3.3Generalizedreciprocal method (GRM) I 1.4Delay-timeinterpretation methods 1.4.1Delay time 1.4.2Barry'smethod 1.4.3Tarrant'smethod 1.4.4Wyrobek'smethod I 1.5Wavefrontinterpretation methods I 1.5.I Thornburgh'smethod I 1.5.2Hagedoorn'splus-minus method I 1.5.3Hales'graphicalmethod I 1.6Geologicinterpretationof refractiondata Problems References
t2 3-D Methods Overview 12.l 3-D acquisition 1 2 . 1I. A c q u i s i t i o nr e q u i r e m e n t s 1 2 . 1 . 2M a r i n e3 - D a c q u i s i t i o n 1 2 . 1 . 3L a n d 3 - D a c q u i s i t i o n 12.23-D processing 12.3Displayof 3-D data 12.4Interactive3-D interpretation 12.53-D interpretation Problems References
l 3 Specializedtechniques Overview
1X
403 404 405 409 4t2 415 418 4t9 420 425 42s 425 425 111
427 428 429 433 433 433 434 439 439 439 440 441 442 442
13.1Exploration with S-waves l3.l.l Why explorewith S-waves 13.1.2.S-waverecordingon land 13.1.3S-waverecordingat sea 13.1.4Processing and displaying S-wavedata 13.1.5Interpretationand useof S-wavedata 13.1.6 S-wavebirefringence I 3.2 Three-componentrecording 13.2.1Acquisition | 3.2.2Polarizationfi ltering 13.3Channelwaves(normal-mode propagation) 13.4Vertical seismicprofiling (VSP) 1 3 . 4 . 1G e n e r a l 13.4.2VSP typesand their uses 13.4.3Recordinga VSP 1 3 . 4 . 4V S Pp r o c e s s i n g 13.4.5VSP planning I 3.5 Seismictomography 13.5.1General I 3.5.2Tomographicconcepts 13.5.3Solutionfor a limited number of discretecells I 3.5.4Cross-holemeasurements 13.6Time-lapsemeasurements 13.7Boreholestudies I 3.7.I Salt-proximitysurveys 13.7.2Sonic waveformlogging I 3.7.3Boreholeteleviewer 13.8Passiveseismicmethods 13.9Joint inversion I 3.I 0 Geostatisticalmethods Problems References
t4 Specializedapplications 442 443 446 446 448 451 451 451 451 452 453 457 459 460 461 466 467 471 4'7|
Overview 14.I Engineeringapplications 14.l.l Objectivesof engineering work 14.1.2Refractionsurveyson land 14.1.3Reflectionsurveyson land 14.L4 Marine engineering surveys 14.2Coal geophysics 14.2.1Objectivesof coal geophysics 14.2.2Propertiesof coal 1 4 . 2 . 3L o n g w a l m l ining 14.2.4Surfaceseismicmethods 14.2.5In-seammethods 14.2.6Miscellaneousaspectsof coal geophysics I 4.3 Groundwater, environmental, archaeological,and geothermal applications I 4.4 H ydrocarbon-reservoir applications 14.4.1Introduction
411 471 471 474 474 415 476 476 476 483 483 487 487 487 488 489 492 492 492 493 496 491 499 500 500 500 500 s00 502 502 s02 503 505 505 505 505 505 506 506 508 508 508 508 508 509 5t2 512
5t2 512
CONTENTS l4.4.2The nature of hydrocarbon reservoirs I 4.4.3Reservoirdelineation I 4.4.4Reservoirdescription 14.4.5Reservoirsurveillance Problems References
l 5 Backgroundmathematics Overview l 5 . l S u m m a r i eos f b a s i cc o n c e p t s l5.l.l Determinants 15.1.2Vectoranalysrs 15.1.M 3 a t r i xa n a l y s i s 15.1.4Seriesexpansions 15.1.5Complexnumbers 15.1.6Method of leastsquares I 5.1.7Finite differences 15.1.8Numericalsolutionof differentialequations 15.l.9 Partialfractions 15.2Fourier seriesand Fourier transforms 15.2.1Fourierseries I 5.2.2Fourier integral I 5.2.3Fourier transforms I 5.2.4Multidimensional Fourier seriesand transforms I 5.2.5Specialfunctrons 15.2.6Theoremson Fourier transforms I 5.2.7Gibbs' phenomenon I 5.2.8Convolutiontheorem I 5.2.9Cross-correlationtheorem I 5.2.l0 Autocorrelation l 5.2.1I Multidimensional convolution | 5 . 2 . 1 2R a n d o mf u n c t i o n s I 5.2.I 3 Hilbert transforms 15.3Laplacetransform 1 5 . 3 . 1I n t r o d u c t i o n 15.3.2Theoremson Laplace transforms 15.4Linear systems 15.4.I Introduction
15.4.2Linear systemsin seriesand parallel 15.5Digital systemsand z-transforms 15.5.1Samplingtheorem I 5.5.2Convolution and correlation of sampledfunctions 15.5.3z-transforms I 5.5.4Calculationof z-transforms; Fast Fourier Transform I 5.5.5Applicationof z-transforms to digital systems I 5.5.6Phaseconsiderations I 5.5.7Inteeralrelationfor inverse z-transforms 15.6Cepstrumanalysis 15.7Filtering 1 5 . 7 . 1I n t r o d u c t i o n 15.7.2Filter synthesisand analysis 15.7.3Frequencyfiltering 15.7.4Butterworth filters 15.7.5Windows 15.7.6Optimum filters Problems References
513 514 5t4 515 515 515 517 517 5r7 517 518 519 522 522 523 527 529 530 531 531 532 532 533 533 538 539 540 541 542
547 547 547
548 548 549 550 554 554 555 555 555 556 55'7 558 559 563 566
Appendices A
List of abbreviationsused
569
B
Trademarksand proper namesused
569
C
Randomnumbers
570
D
Units
570
E
Decibelconversion
5t\
F
Typicalinstrumentspecifications and conventions
571
542
543 )4)
545
G
A seismicreport
571
545 s46 546
H
Symbolsusedin mapping
572
Index
515
Preface
Many improvementshave occurred in the seismic method since the publication of the first edition in 1982.Conceptsthat were of academicconcern then havesincebecomepracticaltools and someof the new concepts we have added may become tomorrow's tools. We want this book to be a referencework as well as a textbook and guide for practicing geophysicists. Thesethree objectivesare not alwayscompatibleancl readerswill often skip over portions that do not fit their current needs,hopefully later referring back to skipped portions. For those readers who do skip about, we have cross-referenced sections,equations. and figures.For thosewho are rustywith theii mathematics, we expressconceptsin words as well as by equatlons. Our specialinterestis in the interpretationof geophysicaldata, but an interpreterneedsto havea thorough understanding ofgeophysicalprinciplesin order to determinethe validity of his data and the possibility that featureshe seesare artifacts of acquisitionor processing.To this end, we have tried to emphasize seismicfundamentals. We give a systematicderivation of relationships from first principles,exceptlor a few caseswhere the derivationsare excessivelylengthy or involve higher mathematics,in which instanceswe refer the readerto other sources.As the prefaceto our first edition states, 'A reader willing to take the mathematicson faith should be able to jump over the equationsand still seethe implicationsof the mathematicalconclusrons, lvhich we haveendeavoredto explain in words rather than merely letting the equations speak for themselves.We have been encouraged by Sir Harold Jeffreys'prefaceto The Earth (1924): Ifthe geologist cannotfollowa partofthe book,I hopehe riill omit it andgo on.. .. Mathematically trainedreaders, *ith fewexceptions, will do thesame. Our treatment of seismic theory has been expanded.We haveexpandedpartitioning at interfaces, the heart of most seismicapplications,and made it a separatechapter.Anisotropy, AVO, Stoneleywaves, and tube waves,merelymentionedin our first edition, are now discussedin more detail. 3-D methods and -1-D interpretation now occupiesan entire chapter. Techniquessomewhatout of the mainstream.suchas
VSP, S-wavemethods, and channel wavesare now expanded into a full chapteron specializedtechniques, and we have added new topics such as tomography and geostatistics. One chapteris devotedto nonpetroleum applications,including not only coal and engineering seismicwork, but also the growing areas of groundwater,environmental,and reservoir seophvsics. Our final chapteron mathematicalbackg-roundis again intended to refresha reader'sforgotten mathematical concepts. Terms definedare indicatedby italics.precisionof terminology is often one of the clearestindicationsof a person'sdegreeof understandingand we havemade specialeffort to defineand usethe specializedvocabulary of seismologyprecisely. This book is structuredto be as consistentas possible. Mathematicalconventions,definitions,and the symbolsusedthroughoutthe book are listedimmedi_ ately following this preface.We havetried to conform to acceptedpracticesand nomenclature,but we have had to usesomesymbolsfor severalpurposes. Each chapterbeginswith an overviewto orient the reader as to the various topics to be discussedand their relationshipto each other. All chaptersexcept the first end with problems;theseendeavorto eluci_ dateaspectsnot treatedin the text and developproofs and additional relationships.Each problem has been designedto illustratea specificpoint and we have included hints where we anticipate studentsmay have difficulty in knowing how to proceed.Enlarging the book'sfiguresto usewith the problemsinvolvingthem should not prove difficult with the ready availability of enlargingcopiers. We acknowledgethe assistanceof many peonle in the preparationof this book and expressour thanks to them. In addition to thosecited in our first edition (Harry Mayne, Dan Skelton, Bill Laing, O. Leenhardt, Bruce Frizelle, Howard Taylor. Thomas Thompson,and Willis Reed),we particularlythank Barbara Barnes,Leslie Denham, Brian Evans, Tony Lauhoff, Dereck Palmeq and Margaret Sheriff for their help with this edition. We also expressappreciation to the University of Houston GeosciencesDepartment and the Curtin University of Technology (whereone of us (RES) worked on this book while the Haydn Williams Fellow). R. E. Sheriff L. P. Geldart
Mathematical conventions and symbols
General rules and definitions Generalfunctions C, g(l) c(/)* h(/) g(O, G{,a) C,{,")
d"o(')
Functionof the discretevariablet : nA, n : 0 , * 1 ,- r 2 , . . . . Functionofa continuousvariabler Convolutionof g(r)with /r(r) Functionsinvolvingthecepstrum transform:log G(ro): G(al e+ C(o Transformof g(r) to a function of frequencyz the argumentsy or to indicateFouriertransform,s Laplace transform,z z-transform Correlationof g(r) with ft(t)as functionof the time shift .r; a cross-correlation if g * h, 6,rG) : autocorrelation
Specialfunctions box,,It]
Boxcar of unit height and width a, centeredat t :0
comb[r] sgn[r] sinc[r] step[l]
Seriesof equallyspacedunit impulses Signof t : -l for I < 0, +l for l > 0 (1/r)sin I Unit stepfunction,step(l): 0 for r < 0, +lforr>0 Unit impulseat / : 0
6[4,6,
Mathematical conventions Approximately equal to Denotes corresponding functions in different domains, the arguments v, e, s, z indicating the type of transform; thus, g(t) e qv) and g(r) e G(r,r)indicate Fourier transforms, g(r) e+ G(r) a Laplace transform, g, e G{z) a z-transform; g(x, "y) <+ G(( 0) a Radon transform; lowercaseletters indicate the time domain, uppercasethe frequency domain. J Denotes a time sequenceconsisting of the la,b, c, Q elements a, b, c, d, with the superscribed arrow indicating the value associatedwith t : 0 (b in this instance);values not otherwise specifiedarc zero. A Vector quantity, magnitude is lAl A . B ,A x B Scalar and vector products ofA and B I Matrix with elementsa.. y'r Transposeof matrix d e
arg(o) tl
v v2
v0 v.A V X A det(a)
a{}
Argument of
D { } D-'{ } E { } exp(x) g(0+), g(0-) Valueof g whenapproaching0 from right, left q4, Ge r) Complexconjugateof G(z) P (e,) Probability of e, Re{g(r)}, Im{g(t)} Real,imaginarypartsof g(t) Absolutevalueor modulusof w, W lwl,lWl i, i, z Time derivativesof x, y, z ,a Productaoa(r2a3'' an llo, i=0
* L s, i:0 ls-
S u m g*o B ,* ' " + g , Sumofgooverappropriate valuesofk
Latin symbols a
a. b. c a,, b, a,, b,, c,, A, B A, B, C A(t) A(v), B(v)
.t,.8 c /-c.t'
C D
Element spacing, rate of increaseof velocity with depth, area, width of a boxcar Constants Angles of incidence Fourier-series coefficients Constants Amplitudes of waves or of displacements Amplitude of envelope,amplitude
attributedto reflectivity Amplitudespectrum potential Amplitudesof displacement functions,matrices Specificheat at constantvolume,pressure Incompressibility: 111r, volume fraction of clay Displacement potential function for diffraction, distance
xiv D., D* ei et
E E", EU E*, E, l(t), f ,
"fft),"fr "f,(t), "f : .f"(t) F
MATHEMATICAL CONVENTIONS
Depth of source,weathering Error in fth output Impulse responseof sequenceof reflectors Sum of errors squared, Young's modulus, energy.energydensity.energyratio Elevation of surface,datum Fraction of energy reflected,transmitted Filter in time domain, function of I High-pass filter Low-pass filter Responseof filter to unit step in time domain Array response,constant, magnitude of lorce, depth-conversionfactor
F(u),r(
glt), g, g,\t)
s(o G(u), G(or), qz) h
function Acceleration of gravity Seismictrace in time domain, input trace. function of I Quadrature trace Cepstrum of G(o) or G(;) Seismictrace in frequency domain Damping factor, distance to reflector or refractor, depth, thickness Output in time domain Desired output, complex trace Magnetic field strength, depth
h(t), h, h(t), tt, H H(v), H(a), H() Output in frequencydomain 7(v),.Vla), Desired output in frequency domain i Current. index io Angle of raypath at source point i, Inversefilter in time domain i,i,k Unit vectors in x-, .y-,z-directions I Intensity Transform ol inversefilter 4") (- l;'" J j Index k Constant. bulk modulus. index K Force on geophonecoil per unit current. effectiveelastic modulus ( Distance in Radon transform (,m,n Direction cosinesrelative to ,r-, l-, r-axes e , ,( " , ( o C r i t e r i ai n o p t i m u m f i l t e r i n g L Kinetic energy per unit volume, length. prediction lag, self inductance Lu Mr Delay at location k due to structure, normal-moveout error m Mass m,n Constants, exponential decay parameters, integers M Effective elastic modulus. width of frinse zone n Integer, number of layers
.vo
l.
AND
SYMBOLS
Impulse responseof near-surfacezone Noise p, p' Raypath parameter P Power p, Impulse responseof waveshapemodifying factors in the earth Pressure O Quality factor, probability r Distance. integer,radius, radial coordinate r,s Receiver.sourcecoordinates r,R Radius.resistance rr Additive noise R,R, Reflection coellicient ol lth interface, displacementpotential function for reflection R' Resistivity R*.S^ Delay due to geophone. source at location k R(u),R(
s
s,,
T
\1.{THEMATICALCONVENTIONS AND SYMBOLS
Il' , i . .\, \l u). X(
responseof water layer, downgoing waveform S-wave acoustic impedance Displacement, distance, offset Critical distance,crossoverdistance lor a refraction Imaginary part of Fourier transform : -(sine translorm) Depth, :-transform parameter P-wave acoustic impedance
Greek symbols
I, LN
\,, tr, p F '' F,' F* v Io
v,1.t) vN
,:, -r, B -. -i, 'r(f) .rtu). 1(o) I6 6 . 6. d(1)
fl
a,,.a,, e i i I I H
H, H, O r
K\
P-wavevelocity, angle, angle of approach Fourier-seriescoefficients S-wave velocity, angle Phaseor phase difference,specific heat ratio, potential function, sourcedensity Phaseshilt Instantaneousphase Phasespectrum Geophone transductionconstant, measureof simplicity Angle of S-wave,delay time, logarithmic decrement Delay time associatedwith shotpoint, geophone
Unit impulseat r : 0 Dilatation,increment, samplinginterval Eccentricity, phaseshift upon reflection. straln N o r m a l , s h e a r i n gs t r a i n s Error matrix Argument of wave function, quefrency Vector displacement - ai * rj * n'k Absorption coefficient Outward-drawnunit normal Angle, angle of P-wave, argument of complex quantity,polar coordinate, sphericalcoordinate(colatitude) Critical angle Angle of rotation about x-axis Vector rotation : 0,i + 0,j + 0-k Angular wavenumber : 2n(wavenumber) : 2n7^ 2rr(apparent wavenumber) 2n(Nyquist wavenumber) Lame constant.length ratio. constant. wavelength,weighting lactor
v
€ ; o
o." I
Y
0 d",,(r)
o
xv
Apparent wavelength Nyquist wavelength Lam6 constants for transverselyisotropic medium Mass ratio, mass/unit length, rigidity (shear) modulus (a Lam6 constant) Rigidity moduli for transverselyisotropic medium Frequency : al2q -- llT Natural frequency,fundamental frequency Instantaneous frequency Nyquist frequency Vector potential Dip, distance from origin to moving point on a curve Strike Density, radius (of curvature) Convergencefactoq Poisson'sratio, standard deviation, strength per unit length Stressin x-direction on surface perpendicular to y-axis Damping factor, tension Scalar wave function, source density Angle, loss angle, magnetic flux, porosity, P-wave displacement potential function, spherical coordinate (longitude) Correlation of gO with ft(l) as function of time shift r Transform of Q, transform of P-wave displacementpotential function Cross-energyspectrum (transform of
0"lr))
x,x v rf(x, :, l) f*(x, :, l*) lP(x,, rc-,o)
VL(x,,r-, r) (r) (')o 0l
o
S-wave displacement potential function Wavefunction. disturbance Wavefunction in x. :. and I dimensions Wavefunction in moving coordinate system translorm of wavefunction Transform of wavefunction with respect to lr, : Angular frequency : 2nv Natural frequency Nyquist frequency Vector potential function for rotation
Introduction
Overview Exploration seismologydeals with the use of artificially generatedelasticwavesto locatemineral deposits (including hydrocarbons,ores, water, geothermal reservoirs,etc.), archaeologicalsites, and to obtain -eeologicalinformation for engineering.Exploration seismologyprovidesdata that, when usedin conlunction with other geophysical,borehole,and geological data and with conceptsof physicsand geology,can provideinformation about the structureand distribution of rock types.Usually,seismicexplorationis part of a commercialventureand, hence.economicsis an ever-presentconcern. Seismicmethods alone cannot determine many of the features that make for a profitable venture and, even when supplementedby other data, a unique interpretation is rarely evident. Seismicexploration usually stops long before unambiguousanswersare obtained and beforeall has been learned that might possibly be learned, becausein judgment further information is better obsomeone's tained in some other way, such as by drilling a well. Seismicmethodsare in continual economiccompetition with other methods. Almost all oil companiesrely on seismicinterpretation for selectingthe sitesfor exploratoryoil wells.Despite the indirectnessof the method- most seismic work results in the mapping of geologicalstructure rather than finding petroleumdirectly- the likelihood of a successfulventureis improvedmore than enough to pay for the seismicwork. The enormous detail produced by 3-D techniqueshas opened up a huge reservoir engineering potential. Likewise, seismic methods are important in groundwatersearchesand in civil engineering,especiallyto measurethe depth to bedrock in connection with the construction of large buildings, dams, highways, and harbor surveys, and to determine whether blasting will be required in road cuts, if potential hazards such as limestone caves or forgotten mine workings underlie building sites,if tunnels or mine drifts are likely to encounter water-filled zones, or if faults are present that might be hazards to a nuclear power plant. On the other hand, seismic techniques have found little application in direct exploration for minerals becsuse they do not produce good definition where interfaces between different rock types are highly irregular. However, they are useful in locating features such as buried channels in which heavy minerals may be accumulated.
Exploration seismologyis an offspring of earthquake seismology.When an earthquake occurs, the earth is fractured and the rocks on opposite sidesof the fracturemove relativeto one another.Sucha rupture generatesseismicwavesthat travel outward from the fracturesurface.Thesewavesare recordedat various sites using seismographs.Seismologistsuse the data to deduce information about the nature of the rocks through which the earthquakewavestraveled. Exploration seismicmethods involve basically the sametype of measurements as earthquakeseismology. However,the energysourcesare controlled and movable and the distancesbetweenthe sourceand the recordingpoints are relativelysmall.Much seismicwork consistsof continuouscoverage, wherethe responseof portions of earth is sampledalong lines of successive profile. Explosivesand other energysourcesare used to generatethe seismicwavesand arraysof seismometers or geophonesare usedto detectthe resultingmotion of the earth. The data are usuallyrecordedin digital form on magnetic tape so that computer processingcan be usedto enhancethe signalswith respectto the noise,extract the significantinformation, and display the data in such a form that a geological interpretationcan be carried out readily. The basic techniqueof seismicexplorationconsists of generatingseismicwavesand measuringthe time required for the wavesto travel from the sourceto a seriesof geophones,usuallydisposedalong a straight line directedtoward the source.From a knowledgeof traveltimesto the various geophonesand the velocity of the waves,one attempts to reconstructthe paths of the seismicwaves.Structuralinformation is derived principally from paths that fall into two main categories:head-waveor refractedpathsin which the principal portion of the path is along the interfacebetween two rock layers and hence is approximately horizontal, and reflectedpaths in which the wave travels downwardinitially and at somepoint is reflectedback to the surface,the overallpath being essentiallyvertical. For both types of path, the traveltimesdepend upon the physicalpropertiesofthe rocks and the attitudesof the beds.The objectiveof seismicexploration is to deduceinformation about the rocks, especially about the attitudesofthe beds,from the observedarrival times and (to a limited extent)from variationsin amplitude, frequency,and waveform. A brief outline of the seismicreflectionand refraction methods is given first (gl.l); this explanationig-
2 norescomplicationsand variations,which are the subjectsof futurechapters. Exploration seismologyis a fairly young activity, having begun only about 1923.The history of seismic exploration is summarized in $l.2. The seismic method is by far the most important geophysicaltechniquein termsof capitalexpenditure(gl.3) and number of geophysicistsinvolved. The predominanceof the seismicmethod over other geophysicalmethodsis due to various factors, the most important of which are the high accuracy,high resolution,and greatpenetration of which the method is capable.Seismicliterat u r e i s d i s c u s s eidn S l . 4
l.l Outline of seismic methods l.l.I Seismicreflectionmethod Seismictechniqueshavechangedconsiderablywithin recentyearsand many variationsexist.The technique describedin what follows providesa background to the understanding of subsequent discussions; the reasons for various stepsand various modificationsof techniques will be describedin subsequent chapters. Assume a land crew using an explosivecharge as the energy source.The first step after determining properlocationsis the drilling of a verticalhole in the earth at the sourcepoint, the hole diameterbeing perhapsl0 or l2 cm and the depthusuallybetween6 and 30 m. A chargeof I to 25 kg of explosiveis armed with an electricblastingt'up and then placednear the bottom of the hole. Two wires extendfrom the cap to the surface,where they are connectedto a blaster, which is usedto sendan electricalcurrent through the wires to the cap, which then explodes,initiating the explosionof the dynamite(the sftol). Two t'ables2 to 4 km long are laid out in a straight line extending each way from the hole about to be fired. The cablescontain many pairs of electricalconductors,eachpair terminatingin an electricalconnector at both endsofthe cable.In addition.eachoair of wiresis connectedto one of severaloutletsspacedat intervalsof 25 to 100m along the cable.Severalgeophones(seismometers) are connectedto each of these outlets so that each pair of wires in the cablecarries the output energyof a groupof geophonesback to the recording instruments.Becauseof the small spactng betweenthe geophonesin the group attachedto one pair of wires,the whole group is approximatelyequivalent to a singlefictitious geophonelocatedat the center of the group.Usually,48 or more geophonegroups are located at equal intervals along the cable.When the dynamite charge is exploded, each geophone group generatesa signal that dependsupon the motion of the ground in the vicinity of the group.The net result is the generationof signalsfurnishing information about the ground motion at a number of regularly spacedpoints (the groupcenters)along a straight line passingthrough the source. The electricalsignalsfrom the geophonegroupsgo
INTRODUCTION to an equal number of amplifiers.Theseamplifiersincreasethe overall signal strengthand partially eliminateQt'ilterout) parls of the input deemedto be undesirable.The outputs from the amplifiers along with accuratetiming signalsare recordedon magnetictape and on paper records.Thus, the recordeddata consist of severaltrace.s,eachtrace showinghow the motion of one geophone group varies with time after the sourceactivation. The data are usually processedto attenuatenoise vis-a-visreflectedenergybasedon characteristicsthat distinguish them from each other, and the data are displayedin a form suitablefor interpretation. Events,that is, arrivalsof energythat vary systematically from trace to trace and that are believedto represent reflectedenergy,are identified on the records. The arrival times (the interval betweenthe sourcernstant and the arrival of the energy at a geophone group, also known as the traveltinte)of theseevents are measuredfor variousgeophonegroups.The location and attitudeofthe interfacethat gaverise to each reflectionevent are then calculatedfrom the arrival times.Seismicvelocityentersinto the calculationol the locationand attitudeofthe interfaces. The results are combinedinto cross-sections and contour maps that representthe structure of the geological interfacesresponsiblefor the events.Patternsin the seismic data are sometimesinterpretedin terms of stratigraphic features or as indicators of hydrocarbons. However,the presenceor absenceof hydrocarbonsor other mineralsis usually inferred from the structural information. We have introduced a number of terms used in a specializedsensein seismicwork (indicatedbyitalic'.s), for example,sourcepoint,group, trace,events,and arrival time. Exploration seismologyabounds in such technicalterms.We shallhenceforthuseitalicsto indicatethat we are defininga term; we shall follow the definitions given in the Ent'yclopedit'Dictionary oJ'Explorution Geophysit's (Sheriff, l99l) for seismicterms and the Glo,ssary o/ Geology(Batesand Jackson,1987) for geologicterms. 1.1.2SeismicreJractionmethod The principal differencebetween reflection and refraction methods is that for refraction, the distance betweensourceand geophonesis large relativeto the depths of the interfacesbeing mapped, whereasit is small or comparableto the depthsfor reflection.Consequently,the travel paths in refraction work are predominantly horizontal, whereasfor reflection work, they are predominantly vertical. Head wavesor refractions(see$3.5)enter and leavea high-velocitybed at the critical angle and only a bed with velocity significantly higher than any bed above it can be mapped.Consequently,the applicationsof refraction methods are more restrictedthan those of reflection. (It should be noted that refraction is used in two different sensesin seismology,to refer to the bending
HISTORYOF SEISMICEXPLORATION t'rfraypathsdue to changesin velocity and in the present senseof involving head waves.The classicalmapping of high-velocitymassessuchas salt domesis also classedas a refractionmethod,although refraction at the critical angle is not necessarilyinvolved; see .il1.1.2.) Refraction exploration generally involves greater distancesthan reflectionwork, so strongersourcesare required. Because distributed in-line geophones nould attenuatethe head wavesthat havean appreciable horizontal componentof motion, geophonesare either bunchedtogetheror distributed perpendicular to the source-geophoneline. Otherwise,however,the sameequipmentcan often be used.
1.2 History of seismic exploration I .). I Historicalsources This accountis basedmainly on articlesby Barton 11929);Heiland (1929a, 1929b): Mintrop (1931); Shaw Bruckshaw,and Newing (193l); Rosaiieand ; e G o l y e r( 1 9 3 5 ) R ; o s a i r e( 1 9 3 5 ) L ; eet L e s t e r( 1 9 3 2 ) D ( 1 9 3 8 ) ;W e a t h e r b y( 1 9 4 0 ) ;V a j k ( 1 9 4 9 ) ;S c h r r e v e r ( 1 9 5 2 )B ; c G e ea n d P a l m e r( 1 9 6 7 ) E ; o r n ( 1 9 6 0 )M ; lki n s ( 1 9 7 0 ) ;L a i n g a n d S e a r c y( 1 9 7 5 ) ;O w e n ( 1 9 7 5 ) ; ; w e e (t 1 9 7 8 ) ; G r e e(n1 9 7 9 )B ; a t e sG P e t t y( 1 9 7 6 )S , ask e l l . a n d R i c e ( 1 9 8 2 ) ,a n d K a r c h e r( 1 9 8 7 ) ,s u p p l e mentedby conversations with individualswho were personallyinvolvedin earlygeophysical work. Recent historicalarticlesthat offer interestingglimpsesinto seismic history include Barrington ( 1982); Clark ( 1 9 8 2 , 1 9 8 3 , 1 9 8 4 a , 1 9 8 4 b ,1 9 8 5 , 1 9 9 0 a ,1 9 9 0 b ) ; ; r o u b a s t (a1 9 8 2 ,1 9 8 3 a1, 9 8 3 b1, 9 8 3 c , M a y n e( 1 9 8 2 )P 1 9 8 4 ,1 9 8 5 a 1 , 9 8 5 b ,1 9 8 6 a ,1 9 8 6 b ,l 9 9 l ) ; R o b e r t s o n ( I 986);Robinson( I 985);Sheriff( l 985, 1988);Wilcox ( 1 9 9 0 )K ; e p p n e r( 1 9 9 1 )a, n d P r o f f i t t( 1 9 9 1 ) . I .2.2 Preliminary events Geophysical explorationfor oil beganwith the torsion balance,which was developedby Baron Roland von Eotvosabout 1888(Vajk, l9a9).Althoughgravitysurveyswith the torsion balanceweremadein Europeon a limitedscale,beginningabout 1900,to map geologic structures,the first extensivesurveysfor petroleum objectiveswere in the United Statesand Mexico in the 1920s.In December1922,a surveyof the known Spindletopsalt dome in Texasgavea gravity anomaly, but subsequentsurveyswere disappointinguntil 1924 when the Nash Dome was discovered.This resulted in the first geophysicaloil discoveryin January 1926. Through 1929 sixteen salt domes found by torsion balancesurveyssubsequentlyresultedin hydrocarbon (Sweet,1978). discoveries The theory of seismicwavesmight be dated from Robert Hooke's law enunciatedin 1678.but most of the theory of elasticity was not developeduntil the 1800s.Baron Cauchy'smemoir on wavepropagation won the Grand Prix of the French Institute in 1818
3 and S. D. Poissonshowedtheoretically the separate existenceof P- and S-wavesaround 1828.C. G. Knott (1899)presenteda paper on the propagationof seismic waves and their reflection and refraction, and Emil Wiechert and Karl Zoeppritz (1907) published their work on seismicwaves.Lord Rayleigh (1885), A. E. H. Love in l9l1 (seeLove,1927),and R. Stoneley (1924)developedthe theoriesofthe surfacewaves that bear their names. Robert Mallet (1848, 1851) began experimental seismologyby measuringthe speedof seismicwaves using black powderas the energysourceand a disturbanceof the surfaceof a bowl of mercuryas the detector. Mallet obtainedvery low velocities;probably low sensitivityallowed him to seeonly the later cyclesof Rayleighwaves,then unknown. H. L. Abbot (1878) measuredP-wavevelocitiesusing essentiallythe same type of detectors but a very large explosion. John Milne (1885)and T. Gray useda falling weight as a source (as well as explosives)in a seriesof seismicwavestudiesusing two seismographs in line, probably the first seismicspread.Otto Hecker (1900)usednine mechanicalhorizontal seismographs in line to record both P- and S-waves. The possibilityof employingthe seismographto define subsurfaceconditions was first put forward by Milne in 1898(Shaw Bruckshaw, and Newing, l93l). As an earthquake wavetravelsfiom stratato strata,if we studyits reflection andchanging velocityin transit,wc may oftenbeledto thediscovery ofcertainrockystructures burieddeepbeneath our vieq aboutwhichwithoutthehelpof suchwavesit wouldbe hopeless everto attainanyknowledge.... Earthquakes are giganticexperiments whichtell theelastic moduliolrocksastheyexistin nature, andwhen properlyintcrpreted mayleadto thepropercomprehension of manyill-understood phenomena. L. P.Garret in 1905suggestedthe useof seismicrefraction to find salt domes but suitableinstruments had not yet beendeveloped(DeGolyer,1935). 1.2.3Early upplit'utionsto petroleumexploration After the sinking of the Titanic by an icebergin 1912, ReginaldA. Fessendenworked on inventionsfor iceberg detection. Among the methods was the use of acousticwavesin water,and an outcome of this was the first (U.S.)patent(fig. Ll) on the applicationof seismicwavesto exploration,applied for in 1914and issuedin 1917,entitled "Method and apparatusfor locating ore bodies."Fessenden's patent said: Theinventiondescribed hereinrelates to methods andapparatuswhereby,beinggivenor havingascertained two or moreof the followingquantities, i.e.,time,distance, intensity and medium,oneor moreof the remainingquantities maybe determined. He proposed using sourcesand detectorsin waterfilled holes,and locatingore bodiesby both the useof peflectionsfrom them and by variations they introduce in traveltimemeasurementsbetweenholes.His
INTRODUCTION
l. A.ttssilto$r, Ittlloo rl0 t??rllt0t t0t toc^||ro ota a00t$, atBElltx it(ta ,aa.tl, rrtt.
1,94O,899.
lltrntdf*pL 18,l1)17.
was apparently only brought into application efforts about 1925. Mintrop in 1919 applied for a German patent on "Method for the determination of rock structures," which was issued in 1926. Mintrop's patent said: Where the problem is to obtain . . . the approximate composition of the strata,the divining rod has beenusedas is well known. However,. . . it has not yet been possibleto ascertain a connectionofunique meaningbetweenthe indication of the divining rod and the geologicparticularitiesof the subsoil.... Accordingto my invention... the connection of mechanicalwaveswith the characteristicpropertiesof the strata is much more immediate . . . mechanicalwavesare artificially generated... by detonating a certain amount of explosives, their elasticpropagationthrough the variousformations is recordedby a seismometerlocated at a suitable distance. . . from the recordsof the latter the velocitiesof the various wavesand the depth to which they penetrated can be determined.which allows conclusionsas to the succession,thickness,density as well as the direction of the strike and dip of rock formations.
tB
John William Evans and Willis B. Whitney in 1920 "Improvements applied for a British patent on in and relating to means for investigating the interior of the Earth's crust" which was issued in 1922. Their patent said:
//n y'rro
First page of Fessenden'spatent.
patent was subsequentlychallenged(unsuccessfully) by (amongothers)Mintrop (1931)becauseFessenden used "acoustic" waves rather than "seismic" waves and becausehis use of boreholesfor sourcesand detectorsdid not accord with subsequentpractice. Ludger Mintrop in Germanyin l9l4 deviseda seismograph with which he could make observationsof explosion-generated waveswith suflicientaccuracyto make explorationfeasible. The Germansand Allies both experimentedduring World War I with the useof threeor more mechanical seismographsto locate enemy artillery, but airwaves generallyprovedmore satisfactorythan seismicwaves for this purpose.Among those involved in theseexperiments were Mintrop and the Americans R. A. Fessenden,E. A. Eckhardt, W. P. Haseman, J. C. Karcheq and Burton McCollum. Thesesix were predominant in the developmentof commercialapplication of seismicwavesafter the war. McCollum attributed the idea of applying seismic methods to petroleum exploration to Haseman (unpublished "Recollections re McCollum" by R. L. Palmer).Mintrop's work was clearly independentand Fessenden
The presentinvention . . . is characterizedin that the sound waves. . . are receivedsimultaneouslyor approximatelyso at a plurality (at least two . . .) of receivingstations. . . for the following reasons:Even in the simplestcasewhen it is known that the stratum to be examinedis horizontal there are two unknown quantitiesnamely(l) the averagevelocity of the reflectedwave . . . and (2) the depth of the reflecting stratumand thereloretwo equations... and two observations are consequentlynecessary. Despite their rather complete grasp of reflection seismology, this patent does not figure prominently in subsequent developments, which concentrated on refraction. Udden (1920) wrote in the Bulletin of the American Association oJ Petroleum Geologists (AAPG) (and illustrated with fig. 1.2): it ought to be possible,with presentrefinementsin physical apparatusand their use, to construct an instrument that would record the reflectionsof earth wavesstarted at the surlace, as they encounter such a well-marked plane of differencein hardnessand elasticityas that separatingthe Bend and Ellenberger formations (in North-central Texas).. . . A seismicwavemight be startedby an explosion at the surlaceof the Earth, and a record of the emergedreflection of this wave . . . might be registeredon an instrument placed at some distance from the point of explosion. . . . It ought to be possibleto notice the point at which the first reflection from the Ellenberger appears.. . . With a map of the surface of the Ellenberger,it seemsto me that millions ol dollars worth of drilling could be eliminated. ln 1920, the Geological Engineering Company was founded by Haseman, Karcher, Eckhardt, and McCollum to apply seismic exploration to finding petroleum. Karcher had recorded a seismic reflection
HISTORY OF SEISMIC EXPLORATION
Fig. 1.2 Reflection expected from the contact between the Bend formation and the underlying Ellenburger limestone. (From Udden. 1920.)
from wavesgeneratedby artillery at the Indian Head test range in Maryland in l9l7 and in a quarry (fig. l.l6a) in Washington,D.C., in 19l9 (Karcher,1987). They convertedan oscillographinto a thrqe-tracerecorder and constructed electrodynamicgeophones from radiotelephonereceivers.In June 1921,Karcher, Haseman, I. Perrine, and W C. Kite at Belle Isle (Oklahoma City) obtained a clear reflectionfrom the contact betweenthe Sylvan shaleand the Viola limestone (fig. 1.3).About five months of reflection and refraction experimentationwere carried out. One experiment involved dropping dynamite from an airplanein an attemptto obtain more nearlyplanewaves (Karcher had tried using aerial fireworksas a source in l9l9). The company ran out of funds when a surplus of oil forced the price down to l5llbarrel. The principals returned to their former jobs, except for McCollum. He agreed to settle with the company's creditors in return for the company's patents and equipment. During 1920-1, Mintrop (Keppner, l99l) shot refraction lines across two known salt domes in northern Germany and discoveredanother,the Meissendorf dome, although it had no commercial significance.In 1921,he founded Seismosto do geophysicalexploration and subsequentlywrote a number of pamphletspromoting refractionexploration.In 1922, Seismostried seismicmethods in Swedenfor mining objectivesand in Holland for coal mapping. EverettLee DeGolyer wrote on October 3,1922, to J. B. Body in London (the following threeextractsare from DeGolyer's papers in the library of Southern Methodist University,Dallas): Youwill remember thatduringthepastsummerDr. Barton, of the AmeradaPetroleumCorporation'sstaff,spentsome time in Europereceivinginstructionin the useof Eiitvos torsionbalances, andwhiletheremadeseveral visitsto Germanyto investigate other physicalmethodsof approachto geologicproblems. Oneof themethodswhichinterestedhim verymuch,and rrhichhe seemedto think had considerable possibility,was
the Seismic method. . . . I should like to suggestthat it be called to Dr Erbh [Shell's]attention with the recommendation that he consider its availability for use in the Mecatepec-Papantla District [Mexico]. . . . Body wrote to DeGolyer on December 14, 1922: You will have seenmy cableNo. 88. . . . "Negotiating
with Seismosfrom Hannover for using Mexico their method measuringwith seismographtransmissionwavescausedby explosionsthereby determining depth positions subterranean Tamasopoalso outline salt domes.Method gavesatislactory resultscentral Europe and are assuredcan be used Mexican conditions.Our intention is sendout party. . . ." Seismos party I began work in the Golden Lane area of Mexico for Mexican Eagle (Shell) in 1923. The contract for this work provided: Seismosbind themselvesto organizean expeditionin order to carry out the . . . investigations.. . . This expeditionshall consist of 2 seismologistsand I mechanic,all of them experts with thoroughly up-to-datetechnical knowledgeand possessing suchzeal and senseof duty as is requisitefor the successof their work. [They were]to be equippedwith two complete seismicfield-stationswith the necessaryinstruments . . . to carry out in Mexico during 25 days effectual observations.. . ina geologicallyknownterritory. . . . Upon arrival the expedition shall confer with the local manager . . . who shall decidewhereand when their operationsshall be carried out and to the solutions of which geologicalproblemssameshall be applied,on the understandingthat as far as purely scientificquestionsare concerned. .. they shall usetheir own discretion.. . . Compensation was to be U.5.$600 for the two seismologists together and $150 for the mechanic during the time the expedition was in Mexico and $500 for the instruments. If Mexican Eagle so elected, the contract "by could be replaced a new contract concluded for an indefinite period and for observations in Mexican regions geologically unknown." In this case, monthly compensation was to be increased to $800 and $250 for the men and $1000 for the instruments. The geological problem involved finding high-velocity lime-
INTRODUCTION
{ JT ti.ili$
te
$
* *
t $!i#s
:ilfl' Jstr e r
t'
, .:1 .,,1 ir!*
t -*i.$Jr- s" -S "rL*'*e*"-q,-h.
! :
tii
cletattt*s E.1.. o.tu^
Vlc la. Ltnestone
ot t.t.'ALoue !aYar Sla
.
Scctionon VincCreeh r'r'l !inch.l00/t Ju$ 22 flooc4s attircl
it1,t. l92l
(b)
&c 27
(c,
Fig. 1.3 First application of the reflection seismographto exploration. (From Schriever, 1952.) (a) Two reflection records made in September l92l: E marks the explosion time, R the reflection from the Viola limestone, and BP the airwave (blast-
phone). (b) First depth section,at Vines Branch, Oklahoma, August 9, 1921. (c) First seismic structure map! near Ponca City, O k l a h o m a . S e p t e m b e rl 9 2 l .
stone reefsunder a shalecover,a situation for which refraction appearedto be ideal. Seismos party 2 began work in Oklahoma and Texas for Marland Oil Company (a predecessorof Conoco), also in 1923. Seismosparty 1 moved to Texasto work for Gulf Oil rn 1924and in Junediscoveredthe Orchard Dome southwestof Houston, which is usuallyconsideredto be the first seismic(refraction) hydrocarbon discovery,a claim disputed by McCollum (see what follows). Early refraction records are shown in figs. l.4a and 1.4b.
The Seismoscrewsuseda mechanicalseismograph (fig. 1.5) consistingof a masssuspendedby a horizontal leaf spring with a natural frequencyof about l0 Hz. The only amplification was mechanicaland optical, and recordingwas done by directing a beam of light onto a mirror connectedto the massby a hair so that the mirror rotated when the massmoved,and then onto a strip of photographicpaper moved by a hand crank turned by the observer.Shotpoint-toseismographdistancewas surveyedand a blastphone (fig. 1.6) was used to record the airwave to find the
end continue again at the left end. TB : shot instant obtained by radio and R : refraction arrival. (b) Refraction record, Texas,June 1932.
Fig. 1.4 Early refractionrecords.(Courtesyof Conoco.)(a) Recordobtainedwith mechanicalseismograph,1924 or 1925; therecordingwashelicalabouta drum so that tracesat theright
7
q l
r--t
d | . "
=+l-^ iII I I\
l-tncto'
I
/s , r
t
/ i .
- ' -
f . ' t I (r' f
--./
- /
t
|
,\
l..r.ai f-.
ftir.J 0
tqh;at.;,ot
2'
'ot.;tr.9..tt ',h.
tt"
X-
\
q
Oll..ttt'
a
C.--..a1
7eat.
Fis. I h Sho*tat Oa. Nolc
-
gnleoa
Schoaerr'<
Votficc
a..t t
Soit n.
C.n..r.^t
t?
llochcarcol
pottftoq.?
Fraraaatlt
cl
Artoateaott ol
?e.t,
Estiraoar
t.t'ao
?..1.fo.
Scaaot..ah,
OLS2troe Shilling
Ecitaot>oph,
f'c-lo
4..h..
t!r.
l.'t...r.1.a.
2.a.ar'.-
of
t.
OLto.tce
2....ar.
gnr1, Trre
Fig. 1.5 Mintrop's mechanical seismograph.Movement of the case with respect to the inertial mass tilted the aluminum cone,
pulling on the hair and rotating the mirror. (From Malamphy, 1929.)
INTRODUCTION
Fig.1.6 Blastphone usedto detect theairwave for determining shot-detector distance. The diaphragm d is a pie tin and the shot instant. (Subsequently, radio was used to determine the shot instant and the airwavearrival to find the shot-to-detectordistance.)The overall sensitivity and precision were low and profiles were only 3t,/z miles long, which gave limited penetration so that Seismoscrewsmisseda numberof domesat moderate depths.L. P. Garrett of Gulf Oil, for whom Seismos was working, developed the fan-shooting method ($l I . I .2) about I 925,which increasedthe effectiveness in locatingsalt domes.By 1929,the refractionmethod had found fifty salt domes that resultedin hydrocarbon discoveries(Sweet, 1978).During the same period, "geology and accident" discoveredone dome (Barton 1929:616). Followingthe failure of the GeologicalEngineering Companyin 1922,McCollum obtainedthe backingof Atlantic Refining and formed McCollum Geological Exploration to carry out refractionwork. New equipment wasbuilt, and in 1924both reflectionand refraction was usedin the Tampico areaof Mexico.The first well drilled on a seismiclocation, La Gatero No. 4, was dry, although the seismicprediction was correct. In May 1924, the Zacamixtle 199 well in the Golden Lane area succeededin finding oil, to dispute the claim of the Orchard Dome in Texas as the first seismic discovery. However, the Mexican well was noncommercialat the time becauseof its remote location (Owen, 1975).In 1928the Atlantic-McCollum joint venture was dissolved;McCollum and Atlantic divided the four sets of instruments and McCollum formed McCollum Exploration Company.
transducer a carbon granule microphone. (Photographed at the Museum of the Geophysical Society of Houston.)
The Marland Oil Company had supported two months of the l92l GeologicalEngineeringCompany reflection experimentation(which was unsuccessful) and had brought Seismosparty 2 to Texasin 1923. The Seismosparty failed to find any salt domes for Marland. In 1925, Marland hired Haseman, Eckhardt, Eugene McDermott and others to develop a more sensitiveelectrical seismograph.The Marland field party began exploration in 1926, replacing the Seismosparty. The equipmentworked well, but Marland never recorded a salt dome discovery. 1.2.4 The GeophysicalResearchCorporation DeGolyer was at first disappointedwith the refraction method, but successby Seismoscrews working for Gulf changedhis mind and he beganto searchfor personnel to develop seismicmethods. He learned of Karcher's 1921experimentsand in May 1925, Amerada, Rycade (an Amerada subsidiary)and Karcher fiormed the Geophysical Research Corporation (GRC). They acquiredFessenden's patent and his servicesas consultant. GRC built an electricalseismographthat was much more sensitivethan the Seismosmechanicalseismograph. The detector was a variable-reluctancetype and the amplifier was resistance-coupled using a vacuum tube. The oscillographused two galvanometers and the recording film was hand-cranked.Timing lines were obtained by shining a light through slits attachedto the prongs of a 50-Hz tuning fork. The
HISTORYOF SEISMICEXPLORATION time-break (shot instant) was transmitted by interrupting a CW (continuous-wave) transmitter. GRC fielded sevenfield parties in 1926and refraction explorationgreatlyexpanded.A GRC crew under E. E. Rosaire was forbidden to shoot profiles more than 3t/z miles in length, which had becomethe standard distancesince it had been successfulfor Mintrop, but the observers"got lost" and discoveredthe Port Barre salt dome (Sweet, 1978). Thereafter, the standard distancebecame6 miles. Refraction at the time was used as a reconnaissance method and was usually followed by detailing with a torsion balance(and later gravimeter)survey. GRC party 6, an experimentalcrew,tried reflection work in Kansasin 1926.They soon moved to Texas and obtained usable reflection records from the caprock of the Nash salt dome.Other GRC partiesalso experimentedat recording reflections.ln 1927,party 6 moved to the SeminoleBasin of Oklahoma, an area ideally suited to reflection work, where they soon found a structure that becamethe first discoveryby the reflectionmethod, the Maud Field (in 1928).This successwas quickly followed by others,and by 1930, the reflectionmethod beganto take over from the relraction method.Early reflectionrecordsare shownin fis.1.16.
Fig. 1.7 The Petty prototype geophone. The "steady mass" m rs on a long beam hinged (h) at the left and supported by a strong spring s. At the right end, the beam is attached to one plate of an air-gap condenserc. Movement of the case with respect to the steadymasschangesthe separationof the condenser
;
s3 I I F
r +.
,e.
*
t
I
9 1.2.5 Other activitiesin the 1920s Humble Oil Company, at the instigation of Wallace E. Pratt, establisheda geophysicaldepartment in 1924 under Dr. N. H. Ricker, and the following year fielded two refraction crews using mechanical seismographs designed by O. H. Truman (Carlton, 1946). These crewsbeganusing a telephoneline to carry the timebreak, but beforethe end of 1925,they usedradio for both communicationsand transmissionof the timebreak. Frank Rieberln 1924obtainedfunding (from General Petroleum, Standard Oil of California. Associated, and Shell) for a refraction survey in the San Joaquin valley of California. This survey was unsuccessfulin obtaining deep information. Rieber carried out other surveysin California in 1921,8,but his company failed in 1930.ln 1932,he beganwork on reflection instruments,and in subsequentyearsintroduced a number of instrumentalinnovations. ln 1925,the Petty GeophysicalEngineeringCompany was formed by Dabney E. Petty and Olive Scott Petty (and other family members). They felt they could easily improve on Mintrop's mechanicalseismograph, and in 1926fielded a crew equipped with condenser-type geophones(fig. 1.7)and vacuum-tube amplifiers.They used string galvanometers(fig. 1.8)
plates, the change in capacity being proportional to the displacement. The dimensions are 48 X 32 x 15 cm. (photographed at the Museum of the Geophysical Society of Houston.)
10
Fig. 1.8 String-galvanometerharp. Currents pass through fine wires (some are broken on this harp) held taut by small springs. causing the wires to be deflected in a magnetic field. Shadows
and a camerawith photographicpaper pulled along by a springmotor, shadowscastby the moving strings on the paper were recorded.The Pettysdid appreciable experimentationto find a quicker, easierway to locatesalt domes.They discoveredthat a salt forerunby its amner (fig. 1.9),which could be distinguished plitude, could be usedto tell if a salt dome had been encountered even without knowing the shot-todetectordistance.They also found that the Rayleighwave pattern changedwhen a salt dome intervened and usedthis fact when they could not get a readable P-wave.The increasedsensitivityof their equipment and their interpretationalingenuity allowed them to surveywith smallershotsthan others used. ln 1927,the first well velocity measurementswere made. A geophonelowered5000ft (1500m) into a Gulf well in Kansas recordedthe traveltime from a shot at the surface.Also in 1927.C. A. Heiland establishedthe first coursein explorationgeophysicsat the ColoradoSchoolof Mines. McCollum successfullymapped the Barbers Hill Dome by reflectionin 1928using 100detectorsat each station spacedto attenuatehorizontal waves,but the use of multiple detectorswas too cumbersomeand so was abandoned;it was revived about the mid-1930s with four to six detectorsper group. In the late 1920s,seismicexplorationbeganto move abroad: to Persia (Iran) and Venezuelain 192'7,to Australia in 1929.to the NetherlandsEast Indies in 1930. Donald C. Barton (1929), who subsequentlybecame first president of the Society of Exploration Geophysicists(SEG), describedthe early methods: method,a trooprather Forworkwith themirage[refraction] of onefiringunit,two, threeor four recommonlyconsists ceivingunits,a squadof hole diggers,a chiefof party,a "landman," a crewof surveyandin somecases a calculator, . . . Thefiringunit. . . is .ors,andin somea hole-fillingcrew. ... to firethecharge, apparatus with thenecessary equipped
INTRODUCTION
of the wireswerefocusedonto photographicpaper.A stringat the recordis shownin fig. I . I 6e.(Photographed galvanometer Societyof Houston.) Museumof the Geophysical
with meteorologicalapparatusand with a sendingand receiving wirelessset,which is usedto communicatewith the receiving units and to send out the instant of the explou n i t . . . i s e q u i p p e dw i t h a s e i s m o sion... . The receiving graph, . . . a wirelesssendingand receivingset,and meteorologicalapparatus.... To set up a station,a 3 inch hole is dug to a depth of 3 ft, the geophonecableis reeledout and the geophoneis dropped down the hole. . . . Each receiving unit ... signalsthat tentativelyit is ready to receive.... When all . . . have signaledtheir o.k. for firing, the firing mastersetshis wirelesssendingout a continuouswavenote, . . . waits a standardshort interval and then fires the charge. The wirelesskey is held down by a circuit which goesaround the dynamite.The explosioninstantaneouslybreaksthe circuit, causesthe releaseof the wirelesskey and the instantaneous [sic] cutting off of the wirelessnote. . . . The average chargesused ... range from 40 to 250 lbs. For the same shots,SeismosGesellschaftwould use two to three times as largeacharge.... In the reflectiontype ofshooting, the chargeis very much smaller.. . . The practice. . . [is to placethe] main charge17 to 25 ft down a 6 inch hole and the auxiliary chargeat the surface.The latter is usedto producean air wave.The holes are dug with hand augers... . The distancebetweenthe fir... rangesfrom 1.2 to 1.8 ing point and the seismograph times the depth of the lormation which it is desired to m a p . . .. A scout from a rival companynot uncommonly is set to watch the troop and to report their activity to his company and especiallyto report anything to indicate that possibly they may havepickedup a salt dome. He often getsto be on good terms with the troop, but at critical momentsthey go to all sortsof strategyto outwit him. 1.2.6 Early geophysical case history The exploration of Cameron Meadows field, a salt dome in Louisiana, documented by McGuckin (1945), provides interesting comparisons of early exploration methods. Attention was first called to this "sulphur gas" seeps ("boils") in the area because of "no recognizable physiographic marsh. The area has
HISTORY OF SEISMIC EXPLORATION
11
I '!
I I
I I
II
lxJII Utl.ihIlit Iil ll u IL,illul
Fig. 1.9 Refraction recording, 1930.(a)Normal(nosalt)record;(b) recordshowingsaltforerunner; (c) recordingtruckin
use about this time. (Parts (a) and (b) are from petty, 1976; parl (c) is courtesy of Haliburton Geophysical Services.)
expression. . . [exceptthat] Old North Bayou. . . may possiblybe deflectedslightly," accordingto the Louisiana GeologicalBulletin No. 6 in 1935. A seriesof geophysicalsurveyswere carried out from 1926to 1943.They had different objectivesand covereddifferentareas.Hence,the maps shownin fig. l.l0 were to different scalesbut they have been enlargedor reducedto facilitatecomparisons. The SeismosCompany used its one-channelmechanical seismographto shoot refraction over this areain 1926as part ofa larger survey.Seismosgenerally built tiny isletsof sandbagsto support its detector abovethe water.The report said: "The surfaceindications around the shellhill of tent location 145.its sud-
den uplift out of a very deep marsh, and a gas seep south of it, lead to the conclusion that it migtrt Ui causedby the presenceofharder layers.However,the investigations. . . show clearly that no harder layers occur down to considerabledepths.. . . there may be a possibility to find a structurein sections2I and 2g of this region."The main part of the CameronMeadows field was subsequentlydiscoveredin section 21. Seismosinterpreted(correctly) SW-dip southwestof the recordingstation(fig. l.l0a).'source-detectordistances of less than 3.5 miles did not provide very deeppenetration. A reconnaissancetorsion balance survey in l92j (fig. 1.10b)indicateda large closedgravity minimum
t2
INTRODUCTION
|'
1
>:
I
\l,l:
a
a
.9+.
I
tc
-.&'d'
PROOU
3 SEEP3
t\
tl
/
a
(b)
the same Fig. 1.10 A sequence of maps(to approximately domebasedon theearlygeoscale)of theCameronMeadows (FromMcGuckin,1945:1-16.)(a) Seismos physical surveys. reconmechanical refractionmap,1926.(b) Torsion-balance (c)Geophysical gravitygradients. naissance map,1927, showing Research Corp.(GRC)refractionfan map,1928;the filled-in refractionmap,1929. areasindicateleads.(d) GRCcorrelation (i) Map (e)Geophysical map,1933. Service, Inc.,dip reflection wellsthatencountered of thetop of saltlromdrilling,showing
salt.(g) Top-saltmap from McCollumrefractionshootinginto a well, 1942.(h) Top-saltprofile from McCollum refractionsurvey into a well and from well data;the deepestmap ofthe 1942 Pettycontinuousprofiling surveyis alsoindicated.(i) PettyGeophysicalEngineeringCo. continuousprofiling reflectionmap to definefaulting on the south flank, 1942.O RobertH. Ray,Inc., gravimetersurvey,1943,showingalso residualgravity (dashed contours).
centeredin section24 at the left edgeof the fig. l. l0 maps.An unsuccessfulwell was drilled on this minimum; the Cameron Meadows area lay 3 miles to the east on the easternflank of the minimum. A refraction fan shot in 1928from SP-9(fig. l.l0c) indicated a salt lead (in the direction of the blackedin area), but a secondfan from SP-78was interpreted as failing to confirm the lead, and it was concluded that no salt dome was present.However,additional fans shot to averagedistancesof 8 miles in 1929(one in the upper left corner offig. l.l0c) suggesteda salt dome in section21. A follow-up correlationreflection survey lasting I 7 days in July 1929(fig. I . l0d) mapped the closureon which the discoverywell, completedin 1931, was drilled. A dip-method survey (fig. 1.10e)
wasrun in 1933to serveas a guide for further drilling. A map of the top salt basedon 15 wells is shown in fig. l.l0f. The jump correlationsin the correlationand dip-methodsurveysprecludedthe mapping of faults. Becausethe refraction fans had suggestedan extension to the southeastwhere the seepswere located, a seriesof radial lines were shot in 1942into a geophone located near the salt in an abandoned well on the northeast flank of the dome (the method is describedin $11.1.3).The resultingfnap of the salt dome, shown in fig. l.l0g, can be comparedwith fig. offig. l.l0h showsthe general l.l0f. The cross-section agreementbetween seismicand well results. Continuous profiling was carried out in 1942 to map the southeasternnosing that had been indicated
HISTORY OF SEISMIC EXPLORATION
l3
'1,
by shootinginto the well. This surveydefinedfaulting and the deepestmap, a phantom severalthousandfeet above the salt, is shown in fig. 1.10i. No rerlections were recordedin the mainly shalesectionbelow this phantom, although the shale section also contains someprospectivesands. ln 1943,a gravimetersurvey (fig. 1.10j)conducted over the areaconfirmedthe earliertorsion balanceresults.It showedthe producing areaat the SE-edgeof a residualgravity anomaly. 1.2.7 Developmentof the geophysicalcontracting industry Burton McCollum in 1922 applied for a patent on "Method and apparatusfor determiningthe contour of subterraneanstrata," which was issued in 1928 along with two other patentson variationsof seismic methods. McCollum sold two of his patents to the TexasCompanyin 1928and sevenmore between1929
and 1935.These and other patents were transferred to the Texas Development Company, which tried to collect royalties from others but was mainly unsuccessful. In 1934, they sued Sun Oil Company for patent infringement.Almost the entire petroleumindustry joined with Sun in the defense;the matter was settledout of court in 1937.The settlementinvolved companies forming a SeismicImmunities Group and granting each other royalty-freelicensesof their patents and of patents for which they might file within a year of withdrawal from the group. Initially, 64 patents were involved, including 2 of Mintrop's, l0 of McCollum's,2 of Harvey C. Hayes',8 of Fessenden's, and 2 of Karcher's. Severalpayment schemescould be elected;one involved a lifetime payment of $10,000 per party, a party being defined as either (a) a single recording unit with no more Ihan 12 traces or (b) up to four recording units where shot-to-detector distance exceeded2 miles (to cover respectivelyreflection and refraction work). The Mayne CDP patent (see
14 $1.2.9)was one of the last important patentsinvolved before the group disbanded entirely. ln 1929, a new Amerada president decided that GRC would no longer do reflection work for other companies (Karcher, 1987). Although Petty and McCollum offered independent alternativesto accomplish geophysicalwork and some oil companies, such as Humble and Gulf, operatedtheir own crews, the oil companiesin generalencouragedthe formation of more new geophysicalenterprises.Thus, the early 1930ssaw the advent of many geophysicalcontractors,includingmost that dominatetoday.Most of thesewere formed by people who left GRC since it dominatedthe industry until then; some of theseare shownin fig. l.l L In addition,a few companies(such as Rogersand General) were formed by people who left other companiessuch as Petty, and still other companies(such as Heiland) were formed without clear connectionsto precedingindustry. Most of the major geophysicalcontractorsthrough the 1980scan be traceddirectly back to spinoffsfrom GRC. Haliburton GeophysicalServiceswas the successorto GeophysicalServiceInc. (GSI), which was lormed in 1930(aswell as successor to other companies,including Petty).Schlumbergeris successor to Seismograph ServiceCorp.(SSC)formedin 193l (and to Seismosand Prakla). Teledyneis successorto Independent Exploration formed in 1932. Western Geophysical Company, formed in 1933, is still independent;it has now taken over Haliburton Geophysical Services. Grant Geophysics is successor to United Geophysical,formed in 1935.Compagnie Generale de G6ophysique (CGG) is successorto SGRM, which began refraction work in France in | 930. The field work of Seismosdeclinedto zero in 193I . but Seismosrevived refraction work in Germany in 1934and beganreflectionwork about the sametime. Prakla was foundedin 1936and subsequentlymerged with Seismos to form Prakla Seismos.The rapid growth of explorationgeophysicswas almost entirely due to privateenterprisewith intenserivalry and competition and extremesecrecybetweenthe individual companiesinvolved.From the early 1930sto the early 1990s,no singlecompany dominatedgeophysicalexploration. However, by 1994 only two large contracting companies,Schlumbergerand Western,continued (seefig. 1.24).
INTRODUCTION
ggN|@:
(vrNNNNNNNN \iW,{u
YNiW, );tfrflffiir
--
w;i tK<.M' -'i/-
)
i
:Jv-/'
PEIROLCUM
'Amerada F-ig. Lll The Tree," a diagram drawn in 1950 to show geophysicalcontracting companies formed by people who left GRC. (W J. Zwart and K. M. Lawrence located this historic document.)
Fig. l.l2 Growth of multichannel recording. The starting point in l914 is Mintrop's first portable seismograph.The vertical scale gives the first known instance of use of numbers of channels.The use ofgroup recorders in the 1980seffectivelyremoved an upper limit on the number of channelsexcept for operational practicality. In one instance, 4000 channels reputedly were used.
1.2.8Evolutionof refiectionequipmentand methods The first GRC reflection work in 1926 employed the same two-galvanometerarrangementused in refraction work, but a third galvanometerwas addedsoon. A four-channelsystemwas built in 1928and before long six-channelinstrumentswerein use;the standard was 6 to 8 in 1937and by 1940most crewswere l0 to l2 channel.The number of channelshas continuedto increase(fig. l.l2). For many years after World War II, 24 channelswere standard,then in the late 1960s.
48 channelsbecamecommon, and today (1994)most crewsuse 120 to 240 channelsand someuse appreciably more. Digitization at the geophone(97.5.2)has now effectivelyremovedlimits,onthe numberof channels that can be recorded. The mechanical seismographwas soon replaced with electricalgeophonesand vacuum-tubeamplifiers. The early electrical geophoneswere mostly of
HISTORY OF SEISMICEXPLORATION three types: capacitance, variable-reluctance,and moving-coil electrodynamic;oil damping was generally used.Early electricalgeophones(fig. 1.13)had to havehigh sensitivitybecauseof the high noiselevelof availablevacuum tubes. For the variable reluctance and moving-coil types, this meant large magnetsbecauseof the low permeabilityof the magneticmaterials then available.As better magneticmaterials and lower-noisevacuum tubes becameavailable,the electromagneticgeophoneincreasedin sensitivityand decreasedin weight (from some 15 kg to a few hundred grams),electromagneticdamping replacedoil damping, and the electromagnetictype eventuallybecame dominant (for land work). As a result of these improvements,multiple geophonesper channelbecame practical; this usagewas introduced in 1933and was common practiceby 1937. The gain of early instrumentswas constantand repeatedshotswere usually required so that reflections at severalarrival times could be mapped.Sometimes the gain was manually changedduring the recording by the operatorturning a switch.About 1932,automatic gain control was developed,first by changing the grid biaswith time after the time-break,laterby a feedbackcircuit.Amplifiersincreased in gain,sophist i c a t i o n( i n i t i a ls u p p r e s s i o n a .u t o m a t i cg a i n .m i x i n g . etc.),and reliability.A lO-channel recorderfrom 1931. the first to change frequency responsewith time, rs shownin fig. 1.14.Sometiming wheelsare shownin fig. l.l5 and reflectionrecordsare shownin fig. 1.16. About 1950, recording instrumentsbecame sufficiently reliablethat the observercould "do a day's work ratherthan instrumentrepair and adjustment." The Southwestern IndustrialElectronics(SIE) Company'sP-l I recordingsystemwas a major advancein
F i g . l . l 3 E a r l y g e o p h o n e si n t h e M u s e u m o f t h e G e o p h y s i c a l S o c i e t y o f ' H o u s t o n . T h e g e o p h o n e sw e i g h ( l e f t t o r i g h t , b a c k
l5 reliability.A chronologyof someinstrumentdevelopmentsis givenin table 1.1. The need for weatheringcorrections ($8.8.2)was recognizedvery early and shallow refraction shots were often made for this purpose.The first mapping was done by correlating reflectionson widely separatedprofiles(fig. l.l7). Barton (1929)wrote: a depthdetermination is madeby eachshotandto mapthe dip,foldingor faultingofthe surface, . . . it is necessary only to scatter"shots"over the areato be mappedand draw structure-contours or profilesfrom the results.Practically the applicationof the methodis somewhat uncertain. ... Theimpossibility of recognizing thereflecting bedis a seriousdisadvantage.... The correlationmethod did not work well in the Gulf Coast becausethe area lacks distinctivereflections. ln 1929.T. I. Harkins noticedthatabnormal stepouts [dipmoveout see94.1.2] wererathercharacteristic of the (Darrowdome)areaand that theseabnormalstepoutsreversed. He correctlyattributedthisphenomenon to dippingbeds.[Rosaire andAdler 19341 Soon dip shootingwas carriedout along continuous lines of traverse. Although from the earliestdays crewscarried out surveysin water-coveredareas,the methodswere basically those for land crews,improvisedfor use in water.Petty(1976)describes a surveyin Chacahoula Swamp,Louisiana,in 1926(fiC. l.l8), and in 192'/, GRC fielded two crews for work in water-covered areas (Rosaireand Lester, 1932).Sidney Kaufman (personalcommunication),in lollowing up an onshorelead in 1938,took his Shellshallow-water crew seaward4 miles into 65 feet of water. Survevorson-
r o w )6 . 1 8, . 7 , 7 . 9 , 6 .(7f r,o nrto w )8 . 8a, n d0 . 8k g .A r r h el o w e r right is a modern phone(30 g) for comparison.
F ' i g .l . 1 4 P e t t y l 0 - c h a n n e lr e c o r d e rf r o m 1 9 3 1 .V a c u u m t u b e s "harp" H V amplified the current, which then passedthrough a (of the type shown in fig. 1.8): light fiom a source L passedby the harp and was focusedonto photographic paper in the takeup
m a g a z i n eM . A t i m i n g w h e e lT ( s e ef i g . l . l 5 ) d r i v e n b y a c l o c k interrupted the light to give the timing lines. (Photographed at the Museum of the Geophysical Society of Houston.)
Early timing wheels ("paddle wheels"). The wheels Fig. l.l5 were rotated by a clock motor so that they cut the light beam to produce timing line shadows. C)bserversoften had individual-
ized wheels that characterized their records. (Photographed the Museum of the Geophysical Society of Houston.)
-ivl='--
r l
l l
(a)
hfiln,ipael=
P oartcc
.i :.l.::]j :ti ..";..i .,.l. ......i .i l: :';J]':T'j
(f)
Fig. 1.16 Early reflection records. (a) First record made in a rock quarry near Washington, D.C., April 12, 1919,by Karcher. Time increasesfrom right to left; the upper trace is the timebreak; the lower traces are the geophone responseat different gains. Three reflections are marked. (From Schriever,1952.)(b) Record showing reflection from caprock of the Nash Dome,
Texas, 1926; the charge is I pound; the offset is 950 ft. (From Weatherby, 1940.) (c) 1929 three-channel Oklahoma record showing Viola reflecrion. (From Weatherby, 1945.)(d) 1929 rec_ ord from Cimarron anhydrite in Kansas. (e) 1934 Californra record with AGC. (From Weatherby, 1940.) (f) l93g srrinegalvanometer record lrom Mississippi.
INTRODUCTION
l8
Table 1.1 Chronologyof seismicinstumentation and methods l9l4 l9l7 1921 1923 1925
1926 1927 1929 l93l
1932 1933 1936 1939 1942 1944 194-l 1950 1951
Mintrop'smechanicalseismograph patent on seismicmethod Fessenden Seismicreflection work by Geological EngineeringCo. Refraction exploration by Seismosin Mexico and Texas Fan-shooting method Electrical refraction seismograph Radio used lor communications and/or timebreak Reflection correlation method First well velocity survey Reflectiondip shooting Reversedrefractionprofiling Use of uphole phone Truck-mounteddrill Automatic gain control Interchangeablefilters Use of multiple geophones pcr group Riebersonograph;first reproducible recording Use of closedloops to checkmisties Record sections Mixing Large-scalemarine surveying Use of largepatterns Marine shootingwith Shoran Common-midpointmethod+ Medium-rangeradionavigation
1952 1953 1954 1955 1956 196l-2 1963 1965 1967 1968 1969 19'71 1972 1974 19'15 19?6 1984
1985 1986 1988 I 989 1990
Analog magnetic recording* Vibroseisrecording* Weight-dropping Continuousvelocity logging Moveablemagneticheads Centraldata processing Analog deconvolutionand velocity filtering Digital data recording* Air-gun seismicsource Depth controllerson marine streamer Binary gain Velocity analysis Transitsatellitepositioning Instaneousfloating-pointamplifier statics Surface-consistent Bright spot as hydrocarbon indicator Digitization in the field Seismicstratigraphy Three-dimensionalsurveying Image-ray migration (depth migration) Amplitude variation with offset Determiningporosity from amplitude DMO (dip-moveout)processing Interpretationworkstations Towing multiple streamers S-waveexoloration Autopicking of 3-D volumes Dip and azimuth displays Acoustic positioningof streamers GPS satellitepositioning
*The acceptanceofthese methodsis shown in fig. 1.21. Dates are approximate;secrecyand competition often in-
volved developmentand use of the samefeature by several companieswithout public disclosure.
shore directed locations and this imposed the 4-mile limit. The survey was conducted from three 35-foot fishing boats.The instrumentswere eight-channelusing one land geophoneper channel bolted to an l8inch steelplate to keep it upright on the seafloor. Extensivemarine operationsdid not appear until 1944when Superior and Mobil beganrefraction fanshootingfor salt domesoffshoreLouisiana(Jack Lester, personal communication).A survey to map the offshore extension of Los Angeles basin fields was also carried out about this time (C. C. Bates,personal communication). A surveyor onshore gave lnstructions to keep lines straight while wire paying out through a countergavethe distance;buoyswere setto indicate locations. As work progressedfarther offshore,the chaining continuedon a compassbearing. Sightingon shot plumes(watersentup into the air by the shot explosion)both visually and with radar was also used. Surveying was the principal operational problem and often constitutedthe major cost. Shoran came into use about 1946,followed by Raydistabout 1951.The early refraction and reflection work used geophonesplanted on the bottom. About 1946' reflection work began using a l2-channelbottom drag
cable with gimble-mountedgeophones.The floating streamerwasfirst usedin 1949-50.Both the radionavigation methodsand the floating streamerwere based Proffitt (1991)sumon World War II developments. work. marizesthe history of marine I .2.9 Reprodut'ible recording, the common-midpoint sources method,and nonexplosive "Sonograph" Frank Rieber (1936) proposed the method of recordingseismicdata (fig. L 19) so that it "played back." His oscillographrecordedin could be variable density on film. On playback, variations in the intensity of a light beam that passedthrough the film weredetectedby a photocell.Rieberusedthe Sonograph to determinethe variation of reflectionamplitudewith apparentdip. DespiteRieber'spioneeringwork, reproduciblerecording did not becomepractical until the introduction of magnetic-tape recording. Commercial recording and playback equipment became available about 1952.The principal advantageof magnetic-tape recordingwas thought to be the ability to replaywith different filters.About 1955,moveableheadsallowed
HISTORY OF SEISMIC EXPLORATION
t9
static and normal-moveout corrections ($6.1) to be applied. The growth of analog magnetic-taperecordingis shownin fig. 1.21. A very important postwardevelopmentwas the use of record sectionsfor interpretation.Individual seismic recordshad been laid out adjacentto each other in the interpretationprocessfor a long time (fig. 1.20), but the large sizeofindividual recordsand variations in paperspeedand developingquality madeit difficult to obtain a synopticview.Normal moveout($4.1.1), irregularitiesin recordingor spreads,and the wiggletrace display mode added to the difficulties. Gulf Oil and Carter (now part of Exxon) and perhapsShell apparently led in developing variable-density or rariable-areadisplayswith uniform horizontal scale .rnd display amplitude.Carter bought Rieber'sequrpment for this use(amongothers)about 1946. Common-midpoint(CMP, originally calledCRP or -'ommon-reflectionpoint, later CDP or commonjepth point; see $8.3.3)recordingwas inventedby Harry Mayne (Petty Geophysical)in 1950as a way of .lttenuatingnoisethat could not be handledby the use ..i arrays.Magnetic-taperecordingmadeCMP practi-rl. and CMP recordingbeganabout 1956,but it did
not becomeusedextensivelyuntil the early 1960s(fig. l.2l) when its ability to attenuatemultiples ($6.3.2) and other kinds of noiseled to rapid adoption. Today, its useis nearly universal. Magnetic-taperecording also permitted the addition of tracesand thus the use of weaker sourcesbecause records from severalweak sourcescould be added togetherto get the effect of a strongersource. McCollum introduced the use of a dropped weight, the Thumpeq as a seismicsourceabout 1953.Weightdropping expandedseismicwork in areasof difficult shothole drilling, such as West Texas,and in desert areaswherewater for drilling is scarce. A variety of surfacesourcesfor use on land were also developedbesidesweight-dropping.The mosr ingeniousof these,the VibroseisrM method(see97.3.1;a list of trademarksand the companiesthat hold them is given in app. B) was developedby John M. Crawford, William Doty, and Milford Lee and first usedin 1953.Surfacesourcesare now usedfor about half the land work and Vibroseisis the predominant surface source.Severalalternativesto the use of dynamite as a source in the marine environmentwere developed about 1965.They were generallycheaperand more
::g LI7 Portion ofa dip map that resulted from dip shooting, .ruary 1935. Dips were expressed in feet per mile and the
arrow lengths indicated the spacing for 50-ft contours. (Courtesy of Conoco.) N
t
Ol
-J-
I
I oLtGocEXa oto
CONTINENTAL OIL COMPANY SEISMOSSTRUCTUREMAP ru ABBEVILL4 u l.16'
ull-l:ttJ_g
frm_eurall__ l-+tuPcdu-m Gntmttttil! svdt? 6ru Il5l
Fv
r.
t€
q
INTRODUCTION
20
.7r
"..$'$
Fig. 1.18 Early refraction work. (From Petty, 1976.) (a) D. E. Peity washes a reiraction record in Chacahoula Swamp; the
efficient and adaptable to CMP recording. Consequently, they rapidly replaceddynamite as a marine source(fig. l.2l). In addition,they wereenvironmentally acceptablebecausethey did not injure marine life. Although some sophisticatedplayback processing was done with magnetic-taperecordingand somedig-
t
*rf r{
,.t *
geophone is on the cypress stump in the background. (b) Petty (in boat) with his crew in Chacahoula Swamp.
ital processingwas done on analog data, the full potential of data processingwas not achieveduntil digital recording was introduced in the 1960s.Digital recordingnot only resultedin higher fidelity, but also in the large-scaleapplication of the digital computer in the processingand interpretation of seismicdata' "digital revolution" was probably the most farThe
HISTORY OF SEISMIC EXPLORATION
Rieber's sonograph, 1936. Field data were recorded Fig. l.l9 on fiI. in variable-density mode. In playback, the total light through a slit was summed to give a single output trace By ohanging the slit angle, data with various angles of approach (alsoialied apparent dip; see$4.1.2)could be emphasized,each
reachingdevelopmentin seismicexplorationsincethe pioneeringdays. For example,obtaining useful data in the North Seais almostimpossiblewithout deconvolution($9.5). I .2.I0 Recanthistor)) Sincethe developmentof the common-midpoint,Vimethods,a succession broseis,and digital-processing have expanded many improvements incremental of lbld the amount of geologicinformation extractable from seismic data. In consequence,the seismic method is being applied in ways not previouslycontemplated. The prevailingconcept prior to the 1970swas that noise was so much stronger than the seismicsignal that only structural information could be extracted from seismicdata on a practicablebasis;consequently, the emphasiswas almost exclusivelyon noiseattenuation in order to obtain more accuratetraveltimes.Recognition in the early 1970sthat a hydrocarbonaccumulation sometimeschangedthe reflectivity enough "direct" detection and mapping led to to allow its more accuraterecordingand interpretationof amplitude information. In the mid-1970s,recognitionof depositionalpatternsin seismicdata further changedattitudes and gave rise to the belief that much of what had previously been regarded as noise was actually geologic signal. The developmentof threedimensional(3-D) methodsin the late 1970sbeganto resolvethe interpretation ambiguitiesinherent in in-
2l
slit angle giving an additional trace. Thus, the sonogram record displayed amplitude in the angle-of-approach versus arrivaltime domain. (Two views from advertisements in Geophysit's, vols. I and 2.)
terpolating between seismiclines and also provided significantnoisereduction.3-D revealsso much structural and stratigraphicdetail that its use in reservoir engineeringis growing very rapidly (seefig. l.2l). It had long beenrecognizedthat the combined use of S- and P-waveswould permit extractingmore useful geologic information than from P-wavesalone. The developmentof S-wavesourcesresultedin appreciableexperimentationin the early 1980s,the primary objectivesbeing hydrocarbon and lithology identification. Measurement of amplitude variation with offset(AVO), which givesmuch the sameinformation as the combined use of S- and P-wavesbut at lower cost, resultedin somecurbing of S-wavestudies.Today,S-waves(and three-componentrecording)are being studied mainly to measure fracture orientation and intensity. The l9l7 Fessendenpatent contemplatedseismic measurementsin boreholes,and in the late 1920s,a boreholegeophonebegan to be used to definea salt dome flank (as an extensionof the refractionmethod) and to measureseismicvelocity.Gal'perin (1974) describedSovietdevelopmentof vertical seismicproflling (VSP)during the 1960-70period. The useof borehole measurementsfor purposes beyond simply velocity measurementexpandedin the early 1980s. Tomographicborehole-to-boreholeand borehole-tosurfacemethodshavebeenundergoingrapid development sincethe mid-1980sbut are still experimental. Three-dimensionalsurveyingrequiresmore channelsfor its efficientexecutionand involvesmore logis-
INTRODUCTION
22
* ,g
recFig. 1.20 Early record section made by splicing individual and orEs together.The records are made with a l0-trace camera
tical problemsin the field. Thesehaveled to increased ur. of digitization at the geophone and telemetry methodsfor recordinginformation' Marine seismicdata acquisitionhas been rendered and more emcient by towing more than one source that more than one streameroffset by paravanesso pass single a on severallines of data can be acquired sysof a ship. The use of improved radiopositioning ' precithe in refinement in continual temshai resulted seisrion oifo.utlng acquisitionpoints at sea'Marine satTransit of use mic exploration ttui made extensive Global the uses extensively ettltepositioningand now poritlonlng Sys6m (GPS),both developed.bythe U'S' Navy. The-Gi'S is also being usedfor land surveying' Ships involved in 3-D work now have very elaborate potitio"lng systems for determining, in real time *itttln u fe-wmeters,the locations of all of the survey (sourceand eachhydrophonegroup in each ;l;;;.,t coordistreamerfor everyenergyrelease)in the local to order in needed is nut. tytt.-. Thi; information ifthe advise to also and properly data bin and correct
lower marked hoare exceptionally uniform for the period The of Conoco') iizon is clearly iut by a large fault (Courtesy
surveyis obtaining the requisiteuniformity of coveragewhile still on the ProsPect. in The power of computersincreasedenormously and decreased costs time, theiame the late 1980s;at practical ilr. tp..a increasedso much that it became to piovide interpreters with their own. computers interpretation' Work1*oikrtotionr) to help with problems data-handling the of stations solve many an interof much so consumed have that historically p..t.f. time, allowing more cross-checkingand disptaying of data in waysthat make featuresof interest -oi. uitibt., and generallyallowing for a more completeand accurateinterpretation' proThe interpretercan also carry out simple data even become computers cessingat the workstation.As more iowerful and rapid, it is expectedthat.interpretcharac.r, *lit be ableto tailor processingmore to the This i..itti"t and problemsln their particular data' and processors -uJ to-.*ttut "lot. the gap between processing digital with iniJtpt.,..t that developed about 1960(fie.l'22\. enorShips acquiring marine 3-D data carry an
I
GEOPHYSICAL ACTIVITY
-\
1OO"/o
i,
lj
t
"-{,
,
Pi
Fi .' 5 , , ,
5O"/"
F ii
fl
1953
, tl
b,t
I
ri.'.,,,*, t
9 r
'sl
Oo/o
.r-"?" .t?'
,
-/
ir, 4
1960
1970
1980
1990
Fig. l.2l Percentageofseismic activity involving various techniques. (Data from SEG annual Geophysit'ul At'tivity Reports, pre-1981 data are for U.S. activity, post-1980 for worldwide ac-
tivity,3-D datafromDutt, 1992,adjusted according to judgmentexpressed in Goodfellow, 1991.)
mous amount of computer power.Marine acquisition is highly automatedand shipboardcomputersare capable of elaborateprocessing.Workstationspermit a preliminary interpretationto be made quickly. The major usersof seismicdata, especially3-D but also VSP and other seismic methods, have been changingfrom the exploration to the production departmentsof oil companies.The precisionand detail of 3-D seismic data make it an increasinglycosteffectivetool in field developmentand production. It is becomingincreasinglyrecognizedthat most reservoirs are quite heterogeneous and seismicdata provide about the only way of determininghow they change horizontally.This is especiallyimportant in the marine environmentwheredrilling and investmentcosts are so large,but it is also true on land. The use of seismic methods in coal studies has grown rapidly sincelongwall mining becamethe major extraction method for deep coal deposits(S14.2). Someof the most rapidly growingareasof seismicapplicationsare in engineering($14.l), groundwater,and wastedisposal(S14.3).
creasesin the productivity (and cost) of a field creq especiallyof a marine crew. Much uncertainty existstoday as to the future of geophysicalactivity. The majority view is that new technologywill continueto createopportunitiesin the geophysical industryand the levelofpetroleumactivity will not lall much farther; however,a return to the high activity of the 1980sis thought to be unlikely. Petroleum-related opportunities for geophysicists should continueat about the current leveland opportunities in nonpetroleum areas should continue to grow. Although seismiccrew activity has been long regardedas a leadingindicatorof the healthof the petroleurn (and energy)sectoqit may be losing validity as an economicpredictor becauseof changesin technology, attitudes,and world politics. The petroleum industry is beginningto shift drilling funds into 3-D seismology.Environmentalconcernsare changingthe demand part of the hydrocarbon supply/demand equation.For years,the United Statesdominatedthe petroleumindustry,but in the 1970s,much of the economic control shifted to the OPEC countries.In the 1980s, rising North Sea production changed the supply/demandbalance in Europe, and recently the revelation of enormous reservesand decayedinfrastructurein the former Soviet Union has introduced new uncertainty.Future changesmay be dominated by unpredictablecrises,just as in the past appliedgeophysicswas very much affectedby eventssuch as the cold war and conflictsin the Middle East. Petroleumand geophysicalservicecompaniesare
13 Geophysical activlty I .3. I Thefuture of exploration seismology The petroleum industry has long dominated applied geophysics.A graph of the number of seismiccrews searchingfor oil and gas in the United States(fig. 1.23)presentsa discouragingpicture. However,much of this declinein the number of crewsis offset bv in-
INTRODUCTION
z+
t9703
slnplr pott-3leck (c.10Ea) PROCESSING Concurrantprocaaalngtnd Int.g.at.d rt th! d.sklop
Err
Thc Ealch Pt@..!lng
to"ent ot txten PROCESSNE
Acqulsltlon
atrlm( Sgill ratlsilon lilo tlrar dlaalPlln'i
PROCESSING pott-3trck R.rl-tlma pr.- snd prodttlng on wk8tallona lc. t9E7)
COLLABORATIVE
ACQUSI
Multldlrclpllnary l$ms F{an, ecqul?a, procasr, F€n, dtta con@rttntly and Inlfptal lo ldmtlly
optlmC Flremottrt
Fig. 1.22 Concept showing the specializationthat followed the advent of digital processingand the projected unifying resulting
from the increased Power of workstations. (From Landmark Graphics Corp., 1992.)
reorganizing(seefig. 1.24) and repositioning to accommodateexpectedchanges.Major petroleumcompaniesare shifting their interestsoutside the United Statesand Canada, where they perceivegreater opportunities.This has left behind a wealth of opportunities,but small companieshavebeenslow to take advantageof thesebecauseof restrictedfunding. An often-promulgatedconcept is that the Earth's petroleum resourceshave topped out and an exponential decline is inevitable.Past predictions of the timing of this declinehave invariablybeen wrong becausegenerallythey havenot allowedfor technologic improvements.Lindseth(1990)found that the amount of oil discoveredper well has been nearly constant (fig. 1.25)rather than decliningsharplywith time; the periodic arrival of new technologypresumablyarrests the declines.Thus, new technology(which almost everyone predicts) should continue to sustain the geophysicalindustry.
-ot includeequipmentcostsor costsof studentlabor), and totals lump both small-scaleand large-scaleoperthe reports are regardedas relaations.Nevertheless, tively accurateand permit judgments with regard to trends.The latest annual report (as of early 1994)is for the year l99l (Riley, 1993).In addition,monthly reports of seismiccrew activity are publishedin The LeadingEdge.The following is basedon thesereports and Dutt (1992). The number of seismiccrewsis shown in fig. 1.23b along with the number of wildcat wells drilled. The number of seismiccrewswas long regardedas a leading indicator of the petroleum-industryeconomy,but major changesin the early 1990shave changedthis situation (see also fig. 1.27). The sharp upturns in prices and activity in the 1970sand early 1980sresulting from the Middle East oil crisisdid not produce comparableincreasesin hydrocarbondiscoveries(see fig. 1.25). The mean wellheadcostsof oil and natural gas adjusted for inflation are shown in fig. 1'23a.Economics along with technologyhave been the governingfactors in seismicactivity. A surplus of oil about 1937 produced a decline in activity that lasted until the United Statesbecameinvolved in World War II. A doubling of petroleumpricesbetween1945and 1948 resulted in an increasein seismicactivity' However, major finds of oil in the Middle East after World War II resultedin another world surplus of oil and prices dropped.From 1948to 1973,the price of petroleum
1.3.2History o/ seismicactivitY Geophysical activity is tabulated each year by the Societyof Exploration Geophysicists(SEG). Admittedly,not all activity is reported (the most important omission has been activity in the [former] Soviet Union and China), someis reportedon differentbases (some reports include only acquisition and some include processingand/or interpretation), accounting practicesdiffer (reported university work often does
slm plrMplauMaulo JaqrlnN
066|.u!ocrrdsec J3w/srellop q
.
q
.
r
:
A
ol
O O
C O
@
v
o
o <.I rO)
o
e.t IP
to)
t9
t
-.....h
/
I
/
= " t/
lI r,I { "
r'( /
-J
o cr,
I
-
I
.EE
l -
J
r
l
:/ ,i/ t/
, t 6
r 6
frB
l :
I \
--=.
'83
-+
I I
. : o , q
\t '
l\
I
.- o q 3 Y- .
t-
t
l -
\
\
-
: : e
,]
! ^ a
l
I
I
I I I
.
I
o N
tl t"l
I I
F
8l I I
o \)
:YO;
t l
; l
y Y_>
.n>;. 5 H E
: l
.r
\ ' .9\
il
h
?
o ao o
u ,
r f r l \l
\ v
.y
=,. ^ o a
;.ll
r \
\
-
L U { Y :\/
q I
I I
-
. e t ' -
v.l (o o
;
' ^ - o
H
al
:
e i :
lt -l 1
I
\
boi*o = q
v
i %-\ o.:, 9.\
o |r)
'1'4'
(
(
> r 3 ^ 6 =
t
.r O! , . t,",,,1
n o)
s
or,
\
-
c a i i o t r o
;$ e
. E F C
d E h tr -.= d
!
:
:z^z^: .
%)\
'rx
O : O * ' o= o= Y
t
.
o s o)
4 >
9
2
l . x
Y 7 0 . 6 Y 4
\ ' J 5 ^o)
o N
9
:
€
066Lul acudllo larreq/ellop
a
i
5 I
5. r
sMoJcJoJaqunN
- E - : E N U.tr
\ (t o)
O a H
€ d
ir<9
INTRODUCTION
26
Drcrra Ad$ (honclnnlc,) -i LlttonRao'jrc..o'o[wr|tmAd8#wcrEmoco9hFictl(DEsser30%rutbn?0%) OcoSonc-,t --5Hdliburtoo Oeophylicrl l-U.tUUnnmOcoptydol
os'Locrrrlrunmaru)J
---.--*r.-l Slem Oeophyll OilnTen 6
Irprtroutprt
Irplrt/olriput
c,o.o. Dlglm (Rry0Eo)
tsdmuk Onphis
industryln contracting in thegeophysical Fig.1.24 Changes and wastakenoverby Schlumberget SSC(Raytheon) lale1992, OnlymajorconwastakenoverbyWestern. Haliburton in 1993.
remained almost constant and activity generallydeclinedfor most of this period, the declinebeingslowed and occasionallytemporarily reversedby new developments. Natural gas reservespeaked about 1970 und, fo. a while thereafter,explorationhad gas rather than oil as an objective.ln 1913-4,oil pricesincreased sharply as a result of the limiting of suppliesby the OPEC (Organizationof PetroleumExporting Countries) cartel. The price increasesas well as policy changescausedby uncertaintiesabout dependenceon foreign suppliesstimulatedseismicexploration' Conrecernsabout secureoil suppliesdiminishedas large "safe" other serveswere found in the North Sea and areas and geophysicalactivity went into the decline (especially in the United States)that continuestoday' ' Activity outsidethe United Statesincreasedrather steadily until 1958 and then leveledoff. During the period 1958-74the geographyofactivity changedseveral times in responseto political and economicfactors and discoveriesin new areas.Activity in Latin America declined sharply after 1959becauseof discouraging results and political changes in several countiies. The discovery of significant hydrocarbon reservesin North Africa, the beginningof North Sea exploration,nationalizationthreats in lndonesia,the opining of tropical African watersto exploration,and repeatedpolitical disruptionsin North Africa and the Uiaate East wereprobably the most significantof the events.Internationalactivity since l98l (fig. l'26) did not declinenearly as steeplyas in the United States, and since 1987,activity outside North America has beenincreasingsteadilY' The history of seismicactivity is also illustratedin
tracting companies are shown, In a sense,this updates the Ame r a d a T r e e s h o w n i n f i g . 1 . 1l . ( F r o m D u t t , 1 9 9 2 . )
frg. 1.27. The number of fleld crews (especiallyon tana) nas beendecliningsincethe early 1980sbut the volume of new data acquiredsince 1988has been increasingbecauseofthe shift from 2-D to 3-D data acquisition. 1 . 3 . 3D a t a f o r l 9 9 l Expenditures for geophysicaldata acquisition and processingin l99l were U.S'$ 2250 million (Riley' 1993).While the activity data are not strictly comparable with previousperiods,they indicatethat expenditures were up 3"/ufrom 1990 and 54o/ofrom 1987, when expendituresplunged after the Middle East oil of the peak expencrisis;however,they are only 53o/u dituresof U.S.$4168million in 1982.Theseexpenditures are shownby objectivesin table | .2 and by areas in table1.3and fig.1.26.Activity in the United States continued to declineby 25% of the 1990figure, now standingar 160Aof worldwideactivity,comparedwith in 1987' doublethis percentage Seismic work constituted almost 97"k of the reported geophysicalexpenditureand99o/oofthis work irad petroleum objectives.Although table l'2 shows only 13.6%of expenditureshad petroleum development (as opposed to petroleum exploration) objectives, iiley-(1993) gives severalreasonswhy he believes this figure is considerably unders{rted' Goodfellow (1991: 62) in the report for 1990 stated "we believethat a considerablylarger proportion that . . . was actually spent on development ' ' ' [probably] 24 percent)'cornparedwith a reported 6'20h'Several recint spectacular successesin defining reservoirs
GEOPHYSICALACTIVITY
27
Table 1.2 Worldwidel99I expenditures by objectives(U.5.$ x 103) Object
Land
Transition
Marine
Petroleum Exploration Development Minerals Environmental Engineering Geothermal Groundwater Oceanography Research Totai-Percent
1 189500. 252600. 1 61 0 0 . 3 100. 34 400. 400 2 200. 10. 9 000. 1 507300. 62.0
6 100 27 900
8 1 79 0 0 . 49 300.
Airborne
6 600. 1l 900. 140. 15.
Borehole
I 860 900. 690. 180.
900. 140. 900. 500. 869500. 35.7
300. 34 300. t.4
80. I 8 700. 0.8
320. 4 000. 0.2
Percent
96.7 8 3 I. 13.6 1.2 0.1 1.4 0.1 0.1 < 0.1 0.4
Nole. Becauseof differencesin the manner of reporting, there are minor inconsistencies in some of the numbersin this and the followins tables.
!:B At A l
l
I
t
f
I
g t
E I
t
r
t
t
o
t
o ! t
(,
60
t
I 3-D
Refrectlon36bmlc
ber of crews(fig. 1.27a).Increased explorationactivity in the late 1970sbrought about by threatenedsupplies from the Mideast produced a substantialincreasein unit costs(fig. 1.28),but unit costshavebeendeclining since 1980,the decreasebeing especiallyimpressive when adjustedfor inflation. Nonpetroleum seismicstatisticsare given in table 1.5.Thesefiguresare probablymuch more incomplete than the petroleum statistics becausemany small companies are involved. Environmental and engineering work generallyinvolve detailed surveyingof small areas,whereasoceanographicwork is apt to involve cursory surveysof large tracts of ocean, and crewsmay rangefrom 2 to 3 peopleto as many as 50 or so. Nevertheless, the statisticsdo give someidea of the scopeofgeophysicalwork and work in theseareas probablywill increasesignificantlyin the yearsahead. Regarding the seismicsourcesused for acquiring
Prudhoo Bay
Cumulativeexploralory wells (x 10,000) Fig. 1.25 Oil-finding eflrciencyindicated by new oil lound per well drilled. (After Lindseth, 1990.)
have been attributed to this type of work (Sheriff, 1992).Oil companiesare now resurveyingolder finds with newerseismictechnologyin both the marine and land environments,resulting in increasingtheir production and proven reservessubstantially(Abriel et a l . ,l 9 9 l ) . Table 1.4 lists petroleumseismicactivity statistics. Although many different kinds of work are averaged together in these statistics,the figures are probably representative ofthe costsand produtivity ofpresentday full-size geophysicalcrews. Marine work producesmuch more data than land work and the ratio of the volume of new marine data to new land data (f9. | .27b)is quite differentfrom the ratio of the num-
Table 1.3 WorldwideI99l expendituresbv areas (u.s.$ x lqt)
Area United States Canada Mexico South America Europe Africa Middle East Far East Australia-New Zealand International Total
Costs
3'71200. 133800. 44 600. 28'7600. 566700. 236800. 3 1 23 0 0 . 202000. 86 300. l8 900. 2250nU
Percent oftotal
Percent change 1990-l
t6.4 5.9 2.0 12.7 25.r 10.5 13.8 8.9
-36 -5 +700 +47 +58 +9 +ll9 -24
3.8 0.8
-27 -t2.
il
INTRODUCTION
28 E a s t e r nH e m i s P h e r e
W e s t e r nH e m i s P h e r g
2500
2000 c
:
r 1500
? f
1000
'77
'79
'81
' 83
'85
'87
'89
'91
Fig. 1.26 Expenditures on geophysicalpetroleum exploration and development by areas. (After Riley, 1993 ) (a) Western Hemisphere; the areas from the bottom upward represent the
Table 1.4 Petroleuml99l seismicactivity statistics Transitionzone
Land
Marine
Acquisition costs
(u.s.$x l0) Line miles Line kilometers Crew-months Averagemiles/ month Averagekm/ month Averagecost/ month
(u.s.$) Averagecost/ mile (U.S.$) Averagecost/ km (U.S.$) Cost of 3-D/ mile' (U.S.$) Cost of 3-D/ km' (U.S.$)
1 M2 t00. 242000 389000 2'780
34000. 24't00 39700 61
867200. I 367000 2 199000 94'7
87
405
| 440
140
651
2 320
519000 557000
9 1 60 0 0
4 600
I 400
630
2 860
870
390
36000
27 300
13900
l0 500
the land miles,explosivesconstituted34.6o/o,vibrators 59.2%,landair guns0.6%,and weightdrop 0.1%'Air guns were the only marine sourcereported for petro-
United States,Canada, South America, and Mexico (b) Eastern Hemisphere; the areas from the bottom upward represent Eu,op., Afti"u, the Middle East, Australia, and the Far East'
leum work. The percentageof land work that was 3-D cannot be calculatedbecausesome numbersare reported in line miles and some in squaremiles surveyed.Although some marine work was reported in squaremiles surveyed,l2.5ul' of the line miles reported were 3-D and so the total percentageexceeds this value. 1.4 The literature of exploration seismolos/ A. S. Eve and D. A. Keys (1928)wrote in their preface "we to Applied Geophysics, know of no book in English which deals with the theoretical and practical sidesof all of the many schemesof exploration now available."This was only 4 yearsafter the first discovery of hydrocarbonsbasedon seismicrefraction. Eve "in 1928 there were thirty or and Keys noted that 'troops' at work . . . eachconsisting groups or , more of three to five trained men, with an equal number of helpers."Extreme secrecywas common at this time and their book givesonly a brief sketchof methods. "blacklbox" elements As late as the early 1950s,some remained,that is, detailsas to how they worked were not disclosed. Literature on earthquakeseismologyprecededthat dealing with prospecting applications. H. Jeffreys' classicThe Earth appearedin 1924(3rd ed. in 1952). L. D. Leet's Practical Seismologyand Seismic Pros-
LITERATURE OF EXPLORATION SEISMOLOGY
r2,000 I 1,000 r0,000 9,000 1.000 !
7.000
>
5,OOO
3 s.ooo a.000 !,000 2.000 r,000
'77
' 79
! r
' lJ
' !5
laor
(a)
PercentMarineLine-Miles 5a
^
6J
55
6a
7t
t.aoo
I r.zoo 3 r.ooo E
loo
.5 -
600 a00
79
' t|
'!J
t5
'a7
t9
(b)
Frg. 1.27 Worldwide land and marine acquisition. The stippled area indicates land, the diagonal slashed marine. (From Riley, 1993.)(a) Number of field crew-months; (b) volume of data acquired.
pecting(1938)combined earthquakeand exploration >eismology. Although geophysicalliteratureis publishedin several languages,the seismologistwho reads English is especiallyfortunatein that almost all important refer3ncesare in this language.Most of the important papersand books that haveappearedin other languages :ave either English equivalentsor English transla:rons.Furthermore, most of the important technical pubrapersare containedin twojournals, Geophysics, .rshedby the Society of Exploration Geophysicists SEG), and GeophysicalProspecting,published by the
29
European Association of Exploration Geophysicists (EAEG). The Society of Economic Geophysicists was founded in Houston in 1930;the name was changed that sameyear to the Societyof PetroleumGeophysicists and in 1931to the Societyof Exploration Geophysicists.It continuesto be the largestprofessional geophysicalsocietytoday.The societybeganpublication of Geophysics in 1936.Prior to this, paperswere published in issuesof the AAPG Bulletin and Physics; many of the most important papersprior to 1936were republished in Early GeophysicalPapersin 1947. The European Association of Exploration Geophysicists was founded in l95l and beganpublishing Geophysical Prospectingin 1953. The unrefereedmagazinespublishedby thesetwo societies,The Leading Edge and the f irsl Break, provide surveyarticles,interpretationcasehistories,and information about newer topics. The Canadian and Australian Societiesof Exploration Geophysicsalso publish journals that are more along the lines of The Leading Edge and Ihe First Break than of Geophysics and GeophysicalProspecting.Otherjournals that often contain important articles are published in Europe, India, and elsewhere. The Bulletinof the AmericanAssociation of Petroleum Geologistsoften contains rmportant papers on interpretive applications of geophysics.The geophysicalliteratureof basicseismology also often contains papers of interestto exploration seismologists. The most important non-Englishjournalsare Russianand Chinese. A CumulativeIndex of Geophysicsis published every few years (most recently as a supplement to the March 1990issueof Geophysics); it lists the papersin the publicationsof most of the foregoingsocietiesexcept for those of the American Associationof Petroleum Geologists.The cumulativeindex is also availableon a computerdisk, which also liststhe expanded abstractsofpapers given at the annual meetings.This computer disk can be searchedfor key words. The most important papers from Geophyslcsare reprinted in the 25th and 50th anniversaryvolumes(Classicpapers of the past 25 years,1985)and important exploration seismicpapers from various journals are reprinted in three volumes of the Treatiseof Petroleum GeologyReprint Serles(Beaumont and Foster,1989). A seriesof 14 (as of 1994) reprint volumes dealing with various subjectsand a number of other geophysics books are published by the Society of Exploration Geophysicists. A multitude of books on various aspectsof seismic explorationare availabletoday.In the first edition, we were able to list most of the important books on aspects of seismicexploration, but today there are so many that it is not feasibleto do this. Many are referencedin subsequentchapters.Seismictechnologytoday embracesso much signal processingand computer technologyas well as geologythat a readinglist would include many works that are not specifically geophysical.Particular mention should be made of
= 6
E
4ooo
A o
!l1E66 1966
1075 costs adjusted for inflation. (Data from SEG Geophysital Activity Reports.)
F i g . 1 . 2 8 S e i s m i cc o s t s p e r m i l e ( 1 9 8 0 a n d p r e - 1 9 8 0 ,W e s t e r n Hemisphere; post-1980, worldwide). The dotted curves show
Table 1.5 Nonpetroleuml99l seismicactivity Surveytype
Typework
Expenditures(U.S.$x 103)
Minerals
P-wave reflection S-wavereflection Refraction P-wave reflection S-wavereflection P-wave reflection S-wavereflection Refraction Reflection Refraction Passive Reflection P-wave reflection S-wavereflection Refraction
5 290. I 050. t70. 820. 60.
Environmental Engineering
Groundwater Geothermal Oceanography Research
J l .
n a
12. 410. I 10. 0.3 920. 4 910. I 50. 15.
Cost/mile
Costikm
3 150. 6 900. 2 900. 7 300.
1 960. 4 300. I 800. 4 600.
I 500. 1*0. 6 100. 4 300 I 600.
940. 780. 3 800. 2 600. I 000.
90. 2 900. 50000. l5 000.
60. I 800. 31000. 9 300.
REFERENCES the safety and environmental guides published by the International Association of Geophysical Contractors (IAGC). References Abbot,H. L. 1878.On the velocityof transmission of earth waves. Amer.J. Sci.Arts,Ser.3, 15:178-84. Abriel,W.L., P S.Neale,J.S.Tissue, andR. M. Wright.1991. Modern technology in an old area. Bay Marchand revisited. The Leading Edge, 10(6):21,35. Barrington, lo
T. 1982. Cecil Green. The Leading Edge, l(l):
/4.
Barton,D. C. 1929.The seismicmethodof mappinggeologic structure.In Geophysical Prospecting, pp. 572,624.New York: AmericanInstituteof Mining and MetallurgicalEngineers. Bates,C. C., T. F. Gaskell,and R. B. Rice. 1982.Geophysics in the Afairs of Man Oxford: PergamonPress. Bates,R. L., and J. A. Jackson.1987,Glossaryof Geology,3d ed. FallsChurch,VA: AmericanGeologicalInstitute. Beaumont,E. A., and N. H. Foster.1989.Geophysics I: Seismic .Vethods;Geophysics II: Toolsfor SeismicInterpretation;Geopht'.sics III: GeologicInterpretationof SeismicData,Treatiseof PetroleumGeology,ReprintSeriesNos. 12, 13,and,14.Tulsa: .{mericanAssociationof PetroleumGeologists. E[rrn, W T. 1960.A review of geophysicalinstrumentation. Geophysics, 25277-91. - arlton, D. P. 1946.The History of the Geophysics Department. Houston:HumbleOil and RefiningCo. -lark, R. D. 1982.Gerald Westby.The LeadingEdge,l(l): .rrk. R. D. 1983.SidneyKaufman. The LeadingEdge,2(7\: ::7. :rk. R. D. 1984a.T. I. Harkins. The LeadingEdge,3(4\: r t8. ..r-k.R. D. 1984b.C. Hewiu Dix. The Leading Edge,3(8\: .
1 1
.:k. R. D. 1985.EndersRobinson.The LeadingEdge,4(2): - 10. ,:i. R. D. 1990a.Theodor Krey. The LeadingEdge,9(4); : lt. .:i. R. D. 1990b.Kenneth E. Burg. The Leading Edge, * l t ) ) :l 3 1 6 . .::. papersof the past25 years.1985.Geophysics, 50: 179'l:lrer, E. 1935. Notes on the early history of applied geo!:;s in the petroleum industry. Trans. Soc.Pet. Geophys.,6: r Reprinted in Early Geophysical Papers of the Society of ,ttion Geophysiclsts,pp. 245-54. Tulsa: Society of Explo: Geophysicists,1947.) J B. 1992.Seismicoveryiew.New Orleans: Howard, Weil, -rsse.Friedrichs Inc. . T A, 1970. A Brief History of Gulf's Geophysical Pros'.- Pittsburgh: Gulf Researchand Development Co. r. S . and D. A. Keys. 1928. Applied Geophysics. Cam.. Cambridge University Press. :::r. E. I. 1974. Vertical Seismic Profiling Tulsa: Society : .ration Geophysicists. . - ,.ri. K. 1991.Geophysical activity in 1990. The Leading Itlll):45-72. , H. 1979. John Clarence Karcher. 1894 1978. father ', -::ection seismograph.Geophysics,44: 1018-21.
3l Hecker,O. 1990.Ergebnisse de Messungvon Bodenbewegungen bei einer Sprengung. Gerland'sBeitrrige zur Geophysik,4: 98-104. Heiland,C. A. 1929a.Moderninstruments and methodsof seismic prospecting.ln Geophysical pp. 625-53.New Prospecting, York: American Institute of Mining and Metallurgical Engineers. Heiland, C. A. 1929b.Geophysicalmethods of prospectingPrinciplesand recentsuccesses. Quart. Col. Sch.Mines,A(\,t, Jeffreys, H, 1952.TheEarth,3ded.Cambridge:CambridgeUniversityPress. Karcher, J. C. 1987.The reflection seismograph:Its invention and usein the discoveryof oil and gasfields.TheLeadingEdge, 6(11):l0-20. Keppner,G. 1991.Ludger Mintrop. The LeadingEdge, l0(9): 2 t-8. Knott, C. G. 1899.Reflexionand refraction of elastic waves, with seismologicalapplications.Phil. Mag., 48:64-97. - The First Fifty Laing, W E., and F. Searcy.1975.Geophysics lears.Houston:Conoco. Landmark Graphics Corp. 1992.The ComingReunionof Seismic Interpretationand ProcessingHouston: Landmark Graphics Corp. Leet,L. D. 1938.PracticalSeismologyand SeismicProspecting. New York: Appleton-Century. Lindseth,R. O. 1990.The new wavein explorationgeophysics. TheLeadingEdge,9(12)t9-15. Love, A. E.H. 1927. Some Problemsof GeodynamicsCambridge:CambridgeUniversityPress. Malamphy,M. C. 1929.Factorsin designof portablefield seismographs.Oil llteekly,March 22, 1929. Mallet, R. 1848.On the dynamicsof earthquakes; beingan attempt to reducetheir observedphenomenato the known laws of wave motion in solids and fluids. Irans Roy.Irish Acad., 21:50-106. Mallet,R. 1851.Secondreporton the factsofearthquakephenomena.BAAS,2l: 272-320. Mayne,W. H. 1982.The evolutionof geophysical technology. TheLeadingEdge,l(l):75-80. McGee,J. E., and R. L. Palmer.1967.Earlyrefractionpractices. ln SeismicRefractionProspecting, A. W. Musgrave,Ed. Tulsa: Societyof ExplorationGeophysicists. McGuckin,G. M. 1945.History of the geophysical exploration of the CameronMeadowsDome,CameronParish.Louisiana. Geophysics, l0: l-16. Milne, J. 1895.Seismicexperiments. Trans.Sei,s.Soc.Jpn., B: l-82. Mintrop, L. 1931.On theHistoryof theSeismicMethodfor theInvestigationof Underground Formationsand Mineral Diposits.' Hanover,Germany:Seismos. Owen,E. W. 1975.Trekof the Oil Finders:A History o! Explorationfor Petroleum,AAPG Memoir 6. Tulsa:American Association of PetroleumGeologists. Petty,O. S. 1976.SeismicReflections. Houston: Geosource. Proffitt,J. M. 1991.A historyof innovationin marineseismic data acquisition.TheLeadingEdge,l0(3):24 30. Proubasta,D. 1982.O. S. Petty.TheLeadingEdge,l(7): 16-24. Proubasta,D. 1983a.John Hollister.The LeadingEdge,2(7): 14 t9. Proubasta,D. 1983b.Henry Salvatori.TheLeadingEdge,2(8\: t4-22.
)z
Proubasta,D. 1983c.John Crawford. The LeadingEdge'2(12): t6-26. Proubasta,D. 1984.Remembranceof geophysicalthings past' TheLeadingEdge,3(10'):32-8' Proubasta,D. 1985a.SvenTreitel. TheLeadingEdge'4(2\:24 8' Proubasta,D. 1985b.Harry Mayne. The Leading Edge' 4(7): t8 24. Proubasta,D. 1986a.Erik Jonsson.The Leading Edge' 5(6)" t4-23. Proubasta,D. 1986b.Enders Robinson and the shot heard round the geophysicalworld. TheLeadingEdge,3(9):14 17' Proubasta,D. 1991.Maurice Ewing. The LeadingEdge,l0(3)" 15 20. Rayleigh,Lord. I 885.On wavespropagatedalongthe planesurfaceof an elasticsolid.Proc.LondonMath Soc.,17:4-11' Rieber,F 1936.A new reflectionsystemwith controlleddirecl: 97-106. tional sensitivity.Geophysics, activityin l99l Riley,D. C. 1993.Specialreport:Geophysical The LeadingEdge,l2z 1094-1I 17. Robertson,H. 1986.EveretteLee DeGolyer.TheLeadingEdge, 5(ll):l4 21. Robinson,E. A. 1985.A historicalaccountof computerresearch in seismicdata processing,1949-1954.The Leading Edge,4(2\:40-5. Rosaire,E. E. 1935.On the strategyand tacticsof exploration for petroleum.J. Soc.Pet. Geophys.,6t1l-26 (Reprintedin Eariy GeophysicalPapersof the Societyof Exploration-Geophysicrsri pp. 255 70. Tulsa: Societyof ExplorationGeophysicists,1947.) Rosaire.E. E.. and J. L. Adler. 1934.Applicationsand limitationsof dip shooting.Bull. AAPG, 18: 19 32. Rosaire,E. 8., and O. C. Lester,Ir. 1932.Seismologicaldiscoverv and partial detail of Vermillion Bay salt dome.Bull' AAPG'
INTRODUCTION
Papersof the Society 16: 5l-9. (Reprintedin Early Geophysical pp. 381-9. Tulsa: Societyof Exof Exploration Geophysicists, 1947.) plorationGeophysicists, Schriever,W. 1952.Reflectionseismographprospecting How l7't 936-42. it started.Geophysics, Shaw H.. J. M. Bruckshaw and S. T. Newing' 1931.Applied London: His Majesty'sStationeryOffice. Geophysics. technologythrough Sheriff,R. E. 1985.History of geophysical in Geophysics.Geophysics,50':2299-2408' advertisements and interpretationoi seismtcreSheriff,R. E. 1988.Processing flection data: An historical pr6cis. The Leading Edge' 7(l): 40 2. Dictionaryof ExplorationGeo' Sheriff,R. E. 1991.Encyclopedic physics,3d ed.Tulsa:Societyof ExplorationGeophysicists. Tulsa: Societyof Sheriff,R. E., ed. 1992.ReservoirGeophysics. Exploration Geophysicists. Stoneley,R. 1924.Elasticwavesat the surfaceof separationof two solids.Proc. Roy.Soc.( London),A-106:416-28. ProspectrzgSudbury Sweet,G. E. 1978.History of Geophysical England:Spearman. of a newmethodof makingunUdden,J. A. 1920.Suggestions Bull. AAPG,4: 83 5. (Reprintedin dergroundobservations. 16:7l 5-16.) Geophysics, 14:6-9' Vajk, R. 1949.Baron Roland Eotvos.Geophysics, Weatherby,B. B. 1940.History and developmentof seismic 5: 215-30. prospecting.Geophysics, in Oklahoma' B. B. 1945.Early seismicdiscoveries Weatherby, s, l0t 345-67. Geophysic Wiechert,8., and K. Zoeppritz.1907.Uber Erdbebenwellen' der Wissenschaften Nachrichrenvonder Ki)niglichenGesellschaft pp. 415-549.Berlin. zur Gdttingen, of the seconddecadeof seisWilcox,S. W. 1990.Reminiscence TheLeadingEdge,9(8ll42-5. mic prospecting.
2
Theory of seismicwaYes
Overview
fronts and raypathsare introduced,as is the more general Huygens'principle approach. The two forms of the wave equation that had been derivedearlierare relatedto two typesof disturbances that can travelthrough the body ofsolids ($2.4).These involve changesin volume (P-waves)and rotations (S-waves).Discussion of potential functions, from which particle displacementsand velocitiescan be derived, follows.At interfaces,both stressesand particle displacementsmust be continuous; these boundary conditions are discussedin $2.4.4. Surface waves are examined next. Rayleigh waves are important becauseof the ground-roll noise that they produce on seismicrecords.Love, Stoneley,and tube wavesare encounteredoccasionally. Most seismictheory assumesthat media are isotropic, that is, their propertiesare the sameregardless of the direction of measurement.Anisotropy ($2.6)of severaltypes has beenobserved;howevet anisotropic effectsare usually small. The most important exceptions requiring study are those of transverseisotropy becauseof layeringand fracturing. Section2.7 examineswhat happensto seismicbody wavesas they travel in the earth. Intensity decreases becauseofgeometricalspreading(divergence)and absorption (and partitioning at interfaces;seechap. 3). Divergenceis the most important factor affectingthe change of intensity for the first few kilometers,but eventuallyabsorptionbecomesdominant. Absorption increasesapproximatelylinearly with frequencyand hencechangesthe waveshapewith distance.Various expressionsfor absorption are interrelated.Dispersion and the conceptsofgroup and phasevelocityare discussed,although dispersion is not an importqgt factor in seismicexploration. Reflection and refraction are discussedin $2.7.5. Diffraction ($2.8),the scatteringof wavesat discontinuities, involves somewhat complex mathematics. However, the construction of diffraction wavefronts using Huygens'principle is fairly straightforwardand nonmathematical.
The seismicmethod utilizesthe propagationof waves through the earth. To introduce the basicconceptsof wave motion, we flrst discusswaveson a stretched string($2.1.1)and introducedefinitionsofphase,frequency,wavelength,and other terms dealingwith periodicity.Becausewavepropagationdependsupon the elasticpropertiesof the rocks, we next discusssome of the basicconceptsof elasticity.(For more thorough treatments,seeSaada,1974,or Landau and Lifshitz, 1986.) The sizeand shapeof a solid body can be changed by applying forcesto the externalsurfaceofthe body. Theseexternalforcesare opposedby internal forces, which resistthe changesin sizeand shape.As a result, the body tendsto return to its original condition when the externalforcesare removed.Similarly,a fluid resists changes in size (volume) but not changes in shape.This property of resistingchangesin srzeor shapeand of returning to the undeformedcondition when the externalforcesare removedis calledelasticity. A perfectlyelasticbody is one that recoverscompletelyafter beingdeformed.Many substances including rocks can be consideredperfectly elasticwithout appreciable error provided the deformations are small.as they are in seismicsurveys. The theory of elasticity relatesthe forces that are applied to the external surface of a body to the resulting changesin size and shape.The relations between the applied forces and the deformations are most convenientlyexpressedin terms of the concepts of stressand strain. Strain, a changein shapeor dimensions,is generallyproportional to the stress(force per unit area) that producesit, as statedin Hooke's law. The constantof proportionality is called an elastic constant, or modulus, and moduli for different types of stressand strain are interrelated. Section 2.2 concerns seismic-wavemotion. Newton's secondlaw of motion, that an unbalancedforce on a massproducesan acceleration,is used to derive two forms of the waveequation.The waveequationis expressedin vector as well as the more conventional scalarnotation. Methods of including a sourceof disturbance and Kirchhoff's theorem are also given in this section. Plane- and spherical-wave solutions to the wave equation are given next. Waves are disturbances that travel through the medium. The concepts of wave-
2.1 Theory of elasticity 2.l.I Waveson a stretchedstring As an introduction to seismicwavesin three dimensions, we consider the one-dimensionalwave in a stretched string becausemany basic conceptsof wave JJ
THEORY OF SEISMIC WAVES
)+
motion can be more simply illustrated in this way. Parts of the following discussionwill be treated later in a broadercontext. We assumean ideal case where the mass of the string per unit length, p, is negligiblysmall in comparison with the tension,t, in the string, that the string when at rest is along the x-axis,and that the displacements,rf, which are parallel to the y-axis, are small in comparisonwith the length of the string so that angles o., and o., are also small (fig. 2.la). Becausethese anglesare not equal,the tensionproducesa net force in the y-direction (the net force in the x-direction is negligible)on an elementof the string, Ax, equal to t(sin c, - sin c,) - r(tan ct2- tan c,) - t(d{/dxl-, d$/dxl,,) - t A(drl/dx). Newton's secondlaw of motion statesthat this force equals the product of the massp Ax and the acceleration02'1il6t2. Dividing both sidesby roAx and taking the limit as Ax -+ 0 givesthe one-dimensionalwaveequation:
or P.ol /-cta3t
, J-__\./i
: (plt)0' ,$l0tz: (llW)02\tl0t,, (2.1) 02$10x2 where V = (rlp.)",(comparewith eq. (2.45)).Equation (2.1)showsthat Zhas dimensionsof distance/time,or velocity.The waveequation relatesvariation in space (the left side)with variation in time (the right side). The general solution of eq. (2.l) (also called d'Alembert'ssolution;see$2.2.5)is ,1,(x,t) = t, k - Vt) + 'ltr(x + Vt), (22) whererf , and rf, are arbitrary functions,rf , is a disturbancemoving in the positivex-directionwith increase of time, rf, a disturbancemoving in the negativexdirection, and V is the velocity of propagationalong the string (seethe following). Fourier analysis($9.1.2) showsthat any waveform (within reason)can be representedby a superposition of harmonic (sinusoidal)waves,so we do not losegenerality by confining our attention to harmonic waves. Thus, we considera harmonic solution of eq. (2.I ) in the form r.p= I cos [(2,n/\)(x * Vt)].
vlt.
F,aqucnct
I
-
P c ri o d
(b)
--T----:
l
l
tFWovalane
wov.numbrr =
th....+l
a;r..L;gi;(c)
(2.3)
The waveform is harmonic with r! varying between * A and - A ; A is the amplitude.If we look at the wave passinga fixed point in space(fig. 2.lb), period 7is the time betweensuccessive repetitionsof the waveform; frequencyv : llT is the number of wavesper unit time. If we look at the waveformat somemoment of time (fig. 2.lc) the distancebetweensuccessive repetitions of the waveform is the wavelength)\ and l/L is the wavenumber or number of wavesper unit distance. Multiplying IIT and llltby 2rr, we get the angularfrequencya : 2nlT : 2rv and the angular wavenumber r : 2rl}'. Becausev is the number of wavespassinga fixed point per unit time and eachwavehas length tr, velocity Z must be given by the equation V:
r+- PrriOd --l !
Q.4)
The argument of the cosine in eq. (2.3), namely,
(d) Fig. 2.1 Waves on a stretched string. (a) Portion of the string showing the relation betweendisplacementand tension; (b) representation of the wave in time; (c) representation of the wave in space;(d) the effect of change in mass/unit length.
(2rllr) (x - Vt1 : r(x - Vt): (rcx - ot), is calledthe phase.ln eq. (2.3), the phaseis zero at the origin; at times we add a fixed phase angle ^yoso that the phase becomesKr - r,-lt+ "yo.
THEORY OF ELASTICITY
I
35
Returning to the stretchedstring, if the mass/unit length changesabruptly from p, to p2 at somepoint, say, x : 0 (fig. 2.ld), certain boundary conditions ($2.4.4)must hold, namely,both the displacementand the y-componentof the tension in the string must be continuous,that is, neither changesin value as we go through the junction. These conditions can be expressedby the equations *,.r, : t,,rn,, r(dr!/dx),"r,: r(drlr/dx).,rn,.
(2.s)
We take the incident waveas l, cos (r,x - ol) coming from the left and the wavepassingon to the right (the transmittedwave) as l, cos (rrx - tot); however,we cannot satisfyeqs.(2.5)with thesetwo wavesonly and we must postulatea reflectedwave going to the left, l, cos (x,x + cor).Substitutinginto eqs.(2.5),we find that the boundaryconditionswill be satisfiedprovided A,+ A,: A,,
*,A,) ",)',: iit,.
I
(2.6a)
]
Equations(2.6a) can be solved for A,and A,: R : A , lA , : ( r z - x , ) / ( x *, r , ) , I
T= rq.,lA,:Z^,4*rl*,.y,
i
(2.6b)
where R and T are called the reflectioncofficient (or refectivily) and the transmissioncofficient, respectively(seealso93.2). If the string is fixed at x : 0, the effectis the same as if p, : -; then T : 0, so no wave is transmitted, and R : +1, which meansthat the reflectedwave is the sameas the incident one exceptthat the direction of travel is reversed.The two wavesinterfere($2.3.2) at the fixed end to produce perfect cancellation, hence,zero movement(node).If both ends are fixed, perfectcancellationmust occur at both ends,so these are nodes. When a string fixed at both ends is vibrating at its lowestfrequency,calledthe fundamental(u"), the displacement has its maximum amplitude at the midpoint (antinode). The wave pattern is fixed, so the wave is said to be stationary,or standing.If the string length is L, L : ),/2 and v,,: VII\ : Vl2L. The strins
Fig. 2.2 Componentsof stresson facesperpendicularto the x-axis.
can vibrate in a number of patterns called modes or eigenstates,the frequencies being harmonics (multi_ ples)of the fundamental,that is, vi = nvo,n : 1,2,3, . . . . In eachcase,the endsofthe string are nodesand L: nttl2: (2n)|t14. If the left end of the string is fixed and the right end free, we set K2 = 0 and get R = -1. The end of the string is an antinode, L = |t14, v^ : Vl4L, and the harmonicsare u : (2n + l)vo and,L : (2n + l)\14. The two casesof a string fixed at one end only and fixed at both endsare analogousto organ pipesilosed at one end only and closedat both ends(Logan, l9g7; s e ea l s oS 1 3 . 3 ) . 2.1.2 Stress S/ressis definedas force per unit area. Thus, when a force is applied to a body, the stressis the ratio of the force to the area on which the force is applied. If the force variesfrom point to point, the stressalso varies, and its value at any point is found by taking an infinitesimally small elementof area centeredat the point and dividing the total force acting on this area by the magnitudeof the area.If the force is perpendicularto the area, the stressis said to be a normal .r/re$ (or pressure).In this book, positive valuescorrespondto tensile stresses(the opposite convention of signs is sometimesused).When the force is tangential to the element of area, the stressis a shearings/ress.When the force is neither parallel nor perpendicularto the elementof area, it can be resolvedinto components parallel and perpendicularto the element;hence,any stresscan be resolved into component normal and shearingstresses. If we consider a small elementof volume inside a stressedbody, the stressesacting upon each ofthe six facesof the elementcan be resolvedinto components, as shownin fig. 2.2 for the two facesperpendicularto the x-axis.Subscriptsdenote the x-,1,-, and z-axes, respectively, and o,.*denotesa stressparallel to the y_ axis actingupon a surfaceperpendicularto the x-axrs. When the two subscriptsare the same (as with o.,), the stressis a normal stress;when the subscriptsare different (as with o,,), the stressis a shearingsiress. When the medium is in static equilibrium, the stressesmust be balanced.This meansthat the three stresses,o,,, or,, and o,.., acting on face OABC must be equal and opposite to the correspondingstresses shown on opposite faceDEFG with similar relations for the remaining four faces.In addition, a pair of shearingstresses, suchas oy,,constitutea coupletending to rotate the elementabout the z-axis,the magnitude ofthe couple being force X lever arm = (o u dy dz) dx. If we consider the stresseson the other four faces, we find that this couple is opposed solely by the couple due to the pair of stresseso"" with magnitude (o,, dx dz) d): Becausethe elementis in equilibrium,
THEORY OF SEISMIC WAVES
JO
the total moment must be zero; hence o", : or". In general,we must have or:
oii'
Au oy
(2.7\
r
2.1.3Strain When an elasticbody is subjectedto stresses, changes in shapeand dimensionsoccur.Thesechanges,which are called strains,can be resolvedinto certain fundamental types. Consider rectanglePQRS in the xy-plane (seefig. 2.3). When the stressesare applied,let P move to P', PP' having componentsu and v. If the other vertices Q, R, and S have the samedisplacementas 4 the rectangleis merelydisplacedas a whole by the amounts u and v,'in this case,there is no changein sizeor shape, and no strain exists.However,if u and y are different for the different vertices,the rectanglewill undergo changesin sizeand shape,and strainswill exist. Let us assumethat u : u(x,y) and y : r(r, y). Then the coordinatesof the verticesof PQRS and P'Q' R'S' are as follows: P(x, y): P'(x * u, y + v); Q@ + dx, y):
Q'(** d x* u + 4 a *,y * v *#*) ' S(x,y + dy): s'(" + u + !! dy,y +dy + r * j,ar)' R(x+dx,y+dy):
R ' ( " +d x * u + 4 d x . \ i , o r ,
y+dy*,*3.1a"+jjcr). In general,the changesin u and y are much smaller than the quantitiesdx and dy,' accordingly,we shall assumethat the terms (duldr), (6ulAfl, and so on are small enough that powers and products can be neglected.With this assumption,we seethe following: l . PQ increases in length by the amount (6ul0x) dx and PS by the amount (lvl0y) dy; hence 6ul0x and 6vl0y are the fractional increasesin length in the direction of the axes. 2 . The inflnitesimal angles6, and 6, are equal to \vl6x and 6ul0y,respectively. J . The right angleat P decreases by the amount El+E2:3vl3x+AulAy. 4. The rectangleas a whole has been rotated counterclockwisethrough the angle (6, 6r)12: (6vl3x - \ula)12. Strain is definedas the relativechange(that is, the fractional change)in a dimensionor shapeof a body. The quantities 6ul3x and 0vl6y are the relative increasesin lengthin the directionsofthe x- and y-axes, and are referred to as normal strains. The quantity 6vl6x i \ulEy is the amount by which a right anglein
sf -
au,.:Tar-"'|
,uj,---------l
iI
I
dy
t l rl
i
I
La=- Itv-
P ' I
---_______rt+-
l+-dx
. l-or
_J:'
F-l
I Fig. 2.3
J --\-au
ia'
u->\
I -N
Analysis of two-dimensional strain
the xy-plane is reducedwhen the stresses are applied, hence,is a measureof the changein shapeof the medium; it is known as a shearingstrain and will be denotedby the symbol e.,. The quantity (6vl6x dul6y)12,which representsa rotation of the body about the;-axis, does not involvechangein size or shapeand henceis not a strain; we shall denote it by the symbol 0-. Extending this analysis to three dimensions,we write (r.r,4 w) as the componentsof displacementof a point P(x, y, z). The elementarystrainsare thus
du Normal strains a," : -' dx 0v 8.. : ^ ' dy 6w.
(2.8)
4,,:
dz
: - y Shearingstrains 8,.,: Er, ' d !" x d !., E y " - - E : -'0y 4*4' 6z'
a,r:ar,:!-! dz
(2.e\
dx
In addition to thesestrains,the body is subjectedto simple rotation about the three axesgiven by ^
H
0":
e :
dwldv :
-
dvtdz
2
6ul6z - 6wl6x
(2.10)
z lvldx - 6ul0y
Equations(2.10)can be written in vectorial form (see $ l 5 . 1 . 2 ( aa)n d 1 5 . 1 . 2 ( c ) ) :
@ : 0 , i + e j + 0 , k : V x 6,
2
( 2.n)
THEORY OF ELASTICITY
J I
changein volume per unit volume A is . 0 u A : e . . * e ,' -, . * e - - : - - ' * ! * dx 0y
dz
(2.r2)
2.1.4Hooke'slaw
c 6
Stnin
-+
Ruptur
Tim.
_.+
In order to calculatethe strainswhen the stressesare known, we must know the relationshipbetweenstress and strain. When the strainsare small, this relation is given by Hookes /anl which statesthat a given strain is directly proportional to the stressproducingit. The strainsinvolvedin seismicwavesare usuallylessthan l0 8 exceptvery near the source,so that Hooke'slaw holds. When several stressesexist, each produces strains independentlyof the others; hence,the total strain is the sum of the strainsproducedby the individual stresses. This meansthat eachstrain is a linear function of all of the stressesand vice versa.This linearity has important implicationsthat will be utilized later: It allows us to representcurved wavefrontsas a superpositionof plane waves,for example,in p-r transforms($9.1.5 and 9.1l.l ), to expressa reflected wavetrainas a superpositionof individual reflectrons (theconvolutionalmodel),and to justify manyaspects of seismicdata processing. In general,Hooke's law leads to complicatedrelations. Stress and strain can both be regarded as second-order(3 x 3) matricesso that the Hooke'slaw proportionality relatingthem is a fourth-ordertensor. Stressand straincan alsobe lookedon as (l X 6) matrices(as in eq. (2.l5)) and the Hooke'slaw proportionality as a 6 x 6 matrix whoseelementsare elastic constants(Landau and Lifshitz, 1986:32 5l). Symmetry considerationsimmediatelyreducethe number of independentconstantsto 21. However,when the medium is isotropit',that is, when propertiesdo not dependupon direction, it can be expressedin the following relativelysimpleform (Love, 1944:102): o,, : \A * 2p,e,, (i : x, y, z), (2.13)
(D)
Fig. 2.4 Stress strain.time strain; (b) strain versus time.
U:v.r.
relationships. (a) Stress versus
o,,: 2p"e,,
(2.14)
Theseequationsare often expressedas a matrix equation, o : Ce: o.r*
where( : ui + vj + wk is the vector displacementof point P(x, y), and i, j, k are unit vectorsin the x-, y-, :- directions,respectively. The changesin dimensionsgiven by the normal strains result in volume changes when a body is stressed.The change in volume per unit volume is called the dilatationand representedby A. If we start with a rectangularparallelepipedwith edgesdx, dy, and d: in the unstrainedmedium. in the strainedmedium the dimensionsare dx(l + s,,), dy(l * e,.,),and d:(l + e--),respectively;hencethe increasein volume is approximately(e.. * e,,, * e,_)d,t dy dz. Because the original volume was (dx dy dz), we see that the
(i,j : x, y, z; i + j).
o"" C,,
o., oy o,,
I \ + 2 p \ I 0 0 0 \ tr+2pI 000 I \ \ + 2 p 0 0 0 0 0 p 0 0 0 0 0 p 0 0 0 0 0
l%,
1",, lu..
0 0 0 18r' p Ile,,
1"",
(2.rs) The equationis sometimeswritten e : So, whereS : C r. Components of C (or S) are sometimescalled stffiess (or compliance)components. The quantities\ and p are known as Lam6'sconstants. If we write e,, : o,,lp",it is evident that e,, is
T H E O R YO F S E I S M I CW A V E S
38 smaller the larger p is. Hence, p is a measureof the resistanceto shearingstrain and is often referred to as the modulus o/' rigidity, incompressibility,or shear modulus. Although Hooke'slaw has wide application,it does When the stressis increased not hold for largestresses. beyond an elastic limit (fi5. 2.4a), Hooke's law no longerholds and strainsincreasemore rapidly.Strains resulting from stressesthat exceedthis limit do not entirely disappear when the stressesare removed. With further stress, a plastic yield point may be reachedat which plastic flow begins and the plastic yieldingmay resultin decreasingthe strain.Somematerials do not pass through a plastic flow phase but rupture first. Rocks usually rupture at strains - 1 0 - 3 - 1 04 . Some materialsalso havea time-dependentbehavior to stress(fig. 2.ab). When subjectedto a steady stress,such materialscreep until eventuallythey rupture.Creepstraindoesnot disappearifthe stressis removed. 2.L5 Elasticconstants Although Lame's constantsare convenientwhen we are usingeqs.(2.13)and (2.14)other elasticconstants are also used.The most common are ktung'smodulus (E), Poisson's ratio (o), and the bulk ntodulus(ft) (the ratio symbol o is more or lessstandardfor Poisson's the subscriptsshould preventany confusion with the stressou). To define the first two, we considera medium in which all stressesare zeroexcepto,-. Assumdimensions ing o,. is positive(that is, a tensilestress), parallelto o., will increaseand dimensionsnormal to this meansthat e.. is positive(elono,, will decrease; gation in the x-direction)wherease,.,and €--are negative. Also, we can show(seeproblem2.la) that e,, : e--.We now defineE and o by the relations E:
o,,/e,,,
o : - e , , , / D . .: - e - - l e , , ,
(2.16) (2.11)
with the minus sign insertedto make o positive. To define the bulk modulus k, we consider a medium acted upon only by a pressure0; this is equivalent to the stresses o . r : o . , . . :o , . : 0 . o . , . , : o , , ,: o , r : - 0 , Pressure0 causesa decreasein the volume AT and a dilatation L : LYIT:, k is definedas the ratio of the pressureto the dilatation that it causes,that is,
k:
-911,,
( 2 .l 8 )
with the minus sign insertedto make k positive.Somel/k, is usedas an elasticcontimesthe compressibility, stant rather than the bulk modulus. By substitutingthe precedingvaluesin Hooke'slaw, we can obtain the following relations betweenE, o, and k and Lam6's constants,\ and p (seeproblems 2.lb and2.1c):
-
F
p(3\ + 2p) :
(2.re)
A+Lr (t=
A
2(}' + P)'
k : l (13 \ + 2 u , t .
(2.20) (2.21)
In nonviscousfluids, the shear modulus pr : 0, and hencek : \. Becausewe have not previouslygiven a specificname to L, we may call it thefuid incompressibility. By eliminating different pairs of constants among the three equations,many different relations can be derivedexpressingone of the five constantsin termsof two others(seeproblem2.2). The elasticconstantsare definedin sucha way that they are positive numbers.As a consequenceof this, o must have values between0 and 0.5 (this follows from eq. (2.20),becauseboth \ and p are positiveand hence\/(\ + p) is lessthan unity). Valuesrangefrom 0.05 for very hard, rigid rocks to about 0.45 for soft, poorly consolidatedmaterials.Liquids have no resistanceto shearand hencefor them p : 0 and o : 0.5. For most rocks, 4 k, and p lie in the range from 20 to 120GPa (2 x 10",to 12 x l0'0 N/m' ), trgenerally being the largest and p the smallest of the three. Tablesof elasticconstantsof rocks havebeengivenby Birch (1966).(Seealsoproblem2.4.) an isotropic Most of the precedingtheory assumes medium. In fact, rocks are usually in layers with differentelasticproperties,thesepropertiesoften varying with direction. Nevertheless, in discussingwave propagation,we generallyignore suchdifferencesand treat sedimentaryrocks as isotropic media; when one does so, the results are useful and to do otherwise leads to extremelycomplex and cumbersomemathematical equations,exceptfor the caseof transversely isotropicmedia,that is, media in which the properties are the samein one plane but different along the normal to the plane. Some rocks, especiallyshales,are transverselyisotropic,and more importantly, a series of parallel beds,eachof which is isotropic,but where the properties vary from bed to bed, behavesas though it is transverselylisotropic (Postma, 1955; Uhrig and van Melle, 1955).Anisotropyis discussed in $2.6. 2.1.6 Strain energy When an elastic medium undergoes deformation, work is done and an equivalentamount of potential energy is stored in the medium; this energy is intimately relatedto elasticwavepropagation. If the stresso,- resultsin a displacemente,., we assume that the stressis increaseduniformly from zero to o....,and hencethe averagestressis o,,/2. Thus, -E : work done per unit volume : energyper unit volume : o,,e,12.
WAVE EQUATIONS
39
Summing the effectsof all the independentstresses and using eqs. (2.13) and (2.14) gives (Love, 1944: 100) , :
o,u,,
:))
: j(o..",,
62u
p;, : unbalancedforce in the x-direction on ot- a unit volume
* orr.8r,,* o,,8,, * o..".."
* o,,,8.,, *
Newton's secondlaw of motion statesthat the unbalancedforce equalsthe masstimes the acceleration; thus, we obtain the equation of motion along the xaxls:
o--*er.)
: l' t[ +- ( \ A + 2 P " e ,*, t*e) ), ", 1 , - |I .
u*i'1
: jf 4' + p(r.l. + ef, + e?_) + lp(ei,+ ef- + e1.).
(2.22)
Notethat eq.(2.22)gives 0 E l 6 e , , :} ' A + 2 p e , , : o . . , : o\,., 6El0e,,: p,e\,. hence, 3E/6x,, : o ,
_ d o . , T, d o . , . dr 6y
(i,j : x, y, z).
(2.23)
lto,, ^A:u _ , do,, -t'df dr 0y
o , , +, 0 o , .d. r , a,
o , *
6o O ' ' d r
Because thesestresses areopposite to thoseactinson therearface,thenet (unbalanced) stresses are r,x
'-%,0r, dx
{o--r' 0x'
dx
ao'.. dx
6x
0y
do,_
0z
, r') 6:l
: (\ + r,)la+ u.v.r,
r, )St
where V2a is the Laplacian of u : A2ulAx2* 62ul0y,-t (seeeq. (15.14)).By analogy,we can write the 32ul0z2 equationsfor y and w.' o-v
p '
At2
_.,.
Similarexpressions hold for the other faces;hence,we hnd for the total force in the direction of the x-axis the expression do,. , do., T
: ^:1t p"v2u * *u1 C:.:;.
oo.,d"
Thesestresses act on a face having anarea(dy d;) and affectthe volume (dr dy d:); hence,we get for the net lorcesper unit volume in the directionsof the rc_.y_. and :-axes the respectivevalues 9%o 0x'
dz
: ^:i. .[,i].(,11 .':;) . (,';;: .::;)l
Up to this point, we havebeendiscussinsa medium in staticequilibrium.We shallno*..-ou.lthis restric_ tron and considerwhat happenswhen the stresses are not in equilibrium.In fig.2.2,we now assumethat the stresses on the rear faceof the elementof volumeare as shown in the diagram but that the stresseson the liont face are, respectively,
'.o', or.
, dtr,-_
: ^:: * ,*qu";. -'r] . *or";.
2.2.1 St'uhr v:uveequation
O o" d x , ox
(2.24)
dz
wherep is the density(assumedto be constant).Simi_ lar equationscan be written for the motion alons the y- and z-axes. Equation (2.24) relatesthe displacementsto the stresses. We can obtain an equationinvolvingonly dis_ placements by using Hooke's law to replace the stresses with strainsand then expressing the strainsin terms of the displacements, using eqs. (2.g), (2.9), ( 2 . 1 2 )(. 2 . 1 3 )a, n d ( 2 . 1 4 )T. h u s .
2.2Wave equations
o,. *
do,,
62w
A
A
: ( t r + *)o-+rV)r'.
:
;}A
p - " : ( r +p ) ' - * p V r r y .
(2.261 (2.271
dt"
To obtain the waveequation,we differentiatethese three equationswith respectto x, y, and z, respectively,and add the resultstogether.This gives i ) '( a u d r du lA2L a,A a,A\ + - \l : ( \ + P ) l + | 'P ^ , 1 " -+ 3: / dy ilr\dx \dr2 6y, 0:2|
+ -*v,F! + 9l + ar\ \ax
thatis,
,Yr,:: (r + 2p)V'A
oy
ozl'
THEORY OF SEISMIC WAVES
o'o, *19;u4: l
|
where
(2.28)
cr' : (\ + 2St")lp. ) By subtractingthe derivativeof eq. (2.26)with respectto z from the derivativeof eq.(2.27)with respect to y, we get
in two ways in general: (a) include in the wave equation terms that representthe forces generatingthe wavesor (b) surroundthe point of observationP by a closed surface 9 and regard the effect at P as being given by a volume integral throughout the interior of I to take into accountsourcesinsideg plus a surface integral over I to give the effectof sourcesoutsideI (see$2.2.4).To apply the first method, we note that eqs. (2.25),(2.26), and (2.27) are equivalentto Newton's secondlaw, and thesethree equationsare combined in eq. (2.31).Therefore,a sourcecan be taken into account by adding to the right-hand side of eq. (2.31)the term pF, where F is the externalnonelastic force per unit mass(often calledbodylbrce) that gives riseto the wavemotion. Thus,eq. (2.31)becomes
,#(:;-9:.,'(X-y), that is,
L a'e.: V2o. 9' ur' where
rr-(
p ; ; : (\ + p) VA + p V'( + pF.
(2.2e)
9'= p,lp.
Taking the divergenceand curl of eq.(2.34)and using e q .( 1 5 . 1 4a) n d p r o b l e m1 5 . 7g i v e s
^:orvrA+v.F, By subtractingappropriatederivatives,we obtain srmilar resultsfor 0,,and 0-. Equations(2.28) and (2.29) are differentexamplesof the waveequation,which we can write in the generalform I drU v2 af
= vr,lr.
(2'30)
where V is a constant. 2.2.2 Vectorwaveequation The waveequationcan also be obtained using vector methods. Equations (2.25), (2.26), and (2.21) are equivalentto the vectorvtaveequation: ^)y
(2.31)
dt"
If we take the divergenceof eq. (2.31) and use eqs. (2.12)and (15.14)we get eq. (2.28).Takingthe curl of eq. (2.31)and usingeq. (2.11)and problem 15.7gives the vector waveequationfor S-waves(see$2.4.1),
(2.32) which is equivalentto the three scalarequations, I'
A " 2"A,
p' at'
: v20,
1 i: x , y . _ - ) .
(2.33)
2.2.3 Waveequationincludingsourceterm The foregoing discussionof the wave equation has made no mention of the sourcesof the waves,and in fact, the equations discussedare only valid in a source-freeresion. Sourcescan be taken into account
(2.3s)
ar@ : B r v r o + v x F l 2 . at2
(2.36)
Theseequationsare difficult to solveas they stand. The solution is greatly simplifiedby using the Helmholtz separationmethod, which involves expressing both ( and F in terms of new scalarand vector functions.Thus.we write
(:v0+Vx1,
0-( p= : (I + p) VA + p"V'(.
(2.34)
oI-
F:VY+Vxq
V'x:0, V'O:0.
(2.31) (2.38)
Then, usingproblem 15.7,we obtain
.\:V'(=V'0. ) 20:rVx(=-V,x, l V.F=V:Y. I
VxF:-V2O.
(2.3e)
)
Substitutingin eqs.(2.35)and (2.36),we get
V , ( c , ' V , d + Y - #: r) ,
v ' ( e ' v ' x + o - #:)t Wheneverd, X, I or O contain powersof x, y, and z higher than the first, theseequationscan only be satisfied for all valuesof x, 1 and z if the expressions inside the parenthesesare identically zero at all points. Becausea linear function ofx, y, and z correspondsto a uniform translation and/or rotation of the medium, we can ignore this possibility and write (Savarensky, 1975:199)
a'0 : af
ctrVrd * Y,
(2.40)
WAVE EQUATIONS
a1 :
41
B' V'1+ o.
dt"
(2.41)
tainedidenticalresultsfor S-waves.Thus,the previous equationsrefer to either P- or S-waves.
2.2.4 Kirchhoff's theorem
2.2.5 Plane-wave solutions
Method (b) referredto in 92.2.3is in fact an extension of method (a). It uses the superposition concept (which followsfrom the linearity expressed in Hooke's law). We regard the wave motion at a point P as the superpositionof the wavesfrom all sourcesR within somevolumeV surroundingP plus the wavesradiated by points Q on the surfaceI surroundingthe volume (which takes into account any disturbances from sourcesoutside the volume). We adjust the times for thesesourcesso that their effectsall arrive at P at the sameinstant ln. We take Y(x, y, z, lo) in eq. (2.40) as the sourcedensity (body force/unit volume) inside g and specify6@, y, z, /o) lor eachpoint on the surface lf , t o, and to being the retardedtimes (tt)- rll), where Z is the velocity,and r is the distancebetweenP and the sourcesR or Q, that is, rlV is the time for the wave to travel from R or Q to P Thus, we specifythe wave n.rotionat different points at different times such that the wavesfrom all points arrive at P at the same instirnt /0. The result, known as Kirchhofl''stheorem(or fbrmula)(Ewing,Jardetzky, and Press,1957:l6), is
Let us consider first the case where r! is a function only ofx and /, so that eq. (2.30)reducesto
lndr,(.r', y,:.t,,): () r" IJI
I d,u_ a,{, ln Af
0x2
(2.4s)
Any function of (x - Vt),
* :jk
- v0,
(2.46)
is a solution of eq. (2.45)(seeproblem 2.5a)provided that r! and its first two derivativesare finite and continuous. This solution (known as d'Alembert's solution) furnishesan infinite number of particular solutions (for example, ek(\ vt\,sin (x - Vt), (r - V03, wherewe must excludepoints at which thesefunctrons and their first three derivativesceaseto exist or are discontinuous).The answerto a specificproblemconsistsof selectingthe appropriatecombinationof solutions that also satisfiesthe boundary conditions for the problem. A body waveis definedas a "disturbance"that travels through the medium and carries energy (Logan, 1987:230).In our notation,the disturbanceg is a volume changewhen rf : A and a rotation when I : 0,.Obviously,the disturbancein eq. (2.46)is traveling along the x-axis. We shall now show that it travels with a speedequalto the quantity Z In fig. 2.5athe certainpart ofthe wavehas reached point P,,at time to. If the coordinateof P,, is r,,, then the value of g at P,, is t,, : .f(xu- Vt(,).lf this same portion of the wavereachesP, at time /0 + Al, then we havefor the value of rf at P,
- to,a!"'t . JI{(;Xi;)t:il
. (i)[:l]].'
t) 4)\
rhere I is the outward-drawnunit normal, and the .quarebracketsdenotefunctionsevaluatedat point Q .,: tinle to: tu - rl V, [$l is often referredto as a re'.tnladpotential.lf we assumethat eachsourceemits ':.hericalwaves($2.2.6)of the form (l/r)e j,il(r/r,)(see -;s (2.55)and (2.56)),eq. (2.42)becomes(Savaren. , . r .1 9 7 52: 3 4 )
r;dr,(.r, !, :, t,,) :
(;)JII O*
.
,(243) lJ {,[:l] rorj,,!]av
(l/r)er.(lo-l/'r
:
But, becausethis is the sameportion of the wavethat was at Puat time lo, we must haverlr,,: r.!,,that is, xn - Vto: xn * Ax - V(to+ Lt). Thus, the quantity Izis equal to AxlAt and is therefore the speedwith which the disturbancetravels.The reciprocalof velocity,l/Z is calledslowness. A function of (rt+ Vt), for example,* : g(x + Vt), is alsoa solutionof eq. (2.45).It denotesa wavetraveling in the negativex-direction. The generalsolution o f e q .( 2 . 4 5 ) , - Vt) + g(x + Vt), S : l("x
':re in the integrand, ,)] :
V, :,/[ru * A,x V(to+ Lt)|.
€ejot0,
(:
(llr)e
:-,tv,
(2.44) : .'.'is the angularfrequency(seeg2.l.l). J:crrusewe startedfrom eq. (2.40),eqs.(2.42)Io - -.-' rrrevalid for P-waves(see$2.4.1).However,we : iust as well havestartedfrom eq. (2.41)and ob-
(2.41\
representstwo wavestravelingalong the x-axis in oppositedirectionswith velocityZ The quantity r + Vt (or a constanttimes theseexpressions;see$2.1.1)is the phase.The surfaceson which the wave motion is the same,that is, the surlaces on which the phase has the same value, are known as wavefronts.In the casewe are considering, '! is independentof y and;, and so the disturbanceis
THEORY OF SEISMIC WAVES
A1
the same everlrvhere on a plane perpendicular to the x-axis; the wavefront is therefore plane and the wave Note that the wave is travelingin the is a plane u.'cve. direction normal to the wavefront:this holds for all wavesin isotropicmedia.A line denotingthe direction of travel of the waveenergyis called a raypath. Plane waves are easier to visualize and to treat mathematicallythan more complicatedwaves.Moreover, curved wavefronts can be approximated as closelyas desiredby a superpositionof plane waves. It is convenientat times to havean expressionfor a plane wave traveling along a straight line inclined at an angle to each of the axes.Assumethat the wave is traveling along the x'-axis, which has direction cosines({, m, n) relativeto the -x-,y-, and :-axes (fig. 2.6).Then,at a point P on the,t'-axisat a distance-r' from the origin, we have
Fig. 2.5
lllustrating the velocity ofa wave
x':(xlmy*nz, wherethe coordinatesof P are (-t, l :). Then, q :.f((v t my * nz - v0 +g((xlmylnz
+ vt).
(2.48) (, : coso, m: cos02
2.2.6 Spherical-u,avesolut ions
a:coS0r
In additionto planewaves,we shallhaveoccasionto use another important type of wave, the spherical x,aye,where the wavefrontsare a seriesof concentric sphericalsurfaces.We expresseq. (2.30)in spherical coordinates(r e,6;, where0 is the colatitude,and $ the longitude(seeproblem2.6b). 1d2S: ,. dt2
(""'il) J, .,i, 'i[iI (":Y). a.fl. +
sinrOddrl
Fig. 1.6
W a v ed i r e c t i o n n o t a l o n g a n a x t s
Fig. 2.7
Relation between spherical and plane waves.
e.4s)
We consideronly the specialcasewhen the wavemotion is independentof 0 and $, henceis a function only of r and l. Then we get the simplifiedequation
'"':Y:,:i," (":Y)
(2.50)
A solutionof the foregoingequationis \ 1: ( t l r ) J Q - V t )
( 2 . 5)1
(seeeq. (2.46\).Obviously, ,11:(llr)g(r+Vt) is alsoa solutionand the generalsolutionofeq' (2.50) (seeproblem2.5c)is '$ : (llrV(r - Vi) + (1lr)g(r+ Vt),
(2.52)
in which the first term representsa wave expanding outward from a central point and the secondterm a wavecollapsingtoward the central point. When r and I are fixed, (r - Vtl is constant and hencerl is constant.Thus, at the instant l, the wave
has the samevalue at all points on the sphericalsurface of radius r The sphericalsurfacesare therefore wavefrontsand the radii are rays.Obviously,the rays
GENERAL ASPECTSOF WAVES
l a
+J
are normal to the wavefrontsas in the caseof plane rvaves.(This is not always the case in anisotropic media.) As the wave progressoutward from the center,the radius increasesby the amount Z during each unit of time. Eventually,the radius becomesvery large and the portion ofthe wavefrontnear any particular point rvifl be approximatelyplane.If we considerfig. 2.7, we seethat the error that we introduce when we replace the sphericalwavefront PQR by the plane wavefront P'QR' is due to the divergencebetweenthe true direction of propagationgiven by the direction of the radius and the assumeddirection normal to the plane. By taking OQ very large or PR very small (or both), we can make the error as small as desired.Because planewavesare easyto visualizeand also the simplest to handle mathematically,we generallyassumethat conditions are such that the plane-waveassumption is valid.
23 General aspects ofwaves 2.3.I Harmonicy'uves In $2.2.5and 2.2.6,we discussed the geometricalaspectsofwaves, that is, how they dependon the space We now considerthe time dependence coordinates. of wavemotion. The simplesttime variation that a wavecan havels lrurmonit(sinusoidal), equivalentto simpleharmonic motion.ln general,wavesaremorecomplexthan this, but the methodsof Fourieranalysis({i 15.2)allow us to representalmostany complexwaveas a superposition of harmonic waves.Harmonic waves,becauseof their simplicity,can be regardedas the time equivalent of plane wavesin space. Adding nl2 to the phasein eq. (2.3)changescosrne to sine. so harmonic wavescan be written in either form. Some of the commonest forms are the following: t : I cos [(2rrl\Xx - Vt)] : A cos <(.r - Vt) : I cos(rr - t'rt) : I cos2tr(xl),,* vt) : A cos2r(xllt - tlT"1 : I cosa(xlV - t), { : I cos x(d,x+ my } nz - Vt) : I sin [rc({x + my I nz - Vt) + nl2],
(2.s3)
I es+t
q : @lr) cosrc(r- V0 + (B/r)cosr(r + Vt). (2.55) Equation(2.53)represents a plane wave travelingin the t,r-direction, eq. (2.54) a plane wave moving along a straightline with directioncosines((, m, n), and eq. (2.55) a sphericalwave expandingfrom and collapsingtowardthe origin. Equation(15.45)enablesus to combinethe cosine and sine expressionsfor a harmonic wave;thus, if we wnte r! :
lgroltrr+,n|+nzrr
4 -
Aejdtttv o,
(2.56)
we can get either the cosineor sineform by taking the real or imaginary part of r.f. The quantities((, m, r) in eq. (2.54) representthe direction cosinesof the ray. In problem 15.9a, we show that (2 + m2 * n2: l. Although ordinarily each of the cosineshas a maximum value of unity, satisfying the waveequationrequiresonly that the sum of the squaresbe unity. If we admit pure imaginarynum"direction cosines"can be greater bers, some of the than ,unity.Let us take in fig. 2.6, 0, : j0. 0, : :n. 0, : i n - j0. 0 beingreal and positive:then d:cosj0:cosh0, m:0, n : cos (:rr - je) : sinj0 : j sinh 0, () i m1 + n2 : cosh20 - sinh: 0 : l, *
:
Ag
(o:/t') sinh0ej(ol(.!/t]coshe rl.
(2.57)
This representsa plane wave travelingparallel to the x-axis with velocity Vlcosh 0 < V and amplitude Ae @rnsinhH. If we had taken0, : _j0, this would give a wavetravelingin the x-direction with amplitude decreasingupward in the negativez-direction.Because the amplitude decreasesexponentiallywith z, these wavesare calledevanescentwaves.We shall refer asain t o t h e s ew a v e si n N 2 . 7 . 5 . In explorationseismology,the rangeof frequencies recorded with appreciableenergy is generally from about 2 to 120 Hz, and the dominant frequencieslie in a narrower range from 15 to 50 Hz for reflection work and from 5 to 20 Hz for refraction work. Becausevelocitiesgenerallyrange from 1.6 to 6.5 km/s, dominant wavelengthsrangefrom about 30 to 400 m for reflection work and from 80 to 1300 m for refraction. 2.3.2 Wuvainterf'crent'e If two wavesare superimposed, they interferewith eachother; the interferenceisconstrut'liue if they tend to add and destructiveif they tend to cancel.When the two wavesare harmonic and have the samefrequen(her.rce ciesand wavelengths the samevelocities), their amplitudessometimesadd togetherand sometimes cancel(at leastpartially); thus, they form a new wave of the samefrequencyand wavelengthwith different amplitudeand phase-shifled. When severalharmonrc waveswith different amplitudes,frequencies,and/or wavelengthsare addedtogether,tht resultsare usually very complex; constructiveinterferenceoccurs when the phasesare nearlythe same(e.g.,$2.7.4and 13.3). otherwise destructiveinterferenceresults in at least someattenuation.lf the wavesare not harmonic, they can be resolvedby Fourier analysis(99.1and 15.2) into harmonic componentsthat can then be addedto determinethe nature of the interference. If we add two harmonic wavesof equal amplitudes (A) and velocities but slightly different frequencies (seeproblem2.1),Ihesum is B cos (rox - ont),where B : 2A cos (Arcx - Ato/), rcoand
THEORY OF SEISMIC WAVES
44 the values for the two waves.We regard -Bas the vartable amplitude of the resultant wave; at a fixed point, -r2A at the rate of L'al2n times per -Bvaries between second,that is, slowly in comparison with the wave frequencyaro.This phenomenonis calledbeating. 2.3.3 Huygens'principle The solutionsof the waveequationgivenby eqs.(2.47) and (2.52)are restrictedto plane and sphericalwaves. On the other hand. the Kirchhoff formula is valid for any type of body wave.As expressedin eq. (2'42) (assumingno sourcesinside9), it statesthat the effectat a point P is the sum of effectsthat took place earlier at all points on a surfaceI enclosing4 allowancebeing made for the time for theseeffectsto travel from 9 to P. Thus, each point on I behavesas though it were a new wave source. To obtain Huygens'principle,we take I coincident with that portion of the wavefrontthat we wish to take into accountin finding the effectat ^8 and then complete the closed surfaceby passingit through space where the effect has not yet arrived so that $ rs zero over this part. Huygens' principle is important in understanding wave travel and is often useful in drawing successive positionsof wavefronts.Huygens'principlestatesthat every point on a wavefrontcan be regardedas a new sourceof waves.The physicalrationalebehind this is that each particle located on a wavefront has moved from its equilibrium position in approximately the same manner. that the elastic forces on neighboring particlesare therebychanged,and that the resultant of the changesin force becauseof the motion of all the points on the wavefront thus begins to produce the motion that forms the next wavefront.In this way, Huygens' principle helps explain how information about seismicdisturbancesis communicatedin the earth. Specifically,given the location of a wavefront at a certain instant, future positionsof the wavefront can be found by consideringeach point on the first wavefrontas a new wavesource.In fig. 2.8, lB is the wavefrontat the time lu and we wish to find the wavefront at a later time /,, + Ar. During the interval At, the wave will advancea distance V L't, V being the velocity (which may vary from point to point)' We select points on the wavefront, Pp P2,P,' and so on, from which we draw arcs of tadri V Al. Provided we selectenoughpoints,the envelopeof the arcs (l'B') will defineas accuratelyas we wish the position of the
wavefront at time t0 + Al. Except on the envelope,the elemental waves interfere destructively with each other so that their effectscancel.When lB is plane, and V constant,we needdraw only two arcs and the straight-linetangent to the two arcs definesthe new wavefront. Note that Huygens' principle gives only phaseinformation; it doesnot give amplitudes' 2.4 Body waves 2.4.1 P-wavesand S-waves Up to this point, our discussionof wave motion has beenbasedupon eq. (2.30).The quantity r! has not been defined;we have merely inferred that it is some disturbancethat is propagatedfrom one point to another with speed Z However,in a homogeneousisotropic medium,eqs.(2.28)and(2.29)must be satisfied. We can identity the functionsA and 0,with rf and conclude that two types of wavescan be propagatedin a homogeneousisotropicmedium, one corresponding to changesin the dilatation A and the other to one or more componentsof the rotationgivenin eq' (2.1| ). The first type is variously known as a dilatational, longitudinul, irrotatknul, t'ompressional,or P-wave, the latter namebeinggivenbecausethis type is usually the first (primary)eventon an earthquakerecording. The secondtype is referredto as the 'vheur,transverse, it is usuallythe second rotutional,or S-nave(because major eventobservedon earthquakerecords).The Pwavehas the velocityo in eq. (2.28)and the S-wave the velocityB in eq. (2.29),that is,
":(^*tu\'':(\'''
(2.58)
B = \(p*/ ) " ,
lr sqr
\
p
/
where M is the P-l'rive ntotlulus.Becausethe elastic constantsare alwayspositive,ct is alwaysgreaterthan B. Using eq. (2.20),we seethat
(2.60
: : ( ^ f r * ) ' " : ( 0 r ' - - ' " ) ")
(seefig. 2.9). As o decreasesfrom 0.5 to-0, P/ct increasesfrom 0 to itr maximum value, l/r/2; thus, the velocity of the S-waverangesfrom 0 to 70% of the velocity of the P-wave. For fluids, p is zero and henceB is also zero; therefore S-wavesdo not propagatein fluids. Using eq. (2.21),we seethat for a fluid, tr' : k, hence, o : lklp)'''
Fig. 2.8
Using Huygens'principle to locate new wavefronts.
\Pt
(2.6r)
The seismicvelocity in actual rocks depends on many factors, including porosity, lithology' cementation, depth, age, pressureregime, interstitial fluids, etc.. which are discussedin chap' 5. The velocity of water-saturatedsedimentary rocks is generally in the 1.5to 6.5 km/s range,increasingwith loss of porosity,
BODY WAVES
4\
a.lp 0.5 5.0
0.4
3.0 2.0
n a
1.5 1.0
v
o.2
0.4
0.6
9ta Fig.2.9
B/cras a function of Poisson'sratio o and k/p.
mum compression (maximum A) at the wavefront D,' particle velocity is zero at each of thesepoints. We can visualizethe plane-wavesituation by imagining that the radiusin fig. 2.10has becomevery large so that the wavefrontsare practically plane surfaces. The displacementswill be everywhereperpendicular to theseplanesso that there will no longer be convergenceor divergenceof the particlesof the medium as they move back and forth parallel to the direction of propagationof the wave.Sucha displacementis longitudinal, which explains why P-wavesare sometimes called longitudinal waves.P-wavesare the dominant wavesinvolvedin seismicexploration.A planeP-wave is illustratedin fig. 2.11a. To determine the motion of a medium during the passageof an S-wave,we return to eq.(2.29)and consider the casewherea rotation 0,, which is a function of x and t only, is being propagatedalong the x-axrs. We have
L a'q,: a'9,,
g' AP
i)x2
Because 0v 3u 0v z H' _0: x O y d x from eq. (2.l0), we seethat the wave motion consists
Fig. 2.10
Displacements for a spherical P-wave.
cementation,depth, and age. (Velocity versusdepth relationsfor three situationsare shown in fig. 11.28.) The velocity of P-wavesin water is approximately1.5 km/s. P-wave velocity is lowered, often markedly, *hen a gasreplaceswater as the interstitialfluid. This is especiallyimportant in the near-surface,generally above the water table, where a low-velocity layer tLVL, also called the weatheredlayer) typically has a relocity in the 0.4 to 0.8 km/s range,occasionallyas lorv as 150m/s, sometimesas high as 1.2 km/s. Let us investigatethe nature of the motion of the medium correspondingto the two types of wave motron. Consider a sphericalP-wave of the type given bv eq. (2.51).Figure 2.10showswavefrontsdrawn ar quarter-wavelength intervals, r being chosen so that x I7 is a multiple of d2. The arrows representthe di:ection of motion of the medium at the wavefront. The medium is undergoingmaximum compressionat B fthat is, the dilatation A is a minimum) and mini-
W W W W W (a)
(b)
Fig. 2.11 Motion during passageof plane body waves.(After Earth,2d ed., by F. Pressand B. Siever,p.424. Copyright 1974 by W H. Freeman and Company; reprinted with permission.) (a) P-wave; (b) S-wave.
THEORY OF SEISMIC WAVES
46 solely of a displacementv of the medium in the ydirection, v being a function of both x and t, Because u is independentof y and z, the motion is the same everywherein a plane perpendicular to the x-axis; thus, the case we are discussingis that of a plane S-wavetravelingalong the x-axis (fig. 2.I 1b). We can visualizethe foregoing relations using fig. 2.12.When the wavearrivesat -Eit causesthe medium in the vicinity of P to rotateabout the axis Z'2" (par' allel to the;-axis) through an anglee. Becausewe are dealingwith infinitesimalstrains,s must be infinitesimal and we can ignore the curvatureof the displacementsand considerthat points suchas P' and P" are displacedparallel to the y-axis to the points Q' and Q". Thus, as the wavetravelsalong the x-axis,the medium is displaced transverselyto the direction of propagation,hencethe name transversewave.Moreover,becausethe rotation variesfrom point to point at any given instant, the medium is subjectedto varying shearing stressesas the wave moves along; this accounts for the name shearwave. Becausewe might havechosento illustrate0,,in fig. 2.12insteadof 0-, it is clear that shearwaveshavetwo degreesof freedom,unlike P-waves,which have only one - along the radial direction. In practice,S-wave motion is usually resolvedinto componentsparallel and perpendicularto the surfaceof the ground, these When are known respectivelyas Sf1- and SV-w'aves. the wave is traveling neither horizontally nor vertically, the motion is resolvedinto a horizontal [Sl{ component and a component in the vertical plane through the direction of propagation. Henceforth' S-wavewill mean SZ-waveunlessotherwisenoted. Becausethe two degreesof freedomof S-wavesare independent,we can havean S-wavethat involvesmotion in only oneplane,for example,Sll or SZmotion; such a wave is said to be plane-polarized.We can also havea wavein which the SH and S Z motion havethe same frequencyand a fixed phasedifference;such a wave is elliptically polarized. Polarization of S-waves is a factor in their explorationuse (see$13.1).Note that we cannot havea sphericallysymmetricalS-wave (analogous to the P-wave illustrated in fig. 2.10). S-waveamplitude must vary with direction. In the caseof a medium that is not homogeneous and isotropic, it may not be possibleto resolvewave motion into separateP- and S-waves.However,inhomogeneitiesand anisotropy in the earth are small enough that the assumption of separate P- and S-wavesis valid for practical purposes.
Fis..2.12 Rotation of medium during passageof an S-wave
and 1(x, y, z, t), which are solutionsof the P- and Swaveequations,respectively, and which are so chosen that u, v, w (or i, v, *) can be found by differentiation. A simpleexampleof suchfunctionsis the following:
V0:( :(ui+ui+ ruk),
X:0, so that
(2.62)
a0
,' r : q 0
0y'
6x'
This procedureis valid only if it correspondswith A being a solution of the P-waveequation.Because( is a solutionand A : V' ( : V'0, A is alsoa solution (becausederivativesof a solution are also solutions). SettingX : 0 is equivalentto sayingthat S-wavesdo not existand this choiceof potential functionsis suitable for discussingwavemotion in fluids. For wavemotion in three-dimensionalsolids,d and 1 can be definedso that
r : v ( o +*) - o'*u
(2.63)
This ensuresthat A and 0 are solutionsofthe P- and S-waveequations,respectively(seeproblem 2.9a). For two-dimensionalwavemotion in the xz-plane, g and 1 can be definedby
(:V0+Vx1,
x:-xi,
2.4.2Displacementand velocitypotentials Solutionsof the waveequationssuch as those in eqs. (2.48) and (2.52) furnish expressionsfor A and e. Howevet often we needto know the displacementsa, v. "lr'.or the velocities i : duldt, i, w, and referenceto eqs. (2.8) to (2.12) shows that these are not easily found given only values of A and 0,. This difficulty is often resolvedby using potential functions6@, y, z, t)
d0 0z
u:
ad
^ t dx
ax ^'t dz
w
=99_ax dz
dx
,,*, ]
It is easy to show that eqs. ( 2 . 1 2 )a f i ( 2 . 1 1 )c a n b e expressedas
A:V.(:V'd, I
2@: V x (: V'Xi, )
(2.6s)
BODY WAVES
A 1
so that A and @ are again solutions of the p- and S-waveequations(seeproblem 2.9b). Becausethe wave equationsare still valid if both sidesare differentiatedwith respectto time /, it follows that velocity potentialswill be obtained in each of the preceding.casesif u, v, w, and ( are replaced with n, n, w, and i.
2.4.3 Waveequation influid media In fluids, only P-wavesare propagatedand we are generally interestedin pressurevariationsrather than displacementsor velocities,as in solid media. Equation (2.62) can be expressedin terms of pressureg. We redefined in the form
VO:ri+ij +wk, fi:#,
etc.(2.66)
In eq. (2.24),we set o.., : or,, : o," : 0,
o,._,: 0r, : o_:
-g;
hence,using eq. (2.24),we get d:u Ag p. . : - ; = acceleration along the x-axis, (2.67) dx dl'
and similarly for the y- and z-axes.Adding the three componentsof accelerationgives .1A -V9' P V"^Y : dI
Ignoring the additiveconstantdue to hydrostaticpressure(becausewe are interestedonly in pressurevariatrons).
^ a ?J': -p
d :JopQ. d
(2.68)
if we consideronly harmonic wavesof the form -
6
Ae:,",--'t
:
lgt
(seeeq. (2.56)).Thus, both g and I sarisfythe p-wave equationas in eq. (2.28),the velocity reducingto a : (klp)t/2in fluids(seeeq. (2.61)). In the caseof a gas, k dependsupon the way the uasis compressed,isothermallyor adiabatically(that 15.with no transferof heat during the wave passage). For sound wavesin air, the compressionis essentially .rdiabaticso that the pressureand volume obey the iaw, .')I'" : constant,
^l = ('rl(', - 1.4 for air, (2.69)
'* herec.,and c' are the specificheatsat constantpres.ure and volume, respectively(Hsieh, 1975: 54-5; Lapedes,1978).Equation(2.18)can be written LeP
, A
:
-
Vdg
L1ft1r d1/" ,.hereA9 is thepressure changecreatedby thewave.
By using the adiabatic law, logarithmic differentiation of eq. (2.69) gives k = "y0, and hence o:
lyTlp)v2
(2.70)
2.4.4 Boundary conditions When a wavearrives at a surfaceseparatingtwo media having different elasticproperties,it gives rise to reflectedand refractedwavesas describedin 93.1.1.The relationshipsbetweenthe various wavescan be found from the relationsbetweenthe stressesand displacementson the two sidesof the interface.At the boundary between two media, the stressesand displacements must be continuous. Two neighboringpoints R and S, which lie on oppositesidesof the boundaryas shownin fig.2.13will in generalhavedifferent valuesof normal stress.This differenceresults in a net force that acceleratesthe layer between them. However, if we choose points closer and closer together,the stressvaluesmust approach each other and in the limit when the two points coincideon the boundary,the two stresses must be equal. If this were not so, the infinitesimallythin layer at the boundary would be actedupon by a finite force and hencehave an accelerationthat would approach infinity as the two points approacheachother. Becausethe same reasoningapplies to a tangential stress,we seethat the normal and tangentialcomponents of stressmust be continuous (cannot change abruptly) at the boundary. The normal and tangentialcomponentsof displacement must also be continuous.If the normal displacement were not continuous,one medium would either separatefrom the other,leavinga vacuumin between, or elsewould penetrateinto the other so that the two media would occupy the samespace.If the tangential displacementwere not continuous, the two media would move differently on opposite sides of the boundary and one wtruld slide over the other. Such relative motion is assurnedto be impossibleand so displacementmust be continuous. When one or both of the solid media are replaced by a fluid or a vacuum, the boundary conditions are reducedin number(seeproblem2.10). \ 2.4.5 Wavesfroma sphericalsource The potentialfunction6: Qr)flt - rlI)is a solution to the waveequationwhen thereis sphericalsymmetry (seeeq. (2.51));hence,the radial displacementrz(ar) is
u(r, t):'# : -(lr)t( - ;)
.0;,v(-;)l
(2.11)
(using eq. (2.62) with the x-axis in the radial direction). For harmonic waves,the two terms have equal importance at a distancer : |tl2rr, but the first term decaysrapidly in importanceat greaterdistances.The
THEORY OF SEISMIC WAVES
48
^l o" ^,1o,,
"'f o,,
.tl Fig.2.14 Radial displacementinvolvesshapedistortion. When the radial displacement decreaseswith distance from source S, sectot ABDC becomes thinner and approaches a rectangular plate.
{o"
of normalstress. Fig.2.13Continuity
second term is the far-field ffict, wheteas the nearfietd effectdependson both terms. This distinction is important when calculating a far-field waveshape from near-field recordings.Note that radial motion involves shape distortion (fig. 2.14) and therefore shearstrain. Equation (2.11) can be usedto derivethe wavemotion createdby symmetricaldisplacementof the medium outward from a point source.When the wave is createdby very high pressures,as in an explosion of dynamite, the wave equation is not valid near the source becausethe medium does not obey Hooke's law there; this difficulty is usually resolvedby surrounding the sourceby a sphericalsurfaceof radius r,,such that the waveequationis valid for r > ro' then specifyingthe displacementor pressureon this surface due to the source. Let us consider the case where the displacement u(r, t) is to be found, given the displacement uo(t) of the surfacer: rn.We let 6 : t (r ro)/I/and write
Note that the lower limit of the integral means that t : 0 is the instant at which the wavefirst reachesthe surfacero, uo(t)being zero beforethis. To carry the calculationfurther,we must know uo(/). Let us approximatean explosionby the expression uo(t) : ke-'l
: 0
o'dt J'Q):-rnve'"','!i,',uker'. rtrc- e ut). \vk 1s Vlru - a - r)l V We replaceI in this expressionby ( : t - (r and eq. (2.73)becomes rok dd : l' ,-'o'" - ee 's ulr. tl : Ar r(Vlrn - a) Lro
-Y-e-'u'u+!r-"r] r r l
(
-
then
t):#: -l)trr,.I,Wl Q73) u(r, -[J,nt, * ,)rfff uo(tt:
(2.74)
Using thesevaluesand multiplying both sidesof eq' by the integrating factor evtt'o,we get Ql\
d dl
: [.''"/(r)l ,"' *'frr] , , r \ - , J el,' olof r0dl : f(t):
I L -ro Vuo(!)en,t,o,
- r o V e - r ' r ' o u o ( / ) e " ' ' od t ' ( 2 ' 7 5 ) Jo
o'] e .,6)
Then
S0 0: Qtr)l(0, ( > 0 , r = , r l e . l Z ) : 0 I
At r : rn, (: t and u(r,t) : uoQ),whereuo(t)depends on the specificsource:
I ?3:"
( ' , - , n , , -, o . , . ) . _..r,k , r(Vlro - a\ \r,, ,
(2.77) r ))
ro. (2.78)
the latter equationgiving the far-field solution. The fact that eqs. (2.77) ar,d (2.78) are valid only for ( > 0 (seeeq. (2.72))merely meansthat u(r, t) ts zero until t : (r - r^)ll\ that is, until the disturbance reachesthe point. At this instant, ( : 0 and u(n t) : k(rolr); hence the initial displacementis the same as that of the surface r0 except that it is reduced by the factor rJr, that is, u(n t) falls off inversely as the distance(see$2.7.1and eq. (2.109).Moreover,u:0 at / : - and also when (seeeq. (2.77)) V(llro - llr)e ltr'o+ (Vlr - a)e-'t : Q, that is. when t:
t -- t n " + V
V(r-r^) I ln Vlrn-a ror(a-Vlr)
SURFACE WAVES
49
Provided Vlro) a > Vlr, this equationhas a real positive root and u(r, l) will vanish, that is, the displacement must changesign. BecauseVlroislarge in practice and Vlr rapidly becomessmall, in general the unidirectionalpulsein eq. (2.76)givesrise to an oscillatory wave. By using different expressionsfor ao(l)in eq. (2.75) or by specifyingS|,,(t),the pressureat the cavity, we can investigatethe wave motion for various spherically symmetricalsources(seeBlake, 1952;Savarensky, 1975: 243-55). By finding the limit as a in eq. (2.76)goesto zero(seeproblem2.12),wegetthe result lor a unit step,step(r);then the resultsfor other inputs can be found using convolution techniques (see $r 5 . 4 .)l. 2.5 Surface waves 2.5.I General The waveequationsfor P- and S-wavesin terms of the potentialfunctionsof eq. (2.64)are V:S :
(l/ar) Ar{,ldtr,
YtX, : (118' ) l' yrl6t', YtXr:
(llBr) \ryrl6tr,
(p-wave)
componentsexist (S^F1-motion is parallel to the xyplane and so is not involved in the boundary conditions) and adjust their amplitudes to satisfy the boundary conditions. Appropriate potentialsare +
:
Ae
vn't,
Xt,
:
Be
neejKtx
vn),
(2.82) wherez and n must be real positiveconstantsso that the wave decreasesin amplitude away from the surface; V^ is, of course, the velocity of the Rayleigh wave.Substitutingg and 1,, in eqs.(2.79)and (2.80) glves m2 : (.1- V' ^la' ),
n' : (l - Vr-lgr).
(2.83)
Becausem and n are real, li < g < o, so that the velocity of the Rayleighwave is lessthan that of the S-wave. We next apply the boundary conditions.Using the resultsof problem2.1l, we get for : : 0
(2.19)
=trv:d* 2pflt - l'*-'):, I \r,:' dx d:l
a
{Strz-wave.;(2.80)
';_1,, : r : u(,o^:!o=ilr) J
f fZ.S+l
o.,,
(SI/-wave) (2.81)
wherethe S-wavepotential hasbeenreplacedwith the l'unctions1,. and XH correspondingto SZ- and Sl1components.If we considerplane wavestravelingin the directionof the -t-axisin an infinitehomogeneous medium,solutionsof theseequationsare of the form elx(\ ''t, V : o or B. However,othersolutionsarepossiblewhenthe infinitemediumis dividedinto different media.When the.r1-planeseparates two media,solutions of the form e'(:eiK(\ '?)existundercertainconditions. Thesesolutionscorrespondto plane waves travelingparallelto the,rr-axiswith velocity V and amplitude decreasingexponentiallywith distancefrom the ,ry-plane(in a semiinfinitemedium; see$2.5.2to 2.5.4). Such wavesare called sur/at'ewavesbecause theyare "tied" to the surfaceand diminishas they get farther from the surface.
mEe)K(\
Substitutingeq. (2.82)into the foregoingand setting : : 0 gives l(|t + 2p")m,- \ll
+ 2jnp"B: 0
and -2jmA + (n'+ l)B:
0.
We can useeqs.(2.58),(2.59),and (2.83)to write the first result in the form (2P'-
Vil'l + 21n$18: 0.
Eliminating the ratio BIA from the two equations gives l (2 - V]l$)(n2 + 11: 4*n; hence,
2.5.2 Ra"vleigh v,uves The most important surfacewavein explorationseismology is the Ra1'lr,ighv'ave,which is propagated along a free surfaceof a solid. Although a "free" surlbce means contact with a vacuum, the elastic constants and density of air are so low in comparison with valuesfor rocks that the surfaceof the earth is approximatelya free surface.Groundrol/ is the term commonly usedfor Rayleighwaves. We take the free surfaceas the x.y-planewith the :-axis positive downward. The boundary conditions (ti2.4.4)require that ct,": 0 : o,, at z : 0 (seeproblem 2. l0), that is, two conditions must be satisfied, and so we require two parameters that can be adjusted.Therefore,we assumethat both P- and SV-
vi-
89' Vi+ Q4 - l6B'la')$av] + l 6 ( B r l a ,- l ) p u : O .
(2.85)
Becausethe left side of eq. (2.85)is negativefor V^: 0 and positive for V*: +8, a real root must exist between thesetwo values,this root giving the Rayleigh wave velocity Z^. However,we cannot find this root without knowing p/ct. For many rocks, o - t/q, that is, (B/ct), - t/z from eq. (2.60).If we use this value, the three roots of eq. (2.85) are Vt*: 49r,2(l r l/.,F)82. Because V^lg must be lessthan unity, the only permissiblesolution IS
Vi:2(r - l/{3)8.,
or
V*: 0.9t99.
THEORY OF SEISMIC WAVES
50 W e n o w f i n d t h a t \ l a : 0 . 5 3 1l,n : 0 . 8 4 8n, : and BIA: +1.468j;hence, 0 yr:
:
0.393,
6r.
vRt)i, le-0.848K2 ejKtx 0 3 e 3 x ue j K ( r r R ' ) . l.468jAs
Using eq. (2.64),we get for the displacementsat the surface rRl). w : 0.620r
-
lre,,,,^'ejK(f
t's1), t
Xt
:
Ble,r(--ejK(\
Medium (2):
rs1)'
:
Are^.^'ejK(r
l/st),
y, :
fl'gnr*zgi"G vst'),
wherem,, n, are real,positiveconstants,and Z, is the velocity.Substitutingd,, X, in eqs.(2.79)and (2.80), we find that ml : | - 1V,la,)2.
ni : | - (V,lp)'
(i : 1,2), (2.88)
Becausem, and ti, are real. Z. must be less than the smallerof B, and B.. The boundary conditions required that w, : wt, Lt,: tt1,o--,lr: o,.l:, o,--l': o.-1.at: : 0' The results of problem 2.11 show that theseconditionslead to equationsinvolving first and secondderivativesofthe potentials,; being setequal to zero after the differentiation; consequently,all terms will have the factors ejK(\ t'sr)and either r or r:, and thesefactorswill cancel out, so we can ignore them; at the sametime, the exponential term in z will become unity. Moreoveq differentiationwith respectto r and z is equivalentto multiplyingthe potentialsby jrc a\d +miK or +niK, respectively;by eliminatingrc,differentiationbecomes equivalentto multiplying by j and lm,, tn,. The four boundaryconditionsnow give fr,A, - jB,: -m.A. - iB., jA,4-n,B,: jA. - n.8., \,(-l
+ m | ) A , + 2 p , ( m l A ,- i r , B , ) : \, (- 1 + m!)A' + 2P.(m1A'+ jn.B,),
p.,f2jm,A,+(nl+l)B,l : p,.l-2jm,A, + (nl + l)8,1. If we transfer all terms to the left-hand side, we equations($15.1.1); havea set of four homogeneous thesehave a nontrivial solution only if the determinant of the coefficientsvanishes.Settingthe determinant equal to zero and using eqs.(2.58),(2.59),and (2.88),we get the following equation for Vr: V ! l ( p , - p , ) ' - ( p , m ,* p . m , )( p , n ,* P , n , ) . + 4 4 0 t , - p J [ p , ( l - m , n , )- p , ( l - m r n . ) ] + 4 ( p , - F r ) t ( 1 * m , n , )( l * m r n , ): 0 .
(2.8e)
Equation (2.89)was first given by Stoneley(1924). Scholte(1947)studied the propertiesof the equation and found that a solution alwaysexistswhen one of the media is a fluid but, when both media are solids, a solution exists only when B, - B, and the ratios prlprand p,/p, fall within the narrow limits shown in fig. 2.17. Thesewavesare a type of generalizedRayleigh wavesand are usually called Stoneleywaves. Stoneleywavesare often presentin borehole seisfrequenciesare far mic surveys($2.5.5).Stoneley-wave below those used in sonic logging ($5.4.3),but they fall within the frequencyrange of VSPs ($13.4)and Stoneleywavesconstitutean important sourceof coherentnoisein VSP surveys.
Directionof wavepropagation
Surface
f
A Y
l
- L
\<
l0'
20'
( .
)
7) I +
I
U
30'
40' 50t
60'
70'
: ,.lergh waves.(a) Cross-section showing motion on ,:J diminishing with depth for a semiinfinite solid. , :--.rrrtlon of a particle on the surfaceof a semiinfinite .-rl motion of a particle on the surface (from How, Ralleigh-wave motion from a small explosion as -:rred geophones;motion changesfrom retrograde , : . r b o u t4 0 f t ( a f t e r D o b r i n , l 9 5 l ) .
I
fl I
I /
0
80'
e
g0'
e
100'
t (d)
THEORY OF SEISMIC WAVES
52
n2xz--) 0 We must have q, real and positive so that e as z -) +-; therefora, Vt 1 Br. However,qr is unrestricted becausez is finite in the upper layer. Applying the boundary conditions,we have at z : - h , o r , : 0 : p r s , , l ' s o 6 v , l 0 z: 0 f r o m e q ' ( 2 ' 9 ) ' that is,
0.5 0.4 o 0.3
Ae ,r*n- Berr*r'- O.
0.t 0
Fig. 2.16 ratio, o.
0.2
0.8
0.6 0.4 VEIICITY RANO
: cr.,lz,vr: v2,so At z : 0, o,,"11 -lL,\,C, tLfl,(A B):
1,0
Rayleigh-wave velocity, Z^, as a t'unction of Poisson's
and A + B :C . s 2tvh,b : prtl,/lr,tl,, theseequations
By setting6: become
a A- B : 0 , A-B+bC:0, A+B-C:0.
I I )
(2.er)
For thesehomogeneousequationsto havea nontrivial solution.the determinantof the coefficientsmust vani s h ( s e e$ 1 5 . 1 . 1t)h, a t i s ,
l,
l'
-l
-t
0l
,l: u ,
-'l lr +l
o3
o.r
,lrr, Fig. 2.17 Conditions for the existenceof a Stoneleywave; solutions exist within the shaded area. (Alier Scholte' 1947.)
2.5.4Lovewuves Love waves(Love, l9l l) are surfacewavesconsisting of SH-motion parallelto an interface'They exist only when a semiinfinitemedium is overlain by an upper layer of finite thicknessterminating at a free surface' We take the lower interface as the -.ry-planeand the -h; the SHfree surface as the parallel plane z : of component only The y-direction. is in the motion displacementis v, so ( : vi in eq.(2'11),hence,v satrsfies the wave equation and we can dispensewith the potential1" of eq. (2.81)and use v instead. The boundary conditions (see problem 2'10) require that o., : 0 &t z : -h and that o,.- and v be continuousat z : 0; thus, we need three parameters to adjustand so we write the following: M e d i u m( l ) : -h = z < 0. vil), v, : (Aeu*' ",u39 rr*)el<" Medium (2): V, :
Q!-nz*'giK\r
- vLt),
0 S
Z <
+-.
Substituting vr and v2in the wave equdtions gives
r?:r-(vJg)"\ \tr:l-(vLlg,)' . )
(2.e0)
-b : (l - a)l(l + a) :(l :
(grr*r, -
- e ' r r . r ) / ( l* e : ' ' " ' ;
g-rr"i')/(grr.r' + e n'd')
: t a n hr | K f t : - ( p . r l r l p , 1 , ) . But tanh -t is positive for all real valuesof x, also 1, is real and positive; therefore,rlr must be imaginary' = that is, rl, : j(, where ( is real. Becausetanh jx j tan x, we now get pzrlz: p,( tan (rcft.
(2.92)
From eq. (2.90),we have
r e | f i : l - r l i: l + ( ' , sothat Il > B,.Thus, 9,> 4> 9,, and the S-wavevelocity must be higher in the deeper layer than in the surface layer, ( then being in between the two velocities. Becauser : 2nl\ : .14, as the frequency increasesfrom zero, tan r{h increasesand approaches infinity; thus for eq. (2.92) to hold, as the frequency increases,( must approach zero and If must approach its ( B,. Conversely,as K approacheszero, approaches maximum value and trfapproachesBr. Hence,at high frequencies, the Love-wave velocity approaches the velocity ofS-wavesin the surfacelayer,and as the frequency approacheszero, the Love-wave velocity approachesthe S-wavevelocity in the lower layer (Dobrin.1951).
SURFACE WAVES
)J
The expressionfor v, can be written v, : :
(Ae:*L' + Be iKLz)etk(x-vL' jKLz)ejK(xvLn A(ejKLz + ae
on using eq. (2.91).Therefore, v, : :
/(gi*tz
+
e-2jK{re-jK(z)ejK(x-
AlejKAd+h) 1
vLt)
g-jx((z+l)]gjx(x- th- vLt)
: 2Alcos r((z _r h)lst*e tn_vo
(2.93) Az
on taking the real part of the amplitude. We seethat vr vanisheson planeswhere r((z + h) : (r + ll2)r
I
(r integral) (2.94)
(recall that ft is positiveand z is negativein the upper fayer);theseplanesare callednodalplanes(see$2.I . I ). Nodal planesare characteristicof normal-modepropagation ($13.3)and indeed Love waves can be explainedin terms of normal-modepropagation(Grant : l-5). a n d W e s t .1 9 6 5 8 Fig. 2.18
2.5.5 Tubewaves Waves traveling in a fluid-filled borehole or on the walls of a borehole in the direction of the axis (tube waves)are of considerableinterestin velocity surveys in wells ($5.4.2),in vertical seismicprofiling ($13.4), and in sonic logging ($5.4.3). Because they have mainly only I degreeof freedom(along the axis),their amplitude decreasesslowly with distance.Sometimes severalmodesoftube wavesare presentand often the mechanismsof their generationand the natureof their motion are not clear. Tube waveshave the potential of furnishing infiormationabout the elasticproperties and permeabilityof the surroundingformations. Most tube-waveenergy travels axially, but radial motion is also involved in some modes. A pressure geophoneor one hanging freely in the borehole will sensethe maximum tube-waveeffectsin the borehole fluid, whereasa geophoneclamped to the borehole wall will sensemuch smallermotion. The classicaltube wave is merely a P-wavepropagating in the fluid, the borehole wall expandingand contractingas the pressurewavepasses.We assumea homogeneousfluid in a cylindrical boreholepenetratisotropicmedium (fig. 2.18).Using a homogeneous ing I for the pressureand lt for the displacement, Newton'ssecondlaw,net force : massX acceleration, applied to a volume element of the fluid, V : rr2 Az,is
uo;|. (1?^') trr:- -(prr'^') ag 0z
62w AP
F r o m e q .( 2 . 1 8 ) ,
8l : -kL:
-kAYl\ .
Changes involved in passageofa tube wave.
The changein volume A1/ is due to expansionboth along the axis and radially,that is, LY : rr2'! u * (2nru,)a,2, 0z wherea, is the changein the radius of the hole. Thus, we get
: -k (uo'; *'?) QP
(2.e6)
Lamb (1960:$157)derivedthe followingrelationbetweenu, and I for an annulusofinner and outer radii r and R, where c, o, and p are respectivelyYoung's modulus, Poisson'sratio, and the shear modulus for the annulusmaterial:
u, _0 (l + q)(Rl+ l) r
E
]o,'
R2-l
If we let R -r -, we obtain for a cylindrical hole in an infinite medium u,lr :0(l
+ o)lE:012p"
(usingproblem2.2).Substitutionin eq. (2.96)gives
ei lt ; *l \*_:/ - -0^w' dz
and substitution of this result in eq. (2.95)givesthe waveequation:
"n; : e)*,r 'r::(f * 1)' rzrr
White (1965: 153-6; 1983: 139-91) discussestube
(2.9s) ' *atuesin sreaterdetail. (1981)
discusstwo other tubeCheng and Toksoz wavemodes.One is a Stoneleywave($2.5.3)propagating along the boreholewall and dying awayexponentially in the formation surroundingthe borehole;this
THEORY OF SEISMIC WAVES
\4
is the dominant tube-wavemode in VSP work. The other tube-wave mode is pseudo-Rayleigh waves, guidedwaves($13.3)confinedlargelyto the fluid, also dying away exponentially in the surrounding formation. Both wavesare dispersive(52.7.4). Cheng and Toksozcalculateddispersioncurvesfor both modes(fig. 2.19a).The Stoneleywaveis slightly dispersivewith both group and phasevelocitiesclose to 0.9ct.,where o, is the P-wavevelocity in the borewavescanhole fluid (seeeq. (2.61)).Pseudo-Rayleigh not existbelow a minimum frequency(wherethetr velocity equals the S-wavevelocity of the surrounding rock, B,) and their group velocity passesthrough a minimum, which resultsin an Airy phase(see$13.3 and fig. 13.19).Severalmodes may exist (see eq. (13.1)).Pseudo-Rayleigh wavesare not a factor in ordinary seismicwork (fig. 2.19a showsa l0-kHz lowfrequencycutoff), but they are involvedin sonic logging. At higher frequencies,the velocitiesof both Stoneley and pseudo-Rayleighwaves approach the Swave velocity in the medium surrounding the borehole. "synthetic microCheng and Toksoz calculated one of which seismograms"for variouscircumstances, is shown in fig. 2.19b;fig. 2.19cshowsan observed waveform. Hardage(1985)discusses the role of tube wavestn VSP surveys.Figure 2.20a shows progradeelliptical motion in an axial plane.The radial motion is zero at the center of the hole and maximum at the borehole wall, where it is continuous(fig. 2.20b),but it decays rapidly in the surroundingformation. The axial component of motion is relativelyconstantin the fluid but is discontinuousat the boreholewall whereits amplitude decreases by a factor as largeas severalhundred. This explainswhy geophonesshould be clamped to the boreholewall. Tube wavesare reflectedat impedancechanges,just as other acousticwavesare ($3.2).When the borehole area changesfrom a, to a., the refleccross-sectional tion (R) and transmission(7n)coefficientsare (Hard a g e ,1 9 8 5 : 8 6 - 7 ) R-azQ2t
at, al
T:
2:,
(2.98)
a2+ el
(comparewith eqs.(3.14)and (3.15)).At the top of the borehole fluid and the bottom of the hole, R : - I and *1, respectively. Tube wavesare also reflected at a geophonesondeand wherecasingchanges.Figure 2.21 showsseveralreflectedtube waves. Tube wavescan be generatedby almost anything that disturbs the borehole fluid. The most common sourceis a Rayleighwave passingover the top of the borehole;thus, tute wavesare uncommon in maririe VSP surveysand, in land surveys,lowering the bprehole fluid level often lessenstube-wavegeneration. Tube wavesinitially have the same spectrum as the generatingsourceand their spectrumchangesslowly becausethereis little absorptionin the boreholefluid.
t
9 UJ
-- Phose -
Group
ieuoo- z> \ \ Royleigh
o Ld
N J
(r z
Sloneley'
ro
20
(kHz) FREQUENCY
ANISOTROPIC MEDIA
))
I OOIVNGONG TUBEI\IAVE
| ,.r,01,...0 BoR€HoLE
I
lA/\rAf
variation of seismic velocity with the direction in which it is measured or with wave polarization ($13.1.6).The generalelasticitymatrix relating stress o, to strain eo,(the generalizedform of the 6 X 6 matrix in eq. (2.I 5)) can contain at most 2l independent constants becauseof symmetry considerations,but Winterstein(1990: 1084-5)saysthat only l8 of these can be truly independent.The number of independent constants depends on the symmetry of the system (Love, 1944:99). A number of different types of symmetry (symmetry systems)can exist. Classically,eight systemsare defined (Love, loc. cit.; Landau and Lifshitz, 1986; Saada, 1974),but some writers define subsystemsas well; for example,Winterstein(1990:1083 5) lists ll systemsplus subsystemsin discussingcracks.Anisotropy typesare associatedwith the symmetrysystems. At seismicwavelengths,however,the only anisotropy types reported are transverseisotropy (hexagonal symmetry), orthorhombic anisotropy, and monoclinic anisotropy. Transverseisotropy involves elastic properties that are the samein any direction perpendicularto an axis but are different parallel to this axis. Two important types of transverseisotropy are observed;that with a nearly vertical symmetry axis (thin-layer anisotropy) and that with a nearly horizontal axis (azimuthalanisotropy)(Bush and Crampin, 1987).Transverseisotropy is the most important type of anisotropy encountered;it is discussedfurther in 92.6.2. Orthorhombicanisotropyis equivalent to a superposition of thin-layer anisotropy and azimuthal anisotropy. It arises becausea vertical fracture system has
ELASTICROCK MATERIAL PARTICLEMOTION
il1ffifi-l lvvr|/\r
l---
I I H A R D I IF O R M A T I O N
| 630 |620 r6to
6 4 2
IISOFTII FORMATTON
r650 I640
r q
sEcoN0s
to
DOUELE CASING
500 2 r/R (c)
rooo o u F
: l0 Wave motion for a tube wave. (From Hardage, 1985: -! ) (a) Prograde elliptical motion of fluid particles during .,ge of a tube wave (ellipticity is greater than shown here). r',ul and radial displacementsfor hard formation, v : 82 .,:d lc) lor soft formation.v : 74H2.
3 rsoo I I
o
2ooo
2 500
.:quently, tube wavesoften have appreciableenr the signalrangeevenafter considerabletravel.
A
CEMENI
\nisotropic media l. pes of anisotropy ' . ,,nl ls a generalterm denoting variation of a - .. propertydependingon the directionin which - :,rsured.Seismicanisotropy is evidencedby a
Fig.2.21 VSP record showing severaltube waves. Tube wave (1) is generatedat the baseofthe surfacecasing; (2) is generated at the surface by a Rayleigh wave; (3) is a reverberationofwave (2) betweenthe well sondeand the surface;and (4) is a reflection f r o m t h e b o t t o m o f t h e b o r e h o l e .( F r o m H a r d a g e . 1 9 8 5 : 8 8 . )
THEORY OF SEISMIC WAVES
56 been superimposedon a horizontally layeredsystem' VSP data from the Paris Basin have beeninterpreted using an orthorhombic model (Bush and Crampin. 1987;MacBeth, 1990).Layering anisotropyis usually much stronger than fracture anisotropy so that the overalleffectmay be difficult to distinguishfrom thinlayer anisotropy.Monoclinic anisotopy can be produced by superimposingtilted fractureson a layered medium (Schoenbergand Muir, 1989)' Examplesof monoclinic anisotropyhavebeenobservedin the field (Crampin, McGonigle, and Bamford, 1980; Wintersteinand Meadows,1990). The stress-strainrelationshipsrequire 5 independent elasticmoduli for transverseisotropy, 9 for orthorhombic anisotropy,and l3 for monoclinic anisotropy, comparedwith only 2 for the isotropiccase. 2.6.2 Transverseisotropy Taking the z-axisas the axis of symmetry,Love (1944'. 160-l) showedthat for transverseisotropy, Hooke's law reducesto the following: o., : (tr -F 2p )e,., * \,,".,r,* \re-,, (2.9e) o,,,.: \,,e.. + (\ + 2*)er,* I'.e--, o-- : \re., * \r€,,, + (\r + 2pt)",,,
o...: l-L€,,, I or-: p*8,.,, r o-, :
p*e-,,
(2.100)
(Crampin, l98l). For horizontal thin-layer refringence anisotropy, the two wavesare the 4SP-waves(that is, quasi-S-waveshaving displacementparallel to the symmetryaxis) and SR-waves(displacementin radial directions).For azimuthalasymmetry,they are sometimes called qSV- and Sl1-waves. In anisotropicmedia, pure S- and P-wavesmay exist only in certain directions.In transverselyisotropic media, SZ- and P-modesof propagationare coupled (see$2.6.3).Wavefrontsare not in generalorthogonal to the directionsof wave propagatton.Phasevelocity is velocity perpendicular to a surface of constant phase(a wavefront), and group velocity,the velocity with which the energytravels($2.7.4),is in a different direction (see fig. 2.23). The surfaces for SZwavefrontsmay havecusps. Anisotropy is often described by the fractional differencebetweenthe maximum and minimum velocities for a given wave surface,i.e., (V^ - V^^)|Z-^*, sometimesby the ratio of maximum and minimum velocities, V^ulV^-. Uhrig and van Melle (1955)give a table showing anisotropyvaluesof 1.2to 1.4for rocks at the surface at depthsof 2.1 to 2.4 km and 1.1to 1.2for sediments in west and central Texas.Stoep(1966)found average valuesbetween1.00and 1.03for TexasGulf Coast sediments.S6gonzacand Laherr6re (1959) obtained to 1.08to 1.12for valuesfrom 1.00for sandstones limestonesand l.l5 to 1.20for anhydritesfrom the northern Sahara.
)
wherethe five independentconstantsare \ and p., tr'r and p' and p*. Layering and parallel fracturing tend to produce transverseisotropy. A sequenceof isotropic layers (suchas sedimentarybedding)producesthin-layeranisotropy for wavelengthsappreciablylarger than the layer thicknesses(), > 8d where d is layer thickness; seeEbrom et al., 1990).The symmetryaxis is perpendicular to the beddingwith the velocitiesof P- and Swaves that involve motion parallel to the bedding larger than those involving motion perpendicularto the bedding. The velocity parallel to the bedding is greaterbecausethe higher-velocitymemberscarry the first energy,whereasfor wave motion perpendicular to the bedding, each member contributesin proportion to the time takento traverseit. Nonhorizontal fracturing and microcracksproduce azimuthal anisotropy with a symmetry axis perpendicular to the fracturing (fractures often are somewhat parallel and vertical).The velocity of wavesthat involvemotion parallel to the fracturing (S') is larger than that of waveswith motion perpendicularto the fracturing (S,). If the motion is neither parallel nor perpendiculaito the fracturing, an S-wavesplits into i*o *uu.t with orthogonal polarizations(fig. 2'22): one (S ) traveling at the S' velocity,the other (S') at the S, velocity; this is calledshear-wavesplitting ot bi-
isotropicmedia 2.6.3 Wuveequationfor transversely When media are not isotropic, the mathematicsbecome more complex the more anisotropic the medium. However,the case of a transverselyisotropic medium can be treated without great difficulty. We consider wavesin the rz-plane, where the symmetry axis is along the z-axis.Derivativeswith respectto y are zero, but S-wavesmay involve motion in the ydirection.We substituteeqs.(2.99)and (2.100)into eq. (2.24), and using eqs. (2.8) and (2.'7),we get the waveequationsfor transverselyisotropicmedia: 62u '3P
d o .' . + d o , " 0: 0x
a"'l : u [ , ^' + 2 '' t' a du x + ^ .' d : l + arL
. #)] i,[-.(::
.. 02w = (\ + 2pf p*91 + (r, * p ' ) ^dz; ,dx #,+ I A,, 6zv d:v P ^ , : l r t . , t F * . , . ' cJI'
( 2 .l 0 l ) (2.102)
d:-
dX'
31u rJ:N .d2w Par. : (\- + **) u" A, * F"a", * 32rt'
(\-+2P)
dz-
.
(2.l 03)
t
EFFECTS OF THE MEDIUM ON WAVE PROPAGATION
57
thesebecome (V2 - afi(' - o*znz)(A - (oi - o*' + g*')(t : 0, lV' B*2n2lnB (V2-a2rn2-o*zgz)nA + l V ' - ( o l - o * ' * 9 * ) n ' - 9 * z ( z l ( B: 0 . Eliminating A and B givesthe following quadratic equationin Z2: [Vt
- (oi - ct*2 + g'k2)(2- g*'rtln
(v, _ ul(, _
o*z4z)(
: _ V : _ ( o i _ o * , * 9*)n'- B*z(zl( Fig. 2.22 S-wave propagation in a lractured medium with cracks oriented N45"W For an S-wavetraveling parallel to fracturing, the velocity (Sr) is slower for a component involving motion perpendicular to the fracturing than for one involving motion parallel to the fracturing (velocity S,).
Note the dependence in eqs. (2.101)and (2.103)on derivativesof both u and w; P- and SZ-wavesare said to be coupled.The Sf/-wave governed by eq. (2.102) is, however,independentof the other two. We simplify the problem by assuminga plane wave travelingin the xz-planein the direction ofincreasing ,r and decreasing:,the anglebetweenthe raypathand the x-axis being 0. We now usethe potential functions of eq.(2.64)in the form d:ler-t.
1:fsr-i
where ( x - n z ) l V- t ,
g:
(:cos0.
n:sin0.
Then
,:4*lx dx
0z
: (;)u^
- nB)e:-t,
, : u Q - 4 = -(:,\r^ * (81s,-,' 6z
dx
Whenwe substitutetheseinto eqs.(2.101)and (2.103), the following factors appear in every term and hence can be ignored:jall\ (jor),, and ej-(.Equations(2.101) and (2.103)become lpV'( lpV'n lpV'n + [pV(
(L + 2p,)f3- (tr,+ 2p"*)h' lA - (\, + 2p - \, - p*)('n - p"*n3lB: 0, (\, * 2pr)r3 - (\,- + 2p,*)(' n]A + (p* - 2p",)(n2- p,*(3lB : 0.
c,*t : (\, + 2p,*)lp,
ctl : (}", + 2p,,)lp, F*' : l-r*/p,
a2,.n2_ d i 2 ( z ) n
or [V'-
( o i - c t * 2+ 9 * 2 ) ( ' - B * ' n z y
X (V2 -
o'rn' -
o*z(z)42
- p'l2c21 + lV' - (oi - o*' + g,*2)n2 x(V2 - ai(, - o*zrz1( : 0. (2.104) The solution hasbeengivenby Stoneley(1949),Grant and West (1965:42),and White (1965: 46).The roots are always real and positive and approach o and B of eqs. (2.58) and (2.59) as the anisotropy approaches zero. When the wave is traveling vertically, ( : 0, n : l, and V : ctr or B* for verticallytravelingP- or SI1waves.When ( : l, n : 0, V : o, or B*, corresponding to horizontally traveling P- or S/I-waves.However,when the wave is traveling at an angle to the vertical, the roots are complicatedfunctionsof the elastic constantsand the motion is not separatedinto distinct P- and S-waves. 2.7 Effects of the medium on wave propagation 2.7.1 Energy density and geometricalspreading Probably the single most important feature of any wave is the energyassociatedwith the motion of the medium as the wavepassesthrough it. Usually,we are not concernedwith the total energy of a wave but rather with the energy in the vicinity of the point where we observe it; the energydensity is the energy per unit volume. Consider a sphericalharmonic P-wave for which the radial displacementfor a fixed value of r is given Dy u:
Writing ai : (\, + 2p.,)lp,
(V2 -
A c o s( o t * ^ y ) ,
where 1 is a phase angle. The displacement r'tranges flrom -A to *A. Becausedisplacementvaries with time, each element of the medium has a velocity, ,i :
THEORY OF SEISMIC WAVES
58
Wavefront at time I + al
Wavelront at lime t Fast direction
Slor/ direction
I Wlocity function
(b)
(a)
(c) Fig.2.23 Wavefrontsin anisotropicmedia (a) Applicationot' Uuygens'principleto an anisotropicmediumillustratesdirectionind magnitud.diff...n..t betweenphaseand groupvelocities.(b) FerLat'sprincipleappliedto a reflectionfor a coincident sourceand receivershowsthat a reflectionmay not occur at a right angleto the reflector.(c) Sl/-wavefronts(surfacesof
6ul0t, andan associatedkinetic energy.The kinetic energy 6Eo contained within each element of volume 6.1/is EQ : l{PEl/)r;" The kinetic energyper unit volume is 6.E,,
#:
, .r * or t u ': l o o ." A' sin' ( 1;'
This expressionvaries from zero to a maximum of ipaltA'. The wave also involves potential energy resulting from the elasticstrainscreatedduring the passageof the wave. As the medium oscillatesback and forth'
isotroptcmeconstantphasefor a point source)in transversely are not ellipdia are eliiptical;however,P- and Sl/-wavefronts axis of vertical with V,. Vn) instances. special in excepi tical ,y-rn.try. Z. is group velocity as a function of the anglewith the symmetrYaxts
the energyis convertedback and forth from.kinetrcto potentia'i forms, the total energy remaining fixed' iWh.n u particle is at zero displacement,the potential energyii zero and the kinetic energyis a maximum' and;hen the particle is at its extremedisplacement' the enersv is all potential. Becausethe total energy - e'iuals ti'e maximum value of the kinetic energy,the , .n.tgy density E for a harmonic wave is E:
r o t r 2 A 2- 2 n z p v 24 2 .
).'
(2.l0s)
Thus, we seethat the energy density is proportional to the first power of the densityof the medium and to it. ,..orrd^power of the frequencyand amplitude of the wave.(SeeBraddick, 1965,for a different derivation of eq. (2.105).)
EFFECTS OF THE MEDIUM ON WAVE PROPAGATION
59
We are also interestedin the rate of flow of energy and we define the intensity as the quantity of energy that flows through a unit areanormal to the direction of wave propagationin unit time. Take a cylinder of infinitesimal cross-section,69, whose axis is parallel to the direction of propagationand whose length is equal to the distancetraveledin the time, Et. The total energyinsidethe cylinder at any instant t is EV 6t 6g: at time I + Er all of this energyhas left the cylinder through one of the ends.Dividing by the area of the end of the cylinder,Eg, and by the time interval, 61, we get 1, the amount of energypassingthrough unit area in unit time: r : EV
(2.106)
Fig.2.24
Dependence of intensity upon distance.
For a harmonic wave,this becomes t :
)pVarA,
: )qzp/y2[2.
(2.101)
In fig. 2.24, we show a sphericalwavefrontdiverging from a center O. By drawing sufficientradii, we can definetwo portions of wavefronts,g, and gr, of radii r,''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''and rr, such that the energy that fows outward through the spherical cap 9, in I second must be equal to that passingoutward through the spherical cap 9, in 1 second(becausethe energyis moving only in the radial direction).The flow ofenergy per second is the product of the intensity and the area;hence, I,9r:
1r9..
Becausethe areas9, and g, are proportional to the squareof their radii, we get I./I, : 9 r19. : (r,lrrl2. Moreover,it follows from eq. (2.106)that E is proportional to 1 and hence [,11,: ErlE,= (r,lrrl2.
(2.108)
Thus, geometricalspreadingcausesthe intensity and the energydensity of sphericalwavesto decreasernverselyas the squareof the distancefrom the source (Newman, 1973).This is calledsphericaldivergence. For a plane wave,the raysdo not divergeand hence the intensity of a plane wave is constant.Figure 2.24 could representa cross-sectionof a cylindrical wave, that is, a wavegeneratedby a very long linear source, arcs 9, and 9. being cylindrical wavefronts.Because the arcsare proportional to the radii, cylindricaldivercausesthe intensity to vary inverselyas the ra.qer?ce dius. Thus, we can write Irl I, : ErlE, : (rrlrr)-,
(2.l 0e)
nherem : 0, I, or 2 accordingas the waveis plane, e rl i n d r i c a lo. r s p h e r i c a l . Ratios of intensity,energy,or power are usually expressedin decibels,the value in dB being 10 log,oof the intensity, energy,or power ratio. Becausethese \ ary as the squareof the amplitude,dB is also given rs 20 log,oof the amplitude ratio. The natural log of rhe amplitude ratio (in nepers)is also used(seeprob. e m2 . 1 7 ) .
The foregoing assumesconstant velocity, whereas velocity usuallyincreaseswith depth, producingmore rapid spreading.A factor of Vlt is often used (99.8), where Z, is the stacking velocity ($5.4.1).The term "spherical divergence"is still used in this situation eventhough wavefrontsmay not be spherical. 2.7.2 Absorption (a) General. In the precedingsection,we considered variationsof the energydistribution as a function of geometry.Implicit in the discussionwas the assumption that none of the wave energy was transformed into other forms. In reality,as the wavemotion passes through the medium, the elastic energy associated with the wavemotion is graduallyabsorbedby the medium, reappearingultimatelyin the form of heat.This processis called ab.sorption and is responiiblefor the eventualcompletedisappearanceof the wavemotion (seealso 96.5).Toksozand Johnston(1981)summarize much of the literatureregardingabsorption. The measurementof absorption is very difficult, mainly becauseit is not easy to isolate absorption from other effectsmaking up attenuation(see$6.5.2). Moreoveq absorption varies with frequency,so that it is not clear how laboratory measurementsapply to seismicwavetravel in the earth. (b) Expressionsfor absorption. The decreaseofamplitude due to absorption appearsto be exponential with distancefor elasticwavesin rocks.Thus, we can write for the decreasein amplitude becauseof absorption A:
A o e\ , ,
(2.110)
whereI atd Aoarevaluesof the amplitudesof a plane wavefront at two pojhts a distance x apart, and 1 is the absorptioncofficient. Other measuresof absorptionare basedon the decreasein amplitude with time; to relatetheseto n. we assumea cyclic waveform: A : Aoe t" cos 2rvt,
(2.ttt)
and make measurements at a fixed location;ft is called
THEORY OF SEISMIC WAVES
60 lhe dampingfactor. The logarithmicdecrement(log dec) E is defined by
u: 'n(u,no,,,XTJl'i;t1. ,**) etn) It can be expressedin terms of the damping factor as 6:
hT : hlv : 2Thla,
(2.r13)
where Z is the period; 6 is measuredin nepers.Quality factor Q can be definedas Q : 2rl(fraction of energylost per cycle)
:2r(ElLE,
(2.1t4)
where AZ'is energy loss. Becauseenergy is proporand AEIEo: tional to amplitudesquared,f, : Eos-znt 2h Lt. SettingA,t : T we getLEIE,: 2hT: 2E and Q:
dhT:
t/6.
(2.lls)
If n is the number of oscillationsfor the amplitude to decreaseby the factor e, then eh'r : e, n: llhT and Q:
(2.116)
nr.
Stilf another manner of expressingQ is Q : cot 0, where $ is the lossangle. During one period, a wave travelsone wavelength so that if the loss of energyis due to absorptiononly, ( f r o m e q s .( 2 . 1 1 0 ) f a c t o ri s h T : 1 \ the attenuation and (2.1Il)), and we can interrelate11,6, and Q. (2.117) Q: nln),: al2\V : d6. Absorptionin the form givenby eq.Q.ll0) appears naturally in solutionsof the type given in eq. (2.56)if we permit the elastic constantsto be complex numbers.Real elasticconstantvaluescorrespondto media without absorption and complex values imply exponential absorption.Complex valuesof tr and p result in complexvelocityvalues(seeeqs.(2.58)and (2.59)). lf the llV in eq. (2.56)is replacedwith llV + jl/
--
Aei.tnt,r*jr/o)-/l :
wherex, is the distanceto the source.The table shows that lossesby spreading are more important than lossesby absorptionfor low frequenciesand short distancesfrom the source.As the frequencyand distance increase,absorptionlossesincreaseand eventuallybecome dominant. The increasedabsorptionat higher frequenciesresults in changeof waveshapewith distance.Peg-leg multiples ($6.3.2b)and possibly other mechanisms also produce waveshapechanges.Figure 2.25 shows the energy decreasingwith distance and with frequency; the frequency-dependentattenuation is greaterthan expectedfrom absorptionalone. 2.7.4 Dispersion;group velocity VelocitiesV a, and B, which appearin $2.2and subsequent sections,are phasevelocitiesbecausethey are the distancestraveledper unit time by a point of constant phase(for example,a trough) of a simple wave suchas thosein eqs.(2.53)to (2.55).This is not necessarily the velocity with which a pulse travels,called the group velocity. For the wavetrain shown in fig. 2.26a,wecan determinethe group velocity U by drawing the envelopeof the pulse (the double curve ABC, AB'C) and measuringthe distancethat the envelope travelsin unit time. The phasevelocity Z is given approximatelyby the rate of advanceof a distinct "phase break," as indicated in figs. 2.26a and 2.26b, but to find V accurately, we should decomposethe pulseinto its frequencycomponentsby Fourier analysis(seeeq. (l 5. I I 3)) and measurethe speedof each component l(o)sirt't.
Ae-\rer6lrtv 4,
which agreeswith eq. (2.1l0). 2.7.3 Relativeimportctnce of absorptionand spreading To compare the loss by absorption with the loss of intensity by geometricalspreading(seeeq. (2.108)), we have calculated the lossesin going various distancesfrom a point 200 m from the sourceassuming r1 : 0.15 dB/\. The results shown in table 2.1 were calculatedusing the following relations:
Divergence
Absorption:
intensity ross indB:
l3i:il [;,,1n,
: 0.3(x/\): 0.3(n,- 200yI - 0.3u(x"- 200)12000, Spreading:
intensity ross indB:
13i::i:
,[;,,lor,
Fig. 2.25 Loss of amplitude as a function of one-way traveltime, based on measurements with a geophone clamped in "diborehole with the source at the surface. The curves labeled "divergence plus transmission loss" are calcuvergence" and lated from sonicJog data allowing for loss of energyin transmission through reflecting interfaces. The 20-, 40-, 60-Hz curves show attenuation at those frequencies.(Courtesy of SSC.)
61
EFFECTS OF THE MEDIUM ON WAVE PROPAGATION I
i
Table 2.1 Energy lossesby absorptionand spreading (n: 0.15dBlwavelength and V: 2.0 kmls) Distance from shotpoint (x,) Frequency (v) 1200m 2200m 4200m 8200m
t
I
lHz 3 l0 30 100 Spreading All Absorption
0.075dB 0.22 0.75 1 a
7.5 16
0.15dB 0.45 1.5 A <
15 2l
0.3dB 0.6dB 0.9 1.8 3 6 9 l8 30 60 26 32
If phasevelocity Zis the samefor all frequenciesin the pulse,the pulse shapedoes not change and U : tr{ Howeveqif the velocity varieswith frequency,the different componentstravel with different speeds,the pulse shapechanges,and U + V that is, the medium is dispersive. Considerthe two harmonic wavesshown in fig. 2.26c that travel at slightly different velociries, the higher-frequencyone being faster than the lowerfrequencyone. The "pulse" that resultsfrom their interferencechangeswaveshapeand travelsat a velocity different from either of them (greaterthan either in this instance).If we write l(or)srt.' -,)for a plane-wave componenttravelingalong the x-axis, r being r(to), in general,,4(o) varies slowly whereasthe phase(xx ort) varies rapidly. When adjacent frequencycomponents are added togethet the net result is usually approximatelyzero becauseof destructiveinterference. However,when the phase(rr - or/)variesslowly,constructiveinterferenceoccursin the vicinity of a point (r, t). The condition for this is d. :u:* Orlx(to)x-(')/l
d x ( o )- r . O(r)
Point (x, l) will move with velocity U where U : d:c/dt(see{i2.2.5).Hence,differentiationof the above equationgives
frequency,we have inversedispersionand the opposite is true (asin fig.2.26a). of most Dispersionof body wavesis a consequence theoriesproposedto accountfor absorption.Aki and Richards (1980: 170-2) show that the assumptionof constant Q, which most data indicateis the situation in solid earth materials,and no dispersionare inconsistentbecausethey lead to noncausality.Their argument follows. Starting with a plane-waveimpulse at x : 0 : I a n d u s i n ge q s .( 1 5 . 1 2 7a) n d ( 1 5 . 1 3 6 )w, e have $(x, 0 : 6(t xll4 <) e-)dnv. Adding attenuation corresponding to constant Q (seeeqs.(2.110)and (2117)),the right side becomes t6txt2vo; we must use the absolute value of (l) to eej@x/t/ avoid havingthe amplitude increasewith increasingx when
t6,
dt
- W aO dl Va( ar )l] l
The derivativeis small, so Ll-V+.dV:V+rd': do dv
v - )rd,v, , CIA
( 2 . 1l 8 ) where V to,v, tr, dVlda, dVldv, and d tr4d),are average values for the range of frequenciesmaking up the principal part of the pulse. (See problem 2.1 for a more elementaryderivationof eq. (2.I l8).) When Z decreases with frequency,we have normal dispersion,and V is larger than H where the envelope travels slower than the individual cycles;this is the usual casewith eround roll. When Z increaseswith
^'
||
znLJ^
+ :
'\t2t Qteju, e- u,\rilr da
*-.-'utn-,,'n,.,., 6r]
J
-a[J:
eau+iB)a, + s.rr+ia, d6} J.-
where A = xl2VQ, and B : (t - xlt).Integration gives
{(x,t) : (ll2r)2Al(A, + R) tl2nYp (xl2vQ)' + (t - xlnt
(2.ne)
This function is shown in fig.2.27; it has a maximum valueat t : xlV and is roughly symmetrical.Observations show insteada sharperrise near x/Zfollowed by a slowerdecay.The function of eq. (2.1l9) has a finite value for I < 0, x * 0, and is thereforenoncausal, showing that our assumptionsare inconsistent.We conclude, therefore, that absorption necessarilyrequires that V varieswith to, that is, dispersionmust exist. Dispersion is important for severalreasons,perhaps the most important being that the energy of a pulsetravelswith the velocity U (exceptwherethereis appreciableabsorption;seeBrillouin, 1960:98-100). Dispersionof seismicbody waveshas not beendefinitively observed over the wide range of frequencies from h.ertzto megahertz.Most rocks simply exhibit little vafiation of velocity with frequencyin the seismic freguencyrange.Ward and Hewitt (1977)found the same velocity at 35 Hz as at 55 Hz in a monofrequency well survey to about 800 m. Futterman (1962)showsthat the dispersionexpectedfor seismic body wavesis small for usual situations.Dispersionis, however,important in connectionwith surfacewaves (see$2.5)and channelwaves($13.3)as well as other phenomena.
:t"l,[,"t,]] r:r'l :l,h
u:d! :
I r f0
r) :
62
THEORY OF SEISMIC WAVES
I I
*l 9 t b l
"l I
u r o u p v e f o c i l yn:
= "
P h a s € v c l @:iftf' : v
---(c)-
Fig.2.26 Comparison of group and phase velocities.(a) Definition of group velocity U and phase velocity Z (b) arrival of a dispersive wave at different geophones; (c) two sine waves of slightly different frequency and velocity traveling from left to
right form beats; the envelope travels with the group velocity U - Ao/Arc and points of constant phase within the beats with t h e p h a s ev e l o c i t i e s V , : a , l r , a n d V . - o , / r c . ( f r o m G e r k e n s ,
2.7.5 ReJlection and refraction;Snell'slaw
downwarda distanceV. L,t. By drawingarcswith center A' and lengthsequal to V, Lt and Z, Al, and then drawing the tangentsfrom R to thesearcs,we locate the new wavefronts,RS and RI in the upper and lower media.The angleat S is a right angle and A' S : V, L,t : -B'R,'therefore,the trianglesA'B'R and l'SR are equal,with the result that the angleof incidence0, is equal to the angle of reflection 0l; this is Lhelaw of reflection.For the refractedwave,the angle at ?'is a right angleand we have
Whenevera waveencountersan abrupt changein the elasticproperties,as when it arrivesat a surfaceseparating two beds,part of the energyis refectedand remains in the samemedium as the original energy;the balanceof the energyis refractedinto the other medium with an abrupt changein the direction of propagation occurring at the interface.Reflectionand refraction are fundamental in exploration seismology and we shall discussthesein somedetail. We can derive the familiar laws of reflection and refraction using Huygens'principle.Considera plane wavefront AB tncident on a plane interface as in lig. 2.28 (if the wavefrontis curved,we merelytate I and 8 sufficientlyclosetogetherthat AB is a plarle to the requireddegreeofaccuracy; however,seealso $2.8.1); 1.8 occupiesthe position A'B' when I arrivesat the surface; at this instant, the energy at .B' still must travelthe distance.B'Rbeforearriving at the interface. If B'R : V, L.t, then At is the time interval between the arrival of the energyat A' and at R. By Huygens' principle, during time At, the energy that rcached A' will have traveledeither upward a distance V, Lt or
I 989:37).
V, L,t : I'R sin0, and
vrat : l'R sin0,, hence,
sin 0,
sin e"
Vt
V2
(2.r20)
Angle 0, is calledthe angleof reJractionand eq. (2.120) is the /aw of refraction, also known as Snell'slav,. The anglesare usuallymeasuredbetweenthe raypathsand a normal to the interface. but these ansles are the
DIFFRACTION
63 sin 0, :
VrlVr.
(2.12r)
For anglesof incidencegreaterthan 0-,it is impossible to satisfySnell\ Iaw (usingreal angles)becauiesin 0, cannot exceedunity and total refiectior occurs. ThiJ does not mean that l00o/oof the energy is reflected as P-waves,however,becauseconverted S_waves(see $3.1.1)and evanescentwaves(see $2.3.1)are gen_ erated. Noting the method used to derive eq. (2.57) in $2.3.1,we write Snell'slaw for the case0, > e, (seefig. 2.29) in the form F r g . 2 . 2 7 I l l u s t r a t i n ge q . ( 2 .I l 9 ) .
same as those between the interface and the wave_ tionts in isotropic media. The laws of reflectionand refractioncan be combinedin the singlestatement:at an interface,the quantityp : (sin 0,)lV hasthe same value for the incident, reflected,and reiractedwaves. The quantity p is called the raypathparumeter lt will be shownin $3.l.l that Snell'slaw alsoholdsfor wave conversionfrom p- to S-waves(and vice versa)uDon reflection or refraction. The generalized form of Snell'slaw (eq.(3.1))will be undersroodin futureref_ 3rencesto Snell'slaw. When the mediumconsistsof a numberof parallel reds,Snell'slaw requiresthat the quantityp havethe )ame value everywherefor all reflectedand refracted :al's resultingfrom a given initial ray. The loregoingderivationassumeda planar surface .rnd therefore specular reflection. If the surface in_ ;ludes bumps of height d, reffectedwavesfrom them .rill be aheadof those from the rest of the surfaceby lil Thesecan be neglectedwhere2dl>\
;. 1.28
Reflection and refraction ofa plane wave.
sin 0, : (VrlV) sin 0, : sin (jrr - j0) : c o s j O : c o s h0 : L /? : cos 0: : sin j0 : j sinh 0; hence,eq. (2.56)becomes *
:
,qe
(ozlrasinh0ejo(r/racosh0_,1.
(2.122)
If we take 0 negativein fig. 2.29,the only changeis in the sign ofthe first exponentialon the right_handside. Thus, just as in the case of eq. (2.5i--),evanescent wavescan existon both sidesofthe interfaceand their amplitudesdecreaseas we go awayfrom the interface. The rate of attenuation is proportional to sinh 0, which has its maximum value at the grazing angle, e, .:^ lT The introduction of imaginary angles to satisfy-Snell's law for angles e*.eeding the critical angle means that the reflectioncoefficient($3.2)will be complex and phaseshifts will occur (seeoroblem 3.6b) that will be complicatedfunctionsof the anele of incidence. Snell'slaw is very useful in determining raypaths and arrival times and in deriving reflectoi position from observedarrival times,but it doesnot sive infbr_ mation about the amplitudes of the reflJcted and transmittedwaves.This subjectis taken up in chao.3. 2.8 Diffraction 2.8.1 Basicformulas In discussingreflectionand refraction,we statedthat when an interfaceis curved we merelyhaveto selecta portion suflicientlysmall that it can be considereda plane. However, such a simplification is not always possible,lor example,when the radius of curvatureof an interfaceis lessthan a few wavelengthsor the re_ flector is terminated by a fault, pinchout, unconfor_ mity, etc. In such cases,the simple laws of reflection and refractionare no longer adequatebecausethe en_ ergyis dffiacted ralher than reflectedor refracted. Be_ causeseismicwavelengthsare often 100 m or more, many geologicfeaturesgive rise to diffractions. The mathematicaltreatmentof diffraction is com_ plex and we shall give only a brief summaryof a sim_ plified treatment due to Trorey (1970).fe shall as_ sume a coincident source and receiver (see Trorev. 1977,for the noncoincidentcase)and constantveloc_ ity. Using $ in place of r!, we take the Laplacetrans_ ficrmof the waveequation.eq. (2.30).obtaining
THEORY OF SEISMIC WAVES
64
assumea constantreflectioncoefficientover y, so that c in eq. (2.123)is constant.Clearly,llr : 0: O over the hemisphere,hencethe contribution to the integral oyer the hemisphereis zero. We can also set O : 0 over the portions of the plane z : h exceptfor the portion I whoseeffectwe wish to evaluate. We now substituteeC.Q.123) in eq. (2.124),noting that r in eq. (2.123)is now r,,in fig. 2.30abecausethe sourceis now at the imagepoint O'; hence 0 r_ 3 r : i : h . 611 i)z r r'
V-s:9L : Fig. 2.29
Imaginary angles of reflection and refraction.
V' 6 : \lv' )
: rro.rrr(r,* ,r),
a26lAf er V' O : (slV)'Q,
where O(x, y, z, s) is the the Laplace transfqrm of 66, y, z, t) (see515.3),and the double-headedarrow indicatesequivalencein different domains.Note that we are assumingthat $ and 6$l0t are zero at / : 0 for all x, y, z. The solution of this equation for a point sourceat the origin is q : @tr)e
",tv,
(2.123)
wherer is the distancefrom the sourceto the point of observation,and V is the wave velocity.(This can be verified by direct substitution,noting that 12: x2 * y2 + z2,6rlOx : xlr, etc.)In general,c'should include the Laplace transform of the input waveform at the source,but in effectwe havetaken the transformto be unity, that is, the sourceis cEO (eq. (15.180)).The results for other types of sourcescan be found by time-domain convolution (see eqs. (15.201) and ( I 5.202)). In a source-freeregion, the P-wavepotential function $ is given by eq.(2.42)with Y : 0; hence,we can get another expressionfor $ by taking the Laplace transform of eq. (2.42),the result being
" -{'*,[ni;-u#]- :[:,.]].' 4ne:jJ (2.r24) The factor e-v/r/arisesbecause$ in the integrand of eq.(2.42)is evaluatedat time t : to - r/4 whereasO is the transformof$(x, y, z, t) (seeeq. (15.187)). 2.8.2Dffiaction effectof part of a planereflector We shallnow calculatethe diffraciion effectof an area 9 that is part of a plane reflectorz : h (seefig. 2.30a), both sourceand detectorbeing at the origin. We enclose the origin with a hemisphereof infinite radius with center(0, 0, ft), the baseof which is the planez : ft. In order to apply eq. (2.124),we replacethe source with its image at (0, 0, 2h), thus making the hemispherea source-freeregion.We ignore absorptionand
a!!,) : -h.
!.
0r1 6z rn' dr1 13' d O _ d O 6 r n_ _ r r . , ^ , , ( l s\/_r\ + d1 dro d1 Vl\ r, I r0 \rn
where we have set r,, : r afler differentiating. The result is
:,rll".*,0+ ).)av e tzs) 2,,e This surfaceintegral can be transformedinto a contour integral as follows. In fig. 2.30b,the elementof area is p dp d0 in polar coordinates;becauser' : p2 * h', p dp : , dr and, therefore,
2re: ,rlJ,",.,(:,+ ',)a,aee t26) If we integratethe first term by partswith respectto 4 we obtain l"
' ",'''
J,, rt
e ^'"1" se 2"tv' 6, = -2r1,,- l'2 or'
J., vr2
Substitutingin eq. (2.126),we get
'",/v - (ttrlte '*,'lde. 4tru:,n$ltn:rc (2.121) If the z-axisdoesnot cut y, we can get r : ( for points on the boundary,giving Q : -(chl4nldttlt,t. 2r€l/d0.
Q.128)
J
where I traversesthe boundary of I in the counterclockwisedirection. Ifthe z-axiscutsI (seefig. 2.30c),rt: h constant in eq. (2.127),so that Q : (ct2hlet,nrv- lshl4Trdrtl('1. 2' €//d0. J
(2.r2e)
whereI again traversesthe boundary in the counterclockwisedirection. If I includesthe entire xy-plane,
DIFFRACTION
65
(c)
; 1.30 Diffraction effect of a plane area g. (After Trorey, .-rl.) (a) Calculationusing a s u r f a c ei n t e g r a l ; ( b ) c a l c u l a t i o n .::rs a line integral where the origin is not over the area; (c) .ulation when the origin is over the area; (d) evaluating the : integral when ( is multivalued.
, . *,e have a continuousplane reflector,t : - and ': rntegralvanishes. The first tepm in this equation .\ representsthe s_implerefl&tion from this plane 'J the integral representsthe diffracted*uu.. Co-_ ::rion of eqs. (2.128) and (2.129)shows that the ::lcted wave is given by the same expressionin :] CASES.
\n lmportant point to note is that both the reflec_ r .rrrddiffraction terms in eqs. (2.128) and (2.129) -- Jerivedfrom the integral in eq.(2.125),wherethe .:,srationis carried over the entire surface.When we : :.tvSood think of reflectionand diffraction as oc_
curnng at a point or along a line, we are greatly sim_ plifying the actual phenomena.In fact, both reflec_ tions and diffractionsare the resultantsofenergy that return from all parts of the surface.From this point of view a reflectionis merelya specialtype of diffraction, a point ofview that has interestingpractical applications(see99.12.2). 2.8.3 Time-domainsolution/br dffiaction We now obtain the time-domain solution of eqs. (2.128) and (2.129).The inversetransform of the re-
THEORY OF SEISMIC WAVES
66 flection term on the right-hand side of eq. (2.129) givesthe impulse (cl2h)6(t - 2hln, that is, a repetition of the input at the sourceafter a delay of 2hlV which is the two-waytraveltimefrom the sourceto the plane surface,with the amplitude falling off inversely as the distance.Thus, the reflection has the same waveshapeas the source.The diffraction terms can be found as follows:We write t : 2ElV which is the twoway traveltimefrom the sourceto the variablepoint on the boundary.Equation (2.128)now becomes
o:
z(,!!'t)A!9\t) (t,+t,-t)(t,-f)tt2 (4chynlnLat)
(t7 + ti- t)(t, :0
(1>
(2.132)
(t
whereI : 2ElV t,: 2rlV and t, -- 2yolV. #f"r\,: "]uf?#o,(2,30) This valueof $(t) givesthe diffractedwaverecorded
We must pay careful attention to the limits of integration because(, and hencel, is in generala multivalued function of 0; for example,when 0 : 0. in fig. 2.30d, € can have any of the values {-, {,, or (,. To avoiddifficulties,the integralis calculatedas the point ofintegration goesfrom A to B (0 from 0, to 0r), then from 8 to C, C to D, and finally D to A, the proper valuesof { (and l) being usedalong each segmentof the path. Along a given portion of the path, say,betweenI : /r and t : t2(t2) /,), we have
o:
fact B and D are aI infinity, so that 0 increasesfrom -lrr to +]n as the point of integration,4 traversesthe botndary in a clockwise direction. The result (see problem2.19)is
hl:,';.(::)d/: f-
d(0e-"dr,
Comparing the right-hand integralwith we concludethat eq. (15-178a), 0(/):0 : (chlrlnt' )(d0ldt) :o
at point P(0, 0, 0) as the result of an impulse,c 6(l), appliedat the samepoint. If the input is cg(t)instead of c 6(t), O will have the factor G(s)and the response becomes0(r) * g(r) (seeeq. (15.195). Equation(2.132)givesthe diffraction effectwhether P is offthe plane,as in fig. 2.31,or over the plane; becausey,,changessign as P passesover the edge,the diffractedwaveundergoesa l80o phaseshift as P passesover the edge.Moreover,if we write D for the value of d for the diffractedwaveobservedwhen P is infinitesimally close to the edge and to the left of it, the total effect observedwhen P is the samedistanceto the right of the edgewill be R 4 R beingthe value of the reflectionterm in eq. (2.129).BecauseS(l) is continuous,
(2.131)
(tt.).
The derivative,d0/dl, is finite exceptwhen { is constant, suchas whereI is boundedby an arc ofa circle with its center at the origin for which cased/ : 0. In this specialcase,eq. (2.130)gives
R
D
or
( 2 r.3 3 )
Thus, the maximum amplitudeof the diffraction from a half-planeis half the amplitudeof the reflectedwave (as observedfar from the edge). Figure 2.32 shows what is expected from a half-plane based on eq. (2.132).As the edgeof the reflectoris approached,the diffractiongains in amplitudewhereas(R - D) decreases in amplitudeuntil at the edgeD : :R and the
Q : (chlnVrti)e 'o(0, - 0i), where 0, and 0, fix the end points of the circular arc, and t,,is the two-waytraveltimeto the arc. The inverse transform is g : (chlnv,ti)(e,- Oi)E(/- lo). When d0/dl is finite, we can get the time-domarn solution for the diffractedwaveby dividing the boundary of the arcaI so that the two-way traveltimet betweenP and the fioundary is a single-valuedfunction of 0 in eachpart, calculatingS for eachpart from eq. (2.131),then summingthe various 0's to get $ for the diffracted wave. 2.8.4 Dilfraction ffict oJ a halJ-plane A simple illustration of the method is the calculation of the diffraction effectin the important caseof a horizontal half-planeat a depth ft, the edgebeing parallel to the x-axis and a distanceyo from it. By referringto fig. 2.31, the edge of the half-plane is BD, where in
Fig. 2.31
Calculation of the diffraction from a half-plane
Surface
I / = 1 . 6k m / s
1.0
. , , i; : l-l*t': j
[iii] H[+--tr-tl[,1i
l--i-?-i]: t- i-T ti-l--t-f-r : ; i i - ; ( . t l: : t : f i i l l i . i ; i ] I j i ' a-: ili | -, ii - * i - - il : . , - - + f T -l , ' * j I i ; i i I : i i i i l' i i I I i I i I i ; I
i i I ; I i i , ; i rr , i I i i l , i I I I l , i _i , i i I ! i i i I i I I I I-i---ri-1i-- ;-*{- _f++*$-,=1-;
r l. ;* I i i I ; I t I i I l- l. i i, I , i l- i' , : :
E
tr
I.J
:-
i i, 1I ;r i i , i , i i i . i ; l , r i i , i I i i ' iI i i i i . i i ' iil-' ii .i iI - LI iI l+i,1i*l=i=-:1. -'. +'+ ts:r,-l-l-+
ilI i i l j i i ; l , ;I r : i i i l ; i ' ir ; I t i i i
;
i,t j,l-ir-irj i, ir- l-t i t ; i, ,J+i=l-i,=-i, ;j i j,i i'i-l i i i : : , 1i ,ii I I I
1.6
iIii
i I i'i ;
iii
,-- +11 j jT-i-,ii-'i--i l+ ,--;l-i i r ,i , L i i l-ri i i i ; - l 'I i l i , I I i , _ , . 1 I - r - i i " ] i
(b)
F'ig. 2.32 Seismic response of a half-plane. (After Trorey, 1 9 7 0 . ) ( a )M o d e l a n d ( b ) c o m p u t e ds e i s m i cr e c o r df o r c o i n c i d e n t
, l i
a
sourcesand geophones.The arrowhead indicates the location of the edge of the half-plane.
l l l , tl J
| = to + 2Ll t=to+2Lt
t:to+2Lt
Fig. 2.33
Diffracted wavefronts for'a laulted bed.
THEORY OF SEISMIC WAVES
68 sum is jR. The phasereversalofthe diffraction before the edge is reached (the backward branch of the diffraction) from that beyond the edge (the forward branch\is evidentin fi'g.2.32.
2.8.5 Using Huygens'principle to constructdffiacted wavefronts The surface integral in eq. (2.125) shows that the diffraction effectat a point is the sum ofeffectsarising from the entire diffracting surface.This suggeststhe use of Huygens' principle to construct diffracted wavefronts,and this is the casefor points more than a few wavelengthsaway from the diffracting source. Figure 2.33 illustratesthis construction for a faulted reflector.We assumea plane wavefront lB incident normally on the faulted bed CO, the position of the wavefront when it reachesthe surfaceof the bed at I : 1,,being COD. At t : t(i + Al, the portion to the right of O has advancedto position Gl1, whereasthe portion to the left of O has been reflectedand has reached position Efl We might have constructed wavefrontsEF and GH by selectinga largenumber of centers in CO and OD and drawing arcs of length VL,t; EF and GH would then be determined by the envelopesof thesearcs. However,for the portion Ef, there would be no centersto the right of O to define the envelope,whereasfor portion GH there would be no centers to the left of O to define the envelope. Thus, O marks the transition point betweencenters that give rise to the upward-travelingwavefront .E^F and centersthat give rise to the downward-traveling wavefront GH; arc FPG with center O is the diffracted wavefront originating at O and connecting the two wavefronts,EF and GH. The diffracted wavefront also extends into the geometrical shadow area GN and into region FM. The characteristicsof diffractionsin various sttuafurther in $6.3.1. tions are discussed
Problems 2.1 (a) If o,, is the only nonzero normal stress,that is, if o,,, : c,, : 0, useHooke'slaw,eq. (2.I 3), to show that strain Err : E-2,and verify eq. (2.20) for Poisson'sratio. (b) By adding the three equationsin part (a) for o,,, op, and o,,, deriveeq. (2.19)for Young'smodulus. (c) PressureI is equivalentto stresseso,, : or," : o", : -9. Substituting these relationshipsinto eq. (2.13),derive eq. (2.21)for the bulk modulus. 2.2 The entries in table 2.2 expressthe quantities at the headsof the columnsin terms of the pairs of elastic constantsor velocitiesat the left ends of the rows. The first three entriesin the ninth row are eqs.(2.19) to (2.21). Starting with these and eqs. (2.58) and (2.59),derivethe other relationsin the table.
2.3 (a) Firing an air gun ($7.4.3)in water createsa pressuretransient a small distance away with peak pressureof 5 atmospheres(5 x 105Pa). If the compressibilityof water is 4.5 x l0-'o/Pa,what is the peak energydensity? (b) If the samewaveis generatedin rock with \ : p : 3 x l0'0 Pa, what is the peak energydensity?Assume a symmetricalP-wavewith e,, : €rr: e,,, tij: 0 fot i*j. 2,4 To illustrate the interrelationshipand magnitude of the elasticconstants,completeTable2.3. Note that thesevaluesapply to specificspecimens,the valuesfor rocks range considerably,especiallyas porosity and pressurechange. 2.5 (a) Verify that S : .l(x - Vt) and * : g(x + Vt) in eqs. (2.46) and (2.47) are solutionsof the onedimensionalwaveequation,eq. (2.45).(Hint: Let ( = x - Vt and show that
ar!_ dfa(_d.f=r, 0x
d(
d( dx
etc.) (b) Verify that rp : J'(x + my * nz - Vt) + g((x + my * nz + Vt) in eq. (2.48)is a solutionof the planewaveequation,eq. (2.30). (c) Using the sametechnique,show that * : (llr)f(r - Vt) + (llr)SQ + Vt) in eq. (2.52)satisfiesthe wave eq. (2.50). equationin sphericalcoordinates, 2.6 (a\ Show that the waveequation,eq. (2.30),can be written in cylindrical coordinates(x : r cos 0, y : r sin 0, and : : ;; seefig. 2.34a)as a' {,
la{,
612
r 6r
la'q, f
I A:rl,
n' +-
T
12 602
622
V2 Af
(b) Verify that eq. (2.49)isthe waveequationin spherical coordinatesby substitutingthe following coordinatetransformation(seefig. 2.34b)into eq. (2.30): x:rsin0cos$,
0' I : ;:'J,?:''
(For an easiersolution,seeproblem 15.8.) 2.7 A pulse composed of two different frequency components,ou * Ao, can be representedby factors involving the sum and differencesof the frequencies. If they have equal amplitudes,we can write for the two components .4 cos (rcrx- art), I cos (r,x - o,l), ttl, - o)0 Ao, ru : 2nllto : where
S
j--s 9 A
> EA_
s
s
s
*I r lTt { l T | iF F F G + F rl'
I
s i
r,'
! 1v1
- -^ * iR r .
I
.eis _ln €l_i _1& JE- -l* _]! >;* _];
qr5
F!
ra 9ca
S h
N j
r
",x ;.= ?9 d
\
^
^
{i
.
t
i
.
- + - S c - r o - ' ' ^ + -8. -t -Y
O
>
^
-'
- -
d
4.
l
'E
(
a
F1
.J 5.<
-
..l
.{
b +
s
= ot
A E l .
I
t l 6.\ t 6
Hl^
=
X
1.1 |
r l Y l *
q R
l.\
<
-v
\O
-
r
l
Y
E
i
^
. + 6
b * l
6lO.t
I
h a]
l -
I
6
d
T
2.
11a:h r f xr*'lJ ilp l'i
N a l 1 I l..l H.l
O
\
I
I
I l
t
a i : b
l6l I
^= x - 7
l o 6
d E-r
r
<'
?le :ai f
I rt'l
-r.l lr'r I
l-
N
t l -
ll.l
-
q
q
C ctN
rt
,4
.t\ I c
e
^-!
a< c.l c.t
(.)
-
' Y
g H,.l
€ qi
-
' )
a kf
.
f
i
5
F
a rJ
j
a r
i
\
jl-
:
(
g
-T:-
;'
1T
5r< -f? 2
e,t a z 9 'j
_
g
.--
S
.: _
-1;--
& +-.ca
f**ir€=-- E z a ii
g
THEORY OF SEISMIC WAVES
70
Fig.2.34 Coordinate systems.(a) Cylindrical coordinates; (b) spherical coordinates.
(c) Show that the envelopemoveswith the group velocity tl where I- r = L a : d ' : Ar dr
v-xdv=v+tdv dt'r d\
(seefig. 2.26). 2.8 The magnitudesof period I frequencyv, wavelength \, and angular wavenumberr are important in practical situations.Calculate l1 \, and r ,for the situationsshownin table2.4. 2.9 (a) Show that the potential function ( : V(0 + 6yldz) - V' 1k of eq. (2.63)requiresthat A and 0- be solutionsof the P- and S-waveequations,eqs. (2.28) and (2.29), respectively.(I/rn l.' Recall that $ and 1 are solutionsof the waveequationand calculateV ' ( and V x ( u s i n ge q s .( 1 5 . 1 2a) n d ( 1 5 . 1 3 ) . ) (b) Show that the dilatation and rotation (eqs.(2.65)) can be derivedfrom ( in eq. (2.64)using eq. (15.14) and the resultsofproblem 15.7. 2.10 Justifyon physicalgroundsthe following boundary conditionsfor different combinationsof media in contact at an interface: (a) Solid-fluid: normal stressand displacementare continuous,tangential stressin the solid vanishesat the interface. (b) Solid vacuum: normal and tangential stressesin the solid vanish at the interface. (c) Fluid-fluid: normal stressesand displacements are continuous. (d) Fluid vacuum:normal stressin the fluid vanishes at the interface. 2.11 Using eqs.(2.8),(2.9),(2.12),(2.t3), (2.t\, and (2.64),show that the boundary conditions at the xyplane separatingtwo semiinfinitesolids require,for a wave in the rz-plane, the continuity of the following potential functions:
(d, - x*). (6, + x,). IV' $ + 2p(6""- x,), p(20,,+ x,,- x),
where the subscripts denote partial differentiation (theseare respectivelythe normal and tangentialdisplacements,normal and tangentialstresses). 2.12 A sourceof seismicwavesproducesa step displacementon a sphericalcavity of radius r0 enclosing the sourceof the form stepo(/):0(t<0), :kft>0). Show from eq.(2.77)that the displacementis given by
,r:10,, - 1). ^,, + rl
Is the motion oscillatory?What is the final (permanent) displacementat distancer? 2.13 Show that for harmonic wavesof the form $ : (Alr) cosa(rlV - l), the two termsin eq. (2.71),which decayat differentrates,are of equalimportanceat distance r : |tl2r. 2.14 Equations(2.86) and (2.87)for a Rayleighwave are valid at the surfacez : 0 for o : ll4. (a) Show that at depthsz * 0,the expressionsfor the u and w are x- and z-displacements r(x _ v^t), + 0.577e0.3e3s)sin u: rA(_e 0.8a8Kz 0 3e3s) 0.848K:+ : 1.468e w rl(-0.848e x cosK (x - 4t). (b) What are the valuesof u. w. and 0 when z : ll2r? When z : l/rc? (c) Is the motion retrogradefor all valuesof z? (Hint: Note that for the motion to changedirection,the amplitude of either u or )r must passthrough zero.) (d) What are the valuesof (, the Rayleigh-wavevelocity, when o : 0.4 and when o : 0.2? What are the correspondingvaluesofthe constantsin part (aX 2.15 Assumethreegeophonesso orientedthat one records only the vertical componentof a seismicwave, anotherrecordsonly the horizontal componentin the direction of the source,and the third only the hori-
REFERENCES
7l
Table 2.3 Example of magnitudesof elastic constantsand velocities Water Young'smodulus,E (x 10'Pa) Bulk modulus,k (x 10, Pa) Rigidity modulus, t'. (x 10' Pa) Lam6's\ constant(X 10' Pa) Poisson'sratio, o Density,p (g/cm,) P-wave velocity, o (km/s) S-wavevelocity, B (km/t
Stiffmud
Sandstone
Limestone
Granite
16
54
50
0.34 1.9
0.25 2.5
0.20 2.'7
2.1 0.5 1.0 1.5
0.43 1.5 1.6
Table 2.4 Magnitudesof T X, and x o (km/s)
Forv:15H2
r(s) Weathering(min.) Weathering(avg.) Water Poorly consolidatedsands shales at 0.75km Tertiary clasticsat 3.00 km Porouslimestone Denselimestone Salt Anhydrite
r (m)
Forv:60H2 K ( m ' )
7(s)
r (m)
K (m-')
0.1 0.5 1.5 2.0 J.J
+-)
5.5 4.0
6.1
zontal component at right anglesto this. Assume a simplewaveshapeand draw the responseof the three geophonesfor the lollowingcases: (a) A P-wave traveling directly from the source to the geophones. (b) A P-wavereflectedfrom a deephorizon. (c) An S-wavegeneratedby reflection of a P-wave at an interface. (d) A Rayleighwavegeneratedby the source. (e) A Love wave. Compare the relativemagnitudesof the components for short and long offsets. 2.16 (a) A tube wavehas a velocity of 1.05km/s. The fluid in the boreholehas a bulk modulus of 2.I 5 x 1O' Pa and density1.20g/cm3.The wall rock haso :0.25 and p : 2.5 glcm3 . Calculatep and o for the wall rock. (b) Repeat fot Vr: 1.20 km/s and 1.30 km/s. What do you concludeabout the accuracyof this method for determiningp? 2,17 The natural logarithm of the ratio of amplitudes is measuredin nepers.Show that I neper : 8.686dB. 2.18 A refraction seismicwaveletassumedto be essentiallyharmonic with frequency40 Hz is found to have amplitudesof 5.00 and 4.57 mm on traces2.50 and 3.00 km from the source.Assuminga velocity of 3.20 km/s, constant subsurfaceconditions,and ideal recording conditions,what is the ratio of the amplitudes on a given trace of the first and fourth cycles?
What percentageof the energy is lost over three cycles?What is the value of /r? 2.19 Using eq. (2.131),the generalequationfor the diffraction from a plane surface,verify eq. (2.132)for the diffraction effectof a half-plane.
Referenccs Aki, K., and P. G. Richards. 1980. Quantitatiw Seismology; Theory and Methods. San Francisco: W H. Freeman. Birch, F. 1966. Compressibility; elastic constants. ln Handbook of Physical Constants, S. P Clark, ed., GSA Memoir 97 Blake, F C. 1952.Spherical wave propagation in solid media. I Acoust. Soc. Amer.. 24: 211-15. Braddick, H. J. J. 1965. Vibrations, Waves,and Diffractions New York: McGraw-Hill. Brillouin, L. 1960. Wave Propagation and Group Velocity. New York: Academic Press. Bush, L, and S. Crampin. 1987.Observations of EDA and PTL anisotropy in shear-wave YSP, Expanded Abstracts, 57th Annual International Meeting of the Society of Exploration Geophysicists, pp.646 59. Tulsa: Society ofExploration Geophysicists. Cheng, C. H., and M. N. Toksoz. 1981. Elastic wave propagation in fluid-filled borehole and svnthetic acoustic loss. Geophysics, 462 1042 53. Crampin, S. 1981. A review ofwave propagation in anisotropic and cracked elastic media. Waye Motion, 3: 343-91.
72 Crampin,S.,R. McGonigle,and D. Bamford.1980.Estimating crack parametersfrom observationsof P-wavevelocity antso45: 345-60. ttopy. Geophysics, Dobrin, M. B. 1951.Dispersion in seismicwaves.Geophysics, 16:63-80. J. A. McDonald, Ebrom,D. A., R. H. Tatham,K. K' Sekharan, and G. H. F. Gardner.1990.Dispersionand anisotropyin laminated versusfractured media: An experimentalcomparison' ExpandedAbstracts,60th Annual InternationalMeetingof the pp. 1416-19.Tulsa:SociSoiietyof ExplorationGeophysicisls, ety of Exploration Geophysicists. Ewing,W. M., W. S.Jardetzky,and F. Press 1957.Elastic Waves in LayeredMedia.New York: McGraw-Hill' Futterman,W. I. 1962.Dispersivebody waves.J. GeophysRes', 67:5279-91. Gerkens,J. C. d'Arnaud. 1989.Foundationof ExplorationGeop/ryslcsAmsterdam:Elsevter. Grant. F. S.,and G. F. West. 1965'InterpretationTheoryin Applied GeophysicsNew York: McGraw-Hill. Hardage,B. A. 1985. VerticalSeismicProfling, Part A' PrinPress. ciptes,2ded. London:Geophysical Howell, B. 1959. Intoduction to Geophysics.New York: McGraw-Hill. Hsieh, J. S. 1975. Principlesof ThermodynanicsNew York: McGraw-Hill. New York:CambridgeUniversityPress' Lamb,H. 1960.Statics. Landau, L. D., and E. M. Lifshitz. 1986.Theoryof Elasticity, 3d ed. Oxford: PergamonPress. Lapedes,D. N., ed. 1978,McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Physics and Mathematics.New York: McGraw-Hill.. Logan,J. D. 1987.AppliedMathemalicsNew Yorkr John Wiley' Love. A. E. H. 1911.Some Problemsof GeodynamicsNew York: Dover. Love,A. E.H. 1944.A Treatiseon the MathematicalTheoryoJ' Elasticity.New York: Dover. polarizationsfor anMacBeth,C. 1990.Inversionof shear-wave isotropy using three-componentoffset YSPs. ExpandedAbMeetingofthe Societyof Ex' innual International st.::acls,60th ploration Geophysicists,pp. 1404-6 Tulsa: Society of Exploration GeoPhYsicists. Newman, P. 1973,Divergenceeffectsin a layeredearth Geo' plrysdcs, 38: 481-8. Postma,G. W. 1955.Wavepropagationin a stratifiedmedium' 20: 780-806. Geophysics,
THEORY
OF SEISMIC WAVES
Press.F.. and R. Siever.1978.Earth,2d ed. San Francisco: W. H. Freeman. Saada,A. S. 1974.Elasticity: Theoryand Applications.Oxford: PergamonPress. A. 1975.SeismicWaves.Moskow: MIR. Savarensky, M., and F. Muir. 1989.A calculusfor finely layered Schoenberg, 54: 581 9. media.Geophyslcs, Scholte,J. C. 1947. The rangeof existenceof Rayleighand Stoneley waves. Royal Astron. Soc. Monthly Notices Geophys Snpp,Ser.A, 106:416-28. S6gonzac,P. D., and J. Laherr6re.1959.Application of the conin Northern tinuous velocity log to anisotropymeasurements Prosp.,7z202-17. Geophys. Sahara:Resultsand consequences. in wells. Stoep,P M. 1966.Velocityanisotropymeasurements 900 16. Geophysics,3l: Stoneley,R. 1924.Elasticwavesat the surfaceof separationof two solids.Proc. Roy.Soc.(London),A-106:416-28. implicationsof aeolotropy R. 1949.The seismological Stoneley, in continental structures.Monthly Notices, Roy.Astron. Soc. Geophys.Supp., 5: 343-53. Toksoz,M. N., and D. H. Johnston.1981.SeismicWaveAttenuReprintSeries2. Tulsa:Societyof Exation,SEGGeophysical plorationGeophysicists. Trorey, A. W. 1970.A simple theory for seismicdiffractions. Geophysics, 35:.762-84. Trorey,A. W. 1977. Diffractionsfor arbitrary source receiverlo42':| 177-82. cations.Geophysics, Uhrig, L. F., and F. A. van Melle. 1955.Velocityanisotropyin 20: 774-9. stratifiedmedia.Geophysics, borehole Ward,R. W.,and M. R. Hewitt. 1977.Monofrequency 42t | 1t745. traveltimeswvey.Geophysics, and White. J. E. 1965.SeismicWaves- Radiation,Transmission, New York: McGraw-Hill. A t tenuation. Sound Applicationof Seismic White, J. E. 1983.IJnderground Waves.Amsterdam:Elsevier. Winterstein,D. F. 1990.Velocity anisotropyterminologyfor 55: 1070-88. geophysicists. Geophysics, poWinterstein,D. F., and M. A. Meadows.1990.Shear-wave larizationsand subsurfacestressdirectionsat Lost Hills Field. ExpandedAbstracts,60th Annual InternationalMeeting of the pp. l43l-4. Tulsa:Society Societyof ExplorationGeophysic,rrs of ExplorationGeophysicists.
3
Partitioning at an interface
Overview The partitioning of energyat interfacesis the central phenomenonof seismicexploration.Boundary conditions permit calculatinghow wave energy is divided among reflectedand transmittedwaves.The most easily understoodapproach,in terms of displacements, yields Zoeppritz' equations,and the calculation in terms of potentialsyields Knott's equations.Both approachesare given here,eventhough they accomplish the samepurpose,becauseof the importanceof partitioning. For the simple but important caseof normal incidence($3.2),which is commonlyassumedin most reflection work, Zoeppritz' (or Knott's) equations reduce to the familiar equationfor the normal reflection coefficient.This equationstatesthat the reflectionamplitude, comparedwith the incident amplitude,varies directly as the changein acousticimpedance(the product of velocity and density).Examplesof reflection coefficientmagnitudesare given. Reflectionat nonnormal incidence($3.3)leads to wave conversion and amplitude changes,especially near the critical angle.The Zoeppritz equations,while exact,do not givea feelingfor how amplitudesdepend on the various factors involved. Severalapproxlmations havebeenmade in an effort to achievean equation form that givesmore insight into the changesexpected for various situations. In particulaq the variation of amplitudeswith angle (93.4),more commonly expressedas amplitude variation with offset (AVO), has becomeimportant in the last few yearsas an indicator of hydrocarbongas. Refraction methods are usually basedon a simple head-waveconcept ($3.5) (although the waves lnvolved are, in fact, much more complex); the simple conceptyieldscorrect traveltimesand providesa basis for the interpretationof head-wavetraveltimes.
tions are the amplitudesof the wavesgenerated.When both media are solids, there are four equations resulting from the boundaryconditions,so that we must havefour variables.A P-wave(or an S-wave)incident on an interfaceseparatingtwo solidsmust in general generatereflectedand refractedS-wavesas well as reflected and refractedP-waves.Thus, for an incident P-wave,as shown in fig. 3.1, we havereflectedand refracted P-wavesat angles0, and 0, and reflectedand refracted S-waves at angles 6, and 6r. The waves whosemodeschangeat an interface(the reflectedand refractedS-wavesin the foregoingexample)are called convertedwaves. Note that S-waveshave 2 degreesof freedom,and motion perpendicularto the plane containing the incident waveand the normal to the interfaceis not involved in conversion from P- to S-wavesnor vice versa.Wherethe interfaceis horizontal,this is equivalent to sayingthat incident P-wavescan generatereflected and refracted P- and SZ-wavesbut not S.F1Waves,that incident SZ-wavescan generateP- and SZ-waves,but that incident Sl1-wavesgenerateonly reffected!a0d refractedS11-waves. Snell's law can be extended to cover converted waves.In fi5. 2.28, we change0i to E,, the angle of reflectionof the convertedS-wave.Writing o, and B, for the P- and S-wavevelocities,we have S i n0 , : B ' N A ' R : d t L t l A ' R , sin 6, : A'SIA'R: 9, L^tlA'R, hence.
3.1.1General The boundary conditions describedin $2.4.4lead to rather complex relationsfor reflectionand refraction at an interface.The nature of the two media fixesthe densitiesand elasticconstantsand thus the velocities. The angles of reflection and refraction are fixed in terms of the velocities,as will be shown. The only variablesremaining to satisfy the boundary condit-)
sin0,
Pr
0l
Following the same procedure for the refracted S-wave,we arrive at the generalform of Snell'slaw:
stn0r : I! j, : srn0: : An9,a :, r ' 0r
3.1 Application of boundary conditions
s i nE ,
g,
c2
(3.1)
9,
Note that p is the componentof the slownessof each ray in fig. 3.1 parallel to the interface.We conclude, therefore,that waveconversion,reflection,and transmissiondo not changethe componentof the slowness parallelto the interface. 3.1.2. Zoeppritz'equations Theseequations(Zoeppritz, 1919)determinethe amplitudesofthe reflectedand refractedwavesat a plane
PARTITIONING AT AN INTERFACE
74
- r 4 o c o s g t + A l cos 0r - B, sin 6,
- -A2 cos 0, - B, sin 6r,
(3.3)
,40sin 0, * ,4, sin 0 r + B r cos Er : '42sin 0: - -8, cos
(3.4)
By usingeqs.(2.8),(2.9),(2.13),and (2.14),the last two boundary conditions become
Pl, trl, rll, dl, Pl P 2 , ) \ 2 , P 1 ,d z , P 2
+ d --,ldz)+ 2p",(dw,ldz) tr,(drz,/dx : tr.(Da,/dx+ dwrldz)+ 2p.r(dwrldz), p.r(durldz+ dru,/Ex) : p,r(du.ld:+ du,,/Dx). Because
Fig. 3.1 Waves generatedat a solid solid interface by an incident P-wave.Displacement polarities assumedin $3.1.2 are indicated.
interfacefor an incident P-wave.We write A,', A,, 42, 8,, and ^8,for the displacementamplitudesof the incident, reflected,and refractedP-waves'and for the reflected and refracted S-waves(seefig. 3'l), the plus signs indicating the positive directions of displacements. We consider wavestraveling in the xz-plane, the interfacebeing the xy-plane' We can write for the incident wave(comparewith eq. (2.56))
:
f0ejo(rsinsl
: c o s f l l ) / r i :l
f09ro,r'(\
then [ I ' , s i n 0 , + ( \ r + 2 p , ) c o s0 , c o t 0 , ] ( A o + A ) - ( 2 p , c o s6 , ) . 8 , : [\, sin 0" + (\, * 2p,)cos0, cot 0,]1, + (2p, cos6,)8,,
/coroll.
where we have omitted the factor e-j'' becausewe shall not be differentiatingwith respectto time and the factor will cancelout in the boundary conditions' We can now write for the various wavesin fig' 3'1, rlro: loer'(', \rt:
Ap)@{l
qr/ : Brer'{r,
{r, :
l , e' r d ( r ,
I
l(3.2a1 r!' = f.er-(i. i
where = p(x - z cot 0,), f1r.ro, ( , : p ( x + z c o t 0 , ) , { r : p ( x - z cote,), (', : p(x + z cot E,),\lr: p(x - z c o t E j J
6
(the minus signsmean that the wavepropagationis in the direction of the negativez-axis). Next we resolvethe displacementsU', rfi into componentsalong the x- and z-axes.This gives I At zlo sin 0r ej-ao l, - A o c o s0 r e j ' { o* l , - I,
sin 0r ej'{r + sin 0r ej-\zc o s0 , e p r rc o s0 , e j ' { : -
Br cos 6' er-ai' Bzcos62er'{2, - 8 ,s i n 6 ' e r d i ' B , s i n6 ' e r r i '
The boundary conditions require that when z wr:
tr,(lo sin 0t + At sin 0, * .8, cos b') + (\r + 2p,) (.40cos0, cot 0, * l , c o s0 , c o t 0 , - 8 , c o s6 , ) : lrr(Arsin 0, - B, cosbr) + (\, + 2pr) (Arcose2cot 02+ B2cos6r);
fogjot{r+z:)/'r
{,,:
ut : uz: wr: ||z:
Dtj/dx: s.p*i, Erf,/dx : jtoprf,, : jorp(+cot6,)rfj, d,!,ldz : jop( + cot 0,){,, : we can drop the factor jtop and considerthat 0/3r +cot get the +cot for now We 6,' or 0, I and 6li)z: normal stresscondition
w2'
: I12t l'11
o",1,: o""ly
or
fr ^,* z*,)- 2p,sin' o,( A o +
aino
L - t[,^. *
sin0.
+ (2pzcos E,)-8,.
and(3.1), By usingeqs.(2.58),(2.59), /p,oi 2p,Plsin' 0,\ I-'. 1(Ao+A,)-(2P,BlcosE')B' \ P o ' l - 2p,Bisin' O,\ - - -lAr+Qpr}' rcos62)82. : l ' /o,ol :
\
P
*
,
1
Hence, prg?(l ?9in S?)(,1^ '+
At)-
2o'B'(sinE' tot-QJ3,
Pqt
: 0,
r, * 2d$T.ee$t4.
o.,1,: o'-12'
At z :0, all ofthe exponentialfactors reduceto er-pso that the exponentialfactors can be omitted when formulating the boundary conditions. The first two boundary conditions give
2p,) - 2p. sin'o.
A ) - ( 2 p , c o s6 , ) 8 ,
Finally, (Ao + A)Zt cos 26, - B,W, sin 26, : ArZrcos 262+ B2W2sin 2Er,
(3.5)
\PPLICATION OF BOUNDARY CONDITIONS ;:,eft Zi: p,c, and W: p,F,;Z, and W, are called - - .trtsticimpedances. The last boundary condition gives ll-rll(-Ao * l,)cos er + -Brcos 6, cot 6,] + [(- Ao * l,)cos 0, - B, sin 6,]] : lLz\t Azcos0, * B, cos6, cot Er) * (- Arcos02- ,8,sin 6r)), ..:i
75
equivalent to multiplication by I and by -r cot 0, and -r cot 6,, respectively, and the common factor ej.p'is omitted after the differentiation.Problem 2.ll gives the expressionsfor the normal and tangential displacementsand stressesin terms of derivativesof S and 1. The first boundary condition requiresthe continuity of normal displacementsat the interface,that is,
l).
* i l - A o + A ) 2 c o s 0 r + B , ( c o s6 , c o t 6 , - s i n 6 , ) ) = lL.l-2Azcos e2 + Br(cos6, cot E2- sin 6r)). 'p,\llp\) le Ao + A,)2 cos0, sin 6, * B, cos 26,1 = b'9llPP)?2Ar cos 0, sin 6, + B, cos 26r), . (g,la,)W,(-Ao * l,)sin 291+ Wpt cos 26r : - ( B r l a r ) W r A r s i n 2 0 r + W 2 B 2 c o2s b r . ( 3 . 6 ) Collecting together the results of applying the :.:.rndary conditions, we have the four Zoepprtiz :: Jations:
i
- A)Zt cos 26, - B,W, sin 26, : ArZ, cos 2E2+ B2Wzsin 26r,
- 1 + A ) ( g , l a , ) w , s i n2 0 , + B , w , c o s 2 6 , = - A.(S2|(}2)W, sin 20. + B2W2cos 26,.
(3.3) (3.4)
(3.6)
- 3 Knott'sequqtions r-,-.-.It(1899)was the first to derive equationsgiving : rmplitudesofreflectedand refractedwavesgener::-r at a plane interface.He used the displacement :' :3ntial functions$ and 1 of eq. (2.64)in the form: \ t e d i u m( l ) :
\ t e d i u m( 2 ) : Q2:.dtei'tz, yr: fi.si-1t,
z:o
(- du + d)cot 0, - %, : - Nz cot 0, - 9)r. The next condition is that the sheardisplacementsbe equal:
: (3*. (:*.:+) #),
- : o
(.{o + .{r) * 9J,cot 6, : d, - 9J,cot Er. The continuity of normal stressrequiresthat
\ V,6-r-,- lrTt- d-r'l ) x dz \dr-
I
be continuous;thus, (3 5)
Thus, for a P-waveof given amplitude lo incident , :he angle0, on a plane interfaceieparating two ml- " - : rrith given valuesof p, pr,o, and B, Snell'slaw de:irlrnes the angles 0, and 6,, whereas Zoeppritz' :: -.rrionsfix the reflectedand refractedamplitudesl, --,: B. Similarequationscan be derivedfor an inci:::.: .S-wave. For a fluid medium, B, : 0 becauseonly j -.irres a r ep r o p a g a t e d .
q, : s/oer.
:(::-*),
hence.
.:rs becomes
.{ + l,)cos 0, - .8, sin 6, - -A2 cos 02 - B, sin 6r, 1 l , ) s i n 0 , * 8 , c o sE , : lz sin 0, - B, cos 62,
(*-*)
\r(.do + "e/,Xl + cot2Or) + 2p",[(.N,u * .d,)cot20,- !Z},cot 6,] : \,d.( I * cot20,)+ 2yt"r(d2cot20, * (Z,cot D,). By usingeqs.(2.58),(2.59),and (3.1),this becomes p,(cot26,- l)(.d, * d,) - 2p",9),cot6, : pr(cot26,- l)dr* 2p";frrcot6,. Continuityof the tangentialstressmeansthat
-33) *(,#1,.33 is continuous;thus, IL,[2(*d,, + "d,)cot0r + g]r(cotrb,- l)l : Fr[-2d, cot e, + %,(cot26,- l)]. If we substitutea, : cot 0i, br : cot 6p and c,: bi - l, the precedingequationsbecome -a,do + a,d, - '!J, : -a,d, - ,fr., (3.1) .ilo+dt+ bllJt:.ilr-
br%.,
(3.g)
llrcrdo * p,c,.d,- 2p"rb r9), IL'czd, * 2p".b;%r, (3.9) -2p"rardoI 2p.,a,d,* lt"rc%, : -2p"radr* p"rcr,frr. (3.10) (Note that .d, and 9J,in theseequationsare the amplitudes of the potential functions $ and 1, not of the
PARTITIONING AT AN INTERFACE
76
(Volume of cylinder) x .E : (ar cos 0'Xp,to '*rlzai) : o')' ltro,too.d3(cot
equadisplacementsas in eqs. (3'3) to (3'6))' These. of equations subsituting by alsobe obtained il;t;" (3'6)' (3'3) to eqs' (3.13) into the form of eq. 3.I .4. Distributionof energY property' If Knott's equations have a very interestin^g third first.and we multipiy correspondingsidesof the second ofthe sides equation; and alsocorresponding products' and fourth equations,and then add these is the result
Becausesimilar expressionsmust hold for the energy have carried away by the other waves.we seethat we to ob(3' l.l by l :pr'ro in eq. term each onfy to mutiipiy tain tire distri6ution of energy among the various
+ (p, cot Er)9)i+ (prcot9r)dl (p, cot Or)-d? ( p , + c o t6 , ) % i : 1 P , c o t 0 , ) s 4 3 ( 3 ' ll ) relate Becausethe first and third Knott equations two the on stress and displacement to the normal fourth and second the whereas interface the of sides the t.iu,. to the tangential displacement and stress' area' per unit energy of pioJ""tt havethJ dimensions (3' I I ) F.l- tnit we make the correct surmise that eq' revarious givesthe distribution of energyamong the we this' f,ected and refracted waves' To demonstrate pothe terms,of in (2'105) r-epeatthe derivationof eq' becauseit tential function O (X doei not enter here we have "o.r"..n, S-waves).For the incident P-wave' E* for the kinetic energy per unit volume
uu+:1,,[(*)'. (Y)'l
waves. 3.2 Partitionlng
at normal incidence
Zoepprtiz'equationsreduceto a very simpleform for normal incidence.The curveschangeslowly for small angelsof incidence(say,up to l5'), so the resultsfor normal incidencehavewide application.For a P-wave at normal incidence,there are no tangential stresses , , : B . : 0 a n d e q s '( 3 ' 3 ) a n d d i s p l a c e m e n thse; n c eB to (3.6)reduceto A, * Ar: Ao, Z,A, - ZrAr: -ZrAn. The solution of theseequationsis A , 0 , p ,- c r P r- 2 2 - Z t - 5 2 22 A'o: ",0, * o,P' Z, + z, - L(\nZ): l{Aa/o + L'PlP), \
P:
r' : : A , : Au
2o,pr d z P z* c r P '
22, _.
( 3 .l 4 )
(3.15)
22+ Zt
coeffiEquations(3.14)and (3'15)give the reflection Equation 7l cient R and the transmissioncoemcient of a sequenceof isoi:.i+l tfto*t that the amplitudes in the log of changes of reiord a lated reflectionsare in seismic taken viewpoint the impendances, acoustic reenergy of tog manufacture($5.4.5).The fractions reE, and E^ by given n."",.0 and trans;itted are reflection called sometimes ;;;;Jt i*hich are also and transmissionenergycoemcients):
:l'[(*,)'.(3;*,)'l take 0l6x: Usingeqs.(3.2)and notingthat wemu3t -0o-rcoser)/ct'and6tdt= -jo' we have :ri,'ata):' forz:0,
?+: ;,'[,*'r'.''
^
u,prazAl C t , P , t l l:f r
* [t':,ttt'1,,'{'}.,*..,n01,,'' ,. the exTaking the maximum of the real part, we find is, pressiin for the energydensity 4 that E : lp,.i o(.4Ju,)'-
(3'12)
Comparisonwith eq. (2'105)showsthat do:
(a,lo)Ao,
( 3 .I 3 )
in the where ,4^ is the amplitude of the displacement of ProPagation. direction interifr. ".t..gy biought up to a unit area of the be the will P-wave incident the by time p.t rrnii fu"" energyin a cylinder of length o' of unit.cross-sectlon and inclined at an i-"utut.a parallel to the interface), that is' surface, the to normal angle O,toihe
,
('r..'r,)=
- o . r P r . u ' 2: A i 4 Z ' Z '
: Rr. (3.16)
Z" -'
,)r'l'),1': 2',r'' a,p,r,r2,4i
t3'll\
1' Note that eqs' (3'16) and Obviously,ER + Er: Z, are in-terchanged; i:.r2i"..'""ihanged if .1, an! not depend upon does partition hence, the energy -iontuint wave' When incident the *fri.tt -.alutransmltZ - l Z , : l . R : E o : 0 . a n da l l t h ee n e r g yi s : ",.'i' p' and p, that require ito,"itt"t thi! does not zero approaches contrast : "". As the impedance ", unity; R approaches and zero Iapproaches oi inntirv, is from unity' ifru., ,tt.iu*hei the impedancecontrast the stronger the reflectedenergy' Table 3.1 showshow the reflectedenergyvariesfor wlthln impedancecontrastssuch as may be expected contrasts the earth. Becauseboth densityand velocity only ".. r*"ff for most of the interfacesencountered'
PARTITIONING AT NONNORMAL INCIDENCE
ll
Table 3.1 Energy reflectedat interfacebetweentwo media First medium
Secondmedium
Interface
Velocity
Density
Velocity
Density
ztlz2
Sandstoneon limestone
2.0 3.0 2.1 4.3 t.5 1.5 1.5 0.5 2.4 2.4 2.2
1 1
3.0 2.0
2.4
1 ^
z. -)
2.4 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.5
4.5 1.5 3.0 0.36 2.0 2.5 2.2 2.5
2.4 2.4 2.0 2.5 0.0012 2.0
0.6'7 1.5 0.93 0.97 0.50 0.20 3800 0.19 0.96 1.39 0.69
Limestoneon sandstone Shallowinterface Deep interface "Soft" oceanbottom "Hard" oceanbotom Surfaceof ocean(from below) Baseof weathering Shaleover water sand Shaleover gas sand Gas sand over water sand
1 A
z.J z-J
1.8
) A
z-)
1.8 L. -)
F
0.2 -0.2 0.045 0.022 0.33 0.67 -0.9994 0.68 0.02 0.16 0.18
0.040 0.040 0.0021 0.000s 0 . 1I 0.44 0.9988 0.47 0.0004 0.027 0.034
All velocitiesin km/s, densitiesin g/cmr;the minus signsindicate lg0" phasereversal.
a small portion ol the energyis reflectedat any one interface; this is illustrated by the first four lines in table 3.1. The "sandstone-on-limestone" interfaceis about as large a contrast as is apt to be encountered, whereasthe "shallowinterface"and "deepinterface" figuresare much more typical of most interfacesrn the earth;hence,usuallyappreciablylessthan l,Z,of the energyis reflectedat any interface.The maJorexceptionsinvolvethe bottom and surfaceof the ocean and the surface and base of the weathering (see {5.3.2).A much larger proportion of the energycan be reflectedfrom these,and hencethey are especially lmportant in the generationof multiple reflections (96.3.2)and other phenomenawith which we shall deal later. Note that although the energyfractions E o and E, do not dependon which side of an interlacethe wave is incident,this is not true of the reflectedamplitude s/, becauseinterchanging Z, and Z, in eq. (3.14) changesthe sign of the ratio drld,, A negativevalue of "d, means that the reflectedwave is 180. out-ofphase with the incident wave; thus. for an incident wave sln cos to/ the reflectedwaveis s/, cos (ot + n). In table 3.1 , phasereversaloccurs for the situatrons wherc Z, exceedsZ.
33 Partitioning at nonnormal incidence Turning now to the generalcasewhere the angle of incidenceis not necessarily0', fig. 3.2 showsenergy partition as functionsof the angleof incidencefor certain valuesof parameters.Many curveswould be required to show the variations of energy partitioning as a function of incident angle becauseof the many parametersthat can be varied:incidentP-, SH-, or SVwave,P-wavevelocity ratio, densityratio, and S-wave
velocitiesin eachmedium (or the equivalentof defining Poisson'sratio for eachmedium). Figure 3.2a shows the partitioning of energy as a function of the angle of incidencewhen a P-waveis incident in the high-velocitymedium for a P-wavevelocity ratio a,la, : 0.5, a densityratio prlp, : 0.8, o, : 0.30,and o, : 0.25.For small incidentangles, all of the energyis in the reflectedor transmittedPwaves,E^r, and Er* respectively, and hencethere are essentiallyno S-waves.As the incident angle increases,some of the energy goes into reflectedand transmittedS-waves,d*. and .Er.r,respectively, mostly at the expenseof the reflectedP-wave.Note that at intermediateanglesof incidence,the reflectedS-wave carries more energy than the reflectedP-wave.Such convertedwaves(wavesresultingfrom the conversion of P-wavesto S-wavesor vice versa at an interface) are sometlmes recorded at long offsets where they are evidencedby alignmentsthat disappearas one tries to follow them to shorter offsets(see(R)"" in fig. 6.28b).As grazingincidenceis approached,the energy of the reflected P-wave increasesuntil at grazing incidenceall of the energyis in the reflected P-wave. The oppositesituation is shown in fig. 3.2.b,where a . l a , : 2 . 0 , p , l p , : 0 . 5 , o , : 0 . 3 0 ,a n d 0 2 : 0 . 2 5 . BecauseZ, : Z, the P-wavereflectioncoefficientis essentiallyzero for small incident angles.As the incident angle increases,S-waveenergyincreases. As the critical anglefor P-wavesis approached,the transmitted P-waveenergyfalls rapidly to zero and no transmitted P-waveexistsfor larger incident angles.Also, as the critical angle for P-wavesis approached,both reflected P-wave and reflected S-wave become very strong; such a buildup in reflectionstrengthnear the critical angle is called v,itle-anglerefection Sometimes it is possibleto make useof this phenomenonto map reflectorsusing long offsetswherethey cannot be fol-
PARTITIONING AT AN INTERFACE
78
1.0
1.0
7
.7
(,
o . E. u z u .
E U z U
o < 4
.1
.1
0
30
40
50
60
70
ANGLEOF]NCIDENCE (b)
1 0 4.0
3.0
(,
t.0
t U z u o U F
t I U z U 7 o uJ F o uJ
.9 .6 7 6
o u
J
J L
U t (L (L
uJ c
2 .1
,l 0
0
30
4C
50
60
70
ANGLEOF INCIDENCE (c)
A N G L EO F I N C I D E N C E (d)
F i g . 3 . 2 P a r t i t i o n i n g o f e n e r g y b e l w e e n t r a n s m i t t e da n d r e flected waves as a function of angle of incidence for the case of an incident P-wave. (From Tooley, Spencer,and Sagoci, 1965, e x c e p t ( c ) f r o m D e n h a m a n d P a l m e i r a , 1 9 8 4 . )( a ) C a s e w h e r e t h e v e l o c i t yi n t h c i n c i d e n tm e d i u m i s l a r g e r ;o , / u , - 0 . 5 , p . / p , 0 . 8 . o , - 0 . 3 , a n d o . - 0 . 2 5 . ( b ) C a s ew h e r e t h e v e l o c i t y i n t h e
i n c i d e n t m e d i u m i s s m a l l e r ;a , l a , : 2 . 0 , p . / p , - 0 . 5 , o , : 0 . 3 , and rr, - 0.25. (c) Fraction of energy reflected as a P-wave for v a r i o u s P - w a v ev e l o c i t y r a t i o s : p . / p , - 1 . 0 a n d o r : c r 1 : 0 . 2 5 . (d) Fraction of energy reflectedas a P-wave lor various density r a t i o s a n d o . / o , - 1 . 5a n d o , : o . - 0 . 2 5 .
lowedat short offsets(Meissner,1967).As the critical angle for S-waves is approached, the transmitted S-wavefalls to zero. If we had not had a densitycontrastbut otherwrse the valueshad been as indicatedin fig. 3.2b, there would havebeen a reflectedP-waveat small incident angleswhosefractional energywould havedecreased slightly as the incident angleincreased. Figure 3.2c showsthe P-wavereflectioncoemcient for various P-wavevelocity ratios when p, : p, and or : o: : 0.25.The reflectedenergyis zero for a velocity ratio of I (no impedancecontrast)and increases both as the ratio becomeslarger than I and as it becomes smaller than L The two peaks for ct,/ct,) I occur at the critical anglesfor P- and S-waves,respectively.Figure 3.2d showsthe energyof the reflectedPwave for various density contrastswhen a,/ct, : l'5 a n do , : o , : 0 . 2 5 . Koefoed (1962)gives 100tablesof the longitudinal and transversereflectionand transmissioncoefficients and the phaseshiftsfor anglesgreaterthan the critical angle(see$2.7.5)for incident longitudinal waves.
3.4 Variation of amplitude with angle (AVA) eqs.(3.3)to (3.6),conThe four Zoeppritzequations, tain four unknowns, At, Bp A., and -Br. Dividing through by ln, we can solvefor the four reflectionand transmissioncoemcientsR, : A,l Au, R" : BrlAu, rule T, : A,l An,and Q : BrlA6,usingeitherCramer's (eq. (15.3b))or matrices(eq. (15.22)).Aki and Richards (1980:chap. 5) derivedexpressionsfor thesefor P- and S-wavesincident on each of the five combinations of solid, fluid, and vacuum half-spaces.The expressionsare, however,quite complex. In the following, we assumethat Ap/p, Act/c, and AB/p are all small, p, cr, and B being averages(note that Ao/o neednot be small;seeproblem 3.10).These conditionsare satisfiedfor almost all sedimentarysituationswhereRo < 0.2 (R0is the reflectioncoefficient at normal incidence);in this case,the changesin the raypath direction are small. To show this we let 0, : e, + 40, 0 : (0, + gr)12: 0,;then sin 0, : sin (0, + Ae; : tin 0, cos A0 * cos0, sin A0 : sin 0, * A0 cos0,.
VARIATION OF AMPLITUDE WITH ANGLE (AVA) By using Snell'slaw: sin Orlsin0, = 1 + A0 cot 0 - crlo, - (ar + Act)/ct'- I + Ac/q, so A0 : (Ac/ct)tan0. Aki and Richards (1980:eq. (5.44))expand the terms in the exact expressionsfor the reflectionand transmissioncoefficientsfor a P-wave incident on a solid-solid interface,assumingthat the squaresand products of differentials are sufficiently small that they can be dropped. For the reflectedand transmitted P-waves,they get
-.(l],,,',; R,::[, +.i-",(*) -'(9,''.'(T)],
(3,e)
^ J : ^ Jj a+, ( , _ , : ^ ) 1, Substitutinginto eq. (3.18)and dividing by R,,,we have R , , l R , , : | + P s i n 2 0+ Q ( t a n : o- s i n : o ) , whereR,,: (Act/cr+ L,plp)|2from eq. (3.14),
(^ ) '
:
Ao/o
- zorl , -
I
Ao
n"tf--r'
(3.20)
I
Ao,Ap ,,Ap/p T
cr
I
p
T
Aa/o
The last term in eq. (3.20) is almost alwayspositive and thus increasesR" at very largeanglesofincidence (> 30'), but it is small for the anglesusuallyinvolved
(3'21)
Hilterman (private communication) rewrites eq. (3.20)in the form r
l t:
'l
R o = R n l ' - o f P,li n , e l(*.r 0- o" ) .' s i n 2 o \"/ [ J
* ^,o;
Theseequationsare valid when (a) Act/o, AB/B, and Ip/p are small(hence,A0 and AE are also small),(b) e < 80'if ct"( ct,,or (c) 0 < l0o if cr,) ct,.Hilterman (privatecommunication)believes condition(c) can be relaxedto 0 < 0, - 10" if o, ) (I,, where0, is the criticalangle.The form of the equationsallowsone to seethe separateeffectsof changesin density and Por S-wavevelocities,which are difficult to seefrom the exactexpressions. Equation(3.18)is frequentlyused to find the amplitude variation with offset (AVO) for reflectedP-waves. Shuey(1985)decidedthat Poisson's ratio was the elasticconstantmost directly relatedto the variation of R,, with 0, and thereforeusedeq. (2.60)to replace B with o. Takingthe log of eq. (2.60)and differentiatins. we have
+ Q)(l l - o
R"/Ro-l+Pg' '
(3,8)
r,:' ;(^f). (l*"u ') (:)
, : f n- o '
in reflectionseismology. The middle term in eq. (3.20) governsRp at intermediate angles;this term can have either sign and it is mainly the factor Ao/Ro that determines whether Rp decreasesor increaseswith 0. R. can changesign with increasing0 if the middle term in eq. (3.20) has polarity opposite to that of Ro. In some young clastic sections,Ap/p - -Act/o, which causescalculationdifficulties.For 0 < 30', eq. (3.20) can be further simplified(Shuey,1985:612) to
[,"",,
- . (l)' ,,",r]. 1322a1
where most of the dependenceon o is in the middle term. The relativecontributionsof the three terms in eq.(3.22a)are shownin fig. 3.3 for one situation.Hilterman further approximateseq. (3.22a)as R" = Rncos20+ 2.25Ao sin' 0.
(3.22b)
Ostrander (1984) applied theseresultsto practical cases (fig. 3.4). The reflection coefficient becomes more negative with increasing incident angles (fig. 3.4b)and vice versa(fig. 3.4c).For practicalreflection cases,three possibleresultsexist: l. For little changein Poisson'sratio (fig. 3.4a), the amplitudedecreases with increasingincident angle regardlessof the polarity of the reflectioncoefficient. For (a) a positivereflectioncoefficientand an increasein Poisson'sratio (which is apt to be true for a gas/watercontact or the baseof a gas sand embeddedin shale),or (b) a negative reflection coefficient and decreasein Poisson'sratio (which is apt to be true for the top of a gas sand embeddedin shale),the amplitude increaseswith incident angle. -). F-or(a) a positivereflectioncoemcientand a decreasein Poisson'sratio, or (b) a negative reflectioncoemcientand an increasein Poisson'sratio, the amplitudedecreases with incident angle at first and then the waveformreversespolarity and the amplitude increases with oppositepolarity. This is apt to be true for high-impedancereservorrs. Where a porous sandstoneencased in shale is water-saturated,Poisson'sratio is apt to be slightly smaller for sand than for shale, but when the pore spaceis filled with gas,Poisson'sratio for sandstoneis apt to be much smallerthan for shale.Consequently, the variation of amplitude with angle of incidence (AVA) is often regardedas a hydrocarbon indicator
Offset g
Offset
Offset
2.O
2.5
3.0
3.5
(a)
(b)
Fig. 3.3 Contribution of the three terms in eq. (3 22a) as a function of offset, for data from a well ollshorc Vermillion Pari s h " L o u i s i a n a .( a ) , ( b ) , a n d ( c ) r e f e r t o t h e f i r s t . s e c o h d 'a n d
(c)
third terms. respectively.(Courtesy ol Geophysioal Development Co.)
z
2
= 9
:==:I-:l
o
A N G T CO ' I N C I D € N C-I
z
o 2 o
(a) Fig. 3.4 Variation of a P-wave reflection coefficient with angle ofincidenceF . o r c u r v e sl , c t r l o , : p r l p , : 1 . 2 5 ; f o r 2 , l . l l ; f o r 3, 1.0; lor 4, 0.9; and for 5, 0.8. (From Ostrander, 1984.)(a) No change in Poisson'sratio at the interface (solid curves, or : o: :
0.3; dashed, or - o: : 0.2). (b) Decreasing Poisson's ratio ( s o l i d ,o , : 0 . 4 , o . - 0 . 1 ; d a s h e d ,o ' = 0 ' 3 , o z : 0 . 1 ) . ( c ) I n creasing Poisson'sratio (solid, o, : 0.1, o, : 0.4; dashed. o, 0 . 1 .o " : 0 . 2 ) .
HEAD WAVES
I
81
($10.8).A common situation in young clastic sediments (the "bright-spot" case,$10.8)is for a sand to have an acousticimpedancenearly the same as surrounding shale when liquid-filled but a much lower acoustic impedancewhen gas-filled.The result is a strong negativereflection marking the top of a gas sand and a strong positive reflection at the base (or at the fluid contact betweenthe gas- and liquid-filled portions); both reflectionsthen increasein amplitude with incident angle, as shown in fig. 3.5. However, changesin parametervaluescan alter theseresponses. Poisson'sratio can changewhere no reservoiris pres-
gf-
x' _--_4 ,
P
z g I
O
cofiPUt€o o.o OBSTRVED GAs SANO
lt lt ul
o o z 9
V2Lt
(b)
o.2
o.l
F
o
UI ll. lrJ E o.o l-
-/-.t' -t+*-
- - corr PUIED €+c oBs€RvED W A T T RS A N D **o--;-t*--F'u-ct-=.oTi
|000
231?
3624
4936
0t = 59'26'
5756
oFFSET (FEET) Fig. 3.5 Variation of amplitude with offset for a gas sand and a water sand. (From Yu, 1985.)
ent and also whereonly a little gas is present,so that an AVO anomaly does not necessaryindicatea com_ mercial reservoir.The measurementof AVO is also lraught with measurementand processingdifficulties (see Castagnaand Backus, 1993; Allen and peddv.
r993).
3.5 Head waves In refraction seismology,we make use of wavesthat havebeenrefractedat the critical angle(figs.3.6aand 3.6b); thesewavesare calledheadwaves,conical waves, or merely "refractions." The name ',conical waves" arisesbecausethe wavefrontsobtainedwhen we rotate fig. 3.6b about the vertical axis OL are conical surfaces generatedby wavefronts such as RO Head waveswerefirst postulatedby Mohorovi6i6in 1909to explain earthquakeobservations. In fig. 3.6a, we see a p-wave incident on the refracting horizon at the critical angle 0,. After refraction, it travels along the interface in the lower medium. This producesan oscillatorymotion parallel to and immediatelybelow the interface(as shown by the double-headedarrow just below the interface). Becauserelative motion betweenthe two media is not possible,the upper medium is forcedto move in phase with the lower medium. The disturbancein the upper medium travels along the interface with the same ve_ locity Vrasthe refractedwavejust below the interface.
Fig. 3.6 Head waves.(a) Motion at the interface; (b) wavefront emerging from relractor at the critical angle; (c) changes rn beam width upon refraction.
Let us assumethat thesedisturbancesrepresentedby the arrows reach point p in fig. 3.6b at time l. According to Huygens'principle,p then becomesa cen_ ter from which a wavespreadsout into the upper medium. After a further time interval Ar, this wavehas a radius of ( At whlle the wave moving along the refractor has reached Q, PQbeingequal to Il [t. Draw_ ing the tangent from Q to the arc of radius l( A,t, we obtain the wavefront RQ. Hence, the passageof the refracted wave along the interface in the lower me_ dium generatesa plane wave traveling upward in the upper medium at the angle 0, where
sin0 : t(AtlryLt : V,lU Thus, we seethat 0 : 0. so that the two inclined portions of the path are symmetricallydisposedwith respectto the normal to the refractor. In $3.1.4,we showedthat the energycarried by a wave was proportional to the cross-sectionof the beam; however,the beam width of the wave from M to Q in fig. 3.6b is zero, so head wavesshould have zero energy density and therefore should not exist. However,head wavesdo exist and frequently are very strong.The apparentconflict betweentheory and observationis due to the assumptionthat the sourceis at infinity so that the incident wave is plane. For a sourceat a finite distancefrom the interface,the incident wave is spherical and the situation is changed dramatically. The propagationof sphericalwavesin layeredme-
PARTITIONING AT AN INTERFACE
82
summarize the mathematics involved and Bortfeld (1962a,1962b)givessolutionsfor specialcases. The numbersand types of head wavespredictedby Cagniard'sresultsdependupon the relativevaluesof the velocities.Figure 3.7 showsthe head wavesfor an incident P-wave for two cases:(a) P, ) o, and (b) o, ) 9, > 9,. In the first case,five head wavesexist, the maximum possiblenumber; four are in the upper medium. one in the lower. In the secondcase,there are two head wavesin the upper medium and one in the lower. Problems 3.1 Derive the following results: (a) The displacementsof a free surfacefor an incident P-waveof amplitude lu are ulAo: lzlQn + n)l(la sin 0 * cos E)e:'o' 'r, \\tlAo: t-zlQn + n)l(n cos 0 + sin E) si'@' tt' wherem : (9/o)tan 26 and 4 : (a/B)cos26/sin 20. (Hint: The displacementsof a free surfaceare not restricted,so eqs.(3.3)and (3.4)haveno meaning'Set B r i n e q s .( 3 . 5 )a n d ( 3 . 6 )a n d e x p r e s rs, la n d Ar:0: w in termsof A,l AnandBrlAo.) (b) For normal incidenceon a free surface, ulAn: 0,
w lA , ' : - 2
(z: 0).
(c) At the free surfaceof a solid, where0 : 45", cr : 3 km/s, B/a : l/{i; then u l A o: 1 ' 7 9 3 '
wlAu: -l'035'
(d) At the surfaceof the ocean, ulAo: 0' (b) Fig. 3.7 Head waves. (After Cagniard, 1962.) (a) At an interface where o, ( pr; (b) at an interface where ct, > 9, > 9'.
dia has been discussedby many writers. Sommerfeld (1909)dealt with the propagationof electromagnettc wavesgeneratedby a sourceat an interfaceand with a sourceabovethe interface(Sommerfeld,1949:237 46). Joosand Teltow (1939)showedthat Sommerfeld's resultsappliedto elasticwaves.Jeffreys(1926)was the first to show clearly that the waveequationpredicted the existenceof head waves.Ewing, Jardetzky,and Press(1957:$3.3)used Sommerfeld'sresultsto develop the theory ofhead waves. The most completeaccountof headwavesis that of Cagniard (1962). He assumed a source giving a displacementof (l/r;srt*--') and usedLasteady-state place transform theory ($15.3)to obtain solutionsof the waveequationin terms of complexintegrals;convolution ($9.2)then givessolutionsfor other types of inputs.The mathematicsinvolvedis very complexand we evaluationof the integralsis difficult; nevertheless, regard the problem of the existenceof head wavesas resolved.Grant and West(1965:$6'3)and Dix (1954)
w l A o : - 2 c o s0 '
per(an incident ,SF1-component 3.2 For an ,SF/-wave pendicularto the paperin fig. 3.I ), write the boundary conditionsand find the amplitudesof all reflectedand refractedwaves.The absenceof P-wavesis important in S-wavestudies. 3.3 (a) Derive Knott's equationsand Zoepprtiz' equa' tions for a P-waveincident on a liquid solid interface when the incident wave is (i) in the liquid and (ii) in the solid. (b) Calculatethe amplitudeof the reflectedand transmitted P- and S-waveswhere an incident P-wave strikesthe interfacefrom a water layer (o : 1.5 km/s, B : 0, p = 1.0 g/cm3)at 20'when the seafloor is (i) "soft" (a : 2.0 km/s, : l'0 km/s, p : 2.0 glcm3): P "hard" (o : 4.0 km/s, : 2.5 km/s, p: 2.5 and (ii) B g/cm3). (c) Repeatpart (b) for an angleof incidenceof 30'. 3.4 Derive the Zoeppritz equations for an incident SZ-waveand (b) an incident Sf/-wave. 3.5 Show that the maximum amplitudeof an incident waveand its reflectionat the surfaceof the oceanoccurs at the depth \/(4 cos 0), where 0 is the angle of incidence,by expressingpressureI in the form used in eq. (3.2)and applyingappropriateboundary conditions.
i
REFERENCES
83
Surfaceofearth, S V:0.60
Geophone
km/s, p : 1.45g/cmr,thickness: 10 m, absorptioncoef. = 0.45 dB/\ Base of near-surfacelayer, A Source
V : 2.40 km/s, p : 2.35 glcml,thickness: 600 m, absorptioncoef. = 0.30 dB/tr Interface B V:3.20
kn/s, p : 2.68 glcm3,thickness: 800 m, absorptioncoef. = 0.25 dB/\ lnterface C V : 3.40 km/s, p -- 2.70 glcm3
Fig. 3.8
A layered model,
3.6 (a) Using eq. (2.56)to representa planewaveincident on a plane interface,show that a complex coefficientof reflection,R: a * jb, a, + b2< l, R being definedby eq. (3.14),correspondsto a reductionin amplitude by the factor (a2+ 6z7rtz and an advancein phaseby tan | (bla). (b) Show that an imaginaryangleof refraction,0, (see S2.7.5)in eqs.(3.3)to (3.6)leadsto a complexvalue of R, and henceto phaseshifts. 3.7 Calculate the reflection and transmission coefficients,R and 7 of eqs. (3.14) and (3.15),for a sandstone-shale interfacefor the following: ( a ) V " " : 2 . 4 3 , V " h : 2 . 0 2 k m / s ,p , " : 2 . 0 8 , a n d p . , : 2.23 glcm3; ( b ) V , " : 3 . 3 5 ,V " h : 3 . 1 4k m / s ,p " .: 2 . 2 1 ,a n d p , , : 2.52 glcm3 (c) What are the correspondingvaluesin nepersand in decibels? 3.8 Assumehorizontal layering,as shown in fig. 3.8, and a sourcejust below interfacel. (a) Calculate(ignoring absorptionand divergence)the relative amplitudes and energy densitiesfor the primary reflectionsfrom B and C and the multiples(see $6.3.2)BSA, BAB, and BSB (wherethe lettersdenote the interfacesinvolved).Compare traveltimes,amplitudes,and energydensitiesof thesefive events. (b) Recalculatefor l5- and75-Hz wavesallowins for absorption. (c) Recalculate amplitudes for the l5-Hz wave allowing also for divergence.Normalize valuesby letting the divergenceeffectsof reflection.Bbe unity. (d) Summarizeyour conclusionsregarding(i) the relative importanceof multiples versusprimariesand (ii) the relativeimportanceof differentattenuationmechanlsms. 3.9 Show that when angles in the Zoeppritz equations,eqs.(3.3)to (3.6),are small(so that the squares and productsare negligible), eqs.(3.14)and (3.15)are stillvalid and
B,: ]WL!+a2,, Ao (Iryt+ Wr)(Z,* Zr)' B, : ,2W9 12{ Ao (Wt + Wr)(Z,t Zr)' 4:2,02-2r0,, r:WFr_W2. 3.10 In 93.4,we statedthat Aolo is not necessarily smallwhenAa/ct,AB/B,andAp/pareall small;verify thisstatement. (Hint: Useeq.(2.60).) 3.11 How wouldyou recalibrate the scaleto change a plot showingamplitudevariationwith offset(AVO) into a plot of amplitudevariationwith angle(AVA)? Whatwill betheeffectif velocityincreases with depth? Referenecs Aki, K., and P. G. Richards. 1980. Quantitative Seismology: Theory and Methods, Yol. l. San Francisco: W H. Freeman. Allen, J. L., and C. P. Peddy. 1993. Amplitude Variation with Ofsetes: Gulf Coast Slndres. Tulsa: Society of Exploration Geophysicists. Bortfeld, R. 1962a.Exact solution ofthe reflection and refraction ofarbitrary sphericalcompressionalwavesat liquid-liquid interfacesand at solid-solid interfaceswith equal sh-earvelocities and equal densities.Geophys.prosp.. l0z i5 67. Bortfeld, R. 1962b.Reflection and refraction of soherical compressional wavesat arbitrary plane interfaces.Geophy.r.prosp., l0:517-38. Cagniard, L.1962. Reflection and Refraction of progressive Seismic Waves, E. A. Flynn and C. H. Dix, trans. New york: McGraw-Hill. Costagna, J. P., and M. M. Backus. 1993. Oflset-DependentReTheory and Practice oJ AVO,lniiysis. Tulsa: Society fectivity of Exploration Geophysicists. Denham, L. R., and R. A. R. Palmeira. 1984.Discussion on reflection and transmission of plane compressional waves. Geophvsics. 49l.2195.
84 Dix, C. H. 1954.The methodof Cagniardin seismicpulseproblems. Geop hysi cs, 19: 722-38. Ewing,W. M., W. S.Jardetzky,and F. Press.1957,Elastic Waves in LayeredMedic. New York: McGraw-Hill. Grant, F. S., and G. F. West. 1965.InterpretationTheoryin ApNew York: McGraw-Hill. plied Geophysics. Jeffreys,H. 1926.On compressionalwavesin two superposed layers.Proc Camb.Phil. Soc.,22:,472-81. Joos,G., and J. Teltow.1939.2,lr Deutung der Knallwellenausbreitung an der Trennschichtzweier Medien. Physik Z.' 40: 289-93. Knott, C. G. 1899.Reflexionand refractionof elasticwaveswith Phil Mag.,8:64 97. applications: seismological Koefoed,O. 1962.Reflectionand transmissioncoefficientsfor Prosp.,l0:. 304-5I . planelongitudinalincident waves.Geophys. Meissner,R. 1967.Exploringdeepinterfacesby seismicwideProsp.,15: 598-617. Geophys. anglemeasurements.
PARTITIONING AT AN INTERFACE Ostrander,W. J. 1984.Plane-wavereflectioncoefficientsfor gas sands at nonnormal angles of incidence. Geophysics,49" 163748. Shuey,R. T. 1985.A simplificationof the Zoeppritz equations. 50: 609-14. Geophysics, Sommerfeld,A. 1909.Uber die Ausbreitungder Wellen in der drahtlosenTelegraphie.Ann. Phys.,28: 665J 36. Sommerfeld,A. 1949.Partial DifferentialEquationsin Physics. New York: AcademicPress. and H. F. Sagoci.1965.Reflection Tooley,R. D., T. W.,Spencer, and transmissionof plane compressionalwaves.Geophysics, 30: 552-70. Yu, G. 1985. Offset-amplitudevariation and controlled50t 2697-708. amplitudeprocessing.Geophysics, Zoeppritz,K. 1919.Uber reflexionund durchgangseismischer VII WelGn durch Unstetigkerlsfliischen.Uber Erdbebenwellen det Wissenschaften B, Nachrichtender Ki)niglichenGesellschaft Math. Phys.,Kl: 57-84. zu Gdttingen,
4
Geometry of seismic wayes
Overview This chapter uses a geometrical-opticsapproach to derive the basic relationshipsbetweentraveltimeand the locations of reflecting/refractinginterfaces,most structuralinterpretationrelieson such an approach. The accurateinterpretation of reflection data re_ quires a knowledgeof the velocity at all points along the reflectionpaths. However,even if we had such a detailed knowledge of the velocity, the calculations would be tedious;often we assumea simple distribu_ tion of velocitythat is closeenoughto give useable results.The simplestassumption,which is made in \4.1, is that the velocityis constantbetweenthe surfaceand the reflectingbed.Although this assumption is rarely even approximatelytrue, it leads to simple formulasthat giveanswersthat are within the requiied accuracyin many instances. The basicproblem in reflectionseismicsurveyingis to determinethe positionof a bed that givesrisero a reflectionon a seismicrecord. In genelal.this is a problem in three dimensions.However,the dip is of_ ten very gentle and the direction of profiling is fre_ quentlynearlyalong eitherthe directionof dip or the directionof strike.In such cases,a two-dimensional solution is generally used. The arrival time-versusoffsetrelationfor a plane reflectorand constantvelocity is hyperbolic.The distanceto the reflectorcan be found from the reflection arrival time at the source point if the velocity is known. The variation of arrival time as a geophoneis moved away from the source, called normal moveout, providesthe most important criterion for identifying reflectionsand a method of determining velocity. The dip is found from differ_ encesin arrival times of a reflectionat different loca_ tions after correctionfor normal moveout:dio moveout is relatedto dip and alsoto the angleof approach of wavefrontsat the surfaceand to apparentvelocity. Reflectiordip and strike can be found from the componentsof dip moveout at the intersectionof seismic lines.Reflectingpoints move updip as source-receiver offset increases,so that the traces in a commonmidpoint gather do not have common reflectins points. Section4.2 dealswith reflectionraypathswherevelocity changesvertically;this resultsin changesin ravpath direction.One solutionin somesituaiionsis io use equivalentaveragevelocity.For parallel velocity layers,the slope of the traveltimecurve gives(in the 6)
limit as x -+ 0) the root-mean-square(rms) velocity. Vertical velocity is often expressedas a function of arrival time or depth. Where velocity is linear with depth, wavefrontsare sphericaland raypathsare arcs of circles,facts that can be usedin graphicalplotting ol depth sections. Section 4.3 concerns the geometry of head-wave pathsas usedin refractionexploration.In most cases. we assumea seriesof beds,each having a consranr velocity, the velocity increasingor *. go to deeper beds,and then we deriveformulas relatingtraveltime, offset,depth, dip, and velocities.The casesconsidered include a single horizontal refractor, several horizontal refractors,and a singledipping refractor. Velocities can be found from slopesof the traveltimeversus-offsetcurves, depths from the intercepts of projections to the source point, and dip from the differencesin depth at two sourcelocations.Wherevelocity increaseswith depth, diving waveseventually return to the surfaceeven where reflectionis not in_ volved. Refraction paths in the case of a linear rn_ creasein oveiburdenvelocity are also considered.
4.1 Reflection paths for constant velocity 4.1.I Horizontalreflectot normal moveout The simplesttwo-dimensionalproblem is that of zero dip illustrated in the lower part of fig. 4.1. The reflecting bed, AB, is at a depth I below sourceS. Energy leavingS along the direction SC will be reflected in such a direction that the angle of reflectionequals the angleofincidence. Although the reflectedray CR can be determined by laying off an angle equal to a at C, it is easierto luseimagepoinr { which is locatedon the samenormal to the reflectoras S and as far below the bed as S is above.If we join I to C and prolong the straight line to R, CR is the reflectedray (becauseCD is parallel to S{ making all the anglesmarked a equal). Denoting the averagevelocity by ( traveltimeI for the reflected wave is (SC + CR)IV. However, SC : C1, so that 1R is equal in length to the actual path, SCR. Therefore, I : INV and in terms of x, the source-to-geophone distance(ofset), we can write
Ltzlz:yzq47z,
(4.1)
GEOMETRY OF SEISMIC WAVES
86
v2t2l4h2_x2l4h2:1.
(4.2)
Thus, the traveltimecurve is a hyperbola,as shown in the upper part offig. 4.1. The geophoneat R will also record the direct wave, which travelsalong the path SR. BecauseSR is always lessthan SC + CR, the direct wave arrivesfirst. The traveltimeis /, : xlV and the traveltime curves are the straightlines OM and ON passingthrough the orig i n w i t h s l o p e so f t l / Z When distancex becomesvery large,the difference betweenSR and ,SC + CR becomessmall, and the reflection traveltime approaches the direct-wave traveltimeasymptotically. The location of the reflectingbed is determinedby measuring /,,, the traveltime for a geophone at the sourcepoint.Settingx : 0 in eq. (4.1)' we seethat
I : lvt,. Equation (4.l) can be written f - x2lv2 + 4h2lv2: x2lV2 * ti.
(4.3)
(4.4)
If we plot 12againstx2 (insteadof / versusx, as in fig. 4.1), we obtain a straightline of slope l/22 and intercept ri. This forms the basis of a well-known " schemefor determining V the X1 - T2 method"; this will be describedin $5.4.4a. We can solveeq. (a.l ) for t, the traveltimemeasured on the seismicrecord. Generally 2ft is appreciably largerthan x, so that we can usea binomial expansion ( $ 1 5 . 1 . 4 ca)s f o l l o w s : + (xl2h)' ltt' : /0[l + (xlVt)2lt'' t : Qhlnl (4.5) : /0u + t{xtVtJ, -'U{xlVto'So + . . .1. lf t. t., x,, and x, are two traveltimesand offsets,we haveto the first approximation Lt : t, - t, = (xl - x])l2Vrt,,.
(4.6)
In the special case where one geophone is at the sourcepoint, At is known as the normal moveout (NMO), which we shall denoteby Lt,*o. Lt rro - x2l2V2tu: x2l4Vh'
(4.7)
At times,we retain anotherterm in the expansion(see alsoproblem4.lc): Ltfiro:
x2l2v2t,,- xalSvatl : (v2l2V' t)[l - (xl4h)' ].
(4.8)
From eq. (4.7), we note that the normal moveout increasesas the squareof the offsetx, inverselyas the squareof the velocity,and inverselyas the first power of the traveltime(or depth - seeeq. (4.3)).Thus, reflection curvatureincreasesrapidly as we go to more distant geophones;at the sametime, the curvaturebecomesprogressivelylesswith increasingrecord time. The concept of normal moveout is extremelyimportant. It is the principal criterion by which we de-
\
l-) I
Fig. 4. I
Traveltime curve for a horizontal
reflector
cide whetheran eventobservedon a seismicrecord is a reflectionor not. If the normal moveoutdiffersfrom the valuegivenby eq.(4.7)by more than the allowable experimentalerror, we are not justified in treating the eventas a reflection.One of the most important quantities in seismicinterpretationis the changein arrival time causedby dip; to find this quantity,we must eliminate normal moveout.Normal moveoutmust also be "stacking" (adding together) eliminated before common-midpoint records (see $8.3.3).Finally, eq. (4.7) can be used to find Z by measuringx, /n, and Lt *rr,,, this forms the basis of the Z-Aln method of findingvelocity(see$5.4.4b)and alsoof velocityanalysis ($9.7).Brown (1969) discussesrefinementsto handle dip and long offset. 4.1.2 Dipping reflector;dip moveout When the bed is dipping in the direction of the profile, we havethe situationshownin fig.4.2, { beingthe dip, and /r the distancenormal to the bed. To draw the raypath for the reflectionarriving at geophoneR, we join imagepoint 1to R by a straight line, cutting the bed at C. The path is then SCR, and t is equal to (SC + CR)IV;becauseSC + CR : 1R, applicationof the cosinelaw to triangle S1Rgives V2f :
JR2
: x2 + 4h' - 4hxcos(ln + i) : x2 * 4h2+ 4hx sin l.
(4.e)
REFLECTION PATHS FOR CONSTANT VELOCITY
87
On completingthe squares,we obtain
- (x + 2h sin {), (2h"* €F (2h cosO' V2t2
= l.
Thus, as before,the traveltimecurve is a hyperbola, but the axis of symmetry is now the line x : -2h x sin { instead of the l-axis. This means that r has different values for geophonessymmetricallyplaced on opposite sidesof the sourcepoint,unlike the case for zero dip. Settingx equalto 0 in eq. (4.9)givesthe samevalue for ft as in eq. (4.3); note, however,that h is not measured vertically as it was in the earlier result. We call points C, C' , C" in fi5. 4.2, where the anglesof incidenceand reflectionare equal,reflectingpoinls.(These are sometimecalled "depth points," but this term is also usedfor the point on the surfacemidwaybetween sourceand receiver;we call the latter a midpoint, and to avoid confusion we shall avoid the term "depth point.") The updip displacementof reflectingpoints compared to midpoints for dipping reflectorsis important in migrating data (99.10.2)and in the common-midpointmethod(98.3.3). To obtain the dip, (, we solve for I in eq. (4.9) by assumingthat 2h is greaterthan x and expandingas in the derivationof eq. (4.5).Then
'!(,*"'* 111''" g) v\ 4h, )
,."\(, *
x' + 4ftr sint).
th '
(4.10)
I
using only the first term of the expansion.The srmplestmethodof finding t is from the differencein traveltimes for two geophonesequally distant from and on oppositesidesof the source.Letting .r in fig. 4.2 havethe values*Ax for the downdip geophoneand -Ar for the updip geophoneand denotingthe equivalent traveltimesby l, and /,, we get
''" ,], r - r. * (Ar)';f,o" [r r. - r.
+
(44'-
8h2
[r at,,: t,-
4h A x s," ,]
/A" 'in €\ I. : ,.
\
o
)-
2a'x
nsrnt'
Dip { is given by
sin{-:r(,4*)
(4.r1)
The quantity L,tolAxis calledrhedip moveout.(Note that dimensionally, dip moveout is time/distance, whereas normal moveout is time. Note also that
Fig. 4.2
Traveltime curve for a dipping reflector
DMO or dip-moveoutprocessingt$9.10.21 involves different concepts.)For small angles,{ is approximatelyequalto sin (, so that the dip is directly proportional to A/, under thesecircumstances. To obtain the dip as accuratelyas possible,we use as large a value of Ax as the data quality permits; for symmetrical spreads(S8.3.1), we measuredip moveoutbetweenthe geophonegroups at the opposite ends of the spread, Ax then beinghalf the spreadlength. Dip moveout can also be measuredby the time difference between 1,,at different sourcepoints.As shownin fig. 4.3, A/u : /,,,- /,,,and
sin{ : I;, (u. U*),
(4.12)
whereAx is the distancebetweensourcepoints.When we measuredip on a recordsection($8.8.3), Ax is the distancebetweenany two convenientpoints. It should be noted that normal moveout was eliminated in the derivationof eq. (4.ll). The terms in (Ax)' that disappearedin the subtractionrepresentthe normal moveout. Figure 4.4 illustratesdiagrammaticallythe relation betweennormal moveout and dip moveout.Diagram (l) representsa reflection from a dipping bed; the alignment is curved and unsymmetrical about the sourcepoint. Diagram (B) shows what would have been observedif the bed had been horizontal; the alignment is curved symmetricallyabout the source position owing to the normal moveout. The latter rangesfrom 0 to 13 ms (l millisecond: 10-3s = I ms, the unit of time commonly usedin seismicwork) at an offset of 400 m. Diagram (O was obtained by subtractingthe normal moveoutsshown in (B) from the arrival timesin (A).The resultingalignmentshows
88
GEOMETRY OF SEISMIC WAVES
tr.,: \/sin a:
2rk",
(4.13b)
where L" is the apparentwavelength,and r"l2r the apparentwavenumber. Equation(4.13a)is somewhatsimilar to eqs.(4.I I ) and (a.l2), but it has a different significance,becauseit givesthe direction of travel of a planewaveas it reachesthe spread,Vbeingthe velocity between C and the surface. In eqs. (4.11) and (4.12), V is the averagevelocity (54.2.2)down to the reflector,and ( is the angle of dip. Becausesin o can be very small, the apparent velocity \ (and L,) can be very large, and for energyapproachingvertically,
4: *'
Fig.4.3 Geometry involvedin dip moveout measured between sourcepolnts or on recordsections. the effect of dip alone; it is straight and has a time differencebetweenthe outside curves of l0 ms, that is, A/, : l0 ms when Ax : 400 m. Thus, we find that t h e d i p i s 2 5 0 0 ( 1 0x l 0 - Y 8 0 0 ): 0 . 0 3 1r a d : . 1 . 8 ' . The method of normal-moveoutremovalillustrated in fig. 4.4 was usedto demonstratethe differencebetween normal moveout and dip moveout. If we require only the dip moveout, Lto, we merely subtract the traveltimesfor the two outsidegeophonesin (l). Frequently,we do not have a symmetricalspread and we find the dip moveoutby removingthe effectof normal moveout. As an example, refer to fig. 4.4, curve (D), which shows a reflection observedon a spreadextendingfrom x : -133 m to n : +400 m. L e t / , ,: 1 . 2 2 5s , t r : 1 . 2 2 3s , t , : 1 . 2 4 2s , a n d Z : 2800 mis. From eq. (4.7), we get for Atrro at offsets of 133and 400 m, respectively, the values I ms and 8 ms (rounded off to the nearestmillisecond because this is usually the precision of measurementon seismic records).Subtractingthesevalues,we obtain for the correctedarrivaltimes /, : 1.222and t,: 1.234: hence,the dip moveoutis l2l(53312)ms/m. The correspondingdip is ( : 2800(12x l0 V533) : 0.063 rad : 3.6'. An alternativeto the precedingmethod is to usethe arrival times at 133m and x : +133 m, thus obtaining a symmetricalspread and eliminating the needfor calculatingnormal moveout.However,doing this would decreasethe effectivespread length from 533 m to 266 m and thereby reduce the accuracyof the ratio (L,tolL,x). The apparentvelocity V. of a wavefront is the ratio of the distance(Ax) betweentwo points on a surface (usually,the surfaceof the ground) to the difference in arrival times (Al) for the same event at the two points. It is given by V , : L , x l L t : V J s i na ,
(a.l3a)
where o is the angle of approach(fig. 4.5); o is sometimes calledapparentdip. We can divide this equation by the frequency to give
4.1.3 Cross-dip When the profile is at an appreciableangle to the direction of dip, the determinationof the latter becomes a three-dimensionalproblem and we usethe methods of solid analytical geometry.In fig. 4.6, we take the xy-planeas horizontal with the z-axisextendingvertically downward. Line OP of length ft is perpendicular to a dipping planebed that outcrops(that is, intersects the xy-plane)along line Mll if extendedsufficiently. We write 0r, 0,, 0, for the anglesbetweenOP and the x-, y-, and z-axes,and (., m, n for the direction cosines of OP The angle E between MN and the xaxis is the direction of strike of the bed while 0, : {, the angle of dip. The path of a reflectedwave arriving at geophone R on the x-axiscan be found using imagepoint L The line joining 1 to R cuts the reflectorat Q; hence,OQR is the path. BecauseOQ : QI,line 1R is equalto Zl, t beingthe traveltimefor the geophoneat R. The coordinatesof 1 and R are respectively(2h(, 2hm,2hn) and (x, 0, 0); hence,we have p1, : : : :
(IR)2 (x - zhe)' + (0 - 2hm)' + (0 - 2hn)' x2 + 4h2(C,+ m2 i n2)* 4hh x2 + 4h'- 4hk,
because(2 * m2 + n2: I (problem15.9a). When x : 0. we obtain the samerelation between h and tuas in eq. (4.3).Proceedingas in the derivation of eq. (4.I 0), we get for the approximatevalue of /, /:ro(l+
x) - 4h(x\
8n, )
By subtracting the arrival times at two geophones locatedon the r-axis at "r : +Ar, we find
at, : t,,,((L,xlh) :2( d:cos0,
A,xlV.
- j"ffit;)
(4.14)
REFLECTION PATHS FOR CONSTANT VELOCITY
89
+400 m +383 +267 +200 + 133 +67 ,o
0 -67 -
IJJ
- 200 -26'l - 333 -400 m
Fig. 4.4 Relation between normal moveout and dip moveout. For curves (A), (B), and (Q, /" : 1.000s and Z : 2500 m/s. For
curve(D), to: 1.225s, t, = 1.22!s, t.: m/s. /is the averagevelocity.
1-242s, and I/ = 2800
(x*mylnz:h. Settingz : 0 givesthe equationofthe line ofintersection of the reflectorand the surface;this strikeline has the equation (x*mY:ft' The interceptsof this line on the x- and /-axes are hl( and hlm. Referring to fig. 4.7, we find that tan ,= : Fig. 4.5
Finding the angle of approach of a wave
: q{.14{)
If we also have a spread along the y-axis (crossspread), we get
,??: cos,r: !;, (a;;),
(4.r 5)
whereAr, is the time difference("cross-dip")between geophonesa distance 2 L,y apart and symmetrical about the source.Because ,4 : cos € : tl _ (C2+ m2)lr2 sin € :
(l
-
4z|D :
C hlm : ,,. nt( m
(C2 + m2)tt2
: ln [(o*)'* f1")'1"' (416) 2 [\Ax/ \Ayl I The componentsof dip moveout, Lt.lLx and Lt,,lL'y, are also called apparentdips. To find the strike E, we start from the equation of a plane (that is, the reflector)that has a perpendicular from the origin of length ft and direction cosines({, m, n), namely(seeproblem 15.9b),
(L,t,lA,y)
(4.r1)
Consider the case where the profile lines are not perpendicular,for example,where they are in the r, and r, directions of fig. 4.8a and the dip is in the ro direction. We expressthe dip moveout as the vector (drldx)ro: AO; the componentof dip moveouton the line in the r, directionis thus (dtldx)ro' r, : (dlldx)cos 9 : OB (seeproblem 4.2a).The converseproblem of finding the total dip moveout from measurementsof the componentsof dip moveout OB and OC can be done graphically,as shown in fig. 4.8b (seealso problem 4.2b), or mathematicallyas follows.We take one profile along the x-axis and the other along the y'-axis at an angle a to the x-axis. By taking the length of a symmetricalspread along the y'-axis as 2Ay', the coordinatesof the ends of the spread(relativeto the r-, y-axes)are * Ly' cos a, +Ay' sin o. Then V2ir*: (2h( t- Ay' cos c)2 + (2hm + Ay' sin a)2 + (2hn)2 : (Ly'), + 4h2-r 4hLy'((. cos ct + zt sin a).
GEOMETRY OF SEISMIC WAVES
90
path for a dipFig. 4.6 Three-dimensional view oi a reflection ping bed.
The dip moveoutalong this line, At'lAy', is Lt' ILY' : 2(( cosa * m sin o)/ Z
Fig.4.7
D e t e r m i n a t i o no f s t r i k e
(4' 18)
Becausect is known, { can be found from AllAr and m f r o m e q .( 4 . 1 8 ) . 4.t .4 Reflet'tionpointsfor ffiet receivers When the sourceand receiverare coincident and the velocity is constant,the locus of a reflectingpoint R for constant traveltimeas the dip ( varies is a circle (fig. 4.9a).However,when the sourceand receiverare ofset by'-x, the locus is an ellipse(fig' a'9b) with the sourceand geophoneat the foci; this follows from the : Vt is a definition oi an ellipsebecauseSR + RG given by is I traveltime the for constant.The equation (4.9), namelY, eq. (Vt)' : 4h2+ 4s2+ 8ftssin {' Expressingthis in terms of the depth at the midpoint M,h':/r*ssin{: (4'19) (Vt)' : 4(h')' + 4s2cos2{
Apparent dip 20 ms/km
(comparewith problem4.3); Levin (1971)writesthis equation: t' : 4(h')' 1V2* 4s2lV]ro,
z
2hn'
2' -l
s+h(
::
\eo
\e6-
where V*ro= Vlcos(; thus, hro> V n ng.'i."lU,the reflectionpoint R has moved updip by fR": AL. To determine AI, we find the coordinut.t 1"0,zo)and 6r, z,l of points P and. R-.Because ( ur it'putiit"l to 51' xo is s h'(' and zois.h'n' and sourcethe 2s and S'I, n being direction cosines of joing.optto'* distance.lf (x' z) is a point on the line ing l and G we must have
2' - ! :21!J]
\a
9.20)
: 1r,
hn
where k is a parameterthat fixes the location of the point (x, z) albng,IG To get k' we use the fact that IG
\-d
\a-
-
\ --
\-io
\'
- - - - t\
Fig. 4.8 Determining dip and strike from nonperpendicular O ob"r".uations. (a) Relaiion between the point of observation (b) ExO) from updip (l always is and the reflecting point,4 ample of a graPhical solution.
VERTICAL VELOCITY GRADIENT AND RAYPATH CURVATURE cuts the reflector at R, so (x, z) must satisfy the equation ofthe reflectingplane (seeproblem 15.9b): -(x*nz:h.
9l
changesfrom one velocity function to another do not necessarilyimpose a seriousburden upon the interpreter.
Substitutingthe previousvaluesfor (x, z), we get -(l2s - k(hc + s)l + n(khn) : ft,
4.2.2 Equivalentaveragevelocity
that is, k: (h + 2k)l(h + (s) : (h + 2h)lh'. Therefore, the coordinatesof R are (seeproblem 4. I l). x, - 2s - k(h( + s) : 2s - (h( + s)(lr + 2k)lh' : xo - (n2s2lh' (4.21a) , and k(hn) : (h + 2(s)(hn)lh': zu - (,2ns2lh'.
z,:
(4.21b) Finally, (AL)'
("0 -
:
x,), * (zo - z,)2 (s2lh')2((2n4 + (4n2)
:
(s2lh')2((2n2),
:
and 67 : (s' lh')sin{ cos g : (s,l2h')sin2f. G'2Ic\ If we wish to stackdata elementsthat havethe common reflectionpoint R, we have to stack updip from the midpoint by the distanceAx, where Ax : Atlcos 6 : (srlft,)sin{.
(4.22a)
The updip offsetAx changesthe zero-offsettime by A,t : 2 A,x sin llV : 2(s2lh,Z)sinr(. (4.22b) The DMO (dip moveout)correction(99.10.2) accommodatesthis updip movementof the reflectingpoint as offsetincreases. 4.2 Vertical velocity gradient and raypath curvature 4.2.1 Efec't of velocityvariation The assumptionof constant velocity is not valid in general,the velocity usually changingas we go from one point to another.In petroleumexploration,we are usually dealing with more or less flat-tying bedding and the changesin seismicvelocity as we move horizontally are for the most part small, being the result of slowchangesin densityand elasticpropertiesof the beds.Thesehorizontal variationsare generallymuch lessrapid than the variationsin the vertical direction wherewe are going from bed to bed with consequent lithological changesand increasingpressurewith increasingdepth. Becausethe horizontal changesare gradual, they can often be taken into account by dividing the surveyarea into smallerareaswithin each ofwhich the horizontal variationscan be ignoredand the same vertical velocity distribution used. Such areasare often large enough to include severalstructures of the size of interest in oil exploration so that
Vertical variations in velocity can be taken into account in various ways.One of the simplestis to use a modification of the constant-velocitymodel. We assumethat the actual sectionexistingbetweenthe surface and a certain reflectinghorizon can be replaced with an equivalentsinglelayer of constantvelocity 7 equal to the averagevelocity betweenthe surfaceand the reflectinghorizon; 7 is the equivalentaveragevelocity. This velocity is usually given as a function of depth (or of tu,which is nearly the sameexceptwhen the dip is large).Thus, the sectionis assigneda different constant velocity for each of the reflectorsbelow it. Despitethis inconsistency, the method is usefuland is extensivelyapplied.The variation ofthe averagevelocity with /,, is found using one of the methods describedin $5.4.For the observedvaluesof the arrival time to,we selectthe averagevelocityTcorresponding to this reflector; using the values of lo, the dip moveout, LtulL,x, and \ we calculatethe depth ft and the dip ( usingeqs.(4.3)and (4.I 1).
4.2.3 Velocitylayering When the velocityis constant,eq. (4.l) showsthat a graph of tr versusrr is a straight line with slopellV2. Ifthe velocityvariesin the verticaldirection,raypaths will bendas requiredby Snell'slaw (eq.(3.1)).A commonly used method to take into account vertical velocity variationsis to replacethe actualvelocitydistribution with a number of horizontal layersof different velocities, the velocity being constant within each layer. We can approximate any vertical velocity changesas closelyas desiredby using enough layers. A graphical method using a wavefront chart can be usedto find the depth and dip ofa reflectinginterface; the preparation and use of these charts will be disc u s s e di n 9 8 . 8 . 3 . In effect,we replaceactual raypathswith a seriesof line segmentsthat are straight within each layer but undergoabrupt changesin direction at the boundaries between layers. Larger portions of travelpaths are spent in the higher-velocity layers as the sourcegeophonedistanceincreases. The resultis that a graph of /2versus,r' is slightlycurved,as shownin fig. 4. l0b. Dix (1955) showedthat eq. (4.4) can still be used exceptthat the slope ofthe :r2 t2curve at x : 0 yields the inverseof the rms velocity squared,llV,2^".Weapproximate the x2-t2 curve by the straight line
t' :x2lV!^"+tfi; hence,
dtldx : xlVl^, t.
(4.23)
G E O M E T R Y O F S E I S M I C WAVES
92
- S + S +
S,G
s
G
ilrvr
(a) Fig. 4.9 Loci of reflection points for various dips. (a) Coincident source and geophone; (b) geophone offset from source.
The angleof approach,l' is given by
sini, : n,'dx + : :L V,'*,t
g'24)
using eq. (4.23). Also, writing A/, for the vertical traveltime through the ith bed, and, becausex ts small. we have
jx : : =
Ax, * Ax, : hrtan i, + h2tan v, Lt, sin l, * v, Lt.,sin i, i,lV, (4 Lt, + Vl L,tr)sin + Ltr)(x.lvh"t) (V1 Lt, Vl
from eq. (4.24) (note that x cancels here becausewe haveasiumedit to be small).Becauset - 2(L't, + Alr)' we get
i ,,o,. i't
'Vr2m s:
i
e
It
This equationcan be generalizedfor r horizontal beds (Dix, 1955),giving lz
v2
-
v 2
-+ v2
r.,
(4.2s)
(4.26)
Shah and Levin (1973)give higher-orderapproximations necessaryto get more accuracy for large values of x. Fig. 4.10 Derivation of the formula for x2-t2velocity in twolayermedium.(a) Reflectionpath. (b) xt-l2 curve(the curvature The reciprocalof the slope of the dashedline is exaggerated). (tangentto the curve at x : 0) givesthe rms velocity'The bestfit stiaight line for someportion of the curve is what is often *ru.r.tid; the slopeof this line (showndashed)is the reciprocal "stackingvelocity" of the squareof the % ($5.a.aa);it depends on the portion beingfit.
4.2.4 Effect ofvariable velocity on raypath direction Changesin the direction of rays at interfaces are determiied by Snell'slaw (eq. (3.1)).For planar parallel layering (fig. a.ll), the angle of emergencefrom a tayer equatsthe angle ofentry into the next layer and
V E R T I C A L V E L O C I T Y G R A D I E N T A N D RAYPATH CURVATURE the raypath parameter p : (sin i)lV : (sin i)lVo : ArlAx (seeeq. (4.13a))specifiesray direction,'thai is, p is constant along any ray and is fixed by the direction in which the ray left the source.Note that l/Z is the slownessandp is the component of slownessparallel to the interface,hence,the componentof slowness parallel to the interface is constant for each ray. In earthquakestudies,it is often assumedthat the earth is divided into concentric sphericalshells(layers) of constant velocity, as in fig. 4.12. In this case, the angleofentry into a layeris not equalto the angle of exit from that layer, that is, i, * it. However. becauseOP : r, sin r, : r. sin i!. uiing Snells law shows that (r, sin ir)lVr: (r, sin r.)/2,. Thus, in this case, direction can be specifiedby a raypath parameterp,.. p' : (t"sin i")|V".
4
dz
V:
I t a ni d z , I
I
t:
l
lz
l" I
PVdz
- lPvz'1trz' l. [t
-u'1"':o'""' t : l"'.o l, ;'1."r,'-oi,,r, ),"
: j f"o, ro- cost),
,:tl'
a ),"u(l -
(4.31)
. : l r -n f + ( l u-
u2)tt2 a
[l
ll'
u,1trzjl,
:;,'lffi(H3;1 :''"
tan ! i. 2 l tt,|r):
(4.32)
P:[l+(x')213/2lx',
(4.28)
,/ cos I g
where
z
J .z . o r , - - '
hence, -r ' :
.:
The parametric equations(4.31) and (4.34) give the coordinates x and z, the parameter i being related to the one-waytraveltimer by eq. (4.32)or (4.33). The raypath given by eqs. (4.31) and (4.34) is a circle; this can be shown by calculatingthe radius of curvature p, which turns out to be a constant:
V(z),
FZ
x:
V:Vo*az, where Voisthe velocity at the horizontal datum plane, Z is the velocity at a depth z below the datum plane, and a is a constant whosevalue is generallybetween 0.3/sand 1.3/s. If we introducea new variableu : pV : sin r, then du : p dV : pa dz, and we can solvefor x and t as follows (p is the raypath parameter):
i : 2 tan t(e. tan jil, (4.33) : z (V V)la: (sin i sin io)lpa. (4.34)
In the limit when n becomesinfinite, we get
dz
Sometimeswe can expressZas a continuousfunction of z and integrateeqs.(4.29)and (4.30).One caseof considerableimportanceis that of a linear increaseof velocity with depth, namely,
4 = 1Q),
A,x, : Az, tan i,, Lz' At,: \cos i,'
-:t3fl/.
4.2.5 Linear increaseof velocity with depth
hence,
: sin ro _ , V o r '
sini_sinro:, V V o r ' dx dt -
(4.30)
- (Pv7'1"'
BecauseZ is a function of z, eqs.(4.29) and (4.30) furnish two integral equationsrelatingx and r to the depth z. Theseequationscan be solvedby numerical methods when we have a table of values of Z at various depths.
(4.27)
At times,the assumptionis made that the velocity varies in a systematiccontinuousmanner and there_ fore can be representedby a velocity function. The actual.velocity usually varies extremelyrapidly over short intervals,as shown by sonic logs (see $5.a.3); however,if we integratethesechangesover distances of a wavelengthor so (30-100 m), we obtain a func_ tion that is generallysmoothexceptfor discontinuities at marked lithological changes.If the velocity discon_ tinuities are small, we are often able to representthe velocity distribution with sufficient accuracy by a smoothvelocityfunction. The path of a wavetraveling in such a medium is then determinedby two integral equations. To derivethe equations,we assumethat the medium is divided into a large number of thin bedsin each of which the velocity is constant;on letting the number of beds go to infinity, the thicknessof each bed becomes infinitesimal and the velocity distribution be_ comes a continuous function of depth. Referring to fig. 4. I l, we havefor the nth bed srl_L
,:|;,
93
(4.2e)
, :d x tan i, using eqs.(4.31) and (4.34), i: ,, d2x d. .di dl x : ;.: ;.(tanr). : sec,i oz. o, dz dz : pa sec2i,using eq. (4.34). f
94
GEOMETRY OF SEISMIC WAVES
s
F-'"--l l
\
Hence,
l
( I + tan2i)r/2 | "f I = : l lV^\ .:constant. pasec't pa \4/slnro
l
\
r
t
t
l
- - - F - J \
Fig.4.1I
l
Raypathwherevelocityvarieswith depth.
Figure 4.13 shows a ray leaving the source at the angle lo. The center, O of the circular ray lies above the surface a distance p sin io, that is, Vola. Because this is independentof io,the centersof all rays lie on the samehorizontal line. This line is locatedwherethe velocity would be zero if the velocity function were extrapolatedup into the air (becausez : -Vola at this elevation). To determinethe shapeof the wavefront,we make use of fig. 4. 14.The raypathsSl and S.Bare circular arcs with centersO, and O, respectively.If we continue the arcs upwardsto meet the vertical through S at point S', line O, O, bisectsS'S at right angles.Next, we selectany point C on the downward extensionof S'S and draw the tangentsto the two arcs, CA and C.B.From plane geometry,we know that the squareof the length of a tangent to a circle from an external point (fiorexample,CA' ) is equal to the product of the two segmentsof any chord drawn from the samepoint (CS. C,S'in fig.4.14).Using both circles,we seethat CS' CS' : CA2: CB2, hence, CA : C,B.Thus, a circle with center C and radius R : C,4 cuts the two raypathsat right angles. Because,Sl and S.Bcan be any raypaths and a wavefront is a surfacethat meetsall rays at right angles, the circle with center C must be the wavefront that
Fig. 4.12 Seismicray in a sphericallylayeredearth with construction to show the geometricsignificanceof the ray parameter.
Fig. 4.13
Circular ray leaving the source at the angle L.
Fig. 4.14 Construction of wavefronts and raypaths for linear increase of velocity.
REFRACTION PATHS passesthrough A and,B.Even though arc SA is longer than S4 the greater path length is exactly compensatedfor by the higher velocity at the greaterdepth of raypath sl. We can draw the wavefront for any value of r if we can obtain the valuesof 11 and R in fig. 4.14. Thus, the quantities .F1and R are equal to the values of ; and x for a ray that has i : ]r at time r, that is, SD in 'crf the diagram. Substitution i: jn in eqs. (4.31), (4.33),and (4.34)yields tan)io: s '', sin lo : sechct, cos r0 : tanh at, H : (llpa)(l - sin io) : (Vola)l(llsini) - 1l : (Z/a)(coshat - l), (4.35) R : (llpa)cos io: (Vola)cotio : (Vola)sinhat. (4.35) Equation showsthat the centerof the wavefront moves downward and the radius becomeslarger as time increases. Field measurementsyield valuesof the arrival time at the source/oand angleofapproach ArlAx. Because the ray that returns to the sourcepointmust have encountereda reflectinghorizon normal to the raypath and retracedits path back to the point of origin, the dip is equal to angle i, at time t : t"tn.Thus,to locate the segmentof reflectinghorizon cbrrespondingto a set of valuesof t,, and AllAx, we make the following calculations: (a) , : )ro,
95 of the overlying bed so that it never carries a head w a v e( s e e$ l 1 . 2 ) . 4.3.2 Singlehorizontal refractor For the caseof a singlehorizontal refractinghorizon, we can readily derivea formula expressingthe arrival time in terms of the offset, the depth, and the velocities. In fig. 4.15, the lower part shows a horizontal plane refractor separatingtwo beds of velocities Z, and V2,whereVr) V,.For a geophoneat R, the path of the refractedwave is OMPR, 0. being the critical angle.The traveltime/ can be written
t :
OM
+
MP , P R 1-
Vt
vt
V2
: \- f! !?"s. + v2
_x T V2
MP v2
-f
^OM vl
z
2h "Z, cos0,
2h l r r- 4 r i n e'I \ tr/,cos 0 \ V,
x
2hcos0
V2
Vl
(4.36)
wherewe haveusedthe relation sin 0. = V,IV.inthe last step.This equationcan also be wiitten t : (xl Vr) -t t,,
(4.37)
where t,:
(2hcos0,)/2,,
(4.38)
(b)io:,'"-'(n.i,i), (c) j, : 2 tan-t(s"' tan
;,0), (d) H :(V/a)(cosh at * l), (e) R: (Vola)sinhat. With thesevalues,we find C lay off the radius R at the angle i,, and draw the reflectingsegmentperpendicular to the radius, as shown at the point A in fig. 4.14.This method is easilyadaptedto a simpleplotting machine (Daly, 1948) or to wavefront charts (Agocs,1950). Refractionstudiesinvolvinglinear increaseofoverburden velocity are discussedin 94.3.6. 43 Refraction paths 1.3.1General Refraction seismology involves the study of head waves($3.5)using primarily first arrivals,the equivalent of first breaksin reflectionseismology(see,however,secondarrivals,$11.2).For a head wave to be generated,the velocity below an interface must be higherthan that aboveit; accordingly,we shallassume rn the following sectionsthat the velocity increases downwardmonotonically.However,this is not always thecase,and problemssometimesresultfrom a hidden thlind) zone,a layer whosevelocity is lower than that
h :
) V , t , l c o s0 , .
Obviously,the head wave will not be observedat offsetslessthan the critical distance,OQ in fig. 4.15, writing x' for the critical distance, x' : OQ: 2htan0.: 2htan[sin | (V1lVr)) : 2h[(VrlV,)2 -
lfi/2.
(4.39)
The relation betweenx'lh and V.lV, is shown in fig. 4.16.As the ratio VrlV,increases, x'decreases.When VrlV, equals1.4,x' is equal to 2h. As a rule of thumb, offsetsshould be greaterthan twice the depth to the refractor to observerefractionswithout undue interferencefrom shallowerhead waves. Equations(4.36)and (4.37)representa straighrline of sfope llV, and intercepttime tr This is illustrated in fig. 4.15, where OMQ, OMP'R', OMPR, and OMP'R' are a seriesof refractionpathsand DWS the corresponding time-distance curve. Note that this straight-lineequationdoesnot havephysicalmeaning for offsetslessthan r' becausethe refractedwavedoes not exist for such values of x,' nevertheless, we can project the line back to the time axis to find r,. The problem to be solved usually is to find the depth h and the two velocities V, and Vr. The slope of the direct-wavetime-distancecurve is the reciprocal of V, and the same measurement for the refraction eventgives V,We can then calculatethe critical angle
96
GEOMETRY OF SEISMIC WAVES
0. from the relation 0" : sin-t (VtlV), and use the intercepttime, t,, to calculateft from eq. (4.38). In fig.4.15, the time-distancecurvesfor the reflection from the interface AP" and for the direct path are representedby the hyperbola CDE and the straight line OF, respectively.Becausethe path OMQ can be regarded either as a reflection or as the beginning of the refracted wave,the reflection and refraction timedistancecurves must coincide at x : x', that is, at point D. Moreover,differentiatingeq. (4.1) to obtain the slope of the reflection time-distance curve at x : x', we find
fa,l:["]
l a " J" =.,|,q i l , -'
:L(_o2
part of the refraction path is traversedat velocity V, so that as x increases,eventually the refraction wave will overtakethe direct wave. In fig. 4.15, these two traveltimes are equal at the point W lf the offset correspondingto W is r., we have
Vt
We see. therefore. that the reflection and refraction curves have the same slope at D, and, consequently, the refraction curve is tangent to the reflection curve atx:x'. Comparing reflected and refracted waves from the samehorizon arriving at the samegeophone,we note that the refraction arrival time is always lessthan the reflection arrival time (except at D). The intercept time /, for the refraction is lessthan the arrival time /o for the reflectionat the sourcepointbecause t, : (2hlVr)cos0,,
to: 2hlV,;
hence,/, < lo. Starting at the point Q, we seethat the direct wave arrivesaheadof the reflectedand refractedwavesbecauseits path is the shortestof the three. However,
2h
Vt
V2
z
cosu.,
=:('';,'') o+,,,,,, =t(ffi,1'"
\
V2
Y
, r : t l- ,L,)I *' r,
(4.40)
v,\oM + M el
= l s l n 0 : -l
Y
This relation is sometimesused to find ft from measurementsof the velocities and the crossoverdistance x.. However,usually we can determinetr more accurately than x. and henceeq. (4.38) providesa better method of determiningh. The relation between4ift and VrlV, is shown in fig. 4.16. 4.3.3 Severalhorizontal refractors Whereall layersare horizontal,eq. (4.36)an be generalized to cover the caseof more than one refracting horizon. Considerthe situation in fig. 4.17, wherewe have three layersof velocities,V,, V, and Zr. Whenever Vr) V,we havethe refraction path OMPRand corresponding time-distance curve I4/g just as we had in fig.4.15.If Vr) Vr) V,,travelby a refraction path in V, will eventually overtake the refraction in V, The refraction paths such as OM' M" P" P' R' are fixed by Snell'slaw: sin 0, v.l
: s,tl&: v2
where 0., is the critical angle for the lower horizon and 0, is lessthan the critical anglefor the upper horizon. The expressionfor the traveltimecurve SZis obtained as before:
'| lo'
t : :
OM' + R'P' M'M' + P'P" + - + vl v2
M'P' v3
2h, 2h, * Z, cos 0, Vrcos 0,, x - 2h. tan0. - 2h tan 0
V. x Vj
2h,
l.
+------...........---ll
Z, cos 0", \
-
ftri"e",)
2h, (t * rin e,) Z, cos0, \ ,4
: - ^+ A
M
P
'
y
z
P
P
"
Fig. 4.15 Relation between reflection and reliaction raypaths and traveltime curves.
L/
- - - - 2 c o s 0 . -+ 2h 2h + ,, + vl v2
cos0,:
+
t
(4.4r)
97
REFRACTION PATHS
curve to permit it to be analyzed correctly. We can find all of the velocities(hence,the angles0, also) by measuringthe slopes of the various sectionsof the time-distancecurve and then get the thicknessesof the layers from the intercepts
&.""
(4.43) '.: t-#,.. ('.- Z'^'';,'u')
:/depth,
' z
4.3.4 Effect of refractor dip
cr,-. St/car lce/depth)
0
l
3
5
V z /V t
Fig.4.16 Relation between critical distance x', crossoverdisrance x", and velocity contrast.
The simple situations on which eqs. (4.36) to (4.43) are basedare frequently not valid. One of the most serious defects is the neglect of dip because dip changesthe refraction time-distance curve drastically. The lower part of fig. 4. I 8 showsa vertical dip section through a refracting horizon. Let t be the traveltime for the refraction path OMPO'. Then, we have I
I I I I v,l o
I
o
OM + O'P MP T Vt V2 (ho+h,)tan9, _ hd+ h, *OQZ, cos 0. V2 : x c o s '(* u cho, s+0h. .. . (4.44)
_
V2
Vl
If we place the source at O and a detector &t O' , we are "shooting downdip." In this case,it is convenient to have I in terms of the distance from the source to the refractor ho; hence, we eliminate fr, using the relation h,:
h o* x s i n ( .
Writing t, for the downdip traveltime, we obtain to: (xlVr)cos( + (x/()cos 0. sin | + (2hulV,)cos0, : (xlV,)sin (e" + €) + (2holV,)cos0, :(xlV,)sin(0.+0+t,d,
(4.4s)
where tro: (2holVr)cos 0,. Fig. 4.17 Raypaths and traveltime curves for two horizontal refractors.
Thus, the time-distance curve for this refraction is also a straightline whoseslopeis the reciprocalof the velocity just below the refracting horizon and whose interceptis the sum of terms of the form 2h,cos 0rlV,, each layer above the refracting horizon contributing one term. We can generalizefor n layers:
,: ur,*z
where 0, : sin-'(V,lV^). This equation can be used to find the velocitiesand thicknessesof each of a series of horizontal refractinglayers,eachof constantvelocity higher than any of the layers above it, provided each layer contributes enough of the time-distance
)
The result for shooting in the updip direction is similarly obtained by eliminating ftr:
t,: (xlV,)sin(0. - {) + r,", where
t,,: (2hJV,j)cos 0".
) )
(4.461
)
Note that the downdip traveltime from O to O' is equal to the updip traveltime from O' to o,' this sourcepoint to sourcepoint traveltime is called the reciprocal time and is denoted by l" The concept that traveltimealong a path is the sameregardlessof the direction of travel is an example of theprinciple of reciprocity. Theseequations can be expressedin the sameform as eq. (4.37): to: (xlV) * t,o,
(4.47)
(xt\) + t,,,
(4.48)
t,:
GEOMETRY OF SEISMIC WAVES
98
Raypaths and traveltime curves for a dipping re-
Fig. 4.18 fiactor.
where V :
Vtlsin(0. + €),
(e. - 0. V,: V,lsin (4.49)
Voand V,are apparentvelocitiesand are given by the reciprocalsof the slopesof the time-distancecurves' For reversedprofiles,suchas shown in fig.4.18' eq. (4.49) canbe solvedfor the dip ( and the critical angle 0, (and hencefor the refractor velocity Z'): l sin r(VtlV,)1. o, : j [sin t(VtlV,l+ ] ,' o . r ' , -r( t(v € : I lsin l l v l ) s i n v t l v " ) 1 .) The distancesto the refractor, h, and h,,, can then be found from the interceptsusing eqs.$.a\ and (a.46). Equation (4.49) can be simplified where { is small enough that we can approximateby letting cos ( - I and sin € : €. With this simplificationeq. (4'49) becomes VJVr: sin (0. + t) = sin 0. + ( cos 0.' VlV,: sin (0. - O : sin 0. ( cos 0,; hence,
and assumingthat { is small enoughthat higher powers of ( are negligible: ' V , , : ( V , l s i no , X c o s{ + c o t 0 , s i n { ) : Vr(l - t cot 0,)' V , : V r ( l + t c o t0 , ) ; hence,
v,: :(v,t+ v,)
(4.s2)
4.3.5 Diving waves It is obviousthat raypathswill eventuallyreturn to the surface wheneverthe velocity increaseswith depth. The wavestraveling by such raypaths are called diving wayes.Symmetry shows that for horizontal velocity layering,the angleof emergenceis io(fig. 4.19a);at the : deepest point on the raypath (h-), i : 90" and p point on llV^, that is,p is the slownessat the deepest the iaypath for a diving ray. We can rewrite eqs.(4.29) and (4.30)for this situation as
,:2fr-
(4.53a)
s i n0 , : ( V t l v r \ : : V t I l l l v d l + 0 l V , l j , so that
u v,-;l (U V )+ (rl 4) 1.
( 4.s1)
An even simpler approximate formula for Vt (although slightly less accurate) can be obtained by applying the binomial theorem($15.1.4c)to eq. (4.49)
dz- .lo(4.53b) ', -' vrzllt 1pv(:)1't''2' )n the doubling factor of 2 arisingbecauseof the raypath from h^back to 0. If x, / measurementsare available for diving ways from a common source and if the velocity hai increasedwith depth monotonically,then
99
REFRACTION PATHS eqs.(4.53)can be solvednumericallyfor V(z). For a linear increaseof velocity,eqs.(4.53)become (seeproblem 4.20a) x : (2Vola)cotio : QVolal)sinh(atl2), (4.54a) (4'54b) t : (2la) ln [cot (iol2)]' and the maximum depth of penetrationis h^: (VJa)fcosh(atl2)- ll.
(4.55)
For the case of concentric spherical layering (fig' 4.19b),eqs.(4.53)become(seeproblem 4.20b)
o:'r",-##w,,*' (456a) ' : 2 1 " v t r l, R,_h^
dr
where A is the angle subtended at the center of the Earth by raypath SO and R" is the radius of the Earth' Richter (1958:app. VI) givesa numericalsolution for Z(r) in eqs.(4.56).Using LDEF in fig. 4.19b' we can write eq. (4.27)as
I I lh^ I I
: u'/uo?r'.rr., i)lVo: VndtJR"UO p' : R"(sin At the deepestPoint, P' : r^l\, p' : r^lV^:
w,.,
(4.s6b)
lp'V(r)lrl' ltt2'
so
(R1zr)sinlo : Et/bAor. (4.58)
If we plot a curve of traveltimeI versusangular distance A for an earthquakeevent at various stations, the slope, Ltl6L, givesr ^l V-. With diving waves,two velocity situationsrequire specialattention.A velocity gradientin a layer that is substantiallyhigher than the gradient abovethe bed, as in fig. 4.2ba,causesa very sharp increasein raypath curvature and a folding back of the time-distance curve. Such a triplication of branchesof the timedistancecurve (fig. 4.20c)is usuallydifficult to seebecausethe later branchesbecomelost in the later cycles of the earlier arrivals. Unless all branchesare correctly recognized,errors will be made in solving the time distance observationsfor Z(z)' The other situationleadingto errorsin determining Z(z) is that of a velocity inversion(fig' a'20b)' The inversionmay producea gap in the time-distancecurve' as in fig. i.iOc, anA this gap may not be recognized becausediffraction tends to fill it in' Although fig' 4.20 shows situations for planar layers,similar (but more complex) situations occur with concentric sphericallayersin earthquakestudies'
(b) (a) PlaFig. 4.19 Raypaths for increasein velocity with depth nar velocity layering; (b) concentric velocity layering'
|
-
I.sN
L I ' tNP
J' - ' 'PR
:2tr*+(x-2MI\\lV^' Noting that (sin i)lVo : (sin 0.)/ V, : llZ-, we find from eq. (4.32) I . /tan ]0.\
trr: i," \45/
:t"'"1(r^r-r,--rr,,)("-urn'')l
:j["",n-'(A *'n'(A], 4.3.6Linear increasein velocityabovea refractor The caseof a high-velocitylayer overlainby a layerin which the velocity increaseslinearly with depth (fig' 4.21) is of considerablepractical importance'The relation betweent and x for a horizontal refractor can be found as follows:
'x : where use has been made of the identity cosh get (4.31)' we l)'"]. From eq. ln[x + (x' MN : (l/pa)(cos io - cos 0.)
: (rlpa){lt- (VJV,,)'l'''- tt - (4lV-)'\'''}'
GEOMETRY OF SEISMIC WAVES
100
t i o n a t t o : 2 . 3 5 8 s , g i v e nt h a t t h e v e l o c i t yv : Z ' S O km/s. (b) Typical errors in t,V tomight be 0'6 m, 0'2 km/s, unOj -s. Calculate the corresponding errors in A't*ro approximately.What do you conclude about the accuracy of A/".o calculations? (c) Show itiat ttre more accurateNMO equation,eq' (4.8),can be written Lt|uro- L,trro(l - LtNMJ2t), in terms of the first-ordervalue of Lt NMogiven by eq' (4.7). Taking into account the errors in x, V /n,when is this equationuseful? 4.2 (a) Show that the quantity dtldx can be considered as a vector or component of a vector according as d/ correspondsto the total dip or component of dip. of fig' 1b; Using fig. 4.22, verify that the constructio-n (Hint: Ex(4'18)' eq' as results +.SUgiu.t th. tu-. pressf , m, and OC in terms of OA.) i.: Stto* that the equation for a dipping reflection, eq. (4.9),becomes (Vt)z : (2x cos $' + 4h7 determlne Fig. 4.20 Velocity situationsmaking it difficult to gradient' iiri"-Airtun"" curves (a) Region with large velocity (c) Time-distancecurvesfor inversion' velocity with n"gion ift (a) (solid linel and (b) (dashedline); diffractionswill ;ii;;; complicatethesecurves.
(Gardner, 1947),where ft is replacedby ft., the slant depth at the midpoint betweenthe sourceand receiver (seefig. 4.23).
V,=l'o+oh, 1J:^
in velocityin the with a linearincrease Fig.4.21 Refraction upperlayer.
Fig. 4.22 Combiningdip components'
Substituting in the first expressionfor t gives (4.59) t : (xth) + to, where /o : intercept time:
| (V^l%)- "olq_:V_ry!^Dl to= " -(2la){fcosh + ll - (V'lV^)')'''I'(4'60) (% l4)'l''' tl The slope of the head-wavetraveltime curve gives V-' A curve is plotted of to againsth,(or V) for given valuesof Zoa\d o, arrdh,and V,are read from this curve for particular measurementsof r0'
( I I I I I
s' Problems 4.1 6\ Calculate the normal moveout A/r.o for geophones 600 and 1200 m from the source for a reflec-
i,' A'
Fig. 4 23
Derivation
of X2-72
relation
for a dipping
bed'
PROBLEMS
l0l
+.4 (a) Using the dip-moveoutequation,eq. (4.11), and the resultsof problem 4.3, verify the following result (due to Favreaccordingto Dix, 1955): tan(:
t l t 2 A B -t i ) t t 2 '
where{ : dip, I : tru - tr", tu": traveltimebetween sourceA and receiverB, tn: traveltimeat sourceS tseefig. 4.23.y. (b) Using eq. (a.9), show that sin { :
- t2")l\h,r. Vr(t?rn
(c) Under what condition is the result in part (b) the sameas eq. (4.I l) and also consistentwith part (a)? 4.5 The expressionfor dip in terms of dip'moveout, eq. (4.l1), involves the approximation of dropping higher-orderterms in the quadraticexpansionusedto get eq. (4.10).What is the effecton eq. (4.11)if an additional term is carried in this expansion?What is the percentagechangein dip? 4.6 In fig. 10.5b,the reflectiontime at the top is 1.0s and the depth 1500m, the reflectiontime at the bottom is 1.4s, the interval velocitybetweeneventsI and 2 is 3300m/s,and the tracespacingis 100m. Calculate the depth and dip ofthe three reflectors. 4.7 A well encountersa horizon at a depth of 3 km with a dip of7". Sourcesare located200 m updip from the well with a geophoneat depthsof L0 to 2.6 km at intervals of 400 m. Plot the raypathsand traveltime curvesfor the primary reflectionfrom the 3-km horizon and its first multipleat the surface.AssumeZ: 3.0 km/s. (Hint: Seefig. 6.33.) 4.8 The numbered ticks at the top of fig. 8.5 are 1 km apart. (a) Select two fairly steeply dipping reflections,assume velocities(fairly high in this area), and determine the approximatedips. (b) Figure 8.5 is a migrated section; by what horizontal distancesare the reflecting points for these eventsdisplaced,that is, how far did they migrate? (Hint: See$8.8.3and fig. 8.30.) 4.9 @) SourcesB and C are respectively600 m north and 500 m east of sourcel. Traveltimesat A, B, and C for a certain reflectionare to: 1.750,1.825,and 1.796s. What are the dip and strike of the horizon, Z being 3.25 km/s? (b) What are the changesin dip and strike if line AC has the bearingN80'E? a.l0 (a) Two intersectingseismicspreadshave bearings N10'E and N140'E. If the first spreadshowsan event at to : 1.160s with dip moveout of 56 ms/km and the same event on the secondspread has a dip moveout of 32 ms/km, find the true dip, depth, and strike, assumingthat (i) both dips are down to the southand west,and (ii) dip on the first spreadis down to the south and the other is down to the southeast. The averagevelocity is 3 km/s. rb) Calculatethe position of the reflectingpoint (migratedposition) for each spreadin (i) as if the cross rnformationhad not beenavailableand eachhad been rssumedto indicatetotal moveoutl comDarewith the
resultsof part (a). Would the errors be more serious or less seriousif the calculationswere made for the usual situation where the velocity increaseswith depth? 4.11 Verify the derivation of the expressionfor k in $4.1.4and of eq. (4.21a). 4.12 Given the velocity-depthdata shownin fig. 5.19, what problems would you expect using simple functional-fit relationsin the different areas? 4.13 (a) CalculateV and V,^"down to each of the interfacesin table 4. l. Why do they differ (give a geometrical explanation)? (b) Pfot V and V,_.versusdepth and versustraveltime and determinethe best-fit straight lines for the four cases.What are the main problemsin approximating data with functional fits? Table 4.1 Layeredmodel Depth (km)
Velocity (knts)
0 1.00 1.00-2.50 2.50-2.80 2.80-4.80
2.00 3.00 6.00 4.00
4.14 (a) Assumingflat bedding,calculatedepthscorresponding to t0 : 1.0,2.0,2.1 , a n d 3 . 1 s u s i n gt h e velocity functions for V and Z.*. determinedin problems4. l3a and 4. | 3b.What errorsare introducedrelative to the depthsgiven in table 4. l? (b) Using the velocitydata in table4. l, tracea nonvertical ray through the various layersand find the arrival times and reflectingpoints offlat reflectorsat eachof the interfaces. 4.15 (a) Repeatthe calculationsof problem 4.14a assumingdip moveout of 104ms/km and find the dip in eachcase. (b) Tracerays assumingthe velocity is constantat the vafuesof V and V,^"calculatedin problem 4. 13. Find the arrival times and reflectingpoints of reflectorsat eachof the interfaces. 4.16 Figure 7.45showspart of a seismicrecordwhere the geophonegroup spacingis 50 m, the offsetto the near groups being 50 m and that of the far groups 600 m. (a) What is the velocity of the first-breaks? (b) Assumingthat the sourceis below the baseof the LVL and that the LVL velocity is 500 m/s, how thick is the LVL? (c) Arrival times at the sourcepoint for two reflections are given as 0.415 and 0.778 s; what are the average velocitiesto thesereflectors? (d) For these reflections, the arrival-time differences betweenthe far traces in opposite directions from the sourcepoint are given as +0.005 for both reflections. What are the dips of thesereflectors? (e) What is the dominant frequency of these reflections (approximately)?
GEOMETRY OF SEISMIC WAVES
102
t
frr =300m
,/r = 3 km/s
ft: =300m
/z = l'5 km/s
Y1 = 3 kmls
Iz. = 6 km/s
Vt = 6kmls (a)
(b)
Fig.4.24 Two different geologic sections that give the same refraction time distance curves.
4.17 (a) Giventhe velocityfunction V : |.60 + 0.60: km/s (z in km), find the depth, dip, and offset of the point of reflection when In : 4.420 s and AllAr : 0. 155 s/km. What interpretation would you give of the result? (b) If the ray continued without reflection,when and where would it emerge?What moveout would be observedat the recording spread?Calculate the maximum depth of penetration. 4.18 (a) Show that the two geologicalsectionsillustrated in flg. 4.24 produce the same time-distance curves. (b) What would be the apparent depth to the lower interfacesin figs. 4.24a and 4.24b if 4 : 3.15 km/s insteadof 6 km/s? 4.19 Figure 4.25 showsa refraction profile recorded as a ship firing an air gun moved away from a sonobuoy. Identify the direct wave through the water and disuseits traveltimesto give the source-to-sonobuoy tances(assume1.5km/s as the velocity in water). (a) Identify distinctivehead-wavearrivals,determine their velocities,intercept times,and depths of the refractors assumingflat bedding and no velocity inversions. (b) What is the water depth? Identify multiples and explain their probable travel paths. (The data in the upper right corner result from paging ($8.6.3)and actually belong below the bottom of the record.) a.20 (a) Verify eqs.(4.54) and (4.55).(Hint: Use eqs. ( 4 . 3 1 )t o ( 4 . 3 4 ) . ) (b) Deriveeqs.(4.56).(Hint: ln fig. 4.19b,M.BC gives (V 6t)' : (6r)' + (r EA)' ; using eq. (4.27), show that O' : Qllz1, (6A/6r);eliminating first 61, then 64, and integratinggiveseqs.(4.56a)and (4.56b). 4.21 If the velocity function in problem 4.17 applies above a horizontal refractor at a depth of 2.40 km, where the refractor velocity is 4.25 km/s, plot the traveltime-distance curve. 4.22 Given that situations (a) through (h) in fig. 4.26 involvethe sametwo rock types,draw the appropriate time distancecurves.Diagram (c) showstwo casesfor dip in oppositedirections.In figs.(i) and O, the velocity in the lower medium varies laterally accordingto the density of the shading. 4.23 Barton (1929) discussesshooting into a geo-
phone placed in a borehole(fi9. a.27) as a meansof determiningwhere the bottom of the borehole is located. (a) Given that A, B, D, and.E are equidistant from lA in the cardinal directions and assumingstraight-line travel paths at the velocity V and that the traveltimes from D and -E are equal, derive expressionsfor CC' and CW in fig. 4.27ain terms of the traveltimesfrom A and B, tA(.,ar'd tB(.,. (b) What are the valuesof tAC,and trr. for V : 2.500 kmls, AW : BW : CC' : 1000m, CW -- 200 m? (c) How sensitiveis the method, that is, rvhat are L,(CC')lL,tnr.,,and L(CW)IL/,..,?For the specificsituation in part (b), how much changeis there in WC and CC' per milliseconderror in /r.,? (d) Modify the assumptionsin part (b) by taking the velocity as 1.5 km/s for the first 500 m and 3.5 km/s for the lower 500 m. What are the actual traveltimes now and how would thesebe interpretedassumingthe straight-pathassumptionin part (a)? 4.24 SourcesA and B arelocatedat the endsof a225m spreadof l6 geophones.Using the data in table4.2, find the velocities,dip, and depth to the refractor.
Table 4.2 Refractionprofle r, (m)
/1 (ms)
/8 (ms)
rr (m)
0 l5 30 45 60 75 90 105 t20 r35 150 165 180 195 2t0 225
0 10 21 30 4l
98 92 87 8l
225 210 195 180 165 150 135 120 105 90 75 60
\tl
I I
59 65 70
65 60 52
t)
40
'78 81 85 89 94 98
43 )t
31 2l l0 0
A< JU
l5 0
F
Fig. 4.25 Sonobuoy refraction profile in Baffin Bay. Source was a 1000-in.rair gun. (Courtesy of Fairfield Industries.)
,F]
(e)
A
Fig.4.26 Time-distance curves for various twoJayer configuraions. This figure is adapted from Barton (1929) in the first publication in English on the seismic method The part above O of each diagram provides space for a curve of arrival time versus distance foi the model shown in cross-sectionbelow O' In each
te , ,
t t t
^-
- -- - - -, - ! ^
W
-2-----'
€t I
t I I
v (a)
c a w
\
lt l.'
(bl Fig. 4.27 Mapping a crooked borehole by measuring traveltlmes to a geophone at C' in the borehole (From Barton' 1929.) (a) Plan view; (b) vertical section AWB'
(t)
(/)
case,the velocity in the cross-hatchedportion is higher than that above. Part (a) has been completed to show what is expected. In (c), two alternatives are given so two sets of curves should be drawn. In (i) and (), refractor velocity varies horizontally and is proportional to the shading density.
REFERENCES References of veAgocs,W. B. 1950.Comparisonchartsfor linearincrease 15::22636. locity with depth.Geophysics, Barton,D. C. 1929.The seismicmethodof mappinggeologic pp. 572 624.New York: structure.In Geophysical Prospecting, AmericanInstituteof Mining and MetallurgicalEngineers. Brown, R. J. S. 1969.Normal-moveoutand velocityrelations for flat and dipping bedsand for long offsets.Geopftlsics, 34: 1 8 09 s . Daly,J. W 1948.An instrumentfor plotting reflectiondata on the assumptionofa linearincrease ofvelocity.Geophysics, 13: 153 t.
105 Dix. C. H. 1955.Seismicvelocitiesfrom surfacemeasurements. 68-86. Geophysics,20: Gardner.L.W. 1947.Verticalvelocitiesfrom reflectionshoot12: 221-8. ing. Geophysics, Levin,F. K. 1971.Apparentvelocityfrom dippinginterfacere36: 510-16. flections.Geophysics, Richter, C. F. 1958. ElementarySeismology.San Franctsco: W. H. Freeman. Shah,P.M., and F. K. Levin. 1973.Grosspropertiesof time 38:643 56. distancecvves. Geophysics,
t
Seismicvelocity
()verview Knowledgeof velocity valuesis essentialin determining the depth, dip, and horizontal location of reflectors and refractors, in determining whether certain things like head wavesand velocity distortionsoccur, and in ascertainingthe natureofrocks and their interstitial fluids from velocity measurements. We developa heuristic appreciationof the factors that affect seismicvelocity from a conceptualmodel of a sedimentary rock. F. Gassmann,M. A. Biot, and J. Geertsmadevelopeda model for a fluid-filled porous rock, and G. H. P. Gardner, L. W. Gardnet and A. R. Gregory hypothesizedthat microcracksin nonporous rocks lower velocity.Fracturing also generally lowersvelocity. Lithology is the most obvious factor we would expect to control velocity.However,velocity rangesare so broad and there is so much overlap that velocity alonedoesnot providea good basisfor distinguishing lithology.Sand velocities,for example,can be smaller or larger than shalevelocities,and the sameis true tbr densities; both velocityand densityplayimportant rrles in seismicreflectivity. Porosity appearsto be the most important single factor in determininga rock'svelocity,and the dependenceof porosityon depth of burial and pressurereli'tionships makes velocity sensitiveto these factors also.Velocity is generallyloweredwhen gas or oil replaceswater as the interstitial fluid, sometimesby so nruchthat amplitude anomaliesresult from hydrocarf,on accumulations. The near-surfacelayer of the earth usually differs markedlyfrom the remainderof the earth in velocity lnd some other properties. This makes the near\urtacelow-velocitylayer(LVL) especially important; !rur determinationsof depths,attitudes,and continuLn of deeper eventsare affectedas reflectionspass through this layer.In arctic areas,a zone of permanentlyfrozenearth,permafrost,distortsdeeperevents lecauseof an exceptionallyhigh velocity.Fluid pres.ure that exceedsthat of a column of fluid extending :!r the surface("normal" pressure)lowersseismicve;.rci1yt11ti.is usedto predict abnormal pressures.Gas just belowthe sea rrdratesthat form in the sediments ir-rorin deepwater also producevelocity changes. Velocity terminology is often misusedand causes rruch confusion.Section5.4.1 attemptsto clarify the rrecisemeaningof average,root-mean-square, stack-
107
ing, interval, Dix, phase,group, apparent,and other velocity terms. Seismicvelocity is measuredin boreholesby sonic logs ($5.4.3)(and by vertical seismic profiling discussedin $13.4).Velocityis also measuredby surface seismicdata becauseof the dependenceof normal moveout on velocity.The reflection-coemcient equation can be usedto obtain velocity information from amplitudes.a form of inversion.
5.1 Model of a sedimentary rock 5.1.I A pack oJ uniformspheres Seismicvelocityas givenby eqs.(2.58)and (2.59)relates to a homogeneousmedium, but sedimentary rocksare far from homogeneous. Theseequationscan be written, for solid media, cr2: (tr + 2p")lp,
B' : t-rlp,
and for fluid media, c t ,: \ / p ,
g.:0;
hence,in general,
y : lKto),,2,
(5.1)
where K is the effectiveelastic parameter.Thus, the dependence of Z upon the elasticconstantsand density appearsto be straightforward.In fact, the situation is much more complicatedbecauseK and p are interrelated,both dependingto a greateror lesserdegree upon the material and structureof the rock, the lithology, porosity,interstitial fluids, pressure,depth, cementation,degreeof compaction,and so on. The most notable inhomogeneityof sedimentaryrocks is that they are porous, containing fluid-fllled spaces within them. Porosity is simply the pore volume per unit volume.Wang and Nur (1992b)discusstheorres relatingseismicvelocity to the compositionof rocks, The simplest rock model consists of identical spheresarrangedin a cubicpattern(fig.5.la) with the matrix subjectedto a compressivepressureL If the radius of the spheresis R, the force ,F pressingtwo adjacentspherestogetheris the total force acting on a layer of n X n spheres(that is, (2Rn)' 2|)divided by the number of spheres(!t'), or F : 4R29. This force causesa point ofcontactto becomea circleofcontact
SEISMICVELOCITY
108 of radius r and the centersto move closertogethera distances (seefigs. 5.lb and 5.1c),r and s being related to R, I and the elastic constants4 o of the spheresby Hertz' equations (see Timoshenko and Goodier. 1951:3'72-7): r : [3(l - o2)RFl4E|t3, (5.2) t s : [9(l - o')'F'l2RE']n. I When a P-wavepasses,I changesby A9, resulting i n c h a n g e sL F : 4 R ' L 9 a n d A s : - 2 R e , w h e r e e t s the strain in the direction of F (seefig. 5.ld). Thus, the effectiveelasticmodulus K is given by Ag : 1. .(: - '
I2R -s --l
L
!g:
AJ
r AF : | 3E'9 1'''
2Rl,
Lgtl-o')'l
on differentiatingeq. (5.2).The averagedensity is the weight of a spheredivided by the volume of the circumscribedcube,that is, p :71ttO3p)/(2R)3 : t/orP, p being the density of the material of the spheres. Thus, we get for the P-wavevelocity, ("n,.,
Fig. 5.1 Effects ofcompression on a cubic packing ofspheres. (After White, 1965.)(a) Cubic packing; (b) force causescenters to move closer together; (c) force causes point contact to become circular area of contact; (d) effect of change in force.
V."r,.: (Kl-p)tt': I81E2gl(l - o2)2?rrpslr/6. (5 . 3 ) Gassmann(195l) calculatedthe velocityfor a hexagonal packing of identical spheres(fig. 5.2) under a pressureproduced by the weight of a thickness: of overlyingspheres;he obtained for a vertical ray Vn,-: fl28E' gzl(l - o2)2rr2p)fi/o, (5.4) where g is the accelerationof gravity. BecauseI is nearlyproportionalto:, eqs.(5.3)and (5.4)give the samevariation of velocitywith depth. Faust (1953) found an empirical formula for velocity in terms of depth of burial z and formation resistivityR', that is consistentwith eqs.(5.3)and (5.4): 4:
900(zR')"o,
/5 5\
Vrbeing in m/.1,: in m, and R' in ().m. However,the deviations of individual measurementswere very large, indicating the presenceof other factors that havenot beentaken into account. Random packsof well-sortedparticleshaveporosities in the range of 45 50Vo,but under pressure,the particles deform at the contacts,and as a result the density increasesand the porosity decreases(Sheriff, 1911;theelasticconstantsalsochange see$5.2.5). on the model 5.1.2 Expectationsba,ged What velocity relationshipsmight we expectbasedon the foregoingmodel of a rock? Clearly,porosity will be an important factor in velocity becauseit should alTectboth the effectiveelasticityand the density,and indeed it is often said that porosity is the most important factor in determiningthe velocity of a sedimentary rock. The contactareabetweenspheresis not proportional to the pressureforcing them together,so we may expectthat the pressuredependenceofvelocity will not be linear but will diminish with increasing
pressure(or with depthof burial).Fluid filling the intersticesin a rock may be expectedto resistthe effects of the overburden,that is, the overburdenweight tendsto squeeze out the porositywhereasthe interstitial fluid tends to preservethe porosity. Thus, the effectivepressureon a rock will be the differencebetweenthe overburdenpressureand the fluid pressure, the di/firential pressure.If the pore spaceis connected to the surface,the fluid pressureshould be that of a column of porefluid extendingto the surfacewhereas the overburdenpressureis the weight of the overlying rocks. Where this is true, the pressureis said to be normal. However,if the pore fluid cannot escapeto allow the grain-to-graincontactsto adjustto normal pressure,then some of the overburdenweight will be supportedby the interstitial fluid and we will havean overpressured situation. An overpressuredrock will "feel" the same differential pressureas it would at some shallowerdepth, where it would have a lower velocity, and, hence, we expect overpressuringto lower the velocity. We would not expectthe deformationof a rock under high pressuresto be elastic.Hence,if a rock from which the porosity has beensqueezedout by depth of burial should be uplifted, we would not expectporosity to return, except for a small amount becauseof some remaining elasticity. The porosity of a rock might be expectedto dependon the maximum stresses it has endured since formation, that is, porosity may dependon the maximum depth of burial rather than on the presentdepth. Gas as a formation fluid is much more compressible than a liquid and hencegas in the pore spaceshould lower the velocity much more than oil or water. In fact, gas is so compressiblethat the presenceof just a
MODEL OF A SEDIMENTARY ROCK
109
t r )
W ! z
.V
\
l
7
\
.
(c)
\
@)
Fig. 5.2 Close packing of uniform spheres.(a) Cubic packing (as in fig. 5. la), an arrangement that is not gravitationally stable. (b) Hexagonal packing, gravitationally stable and the densest packing possible. (c) First layer of a hexagonal stack, showrng two classesof sites (.4 and B), adjacent sites of which cannot both be occupied at the same time (for example, the two dashed
locations). (d) Second layer of spheresshowing how occupyrng some I and some B sites leavesextra spacein between.(e) Hexagonal stack with left side occupying I sites and right portion B sites; the consequence is increased porosity. The random choice of,4 and B sites leads to a completely random pack after a few layers.
small amount of gasshould lower the effectiveelasticity nearly as much as a large amount, and hencewe expectthe effectof gas on velocity to be very nonlinear.Gas in the pore spacewould affectdensityas well as effectiveelasticity; if we gradually introduce gas into the pore space,the first small amount of gas should have a large effect on the numerator of eq. (5.1), but additional gas will have much less effect, whereasthe effecton the density term in the denominator will be linear with the amount of gas.Thus, as the amount of gasis graduallyincreased,we expectat first a sharpdecreasein velocityand thereaftera gradual steady increase in velocity. The near-surface weatheringlayerbeinggenerallyabovethe water table, we expect it to have exceptionallylow velocity. BecauseS-wavesdo not travel through fluids,the nature of the pore fluid should have little effect on S-waves
compared to that on P-waves;however,it will still havea minor influencebecauseof its effecton the density. By changingP-wavevelocity much more than Swave velocity, the presenceof gas will change the effectivevalue of Poisson'sratio and hence change amplitude-versus-offset relationships. Cementationand pressure-induced recrystalization would be expectedto decreaseporosity. Very few of the things that might happento rocks increaseporosity (seefig. 5.3a).Hence,generally,we may expectporosity to decrease(and velocity to increase)with increasein depth of burial (fig. 5.3b),cementation,age, as sorting becomespooret and so on. The major failure in expectationsis that an increase in densityusuallydoesnot lower velocity,as might be expectedfrom eq. (5.1). Phenomonathat changethe densityusuallychangethe effectiveelasticitymore, so
SEISMIC VELOCITY
ll0
0.0s
suming that relative motion between the fluid and rock is negligible.We shall follow the account given by White (1983:57-63). The rock is assumedto be a porous skeleton or framework with the pore fluid moving in unison with the rock so that there are no viscousenergylosses.To distinguishvarious componentsof the system,we use the following notation for the bulk moduli: kt.,k., k*, and k refer respectivelyto the fluid filling the pore space,the material comprising the skeleton,average values for the skeleton plus empty spaces,and the fluid-filled skeleton.We use $ for the porosity and C: llk for the incompressibility.We assumethat the saturatedrock is isotropic and that the fluid has no effecton the shearmodulus, so p : p*. The average density is simply the volume-weightedaverage:
Averageporosity,P 0 . 2 0 0 . 3 00 . 4 0 0.10
0
) ^ lz
x o
l0
/ 3 '9/
J
st
P:0P/+ (1 0)P,.
We considera cube of the saturatedrock and apply an incremental pressure A0. We assume that the pores are interconnectedso that the fluid pressureis that applied to the pore openingson the cube faces (however,no fluid enters or leavesthe cube because there is no fluid motion relativeto the rock). We write for the total pressure
l5
-. (a)PorGity (%) ? p 3
(5.6)
0
A0 : A9* + Lgt.
r08'
(5.7)
From the definition of dilatation, we can write eq' (2.18)in the form -LY|V : C 49.
6
; d
o o
Thus, the pressureA9r changesthe fluid volume by - LlrtlY : the ma6C, tW,. But A0, also compresses terial of the skeleton,so -A{,/Y : (l - d)C" AE. Finally, A9* compresses the skeleton so that -AT./1/ : C, A0*. Adding these three effects,we find for the total volume change
( - L Y | V ) : [ 6 C , +( 1 - 6 ) C "A )E + c. ag*.
Fig. 5.3 Factors affecting porosity. (a) Porosity in a clastic rock decreaseswith depth of burial (compaction), cementation, and "limpoorer sorting, but is essentiallyunchanged by uplift. The it-of-porosity" line refers to normally pressured situations and ignores possible secondary porosity. (After Zieglar and Spotts. 1978.) (b) Porosity depth curves. (From Atkins and McBride, 1992; reprinted with permission.)
rltoaa SAtrlt lllrllxc raal (tlw tlctoclactll
o
E
!o that the explicit densityterm in the denominatorgives the wrong implication. Biot, Geertsmaequations 5.1.3 Gassmann, To obtain a useful formula for the velocity of a fluidfilled porous rock, the effectsofporosity and the pore fluid must be taken into account. Gassmann(1951) derivedexpressionsfor the effectivebulk modulus as-
(5.8)
oattto
.ttot
lllrll
rclotllY
l.ta
oaitlll
l.l
(tturr
DrY tlrtrt lr tlrlttio ilcrclrcllxo
lttlr lt ttc'c rilllrlD)
r o o ' m s a m c n f r
Pr$sure(P.s.i.) Fig. 5.4 Effect of microcracks on velocity of gabbro. (From Gardner, Gardner, and Gregory, 1974.)
I
Velocitg(km/s) 2 3 4
I
I
Alfuvium, * Drg sand, Veaihering
c-r H-?
l-2H l-
7r
t,5-t I
F-4-.|
4 Hud
F3a
Glacial
-21
Shale
Smd, Sandstone
Lirnestone
Dolomile
Arrhgdrile,
r Ggpsum A Selt
6rrnite
l-1 FS
4-l
l-5 + Fig. 5.5 P-wave velocities lor various lithologies. Data from ( l ) G r a n t a n d W e s t ( 1 9 6 5 ) ;( 2 ) Kearey and Brooks ( 1 9 8 a()3 ;)
Lindseth (1979);(4) Mares ( 1984);(5) Sharma ( 1976);(6) Sheriff a n d G e l d a r t ( 1 9 8 3 ) ;a n d ( 7 ) W a t e r s( 1 9 8 7 ) .
SEISMIC VELOCITY
tt2
- l) in the nuAdding and subtracting (k*lk,)(k*lk" merator, we get
k:k*+
Fig. 5.6 Histogram ofvelocity values tabulated in Birch (1942) for different lithologies. (From Grant and West, 1965.)
3 . 3t rt
x
Best-fit lines Sands
tr 3.lH
Shales
2.9LL Oc
r E N
d
-
-SUd_ltne
V)
Fig. 5.7 Portion of SP- and velocity logs for a well in the U.S. Gulf Coast. The SP-values distinguish sands from shales. (After Sheriff. 1978.)
(t-k*lk,)2
60lkf - vk") + (l/k,xl k*lk") ( 5I. 1 )
Thus, k equals k* for the skeletonplus a term that dependsin part upon the fluid filling the pores. BeM : k + 4p"13(seeeq. (2.58)and table2.2),we ca:erse can add 4p,13to both sidesand get (t - k*lk")2 M:M** -
+(ykf uk")+ (uk")(r u.,o(1,4
Becausea2 : Mlp, the P-wavevelocity dependsupon the fluid bulk modulus and the porosity as well as the rock properties.On the other hand, the fluid influencesP only through the density (seeeq. (5'6)). One might expect the coupling betweenthe rock skeletonand the fluid to be greaterat low frequencies; Gassman's equation is therefore called the lowfrequencysolution. Biot (1956)assumedthat the fluid "highcould flow through the pore spacesto give a frequency solution"; this introduced the additional factorsof fluid viscosityand matrix permeability.Biot alsodefinedthe low-frequencyrangeof the applicability of the Gassmannequationas v < 0.1(e$l2rrrP,),
(5.13)
wheree is fluid viscosity,and r is matrix permeability. Geertsmaand Smit (1961) derived an equation We obtain another equation for - LYIY'by considering that A9* producesa relativevolume changein the skeletonplus pores equal to C* A9* and A0, results in a relative change in the skeleton material C" Ag, (the volume changeof the fluid is taken care of in the'term C* A9*). Adding, we find that
( - L 1 fl 1 f ) : C , A E + C * A g *
VEI-oclTY (lus)
(5.9)
Equations(5.8) and (5.9) are now solvedfor A0, and A0* with the result
- C) Lgr: e^1'r'1r)G"- C*)/[oC*(C" +c, (c, - c*)1, Ag*: (-A1//D0(C"- C)tl+C*(c,- c/) + c.(c, - c*)1. Adding and using eq. (5.7),we havefor the effective bulk modulus
As
t(c,-_91(E lr : "k,__r_ c -Lyfv oc*(c, - C,)+ c"(c,- c*)' o(r/k"- !tk) + (rtk"-rtk*) _ d ( l / k * )l (t k , - l t k , l + ( l l k , x l l k , - l l k * l '
14000 fr ONE WELL
97 WELLS
(a)
(bl
(s.l0)
Multiplying numeratorand denominatorby k* gives
- uk) + (k*lk"- l)l/to(l/fr"- rlkf) k : tk*601k" + (l/k,xk*/k,- l)1.
Fig. 5.8 Shale velocities in the Ship Shoal region, ofshore Louisiana. (From Hilterman, 1990.) (a) A velocity analysis in one well; (b) histograms showing velocities in 97 wells throughout the area.
EXPERIMENTAL DATA ON VELOCITY from the Biot equationswhere wavelengthis greater than pore size: u -
{[(:. ?)+
il-c,/c),
IiJ," (l -0-C./C)C.+6gJpJ (5.l4)
This equationgivesvaluessimilar to eq. (5.12).These equationsfit experimentaldata reasonablywell considering how many variablesare usually not known precisely.
5.1.4 Model of a nonporousrock The foregoingsectionsbasicallyexplain observedvelocity variationsas attributablemainly to changesin the porosityand the fluid filling the porosity.However, nonporousrocks also show variation of velocity with pressureand other parameters. Gardner, Gardner, and Gregory (1974) hypothesized that nonporous rocks have minute voids (,.microcracks")that result in loweringthe velocity.Generally, rocks are composedof many minerals that have different temperature coefficientsof expansion, so that a temperaturechange will create stressesand open up microcracks.To testtheir hypothesis,they determined the velocity-pressureresponsefor a gabbro with only 1.77oporosity and then heatedthe gabbro to 750'C and cooled it, after which they repeatedthe velocity-pressuremeasurement(fig. 5.4). The loweringof the velocity pressure curveis presumedto be due to the creation of new microcracks.After being subjectedto pressure,the samplereturnedto a higher velocity when the pressurewas lowered;presumablv. the pressurehealedsome of the microcracks.probably,repetition of the pressurecyclewould heal more mrcrocracksand elevatethe velocity-pressurecurve s