E Y E W I T N E S S
A L S O BY J E D P E R 1
Paris "Iriritbc3trtIt~nJ
Gallery Cioing
E Y E W
T N E S S
R E P O ...
41 downloads
3177 Views
25MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
E Y E W I T N E S S
A L S O BY J E D P E R 1
Paris "Iriritbc3trtIt~nJ
Gallery Cioing
E Y E W
T N E S S
R E P O R T S
A N
A R T
WORLD
J E D
F R O M
I N
C R I S I S
P E R L
BASIC B O O K S A N i - W IZt PLJHL I C B O O K
Cop>right G7 2OlfOb! Jed f'erl f%trbfr\hedby Rksxc ffocrkr, Pi Member t j t the 13erwu\t3ook\ (;rc)uy> Mo,t of the rnaterral tn thi\ book oripirrally appeared, in somewhat ilifferent form, 1x1 Thc~?ir\v Ki.ytrrhl~c ""A Ikgeant" wa,s firc,t pul>hrhcd1x1 .$$t?drvn Parnfrn. .it11 r~ghtsreserved, Printiscl in the IIz1ztc.d Statcc, of fuznerisd. So part tjf this I>ijcjli may be reproduc-ed In xllnnner u hat\tirver n lrhou t n rirren pernllsrxc~nexcept in the cacle ot' brief qutrrations r~~~bcbdiecl in critical article\ and re.cre.i\S. Idor inlijrmatron, addrest Rasis X3ocllis, 10 East 53rCi Street, Ne\\ York, ?\;Y10022- 5299.
Pert, jcd,
t.! c"\\7itnc\\: report\ from 211 art ortd in cristc, / Jcd Ikrl. 1.). crl1. "4: Sew itrpublic bt~ok." I ncludes index. ISlft\; 0-465-lf552tf-lt
I.
Art, Modern
NT4"3f..P389 2000
701 ",18 dc2Z 99-049794
2 0 t h century 2, A r t , 1. fltl~*,
C O N T E N T S
ARTISTS A N D AUDIENCES
C O N T E M P O R A W DEVELOPMENTS
7uvmtts!y (I* p ~ l t t t ~ painrgrig r!~
T~~7onlhl~ -1lnle
Slrrrek4, Ifrtai~,"claumarr
Hulrhwi C4 R If
Solitary in the City cjf Art \ttar Stones
Kltuj
T&r lvvr tYV!itttzr? 1Jz~mtt~xl
L0~7rdOll(;rlt
LPl~ilKo>s~?[~
Born liz~deuSaturn
13zlE-jsn~~n
The 3 hlrcS t 1egue.c
w i ~ ~si~lf-ttlar~ lt
Rmtrcusl
4n lirlknown Rldsterfrtlece Ircxn Efilrat 4bstrac.t Rla tters
jotzlt
S t ~ j d i ~(I4r uh,frbt~-tpultrtlrtjl
Launsir tY l~tthtt~sdot t l r (l
k n ~ c r ~ c aIteal n
A
i t l ? ~ t ~ t ~rt~t~llstn ~ ? ~ ~ ~ d ~ > ~
Flag IJurnir~g jcl?ip~rjobltl~ The %peof I < c c ' ( I ' L c ~ ~
haft f ;olb2lt1 l Aart 111 ?iwYt?d
j ~ f ftVizLl
Imper\tjna1 linchantmcnt
t.art h
7 ~ m m Rrfl a c"
4 I'rtgeant
A
Ilntils~-~~?e painrzn(9
7 wildr \Ytnkfii~Ii;Z
1 ?path and Kealirnl
C:httik
C:lit,\c. Iialsrrel Ltrderrraurr
A R O U N D THE M U S E U M S
I-aornlalAti-lca I'rttntlng
14,
",4frli~~7 h~ Art
i$U
121?t~ttt~~rlt " ~t JIZP I;ugaqmhslm
a \ttc>man I,orcd . ~ ~ I C E P(i~mhodftl-ft IZ~ (~rt
4 Serpent, a Smlc. a Pryer Latc5t and C ;rc"atc"\t Scstt~ngt l x Stage
Ifrirqur'.c
l a t ~u v ~ k
E'htlttt~n l thr Ifallrts RUSJPS A
CO n t e n t 5 Acropolis Now
Thp Cetty Center in Los Angeles
Bring in the Amuteurs
Impressionist exhihitions
Being Geniuses Together
Culder, Lider €6 Aulro
265 284
293
T H E A R T OF S E E I N G
A cknnwledpwnts
33 1
Index
33.3
E Y E W I T N E S S
This page intentionally left blank
A R T I S T S
A N D
AUDIENCES
This page intentionally left blank
About a ciecacie ago, \\-hen Cindy Sherman started she\\-ing her big <:ibiichrome self-portraits and it seemed as if rver\- hot artist in New York \\-as into photographic imagery. an editor from a general interest \\-eekly magazine called me to n k if I'd be interested in doing a story about Sherman. Actually, the piece he had in mind m-ould look at much more than Cindy Sherman. This editor m-anted a \\-rim to survey the m-hole phenclmenon of artists who appopriate photography; Sherrie i.evine had been rephotographing classic images for a couple of years, and I)oug and Mike Starn \\ere beginning to cause a stir \\-ith their collages made of stained and ripped photcrgraphs. The editor knen- that I didn't haye an!; patience for Sherman's l\-ork. In fact. he was interested in me in part hecause I'd already \\-ritten n thumbs-~iokvnpiece. My opinions, he assured me. kveren't a problem: I could sav anything I wanted in the article. He \\-asn't interested in \\-hether the work was gr30d or bad. He \\-as interested in all the exciten~entthat Cindy Sherrnan and these other artists m-ere generating.
In the m-eek or so het\%-eenhis call and the lunch date that l\-e arranged.
I found myself regarding the project =with increasing trepidation. I didn't think I could cio the piece, and \\-hen \ve got together I explained \\-h?. I iiislikecl Sheman" svork passic~natelv;h t ~ m\. t ctecision \\-as based cm sclntething more than my reaction to the lvork. My feeling \\;is that Sherman's notoriety \\-as ba\ically a public relation5 gambit. and I ciidn't \\-ant to hecome a part of the PR. At that point m\- lunch companion began to act rather uneasy. He haci meant the assignment as an opportunity for me, and he found m\- qualms more than a little t3izarrc. The more we talkeci, the
more hostile he becan~e.He accused rile cif carecrisn~;and an odd kind of reverse careerism it \\-as that \voulci have me turning cio\vn \\hat \\-as clearly a major a\rignment. He was so upset that he sugge\ted that I pay for m\- half
of otrr meal, Things calmeel dcxvn a little by the time \ve got to the espresso. He asked if there \\-as another story that I wanted to do. Therc \\;is. I suggesteel that in hict therc is a \;\-holecitl~erart worlcl ciut there-kvhat
a lot of rrs have conle
to call, shortlland style, the real art n-orltf. Therc are artists \I-ho arc wi~rking consistentb, evolving in boom tirue\ and in bust time\, and I pri>po\ed that they deserve a hell of
3
lot more attention than they receive. I ex-
plained that I didn't m-ant to add fuel to the Sherman boom preci\ely because booms like this one are sucking life ancl energy out of the other art \I-orld. Art stars like Sheurnan-and
David Salle and Julian Schnahel-have
distorteel the art scene. Their exhibitions cion't give public expression to private feelings so much as they offer canny responses to market pressures. The mass appeal of an arti\t like Schnabel has everything to cio with his indifference to \\-hat ought to he an artist's most urgent concern. \\-hich is the internal logic of a work of art. 4 s for the arti\ts who do care ahout \\hat goes on i n d e art, they arc being left with fewer and fewer outjets for their work.
R\- no\;\-the serious nrti\ts are desperate: they're gasping for air. As it happeneel, I \\;is able to name at lea\t one member of this other, private art \\-orld that the eclitor knem-. "Oh her." he said. "Is she important?" I tolci him that to many people she is one of the best sculptors alive, but he seemed nonplussed l,\- the thought. and also l,\- m\- idea for an alternative story. He'd calleel me up to commission an article ahout an art star. not to
find o u t that there is a r o m p l e t e h different, unglamorous, half-buried scene out there. You don't have to knon- anything ahout art to know tha.t thc art \\-orlcl is surcfire cultural entertainment, and that was the one thing this editor
knem- for sure. .4 hit of Sherman hashing would he okay: n little outrageciuhness on the part of artists and critics alike helps to give the art world its appeal. People like to hear that the art stars are overinflated. That's part of the titillation. But n-hen ytju tell an editor thzt something more is at stake, that the hype around the public art \\-orld may actually hurt somehod\-. that is too much. Nobody \v;ints to believe that the art stars are ciestroying the visual arts. If that's the case. things could begin to get depressing. Yau might even end up feeling guilt\- for having treated the art \\-orld as a playground. as little more than high-end medin gossip. Rut of course the editor found somehod\- \vho \vould do the job he \\antecl done. A couple of months later, I openeii up that magazine and there \\-a\ Cinciy Sherman, larger than life.
Taken at kicc value, that lunch ciate, though a less than perfectly amizihle mcounter, \\;isn't really worth kvorrying about. Rut I think something fundanlental \\as at stake. The eciitor I \\-as talking \\-ith is a serious fellow, and he ol?viously felt that by looking at some murh-talked-about n e n art. and ho&-it's being pron~otedand d i s ~ ~ ~ s and s e ~\vho's i, selling and \vho's buying. \\-e coulci learn something not only about the \\-ork of these photo artists but also ahout ourselves. I can appreciate this line of thinking, but onlv up to a point. People h;tve always been kiscinated l,\- the relationship het\\-een the contest in which art is experieawd and the sontent of art itself. K'hv shotrlcln? they l-te?But\;\-henan editor tells a critic that it doesn't really matter if you like the work or not, just so long as you report on \\hat everybody is saj-ingahout it. my alarm bells start going off. Ke are at a point where context is in danger of sxviimping contmt. 'I'he itssumpticlns I brought to that lunch date are the sitme ones I bring to a gallery or a museum shm-. I believe that a \vork of art must have a free-
standing value. Formal value, are one element in the equation: I take it for granteci that a \%-ork\%-eexperience visually must he visual1~-resolved. Rut the arti\t \vho gives this \%-orkits value is pulling together all kinc1s of experiences. Narrative mai- be as important as color; the startling character of the imagery mai- be \I-hat fuels the vigor of the line. Vi'i~atcclunts is that \%-hateverthe artist is thinking or feeling is absorbed into the look. the rharacter. the intricacies of the \\-ork. The painting, the sculpture, the collage, the assenlblage makes its own terms, and n-e judge what we see. Notv I'm sure that that editor believes in the freestanding value of
3
'i%-ork of art, But I h l atso kiirlv certain that he believes that stlch value is colclred, mt~tated,rvvalued by the context in \%-hichtve see the
\%-G&.
it paint-
ing or sculpture that he might agree is not especially engaging gains interest-which
for him may be equivalent to value--hecause
there's a lot
of buzz around it. because it's expensive, or heciiuse it's being promoted by the right celllector, dealer, curator, or critic. (If cclurse people h c e altvays been interested in some version c~f~ v l ~11-e a t now think c~fa\ market fcjrces and fashion shifts, hut never hefcjre have sc, manv intelligent people been so \%-illingto believe that art is at the mercy of life. that art is less a thing unto itself than a habit of mind, a sort of accent or highlight that can adhere to anything. .4nd so l\-e are urged to regard fashion as art. career as art, money a, art, The ever-iieepening ciividc between \%-hatI think of as the put3lic and private art \%-orldsis less the product of market forces than the result of this funditmental disagreement about the nature of art. The freestanding value of art is e,sentiall\- an insider's idea. born of the experience of the studio. m-here emoac~ns,sensibilities, and experiences are given a form that can carry meaning. That the \\-hole tvorld should revere the stan~l-alonemagic of such \%-orks---ofa Rembrandt self-portrait, for example. or of Mon~lrian'sBmililwirj) oes not make this any le,s a private ideal. The \\-orid gcxs to
the Rembrandt or the Mondrian for the explosively, expansively private expmiences that they afford. ( )r so I believe. The contextualists see it differently. For them, Remhran~lt'sself-portraits are mostly of interest as reflections of a seventeenth-century idea of the individuaI: they're about marketing in~lividualism. And Mon~lrian'sRnriiiiwir) Boogiu B7,iytr is n sort of seismographic record atomization and alienation. &%rt, in short, ~loesnot so of twentieth-cent~~ry much shape the m-orld as it is shaped by the world. Pikintin85 ancl sculptures are tokens ancl artifacts: they're regarded as the sloughed-off shells of cultural or social experiences. This vie- may originate in a nineteenth-century reaction agiinst the bourgeois sentimentaliration of art. But \\hat begin as an anticq3italist critiy rrc has tilrned out to be a markter" dream. The Marxist \vho saj-Sthat no artist's imagination is free has provided a comfortable context for the corporate executive who \\-ants tci fund only the museum retrospctive of the artist \vhci\e \vork has the lvidest appeal. ( If
course I'm dra\\-ing the lines a little more clearly than they are gener-
ally drawn in life. Many people m-ho concern themselves with the visual arts k n m - that a painting or sculpture ought to stand alone; they are contextualists only to a certain degree. But the drift of current thinking is invariably in the contextualist direction, and cc~ntemporar~ artists who don't tilt that jq-ay are bound to have a hard time. Take the painter roan Snyder, whose - .emotions ought to jq-onderfully extravagant presentations of high-flving
give her work a \vide appeal. In large, panoramic pitintings such as .? .bil . $ t t ~ ~ ~
riliil iy irri Opttmii, Siiyiler gives almost operatic rolorings to theme, of death and hope; she does this kind of thing Inore convincing1y than any other artist of our day. Yet Snyiler, who \\-as horn in 1940, has not yet had a significant Nrm- York muheurn show, a fact that I beheye is linked to the emphatically private, freestanding nature of the work she cloe,. Her pitintinps don't appeal to the contextualists, and t h y pretty much contrtst the upper ecfielons of the art e\tal->listiment,
C i n d ~Sherman, by contrast, is a phenomenal success precisely because her \;\-arkis atl at-tcirrt the c-ultrrral context. 111her early IJtgftled iC~lniStzZ/s, Sherman managed to give these contextualist theme* some visual musicality. I don't think thzt the lintrtiirld Film Jtrlls are a galvrmic achievernmt, but Sherman's small-sized self-portraits, in which she enacts dozens of movie ancl TV scenarios, ciffer such delicate variations on c-incn~aticconventiclns that the camp sensihi1it:- achieves n certain detached. dream-like unity. In the m-ork that Sherman has done since the hint Stills, however-and
this incluiies ever!--
thing from her stage\- impersonations of figures in ()Id Master portraits to a recent series focusiq on battered (2Joe and Ken dolls-the
dramatics are lit-
tle more than talking points and polemical ilouri,he,. Sherman's costumes and disguises are custom-made for the contextualists; her lnutating imagery is just right for an audience that twlieves th;tt art has no substance, no e\sence. Sherman's defenders m-ill n q u e that her house-of-mirrors images are part of a long tradition. and there is no denying that the assault on the stand-alone integrity of art has come from u-ithin art itself and has been aimed l;\-itha ~ieathlyprecision that only insiders could muste.;, As early as the 1880s. a group of Parisian artists \vho called themselves the Incohkrents highlighted the preposterousness of official art l,\- creating \\hat amounted to the first anti-art, The Incohkrents turned arti\tic c-onventions into hovc-ling ahsuriiities when they carried lyric elusiveness into mind-numbing emptine,~ancl twisted expressive dramas into cartoonish confusions. There is certainly some intellectual allure to the games that the Inioh4rents played. .4nd no one can deny that Marcel Duchamp's steel-trap enigmas have had a vast appeal. Yet \\hen a skepticism about the essential value of art is buift into art, jq-C are in for bad tirtle*. \Xihether you call this approach Iladaist. contextualist, situationist, or some other name, the assun~ptionis that art idbtrrn, lives, and dies in the public sphere. Such an art can have no free5tanding value; the very idea of
value is regarded a\ a social construct. It's ciifbcult to defend art against this contextualist assault, especially if we are hone\t enough to admit that although art has a freestanding value it stands in different places at ciifferent timer. ( Ince we have acknon-ledged that art is ah-ays on the move, the contextualists will saj- that we have given a%-aythe game. Rut to argue that a stained-gla\s \\-indo%-in (:hartrcs (:;tthedral or a painting of lovers in a park l,\- R t t e a u achieves its stand-alone authority in relation to a particular time and place is not to deny that each 11-orkhas n life of its 011-n. And fcx those of us m-ho still crave the thrilling experiences that only art can offer, understanding exactly where the contntu;tlist a\sault came from may he far less important than figuring out \\here \\-e go from here. I kno%-that there are still plenty of artists and gallerygoers and museumgvwuvho \\ant that stand-alone experienle. Rut in a \\-orld \\-here the art market seems to have n ~ o r intellectual c cachet than art itselt; there may be nothing more difficult than finding a \\-a!- for artists ancl audiences to come together ancl artu;tlly, ,imply, look at art.
The glanlour factor in the art world is nothing new. r t chat has been keeping people amused. annoyed, sedurcci, irate for a very long time. In m e r ica. the modern puhlicitv mills began to crank up \\-ith the Armory She\\- of 1913, hut the)- nnlv really got gc,ing in 1949, when L!fi magazine gave its
reaclers a good laugh l,\- supge\ting that Tackson Follock. a moody Green\\-ich Village legend \vho likeci to drip paint, just might be the greatest artist alive. (Ince the public had kvondered at and h<)%-ledover Pcillock, the pattern \\-as set and people were screaming for more. Pop Art \\-as hog heaven. and everybody hopped on the art merry-go-round. If you couldn't afford n Tasper Johns F l ~ g at , least you cc~uldafford the &%merican flag canisters that
\\-ere sold at hip shops like z u m a . B\- the 1080s it \\-as taken for granted that R l l Street money fueled the carnival, and everybody \\-as talking about the \\-aiting list to t3u-y pitintings at the Marv Boone Gallery and ahou t the size of the latest art star" loft iin SclHo. Looking back on all of this, there are those \\-h0 \\-ill say that my talk \I-ith that maprtzine editor \\-as just bt~sinersas t ~ s ~ l aThe l , media, after all, have their share of fairly sophisticateci st;ltus quo t!pes. and if you begin to say that the hype has gone out of control, they'll pml7;tbly tell you that it \I-as just as b d back in the nineteenth century, \I-hen Bat~dela.ireand Daumier m-ere complaining about the philihtines at the Salons. Rut of course knov\-ing that things were h d once ilpc-m a time does not mean that they are necessarily okay today. I11 any event. t h i n g are not all had. Far from it. I11 the galleries there is go0~1\vork to be seen. In the studios of Nen Yorkand, for all I knovl; across the country-artists
in their 30%and 40s and 50s
and 60s are lnaking the incremental developments and the leaps that take art to a ne'iq- place. But even as the headlines have shifted from julian Schnabel's plate smashing, to Terse Helms's NE.% hashings-and
now, in the
late '90s. to the architects \\-h<)design the museums where all the overscaled art of the past quarter century is going on perinanent display-the
most
important story in the art \vorld remains untold. The support system of galleries, grants. collectors, curators, and puhlications that makes it possible for artists to h;tve slow-~1evelopi11g,seriou:. carecrs is in a s t s e of near total collapse. Mo:.t of the people \vho believe in the frees e n ~ l i n gvalue of art have twen s i l e n c e d l f not s ~ - e pa\va\-. t This is \vh;tt you hear if vou talk to the artists. I*ivingin the midst of an overinilated art \vorld. an art \\-orId m-here context is all, painters and sculptors no longer know \\-here to turn. Fe\\-er and few-er sho\vs get reviewed t3ecause the work has some inherent qualiw: fern-er and fewer galleries are \villing to make the rommitlnent to an artist's gradual drvelopmmt. The art 11-orld,to the extent that
it s u p p x t s a vital evolutionary process, is on the verge of extinction. The artists---let me emphasizt.*are
still at \\-ark. Rut they are in drspitir. and their
despair is ttlrninf: into a masochistic malaise that threatens them horn within, even as career options ~lisiippear.\%%at f
big part-lf
its signihcance.
Wlho exactly are these artists who are not receiving the support that the\- need and cieserve! I could name many, each a different case. each unable to receive a proper hearing. Th begin. I m-ant to point briefly to two: Barbara C;oodstein and Stanley Lewis. Rtlth are in their 50s, both have
shorn-n at snlall cooperative galleries in New York (:it\- for years. ( h o d stein is probahlv the most original sculptor of her generation. The landscapes in her show at the Bo\\-er\-Gallery in the spring of 1999 announced a ne\\- pastoral mode, a p a t o r a l in m-hich serenity seems to he kvrenched from the jangling upheavals of modern life. 4 s for i.enis, some of the landscape paintings and &a\\-ings that he has produced in the past q u u t e r century are as beautiful as any that have been created anywhere in the \\-orld ciuring this period. n d the large. denselv \\-orked drawings of studio interiors that he ertfiibited in 1995 are among the most eioqurnt imp w s i o n s of the space m-here an artist creates t h a t I have ever seen. C;oo~isteinand Len-is come out of an t~ndergroundart \\-orfd where tradition and innovation are still believed to be reconcilable. Yen- k r k e r s may pay lip service to this vie\\-point, hut if you're looking for a clever career move, you'd be advised to look else\\-here. 11-hich hasically means you'd he advised to join fcjrses 11-ith the contextu it l'1st~. C;oci~istein'ssculpture is in 10%- relief, and her technique is nhsolutelv her
m-n. She \\-arks in plaster on plywood hoards, building up this 11-ondrrfully fluid material into fi~rmsthat are a sculptor's reconsideration of the traditions of pitinter!? painting. Her subjects are the figure and the landscape, hut every-
thing in her \\-orks is simplified. reduced. so that \\-hat meets the eye is a sequence of iconic, telegraphic signs. A panoramic lanclscape is transfcirmeii into a couple of undulating arabesques. A house next to a tree is evc~kedwith the deliberate brevity of (:hinew calligraph7-.Some of C;oodstein's fillest figure pieces are variations on ciailsical themes-the'l'lrw~
I;lac-ni,
the Plrtlvand here
she seems to feel the pressure of the \\-hole tradition pushing her for\\-ard. ( Iften she paints the boards black or clark green, so that the pats and lines and jabs of plaster stand out like stars in a night sky. Her figures are summations. abbreviations. The cycle of Ihrrr [;rdrri is her memory of Raphael rememhering Pompeii. (;oodstein's \\-ork, \vith its passionate mix of c o n v e h c ~ n a l sorrrces and uniomentional methods?is astcmishi~lglyconcise, Stank\- idem-is'srcpre\entational paintings arc also informed by a taste for abstraction. I_e\\-ishas a gift f63r ripe. painterly surfaces and for plangent, gray-purple-green tonalities. His landscapes may renlind people of the work of contemporary English Expressionists, of Leon Kossoff and especialiy Frank huerbarh. The jagged fc3rms in idem-is'slandscapes could even strike some gallerygoers as t,orro\vings from huerbarh. hut I find Le~visat his best to be an infinitely more satisfying and original artist than huerbarh ever is. In Lem-is's smalli\h paintings. the angles and elisions that suggea a kiscinatingly- lab\-rinthine . smse of spare really add up: they give us a complete view. And no one else has rendered the odd, edgj- spares in suburban nlericathe sides of roads, the gas stations-\\ith
quite the lyric delicacy that Le~vis
achieves. His .4merica. shamhly ancl appealing, is not unlike Kossoff's I.ondon. In recent years. some of Le%-is'smost complex and t3eguiling inventions have been his clra~q-ings.The big, heavily \\-orked \ie%-s of his 0%-n jam-parkeci stuciio. with pencil lines jablung into and even tearing at the paper. have a thrillingly overeliiborate~Mannerist power. Terrific \\-ark--by artists \vho range in age from their late 30s to their earl\- 70s-isn't
alxx-ays ignorecl entirely, but it rarely receives the conien-
trated, serious attention that it cleserves. Khy isn't there more focus on the abstract sculpture of Geoffrey Meyxvorth and the figure sculpture of Robert Taplin and Natalie <:harko\\-; on the abstract paintings of Spencer C;regory. Rill Rarrell. Pat .&darns, Shirley laffe. Thornton \Krillis, and Trevor Kinkfield; on the geometrized realities that \\-e encounter in the \\-ork of iacqueline Uma, Richard <:hiriani, and .%IfredRussell; and on the various kinds of representational painting that are clone by Rita Raragona. Richarcl La Prcsti, Carl Plansky. Temma Bell, Mari I.yons, I.ouis;t Matthiiisdottir, Cial-triel 1,adernlan. 1,ennart ,%nderson,Hefen Miranda Kilson, I,isa 2%-erling,and Ned Small! I could mention more artists \vho are equally gifted. equally deserving of ;ldditional attention. Even \\-hen painters \\-h0 are doing major m-ork have reasonahl>; big follol\-ings---I'm thinking, again, of loan Sn\-der, and also of Rill Tensen-they
seem to remain co-
terie tastes, admired in art departments, collected to some degree, hut not reall\- part of the American art establishment that is known around the world. As for Barhitra (;ooilstein3s and Stanley Lekvis's work, it's rarely seen by an\-hod\- he\-oncl , n small circle of admirers. .%nd despite the extraordinary ability these artists have demonstrated to go it alone, to sta\- focused on the freertanding value of art, the long-term effects of ruch a restricted atldienze cannot he healthy. The absence of significant financial rewards is one prohlem, and by no means a mincir one. I_rwis,e*peciiilly, has had a significant teaching career, lvhich ran fill the financial void. Rut even if W-easbume that comlnitted arti\t\ do fincl a \\-ay to survive financially, there remains a larger question. Khat happens to an artist \vhc)re clevelopment receives so little public recognition! I am not speaking here about unfulfilled promise. I am referring to artists \vho have done an immense amount ancl no%-,at rnid-career. arc at the point where the\- have to find it \\-ithin themselves to do even more. Can artists keep on doing their ~lamnecle\t\\-hen the \\-ide \\-orld
doesn't give a ciarnni The que\tion needs to be addressed right no\\. h generation thttt is coming into its 0 % - n t h a treally has already come into its o\vn-is
having a terrible time nlaking contact \\-ith the audience it de-
serves. Both <;oodstein and Lewis 0%-ea debt to the painter Ideland Bell. \\-h0 died in 1091 at the age of 69. Bell's grandly scalecl tigurc compositions have a hard-edgecl yet free-flokving exuberance. and there's an astonishing!\- elegant vehemence to many of his self-portraits and portraits. These pitintinps, \\-ith their from-the-ground-up structural concision. supge\t a number of ~ - 9 ins n-hich a representational artist can learn horn abstraction. Certainly
both C;oodstein and I,ewis h c e built on some of Bell's idea\. But a comparison between his career and theirs makes it clear how much more clangerilus it is to be an independent artist trlrlay than it was a generation
ilr
two
ago, \\-hen Bell \\-as lnaking his \\-ay. Bell \\-as often described as the archetypal art world outsider. Emerging in the years \\-hen Pop r t ' s clever Zeitgeist reaclings were dominating the news, Bell insisted that art has its 0%-nlogic, its 0%-npo%-er.True. he hardly ever sold a painting. But he had a distinguished dealer in Robert Schoelkc~pf,and over the \-ears he \\-as the subject of feiiture articles in .?ris.
j l r i lYeu, (h\- John .4shhery), A r t rn jlmrrzr-tr (by rohn Hollancier). anci the ~YPW
York Iitrz~c,and in 1987 he tinally received a retrospective at the Fhillips Collection in Kashington. I).<:. Barhara C;oodstein, although her sculpture doesn't look anything like Bell's painting, is the artist \\-h<)I expect will carry Bell's brand of radically simplified representation into the nest century, yet she has never had a dealer committed to her n-ork, has never been the subject of
3
feature article in an art magazine. has never even had a
\\-ork in a museum shm-. The ciifference in their careers tells you something \-er\- scary about the ever-ciiminishing opportunities for serious art since Bell arrived in Nevc- York in the 1940s.
In order to see \\h!
it is so much harder for authentic in~iepen~lent \\-ork to
pn)rper no\\- than it was a generation ago, l\-e have to look beyond career specifics to the overall structure of the art scene. The art world that \\-as tmrn in New York after n r l d War II is mo\ing into its sixth decade, and \\-hat \\-e've been seeing in the past fen- years is a svstemic crisis. Matters have reached the point \\here nothing in the art \\-orld really seems to kvork any l o n g e ~ n oin t a \\-ay that encomages n-hat I m-ould call major art, anym-ay, Kcrrc living in a dysfunctional art \\-orld. And to understand this disoriier, \I-e must tlnderstand u-fiat made the scene ftlnction (although often haltingly and half-fieartedly) in the first place. The Nem- York art world has all\-ay\ had t\\-o ciimmsions: one public, one private. To the extent that there \\-as ever n meaningful relationship bet ~ - e e there n realms, the public art world n-as an outgrokvth-and reflection-of
at best a
the private art world, of the autistshrt world. It is al%-ay\in
the artistshrt n-orki that forms are reimagined and rcinvented, and that new expressive possibilities r-omr into their on-n. (If course this split het\\-een a public ancl n private art m-orld is nothing new. The Salons and academier of eighteenth- ancl nineteenth-century liurope, lvhich generally operated under government auspices. arteci as clearinghouses, making career defining decisions about which artists would gain access to commisions, patrons, and the public that visited major exhihitions. Neeci I point out that these premodern and early modern inrtitutions had more than their share of bt~rcauzratiirigidities? The every-man-fcjrhimself free-for-all that began to take shape in the late nineteenth century, as artists fcjund themselves competing for representiition by an ever-grokving number of commercial galleries, \\-as a \\-elcorne change. In many respects the commercial dealers succeeded in giving individu;tl arti\ts a more
direct access to the public. The relativel~rapid acceptance of as radical a devejopment as abstract art \\-outd have been inconceiv;tblr n-itl~outthe more fluid relationship betm-een artist and audience that was fostered bj- a new generation of activist clealers. In the )-ears after \*rErorld WLr 11, when the Ne\v York art would its u-e knonit \\;is first coming into focu:,, the private ancl public spheres were in a hirlv health\- balance. ;i\-ant-garde Paris was a huge in\piration. n d an all-American clistaste for official patronage and the rigiditie:, of tradition helpeci to give the Nen York situation a livelv, improvisational chararter. Many people t3elieved that a new kind of audience \\-as coming into being-an
audience
t h t was more ad.\-cntureson~e, more independent. This was true, at least up to a point. There \\-as an eciuiated public that took an interest in deselopments at the Museum of Modern Art and the Khitney, in art coverage in
lirnr and L$>, in the lineup at international shows such as the Venice Riennale. and in exhibiaons at a f e blue-chip ~ commercial galleries, such as those of Sidne\- lanis and, later, Leo Castelli. Rut if avant-gardism \\-as in certain respect\ in sync l\-ith an older American feeling for the importance of the individual, there \\ere also danger signs. In the egalitarian atmosphere of Ye\\- York, even rawal gallerygoers could begin all too e a d v to imagine that they un~lerstoodmore about the avant-garde imagination than the\: reidly did. <:ontext \\-as beginning to c>\-ertakecontent. The sophisticated public's go\sip~familiaritv m-ith the life and time, of lackson Pollock or Killem de Kooning set the stage for a new kind of ultra-hip philistinism. .4nd artists who m-anted to be better knoll-n \\-ere sometimes glad to confuse the put7lic imagination =with their o\\-n. "Let your monstrous subconscious make n quick buck for yoursrlf." the painter .4d Reinhardt announced in one of his ciirtoon collages. published in the magazine trun,[i;irteuirari in 1952. "Hollar 'Hang the museums!"' he urged. "until the\- hang you, then clam up and collect."
The curators, dealers, and editors who \\-ere shaping this kist-gro\\-ing public art m-orld had been 11-eanedon the legendary doings of early-tkx-entieth-century figures such as m b r o i s e \rc,llard. I);lniel-Henry Kahnkveiler. and Gertr~ldeand l,eo Stein. The tastemakers at New York's museums, ,galleries, and magazine, saw that their predecessc~rshad looked to iirtists fcjr guidane, and the\- n1e;lnt to do the same in %\v York. Thev cared, elpecially after the m-ar, about \\-hat the ?lunger painters and sculptors m-ere doing, and they agreed \\-ith the artists \\-h0 sal\ the blue-chip galleries as fitting into a \\-ider constellation of galleries and exhibitions, \\hi& included developments at some important artist-run cooperatives and artist-organired exhibitions (the Tenth Street annuals are an example). The artists \\-ere certainly a%-arcof the expitnding coverage in the more popular magazines, hut the\- n-ere also deeply absorbed h)- the &"rr.lrssitrnsthat m-ent cm at the r t i s t s ' Club. and l,\- the hundrecis of short revie&-*of exhil3itions that appeared in the art magazines each and every month and added u p to n t,lo\v-by-blo~-account of %-hatartists \\-ere doing. 'I'he line betxeen the publjc art \\-orld and the private art world n-as ntrt alxx-ays clear. and that porousness could be n good thing, at l e a t m-hen it \\-orked to give private expressions a public dimension. The art magazines them,elves had both a public and a private side. You might say that the feature articles in the art magazine, \\ere public, \\-hereas the short revie&-*of crne-person she\\-s m-ere a piirt of the private kvorld. Art coverage in literary and political magilzine, such as the
lydtitrtr
and P L I T ~ ~RV~IPM. S ~ F I despite their
small readerships, coulci spitn the tkx-o realm,, as did certain galleries. such as Betty Parsons' and Mrtrrha Tackson's. ,%nti when Alfred H. Barr Tr., the fc3unding director of the Museum of Modern Art. took a part in arasts' gatherings downto%-n.he \\-as shokving ho\\ involved he \\;is \\-ith that more private art kvorld. In 1960, in a letter to the 1Yi.w York Tlrirnrs, Rarr said, "The artists l e d : the museum follows, exhil?iting, collecting and publishing their
\\-ork. In so cioing it tries to act with both \visdorn and courage, hut also \vith akvareness of its 011-n &illihility."Surely this \\-as the truth, but the very fact that it neecieci to be stated so t3luntly suggeaed that by 1960 there was reason to \\-oncler if things \\-ere really still \\-orking this \\-ay. The essential point is that through most of the '501, ancl to a lesser degree even into the '60s and 'TO%, the value, and reputations that don~inntedthe public art 11-orldm-ere often fc>rrnedin the artists' private art world. The &ime that dc Kooning and Follock achieved in those years \\;is an outgrowth of their downto%-nreputaticrns. 1do not mean ttr suggest that there \\-as ever a time \vhm everything \vent right. Far from it. The gonrr, careerism that \\-e think of as characteri,tic of the '80s had its origins in the '501, ancl there were all\-ays reputations that were largely shapeii by the public art \\-orid. Rut the fact is that, e,pecially in the '50s and '601, a great deal of the art that made its \\-a\-uptonn had its origins 40%-ntonn,in a culture in lvhich public reno%-n, although desirable, \\-as not a formative value, not the litrntlh test it n-ould he once iontextualism was king. lPhtls in the '51)s, and to a lebser extent all the \\-a\-into the '70s, the public art \\-orlci could he said to be an imperfect but still pretty reliable mirror of the artists' art world. \\-here \\-hat really mattered u-as tlie freestanding value of a \\-ark of art. hforc tha.n that, there \\-as a sense among artists, and among those v\-tlo fc,ilo\\-eciart clo,ely, that a public reputation was of value only to the extent that it \\-as seconded by artists. Many of the painters and sculptors \\-h0 crowdeci into the Cedar Ta-ern, the Cireenwkh Village hangout that the Abstract 1:xpressionists made famous in the 19Sf)s,took it for granted that even those \\-h0 had succcedeii upto%-n\\-ould ultimately be jucigeci dolvntown. Some of this was lip service, but rnt~shof it was not. There n-as a story that circulated about how cieliphtell Tackson Follork \\as \\hen Earl Kerkam, a marvelouh painter of figures and still lifes who had an archetypal artists' art world reputation, let him tinon- that some recent \\-ork n-as "'not
t3itci." The point of the anecdote is that Follock. cie\pite his public ktrne. hungereci for a kincl of appmval that only the arti\tsSart \vorlci could provide. In the criticism that the pitinter Fairfield Porter \\;is \\-riting in the early
'hOs, the ktrnous ancl the not-$0-kmous and the barely knolvn are discussed next to one another, and they are judged bitsicallt- not in term, of their success in the big public m-csrltf but in terms of the value thrtt their n-ork has for their peers. No matter how \\-ell-kno\vn an artist became, the jucignlents of fellow arti\ts continued to be extremelt- important, Mark Rothko's depression in the 1060s cannot he separated from his alvareness that many artists and m-riters believed--and
this belief %-asreflected in e5sa)-s in little maga-
zines such as Scrup and E\.ergmi.rr Rerrart.
that he hrtd fallen into a formula,
\\-hich his spectacular success, including a retrospective at the Museum of hfodern Art, son~ehovconly uncierscored. Rothko conlmitted suicide in 1970, dying in a pool of blood in his stuciio. and there is probably more than n kernel of truth to the luridly elaborate hngiograph\- that has gro\\-n up around that terrible event. There \\ere surely many kctors that fueled his nlassive depression. But \\-h0 can deny that Rothko \\-as at lea\t in part unclone t3j- a ktme thttt, ho\ve\-er much he haci hungered for it, dissolveci the very values that had once sustained him? In Rothko's later years, the public art \vorlci and the private art \\-orld \\ere less and less able to i'unctii~neffectively as two sides of a single, relatively \\-ell-integrated organism. n d if this tkx-o-part organism has continucci to operate at all since the '701, it is only heciiuse it's no\\- operating in reverse, \\-ith the public art \\-orld ciictating the term, of the private one. The growing prestige of .%meriran art gave the freestanding value of art a new context. Artists of Rothko's generation t3enefiteci. Then the c o n t n t devoured the art, If 1%-econsider I3uchamp's gnomic observation. made in 1957, to the effect that the spectator "a~iiishis contribution to the rreathe act." \ve may
begin t o sce that this reversal has a kind of I3adaist logic. Certainly, the Dariaists have done their ciamnecie\t to undermine the stand-alone integwty of art. Rut their authority probably originateh in their hilving been the first people to see the m-riting on the \\-all and to how to m-hat they \\-ere not sorry to believe \\as an inevitability. Ry now, in any event. \\-e are all, Datfaists and anti-Dadaists alike, at the mercy of developments that we are at hest ill-equipped to control. And although l\-e can dexribe these develc,pment =with a gciod deal of accuracy, we may never come up l\-ith a theory that explain5 them entirely to our satiskiction. \%%at m-e do knoll- is that in the nineteenth century the collapse of the old system of Salons and academies set the stage for an increasingly improvi3;ltional interaction between artist and atxdience-and
h r the incandescent excitement of the avant-
garde. Rut apparently a creatWe relationship het\\-een the artist ancl the audience coulci also turn into a collusive relationship t3etiveen avant-gardism and populism. liltimately, t h i increasingly compromised alliance endangercci the arti\t's hard-\\-on modern st;ltuh a\ the person \\-h0 makes private expe"ienr-es public. The t3eginning of the end came \\-ith the explosion of Pop r t in the early 1060s. Rut if I am rorrcc t in t3elieving that the hostilitv to art's standalone poll-er has a long history, then Pop Art \\-as less a catiilyzing force than a neat conclusion. Pop Art's subject lnatter dramatized the shift from a private to a public avant-garde because so many of those Fop image$ and motifs \\ere drawn from material that had no private nleaning for the artists. hndy W~rhol.who came out of the \vorld of adverti\ing, defi~leda nem- kind of art world career-the e .t
career that \\-as conciucteci entirely in the public
that point the public art \\-orld became self-perpetuittinp; or at least
it \\-as then tha.t want-garde art came to be tied to market values rather than to arti\tic valtre\.
A whole culture has g r o ~ - nup in Karhol" 11-ake,a L-nlturethat h!- now include\ its c,\;\-neducational institutions, such ar the <:alifc,rnia Ir~stituteof the Arts, where students are taught little, it seems to me, beyond hou- to have public art world careers. At such institutions, the keestanding value of art is an arcane idea-ar
o d ~ iancl , maybe as oddly charming, ar not \\-raring
\\-hite shoes before Memorial Ilay. The public art \vorlci has hecome self-perpetuating. (:ontextualists are, of course, masters of self-perpetuation. As for the private art world, it has twcorne inrrearingly isolatecl, fracturecl, frozen.
K h e n I talk =with literary people about \\-hat's going on in the art \vorlci, they often see parallels het\\-een art hype and hook hype, and to some extent
I suppo\e these analogies make sense. As a parallel to the artists' arti\ts. to figures like Rarbara Goodstein and Stanle\- Lewis. literary friends \\-ill think of writers' writers and poets' poets. The literary 11-orld,especially in the midst of the conglomeration of publishing in the '90s. offers plenty of analogies. Rut I think that there is reason to t,elie\-e that the art \vorlil is even n ~ o r evulmrable to media forces than the literary m-csrld. Kcxks csf art, \\-hich can be taken in \vith a single glance, create an illusion of instant capture, in\tant expertise. hlthcjugh even a vaguely crcclihle opinion about a novel will involve putting in the number of hours it takes to get through at leart n p u t of the hook, all it takes to have a vaguely credible opinion about of \-our head around a gallery. Visual art a painting by David Salle is n ~1%-erve provides people =with the promise of instant access. Ancl the art that gets the attention satisfies that neecl f m quick satisfaction-it's
all up front, there are
no nuances or mysteries to unravel. It never takes you out of this 11-orld. hfuseums have become the pLrlces where the contemporay art hype reaches the boiling point. The museum, expect to cira\\- audiences of a size
that they never clreanled of before, and they uncierstandrtbly feel that this mlargeci public needs to be given a carefully shaped and predigesteci view of contemporary art. In order to create this neatly tailored picture, curators \\-illfully deny the variety of the contemporary scene; they can't be bothered =with stand-alone. private experiences. liven as the number of arti\ts at \\-ork has expanded geometrically, the number of artists inilucieci in major survevs has p l t ~ n ~ ~ n e tAe dgeneraticrn . ago, the important contemporary ilverviea-s held at the W'hitney in New Ut3rk and
thc I:arnegie in Pittsburgh
contiiined 100 or more artists: today they oftm include n half, or n quarter,
of that ntrmber. The truth is that the old surveys were ciften criticized for their eclecticism and their aimlessnecrs, but in retrclspect u-e can sec that at l e a t they gave a large number of artists some access to a muheurn audie n c e a n c i vice versa. At the same time. they kept curators out of the godlike ptssitiiin they have achieved in recent years. Those older surveys \I-eren't summaries of trends, they were designed fcjr an audience ll-ith some sophistication. an audience that could deal with the varietv of contemporary developments. Today's surveys aren't really surveys at all, they're more like quickie summaries. Museumgoers may feel less overlhelmed, but from the artist's point of vie&-the result is that there are far more artists jockeying for kir fen-er plarcs. n d this means that there's less chance of an artist's m-ork getting to the public. The new surveys are a big lie. snoN- j o h that clistanre the auciience from \\-hat's really going on. The changes in survey she\\-s are only one sign of the increasingly restricted opportunities open to those artists \I-ho are determined to follontheir o\vn lights and create work that does not fit ea\ily with the art \\-orld's formulaic expectations. Another problem is the art magazine,. lvhich have in the p;t\t tkx-enty years largely ahitndoned their old job of reporting what
gee, on in the galleries and instead have become publicitv machines for art stars anci art star \v;innabes. In the '50s and '60s any artist \vho managed to
have a s h o in ~ New York (:it\- was virtually guitranteed at least a brief revieu-. Mo\t revie\\-*at that time were really substantial: the\- really clelved into the 11-ork.They n-ere kvritten by amazingly astute critics, such as the artists Donald j'ud~i.Siciney Tillim. and Fairfield Porter, and the poet lames Schuyler. The importance of short revie\\-$for the art cornmunit\- ciinnot be c,\-erestimated. They nmclunt to n kind of kvritten conversation about art, n reflection of the dialogue that's going on among the artists. Yet now, even \I-ith hundreds more vlleries, fewer s h m - \ are revieu-ed than ever before. The art market, like any area of life in \\-hich large sum, of money arc at stake. has exerted a hszination practically forever. yet there has p r o h a b l ~ never been a time \\-hen the writers and curators and gallery 0%-ners\\-h0 present art to the public have been so 11-illing to all011 content to dissolve into the marketing context. In the pitrt deca~le,an extraordinar\- anlount of attention. both in the art press ancl the main\tream media, has fr~cusedon the crazy prices pitid for contemporary art at auctions and on the 1v;liting lists at the blue-chip pllleries. In the spring of 1999.11-arksby contemporary artists, among them Robert (Goher, 11-ent at auction fcjr a nulnber of price5 in the h~rndredsof tli~ousancisofdollars. This nevc-s har a fascination; but it also leaves a lot of people feeling distanced from contemporary art. Thirty years ago, iollecting iontempcxay art \\-as somrthing that many eciuc;lted people clid, at least in a small \\-a\-.If you c o u l h ' t affc~rdthe paintings, you might buy trriginal graptlics by Picasso and X/lati\se-not
to men-
tion lvorks on pitper l,\- contemporary m e r i c a n s . In fact, it is still possible to collect u-orks of yt~alityfor a feu- thousand dollars. Rut the new4 of the immense prices that are being paid for works by Schnahel and Rasquiatand, now, Shermnn and (Goher-makes
people believe that all art that's
\\-orth having is expensive. And that ties right into the deeper feeling that art no longer has a stand-alone impact, an impact that people can re\pond to irrespective of prices, labels. reputations. n d so lve're losing the old au-
dience of sc~metirneart c-ollectors-the
collectors cif moderate means. The
hype makes people feel that art is out of reach. flverywhere I look there arc signs of diminishing opportunities for seri<,usl\-ork to he seen and discussed. In an article in the A r t lounrui---puhlisk~ed
l,\- the College Art Association. \\-hich is the professional organization for artists and art historims----the painter Philip Pearlstein has discussed n kind of censorship that is not often even recognized. Pearlstein tells of sitting on art panels at the YEA and other institutions where the basic asstlmption is that certain stvles in =which the public art \\-orld isn't interesteci can simply be excluded from cc~nsideration.Among the styles Pearlstein cites arc various kinds of representiitional pitinting ancl \\-hat he calls traditional ahstraction: types of v,-ork, in short. that arc grounded in a belief in the stand-alone value of art. (;rants, even snlail ones, have st~stainedmany unionventional artists. But in recent years, moit grant-giving processes have become t~cspeIessly tied to the market va1~e)of the public art m-orld. K e live in a trickle-cio\\-n art \\orid. Khatever attention and support doesn't go to the art stars seem, to go to their clone,. Art teaching is ciominated by the kvannabes; and all they cio is teach stucients to mimic art-star vait~e\,\\-hich is aI1 they, the teachers, kntrkv h w to do. Kba.t's gcling m in the art schools may be the most ciisa\trous development of all. In the past forty years, the teaching of art in structured academic settings has helpeii sustain pitinting and sculpture in Ye\\-York and the rest of the country. Far from being hiding places for failed artists. art departments have been places \\-here artists \\-h0 \\ere too unconventional or independent to prosper in the marketplace have been able to sustain an art culture of their own. After the 11-ar,arti,ts, among them Ad Reinhardt and Mark liothko, made BrookIyn College one of the country's great art departments. In the early '705,
\\-hen I \\-;is planning to be a painter. some schools still had that kincl of generative power, notably the pitinting depitrtment of the Kansa, City Art In-
stitu te, under the direction of T i l b ~ l rNie\vald, and the (Graduate Program of (2ueens College. \\-here Louis Finkelstein, Rosemarie Beck, and Gahriel Laclerman. among others. \\-ere all teaching. As late as the '70%.the academic net\%-ork,the grant-giving network. and the gallery network \\ere functioning much as thev had in the 'SOS, and in some cases functioning better than they ever haci before. In the '80s. however, every a\pect of the art \vorld began to feel the pressure of the market. for there seemed to he feb-er and fener people who t3elieved that \vh;tt commantled high prices might not he more or less synonymous with \\-hat m-as good. liniversjty administrators became all too conscious of the public art \\-orld, and they began to expect their departments to reflect putdic art \\-orld value,. Something in the inefhhle mix of art and glamour that had attracted Khll Street to SciHo in the first place had an equally stnjng impact on ncadelnics and other intellectuals \\-h0 hilve little. financi~tllyspeaking, to gain. The academics. \\-h0 are more oftm than not inclined to think rontextually, didn't \\ant to he excluded from the party. The party \\-as in full sb-ing in SoMo in the early '80s. Then K'arholism and Keapanomics fell into t3eci together. Then their love child, Robert Mapplethorpe. \\its transformed from a clever aesthete into a martyr at the altar of political art. n d once all this had happened, nol7ody coulci tell any longer \\-here market pressures left off and the pressures of political correctness began. The Left might have been expected to approach a t3ooming art market \\-ith a certain degree of skepticism, hut in recent years this does not seem. l>\-and large, to have been the case. For those \vho arc inclined to see arti\tic vision as essentially grounded in economic or social hctors. the ever-gro\ving pcnver of the market is so perfectly logical a cievelopment that it can inl he regarded by Leftist scholars as a spire glee a\ ea\ily as ~lisrnay.W ~ r h omay kind of demc~nicfigure, hut they can hardly help feeling that he's just the demon the story needed. In the early "Qs, \\-hen 1Varhol fitled canvases with
nothing but dollar signs, he gave these art historians the perfect finish to all their studies of the rise of the market. And the market itself ran begin to look like a radical force-a
force that explodes \\-hat many are inclined to
believe is an antiquated idea of the arti\t as an individual. In the '70s and early '80s an artist pitinting small landscapes or ahstractions \\-ould have been tolci by ciralers that \\-hat the money people \\-anted \I-asn't "just another" landscape or abstraction, no matter ~ O M goad. B\- the late '80s that same a r t i s t l f that artist happened to he a 11-oman-1-ould be tolci by many critics that she haci no right to paint in a traditional genre because those genres m-ere male-dominated. For intellectuals \vho m-ere hasicaljy fdmiliar m-ith nothing hut public art \\-orid value\. the economic rationale ancl the political rationale began to converge. It cioesn't seem to matter that we are living in a period when, for the first time in history, \\-omen are making the high-art trariitions absolutely their 0%-nand proving in the pmcess that trariition is gender blind. The bottom line is that the \\-hole strtlcture that has st~stainedart in this country has come to be clorninated by public art \\-orld values-that
is, l,\- market-iiriven art. The artists
\I-ho are committed remain, but the\- are frighteningly isolated.
The Deal A4akpr.s As the '90s got t~ndrr\\-ay,the VVal1 Street money that had fueleJ the art orgy csf the '80s evapc~rated.I k r n all sides thew were announcements that the unholy marriage of Khrholism and Reaganomics that had set the art \\-orld spinning haci collapsed. Art hjpe, many imagined. \\-as a thing of the part. h i t i c l n prices plummeted, and gItl1et.ie.t that had only recentlv clpened their doors \\-ere clohing. This. at least, is the story that is generally told. It is accurate in
S I I I L I ~of
its specifics: the t ~ n s ~ auction ld loth, the col-
liipsing real estate values. Rut those m-ho imagined that the insane expecta-
tions of the '80s-art
as a fix, as an ever-changing ciecor-\voulci
ciie along
\%-ithI)rexel Burn ham 1,amhert \%-eretotally mistaken. It was simply impossible that reputations on which so much attention had been lavished v\-ould t-te allo\veii to disappear. The people who hjpe art still believe that the hype makes sense. ( )ne of the most depressing de~elopmentsof the '90s has been the inristence with =which reputations that not even the trenclies care about are paindessiy mhtained. Who any longer gives a d a m n al?out Haim Steint-tach's shelves lined \%-ithbtlvablesi Yet the work is still reviewed in the iYozv
firk Tltrti's. Ti, do otherwise would be to reveal that the emperors of the 38f)s never had an!; dothes. In the '80%a lot of people \vould have said that \ve \%-ereliving in the Age of the Art Stars. As fcx the '90,. I think kve'cl probably hilve to call this the Age of the Ileal Makers. This is the apotheoris of context, the final annihilation of cc~ntent.Of course the deals are often tfeligned to keep the art stars' reputations alive. The deal makers inclucie some commercial dealers, along \%-ithsome c-trrators, s o n ~ emuseum direc-tors, and some collectcirs--7ho not inirequentlv double ai, museunl trusteer. But the individuals-a is the kev to unclerstancling the g e of the Ileal Makers-are
this
less significant
t h n the svnergy I-tetm-een the players. The deal maker isn't in the business of making judgment about art. There people may represent the ultimate triumph of the public art n-orld in that they coultfn? care less what artists think or feel or do in the privacy of their studios. Deal makers approitch artists and art in the same spirit that thev approach museums. galleries. collectors, ctlrators, and critics. For the deal maker, noholty and no thing has a freertancling value; there is no such thing as an artist's imagination. If you're u it a deal maker, you m-ill find an nrtirt's work interesting became y ~ think \%-illlook goad in a """in
spare: you \\ant to fill the space so you can get
attention a d k i n g in the cram-JI; and you want t o bring in the
cro\\-ds so that donors will decide that yours is the hot institution and give money for a building expansion. The mo\t spectacular representative of the Age of the Deal Makers is T h o m s Krens, the director of the Ckggenheim Museum for the past decade. From the t3eginning. Krens lookeci at the (;uggmheim in term, of its assets. He had a legenclary building ciesipned by Frank Llo)-ii Kright: he had a 11-orldclars cclllection of classic modern art; he had name recognition. Doe, Krens like rno~iernart! Iloes he like Kright's t3uilriing! K h o knows? K h o cares! At first Krens's plan to turn the Gugpenheim into an international operation came up against a considerable amount of hometokvn res e n t m n t : Nem- Yorkers felt that the Cirrggenheim was a Manhattan institution and ought to remain that \\-ay. Rut the ineluctable logic of the deal makers is &l\\-a\-,centrifugal movement. and \\-hat Krens sit\\- in the (Guggenheim m-ere marketable arrets. Krens has a sensibility, hut it has nothing to d o \\-ith art. This is a marketer's sensibility, a feel for international deals that involve po&-erfulpeople plqing ball \\-ith other pc,\verful people. The (Guggenheim collection and the (;uggenheim name coulci be offered to foreign governments. Those governmmts \\-ould pay to t3uild new satellite (Guggenheims, such as Frank (Gehry's museum in Bilbao, Spain. Ancl the expanding empire would attrat-t new money. "'The ,%rtof the Motorcycle," the exhiisition of more than a hundred big bikes that filled Frank Llo)-ii Kright's (;uggenheim Museum in the summer of 1998 and broke all the museum's previous attendance records, n-as the apotheosis of the art of the deal. As n museum concept, "The Art of the Motorcycle" \\-as bottom feeding for the f;l,hion conscious. Krens, a bike aficionado himselt; who could not hilve done the she\\- m-ithciut the corporate support of BMNI, \\-as rcasburing anybody \\-h0 has ever had a guiltily amt3ir;ilent feeling about the mvsterious othernehs of modern art that the dream \\-as der~dancl the\; \\-ere ciff the hook. He acted ar if "The Art of the
Motorc\cle" \\-as a public service-a "very serious project." If he \\;is serious about anything, it was about fulfiiling some ultimate macho kintiisy. Rasicall,, \\hat y ~ had u here \\-as an exhibit that was tailor-made to delight the
m11 Street Masters of the Univerrc \vho helped Krens transfc3rm the Guggenl~ein~ into an international entertainment ci>nortium.Writh lirens, the public art \vorlci twcornes the multinational art \\-orld. Dennis Hopper. \vho \\-as motorcycle crazy long before he directeci
Rz~itar,ot,serveci in the exhibition catalog that \\-hat had first attracted him to bikers \\;is their not being "corporate tie-\\-ielciing execs from R l l Street." Rut of course a great many of the hikes at the (;uggenheim m-ere nlway, rich men's toys, and there is no way this show ever m-ould have played the (Guggenheim if n lot of the "corporate tie-11-ielding execr" \\-h0 support Krens had not likcci the 13ike-as-art equittion. Krens is telling the new museum tvcoons that they don't have to like pitintings and sculptures much in ilrder to get into this erctusive club. ".Zn art museum's special est~ibitions programming should fit into n strategic plan." Krens expliiined of "The .4rt of the Motorcycle." And \\-hat better strategic plan could Krens have offered his pittrons than one that began by gi\ing them the opportunity to trade in their rep ties for black leather jackets! Perhaps the deepest irony of Krens's tenure at the (Guggenheim is th;tt he has raised this mega-public institution on the foundations of a museum that \\-as originally iiedicated to some of the least popular of all modern art. In its first incarnation, as the Museum of Non-Objective Fainting, the (Guggenheim opened on East 54th Street in 19.19 and fcatureci abstract paintings by Kandinsky and others that \\-ere still less than beloveci at the Museunl of Modern Art, \\here the audience haci only recently made its peace \vith the Fc)\timpressionists. The Museum of Non-Objective Fainting \\;is meant to bring the put,lic up to speed \vith what the mo\t aloofly experimental artists \\-ere doing; non-objective pitinting still remain\ a reach for many museum-
goers. Yet the very idea of cultural aspiration, lvhich once fueleci the public's strtlgple tii grasp an artiilt's nmcist private expressions, is nom- regaded as fuddv-iiuddy stuff, at least by Thorn%\Krens. Krens has become the cheerfully clark prophet of museological pragmatism. Small-as
the Guggenheiru once m-as-is
not o d y no longer consid-
ercci beautiful; it's seen a\ stupid. Krens claims to face hard facts that other museum directors avoid. m-hen he argue* that he need, glnmc~rousinternational partnerships to pa\- the bills and that he must turn the nluseum into an art lnultiplex in order to bring in the crokvds. Rut \\hat some call h o ~ - ing to the inevitable mai- in fact be a tragic lark of imagination that turn5 our \\-orst-ca\e sc-cnariointo our o d y option.
In the '805. criticism5 of the art lvorld status quo had a certain cachet. Rut in their 0%-n\\-a\-the brilliant critiques--7hich
reached a peak of comic mis-
chevotlsness in "The Sohoiad,'Yffobert Hughes's "Satire in Heroic <:(>uplets Drawn from Life," published in the ~YPW York Rniint t j f B i l i l k ~in 1984----co~lclhe a* destructive as the hype. li'hen n m-itty 11-ritcr turns the art 11-orld into n grotesque carnival, we have another, cleverer form of contextualiration. and the result may he that people give up on contemporary art entirely. And \\-hen that happens, brilliant. dedicated artists arc in clanger of being ignorcci along \\-ith the hype artists. In the '80s. it was all too easy to mock the big money and the glamour; anti-hjpe could become another kind of hype. In the '90s, though. a nlilder tone of bemused acceptance has come into kivor, mai-he because critics are &\\;ire that nothing the\- say makes much of a difference. When the 1995 li'hitnev Biennial opened, three major critics \\-horn one \\-ould not have expecteci to agree about much of an)thing came out m-ith the phrases "I like thi, one" or "I like it." This was said 11-ithn cer-
tain archness, with a sort of sigh. "Like" is s t ~ c ha bland word, and it \I-as used for its blandne,~.I think that critics \\-ere struggling to find a \\-ay to re\pond to the Age of the Deal Makers. They knew that if they tried to argue with the art. or with the curator's underlying assumptions, they \\-ould get no\\-here. The deal had been cut. The case m-as clo\ed, But of course the case is not closed. The artists are still working, and there is an eciurated auciience that \\-ants to understand why things have gone so \\-rang. The only experience I find more depressing than \\-alking thmugh the \XrhitneyBiennials is reading the critics \\-h0 say. "Yes, it's had. but this is \\hat there is." Khen I go thmugh those Biennials, m!- reaction is different. "Yes, this is bad," I ttt~ink,"and it's bad bemuse it excludes everything vital and exciting in m t e r n p o r a r v art." I'm wondering \\-h? Rafbara (Goodstein and Strtnle~Le\;\-isand tlozens of other artists haven't E-teen included--and
among the artists m-e haven't seen in these she\\-s in recent
years are pitinters as \\ell-kno\vn a, Rill lensen and loitn Snvder. Ti.,iia)- the mo\t radical thing an artist can do is paint a tightly structured and internally coherent painting, yet e v m if there is a single major curator in this c o r n a y who ha.s the brains to recisgnize such \\-ork, there is not a single one
\\-h0 has the guts to give that \vork institutional support. The real artists are still \\-orking. The tragedy is that they have no \\;I!-
of making contact with
the audience that really cares. K h a t is to E-te done? The only solution is for people to E-tegin to put E-titck together the structures that have histt~ricallysuppc~rtedthe artists' art 'i\-orld in the ITnited State\. lye need dealers, c-ollectors, critics, and curators
\\-h0 \\-ill stand up for the freestanding value of art-day
by dav. case by raw.
(Given h m - far matters have gone. I am not sure this renekved support is any longer fea,ihle, but there is nothing to do hut give it n try. I can understand
\\-h\ the big museum, are unable to respond to all the cliss;ttisfidction out therc: they're basically in thrall to the money interests. to the deal makers.
Rut I do \\-oncler 11-hywe aren't seeing more innovative programming in the smaller museums. where there may still be some independent curators and trustees left. And \\-h3t about the college\ and t~niversities,u-hich have their own net\%-orkof galleries and small collections? People \\-h0 still t,elie\-e in a private art \vorld must pool their resources. The effort has txgun. One example is the small retrospective of work by Louisa Matthiasdottir. the grandest still life painter of recent cleca~le\.\\-hich tourcc1 roughly a dozen colleges and unkersities in the mid-'90s. \Ye need n ~ o r cshon-s like this, I am also looking for a new gemration of art ~lealers \\-ho, beginning slo\vl\- and building on that tremendous stock of gifted artists no\\ in their 30s and 40s and 505, create galleries m-here, as Clement C;reenberp once m-rote of the Retty Pi~rsonsGallery. "art gee, on and is not just s h i i ~ - n and sold." To he sure, it's harder to operate such a gallery tha.n it \\;is for Retty Farsons or j'ulien I.ev\-: it costs so n ~ u c hmore to run a dignified operation th;tn it did forty or fifty years ago. But our hest hope may still rest \\-ith the rise of a n e n gmeration of gallery 0%-ners\\-h0 are independent and committed--\\-h0
carry on in the great tradition of early-
twentieth-century Paris and mid-century S e w York, n-hen dealers knell\\-hat it nleant to cast their lot with a community of artists. The greate" danger is the sense of hopelessness among the artists. They desprately need a ne\\ \\aye of dedicated cle;tlrrs; more eager, infcjrmed collectors: n determination on the part of smaller museums to exhibit. document. and preserve uncompromisingly independent contemporary art: an upsurge of serious critical kvritinp; ad~iitionalforums m-here nrti\t\ can get together and talk. The public art world has t~ecomesuch an over%-helmingl\- oppressive force in arti\ts9lives that many painters and sculptors have already given up hope that the reveliitions that sustain them in the studio \\-ill ever again have a public presence. Once upon a time a major arti\t \\;is a person like \Yillem de Kooning, who came up through the ranks and
never forgot that he \\;is a part of a community of artists. Ti.,iia\- a major artist is a person like Jeff Koons, who has oversized knickknacks manuhctured by hired hands and doesn't knoll- that there is a cornmunit\- of artists and is proud of his ignorance. So kir as Knons is concerned, the deal nxiliers are the only artists left standing. Koons is one of them. K h a t y ) u see \\hen
you compare de Kclnning and Koons is not a difference in quality or degree. It's a difference in kind. The art \\-orld has become the most glamomus \vilderness imaginable, be\\-itdling and nurnl-ting at the samr time. it ma?. he overstating the case to say that the future of art is in the t3;tlanrc. But most of the artists to \\horn I talk believe that \ve are Lising in \er>-ciark time,. If arti\ts and audiences can confront the full extent of their alienation, ma\-be then people can hegin to shake off that smse of hopelessness and things can start to turn around. If this is going to happen, it \\-ill involve a lot of small arts of courage, all of them animatecl t3j- a \\-illingness to reject r o n v e h o n a l taste and ronventional 11-isdom all along the Line. The artists \I-ho are most deeply cc~mmitteci to \\hat they're cioing in the studio have to reestablish contact with the audience that hates the hype.
This page intentionally left blank
CONTEMPORARY
DEVELOPMENTS
This page intentionally left blank
TWOMBLV TIME
The idea that art began \\hen somehodv impulsively scratched something on a \\-all \\-ill do just fine as a creation myth for painters, Why that first artiit made thrtt first mark, however, is subject to as many different interpretatic~nsa* there are time* \\hen artists have thought about the origins of art. In the late 1700s. \\hen European painters were on the verge of a century of realist revolutions, some artists were attracted to a Greek legend that stated that the inventor of painting \I-asa woman, a (:orinthian maiden \I-ho decided to trace the profile of her soon-to-be-departed lover on a \I-all, This storv, U-fiiclicombined a clrt\siial setting, a romantic sentiment, and a realist impulse, suited an age that occasionally could \velci such apparently divergent sensibilities into bold historical drama. But in more recent t i m e , \\-hen abstraction rather than imitation has been the artiit's ciefini~lgexperience, the origin m!-ths that have interesteci people have had a less clearcat narrative. Henri Focillon, the French writer \\-hose 1936 e,say "In Praise of Hands" came out of the Expressionist impulses of early-tm-entieth-century European art. pudied the beginning hack from Corinth to the Age of the Titans. He suggesteel that \\-hat was essential \\-as not han~i-eyecoordination, hut the tiand's inherent capacities-its
delicate yet forceful musculauitv and its
tactile sensitivity. Focillon imagined a centaur in a forest, ancl how, while moving along on his four hooves. the mythological heaht would be "inhaling the \\-orld thmugh his hands, stretching his fingers into a web to catch the imponderable." "The hand's trial,. experiments and divinations." I'orilIon believed. were still going on in artists' studio\ in the twentieth century. And \\-hen I'orillon's essay appeareci in Nen York in 1948, under the imprint
of the art book pt~hlistterKittenborn, there \\-as a
Korld atldience that
\\-asprimed to receive the melsitge thzt the magic is in the making. It has been just at-tout fift!- years since Focillon's essay appeared here. That is both a very long time and a very short time so far as art is concerned. And even though the idea of the artist as a magician has been attacked fi-om every imaginable angle in the past severat years, this remains the only- m\-th t-tj- =which anybody who gee, into a studio and gets clown to work on a regu-
lar basis can seem tts live. Artists stiII bef~evethat the inlplrlse t o make marks predates the impulse to represent, nncl the\- have made painterliness the hfanhattan version of naturalness-a naturalness that can E-te turned to contradictory ends and that often seems, even \\-hen it iignorecl or attacked, to be honored in the breach. In the pit\t fen- years we have seen a number of museum retrospecthes in lvhich contemporary artists are illtent on demonstrating that in the beginning and in the end there is nothing hut the mark. The5e shc3\vs-devotecl and, no%-,
Tkl-omhly-have
to Rohert Ryman. Killem d r Kooning.
underlined both the potency of a great ori-
gin myth and the clangers in store for any artist \vho expects a limited definition of painting t o he relevant t~ the Fir-from-limited number of situittions that present themselves over a lifetime of v.-ork.
Cy Tm~ornhly,\\-hose retrospective is at the Museum of Modern Art this fall, likes a classical a\sociation, ancl he probably \voulLln't mind our imagining that in nlore than a few- of his canva\es a centaur has clone some ti11ger painting. That Tuomhly has often made his painterly marks m-ith pencil or crayon doesn't s ~ g g e \at rejection of the painterly gesture so much as the relevance of that mark to a range of unconventional situittions. T\\-omhly is saying that he's painting even \\-hen he's not pitinting. There are classical titles and inscriptions clerived from Greek and Roman lvriters scattered through the \\-ork of this artist \\-h0 has made his home in Italy since the late 1950s (he's 65). These antique allusions give his late modern improvisa-
tional manner, \\-ith its big expanses of emptv lvhite canvas. a feeling of heing groundeci in the lvhite marble lan~lscapeof classical legend. T\%-o~-r,mbl\gives the impression that he's a contemporary artist with fi11e premodem credentials. The T\\-omhly sho\v. \\-hich \\-as organized bj- I-presmts a careful, chronological vie&-of the career. the show sugge\t"that
the \\-a\- to understan~iTm~omhlyis in terms
of a cyclical, rather than a linear, development.
rZ small repertoire of
themes and motih, almost all of them in place very near the t3eginning. have been reappearing for more than forty years. T\~ombly'smost ardent fans may leave the retrospective feeling that they \vould like to see more. \\-hich is not the \\-orst feeling to have at the end of a big sho\v. Those \vho don? care fcjr the jq-ork \\-ill find that thei-ke reactled the end cif the show t3efore they've reached the end of their mpe. T~x~ornbly knm-s hen- to maximize his gift for deft, elegant effects, or at lea\t he used to know hm-, in the first piirt of his career. up until the mid1960s. Looking at these sand- and $no%--and ivory- ancl slate-colored paintings, a mtlsetlmgoer takes in one incident and then another incident, and there's plea\urc to he derived from the smsiti\itv with lvhich T\\-omhly engraves a pencil line into thick pitint or tkx-irls together little puffs of pigment. His work can he interpreted as n textbook e x m p l e of late modern Expressionism; the living painters v\-hoend up \\-it11 rctrclspectives at the hfuse~rrn of Modern Art are often the ones whose work appears to have an educational purpose. T\~omblypresmts self-conscious a\vku;irdne,s as virtuosity. He uses substructures a\ surfaces. He asks the part to stand in for the m-hole.
All of thew arc familiar, and in some cases do\.\-nright venerable, modern
techniques. Especially in the paintings of the mid-1950s. T\%-omblymakes good use of an image that is cleriveci from de Kooning: the stroke that turns abruptly at a ninety-degree angle. and in the act of "bending over" creates n hairpin t u r n in space. In space-malijng terms, this is the m i s t that T\t~omblyever manage\ to do. The pitintings are full of small, t3eguiling effccts. T\\-omhly sees a canvas a\ an idic~s)-ncraticalkornamented surface. This sort of surEace. somewhere t,etv,-een a notel3ook page and a graffiti-scarreci \\-all, \\-as already in clanger of becoming overlv self-conscious \\-hen Miri, \\-as doing h i emptied-out picture poem\ in the 1920s. T\vomhly's rectangle of canvah, with the m-eave of the fabric either she\\-ing or covered over by n thick layer of kihite or gray paint, in bulletin hoard on =which the artist posts lots of messages. (The gray paintings with white lines from the 1960s have been referred to as chalkhoards or blackboards, for ohvic~usreasons.) Although T~\~ombl\may insl-ribe more \\-ords in his hrd-to-past;" klancfkx7riting tha.n most people are going to \\-ant to take the time to reacl, these bits of poetry and verbid graffiti do add another dimension to his \crawled and siratshed abstract images.
Among the cryptic and not-so-cryptic messages that T\vombly includes are clnsicitl place names ancl pornogriiphic squiggles. A11 announcements, he seems to suggest, are equal. There's taste and intelligence and wit to these canva\es, but there is no heedlessness. T\\-ombl\-knows h o ~to- scatter bits across a big surkize, he understands ho\\ to rnxvd things for an effect. and he knm-s how to adjust the rhythms. Yet the experience of the pitintings remains additive-that's
the
t3ipgeg ppml?lem \vith the \\-ork. The pitinters \vho give us an experience of magical amplitude find \\-a=,-, to make their effccts expiincl almost geometricall\-; they convince us that the world they've created is some\\-hat beyond their rontn,l, that two plus t\\-o equals a lot more than fi~ur.T\\-ombly never manages to make that happen. His painting are designed, not composed.
It doesn't help that T\\-omhly is no colorist. There is some varietv to his palette. and he's certiiinly attuned to the individualitv of the patches of pigment that he arrange* on n canva*, hut he doem't knoll- how to orchestrate colors. For most of the show, he makes a virtue of this liability; only in the last few room, doe, he attempt some color coml-tinatic~nsthat are really beyond him. In the recent Four
Suilsi~ricycle.
T\%-omblyseem, to be trying to
learn n thing or two from the late Toan Mitchell, hut his juxtapositions of yello\v and blue and purple and green have no impact. The work doe\n3t take off. The key to T\\-omhly's small poetic originality rests in the \\-a\-that he isolates each element. 13-en\\hen he overlaps things---a crahl-t~scra\vl, a doodle of paint-eac
h l-tit retains its cool. stand-alone personality. The self-
consciousness of this m-csrk rnakes a museumgoer feel self-conscious. rZ day or two after y s u see the Tm~omhlyshci&-,\\-hat you mai- recall is all the careful looking that you clid, rather than an)thing that you artu:tlly saw.
l r i s i t ~ r sto the Tw/-t>n~hlv ehihititrn at the Modern-and been reaJifig al-tout Tlrc-ornbly in the press-\\-ill
anyhoJ!. v\-ho's
quite n a t u r a v \\-oncler
\I%\- it ib that so much attention is focused on a partiiulau arti\t at a partii-
ular time. The retrospective provide, an occasion, but of course some retrocase, the aviditv spective~garner more attentian t h n others. In T\"r-omb1~'s \\-ith \\-hich he ancl his \\-ork are being examineif suggests something about the m!-sterious movements of artistic sensil-tility.Transformations in taste may appear to be shaf-ted by the peiipie in the museilrns and the auction houses and the t3lue-chip galleries. Rut as often as not, taste percolates up\\-ard, \vith ideas and apprehensions that first take hold in the stuciios of a considerable nulnber of artists someho\v finding their way into the wider \\-orld. Although hshion can be a crucir but useful barometer of evolutionary trends and gecilogicitl shifts in the thinking of arti\ts, there are transfr~rmaticjns that occur over periods of years and even decades jq-ith
3
sIo%--movingforce that the audience, if it's overly concerned with \\hat's happening this m o n t t ~or this season, \\-ill be ha.rd put to compreknd.
In T\x7omhly, Kirk Iiarnedoe ha4 surely found a big-name artist kvhose ability to he both unabashedly lyricid and dryly ironic about his 0%-nlyrici\m defines, thmugh its very paradox. haute taste in 19%; you might say that T\~ombly'scharm rests in his not resolving a paradc~xso much as he enshrines it. Historically speaking. T\vombly's brand of painterline\* comes a g e n ~ a t i o nor two after de Kooning's (\vhose retrospective icurrently plzii-ing opposite T\\-ombl~'sat the Metropolitan Museum of .4rt) and perhaps half
3
generation before Rolxrt Ryman's (whose retmspective \\;is at
the Mc>derna year ago). T\vombly certainly offers a muheurngoer a lot more than that painterlv M i n i m a l i ~Robert Ryman. whose lvhite brushstrokes are so evenly inflected that every mark is canceled out by every other oneand a viewer is left feeling hi-almed. An artist who marshals his slim painterly resources as rigidly as R\-man must have some inkling of the numbing effect that his j\-ork is going to have on many museumgoers. Rut the off-p~lttingregularity of some of the later galleries in the de Kooning retmspective suggests that even an arti\t of infinitely greater gifts than Rynlan. when his essential subject is the individualism of the hushstroke j\-ithin the pluralism of the painang. cannot expect the most t3eautiful pasxsof the brush to sustain our interest over the course of a long career.
De Kooning, \vho at 90 is no longer painting. used to handle a paint-saturated hruhh with more wit and elegance than anybody else in .4mericit. No lifeu7ork based on the cult cif the brushstroke rivals the l->rilIianceand fkscination of iie Kooning's. Still. by the late '50s, the preoccupation lvith passagework over bro;.tJ cor7tlpositionai movelnents led to a diminishment in de Kooning's work, and at that point T~x~ornbly kicked in \I-ith his 0%-ntake on de Kooningecyue diminishment. T\\-ombly didn't study 11-ith de Kooning, hut cie Kc~nninghad taught at Black Mc>untainCollege in North Car-
olina before Tkx7ombly got there, a d the 1)utchman's \\-ark m-as,cif ccsurse, a nlajisr inflt~enceat the school. T\x-omblv join\ a studied severity that is not unlike Ryman's to a giddy painterliness that is not unlike de Kooning's, and brings o u t a strain of coolly nihilisac painterliness that runs straight thmugh hit\- years of the Sihool of Ne\v York. Kc cfidn't neeci a T\\-omhly retrospective or a dc Kclnning retmspective to demonstrate that these veteran artists arc on a lot of \-cjunger artists' minds. liven kvithout the shm-S,it's abundantly apparent that '50s--style painterliness is resurgent. often \vith an ironic edge. In part this is a generational thing. Arti\ts in their 40s arc kiscinated by the mid-century years; they feel an almo\t lnagnetic pull hack to the world as it \\-as\\hen they \\-ere young. There have been rncinths in New York \"Y-hen-between the shcikvs at the Fainting Center. Andre Zarre. 55 Mercer. and a number of other LION-ntokvn gallrries-it's
been clear that the impact of de Kooning's bravura brush-
\\-ork on Twomhlv and countless artists \vho were exhibiting along 10th Street in the 1950s has reappeared, phoenixlfke, in the SoHo of the ttr)c)l)s. Solne of this may he cop\-cat stuff; a lot of it is much more than that. Fainthanclling has t3ecorne such an issue among the artists that for the first time in anybody's memory Ne\\- York has a hometo%-nbrand of pigments that rivals the hest produced in Fun~pe.And make no mistake about it: \\-hen artists arc going bark to t3;tsics in the stuciio. the repercussions are going to be felt \\ay t3eyond the studio. Materials matter. and even nonartists knov\-it. itt the de Kclcining retrospective at tbc X/letropcilitan, museurngoers arc tiiking a long, hard look at a color phcitogrilph of dr Kncining's paint tiible that has been installed in the galleries: they m-ant to see ho\\ it's done. Today a lot of artists are cioing it \vith \XrilliamsburgFaint. the brand that's h o r c c i l>\-Bill rensen and Rrice Marden ancl that is no\\- solci from a street-level store on Eliral3eth just t>elo\vHouston. This is the kind of spare, unprepossessing retail shop-1%-ith artists' exhibition announcements
pmted all nrouncl on the m-alls-that
people don't believe can make a go of
it anvnlore. The entreprenrur behind Wif liarnsburg Pi~intis a painter n a m d Carl Plansky, n-hose first show at 55 Mercer in 1992 contained some tttiskly \\-orked landscape-t33sed abstractions of
2
\I-ho'd seen Plansky's debut shokv-together
fairly high ralibcr.
gallerygoer
with a number of other distin-
guisheci exhil?itions, most recently Temma Bell's at the Ro&-er\-Gallery and Faul ReGka's at Salander-( I'Reilly-could
\\-ell ask \\-h\- anybody imagines
that virtuoso painthandling is not alive and \\-ell. Fainthandling has al\v;i!-s defined the Ne\v York School. much a\ rolor \\-as the defining experience for Venice and composition was for Paris. Rut for artists the que\tion isn't how pitinterly pitinting looks in the gallery; it's \\-hat they can do with it in the stuciio. T\~ombl\.'s\\-a\-of treating the ran\-a., as
a page in an aesthete's journal is something that artists can pi":
up
on. His version of ilatne*s gain* unexpected implicatic~nsin the l\-ork of loan Sn\-der, jq-fio gives diaristic pzinting a rncire exyloiive, heart-on-the-sleeve character. .4ncl Carroll L3unham.s paintings-in
which comic-hook-bright
color and psychedelic imagery achieve some elegance and 11-eight-are rather like TR-omhl\-'s Delphic pronouncements translated into NeuYt~rkese.Terrific painthandling is a l i ~ eand \\-ell. But there is reason for concem. For every painter \\-h0 handles a brush eloquently there is no\\- another painter \\-h0 is glad to make a joke of that kincl of virtuosity. There is a new kincl of painterlv painting that's sci arch and jejune that it de\erves to he taken no more seriously than the beatnik stvles thzt are st~rfacingin the tfo\vnton-n c-lubs. In some cases ttte mishievousness is right out in the open. a\ is the case \vith the cartoonish stvles of Karen Kilirt~nikor Sue lVitlian~\,In other cares-hfarv Kinters come to mincl-the
Heiln~annand Terrv
po\e is subtler, so that you may not even be
sure if the artists themselves understand that they're slyly clistanring themselves from the past. I suspect that some of today's T\\-omhl\--\\-atcherr~l?ly-kviitcliers
aren't all that different from today's archeologists of the Beat mtivement: some mai- even regard T\\-omhly as the Paul Bo&-lesof the visual arts. Today's painters have one fundanlental choice: their brush\\-ork can be hiinrlt or their brusliwork Gin be ironic. Yct \\-hen Tc\-mbly,m-ho is being granted old modern master status, creates paintings that seem to sweep aGde the concept of choice in kivor of the possihilitv of being all things to all people, he's hailed for giving do\vntom-n plurali,m an aristocratic sheen. The hip auiiience regards painting \vith such aml3ivalent skepticism that it can hardly tell the difference between the ambiguities and in~niesthat are built into a painting and the one, that they project onto a painting. Gatlerygoers mav read the ebullient passage5 in the canvases of Toan Mitchell as ironic high spirits. and perhaps there is something to this interpretation of the \\-ork of the Abstract Expressionist \\-h0 died in 1092 \\-ith her reputation soaring. It's also possible to discern an elenlent of ironv in middle-perioii de Kooning, where he occasionally appears to be gently satirizing the heaviness of his own earlier m-ork. Rut \\hen 11-e talk about Mitchell and de Kncining \\-e're talking about the gambles of arti\ts kvho. whatever their limitation\. can construct a p i n t i n g in \\-hich iron\. is cine element in an emotjonal equation. T\vombly, unlike many of the Young Turk, \vho take him for their old master. knom-s how to expresh di\passic>n with a little painterlv pahion. Khen he evokes Mitchell in some of his p;t\sages of f~lllcolor. he ma!- not make the allusion work fcjr him, hut he is ackno&-ledgingthat a painter has some options, iis an accompaniment to tlie Modern shorn-, the (Gagoian G d e r y , in its elegmt made-over garage csn 1Yooster Street, is presenting an enormous three-part painting by TR-c~mhly.He lvorkeri on this untitlrii fifty-tkx-o-foot-\&
painting for fifteen years and finished la\t spring. It's an
mgaging composition-a
sort of guide to T\vombl\.'s predilection\. Moving
from left to right \ve pas5 through a landscape of choice$. There's the land of
no color: there's a broad plain crossed by thickets of lines and in\cribed lvith the \voriis "The Anatomy of Melancholy": and there's a grand burst of fire\\-orks in orange and \iolet and vello\v. This painting embrace$ several different moods, yet it's so large and spare a \\-ork that each mood is \\-rapped in its o\vn aureole of skepticism. T\vombly's triptych reminds us that the use of a painterly mark to shatter the illusions kvithout =which painting cannot live isn't something that \\-as cireamed up by toclay's juht-out-of-artschool skeptics. There are olci skeptics. too.
Much of =what is best and worst in this old skegtic-'Smature aihievement can he traced hack to Tu-omhlv's Black Mountain College experience. I shoulci say that \\hen I speak of Black Mountain, I am not necessitrily thinking of the experimental North Carolina college as it flourished in the '40s and 300s and is descril-ted t-ty historians, but as it lives on in the after all, \\-as there for not more than a imaginations of artists. T\%-c~-ombly, year. Black Mountain, no matter ho\\- long ago it rloseci its doors. endures as a tradition-a
myth, if you will-h\-
=which artists live. .4t Black Moun-
tain, painting had less to d o \\-ith an immersion in the stuciio than with a painter's effcrts to synthesize all kinds of avant-garde activity and in general open up the studio to the world: some people still t-telieve that's \\-hat a painter eioes. There's another, alternative tradition that also contint~ei, to have a kind of ~nt-thicstatus; it's the one that held S&-ayin the 20s and '50s at the Hofmann School in Nen- York m d Pro\-incetokvn. Klhen you stuiiied lvith Hans Hofmann. you were on a completely ciifferent \\-ave length than you \\-ere at Black Mountain. Hofmann shcikved young artists h o n to go into the studio and express anything and everything that they knell- about the 11-orld through the dynamism of the composition, the \\-eight of the rolor, the livelinei,~of the hruhh. Some people still believe in that, too.
T\vombly3sattitucie to\v;ird the rla\sical past----his creation rn\th. if you \I-ill-has
everything to do n-ith Black Mountain relativism. Me is st~relyca-
pable of uncierstanciing antiquity as n hirly solid arrangement of literarj- and artistic monunlents, but wh;tt attracts him about those montrments is the extent to lvhich time has \\-reakeci change\ on them rather than the extent to 'iq-hich they have rernained the same. There are no absoltrtes in this view of history. The mo\t beautiful line of poetry can he a f r a g m e n t q r p h a n e d \\-ords. The most beautifully painted passage on the \\;ills of Pompeii is hscinnting because it has been ravaged bj- time. 'lh he interested in the patness of the pa\t is a perfectly natural attitude fcjr an artist. hut it is by no means the oniv viable m-?- to apprtjach the pa\t, and it is certainly a view that's irreconcilable \\-ith Mofinann's belief in the immediac\- of painterly expresis alive for other kinds of arti\ts as u-ell, Six sitrn. Pompeii, alive for T\x-ombl~, months ago, a fen- steps from \\-here T ~ ~ - o m hi l yno\\- shokving his mural painting at <;agosi;tn, Temma Bell, in her exhibition at the Roll- er^ Gallery, seemed to simply pick up \\here the Fomprian pitinters had left off. Bell is a painter \.ifits has no interest in historicat ret~itivism;she's involved -\l-itha completely different tradition than T117omblv. If he" Black Mountain, she's E l o h a n n School. The key to Bell's off-handed lucidity is her immersion in an idea of calligraphic realism that she firlds equally alive in the art of ancient Pompeii, Renaissitnce Venice, ( h r o t . Dufy. and (;iacometti. T\\-omhly has his on-n calligraphic method, hut it is n critique (and not alxx-ays a persuasive critique) of olci ciralving styles. For Bell, painterliness isn't a paradoxical mod~ \\;ills \\ere ern position; it's just the thing that pitinters do. In Bell's s h o the packed, almost 11-allpaper-like.11-ith painting of upstate Ne\n York. and the artist took in everything: rolling hills, field,, trees, fences, barns, houses. animals, figures. She presmted it all \\-ith a ilo\ving, comic-elegant speeci that \\-e knoll- from some of the great Fompeian \\-all paintings. Not every paint-
ing reached the high level of the fiftv-eight-inch-long From ? i e ~fc Trws, but the attack of Bell" brush all\-avs hatl a tlefiniteness that E-iohann ~ o t ~ l d have appmved. Although Bell is too young to have actually studied with Hofinann. I imagine that he m-ould also approve of the \\-ay she strengthens her grip on the present by assimilating the experience of the past. T\vombly, ever the son of Black Mcjuntain Ctlllege, pocritions himself in the present giving a riveting late modern auhteritv to each thought that he has about the p a t . K h a t an artist makes of painting is not so much a matter of freely choosing among a varietv of options as it is a matter of making the most of a fe\v intuitions that are absolutely one's OR-n.Every time a painter paints, m-e \I-ant to see \I-hat those intuitions arc, To paint is to sllon- your hand. It is left to the audience to decide \\-hether the \\-a\- the artist handles pitint reveals unselfconscious virtu~aity,a canny ilnitation of virtu
~ P C O I I I Pso
o h c u r e that the
quecrtion of ?%-hether\\-illed inauthenticity can be a new kind of authenticitv can scarcely he addressed. The audience has a hard enough time recognizing the old kind of authenticity. Tkvornbly rather plqh into all thecre confusions. There is a tlehate going on that is t3;tsically about the status of painting in a time \\-hen phcitographv is dominant. This debate is as old as photograph\: itself, hut it does seem to he heating up right no\\. Tc~day'smuseumgoer frequentl? learns about painting. and keeps ahrea\t of developmmts in the visual arts,
looking at photographic reproductions. This makes it tlifbcult
to evaluate a pitinter's lvork. The actual surface of a pitinting, of any painting, \\-it17 its uneven texture, can seem like a bad parody of the real thing. if the real thing is the seamlessnecrs of a photograpl~icprint. Painting has been looking prohlelnatical for so long that it has come to the point where every time a painter paints. somehod\- thinks that painting is on trial. Artists may
reject the pmsecutorial spirit. but in recent sea\ons there has been a \\-hole slew of highly regarcled theme shons that amount to art-\\-orlii triitls in \\-hich the real painterliness faces off against the mock. And \\-hat better place to seek a verdict than New York, the city that gave
uh
the la\t unam-
bivalent clefinition of painting fiftv years ago? Tm~ornhlyis the tvpe of painter that the Museum of Modern .4rt has Liked for a long time: a Iladaist in C:lassiiistk clothing, Both the t3adaists and the <:la\sicists anlong Ye\\- York arti\ts. ho&-ever.may find that T\vombly9s victories arc, for the mo\t part, too ea\\-. In the plleries of Nen York (:it\-, the m-ars bet-++-een the Iladi-iistsand the Classicists, \\-h0 are also the Black Mountain people and the Mans Hofinann people. rage on. Market forces may be kvith Tm~omhly,hut market forces are not the he-all and the end-all. That elegantly scribt3led \vorlcl of T\\-omhly's is one opinion ahout \\-hat 1994 thinks that 1950 thought ahout 50 13.1 . Arti\ts. often clo\e-mouthed in public, are vehement \\-hen thev get down to kvork in their studio\. They have their o\vn opinions ahout \\-hat the recent past is telling them ahout the distant past. And \\-h\- not! \%%at is at stake is nothing less than the creation m>-tbsthat a r t i t s are living h)-.
You hear the Brtlie liauman show almost before you see it, became the cries and commands that provide the audio component for some of the artist's videos are so loud that thev cut straight through the gllleries to the entrance of the exhibition. (:t?ming off the escalator onto the second floor of
the Hirshhorn Museum in W ~ h i n g t o n \%-here . the retrospective of this 53year-idd artist is up over the v\-inter,unsuspecting museilmgoers may \%-onder if something awful is going on in the galleries. but for visitors who knollthe N a u n ~ a nrotrtinc, this is just l->usincssa, usual. The \;\-orks\%-ithsoundtracks include
"No."and
C:lijtvm
'Ibrtrrr~, in v\-hid1it man in a clown L-ostumekeeps saying
Sliii In Your I I Q ~ IIvil~iotr ir Chuir, in =which an off-camera voice puts
repetitive movethe mime on the video through a series of hard-to-fc~llol~ ments. Noise in a milsetBm is by no m a n s N a u m n ' s imentinn, but tike silence on n concert stage. that other rather shop\\-orn experimental ploj-, it's a break n-ith somention that's still tjirlv certain to put the audience on tenterhooks. That, no doubt about it, is where N a u n ~ a nm-ants t ~ s . Nauman has dealt with all the big t o p i r m e x , polver. vic~lenrc-hut he has ciealt with them impersonally, a, media-grabbers, a, contemporar~flash paint$. If y j u compare a large-scale Nauman with n large-scale Donald iudd ilr
Mark di Suverr) or Narn fllne Pi~ik-;ill these arti\ts m-ere very much on
the scene in the late f c)hi)-you
see that Naurnan's over\%-helmingstate-
. h e w ' m n ppersonal f e r w r to his ments are anti-grand grand g f i t u ~ s T megalomania. The retrospective is wildly heterogeneous: there are mc~vieh. hologram,. videos. and pieces ranging from bantam \\-eight to behemothsize, made of wax, neon, cast iron. aluminurn. \\-allhoard. tn-o-by-fours.
f lexiglas, steel, anti foam. Yet the net effect is ct~riouslytamped doll-n-a muffled shriek. This is me,sage art. but the message, don't quite get across. \%-hichis (of course) the me\sage. Nauman has been \\ell k n m - n for a quarter century. In the p;t\t half decade he's become a living legen~1.This work has a queasy aml->iguit\-that a lot of art lvorlci movers anti shakers seem to love. The Nauman retrosper-tive, m-llich was organized by the Kalker ,d\rt <:enter in Minneapolis and \\-asseen there last spring, makes its next stop at the Museum of McIdern Art in Ne\v York this spring. During the thirty-year
period that is surveyed. Nauman has made use of lots of new or nem-ish media. but he's al\\;$!-~ used them ofthitndedly. as if they were all old hat. It's pa\"ihe to un~ierstanciNaulnan a* one of the first avant-garde artists m-ho has been indifferent to style. He \\-ants to prove that the next style is not the better style, and he wants to make that paint while he" sdong the latest thing. Most of Nsuman's work looks reheated, intmtionally so. He regards Minimalism. Body Art. and Environmental r t as the same stuff in ciifferent package*. And he's right. This is zivant-gardism for the micro\va\-e generation. Nauman has become a renegade superstar hero for younger artists. such as Cadv Noland, Kiki Smith, hlatthem- Barney, and j'essiia Stockholder,
\\-h0 see the art of the '60%and '70s as their image hank, their junk pile. Rruce Nauman gets us nervous and t\x-itchy and ill at ea*e-that's
the
nlain thing. In some of tlte earliest works inclucled in this shm-, he films himself putting on theatrical makeup and photographs himself playing \I-ith his toes, and 11-e're left wit11 the feeling that weke invaded his privacy, In a lot of the later kvork-the
torture videos, the neon drawings of erect
penises, the neon signs that tell us that \\-e're going to "PUCK AND DIEwit's ea\y to feel that Nauman has invaded our privacy. The environmental \\-orks consisting of oddly shapecl passage\\;$!-S and rooms arc meant to disc3rirnt us. I presume that the recent assemblages made of anirnal ca*ts that Nauman purchases from a taxiderm~.supply house are supposecl to put us
off. And vet a lot of the time N a u n ~ a ncloer not, so far as I arn concerned, exactlv succeed in unnerving us. Maybe he doesn't c u e about that. either. <:ertainly, it's impo\sihle to sink into Nauman's work or feel overtaken by it. In the course of the sllon; mtlseumgiirrs have to adjust to so many different media, and to so many oddly mixed media, that they may never get to the paint \\-here they're having anything hut first impressions. Nauman gave himself the starring role in the photographic \\-ork that he \\-as doing in the late 1060s, and only here, at the beginning of the shmv, does
he manage to make us feel a bit emoaonally involved. At 26 or 27, the age at
\I-hiih he did the l f l ~.9,4ak~-F@ t movies and the f1t~li:yrumSrrres, Nauman had the slender build, pleasing1\-shapecl shoulders, ancl slightly masklike face of an Ancient Greek kc~urosfigure. He \\-as not kvildl! good-looking, hut it is a time in life \\-hen moderate!\- attractive people can look \vilcllv good-looking. and Nauman's imperturbable. unto-myself manner----that youthfill self-absorption-u~as part of his college-t-tohemian charm. In 11ri Mirku-lill, Nauman, barechested. slo\\-ly plasters thick opaque makeup on his kice in four tones-\-hite.
pink. green. and black. .4lthough
I can't imagine kvatching this quartet of films for more than a feb- minute\, Nliuman is an interesang ciimera subject. nc~bnclvis forced to stay any longefihan tltev care to,and his narcissism does have some humor and appeal. The same goes for the flt~lirijrums.m-ith their outer-space red depths in jq-hich N;luman, 11-earhg it striped shirt and jeans, slrtlnches up his body, tjq-eaks his nose, ticides his toes. He" enjocng hil, ovc-n body-this
is inno-
I can see the appeal of these kooky in-
cent, nongenital masturbation-ancl tinlate scenes.
In thew first 11-orks,Naunlan is the kouros as I-tohen~ianclovc-n. In a few other videos, althciugh h i peregrinations rouncl his empty studio are alreaclv too deep into neo-Beckettland for my taste. I can appreciate his flat demeanor and the no-style stylishness of his standard-issue T-shirts. I clo not think it is amiss to see a hint of sexiness in his bare feet in l>aniu
Ewr-
iise (m the Pvrirlietvr ofu \qsurr: Nauman probably imagined that he could turn
on half the m-orld by taking off his shoes, nncl perhaps he wasn't kir from
y
jq-fi~ng.1Y~iltzibrtll~/~tvs of t b L~~ f Hu i of .
W
M) - Hnily - lkkrn ill 7bn-lsrh ilrtunuls makes
me stop and look and think. When Nauman distills his 011-n body into icy green neon curves, one ran grant him the ingenuity of u\ing Minimalism as the stealth weapon of an erotic sneak. Rut this isn't anything that deserves a six-citv museum tour. and after the first group of works the show col-
lapses. The youthful quiet egotist who \\-ants to grab our attention becomes a middle-aged ritving egotist. \Kkr.'reon the receiving end of a mixed-medin mugging. The show is a spra\vling, chilly experience. It's easy just to \\;ilk by Nauman's nothingizh dra\\-ings. hut there are other m-orks that. by \irtue of their sire alone. ran hardly be avoidecl, even \\-hen you're mo\tly looking for the \\-a\- out. Si~riih.Inz~rrivTrrirr!yii.is one of a number of pieces that hang from the ceiling: a cast iron chair hovers in the center of ;l Minimalist triangle of steel beam,.
0 1 1 Ilrairud ~ Llri. irriil D i e
is a \\;ill of neon lettering. \\-ith messages
flashing on and flashing off, among them "PISS AND I)IE/I'ISS AND LIVIi." Neon color. lvhich can be magic in the ciarkne\s of a city. looks like nothing in a \\ell-lit gallery, hut then for Nauman no-thing is a metaphor. There's a series of silhouettecl figures done in neon that recall the sleekly anonymous ones that made Ernest Trova famous in the 'GO\, onlv in place of Trova's spare-age androgyny Nauman gives us jumbo-size penises that flash erect and then ilnrh limp and then erect and then limp. Nauman is alrno\t ar attached to repetition as he is to inconsistency. If inconsistencv represents the self-indulgentlv experimental side of his personalitv. repetition is apparently the only \\-a\- he thinks he can get anything through trur tliick skulls. The musenm is a lab. The artwork., are the lab equipment. Nauman experiments on us, and in case \\-e aren't quite sure that this is \\hat he has in mind, he inclucler a rat t3umbling through a maze. ( In
a video projection, the rat makes itr -\l-a\-ttlroilgh its c l r a g e Plexiglah
l&)-rinth whik a ytsung man thuntps on a ifrum set; the work, called Luidrrrril
flplplessrspss
in Rirt3
(Rllik lrrril
Rill1 Drurram~r),also includes the maze (\%-itboutthe
rat). In installations such ar C:t?rridor Irr5tirlllrtritn (Mirk W!dpr
Irr5tirll~tlon/and
Yi1-
iou Ria~mcli.lillrgslirr;). Nauman is testing our reactions to unFdmiliar spitces. so
\\-e become the rats \\-h0 are put through the maze. Ancl then, like a lot of h b a n i m l s , we end t ~ in p the morgue, which Natlman suggests \\-ith his
heaps of cast animal rarrahses and his casts of decapitated h~lmanheadsmany of t l t e m i n a variety of <:rayol;i colors.
There is nothing that can be said against Nauman that ham? talready been said in his k o r . Peter Schjeldahl, \\-hose elegantly lvrittm columns in the
I.llilnijr livie arc our most reliable guide to \\.hiit tlte art m-orld fast set is thinking. says that Nauman's gift "consists in ohrerj-ing and being true to a 'hilure to communicate' twilt into every language, every style." This may be a savvy n-ay of dercrihing the sense of drift that a Nauman
S ~ O M induces, -
but isn't it something like the ultimate cop-out to say that an arti\t's failure to communicate is actually his \\-a\-of communicating? Lers is more may be one of the great high modern revelations, but it does not cc~ntravenetile fait that what vou see is what YOU get and that %\-hatYOU get in Nauman is nothing much. Schjeldahl says that N;luman creates art that ""c.annotbe handed do\\-n ar a tradition." It seenlr to me that Naunlan's real achievemmt is to have persu;trieci the public that he operates in a universe where neither the high art trariitions nor the most rudimentar). standareis of popular entertainment ever come into play. Nauman's ocitily shapeci \\;ilk-in environments provt~kea mild, rather metaphorical smse of clnustrophcihia. m-hich m-ill not impress anvhody \\-h0 has encountered the Mannerist gardens and interiors that were being construrteci in Europe 450 years ago. hncl \\hat can the average museumgoer, \\-h0 takes the technical \\-irardry of MTV for granted, possibly make of the shodiiv production values in Nauman's \-ideos! Somehodv is sure to explain that Nauman's homevideo ineptne5s is his 1060s version of old-modern primitivism. It seems that \I-henever historical precedents are invoked in support of Iate-tx-entiethcentury experimentatic~n,it is in order to intimidate the audience, to shut people up. (Ince upon n time, artists challenged corn-entionai beliefs. No\\some of them just \\-ant the auciiencc to suspend judgmmt.
This is Nauman's first major museum shon- in the [Jnitcd States since
1972, and although he has never been out of the public eye, the timing is impeccable for a Inan \\-h<)is now seen as the middle-aged dad of a new nmixedmedia generation. Nsuman's zinti-;leghetic i"tt;iilght in the art sc-hools. SO are his lnarketing strategies. .41thc)ugh this has never been the kind of work that most upscale collectors \\ere going to put in their home,. the marketproof look of a lot of Nauman's pieces can he a selling point nmc,ng the museum and fc3unciation people and the blue-chip collectors \\-ho pride themselves on going where the husineis-as-usual art world fears to go. In the 1980s. \\hen collectors were betting serious money on new painting, expertunipht have dismissed the whole mixed-mediii bag ai n leftover from the self-righteous '60s. Bllt since the early 199i)s, the market has been in the doldrums. and galleries that can't sell pitintings anyway have been more inclined to give precious show s l o t to \\-ork that is practically unsaleable. At leait the dealers can feel virtuous l\-hile they're surveying the red ink. Nauman's marketing skills are relevant to our experience of his n-ork. Khen the pieces that arc on ciisplai- are ai no-dimensional as moit of Nauman's, the yueition that ends up sticking in our minds is \\-h? people allow fijm to bore them on this trujy staggering scale. Our aging youth culture
likes artists who survive their youth l\-ithout ever gro&-ingup, ancl in middle age Nsuman ha\ a knack for making his helter-skelter productions look Like a consistent development, even if it's sometimes only in a consistently inconsistent u-ay, He understands that the chamber-scale sexual sensationalism in his early m-ork. =which included a video of his 011-n genitals smeared \\-ith black pigmmt, looks visionarv a quarter century later, \\-hen law- enforcement officials in (:;tliforni;t arc allolved to photograph a pop star's private parts, ancl a Nen York City tabloid prints a photograph of the knife that a l\-oman used to cut off her husband's penis. The hard-edged vie&-of sex and violence that m-e get in Nauman's mixe recent n-ork is ai enti,tianailq-
dissociateci as \\hat \\-e're seeing on the talk sholvs and the celel3ritv trials on televisicln. ,d\ Nauman s h m - is just arts). pay-per-view TV. Irisitors will most likely leave the retrospective thinking atmut Nauman" videos csf a tortured clown and a torn~entedn~inle.Nartn~anhas been Jressinp
LIP
actors in these generic L-ostilmessince the late 1980s-they're
the most recent rats to he run through the maze. In an intervie%-in the nlagazine P~rbrtt,he refkrreci t o such costumes as masks hehinti 11-hiih "there's something you don't ]\no\\- and you're never going to find out." Rut Nauman's theatricitl fcdk are so much the passive hgures-even
\\hen
they're hokvling at u e t h a t their co\tumes register less as masks than as I~TIIIIP. lvhich Schjelciahl has iiescribcci as a "masterpiece" straitjackets. C:~F~L.II that "p"euopen a big, scary mtemporrtrv sublime," is a six-screen video shovc-in which lve see an actor in a clown costume sitting on a toilet. getting t3onkeci on the head by a pail of \vater, reciting a tongue twister that twgins "Pete and Repeat m-ere sitting on a fence," and saying "Xo" over and over again. There's no my,tery to this clown; he's just Nauman's vision of the \\-retcheci of the earth as a robotic kitsch puppet. In .$hit irri Yorrr Miri ir
I-luird
Cirilrr, the puppet is a female mime and the oppressor is heard but not seen.
The pitthetic minle goes through her paces-a movements-in
series of tortuous bends and
response tcs the droning off-screen iomnlands of a male
vcrice that orders her t i ~" P t ~your t hat m the table. Put your head on your hat. Put your hand on your head with your head on your hat. . . . " Nartn~an\\-ants us to knoll- that his vicieos csf conhnen~entand torture are n response to recent politicill events. In 1981 he read Jacoho Timerman's
P ~ Z S ~ IWlfhllat ~ I P I ii ~YQFW. C ~ l Wlfhllat i ii fYfltn/j~r and it made a big impression. Yet Nartn~an'storture videos are such a kishion-consciotrs mix csf hilininlalisrn and kitsch that it seems n little sill\- to imagine that they're going to help us ccsnnect \\-itit the nightmare of life under a totalitarian regime. Nauman shovc-s no interest in the victirtls in his videos. There are no nuances to his
represemations of the oppressor or the oppressed. and he doesn't get at \\-hat goes on between them. These videos are startling. but they are e\sentially inert. Nauman tloem't create a lvork of art that has complex internal dvnamics. Perhaps he tloem't intend to. But he tloe, expect us to have all kinds of complicitted reactions. Kc're suppo\ed to takr his shiick treatlnent and transform it into an artistic experience. No 11-ondercritics like to dig in. that rageuhrough NauI have no idea jq-t.rett1c.r the ps~chopatt~ologv man's recent m-ork is a put-on, a mid-career strategy. or straight from the heart, Frankly, I don't care. Kbat's extraordinary isn't that Kaumnan shrieks, but that people listen. His relationship with the museum world is pure
S&M, The musetlms invite him in, and he lets them have it. He's a control freak-he
hurts neon thtxntlerbolts, l->uildstletention ct~an~l->ers, shouts
command,. Since the museums keep coming hack for more, one has to ns,unIe that the people whii make the decisions are gettinp e x x tly jq-hat the\jq-ant. 117 the get-ttrugh Ic)W()s,N;luman is the Now hfan. JIX~-ARY
2 3 , 1995
SOLITARY I N THE CITY OF ART
T\\-o contempc,rary figure painters have for all intents and purposes chucked their surnames ancl their given name* in kivor of singular, rather exotic appellations. Ralthus is a childhood nickname that the young artist \\-as urged to use professionally l->yncr less an authoritv than his mother's friend Itilkr. Ritaj is the name of the man whom the artist's mother married \\-hen the t 3 0 ~\\iis 8 or 9. and although it is prekiceti by the initials R. B., the Itonald that the "K" stands fcjr is t~secl.so little as to be almost a secret. These
are artists of different generationr--Ralthu, is Xh, Kitaj is 62-n-ho
m-ere
born and have lived in different places and \\-hose \vork is in many respects as difkrent as night and day. Rut I think there is a link between these two figure painters \vho have made big. singular reputations for themselves in a contemporarv scene in which ahstraction comes first, a d their stand-alom nanles are not irrelevant to that link. At least this is h o ~it- seemed to rne last sumrner in Lon~ion,\\-hen the Kitaj retrospective that has just opened at the Metropolitan Museum of Art \\-as at the Tate Gallery at the same time that the Lefevre Gallery \\-as hosting a Balthus sholv. lvhich consisted of n single ne\\- painting, an almost six-and-a-half-fcmt-high canvas of n t3lond-haired girl plai-ing \\-ith a rat. Ralthus is painting sl~\\-lythese days. so the appearance of 7 % Cat ~ with
ikftrrt~r111, the first m-ork to come out of his studio in five years, is an event. And \\hat a pitinting it is. with its rainho\\- luxuriance of color harmonized and rnelted together by means of a magicill chi;lroscun,. There's n density to this pitinting that you \\-ill not find in an\thing in the Kitaj retrospective. In their intentions and ambitions, however, Baitbus and Kitaj are interestingly comp1ement;~rvfigures. The realist-in-an-age-t1f-a13straction equation doess s their situittions. True. these n't even begin to describe the ~ n ~ l s u a l n eof artists often appeal to people m-110 are dissatisfied m-ith the Inore reduced fcjrn~scif classic abstract art. But there's a nonconti>rnlism and an art-forart's-sake feverishness about BaIthus and Kitaj that pauadouically links them all the \\a\- hack to the nc~nconformirtt3epinnings of the modern movement against 11-hichthey're often said to be in revolt. The painters and \I-riters n-ho revere Aalthus as a (:lassicist in spite of his sometimes incendiary erotic subject matter may ncit cotlntemnce Kitaj, who is an idicrsyrtcratic Expressionht in spite of his obvious reverence for the modern canon. Rut for those \vhci keep close tabs on \\-hat both painters are up to, Balthus and Ritaj can look like the true inheritors of earlv-twentiettt-century revo-
lution. The tm-o artists paint paintings that pokr holes in the modern pieties. and m-herever and m-henever the\- exhibit, polemics fly. These artists are not easy to place: that9\kej- to their appeal. They paint appitrendy p c ~ ~ dsubject ar matter-a
hiond girl in Itattht~s'sI & f Cat mrlr ,Mrrri?r
LII, a street scene in Kitnj's Cued C~urt(198.%84), the dazzling melange of figures that \\-as platered all over Lon~lon'sUndergnjun~llast summer on the posters ~ Ralthus ancl Kitnj have such insistently personal advertising the Tate s h o Yet ought to be put together that the\- transform the ideas about how a pai~~ting
' t~r bare realist hcts into enveloping formal puzzle\, so that realit!. itself L K" ~Fins seem son~ehowal->strac t. Their l;\-orkleaves the cild debates alxru t abstraction versus representation where they ought to he, m-kch is in tatters. With the trit evolution of Krstem art to\\-ard ever umph of abstraction, =which h n ~ u g hthe greitter verisimilitude to such a startling conclusion. the possil?ilit>-opmeii up of beginning all over again, with realism as just n choice among choices. Looking at the \\-orl, of Balthus and Ktaj, \vho have made that choice, you
mq be-
gin ttr have tbr impression that the eilsentid polarity in twentieth-L-entuqat-t isn? between realism and abatractian, but bet=-een the public and the private-I>et\\-ecn the extent to l;\-hichan artist makes use of farms and struttures that are already \\-idely understood and the extent to \\-hich an artist invents a language th;tt is entirely his own.
Kitaj, \\-h0 \\-rote much of the text for the catalog of his retrospective, has been extremely forthcoming about how it feels to live at a time when, a\ far a\ art is concerned, a ~ t h i n goer. g He has a conversational prose style that's slangv. erudite, and hold, and that sometime\ recalls the lvriting of an earlier idiosyncratic .4merican mvthmakrr. Ed\\-ard L3ahlherg. Kitaj \\-rites of "the cram drama of painting," and of being "a painter \\-h0 snips offa length of picture from the flaw-ed scroll l\-hich is ever depicting the train of his interest." Although Kitaj's insistmce on explaining himself to his audience is
rather unusuai fcir an artist, 1 don? think that he" smistaken in believing that an artist \\-h0 goes his ojq-n \v;$)- \\ill cio \\ell to t3lon- his own horn. "Some people." he observes, "live out their lives in places they don't come from, assigning themselves to a strange race and an alien sense of land and city. K h o is to $a)-\\-h\- they do what they do with their lives, or for that matter. \\-h? painters do m-hat they do 11-ith their painting lives?" Rv no\\tjq-entieth-century art is such a maze of iiepersonalized "isms" that an artist has to insist on esac tlt. how he does or doer not fit in. Could it he that even Balthus, \\-h0 h a for most of his sixty-odd-year career taken the position that the work should speak for itself, is t3eginning to suspect that those \vho remain silent are condemned to being misunderstood! In recent years Balthus has exouraged his literary friends, u-ho u-ere once instructett not even to n~entionthe date of his birth, to examine the ills and out, of his hiopaphy. And he has himself been doing something he never diii-granting
interview-S.The most extensive of these. put>lishetiin the lin-
glish quarterlv .Mi~di.rnP d t j l t r n this past fall, is a conversation that Balthus had over the course of an afternoon with the rcsck strtt. David Bowie (1%-hois a serious collector of contemporary English art and has lately hegun to s h o ~his C N - ~
pai~lti~lgs), This interview is an essential addition to the Balthus archives,
a great old pitinter's most sustzuned effort to tell us \\-hat he helin-es. Kben Baftlius and lCitaj speak out, they present contemporary .;aria.ticln on a theme that got.\ aiI the way hack to Rat~deiaire.'They I-relieve that in order to k n m - himrelf, the artist must know his public. And they t3elieve th;tt if the artist's imagination is powerful mough it can goad, skekver. refute. ignore. correct. and in rare instances even transform public perception. Balthus a d Kitrtj take this cisrnplex relationship n-ith the pul-rlii in .;er)- different tiirections. In the , L I d ~ r ePd1t11e1.sinterview; Balthus observes that "pmbably . . . \.;hiit people hate so much in m!- \\-ark is harmony. Everything is so contrary to harmony today." If you examine this statement for n moment,
you realize that here \ve have our preenlinent figure painter asserting that the reality he presents in his paintings is a reality that rontrariicts the Edits of Life. Ktrtj, on the other hand, can sound like an eccentric populist when he sets out his ideas. He has kvwttrn that his paintings are "picture\ of an imperileci \\-0rlc1 YOU may knoll- only as imperfectly as I iio, if at all." In Kitaj's lvriting, the line bet\\-ren \\hat's within the studio and \\-h;tt's heyon~1the studio is never clraj\-n very clearly. He argues against the ivtjry t m - r r by suggesting that public experience is a magnification of private experience. Yet in his o\vn rounditbout \\-ay he arrives at an attituiie that is, a\ much as Balthus's magi\terial isolaticln, a version of the Bat~defrtireanstance-the
artist is tiirever ru-
minating on his troubled relationship =with the public. The tvpical Balthus pitinting is of a person alone-the
solitary girl in the
t3;trcly furnished room. The t y i c a l Kitaj is a crowd scene. But Ktaj has also painted retreats: there are some canvases of deserted interiors, especiallv bedrooms, that he has described as his recollections of time spent with friends and lovers. And Balthus ha\ paintrci street scene, full of strangers
\\-ho, unbekno\vnst to trne another, are taking their places in what amount to surreal urh;tn pantomime,. In fact one of the grande\t images of modern public life comes from Balthus, 11-ho completed his final salute t o the
f arisian streets, T ~ Pilssagii P dtl Colntrt~ri~ Sar~t-~4lz(lrP, in f 994, just before he moved his studio from the city that fcxrned him a* an artist. Kitaj saw the Pd\sirge----in =which Balthus appears as the figure carrying n baguette-at
the
Baithus retrospectke in 1983 in Paris, and it inspired \\-hat is certainly Kitaj's best painting so h r . the phantasmagoria on the subject of i*,n~lonstreet life.
~ Lc'tl~lilti B7C2 jlkv Rtyigp~s) \\-ith the meandering title: C P ICt~tlri, Cecil Court is a real place-a c,ff<:hnring Cross Roitd-but
teens)- street of antiquarian bookshops just the theme of Kitaj's painting, =which is the citv
a* a theater in =which m-e act out our lives, will he himiliar to anybody 11-ho has lived in a great metropolis. Kitaj (who \\;is born in (:leveland, ( Ihio. and
grem- up there and in Troy. N e n York) has become a connoisseur of cities: N ~ MYt~rk, Paris, &%rnsterdam, Los Angeles, and, of course, London, which
has been home t3itse for more than thirty years.
Cri-ll Corirt
is about the Lon-
don phase of Kitaj's life, hut it is also about the inside-outside status of an artist \\-h() keeps his own counsel amid the crazy iirCtlsof the world. The schematic perspective and bright coloring th;tt E t a j uses in
Cri-ll Ct9srt
recall
a Victorian toy theater, and through this mad-cap setting---all hillhoard bright colors m d acid-etched line\-rush
a cast of characters that define
London's heterogeneity. They include a bald old man gra\ping a nosegai-, a doll-like pitir of kids, a young \\Oman \\-ho, legs ajar, throws herself ;tt the \\-orld. These m m and \\-omen are memorable in the \\-ay that people \\-e catch sight of in the street can he memc~rahle:we comprehend a personality in a glance, or at least \\-e think \ve do. Yet each of Ktaj's figures is absorbed in some private reverie, and they are all appitrcntly ot,li\ic~usto the artist, l;\-horecline5 in the midst of the urban maelstrom on a cbron~eLe <:orbusier lounge chair, a book at his side and another object. m-hich may \\-ell be a book, in his hand, So far as I knoll; Kitaj's Cuiti Coriri and Ralthus's Pauirg~hitvr never hung
in the same room, but the\- \\-ould make an interesting pair. Kitaj is bitsically developing it vxiatian trn Ratthus3 absorbha theme, except that the street life that is depressive in the Paris painting become, lnanic in the I.ondon painting. Where the m0od of 1 7 P~ssirge ~ iir~Commrrir Sirrnt-/l,iiirr' is mibty and grayed-do\vn and quietly discreet. Cut-ri Ct9urr, paintecl thirty years later. is hard-edged and almost brash. Balthus see, himself from the t3itck. kvalking a\;\-ayfrom us; you might say that he's forever retreating from the tm-ilit scene he has imaginecl. Kitaj, reclining in the rnidht of everything in Cecil Court, is the lead player \vhci does not---or prefers not to-fit
in. Kitaj, an
American living in Lonclon, paints pitintings that give the idondonstreets an American vehemence. Balthus, altt~oughborn in Paris, has spent more of
his life in Italy and S\\-itzerland (where he lived as a child, pitsseci some of n r l d War II. and hiis non- settled dom-n). and his imagination is perhaps n ~ o r at e home in the Rcxne or Siena or Kyoto of art history than in the Paris of fact. Roth artists have gone in their 0%-ndirections-they're
sc~litariesin
the crc)wCZ~dcity of art,
Cut-ii Ctoart comes near the midpoint of Kitaj's retrospective. T h i ithe painting to m-hich everything m-e have seen before seems to lead. and it is the meilure agiinst 11-hichevery work that comes after, including such interestas Ili rbu 51.11 and TIPW~rliirt!y.must be juiiged. The period of ing recent pai~~tings
Cued Cnlrri and of another first-rate piiinting, the recollection of an .4merican t3oyhooJ that is called Bus~hiril.is Kitaj's most fertile phase; thew kvorks are 130th ciateti 1983--84. Rut I'm not sure how- much people \\-ill be able to fi~cus on them within the context of the show because. like most retn~spectivesthat are mounted these days, the Kitnj s h o ~is- \\-ay too big. -4 dozen paintings and three dozen cirawings \\-ould have given a far better sense of \\-hat Kitaj can do than the more than one hundrecl. items that are includett here. se As it is, the drawings get a little bit l0\t, and that's a shame, b e c a ~ ~ they are among Kitaj's finest achievements. Kitaj's way \\-it11 a pencil or n stick of charconl or pastel is absolutely intuitive: dr;i\\-ings that catch the eye this easily can't be lvilled into existence. Kitaj draws in a naturalistic and at times even journalisac vein that 0%-essomething to L)egas and something t o Lautrcc: he uses elegant knife-edge linear effects to create claw-up views of the people he kniw-\ and loves, and the end prcjduct is a casually encyc-lopedic contemporary portrait gallery. The studies of public figures \\-h0 also happen to be good friends, such as Isaiah Berlin and Philip Roth. shom- an easy, idiomatic grasp of the \;I!-
that a &iceunlocks a personality. E t a j draws
(Juentin Crisp using a mix of charcoal and muted pa*tel that is one of his mo\t successful chromatic conceptions; the result is a stunning Expressionistic image. terrifying and appealing. The studio nudes, t3ntl1 female and
male, exude a physicd self-confidence that gives us Kitnj's definitic,n of gK,&-n-up erotic experience. \Vho else has done male nudes that ronvev a man's sense of sexual power2 There are also extraordinarv Lira\\-ings of Kitaj's family-his
mother, ciaughter. and son. The drakving of his son i.em
reacling a hook is among the very best-xact
yet meltingly mmantic.
Khen an artist cirms from life, he kvmts to give an imaginative dimmsion to actual things. Kitaj is by no\\- an old hand at this kind of transfcirmation. yet \\-hen he turns frt~rndra\\-ing to pAnting he often seems to httve no compass to guide him. As a ciraftsman. Ktaj uses nature to ciiszipline his imagination. As a painter, he hiis an imagination that is larger than life. so much so thttt there are rooms in the retrospecthe \\-here nothing tliat he imagines is plain!?, simply alive as art. He turns his intellectual gifts into hyperbolic effects. He \\ants ever!-thing from his tigures: he means them to hold together complicated allegories involving themes such n memory and obsession, \\-hich I can't help concluding n ~ u s he t paihng-proof. In .Igilrn,i Slirrrii~r ( 1 9 ( 3 H t ) , he paints a city ftdl of gossips; in
B717fttt"liU ~ I L /ikf~ltt(19%-43) a battle is
breu-ing behveen the sexes; I ; l v ~ n n ~ l il'rllrltjr h (L 94G4.3) is a landscape of memor!-. The ideas are thriilingly serious, hut n lot of these paintings are just sillyputty "aces. Foreground and biickgrouncl, left and right, up ancl down slide into one another lvith a casu;tl \\-illfi~lne\sthttt forecloses any possilaliw that the canvas can cohere. Gcrl C;otirt and Uu5pb~11are tlt~iddream spaces thttt someh o simultaneou\ly ~ respect an idea of spatial ancl temporal unity.
(;wipnirzch
IYtildgu may follon-a dream logic. hut it does not make pictorial sense, and that is the onlv kind of sense thttt ever really matters in pai~~ting.
Kitaj's fascination as an artist has to cio lvith his \\-ay of pulling clisparate idea., and inspi'ations together into an insouciant si:rapboi>kstyle. He certainly gives nem- panache to a collage-soaked smsihilitv that runs through classic modern art and literature ancl is exemplified by Err;%Pound's Cusii~s
and Max Beckmann's tripychs. I salute Kitaj's intellectual nen-iness. Who else kvould even imagine that it \\as possible to paint \Valter Benjamin's idea\, the experiences of Khlter Lippmann. Tixlmudic concepts. a scene from the details of one's earliest sexu;ti encounters? Kitaj the life of Henry &%dams, has ciarcci to go where no one with his sophistication has gone before. Yet there are just too many paintings in =which Kitaj is letting the pieces fall as the\- may and then plugging up the compositional cracks =with blocks of t3rigl't. flat color. He tolerate\ far too many grating. stop-and-start effects. Disjuncture. \\-hich is kej- to Kitaj's work. is a method he has aditpted from the copybook of abstraction. 1)isjuncture once t3rought fresh drama into art l>\-rhallmging the idea that a painting represents a single slice of time and space. But tociav abstraction is all too often a virtually acadenlic mterpri,e. dedicated to preserving some small trove of painting's possilalities, and Kitaj's \er!- crarine\s has a strong ~10seof the formulaic. Still. it is Kitaj's \\ay of ilsi~lg the (:uhist-derived idea of disjuncture to rehabilitate older form\ of storytelli~lgthat has en~learedhim to many of today's unconventional reitlists, \vho say that they \\-ant to bring narrative hitck into art. If you like Kitaj-<)r
the
idea of Ritaj----it is going to be because he has so many stories to tell. Yet last summer in London, \\-hen the only p a i ~ ~ t i nthat g Balthus has tinished in the past five years was hanging across to\\-n from the Kitaj retmspective, each exhil3ition \\a\ in its own \\ay a s t z k reminder of ho%-pnjhlematic narrative is today. Ralthus had rejected exactly the kind of comple.; narratives that his 1 \vith 1,001 stories to tell fans desperately lvanted him to pn~duce.n ~ Kitaj. about our overpopulated 11-orld.was in the midst of a project that no living artist could possibly bring to completion.
P ~ f n t r fintervievc; i Baltk~ussotrnds both cheerful and austere, In the .qiq~d~rt~ a latter-dav pirrlmi?p[~rensconced in a Sm-iss "'retirement" from n-hich he's pleased to contemplate his turbulent pa\t in Paris ancl Rome. Balthus is perfectly &\\;ire of W-hatis going on around him and of the contemporary ap-
peal of Kitaj's overload of images. Yet he has no complaint. Sometimes he simply turns aside a line of questioning, and a fen of those silences tell us everything that \%-eneed to knm-. Listen carefully to Balthuh on the subject of subject matter; after all, his sexually explicit imagery \\-as iontroversiai long before Rohert Mapplethc3rpe \\-as horn. "The subject has no importance." Ralthus saj-S."The subject for me is al\\-a\-sa pretext to make a painting.'T!~is is not an eva.,ion but it L-onsideredhigfi modern position. Balthus \%-a.ntsboth the provocateurs and the prudes to knon- that they're mixsing the point, Khat, then, is the point! I think th;tt according to Balthus it is that the red storv is the storJ-of the making of the pai~~ting. Balthus is, after his 0%-nhshion, a formalist, but he hastens to distance hirnself Ifrcmi \%-hathe secs as the solipsistic situation of the artist \vho is "obsessed l>\-pai~~ting." \Xrh;ttBalthus t3rlie~esis missing in much rnociern pAnting is "tension . . . a sort of no repose." .%S far as his own practice is concernr~i.he finds the needed tension not in his subject matter but in the \cry pnlcess of Iooking-"looking
at a ch;tir.
looking at a cup of tea, or any object at all." The looking out is also n looking in, for the truth is that much of the apparently naturalistic- material in Ralthus's paintings has been dreamed up in the studio. There's an almost metaphj-sical dimension to perception. As Ralthus explains it, even "whm I paint ,[)mething after nature. I'm al\\-a\-srecognizing something in mvself." Ralthus's rejection of the questic~nof suhjec t matter-althc3ugh
proha-
bly to some degree strategic, a jibe at the people \%-h0imagine themselves to be his disciples and \%-h0t3elieve that subject matter is the engine ciriving p a i n t i n ~ c u n t r a ' t s dramatically 11-ith Kitaj's manic cultivation of a dozen subjects at once. And \-et even Ritaj ciinnot exape the elsentiai fact of modern art, =which is that the \%-aythat a painting is made. once a matter of hehind-the-scenes magic. is no\\- the key t~ a viewer's heart and mind. It doesn't matter m-hether the painting is more or less abstract, mtrre trr less
realistic. Since reality is no longer a given. everything is a gamble. If Kitaj is an extrclne case of the tendency of modern art to mirror a l\-orld that many people believe has gone all to pieces. Ralthus is our most triumphant current e x m p l e of an artist \\-ho knows how to put it all back together. In the
Madpm Parnrvrr intervie&-he says that he is "nl\\-ay\ tapping on the same nail. I think \\hat I have kept in a certain \\-ay, is rnv vision a\ a child. That sort of surprise in front of things." Kith this parable of a child banging a first nail into a first piece of \\-ood \vho turns into an old man \vho's doing exactly the same thing. Balthus take\ his rightful place among the great simplificrs.
"I'm considering myself n a craftsman." he says. "I don't m-ant t o be an artist. I have a horror of the \\-orCf,'' Since completin g the melancholy P~sslrguiitr Cnnini~n-uSirlni-~ltrdri;in 1954, Balthus has become an increaiingly inn-ad-turning painter, He has put ncr more than two figures in a painting in the past twenty-eight years; mostlv he paints one figure at a time. The raw materials that go into his paintings don't vary that much. There are the juxtaposed plane, of floor and \\a11 and furniture, the curves of the model's body, the angle of the light. But thmugh subtle shifts in the \\-ay that he carpenters together these e\sential elements, he no%-seems to be able tci make just ahtrut anytfiing ha.ppen. He's a ma\ter craftsman m-ho l\-arks unhurriedly, deliberately: the authenticity of the pmiluct is guaranteeci by the austerity of the process. Balthus has l->ec-omeas lnuch cif a E-tack-to-basics artist as Mondrian. I think it is Ralthus's in*istence on simplicit\- that frequently dismai-s those who look to his work for \\-hat Mondrian cioe, not give them. n d those \\-h0 find something \\-anting in the figu rc paintings of Bal thus may \\ell end up being happier l\-ith the work of Kitaj. \\-h0 keeps knocking together memorably crazy 'iq-hatnotsout cif all kinds ofhtrnd n~aterials. In London I heard it said that Ralthus's n e n canvas \\-as perfect hut sornehow not satisfying. Balthus has anslvereci this complaint in the ,Wod~re
Pdiniris interview, in =which he observes that if people look to his paintings
for the disharmony that they knoll- in life they will he disappointeci. He saFs that people are "shrinking tuck from t3ea~tv.. . . I i v o ~ speak of beautv, you are at cince suspected o f . . . kitsch.'" Khen I);ivid liolvie asks Ralthus \\-hich of his pitintings he like\ the best, he am%-ers,as many artists do, by tafking ahtrut his recent work. I agree \\-ith Ralthus \\-hen he saFs that the nem- CA ivrih ,Llrm?r is one of the finest things he has ever done. It's a painting that t~nitesthe Biedermeier soliditv
of the iompo\itions that first made Balthus h m o u s in the 1931)s m-ith the overripe color that was enchanting him in the 1950s: that is it\ particular k n d of harmon!. Here the old lialthusian erotic charge has cooled to an androgynous tingle. The young girl, ciresseci in a contemporary tunic-and-leggings combination th;tt looks a lot like a meciieval costume. might e a d v be mitaken for an extremely han~isomeyoung prince. The painting offers a distant. philosophical view of beau t\-.The key to everything is the \\-ork's extraordinary scale. ?be Ckr wtth ,Llzr~?rI I I is at cince intiltlate and rnonun~ental, and that union of oppo\ites leaves us 11-itha feeling of alrno\t preternatural calm. There is a story to he read in this densely worked yet utterly spontaneous canvas. and it is a very simple one. Balthus began to pitint a hiry-tale princess: he 11-orkeci for five long years; and m-hen he \\-as finished the princehs had been granted eternal life.
WAR STORIES
Deep into the second decade of the culture \\-ars. \vith the assaults and countera*saults unfolding 11-ith undiminhhed ferocity, the contemporary art that generally receives the most attention is jingoistic, one-dimensiona1. a placard raised in a dehate. This sloganeering that masquerades n art come* from all side* and is seen every\\-here. (In an average day in SoHo. n gallerygoer \\-ill be unable to avt~idthe canned chaos of retro-'60s assemcartoon styles. and a prefkb tradiblage, the if-you-ran't-lick-'e1n-jc)inn'en~ tionalism that range* from i.o\ n g e l e s Minimal to Mediterranean Classic. Some artists cornl?iinre classics ancl cartoons. They
mq,at least temporar-
ily. be hailed as sax*\-\-politicians. As for the best pAnters and sculptors, they have h;tsically derided not to take positions. Excellent artists are \\-orking and nhil,iting, hut \vhm the\- dc-~exhilit \\-hat mq first strike a galler>-goeris the i~~warifne\s of the u-ork, a self-ahsorpticin that can bt. mistaken frtr irrelevance, This quality is not necessarily linked to the size of an artist's reputatk'n: a resolute self-containment is as essential a factor in the enigmatic ahstracti~insof Rill Jensen,m-ho is the moht original painter to have nchin-ed a top-flight reputiition in recent years, as it is in the \\-ark of many less \veil-knoll-n artists. The strongest \\-ork that9\k i n g clone today suggests no dominant shle, tx..~t it all hiis scimething of the fierce clarity and complicate~iinn-ardne\s that one expects from private journal entries made in kvartime. to the SoL-Io vileries 1.rcdd This is niit a moment when casml ex-llrsic~ns much appeal, and I ciinnot blame the sophisticated public that has ,v,-orn c,ffcontemporarv art, preferring to return to the ( )ld Ma*ters in the Metropolitan and the Frick. Even the critics are in denial. The muffled, npologeticall\. evenhancled reviews of the \i'hitne\- Biennial that have appeared since
the she\\- openeci in March suggest that the very people who make contemporary art their business don't expect much and are in a make-~ioframe of mind. Klaus Kertess. kvhci organized this year', Biennial, is passing the peace pipe around m-hen he \\-rites in the catalog that he supports "not a return to formalism hut an art in which meaning is embedded in formal value." Like so many late-t3reaking devclopmmts in the culture lviirs, the 199.5 Biennial is horn of reaction, in this case a reaction to the li'hitney's la*t Bimnial. The theme of the 1093 she\\- \\-as announced in a catalog preface in \I-hich the museum's director, I)a.i.iJ lioss, praised the artists for their rejection of "cynical formalism" in &\or of "the geopolitical, the psychosocial," and \\-hat he c a l l e d i n an attempt at hyperliteracv that sc~undedmore like illiterat-\--"the
hodv's politic." This \\-as a s h m - in which an artist with de-
grees from Brown and Stanforil reflected on man's inhumanity to man Jressinp up in kitsch ethnic garb a d spending several hours a d~ locked in a metal cage m-atching old \vesterns on TV .4 m-hole museum full of that kind of poststructurillist radical chic turned out to be too much even for the people \\-h0 live for politicill art, and Ross and his curator. Elisabeth S ~ ~ s s m afound n, themselves \\-ith what became regarded as The Bienaial That Had (;one Too Far. Ross haci plaj-eci the art-and-politics card and lost, and t~avinghit bottilm he h e m - that there was niwhere to go but up. Since then the K'hitney hasn't e,che.;i-ed politicd gestures, it's just become better at packaging them and distributing them. This seaon's political she\\-. "Black Male: Representations of Masculinity in (:ontemporar\- .4merican Art." got the generally \\-hite male critics into exactly the \\\-eat of guilt and remorse and arcommo~lationthat the li'hitney had hoped to trigger in
1093. And no\\-, just a n ~ o n t hafter ""Back Male" m-cnt tlown, we have the payhat-k, a Biennial that the \\-hite hews can say is nice to look at. Klaus Rerte\s has mounted the ultimate nonthreatming Biennial. Krht~. after going thmugh this show that fills every floor and nook and cranny of
the Brhitney, believes that Kertess stands for anything at all! Kertess has been spoken about as a man \vho cares ahout painting, but these clays caring about painting is often nothing but a debating point, ancl the Biennial that Kertess has come up with is little more than a truce among rival kctions. There are no high points: the loll- points are kimiliar one,: the me\sage is that \;\-hatis is \;\-hatis.. The scariest thing ahout the mid-'90&mood is that people are so \\-ithdra%-nthat they're missing the point of, or even missing entirely, a lot of the new work that has a c-oncentrated fcjrce. Trcvor \Virtkfielct\ first shciw cif paintings in six years, which \\-as at E, M. Donahrre, presented a complicatecily allegorical view of po\tmodern chaos that if taken to heart could prohahlv cure a case of the Biennial hlahs. But given that nohod); any longer believes that miracles can happen in art galleries. I \l-on't he surprised if even the people \\-h0 \a;\\-\Vinhfield's \\ark have difficult\- disting~lishingit fro111 the overfull eccentric abstractions of Lari Pittman. =which are pitrt of the Biennial blahs. Kinkfield's u-as one of the two stlows in recent n-eeks that have given a gallerygoer something to take out of the gillery and play ar0~1nc1 with in the n~inJ'seve. The other n-as S t a n l e ~Lewis's first completelv coherent show in eight years. \\-hich \\-as at the Bo\\-ery Gallery. I.e\\-is's jitgged yet delicate painterly realism is in every obvious \;\-ayunlike Brinkfield's zany Surrealist c,nslaught--they're
pn~hahl\-totidly unaware of each other's l;\-ork-hut
this
time around both artists \\-ere cleali~lgwith the same suhject. The best \\ark in \Vinkfield3ssho&-\\-as a painting called 17iu Strrdtij, and the stnjngeht group of \\-orks in Lem-is's \\-as a series of dra;\\ings of his stuciio. The studio is alkvays \\-here the action is, and Kinkfield and I.e\vis. by putti~lgthe action in italics. are telling us that they're hanging in there fcjr the duration. Kba.t happens when an artist gets do&-nto jq-ork is aln-vs essentiatly the same. It has to clo \vith p~lshingfor1115 as kir as they will go. \vith allokving
the logic of the forms to unfold as you g<,along. There must he logic, but the mFstery is that the logic is always changing, and an artist neecis an extraordinary combination of open-mindcilne,~and precision to be able to go
\\-hen the going gets good. (;oing deeper into the studio is literally the subject of Lewis's big. romantically Expressionist pencil clra\\ings, and he makes the theme \\-ork for him because he n~ltkesa gallerygoer believe that each plunge into real space is an emotional adventure. There were several startlingly lovely paintings in the Rower\- shon. \\-ith unforieci yet precise passage5 of autumn foliage set against hard blue sky, but the stuclio &a\\-inps v\-ere the main event. Len-is has a gorgeous \\-a\-kvith his jitbl3ing pencil lines: he erases so much that the paper starts t o give out; and then he collages on more paper and starts ag;tin. He makes me h e l dizzy as I go tltrouph this jumbled lab\-rinth of easel& tables, shelves, sculptures. paintings, paint cans, and miscellaneous junk. These convoluted Mnnnrrist spaces are full of contradictory vistas and alarming leaps in scale. Le\\-is gives h i dra\\-ings some of the space-fmtasv element t h a t we know from Piranesi's Cilrcerl. and this makes perfect sense, because the artist's studio ran fcel like a prison (in spite of all the potential escape routes). Le\\-is uses abstract velocities for realist effect, and he's right to bring this kincl of dissc~nanceinto his work, because m-e're living at a time \\hen homogeneity strikes us a* an impossibility-a
dream that failed. Purism looks
illogical: more than that, it looks ~lishone5t.The lvork that seems to he rating ahead admits of the simultaneous presence of opposing fc3rces---abstract and realist. Classic ancl Romantic---ancl revels in the unexpected affinities. Modern art began h\- taking the nineteenth century's encyclopedic rataloging of the past for granted. The artists admired that pa*t, plzii-ed with it. leaped fcjrward from it. (:reatic~nwas a reacti~n.Rut in the hest 11-orkthat's coming out of the studios today, there's less of an us-and-them feeling
about the reliltionship of the old and the new, the sophisticated and the vernacular. The artists \\-h0 are no%-in their 40s and 50s took in everything at once-pop
culture, Ild Masters. modern art---and the result is that mix-
ups don't surprise them, and they are able to think of certiiin kinds of mixups as suggesting nem- kind, of unity.
KIatls Kertess has included all kinds of styles in his Khitney Biennial, but this does not mean that the artists he is spotlighting k n o n what t o d o \\-ith their freedom to choose. Kertess has an eve for arresting images. t ~ t he doesn't k m % -how structures bring imagery to life. S o \\-hat's the point? The shcm- preaches open-mindedness, hut at heart it's produit-oriented, ends-oriented. Kertess's idea of a gooci painting is an elegant surface that does n o t k n g (as in Brice Marden) or nest t o notfiing (as in the Agnes Martins). His choice of a painterlv realist is the likable but limited Iane I'reilicher, lvhc) knons ho%-to nurse her nayvet(. so that it registers as a curious poetic mannerism. Vi'hen he digs up a younpcr abstract artit-Sam Reveles is a rase in point-the
lvork is so flaccid and inept that it leaves
one m-ondering if Kcrtess has an): idea of hum- a brushstroke achieves d);namic poner. n c i Kertess cioesn't do much better lvith photography, althcjugh leff Witll's photographic variation on a Hokusai print-in
=which a
gust of n-ind lifts a huncile of papers into the air and men clutch their headgear-cioes
uncover pleasing poetic ciouble entencires \\-ithin t h e
pearlv light of ;in unexceptional day. In his catalog e,say Kertess looks to Borges's Fdmous story "The Library of Bahrl" for an analogy to the art scene. m-hich he speaks of as the Museum of Babe!. Kertess doesn't press the analogy, hut he does, in an eight-page picture e,say that precedes the title page, justapose photographs of the Tcnver of Babe! and the Virhitne.r-Museum, and he obviously believes that contemporary arti\ts are caught in the rnidbt of a Rabel of meaning. Kertess rea*c,ns
that the artists \vho are confronted \\-ith this overload must reach beyond meaning h\- turning
''3
mental concept into completely sensory experi-
mce." n d he goei on to saj- that "this transference that takes place in time and space is metapllor.'" Rertess isn't much of a \I-riter, but the ideas he's alluding to are ai o h i clus ai they are arnorptlous, m d contentptsrai~artists won't have any troutde knolving \\hat he has in mind. You can count on the fingers of your hands, however. the artists in this Biennial who ran present metaphor as a process, not an a ~ i t u d e.4 . room-size assemblage. such ai the j'ason Rhc3adrs piece with the heaps of donu ts, is, like the rest of the neo-A11an Raprokv and neo-Brure Nauman stuff in the sho\v, ideologicallv metaphorical, nothing more. So is moit of X\-hatwe see here of ciirtoon-inspired art. although Carroll Ilunham and Philip Taaffe, \vho t3oth adapt some of the surface effects of popular illustration and design. do prove that pop color and pop form have metaphorical possibilities. Taaffe's abstractions. with their Midiile Eastern patterning and retro-chic l?iomorphism, ma!- add up to little more than great graphic cie\ign, hut the artist's \\-a\-of stmciling and printing his c010rs gives irnpm~malitya piquant visual character that can heat up a work. The problem for artists \\-h<,see real picture-making possibilities in pop imagery is that it's almost impossibly hard to fc)llo\\- an intuitive visual logic \\-hen one is using fr~rmsthat have heen devised to make everybody see and feel the same thing. No artist has heen caught in this dilemma more oftm than Dunham. a psvchedelic sophisticate who can he hard ancl calculating in his paintings (see the Biennial selection) and generally loosens up in a good \\-ay in his diaristic cira\vings, \\here he remembers \\-here R. Crumb ends a nni. and C. Dunharn btk'
As for Trcvor VYinkfield, whose show at fl, M. Donahue opened in the same \\-rek as the Bienniitl, he gets going at exactlv the point \\here the Kertess show" cartoon side runs out of steant. W'inkfield's work is cartoonis11 in
that the mass-market people couldn't imagine in their \\-ildcst dreams. Kinkfield make\ a metaphor out of Kertess's Babel, but I cloubt that Kertess really \\-ants to have his conflicts resolved. 1,rC'inkficld'sa13strat-tions are the products of a delightfully split sensihilitv-ha1f lid\\-ardian pack rat-ancl
orthodox (:onstructivist, half
that split gives him intuitive access to the high-vcr-
sus-lon confusions. Kinkfield presents a construction-paper-13right lvorld in thingamajigs and even inanimate objects \\-hich people are amalg;ms of -,%-\-rid , going to happen next in ily off the handle. Although one never k n o ~ -\\hat's Kinkfield's hard-edged Surrealist spaces, he does understand that it is his responsibility to demonstrate th;tt the center ultimately holds. He's an anthologist of kitsch dra\\-ing shies, each considered thnjugh his eyes, his smsilaliw. He's also a connt~is,eurof the shifts in emphasis that turn s ~ l into e neo-st>-le and then into n e n st>-le.( If the t m paintings in the Donahue show, five or six are of an Art t3eco intricacy that's almost too clever, three or four are first rate. ancl 11ru Stfrihil,an audacious treatise on the art of piunting, is pnjhablv the best thing that Kinkfield has ever done,
In I%P S I I I J E ~\*Y;rinkfic.ld ?, presents both the creator and the sueation-to the right is t h e I3adaist marionette of an artist. t o the left is \\-hat he's \I-rot~pht-and Vi'inkfiel~ishows them to be both distinct and intertm-ined.
The artist is a harum-sciirum comic hero \\-h0 aclvertises his lofty aspirations with a sort of medieval headgeau and a bit of sihoolbov" scornanhero drag, but basically he's so busy trying to hold the line in the studio that he can't give us the time of day. His easel, composed of Suprematist angled lines and a couple of pipes that recall Magritte's Cut-i a'est piis unr prpu, is in a state of near-collapse. n d the paihng-within-a-painting-22
harcl-
to-parse creation that includes, maybe, a hit of Grand (:anyon kitsch-is dangerousk aske\\-. lllr Stfrdzir. \\-ith its inspiriting orchestrations of deep recls and blues. is the self-portrait of an artist \\-h0 km\\-s the world is going crazy and \vho just presses on. The mess;tge is altogether upbeat. If you
have your feet firmly planted on the ground-as shou-n frijrn aho-\-e,clearly are-then
this artist's sandled ones.
everything else can float and flv m d
spin, K h a t I love atmut this painting is the carefully kveiphted details that Kinkfield gives to his \vilde*t kncies. A treatise on painting must have its color theory, and Kinkfield presents his in the form of a shelf with glass beakers full of paint that appears in t3oth a six-color and a seven-color version; it's reminiscent of the
I O ~ Sof
l a h ~ r a t ~ r y - p r e c ijars e of pigments in
p h o t o g ~ i p l xof Kandinsky's Paris studio. On the right side of
nlu Stuiilo the
cache of colors is in good order, as neat as in Kandinsky's atelier. On the other side of the painting, h<>\\-ever, something is amiss. The shelf is slipping, and the beaker of purple paint is no\\-here to he found. I m-ondered \\-hat haci twcome of that royal purple. and then I found it clu tcheci in the marionette-like artist's ha.nd. With the brush in his r,ther hand, he's bt~sy giving his painting a fen- purple pit\sage\. ( If course the shelf is at an angle: inspiration has struck. n d thmugh a process of transfc~rmation.\\-hereby the pitint within the pitinting is picked up l,\- the painter in order to create the painting, Kinkfield, for perhaps the first time in his career, pushes beyond ~iazrlingdesign to the freeciom of composition. Kinkfirlci's eclecticism can be called postmodern. But postmodern implies reaction, a\ in the new ttate for the old reacting against the old ta\te for the new, and Brinkfield is too much the unronflicted antipurist to he an ideologue of any stripe. The best artists of lyinkfield's generation-he's 51-are
all committed to an idealistic eclecticism. Such an open-ended aes-
thetic could never gain wide acceptance amid the perpetually r e d r a ~ - nbattle lines of the art scene, and h\- no?%-its origins are lost forever in the pwhistory of the culture \\-ars. but artists are dreamers ancl they just keep on dreaming. ,%pparentlvthei-krcnot the only ones. 1)amneci if KLauss Kerte\s, 11-ho's34, doesn? tbelieve in that openness, too. And he's pone right out
and sold the ifream to the devil by turning ideatistic eclecticism into a Khitney Museum product. K h e n it i.on1es tir contemporary art, ntjbody can make a difference at the 1i'hitne)-: the place is too far gone for that. Rut doesn't it ever occur to itqbody ttr just sq. no?
Leon Ki?ssoff paints a gritty, untouristy London, and he does it \\-ith such \\-onderful miling pitint surEaccs ancl pearly opitlescent gm!-s that even people \vho k n m - the citv fairly m-ell may feel some regret at the things they have rnisseci. Kossoff is representing lingland at the ITeniceBiennale this summer, and in the couple of dozen paintings that hang in the beautiful galleries of the British Pavilion-they
include portraits, nudes, and land-
scape" as \\-ell as city vie\\-*--he gives this shambl\-, rumpled, h u m ~ l r u m London of his an exhilarating. ilolving grace. Kossc~ffis a city cineller to his fingertips. He knolvs that ordinary sights can have n tillismanic PO\\-er preciselv because m-e're seeing them all the time. In some recent paintings of people rushing to and fro in front of a ilolver stall at the limbankmmt Station of the [Tnderground, he uncovers a
grayeci-tio\vn-yet-cc3ruscated 1990s version of the poetry of the everyday. Another series of paintings, which he's been \\orking on for ciecades. features the boldly piled-high facade of one of the monuments of English Baroque awhitecturc: Nicholas E-lawksmoor's <:hristchuw h, \\-hi& rises out trf the rough-and-read\- nrighhorhc)od of Spitalfirlcir, not far from the citv. In Kossoff's (:hristchurch pitintings, the magnificent formal insentheness of
a masterkvork that's just down the street become, one element in the dynamics of neighhorhood life. Kossoff, kvho's 69, grew up near (:hristchurch. and in these paintings one feel&hciw nmuch has gone on around the church. \\-ith its ciramatically soaring clock to\\-er. Spitalfieliis has been htsme to \\-ayes of Russian Jewish, Irish, and Rmgali immigration and is no\\- being gentrifie~i(the art team of (iilbert and (ieorge lire around the corner). I n~entilsntitis neighhorhocsd history because Londoners with whom I locked at the paintings in Lrenice tidd n1e about it, but in a sense it" implicit. The social forces that underlie Kossoff's churning surEaccs are kimiliar to anybtrdy who's spent time in the urban maelstrom, in Idondonor New h r k or a number of other cities. Although Kossoff hasn't had all that many one-man sholvs in lingland, he is non- a major figure in Idondon.where he's vie&-eciin the context of an ilngciing lnf,rlish Liclmantic-Expressic~nisttrdition. In tbc past twenty ?cars he has also had t\\-o s h o ~ -in s New York and three in Los Angeles. and these American appearances have left a stmng impwsion. Around 19.50 Ko\soff sti~diecim-ith David Bomberg, a painter \\-ho's gone into the history btroks \\-ith a fe&-angular \Tortic-ist abstractions from I9 12-13 but \\-h<)devoted mo\t of his \\-orking life (he died in 1957) to an emc~tive,painterk realism. The relationship between Bomberg ancl Kossoff (and Frank 4urrh;ich. another Bolnberg student with a ilnir for Idondongrit) is a case of an influence that's so clear that the younger generation's \\-orl\ alrnmt becomes an organic extmsion of =-hat the older generation \\-as doing. Some of Rc?ssoff's drawings, \\-ith their heavy, jutting line,. might be mistaken for the studies of Idondon architecture that Bcimberg \\-a doing fifty years ago. .4nd in Bomberg's earl\- ITorticist works there's an equation het\%-eenthe overall activation of the surface and the over%-helmingnessof city life that Kossoff has had the inspiration to bring all the \\-ay into the open through his everpresent net\%-arkof thickly Lira\\-n dark lines.
Thew in\istent lines give Kossofi's paintings the magnifieci clarity of children's book illt~strations.Such linear overdetern~inationis a calc~rlatedrisk for a painter. and although this kind of thing can work \\-ell in the cityscapes, \\-here it gives contemporary life a once-upon-a-time magic, in many of Kossofi's portraits and figure paintings the results are le,s satisfnctor\-. Not that extreme linear reduction can't \\-ork for a figure painter: it's \\-hat gives I.(.ger's people their placid monumentality. Rut Kossoffwants his heavily \\-eighted contours to suggest psychological clepth. and although he manageflto tell us sc~methingabout n person, his noses and eyes and mouths have a jotteci-iio\vn quality that doesn't really pull together the animated surEaces of these tan-and-t3rirk-colc~red figures.
I think Kossoff is &\\;ire of the pml,lrm. Some recent pitintings of female nudes slumped in a chair are convinringl\- \\eighty; the movement from part to part a ~ g g " t u kincl of unreiaxing exhaustir~n.Rut the drawing in the figures doesn't give us the specificitv that \\-e \v;int from a portrait or a studk, nucie, and the color in the figures, although nuanced, is a bit oppressive. Sometime\ Kossofi's pitint surface, \\-hich has generally been \er> very thick-the
artist's equivalent of a geologic-a1build-u p--suggests
mucidle
rather than depth. Most of the recent heads are too thickly painted; it's mun~mifiedflesh. Part of =-hat\ exciting about some of the recent Ifindon views is that Kossoffis stopping before the surEace closes do\\-n, so that you feel i l u i d i ~as \veil as \\-eightine,~in the handing of the pitint.
All of Ko\soff's figures have some\\-hat oversizeci features and a \\ear) look in their eyes. I've come to think of Knssc~ff'speople a* his lovable. superannuated munchkins. That's not necessarily n bad thing: Poussin did munchkins, too. The comparison ciccilrs to me hecituse it ciccilrred to Kix-,soff. \vho did loose copie5 of a Foushin painting. Cq~hilitrdoil ilerorir. some the s starring roles; f'le years ago. But then Youssin rarely gives his ~ n t ~ n c h k i n sees them as toy people set in over%-helming landscapes. In Knshoff's
cityscapes, the figures have an echo of that toylike charm that we know from Potrssin. I can sec that all the hard 'i\-ork that Kossoff has devoted to the studio nudes pa\-Soff in the rityzcapes. where the little people who scurri- through a Idondondo\\-npour or hurry home from the Undergroun~istation are rendered lvith such summary force. In the (:hristchurch paintings, the figures moving along the side\\-;ilk don't look at the church, and m-e find ourselves follolving their glances even a\ lve look both at them and at the architecture; it makes for a satisfyingly ]a!-ereci experience. Kossoff pia!-S lvith an interesting idea of likeness-in-unlikenw by describing the architecture and the figures \\-ith the same dark lines. There's an equivalence created. so that the building becomes a living, anthropomorphic presence that presses dolvn against the people even as they're pounding the pavement. Kossc~fftakes the exact mea\ure of C:hristchurch3sgrandeur, hut he also like, to bring out the beauty-in-ugliness of a kind of urban architecture t h t ' s grown up a h o s t by accident. The BmbiTtnkn~entStation and M t ~ q e r ford Bridge paintings, with their veritable collage of cla\hing volume, and textures, are as much about the weird kiscination of an unplanned myironment as are the paintings of New York Citv's I h i o n Square and 56th Street that Fairfielii Porter ciid in the '70s. (That won't surprise people \\-ho've found them,elves thinking that there are more than a few similarities bet\\-een today's sprakvling multicultural London and our sprakvling multic ultural Ne\v York.) Kossofi's color is at its best in his cityscapes. more varied and open-encied than in the figures. but even here he sometimes depends too much on surface design. The chilciren's-illustratic~nflatne,s gives the citvscapes a nice element of surprise; I feel that Kossoff is allolving himself to have immediate, unromplicitted reactions to n complicated em-in~nment.The citvscapes aren't ever t,landl\- reductive. hut there's not all\-ays enough spare to breathe. When
Kossoff paints a shade\\-y area that's supposed to supge\t some depth, the color can go dead on him. He likes to squash his perspective, so that dingonals turn into concavities and the plane, that are meant to go bark in space lean to\\-ard the surface. This spatial indecision. 11-hichmight he a painterly equivalent of the feeling that moviemakers achieve \vith their hand-held cameras, is something that Kossoff occasionally overplays. His pulsating city is sometimes jr~sta \\-01~E3lycity.
Kossc~ffisg f i ~ x i n gas a painter; the recent cityscapes seem to be the work of an artist who is breathing more easily. m-ho's not so tense, so clutched. In the newer canva,es, the surfaces have a welcc~meopenness and t l t ~ i d i tso ~ , that I begin to feel that everything is changing. evolving. expanding, right t3efore
m!- eyes. Ihfortunately, though. in Venice, \\-here the British Pavilion happened to he just about the onlv place where contemporary painting \\-as pwentecl as a gamble \\-orthy of
;I
large talent. most people seemed to re-
gard Kc?ssoff's \vork as a take-it-or-leave-it pmposition. He was a painterly painter, and that \\-as all there was to say. For some Yen- Yorkers 11-hci've \\-atched in recent years as London painters have received a surprisingly large nmclunt of a t t e n t i r ~ n l naddition to Ko\soff I'm thinking of Lucian , Frank AtlerFreud, R. B. Kitaj, H()%-ardHodgkin, Rodrigo M o ~ n i h a nand t33ch-the
British presence in Venice roulci look like more of the same. This
year's big theme show in \renice. which the Biennale's director. rean Clair. devoted to the figure in t\\-entieth-century art ancl gave the title "Identity and .41teritC3(that's their English), included work by Knssc~ffasm-ell a, Franci, Bacon, Freud, and Kitaj. Kitaj, on the basis of his paintings in "Identity and .2tteritv,'\\-as a\ccaidedthe Bienmle's grand prize.
In Lrenice, \\here the American Pavilion \\-as devoted to a group of video installations by Bill Viola called Brrrri.il .$ri:rrfr,you roulci see an nglo-.%merican face-off betm-een mind-n~~mbing traditionalism and healthy innovation
or bet\\-ern healthy traditionalism and mind-numbing i n n o v a t i r ~ n l all t depended on your point of vieu: Yet the Engliskl situation was more complicated than the British Pi~vilionmight have led one to imagine, for the British choice was deepl\- resented by those \vho regard them\elves as being on I.on~ion'scutting edge. The)- had their 011-n Biennale shm-. m-hich fentured video and installation art, in the Scuola cii San Fa\quale. a twenty-orso-minute walk from the Biennale grounds. (Like Ko\roff's exhihiaon, it \\-as under the auspices of the British (:ouncil.) Ilinos and Take (:hapman \\-ere the stars of the Scuola. lvith their three-tiimmsional appropriation of the "Great deeds-against
(lf W U I'm ~ ~ the dead!" plate from Goys's DISIISIPTS
not really sure if the <:hapmans meant to declare them\elver a h n - a r or anti-art by reducing the harrokving delicacy of Go)-a's etching to the cimp spectacle of several life-size Km dolls lvith their genitals ripped out, but no-
btrdy could doubt that the (:hapmanil kniw- tlol\- to cause it stir. linglish painters may feel that they're as much at the mercy of antipainting a\ nnyhodv else is today, hut at the Biennale they looked like practically the only artists alive who rare to paint pictures of the \\-orld. Although I don't think that's the case, therc arc certainly people in a lot of places. including Neu- Yt~rk,\\-h<)do. Painting from I.on~ionis becoming a populiir export. .4fter closing in Vmice in September, the Knrsc~ffsho\vtravels to the Stedelijk in Amsterdam.
exhibition called '"I;ror7t1 I,ondon,"
\I-bich opened in EdinbuuZr;h this summer anti includes Kosoff, Baron, l:ret~d,Auerhach, Kitaj, and several other artists, will be traveling to Luxembourg, Lausanne, and Barcelona. \*rErilliamLiebernlan, the &airman of tjq-entieth-ccntur~;art at the hletri~politanhluseilm, has had enough rctrospectives of London-haseci arti\ts (Hodgkin is slateci for this kill) to make it seem that \\-hatever the fi~lancialadvantages of transatlantic cooperation. he certainly believes that the Brits arc the painters for the '90s. h Kossoffretrospctive \\ill be nlounteci at the Tate in 1096. m e r i c a n nluseunl officials
\\-h0 \\-atched in 1994 as the I.ucian Freuci retrospective at the Metropolitan Museum became the number-one topic at Manhattan clinner parties might \\-ant a piece of the action, even if it's hard to imagine Kossoff having the knock-'em-dead impact of Sigmunci Freud's grandson. \vhois convinced half living no\\- not in spite of the lvorld th;tt he has the last \\-(3rd on h o ~we're ‘1l ent. but on account of his small, cold t*
linplish art is no more one thing than American art. but there is something to the idea of a national artistic character, and who can doubt that today the English artistic character has an international appeal! In lingland. \I-here the ct~lturalbedrock is literarv, artists have al%-aysbeen inclined to tell stories or illustrate clramatic mon~entscsf the kind that csne k n o ~ -t si - c m ~ poetry, ancl Kosscsff's cityscapes have that literary quality. even if W-hathe offers is as pared-donn a poetic vignette as "I \\-allcell!,t
(:hristrhurih one
stormy summer rlay." There are masterpieces of Romantic poetry that begin \\-ith little more. The literary disposition in Engli\h art has given it an ambiguous status h rnucll of this century, and in our postmodern em-ironment the British resistance to the modern idea that the content emerges from the form can look quite appealing. People arc right to be fed up with such modern ilichks as art-cm?-tell-a-story and art-must-look-like-ncsth-
ing-you've-seen-t,efc)re. They're right to admire Kossoff. But we arc in danger of being \\vamped bj- an equally arbitrary set of postmodern rlichis. and they clo Kossoff no good. <:ontemporary English artists may feel that fcjreigners exaggerate the significance of a national arti,tic character. The English tt~elnselves,ho\vever, arc lnakinp an assumption about national norms m-hen thev insist that an artist" sq-ork tse understood in terms of some other strong sense csf belonging, \\-hich in Leon Kossoff's case has to do with his having gn,&-n up in a poor London j'e\\-i-i\hkimilv. Khen \i:illlemar ]anusrczak, revie&-ingthe Riennale in the limes of London on fune 18, observed that "yt)u can t akL ~ i m a n a
out of the shtetl hut you cannot take the shtetl out of a man," he did not exactly intend a put-do\\-n--ranuszcxitk
hastened to add that the same
could be said of Coutine and Rothkc~-hut
he \\-as sugge*ting that re\\-ish-
ness nlight limit an artist's options. 1 t h c ) u g h lanuszczak is possibly the only London critic \\-h0 said a* much in print, there m-ere quite a few people at the Riennale, pro-Kossoff and nnti-Kossoff, \\-h0 m-ere saying more or less the same thing. Ti, Londoners who arc tired of ail the talk about the EngLishne5s of English art, their comments about the Ie\%-ishmssof Jekk-ish art are probably a case of giving as good a* they get. They have n point. Rut j'ewishness has a \\-ay of being po\ed as a fixed condition, rather than as something that an artist is horn into and gro\vs through and then subjects to imaginative transfc3rmation. Holk-everKossoff may choose to regard or ~iisregardhis Je\vishnesr,it's unquestionably a factor in the work. It has hem ol3served that (:hristchun-h. for a ]elk-ishboy, must have had the seductive-scar\- Fdrcinati~inof the unknown. There's probably something to the fact thtrt the student-teacher relationship twtneen Kossoff 2nd Bomberg \\-as a relationship bet\\-ren t\vo London Iem-S. (Bomberg, who had lived alld painte~iin r;lle*ti~lein the '2Os, would have been pufectly a\\-are of this.) And there is of course much in Kossoff's paintings that brings Soutine to mind. All of this count-hut
its significance must be
read from the 'iq-ark, not into the \\-ark. The connection to Soutine has to dcl \I-ith a lot of artistic Ftctorb that have nothing n-hatever to do with the shtetl. Khat Kossofi's best recent \\-ork brings to mind is Soutine the I'ranrophile,
\\-h0 gave us one of the rentur>-'smost original reinterpretations of the tradition of (:ourbet and (:on~t.That in turn may relate to Kossoff's oft-remarked afbnity with (:c)nstahle. whose place in English art is in certain re\pects not unlike that of (I:c)rrrbet in I'rance, Although some in England \\-ill regard rekvishness and Iinglishne,~as irreconcilable. it may he that in imaginative terms-kvhich
are the only terms
that really matter to an arti\t----they are reconcilable. If English culture is e\sentially l i t e r a r ~so. too, is Je~vishculture. And the English artist \vho. as an outsider to the modern movement, feels at home 11-ithpostmacfern storpelling may fixlii that his Ie&-ishnessfits right into a cleveloping equittion. This mai- help explain \\-h!- so many of the painters who are grc?upeci under the rubric of the School of idondonare Ie\vish. 4 year ago. \\-hen Kitaj reacted to the critical drubbing that his %te retrospective received by saying that anti-Sexnitism \;\-asinvolved, a lot cif ,4nrr?ricans tlidn't know whitt to make of hi, claims. There \\-as a feeling in Ye\\- York that he \\-its euaggrratthat I've been to Venice ancl seen h o ~i n- s i s t m t l ~Kossoff's painting ing. No\\is linked with Kossofi'\ Tekvishness. I think Kitaj \\;is onto something. Khether i.ondon's high-cult postmodern publiritv machine loves you or hateh you, it's definitely something to see it sxvinging into action. Readers
of David Svlvester's essay for the Kossoff show in Venice may find themselves thinking bark to Lucian I'reud, because Sylvester makes on Kossoff's t3ehalf the same overreaching compitrison to Rembraniit that a number of \\-riters make on t3ehalf of Freud. (I may be getting \vhim\ical here, hut is Kembran~lt,n-ho took such an interest in Am\terdam's Jews, viewed as an-
other element in the School of London's Iewish connection?) The compari- a n v t h i q t~sefulabout either Kossoff or son to Rembrandt doesn't say
Freud, h u t qt~alitativedistinctions are irrelevant to a puhIic tfiat accepts Rembran~lt'sname as part of the hack-to-tradition PR mvhtique. Kcjssciff. an apparently modest man \vho just means to mind his 0%-n t3usiness, may be a little startled to find that his perfectly uniierstaniiahle reluctance to permit studio vi\its or give int"rviem-Si, non- repcirted in Gnrt3nesque terms. That Kossoff lvorks in a paint-encrusted studio seems remarkable to some; R ~ d hi c h s , the ctlrator of the Ste~felijk,writes about this \\-orkplarc as if it \\ere some kind of shrine. Sylvester quotes Lakvrence C;o\ving as describing Kossoff's painterly surfaces n a "confessic>nal net-
\\-ork." H;t\enSt\\-e already had enough mumho jumbo rna~ieout of the fkct that there's a lot of paint on somebody's canvases! Sylvester. \vho knew (2acometti and has recently published n book on him, is so into the eustentialisrn of process that he miis up confusing Kcjssoff's fine painangs \\-ith C;iacometti's sublime ones. Rut then literary types have all\-a\-,mistakrn Giacometti for n process-oriented artist. as if his greatness had to do 11-ith his changing t h i n g so much and not 11-ith the perfect accuracy and eloquence of his fillistled canvases. (If incfecision made masterpieces, there would he a lot more of them.) The point is not more paint or l e s paint. or more subject matter or less subject matter: it's the appnjpriateness of what's there. I think Kossoff ~vould agree, Even as he's being hypecl as the art \\-iirIClt3slatest anti-star, tljs piiintitngs are becoming less mannered. more direct. There have been times. especi~tlly in the '60s and '70s, \I-hen Kossoff was into paint far its own sake, and the results \\-ere overly impastoeif surkizes, clotted dark color, and a ciisturl,inglv \\-eM>\-overlay of pray-kvhite drips. In recent years he's twen simplifying his painthandling. and the result. especially in the nrm-er (:hristchurch and Emt3ankment floner-stall paintings. is an admirable openness and lightness. 'Ihese are just libout the best canvaws that he has ever done. Khen he paints the flo\ver stall, Kossoff is declaring his interest in the pan-er of pure color. .4lthough he's not giving up his grily-and-tan \ision of London. he is alloning more and more brightness to seep into the moist atmosphere, and the result is a glinting richnesh. a huc)v;~nc)-.Kossoff is moving from not-enough-color to no-color color. This is something that
you can learn all about in Venice, \\here Titian filled big canvases \\-ith raint>o\v-richgraj-s. Kc?ssoffwon't bear comparison \\-ith that ultimate Iienetian master, but I think it says a gciod deal about this Englishman" sn-ork that it does not look ridiculous in the Iienetirtn context-. SEPTEMBER 4,1995
BORN UNDER SATURN
The j\-ork that Bill Iensen has heen doing in the pitst several years is as exciting as any painting that has ever heen done by an .4mrricitn. This 49-yearold arti,t is a master of inchoate, muffled-yet-fierce emotions, and ncs other arti\t alive has given us sc, many haunting impressions of the loll-ering, saturnine side of the artist's spirit. Bv contemporarj- standards rensen's abstract cam-ases are small-enerally
tkx-o or three feet high----and this fc~cuhesuh
on the autographic force of the surEace. 11-hichhe builds up and rubs down and then builds up again m-ith a concentrated lyricism that's so intense that it can be a little scary. lensen has an alchemist's gift for turning piled-high brushstrokes and flotsam-like bits of pigment into the st~bstanceof a mvt hical natural \vorlci. It's an ugly-beau tiful unkerse, where the vistas are eerie, the color is febrile. and every landmark has a scintillating allegorical po&-er. i of meanderThe poetry of imsen's work is n matter of hints n n ~flashes, unfurlings. There's a marvelous slo\vness to these painti n g ~ unfoldings. , ings: you feel rensm's contemplative pitce. ( h e \\-ay to explain \\-hat rensen doe, is l,\- explaining \\hat he does not do. He never employ\ an end-to-md structure that takes its essential logic from the rectangular shape of the cam-as. Thatk the French n-a>--compcssition as a discipline that leads to a revelation---ancl it has nothing to do with lensen's piece-l3y-piece. questing approach. Although there are many Iensen painting, that contain a singular, looming image. he arrives at that all-in-one impact indirectly, incrementally. Ys~uget the feeling that he's begun each painting by fs~cusingon some tin\ element-the
color of a brushstroke. the weight of a line. the
thrust of a curve---and that for him the process of making a painting is the px~cess""fvatching that first mark or gesture gn~m-.In Iensen's m-ork.
grim-th is gradual, uneven. surprising-like
bits of moss and lichen appear-
ing on drc;i\-ing branches and then spreading unpreciictahly, creating romantically irregular patterns. There are six piiintings in the Bill Iensen show at the Marv Boone Gallery in Nrv. York. ancl in order evm to bepin to look at them a gallerygorr has to t - n o t h i q mood. Tk-o tune in to the artis t's quietert, slo\vest, dc~ing-almo\ paintings. Gbssas ancl Pirijirn, are \er!- impressive. Both are vertical, a hit over three feet high, with a horizon line ciividing the surface into nearly equal parts and summoning up, m-ith almost diagrammatic abruptness. n view of sky , cold blue hrushstn~kesspread above and earth or ocean below. f i b s ~ a r m-ith out before the orange-yello~-haze of the sun, is the primordial. Hclmeric sea. In Pdgira, clouds of that same cool blue scutter armss a greenish sky, a s h that's as unins-iltiw as the n ~ u g hred-ad-black , terrain belt~v. These s~rnhnliclandscapes contain no trace of a human presence; no path cuts through the gloom of
Pagirtr,
no boat could navigilte the danger-
ous \\-ater, of Ct?iirssus. In the lower portions of the painting. rensen curves his elements to give just a suggestion of perspectival depth. hut he's not invoking a particular place so much as summoning a harshly sublime mood. He', an ultra-sophisticated artist creating barbaric scran-ls. And the painthanclling. 11-ithits complete lack of charm. underline the peremptorv spirit of these works. When I look at the pitintings close up, I feel the chill of the palette knife rather than the softne5s of the brush. The roughed-up paint has some of the quality of Eastern calligriiphj-, of those complicated. iconic gestures that seem to emerge almost involuntarily out of an artist's reserves of calm. These landscapes, n-hich feel both 11-orn-out m J tlntouched. are ahnut mapping unmappable experiences, about being in a place that has no beginning and no end. ~ a third painting, ralleci Wlf:turL~fiht,that does a In the Roone s h o there's remarkable job of evoking frozen desolation by means of a fe\v t > r n ~ -marks n
set on a beautifully distressed surfiice. But after Cnlnsus, Pirgerr, a d B7fflbpr
Light, the quality of the 11-orkdrops precipitouslv; the three other paintings are so understated that in each case I can c-onclude cinly that lensen has left some essential part of the story inside his head. 4 s I moved around the gallery. every other painting clre\\- a blank. n d since f e n s e f i dominant theme here is the fascination of near emptiness, the outright enlptiness of one half of the selections can't but t~ndercctteven his subdest efforts. The shc)n-is sunk 1zv all this weak work. It's an out-otrfc~cusexhilzition, cine that conveys no sense of the v a r i e ~ of Jensen's recent pAnting, and I can't see how people leaving Boone \\ill understand \\-hat kind of an artist lensen redly is. This show is a verv disturl3ing event. In the 1940s. Clement (;reenlzerg often complainecl in print that the best American painting \\-as to be seen in the artists' studios rather than in the galleries. This fall Bill fensen confcluncfs us \\-ith the rase of a remarkable artist \\-h0 is showing at \\-hat is generally regiiriieii as one of the most prestigiclous galleries anjunc1. but has left the majori y of his strongest \\ark a few mile\ a%-ay.in his studio in Bmoklyn.
I realize that by compat.inp the shi)w at hfary Boom m-ith the much larger group of paintings I ,a\\- in lensen's studio some six months ago, I'm making a value judgment that's based on in\ider informatic~n.I'm loath to take advantape of such information, but the mismatch betm-een \I-hat fensen has been cioing in his stuclio ancl \\-hat's on display at Boone does such a disservice to the gallerygoer that a critic cannot hut offer a behind-the-scenes view. This is o d y fensen's second ,bm-at Boone, and the gap between his authenticity and her st\-Iishness is wider than it \\-as two \-ears ago, \\-hen he first exhibited on \Vest Bm;td\va\-. There is no excuse for his not shokving at lea\t a half-dozen more paintings, including some of his recent underx-ater universes and fiery nightscapes. There's certainly enough room at Boone to demonstrate that lensen is ntw.- able to present cimplicated embiematic subject nlatter with intuitive ease.
At the t3eginning of the '80s Mary Roone pioneereci, almost single-handedly, an overbearingly austere. Zen-Fascist style in gallery ciesign, and I,\now it ciominates the upscale scene. Boone's space at 417 \Vest Broadnay gave the slob-job work of Julian Schnahel and L);ivid Salle the VIP send-off that it so desperately needed, but this gallery flzttens out paintings that are discreetly emotional. The Mar\ Boone Gallery turns Jensen's pitintings into postage "amp"
even his strongest cam-ases look underpo\vered. The real
stars are Boone's perfectly smooth, nearlv empty gallery \\;ills. This is a hell of a spackle-ancl-paint job, but it doesn't make for an artist-friendly environment, At the very least, Roone coulci have let gallerygoers in on \\-hat Jensen is up to by presenting, in one of the other room\ in her capacious building, the suite of intaglio prints that he completecl in the spring of 1994 for an artist's h ~ o ktitled Pt~stcilnisFlrn Truhl. This collah~rationn-ith the poet John Yan is an homage to the Awtrian poet Geclrg Tt-akl, \\-h<,died in f C)14 at the
ape of 27. In these prints. which are a mixture of iiquatint ancl etching and just about everything else that can be done on a iopper plate, fensen is doing \\-hat \\-@ don't see him cioing at Roone-alternating
skyzcapes and land-
scapes, biding-akvay images and rushing-for%-;irdimages, getting into the details of an imaginary \vorlci. So \\-h\-is the public being cienied access to this \\-orkl Has somebody calculated that Jensen's fezunclity will not go over \I-ith the SoHo auditme? Tit the extent that the Boone she\\- represents Iensen as a visionary kvandering in the lvilderness, it's not a completely inaccurate vie\\- of the artiit. But Jensen is a lot of other things. He's an artist
\\-h0 kncnvs something about complexity and richness ancl pitrariox, and in an art scene that's de\perate for variety and expansivene\s. it's maddening to think that people aren? s e e i q what Jensen can do. Likc so much that's urgent in contemporary art, Ienscn's lvork ciraws some of its force from the artiit's e\sentially solitary position. from his very
liick of significant reliltionship to anything that anybody else is doing. True. Icnsen's small formats. hiomorphic forms, and impastoed surfaces have been lvidely imitated. They have by no\\- generatecl a whole nem- kincl of artschool product. The allegorical polver of his lvork \\as an elenlent in the '80s art experience, hut even so rensen's paintings never lost their sornhrr deAoone, rensrn's solitude is turned into a i.ommercial c-lithi., tachment. &%t SOIMC) and it's easy to forget that he's just about the only artist \vhc)'s h'~~T-en
internal coherence to Neoexpressionism-\\-hicl1
was the '80s \\-a\-of finally
trying to deal with all the overn-helming emotions that \\ere left over from the '60s. Khercas most of the Neoexpressionists have treatecl generational feelings \\-ith tri\ialiring irony, as Zeitgeist t,ulletin\. rensrn has v l s a i l i i z ~ dthe pa\t-'60s feverishness.
Iensenk first breakthrough came late in the 1070s, when he unsovered new life in a strain of mystical nature poetry that had run through ,%mericanart from the stcrrrr.1-tossedseascapes of Alhert Pi11kb;rln Ryder to the musical abstractions of Arthur I)ove ancl the Maine fc3rests of Mars~lmHartley. These \\-ere not exactly unricrknt3~-nor unricrappeciatd artists. \%%at \\-assignificant abcmt Jensen's encounters with an earlier American art \\-as that he uncovered a contemporary urgmcy in paintings that were generally regarded as
of little more than historical interest. Jensen a\r~idedthe risks of antiquuianism: he made the experience of there early American modcms feel very much his OR-n.People sax7Imsen's small fi~rmats,and the specificih \\-ith lvhich he drekv his enigmatic \isions. ar signifying a break with the overbearing scale and homogeneous look of post\\-ar m e r i c a n art. That led to the conclusion th;tt Iensen m-as anti-Abstract Expressionist. h retrospect, him-ever, it seems that Iensen was only fincling his own \\ay back into Abstract Expressionism. Ienscn c-an~eto Kcw h r k kern Minnesota, where hekd studied l;\-ithPeter Busa, an old friend of Pollockk,, and when he first exhibited the paintings
in =which small redefined beautiful it \\-as his \v;$!- of rejecting not h s t r a c t lispressionism but a calcified view of the movement. lensen \v;mted to get a\\-ay from the chilled-out imagery of the later '50s and 'GO\, hack to the high-pitched, densely figured, grittv, even Gothic temperament of Pollock and Gorky 2nd de Kncining in the '40s. His in\\-iird-turning scale. m-hich is as much of an extreme statement n the .4hstract Expressionist\ \\all-sized canvases, \\-as a personal \\-ay of refcjcusing attention on the surface. And once rensen had gotten do\\-n to basics, he knew that he could gci anywhere, t h t he could yrrestic~nall the underlying ? i e ~York f cfioed a\sumptions. In the mid-'80s he experimented \vith a sort of Surrealist lan~lscapethat \\-as so literal it risked at-adernicisrn. He's learned much f r ~ i ~the n strean~lined forms of h r p and other Purist&;and in recent years he's looked farther afield, at the mc~untainsin Trecento painting. at Goys and Micheliinpelo and Chinese scrolls. Khether lensen is reaching for a dense, cloisonn6 effect or something glancing and open-mdeci, he takes the same from-the-groun~1-upapproach to form. E~erythinghegin, \\-ith the cira\ving, \\-hether it's being done \vith pencil, ink, or oil paint. li'hen lensen is drakving, he's cultivating his garden, \\-a":hing things grow. In recent years he has developeci a way of w-orking in t3lark and \\-hite \vith brush and ink that's his alone; in the spring of 1994 on these d r a ~ v i n g ~the a t Kashbt~rn there \\-as a ren~arkirhleS ~ O M centered
Gallery (where Iensen began exhibiting in 1980 and continues to she\\- his graphic work). rensen lai-s strokes clown on thick paper. t3lots and sponge\ them lvhile they're still damp, and then \\-orks t3;tck into the surkce. He's literally \\-atering the paper. so that it become, the soil from 11-hichthe images emerge. He pushes into that dense, loam!- surface (he uses gorgeous paper) over ancl over apilin. so that the result is an em-eloping, dark-pe\\-ter m!-steriousness. This i, parallel to \\hat he doe, m-ith pigments and oils in the paintings. I t h o u g h the highly lvorked paint surface has become a
mannerism in many of his imitators. with fensen it's tied so closely to the discovery of fc>rrnsthat even his most exquisitely rubbed-dc~\vneffects have an invigorating straightfc~r\vardness. In his printmaking. Iensen is doing just about everything that's possible on a copper plate; he seem\ to be \\-orking inside the metal, extracting its secrets. For the past six Years. some of the motif\ that dominate his paintings have also been cropping up in the plates that he's been preparing for Pt?sri-irrils
/n?m iiairkl. The finished hook, which presents the fensen universe betu-een hard covers, bears comparison to some of the fir~ertillustration that French artists did in the first half of the century. True. John Yau's poems. despite some striking line,. are mostly Surrealist t,oilerplate, but many remarkable artists' hooks hilve had unremarkable text\, and in any event Irnsen's real subject isn't Yau's poetry hut Trakl's. This u s t r i a n lvriter is generally seen as a bridge between fin de sikcle dreamine,~and Expressionist simplification. and in many respects Rill Jensen is a kindred spirit. fensen may have had Trakl's "nocturnal lving-beat of the soul" in mind \\-hen he created several t3irdlike forms out of lightly inscribed lines. In Trakl's poetry "Scarlet banners \\-hirl through the mourning of the maple-tree," "The tree of grace t3lossoms golden out of the cool sap of the earth." and "All roads end in t3lack deca>-."It's a late-autumn atmosphere that one knows from fensm's paintings, and in Pt~stcilnisbnn liilki this American contempcirary i, in a German Romantic state of mind, 11-eaving themes of earth and air, heaviness and lightne,~.gro&-thand decay into a shaLio\\-y,interic~rdrama.
Ptntcunisfinn lhki opens n-ith a composition of looming fc3rms framing a t3;trren land. There are hovering heraldic cievices, and bizarre tubular shapes that are like root systems rekacteci t h o u g h a Baroque imagination. fensen even manages to bring comic grace notes to the saturnine spirit of Pt?sri-irrils /nlra
Truhl; he sees the humorous side of his weird visionary landscapes. Pt~st-
cunls /nlra iiairkl i b something rare in contemporarv American art: a collahora-
tion twtkx-een a pitinter \\-h0 glories in the demands of intaglio printmaking and n master printer-Rill
C;oldston of IJniversal I_imitedArt Editions in
Kcst Islip. Ye\\- Y o r k % - h opml,;tbly spends much of his time holciing the hands of big-name artists \\-h0 just \\-ant to make a quick buck lvith some print editions. Kith this collaboration het\%-een<;olciston and lensen, ULAE has become the first Ameriian print studio since Vi'orld Khr I2 to produce an artist's hook that actually ciipitalizes.on the almost limitless emotional possibilities that are inherent in the printn~aker'sart, Atmosphere is a central protagonist in much of Tensen's work. This is
\\-h\-he has. such an intuitive feeling for the velvety chiaroscuro of intaglio printmaking. Many of his str0nges.t Lira\\-ing. prints, and painting leave us in a state of pleasurable suspension, because lve can't exactly saj-what \\-e're seeing. even though \\-e know precisely h o it's ~ making us feel. In the pitintings at Boone this fall, Trnsen takes nonspecificity as fkr as it \\ill go; even the clearest pitintings give us little to touch dolvn on. save for those casually dra%-nhorizon lines that hepitrate earth from air. Ohviouslv lensen is tes.ting the limits of his anticlassical, antiarchitectonic method, and that's perfectly legitimate. The problem is that some of these paintings that are meant to be emotionally elusive are also f~jrmallyunresolved, so that lensen's homegn,&-n. u nto-m!-self strength twgins to look like homegnjnn ot,tuseness.
1 think Jensen meant to offer tls a ke! to this evanescent n-orld of his \\-hen he gave a number of the Roone paintings homage-to-greatmoviemaker titles, One of the weakest canvases is n r ~ n ~ eafter d ,%ndrei Tarkovsky's film
. $ f i l j k ~ rThere .
are three that refer to Bergman: the delicate
B7f'ilrtrr Light, the inconclusive Hi?rrr of rhp BTiY; ancl the vacuous Mud~lnjcJu Suriv (Rergman directed n production of the Mishima plzii- that was presented at the Brooklyn %cadem!- of Music last seas.on). I don't \\-ant to hear dolvn on the relationship twtkveen particular titles and particular paintings-it \I-ould on1y t~nderlinethe problems. \I-itll thew 11-~rks-but I take Tensen
ahsc~lutelvseric~uslym-hen he encourilget us to believe that there's n connection bet=-een movie ittmosptlere and painting atmosphere, 'That conneaion is at the heart of Tensen's recent lvork, especiallv some of the lvork that \I-e're not seeing at Roone. I think Tensea is the first artist of his generation jq-ho's done jq-hat so many have tallied about doing: he" \?rought something of the movie experience into painting. Tensen understands that the e\sence of the movie image isn't its iompositicin hut it\ flow. its changeat,lmess, it\ kinetic feel. ByhereasI);ivid Sdle \\-ill fcxus on the campy ciissoriated qualities of the film still, Tensen \\-ants to use his antiarchitectonic kind of painting to evoke the flooding-over-us high of movie emotic~n.People m-ho k n m - 'Tarkovsky's mc~vie,see immediately jq-fiy jensen is & a - n to them; lensen's loorninp enigmas and watery and misty effects parallel Tarkc>vsky'sallegorical universe. \%%at the critic Piiul Coate\ says of T~rkovsky-that he creates a m-orld that "exists simultaneouslv in the monochrome of depression and the color of joy"--goes
f63r
Tcnsen, too. With Tarkossky, it's the lvildness and the strangeness that Tensen is responding to. In the rase of Bergman. the affinitie, are subtler, more entotionatIy complex, so much so that it's tempting to believe that bnsen has closer artitic ties to this Sm.ecli(rh director thxn t i anv ~ painter living or tiead. Tensen shares Bergman's taste for looming. spiky Gothic imagery. And Tcnscn. \\-h0 comes from a Minnesotan-Scandinavian background, has a feeling for the t,eautv of iie\olation that's part of a Northern liuropean tradition that Rergman has defined for m e r i c a n audiences practically since Tensen n-as born. If such early Tensens as Cri?urz
(f
Ibllrn ancl Ibr IVrljp~rts11g-
ge\t the ciark medievalism of Wergman's .$mi.nrhS w l (kvhich \\;is an art-house chestnut by the time lensen went t o college). some of the Inore recent Sienese lnn~iscapesand ebullient!\- striped snaky shapes ~ ~ g the g euuhere ~ ant Rergman of
nlu -2lirglr- Eleir. In Rergman. sensuciusne5scan flash up in the
midst of severitv, and an allegory can leap into startling life. I think Iensen is bringing these same strong. contradictory forces into his painting. He. too, can give ponJerous elnotions an immediate, flokving grace. The Northern artist is the sensualist who is forever at 'iq-ar with his
,tiding-one-intt>-tl~e-otfieremotions are our emi>tions. With his darkfv tsurning conflicts. his full-out lyricism, his feeling for a beauty thttt's sometime, indistinguihable from the grotesque. rensen keeps us baffled and uncare to knoll- alsout nerved. He knovc-s more al-tout us than l;\-eson~etin~e, i>urselves.X/let ani:holy ? l!ivided? ftlarooned?This is not hon- the generation that started out in the '60%ever expected to feel.
THE THIRD
DECREE
W'hy is it that the critics who trllnlpet the death of painting, or even the end of art as we know it, rarely have anything dire to say about the state of sculpture? The apocalyptically minded could certainly 61ld ditnger signs if they kvmted to. h \ \ - e l l - c o n s t r t d n e n sculpture is much more of a rarity t h n a weH-conhtxucted new painting. &%nd even in the gaileries that are re-
gardrd as strong supporters of experimentation, \\-orks that hang on the \\-all not infrequently outnumber \\-ork, that sit on the floor. f i t not a season goes bj- kvithout somebody declaring that painting, at least painting that's any good, is going to disappear or has already ciisappeared. In some quarters there is a stmng desire to dismiss all the painters, for simply by cioing \\-hat they c10 they have resisted the modern principle of perpetuitl artistic- change. Fainters are still \\-orking \\here they've alw-avs \vorked. which is up agilinst the \\-all. The sculptors. mean\\-hile, have allo\\-rd themselves to be t3;tcked into quite a few- corners. but any jam that they've found themselves in has been turned into yet another rase of healthy experimentation. If sculpture remains the art that the trendu-atchers feel most c-amfortable \\-itheit's t3ecause sculptors have
and large accepted the avant-garde agit-
prop about being constantfy on the rncivt. just \\.hen sinebody might have thought to cieclare the cieath of sculpture. sculpture has slipped away and reinvented itself as a Primary Structure. a Specific (Ihject, as Scatter Art, as something Site Specific. Environmental, or <:onceptual. This season. like every other season. sculpture is in the news. There has been a much-talked-about shm\ at Face\X;ildrnstein of new work by Kiki Smith. whci prohahl\- has the fastest-grokving reputiition of an): contemporary Americiin artist; and there are other shokvs of y3ung-to-mid-career artists, among then1 jessica Stockholder and Me1 KenJric-k, each of =whom has turned sculpture inside out, apparently for no other reason than to keep people's attention. Rut this is not the half of it. If one needed to he remin~irdthat sculpture's quick-change status is not exactly n recent developspecializes in teaching old hats (and ment, there's Claes (Ildenburg. \\-h<> erawrs and clothespins . . . ) n e n tricks, \\-ith an exhil3ition calleci "An Anthology" that openeci at the National Gallery in R s h i n g t o n last \\-inter and is no%-at the Guggenheim in N ~ Kh-r k . Some mai- regard (Ildenl-turg as a
modern classic, but then where does that put C:onstantin Branct~si,\\-h0 is the subject of a retrospective that opened in Paris last spring ancl is n o n at the Philadelphia Museum of Art? It \vould be nice to be able to say that Rrancuhi, a titan \\-h0 died in 1957 at the age of 81. set modern sculpture on its \\-ay ancl is al\vii!-s there for those kvho'd like to get hack on track. Rut the truth is that Brancusi has nothing much to cio \\-ith \\here sculpture is today, and to the extent that modern sculptors look to him the\- hopelessly misconstrrre him. ()ldrnhurg, not Rrancusi, is our fr~undingkither. a fact that \\-ill offer no comfr~rtto museumgoers \vho. 11-hiletaking in thirty-five years of v.-ork in a chmnological %*centaround Frank I_lo\-rl\Krright'sspiral ramp, find that, artistically speaking, it's do\\-nhill all the way. The brusque, \\-ayward charm that Oldenburg could achieve in 1960 and 1061 \vith some painted plaster replicas of cheap clothes and high-ciilorie cieserts evaporated pretty fast. He's spent decades asserting ever larger claims for the same everyrlay subject matter that he first bmught together in The Store that he set up in his stuJio on
East 2nd Street in December 1961. 'l'he tfiought that you rnigbt make
anything into high art by literally inilnting it was a fair joke the first time. t3u t cioe, it bear repeating tkx-ice, not to mention hundreds of times! (
If course nohod\; expects subtlety from this cheerfully megalomaniacal
artist. Everyhod\; just wants Oldenhurg to he himself, and that includes younger artists \vho look at his huge popular success ancl are encouragecl to imagine that the\-. too, have a future north of 14th Street. He's a cio\vnto\vn boy n-ho made it, ancl with
Klilfe SIiclnd
ihri~trgb&%!l (done in 1986 and. like all
the recent \\-ork. in collaboration \\-ith Ctjosje van Rruggen) he presmts a kind of oversized polemical flourish that today's retro-conscious artists
\\-ould do themselves if only they had the \\-herem-ithal.Near the top of the (;uggenlxim's ramp, this tx-elve-foc>tknife blade, made of plasterboard, sticks straight out of the \\-all, creating the impression that somebody has
thrust a gigantic piece of cutlery into the gallery. K~rrfeSllrrrlg ihrl~trghWull is far too calc~rlatedto kick ciff a visceral, en~otionafrcai-tion, but as an insider view of rculpture as contemporarv aggre\sor its nleaning is as unavoidable as a tabloid headline: AItTIST STABS MlJSEIIhf. Dariaist gestures are exactly \\-hat we expect from (lldenhurg. who \\;is Labeled a Neo-1)adaist \%-henPop Art n-as still a movement in search of a catch\- name. Actually, he's remained more of a Neo-Dadaist than a Pop Artist: he's still basically kvreaking variations on the transgressive potential
of sculpture that Marcel L3uchamp first defined in 1915. two years after he'd begun to put his name on store-bought objects and smd them out into the \%-orld.Among those early Readymades were a t3icycle \\heel. a bottle rack, a urinal, and a ,no\\- shovel. 1)uchamp's essential in\ight \\-as that it \\-ould be easier to make anti-art out of rculpturc than out of p~tinting.Go up against u challenging the vigor of Impressionism and Pcistimpainting and y ~ were pxsiconism. of Fauvism and Cubism. Rut go up against sculpture and all you were really ~ioing\\-a\ puncturing a lot of nineteenth-ccntuq hot airall those rom-s of plaster casts of classical sculpture in the academies. all those dull t ~ m n z etigurcs in all those citv squares. The urinal sent up centuries of icy marbles; it pished on the \\-hole classical trariition. d Although the early c Ilcienburgs are ~ i o m e s t i ~ a t e1)uihamps-homemade R e a d \ ; m a d e s l n recent years (Ildenburg h a become a Corporate Daditist. Like just about all high-pnjfile contemporary sc ulpture. ho~-ever. his \I-ork makes its bid for attention on the basis of a paradox, n-hicfi is that Daditism. having t~lrneiisculpture against sculpture. has h n ~ u g hsculpture t to the fore. Sculpt~lrehas become the Other (it can be anything!). and it's popular for that very rcascln. Sculpture can he n friendlv neighhorhciod Other. . for sculp\%-hatarts organizations erect at outdoor sites for summer f ~ mAs tors \vho are in the limelight, the\- are alrno\t invariably doing \vork that's thought to be interesting insokir as it is \\-fiatever it isn't expected to be, And
this season, what is sculpture not expected to be that it's being? Du~ahan~p, \\-h0 perhaps thought that painters dcserved a bigger piece of the action, once c,bser\-rd that "since the tubes of paint used by the artist are manufactured and readymade products. m-e must conclude that all the paintings in the \\-orld are "Readvrnades ,%ided."Tcll, at the D i a Foundaticin on Kkst 22nd Street, sculpture is no\\- a giant painting that's galloped off the m-all. Iessiia Stockholder is the artist. ancl the long title of her Dia installation is Yozrr Skuz zn tltzs B?>uth~r Bozrmr i"~lc~-l'arre~~/s P Jtvl3Elc)n PcI~~UIT?V. Stockh~lcicrknon-S
all the move, of the Oldenhurg generation. She roughs up the big groundfloor Dia space \\-ith inexpensive materials-stacking tric cords-and
crates, carpeting, elec-
then she pulls it all together \vith an intelligmt feeling for
abstract color ancl theatrical pacing ancl three-~iimensionddesign. It takes some taste to arrange that huge pile of purple plastic crates near that salmon-colorcd \\;ill, and it's nifty ho\\ the vellom-extension cords run from each light socket on the ceiling into a gigantic heap of table lamps mounted on a pliitfcirm to one side. Rut \\-hen Stockholcicr manipulates a*semhlngist corn-entions-and tions-she
seventy-five years after Kurt Schm-ittersthese
rlrv
conven-
treats them generically, almost academically. There's a t3landness
to the lvork; it lacks in~lividualizatic~n, tmsion, point. Stockhcilder is pmbably expecting us to do the emc~tionalm-ork for her. but then no scutptor who's aihirved
it
big repcltation in recent years seems
pwpawd to take emc~tionalresponsibilitv. Everybody has adopted the Meret
c Ippenheim approach: line the tea c u p 11-ithfur and let the audience do the rest. Riki Smith understands that all the tea cups have already been lined \\-ith fur. and that t3j- now the had-olci bronze figure. under the right con&tions, is the neweht thing aroilnti. In her shorn- at PaceWil~iensteinon (Greene Street, lumpish figures. rno\tiy executed in bronze, hung or sat or stood in odd places, while a flock of dead birds, also in bronze. \\-a\ scattered across the floor. It \\-as Svmholist salon art given a Minimalist presentation.
( If
course Kiki Smith has her carefully cultivated little quirks. In addition
to the figures ancl t3irds. there \\ere chains and charms and baubles hanging herc and there. &4ndher figures have name\ like Llltrh and lip LM~tr,so thzt 11-e get the idea that myths are being retold for our time. Rut her figure modeling-which
is i n \ e c ~ ~ rto e . put it kindly-demonstrate\
no interest in the
body except insohir as it ran kick off m-;in sentimental-humani,t thoughts in gallrrygoerr \\-h<)'\-esecretly hoped that art \\-ould come back around to their \\-ay of seeing things. It's the off-the-pedestals. tops\--tur\-\ in\tallation in a huge. \\-hite cio~-ntokvnspitce that gives this malvkish stuff its ring. In the late '60s. Rohert Morris flung felt strips amund a gallery and they called it Scatter hrt, tn the '90s, Kiki Smith cJrihbles I-tronze irows in a gatlery and it's liso-Feminist. 4 great deal of tmuhle prohahly went into casting all those troll-S,
but the emotion m-as readymade.
Duchnmp turns up in the background of the Brancusi retrospective in Philadelphia. or he cioes if you read Ann Ternkin's catalog essa>-on "Brancusi and His r2merican <:ollectcsrs." A central theme herc is the strong atfvcscat\- of Rrancusi by Duchamp, m-ho\\-asa kry figure in the Franco-American
avant-garde. L3uchamp got .4meri':an dealers and collectors interested, and t h t ' s in part why there are so man!; Brancnsis in our museums. Ternkinthe <:urator of T\\-mtieth-<:entury Art in Philadelphia. \\-h0 organizecl the sh<)\\-\\-ith Margit Rokvell, Chief (:urator of I)ra\\-ings at the Museum of Modern Art-rewunts
an anecdote about I)-LIC hamp, Brancusi, and I,i.ger
going to an aviation show in Paris. "Observing a diiny 1netaI prc)pel!er,'' Ternkin writes, "Duihamp allegeclly a\kell Rranc usi ho&-any artist could pa\"ihl\- do better." I expect that Duchamp knem--ancl he kne\\--that
a Rranr-rrsi Bird
in L 5 ~ ~ m-as i r c ~ better.
Brancusi knem- that
Then agaj, Dui:ba.mp de-
voted a great deal of his life to lvork that begged the question of better and \\-orse, or at least led people to believe that it did. The pmpeller is a red her-
ring, but as a yilr5tion that never seems to go am-ay it detracts attention from the e\sential paradc~xof Brancusi'r \\-ork. \\-hich is th;tt his streamlined, erotically charged nlodern form, are groundecl in a vehemently prernodern, an almost medieval, sense of craft, In Pl~iladelphiathe Brancusi sfiol\- has been presented a little too ioolIv. The installation includes \I-alls \I-ith translt~ientinsets that are an intelligent attelnpt to echo the look of Rrancusi's studio, ancl the low platforms on \\-hich the sculptures are arranged are certainlv attractive. Rut it's all in such damn good ta\te that the show begins to look like one of the ads for Cnlvin Klein's new line of home p r o d ~ c t \ There's . an evenness to the pacing. a lack of surprise. Brancusi could do with some unapologetic showmanship. h u should feel the light flashing off Brril
in
asat.lirect,
unmed~atedexyerience: you m-ant to be awestruck, the way you ;Ire by a glimpse of an Alpine peak. Sculpturecl form is present in the \\-orld in a \\-ay that no form in a painting ever is; the Philadelphia installation pictorialires the lvork, sets it in a handsome. slightly grayecl-iiolvn context, and that's no good. The twonze version of the lill?nri 1Y~firr.s.with its shimmering surhces. is probably the most luxuriantly t3eautiful use of metal in the entire European traclition: it ought to flash out at uh. with the blinding fcjrce of a tropical sun. In Pk-tiladelphia, the Blorril Kt>gr~ssdoesn't make enough of an impression, it's jusc an exquisite Parisian souvenir.
ancl entertained a long list Although Rrancuhi lived in Paris for fifty years P
of famous names in his Montparnasse studio, his achievement stands at a remove from that complicitted, Fdst-moving period in European art. Matisse and Picasso codcl build on f:ez;tnne and Seurat and fngres and Delairrsix; but for Brancusi, who arrived in Paris in 1904 at the age of 28, there n-as only the equiroc;il, high Romantic- example of Rodin. in lvhme studio he \\-orked t,riefl\-. The profound ronneraons that Brancusi estat,lished through his sculpture \\-ith India. Greece, ancl Africa, clo tie into a \\-hole series of early-
tjq-entietfi-century interests in the archaic, the primitive, the non-Kcstern, and the naive: but whereas Picasso and Matisse drew general conclt~sions
m sources, Brancusi put about the nature of h r m and strtlcture h ~ Ear-flung e\-er>-thinghe knew into singular, solitan- objects. If Wranrusi h3~1no significant artistic parent figures, he has also probably had less impact on succee~iing generations of sculptors than Picasso. \\-h0 lvorkeci in three dimmsions only part-tin~e.Even those \l-ho really learned from Rrancusi have tended to for us on his sense of qualit>-rather th;tn on his sense of form. The seamless magic of Branct~si'sgreatest u-ork is not un~elatedto this paucity of ancestors and descendants. Perhaps because he ll-orked on the same subjects or close variants for so long, Branct~si\\-as able to cover his tracks rompletel\-, so that museumgoers don't find themselves \\-orking their way into the sculpture so much as they comprehend it at once. A