THE FAMILIES AND GENERA OF VASCULAR PLANTS
Edited by K. Kubitzki
Volumes published in this series Volume I
Pteridop...
334 downloads
9356 Views
23MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
THE FAMILIES AND GENERA OF VASCULAR PLANTS
Edited by K. Kubitzki
Volumes published in this series Volume I
Pteridophytes and Gymnosperms Edited by K.U. Kramer and P.S. Green (1990) Date of publication: 28.9.1990
Volume II
Flowering Plants. Dicotyledons. Magnoliid, Hamamelid and Caryophyllid Families Edited by K. Kubitzki, J.G. Rohwer, and V. Bittrich (1993) Date of publication: 28.7.1993
Volume III
Flowering Plants. Monocotyledons: Lilianae (except Orchidaceae) Edited by K. Kubitzki (1998) Date of publication: 27.8.1998
Volume IV
Flowering Plants. Monocotyledons: Alismatanae and Commelinanae (except Gramineae) Edited by K. Kubitzki (1998) Date of publication: 27.8.1998
Volume V
Flowering Plants. Dicotyledons: Malvales, Capparales and Non-betalain Caryophyllales Edited by K. Kubitzki and C. Bayer (2003) Date of publication: 12.9.2002
Volume VI
Flowering Plants. Dicotyledons: Celastrales, Oxalidales, Rosales, Cornales, Ericales Edited by K. Kubitzki (2004) Date of publication: 21.1.2004
Volume VII
Flowering Plants. Dicotyledons: Lamiales (except Acanthaceae including Avicenniaceae) Edited by J.W. Kadereit (2004) Date of publication: 13.4.2004
Volume VIII Flowering Plants. Eudicots: Asterales Edited by J.W. Kadereit and C. Jeffrey (2007) Volume IX
Flowering Plants. Eudicots: Berberidopsidales, Buxales, Crossosomatales, Fabales p.p., Geraniales, Gunnerales, Myrtales p.p., Proteales, Saxifragales, Vitales, Zygophyllales, Clusiaceae Alliance, Passifloraceae Alliance, Dilleniaceae, Huaceae, Picramniaceae, Sabiaceae Edited by K. Kubitzki (2007)
The Families and Genera of Vascular Plants Edited by K. Kubitzki
IX
Flowering Plants · Eudicots Berberidopsidales, Buxales, Crossosomatales, Fabales p.p., Geraniales, Gunnerales, Myrtales p.p., Proteales, Saxifragales, Vitales, Zygophyllales, Clusiaceae Alliance, Passifloraceae Alliance, Dilleniaceae, Huaceae, Picramniaceae, Sabiaceae
Volume Editor: K. Kubitzki in Collaboration with C. Bayer and P. F. Stevens
With 174 Figures
123
Professor Dr. Klaus Kubitzki Universität Hamburg Biozentrum Klein-Flottbek und Botanischer Garten Ohnhorststraße 18 22609 Hamburg Germany
Library of Congress Control Number: 2006928744
ISBN-10 3-540-32214-0 Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York ISBN-13 978-3-540-32214-6 Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permissions for use must always be obtained from Springer-Verlag. Violations are liable for prosecution under the German Copyright Law. Springer is a part of Springer Science+Business Media springer.com © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2007 The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Cover design: WMXDesign, Heidelberg, Germany Typesetting and production: LE-TEX Jelonek, Schmidt & Vöckler GbR, Leipzig, Germany Printed on acid-free paper
31/3150/YL – 5 4 3 2 1 0
Preface
The present volume contains treatments of various eudicot orders which all are strongly supported in molecular analyses. A first group comprises Proteales, Buxales and the enigmatic Sabiaceae which, together with Ranunculales and Trochodendrales, treated earlier in Vol. II of this series, represent the basal grade of early-diverging eudicots. Although all of them have clearly tri-orate pollen, making them eudicots, they otherwise lack the strict eudicot floral organisation, particularly with regard to flower merosity, phyllotaxis and perianth structure. The same is true for the order Gunnerales which, however, according to findings of molecular systematics, forms part of the strongly supported core eudicots. All these orders to some extent bridge the morphological gap between basal angiosperms and typical core eudicots. Plesiomorphic floral traits, although less pronounced, are also found among the isolated but clearly core eudicotyledonous Saxifragales, treated in this volume, and particularly in the early-diverging woody families of this order. Some of these latter families were included in Vol. II, which followed a classification used prior to the discovery of the modern concept of Saxifragales. The exact interrelationships among the early-diverging eudicot orders still remain largely unresolved. This is even more true for many of the core eudicot orders included in the present volume, i.e. Vitales, Crossosomatales, Geraniales, Zygophyllales and Myrtales, and also for two of the families not assigned to order, i.e. Huaceae and Picramniaceae. A possible relationship between Dilleniaceae and woody Caryophyllales, as suggested by recent studies, opens an interesting new perspective on the evolution of this family. Included in this volume are two subclades of the vast Malpighiales. These are Passifloraceae with two satellite families, and Clusiaceae/Hypericaceae with Podostemaceae, which recently have been identified as very close relatives. My deep thanks go to all authors of this volume, who have provided such highly interesting and scholarly contributions, and to all those who have freely shared additional information and/or have commented on earlier drafts of the contributions. These include B.G. Briggs, T. Clifford, G. Jordan, B. Makinson, P. Olde, R. Barker, J.A. Doyle, P.J. Rudall and C.A. Furness (Proteaceae); H. Manitz (Aphanopetalaceae); A.E. Orchard (Haloragaceae); P.H. Linder and M. Weigend (Geraniales); A. Bernhard and W.J.J.O. de Wilde (Passifloraceae); the late M. Ricardi S. (Malesherbiaceae); I. Jäger-Zürn and T. Philbrick (Podostemaceae); and S. Renner, P.G. Wilson and J. Schönenberger (Myrtales). I am also grateful to M.L. Matthews and P.K. Endress for showing me their papers prior to publication elsewhere. Mark C. Chase is thanked for always making available the newest results of his pathbreaking studies. The copyright holders of the illustrations included in this volume are thanked for their generous permission to use their valuable material. As always, it is a pleasure to acknowledge the agreeable collaboration with the staff of Springer-Verlag, who kindly responded to all requests I had in connection with the production of this volume, and to thank Monique T. Delafontaine for her meticulous copy editing of the manuscript. Hamburg, September 2006
K. Kubitzki
Contents
Introduction to the Groups Treated in this Volume K. Kubitzki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction to Berberidopsidales . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction to Buxales . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction to the Clusiaceae Alliance (Malpighiales) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction to Crossosomatales . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction to Fabales . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction to Geraniales . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction to Gunnerales . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction to Myrtales . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction to the Passifloraceae Alliance (“Passiflorales” = Malpighiales) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction to Proteales . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction to Saxifragales . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction to Vitales . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction to Zygophyllales . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Families Unassigned to Order . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . General References
1 1 2 3 3 5 5 7 7 12 12 15 18 19 20
............................................
21
Aextoxicaceae
K. Kubitzki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
23
Alzateaceae
S.A. Graham . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
26
Aphanopetalaceae
K. Kubitzki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
29
Aphloiaceae
K. Kubitzki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
31
Berberidopsidaceae
K. Kubitzki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
33
Bonnetiaceae
A.L. Weitzman, K. Kubitzki and P.F.Stevens . . . . .
36
Buxaceae
E. Köhler . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
40
Clusiaceae-Guttiferae
P.F. Stevens . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
48
Combretaceae
C.A. Stace . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
67
Crassulaceae
J. Thiede and U. Eggli . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
83
Crossosomataceae
V. Sosa . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119
Crypteroniaceae
S.S. Renner . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 123
Daphniphyllaceae
K. Kubitzki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 127
VIII
Contents
Didymelaceae
E. Köhler . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 129
Dilleniaceae
J.W. Horn . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 132
Geissolomataceae
F. Forest . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 155
Geraniaceae
F. Albers and J.J.A. Van der Walt . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 157
Grossulariaceae
M. Weigend . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 168
Gunneraceae
H.P. Wilkinson and L. Wanntorp . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 177
Haloragaceae
K. Kubitzki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 184
Huaceae
C. Bayer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 191
Hypericaceae
P.F. Stevens . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 194
Iteaceae
K. Kubitzki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 202
Ixerbaceae
J.V. Schneider . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 205
Krameriaceae
B.B. Simpson . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 208
Ledocarpaceae
M. Weigend . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 213
Leeaceae
J. Wen . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 221
Lythraceae
S.A. Graham . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 226
Malesherbiaceae
K. Kubitzki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 247
Melianthaceae
H.P. Linder . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 250
Oliniaceae
M. von Balthazar and J. Schönenberger . . . . . . 260
Paeoniaceae
M. Tamura . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 265
Passifloraceae
C. Feuillet and J.M. MacDougal . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 270
Penaeaceae
J. Schönenberger, E. Conti and F. Rutschmann . 282
Penthoraceae
J. Thiede . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 292
Peridiscaceae
C. Bayer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 297
Picramniaceae
K. Kubitzki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 301
Podostemaceae
C.D.K. Cook and R. Rutishauser . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 304
Polygalaceae
B. Eriksen and C. Persson . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 345
Proteaceae
P.H. Weston . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 364
Pterostemonaceae
K. Kubitzki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 405
Quillajaceae
K. Kubitzki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 407
Rhynchocalycaceae
J. Schönenberger . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 409
Sabiaceae
K. Kubitzki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 413
Saxifragaceae
D.E. Soltis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 418
Stachyuraceae
J.V. Schneider . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 436
Staphyleaceae
S.L. Simmons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 440
Strasburgeriaceae
W.C. Dickison . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 446
Contents
IX
Surianaceae
J.V. Schneider . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 449
Tetracarpaeaceae
K. Kubitzki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 456
Turneraceae
M.M. Arbo . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 458
Vitaceae
J. Wen . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 467
Vochysiaceae
M.L. Kawasaki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 480
Zygophyllaceae
M.C. Sheahan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 488
Additions and Corrections to Volumes II–VI . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 501 Index to Scientific Names . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 503
List of Contributors
Albers, Focke
Botanischer Garten, Universität Münster, Schlossgarten 3, 48149 Münster, Germany
Arbo, María M.
Instituto de Botánica del Nordeste, Casilla de Correo 209, 3400 Corrientes, Rep. Argentina
Balthazar, Maria von
Swedish Museum of Natural History, Division of Palaeobotany, P.O. Box 50007, 10405 Stockholm, Sweden
Bayer, Clemens
Palmengarten der Stadt Frankfurt, Siesmayerstr. 61, 60323 Frankfurt/Main, Germany
Conti, Elena
Institut für Systematische Botanik und Botanischer Garten, Universität Zürich, Zollikerstr. 107, 8008 Zürich, Switzerland Institut für Systematische Botanik und Botanischer Garten, Universität Zürich, Zollikerstr. 107, 8008 Zürich, Switzerland (deceased)
Cook, Christopher D.K. Dickison, W.C. Eggli, Urs Eriksen, Bente
Sukkulenten-Sammlung, Mythenquai 88, 8002 Zürich, Switzerland Department of Botany, University of Göteborg, P.O. Box 461, 40530 Göteborg, Sweden
Feuillet, Christian
Department of Botany, Smithsonian Institution, P.O. Box 37012, Washington, DC 20013-7012, USA
Forest, Felix L.
School of Biological Sciences, Plant Sciences Laboratories, The University of Reading, Reading RG6 6AS, UK
Graham, Shirley A.
Missouri Botanical Garden, P.O. Box 299, St. Louis, MO 63166-0299, USA
Horn, James W.
Department of Biology, Duke University, P.O. Box 90338, Durham, NC 27708-0338, USA. Present address: Fairchild Tropical Botanic Garden, 11935 Old Cutler Road, Miami, FL 33156-4242, USA
Kawasaki, M. Lúcia
Department of Botany, Field Museum, 1400 S. Lake Shore Drive, Chicago, IL 60605-2496, USA
Köhler, Egon
Spezielle Botanik und Arboretum, Humboldt-Universität, Späthstr. 80/81, 12437 Berlin, Germany
Kubitzki, Klaus
Biozentrum Klein-Flottbek und Botanischer Garten, Universität Hamburg, 22609 Hamburg, Germany
XII
Linder, H. Peter
MacDougal, John M.
List of Contributors
Institut für Systematische Botanik und Botanischer Garten, Universität Zürich, Zollikerstr. 107, 8008 Zürich, Switzerland Missouri Botanical Garden, P.O. Box 299, St. Louis, MO 63166-0299, USA
Persson, Claes
Department of Botany, University of Göteborg, P.O. Box 461, 40530 Göteborg, Sweden
Renner, Susanne S.
Botanische Staatssammlung, Menzinger Str. 67, 80638 München, Germany
Rutishauser, Rolf
Institut für Systematische Botanik und Botanischer Garten, Universität Zürich, Zollikerstr. 107, 8008 Zürich, Switzerland Institut für Systematische Botanik und Botanischer Garten, Universität Zürich, Zollikerstr. 107, 8008 Zürich, Switzerland Spezielle Botanik, Universität Leipzig, Johannisallee 21–23, 04103 Leipzig, Germany
Rutschmann, Frank
Schneider, Julio V. Schönenberger, Jürg
Department of Botany, University of Stockholm, Lilla Frescativägen 5, 10691 Stockholm, Sweden
Sheahan, Mary C.
Jodrell Laboratory, Royal Botanic Gardens Kew, Richmond SRY TW9 3DS, UK
Simmons, Sara L.
Department of Integrative Biology, University of Texas, Austin, TX 78712, USA
Simpson, Beryl B.
University of Texas, Section of Integrative Biology, 1 University Station A 6700, Austin, TX 78712, USA
Soltis, Douglas E.
Department of Botany, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL 32611-7800, USA
Sosa, Victoria
Instituto de Ecología, A.C., Apartado Postal 63, 91000 Xalapa, Veracruz, México
Stace, Clive A.
Department of Botany, University of Leicester, University Road, Leicester LE1 7RH, UK
Stevens, Peter F.
Missouri Botanical Garden, P.O. Box 299, St. Louis, MO 63166-0299, USA
Tamura, Michio
4-25-7 Ao-gein, Mino, Osaka 562-0025, Japan
Thiede, Joachim
Schenefelder Holt 3, 22589 Hamburg, Germany
Van der Walt, J.J.A.
(deceased)
Wanntorp, Livia
Department of Botany, University of Stockholm, Lilla Frescativägen 5, 10691 Stockholm, Sweden
Weigend, Maximilian
Institut für Biologie/Systematische Botanik, Freie Universität Berlin, Altensteinstr. 6, 14195 Berlin, Germany
Weitzman, Anna L.
Department of Botany, Smithsonian Institution, P.O. Box 37012, Washington, DC 20013-7012, USA
List of Contributors
Wen, Jun
Department of Botany, Smithsonian Institution, P.O. Box 37012, Washington, DC 20013-7012, USA
Weston, Peter
Royal Botanic Gardens, Mrs Macquaries Road, Sydney, NSW 2000, Australia
Wilkinson, Hazel P.
Jodrell Laboratory, Royal Botanic Gardens Kew, Richmond SRY TW9 3DS, UK
XIII
Introduction to the Groups Treated in this Volume K. Kubitzki
Introduction to Berberidopsidales 1. Dioecious tree, young parts covered with ferrugineous scales; leaves conduplicate, entire; flowers 5(6)merous, enveloped in bud by firm calyptrate bract; stamens 5, alternating with nectary glands; gynoecium 1-carpellate; ovules 2, pendulous from apex of locule; style apically bifid; fruit dry, indehiscent; seed with ruminate endosperm and embryo of about half the length of seed. 1/1, S Chile and adjacent Argentina Aextoxicaceae – Scandent shrubs, largely glabrous; leaves involute (Berberidopsis), spiny-toothed or entire; flowers hermaphrodite, acyclic and with disk, or cyclic, pentamerous and without disk; gynoecium 3–5-carpellate; ovules several to many, each on 3–5 placentas; style not bifid; fruit berry-like; embryo small. 2/3, S Chile and SE Australia Berberidopsidaceae
A close relationship between Berberidopsidaceae and Aextoxicaceae has never been considered until gene sequence studies provided strong support for a relationship between them (see family treatments). In the four-gene analysis of eudicots (Soltis et al. 2003), Gunnerales and subsequently Berberidopsidales are sister to all other core eudicots, the latter being strongly supported by molecular data and isolated from all other clades (Fig. 1). Aextoxicum has long been known for its peculiar wood anatomy, particularly the high number of bars of the vessel element perforations. A recent study by Carlquist (2003) has revealed many important similarities in the wood anatomy of the two families, although these are plesiomorphic. Pollen grains are relatively small and tricolpate to indistinctly colporate. The two families share encyclocytic stomata (Soltis et al. 2005), a rare character in angiosperms, stout filaments, and a ring of vascular bundles in the petiole (Judd and Olmstead 2004). Unfortunately, many important characters are not known for both taxa but available information shows that Berberidopsidales are very plastic in their floral structure, combining (even within the same family, Berberidospidaceae) both spiral and whorled patterns, and 1-, 3- and 5-merous
gynoecia. The spiral sequence of initiation of floral organs in Berberidopsis, with a tendency of arrangement in alternating groups of five, may represent an incipient case of pentamery (Ronse DeCraene 2004) but this is problematic, in view of the firmly established pentamerous floral structure characteristic for core eudicots which exists in parts of Berberidopsidaceae and in the closely related Aextoxicum (see Berberidopsidaceae and Aextoxicaceae, this volume).
Fig. 1. A phylogenetic hypothesis of eudicot relationships, based on a four-gene dataset (Soltis et al. 2003)
2
K. Kubitzki
Morphologically, basal eudicots exhibit considerable structural disjunctions, which underlines their relict nature. This is also corroborated by the remarkable angiospermous fossil from the Early Cretaceous, Teixeira lusitanica, which shows affinities to members of Ranunculales, and to Berberidopsidaceae, Hamamelidaceae and Daphniphyllaceae (von Balthazar et al. 2005). Characters such as the dimerous floral structure, known from Gunnera, and presumably plesiomorphic traits (decurrent stigmas, antepetalous stamens, etc.), known from other basal eudicot families such as Proteaceae and Sabiaceae, are not found in Berberidopsidales.
References Balthazar, M. von, Pedersen, K.R., Friis, M.E. 2005. Teixeira lusitanica, a new fossil flower from the Early Cretaceous of Portugal with affinities to Ranunculales. Pl. Syst. Evol. 255:55–75. Carlquist, S. 2003. Wood anatomy of Aextoxicaceae and Berberidopsidaceae is compatible with their inclusion in Berberidopsidales. Syst. Bot. 28:317–325. Judd, W.S., Olmstead, R.G. 2004. A survey of tricolpate (eudicot) phylogenetic relationships. Amer. J. Bot. 91:1627–1644. Ronse DeCraene, L.P. 2004. Floral development of Berberidopsis corallina: a crucial link in the evolution of flowers in the core eudicots. Ann. Bot. 94:741–751. Soltis, D.E. et al. 2003. See general references. Soltis, D.E. et al. 2005. See general references.
Introduction to Buxales 1. Dioecious trees; flowers apetalous, male with one stamen pair, female often paired, a single carpel; pollen grains tricolpo-di-orate; seeds exalbuminous. 1/2, Madagascar Didymelaceae – Monoecious, rarely dioecious shrubs or herbs; flowers with weakly differentiated perianth, male with decussate tepals and 4, 6 or more stamens, female with spiral tepals and a 2–4-carpellate, syncarpous gynoecium; pollen grains 3–7-colporate with 3–6 pores per colpus, or pantoporate; seeds albuminous. 5/c. 100, all continents, except Australia Buxaceae
Buxales comprise Buxaceae and Didymelaceae, grouped together by traits such as cyclocytic stomata, leaf venation pattern, wood anatomical peculiarities including many sclereids, racemose inflorescences, small, imperfect, often dimerous flowers with decurrent stigmas extending the entire length of the stylodia, stamens with more or less basifixed anthers and conspicuous connective anther protrusions, and the occurrence of very
peculiar steroidal pregnan alkaloids. The most obvious trait of Buxales is the plasticity and simplicity of perianth organisation. In some of their members (Didymeles, male Styloceras), a perianth is completely lacking and, in Buxaceae, the tepals hardly differ from vegetative bracts below the flower (von Balthazar and Endress 2002a) and in female flowers they are spirally arranged, making the delimitation of flowers difficult. The stamens are always antesepalous and the stamen-sepalum complex of Buxaceae is similar to that of Proteaceae, also in the supply of the sepals by a single trace. Stamens, when occurring in low number, are arranged in dimerous whorls but, for higher numbers (in Notobuxus 6, 8, and up to more than 40), less regular arrangements prevail. Palynologically, Buxales are highly diverse (Bessedik 1983; Doyle 1999). An early fossil attributable to Buxales (Doyle 1999) is a pollen from the Aptian/Albian of northern Gondwana, which has simple colpate apertures and a striate(-reticulate) sculpture and has been related to the buxaceous megafossil Spanomera (Drinnan et al. 1991). In the late Albian of Gabon and Brazil, the tricolpodiorate pollen Hexaporotricolpites (Boltenhagen 1967) appears. This pollen type may be related to extant Didymeles from Madagascar (cf. Fig. 36), which has left a fossil record in the southern Indian Ocean, Australia, New Zealand and New Caledonia. Similar pollen grains with an increasing number of pores and meridional colpi, later in pantocolporate and eventually pantoporate configuration, the latter combined with a crotonoid exine pattern (cf. Fig. 11D), appear both in the fossil record and in extant Buxus (Köhler 1981; Köhler and Brückner 1982; Bessedik 1983). Buxales form part of the grade of earlydiverging tricolpate(-derived) dicots or eudicots, which also comprises Ranunculales, Sabiaceae, Proteales and Trochodendraceae (cf. Fig. 1). With several early-diverging eudicots, and partly also with some basal core eudicots (Gunneraceae, Myrothamnaceae and some basal families of Saxifragales), Buxales share characters which are known also from the eumagnoliids. Particularly remarkable are the dimerous flowers, the supply of the sepals by a single trace, and the stamensepalum complex, in which Buxaceae agree with Proteaceae. Conspicuous connective protrusions are known from other early-diverging eudicots and some basal core eudicots, including Proteaceae, Platanaceae, Trochodendraceae, Myrothamnaceae; basifixed anthers are widespread in early-diverging
Introduction to the Groups Treated in this Volume
eudicots. Elongate stigmas decurrent in two crests are shared with Platanaceae, Myrothamnaceae and Trochodendraceae but are also found in some Saxifragales. Nectary disks are rare in early-diverging eudicots and, apart from the intrastylodial nectariferous structures in Buxaceae, are known only from Proteaceae and Sabiaceae.
References Doyle, J.A. 1999. The rise of angiosperms as seen in the African Cretaceous pollen record. In: Heine, K. (ed.) Palaeoecology of Africa and the surrounding islands. Rotterdam: Balkema, pp. 3–29. For other references, see the selected bibliographies of Buxaceae and Didymelaceae, and the General References (this volume).
3
now well established (Soltis et al. 2000; Savolainen, Fay et al. 2000), and Podostemaceae appear sister to Hypericaceae or perhaps nested inside this family (Gustafsson et al. 2002). As the sinking of Podostemaceae in the broadly delimited Clusiaceae would lead to a highly heterogeneous unit, it appears preferable to “save” an independent family Podostemaceae by segregating Hypericaceae from Clusiaceae s.l., following the approach of many earlier authors such as Takhtajan (1997), although the separation in terms of contrasting characters between the latter two is not very strong. Characters common to the three families include resin cells and secretory ducts, containing xanthones, and bitegmic and tenuinucellate ovules.
References Introduction to the Clusiaceae Alliance (Malpighiales) 1. Annual cataract-dwellers with unclear differentiation of stems, roots and leaves (roots often crustaceous, ribbon-like; leaves sometimes terminal and doublesheathed); fertile pollen and fertilisable embryo sacs developed underwater; [pollination autogamous or cleistogamous, rarely allogamous; female gametophyte reduced Allium type; no double fertilisation and no endosperm; seed set high]. 49/c. 280, worldwide, tropical and warm-temperate regions Podostemaceae – Woody or herbaceous land plants 2 2. Leaves alternate, serrulate, initially setulose, convolute; latex 0; stamen connective glands 0; capsule with persistent column. 3/40, northern South America, West Indies, and SE Asia to New Guinea Bonnetiaceae – Leaves opposite or alternate, entire, not setulose, not convolute; latex often present in glands or secretory canals; stamen connectives often with glands producing oil or resin; fruit, if capsular, then rarely with persistent column 3 3. Stylodia free, at least distally; flowers perfect; sepals and petals 3–5; aril 0; trichomes, if multicellular, then stellate; woody or herbaceous. 9/540, worldwide Hypericaceae – Stylodia free or fused to form a simple style; flowers perfect or unisexual; sepals 2–20, petals 0–8; aril sometimes present; stellate hairs very rare (Caraipa, Marila); woody. 27/1090, pantropical Clusiaceae
Although these families have been intensely studied by generations of botanists, recent work has considerably modified our understanding of their phylogenetic relationships and details of their family and tribal delimitation. Molecular studies have revealed one enigma of long standing – the systematic position of Podostemaceae. Their close relationship with Clusiaceae s.l. (i.e. including Hypericaceae) is
For references, see the Selected Bibliography of ClusiaceaeGuttiferae and the General References (this volume).
Introduction to Crossosomatales 1. Perianth biseriate 2 – Perianth uniseriate; [flowers solitary] 6 2. Leaves opposite, pinnately compound, rarely unifoliolate; embryo green; [ovary syncarpous or apocarpous; ovules anatropous]. 2/40–50, temperate to tropical regions, mainly of the northern hemisphere Staphyleaceae – Leaves alternate, simple (if opposite and simple to slightly trilobate and gynoecium apocarpous, see Apacheria in Crossosomataceae); embryo achlorophyllous 3 3. Flowers solitary 4 – Flowers in panicles, racemes or spikes 5 4. Sepals 4–10; stamens 5 + 5; anthers dorsifixed; pistil 4–7-carpellate; style simple; ovules 1 per locule, anatropous; fruit indehiscent, fibrous; seed with rudimentary aril; embryo straight; vessel element perforation scalariform; T-shaped unicellular trichomes present. 1/1, New Caledonia Strasburgeriaceae – Sepals (3)4–5(6); stamens 4–50 (flower haplostemonous, diplostemonous or polystemonous); anthers basifixed; gynoecium apocarpous, 1–5(–9)-carpellate; ovules 1–many per carpel, campylotropous; fruit follicular; seed arillate; embryo curved; vessel element perforation mostly simple; T-shaped trichomes 0. 4/10, North America, with Mexico Crossosomataceae 5. Flowers strictly 5-merous; ovules 2 per locule; pollen 4(5)-colporate; fruit capsular; aril rudimentary; vessel element perforation scalariform; T-shaped unicellular trichomes present. 1/1, New Zealand Ixerbaceae – Flowers strictly 4-merous; ovules many per locule; pollen 3-colporate; fruit berry-like; seed with soft
4
K. Kubitzki funicular aril; vessel element perforation simple; T-shaped trichomes 0. 1/c. 16, E Asia Stachyuraceae 6. Leaves decussate, entire; tepals 4; stamens 4 + 4; anthers dorsifixed; ovary 4-locular, with 4 twisted stylodia; ovules anatropous; fruit capsular; seeds with swollen funicle; embryo straight; T-shaped unicellular trichomes present. 1/1, South Africa Geissolomataceae – Leaves alternate, serrate; tepals 4–5(6); stamens many; anthers basifixed; ovary unilocular; style simple; ovules campylotropous; fruit a berry; seeds arillate, incurved with hippocrepiform embryo. 1/1, E and southern Africa, islands of Indian Ocean Aphloiaceae
Until very recently, these apparently disparate families had been placed in different rosid orders and some had been “dumped” in larger families such as the broadly construed Saxifragaceae (Ixerba) or Flacourtiaceae (Aphloia). The taxonomic history of the individual families is briefly described in the family treatments, and has been treated in more depth by Matthews and Endress (2005). Although Takhtajan (1987) for the first time used the name of the order Crossosomatales which, in his approach, comprised only the name-giving family, a broader concept of the order was not achievable in the pre-molecular era largely because the characters traditionally used in higher-level classification are very variable in these seven families (see Conspectus). During recent years, several molecular studies have contributed to the recognition of the relationships in the entourage of Crossosomataceae. In their rbcL and combined morphological and rbcL studies, Nandi et al. (1998) found a clade of {[(Crossosoma + Stachyurus) Staphylea] Geissoloma}, albeit without significant support. Strong support for [(Crossosoma + Stachyurus) Staphylea] was adduced by further rbcL studies (Savolainen, Fay et al. 2000; Sosa and Chase 2003) and multigene analyses (Soltis et al. 2000; Cameron 2003), and for Ixerba + Strasburgeria by rbcL (Savolainen, Fay et al. 2000; Sosa and Chase 2003) and multigene studies (Cameron 2003). When included in the analysis, Ixerba + Strasburgeria, Aphloia and Geissoloma usually appeared in the same clade as Crossosoma, Stachyurus and Staphylea, although statistical support for this was low. The concept of Crossosomatales proposed by Savolainen, Fay et al. (2000) and Soltis et al. (2000), comprising Crossosomataceae, Stachyuraceae and Staphyleaceae, has later been extended to include all seven aforementioned families (see also Stevens 2005). This concept is now confirmed by the broad-based comparative study of Matthews and Endress (2005), which has revealed structural traits, particularly previ-
ously neglected floral characters, which are shared in different constellations by groups of two, three or more families of the whole alliance. The group as a whole is only weakly characterised. Stomata are usually anomocytic. Leaf margins are usually toothed. Stipules are lacking only in Ixerbaxceae and some Crossosomataceae. Vessel elements have scalariform perforation, Crossosomataceae and Stachyuraceae excepted. Sepal and petal aestivation is imbricate throughout, and stamens are always incurved in bud; anthers are tetrasporangiate; nectary disks are present. Ovules are bitegmic and crassinucellar, mostly anatropous; Aphloiaceae and Crossosomataceae have campylotropous ovules. Pollen grains are colporate and usually have lalongate endoapertures; the gynoecium is often stalked; the carpel tips are often postgenitally united to form a compitum. The seed coat is testal. Sieve element plastids are S type throughout. Ellagitannins and gallotannins, but no proanthocyanidins, are known from Crossosomataceae. More restricted are the following traits. Ixerbaceae and Strasburgeriaceae have large flowers with petals forming a tight, pointed cone in bud, stamens with sagittate anthers, and a rudimentary aril. These families share with Geissolomataceae T-shaped unicellular trichomes and a punctiform stigma on postgenitally united and twisted carpel tips, and only one or two ovules per carpel. Aphloiaceae, Geissolomataceae, Ixerbaceae and Strasburgeriaceae share pollen grains with pronounced protruding endoapertures (“pollen buds”). Crossosomataceae, Stachyuraceae and Staphyleaceae have polygamous or functionally unisexual flowers, and Crossosomataceae and Aphloiaceae (although not resolved as sisters in molecular studies) share polyandrous flowers, basifixed anthers, a stigma with two or more decurrent crests, campylotropous ovules and reniform seeds (data from Matthews and Endress 2005). Crossosomatales are core eudicots but otherwise their relationships are still unclear: they appear at the base of eurosids II (Savolainen, Fay et al. 2000; Soltis et al. 2000) or eurosids I (Hilu et al. 2003), or in a polytomy with Geraniales, Myrtales, eurosids I and eurosids II (APG II 2003), but always with low statistical support.
References For references, see the General References (this volume).
Introduction to the Groups Treated in this Volume
Introduction to Fabales 1. Stylodia gynobasic; [woody; flowers regular; gynoecium apocarpous, 1–5-carpellate; ovule unitegmic (only Suriana known); endosperm 0 or sparse; nectary only rarely present; vestured pits in Recchia]. 5/8, in warm-temperate and tropical regions, widely distributed Surianaceae – Style or stylodia not gynobasic 2 2. Gynoecium syncarpous, 2–8-carpellate (sometimes 1locular); pollen grains 7–28-colporate; seeds mainly endotestal; leaves estipulate; [woody or herbaceous; nodes unilacunar with a single trace; vessel element perforations usually simple; vestured pits sometimes present; flowers actinomorphic to zygomorphic; nectary a disk, a gland, or 0; seeds often arillate]. n = 6–23. 21/800–1,000, widely distributed in tropical, subtropical and temperate regions Polygalaceae – Gynoecium (nearly) apocarpous; pollen grains mostly 3-aperturate; seeds exotestal; leaves stipulate; [nectariferous disk usually present] 3 3. Flowers strictly actinomorphic; carpels 5, only basally connate; pollen grains in monads; seeds exarillate; endosperm thin; cotyledons convolute; stipules small; nodes unilacunar; vessel elements with simple and scalariform perforation; vestured pits 0; [woody; bark strongly saponiferous]. n = 14. 1/2, warm-temperate southern South America Quillajaceae – Flowers actinomorphic to zygomorphic; carpel usually 1 or very rarely more (and then each carpel with a terminal stylodium); pollen grains in monads, tetrads or polyads; seeds arillate or not; endosperm usually 0, rarely sparse or even copious; stipules sometimes modified into prickles or spines; nodes tri-(penta-)lacunar; vessel elements with simple perforations, the lateral pits often vestured; [roots very often with N-fixing root nodules]. 640/1800, widely distributed throughout the world Leguminosae–Fabaceae s.l. (not treated in this volume)
A clade comprising these four families was resolved as belonging to eurosids I by early molecular studies (Chase et al. 1993; Fernando et al. 1993; Morgan et al. 1994) and is strongly supported in several multigene analyses (e.g. Soltis et al. 1999, 2000). Morphologically, the four families have little in common, apart from the basically core eudicot floral organisation. Stevens (2005) notes green embryos and often fluorescent wood, and absence of ellagitannins (which are, however, present in Leguminosae) as common traits.
References Chase, M.W. et al. 1993. See general references. Fernando, E.S. et al. 1993. See selected bibliography of Surianaceae. Morgan, D.R. et al. 1994. See selected bibliography of Quillajaceae.
5
Soltis, P.S., Soltis, D.E., Chase, M.W. 1999. Angiosperm phylogeny inferred from multiple genes as a tool for comparative biology. Nature 402:402–404. Soltis, D.E. et al. 2000. See general references. Stevens, P.F. 2005. See general references.
Introduction to Geraniales 1. Embryo small, straight, achlorophyllous; endosperm copious; secondary xylem always with rays; [either (sub)shrubs or small trees with mostly 5-merous flowers and simple leaves and regular flowers (Greyia), or with pinnate leaves and ± zygomorphic flowers (Melianthus, Bersama), or herbs with mostly 4-merous flowers and commissural stigmas (Francoa, Tetilla)]. 5/19, subsaharan Africa, southern South America Melianthaceae – Embryo large, circinate, twisted, or cochlear, rarely (Rhynchotheca) straight, chlorophyllous; endosperm usually scant; secondary xylem often rayless 2 2. Pollen grains tricolp(or)ate; style elongate, with 5 style branches or (Hypseocharis) unbranched with capitate stigma; fruits schizocarpic with 1-seeded awned mericarps or (Hypseocharis) loculicidal capsules; seed coat with crystalliferous endotesta and thickened but not lignified exotegmen. 5/c. 835, nearly worldwide Geraniaceae – Pollen grains pantoporate or inaperturate; style very short, with 5–3 elongate stigmatic branches; fruits septicidal or septifragous capsules with 1–many-seeded locules; seed coat usually lacking mechanical layers (Viviania, exotegmic); Balbisia with mucilaginous exotesta. 4/c. 18, South America, mostly Andean Ledocarpaceae
The former, broadly construed concept of the order Geraniales (e.g. Engler 1892) comprised 15–20 families including disparate groups such as Oxalidaceae, Tropaeolaceae, Zygophyllaceae, Rutaceae and Euphorbiaceae. Based on the work of many authors, notably Takhtajan (e.g. 1959, 1987) and Dahlgren (e.g. 1980), Geraniales were stepwise restricted by the exclusion of orders such as Rutales, Polygalales and Malpighiales. Yet, in a still more recent survey of dicotyledon families, Thorne (2001) merged Geraniales with Linales (= Malpighiales), mainly on account of these sharing a tendency for obdiplostemonous flowers with 10–15 stamens and a 5-partite gynoecium. It is difficult to understand why Oxalidaceae, for instance, were for so long considered to belong to Geraniales, although the former differ in possessing traits such as free stylodia, abundant endosperm, and capsular fruits (see treatment of Oxalidales in Vol. VI of this series). In the pioneering molecular studies of Price and Palmer (1993), Morgan and Soltis (1993) and
6
K. Kubitzki
Chase et al. (1993), the five genera of Geraniaceae s.str. grouped with Hypseocharis and, in some analyses, also with Viviania, Greyia and Francoa, and often also with Crossosoma, whereas other families of the erstwhile Geraniales were clearly excluded. More recent molecular work (Soltis et al. 2000; Savolainen, Fay et al. 2000; Sosa and Chase 2003) has resolved Geraniales and Crossosomatales (see treatment in this volume) as sister groups placed at the base of eurosid II orders, but the statistical support is tenuous and the Angiosperm Phylogeny Group (APG II 2003) lists both orders among the unresolved rosids. Evidence for a sister group relationship of Melianthaceae and Ledocarpaceae and, in turn, of both of these with Geraniaceae is provided by the rbcL analyses of Savolainen, Fay et al. (2000) and Sosa and Chase (2003). This is notable, as morphologically Ledocarpaceae and Geraniaceae seem to have more in common than any of them have with Melianthaceae (see below). Support is also strong for recognising Melanthiaceae and Geraniaceae in the circumscription adopted in this volume but it is less strong for the morphologically more diverse Ledocarpaceae. Biebersteinia, a Eurasian monotype which often had been related to Geraniaceae (e.g. Knuth 1931), agreeing with this family in some details of fruit and seed morphology (Boesewinkel 1988), in molecular studies is resolved as sapindalean (APG II 2003). A morphological characterisation of Geraniales is difficult because the genera of Melianthaceae and, less so, of Ledocarpaceae are diverse. It is true that all Geraniales have anomocytic stomata, vessels with simple perforation, 5- or 4-merous hypogynous flowers with a persistent calyx, and either haplostemonous or more often obdiplostemonous androecia with paired antepetalous stamens, 5(–3)-carpellate syncarpous gynoecia with simple styles (extremely short in Balbisia) terminating in 3–5 stigmatic lobes or branches, axile or rarely basal placentation, anatropous to campylotropous bitegmic and crassinucellar ovules and, where known, a Polygonum type embryo sac and Nuclear endosperm. All Melianthaceae have copious endosperm, and Melianthus, Bersama and Greyia share multilacunar nodes. Francoa and Tetilla, formerly included in Saxifragaceae, differ from this family in the commissural stigma, the 4-merous flowers, Nuclear endosperm and the lack of myricetin. Otherwise, multilacunar nodes are not known in Geraniales, and the endosperm is absent or scanty in Geraniaceae. Ledocarpaceae and
Geraniaceae agree, however, in numerous traits, such as rayless wood, acuminate to awned sepals, broadened filaments and sometimes basal nectariferous appendages, tanniniferous seed coats, green embryos and (Rhynchotheca excepted) curved or cochlear embryos. Differences between the two families exist in growth habit, pollen morphology and seed coat anatomy (Boesewinkel 1997). Anthecologically, Geraniales families are diversified. Nectaries are present in all families, and Geraniaceae depend on a broad variety of insect groups as pollinators and only occasionally on bird, whereas Melianthaceae rely strongly on bird pollination. In Ledocarpaceae, Viviania produces copious nectar as reward for insect and other pollinators whereas the remaining genera, Balbisia and Rhynchotheca, lack nectaries. Balbisia has pollen flowers, and its showy corolla indicates that it is also zoophilous; one species, B. gracilis, may be anemophilous. Rhynchotheca has apetalous flowers with large, pendulous anthers and shows synchronous mass-flowering, all indicative of anomophily (Weigend 2005). Thus, the morphological disparity of Ledocarpaceae appears to be related to their range of pollination syndromes, which may explain the difficulties morphological workers had in recognising the circumscription and affinities of the family. Phytochemically, Geraniales are characterised by the typical presence of ellagitannins; ellagic acid has been recorded from all genera (Tetilla not studied); gallotannins are also present in Geranicaeae, and geraniin, an ellagitannin based on dehydroxyhexahydroxydiphenic acid, is a prominent compound in Geranium. Proanthocyanidins are uniformly lacking from aerial parts but occur in seed coats and are recorded also from the rootstocks of Geraniaceae. Other biodynamic compounds include the bufodienolides and pentacyclic triterpenoids in Melianthaceae (Hegnauer 1969, 1989).
References APG II 2003. See general references. Boesewinkel, F.D. 1988. The seed structure and taxonomic relationships of Hypseocharis Remy. Acta Bot. Neerl. 37:111–120. Boesewinkel, F.D. 1997. Seed structure and phylogenetic relationships of the Geraniales. Bot. Jahrb. Syst. 119:277– 291. Chase, M.W. et al. 1993. See general references. Dahlgren, R. 1980. A revised system of classification of the angiosperms. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 80:91–124.
Introduction to the Groups Treated in this Volume Engler, A. 1892. Syllabus der Vorlesungen über spezielle und medizinisch-pharmazeutische Botanik. Berlin: Gebr. Borntraeger. Hegnauer, R. 1969, 1989. See general references. Knuth, R. 1931. Geraniaceae. In: Engler, A., Harms, H. (eds) Die natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien, ed. 2, 19a. Leipzig: W. Engelmann. Kubitzki, K. (ed.) 2004. Flowering plants. Dicotyledons. Celastrales, Oxalidales, Rosales, Cornales, Ericales. The Families and Genera of Flowering Plants, VI. Berlin Heidelberg New York: Springer. Morgan, D.R., Soltis, D.E. 1993. See general references. Price, R.A., Palmer, J.D. 1993. See general references. Savolainen, V., Fay, M.F. et al. 2000. See general references. Soltis, D.E. et al. 2000. See general references. Sosa, V., Chase, M.W. 2003. See general references. Takhtajan, A.L. 1959. Die Evolution der Angiospermen. Stuttgart: G. Fischer. Takhtajan, A. 1987. See general references. Thorne, R.F. 2001. See general references. Weigend, M. 2005. Notes on the floral morphology in Vivianiaceae (Geraniales). Pl. Syst. Evol. 253:125–131.
Introduction to Gunnerales 1. Poikilohydric shrubs; nodes trilacunar; axial parenchyma 0; rays uniseriate; leaves opposite; flowers unisexual, hypogynous; perianth of up to 4 scales; stamens 3–8; ovary 3–4-locular; stylodia 3–4, broad, recurved, with ventrally decurrent stigma; pollen in tetrads; embryo sac Allium type (bisporic, 8-celled); fruit a septicidal capsule; sieve-element plastids S type. 1/2, E and South Africa, Madagascar Myrothamnaceae (see Vol. II) – Perennial herbs, often giant and nearly acaulescent, with endosymbiontic Nostoc cells; nodes multilacunar; vascular system nearly always polystelic; leaves alternate; flowers epigynous, 2-merous; ovary 1-locular; stylodia subulate; pollen in monads; embryo sac Peperomia type (tetrasporic, 16-celled); stylodia 2; fruit a drupe; ellagitannins present; sieve-element plastids Pcf type. 1/c. 60, mainly in southern hemisphere Gunneraceae
Traditionally, Gunneraceae were included in Haloragaceae; Takhtajan (1997) placed them in Saxifraganae. Numerous molecular studies recovered the family in close association with the desert shrub Myrothamnus at the base of core eudicots, where they form a strongly supported clade. There is also evidence for the position of this clade as sister to all remaining core eudicots (cf. Fig. 1), a grouping indicated in various analyses and strongly supported particularly by Soltis et al. (2000, 2003) and Hilu et al. (2003). Gunnera very probably has dimerous flowers and the same may apply to Myrothamnus (see Conspectus). Dimery is not only widespread in early-diverging eudicots such as Proteaceae and
7
many Ranunculaceae but usually also co-occurs with trimery in basal angiosperms (Kubitzki 1987) or even with pentamery in early-diverging eudicots (Soltis et al. 2003). This is not seen in character reconstructions if only a single exemplar per family is included in a tree, as in the reconstruction of perianth merosity in Fig. 3 of Soltis et al. (2003). Indeed, both in basal angiosperms and early-diverging eudicots, there is pronounced variation in floral merosity, and the stereotyped pentamerous floral structure with diplostemony or haplostemony occurs only above the node to Gunnerales. Thus, in Ranunculaceae, pentamery, where it occurs, is restricted to the perianth and, in pentamerous Sabia (Sabiaceae), the sepals, petals and stamens stand on the same radius, a clear violation of Hofmeister’s rule but quite common in “basal” eudicots, as in Gunnera itself (see also Doust and Stevens 2005). Yet, following the node to Gunnerales, the typical pentamerous eudicot pattern is strictly conserved, and further variation is limited to processes such as fusion, reduction and multiplication of stamens and/or carpels and of perianth parts. Gunnerales, although forming part of the core eudicot clade, have not achieved (or have lost?) the pentamerous pattern, but agree with many core eudicots in possessing potent allelochemicals based on ellagic acid.
References Doust, A.W., Stevens, P.F. 2005. A reinterpretation of the staminate flowers of Haptanthus. Syst. Bot. 30:779–785. Hilu, K.W. et al. 2003. See general references. Kubitzki, K. 1987. Origin and significance of trimerous flowers. Taxon 36:21–28. Kubitzki, K., Rohwer, J.G., Bittrich, V. (eds) Flowering plants. Dicotyledons. Magnoliid, Hamamelid and Caryophyllid families. The Families and Genera of Vascular Plants, II. Berlin Heidelberg New York: Springer. Soltis, P.S., Soltis, D.E. 2004. The origin and diversification of angiosperms. Amer. J. Bot. 91:1614–1626. Soltis, D.E. et al. 2000. See general references. Soltis, D.E. et al. 2003. See general references. Takhtajan, A. 1997. See general references.
Introduction to Myrtales 1. Ovary unilocular with apical placentation, inferior (half-inferior in Strephonema); indumentum almost always of slender, unicellular, thick-walled, pointed hairs with a distinctive basal compartment; inflorescences indeterminate; [stamen whorls 1 or 2, the
8
K. Kubitzki
–
2.
– 3.
–
4.
– 5.
– 6. – 7.
–
1
outer sometimes with 2 or 3 times the normal number of stamens; pseudocolpi + (0 in Strephonema); intrastaminal disk often +; fruit 1-seeded, a drupe, usually flattened, ridged and/or winged; cotyledons twisted (massive and hemispheric in Strephonema)]. 14/500, pantropical Combretaceae Ovary usually multilocular with axile placentation, more or less inferior; fruit 1–many-seeded, usually a capsule or berry; indumentum various but not as above 2 Leaves with secretory cavities usually containing essential oils (0 in Psiloxylon), spirally arranged or opposite; pollen oblate, brevi- to longicolpate, lacking pseudocolpi; style base often sunken in apex of gynoecium 3 Leaves lacking secretory cavities, not aromatic; pollen often with pseudocolpi; style base generally not sunken (sunken in some Vochysiaceae) 4 Dioecious; leaves spiral; stamens ≥ 10, erect in bud; anthers tetralocular at anthesis, dehiscing by slits; embryo sac bisporic. 2/4, south-eastern Africa, Mascarenes Myrtaceae–Psiloxyloideae∗1 Flowers bisexual, rarely andromonoecious; leaves spiral or opposite; stamens (few–)usually many, inflexed in bud; anthers bilocular at anthesis, dehiscing with longitudinal or apical slits or pores; embryo sac monosporic; [ovary (nearly superior–)inferior, (1)2– 4(–18)-locular; fruits capsular, indehiscent, or fleshy]. c. 140/over 5,500, tropical to warm-temperate regions mainly of southern hemisphere, with greatest diversity in the Australasian region Myrtaceae–Myrtoideae∗ Flowers strongly mono- or asymmetric; fertile stamen 1, staminodes 0–several; pollen without pseudocolpi; [petals (0)1–3(5); style base ± sunken in apex of gynoecium; fruit a loculicidal capsule or samaroid]. 8/200, most neotropical, 2/5 of them in West Africa Vochysiaceae Flowers usually not strongly zygomorphic; stamens > than 1; pollen often with peudocolpi 5 Pollen with viscin threads on proximal surface and unique paracrystalline beaded exine, the central body of the grain circular to triangular with (2)3(–6) protruding apertures, pseudocolpi 0; embryo sac monosporic, 4-nucleate; endosperm diploid; [flowers (2)4(5, 7)-merous; stamens usually arising from rim of the well-developed hypanthium; fruit a capsule, or dry and indehiscent; interxylary phloem often present; vegetative parts rich in oxalate raphides; exotegmen fibrous]. 17–24/675, widely distributed from tropics to arctic-alpine regions Onagraceae∗ Viscin threads 0, exine different; pollen apertures usually not protruding but pseudocolpi often present; embryo sac 8-nucleate, endosperm triploid 6 Pollen grains 3-porate, lacking pseudocolpi; [ovary superior to partly inferior; branched foliar sclereids +] 7 Pollen grains (2)3-colporate; pseudocolpi present or not 8 Gynoecium 4–8-carpellate and -locular; petals shortly clawed; stamens 12 or numerous; tall trees with drooping, 4-angled ultimate branches. x = 10. 1/2, Southeast Asia, New Guinea Lythraceae p.p. (Duabanga) Gynoecium 10–20-carpellate and -locular; petals linear(-lanceolate) or 0; stamens numerous; swamp
The asterisk denotes taxa not treated in this volume.
8.
– 9.
– 10. – 11.
– 12.
–
13.
–
and mangrove trees with pneumatophores. x = 12. 1/5, coastal Africa to Pacific islands Lythraceae p.p. (Sonneratia) Annual aquatic with floating leaves and submerged filiform-dissected stipules; flowers emergent, 4merous; sepals basally connate into a tube, 2 or 4 of them accrescent in fruit as hornlike or spine-like projections; stamens 4, alternipetalous; gynoecium 2-carpellate, ovary partly inferior; fruits 1-seeded; endosperm 0 but one cotyledon starchy, very large, retained within the fruit. 1/3 (or 15?), temperate to tropical regions of Old World, except Australia Lythraceae p.p. (Trapa) Terrestrial 9 Endothelium present (at least, in Axinandra); [glabrous trees, often with quadrangular twigs; inflorescences indeterminate; flowers hypogynous to perigynous, 4–5-merous, obhaplostemonous or rarely diplostemonous; anther endothecium ephemeral; pollen tricolporate-pseudocolpate or (Crypteronia) bisyncolporate; petals 0 or (Axinandra) small and connate apically, falling off as a cup when the flower opens; ovary ± inferior, 2–6-locular; capsule woody or chartaceous]. 3/10, South and Southeast Asia, Malaysia Crypteroniaceae Endothelium 0 10 Flowers strictly obhaplostemonous; [plants woody; anther endothecium ephemeral] 11 Flowers usually diplostemonous or multistaminate; Melastomataceae and Lythraceae rarely (ob)haplostemonous 14 Hypanthium rim ending with some blunt teeth (“epicalyx”); ovary inferior, 3–5-locular; pollen heteropolar with unequal colpi and “half pseudocolpi” restricted to one polar face; sepals conspicuous, white or pinkish, inserted on margin of hypanthium; petals scale-like, minute, closing the hypanthium in bud; [stamens inserted on inner rim of tube below petals; fruit drupaceous]. x = 10. 1/c. 8, southern and eastern Africa, from Ethiopia to South Africa Oliniaceae Epicalyx 0; ovary superior; pollen isopolar; petals, if present, not closing the hypanthium 12 Flowers (5)6(7)-merous; hypanthium stellate; petals minute, hood-like, lobate and unguiculate, arising from hypanthial rim; septum between the two microsporangia of each theca persistent; pollen 3-colporate with pseudocolpi; gynoecium 2(3)carpellate, ovary 1-locular/partly bilocular; embryo sac monosporic/8-nuclear; fruit capsular. n = 10. 1/1 Rhynchocalycaceae Flowers 4–5(6)-merous; hypanthium tubular; petals strongly reduced or 0; septum between the two microsporangia not persistent; embryo sac bisporic or tetrasporic 13 Flowers 4-merous; nodes unilacunar; foliar sclereids 0; hypanthium large, often conspicuously coloured; ovary 4-locular; pollen with pseudocolpi isomerous with apertures; embryo sac tetrasporic, 16-nucleate. n = 10. 7/23, Cape Province of South Africa Penaeaceae Flowers 5(6)-merous; nodes trilacunar; branched foliar sclereids +; pollen without pseudocolpi; hypanthium green to yellow, 4–6 mm long; ovary 2-locular; embryo sac bisporic. 1/1, Costa Rica to Bolivia Alzateaceae
Introduction to the Groups Treated in this Volume 14. Stamen connectives dorsally enlarged and often massive; anther dehiscence often ± poricidal; [pollen with pseudocolpi; leaves opposite; crystal druses and/or styloids +] 15 – Stamen connectives dorsally not enlarged; anther dehiscence by longitudinal slits 16 15. Leaf venation pinnate or brochidodromous (very rarely, acrodromous); plants woody; flowers strictly epigynous, diplostemonous; stamen connectives generally provided with depressed elliptic terpenoidproducing dorsal glands; anthers with fibrous endothecium, dehiscing by slits (sometimes short and functioning as pores); terminal leaf sclereids +; stomata paracytic; secondary xylem with axially included phloem islands; fruit baccate; seed coat with fibrous exotegmen; seeds 1–few, generally with welldeveloped storage cotyledons. x =? 6/440, pantropical Memecylaceae∗ – Leaf venation acrodromous (very rarely, pinnate); plants woody or herbaceous; flowers actino- to zygomorphic, wholly or partly epigynous, diplostemonous or (ob)haplostemonous; stamen connectives without dorsal glands; anthers mostly poricidal, endothecium 0; terminal leaf sclereids 0; stomata anemocytic, polycytic or encyclocytic; secondary xylem generally without included phloem islands; fruit capsular or baccate; seed coat without fibrous exotegmen; seeds many, with small cotyledons; [indumentum very diverse, trichomes multicellular, scale-like]. x = 17. 185/4,500, mainly in tropical and subtropical regions of the world, with greatest diversity in South America Melastomataceae∗ 16. Herbaceous or woody; ovary superior (to inferior); flowers usually diplostemonous or flowers (ob)haplostemonous; petals crumpled in bud; stamens inserted at the base of floral tube or above, whorls of unequal length; heterostyly widespread; pollen grains tricolporate, pseudocolpi 0 or isomerous with or double the number of apertures; fruit capsular or baccate. 30/c. 600, worldwide, mainly in subtropical and tropical regions Lythraceae p.m.p. – Woody; ovary inferior; stamens many, covering the inner floral tube surface from the rim to the ovary; homostylous; pollen tricolporate, with indistinct pseudocolpi; ovary 7–9(–15)-loculate, carpels in 1 whorl or in 2–3 superposed layers; fruit a leathery berry; seeds many, with translucent sarcotesta. 1/2, from Balkan Peninsula to Himalayas and on Soqotra Lythraceae p.p. (Punica)
Earlier hypotheses on the composition of the order Myrtales are partly congruent with modern concepts. A.P. de Candolle, for instance, in 1828 in the third volume of his Prodromus, combined all major myrtalean families, such as Combretaceae, Onagraceae, Memecylaceae, Melastomataceae, Myrtaceae and, surprisingly, also Vochysiaceae into Myrtales. In addition, he included Alangiaceae, Rhizophoraceae and Lecythidaceae. This and similar circumscriptions of Myrtales persisted in most classifications up to the second half of the 20th century. Mainly due to the work of Briggs
9
and Johnson (1979) and Dahlgren and Thorne (1984), heterogeneous elements were subsequently excluded. Since then, the circumscription of the order has remained unchanged, the only exception being the reinsertion of Vochysiaceae which, based on their unique floral morphology, had not been included by most authors. Rather, they had associated it with families such as Polygalaceae and Euphroniaceae. However, phylogenetic analyses of molecular data as well as morphological evidence strongly supports the inclusion of Vochysiaceae into the order (Conti et al. 1996). In the present circumscription, the order comprises 12 families (see Fig. 2 for a phylogenetic hypothesis) and more than 9,000 species, representing about 6% of core eudicot diversity. Myrtales
Fig. 2. A phylogenetic hypothesis of relationships of Myrtales families, mainly based on Clausing and Renner (2001), Sytsma et al. (2004) and Wilson et al. (2005)
10
K. Kubitzki
are characterised by the combination of vestured pits and bicollateral vascular bundles in the primary xylem, resulting in the appearance of phloem included within the secondary xylem (van Vliet and Baas 1984), and also by several embryological features (Tobe and Raven 1983). Additional characters found in part throughout the order include opposite leaves with undivided laminas, even in the aquatic members; small or rudimentary stipules; short to elongate hypanthia; stamens incurved in bud; vessel elements with simple perforations, paratracheal axial parenchyma and usually nonseptate fibres; secondary phloem stratified in young twigs; unilacunar nodes; simple styles; pollen with subsidiary “colpi” (“pseudocolpi”, i.e. meridional invaginations in the intercolpial regions, apparently with a harmomegathic function); 2-celled pollen; a crystalliferous endotesta; scarce or no endosperm; and copious amounts of galloand ellagitannins, the latter often methylated. Morphological studies significantly contributed to our knowledge of Myrtales in the 1970s and 1980s, and many of these appear in the Myrtales symposium volume published in the Annals of the Missouri Botanic Garden (vol. 71, 1984). Following the comparative analysis of inflorescence structure by Briggs and Johnson (1979), Weberling (1988) analysed the inflorescences from a typological point of view. Monotelic thyrsopaniculate inflorescences, postulated to be basic in the order, predominate in Myrtaceae, Melastomataceae, Oliniaceae and other smaller families whereas Combretaceae and Onagraceae are polytelic throughout. Nevertheless, the aspect of character polarity of inflorescences is yet not completely settled, and recent work shows that within Lythraceae alone the monotelic condition is derived at least four times from the polytelic (Graham et al. 2005). The so-called pseudocolpi are a peculiar character of the pollen grains of many Myrtales, and the distribution and different expressions of these structures are problematic. The absence of pseudocolpi from part of Lythraceae is striking, as is the occurrence of “double” pseudocolpi in another part (Patel et al. 1984). Their complete absence from Onagraceae and the Myrtaceae clade have led earlier authors (Dahlgren and Thorne 1984; see also Johnson and Briggs 1984) to postulate the origin of the pseudocolpi after the branching off of these two families. In view of recent phylogenetic hypotheses (Fig. 2), however, it seems more parsimonious to consider pseudocolpi as ancestral for the order as a whole.
Modern phylogenetic studies in Myrtales started with the seminal work of Johnson and Briggs (1984), and many of their findings have later been confirmed by molecular studies (Conti et al. 1996, 1997, 2002; Clausing and Renner 2001; Sytsma et al. 2004; Wilson et al. 2005). Molecular analyses generally provided strong support for the monophyly of individual families, and also interfamilial relationships have been greatly clarified. The morphological circumscription of families and larger clades turned out to be more difficult (see Conspectus of families). The exact position of the order within the eudicots is not clear and, together with Crossosomatales and Geraniales, Myrtales are left unplaced within the rosids (APG II 2003; see also the angiosperm-wide analysis of matK sequences by Hilu et al. 2003). Combretaceae often appear to be sister to the rest of the order but statistical support for this is still tenuous. Onagraceae and Lythraceae are sister taxa, the former possessing raphides, the latter alkaloids. Onagraceae are highly autapomorphic (see Conspectus). Among the remaining families, Melastomataceae, Memecylaceae and their sister group, the CAROP families (Crypteroniaceae, Alzateaceae, Rhynchocalycaceae, Oliniaceae and Peneaeaceae), are characterised by dorsally massive anther connectives. Renner (1993) and Clausing and Renner (2001) determined the acrodromous leaf venation and lack of a fibrous anther endothecium as being synapomorphic for Melastomataceae, and the terpenoid-producing connective glands as synapomorphic for Memecylaceae. The few genera of Melastomataceae which lack the peculiar, arching leaf venation are nested within the family and thus are clearly derived, and the occurrence of an anther endothecium in the basal melastom genus Pternandra is interpreted as a plesiomorphy (Clausing and Renner 2001). Interestingly, Pternandra also has the interxylary phloem islands (included phloem) which generally occur in Memecylaceae. This trait is interpreted as parallelism, and not as plesiomorphy, because Pternandra agrees with Melastomataceae in most other wood characters. The CAROP families share the loss of an anther endothecium (probably evolved independently from Melastomataceae) with obhaplostemonous flowers (Schönenberger and Conti 2003) and the presence of stipules (Johnson and Briggs 1984). Apart from these features, the four families are strongly diversified. Particularly Crypteroniaceae, with their variable androecium and gynoecium
Introduction to the Groups Treated in this Volume
structure, defy any attempt for a sound morphological family characterisation; the circumscription of this family follows largely molecular findings. The melastom/CAROP clade is sister to the Myrtaceae/Vochysiaceae clade. Myrtaceae represent the largest, most diverse family of the order, for which a detailed classification has recently been established (Wilson et al. 2005). The inclusion of the somewhat aberrant genera Psiloxylon and Heteropyxis in Myrtaceae increases the support for the monophyly of the family, compared to a separate treatment of these two taxa as monogeneric families. The great size of Myrtaceae encompasses much variation in inflorescence, floral and fruit structure, which has been explored by numerous studies subsequent to the seminal contributions by Briggs and Johnson (1979) and Johnson and Briggs (1984). Until the advent of molecular systematics, the close relationship of Vochysiaceae and Myrtaceae had been camouflaged by the distinct floral organisation of the former family but Vochysiaceae have many myrtalean traits, and share the plesiomorphic (see the hypothetic “Protomyrtalis” of Johnson and Briggs 1984) sunken styles and 1–2-celled hairs with many Myrtaceae (Stevens 2005). Much work has been dedicated to the elucidation of the biogeographic history of Myrtales. This task is complicated due to the ancient origin of the order and its poor fossil record (see Sytsma et al. 2004). Recent dating analyses have estimated the crown group of Myrtales to be 107 (Wikström et al. 2001) or 110 million years old (Sytsma et al. 2004), corresponding to the Albian of the Lower Cretaceous. The split between the Myrtaceae/Vochysiaceae clade and the Melastom/CAROP clade may also have occurred in the Albian. This implies that Gondwanan vicariance was an important factor in the biogeographic history of this lineage, as seems reflected by, for instance, the disjunct distribution of the CAROP families and the out-of-India dispersal of Crypteroniaceae (Rutschmann et al. 2004). As for Myrtaceae, Sytsma et al. (2004) could not unambiguously determine the place of their initial diversification, although the extant members of the family are clearly Australasian in origin and a more recent move to South America occurred in the early Eocene, possibly using the temperate Antarctic land bridge. Vochysiaceae are clearly neotropical; the African representatives of the family are nested within a South American clade and may have reached Africa by long-distance
11
dispersal in the Neogene, when the Atlantic had already rifted c. 80 million years ago in the equatorial region (Sytsma et al. 2004). The initial radiation of Melastomataceae is hypothesised to have occurred during the Palaeocene/Eocene along the northern shore of the Sea of Tethys (Renner et al. 2001). From there, the family may have dispersed to North America and throughout Eurasia, later also to South America and from there with repeated long-distance dispersal events to Africa, Madagascar, India and Indochina.
References APG II 2003. See general references. Briggs, B.G., Johnson, L.A.S. 1979. Evolution in the Myrtaceae – evidence from inflorescence structure. Proc. Linn. Soc. New South Wales 102:157–256. Candolle, A.P. de 1828. Prodromus systematis naturalis regni vegetabilis. Pars III. Paris: Treuttel & Würtz. Clausing, G., Renner, S.S. 2001. Molecular phylogenetics of Melastomataceae and Memcylaceae: implications for character evolution. Amer. J. Bot. 88:486–498. Conti, E. et al. 1996. See general references. Conti, E. et al. 1997. See general references. Conti, E. et al. 2002. See general references. Dahlgren, R., Thorne, R.F. 1984. The order Myrtales: circumscription, variation, and relationships. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 71:633–699. Graham, S.A. et al. 2005. See general references. Hilu, K.W. et al. 2003. See general references. Johnson, L.A.S., Briggs, B.G. 1984. Myrtales and Myrtaceae – a phylogenetic analysis. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 71:700–756. Patel, V.C., Skvarla, J.J., Raven, P.H. 1984. Pollen characters in relation to the delimitation of Myrtales. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 71:858–969. Renner, S.S. 1993. Phylogeny and classification of the Melastomataceae and Memecylaceae. Nordic J. Bot. 13:519– 540. Renner, S.S., Clausing, G., Meyer, K. 2001. Historical biogeography of Melatomataceae: the roles of Tertiary migration and long-distance dispersal. Amer. J. Bot. 88:1290–1300. Rutschmann, F., Eriksson, T., Schönenberger, J., Conti, E. 2004. Did Crypteroniaceae disperse out of India? Molecular dating evidence from rbcL, ndhF, and rpl16 intron sequences. Intl J. Pl. Sci. 165, suppl. 4:S69–S83. Schmid, R. 1980. Comparative anatomy and morphology of Psiloxylon and Heteropyxis, and the subfamilial and tribal classification of Myrtaceae. Taxon 29:559–595. Schönenberger, J., Conti, E. 2003. Molecular phylogeny and floral evolution of Penaeaceae, Oliniaceae, Rhynchocalycaceae, and Alzateaceae (Myrtales). Amer. J. Bot. 90:293–309. Stevens, P.F. 2005. See general references. Sytsma, K.J. et al. 2004. See general references. Tobe, H., Raven, P.H. 1983. An embryological analysis of the Myrtales: its definition and characteristics. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 70:71–94.
12
K. Kubitzki
Vliet, G.J.C.M. van, Baas, P. 1984. Wood anatomy and classification of the Myrtales. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 71:783–800. Weberling, F. 1988. The architecture of inflorescences in the Myrtales. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 75:226–310. Wikström, N. et al. 2001. See general references. Wilson, P.G., O’Brien, M.M., Heslewood, M.M., Quinn, C.J. 2005. Relationships within Myrtaceae sensu lato based on matK phylogeny. Pl. Syst. Evol. 251:3–19.
Introduction to the Passifloraceae Alliance (“Passiflorales” = Malpighiales) 1. (Andro)gynophore 0; petal aestivation contorted; corona rarely present and then weakly developed; calyx and corolla separating from developing fruit and falling together; seeds arillate, pitted. 10/+200, Africa, America Turneraceae – (Andro)gynophore usually present; petal aestivation cochlear; corona often present and strikingly coloured 2 2. Stylodia inserted beneath the top of ovary; stamens 5; pollen grains 3-colporate; seeds exarillate; calyx persistent in fruit; tendrils 0. 1/24, Chile, Peru Malesherbiaceae – Stylodia inserted on top of ovary; stamens 4, 5, or many; pollen grains 3–12-colporate or -foraminate; seeds arillate; tendrils often present. 17/700–750, pantropical Passifloraceae
These three families are closely related and also could be merged into one, as suggested as an option by the Angiosperm Phylogeny Group (APG II 2003); here, they are treated separately because their authors prefer the traditional family circumscription. Whereas the molecular data of Chase et al. (2002) confirm that these families form a clade, at the time of writing of these accounts and this introduction (Sept. 2005), it still remains unclear whether the separation of these families involves paraphyly. They share important characters such as an extrastaminal corona, exotestal seeds, cyclopentenoid cyanogenic glucosides and/or cyclopentenyl fatty acids, and biparental or paternal transmission of plastids (the latter not observed in Malesherbiaceae). Whereas seed structure and chemical make-up appear quite constant in the group, a corona is not always present and its expression is quite diverse. It is developed in its full-fledged form in Passifloraceae, mainly Passiflora, but is only weakly in the possibly basal Adenias and also in Turneraceae and Malesherbiaceae; it is difficult to decide whether this represents an anagenetic or reductional transformation. Accessory or superposed buds, as in Passifloraceae, are found also in various
members of Salicaceae and Achariaceae (de Wilde 1971b, at that time included in Flacourtiaceae) where, however, no cyanogens are present; still, a corona is known from Abatia, which led earlier researchers to include the genus in Passifloraceae. Its placement in Salicaceae on the basis of molecular evidence (Chase et al. 2002) is corroborated by morphological evidence. Thus, in contrast to Passifloraceae, Abatia has opposite leaves, valvate calyx aestivation and extrorse anthers, and both the coronal threads and stamens are irregularly arranged whereas in Passifloraceae the corona elements are in distinct whorls and the stamens in the polystemononous genera of this family are in a single whorl (Bernhard 1999); the corona may not be homologous in both groups.
References For references, see the Selected Bibliography of Passifloraceae and the General References (this volume).
Introduction to Proteales 1. Herbaceous, cambial activity 0; sepals 2, stamens numerous, spirally arranged; carpel closure by secretion; ovule 1 per carpel, anatropous; pollen grains variously furrowed or rarely sulcate or tricolpate; simple benzylisoquinoline alkaloids (aporphines) present; myricetin and condensed tannins 0; carpel closure by secretion; flowers thermogenic]. 1/1 or 2, North America, Asia, Australia Nelumbonaceae (see Vol. II) – Woody; sepals or tepals > 2, stamens whorled; carpels postgenitally fused; ovules 1 or 2, rarely more per carpel, usually orthotropous; pollen grains triaperturate(-derived); benzylisoquinoline alkaloids 0; myricetin and condensed tannins present but gallate 0; [seeds lacking starch but containing fat oil and protein] 2 2. Stipules 2, often fused; flowers small, unisexual, in globular heads; perianth 3–4(–7)-merous, the petals vestigial; carpels 3–8, distinct, ovules 1(2); pollen grains tricolpate; triterpenes +. 1/c. 7, North America and Asia Minor to East Asia Platanaceae (see Vol. II) – Stipules 0; flowers usually bisexual, in racemes, panicles, or condensed, often paired; perianth of 4 (very rarely 3 or 5) valvate tepals; stamens antetepalous, often adnate to tepals, alternating with hypogynous nectar secreting glands; carpel 1; ovules 1–2(–many); pollen grains triporate, rarely tricolporoidate or diporate; triterpenes 0. 80/1,700, mainly southern hemisphere, best developed in Australia Proteaceae
The three families united in this order form an unexpected alliance, which was discovered by early molecular work and since has received support in
Introduction to the Groups Treated in this Volume
various multigene analyses. Sabiaceae, here left unplaced as to ordinal allocation (see family treatment), are also often found together with Proteales (cf. Fig. 1). As is evident from the characters given in the Conspectus, Nelumbonaceae appear quite out of place in this alliance. Their ranunculalean chemistry (see Gottlieb et al. 1993) is accompanied by completely ascidiate carpels without any postgenital fusion, which Nelumbo shares only with Berberidaceae; the ovules are anatropous (Igersheim and Endress 1998). Nelumbo has a dimerous calyx (Hayes et al. 2000; in contrast to information given erroneously by Kubitzki 1993), but dimerous whorls are widespread in basal eudicots (Drinnan et al. 1994; Doyle and Endress 2000; Soltis et al. 2003) and are by no means exclusive for earlydiverging eudicots. Nelumbonaceae are remarkable with regard to pollen development. Whereas in basal angiosperms (monosulcates) there is much variation between the simultaneous and successive type of microsporogenesis, almost all eudicots (triaperturates) have simultaneous microsporogenesis, with the notable exception of Nelumbonaceae (Kreunen and Osborn 1999) and Proteaceae (Furness et al. 2002; including the diporate proteaceous pollen: Blackmore and Barnes 1995). The co-occurrence of putatively monosulcate and triaperturate pollen in Nelumbo (Kuprianova 1979; Blackmore et al. 1995) raised great phylogenetic interest but later (Borsch and Wilde 2000) was found to be part of an extensive, regular variation pattern influenced by factors such as a delay in aperture ontogeny (Kreunen and Osborn 1999). Platanaceae and Proteaceae, which are resolved as sister taxa in most molecular analyses, have much in common morphologically, including the presence of five carpellary bundles (rather than three in most Ranunculales and in the early-branching Proteacea Bellendena), ample tanniniferous tissue in the carpels, mostly one or two large, orthotropous ovules of which the upper is pendent, and floral organs which may be arranged in dimerous whorls. Traditionally, Proteaceae had been interpreted as tetramerous but the ontogenetic work of Douglas and Tucker (1996a) supports the interpretation of their perianth and androecium as dimerous. Possibly, Proteaceae are primarily apetalous; the nectarial hypogynous scales, which alternate with the tepals, are positioned inside the stamen whorl and their initiation takes places after that of all other floral organs (Douglas and Tucker 1996),
13
which is inconsistent with their interpretation as erstwhile petals. Both extant and fossil Platanaceae show considerable variability in the number of floral parts. Some of their mid-Cretaceous and early Tertiary representatives had strictly pentamerous perianths with five stamens and five carpels respectively (Friis and Crane 1989), but clear tetramery existed, for instance, in the Late Cretaceous Quadriplatanus (Magallón et al. 1997), in which the female flowers had two perianth whorls and eight carpels. Proteaceae pollen is known for differing from the widespread developmental pattern in eudicots, in which apertures are formed in pairs at six points in the developing tetrad, following Fischer’s Rule. In Proteaceae, the apertures are formed in groups of three at four points in the tetrad (Garside 1946). Furness and Rudall (2004), who quoted Illiciales, Proteaceae and Olacaceae as the only examples in angiosperms for pore orientation according to Garside’s Rule, argued for origins of this developmental mode of triaperturate pollen independent from the developmental pattern following Fischer’s Rule which characterises the majority of the eudicots. Illiciales are, however, irrelevant in this context because their “tricolpate” condition is an extension of the trichotomosulcate arrangement, which is often found among monosulcates in which Illiciales are embedded (Huynh 1976; Doyle et al. 1990). The pollen grains of some Olacaceae, which are formed according to Garside’s Rule, appear autapomorphic because this family is deeply embedded within the triaperturate group. Also for Proteaceae, it is difficult to envisage a completely independent origin of the triaperturate condition from a monosulcate/trichotomosulcate ancestor: even if Proteales were basal in eudicots, Proteaceae are nested within Proteales, in which Platanaceae and Nelumbonaceae produce “normal” triaperturates. Any hypothesis of an independent origin within this order would then require one or two additional origins of the normal Fischer’s Rule tricolpate type, a non-parsimonious assumption. Rather, these considerations all favour an origin of the proteaceous condition from normal tricolpates, much as concluded for Olacaceae. This view is shared by Blackmore and Crane (1998) who tend to view the Garside’s Rule arrangement in Proteaceae as derived. A triporate fossil pollen from the Cenomanian (mid-Cretaceous) of the Northern Gondwana Province, Triorites africaensis, has often been related to Proteaceae. The ultrastructural analysis of
14
K. Kubitzki
Triorites by Ward and Doyle (1994) suggests that Triorites pollen is not tricolporate-derived, as usually is the case with triporates, but perhaps directly from tricolpate. Ward and Doyle (1994) considered this as an additional piece of evidence against a derivation of the family from a rosid ancestor – of course, amply confirmed by molecular data. A number of Late Cretaceous (Late Santonian-Early Campanian) follicular fruits from southern Sweden (Leng et al. 2005) exhibit several similarities with Proteaceae, particularly with the first branching lineages in the family. These include a plicate carpel structure with a vascular system of three bundles, several anatropous, probably bitegmic ovules, and a more or less sessile stigmatic area which is located at the distal-most part of the ventral slit and extends over the topological apex to the abaxial side of the follicle. Although these fossils differ from extant Proteaceae in having unisexual and obviously perianth-free flowers and several ovules, they represent an extinct lineage of basal eudicots which probably was close to modern Proteaceae. Johnson and Briggs (1975), with admirable intuition, anticipated that Proteaceae are not only an “isolated” but also a fairly basal family, rather than belonging somewhere in the rosids, this having been fully confirmed by the evidence available 30 years later.
References Blackmore, S., Barnes, S.H. 1995. Garside’s rule and the microspore tetrads of Grevillea rosmarinifolia A. Cunningham and Dryandra polycephala Bentham (Proteaceae). Rev. Palaeobot. Palynol. 85:111–121. Blackmore, S., Crane, P.R. 1998. The evolution of apertures in the spores and pollen grains of embryophytes. In: Owens, S.J., Rudall, P.J. (eds) Reproductive biology. Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, pp. 159–182. Blackmore, S., Stafford, P., Persson, V. 1995. Palynology and systematics of Ranunculiflorae. Pl. Syst. Evol. suppl. 9:71–82. Borsch, T., Wilde, V. 2000. Pollen variability within species, populations, and individuals, with particular reference to Nelumbo. In: Harley, M.M., Morton, C.M., Blackmore, S. (eds) Pollen and spores: morphology and biology. Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, pp. 285–299. Douglas, A.W., Tucker, S.C. 1996. Comparative floral ontogenies among Persoonioideae including Bellendena (Proteaceae). Amer. J. Bot. 83:1528–1555. Doyle, J.A., Endress, P.K. 2000. Morphological phylogenetic analysis of basal angiosperms: comparisons and combination with molecular data. Intl J. Pl. Sci. 161, suppl. 6:S121–S153. Doyle, J.A., Hotton, C.L., Ward, J.V. 1990. Early Cretaceous tetrads, zonasulculate pollen, and Winteraceae. II.
Cladistic analysis and implications. Amer. J. Bot. 77:1558–1568. Drinnan, A.N., Crane, P.R., Hoot, S.B. 1994. Patterns of floral evolution in the early diversification of non-magnoliid dicotyledons (eudicots). Pl. Syst. Evol. suppl. 8:93–122. Endress, P.K., Igersheim, A. 1999. Gynoecium diversity and systematics of the basal eudicots. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 130:305–393. Friis, E.M., Crane, P.R. 1989. Reproductive structures of Cretaceous Hamamelidae. In: Crane, P.R., Blackmore, S. (eds) Evolution, systematics and fossil history of the Hamamelidae, 1. Oxford: Clarendon Press, pp. 155– 174. Furness, C.A., Rudall, P.J. 2004. Pollen aperture evolution – a crucial factor for eudicot success? Trends Pl. Sci. 9:154–158. Furness, C.A., Rudall, P.J., Sampson, F.B. 2002. Evolution of microsporogenesis in angiosperms. Intl J. Pl. Sci. 163:235–260. Garside, S. 1946. The developmental morphology of the pollen of Proteaceae. J. S. African Bot. 12:27–34. Gottlieb, O.R., Kaplan, M.A.C., Zocher, D.H.T. 1993. A chemosystematic overview of Magnoliidae, Ranunculidae, Caryophyllidae and Hamamelidae. In: Kubitzki, K. (ed.) The Families and Genera of Vascular Plants, 2. Berlin Heidelberg New York: Springer, pp. 20–31. Hayes, V., Schneider, E.L., Carlquist, S. 2000. Floral development of Nelumbo nucifera (Nelumbonaceae). Intl J. Pl. Sci. 161, suppl. 6:S183–S191. Hoot, S.B., Magallón, S., Crane, P.R. 1999. Phylogeny of basal eudicots based on three molecular data sets: atpB, rbcL, and 18S nuclear ribosomal DNA sequences. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 86:1–32. Huynh, K.-L. 1976. L’arrangement du pollen du genre Schisandra (Schisandraceae) et sa signification phylogénique chez les Angiospermes. Beitr. Biol. Pflanzen 52:227–253. Igersheim, A., Endress, P.K. 1998. Gynoecium diversity and systematics of the paleoherbs. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 127:289–370. Johnson, L.A.S., Briggs, B. 1975. See general references. Kreunen, S.S., Osborn, J.M. 1999. Pollen and anther development in Nelumbo (Nelumbonaceae). Amer. J. Bot. 86:1662–1676. Kubitzki, K. 1993. Platanaceae. In: Kubitzki, K., Rohwer, J.G., Bittrich, V. (eds) Flowering plants. Dicotyledons. Magnoliid, Hamamelid and Caryophyllid families. The Families and Genera of Vascular Plants, II. Berlin Heidelberg New York: Springer, pp. 521–522. Kubitzki, K., Rohwer, J.G., Bittrich, V. (eds) Flowering plants. Dicotyledons. Magnoliid, Hamamelid and Caryophyllid families. The Families and Genera of Vascular Plants, II. Berlin Heidelberg New York: Springer. Kuprianova, L.A. 1979. On the possibility of the development of tricolpate pollen from monosulcate. Grana 18:1–4. Leng, Q., Schönenberger, J., Friis, E.M. 2005. Late Cretaceous follicular fruits from southern Sweden with systematic affinities to early diverging dicots. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 148:377–407. Magallón, S., Herendeen, P.S., Crane, P.R. 1997. Quadriplatanus georgianus gen. et sp. nov.: staminate and pis-
Introduction to the Groups Treated in this Volume tillate platanaceous flowers from the Late Cretaceous (Coniacian-Santonian) of Georgia, U.S.A. Intl J. Pl. Sci. 158:373–394. Ressayre, A., Dreyer, L., Triki-Teurtroy, S., Forchioni, A., Nadot, S. 2005. Post-meiotic cytokinesis and pollen aperture pattern ontogeny: comparison of development in four species differing in aperture pattern. Amer. J. Bot. 92:576–583. Soltis, D.E. et al. 2003. See general references. Ward, J.V., Doyle, J.A. 1994. Ultrastructure and relationships of mid-Cretaceous polyforate and triporate pollen from northern Gondwana. In: Kurmann, M.H., Doyle, J.A. (eds) Ultrastructure of fossil spores and pollen. Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, pp. 161–172.
– 9.
–
Introduction to Saxifragales 10. 1. Trees; stigmas decurrent; pollen colpate or pantoporate; [anthers with protruding connectives] 2 – Trees or herbs; stigmas subulate, capitate or spatulate; pollen colpor(oid)ate, rarely porate 5 2. Flowers mostly hermaphroditic; anthers mostly dehiscing with valves; [trichomes mostly stellate or tufted; flowers (2–)4–5(–7)-merous, calyx rarely 0, petals often adaxially circinate; ovary inferior to superior, 2-carpellate with straight stylodia; iridoids 0]. n = 8, 12, 18. 27/82, tropical to temperate, C and E North America, SE Europe through S, E and SE Asia to New Guinea and NE Australia Hamamelidaceae (see Vol. II) – Dioecious; anthers dehiscing with slits or rudimentary valves 3 3. Ovary unicarpellate with abaxial suture [but the solitary carpels (= female flowers) united into pseudanthia]; iridoids 0; [fruit a samara; seed with large embryo]. n = 19. 1/2, China and Japan Cercidiphyllaceae (see Vol. II) – Ovary bicarpellate; no pronounced shoot dimorphism; iridoids present 4 4. Female flowers in globose heads, male in terminal globose racemes; stipules present; pollen pantoporate; embryo > half the length of the seed; secretory ducts in all vegetative tissues. n = 8. 1/13, C America, E Mediterranean, E Asia to Malesia Altingiaceae (see Vol. II under Hamamelidaceae) – Flowers in elongate racemes; stipules 0; pollen tricolpate; embryo minute; secretory ducts 0. n = 8. 1/10, E Asia, Malesia Daphniphyllaceae 5. Flowers polyandrous 6 – Flowers haplostemonous or diplostemonous. Core Saxifragales 7 6. Apocarpous; stamens in 5 fascicles; seeds with shining sarcotesta; perennial herbs or (half)shrubs. 1/40, northern hemisphere Paeoniaceae – Syncarpous, ovary unilocular; stamens not distinctly fasciculate; seeds with black crustaceous coat; trees. 3/11, South America, Africa Peridiscaceae 7. Flowers essentially 4-merous; [leaves estipulate; nodes unilacunar] 8 – Flowers essentially 5 >-merous 10 8. Ovary superior, nearly apocarpous; anther wall without fibrous endothecium; [pollen tricolporate; fruit fol-
– 11.
– 12.
–
13.
– 14.
–
15
licular; seeds very small, winged; low glabrous shrub]. 1/1, Tasmania Tetracarpaeaceae Ovary inferior or semi-inferior, the carpels at least basally connate; anther wall with fibrous endothecium 9 Leaves alternate, opposite, or verticillate; ovary inferior, 4(–2)-carpellate; stylodia free with penicillate stigmas; vessel elements with simple perforation; pollen 4– 6(–20)-colpate or -porate, often aspidiate; [tanniniferous terrestrial or aquatic herbs, shrubs or small trees]. n = 7 (6, 9, 21, 29). 8/150, worldwide but mainly Australia Haloragaceae Leaves opposite; ovary semi-inferior, 4-carpellate; style shortly 4-lobed; stigmas papillate; vessel elements with scalariform perforation; pollen tricolporate; [petals small or 0; climbing shrubs]. 1/2, Australia Aphanopetalaceae Shrubs; [leaves alternate; vessel element perforation mainly scalariform; ovary syncarpous] 11 Herbs; [seeds exotestal] (but see Crassulaceae) 13 Gynoecium 5-carpellate; style shortly 5-lobed; [ovary largely inferior with 4–6 ascending ovules/locule; stigmas radiate; stipules minute; pollen 3-colporate; vessel elements also with simple perforations]. 1/3, Mexico Pterostemonaceae Gynoecium 2-carpellate; style cleft or not 12 Ovary inferior, 1-locular; fruit a berry; seeds usually numerous, small, mucilaginous; embryo small; pollen 8-zonocolporate, pentacolpo-di-orate, or pantoporate; erect, arching, trailing or prostrate shrubs often with 3- or 2-forked or simple nodal spines and smaller internodal bristles, and long-petiolate, basally 2-veined leaves; [seed coat with exotestal mucilaginous palisade, endotesta crystalliferous]. n = 8. 1/150–200 Grossulariaceae Ovary nearly superior to 3/4 inferior, 2-locular; fruit a capsule; seeds few to many, dry; embryo large, curved; pollen bilateral, 2-porate; unarmed shrubs or small trees with short-petiolate, pinnately veined leaves; [anthers with globular protrusion of the connective; stylodia separate to fused but apically coherent with globular stigmas]. n = 11. 1/c. 27, E and SE Asia, one sp. in Africa, one in North America Iteaceae Fruit a 5–7-carpellate and -beaked stellate capsule, the beak of each carpel circumscissile above the syncarpous region; nodes unilacunar; vessel element perforation scalariform; [rhizomatous perennials; petals 0 or very small]. n = 8, 9. 1/2, E North America, E and SE Asia Penthoraceae Fruiting carpels not dehiscing along a circumscissile suture; nodes uni-, tri- or multilacunar; vessel element perforation simple 14 Succulent herbs, subshrubs or rarely shrubs; stipules 0; nodes trilacunar or unilacunar; leaves usually simple and entire; gynoecium isomerous with perianth; nectariferous scale near base of each carpel (petaloid in Monanthes and some Sedum). n = 4–22+. 33/1,410, widely distributed mostly in arid temperate or warm regions, and centred in Mexico and South Africa Crassulaceae Not succulent, perennial and annual herbs; stipules present or leaf basis sheathing; nodes trilacunar or multilacunar; leaves simple or pinnately or
16
K. Kubitzki palmately compound or decompound; gynoecium 2(– 5)-carpellate; nectariferous disk mostly present. n = (5, 6)7(11, 12, 15, 17, 18). 33/1,410, nearly cosmopolitan but mainly in northern temperate zone and centred in North America Saxifragaceae
Saxifragales, in the circumscription followed in this volume, are the result of a series of molecular analyses carried out over the past 15 years or so (Chase
Fig. 3. A phylogenetic hypothesis of relationships of Saxifragales families, based on Fishbein et al. (2001), Fishbein and Soltis (2004) and, for Peridiscaceae, on Davis and Chase (2004). Note that resolution among the basal woody families is weekly supported. Hamamelidaceae, Altingiaceae and Cercidiphyllaceae were treated in Vol. II (Kubitzki et al. 1993) of this series
et al. 1993; Morgan and Soltis 1993; Soltis and Soltis 1997; Fishbein et al. 2001; APG II 2003; Davis and Chase 2004; Fishbein and Soltis 2004, among others). The monophyly of this clade is strongly supported. Moreover, there is a 1 bp insertion common to all members of the order (Soltis and Soltis 1997). In addition to the Core Saxifragales traditionally considered to belong to this order (see Fig. 3), it comprises also Haloragaceae, the controversial Paeoniaceae, some woody “hamamelidid” families (Cercidiphyllaceae, Hamamelidaceae, Altingiaceae, Daphniphyllaceae), and the enigmatic Peridiscaceae. Outgroup relationships of Saxifragales are weakly supported (Savolainen, Chase et al. 2000; Soltis et al. 2000) but the group is often found together with Vitaceae at the base of the large eurosid clade. A group comprising the families now constituting the order Saxifragales has never before been recognised in traditional systematic studies. In comparison with older concepts such as of those of Bentham (1865), Engler (1891, 1930) and Cronquist (1981), and partly also with the more recent but essentially morphologically based classifications by Huber (1991), Takhtajan (1997) and Thorne (2001), the present circumscription differs in three major points, first, in the exclusion of the lineages having tenuinucellate ovules and containing iridoids; second, in the inclusion of Haloragaceae, Peridiscaceae and Paeoniaceae (included in Saxifragales by Huber 1991); and third, in the addition of several woody families showing presumably plesiomorphic characters such as valvate anther dehiscence, apiculate connective protrusions and tricolpate pollen, some of which persist here and there in the Core Saxifragales. ad 1. The first to recognise the systematic significance of ovules was Warming (1878), and the bitegmic ovules of Itea led van Tieghem (1898) to propose the transfer of Itea from Escalloniaceae to Saxifragaceae. He later (van Tieghem 1901) used the distinction between bitegmic and unitegmic ovules as a rigorous criterion in the classification of the whole plant kingdom, which resulted in a system containing inconsistent and unnatural groupings, discrediting the use of this character. Consequently, his views were wholly rejected by other botanists and Engler (1930), when commenting on Hydrangioideae and Escalloniodeae which he included in his Saxifragaceae, argued that the number of integuments had little systematic significance because, among otherwise clearly related genera of Ranunculaceae, their number
Introduction to the Groups Treated in this Volume
can be variable. However, Mauritzon (1933), in his embryological studies of Saxifragales, found ovule characters to be useful, and Philipson (1974) suggested that a distinction be made between families in which the ovular characters are constant, as opposed to those in which some variation in this respect occurs sporadically. Taxa such as Escalloniaceae, Hydrangeaceae, Phyllonoma, Montinia and Eremosyne, transferred to the asterids by Soltis and Soltis (1997) on the basis of molecular evidence, are all unitegmic and iridoid-positive. Some unitegmic genera (Darmera, Micranthes) persist in Saxifragaceae but these are embedded in broader bitegmic lineages and lack iridoids, whereas the few iridoid-positive Saxifragales are bitegmic. ad 2. Haloragaceae traditionally have been related with Myrtales but Takhtajan (1997) demonstrated that they have more characters in common with Saxifragales. Peridiscaceae have often been related to Flacourtiaceae but the three-gene analysis of Davis and Chase (2004) adds the family, with the inclusion of Soyauxia, to the Saxifragales where they come out with Daphniphyllaceae and the other woody groups at the base of the Saxifragales clade, albeit with low support (M.W. Chase, pers. comm. Nov. 2003). A close relationship between these three taxa is not reflected by morphological traits, although the anther flaps of Soyauxia are found in some basal Saxifragales families as well. Paeoniaceae, large-flowered, apocarpous, with striking seed-presentation and strongly autapomorphic2 , in the analysis of Fishbein and Soltis (2004) are basal to Core Saxifragales. ad 3. Within the Saxifragales, but outside the Core Saxifragales, iridoids occur in two families, Altingiaceae and Daphniphyllaceae, where they are poorly diversified chemically (Kaplan and Gottlieb 1982), perhaps due to the small size of these families. These are the only reports of iridoids outside the asterids. The tricolpate pollen predominating in Cercidiphyllaceae, Hamamelidaceae and Daphniphyllaceae is likely to be a plesiomorphic trait; in fact, the apertures of Cercidiphyllum appear quite archaic, and are intermediate between the poroidate and colpoidate condition (Praglowski 1975); however, there are transitions to compound (colporoidate or colporate) apertures known from within Daphniphyllum. In the Core Saxifragales, elabo2 The record of iridoids sometimes indicated for Paeonia (e.g. in Stevens 2005) may be based on Nekratova et al. (1988, in Rast. Resur. 24:392–399), who may have mistaken monoterpene glucosides of the Paeoniflorin type for iridoids (Hegnauer 1990).
17
rate compound apertures (with well-differentiated exo- and endoapertures) are the rule but sometimes (Saxifragaceae) they are not fully developed. On the whole, the woody basal families of (“nonCore”) Saxifragales appear as isolated remnants of formerly more richly developed, archaic lineages, as is particularly well documented for Cercidiphyllaceae. Resolution within the Core Saxifragales is better supported, mainly due to the efforts of Fishbein et al. (2001), and even a cursory glance at the topology reproduced in Fig. 3 reveals that a broader concept of Saxifragaceae (with the inclusion of Tetracarpaea and Penthorum) is untenable, unless Crassulaceae and Haloragaceae were to be incorporated, too. The topology of Fig. 3 is also useful for a comparison with character transformations which can be recognised in the Core Saxifragales. The transition from woody to herbaceous growth, usually accompanied by the loss of scalariform perforation plates of the vessel elements, has taken place some five times within Saxifragales – in Paeoniaceae, Saxifragaceae, Crassulaceae (the few woody members of which are definitely secondarily woody; see Crassulaceae, this volume), Penthoraceae and the woody/herbaceous Haloragaceae. Penthoraceae are remarkable for having “retained” scalariform perforation in spite of being herbaceous. Grossulariaceae are strictly woody whereas their sister group Saxifragaceae is largely herbaceous – a remarkable difference, although both agree in details of shoot morphology and growth dynamics, as is well described by Weigend under “Affinities” of Grossulariaceae (this volume). Anthers in Saxifragales are remarkably uniformly basifixed but gynoecium structure, particularly in Core Saxifragales, is labile. Pterostemonaceae stand out with an isomerous and apocarpous gynoecium within an otherwise 2–3-carpellate Saxifragaceae alliance; the gynoecia of Crassulaceae and Tetracarpaeaceae are also (nearly) apocarpous. Free stylodia are widespread, and most groups with this character seem to lack a compitum. The functionally advantageous fusion of stylodia into a common style is uncommon (Grossulariaceae, Iteaceae, Aphanopetalaceae). Although there is no indication that apocarpy here, or in the (other) eurosids where it also occurs, is due to a reversal, it is difficult to imagine that this character expression should be plesiomorphic in these groups. Minute embryos characterise Peridiscaceae, Daphniphyllaceae, Paeoniaceae, Grossulariaceae and Tetracarpaeaceae; all other groups have medium-sized or large embryos.
18
K. Kubitzki
References APG II 2003. See general references. Bentham, G. 1865. Ordo LIX. Saxifrageae. In: Bentham, G., Hooker, J.D., Genera Plantarum, I, ii. London: Reeve, pp. 629–655. Chase, M.W. et al. 1993. See general references. Cronquist, A. 1981. See general references. Cutler, D.F., Gregory, M. (eds) 2000. Anatomy of the Dicotyledons, 2nd edn. Vol. 4, Saxifragales. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Davis, C.C., Chase, M.W. 2004. Elatinaceae are sister to Malpighiaceae; Peridiscaceae belong to Saxifragales. Amer. J. Bot. 91:262–273. Engler, A. 1891. Saxifragaceae. In: Engler, A., Prantl, K., Die natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien III, 2a. Leipzig: W. Engelmann, pp. 41–93. Engler, A. 1930. Saxifragaceae. In: Engler, A., Prantl, K., Die natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien, ed. 2, 18a. Leipzig, W. Engelmannn, pp. 74–226. Fishbein, M., Soltis, D.E. 2004. Further resolution of the rapid radiation of Saxifragales (Angiospetrms, Eudicots) supported by mixed-model Bayesian analysis. Syst. Bot. 29:883–891. Fishbein, M. et al. 2001. See general references. Hegnauer, R. 1990. See general references. Huber, H. 1991. Angiospermen. Leitfaden durch die Ordnungen und Familien der Bedecktsamer. Stuttgart: G. Fischer. Kaplan, M.A.C., Gottlieb, O.R. 1982. Iridoids as systematic markers in dicotyledons. Biochem. Syst. Ecol. 10:329– 347. Kubitzki, K., Rohwer, J.G., Bittrich, V. (eds) Flowering plants. Dicotyledons. Magnoliid, Hamamelid and Caryophyllid families. The Families and Genera of Vascular Plants, II. Berlin Heidelberg New York: Springer. Mauritzon, J. 1933. Studien über die Embryologie der Familien Crassulaceae und Saxifragaceae. Ph.D. Thesis, Lund University. Morgan, D.R., Soltis, D.E. 1993. Phylogenetic relationships among members of Saxifragaceae sensu lato based on rbcL sequence data. Amer. J. Bot. 80:631–660. Nemirovich-Danchenko, E.N. 1994. Morphology and anatomy of the seeds of Iteaceae (in Russian). Bot. Zhurn. (Moscow & Leningrad) 79:83–87. Philipson, W.R. 1974. Ovular morphology and the major classification of the dicotyledons. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 68:89–108. Praglowski, J. 1975. Pollen morphology of the Trochodendraceae, Tetracentraceae, Cercidiphyllaceae and Eupteleaceae with reference to taxonomy. Pollen Spores 16:449–467. Savolainen, V., Chase, M.W. et al. 2000. See general references. Soltis, D.E., Soltis, P.S. 1997. Phylogenetic relationships in Saxifragaceae sensu lato: a comparison of topologies based on 18S rDNA and rbcL sequences. Amer. J. Bot. 84:504–522. Soltis, D.E. et al. 2000. See general references. Stevens, P.F. 2005. See general references. Takhtajan, A. 1997. See general references. Thorne, R.F. 2001. See general references.
Tieghem, Ph. van 1898. Structures de quelques ovules et parti qu’on en peut tirer pour améliorer la classification. J. Bot. (Paris) 12:197–220. Tieghem, Ph. van 1901. L’œuf des plantes considéré comme base de leur classification. Ann. Sci. Nat., Bot. VIII, 14:213–390. Walker, J.W. 1974. Aperture evolution in the pollen grains of primitive angiosperms. Amer. J. Bot. 61:1112–1136. Warming, E. 1878. De l’ovule. Ann. Sci. Nat. VI, 5:177–266.
Introduction to Vitales 1. Small trees, shrubs, or herbs; tendrils 0; stipular wings conspicuous, sheathing; inflorescences terminal; floral disk tubular, not producing nectar; due to secondary septation, ovary 4–6(–8)-locular, ovule 1 per locule. 1/34, mainly southern Asia, extending to Africa/Madagascar and Australia Leeaceae – Woody lianas usually with leaf-opposite tendrils, rarely succulent small trees or erect herbs; stipules not sheathing the petiole margins; inflorescences often leaf-opposed; floral disk intrastaminal, ring-shaped, cupular, or gland-shaped, usually nectariferous; ovary 2-locular, ovules 2 per locule. 14/c. 750, pantropical Vitaceae
Traditionally, Vitales were included in Rhamnales – both have antepetalous stamens – but Takhtajan (1997) dismembered this association because Vitaceae and Leeaceae differ from Rhamnaceae in their berry-like fruits and seed structure, and in having raphide sacs in the parenchymatous tissue; he placed them as “Vitalanae” close to his Proteanae at the end of his Rosidae. Corner (1976) was much impressed by the thick, lignified endotesta and small embryo of the seeds of Vitaceae, which he found “scarcely improved on that of Magnolia and. . . even more primitive”. Vitales also have a tracheidal exotegmen, which is a rare feature in angiosperm seeds – apart from Dilleniaceae; it is listed only for Cunoniaceae by Nandi et al. (1998). Vitaceae, Leeaceae and Dilleniaceae are the only angiosperm families which share the lignified endotesta and tracheidal exotegmen. The first to find an association between Vitaceae and Dilleniaceae were Nandi et al. (1998) in a combined rbcL/morphological analysis. In an rbcL analysis (Savolainen, Fay et al. 2000), Vitales and Dilleniaceae appear in a sister position to Caryophyllales. The two-gene analysis of Savolainen, Chase et al. (2000) and the three-gene analysis of Soltis et al. (2000) place Vitales at the base of the rosid clade. In the matK analysis of Hilu et al. (2003), the rosids are sister to Vitis and Tetracera (in turn, sister taxa) and to other taxa
Introduction to the Groups Treated in this Volume
including Berberopsidales, Santalales (relative positions were uncertain), and Caryophyllales plus asterids. In the four-gene study of Soltis et al. (2003), Vitales occupy a position at the base of a Caryophyllales/Saxifragales clade. None of these associations is strongly supported. Thus, a closer relationship between Vitaceae/Leeaceae and Dilleniaceae can not be ruled out. Perhaps both families branched off at the base of the core eudicot tree and both, but Dilleniaceae more probably than Vitaceae/Leeaceae, may be related to Caryophyllales. Evidence for placing Vitales in rosids is tenuous because the molecular data are not convincing. Note, however, that Stevens (2005), citing Oxelman et al. (2004), mentions that the RPB2 gene may not be duplicated in Vitales, perhaps suggesting a position outside core eudicots. Summarising, one may agree with Stevens (2005, on Vitales) that Vitales have no firm position as yet, although a more strongly supported association with Dillenaceae and Caryophyllales would not come as a surprise.
References Corner, E.J.H. 1976. See general references. Hilu, K.W. 2003. See general references. Nandi, O.I. et al. 1998. See general references. Oxelman, B., Yoshikawa, N., McConaughy, B.L., Luo, J., Denton, A.L., Hill, B.D. 2004. RPB2 gene phylogeny in flowering plants, with particular emphasis on asterids. Mol. Phylog. Evol. 32:462–479. Savolainen, V., Chase, M.W. et al. 2000. See general references. Savolainen, V., Fay, M.F. et al. 2000. See general references. Soltis, D.E. et al. 2000. See general references. Soltis, D.E. et al. 2003. See general references. Stevens, P.F. 2005. See general references. Takhtajan, A. 1997. See general references.
Introduction to Zygophyllales 1. Hemiparasitic; stipules 0; flowers solitary or in botryoid panicles, zygomorphic; the two abaxial petals lipid-secreting, the three adaxial ones forming a flag; stamens ± as many as petals; ovary 1-locular; pollen 3-porate; vessels with non-vestured pits; axial parenchyma usually with one cell per strand; storying absent or nearly so; crystals many per cell, mostly in axial phloem parenchyma; n = 6. 1/18, New World Krameriaceae – Autotrophic; stipules +; flowers solitary, paired or in few-flowered cymes, regular or rarely slightly zygomorphic; nectar-secreting disk often +; stamens 1 or
19
2 times as many as petals; ovary (2–)5(–12)-locular; vessels with vestured pits; axial parenchyma usually with 2–4 cells per strand; storying present in axial parenchyma, sometimes in rays; crystals one per cell or septate portion of cell in wood or secondary phloem; x = 6–15. 22/230–240, in hot dry regions all over the world Zygophyllaceae
Previously, Krameriaceae and Zygophyllaceae were placed in different orders, and no close relationship between them had been recognised. Molecular studies, particularly the multigene analyses of Soltis et al. (2000) and Savolainen, Chase et al. (2000), revealed a strongly supported clade consisting of the two families within eurosids I. Ordinal status for this clade, which appears not to fit in any other rosid order, was suggested by Soltis et al. (2000). Zygophyllaceae and Krameriaceae are quite diverse but have more or less pentamerous and (ob-)diplostemonous(-derived) flowers, bitegmic/crassinucellate ovules, and simple styles, and thus conform to a generalised rosid pattern. They agree in various wood characters such as simple perforation plates in vessels, and the presence of tracheids (vasicentric, in the case of Zygophyllaceae), which are considered as plesiomorphous within eurosids whereas other characters, listed by Carlquist (2005) and partly included in the Conspectus above, are autapomorphous; the paedomorphic rays of Krameria are probably related to its hemiparasitism. The presence of anthraquinones may indicate their relationship to the nitrogen-fixing clade (Cucurbitales, Fagales, Fabales, Rosales) where these compounds are more often found (Savolainen, Chase et al. 2000), and to which they appear close in some analyses, although with low support. Apart from the presence of harman alkaloids in both families, the remarkable diversification of lignans and neolignans is a strong link between them (see “Phytochemistry” in family treatments) although, according to our present knowledge, these compounds in Krameriaceae are localised in the roots but in Zygophyllaceae on the leaf surface and in the wood.
References Carlquist, S. 2005. Wood anatomy of Krameriaceae with comparisons with Zygophyllaceae: phylesis, ecology and systematics. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 149:257–270. Savolainen, V., Chase, M.W. et al. 2000. See general references. Soltis, D.E. et al. 2000. See general references. Stevens, P.F. 2005. See general references.
20
K. Kubitzki
Families Unassigned to Order Four families are treated in this volume which are not assigned to order: Dilleniaceae, Huaceae, Picramniaceae and Sabiaceae. By and large, they do appear related to groups contained in this volume but, currently, evidence is not sufficient for including them into a specific order, and elevating them to monotypic orders does not seem appropriate because it would not convey any phylogenetic information. Apart from the following brief comments, a fuller discussion of the relationships of these families is found in the family treatments. Dilleniaceae. In the past, this family was considered a central group from which others radiated. This has not been confirmed by recent phylogenetic studies. Dilleniaceae have resisted attempts of molecular studies to determine their closest relative but it seems that they have some affinity with Caryophyllales. In his treatment of the family (this volume), J.W. Horn describes several important characters uniting Dilleniaceae and (woody) Caryophyllales such as Rhabdodendraceae. In the light of the internal topology of Dilleniaceae, with the genera showing anomalous secondary growth at the base of the family tree, this connection between Dilleniaceae and Caryophyllales gains weight. Molecular support for this relationship is, however, still weak (see also Introduction to Vitales, this volume).
Huaceae. This family has rare features, including the sepaline glands, cristarque cells, odour of garlic, and folds in the polar areas of the peroblate pollen grains. All existing morphology-based hypotheses for the placement of Huaceae are untenable (see family treatment, this volume), and the results of molecular studies, pointing to an association with Oxalidales/Malpighiales, have no strong support. The affinity of the family remains obscure. Picramniaceae. The two genera forming this pinnate-leaved family do not show particularly striking morphological features and traditionally have been considered an aberrant element of Simaroubaceae, from which they differ in structural and chemical traits (see family treatment, this volume). Molecular data point, albeit with low support, to a position of the family either sister to all rosids or sister to Zygophyllales. Sabiaceae. This family, formerly included either in Sapindales or in Ranunculales, is now clearly placed in the early-diverging eudicots. In molecular analyses it diverges after, before, or with Proteales but the support uniting these two groups is nearly always low. The pentamerous floral structure is quite different from the stereotyped pentamerous pattern of core eudicots; it is unique within eudicots. Available molecular evidence is not sufficient for an inclusion of Sabiaceae in Proteales, apart from the limited anatomical similarities between them. For further details, see treatment of Sabiaceae and Introduction to Gunnerales (this volume).
General References
Morphology, Anatomy, Embryology, Chromosomes and Palynology Behnke, H.-D. 1991. Distribution and evolution of forms and types of sieve-element plastids in the dicotyledons. Aliso 13:167–182. Carlquist, S. 2003. Wood anatomy of Aextoxicaceae and Berberidopsidaceae is compatible with their inclusion in Berberidopsidales. Syst. Bot. 28:317–325. Corner, E.J.H. 1976. The seeds of dicotyledons, 2 vols. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Davis, G.L. 1966. Systematic embryology of the angiosperms. New York: Wiley. Eichler, A.W. 1875–1878. Blüthendiagramme, 2 vols. Leipzig: W. Engelmann. Erdtman, G. 1952. Pollen morphology and plant taxonomy. Stockholm: Almquist & Wiksell. Fedorov, A.A. (ed.) 1969. Chromosome numbers of flowering plants (in Russian). Leningrad: Nauka. Hideux, M.J., Ferguson, I.K. 1976. The stereostructure of the exine and its evolutionary significance in Saxifragaceae sensu lato. In Ferguson, I.K., Muller, J. (eds) The evolutionary significance of the exine. Linnean Society Symposium Series no. 1:327–378. London: Academic Press. Johri, B.M., Ambegoakar, K.B., Srivastava, P.S. 1992. Comparative embryology of angiosperms, 2 vols. Berlin Heidelberg New York: Springer. Matthews, M.L., Endress, P.K. 2005. Comparative floral structure and systematics in Crossosomatales (Crossosomataceae, Stachyuraceae, Staphyleaceae, Aphloiaceae, Geissolomataceae, Ixerbaceae, Strasburgeriaceae). Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 147:1–46. Metcalfe, C.R., Chalk, L. 1950. Anatomy of the dicotyledons, 2 vols. Oxford: Clarendon Press (2nd edn 1979 onwards). Netolitzky, F. 1926. Anatomie der Angiospermen– Samen. In: Linsbauer, K. (ed.) Handbuch der Pflanzenanatomie, 2. Abt., 2. Teil, vol. 10. Berlin: Borntraeger. Takhtajan, A. (ed.) 1991–2000. Anatomia seminum comparative (in Russian). Leningrad St. Petersburg: Nauka/Mir et Semja (Vol. 3: CaryophyllidaeDilleniidae; Vol. 4: Dicotyledons Dilleniidae; Vol. 5: Rosidae I; Vol. 6: Rosidae II).
Systematics and Classification APG (Angiosperm Phylogeny Group) 1998. An ordinal classification for the families of flowering plants. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 85:531–553.
APG (Angiosperm Phylogeny Group) II 2003. An update of the Angiosperm Phylogeny Group classification for the orders and families of flowering plants. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 141:399–436. Cronquist, A. 1981. An integrated system of classification of flowering plants. New York: Columbia University Press. Cronquist, A. 1988. The evolution and classification of flowering plants, 2nd edn. Bronx, NY: New York Botanical Garden. Johnson, L.A.S., Briggs, B. 1975. On the Proteaceae – the evolution and classification of a southern family. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 70:83–182. Johnson, L.A.S., Briggs, B.G. 1984. Myrtales and Myrtaceae – a phylogenetic analysis. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 71:700–756. Stevens, P.F. 2005. Angiosperm Phylogeny website, version 5. http://www.mobot.org/MOBOT/research/ APweb/welcome.html Takhtajan, A. 1980. Plant life, vol. 5, 1. Leningrad: Nauka. Takhtajan, A. (ed.) 1981. Plant life, vol. 5, 2. Leningrad: Nauka. Takhtajan, A. 1987. Systema Magnoliophytorum. Leningrad: Nauka. Takhtajan, A.L. (ed.) 1996. Anatomia seminum comparativa, vol. 5 (in Russian). St. Petersburg: Mir et Semja. Takhtajan, A. 1997. Diversity and classification of flowering plants. New York: Columbia University Press. Thorne, R.F. 2001. The classification and geography of the flowering plants: dicotyledons of the class Angiospermae. Bot. Rev. 66:441–647. Thorne, R.F. 2004. An updated classification of the class Angiospermae (8/9/2004). Xeroxed and privately distributed.
Phytochemistry Bate-Smith, E.C. 1962. The phenolic constituents of plants and their taxonomic significance. I. Dicotyledons. J. Linn. Soc. Bot. 58:95–173. Gibbs, R.D. 1974. Chemotaxonomy of flowering plants, 4 vols. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press. Hegnauer, R. 1962–1992. Chemotaxonomie der Pflanzen. Basel: Birkhaeuser (Vol. 1: 1962; Vol. 2: 1963; Vol. 3: 1964; Vol. 4: 1966; Vol. 5: 1969; Vol. 6: 1973; Vol. 7: 1986; Vol. 8: 1989; Vol. 9: 1990; Vol. 10: 1992). Nandi, O.I., Chase, M.W., Endress, P.K. 1998. A combined cladistic analysis of angiosperms using rbcL and non-molecular data. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 85:137–212.
22
Palaeobotany Knobloch, E., Mai, D. 1986. Monographie der Früchte und Samen in der Kreide Mitteleuropas. Rozpravy ústredního ústavu geologického svazek 47. Praha: Czechoslovachian Academy. Krutzsch, W. 1989. Paleogeography and historical phytogeography (paleochorology) in the Neophyticum. Pl. Syst. Evol. 162:5–61. Muller, J. 1981. Fossil pollen records of extant angiosperms. Bot. Rev. 47:1–142.
Molecular Systematics Albach, D.C., Soltis, P.S., Soltis, D.E., Olmstead, R.G. 2001. Phylogenetic analysis of asterids based on sequences of four genes. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 88:163–212. Anderberg, A.A., Rydin, C., Källersjö, M. 2002. Phylogenetic relationships in the order Ericales s.l.: analyses of molecular data from five genes from the plastid and mitochondrial genomes. Amer. J. Bot. 89:677–687. Anderson, C.L., Bremer, K., Friis, E.M. 2005. Dating phylogenetically basal eudicots unsing rbcL sequences and multiple fossil reference points. Amer. J. Bot. 92:1737– 1748. Cameron, K.M. 2003. On the phylogenetic position of the New Caledonian endemic families Paracryphiaceae, Oncothecaceae, and Strasburgeriaceae: a comparison of molecules and morphology. Bot. Rev. 68:428–443. Chase, M.W., Soltis, D.E., Olmstead, R.G., Morgan, D., Les, D.H. and 37 others 1993. Phylogenetics of seed plants: an analysis of nucleotide sequences from the plastid gene rbcL. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 80:528–580. Chase, M.W., Zmarzty, S., Lledo, M.D., Wurdack, K.J., Swensen, S.M., Fay, M.F. 2002. When in doubt, put it in Flacourtiaceae: a molecular phylogenetic analysis based on plastid rbcL DNA sequences. Kew Bull. 57:141–181. Conti, E., Litt, A., Sytsma, K.J. 1996. Circumscription of Myrtales and their relationships to other rosids: evidence from rbcL sequence data. Amer. J. Bot. 83:221–233. Conti, E., Litt, A., Wilson, P.G., Graham, S.A., Briggs, B.G., Johnson, L.A.S., Sytsma, K.J. 1997. Interfamilial relationships in Myrtales: molecular phylogeny and patterns of morphological evolution. Syst. Bot. 22:629– 647. Conti, E., Eriksson, T., Schönenberger, J., Sytsma, K.J., Baum, D.A. 2002. Early Tertiary out-of-India dispersal of Crypteroniaceae: evidence from phylogeny and molecular dating. Evolution 56:1931–1942. Davis, C.C., Webb, C.O., Wurdack, K.J., Jaramillo, C.A., Donoghue, M.J. 2005. Explosive radiation of Malpighiales supports a Mid-Cretaceous origin of modern tropical rain forests. Amer. Naturalist 165: E36–E65. Fishbein, M., Hibsch-Jetter, C., Soltis, D.E., Hufford, L. 2001. Phylogeny of Saxifragales (angiosperms, eudicots): analysis of a rapid, ancient radiation. Syst. Biol. 50:817–847.
Graham, S.A., Hall, J., Sytsma, K., Shi, S.-H. 2005. Phylogenetic analysis of the Lythraceae based on four gene regions and morphology. Intl J. Pl. Sci. 166:995– 1017. Hilu, K.W., Borsch, T., Müller, K., Soltis, D.E., Soltis, P.S., Savolainen, V. and 10 others 2003. Angiosperm phylogeny based on matK sequence information. Amer. J. Bot. 90:1758–1776. Morgan, D.R., Soltis, D.E. 1993. Phylogenetic relationships among members of Saxifragaceae sensu lato based on rbcL sequence data. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 80:631–660. Price, R.A., Palmer, J.D. 1993. Phylogenetic relationships of the Geraniaceae and Geraniales from rbcL sequence comparisons. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 80:661–671. Savolainen, V., Chase, M.W., Hoot, S.B., Morton, C.M., Soltis, D.E., Bayer, C., Fay, M.F., de Bruijn, A.Y., Sullivan, S., Qiu, Y.-L. 2000. Phylogenetics of flowering plants based on combined analysis of plastid atpB gene sequences. Syst. Biol. 49:306–362. Savolainen, V., Fay, M.F., Albach, D.C., Backlund, A., van der Bank, M., Cameron, K.M., Johnson, S.A., Lledó, M.D., Pintaud, J.C., Powell, M., Sheahan, M.C., Soltis, D.E., Soltis, P.S., Weston, P., Whitten, W.M., Wurdack, K.J., Chase, M.W. 2000. Phylogeny of the eudicots: a nearly complete familial analysis based on rbcL gene sequences. Kew Bull. 55:257–309. Soltis, S.E., Soltis, P.S., Nickrent, D.L., Johnson, L.A., Hahn, W.J., Hoot, S.B., Sweere, J.A., Kuzoff, R.K., Kron, K.A., Chase, M.W., Swensen, S.M., Zimmer, E.A., Chaw, S.M., Gillespie, L.J., Kress, W.J., Sytsma, K.J. 1997. Angiosperm phylogeny inferred from 18S ribosomal DNA sequences. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 84:1–49. Soltis, D.E., Soltis, P.S., Chase, M.W., Mort, M.E., Albach, D.C., Zanis, M., Savolainen, V., Hahn, W.H., Hoot, S.B., Fay, M.F., Axtell, M., Swensen, S.M., Prince, L.M., Kress, W.J., Nixon, K.C., Farris, J.S. 2000. Angiosperm phylogeny inferred from 18S rDNA, rbcL, and atpB sequences. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 133:381–461. Soltis, D.E., Senters, A.E., Zanis, M.J., Kim, S., Thompson, J.D., Soltis, P.S., Ronse deCraene, L.P., Endress, P.K., Farris, J.S. 2003. Gunnerales are sister to other core eudicots: implications for the evolution of pentamery. Amer. J. Bot. 90:461–470. Soltis, D.E., Soltis, P.S., Endress, P.K., Chase, M.W. 2005. Angiosperm phylogeny, classification, and evolution. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press. Sosa, V., Chase, M.W. 2003. Phylogenetics of Crossosomataceae based on rbcL sequence data. Syst. Bot. 28:96–105. Sytsma, K.J., Litt, A., Zjhra, M.L., Pires, C., Nepokroeff, M., Conti, E., Walker, J., Wilson, P.G. 2004. Clades, clocks and continents: historical and biogeographical analysis of Myrtaceae, Vochysiaceae and relatives in the southern hemisphere. Intl J. Pl. Sci. 165 suppl.:85– 105. Wikström, N., Savolainen, V., Chase, M.W. 2001. Evolution of the angiosperms: calibrating the family tree. Proc. Roy. Soc. London B, 268:2211–2220.
Aextoxicaceae1 Aextoxicaceae Engler & Gilg in Engler, Syllabus, ed. 8:250 (1920), nom. cons.
K. Kubitzki
Dioecious trees; twigs, the lower side of leaves, inflorescences and flowers including the ovary covered with ferrugineous scales. Leaves alternate to subopposite, simple, entire, conduplicate and sometimes minutely peltate, pinnately veined, estipulate. Inflorescences racemes or botryoids usually in groups of 3 or more, branching from axils of basal prophylls, the male ones longer and more abundant than the female ones; bracts very small, rounded. Flowers (4)5(6)-merous, hypogynous, regular, enveloped in bud by a firm calyptrate bract; sepals orbicular, free, thin, strongly imbricate, caducous; petals broadly clawed, incurved in bud, oblong, with thick midrib, imbricate, persistent; male flowers: stamens 5, antesepalous, alternating with well-developed fleshy, reniform nectary glands; anthers dorsifixed, introrse, opening by short slits towards the apex, with persistent septum between pollen sacs; gynoecium vestigial; female flowers: staminodia fleshy, alternating with the nectary glands; gynoecium 1-carpellate, style short, strongly deflexed to one side and appressed to the ovary, apically bifid; ovary with 2 pendulous ovules; ovules anatropous, with a long extended endostome. Fruits dry, indehiscent, oneseeded; endosperm ruminate, oily-proteinaceous; embryo well-developed, cotyledons flattened, cordate-orbicular. n = 16. Monotypic, Aextoxicon punctatum Ruiz & Pav., a tree of the coastal and lake region of southern Chile and adjacent Argentina. Morphology and Anatomy. On young shoots, the far-advanced conduplicate leaf primordia appear the year before they unfold (Fig. 4). They are densely covered by stellate scales and overwinter without being enclosed in a bud. Such “naked buds” are characteristic of several trees of the humid-temperate Valdivian rainforest and are also well-developed in young shoots of Proteaceae such 1
Including personal observations by P.F. Stevens and W. Stuppy.
Fig. 4. Aextoxicaceae. Aextioxicon punctatum, “naked bud” in February (early fall), the conduplicate leaf primordia densely covered by stellate scales; note also the minute peltation. (Photograph B. Fiebig)
as Gevuina avellana (pers. obs.). In the unfolded leaves, the cover of stellate scales is restricted to the lower leaf surface. Between the scales, short glands are interspersed. The plants are strongly tanniniferous but lack ethereal oil cells. The leaves are sometimes minutely peltate; on the adaxial side, the mesophyll tissue is uninterrupted at the base. Phellogen is superficial, and there are cortical sclereids, pericyclic fibres, and a strikingly heterogeneous pith. Nodes are trilacunar, and the peti-
24
K. Kubitzki
ole bundle is annular, although slightly flatter on the adaxial surface. Stomata are actinocyclic with 5–7 accessory cells. There are two layers of palisade tissue. Prismatic crystals, but no druses, are present in the stem, petiole and lamina, as are sclereids; in the lamina, they are quite spectacular, being as tall as about half the thickness of the blade. The wood of Aextoxicon is remarkable for its long vessel elements and tracheids (mean length 1,357 and 1,528 µm respectively), the former with perforation plates showing various degrees of pit membrane remnants and 49–84 bars per plate. Axial parenchyma is diffuse; rays are multiseriate and uniseriate, the uniseriate rays and uniseriate portions of multiseriate rays composed of upright cells, the central portion of multiseriate rays composed of markedly procumbent cells (Carlquist 2003). The morphological interpretation of the firm cover enclosing the flower buds has always been contentious. Some authors thought that it might represent the fused prophylls or a transformed sepal. The latter view was favoured by Pax and Hoffmann (1917), who found cross sections of the flower cover to consist of a single leaf organ. In contrast to all earlier descriptions, the ovary is 1-carpellate, not 2-carpellate. Embryology. The ovules are bitegmic and crassinucellate; the outer integument 2–3 cells thick, the inner 5–7. The endostome projects beyond the exostome. The ovules have a massive nucellar beak and numerous parietal layers (Mauritzon 1936). Several authors characterised the ovule as apotropous, which is inappropriate by definition, as the monomerous ovary has no central axis. Pollen Morphology. Pollen grains are spheroidal, tricolporate, with lalongate ora, 17 × 18 µm (Erdtman 1952). Fruit and Seed. The drupes have a coriaceous pericarp, and the endocarp cracks along two lines. The solitary seed is campylotropous, the seed coat is undifferentiated, about 6 cells thick, and tanniniferous, the endosperm is ruminate, and the embryo is slightly curved and seems to be horizontaloblique in the seed. Phytochemistry. Aextoxicon is strongly tanniniferous.
Fig. 5. Aextoxicaceae. Aextoxicon punctatum. A Flowering and fruiting branch. B Two leaves with axillary raceme. C Stellate scale. D Flower bud. E Same, calyptrate bract removed. F Male flower, one petal removed. G Female flower showing disk, staminodes, scaly gynoecium and deflexed style, petals removed. H Fruit with seed. (Drawn by M. Raspini; Dimitri 1972)
Aextoxicaceae
Affinities. The position of Aextoxicon has been disputed by many authors (see, e.g. Pax and Hoffmann 1917; Takhtajan 1997), and placements in or close to Euphorbiaceae, Celastrales, Sapindales and Icacinaceae have been proposed. More recently, gene sequence analyses established a sister relationship with Berberidopsidaceae at the basis of the core eudicots (Angiosperm Phylogeny Group, APG II 2003). This is supported also by anatomical data, although these refer mostly to plesiomorphies, as emphasised by Carlquist (2003). Distribution and Habitat. Aextoxicon is member of the temperate Valdivian rainforest in Chile and adjacent border with Argentina, growing preferentially at localities with high air humidity. In coastal habitats, it is a small tree and wind-shorn shrub on dunes and rocks and, further inland in the lake region, a medium-sized tree. Aextoxicon extends from 36 to 44◦ S and, further north at about 30◦ S, has a relic occurrence in the Chilean Coastal Cordillera.
25
One monotypic genus: 1. Aextoxicon Ruiz & Pav.
Figs. 4, 5
Aextoxicon Ruiz & Pav., Prodr.: 131, t. 29 (1794).
Selected Bibliography APG II (2003). See general references. Carlquist, S. 2003. Wood anatomy of Aextoxicaceae and Berberidopsidaceae is compatible with their inclusion in Berberidopsidales. Syst. Bot. 28:317–325. Dimitri, M.J. (ed.) 1972. La región de los bosques andinopatagónicos. Buenos Aires: INTA. Erdtman, G. 1952. See general references. Mauritzon, J. 1936. Die Embryologie und systematische Abgrenzung der Reihen Terebinthales und Celastrales. Bot. Notiser 1936:161–212. Pax, F., Hoffmann, K. 1917. Systematische Stellung der Gattung Aextoxicon. Jahresber. Schles. Gesell. für vaterländ. Cultur 1916, II. Abt., Zool.-bot. Sekt.: 17–21. Radcliffe-Smith, A. 1987. Segregate families from the Euphorbiaceae. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 94:47–66. Takhtajan, A. 1997. See general references.
Alzateaceae Alzateaceae S.A. Graham, Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 71:775 (1985).
S.A. Graham
Small evergreen trees or shrubs, sometimes hemiepiphytic; young stems and axes of the inflorescence quadrangulate. Leaves opposite or whorled, simple, entire; blades oblong-obovate or elliptical, coriaceous, glabrous, venation brochidodromous; stipules 2–a few. Inflorescences thyrsoidal, axillary at the ends of branches, 10–30-flowered; flowers actinomorphic, bisexual, barely hemi-epigynous, 5(6)-merous, apetalous or possibly petals rudimentary; floral tube campanulate; sepals valvate, thick, irregularly fleshy on the adaxial surface; stamens 5, fleshy, inserted below the sinus of adjacent sepals at the margin of a broad lobed nectary, filaments short with large cordate connective, the anthers dorsifixed, introrse, the sporangia terminal; ovary superior, bilaterally compressed, bilocular; placentation parietal; ovules 40–60, horizontally imbricate in staggered vertical rows. Fruits bilaterally compressed dry capsules dehiscing loculicidally. Seeds flattened, oblong to lunate, thin, encircled by a fragile membranous wing; embryo central, straight; endosperm 0. n = 14. A single species, Alzatea verticillata Ruiz & Pav. with two narrowly separated subspecies from Central and South America. Vegetative Anatomy. Anatomy agrees with generalized characteristics of the Myrtales but does not indicate close affinities to any one family. Leaves include sclereids of the same shape as the spongy mesophyll cells; stomates are anomocytic and cyclocytic (Keating 1984). Uniquely, among the families to which Alzatea has been previously related, Alzatea has trilacunar three-trace nodes, rather than unilacunar one-trace nodes (Graham 1984). Wood anatomy (Baas 1979; Baas and Zweypfenning 1979) is characterized by diffuse vessels, solitary or in radial multiples of 2–4 with inter-vessel pits vestured and end walls oblique with simple perforations; septate fibers with thin walls; very scanty paratracheal parenchyma; rays of type heterogeneous I-II, 1–3-seriate; crystals
absent. Internal phloem forms a continuous ring, and druses are abundant in chambered phloem parenchyma. Flower Structure. The fleshy flowers are small, 4–6 mm long. They are obhaplostemonous, a synapomorphy that unites members of the clade Alzatea + Rhynchocalycaceae + Oliniaceae + Penaeaceae (Schönenberger and Conti 2003). van Beusekom-Osinga and van Beusekom (1975) report rudimentary petals that are scarcely visible and already mucilaginous in bud, although even these are not always present (Graham, pers. obs.). The stamens are easily mistaken for petals, due to enlarged heart-shaped, pinkish connectives that are conspicuously exserted between the sepals at anthesis. Embryology. Tobe and Raven (1984) investigated the embryological development of Alzatea and compared it to that of related families. The anthers are tetrasporangiate; the endothecium and the middle layers of the anther wall degenerate early; dehiscence is accomplished by rupture of thin-walled epidermal cells. Ovules are anatropous, crassinucellate, and bitegmic. Embryo sac formation is of the bisporic Allium type, a type unknown elsewhere in the order. The archesporium is multicelled. The inner integument remains two-layered, and ultimately elongates beyond the outer integument to form the micropyle. Endosperm is probably of the Nuclear type and cotyledons are planar. Embryology of Alzatea is most similar to that of Rhynchocalycaceae, and in general agreement with other Myrtales (Tobe and Raven 1984, 1987). Pollen Morphology. Pollen grains are circular in outline, tricolporate; the ektexine bridges over a circular pore; the exine is psilate bordering the colpi, thinner and verrucate-aerolate in the mesocolpal regions, thus suggesting faint sub-
Alzateaceae
sidiary colpi; diameter 18–22 µm (Graham 1984; Patel et al. 1984; Graham et al. 1985). The external morphology of the exine is relatively generalized whereas the internal structure shares a zigzag columellar layer with Dactylocladus and Axinandra in the Crypteroniaceae (Patel et al. 1984).
27
and South America. Considered restricted to Peru and Bolivia until it was discovered in Costa Rica in 1936, subsequent discoveries in Panama in 1978 and Colombia in 1986 revealed a more continuous distribution than previously known (Silverstone-Sopkin and Graham 1986). Increased
Karyology. A haploid chromosome number of n = 14 has been counted from A. verticillata subsp. amplifolia (Almeda 1997). Given a basic number for the order Myrtales of x = 12 (Raven 1975), the basic number of Alzateaceae may have arisen from x = 12 as an ascending dysploid or alternatively, it may represent a tetraploid from an ancestral base of 7 (Almeda 1997). Clarification may come when chromosome numbers of Crypteroniaceae, considered ancestral to Alzateaceae (Schönenberger and Conti 2003), become known. Phytochemistry. Ellagic acid and flavonoid mono- and di-glycosides, including quercetin 3-Oglucoside and quercetin 3-O-diglucoside, have been detected in leaves of Alzatea (Graham 1984; Graham and Averett 1984). The profile is in keeping with that of the order, which is rich in ellagic acid and tannins (Hegnauer 1969). It differs from the common pattern by the absence of myricetin and C-glycoflavones (Graham and Averett 1984). Affinities. In the past, Alzatea has been aligned with eight families in five orders, among them, Lythraceae and Crypteroniaceae in Myrtales (Lourteig 1965; van Beusekom-Osinga and van Beusekom 1975). Graham (1984) elevated Alzatea to family status after comparison of extensive non-molecular data that determined that Alzatea was distinctly separated from its nearest living relative, Rhynchocalyx. Phylogenetic analyses of cpDNA sequences from several genes and chloroplast spacer regions now affirm the monophyly of Alzateaceae as a member of Myrtales in a lineage with the Southeast Asian Crypteroniaceae sister to Alzateaceae + the African families Rhynchocalycaceae, Oliniaceae, and Penaeaceae. Alzateaceae, in turn, are sister to Rhynchocalycaceae–Oliniaceae + Penaeaceae, a position supported by bootstrap values varying from ≤ 50 to 92%, depending on the analysis (Conti et al. 1997, 2002; Clausing and Renner 2001; Schönenberger and Conti 2003). Distribution and Habitats. Alzatea grows in mid- to low-montane forests along the eastern slopes of the Andes and mountains of Central
Fig. 6. Alzateaceae. Alzatea verticillata. A Flowering twig. B Flower bud. C Flower. D Disk. E Three stamens. F Transversal section of ovary. G Fruit. H Transversal section of fruit. I Seed. (Lourteig 1965)
28
S.A. Graham
collections have diminished the morphological differences between subspecies (Graham 1995). Only one genus: Alzatea Ruiz & Pav.
Fig. 6
Alzatea Ruiz & Pav., Prodr.: 40 (1794).
Description as for family.
Selected Bibliography Almeda, F. 1997. Chromosomal observations on the Alzateaceae (Myrtales). Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 84:305– 308. Baas, P. 1979. The anatomy of Alzatea Ruiz & Pav. (Myrtales). Acta Bot. Neerl. 28:156–158. Baas, P., Zweypfenning, R.C.V.J. 1979. Wood anatomy of the Lythraceae. Acta Bot. Neerl. 28:117–155. Clausing, G., Renner, S.S. 2001. Molecular phylogenetics of Melastomataceae and Memecylaceae: implications for character evolution. Amer. J. Bot. 88:486–498. Conti, E. et al. 1997. See general references. Conti, E. et al. 2002. See general references. Graham, S.A. 1984. Alzateaceae, a new family of Myrtales in the American Tropics. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 71:757–779. Graham, S.A. 1995. Two new species in Cuphea (Lythraceae), and a note on Alzateaceae. Novon 5:272–277.
Graham, S.A., Averett, J.E. 1984. Flavonoids of Alzateaceae (Myrtales). Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 71:855–857. Graham, A., Nowicke, J., Skvarla, J.J., Graham, S.A., Patel, V., Lee, S. 1985. Palynology and systematics of the Lythraceae. I. Introduction and genera Adenaria through Ginoria. Amer. J. Bot. 72:1012–1031. Hegnauer, R. 1969. See general references. Keating, R.C. 1984. Leaf histology and its contribution to relationships in the Myrtales. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 71:801–823. Lourteig, A. 1965. On the systematic position of Alzatea verticillata R. & P. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 52:371– 378. Patel, V.C., Skvarla, J.J., Raven, P.H. 1984. Pollen characters in relation to the delimitation of Myrtales. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 71:858–969. Raven, P.H. 1975. The bases of angiosperm phylogeny: cytology. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 62:724–764. Schönenberger, J., Conti, E. 2003. Molecular phylogeny and floral evolution of Penaeaceae, Oliniaceae, Rhynchocalycaceae, and Alzateaceae (Myrtales). Amer. J. Bot. 90:293–309. Silverstone-Sopkin, P.A., Graham, S.A. 1986. Alzateaceae, a plant family new to Colombia. Brittonia 38:340–343. Tobe, H., Raven, P.H. 1984. The embryology and relationships of Alzatea Ruiz & Pav. (Alzateaceae, Myrtales). Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 71:844–852. Tobe, H., Raven, P.H. 1987. The embryology and relationships of Dactylocladus (Crypteroniaceae) and a discussion of the family. Bot. Gaz. 148:103–111. van Beusekom-Osinga, R.J., van Beusekom, C.F. 1975. Delimitation and subdivision of the Crypteroniaceae (Myrtales). Blumea 22:255–266.
Aphanopetalaceae Aphanopetalaceae Doweld, Prosyllabus tracheophytorum: XXVII (2001).
K. Kubitzki
Scrambling or viny shrubs, glabrous throughout; nodes unilacunar, 1(+ 2) trace; stems with conspicuous raised lenticels. Leaves opposite, simple, serrate to mostly entire, shortly petiolate; stipules 0 but with minute colleters at each side of the nodes. Inflorescences lax axillary panicles, or flowers solitary; pedicels at the mid with 2 prophylls. Flowers regular, hermaphrodite, tetramerous, half-inferior; sepals largely separate, imbricate at lower level, greatly enlarged in fruit and persistent, borne in pairs at slightly different levels, their basal parts coalescing with basal portions of petals (when present) and stamens into a short floral tube which is adnate to the lower half of the ovary wall; petals minute with reduced blade or completely absent (even within the same individual); stamens 8; anthers oblong, 2-lobed at base, almost basifixed, tetrasporangiate, with connective protrusion, dehiscing with longitudinal slits, latrorse-introrse; gynoecium of 4 laterally concrescent carpels; ovary one quarter- to half-inferior, 4-locular, deeply 4-furrowed, gradually tapering into a 4grooved, apically 4-lobed style with 4 canals; stigmas terminal, highly papillate; ovules 1 per locule, descending, suspended on axile placenta with long, thick funiculus, bitegmic, anatropous. Fruit nut-like, hard, 1-locular and 1-seeded, with the sepals persistent; seed hippocrepiform or reniform; embryo curved; endosperm fleshy. A family comprising a single genus with two species in Australia. Anatomy and Morphology. (All data from Dickison 1980b, Dickison et al. 1994, and Dickison and Rutishauser 1990). Between the opposite leaves, small non-vascular colleters are present, which perhaps are reduced stipules. The innermost layer of the cortex is formed by a well-defined endodermis. Nodes are unilacunar and the single large trace diverges to produce dorsally or laterally situated petiolar bundles. Stomata are anomocytic. The leaves are bifacial; the epidermis is uniseriate.
Dark deposits have been found in the mesophyll of both species. Leaf teeth are weakly vascularized and non-glandular. In mature stems, prominent lenticels develop on the cortex. Cork is surficial. Vessels are solitary or rarely in radial multiples; vessel elements with scalariform perforation plates with 2–6 thick, fully bordered bars; fibre-tracheids non-septate, thick-walled, pitted, rays homocellular, uniseriate and heterocellular, multiseriate, the latter 2–4 cells wide and composed of procumbent and upright cells. Axial parenchyma is scarce and apotrachealdiffuse. Floral Structure. Apart from the details given in the family description, information on the vascular anatomy of Aphanopetalum can be found in Dickison (1975) and Dickison et al. (1994). Pollen Morphology. Pollen of Aphanopetalum is tricolporate, prolate, fully tectate; the endoaperture is simple-diffuse; the rugulate-stellate sculpture is unique in Saxifragaceae/Cunoniaceae (Hideux and Ferguson 1976). Embryology. The anther has a fibrous endothecium and a tapetum of 2–3 cells. The ovules have a long, thick funiculus, and are bitegmic and anatropous. Affinities and Phylogeny. Until recently, the systematic relationships of Aphanopetalum were unclear. Hoogland (1960) and Dickison (1980b) noted that this genus was out of place in Cunoniaceae. It differs from Cunoniaceae in having unilacunar nodes and lacking stipules, and from Saxifragaceae in having opposite leaves and lacking foliar trichomes, and is unique in possessing a pronounced endodermis. However, tetramerous flowers and single (or 2) ovules per carpel are known elsewhere in woody Saxifragales. This is consistent with the results of molecular studies, particularly with the topology of Fishbein et al. (2001), in which
30
K. Kubitzki
Fig. 7. Aphanopetalaceae. Aphanopetalum resinosum. A Habit. B, C Flower. D Androecium and gynoecium.
E Stamen. F Pistil. G Carpel, vertical section. (Drawing F. Bauer; Endlicher 1841)
Aphanopetalum is part of the “Haloragis clade”, which is sister to the “Saxifragaceae clade”.
Dickison, W.C. 1975. Studies on the floral anatomy of the Cunoniaceae. Amer. J. Bot. 62:433–447. Dickison, W.C. 1980a. Diverse nodal anatomy of the Cunoniaceae. Amer. J. Bot. 67:975–981. Dickison, W.C. 1980b. Comparative wood anatomy and evolution of the Cunoniaceae. Allertonia 2:281–321. Dickison, W.C., Rutishauser, R. 1990. Developmental morphology of stipules and systematics of the Cunoniaceae and presumed allies. II. Taxa without interpetiolar stipules and conclusions. Bot. Helv. 100:75–95. Dickison, W.C., Hils, H.M., Lugansky, T.W., Stern, W.L. 1994. Comparative anatomy and systematics of woody Saxifragaceae. Aphanopetalum Endl. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 114:167–182. Endlicher, S. 1841. Iconographia generum plantarum, II, tabula 39. Wien: F. Beck. Fishbein, M. et al. 2001. See general references. Hideux, M.J., Ferguson, I.K. 1976. See general references. Hoogland, R.D. 1960. Studies in the Cunoniaceae. I. The genera Ceratopetalum, Gillbeea, Aistopetalum, and Calycomis. Austral. J. Bot. 8:318–341.
Only one genus: Aphanopetalum Endl.
Fig. 7
Aphanopetalum Endl., Gen. Pl.: 818 (1839), and Iconogr. t. 96 (1839); Bentham, Fl. Austral. 2:441–442 (1864).
Description as for family. Two species in Australia, A. resinosum Endl. in river scrubs of temperate southern Queensland and New South Wales, and A. clematideum Domin in crevices of limestone rocks in south-western Australia.
Selected Bibliography Bailey, F.M. 1990. The Queensland flora. Queensland: H.J. Diddams.
Aphloiaceae Aphloiaceae Takht., Bot. Zhurn. (Moscow & Leningrad) 70:1691 (1985).
K. Kubitzki
Evergreen shrubs or slender trees, entirely glabrous. Leaves persistent, alternate, serrate or serrulate, rarely subentire, penninerved, petiolate; stipules minute, caducous. Flowers hermaphrodite, axillary, solitary or in few-flowered racemes or fascicles, sweet-scented; bracts scale-like, minute; pedicels with 1–3 scaly bracteoles in the lower half; perianth uniseriate; sepals 4–5(6), white, turning yellowish, free except at the base, imbricate, orbicular, the inner 3 more membranous and petaloid; petals 0; stamens very numerous, free, inserted towards the outer edge of a glandular disk; filaments filiform; anthers small, orbicular, introrse, basifixed near the base; gynoecium monomerous; ovary superior, ellipsoid, sessile or shortly stipitate, 1-locular; placentation lateral with 6–8 alternating ovules in 2 rows; ovules campylotropous; stigma sessile, large, capitate-bilobed and somewhat decurrent on ventral side. Fruit a fleshy, white berry with persistent perianth and about 6 obovate seeds; testa crustaceous, smooth, whitish, glossy; embryo incurved; endosperm sparse. A monogeneric family with a single polymorphic (or 8?) species in eastern and South Africa, Madagascar including the Comores, and the Mascarenes and Seychelles. Vegetative Morphology and Anatomy. Aphloia theiformis is a shrub or slender tree; the branchlets are drooping and longitudinally striate with a stronger line decurrent from a stipulate cushion. Leaves are distichous. Friedmann and Cadet (1976) observed that juvenile plants growing in xeric habitats on Réunion have pinnatisect leaves, whereas these are undivided in adult specimens. The cork is pericyclic; stomata are anisocytic; nodes are 3-lacunar (Stevens 2005). In the wood, growth rings are poorly defined. The vessel elements are mostly very long (1,051–2,416 µm) and have scalariform perforation plates. Rays are unicellular with upright cells, and multiseriate heterocellular with long uniseriate extensions. Fibre-
tracheids are present, and the axial parenchyma is vasicentric and apotracheal-diffuse (Miller 1975). Reproductive Structures. van Tieghem (1899) found the vascular supply of the stamens originating from five antesepalous trunk bundles. A detailed analysis of the floral morphology and anatomy was given by Matthews and Endress (2005). The bitegmic, crassinucellate and campylotropous ovule develops into an incurved seed with a hippocrepiform embryo. The seeds are exotestal. In the mature seeds, the testa is multiplicative with several outer, strongly thickened lignified layers and the tegmen crushed (Trifonova 1992).
Fig. 8. Aphloiaceae. Aphloia theiformis. A Flowering branch. B Flower bud. C Flower. D Stamen. E Pistil, vertical section. F Same, transversal section. G Fruit. H, I Seed. (Engler 1910)
32
K. Kubitzki
Pollen Morphology. The pollen grains are spheroidal, 20–25 µm long and wide, striate, tricolporate with large, elliptical, lalongate endoapertures, the colpi diffuse, weakly costate; the exine is 1.5–2 µm thick (Keating 1973). Phytochemistry. Bate-Smith (1965) recorded mangiferin from Aphloia. Affinities. Takhtajan (1987) placed Aphloiaceae in his Violales, along with Berberidopsidaceae and Flacourtiaceae. Since then, various molecular studies have recovered Aphloia together with Ixerba in association with the Crossosomatales clade (see Soltis et al. 2000; Savolainen, Fay et al. 2000; Cameron 2003). Distribution and Habitats. In submontane forest, mist forest and riverine forest, and in upland riverine bushland, 1,300–2,900 m. A single genus: Aphloia (DC.) Benn.
Fig. 8
Aphloia (DC.) Benn. in Benn. & Br., Pl. Jav. Rar. 2:192 (1838). Neumannia A. Rich. (1845).
A problematic, polymorphic species, Aphloia theiformis (Vahl) Benn., see above.
Selected Bibliography Bate-Smith, E.C. 1965. Recent progress in the chemical taxonomy of some phenolic constituents of plants. Mém. Soc. Bot. France 1965:16–28. Cameron, K.M. 2003. See general references. Engler, A. 1910. Die Pflanzenwelt Afrikas, 1. Leipzig: W. Engelmann. Friedmann, F., Cadet, T. 1976. Observation sur l’hétérophyllie dans les îles Mascareignes. Adansonia II, 15:423– 440. Keating, R.C. 1973. Pollen morphology and relationships of the Flacourtiaceae. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 60:273– 305. Krishnan, N. 1981. Pollen morphology of some Flacourtiaceae. Proc. Ind. Acad. Sci., Pl. Sci. 90:163–168. Matthews, M.L., Endress, P.K. 2005. See general references. Miller, R.B. 1975. Systematic anatomy of the xylem and comments on the relationships of Flacourtiaceae. J. Arnold Arb. 56:20–102. Savolainen, V., Fay, M.F. et al. 2000. See general references. Soltis, D.E. et al. 2000. See general references. Stevens, P.F. 2005. See general references. Takhtajan, A. 1987. See general references. Tieghem, P. van 1899. Sur le genre Neumannia considéré comme type d’une famille nouvelle, les Neumanniacées. J. Bot. (Morot) 13:361–367. Trifonova, W.I. 1992. Aphloiaceae. In: Takhtajan, A. (ed.) Anatomia seminum comparativa, 4. St. Petersburg: Nauka, p. 80. Wild, H. 1960. Flacourtiaceae. In: Exell, A.W., Wild, H. (eds) Flora Zambesiaca 1, 1:261–298. London: Crown Agents.
Berberidopsidaceae Berberidopsidaceae A.L. Takhtajan, Bot. Zhurn. (Moscow & Leningrad) 70:1691 (1985).
K. Kubitzki
Scandent shrubs with sympodial branching and collateral axillary buds. Leaves spiral, simple, sub-3–5-pli-nerved, entire to coarsely dentate, estipulate, petioles pulvinate or not. Flowers in racemes or solitary, hypogynous, hermaphrodite (always?); pedicels with prophylls; petals welldeveloped, either distinct from sepals, or outer sepaloid tepals grading into inner petaloid ones; disk extra-staminal, persistent in fruit, or 0; stamens either in a single whorl of 6–13, or numerous and densely packed on torus; anthers (sub)basifixed, dehiscing longitudinally laterointrorse; ovary 1-locular, placentas parietal, 3 or 5, ovules epitropous, 2 or more per placenta. Fruit berry-like, indehiscent, with persistent style; seeds with fleshy or leathery exotesta, with chalazal arilloid (only Streptothamnus); endosperm copious, oily-proteinaceous; embryo minute. Two genera, one monotypic in Australia, the other with one species in Australia, another in Chile. Vegetative Anatomy. The leaves are hypostomatic, and the stomata are cyclocytic and surrounded by one or two rings of subsidiary cells. Other leaf anatomical features are restricted to the two species of Berberidopsis, such as the possession of 1–3-celled uniseriate hairs, druses and solitary crystals in the petiole, and sclerenchyma accompanying major leaf veins. In the c. 4 mm thick twigs of both genera, cork is not developed; growth rings are present; rays in secondary xylem are 1–multi-seriate, composed of procumbent cells, the uniseriate portions composed of upright cells; vessels are exclusively solitary and have scalariform perforations with 18–41 bars; a faint spiral thickening is present only in vessels of Berberidopsis corallina; fibres have distinctly bordered pits in radial and tangential walls and are non-septate (fibre-tracheids); axial parenchyma is mostly diffuse (Miller 1975; Baas 1984; Carlquist 2003).
Floral Morphology. Whereas Streptothamnus (and the closely related Aextoxicum) have cyclic pentamerous flowers with persistent calyx lobes and five caducous petals, the flowers of Berberidopsis are acyclic and fully spiral, with all floral organs following a regular sequence in a 2/5 pattern (Ronse De Craene 2004) and tending to appear in alternating groups of five. Pollen Morphology. Pollen grains are spheroidal to prolate and tricolpate to tricolporate, and tectate-columellate with an imperforate to microperforate tectum the sculpture of which varies from foveolate to rugulate and striate; those of Berberidopsis are 20–30 µm and of Streptothamnus smaller than 15 µm (Keating 1973, 1975; van Heel 1984). Seed. The seeds of Berberidopsidaceae have a peculiar protruding, “sausage-shaped” raphe. They are endotestal; the inner epidermis of the testa has strongly lignified pitted cells each containing a crystal. There are also indications of a less pronounced fibrous exotegmen. The embryo is very small. All these features distinguish Berberidopsidaceae from Flacourtiaceae (= Salicacaceae plus Achariaceae), in which they formerly were included and the seeds of which are exotegmic and have a sarcotesta formed by the outer integument (van Heel 1979, 1984); the embryo in those families is also larger. Affinities. The recognition of a second species of Berberidopsis (formerly included in Streptothamnus) by Veldkamp (1984) has prompted the anatomical studies of van Heel (1984) and Baas (1984), which have provided evidence for the restriction of the formerly more broadly circumscribed tribe Berberidopsideae to Berberidopsis and Streptothamnus. Takhtajan (1985) elevated this tribe to family rank but retained the narrowly circumscribed Berberidopsidaceae
34
K. Kubitzki
in Violales, along with Flacourtiaceae (Takhtajan 1987, 1997). Nandi et al. (1998), on the basis of a combined morphological/rbcL analysis, were the first to suggest a relationship between Berberidospsidaceae and Aextoxicaceae – never even considered in pre-molecular times – and Carlquist (2003) pointed to the great similarities in the wood anatomy of the two families, all of which, however, are plesiomorphic. The association of Berberidospidaceae with Aextoxicaceare has received such strong molecular support that Soltis et al. (2000) and Savolainen, Fay et al. (2000) suggested that the two families be placed in the same order. A four-gene analysis of eudicots (Soltis et al. 2003) has provided a resolution of the major core eudicot lineages, in which Gunnerales and subsequently Berberidopsidales are sister to all major core eudicot lineages. However, the relation of Berberidopsidales to other core eudicots is unclear.
Ronse DeCraene (2004) analysed the spiral sequence of initiation of perianth members and stamens in Berberidopsis corallina, and found a tendency of these organs to occur in alternating groups of five which, according to him, may represent an incipient case of pentamery. At first glance, this might appear convincing, particularly in view of the position of Berberidopsidaceae at the basis of the core eudicots above the node leading to (dimerous) Gunnerales, but it is problematic with regard to various structural aspects of the relatives of Berberidopsis, and of Berberidopsis itself. Berberidopsis has a tepaline perianth of 13–17 members whereas in Streptothamnus, which has five sepals and five petals, the androecium consists of numerous stamens which are densely packed but do not show any particular arrangement – evidently a derived condition. The paracarpous gynoecium in both genera of Berberidopsidaceae is also probably derived. These traits would hardly be expected in a group in which the transition from the spiral to the whorled condition took place quasi before our eyes, because then a less derived gynoecium structure would be expected, too. Even more pertinent seems the fact that the flowers of closely related Aextoxicon, with their fixed pentamery and haplostemony, are quite typically core eudicot. For these reasons, the spiral arrangement in Berberidopsis is probably a derived, rather than the original condition. Uses. Berberidospsis corallina has very showy, coral red or scarlet flowers, and has been introduced into gardens in Chile and Great Britain. Key to the Genera 1. Flowers acyclic; tepals 13–17, spirally set, caducous; disk present, persistent; stamens 6–13, filaments short, connective broad, muriculate, anthers muriculate 1. Berberidopsis – Flowers cyclic; sepals 5, persistent, petals 5, caducous; disk 0; stamens numerous, filaments longer than anthers, filiform, connective inconspicuous except for terminal lobe, anthers smooth 2. Streptothamnus
1. Berberidopsis Hook. f.
Fig. 9
Berberidopsis Hook. f. in Curtis, Bot. Mag. III, 18: t. 5343 (1862); Gunckel, Bol. Univ. Chile 46: 24:24–27, fig. (1964); Veldkamp, Blumea 30:24–28 (1984). Fig. 9. Berberidospidaceae. Berberidopsis corallina. A Flowering branch. B Flower buds. C Androecium. D Pistil with nectary disk. E Pistil, vertically cut. (Schneider 1912)
Leaf blades ovate to hastiform, entire to coarsely dentate. Flowers solitary or in many-flowered racemes; disk with as many lobes as stamens; style
Berberidopsidaceae
club-shaped with inconspicuous stigma; ovary with 3 or 5 placentae. Fruit with thin pericarp; seeds numerous; raphe a narrow, sausage-shaped lateral wing. Two species, B. beckleri (F. Muell.) Veldk., in montane rainforest of Queensland and New South Wales, Australia, and B. corallina Hook. f., in gorges by streams in the Coastal Cordillera of southern Chile from Prov. Talca to Osorno. 2. Streptothamnus F. Muell. Streptothamnus F. Muell., Fragm. Phyt. Austral. 3:27 (1862); Jessup in Fl. Australia 8:76 (1982).
Leaf blades ovate to elliptic, entire; flowers solitary or in a ± leafy raceme; disk 0; anthers basifixed; stigma mushroom-shaped; ovary 1-locular, placentas indistinct, probably 3. Fruit with thickish pericarp; seeds up to 25 per fruit, with median-lateral chalazal aril. One species, S. moorei F. Muell., in montane rainforest of Queensland and New South Wales, Australia, sometimes together with Berberidopsis beckleri F. Muell.
Selected Bibliography Baas, P. 1984. Vegetative anatomy and taxonomy of Berberidopsis and Streptothamnus (Flacourtiaceae). Blumea 30:39–44.
35
Carlquist, S. 2003. Wood anatomy of Aextoxicaceae and Berberidopsidaceae is compatible with their inclusion in Berberidopsidales. Syst. Bot. 28:317–325. Heel, W.A. van 1979. Flowers and fruits in Flacourtiaceae. IV. Hydnocarpus spp., Kiggelaria africana L., Casearia spp., Berberidopsis corallina Hook. f. Blumea 25:513–529. Heel, W.A. van 1984. Flowers and fruits in Flacourtiaceae. V. The seed anatomy and pollen morphology of Berberidopsis and Streptothamnus. Blumea 30:31–37. Keating, R.C. 1973. Pollen morphology and relationships of the Flacourtiaceae. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 60:273–305. Keating, R.C. 1975. Trends in specialization in pollen of Flacourtiaceae with comparative observations of Cochlospermaceae and Bixaceae. Grana 15:29–49. Miller, R.B. 1975. Systematic anatomy of the xylem and comments on the relationships of the Flacourtiaceae. J. Arnold Arb. 56:20–102. Nandi, O.I. et al. 1998. See general references. Ronse DeCraene, L.P. 2004. Floral development of Berberidopsis corallina: a crucial link in the evolution of flowers in the core eudicots. Ann. Bot. 94:741–751. Savolainen, V., Fay, M.F. et al. 2000. See general references. Schneider, C.K. 1912. Illustriertes Handbuch der Laubholzkunde, 2. Jena: G. Fischer. Soltis, D.E. et al. 2000. See general references. Soltis, D.E. et al. 2003. See general references. Takhtajan, A. 1987. See general references. Takhtajan, A. 1997. See general references. Veldkamp, J.F. 1984. Berberidopsis (Flacourtiaceae) in Australia. Blumea 30:21–29. Warburg, O. 1894. Flacourtiaceae. In: Engler, A., Prantl, K., Die natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien III, 6a. Leipzig: W. Engelmann. pp. 1–56.
Bonnetiaceae Bonnetiaceae (Bartl.) L. Beauvis. ex Nakai in Bull. Tokyo Sci. Mus. 22:25 (1948).
A.L. Weitzman, K. Kubitzki, and P.F. Stevens
More or less subpachycaulous small to mediumsized trees and shrubs. Leaves convolute, spiral, crowded towards apex of branches, with close, ascending lateral veins, margins serrulate, initially setulose, estipulate; petiole short or 0. Flowers single, or more or less cymose inflorescences; pedicels with 2 prophylls or several bracts; flowers bisexual, cyclic; sepals 5, unequal, free, quincuncial; petals 5, contorted, free; stamens numerous; filaments slender, free, or basally connate into 5 antepetalous bundles; anthers short, basifixed; fasciclode + or 0; ovary 3(–5)-locular, with numerous orderly arranged ovules on biseriate axile placentae; stylodia free or united into a branched or simple style; stigmas papillate. Fruits septicidal capsules with a persistent central column; seeds with scanty endosperm; embryo straight. Three genera and about 40 species, northern South America, West Indies, Southeast Asia, West Malesia, Moluccas and New Guinea. Vegetative Morphology and Anatomy. Bonnetiaceae are stout-stemmed shrubs or usually small trees with few branches. The smallest species, Bonnetia ahogadoi, is notable for its trailing and rooting inflorescence axis which also acts as a stolon (Fig. 10), whereas Ploiarium alterniflorum, a small, stilt-rooted tree, may grow up to 25 m high on swampy peat soil in Johore (Corner 1978). The terminal bud usually lacks scales, axillary buds are small, and branching appears to be sylleptic, although in B. ahogadoi growth of the main axis appears to be rhythmic (Steyermark 1984) and there are scales at the base of flagelliform inflorescence shoots. The leaves remain rolled up as the bud elongates, and are more or less sessile and usually have a distinct but not very prominent midrib. The plants are completely glabrous, except for tiny colleters found in the leaf axils. The leaf margin is usually minutely serrulate and only rarely entire but, in the juvenile stage, it is always provided with minute setae which fall off during leaf expansion
but persist in the tiny, revolute leaves of Bonnetia roraimae. Archytaea and Ploiarium have vascularised, disciform structures borne immediately inside the margin and on the lower surface of the blade and in its upper one-third. Venation is often eucamptodromous, sometimes more or less brochidodromous or parallelodromous. The phellogen in the stem is surficial in origin, that in the root is initiated 3 or 4 layers deep in the cortex. There are brachysclereids in the stem cortex, a sheath of fibres in the pericyclic position, and groups of fibres in the secondary phloem (see also van Tieghem 1885). The heartwood is dark reddish brown and heavy. Vessel elements are solitary, of medium length, and their perforations are simple/transverse; uniseriate rays are of upright cells, and multiseriates (2–4 cells wide) consist of procumbent cells with uniseriate extensions of upright cells; axial parenchyma is scanty paratracheal, and fibres are mostly thick-walled. Xylem parenchyma forms an adaxial cap on the vessels. Nodes are trilacunar in Bonnetia, unilacunar in Archytaea and Ploiarium. The separate traces are visible in leaf scars although, in taxa such as Bonnetia ahogadai, traces are more or less confluent in the outer part of the cortex. Ploiarium has an arcuate midrib bundle, that of other taxa is more complex, the tissue on the adaxial side in particular being irregularly arranged. Vascular bundles are embedded, and the marginal setae of Archytaea and Ploiarium, but not those of Bonnetia, are associated with vascular tissue. Stomata are anomocytic and an adaxial hypodermis is sometimes present. The leaf anatomy of Bonnetia is remarkable: the epidermis is often mucilaginous and its cells bulge and intrude between the mesophyll cells; foliar sclereids are widespread in the mesophyll; and the leaf midrib and all veins including the terminal veinlets are surrounded by an endodermis of thin-walled cells provided with Casparian strips (Maguire 1972; Dickison and Weitzman 1996; Weitzman and Stevens 1997).
Bonnetiaceae
Inflorescence and Flowers. Inflorescences are lateral, and several species appear to have axillary flowers. However, these are probably reduced inflorescences, and the “pedicels” bear 2–several bracts along their length, sometimes very close to the calyx. The sepals of Bonnetia, and perhaps also Ploiarium, are terminated by setae very like those found on the leaf margins. The petals are predominantly white or pink. Whether or not the androecium of Bonnetia is fasciculate needs study; fascicles have been reported (e.g. Steyermark 1984) but their existence – at least, as evident in later bud or flower – has been questioned (Kobuski 1948; PFS, pers. obs.). It is not known if the fasciclodes of Ploiarium secrete nectar; otherwise, there are no reports of nectar from the family (Dickison and Weitzman 1998). Pollen Morphology. Pollen is 28 to almost 60 µm long, oblate-spheroidal, tricolporate with wide colpi and circular ora. Sometimes, as in B. lancifolia, the colpi are fused at the poles, leaving a triangular polar space. There are costal colpi in Archytaea and Ploiarium, and all taxa have costal pori. The nexine, 0.5–4 µm thick, is thicker than the sexine, which is finely reticulate (Erdtman 1952; Maguire 1972; Steyermark 1984; Salgado-Laboriau and Villar de Seoane 1992). Seed. The seeds are quite small, and Corner (1976) suggested that the seed coat of Ploiarium is probably endotestal, although its development has not been studied. Exotestal cells are thin-walled and polygonal, endotestal cells are usually isodiametric, low, and with sinuous anticlinal walls, lignification is extensive and there are numerous narrow plasmodesmata. Ploiarium alternifolium has rather elongated endotestal cells, and the anticlinal walls of those of Archytaea are almost straight. There is a thin, persistent layer of endoperm surrounding the straight embryo. Although the cotyledons are generally small, those of Bonnetia range from 1/2–1/6 the length of the embryo. Germination is epigeal (Ploiarium). Phytochemistry. Bonnetiaceae are rich in xanthones with various substitution patterns, and bixanthones and anthraquinone xanthones have been reported from Ploiarium (Kubitzki et al. 1978; Bennett et al. 1990). Xanthones are also richly diversified in Clusiaceae and Hypericaceae (Bennett and Lee 1989).
37
Family Circumscription and Affinities. When the exudate-producing genus Neotatea and the anther gland-bearing genera around Kielmeyera and Caraipa are removed from Bonnetiaceae, as suggested by Weitzman and Stevens (1997), the family becomes very homogeneous. Although in the past members of the family have been included in the “intermediate” zone between Theaceae and Clusiaceae/Hypericaceae, the former are now in Ericales, and possession of xanthones, floral morphology, testa anatomy, etc., all link Bonnetiaceae with Clusiaceae/Hypericaceae. The combination of characters of wood anatomical characters presented above sets Bonnetiaceae apart from Theaceae, with which Baretta-Kuipers (1976) compared them, and also Guttiferae and Hypericaceae. Gene sequence analyses by Savolainen, Fay et al. (2000) and Gustafsson et al. (2002) confirm the close relationship of Bonnetiaceae with Clusiaceae/Hypericaceae. The inclusion of Ploiarium in Malvales (Savolainen, Fay et al. 2000) was probably due to a mistaken identification, since i.a. the distinctive seed coat anatomy of Archytaea is quite unlike that of Malvales. Elatinaceae have also often been considered as possibly related to Bonnetiaceae, agreeing in testa anatomy and a number of other features, but molecular data place them sister to Malpighiaceae (Davis and Chase 2004); whether or not that family is close to Bonnetiaceae, etc., is unclear. Distribution and Habitats. The two closely related, small genera Archytaea and Ploiarium are disjunct between Southeast Asia/Malesia and northern South America, whereas Bonnetia is restricted to continental South America, with one species on Cuba. Archytaea prefers open habitats, often by creeks, always on nutrient-poor soil, ranging from lowland to mid-altitudes. Bonnetia is most speciose in the Guayana Highland and its surroundings, where 27 species are found, all but one (B. paniculata) of which are endemic to this region. Most of them have only a limited altitudinal range, with the majority preferring the mesothermic/submicrothermic belt (1,200–2,700 m; Huber 1988), but Bonnetia crassa spans a belt of 2,000 m. With increasing altitude, the bonnetias tend to be of lower stature. Bonnetia ahogadoi is a low shrublet growing at localized sites on peat in rock depressions of the Chimatá Massif in Venezuela
38
A.L. Weitzman, K. Kubitzki, and P.F. Stevens
Fig. 10. Bonnetiaceae. Bonnetia ahogadoi. A Habit. B Leaf. C Flower. D Androecium and gynoecium. E Anther. F Ovary, transversal section. G Capsule at beginning of dehiscence.
H Two valves of dehiscent capsule with adherent seeds and persistent columella. I Seeds, various positions. (Drawing by B. Manara; Steyermark 1984)
at an altitude of about 2,100 m (Huber 1992). Ploiarium grows in the lowland, often close to the sea, and on swampy peaty soil (Corner 1978) or on nutrient-poor white sand in the heath forests of Borneo.
Genera of Bonnetiaceae
Uses. The wood is durable and in Asia/Malesia locally used for constructions, but is not a commercial timber.
Key to the Genera 1. Androecium not fasciculate; ovary 3(4)-locular 3. Bonnetia – Androecium 5-fasciculate; ovary 5-locular 2 2. Flowers in 3–many-flowered inflorescences; sepals and stamens caducous; style simple 2. Archytaea – Flowers solitary; sepals and stamens persistent; stylodia 5, free to base 1. Ploiarium
1. Ploiarium Korthals Ploiarium Korthals, Verh. Nat. Gesch. Bot., ed. Temminck: 135 (1840); Kobuski, J. Arnold Arb. 31:196–207 (1950), rev.
Trees, sometimes vast, or shrubs. Flowers solitary; pedicels ancipitous, increasing in diameter towards apex; sepals caducous; nectary glands 5, alternating with petals; stamens numerous, caducous, in 5 antesepalous fascicles; ovary 5-locular; stylodia 5, free to base, persistent. Capsule dehiscing from the base; seeds linear; endosperm fleshy. Three species, from Cambodia through Malay Peninsula to Sumatra, Borneo and Halmahera. 2. Archytaea Mart. Archytaea Mart. in Mart. & Zucc., Nov. Gen. Sp. Pl. 1:116 (1826); Weitzman & Stevens, BioLlania Esp. 6:556–557 (1997); Weitzman, Fl. Venez. Guayana 9:310–313 (2005).
Bonnetiaceae
Small trees or shrubs. Inflorescences axillary, 3– many-flowered; peduncles ancipitous, increasing in diameter towards apex; pedicels midway with prophylls; sepals persistent; nectary glands 5, alternate with petals; stamens numerous, persistent, in 5 antesepalous fascicles; ovary 5-locular; style simple, persistent. Seeds numerous, linear, imbricate, exalbuminous. Two species, in the Guayana sandstone region and adjacent lowlands of northern South America. 3. Bonnetia Mart.
Fig. 10
Bonnetia Mart. in Mart. & Zucc., Nov. Gen. Sp. Pl. 1:114 (1826), nom. cons.; Kobuski, J. Arnold Arb. 29:393–413 (1948), rev.; Weitzman, Fl. Venez. Guayana 9:313–324 (2005). Neblinaria Maguire (1972). Neogleasonia Maguire (1972) except N. duidae (Kobuski & Steyerm.) Maguire Acopanea Steyerm. (1984).
Trees or shrubs. Flowers solitary or up to three on axillary peduncles or occasionally arranged in loose panicles with ancipitous or terete peduncles; sepals persistent; stamens very numerous, persistent, the filaments adnate to the base of the ovary and otherwise free; anthers dehiscing longitudinally or by two pores at the base; ovary 3(4)-celled; stylodia 3, or style simple and then sometimes apically branched. Seeds linear, elongated above and below into a small membranous wing. About 29 species, mainly in the Guayana highland and adjacent regions, with B. paniculata Spr. ex Benth. extending along the Andes to Peru, B. stricta (Nees) Nees & Mart. along the Atlantic coast southwards to Rio de Janeiro, and B. cubensis (Britton) Howard in Cuba.
Selected Bibliography Baretta-Kuipers, T. 1976. Comparative wood anatomy of Bonnetiaceae, Theaceae and Guttiferae. In: Baas, P., Bolton, A.M., Catling, D.M. (eds) Wood structure in biological and technological research. Leiden Botanical Series 3, pp. 76–101.
39
Bennett, G.J., Lee, H.-H. 1989. Xanthones from Guttiferae. Phytochemistry 28:967–998. Bennett, G.J., Lee, H.-H., Lowrey, T.K. 1990. Novel metabolites from Ploiarium alternifolium: a bixanthone and two anthraquinolyxanthones. Tetrahedron Lett. 31:751–754. Corner, E.J.H. 1976. See general references. Corner, E.J.H. 1978. The freshwater swamp-forest of South Johore and Singapore. Gard. Bull. suppl. 1. Singapore: Government Printers. Davis, C.C., Chase, M.W. 2004. Elatinaceae are sister to Malpighiaceae, and Peridiscaceae are members of Saxifragales. Amer. J. Bot. 91:262–273. Dickison, W.C., Weitzman, A.L. 1996. Comparative anatomy of the young stem, node and leaf of Bonnetiaceae, including observations on a foliar endodermis. Amer. J. Bot. 83:405–418. Dickison, W.C., Weitzman, A.L. 1998. Floral morphology and anatomy of Bonnetiaceae. J. Torrey Bot. Soc. 125:268–286. Erdtman, G. 1952. See general references. Gustafsson, M.H.G., Bittrich, V., Stevens, P.F. 2002. Phylogeny of Clusiaceae based on rbcL sequences. Intl J. Pl. Sci. 163:1045–1054. Huber, O. 1988. Guayana highlands versus Guayana lowlands, a reappraisal. Taxon 37:595–614. Huber, O. 1992. La vegetación. In: Huber, O. (ed.) El macizo de Chimatá. Caracas: Todtmann, pp. 161–177. Kobuski, C.E. 1948. Studies in the Theaceae, XVII. A review of the genus Bonnetia. J. Arnold Arb. 29:393–413. Kubitzki, K., Mesquita, A.A.L., Gottlieb, O.R. 1978. Chemosystematic implications of xanthones in Bonnetia and Archytaea. Biochem. Syst. Ecol. 6:185–187. Maguire, B. 1972. Bonnetiaceae. In: The Botany of the Guyana Highland. Part IX. Mem. New York Bot. Gard. 23:131–165. Prakash, N., Lau, Y.Y. 1976. Morphology of Ploiarium alternifolium and the taxonomic position of Ploiarium. Bot. Notiser 129:279–285. Salgado-Laboriau, M.L., Villar de Seoane, L. 1992. Contribución a la flora polínica de los tepuyes. In: Huber, O. (ed.) El macizo de Chimatá. Caracas: Todtmann, pp. 219–236. Savolainen, V., Fay, M.F. et al. 2000. See general references. Steyermark, J.A., 1984. Theaceae (Bonnetiaceae), pp. 323– 330. In: Flora of the Venezuelan Guayana, I. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 71:297–340. van Tieghem, Ph. 1885. Second mémoire sur les canaux sécréteurs des plantes. Ann. Sci. Nat. VII, Bot. 1:5–96; see particularly Ternstroemiacées, pp. 43–46. Weitzman, A.L., Stevens, P.F. 1997. Notes on the circumscription of Bonnetiaceae and Clusiaceae, with taxa and new combinations. BioLlania Edic. Esp. 6:661– 564.
Buxaceae Buxaceae Dumort., Comment. Bot.: 54 (1822), nom. cons.
E. Köhler
Evergreen shrubs or trees, rarely subshrubs or rhizomatous perennial herbs, glabrous, sometimes with uni- or multicellular hairs, monoecious, rarely dioecious. Leaves alternate or decussate, petiolate, rarely sessile, entire, rarely dentate, pinnately veined, less often tripliveined, estipulate. Flowers in axillary or terminal botryoids or spikes, the male above the female ones, or one female above the male, subtended by decurrent bracts, the female with prophylls. Flowers actinomorphic, hypogynous; male: tepals 4, decussate, rarely wanting; stamens free, 4, 6 or 8, antetepalous, or rarely up to 45 in a more complex arrangement, if 6, then two pairs opposite the inner tepals, often inserted around a pistillode; anthers dorsifixed, dithecal, tetrasporangiate, longitudinally dehiscent, borne on long filaments, rarely sessile; pistillode present or wanting; female: often larger than the male, fewer or solitary; tepals 4–6; ovary syncarpous with free stylodia, (2)3(4)-carpellate, sometimes with false septa; placentation axile; stylodia subulate, divergent, rarely connate at the base, stigmatic area decurrent along the ventral fold; ovules usually 2 per locule, anatropous. Fruit a dry capsule with persistent stylodia, loculicidally dehiscent into 2-horned valves, or indehiscent, subdrupaceous or berry-like. Seeds black or dark, frequently carunculate; endosperm copious, fleshy, oily; embryo straight, cotyledons flat. A family comprising 5 genera with c. 100 species, distributed in the Northern Hemisphere of the Old and New World, extending to Andean South America and its Caribbean coast, to South Africa and Madagascar, and to peninsular Malaysia. Vegetative Morphology. Most Buxaceae are evergreen shrubs or trees up to 15 m tall. Only Pachysandra comprises erect or prostrate subshrubs and perennial herbs. Its sympodial rhizomes have adventitious roots and develop simple or sympodially branched stems with alternate, apically clustered leaves. The leaves are alternate in
Styloceras, Sarcococca and Pachysandra, decussate in Buxus and Notobuxus, where decurrent leaf bases form lateral internodal folds (Fig. 12A). In some Cuban Buxus, distichous leaves are interspersed with decussate pairs of very small ones inserted on short shoots. The leaves are usually entire but toothed in Pachysandra. Brochidodromous venation, occurring in Sarcococca, Notobuxus and Buxus, and variously modified in the latter, is regarded as basic. Styloceras and Asian Buxus species possess eucamptodromous venation. Cladodromous patterns are found in South African and Malagasy Buxus; Pachysandra has craspedodromous venation. Whereas the brochidodromous type prevails in the tropics, the derived patterns occur in subtropical and temperate regions of both hemispheres (Köhler 1993). Species of Buxus possess a grey, deeply fissured bark. Vegetative Anatomy. Old World Buxus and Notobuxus species have a cortical vascular bundle in each angle of the branchlets, accompanied by fibre strands in the Eurasian taxa. Both are wanting in New World Buxus and the remaining genera (van Tieghem 1897; Mathou 1940). Elongated fibres and large stone cells are frequent in the primary cortex. Chains of small, irregularly thickened sclereids with oxalate crystals, surrounding a larger fibre (‘Kristallkammerfasern’), occur in Pachysandra, Sarcococca and Styloceras. Secretory cells, often arranged in longitudinal rows, are frequent in Buxus, Pachysandra and Sarcococca, less prominent in Styloceras (Metcalfe and Chalk 1950). Vessels are mostly solitary and of small diameter, rather wide in Styloceras. They are of medium length in Buxus and Notobuxus but exceptionally long in Sarcococca and Styloceras, reflecting a continuous occupation of mesic sites (Carlquist 1982). They have scalariform perforations with a great range of numbers of bars (Köhler, unpubl. data). The fibrous elements are tracheids with bordered
Buxaceae
pits similar to vessels. The axial parenchyma is diffuse apotracheal throughout the family. Uniseriate rays are as frequent as multiseriate ones. The heterogeneous rays of Styloceras, which are up to four cells wide, are most primitive. Styloceras is an unspecialized, highly mesic type, followed by Sarcococca, whereas Notobuxus and especially Buxus are more specialized in adaptation to xeric conditions. The sieve element plastids represent a specific subtype, PVIc, with a globose protein crystal (Behnke 1982). Leaf epidermis cells are thin to strongly cutinized in Buxus, and covered with epicuticular waxes. Their anticlinal walls are sometimes extremely thickened, confining lumina to a central canal or basal rests in Cuban Buxus (Köhler and Schirarend 1989). The indumentum comprises thick-walled hairs of one to several cells. Stomata are usually abaxial and are laterocytic, occasionally cyclocytic (Baranova 1980); they have prominent outer ledges which sometimes bear a peristomal rim. A hypodermis is present only in Styloceras. The mesophyll contains prominent secretory cells, which sometimes form a continuous hypodermal layer and may be interspersed with brachy- , osteoor astrosclereids. Druses and solitary oxalate crystals are frequent; cells with coarse crystal sand are rarer. The vascular bundles are accompanied by arc-shaped or ring-like sclerenchymatous sheaths. The petiole is supplied by a median and two lateral bundles, the latter being replaced by fibre strands in Eurasian Buxus. The nodes are unilocular with one trace. Inflorescence Structure. Inflorescences are axillary or terminal, rarely borne at the base of the stem (Pachysandra procumbens), and shortly pedunculate or sessile. In Buxus, Notobuxus and Styloceras kunthianum, they are usually botryoids with lateral male flowers and a terminal female flower. Pachysandra and some Sarcococca have open spikes with lateral male flowers in the upper part of the inflorescence and female flowers below. In the dioecious species of Styloceras, male flowers form long spikes sometimes terminated by a peloric flower; female flowers are solitary or in thyrses (von Balthazar and Endress 2002b). Flower Structure. The bracts preceding the reproductive organs of male flowers are always arranged in a decussate pattern whereas the uppermost four, bract-like phyllomes are tepal-like and inconspicuous or whitish (Sarcococca) and creamy
41
petaloid (Buxus). There are typically four stamens, in Notobuxus six or up to ten; in Styloceras, they are numerous. Filaments are long-exserted, stout, sometimes clavate. Anthers are introrse, dorsifixed with a protruding, ± coloured connective tip. The stamens are frequently inserted around a pistillode, which is quadrangular to 4-lobed, sometimes truncate in Buxus and Pachysandra or urceolate in Sarcococca, but very reduced in Notobuxus and absent in Styloceras. It possesses a nectariferous structure (Daumann 1974; Vogel 1998). In the female flowers the carpels are usually preceded by a pair of prophylls and several spirally arranged bracts which are only weakly differentiated towards tepals (von Balthazar and Endress 2002b). The locules of the ovary contain two collateral ovules and are separated by spurious septa in Pachysandra and Styloceras. The stylodia are rather long, slender and recurved in Styloceras, erectsubulate in Pachysandra, more stout in Sarcococca, and short-divergent in Notobuxus and Buxus. Protuberances between the bases of the stylodia function as nectaries and are considered to be of androecial derivation (Daumann 1974). Embryology. The anther wall has a 1-layered fibrous endothecium. The tapetum is secretory and its cells become binucleate. Pollen meiosis is simultaneous, resulting in tetrahedral or isobilateral tetrads. Pollen is 2-celled when shed (Davis 1966). The ovules are anatropous, pendulous, with the micropyle towards the axis in Buxus and Notobuxus or averted in Sarcococca. They are bitegmic, crassinucellate with a pronounced nucellar cap; the micropyle is made up by the inner integument (Wunderlich 1967; Corner 1976). Protuberances of the placenta form an obturator in Pachysandra. A proliferation of the outer integument, forming a hood over the nucellus, develops a prominent caruncle in the latter (Channel and Wood 1987). The megaspores are arranged in linear (Sarcococca, Pachysandra) or T-shaped tetrads (Buxus and Notobuxus), the chalazal one developing into a Polygonum type embryo sac. The synergids have a filiform apparatus. The antipodes persist into postfertilization stages and a small degree of secondary multiplication has been reported. Endosperm formation is cellular, but nuclear in Sarcococca (Wiger 1935). Embryogeny follows the Onagrad type. Occasionally, parthenocarpy has been reported for Buxus, and some Sarcococca species seem to be obligate apomicts (Naumova 1980). Nucellar polyembryogeny is recorded for S. humilis.
42
E. Köhler
Pollen Morphology. Pollen grains are ± spheroidal and vary in the size range 20–50 µm. Apertures range from 3-colporate in Notobuxus to 3–7-colporate, 5–12-pantocolporate and 12–40pantoporate in Buxus (Fig. 11A–C), whereas only pantoporate grains occur in Sarcococca, Pachysandra and Styloceras (Köhler 1981; Köhler and Brückner 1982). The colpi of Buxus pollen contain 3–6 circular ora, the number of ora decreasing in pantocolporate forms (Fig. 11B), eventually giving
rise to pantoporate grains (Fig. 11C). The pores are roundish with sculptured membranes (Brückner 1993), which also occur in Styloceras. The exine sculpture, providing taxonomically significant characters in Buxus and Notobuxus, comprises comparatively free, interlaced ridges and a coarse or fine reticulum, which sometimes bears small spinulae. Others have supratectal pilate-verrucate elements. The exine of Styloceras is finely reticulate with pointed spinulae and, in Sarcococca and
Fig. 11. Buxaceae, pollen grains. A Buxus arborea, tricolpo4-orate grain showing one colpus, ×3,500. B Buxus benguellensis, pantocolpo-2-orate grain, ×2,700. C Buxus
cochinchinensis, pantoporate grain, ×2,600. D Sarcococca wallichii, pantoporate grain with crotonoid exine pattern, ×1,800. (Orig. Köhler)
Buxaceae
Pachysandra, a ‘crotonoid’ pattern is observed with reticulately arranged triangular and linear units based on a ledge, which is supported by bacula (Fig. 11D). Karyology. Chromosome numbers of the family are mainly multiples of x = 7 (Hans 1973). With the exception of a tetraploid record for Buxus sinica (Huang et al. 1986), the Eurasian and New World species of Buxus share 2n = 28 (Köhler, unpubl. data). For Sarcococca, diploids with 2n = 28 (less frequently, tetraploids) are recorded. An aberrant number of n = 12 is given by Singh et al. (1982). In Pachysandra, a wider range with n = 12, 13, 24, 27 is found (Raven 1975; Kurosawa 1981). Notobuxus diverges with 2n = 20. Pollination and Reproductive System. (See also the summary by von Balthazar and Endress 2002a). In male flowers of Buxus, Sarcococca and Pachysandra and, perhaps, also of Notobuxus, rudiments of a pistil are present but the flowers are functionally unisexual. In female flowers, no rudiments of stamens are found. The mixed inflorescences of Buxus, Sarcococca and Pachysandra are protogynous. Self-fertility is reported for Pachysandra procumbens by Robbins (1962). Since the tepals are commonly inconspicuous, pollinator attraction is by other floral parts. Sarcococca and Pachysandra have showy tepals with white filaments and red or yellow anthers; the filaments emit a strong, sweet scent. In the centre of the male flowers of Sarcococca and Pachysandra, a nectary is present but, in their female flowers, attractants are lacking. Pollination depends on the strict foraging behaviour of insect visitors, which always move from the base to the apex of the inflorescence and thereby inadvertently touch the female flowers (Vogel 1998). The flowers in many Buxus attract bees and flies by a faint scent, and nectar is produced by the pistillode in male flowers or on nectariferous structures between the carpels in the female flowers (Fig. 12C). In African Buxus and the closely related Notobuxus, no nectariferous pistillodes nor pistils are found, and wind pollination was suggested for these species (Vogel 1998), which would be compatible with their increased number of stamens, although the pollen is well-sculptured and does not suggest wind pollination (Köhler and Brückner 1982). Fruit and Seed. The fruit of Buxus and Notobuxus is a dry, loculicidal capsule with leathery exocarp and persistent stylodia, dehiscing basipetally
43
into three spreading, 2-horned valves. The detached cartilaginous endocarp partly encloses both seeds and ejects them forcibly. In Pachysandra, transitions from indehiscent capsules to subdrupaceous white and pulpy fruits occur. In Sarcococca and Styloceras, the fruit is sub- to fully drupaceous, with a pulpy mesocarp and a thin crustaceous endocarp in the former, and a cartilaginous endocarp divided in 4–6 pyrenes in the latter. The seeds are oblong, trigonal, with a smooth, shining black, brown or blue coat. The raphe is scarcely discernible, showing a slight postchalazal ramification of bundles in Buxus. There is a caruncle, rather prominent in Pachysandra, and reduced to two small, white lobes on either side of the micropyle in Buxus. Seeds of Sarcococca and Styloceras are ecarunculate. The family has an exomesotestal seed coat, with a multiplicative testa in Sarcococca and Pachysandra but not in Buxus. These genera share a palisade of thick-walled, prismatic cells in the outer epidermis, followed by crushed parenchymatous cells (Melikian 1968). In Buxus, the inner epidermis is shortly palisadic and lignified at the micropyle, forming a false endostome (Corner 1976). The embryo is slightly curved with a long radicle in Buxus, but straight with a short radicle in Sarcococca. The cotyledons are thin and flat and the endosperm is fleshy and oily. Dispersal. The ejection mechanism of Buxus and Notobuxus may suffice for localized seed dispersal; abiotic agents such as rain or flowing water may account for dispersal over larger distances. The caruncle is related to ant dispersal, which has been observed in B. sempervirens and is likely to act also in Pachysandra procumbens, where the carunculate seeds are released on the ground. The drupaceous fruits of Sarcococca and Pachysandra terminalis are indicative of endozoochory, probably by birds. This seems to be true also for Styloceras, where the tardily dehiscing fruit exposes a gelatinous pulp surrounding the blue seeds (Gentry and Foster 1981). Phytochemistry. Buxus, Sarcococca and Pachysandra contain a series of highly elaborated steroidal alkaloids of the aminopregnan type, which are derived from triterpenoids (Hegnauer 1964, 1989) and are shared with Didymelaceae. More than 150 alkaloids, mainly pregnan and irehdiamine derivatives, have been isolated from Buxus, Sarcococca and Pachysandra, whereas those of Styloceras are unknown. Condensed tannins
44
E. Köhler
have been found in some Buxus but are not prominent. Seventeen Cuban Buxus species have been recognized as nickel-hyperaccumulators, reaching nickel contents of 1,000 to 25,000 µg g−1 dry weight (Reeves et al. 1996), which might be of taxonomic interest. Relationships Within the Family. Two major clades can be recognized within the family (von Balthazar and Endress 2000, 2002a), one comprising Pachysandra, Sarcococcus and Styloceras, and another of Buxus with Notobuxus. Pachysandra and Sarcococcus are strongly supported as monophyletic groups in a sister relationship to Styloceras. American and Eurasian Buxus each represent a strongly supported clade, with Notobuxus embedded among the African members of Buxus. von Balthazar and Endress (2002a) suggest either to sink Notobuxus in Buxus, or to keep Notobuxus at generic level and integrate all African Buxus in this genus. Shared characters among Sarcococcus, Pachysandra and Styloceras include the occurrence of two (rarely three) carpels, the lack of interstylar nectaries, a micropyle formed by both integuments, attractive stamens in male flowers, and fleshy fruits. In addition, Styloceras and Pachysandra share a secondary partition of the ovary. Notobuxus shares with Buxus a similar inflorescence and perianth structure, 3-carpellate female flowers, interstylodial nectaries, micropyles formed by the inner integument, rudimentary arils, and capsular fruits; in male flowers, stamens are sessile and the pistillode is lacking in some species (von Balthazar and Endress 2002a). Affinities. Until very recently, the phylogenetic position of Buxaceae has remained problematic (see Webster 1987 and Jarvis 1989 for reviews). The family has frequently been associated with Euphorbiaceae and also Celastrales, but Hamamelidales and Pittosporales have also been considered. Recent morphological, molecular and combined data analyses (Nandi et al. 1998; Soltis et al. 2000, 2003; The Angiosperm Phylogeny Group, APG II 2003) place Buxaceae as sister to Didymelaceae (Buxales) together with Ranunculales, Sabiaceae, Proteales and Trochodendraceae in a grade at the base of the eudicots. Palaeobotany. Early fossil records (Spanomera) from the Albian/Cenomanian of the Potomac
Group are closely related to Buxaceae (Drinnan et al. 1991). Among fossil pollen attributable to Buxaceae, the ‘crotonoid’ Pachysandra-Sarcococca type appeared initially in the Upper Cretaceous of central Europe and, in the Palaeogene, subsequently extended westwards and then eastwards along the north-Tethyan warm-temperate vegetation belt; by the Miocene, it had arrived in East Asia (Krutzsch 1989). Macrofossils of Pachysandra are known from the Upper Eocene and of Sarcococca from the Upper Oligocene/Miocene of central Europe (Mai and Walther 1985). Colporate Buxus pollen is known from the Lower Eocene (Kedves 1962), followed by a succession of types (Bessedik 1983) which document the coherence with pantoporate Buxus pollen of the Lower Miocene (Krutzsch 1966). Fruits and leaf remains of Buxus with Eurasian-type venation have been found in the Miocene of Bohemia (Kvacek et al. 1982) and the Oligocene of East Asia (Uemura 1979). Styloceras pollen is recorded from the Eocene of Argentina and the Pliocene of Colombia (van der Hammen 1974). Distribution and Habitats. The genus Buxus has a disjunct intercontinental distribution with a centre of diversity in tropical to temperate East Asia and another in the Caribbean, whereas only few species, including the most primitive taxa, occur in Africa from Ethiopia to the eastern Cape in South Africa and in Madagascar. The genus has a wide ecological range and grows in dry scrub forests, on limestone cliffs, in the understorey of montane rainforests, occasionally in cloud forests, sometimes above 3,000 m; it frequently grows on ultramafic soils. Notobuxus has a scattered distribution in coastal forests between Kenya and the eastern Cape, and in equatorial forests from Sierra Leone to Nigeria. Sarcococca is widely distributed in tropical and subtropical Asia from Afghanistan to China, Indonesia and the Philippines, growing in the understorey of montane forests, often at higher altitudes. A single New World species occurs in Guatemala. Three species of Pachysandra are native to China, Japan and Taiwan, and one to south-eastern North America, growing in rich mesophytic forests in mountain regions. Species of Styloceras are confined to the Andes of South America from Venezuela to Bolivia, growing in forests between 2,500 and 3,800 m. A recently discovered species from Amazonian Peru suggests that the genus may be an old lowland forest element (Gentry and Foster 1981).
Buxaceae
45
3. Male flowers with 4 stamens opposite the tepals, longexserted; pistillode present 1. Buxus – Male flowers with 6(–10) stamens, two pairs opposite the inner tepals; anthers sessile; pistillode as a flat disk, or absent 2. Notobuxus 4. Woody shrubs or small trees with entire leaves; fruit ± drupaceous 3. Sarcococca – Perennial herbs with procumbent stems, leaves ± coarsely toothed; flowers borne at the base of the stem or terminal; fruit an indehiscent capsule or subdrupaceous 4. Pachysandra
Genera of Buxaceae 1. Buxus L.
Fig. 12
Buxus L., Sp. Pl. 2:983 (1753); Hatusima, J. Dept. Agric. Kyusyu Imp. Univ. 6:261–342 (1942), Asiatic spp.; Friis, Kew Bull. 44:293–299 (1988), African spp.; Schatz & Lowry II, Adansonia III, 24:179–196 (2002), Malagasy spp.
Fig. 12. Buxaceae. Buxus moctezumae. A Portion of branch with decurrent leaf bases. B Inflorescence with a terminal female flower and lateral male flowers. C Nectaries of female flower, surrounded by stylodia. D Dehisced fruit. (Köhler et al. 1993)
Economic Importance. The family is economically important for its horticultural value. The genus Buxus has yielded more than 150 registered cultivars, mainly of B. sempervirens and B. microphylla (Batdorf 1995), which are used for edging, as hedges suitable for pruning and topiary work. The hard, closely grained wood is employed for turning, engraving and manufacturing instruments. Pachysandra terminalis is widely grown as ornamental ground cover. Styloceras provides firstclass timber for joinery.
Key to the Genera 1. Tepals absent in male flowers, stamens numerous; rudiment of ovary wanting; ovary 2(3)-carpellate 5. Styloceras – Tepals present; stamens usually 4, rarely 6–10 2 2. Leaves decussate; female flowers terminal in racemes or clusters; fruit a 3-valved capsule 3 – Leaves alternate; female flowers at base of racemes or spikes; fruit ± drupaceous 4
Shrubs or trees with tetragonal branchlets, leaves decussate. Inflorescences lax to glomerate botryoids of male flowers with a terminal female. Male flowers 4-merous, tepals decussate, stamens antetepalous, inserted around a pistillode. Female flowers with 4–6 tepals, ovary 3-carpellate, with divergent stylodia, stigmas 2-lobed, decurrent along the ventral fold. Fruit a 3-horned capsule, loculicidally dehiscing into 2-horned valves, ejecting trigonal black seeds. 2n = 28, (56). About 90 species in Central America, West Indies, northern and southern Africa, Madagascar, East Asia. For the relationship between the African Buxus and Notobuxus, see below. 2. Notobuxus Oliv. Notobuxus Oliv. in Hook, Ic. Pl. 14:78, t. 1400 (1882); Friis, Kew Bull. 44:293–299 (1989); Phillips, J. S African Bot. 9:138– 140 (1943).
Shrubs or small trees; leaves decussate. Inflorescences subfasciculate botryoids with few male and a terminal female flower. Male flowers tepals 4, stamens 6(–10), two pairs opposite the inner tepals; anthers sessile, pistillode minute or wanting. Female flowers tepals 4–6, ovary 3-carpellate with short, recurved stylodia; stigmas decurring. Fruit a greenish-brown, red or black, loculicidal capsule with persistent stylodia. Seeds oblong-ovoid to trigonal, black, 2n = 40. Five species, equatorial West and Central Africa, east to South Africa. This genus is close to Buxus, of which it is treated as a subgenus by Friis, but it differs in the number of stamens, chromosome number and traits of the exine.
46
E. Köhler
3. Sarcococca Lindl. Sarcococca Lindl., Bot. Reg.: t. 1012 (1826); Sealy, Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 92:117–159 (1986), rev.
Small trees or shrubs; leaves alternate, ± triplinerved. Inflorescences androgynous botryoids or spikes, sometimes unisexual. Male flowers above, 4merous, with pale or white tepals, whitish stamens and an urceolate pistillode. Females bracteolate, 4– 6 tepals, ovary 3–2-carpellate, with stout recurved stylodia, stigma sulcate, ventrally decurrent. Fruit purplish red or black, indehiscent, subdrupaceous or with dry mesocarp, stylodia persistent. Seeds often solitary, hemispherical to subglobose, brownish black. 2n = 28, less frequent 2n = 56. Eleven species, Southeast Asia. The affiliation of S. conzattii (Standley) I.M. Johnst. from Guatemala is doubtful. 4. Pachysandra Mich. Pachysandra Mich., Fl. Bor. Amer. 2:177 (1803); Robbins, Sida 3:211–248 (1968), rev.
Procumbent rhizomatous subshrubs or perennial herbs, branches ascending, leaves alternate, coarsely dentate to nearly entire. Inflorescences axillary or terminal spikes, male flowers above, few females below, male 4-merous, with pale tepals, whitish stamens, attached around a rectangular to truncate pistillode; female subtended by prophylls, with 4–6 tepals, ovary 2–3-carpellate, with spurious septa, stylodia erect to recurved, stigma sulcate, decurrent. Fruit reddish brown to black, indehiscent 3-horned capsules or subdrupaceous, white and pulpy. Seeds trigonal, dark brown or black. 2n = 24, 26, 48, 54. Five species, Atlantic North America, China, Taiwan. 5. Styloceras Adr. Juss. Styloceras Adr. Juss., Euph. Tent. 53: t. 17 (1824).
Trees or shrubs, dioecious, rarely monoecious, leaves alternate. Male inflorescences short, pendent spikes, sometimes bisexual, tepals wanting, numerous subsessile stamens inserted in a triangular bract, pistillode absent. Female flowers solitary, tepals 3–5, bract-like, ovary 2–3-carpellate, divided by secondary septae, with long, basally distant stylodia, recurved at the tip, and long, decurrent stigmas. Fruit yellow, globose, drupaceous, ± fleshy, indehiscent or tardily dehiscent, stylodia persisting as subapical horns. Seeds oblong, dark blue. Five species, Andean South America.
Selected Bibliography APG II 2003. See general references. Balthazar, M. von, Endress, P.K. 2002a. Reproductive structures and systematics of Buxaceae. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 140:193–228. Balthazar, M. von, Endress, P.K. 2002b. Development of inflorescences and flowers in Buxaceae and the problem of perianth interpretation. Intl J. Pl. Sci. 163:847–876. Balthazar, M. von, Endress, P.K., Qiu, Y.-L. 2000. Phylogenetic relationships in Buxaceae based on nuclear internal transcribed spacers and plastid ndhF sequences. Intl J. Pl. Sci. 161:785–792. Baranova, M.A. 1980. Comparative stomatographic studies in the family Buxaceae and Simmondsiaceae (in Russian). In: Zhilin, S.G. (ed.) Systematics and evolution of higher plants. Leningrad: Nauka, pp. 68–75. Batdorf, L.R. 1995. Boxwood handbook. Boyce: American Boxwood Society. Behnke, H.-D. 1982. Sieve-element plastids, exine sculpturing and the systematic affinities of the Buxaceae. Pl. Syst. Evol. 139:257–266. Bessedik, M. 1983. Le genre Buxus L. (Nagyipollis Kedves 1962) au Tertiaire en Europe occidentale: évolution et implications paléogéographiques. Pollen Spores 25:461–486. Brückner, P. 1993. Pollen morphology and taxonomy of Eurasiatic species of the genus Buxus (Buxaceae). Grana 32:65–78. Carlquist, S. 1982. Wood anatomy of Buxaceae: correlations with ecology and phylogeny. Flora 172:463–491. Channell, R.B., Wood, C.E. 1987. The Buxaceae in the southeastern United States. J. Arnold Arb. 68:241–257. Corner, E.J.H. 1976. See general references. Daumann, E. 1974. Zur Frage nach dem Vorkommen eines Septalnektariums bei Dikotyledonen. Zugleich ein Beitrag zur Blütenmorphologie und Bestäubungsökologie von Buxus L. und Cneorum L. Preslia 46:97–109. Davis, G.L. 1966. See general references. Drinnan, A.N., Crane, P.R., Friis, E.M., Raunsgaard Pedersen, K. 1991. Angiosperm flowers and tricolpate pollen of Buxaceous affinity from the Potomac group (MidCretaceous) of Eastern North America. Amer. J. Bot. 78:153–176. Gentry, A.H., Foster, R. 1981. A new Peruvian Styloceras (Buxaceae): discovery of a phytogeographical missing link. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 68:122–124. Gibbs, R.D. 1974. Chemotaxonomy of flowering plants, 2. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press. Hans, A.S. 1973. Chromosomal conspectus of the Euphorbiaceae. Taxon 22:591–636. Hardman, R. 1987. Recent developments in our knowledge of steroids. Pl. Medica 53:233–238. Hegnauer, R. 1964, 1989. See general references. Huang, S.F., Chen, S.J., Shi, X.H. 1986. Plant chromosome count (2). Subtrop. For. Sci. Tech. 3:41–47. Jarvis, Ch.E. 1989. A review of the family Buxaceae Dumortier. In: Crane, P.R., Blackmore, S. (eds) Evolution, systematics, and fossil history of the Hamamelidae, 1. Oxford: Clarendon Press, pp. 273–278. Kedves, M. 1962. Nagyipollis, a new pollen fgen. from the Hungarian Lower Eocene. Szeged: Acta Biol. 8:83–84.
Buxaceae Köhler, E. 1981. Pollen morphology of the West IndianCentral American species of the genus Buxus L. (Buxaceae) with reference to taxonomy. Pollen Spores 23:37–91. Köhler, E. 1993. Blattnervatur-Muster der Buxaceae Dumortier und Simmondsiaceae van Tieghem. Feddes Repert. 104:145–167. Köhler, E., Brückner, P. 1982. Die Pollenmorphologie der afrikanischen Buxus- und Notobuxus-Arten (Buxaceae) und ihre systematische Bedeutung. Grana 21:71– 82. Köhler, E., Brückner, P. 1990. Considerations on the evolution and chorogenesis of the genus Buxus (Buxaceae). Mem. New York Bot. Gard. 55:153–168. Köhler, E., Schirarend, C. 1989. Zur Blattanatomie der neotropischen Buxus-Arten und ihre Bedeutung für die Systematik. Flora 183:1–38. Köhler, E., Fernández, R., Zamudio, S. 1993. Buxus moctezmae Köhler, Fernández et Zamudio (Buxaceae) una especie nova de Estado de Querétaro, México. Feddes Repert. 104:295–305. Krutzsch, W. 1966. Zur Kenntnis der präquartären periporaten Pollenformen. Geologie 15:16–71. Krutzsch, W. 1989. Palaeogeography and historical phytogeography (palaeochorology) in the Neophyticum. Pl. Syst. Evol. 162:5–61. Kurosawa, S. 1981. Notes on chromosome numbers of Spermatophytes. J. Jap. Bot. 56:245–251. Kvacek, Z., Buzek, C., Holý, F. 1982. Review of Buxusfossils and a new large-leaved species from the Miocene of Central Europe. Rev. Palaeobot. Palynol. 37:361–394. Mai, D.H., Walther, H. 1985. Die obereozänen Floren des Weißelster-Beckens und seiner Randgebiete. Abh. Staatl. Mus. Mineral. Geol. Dresden 33:1–260. Martin-Sans, E., Ponchet, J. 1930. Sur l’appareil sécréteur des Buxus. Bull. Soc. Hist. Nat. Toulouse 60:231–232. Mathou, Th. 1940. Recherches sur la famille des Buxacées. Toulouse: Douladoure. Melikian, A.P. 1968. On the position of the families Buxaceae and Simmondsiaceae in the system (in Russian). Bot. Zhurn. (Moscow & Leningrad) 53:1043–1047. Metcalfe, C.R., Chalk, L. 1957. See general references. Nandi, O.I. et al. 1998. See general references.
47
Naumova, T.N. 1980. Nucellar polyembryony in the genus Sarcococca (Buxaceae) (in Russian). Bot. Zhurn. (Moscow & Leningrad) 65:230–240. Pax, F. 1896. Buxaceae. In: Engler, A., Prantl, K., Die natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien III, 5. Leipzig: W. Engelmann, pp. 7–23. Raven, P.H. 1975. The bases of angiosperm phylogeny: cytology. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 62:724–764. Reeves, R.D., Baker, A.J.M., Borhidi, A., Berazaín, R. 1996. Nickel-accumulating plants from the ancient serpentine soils of Cuba. New Phytol. 133:217–224. Robbins, H.C. 1962. A monographic study of the genus Pachysandra (Buxaceae). Ph.D. Thesis, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN. Sealy, J.R. 1986. A revision of the genus Sarcococca (Buxaceae). Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 92: 117-159. Singh, G., Bir, S.S., Gill, B.S. 1982. In: Löve, A. (ed.) IOPB Chromosome number reports LXXVII. Taxon 31:761– 777. Smets, E. 1988. La présence des ‘nectaria persistentia’ chez les Magnoliophytina (Angiospermes). Candollea 43:709–716. Soltis, D.E. et al. 2000. See general references. Soltis, D.E. et al. 2003. See general references. Uemura, K. 1979. Leaf compressions of Buxus from the upper Miocene of Japan. Bull. Nat. Sci. Mus. Tokyo, C, 5:1–8. van der Hammen, T. 1974. The Pleistocene changes of vegetation and climate in tropical South America. J. Biogeogr. 1:3–26. van Tieghem, P. 1897. Sur les Buxacées. Ann. Sci. Nat. Bot. VIII, 5:289–338. Vogel, S. 1998. Remarkable nectaries: structure, ecology, organophyletic perspectives, IV. Miscellaneous cases. Flora 193:225–248. Webster, G.L. 1987. The saga of the spurges: a review of the classification and relationships in the Euphorbiales. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 94:3–46. Wiger, J. 1935. Embryological studies on the families Buxaceae, Meliaceae, Simaroubaceae and Burseraceae. Thesis, Lund University. Wunderlich, R. 1967. Some remarks on the taxonomic significance of the seed coat. Phytomorphology 17:301– 311.
Clusiaceae-Guttiferae Guttiferae Jussieu, Gen. Pl.: 255 (1789), nom. cons. Clusiaceae Lindl., Nat. Syst. Bot., ed. 2: 74 (1836), nom. cons., nom. alt.
P.F. Stevens
Evergreen shrubs or trees, epiphytic or not, glands and/or canals in most parts of the plant; xanthones widespread; plants glabrous or with uni- or multicellular hairs, colleters common; terminal bud scaly or naked. Leaves opposite, sometimes whorled or alternate, entire, estipulate, but paired ‘glands’ sometimes found at base. Inflorescences terminal or axillary, rarely flowers single, often modified cymose. Flowers perfect or unisexual, actinomorphic, usually with prophylls, sepals free, occasionally fused, 2(3)4, or 5(–20); petals (0, 3)4–5(–8), free; stamens (4–)∞, free or variously fasciculate, phalangiate, or otherwise connate, fascicles or phalanges opposite the petals, anthers dithecate, extrose to introrse, opening by slits, rarely pores, connective often with glands of various types; receptacular nectary absent; ovary superior, 1–5(–20)-locular, placentation axile or parietal, apical or basal, ovules (1)2–∞/carpel, anatropous, sometimes amphitropous, bitegmic, tenuinucellate; free stylodia or simple style long to short or 0, stigmas more or less expanded, smooth and sticky or minutely porate, rarely papillose or ± punctate; fruit a berry or septicidal or -fragal capsule, seeds small to large, winged or arillate or not, testa with epidermis and exotegmen alone, the latter lignified and with sinuous anticlinal walls, or more complex and with vascular bundles permeating a many-layered testa, distinctive exotegmen then often absent; embryo large to small, cotyledons massive to almost absent; endosperm initially free nuclear, often absent at maturity; germination epigeal or hypogeal, if latter, then radicle may die early, replaced by adventitious roots. A family of 27 genera and 1,090 species; largely restricted to lowland tropics. Characters of Rare Occurrence. Exudate black (surrounding embryo of Chrysochlamys, floral resin of Clusia scrobiculata); leaves lacking free glands or canals (some Kielmeyera, Kayea);
bracts enveloping partial inflorescences and falling off like a calyptra (Tovomita calodictyos); flowers zygomorphic by abortion of fascicles (Marila sp.); petals and sepals 3 (some Garcinia); abaxial glands on prophylls and calyx (Clusiella); corolla tubular (Clusia gundlachii) or absent (Calophyllum); anthers with porose dehiscence (Poeciloneuron, some Marila, Clusia, and Garcinia); staminodes of the pistillate flower more strongly adnate to the corolla than phalanges of the staminate flower (Garcinia hollrungii) or staminodes opposite the sepals; pollen in tetrads (Kielmeyera spp.); fruits drupaceous (some Garcinia); seeds papillate (Neotatea); testa soft, with disorganized xylem (Kayea kunstleri, Symphonia); cotyledons fused (Mammea spp.). Vegetative Morphology. Clusiaceae are all woody plants. The trunk may be buttressed (some Calophyllum), or there may be knee (some Symphonia) or prop (Dystovomita) roots; the latter are strongly diageotropic initially. Clusia and its relatives are often epiphytes that only secondarily establish contact with the ground; adventitious roots commonly develop along the stem, and in epiphytic species of Clusia they may encircle and even strangle the host. Kielmeyera, a plant of rather drier areas, may develop a lignotuber, from which it resprouts after fire or drought; root suckering occurs in Mammea acuminata and Garcinia griffithii and layering in Chrysochlamys. Some species of Kielmeyera, Neotatea and Mammea have relatively stout, little- or unbranched stems and large leaves, although the three genera grow in very different habitats. Growth of most taxa is initially monopodial, the lateral branches being orthotropic to plagiotropic (in Garcinia and Symphonia, these may be rigidly plagiotropic). The terminal bud may lack scales, and then the flush may have only one (frequent in Garcinia, Clusia, and Calophyllum) or more pairs of leaves; branches develop from the axils of the uppermost
Clusiaceae-Guttiferae
pair of leaves of the last flush as the terminal bud grows out. Symphonieae, Mammea, some species of Calophyllum, etc., have terminal buds with two or more pairs of scales (Garcinia may approach this condition); branches here usually arise in the axils of the uppermost scales (Mammea) or the lowest pair of expanded leaves (Symphonia). In Mesua, the apical bud aborts at the seedling stage (at least, in M. ferrea), and all growth is by axillary branches; apical buds also abort in some Calophyllum, Lebrunia, etc. In several (?all) species of Kayea, the apical bud of each orthotropic innovation grows on as a plagiotropic lateral shoot, and an axillary bud produces the next orthotropic leader. Tovomita has lateral branches that are plagiotropic by substitution; axillary shoots there may be truly sylleptic. Clusiaceae are often glabrous (Mammea, many Clusioideae); taxa with unicellular hairs are scattered throughout the family. Stellate hairs characterize Caraipa, and branched or stellate hairs occur in Marila; Calophyllum has irregular multicellular hairs. Colleters are common. Buds in taxa that lack perulae are sometimes covered with dense indumentum, as in Calophyllum (it lacks colleters). Terminal and axillary buds in Garcinia, Dystovomita, Poeciloneuron, and elsewhere are often enclosed in deep excavations of the petiole bases; colleters are usually present as well. In Mesua, axillary buds are immersed in stem tissue, and in Mammea they are small and lie almost flush with the stem; they are usually more prominent. There are no stipules, but paired ‘glands’ on either side of the leaf base are quite common. In Mahurea exstipulata, these occur immediately above the insertion of the leaf and appear to be modified colleters. Garcinia commonly has small, glandular or eglandular stipuliform structures immediately below the leaf insertion, while in Endodesmieae and Symphonieae similar structures are lateral and more delicate; they may even be peltate. In Montrouziera, Garcinia, and Mahurea (the only taxa examined), they lack a vascular supply. The lamina is usually petiolate and the midrib is nearly always obvious. Venation is commonly eucamptodromous or brochidodromous, rarely acrodromous, and is more or less reticulodromous in Kayea, Mammea, and Caraipa in particular. The secondary veins are often rather close together and are joined by a submarginal vein; in Calophyllum, the marginal vein is embedded in marginal thickening and usually cannot be seen, while in
49
Garcinieae, Symphonieae and Endodesmieae the submarginal vein is within 2 mm of the margin. Tertiary venation is notably scalariform in many species of Mahurea, Caraipa, and Marila; in Calophyllum and Neotatea in particular, tertiary venation is apparently absent. Seedlings of Calophyllum and Mammea can show substantial variation in leaf arrangement and rate of growth that is not evident in adults, in Calophyllum some species even having alternate leaves (all adults have opposite leaves; Stevens 1980). Vegetative Anatomy. Vesque (1889, 1892) provides a general survey of leaf anatomy that has still not been surpassed; Metcalfe and Chalk (1950) summarize other early literature; more recent studies include those of Schofield (1968), and Paula (1976 and references therein). A distinctive feature of Clusiaceae is the exudate-containing glands and canals found throughout the plant (hence the alternative name, Guttiferae), although this has not been surveyed at even a gross level. Canals are associated with the vascular tissue and are also found in both the cortex and pith. Systematically important variation is found in the secretory tissues of the appendicular organs of the plant. These are commonly more or less independent of the vascular tissue, and are probably schizogenous glands or canals. All cotyledons that I have seen possess canals, whatever the condition in the foliage leaves. Clusiella has both glands and canals in its leaves, a combination found in some species of Mammea, Garcinia (probably independently derived in sections Tagmanthera and Daedalanthera), and perhaps also in Symphonieae (particularly poorly known). However, a genus usually has either glands or canals. Glands are notably elongated in Endodesmia and some species of Mammea and Marila. Black glands, perhaps containing hypericin, occur in Mammea, Marila, etc. (these can be confused with spots caused by fungal infections). Most Clusieae and Garcinieae have two or more series of canals in the mesophyll, one near the adaxial side of the lamina and the other near the abaxial; they pursue a more admedial course than the secondary veins (and are more admedial on the adaxial side of the lamina than on the abaxial). Canals are dendritic in Clusia (Pilosperma), and branched canals occur in some species of Garcinia, Clusia, and possibly in Symphonieae such as Pentadesma. Calophyllum has distinctive leaves with closely set secondary veins alternating with canals; the latter are interpreted as being modified veins
50
P.F. Stevens
(Ramji 1967). Neotatea is similar, and there are tendencies toward this condition in Kayea. Canals commonly occur in petals and filaments (not all genera have been surveyed); in Clusia, for example, the stout filaments may consist very largely of resin-containing glands and canals. Nodes are single trace from a single gap. In Montrouziera, the single trace divides in the bottom of the petiole into several, normally oriented bundles. In some species of Mammea, too, the trace divides, but the additional petiole bundles are inverted. The petiole bundle is usually simple, either arcuate (Calophyllum) or more or less circular, or more complex (Marila). The midrib bundle is arcuate when the petiole bundle is arcuate, or more or less circular, with phloem toward the outside. However, in Mammea, Mesua, and some species of Marila, the adaxial layer of vascular tissue is inverted, the adaxial tissue being xylem, while in many genera there are three or more layers of xylem and phloem (the phloem of the adaxial layer is itself adaxial). In Endodesmieae, xylem and phloem of the midrib bundle do not form large blocks of tissues. The vascular bundles of even the higherorder veinlets are often transcurrent, being joined to at least one surface of the lamina by echlorophyllous and often lignified tissue, but in Clusioideae in particular the vascular bundles – sometimes even the midrib, too – are embedded. Hypodermes are common, although their presence is rarely entirely consistent within genera of any size. The abaxial or near-abaxial layers of spongy mesophyll may become thick-walled and lignified; again, this is usually not completely consistent in a genus. Isolated mesophyllar sclereids are rare, but most species of Mammea have fibers, either in a subepidermal sheet, as vertically elongated bundles in the palisade mesophyll, or, less frequently, isolated and wandering through the mesophyll (Dunthorn 2002). Epidermal cells have straight to sinuous anticlinal walls (the latter especially on the abaxial surface). Leaves are overwhelmingly hypostomatic; stomata are paracytic. Lignification of the echlorophyllous tissue in the lamina margin is common in Kielmeyeroideae. The position of initiation of the phellogen in the root is taxonomically very important; it may be superficial, (sub)epidermal, or deep-seated, interior to the pericycle. The phellogen in the stem is superficial. There are fairly extensive data on wood anatomy, but inconsistencies in the use of descriptive terms and a number of contradictions in the literature present problems. Vessels are
either single or in multiples, being in oblique lines in large-seeded Kielmeyeroideae. Perforation plates are usually simple, although they are sometimes scalariform. Vasicentric tracheids have been recorded from a number of taxa. Wood parenchyma usually occurs; it is paratracheal (in a variety of configurations) or apotracheal, diffuse or banded. Fiber tracheids and libriform fibers have both been recorded; both may occur within the one genus (Kayea, Marila). Septate fibers occur, but their distribution is very sporadic; septate and non-septate fibers can be found in the same individual (Baretta-Kuipers 1976). A variety of ray types have been reported and there may be variation of systematic interest – thus, the rays of Mesua are largely uniseriate, those of Kayea largely multiseriate. Silica may occur in the rays. Inflorescence Structure. Inflorescences are terminal or axillary, rarely ramiflorous. In Clusiella, the terminal inflorescence is evicted by the vigorous growth of an axillary shoot from immediately below the inflorescence, and hence appears axillary. The inflorescence is usually modified cymose or thyrsiform, and a terminal flower is nearly always present. Single, terminal flowers are common in Symphonieae. In Mesua ferrea there are single, axillary flowers, perhaps the terminal flowers of a reduced inflorescence, but in other species of the genus the few-flowered inflorescences lack terminal flowers. Marila has racemiform inflorescences in which the often numerous flowers open more or less simultaneously; again, there is no obvious terminal flower. Fasciculate inflorescences are common (e.g., Garcinia, Symphonia, Mammea); they are usually modified cymes. Flowers normally have both bracts and prophylls, but the latter are absent in Calophyllum, Lebrunia, and Kayea lepidota. Bracts, prophylls and sepals intergrade in some Clusieae (see also Gustaffsson 2000), and the lowermost pair of sepals in genera such as Tovomitopsis may in fact be prophyllar. Floral Structure. Sepals and petals are nearly always present and are usually free; they can be difficult to distinguish (Gustafsson 2000). Sepals are commonly five in number and quincuncial in aestivation, four and decussate, or two and valvate or even connate. When there are five petals, they are often contorted, when four, then decussate aestivation is common; petal numbers in Mammea increase by the division of the innermost petals. Clusia gundlachii has a remarkable, undivided tube
Clusiaceae-Guttiferae
surrounding the androecium; it shows no evidence of being a composite structure, even when very young (Gustafsson 2000). Pubescence of the calyx and corolla is uncommon. The androecium may be basically fasciculate or phalangiate, the numerous stamens found in most species representing the products of five, antepetalous primordia (Figs. 14, 16, 17, 19). In pistillate flowers, structures that are usually in the antepetalous position may represent these fascicles. Kielmeyeroideae have slender, free (rarely fused – some species of Mammea) stamens with no evidence of fasciculation, although in the monosymmetric flowers of an undescribed species of Marila there are no stamens opposite two petals, suggesting that two fascicles are missing. Anther glands are common and diverse: they may be absent (Calophyllum, Poeciloneuron); barely perceptible, sometimes paired and apical (Mammea); single and more prominent (Mammea, Marila, Kayea); strongly crateriform, presumably after the contents are removed (Marila; in Caraipa, they contain a highly aromatic oil and the covering ruptures during anthesis); or relatively long and apparently tubular (Marila). Clusioideae show extreme androecial variation, although our knowledge is based almost entirely on general surveys from over a century ago (e.g., Pierre 1883–1885; Engler 1888, 1925; Vesque 1889, 1892, 1893, but see Gustafsson and Bittrich 2002 for Clusia). The filaments are stout, the anthers even being embedded in them. Garcinieae and Symphonieae often have clearly phalangiate androecia; in the latter, they occur at the end of a long tube. Decaphalangium (= Clusia) was described as having ten phalanges; it is best interpreted as having ten locellate anthers; some other Clusia, Kielmeyera, and Poeciloneuron also have locellate anthers. In both Garcinia and Clusia, androecial fusion may obscure the limits of individual stamens (see below), although epidermides delimiting the stamens can at least sometimes be seen in transverse section. Although an exudate may cover the whole androecium in Clusia and its relatives, or the whole filaments may consist of massive glands, distinct anther glands are rare in Clusioideae. There is no nectary at the base of the ovary. In Symphonia, however, there is a nectariferous disc surrounding the staminal tube that may represent the antesepalous whorl of the androecium (Fig. 19C); nectar is also secreted by other Symphonieae. Nectar may be secreted at the base of the androecium, as in some species of Clusia.
51
Some species of Garcinia produce an almost mucilaginous secretion from the center of the flower (P. Sweeney, pers. comm.). There are usually 2–5 carpels; when equal in number to the perianth whorls, they are opposite the sepals. Calophyllum has several vascular bundles in the style, the stigma is often definitely 2or more-lobed, and the single-ovulate gynoecium is multicarpellary. However, how many carpels make up the gynoecium in Endodesmia and Lebrunia, with its single, apical ovule and punctate stigma, is not clear. There is an apparent increase in carpel number within Garcinia, Clusia, and Mammea (Paramammea); in the latter, there may also be twice as many ovary loculi as stigmatic lobes. Placentation is basically axile, although the placentae may fail to meet in the middle, as in Mesua and Mammea; Clusiella has laminar placentation (Notis 2004), and Allanblackia has parietal placentation. Basal ovules occur in Kayea and Calophyllum, apical ovules in Endodesmieae. Ovules are anatropous, bitegmic, bistomal and tenuinucellate, although Mammea americana apparently has a single, massive integument some 26 cells across (Mourão and Beltrati 2000), while the micropyle of Garcinia mangostana is described as being exostomal (Lim 1984). Embryo sac development is of Polygonum type. However, little is known of ovule morphology and embryo sac development. Most Clusioideae have short stylodia representing the separate tips of carpels; the stigmas are usually distinct. The sessile stigmas of Garcinia are more nearly connate; Kielmeyeroideae often have long, simple styles, whether free or fused. The stigma is often more or less expanded, and the surface is smooth or variously sculptured (the latter especially in Garcinia). However, in Kayea, Poeciloneuron, and Endodesmieae it is punctate, while the expanded stigmas of Clusia section Cordylandra have stout, pointed hairs and those of C. section Criuva are papillate. There is a small aperture at the apex of the style branches in Symphonieae through which the pollen enters, but no exposed stigmatic surface at all. Floral Anatomy and Development. Little is known about floral anatomy and development. Stamen initiation is centrifugal in those few taxa in which this feature has been observed (e.g., Kubitzki 1978). Androecial development in Garcinia and Clusia shows extreme variability, in some species of the latter the normal parts of the stamen be-
52
P.F. Stevens
ing unrecognizable (Bittrich and Amaral 1996). The two antesepalous phalanges in species of Garcinia section Tagmanthera (Exell and Robson 1960) may result from fusion of phalanges in pairs (cf. Hypericaceae, this volume). The vascular tissue of the stamen phalanges of Lorostemon and its relatives is siphonostelic (Kawano 1965); siphonosteles, or close approximations to them, are found in the stout filaments of some species of Clusia (pers. obs.). Pollen Morphology. Seetharam (1985) surveyed the pollen of the family using a light microscope (see also Yi 1979; Barth 1980; Jones 1980; Seetharam and Maheshwari 1986; GonçalvesEsteves and Mendonça 2001). Extensive pollen variation in Madagascan species of Mammea (Presting et al. 1983) is caused by cryptic dioecy (Dunthorn 2004, see below). Pollen is usually in monads, although Kielmeyera may have tetrads. The grains are usually tricolporate, sometimes triporate; Garcinieae and Symphonieae often have more than three apertures. Costae colpi are usually present, and there is considerable variation in endaperture type and orientation. The pollen surface may be reticulate, rugulose, fossulate, foveolate, psilate or scabrate; supratectal elements occur in some genera, notably Chrysochlamys, and some species of Garcinia are densely spinulate. In most taxa, the nexine is < 1 µm thick, but in many Symphonieae it is > 1.5 µm thick. Karyology. There is extensive infraspecific variation within Garcinia xanthochymus (Chennaveeraiah and Radzan 1980). However, there may be little cytological variation within Clusia, gametic numbers of 30 having been recorded for several unrelated taxa (da Cruz et al. 1990). The few counts known from Clusioideae show high base numbers of 28–48, and comparable numbers for Kielmeyeroideae are 16–21 (Carr and McPherson 1986). Pollination and Reproductive Systems. Dioecy is common in Clusieae and Garcinieae, but is only sporadic elsewhere. The breeding system of Mammea, often described as being androdioecious, is cryptically dioecious (Dunthorn 2004) – hence the bizarre pollen morphology of some species, usually reported from ‘perfect’ flowers (see above). A few Calophyllum are dioecious; andromonoecy is common in Kielmeyera (Saddi 1989). Garcinia and Clusia need more study. Ag-
amospermy is known from Clusia rosea, C. minor, and Garcinia mangostana; in the latter, adventive embryony in particular occurs (Maguire 1976; Lim 1984; Richards 1990a, b, c). Furthermore, in some species of Clusia there are three flower types – staminate, pistillate, and perfect (Bittrich and Amaral 1997; Lopes and Machado 1998) – while C. minor has perfect flowers (B. Hammel, pers. comm.); in neither Garcinia nor Clusia is dioecy strict. Apomixis is sporadic elsewhere in Clusiaceae, possibly occurring in Calophyllum (Stevens 1980); polyembryony is known from a few species in Calophyllum, Kayea, and Garcinia, including G. magostana. There is little information about hybridization in Clusiaceae (for Calophyllum, see Stevens 1980); fairly extensive artificial crosses have been made in Clusia (V. Bittrich, pers. comm.). The predominant petal color in the family is white or yellow; pink, purple or red being less common. Many Clusiaceae from the New World tropics produce resins – in particular, polyisoprenylated benzophenones mixed with fatty acids – or other exudates from distinctive anther glands, secretions by the whole staminal mass, the stigmatic surface, or the staminode or pistillode (Ramirez B. and Gomez 1978; Armbruster 1984; Rodrigues C. et al. 1999; Mesquita and Franciscon 1995; Bittrich and Amaral 1996, 1997; Oliveira et al. 1996; Porto et al. 2000; Carmo and Franceschinelli 2002). In Clusia in particular, the secretions are collected by megachilid and other resin-collecting bees, and such pollination mechanisms have evolved more than once (including in Clusiella, see especially Gustafsson and Bittrich 2002). The aromatic oils in the filaments of Tovomita are collected by euglossine bees, and different fragrances may be involved in species barriers (Noguiera et al. 1998). Some Clusia are night-flowering and pollinated by beetles (including the banana-scented C. flava; B. Hammel, pers. comm.), with pistillate flowers perhaps mimicking staminate flowers (Correia et al. 1993); Clusia growing at higher elevations tends to produce nectar, rather than resin (Armbruster 1984). Little is known about what the various anther glands produce, although resins and/or hypericin and similar substances are likely candidates. Pollen may be a major reward, e.g., Calophyllum; buzz pollination is reported from Kielmeyera (Oliveira and Sazima 1990) and some Clusia, Mahurea, and Caraipa (Bittrich and Amaral 1996). Symphonia and its relatives have large, often red flowers and produce nectar; birds, butterflies, monkeys, and in Madagascar,
Clusiaceae-Guttiferae
also lemurs are reported to visit the flowers (e.g., Perrier de la Bâthie 1951; Croat 1978; Pascarella 1992). Platonia insignis is bird-pollinated (Maués and Venturieri 1996), Moronobea coccinea was observed to be pollinated exclusively by parrots (Vicentini and Fischer 1999), while Pentadesma butyracea is bat-pollinated (Petterson et al. 2004). Fruit and Seed. Fruits are commonly capsular, dehiscence being septicidal or septifragal (Mesua, Clusieae). In Kayea, the calyx is often massively accrescent, in some species quite surrounding the capsule; the fruits are then indehiscent. Berries with a single seed and a woody testa occur in Mammea and Calophyllum; similar fruits of Endodesmieae have a thinner testa and the pedicels may be swollen. In Mammea americana, the inner part of the endocarp often becomes firmly attached to the seed coat (Mourão and Beltrati 2000; pers. obs.), and there is a well-developed periderm. Garcinieae and Symphonieae have several-seeded berries, while in Clusiella the berries may contain thousands of minute seeds. In Platonia insignis, the fleshy inner part of the pericarp becomes attached to the testa and covers it when the seeds are released after dehiscence of the fruit (Mourão and Beltrati 1996a). The endocarp is notably massive and sclerified in some species of Garcinia (largely east Malesian), the surface being strongly ridged. Clusiaceae with seeds less than 4 mm long usually have a testa with an epidermis, as well as a low, lignified exotegmen with sinuous anticlinal walls developing from the outer epidermis of the inner integument (see also Corner 1976). There is a single, chalazal vascular bundle. In many larger-seeded taxa, the testa is thicker and the vascular bundle proliferates (in Dystovomita it is braided, but restricted to the chalazal position); the exotegmen is then often absent. The exotegmen in large-seeded taxa such as Allanblackia is tall (Delay and Mangenot 1960), although it is difficult to equate the massive lignified layer in the seed coat of genera such as Lorostemon with an exotegmen. Platonia insignis has a testa of unthickened cells and a few brachysclereids in the tegmen (Mourão and Beltrati 1996b). The seed coat of Symphonia consists of a mass of almost cottony and unlignified fibers, while there is a layer of cells with scalariform thickenings in that of Kielmeyera. In Clusieae, the seed is more or less surrounded by a red or white aril, the latter in some Chrysochlamys, and in Tovomita the fruits are also red inside (V. Bittrich, pers. comm.). In Tovomita, the aril appears to be vascularized.
53
The endosperm may persist in small-seeded taxa as a thin layer around the embryo; it has largely disappeared by maturity in larger-seeded taxa. The proportions of cotyledon, hypocotyl and radicle vary greatly. Kielmeyeroideae such as Marila and Clusiella have small embryos less than 3 mm long and with cotyledons 30–60% of their lengths, but most genera have seeds over 6 mm long that are made up largely of cotyledons; in Caraipa, Haploclathra, and Kielmeyera, the cotyledons are strongly cordate whereas in Kayea they are more or less peltate. In Clusioideae, on the other hand, the cotyledons are minute (e.g., Clusia) or almost invisible (many species of Garcinia, Symphonieae), the often large embryo being made up of a grossly swollen hypocotylar region, the tigellus (e.g., Brandza 1908). Axes of such embryos are usually straight, but are S-shaped in Platonia insignis (Mourão and Beltrati 1996b) and some species of Garcinia. The embryo is usually white, but in Caraipa, Kielmeyera, and Clusieae it is often green, while in Calophyllum suberosum it is a rather violent purple. There is much variation in germination (La Mensbruge 1966 provides some information). Species with seeds under 10 mm long are usually epigeal and phanerocotylar, even when the cotyledons are relatively minute, c. 1/10 the seed in length, as in Clusia. Larger seeds over 10 mm long and consisting of proportionally huge cotyledons are either hypogeal and cryptocotylar (Calophyllum, Mammea), or epigeal and phanerocotylar (Caraipa, Kielmeyera); there is infrageneric variation in Poeciloneuron. Larger seeds consisting mostly of tigellus often develop adventitious roots in the epicotylar region, the hypocotyl does not elongate, the cotyledons do not develop further, and the radicle eventually dies, or at least becomes inconspicuous (Garcinia-type germination – see Brandza 1908; also in Symphonia, Tovomita, etc.). However, in other taxa with such seeds, the hypocotyl elongates, the tigellus becomes erect, and the cotyledons expand (Garcinia section Macrostigma, Chrysochlamys), while germination in Platonia is hypogeal, but adventitious roots do not develop. Dispersal. Mammea odorata, with its thick, woody, but not notably dense seed coat, and Calophyllum inophyllum, with a spongy layer immediately surrounding the seed, are strand plants that are water-dispersed. Fruits of the latter species may also be eaten by bats, as are some other
54
P.F. Stevens
species of the genus; the many blue-fruited species of Calophyllum (primarily from east of Wallace’s Line) may be dispersed by birds (Stevens 1980). The large, fleshy fruits of Mammea seem to be attractive to mammals, being eaten by a variety of lemurs in Madagascar, and seeds of the arillate New World Clusieae are dispersed by birds (e.g., Spruce 1855), although ants subsequently affect the distribution and germination of seeds of the primarily bird-dispersed Clusia criuva (Passos and Oliveira 2002). Taxa with small, dry seeds, and those with winged seeds, are probably wind-dispersed, although seeds of Haploclathra and Caraipa, with their proportionally very small wings, may be water-dispersed (Kubitzki 1989: the seeds certainly float well). Symphonia, whose fruits are eaten by animals, has dispersed across water to achieve its present-day distribution (Dick et al. 2003). Phytochemistry. Clusiaceae are noted for producing a wide array of isoprenylated xanthones, biflavonoids and anthraquinones (e.g., Xu et al. 2001 and references therein), 80 new xanthone structures having been reported in the years 1980–1988 alone (Bennett and Lee 1989). Most xanthones have a restricted distribution, although macluroxanthone and in particular mangiferin are more widespread. Interestingly, few xanthones are known from Clusieae, although benzophenones, their precursors, have been isolated from them. Prenylated benzophenones are known from Clusia, Tovomita, Tovomitopsis, and Moronobea (Delle Monache et al. 1991; A. Marsaioli, pers. comm.). 1,3,5,6-tetraoxygenated xanthones are known only from African species of Garcinia and from species of Rheedia (= Garcinia), but not in Asian species of Garcinia (Bennett and Lee 1989). Biflavonoids with 3-8 , 3 -8 and 8-8 linkages also show distributions of potential systematic interest (Owen and Scheinmann 1974; Waterman and Husain 1983), while there are distinctive coumarin derivates substituted at position 4 in Kielmeyeroideae (Taylor and Brooker 1969). Tocotrienolic acids and terpenes are also found in Clusia exudates (A. Marsaioli, pers. comm.). Relationships Within the Family. Planchon and Triana (1860, 1862 and references therein) laid the foundation of our knowledge of the family, while Vesque (1893) was its last monographer; he also made extensive anatomical observations. Mahurea, Kielmeyera, Marila, and their relatives are here included in Clusiaceae, although usually
placed in Bonnetiaceae or Theaceae, often having been considered to be ‘linking’ genera (e.g., Maguire 1972; Baretta-Kuipers 1976; Field 1978; Cronquist 1981). Hypericaceae are here excluded from Clusiaceae (Stevens, this volume). Within Clusiaceae, Kielmeyeroideae (as Calophylloideae – Robson 1978) form one major clade. Phylogenetic relationships between genera are unclear, taxa with cordate cotyledons apparently forming a paraphyletic group in some family-level morphological analyses (own unpubl. data), although monophyletic in a three-gene molecular study (Notis 2004). Although Clusiella is sister to Clusioideae in morphological analyses, molecular data place it firmly within Kielmeyeroideae, where it is a fascinating example of general ecological convergence with Clusia (Gustafsson et al. 2002); it may be associated with other small-seeded Kielmeyeroideae, especially when morphological data are included (Notis 2004). Within Kielmeyeroideae, Endodesmia may be sister to all other taxa, with Mammea sister to the remaining taxa; within the latter, Calophyllum + Mesua and Kayea + Poeciloneuron are two pairs of sister taxa (Notis 2004). (Endodesmieae are vegetatively like Clusioideae, they have fruits like Calophyllum (Kielmeyeroideae), and a unique gynoecium; their germination, chromosome number, root anatomy, etc., are all unknown.) Clusioideae, also monophyletic, are made up of Clusieae, Symphonieae, and Garcinieae. Evidence from both the androecium and gynoecium (the stigma) suggests that Symphonieae are monophyletic, but most genera are poorly known; Montrouziera and Moronobea in particular are very similar. Molecular data do not find a strongly supported Symphonieae (Gustafsson et al. 2002). Tovomita (Clusieae) has Garciniatype germination, while some species of Garcinia section Macrostigma germinate like Clusia, as well as apparently having seeds with an exotegmen. Garcinieae and Clusieae are clearly distinguished, and Garcinia germination type may have evolved twice. Clusia includes Decaphalangium and Renggeria, which with Clusia section Cordylandra make a clade (Gustafsson and Bittrich 2002) characterized i.a. by their stigmas, which have stout hairs. Other genera have been synonymized under Clusia (Gustafsson and Bittrich 2002); they were based on slight differences in the androecium, e.g., generally having few anthers (and also ovules). Pilosperma has distinctive branching canals in the leaf; it, too, is best included in Clusia. Tovomitopsis is poorly known, but it may be sister to
Clusiaceae-Guttiferae
Chrysochlamys (Gustafsson and Bittrich 2002), and so it is recognized here (cf. Gustafsson et al. 2002). Affinities. In the past, Clusiaceae have been linked to the heterogeneous Theaceae by ‘intermediate’ genera such as Kielmeyera (e.g., Baretta-Kuipers 1976). Although both have numerous, centrifugally developing stamens and bitegmic, tenuinucellate ovules (e.g., Erbar 1986), Sladeniaceae, Theaceae, and Pentaphylacaceae, into which Theaceae are currently divided (Stevens and Weitzman 2004; Stevens et al. 2004; Weitzman et al. 2004 [as Ternstroemiaceae]), are now all well established as members of the asterid Ericales (e.g., Anderberg et al. 2002). Clusiaceae are part of Malpighiales (e.g., Chase et al. 1993; Davis and Chase 2004). Within Malpighiales, the immediate relatives of Clusiaceae seem well established. Clusiaceae are close to Bonnetiaceae (e.g., Gustaffson et al. 2002) and in particular Hypericaceae (see also Crepet and Nixon 1998). At least some members of all three families have distinctive xanthones (Kubitzki et al. 1978), similar, exotegmic seeds, and antepetalous staminal fascicles or phalanges. However, Bonnetiaceae have long, terminal buds, trilacunar nodes (most taxa), and minutely serrate leaves, although the polarities of these characters are unclear. A rather low base number of n = 11 from Ploiarium is most like numbers in Hypericaceae; Hypericaceae-Hypericeae and Bonnetiaceae also both have papillate stigmas, although Bonnetiaceae apparently lack glands or canals. It has caused something of a stir to find that Podostemaceae are also part of this group, and they, too, have tenuinucellate ovules and at least some xanthones; for further details, see Hypericaceae (this volume). The relationships of the Clusiaceae group of families are unclear. Elatinaceae have often been associated with them, but they are probably sister to Malpighiaceae (Davis and Chase 2004). Although Elatinaceae have exotegmic seeds rather like those of Clusiaceae, xanthones have not been detected in them (Hegnauer 1966), and there are a number of similarities between them and Malpighiaceae (Davis and Chase 2004; Stevens 2005). The Clusiaceae group may be close to families such as Ochnaceae (Davis and Chase 2004); interestingly, Malpighiaceae + Elatinaceae may in turn be close to that group. Distribution and Habitats. Clusiaceae are mostly plants of moist, tropical, lowland or
55
lower montane forests. Most genera occur in primary forest, where they may be rheophytes (e.g., Calophyllum rupicola) or grow in peat swamps (C. sundaicum) or black-water floodplains (Caraipa, Haploclathra spp.). Kielmeyera in South America grows in more open and drier vegetation. Epiphytic or lianescent taxa are found almost exclusively in Clusieae and Clusiella, both tropical American. Crassulacean acid metabolism occurs in Clusia, which shows considerable flexibility in carbon metabolism (Lüttge 1999, 2002). Pending a more detailed phylogeny, little can be said about the biogeography of the family. Bonnetiaceae, close to Clusiaceae, includes the New World Bonnetia and the Malesian-American Ploiarium and Archytaea. Within Clusiaceae, Kielmeyeroideae have many neotropical taxa, e.g., Marila, Caraipa, Neotatea, and Mahurea; Endodesmia and Lebrunia are from the African mainland. Other genera are primarily IndoMalesian, although Mammea is notably diverse in Madagascar; it and Calophyllum are also poorly represented in America. The African and American species of Mammea are notably more similar to each other than to other species in the genus. Within Clusioideae, Symphonieae occur in Africa-Madagascar, America, and New Caledonia (Montrouziera). Symphonia has an amphi-Atlantic distribution, and shows strong molecular differentiation within S. globulifera s.l. (Dick et al. 2003); at least three dispersal events across marine barriers seem necessary, given the age of the genus and its current geographic distribution. Clusieae are restricted to America, while Garcinieae are largely Old World (Garcinia in America is not at all diverse). The diversification of both Clusia and Garcinia may be linked to the extreme variation of their androecium. Fossil Record. The fossil record of Clusiaceae is poor. Fossil pollen such as Kielmeyeropollenites eoceni is known from the Eocene of India, and pollen ascribed to genera such as Symphonia, Pentadesma, and Calophyllum is known from the middle Eocene onward in the regions the genera currently inhabit (Muller 1981). Pachydermites diederexii, fossil pollen of Symphonia, is used for stratigraphic dating by the oil industry (R.J. Morley, in Dick et al. 2003). Some fossil woods have been identified as Clusiaceae, including Symphonioxylon from the lower Miocene in Egypt, the Middle Tertiary of India, and Cretaceous rocks of Somalia; woods similar to those of Calophyllum,
56
P.F. Stevens
Kayea, and Mesua have less-startling distributions (Müller-Stoll and Mädel-Angeliewa 1986). Flowers of Paleoclusia, recently described from the Turonian (c. 90 Ma b.p.) in New Jersey, USA, show signs of producing resins and being pollinated by meliponine or similar bees (see above); note, however, that unlike at least some Clusia, the outer anticlinal walls of the exotesta are well developed and there are hairs on the flower (Crepet and Nixon 1998). A few Pleistocene fossils are also known, e.g., of Garcinia in the New Hebrides (Fosberg 1977). Economic Importance. Garcinia mangostana, the mangosteen, is one of the finest tropical fruits; the inner part of the pericarp (the ‘aril’ of some) is eaten. Other species of the genus also produce tasty fruits, often more acid than those of the mangosteen, and the young leaves of some are edible. The pericarp of Mammea americana (the mammey apple) is another tropical delicacy, and fruits of Moronobea coccinea and in particular Platonia insignis (‘bacuri’; Maués and Venturieri 1996) are also esteemed. The flowers of Mammea siamensis yield a scent. Garcinia twigs are commonly used as chew sticks in West Africa (M. Cheek, pers. comm.). The wood of Mesua ferrea, the ironwood, is very hard; the plant has very ornamental flowers and foliage, and has long been cultivated in India and Java in particular. Species of Symphonia are also spectacular when in flower; the stiff leaves of Clusia rosea have been sent as postcards through the U.S. mail (C.E. Wood Jr., pers. comm.). Many of the larger trees in the family provide useful timber. Thus, Calophyllum is logged through much of Malesia (as ‘bintangor’ or Calophyllum); the wood of C. inophyllum was formerly much valued for the building of canoes and boats. Oils and fats, valuable as medicines and for household activities such as lighting, cooking and making soap, can be obtained from the seeds of species of Calophyllum, Pentadesma, and Garcinia. Moronobea can be weedy. Gamboge (the name is derived from ‘Cambodia’) is extracted from the resin of species of Garcinia; it is a pigment giving a bright yellow color, and also a potent purgative. Several species are important in local pharmacopeias, while in western medicine anti-tumor activity has been detected in xanthones and benzophenones (Bennett and Lee 1989); Calophyllum show some promise as a source of anti-AIDS drugs (McKee et al. 1996). A methanolic extract of Clusia exudate is active against bacteria and fungi (A. Marsaioli, pers. comm.).
Classification of Clusiaceae I. Subfamily Kielmeyeroideae Engler (1888). 1. Tribe Calophylleae Choisy (1824). Genera 1–12 2. Tribe Endodesmieae Engler (1921). Genera 13–14 II. Subfamily Clusioideae Engler (1888). 1. Tribe Clusieae Choisy (1824). Genera 15–18 2. Tribe Garcinieae Choisy (1824). Genera 19–20 3. Tribe Symphonieae Choisy (1824). Genera 21–27
Key to the Genera 1. Leaves alternate; androecium not obviously fasciculate or phalangiate; fruit capsular 2 – Leaves opposite, if alternate, then androecium fasciculate and fruit a berry 5 2. Secondary veins closely parallel, tertiary veins not evident 1. Neotatea – Secondary veins not closely parallel, tertiary veins well developed 3 3. Anthers lacking obviously crateriform glands; seeds with wing > 2 mm wide 5. Kielmeyera – Anthers usually with crateriform glands; seeds with wing < 2 mm wide 4 4. Plants lacking stellate hairs; capsules longer than wide, seeds numerous 3. Mahurea – Plants with (minute) stellate hairs; capsules about as long as wide, seeds < 3 6. Caraipa 5. Styles simple, often longer than the ovary (Poeciloneuron with free stylodia), filaments long, much more slender than the anthers; stigma papillate or smooth; plants rarely dioecious 6 – Free stylodia or simple styles usually shorter than the ovary; filaments none, or at least half the width of the anthers; stigmas not papillate; plants often dioecious 14 6. Lamina with prominent, close secondary veins almost at right angles to midrib; fruit baccate, seed single, large 7 – Lamina with often inconspicuous secondary veins leaving midrib at acute angle; fruit usually capsular, with few to many seeds 9 7. Stipuliform structures absent; indumentum well developed, at least on buds; stamens free 12. Calophyllum – Stipuliform structures present; indumentum none or slight; stamens fused and/or fasciculate 8 8. Lamina with glands and short canals; inflorescences terminal; sepals 5, quincuncial 13. Endodesmia – Lamina with canals, but not crossing secondary veins; inflorescences axillary; sepals 4, decussate 14. Lebrunia 9. Terminal bud aborting; axillary buds immersed in stem 9. Mesua – Terminal bud functional; axillary buds more or less evident 10 10. Inflorescences racemose, flowers opening simultaneously; capsules with ∞ seeds < 3 mm long 2. Marila – Inflorescences not racemose, flowers usually opening successively; capsules with < 4(–8) seeds > 8 mm long 11
Clusiaceae-Guttiferae 11. Terminal buds without perulae; hairs multicellular; cotyledons cordate 7. Haploclathra – Terminal buds perulate; hairs unicellular or plant glabrous; cotyledons not cordate 12 12. Anthers porose; stylodia long, free 8. Poeciloneuron – Anthers dehiscing by slits; style very short to long, more or less fused 13 13. Inflorescence usually with axis; style long; fruit capsular, and/or calyx massively accrescent 10. Kayea – Inflorescence fasciculate; style short; fruit a fibrous berry; calyx deciduous 11. Mammea 14. Lamina clearly with glands and canals; large gland on abaxial surface of prophylls and often sepals; fruit a many-seeded berry; cotyledons 1/2 length of embryo 4. Clusiella – Lamina rarely with both glands and canals; prophylls and calyx lacking surface glands; fruit capsular, or if baccate, then seeds few; cotyledons < 1|10 length of embryo 15 15. Terminal bud perulate; flowers perfect; anthers 1.7– 40 mm long; stigmas minute, porose 16 – Terminal bud usually not perulate; flowers rarely perfect; anthers usually < 2 mm long; stigmas much expanded 22 16. Filaments connate into a tube; seed with hairyappearing testa 28. Symphonia – Filaments not connate into a tube; seeds lacking hairy testa 17 17. Stamens 15+/phalange; anthers more or less locellate 18 – Stamens 3–13/phalange, anthers rarely locellate 19 18. Inflorescences with single flowers; filaments well fused 24. Platonia – Inflorescences with 3–15 flowers; filaments barely fused 22. Pentadesma 19. Petals ligulate, usually spreading at anthesis 20 – Petals usually broadly elliptic and erect at anthesis 21 20. Anthers 10–40 mm long; ovules 12–∞/carpel; tall, lignified exotegmen usually present 26. Lorostemon – Anthers 8–9 mm long; ovules c. 4/carpel; exotegmen absent 27. Thysanostemon 21. Style usually shorter than ovary; stamens twisted; ovules 3–10/carpel 23. Moronobea – Style as long as or longer than ovary; stamens straight; ovules 12–∞/carpel 25. Montrouziera 22. Stipuliform structures present or not; androecium often fasciculate; fruit nearly always baccate (capsular, drupaceous) 23 – Stipuliform structures absent; androecium not obviously fasciculate; fruit capsular 24 23. Placentation parietal; ovules 12–∞/carpel 21. Allanblackia – Placentation axile; ovule 1/carpel 20. Garcinia 24. Ovules 1–2(–4)/loculus; aril vascularized 25 – Ovules (1–)4–∞/loculus; aril not vascularized 27 25. Petiole base only slightly if at all excavated; axillary branches lacking long basal internode; stylodia none 19. Chrysochlamys – Petiole base often strongly excavated; axillary branches with a distinctively long basal internode; stylodia often distinct 26 26. Stylodia distinct; outer sepals enveloping bud 17. Tovomita – Stylodia none; outer sepals not enveloping bud 18. Tovomitopsis
57
27. Leaf base deeply excavated; inflorescences axillary 16. Dystovomita – Leaf base not or slightly excavated; inflorescences usually terminal 15. Clusia
Genera of Clusiaceae Basic Characters Plant woody; leaves opposite, ± coriaceous, entire, stipules 0; inflorescence ± cymose; stamens free, anthers extrorse, ovary superior, placentation axile, stigma wet; fruit dehiscing down septal radius; seed exarillate. I. Subfam. Kielmeyeroideae Engler (1888). Leaves with ± spherical glands, veins usually transcurrent; flowers perfect; filaments much narrower than the anthers; style simple; cotyledons > 1/3 length of seed; phellogen in root deep-seated. I.1. Tribe Calophylleae [No characters for the tribe.] 1. Neotatea Maguire Neotatea Maguire, Mem. New York Bot. Gard. 23:161 (1972).
Sparsely branched small trees; hairs unicellular; terminal bud not perulate, no colleters; leaves spiral, secondary veins closely parallel, alternating with canals; inflorescences terminal, 1–5-flowered; sepals 5, quincuncial; petals 5, contorted; anthers 5–6 mm long, glands large, spherical; carpels 3, ∞ ovules/carpel, style short, stigma expanded; fruit septicidal; seed papillate, testa simple, exotegmen present; embryo c. 2.5 mm long, cotyledons 1/3– 1/2 its length, endosperm present; germination unknown. Four species, northern South America; colline. 2. Marila Swartz Marila Swartz, Prodr. veg. ind. occ.: 84 (1788).
Trees; hairs stellate or branched, also often uniseriate; terminal bud not perulate, no colleters; secondary veins distant, tertiaries often scalariform, glands sometimes elongated; inflorescences with (2–)∞ flowers, racemiform, terminal, branched, or axillary, branched or unbranched, flowers opening simultaneously; sepals 5, quincuncial; petals 5, aestivation various,
58
P.F. Stevens
anthers 1–5.5 mm long, porose or not, glands large, spherical, or becoming strongly crateriform, or tubular; carpels 3–6, ∞ ovules/carpel, style short, stigma moderately expanded; fruit septicidal, seeds often with a tuft of hairs at one end, testa simple, exotegmen present, embryo < 1 mm long, cotyledons 1/2–2/3 its length; germination epigeal. Circa 40 species, many undescribed, Central America, the Caribbean, and northwestern South America; usually below 1,000 m. 3. Mahurea Aublet Mahurea Aublet, Hist. Pl. Guiane 1:558 (1775); Kubitzki, Mem. New York Bot. Gard. 29:131–138 (1978).
Trees; hairs unicellular; terminal bud perulate, colleters present; leaves spiral, secondary veins distant, tertiaries often scalariform; inflorescences terminal, with ∞ flowers; sepals 5, quincuncial; petals 5, contorted; anthers 1.2–2 mm long, gland large, becoming deeply crateriform; carpels 3(4), ∞ ovules/carpel, stigma moderately expanded; fruit septicidal, seeds winged, testa simple, exotegmen present, embryo c. 1.5 mm long, cotyledons 1/2–2/3 its length; germination unknown. Two species, the Guyanas, Venezuela and northern Brazil; low to moderate alt. 4. Clusiella Planchon & Triana Clusiella Planchon & Triana, Ann. Sci. Nat. Bot. IV, 14:253 (1860); Hammel, Novon 9:349 (1999), rev.
Trees, epiphytes or lianes; glabrous; terminal bud perulate, single interpetiolar stipuliform structure; secondary veins rather close, tertiaries obscure, also canals; plant dioecious; inflorescences pseudo-axillary, with 1–15 flowers, prophylls and all or some sepals with a prominent abaxial gland; sepals 5, quincuncial; petals 5, contorted; anthers < 1 mm long, gland 0; carpels 5–15, placentation laminar, ∞ ovules/loculus, funicles long, style 0, stigmas expanded, ± separate; fruit a many-seeded berry, testa simple, exotegmen present, embryo < 2 mm long, cotyledons ± 2/3 its length; germination unknown. Seven species, Central America and tropical South America; low alt. 5. Kielmeyera Mart. Kielmeyera Mart. & Zucch., Flora 8:30 (1825); Saddi, Comp. ext. morph. studies genus Kielmeyera (1989); Saddi, O genero Kielmeyera na flora de Mato Grosso (1996).
Small trees, sometimes little branched, or sprouting from a enlarged rootstock; glabrous, or hairs unicellular, sometimes fasciculate or uniseriate; terminal bud perulate, colleters present; leaves spiral, secondary veins distant, fine venation reticulate; inflorescences terminal, 3–∞ flowers; sepals 5, quincuncial; petals 5, contorted; anthers 1–2.5 mm long, locellate or not, gland sometimes subcrateriform, present or not; carpels (2)3, ∞ ovules/carpel, stigma expanded; fruit septicidal; seeds winged, testa with scalariform layer, exotegmen absent, embryo 10–25 mm long, flattened, cotyledons huge, cordate; germination epigeal (?always). Forty-seven species, overwhelmingly Brazilian; low alt. 6. Caraipa Aublet Caraipa Aublet, Hist. Pl. Guiane 1:561 (1775); Kubitzki, Mem. New York Bot. Gard. 29:82–131 (1978).
Trees; hairs stellate, sometimes unicellular or uniseriate; terminal bud perulate or not, colleters present; leaves spiral or distichous, secondary veins distant, tertiaries often scalariform. Inflorescences terminal and axillary, with 3–∞ flowers; sepals 5, quincuncial; petals 5, contorted; anthers < 2.5 mm long, gland large, becoming crateriform, rarely absent; carpels 3, 1–4 ovules/carpel, style long, stigma expanded; fruit septifragal; seeds narrowly winged or not, embryo > 6 mm long, flattened, exotegmen 0, cotyledons huge, cordate; germination epigeal. Circa 28 species, from Brazil (most) to Peru, Colombia, Venezuela and the Guianas; low to moderate alt. One undescribed species lacks glands on the anthers. 7. Haploclathra Bentham Haploclathra Bentham, J. Proc. Linn. Soc., Bot. 5:58 & 64 (1860); Lleras, Mem. New York Bot. Gard. 22:129–136 (1972).
Trees; hairs unicellular, branched or multicellular, uniseriate; terminal bud not perulate, colleters present; secondary veins distant, tertiaries scalariform; inflorescences terminal, with ∞ flowers; sepals 5, quincuncial; petals 5, contorted; anthers 1.5–5 mm long, locellate, eglandular; carpels 3, 1–2 ovules/carpel, style short, stigma expanded; fruit septifragal; seeds narrowly winged, testa complex, exotegmen absent, embryo > 9 mm long, flattened, cotyledons huge, cordate. Four species, Brazilian Amazonas and Peru; low alt.
Clusiaceae-Guttiferae
8. Poeciloneuron Beddome Poeciloneuron Beddome, J. Linn. Soc., Bot. 8:267, pl. 17 (1865).
Trees; hairs unicellular; stipuliform structures present; terminal bud perulate, colleters present or not; petiole base excavated; secondary veins distant, fine venation reticulate; inflorescences axillary or terminal, with 1–∞ flowers; sepals 4, decussate, or 5, imbricate; petals 6, ± imbricate, or 5, contorted; anthers 2.5–6 mm long, porose, locellate or not, eglandular; carpels 2, 2 ovules/carpel, stylodia free, long, stigma punctiform; fruit septicidal (?septifragal); testa complex, exotegmen absent, embryo 1–3 cm long, cotyledons huge, germination hypogeal or epigeal. Three species, Western Ghats of India; medium alt. P. pauciflorum Beddome very distinct, but poorly known. 9. Mesua L. Mesua L., Sp. Pl.: 515 (1753).
Trees; plant glabrous or hairs unicellular; terminal bud aborting, axillary buds immersed, colleters not obvious; secondary veins rather close, fine venation closely reticulate. Flowers single, axillary, or in 2–6-flowered axillary inflorescences; sepals 4, decussate, or 5, quincuncial; petals 4 or 5; anthers 1.5–4 mm long, with obscure glands in connective or not; carpels 2, 2 ovules/carpel, style long, stigma peltate; fruit septifragal, septae woody, persistent; testa complex, exotegmen absent, embryo 1.2–2.5 cm long, cotyledons huge, germination hypogeal. Five species, Sri Lanka and the Western Ghats of India (4 spp. only from there) to Sumatra; usually low alt. M. ferrea L. throughout the range, long introduced (and problematic taxonomically) in Java, widely cultivated elsewhere. 10. Kayea Wall. Kayea Wall., Pl. Asiat. Rar. 3:5, t. 10 (1832).
Tree; plant glabrous, but stem often papillate; terminal bud perulate, colleters present; secondary veins usually distant, fine venation closely reticulate. Inflorescences terminal and axillary, (1–)5–∞ flowers; sepals 4, decussate, outer pair connate or not; petals 4, aestivation various; anthers < 1 mm long, gland large or absent; carpels (3)4, 1–3 ovules/carpel, basal, septae not developed, style long, usually shortly divided at the apex, stigmas
59
punctate; fruit capsular, usually surrounded by massively accrescent calyx; testa complex, exotegmen absent, embryo > 5 mm long, cotyledons huge, (sub)peltate, germination hypogeal. Circa 75 species, many undescribed, one species in Sri Lanka, the rest northeast India to Australia; low (moderate) alt. Most diverse in western Malesia.
11. Mammea L. Mammea L., Sp. Pl.: 512 (1753). Paramammea Leroy (1977).
Trees, sometimes unbranched and schopfbaum; plant glabrous; terminal bud perulate; colleters present; leaves rarely spiral, secondary veins distant, fine venation reticulate, resin canals also rarely present; plant dioecious, inflorescences axillary, fasciculate; sepals 2, connate; petals 4–6, aestivation various; anthers 0.6–4 mm long, glands large and single, to small or absent; carpels 2(4), 2(4) ovules/carpel (ovary 8-locular), style short, stigma peltate; fruit a fibrous berry, rarely a septifragal capsule; testa complex, exotegmen absent, embryo ≤ 1.2 cm long, cotyledons massive, sometimes connate, germination hypogeal. Circa 75 species, many undescribed, 2 species in Central America, 3 species in Africa, the others from Madagascar (the center of diversity) to the Pacific and New Caledonia; low to medium alt. The plants appear to be andromonoecious.
12. Calophyllum L.
Fig. 13
Calophyllum L., Sp. Pl.: 513 (1753); Stevens, J. Arnold Arb. 61:117–699 (1980), rev.
Trees; hairs multicellular; terminal bud perulate or not, colleters absent; secondary veins closely parallel, alternating with canals, glands 0; inflorescences axillary, rarely terminal, (1–)3–∞ flowers, prophylls absent; sepals 4, decussate; petals like sepals, 0–8, aestivation various; anthers 0.4–2.5 mm long, gland absent; carpels ?2–?4, ovule single, basal, septae absent, style usually long, stigma moderately expanded to peltate; fruit a fibrous one-seeded berry; testa complex, exotegmen absent, embryo (3–)6 mm long, cotyledons massive; germination hypogeal. Circa 186 species, c. 10 species in the American tropics, the rest from Madagascar to the Pacific; low (moderate) alt.
60
P.F. Stevens
sate; petals 4, contorted; stamens 9–12/fascicle, filaments free; embryo ?1.5–2.2 cm long. One species, L. bushaie Staner, western tropical Africa; low alt. II. Subfam. Clusioideae Engler (1888). Plant usually glabrous; lamina with canals (glands), veins usually embedded; plant dioecious (flowers perfect); anthers usually lacking glands; filaments usually stout; style or stylodia short or none; cotyledons <1/10 length of embryo; phellogen in root superficial. II.1. Tribe Clusieae Choisy (1824).
Fig. 13. Clusiaceae. Calophyllum trachycaule. A Flowering branch. B Flower. C Stamen. D Pistil. E Fruit. (Lauterbach 1922)
I.2. Tribe Endodesmieae Engler (1921). Indumentum sparse, hairs unicellular; terminal bud not functional; stipuliform structures present; veins more or less embedded; androecium fasciculate, anthers < 1.1 mm long, lacking glands; ovary apparently 1-carpellate, ovule 1, apical, style long, slender, punctate; fruit a 1-seeded berry, pedicel more or less swollen; testa complex, exotegmen absent; embryo large, cotyledons massive (germination and position of root phellogen unknown). 13. Endodesmia Bentham Endodesmia Bentham in Bentham & Hooker f., Gen. Pl. 1:166 (1862).
Tree; lamina with elongated glands or short canals; inflorescences terminal, 5–∞ flowers, prophylls present; sepals 5, quincuncial; petals 5, contorted; stamens ∞/phalange, filaments connate; embryo 1–1.4 cm long. One species, E. calophylloidea Bentham, western tropical Africa; low alt.
Terminal bud eperulate; stipuliform structures absent; plants usually dioecious; androecium not obviously fasciculate or phalangiate; stylodia ± free, stigmas expanded, smooth; fruit septifragal; seeds arillate, exotegmen present (absent). 15. Clusia L.
Fig. 14
Clusia L., Sp. Pl.: 509 (1753); Vesque in C. DC., Monogr. Phanerog. 8:27–144 (1893); Engler in Nat. Pflanzenfam. ed. 2, 21:198–204 (1925). Quapoya Aublet (1775); Maguire, Mem. New York Bot. Gard. 23:192–193 (1972). Havetia Kunth (1821). Renggeria Meisn. (1837); Maguire, Mem. New York. Bot. Gard. 23:193–197 (1972). Havetiopsis Planchon & Triana (1860). Oedomatopus Planchon & Triana (1860). Pilosperma Planchon & Triana (1860). Decaphalangium Melchior (1930).
Trees, shrubs, epiphytes or lianes; petiole bases at most very slightly excavated; stamens sometimes connate, anthers also introrse, variable in morphology; 1–∞ ovules/carpel, sometimes stylodia +, or stigma with sharp or rounded papillae; exotegmen present, aril evascular; embryo green, less often white, 2–8 mm long; germination epigeal. Circa 300 species, Mexico to South America, the Caribbean; low (moderate) alt. The genus is poorly known; Vesque recognized 4 genera, and within Clusia, 4 subgenera and 9 sections; Engler placed all taxa in Clusia in 2 subgenera and 16 sections.
14. Lebrunia Staner
16. Dystovomita D’Arcy
Lebrunia Staner, Bull. Jard. Bot. Brux. 13:105 (1934).
Dystovomita (Engl.) D’Arcy, Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 65:694 (1979).
Tree; lamina with canals crossing fine veins but parallel to the secondary veins; inflorescences axillary, c. 10-flowered, prophylls 0; sepals 4, decus-
Trees; petiole bases very deeply excavated; inflorescence axillary; sepals not enclosing bud;
Clusiaceae-Guttiferae
61
garcinioid. Circa 25 species, Central and South America; low (moderate) alt. The genus needs revision. 18. Tovomitopsis Planchon & Triana Tovomitopsis Planchon & Triana, Ann. Sci. Nat. IV, Bot. 14: 261 (1860).
Tree; petiole bases not excavated; sepals 2, free; one ovule/carpel; stylodia free; seeds unknown. Circa 3 species, South America; low alt. The genus is very poorly known. 19. Chrysochlamys Poepp. Chrysochlamys Poepp. in Poepp. & Endl., Nov. Gen. Sp. 3: 13, t. 211 (1840). Balboa Planchon & Triana (1860).
Trees; petiole bases slightly to not excavated; inflorescences sometimes axillary; 1 ovule/carpel; testa
Fig. 14. Clusiaceae. Clusia (Decaphalangium peruvianum). A Flowering branch. B Flower seen from above. C Flower seen from beneath. D Anther, ventral view. E Vertical section of flower with rudimentary ovary and anther. (Melchior 1930)
1–2 ovules/carpel; aril evascular, testa sometimes moderately complex, exotegmen present; embryo c. 10 mm long; germination not known. Four species, Central and South America; low alt. 17. Tovomita Aublet
Fig. 15
Tovomita Aublet, Hist. Pl. Guiane 2:956, t. 364 (1775). Tovomitidium Ducke (1935).
Trees; basal internode of branches long; petiole bases moderately excavated or rarely not; sepals 2, connate or rarely free, enveloping bud; 1 ovule/carpel, stylodia sometimes as long as ovary; testa complex, exotegmen absent, aril vascularized; embryo 10–30 mm long; germination
Fig. 15. Clusiaceae. Tovomita brasiliensis. A Flowering branch. B Partial male inflorescence with one open flower. C Stamens and pistillode. D Part of infructescence, enlarged the coherent stylodia. E Dehisced fruit. F Seed. (Drawn by B. Angel; Mori 2002)
62
P.F. Stevens
complex or not, exotegmen absent, vascularized; embryo 8–20 mm long; germination epigeal. Circa 55 species, Central and South America, Caribbean (St. Lucia); low (moderate) alt. The genus needs revision. II.2. Tribe Garcinieae Choisy (1824). Terminal bud usually eperulate; stipuliform structures present or not, stout; plants usually dioecious; androecium in staminate flowers phalangiate; style simple, short or 0, stigma expanded, free or ± fused; fruit baccate; testa complex, exotegmen usually absent; embryo (0.4–)1 cm long, cotyledons < 1|10 its length. 20. Garcinia L.
Fig. 16
Garcinia L., Sp. Pl.: 443 (1753). Rheedia L. (1753). Ochrocarpos Noronha ex Du Petit-Thouars (1806). Tripetalum K. Schum. (1889). Pentaphalangium Warb. (1891). Septogarcinia Kostermans (1962).
Terminal bud eperulate, occasionally with perulae; glands sometimes also present, petiole bases usually strongly excavated; androecium sometimes not phalangiate, stamens connate or not, staminodia frequently present in pistillate flowers;
carpels 2–7(–c. 20), 1 ovule/carpel; fruit sometimes septifragal; exotegmen absent or rarely present and then the cells low; germination garcinioid (epigeal). Circa 260 species, pantropic, least diverse in America; low to medium alt. The anthers may sometimes be introrse, and the surface of the style varies considerably. 21. Allanblackia Oliver Allanblackia Oliver in Bentham & Hooker, Gen. Pl. 1:980 (1867); Bamps, Bull. Jard. Bot. Natl Belg. 39:347–357 (1969), rev.
Terminal bud perulate (?); petiole bases with slight excavations; stamens connate, anthers with small ‘glands’, staminodia present; carpels 5, placentation parietal, ovules 12–∞/carpel; exotegmen present, the cells tall; germination hypogeal. Nine species, Africa, Guinea and Zaire east to Tanzania; low alt. II.3. Tribe Symphonieae Choisy (1824). Terminal bud perulate, colleters usually absent; ± peltate stipuliform structures present; inflorescence terminal; flowers large, with short androgynophore; sepals 5, quincuncial, petals 5, contorted; androecium phalangiate, phalanges usually free, anthers introrse, staminodia common, usually free; carpels 5, 4–8 ovules/carpel, style simple, usually with 5 distal branches, stigma small, with apical aperture; fruit ± baccate; testa complex, exotegmen with tall cells, or 0; embryo > 1 cm long, cotyledons < 1|20 its length. 22. Pentadesma Sabine Pentadesma Sabine, Trans. Hort. Soc. 4:457 (1824); van Meer, Bull. Jard. Bot. Etat Brux. 35:411–433 (1965).
Inflorescence with 3–15 flowers; petals broad; ∞ stamens/fascicle, filaments smooth, only slightly connate, anthers 7–16 mm long, locellate; ∞ ovules/carpel; exotegmen absent; germination garcinioid. Five species, Mali to Zaire and Ruanda; low alt. 23. Moronobea Aublet Fig. 16. Clusiaceae. Garcinia hunsteinii. A Flowering branch. B Flower. C Male flower, perianth removed. D Two stamen fascicles. E Anther. F Pistil of female flower. G Stigma, seen from above. H Ovary, transversally sectioned. I Branchlet with two fruits, one of which vertically sectioned. J Seed. (Lauterbach 1922)
Moronobea Aublet, Hist. Pl. Guiane 2:788, t. 313 (1775).
Flowers single; petals usually broad, erect; 3–4 stamens/fascicle, spiral, filaments papillate, anthers 18–25 mm long, locellate; 3–10 ovules/carpel, style medium; exotegmen present; germination
Clusiaceae-Guttiferae
hypogeal. Seven species, Brazil, the Guyanas, Venezuela, Colombia; low to medium alt. 24. Platonia Mart.
63
papillate or not, anthers 4–20 mm long; 12–∞ ovules/carpel; exotegmen present; germination unknown. Five species, New Caledonia; low alt.
Fig. 17
Platonia Mart., Nov. Gen. Sp. 3:168, t. 289 (1829).
26. Lorostemon Ducke
Fig. 18
Flowers single; petals broad; ∞ stamens/fascicle, filaments papillate, anthers 8–11 mm long, ± locellate; ∞ ovules/carpel, style long; exotegmen absent, germination hypogeal. One species, P. insignis Mart., Guyanas, Brazil; low alt.
Lorostemon Ducke, Arq. Int. Biol. Veg. Rio de Janeiro 1:210 (1935).
Montrouziera Planchon & Triana, Ann. Sci. Nat. IV, Bot. 14:292 (1860).
Flowers single; petals narrow; 3–13 stamens/fascicle, filaments papillate or not, anthers 10–40 mm long; ovary long-stipitate or not, 12–∞ ovules/carpel; style not branched; exotegmen usually present; germination not known. Five species, South America; low (moderate) alt. Poorly known.
Inflorescence with 1–5 flowers, sometimes axillary; petals broad; 3–10 stamens/fascicle, filaments
27. Thysanostemon Maguire
25. Montrouziera Planchon & Triana
Thysanostemon Maguire, Mem. New York Bot. Gard. 10:132 (1964).
Fig. 17. Clusiaceae. Platonia insignis. A Flower buds. B Flower in anthesis. C Flower with perianth removed, showing phalanges and style with style branches. D Vegetative branch tip. E Two fruits, in one the pericarp partly removed. F Seed. (Cavalcante 1972)
Fig. 18. Clusiaceae. Lorostemon bombaciflorum. A Flowering branch. B Flower. C Stamen fascicle, ventral and dorsal view. D Pistil. E Ovary, transversally sectioned. F Fruit. G Seed. (Ducke 1935)
64
P.F. Stevens
Stipuliform stuctures not seen; flowers single; petals narrow; 4–6 stamens/fascicle, filaments papillate, anthers 8–9 mm long; c. 4 ovules/carpel; exotegmen absent; germination not known. Two species, Venezuela; low to moderate alt. Poorly known.
ovules/carpel; testa fibrous, exotegmen absent; germination garcinioid. Circa 23 species, tropical America, Africa, most diverse in Madagascar, S. globulifera L. f. widespread and variable; low to medium alt.
28. Symphonia L. f.
Selected Bibliography
Fig. 19
Symphonia L. f., Suppl.: 49 & 303 (1781); H. Perrier, Fl. Madag. Comores 135e & 136e fam.: 13–31 (1951).
Inflorescences with 3–9 flowers (axillary); petals broad; androgynophore absent; fascicles connate, 3–6 stamens/fascicle, filaments smooth, anthers 1.7–5 mm long, extrorse, connective with glands, a low annular nectary outside androecium; 4–8
Fig. 19. Clusiaceae. Symphonia globulifera. A Flowering branch. B Flower. C Flower with petals removed. D Same with perianth and most of staminal tube removed. E As D, but showing ovary in transversal section. F Fruit. G Seed. (Robson 1961)
Anderberg, A.A., Rydin, C., Källersjö, M. 2002. Phylogenetic relationships in the order Ericales s.l.: analyses of molecular data from five genes from the plastid and mitochondrial genomes. Amer. J. Bot. 89:677–687. Armbruster, W.S. 1984. The role of resin in angiosperm pollination: ecological and chemical considerations. Amer. J. Bot. 71:1149–1160. Baretta-Kuipers, T. 1976. Comparative wood anatomy of Bonnetiaceae, Theaceae and Guttiferae. In: Baas, P., Bolton, A.M., Catling, D.M. (eds), Wood structure in biological and technological research. Leiden Botanical Series 3, pp. 76–101. Barth, O.M. 1980. Morfologia do pólen e palinotaxinomia do género Kielmeyera (Guttiferae). Rodriguesia 32, 55:105–133. Bennett, G.J., Lee, H.-H. 1989. Xanthones from Guttiferae. Phytochemistry 28:967–998. Bittrich, V., Amaral, M. do C.E. 1996. Flower morphology and pollination biology of some Clusia species from the Gran Sabana (Venezuela). Kew Bull. 51:681–694. Bittrich, V., Amaral, M. do C.E. 1997. Flower biology of some Clusia species from Central Amazonia. Kew Bull. 52:617–635. Brandza, G. 1908. Recherches anatomiques sur la germination des Hypéricacées et des Guttifères. Ann. Sci. Nat. IX, Bot. 8:221–300, pls 5–15. Carmo, R.M., Franceschinelli, E.V. 2002. Pollinação e biologia floral de Clusia arrudea Planchon & Triana (Clusiaceae) na Serra da Calçada, município de Brumadinho, MG. Revista Brasil. Bot. 25:351–360. Carr, G.D., McPherson, G. 1986. Chromosome numbers of New Caledonian plants. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 73:486–489. Cavalcante, P.B. 1972. Frutas comestiveis da Amazônia, I. Belém, Pará: Museu Paraense Museu Goeldi. Chase, M.W. et al. 2003. See general references. Chennaveeraiah, M.S., Radzan, M.K. 1980. Karyomorphological and phytochemical studies in evaluating species relationships in Garcinia L. and systematic position of the G. xanthochymus complex. J. Indian Bot. Soc. 59:251–262. Corner, E.J.H. 1976. See general references. Correia, M.C.R., Ormond, W.T., Pinheiro, M.C.B., De Lima, H.A. 1993. Estudo de biologia floral de Clusia criuva Camb. Um caso de mimetismo. Bradea 6:209–219. Crepet, W.L., Nixon, K.C. 1998. Fossil Clusiaceae from the Late Cretaceous (Turonian) of New Jersey and implications regarding the history of bee pollination. Amer. J. Bot. 85:1122–1133. Croat, T.B. 1978. Flora of Barro Colorado Island. Stanford: Stanford University Press. Cronquist, A. 1981. See general references.
Clusiaceae-Guttiferae da Cruz, N.D., Sellito Boaventura, V.M., Sellito, Y.M. 1990. Cytological studies on some species of the genus Clusia L. (Guttiferae). Revista Brasil. Genet. 13:335–345. Davis, C.R., Chase, M.C. 2004. Elatinaceae are sister to Malpighiaceae; Peridiscaceae belong to Saxifragales. Amer. J. Bot. 91:262–274. Delay, C., Mangenot, G. 1960. Le développement de la graine chez Allanblackia floribunda Oliv. Ann. Sci. Nat. XII, Bot. 1:387–440. Delle Monache, F., Delle Monache, G., Gáes-Baitz, E. 1991. Chemistry of the Clusia genus. Part 6. Prenylated benzophenones from Clusia sandiensis. Phytochemistry 30:2003–2005. Dick, C.W., Abdul-Salim, K., Bermingham, E. 2003. Molecular systematic analysis reveals cryptic Tertiary diversification of a widespread tropical rain forest tree. Amer. Naturalist 162:691–703. Ducke, A. 1935. Plantes nouvelles ou peu connues de la région amazonienne (VIIème série). Arq. Inst. Biol. Veg. Rio de Janeiro 1:205–212. Dunthorn, M.S. 2002. Anatomy and palynology of Mammea L. (Clusiaceae). M.Sc. Thesis, University of Missouri, St. Louis. Dunthorn, M.S. 2004. Cryptic dioecy in Mammea (Clusiaceae). Pl. Syst. Evol. 249:191–196. Engler, A. 1888. Guttiferae and Quiinaceae. In: Urban, I. (ed.) Flora Brasiliensis, vol. 12, 1. Leipzig: Fleischer, pp. 382–486, pls 79–110. Engler, A. 1925. Guttiferae. In: Engler, A., Prantl, K., Die natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien, ed. 2, vol. 21. Leipzig: W. Engelmann, pp. 154–237. Erbar, C. 1986. Untersuchungen zur Entwicklung der spiraligen Blüte von Stewartia pseudocamellia (Theaceae). Bot. Jahrb. Syst. 106:391–407. Exell, A.W., Robson, N.K.B. 1960. New species of Polygala and Garcinia from tropical Africa. Bol. Soc. Brot. II, 34:93–97. Field, B.S. 1978. Theaceae. In: Heywood, V.H. (ed.) Flowering plants of the world. New York: Mayflower Press, pp. 82–83. Fosberg, F.R. 1977. A fossil Garcinia fruit from the New Hebrides, Melanesia. Pacific Sci. 31:293–297. Gonçalves-Esteves, V., Mendonça, C.B.F. 2001. Estudo polínico em plantas de restinga do Estado do Rio de Janeiro – Clusiaceae Lindl. Revista Brasil. Bot. 24:527–536. Gustafsson, M.H.G. 2000. Floral morphology and relationships of Clusia gundlachii with a discussion of floral organ identity and diversity on the genus Clusia. Intl J. Pl. Sci. 161:43–53. Gustafsson, M.H.G., Bittrich, V. 2002. Evolution of morphological diversity and resin secretion in flowers of Clusia (Clusiaceae): insights from ITS sequence variation. Nordic J. Bot. 22:183–203. Gustafsson, M.H.G., Bittrich, V., Stevens, P.F. 2002. Phylogeny of Clusiaceae based on rbcL sequences. Intl J. Pl. Sci. 163:1045–1054. Hegnauer, R. 1966. See general references. Jones, S.J. 1980. Morphology and major taxonomy of Garcinia (Guttiferae). Ph.D. Thesis, University of Leicester. Kawano, S. 1965. Anatomical studies on the androecia of some members of the Guttiferae – Moronoboideae. Bot. Mag. Tokyo 78:97–108.
65
Kubitzki, K. 1978. Caraipa and Mahurea (Bonnetiaceae). In: Maguire, B. and Collaborators, The botany of the Guyana Highlands, part X, pp. 82–138. Mem. New York Bot. Gard. 29:1–832. Kubitzki, K. 1989. The ecogeographical differentiation of Amazonian inundation-forests. Pl. Syst. Evol. 162:285– 304. Kubitzki, K., Mesquita, A.A.L., Gottlieb, O.R. 1978. Chemosystematic implications of xanthones in Bonnetia and Archytaea. Biochem. Syst. Ecol. 6:185–187. La Mensbruge, G. de 1966. La germination et les plantules des essences arborées de la fôret dense humide de la Côte d’Ivoire. Nogent-sur-Marne: Centre Technique Forestier Tropical. Lauterbach, C. 1922. Beiträge zur Flora von Papuasien. IX. Die Guttiferen Papuasiens. Bot. Jahrb. Syst. 58:1–49. Lim, A.L. 1984. The embryology of Garcinia mangostana L. (Clusiaceae). Gard. Bull. Singapore 37:93–103. Lopes, A.V., Machado, I.C. 1998. Floral biology and reproductive ecology of Clusia nemorosa (Clusiaceae) in northeastern Brazil. Pl. Syst. Evol. 213:71–90. Lüttge, U. 1999. One morphotype, three physiotypes: sympatric species of Clusia with obligate C3 photosynthesis, obligate CAM, and C3-CAM intermediate behavior. Pl. Biol. 1:138–148. Lüttge, U. 2002. The genus Clusia L.: molecular evidence for independent evolution of photosynthetic flexibility. Pl. Biol. 4:86–93. Maguire, B. 1972. Bonnetiaceae and Tetrameristaceae. In: Maguire, B. and Collaborators, The botany of the Guyana Highlands, part IX, pp. 131–192. Mem. New York Bot. Gard. 23:1–832. Maguire, B. 1976. Apomixis in the genus Clusia (Clusiaceae) – a preliminary report. Taxon 25:241–244. Maués, M.M., Venturieri, G.C. 1996. Ecologia de polinização do Bacurizeiro (Platonia insignis Mart.) Clusiaceae. Bol. Pesquisa 170:1–24. McKee, A.C., Covington, C.D., Fuller, R.W., Bokesch, H.R., Young, S., Cardellina, J.H. II, Kadushin, M.R., Soejarto, D.D., Stevens, P.F., Cragg, G.M., Boyd, M.R. 1996. Pyranocoumarins from tropical species of the genus Calophyllum: a chemotaxonomic study of extracts in the National Cancer Institute collection. J. Nat. Prod. 61:1252–1256. Melchoir, H. 1930. Decaphalangium, eine neue Gattung der Guttiferen aus Peru. Notizbl. Bot. Gart. Mus. BerlinDahlem 10:946–950. Mesquita, R. de C.G., Franciscon, C.H. 1995. Flower visitors of Clusia nemorosa G.F.W. Meyer (Clusiaceae) in an Amazonian white-sand campina. Biotropica 27:254– 257. Metcalfe, C.R., Chalk, L. 1950. See general references. Mori, S.A., Cremers, G., Gracie, C., de Granville, J.J., Heald, S.V. et al. 2002. Guide to the vascular plants of central French Guiana. Part 2. Dicotyledons. Mem. New York Bot. Gard. 76, 2:1–900. Mourão, K.S.M., Beltrati, C.M. 1996a. Morfologia dos frutos, sementes e plântulas de Platonia insignis Mart. (Clusiaceae). I. Aspectos anatômicos dos frutos e sementes em desenvolvimento. Acta Amazonia 25:11–31. Manaus: Instituto Nacional de Pesquisas da Amazônia. Mourão, K.S.M., Beltrati, C.M. 1996b. Morfologia dos frutos, sementes e plântulas de Platonia insignis Mart.
66
P.F. Stevens
(Clusiaceae). II. Morfo-anatomia dos frutos e sementes maduros. Acta Amazonia 25:33–46. Manaus: Instituto Nacional de Pesquisas da Amazônia. Mourão, K.S.M., Beltrati, C.M. 2000. Morphology and anatomy of developing fruits and seeds of Mammea americana L. (Clusiaceae). Revista Brasil. Biol. 60:701–711. Muller, J. 1981. Fossil pollen records of extant angiosperms. Bot. Rev. 47:1–142. Müller-Stoll, W.R., Mädel-Angeliewa, E. 1986. Ein neues Guttiferenholz aus dem Tertiär von Java, Calophylloxylon intermedium sp. nov. Feddes Repert. 97:225–233. Nogueira, P.C. de L., Marsaioli, A.J., Amaral, M. do C.E., Bittrich, V. 1998. The fragrant oils of Tovomita species. Phytochemistry 49:1009–1112. Notis, C. 2004. Phylogeny and character evolution of Kielmeyeroideae (Clusiaceae) based on molecular and morphological data. M.Sc. Thesis, University of Florida, Gainesville. Oliveira, P.E.A.M. de, Sazima, K. 1990. Pollination biology of two species of Kielmeyera (Guttiferae) from Brazilian cerrado vegetation. Pl. Syst. Evol. 172:35–49. Oliveira, C.M.A., Porto, A.L.M., Bittrich, V., Vencato, I., Marsaioli, A.J. 1996. Floral resins of Clusia spp.: chemical composition and biological function. Tetrahedron Lett. 37:6427–6430. Owen, P.T., Scheinmann, F. 1974. Extractives from Guttiferae, XXVI. Isolation and extraction of six xanthones, a biflavanoid, and triterpenoids from the heartwood of Pentaphalangium solomonse [sic]. J. Chem. Soc. Perkins Trans. 1 1974:1018–1021. Pascarella, J.B. 1992. Notes on flowering phenology, nectar robbing, and pollination of Symphonia globulifera L. f. (Clusiaceae) in a lowland rain forest in Costa Rica. Brenesia 38:83–96. Passos, L., Oliveira, P.S. 2002. Ants affect the distribution and performance of seedlings of Clusia criuva, a primarily bird-dispersed rain forest tree. J. Ecol. 90:517– 528. Paula, J.E. de 1976. Anatomia de Lorostemon coelhoi Paula, Caraipa valioli Paula e Clusia aff. macropoda Klotzsch (Guttiferae da Amazônica). Acta Amazonia 6:273–291. Manaus: Instituto Nacional de Pesquisas da Amazônia. Perrier de la Bâthie, H. 1951. 136e famille Guttifères (Guttiferae). In: Humbert, H. (ed.) Flore de Madagascar et des Comores. Paris: Firmin-Didot. Petterson, S., Ervik, F., Knudsen, J.T. 2004. Floral scent of bat-pollinated species: West Africa vs. the New World. Biol. J. Linn. Soc. 82:161–168. Pierre, J.B.L. 1883–1885. Flore forestière de la Cochinchine, fasc. 5-7. Paris: Octave Doin. Planchon, J.E., Triana, J. 1860. Mémoire sur la famille des Guttifères. Ann. Sci. Nat. IV, Bot. 13:306–376, pls 15, 16. Planchon, J.E., Triana, J. 1862. Ibid. Ann. Sci. Nat. IV, Bot. 16:263–308. Porto, A.M., Machado, S.M.F., Oliveira, C.M.A., Bittrich, V., Amaral, M.C.E., Marsaioli, A.J. 2000. Polyisoprenylated benzophenones from Clusia floral resins. Phytochemistry 55:755–768. Presting, D., Straka, H., Friedrich, B. 1983. Palynologica Madagassica et Mascarenica. Familien 128 bis 146. Trop.-subtrop. Pflanzenwelt 44, 93 pp. Mainz: F. Steiner.
Ramirez, B.W., Gomez, P.L.D. 1978. Production of nectar and gums by flowers of Monstera deliciosa (Araceae) and some species of Clusia (Guttiferae) collected by New World Trigona bees. Brenesia 14–15:407–412. Ramji, M.V. 1967. Morphology and ontogeny of the foliar venation of Calophyllum inophyllum L. Austral. J. Bot. 15:437–443. Richards, A.J. 1990a. Studies in Garcinia, dioecious tropical forest trees: agamospermy. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 103:233– 250. Richards, A.J. 1990b. Studies in Garcinia, dioecious tropical forest trees: the phenology, pollination biology and fertilization of G. hombroniana Pierre. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 103:251–261. Richards, A.J. 1990c. Studies in Garcinia, dioecious tropical forest trees: the origin of the mangosteen (G. mangostana L.). Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 103:301–308. Robson, N.K.B. 1961. Guttiferae. In: Exell, A.W., Wild, H. (eds) Flora Zambesiaca, vol. 1, 2. London: Crown Agents for Oversea Governments and Administrations, pp. 378–404. Robson, N.K.B. 1978. Guttiferae. In: Heywood, V.H. (ed.) Flowering plants of the world. New York: Mayflower Books, pp. 85–87. Rodrigues, C.M.C., Teixeira Osmond, W., Pinheiro, M.C.B., Lima, H.A. de 1999. Biologia de reprodução de Clusia lanceolata Camb. Hohnea 26:61–73. Saddi, N. 1989. Comparative external morphological study in the genus Kielmeyera Martius (Guttiferae). Publ. Avuls. Herb. Central 2, Cuiabá. Schlechter, R. 1906. Beiträge zur Flora von Neu-Kaledonien. Bot. Jahrb. Syst. 39:1–274. Schofield, E.K. 1968. Petiole anatomy of the Guttiferae and related families. Mem. New York Bot. Gard. 18:1–55. Seetharam, Y.N. 1985. Clusiaceae: palynology and systematics. Institut Franç. Pondichéry: Travaux de la section Scientifique et Technique, t. 21. Seetharam, Y.N., Maheshwari, J.K. 1986. Scanning electron microscopic studies on the pollen of some Clusiaceae. Proc. Indian Acad. Sci. (Pl. Sci.) 96:217–226. Spruce, R. 1855. Note on Clusiaceae. Hooker’s J. Bot. Kew Gard. Misc. 7:347–348. Stevens, P.F. 1980. A revision of the Old World species of Calophyllum (Guttiferae). J. Arnold Arb. 61:117–699. Stevens, P.F. 2005. See general references. Stevens, P.F., Weitzman, A.L. 2004. Sladeniaceae. In: Kubitzki, K. (ed.) The Families and Genera of Vascular Plants. VI. Flowering Plants: Dicotyledons: Celastrales, Oxalidales, Rosales, Cornales, Ericales. Berlin Heidelberg New York: Springer, pp. 431–433. Stevens, P.F., Dressler, S., Weitzman, A.L. 2004. Theaceae. In: Kubitzki, K. (ed.) The Families and Genera of Vascular Plants. VI. Flowering Plants: Dicotyledons: Celastrales, Oxalidales, Rosales, Cornales, Ericales. Berlin Heidelberg New York: Springer, pp. 473–471. Taylor, H.L., Brooker, R.M. 1969. Isolation of uliginosin A and uliginosin B from Hypericum uliginosum. Lloydia 32:217–219. Vesque, J. 1889. Epharmosis, sive materiae ad instruendam anatomiam systematis naturalis. 2. Genitalia foliaque Garcinearum et Calophyllearum. Vincennes: Delapierre.
Combretaceae Combretaceae R. Br., Prodr.: 351 (1810), nom. cons.
C.A. Stace
Trees, shrubs, subshrubs or lianes, sometimes mangroves, rarely spiny. Indumentum almost always of unicellular, slender, thick-walled, pointed hairs with a distinctive basal compartment (‘Combretaceous hairs’) alone or with glandular hairs of one (or rarely both) of two types – short, capitate stalked glands, and subsessile peltate scales. Leaves opposite (or whorled) or spiral, petiolate, simple, entire, with pinnate venation, often with a pair of petiolar glands or domatia; stipules 0 or vestigial. Inflorescence axillary or terminal, capitate to expanded, of simple or paniculate spikes or less often racemes. Flowers with simple, usually caducous bracts, bisexual, or bisexual and male in same inflorescence, or rarely dioecious, 4- to 5-merous, actinomorphic, or sometimes weakly zygomorphic, epigynous or rarely semi-epigynous; hypanthium (receptacle) surrounding ovary (lower hypanthium) and extended beyond into saucer- to tube-shaped upper hypanthium, with 2 prophylls fused to lower hypanthium in Laguncularieae; sepals 4–5(–8), borne at tip of upper hypanthium, sometimes vestigial, rarely accrescent; petals 4–5, usually borne at or near tip of upper hypanthium, often small, sometimes conspicuous, or often 0; stamens usually twice as many as sepals (rarely to 16), borne inside upper hypanthium usually at two levels, sometimes as many as sepals, rarely second whorl represented by staminodes, exserted or included, with dorsifixed, usually versatile, rarely adnate, 4-locular anthers; nectariferous disk often present at base of upper hypanthium; ovary 1-locular; ovules (1)2–7(–20) (usually 2), apical, pendulous, anatropous, bitegmic, crassinucellate; style simple, with usually punctiform stigma. Fruit 1-seeded, indehiscent or rarely tardily dehiscent, with dry or spongy to succulent wall, often with 2–5 papery to leathery wings; endosperm absent in mature seed; cotyledons usually 2(–5) or fused to appear 1, variously folded or twisted in seed, rarely flat or hemispherical.
A pantropical family with 14 genera and c. 500 species. Characters of Rare Occurrence. Mangroves: Lumnitzera, Laguncularia (Conocarpus mangrove-associate) Branches spiny: Terminalia (former Bucida), some Combretum Semi-inferior ovary: Strephonema Slightly zygomorphic flowers: some Combretum (including former Calopyxis), Lumnitzera littorea, Dansiea Dioecious flowers: Combretum rupicola, Conocarpus (± so), Laguncularia (± so) Andromonoecious flowers: many Terminalia, Pteleopsis Markedly accrescent calyx: Calycopteris Only one whorl of stamens: Terminalia tetrandra, some Combretum (former Thiloa and Meiostemon) Staminodes representing one whorl of stamens: Combretum gracile, some flowers of the variably dioecious species and of Lumnitzera littorea Stamens with adnate anthers: Buchenavia Ovules often more than 8: Macropteranthes, Dansiea Tardily dehiscent fruits: Combretum (former Quisqualis) Fruit-wings derived from prophylls: Macropteranthes, Dansiea Cotyledons flat, not folded: Strephonema, Combretum sects. Cacoucia (some) and Calopyxis (some) Cotyledons fused: some Combretum Three or more cotyledons: some Terminalia Vegetative Morphology. All species of Combretaceae are woody, varying from tall timber trees or lianes (mostly in forest) to short shrubs or subshrubs (in savannah). A few species possess stem thorns. In the fire-prone savannahs of Africa and India, there are about 20 species of subshrub in the genus Combretum: plants with large underground ‘trunks’ putting up annual aerial shoots
68
C.A. Stace
which are burnt to the ground during the dry season. These species belong to four different sections of the genus (Keay 1950), in two cases together with forest scandent shrub and liane species, and in the other two cases together with savannah tree and shrub species. Some of the shrubs develop into lianes or ‘scrambling shrubs’ if left ungrazed and provided with a support. The lianes often climb over 30 m high, especially in the genus Combretum, while the smallest subshrubs do not exceed 20 cm. Combretum species are mostly subshrubs, shrubs or lianes, with very few trees (exceptionally, C. leprosum and C. glaucocarpum up to 25 m in Brazil). The largest trees are over 50 m tall and are found in the genera Terminalia and Buchenavia; buttresses are present in several species. Corner (1940) described the characteristic ‘pagoda-trees’ of Malaya, belonging to nine different families, in which the main branches are held in horizontal tiers with the leaves in flat bunches dispersed over the top side of each tier. This growth habit is so characteristic of several species of Terminalia (notably, T. catappa) that Corner termed the sympodial branching pattern which gives rise to it as “Terminalia-branching”. Two genera are true mangroves: Lumnitzera from East Africa to Australia and Laguncularia in West Africa and East and West America. Both develop characteristic pneumatophores – in Lumnitzera, these are looped above the mud (‘knee-roots’) whereas in Laguncularia they are simple or branched projections from the mud
Fig. 20. Combretaceae. Old specimen of Conocarpus erectus in a dune-valley of Peninsula de Paraguaná, Caribbean. (Phototograph K. Kubitzki)
(‘peg-roots’). Fruit-vivipary is, however, scarcely exhibited; in Laguncularia, the radicle is reported barely to pierce the seed-coat while the fruit is still on the tree. In addition, Conocarpus erectus, with a distribution similar to Laguncularia, is often considered a mangrove, but its lack of vivipary or pneumatophores suggests that it is best considered a ‘mangrove-associate’ (Fig. 20). Some Terminalia species are also mangrove-associates. Terminalia cuneata (India) is not one of these, but it sometimes produces erect pneumatophore-like aerial roots when the root-system is submerged (Adamson 1910). The leaves of Combretaceae are evergreen or deciduous, according to the vegetation type the plants inhabit. In some genera, notably Buchenavia, they are clustered in dense spirals at the swollen tips of twigs. A pair of sessile secretory glands is present in many species, particularly Terminalia, Buchenavia, Laguncularia and Conocarpus; their presence and position are of diagnostic value. Klucking (1991) presented an extensive survey of leaf venation in the family, providing many excellent illustrations, covering 11 genera and 223 species. His study, however, lacks an analytical element and, in several cases, specimens under different names for the same species (e.g. Terminalia amazonia and T. obovata) fell into different categories of venation pattern. Alwan (1983) covered 144 species in all 13 genera. Using the terminology of Hickey (1973), he recognized six major types within this broad pattern, five of them representing grades from brochidodromous to eucamptodromus, and the sixth being craspedodromous. There seems to be no taxonomic correlation of these types as high as genus level; all six types occur in Terminalia, and craspedodromous only in that genus. Many species bear foliar domatia – small pocket- or bowl-shaped pits in the axils of the main lateral leaf-veins on the lower leaf surface; they are particularly common in Terminalia, Buchenavia and Conocarpus, in which their presence and structure are species-constant. Pocket-shaped (‘marsupiiform’) domatia occur widely in Combretinae and Terminaliinae, but bowl-shaped (‘lebetiform’) ones are found only in the above three genera of Terminaliinae. In Strephonema, the leaves have marginal revolute domatia. Stipules are said in all floristic accounts to be absent from Combretaceae. Weberling, in Dahlgren
Combretaceae
and Thorne (1984), stated that they are present in “nearly all families of Myrtales”, although in Combretaceae he found them only as tiny “rudimentary finger-like projections” near the petiole base and only in a few of the species examined. Vegetative Anatomy. Leaves are usually dorsiventral, with no hypodermis but with 1–2 adaxial palisade layers and a broader spongy mesophyll (Tilney 2002). In the mangroves Laguncularia and Lumnitzera, in the related Macropteranthes and Dansiea to a slight degree (abaxial palisade weakly developed), in the mangrove-associate Conocarpus, and in a few other scattered taxa, the leaves have an isobilateral organization, with palisade on both sides and a central large-celled water-storage tissue; this is clearly an anatomical syndrome correlated with physiological drought (Stace 1966). Midrib structure is described by Keating (1984) and Tilney (2002). Stomata are usually present only on the lower epidermis, but are on both upper and lower surfaces in the species with fully isobilateral leaves and also in some species of Terminalia and other genera with coriaceous dorsiventral leaves. Stomata are basically anomocytic throughout the family, except in Strephonema where they are paracytic (Stace 1965). In the mangroves Lumnitzera and Laguncularia, the anomocytic stomata are cyclocytic. The trichomes of the Combretaceae are diagnostic. Non-glandular hairs are almost always in the form of ‘Combretaceous hairs’ – unicellular, pointed, very thick-walled hairs (leaving virtually no lumen) which possess a distinctive, often swollen basal compartment. Apart from Strephonema, these occur in all species (over 300) examined to date, except for the apparently completely glabrous Lummitzera littorea (but they do occur in L. racemosa). In Strephonema, they occur in S. mannii but not in the other two species (S. sericeum and S. pseudocola), where only 2armed thin-walled hairs usually with a basal compartment, as well as some intermediate forms, are present (Stace 1965). The 2-armed hairs were described by Heiden (1893) from Conocarpus, but I have been unable to confirm this. A few (taxonomically scattered) species possess some simple thin-walled hairs, among a predominance of Combretaceous hairs. Combretaceous hairs have elsewhere been reported only from a few Myrtaceae and Cistaceae (Solereder 1908). Glandular trichomes are of two main types: glandular hairs with a short uniseriate stalk (rarely
69
longer and multiseriate) and clavate or capitate head; and peltate scales, with a very short uniseriate stalk and a 1-cell-thick plate-like head consisting of eight to a few hundred cells (Fig. 24; Stace 1965). One or other type (extremely rarely both) is present in every species of all genera of subtribe Combretinae. The presence of these glandular trichomes, and the cell-delimitation of the scales, are extremely important taxonomic characters in this subtribe. Dome-shaped sessile glandular structures are found in Laguncularia at the base of deep, narrow-orificed pits found on both leaf surfaces, usually visible as a mound on the leaf surface. The superficially similar pits on the lower epidermis of Conocarpus do not contain glands and are best considered as domatia. In the latter genus, however, small stalked glands occur sparsely on both leaf surfaces; these resemble those of the Combretinae but they are perhaps related to the saline habitat of Conocarpus. In young twigs, the vascular bundles are bicollateral in almost all species examined (Dahlgren and Thorne 1984; Tilney 2002). Phloem islands (‘included phloem’) are present in the wood of only four of the six genera studied of subtribe Combretinae (van Vliet 1979). den Outer and Fundter (1976) found that both the periderm and the secondary phloem of Strephonema resemble those of the rest of the family in many characters, but differ in having type I sieve-tubes (types II or III in other genera) with longer elements than in all other genera. The sieve-tube element plastids are S-type throughout the family, as in the rest of Myrtales (Behnke 1984). Wood anatomy has been thoroughly surveyed by van Vliet (1979) and van Vliet and Raven (1984). Growth-rings are distinct or not, the wood being usually diffuse- but sometimes ring-porous, with parenchyma mostly paratracheal but often apotracheal or marginal, the first type varying from scanty to confluent-banded. Hence, virtually the whole spectrum of possibilities is covered. More interesting or unusual characters are the vestured pits, fibre-tracheids, radial vessels, ray-types, vessels of two distinct sizes, and included phloem. Strephonema differs from the other genera in having distinct aggregates (tangential bands) of apotracheal parenchyma, heterocellular rays of types II–III, vestured pits of type A (type B in rest of family) and fibre-tracheids (fibres with distinctly bordered pits, absent from rest of family). Subtribe Combretinae (all species examined) is characterized by two characters absent from the rest of the
70
C.A. Stace
family: vessels of two very distinct diameters, and uniseriate rays containing radial vessels with perforations in their tangential walls, those in the terminal elements connecting with very narrow axial vessels or tracheids. These radial vessels are, in fact, unique among all plants. Anatomy of the peg-roots of Laguncularia is described by Jeník (1970), and of normal roots of Combretum by Verhoeven and van der Schijff (1974). Inflorescence Structure. Weberling (1988) described the inflorescences as “polytelic throughout”, i.e. with indefinite growth, the inflorescence lacking a terminal flower. The commonest type of inflorescence is the spike, occurring in most genera including the two largest, Combretum and Terminalia (Figs. 22–24). Usually, the flowers are more or less sessile but in some cases they are shortly pedicellate, conspicuously so in Strephonema and Pteleopsis, forming a raceme. In most cases, the bracts are small and caducous but sometimes they persist and occasionally are large and conspicuous, presumably to attract pollinators, e.g. red in Combretum mussaendiflorum, white in C. racemosum. Variations occur in two directions. Firstly, the spikes (or racemes) are often branched, sometimes forming quite large compound spikes/racemes; this is common in several genera, including Combretum, but rare or absent in others, e.g. Terminalia and Buchenavia respectively. Secondly, the spikes may be congested (Exell 1962), in extreme cases forming apparent umbels (e.g. many Combretum, Guiera, some Terminalia, Pteleopsis) or cone-like structures (Conocarpus, Anogeissus, Finetia). Flower Structure. The common flower organization in the family includes an inferior 1-celled ovary with (1)2–7(–20) apical ovules leading to a 1seeded fruit and a tetramerous or pentamerous perianth with both 1-whorled calyx and corolla and an androecium of 1 or 2 stamen whorls. The hypanthium is usually divided into two parts: a lower one surrounding and fused to the ovary, and sometimes extended above it as a stalk-like support for the next (or the latter might be part of the next), and an upper one extended above it and bearing the sepals, petals and stamens. In Laguncularieae, there is scarcely any distinction between an upper and lower hypanthium. In Dansiea, the lower hypanthium is fused to the ovary only on one side.
Variation from this pattern is in four main directions: (1) loss of petals in virtually all Terminaliinae and some Combretinae; (2) loss of one whorl of stamens in some Combretum (former Thiloa, where the missing whorl is replaced by staminodes in 1/3 species, and former Meiostemon) and Terminalia tetrandra (former Terminaliopsis); (3) elaboration of the upper hypanthium into an attractive campanulate to tubular structure in some Combretum; and (4) a trend towards unisexuality – the plants andromonoecious in Terminalia and Pteleopsis, and flowers/plants variably bisexual, monoecious or dioecious (probably mainly functionally dioecious) in Conocarpus, Laguncularia and Combretum rupicola. The petals are rarely large and attractive; exceptions are a few Combretum species and Lumnitzera. In some Combretum, it is the antepetalous stamens which are missing (Stace 1968) whereas in other Combretum and Terminalia tetrandra it is the antesepalous ones (Capuron 1967). In two of the three species of Combretum sect. Thiloa, there are glandular outgrowths (caruncles) on the connectives. In some taxa, e.g. Lumnitzera littorea, variable numbers of stamens are aborted or sterile, giving a total of 5–10 functional ones. In most taxa, the disk is a continuous ring of nectariferous tissue at the base of the upper hypanthium, but sometimes it is vestigial or absent. In Lumnitzera littorea, the ring is broken at the most ventral point, where the stamen is usually lacking. In Dansiea, the nectary is reduced to a bilobed outgrowth only on the dorsal side. The style is adnate to the upper hypanthium for various distances in Lumnitzera littorea and some Combretum (including former Quisqualis). In Strephonema, the flowers are only semiepigynous, the lower hypanthium extending less than halfway up the ovary and the upper hypanthium arising from it at that point as a short ‘calyxtube’, and bearing the sepals, petals and stamens (Fig. 21). Floral anatomy, particularly vascular architecture, was treated by Venkateswarlu and Rao (1970). The pattern in Lumnitzera, with three traces to each sepal, was considered ancestral to the situation in Combretinae and Terminaliinae, with only one trace to each. Moreover, Lumnitzera has 8 traces in the style, said to represent the ancestral polycarpellary state, whereas the rest of the family have 2–5, and it was the only genus studied to have traces to the nectariferous disk. Subsequent work by Fukuoka et al. (1986) did not wholly confirm these earlier findings, and they concluded that
Combretaceae
Lumnitzera represents a separate line of development, rather than an ancestral state. Embryology. Male and female embryological details have been summarized by Tobe and Raven (1983); seven genera have been examined. Virtually all details agree with the common situation in the Myrtales (see family description), and little variation within the family is known. The ovules lack integumental vasculature, and the embryo sac is of the Polygonum type but usually with ephemeral antipodals. Guiera, however, was found by Venkateswarlu and Rao (1972) to have persistent antipodal cells and a micropyle formed from only the inner integument, both being unique character-states in the whole of Myrtales. Endosperm formation is Nuclear but an endosperm is absent in the mature seed. Pollen Morphology. Data presented here come from work of J.H. Tallis (1963, unpubl. data), B. Batts (1969, unpubl. data), A.-R.A. Alwan (1983, and unpubl. data), Patel et al. (1985), El Ghazali (1993) and El Ghazali et al. (1998); all current genera except Finetia and Dansiea were covered. In Strephonema, Buchenavia and Laguncularia, the grains are tricolporate; these genera are not related and this type of pollen does not occur in the genera most closely related to the latter two genera (Strephonema is isolated). These three can easily be distinguished by their surface sculpturing: reticulate, echinate and psilate respectively. The grains of the other nine studied genera are heterocolpate, i.e. the three colpi (each with a central pore) alternating with three pore-less subsidiary colpi (or pseudocolpi), and exhibit a similar range of surface sculpturing. Heterocolpate grains are found in 8 of the 14 families of Myrtaceae but in very few non-Myrtalean families (Dahlgren and Thorne 1984). Apart from this important feature, it can be concluded that pollen characters are very useful at generic and lower levels, but scarcely contribute to an understanding of generic relationships in Combretaceae. Probably too much was made by Patel et al. (1985) of the distinctive reticulate grains of Strephonema, since the strikingly striate grains of Combretum rhodanthum figured by El Ghazali (1993) appear no less distinctive. Some of the other generic characteristics summarized by Patel et al. (1985) break down when more species are surveyed, e.g. echinate grains are not constant in Anogeissus, but others do not, e.g. tricolporate echinate grains in Buchenavia (quite unlike
71
those in the presumably related Terminalia). The ranges found in the large genera Combretum (El Ghazali) and Terminalia (Alwan) suggest that their infrageneric classification might be reinforced by pollen morphology. Fruit and Seed Structure and Germination. Strictly spoken, the ‘fruit’ is a 1-seeded pseudocarp formed from the inferior ovary and surrounding the lower hypanthium, except in Strephonema where the semi-inferior ovary is mostly exposed from the hypanthium at fruiting, the latter remaining adherent to the base of the fruit. Where there is a stalk-like extension at the tip of the lower hypanthium, this may or may not persist as a fruit-beak. The fruit wall (pericarp plus hypanthium) may be thin and hard, or become differentiated as spongy or succulent tissue, or develop 2–5 wings. All situations are common, often within one genus. The inner part of those pericarps which become succulent may be very hard and woody, forming a pseudodrupe, as in many Terminalia and all Buchenavia. In some cases, the fruits are aggregated into compact heads, the Alnus-like ‘cones’ of Conocarpus representing the extreme. In Calycopteris, the 5 wings are developed from the accrescent calyx, and in Macropteranthes and Dansiea the 2 wings are accrescent prophylls. Fruit anatomy in Laguncularia and Combretum is described by Valente et al. (1989, 1994). An endosperm is absent and the embryo fills the seed. In Strephonema, the two cotyledons are massive and hemispherical (conduplicate). Those of Combretum sect. Calopyxis approach this condition. In Combretum sect. Cacoucia, the cotyledons are less massive but still not folded (also conduplicate) but in all other Combretaceae they are folded, although they can be thick and succulent, e.g. Terminalia megalocarpa (Coode 1973). Folding is either convolute (spiralled together) or irregularly complicate (folded upon themselves, often complexly). The distribution of these three types in the tribes and subtribes is as follows: Strephonematoideae – conduplicate (hemispherical) Combretoideae Laguncularieae – spirally convolute Combreteae Combretinae – irregularly complicate (mostly), spirally convolute or conduplicate Terminaliinae – spirally convolute
Both epigeal and hypogeal germination is common and seems to have little taxonomic significance
72
C.A. Stace
above species level; both types are found in both Combretum (Jackson 1974) and Terminalia. Strephonema shows hypogeal germination (Jongkind 1995b). Of the two mangroves, Laguncularia is epigeal and Lumnitzera hypogeal (Tomlinson 1986) whereas Macropteranthes, a close relative of the latter, is epigeal (N. Byrnes, pers. comm.). Tomlinson reported Conocarpus and Terminalia catappa to be hypogeal, as did Brandis (1893) for T. bellirica, but several Southeast Asian species of Terminalia are epigeal. Terminalia megalocarpa, like some others from Southeast Asia, has 3–4(–5) cotyledons (Coode 1969, 1973). Species of Combretum from African fire-prone savannah, e.g. C. viscosum, C. molle and C. bauchiense, have two epigeal cotyledons with long, fused petioles arising from below the soil and protecting the subterranean plumule bud (Jackson 1974, Onyekwelu 1990). In some seedlings of C. viscosum, the cotyledons are also fused, forming a deep cup with a circular rim (C.A. Stace, unpubl. data). When the shoot grows, it breaks laterally from the base of the fused petioles and emerges from the soil some centimetres from the cotyledons. This peculiar mode of germination has been termed ‘cryptogeal’, and is exhibited by pyrophytic species in other families. Karyology. About 112 chromosome counts for c. 47 species in 7 genera have been reported. By far the commonest counts are 2n = 24 and 26, the former being characteristic for Terminalia, Conocarpus, Anogeissus and Guiera and the latter for Combretum (including former Quisqualis), Calycopteris and Lumnitzera. The base numbers thus appear to be x = 12 and 13, the former in Terminaliinae and the latter in Combretinae and Laguncularieae. In addition, in both Terminalia and Combretum triploids, tetraploids, hexaploids and octoploids have been reported, the highest numbers being 2n = 96 for T. bellirica and 2n = 104 for C. celastroides. Some of the variation in ploidy level is infraspecific, e.g. 2n = 24, 48 and 72 in Terminalia chebula. Ohri (1996) reported DNA C-values for six species of Terminalia. For three diploids, 2C-values were 3.6 to 7.13 pg, for a triploid 10.19 pg, and for two tetraploids 7.3 to 12.8 pg. This gives an almost twofold variation (1.8 to 3.56 pg) in 2C-value per basic genome. In five Indian taxa, the 2C-value was 8.01 to 9.66 pg (Srivastava et al. 2001). These values are above average for tropical hardwoods (Ohri and Kumar 1986).
Pollination. Three major adaptations relevant to pollination are evident in the family: loss of petals; enlargement of upper hypanthium; and clustering of flowers into groups. Large coloured petals, as in a few Combretum species, especially those formerly in Quisqualis (Fig. 25), are rare. In C. indicum the flowers are sweetly scented, especially in the evening, and the long narrow hypanthium shows this to be a typical hawkmothpollinated flower. In nearly all other Combretaceae, the petals are relatively small and inconspicuous, or lacking, and three major pollination syndromes can be detected. Firstly, scentless flowers with large, red to yellow upper hypanthia, found in Combretum (including former Calopyxis) in West Africa and Madagascar, are presumably pollinated by sunbirds, although no direct observations have been made. The same is true of C. cacoucia regarding hummingbirds in America. Secondly, small whitish or pale fragrant flowers are the commonest situation throughout the family, and are pollinated by a wide range of insects, including beetles, flies, bees and butterflies. They usually have very well-developed nectaries inside the hypanthium, and are frequently grouped into larger clusters. In India, Srivastava (1993) found that four species of Terminalia were self-incompatible, and were visited by these orders of insects for both pollen and nectar. Thirdly, in tropical America the very widespread Combretum fruticosum and several related species (sect. Combretum) exhibit the ‘bottle-brush’ syndrome (cf. Australian Callistemon), with sessile, scentless, nectariferous flowers crowded on an elongated axis and possessing long, rigid stamens, with the stigma and anthers at the same level. The whole flower, of which the filaments are the most conspicuous part, starts yellow and then changes to red. These are pollinated primarily by hummingbirds (many direct observations), but other birds, butterflies and monkeys also play their part (Schemske 1980; Prance 1980). The species has been shown to be self-incompatible (Bernardello et al. 1994). In the self-compatible mangrove genus Lumnitzera, L. littorea has red flowers with well-exposed anthers and is pollinated mainly by sunbirds and honeyeaters whereas L. racemosa has white flowers and less-exposed anthers and is pollinated by various insects (Tomlinson 1986). Combretum lanceolatum is remarkable for producing a sweet, gelatinous secretion in form of pellets, rather than liquid nectar, which attracts a great diversity of bird visitors (Sazima et al. 2001).
Combretaceae
Dispersal. Present evidence suggests that species with winged fruits (mostly in savannah) are wind-dispersed, and those with succulent fruits (often riverine or in forest) are animal- or waterborne. In African savannah species of Combretum with large fruits, e.g. C. zeyheri, the wings probably act as sails as the fruit is blown along on the ground (Exell and Stace 1972). In Southeast Asia, Terminalia catappa is dispersed by both seawater and fructivorous bats (Exell 1954). Many species of Terminalia, as well as the two mangrove genera, have spongy rather than succulent fruits, often with airspaces in the mesocarp, and are well adapted for sea-dispersal. Phytochemistry. Ample phytochemical data on Combretaceae indicate that little insight is gained into relationships within the family, but that the position of the family in the Myrtales is strongly confirmed (Dahlgren and Thorne 1984). Particularly characteristic are condensed tannins, gallyol-and ellagi-tannins; among the flavonoids, the flavonol myricetin, various O-methyl flavonols, C-glycoflavones and proanthocyanidins (but no other flavones or iridoids); only few alkaloids; and triterpene saponins. Skoczylas et al. (1994) reported long-chain rubber-like polyisoprenoid alcohols in leaves of Lumnitzera. Anderson and Bell (1977) found differences in the composition of gum exudates in seven African Combretum taxa, and Carr and Rogers (1987) described a method of identifying species of this genus from southern Africa by TLC ‘fingerprints’ of polar constituents of leaf extracts. Laguncularia possesses gums similar to those of Combretum (Léon de Pinto et al. 1993). Large cells containing a single calcium oxalate druse are characteristic of the mesophyll of most (?all) genera; they frequently cause a pimple-like mound on the epidermis and/or pellucid dots when the leaf is held against the light. Subdivision and Relationships Within the Family. Strephonema, originally tentatively assigned to Lythraceae, differs from the rest of the genera in several characters and was separated as the subfamily Strephonematoideae by Engler and Diels (1899). Others have suggested a distinct family for it, but it possesses the diagnostic Combretaceous hairs and it consistently fell into the same single clade as the rest of the family in all the cladograms figured by Johnson and Briggs (1984). Most of the rest of the family (Combretoideae) forms two major groups based around Combretum
73
and Terminalia respectively, first recognized by de Candolle (1828), and later by Engler and Diels (1899, 1900) as the tribes Combreteae and Terminalieae. These have been variously distinguished (cotyledon folding, de Candolle 1828 and Engler and Diels 1899, 1900; presence of petals, Don 1832; presence of glandular trichomes, Stace 1965). Two groups of closely related, traditionally recognized genera form the cores of these two tribes respectively: Combretum, Meiostemon, Thiloa, Quisqualis and Calopyxis; and Terminalia, Terminaliopsis, Ramatuellea and Bucida. In addition, Buchenavia, Conocarpus, Anogeissus and Finetia also clearly belong to Terminalieae. Three other genera have variously been placed in tribes or subtribes of their own or subsumed into one of the above two: Guiera, tribe Guiereae (nom. nud.) (Venkateswarlu and Rao 1972); Calycopteris, tribe Calycopterideae (Engler and Diels 1899); and Pteleopsis, subtribe Pteleopsidinae (Exell and Stace 1966). All three have been placed in the Combreteae, and Pteleopsis also in Terminalieae (Vollesen 1981). In my view, Calycopteris is clearly a member of Combretinae, Pteleopsis of Terminaliinae, and Guiera is of uncertain affinity. I have retained Guiera in Combretinae, as it possesses scales and petals, but it might almost equally belong to Terminaliinae or a separate subtribe; DNA sequences are highly desirable. Four additional genera, Laguncularia, Lumnitzera, Macropteranthes and Dansiea, form a well-defined group which was once placed in Terminalieae or Combreteae, according to the character used to separate these tribes, but which was separated as a third tribe Laguncularieae by Engler and Diels (1899). Exell and Stace (1966) recognized 20 of the above 21 genera (Dansiea was not then described) in two subfamilies: the unigeneric Strephonematoideae and the Combretoideae. They considered Laguncularieae, with two prophylls fused to the hypanthium, to be more distinct than the rest of Combretoideae, which formed an enlarged Combreteae divided into three subtribes: Combretinae, Terminaliinae and the unigeneric Pteleopsidinae, which they thought did not fall into either of the other subtribes. Since then, Vollesen (1981) has presented clear evidence for merging the latter two subtribes. I have been unable to confirm Johnson and Briggs’s (1984) assertion that Strephonema has a pair of prophylls, and therefore consider that those of Laguncularieae do indeed represent a synapomorphy. Despite this advanced character, it is likely
74
C.A. Stace
that Laguncularieae are not an advanced group; the presence of petals, the floral vasculature and the hypanthium not separated into upper and lower portions are indicative of this. The main argument in Combretaceae classification today is how many genera should be recognized among the five and four core genera listed above in Combretinae and Terminaliinae. A conservative classification would recognize only one genus in each group, and it is probably true that separating any of the genera from Combretum or Terminalia respectively would leave the latter two paraphyletic. The types and taxonomic distribution of glandular trichomes in Combretinae support this view. Jongkind (1991, 1995a) argued for the inclusion of Quisqualis and Calopyxis in Combretum, just as Engler and Diels (1899, 1900) had done for Poivrea and Exell (1953) had done for Cacoucia, not on any theoretical basis but because the supposed differences could not be sustained; in fact, Cacoucia is as distinct from Combretum as is Calopyxis. The genera Thiloa and Meiostemon remain distinct, but they are probably no less closely evolutionarily related to Combretum subg. Combretum than are Cacoucia, Poivrea, Quisqualis and Calopyxis to Combretum subg. Cacoucia. In Terminaliinae, Terminaliopsis and Ramatuellea have few claims for separation from Terminalia, each representing specialized parts of the latter. Describing an apetalous species in the erstwhile petaliferous genus Pteleopsis, Vollesen (1981) considered that it could still be separated by the male flowers being at the base of the inflorescence, not at the apex, as in Terminalia. However, there are species of Terminalia with basal male flowers (sect. Ramatuellea), so there is no single character diagnosing Pteleopsis, although it remains a very distinctive taxon. The genus Bucida is traditionally separated from Terminalia by the retention of the upper hypanthium and calyx on the fruit. This character is, however, also found in three Madagascan Terminalia species of quite different facies (Capuron 1967), and in two other species from the Solomon Islands of yet different affinity (Exell 1935), and one species of Bucida does not possess it constantly. In my view, only Combretum, Terminalia and Pteleopsis of the above 12 should be recognized at generic level. Molecular studies (plastid and rDNA ITS sequences) on eight genera and 18 species by Tan et al. (2001, 2002) have largely confirmed the current suprageneric treatment. Strephonema is sister to the rest, and within the latter Laguncularieae (Lumnitzera, Laguncularia) are sister to the
remainder, which divide into Combretinae (Combretum including former Quisqualis, Calycopteris) and Terminaliinae (Terminalia, Anogeissus, Conocarpus). More recently, Sytsma et al. (2004) sequenced four genera (three at present recognized) and obtained rather different results, Conocarpus being sister to Terminalia (including Bucida) plus Combretum (as Quisqualis). Clearly, much more molecular work is required. Affinities. Combretaceae were considered one of 14 “core families of Myrtales” by Dahlgren and Thorne (1984), but “any close connections [to any of the other 13 families] are not obvious”. In Johnson and Briggs’s (1984) main cladograms, based on 77 morphological and anatomical characters, the sister clade to a clade containing only Combretaceae contained seven of the other core families: Penaeaceae, Alzateaceae, Oliniaceae, Rhynchocalycaceae, Crypteroniaceae, Memecylaceae and Melastomataceae. Despite the possession of Combretaceous hairs by some of their members, Myrtaceae were more distant. In Conti et al.’s (1996) cladistic analysis of rbcL sequence data, a different result was obtained: Combretaceae formed a clade along with Onagraceae and Lythraceae which was sister to all the other Myrtales (the above seven plus four other families). Similarly, Soltis et al.’s (2000) analysis of seven of the families using 18S rDNA, rbcL and atpB sequences revealed three unresolved subclades – Combretaceae, Onagraceae and Lythraceae – and four other families. The Angiosperm Phylogeny Group classification (APG II 2003) recognizes the Myrtales with 14 families, 13 of which are the same as those of Dahlgren and Thorne (1984) (Trapaceae merged into Lythraceae; Vochysiaceae added). Sytsma et al. (2004) found Combretaceae to be sister to all the other 13 families combined. There is thus agreement that Combretaceae are a distinct family which diverged early (perhaps first) in the evolution of Myrtales. Distribution and Habitats. Combretaceae occur throughout the tropics, with short extensions into warm temperate zones, i.e. to 37◦ 15 S in Argentina, 33◦ 46 S in South Africa and c. 26◦ S in Australia, and to 28◦ 30 N in Florida, 29◦ N in Baja California, 32◦ 20 N in Bermuda, 29◦ 30 N in China and c. 31◦ N in India. The two large genera, Combretum and Terminalia, occur in all continents (Combretum not discovered in Australia until 1980). The greatest genetic diversity of Combretum is in Africa, that of Terminalia in Southeast Asia.
Combretaceae
One mangrove, Laguncularia, occurs in both America (east and west coasts) and West Africa, and the other, Lumnitzera, from East Africa to Australia. The mangrove-associate, Conocarpus, has a similar distribution to Laguncularia, but there is also a second non-mangrove species (C. lancifolius) in northeast Africa and Arabia. Anogeissus occurs in both Africa and Asia, but the other seven genera are confined to one continent. There are only three amphi-Atlantic species: Laguncularia racemosa, Conocarpus erectus and Terminalia lucida. Combretaceae can be important constituents of forest, savannah and mangrove-swamp, and occur from sea level to (in Southeast Asia) over 3,000 m altitude. In parts of southern Africa, several species of Combretum, viz. C. zeyheri, C. molle, C. apiculatum, C. hereroense and C. mossambicense (Exell 1978), are characteristic and hence indicators of cupriferous soils. Palaeobotany. Friis et al. (1992) described flowers (Esgueiria adenocarpa E.M. Friis, K.R. Pedersen & P.R. Crane and E. miraensis E.M. Friis, K.R. Pedersen & P.R. Crane) from the Late Cretaceous of Portugal which they ascribed to Combretaceae. They had an inferior unilocular ovary with three stylodia and up to six apical anatropous ovules, five sepals and five sepals borne on the top of the ovary, and eight stamens (in two whorls of three and five) borne on the top of the ovary. The ovary and sepals had abundant simple hairs and peltate scales. Overall, there is good concordance between the features of Esgueiria and Combretaceae, but confirmation of the family status could only be made from anatomical analysis of the hairs; the photographs provided suggest that they might be Combretaceous. Primitive characters would be the three stylodia and the absence of an upper hypanthium. There are many earlier records of fossil supposed Combretaceae, involving wood, leaves, flowers, fruits and pollen from the Mid-Cretaceous (c. 100 Ma b.p.) onwards, all ascribed to modern genera or to fossil genera based on modern names. However, the evidence of them belonging to Combretaceae is tenuous and based on gross morphology only, except perhaps in the case of the Late Cretaceous and Tertiary wood Terminalioxylon (Friis et al. 1992). Economic Importance. Combretaceae are not of great worldwide economic importance. The larger species of Terminalia are valued as timber trees, mostly for local uses but in some cases in
75
the European and American markets, e.g. the West African T. ivorensis (‘idigbo’) and T. superba (‘afara’), the American T. amazonia (‘nargusta’ or ‘roblé coral’) and T. oblonga (‘sura’), and the Asian T. elliptica (‘Indian laurel’), T. cuneata (T. arjuna, ‘kumbuk’) and T. bialata (‘chuglam’). In the West Indies, Laguncularia is valued for fence-posts and Conocarpus for fuel. The fruit of several species of Terminalia (e.g. T. catappa, ‘Indian almond’) have edible kernels, as do species of Combretum sect. Calopyxis in Madagascar; in South America, Asia and Africa, several species of Combretum and Terminalia are commercial sources of gums; in Asia, the fruits of certain species (e.g. T. chebula) known collectively as ‘myrobalans’ are important for dyeing and tanning. Dalziel (1937) has 11 pages of entries for Combretaceae. Species of Terminalia, especially T. catappa throughout the tropics, are much grown as shade plants, and of Combretum (including former Calopyxis and Quisqualis) as ornamentals.
Key to the Genera 1. Ovary semi-inferior, the calyx-tube arising from its sides; seeds with massive hemispherical cotyledons 1. Strephonema – Ovary inferior, the hypanthium extended from its apex; seeds with flattened, usually variously folded cotyledons 2 2. Hypanthium with 2 adnate prophylls (sometimes developed as wings) 3 – Hypanthium without adnate prophylls 6 3. Prophylls not accrescent and not forming wings to the fruit; thick-leaved mangroves 4 – Prophylls accrescent to form 2 wings to the fruit; plants not mangroves 5 4. Leaves opposite, with minute narrow-orificed pits on both surfaces; hypanthium (above ovary) < 5 mm; petals pubescent, < 2 mm 2. Laguncularia – Leaves spiral, without surface pits; hypanthium (above ovary) > 5 mm; petals glabrous, > 3 mm 3. Lumnitzera 5. Hypanthium adnate to ovary all round; nectariferous disk forming an intrastaminal ring at base of hypnthium 4. Macropteranthes – Hypanthium adnate to ovary on ventral side only; nectary a 2-lobed outgrowth on inner dorsal side of hypanthium 5. Dansiea 6. Fruits aggregated into ‘cones’ (Alnus-like but without persistent bracts) 7 – Fruits not aggregated into Alnus-like ‘cones’ 9 7. Fruits without terminal beak, strongly recurved at apex 11. Conocarpus – Fruits with terminal beak, not recurved at apex 8 8. Ovary and fruit 2-winged; beak of fruit formed from whole of distal stalk-like part of lower hypanthium 9. Anogeissus
76
C.A. Stace
– Ovary and fruit 4-ridged; beak of fruit formed from only lower half of distal stalk-like part of lower hypanthium 10. Finetia 9. Calyx-lobes accrescent, forming 5 terminal fruit-wings 13. Calycopteris – Calyx-lobes not or scarcely accrescent, not forming fruit-wings 10 10. Petals usually present, rarely absent; leaves and inflorescences with glandular trichomes (stalked glands and/or scales) 11 – Petals usually absent, sometimes present; leaves and inflorescences without glandular trichomes 12 11. Fruits in radiating capitate clusters, linear to narrowly fusiform, with persistent upper hypanthium 14. Guiera – Fruits not in radiating clusters, not linear, without persistent upper hypanthium 12. Combretum 12. Anthers adnate to filaments; fruit a wingless pseudodrupe 8. Buchenavia – Anthers dorsifixed and versatile; fruit various 13 13. Andromonoecious, with bisexual flowers restricted to apex of rhachis; all flowers long-stalked 7. Pteleopsis – All flowers bisexual or, if andromonoecious with bisexual flowers restricted to apex of rhachis, at least bisexual flowers sessile or more or less so 6. Terminalia
Genera of Combretaceae I. Subfam. Strephonematoideae Engl. & Diels (1899). Trees; ovary semi-inferior; cotyledons conduplicate, hemispherical, massive; stomata paracytic; wood with tangential bands of apotracheal parenchyma; pollen tricolporate; one- and twoarmed Combretaceous hairs present; glandular trichomes absent; petals present. 1. Strephonema Hook. f.
Fig. 21
Strephonema Hook. f. in Benth. & Hook. f., Gen. Pl. 1:782 (1867); Jongkind, Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 82:535–541 (1955), rev.
Characters of subfamily; leaves spiral, without petiolar glands, with basal revolute domatia; inflorescences axillary, subumbellate to elongated simple to compound racemes; flowers (4–)5merous, bisexual, pedicellate; stamens 10, with versatile anthers; ovules 2; germination hypogeal. Three species, western tropical Africa. II. Subfam. Combretoideae Engl. & Diels (1899). Trees, shrubs, mangroves or lianes; ovary inferior; cotyledons flattened, variously folded or rarely
Fig. 21. Combretaceae. Strephonema sericea. A Flowering branch. B Flower with subtending bract. C Flower, vertical section. D Fruit. E Fruit, half of pericarp and seed-coat removed. (Engler and Diels 1900)
conduplicate; stomata anomocytic (or cyclocytic); wood without tangential bands of apotracheal parenchyma; pollen tricolporate or heterocolpate; only one-armed Combretaceous hairs present; glandular trichomes present or absent; petals present or absent. II.1. Tribe Laguncularieae Engl. & Diels (1899). Trees, shrubs or mangroves; stomata anomocytic or cyclocytic; cotyledons spirally convolute; leaves with isobilateral or weakly isobilateral anatomy; stalked glandular trichomes absent; hypanthium with 2 adnate prophylls; upper and lower hypanthia scarcely differentiated; petals present; anthers versatile; chromosome base number 13 (as far as is known). 2. Laguncularia C.F. Gaertn.
Fig. 22
Laguncularia C.F. Gaertn., Suppl. Carp. 209, t. 217 (1807); Exell, Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 45:162–164 (1958); Stace, Fl. Venez. Guayana 4:344 (1998).
Mangroves, often with pneumatophores; leaves opposite, with pair of petiolar glands, with sessile glands in minute sunken pits, without marginal
Combretaceae
77
or pedicellate; nectary a disk; petals glabrous; stamens 5–10; ovules 2–5; fruit unwinged; germination hypogeal. Two species, East tropical Africa to Australia. 4. Macropteranthes F. Muell. Macropteranthes F. Muell., Fragm. 3:151 (1863); Pedley, Fl. Australia 18:256–260 (1990).
Trees or shrubs; leaves spiral or opposite, without petiolar glands, with glands on margin near base; inflorescence axillary, of (1–)2 flowers; hypanthium adnate all round ovary, its prophylls accrescent to form winged fruit; flowers 5-merous, bisexual, sessile or pedicellate; nectary a disk; petals pubescent; stamens 10; ovules 6–12; germination epigeal. Five species, Australia. 5. Dansiea Byrnes Dansiea Byrnes, Austrobaileya 1:385 (1981); Pedley, Fl. Australia 18:260–262 (1990).
Fig. 22. Combretaceae. Laguncularia racemosa. A Fruiting branch. B Flower buds with bracts. C Petal and stamen. D Style, disk and ovules (below). E Immature fruits. F Fruit, vertical section. G Fruit, transverse section. h = hypocotyl, c = cotyledons. (Engler and Diels 1900)
glands; inflorescence a terminal panicle of spikes; hypanthium adnate all round ovary, its prophylls not accrescent; flowers 5-merous, bisexual to dioecious, sessile; nectary a disk; petals pubescent; stamens 10; ovules 2; fruit unwinged; germination epigeal. One species, L. racemosa (L.) C.F. Gaertn., eastern and western tropical America, western tropical Africa. 3. Lumnitzera Willd. Lumnitzera Willd., Gesell. Naturf. Freunde Berlin N. S. 4:186 (1803); Exell, Fl. Males. I, 4:585–589 (1954); Gangopadhyay & Chakrabarty, J. Econ. Tax. Bot. 21:325–329 (1997), rev.
Mangroves, often with pneumatophores; leaves spiral, without petiolar glands, with glands on margin; inflorescence a terminal raceme or axillary spike; hypanthium adnate all round ovary, its prophylls not accrescent; flowers 5-merous, bisexual, sessile
Trees; leaves spiral to subopposite, without petiolar glands, with glands on margin near base; inflorescence axillary, of (1–)2 flowers; hypanthium adnate to ovary on ventral side only, its prophylls accrescent to form winged fruit; flowers 5-merous, bisexual, subsessile; nectary a dorsal outgrowth; petals pubescent; stamens 10; ovules 14–20; germination? Two species, Australia. II.2. Tribe Combreteae DC. (1828). Trees, shrubs or lianes; stomata anomocytic; cotyledons conduplicate, spirally convolute or irregularly complicate; leaves usually with dorsiventral, sometimes with isobilateral, anatomy; stalked glandular trichomes present or absent; hypanthium without adnate prophylls; upper and lower hypanthia well differentiated; petals 4–5 or 0; anthers versatile or adnate; chromosome base number 12 or 13. II.2. a. Subtribe Terminaliinae (DC.) Exell & Stace (1966). Terminalieae [Terminaliées] DC. (1828). Pteleopsidinae Exell & Stace (1966).
Trees or shrubs; leaves usually spiral, usually with dorsiventral, sometimes with isobilateral, anatomy; petiolar glands often present; scales absent; stalked glands usually absent; flowers bisexual or andromonoecious, rarely dioecious,
78
C.A. Stace
sessile; petals usually absent, sometimes present; anthers versatile or adnate; cotyledons spirally convolute; fruit usually with hard sclerenchymatous endocarp; wood without vessels of 2 very distinct diameters and without rays with radial vessels; chromosome base number usually 12. 6. Terminalia L.
Fig. 23
Terminalia L., Syst. Nat., ed. 12, 2:674 (1767) & Mant. Pl. 21 (1767), nom. cons.; Alwan, Taxonomy Terminalia (Combretaceae) & related genera (1983), reg. rev.; Capuron, Combretacées arbust. arbor. Madagascar: 9–96 (1967); Coode, Man. forest trees Papua New Guinea, 1, Combretaceae: 5–78 (1969); Exell, Fl. Males. I, 4:548–584 (1954); Exell, Fl. Zambesiaca 4:166–181 (1978); Gangopadhyay & Chakrabarty, J. Econ. Tax. Bot. 21:334–362 (1997), reg. rev.; Griffiths, J. Linn. Soc., Bot. 55:818–907 (1959), reg. rev. Bucida L. (1759), nom. cons. Ramatuellea Kunth in Humb. (1825) (‘Ramatuela’, ‘Ramatuella’). Terminaliopsis Danguy (1923).
Trees. Leaves spiral, often with pocket-shaped or bowl-shaped domatia, frequently with petiolar glands; stalked glands 0; inflorescence an axillary lax to congested spike, the spikes often clustered
at branchlet-ends, rarely the spikes branched; flowers bisexual or plants andromonoecious, the male flowers basal, apical or mixed, at least the bisexual ones sessile, 5- or rarely 4-merous; upper hypanthium sometimes persistent in fruit; petals absent; stamens usually (4–5, 8)10; anthers versatile; fruit 2- to 5-winged or -ridged or ± terete, radially symmetrical or flattened, dry or succulent; chromosome base number usually 12. About 190 species, pantropical. 7. Pteleopsis Engl. Pteleopsis Engl., Abh. Königl. Akad. Wissensch. Berlin 1894: 25 (1894); Exell, Fl. Zambesiaca 4:162–166 (1978).
Leaves spiral, subopposite or opposite, without domatia, without petiolar glands; stalked glands 0; inflorescence an axillary congested spike, the spikes often clustered at branchlet-ends; plants andromonoecious, flowers long-stalked, 5- or 4-merous; upper hypanthium deciduous before fruiting; petals usually present (absent in P. apetala Vollesen); stamens 10 or 8; anthers versatile; fruit 2-winged, flattened, dry. About 10 species, Africa. 8. Buchenavia Eichler Buchenavia Eichler, Flora 49:164 (1866), nom. cons.; Exell & Stace, Bull. Brit Mus. (Nat. Hist.), Bot. 3:1–46 (1963), rev.; Alwan, Taxonomy Terminalia (Combretaceae) & related genera (1983).
Leaves spiral, often with pocket-shaped or rarely bowl-shaped domatia, usually with petiolar glands; stalked glands 0; inflorescence an axillary lax to congested spike, the spikes usually clustered at branchlet-ends; flowers bisexual, sessile, 5-merous; upper hypanthium deciduous before fruiting; petals absent; stamens 10; anthers adnate to filaments; fruit 5-ridged or ± terete, radially symmetrical or rarely slightly flattened, succulent. Twenty species, tropical America. 9. Anogeissus (DC.) Wall. Anogeissus (DC.) Wall., Numer. List no. 4014 (1831); Scott, Kew Bull. 33:555–566 (1979), rev. Conocarpus sect. Anogeissus DC. (1828).
Fig. 23. Combretaceae. Terminalia brownii. A Flowering branch. B Flower, vertical section. C Part of infructescence. D Fruit, transverse section. (Engler and Diels 1900)
Leaves spiral, opposite or subopposite, usually with dorsiventral anatomy, sometimes with pocket-shaped domatia, without petiolar glands; stalked glands absent; inflorescence a solitary or a raceme or compound raceme of compact conelike spikes; flowers bisexual, sessile, 5-merous; upper hypanthium deciduous before fruiting;
Combretaceae
petals absent; stamens 10; anthers versatile; fruit 2-winged, flattened, dry and achene-like, retaining whole of distal stalk-like part of lower hypanthium at fruiting; chromosome base number 12. Seven species, western tropical Africa to Southeast Asia.
Finetia Gagnep., Notul. Syst. (Paris) 3:278 (1917); Scott, Kew Bull. 33:555–566 (1979), rev. Anogeissus sect. Finetia (Gagnep.) A.J. Scott (1979).
Leaves opposite or subopposite, without domatia, without petiolar glands; stalked glands 0; inflorescence a solitary or a raceme of compact cone-like spikes; flowers bisexual, sessile, 5-merous; upper hypanthium deciduous before fruiting; petals absent; stamens 10; anthers versatile; fruit 4-ribbed, slightly flattened, dry and achene-like, retaining only lower half of distal stalk-like part of lower hypanthium at fruiting. One species, F. rivularis (Gagnep.) Lecomte, Thailand and Laos. 11. Conocarpus L.
or irregularly complicate; fruit without hard sclerenchymatous endocarp; wood with vessels of 2 very distinct diameters and with rays with radial vessels; chromosome base number 12 or 13. 12. Combretum Loefl.
10. Finetia Gagnep.
Fig. 20
Conocarpus L., Sp. Pl.: 176 (1753); Exell, Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 45:161–162 (1958), reg. rev.
Mangrove-like shrubs or trees, without pneumatophores; leaves spiral with bowl-shaped domatia and petiolar glands; minute stalked glands present; inflorescence a raceme or compound raceme of compact cone-like spikes; flowers bisexual to dioecious, sessile, 5-merous; upper hypanthium deciduous before fruiting; petals 0; stamens (5–)10; anthers versatile; fruit 2-winged, flattened, dry; chromosome base number 12. Two species, one (C. erectus L.) a mangrove-associate in western and eastern tropical America and western tropical Africa, the other (C. lancifolius Engl.) a tree of sandy soils in Northeast Africa and southern Yemen. II.2. b. Subtribe Combretinae Exell & Stace (1966). Calycopterideae Engl. & Diels (1899).
Trees, shrubs or lianes; leaves usually opposite, usually with dorsiventral anatomy; petiolar glands 0; stalked glandular trichomes (stalked glands and/or scales) present; flowers bisexual (dioecious, one species of Combretum), usually sessile; petals usually present; anthers versatile; pollen heterocolpate; cotyledons conduplicate, spirally convolute
79
Figs. 24, 25
Combretum Loefl., Iter Hispan. 308 (1758), nom. cons.; Engler & Diels, Monographieen afrikanischer PflanzenFamilien und -Gattungen, III & IV (1899–1900), reg. rev.; Exell, J. Bot. 69:116–124 (1931), part. rev.; Exell, J. Linn. Soc., Bot. 55:103–141 (1953), reg. rev.; Exell & Stace, Bol. Soc. Brot. II, 40:19 (1966), part. rev.; Gangopadhyay & Chakrabarty, J. Econ. Tax. Bot. 21:297–325, 329–334 (1997), reg. rev.; Jongkind, Bull. Mus. Natl Hist. Nat., B, Adansonia 17:191–200 (1995), reg. rev.; Stace, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 95:156–165 (1968), part. rev. Quisqualis L. (1762). Cacoucia Aubl. (1775). Poivrea Comm. ex Thouars (1811). Calopyxis Tul. (1856). Thiloa Eichler (1866). Meiostemon Exell & Stace (1966).
Shrubs or lianes, rarely trees. Leaves opposite, sometimes verticillate; stalked glands and/or scales present; flowers 4-or 5-merous, usually sessile, sometimes stalked; upper hypanthium and calyx deciduous before fruiting; petals usually present, sometimes 0; stamens usually 8 or 10 (rarely more), sometimes 4; fruit 4- to 5-winged or -ridged or ± terete, dry or succulent, not achene-like; cotyledons conduplicate, spirally convolute or irregularly complicate; chromosome base number usually 13. About 255 species, pantropical except Pacific islands and most of Australia. Three subgenera are recognized: subg. Combretum, with peltate scales and usually with petals (about 150 spp. in about 33 sections, including Meiostemon and Thiloa); subg. Cacoucia (Aubl.) Exell & Stace, with stalked glands and usually with petals (about 104 spp. in about 17 sections, including Poivrea, Cacoucia, Quisqualis and Calopyxis); subg. Apetalanthum Exell & Stace, with stalked glands and scales, and without petals (one species). 13. Calycopteris Lam. Calycopteris Lam., Tabl. Encycl. 1:485, t. 357 (1793); Exell, Fl. Males. I, 4:584–585 (1954). Getonia Roxb. (1798).
Scrambling shrubs. Leaves opposite or subopposite; scales present; flowers 5-merous, ± sessile; upper hypanthium persistent in fruit, with accrescent
80
C.A. Stace
Fig. 25. Combretaceae. Combretum poggei (subg. Cacoucia). A Flowering branch. B Flower, vertical section. C Fruit. D Fruit, transverse section. (Engler and Diels 1899) Fig. 24. Combretaceae. Combretum bongense (subg. Combretum). A Flowering branch. B Flower bud. C Flower, vertical section. D Leaf underside. E Leaf, transverse section, showing a scale. (Engler and Diels 1899)
calyx forming 5 wings; petals absent; stamens 10; fruit dry, achene-like; cotyledons irregularly complicate; chromosome base number 13. One species, C. floribunda (Roxb.) Lam., Southeast Asia.
Shrubs; leaves opposite or subopposite; scale-like glandular trichomes present; flowers 5-merous, sessile; upper hypanthium persistent in fruit; petals present; stamens 10; fruit dry, achene-like; cotyledons spirally convolute; chromosome base number 12. One species, G. senegalensis J.F. Gmel., western tropical Africa.
Selected Bibliography 14. Guiera Adans. ex Juss. Guiera Adans. ex Juss., Gen. Pl.: 320 (1789).
Adamson, R.S. 1910. Note on the roots of Terminalia arjuna Bedd. New Phytol. 9:150–156.
Combretaceae Alwan, A.-R.A. 1983. The taxonomy of Terminalia (Combretaceae) and related genera. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Leicester. Anderson, D.M.W., Bell, P.C. 1977. The composition of the gum exudates from some Combretum species; the botanical nomenclature and systematics of the Combretaceae. Carbohyd. Res. 57:215–221. APG II 2003. See general references. Behnke, H.-D. 1984. Ultrastructure of sieve-element plastids of Myrtales and allied groups. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 71:824–831. Bernardello, L., Galetto, L., Rodgriguez, I.G. 1994. Reproductive biology, variability of nectar features and pollination of Combretum fruticosum (Combretaceae) in Argentina. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 114:293–308. Brandis, D. 1893. Combretaceae. In: Engler, A., Prantl, K., Die natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien III, 7. Leipzig: W. Engelmann, pp. 106–130. Candolle, A.P. de 1828. Combretaceae. In: Prodromus systematis naturalis regni vegetabilis, 3. Paris: Treuttel & Würtz, pp. 9–24. Capuron, R. 1967. Les Combretacées arbustives ou arborescentes de Madagascar. Madagascar: Centre Technique Forestier Tropicale. Carr, J.D., Rogers, C.B. 1987. Chemosystematic studies of the genus Combretum (Combretaceae), I. A convenient method of identifying species of this genus by a comparison of the polar constituents extracted from leaf material. S. African J. Bot. 53:173–176. Conti, E. et al. 1996. See general references. Coode, M.J.E. 1969. Manual of the forest trees of Papua and New Guinea. Part 1, revised. Combretaceae. Lae: Department of Forests. Coode, M.J.E. 1973. Notes on Terminalia L. (Combretaceae) in Papuasia. Contr. Herb. Austral. 2:1–33. Corner, E.J.H. 1940. Wayside trees of Malaya. Singapore: Government Printing Office. Dahlgren, R., Thorne, R.F. 1984. The order Myrtales: circumscription, variation and relationships. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 71:633–699. Dalziel, J.M. 1937. The useful plants of West Tropical Africa. London: Crown Agents. Don, G. 1832. Combretaceae. In: A general history of the dichlamydeous plants, 2. London: Rivington, pp. 655– 668. El Ghazali, G.E.B. 1993. A study on the pollen flora of Sudan. Rev. Palaeobot. Palynol. 76:99–345. El Ghazali, G.E.B., Tsuji, S., El Ghazali, G.A., Nilsson, S. 1998. Combretaceae. In: Nilsson, S. (ed.) World Pollen and Spore Flora, 21. Oslo: Scandinavian University Press. Engler, A., Diels, L. 1899. Monographien afrikanischer Pflanzen-Familien und -Gattungen, III. Combretaceae africanae (I) Combretum. Leipzig: W. Engelmann. Engler, A., Diels, L. 1900. Monographien afrikanischer Pflanzen-Familien und -Gattungen, IV. Combretaceae africanae (II) excl. Combretum. Leipzig: W. Engelmann. Exell, A.W. 1931. The genera of Combretaceae. J. Bot. 69:113–128. Exell, A.W. 1935. Species of Terminalia from the Solomon Is. J. Bot. 73:131–134. Exell, A.W. 1953. The Combretum species of the New World. J. Linn. Soc., Bot. 55:103–141.
81
Exell, A.W. 1954. Combretaceae. In: Steenis, C.G.G.J. van (ed.) Flora Malesiana I, 4:533–628. Djakarta: Noordhoff-Kolff. Exell, A.W. 1962. Space problems arising from the conflict between two evolutionary tendencies in the Combretaceae. Bull. Soc. Roy. Bot. Belgique 95:41–49. Exell, A.W. 1978. Combretaceae. In: Launert, E. (ed.) Flora Zambesiaca 4:100–183. London: Flora Zambesiaca Managing Committee. Exell, A.W., Stace, C.A. 1966. Revision of the Combretaceae. Bol. Soc. Brot. II, 40:5–25. Exell, A.W., Stace, C.A. 1972. Patterns of distribution in the Combretaceae. In: Valentine, D.H. (ed.) Taxonomy, phytogeography and evolution. London: Academic Press, pp. 307–323. Friis, E.M., Pedersen, K.R., Crane, P.R. 1992. Esgueiria gen. nov., fossil flowers with combretaceous features from the Late Cretaceous of Portugal. Biol. Skr. 41:1–45. Fukuoka, N., Ito, M., Iwatsuki, K. 1986. Floral anatomy of the mangrove genus Lumnitzera (Combretaceae). Acta Phytotax. Geobot. 37:69–81. Griffiths, M.E. 1959. A revision of the African species of Terminalia. J. Linn. Soc., Bot. 55:818–907. Heiden, H. 1893. Anatomische Characteristik der Combretaceen. Bot. Centralbl. 55:353–360, 385–391; 56:1–12, 65–75, 129–136, 163–170, 193–200, 225–230. Hickey, L.J. 1973. Classification of the architecture of dicotyledonous leaves. Amer. J. Bot. 60:17–33. Jackson, G. 1974. Cryptogeal germination and other seedling adaptations to the burning of vegetation in savanna regions: the origin of the pyrophytic habit. New Phytol. 73:771–780. Jeník, J. 1970. Root system of tropical trees, 5. The pegroots and the pneumathodes of Laguncularia racemosa Gaertn. Preslia 42:105–113. Johnson, L.A.S., Briggs, B.G. 1984. Myrtales and Myrtaceae –a phylogenetic analysis. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 71:700–756. Jongkind, C.C.H. 1991. Novitates Gabonenses, 6. Some critical observations on Combretum versus Quisqualis (Combretaceae) and description of two new species of Combretum. Bull. Mus. Natl Hist. Nat., B, Adansonia 12:275–280. Jongkind, C.C.H. 1995a. Prodromus for a revision of Combretum (Combretaceae) for Madagascar. Bull. Mus. Natl Hist. Nat., B, Adansonia 17:191–200. Jongkind, C.C.H. 1995b. Review of the genus Strephonema (Combretaceae). Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 82:535–541. Jongkind, C.C.H. 1998. Combretaceae. In: Morat, P. (ed.) Flore du Gabon, 35. Paris: Association de Botanique Tropicale. Keating, R.C. 1984. Leaf histology and its contribution to relationships in the Myrtales. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 71:801–823. Keay, R.W.J. 1950. The systematic position of suffrutescent species of Combretum Loefl. Kew Bull. 5:255–257. Klucking, E.P. 1991. Leaf Venation Patterns, 5. Combretaceae. Berlin: J. Cramer. Léon de Pinto, G., Nava, M., Martínez, M., Rivas, C. 1993. Gum polysaccharides of nine specimens of Laguncularia racemosa. Biochem. Syst. Ecol. 21:463–466. Ohri, D. 1996. Genome size and polyploidy variation in the tropical hardwood genus Terminalia (Combretaceae). Pl. Syst. Evol. 200:225–232.
82
C.A. Stace
Ohri, D., Kumar, A. 1986. Nuclear DNA amounts in some tropical hardwoods. Caryologia 39:303–307. Onyekwelu, S.S.C. 1990. Germination, seedling morphology and establishment of Combretum bauchiense Hutch. & Dalz. (Combretaceae). Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 103:133– 138. Outer, R.W. den, Fundter, J.M. 1976. The secondary phloem of some Combretaceae and the systematic position of Strephonema pseudocola A. Chev. Acta Bot. Neerl. 25:481–493. Patel, V.C., Skvarla, J.J., Raven, P.H. 1985. Pollen characters in relation to the delimitation of Myrtales. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 71:858–969. Pedley, L. 1990. Combretaceae. In: George, A.S. (ed.) Flora of Australia 18:255–293. Canberra: AGPS Press. Prance, G.T. 1980. A note on the probable pollination of Combretum by Cebus monkeys. Biotropica 12: 239. Sazima, M., Vogel, S., Prado, A.L. do, Oliveira, D.M. de, Franz, G., Sazima, I. 2001. The sweet jelly of Combretum lanceolatum flowers (Combretaceae): a cornucopia resource for bird pollinators in the Pantanal, western Brazil. Pl. Syst. Evol. 227:195–208. Schemske, D.W. 1980. Floral ecology and hummingbird pollination of Combretum farinosum in Costa Rica. Biotropica 12:169–181. Skoczylas, E., Swiezewska, E., Chojnacki, T., Tanaka, Y. 1994. Long-chain rubber-like polyisoprenoid alcohols in leaves of Lumnitzera racemosa. Pl. Physiol. Biochem. (Montrouge) 32:1–5. Solereder, H. 1908. Systematic anatomy of the dicotyledons. Transl. Boodle, L.A., Fritsch, F.E.; revised Scott, D.H. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Soltis, D.E. et al. 2000. See general references. Srivastava, P.K. 1993. Pollination mechanisms in genus Terminalia Linn. Indian Forester 119:147–150. Srivastava, P.K., Raina, S.N., Thangalevu, K. 2001. Nuclear DNA and fruit (seed) variation in section Pentaptera of genus Terminalia Linn. Indian Forester 128:289– 295. Stace, C.A. 1965. The significance of the leaf epidermis in the taxonomy of the Combretaceae, I. A general review of tribal, generic and specific characters. J. Linn. Soc., Bot. 59:229–252. Stace, C.A. 1966. The use of epidermal characters in phylogenetic considerations. New Phytol. 65:304–318. Stace, C.A. 1968. A revision of the genus Thiloa (Combretaceae). Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 95:156–165.
Stace, C.A. 1981. The significance of the leaf epidermis in the taxonomy of the Combretaceae; conclusions. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 81:327–339. Sytsma, K.J. et al. 2004. See general references. Tan, F.-X., Shi, S.-H., Huang, Y.-L., Du, Y.-Q., Wang, Y.-G., Gong, X. 2001. Analysis of nrDNA ITS sequences in the subfamily Combretoideae (Combretaceae) and its systematic significance. Acta Bot. Yunnanica 23:239– 242. Tan, F.-X., Shi, S.-H., Zhong, Y., Gong, X., Wang, Y.-G. 2002. Phylogenetic relationships of Combretoideae (Combretaceae) inferred from plastid, nuclear gene and spacer sequences. J. Pl. Res. 115:475–481. Tilney, P.M. 2002. A contribution to the leaf and young stem anatomy of the Combretaceae. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 138:163–196. Tobe, H., Raven, P.H. 1983. An embryological analysis of Myrtales: its definition and characteristics. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 70:71–94. Tomlinson, P.B. 1986. The Botany of mangroves. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Valente, M. da C., Marquete Ferreira da Silva, N., Guimarães, D.J. 1989. Morfologia e anatomia do fruto de Combretum rotundifolium Rich. (Combretaceae). Rodriguésia 67:45–51. Valente, M. da C., Marquete Ferreira da Silva, N., Guimarães, D.J. 1994. Morfologia e anatomia do fruto de Laguncularia racemosa (L.) Gaertn. f. (Combretaceae). Arch. Jard. Bot. Rio de Janeiro 32:39–50. Venkateswarlu, J., Rao, P.S.P. 1970. The floral anatomy of Combretaceae. Proc. Indian Natl Sci. Acad., B, 36:1–20. Venkateswarlu, J., Rao, P.S.P. 1972. Embryological studies in some Combretaceae. Bot. Notiser 125:161–179. Verhoeven, R.L., Schijff, H.P. van der 1974. Anatomical aspects of Combretaceae in South Africa. Phytomorphology 24:158–164. Vliet, C.J.C.M. van 1979. Wood anatomy of the Combretaceae. Blumea 25:141–223. Vliet, C.J.C.M. van, Raven, P.H. 1984. Wood anatomy and classification of the Myrtales. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 71:783–800. Vollesen, K. 1981. Pteleopsis apetala sp. nov. (Combretaceae) and the delimitation of Pteleopsis and Terminalia. Nordic J. Bot. 1:329–332. Weberling, F. 1988. The architecture of inflorescences in the Myrtales. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 75:226–310.
Crassulaceae Crassulaceae DC. in Lam. & DC., Fl. Franç., ed. 3, 4, 1: 382 (1805), nom. cons. J. Thiede and U. Eggli1
Perennial or rarely annual or hapaxanthic herbs to (sub)shrubs, rarely aquatics, treelike, epiphytic or scandent, with ± succulent leaves, sometimes with succulent stems, rhizomes, underground caudices or succulent roots; indumentum of unior multicellular, often glandular hairs, or plants glabrous. Leaves (sub)sessile or rarely petiolate, usually alternate and spiral, or opposite-decussate or rarely whorled, frequently aggregated into rosettes, simple, rarely compound, usually entire or crenate to lobed, rarely dissected, estipulate. Inflorescences usually terminal, bracteate, usually many-flowered, basically thyrsoids, also pleio-, di-or monochasia (cincinni) or rarely true panicles, racemes or spikes. Flowers hermaphrodite, rarely unisexual, actinomorphic or very rarely zygomorphic, usually proterandrous, (3–)5(–32)merous; sepals free or connate at base, sometimes distinctly unequal in size; petals free or connate to a short to long corolla tube; stamens as many as or usually twice as many as petals; filaments free or ± connate with a tubular corolla; anthers basifixed in basal pit, 4-sporangiate, 2-locular at anthesis, dehiscence latrorse or slightly introrse by longitudinal slits; ovary usually ± superior to semi-inferior; carpels as many as petals, usually free or almost so, sessile or sometimes stipitate, tapering gradually to abruptly into short to long, erect to divergent stylodia, basally with a small to conspicuous dorsal nectary scale; stigma small, (sub)apical, often poorly differentiated; ovules usually many, rarely few to one, anatropous, crassi- or tenuinucellate, bitegmic, on parietal to marginal placentae. Fruits usually follicles, and usually ± completely dehiscent along the ventral suture, rarely few-seeded, indehiscent and nutlike; seeds smallish, usually 0.5–1 mm long, elongate-fusiform, longitudinally ridged (costate) or papillate (uni-or rarely multipapillate), rarely 1
U. Eggli provided the key and generic descriptions extracted from Eggli (2003) which were largely revised here.
(nearly) smooth, usually brownish; embryo small, straight; endosperm cellular, scanty. A family of 34 genera with c. 1,410 species distributed worldwide, usually in arid and/or rocky habitats, with centres of diversity in Mexico and South Africa. Vegetative Morphology. Crassulaceae are usually perennial herbs to (sub)shrubs, rarely small trees (the Malagasy Kalanchoe beharensis and K. dinklagei reach 8–10 m). The epicotyl is usually well developed; rarely does it remain very small (’t Hart 1982). In most perennials, the whole shoot system and at least some leaves survive unfavourable periods (frost, drought). Leaves are shed only when additional storage organs are present: succulent, ± elongated stems (e.g. Tylecodon) or small, tuber-like swollen stems (e.g. Dudleya subg. Hasseanthus). Rhizomes are usually sympodial, rarely monopodial (Rhodiola). In Aeonium, the modular growth form correlates with sectional classification (Jorgensen and Olesen 2000). Some highly reduced annual Crassula are morphologically aberrant: flowers of C. pageae are embedded in a short ‘disc’ derived from connate side shoots (coenosom, described in detail by Jäger-Zürn 1989), and C. aphylla forms leafless, ± globular shoots reaching maturity at about 3 mm Ø; it may represent the smallest succulent plant. Few Sedum from the Mediterranean and the Mexican Sierra Madre (Clausen 1977) are strictly biennial. Facultative annuals to perennials are found in Mediterranean Sedum and Macaronesian Aichryson and Monanthes icterica. Root apices often contain anthocyanins and are reddish. Roots are usually fibrous, rarely thickened-fusiform (Villadia p.p., Hylotelephium p.p.) or tuberous. Tuberous rhizomes or rootstocks may develop from the hypocotyl (Rhodiola rosea), the upper part of the main root and hypocotyl (Dudleya caespitosa), or the hypo- and epicotyl (Umbilicus). Sedum obtusifolium forms subter-
84
J. Thiede and U. Eggli
ranean runners with tuberous thickenings, and S. amplexicaule forms propagules from the swollen leaf bases clasping the stems. Secondary growth in roots and root tubers of Sedum and Hylotelephium is described by ’t Hart (1994a). Adventitious roots are formed by many prostrate to suberect shoots (e.g. many Sedum) or ± upright shoots of shrubs, especially under conditions of high air humidity (e.g. Aeonium); this ability is used for vegetative propagation in horticulture. Thickened short roots in Sempervivum, Sedum and some other genera which are inhabited by mycorrhizal symbionts (hyphomycetes, Berger 1930) need re-study. The root-nodules recently reported for Sinocrassula (Akiyama et al. 2001) may belong here. Germination is epigaeal and cotyledons are fleshy, usually petiolate and long persistent. Adult leaves are usually simple and only rarely pinnately compound (some Kalanchoe, e.g. K. pinnata), palmately lobed (Crassula alcicornis), laciniate (Kalanchoe laciniata) or peltate (Umbilicus sect. Umbilicus and a few Kalanchoe). The leaves are ± flat to subulate and often ± flat above and semi-terete below, partly with a ± developed keel. The leaf margin is usually entire or ± crenate (e.g. Umbiliceae), partly with cilia (e.g. many Aeonium). Heterophylly is found in some Orostachys and Rosularia (summer vs. winter rosette; Eggli 1988; Ebel et al. 1991a) and in Sedum diversifolium and S. greggii (sterile vs. flowering). Leaves typically break off easily and form adventitious shoots at the place of separation, a means of vegetative propagation in nature (e.g. Adromischus) which is widely used in horticulture. Many Kalanchoe species of sect. Bryophyllum form adventitious shoots (gemmae) on leaf margins. Sedum viviparum and S. gemmiferum form gemmae in the vegetative region, and Crassula multicava, Kalanchoe miniata, etc. within the inflorescences. The leaf arrangement is usually alternate (most Kalanchoideae and Sempervivoideae) or decussate (most Crassuloideae), rarely whorled (e.g. a few Sedum). Leaf aggregation in ± dense rosettes evolved independently in many genera of nearly all major clades (except Umbiliceae), especially within Sempervivoideae. In spirally arranged rosettes, the number of spirostichies may be of systematic value (e.g. Monanthes; Nyffeler 1992). The rosettes may be ± stem-less, with the leaves remaining attached to the stem at least for some time, or terminal at the shoot tips of (sub)shrubs, with dried leaves being usually shed. Stolons are a means of vegetative propagation in some rosettes (e.g. Semper-
vivum, Orostachys). The rosettes become ‘closed’ and form bud-like structures (‘resting rosettes’) during drought periods in some Aeonium (Ebel et al. 1991b), Orostachys (Ebel et al. 1991a) and Rosularia (Eggli 1988). Vegetative Anatomy. A detailed account was provided by Gregory (1998, with many references), from which data were taken if not cited otherwise. Soil root hairs are usually unicellular; those of aerial adventitious roots may be uni- or biseriately multicellular. The leaves are generally bifacial, succulent (weakly so in some Crassula (Tillaea) and few Sedum with small and thin scale-like leaves) and typically centric or intermediate between centric and dorsiventral. Palisade parenchyma is normally absent; the adaxial cells are sometimes palisade-like. Most leaves are thickish and exhibit a mesophyll with continuous transition from outer chlorenchyma to inner water-storage parenchyma with large achlorophyllous, highly vacuolated cells. Thinner leaves lack this differentiation and are chlorenchymatous throughout. Vascular bundles are collateral and in flat leaves in one row, in terete leaves in a circle, or irregular. Tissues often contain copious tannin. Solitary crystals and druses are common; crystal sand is found in Adromischus, Cotyledon, Kalanchoe and Umbilicus (also within secondary growth). The nodes were studied for few species only and vary even within genera (1-lacunar:1-trace; 1:2 or 1:3, 3:3, 3–multi:3–multi, or multi:3–8). Hydathodes of the ‘epithem’ type are present in many (all?) Crassulaceae. Crassuloideae typically have numerous hydathodes along the margin and/or on the leaf surface of one or both faces (Toelken 1977; Martin and von Willert 2000; see also under Physiology). Kalanchoideae and Sempervivoideae typically have one (sub)apical hydathode only (e.g. Rosularia, Eggli 1988); marginal hydathodes are rare, e.g. Aichryson p.p. (Caballero and Jiménez 1977) or Phedimus (’t Hart and Bleij 2003). The venation is pinnate or palmate and camptodromous or reticulate, usually with a distinct intramarginal vein. In ± flat leaves, the midvein typically protrudes at least on parts of the lower face. The leaf epidermis is usually one-, occasionally two- (to three)-layered. Outer walls are thin (mesomorphic) to extremely thick (xeromorphic), the anticlinal walls straight (especially in xeromorphic types) or wavy to markedly sinuous (especially in mesomorphic types). Some Crassula, Monanthes
Crassulaceae
and Tylecodon species exhibit enlarged epidermal cells (bladder-cell idioblasts). The cuticle is usually smooth or with fine striations (e.g. Aichryson) or distinct ridges (e.g. Aeonium). Epicuticular wax deposits are in rods, irregularly lobed platelets, threads, smooth platelets or a very thick layer fissured into platelets (Fehrenbach and Barthlott 1988). Stomata are usually superficial to somewhat sunken (some Crassula) or raised (some Sedum), and usually anisocytic or rarely helicocytic (Kalanchoe and Sedum) and mesogenous with 3–8(–10) subsidiary cells. Stomata are usually ± equally numerous on both faces, or more numerous abaxially (rarely adaxially) and usually irregularly orientated. The stomatal density is low, similarly to other leaf succulents, and about 5–80 per mm2 . Cystoliths are reported for Orostachys japonicus. Hairs occur usually on both leaf surfaces when present, with six types: (1) unicellular, simple, thick-walled; (2) unicellular swollen bladder-cell idioblasts with constricted base sometimes covering the epidermis completely; (3) most common are multicellular simple hairs with biseriate stalk which may be non-glandular or glandular with ± spherical heads of 2–12 secretory cells; (4) multicellular stellate hairs with 3(–6) apical arms (only in Malagasy Kalanchoe with dense-felty tomentum, e.g. K. beharensis; Boiteau and Allorge-Boiteau 1995); (5) multicellular sessile hairs with 2–3 basal cells and small head; and (6) multicellular uniseriate, simple or capitate hairs. On young stems, the periderm arises usually in the subepidermis, also in the epidermis or more deeply in the cortex and forms continuous rings or separate groups of cork cells. Additional cambia from the outer cortex sometimes lead to thick periderms (e.g. Kalanchoe beharensis). The cork is impregnated with resin in some Malagasy Kalanchoe. A peeling outer bark occurs in stem-succulent pachycauls (Tylecodon p.p., Aeonium smithii, some Sedum). The epidermal cells are thin-walled. Subepidermal collenchyma layer(s) are reported for some genera. The cortex is parenchymatous, sometimes with chlorophyll, and aerenchymatous in the semi-aquatic Crassula inanis (Moteetee and Nagendran 1997). A distinct endodermis is recorded for some genera. Secondary growth typically yields vessels, parenchyma and lignified fibres in distinct bands, layers, or as ground mass. The pith is parenchymatous, later sometimes lignified. Medullar bundles
85
are reported for some genera. Stem succulents often have secondary growth dominating in the parenchyma of cortex and pith. Growth rings are absent. The phloem is poorly developed. The wood structure is rather similar between unrelated genera and conspicuous in its juvenile features (raylessness, short vessels without variation in length and shape within the radius, and with secondary thickenings characteristic of the primary xylem), and differs strongly from the secondary wood of ‘normal’ woody plants. These differences were interpreted by ’t Hart and Koek-Noorman (1989) as resulting from paedomorphosis and were thought to indicate secondary woodiness derived from a primarily herbaceous ancestor (see also Phytochemistry). Vessel elements are moderately short (100–229 µm) with slightly inclined end walls. Perforation plates are simple (rarely reticulate in Sedum). Vessels have helical and annular lateral wall thickenings and/or scalariform(-reticulate) pitting. Libriform fibres are non-septate with simple pits and thin to thick walls, and form the major part of the wood in most species. Axial parenchyma is usually scanty paratracheal, but may rarely constitute the entire ground tissue, as in Crassula arborescens and some Monanthes. Cortical bundles are reported for some thick-stemmed taxa but are merely leaf-traces running ± vertically for some distance. The rhizome anatomy of Sedum tuberosum and Rhodiola rosea was described by ’t Hart (1982, 1994b). Ultrastructure. Crassulaceae exhibit the S0 type of sieve element plastids (without protein inclusions and without starch) not found elsewhere in Saxifragales (Behnke 1991). Chloroplast ultrastructure differs between C3 and CAM species (Teeri and Overton 1981). Inflorescence structure. Detailed data can be found in Troll (1964, 1969) and especially in Troll and Weberling (1989). Inflorescences are usually thyrsoids (monotelic, i.e. with a terminal flower). Rarely, the terminal flower may be reduced, partly together with the distal part of the inflorescence (Adromischus, Umbilicus). The partial inflorescences are dichasia (frequent in Crassuloideae, Kalanchoideae, Telephieae, Umbiliceae), monochasia (double or simple cincinni; frequent in Semperviveae, Aeonieae and Sedeae) or thyrsoids. They are sometimes concaulescent and thus branch off above their subtending bracts (e.g.
86
J. Thiede and U. Eggli
Aeonium), or the bracts are recaulescently shifted onto the partial inflorescences (e.g. Tylecodon reticulatus). Rarely, intercalar inhibition zones with bracts not subtending partial inflorescences are found (Aichryson, some Crassula). Some species produce pleiochasia (pseudowhorls of three or more distal partial inflorescences below the terminal flower); proximal partial inflorescences are absent or consist of few to single flowers only (e.g. Sempervivum tectorum). Cymoids with one cincinnus or two cincinni below the terminal flower are also frequent. In uniflowered species, only the terminal flower is developed. Obligately uniflowered inflorescences appear to be rare (e.g. Sedum humifusum). In Kalanchoe, all intermediates from manyflowered thyrsoids over racemes to solitary flowers occur. True panicles (some Adromischus and Umbilicus), racemes (some Umbilicus), double racemes (Umbilicus oppositifolius) or spikes (some Adromischus) are rare. The presence of prophylls, as in the botryoids (e.g. Villadia imbricata), is interpreted as derived from thyrsoids. Lateral inflorescences occur in some Sedum, Aichryson, Aeonium, Rosularia, Prometheum and throughout in Afrovivella, Meterostachys, Rhodiola, Dudleya and the Echeveria group. Flower Structure. Pedicels are distinct to (nearly) wanting. Either two, one or no prophylls are present. The flowers are usually upright to spreading, rarely pendent (then, again upright in the fruiting stage) and nearly always hermaphrodite (plants dioecious in Rhodiola p.p.). The length of the flowers ranges from a few mm (some Crassula [Tillaea]) to 140 mm (Kalanchoe marmorata). Flowers are actinomorphic, slightly zygomorphic only in Tylecodon grandiflorus, Kalanchoe elizae and K. robusta, (3–)5(–32)merous, and differ strongly in the degree of sympetaly (see, for instance, Figs. 28, 30). The sepals are usually green, (nearly) free or ± connate and usually much shorter than the corolla. They are usually equal and basally connate with the receptacle, or (in Sedum subg. Sedum) often free and ± spurred at base and unequal in size. Petal aestivation is quincuncial, cochlear, or contorted in Sedum (’t Hart 1990), imbricate or contorted in Crassula, convolute in Dudleya, imbricate in Sedella, Thompsonella and most Echeveria, and valvate in a few Echeveria. The petals are typically thin-textured (rarely membranous in annual Crassula), rarely thickish-succulent (e.g. Echeve-
ria), frequently dorsally keeled and sometimes papillose to hairy, and completely free or slightly to nearly completely connate to a corolla tube. Sympetaly is found in all Kalanchoideae and is frequent in many Sempervivoideae where it is of multiple origins (’t Hart et al. 1999; Mort et al. 2001). Petals are yellow, red, white, greenish to brownish with intermediates, very rarely blue (e.g. Sedum caeruleum), often unicoloured, partly bi- to rarely tricoloured (e.g. many Echeveria), sometimes with dots (some Pachyphytum) or irregular spottings (most Graptopetalum). Petals rarely have subapical unifacial precursory tips (‘Vorläuferspitzen’; e.g. Crassula subg. Crassula, many Sedum, some Villadia). Leinfellner (1954) studied the basal petal scales of Pachyphytum, which are also found in some Echeveria. The androecium is obhaplostemonous (Crassuloideae; then, antesepalous stamens only) or more frequently obdiplostemonous (most Kalanchoideae and Sempervivoideae). In obdiplostemonous androecia, the antesepalous stamens are typically longer. In sympetalous corollas, the stamens are ± connate with the tube; the antepetalous (always?) inserted somewhat higher than the antesepalous ones. The filaments are free from each other, usually ± thin-filiform, rarely broadened or thickened. The anthers are usually about 1 mm long, but are longer in long-tubed flowers. Anther colours are usually yellow or red, but also orange, purple, brown, black, white, pink and green with nearly all intermediates and partly infraspecific variation; they are of some taxonomic value (Thiede, unpubl. data). The gynoecium is nearly exclusively isomerous with the perianth (oligomerous only in Sedum tricarpum and S. bonnieri). The ovary is usually superior and the carpels are (nearly) completely free, rarely connate higher up and completely connate only in Crassula pageae (Jäger-Zürn 1989). Soltis et al. (2003) suggested that the ovary in Crassulaceae is secondarily superior, according to a characterstate reconstruction based on molecular data. The carpels narrow gradually to abruptly into separate, erect to divergent stylodia which are usually short to very long in long-tubed flowers. The stigma is small, often poorly differentiated, usually terminal (lateral in some Crassula, Toelken 1977). A compitum is recorded from some Echeveria. The carpels nearly always exhibit nectary scales at their dorsal bases (absent in a few Crassula, Sedum and Aeonium), which are usually less than 1 mm long and very diverse in shape and colour.
Crassulaceae
In Monanthes, Sedum surculosum, S. longipes and S. pentastamineum, the large, petaloid nectary scales are more obvious than the petals. Floral Development and Anatomy. Floral anatomy, vasculature and development have been described in general by Wassmer (1955), Jensen (1966) and Quimby (1971), for Sedum, Crassula and Phedimus by Eckert (1966), for Kalanchoe by Tillson (1940), for Hylotelephium by ’t Hart (1985c) and for Crassula pageae by Jäger-Zürn (1989). During ontogenesis, sepals develop much earlier than petals (Wassmer 1955). The haplostemonous Crassula dejecta lacks antepetalous (outer) stamens and otherwise develops as the obdiplostemonous Sedum acre, thus indicating that flowers in Crassulaceae are probably basically obdiplostemonous (Eckert 1966). The anthers are median-sagittate in shape (transverse-sagittate in other Saxifragales studied by Endress and Stumpf 1991). Anthers are basifixed, and the filament is attached to the connective with its very thin upper end in the basal pit (dorsifixed only in Rhodiola hobsonii). Anthers are usually latrorse, slightly introrse only in Crassula, Sinocrassula yunnanensis and Umbilicus rupestris (as U. pendulinus; Wassmer 1955) and usually caducous. The anther epidermis is astomate and shows different types (Endress and Stumpf 1991). Apical connective protrusions with different shapes were found in several genera (Wassmer 1955; Endress and Stumpf 1991); in Kalanchoe they may function as secretory glands (Raadts 1979). The carpels are open in early developmental stages and postgenitally connate and are mainly plicate. Carpels within a flower are congenitally connate at least for a short distance below and postgenitally above; completely free carpels have not been found. Ontogenetic studies suggest that the nectary scales represent emergences of the carpels (Wassmer 1955). They exude nectar through stomata (Said 1982). Embryology. Embryology was studied especially by Mauritzon (1930, 1933), and also by Rocén (1928), Souèges (1936) and Fétré and Lebègue (1964). Reviews are by Davis (1966) and Johri et al. (1992), from which most data were taken. The anther wall comprises a persistent epidermis, a one-layered fibrous endothecium, two ephemeral middle layers, and the secretory, uninucleate tapetum. Microsporogenesis is simultaneous. Pollen is shed in monads. It is binucleate and sometimes contains starch grains. The ovules are
87
anatropous, bitegmic and crassinucellate in Kalanchoideae and Sempervivoideae, and tenuinucellate in Crassuloideae. The micropyle is usually formed by both integuments which are both 2-layered. The embryo sac is usually of the normal Polygonum type. In Hylotelephium, an embryo sac of the bisporic Allium type develops from the chalazal dyad. In Prometheum, haustoria are given off from the megaspores and pass through the nucellus into the integuments; such megaspore haustoria are a rather unusual feature. The embryo sac generally contains starch grains. Endosperm formation is ab initio cellular, usually with a chalazal endosperm haustorium, and differs between Crassuloideae and Kalanchoideae/Sempervivoideae (Mauritzon 1933). The endosperm is scanty, fleshy and typically reduced to a 1-layered cap surrounding the hypocotyl (Krach 1976). The zygote divides into embryo, suspensor and a suspensor-haustorium within the nucellus (Mauritzon 1933). The embryogeny conforms to the Caryophyllad type. The embryo is small, long and straight, without a plumula, and stores aleuron as well as oil (Krach 1976). Pollen Morphology. The pollen is usually 3-colporate and subspheroidal to prolate in equatorial view, ± convex-triangular in polar view, and 13–38 µm long. Apertures are lalongate. The sexine is about as thick as the nexine. The tectum is complete and usually striate, reticulate, rugulate or cerebroid (Hideux 1981). The striae have a straight or rarely irregular margin (Monanthes). More rarely, the tectum is (nearly) completely smooth (Sempervivum sect. Jovibarba; Rosularia p.p., Prometheum) or has a fine OL-pattern. Colpi are tenuimarginate, with the thin exine usually protruding at the equatorial part of the colpi (Erdtman 1952). Pollen morphology may vary within the same inflorescence and is thus of restricted systematic applicability (Kim 1994). Data are based on an overview SEM study by Hideux (1981), more focused SEM studies for Sempervivum (incl. Jovibarba; Parnell 1991), European Sedum (’t Hart 1975), Rosularia and Prometheum (Eggli 1988), Monanthes (Nyffeler 1992), Korean Sedum (Kim 1994) and Korean Crassulaceae (Sin et al. 2002), and on light microscopy for Aeonium (Pérez de Paz 1980). Pollen morphology of Crassulaceae is similar to that of Saxifragaceae (Erdtman 1952). Karyology. Crassulaceae display an extensive variation in chromosome numbers among and often within genera and often among species,
88
J. Thiede and U. Eggli
and possibly represent the karyologically most diverse family of angiosperms. The base number for the family and subfamilies Crassuloideae and Sempervivoideae, x(n) = 8, is also found in outgroups (Penthoraceae, Haloragaceae). The basic chromosome numbers for the major clades have been reconstructed by Mort et al. (2001). Many studies have been conducted on North American taxa (Graptopetalum and Thompsonella, Uhl 1970; Pachyphytum, Uhl and Moran 1973; Sedum, Uhl 1976–1992; Echeveria, Uhl 1994–2005; intergeneric hybrids, Uhl 1993–1995; Lenophyllum, Uhl 1996; Villadia, Uhl and Moran 1999), on European Sedum by ’t Hart (especially 1985a, 1991), on European and Macaronesian Semperviva by Uhl (1961), on Rosularia by ’t Hart and Eggli (1998), on Crassula by Merxmüller et al. (1971) and Friedrich (1973), and on Kalanchoideae by Uhl (1948). The Asian taxa are less thoroughly studied (Uhl and Moran 1972; Wakabayashi and Ohba 1999). Karyotypes are typically rather symmetrical and the chromosomes small (less than 1 or 2 µm), so that pairs and structural details can hardly be recognised. Satellites are present in Crassula subg. Crassula (Friedrich 1973) and some other genera (Sharma and Gosh 1967). Most larger and also some smaller genera exhibit different base numbers and few to many polyploids, partly including high polyploids. Closely related genera often, but not always, exhibit different base numbers. Karyological variability reaches an extreme in Sedum and especially in the Echeveria group (Uhl 1992). Among the 62 studied European/Mediterranean Sedum species, about 140 cytotypes with all base numbers from 5 to 18 and some higher ones (20, 22, 24, 25, 29, 37) have been found. The data show that 64% of these cytotypes are polyploid, and nearly half of the species exhibit polyploids among diploids, some of them high polyploids (S. rubens: 20×) or complete series (S. forsterianum: 2 to 8×), partly also dysploids (’t Hart 1991). The high degree of polyploidy is attributed at least partly to allopolyploidy (’t Hart 1991), which was demonstrated experimentally (’t Hart et al. 1993). The Mexican Sedum suaveolens exhibits the highest chromosome number in angiosperms, n = 320 (= 40×). See also under Reproductive Systems. Pollination and Reproductive Systems. Flower induction in Kalanchoe is under short-day conditions (Engelmann 1960), whereas Hylotelephium telephium is a long-day plant (’t Hart and
van Arkel 1985). In Echeveria, short- as well as long-day plants are found (Rünger and Wehr 1969). Flowers are usually proterandrous, with the anthers of the antesepalous (inner) stamens releasing pollen before the anthers of the antepetalous (outer) ones. Sometimes, anthers dehisce already within the floral bud (Wassmer 1955). Proterogyny and homogamy are rare (e.g. some European Sedum). Differentiation among the two whorls for allogamy (stamens of outer whorl bending over petals) and autogamy (inner whorl remaining erect or bending over stylodia), respectively, is common in European Sedum and Sempervivum (Günthart 1902). Stamen movements are extreme in Graptopetalum, where the stamens curve back towards the sepals and petals during anthesis (Moran 1949). Crassula (Tillaea) muscosa is autogamous, and C. aquatica appears to be cleistoand autogamous (Berger 1930); some tendency towards cleistogamy has also been observed in Sempervivum sect. Jovibarba (Günthart 1902:61). Crassulaceae appear to be usually selfincompatible but Sedum sect. Gormania shows self-compatibility in varying degrees (Denton 1979). Fecundity in Echeveria gibbiflora is limited by pollen and resource availability (Parra et al. 1998). In Hylotelephium telephium, di-, tri- and tetraploid cytotypes are sympatric (’t Hart 1985b). Studies on the conservation genetics of Rhodiola integrifolia subsp. leedyi (Olfelt et al. 1998, 2001) and Dudleya multicaulis (Marchant et al. 1998) revealed a high intrapopulation genetic variation, indicating little gene flow among the isolated populations. Floral biology is poorly studied and largely restricted to the establishment of floral types and pollination syndromes. The carpellary nectary scales exude nectar in large quantities, which often forms glistening droplets. The few Crassulaceae without nectary scales may have deceptive flowers. Five major pollination syndromes are found (mostly taken from Vogel 1954). 1. Melittophily is assumed for taxa with a free, rotately spreading (e.g. most Sedum, many Telephieae and Umbiliceae, Aeonium, Sempervivum) or short tubular corolla (e.g. many Crassula species, Kalanchoe p.p., Tylecodon p.p. (Gess et al. 1998), Umbilicus). It represents the most frequent and least specialised, possibly plesiomorphic syndrome in Crassulaceae. 2. Psychophily corresponds to long-tubed salvershaped flowers (Adromischus, Pistorinia,
Crassulaceae
Kalanchoe, e.g. K. rotundifolia) or flowers with at least connivent petals forming a tube-like structure (e.g. Crassula coccinea) and intensive colouration (red, yellow) and scent production over the day. This floral type has earlier led to artificial generic segregations (e.g. Rochea for long-‘tubed’ Crassula species such as C. coccinea). 3. The sphingophilous syndrome (long, whitish corolla tubes, nocturnal scent) appears to be restricted to a few Crassula (e.g. C. fascicularis; detailed study by Johnson et al. 1993) and some Kalanchoe (e.g. K. marmorata), and thus to Africa. 4. Ornithophilous flowers (red, long-tubed corollas, lack of odour, abundant nectar production, exserted anthers) are found in species of Kalanchoe, Cotyledon, Tylecodon, Echeveria (Parra et al. 1993) and Dudleya. There appears to be a gradual transition from psycho- or melittophily to ornithophily. The psychophilous Crassula coccinea is also visited by nectar birds (Vogel 1954). In Dudleya, the gradual shift from bee to hummingbird pollination has been demonstrated to be accompanied by changes in nectar amount, increase in tube length, colour shift to reddish corollas, and shift from low to high auto-fertility (Levin and Mulroy 1985). 5. Myophily is assumed for Monanthes (open flowers with darkish colours, freely accessible nectar produced by large nectary scales; Vogel 1954). Carrion flies are possible pollinators for the fade-coloured and foetid flowers of most Graptopetalum (Moran and Meyrán 1974). In both genera, the darkish to fade flower colours are accompanied by corresponding anther colours (Thiede, unpubl. data). Some Crassula and Sedum species with small, insignificant whitish flowers with a musky scent are probably also fly-pollinated. The report of effective ant pollination for Sedum pusillum is one of the few known cases of ant pollination in angiosperms (Wyatt and Stoneburger 1981). When exploiting the freely accessible nectar from the nectary scales, the ants ‘accidentally’ transfer pollen over the dense stands of the plant, but bee pollination also occurs. Flower visits by ants were also reported for Kalanchoe (Bahadur et al. 1986) and may be more frequent, at least accidentally. Melittophily is widespread and dominates in the northern temperate region, whereas psycho-,
89
sphingo- and ornithophily are restricted to (sub)tropical or southern temperate regions. Pollination syndromes in southern Africa are more diversified than in North America. The derived pollination syndromes are certainly of multiple origin within Crassulaceae, possibly from the plesiomorphic melittophily. Hybridisation patterns in European Sedeae are strictly correlated with the presence or absence of four morphological character states (see Subdivision). Species can be hybridised only when they agree in all four character states, but not all hybrids are possible (’t Hart and Koek-Noorman 1989). In Aeonieae, hybridisation patterns correspond to present generic boundaries between Aichryson, Monanthes and Aeonium (incl. Greenovia): no hybrids between genera, but many within these genera are possible. The c. 200 species of the Echeveria group appear to be fully interfertile (though natural hybrids are rare) and form the largest comparium known among angiosperms (Uhl 1992). Fruit and Seed. Fruits are usually many-seeded follicles which dehisce xerochastically; hygrochastic opening is rare (e.g. Sedum acre). Fruit dehiscence is sometimes reversible under humid conditions (Phedimus aizoon; Huber 1961) or, vice versa, the suture opens fully only under humid conditions but closes again when drying out (Sedum acre and S. annum; Stopp 1957). The ripe follicles either remain upright (orthocarpic) or become divergent to stellate-patent (kyphocarpic). An earlier classification of Sedum based on these features (Fröderström 1930–1935) proved to be artificial. Follicles of most genera dehisce completely along the ventral suture; other types are more rare: the suture mainly opens apically or basally only, or the plicate carpel part breaks off as a whole (Aeonium sect. Greenovia). Some species of Crassula sect. Glomeratae have only 1- or 2-seeded follicles from which the upper part breaks off with circumscissile splits and encloses one or two seeds (Stopp 1957; Toelken 1977). Similar fruits are found in Hypagophytum and some Sedum. Sedella and Sedum microcarpum have one-seeded, non-dehiscent nutlike fruits, and the fruits of Sedum smallii dehisce with a tear-shaped flap unique within the family (Clausen 1975). In European Sedum, kyphocarpic follicles usually exhibit carpel walls broadened to ± distinct ‘lips’ (possibly favouring splash-cup dispersal by rain), whereas orthocarpic follicles are without lips (’t Hart 1991).
90
J. Thiede and U. Eggli
Fig. 26. Crassulaceae. Seed surface structures. A Crassula streyi. Sinuate (unipapillate) (‘Puzzle-Modell’ of Knapp 1994): anticlinal walls sinuate, periclinal walls usually convex to centrally papillate or rarely almost smooth (Crassuloideae). Types B–D Anticlinal walls straight. B Kalanchoe brachyloba. Costate (bipapillate) (‘Leitermodell’): cells with two papillae at each distal end. The papillae remain ± free or are mostly fused to form distinct costae with those of the neighbouring cells, partly with transverse connections (Kalanchoideae and all Sempervivoideae,
except for the following). C Umbilicus horizontalis. Multipapillate (‘Warzenmodell’): cells with 2–3(–5) small papillae which are usually unequal in size and form small groups with those of adjacent cells (only genus Umbilicus within tribe Umbiliceae). D Sedum wrightii. Reticulate (unipapillate) (‘Wabenmodell’): the lateral cell-walls are always thickened and form a distinct reticulate pattern, usually with a central papilla (Acre clade). Scale: A 100 µm, B 1,000 µm, C, D 10 µm. (A, C From Knapp 1997 and B, D from Knapp 1994)
The seeds are ± oblong-fusiform, ± brownish, usually 0.5–1 mm long and weighing c. 0.02 mg (Sempervivum). The East African Sedum epidendrum and the Mexican S. botteri and related species exhibit seeds up to 3 mm in length, a possible adaptation to their epiphytic habitats (Clausen 1959: 46; Gilbert 1985). The seed coat is 4-layered: the exotestal cells have a ± thickened outer wall, the inner exotegmic cell layer is pigmented, and the two middle layers are completely crushed (Krach 1976). The chalazal region is obtusely
rounded or elongated to acute (apiculate; Fig. 26B; Knapp 1994: 163). The micropylar region is partly surrounded by the outcurved testa which forms a distinct corona (Fig. 26B; Kalanchoideae, some Sedum; ’t Hart and Koek-Noorman 1989; Knapp 1994: 163). In SEM studies of testa structures (’t Hart and Berendsen 1980, for Sedum; Knapp 1994, 1997), four main types are distinguished, differing mainly in the number and position of papillae and concurring well with phylogenetic patterns (Fig. 26A–D): A sinuate-unipapillate with
Crassulaceae
sinuate anticlinal walls, or B costate-bipapillate, C multipapillate and D reticulate-unipapillate with straight anticlinal walls. Specific SEM datasets have been published for Crassula (Bywater 1980; Wickens and Bywater 1980; Bywater and Wickens 1983), Sedum sect. Ternata (Calie 1981), Sedum sect. Gormania (Denton 1982), Rosularia and Prometheum (Eggli 1988), Monanthes (Nyffeler 1992) and East Asian taxa (Gontcharova 1999). Dispersal. The follicles usually release the seeds immediately after ripening. The seeds are dispersed by gravity and wind, but are much larger than typical anemochorous dust seeds (e.g. orchids, many parasites). Nakanishi (2002) recorded splash-cup dispersal by raindrops for the divergent follicles of two Japanese Sedum spp.; this mechanism may be more frequent. The seed number in Crassulaceae may be very high (an old inflorescence of Aeonium nobile was estimated to produce about 50,000 flowers (Burchard 1929) and 500,000 or even much more seeds). Most seeds are dispersed over short distances as anemochorous seed rain around the mother plant (Parra et al. 1993). Anemochorous long-distance dispersal appears to be rare, as evidenced, e.g. by the closely related island vicariants on the Canary Islands, and the rarity of pronounced disjunctions. Evidence for long-distance dispersal comes from molecular data (van Ham and ’t Hart 1998; Mort et al. 2001). Berger (1930) suggested the possibility of secondary dispersal by water and ants, but evidence is wanting. Ripe seeds typically remain viable for a few years only or even less. On wet soil, seeds typically germinate within a few days (in cultivation) and generally in light. Studies on the germination ecology of the winter annuals Sedum pulchellum and S. smallii from the eastern USA revealed after-ripening of the seeds during summer, which is interpreted as an adaptation to summer-dry habitats (Baskin and Baskin 1972, 1977). Phytochemistry. Reviews are given by Hegnauer (1964, 1989) and Stevens (1995a, b). Crassulaceae accumulate large amounts of sedoheptulose, which is the most abundant sugar in most species. In contrast to many other succulents, nearly all species investigated to date contain isocitrate (Hegnauer 1964). Proanthocyanidins (condensed tannins) have been found in all clades, except for the Acre clade
91
where they are absent or at least rare and replaced by alkaloids (Stevens et al. 1992, 1995; Stevens 1995a). Proanthocyanidins are widespread both in woody and herbaceous Crassulaceae. The lack of exclusivity in the woody representatives supports the hypothesis that Crassulaceae are primarily herbaceous (Stevens 1995a), which is also supported by wood anatomy (see there). Galloyl esters are common, but ellagitannins are absent, in contrast to Saxifragaceae and Penthoraceae (Jay 1971). Flavonols and flavones, both unmethylated and methylated, are known to occur in Crassulaceae, but myricetin is rare (Denton and Kerwin 1980; Hegnauer 1989; Stevens et al. 1996). Wax composition (in particular, alkane and triterpene profiles) has been studied by Eglinton et al. (1962), Manheim et al. (1979), Bowman (1983) and Stevens et al. (1994). Since the isolation of sedamin from Sedum acre in 1939, many different pyrrolidine and piperidine alkaloids have been detected in Sedum subg. Sedum (several studies on Sedum acre; see Hegnauer 1989; Stevens et al. 1993) and in Echeveria. Alkaloids thus seem to be restricted to the Acre clade, but they are absent in its more derived members (except Echeveria; Stevens et al. 1992, 1995). Cyanogenic substances have been found in some, but not all Crassulaceae studied. Cyanogenesis is weak especially in Sedum, and several species appear to be polymorphic in this respect (Hegnauer 1989). The South African Tylecodon paniculatus contains toxic bufadienolides which may cause a lethal cattle disease (‘krimpsiekte’). Structurally similar poisons occur in Tylecodon grandiflorus, Cotyledon and Kalanchoe (incl. Bryophyllum; Hegnauer 1989). Bufadienolides from Kalanchoe (Bryophyllum) are reported as potent, novel antitumor agents (Yamagishi et al. 1989) and insecticidal compounds (Supratman et al. 2001). Subdivision and Relationships Within the Family. The infrafamilial classification is under debate over the last 200 years (review by ’t Hart and Eggli 1995). Most classifications relied heavily on a few trivial characters such as habit, leaf arrangement, number of floral parts, degree of petal fusion, number of stamens, and position of ripe follicles. However, most of these characters are of restricted value due to extensive homoplasy (’t Hart 1995; van Ham and ’t Hart 1998; Mort et al. 2001). Molecular data (’t Hart et al. 1999) indicated
92
J. Thiede and U. Eggli
that sympetaly originated six times independently in European Crassulaceae of the Leucosedum clade. The widely accepted classification by Berger (1930) suffered strongly from such inadequacies. For instance, subfamily Cotyledonoideae, which includes Berger’s African/Eurasian sympetalous Crassulaceae, has long been revealed as artificial (e.g. Uhl 1948). ’t Hart and Koek-Noorman (1989) and ’t Hart (1991) discovered hitherto largely unrecognised characters of considerable systematic value in European Sedum and related genera: interspecific crossbreeding is possible only between species which agree in the character states for testa ornamentation (costate vs. reticulate-papillate), shape of the micropylar region (coronate vs. apiculate), sepal insertion (free vs. connate at base), and presence or absence of glandular hairs. Groups characterised by these long-overlooked characters usually agree well with those of molecular studies. Many other, such more cryptic characters have been established as synapomorphies for the major clades by Thiede (unpubl. data). Molecular data (cpDNA trnL-trnF spacer sequences: ’t Hart 1995; cpDNA RFLPs: van Ham and ’t Hart 1998; cpDNA matK sequences: Mort et al. 2001) led to the recognition of seven major clades; an eighth clade has recently been found (nuclear ITS and trnL-trnF sequences; Mayuzumi and Ohba 2004). From the six subfamilies of Berger, only the largely monogeneric Crassuloideae (Crassula) and Kalanchoideae (Kalanchoe s.l.) were found to be monophyletic. Here, the revised classification of Thiede (unpubl. data) is adopted, which largely follows the sequencing convention (Fig. 27), i.e. it assigns the same rank to clades which branch off subsequently (three major clades: subfamilies; five major clades within Sempervivoideae: tribes). This contrasts with a previous proposal by ’t Hart (1995), who followed the ranking convention and classified the two sister-clades of subsequent di-
chotomies with formal ranks in descending order. Here, three subfamilies are recognised, as suggested earlier by Thorne (1983, 1992): the two morphologically well-supported Crassula and Kalanchoe clades are recognised as Crassuloideae (Crassula clade) and Kalanchoideae (Kalanchoe clade) respectively, and the remaining six clades are subsumed as Sempervivoideae (formerly Sedoideae). Within the latter, five tribes are recognised (Fig. 27): the Hylotelephium clade as tribe Telephieae, the Rhodiola clade as tribe Umbiliceae, the Sempervivum “clade” as tribe Semperviveae, the Aeonium clade as tribe Aeonieae, and the Leucosedum and Acre clades together as tribe Sedeae. It should be noted that the Crassula and Kalanchoe clades, which preferentially are (sub)tropical, are morphologically highly derived (see diagnoses of subfamilies Crassuloideae and Kalanchoideae), whereas the predominantly temperate Sempervivoideae largely retain the basic features of the family which have been recognised by outgroup comparison. For this reason, the taxonomic treatment starts with subfamily Sempervivoideae characterised by the basic features of the family. Molecular data (’t Hart 1995; van Ham and ’t Hart 1998; ’t Hart et al. 1999; Mort et al. 2001) indicated that Sedum, by far the largest genus of Crassulaceae, is highly paraphyletic. Sedum encompasses the least specialised species groups within the Semperviveae, Aeonieae and Sedeae, and is definable with plesiomorphic features only. All other genera in these tribes are derived from within Sedum and form a monophyletic lineage together with the latter. This implies that many segregates of Sedum are closely related to other genera in the Sempervivum, Aeonium, Acre and Leucosedum clades. In order to reflect phylogenetic relations within Semperviveae, Aeonieae and Sedeae, the segregates of Sedum identified to date by molecular studies are placed according to these molecular data. For most segregates, no generic names other than Se-
Fig. 27. Summary tree of Crassulaceae, showing the eight major clades, their number of genera/species (incl. Sedum), their main distribution, and the formal classification. The number of synapomorphies for the major clades (if any) is indicated above the branches; bootstrap support below the branches (∗ = 50–70%; ∗∗ = 71–90%; ∗∗∗ = 91–100%). The genus Pistorinia of tribe Sedeae is not included. Further explanations are provided in the text. Combined from molecular data of van Ham and ’t Hart (1998), cpDNA restriction sites, Sempervivum clade; Mayuzumi and Ohba (2004) and
Mayuzumi (unpubl. data), ITS and trnL-F sequences, Hylotelephium and Rhodiola clades; Mes et al. (1995), trnLF sequences, Aeonium clade; Mort et al. (2002), matK, trnL-F, psbA-trnH and ITS sequences, Aeonium clade; and Mort et al. (2001), matK sequences, all other clades. Abbreviations: Appendic. = subsect. Appendiculatae, S. = Sedum with [G] = subg. Gormania and [S] = subg. Sedum, Medit. = Mediterranean, Eur. = Europe, N. East = Near East, Umbilic. = Umbiliceae, Semper. = Semperviveae, Kalan. = Kalanchoideae, Cras. = Crassuloideae
Crassulaceae
93
94
J. Thiede and U. Eggli
dum are available (except for Petrosedum or perhaps Oreosedum, Amerosedum, etc.). However, the phylogenetic status of most of these segregates is insufficiently known, not to mention the dearth of morphological characters which could define them. Therefore, they are all classified here under Sedum but mentioned in the respective clades along with the genera most closely related to them. It is unlikely, and not intended, that any of these segregates will ever be elevated to generic status. The inclusion of all genera derived from within Sedum into a broadly defined, then monophyletic Sedum would be highly impractical because of the dramatic morphological heterogeneity of the resulting taxon. The other course, splitting Sedum into numerous constituent monophyletic taxa, would result in a tremendous increase of very small genera usually ill-defined morphologically; most of these can not be identified with present knowledge. A third option would be the inclusion of the segregates of Sedum into the existing, cladistically contiguous genera. Again, apart from presently insufficient knowledge and lack of morphological characters of these clades, several consist only of species of Sedum and do not contain a genus with which these could be united taxonomically (see particularly the molecular data for European Sedum by ’t Hart et al. 1999). Here, we follow ’t Hart’s (1995) suggestion to accept Sedum as a paraphyletic grouping. Genera derived from within Sedum should be monophyletic and for practical reasons not monospecific, and morphologically well defined (cf. ’t Hart 1995: 165), but this is not yet achieved for all genera (see especially the Echeveria group). A molecular clock model dates the origin of Crassulaceae at 69–77 Ma B.P., of the Crassuloideae/Kalanchoideae+Sempervivoideae split at 39–41 Ma B.P., of the Kalanchoideae/Sempervivoideae split at 25–29 Ma B.P., and of the split between the Leucosedum and Acre clades at 13–18 Ma B.P. (Wikström et al. 2001; cf. Fig. 27). A complete species-level taxonomic synopsis is provided by Eggli (2003). Affinities. Crassulaceae were usually placed next to Saxifragaceae and the monogeneric Penthoraceae, either within Rosales (Cronquist 1968; Thorne 1968) or Saxifragales (Takhtajan 1969; Thorne 1992). The circumscription of Crassulaceae is nearly undisputed, except for the inclusion of Penthorum by some authors (de Candolle 1828; Torrey and Gray 1838; Schönland 1894; Hutchinson
1973). Molecular data (Morgan and Soltis 1993; Soltis and Soltis 1997; Fishbein et al. 2001) establish the monophyly of Crassulaceae. Putative morphological synapomorphies are leaf succulence, anisocytic stomata and carpellary nectary scales. Homoplasious synapomorphies are thyrsoid inflorescences, papillate seeds and obdiplostemony, which are shared with Saxifragaceae; papillate seeds are also found in Penthoraceae. Penthorum, formerly included in Crassulaceae, approaches some Phedimus species and its peculiar fruit is similar to that of Sedum (Diamorpha), but it differs clearly from Crassulaceae in its non-succulent leaves with anomocytic stomata, its vessel and fibre structure, its diplostemonous flowers, in having the follicles connate almost to the middle, the lack of carpellary nectary scales, the presence of an operculum, and in its chemistry (see Penthoraceae, this volume). Saxifragaceae differ primarily in their oligomerous gynoecium, the presence of a nectariferous disc and of non-succulent leaves with stipules or sheathing leaf bases, and usually anomocytic stomata (see Saxifragaceae, this volume). According to molecular data, Crassulaceae belong to a distinct clade within Saxifragales, from which Crassulaceae, Aphanopetalaceae, Tetracarpaeaceae, Penthoraceae and Haloragaceae branch off successively. Stevens (2005) lists an axis with endodermis, nodes 1:1 and the lack of stipules as putative morphological synapomorphies. This clade is in turn sister to a clade which includes Saxifragaceae, Grossulariaceae, Iteaceae and Altingiaceae (Savolainen, Chase et al. 2000; Savolainen, Fay et al. 2000; Soltis et al. 2000; Fishbein et al. 2001). Distribution and Habitats. Crassulaceae occur almost worldwide. General distribution patterns and centres of diversity are described by ’t Hart (1997a); for North America, a detailed survey is given by Thiede (1995), and climatic correlations are presented by Teeri et al. (1978). More focused datasets have been published for Sedum (Böttcher and Jäger 1984), European taxa (Meusel et al. 1965; Jalas et al. 1999), Mediterranean Sedum (’t Hart 1997b), Crassula (Jürgens 1995), Tylecodon and Cotyledon (van Jaarsveld 1994), and Rhodiola (Ohba 1989). Crassulaceae are often viewed as a typical northern temperate element, but species diversity is concentrated in Mexico (about 325 species) and South Africa (about 250 species). The taxa of the eastern USA and especially the Mexican upland regions represent a distinct terminal clade within
Crassulaceae
the Acre clade, including the majority of North American Crassulaceae (van Ham and ’t Hart 1998; Mort et al. 2001). Southern African Crassulaceae belong exclusively to Crassuloideae (Crassula) and Kalanchoideae (van Ham and ’t Hart 1998; Mort et al. 2001). Genera of the latter are predominantly distributed in either the winter-rainfall (Tylecodon, Adromischus) or the summer-rainfall region (Kalanchoe). Cotyledon and Crassula are distributed in both regions, but many sections in the latter are specialised (Jürgens 1995). Diversity centres of secondary importance are the wider Californian winter-rainfall region (lineage within the Leucosedum clade with Sedella, Dudleya and the American Sedum subg. Gormania), Macaronesia (Aeonieae and a few Sedum species of the Acre clade), the Mediterranean (mainly Leucosedum clade: Sedum subg. Gormania, Pistorinia and Rosularia, and a few Sedum subg. Sedum in the Acre clade), the wider Himalayan region (Telephieae and Umbiliceae and the Asian Sedum subg. Sedum), East and Northeast Africa (Crassula, Kalanchoe, Sedum, Cotyledon, Hypagophytum, Afrovivella), and Madagascar (Kalanchoe, Perrierosedum, a few Crassula). All these centres, except for the Himalayan one, exhibit at least one or two (near-)endemic genera. Crassulaceae are poorly represented in the humid tropics as well as in South America (Thiede 1995) and Australia (Toelken 1986). Most genera are confined to a single continent. Exceptions are Sedum, Kalanchoe, the circumboreal Rhodiola and Hylotelephium, and the semi-aquatic Crassula (Tillaea), the worldwide distribution of which is attributed to long-distance dispersal by birds (Bywater and Wickens 1983). Of the genera restricted to the New World, only Echeveria and Villadia extend to South America, separated by a broad gap in Central America; all others are confined to North America and Guatemala (Thiede 1995). Migration and diversification of Crassulaceae principally followed the route (southern) Africa → Asia → Europe-Mediterranean → (northern) America (Fig. 27; see also van Ham and ’t Hart 1998 and Mort et al. 2001). Since Crassuloideae and Kalanchoideae are mainly southern African (Fig. 27), a first major diversification in southern Africa is assumed. The next branching clades, Telephieae and Umbiliceae, are mainly Asian, with Umbilicus and Phedimus extending to the eastern Mediterranean. Semperviveae extend from the Middle East to the Mediterranean and parts of Europe. Aeonieae and Sedeae are basically
95
European-Mediterranean. Aeonieae are diversified in Macaronesia, and Sedeae include distinct northern American lineages within the Leucosedum and Acre clades. The northern temperate clades are poor in species; whereas northern American and southern African lineages are highly diversified (Fig. 27). Growth form zonation reflects the climatic conditions: hemicryptophytes (Hylotelephium, many Umbiliceae) are restricted to northern temperate regions, annuals occur in climates with short vegetation periods, especially in winter-rainfall regions (’t Hart 1997b) and in alpine regions especially in East Asia, and subshrubs are restricted to regions without severe frosts. In contrast, small, often rooting and/or mat-forming herbs as well as stem-less rosette plants occur nearly throughout all regions (cf. also Böttcher and Jäger 1984 for Sedum). Crassulaceae generally prefer azonal sites, usually with more moderate temperatures and higher air humidity. Most taxa grow in arid habitats such as rocks and rock fissures under otherwise more humid climatic conditions, or in mountain regions in moderately arid areas, and are largely absent from hot deserts and arid lowlands. An exception is the arid coast of California, where many Dudleya species occur under moderate temperatures on coastal rocks exposed to sea breezes and fog (Thiede 2004), and the arid southern African Succulent Karoo, which exhibits a considerable species richness. Many rock plant communities with Crassulaceae have been described for Tenerife (Rivas-Martínez et al. 1993), Europe (Ellenberg 1996), Africa (Knapp 1973) and Arabia (Deil 1991). More unusual habitats are wet bogs (e.g. Sedum villosum), ephemeral water ponds where many Crassula (Tillaea) occur nearly hydrophytic, seasonally wet rock pools (e.g. Sedella), or moist forests with a few epiphytic Echeveria (Mexico, Central America), Sedum (Central and East Africa) and Kalanchoe (Madagascar). Edaphic specialisation is rare, e.g. Sempervivum dolomiticum is found only on dolomite, and Sedum alpestre occurs on siliceous and Sedum atratum on calcareous soil (Huber 1961). Germination and seedling establishment in rock habitats often occur within lichen or moss covers (e.g. Dudleya; Riefner et al. 2003). Crassulaceae frequently represent a first pioneer vegetation on shallow soils (e.g. Braun-Blanquet and Sutter 1982). Parasites. Specific crassulacean fungal parasites, the powdery mildews Erysiphe sedi and
96
J. Thiede and U. Eggli
Microsphaera umbilici (Braun 1987) and the rusts Puccinia umbilici and P. rhodiolae and Uromyces sedi, are all restricted to Telephieae and/or Umbiliceae. For further data on specific Puccinia, see Huber (1961). The rust fungi Endophyllum sempervivi and the mildews Fusarium solani and Phytophthora nicotianae var. parasitica occur on Sempervivum leaves (Ph. Neeff; in litt. 2004). The mildew Oidium kalanchoeae is known only from cultivated Kalanchoe (Braun 1987). Within angiosperms, Cuscuta campestris (Convolvulaceae) and Tapinanthus oleifolius (Loranthaceae) are unspecific parasites on Cotyledon (Visser 1981). Cuscuta spp. are occasionally found on European/Mediterranean Sedum, Petrosedum and Aeonium (U. Eggli, pers. obs.). Several mining insect larvae feed specifically on Crassulaceae: Sandia xami (Lepidoptera) on Mexican species (Jiménez and Soberón 1989), Phytomyza sedi (Diptera) and Glyphipteryx equitella (Lepidoptera) on European Sedum, and Phytomyza rhodiolae (Diptera), P. sedicola, Yponomeuta vigintipunctatus (Lepidoptera) and Apion sedi (Coleoptera) on European Telephieae and/or Umbiliceae (Huber 1961; Bland 1995). Thuleaphis sedi is a specialist aphid on Rhodiola rosea (Jacob 1964). Physiology. Nocturnal CO2 fixation based on the Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) pathway was first detected in Crassulaceae and named after this family, although it is now known to occur in many succulent taxa and a few non-succulents. CAM is expressed in many Crassulaceae and is either constitutive or facultatively induced under certain environmental conditions, especially under drought stress, and is found even in the weakly succulent semi-aquatic Crassula (Tillaea; Keeley 1998). Detailed data on CAM have been published for Sedum and Aeonium (Pilon-Smits 1992), Macaronesian Aeonieae (Lösch 1990), and Kalanchoe (Kluge and Brulfert 1996). Crassulaceae and other CAM plants are often highly endopolyploid (de Rocher et al. 1990), but the reason for this is unknown. Most Crassula studied by Martin and von Willert (2000) absorb water deposited on the leaf surfaces via hydathodes (see Vegetative Anatomy), which may subsequently stimulate CO2 fixation rates. Palaeobotany. Probably no fossil remains are known (Thomas Bolliger, pers. comm.); leaf fossils ascribed to Crassulaceae (e.g. Crassulaceophyllum) are doubtful.
Economic Importance. Apart from their horticultural value, Crassulaceae have minimal economic importance. Kalanchoe blossfeldiana cultivars are annually produced in large quantities as popular pot plants. Species of Hylotelephium, Phedimus, Sedum and Sempervivum are frequently cultivated in rock gardens and increasingly used for ‘green roofs’. Most perennial taxa of the family are choice collectors’ plants and commonly grown by succulent plant enthusiasts. Overviews of genera and species of horticultural importance are given by Cullen (1995) and Huxley et al. (1997). Several species, especially Kalanchoe pinnata, are aggressive invaders in the tropics. Nowadays, Crassulaceae are not used for food, although especially Petrosedum rupestre (vernacular name ‘Trip-Madame’) was recommended for salad in medieval herbals (’t Hart 1997a) and has locally been used as salad or pot-herb (Lippert 1995). The fleshy leaves may appear appealing in arid environments, but they are completely tasteless or bitter and are generally avoided even by cattle (’t Hart 1997a). Rhizomes of Rhodiola rosea have some use in folk medicine and were used officinally (‘Rose Root’; Radix Rhodiolae); an ethnobotanical review for Norway lists many uses (Alm 2004). For further data on folk uses and folk names of Central European taxa, see Huber (1961). Several Asian species of Rhodiola have been the subject of intense phytochemical and pharmacological studies (e.g. Kurkin and Zapesochnaya 1986; many older Russian references listed by Clausen 1975: 531). The medicinal properties of their rhizomes were known for a long time, and recent investigations have identified a vast array of different chemical compounds (e.g. Yoshikawa et al. 1996). There exist attempts for the large-scale cultivation of at least R. sachalinensis for the improved production of certain bioactive compounds (e.g. Xu et al. 1998). Conservation. Most Crassulaceae occur in rocky places not prone to habitat destruction (’t Hart 1997a). Narrow endemics (frequent in California, Mexico, Africa, Madagascar and Macaronesia) may be seriously threatened by land development and tourism. For example, two of three accessible populations of the Madeiran Sedum fusiforme have been destroyed during the construction of tourist accommodations (’t Hart 1997a). Legal and illegal trade and collecting of wild plants do occur but appear to be rather restricted,
Crassulaceae
compared to other succulents, due to low demands and easy vegetative and generative propagation (data for South Africa: Newton and Chan 1998). Genera popular in horticulture are typically protected under state laws (e.g. Sempervivum, Aeonium and Aichryson). Sedella leiocarpa and eight Dudleya taxa are listed as endangered in the USA (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service 2004). Many data (general and per country listings with IUCN categories) are included in Oldfield (1997). Golding (2002) lists the IUCN Red Data List categories for many southern African species per country. Studies on the conservation biology (reproduction, life history, population genetics) are available for Rhodiola integrifolia and Dudleya multicaulis (see Reproductive Systems). Special ex situ propagation programs have been initiated for some endangered local endemics (e.g. the Madeiran Aichryson dumosum, Fernandes 1997). Most genera and species of horticultural appeal appear to be cultivated in specialised public and private collections.
97
Stamens equal in number to petals 2. Leaves usually decussate, rarely verticillate; with hydathodes along margins and/or leaf face; seeds sinuatepapillate (Crassula type) 3 – Not as above; leaves spiral 4 3. Perennial tuberous herbs, flowers 10–12-merous; fruits 2-seeded, breaking transversely (Ethiopia) 34. Hypagophytum – Not as above; when plants tuberous or flowers polymerous, then fruits not few-seeded 33. Crassula 4. Plants with persistent or monocarpic rosettes 5 – Plants without rosettes 7 5. Monocarpic rosette-forming herbs (Asia) 6 – Perennial shrublets with lax rosettes at branch tips (Mexico) 25. Graptopetalum p.p. 6. Inflorescences broad, flat-topped, corymboid thyrsoids 1. Sinocrassula – Inflorescences narrow-elongate thyrsoids 2. Kungia 7. Plants tuberous; leaves peltate; inflorescences elongate racemes 7. Umbilicus p.p. (U. heylandianus) – Not as above, annual to perennial herbs 8 8. Annual to perennial herbs; fruits many-seeded follicles (N hemisphere) 22. Sedum p.p. (e.g. S. rubens) – Minute annual herbs; fruits 1-seeded nutlets (USA: California) 20. Sedella p.p.
Stems frail or leaves caducous Conspectus of Crassulaceae I. Subfam. Sempervivoideae Arn. (1832). 1. Tribe Telephieae (’t Hart) Ohba and Thiede ined. (= Hylotelephium clade). Genera 1–5 Incertae sedis: genus 6 2. Tribe Umbiliceae Meisn. (1838) (= Rhodiola clade). Genera 7–10 3. Tribe Semperviveae Dumort. (1827) (= Sempervivum clade). Genera 11–12 and Sedum subg. Gormania p.min.p. (S. assyriacum, S. mooneyi) 4. Tribe Aeonieae Thiede ined. (= Aeonium clade). Genera 13–15 and Sedum subg. Gormania p.min.p. (series Caerulea, Pubescens and Monanthoidea) 5. Tribe Sedeae Fr. (1835). a. Leucosedum clade Genera 16–21 and Sedum subg. Gormania p.maj.p. b. Acre clade Genera 22–28 and Sedum subg. Sedum II. Subfam. Kalanchoideae A. Berger (1930) (= Kalanchoe clade). Genera 29–32 III. Subfam. Crassuloideae Burnett (1835) (= Crassula clade). Genera 33–34
Perennials with monocarpic rosettes with terminal inflorescences
Key to the Genera 1. Stamens equal in number to petals – Stamens double in number to petals
9. Perennials, but leaves or aboveground stems annually caducous 10 – Annual or biennial, or perennial and then with at least some perennating leaves 17 10. Stems perennial, succulent, ± elongated; leaves crowded at branch tips (southern Africa) 31. Tylecodon – Stems annual, not succulent; perennials with underground tubers, rhizomes or thickened roots (usually outside Africa) 11 11. Plants with tuberous stems 12 – Plants with rhizomes, caudices or thickened roots 13 12. Leaves not peltate; inflorescences axillary, cymose (W USA and Baja California) 21. Dudleya p.p. (D. sect. Hasseanthus) – Leaves usually distinctly peltate; inflorescences terminal, racemes or panicles 7. Umbilicus p.p. 13. Plants with thickened roots; leaves terete-subulate (America) 23. Villadia p.p. – Plants with rhizomes or caudices; leaves flat 14 14. Carpels narrowed at base (stipitate-attenuate) 5. Hylotelephium – Carpels with broad base 15 15. Rhizomes thin; inflorescences pleiochasia 10. Phedimus p.p. – Plants with very thick rhizome; inflorescences thyrsoids 16 16. Petals free; flowers often unisexual (plants monoecious or dioecious) 9. Rhodiola – Corolla connate at base for 1/3–2/3 8. Pseudosedum
2 9
17. Plants with perennial monocarpic rosettes with terminal inflorescences 18
98
J. Thiede and U. Eggli
– Plants annual (rarely biennial or triennial), or perennial and then not with monocarpic rosettes with terminal inflorescences 24 18. Nectary scales larger than the insignificant petals (Canary Islands) 14. Monanthes p.p. (M. sect. Monanthes) – Nectary scales inconspicuous, much smaller than the showy petals 19 19. Flowers 5(rarely 6)-merous; inflorescences corymboid to much elongated and spike-like thyrsoids 20 – Flowers (5)6–32-merous; inflorescences corymboid to dome-shaped thyrsoids or with several cincinni, never spike-like 22 20. Inflorescences flat-topped, corymboid thyrsoids, or cymose, few-flowered (eastern Mediterranean, W Asia) 18. Prometheum p.p. – Inflorescences elongate, many-flowered 21 21. Partial inflorescences helicoid (Turkey, Iraq, Turkmenistan) 17. Rosularia p.p. (R. elymaitica) – Partial inflorescences never helicoid (C to E Asia) 4. Orostachys 22. Leaves semi-terete, not apiculate; flowers 5-merous; white (Europe/Mediterranean) 22. Sedum p.p. (e.g. S. hirsutum) – Leaves usually flat and apiculate; flowers 6–32-merous 23 23. Rosettes sessile, usually < 10 cm; inflorescences pleiochasia; flowers 6–18-merous, often pink to purple, rarely white or yellow; carpels (sub)erect (Europe to Caucasus) 11. Sempervivum – Rosettes sessile or at branch tips, often > 10 cm; inflorescences thyrsoids or pleiochasia; flowers (6–)10–32merous, often yellow or whitish, rarely reddish; carpels spreading (mainly Macaronesia, also N and NE Africa and SW Arabia) 15. Aeonium 24. Leaves decussate throughout length of stems 25 – Leaves alternate at least in upper stem parts, or in rosettes, rarely verticillate 32
Leaves decussate 25. Annual to biennial, glabrous to glandular-hairy herbs, to 15 cm; flowers (4)5-merous, white, pink or purplish; petals 4–5 mm (Mediterranean) 26 – Perennial herbs (rarely monocarpic), or shrubs or small trees, or lianas; flowers 4–6-merous; petals > 5 mm, in various colours 27 26. Annual glabrous herbs; inflorescences to 5 cm 10. Phedimus p.p. (P. stellatus) – Annual to biennial, glandular-hairy herbs; inflorescences to 60 cm 22. Sedum p.p. (e.g. S. cepaea) 27. Flowers 4-merous; herbs (rarely monocarpic) to shrubs or small trees, or lianas 30. Kalanchoe – Flowers 5- or 6-merous; shrublets or herbs 28 28. Flowers (5)6-merous, white 29 – Flowers 5-merous, not white (Africa, Caucasus, North America) 30 29. Shrublets to 80 cm tall (Madagascar) 6. Perrierosedum – Dwarf herbs to 10 cm tall (Europe/Mediterranean) 22. Sedum p.p. (e.g. S. dasyphyllum) 30. Herbs with creeping stems; leaves petiolate, flat and thin; inflorescences arching over; flowers yellow, narrowly urceolate (Caucasus) 7. Umbilicus p.p. (U. oppositifolius)
– Not as above 31 31. Shrubs; leaves not easily detached; flowers 2–3 cm, usually pendent; corolla connate at base (Africa, Arabia) 32. Cotyledon – Herbs; leaves often easily detached; flowers to 1 cm, ± upright; petals free (USA, Mexico) 24. Lenophyllum 32. Leaves verticillate (Africa) 22. Sedum p.p. (e.g. S. epidendrum) – Leaves alternate at least in upper stem parts, or in rosettes 33 33. Annual (to rarely biennial or triennial) herbs 34 – Perennial herbs to shrublets 40
Annuals 34. Flowers 6–7-merous, dirty white; nectary scales conspicuous, larger than the insignificant petals (Canary Islands) 14. Monanthes p.p. (M. icterica) – Flowers 5–12-merous; nectary scales inconspicuous and never larger than the showy petals 35 35. Flower 5-merous; corolla distinctly connate (Iberian Peninsula, N Africa) 36 – Flower 5–12-merous; petals (nearly) free 37 36. Filaments inserted at the base of the corolla tube; stylodia ±1 mm 22. Sedum p.p. (S. mucizonia) – Filaments inserted slightly below the mouth of the corolla tube; stylodia 2.5–5 mm 16. Pistorinia 37. Annual to biennial herbs; leaves flat; young plants with conspicuous basal rosettes (E Mediterranean) 22. Sedum p.p. (S. lampusae, etc.) – Young plants without basal rosettes 38 38. Fruits 1-seeded nutlets (USA: California) 20. Sedella p.p. – Fruits many-seeded follicles opening at ventral suture 39 39. Annual to triennial herbs; leaves flat, often ± rosulate near branch tips; flowers yellow; nectary scales 2–5-fid (Macaronesia) 13. Aichryson p.p. (A. sect. Aichryson) – Annual herbs; leaves ± semi-terete; nectary scales entire (northern hemisphere to E Africa) 22. Sedum p.p.
Perennials with large nectary scales 40. Nectary scales conspicuous, larger than the insignificant petals 41 – Nectary scales inconspicuous, much smaller than the showy petals 43 41. Leaves with bladder-cell idioblasts (Canary Islands) 14. Monanthes p.p. – Leaves without bladder-cell idioblasts 42 42. Flowers 5-merous; stems elongate, repent (Mexico) 22. Sedum p.p. (S. longipes) – Flowers 5–7-merous; stems short and thick; leaves in rosettes (Morocco) 22. Sedum p.p. (S. surculosum) 43. Inflorescences terminal; leaves not in rosettes 44 – Inflorescences lateral; leaves usually in distinct rosettes, or at least crowded at branch tips 49
Perennials without rosettes and with terminal inflorescences 44. Plants herbaceous, at highest slightly woody at base 45 – Plants shrubby 47 45. Corolla connate (Mexico, Peru) 23. Villadia p.p. (V. imbricata, etc.)
Crassulaceae – Petals free 46 46. Leaves ± densely imbricate and acuminate; flowers yellow(ish); fruits erect (Europe/Mediterranean) 12. Petrosedum – Leaves not densely imbricate nor acuminate; fruits erect to spreading (northern hemisphere to E Africa) 22. Sedum p.p. (p.max.p.) 47. Stems distinctly succulent, with ± flaking papery bark; inflorescences pleiochasia; petals free 22. Sedum p.p. (e.g. S. frutescens) – Stems not distinctly succulent, without flaking papery bark; inflorescences elongate; corolla connate 48 48. Leaves usually soft fleshy, semi-terete; inflorescences thyrsoids; filaments glabrous (America) 23. Villadia p.p. – Leaves firmly fleshy; inflorescences thyrses or spikes without terminal flower; filaments papillate where connate with corolla (southern Africa) 29. Adromischus
Perennials with rosettes, lateral inflorescences, and the corolla connate for most of its length 49. Corolla connate for most of its length; petals distinctly fleshy (America) 50 – Petals free or corolla connate for less than 1/2 of its length; petals membranous 51 50. Leaves usually very thick and with strong wax bloom; inflorescences cincinnoid; bracts usually very large and ± covering the flowers at anthesis; petals with basal scale on each margin (Mexico) 28. Pachyphytum – Inflorescences racemose, cymose-paniculate, spicate thyrsoids, or cincinnoid; petals usually without, rarely with small scales (southern USA to Argentina) 27. Echeveria
Perennials with rosettes, shrubby habit and lateral inflorescences, and petals free or corolla connate for <1/2 of its length 51. Shrublets; rosettes at branch tips 52 – Stem-less herbs 56 52. Leaves glandular-hairy; flowers yellow, 7–8-merous (Canary Islands) 13. Aichryson p.p. (A. sect. Macrobia) – Leaves glabrous (America) 53 53. Leaves with intensive wax bloom; rosettes typically branching dichotomously; leaves not easily detached; seeds costate (W USA and Baja California) 21. Dudleya p.p. (e.g. D. formosa) – Not as above; seeds reticulate-papillate (mainland Mexico, Guatemala) 55 54. Petals (almost) free, yellow or white 22. Sedum p.p. (S. sect. Pachysedum) – Corolla connate at base 55 55. Inflorescences broad thyrsoids with cincinnoid partial inflorescences; inner face of petals usually with ± red to brown spottings, or whitish to yellowish 25. Graptopetalum p.p. – Inflorescences elongate and narrow, partly spike-like thyrsoids; petals inside ± purplish-red, unspotted 26. Thompsonella p.p.
99
Perennials with stem-less rosettes and lateral inflorescences, and petals free or corolla connate for <1/2 of its length 56. Leaves glandular-pubescent to glandular-hairy; corolla connate at base 57 – Leaves glabrous; petals free or corolla connate at base 59 57. Plants offsetting with long brittle runners; leaf apex mucronate, margins distinctly ciliate (Ethiopia) 19. Afrovivella – Plants not offsetting or with short runners; leaf apex not mucronate, margins usually not ciliate 58 58. Leaves densely glandular-pubescent; flowers 5-merous, white or pale yellow/reddish; fruits erect or spreading (E Mediterranean to W Asia) 18. Prometheum p.p. – Leaves glandular-hairy; flowers 5–9-merous, white to pink(ish); fruits erect (E Mediterranean, Near East to E Asia) 17. Rosularia p.p. 59. Plants with thickened taproot; leaf apex cuspidate to spinulose; carpels connate at base, with only 4–6 ovules each (Asia) 3. Meterostachys – Not as above 60 60. Rosettes typically branching dichotomously; leaves usually with intensive wax-bloom, not easily detached; bracts semi-amplexicaul, never spurred (W USA and Baja California) 21. Dudleya p.p. – Not as above (southern USA, mainland Mexico) 61 61. Leaves usually mucronate; inflorescences short and broad thyrsoids; petals usually with ± red to brown spottings, or bright pink 25. Graptopetalum p.p. (G. sect. Graptopetalum) – Leaves not mucronate; inflorescences elongate and narrow, partly spike-like thyrsoids; petals inside ± purplish-red 26. Thompsonella p.p.
Genera of Crassulaceae Basic Features Herbaceous, arhizomatic perennials, tanniniferous, with solitary crystals or druses; shoots aerial; leaves alternate, scattered (dispersed), succulent∗ , sessile, ± flat, entire, with marginal hydathodes, glabrous or with non-glandular indumentum; stomata anisocytic∗ ; inflorescences terminal thyrsoids∗ , partial inflorescences dichasial; flowers ± erect, actinomorphic, 5merous, obdiplostemonous∗ ; sepals ± appressed to corolla, connate at base; corolla choripetalous, spreading; stamens with filaments free to base; anthers basifixed, latrorse, yellow, without terminal connective appendage; ovary superior; carpels free (nearly) to base, with many crassinucellate ovules and carpellary nectary scales∗ at their bases; fruits erect follicles, opening along whole suture; seeds small, ± cylindrically fusiform, ± brown, testa papillate∗ . x = 8.
100
J. Thiede and U. Eggli
Note: these features are valid for all genera of the family, unless modified in the subsequent characterisations of subfamilies, tribes, clades or informal generic groups in which their characters behave correspondingly. Putative synapomorphies for higher taxa and major clades are marked with asterisks (∗ ). Note the distinction made between taxonomic characters which are valid only for the genera included in the respective taxon (e.g. tribe), thus excluding the formalised segregates of Sedum, and cladistic synapomorphies which are valid for all members of a clade, including the segregates of Sedum. The synoptic treatments for all genera included in Eggli (2003) as well as standard flora works are not cited in the descriptions of the genera. Subfamilies Sempervivoideae and Kalanchoideae Leaves usually with single (sub)apical hydathode∗ ; seeds costate∗ . Genera 1–32. (Note that basic features for family are further valid.) I. Subfam. Sempervivoideae Arn. (1832). Flowers (4)5(–32)-merous, flowers obdiplostemonous (rarely haplostemonous, but then leaves never decussate); seeds costate with many (>6, usually c. 10) costae∗ in side view. Genera 1–28. Largely confined to the northern hemisphere. I.1. Tribe Telephieae (’t Hart) Ohba & Thiede, ined. Leaves usually in rosettes (except Hylotelephium), rosettes usually monocarpic, leaves partly cuspidate; petals often spotted to mottled with red to brown; carpels stipitate or connate at base; flowering mainly in autumn. Genera 1–5. Mainly in temperate Asia. 1. Sinocrassula A. Berger Sinocrassula A. Berger in Engler & Prantl, Nat. Pflanzenfam., ed. 2, 18a:462 (1930).
Perennial, sometimes annual or biennial herbs, glabrous, papillose or rarely pubescent; leaves obtuse to usually acuminate, often mottled with red; inflorescences broad corymbose thyrsoids, simple
to richly branched; flowers campanulate-urceolate; petals free, connivent to urceolate corolla; ± whitish, greenish or rose, ± mottled with red, orange or brown; stamens 5, alternating with and slightly shorter than petals; carpels connate at base; stylodia abruptly narrowed. n = 11. Seven species, northern India (Uttar Pradesh), Bhutan, eastern Tibet, south-western China (Yunnan, Szechuan). 2. Kungia K.T. Fu Kungia K.T. Fu in J.N.W. Teachers Coll. (Nat. Sci.) 1:3 (1988). Orostachys sect. Schoenlandia H. Ohba (1978).
Herbs, glabrous or hairy; stolons present; sterile stems usually present; basal leaves in subsessile rosettes, decussate or usually alternate, obtuse; flowering stems erect, very slender but strong; inflorescences many-flowered terminal, narrow, racemiform or paniculiform thyrsoids; sepals lanceolate-triangular, much shorter than petals, spurless; petals connate at base, lanceolate, red or purple; stamens 5, alternating with petals, shorter than petals; anthers oblong-reniform; carpels nearly free, oblong, base attenuate or stalked; stylodia long. Two species, south-western China (northern Szechuan, Gansu, Shaanxi), on rocky slopes from 700–3,100 m. Sister to Sinocrassula, according to molecular data (Hideaki Ohba, unpubl. data, pers. comm. 2004); the two genera share haplostemonous flowers. Formerly classified as sect. Schoenlandia within Orostachys. 3. Meterostachys Nakai Meterostachys Nakai, Bot. Mag. (Tokyo) 49:74, 210 (1935); Moran, Cact. Succ. J. (U.S.) 44:262–273 (1972); Ohba, J. Fac. Sci. Univ. Tokyo III, Bot. 12:173–174 (1978).
Herbs with thickened taproot; leaves in small rosettes, apex cuspidate to spinulose, often cartilaginous; inflorescences axillary, simple, cymose; flowers (4)5-merous, pedicels often longer than flowers; petals upright, connate at base for 1/3 to 2/5, white, often with reddish hue; stamens distinctly shorter than petals; carpels connate at base, suberect, with only 4–6 ovules each; n = 16. Only 1 species, M. sikokiana (Makino) Nakai from Japan, Korea and China (Byalt 1997). Sister to Orostachys subsect. Appendiculatae, according to molecular data (Mayuzumi and Ohba 2004).
Crassulaceae
101
4. Orostachys Fischer Orostachys Fischer, Mém. Soc. Imp. Naturalistes Moscou 2:274 (1809); Byalt, Novost. Sist. Vyssh. Rast. 32:40–50 (2000), rev. (in Russian).
Biennial monocarpic herbs; leaves of first year in solitary rosette, rosettes often dimorphic with compact winter (resting) stage, normally offsetting; leaves linear to ovate, apex cuspidate (ser. Appendiculatae) or blunt (ser. Orostachys); inflorescences dense, narrowly pyramidal to cylindric, many-flowered thyrsoids, usually with secondary branches; sepals connate at base; corolla ± stellate; petals lanceolate, subconnate, white, pink or red; stamens longer than petals; carpels stipitate; stylodia slender. n = 12. Eleven species, Russia (East Siberia), Kazakhstan, Mongolia, China, Korea, Japan. Polyphyletic, according to molecular data (Mayuzumi and Ohba 2004): subsect. Orostachys is nested within Hylotelephium, and subsect. Appendiculatae is sister to Meterostachys but differs strongly from that genus and should possibly be given separate generic status. See also under Kungia. 5. Hylotelephium H. Ohba
Fig. 28
Hylotelephium H. Ohba, Bot. Mag. (Tokyo) 90:46–47 (1977); Fröderström, Acta Horti Gothob. suppl. 5:1–75 (1930), sub Sedum; Ohba, J. Fac. Sci. Univ. Tokyo III, Bot. 12:162–166 (1978).
Hemicryptophytes with rootstock of fibrous to tuberous, often carrot-shaped roots and short, fleshy or woody rhizome (H. populifolium (Pall.) H. Ohba with perennial, woody, frail stems); flowering stems from adventitious buds on rootstock or basal nodes of former years’ flowering stems, simple, annual, usually with numerous leaves and visible internodes, some species with additional vegetative shoots; leaves alternate, rarely decussate to 3–5-whorled, broad, flat, margin entire, crenate, or lobed, apex usually blunt; inflorescences thyrsoids, compound or paniculate or umbellatecorymbose in shape, dense and many-flowered; flowers (4)5-merous; petals usually free, white, purple, pink or red, occasionally yellowish or greenish; stamens shorter to longer than petals, those opposite petals basally connate with them; carpels stipitate. n = usually 12, also 11, 23, 24, 25, 46. About 27 species, East Asia, Siberia, Caucasus, Europe, North America. A relatively recent segregate from Sedum s.l. The division into two sections with two series
Fig. 28. Crassulaceae. A–C Hylotelephium telephium. A Flowering plant with tuberous roots. B Flower seen from side. C Seed. D–F Kalanchoe grandiflora. D Flowering shoot. E Flower, opened out. F Ovary with hypogynous scales. (Berger 1930)
(Ohba, l.c.) is not supported by molecular data (Mayuzumi and Ohba 2004). These data also indicate that Orostachys sect. Orostachys is nested within Hylotelephium; the two taxa share blunt leaves, stipitate carpels and x = 12. This causes nomenclatural problems, since Orostachys antedates Hylotelephium. Orostachys paradoxa (A.P. Khokhr. & Vorosch.) Czerep. links both taxa (Byalt 1998).
Incertae sedis: 6. Perrierosedum (A. Berger) H. Ohba Perrierosedum (A. Berger) H. Ohba, J. Fac. Sci. Univ. Tokyo III, Bot. 12:166 (1978).
Branched shrublets 50–80 cm; stems 4-angled; leaves decussate, oblong-spathulate, base long-
102
J. Thiede and U. Eggli
attenuate, margins crenulate; inflorescences terminal, corymbose-cymose, 5–10-flowered, pedunculate; flowers (5)6-merous; sepals free; petals free, broadly spathulate, white tinged with red; filaments shorter than petals; nectary scales conspicuous, 3–3.5 mm, tips bifid; carpels free, ventrally straight, tapering towards tip. Only 1 species, P. madagascariense (H. Perrier) H. Ohba from Madagascar. Possibly linking the African Kalanchoideae with the Asian Telephieae. I.2. Tribe Umbiliceae Meisn. (1838). Rhizomatic hemicryptophytes to tuberous geophytes∗ ; leaves usually crenate to dentate∗ (except Pseudosedum); flowering mainly in spring to early summer. Genera 7–10. Mainly in temperate Asia. 7. Umbilicus DC. Umbilicus DC., Bull. Sci. Soc. Philom. Paris 3:1 (1801). Chiastophyllum (Ledebour) Stapf ex A. Berger (1930).
Small herbs with tubers and frail stems (sect. Umbilicus) or with short, creeping and rooting rhizomatous stems (U. oppositifolius); tissues with crystal sand; leaves alternate (sect. Umbilicus) or decussate (U. oppositifolius), suborbicular, with distinct petiole, ± peltate with central dimple (sect. Umbilicus) or not peltate (U. oppositifolius); inflorescences many-flowered, long terminal panicles or racemes (sect. Umbilicus) or double racemes (U. oppositifolius), without terminal flower, upright (sect. Umbilicus) or arching over (U. oppositifolius); flowers usually ± horizontal or drooping, rarely haplostemonous (usually in U. heylandianus Webb. & Berth.); corolla tubular or campanulate; petals connate, white, green or yellow; filaments usually connate with corolla for most of their length; seeds multipapillate, papillae arranged in small groups (sect. Umbilicus) or connate (U. oppositifolius). n = 24. Thirteen species, western, southern and central Europe, Macaronesia, Mediterranean, Near East to Caucasus, Arabia, North, Central and East Africa. Divided into sect. Umbilicus, which exhibits complex patterns of variation probably due to selfpollination and is in need of revision, and sect. Chiastophyllum with U. oppositifolius (Ledeb.) Ledeb. from the Caucasus, which is also recognised at generic level by some authors.
8. Pseudosedum (Boiss.) A. Berger Pseudosedum (Boiss.) A. Berger in Engler & Prantl, Nat. Pflanzenfam., ed. 2, 18a:465 (1930).
Hemicryptophytes; flowering stems one to numerous, arising from usually well-developed simple or branched sympodial rhizome, old stems usually persistent; leaves usually linear, (sub)obtuse, broadly spurred, subterete, entire, usually fleshy; flowering branches one to many, simple, usually densely leafy, 5–40 cm; inflorescences dense terminal thyrsoids, corymbose or umbellate, rarely paniculate, usually many-flowered; flowers (5)6merous; corolla campanulate to tubular; petals connate at base for 1/3 to 2/3, lobes ± divergent, pink to violet or red or pure white; fruits erect or slightly divergent follicles. Twelve species, Central Asia; stony soils in mountainous regions. Sister to Rhodiola, according to molecular data (Mayuzumi and Ohba 2004); the two genera are hemicryptophytes, with usually well-developed rhizomes. 9. Rhodiola L. Rhodiola L., Sp. Pl.: 1035 (1753); Ohba, J. Fac. Sci. Univ. Tokyo III, Bot. 12:139–198 (1978); l.c. 12:337–405 (1980); l.c. 13:65–119 (1981); l.c. 13:121–174 (1982). Clementsia Rose (1903).
Hemicryptophytes; rhizomes monopodial, massive or slender, apical part with foliage and/or scaly leaves; leaves usually flat; flowering stems sometimes persistent for a while; inflorescences usually broad thyrsoids, partly reduced to solitary flowers or rarely racemes; flowers hermaphrodite or plants dioecious (rarely monoecious), 4–5(6)merous, pedicellate, when dioecious: petals and ovaries opposite in male but alternate in female plants, when hermaphrodite or monoecious: petals and ovaries always opposite; calyx fleshy, in female plants forming a tube divided into 4–5(6) ± equal lobes; petals free, white, reddish, deep purplish-red or pale yellow to greenish, always longer than sepals in female plants; carpels superior to semi-inferior, usually connate at base (rarely completely free), straight at anthesis, slightly patent in fruit. n = 7, 10, 11, 22, 33, 44, 55. About 58 species, East Asia, Siberia, North America, Europe; especially sub-Arctic and alpine zones. The subdivision into four subgenera with seven sections (Ohba 1978) is not supported by molecular data (Mayuzumi and Ohba 2004).
Crassulaceae
10. Phedimus Raf. Phedimus Raf., Amer. Monthly Mag. Crit. Rev. 1:438 (1817); Grulich, Preslia 56:29–46 (1984), sub Asterosedum; Chung & Kim, Korean J. Pl. Taxon. 19:189–227 (1989), rev. Korean taxa. Aizopsis Grulich (1984). Asterosedum Grulich (1984). Spathulata (A. Borissova) A. Löve & D. Löve (1985).
Perennial or rarely annual herbs, usually glabrous, sometimes stems woody at base, emerging from thin woody rhizome; leaves decussate or alternate, base narrowed; with several hydathodes on lower face along margins; flowering branches erect or ascending; inflorescences usually dense many-flowered terminal pleiochasia; flowers (4)5–6(7)-merous; sepals usually unequal; petals free, usually spreading, white, pink, red, purplish (subg. Phedimus) or yellow (subg. Aizoon); anthers red (subg. Phedimus) or yellow, orange or reddish (subg. Aizoon); fruits follicles, usually spreading; seeds costate-papillate (i.e. papillae incompletely connate to costae), multipapillate in P. selskianus (Regel & Maack) ’t Hart (’t Hart and Berendsen 1980; Gontcharova 1999). n = 5, 6, 7, 8, 15–16, c. 32, 33, 34. Eighteen species, eastern Europe and Asia. Only recently re-segregated from Sedum. Divided into subg. Phedimus (stems creeping and rooting, with sterile stems; x = 5, 6, 7; 5 spp.; Mediterranean to Caucasus) and subg. Aizoon (annual shoots often woody at base, emerging from woody rhizome; follicles with distinct lips along suture; x = 8; 13 spp.; China, Japan, Korean and Central Siberia). Subg. Aizoon is distinct morphologically, karyologically and according to molecular data (Mort et al. 2001; Mayuzumi and Ohba 2004), and also recognised at generic level as Aizopsis by some authors. All other Sempervivoideae Plants often glandular-pubescent; leaves basically (semi-)terete∗ (in derived genera often ± flat and thick); partial inflorescences typically monochasial∗ (double or single cincinni). Genera 11–28. Mainly northern temperate region, also North, Central and East Africa and southern America. I.3. Tribe Semperviveae Dumort. (1827). Leaves acuminate; inflorescences pleiochasial; flowers poly(at least 6)-merous; base chromosome numbers high, n = 12–16.
103
Genera 11 + 12. Sedum assyriacum Boiss. (Near East) and S. mooneyi M.G. Gilbert (Ethiopia) of Sedum subg. Gormania, and possibly further species related to these, also come out here according to molecular data (’t Hart 1995; van Ham and ’t Hart 1998). These two species do not share the tribal characters but their yellow flowers agree with those in Petrosedum and some Sempervivum. 11. Sempervivum L. Sempervivum L., Sp. Pl.: 464 (1753); Praeger, Account Sempervivum Group (1932). Jovibarba (A.P. de Candolle) Opiz (1852).
Leaves rosulate, with glandular and non-glandular hairs, reproducing vegetatively through axillary stolons or rarely through rosette division, flattened, glabrous or pubescent, with marginal cilia; inflorescences usually pleiochasia, partial inflorescences dense, with (2)3(4) single or double cincinni; flowers 6–18-merous; petals spreading and pink, purple, yellow to almost white (sect. Sempervivum) or erect during anthesis, with fimbriate margins and (pale) yellow to whitish (sect. Jovibarba); nectary scales ± square; carpels (sub)erect. n = 16–19, 21, 32, 34, 36, 40, 42, 54. About 63 species, Morocco (Atlas Mts.), Europe to north-western and central Russia, Balkan Peninsula, Carpathians, Turkey, northern Iran, Caucasus. Divided into sect. Sempervivum (flowers 8–18merous; x = 16–21) and sect. Jovibarba (flowers 6(7)-merous; x = 19; 2 spp.; ’t Hart and Bleij 1999). According to molecular data, Jovibarba is nested in Sempervivum (Philipp Neeff, pers. comm.), or both are sister groups (Mort et al. 2001). Notoriously difficult in its taxonomy, due to reticulate evolution. A revision is being undertaken by Ph. Neeff (University of Essen, Germany). Sempervivum shares several features with Petrosedum. 12. Petrosedum Grulich Petrosedum Grulich, Preslia (Praha) 56:39 (1984); ’t Hart, Biosyst. stud. Acre-group and ser. Rupestria of gen. Sedum (Crassulaceae): Thesis Univ. Utrecht (1978). Sedum ser. Rupestria A. Berger (1930).
Mat-forming herbs, glabrous, inflorescences also glandular, perennating with branching and rooting non-flowering ascending to repent shoots; leaves (semi-)terete, linear-elliptic, acuminate, spurred,
104
J. Thiede and U. Eggli
usually densely imbricate; flowering shoots erect, simple, 10–60 cm, often ± woody at base; inflorescences usually pleiochasia, partial inflorescences single or double cincinni, at anthesis erect or nodding; flower (sub)sessile, 6–7(–12)-merous; sepals acute to acuminate; petals obtuse, spreading during anthesis, yellow, rarely white; filaments usually yellow; carpels erect, dark brown in fruit; stylodia long. n = 12, 13, 16, 17, 24, 26, 32, 34, 36, 44, 48, 56. Seven species, western and central Europe, Balkan, Mediterranean. Sedum ser. Rupestria is here recognised at the generic level, since morphologically it is highly distinct from European-Mediterranean Sedum, also in its embryology (Mauritzon 1933), flavonoid patterns (Stevens et al. 1996) and epicuticular triterpenes (Stevens et al. 1994). According to molecular data, Petrosedum does not form a clade together with Sempervivum, but the two form a polytomy (van Ham and ’t Hart 1998; Mort et al. 2001) or place separate from each other (’t Hart 1995). I.4. Tribe Aeonieae Thiede, ined. Plants glandular-hairy; leaves usually ± flat, in ± distinct rosettes; flowers poly(at least 6)-merous; carpels often with glandular hairs, immersed into receptacle; seeds usually costate-papillate (i.e. papillae incompletely connate to costae) to costate. Genera 13–15. Mainly in Macaronesia. Sedum subg. Gormania ser. Caerulea, Pubescens and Monanthoidea (from North Africa) also belong here, according to molecular data (Mes and ’t Hart 1994; Mes 1995; ’t Hart 1995; van Ham and ’t Hart 1998), but do not exhibit all of the tribal characters. 13. Aichryson Webb & Berth. Aichryson Webb & Berth., Phytogr. Canar. 1:180 (1840); Bramwell, Bol. Inst. Nac. Inv. Agron. (Madrid) 28:203–213 (1968), synopsis; Fairfield et al., Pl. Syst. Evol. 248:71–83 (2004); mol. phylog. Macrobia (Webb & Berth.) G. Kunkel (1977).
Annual to triennial monocarpic herbs (sect. Aichryson) or small perennial shrublets (sect. Macrobia); stems densely hairy or glabrous, branches occasionally slightly woody; leaves alternate, often ± rosulate near branch tips, sessile or petiolate, entire or crenulate, glabrous or (glandular) hairy to viscid; inflorescences few- to many-branched, lax thyrsoids; flowers 6–12-merous; sepals glabrous
or hairy; petals pale or deep yellow; nectary scales 2–5-fid; carpels glabrous or glandular-hairy; fruits erect follicles; seeds costate-papillate to costate. n = 15, 17, 30. Fourteen species, from Macaronesia (Canary Islands, Madeira, Azores [Santa Maria]), naturalised in Portugal. Divided into sect. Aichryson and sect. Macrobia (2 spp.). 14. Monanthes Haw. Monanthes Haw., Saxifrag. Enum., 2:68 (1821); Nyffeler, Bradleya 10:49–82 (1992), rev.; Nyffeler in ’t Hart & Eggli, Evol. Syst. Crassulaceae: 76–88 (1995); Mes et al., J. Evol. Biol. 10:193–216 (1997), mol. phylog.; Cartwright et al., IOS Bull. 12:23–24 (2004), mol. phylog. (abstract). Petrophyes Webb & Berth. (1841).
Herbs or shrublets, perennial, M. icterica annual; leaves alternate, rarely decussate, usually in rosettes or scattered along stems, glabrous or glandular-hairy, covered with bladder-cell idioblasts; inflorescences terminal from rosette or at branch tips, or lateral shoots, reduced thyrsoids of 1–3(–5) cymes with (1–)3–8 flowers; flowers (5)6–8(9)-merous; petals insignificant in colour and size, pale yellow, variously striped with red; nectary scales larger than petals, bilobed or flabellate, pale yellow to dark red; carpels often with glandular hairs; fruits follicles, rarely breaking off transversally; seeds costate-papillate to costate or almost smooth. n = 18, 36, 54; 10 in M. icterica. Nine species, from Macaronesia (Canary and Selvagens islands). Divided into four sections (Nyffeler in Eggli 2003). The position of M. icterica (Webb ex Bolle) Christ (sect. Annuae) is equivocal, according to molecular data: sister to Aichryson (Mes et al. 1997; Mort et al. 2001; weak to moderate support), between Aichryson and Monanthes (Mort et al. 2002; strong support), or sister to the rest of Monanthes (Cartwright et al. l.c.; weak support). Monanthes is sister to Aeonium, according to molecular data; the two genera share a chromosome base number of x = 18. 15. Aeonium Webb & Berth.
Fig. 29
Aeonium Webb & Berth., Phytogr. Canar. 1:184 (1840); Liu, Syst. Aeonium, Natl Mus. Nat. Sci. (Taiwan) Spec. Publ. 3 (1989), rev.; Mes & ’t Hart, Mol. Ecol. 5:351–363 (1996), mol. phylog. Greenovia Webb & Berth. (1840). Megalonium (A. Berger) G. Kunkel (1980).
Crassulaceae
105
Fig. 29. Crassulaceae. A–E Aeonium tabulaeforme. A Rosette. B Leaf from rosette. C Flowering plant. D Flower. E Carpels with hypogynous scales. F–H Sedum sedoides.
F Flowering plant. G Flower. H Carpel with detached scale. (Berger 1930)
Perennial, rarely biennial, sometimes monocarpic subshrubs or single or caespitose subshrubby rosette plants; stems glabrous, puberulent, or with reticulate pattern, leaf scars often distinct; leaves glabrous, glabrate, pubescent, or viscid, margins often ciliate; inflorescences terminal (axillary in A. simsii (Sweet) Stearn), often large thyrsoids or pleiochasia (esp. sect. Greenovia), scape distinct; flowers (6)7–12(–16) or 18–32-merous; sepals connate at base, glabrous or pubescent; petals free, spreading or slightly recurved, usually yellow(ish) or whitish; nectary scales rarely absent; carpels sometimes distinctly immersed in the receptacle, often with glandular hairs; fruits kyphocarpic; seeds costate-papillate or most often costate. n = 18, 27, 36. About 36 species, Macaronesia (Canary Islands, Cape Verde Islands, Madeira), south-western Morocco, Northeast and East Africa and Yemen. According to molecular data (Mes 1995; Mes et al. 1996; Mort et al. 2002), paraphyletic with respect to Greenovia; the latter is recognised as one of five sections within Aeonium (Nyffeler in Eggli 2003). Aeonium is a classic example of adaptive radiation leading to a broad array of growth forms, which has been studied with regard to phylogenetics (Mes 1995; Mes et al. 1997; Mort et al. 2002), adaptive radiation (Jorgensen and Olesen 2001), growth forms (Mes and ’t Hart 1996; Mes et al. 1996; Jorgensen and Olesen 2000) and ecophysiology (Lösch 1990). A. nobile (Praeger) Praeger may exhibit the largest rosettes in the family, with up to 80 cm Ø.
I.5. Tribe Sedeae Fr. (1835). No tribal characters. Genera 16–28. This tribe includes the Leucosedum and Acre clades which both are well supported with molecular cpDNA restriction-site data (van Ham and ’t Hart 1998). With a broader sampling of matK sequence data (Mort et al. 2001), both clades are weakly supported only and together sister to Sedum magellense Tenore (cf. Fig. 27); this pattern may become even more evident with an exhaustive study. Thus, both clades for the time being are not recognised as distinct taxa but are subsumed as two informal clades within tribe Sedeae. I.5. a. Leucosedum clade Plants usually glandular-hairy (not in American taxa). Genera 16–21. Mainly in winter-rainfall regions. This clade also includes the major part of Sedum subg. Gormania, which is broadly paraphyletic according to molecular data (van Ham 1994; van Ham and ’t Hart 1998; ’t Hart et al. 1999; Mort et al. 2001). Genera 16–19 Petals connate. Genera 17 + 18 with rosettes. These taxa are independently derived from within European-Mediterranean Sedum subg. Gormania, according to molecular data (van Ham and ’t Hart 1998; ’t Hart et al. 1999; Mort et al. 2001).
106
J. Thiede and U. Eggli
16. Pistorinia