Bloom’s Modern Critical Views African-American Poets: Volume I African-American Poets: Volume II Aldous Huxley Alfred, ...
212 downloads
2845 Views
841KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Bloom’s Modern Critical Views African-American Poets: Volume I African-American Poets: Volume II Aldous Huxley Alfred, Lord Tennyson Alice Munro Alice Walker American Women Poets: 1650–1950 Amy Tan Anton Chekhov Arthur Miller Asian-American Writers August Wilson The Bible The Brontës Carson McCullers Charles Dickens Christopher Marlowe Contemporary Poets Cormac McCarthy C.S. Lewis Dante Aligheri David Mamet Derek Walcott Don DeLillo Doris Lessing Edgar Allan Poe Émile Zola Emily Dickinson Ernest Hemingway Eudora Welty Eugene O’Neill F. Scott Fitzgerald Flannery O’Connor Franz Kafka Gabriel García Márquez
Geoffrey Chaucer George Orwell G.K. Chesterton Gwendolyn Brooks Hans Christian Andersen Henry David Thoreau Herman Melville Hermann Hesse H.G. Wells Hispanic-American Writers Homer Honoré de Balzac Jamaica Kincaid James Joyce Jane Austen Jay Wright J.D. Salinger Jean-Paul Sartre John Irving John Keats John Milton John Steinbeck José Saramago J.R.R. Tolkien Julio Cortázar Kate Chopin Kurt Vonnegut Langston Hughes Leo Tolstoy Marcel Proust Margaret Atwood Mark Twain Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley Maya Angelou Miguel de Cervantes Milan Kundera Nathaniel Hawthorne
Norman Mailer Octavio Paz Paul Auster Philip Roth Ralph Ellison Ralph Waldo Emerson Ray Bradbury Richard Wright Robert Browning Robert Frost Robert Hayden Robert Louis Stevenson Salman Rushdie Stephen Crane Stephen King Sylvia Plath Tennessee Williams Thomas Hardy Thomas Pynchon Tom Wolfe Toni Morrison Tony Kushner Truman Capote Walt Whitman W.E.B. Du Bois William Blake William Faulkner William Gaddis William Shakespeare: Comedies William Shakespeare: Histories William Shakespeare: Tragedies William Wordsworth Zora Neale Hurston
Bloom’s Modern Critical Views
Flannery O’connor New Edition
Edited and with an introduction by
Harold Bloom
Sterling Professor of the Humanities Yale University
Bloom’s Modern Critical Views: Flannery O’Connor—New Edition Copyright © 2009 by Infobase Publishing Introduction © 2009 by Harold Bloom All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage or retrieval systems, without permission in writing from the publisher. For more information contact: Bloom’s Literary Criticism An imprint of Infobase Publishing 132 West 31st Street New York NY 10001 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Flannery O’Connor / edited and with an introduction by Harold Bloom. — New ed. p. cm. — (Bloom’s modern critical views) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-1-60413-589-3 1. O’Connor, Flannery—Criticism and interpretation. 2. Women and literature— United States—History—20th century. I. Bloom, Harold. II. Title. III. Series. PS3565.C57Z66784 2009 813'.54—dc22 2009016388 Bloom’s Literary Criticism books are available at special discounts when purchased in bulk quantities for businesses, associations, institutions, or sales promotions. Please call our Special Sales Department in New York at (212) 967-8800 or (800) 322-8755. You can find Bloom’s Literary Criticism on the World Wide Web at http://www.chelseahouse.com. Contributing editor: Pamela Loos Cover designed by Takeshi Takahashi Printed in the United States of America IBT IBT 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 This book is printed on acid-free paper. All links and Web addresses were checked and verified to be correct at the time of publication. Because of the dynamic nature of the Web, some addresses and links may have changed since publication and may no longer be valid.
Contents
Editor’s Note
vii
Introduction 1 Harold Bloom “Coming unalone”: Gesture and Gestation in Faulkner and O’Connor Philip M. Weinstein
9
Apocalypse of Self, Resurrection of the Double: Flannery O’Connor’s The Violent Bear It Away Suzanne Morrow Paulson Intellectuals and Would-Be Artists Laurence Enjolras The Action of Mercy Joyce Carol Oates
35
43
“Backwards to Bethlehem”: Evangelicalism in Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood Timothy P. Caron The Prophet and the Word in the Desert Richard Giannone
49
77
21
vi
Contents
Climbing into the Starry Field and Shouting Hallelujah: O’Connor’s Vision of the World to Come 103 Ralph C. Wood Flannery O’Connor: “Funny Because It Is Terrible” Michael Dunne O’Connor and the Body: Incarnation, Redemptive Suffering, and Evil John D. Sykes Jr. Chronology
167
Contributors
169
Bibliography
171
Acknowledgments Index
177
175
139
119
Editor’s Note
My introduction, much disputed by some of O’Connor’s more pious admirers, expresses unmixed aesthetic admiration for The Violent Bear It Away and the best of the short stories, while observing that her professed Catholic orthodoxy is far less prevalent in her work than is the ancient Gnostic heresy. Faulkner, her prime precursor, is juxtaposed with O’Connor by Philip M. Weinstein, while Suzanne Morrow Paulson studies the figure of the double in The Violent Bear It Away. Laurence Enjolras chronicles some of O’Connor’s ironical portraits of mock-intellectuals, after which Joyce E. Carol Oates finds in The Artificial Nigger one of O’Connor’s visions of divine grace. The role of evangelical religion is traced in Wise Blood by Timothy P. Caron, while Richard Giannone depicts the Tarwaters, uncle and nephew, as the prophets of The Violent Bear It Away. Ralph C. Wood emphasizes the authentically apocalyptic element in O’Connor, after which Michael Dunne uncovers what I would call a Jansenist strain in her violent comedy. In a closing essay, John D. Sykes Jr. meditates on O’Connor’s visions of redemptive suffering as our pathway to sharing the incarnation of Christ.
vii
H arold B loom
Introduction
A
professedly Roman Catholic prose romance begins with the death of an eighty-four-year-old southern American Protestant, self-called prophet, and professional moonshiner, as set forth in this splendidly comprehensive sentence: Francis Marion Tarwater’s uncle had been dead for only half a day when the boy got too drunk to finish digging his grave and a Negro named Buford Munson, who had come to get a jug filled, had to finish it and drag the body from the breakfast table where it was still sitting and bury it in a decent and Christian way, with the sign of its Saviour at the head of the grave and enough dirt on top to keep the dogs from digging it up.
Flannery O’Connor’s masterwork, The Violent Bear It Away, ends with the fourteen-year-old Tarwater marching toward the city of destruction, where his own career as prophet is to be suffered: Intermittently the boy’s jagged shadow slanted across the road ahead of him as if it cleared a rough path toward his goal. His singed eyes, black in their deep sockets, seemed already to envision the fate that awaited him but he moved steadily on, his face set toward the dark city, where the children of God lay sleeping.
Harold Bloom
In Flannery O’Connor’s fierce vision, the children of God, all of us, always are asleep in the outward life. Young Tarwater, clearly O’Connor’s surrogate, is in clinical terms a borderline schizophrenic, subject to auditory hallucinations in which he hears the advice of an imaginary friend who is overtly the Christian Devil. But clinical terms are utterly alien to O’Connor, who accepts only theological namings and unnamings. This is necessarily a spiritual strength in O’Connor, yet it can be an aesthetic distraction also, since The Violent Bear It Away is a fiction of preternatural power and not a religious tract. Rayber, the antagonist of both prophets, old and young Tarwater, is an aesthetic disaster, whose defects in representation alone keep the book from making a strong third with Faulkner’s As I Lay Dying and Nathanael West’s Miss Lonelyhearts. O’Connor despises Rayber and cannot bother to make him even minimally persuasive. We wince at his unlikely verbal mixture of popular sociology and confused psychology, as even Sally Fitzgerald, O’Connor’s partisan, is compelled to admit: Her weaknesses—a lack of perfect familiarity with the terminology of the secular sociologists, psychologists, and rationalists she often casts as adversary figures, and an evident weighting of the scales against them all—are present in the character of Rayber (who combines all three categories).
One hardly believes that a perfect familiarity with the writings, say, of David Riesman, Erik Erikson, and Karl Popper would have enabled O’Connor to make poor Rayber a more plausible caricature of what she despised. We remember The Violent Bear It Away for its two prophets and particularly young Tarwater, who might be called a Gnostic version of Huckleberry Finn. What makes us free is the Gnosis, according to the most ancient of heresies. O’Connor, who insisted upon her Catholic orthodoxy, necessarily believed that what makes us free is baptism in Christ, and for her the title of her novel was its most important aspect, since the words are spoken by Jesus himself: But what went ye out for to see? A prophet? yea, I say unto you, and more than a prophet. For this is he, of whom it is written, Behold, I send my messenger before thy face, which shall prepare thy way before thee. Verily I say unto you, Among them that are born of women there hath not risen a greater than John the Baptist: notwithstanding he that is least in the kingdom of heaven is greater than he. And from the days of John the Baptist until now the kingdom of heaven suffereth violence, and the violent take it by force.
Introduction
I have quoted the King James Version of Matthew 11: 9–12, where “and the violent take it by force” is a touch more revealing than O’Connor’s Catholic version, “and the violent bear it away.” For O’Connor, we are back in or rather never have left Christ’s time of urgency, and her heart is with those like the Tarwaters, who know that the kingdom of heaven will suffer them to take it by force: The lack of realism would be crucial if this were a realistic novel or if the novel demanded the kind of realism you demand. I don’t believe it does. The old man is very obviously not a Southern Baptist, but an independent, a prophet in the true sense. The true prophet is inspired by the Holy Ghost, not necessarily by the dominant religion of his region. Further, the traditional Protestant bodies of the South are evaporating into secularism and respectability and are being replaced on the grass roots level by all sorts of strange sects that bear not much resemblance to traditional Protestantism—Jehovah’s Witnesses, snake-handlers, Free Thinking Christians, Independent Prophets, the swindlers, the mad, and sometimes the genuinely inspired. A character has to be true to his own nature and I think the old man is that. He was a prophet, not a church-member. As a prophet, he has to be a natural Catholic. Hawthorne said he didn’t write novels, he wrote romances; I am one of his descendants.
O’Connor’s only disputable remark in this splendid defense of her book is the naming of old Tarwater as “a natural Catholic.” Hawthorne’s descendant she certainly was, by way of Faulkner, T.S. Eliot, and Nathanael West, but though Hawthorne would have approved her mode, he would have been shocked by her matter. To ignore what is authentically shocking about O’Connor is to misread her weakly. It is not her incessant violence that is troublesome but rather her passionate endorsement of that violence as the only way to startle her secular readers into a spiritual awareness. As a visionary writer, she is determined to take us by force, to bear us away so that we may be open to the possibility of grace. Her unbelieving reader is represented by the grandmother in the famous story “A Good Man Is Hard to Find”: She saw the man’s face twisted close to her own as if he were going to cry and she murmured, “Why you’re one of my babies. You’re one of my own children!” She reached out and touched him on the shoulder. The Misfit sprang back as if a snake had bitten him and
Harold Bloom
shot her three times through the chest. Then he put his gun down on the ground and took off his glasses and began to clean them.
That murmur of recognition is what matters for O’Connor. The Misfit speaks for her in his mordant observation: “She would of been a good woman, if it had been somebody there to shoot her every minute of her life.” Secular critic as I am, I need to murmur: “Surely that does make goodness a touch too strenuous?” But O’Connor anticipates our wounded outcries of nature against grace, since we understandably prefer a vision that corrects nature without abolishing it. Young Tarwater himself, as finely recalcitrant a youth as Huckleberry Finn, resists not only Rayber but the tuition of old Tarwater. A kind of swamp fox, like the revolutionary hero for whom he was named, the boy Tarwater waits for his own call and accepts his own prophetic election only after he has baptized his idiot cousin Bishop by drowning him and even then only in consequence of having suffered a homosexual rape by the Devil himself. O’Connor’s audacity reminds us of the Faulkner of Sanctuary and the West of A Cool Million. Her theology purports to be Roman Catholicism, but her sensibility is southern gothic, Jacobean in the mode of the early T.S. Eliot, and even Gnostic in the rough manner of Carlyle, a writer she is likely never to have read. I myself find it a critical puzzle to read her two novels, Wise Blood and The Violent Bear It Away, and her two books of stories, A Good Man Is Hard to Find and Everything That Rises Must Converge, and then to turn from her fiction to her occasional prose in Mystery and Manners and her letters in The Habit of Being. The essayist and letter writer denounces Manichaeism, Jansenism, and all other deviations from normative Roman Catholicism, while the storyteller seems a curious blend of the ideologies of Simone Weil reading the New Testament into the Iliad ’s “poem of force” and of René Girard assuring us that there can be no return of the sacred without violence. Yet the actual O’Connor, in her letters, found Weil “comic and terrible,” portraying the perpetual waiter for grace as an “angular intellectual proud woman approaching God inch by inch with ground teeth,” and I suspect she would have been as funny about the violent thematicism of Girard. To find something of a gap between O’Connor as lay theologue and O’Connor as a storyteller verging on greatness may or may not be accurate but in any case intends to undervalue neither the belief nor the fiction. I suspect, though, that the fiction’s implicit theology is very different from what O’Connor thought it to be, a difference that actually enhances the power of the novels and stories. It is not accidental that As I Lay Dying and Miss Lonelyhearts were the only works of fiction that O’Connor urged on Robert Fitzgerald or that her own prose cadences were haunted always by the earlier
Introduction
rather than the later Eliot. The Waste Land, As I Lay Dying, and Miss Lonelyhearts are not works of the Catholic imagination but rather of that Gnostic pattern Gershom Scholem termed “redemption through sin.” Wise Blood, The Violent Bear It Away, and stories like “A Good Man Is Hard to Find” and the merciless “Parker’s Back” take place in the same cosmos as The Waste Land, As I Lay Dying, and Miss Lonelyhearts. This world is the American version of the cosmological emptiness that the ancient Gnostics called the kenoma, a sphere ruled by a demiurge who has usurped the alien God and who has exiled God out of history and beyond the reach of our prayers. In recognizing O’Connor’s fictive universe as being essentially Gnostic, I dissent not only from her own repudiation of heresy but from the sensitive reading of Jefferson Humphries, who links O’Connor to Proust in an “aesthetic of violence”: For O’Connor, man has been his own demiurge, the author of his own fall, the keeper of his own cell. . . . The chief consequence of this partly willful, partly inherited alienation from the sacred is that the sacred can only intrude upon human perception as a violence, a rending of the fabric of daily life.
On this account, which remains normative, whether Hebraic or Catholic, we are fallen into the kenoma through our own culpability. In the Gnostic formulation, creation and fall were one and the same event, and all that can save us is a certain spark within us, a spark that is no part of the creation but rather goes back to the original abyss. The grandeur or sublimity that shines through the ruined creation is a kind of abyss radiance, whether in Blake or Carlyle or the early Eliot or in such novelistic masters of the grotesque as Faulkner, West, and O’Connor. The ugliest of O’Connor’s stories, yet one of the strongest, is “A View of the Woods” in Everything That Rises Must Converge. Its central characters are the seventy-nine-year-old Mr. Fortune and his nine-year-old granddaughter, Mary Fortune Pitts. I am uncertain which of the two is the more abominable moral character or hideous human personality, partly because they resemble each other so closely in selfishness, obduracy, false pride, sullenness, and just plain meanness. At the story’s close, a physical battle between the two leaves the little girl a corpse, throttled and with her head smashed upon a rock, while her grandfather suffers a heart attack, during which he has his final “view of the woods,” in one of O’Connor’s typically devastating final paragraphs: Then he fell on his back and looked up helplessly along the bare trunks into the tops of the pines and his heart expanded once
Harold Bloom
more with a convulsive motion. It expanded so fast that the old man felt as if he were being pulled after it through the woods, felt as if he were running as fast as he could with the ugly pines toward the lake. He perceived that there would be a little opening there, a little place where he could escape and leave the woods behind him. He could see it in the distance already, a little opening where the white sky was reflected in the water. It grew as he ran toward it until suddenly the whole lake opened up before him, riding majestically in little corrugated folds toward his feet. He realized suddenly that he could not swim and that he had not brought the boat. On both sides of him he saw that the gaunt trees had thickened into mysterious dark files that were marching across the water and away into the distance. He looked around desperately for someone to help him but the place was deserted except for one huge yellow monster which sat to the side, as stationary as he was, gorging itself on clay.
The huge yellow monster is a bulldozer, and so is the dying Mr. Fortune, and so was the dead Mary Fortune Pitts. What sustains our interest in such antipathetic figures in so grossly unsympathetic a world? O’Connor’s own commentary does not help answer the question and introduces a bafflement quite its own: The woods, if anything, are the Christ symbol. They walk across the water, they are bathed in a red light, and they in the end escape the old man’s vision and march off over the hills. The name of the story is a view of the woods and the woods alone are pure enough to be a Christ symbol if anything is. Part of the tension of the story is created by Mary Fortune and the old man being images of each other but opposite in the end. One is saved and the other is dammed [sic] and there is no way out of it, it must be pointed out and underlined. Their fates are different. One has to die first because one kills the other, but you have read it wrong if you think they die in different places. The old man dies by her side; he only thinks he runs to the edge of the lake, that is his vision.
What divine morality it can be that saves Mary Fortune and damns her wretched grandfather is beyond my ken, but the peculiarities of O’Connor’s sense of the four last things transcend me at all times, anyway. What is more interesting is O’Connor’s own final view of the woods. Her sacramental vision enables her to see Christ in “the gaunt trees [that] had thickened into
Introduction
mysterious dark files that were marching across the water and away into the distance.” Presumably their marching away is emblematic of Mr. Fortune’s damnation, so far as O’Connor is concerned. As a reader of herself, I cannot rank O’Connor very high here. Surely Mary Fortune is as damnable and damned as her grandfather, and the woods are damnable and damned also. They resemble not the normative Christ but the Jesus of the Gnostic texts, whose phantom only suffers upon the cross while the true Christ laughs far off in the alien heavens, in the ultimate abyss. O’Connor’s final visions are more equivocal than she evidently intended. Here is the conclusion of “Revelation”: Until the sun slipped finally behind the tree line, Mrs. Turpin remained there with her gaze bent to them as if she were absorbing some abysmal life-giving knowledge. At last she lifted her head. There was only a purple streak in the sky, cutting through a field of crimson and leading, like an extension of the highway, into the descending dusk. She raised her hands from the side of the pen in a gesture hieratic and profound. A visionary light settled in her eyes. She saw the streak as a vast swinging bridge extending upward from the earth through a field of living fire. Upon it a vast horde of souls were rumbling toward heaven. There were whole companies of white-trash, clean for the first time in their lives, and bands of black niggers in white robes, and battalions of freaks and lunatics shouting and clapping and leaping like frogs. And bringing up the end of the procession was a tribe of people whom she recognized at once as those who, like herself and Claud, had always had a little of everything and the God-given wit to use it right. She leaned forward to observe them closer. They were marching behind the others with great dignity, accountable as they had always been for good order and common sense and respectable behavior. They alone were on key. Yet she could see by their shocked and altered faces that even their virtues were being burned away. She lowered her hands and gripped the rail of the hog pen, her eyes small but fixed unblinkingly on what lay ahead. In a moment the vision faded but she remained where she was, immobile. At length she got down and turned off the faucet and made her slow way on the darkening path to the house. In the woods around her the invisible cricket choruses had struck up, but what she heard were the voices of the souls climbing upward into the starry field and shouting hallelujah.
Harold Bloom
This is meant to burn away false or apparent virtues and yet consumes not less than everything. In O’Connor’s mixed realm, which is neither nature nor grace, southern reality nor private phantasmagoria, all are necessarily damned, not by an aesthetic of violence but by a Gnostic aesthetic in which there is no knowing unless the knower becomes one with the known. Her Catholic moralism masked from O’Connor something of her own aesthetic of the grotesque. Certainly her essay on “Some Aspects of the Grotesque in Southern Fiction” evades what is central in her own praxis: Whenever I’m asked why Southern writers particularly have a penchant for writing about freaks, I say it is because we are still able to recognize one. To be able to recognize a freak, you have to have some conception of the whole man, and in the South the general conception of man is still, in the main, theological. That is a large statement, and it is dangerous to make it, for almost anything you say about Southern belief can be denied in the next breath with equal propriety. But approaching the subject from the standpoint of the writer, I think it is safe to say that while the South is hardly Christ-centered, it is most certainly Christ-haunted. The Southerner, who isn’t convinced of it, is very much afraid that he may have been formed in the image and likeness of God. Ghosts can be very fierce and instructive. They cast strange shadows, particularly in our literature. In any case, it is when the freak can be sensed as a figure for our essential displacement that he attains some depth in literature.
The freakish displacement here is from “wholeness,” which is then described as the state of having been made in the image or likeness of God. But that mode, displacement, is not what is operative in O’Connor’s fiction. Her own favorite, among her people, is young Tarwater, who is not a freak and who is so likable because he values his own freedom above everything and anyone, even his call as a prophet. We are moved by Tarwater because of his recalcitrance, because he is the Huck Finn of visionaries. But he moves O’Connor, even to identification, because of his inescapable prophetic vocation. It is the interplay between Tarwater fighting to be humanly free and Tarwater besieged by his great-uncle’s training, by the internalized Devil, and most of all by O’Connor’s own ferocious religious zeal, that constitutes O’Connor’s extraordinary artistry. Her pious admirers to the contrary, O’Connor would have bequeathed us even stronger novels and stories, of the eminence of Faulkner’s, if she had been able to restrain her spiritual tendentiousness.
P hilip M . W einstein
“Coming unalone”: Gesture and Gestation in Faulkner and O’Connor
I
’m going to be using these terms, gesture and gestation, literally and figuratively. “Gesture” points to the rhetorical stances of a writer’s work, its characteristic ways of implicating the reader. Analyzing Faulkner’s poetics of description, André Bleikasten noted that “what captures our attention, is not so much what is described as the sheer movement and momentum of describing . . . its headlong rush, its furious forward flight” (182). Like Van Gogh’s brush stroke that mesmerizes us more than the object it depicts, Faulknerian narrative in the early experimental masterpieces aggresses the reader, demands—through its own discontinuities, its frequent dissolving of the distinctions between narrator and character—that the reader re-orient him/herself to its stresses, accommodate its transgressions. O’Connor’s rhetoric gestures otherwise: crisp, flat, declarative rather than vocative, her prose distills a human landscape arrested and placed down to its last detail. Her relentlessly perceptive narrator never merges with her tragicomically blinded characters. As to “gestation” I mean mainly the writer’s complex of attitudes towards things that burgeon in time: things as local as a woman’s swelling body about to give birth, things as general as a novel whose plot requires several generations of behavior or a body of works where the later ones creatively draw on the données of the earlier ones. The quotation in my title comes from As I Lay Dying: “The process of coming unalone is terrible” (As I 56), Dewey Dell thinks with respect to From Faulkner, His Contemporaries, and His Posterity, edited by Waldemar Zacharasiewicz, pp. 262–75. © 1993 by A. Francke Verlag Tübingen and Basel.
10
Philip M. Weinstein
her incomprehensible pregnancy, and this thought articulates the dynamic operating more broadly in the text’s vulnerable characters, its fragmented form, and its exposed reader: the process of being invaded, becoming other within. Faulkner’s early experimental fiction engages directly the torment of self-division, and it passes this torment right into the subjective experience of the reader. At such moments “the clotting which is you” seems to dissolve back into “the myriad motion” (As I 149–150), individual identity to re-enter the floodwaters from which it arose. This experience of traumatic pre-oedipal merger fuels the texts Faulkner wrote between 1929 and 1936, and I want to examine in what follows the resonance of “coming unalone” in both Faulkner’s novels and O’Connor’s stories. Rather than focus on a few representative works, I shall touch on many of them, preferring to risk the Charybdis of excessive claim than to wash ashore on the Scylla of microscopic close readings. As I Lay Dying centers on the terror of coming unalone. Addie dies within each of her children—never was Mr. Compson’s dictum that death is something that happens to others better borne out—and her dying shatters their apparently independent identity into shards. Her existence within them all is now clamorous, useless, and inexpellable. She dies slowly, at their pace not hers, and the paradox emerges: “how can a body that still is be thought of as was? how can I, whose self has depended upon, and been defined in relation to, another self, now understand the integrity of my own identity?” (Sundquist 169). The book’s intimacy resides in its apparently unmediated access to such unspeakable thoughts within the Bundren children violated by their mother’s presence/absence—an intimacy we share every time we decode phrases as cryptic as “My mother is a fish.” (I return later to why such a phrase cannot occur within O’Connor’s rhetoric: her narratorial idiom requires no such emotional nearness to be decoded.) “It takes two people to make you, and one people to die. That’s how the world is going to end” (As I 35). So Darl thinks, and the proposition seems irrefutable, yet Faulkner’s texts focus as much on the two that make you as on the one that dies. Those two are in you, and his great work tirelessly registers identity as beleaguered intersubjectivity, an internal terrain filled with the static of parents pronouncing and siblings squabbling. Benjy’s, Quentin’s, Jason’s, Darl’s, Dewey Dell’s, and Vardaman’s heads reel with the sayings and thoughts of others; they circle ceaselessly round the axis of other subjectivities already encamped within even if absent without. Personal identity emerges here as a sort of liquidity, a boundaryless resource within which others have already plunged their signatures. As Lacan argues, the Symbolic penetrates us long before we master and enact its logic; we are others’ long before we even think of becoming our own.1
“Coming unalone”: Gesture and Gestation in Faulkner and O’Connor
11
“Coming unalone” emerges in these experimental texts as both the staple of characters’ vertiginous identity and the uncomfortable effect of reading Faulkner. Nothing stays properly possessed. Speeches said by some characters echo in the minds of others; cryptic phrases coming from anywhere—Father, Mother, Addie, Darl, McEachern, the anonymous surrounding culture— penetrate within, coil and transform; events get revisited under other eyes and appear other. The authority of a commanding rhetoric is absent, Bakhtin would claim, as various idiolects “abrupt” upon each other within a dialogic text no one linguistically owns.2 Insofar as the reader’s identity is also provisional, makeshift, open to reshaping and eager to read because it seeks out the reshaping, it becomes as well a text under siege. As Jameson has argued persuasively, the decisive ideological activity of a text occurs within its form, not its content, and Faulknerian form in the early masterpieces acts upon the reader as a dislocation if not an overwhelming.3 Bleikasten was the first to read this overwhelming thematically as “the scandal of this ‘terrible’ life” (F’s AILD 133), and Kristeva has urged us to speak of such a text’s transgressive form—with its gaps, incoherences, discontinuities—as “semiotic”: “To rediscover . . . what is heterogeneous to the system of meaning and what calls in question the transcendental subject: these, it seems to me,” Kristeva writes, “are the stakes for which semiotics is now playing” (System 31). Increasingly, this transcendental subject is revealed to be male, and the plot disrupted by the outburst of the “semiotic” is the patriarchal one of coherent male subjectivity sustained and passed on, from father to son.4 Faulkner’s undoing of this plot is inseparable from his refusal of its rhetorical decorum. What do the great novels revolve around if not the spectacle of illegitimacy and miscegenation? In this sense the scandal can be defined more precisely: illicit gestation, the swelling of life within a female body no one owns. The transgressed law of the father, the penetrated body of the errant daughter: beginning with Caddy (whose betrayal of the patriarchal enterprise launches Faulkner’s novelistic career), moving through Temple and Addie and Dewey Dell and Lena and Eula, Faulkner’s texts come upon these women as tragic or comic misconceivers, women whose defining gesture is illicit intercourse producing (or threatening to produce) offspring outside the patriarchal norms. The narrative accesses them through the hallucinatory male gaze of their brothers, fathers, uncles, and other custodians of the law. Their “coming unalone” is simultaneously the scandal of parturition—a second being lodged within a first being and laboring to exit—and the violation of family proprieties. The only birth Faulkner cares to follow is the one that transgresses normative boundaries, the offspring he most memorably explores is the orphan or the bastard, the child literally or figuratively cut off
12
Philip M. Weinstein
from maternal care, paternal training, the child whose internal boundaries have been transgressed as well. Idiocy appears in his work as the sign both of a psyche gone awry—its mental circuitry hopelessly crossed—and of a family’s illicit continuation, the line of descent inextricably befouled through figurative incest or literal miscegenation. “It takes two people to make you, and one people to die.” By Darl’s logic the world should end thus, yet Faulkner’s doomed families keep reproducing. Even the Bundrens renew themselves, and despite the accumulating corpses the Compsons and Sutpens seem immortal as those novels conclude, Caddy’s daughter Quentin and Sutpen’s great-grandson Jim Bond imagined somewhere on the periphery of the text, uncontainable by the logic of extinction through impurity. As Faulkner’s career continues, reproduction takes on new powers. Perhaps the most moving moment in Go Down, Moses’s sevengenerational history occurs when old Ike McCaslin, after repudiating the “doe” in every way he can, touches her hand: “He didn’t grasp it, he merely touched it—the gnarled, bloodless, bone-light bone-dry old man’s fingers touching for a second the smooth young flesh where the strong old blood ran after its long lost journey back to home. ‘Tennie’s Jim,’ he said. ‘Tennie’s Jim’ ” (GDM 362). Back to home, yet not so: she exits from this text to parts unknown and a future beyond narration, carrying Roth’s baby and with it the inextinguishable mixed and scandalous history of McCaslins black and white. Time that brought mainly entropy and dishonor in The Sound and the Fury still brings those bitter fruits, but it brings more as well. Memory that gives pain for Bayard or Quentin or Addie becomes generous in Absalom, restorative in Go Down, Moses, self-reshaping in Requiem, a source of joy in The Reivers. Ratliff emerges as Faulkner’s story-teller, the living integument whose vernacular recastings and revisitings bind his hearers together into a temporary community of interwoven subjectivities. Faulkner’s work is nourished by the prodigality of gestation as much as it thrives on the scandal of gestation. Sexual conception is the lifeblood of his fiction, the generating of offspring its focal event. His own career testifies to the same gestative powers: what other writer has so richly brooded upon earlier performances, drawn from them unseen potential, invented sequels, revisions, reversals? Time is the medium upon which Faulknerian creation battens. It matters not, finally, how illicit, mixed, and revisionary that creation is: the business of making exceeds that of dying. If Temple Drake embodies Faulknerian scandal, “A Temple of the Holy Ghost” announces its O’Connor counterpart. Not what she might do (Temple as subject) counts here, but what God has done to her (Temple as object: of the Holy Ghost). The body emerges in this story less as a site for potential and illicit subjective encounters involving the group dynamics of race and
“Coming unalone”: Gesture and Gestation in Faulkner and O’Connor
13
class (these dynamics are superficially operative here, not fundamentally, as in Faulkner) than as the site of an already ordained freakish opposition between the human and the divine. All bodies in O’Connor’s work are passing strange. To be in a body is, for her as never for Faulkner, a spectacle unto itself. Few writers exceed her in mapping the minute bizarreness of arms, legs, noses, chins, postures, ways of walking and sitting. These eccentricities culminate in the double-sexed circus freak of this tale: She could hear the freak saying, “God made me thisaway and I don’t dispute hit,” and the people saying, “Amen. Amen.” “God done this to me and I praise Him.” “Amen. Amen.” “He could strike you thisaway.” “Amen. Amen.” “But he has not.” “Amen.” “Raise yourself up. A temple of the Holy Ghost. You! You are God’s temple, don’t you know? Don’t you know? God’s Spirit has a dwelling in you, don’t you know?” “Amen. Amen.” (CompS 246)
O’Connor’s scandal, unlike Faulkner’s, is divinely decreed; its burden is to be accepted. We live daily in its midst and through our adroit maneuvers we usually manage to evade its recognition; we carry on. But the freak gives the game away: at his bodily core, at the site of his reproductive organs, he registers a grotesque flouting of natural law. Reversing Parker’s attempt to tattoo God on his back, the freak was born with God’s tattoo already in place, lower down, the male and female signs cancelling each other out in their revelation of the scandalous truth. That truth is simply the absurdity of taking human procreative power as the natural model for human well-being. If Abraham is the father figure of Judaism because God marked him as fertile long past the time of his potency—thus promising Israel its full gestation in time—O’Connor by contrast connects Abraham with bodily erasure: “God’s reasonable man,” she writes, “the prototype of whom must be Abraham, willing to sacrifice his son and thereby show that he is in the image of God Who sacrifices His Son” (HB 116). The move to yield up life characterizes the reasonable man, and the female capacity to gestate life stimulates O’Connor to some of her zaniest scenes. Here is Mrs. Freeman (“Good Country People”) describing to Mrs. Hopewell her daughter Glynese’s courtship:
14
Philip M. Weinstein
“Glynese gone out with Harvey Hill again last night,” she said. “She had this sty.” “Hill,” Mrs. Hopewell said absently, “is that the one who works in the garage?” “Nome, he’s the one that goes to chiropracter school,” Mrs. Freeman said. “She had this sty. Been had it two days. So she says when he brought her in the other night he says, ‘Lemme get rid of that sty for you,’ and she says, ‘How?’ and he says, ‘You just lay yourself down acrost the seat of that car and I’ll show you.’ So she done it and he popped her neck. Kept on a-popping it several times until she made him quit. This morning,” Mrs. Freeman said, “she ain’t got no sty. She ain’t got no traces of a sty.” (CompS 281)
Besides the class-coded humor that fuels O’Connor’s comedy, this passage also suggestively figures Glynese’s sty therapy as sexual intercourse, fusing the notions of illness, fornication, and the grotesque. These traits appear in perhaps their most condensed form at the beginning of “A Circle in the Fire.” There, in an echo of the Freeman-Hopewell pair of mothers, the white-trash mother gets the good lines: “You know that woman that had that baby in that iron lung?” Mrs. Cope, seeking to discontinue this discussion so promising in its vulgarity, changes the subject, but to no avail. Mrs. Pritchard gets in the last word: “Yes’m, see she was in it four months before she even got thataway. Look like to me if I was in one of them, I would leave off . . . how you reckon they . . . ?” (CompS 176–77). Mrs. Cope may see in such stories only whitetrash vulgarity, but we glimpse in them the lineaments of O’Connor’s carnal drama: that we physically reproduce ourselves within the invisible constraint of God’s suspended judgment, that catastrophe awaits us at any moment, that procreative intercourse is a seamy last-minute distraction from the arresting transactions that count. Wise Blood, as Bleikasten has noted, insistently ties the mother to the thematics of death.5 Connected with a coffin or car, a black Bible, and spectacles, the mother registers—as whore, acquaintance, or lover—as a carrier of damnation through intercourse, blindness through desire. Sabbath Hawks grotesquely gathers the shrunken mummy’s head to her breast, while a stunned Hazel Motes looks at himself and her through his mother’s glasses: “He saw his mother’s face in his, looking at the face in the mirror. He moved back quickly and raised his hand to take off the glasses but the door opened and two more faces floated into his line of vision; one of them said, ‘Call me Momma now . . . ’ (WB 102). Momma and mummy: gestation and eternal death—this sinister equation resonates throughout the stories. Ruby
“Coming unalone”: Gesture and Gestation in Faulkner and O’Connor
15
Hill whose pregnancy feels like the incursion of death, “a pain like a piece of something pushing something else” (CompS 101), Mrs. Greenleaf whose religious writhing on the earth appears to Mrs. May as white-trash sexual abandon—to come unalone is for these figures not a creative scandal but the annihilation of their deepest social identities. The stories specialize in punished mothers, in collapsing the family dynamic by undoing the fulcrum figure of the mother. Mrs. May’s fate— to be gored to death by a bull—is the extreme instance of the general fate in which a child’s self-recognition is enabled by the mother’s death. Mrs. Chestny in “Everything that Rises,” Thomas’ mother in “The Comforts of Home,” the grandmother in “A Good Man”—all these mothers are foredoomed. O’Connor writes: “I am very happy right now writing a story in which I plan for the heroine, aged 63, to be gored by a bull. I am not convinced yet that this is purgation or whether I identify myself with her or the bull” (HB 129). The meanings can be sorted out later but the final action is already crystalline: the mother must die.6 And indeed the endings are always in place; nothing gestating can alter their predetermined imposition. To come unalone in O’Connor is to undergo a violation by God or by Satan: the difference between these two violations is minimal. But the difference between her narrator’s grasp on the encounter and her characters’ blindness to it is maximal. O’Connor’s narrator never shares the narrative role with her protagonists by inhabiting their rhetoric. “You have to be able to dominate the existence that you characterize,” she insisted. “That is why I write about people who are more or less primitive” (HB 106). To read her is thus—by comparison to Faulkner—to remain relatively intact at the spectacle of her protagonists’ shattering. She who is unsurpassed in describing disintegration nevertheless enacts in her own narrative stance, and thus passes on to the reader’s subjectivity, the godlike survival of a catastrophe that always happens to others. Security—the bane of her fiction’s récit—reigns supreme in the gesture enacted by her discours. As Denys Turner puts it in his study of ideology, we have “a contradiction between a meaning conveyed explicitly and a meaning conveyed by the act itself of conveying” (26). Like gods we watch, mesmerized but inviolate, the increasingly predictable collapse of numberless small worlds. Put otherwise: given a spectrum of subjective positions that go from the precision of relentless insight to the errancy of comic blindness, O’Connor’s narrative voice opts for a polar version of the former in order to seize vividly upon a polar version of the latter. Cliché emerges as the distinctive tool for maintaining this separation. Unlike Faulknerian vernacular narrators, who often share—and thus subjectify—the discursive assumptions of their subjects, the O’Connor narrator eschews cliché at all cost.7 More, her assumption that cliché governs the
16
Philip M. Weinstein
discourse of communal life is fateful. It ensures that, as Hulga exclaims, we are blind to our own light (Hulga remaining the victim as well as the speaker of this insight), and that whatever is verbally shared by her characters is necessarily superficial and erroneous: “we” is the marker of an unfailingly deluded community. Her characters’ common discursive ground is a tissue of class- and race-propelled fictions, seeking to shore up status, to ward off displacement, and guaranteed to fail. The vision of radical displacement they would shield themselves from does attach to political realities—the Holocaust vision of boxcars of intermingled bodies, all heading to extinction, the lowest and the highest bound together in disaster, all hierarchy mocked—but O’Connor has no pity to waste on this nightmare image because it is simultaneously for her a prophetic image: one that reveals not the historically determinate violence visited upon a specific group—the Jews—but rather figures for us all our ahistorical and universal fate. Defending the Church’s position on birth control, she wrote: “I wish various fathers would quit trying to defend it by saying that the world can support 40 billion. I will rejoice in the day when they say: This is right, whether we all rot on top of each other or not, dear children, as we certainly may” (HB 338). It may take two people to make you, but O’Connor was sure that the critical fact was annihilation—not engineered by yourself alone but wrought into God’s design. Natural gestation, the premise of earthly continuity, is a dodge; social distinctions a sham. What we need to know is that our human orders (our secular arrangements) are distractions and that we are going to rot. From this frame of transcendent values any local disturbance is a tonic sign—the violent bear it away—and piecemeal or radical programs of reform receive her most withering sarcasm. I want to close, though, by briefly suggesting that for both writers the repudiation of communal possibilities—of reformable social arrangements that might better accommodate the violation of individual aloneness—is a position they arrive at not just by native genius or religious conviction but by a larger disdain for the social that is wrought into the cultural moment they share: Modernism. Richard Moreland has provocatively argued that the irony governing Modernist critique conceals the writer’s investment in the scene he would transcendently lay bare.8 Thus the stance of isolated and revelatory disillusionment—enacted at different times by Darl or Quentin or Mr. Compson or Ike McCaslin—obscures the interplay between observer and observed, and continues to repress class, race, and gender aspects within the scene being observed. With respect to “coming unalone,” I would suggest that As I Lay Dying everywhere produces it as a primordial experience of integrity violated, a metaphysical state of the loss of innocence. But suppose that such a privileged undergoing of shock—apparently beyond condition, touching down
“Coming unalone”: Gesture and Gestation in Faulkner and O’Connor
17
to bedrock—were actually dependent upon a patriarchal notion of transcendental ego, and that its Faulknerian overlay were fueled by his culture’s inextinguishable fear of miscegenation? Suppose that embattled virginity were a socially generated illness of the male mind surveying an impending and hostile world “out there”? As for O’Connor, her disdain for the topical as a shaper of subjectivity should not obscure the fact that she forged her own subjective identity through participation within a host of socially constructed economies.9 Her Incarnational Catholicism was richly supported by contemporary Catholic thinkers (Gilson, Guardini, Maritain, Marcel, Teilhard) as well as by a New Critical emphasis on the topical as ideologically contaminated, while the visionary (for them a poem, for her God’s script or the authority of her own narrative voice) remains sacred and inviolable territory.10 Trained at Iowa and in touch throughout her life with critical authorities like Allen Tate and Caroline Gordon, Andrew Lytle, Robert Lowell, and Robert Fitzgerald, she was no one’s mere pupil, yet her combination of aesthetics and belief is suffused with the reigning dicta of the 1940s and 1950s.11 If not a partisan, she was nevertheless highly trained—trained to believe in the insignificance of all social training. Her aloneness too was violated, thanks to which we have not the death her stories ceaselessly celebrate but that unforgettable gestation that is the stories themselves.
No t e s 1. Lacan’s argument about the mirror stage is too well-known to need rehearsal here. Suffice it to say that the child’s entry into the Symbolic field of language and culture registers not upon a blank slate but upon an interiority whose tumultuous prehistory has been shaped by the penetration of discontinuous images and phrases, molding the “moi” that precedes the “ je.” The “méconnaissance” that follows leads Lacan to state that “[t]he promotion of consciousness as being essential to the subject in the historical after-effects of the Cartesian cogito is for me the deceptive accentuation of the transparency of the I in action at the expense of the opacity of the signifier that determines the I . . .” (“Subversion of the subject” 307). Ragland-Sullivan opens up usefully this dimension of Lacan’s argument. For application of such a paradigm to Faulknerian subjectivity, see my “Thinking I Was I Was Not Who Was Not Was Not Who”: The Vertigo of Faulknerian Identity,” as well as my full-length study of Faulkner entitled Faulkner’s Subject: A Cosmos No One Owns. Warwick Wadlington makes a sustained case for viewing the generation of personal identity in Faulkner’s texts as a process of encounters with culturally proposed models of being. 2. Bakhtin explores most fully the novelistic use of language(s) as an interactive play of competing worldviews in “Discourse in the Novel.” A notably Faulknerian description of the dialogic, however, appears in his text on Dostoevsky: “Everywhere there is an intersection, consonance, or interruption of rejoinders in the open dialogue by rejoinders in the heroes’ internal dialogue. Everywhere a specific sum total of
18
Philip M. Weinstein
ideas, thoughts, and words is passed through several unmerged voices, sounding differently in each” (265). 3. See The Political Unconscious 17–102. 4. Kristeva pursues the implications of the “semiotic” most dramatically in the form and theme of her essay “Stabat Mater.” The project of disrupting the male plot of patriarchal descent—of releasing the female voices repressed in this plot—is of course common to much contemporary feminism. For a powerful commentary on the philosophical underpinnings of this male “plot,” see Irigaray. For a suggestive, if debatable, reading of Faulkner’s repressed female voices, see Gwin. 5. “But the most remarkable feature is that the themes of sin and guilt, sex and death, all coalesce around the mother figure and its surrogates. . . . It is no surprise then that Motes’ erratic quest should end in oedipal self-blinding and selfdestruction. His tragic end completes identification with the dead mother: it is both fulfillment and expiation of the same desire” (Bleikasten, “Heresy” 150). In my reading of Wise Blood the Oedipal is not the commanding paradigm. Hazel at the end escapes the suffocating hold of the mother by withdrawing from Mrs. Flood’s blinded vision: “and she saw him moving farther and farther away, farther and farther into the darkness until he was the pin point of light” (WB 126). For Bleikasten the religious frame finally fails to account for the savagery of O’Connor’s work. His reading assumes that a genuine religious economy would produce texts more pacified, but John Burt’s demur is pertinent: “What O’Connor’s works present the reader with is not a body of illustrated doctrine, nor even a body of doctrine hammered with ruthless irony into the minds of recalcitrant readers, but the experience of doubt whether life has any meaning at all, an experience which religion exists to enlarge, not to pacify” (138). 6. O’Connor had as much trouble getting into the middles of her fiction as Henry James had getting past the middles of his. O’Connor’s endings were less in doubt. One is tempted to speculate biographically that her incurable illness served her as the clearest index of what had not yet arrived but would indubitably come, exposing the illusory “gestativeness” of time in the interim. She writes to “A”: “I have found it out [that things cannot be worked out on the surface] . . . the hard way and only in the last years as a result of I think two things, sickness and success. In a sense sickness is a place, more instructive than a long trip to Europe, and it’s always a place where there’s no company, where nobody can follow. Sickness before death is a very appropriate thing and I think those who don’t have it miss one of God’s mercies. Success is almost as isolating and nothing points out vanity as well” (HB 163). 7. Commenting on Cecil Dawkins’ manuscript story, she writes: “Caroline [Gordon] would say that on the last sentence you shouldn’t say kept ‘right on’ praying. Right on is colloquial and lowers the tone. You might say that he continued to pray—or anything not colloquial” (HB 333). If this distinction between O’Connor’s narrator-subject and her character-object is crucial, it is nevertheless not absolute, and a good case could be made for O’Connor’s remarkable inhabiting of characterstances not her own: an inhabiting enabled (because delimited) by her scrupulous deployment of colloquial and standard English. Without such acts of brilliant “counter-transference” she would hardly be worth reading. I have wanted here to stress the other side of this dynamic: that her narrative strategy cannot permit the sustained identificatory and boundary-transgressing moves that characterize the production of subjectivity within Faulkner’s experimental masterpieces.
“Coming unalone”: Gesture and Gestation in Faulkner and O’Connor
19
8. Moreland writes: “The New Critical and modernist construction of a metaphysical opposition between reality and fiction appears hard enough on sentiment to seem the unsentimental truth, and not actually sentimentality’s self-defence, a way to avoid questions about the particular origins and consequences of particular fictions and about their possible complicity in that cruel or indifferent reality they seem to oppose” (25). This vein of flourishing Faulknerian commentary was opened by Carolyn Porter’s influential Seeing and Being: The Plight of the Participant Observer in Emerson, James, Adams, and Faulkner. As much as I welcome its attention to the interrelations between canonical texts and cultural currents, Moreland runs the risk of reifying Modernism as a set of assumptions and procedures whose lens upon the present scene was unchangingly hostile: the same stance operative in Eliot, Joyce, Pound, Faulkner . . . 9. To “A” she writes: “The topical is poison. I got away with it in ‘Everything That Rises’ but only because I say a plague on everybody’s house as far as the race business goes” (HB 537). This passage is often cited approvingly by O’Connor’s critics (see Kessler 44) as proof of her successful disregard of the mundane. But, as Moreland might argue, the disregarded mundane manages to insinuate itself nevertheless. In “The Artificial Nigger,” for example (one of her favorite stories), the race and gender subtext is disturbingly reactionary. O’Connor figures Nelson’s desire to see Atlanta and touch down to his origins as black: “He wanted to look down and down into her [the huge black woman’s] eyes while she held him tighter and tighter. He had never had such a feeling before. He felt as if he were reeling down through a pitchblack tunnel” (CompS 262). The implications of that tunnel—that white and male have their repressed sources in black and female—are adroitly evaded by the story’s safe delivery of its chastened males back to their rural Eden, the serpents of sex and the “race business” safely relegated to the Dantesque sewer-system of modern Atlanta. 10. O’Connor writes Cecil Dawkins in 1957: “Anyway, to discover the Church you have to set out by yourself. The French Catholic novelists were a help to me in this—Bloy, Bernanos, Mauriac. In philosophy, Gilson, Maritain and Gabriel Marcel, an Existentialist. They all seemed to be French for a while and then I discovered the Germans—Max Picard, Romano Guardini and Karl Adam” (HB 231). Perhaps the most telling aspect of this passage is O’Connor’s conviction that you must “set out by yourself ”—followed by a thick cluster of names and texts and disciplines helping you to map your path. 11. Frederick Crews makes this point with characteristic trenchancy: “Like so many college-trained writers who have succeeded her, O’Connor never wrote without a sense of the critics looking over her shoulder. Nor, in her shorter fiction at least, did she ever stray from the regnant Creative Writing mode. Even the most impressive and original of her stories adhere to the classroom formula of her day: show, don’t tell; keep the narrative voice distinct from those of your characters; cultivate understatement; develop a central image or symbol to convey your theme ‘objectively’; and point everything toward one neatly sprung ironic reversal. No one has ever put it all together with greater deftness” (49).
Wor k s Ci t e d Bakhtin, Mikhail. “Discourse in the Novel.” The Dialogic Imagination. Tr. Caryl Emerson and Michael Holquist. Austin: U of Texas P, 1981.
20
Philip M. Weinstein
. Problems of Dostoevsky’s Poetics. Tr. Caryl Emerson. Minneapolis: U of Minnesota P, 1984. Bleikasten, André. Faulkner’s “As I Lay Dying.” Tr. Roger Little. Bloomington: Indiana UP, 1973. . “The Heresy of Flannery O’Connor.” In Critical Essays on Flannery O’Connor. Melvin Friedman and Beverly Lyon Clark eds. Boston: G.K. Hall, 1985, 138–58. . “Faulkner and the Paradoxes of Description.” In Faulkner’s Discourse: An International Symposium. Lothar Hönnighausen ed. Tübingen: Niemeyer, 1989, 170–83. Burt, John. “What You Can’t Talk About.” In Modern Critical Views: Flannery O’Connor. Harold Bloom ed. New York: Chelsea House, 1986, 125–43. Crews, Frederick. “The Power of Flannery O’Connor.” The New York Review of Books 37 (1990): 49–55. Faulkner, William. As I Lay Dying: The Corrected Text. New York: Vintage, 1987. [As I] Gwin, Minrose. The Feminine and Faulkner. Knoxville: U of Tennessee P, 1989. Irigaray, Luce. Ce Sexe qui n’en est pas un. Paris: Editions de Minuit, 1977. Jameson, Fredric. The Political Unconscious: Narrative as a Socially Symbolic Act. Ithaca: Cornell UP, 1981. Kessler, Edward. Flannery O’Connor and the Language of Apocalypse. Princeton: Princeton UP, 1986. Kristeva, Julia. “The System and the Speaking Subject.” In The Kristeva Reader. Toril Moi ed. New York: Columbia UP, 1986, 24–33. . “Stabat Mater.” In The Kristeva Reader. Toril Moi ed. New York: Columbia UP, 1986, 160–86. Lacan, Jacques. “The subversion of the subject and the dialectic of desire in the Freudian unconscious.” Ecrits: A Selection. Tr. Alan Sheridan. New York: Norton, 1977, 292–325. Moreland, Richard C. Faulkner and Modernism: Rereading and Rewriting. Madison: U of Wisconsin P, 1990. O’Connor, Flannery. The Complete Stories. New York: Farrar, Straus, and Giroux, 1973. [CompS] . The Habit of Being: Letters of Flannery O’Connor. Sally Fitzgerald ed. New York: Vintage, 1980. [HB] . Wise Blood. In Three by Flannery O’Connor. New York: Signet, 1962. Porter, Carolyn. Seeing and Being: The Plight of the Participant Observer in Emerson, James, Adams, and Faulkner. Middletown: Wesleyan UP, 1981. Ragland-Sullivan, Ellie. Jacques Lacan and the Philosophy of Psychoanalysis. Urbana: U of Illinois P, 1986. Sundquist, Eric. “Death, Grief, Analogous Form: As I Lay Dying.” In Philosophical Approaches to Literature: New Essays on Nineteenth- and Twentieth-Century Texts. William E. Cain ed. Lewisburg: Bucknell UP 1983, 165–82. Turner, Denys. Marxism and Christianity. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1983. Wadlington, Warwick. Reading Faulknerian Tragedy. Ithaca: Cornell UP, 1987. Weinstein, Philip M. “ ‘Thinking I Was I Was Not Who Was Not Was Not Who’: The Vertigo of Faulknerian Identity.” In Faulkner and the Craft of Fiction. Doreen Fowler and Ann J. Abadie eds. Jackson: UP of Mississippi, 1989, 172–93. . Faulkner’s Subject: A Cosmos No One Owns. New York: Cambridge UP, 1992.
S uzanne M orrow P aulson
Apocalypse of Self, Resurrection of the Double: Flannery O’Connor’s The Violent Bear It Away
F
lannery O’Connor’s The Violent Bear It Away seems to resist the glimpse of the author’s “sacred consciousness” that she promised the reader.1 An odyssey toward madness rather than salvation, the novel begins with the death of Mason Tarwater and ends with a grotesque “resurrection” as old Tarwater’s will takes over the psyche of his young nephew, Francis. This “resurrection” of Mason’s evangelical self in fact signifies the boy’s psychological death: “Nothing seemed alive about the boy but his eyes” (CW 477). Are those eyes traditional signifiers (windows of the soul)? Or are they postFreudian (castration displaced upward)? Some traditionalists tend to see The Violent Bear It Away as a failure, missing the artfully interwoven but crippling interrelationships of the three main characters: Mason, Rayber, and Francis. A psychological reading centered on doubling phenomena seems pertinent to this, her second novel, which “turns” on events surrounding Rayber, the psychologist—not that this intensely complex and carefully wrought novel can be finally or easily explained or that we ought to equate the author’s views with those of Rayber. But certainly we ought to heed O’Connor’s statements in her letters: “I really have quite a respect for Freud when he isn’t made into a philosopher” (HB 491).2 We may acknowledge her belief in the “sacred” and still understand
From Flannery O’Connor: New Perspectives, edited by Sura P. Rath and Mary Neff Shaw, pp. 121–38. © 1996 by the University of Georgia Press.
21
22
Suzanne Morrow Paulson
that she does not primarily aim to be a philosopher in her novels. She does aim to understand human nature and modern life. Although she is a religious writer, O’Connor accepts Freudian theory and understands Freudian symbols in her attempt to come to grips with modern times and secular thinkers. Her letters reveal a keen interest in the “doubling” tradition (which includes such writers as Poe, Dostoevsky, Conrad, and Nabokov)—a modern tradition of using “eyes” in the Freudian way. And John T. Irwin’s 1975 study argues that understanding the tradition of the double figure as it relates to Freudian thought rewards the critic desiring a complete understanding of Faulkner, the southern writer O’Connor admired most. O’Connor purposefully drew her characters to render what she calls the “many wills conflicting in one man.”3 Because few critics attend to this aspect of her intention, I will approach The Violent Bear It Away through Freud and the psychology of the divided self to suggest new possibilities for all her work.4 Throughout this novel, O’Connor suggests that old Tarwater cannot transcend the physical self and the bonds of egoistic and narcissistic desires. Pathological, Mason creates Jesus in his own image. Otto Rank’s Freudian interpretation of doubling is apropos; in The Double: A Psychoanalytic Study Rank sees the double figure as “a projected wish fulfillment—and as a reflection of the subject’s narcissism” (30). Jesus is for Mason a manifest double representing his own salvation. Mason declares his transcendence through Jesus, while O’Connor paints his physicality with a vividness that negates any such possibility She draws the would-be prophet in the “bleeding stinking mad shadow of Jesus” (465), a symbol for entrapment and not salvation: “red ropes appear in his face” (335–36) with the death stroke. Even his corpse is trapped, unable to fall because his belly is caught under the breakfast table. O’Connor further defines Mason with imagery of the caged, erotic self: a “bull-like old man,” with “silver protruding eyes that looked like two fish straining to get out of a net” (335). Mason, portrayed as a primitive, unholy, false prophet-father, significantly builds a religion without woman, and any woman in the novel, any fleshly “goddess,” represents sin as well as death. By focusing on the father and excluding worship of the holy mother, O’Connor separates Tarwater’s religion from Catholicism—but beyond that she also suggests his severe ontological insecurity, his fear of death.5 As Joseph Campbell notes in A Hero with a Thousand Faces, the rejection of woman represents the desire to deny one’s origin in the womb and to become the omphalos, that is, to be alive without knowledge of death (129). Any acknowledgment of woman necessitates an acknowledgment of the body and its functions—that men cannot give birth and that women cannot give birth alone. Moreover, physical generation produces the son who perpetuates the Oedipal tragedy.
Apocalypse of Self, Resurrection of the Double
23
Mason’s narcissistic project is to make good his own “rescue” from the “womb-tomb” by repressing his own physicality, by affirming instead his spirituality, and by appointing himself the prophet-creator of a “procreative double,” Francis, who will carry out his “calling.” Mason gives birth to Francis through the rite of baptism and then orders Francis to baptize Rayber’s son, Bishop, a dimwit, if old age or death prevents the crazed uncle from performing this sacrament in his lifetime. Francis carries out the order to baptize Bishop as though the old man were a ghost at his side. Using baptism to extend his boundaries of self like a wall around young Tarwater, Mason simultaneously performs an act of regeneration and murder—to be repeated later when Francis baptizes/murders Bishop. Francis, then, becomes Mason’s “immortal self.” O’Connor informs us that Mason “was a one-notion man” (354), and this is irony at its best when we consider the old man’s psychic fragmentation. Mason is not one, but two—or several—especially as he relates pathologically to Francis, who functions as both son and wife, offering hope for the future as a procreative double and serving as the necessary partner who staves off the loneliness of a solitary existence. Francis provides Mason with a sense of existing, but the great-uncle can tolerate his grandnephew only as a double, not as an independent human being. The fury of Mason’s efforts to save himself through the creation of a prophet-self and a procreative double intensifies each time he encounters the unwanted double, Rayber—the nephew Mason most vehemently denies. O’Connor, though, draws a parallel between them by making both men evangelical zealots. Rayber’s skepticism and Mason’s religious fervor grow out of a narcissistic drive to bolster a weak and deprived sense of self—a fearful self unable to develop meaningful relationships with others. Mason, feeling threatened by Rayber, denies his nephew’s very existence and asserts that he is “Nothing. He’s full of nothing” (366). His sense of emptiness within serves as the precursor of his schizophrenia. He denies the vacuum he feels within his own self by projection—sometimes feeling Rayber’s presence as “Nothing,” and other times, like Rayber, suffering from a pathological sense of being penetrated by a threatening “Other.” The boundaries of Mason’s self waver, sometimes projecting another self outward when he instructs Francis to follow the calling, sometimes experiencing a psychic split within when he accepts orders from the Jesus-voice, and sometimes fearing an intrusion by a completely foreign self when he encounters Rayber. Although we “know that within the territory of ourselves there can be only our footprints” (43)—to borrow a phrase from R. D. Laing’s The Divided Self—Mason feels that Rayber has been “creeping into his soul by the back door” (331). Mason feels not only that Rayber can get into his mind
24
Suzanne Morrow Paulson
but also that by so doing he will be made into “a piece of information inside his head” (339). Rayber’s fears follow the belief in primitive cultures that death results from reproductions of the self in a mirror, photograph, or reflection. Tarwater acts “like he had been killed in his very soul” (345) when Rayber publishes his article on Mason’s pathological state. His sense of an inner void makes him vulnerable to such fears as those that cause obsessive drives toward selfpreservation—or extension of self to encompass the immortal double. Mason, then, relates to others in clear-cut ways (love or hate exclusively). By examining Francis and Rayber from his perspective, we better fathom his psyche. A similar approach to Rayber proves worthwhile because both Mason and Rayber try to generate a procreative double, Francis. Rayber, though, demonstrates a complexity of motivation that Mason lacks: he suffers from a troubled conscience, a sense of guilt, and a profound ambivalence in his relationships to others—simultaneously fearing and seeking Francis, coveting and abhorring Bishop. To understand Rayber’s character and his effect on Francis, we must first examine his similarities to Mason—especially those revealed by the Lucette incident. Moreover, understanding how Rayber differs from Mason and accounting for Bishop’s and Francis’s influence will clarify the threesome at the heart of this novel. Rayber—no less a prophet than Mason but a prophet of death rather than resurrection—tells Francis that men don’t “rise again” (399), wishing to “save” him from the notion of resurrection, from the “mad Jesus.” Likewise, Rayber wishes to “save” the Carmody girl. He feels “some mysterious connection” (414) between himself and Lucette, comparing her case to his own “seduction” (408) by Mason. Doubling here transmogrifies to exploitation of another: Lucette by her parents, himself by his uncle, Francis by his greatuncle. Of course, irony colors our perception of Rayber’s outrage as O’Connor likens Rayber to Mason. Rayber commits the same crime of exploitation by doubling when he attempts to remake Francis. In fact, Rayber’s “fanatical country preacher” side (438) mimes Mason and reveals the narcissistic nature of his endeavors to create a procreative double out of Francis. Much like Mason, Rayber’s “uncontrollable fury” (393) and “fantastic anger” (394) peak when Francis resists his efforts at “reconstruction.” Rayber condemns Mason’s “foolish violence” (377), and yet this accuser is nearly capable of drowning a child. Hypocrisy and narcissism dominate Rayber’s personality. He preaches to Mason about “the real world where there’s no saviour but yourself ” (379) and then advocates the prophet of self to Francis even more fervently because his own identity is at stake. It is soon clear that not only Rayber’s efforts at “reconstruction” but also Mason’s muddied baptismal waters threaten the freedom of Francis, who weakly
Apocalypse of Self, Resurrection of the Double
25
perceives the devil-prophet within them both. Before his return to Rayber, Francis is haunted by images of his past—memories that conflate various versions of his uncle “as if the schoolteacher, like the devil, could take on any look that suited him” (365). Moreover, Francis perceives the resemblance between Mason and Rayber whenever he ponders Rayber’s eyes: “He saw them as dark gray, shadowed with knowledge, and the knowledge moved like tree reflections in a pond where far below the surface shadows a snake may glide and disappear” (365). These shadows of the old man’s bulging, fish eyes (both fish and snakes glide in water) represent sexual sublimation. The snake is hardly visible. Like Mason, Rayber eliminates the female element from his life and sublimates his misogyny, which stems from incestuous wishes as well as a fear of the “womb-tomb.” Guilt results, and he seeks the mother to make amends by marrying Bernice Bishop, a woman twice his age who could produce but half a child. He then finds it necessary to get “rid of his wife” (400). Bishop becomes the wife for Rayber, as Francis did for Mason. The relationship of Rayber and Bishop parallels an illicit marriage between “two bachelors whose habits were so smoothly connected that they no longer needed to take notice of each other” (400). They function, that is, as a “couple,” although not of the usual mixed gender. This same-sex relationship destroys the autonomy of both Rayber and Bishop. Rayber’s psychic problem becomes clear only when we better understand his relationship to Bishop. Rayber sometimes feels “a love for the child so outrageous that he would be left shocked and depressed for days, and trembling for his sanity” (401). Algene Balliff ’s review suggests that latent wishes for homosexual incest cause Rayber’s divided self. He notes how both Francis and Rayber fear penetration by Mason’s “seeds” and how Rayber wishes to avenge his early “seduction” by Mason (360). Rayber’s ambivalent relationship to Bishop began with an ambivalent relationship to Mason. Rayber remarks that he feels a “morbid surge of a love that terrified him” when he thinks of “a stick or a stone, the line of a shadow, the absurd old man’s walk of a starling crossing the sidewalk” (401). He also feels a “longing to have the old man’s eyes—insane, fish-colored—” (401). The stick, the stone, the line, the fish, and the eyes suggest phallic symbols to a wide variety of analytical persuasions from Freud to Lacan. How does Rayber control his “longing”? O’Connor answers that question directly: “He slept in a narrow iron bed, spoke little, and cultivated the dullest of friends.” In short, he lives a half-life of sublimated, incestuous homosexuality “to have any dignity at all” (402). Moreover, the author tells us that Rayber’s “outrageous love” for Bishop is also “irrational and abnormal” (401). Bishop, then, might be defined as Rayber’s seelenspiegel, or double as mirror revealing “the imperfections of his inmost mind and soul,” as Ralph Tymms puts it in another context (Doubles 83). Rayber keenly feels himself
26
Suzanne Morrow Paulson
fragmented and deformed, even confusing his own maimed ear with Bishop’s: “Absently Rayber put his hand on the little boy’s ear . . . his fingers tingling as if they touched the sensitive scar of some old wound” (424)—that is, Rayber’s wound from Mason’s shotgun. Even when comforting his only son, the father’s narcissism intrudes. Francis observes that the idiot child “might have been a deformed part of [Rayber] that had been accidentally revealed” (390). Bishop’s presence stokes the fire that drives Rayber to make of Francis a narcissistic reflection of his own thoughts, thus achieving a sense of wholeness and extending himself in time by establishing a procreative double. Gradually, the reader notices that the inability of human personality to establish a full relationship of communication and love—acceptance of the “other” as a person and not merely as a double—results in a setting devoid of sound. Rayber, Bishop, and Francis all share the same affliction—deafness— during the course of this novel. Rayber is deaf by Mason’s gun, Bishop by an act of God, and “the boy [Francis] for all the interest he showed might have been the one who was deaf. Silent, he viewed everything with the same noncommittal eye” (398). Others have noted the thematic importance of silence in this novel, but no one has realized that a probable source is Freud’s study on repetition—a study that discusses the basis for “the uncanny effect of silence.” Freud explains that our sense of experiencing an event as “uncanny” has to do with the return of the repressed. Silence and deafness, then, signify the return of infantile memories felt as the presence of Mason—an intruding double representing “silent seeds” of madness within Rayber and Francis. Both the nephew and the grandnephew of Mason fear that these “seeds” may open “one at a time” (478) in their blood. Rayber wants to exorcise Francis’s “morbid impulse” to baptize his son—that impulse which he considers a manifestation of the Mason within Francis. Francis therefore represents to Rayber the affliction of having Mason as the devil double within. When Francis enters his house, Rayber feels the presence of Mason: “Rayber had never, even when old Tarwater had lived under his roof, been so conscious of the old man’s presence” (398). Paradoxically, it is the Mason in Francis that Rayber fears and his own double in Francis that he seeks. The boy represents both a promise for immortality as a procreative double and a threat to Rayber’s own sanity as a symbol for Mason. Rayber struggles to save himself by saving Francis: “The eyes [Francis’s] were the eyes of the crazy student father, the personality was the old man’s, and somewhere between the two, Rayber’s own image was struggling to survive” (402). The fact that Francis also represents a fragment of Rayber’s guilt intensifies the schoolteacher’s struggle: Rayber sees “some horror of his dreams take shape before him” (386) in the form of Francis because the boy’s “eyes
Apocalypse of Self, Resurrection of the Double
27
were not his own. They were the student’s eyes, singed with guilt” (392). Who is the one most singed with guilt? Rayber feels guilty because he served as a sort of pimp for his sister, failed to pursue custody of Francis, attempted to murder Bishop, and sublimated his own homosexual urges. How can Rayber claim the power to save Francis when he himself is so riddled with guilt? He bases his claim to strength on the false premise that he has exorcised himself of the old man, something he cannot substantiate. After his assertion of freedom (“I’ve resisted him”), O’Connor undercuts that claim: “He felt a madness on him to talk about the old man” (436). Everyone in this novel wants to destroy or escape from the father figure. Nobody wants to be the responsible father. Rayber’s only genuine opportunity to be the father and the savior is missed. O’Connor relentlessly depicts the isolation of each individual, the unwillingness to make sacrifices for others and to be self-giving. When at long last Francis is receptive, Rayber is unable to transcend the barriers of his own narcissism and fails to offer Francis the helping hand he so desperately needs. Rayber follows Francis through the midnight streets but rejects him when he finally finds him outside the tabernacle—although “the sight of Rayber seemed to afford [Francis] relief amounting to rescue” (415). Rayber’s wooden response to Francis’s need tells us that there is no rescue, no resurrection, no salvation—only collision of warring selves and disintegration. Every double with an open heart meets his shadow with a closed heart. Rayber realizes this the next day when he again approaches Francis—too late; he faces “the glint of a metal door sealed against an intruder” (417). Rayber’s despair reaches its apex when he, too, begins to hear “the voice of a stranger” (407) within. Finally rejecting Francis as double because Mason possesses the boy, Rayber creates his own inner double as a final, desperate compensation. Rayber faces the hopelessness of Tarwater’s schizoid self with a schism of his own psyche into “a violent and a rational self ” (417), an inner and outer voice. The schoolteacher’s story ends with Bishop’s drowning— severing the all-too-tenuous threads of his psyche. Without Bishop, Rayber cannot live with his own guilt. Being lost themselves, both Rayber and Mason direct the explosive force of their actions toward Francis. Their struggle to survive decimates their nephew. Whereas the patterns of doubling that Rayber and Mason typify are for the most part other-dependent, Francis tries to fortify his psychic energies independently. He must build the integrity of his own inner self while defending that self against intrusion by those who would remake him. To preserve his identity, he constantly battles against Mason and Rayber. Finally, Francis cannot develop his own personality because other ruthless personalities crash the soundless barrier of his consciousness. Tracing Francis’s enormous
28
Suzanne Morrow Paulson
struggle to expel Rayber and Mason—especially Mason’s compulsion to baptize Bishop—will reveal that this novel ends by depicting a shattered form of Francis’s psyche, a form that seems to absorb the identity of his two uncles and thus is lost. Early in this novel, O’Connor establishes a relationship of doubling between Francis and the old man’s corpse. The boy’s visage is skeletal and ancient as he goes about the “bidnis” of burying his uncle. That he is double for a corpse foreshadows his psychological death—his ultimate possession by his great-uncle: “His cheekbones protruded, narrow and thin like the arms of a cross, and the hollows under them had an ancient look as if the child’s skeleton beneath were as old as the world” (360). Mason’s corpse forms an alien double within Francis. Laing describes a similar sense of alien personality traits “embedded as pieces of shrapnel in the body” (105). The “corpse” later pursues Francis in the form of Bishop. Francis struggles to exorcise the father-corpse to save himself. Mason as double within (and in Bishop as double without) acts as the primary force that overwhelms O’Connor’s protagonist, who tries to overcome the father and the facts of death not by creating an immortal self in the form of a procreative double like Rayber and Mason but by making of himself a god. For one thing, he clings to the idea of being an orphan born in a wreck because this makes him unique. He strives to attain epic proportions and hopes to transcend the anonymous crowd. As a result, he believes he evades the usual male–female conception. He rejects the father much in the same way that Mason and Rayber deny the mother and for the same reasons. Indeed, the circumstances of Francis’s birth as he is extracted from his mother’s dead body seem miraculous, while paradoxically reinforcing the impression that he was doomed from the start. When Rayber tells Francis, “You have a father,” he responds by feeling “some unspeakable outrage” (407). Having a father exposes his physicality and his mortality, thus undermining his claims to special conception. Being born from the “womb of a whore” is a perverse parody of the virgin birth of Christ; Francis acts “as if he were declaring a royal birth” (407).6 Similarly, escaping school is equated with escape from mortality. It was “the surest sign of his election” to study the prophets “who escaped death” (340). He accepts his great-uncle’s religion when it includes “strange beasts with giant wings of fire” (334), but he rejects it when there is “no fire in his uncle’s eyes and [when] he spoke only of the sweat and stink of the cross, of being born to die” (334). After Mason’s death, when Francis expects “to hear a voice from on high, he hears instead the sounds of “a hen scratching beneath him” (337)—unintelligible sounds that point to his solitariness. The upper, fantasized world of the numinous universe comes crashing down when
Apocalypse of Self, Resurrection of the Double
29
the voice of the despairing imagination rejects the uncommunicative chicken grubbing in the ground. Francis creates instead its own shadow-voice. He straddles two realities—a fantasized, private inner landscape and the all-tooreal, external, public “other”—until he slips and falls into the mad world of his old uncle. Francis attempts to act when all those around him are attempting to make him act for them. The essence of his struggle poignantly emerges as he looks into the fountain pool at his wavering reflection “trying to form itself ” (432)—the barriers of self, unsteady and unclear. O’Connor grounds Francis’s inability to establish a secure identity in his compulsion to baptize Bishop. This compulsion, of course, was implanted by Mason. Upon the death of old Tarwater, Francis hopes to be reborn and to build a new self. There seems to be hope for a new start early in the novel when Francis approaches the womb of the city, saying: “I’m just now waking up” (363), but he then mistakes the city lights for the burning shack. This rebirth is “earmarked” by death as surely as Rayber was “earmarked” by Mason. The Mason within lives, and the city ahead represents death as surely as the shack behind. The journey to the city appears to be an escape from Mason, but nonetheless, he is everywhere along the way. Meeks, the nameless auto-carrier driver, and the rapist are objective, “double-by-duplication” character fragments of Mason—creations O’Connor meant to further define the relationship between Francis and Mason.7 In other words, Francis journeys to his uncle’s house and along the way meets the salesman, Meeks, who represents the preaching and teaching side of Mason—not to mention the voice of the community promoting societal mandates to attend school and participate in the community. His words fall on the sleeping boy as his great-uncle’s ignored sermons often fell when the boy was busy dreaming out the window. Like Tarwater, Meeks plans to teach the boy something whether he is receptive or not. He preaches the merits of love and work while disclaiming: “I’m not going to be a preacher to you” (380). Then on his way home, Francis serves the auto-carrier driver as he served Mason in that he needs the boy to hang on to consciousness so as not to crash, much as Mason needed Francis to give him a sense of existing. Both relationships are purely narcissistic. Finally, near Powderhead Francis encounters the man in the lavender shirt. When they first meet, O’Connor tells us that the boy saw “something familiar to him” (469), perhaps suggesting both Rayber and Mason, as well as their latent homosexuality that finds expression in this incident. Francis burns the place of the rape just as he burned Mason’s shack. The rapist takes Francis’s hat just as Mason and Rayber both attempted to appropriate a fragment of his self.8
30
Suzanne Morrow Paulson
Thus Francis struggles to expel both the will of the old man and that of his uncle. When Francis returns to Rayber, he observes: “His uncle’s face was so familiar to him that he might have seen it every day of his life” (386), perhaps even in the mirror. He brags that he burned the old man just as Rayber would have done it. And in the end, he completes the job Rayber started when he attempted to drown his own son.9 To resist becoming the double of Rayber, Francis keeps his distance from the schoolteacher, maintains his isolation, and protects himself from his uncle’s penetrating eyes, ironically becoming more and more the Mason who isolated himself at Powderhead. Francis also becomes more and more like Mason in that he fears penetration by Rayber, worriedly asserting: “I’m free . . . outside your head. I ain’t in it” (400). Francis cannot escape becoming a character fragment of both Rayber and Mason. When Rayber takes the boy to Cherokee Lodge hoping to win him over, Francis envisions the lake as a baptismal site. Then at the lodge, Rayber’s face appears in Francis’s mirror. The confused boy notices his own “weakness working itself up from his knees [and forcing] . . . a tremor in his jaw” (434), like the tremors that typify Rayber. Bishop additionally threatens Francis. The reader wonders whether Francis makes a captive of Bishop, or Bishop captures Francis? Although Rayber concludes “that it was Bishop who had . . . made the capture” (452), the interactions of these cousins go beyond a mere power struggle. The first description of Bishop bears a striking resemblance to that of Francis: Bishop: His eyes were slightly sunken beneath his forehead and his cheekbones were lower than they should have been. He stood there, dim and ancient, like a child who had been a child for centuries. (388) Francis: His cheekbones protruded, narrow and thin, like the arms of a cross, and the hollows under them had an ancient look as if the child’s skeleton beneath were old as the world. (360)
Bishop’s “ancient look” haunts Francis as a symbol for the old man’s will, which he fears yet compulsively obeys. The old man finally gets into everybody. His resemblance to Bishop unnerves both Francis and Rayber. At the lodge, it becomes evident just how much Mason has penetrated Francis when the boy writes “in an old man’s meticulous hand” (425). After Francis murders Bishop, the disturbed boy again sees the old man’s bulging, “fishcolored” (461) eyes. He seeks a sense of true self by murdering the person who represents his devil self, and in that very act he becomes a confirmed slave to Mason.
Apocalypse of Self, Resurrection of the Double
31
Francis’s progress toward madness can be most clearly traced in his relationship to the strange voice that Francis hears when he digs his great-uncle’s grave at the start of this novel—a “voice” announcing the coming of Francis’s psychic split. The crack of the anguished self manufactures its own balm to soothe its sense of isolation, but the balm allows the two selves to slide apart. The creation of “another” voice marks the concluding stages of madness well documented in the literature on doubling.10 In Part 3, O’Connor manages surreal effects when she renders Francis’s struggle to repress his “momentous failure” (457) by asserting that he has been “tried in the fire of his refusal, with all the old man’s fancies burnt out of him” (464). The language and imagery of his denial contradict his claim: if he were truly rid of the old man’s thoughts (often expressed by infernal imagery), he would not be speaking in terms of “fire of his refusal” or “fancies burnt out of him.” The inner voice transmogrifies from friend or “the wise voice that sustained him” (429) to “adversary” (475). Francis burns his alter ego, clarifying the extent of his failure to exorcise Mason: he devastates his other self with fire, Mason’s element. Culminating in the image of the “crater opening inside him” (476), the apocalyptic imagery in the last pages of this novel implies the final and complete resurrection of Mason in the form of the devil-double within Francis. The significance of the seemingly apocalyptic world does not register beyond each isolated, individual psyche. The Negro Buford senses only “a burning in the atmosphere” (477). He observes but is not singed. O’Connor here affirms man’s ultimate isolation and the reality that there is no ground without a grave somewhere nearby. And where in this novel is that ground sacred? The complex patterns of doubling form an iron mesh that traps Francis. In spite of O’Connor’s belief in personal responsibility, this novel acknowledges the forces of psychological determinism.11 This is not to say that Francis lacked the freedom to struggle against the forces that undid him. O’Connor declares in her letters: “You might make a case of sorts for Tarwater being determined since his great uncle has expressly trained him to be a prophet . . . but actually neither of them [Rayber or Francis] exhibits a lack of free will . . . an absence of conflict . . . they spend all their time fighting within themselves, drive against drive” (HB 488). By emphasizing the divided self here, I do not finally wish to undermine the importance of other approaches to O’Connor’s work. Theology and philosophy ought to play a role in any analysis of her art. And yet her primary aim in this particular novel is to explore the suffering and psychology of a child and those who shaped that child. This suffering was perhaps partly caused by living in the modern world devoid of true faith, but more important, the suffering in this case was caused by parental abuse.
32
Suzanne Morrow Paulson
That O’Connor so clearly represents the psychological realities and the inner landscapes of her characters bespeaks her intense compassion for them. Often, she objected to those who viewed her characters as if through “a glassbottomed boat” (HB 376). The author is demanding here that her reader experience sympathetically what her characters experience. We ought to feel sympathy not only for Francis but also for Mason. It is in this sense that she declares she is “right behind him [Mason] 100 percent.”12 Her assertion (HB 536) that Mason speaks the truth does not necessarily imply that his actions are divinely inspired. The irony that obtains when an evil character speaks the “truth” because an author wishes to emphasize a point is common enough in modern literature. We should not let O’Connor’s statements about Mason mislead us into assuming, as Martha Stephens does, that the author approves of Mason’s basic character (108). Another statement of this sort about another evil character in a neglected story, “The Partridge Festival,” clarifies O’Connor’s position: “I am all for Singleton in this, devil though I rightly consider him to be” (HB 443). O’Connor suggests that acknowledging man’s capacity for deviltry and accepting it as human, not alien, enables a person to “face his own psychic realities” (HB 382), exactly Freud’s goal during therapy. O’Connor studies will always be an arena for debate, given her paradoxical religious stand and yet her interest in Freudian psychology—her pious assertion that she is “against [Freud] tooth and toenail” and yet her willingness “to admit certain uses for [Freud]” (HB 110). This underlying conflict is expressed again and again in her letters and manuscripts. For example, she says that we ought to “love everything and specifically Christ” (HB 484) but admits to feeling a “lack of love for the race of man” (HB 335). How can anyone claim to solve the dilemma of what O’Connor intended?13 As the pain of living with disease gave way to the pain of facing death, O’Connor’s work and her attitude toward it underwent constant revision. Where we ought to expect her work to yield most fully and easily to religious interpretation—that is, in a novel rife with biblical references and one that even quotes the Bible in the title—she proves most resistant. What we can finally assert is that the value of The Violent Bear It Away depends on its insights into human nature and what it reveals about the psychology of the divided self. Her other works offer a rich store of possibilities for further analysis in this vein.
No t e s 1. In “Novelist and Believer” O’Connor affirms that the “sacred consciousness” of the author “will inevitably suggest that image of ultimate reality as it can be glimpsed in the human situation” (MM 158).
Apocalypse of Self, Resurrection of the Double
33
2. Although O’Connor may have said that “a Freudian could read this novel and explain it all on the basis of Freud” (HB 343) with tongue in cheek—and she certainly would not approve of the reductive notion that God is wish fulfillment—still she was familiar with Freud’s work and probably attracted to his focus on narcissism and self-awareness. 3. O’Connor’s preface to Wise Blood here quoted seems to contradict what she says in Mystery and Manners: “[In Francis’s] compulsion to be a prophet . . . there is the mystery of God’s will . . . not a compulsion in the clinical sense. [And then she hedges.] However, this is a complicated subject and requires to be elucidated by someone with more learning than I have” (116). Many have been misled by the earlier part of this quote. The fact is that O’Connor exhibits a definite interest in Freud, even acknowledging that for her first novel, Wise Blood, “the Oedipus business comes nearer home” (AM 68) than other sources. Needless to say, I disagree with earlier critics (cf. Martha Stephens’s Question of Flannery O’Connor) that see her as a writer of “nothing . . . except pure religious passion” (131). 4. Most of the critics dealing with O’Connor’s “double” figures lack a psychoanalytic perspective (Kahane and Rosenfield are exceptions): see Donald Gregory, “Enoch Emery: Ironic Doubling in Wise Blood ”; Claire Rosenfield, “The Shadow Within: The Conscious and Unconscious Use of the Double”; Albert Sonnenfeld, “Flannery O’Connor: The Catholic Writer as Baptist”; and Marion Montgomery, “Cloaks and Hats and Doubling in Poe and Flannery O’Connor.” In “Comic Vibrations and Self-Construction in Grotesque Literature,” Claire Kahane points out that Enoch Emery mirrors Hazel Motes and relates doubling phenomena to the uncanny in the manner of Freud. An early review in Commentary, October 1960, by Algene Balliff, considers Tarwater’s “double” traditionally, conceiving of the boy as halfangel, half-devil, thus neglecting psychological doubles, although Balliff ’s insights regarding Rayber’s split seem sound. 5. I am indebted to Professor Chester G. Anderson’s lectures on double fictions (April 1975, the University of Minnesota, Minneapolis). 6. See Otto Rank, The Myth of the Birth of the Hero, for an analysis of how the virgin and holy births are connected in myth and pseudo-history as well as in childhood fantasies. 7. Ralph Tymms points out that “an essential distinction is to be made between the double-by-duplication and the double-by-division, though these distinct psychological approaches constantly mingle” (16). 8. The manuscripts collected at the Ina Dillard Russell Library in Mill edgeville reveal O’Connor’s ongoing interest in homosexuality. In one early draft of Wise Blood, Hazel seems to be trying to convince Leora Watts, a prostitute, that he is sexually experienced: “No,” he said, “you are not the first. I was ten years old,” he said, “and it wasn’t a girl. It was a boy named Ford Tester.” “You’re making that up,” she said. . . . Her eyes were dark and mocking, and he tried to see down into them. “There’s nothing under them,” he said. “There was nothing under this boy’s either.” “Them what?” she muttered. “You needn’t liken me to any filthy kid you jerked off.” “His eyes were clogged up,” he said. “They looked like puss.”
34
Suzanne Morrow Paulson
In another example, a scoutmaster tries to interest one of his scouts in sex: “Johnson went forward quickly as if he had been hit on the legs from behind and when he was in reach the master caught him by the shoulder and propelled him with one push into the dark far end of the loft. Then he strode after him and disappeared. B. K. could hear their voices but not the words. He could make out Johnson’s hat and his shoulder with the master scout’s fingers clutched around it. The hand moved back and forth suddenly as if the shoulder were a broken ear. It was thrusting in and out, then he heard Johnson whine, ‘Lemme be, I ain’t going to do it’ ” (Folders 168c–168f). The master scout in other versions of this incident is called the Misfit. Rayber’s behavior in “The Barber” also should be seen in this context. The story starts with a barber asking Rayber, “You a nigger-lover?” in relation to the election of Darmon, a liberal. Rayber then notices the black helper, George, and wonders “what George’s leanings were. He was a trim-looking boy” (CS 16). 9. Robert Rogers sees the case in which one character completes what another started as a special case of doubling. 10. E. T. A. Hoffmann, Georg Büchner, and Fyodor Dostoevsky exploit the idea of the “figment” voice in their doubling fictions about madness. 11. In “Psychological Determinism and Freedom in Flannery O’Connor,” Nancy B. Barcus offers some insights on this issue and on Freudian elements in this novel, explaining that Rayber “has homosexual urges toward his idiot child, who somehow reminds him of the old man” (30). 12. Hicks, “A Writer at Home,” 22. 13. For a discussion of character fragments, condensation, decomposition, and the “composite mind of the author,” as related to the author’s intention, see Rogers, 67.
L aurence E njolras
Intellectuals and Would-Be Artists
F
lannery O’Connor’s skillful use of deft and chilling irony is best demonstrated in her characterization of intellectuals and would-be artists. In five of her stories, she introduces bachelors and spinsters in their thirties who live the agony of being fully dependent on mothers whose values and petty concerns they loathe, mothers whom they can neither love nor leave, mothers because of whom they have turned into angry, isolated, impotent individuals. These smarter, frustrated individuals are trapped in a conflicting situation in which they see themselves as victims. However, as the author craftily shows, in reality they are all failures, ineffectual creatures who have deluded themselves in thinking that they know something, possess something, or can achieve something. The full irony of their situation lies in the fact that they blame their mother or their entourage for what they have become, while the core of their frustration rests in their ego. Hating the life they have to live, scorning their families, they have for the most part never made a move to escape; when they have, it was only to discover their inability to manage by themselves. Riveted to their mothers because of a weakness of body or of character, which renders them all the more furious, they turn to a world of pretense in which they suffer their martyrdom while shutting out everything that they find unbearable around them. Invariably, their ivory towers prove to be equally vulnerable shelters: in climactic instances in which they
From Flannery O’Connor’s Characters, pp. 43–58. © 1998 by University Press of America.
35
36
Laurence Enjolras
are given to realize their uselessness and ridiculousness, their fragile worlds collapse, living them aghast, compelled to confront reality. In each tale, the youths’ illusive quest for values, their artistic humanism, or their deceitful identities are suddenly annihilated, and they must accept what their true nature really is, something which they have been denying all along. Joy Hopewell, in “Good Country People,” is the perfect stereotype of the intellectual. At thirty-two, she has hardly allowed herself much fun and pleasure. Highly educated, holding a Ph.D. in philosophy, she spends her time reading or retreated in her thoughts in order to avoid her mother’s affable but commonplace and mediocre conversation; she tolerates other people around only for the sake of being spared the drudgery of having to pace the farm with her mother, for she dislikes nature anyway and hates anything related to it. She cannot help being rude to everybody because of the smugness and vanity she senses in people. She has never approached young men whom she finds invariably stupid; besides, she is all mind and cannot imagine herself touched by the matters of the heart. Through the years, she has managed to make herself the personification of hatred: endowed with a sullen disposition, she has a naturally ungracious appearance which she will not even try to improve with a smile; she has a wooden leg which she stomps heavily to make it more blatant; to round off the ugliness of her character, she has legally changed her name to Hulga, one she feels best fits her on account of its ugly sound and the connotations attached to it. The rage which eats her encompasses everything, including herself, and, unable to see anything positive or pleasant in life, she wants at least to make sure people know the conclusion she has come to, even if she cannot succeed in imposing it on them. However, in the course of a few hours, this solid, fierce, knowledgeable, all-too-sure maiden is shocked into recognizing her own self-deception, a discovery ironically provoked by a simple, innocent-looking Bible salesman who tricks her ruthlessly. The blow dealt to her is subtly and progressively orchestrated. At first, with domineering superiority, she despises Manley Pointer whom she takes for a simple country boy fool enough to be concerned with the Scriptures, while she has declared herself an atheist long ago. But on seeing him to the gate, she lets herself be talked into a picnic for the morrow. At this point, readers’ suspicion is aroused as to what may be the first sign of a weakness that will later prove to be fatal, all the more so that, part of the night, she dreams of seducing the young boy, and that she goes to their rendezvous with whatever touch of femininity a whiff of Vapex used for perfume may impart. Once they are together, the boy flatters her in a deceitfully childlike way, and she vainly believes that he admires her. His kisses are so sweet, so innocent, his speech so genuine, his manners so awkward, that with full lucidity, amused detachment, and a trace of pity, she
Intellectuals and Would-Be Artists
37
considers him like a baby she fancies for an instant to educate, to enlighten, and to rid of his blindfolds in order to bring him to “a deeper understanding of life” (p. 284). All of a sudden, though, the embryonic romance turns into a sadistic scene in which Joy-Hulga, who has surrendered completely to the boy by permitting him to take off her wooden leg, and, by so doing, has abandoned her very being to his care, is cruelly flouted when out of a hollow Bible he has been carrying in his suitcase he exhibits a flask of whiskey and a deck of obscene cards. Moreover, once he has disclosed his true nature to her, assuring her that selling Bibles does not necessarily imply believing in the Bible, he runs away with her wooden leg which, he says, will enlarge his collection of “interesting things” that includes “a woman’s glass eye” (p. 291) among other things. Left alone in the full intensity of the blow she has been given, with the terrible revelation delivered to her: “you ain’t so smart. I been believing in nothing ever since I was born!” (p. 291), Joy-Hulga slowly realizes that she has been violently wrenched from her fragile pedestal. In Julian, the protagonist of “Everything That Rises Must Converge,” Flannery O’Connor has drawn a devastating portrait of a young, white, liberal Southerner torn between his unavowed longing for a past era and the certainty that it was one of wrongdoing, all the while finding the new one as repugnant and as insufferable in its low moral, intellectual, aesthetical, and social dimensions. Desperately trying to distinguish himself from everything which he hates in the South, he turns his wild hostility towards his mother who openly carries all the clichés of speech and manners (as to racism or class distinction, for instance) that she and the majority of her peers have not yet overcome. Sensitive, educated, with a dubious future as writer in front of him—while ironically reduced to sell typewriters in the meantime—depressed because of what he must confront, Julian can only retreat into the protecting bubble of his mind where he is free to see and condemn, and where he feels safe from any external judgment. His idealized image of himself is nonetheless very much threatened by self-doubt and self-pity, two feelings which prevent him from engaging in any creative or even relevant action. Every one of his attempts to assert his desire for integration turns awkwardly flat or takes tinges of sentimentalism. Wanting to teach his mother a lesson, he imagines all kinds of situations in which she would be so shocked that she would finally learn from her fundamental errors. Scenarios rush through his mind, which include getting a Negro doctor to save her from a desperate illness, befriending respectable Negro lawyers or distinguished Negro professors, bringing home a Negro fiancée, or demonstrating as a sympathizer at a sit-in. His efforts are miserable attempts which fall short of expectation. For instance, during the bus ride, when he deliberately addresses the Negro who is sitting next to him with the mere intention of disturbing his mother, his gesture of
38
Laurence Enjolras
liberalism has an adverse effect: it only seems an annoyance to the Negro since the light he has asked for is of no service because of the “No smoking” sign posted over the door—furthermore, he has quit smoking some months before, unable to afford it any longer. Ironically, to Julian’s dismay, despite her condescension and racist feelings for the entire Black race, it is his mother who succeeds in establishing a friendly contact with a little Negro boy, playing hide-and-seek with him through her fingers. In Julian’s case, the pathos of his situation lies in the fact that he has genuinely convinced himself that he is emotionally free from his mother, that he can judge her with superior objectivity, that he is in no way dominated by her. It is all too obvious that these are only illusions. As a matter of fact, he is kept ineffectual and paralyzed by his unavowed emotional as well as physical dependence on her. Thus his life is a hopeless struggle against his confused feelings of guilt and frustration, of love for his mother and hatred for what she represents, of apparent detachment from human contacts and domination by them. In the final scene of the story, not only his mother, but he, too, learns his lesson. Rejoicing that she should at last realize facts in their blatant reality, ready to provide her with an explanation of their meaning, Julian’s triumph is but very short: as his mother collapses to her death on the pavement, he suddenly comprehends the full horror of his own new and complete isolation, his tragic abandonment into a world hostile to him, a world highly detestable in which he now will necessarily meet his own symbolical death in the form of his innate inarticulateness and useless, albeit remorseful grief. “The Enduring Chill” is a story which presents the progression of the inner crisis a young intellectual is undergoing just before his death which he thinks imminent, and the anticlimactic moment of revelation which suddenly destroys the sentimental world of illusions and sufferings he has created for himself when he realizes that he is not to die yet. Like every other young intellectual protagonist portrayed by Flannery O’Connor, Asbury is ill-tempered, sullen, egotistical, verbally aggressive, rude, spiteful, and highly disappointed in a family whose members he finds banal, stupid, and narrowminded. Smarter and shrewder, he also has an artistic temperament and a liberal mind which make it all the more difficult for him to cope with and to accept the coarseness he witnesses around him. Despising his rural background, he has gone to New York, convinced that he could meet true culture there as well as enlightened minds to converse with. Soon, seriously ill, out of a job and penniless, he is forced to come back to the family farm in the South to wait for his death, which he presumes to be close, but which will at least put an end to the moral agony he is sure to have to endure in the meantime. We learn that when he arrives, his self-assurance has just been dealt a serious blow, and that the false identity he has created upon assumed talents
Intellectuals and Would-Be Artists
39
which he has progressively been obliged to recognize as illusory is taking blurred contours. The caustic prediction of his pragmatic sister that “Asbury can’t write so he gets sick. He’s going to be an invalid instead of an artist . . . all he’s going to be around here for the next fifty years is a decoration” (p. 373) is indeed a true one, which Asbury tries in vain to ignore or refute, but which he faces more and more acutely every day. Unable to write or to create anything, he violently puts the blame on his mother, vehemently accusing her of a pernicious influence which turned him into the failure he is. The discovery of his shortcomings is a painful one indeed. Unable to unleash his despair openly to his mother, though, he has written her a long letter which he hopes will make her realize what part she had to play in his tragedy: I came here [New York] to escape the slave’s atmosphere of home, . . . to find freedom, to liberate my imagination, to take it like a hawk from its cage and set it “whirling off into the widening gyre” (Yeats) and what did I find? It was incapable of flight. It was some bird you had domesticated, sitting huffy in its pen, refusing to come out! . . . I have no imagination. I have no talent. I can’t create. I have nothing but the desire for these things. Why didn’t you kill that too? Woman, why did you pinion me? (p. 364)
Like Julian’s, Asbury’s feelings are of a conflicting nature. He feels scorn for his mother’s vapidity, impatience for her maternal care which he finds excessive, hatred for her ego which he believes is destroying him, contempt for her lack of liberalism, self-loathing for his dependence on her, and a global devastating rage for everything that concerns her from far or near. Despite his obsessing fury, however, he is left paralyzed, with his wrath burning inside him, because of some mysterious bond which prevents him from ever attacking her directly. The conflict is entirely kept within the confines of his mind, as this is the only way he can pour forth bitter invectives against her. Only after his death will she discover the details of his living agony spelled out in the letter left for her. In reality, Asbury’s ego, not his mother, is the sole instrument of his destruction. He is a failure in whatever he tries, for his convictions are inadequate, but instead of searching himself for the reasons of that inadequacy, he sees himself as the sad victim of an order around him that has gone entirely wrong. The point of self-recognition is close, though; a first hint is given when, upon his arrival on the farm, he crosses the dull gaze of a cow “watching him steadily as if she sensed some bond between them” (p. 362); later, in a dream in which he visualizes his impending burial, with Art come to pay him his due tribute, he awakes with a shudder at the image of a “large white [cow], violently spotted, . . . softly licking his head as
40
Laurence Enjolras
if it were a block of salt” (p. 374). In addition, Asbury’s ultimate attempt to experience a last “moment of communion when the difference between black and white is absorbed into nothing” (p. 368) and racism completely annihilated, turns into a miserable failure and proves once and for all that communication with the black hired help on the farm is impossible. Furthermore, Father Finn, a Jesuit he has asked over to have a last intellectual talk before his death, proves to be different from the person he expected: unconcerned with literature, he is obsessed with prayers and catechism and delivers an accusatory sentence: “The Holy Ghost will not come until you see yourself as you are—a lazy ignorant conceited youth!” (p. 377). Ironically, the last stroke which crowns this series of steps towards lucidity is given him by his mother and Block, the family doctor, the two persons whose common sense and practical qualities he has been despising throughout his life with superior distrust; in a humorous instant, when Block delivers his diagnosis of Asbury’s illness, triumphantly assuring that “undulant fever [will] keep coming back but . . . won’t kill [him],” comparing it with “Bang’s in a cow” (p. 381), the youth is left ranting and aghast at the sight of the bright intense smiling face of his mother and at the simultaneous collapse of all his illusions. We may suspect that the violent anticlimax, which sweeps away his fancies of a romantic death that would have delivered him from the misunderstanding of his family and pals, while unfolding his own real nature in front of him, makes him envision a new life, together with newly emerging values. Calhoun, the protagonist of “The Partridge Festival” is another example, like Asbury, of a young adolescent who has deluded himself about his talents and has created a false identity for himself; despite many evidences to the contrary, he persists in believing that he is an artist, a sensitive nature full of humanism, and that he is the only one among the people he lives with to correctly interpret the different manifestations of human behavior as well as to understand the meaning of life. Like the other youths mentioned previously, he likes to think that he is free in his doings and judgments. To be able to devote a large part of his time to art in general and writing in particular, he spends every summer busily selling all kinds of things, thus making money to afford independence the other three seasons. The fact that he is extremely good at selling, that he genuinely enjoys doing it, that he has been given an achievement scroll for his performance as a salesman casts a slightly unpleasant shadow on his ego which he would like to envision totally detached from anything material, above all from all petty concerns. He resolutely refuses any trace of resemblance with his late great-uncle whom he holds in contempt for his practical turn of mind and his calculating, businesslike character. Instead, the boy creates a fanciful portrait of himself after the image of Singleton, a murderer whose photograph in the newspaper has fevered his imagination.
Intellectuals and Would-Be Artists
41
To him, Singleton is a victim of society to whom he is determined to do justice by writing a novel in which he will denounce the cruelty of the social system responsible for the man’s sufferings and tragedy. Imbued with notions such as individualism, nonconformism, depth of character, and intellectual superiority, he walks the festive streets of the town where the shooting has taken place, trying in vain to collect manifestations of the townspeople’s sympathy for Singleton, trying with equal uselessness to impose his own perception of him on the resentful inhabitants. However, such blatantly unanimous animosity on their part does not succeed in shaking his opposite convictions. Prompted by the girl next door whose sense of justice has been similarly injured by the whole case, he sets out with her to the State Hospital to confront the object of his artistic and humanistic delirium. Just before Singleton is introduced to them, Calhoun and Mary Elizabeth, whose hostility and scorn for one another have been high up to this point in the story, feel a sudden kinship overflow them in anticipation of the importance of the revelation that awaits them. The revelation proves to be important indeed, but hardly of the nature they expected. In front of them appears a hideous, gesticulating character who casts leering glances at the girl and utters suggestive remarks to her. The encounter does much to provide the two youths with an unequivocal representation of Singleton’s true nature. Shocked by the frightening show, with their illusions and ideals suddenly destroyed, they understand the full extent of their initial error. Back on the road, exhausted after so intense an emotion, Calhoun pulls the car up the side of the highway; the sight of the reflection of his face in Mary Elizabeth’s glasses precipitates his self-recognition: it is not an artist, but the master salesman he has always been who looks back at him triumphantly. As is to be expected, the portrayal of these intellectuals and would-be artists is not gratuitous. For all the irony which shrouds it, O’Connor’s point is clear: idealizing their own selves, creating fallacious identities which they praise, blinding themselves with the conviction of their superiority over their fellow men, adoring secular gods, such as Art, these heathen are on the wrong path because they see themselves as the center of a universe they interpret with erroneous values. They do satisfy Josephine Hendin’s characterization of Flannery O’Connor’s protagonists, whom she perceives as follows: Demanding neither hope nor salvation, O’Connor’s heroes need only certainty. And all they can know absolutely, “know for sure,” is isolation, rage, and death.1
Self-imposed, indeed, because self-created, isolation is their lot; a rage devastates them; and a symbolical death—the death of their old ego—awaits
42
Laurence Enjolras
them and strikes them in an intense moment of enlightenment regarding their real nature, which turns out to be common rather than unique. The author’s treatment of this type of character is different from her treatment of other types: their encounter with God or their sudden awareness of the universe in religious terms is not a direct one. Instead of learning about the presence and power of God, thus realizing the insignificance of human beings before the Divine, they discover the pettiness of their character, their vanity, their arrogance and their smugness only in reference to their own self. Of course, in the process, they learn Christian behavior, gain Christian qualities, discover what humility, charity, and altruism are, and they will eventually understand what religious connotations and implications these notions carry. However, whereas the presence of God has been revealed to the children or to the conceited, self-righteous people we have dealt with previously, it is not immediately revealed to the intellectuals or would-be artists: they will first approach it, then will discover it only after a necessary trudging along the path of Christianity has taken place. Ultimately, though, they will learn the same lesson as other characters portrayed in the stories, and will be given the opportunity to discriminate between human nature, human matters, human vulnerability, human uncertainty, human damnation on earth, and supernatural, almighty Divinity. With this category of characters, O’Connor has pushed irony to the extreme, for she has chosen to create her intellectuals and would-be artists as declared atheists. Such a device, blatant as it may be, is nonetheless a powerful one.
No t e 1. Josephine Hendin, The World of Flannery O’Connor (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1970): 37.
J o y ce C arol O ates
The Action of Mercy
I see from the standpoint of Christian orthodoxy. . . . For me the meaning of life is centered in our Redemption of Christ and what I see in the world I see in relation to that. Flannery O’Connor, “The Fiction Writer and His Country”
O
riginally published in The Kenyon Review in Spring 1955, and reprinted in A Good Man Is Hard to Find (1956), this graceful, parable-like short story, with its precise, weighted language and its comically sympathetic rural Georgians, Mr. Head and his ten-year-old grandson Nelson, is virtually unique in Flannery O’Connor’s oeuvre, ending not in violent death, nor even in devastating irony, but with tenderness. O’Connor’s more characteristic prose fiction bristles with cruel and sometimes savagely funny observations; “The Artificial Nigger” is comedy of another order. Because they are an old man (Mr. Head at sixty behaves rather more like a man in his mid-seventies) and a young boy (though Nelson is a “miniature old man”), the grandfather and grandson are presented as sinners of a mild, entirely human sort. Mr. Head is foolishly proud and vain (“Mr. Head could have said . . . that age was a choice blessing and that only with years does a man enter into that calm understanding of life that makes him a suitable guide for the young”) and Nelson is impudent, vain, and quarrelsome (“ . . . the boy’s look was ancient, as if he knew everything already and would From Kenyon Review 20, no. 1 (Winter 1998): 157–60. © 1998 by Kenyon Review.
43
44
Joyce Carol Oates
be pleased to forget it”). These are genial cartoonish figures, country bumpkins to be subjected to O’Connor’s typical ritual of humbling, unmasking, and redemption. On its surface, “The Artificial Nigger” is a straightforward story, hardly more than an amusing anecdote: a back-country grandfather takes his grandson to Atlanta for a day visit with the secret intention of showing the child that “he had no cause for pride merely because he had been born in a city . . . [Nelson would] see everything there was to see in a city so that he would be content to stay at home for the rest of his life.” In Atlanta, the two become lost, quarrel; Mr. Head frightens Nelson by hiding from him, and then denying that Nelson is his grandson, when the child desperately needs him; Nelson is furious with Mr. Head and refuses to speak to him; at last, exhausted by their adventure, and having no one but each other, the two are reconciled; they return to their rural home, with Nelson determined never to journey to Atlanta again. There is a situation-comedy slickness to this resolution, which would seem to undercut the boy’s discovery of blacks and his attraction to them; he seems to have reverted to his grandfather’s ways, unilluminated by his grandfather’s religious vision. Beneath the anecdotal surface, however, the story moves toward what O’Connor calls “an action of mercy”— the mysterious operation of grace in the characters’ lives, intersecting as they do with both “real” and “artificial” Negroes, bringing Mr. Head to an eloquent epiphany that presumably changes his life and his subsequent attitude toward his grandson, himself, and God: He saw that no sin was too monstrous for him to claim as his own, and since God loved in proportion as He forgave, he felt ready at that instant to enter Paradise.
Since there has been little to prepare us for Mr. Head’s vision, little to suggest that he is a man deeply immersed in Christian orthodoxy and the Bible, this turn of mind is not very convincing; but “The Artificial Nigger” like O’Connor’s fiction generally is not meant to be realistic. Suffused with Catholic ideology, or in any case a passionate wish to believe in Christ and salvation by way of the Roman Catholic Church, Flannery O’Connor is the most visual and relentlessly “symbolic” of writers. Her dreamlike rural landscapes are alive with that intense, primitive power of the inwardly focused imagination we find in the seventeenth-century New England Puritans and in other deeply religious individuals for whom nothing can be accidental, contingent or without meaning; on the contrary, everything is charged with significance; as the Jesuit poet Gerard Manley Hopkins has said, “The world is charged with the grandeur of God.” When such believers are gifted with imagination (and what is imagination but, in part, a mysteri-
The Action of Mercy
45
ous metaphor-making capacity), the “natural” world scarcely exists except as a supernatural manifestation; surfaces are masks through which an underlying, far more significant reality asserts itself in ways that may be startling and original and sometimes grotesque. In Catholic orthodoxy, for instance, the communion wafer, or host, is not a symbol of Christ’s bodily sacrifice, is—literally—Christ’s body. As O’Connor has said in “The Grotesque in Southern Fiction,” what she sees on the surface of the world is of interest to her only as she might penetrate “through it into an experience of mystery itself.” In O’Connor’s fiction, a bird-shaped water stain on a bedroom ceiling is a manifestation of the Holy Ghost emblazoned in ice instead of fire (“The Enduring Chill”); the setting sun is “a huge red ball like an elevated Host drenched in blood (“A Temple of the Holy Ghost”); a fire started in a woods by vandals is a revisiting of the ordeal of Old Testament prophets in a fiery furnace (“A Circle in the Fire”). There are lyric passages in O’Connor that call to mind the luminous beauty of paintings by the astonishing Renaissance artist Georges de la Tour that portray ordinary domestic life (a woman placidly picking fleas off her body, for instance) in such vivid chiaroscuro as to imply a supernatural symbolic meaning. There are broadly comic passages that suggest the stylized caricatures of the American regionalist painter Thomas Hart Benton. O’Connor spoke of herself as a “realist of distances” for whom the grotesque—the violent, comic, and caricatured—was of primary interest; the “ordinary aspects of daily life” were of little fictional interest. The “realist of distances” looks for a single image that will connect or combine or embody two points: one is a point in the concrete, the other a point not visible to the naked eye “but believed in by him firmly, just as real to him, really, as the one that everybody sees.”1 Consequently, “The Artificial Nigger” is a highly artificial, self-consciously wrought story in the mode of 1950s symbolic prose. O’Connor’s models may well have been Joseph Conrad (particularly Heart of Darkness and The Secret Sharer which were available in 1950 in a popular mass-market paperback with an introduction by the distinguished critic Albert J. Guerard) and James Joyce (particularly Dubliners), prose stylists notable for their reiterated patterns of imagery and their penchant for carefully phrased, musically cadenced finalparagraph epiphanies. The story’s opening is ornamental and static as an altarpiece, with an elaborate description of moonlight in the room Mr. Head and Nelson share in which “the color of silver”—“dignifying light”—“miraculous moonlight”—“snow-white in the moonlight” point emphatically away from the merely naturalistic; Mr. Head’s trousers exude “an almost noble air, like the garment some great man had just flung to his servant”; the invisible narrator informs us, with startling erudition, that Mr. Head “might have been Virgil summoned in the middle of the night to go to Dante, or, better, Raphael,
46
Joyce Carol Oates
awakened by a blast of God’s light to fly to the side of Tobias.” Really? the reader thinks. Who is telling us this? And in what tone—mocking, whimsical, deadly serious? Once past this tesselated opening, which seems to have been written for academic New Critics of the era, primed on Robert Penn Warren and Cleanth Brooks, to decode, the story begins to breathe on its own, and O’Connor trusts to her characters, through dialogue, to engage and move us. Their wide-eyed adventures in Atlanta, which involve wandering into a Negro neighborhood where they soon get lost, are reminiscent of the cruder, bawdier adventures of Virgil and Fonzo Snopes in Memphis in William Faulkner’s Sanctuary (1931), which end with the country-bumpkin Snopeses being brought to a Negro brothel by a Snopes cousin. Mr. Head and Nelson are both fascinated by and fearful of Negroes; their reconciliation is by way of their awed contemplation of an “artificial nigger”—a vulgar lawn ornament they discover in a white Atlanta neighborhood: It was not possible to tell if the artificial Negro were meant to be young or old; he looked too miserable to be either . . . [Mr. Head and Nelson] stood gazing at [him] as if they were faced with some great mystery, some monument to another’s victory that brought them together in their common defeat. They could both feel it dissolving their differences like an action of mercy.
The “artificial nigger” is a mysterious agent of grace, perhaps like the crucified Christ. In Mystery and Manners, the collection of essays and letters published in 1969, five years after her premature death at the age of thirty-nine, the author speaks straightforwardly of “The Artificial Nigger” in Catholic terms, stating that the “artificial nigger”2 reunites Mr. Head and Nelson in a way not to be explained except as a “working of grace.” Does “The Artificial Nigger” succeed as a story if the reader is unaware of, or unsympathetic with, its Christian subtext? Here, as elsewhere in O’Connor’s most accomplished short fiction, the story moves with its own dramatic momentum; the Christian imagery is sensed rather than made explicit; for the skeleton beneath the story is not nearly so engaging as the story itself. Amid O’Connor’s work, “The Artificial Nigger” is memorable for its portrayal of comic yet sympathetic characters and for the unexpected “mercy” of its conclusion.
No t e s 1. Flannery O’Connor, Mystery and Manners, eds. Sally and Robert Fitzgerald (Farrar, Straus & Giroux, 1969), 42.
The Action of Mercy
47
2. O’Connor, 116. Here, the word “nigger” is used by Flannery O’Connor herself; it would appear to have been a usage common to her, as to her fellow Caucasian Georgians. Forty years after the composition of “The Artificial Nigger,” the very word “nigger” has become so highly charged with political significance that any work of art containing it, especially by a white Southerner, is unwittingly abrasive, even provocative. O’Connor could not have foreseen how the word “nigger” would have come to seem, in some quarters of America, an actual obscenity of the nature of those sexual obscenities she would not have wished to include in her fiction. (There is at least one distinguished American university in which a large-enrollment literature class petitioned successfully to have “The Artificial Nigger” removed from its syllabus as a racist text.)
T imoth y P. C aron
“Backwards to Bethlehem”: Evangelicalism in Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood
I have found that violence is strangely capable of returning my characters to reality and preparing them to accept their moment of grace. Their heads are so hard that almost nothing else will do the work. This idea, that reality is something to which we must be returned at considerable cost, is one which is seldom understood by the casual reader. —Flannery O’Connor
F
Think not that I am come to send peace on earth: I came not to send peace, but a sword. —Matthew 10:34
lannery O’Connor often spoke of the impact of her Christian views upon her art and claimed that her notion of reality was a supernatural one, a reality given meaning through her commitment to the Catholic church: “I am no disbeliever in spiritual purpose and no vague believer. I see from the standpoint of orthodox Christianity. This means that for me the meaning of life is centered in Redemption by Christ and what I see in the world I see in its relation to that.”49 This vigorous proclamation of Christian belief, which probably sounds so alien to most of Wise Blood ’s contemporary readers, distinguishes her intertextual use of the Bible from that of Faulkner,
From Struggles Over the Word: Race and Religion in O’Connor, Faulkner, Hurston, and Wright, pp. 22–51, 147–57. © 2000 by Mercer University Press.
49
50
Timothy P. Caron
Hurston, and Wright. These other authors view the Bible as a contested site where each struggles with the white South’s dominant religiosity, but O’Connor’s Wise Blood actually endorses many tenets of that dominant religiosity. Wise Blood intertextually evokes the Bible to elicit a commitment of Christian faith from its readers. O’Connor seeks to modify her readers who, like her characters, she feels have become so hard-headed through unbelief that they too do not recognize the necessity of God’s grace. While Faulkner, Hurston, and Wright invoice biblical stories to comment upon and critique prevailing Southern racial inequities, O’Connor replicates the way the white South traditionally used the Bible to deflect concern away from societal considerations toward matters of personal piety and salvation. What I am not attempting to do is to deny the strength of O’Connor’s Catholic convictions; instead, I would like bring to light the common ground that she shared with the region’s white Protestantism, namely, an emphasis upon spiritual regeneration above all else. Her work seeks to change the wandering South, to confront it with the sword of Christian conviction so that her Southern readers will return to their region’s (in her opinion) diminishing faith. An example in Wise Blood is Solace Layfield, murdered by Hazel Motes, who could be said to have been redeemed, saved by God’s grace, as Haze runs him down with his Essex and then backs over the fallen prophet. Layfield dies with God’s name upon his lips, asking for forgiveness of his sins.50 Within Wise Blood, violence is divorced from a social context and placed squarely within the theological realm; violence serves as a metaphor for Christian conversion. In a similar manner, O’Connor relentlessly pursues her readership, aggressively confronting them with the message that they are doomed if they persist in living without Christian redemption. The violence her characters experience is the means by which O’Connor’s evangelical message reaches her audience’s ear. She felt the importance of her mission justified such measures, maintaining that you must “shout” or draw “large and startling figures” to reach the spiritually “hard of hearing” and “almost blind.”51 However, when shouting to the “hard of hearing,” dissenting voices are often drowned out. To paraphrase the litany of many Southern Protestant preachers practicing baptism by immersion, O’Connor’s fiction illustrates her characters’ death to their old way of life and their rebirth into Christ to walk: with Him. As Louise Gossett notes, “the crux of [O’Connor’s] fiction is the human being’s need to recognize the peril of damnation in which he lives.”52 Because of the confrontational tone of much of her non-fiction and the impassioned instructions she often gave on how she wanted her stories and novels to be read, many O’Connor critics have aligned themselves with her passionate advocacy of the Christian message
Evangelicalism in Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood
51
and read her stories and novels only through the critical lens of evangelical Christianity. A partial list of the more memorable examples of such studies would include Sister Kathleen Feeley’s Flannery O’Connor: Voice of the Peacock, John R. May’s The Pruning Word: The Parables of Flannery O’Connor, Marshall Bruce Gentry’s Flannery O’Connor’s Religion of the Grotesque, Richard Giannone’s Flannery O’Connor and the Mystery of Love, Robert H. Brinkmeyer’s The Art and Vision of Flannery O’Connor, John F. Desmond’s Risen Sons: Flannery O’Connor’s Vision of History, and Harold Fickett’s Flannery O’Connor: Images of Grace. Also, any number of essays taken from almost any issue of the Flannery O’Connor Bulletin demonstrate the same orthodoxy of critical approaches. For each of these critics, identifying with the author’s faith is a prerequisite for correct reading of the fiction. In the introduction to Flannery O’Connor: New Perspectives, Sura P. Rath discusses the early reception of Wise Blood. Early critics were unaware of O’Connor’s devout Christian beliefs and ascribed to her an unhealthy interest in seamy characters. It has only been after O’Connor inserted her infamous preface to the novel (which is reproduced in all subsequent editions) that critics have followed her lead in reproducing the text’s theology. To take a recent example, Laura B. Kennelly’s “Exhortation in Wise Blood: Rhetorical Theory as an Approach to Flannery O’Connor” encourages us to read the novel as an “exhortative” text. Of course, what we are exhorted to see is that “contemporary society face[s] a dangerous loss of spiritual awareness” and that “the saga of Hazel Motes and those around him [can] transmit a new way of seeing life . . .”53 The rhetoric of the white South’s salvation theology is nothing if not exhortative. In the introduction to his recent anthology, New Essays on Wise Blood, Michael Kreyling announces that his particular collection “has been assembled not to reinforce the consensus on O’Connor’s literary reputation, but to shake it a little out of complacent habits.”54 Kreyling convincingly argues that the result of these “complacent habits” has been “nearly five decades of repetitive affirmations of the theological message believed to inform O’Connor’s work, reinforced by the tacit belief that her considerable suffering crowned her word with a special truth status.”55 Kreyling traces the general outline of O’Connor criticism, surveying attempts to read her works both “against” and “with” its theological grain. As a challenge, the essays in Kreyling’s collection run counter to the majority of O’Connor criticism, in general, and Wise Blood ’s criticism, in particular. In this collection, Wise Blood is variously read as a critique of Cold War consumerism, the embodiment of Lacan’s psychoanalytic theory of the gaze, and as an example of feminist resistance to male dominated culture and speech. Each of the essays in the Kreyling volume tacitly confronts what Martha Stephens has labeled the “problem of assent”56 in reading O’Connor’s fiction.
52
Timothy P. Caron
What if, unlike O’Connor herself, one does not read with the eyes of faith? Or, what if one does not read with O’Connor’s faith, but with a faith more concerned with social justice? To take a smaller example before considering the novel Wise Blood, what is a critic such as Stephens or André Bleikasten, who raises many of the same questions, to make of a short story like “The River?” In this story, a young boy’s parents—who could serve as the prototypes of worldly dissolution which so dismayed O’Connor—are too hung-over to attend to their son, so they leave him in the care of a good country woman who takes him to a “preaching and healing at the river.”57 There the preacher baptizes the boy, initiating him into his new life in the “Kingdom of Christ.” The following day, while his parents are again hung-over, little Harry Ashfield slips out of their apartment and makes his way back to the river where he drowns trying to baptize himself again. As he goes under for the final time, he feels a “long gentle hand”58 pulling him along the way toward a union with the saints. O’Connor explained her recurring tendency toward depicting violent conversions by saying, “When I write a novel in which the central action is a baptism [referring to her second novel, The Violent Bear It Away], I am very well aware that for a majority of my readers, baptism is a meaningless rite, and so in my novel I have to see that this baptism carries enough awe and mystery to jar the reader into some kind of emotional recognition of its significance.”59 And the drowning of Harry Ashfield is quite jarring. O’Connor anticipated most critics’ recalcitrance to her sacramental vision and, concerning “The River” and Harry’s ultimate fate, defended her work by embracing the white South’s salvation-oriented religiosity: “[Harry] comes to a good end. He’s saved from those nutty parents, a fate worse than death. He’s been baptized and so he goes to his Maker; this is a good end.”60 The grief of the young boy’s family, the pain of his death—neither of these factors is allowed to weaken the story’s ending, nor are they acknowledged in O’Connor’s insistence that her readers view this character’s death only in the best possible terms. O’Connor’s fiction invokes the Bible not in any openly revisionary sense—neither revising the white South’s popular notions of the Bible nor that particular interpretive community itself—but as an authorization, an appeal, as if directly to the ultimate expression of God on Earth, His Holy Word. O’Connor’s evangelical intertextual appropriations from the Bible are very similar to one of the white South’s strongest biblical interpreting strategies: the Bible’s perceived evangelical thrust makes it more of a document of the relationship between God and humanity and less of a guidebook for the relationships between and among Southern whites and blacks. The title of O’Connor’s second novel, The Violent Bear It Away, perfectly exemplifies a biblical intertext employed to spur her readers to Christian commitment.
Evangelicalism in Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood
53
What could easily be interpreted as a call for political insurrection in the biblical text—“And from the days of John the Baptist until now the kingdom of heaven suffereth violence, and the violent take it by force”61—is read by the evangelical South (and most O’Connor critics) as a challenge to one’s soul. Similarly, Wise Blood ’s revoicings of the New Testament turn away social questions of racial injustice by focusing upon the efforts of true believers to claim the “kingdom of heaven.” Thomas Schaub makes a similar point when he asserts that “throughout [her] fiction, it isn’t too hard to see that . . . these violent conversions [of characters like Hazel Motes from Wise Blood] are meant to operate as much against the liberal reader as against the central character.”62 Schaub’s American Fiction in the Cold War does a remarkable job of placing O’Connor’s fiction within the context of Cold War liberalism and its rhetoric, arguing that “the premises of O’Connor’s work were remarkably consistent with those of the very audience she imagined withering under her attack.”63 The common premises that Schaub detects between her fiction and the discourse of modern American liberalism are a belief in human imperfection, the presence of evil, and a “necessity to recognize the limitations of human control and aspiration.”64 Despite this common ground, O’Connor often saw herself as being at odds with these “liberal readers,” whom she often labeled “innerlekchuls” in her correspondence, and she was hesitant of making tactical alliances with those who did not share her uncompromising Christian faith. As she appropriates biblical material, O’Connor’s identification and shared sympathies with Southern Protestantism influence her intertextual project, giving her a different agenda from the rest of the authors in this study. For example, William Faulkner’s intertextual use of the Bible in Light in August assails the white Southern Protestantism that views the Scriptures as a divinely sanctioned statement of white superiority. Through his depiction of Yoknapatawpha County’s fear and hatred of Joe Christmas, he exposes the white community’s use of the Bible to authorize Christmas’s eventual lynching. Hurston’s Moses, Man of the Mountain creates an alternative African-American world apart from the oppressive white South, and Wright’s Dan Taylor and Aunt Sue from Uncle Tom’s Children employ a distinctly black religiosity as a foundation for the fight against Jim Crow. Both Moses, Man of the Mountain, and Uncle Tom’s Children utilize the black church’s theological legacies to inform their respective intertextual practices. Whereas Hurston and Wright adopt elements from the black church’s struggle against an oppressive society, and Faulkner reveals the racism of a small but vocal biblical interpretive community, O’Connor’s intertextual practice replicates the white church’s silence over unjust racial practices that arose from a militant emphasis upon personal salvation and redemption.
54
Timothy P. Caron
Kreyling is right in his insistence that the critical orthodoxy surrounding O’Connor has resulted in an “orthodox line [that] is narrow, deep, and resistant to revision.”65 And his anthology, along with Jon Lance Bacon’s Flannery O’Connor and Cold War Culture, does much to redirect the attention focused on Wise Blood and the rest of O’Connor’s fiction. However, that is not to denigrate the theologically informed investigations which have already revealed great insights into her work or to suggest that there is nothing else to be gained from such investigations. Indeed, in one sense, this chapter is but another religiously-oriented investigation of Wise Blood, but with two important differences: first, I want to point to the shared concerns of Wise Blood and the dominant religiosity of the white South’s silence over racial matters; and, secondly, I want to place O’Connor’s evangelical fervor in dialogue with other biblically shaped texts, which reflect the variety of the Southern religious experience. This salvational emphasis of the white South, though diminished, still characterizes the region known as the Bible Belt. O’Connor stresses that the South is the last remaining region of America where Sam Jones’s66 grandma would read “the Bible thirty-seven times on her knees,” and it is “made up of the descendants of old ladies like her. You don’t shake off their influence in even several generations.”67 What white Southerners have inherited but not “shaken off ” from figures such as Grandmother Jones is a common medium of expression, a shared set of images, allusions, stories, and tropes which provides them with a common vocabulary emphasizing the soul’s need for salvation. Reading the Bible in the South is the pursuit of literate individuals from all classes, from the educated upper classes to the poorest dirt farmers.68 As a devoted reader and student of the Scriptures herself, O’Connor uses the Bible as her primary “instrument to plumb Christian meaning.”69 O’Connor uses biblical intertexts to invest her characters’ struggles with a religious urgency and ground them in the supernatural reality she believed in so strongly herself. Because of her adamant Catholicism, O’Connor might seem an outsider among a grouping of Southern writers that includes William Faulkner, Zora Neale Hurston, and Richard Wright. As Southern historians, and Southern historians of religion in particular, have long known, the overwhelmingly Protestant South, outside of a few areas, has not been very tolerant or accepting of Catholics. Louis D. Rubin was given perhaps only to slight exaggeration in his characterization of many Southern Protestants of the 1950s and 1960s when he described them as believing that “the Pope of Rome is a minion of Satan, and a Catholic priest a mysterious and dangerous man.”70 An earlier generation’s animosity toward and blaming of Catholics for the ills of the region and the nation can be found in an article in the Memphis Commer-
Evangelicalism in Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood
55
cial Appeal from 1928 which claimed that “three of our presidents have been assassinated, and it is understood that every one of them fell at the hands of Catholics. I have never heard a statement to the contrary.”71 However, as a Southerner, O’Connor received what Rubin calls a “double heritage,”72 a Catholic doctrinal orthodoxy along with a knowledge of and affinity for the region’s evangelical fundamentalism. As to the latter component of her amalgamated theological heritage, O’Connor discusses these submerged or “underground affinities” in her essay, “The Catholic Novelist in the Protestant South.” She defines the Protestant South as the last region of America where Christianity and Bible reading have not been demoted to a “department of sociology . . . or personality development,” either of which would have appalled O’Connor. She claims that in the South, at least, the supernatural is not an embarrassment. Because of her concern with saving souls and her commitment to personal Bible study, O’Connor proclaims a religious “kinship” with Protestant “backwoods prophets and shouting fundamentalists.”73 As she explained elsewhere, “in the South the general conception of man is still, in the main, theological.”74 More specifically, O’Connor’s kinship with her Protestant neighbors results from a shared belief in the “divinity of Christ, . . . the Redemptive Power, [and] the physical resurrection.”75 O’Connor maintained that the differences she had with Southern Protestants were “on the nature of the Church, not on the nature of God or our obligation to Him.”76 O’Connor wrote to the novelist John Hawkes that she accepted “the same fundamental doctrines of sin and redemption and judgement”77 as her Southern Protestant fellowbelievers. Despite differences of denominational loyalty, a white Southern “Child of God”—whether Sam Jones or Flannery O’Connor—would know his or her spiritual brothers and sisters because he or she would recognize a similar concern with salvation. Samuel S. Hill characterizes the emphasis placed upon personal salvation by the white South as “verticalist.”78 This term emphasizes the dominant relationship of the white South’s theology, a relationship plotted along a vertical axis between a morally requiring God and sinful humans. Conversion, or in the white church’s vocabulary, “getting right with God,” is necessary to establish this vertical bond. Southern social ills such as child labor, sharecropping, illiteracy, and race relations received little attention from the region’s religion because the white church emphasized “the temporary nature of this world as a place whose evils must be endured.”79 O’Connor’s own verticalist disposition is apparent in Mystery and Manners when she proclaims her readers’ need to realize their “dependence on the grace of God [for salvation], and a knowledge that evil is not simply a problem to be solved, but a mystery to be endured.”80 Much like the Southern white church, whose religion
56
Timothy P. Caron
is “dominantly a conservative or reinforcing agent for the traditional values held by white Southern society,”81 O’Connor’s focus on the soul’s condition deemphasizes the region’s social concerns. The “story” necessary for constructing O’Connor’s fiction is the story of individual sinners’ redemption that white Southern Protestants stress in their evangelical, salvation-oriented interpretations of the Bible. In Wise Blood, O’Connor utilizes her familiarity with the Bible and relies upon a similar, although perhaps lesser, knowledge in her Southern readership. As she says elsewhere: “Abstractions, formulas, laws will not serve here. We have to have stories in our background. It takes a story to make a story. It takes a story of mythic dimensions, one that belongs to everybody, one in which everybody is able to recognize the hand of God and its descent. In the Protestant South, the Scriptures fill this role.”82 O’Connor’s fiction then is to lead readers back to its narrative source—the Bible. This reading of the Bible as a single, sustained narrative which relates the Christian story of Christ’s redemption is common to Protestantism. For example, theologian Carl Ficken’s God’s Story and Modern Literature succinctly summarizes this hermeneutical principle: “The Christian’s life and faith are shaped within a community that exists because of the great story of God’s freeing and sustaining love. The Bible tells that story; the church has repeated it, lived it, been nourished by it for centuries. We are a people who know how to read a story and how to tell one.”83 Upon (re)turning to the Bible, readers will find what the white South’s Protestant tradition finds in its “infallible Bible, . . . especially the King James version of it”84: the salvation story. In white Southern religiosity, the Bible provides insight into the state of one’s soul—will you stand before a demanding God as an unregenerate sinner, or as a redeemed believer? White Southern ministers and their congregations often deflected issues of race relations because they did not conceive of the region’s “race problem” as a matter of individual morality. For O’Connor, the relationship between her fiction and the Bible is an anagogical one, revealing the link between the known world and the supernatural reality embodied in Christ’s incarnation, His redemptive death, and His resurrection. O’Connor often referred to the anagogical element present in what she considered good fiction: “The kind of vision the fiction writer needs to have, or to develop, in order to increase the meaning of his story is called anagogical vision, and that is the kind of vision that is able to see different levels of reality in one image or one situation.” Within her own work, she strove to invest her writing with an “anagogical vision” in an effort to reveal “the Divine life and our participation in it.”85 Wise Blood ’s biblical intertextuality, the novel’s prime anagogical manifestation, is “verticalist” in much the same way that O’Connor’s theology is verticalist; the novel invokes the Bible to insist upon personal salvation dispensed by a morally demanding God to
Evangelicalism in Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood
57
whom everyone will one day be accountable. O’Connor appropriates biblical stories, figures, characters, and tropes so that her work might echo with the same urgent redemptive message she finds so prevalent in the Scriptures. Her own reading of the Bible and her intertextual appropriations mediate between her fiction and the supernatural realm it seeks to engage. O’Connor invokes the WORD into her words, investing Wise Blood with seemingly timeless and universal qualities, but her intertextual revoicings actually reflect the reading practices of a specific time and place. Wise Blood ’s intertexts reflect the white South’s obsession with individual sin and salvation. This sin/salvation fixation is encapsulated in Wise Blood ’s twin characters of unbelief and belief, Enoch Emery and Hazel Motes, respectively, whose exploits demonstrate O’Connor’s fervent belief in the necessity of spiritual rebirth. In O’Connor’s fiction, each individual must choose Christ, as does Haze, or the world, as does Enoch. As Robert Brinkmeyer has noted, a fundamentalist, evangelical theology, which is embodied in Haze’s mother and grandfather, underpins the novel.86 “Every fourth Saturday,” Hazel’s grandfather drove “into Eastrod as if he were just in time to save them all from Hell, and he was shouting before he had the car door open.”87 And the message the old man delivered was extremely simple—all listeners must surrender to the “soul-hungry” Jesus or they will face the Hell from which Jesus was so desperate to save them. There are no fine theological points or room for discussion—one must choose redemption or damnation, Jesus or the world. As they move through Taulkinham,88 Enoch and Haze are anagogically linked to the Bible in two ways: their names render moral pronouncements on life’s vacuity outside of Christ, and their actions reveal their desperate longing for some supernatural significance in their lives. Emily Archer concludes that O’Connor’s “consistent attention to meaningful, unarbitrary character naming should . . . be perceived as an anagogical signal, a clue that names can somehow ‘make contact with mystery’ ”89 (emphasis added). For example, Enoch Emery is an intertextual revoicing of two different Enochs from the early chapters of Genesis.90 The first is the son of Cain, born after his father was cursed for killing Abel.91 In his wanderings, Cain founded a city which he named after his first born son. The white South’s religiosity interprets this Enoch (Cain’s son) as a figure for sinful man. Therefore, Enoch Emery’s name links him to this first Enoch’s Old Testament story; Enoch Emery is the “son” of the Bible’s first example of willfulness and distance from God after the Fall. The familial connection between O’Connor’s character and the Old Testament Cain is further revealed when Enoch mentions his daddy’s scar to Haze. Like his intertextual biblical predecessor, Enoch Emery is a man living under a system of rituals, outside of the Grace of Christ, completely clueless about Jesus’ redemptive mission. Despite Enoch Emery’s boast that he
58
Timothy P. Caron
knows a “whole heap about Jesus,”92 he fruitlessly seeks to fulfill his spiritual impulses through a series of rituals in the park, such as his viewing of the shrunken mummy,93 without an evangelical faith in Christian redemption. These rituals display Enoch’s religious nature, but in O’Connor’s redemption-oriented vocabulary, he is only “Christ-haunted” and never “Christcentered.” Enoch symbolizes for O’Connor the component within humanity “that demands the redemptive act,”94 yet he is unable to convert the factual knowledge of Jesus he acquired at the Rodemill Boys Bible Academy into a practicing Christian faith. For O’Connor, faith can never be just a matter of facts or biographical knowledge about the life of Jesus. Enoch Emery’s intertextual relationship with the second Enoch of Genesis is ironic. This second Old Testament Enoch was the child of Adam and Eve’s third son, Seth. This Enoch was a righteous man and a Hebrew patriarch from whose descendants Noah would eventually be born. Genesis 5:24 describes this Enoch walking with God, avoiding death, and being taken directly into communion with God: “. . . and he was not; for God took him.” Unlike every other patriarch listed in the genealogy between Adam and Noah, the length of Enoch’s life is never given. In the New Testament, the writer of Hebrews revoices Enoch’s story to demonstrate the rewards of godly living: “By faith Enoch was translated that he should not see death; and was not found, because God had translated him: for before his translation he had this testimony, that he pleased God.”95 In an ironic retelling of this biblical story, O’Connor also “translates” her Enoch from what the white South’s theology would consider a spiritually vacuous human being into an animal, both of whom lack the ability to connect with God. All of Enoch’s innate religious desires are twisted by Taulkinham’s consumerism. For instance, O’Connor’s Enoch’s greatest goal is to be “THE young man of the future, like the ones in the insurance ads.”96 In the theological framework of the white South, the logical conclusion of Enoch’s quest to fulfill his religion of self-advancement is when he becomes an animal, assuming the form of a gorilla and being translated into an it.97 As Enoch dresses himself in the gorilla-suit, O’Connor shifts from the human pronoun “he” to the inhuman pronoun “it”: In the uncertain light, one of his lean white legs could be seen to disappear and then the other, one arm and then the other: a black heavier shaggier figure replaced his. For an instant, it had two heads, one light and one dark, but after a second, it pulled the dark back head over the other and corrected this. It busied itself with certain hidden fastenings and what appeared to be minor adjustments of its hide.98
Evangelicalism in Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood
59
After worshipping the shriveled mummy, the unregenerate god of pop psychology and profit-motive theology, Enoch Emery’s deity rewards him, and “no gorilla in existence, whether in the jungles of Africa or California, or in New York City in the finest apartment in the world, was happier at that moment than this one.”99 In an example of a critic replicating Wise Blood ’s verticalist theology, Richard Giannone appropriates O’Connor’s and the white South’s rhetoric of Christian salvation when he writes of this scene, “the Enoch of Genesis may have been translated to heaven . . . , but the gorilla on the rock is humanity shorn of glory.”100 But the translation of Enoch Emery from man to gorilla reveals Wise Blood ’s deferral to prevailing Southern opinions on race. The South’s racist images of blacks as sub-human beasts lurk just beneath the surface of this scene. By the end of the transformation, Enoch is a black, shaggy brute completely ruled by base or “animal” desires. In attempting to demonstrate that all humans urgently need a regenerative encounter with Christ, O’Connor creates a portrait precariously close to the white South’s stereotypical menacing black male. Enoch’s metaphorical transformation sounds suspiciously close to the core of Gavin Stevens’ speech about Joe Christmas’s “warring” white and black blood from Light in August : both men succumb to inherent weaknesses. Both Hazel and Joe Christmas wage a losing fight against their “darker” natures before completely submitting to their evil inheritances. O’Connor’s insistence that her fiction be interpreted using anagogical principles deflects attention away from possible racial considerations. For O’Connor and the evangelical white South, racial injustice is not a matter of individual piety but simply a worldly injustice to be endured. While O’Connor links Enoch Emery to the Old Testament, demonstrating the consequences of life without Jesus, Hazel Motes is intertextually linked primarily to the New Testament. His name invokes the pervasive New Testament imagery of blindness because first Haze is blind to God’s summons, and then he so completely submits to God that he blinds himself so that he will not be distracted from his newly acquired spiritual vision. Hazel Motes’ name comes from Jesus’ admonition in Matthew 7:3–5: “And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother’s eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye? Or how wilt thou say to thy brother, Let me pull out the mote out of thine eye; and, behold, a beam is in thine own eye? Thou hypocrite, first cast out the beam out of thine own eye; and then shalt thou see clearly to cast out the mote out of thy brother’s eye.” In Wise Blood ’s theological framework, the young man from Eastrod is blind to God’s call because of the obfuscating “haze” of his apostasy and the log-sized “mote” of personal pride in his own eye, i.e., thinking he has not sinned and does not need salvation. Haze’s metaphorical and literal blindness evoke a large net-
60
Timothy P. Caron
work of New Testament images all connected by the white South to proper seeing, that is, the ability to distinguish Jesus’ teachings and how one is to follow them. For instance, Christ proclaims that “the light of the body is the eye,” and if it is filled with light, “then thy whole body shall be filled with light.”101 In O’Connor’s revoicing of this New Testament trope, before his conversion when he acquired his spiritual sight and lost his physical sight, Haze was guilty of having eyes, yet having no sight.102 As spiritually exhortative as O’Connor intends their names to be, Enoch Emery and Hazel Motes most dramatically reveal O’Connor’s project of evangelical biblical intertextuality through their actions. For the reader initiated into the white South’s redemption-oriented theology, nearly everything they do points toward the futility of life without God’s grace while encouraging readers to return to or establish relationships with Christ. For example, the anagogical significance of Enoch’s pursuit of the “new jesus,” which he believes to have found in the shriveled mummy, clearly reveals O’Connor’s scorn for false idols. O’Connor uses a key word from her religious vocabulary to describe the mummy and its significance to Enoch: “It was a mystery, although it was right there in a glass case for everybody to see and there was a typewritten card over it telling all about it. But there was something the card couldn’t say . . .”103 (emphasis added). What this shriveled little man cannot communicate to Enoch is some sense of the divine Mystery (as O’Connor usually designated it) of God’s redemptive involvement in and concern for individuals. O’Connor’s disdain for such frail idols is revealed in her manipulation of biblical intertexts surrounding Epoch’s veneration of the mummy and its rewards. Compelled by his vague spiritual yearnings, Epoch begins to clean his rented room for the arrival of his sacred visitor. The object receiving the most attention, since it will be the future home of his god, is a washstand which was “built in three parts and stood on bird legs six inches high. . . . The lowest part was a tabernacle-like cabinet which was meant to contain a slopjar”104 (emphasis added). He paints the inside of his tabernacle with gilt paint and places the mummy inside of what O’Connor, in all obvious allusion to the Hebrew Ark of the Covenant, calls an “ark.”105 Like a chief priest from the Old Testament, Enoch now waits for directions from his god, whose relics are to be housed in a completely secular version of the Ark of the Covenant inside the holy of holies of Epoch’s room. For O’Connor, the mummy is no more spiritually enlightening than the human excrement that used to fill the slop-jar the washstand was designed to hold. The result of Enoch’s willful pursuit of this new jesus is already apparent: he spiritually de-evolves from a human being and is translated from a person into an “it.” O’Connor once described Epoch as a “moron and chiefly a comic character.”106 O’Connor is able to laugh the laugh of the justified because of her
Evangelicalism in Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood
61
firm religious faith. If readers find humor in Enoch’s exploits, there is little to laugh at in the grim spectacle of Haze working out his salvation “in fear and trembling” and numerous mortifications of the flesh. Not only does Haze blind himself in his quest for redemption, but in the last days of his life, he also wraps barbed wire around his chest and fills his shoes with pebbles and broken glass. To understand Haze’s struggle against unbelief, one must understand the Motes family’s religious legacy. Haze received some of his earliest teaching about Christ from the frightening figure of his grandfather, “a waspish old man who had ridden over three counties with Jesus hidden in his head like a stinger.”107 The grandfather spoke of a relentless, frightening, “soul-hungry” Jesus who would chase sinners “over the waters of sin,” and despite any obstacle, He “would have them in the end.”108 As O’Connor herself claimed, the only thing that Hazel retained from this frightening exposure to his grandfather’s evangelical tirades was “a sense of sin. . . . This sense of sin is the only key he has to finding a sanctuary and he begins unconsciously to search for God through sin” (emphasis added).109 This quest for redemption, regardless of where it might lead, is the common ground that forms the religious kinship with the white South’s evangelical Protestantism, which O’Connor acknowledged in her “underground affinities” with “back-woods prophets” and “shouting fundamentalists.” By the novel’s conclusion, Hazel does not seem to even be living in this world, much less showing any concern for its injustices. O’Connor dramatizes Haze’s willful rebellion and flight—both in terms of theology and geography—from his calling from God in the opening and closing scenes of chapter 7. Just as God directed Moses and the Israelite nation out of Egyptian bondage with a cloud to direct them by day, He also seeks to lead Hazel with a cloud, one reminiscent of an Old Testament patriarch: “The sky was just a little lighter blue than [Hazel’s] suit, clear and even, with only one cloud in it, a large blinding white one with curls and a beard.”110 Hazel, however, is too busy trying to seduce Sabbath Hawks (who is busy trying to seduce Hazel) to take notice of God’s attempts at spiritual guidance. By the end of the chapter, the cloud-image of an Old Testament, patriarchal figure has given way to “a bird with long thin wings and was disappearing in the opposite direction.”111 O’Connor’s text seems eager to bestow upon Hazel an anointing similar to Christ’s when the Holy Spirit descended upon Him in the form of a dove.112 The distances between Haze’s theology and that of the evangelical South—which reads this New Testament story as the starting point of Christ’s redemptive mission—is revealed in the simple act of Hazel driving “in the opposite direction” of this heavenly sign. Despite their nearly constant grumbling against Jehovah and the insurrections they mount against Moses, even Hurston’s recalcitrant Hebrews from Moses, Man of the Mountain are more spiritually attuned to God’s signs than Hazel.
62
Timothy P. Caron
The clouds in the countryside are not the only signs O’Connor has placed in Hazel’s path that he fails to read, signs which become increasingly obvious to the reader attuned to her evangelical project. Haze commits the sin of pride when he repeatedly claims not to need Christ’s intervention for salvation, as he tells the waitress at the zoo’s restaurant, “I AM clean.” So, with the log-sized mote of pride in his own eye, Haze cannot read such subtle signs as the clouds. Hazel is so blind to the efforts of the “soul-hungry Jesus” that before his conversion he also fails to interpret correctly the most obvious signs the “wild ragged figure”113 of the relentless Jesus places before him. These are literally the road-side signs whose fundamentalist urgency demands that Haze abandon his sinful ways. On a trip out of the city, Haze sees a gray boulder beside the road. “White letters on the boulder said, WOE TO THE BLASPHEMER AND WHOREMONGER! WILL HELL SWALLOW YOU UP?”114 Haze spends several minutes pondering the sign’s question, one of special significance for Hazel, considering his involvement in the Church Without Christ and with Leora Watts, and for O’Connor’s apostate readership whom he represents within Wise Blood ’s narrative world. Here O’Connor reveals her affinity with the evangelical white South, the large capital letters shouting to the spiritually deaf. Haze especially studies “the two words at the bottom of the sign. They said in smaller letters, ‘Jesus Saves.’ ” Haze reacts with anger and declares, “I don’t believe in anything.”115 The Church Without Christ says that there are no longer signs from God, if there ever were any, so Haze returns to Taulkinham unaware that Christ is preparing an unmistakable message for the recalcitrant young man from Eastrod. Or, is it O’Connor preparing an unmistakable message for us as readers? O’Connor again reflects the conversion-oriented theology of the white South as she depicts three events which facilitate Hazel’s eventual confrontation with an otherworldly Jesus: Hazel destroys the dust-filled new jesus; he kills the false prophet, Solace Layfield; and the patrolman pushes his car over the embankment. In the first of these events, Enoch thinks he is rendering a great service to his deity by uniting the mummy with Hazel whom he supposes to be a great prophet of his secular god, a sort of John the Baptist whose lone voice in the wilderness of Taulkinham is preparing the way for this physical, unregenerate god. Yet what causes Hazel to reject this new jesus is what O’Connor once called his own type of “Wise Blood,”116 a blood, unlike Enoch’s, that intuitively recognizes that the shriveled mummy is not what he has been pursuing. Having never been anything more than “all man” and possessing no blood to spare for humanity’s redemption, this new jesus serves no spiritually redemptive purpose for O’Connor. Hazel recognizes this when his vision is made hyperacute by putting on his mother’s Bible-reading glasses and viewing the tableau of Sabbath cradling the shrunken mummy,
Evangelicalism in Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood
63
an intertextual parody of the Catholic iconography of Madonna and Holy Child; she holds the shriveled little corpse “in the crook of her arm, . . . fitted exactly into the hollow of her shoulder.”117 Hazel responds to this blasphemous mother and child with great violence—he throws the new jesus against a wall, “and the trash inside sprayed out like dust.”118 He then throws the skin out the back door into the rain. Harold Fickett, in a passage whose rhetoric is virtually indistinguishable from O’Connor’s, or the white South’s dominant religiosity, concludes that “Haze . . . recognizes that he has indeed been presented with a new jesus—a jesus shrunken to the size to which Hazel’s unbelief would tailor him; a jesus that is a continuing sign of our mortality, that lives on in a mummified eternity only to proclaim the impossibility of resurrection.”119 O’Connor says much the same thing in a letter to “A”120 dated 23 July 1960: “That Haze rejects the mummy suggests everything. What he has been looking for with body and soul throughout the book is suddenly presented to him and he sees it has to be rejected, he sees it ain’t really what he’s been looking for.”121 Hazel’s momentary insight does not accomplish his redemption; rather, it is merely a step in clearing away the log-sized mote of personal pride that prevents him from recognizing his need for a redemptive encounter with Jesus. The second event preparing Hazel for conversion—paradoxical as it may sound—is his killing of his narrative twin, Solace Layfield. Layfield is Hazel’s textual double: when Hoover Shoats realizes that Hazel will not compromise his Church Without Christ for monetary gain, he simply hires a Hazel lookalike to help him work his scam. Hazel moves toward conversion when he strips away his double’s pious costume. [Layfield] began to run in earnest. He tore off his shirt and unbuckled his belt and ran out of the trousers. He began grabbing for his feet as if he would take off his shoes too, but before he could get at them, the Essex knocked him flat and ran over him. Haze drove about twenty feet and stopped the car and then began to back it. He backed it over the body and then stopped and got out.122
Earlier, a woman in the crowd asked Hazel if he and Shoats’s “True Prophet” were twins, and Hazel foreshadows Layfield’s impending murder when he replies, “If you don’t hunt it down and kill it, it’ll hunt you down, and kill you.”123 This comment does not so much reveal Hazel’s murderous tendencies as it does his realization, at least on what O’Connor considered his intuitive or “blood” level, that he must rid his own self of its disbelieving elements. Put another way, within the anagogical interpretive mode favored by Wise Blood and the Southern white church, Hazel’s violence is interpreted
64
Timothy P. Caron
not so much a murder of Layfield as it is a violent exorcism of his own sinful elements that obstruct his view of the redeeming Christ. Anagogy displaces the moral concerns regarding violence in the here and now. In the terms of O’Connor’s universe, Hazel functions as Layfield’s instrument of grace because, as the consumptive false prophet lies beneath the Essex, he confesses his sinful nature before Jesus and dies asking for His forgiveness: “ ‘Jesus hep me,’ the man wheezed.”124 The final step of Hazel’s preparation for conversion is when the patrolman destroys Hazel’s car. Though Haze claims that not even a lightning bolt could stop his Essex, he does not reckon on the mysterious patrolman who polices the outer limits of Haze’s apostasy and prohibits him from getting too far in his attempts to outrun God. This point is reinforced by another road sign that Hazel deliberately tries not to read—“Jesus Died for YOU”125— just moments before the policeman pulls him over. The officer pushes his car over an embankment, destroying his vehicle and his ability to run from God. “Haze stood for a few minutes, looking over at the scene. His face seemed to reflect the entire distance across the clearing and on beyond, the entire distance that extended from his eyes to the blank gray sky that went on, depth after depth, into space. His knees bent under him and he sat down on the edge of the embankment with his feet hanging over.”126 Hazel has now completed his third preparatory experience necessary for receiving Jesus’ mysterious redemptive grace. This scene secures the intertextual bond between Hazel and Paul: both men violently experience God’s grace as they travel isolated country roads to preach their individual messages against the Gospel. Immediately following his encounter with the patrolman, Haze rushes back to the city to blind himself with the mixture of quicklime and water. The blindness of Saul and Hazel is the bridge between their old selves and their new ones. Saul’s blindness, the scales covering his eyes, is God’s chastening tool. After his rebirth as the apostle Paul, he continually suffered from a “thorn in the flesh” which kept him humble before God. Hazel likewise disciplines his flesh with the metal thorns of three strands of barbed wire wrapped around his chest.127 These harsh measures do eventually convert him into a beam of redemptive light at the novel’s conclusion. In fact, O’Connor has Haze finally recognize the truth behind Jesus’ teaching in Matthew 18:9 (a particularly favorite passage of the evangelical white South) that it is better “to enter into life with one eye [or, in Hazel’s case, with no eyes] rather than having two eyes to be cast into hell fire.” Hazel’s self-mutilation allows O’Connor to emphasize two crucial components of the white South’s redemption-oriented theology: first, Hazel’s blindness eliminates the distractions which have so long kept him from surrendering to Jesus’ pursuit; secondly, he gains a more intense spiritual vision
Evangelicalism in Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood
65
allowing him to see what he is now running toward and not from. As Mrs. Flood notices after Hazel rubs quicklime and water into his face, his eyes reveal a “peculiar pushing look, as if [he] were going forward after something [he] could just distinguish in the distance.”128 While Hazel’s means of salvation are extremely Catholic (i.e. through his penitential acts), the evangelical call that leads to his conversion is highly Protestant. An important distinction should be made between Saul/Paul and Hazel, however. While both men bicker with Christianity, their motives could not be farther apart. Theologian Martin Hengel observes that Saul/Paul persecuted the early Christian community “in the firm conviction that in so doing he was acting according to God’s law and will, in zeal for this law.”129 The newly founded cult of Jesus was highly critical of the Mosaic law, leading to the eventual stoning of one of the church’s most influential leaders, Stephen (Acts 7:55–60). Saul held the cloaks of the men who stoned Stephen, and seemingly spurred on by this action, he began to persecute the early church in Jerusalem and surrounding areas, imprisoning believers (Acts 8). Haze, on the contrary, denigrates Christianity not because he sees himself as fulfilling God’s law but because he wants to deny that there even is a God. Once Hazel has blinded himself, he begins his journey “backwards to Bethlehem,”130 drawing toward a spiritual union with Christ as he approaches death. Hazel’s journey has truly come full circle now with his end fully recognizable in his beginning. Wise Blood opens and closes with the memento mori images of death in life that Hazel’s surrender to Christ fully embodies within the white South’s salvation oriented theology. O’Connor describes the “plain and insistent”131 outline of a skull under Hazel’s skin on the novel’s first page, and on its last, the same memento mori fuses with the description of Hazel’s eyes, his hyperacute organ of spiritual sight: “The outline of a skull was plain under his skin and the deep burned eye sockets seemed to lead into the dark tunnel where he had disappeared.”132 Hazel’s self-blinding, which bestows upon him a theological “tunnel-vision,” and his other penitential acts lead to a union with Jesus as he becomes the “pin point of light” that Mrs. Flood had detected in his sightless eyes. It is this dark tunnel that leads him back to Bethlehem and his soul-saving encounter with Christ. Wise Blood is O’Connor’s evangelical project, and Hazel’s blindness is her metaphor for the occlusion of humanity’s spiritual sight. But the text of Wise Blood itself might be said to possess a blind spot; O’Connor is so intent upon demonstrating the machinations of Christian grace that the Southern white church’s verticalist tendencies are replicated in Wise Blood. The extent of O’Connor’s identification with the white Protestant South’s hierarchy of heavenly concerns over earthly ones is suggested by her refusal to meet James Baldwin in Georgia in the spring of 1959. To use O’Connor’s own words, it
66
Timothy P. Caron
“just wouldn’t do” for a white woman (regardless of the fact that O’Connor never considered herself a real Southern “lady”) to meet with a black writer of the stature and reputation of James Baldwin to discuss art. She explained her reasons for not meeting with Baldwin in a letter to Maryat Lee: “No I can’t see James Baldwin in Georgia. It would cause the greatest trouble and disturbance and disunion. In New York it would be nice to meet him; here it would not. I observe the traditions of the society I feed on—it’s only fair.” O’Connor concluded by saying that one “might as well expect a mule to fly” as for her to see Baldwin within the state borders of Georgia.133 Even in short stories, such as “The Artificial Nigger” and “Revelation,” where her focus seems to be explicitly upon Southern race relations, O’Connor’s stories demonstrate an emphasis upon her white main characters’ “moments of grace,” and Southern blacks are just the impetus of her white characters’ “salvation,” as in the case of Mrs. Turpin. In a recent attempt to deal with the question of race in O’Connor’s short fiction, one of her most theologically sympathetic critics, Ralph Wood, examines her correspondence with Maryat Lee and concludes that “Flannery O’Connor often sounds like an unabashed racist in her privately expressed opinions.”134 However, he goes on to differentiate between what she wrote in her letters and the purer expressions of her fiction. Wood finds that her fiction offers “the way of the Cross” as the only viable solution to “race hatred.”135 This seems to me to be a strange dichotomy that allows Wood, like O’Connor and much of the rest of her audience, to deflect social concerns with theological ones. As he says, in a statement that sounds as much like O’Connor as anything she wrote herself, “the liberal estimate of human nature is mistaken in the most fundamental way. It ignores the enduring reality of Original Sin, especially in its power to infect the racially righteous no less than the racially sinful.”136 In essence, Wood, in the classic rhetorical gesture of O’Connor’s partisan critics, once again replicates the white South’s response to racial inequality: why concern ourselves with racial inequality in the here-and-now when everything will be remedied in the hereafter? To paraphrase Paul in the New Testament, O’Connor might have been forced to live in the world, but she zealously refuses to be of the world, especially the South’s racial struggles, which Wise Blood (and most of its critics) so studiously avoids.
No t e s 49. Flannery O’Connor, “Fiction Writer and His Country,” 32. 50. Flannery O’Connor, Wise Blood, 108. 51. O’Connor, “Fiction Writer and His Country,” 33–34. 52. Louise Y. Gossett, “Flannery O’Connor,” 490. 53. Laura B. Kennelly, “Exhortation in Wise Blood: Rhetorical Theory as an Approach to Flannery O’Connor,” 166.
Evangelicalism in Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood
67
54. Michael Kreyling, introduction to New Essays on Wise Blood, 2. 55. Ibid, 3. 56. Martha Stephens, The Question of Flannery O’Connor, 10. 57. Flannery O’Connor, The Complete Stories, 169. 58. Ibid, 174. 59. Flannery O’Connor, “Novelist and Believer,” 162. 60. Conversations with Flannery O’Connor, 58. 61. Matthew 11:12. 62. Thomas Schaub, American Fiction in the Cold War, 123. 63. Ibid, 125. 64. Ibid, 124. 65. Kreyling, introduction to New Essays on Wise Blood, 7. 66. Samuel Porter Jones (1846–1906) was one of America’s most popular evangelical preachers in the late nineteenth and very early twentieth centuries. He swore at his father’s deathbed to forsake alcohol and his profligate lifestyle, accepted Christianity shortly afterward and preached his first sermon within a week after his conversion (Henry Warner Bowden, “Samuel Porter Jones,” 367). 67. O’Connor, “Catholic Novelist in the Protestant South” 201–202. 68. Ibid, 203. 69. Ibid, 209. 70. Louis D. Rubin, “Flannery O’Connor and the Bible Belt,” 50. 71. Quoted in Kenneth K. Bailey, Southern White Protestantism in the Twentieth Century, 104. 72. Rubin, “Flannery O’Connor and the Bible Belt,” 74. 73. Flannery O’Connor, “Catholic Novelist in the Protestant South,” 207. 74. Flannery O’Connor, “Southern Fiction,” 44. 75. Rubin, “Flannery O’Connor and the Bible Belt,” 69. See Robert Brinkmeyer’s The Art and Vision of Flannery O’Connor for another insightful discussion of the common spiritual concerns O’Connor shared with her Protestant neighbors. 76. O’Connor, “Catholic Novelist in the Protestant South,” 202. 77. Flannery O’Connor, The Habit of Being, 350. 78. Samuel S. Hill, Southern Churches in Crisis, 92. 79. Samuel S. Hill, “The South’s Two Cultures,” 41. 80. O’Connor, “Catholic Novelist in the Protestant South,” 209. 81. Hill, “The South’s Two Cultures,” 36. 82. O’Connor, “Catholic Novelist in the Protestant South,” 202. 83. Carl Ficken, God’s Story and Modern Literature, ix–x. 84. Edgar T. Thompson, “God and the Southern Plantation System,” 61. 85. Flannery O’Connor, “The Nature and Aim of Fiction,” 72. 86. Brinkmeyer, The Art and Vision of Flannery O’Connor, 105. 87. Ibid, 10. 88. Several critics have discussed the symbolic function of Taulkinham in relation to some of the more decadent cities of the Bible. See Thomas Lorch, “Flannery O’Connor: Christian Allegorist,” for a reading of Wise Blood which examines O’Connor’s debt to Christian allegorists, such as Bunyan, and which reads Taulkinham as a contemporary version of Vanity Fair; Horton Davies, “Anagogical Signals in O’Connor’s Fiction,” for a catalogue of recurring religious symbols in the depiction of Wise Blood ’s apostate Southern city; and Sallie McFague, “The Parabolic in Faulkner, O’Connor, and Percy,” in which she finds that, like the Gospel parables
68
Timothy P. Caron
of Christ, O’Connor’s fiction is rooted in the everyday world while revealing a supernatural reality. See also Marshall Bruce Gentry’s Flannery O’Connor’s Religion of the Grotesque, particularly 123–24, for an insightful discussion of the absent and/or twisted theologies of Taulkinham’s citizens. 89. Emily Archer, “ ‘Stalking Joy’: Flannery O’Connor’s Accurate Naming,” 22. 90. James L. Green, “Enoch Emery and His Biblical Namesakes in Wise Blood,” 418. 91. Genesis 4:17. 92. Wise Blood, 26. 93. Harold Fickett also argues that Enoch’s religious desires are revealed through the rituals he constantly performs and even goes so far as to liken them to a type of liturgy (Harold Fickett, Flannery O’Connor: Images of Grace, 42–43). 94. O’Connor, “Southern Fiction,” 48. 95. Hebrews 11:5. 96. Wise Blood, 98. See Jon Lance Bacon’s essay, “A Fondness for Supermarkets: Wise Blood and Consumer Culture,” and his book-length study, Flannery O’Connor and Cold War Culture, for investigations of Wise Blood as critique of rampant American consumerism. 97. See William Allen’s “The Cage of Matter: The World as Zoo in Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood ” for a discussion of Enoch’s “translation” into the gorilla. Allen sees this change as prefigured in Enoch’s fascination with the zoo animals and as a reward for the religious offices performed at the zoo. 98. Wise Blood, 101. 99. Ibid, 102. 100. Richard Giannone, Flannery O’Connor and the Mystery of Love, 25. 101. Matthew 6:23. 102. Mark 8:18. 103. Wise Blood, 41. 104. Ibid, 67. 105. Ibid, 89. 106. Flannery O’Connor, “On Her Own Work,” 116. 107. Wise Blood, 9. 108. Ibid, 10. 109. Quoted in Fickett, Flannery O’Connor: Images of Grace, 39. In this passage, Fickett is quoting from an unpublished letter of O’Connor’s written as a summary of Wise Blood for potential publishers. She wrote this letter before Wise Blood was accepted for publication by Robert Giroux, who would eventually publish all of her work, and after John Selby had released her from a contract given to her based upon the merit of her early stories and her M.F.A. thesis. 110. Wise Blood, 60. 111. Ibid, 65. 112. Matthew 3:16; Mark 1:10; Luke 3:22; John 1:32. 113. Wise Blood, 10. 114. Ibid, 38. 115. Ibid, 39. 116. O’Connor, The Habit of Being, 350. 117. Wise Blood, 94–95. 118. Ibid, 96. 119. Fickett, Flannery O’Connor: Images of Grace, 43.
Evangelicalism in Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood
69
120. “A” is the designation given by Sally Fitzgerald in her editing of O’Connor’s correspondence to a woman who first wrote to O’Connor in 1955. “A” wished to remain anonymous in O’Connor’s collected letters. She and O’Connor wrote to each other from 1955 until O’Connor’s death in 1964. 121. O’Connor, The Habit of Being, 404. 122. Wise Blood, 105. 123. Ibid, 85. 124. Ibid, 105. This scene from Wise Blood is particularly reminiscent of several O’Connor short stories where murder and mayhem serve as the agents of God’s grace, bringing the victims to some saving knowledge of Christ. The Misfit, from “A Good Man is Hard to Find,” is probably the best known and most often studied example of this tendency in O’Connor’s work. 125. Ibid, 106. 126. Ibid, 108. 127. Giannone, Flannery O’Connor and the Mystery of Love, 13. 128. Wise Blood, 110–11. 129. Martin Hengel, The Pre-Christian Paul, 65. 130. Wise Blood, 113. 131. Ibid, 3. 132. Ibid, 120. 133. O’Connor, The Habit of Being, 320. 134. Ralph C. Wood, “Where Is the Voice Coming From?: Flannery O’Connor on Race,” 92. 135. Ibid. 136. Ibid, 100.
Bibl io gr a ph y Allen, William. “The Cage of Matter: The World as Zoo in Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood.” American Literature 58 (May 1986): 256–70. Archer, Emily. “ ‘Stalking Joy’: Flannery O’Connor’s Accurate Naming.” Religion and Literature 18 (Summer 1986): 17–30. Bacon, Jon Lance. “A Fondness for Supermarkets: Wise Blood and Consumer Culture.” New Essays on Wise Blood. Michael Kreyling, editor. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1995. . Flannery O’Connor and Cold War Culture. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1993. Bailey, Kenneth K. Southern White Protestantism in the Twentieth Century. New York: Harper & Row, 1964. Bailey, Thomas Pierce. Race Orthodoxy in the South. New York: Neale Publishing Company, 1914. Baker, Houston. Blues, Ideology, and Afro American Literature: A Vernacular Theory. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1984. Barthes, Roland. “Theory of the Text.” Ian McLeod, translator. Untying the Text: A PostStructuralist Reader. Robert Young, editor. Boston: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1981. Bleikasten, André. “The Heresy of Flannery O’Connor.” Critical Essays on Flannery O’Connor. Melvin J. Friedman and Beverly L. Clark, editors. Boston: G.K. Hall, 1985. . The Ink of Melancholy: Faulkner’s Novels from The Sound and the Fury to Light in August. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1990.
70
Timothy P. Caron
Blotner, Joseph. Faulkner: A Biography. One volume edition. New York: Vintage Books, 1991. . William Faulkner’s Library: A Catalogue. Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia, 1964. Boles, John B. “The Discovery of Southern Religious History.” Interpreting Southern History. John B. Boles, editor. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1987. Bowden, Henry Warner. “Samuel Porter Jones.” Encyclopedia of Religion in the South. Samuel S. Hill, editor. Macon GA: Mercer University Press, 1984. Brinkmeyer, Robert. The Art and Vision of Flannery O’Connor. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1989. Brooks, Cleanth. “Faulkner’s Ultimate Values.” On the Prejudices, Predilections, and Firm Beliefs of William Faulkner. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1987. Cash, W. J. The Mind of the South. New York: Random House, 1991. Coffee, Jessie. Faulkner’s Un-Christlike Characters: Biblical Allusions in the Novels, Ann Arbor: UMI Research Press, 1983. Cone, James H. “Black Theology as Liberation Theology.” African American Religious Studies: An Interdisciplinary Anthology. Gayraud Wilmore, editor. Durham: Duke University Press, 1984. . God of the Oppressed. New York: Seabury Press, 1975. Culler, Jonathon. “Presupposition and Intertextuality.” Modern Language Notes 19 (1976): 1380–96. Davies, Horton. “Anagogical Signals in Flannery O’Connor’s Fiction.” Thought 55 (1980): 428–38. Davis, Thadious. Faulkner’s “Negro”: Art and the Southern Context. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1983. Desmond, John F. Risen Sons: Flannery O’Connor’s Vision of History. Athens: University of Georgia Press, 1987. Dunjee, Roscoe and Carl Murphy. “Negro Editors on Communism: A Symposium of the American Negro Press.” Reprinted in August Meier & Elliott Rudwick’s Black Protest Thought in the Twentieth Century, New York: Bobbs-Merrill, 1971, Duvall, John N. “Murder and the Communities: Ideology In and Around Light in August.” Novel: A Forum on Fiction 20 (1987): 101–20. Eliot, T. S. “Tradition and the Individual Talent.” Contemporary Literary Criticism: Literary and Cultural Studies. Second edition. Robert Con Davis and Ronald Schleifer, editors. New York: Longman, 1989. Ellison, Ralph. “Change the Joke and Slip the Yoke.” Shadow and Act. New York: Random House, 1986. . “Remembering Richard Wright.” Going to the Territory. New York: Random House, 1986. . “The World and the Jug.” Shadow and Act. New York: Random House, 1972. Engels, Frederick. “On the Early History of Christianity.” On Religion. Karl Marx and Frederick Engels. New York: Schocken Books, 1964. Fabre, Michel. The Unfinished Quest of Richard Wright. Isabel Barzun, translator. William Morrow & Company: New York, 1973. Fadiman, Regina K. Faulkner’s Light in August: A Description and Interpretation of the Revisions. Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia, 1975. Faulkner, William. Light in August. New York: Vintage, 1972. . Lion in the Garden: Interviews with William Faulkner. James B. Meriwether and Michael Millgate, editors. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1968.
Evangelicalism in Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood
71
Feeley, Kathleen, Flannery O’Connor: Voice of the Peacock. New Brunswick NJ: Rutgers University Press, 1972. Felder, Cain H. “The Bible, Re-Contextualization, and the Black Religious Experience.” African American Religious Studies: An Interdisciplinary Anthology. Gayraud Wilmore, editor. Durham: Duke University Press, 1939. . “Race, Racism, and the Biblical Narratives.” Stony the Road We Trod: African-American Biblical Interpretation. Cain Hope Felder, editor. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 1991. Ficken, Carl. God’s Story and Modern Literature. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1985. Fickett, Harold (text) and Douglas R. Gilbert (photographs). Flannery O’Connor: Images of Grace. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1986. Flynt, Wayne J. “One in the Spirit, Many in the Flesh: Southern Evangelicals.” Varieties of Southern Evangelicalism. David E. Harrell, editor. Macon GA: Mercer University Press, 1981. Franchot, Jenny. “Invisible Domain: Religion and American Literary Studies.” American Literature 67/4 (December 1995): 833–42. Fredrickson, George M. The Black Image in the White Mind. New York: Harper & Row, 1971. Gates, Henry Louis, Jr. The Signifying Monkey: A Theory of Afro-American Literary Criticism. New York: Oxford University Press, 1988. Genovese, Eugene. Roll, Jordan, Roll: The World the Slaves Made. New York: Random House, 1971. Gentry, Marshall Bruce. Flannery O’Connor’s Religion of the Grotesque. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 1986. Giannone, Richard. Flannery O’Connor and the Mystery of Love. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1989. Gilroy, Paul. The Black Atlantic: Modernity and Double Consciousness. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1993. Girard, René. Violence and the Sacred. Patrick Gregory, translators. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1977. Gossett, Louise Y. “Flannery O’Connor.” The History of Southern Literature. Louis D. Rubin, Jr., et. al, editors. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1985. Gravely, Will B. “The Rise of African Churches in America: (1786–1822): Re-Examining the Contexts.” African-American Religious Studies: An Interdisciplinary Anthology. Gayraud Wilmore, editor. Duke University Press: Durham, 1989. Green, James L. “Enoch Emery and His Biblical Namesakes in Wise Blood.” Studies in Short Fiction 10 (1973): 417–19. Grisset, Michel. “Introduction: Faulkner Between the Texts.” Intertextuality in Faulkner. Michel Grisset and Noel Polk, editors. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 1985. Gwynn, Frederick and Joseph Blotner, editors. Faulkner in the University: Class Conferences at the University of Virginia, 1957–1958. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press, 1959. Hale, Grace Elizabeth. Making Whiteness: The Culture of Segregation in the South, 1890–1940. New York: Pantheon, 1998. Harrell, David Edwin, Jr. “Introduction.” Varieties of Southern Evangelicalism. David E. Harrell, Jr., editor. Macon GA: Mercer University Press, 1981. Harrington, Evans. “ ‘A Passion Week of the Heart’: Religion and Faulkner’s Art.” Faulkner and Religion. Doreen Fowler and Ann J. Abadie, editors. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 1991. Harris, Trudier. Exorcising Blackness: Historical and Literary Lynching and Burning Rituals. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1984.
72
Timothy P. Caron
Headon, David. “ ‘Beginning To See Things Really’: The Politics of Zora Neale Hurston.” Zora in Florida. Steve Glassman and Kathryn Lee Seidel, editors. Orlando: University of Central Florida Press, 1991. Hebel, Udo J. “Towards a Descriptive Poetics of Allusion.” Intertextuality. Heinrich F. Plett, editor. New York: Walter de Gruyter, 1991. Hemenway, Robert. Zora Neale Hurston: A Literary Biography. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1977. Hengel, Martin. The Pre-Christian Paul. Philadelphia: Trinity Press, 1991. Hill, Samuel S. The South and the North in American Religion. Athens: University of Georgia Press, 1980. . Southern Churches in Crisis. New York: Holt, Rinehart, & Winston, 1967. . “The South’s Two Cultures.” Religion and the Solid South. Samuel S. Hill, editor. Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1972. . “Survey of Southern Religious History.” Religion in the Southern States: A Historical Study. Samuel S. Hill, editor. Macon: Mercer University Press, 1983. Holman, C. Hugh. “The Unity of Faulkner’s Light in August.” The Roots of Southern Writing: Essays on the Literature of the American South. Athens: University of Georgia Press: 1972. The Holy Bible Containing the Old and New Testaments. Authorized King James Version. Meridian: New York, 1974. Hunt, John W. William Faulkner: Art in Theological Tension. Syracuse NY: Syracuse University Press, 1965. Hurd, Myles Raymond. “Between Blackness and Bitonality: Wright’s ‘Long Black Song.’ ” CLA Journal 35/1 (September 1991): 42–56. Hurston, Zora Neale. “Characteristics of Negro Expression.” Voices From the Harlem Renaissance. Nathan Huggins, editor. New York: Oxford University Press, 1976. . Dust Tracks on a Road. New York: Harper, 1991. . “The First One.” Ebony and Topaz: A Collectaena. Charles S. Johnson, editor. Freeport NY: Books for Libraries Press, 1971. . “How It Feels to Be Colored Me.” The Norton Anthology of American Literature. Third Edition. Volume 2. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 1989. . Moses, Man of the Mountain. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1984. . Mules and Men. New York: Harper Perennial, 1990. . The Sanctified Church. Berkeley: Turtle Island Press, 1983. . Seraph on the Suwanee. New York: Harper Perennial, 1991. . “Stories of Conflict.” Richard Wright: The Critical Reception. John M. Reilly, editor. New York: Burt Franklin & Company, 1978. Jackson, Blyden. “Some Negroes in the Land of Goshen.” Tennessee Folklore Society Bulletin 19 (December 1953): 103–107. Jacobs, Harriet A. Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl. Written by Herself. Jean Fagan Yellin, editor. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1987. JanMohamed, Abdul. “Rehistoricizing Wright: The Psychopolitical Function of Death in Uncle Tom’s Children.” Richard Wright. Harold Bloom, editor. New York: Chelsea House, 1987. Jenny, Laurent. “The Strategy of Form.” French Literary Theory Today: A Reader. Tzvetan Todorov, editor. R. Carter, translator. London: Cambridge University Press, 1982. Jordan, June. “Notes Toward a Black Balancing of Love and Hatred.” Civil Wars. Boston: Beacon Press, 1981. Jordan, Winthrop D. White Over Black. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1968.
Evangelicalism in Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood
73
Kennelly, Laura B. “Exhortation in Wise Blood: Rhetorical Theory as an Approach to Flannery O’Connor. Flannery O’Connor: New Perspectives. Sura P. Rath and Mary Neff Shaw, editors. Athens: University of Georgia Press, 1996. Kinnamon, Keneth. The Emergence of Richard Wright: A Study in Literature and Society. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1972. Klehr, Harvey. The Heyday of American Communism: The Depression Decade. New York: Basic Books, 1984. Kreyling, Michael. Introduction to New Essays on Wise Blood. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1995. Larson, Thomas. “A Political Vision of Afro-American Culture: Richard Wright’s ‘Bright and Morning Star.’ ” Richard Wright: Myths and Realities. New York: Garland Publishing, 1988. Leonard, Bill J. “A Theology for Racism: Southern Fundamentalists and the Civil Rights Movement.” Southern Landscapes. Tony Badger, Walter Edgar, and Jan Nordby Gretlund, editors. Tübingen: Stauffenburg Verlag, 1996. Levine, Lawrence. Black Culture and Black Consciousness: Afro-American Thought From Slavery to Freedom. New York: Oxford University Press, 1977. Lincoln, C. Eric. “Black Religion and the Black Church.” Black Experience in Religion. C. Eric Lincoln, editor. New York: Anchor Press, 1974. . “The Development of Black Religion in America.” African American Religious Studies: An Interdisciplinary Anthology. Gayraud Wilmore, editor. Durham: Duke University Press, 1989. Long, Charles H. “Interpretations of Black Religion in America.” Significations: Signs, Symbols, and Images in the Interpretation of Religion. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1986. Lorch, Thomas. “Flannery O’Connor: Christian Allegorist.” Critique 10 (1986): 69–80. Lowe, John. Jump at the Sun: Zora Neale Hurston’s Cosmic Comedy. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1994. . “Wright Writing Reading: Narrative Strategies in Uncle Tom’s Children.” Journal of the Short Story in English 11 (Autumn 1988): 49–74. Marable, Manning. “Religion and Black Protest Thought in African-American History.” African American Religious Studies. An Interdisciplinary Anthology. Gayraud Wilmore, editor. Durham: Duke University Press, 1989. May, John R. The Pruning Word: The Parables of Flannery O’Connor. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 1976. McClain, William B. “Free Style and a Closer Relationship to Life.” Black Experience in Religion. C. Eric Lincoln, editor. New York: Anchor Press, 1974. McFague, Sallie. “The Parabolic in Faulkner, O’Connor, and Percy.” Religion and Literature 15 (Spring 1983): 49–66. McKnight, Edgar V. The Bible and the Reader: An Introduction to Literary Criticism. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1985. Mencke, John G. Mulattoes and Race Mixture. Ann Arbor: UMI Research Press, 1979. Mitchell, Carlton. “Seventh-Day Adventists.” Encyclopedia of Religion in the South. Samuel S. Hill, editor. Macon: Mercer University Press, 1984. Mitchell, Henry. “Two Streams of Tradition.” Black Experience in Religion. C. Eric Lincoln, editor. New York: Anchor Press, 1974. Montgomery, William T. Under Their Own Vine and Fig Tree: The African-American Church in the South, 1865–1900. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1993. Morgan, Robert and John Barton. Biblical Interpretation. New York: Oxford University Press, 1988.
74
Timothy P. Caron
Morgan, Thaïs. “The Space of Intertextuality.” Intertextuality and Contemporary American Fiction. Patrick O’Donnell and Robert Con Davis, editors. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1989. Morrison, Toni. Playing in the Dark: Whiteness and Literary Imagination. New York: Harvard University Press, 1992. Nadel, Alan. “Translating the Past: Literary Allusions as Covert Criticism.” The Georgia Review 36 (Fall 1982): 639–51. Newman, Mark. “Southern Baptists and Desegregation, 1945–1980.” Southern Landscapes. Tony Badger, Walter Edgar, and Jan Nordby Gretlund, editors. Tübingen: Stauffenburg Verlag, 1996. O’Connor, Flannery. The Complete Stories. New York: Farrar, Strauss, & Giroux, 1971. . Conversations with Flannery O’Connor. Rosemary M. Magee, editor. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 1987. . The Habit of Being. Sally Fitzgerald, editor. New York: Vintage, 1980. . “The Catholic Writer in the Protestant South.” Mystery and Manners: Occasional Prose. Sally and Robert Fitzgerald, editors. New York: Farrar, Strauss, & Giroux, 1969. . “The Fiction Writer and His Country.” Mystery and Manners: Occasional Prose. Sally and Robert Fitzgerald, editors. New York: Farrar, Strauss, & Giroux, 1969. . “The Gothic in Southern Fiction.” Mystery and Manners. Sally and Robert Fitzgerald, editors. New York: Farrar, Straus, & Giroux, 1994. . “The Nature and Aim of Fiction.” Mystery and Manners: Occasional Prose. Sally and Robert Fitzgerald, editors. New York: Farrar, Strauss, & Giroux, 1969. . “Novelist and Believer.” Mystery and Manners. Sally and Robert Fitzgerald, editors. New York: Farrar, Strauss, and Giroux, 1994. . “On Her Own Work.” Mystery and Manners: Occasional Prose. Sally and Robert Fitzgerald, editors. New York: Farrar, Strauss, & Giroux, 1969. . “Southern Fiction.” Mystery and Manners: Occasional Prose. Sally and Robert Fitzgerald, editors. New York: Farrar, Strauss, & Giroux, 1969. . Wise Blood. Three by Flannery O’Connor. New York: Signet, 1983. Orr, Leonard. “Intertextuality and the Cultural Text in Recent Semiotics.” College English 48/8 (December 1986): 811–23. Peterson, Thomas Virgil. Ham and Japheth: The Mythic World of Whites in the Antebellum South. Metuchen NJ: American Theological Library Association, 1978. Plant, Deborah G. Every Tub Must Sit on Its Own Bottom: The Philosophy and Politics of Zora Neale Hurston. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1995. Raboteau, Albert J. Slave Religion: The “Invisible Institution” in the Antebellum South. New York: Oxford University Press, 1978. Rath, Sura P. and Mary Neff Shaw. Flannery O’Connor: New Perspectives. Athens: University of Georgia Press, 1996. Robinson, Cedric J. Black Marxism: The Making of the Black Radical Tradition. London: Zed Press, 1983. Rubin, Louis D. “Flannery O’Connor and the Bible Belt.” The Added Dimension: The Art and Mind of Flannery O’Connor. Melvin J. Friedman and Lewis Lawson, editors. New York: Fordham University Press, 1966. Schaub, Thomas Hill. American Fiction in the Cold War. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1991. Sheffey, Ruthe T. “Zora Neale Hurston’s Moses, Man of the Mountain: A Fictionalized Manifesto of the Imperatives of Black Leadership.” CLA Journal 29 (December 1985): 206–220.
Evangelicalism in Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood
75
Smith, H. Shelton. In His Image, But . . . : Racism in Southern Religion, 1780–1910. Durham: Duke University Press, 1972. Smith, Theophus H. Conjuring Culture: Biblical Formations of Black America. New York: Oxford University Press, 1994. Spillers, Hortense J. “Moving on Down the Line: Variations on the African-American Sermon.” The Bounds of Race: Perspectives on Hegemony and Resistance. Dominick LaCapra, editor. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1991. Stephens, Martha. The Question of Flannery O’Connor. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1973. Stepto, Robert B. From Behind the Veil: A Study of Afro-American Narrative. Chicago: University of Illinois Press, 1979. Sullivan, Nell M. “Persons in Pieces: Race and Aphanisis in Light in August.” Mississippi Quarterly 49/3 (1996): 497–518. Sundquist, Eric J. Faulkner: The House Divided. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1983. . “Faulkner, Race, and the Forms of American Fiction.” Faulkner and Race: Faulkner and Yoknapatawpha, 1986. Doreen Fowler and Ann J. Abadie, editors. Oxford: University Press of Mississippi, 1987. Thompson, Edgar T. “God and the Southern Plantation System.” Religion and the Solid South. Samuel S. Hill, editor. Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1972. Touchstone, Blake. “Planters and Slave Religion in the South.” Masters and Slaves in the House of the Lord: Race and Religion in the American South, 1740–1870. Lexington: University Press of Kentucky, 1988. Trotman, James C. “Our Myths and Wright’s Realities.” Richard Wright: Myths and Realities. James C. Trotman, editor. Garland Publishing: New York, 1988. Turner, Darwin T. In a Minor Chord:. Three Afro-American Writers and Their Search for Identity. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press, 1971. Vandersee, Charles. “American Parapedagogy for 2000 and Beyond: Intertextual, International, Industrial Strength.” American Literary History 6/3 (Fall 1994): 409–433. Walker, Alice. “Dedication—On Refusing to Be Humbled by Second Place in a Contest You Did Not Design: A Tradition by Now.” I Love Myself When I Am Laughing. Alice Walker, editor. New York: Feminist Press, 1979. Washington, Joseph R., Jr. “The Peculiar Peril and Promise of Black Folk Religion.” Varieties of Southern Evangelicalism. David E. Harrell, editor. Macon GA: Mercer University Press, 1981. . “Folk Religion and Negro Congregations: The Fifth Religion.” African American Religious Studies: An Interdisciplinary Anthology. Gayraud Wilmore, editor. Durham: Duke University Press, 1984. Watts, Leon W. “Caucuses and Caucasians.” Black Experience in Religion. C. Eric Lincoln, editor. New York: Anchor Press, 1974. Weathersby, H. L. “Sutpen’s Garden.” The Georgia Review 21 (1967): 354–69. Weinstein, Philip. Faulkner’s Subject: A Cosmos No One Owns. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1992. West, Cornel. “Religion and the Left.” Churches in Struggle: Liberation Theologies and Social Change in North America. New York: Monthly Review Press, 1986. Williamson, Joel. New People: Miscegenation and Mulattoes in the United States. New York: MacMillan, 1980. . A Rage for Order: Black/White Relations in the American South Since Emancipation. New York: Oxford University Press, 1986.
76
Timothy P. Caron
Wilson, Charles Reagan. “The Religious Culture: Distinctiveness and Social Change.” Judgement and Grace in Dixie: Southern Faiths from Faulkner to Elvis. Athens: University of Georgia Press, 1995. Wimbush, Vincent L. “The Bible and African-Americans: An Outline of an Interpretive History.” Stony the Road We Trod: African-American Biblical Interpretation. Cain Hope Felder, editor. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 1991. . “Biblical Historical Study as Liberation: Toward an Afro-Christian Hermeneutic.” African American Religious Studies: An Interdisciplinary Anthology. Gayraud Wilmore, editor. Durham: Duke University Press, 1984. Wittenberg, Judith Bryant. “Race in Light in August: Wordsymbols and Obverse Reflections.” The Cambridge Companion to William Faulkner. Philip M. Weinstein, editor. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1995. Wood, Forrest G. The Arrogance of Faith: Christianity and Race in America from the Colonial Era to the Twentieth Century. Boston: Northeastern University Press, 1991. Wood, Ralph C. “Where Is the Voice Coming From?: Flannery O’Connor on Race.” Flannery O’Connor Bulletin 22 (1993–1994): 90–118. Woodward, C. Vann. The Strange Career of Jim Crow. New York: Oxford University Press, 1974. Woodward, Richard B. “Cormac McCarthy’s Venomous Fiction,” The New York Times Magazine, 19 April 1992, 31. Wright, Richard. American Hunger. New York: Harper & Row, 1977. . Black Boy: A Record of Childhood and Youth. New York: Harper & Row, 1966. . “Blueprint for Negro Writing.” Voices from the Harlem Renaissance. Nathan Huggins, editor. Oxford University Press: New York, 1976. . “How ‘Bigger’ Was Born.” Introduction to Native Son. New York: Penguin, 1984. . Uncle Tom’s Children. New York: Harper & Row, 1965.
R ichard G iannone
The Prophet and the Word in the Desert
Go, lie down; and if he calls you, you shall say, “Speak, Lord, for your servant is listening.”
F
—1 Samuel 3:9
Do not be always wanting everything to turn out as you think it should, but rather as God pleases, then you will be undisturbed and thankful in your prayer. —Nilus, The Sayings of the Desert Fathers
rom 1938 to the summer of 1952, visitors to the backwoods of Tennessee would have seen a man devoting the last fourteen of his eighty four years to raising his grandnephew from infancy to adolescence. Getting to the site would take some doing. To reach it, one turns at the junction of Highway 56 onto a dirt road running ten miles. The route then becomes a twisting, lovely passage. The wide, unpaved road goes through thick growths of trees before narrowing into a rutted wagon path that crosses a field rising to a crest. The view is healing to the eye. Through a forked birch at this promontory, the visitor can see one-quarter mile down to a clearing with an unpainted, two-story shack settled between two chimneys. The homesite is Powderhead. Its inhabitants are Mason Tarwater, the great-uncle, and Francis Marion Tarwater, his grandnephew. These backcountry figures,
From Flannery O’Connor, Hermit Novelist, pp. 144–69. © 2000 by the Board of Trustees of the University of Illinois.
77
78
Richard Giannone
comprising a male world of two, are the heroes of O’Connor’s The Violent Bear It Away (1960). It would do well to pause at the journey’s end to see how these woodsmen live and to look closely at the locale in which they make their day. Patient, discerning eyes will find much to take in. Here is a snapshot of master and disciple epitomizing an ancient way of life that defines the ascetic sensibility shaping all the stories that O’Connor tells. The old man and the young boy are offspring of a family bloodline that George Rayber, the third male relative, describes as “flowing from some ancient source, some desert prophet or polesitter” (CW 402). For the Christian, that genealogy finds its fullest expression in fourth-century Egypt, in the life of a solitary, young peasant-landowner named Anthony. One day, he heard these words of Jesus read in church: “If you wish to be perfect, go, sell your possessions, and give the money to the poor . . . then come, follow me” (Matthew 19:21). Jesus’ charge spoke directly to Anthony; he sold all his property and went to live with an old man who had devoted his life to solitary prayer. In time, Anthony withdrew from the feet of his teacher into the desert, where his struggle to follow Jesus transformed the lonely waste into a paradise. Alone, the hermit developed a practice of fighting demons and controlling his body to find peace with God. If Anthony sought anonymity, he found fame. His daily discipline appeared to others as spectacular physical and spiritual feats that attracted widespread attention and many recruits. The man’s fame multiplied through Athanasius’s influential celebration entitled The Life of Anthony, which appeared about ten years after the renowned Egyptian’s death in 356 a.d. The Life of Anthony combines in this one man the prestige of the pagan wise man and the honor of the Christian holy man with the biblical “man of God.” The man of desert solitude became a spiritual exemplar for all ages. George Rayber cites the models of the unbridled Hebrew prophet and Simeon Stylites, the legendary mid-fifth-century Syrian saint who stood atop a sixty-foot pillar in the desert, to explain the religious call besetting his family as an “affliction” (CW 402). For Rayber, a man of reason, living out God’s word before others is an invitation “he knew to be madness;” for him, prophecy and chosen alienation from society are “irrational and abnormal” (CW 401) demands that he personally fights against through ridicule and even attempted murder. In scorning the desert call, Rayber is not alone. For some, Simeon’s standing on a pillar was an extravagant instance of the morbid phenomenon of asceticism. Others, however, found the solitary figure seeking freedom up in the open air a holy man to be admired and emulated (Lives of Simeon Stylites 15–23). For Simeon’s followers, his pillar (where he spent twenty-eight years) was not a place of punishment but an altar. From his lofty perch, the renouncer moved heavenward by means of taking into
The Prophet and the Word in the Desert
79
himself the suffering and cruelty of the world around him. More than an icon, Simeon’s body gave witness in flesh—not metaphor—to sickness, hunger, and pain. Rayber is aware of the harsh extravagance of ascetic life but not of its contradiction. The schoolteacher’s one-sided judgment is instructive about desert spirituality and its expression in The Violent Bear It Away. Whereas Rayber remarks the physical outrage of Simeon on the pillar, he misses how in withdrawing for spiritual reasons the saint changed people’s lives—not only through miracles but also in simple acts of kindness and justice. By devoting oneself to God, as will be shown, the hermit is called to serve all in need. O’Connor’s heroes in The Violent Bear It Away are modern variations drawn from the ancient profiles of desert life. Elder (abba) and younger Tarwater, described most simply, are solitaries. . . . [T]he Greek word for solitary is monachos, which yields our word monk, a forbidding word for O’Connor’s good country people and an alien status in every culture. Deliberately separated from society, they are hermits, which comes from eremos, meaning desert. In Hebrew and Christian reflection, desert and wilderness are interchangeable conditions in sacred history; and at different times in The Violent Bear It Away, Powderhead resembles both desert and wilderness. Monk, hermit, desert, and wilderness are charged words in the spiritual vocabulary. To appreciate life in Powderhead, one would need to intensify matters by paying even more attention than in the previous chapters to the loaded term ascesis, which in The Violent Bear It Away involves a training and practice whose essence seeks to imbibe the spirit of Scripture. That vital principle embraces the prophetic call of the Hebrew prophets and the renewed embodiment of that vocation in the life of Jesus. This continuum has its basis in spiritual discipline; the practice commended in Powderhead is that of the desert. O’Connor’s recluses are authentic ascetics. They lead a disciplined life of prayer, study, and subsistence farming as rigorous as the regimens maintained in many organized cloisters or charterhouses. Asceticism is a universal phenomenon, and not necessarily religious or even salutary (as becomes clear when one turns to the life of George Rayber). Christian ascetics embrace the rigors of bodily and spiritual training in solitary starkness to draw close to God. The Hebrew prophets and Jesus, who were themselves models for the desert mothers and fathers, guide Mason Tarwater and reign in Powderhead. As in biblical time and during late antiquity, the search in Tennessee involves not speculative knowledge but the religious experience from which ascetic practice is born. The fruits of this experience are fulfilled in the nitty-gritty of daily life. The ruling culture beyond the secluded Tarwater world has little sympathy for old Mason’s ways in the woods. Mason need not concern himself with the hostility, however, for controversy has always surrounded the ascetic
80
Richard Giannone
life. In Edward Gibbon’s famous analysis, Christianity’s alteration of the ferocious Roman temper and civic structure led Gibbon to a stern attack on the indolence of those ascetics who disturbed the accepted way of Christian life by retreating to the nearby Egyptian and Syrian deserts. The Reformation, of course, saw this solitary kind of monasticism as disparaging the body and regarded its denials as unscriptural. The latter charge holds partial truth because Jesus was not a solitary, except on crucial occasions, but a man of public involvement. Such reservations about ascetic solitude would not bring Mason Tarwater out of the woods. Mason, O’Connor’s prophet for our time, is not at all inclined to give up his antisocial life in favor of public acceptance. Far from being persuasive, advice from the heathen culture that Mason abjures only reassures him of the value of flight. Indeed, the old man celebrates his status as stranger in an estranging world. He is incomprehensibility in human form. Besides his enigmatic ways, there is his unfathomable goal of intimacy with God through service as a prophet; and that relation is an extreme Christian mystery holding truths beyond Mason’s own understanding. He does know that to reach God he must pull away from society, and his place on the edge of the settled land marks a more daring displacement than geographical remoteness. Mason’s fearless striking out into the unknown of divine union lands him on the limits of his body, spirit, and personality. There, beyond society and self, old Tarwater seeks to recover the connection with God that O’Connor believes is the fundamental bond for each person. This chapter explores the primary impulses and cultural significance of asceticism and the trials of solitude in The Violent Bear It Away. The discussion first sketches the historical context giving rise and meaning to religious withdrawal in the novel and then takes up the biblical and patristic sources generating the novel’s ascetic action. That action involves Tarwater’s combating his demons and traces his flight and return home. As O’Connor concludes the hero’s weeklong struggle with a rite honoring his self-donation, so this chapter ends by showing how, through the poetics of solitude, the novel O’Connor called “a very minor hymn to the Eucharist” (HB 387) comes together like a liturgical song. * * * O’Connor precisely brackets the climactic events of The Violent Bear It Away within one week and sets its essential antecedent action between 1938 and 1952, a period corresponding to the formative years of the modern world that she judged “terrible” (HB 90). Briefly to historicize the novel is to glimpse a world where the engagements register both the terrors driving a person to find refuge from society and the political urgencies calling to the solitary for help. During the fourteen years that Mason lives as a solitary—fighting
The Prophet and the Word in the Desert
81
his inner demons and dedicating himself to raising his grandnephew to be a prophet—the powerful nations committed themselves to turning the planet into a charnel house. In November 1938, the year Francis Marion Tarwater was born, Kristallnacht inaugurated through mob violence the systematic oppression of German Jews; then there was the wearing of the yellow stars, followed by deportations and finally the camps. The moral distance between Hitler’s Germany and O’Connor’s Powderhead is telling. The people who are hated in the mighty European power are honored in the primitive Tennessee woods. In Powderhead, Israel’s prophets hold the healing answer to the terrible wounds evidenced in the ravages of World War II. Through their keen awareness of evil and misery, these ancient bearers of God’s word articulate the ways through which to overcome oppression and break spiritual chains. Israel’s prophets are heroes of the word; but, even more through their exemplary alienation from the sinful life, they are heroes of being. The Violent Bear It Away reaches all the way back to Moses, Ezekiel, Elijah, John the Baptist, and Jesus to show how asceticism and prophecy join forces to combat the demons spreading their crepe wings over the modern world. The vaunted scientific progress of the twentieth century spawned a technology of death. Ovens, crematories, gas chambers, and artillery wiped out over fifty million people during World War II with businesslike productivity that occasioned patriotic celebration. On the Christian Feast of the Transfiguration, 6 August 1945, the United States displayed its expertise by employing atomic fission on humans, thereby changing the shape of fear while altering the earth’s future. Disintegration continued after peace treaties were signed. Millions more were exiled and became “displaced persons” (an impassive epithet that O’Connor recharged, as seen earlier, with theological power). Then there was the Korean War (1950–53), which raged while Mason was teaching Tarwater the history of the world from Adam’s eviction from Eden to “the Day of Judgment” (CW 331). Even within the shielding Tennessee pines, there persisted the anguish of racism and the prophet’s own violence and iron self-will in disobedience to the command of God, whom he vows to honor. These were some of the social forces darkening the period in which the Tarwater chronicle unfolds. Acutely alive to the moral climate in which she lived, O’Connor summed up the state of things with more than usual precision: “Right now,” O’Connor wrote on 6 September 1955, “the whole world seems to be going through a dark night of the soul” (HB 100). Whereas the clinician Walker Percy diagnosed the institutionalizing of death as the thanatos syndrome, and the cultural observer Don DeLillo later saw the proliferating technologies swell into a cult of death, the ascetic O’Connor defined the malady as an inner extinguishment. For the hermit novelist, the vortex of
82
Richard Giannone
political and psychological turmoil is the inborn center of the person, of the spirit. Terror, impotence, and egotism seep into the inner world to distort the characters’ perception of themselves and creation. Divided within, they are uprooted from their native ground and alienated from God. During these bloodthirsty years, O’Connor witnessed humanity’s stark capacity to destroy its own species and habitat, and she described that willful malice in the warring human relations of her narratives. The “dark night” that O’Connor observed not only eclipsed decency but disabled the soul’s discernment of evil, blurring the line between mad fantasy and sane recognition of evil. But the ruins of society are, for O’Connor, as the shards of the Roman Empire were for the desert-fathers and mothers, stuff for the kingdom. The ancient hermits believed, Thomas Merton explains, that they could “pull the whole world to safety after them” (Wisdom, “Introduction” 23). In her own seclusion, O’Connor developed a similar concern for her age. The effect of her eremitic withdrawal was different than Merton’s political militancy but equally vast. In advance of and alongside Vatican II (1962–65), she conducted a one-woman aggiornamento that brought her readers and church into vital confrontation with the modern world, which in a sense became her hermitage. O’Connor’s good country people would be shocked to learn that they had any connection with a primitive way of life centered on self-denial. Ascetic life belongs to the unreformed past that these advanced people of gumption, whose guidance comes from their own private will, have outgrown. The pangs of flesh, however, make known the infirmities of desire as O’Connor’s characters stare into a drainage ditch, a pool of vomitus, puddles of blood, a raped body, and sweeping tides of darkness. Willful they are, but renouncers they become, amazed and blessed by having their cherished personal wishes violated and brought into alignment with God. They all end up where there is no company, where nobody can follow. Long before illness sent O’Connor to this forlorn place, a desert father reassured humankind that “humility is the land where God wants us to go and offer sacrifice” (Merton, Wisdom 83 [53]). This strange land of surrender is Powderhead. The Violent Bear It Away sets out to draw more firmly that vanishing boundary between a world hostile to life and a sphere of true human order fostering dignity and holiness. Powderhead marks off that border. Its red hills contain a deep withinness. Here is an “empty place” “where there’s nothing” (CW 352), a “ ‘lonesome place’ ” (CW 357) that has the force of a character. The woods are a wilderness with the desert’s stark isolation that drives its inhabitants to their spiritual roots. Daily life is a struggle to maintain footing on the hard ground of being. The truths of Powderhead are known to old Mason, for they run deep in his nature and teaching. With death in sight—and mind-
The Prophet and the Word in the Desert
83
ful that his young charge might turn to George Rayber, who disavowed his prophetic call—Mason admonishes young Tarwater: “ ‘And when I’m gone, you’ll be better off in these woods by yourself with just as much light as the sun wants to let in than you’ll be in the city with him [Rayber]’ ” (CW 344). The red soil, fed by the sun, reveals the plan and promise of God as taking all time to complete. Mason sees himself as a child of the promise—the prophet and heir obliged to train Tarwater as his successor to speak God’s word before others. Before confronting society’s apostasy, Tarwater must admit to and fight against evil in himself: his demons. Mason’s training is rigorous because the battle for Tarwater will be daunting. This hidden warfare demands a life of self-denial and discipline (ascesis) to resist the enemy. Mason is a seasoned veteran of this unseen war against inner evil, and he knows that the struggle is excruciating and fought with meager human resources against superior opponents. To begin with, there is always the human inclination to take the easy way by following one’s own will rather than the hard commandment of God. And so, over the years, Mason wanders into the remotest parts of the woods to thrash out his willfulness with the Lord. Alone, he endures blistering assaults that culminate in a consuming interior fire, leaping in a wildcat’s fury, to claw away any resistance to God. There are other powerful demons in Mason to rend. His faults include wanton violence, a misguided apocalypticism, and a share in Rayber’s following a different moral course than he had hoped for. Even the teacher needs correction. The battle is a ferocious taming of Mason’s tigerish will, and the agony continues until he “couldn’t stand the Lord one instant longer” (CW 358); and then he got drunk. The wounds Mason suffers in wrestling with God are acute. Exhaustion plunges Mason deeply into his heart so as to know its waywardness, its capacity for evil, and its self-deception. He grasps these modulations from within the shattered condition he shares with all humankind. Such depth of passion consists of participation in God’s love and freedom and is made known by the wooden cross that Mason wants over his grave. To recognize the extent of Mason’s sinfulness and the intensity of his inner warfare is to marvel at the outcome of his struggle. Mason achieved the almost impossible task of being a holy man in evil times. He stood guard over sacred texts in the face of public reproach. His is a life well lived. Those around him could feel the old man’s profundity of spirit. “ ‘He was deep in this life,’ ” Buford Munson eulogizes at the beginning of the novel, “ ‘he was deep in Jesus’ misery’ ” (CW 360). With Jesus, Mason fights against Satan. By opening himself to the full range of experience to endure the painful fight against his personal evil, Mason holds all of humanity in the healing presence of Jesus’ passion and obedience to God’s will. The outcome of his solitary
84
Richard Giannone
warfare and the goal of his teaching are one and the same: freedom. “ ‘I saved you to be free, your own self!’ ” (CW 339) Mason reminds Tarwater. Being one’s true self, as Mason’s immersion in Jesus’ misery exemplifies, frees one to love, to see Jesus in the suffering of others, and fearlessly to proclaim God’s word before others to liberate them from the captivity of sin. As Mason goes deeper into Jesus’ life, he translates over time the Gospel into the many various circumstances of life. In this sacramental way, Tarwater, his disciple, comprehends the search for God through living principles in everyday activities. The route to this recognition for young Tarwater runs across his pubertal body, through the wilderness of his tormenting choices, and into the solitude of his cracked heart. The front line of Tarwater’s decisive battle is his will, just as it was for the ancient solitaries. For O’Connor, freedom of the human will involves, as seen in Wise Blood, “many wills conflicting in one man” (CW 1265). O’Connor’s emphasis on the will in its multiplicity reiterates a crucial desert issue. In their quest for holiness, the ancient ascetics were preoccupied with contending desires, and it was precisely the private will that blocked their search. Only by taming the personal will can one move toward God (Sayings, Poemen 54 [174]). Out of the struggle to overcome the impediments of the self-will, the desert-dwellers perceived a connection between human passions and the devil; and that patristic understanding of demons inhabiting our disordered emotions opens a direct way into O’Connor’s controversial reintroduction of Satan into the postmodern, postsuperstitious world of The Violent Bear It Away. A better position from which to understand the demonology in The Violent Bear It Away can be achieved if one pauses briefly to consider the view of evil forces held by the desert mothers and fathers. With the rest of the ancient world, the hermits believed in supernatural beings, both helpful (angels, or messengers) and harmful (satans, or adversaries). The ammas and abbas persistently probed from various directions the operation of these powerful beings. Dorotheos of Gaza, in his Discourses, puts his inquiry with the prosaic brilliance characteristic of the desert-dwellers. He asks his brothers: “Why is the devil called not only ‘enemy,’ but also ‘adversary’?” Dorotheos’s answer goes to the heart of the inextinguishable spiritual energy of the satanic: “He is called ‘enemy’ because he is a hater of men, one who hates what is good, a traitor; an ‘adversary,’ because he always puts obstacles in the way of good” (2 [95]). Such clear-eyed perceptions provided the groundwork on which the solitaries built their knowledge of their opponents. Demons (from the Greek daimones), the hermits came to realize, were deceitful agents waging war against the true God and Jesus. Demons had a power over humans, who must vie, in Saint Paul’s words, “against the cosmic powers of this present darkness, against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly places” (Ephesians 6:12). The desert
The Prophet and the Word in the Desert
85
solitaries mortified their wills and bodies to develop the self-mastery needed to combat the hosts of wickedness assaulting them. That same ascetic control is the discipline that young Tarwater must cultivate to overcome the identical evil agents attacking him. Satan targets the boy precisely because he is raised to serve God. Indeed, the demons swarming both the modern and the ancient worlds hold a special animosity for anyone with spiritual longings. The moment Anthony takes up the life of prayer, the devil hurls thoughts of sexual pleasure before him to turn Anthony’s attention from God. Whether defeated or successful, the devil never lets up. No sooner does Anthony recover from horrible whippings by a demonic multitude than the throng of “beasts and reptiles” attacks him (Athanasius 9 [38]). Never far away and always dusting the human mind with dissuasions, the evil spirits rush to check any inclination toward God. The demons’ intention is to ingratiate their presence into human consciousness by any means. The demons attacking the desert ascetics reassert their malice in The Violent Bear It Away. With updated garb and southern vernacular (easy maneuvers for spirits), the demons pursue their fixed goals against Tarwater: they hate him and put obstacles before any good that his great-uncle had taught him to seek. Insinuation is a mere preliminary to the domination they seek over him. It is a measure of how intimately desert spirituality runs in O’Connor’s sensibility that she intuitively dramatizes Tarwater’s trial as being caught in the swift downward tide of the satanic “thought-flow” charted by the ancient solitaries. The metaphor of thought-flow comes from the Greek logismos, an important word in patristic texts that means thought or idea. In ascetic-monastic usage, logismos most frequently occurs in the plural, logismoi, and is invariably allied to demons to mean evil or passionate thoughts. “Evil thoughts,” says Poemen, “are suggested by the demons” (Sayings, Poemen 21 [170]). The word logismoi recurs in The Life of Anthony and in Origen (Bacht 956–58). Evagrius, a learned Greek among unlettered Egyptian hermits, intending to teach the cunning of demons, in the Praktikos enumerates eight logismoi (the seven deadly sins plus acedia) through which the evil spirits