Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 134 FLUID CATALYTIC CRACKING V MATERIALS AND TECHNOLOGICALINNOVATIONS
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 134 A d v i s o r y Editors: B. D e l m o n and J.T. Yates V o l u m e 134
FLUID CATALYTIC CRACKING V MATERIALS AND TECHNOLOGICAL INNOVATIONS Edited by
Dr. M.L. Occelli
MLO Consulting, 6105 Black Water Trail, Atlanta, GA 30328-2716, USA
Dr. R O'Connor
Akzo Nobel Catalysts, P.O. Box 247, 3800 AE Amersfoort, The Netherlands
2001 ELSEVIER Amsterdam
- L o n d o n - N e w Y o r k - O x f o r d - Paris - S h a n n o n - T o k y o
E L S E V I E R S C I E N C E B.V. S a r a B u r g e r h a r t s t r a a t 25 P.O. B o x 211, 1000 AE A m s t e r d a m ,
The Netherlands
9 2001 E l s e v i e r S c i e n c e B.V. All r i g h t s r e s e r v e d . This work is protected under copyright by Elsevier Science, and the following terms and conditions apply to its use: Photocopying Single photocopies of single chapters may be made for personal use as allowed by national copyright laws. Permission of the Publisher and payment of a fee is required for all other photocopying, including multiple or systematic copying, copying for advertising or promotional purposes, resale, and all forms of document delivery. Special rates are available for educational institutions that wish to make photocopies for non-profit educational classroom use. Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier Science Global Rights Department, PO Box 800, Oxford OX5 1DX, UK; phone: (+44) 1865 843830, fax: (+44) 1865 853333, e-mail:
[email protected]. You may also contact Global Rights directly through Elsevier=s home page (http://www.elsevier.nl), by selecting 'Obtaining Permissions=. In the USA, users may clear permissions and make payments through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA; phone: (+1) (978) 7508400, fax: (+1) (978) 7504744, and in the UK through the Copyright Licensing Agency Rapid Clearance Service (CLARCS), 90 Tottenham Court Road, London WlP 0LP, UK; phone: (+44) 207 631 5555; fax: (+44) 207 631 5500. Other countries may have a local reprographic rights agency for payments. Derivative Works Tables of contents may be reproduced for internal circulation, but permission of Elsevier Science is required for external resale or distribution of such material. Permission of the Publisher is required for all other derivative works, including compilations and translations. Electronic Storage or Usage Permission of the Publisher is required to store or use electronically any material contained in this work, including any chapter or part of a chapter. Except as outlined above, no part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission of the Publisher. Address permissions requests to: Elsevier Science Global Rights Department, at the mail, fax and e-mail addresses noted above. Notice No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made. First e d i t i o n 2001 L i b r a r y o f C o n g r e s s C a t a l o g i n g in P u b l i c a t i o n Data A c a t a l o g r e c o r d f r o m t h e L i b r a r y o f C o n g r e s s h a s b e e n a p p l i e d for.
ISBN: 0-444-50475-3 ISSN: 0167-2991 O T h e p a p e r u s e d in t h i s p u b l i c a t i o n m e e t s t h e r e q u i r e m e n t s o f A N S I / N I S O Z 3 9 . 4 8 - 1 9 9 2 ( P e r m a n e n c e o f Paper). P r i n t e d in T h e N e t h e r l a n d s .
Contents List of Contributors
VII
Preface Defect structure and acid catalysis of high silica, FAU-framework zeolites: effects of aluminum removal and of basic metal oxide addition R.A. Beyerlein and G.B. McVicker The use of microcalorimetry and solid state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) to study the effects of post-synthesis treatments on the acidity and framework composition of several HY-type zeolites M.L. Occelli, A. Auroux, M. Kalwei, A. W61ker and H. Eckert
41
The effects of steam aging temperature on the properties of an HY zeolite of the type used in FCC preparations M.L. Occelli, A. Auroux, A. Petre, M. Kalwei, A. W6lker and H. Eckert
59
Effect of catalyst properties and feedstock composition on the evaluation of cracking catalysts A.A. Lappas, Z.A. Tsagrasouli, LA. Vasalos and A. Humphries
71
Study on the deactivation-aging patterns of fluid cracking catalysts in industrial units F. Herndndez-Beltrdn, E. L6pez-Salinas, R. Garc[a-de-Le6n, E. Mogica-Martinez, J.C. Moreno-Mayorga and R. Gonzdlez-Serrano
87
The improvement of catalytic cracking process through the utilization of new catalytic materials M.I. Levinbuk, V.B. Melnikov, S. Numan, M.L. Pavlov and V.A. Patrikeev
107
NExCC ru _ Novel short contact time catalytic cracking technology J. Hiltunen, V.M. Niemi, K. Lipigiinen, I. Eilos, P. Hagelberg, P. Knuuttila, K. Jiiiiskelgiinen, J. Majander and J. R6ppiinen
111
Effect of vanadium on light olefins selectivity C.-Y. Li, S.-H. Yan, Z.-H. Qiu, L.-W. Tang and M.-Y. Gu
133
Reduction of olefins in FCC gasoline S. Katoh, M. Nakamura and B. Skocpol
141
Gasoline sulfur removal: kinetics of S compounds in FCC conditions A. Corma, P. Gullbrand and C. Marffnez
153
vi Development of a kinetic model for FCC valid from ultra-short residence times M.A. den Hollander, M. Makkee and J.A. Moulijn
167
Deactivation of fluid catalytic cracking catalysts: a modelling approach F. L6pez-lsunza
187
Catalyst design for resin cracking operation: benefits of metal tolerant technologies L.T. Boock and T.F. Petti
201
Active site accessibility of resid cracking catalysts Y. Lu, M. He, J. Song and X. Shu
209
Catalyst evaluation for atmospheric residue cracking, the effect of catalyst deactivation on selectivity W.R. Gilbert
219
Optimum properties of RFCC catalysts S.-I. Andersson and T. Myrstad
227
An experimental protocol to evaluate FCC stripper performance in terms of coke yield and composition C.E. Snape, Y.R. Tyagi, M. Castro Diaz, S.C. Martin, P.J. Hall R. Hughes and C.L. (Arthur) Koon
239
Use of 13C-labelled compounds to probe catalytic coke formation in fluid catalytic cracking C.L. Wallace, C.E. Snape, N.J. Gudde, G.W. Ketley and A.E. Fallick
251
B ifunctionality in catalytic cracking catalysis W.L. Schuette and A.E. Schweizer
263
Catalytic cracking of alkylbenzenes. Y-zeolites with different crystal sizes S. Al-Khattaf and H. de Lasa
279
On the mechanism of formation of organized mesoporous silica that may be used as catalysts for FCC R. Zana, J. Frasch, M. Soulard, B. Lebeau and J. Patarin
293
Catalyst assembly technology in FCC. Part I: A review of the concept, history and developments P. O'Connor, P. lmhof and S.J. Yanik
299
Catalyst assembly technology in FCC. Part II: The influence of fresh and contaminant-affected catalyst structure on FCC performance C.W. Kuehler, R. Jonker, P. Imhof, S.J. Yanik and P. O'Connor
311
Keyword Index
333
vii
List of Contributors
S. A1-Khattaf Chemical Reactor Engineering Centre Faculty of Engineering University of Western Ontario London, Ontario CANADA N6A 5B9
H. de Lasa Chemical Reactor Engineering Centre Faculty of Engineering University of Western Ontario London, Ontario CANADA N6A 5B9
S.-I. Andersson Chalmers University of Technology Department of Applied Surface Chemistry SE-41296 Gothenburg SWEDEN
M.A. den Hollander Industrial Catalysis Department of Chemical Technology Faculty of Applied Sciences Delft University of Technology Julianalaan 136 2628 BL Delft THE NETHERLANDS
A. Auroux Institut de Recherches sur la Catalyse CNRS 2 Av. A. Einstein 69626 Villeurbanne FRANCE R.A. Beyerlein National Institute of Standards and Technology Gaithersburg, MD 20899-4730 USA L.T. Boock Grace Davision 7500 Grace Drive Columbia, MD 21044 USA M. Castro Diaz University of Strathclyde Department of Pure and Applied Chemistry Glasgow G1 1XL Scotland UK A. Corma Instituto de Tecnologfa Qufmica UPV-CSIC Avda. de los Naranjos, s/n 46022 Valencia SPAIN
H. Eckert Institut ftir Physikalische Chemie Westf~ilische Wilhelms-Universit~it Miinster Schlossplatz 7 D-48149 Miinster GERMANY I. Eilos Fortum Oyj P.O. Box 310 06101 Porvoo FINLAND A.E. Fallick Scottish Universities Research & Reactor Centre East Kilbride Glasgow G75 0QU UK J. Frasch Laboratoire de Matrriaux Minrraux (CNRSENSCMu) 3 rue Alfred Wemer F-68093 Mulhouse FRANCE
viii R. Garcia-de-Le6n Programa de Investigaci6n en Tratiamento de Crudo Maya Instituto Mexicano del Petr61eo Ejo Central L~aro C&denas 152 C.P. 07730 M6xico, D.F. MEXICO W.R. Gilbert PETROBAS R & D Center Process Division Rio de Janeiro, 21949-900 BRAZIL R. Gonz~ilez-Serrano Programa de Investigaci6n en Tratiamento de Crudo Maya Instituto Mexicano del Petr61eo Ejo Central L~aro C&denas 152 C.P. 07730 M6xico, D.F. MEXICO M.-Y. Gu Research Institute of Petroleum Processing (RIPP) SINOPEC Beijing CHINA N.J. Gudde BP, Oil Technology Centre Chertsey Road Sunbury-on-Thames Middlesex TW16 7LN UK P. Gullbrand Instituto de Tecnologfa Qufmica UPV-CSIC Avda. de los Naranjos, sin 46022 Valencia SPAIN P. Hagelberg Fortum Oyj P.O. Box 310 06101 Porvoo FINLAND
P.J. Hall University of Strathclyde Department of Pure and Applied Chemistry Glasgow G1 1XL Scotland UK M. He Research Institute of Petroleum Processing China Petrochemical Corporation Beijing 100083 P.R. CHINA F. Hern~dez-Belmin Programa de Investigaci6n en Tratiamento de Crudo Maya Instituto Mexicano del Petr61eo Ejo Central L~aro C~denas 152 C.P. 07730 M6xico, D.F. MEXICO J. Hiltunen Fortum Oyj P.O. Box 310 06101 Porvoo FINLAND
R. Hughes University of Salford Chemical Engineering Unit Salford M5 4WT UK A. Humphries Akzo Nobel Catalysts Inc. 2625 Bay Area Blvd., Suite 250 Houston, TX 77058 USA P. Imhof Akzo Nobel Catalysts Research Center Catalysts Amsterdam THE NETHERLANDS K. J/i/iskel/iinen Fortum Oyj P.O. Box 20 00048 Fortum FINLAND
R. Jonker Akzo Nobel Catalysts Research Center Catalysts Amsterdam THE NETHERLANDS M. Kalwei Institut fiir Physikalische Chemie Westf~ilische Wilhelms-Universit~it Miinster Schlossplatz 7 D-48149 Miinster GERMANY S. Katoh Kashima Oil Company Kashima JAPAN G.W. Ketley BP, Oil Technology Centre Chertsey Road Sunbury-on-Thames Middlesex TW16 7LN UK P. Knuuttila Fortum Oyj P.O. Box 310 06101 Porvoo FINLAND C.L. (Arthur) Koon University of Salford Chemical Engineering Unit Salford M5 4WT UK C.W. Kuehler Akzo Nobel Catalysts Houston, Texas USA A.A. Lappas Chemical Process Engineering Research Institut (CPERI) Department of Chemical Engineering University of Thessaloniki P.O. Box 361 57001 Thermi, Thessaloniki GREECE
B. Lebeau Laboratoire de Mat6riaux Min6raux (CNRS-ENSCMu) 3 rue Alfred Werner F-68093 Mulhouse FRANCE M.I. Levinbuk Gubkin Moscow Oil and Gas University 65 Leninsky prosp. Moscow 117917 THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION C.-Y. Li Research Institute of Petroleum Processing (RIPP) SINOPEC Beijing CHINA K. Lipiainen Fortum Oyj P.O. Box 310 06101 Porvoo FINLAND F. L6pez-Isunza Departamento de Ingenierfa de Procesos e Hidrfiulica Universidad Aut6noma MetropolitanaIztapalapa Av. Michoacfin y La Purisima sin Col. Vicentina Iztapalapa M6xico 09340, D.F. MEXICO E. L6pez-Salinas Programa de Investigaci6n en Tratiamento de Crudo Maya Instituto Mexicano del Petr61eo Ejo Central Lfizaro Cfirdenas 152 C.P. 07730 M6xico, D.F. MEXICO Y. Lu Research Institute of Petroleum Processing China Petrochemical Corporation Beijing 100083 P.R. CHINA
J. Majander Fortum Oyj P.O. Box 20 00048 Fortum FINLAND M. Makkee Industrial Catalysis Department of Chemical Technology Faculty of Applied Sciences Delft University of Technology Julianalaan 136 2628 BL Delft THE NETHERLANDS S.C. Martin University of Strathclyde Department of Pure and Applied Chemistry Glasgow G1 1XL Scotland UK
J.C. Moreno-Mayorga
Programa de Investigaci6n en Tratiamento de Crudo Maya Instituto Mexicano del Petr61eo Ejo Central L~aro C~irdenas 152 C.P. 07730 M6xico, D.F. MEXICO J.A. Moulijn Industrial Catalysis Department of Chemical Technology Faculty of Applied Sciences Delft University of Technology Julianalaan 136 2628 BL Delft THE NETHERLANDS T. Myrstad Statoil's Research Centre N-7005 Trondheim NORWAY
C. Martfnez Instituto de Tecnologfa Quimica UPV-CSIC Avda. de los Naranjos, s/n 46022 Valencia SPAIN
M. Nakamura Nippon Ketjen Tokyo JAPAN
G.B. McVicker ExxonMobil Research & Engineering Co. Annandale, NJ 08801 USA
V.M. Niemi Fortum Oyj P.O. Box 310 06101 Porvoo FINLAND
V.B. Melnikov Gubkin Moscow Oil and Gas University 65 Leninsky prosp. Moscow 117917 THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION
S. Numan Gubkin Moscow Oil and Gas University 65 Leninsky prosp. Moscow 117917 THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION
E. Mogica-Martfnez Programa de Investigaci6n en Tratiamento de Crudo Maya Instituto Mexicano del Petr61eo Ejo Central L~aro C~denas 152 C.P. 07730 M6xico, D.F. MEXICO
M.L. Occelli MLO Consulting Atlanta, GA 30328 USA P. O'Connor Akzo Nobel Catalysts Amersfoort THE NETHERLANDS
J. Patarin Laboratoire de Mat6riaux Min6raux (CNRS-ENSCMu) 3 rue Alfred Wemer F-68093 Mulhouse FRANCE V.A. Patrikeev Salavat Catalyst Factory Salavat 453206 THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION M.L. Pavlov Ishimbai Catalyst Factory Ishimbai 453210 THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION A. Petre Institut de Recherches sur la Catalyse CNRS 2 Av. A. Einstein 69626 Villeurbanne FRANCE T.F. Petti
Grace Davision 7500 Grace Drive Columbia, MD 21044 USA Z.-H. Qiu Research Institute of Petroleum Processing (RIPP) SINOPEC Beijing CHINA J. R6pp~inen Fortum Oyj P.O. Box 20 00048 Fortum FINLAND W.L. Schuette (deceased) A.E. Schweizer ExxonMobil Refining and Supply Company Process Research Laboratories P.O. Box 2226 Baton Rouge, LA 70821-2226 USA
X. Shu Research Institute of Petroleum Processing China Petrochemical Corporation Beijing 100083 P.R. CHINA B. Skocpol Akzo Nobel Catalysts Amersfoort THE NETHERLANDS C.E. Snape University of Strathclyde Department of Pure and Applied Chemistry Glasgow G1 1XL Scotland UK J. Song Research Institute of Petroleum Processing China Petrochemical Corporation Beijing 100083 P.R. CHINA M. Soulard Laboratoire de Mat6riaux Min6raux (CNRS-ENSCMu) 3 rue Alfred Werner F-68093 Mulhouse FRANCE L.-W. Tang Research Institute of Petroleum Processing (RIPP) SINOPEC Beijing CHINA Z.A. Tsagrasouli Chemical Process Engineering Research Institut (CPERI) Department of Chemical Engineering University of Thessaloniki P.O. Box 361 57001 Thermi, Thessaloniki GREECE Y.R. Tyagi University of Strathclyde Department of Pure and Applied Chemistry Glasgow G1 1XL, Scotland
xii I.A. Vasalos Chemical Process Engineering Research Institute (CPERI) Department of Chemical Engineering University of Thessaloniki P.O. Box 361 57001 Thermi, Thessaloniki GREECE C.L. Wallace University of Strathclyde Department of Pure and Applied Chemistry Glasgow G1 1XL Scotland UK A. Wrlker Institut fiir Physikalische Chemie Westf/ilische Wilhelms-Universi~t Miinster Schlossplatz 7 D-48149 Miinster GERMANY S.-H. Yan Research Institute of Petroleum Processing (RIPP) SINOPEC Beijing CHINA S.J. Yanik Akzo Nobel Catalysts Singapore
Preface Catalyst production for the transformation of crudes into gasoline and other fuel products is a $2.1 billion/year business and fluid cracking catalysts (FCCs) represent almost half of the refinery catalyst market (M. MacCoy, Chemical and Engineering News, p. 17, September 20 (1999)). During the cracking reactions, the FCC surface is contaminated by metals (Ni, V, Fe, Cu, Na) and by coke deposition. As a result, the catalyst activity and product selectivity is reduced to unacceptable levels thus forcing refiners to replace part of the recirculating equilibrium FCC inventory with fresh FCC to compensate for losses in catalyst performance. About 1,100 tons/day of FCC are used worldwide in over 200 fluid cracking catalyst units (FCCUs). Today, the worldwide capacity to produce gasoline exceeds the 460 million gal/day. In addition, FCCs are used in the commercial synthesis of acrylonitrile, phthalic anhydride and maleic anhydridie and in the production of 45% of the world propylene (Chemical and Engineering News, p. 51, November 23, 1998). In recognition of the great technological importance of the FCC process, on November 3, 1998 the first commercial fluid bed reactor using catalytic cracking constructed at the Exxon Baton Rouge refinery, was designated a National Historic Chemical Landmark by the American Chemical Society. It is for these reasons that refiners' interest in FCC research has remained high through the years and almost independent of crude oil prices. However, recent oil company mergers and the dissolution of research laboratory, has drastically decreased the number of researchers involved in petroleum refining research projects. As a results the emphasis has shifted from new materials research to process improvements and this trend is clearly reflected in the type of papers contained in this volume. Modem spectroscopic techniques continue to be essential to the understanding of catalysts performance and several chapters in the book describe the use of 27A1, 29Si and ~3C NMR to study variation in FCC acidity during aging and coke deposition. In addition several chapters have been dedicated to the modeling of FCC deactivation, and to the understanding of contact times on FCC performance. Refiners efforts to conform with environmental regulations are reflected in chapters dealing with sulfur removal, metals contaminants and olefins generation In conclusion, as before we would like to express our gratitude to our colleagues for acting as technical referees. The views and conclusion expressed herein are those of the chapter authors whom we sincerely thanks for their time and effort in presenting their research at the Symposium and in preparing the camera ready manuscripts for this Volume. Mario L. Occelli and Paul O'Connor November 2000
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 134 M.L. Occelli and P. O'Conner (Editors) 9 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
Defect Structure and Acid Catalysis of H i g h Silica, F A U - F r a m e w o r k Zeolites: Effects of A l u m i n u m R e m o v a l and of Basic Metal O x i d e Addition Robert A. Beyerlein* and Gary B. McVicker* *National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD 20899-4730 *ExxonMobil Research & Engineering Co., Annandale, NJ 08801 The catalytic properties of ultrastable Y (USY) are directly influenced by the zeolite destruction that occurs during formation of USY and during subsequent hydrothermal treatment. Mildly steamed USY materials exhibit a secondary pore system (mesopores) of 550 nm dimensions, which are evident as light amorphous zones in Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM). Combined high resolution electron microscopy (HREM) and analytical electron microscopy (AEM) investigations on hydrothermally deaiuminated USY materials have shown that, in regions of high defect concentration, mesopores "coalesce" to form channels and cracks, which, upon extended hydrothermal treatment, define the boundaries of fractured crystallite fragments. The predominant fate of aluminum ejected from lattice sites appears to be closely associated with dark bands, which decorate the newly formed fracture boundaries. A smaller proportion of ejected aluminum exists as "nonframework AI" within the zeolite cages. High silica Y materials, having little or no nonframework A1 exhibit poor catalytic activity for a large variety of acidity-dependent reactions. Investigations on mildly dealuminated zeolites suggest that the origin of the enhanced catalytic activity is a synergistic interaction between Br0nsted (framework) and highly dispersed Lewis (nonframework) acid sites. The enhanced cracking, isomerization activity associated with the presence of highly dispersed nonframework A1 species i) is not reflected in direct measures of solid acidity obtained, for example, by calorimetry or by NMR spectroscopy, and ii) is not consistent with a major increase in average acid site strength. Numerous structure/function studies indicate that the critical nonframework A1 species may exist as cationic species in the small cages of dealuminated H-Y. By contrast, partial exchange of high silica Y materials with monovalent cations, such as Na or K, leads to significant reduction in activity, presumably by poisoning acid sites. In prior studies of isobutane conversion over dealuminated H-Y, it was shown that the addition of sodium equivalent to 1/3 of the total framework A1 atoms completely eliminates catalyst activity. Extensions of these poisoning studies show that addition of potassium produces a much stronger poisoning effect, with one K + ion giving an activity suppression roughly equivalent to that produced by two Na § ions. Calcium addition gives rise to a poisoning effect intermediate between those of Na + and K + at low levels of exchange, ca. 10%, but is more mild than that of sodium as Ca ++ exchange levels exceed 20%. Previous correlations of isobutane conversion activity with framework composition support a direct dependence of carbocation-facilitated processes on framework aluminum (A1F), with a linear dependence of carbonium ion rates on A1F content. The observed linear
dependencies exhibited for Na or K addition show that the primary effect of poisoning, or of A1F removal, is a decrease in the number of active sites. Measured selectivities for carbocation products indicate a limiting site density of about A1F/ucell - 8 (out of a maximum 56 A1 among 192 tetrahedral framework sites for a starting zeolite Y), below which carbocation activity diminishes rapidly. Consistent with previous discussion of dual mechanisms, the results for formation of methane, a stable reaction product marker, show that the initiation step and the secondary carbocation processes are intimately linked over the entire range of acid site content, whether manipulated by dealumination or by permanent poisoning by basic alkali or alkaline metal oxides.
1. INTRODUCTION The importance of acid catalysis for the production of fuel and petrochemicals is underscored by recent environmental mandates calling for reformulated motor fuel that contains greater proportions of high octane, branched paraffins and oxygenates. Environmental concerns about the catalysts themselves, particularly the highly corrosive and toxic liquid acids, such as sulfuric and hydrofluoric acids, have created a need for stable, strongly acidic solid acids. Combined theoretical and experimental studies of the last decade have substantially improved our level of understanding of solid acidity in zeolites. The prospect for obtaining a detailed molecular level understanding of heterogeneous catalysts that could better guide the search for improved catalysts appears to be optimum for crystalline solid acids. It is the object of this paper to review our current understanding of the predominant solid acid catalyst, the family of protonated FAU-framework materials stabilized by hydrothermal treatment, originally designated ultrastable Y (USY) [1, 2] and commonly referred to as dealuminated H-Y (H-ultrastable Y). The catalytic properties of ultrastable Y are directly influenced by the zeolite destruction attending its formation and further modification by subsequent hydrothermal treatment. For ultrastable, high silica, FAU framework materials prepared by steam dealumination, interpretation of catalytic data is complicated by the presence of entrained, nonframework aluminum (NFA) species. Although the individual and collective roles of framework and nonframework aluminum species are not well understood, it is clear that the presence of some nonframework A1, presumably highly dispersed, is essential for the strong solid acidity exhibited by high silica H-Y [3-5]. While the critical nonframework species are not easily subject to direct observation, the existence of isolated, intracrystalline NFA species in dealuminated H-Y materials is not in doubt. The importance of certain nonframework A1 species for the ability of zeolitic solid acids to catalyze acidity-demanding reactions [6], such as alkane skeletal isomerization or cracking, is not limited to H-Y. An abundant literature shows a consensus that the development of "enhanced carbocation activity" in mildly steamed HZSM-5 is also critically dependent on
the presence of nonframework A1 [6-9]. Enhancement of carbocation activity, generally associated with BrCnsted acidity, has also been observed in mildly steamed mordenite [10] and in HZSM-20 [ 11 ]. Knowledge of framework geometry is essential for understanding overall reactivity patterns for hydrocarbon conversions over these open framework solid acids. The well-known features of "molecular traffic management" exhibited by these materials are not always limited to molecular sieving, that is reactant or product size exclusion effects. For example, at reaction temperatures of 400 ~ to 500~ dealuminated H-USY and dealuminated mordenite (large pore zeolites)each catalyze the isomerization of isobutane to n-butane [12, 13]. Under similar conditions, the medium pore system HZSM-5 produces relatively little n-butane, but instead yields much methane and propylene [13, 14]. The dramatically different product selectivities in the latter case are attributed to the more severe spatial restrictions of the medium pore ZSM-5, which tend to inhibit hydride transfer and oligomerization/backcracking processes involving bulky reaction intermediates. Ever since the rapid commercialization in the early 1960's of a zeolite-catalyzed process for gas oil cracking [15, 16], zeolites have comprised the predominant usage of solid acid catalysts. The characterization and application of high silica, protonated zeolites in fluid catalytic cracking has been reviewed by Scherzer [17]. A broader overview of the use of zeolites in hydrocarbon processing is found in Maxwell and Stork [ 18]. A large number of potential zeolite catalyst applications in the synthesis of intermediates and fine chemicals have been discussed by Hoelderich et al. [19-21]. An outstanding attribute of the acidic FAU H-Y materials is their ability to catalyze intermolecular hydride transfer reactions in numerous hydrocarbon conversions, which are all but missing in less strongly acidic amorphous solid acids. Despite high industrial and academic interest, the nature of the active site in solid acids remains largely unresolved. In systems of wide interest such as a protonated zeolite, a chlorided or fluorided alumina, or sulfated zirconia, we are unable to quantify the distribution or relative importance of BrCnsted and/or Lewis sites, the surface acid strength, or the concentration of acid sites [22]. Recent advances in physical characterization of sites have substantially improved our understanding of these issues. Both 1H MASNMR [8, 23-25] and 13C MASNMR [26] have been effective in formalizing the structure/function relationships for BrCnsted acid sites in HZSM-5, an especially favorable system for analysis owing to its low BrCnsted acid site density and high crystallinity. So far, only "clean framework" ZSM-5 has been reasonably well characterized. The extension of these and related spectroscopic studies to the more complex systems represented by mildly steamed, carbocation activity enhanced HZSM-5 or dealuminated H-Y comprises a significant experimental and data interpretation challenge.
In the following sections, we review advances in the understanding of (i) the evolution of defect formation in dealuminated H-Y, (ii) the critical role played by nonframework aluminum in the acid catalysis exhibited by these materials and (iii) the dual effects of aluminum removal and of basic metal oxide addition on catalyst activity and selectivity. The discussion of acid catalysis is cast primarily in terms of kinetic methods for classifying solid acidity. As noted in a recent review by Haag [27], the question of acid strength is much more problematic and complicated. Theoretical efforts to elucidate structure-acidity relationships have made great progress, but are primarily limited to the "clean framework" case. Direct measures of solid acid strength within a homologous series of solid acids, e.g., ZSM-5 or dealuminated H-Y, including "in situ" calorimetric and/or spectroscopic methods, will often, but not always correlate with catalytic properties. 2. D E F E C T S P R O D U C E D BY H Y D R O T H E R M A L T R E A T M E N T 2.1. B a c k g r o u n d - F o r m a t i o n of Ultrastable Y
The formation of Ultrastable FAU materials may be viewed as a two-step process in which steam-calcination of the ammonium (or H) form of the Y-zeolite at the approximate conditions T=500~
Pa2o = 1 atm, for 2 hours, leads to the expulsion of A1 atoms from
framework T-sites as indicated in Figure 1. Following aluminum expulsion from framework positions, the resulting vacancies are to a great extent, refilled by silicon atoms migrating from
Two-step process: 1 Calcination of the ammonium (or H) form of the Y-zeolite at T > 500~ PH20< 1 atm ==~>Expulsion of AI atoms from framework T-sites Si I 0 I Si--O-AII 0 I Si
H+ 0 I O-Si-O I 0
Si I 0 H
+
3H20
b,-
Si-OH
H 0 I Si
HO-SI
+
AI(OH)3
G.T: Kerr, 1979
2 Healing / Si replacement- Resulting vacancies are refilled to a large extent with Si atoms Limited concensus
on this m e c h o n i s m
Figure 1. Schematic representation of formation of ultrastable Y materials
the collapsed portions of the crystal. If this "healing" did not occur, the entire zeolite crystal would transform into a predominantly x-ray amorphous phase. The resulting restructured FAU material, originally designated Ultrastable Y or USY [1, 2], displays a contracted unit cell size and increasing hydrothermal stability as framework Si/A1 increases. A typical reduction in unit cell dimension is from 2.470 nm for the starting zeolite Y to 2.456 nm for the product USY. Increasingly more severe steam treatments result in a higher level of dealumination, a more contracted unit cell, and an increasing fraction of crystalline zeolite destruction. In certain chemical methods of dealumination, notably the ammonium hexafluorosilicate (AHF) method of Skeels and Breck [28], the silicon for "healing" of vacancies resulting from framework A1 removal originates from an external source. In contrast, during the formation of USY, the inserted silicon originates from an internal source (the zeolite itself) that results from damage to the zeolite framework with the concomitant formation of mesopores. The mechanism of silica transport and insertion into vacancies was first suggested by Maher, Hunter and Scherzer [29]. According to this mechanism, the silica required to fill the framework vacancies originates in those parts of the zeolite crystal which collapse during the hydrothermal treatment. The silica freed from the collapsed framework migrates under high temperature steam toward the tetrahedral vacancies of the remaining framework and, by filling them, increases framework stability [30]. Prior sorption studies tend to support this interpretation. Based on sorption studies on USY zeolites, Lohse et al. concluded that entire sodalite units, or [3-cages, are destroyed during hydrothermal dealumination [31, 32], leading to the formation of a secondary pore system [30] or mesoporosity in the range of 5 to 50 nm. As shown schematically in Figure 2, the collapse of sodalite units, or even ensembles of them, generates mesoporosity and simultaneously provides the source of Si atoms for healing the framework sites vacated by A1. Lattice destruction of hydrothermally dealuminated (or thermochemically treated) FAU materials, leading to the formation of an amorphous silica phase, may be identified in the 29Si MASNMR spectra by a broadened peak or shoulder at about-110 ppm (TMS) [33]. Recent
29Si and 27A1 MASNMR
and microcalorimetry
investigations of the aging and regeneration of Fluid Cracking Catalysts (FCC) have shed new light on mechanisms of healing and on overall silica losses [34a]. Results of these studies indicate that the products of hydrothermal transformation of the kaolin clay and the alumina/silica gel (components of the catalyst matrix of the composite FCC particle) represent possible sources of silica. Upon aging, each of these components generate penta-, tetrahedrally- and octahedrally-coordinated A1 species, and at the same time, Si compounds, which can contribute both to healing and to net silica losses from the FCC particle [34a,b]. Measurements of silica/alumina composition for a fresh catalyst and for the corresponding equilibrium catalyst from a commercial Fluid Cracking Unit show a dramatic drop in the bulk
Figure 2. Schematic model for mechanisms of dealumination in FAU, showing Si for "healing," and the source of mesoporosity.
SIO2/A1203 ratio from 3.6 for fresh to 2.5 for the used or "equilibrium" catalyst, indicating a substantial silica loss from the FCC particle during use [34b]. 2.2. Nonframework Aluminum- Local Environment
Nonframework aluminum (NFA) is a catchall description for a wide collection of defects that are produced during the formation of USY and during subsequent hydrothermal treatment. NFA species are themselves composed of several different types, some isolated, some agglomerated, as outlined in Table 1. It has proven to be particularly difficult to characterize the many different NFA species in dealuminated H-Y. Structural studies using X-ray and neutron diffraction have indicated the presence of octahedrally coordihated microcrystalline aluminum species in the supercages [35], and isolated tetrahedral aluminum species in the small (sodalite) cages [36], but do not give much information about agglomerated noncrystalline species. A systematic study of the reduction in micropore volume [37] resulting from mild dealumination of H-Y, and of HZSM-5, indicated that the majority of NFA species go to the micropores accessible to N2, the supercages (c~-cages) in the case of H-Y, and to the channels or channel intersections in the case of HZSM-5. The combination of high resolution 29Si and of 27A1 solid state NMR has been effectively applied to studies of
Table 1 Types of aluminum a in ultrastable Y Types detect- Probable structure able by NMR description
Isolated or clustered
Most abundant
TF
T-site
isolated
mildly dealuminated
TNFA
A1 in small cage and/or
isolated
mildly dealuminated
TNFA
clustered alumina species in S-C b and/or surface enrichment
severely dealuminated
PNFA
intermediate between octahedral and tetrahedral
unknown
severely dealuminated
ONFA
alumina species in s-c
clustered
always present
s-c = supercage
[from Ref. 61]
a
T = tetrahedral, 0 = octahedral
b
hydrothermally dealuminated Y zeolites [38]. The former provides direct information on the composition and Si, A1 distribution of the tetrahedral framework, independently of the presence of non-framework A1 species, while the latter allows distinction between tetrahedral framework A1 (-60 ppm) and octahedral non-framework A1 (-0 ppm). The interpretation of 27A1NMR in terms of A1 species location or state of agglomeration is often ambiguous. Even at low levels of dealumination, the contribution of nonframework species to the tetrahedral resonance cannot be ruled out. The fact that a wide range of transitional aluminas exhibit a ratio of tetrahedrally coordinated A1 over total A1 content of about 0.4 [39] illustrates the need for caution in attributing the tetrahedral resonance in zeolites to framework aluminum. Extensively dealuminated samples typically show substantial broadening of the tetrahedral resonance [40, 41], as shown in Figure 3, only a small portion of which can be attributed to framework A1 [41, 42]. In addition, as higher magnetic fields and faster sample spinning have become more routine, a new resonance has been observed at 30 ppm (Figure 3), which has been attributed to either an aluminum in a highly distorted tetrahedral environment [41-44] or a penta-coordinated aluminum species [44, 45]. Application of the novel double-rotation (DOR) spinning technique [46, 47] to the study of
27A1in zeolites [48] has shown two
different tetrahedral A1 species for a commercial USY material, one framework and the other nonframework [48]. On the basis of comparison of single pulse
27A1MASNMR and 27A1CP
MASNMR taken on a steamed Y zeolite, Fripiat and co-workers [49] concluded that a substantial portion of the band near 60 ppm is contributed by tetrahedrally-coordinated NFA.
10
4X
T
Acid wash, 0.1 N HCI . Steam 650~ 4 hr 5X
T
~, It
]\
2X
"
A
Acid wash x 2, 0.1 N Steam650~ 3 hr, NH4§ exch.,acid wash,
o.o33..
A
Calcine 538~ 2 hr Steam 600~ 3 hr
l ~ j ~
T
Parent USY (LZ-Y82)
1X 9 A z~ =+0
~5o
~oo"5'o . . . .
o:sO-~'oo"-l'sOPp",
~
Figure 3. Evolution of deauluminated USY as tracked by 27A1 MAS NMR [42, 61 ]. 9 framework AI" •, nonframework A1. 2.3. Nonframework A l u m i n u m and Mesoporosity
Previous transmission electron microscope (TEM) studies of hydrothermal aging of neat USY materials [50-54] and also of USY cracking catalysts [55-58] have shown 5 to 50 nm defect domains, which were attributed to mesopores. Such features, more pronounced in the presence of vanadium [55, 56], are characteristic of extended hydrothermal treatment. Typical porosity analyses of mildly steamed USY materials show a distribution of mesopore dimensions in the range 5 to 50 nm that is skewed toward the smaller sizes [5 l, 53], supporting the association of the light amorphous zones observed by TEM with the secondary pore system characteristic of USY materials [3 "., 32, 50-53]. A new understanding of the formation and evolution of mesopores has emerged from combined high resolution electron microscopy (HREM) and analytical electron microscopy (AEM) investigations on hydrothermally treated USY materials [42, 59]. In contrast with
11 results of previous TEM investigations [50, 51, 54], HREM and AEM studies of a steam/acid treated neat USY material, and of a high-temperature steam-treated USY cracking catalyst [42, 59], gave clear evidence for an inhomogeneous distribution of mesopores (Figure 4), which occurs concomitantly with further zeolite dealumination. Such inhomogeneities were found to be more pronounced for the (high temperature) steam-deactivated USY cracking catalyst than for the (moderate temperature) steam/acid-treated neat USY material. It was concluded that the extent of inhomogeneity is driven by non-equilibrium processes represented by accelerated steam-aging treatments in the laboratory. In regions with high defect concentration, mesopores "coalesce" to form channels and cracks (Figures 4, 5a, 6), which ultimately define the boundaries of fractured crystallite fragments. At these boundaries, a dark band is often observed which is highly enriched in aluminum (Figure 5), while within the mesopore, aluminum appears to be deficient (Figure 7) [59]. Such dark bands appear to have been observed in prior studies [53], but their presence was not discussed. The predominant fate of aluminum ejected from lattice sites appears to be closely associated with the dark bands, which often decorate these newly formed fracture
Figure 4. HREM image of several USY grains in the steamed USY catalyst showing an inhomogeneous distribution of mesopores. A coalescence of mesopores indicating an evolving fracture is indicated by an arrow [42].
12
Figure 5. (a) TEM image of a few steam/acid treated USY grains. An inhomogeneous distribution of mesopores is seen within individual grains; some grains contain more mesopores than others. In regions with high mesopore concentration, the pores coalesce to form channels (indicated by arrows). (b) HREM image of steam/acid treated USY grains. Many mesopores are formed. Although localized disorder is observed within the pores, the connecting regions remain crystalline [59].
13
Figure 6. HREM image of a steam/acid treated USY grain. Cracks (as indicated by arrows) are formed from the evolution of the coalesced mesopores. Dark bands, which were found to be A1 rich, are seen along these cracks [59].
Figure 7. A1, Si analyses from a STEM image of the region adjacent to and also within a mesopore. Within a mesopores, A1 is slightly deficient [59].
14 boundaries (Figure 6). These features were observed both for the steamed USY cracking catalyst (Fig. 8) and for the steam/acid treated neat USY zeolite (Figs. 5a, 6), consistent with results of previous studies, which found the surface enrichment of A1 to persist through aqueous treatments that remove substantial amounts of aluminum [60, 63]. For the steam/acid-treated neat USY material, the associated development and evolution of nonframework A1 species was investigated by high resolution solid state 27A1 MASNMR (Figure 3) [42, 61 ]. From this parallel study, it was concluded that the extracrystalline phases represented by the dark bands revealed in the electron microscopy studies contribute the majority of the nonframework aluminum species, tetrahedral, penta-coordinate, and octahedral, that were detected by 27A1NMR [61 ].
Figure 8. HREM image showing the fracturing of a USY grain in the steamed USY catalyst. Each fractured crystallite is bounded by cracks evolved from coalescence of mesopores. The dark band seen along each crack is A1 enriched, similar to those observed in the steam/acid treated neat USY material [59].
15
Similar patterns of defect formation were found upon re-investigation by HREM [61 ] of the age-separated FCU fractions from an earlier study [58]. An FCU "young" fraction (Figure 9) proved to be similar to the lab-steamed samples except that defect patterns are more homogeneous than for the case of accelerated aging in the lab. An FCU "old" fraction (Figure 10) shows more destruction, higher concentrations of mesopores, more A1 enriched bands, and the presence of more highly fractured grains than are found in the laboratory-aged samples (Figs. 4, 5, 6, 8).
16
Figure 10. HREM image of an "old" fraction from a commercial Fluid Catalytic Cracking Unit. Extensive crystallite fracture and many prominent dark bands are observed [61].
3. S T R O N G ACIDITY IN U L T R A S T A B L E Y 3.1. Background - Some Nonframework Aluminum is Essential The central role of framework A1 content in defining the catalytic properties of dealuminated H-Y was discussed in a classic paper by Pine, et al [62]. These workers concluded that catalyst activity, selectivity, and octane performance are each correlated with unit cell size, which, in turn is directly proportional to the number of aluminum atoms in the framework. The result of this study is genetically summarized in Figure 11. With increasing dealumination and concomitant loss of framework A1, selectivity (towards naphtha octane and olefinic content) tends to increase, but at the expense of catalyst activity and naphtha yield. The importance of nonframework aluminum (NFA) was not revealed in studies such as this. The more obvious manifestations of NFA species, such as the agglomerated species found in the electron microscopy studies discussed in the previous section, typically lead to decreased activity. Such agglomerated NFA species are thought to contribute to increased coke make
17 and not to desirable products. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) studies on hydrothermally dealuminated H-Y zeolites have shown that a considerable enrichment of aluminum occurs near the zeolite surface during the process of forming USY, with further accumulation at the surface upon extended hydrothermal treatment [60, 63]. Haag [27] observed that this migration of nonframework A1 to the external crystal surface generally lowers activity, presumably due to NFA species that have migrated to the surface and neutralized some of the BrCnsted acid sites near the crystallite surface [27, 63]. Haag further associated the increase in catalytic activity following ammonium exchange of a steamdealuminated zeolite with the reversal of this surface site neutralization [27]. Prior to the mid1980s, NFA species were generally regarded as undesirable, pore-blocking, amorphous "debris" and were often referred to as "detrital" A1. This picture has been changed by more recent studies which show that high silica H-Y materials, having little or no nonframework A1, exhibit poor catalytic activity for acidity dependent reactions (See Ref. 3-5, 61 and Table 2). It is concluded that the presence of some nonframework A1 is essential for the strong catalytic activity exhibited by fresh and mildly steamed USY materials. It is now generally accepted (3, 5, 61, 64) that the activity and selectivity of Y zeolites in catalytic cracking are determined by an interplay of framework aluminum and nonframework aluminum species. The implicated NFA species, presumably well dispersed, may exist as isolated, cationic species in the small cages.
Si/AI 2O 15 i
C
o
!
i
10 i
5 i
!
i
i
i
24.5
c (D
E :15 24.4 fl)
c
~D
24.3
24.2
9
N~ , # Al/ucell
!
Figure 11. Relation between framework composition of USY and unit cell dimension, upon which is superposed a generic representation of the role of unit cell size as a unifying concept in the catalytic properties of USY as discussed by Pine, et al [62].
18 Table 2 Certain NFA species are essential to good catalytic performance a for ultrastable FAU materialsb Si/A1 Unit Cell (nm)
Isobutane conv. rates, mol/(h.g) x l 0 3 total
carb. ion
1. clean framework, high-silica Y
4.9
2.454
13.7
8.5
62
2. conventional USY c
5.1
2.456
35.8
28.7
80
3. USY formed from AHF-dealum. material d
8.1
2.441
43.5
33.1
76
% carb. ion
Catalytic performance of clean framework, high-silica FAU is poor. a 500oc, 1.0 atm, 0.25 atm of i-C4/He (200 cm3/min); pretreat 1 h, 500~ He. b Na level in all three materials is low, Na_< 0.15 wt% [Ref. 3] c LZ-Y82, obtained from Union Carbide Portion of Sample #1, steamed at 570~ (PH2o = IA atm, 2 h) and then ammonium-exchanged.
3.2. Direct Measures of Solid Acidity in Zeolites: (a) Lack of Correlation with Activity, (b) The Question of Superacid Sites The enhanced cracking, isomerization activity associated with the presence of dispersed nonframework A1 species is not reflected in direct measures of solid acidity. In a review of studies of solid acidity by adsorption microcalorimetry, Dumesic and co-workers [65] note that, for dealuminated H-Y, the calorimetric results obtained at room temperature do not correlate with the catalytic activity for cumene cracking at 573 K. Samples with high activity showed essentially the same values of heat of adsorption of ammonia as did samples exhibiting
substantially
lower
activity.
Gorte
and
co-workers
[66]
carried
out
microcalorimetry measurements of pyridine and of isopropylamine adsorption, and also measured activities for hexane cracking on a series of steamed and chemically dealuminated H-Y materials. The calorimetry investigations failed to detect evidence for superacidic sites, and there was no correlation between hexane cracking activities and heats of adsorption for the materials examined. These workers also found no evidence for a very small concentration of strong sites, the presence of which had been previously proposed from calorimetry studies on steam-dealuminated USY catalysts [67]. Sommer, et al. [68] used 1H and 2H N M R to compare zeolite Y-catalyzed versus superacid-catalyzed proton-deuterium exchange in alkanes. From investigations of the extent of H/D exchange during passage of different light alkanes over an acidic D20-exchanged USY material (Si/A1F-- 4.5), it was concluded that
19 dealuminated H-Y cannot be considered as a superacid capable of protonating ~-bonds in alkanes. The acid strength was compared to that of sulfuric acid, consistent with results of Umansky, Engelhardt and Hall [69], and also with recent investigations of 13C chemical shift measurements of mesityl oxide by Haw and co-workers [70], which indicate that the acidity of ZSM-5 is comparable to that of a solution of 70% sulfuric acid.
3.3. Theoretical Studies of Br~nsted Acidity in Zeolites Significant progress has been made in understanding the nature and energetics of BrOnsted acid catalyzed hydrocarbon conversion reactions through theoretical, quantum chemistry-based studies, many of which have been carried out in combination with experiment [71-83]. The results of these studies indicate that stable carbocations in acid catalysis by zeolites may be the exception rather than the rule. In fact, the only such species observed spectroscopically have been exceptionally stable (and bulky) cations such as the methyl indanyl [84] or trityl [85] cations. This consensus is consistent with the landmark contribution by Kazansky [77-80], who first presented a mechanism for protonation of alkenes that did not involve the formation of stable carbenium ions. Theoretical studies by the van Santen group [71-76], initially on reactions of H-D exchange, and more recently extended to a wide range of hydrocarbon elementary reactions [76], have demonstrated a closely-related mechanism by which a stable carbocation is avoided. "The results of calculations indicated that the relatively stable intermediates of hydrocarbon transformations in zeolites are not carbocations but alkoxy groups covalently bound to the zeolite lattice. The carbocations represent high-energy activated complexes or transition states [75]." For example, this group found transition states for ethane cracking that are similar to carbenium ions albeit with stabilization from the lattice [74]. In other words, zeolite catalysts do not stabilize free carbocations, but the transition states associated with reaction pathways do resemble carbocations, consistent with Kazanky's earlier findings [77-80] and with the suggestion by Kramer and McVicker in a 1986 review paper [ 14]. In their recent review of the combined NMR and theoretical studies of solid acidity by Haw and co-workers [25, 26, 81-84], Haw, Nicholas and Xu [83] discuss similar conclusions from their studies of zeolites, emphasizing the contrast with comparable studies on true solid superacids. These workers observed that the body of theoretical and complementary experimental studies of zeolite acidity "do not support the long-held interlocked assumptions that zeolites are solid superacids and that free carbenium ions are prolific in zeolites... One of the earliest results of our combined theoretical and experimental collaboration was to show that H-D exchange in benzene on zeolites could also proceed without a stable benzenium intermediate. In contrast to the results on zeolites, it proved to be very easy to generate carbenium ions on Lewis acids such as A1C13powder and
20 BrCnsted acids such as HB/A1Br3 ... the wealth of NMR observations of cations on true solid superacids provided a context for interpreting and understanding the negative observations on the zeolites [83]." In summary, zeolites, as a class of solid acids, appear not to comprise superacids that stabilize free carbocations. The quantum chemical calculations indicate that carbocation-like transition state pathways, not stable reaction intermediates are available in zeolites. These are thought to proceed via routes that require stabilization from the lattice, such as through formation of surface alkoxy groups.
3.4. Synergism between framework and nonframework sites The question remains "What is the nature of the apparent synergism between framework and nonframework aluminum species that gives rise to enhanced catalytic activity? Beyerlein, McVicker and co-workers [3,4] suggested that the increased catalytic activity exhibited by USY materials, in comparison with "clean framework" FAU materials with comparable Si/A1F, may involve a "synergism" between Br0nsted sites associated with framework A1 and Lewis sites associated with dislodged aluminum. Such a synergism is consistent with the previously proposed concept of superacidity [10, 86] - as distinct from "superacids." A conceptual model for such a synergism was discussed by Lunsford and co-workers [5] who suggested that polyvalent A1 ions in the small cages are responsible for withdrawal of electrons from the framework OH- groups ("bridging hydroxyls"), thus making the protons more acidic. This model appears to be at odds with most direct measures of Br0nsted acidity (Sections 3.2. and 3.3.) and also with the results of combined acidity and reactivity investigations of Soled, McVicker and co-workers on USY zeolites modified by fluoride (HCF3) treatment [87]. For Si/A1 framework ratios near 5.5, these workers observed a substantial activity enhancement (ca. x 1.5) at low fluoride dealumination l e v e l s - in comparison with conventionally steam-dealuminated ultrastable Y zeolites with comparable framework composition. Such an activity enhancement cannot be correlated with either the number or strength of acid sites. In fact, the most active fluorided zeolite, with a framework Si/A1 ratio of about 5.5 and an F content near 1%, contained fewer BrCnsted sites than nonfluorided USY zeolites with similar Si/A1 framework ratios. Temperature programmed desorption of NH3 and integral calorimetric adsorption heats of NH3 indicated that acid strength decreased upon fluorine incorporation [87]. What remains unclear is the possible presence and role of a very small concentration of strong acid sites [67]. Soled, McVicker and co-workers [87] found that integral heats of adsorption obtained from TG/DTA NH3 titrations,160 kJ/mol for USY and 149 kJ/mol for 0.9%F/USY, did not show an increase in acid site strength for the fluorided sample. In contrast, investigations of differential heats of titration with pyridine by Ahsan, Arnett and
21 McVicker [88] revealed a small number of strong sites on both the USY and the 0.9%F/USY samples. Initial heats of adsorption, 144 kJ/mol and 174 kJ/mol for the USY and 0.9%F/USY samples, respectively, suggested that a larger number of exceptionally strong sites are present on F/USY than on USY. At the same time, both the average acid site strength and the total acid site number for the fluorided sample showed a decrease in comparison to USY. These workers concluded that the high activity F/USY catalyst behaves as if there were a larger number of acid sites present capable of converting isobutane. At equal conversions, the USY and F/USY samples exhibited near-equivalent selectivities, both for primary products and for secondary (carbocation) products [88]. The results of these studies raise anew the question: Could a small number of strong sites be key in the strong catalytic acidity exhibited by mildly dealuminated USY catalysts? Fripiat and co-workers have carried out extensive investigations on the nature of Lewis sites in aluminas, dealuminated mordenite, and dealuminated H-Y using both 27A1NMR [49, 89] and FFIR on adsorbed CO [90, 91]. The high resolution 27A1NMR studies [89] indicated the presence of two kinds of Lewis sites within the nonframework A1 distribution in dealuminated zeolites - a tetrahedral site and a pentagonal site with isotropic shifts of about 53 ppm and 37 ppm, respectively. The FfIR-CO adsorption studies [90, 91] also revealed the presence of two types of Lewis sites associated with nonframework aluminum. In the case of dealuminated mordenite, it was further shown that these Lewis sites were highly dispersed. Investigations of the isomerization of n-pentane and of o-xylene over dealuminated mordenites [92] showed initial reaction rates to be proportional to the product of the number of BrCnsted and the number of Lewis sites, suggesting that the the high acidity of dealuminated mordenites derives from a synergistic interaction between BrCnsted (framework) and highly dispersed Lewis (nonframework) acid sites [90-92]. Brunner et al. [6] arrived at similar conclusions from their NMR investigations of acid sites in ZSM-5. Fripiat and co-workers have also applied high resolution 298i NMR REDOR as an advantageous way to study the 1H - 29Si interaction for the characterization of BrCnsted sites [93]. They arrived at the quantitative conclusion that a BrCnsted site is an OH bridging an aluminum to a silicon with only one aluminum neighbor. An OH bridging an aluminum to a silicon with more than one aluminum neighbor is a proton donor but not a BrCnsted site capable of donating a proton to NH3 to make NH4+. These workers also found that there are fewer BrCnsted sites than framework A1 sites and that the difference between the number of BrOnsted sites and the number of framework A1 sites increased with the amount of nonframework A1 [93]. It was suggested that some of the acidic OH groups have disappeared owing to their neutralization by reaction with NFA species, consistent with the suggestion of Haag [27].
22 3.5. Alternative explanations for enhanced activity in mildly steam-dealuminated zeolites It has recently been suggested that the enhanced catalytic activity exhibited by steamed H-Y zeolites may be an artifact of a diffusion-limited reaction, which is "enhanced" by the formation of structural defects during hydrothermal treatment [94]. In the absence of any direct measurements on micropore diffusion, a model is put forth that incorporates the assumption that most of the BrOnsted sites in HY are inaccessible to the "micropore diffusionlimited bimolecular and oligomeric cracking reactions." In this model, the enhanced activity arises from the increase in defects/external surface area associated with hydrothermal treatment rather than from any direct influence of nonframework aluminum. This model fails to explain a number of salient observations in prior literature, including: (1) the markedly enhanced activity in HZSM-5 where the hydrothermal treatment is exceedingly mild [6, 27], (2) the poor catalytic activity exhibited by "clean framework," chemically dealuminated (via ammonium hexafluorosilicate, i.e., AHF) FAU materials [3-5], notwithstanding the demonstrably increased external surface area associated with chemical dealumination via
Table 3 Influence of sample size on Isobutane Conversion: a Results for Ultrastable FAU materials Conversion rates Carb ion Convn., Si/A1F grams mol %
% carb ion act.
total mol/(h'g) x 103
5b
0.30
7.28
69
32.5
22.4
0.196
5
0.40
9.48
70
31.7
22.2
0.194
5
0.50
12.6
73
33.7
24.6
0.215
5
0.60
15.7
74
34.9
25.8
0.225
molec/(min'A1F)
5
0.70
18.8
75
35.9
26.9
0.235
5
0.80
21.1
76
35.3
26.8
0.234
5
1.00
26.9
80
36.0
28.8
0.251
12.4 c
1.00
13.0
71
17.4
12.4
0.227
12.4
2.30
30.1
78
17.5
13.6
0.249
1.0 atm, 0.25 atm of i-C4/He (200 cm3/min); pretreat 1 h, 500~ He. b LZ-Y82 obtained from Union Carbide. c High-silica FAU material prepared from LZ-Y82; 650~ steam, 2 h, PH2o = 1/3 atm; NH4+ exchange; 0.33 N HC1 extraction [Ref. 3].
a 500oc,
23 AHF [3], and (3) the dramatically enhanced activity exhibited by ultrastable FAU materials prepared from AHF-treated materials (see Table 2, Fig. 12 and Refs. 3, 96). In the latter study, Beyerlein, McVicker and co-workers [3] carried out additional isobutane conversion investigations using varying amounts of conventional ultrastable FAU materials with compositions Si/A1F = 5 and 12.4. The results, reproduced in Table 3, show that, over a wide range of sample sizes, total rates and selectivities are little affected. Carbonium ion activity [3, 12, 95] per framework aluminum atom is essentially independent of both sample size and framework aluminum content. Catalyst deactivation in these studies was minimal, barely detectable in the mass balance [3,12]. Such consistency furnishes compelling evidence against the presence of any diffusion limitations in these studies and strongly supports the contention that carbonium ion activity [95] is directly dependent upon framework aluminum content. As discussed previously by McVicker et al. [12], the experimental evidence strongly suggests that a bimolecular mechanism gives rise to the secondary "carbonium ion products" in isobutane conversion, namely, propane, n-butane and isopentane.
3.6. Importance of the concentration and type of nonframework species The dependence of catalytic properties of dealuminated H-Y materials on unit cell size, or equivalently, on framework A1 content, can be profoundly altered by the concentration and type of nonframework species. In the case of steam/mineral acid-dealuminated ultrastable Y materials with framework compositions Si/A1F of 5 or greater, both hexane cracking [5, 97, 98] and isobutane conversion [3, 4] investigations show a linear dependence of activity on framework aluminum content. However, "unconventional" ultrastable Y materials, prepared by mild steam treatment of a "clean framework," AHF dealuminated USY were found by Beyerlein, McVicker and co-workers [3] to exhibit enhanced carbonium ion activity [95] for isobutane conversion (Figure 12). In these studies, carbonium ion activity, as evidenced by skeletal isomerization and oligomerization and back-cracking of isobutane [12], was found to be directly proportional to framework A1 content. It was suggested that the enhanced activity exhibited by the these materials, in comparison with results from conventionally prepared USY materials of comparable framework composition, was associated with their relatively lower content of nonframework A1 species (A1NFA), A1NFA/A1F-- 0.4. By contrast, the conventionally prepared ultrastable materials, for which the ratio A1NFA/A1Franged from 0.66 to 2.2, contained higher levels of nonframework A1. Enhanced activities for similarly prepared materials were observed by L6nyi and Lunsford [98] in the course of hexane cracking investigations on high silica Y materials prepared by mild steam treatment of chemically (AHF) dealuminated (Na +, NH4+)-Y, and by Sun, Chu, and Lunsford [11] on mildly steamed ZSM-20 materials. (ZSM-20 is a high silica, hexagonal variant of FAU.)
24 Interestingly, for framework compositions Si/AIF of 5 or greater, each of these studies showed a ratio A1NFA/A1F = 0.4, consistent with the results of earlier investigations by Beyerlein, McVicker and co-workers [3]. While such studies demonstrate the critical role of nonframework species in the development of strong acidity, no information is provided on their location. Carvajel, Chu, and Lunsford [5] showed that the presence of La 3+ in the small cages leads to a significant increase in hexane cracking activity over that shown by clean framework, high silica FAU materials. These results provided definitive evidence for the association of isolated cationic species in the small cages with the development of enhanced acidity. For a given framework A1 content, each La-exchanged material showed substantially increased activity over that of its clean framework parent material and somewhat lower activity than that of dealuminated H-Y (Figure 13) [5]. The results of this study, and also those from recent investigations of Lewis acidity in dealuminated zeolites by Fripiat and coworkers [89-92], provide compelling evidence that the critical nonframework A1 species are a) highly dispersed, and b) quite possibly exist as cationic species in the small cages of dealuminated H-Y, as indicated from earlier structural studies [36].
,so0utane
30
/I
/
n"~t-
x
---~
E~
20
. ~ x:: 0
~-~ lo o.... 10 20 30 AIF, Framework AI/uc
,,.-.,
240
._=
E 200 160 O
E ::I.
120
~9
80
o
<
40 0
I
I
I
i
a
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 Framework aluminum (AI/u.c.)
Figure 12. Carbonium ion rates from studies of isobutane conversion over high silica Y, ultrastable materials: conventionally prepared, O; prepared from materials initially dealuminated by using AHF, 4,. The single data point at the lower right, II, represents the carbonium ion rate over a low-sodium, AHFtreated FAU material [3].
Figure 13. Hexane cracking activity over variously dealuminated high silica Y materials as a function of framework aluminum content [5] the effect of La3+ exchange. The intermediate activity curve shows the increase in activity following La 3§ exchange of clean framework materials (Those materials exhibiting lowest (near zero) activity are variously prepared clean framework materials). For the materials exhibiting highest activity: 9 Y-type zeolite dealuminated with SIC14; e, Y-type zeolite dealuminated by steaming [5].
25
3.7. Removal of Framework Sites by Poisoning - Comparison with Removal by Dealumination The arguments presented in the preceding section suggest that the exchange of high silica Y zeolite with trivalent cations, such as La 3+ or A13+, has important implications for solid acidity. By contrast, partial exchange of high silicaY materials with monovalent cations, as Na + or K +, leads to significant reduction in activity [4, 61, 66, 97]. The effect on isobutane conversion of controlled additions of Na + to a commercial ultrastable Y (Series 1) and to a further dealuminated ultrastable Y (Series 2) is shown in Figure 14 [4, 61 ]. It is apparent that Na addition suppresses activity much more rapidly than framework aluminum removal by dealumination. As indicated from the results of Na addition given in Figure 14 and by the replotting of these results in Figure 15, the addition of Na + equivalent to 1/3 of the total framework A1 atoms completely eliminates catalytic activity [4, 61 ]. Even lower proportions of added Na + were found to suppress hexane cracking activity in studies by Lunsford and coworkers [97]. It was concluded from these sodium poisoning studies that only a fraction of the framework A1 atoms are associated with strong acidity. This conclusion is supported by results of studies of isopropylamine desorption from dealuminated H-Y by Gorte and coworkers [66], which demonstrated that framework A1 content is significantly greater than BrCnsted acid site density. These workers suggested that each alkali ion affects only a single
Figure 14. Isobutane conversion studies of Na-poisoning [4, 61 ]. Effect on carbonium ion activity of controlled Na + addition to two USY parent materials with different Alp contents: o, Series 1, A1F = 32; A, Series 2, A1F = 21.6. Conditions: 500~ 1.0 atm, 0.25 atm of i-C4/He (200 cm3/min); pretreat 1 h, 500~ He.
26
o o o
40-
II Low Na, Dealuminated Materials
I"-"
x
E
30
133
Na + poisoned AIF = 32
,~
tO
v
E
WP
"kll
20
m
c~
rr
co
10
ii
.o
o
"k 0
--
0
m
I
5
.
I
10
I
I
.
I...
15 20 25 (AI F - 3Na)/Ucell
I
30
35
Figure 15. Effect of Na § addition on Isobutane Conversion - Comparison with dealumination: II, Low Na, dealuminated materials; ~, Na § poisoned materials, Alv= 32. active site and that framework A1 is not a good measure of acid site concentration. In their studies of the effect of NH3-poisoning on isobutane conversion on protonated zeolites (USY and ZSM-5 materials), W. K. Hall and co-workers [99] showed that the selective chemisorption of an NH3 equivalent of less than 10% of A1 tetrahedral [T] sites eliminated more than 90% of the activity. These workers concluded: "...only a small fraction of the total [A1T] sites is doing most of the work [99]." The recent high resolution 29Si NMR REDOR study of mildly dealuminated H-Y by Ffipiat and co-workers [93] has provided quantitative evidence that there are fewer Br0nsted sites than framework A1 atoms. This study showed that the difference between the number of BrCnsted sites and the number of framework A1 sites increased with increasing levels of nonframework A1. It was further suggested that some of the acidic OH groups have disappeared owing to their neutralization by reaction with NFA species [93]. The consistency of results from many different research teams using a variety of approaches furnishes compelling evidence that only a fraction of the framework A1 represents active sites. The notion that each alkali ion affects only a single active site has been called into question by results of hitherto unpublished studies which show that controlled addition of K + to dealuminated H-Y leads to a far more rapid suppression of isobutane conversion activity than does addition of Na + [100, 101]. The effect on isobutane conversion of controlled
27 additions of Na +, K +, and Ca ++ to a USY sample with Si/A1 = 5 is shown in Figure 16. Addition of potassium produces by far the strongest poisoning effect. Calcium addition gives rise to a poisoning effect intermediate between that of Na + and K + at low levels of exchange, ca. 10%, but shows an effect more mild than that of sodium as Ca ++ exchange levels exceed 20%. Comparison of the effect of K + addition on isobutane conversion with that of aluminum removal (Figure 17) shows that the addition of one K + gives an activity suppression roughly equivalent to the removal of 7 framework aluminum atoms. Alternatively, addition of one K § gives an activity suppression comparable to that of about two Na + ions. Similar trends have been reported by P.C. Dijkstra et al. [102] for alkali-ion-exchanged ZSM-5. This group showed that the extent of suppression of hexane cracking activity was directly related to cation size, with the effective degree of poisoning increasing with increasing ionic radius of the alkali metal cations. At equivalent levels of exchange, K + proved to be a more effective poison than Na + by a factor 1.5/1.2. It was concluded that aluminum sites in ZSM-5 are not isolated, but occur in clusters of two or three depending on aluminum content, consistent with suggestions of A1 pairs by Haag et al. [7, 27]. A quantitative assessment of the probability for occurrence of next-nearest neighbor (NNN) A1 pairs in ZSM-5 may derive from appropriate statistical analyses of the results of very recent synchrotron powder diffraction structural studies on Cs-ZSM-5 (Si/A1F = 15.5), which have provided definitive evidence for a nonrandom A1 distribution in ZSM-5 [103].
Figure 16. Effect of Cations, (Na § , K +, Ca ++) on Isobutane Conversion: ~:, Na + A, K § e, Ca ++
28
Figure 17. Effect of K§ addition on Isobutane Conversion- Comparison with dealumination: II, Low Na, dealuminated materials; A, K+ poisoned materials, A1F =32.
3.8. Effect of Acid Site Removal on Selectivity Previous correlations of isobutane conversion activity with framework composition [3] support a direct dependence of carbocation processes on framework aluminum, with a linear dependence of carbonium ion rates on A1F content. The demonstrated linear dependencies for Na or K addition (Figs. 15, 17) show that the primary effect of poisoning, or of framework A1 removal, is a decrease in the number of active sites. Utilizing the demonstrated linear dependencies for Na or K removal, the effect of decreasing acid sites on selectivity by aluminum removal is compared with that of Na addition in Figure 18, and with that of K addition in Figure 19. Carbonium ion selectivities (% carb ion activity) were estimated from the molar product ratio (n-butane + propane + isopentane)/total conversion products [95]. The measured selectivities (Figs. 18, 19) indicate a limiting site density of about A1F = 8, below which carbonium ion selectivity [95] diminishes rapidly.
29
Figure 18. Effect of decreasing acid sites on selectivity- Comparison of dealumination with Na + addition: II, Low Na, dealuminated materials; ~, Na + poisoned materials, A1F = 32.
Figure 19. Effect of decreasing acid sites on selectivity - Comparison of dealumination with K + addition: II, Low Na, dealuminated materials; A, K + poisoned materials, A1F =32.
30 3.9. Methane Formation - Tracking of Initiation Step in Carbocation pathways
Apparently, the likelihood of the initiation step for carbocation processes is sharply reduced in the vicinity of and below a limiting site density of about 8 A1F per unit cell. On the other hand, the results for the formation of methane (Figs. 20, 21), a stable reaction product marker, show that the initiation step and the secondary carbocation processes are intimately linked over the entire range of acid site content, whether manipulated by dealumination or by basic metal oxide addition. Comparison of the methane formation results in Figs. 20 and 21 with the carbocation selectivity results given in Figs. 18 and 19 shows that the initiation step is apparently independent of carbocation activity. These result are consistent with previous discussion of dual mechanisms [12, 14] and also with the results of acidity modification of USY zeolites by fluoride treatment [87]. The enhanced activity per A1F observed upon mild fluoride treatment was suggested to be due to an increased concentration of carbocation intermediates. It was concluded that the sites responsible for increasing the initiation rates, thus increasing the pool of carbocations, are not readily characterized by traditional chemical and physical acidity measurement probes [87, 88]. A combined EPR, NMR and product distribution study of oxidation sites in dealuminated mordenite has shown a strong correlation between the presence of nonframework A1 and the generation of radical cations [104]. Since Lewis sites in H-mordenite have been shown to be associated with nonframework A1 species [89-92], these results suggest a role of nonframework A1 species as electron acceptor sites for the generation of a radical cations, ultimately leading to the formation of olefins. Such a reaction sequence can serve as an initiation step for carbocation pathways, as proposed earlier [14]. Dumesic and co-workers [105] have shown that the reaction kinetics of the catalytic cracking of paraffins can be described by catalytic cycles that involve carbenium
ion
initiation,
l~-scission,
oligomerimization, olefin desorption, isomerization and hydride ion transfer reactions. These workers observe that a model involving carbenium ions is kinetically equivalent to a model involving surface alkoxy species, provided that the surface coverages by reactive intermediates are low. Consistent with the results on methane formation discussed here, Dumesic et al. [ 105] conclude: "Initiation reactions are irreversible, insensitive to conversion and form olefins in conjunction with olefin desorption reactions...Olefin adsorption/desorption reactions are in quasi-equilibrium, but they have a significant impact on activity and selectivity by determining surface coverages of carbenium ions."
31
I
, m *m
n-'~" 0.8 0 a3X
o~-E"~ 0.6
m
0.2 0
0
"
I
5
poisoned AI F 32 =
,m m
0.4
t'-4=-,
:~
Na +
,mm"
C o .0
aC ~~
m Low Na Delauminated Materials
I
10
I
I
I
15 20 25 (AI F- 3 Na)/Ucell
I
30
35
Figure 20. Methane formation rate vs. acid site concentration" m, Low Na, dealuminated materials; ~, Na + poisoned materials, A1F = 32.
Figure 21. Isobutane conversion rate vs. methane formation rate: m, Low Na, dealuminated materials; ~, Na + poisoned materials, A1F = 32; A, K+ poisoned materials, A1F =32; o, Ca ++ poisoned materials, A1F =32.
32 3.10. Severe versus Mild S t e a m T r e a t m e n t of D e a l u m i n a t e d H - Y - Effect on Acidity
Mild steam treatment (700 - 850 K, P~2o ~ 1) of ammonium-exchanged Y materials or of clean framework, high silica Y materials leads to sites of enhanced activity in acidity dependent reactions such as paraffin cracking or isomerization. By contrast, severe steam treatment (970 K to 1100 K, PH2o = 1) leads to rapid deactivation both by massive dealumination to framework compositions Si/A1F of 20 or more and by extensive crystalline destruction, as reviewed in the fluid catalytic cracking literature [17, 62,106, 107] and earlier in this paper. Investigations of differential heats of ammonia adsorption by Yaluris, et al. [108] have shown that, upon severe steam treatment of a USY catalyst (1060 K, Pn2o = 1, 2 hr) the acid site strength distribution shifts toward weaker sites. It has been suggested that the extensive dehydroxylation associated with severe steam treatment leads irreversibly to the formation of strong Lewis sites at the expense of BrCnsted sites [65]. For less severely dealuminated samples, the large scale migration and agglomeration of nonframework species discussed in Section 2 appears to have a retarding effect on activity, as a portion of the acidity and catalytic activity lost by steaming can be recovered by careful acid-leaching [3, 4, 109, 110], which removes both framework and nonframework A1 species. It has been suggested that the microporosity modifications associated with the generation of NFA species during hydrothermal treatment could change the initial pore diameter and thus the availability of acid sites [ 111 ]. Corma, et al [ 112] found that removal of some of the nonframework species from severely steam-dealuminated H-Y led to an enhanced alkylation activity and an extended catalyst life. In the case of mildly steamed HZSM-5, Lago, Haag and co-workers [7] attributed the generation of acid sites of enhanced activity (45 to 75 times more active than sites in clean framework HZSM-5) to the number of paired (NNN) A1 sites in the unsteamed parent. Upon severe steam treatment, or upon mild steam treatment of aluminum-poor HZSM-5 materials with one or less A1F/ucell (Si/A1 =100 or greater), enhanced activity is not observed. Measurements of isobutane conversion over extensively dealuminated H-Y indicate a limiting site density of about A1F/ucell = 8 (Si/A1F = 23 or greater), below which carbonium ion selectivity [95] diminishes rapidly [100]. HREM investigations of mesopore formation in USY materials subjected to different severities of steam treatment showed an inhomogeneous distribution of mesopores among different USY grains as well as within single grains [42, 59, 61]. Such inhomogeneities were found to be more pronounced for materials that were steam-treated at a higher temperature. These inhomogeneities, which encompass the presence of restricted regions with more severe dealumination and also regions with milder dealumination than the average, were attributed to the non-equilibrium nature of the accelerated steam-aging treatments in the laboratory. The
33 presence of numerous regions, less severely dealuminated than the average, can be expected to give a disproportionate contribution to the measured activity. As a result, the interpretation of measurements of solid acidity and/or of catalytic activity becomes increasingly problematic for severely steam-deactivated materials where such inhomogenities are most pronounced. In consideration of the inhomogeneities in defect concentration found by HREM [42, 59, 61 ], BrCnsted sites can be expected to contribute to measured activity even for severely steamdeactivated zeolitic catalysts where the average crystallinity is low. For the case of equilibrium cracking catalyst from the FCU where the average crystallinity is also low, the remaining BrCnsted acidity, and a disproportionate share of catalyst activity, is chiefly associated with the younger catalyst fractions, which have been shown to retain as much as 80% of the fresh catalyst crystallinity [58].
4. CONCLUSION The defect formation, which occurs reproducibly upon steam treatment of protonated zeolites, plays an important, although not well understood role in the acid catalysis exhibited by these materials. During the formation or further dealumination of a USY material by hydrothermal treatment, the collapse of small regions of the crystalline framework generates mesoporosity, simultaneously providing a source of Si atoms for healing the vacancies left by expulsion of A1 atoms from framework T-sites. A new understanding of the formation and evolution of mesopores during hydrothermal treatment has emerged from recent combined high resolution electron microscope (HREM) and analytical electron microscope (AEM) investigations on hydrothermally dealuminated USY materials [42, 59, 61]. The nonequilibrium nature of the accelerated steam-aging treatment in the laboratory gives rise to an inhomogeneous distribution of mesopores, which occurs concomitantly with further zeolite dealumination. In regions with high defect concentration, mesopores "coalesce" to form channels and cracks, which, upon extended hydrothermal treatment, ultimately define the boundaries of fractured crystallite fragments. The predominant fate of aluminum ejected from lattice sites appears to be closely associated with dark bands that often decorate these newly formed fracture boundaries, as observed by H R M . A smaller proportion of ejected aluminum exists as isolated [36] or agglomerated species [35] within the zeolite cages. Similar defect patterns, although less inhomogeneous, have been observed for age-separated (young) fractions from a commercial Fluid Cracking Unit [61 ], where the rate of deactivation is slower than for accelerated steam-aging in the lab. As a consequence of the pronounced inhomogeneities, including numerous regions with milder dealumination than the average, the interpretation of measurements of solid acidity and/or catalytic activity becomes increasingly
34 problematic for severely steam-deactivated materials where such inhomogeneities are most pronounced. High silica H-Y materials, having little or no nonframework A1, exhibit poor catalytic activity for acidity dependent reactions such as paraffin isomerization or cracking. Investigations of mildly dealuminated zeolites indicate that the origin of their high catalytic activity is a synergistic interaction between BrCnsted (framework) and highly dispersed Lewis (nonframework) acid sites. The enhanced cracking, isomerization activity associated with the presence of highly dispersed nonframework AI species is not reflected in direct measures of solid acidity obtained, for example, by calorimetry or by NMR spectroscopy. The question of how nonframework aluminum affects catalytic activity remains an experimental and modeling challenge. The enhanced cracking, isomerization activity of mildly steamed materials almost certainly involves some synergistic interaction between framework BrCnsted sites and highly dispersed nonframework species. The presence of this enhanced activity is not consistent with a major increase in acid site strength. BrCnsted sites are presumably more dilute than the distribution of framework A1 as only a fraction of the framework A1 appears to represent active sites. The critical nonframework A1 species quite possibly exist as cationic species in the small cages of dealuminated H-Y. By contrast, partial exchange of high silica Y materials with monovalent cations, such as Na or K, leads to significant reduction in activity, presumably by poisoning acid sites. In prior studies of isobutane conversion over dealuminated H-Y, it was shown that the addition of sodium equivalent to 1/3 of the total framework A1 atoms completely suppresses catalyst activity [4, 61]. More recent extensions of these poisoning studies show that addition of potassium produces a much stronger poisoning effect, with one K + ion giving an activity suppression approximately equivalent to that produced by two Na § ions. In analogy with conclusions form a recent study reporting similar trends in ZSM-5 [ 102], these results are consistent with the presence of next-nearest-neighbor (NNN) A1 clusters in the FAU framework, such that a single alkali ion can influence more than one acid site. It is noted that conclusions on partial ordering of aluminum in the FAU framework, based on analyses of
29Si MASNMR
intensity data, indicate that A1 NNN pairs tend to be avoided
[1131. The current body of theoretical and associated experimental studies indicate that zeolites, as a class of solid acids, do not comprise superacids that stabilize free carbocations [71-84]. The quantum chemical calculations show that the transition states associated with reaction pathways resemble carbocations. That is, carbocation-like pathways are available in zeolites, but these proceed via routes that require stabilization from the lattice, such as through formation of surface alkoxy groups. In contrast with the results on zeolites, where none other
35 than bulky carbocations have been spectroscopically observed, carbenium ions are easily generated on Lewis acids such as A1C13 powder and BrCnsted acids such as HB/A1Br3 [83]. Previous correlations of isobutane conversion activity with framework composition support a direct dependence of carbocation processes on framework aluminum (A1F), with a linear dependence of carbonium ion rates on A1F content. The demonstrated linear dependencies for Na or K addition show that the primary effect of poisoning, or of A1F removal, is a decrease in the number of active sites. Measured selectivities indicate a limiting site density of about A1F/ucell - 8 (192 T sites/ucell), below which carbonium ion selectivity diminishes rapidly. Consistent with previous discussion of dual mechanisms, the results for formation of methane, a stable reaction product marker, show that the initiation step and the secondary carbocation processes are intimately linked over the entire range of acid site content, whether manipulated by dealumination or by poisoning. The initiation step appears to be independent of carbocation activity, consistent with the conclusions from independent efforts to describe the reaction kinetics of the catalytic cracking of paraffins [105]. While these and related studies have provided new understanding of the initiation step for carbocation pathways on zeolite catalysts, significant challenges remain. The sites responsible for increasing the initiation rates (and thus increasing the pool of carbocations) are not readily characterized by traditional chemical and physical acidity measurement probes. The nature of the initiation step(s) for the cracking of paraffins remains a subject of research. The recent advances in understanding of the bifunctional nature of zeolite catalysts reviewed here have led to some notable advances in Fluid Catalytic Cracking technology. The use of amorphous alumina added to rare earth exchanged Y zeolite to improve FCC activity and conversion to gasoline has been reported by Exxon [114]. The added alumina is reported to increase the Lewis acidity of the catalyst providing a dehydrogenation function. The olefins produced due to the increased Lewis acidity lead to improved conversion on the BrCnsted acid sites of the zeolite. These findings resulted in the commercialization of a new FCC formulation by Exxon.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors gratefully acknowledge many useful conversations with C. Choi-Feng, Werner Haag, Jan Hall, W. Keith Hall, George Kramer, Jack Lunsford, Mario Occelli, Lloyd Pine, G. J. Ray, Bill Schuette and Stu Soled. The expert assistance of B. J. Huggins, L. N. Yacullo and J. J. Ziemiak is also gratefully acknowledged.
36 References: 1. C.V. McDaniel and P. K. Maher, U.S. Patent No. 3,292,192 (1966); U.S. Patent No. 3,449,070 (1969). 2. C.V. McDaniel and P. K. Maher, in Zeolite Chemistry and Catalysis, ACS Monograph 171, Ed. J. A. Rabo (Amer. Chem. Soc., Washington, D. C., 1976) Chpt. 4. 3. R.A. Beyerlein, G. B. McVicker, L. N. Yacullo and J. J. Ziemiak, J. Phys. Chem. 92 (1988) 1967-1970. 4. R.A. Beyerlein, G. B. McVicker, L. N. Yacullo and J. J. Ziemiak, In Syrup. on Fundamental Chemistry of Promotors and Poisons in Heterogeneous Catalysis, Amer. Chem. Soc., New York, April 13-18, 1986, ACS, Div. Petr. Chem. Preprints, Vol. 31, 1986, pp. 190-197. 5. R. Carvajal, Po-Jen Chu and J. H. Lunsford, J. Catal. 125 (1990) 123-131. 6. E. Brunner, H. Ernst, D. Freude, T. Fr61ich, M. Hunger and H. Pfeifer, J. Catal. 1:27 (1991) 34-41. 7. R.M. Lago, W. O. Haag, R. J. Mikovsky, D. H.Olson, S. H. Hellring, K. D.Schmidt and G. T. Kerr, In Proceedings of the 7th International Zeolite Conference, Tokyo, 1986, Eds., Y. Murikami, et al., (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1986) pp. 677-684. 8. E. Brunner, H. Ernst, D. Freude, M. Hunger, C. B. Krause and D. Prager, Zeolites 9 (1989) 282-286. 9. Y. Sendoda and Y. Ono, Zeolites 8 (1988) 101-105. 10. C. Miradatos and D. Barthoumeuf, J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Comm. (1981) 39 11. Y. Sun, Po-Jen Chu and J. H. Lunsford, Langmuir 7 (1991) 3027. 12. G. B. McVicker, G. M. Kramer and J. J. Ziemiak, J. Catal. 83 (1983) 286-300. 13. P. Hilaireau, C. Bearez, F. Chevalier, G. Perot and M.Guisnet, Zeolites 2 (1982) 69. 14. G. M. Kramer and G. B. McVicker, Acc. Chem. Res. 19 (1986) 78-84. 15. C. J. Plank, E. J. Rosinski and W. P. Hawthorne, Ind. Engin. Chem., Product Research Dev. 3 (1964) 165. 16. C. J. Plank and E. J. Rosinski, Chem. Eng. Progr. Syrup. Ser. 73 (63) (1967) 26. 17. J. Scherzer, Octane-Enhancing Zeolite FCC Catalysts: Scientific and Technical Aspects; Marcel Dekker, New York (1990). 18. I. E. Maxwell and W.H. Stork, in Introduction to Zeolite Science and Catalysis, Studies in Surf. Sci. Catal., Vol. 58, Eds., E. M. Flanigen and J. C. Jansen (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1991) p. 571. 19. W. F. Hoelderich, M. Hesse and F. Naumann, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Eng. 27 (1988) 226. 20. W. F. Hoelderich, J. Roseler, G. Heitmann and A. T. Liebens, Catalysis Today 37 (1997) 353-366. 21. W. F. Hoelderich and G. Heitmann, Catalysis Today 38 (1997) 227-233. 22. J. Rabo and G. J. Gadja, Catal. Rev. Sci. Eng. 31 (1989) 385. 23. D. Freude and J. Klinowski, Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun. (1988) 1411-1413. 24. M. Hunger, D. Freude and H. Pfeiffer, J. Chem. Soc., Faraday Trans. 87 (1991) 657. 25. L. W. Beck, J. L. White and J. F. Haw, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 116 (1994) 9657-9661.
37 26. J. F. Haw, M. B. Hall, A. E. Alvarado-Swaisgood, Eric J. Munson, Z. Lin, L. W. Beck and T. Howard, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 116 (1994) 7308-7318. 27. W. O. Haag in ZeoIites and Related Microporous Materials: State of the Art 1994, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., Vol. 84, Eds., J. Weitkamp, H. G. Karge, H. Pfeifer and W. H61derich, (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1994) 1375-1394. 28. a) G. W. Skeels and D. W. Breck, in: Proceedings of 6th International Zeolite Conference, eds., D. Olson and A. Bisio (Butterworths, Surrey, UK, 1984) p. 87 ; b) D. W. Breck, H. Blass and G. W. Skeels, U. S. Patent No. 4,503,023 (1985). 29. P. K. Maher, F. D. Hunter and J. Scherzer, Adv. Chem. Ser. 101 (1971) 266. 30. J. Scherzer, in: Catalytic Materials--Relationship Between Structure and Reactivity; T. E. Whyte, et al., Eds. (Amer. Chem. Soc., Washington, D. C., 1984) pp. 157-200. 31. U. Lohse, H. Stach, H. Thamm, W. Schirmer, A. A. Isirikjan, N. I. Regent and M. M. Dubinin, Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem. 460 (1980) 179. 32. H. Stach, U. Lohse, H. Thamm and W. Schirmer, Zeolites 6 (1986) 74. 33. G. Engelhardt, U. Lohse, M. MS.gi and E. Lippmaa, In Structure and Reactivity of modified Zeolites, Eds., P. A. Jacobs, et al. (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1984) p. 23. 34. a) M. L. Occelli, et al., In Petroleum Refining and Petrochemical Industries, Stud. Surf. Sci. and Catal. Vol. 100, Eds., M. Absi-Halabi, et al. (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1995) p.27; b) M. L. Occelli, private communication, manuscript submitted to J. Catal. 35. R. C. Shannon, K. H. Gardner, R. H. Staley, G. Bergeret, P. Gallezot and A. Auroux, J. Phys. Chem. 89 (1985) 4778-4788. 36. J. B. Parise, D. R. Corbin and L. Abrams, Acta Cryst. C40 (1984) 1493-1497. 37. Y. Hong and J. J. Fripiat, Microporous Materials 4, (1995) 323-334. 38. G. Engelhardt and D. Michel, in: High Resolution Solid-State NMR of Silicates and Zeolites, (Wiley, New York, 1987) ch. V.3.4 (see, e.g., ref. nos. 2 76, 287). 39. G. B. McVicker, unpublished results. 40. J. Klinowski, J. M. Thomas, C. A. Fyfe and G. C. Gobbi, Nature (London) 296 (1982) 533. 41. A. Samoson, E. Lippmaa, G. Engelhardt, U. Lohse and H.-G. Jerschkewitz, Chem. Phys. Lett. 134 (1987) 589. 42. R. A. Beyerlein, C. Choi-Feng, J. B. Hall, B. J. Huggins and G. J. Ray, in: Fluid Catalytic Cracking 1II: Materials and Processes, ACS Symposium Series No. 571, Eds. M. L. Occelli and P. O'Connor (ACS, Washington, D.C., 1994) pp. 81-97. 43. V. Bosfi6ek and D. Freude, Innovation in Zeolite Materials Science, Eds. P. J. Grobet, et al, (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1987). 44. J. Sanz, V. Fomes and A. Corma, J. Chem. Soc., Faraday Trans. 1, 84 (1988) 3113. 45. J.-P. Gillson, G. C. Edwards, A. W. Peters, K. Rajagopalan, R. F. Wormsbecher, T. G. Roberie and M. P. Shatlock, J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun. (1987) 91. 46. a) A. Samoson, E. Lippmaa and A. Pines, Mol. Phys. 65 (1988) 1013. b) A. Samoson and E. Lippmaa, J. Magn. Reson. 84 (1989) 410. 47. Y. Wu, B. F. Chmelka, A. Pines, M. E. Davis, P. J. Grobet and P. A. Jacobs, Nature 346 (1990) 550. 48. G. J. Ray and A. Samosen, Zeolites 13 (1993) 410.
38 49. H. Hong, D. Coster, F. R. Chen, J. G. Davis and J. J. Fripiat, in: New Frontiers in Catalysis, Eds. L. Buczi, et al., Proc., 10th Intern. Congr. On Catal., 19-24 July, 1992, Budapest, Hungary (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1993) pp. 1159-1170. 50. F. Maug6, A. Auroux, J. C. Courcelle, Ph. Engelhard, P. Gallezot and J. Grosmangin, in: Catalysis by Acids and Bases, Eds. B. Imelik, et al. (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1985) p. 91. 51. V. Patzelov~, and N. I. Jaeger, Zeolites 7 (1987) 240. 52. J. Lynch, F. Raatz and P. Dufresne, Zeolites 7 (1987) 333. 53. J. Lynch, F. Raatz and Ch. Delalande, in: Characterization of Porous Solids, Eds. K. K. Unger, et al. (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1988) p. 547. 54. F. Maug6, J. C. Courcelle, Ph. Engelhard, P. Gallezot, J. Grosmangin, M. Primet and B. Trasson, in: Zeolites, Synthesis, Structure, Technology, and Application Eds. B. Dr2aj, et al. (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1985) p. 401. 55. F. Maug6, J. C. Courcelle, Ph. Engelhard, P. Gallezot and J. Grosmangin, in: New Developments in Zeolite Science and Technology Eds.Y. Murikami, et al. (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1986) p. 803. 56. P. Gallezot, B. Feron, M. Bourgogne and Ph. Engelhard, in: Zeolites: Facts, Figures, Future Eds. P. A. Jacobs, et al. (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1989) p. 1281. 57. P. G61in, and T. Des Couri6res, Appl. Catal. 72 (1991) 179. 58. R. A. Beyerlein, G. A. Tamborski, C. L. Marshall, B. L. Meyers, J. B. Hall and B. J. Huggins, in: Fluid Catalytic Cracking II, ACS Symposium Series 452, Ed.M.L. Occelli, (Amer. Chem. Soc., Washington, D. C., 1991) p. 109. 59. C. Choi-Feng, J. B. Hall, B. J. Huggins and R. A. Beyerlein, J. Catal. 140 (1993) 395405. 60. M. B. Ward and J. H. Lunsford, J. Catal. 87 (1984) 524. 61. R. A. Beyerlein, C. Choi-Feng, J. B. Hall, B. J. Huggins and G. J. Ray, Topics in Catalysis, Vol. 4 (1997) pp. 27-42; from: Acidity in Aluminas, Amorphous and Crystalline Silico-Aluminas, Eds. J. J. Fripiat and J. A. Dumesic (Balzer Science Publishers, Amsterdam, 1997). 62. L. A. Pine, P. J. Maher and W. A. Wachter, J. Catal. 85 (1984) 66-476. 63. Th. Gross, U. Lohse, G. Engelhardt, K. -H. Richter and V. Patzelov~, Zeolites 4 (1984) 25-29. 64. P. V. Shertukde, W. K. Hall, J-M Dereppe and G. Marcelin, J. Catal. 139 (1993) 468481. 65. N. Cardona-Martinez and J. A. Dumesic, in: Advances in Catalysis, Vol. 38; eds. D. D. Eley, H. Pines and P. B. Weisz, (Academic Press, San Diego, 1992) pp. 149-224. 66. A. I. Biaglow, D. J. Parillo, G. T. Kokotailo and R. J. Gorte, J. Catal. 148 (1994) 213223. 67. D. Chen, S. Sharma, N. Cardona-Martinez, V. A. Bell, G. D. Hodge, R. J. Madon and J. A. Dumesic, J. Catal. 136 (1992) 392. 68. Jean Sommer, M. Hachoumy and F. Garin, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 116 (1994) 5491-5492. 69. B. Umansky, J. Engelhardt and W. K. Hall, J. Catal., 127 (1991) 128-140. 70. Teng Xu, E. J.Munson and J. F. Haw, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 116 (1994) 1962-1972. 71. R. A. van Santen and G. J. Kramer, Chem. Rev. 95 (1995) 637.
39 72. R. A. van Santen, in: Advanced Zeolite Science and Applications, eds. J. C. Jansen et al. (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1994) p. 273. 73. J. A. Lercher, R. A. van Santen and H. Vinek, Catal. Lett. 27 (1994) 91. 74. S. R. Blaszkowski, M. A. C. Nascimento and R. A. van Santen, J. Phys. Chem. 100 (1996) 3463. 75. M. V. Frash, V. B. Kazansky, A. M. Rigby and R. A. van Santen, J. Phys. Chem. B 102 (1998) 2232-2238. 76. M. V. Frash and R. A. van Santen, Topics in Catalysis 9 (1999) 191-205. 77. V. B. Kazansky, in: Advanced Zeolite Science and Applications, eds. J. C. Jansen et al. (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1994) p. 251. 78. V. B. Kazansky and I. N. Senchenya, J. Mol. Cat. 74 (1992) 257. 79. V. B. Kazansky, Acc. Chem. Res. 24 (1991) 379. 80. I. N. Senchenya and V. B. Kazansky, Catal. Lett. 8 (1991) 317. 81. J. F. Haw, J. B. Nicholas, Teng Xu, L. W. Beck and D. B. Ferguson, Acct. Chem. Res. 29 (1996) 259. 82. J. B. Nicholas, Topics in Catalysis, Vol. 4 (1997) pp. 157-171; from: Acidity in Aluminas, Amorphous and Crystalline Silico-Aluminas, Eds. J. J. Fripiat and J. A. Dumesic (Balzer Science Publishers, Amsterdam, 1997). 83. a) J. B. Nicholas, Teng Xu and J. F. Haw, Topics in Catalysis 6 (1998) 141-149; b) J. F. Haw and Teng Xu, Advances in Catalysis 42 (1998) 115-180. 84. Teng Xu andJ. F. Haw, Am. Chem. Soc. 116 (1994) 10188. 85. T. Tao and G. E. Maciel, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 117 (1995) 12889. 86. a). P. A. Jacobs, Carboniogenic Activity of Zeolites (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1977). b) P. A. Jacobs, H. E. Leeman and J. B. Uytterhoeven, J. Catal. 33 (1974) 17. 87. S. L. Soled, G. B. McVicker, J. J. Ziemiak, G. DeMartin, L. N. Yacullo, K. Strohmaier and J. Millar, In Symp. on Chemically Modified Molecular Sieves, Amer. Chem. Soc., Chicago, August 22-27, 1993, ACS, Div. Petr. Chem. Preprints, Vol. 38 (3), 1993, pp. 546-551. 88. T. Ahsan, E. Arnett and G. B. McVicker, unpublished results. 89. D. Coster, A. L. Blumenfeld and J. J. Fripiat, J. Phys. Chem. 98 (1994) 6201-621!. 90. V. Gruver and J. J. Fripiat, J. Phys. Chem. 98 (1994) 8549-8554. 91. V. Gruver, Y. Hong, A. G. Panov and J. J. Fripiat, in: llth Int. Congr. on Catal., Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., Vol. 101, eds. J. Hightower, et al. (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1996) p. 741. 92. Y. Hong, V. Gruver and J. J. Fripiat, J. Catal. 150 (1994) 421-429. 93. A. L. Blumenfeld, D. Coster and J. J. Fripiat, J. Phys. Chem. 99 (1995) 15181-15191. 94. B. A. Williams, S. M. Babitz, J. T. Miller, R. Q. Snuff and H. H. Kung, A ppl. Catal. A: General 177 (1999) 161. 95. Carbonium ion selectivities were estimated with the molar product ratio (n-butane + propane + isopentane)/total conversion products. This ratio accounts for the major carbonium ion based products arising from isomerization and chain-cracking sequences. Carbonium ion activity was defined as the product of carbonium ion selectivity and total rate (See Ref. 12). 96. J. W. Ward and T. L. Carlson, U.S. Patent 4517073, May 14, 1985.
40 97. P. O. Fritz andJ. H. Lunsford, J. Catal. 118 (1989) 85. 98. Ferenc L6nyi and J. H. Lunsford, J. Catal. 136 (1992) 566-577. 99. W. K. Hall, J. Engelhardt and G. A. Sill, In Zeolites: Facts, Figures, Future, eds. P. A. Jacobs and R. A. van Santen (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1989) pp. 1253-1262. 100. a) R. A. Beyerlein, G. B. McVicker, L. N. Yacullo and J. J. Ziemiak, "Acidity Studies on High Silica Zeolite Y Materials - Effects of Aluminum Removal and of Na, K, Ca Addition," Thirteenth North American Meeting of the Catalysis Society, Pittsburgh, PA, May 2-6, 1993; b) this review paper. 101. The controlled cation additions were carried out using reagents NaNO2, KNO3 and Ca(NO3)2. In each case, hydrated zeolite was combined with a properly diluted reagent solution. In order to ensure equilibrium distribution of the added cations, this wet impregnation step was followed by a programmed calcination with slow nitrite/nitrate decomposition and a final calcination temperature of 475~ For a series of materials coveting the range - 2.5% to 60% cation exchange- good agreement was obtained between nominal and analyzed exchange levels. 102.P.C. Dijkstra et al. Catalysis Letters 10 (1991) 375-382. 103. D.H. Olson, N. Khosrovani, A. Peters, and B. Toby, J. Phys. Chem., In press. 104. G. Harvey, R. Prins, R. Crockett and E. Roduner, J. Chem Soc., Faraday Trans. 92 (1996) 2027. 105. R. D. Cortright, J. A. Dumesic and R. J. Madon, Topics in Catalysis 4 (1997) 15-26. 106.J. Biswas and I. E. Maxwell, Appl. Catal. 63 (1990) 197-258. 107.D.J. Rawlence and K. Gosling, Appl. Catal. 43 (1988) 213-237. 108. G. Yaluris, J. E. Rekoske, L. M. Aparicio, R. J. Madon and J. A. Dumesic, J. Catal. 153 (1995) 65-75. 109. A. Auroux and Y. Ben Taarit, Thermochim. Acta 122 [ 1987] 63. 110.M. Krivfinek, N. Thiet Dung and P. Jim, P. Thermochim. Acta. 115 [1987] 91. 111.L. Kubelkova, S. Beran, A. Malecka and V. M. Mastikhin, Zeolites 9 (1989) 12. l12.A. Corma, A. Martinez and C. Martinez, Appl. Catal. A: General 134 (1996) 169. 113. A. W. Peters, in: Catalytic Materials: Relationship Between Structure and Reactivity, eds. T. E. Whyte, et al. (Amer. Chem. Soc., Washington D. C., 1984) pp. 201-217. 114.W.L. Schuette and A. E. Schweizer, EP 0 749 781 A3, 1997.
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 134 M.L. Occelli and P. O'Conner (Editors) 9 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
41
The use of microcalorimetry and solid state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) to study the effects of post-synthesis treatments on the acidity and framework composition of several HY-type zeolites M.L. Occelli a, A. Aurou b , M. Kalwei c, A. W61kerc, and H. Eckertc
aMLO Consulting, Atlanta, GA 30328, USA blnstitut de Recherches sur la Catalyse, CNRS, 2 Av. A. Einstein, 69626 Villeurbanne, France Clnstitut fiir Physikalische Chemie, Westf~ilische Wilhelms-Universit/it Mtinster, Schlossplatz 7, D-48149 Mianster, Germany The effects of post-synthesis treatments on HY-type zeolites have been investigated by X-ray diffraction (XRD), nitrogen porosimetry, 29Si and 27A1 MAS NMR together with microcalorimetry experiments at 150 ~ with ammonia as the probe molecule. Postsynthesis treatment of NaY crystals with ammonium salts and reaction of NH4Y with ammonium fluorosilicate solutions followed by calcination, can generate silicon-enriched faujasite frameworks (LZ-210s with Si/AI=3.1 and 4.4) which, in addition to a unique distribution of T[nSi,(4-n)A1] sites, are free from extraframework Al-species. Acid site density and the number of strong acid sites (B+L) in these crystals are greater than in the reference HY ; however, the strength of the strongest acid sites in LZ-210 is lower than in LZY-82. As the framework Si/A1 molar ratio in LZ-210 increases, the 29Si spectrum becomes dominated by the T(4Si,0A1) resonance and AI(V) and AI(VI) species can now be detected in the crystals 27A1 spectra. The decreased acid site (B+L) densities in these Sienriched LZ-210s, are attributed to losses of framework SiOHA1 units while the increased strength of the strongest sites is attributed mainly to the removal of most of residual charge compensating Na-ions. IR spectra of pyridine chemisorption have shown that extraframework Al-species in a LZ-210 (Si/AI=4.4) under study, form two types of weak L-sites and that the B-sites present are stronger than in the reference HY (LZY-82). In contrast to LZ-210s, the steam-stabilized ultrastable HY (USHY) has a 29Si spectrum that resembles the one for LZY-82 and its 27A1 spectrum contains resonances representing AI(IV) as well as AI(V) and AI(VI) species; its acidity is lowest owing to a 4.4% Na20 content. Removal of most of the residual charge-compensating Na-ions and
42 steaming produces USHY-DA crystals with increased acidity and framework Si/At = 11.0 that contain only minor amounts of extraframework AI(VI)species. I. INTRODUCTION Although at the time this work was undertaken the price of crude oil was below $11/barrel and now it exceeds the $30/barrel mark, the fluid catalytic cracking technology has steadily continued to evolve to meet the new challenges facing refiners. More than 370 fluid catalytic cracking units are in use worldwide generating the capacity to produce in excess of 460 million gallons of gasoline a day (1). The lead phaseout, reformulated gasoline, together with ever stringent automotive emission standards, provide the main incentive to continue to study the properties of fluid cracking catalysts (FCCs) for gasoline production (2). Today, the demand for olefin-rich gasoline is focusing the refiner attention on new FCC compositions in which acidity can be manipulated to generate materials with a low hydrogen transfer index (3,4). To impart the desired catalytic activity to the aluminosilicate framework, several postsynthesis treatments have been proposed to modify the acidic properties of HY type zeolites (5-11), the main cracking component of all commercially used FCCs. These efforts began almost 35 years ago when researchers at Davison realized that steam-aging NH4Y crystals at mild conditions (500 ~ generates faujasite crystals with a contracted unit cell size (resulting from losses of framework AI(IV) atoms) and greatly improved thermal and hydrothermal stability (5-7). The high (-4 % Na20) residual Na content of Davison's ultrastable Y zeolite (USHY) has a deleterious effect on the crystals acid site density and strength. However, repeated ammonium ion exchange and calcination cycles can yield HY crystals with properties similar to those of USHY and containing only minor (< 0.3 wt.% Na20) amounts of alkali ion impurities (8) as, for example in UOP's LZY-82. Acid-leaching framework Al-atoms with mineral acids (9), or repeated exchange reactions with ammonium salts coupled with thermal and hydrothermal treatments, allows the generation of siliceous faujasite crystals such as those described in this paper. Alternatively, de-alumination can be achieved by exposing HY crystals to gaseous SiCI4 (10), or by reacting a suspension of NH4Y with aqueous (NI-hhSiF6 solutions (11). When using ammonium hexafluorosilicate solutions, reaction conditions and stoichiometry can be manipulated to obtain HY crystals with the desired Si/A1 ratio (11), Si atom distribution and content of extraframework Al species. High resolution electron microscopy ( H R M ) images have shown that, in FCC containing HY type crystals, the extraframework A1 generated during aging migrates from the HY framework (12,13) leaving behind mesopore-containing faujasite crystals whose acidity and catalytic properties depend (in part) on the distribution of their Al species (14,15). The physicochemical properties of modified HY type zeolites have been recently reviewed by Beyerlein and McVicker (see ref. 16 and references therein). The purpose of this paper is to report the use of 29Si and 27A1 solid state MAS NMR data, together with microcalorimetry and FTIR results from pyridine thermodesorption, in the study of the framework composition and acidic properties of several faujasite
43 crystals modified by post-synthesis chemical, thermal and hydrothermal treatments. The utility of NMR and adsorption microcalorimetry to characterize zeolites has been reviewed and discussed elsewhere (17-19) 2. EXPERIMENTAL
2.1 Materials The reference HY (UOP's LZY-82) is a sample prepared by repeatedly exchanging NaY crystals with NH4NO3 solutions; it has a bulk SiO:/A1203 molar ratio of 5.6 and contains 0.16% Na20. The three silicon enriched HY crystals (UOP's LZY-210s) have been produced instead by reacting a slurry of NH4Y crystals with ammonium hexafluorosilicate solutions (11); the LZY-210 samples have a bulk SIO2/A1203 molar ratio of 6.2, 8.8 and 12.8 respectively. Sample LZ-10 is an ammonium exchanged and hydrothermally dealuminated HY(LZ-210) with a bulk SiO2/Al203 molar ratio of 6.0. The sample of ultrastable HY crystals (USHY) from Davison has been prepared by steamaging at 732 ~ (with 100% steam at 1 atm) HY crystals containing a residual 4.4% Na20. Sample USHY-DA has been prepared by reacting USHY with an (NH4)2SO4 solution at pH-2.9. After decomposing the NH4 ions, a second steam-aging and (NH4)2SO4-exchange step reduced the % Na:O level to 0.17 from 4.4. The properties of all the samples under study can be found in Table 1. 2.2 Surface Area Analysis Nitrogen sorption isotherms obtained at liquid nitrogen temperature were collected using a volumetric technique on a Micromeritics ASAP 2010 adsorption instrument equipped with version 3.0 software. Prior to analysis, samples weighing from 0.1-0.3 g were outgassed in v a c u u m at 400 ~ for at least 16 h. The total pore volume was derived from the amount of nitrogen adsorbed at a relative pressure close to unity (P/Po = 0.995) by assuming that all the accessible pores were then filled with liquid nitrogen. Surface area measurements have been performed using the BET equation (20). 2.3 Microcalorimetry Heats of adsorption of NH3 were measured using a heat-flow microcalorimeter of the Tian-Calvet type (from Setaram) linked to a glass volumetric line. Successive doses of gas were sent onto the sample until a final equilibrium pressure of 133 Pa was obtained. The equilibrium pressure relative to each adsorbed amount was measured by means of a differential pressure gauge from Datametrics. The adsorption temperature was maintained at 150~ Primary and secondary isotherms were collected at these temperatures. All samples were dried overnight under vacuum at 400~ before calorimetric measurements were undertaken. The accuracy of the data reported is +/- 4 kJ/mol or +/- 1 kcal/mol. 2.4
298i and 298i NMR
27A! MAS NMR Spectroscopy spectra were recorded at 59.6 MHz on a modified Bruker CXP300 spectrometer. Samples were spun in cylindrical 7mm zirconia rotors at spinning speeds
44 near 4 kHz. 90 ~ pulses of 6~ts length and 30s recycle delays were used in all cases. Chemical shifts were determined relative to tetramethylsilane as an external reference; spectra were deconvoluted into Gaussian lineshape components. 27A1 MAS NMR spectra were obtained at 130.2 MHz using a Bruker Avance (DSX) 500 spectrometer. Samples were spun in cylindrical 4mm zirconia rotors at a spinning frequency of 12 kHz. The spectra were recorded with solid 45 ~ pulses of 2~ts length and relaxation delays of 1s. Resonance shifts are reported using liquid samples of 1M aqueous solutions of AI(NO3)3 as an external reference standard. Prior to measurements, all samples were dried at 400 ~ in air overnight. Because the exact spectral parameters of the AI(IV), AI(V), and AI(VI) signal components are not exactly known (due to a distribution of quadrupolar coupling parameters) no 27A1 lineshape deconvolution was attempted.
2.5 IR Analysis Infrared (IR) spectra were obtained using a Nicolet 3600 spectrometer. Two spectra were obtained from each sample before accepting the results as being representative of the zeolite sample under study. Spectra were acquired with a 2 cm~ resolution (8192 data points) and apodized using the Happ-Genzel algorithm. Self-supporting wafers (4-8 mg/cm2 in density) were prepared by pressing samples between 25 mm diameter dies for one minute at 6,000-7,000 lbs. pressure. Prior to pyridine sorption, the wafers were mounted in an optical cell and degassed by heating at 200 ~ for 2h at 10-3 torr. The pyridine-loaded wafers were then heated (in vacuum) in the 200-500 ~ temperature range. 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 3.1 29Si MAS NMR Results The 29Si MAS ~ spectra of the different HY samples under study are compared in Figure I. As expected, the 29Si spectrum of the reference HY (LZY-82), obtained from NaY (LZY-52) through NH4-exchange and calcination steps, yields a familiar peak pattern containing resonances at -I 06.9, -101.5, -95.8, -90.9, -87.6 ppm representing the different T[nSi,(4-n)Al] sites present, see Figure IA (19). The resonance near -I I0 ppm has been attributed to the presence of extraframework silica (2 I). The Si/AI ratio from this spectrum is 4.5; this value is, considerably higher than the value of 2.8 obtained from chemical analysis, Table 2. This discrepancy can be safely attributed to the presence of extraffamework Al-species which are clearly visible in the 27AI MAS spectrum shown in Figure 2A. In contrast, HY crystals prepared by reacting NH4Y with ammonium hexafluorosilicate solutions followed by calcination, produce the spectrum shown in Figure 1B, indicating a much stronger retention of framework AI and a completely different distribution of T-sites. In fact, whereas the spectrum for HY(LZY-82) is dominated by the T(4Si,0AI) resonance, the contribution to the total spectral intensity in LZ-210 with Si/AI=3.1, increases in the order: T(3Si, IA1) > T(2Si,2AI) > T(4Si,0AI)>> T(1Si,3A1); see Figure lB. As reported elsewhere (11), the hydrolysis of the fluorosilicate salt forms protons and fluoride anions that cause the dealumination of the
45 Table 1. Some physicochemical properties of HY type crystals after calcination in air at 500~ for 1Oh.; bulk Si/A1 molar ratios are from ehemi'cal analysis . . . . . . . . . HY- T)~_e_
Si/A1
ao (nm,)
LZY-82
2.8
2.4480
785
0.16
LZ-210 LZ-210 LZ-210
3.1 4.4 6.4
2.4581 2.4474 2.4377
607 625 629
2.44 1.17 0.01
LZ-10
3.0
2,4310
600
0.17
2.9 8.3
2.4530 2.4360
742 740 . . . . . .
4.41 0.17
USHY USHY-DA
SA(m2/_g)
%Na2Q
Table 2.
29Si chemical shifts (-ppm) and % relative intensity (in parenthesis) results;
some Dhvsicochemical properties of these HY-type zeolites, are described in Table 1 . . . . . . . . .
-
-
HY type
Si/A1
Tf0Si,4A~ T(1Si,3AI) T(2Si,2A1) ~
T(4Si,0AI} SiOT. NMR Chem
LZY-82
87.6 (1.5)
90.9 (4.6)
95.8 (14.1)
101.5 (37.2)
106.9 (37.6)
110.8 (5.0)
4.5
2.8
LZ-210
--
8 9.0 (3.5)
94.6 (27.9) 94,3 (11.0) 95,8 (3.4)
100.1 (50.0) 100.3 (67,8) 101.9 (22.9)
106.2 (16.3) 106.1 (19.3) 107.5 (70.7)
110.1 (2,8) 111,6 (1.9) 111.7 (3.0)
3.4
3.1
4.4
4.4
13.1
6.4
101.5 (16.9)
107.5 (76.7)
110.6 (6.4)
24.0
3.0
101.3 (37.3) 101.3 (1.9.0)
t06.2 (32.2) 106.8
111.9 (9.7) 111.1
4.2
2.9
11.0
8.3
(64.0)
(10.2) . . . . . . . . .
LZ-210 LZ-210 LZ-10 USHY USHY-DA
--
90.3 (7.6)
95,2 (13,2) 95.4 (6.8)
46
A
................
_._ _L L_..~
D i~
G o
-io
.......
-ibo ..... ~ - ~ o
Chemical
Shift
-
-ioo
[ppm]
Figure 1.29Si MAS NMR spectra of: A) HY (LZY-82) and LZ-210 with bulk Si/A1 ratio orB) 3.1, C) 4A, and D) 6.4. The spectra for LZ-10, USHY and USHY-DA are in E, F, and G respectively
47
A
B
120
80
40
0
.-40
Chemical Shift [ppm] Figure 2, ~TAlMAS NMR spectra of A) HY (LZY-82) and LZ-210 with bulk Si/Al ratio of B) 3.1, C) 4.4, and D) 6.4. The spectra for LZ-10, USHY and USHY-DA are in E, F, and G respectively. faujasite structure and the removal of some of the Al in the form of a soluble salt such as (NH4hAIFs. The rest of the AI is re-introduced, together with the Si, to occupy vacant defect sites in the dealuminated faujasite framework. As a result, the concentration of Tsites in which Si is coordinated to one or more A1 atoms increases yielding the spectrum
48 shown in Figure lB. The enhanced concentration of T(3Si, IA1) sites could be of particular importance to the cracking activity of these crystals during hydrocarbon conversion because work by Fripiat and co-workers has indicated that only T(3Si, IA1) groups are Bronsted sites strong enough to protonate ammonia and form NH4-ions (22). When the aforementioned post-synthesis treatment is modified to increase the bulk Si/AI ratio to 4.4 from 3.1 (while the %Na20 decreased to 1.17 from 2.44), the crystals produce a new 29Si spectrum indicating that contributions to the total spectral intensity by the different T[nSi,(4-n)Al] sites has changed; Figure 1C. The 27A1MAS NMR spectrum in Figure 2C contains a single resonance resulting from AI(IV) sites. Thus, as before, only framework A1 has been introduced in these faujasite crystals. It is for this reason that Si/AI values computed by NMR and chemical analysis are in good agreement, see Table 2. After repeated exchanges with NH4-ions and thermal treatments, the %Na20 in the LZ-210 sample decreased to 0.01 from 1.17 while its Si/AI ratio increased to 6.4 indicating dealumination and A1 removal from the crystals during the NH4-exchange reactions; Tables 1-2. As a result, the 29Si spectrum in Figure 1D becomes dominated by the T(4Si,0AI) resonance at -107.3 ppm and extraframework AI(V) and AI(VI) species appear in the 27A1 spectrum in Figure 2D. The large discrepancy between Si/A1 ratios from M R and chemical analysis shown in Table 2 is attributed to losses of framework A1. Results in Table 1 show that as the Si/Al molar ratios in these LZ-210 increases, the crystals exhibit the anticipated (36) unit cell contraction while their SA remains in the 600630 m2/g range. If after treatment with ammonium hexafluorosilicate solutions the silicon enriched HY crystals are steam-aged as in the LZ-10 sample, the T(4Si,0A1) resonance becomes sharper indicating increased local order, Figure 1E. In this figure, contributions of other T[nSi,(4-n)Al] sites to the 29Si spectrum are hardly noticeable indicating substantial losses of AI from the framework. The 29Si spectrum for Davison USHY in Figure 1F resembles the one in Figure 1A for LZY-82, however resonances are considerably less well resolved. The contributions to the total spectral intensity of the different T[nSi,(4-n)Al] sites, are in Table 2. The Si/A1 ratio value of 4.2 computed from the spectrum in Figure IF is higher than the 2.9 value obtained from chemical analysis. As before, this difference is attributed to the presence of extraframework M-species. In fact, the 27A1 spectrum in Figure 2F contains contributions from AI(V) and AI(VI) sites. By repeating the (NH4hSO4 exchange and calcination steps, USHY can be dealuminated to produce USHY-DA crystals with a much higher framework Si/AI ratio, see Table 2. The 29Si spectrum in Figure 1G is dominated by a single resonance representing T(4Si,0AI) sites and it closely resembles the one in Figure 1D for a siliceous LZ-210 sample. 3.2 27A1MAS NMR Results The 27A1MAS NMR spectra of the differem HY samples under study are shown and compared in Figure 2. The spectrum in Figure 2A for HY(LZY-82), has already been
49 discussed elsewhere (19,23). Surprisingly, the spectrum for LZ-210 with Si/AI = 3.1 contains a single sharp resonance near 54 ppm indicative of AI(IV) sites; see Figure 2B. Consistent with this result, the Si/A1ratio (3.4) from NMR is in excellent agreement with the value of 3.1 from chemical analysis. When the treatment with (NH4)2SiF6 solutions is modified to increase the bulk Si/A1 ratio to 4.4 from 3.1, the27Al spectrum remains practically unchanged suggesting that only framework AI has been introduced into the zeolite framework, see Figure 2C. However after reducing the %Na20 level to 0.01 from 1.17, extraframework A1 species are formed and the spectrum in Figure 2D contains a resonance near 0 ppm representing AI(VI) sites and a resonance near 54 ppm that overlaps another centered near 30 ppm attributed to AI(V) species (24) or to highly distorted AI(IV), (25). In the LZ-10 sample (Table 1), the resonance near 30 ppm becomes well defined and, together with the one near 0 ppm, increases in intensity, Figure 2E. In fact, the 27A1 spectrum of the steam-aged LZ-210 crystals shown in Figure 2E, contains resonances from AI(IV), AI(V), and AI(VI) sites. In Figure 2E, the AI(V)+AI(VI) resonances contribute more than 50% to the overall signal intensity. As a result the Si/A1 ratio from NMR is eight times larger than the one from chemical analyfis, see Table 2. Recent results obtained using the double-rotation (DOR) spinning technique (26,27) to the study of AI in zeolites, have concluded that extraframework A1 contains, in addition to AI(V) and AI(VI), some AI(IV) species. By comparing 27A1MASNMR with 27A1 CP MASNMR, it has been shown that in steam-aged HY a substantial portion of the resonance attributed to AI(IV) results from the presence of extraframework A1 (28). Since the 29Si spectrum in Figure 1E for LZ-10 is represented by a tingle resonance from T(4Si,OAI) sites, the AI(IV) resonance in the 27A1 spectrum shown in Figure 2E is attributed to the formation and retention of extraframework AI(IV) species. The spectrum for the USHY sample in Figure 2F resembles the one for HY(LZY-82) in Figure 2A; however it shows the presence of lower levels of AI(VI) species. After dealumination, the resonance attributed to AI(IV) becomes sharper and only trace amounts of residual extraframework AI(VI) contribute to the overall spectral intensity of the USHY-DA sample; see Figure 2G. Although present, the amount of extraframework A1 indicated in Figure 2G is much less than the one seen in Figure 2A for the reference HY (LZY-82). This result has been attributed to a more efficient removal of excess A1 from the faujasite micropores by the sulfate solution used during the NH4-exchange reactions. 3.3 Mierocalorimetry
Mierocalorimetry results have been reported in Tables 3-4 and in Figures 3-4. Sorption isotherms for ammonia chemisorption are shown in Figures 3A-3B respectively. Not shown are secondary sorption isotherms, that is, sorption isotherms for samples after adsorption of the probe molecule and degassing in vacuum at 150 ~ By subtracting the adsorbed volume of the secondary isotherms from the one of the primary isotherms at the same equilibrium pressure (p = 0.2 tort), it is possible to obtain V~, the volume of irreversibly chemisorbed NHs. It has been reported that this value is indicative of the total number (B+L) of strong acid sites present (29,30). The difference in NH3 sorption shown in Figure 3 does not correlate with the crystals BET surface area in Table 1. In fact the
50
NH8 uptake (wn~/g)
~1000
.~,
,
2500
,, , . ,
"u_,.,
u~,J
__,
. .......
:.
,,,.
-
L.Z-2'D-,e.I
-+-
-4-
L,Z-2D-,54
- . e - L,Z-10
A
I.Z..210";4,4
2OOO
1600 I(XX)
0
0.1
0.2.
0.8
0,4
0.8
~0
0.7
1400
B
1200 1000 8OO
0OO
0G ~
o
- ' - LZY-82 . . . . . . .
i .....
oa
: . . . . . .
I:. . . . .
eL=
+
USHY
__+ :
Jt . . . . . .
.
,
. . - i - USHY~)A. t_...
~a cx4 P (torr)
.....
s~.__.,.
o~a
_
_
,tr .
~e
.
.
.
.
.
.
c~7
Figure 3. Ammonia sorption isotherms. HY crystal properties are given in Table I. two LZ-210 samples free from extraframework AI (Si/AI=3.1-4.4, %Na20=l. 17-2.44) and with a surface area in 600-630 m2/g range, sort) almost twice as much NH3 than LZY-82 (Si/AI=2.8 and %Na20~. 16) with 785 m2/g surface area. Although the (B+L) number of strong acid sites (as detem~ed from V~ values) and acid site density (as determined from integral heats) are greater in the Si- enriched crystals, the strength of their strongest sites (L-sites) is 61-68 Ll/mol lower than the one in HY (LZY-82), Table 3. In addition, the two LZ-210 samples have a population of sites with stren~h in the 100-150 lcJ/mol
51 Table 3. Ammonia Chemisorption Data (+/-4kJ/mol) at 150 ~ and at p = 0.2 torr ; Si/A1 ratios .are from chemical analysis . . . . . . . . . . . Si initial Int. A1 Heat Heat NH3 (l,tmol/g) HY Woe kJ/mol (J/~) VT Virr 1. LZY-82
2.8
208
122
1020
680
2. LZ-210 3. LZ-210 4. LZ-210
3.1 4.4 6.4
140 147 191
220 211 94
1893 1919 799
1130 1316 525
5. LZ-10
3.0
190
35
373
188
6. USHY 7. USHY-DA
2.9 8.3
150 i 86
40 67
479 608
161 420
Table 4. Ammonia chemisorption data at 150 ~ (p = 0.2 torr). Population of sites with given strenffth is in ~tmo! NH3/g - bulk Si/AI molar ratios are from chemical analysis data HY Type
Si AI
<100
kJ/mol ~ 100-150
....... 150-200
LZY-82
2.8
280
657
72
LZ-210 LZ-210 LZ-210
3.1 4.4 6.4
341 435 241
1552 1484 433
. . . . 125
LZ-10
3.0
230
107
USHY USHY-DA
2.9 8.3
365 195
102 93 8 8
>200 11 . .
. . --
36
,
12 24 . . . .
---
that is more than twice as large as the one found in LZY-82. LZ-210 crystals with Si/A1=3.1-4.4, do not contain sites with strength greater thanl50 kJ/mol; see Tables 3-4. This moderate acidity has been attributed mainly to the greater levels of Na ions in these two samples; Tables 1-3. When the Si/AI molar ratio in LZ-210 increases to 6.4 from 4.4, initial heat values increase while, as expected, acid site density (as determined from integral heat values) decreases due to losses of framework A1, see Tables 3-4. The appearance of a population
52 Q (kJ/mol) 2oo r - - ' - ' - - - - - -
:
LZ-'210"e.1
-+"
LZ-'210-~4
-'~
LZ-'210-~4
- =
LZ-IO
A |
O 0
_
.....
9
,
,,|
~,,
LI
I(XX)
i
i
|
|
. . . . . . . .
|
RtX)O
1500
250
-
t.~'412
"-I-- 081"~
200
-11- ~ ' O A
100
B
0 0
200
400
~10
,~nmon~ ~
800
1000
(uric/q)
1200
1400
Figure 4. Differential heat of ammonia adsorption as a function of ammonia coverage. (125 ~tmol NH3/g) of sites with strength in the 150-200 kJ/mol range has been attributed to the drastic reduction (0.01%Na20) of Na levels that has occurred in this sample. The sorption isotherms for the two LZ-210 samples free from extraframework AI, overlap over the entire pressure range investigated, Figure 3A. In this figure, the decreased sorption capacity of the LZ-210 sample with Si/AI = 6.4, has been attributed to losses of framework SiOHAI sites and to the deposition of most of the extraframework A1 thus
53 generated inside the crystals micropores. Additional ammonium exchange reactions and thermal and hydrothermal treatments of LZ-210 samples can produce a siliceous (Si/Al=24) framework with a unit cell of only 2.4310 nm that contains trace amounts of Na-ions ; the SA remains high as seen for the LZ-10 sample in Table 1. The low sorption capacity of these crystals (Figure 3A), is the result of a greatly reduced acid sites density induced by severe framework AI losses. However the initial heat in LZ-10 remains high (190 kJ/mol), Table 3. Thus, the dealumination of LZ-210 type crystaIs produces siliceous faujasite frameworks containing a reduced acid site density in which the strength of the strongest acid rites is enhanced and the population of a site with a given strength depends on the concentration of residual charge compensating Na ions and on the framework Si/A1 ratio. The deleterious effects of residual Na ions on acidity are well illustrated by the different microcalorimetry results obtained with USHY (with 4.4% Na20) and USHYDA (with 0.17 % Na20) samples ; see Figure 3B and Tables 3-4. The number of rites available to NH3 ehemisorption in USHY is the lowest measured in this set of HY samples', this result has been attributed to the high level of Na present. Although undergoing severe dealumination, the number of strong acid rites in USHY-DA is more than double the one in USHY. In addition, in USHY-DA there is a large increase in Bronsted type acidity and in initial heat values ; Tables 3-4. Differential heats of ammonia adsorption as a function of coverage are shown in Figure 4. Results for the reference HY (LZY-82) have been discussed elsewhere (23). The differential heat profiles in Figure 4A reveal that, as the isomorphous substitution of AI with Si increases, acid site density and population of sites with a given strength change. In agreement with the sorption isotherms in Figure 3A, the profiles for the two LZ-210 samples with Si/AI ratio of 3.1 and 4.4 are somewhat similar, Figure 4A. When Si/AI=3.1, the LZ-210 crystals contain a small (-142 ~tmol/g) population of sites with strength near 140 kJ/mol and a larger one (-611 lamol/g) with strength near 123 kJ/mol. This large population of sites is attributed to framework Si(OH)A1 groups (30-34) which according to 29Si NMR results (22) are associated mainly with T(3Si, IAI) sites. Sites with strength below 100 kJ/mol have been attributed to interaction of NH3 with weak L-sites or with silanol groups (30-34). When the Si/A1 ratio increases to 4.4 from 3.1, the distribution of T[nSi,(4-n)A1] sites change; see Figure 1C and Table 2. As a result, a population (-388 t,tmol/g) of acid sites with strength in the 128-135 kJ/mol range and second one similar in size (-383 lamol/g) but with strength near 113 kJ/mol can be observed in Figure 4A. At a higher Si/A1 ratio of 6.4, with the exception of a small population of sites with strength near 152 kJ/mol, differential heat of ammonia ehemisorption monotonically decrease with coverage indicating that the dealuminated framework contains an heterogeneous distribution of acid site strengths. In Figure 4A, the sharp decrease in acidity exhibited by the LZ-10 sample has been assigned to drastic losses of Si(OH)AI groups from the faujasite structure during thermal and hydrothermal treatments. The differential heat profiles in Figure 4B for Davison's USHY and USHY-DA, its dealuminated counterpart, provide another example of the deleterious effects of residual charge compensating Na cations on the distribution of acid site strength in the faujasite structure. At a coverage below 250 gmol/g, the acidity of USHY is similar to the one in
54 LZ-10, then as NH3 coverage increases, a small population of sites with strength near 70 kJ/mol (not seen in LZ-10 samples), appears. After dealumination, the crystals %Na20 decreases to 0.17 from 4.41 and although the acidity of the USHY-DA crystals remain lower than in LZY-82, the two zeolites exhibit similar differential heat profiles for ammonia uptakes up to 400 ~mol/g; Figure 4B. 3.4 IR Results The infrared bands of pyridine of interest to this study are the N-H and C-H stretching frequencies as well as the C-C and the C-N stretching frequencies at 15901660 cm1 and near 1500 cm-1 (37). IR spectra showing the C-C and C-N stretching vibrations of chemisorbed pyridine on LZ-210 crystals, are shown in Figure 5. Bands near 1545 cm~ represent protonation of pyridine by Bronsted (B) sites and the presence of coordinatively bonded pyridine on Lewis (L) sites is represented by bands near 1455 cm"~ (37). The strong band near 1490 cm ~ in Figure 5 is attributed to the presence of both B and L sites (37). IR results for LZ-210 with bulk Si/AI=4.4, have been collected in Table 5. In this table, B and L acid site densities as a function of degassing temperature have been obtained by dividing the integrated absorbance in the 1563-1523 cm"1 region and in
Table 5. Pyridine chemisorption data for a Si enriched faujasite (LZ-210 with Si/AI=4.4) and reference HY (LZY-82), calcined at 500~ Oh ; LZ-210 composition is in Table 1. (* = could not be measured with accuracy) .
T(C) 200 300 400 500
LZY-82 (Si/AI=2.7) B L B/L 0.59 0.13 4.54 0.47 0.09 5.22 0.27 0.05 5.40 0.10 0.03 3.33
LZ-210 (S...i/AI=4.4) B L B/L 1.44 0.035 41.1 1.24 * -0.74 * -0.12 * --
.
the 1475-1400 cm"~ region in Figure 5, by the sample density. Pyridine desorption data given in Table 5 indicate that, in contrast to what is generally reported (38) for the reference HY(LZY-82), the exchange procedure with ammonium hexafluorosilicate solutions generates Si enriched faujasite crystals that contain mostly weak L-sites from which thermal desorption is more facile than from the B-sites present. Figure 5A show that aider degassing at 200 ~ there is a broad asymmetric band in the 1400-1475 cm"1 region that appears to be the superposition of two bands. In fact, at 300 ~ this broad and intense band disappears and is replaced by two weak bands centered near 1425 and 1452 -1 O cm respectively, Figure 5B, the low frequency band is no longer visible at 400 C, Figure 5C. Thus it appears that two different types of L- sites are present possibly the results of the different types of extraframework Al-species in the crystals' micropores. In the 200 to 400 ~ temperature range, the amount of pyridine chemisorbed on B-sites in the LZ-
55
~--~
1600
~
~.
, -,.,,
,
,
"
w-
'-
'"
"'~
J ' r -'-~'''''
--'""
'~'1
1500 1400 WAVENUMBERS (1/cm)
Figure 5. Infrared spectra of chennsorbed pyndme on a LZ-210 sample with bulk Si/AI=4.4 The sample has been degassed at 200 ~ and then exposed to pyridine and degassed at" A) 200, B) 300, C) 400 and D) 500 ~ LZ-210 spectrum in Figure 5D closely resembles the one for HY published elsewhere (38). The different acidic properties of LZ-210 type crystals should be of particular interest to researchers investigating the modification and improvement of the reactivity and selectivity properties of fluid cracking catalysts (FCCs),
56 4. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS 29Si and 27A1 MAS NMR spectra have indicated that the reaction of aqueous ammonium hexafluorosilicate solutions with NH4Y can yield HY crystals with a silicon enriched framework free from measurable non-framework A1 species in which T(3Si, IA1)/T(4Si,0A1)>I.0. Microcalorimetry results with ammonia as the probe molecule, have revealed that LZ-210 type crystals with Si/A1=3.1-4.4 have greater acid site density (as indicated by integral heat data) and contain more strong acid sites (as indicated by V~ data) than the reference HY (LZY-82); however the strength of the strongest sites is greater in LZY-82 probably because of its lower Na content. When the severity of the post-synthesis treatment increases to raise the framework Si/A1 ratio of LZ-210 type crystals to 6.4, the 29Si NMR spectrum becomes dominated by the T(4Si,0A1) resonance and AI(IV), together with AI(V) and AI(VI) species are detected by 27A1NMR. FTIR results from pyridine thermodesorption in the 200 ~ to 500 ~ temperature range, have indicated that these extraframework Al-species in LZ-210 are probably responsible for the broad and asymmetric band observed, in the 1400-1475 cmZ region, after degassing the pyridine-loaded crystals at 200 ~ This broad and intense band disappears at 300 ~ to be replaced by two much weaker bands indicating that different Lsites are present and that the strength of these L-sites is low. Replacement of A1 with Si in the faujasite framework, increases B acid site strength and acid (B+L) site density. The high (4.4% Na20) level of residual charge compensating Na ions is what quenches the acidity in USHY crystals. The :9Si NMR spectrum of these crystals resemble the one for LZY-82. After dealumination, the USHY-DA crystals obtained contain 0.17% Na20 and acidity reappears; these crystals yield a spectrum similar to the one for the Si-enriched LZ-210s with Si/Al = 6.4. In USHY-DA, only trace amounts of Al(VI) species can be detected by 27A1 NMR. Thus after repeated exchanges with (NH4)2SO4 solutions most of the Na as well as non framework Al-species are removed from the HY microporous structure indicating that the sulfate anions are more efficient than the nitrate ions (used in preparing LZY-82 type crystals) in removing non framework Al-species from the faujasite micropores.
Acknowledgements Special thanks are also due to Dr. P.S. Iyer for initial M R spectra, to Dr. P. Ritz for IR data and to Dr. A.E Schweizer (Exxon) for elemental analysis and XRD results. This work has been supported by NATO collaborative grant CRG-971497 to MLO and HE.
REFERENCES 1.Chemical and Engineering News, November 23, p.51 (1998). 2. Catalysis Looks to the Future, NRC Dept., Nat. Acad. Press, Washington, D.C. (1992) 3. U.A. Sedran, Catal. Rev.-Sci. Eng., 36, 3, p.405 (1994) 4. E. Dai, C.M .Tsang, R.H. Petty, and M.L. Occelli in "Proc. Int. Zeolite Conf. "Seoul, South Korea; Kodansha -Elsevier, vol. 105 B, p 981 (1996).
57 5. C.V. McDaniel and P.K. Maher in US Patent 3,292,192 (1966) 6. C.V. McDaniel and P.K. Maher in US Patent 3,449,070 (1969) 7. C.V. McDaniel and P.K. Maher in "Zeolite Chemistry and Catalysis", ACS Monograph 171, J.A. Rabo Ed.; Am. Chem. Sot., Ch. IV, Washington D.C. (1976) 8. D.W. Breck in Zeolite Molecular Sieves, Wiley, New York, N.Y., (1974) 9. J. Scherzer, J. Catalysis 54, 285 (1978). 10. H.K. Beyer and I. Belenykaja, Catalysis by Zeolites, B. Imeliket al., Eds.; Elsevier, Amsterdam, p.203 (1980). 11. GW. Skeels,, and D. Breck, in "Proc. 6th. Int. Zeolite Conf", D. Olson and A. Bisio Eds.; Butterworths, p.97 (1984). 12. C. Choi-Feng, J.B. Hall, B.J. Huggins, R.A. Beyerlein, J. Catal. 140, 395-405 (1993) 13. Beyeflein, R.A., Choi-Feng, C., Hall, J.B., Huggins, B.J., and Ray, G.J. "Fluid Catalytic Cracking Iii: Materials and Processes" M.L. Occelli and P. O'Connor Eds.; ACS, Washington D.C., 81 (1994) 14. R.A.Beyerlein, C. Choi-Feng, J.B. Hall, B.J. Huggins and G.J. Ray, Topics in Catalysis, 4, 27-42 (1967) 15. R.A. Beyedein, G.B. MeVicker, L.N. Yaeullo, J.J Ziemiak, J. Phys. Chem.., 92, 1967 (1988) 16. R.A. Beyerlein, G.B. MeVieker, (this volume) 17. A. Auroux, Topics in Catalysis 4, 71 (1997). 18. A. Auroux Catalyst Characterization : "'Physical techniques for solidMaterials ", Chapter 22 ; B. Imelik, and J.C. Vedrine, Eds.; Plenum press, N.Y. (1994). 19. G. Engelhardt and D. Michel, "High Resolution Solid-State NMR of Silicates and Zeo#tes", J.J. Wiley, New York, N.Y. (1987) 20. S. Brunauer, P.H. Emmett and E.J. Teller, J. Am. Chem. Soc.,60, 309 (1938). 21. M.L. Oeeelli in "Catalysts in Petroleum Refining and Petrochemical Industries" M. Absi-Halabi et al., Eds.; Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Elsevier, Amsterdarn,100, 27 (1995) 22. A.L. Blumenfeld, D. Coster, J.J. Fripiat, J. Phys. Chem. 99, 15181-15191 (1995) 23. M.L. Occelli, A. Auroux, M. Kalwei, A. WOlker, and H. Eckert, (this volume) 24. J.P. Gilson, G.C. Edwards, A.K. Peters, K. Rajagopalan, R. Wormsbecher, T.J. Roberie, M.P. Shatlock, J. Chem. Soe. Chem. Comrnun. 91(1987) 25. A. Samoson, E. Lippmaa, G. Engelhardt, D. Lohse, H.G. Jerschwitz, Chem. Phys. Lett. 134, 589 (1987) 26. A. Samoson, E. Lippmaa and A. Pines, Mol. Phys. 65, 1013 (1988). 27. G.J. Ray, and A. Samoson, Zeolites 13,410 (1993) 28. H. Hong, D. Coster, F.R. Chen, J.G. Davis and J.J. Fripiat "'New Frontier in Catalysis", L. Guczi Ed.; Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1159-1170 (1993) 29. A. Auroux "Catalyst Characterization : Physical Techniques for Solid Materials", Ch.22; B. Imelik, J.C. Vedrine, Eds., Plenum press, N.Y. (1994) 30. A. Auroux, Topics in Catalysis, Vol 4, 71-89 (1997). 31. Z.C. Shi, A. Auroux and Y. Ben Taarit, Can. J. Chem. 66, 1013 (1983) 32. A. Auroux, and Y. Ben Taarit, Therm. Aeta, 122, 63 (1987)
58 33. D. Chen, S. Sharma, N. Cardona-Martinez, J.A. Dumesic, V.A. Bell, G.D. Hodge, R.J. Madon, J. Catal. 136, 392-402 (1992) 34. N. Cardona-Martinez and J.A. Dumesic, J. Catal. 125,427 (1990) 35. M.L. Occelli, M. Kalwei, A. Wolker, H. Eckert, A. Auroux and S.A.C. Gould J. Catalysis (submitted) 36. L.A. Pine, P.J. Maher and W.A. Wachter, J. Catal. 85, 466-476 (1984) 37. E.P. Parry, J.Catalysis Vol 2, pp 371-379, (1963) 38. M.L. Occelli, A. Auroux, H. Eckert, M. Kalwei, A. W61ker and P.S. Iyer, Micro. and Meso. Materials 34, 1, 15-22 (2000).
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 134 M.L. Occelli and P. O'Conner (Editors) 9 2001 Elsevier ScienceB.V. All rights reserved
59
The effects of steam aging temperature on the properties of an H Y zeolite of the type used in F C C p r e p a r a t i o n s M.L. Occellia, A. Aurouxb, A. Petr b , M. Kalweic, A. Wolkerc, and H. Eckert c
aMLO Consulting, Atlanta, GA 30328, USA blnstitut de Recherches sur la Catalyse, CNRS, 2 Av. A. Einstein, 69626 Villeurbanne, France Clnstitut for Physikalische Chemie, Westf~ilische Wilhelms-Universit~it MOnster, Schlossplatz 7, D-48149 MOnster, Germany X-ray diffraction (XRD), N2 sorption, 29Si and 27A1 MAS NMR together with microcalorimetry experiments at 150 ~ with ammonia, have been used to investigate the effects of steam-aging temperature (at constant steam-aging time) on the properties of an HY zeolite of the type used in fluid cracking catalysts (FCCs) preparation. 27A1 MAS NMR spectra indicate that exposure for 5h to 100% steam at 760 ~ causes the anticipated removal of framework AI(IV) with the formation of AI(V) and AI(VI) species together with a contraction of the zeolitesurface area and unit cell (u.c) size. When the steaming temperature is raised to 788 and 815 ~ from 760 ~ lattice degradation increases and additional AI(IV) is removed from the lattice and converted (in part) into extraframework AI(V) and AI(VI) species; the presence of these species increases with steaming temperature. Evidence of framework dealumination during steam-aging can be easily observed also in the zeolite 29Si NMR spectra. After steam-aging at 760 ~ the HY crystals yield a 29Si NMR spectrum in which T(3Si, IAI) sites are still present. In contrast, when the steam-aging temperature is raised to 788 and 815 ~ only T(4Si,0A1) sites can be observed in the 29Si spectra suggesting that the AI(IV) detected by 27A1 MAS NMR is mostly non framework. In agreement with NMR results, microcalorimetry experiments with ammonia at 150 ~ indicate that during steam-aging the acid site density as well as the number of strong acid sites in the faujasite structure decrease drastically. However, in the temperature range investigated, the strength of the strongest acid sites remains practically unaffected by steaming.
60 I. INTRODUCTION The importance of framework composition on the activity and selectivity properties of faujasite crystals in a wide range of hydrocarbons conversion reactions has long been recognized (1-4). The specific role of framework and extraframework AI species on HY performance remains largely unexplained although the high catalytic activity of dealuminated HY crystals has been attributed to a synergistic interaction between Bronsted sites in the framework and Lewis acid sites in extraframework Al-species (5). The advent of high resolution solid state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) has allowed the almost routine tracking of AI species in solids (6-9). Specifically, 29Si NMR provides direct information on framework composition and on the Si atoms environment while 27A1NMR allows for a distinction between framework AI(IV) and extraframework AI(IV), AI(V) and Al(VI)-species (8,9). The modifications of HY type zeolites following steam aging at microactivity test (MAT) conditions are important because they mimic and explain in part, the initial decrease in cracking activity that HY-containing fluid cracking catalysts (FCCs) undergo when introduced into a fluid cracking catalyst unit (FCCU) of a typical refinery. The accelerated steam-aging procedure used by researchers in the lab reduces the surface area (SA) of a fresh FCC to values near those measured in the corresponding equilibrium FCC sample (10). Moreover, 29Si NMR spectra of steam-aged and equilibrium FCC samples are practically indistinguishable (10) and the 29Si NMR spectrum of fresh or aged FCCs can be considered a superposition of the spectra of their components (10). After aging, the 29Si NMR spectrum of a fresh FCC is reduced to one main resonance near -107 ppm representative of T[4Si,0A1] sites. In these samples, minor amounts of T[(4-n)Si,nAl] sites may also be present although these sites are not required for high cracking activity during gas oil conversion(10). Similar conclusions have been obtained from 27A1 MAS NMR spectra. However, significant differences exist between steam-aged and equilibrium FCC samples. In fact, steam-aged and equilibrium FCCs have different pore structure, initial heats of ammonia and pyridine chemisorption as well as different distribution of AI(IV), AI(V) and AI(VI) species (10). High resolution electron microscopy (HREM) images have shown that steam-aging give rise to an inhomogeneous distribution of mesopores in FCCs that occurs concomitantly with zeolite dealumination and crystallite fracture (11). Such inhomogeneities, which are more pronounced for higher temperature steam treatments, have been observed among different HY grains as well as within single grains (11). Microcalorimetry experiments with ammonia and pyridine have shown that after aging either at MAT conditions or in a FCCU, a fresh FCC undergoes severe losses in acid sited density while retaining most of the strength of its strongest Lewis acid sites. These rites, and the retention of an open micro and mesoporosity, are believed responsible for the aged equilibrium FCCs cracking activity. Heat flow microcalorimetry with pyridine as the probe molecule, has already been used to study the effects that steam-aging times have on a FCC acidity (12). Aider only 15 rain at 787 ~ (and in the presence of 100% steam at 1 atm), the FCC under study lost most of its total acidity and the main population of sites decreased with increasing steam-aging times (12). It is the purpose of
61 this paper to study the effects of steam-aging temperature (at a constant steam-aging time of 5h) on the framework composition of an HY zeolite of the type used in FCC preparations. 2. EXPERIMENTAL
2.1 Materials The reference HY (UOP LZY-82) is a sample prepared by repeatedly exchanging NaY crystals with NH4NO3 solutions followed by calcination; it has a bulk SiO2/A1203 ratio of 5.6 and contains a residual 0.16 wt.% Na20. The (as received) HY powder was pressed into a thin wafer that was then crushed to produce 80 x 150 mesh granules irregular in size and shape. Prior to steam-aging the granules were calcined in flowing air at 500 ~ Steam-aging was conducted for 5h with 100% steam at 1 atm. The temperatures used were: 760, 788 and 815 ~ The properties of the steamed HY crystals are listed in Table 1 2.2 Surface Area Analysis Nitrogen sorption isotherms obtained at liquid nitrogen temperature were collected using a volumetric technique on a Micromeritics ASAP 2010 adsorption instrument equipped with version 3.0 software. Prior to analysis, samples weighing from 0.1-0.3 g were outgassed in vacuum at 400 ~ for at least 16 h. The total pore volume (PV) was derived from the amount of nitrogen adsorbed at a relative pressure close to unity (p/Po 0.995) by assuming that all the accessible pores were then filled with liquid nitrogen. Surface area (SA) measurements were performed using the BET equation; PV and SA results are presented in Table 1. 2.3
29Si
and
27A! MAS NMR Spectroscopy
29Si NMR spectra were recorded at 59.6 MHz on a modified Bruker CXP300 spectrometer. Samples were spun in cylindrical 7mm zirconia rotors at spinning speeds near 4 kHz. 90 ~ pulses of 6~ts length and 30s recycle delays were used in all cases. Chemical shifts were determined relative to tetramethylsilane as an external reference; spectra were deconvoluted into Gaussian lineshape components. 29Si chemical shifts together with % relative intensity data are reported in Table 2. 27A1MAS NMR spectra were obtained at 130.2 MHz using a Bruker Avance (DSX) 500 spectrometer. Samples were spun in cylindrical 4mrn zirconia rotors at a spinning frequency of 12 kHz. The spectra were recorded with solid 45 ~ pulses of 2~ts length and relaxation delays of ls. Resonance shifts are reported using liquid samples of 1M aqueous solutions of AI(NO3)3 as an external reference standard. Prior to measurements, all samples were dried at 400 ~ in air overnight. Because the exact spectral parameters of the AI(IV), AI(V), and AI(VI) signal components are not exactly known (due to a distribution of quadrupolar coupling parameters) 27A1 lineshape deconvolution not was attempted.
62
2.4 Microcalorimetry Heat of adsorption of NH3 was measured using a heat-flow microcalorimeter of the Tian-Calvet type (from Setaram) linked to a glass volumetric line. Successive doses of gas were sent onto the sample until a final equilibrium pressure of 133 Pa was obtained. The equilibrium pressure relative to each adsorbed amount was measured by means of a differential pressure gauge from Datametrics. The adsorption temperature was maintained at 150~ Primary and secondary isotherms were collected at these temperatures. All samples were dried overnight under vacuum at 400 ~ before calorimetric measurements were undertaken. Microcalofimetry results have been collected in Tables 3-4. 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Nitrogen porosimetry and XRD results for the steam-aged HY crystals, are listed in Table 1. As expected, when the severity of the thermal and hydrothermal treatment increases, the u.c. size of the crystals contracts. It decreased from 2.454 nm in the calcined HY, to 2.425 nm in the HY steam-aged at 815 ~ owing to a severe dealumination of the faujasite framework (13). Dealumination causes partial lattice degradation and the surface area (SA) and pore volume (PV) of the crystals decrease as indicated in Table 1. Table 1. Some physicochemical properties of HY-type crystals (LZY-82 from UOP) after calcination in air at 500 ~ followed by steam-aging at 760, 788, and 815 ~ for 5h with 100 % steam at 1 atm ao PV Surface Area, SA (m2/_g) Sample (nm) (cc/g) Total Micro. Meso. %Na~O 1. HY 2. HY-760 3. HY-788 4. HY-815
2.454 2.431 2.426 2.425
0.27 0.23 0.22 0.17
785 668 649 493
697 580 569 428
88 88 80 65
.
0.16 --,-
3.1 zgsi MAS NMR Results The 29Si MAS and 27A1MAS NMR spectra of HY crystals (LZY-82) steam-aged for 5h in the 760 ~ to 815 ~ temperature range, are compared in Figures 1-2. As expected, the 29Si spectrum of the reference HY (LZY-82), calcined in flowing air, yields a familiar peaks pattern containing five resonances at -106.9, -101.5, -95.8, -90.9, and 87.6 ppm representing the different T[nSi,(4-n)Al] sites present, see Figure 1A (6). The Si/A1 molar ratio from this spectrum computes to 4.5 which is a value considerably higher than the value of 2.8 obtained from chemical analysis results, see Table 2. This apparent discrepancy can be safely attributed to the dealumination of the faujasite structure and formation of extraframework AI(V) and Al(VI)-species that can be easily detected in the 27A1spectrum shown in Figure 2A and elsewhere (10). In Figure 1A, the resonance near -
63
q
A
.
B
A
D I
0
'
-'
'~'
"'--
9
-50
"
'
"
"'
"i"
'
-100
"' . . . .
~'
I
-150
Chemical Shift [ppm] Figure I. 29Si MAS NMR spectra of HY (LZY-82) after: A) calcination in air at 500 ~ followed by steam aging with 100% steam at B) 760, C) 788 and D) 815 ~ 110.8 ppm is attributed to extraframework silica (14) and was not included in the computation of Si/AI ratios. After steam-aging at 760 ~ the 29Si spectrum is reduced to a dominant sharp peak near -108 ppm representing a T(4Si,0AI) resonance. Deconvolution of the entire lineshape reveals an additional resonance at -102.0 ppm presumably representing T(3Si, IAI) sites while the second one at -110.4 ppm again indicates amorphous extraframework silica resulting from crystals degradation and fracture (15). The Si/A1 ratio from this spectnan is -- 45 indicating extensive losses of
64
100
50
0
-50
-100
Chemical Shift [ppm] Figure 2. 27A1MAS NMR spectra of HY (LZY-82) after ' A) calcination in air at 500 ~ followed by steam aging with 100% steam at I arm and at B) 760, C) 788 and D) 815 ~ framework AI from the faujasite structure. In these crystals, the T(3Si, IAI) sites present are the main source of Bronsted acidity. In fact, Fripiat and coworkers have reported that a Bronsted site is a bridging OH between an AI and a Si coordinated to three other Si atoms (16). When the steam-aging temperature is increased to 788 and 815 ~ from 760 ~ the Z9Sispectrum becomes sharper and T(3Si, IAI) sites disappear. The spectrum of the steam-aged HY at 815 C was deconvoluted into a sharp line at -107.7 ppm representing T(4Si,0AI) sites together with a broad contribution centered near -108 ppm
65 Table 2. 29Si chemical shifts (-ppm) for several HY-type zeolites steam-aged at 760, 788, and 815 ~ with 100% steam at 1 atm(* approximate value since the signal near -102 ppm is very weak) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Si/A1 . Sample T(0Si,4AI)T(1Si,3A1) T(2Si,2A1) T(3Si,IA1) T(4Si,0A1) ~ NMR Chem 1.HY 2.HY-760 3.HY-788
87.6 (1.5) . . . . . . . . . . . .
4.HY-815 .
.
.
90.9 95.8 I01.5 (4.6) (14.1) (37.2) . . . . . 102.1 . . . . . (6.6) . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
106.9 (37.6) 108.0 (69.5) 108.1 (100) 107.7
110.8 (5.0) 110.4 (23.9) ......
(72)
(28)
4.5
2.8
45*
2.8 2.8
108
---
2.8
....
attributed to amorphous silica generated during crystals degradation by 100% steam.
3.2 27A1 MAS NMR Results As expected the 27Alspectrum spectrum of the calcined HY (LZY-82) contains two main resonances near 0 ppm and 64 ppm representing Al(VI) and AI(IV) species respectively. Inspection of the spectrum in Figure 2A suggests that the resonance at 64 ppm overlaps another centered near 30 ppm attributed to AI(V) species or to highly distorted AI(IV), (17). Recent results obtained using a double-rotation (DOR) spinning technique (7,8) to the study of Al in zeolites, have concluded that extraframework A1 contains, in addition to AI(V) and AI(VI), some AI(IV) species. By comparing 27A1 MASNMR with 27A1 CP MASNMR, it has been shown that in steam-aged HY a substantial portion of the resonance attributed to Al(IV) results from the presence of extraframework Al-species (9). The 27A1spectrum of the stearn-aged HY at 760 ~ contains three resonances arising from the presence of four, five and six coordinated Al-species representing the dealumination of the HY framework resulting from thermal and hydrothermal treatments, Figure 2B. In the 27Al spectra in Figures 2C-2D, it becomes apparent that as the steamaging temperature is increased, additional Al(V) and AI(VI) species are formed at the expense of framework Al(IV). In fact, the resonance near 64 ppm moves toward lower chemical shift values while its intensity monotonically decreases with temperature. For HY steamed at 788 ~ or at 815 ~ the resonance near 64 ppm is attributed mainly to extraframework AI(IV) species; see Figures 1C-1D and Figures 2C-2D. 3.3 Mieroealorimetry Although microcalorimetry cannot distinguish betwen Bronsted and Lewis acidity, it can relate site strength to the nature of the sites present (12,18-20). In zeolites, the strong sites (> 160 kJ/mol) observed at low NH3 coverage, have been attributed to Lewis
66 Table 3. Ammonia Chemisorption Data at 150 ~ (p = 0.2 torr). Si/AI molar ratios are from 29Si NMR data Sample Si In. H. ...Int.H . ID. AI V~t____ Vr___ V~____ kJ/mol __~ HY (LZY-82) HY-760 HY-788 HY-815
2.8 45 ---
1020 319 222 174
340 155 109 98
680 164 113 76
208 158 156 157
122 33 20 15
Table 4. Site population distribution (in Ixmol NH3_/g );. Si/A1 values are from NMR data, Sample Si/AI Acid Site strength in kJ/mol . <100 100-120 120-150 150-200 >200 HY(LZY-82) 2.8 306 187 470 72 11 HY-760 45 108 27 92 42 0 HY-788 -51 25 57 28 0 HY-815 -49 15 14 23 0 centers (18,19) resulting from extraframework A1 species produced during thermal and hydrothermal treatments. Sites of intermediate strength of adsorption (i.e., 130-160 kJ/mol) have been associated with Bronsted centers, resulting mainly from bridging hydroxyls. Heat of adsorption in the 100-130 kJ/mol range represents weak Lewis sites and below 100kJ/mol what observed is the interaction of the probe molecule with weak L-sites or silanol groups (12,18-20). Microcalorimetry (21,22) results have been reported in Table 3 and in Figures 3-4. In Table 3, initial heats (In. H) are in kJ/mol. Integral heats (Int. H) are in J/g. Vt, Vr and V~ are the total NH3 volume (in txmol/g) adsorbed, re-adsorbed, and irreversibly sorbed at p = 0.2 torr respectively. Chemisorption isotherms for ammonia are shown in Figures 3-4. Not shown are sorption isotherms aider NH3 adsorption and degassing in vacuum at150 ~ By subtracting the adsorbed volume of the secondary isotherms from that of the primary isotherms at the same equilibrium pressure (p = 0.2 torr), it is possible to obtain Virr, the volume of irreversibly chemisorbed sorbate. This value is believed to correlate with the presence of strong acid sites (21,22). In Table 3, initial heats have been associated with the strength of the strongest acid sites present (21,22). On the other hand, integral heats represent the total heat of adsorption evolved at p=0.2 torr and are therefore associated with the solids acid site density. The differences in NH3 sorption shown in Figure 3 and in Table 3, reflect the loss of surface area and crystallinity that the calcined HY (LZY-82) experiences after thermal and hydrothermal treatments at MAT conditions. After steaming at 760 ~ the strength of the strongest acid sites and integral heats ofNH3 chemisorption decrease b y - 50 kJ/mol and 89 J/g respectively. In addition, the number of strong acid sites, as determined by Virr values (Table 3), decreases to 164
67
1400i
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1200 1000
LZY'S2
8O0
" + - HY-]'80 HY-TU
0OO
-,0- HY-818
400 200 0
0,1
0,2
0,8 P (tort}
0.4
(15
0.6
Figure 3. Sorption isotherms for HY (LZY-82) crystals after calcmatlon m mr at 500 ~ followed by steam aging with 100% steam at 1 atm and at 760, 788 and 8 i5 ~
260
Q (kJ/mol) ....
_.
,,
,.
,
. ,
,
~,
,,
- :" LZY-82
, , . ,
~,
,,
~,
~, : _
,
,
,
.....
.,
-4-- HY-Te0
.....
,,
,.,
,
.
._
,. . . . . .
~::_~
- ' ~ HY-TU
-:
--=
. . . . . . .
:
.
~ . . . .
-.B- HY"818
[
1200
1400
200
100
0 t,
0
2O0
4OO ~nla
~X) 800 IOO0 uptak8 (llnol/o)
Figure 4. Differential heat profiles for HY (LZ-Y-82) crystals after calcination in air at 500 ~ followed by steam aging with 100% steam at 1 arm and at 760, 788 and 815 ~
68 l,tmol/g from 680 l,tmol/g in the calcined HY sample. However, when the steam-aging temperature is increased to 788 and 815 ~ from 760 ~ initial heats remain essentially unchanged while integral heats monotonically decrease probably because of losses of framework A1; see Table 3. Depletion of framework A1, following steam aging with 100% steam at 1 arm and at 760,788 and 815 ~ reduces the population of sites with a given strength in a manner shown in Table 4. The corresponding differential heats of ammonia adsorption as a function of coverage are shown in Figure 4. In addition to some strong Lewis sites with strength near 208 kJ/mol, the calcined HY contains two populations of sites, Figure 4. The larger population of sites with strength near 145 kJ/mol is attributed to framework Si(OH)AI groups (12,18-20). The smaller population of site with strength below 100 kJ/mol has been attributed to interaction of NH3 with weak L-sites or with silanol groups (12,18-20). After steam-aging at 760 ~ there is a sharp decrease in acidity that can be safely assigned to losses of Si(OH)A1 groups from the zeolite structure. In fact, the major population of sites with strength near 145 kJ/mol disappears and is replaced by a much smaller one with strength near 130 kJ/mol representing L-sites associated with extraframework Al-species. There are two smaller populations of sites with strength near 80 kJ/mol and 50 kJ/mol attributed to the presence of weak L-sites and silanol groups; see Figure 4. Steam aging at higher temperatures further decreases acid site densities leaving a faujasite structure containing a heterogeneous distribution of site strengths; the strength of these sites monotonically decreases with NH3 coverage; see Tables 3-4 and Figure 4. 4. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS The effect of steam-aging temperature on the physical properties and structural characteristics of HY (LZY-82) have been studied in detail. In general, as the steam aging temperature is increased from 760 ~ to 788 and to 815 ~ there is a progressive decrease in the crystals surface area, pore volume and unit cell size that can be safely attributed to losses of framework AI(IV) from the faujasite structure. In fact, 27A1 NMR spectra have shown that as the severity of the hydrothermal treatment increases, more AI(IV) atoms are transformed into AI(V) and AI(VI) species. In conjunction with 29Si NMR spectral data, the substantial amounts of AI(IV) sites still detected in the 27A1M R spectra suggests the presence of extraframework AI(IV) sites. In agreement with NMR results, microcalorimetry data has shown that steam-aging causes a drastic decreases in acid sites density. Interestingly, even if the number of strong acid sites (as determined from Virr values) decreases with increasing steam-aging temperature, the strength of the strongest acid sites remains practically unchanged near 156-158 kJ/mol. These sites are believed responsible for initiating cracking reactions during gas oil conversion (10). The results of the present study are of relevance for developing an understanding of the equilibration and regeneration process of zeolite-containing fluid cracking catalysts (FCCs). While accelerated aging with steam at MAT conditions cannot reduce all of the physicochemical properties to those in the corresponding equilibrium FCC sample, it produces materials with similar structural characteristics as evidenced from 29Si NMR results (10). Details of this work will be published in a forthcoming paper (10).
69
Acknowledgements
Special thanks are also due to Dr. P.S. Iyer for providing NMR data at the beginning of this research and to A.E Schweizer (Exxon) for elemental analysis and XP~ results. This work has been supported by NATO collaborative grant CRG-971497 to MLO and HE.
REFERENCES
1. R. Beaumont and D. Barthomeuf, J. Catalysis 26, 218 (1972) 2. J.W. Ward, "Zeolite Chemistry and Catalysis", J.A. Rabo Ed.; ACS Monograph No. 171, ACS, Washington D.C., 118 (1976) 3. M.L Poutsma, "Zeolite Chemistry and Catalysis", J.A. Rabo Ed.; ACS Monograph No.171, ACS, Washington D.C., 437 (1976) 4. R.A. Beyeflein, G.B. McVicker, L.N. Yacullo, J.J. Ziemiak, J. Phys. Chem., 92, 1967 (1988) 5. R.A. Beyerlein, C. Choi-Feng, J.B. Hall, B.J. Huggins and G.J. Ray, Topics in Catalysis, 4, 27-42 (1967) 6. G. Engelhardt and D. Michel, "High Resolution Solid-State NMR of Silicates and Zeolites", J.J. Wiley, New York, N.Y. (1987) 7. A. Samoson, E. Lippmaa and A. Pines Mol. Phys. 65, 1013 (1988). 8. G.J. Ray and A. Samoson, Zeolites 13, 410 (1993) 9. H. Hong, D. Coster, F.R. Chen, J.G. Davis and J.J. Fripiat "New Frontier m Catalysis", L. Guczi Ed.; Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1159-1170 (1993) 10. M.L. Occelli, M. Kalwei, A. Wolker, H. Eckert, and A. Auroux, J. Catalysis (accepted) 11. R.A. Beyerlein, C. Choi-Feng, J.B. Hall, B.J. Huggins and G.J. Ray, "Fluid Catalytic Cracking III: Materials and Processes" M.L. Occelli and P. O'Connor Eds.; ACS, Washington D.C., 81 (1994) 12D. Chen, S. Sharma, N. Cardona-Martinez, J.A Dumesic, V.A Bell, GD. Hodge, and R.J. Madon, J. Catal. 136, 392-402 (1992) 13. L.A.Pine, J. Catal. 125, 514(1990) 14. M.L. Occelli in "Catalysts m Petroleum Refining and Petrochemical Industries" M. Absi-Halabi et al., Eds.; Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 100, 27 (1995) 15. J. Scherzer, Octane-enhancing Zeo#te FCC: Scientific and Technical Aspects; Marcel-Dekker. New York, N.Y., (1990) 16. AL. Bluemenfeld, D. Coster, J.J. Fripiat, J. Phys. Chem. 99, 15181-15191 (1995) 17. J.P. Gilson, GC. Edwards, A.K Peters, K. Rajagopalan, R. Wormsbecher, T.G Roberie, and M.P. Shatlock, J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun. 91(1987) 18. A. Auroux, and Y. Ben Taarit, Therm. Acta, 122, 63 (1987) 19. Z.S. Shi, A. Auroux, and Y. Ben Taarit, Can. J. Chem. 66, 1013 (1983) 20. N. Cardona-Martinez, and J.A. Dumesic, J. Catal. 125, 427 (1990) 21. A. Auroux, "Catalyst Characterization : Physical Techniques for Solid_MateriaN', Ch.22; B. Imelik, J.C. Vedrine, Eds., Plenum press, N.Y. (1994) 22. A. Auroux, Topics in Catalysis, Vol 4, 71-89 (1997).
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 134 M.L. Occelli and P. O'Conner (Editors) 9 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
71
Effect of catalyst properties and feedstock composition on the evaluation of cracking catalysts A. A. Lappas a, Z. A. Tsagrasouli a, I. A. Vasalos a and A. Humphries b a Chemical Process Engineering Research Institute (CPERI) and Department of Chemical Engineering University of Thessaloniki, P.O. Box 361, 57001 Thermi, Thessaloniki, Greece b Akzo Nobel Catalysts, Inc., 2625 Bay Area Blvd., Suite 250, Houston, TX 77058 USA The objective of the present paper is to determine the effect of catalyst properties on the FCC product yields and to investigate the interaction between FCC catalysts and feedstocks. The work was carried out in a MAT unit using 12 new catalysts and various types of feedstocks. Main emphasis was given in the investigation of the effect of catalyst accessibility on FCC product yields. The study shows that catalyst accessibility is an important property that affects the catalyst activity and the selectivity of the FCC products.
1. INTRODUCTION Worldwide oil production has grown significantly in this decade and it is going to reach 3.5 billion tons in the first year of the millenium [ 1]. Transportation fuels are the main products from the refineries and they are going to develop further in the future. Furthermore, the new very strict requirements for transportation fuel specifications for the year 2000 and especially for the year 2005 puts the fuel market, supplied by refineries, into a new era. Refineries must increase profitability by processing more residual oil and by producing fuels of improved quality. The refinery of 2000-2005 must invest in new processes where new catalysts must be used. Among refinery processes Fluid Catalytic Cracking (FCC) plays a very important role. On the one hand FCC produces a large portion of the total gasoline and diesel and on the other hand these products contain a lot of undesirable components (sulfur, olefins, aromatics etc.). For these reasons research today emphasizes the development of a new FCC process and new FCC catalysts. The process modifications to FCC in the recent years include the conversion of the conventional FCC units to short contact time units (SCT). Currently, the revamping of many FCC units to SCT FCC means new riser termination technologies or/and improved feed nozzles or/and higher stripper efficiency [2]. FCC's in Europe employing some of the above modifications have increased to 18 by 1998 and are expected to reach 25 by the year 2002. This number is approximately one third of all FCC's in Western Europe [3]. The benefits of SCT-FCC are mainly better dry gas and coke selectivity, more conversion, more throughput and more resid in the feed [3]. However, the optimization of new SCT FCC requires new FCC catalysts [4,5,6]. The FCC catalysts are considered to be equally important to the various technological advances in FCC. Today's FCC catalysts are mixtures of functional components (zeolite, additive, binder, filler) customized to maximize FCC profitability within hardware constraints. The new SCTFCC catalysts are required to equilibrate to higher microactivities than FCC conventional
72 catalysts and are designed to have higher RE content, more zeolite content and more active matrix [6]. The new improved SCT-FCC catalysts can also play an important role in the production of reformulated fuels [7]. For these reasons the catalyst manufacturing companies design new zeolites with optimum aluminum topology, new types of zeolites and matrixes, optimum zeolite to matrix ratio and optimum matrix activity [7,8,9,10]. The target of all these modifications is the synthesis of new catalysts that give more selectivities and better stability. One catalytic feature that is especially important for the optimal performance of FCC catalysts is the accessibility of its active sites. This property has special importance as refineries process heavier FCC feeds. According to literature [9,11 ] accessibility is defined as the catalyst ability to have active sites accessible to large molecular structures which are supposed to interact with these sites within a certain time limitation set by the catalytic process. Catalysts with high accessibility maximize large molecule cracking and minimize secondary reactions such as gasoline overcracking, hydrogen transfer and coke formation. One more advantage of high accessibility is better strippability of catalyst and thus the reduction of coke yield. Nowdays refiners process a wide range of FCC feedstocks while moving toward heavier feeds. The hydrocarbon molecular types in the FCC feedstock are sometimes the most important variables in determining the basic yield structure in FCC [ 12]. For example, more resid in the feed or high aromatics in the feed affect strongly the gasoline and coke selectivity [13]. Sulfur content in the feed influences the final sulfur distribution in the FCC products [12,13]. Optimum catalyst performance can be obtained by matching specific catalyst components with selected feed characteristics [ 14]. The target of the present paper was to investigate the effect of different catalysts and feedstocks on FCC product yields and to establish the interactions between FCC catalysts/feedstocks. Twelve new Akzo Nobel catalysts with different properties and five different feedstocks were evaluated. Special emphasis was given to the effect of catalyst accessibility on the activity and selectivity using catalysts with otherwise equivalent properties but with different accessibilities. The experimental work was carried out in a MAT unit under a range of WHSV values. In the literature, different methods have been proposed for the evaluation of SCT catalysts. Although it is generally accepted that a circulating FCC pilot plant is the most suitable tool, various microscale reactors are suggested in the literature (fixed fluid beds or modified MAT units) [15,16,17,18,19]. 2. EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE
The present study was mainly performed in the MAT unit of Chemical Process Engineering Research Institute (CPERI) using a modified ASTM D 3907-80 procedure [20]. Two temperatures (T=521 and 566 ~ two catalyst residence times (tc=50, 20s) and varied C/O ratios were used for the MAT tests. For the validation of the MAT unit a comparison study of MAT results with CPERI FCC pilot plant results was also carried out. The CPERI FCC pilot plant is a continuous circulating FCC unit designed to simulate the commercial FCC performance. A full description of the CPERI FCC pilot plant is presented elsewhere [21]. Twelve new Akzo Nobel catalysts were evaluated in this study. These catalysts have a wide range of properties but all contain an active matrix. The catalysts 1,3 and 5 are low rare earth (LRE) catalysts with RE203=0.075 wt%. Catalysts 2,4 and 6 have similar Zeolite to Matrix surface areas (Z/M) to catalysts 1,3 and 5 but they have a high RE content (HRE, RE203=2.3, 4.3, 5.3 %wt for the three catalysts respectively). Catalysts 1 through 6 are low accessibility (LA) catalysts with Akzo Accessibility Index-AAI=4 while catalysts 7 through 12 have
73 similar properties (RE, Z/M) but they are high accessibility (HA) catalysts (AAI=26). Catalysts 1,2,7 and 8 have a relatively low Z/M ratio (LZ/M---0.7). Catalysts 3,4,9 and 10 have a high Z/M ratio (HTJM=2.6) while catalysts 5,6,11 and 12 a medium Z/M ratio (MTJM=I.7). Catalysts 1,2,7 and 8 have a low total surface area (LSA=160m2/g), catalysts 3,4 have a medium SA (MSA=185m2/g) while the remaining catalysts have a high SA (HSA>220m2/g). The catalyst properties are summarized below: Table 1 Catalyst properties RE Matrix Access Z/M SA
1 L L L L
2 H L L L
3 L L H M
4 H L H M
5 L L M H
6 H L M H
7 L H L L
8 H H L L
9 L H H H
10 H H H H
11 L H M H
12 H H M H
All catalysts have been deactivated at 795~ for 6 hours (100% steam, 1 atm) in Akzo Nobel laboratories using standard steaming procedures. The catalysts have zero metals loading and so all results presented in this work may differ with a resid feed. For comparison, one commercial catalyst (base catalyst) with low metals content was also used in this study. Five different types of FCC feeds were used in this work. A naphthenic feed (A) was used as standard (or base feed). Feed B is a high sulfur vacuum gas oil while feed HYD-B is the corresponding hydrotreated feed. Feed C is a highly aromatic feed and feed HYD-C is the corresponding hydrotreated feed. Some key properties of the feeds are given below: Table 2 Feedstock properties A B HYD-B C HYD-C API 18.7 20 26.8 13.1 17.3 CA* (ndm), %wt 24 22.3 10.3 49.5 26 Sulfur, %wt 2.51 2.14 0.106 0.78 0.184 *Aromatic carbon content (%0f total carbon) determined bythe method ASTM D-3238 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 3.1. Comparison of MAT and pilot plant data In order to validate the MAT unit a comparison of CPERI FCC pilot plant results and MAT results was carried out. The CPERI FCC pilot plant has been in operation for the last 5 years and its performance has been validated with much commercial data. For the comparison of MAT and FCC pilot plant, the base catalyst was evaluated in both units using all feedstocks of Table 2. For this comparison a unit product factor was used for each FCC product and feed. This factor is defined at constant conversion and gives the ratio of each product yield obtained by a feedstock in relation to the same product yield from the base feed at the same unit. For example the gasoline factors for the two units are:
Gasoline MATfactor: gasoline yield for feedj /gasoline yield for base feed Gasoline Pilot plant factor: gasoline yield for feedj /gasoline yield for basefeed These factors are presented for each one of the five feeds in the Figures 1 and 2 for the C/O ratio and the gasoline yield using a parity plot of the corresponding factor from the two units.
74
C/O factor, Catalyst: Base, T=970~
3.0
at 60%wt conversion
xA liB
2.5
J
El HYD-B O .ca O
eC
2.0
J
o HYD-C
1.5
J
,i..a O ,..-, ~
1.0
Y
0.5
0.0 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
MAT factor Fig. 1. Comparison of M A T and F C C pilot plant for C/O factor
Gasoline factor, Catalyst: Base, T=970~
1.6 xA 1.4
'
LmB
/
O HYD-B
1.2 O
eC o HYD-C
1.0
O
0.8 O ~
0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0
at 60%wt conversion
J
0.0
jf 0.2
0.4
f/ 0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
1.6
MAT factor Fig. 2. Comparison of M A T and F C C pilot plant for gasoline factor
75 Figure 1 shows that with the exception of the heavy feed (C), the C/O factors from the two units agree. Satisfactory comparison between the two units exists for the gasoline (Figure 2), the other product yields and the olefinicities factors as well (not presented in figures). Large differences exist in dry gas factors. This was expected since the fixed bed (MAT unit) is not as suitable as the riser (pilot plant) is for dry gas yields predictions. The rank of the various products produced from all feeds in the two units is identical. For example the crackability order of all feeds is the same in the two units (HYD-B>B>A>HYDC>C). Generally, it can be concluded that the evaluation of the feedstocks is similar in the two units for the majority of the FCC products. In a future paper a similar comparison study using some of the new catalysts will be presented.
3.2. Effect of catalyst accessibility on zeolite retention Based on the measurements of zeolite surface areas (by t-plot method) of fresh and steamed catalysts, we concluded that the catalyst accessibility affects the zeolite retention. By zeolite retention we mean the percentage % of zeolite surface area (ZSA) that remains after steaming in relation to ZSA of the fresh catalyst. Figure 3 presents the difference in the zeolite retention between an HA and the corresponding LA catalyst after steaming (at the same high rare earth level). After deactivation, independently of the type of catalyst (HRE or LRE, HM or LM), the HA catalysts maintain more zeolite than the corresponding LA catalysts. Figure 3 also shows that the zeolite retention depends on the ZSA of catalysts and it is higher for catalysts with higher ZSA. Thus, after deactivation, a HA catalyst with a high RE content maintains 12 % more zeolite than the LA catalyst (with similar the other properties). This result is in accordance with previous studies in Akzo Nobel [9,11 ]. In those studies, using a more realistic catalyst deactivation protocol (metals deposition in a Cyclic Deactivation Unit), it was also concluded that a high accessibility catalytic system give the best zeolite protection. The better ZSA retention at higher AAI is not yet fully understood. It is believed that for the HA catalysts there is a large number of acid sites and hydroxyl groups available which provide alternate sites for poisons to attack, therefore affording the zeolite extra protection.
=
13 11
Q
9
J
f
f
X
7
1~
1~
180
2~
2~
3~
Zeolite SA of fresh catalyst (ma/g) Fig. 3. Effect of catalyst accessibility on zeolite retention (catalysts at same HRE )
76 3.3. Effect of catalyst properties on activity The effect of catalyst properties on catalytic activity (the required C/O for achieving a constant conversion) was studied in the MAT unit under two different experimental conditions: i) T=566~ (1050~ tc=20s (SCT-MAT conditions) and ii) T=521~ (970~ tc=50s (MAT conventional conditions). For the catalyst evaluation at the SCT-MAT conditions the standard feed (feed A of Table 2) was used. The experimental data from this study are presented in Figure 4. The eight most promising catalysts obtained by these results (Figure 4) were further evaluated using 3 feedstocks (A, HYD-C, C of Table 2) in order to establish catalyst/feedstock interactions (the work with the other feeds will be presented in a future paper). In this part of the study the MAT conventional conditions were used since the very refractory feeds (feed HYD-C and especially feed C of Table 2) created operating problems in the unit when the very low run time of 20s was used. Moreover, the use of the highly refractory feed C necessitates comparing yield data at a relatively low conversion level (55%wt). The evaluation of the most promising catalysts with these 3 feeds is presented in Figure 5. Figures 4 and 5 reveal that HA catalysts are always more active than the corresponding LA catalysts. For all types of catalysts (high matrix-HM or low matrix-LM) the HRE catalysts are more active. Catalysts with more active components (Z+M) or higher Z/M ratio are also more active than catalysts with lower active content or lower Z/M. The effects of catalyst accessibility and RE content on catalyst activity are summarized in Figure 6. It seems that at the same RE content the HA catalysts require about 0.5 less C/O than the corresponding LA ones. The effect of the RE content seems to be the same for both HA and LA catalysts. Above a certain RE concentration the effect of RE on catalyst activity is not so strong (Figure 6). Comparing the catalyst ranking from Figures 4 and 5 it seems that the catalyst activity ranking does not depend on the MAT conditions used in the present study. Figure 5 shows that the ranking of catalyst activity is the same for all feeds. Independently of the aromaticity of the feed, the rank of catalyst activity is: cat. 12>cat. 10>cat. 6>cat. 8>cat. 4>cat. 2>cat. 11 >cat.5 >cat. 9 >cat. 7>cat.3>cat. 1
For all feeds, HA catalysts are always more active than the LA catalysts. However, if we examine the difference in the C/O ratio (delta C/O) between a LA and a HA catalyst (with similar the other properties) we can see that catalyst accessibility improves catalyst activity if the feed is more aromatic. This result is summarized in the Table 3. The performance of an HA catalyst in relation to the corresponding LA is much better when the feed has a higher aromatic content. Table 3 Interaction of feedstock type and catalyst accessibility On catalytic activity Delta C/O (LA-HA) Cat.5-Cat. 11 Feed type Cat.6-Cat. 12 Cat.4-cat. 10 HYD-B 0.2 Not Available-NA 0.05 B 0.4 NA 0.4 A 0.7 0.4 0.3 HYD-C 0.7 0.6 0.3 C 1.1 1.3 0.3
Cat.9-Cat.3 NA NA 1.6 1.6 2.1
77
HA
HA
LA
HA
HA
LA
LA
LA
HA
HA
LA
LA
HRE
HRE
HRE
HRE
LRE
HRE
HRE
LRE
LRE
LRE
LRE
LRE
MZ/M
H Z / M M Z / M LZ/M M Z / M H Z / M LZ/M H Z / M H Z / M LZ/M
HSA
HSA
HSA
LSA
HSA
MSA
LSA
HSA
HSA
LSA
H Z / M LZ/M MSA
LSA
Fig. 4. Effect of catalyst properties on C/O ratio
HA
HA
LA
LA
HA
LA
HA
LA
HRE
HRE
HRE
HRE
LRE
LRE
LRE
LRE
HSA
HSA
HSA
M SA
HSA
HSA
HSA
M SA
MZ/M
HZ/M
MZ/M
HZ/M
MZ/M
HZ/M
HZ/M
HZ/M
Fi~. 5. Effect of catalyst/feedstock on C/O ratio
78 The above results are consistent with those from a similar literature study [ 14]. In that work as an FCC feed increased in molecular weight a catalyst with an active matrix become much more active (changes in the ranking were not mentioned). In the present study, since all catalysts have active matrixes while all feeds have similar molecular weights, we can conclude that there is a relation between catalyst accessibility and feed aromaticity. Thus, the high accessibility catalyst activity increases the most when feeds with higher aromaticity are used. The catalyst screening presented in Figures 4 and 5 revealed that the majority of the new catalysts perform better than the base catalyst. Moreover, the new catalysts have a wide range of activities. As discussed above, the magnitude of the catalyst activity depends strongly on the properties of feed being cracked. However, for all feeds of this study catalyst 12 is the most active. Catalyst 12 has a high matrix and a high zeolite content along with high RE content and high accessibility. MAT results, Feed: A, T---970~ tc=50sec, at i5%wt conversion ....
[] LA catalysts9 HA catalysts-
[]
\
L)
3
A v
0
2
4
REzO3 of fresh catalyst (%wt) Fig. 6. Effect of catalyst accessibility and RE content on C/O ratio
3.4. Effect of catalyst/feedstock properties on FCC product selectivities
Gasoline selectivity The gasoline selectivities (gasoline yields at the same conversion) for all catalysts are presented in Figure 7. As expected, the gasoline yield from HRE catalysts (gasoline catalysts) is always higher than the corresponding LRE catalysts (octane catalysts) with similar properties. This happens for both LA or HA, HM or LM catalysts. The most important result from this study is that the HA catalysts are always more gasoline selective than the corresponding LA ones. The difference in gasoline selectivity between a LA and a HA catalyst is higher when the two catalysts are octane catalysts (LRE). Among catalysts (HRE or LRE, HA or LA) with the same matrix more gasoline selective are those with higher zeolite content (higher ZA4 ratio). The zeolite SA of a catalyst is a key parameter for increasing gasoline selectivity. The above effects are summarized in Figure 8 where it seems that for catalysts
79 with the same zeolite SA the HA and HRE catalysts give the maximum gasoline selectivity. It is noticeable from Figure 7 that all the new catalysts present higher gasoline selectivity than the base catalyst. Among all catalysts, cat. 12 has not only the maximum catalyst activity but the maximum gasoline selectivity as well. The effect of feedstock type on catalyst evaluation with respect to gasoline selectivity is presented in Figure 7. The type feedstock influences strongly the gasoline yield. For the same catalyst, the more refractory the feed, the less gasoline is produced. The highly aromatic feed C gives very low gasoline yields for all catalysts tested. The effect of FCC feed hydrotreating is obvious from Figure 7. For all types of catalysts, hydrotreating an FCC feed causes a strong increase (about 30%) in gasoline yields. From Figure 7, it is also concluded that, for the feedstocks tested, the type of feed does not influence the ranking of catalysts. Catalyst evaluation with the base feed (feed A) and the more aromatic hydrotreated-C (feed HYD-C) indicates that when a more aromatic feed is used the significance of catalyst accessibility on gasoline yield increases. However, going to the results with the very aromatic non hydrotreated feed C it seems that with this feed the catalysts present very small variations in gasoline selectivity. This means that the discrimination of catalyst with respect to gasoline selectivity is much more difficult when very heavy feeds are used. For these heavy aromatic feeds the proper choice of catalyst is more strongly governed by other refinery objectives and unit operation [20].
HA
LA
HA
LA
HA
LA
HA
LA
HRE
HRE
HRE
HRE
LRE
LRE
LRE
LRE
HSA
HSA
HSA
MSA
HSA
HSA
HSA
MSA
MZ/M
MZ/M
HZ/M
HZ/M
MZ/M
HZ/M
HZ/M
HZ/M
Fig. 7. Effect of catalyst/feedstock on gasoline selectivity
80 MAT results, Feed: HYD-C, T=970~ tc=50sec, at 55%wt conversion 40.0
_
!
39.5 ~ [] LA catalysts 9 HA catalysts 39.0
~_~..~-~
/ i
-~.
_
o~
38.5
S
38.0 37.5
o
r,r
jJ
37.0 36.5 -
36.0 35.5
j
Z
i..a
35.0 1~
160
2~
220
2~
2~
Zeolite SA of fresh catalyst (m2/g) Fig. 8. Effect of catalyst properties on gasoline selectivity
Coke and dry gas selectivity The effect of catalyst properties on coke selectivities (coke yields at a constant conversion) is given in Figure 9. The HRE catalysts are always less coke selective than the corresponding LRE ones (with similar the other properties). Hydrogen transfer reactions in HRE catalysts force the production of coke from aromatic compounds. By comparing catalysts with the same active content (Z+M), the HM catalysts give more coke. This result is valid for HRE or LRE and HA or LA catalysts. Going to the other heavier feeds it seems that the coke selectivity of each catalyst is feedstock dependent. The degree of feed aromaticity has a very strong influence on coke yields. For example, feed C produces two times more coke than the lighter feeds A and HYDC. Figure 9 shows also that by hydrotreating an aromatic FCC feedstock 50% less coke is produced (feed HYD-C vs. feed C). The role of feed aromaticity in determining the coke selectivity or the coke-to-bottoms selectivity has been recognized by other researchers [14]. By examining the results of coke yields vs. HCO yields of the various catalysts and feedstocks used in this study (not presented in figures), it seems that the catalysts tested show very small variations when the feed C is used. In contrast, the light feed HYD-C differentiates better the catalysts. According to literature [ 14] feedstock effects on coke selectivity are clarified when the catalysts used contain matrices with different activities and when paraffmic feeds are used. In our case all catalysts have active matrix and thus the differentiation of catalysts in respect to coke selectivity is better for the lighter HYD-C feed. The evaluation results for the dry gas (H2, C1 and C2's) yield (not presented in figures) concluded that the RE content of catalysts is the most important parameter that influenced the dry gas yields. Independently of Z/M ratio and the catalyst accessibility the dry gases from HRE catalysts are always lower than that from the catalysts with LRE content. Among the dry gases, the most important effect of RE content is on H2 yield. The hydrogen from a high RE catalyst is about 60-70% lower than that from a low RE one. The corresponding reduction of
81 the total dry gases is 20%. The effect of catalyst accessibility on dry gases was not clear in the present study since the differences between the catalysts in dry gas selectivity were very low (2.2-2.6%wt). The feed effects on dry gas yield were more pronounced than the catalyst effects. The hydrotreating of FCC feed minimizes the dry gas yields. The study of the effect of feedstock type on catalyst ranking, in respect to dry gases, shows that there are similarities in the evaluation data between the two lighter feeds A and HYD-C. However, it seems that the more aromatic feed HYD-C discriminate better the accessibility of the catalyst in relation to the feed A. For the HYD-C all the HA catalysts show lower dry gases in relation to the corresponding LA catalysts (with similar the other properties).
LA LRE
HA LRE
HA HRE
HA LRE
LA LRE
HA HRE
LA HRE
LA HRE
HSA HZ/M
HSA MZ/M
HSA MZ/M
HSA HZ/M
MSA HZ/M
HSA HZ/M
MSA HZ/M
HSA MZ/M
Fig. 9. Effect of catalyst/feedstock on coke yield
LPG gases selectivity In contrast to gasoline, LPG ( C 3 ' S, C 4 ' s) selectivity (not presented in figures) is higher for LRE catalysts. As expected, the C3 and Ca olefinicities from the LRE catalysts are higher than from the HRE ones. The effect of type of feedstock on the olefinicities shows that for all type of feedstocks the HRE catalysts give lower olefinicities. The accessibility property of the catalysts affects also the olefinicities. For all feedstocks the HA catalysts give higher olefinicities in relation to the LA ones. The above results are summarized in Figure 10. Figure 10 shows that by increasing the RE content of a catalyst the olefinicities decrease. However, for a constant RE content the HA catalysts give more olefins. It is clear that the high pore volume of the HA catalysts assist for less hydrogen transfer reactions. These reactions contribute to lower olefin production. The ranking of catalysts in relation to olefinicities is not feedstock dependent at least for the LRE catalysts. For the HRE catalysts the values of olefinicities are low and general results for the feedstock effects can not be concluded.
82 MAT results, Feed: A, T=970~ tc=50sec, at 55%wt conversion
0.70 0.66
l rn LA catalysts]
0.62 9
l " HA catalysts]
0.58 ._o
\
0.54 0.50
O
\
0.46 w
0.42
[]
[]
0.38 0.34 0.30 0
2
4
6
RE203 of fresh catalyst (%wt) Fig. 10. Effect of catalyst/feedstock on Cn olefins
LCO selectivity The results for LCO yield, at a constant conversion, are presented in Figure 11 for the three feeds investigated. Figure 12 summarizes the effects of two catalytic properties (accessibility and Z/M ratio) on the LCO yield for the base feed-A. This figure refers to HRE catalysts although the results are also valid for LRE ones. Among catalysts with the same Z/M ratio and RE content, the HA catalysts give higher LCO yields. This effect of accessibility is valid independently of the type of catalyst (HRE or LRE, HZ/M or LT_/M). Figure 12 illustrates also the impact of Z/M on LCO yields. Among catalysts with the same accessibility and RE content the catalysts with the lower Z/M produce higher LCO yields. The RE content of the catalysts influences also the LCO yield. For both HZ/M and LZ/M catalysts the HRE ones produce more LCO (Figure 11). The study of the effect of type of feedstock on LCO yield (Figure 11) shows that there is a strong influence of feedstock aromaticity on LCO yield. An" increase of the aromaticity results in a reduced production of LCO. A hydrotreated aromatic FCC feed (HYD-C) gives about 20% more LCO than the raw feed (feed C). The effects of catalyst properties on LCO yield, discussed above, are valid for all feedstocks. However, it seems that an interrelation exists between catalyst Z/M ratio and feed aromaticity (Table 4). It is concluded that the effect of high matrix (low Z/M) on LCO yield is more pronounced in the cases where more aromatic feeds are treated. Table 4 Interaction of feed aromaticity and catalyst Z/M ratio on LCO yield Feed type Delta LCO yield (LTJM-HZ/M catalyst) A 1.4 HYD-C 2.2 C 3.2
83
HA HRE HSA MZ/M
HA HRE HSA HZ/M
HA LRE HSA MZ/M
LA HRE HSA MZ/M
HA LRE HSA HZ/M
LA HRE M SA HZ/M
LA LRE HSA
LA LRE M SA HZ/M
HZ/M
Fig. 11. Effect of catalyst/feedstock on LCO yield MAT results, Feed: A, T=970~
22 21
I
9 HM catalysts [] L M catalysts
20 19
tc=50sec, at 5 5 % w t conversion
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
18
17
9
C)
16 15 14 13 12 4
26
AKZO Access~ility Index (AAI) of fresh catalysts Fig. 12. Effect of catalyst accessibility on LCO yield (HRE catalysts)
84
3.5. Development of short form models Using the MAT experimental data of this work, short form models were developed, based on regression analysis studies. By short form models we mean mathematical correlations which can predict FCC conversion and the main FCC product yields as a function of the experimental parameters and catalyst properties. The zeolite surface area, the matrix area, the Z/M ratio and the UCS/RE ratio are properties, which, as it was discussed previously, affect the FCC product yields. Catalyst accessibility was recognized also, in this work, as a very important property that affects the activity and selectivity. However, catalyst accessibility should be taken into account quantitatively, for the development of the short form models. For this reason, and in order to discriminate the accessibility level of each individual catalyst, an attempt was performed to correlate the accessibility with the pore size distribution (PSD) and the pore volume of the catalysts. Based on the measurements of pore size distribution (PSD) of all catalysts (not presented in figures) the differences between a HA and the corresponding LA catalyst were established. LA catalysts present a very sharp peak at about 40A. However, although 3 different types of LA catalysts (cat. 1, cat.3, and cat.5) have different pore volume they have similar PSD and thus a discrimination between them can not be carried out based only on PSD measurements. HA catalysts show a very wide peak at a pore size that seems to be depended on the type of catalysts. Cat.7, cat.8 have a maximum at 60A while the other HA catalysts have the maximum at about 100A. Cat.9 that has the maximum pore volume has the maximum peak at about 150A. Comparing the pore size distribution diagrams for all HA catalysts it was concluded that it could be possible to correlate a degree of high accessibility between them based on PSD and pore volume measurements. However, the development of this correlation needs further investigation. Akzo Nobel has developed a proprietary test by which they can measure the relative rates of mass transfer of key hydrocarbons within FCC catalysts at nonsteady state conditions. The result is known as the Akzo Accessibility Index (AAD. This index was very helpful in understanding deeper the catalyst design parameters [22]. However, for the simplicity of this study and in order to introduce the accessibility property quantitative in the short form models two common accessibility factors (ACF) were defined for all the LA and all the HA catalysts respectively. By assumption it was considered that all the LA catalysts have ACF=I. The ACF of the HA catalysts will result from the regression analysis and will give a quantitative estimation of the effects of accessibility on FCC products. For the determination of the short form models, regression analysis studies were performed and suitable software was developed based on the Levenberg-Marquard algorithm. It is clear that this analysis depends on the choice of the function, which will be used. In this study many different mathematical functions were applied but linear functions were finally selected since they were adequate and simpler than the non-linear models. For the determination of the parameters only the statistically significant variables were considered while for the selection of the best model the F-test was applied at 95% confidence level. In the following the finally selected functions are given for the conversion and gasoline: Conversion (%wt)/(l OO-conversion %wt) = 0.00225 *SAz +O.OO448*SAm+O. 03399*100*RE/USC] *WHSV ~ *(C/O)~ , A CF= 1.09 Gasoline yield (%wt)= [119.562 +1. 703*100*REMJSC+ l.207*ZZM] *WHSV ~ A CF=1.055 It was found that the high accessibility catalysts are always more active than the LA catalysts and have an ACF=I.09. In addition the HA catalysts give higher gasoline yield than
85 ACF=l.055. The validation of the above correlations is generally difficult since there are not available data in literature. However, in the reference [ 11 ] two catalysts, a LA and a HA (with same other properties) are compared. From this comparison the above-defined ACF is estimated as 1.098 which is very close to that suggested in the present study. 4. CONCLUSIONS Twelve new SCT-FCC Akzo Nobel catalysts were evaluated in the present study using a MAT unit. The MAT unit was validated by comparing its results with FCC pilot plant results. The objective of the work was to establish catalyst/feedstock interactions on FCC product yields. It was concluded that catalyst accessibility is a key catalytic property affecting catalyst activity and FCC product selectivities. Under the same MAT operating conditions a high accessibility (HA) catalyst gives 1.09 times more conversion than a LA catalyst one. For similar RE content and Z/M ratio, the HA catalysts are always more gasoline selective than the LA ones. The difference in gasoline selectivity between a LA and a HA catalyst is higher when the two catalysts are low RE catalysts. The LCO selectivity is also influenced by catalyst accessibility. Independently of the type of catalyst (HRE or LRE, HZ/M or LZ/M) HA catalysts give higher LCO yields. Another effect of catalyst accessibility was found on the C3 and Ca olefinicities. At the same RE content, the HA catalysts give higher olefinicities than the LA ones. The rare earth content and the Z/M ratio are two other significant catalytic properties. Among catalysts with similar properties the high RE ones are more active and more gasoline and LCO selective than the LRE catalysts. The rare earth content affects also the dry gases and especially the hydrogen selectivities. A HRE catalyst gives considerably less hydrogen than a LRE one. The catalyst Z/M ratio has a significant impact on LCO yields. Among catalysts with the same accessibility and RE content the catalysts with the lower Z/M produce higher LCO yields. The catalyst evaluation was also performed with a variety of different feedstocks. The type of feedstock has a strong influence on catalyst activity and product selectivity. Generally the more aromatic feed has a lower crackability and gives less gasoline and more coke. However, the catalyst ranking in respect to activity and gasoline selectivity seems to be independent of type of feedstock. The effect of catalyst accessibility on catalyst activity is found to be more pronounced when more aromatic feeds are used. AKNOWLEGMENTS The authors express their appreciation to Dr. G.A. Huff of BP-Amoco for providing samples of the standard catalyst and the three feedstocks.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4.
Courty, P.R., Chauvel, A., Catalysis Today, 29, 9, 3 (1996). Upson, L., AIChE Spring Meeting, N. Orleans (1998). Refining catalyst News, Grace Davison refining Catalyst Europe, Issue No.2, April 1998. Hemler, C.L., Sexton, J.A., Schnaith, M.W., Sexson, P.A., Bartholic, D. AIChE Spring Meeting N. Orleans (1998). 5. Hunt, D.A., AIChE Spring Meeting, Houston (1999).
86 6. Humphries, A., Skocpol R.C., Smit, C.P., O'Connor, P.O, Akzo Nobel Catalysts Symposium, The Netherlands (1998). 7. Humphries A., Yanik, S.J., Gerritsen, L.A., P. O'Connor, P., Desai, P;.H., Hydrocarbon Processing, April (1991). 8. Diddans, P., Nee, J., Paloumbis, S., Grace Davison Europe FCC Technology Conference, Heidelberg (1996). 9. O'Connor, P., Veflaan, J.P.J., Yanik, S.J., Catalysis Today, 43, 305-313 (1998). 10. Haave, H., Diddams, P.A., Grace Davison Europe FCC Tech. Conference, Lisbon (1998). 11. O'Connor, P., Humphries, A.P., 206 th ACS Meeting, Chicago, IL, August 22-27 (1993). 12. Fisher, I.P., Applied catalysis, 65, 189-210 (1990). 13. Lappas, A.A., Iatridis, D.K., Vasalos, I.A., Catalysis Today, 50, 73-85 (1999). 14. Harding R.H., Zhao, X.Deady J., NPRA Annual Meeting, San Antonio (1997). 15. Pimenta, R., Quinones, A.R., Imhof, P., Akzo Nobel catalysts Symposium, The Netherlands (1998). 16. Pearce, J., Keyworth, D., Humphries A., Quinones A., AIChE Spring Meeting, N. Orleans (1998). 17. Wallenstein, D., Harding, R.H., Witzer, J., Zhao, X., Appl. Cat. A: Gen., 167, 141 (1998). 18. McLean J.B, Andrews, R.W. AIChE Spring Meeting, N. Orleans, March 10 (1998). 19. Stockwell, D.M., Wieland, W.S., Himpsl, F.L., AIChE Spring Meeting (1998). 20. Lappas, A.A., Patiaka, D.T., Dimitriadis, B.D., Vasalos, I.A., Applied Catalysis, A:General, 152, 7-26 (1997). 21. Vasalos, I.A., Lappas, A.A., Iatridis, D.K., Voutetakis, S.S., 5th International Conference on Circulating Fluidized Beds Beijing China 28-31 May (1996). 22. Hodgson, M.C.J., Looi, C.K., Yanik, S.J., Akzo Nobel catalysts Symposium, The Netherlands (1998).
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 134 M.L. Occelli and P. O'Conner (Editors) 9 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
87
Study on the deactivation-aging patterns of fluid cracking catalysts in industrial units F. Hern~mdez-Beltran, E. L6pez-Salinas, R. Garcfa-de-Le6n, E. Mogica-Martinez, J. C. Moreno-Mayorga and R. Gonz~tlez-Serrano Programa de Investigaci6n en Tratamiento de Crudo Maya, Instituto Mexicano del Petr61eo, Eje Central Ldzaro Cdrdenas 152, C.P. 07730, M~xico, D.F., M~xico e-mail"
[email protected]; Density graded fractions obtained from three equilibrium catalysts were studied. The zeolite (REUSY) in such catalysts was the same thus allowing the study of their deactivation and aging under different conditions. The deactivation pattern of these catalysts could be depicted by correlating the loss of aluminium (unit cell size shrinkage) of the zeolite with the surface area loss. This correlation has the advantage of being independent of the time on stream or other operating variables (e.g. the Ni content in the feed or the fresh catalyst makeup rate) in the unit and gives good directional influence of the particular operating conditions in a FCCU upon catalyst aging and deactivation. The zeolite framework collapse and zeolite dealumination were considered from the mechanistic and the kinetic point of view and discussed in terms of V poisoning and of the influence of operating conditions in the FCCU. Properties of laboratory deactivated samples were systematically compared.
1. INTRODUCTION Deactivation and aging are important phenomena observed in fluid cracking catalysts during their industrial usage. Due to the importance of these phenomena catalyst, laboratory-testing methods incorporate deactivation and aging protocols to get a more accurate assessment of the catalytic properties and to the potential benefits of catalysts. Laboratory deactivation protocols have been mainly developed by taking the properties of equilibrium catalysts (Ecat) as a reference. An Ecat is actually a complex blend of catalyst particles at different stages of deactivation or of different ages. This blend is produced as a consequence of the periodic addition of fresh catalyst to the catalyst inventory to maintain conversion level. The changes of catalyst properties while aging mainly concern loss in activity, decrease in pore volume and increase in metal levels. Although the laboratory deactivation protocols currently reported in the literature may emulate the average properties of the catalyst at equilibrium, the effects of aging are more difficult to reproduce. This can be explained since the active
88 components (zeolite and matrix) as well as the contaminant metals in the catalyst, age at different rates and following different mechanisms. To better approach the properties of an Ecat it has been recommended to simulate the "age distribution" profile by producing composite samples from samples deactivated at different severities [1,2]. McLean et al. [1] showed that 10% fresh catalyst added to steamed catalysts simulated in a very accurate manner the catalytic properties of an Ecat. The method mentioned previously might fit well for low metals catalyst deactivation. However, metals poisoning simulation is more complicated. It demands features addressing metals profile, metal-catalyst interactions and metals age distribution [3]. The cyclic deactivation methods [3,4] focus on all those features that in many instances are strongly related to the FCCU operating conditions (i.e. metal content in the feed, regeneration temperature and regeneration mode, etc.). Moreover, there is a strong perception that each industrial unit will deactivate the same catalyst in a very different way. Boock et al. [5] focused on the effects that contaminant metals produce in full combustion and partial combustion operations while developing the Cyclic Propylene Steaming (CPS) method. In spite of the advances reported, one of the main questions still remaining concerns the reliability of properties exhibited by artificially deactivated-aged catalysts in representing the properties of the Ecats. These properties can vary in a large extent according to the varying operating conditions found in the units. Therefore, leaming more about deactivation and aging of catalysts directly from industrial units is wise. The analysis of the chemical and physical properties of Ecats can provide rough information related to the performance of the catalyst but hardly give details about the deactivation and aging processes. A more detailed picture can be drawn by collecting information of the properties of Ecats at different stages of deactivation by grading catalyst particles according to differences in density [6,7]. Palmer and Cornelius [6] determined the age of density graded fractions of resid Ecats in a pilot plant according to their Ni content assuming that Ni is deposited quantitatively on the catalyst. Calculations were based on the Ni content in the feed, the feed rate and the catalyst inventory. Compared to a pilot plant operation, the Ni content in the feed and the feed rate to the unit are hardly constant. Therefore, this impacts the accuracy of data that are used to estimate the age of an Ecat and its fractions from their Ni content. The aims of this work were to identify patterns of deactivation and aging in a REUSY catalyst used in industrial units and to determine how such patterns change with operating conditions. Moreover, we have tried to develop a method to acquire information from Ecats that avoids inaccuracy in estimating the age of Ecat fractions from the Ni content. Catalysts deactivation and aging were tracked by simply correlating the relative change of zeolite dealumination and zeolite surface area losses. This correlation has the advantage of comparing catalyst properties on a time independent scale. In order to compare the effects produced by laboratory deactivation protocols we have also studied samples deactivated by steaming, CPS and a modified cyclic method.
89 Understanding deactivation and aging in industrial units and their relationship to operating conditions will help in designing more effective laboratory deactivation protocols for a better assessment of the catalytic properties of fluid cracking catalysts in view of their industrial application.
2. EXPERIMENTAL 2.1 Catalysts Three Ecat samples were obtained from either full (Kellogg Orthoflow-F) or partial combustion (Kellogg Ultra-Orthoflow) units. Table 1 gives the main properties of those samples and the fresh catalysts samples. The full combustion unit operated comparatively at higher regenerator temperature (RegT). Table 1. Properties of the fresh and equilibrium catalysts and data of operating variables from the FCC units. Catalyst 1 Fresh
Catalyst 2 PC1
Surface Area (m2/g)
FC1
Fresh
PC2
.
Zeolite
176
119
123
167
106
Matrix
83
41
39
60
43
Ni (ppm)
n.a.
611
344
n.a.
212
V (ppm)
n.a.
2505
1497
n.a.
991
Fe (ppm)
n.a.
4600
5400
n.a.
3714
Na (%)
0.28
0.19
0.26
0.27
0.23
MAT second order rate constant, K* UCS (nm)
9.4
2.01
1.89
8.1
2.03
2.4580
2.4245
2.4270
2.4510
2.4268
Combustion
--
Partial
Full
Partial
Catalyst inventory (ton)
"-
180
260
180
Daily fresh catalyst makeup (%inventory)*
__
1.5
1.8
1.7
Ni content in feed (ppm)* Feed rate (BPD)*
__
0.23
0.21
0.054
""
36,100
34,900
38,000
Regenerator -686 708 temperature (~ *defined in section 2.5; ** refers to an average of 3-4 months
665
90 The catalysts studied (coded 1 and 2) contained a partially rare earths exchanged ultrastable Y zeolite (REUSY). The rare earths oxide (REO) content was 1.7 wt% and 1.0 wt%, respectively, for catalysts 1 and 2. The type of matrix (silica-sol plus kaolin clay) and the alumina content (33 wt%) were essentially the same in both catalysts. The zeolite to matrix ratio (Z/M) was 2.1 and 2.8, respectively, for fresh catalysts 1 and 2. Catalysts underwent equilibration to very similar surface area and catalytic activity (MAT second order rate constant, K). PC1 showed a lower unit cell size value. The vanadium content on the Ecats ranged from ca. 1200 ppmw to 2500 ppmw. The Ni and Na contents were comparatively lower. Table 2. Properties of density graded fractions of Ecats (catalysts 1 and 2) obtained from partial combustion (PC) and full combustion (FC) units. Sample
wt%
Ni days
Metals (ppmw) Ni V
ZSA (m2g1)
K (MAT)* UCS (nm)
PC1 A B C D
19 29 28 24
130 85 60 31
950 625 437 229
3372 2875 2212 1612
53 120 140 152
1.03 1.89 2.28 2.53
2.4220 2.4238 2.4245 2.4275
FC1 A B C D E
20 24 21 18 17
143 80 59 50 38
657 368 269 230 175
2372 1595 1235 1060 880
42 128 149 154 161
0.84 1.99 2.51 2.38 2.76
2.4243 2.4257 2.4269 2.4277 2.4286
PC2 A B C D
34 27 28 11
173 97 82 33
313 175 148 59
1523 920 775 303
80 130 138 146
1.36 2.32 2.34 2.65
2.4240 2.4259 2.4282 2.4301
*see section 2.5
2.2 Density graded fractions
The samples of Ecats were separated into four to five density graded fractions by means of a modified sink-float method [7] using mixtures of acetone/methyl-diiodide. The starting mixture was adjusted to 1 g/cm 3 density. Step-wise additions of acetone produced mixtures 0.95, 0.91, 0.86 and 0.81 g/cm 3. The floating portion of the catalysts was separated in each operation after centrifugation. The samples recovered from each operation were coded from A to E from the most dense to the
91 less dense. Table 2 shows the main properties of the fractions obtained. The age of fractions was calculated and reported in terms of the "Ni days" [6] that is calculated from the averages of the feed Ni content, the feed rate and the catalyst inventory. PC1 exhibited the highest Ni deposition rate (7.33 ppm/day), followed by FC2 (4.75 ppm/day). It was much lower for PC2 (1.81 ppm/day). The progressive age of fractions matched with the progressive decrease in ZSA and the increase in metals content. The pore volume varied from 0.17 g/cm 3 to 0.21 g/cm 3 for the most aged fractions. It was observed that the matrix surface area was essentially constant at 35-45 m2/g, the lowest values occurred for the most aged fractions.
2.3 Laboratory deactivated samples
In order to compare the effect of lab deactivation protocols samples of fresh catalyst 1 were steamed (sample coded STM) under 100% steam at 788~ for 4 h or deactivated by cyclic deactivation (sample coded CD) according to a method reported elsewhere [8]. This sample contained 680 ppmw Ni and 2930 ppmw V. A sample deactivated by the Cyclic Propylene Steaming (CPS) method was kindly provided by Grace Davison (W.R. Grace Research Center, Columbia, MD) and contained 1030 ppmw Ni and 2160 ppmw V.
2.4 Characterization techniques
The chemical composition of catalysts and fractions was determined by atomic absorption and inductive coupled plasma analysis. The V and Ni content in fractions were used to calculate a vanadium mobility index according to a reported method [7]. Solids were characterized by X-Ray diffraction (Siemens D-500) using ASTMD3942- 85 to calculate the unit cell size (UCS) of the zeolite. Total surface area and zeolite surface area (ZSA) were calculated from nitrogen adsorption (Micromeritics ASAP-2405) data according to ASTM-D3663 and ASTM-4222 methods involving the t-plot method and the Harkins-Jura equation [9]. This approach is currently used for determining the ZSA in fluid cracking catalysts. ZSA was taken as criteria of crystallinity of the zeolite whereas the UCS was related to the zeolite framework aluminium according to the following equation [10a]: A! atoms per UC= 115.2 (UCS-24.191 )
(i)
where UCS = unit cell size (A). Samples CPS, CD and fraction A of Ecat PC1 were studied by Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (EPR). A sample of USY zeolite ion-exchanged (V acetate solution) with ca. 3000 ppmw V was used as a reference. EPR Spectra were recorded at room temperature in a Bruker X-Band equipment at a frequency of 106 Hz. Samples were previously calcined under dry air at 923 K for 2 h.
2. 5 Microactivity test (MAT)
The catalytic activity and product selectivity of Ecats and their density graded fractions were studied in a fixed bed AUTOMAT unit from Xytel using 4 g of calcined (550~ for 2 h) catalyst at C/O=5, 520~ WHSV=16 h1 and 45 sec for feed injection. The feed used was a mixture of atmospheric and vacuum gas oils with
92 properties of 23.35~ 0.51%CCR, 11.9 KUOP, 81~ aniline point, 2.0% S and 896ppmw basic nitrogen. The catalytic activity was expressed in terms of a second order rate constant [K = conversion/(100-conversion) ]. The reaction products were analyzed by Gas Chromatography using two Hewlett Packard (HP) 7960's configured respectively for Refining Gas Analysis and Simulated Distillation according to HP applications. 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 3.1. General features Figure 1 stresses the importance of the relative contribution of the most aged fractions to the calculated average activity of the Ecats' fractions. The cumulative MAT activity in Figure 1 is defined as the percentage of the overall activity of the Ecat that the mixture of catalyst fractions would show. More than 50% of the catalytic activity is provided by fractions possessing more that the half-age of the Ecat. The shape of curves in Figure 1 could be attributed to deviations with respect to average values of by the Ni deposition rate. Deviations are produced by either the feed rate or the feed nickel content variations during the period of time considered. Comparatively PC1 showed a less variable Ni deposition rate while FC1 and PC2 showed somewhat higher nickel deposition rates with respect to average in the front end period thus overestimating the Ni age.
o~" 1 0 0
,A
,t,,
m
._z, ._ 80
~ .__
40
-5 E
20
0
I
0
0
50
100
150
200
Ni age (days) Figure 1. Cumulative MAT activity of fractions from catalysts ( . ) PC1, (B)FC1 and (A) PC2 as a function of their nickel age. The high Ni deposition rate average on PC1 includes a high vanadium deposition rate as observed in Figure 2. Deviations of plots from linearity are essentially related to the V migration phenomena. Figure 2 allowed us to classify the three units. PC1 is a medium to high metal -low temperature operation, whereas FC1 is a medium
93 metal -high temperature operation and PC2 is a low metals -low temperature operation. The MAT activity expressed as the second order rate constant K of the Ecats fractions shows a strong dependence on the zeolite content. (Figure 3a). The correlation using the values of total surface area (Figure 3b) was comparatively poorer thus indicating a greater influence of the matrix component especially for the younger fractions. On the other hand, the laboratory deactivation methods closely reproduced this property as shown by the data from samples STM, CPS and CD. 4000 E 3000 c 2000 C O O
>
1000
0
50
100
150
200
Ni age (days) Figure 2. V content on fractions with respect to their Ni age, ( . ) PC1 (B)FC1 (A) PC2 3.2 Deactivation kinetics. For practical purposes the deactivation rate constant of a catalyst in a FCCU can be estimated from the inverse of the fractional fresh catalyst makeup (T, in days), the MAT activity (A) of the Ecat and the MAT activity (Ao) of the fresh catalyst [11,12] according to the equation"
A = Ao / (kd T +1)
(2)
where A and Ao are expressed as the second order rate constant, K. These numbers are reported in Table 1. The calculated deactivation rate constant kd was 0.055, 0.073 and 0.049 days 1 for PC1, FC1 and PC2 respectively. Therefore, deactivation was faster for FC1 compared to PC1, while PC2 deactivates at a very slow rate. The deactivation trend of fractions can also be observed in Figure 4. The ZSAK number is based on the concept by Mott [13] who calculated a SAK number from the ratio of the total surface area divided by the second order rate constant, K. This number is inversely proportional to the specific activity of the catalyst and thus can
94 be used to differentiate catalysts and deactivation related to aging from discrete events occurring in the unit (metal poisoning, hydrothermal shocks). In this work, the ZSAK number only considered the zeolite surface area as this parameter seems to be closer related to the catalytic activity compared to the total surface area.. Clearly the ZSAK number in Figure 4 tends to a constant with only a slight decrease for the oldest particles for PC1 and FCI. The apparent increase in activity in those fractions can be explained by an increase in the coke yield (see section 3.7) resulting from their higher metal content.
3.5
3.02.5 K
2.0 1.5-
A
1.0
II
0.5 ]
2OO
100
30
ZSA(m2/g) 3.5 3.0
II
2.5
K
2.0 1.5
A
1.0
II
0.5 I
0
100
i
200
300
TSA(m2/g) Figure 3. MAT second order rate constant (K) with respect to the a) zeolite surface area (ZSA) and b) total surface area (TSA) in fractions from ( . ) PC1 (II)FC1 (A) PC2 and samples (+) STM ([]) CPS and (X) CD.
95 70 60
J
5O ~" 40 < o~ N 30 20
i i
10 0
0
r
i
i
50
100
150
200
Ni age (days) Figure 4. ZSAK number for fractions of catalyst (~) PC1 (m)FC1 and (A) PC2. An approach for calculating an apparent deactivation constant according to the exponential equation relating the MAT activity expressed as K (A') and the Ni age expressed in days" r= A' exp (-k t)
(3)
1.2
-
~
0.8
9
0.4 0.0
-
-0.4
I
0
50
I
I
100
150
200
Ni age (days) Figure 5. Ln function of the second order MAT constant K with respect to the Ni age of fractions expressed in days, (~) PC1 (n)FC1 and (A) PC2. Plots shown in Figure 5 as a function of the Ni age had regression coefficients of 0.92-0.98 with slopes being the deactivation rate constants. The values of 0.009, 0.012 and 0.005 days1 for PC1, FC1 and PC2 respectively were calculated. This confirmed the trends previously observed by using the fresh catalyst makeup calculation. However, differences in the absolute values of the constants obtained by the two methods were observed. This could be mostly ascribed to the fact that the
96 fresh catalyst MAT activity used in the makeup rate approach, is comparatively very high thus producing higher values of the apparent deactivation rate constant.
3.3 Aging kinetics It is well known that catalyst deactivation by aging in FCC units occurs mainly by dealumination and crystallinity loss of the zeolite component. The effect of aging is shown by lower surface areas and UC values. As a general rule high RegT, high steam or oxygen partial pressures and high vanadium contents increase dealumination and ZSA losses. Using a method already published [6] we studied the UCS and the ZSA of the Ecat fractions as a function of their Ni age in days. The linear regression of plots in Figures 6 a) and 6 b) allowed calculation of apparent rate constants (KZSA and KDA) related to ZSA losses and zeolite dealumination. The numbers obtained (Table 3) from the linear regression analysis indicate that the zeolite structure collapses at a similar rate in FC1 and PC1. The zeolite appears to be less destroyed in PC2. This can be ascribed to a combined effect produced by the lower RegT and the lower metal deposition rate in PC2 compared to PC1 and FCI. Table 3 indicates that the UC shrinkage is faster in PC1 and much slower in FC1 and PC2. In this case it seems that the zeolite dealumination rate is more sensitive to a high rate of metals deposition than to a high RegT. The values for KZSAand KDA for FC1 indicate that the relative high RegT in the full combustion unit accelerated the ZSA loss but had no major impact upon zeolite dealumination. The high dealumination rate and ZSA loss rate constants in PC1 could be ascribed to its relative high vanadium content. It is important to outline that KZSA is in close agreement with the apparent deactivation rate constant (Figure 5) leading us to conclude that the ZSA is the main parameter related to the catalytic activity. Using the same calculation basis, KDA for the REUSY zeolite studied in this work was one order of magnitude lower than the values calculated for CREY or REY zeolites reported elsewhere [6]. However, the vanadium contents in Ecats were very high (ca..1 wt%) in these cases. _
O E~ <5
O3 N r .J
o
",,~,
4
v
c_J
0
100 Ni age (days)
200
Or 0
100 Ni age (days)
200
Figure 6. Rate of a) ZSA losses and b) Aluminium atoms per unit cell losses for catalysts (~) PC1, (m) FC1 and (A) PC2.
97 Table 3. Regression constants calculated from the plots in Figure 6 from the equations ZSA = AZSA exp (- K ZSA t) and N AI atoms/UC = ADA exp (-K DA t) where t is the Ni age (days). Catalyst
ZSA loss AzsA K
PC1 FC1 PC2 CREY* REY*
246 290 185 -. . -. .
ZSA
0.011 0.013 0.005 . . . .
(days 1)
. .
R2 0.88 0.95 0.89
Dealumination ADA K DA (days "1)
R2
12.7 12.2 15.2 62.3 31.4
0.98 0.89 0.96 n.r. n.r.
0.012 0.006 0.007 0.062 0.068
* Reference [6] n.r.= not reported The numbers in table 3 show that the ZSA at zero Ni days (AZSA) values are overestimated while the AI/UC (ADA) values are underestimated compared to those corresponding for the fresh catalysts. This can be explained by the fact that the data used for the regression analysis are restricted to the branch of the deactivationaging pattern (see section 3.4) where the rate of ZSA loss is accelerated and the zeolite dealumination rate is hindered. In order to get more information it would be necessary to study catalyst fractions corresponding to earlier stages of deactivation. Nevertheless, our results lead us to conclude that the UC shrinkage in REUSY zeolite is the most rapid process (compared to ZSA loss) occurring during the first cycles the catalyst spends in the unit. Therefore, we propose that ADA represents the AI atoms per UC for the initial stabilization of the zeolite UCS during the very first operating cycles the catalyst spend in the unit. It should be expected that ADA is affected by the operating variables. We ascribe the lower ADA numbers obtained with PC1 and FC1 to the relative high RegT compared to PC2.
3.4 Deactivation and aging patterns
Zeolite stabilization under thermal and hydrothermal conditions like those prevailing in a regenerator of a FCCU occurs by a complex mechanism involving crystallinity losses and zeolite dealumination. Both share an initial step that involves aluminium expulsion from the zeolite lattice as illustrated in Scheme 1. This step produces structure vacancies and extraframework alumina (EFAL). Zeolite dealumination occurs in a second step by a mechanism involving silicon insertion to the vacancies left by the aluminium expelled from the framework [10b,14,15]. The silicon, which is transported as Si(OH)4 at elevated temperatures under water vapor atmosphere, is probably produced by zeolite decomposition [10b,15]. Silicon insertion and crystallinity losses are consistent with UC shrinkage and ZSA decreases, respectively. From Scheme 1 it becomes evident that the ZSA loss and the UCS shrinkage are interrelated processes. It should be expected that the rate constants K1 and K2 depend on a number of parameters, whereas K3 would depend to a large extent on the Si(OH)4 partial pressure in the regenerator. Therefore the ratio of K1 or K2 to K3
98 would vary mainly because of K1 or K2 variations and would explain the relative stability of the zeolite. This means also that the same catalyst will probably respond in a different way to the operating conditions in the unit. It follows that ZSA losses (or crystallinity losses) would be accelerated over zeolite dealumination (UCS shrinkage) under full combustion modes, higher temperatures and high V contents Since the UC shrinkage and ZSA loss are close related processes, it was interesting to study them togehther according to the operating conditions and the catalyst properties. Plots in Figure 7 indicate that the REUSY catalysts initially underwent a very fast dealumination process with respect to the ZSA loss. The pattern showed a marked ZSA loss below 10 AI/UC. From that point on, a striking difference among catalysts was observed. Catalyst FC1 and PC2 lost their ZSA at higher aluminium contents. Scheme 1. Reaction pathways for zeolite dealumination- crystallinity loss. Si
SiO2
6I
AI-(SiO)4 ' ~
EFAL +
Si-O-H
H I
0
I Si
(collapse)
H-O-Si
~
Si 0 Si-O-Si-O-Si 0 Si
Data reported in the literature are also plotted in Figure 7. A REHY catalyst [16] steamed (815 ~ at varying time and a CREY resid catalyst [6] tested in pilot plant displayed quite different patterns with a fast ZSA losses with respect to dealumination. Comparatively, the ultrastable zeolite retained higher surface area values at lower UCS. In addition, Figure 7 shows that samples obtained from the laboratory deactivation protocols produced a pattem of lower ZSA and higher aluminium contents compared to equivalent Ecat fractions. It can be concluded that in order to reproduce more closely, the properties of Ecat a less severe steaming of the fresh REUSY catalyst should be used. The aging pattern is quite different between REUSY and high alumina zeolites like CREY or REHY. Initially, there is AI extraction from the lattice with no great destruction of the zeolite framework. Then the collapse of the zeolite structure becomes extremely sensitive to AI losses. It is well known that in order to produce USY zeolites conditions that favor dealumination upon structure collapse are needed. It appears that these conditions lead to dealumination in specific sites throughout the zeolite framework thus making
99 stabilization possible. Similarly, it could be assumed that the number of vacancies that are created in our REUSY catalysts under the FCCU operating conditions seem to be relatively few leading to further dealumination with a very low ZSA losses. However under c.a. 10 AI/UC the zeolite structure collapses much faster upon dealumination. It is concluded that the aluminium sites involved in the zeolite structure under c.a. 10 AI/UC seem to be essential for avoiding structure collapse. 200 160 -
"
E~
///
"~ 1 2 0 E
<
o~ N
80-
/ :l
400
~
9a :: t"
.;;:.;'.:-'" ./,"
~:~'"
.-"
I
1
10 AI atoms/UC
100
Figure 7. ZSA-AI atoms/UC dependence. Fractions from catalysts ( - ) PC1, (m) FC1, (A) PC2, (+) STM, (1-1) CPS, (X) CD, (O) fresh catalyst 1 and (.) fresh catalyst 2. Dotted lines are for: a) CREY catalyst from reference [6]; b) REHY catalyst from reference [16]. The results obtained would lead to rule out the idea that dealumination of REHY catalysts in industrial units could produce an equivalent stabilization toi USY. In order to get a better knowledge on the relative importance of the two phenomena involved the ratio of the incremental differences of ZSA and AI/UC were plotted as a logarithmic function of the number of AI/UC remaining for each fraction (Figure 8). As the zeolite becomes more stable upon dealumination the extent of the relative change of ZSA would depend on the severity of operating conditions that finally produce the zeolite collapse. Thus, the higher the severity of the operating conditions in the FCCU zeolite will collapse at higher AI/UC values and the higher the slope values in Figure 8. The calculated values were 0.62, 0.81 and 0.44 UC/AI for PC1, FC1 and PC2, respectively, while the regression coefficients were 0.880.90.
3.5 The ZSA-AI/UC relationship to catalyst deactivation. The value of the slope of the linear regression functions (Figure 8) is related to the trends and patterns in Figure 7, and possibly this value could correlate with catalyst deactivation. Table 4 summarizes the values of the deactivation rate constants calculated for PC1, FC1 and PC2 according to the method discussed in section 3.2. Since the ZSA-AI/UC ratio functions are calculated on a time independent scale it was necessary to use a reference in order to compare them.
lo0 relative values referred to PC1 were calculated. The ZSA-AI/UC function predicted the trends and orders of the relative deactivation rates in good agreement with the "Ni days" and "makeup" based methods (see section 3.2). Relative numbers are more consistent with deactivation calculated from the "makeup" method. In the industrial units considered in this work, fresh catalyst makeup data were collected in a daily basis whereas the Ni content in the feed was analyzed on a weekly basis
~
6
<
4-
Z
m,
~
2-
N
0-
v
._.1
-2
-
I
0
I
5 10 AI atoms / UC
15
Figure 8. ZSA-AI atoms/UC differential changes in fractions obtained from catalysts ( . ) PC1, (m) FC1 and (A) PC2. Table 4. Deactivation rate constants and relative rates obtained from different calculation basis. Ni days based [6] r = A' exp (-k t)
Makeup based [11,12] A = Ao / (kd T +1)
ZSA-AI/UCS based
k (days1)
relative
k~(days")
relative
relative
PC1
0.0072
1.0
0.055
1.0
1.0
FC1
0.0117
1.63
0.063
1.32
1.31
FC2
0.0046
0.64
0.049
0.89
0.72
Catalyst
The results obtained suggest that deactivation of the REUSY catalysts could be assessed by just looking at the ZSA-AI/UC or UCS ratio pattern in Ecats. This is possible because of the high dependence of catalytic activity upon its ZSA (regardless of the AI content in the zeolite) and because the reduction of the AI/UC occurs concurrently with the ZSA losses.
101
Coke yield (wt %) 8.0 . . . . . .
LPG olefinicity 0.9
7.0
0.8
6.0
X
-
5.0
-
4.0
-
|+m
0.7
D
x"
0.6
41,
"G
0.5
Gasoline yield (wt %) 60-
C4's olefinicity 0.9 0.8
~ Io
50-
9
0.7
41,
0.6
40-
m~+ gm
X
0.5
4)
30-
0.4
LPG yield (wt %) 20-
H2/CH4 (wt/wt) ratio 0.4
15
1,1
0.3
[]
XE] +
10
0.2 0.1
I
0
1
0.0
I
K
2
3
u
I
0
1
K
I
+ nl
2
Figure 9. Product yields and selectivity obtained in MAT with fractions of catalysts (4,) PC1, (11) FC1 and samples (+) STM, (El) CPS, and (X) CD. MAT conversion is expressed as a second order rate constant K.
3.6 The zeolite exchange loss capacity.
Contrary to what was shown for CREY and REY catalysts in resid pilot plant operations [6] the combined ZSA rate loss and dealumination constants failed to agree with the deactivation rate constant in REUSY. This lack of agreement could be explained by the fact that the CREY and REY catalyst used to create the correlation, contained larger amounts of AI and thus the effect of losing framework aluminium had a great impact on the acidity and on cracking activity, it also could be expected that other parameters in addition to the unit cell (i.e. mesoporosity and
102
extraframework alumina) would modify or even explain the catalytic activity as it was shown for dealuminated HY zeolites [17]. Nevertheless, our results indicated that the activity decay of the REUSY catalysts studied correlate very well with the ZSA.
3.7 Product selectivity in MAT Figure 9 shows varying aspects of product distribution obtained in MAT for fractions of PC1 and FCI. They were compared to those obtained with samples STM, CPS and CM samples. No appreciable differences in LPG, gasoline or coke yields were observed between fractions of PC1 and FC1 fractions. Some differences were observed in C4s' and LPG olefins suggesting that the lower UCS in PC1 may contribute to these yields. Higher H2/CH4 ratios were produced with PC1 fractions possibly because of their high metal content. The reason for the high coke yield in the most aged fractions of PC1 and FC1 is less clear. High coke yields can be associated with relatively enhanced non selective cracking on acid sites created by zeolite collapse [17]. Compared to Ecat fractions possessing the same MAT activity, laboratory deactivated samples showed a remarkable agreement in gasoline yield but not in LPG yields. STM produced less propylene thus lowering LPG olefinicity. CPS produced a very high coke yield and H2/CH4 ratio. CD showed lower coke yield and lower H2/CH4 ratio but still high compared to the corresponding Ecat fractions. These features reflect the fact that the metal content in these samples are higher than in the Ecat fractions of similar activity. Also, are metals much more dispersed throughout the catalyst surface because of the method they were impregnated [8].
tJ
1.8
LU
1.2
p, ~ 0.6 -z
o.0
0.8
0.9
1
Density of fraction (g/cm3) Figure 10. Plot for VMI calculation using fractions obtained from catalysts ($) PC1, (m) FC1 and (A) PC2.; VMI is proportional to the slope of the straight line.
3.8 Vanadium poisoning The full combustion unit considered in this work operates at high RegT and excess 02. These conditions would produce vanadium with a higher oxidation state leading to the formation of mobile species, harmful to zeolite stability [18].
103
An attempt to quantify vanadium migration (expressed as a vanadium mobility index or VMI) in FCCUs has been recently reported [7]. Figure 10 shows a plot used to calculate a VMI for the fractions of the three catalysts studied in this work as defined in reference [7] using the V and Ni contents in the Ecats and fractions. The VMi is proportional to the slope of the regression lines and was higher for PC1 (20.1) than FC1 (6.6) and FC2 (1.8) despite the fact that the former operates in a partial combustion mode. Boock et al. [7] studied a large number of FCCUs and found trends for higher values of VM! associated with full combustion regeneration. This lack of clarity indicates that vanadium mobility is affected by other parameters than combustion conditions. In the present study it could be suggested that the higher vanadium deposition rate leads to a high vanadium content in the catalyst inventory thus increasing vanadium mobility in PC1 compared to FCI. The low V content and low RegT in the FCCU of PC2 agree with the low V mobility found in this unit. FC1 showed lower ZSA than PC1 at the same vanadium content as can be observed in Figure 1la. In spite of its higher V content, PC1 deactivates at a slower rate than FCI. The high VMI in PC1 would indicate that vanadium moves at a relatively higher rate from the older to the younger catalyst particles. The results obtained would lead one to conclude that since this "active" vanadium does not accumulate in the older particles, it will be kept away from the zeolite and thus the ZSA will be retained in the older particles. Figure 11b shows that dealumination of PC1 and PC2 follows the same decay trend with the V content. However the fact that PC1 showed a high AI/UC compared to PC2 for the same V content indicates that the time effect is also very important, PC2 being 2 to 3 times older than PC1. On the other hand, Figure 1lb shows that the V activity for dealumination is lower for FCI. As discussed in Scheme 1, structural collapse and zeolite dealumination involve concurrent reactions. The V action at high RegT would produce such a high number of structure vacancies as a consequence of AI ejection that stabilization of the zeolite framework by silicon atoms insertion becomes more difficult. Therefore, the ZSA losses increases at the expenses of zeolite dealumination. 6 5 < 4 oo3
41111
9 A 11
9
9
"~2 IE
N
,,
~,,,,,,,,,,~
c2 ..J
1 0 -1
c_.1
0
1000 2000 3000 V content (ppm)
4000
0
I
I
I
1000
2000
3000
4000
V content (ppm)
Figure 11. a) ZSA and b) AI/UC dependence on the vanadium content in fractions of catalysts (~) PC1, (m) FC1, and (A) PC2
104 Noteworthy, the intercept of the AI atoms/UC is not the same at zero V in Figure 1 lb as it is for zero Ni (Figure 6b). This is explained by the fact that the V content this correlation is based on is not necessarily related to the catalyst age as it is in the Ni case. High V migration tend to normalize V contents on fractions. Therefore high VMI increases the slope value, which is in fact observed for PC2. V species involved in migration and in zeolite structural collapse were studied recently [18]. V exchanges as V ~vinto the cationic positions of the zeolite, preceding destruction of the zeolite framework. EPR can detect such species [18]. EPR spectra are presented in Figure 12. In a pure V-exchanged USY sample the EPR spectrum shows the typical pattern of isolated tetravalent vanadium. The clear hyperfine splitting peaks indicate that the unpaired electron of V 'v is interacting with only one nucleus, pointing out the high dispersion of V species. In other words, in this stage V 'v species may be present as (V=O) 2§ vanadyl ions compensating the negative charge of the zeolite framework.
Figure 12. EPR spectra of V ~'in catalysts and V exchanged USY. The EPR spectra of laboratory deactivated samples and fraction A of catalyst PC1 are more difficult to interpret due to the presence of a broad signal overlapping the V 'v species' signal. However, some hyperfine structure from V 'v species can be still observed mainly in lab-deactivated samples. The broad signal may be ascribed to
105
amorphous V204 or V205. In order to confirm the nature of the true species in such catalysts, simulations should be performed. Nevertheless, from the results obtained in this work we conclude that V cationic species are produced in a large extent in laboratory deactivated samples because of the fast rate of deposition [8]. The absence of an EPR signal on the Ecat might be simply associated with a very low concentration of such species in the catalyst. 4. CONCLUSIONS This study provides good insight into the effects of operating variables in deactivaton and aging of REUSY containing catalysts in industrial units. The REUSY catalyst studied in this work showed deactivation-aging patterns made up of an initial stage where a fast dealumination takes place and a second stage occurring below 10 AI/UC with great destruction of the ZSA. The most aged catalyst particles are major contributors to the catalytic activity of Ecats. The relative rates of ZSA losses and dealumination depend on the operating conditions in the FCCU and on the metal deposition rates. The results obtained also suggest that deactivation of REUSY catalysts can be assessed from the ZSA-AI/UC or UCS ratio pattern in Ecats. This is possible because of the high dependence of the catalytic activity on the ZSA (regardless of the AI content in the zeolite) and because the reduction of the AI/UC occurs concurrently with the ZSA losses. Even though separation of catalyst particles is needed, this approach would facilitate assessment since it is independent of time and average data from the FCCUs. MAT activity-selectivity studies did not show any significant dependence on the particular deactivation-aging process followed by the two catalysts. Metal deposition and steaming severity seemed to be key issues for laboratory deactivation protocols to reproduce typical Ecat properties. The effects of V poisoning could be related to the V content in the catalyst inventory and to the operating conditions in the units. V effects are strongly time dependent. The study of the ZSA-AI/UC pattern produced in a particular unit for a REUSY catalyst could be used as reference to reproduce Ecat properties in fresh fluid cracking catalysts. REFERENCES
1. McLean, J.B. and Moorhead, E.L., Hydroc. Proc., February (1991) 41. 2. Keyworth, D.A., Turner, J. And Reid, T.A., Oil & Gas J., 14 March (1988) 65 3. O'Connor P., Brevoord, E., Powels, A.C. and Wijingaards, H.N., Ch. 10 in Deactivation and Testing of Hydrocarbon Processing Catalysts, P.O'Connor, T. Takatsuka and G. L. Woolery, Eds., ACS Symp. Ser. 634, Am. Chem Soc., Chicago (1996) 147. 4. R.N. Cimbalo, R.L. Foster and S.J. Wachtel, Oil & Gas J., 70 No. 20 (1972) 112. 5. Boock, L., Pretti, T., Rudesill, J., Ch. 12 in Deactivation and Testing of Hydrocarbon Processing Catalysts, O'Connor, P, Takatsuka, T. & Woolery, G., Eds. Acs Symp. Ser. 634, Washington (1996) 171.
106
6. Palmer, J.L. and Cornelius, E.B., Appl. Catal., 35 (1987) 217. 7. Boock, L., Deady, J., Foon Lim T. and Yaluris, G., Catalyst Deactivation 1997, Bartholomew, C. & Fuentes G. Eds., Elsevier Sc. (1997) 367. 8. Hernandez, F., Garcfa de Le6n, R., Mogica, E., Moreno, J.C., Garcfafigueroa E., and Gonz~lez, R., Catalyst Deactivation 1997, Bartholomew, C. & Fuentes G. Eds., Elsevier Sc. (1997) 455. 9. Leofanti, G., Padovan, M., Tozzola, G., Venturelli, B., Catal. Today 41(1998) 207. 10. Breck, D.W., "Zeolite Molecular Sieves, Structural Chemistry and Use", John Wiley; N.Y. (1974) a) Ch. 2; b) Ch.6. 11. Lee, W., ind. Eng., Chem. Proc. Des. Develop., V. 9, No.l, January (1970) 155. 12. Leunberger, E.L., Oil & Gas J., Technology, July 15 (1985) 125. 13. Mott, R.W., Paper AM-91-43, NPRA Anual Meeting, March 17-19, 1991. 14.Kubicek, N., Vaudry, F., Chiche, B.H., Hudec, P., Di renzo, F., Schulz, P. and Fajula, F., Appl. Catal. A: general 175 (1998) 159. 15. Beyerlein, R.A., Choi-Feng, C., Hall, J.B., Huggins, B.J. and Ray, G. J., Topics in Catalysis, J.J. Fripiat and J.A. Dumesic, Eds., J.C. Baltzer A.G., Sc. Pub., 4 (1997) 27. 16. de la Puente, G., Sedran, U.A., Micr. Mat. 12 (1997) 251. 17. Corma, A., Forn#s V., Martinez, A. and Orchilles, A.V., Ch. 35 in "Perspectives in Molecular Sieves Science", ACS Symp. Ser. 368, Am. Chem. Soc., Chicago (1988) 541 18.Trujillo, C.A., Navarro, U., Knops-Gerrits, P., Oviedo, L.A., and Jacobs, P., J. Catal., 168 (1997) 1.
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 134 M.L. Occelli and P. O'Conner (Editors) 9 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
107
THE IMPROVEMENT OF CATALYTIC CRACKING PROCESS THROUGH THE UTILIZATION OF NEW CATALYTIC MATERIALS M.I.Levinbuka, V.B.Melnikov a, Samir Numan a, M.L.Pavlov b and V.A.Patrikeev c "Gubkin Moscow Oil and Gas University, 65 Leninsky prosp., Moscow 117917, The Russian Federation. blshimbai Catalyst Factory, Ishimbai 453210, The Russian Federation. CSalavat Catalyst Factory, Salavat 453206, The Russian Federation. 1. INTRODUCTION For the 50 years that the catalytic cracking exists, the development of both its equipment and its catalysts has been caused mainly by the continuous increase in the proportion of heavy fractions in feed and changes in requirements for the quality and yield of products to be obtained (LPG, LCO, gasoline). But the cracking chemism remained unchanged even after zeolites had come to be used in FCC catalysts. Since the object of the design of the equipment of any catalytic process is to attain the maximum potential yield of the target product possible with the use of a particular catalyst, in recent years nearly all the tasks facing cracking have been solved by improving the production equipment of cracking units. Now, there exist two major way to develop the cracking process: first, to modify the reactor unit in such a way that would allowed the "Short Contact Time" technology to be applied to increase the gasoline yield when processing heavier feed, and, second, to either adapt the reactor vessel to operation at higher temperatures or to build new facilities producing ZSM-5 zeolites, which are the basis for the manufacturing of catalytic additives to the existing commercial catalyst with ultrastable Y zeolite so as to raise the yield of light olefins in LPG (with a decrease in the gasoline fraction yield), which are used as feed for growing capacities of alkylation, MTBE and TAME units. Since cracking gasoline is the major source of olefins in commercial gasolines, the possibility of adjusting the proportion of aromatics to olefins in the chemical composition of the gasoline fraction is very important, because a growths in the reaction temperature or an addition of ZSM-5 zeolite to the main catalyst increases the gasoline olefinicity; this way, though, is restricted by requirements imposed on reformulated gasolines. Both the above-mentioned directions of cracking development as well as the trend to modify the catalyst regeneration unit (the two-step regeneration) are connected chiefly with the fact that the possibilities of enhancing properties of FCC catalysts containing ultrastable Y zeolite to adjust to new tasks facing cracking, are limited. Besides, both manufacturers and consumers of catalysts have to make great investments to implement such ideas in industry. Therefore, the introduction of two new components, low-alumina LAY-zeolite and constant or variable valence metal oxides can provide a solution to many of problems facing cracking
108 process, without any considerable modification of the equipment of existing units required. LAY zeolites as against ultrastable and conventional NaHY zeolites allow catalytic properties to be improved in terms of both the residual Na20 content and the molar SIO2/A1203 ratio in the zeolite framework [ 1]. Variable and constant valence metal oxides constitutes an "oxygen trap" transferring oxygen from the regenerator into the reactor to partially oxidize hydrocarbons in feed (reagent catalyst). This changes the cracking chemism and greatly affect the range of products obtained [2]. 2. EXPERIMENTAL It is to be noted, that the independent existence of two catalytic cracking technologies (TCC and FCC) has always promoted the accelerated introduction of new catalytic components previously tested in TCC catalysts into FCC catalysts (for example, X and Y zeolites, CO complete combustion promoters, ZSM-5 zeolites etc.). Low capacities of TCC units and the flexible technology of TCC catalyst manufacturing makes it easy to include various additions in them. Therefore, LAY zeolites and constant and variable valence metals were first introduced into TCC catalysts and subjected to pilot and industrial tests, and only then were they used in laboratory and pilot tests of FCC catalysts. The preparation of TCC and FCC catalysts containing LAY zeolites and the conditions of their tests in vacuum gas oil cracking on laboratory MAT units (a density of 0.915 g/cm 3, a Conradson carbon of 0.52 wt. %, a sulfur content of 1.52 wt. %, the IBP of 321~ the EBP of 519~ are indicated in [1]. The condition of FCC catalyst testing on a pilot unit are specified in [2]. Oxides of constant and variable valence metals of groups IV to VII were introduced into TCC and FCC catalyst following a technique [3]. Physical and chemical methods of investigation of LAY zeolites and TCC and FCC catalysts are given in [ 1]. Samples of commercial DA-250 (20 wt. % of CREY zeolite) and Emcat-Extra (12 wt. % of RE-USY zeolite) were used for comparison with samples of TCC and FCC catalysts under investigation. 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Major results of the introduction of RELAY zeolites (10 wt. %) into FCC catalyst as compared with CREY zeolites (DA-250) are represented in Tables 1 and 2. It follows from Table 1 that when FCC catalysts are tested in conditional MAT mode at a constant contact time, that target products (gasoline and coke) of vacuum gas oil cracking forms more selectively over FCC catalysts containing only 10 wt. % of RELAY zeolite than over DA-250 (20 wt. % of CREY zeolite). These results also shows that RELAY zeolite combines both the merit of REHY zeolite (a high activity) and that of RE-USY zeolites (a low coke yield). Over 12000 metric tons of Z-10 TCC catalyst based on LAY zeolite was manufactured in Russia from 1994 to 1998. Tests of a TCC catalyst containing 10 wt. % of RELAY zeolite as compared with Emcat-Extra containing RE-USY zeolite under laboratory and industrial conditions at a constant space velocity (which corresponds to actual operational conditions of the catalysts in cracking units) discovered that the gasoline fraction yield has a maximum at lower catalyst to feed ratios over the samples under investigation as against commercial TCC catalysts [1]. The same results are also observed in the case of FCC catalysts if tests are carried out following the MAT method at a constant space velocity (Table 2). It follows from Table 2 that a lower catalyst to feed mass ratio and, consequently, a longer contact time is required to reach a similar feed conversion at a constant space velocity in the case of a LAY-
109 zeolite-containing FCC catalyst as against DA-250 (not to speak of USY-zeolite-based FCC catalysts). Table 1 Tests of FCC catalyst samples in vacuum gas oil cracking through MAT method at a constant contact time of 75 s, and a reaction temperature of 500~ Product Catalyst to feed mass ratio = 4.4 Catalyst to feed mass ratio = 7.0 yields, wt. % DA-250 Sample with DA-250 Sample with 10 wt. % of RELAY 10 wt. % of RELAY Gasoline 40.6 43.8 43.0 48.0 Gas 16.1 16.2 20.5 19.0 LCO 27.1 24.3 19.1 18.7 HCO 6.7 8.9 4.5 4.5 Coke 9.5 6.8 12.9 9.8 Conversion 66.2 66.8 76.4 76.8 The results obtained testify to the necessity of carrying out special researches so as to establish whether it is possible not to adapt cracking units to a process with a shorter contact time if FCC catalysts with RELAY zeolites are used. Table 2 Tests of FCC catalyst samples in vacuum gas oil cracking through MAT method at a constant space velocity of 16 h l , and a reaction temperature of 500~ Product Catalyst to feed mass ratio = 9.0 Catalyst to feed mass ratio = 6.0 yields, wt. % Sample with 10 wt. % of RELAY DA-250 Contact time 37.5 s Contact time 25.0 s Gasoline 49.0 43.2 Gas 20.0 24.1 LCO 19.0 20.0 HCO 7.0 7.0 Coke 5.0 5.7 Conversion 74.0 73.0 Metal oxides were introduced in cracking catalysts by a special technique ensuring that the oxides would not chemically react with the framework and that oxygen would easily be bound and then released in the catalytic reaction-regeneration cycle. One of the major purposes of introducing metal oxides ("reagent catalysts") into cracking catalysts for partial oxidation of hydrocarbons in feed is to acquire the possibility of controlling the chemical composition of gasoline, LPG and LCO without changing the reaction temperature and other process conditions (which eliminates the necessity to modify the equipment of existing units). The potential of reagent catalysts for changing the chemical composition of the gasoline fraction by changing the ratio of zeolite to the metal oxide content in catalyst is demonstrated by Table 3, where the yields of products of vacuum gas oil cracking over TCC catalysts containing oxides of IV group metals are indicated. The content of oxygen-containing hydrocarbons in gasolines did not exceed 0.5 wt. %. It follows from Table 3 that the olefin content in gasoline decreases, and the aromatics content increases with the growths of the zeolite to metal ratio in the reagent catalyst. The same dependence is
110 characteristic of olefin content in LPG, too. However, the product yields over reagent catalysts have a complicated dependence on the contents of pure metal oxide and zeolite in samples, rather than on the zeolite to metal oxide ratio. Table 3 also shows that the use of LAY zeolite in cracking catalysts results in an increase in the aromatics content and a decrease in the olefin content in gasoline. The results obtained were also substantiated by FCC trials on a pilot FCC unit in comparison with a commercial DA-250 catalyst. So, the introduction of LAY zeolites and metal oxides, which ensure the partial oxidation of feed hydrocarbons in the reactor, in cracking catalysts, allows the yields and the chemical composition of target products to be changed within a wide range, without substantial alterations of operation conditions. Table 3 The effect of the zeolite to metal oxide ratio in TCC reagent catalysts on the yields of vacuum gas oil cracking products and the chemical gasoline composition (reaction temperature 460~ space velocity 1.5 h ~, catalyst to feed ratio 3,5)
'
1. Product yields, wt. % Gasoline Gas Light Gas Oil Coke 2. Gasoline composition, wt. % Paraffins Naphthenes Monoolefins Dienes and cycloolefins Arenes The total amount of olefins
o
0
35.2 10.2 27.2 5.8
40.0 12.5 26.5 5.0
32.3 9.0 32.1 4.8
- 36.4 12.0 28.7 6.7
26.5 8.7 29.5 5.0
36.9 8.5 29.2 7.2
41.1 19.7 22.1 8.8
39.7 31.0 11.1 18.2 11.1
37.4 30.4 5.6 26.6 5.6
30,3 17.9 16.2 13.6 22.0 29.8
30.0 24.1 12.4 11.3 22.2 23.7
29.5 30.7 16.2 23.6 16.2
30.2 29.8 8.3 31.7 8.3
33.4 25.3 6.7 34.6 6.7
4. CONCLUSION The development of new catalytic systems based on the executed researches into catalytic and physical and chemical properties of LAY zeolites and metal oxides incorporated into FCC catalysts shall be continued to create an alternative to the idea that catalytic cracking can only be enhanced by improving the equipment. REFERENCES
1. M.I. Levinbuk, M.L. Pavlov et al., Applied catalysis A; General, 172, (1998) 177 2. M.I. Levinbuk, V.B. Melnikov, V.I. Vershinin, USSR Patent #1812785 (1990) 3. M.I. Rustamov, G.T. Farhadova, S.A. Dorofeev, Chem. Tech. of Fuels and Oils, 6 (1991) 6
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 134 M.L. Occelli and P. O'Conner (Editors) 9 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
111
NExCC TM -Novel short contact time catalytic cracking technology J. Hiltunen a, V.M. Niemi a, K. Lipi~iinena, I. Eilos a, P. Hagelberg a, P. Knuuttila a , K. J~i~iskelainenb, J. Majander b and J. R6pp~inenb aFortum Oyj, P.O. Box 310, 06101 Porvoo, Finland bFortum Oyj, P.O. Box 20, 00048 FORTUM, Finland ABSTRACT The demand for reformulated gasoline requires extending the flexibility of cracking operations to maximise the yield of light olefins and aromatics, both of which are to be used as building blocks for petrochemicals. Olefins are widely used for producing alkylates and oxygenates for the gasoline pool while aromatics are suitable for producing a large number of organic intermediates and chemicals. Fluid catalytic cracking combined with various hydrorefining technologies will be the main means used to meet the coming challenges for the refining industry. Demand for a short and exact contact time, higher temperature and a high catalyst/oil ratio, to produce more light olefins, has led to a new NExCC TM process incorporating a totally new reactor type. The NExCC TM design makes it possible to construct large equipment with a small height-to-diameter ratio. Compared to the conventional FCC, the NExCC TM product spectrum is much more olefinic. The process produces a higher conversion and less heavy components (>221 ~ In a suitable setting NExCC TM can also serve as a source of increased propylene production. The gas velocity in a NExCC TM reactor is lower than in a FCCU riser. The flow type in the regenerator is totally different compared with that of the FCC and the reaction time is shorter. The NExCC TM process utilises multi-entry cyclones for separating catalyst from gas flows both in the reactor and the regenerator. The separation efficiency of the multi-entry cyclone is usually better than that of a conventional cyclone, and it is optimal for handling gas flows with high particle concentrations, such as in the NExCC TM process. Fortum Oyj has been developing multi-entry cyclone technology by using cold and hot model tests with different testing units and by using computational fluid dynamics (CFD) for analysis test results and for detailed cyclone design. For a scale-up of the process, models which predict with reasonable accuracy the flow field and chemical reactions both in the risers and the cyclones are required. In order to study the effect of the reactor operation conditions on the product yields and the product quality a kinetic model has been developed. The model takes into account the gasoline PONAcomposition and includes eight product lumps with eight cracking reactions. A micro scale pulse reactor has been developed to obtain the parameters for the kinetic model.
112 1. FUTURE DEMANDS FOR FCC PROCESS There are three global, partly diverging trends that are transforming the refining industry: * 9 9
Available crudes will be increasingly sour and heavy. (Heavy oil constitutes 13% of current production and is expected to exceed 19% by 2003). Regulations are becoming more stringent concerning sulphur, aromatics, and other product and production based emissions. Demand for lighter, high quality transport fuels is increasing.
The demand for reformulated gasoline requires extending the flexibility of cracking operations to maximise the yield of light olefins used as building blocks for petrochemicals and for producing alkylates and oxygenates for the gasoline pool. The aromatics produced are suitable for a large number of organic intermediates and chemicals. Propylene supply may become short as ethane gas replaces naphtha as steam cracker feedstock. Fortum believes that the demand for polymers based on propylene and butylenes will grow faster than that for ethylene. The use of propylene as an alkylate feedstock will accompany the growing demand for high-octane gasoline. Also, the requirement for olefins for gasoline oxygenates (MTBE, ETBE, TAME) or alternatively for iso-octane will be expected to increase worldwide. Developing countries especially, are continuously looking for more profitable value-added conversion applications for cheaper and heavier feedstocks. Fluid catalytic cracking combined with various hydrorefining technologies will be the main means by which to meet the coming challenges for the refining industry. Table 1 Scenarios forecasting the increasing demand for lighter products and transportation fuels. Million toe 1973 1995 2000 2010 1010 1600 1870 2320 Transportation fuels Petrochemicals 125 192 250 300 Other non energy uses 155 192 215 250 Heating and industrial fuels 1510 1216 1265 1430 TOTAL 2800 3200 3600 4300 Share of transportation 36% 50% 52% 54% Source: Bonnifay, P. and Vidal, A., (IFP), CatCon'98, June 3-5, 1998, Houston, TX. The fluid catalytic cracking process is the heart of the modern petroleum refinery. The flexibility of FCC enables the refiner to maximise the yield of desired light products and utilise diverse low value feedstocks.
113
2. PROBLEM AREAS OF PRESENT FCC TECHNOLOGY 2.1. Product properties More stringent specification gasoline will be needed in the future. However the components produced by FCC-units are not optimal. FCC gasoline has a high content of aromatics and olefins and a low octane number compared with the reformate. Nearly all the sulphur in the final product comes from the FCC heavy gasoline fraction. Hydrotreating this fraction for sulphur removal will lower the octane number, because the olefins in this fraction will also be hydrogenated. It is known that by using more severe process conditions, FCC could produce more light olefins for alkylation and etherification.
2.2. Investment A typical level of investment for a new FCC unit in the US Gulf Coast area based on 30,000 bpsd feed, including reaction and regeneration systems and product recovery but excluding offsites, power recovery and flue gas scrubbing, is about $2100-2800 per bpsd ($63-84 Million/unit). Industry has optimised FCC technology for large refineries and that is why the conventional FCC cannot be economically downscaled. Fortum believes that in most cases a 30,000-bpsd unit is the minimum economic size for the present FCC technology. 2.3. Erosion One of the most severe problems with the conventional FCC process is the erosion of construction materials, especially in process areas where high temperatures and high velocities are necessary. Mechanical reliability is paramount in FCC construction. Erosion of the components by the high velocities of the hard catalyst particles is inevitable. Practically every surface of an FCC unit contacting catalyst particles will need surface protection against erosion. The degree of protection required will depend on the severity of the conditions. Erosion of the walls of the components is a safety concern because, in the case of a leak, a substantial amount of hot hydrocarbon gases could escape into the environment. 2.2. Catalyst attrition Catalyst attrition also causes a dust problem. High velocities, especially in the riser reactor and cyclones, tends to grind catalyst particles down into micron size dust which is difficult to separate from vent gases and product streams. Particles are usually separated from the product stream in sedimentation tanks. Dust escaping from the catalyst regenerator into the atmosphere is one of the environmental problems of conventional FCC technology. It can be expected that environmental legislation will be enacted to reduce particulate emissions with a possible target level of 50 m g ~ m 3. Also, refiners using power recovery need to remove the fines in flue gases to avoid turbine blade erosion. Regenerator dust emissions under 100 m g ~ m 3 are difficult to achieve without Third Stage Separation (TSS) equipment. These typically involve multiple, relatively small cyclones.
114 3. D E S C R I P T I O N OF T H E NExCC TM T E C H N O L O G Y
3.1. Process description Demand for a short and exact contact time, an increased temperature and a high catalyst/oil ratio to produce more light olefins, has led to the NExCC TM process which incorporates a totally new reactor type. Both reactor and regenerator are operated in the fast fluidized flow regime type and have direct-coupled cyclones. To increase the catalyst regeneration time, part of the regenerated catalyst is circulated back to the bottom of the regenerator. The regenerator and reactor cyclone diplegs are connected directly to the reactor and regenerator risers without large catalyst vessels (Fig. 1). The reactor is operated a higher temperature, a shorter contact time and a higher catalyst/oil-ratio (see Table 2) than conventional FCC reactors. This is to increase conversion, yield of light olefins and the octane number of the gasoline. It is possible to double or triple the feed to propylene, MTBE, TAME and alkylation processing compared with the possibilities in existing refineries. The regeneration time is shorter than that of bubbling bed FCC regenerators, because mass transfer for coke burning is faster. Table 2 Main process parameters for NExCC TM and FCC
Regenerator Reactor
Temperature Residence time Temperature Residence time .. Catalyst/oi! ratio
NExCC TM
FCC
680- 720~ App. 30 s 550 - 620~ 0.7 - 2.2 s 1 0 - 20..
680- 720~ app. 240 s 520- 550~ 2-5s 5-7
TC=temperature control LC=level control LI=level indication PdI=pressure difference indication
Fig. 1. Flow and control principle of NExCCrU-reactor.
115
3.2. Construction description A multi-entry cyclone is more efficient for handling a higher cyclone catalyst loading with lower velocities and a lower pressure drop than the usual single port cyclones. Risers connected to multi-entry cyclones are optimally ring shaped. This type of geometry makes it possible to design a totally new reactor configuration, a demonstration unit of which has been operated since summer 1997. In the NExCC TM unit the reactor and regenerator have been built concentric, whereby the riser channels have an axially annular cross section. Used and regenerated catalyst flows are controlled by special valves, which are located inside the pressure vessel (Fig. 2).
Fig. 2. Schematic construction of NExCC TM reactor.
3.3. Construction benefits The need for a higher cracking temperature, a shorter contact time and a higher catalyst/oil ratio has led to the conclusion that the mechanical restrictions of existing FCC-units prevent the optimisation of the process for maximum olefin production. The greatest advantage of the NExCC TM reactor is that it facilitates construction of more compact units than the current combinations of reactor and regenerator, thus offering a much smaller footprint and easier installation. Insulation linings are used only in the outer shell to keep the temperature of the pressure shell below a metallurgical limit. All other walls between the channels and most of the other reactor parts are made of heat resistant steel. Only in a limited number of parts is more
116 erosion resistant material is required. The location of potential erosion points and the erosion rate has been studied with the pilot unit over more than two years. The NExCC TM design makes it possible to construct large equipment with a small heightto-diameter ratio, whereby the footprint/space requirements of the equipment are minirnised and problems associated with thermal expansion are reduced. NExCC TM reactors have a light construction; even to the extent that they can be designed portable with a modular construction (Fig. 3). 3.4. Investment benefits A compact, economical design with minimum refractory surfaces means savings in investment costs for equipment, piping and support. Preliminary economics for the NExCC TM process compared to conventional FCC units show that capital investment for a NExCC TM reactor is less than half that of the traditional FCC reactor in a 240 t/h (40 000 bpsd) scale. Due to the single vessel reactor / regenerator system, requirements for piping, foot space, steel structure, insulation and the amount of civil work are minimised, which results in most of the investment advantage.
Fig. 3. NExCCrM-reactor size compared to traditional FCC-reactor.
117 3.4. Product benefits Gasoline quality can be significantly improved by increasing the production of oxygenates and alkylate. Blending these components will lower the content of aromatics and olefins in the final product. The production of light olefins for these processes is possible by the catalytic cracking of heavy distillates with more severe conditions than applied in FCC. Moreover, the amount of olefins in the heavy gasoline fraction is decreased and hydrotreating this fraction has only a minor effect on the octane number. Fig. 4 describes how the NExCC TM process can be integrated into a refinery focused on the production of reformulated gasoline and its oxygenate and alkylate components. Alternatively, iso-butylenes can be converted to valuable iso-octane using the NExOCTANE process. Compared to the conventional FCC, the NExCC TM product spectrum is much more olefinic, producing higher conversion and less heavy (>221~ components. In a suitable setting the NExCC TM can also serve as a source of increased propylene production. While gasoline production is reduced by 40%, compensation comes from increased propylene, ether, and alkylate production. Multiple reactors can be operated in parallel with different feeds, with optimum catalyst and optimum process conditions. The construction of the cyclone offers a short and exactly controllable reaction time as the catalyst enters the cyclone simultaneously from each point of the riser top. In the NExCC TM reactor, the catalyst inventory is located in the diplegs. The inventory is much smaller compared with the FCC-units of equal capacity, which means a rapid response to market needs by enabling a fast catalyst change.
Fig. 4. NExCCrM-unit integrated into a refinery.
118 4. NExCC TM PILOT R E A C T O R RESULTS The main function of the pilot reactor was to demonstrate mechanical operability and to be an erosion test unit. Thus, chemistry studies have mainly concentrated on the rnicroreactor tests. Since its construction the pilot unit reactor has been operated for 7600 hours, which includes 2500 hours on feed. The maximum feed rate so far has been 950 kg/h. The only erosion encountered has been found on the cyclone vanes, but this can be easily handled by proper material choice. 4.1. Results with different feeds Two types of feed have been used; hydrotreated vacuum gas oil (VGO) and untreated VGO. The feed properties are shown in Table 3. Table 3 Feed properties. Hydrotreated VGO 910
VGO 908
wt-% ppm
0.1
1.4 1100
Aromatics
wt-%
35
50
GC distillation I]3P 20% 50% 80% FO3P
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
160 385 446 495 577
151 314 379 438 559
Density
kg/m 3
Sulphur Nitrogen
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
As can be seen from Table 3, the densities of the feeds are almost the same despite the more aromatic nature of the untreated VGO. An explanation for this can be found from the distillation curve, which shows that untreated VGO is lower boiling. For example the LCO fraction (221-343~ content is about 27% in the untreated VGO, whereas it is only 8% in the hydrotreated feed. The NExCCVM-reactor cracking results with the different feeds are compared to "high severity" FCC-yields (base case) in Table 4. Of course a direct comparison is difficult but we think that the yield tendencies between the FCC and NExCC TM and between two types of feeds in the NExCCTM-reactor are quite obvious. Despite the higher riser temperature in the NExCCTM-reactor the conversion is only about two per cent higher than in the FCC. Another feature, as expected, is that conversion of the untreated feed under the same process conditions is lower than that of hydrotreated feed. However, despite the reduced crackability of the untreated VGO the yields of the LPG fraction are almost comparable, hence the lower conversion is reflected primarily in the lower gasoline yield. It is also clear that the higher LPG yield is mostly a consequence of gasoline overcracking.
119 Table 4 NExCC TM results withdifferent feeds compared to typical FCC. .............. FCC Pilot Reactor Partly hydroHydrotreated VGO treated VGO VGO Base +50 +50 Riser temperature (~ Conversion (%)
base
+2.2
-2.2
Yields (wt-%) Dry gas Propylene i-Butane i-Butene C4-alkanes C4-olefins LPG Gaso line LCO+HCO
base base base base base base base base base
+ 1.2 +5.2 -1.0 +2.5 -1.6 +5.2 +8.4 -7.4 -2.2
+2.0 +4.7 -0.6 +2.2 -1.0 +4.7 +8.4 - 12.6 +2.2
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
,,,,
~_
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
~ .
.
.
.
.
.
.
,
.
.
.
.
,l
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
4.2. The effect of oil partial pressure
The effect of oil partial pressure on the product distribution was tested by changing the ratio of prefluidization gas (nitrogen) and feed oil (hydrotreated VGO). Table 5 shows quite clearly that at the lower oil partial pressure hydrogen transfer reactions (olefin+naphthene --) paraffin+aromatic) are minimised. For example the LPG olefins yield can be increased using dilution gas. Also the i-butane/i-butene ratio can be improved for the feed to post-treatment units (e.g. alkylation, etherification). Table 5 Effect of dilutio n on theproduct distribution:. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D ilutant/feedoil (kg/kg)_ _ !.0 . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0:6 LPG fraction ratios Propane/propylene i-B utane/i-butene
0.10 0.60
0.17 1.07
Gasoline fraction yields Paraffins+aromatics 44% 70% - 01efins+Naphthenes .......................5 6 % . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30 % . . . . . . 4.3. Post-treatment without octane loss
Tighter fuel specifications may require reducing the sulphur content in gasoline to a level less than 50 ppm, and it seems that this trend may go down to 10 ppm in the near future. Hence the FCC gasoline, a major source of sulphur in the final product, needs more and more stringent post-treatment to reduce the sulfur content. The sulphur content of FCC gasoline is reduced significantly by removing the heaviest gasoline cut, but this reduces the gasoline
120
yield. On the other hand desulphurization of the heavier cut produces octane loss due to olefin saturation [ 13. The NExCCTMprocess makes the post-treatment problem easier to solve. Fig. 5 shows typical olefin, aromatic and sulphur compound distribution throughout the boiling range of full-range FCC gasoline with the non-hydroteated VGO feed specified above.
I -If- olefins +aromatics
- -X-
-sulfur compounds
1
20
-
400
15
-
300
s? xQi F
E, n 10
-
200
5
-
100
-0
0 30
50
70
90
110 130 150 Boiling point, OC
170
190
210
230
Fig. 5. Sulphur compounds, olefins and aromatics in NExCCTM gasoline. The olefin and aromatic distributions are shown in the yields, so they directly imply the masses that have to be treated. The Cs-fraction consists mainly (69%)of olefins, from which up to 53% are reactive in a NExTAMETM-reactor,which produces high octane blending components for the gasoline pool. In the Cb-fraction olefins are still the main components (63%), but from the CT-fraction the aromatics begin to dominate so that in the Clo-fraction the aromatics content is above 93%. Hence by dividing the NExCCTM gasoline fraction into light (30-80°C) and heavy (80-221"C) portions, and since only the heavy portion contains sulphur and it can be desulphurized without any significant octane loss due to its high aromatic content.
121 5. MULTI-ENTRY CYCLONE TECHNOLOGY The NExCC TM process utilises multi-entry cyclones for separating catalyst from gas flows both in the reactor side and the regenerator side. Fortum Oyj has been developing multi-entry cyclone technology by using cold and hot model tests with different testing units and by using computational fluid dynamics (CFD) to analyse test results and for detailed cyclone design. Flow to the multi-entry cyclones comes through several inlet ports. The flow is directed into a rotating motion by vanes that are placed in a ring on the cyclone circle (Fig. 2). A typical gas entrance velocity to the multi-entry cyclone is at a range of 2 to 10 m/s that results in much less particle attrition and wall erosion rates compared to conventional cyclones.
5.1. Performance of multi-entry cyclones The separation efficiency of the multi-entry cyclone is normally as good as and usually better than the conventional cyclone. In the NExCC TM process there exist high particle concentrations in the cyclone inlet. At high particle concentrations the flow field in the cyclone is dominated by particle flow instead of fluid flow. Therefore high loading ratios should be taken into account in the cyclone design. The separation efficiency has also been estimated also by a model developed by Liesmaki et al. [2] for highly loaded multi-entry cyclones. Typical test results are presented in Fig. 6. The test results are compared with estimated results. The model gives reliable results for particles over 10 l.tm, for smaller particles the air humidity and temperature have a great effect on their flow behaviour. 100
-
"".
.
.
.
.
.
m
--
95 90 o~ 85 >:, c .~_ 80 ._o 0
==:
|r
75
a~
70
.o
00 65 60 55 50
I
~
--B--measured 2.2 kg.cat(kg air
, ..,
~
estimated 3.2 kg.cat/kg air
--at measured 3.2kg.cat/kg air i
i'
J
9
0
i
i
5
10
~ "
i
'
,
i
15 20 25 Particle size, microns
'
i. . . . . . .
30
i
35
. . . . . . . . . . .
40
Fig. 6. Measured multi-entry cyclone separation efficiency compared to estimation by the modified Dietz model.
122 The test cyclone is presented in Fig. 7. The test cyclone diameter was 1.6 m. The tests were carried out with a typical FCC-equilibrium catalyst with the particle size distribution shown in Table 6. The air temperature was 55~ an inlet gas velocity of 2.8 m/s and the solids' concentrations were 2.2 and 3.2 kg.catalyst/kg.air. Table 6 Tested solids particle size distribution. Dp (~tm) Distribution % dp (~tm) Distribut!pn % 0,9 0,10 6,0 0,01 1,1 0,03 7,5 0,02 1,3 0,03 9,0 0,03 1,5 0,03 10,5 0,03 1,8 0,02 12,5 0,04 2,2 0,03 15,0 0,08 2,6 0,01 18,0 0,18 3,1 0,01 21,0 0,23 3,7 0,00 25,0 0,24 4,3 0,01 30,0 0,08 5,0 0,00 36,0 0,25
Fig. 7. Multi-entry cyclone test device.
dp (~tm) Distribution % 43,0 1,97 51,0 6,10 61,0 13,18 73,0 20,06 87,0 22,57 103,0 18,95 123,0 12,26 147,0 3,45 175,0 0,00
123
5.2. Computational Fluid Dynamic in the NExCCrM-reactor development During the last decade computational fluid dynamics (CFD) has proven to be a powerful design tool in many fields of engineering [3-8]. Fortum has u