Groundwater Science and Policy An International Overview
Groundwater Science and Policy An International Overview
Edited by Philippe Quevauviller European Commission, DG Environment, Brussels, Belgium
ISBN: 978-085404-294-4 A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library r The Royal Society of Chemistry 2008 All rights reserved Apart from fair dealing for the purposes of research for non-commercial purposes or for private study, criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 and the Copyright and Related Rights Regulations 2003, this publication may not be reproduced, stored or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of The Royal Society of Chemistry, or in the case of reproduction in accordance with the terms of licences issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency in the UK, or in accordance with the terms of the licences issued by the appropriate Reproduction Rights Organization outside the UK. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the terms stated here should be sent to The Royal Society of Chemistry at the address printed on this page. Published by The Royal Society of Chemistry, Thomas Graham House, Science Park, Milton Road, Cambridge CB4 0WF, UK Registered Charity Number 207890 For further information see our web site at www.rsc.org
Foreword One of the major questions that faces the world at the beginning of this century is the threat to our water resources, both in terms of quantity and of quality. There are today 6.2 billion inhabitants on Earth, 14% of whom are already suffering from hunger, a number that has unfortunately been increasing for the last five years, and 20% of whom lack an adequate drinking water supply. In 2050, there will most likely be 9 billion people. To provide food and an adequate domestic water supply to that many people, with their evolving diets, we will need roughly 75% more water than we use todayw, mostly for agriculture, at the same time as we will need to safeguard a biodiverse and healthy series of natural ecosystems, indispensable for the ecological equilibrium of the planet. In addition, our current urban life, our industrial activity and our agricultural practices increasingly generate sources of contaminants that are spread in the atmosphere, in surface water, on soils and in groundwater, threatening water quality. Finally, these threats must be examined in the context of climate variability, which most likely will be enhanced by impending climate changes, as indicated by the recent Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change released on 29 January 2007z. Not only will more water be needed, but it will have to be available even during droughts. The world has always experienced great climate variability, such as the seven years of fat cows and lean cows in the Bible. For instance, some archaeological studies conducted simultaneously in Greece and China seem to show that a major drought occurred in these two countries around AD 400; in 1876–1878, and in 1898– 1900, there were severe droughts simultaneously in Brazil, China, India and Ethiopia, causing dramatic faminesy. In 1998, following a strong El Nin˜o event, there were large deficits in the grain production in China and Indonesia. These two countries were able to import food from the world stocks, and no major consequences were felt, but the global food stocks fell to a very low level. It is w
See, for example, Les Eaux Continentales, coordinated by G. de Marsily, EDP Sciences, Paris, 2006; M. Griffon, Nourrir la Plane`te, Odile Jacob, Paris, 2006; International Water Management Institute, Water for Food, Water For Life: The Comprehensive Assessment of Water Management in Agriculture, Colombo, Sri Lanka, report to be published 2007. z Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Fourth Assessment Report, 2007. y See, for example, A. Sen and J. Dre`ze, Omnibus, Oxford University Press, New Delhi, 1999; M. Davis, Late Victorian Holocausts, El Nin˜o Famines and the Making of the Third World, Verso, London, 2001 (also available in French: Ge´nocides Tropicaux, La De´couverte, Paris, 2003 and 2006).
v
vi
Foreword
most likely that such events will occur again and severely affect water resources simultaneously across different continents. As emphasised by the Stern Report released on 30 October 2006z, taking action now to combat climate change is of utmost importance, if severe economical and social crises in the course of this century are to be avoided. But this applies also to the protection of the environment and the management of water resources, as shown, for example, by the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment Report8. This book addresses one of the central issues of these concerns: the science and policy of groundwater resource management. Groundwater is and will indeed be a major world resource for both irrigation and domestic use. Aquifers supply, in fact, about one-fourth of the flow of all the rivers in the world, about 90% of it in the low-flow season, about 75% of the drinking water supply in Europe, about 50% worldwide and a majority of the irrigation water in the world; aquifers are also the major natural means of storing water during wet years and make it available during droughts. Finally, almost 20% of the world freshwater reserves are contained in the aquifers, while surface waters only contribute 0.5%; the remaining 80% are the continental ice sheets, not readily usable. Managing and protecting our groundwater resources is thus a very urgent and important task. By contrast, aquifers, because they are not visible and their functioning in general poorly understood, are currently very poorly managed worldwide, or rather not managed at all, and often exploited at the highest possible level without a thought spared for their protection. In fact, very little time is left to learn how our aquifer systems operate, what their reserves are and how to protect and to manage them in order to be able to meet tomorrow’s challenges. This book is thus a timely contribution to this endeavour. With the 2000 Water Framework Directive**, the European Community took the lead in Europe in addressing the issue of re-establishing the ecological and chemical quality of our continental waters, and with the new daughter directive on groundwaterww, adopted on 12 December 2006, the European Community is again setting out the framework for the management of groundwater in Europe. Philippe Quevauviller, who was the leader at the European Commission for the development of the daughter directive on groundwater, was in an ideal position to assemble the necessary multidisciplinary team of specialists who have contributed to this book. Groundwater is indeed a topic that requires the interaction of many disciplines for its management: geologists, hydrologists, geochemists, geobiologists, agronomists and farming experts, health specialists, z
www.sternreview.org.uk. Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, Ecosystems and Human Well-being: Synthesis, Island Press, World Resources Institute, Washington, DC, 2005 (www.maweb.org). ** Directive 2000/60/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 October 2000 establishing a framework for Community action in the field of water policy, Official Journal of the European Communities, L 327, 22.12.2000. ww Directive 2006/118/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council on the protection of groundwater against pollution and deterioration, L 372, 12.12.2006. 8
Foreword
vii
economists, law-makers, social scientists, etc. About 70 such experts from 13 European countries have contributed to this book, with one author from the US Environmental Protection Agency giving some perspectives on groundwater protection in the USA. With eleven different sections, the book in a coordinated fashion covers most of the topics of importance in the management of groundwater, both from the technical side and the management aspect. Bringing together often opposite views of aquifer management, that of the scientist and that of the policy maker, is a rare achievement, for which the authors and the editor must be congratulated. Science–policy integration, regulatory frameworks and stakeholder involvement are covered at the same time as groundwater characterisation, monitoring, risk assessment, remediation, modelling and management at the basin scale. The book ends with a remarkable concluding section on further policy and research objectives that need to be addressed in the coming few years, in order to put Europe at the forefront of groundwater resource management, and to meet the social, economic and ecological challenges of our water supply in the 21st century. Ghislain de Marsily French Academy of Sciences and University Paris VI, Paris, France
Preface Having been educated in geosciences, it was somehow logical that my career path would, after 25 years, bring me back to a scientific sector which opened my eyes as a researcher. Even if my actual research activities primarily focused on environmental analytical developments and applications, and later on quality assurance matters, I never lost interest in geochemistry and geology, and this is certainly what decided me to move from science to policy when the Environment Directorate-General of the European Commission searched for an officer who would develop a new groundwater directive responding to the requirements of the Water Framework Directive (WFD) 2000/60/ECw. The new Groundwater Directive (2006/118/EC)z was adopted on 12 December 2006 and it opens a new era for groundwater protection. Policy developments are also flourishing in other parts of the world as illustrated by the new groundwater rules also adopted in December 2006 by the US Environmental Protection Agencyy, and the recently published FAO legislative study on groundwater in international lawz. These regulations obviously represent progress, but we should not overlook that groundwater data are still very scarce in comparison to data gathered in the surface water sector over the last 40 years. Groundwater is a ‘‘hidden’’ resource which has essentially been monitored in the light of its uses, mainly for human consumption, over the past decades. It is only recently that the environmental value of groundwater has been put forward as a key issue, and this has been reflected in the orientations of the European Union (EU) legislation. Much work, therefore, remains ahead of us to get a better appraisal of risks affecting the qualitative and quantitative status of groundwater, perform representative monitoring programmes and establish management plans that will enable measures to be identified and operated for the sake of prevention of deterioration and enhancement of groundwater quality and quantity. This is specifically the purpose of the WFD and its ‘‘daughter’’ Groundwater Directive. This implementation work, however, will only be efficient if it is backed up by the best of scientific and technological state-of-the-art. One would think, therefore, that it would then be natural that scientific experts work hand-inhand with policy-makers to identify the most appropriate tools and methods w
Official Journal of the European Communities, L 327, 20.12.2000, p. 1. Official Journal of the European Communities, L 372, 12.12.2006, p. 19. See Chapter 3.2 of this book. z FAO Legislative Study no. 86, 2005 (ISSN 1014-6679). z y
ix
x
Preface
that would best serve policy implementation. This is happening to a certain extent, but the situation to date is far from being satisfactory. In other words, the dialogue and interactions between the scientific and policy-making communities are not as straightforward as one could expect. In the sector of groundwater, a bridge between these two communities has developed within the last five years, and greatly contributed to EU policy design and development. It is now time to put sciences and technologies at the service of policy implementation, and this is reflected by the content of this RSC book Groundwater Science and Policy. This book has been written by internationally recognised experts who have gathered experiences in policy or research developments, in particular in the framework of projects funded by the EU Framework Programme for Research and Technological Developments. It represents a unique experience of operational links among the policy and science worlds. Philippe Quevauviller
Contents xxxiii
List of Contributors 1. General Introduction Chapter 1
General Introduction: The Need to Protect Groundwater Philippe Quevauviller 1.1 1.2
Introduction The Scientific Background 1.2.1 The Hydrogeological Cycle 1.2.2 Waters in Aquifers 1.2.3 Groundwater Flows 1.2.4 Groundwater Quality 1.3 Groundwater Deterioration Risks 1.3.1 Quantitative Aspects 1.3.2 Links to Associated Ecosystems 1.3.3 Groundwater Pollution 1.4 Groundwater Risk Assessment: Implications for Policy 1.4.1 Groundwater Protection Needs 1.4.2 Assessment, Prevention and Control 1.4.3 Monitoring 1.5 Conclusions References
3 4 4 5 6 6 7 7 9 10 13 13 14 16 18 18
2. Science–Policy Integration Needs Chapter 2.1 Science–Policy Integration for Common Approaches Linked to Groundwater Management in Europe Philippe Quevauviller 2.1.1
Introductory Remarks on Science–Policy Integration Needs
xi
21
xii
Contents
2.1.2
Science Integration in the Light of Groundwater Management 2.1.3 Examples of Projects in Support of Groundwater Policy 2.1.3.1 Risk Assessment 2.1.3.2 Groundwater Remediation 2.1.3.3 Diffuse Pollution 2.1.3.4 Management Issues and Information Tools 2.1.3.5 Relevant Networks 2.1.4 A Project ‘‘Tailor-Made’’ to Support the New EU Groundwater Directive: BRIDGE 2.1.5 Conclusions: Some Research Needs References
24 25 25 26 26 26 27 27 28 29
Chapter 2.2 Transferring Scientific Knowledge to Societal Use: Clue from the AQUATERRA Integrated Project Philippe Ne´grel, Dominique Darmendrail and Adriaan Slob 2.2.1 2.2.2 2.2.3
Introduction Overview of The AQUATERRA Project Environmental Policies 2.2.3.1 Four Generations of Environmental Policies 2.2.3.2 Science in the Four Generations of Environmental Policies 2.2.4 AQUATERRA Case Studies 2.2.4.1 The Ebro Case Study 2.2.4.2 The Meuse Case Study 2.2.5 Discussions of the Contributions of AQUATERRA to Societal Use Related to Groundwater Resources Management 2.2.5.1 Stakeholder Involvement 2.2.5.2 Learning Approaches in Policy-Making 2.2.6 Conclusions References Chapter 2.3
31 33 35 35 36 38 38 43
51 54 55 56 56
Groundwater Management and Planning: How Can Economics Help? Jean-Daniel Rinaudo and Pierre Strosser 2.3.1 2.3.2
Introduction Economic Methodologies and Tools: Four Possible Ways of Supporting Groundwater Management and Planning 2.3.2.1 Economic Characterisation of Water Uses
58
60 60
xiii
Contents
2.3.2.2 2.3.2.3
Methods to Assess Environmental Costs Economic Methods for Appraisal of Groundwater Projects and Policies: Cost-effectiveness and Cost–Benefit Analysis 2.3.2.4 Economic Behavioural Models 2.3.2.5 Selected Illustrations 2.3.3 Assessing and Simulating Current and Future Socio-Economic Impact of Groundwater Deterioration 2.3.4 Cost Effectiveness Analysis of Groundwater Protection Measures: Finding the Least Costly Way to Reduce Nitrate Pollution to Groundwater 2.3.5 Cost–Benefit Analysis of Groundwater Protection: Finding the Economically Optimal Level of Groundwater Protection 2.3.6 Integrating Economic and Groundwater Models for Simulating Nitrate Pollution in the Upper Rhine Valley Aquifer 2.3.7 Designing Economic Instruments for Groundwater Management 2.3.7.1 Environment Taxes and Charges 2.3.7.2 Tradable Groundwater Licences and Rights 2.3.8 Conclusions References
61
62 63 64
64
66
69
71 73 74 76 77 79
3. Groundwater Regulatory Framework Chapter 3.1 European Union Groundwater Policy Philippe Quevauviller 3.1.1 3.1.2 3.1.3 3.1.4 3.1.5 3.1.6 3.1.7
Introduction The 1980 Groundwater Policy Framework Preliminary Assessment (1982) The Groundwater Action Programme (1996) The Groundwater Policy Framework Under the WFD The New Groundwater Directive 2006/118/EC Policy Integration 3.1.7.1 Nitrates Directive 3.1.7.2 Urban Wastewater Treatment Directive 3.1.7.3 Plant Protection Products Directive 3.1.7.4 Biocides Directive 3.1.7.5 IPPC Directive 3.1.7.6 Landfill Directive 3.1.7.7 Sewage Sludge Directive 3.1.7.8 Other Directives
85 86 88 89 91 97 98 98 99 100 101 101 102 103 103
xiv
Contents
3.1.8 Conclusions: The Need for Worldwide Cooperation References
104 105
Chapter 3.2 US Drinking Water Regulation: The Ground Water Rule Crystal Rodgers-Jenkins 3.2.1 3.2.2 3.2.3
Introduction Federal Statutory Authority Challenges in Developing the GWR 3.2.3.1 US Groundwater System Demographics 3.2.3.2 Occurrence Data 3.2.3.3 Public Health Risks 3.2.4 The Risk-Targeted Approach 3.2.5 Conclusions Acknowledgements References
107 108 108 109 110 112 113 116 116 116
4. Stakeholder Interactions Chapter 4.1 Principles of the Common Implementation Strategy of the WFD: The Groundwater Woking Group Philippe Quevauviller, Johannes Grath and Andreas Scheidleder 4.1.1
The Need for Multi-stakeholder Involvement in the Environmental Policy Development and Implementation Process 4.1.2 The WFD Common Implementation Strategy 4.1.2.1 General Principles 4.1.2.2 Supporting Activity: The Pilot River Basin Network 4.1.3 The CIS Working Group on Groundwater 4.1.3.1 Objectives 4.1.3.2 Leadership and Network 4.1.3.3 Achievements from 2003 to 2006 4.1.3.4 Perspectives for 2007–2009 4.1.4 Perspectives References
121 122 122 123 123 123 124 124 125 127 127
Chapter 4.2 The Pilot River Basin Network: Examples of Groundwater-related Activities Lorenzo Galbiati and Giovanni Bidoglio 4.2.1 4.2.2
Introduction Science–Policy Integration in the PRB Exercise Linked to Groundwater Management
128 129
xv
Contents
4.2.3
Managing Groundwater Bodies in the Shannon PRB for the Implementation of the WFD 4.2.3.1 Groundwater Body Delineation 4.2.3.2 Groundwater Management for the WFD 4.2.3.3 Example of Risk Assessment Methodology for Diffuse Groundwater Pollution in the Shannon PRB 4.2.4 Groundwater Natural Background Levels and Threshold Definition in the Tevere PRBs Under the BRIDGE Project 4.2.4.1 Tevere PRB: The Colli Albani Case Study 4.2.4.2 Groundwater Status Evaluation by Threshold Values 4.2.4.3 Case Study of Salone-Acque Vergini System 4.2.4.4 Case Study of the Protected Area of Castelporziano 4.2.5 Conclusions References
130 131 131
131
133 134 135 136 136 140 141
Chapter 4.3 The Harmoni-CA Initiative Geo E. Arnold, Wim J. de Lange and Michiel W. Blind 4.3.1 4.3.2 4.3.3
Introduction The Harmoni-CA Initiative Process of Bridging the Gap Between Research and Policy/Water Management 4.3.3.1 Harmoni-CA Forums and Conferences 4.3.3.2 CatchMod/Harmoni-CA Workshops 4.3.3.3 Conclusions and Lessons Learned from the Conferences and Workshops 4.3.4 Products/Tools of Harmoni-CA 4.3.4.1 WISE-RTD Web Portal 4.3.4.2 Guidance Documents, Synthesis Reports and Summaries 4.3.5 SPI-Water 4.3.6 Groundwater Directive References
142 143 143 144 145 145 146 146 147 148 149 149
Chapter 4.4 Linking Public Participation to Adaptive Management Claudia Pahl-Wostl, Jens Newig and Dagmar Ridder 4.4.1 4.4.2 4.4.3
Introduction Adaptive Management and Public Participation Rationales and Requirements for Effective Participation in Groundwater Management
150 151 155
xvi
Contents
4.4.3.1
Rationales and Goals for Public Participation 4.4.3.2 Public Participation Provisions in the WFD 4.4.3.3 German Experiences with Public Participation 4.4.3.4 Example: Regional Participation in Groundwater Protection from Agricultural Nitrate 4.4.4 Social Learning in Public Participation: Support for Adaptive Management 4.4.4.1 Appropriate Framing Conditions 4.4.4.2 Well-Designed Process Management 4.4.4.3 Well-Selected Methods and Tools 4.4.4.4 Leadership Issues 4.4.4.5 An Example of Participation-based Measures in Groundwater Management 4.4.5 Conclusions References
155 157 158
159 161 162 163 164 165 167 169 170
5. Groundwater Characterization and Risk Assessment Chapter 5.1 Groundwater Characterization and Risk Assessment in the Context of the EU Water Framework Directive Andreas Scheidleder, Johannes Grath and Philippe Quevauviller 5.1.1 5.1.2 5.1.3 5.1.4 5.1.5
5.1.6 5.1.7 5.1.8 5.1.9
5.1.10
Legal Background Groundwater Body Identification and Delineation Initial Characterisation Further Characterisation Additional Requirements of the WFD 5.1.5.1 Transboundary Groundwater Bodies 5.1.5.2 Groundwater Bodies with Lower Objectives 5.1.5.3 Interaction with Aquatic and Terrestrial Ecosystems Conceptual Model/Understanding Identification of Driving Forces and Pressures Identification of Significant Pressures Assessing the Impacts of Pressures 5.1.9.1 Tools to Assist 5.1.9.2 Scaling Issues Evaluating the Likelihood of Failing to Meet the Objectives
177 180 182 183 184 184 184 184 184 186 187 188 188 189 190
xvii
Contents
5.1.11 Reporting on the Characterisation and Risk Assessment References
191 192
Chapter 5.2 Groundwater Quality Background Levels Emilio Custodio and Marisol Manzano 5.2.1 5.2.2
Introduction Rationale to Establish the Groundwater Quality Baseline 5.2.3 Methods to Establish the Natural Baseline Quality of Groundwater 5.2.3.1 Study of Major and Trace Inorganic Component Chemistry 5.2.3.2 Organic Component Chemistry 5.2.3.3 Hydrogeochemical Modelling 5.2.3.4 Tracers and Temporal Scales 5.2.3.5 Study of Natural Baseline Trends 5.2.4 Conclusions Acknowledgements References
193 195 198 200 202 206 208 211 214 215 215
Chapter 5.3 Groundwater Age and Quality Klaus Hinsby, Roland Purtschert and W. Mike Edmunds 5.3.1 5.3.2
Introduction Groundwater Age Estimation 5.3.2.1 The Definition of Groundwater Age 5.3.2.2 Environmental Tracers for Absolute Age Estimation 5.3.2.3 Geoindicators: Estimating Environmental Change and Relative Ages 5.3.2.4 Numerical Modelling of Groundwater Age 5.3.3 Groundwater Age and Water Quality and Quantity Issues 5.3.3.1 Groundwater Quality as a Function of Age 5.3.3.2 Groundwater Age and Monitoring 5.3.3.3 Groundwater Age and Water (Over)exploitation 5.3.4 Groundwater Age and the Water Framework and Groundwater Directives 5.3.4.1 Groundwater Age and Derivation of Natural Background Levels and Threshold Values
217 219 219 219 223 225 226 226 227 228 228
228
xviii
Contents
5.3.4.2
Groundwater Interaction with Dependent Ecosystems 5.3.5 Case Studies 5.3.5.1 Examples of Danish Case Studies 5.3.5.2 Examples of Swiss and German Case Studies 5.3.5.3 Example of a British Case Study 5.3.6 Conclusions References
228 229 229 231 234 235 236
Chapter 5.4 Characterisation of Groundwater Contamination and Natural Attenuation Potential at Multiple Scales Thomas Ptak and Jerker Jarsjo¨ 5.4.1 5.4.2
Introduction The Integral Groundwater Investigation Method 5.4.2.1 Concepts and Principles 5.4.2.2 The Inversion Problem 5.4.2.3 Application of the Integral Investigation Method 5.4.3 Methodology to Consider Aquifer Parameter Uncertainty and to Delimit Contaminant Source Zones Using Integral Measurements 5.4.3.1 Principles 5.4.3.2 Decision Tree Approach 5.4.3.3 Example of Application at an Industrial Site 5.4.4 Quantification of Natural Attenuation Rates Using Integral Measurements 5.4.4.1 Principles 5.4.4.2 Example of Application at a Former Gasworks Site 5.4.5 Multilevel Integral Investigation of Contamination 5.4.5.1 The Multilevel Integral Investigation Method 5.4.5.2 Example of Application 5.4.6 Conclusions Acknowledgements References
240 241 242 244 247
249 249 255 258 259 259 260 262 262 263 265 266 267
xix
Contents
Chapter 5.5 Improved Risk Assessment of Contaminant Spreading in Fractured Underground Reservoirs Christos D. Tsakiroglou 5.5.1
Introduction 5.5.1.1 Literature Review 5.5.2 Objectives and Approach of the TRACE-Fracture Project 5.5.3 Description of Ringe Site 5.5.3.1 Conceptual Fracture Network Model 5.5.4 Hierarchical Methods for the Determination of Transport Properties 5.5.4.1 Multiphase Transport Coefficients of Single Fractures and Fracture Networks 5.5.5 Numerical Modelling of NAPL Fate in Unsaturated and Saturated Zones 5.5.6 Risk Assessment of Contaminated Sites 5.5.6.1 Site Remediation 5.5.6.2 In Situ Stimulation/Remediation of Contaminated Sites 5.5.7 Socioeconomic Relevance and Policy Implications Acknowledgements References
269 270 271 272 273 275 275 278 281 282 286 287 288 289
Chapter 5.6 Groundwater Risk Assessment at Contaminated Sites (GRACOS): Test Methods and Modelling Approaches Peter Grathwohl and Hans van der Sloot 5.6.1 5.6.2
Introduction Leaching Tests (Heavy Metals, Low-Volatility Organic Compounds) 5.6.2.1 Total Composition vs. Aqueous Concentrations 5.6.2.2 Percolation vs. Batch or Shaking Tests: Comparison to Field 5.6.2.3 Boundary Conditions Leading to Changing Release Rates 5.6.2.4 Release Kinetics 5.6.2.5 Column Tests: Standardisation and Design 5.6.2.6 Concluding Remarks for Leaching Tests 5.6.3 Groundwater Risk Assessment for Volatile Compounds 5.6.3.1 Vapour-phase Diffusion
291 293 293 294 299 299 302 304 305 305
xx
Contents
5.6.3.2
Coupled Models for Simulation of Field Sites 5.6.3.3 Concluding Remarks for Risk Assessment for Volatile Compounds 5.6.4 Modelling for Groundwater Risk Assessment of Inorganic Constituents 5.6.5 Conclusions/Recommendations Acknowledgement References
306 307 309 312 313 313
Chapter 5.7 INCORE: Integrated Concept for Groundwater Remediation Thomas Ertel and Hermann J. Kirchholtes 5.7.1 5.7.2 5.7.3
Motivation and Basic Concept Cycle I: Plume Screening Cycle II: Source Identification 5.7.3.1 GC-MS Fingerprinting for Petroleum Hydrocarbons 5.7.3.2 Isotopic Fingerprinting for Chlorinated Hydrocarbons 5.7.4 Cycle III: Remediation Strategy 5.7.4.1 Remediation Scenarios 5.7.4.2 ISIRE: In situ Remediation Technologies— Decision Support 5.7.5 Implementation 5.7.5.1 Administrative Aspects 5.7.5.2 Cost Considerations 5.7.5.3 Implementation in Projects References
316 319 320 320 329 333 333 335 337 337 337 340 340
6. Groundwater Monitoring Chapter 6.1 Groundwater Monitoring in the Policy Context Johannes Grath, Rob Ward and Andreas Scheidleder 6.1.1 6.1.2
Introduction Monitoring Requirements: Legal Background and Objectives 6.1.3 General Principles 6.1.3.1 Conceptual Model 6.1.3.2 Three-dimensional Characteristics and Variability 6.1.3.3 Aquifer Types 6.1.4 Chemical Status and Trend Monitoring
345 347 349 349 349 351 352
xxi
Contents
6.1.4.1 Overall Objectives 6.1.4.2 Surveillance Monitoring Programme 6.1.4.3 Operational Monitoring Programme 6.1.4.4 Selection of Representative Monitoring Sites 6.1.4.5 Selection of Monitoring Determinands 6.1.4.6 Monitoring Frequency 6.1.5 Quantity (Water Level) Monitoring 6.1.5.1 Overall Objective 6.1.5.2 Monitoring Parameters 6.1.5.3 Selection of Monitoring Density 6.1.5.4 Monitoring Frequency 6.1.6 Review and Update References
352 352 353 353 356 356 359 359 360 361 361 362 362
Chapter 6.2 Screening Methods for Groundwater Monitoring Catherine Gonzalez, Anne-Marie Fouillac and Richard Greenwood 6.2.1
Groundwater Monitoring Requirements and Specific Issues 6.2.2 Environmental Variability: Spatial and Temporal Groundwater Quality Variability 6.2.3 Screening Methods Towards Groundwater Monitoring Needs 6.2.3.1 Common Physicochemical Methods used for Groundwater Assessment 6.2.3.2 Emerging Screening Tools 6.2.3.3 Potential Uses of Emerging Tools 6.2.4 Screening Methods and Priority Substances 6.2.5 New Trends and Perspectives References
363 366 368 368 369 371 374 375 376
Chapter 6.3 Quality Assurance for Groundwater Monitoring Philippe Quevauviller and Ste´phane Roy 6.3.1 6.3.2 6.3.3 6.3.4 6.3.5
Need for Quality Assurance for Groundwater Analysis Within-Laboratory Quality Measures Statistical Control Comparison of Analytical Methods Interlaboratory Studies 6.3.5.1 Introduction 6.3.5.2 Scope of the Groundwater Interlaboratory Programme
378 379 379 380 380 380 381
xxii
Contents
6.3.6
Certified Reference Materials 6.3.6.1 General Principles 6.3.6.2 CRMs for Major Elements in Groundwater 6.3.6.3 CRMs for Trace Elements in Groundwater 6.3.6.4 CRMs for Bromide in Groundwater 6.3.6.5 Conclusions: Availability of Water CRMs 6.3.7 Assessment of Uncertainty Linked to Groundwater Sampling. A Case Study: The METREAU Project 6.3.7.1 Introduction 6.3.7.2 Groundwater Sampling: New Devices 6.3.7.3 Uncertainties Associated with the Sampling Stage 6.3.7.4 Conclusions Acknowledgements References
383 383 384 387 390 391 392 392 393 397 399 400 401
7. Groundwater Pollution Prevention and Remediation Chapter 7.1 Prevention and Reduction of Groundwater Pollution at Contaminated Megasites: Integrated Management Strategy and its Application on Megasite Cases Jeroen Ter Meer, Hans Van Duijne, Rob Nieuwenhuis and Huub Rijnaarts 7.1.1
Addressing Groundwater on Large (Former) Industrial Sites 7.1.2 Risk-based Approach for Contaminated Megasites 7.1.2.1 Integrated Management Strategy 7.1.2.2 Megasite Objectives 7.1.2.3 Concept for Megasites 7.1.2.4 Megasite Categories 7.1.2.5 Modelling and Monitoring 7.1.2.6 Risk Management Scenarios 7.1.3 Relevance of Risk-based Management of Megasites for the Groundwater Directive 7.1.3.1 Case Studies 7.1.4 Conclusions References
405 406 406 407 407 408 410 410 412 412 420 420
Chapter 7.2 Forecasting Natural Attenuation as a Risk-based Groundwater Remediation Strategy Ryan D. Wilson, Steven F. Thornton and David N. Lerner 7.2.1
The Nature of Groundwater Pollution from Point Sources
421
xxiii
Contents
7.2.1.1 7.2.1.2 7.2.1.3 7.2.2 Natural 7.2.2.1 7.2.2.2 7.2.2.3 7.2.2.4 7.2.2.5 7.2.3 Current 7.2.3.1
Sources and Plumes Risk Assessment: Is Clean-up Required? Options for Remediation Attenuation of Contaminants Why Natural Attenuation is Important Contributing Processes Plume Development and Life Phases Biodegradation in Detail Hydrogeology and Heterogeneity Natural Attenuation Assessment Practices Establishing Whether Natural Attenuation is Occurring 7.2.3.2 Establishing Whether Natural Attenuation is Sufficient 7.2.3.3 Steps in Natural Attenuation Assessment 7.2.4 CORONA: A New Natural Attenuation Assessment Philosophy 7.2.4.1 Core and Fringe Controlled Plumes 7.2.4.2 Preferred CORONA Site Instrumentation 7.2.4.3 CoronaScreen Models 7.2.4.4 Output Goals 7.2.4.5 Model Descriptions 7.2.5 Recommendations Acknowledgements References
421 422 423 424 424 424 427 429 432 433 435 437 439 442 442 443 443 444 446 450 451 451
Chapter 7.3 Diffuse Groundwater Quality Impacts from Agricultural Land-use: Management and Policy Implications of Scientific Realities Stephen Foster and Lucila Candela 7.3.1
7.3.2 7.3.3 7.3.4 7.3.5
Why is Agricultural Land-use the Greatest Challenge Facing the New EC Water Directives? 7.3.1.1 How Does Agricultural Land-use Impact on Groundwater Quality? 7.3.1.2 Are All Types of Groundwater Body Equally Threatened by Agricultural Practices? 7.3.1.3 What can be Done to Make Agricultural Cropping more ‘‘Groundwater Friendly’’? Guidelines on ‘‘Best Agricultural Practice’’ Reducing Overall Cultivation Intensity Constraints on Pesticide Manufacture, Sale or Use Improving Irrigation Water Use Efficiency 7.3.5.1 What are the Main Policy Implications for Groundwater Body Quality Protection?
454 457 460 462 462 463 464 465 466
xxiv
Contents
Acknowledgements References
469 469
8. Integrated River Basin Management Chapter 8.1 Integrated Management Principles for Groundwater in the WFD Context Philippe Quevauviller 8.1.1 8.1.2
Introduction Challenges Linked to Groundwater Management 8.1.3 River Basin Management Principles 8.1.3.1 Water and Its Environment 8.1.3.2 River Basin Management Objectives 8.1.4 Operational Management 8.1.4.1 Pollution Control 8.1.4.2 Voluntary Agreements 8.1.4.3 Cost Recovery 8.1.4.4 Institutional Structure 8.1.4.5 Infrastructure vs. Regulation, Financing and Empowerment 8.1.4.6 Decentralisation 8.1.4.7 Privatisation 8.1.5 Planning 8.1.5.1 Functions of Plans and Policies 8.1.5.2 The Planning Process 8.1.5.3 Planning Systems 8.1.6 Analytical Support 8.1.6.1 Analytical Support for Operational Management: Main Challenges 8.1.6.2 Analytical Support and the Strategic Level: New Directions 8.1.7 International River Basins 8.1.7.1 The Challenge 8.1.7.2 International Basins at the Global Level 8.1.7.3 International River Basin Organisations 8.1.7.4 Interbasin Co-operation (Twinning) 8.1.8 Public Participation 8.1.8.1 At European Level 8.1.8.2 At International Level 8.1.9 Conclusions References
473 474 475 475 476 476 477 478 479 479 480 481 481 482 482 482 483 483 485 486 487 487 488 488 489 489 489 491 491 492
xxv
Contents
Chapter 8.2 System Approach to Environmentally Acceptable Farming Ramon Laplana and Nadine Turpin 8.2.1 8.2.2
Introduction Integrated River Basin Management with BMPs to Mitigate NPS Pollution 8.2.2.1 What are Best Management Practices? 8.2.2.2 BMP Typology 8.2.2.3 How to Design Acceptable BMPs ? 8.2.3 How to Build a Cost-effectiveness Grid of Bundles of BMPs 8.2.3.1 Effectiveness Assessment 8.2.3.2 Implementation Costs 8.2.3.3 Building of the Comparison Grid 8.2.4 Conclusions References
494 495 495 497 497 502 502 505 507 508 509
Chapter 8.3 WATCH. Water Catchment Areas: Tools for Management and Control of Hazardous Compounds Thomas Track, Steve Setford, Sharon Huntley, Claudine Vermot-Desroches, John Wijdenes, Damia Barcelo´, Monica Rosell Linares, Peter Werner, Jens Fahl, Hans-Peter Rohns, Claudia Forner, Jesper Holm, Douglas Graham, Eckard Hitsch and Josef Lintschinger 8.3.1 8.3.2
8.3.3
8.3.4
8.3.5
8.3.6
Introduction Near-infrared Fuel Leak Sensor 8.3.2.1 Description of Results 8.3.2.2 Conclusion and Perspectives Analysis of MTBE and Related Compounds in Soil and Groundwater 8.3.3.1 Description of Results 8.3.3.2 Conclusions and Perspectives Immunoassay for Field-based Determination of MTBE 8.3.4.1 Description of Results 8.3.4.2 Conclusion and Perspectives Elucidation of Stimulating and Inhibiting Effects on Biodegradation 8.3.5.1 Description of Results 8.3.5.2 Conclusions and Perspectives Development of an Early Warning and Management System for Groundwater Resources
511 513 514 516 517 517 519 519 520 523 524 525 527 528
xxvi
Contents
8.3.6.1 Description of Results 8.3.6.2 Conclusions and Perspectives Acknowledgement and Further Information
528 531 532
9. Groundwater Status Assessment Chapter 9.1 Methodology for the Establishment of Groundwater Environmental Quality Standards Dietmar Mu¨ller and Anne-Marie Fouillac 9.1.1
Introductory Remarks on Science–Policy Integration Needs 9.1.2 Towards an Integrated Management of Groundwater Resources 9.1.3 The Framework: An Integrated Characterisation Process 9.1.4 Criteria to Assess Quality and Status of Groundwater 9.1.4.1 Natural Background Levels 9.1.4.2 Generic Reference Values 9.1.4.3 Attenuation Criteria 9.1.5 Receptor-oriented Quality Standards Derived by a Tiered Approach 9.1.6 How to Determine a Threshold Value (Example: Surface Water) 9.1.7 Compliance Regime for Groundwater Quality Standards 9.1.8 Conclusions Acknowledgement References
535 536 536 537 538 538 540 541 541 543 543 544 544
Chapter 9.2 Pesticides in European Groundwaters: Biogeochemical Processes, Contamination Status and Results from a Case Study Christophe Mouvet 9.2.1 9.2.2
Introduction Major Processes Involved in the Transport of Pesticides from the Soil to and in Groundwater 9.2.2.1 Sorption and Degradation 9.2.2.2 Biodegradation in Microcosms with Solids from the Unsaturated Zone Below the Root Zone 9.2.2.3 Sorption on Solids from the Unsaturated Zone
545 546 547
548 550
xxvii
Contents
9.2.2.4
Biodegradation in Microcosms with Solids and Water from the Saturated Zone 9.2.2.5 Sorption on Solids from the Saturated Zone 9.2.2.6 Field Studies Involving both Sorption and Biodegradation 9.2.2.7 Synthesis of Published Results on Sorption and Biodegradation below the Root Zone 9.2.3 Status of Groundwater Contamination by Pesticides at European Scale 9.2.3.1 The Waterbase Data Base of the European Environment Agency, June 2006 9.2.3.2 The Indicator Fact Sheet of the European Environment Agency 9.2.4 Status of Groundwater Contamination by Pesticides in Selected European Countries or Regions 9.2.4.1 Status in Italy (Adapted from Refs. 60 and 61) 9.2.4.2 Status in Wallony (Belgium) 9.2.4.3 Status in Sweden 9.2.4.4 Status in France 9.2.4.5 Status in the UK 9.2.4.6 Synthesis of the Data at National and Regional Scales 9.2.5 A Case Study: The Bre´villes Spring 9.2.5.1 Brief Description of the System and the Methods Used 9.2.5.2 Main Results from the Piezometer Network 9.2.5.3 Main Results from the Monitoring of the Spring 9.2.5.4 Conclusions from the Bre´villes Case Study 9.2.6 Conclusions and Perspectives Acknowledgements References
550 553 553 555 555 555 558 559 559 561 564 565 568 570 570 571 572 573 576 576 579 579
Chapter 9.3 Evaluation of the Quantitative Status of Groundwater– Surface Water Interaction at a National Scale Hans Jørgen Henriksen, Lars Troldborg, Per Nyegaard, Anker L. Højberg, Torben O. Sonnenborg and Jens Christian Refsgaard 9.3.1 9.3.2
Introduction The National Water Resource Model (DK Model) 9.3.2.1 Conceptual Model 9.3.2.2 Processes and Data 9.3.2.3 Model Code
584 587 587 587 589
xxviii
Contents
9.3.2.4 Model Parameterisation and Calibration 9.3.2.5 Model Validation 9.3.2.6 A Few Examples of Model Results 9.3.3 Criteria for Sustainable Groundwater Abstraction 9.3.4 Model Results 9.3.5 Discussion and Conclusions 9.3.5.1 Appropriateness of Approach for the WFD 9.3.5.2 Linking the Modelling Approach with Monitoring 9.3.5.3 Strengths and Weaknesses of Approach 9.3.5.4 Novelty of this Work Acknowledgements References
589 591 591 592 596 600 600 601 602 604 604 604
10. Modelling Chapter 10.1 Conceptual Models in River Basin Management Antony Chapman, Jos Brils, Erik Ansink, Ce´cile Herivaux and Pierre Strosser 10.1.1 Introduction 10.1.2 Integrated Water Resource Management 10.1.3 Conceptual Models in the Context of River Basin Management 10.1.3.1 What are Conceptual Models? 10.1.3.2 What Role can Conceptual Models Play? 10.1.3.3 From Conceptual Models to Quantitative/Computer-based Models 10.1.4 Building Conceptual Models in the Context of River Basin Management: Some Principles 10.1.4.1 The DPSIR Framework as a Guide 10.1.4.2 Investigating the Dynamics of River Basin Systems 10.1.4.3 Stakeholder Integration and Response 10.1.5 Experience from the Aqua terra Research Project 10.1.5.1 Context and Objectives 10.1.5.2 Identifying the Main Environmental Issues Relevant to the Case Studies 10.1.5.3 Integrating Stakeholders’ Views 10.1.5.4 Developing Simplified Representations of the Systems Investigated 10.1.5.5 Preliminary Lessons from the Experience of INTEGRATOR 10.1.6 Conclusions
611 612 613 613 614 615 617 617 618 619 620 620 621 622 622 624 625
xxix
Contents
Acknowledgements References
626 626
Chapter 10.2 Modelling Reactive Transport of Diffuse Contaminants: Identifying the Groundwater Contribution to Surface Water Quality Hans Peter Broers, Bas van der Grift, Jasper Griffioen and Ruth Heerdink 10.2.1 10.2.2 10.2.3 10.2.4
Introduction Framing a Conceptual Model Building a Regional Model for the Kempen Area Verifying the Model: Setting up a Customised Monitoring System 10.2.5 Predictions of Groundwater Contributions to Surface Water Quality 10.2.5.1 Discussion 10.2.5.2 Policy Aspects 10.2.6 Conclusions Acknowledgement References
630 631 634 637 640 641 642 643 643 643
11. Conclusions: Further Policy and Research Needs Chapter 11.1 SNOWMAN: An Alternative for Transnational Research Funding Jo¨rg Frauenstein and H. Johan Van Veen 11.1.1 Introduction 11.1.1.1 Transnational Research 11.1.1.2 Soil and Groundwater Management 11.1.1.3 Forerunning Projects and Significant Scientific Input 11.1.2 An ERA-NET Bridging the Gap Between National and European Research 11.1.3 The Way Forward 11.1.3.1 The Meaning of Cooperation 11.1.3.2 A Stepwise Approach Towards Cooperation 11.1.4 The Upcoming Coordinated Call 11.1.4.1 Objectives and Projects 11.1.4.2 The Principles of the Coordinated Call 11.1.5 Conclusions Acknowledgements References
647 647 649 651 654 654 654 657 662 663 664 668 669 670
xxx
Contents
Chapter 11.2 Incorporation of Groundwater Ecology in Environmental Policy Dan L. Danielopol, Christian Griebler, Amara Gunatilaka, Hans Ju¨rgen Hahn, Janine Gibert, F. Mermillod-Blondin, Giuseppe Messana, Jos Notenboom and Boris Sket 11.2.1 Introduction: Groundwater Science and the New Order 11.2.2 The New Groundwater Ecology: Its Interest for Water Management Projects and/or Water Policy Planners 11.2.3 The Groundwater Ecosystem Approach as a Framework for Planning Pollution Prevention and/ or Environmental Protection Strategies 11.2.4 Diversity of Groundwater Habitats and Organisms: Their Usefulness for Environmental Monitoring Programmes 11.2.5 Groundwater-Dependent Ecosystems: A Holistic Representation 11.2.6 Overview: The Expanded Order (Achievements and Future Needs) Acknowledgements References
671
672
674
680 683 684 686 686
Chapter 11.3 Towards a Science–Policy Interface (WISE-RTD) in Support of Groundwater Management Philippe Quevauviller 11.3.1 Introduction 11.3.1.1 General Needs 11.3.1.2 Different Levels of Interactions 11.3.2 Introduction to WISE 11.3.2.1 What is WISE? 11.3.2.2 Why do we Need WISE? 11.3.2.3 What is the Objective of the WISE Process? 11.3.2.4 Does WISE Already Exist? 11.3.2.5 Who will Use WISE? 11.3.2.6 What will WISE be Used for? 11.3.2.7 What are the Next Steps in WISE Development? 11.3.3 EU RTD Funding Mechanisms 11.3.3.1 FP5 Research Projects 11.3.3.2 FP6 Targeted Research and Integrated Projects
690 691 691 693 693 694 694 695 695 696 697 697 697 698
xxxi
Contents
11.3.3.3 FP6 ERA-NET Projects 11.3.3.4 Projects Issued from the Scientific Support to Policies (SSP) Priority 11.3.3.5 Orientations of the 7th Framework Programme 11.3.3.6 LIFE: Demonstration Projects 11.3.4 An Operational Web Interface: WISE-RTD 11.3.4.1 The Harmoni-CA Initiative 11.3.4.2 The WISE-RTD Web Portal 11.3.5 Conclusions: Needs for an Overall Science–Policy Integration Framework References
698
Appendix I Outline of Water Framework Directive Appendix II Outline of Groundwater Directive
704 711
699 699 700 700 700 701 701 703
Appendices
Subject Index
716
Contributors List BLIND Michiel W. RIZA P.O. Box 17 NL-8200 AA Lelystad The Netherlands Email:
[email protected]
ANSINK Erik Wageningen University Environmental Economics and Natural Resources Group P.O. Box 8130 NL-6700 EW Wageningen The Netherlands Email:
[email protected]
BRILS Jos Netherlands Organisation for Applied Scientific Research (TNO) Built Environment and Geosciences Business Unit Groundwater and Soil P.O. Box 80015 NL-3508 TA Utrecht The Netherlands Email:
[email protected]
ARNOLD Geo E. RIZA P.O. Box 17 NL-8200 AA Lelystad The Netherlands Email:
[email protected]. nl BARCELO´ Damia Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Cientı´ ficas Instituto de Investigaciones Quı´ micas y Ambieltales de Barcelona Dept. de Quı´ mica Ambiental Jordi Girona, 18-26 E-08034 Barcelona Spain Email:
[email protected] BIDOGLIO Giovanni European Commission, Joint Research Centre, Via E. Fermi l, TP 460 IT-21020 Ispra (VA) Italy Email:
[email protected]
BROERS Hans Peter Netherlands Organisation for Applied Scientific Research (TNO) Geological Survey of The Netherlands Princetonlaan 6 P.O. Box 80015 NL-3508 TA Utrecht The Netherlands Email:
[email protected] CANDELA Lucila Technical University of Catalonia Dept. of Geotechnical Engineering & Geoscience Gran Capita`, s/n Ed. D-2 ES-08034 Barcelona Spain Email:
[email protected]
xxxiii
xxxiv
CHAPMAN Antony r3 Environmental Technology Ltd c/o School of Horticulture and Landscape University of Reading TOB2, Earley Gate, Whiteknights Reading RG6 6AU United Kingdom Email:
[email protected] CUSTODIO Emilio Technical University of Catalonia Dept. of Geotechnical Engineering Gran Capita`, s/n Ed. D-2 ES-08034 Barcelona Spain Email:
[email protected] DANIELOPOL Dan L. Austrian Academy of Sciences Institute of Limnology Mondsee str. 9 AT-5310 Mondsee Austria Email:
[email protected] DARMENDRAIL Dominique Bureau de Recherches Ge´ologiques et Minie`res (BRGM) 3, avenue Claude Guillemin FR-45060 Orl!ans c!dex 2 France Email:
[email protected] DE LANGE Wim J. RIZA P.O. Box 17 NL-8200 AA Lelystad The Netherlands Email:
[email protected]. nl
Contributors List
EDMUNDS W. Mike Oxford Centre for Water Research Oxford University Centre for the Environment South Parks Road Oxford 0X1 3QY United Kingdom Email:
[email protected]
ERTEL Thomas Sachversta¨ndigen-Bu¨ro Boschstr. 10 DE-73734 Esslingen Germany Email: thomas@sv-ertel de
FAHL Jens University of Technology Dresden Institute of Waste Management and Contaminated Site Treatment Pratzschwitzer Str. 15 D-01796 Pirna Germany Email:
[email protected]. de
FOSTER Stephen IAH President Int. Association of Hydrogeologists P.O. Box 9 Kenilworth (Warwick) CV8 1JG United Kingdom Email:
[email protected]
FORNER Claudia Stadtwerke Du¨sseldorf AG Quality Control Water Wiedfeld 50 D-40589 Du¨sseldorf Germany
xxxv
Contributors List
FOUILLAC Anne-Marie Bureau de Recherches Ge´ologiques et Minie`res (BRGM) 3 avenue Claude Guillemin FR-45060 Orle´ans ce´dex 2 France Email:
[email protected] FRAUENSTEIN Jo¨rg Federal Environmental Agency Dessau Unit II 4.3 Terrestrial Ecology, Land Management, Regional Protection Concepts Wo¨rlitzer Platz 1, 06844 Dessau P.O. Box 1406 DE-06813 Dessau Germany Email:
[email protected] GALBIATI Lorenzo Age`ncia Catalana de l’Aigua Provenc¸a, 204-208 ES-08036 Barcelona Spain Email:
[email protected] GIBERT Janine Universite´ Claude Bernard Lyonl UMR CNRS 5023 EHF Equipe d’Hydrobiologie et Ecologie Souterraines. Baˆt FOREL 43 Bd 11/11/1918 FR-69622 Villeurbanne cedex France Email:
[email protected] GONZALEZ Catherine Ecole des Mines d’Ale`s 6 avenue de Clavie`res FR-30319 Ale`s Cedex France Email:
[email protected]
GRAHAM Douglas DHI–Water and Environment DK-2970 Horsholm Denmark Email:
[email protected]
GRATH Johannes Umweltbundesamt GmbH Spittelauer Laende 5 AT-1090 Wien Austria Email: Johannes.grath@ umweltbundesamt.at
GRATHWOHL Peter Centre for Applied Geoscience Universita¨t Tu¨bingen Sigwartstrasse 10 DE-72076 Tu¨bingen Germany Emai1:
[email protected]
GREENWOOD Richard School of Biological Sciences University of Portsmouth King Henri Building King Henri I Street UK-Portsmouth PO1 2DY United Kingdom
GRIEBLER Christian GSF-National Research Center for Environmental and Health Institute of Groundwater Ecology Ingolsta¨dter Landstrasse 1 DE-85764 Neuherberg/Mu¨nchen Germany Email:
[email protected]
xxxvi
GRIFFIOEN Jasper Netherlands Organisation for Applied Scientific Research (TNO) Geological Survey of The Netherlands Princetonlaan 6 P.O. Box 80015 NL-3508 TA Utrecht The Netherlands Email: jasper.griffi
[email protected]
GUNATILAKA Amara Department of Ecotoxicology Center for Public Health Medical University of Vienna Wa`hringer Strarse 10 A-1090 Vienna Austria Emai1: amarasinha.gunatilaka@ verbundplan.at
HAHN Hans Ju¨rgen Arbeitsgruppe Grundwassero¨kologie Universita¨t Koblenz-Landau, Campus Landau Abt. Biologie Im Fort 7, D-76829 Landau Germany Email:
[email protected]
HEERDINK Ruth Netherlands Organisation for Applied Scientific Research (TNO) Geological Survey of The Netherlands Princetonlaan 6 P.O. Box 80015 NL-3508 TA Utrecht The Netherlands Email:
[email protected]
Contributors List
HENRIKSEN Hans Jørgen Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland GEUS Øster Voldgade 10 DK-1350 Copenhagen K Denmark Email:
[email protected] HERIVAUX Ce´cile BRGM Water Department 3 avenue Claude Guillemin BP 36009 FR-45060 Orle´ans cedex France Email:
[email protected] HINSBY Klaus Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland, GEUS Øster Voldgade 10 DK-1350 Copenhagen K Denmark Email:
[email protected] HITSCH Eckard Salzburg AG Centre Wasser Hagenau 1 A-5101 Bergheim Austria HØJBERG Anker L. Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland GEUS Øster Voldgade 10 DK-1350 Copenhagen K Denmark Email:
[email protected] HOLM Jesper DHI – Water and Environment DK-2970 Horsholm Denmark Email:
[email protected]
xxxvii
Contributors List
HUNTLEY, Sharon Cranfield Centre for Analytical Science Cranfield University Silsoe Bedforshire MK45 4DT United Kingdom Email: s.l.huntley@cranfield.ac.uk
LINTSCHINGER Josef Salzburg AG Centre Wasser Hagenau 1 A-5101 Bergheim Austria Email: josef.lintschinger@ salzburg-ag.at
JARSJO¨ Jerker Stockholm University Dept. of Physical Geography and Quaternary Geology SE-106 91 Stockholm Sweden Emai1:
[email protected]
MANZANO Marisol Technical University of Cartagena Paseo Alfonso XIII, 52 ES-30203 Cartagena Spain Email:
[email protected]
KIRCHHOLTES Hermann J. Landeshauptstadt Stuttgart Amt fu¨r Umweltschutz Hermann Josef Kirchholtes 36-3.51 Gaisburgstr. 4 DE-70182 Stuttgart Germany Emai1:
[email protected]
F. MERMILLOD – BLONDIN Universite´ Claude Bernard Lyou 1 UMR CNRS 5023 EHF Equipe d’Hydrobiologie et Ecologie Souterraines Ba´t FOREL 43 Bd 11/11/1998 FR-69622 Villerubanne Cedex France
LAPLANA Ramon CEMAGREF Unite´ Ader 50 avenue de Verdun FR-33612 Cestas France Emai1: ramon.laplana@cemagref. fr LERNER David N. Groundwater Protection and Restoration Group University of Sheffield Kroto Research Institute Broad Lane Sheffield S3 7HQ United Kingdom Emai1: d.n.lerner@sheffield.ac.uk
MESSANA Giuseppe Istituto per lo Studio degli Ecosistemi CNR – ISE, Sede di Firenze Via Madonna del Piano IT-50019 Sesto Fiorentino/Firenze Italy Emai1:
[email protected]
MOUVET Christophe Bureau de Recherches Ge´ologiques et Minie`res (BRGM) 3 avenue Claude Guillemin FR-45060 Orle´ans ce´dex 2 France Email:
[email protected]
xxxviii
Contributors List
MU¨LLER Dietmar Umweltbundesamt GmbH Spittelauer Laende 5 AT-1090 Wien Austria Email: dietmar.mueller@ umweltbundesamt.at
NYEGAARD Per Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland, GEUS Øster Voldgade 10 DK-1350 Copenhagen K Denmark Email:
[email protected]
NEGREL Philippe Bureau de Recherches Ge´ologiques et Minie`res (BRGM) 3, avenue Claude Guillemin FR-45060 Orle´ans ce´dex 2 France Email:
[email protected]
PAHL-WOSTL Claudia Institute of Environmental Systems Research University of Osnabru¨ck Barbarastrasse 12 DE-49069 Osnabru¨ck Germany Email:
[email protected]
NEWIG Jens Institute of Environmental Systems Research University of Osnabru¨ck Barbarastrasse 12 DE-49069 Osnabru¨ck Germany Emai1: jnewig@ usf.uniosnabrueck.de
PTAK Thomas University of Go¨ttingen Geosciences Center Goldschmidtstrasse 3 DE-37077 Go¨ttingen Germany Email: thomas.ptak@geo. uni-goettingen.de
NIEUWENHUIS Rob TNO Netherlands Institute of Applied Geoscience –National Geological Survey Princetonlaan 6 P.O. Box 80015 NL-3508 TA Utrecht The Netherlands Email:
[email protected]
PURTSCHERT Roland Climate and Environmental Physics Physics Institute, University of Bern Sidlerstrasse 5 CH-3012 Bern, Switzerland Email:
[email protected]
NOTENBOOM Jos Milieu- en Natuurplanbureau Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency. Postbus 303 NL-3720 AH Bilthoven The Netherlands Email:
[email protected]
QUEVAUVILLER Philippe European Commission DG Environment (BU9 3/142) Rue de la Loi, 200 BE-1049 Brussels Belgium Email: philippe.quevauviller@ec. europa.eu
xxxix
Contributors List
REFSGAARD Jens Christian Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland GEUS Øster Voldgade 10 DK-1350 Copenhagen K Denmark Email:
[email protected] RIDDER Dagmar Institute of Environmental Systems Research University of Osnabru¨ck Barbarastrasse 12 DE-49069 Osnabru¨ck Germany Email:
[email protected]
ROHNS Hans-Peter Stadtwerke Du¨sseldorf AG Quality Control Water Wiedfeld 50 D-40589 Du¨sseldorf Germany Email:
[email protected]
ROSELL LINARES Monica Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Cientı´ ficas Instituto de Investigaciones Quı´ micas y Ambieltales de Barcelona Dept. de Quı´ mica Ambiental Jordi Girona, 18-26 E-08034 Barcelona Spain Email:
[email protected]
RIJNAARTS Huub TNO Netherlands Institute of Applied Geoscience — National Geological Survey Princetonlaan 6 P.O. Box 80015 NL-3508 TA Utrecht The Netherlands Email:
[email protected]
ROY Ste´phane Bureau de Recherches Ge´ologiques et Minie`res (BRGM) 3, avenue Claude Guillemin FR-45060 Orle`ans ce`dex 2 France Email:
[email protected]
RINAUDO Jean-Daniel Bureau de Recherches Ge´ologiques et Minie`res (BRGM) 1034, rue de Pinville FR-34000 Montpellier France Email:
[email protected]
SCHEIDLEDER Andreas Umweltbundesamt GmbH Spittelauer Laende 5 AT-1090 Wien Austria Email: andreas.scheidleder@ umweltbundesamt.at
RODGERS-JENKINS Crystal U.S. EPA 1201 Constitution Avenue, NW MC-4607M USA-Washington, DC 20460 United States of America Email: Rodgers.Crystal@epamail. epa.gov
SETFORD, Steve Cranfield Centre for Analytical Science Cranfield University Silsoe Bedforshire MK45 4DT United Kingdom Email: s.j.setford@cranfield.ac.uk
xl
SKET Boris University of Ljubljana, Biotechnical Faculty Dept. of Biology Vecna pot 111, PP2995 SI-1001 Ljubljana Slovenia Email:
[email protected] SLOB Adriaan TNO Environment and Geosciences Dept. Innovation & Environment Van Mourik Broekmanweg 6 P.O. Box 49 NL-2600 AA Delft The Netherlands Email:
[email protected] SONNENBORG Torben O. Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland, GEUS Øster Voldgade 10 DK-1350 Copenhagen K Denmark Email:
[email protected] STROSSER Pierre ACTeon Le Chalimont BP Ferme du Pre´ du Bois FR-68370 Orbey France Email:
[email protected] TER MEER Jeroen TNO Netherlands Institute of Applied Geoscience –National Geological Survey Princetonlaan 6 P.O. Box 80015 NL-3508 TA Utrecht The Netherlands Email:
[email protected]
Contributors List
THORNTON Steven F. Groundwater Protection and Restoration Group University of Sheffield Kroto Research Institute Broad Lane Sheffield S3 7HQ United Kingdom Email: s.f.thornton@Sheffield.ac.uk
TRACK Thomas DECHEMA e.V. Theodor-Heuss-Allee 25 DE-60486 Frankfurt am Main Germany Email:
[email protected]
TROLDBORG Lars Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland GEUS Øster Voldgade 10 DK-1350 Copenhagen K Denmark Email:
[email protected]
TSAKIROGLOU Christos D. FORTH/ICE-HT Stadiou Street, Platani P.O. Box 1414 GR-26504 Patras Greece Email:
[email protected]
TURPIN Nadine UMR Me´tafort-Cemageef-Agro Paris Tech-ENITA-INRA 24 avenue des Landais BP 50085 FR-63172 Aubiere Ce´dex France Emai1:
[email protected]
xli
Contributors List
VAN DER GRIFT Bas Netherlands Organisation for Applied Scientific Research (TNO) Geological Survey of the Netherlands Princetonlaan 6 P.O. Box 80015 NL-3508 TA Utrecht The Netherlands Email:
[email protected] VAN DUIJNE Hans TNO Netherlands Institute of Applied Geoscience – National Geological Survey Princetonlaan 6 P.O. Box 80015 NL-3508 TA Utrecht The Netherlands Email:
[email protected] VAN VEEN H. Johan SKB Bu¨chnerweg 1 Postbus 420 NL-2800 AK Gouda The Netherlands Email:
[email protected] VAN DER SLOOT Hans Energy Research Centre (ECN) P.O. Box 1 NL- 1755 Petten ZG The Netherlands Email:
[email protected] VERMOT-DESROCHES Claudine Diaclone l Bd Fleming-BP 1985 F-25020 Besancon Cedex France
WARD Rob Environment Agency—England and Wales Olton Court Solihull West Midlands B92 7HX United Kingdom Email: rob.ward@ environment-agency.gov.uk WERNER Peter University of Technology Dresden Institute of Waste Management and Contaminated Site Treatment Pratzschwitzer Str. 15 D-01796 Pirna Germany Email:
[email protected] WIJDENES John Diaclone l Bd Fleming-BP 1985 F-25020 Besancon Cedex France Email:
[email protected] WILSON Ryan D. Groundwater Protection and Restoration Group University of Sheffield Kroto Research Institute Broad Lane Sheffield S3 7HQ United Kingdom Email: r.d.wilson@Sheffield.ac.uk
1. General Introduction
CHAPTER 1
General Introduction: The Need to Protect Groundwater PHILIPPE QUEVAUVILLER European Commission, DG Environment (BU9 3/142), Rue de la Loi 200, BE-1049 Brussels, Belgium
1.1 Introduction Groundwater constitutes the largest reservoir of freshwater in the world, accounting for over 97% of all freshwater available on earth (excluding glaciers and ice caps). The remaining 3% is composed mainly of surface water (lakes, rivers, wetlands) and soil moisture. Until recently, focus on groundwater mainly concerned its use as drinking water (e.g. about 75% of European Union (EU) inhabitants depend on groundwater for their water supply). Groundwater is also an important resource for industry (e.g. cooling waters) and agriculture (irrigation). It has, however, become increasingly obvious that groundwater should not only be viewed as a drinking water reservoir, but also as a critical aquatic ecosystem.1 In this respect, groundwater represents an important link of the hydrological cycle for the maintenance of wetlands and river flows, acting as a buffer through dry periods. In other words, it provides the base flow (i.e. the water which feeds rivers all year round) for surface water systems, many of which are used for water supply and recreation. In many rivers, indeed, more than 50% of the annual flow is derived from groundwater. In lowflow periods in summer, more than 90% of the flow in some rivers may come from groundwater. Hence, deterioration of groundwater quality may directly affect other related aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems. Since groundwater moves slowly through the subsurface, the impact of anthropogenic activities may last for a relatively long time, which means that pollution that occurred some decades ago—whether from agriculture, industry or other human activities—may still be threatening groundwater quality today and, in some cases, will continue to do so for several generations to come. The legacy of the past is clearly visible at large-scale contaminated sites, e.g. industrial sites or harbour areas, where it is simply not possible, with 3
4
Chapter 1
state-of-the-art technology and a proportionate use of public and/or private money, to clean up the regional contamination encountered at these locations.2 In addition, the experience of remediation of the past 20 years has shown that the measures taken have in most cases not been able to completely remove all contaminants and that pollutant sources, even if partially removed, continue to emit for long periods of time (i.e. several generations).3,4 Therefore, an important focus should be on preventing pollution in the first place. Secondly, since surface water systems receive a continuous discharge of inflowing groundwater, a deteriorated groundwater quality will ultimately be reflected in the quality of surface waters. In other words, the effect of human activity on groundwater quality will eventually also impact on the quality of associated aquatic ecosystems and directly dependent terrestrial ecosystems if so-called natural attenuation reactions such as biodegradation in the subsurface are not sufficient to contain the contaminants. Finally, groundwater is a ‘‘hidden resource’’ which is quantitatively much more significant than surface water and for which pollution prevention and quality monitoring and restoration are even more difficult than for surface waters, which is mostly due to its inaccessibility. This ‘‘hidden’’ character makes it difficult adequately to locate and quantitatively appreciate pollution impacts, resulting in a lack of awareness and/or evidence regarding the extent of risks and pressures. Recent reports, however, show that pollution from domestic, agricultural and industrial sources is, despite the progress in some fields, still a major concern, either directly through discharges (effluents) or indirectly from the spreading of nitrogen fertilisers and pesticides or through leaching from old landfills or industrial sites (e.g. chlorinated hydrocarbons, heavy metals). For example, around one-third of groundwater bodies in Europe currently exceed the nitrate guideline values.5 While point sources have caused most of the pollution identified to date, there is evidence that diffuse sources are having an increasing impact on groundwater. This chapter develops the elements discussed above as a general introduction to this book, which further elaborates issues related to groundwater policy, protection and remediation throughout the different chapters.
1.2 The Scientific Background 1.2.1
The Hydrogeological Cycle
It is estimated that roughly 22% of freshwater is stored underground, representing some 8 million km3 of 37 million km3 of freshwater found on the planet. Excluding water from polar ice, groundwater constitutes some 97% of all the freshwater that is potentially available for human use on or beneath the earth’s surface. The remainder is stored in lakes, rivers and swamps.6 Groundwater recharge is essentially ensured by rain that infiltrates through the soil into underlying layers; this recharge is occasionally augmented by streams and rivers that lose water to underground strata. Once underground,
General Introduction: The Need to Protect Groundwater
5
groundwater flows at rates which range from more than 10 metres per day to as little as 1 metre per year until it reaches an outlet, e.g. a spring or seepages at the ground surface (which actually keep rivers flowing during dry periods). The time scales at which groundwater flows hence considerably vary, depending on hydrogeological conditions. It may take years to decades for water to move through the soil to reach the water table, the level at which the ground is fully saturated, where it may remain underground for tens or even thousands of years before reappearing at the surface.6 Geological settings may also trap groundwater from both its source and its outlets. Finally, climate change may also lead to groundwater losses by depriving aquifers from recharge as it appears in a number of regions which turned into deserts. The level of available geological and hydrogeological information varies from area to area, and this has an effect on the protection schemes to be developed.7 Where the information is adequate, a comprehensive scheme, based on hydrogeological concepts, is achievable. However, as mentioned below, aquifers are rarely homogeneous and their geological variability conditions the nature of groundwater flowing through their respective lithologies and structures, which makes it difficult to establish large-scale conceptual hydrogeological models.
1.2.2
Waters in Aquifers
The nature of aquifers, consisting either of unconsolidated materials such as sand or gravel or consolidated rock such as sandstone, has a considerable influence on groundwater flows and hence on pollution pathways (see Section 1.4.3). On the one hand, unconsolidated materials, such as sands, can store up to 30% of their volume as water. On the other hand, consolidated materials may also store large volumes of water, depending upon their porosity, but groundwater flow is usually very slow owing to the small size of the pores. In some types of rocks, the capillary attraction between the groundwater and the pore surface does not allow water to be released and hence to flow. However, consolidated materials may also store water in fractures in the rock, which although they usually represent less than 1% of the total volume can be enlarged by dissolution in rocks such as limestones. Enlarged fractures enable the aquifer both to store large volumes of water and permit high groundwater flows,7 which has an impact on pollution spreading (see Chapter 5.5). Aquifers are usually bounded above by an unsaturared zone, which contains both air and water, and below by an impermeable bed constituted, for example, of clay or rock. The boundary between the unsaturared and saturated zones (water table) is found at different depths depending on the hydrogeological and climatic settings, e.g. as much as 100 m below the surface in arid areas and close to the surface in humid areas. Some aquifers are, however, bounded entirely by impermeable layers and contain groundwater under pressure (which enables water abstraction by artesian wells).
6
1.2.3
Chapter 1
Groundwater Flows
With aquifer characteristics in mind (in particular the type of materials containing the water), it is possible to better approximate groundwater flows. Groundwater moves through aquifers as a result of differences in pressure or elevation of the water table within the aquifer. The groundwater flow may be slowed down by various obstructions while moving from the point of recharge to its exit from the aquifer. In some cases, impermeable rock formations (known as aquicludes) such as shale stop completely the water flow, while other geological strata (known as aquitards), such as clay lenses embedded with sand, may slow down the groundwater flow. The groundwater flow rate depends on the permeability and porosity of the aquifer, and on the pressure gradient. As an example, highly permeable aquifers such as limestones respond rapidly to changes in recharge and abstraction rates, and groundwater levels in such areas may fluctuate by as much as 10 m a year and may change by up to 50 m a year.7 The greatest variations in groundwater flow patterns occur where changes in rock types, e.g. limestone overlying sediments and a hard crystalline rock, induce discontinuities in flow and may bring groundwater flow to the surface on the junction between the two rock types. Variations in groundwater flow may also occur within an unconsolidated alluvial aquifer, e.g. great lateral variations occur in the mix of gravel, sand and clay making up the aquifer matrix. In larger-scale alluvial aquifers, layers of sand or gravel-rich sediment interbedded with clay-rich layers induce lateral flow following the more permeable sand- and gravel-rich zones. Needless to say that groundwater flow rates are very small in comparison to those of surface water. In this respect, some groundwater from deep alluvial basins is likely to be thousands or even hundreds of thousands of years old. The slow movement of groundwater largely contributes to its purity since contaminants become highly attenuated during the usually long groundwater flowing pathway to the surface. Groundwater may also become enriched with elements that are naturally present in rocks. Furthermore, saltwater intrusion may occur near coastlines, in particular where the water table is lowered due to abstraction, and this is likely to be accentuated by rising sea levels due to climate change.
1.2.4
Groundwater Quality
Most groundwater originates from water that has permeated first the soil and then the rock below it. The soil removes many impurities and the rock through which the water then flows, perhaps for thousand of years, filters and purifies the water even further.7 It therefore usually reappears at the earth surface free of pathogenic micro-organisms. This is the reason for an increasing exploitation of groundwater resources (see Section 3.1). While groundwater is generally less easily/rapidly polluted than streams and rivers, it often contains high concentrations of dissolved elements from the rock
General Introduction: The Need to Protect Groundwater
7
through which it has passed. Another feature is that when groundwater is polluted, many processes occur during its pathway to the surface; in particular, pollutant loads may be attenuated by adsorption by the rock itself or biochemical transformation into substances that are less harmful than the original compounds. However, severe pollutions may affect groundwater quality over long periods, i.e. once pollutants reach the water table, it may take a very long time before they are flushed out from the aquifer. Furthermore, groundwater quality affected by pollution may take a long time to recover since the water within the aquifer moves so slowly. Once polluted, aquifers are difficult—and sometimes even impossible—to clean up. The process can be likened to trying to squeeze out the last traces of soap from a sponge.7 As stressed above, the complex nature of groundwater is compounded in the context of pollution and quality problems. Let us repeat that the chemical characteristics of aquifer materials and the way pollutants react with them vary greatly. In some cases, pollutants are ‘‘filtered’’ out mechanically or through adsorption onto particles within the soil or aquifer matrix. In other cases, however, pollutants remain mobile and can rapidly spread throughout an aquifer. The aquifer matrix itself can become contaminated and pockets of pollutants can serve as continuous sources of contamination. For example, small pockets of organic solvents can remain as pollution sources virtually indefinitely because of their low solubility in water. Furthermore, changes in pH or other groundwater characteristics can cause the release of toxic materials, such as fluoride, from natural sources within aquifers. Given the hundreds of thousands of naturally occurring compounds in groundwater and aquifer materials, and the similarly large number of compounds present in waste water released to aquifers, understanding and managing pollution problems is a highly complex task. This illustrates the importance of preventing pollution of groundwater from the start rather than dealing with the consequences (Chapter 5.5). All the above considerations have an impact on the way groundwater background levels are evaluated and also on the assessment of groundwater quality either related to its use or to its environmental value. These aspects are discussed in various chapters of this book (Chapters 5.1–5.3 and 9.1).
1.3 Groundwater Deterioration Risks 1.3.1 1.3.1.1
Quantitative Aspects Over-exploitation
Groundwater is extensively used by humans throughout the world as a drinking water resource, with some countries depending almost entirely on it while others only partly using the groundwater resource for drinking water abstraction. Groundwater supplies are of obvious importance in arid areas but they are also extensively used in humid areas, largely because they provide water that requires little or no treatment and which can be cheaply produced.
8
Chapter 1
In addition, its supplies are not subject to abrupt change as a result of abnormal weather, i.e. a dry summer while affecting reservoirs will have little effect on groundwater levels. Finally, groundwater can often be tapped near to where it is needed while surface water must be either developed at the sites of natural dams or reservoirs, or piped at considerable distances to where it will eventually be used.7 However, groundwater should not be seen as a simple alternative to the use of surface water. The inadequate control of groundwater abstraction in many parts of the world usually results in some form of over-exploitation, which can lead to either reversible or irreversible damages (this consideration also applies to damages due to pollution, see Section 1.3.3). In the first case, matters can be corrected and only the question of costs is involved. In the second case, costs are also involved but, in addition, sustainability issues arise since future generations are deprived of an important resource.7 Many aquifers are being over-exploited in the sense that water is abstracted faster than the average recharge rate. This is particularly problematic in the case of fossil groundwater. The control of the balance of groundwater levels (equilibrium between abstraction and recharge) is, however, difficult to apprehend in that the recharge rate of groundwater resources is not constant and can vary considerably with the rainfall pattern. This means that what may be considered as over-exploitation in one year may be a perfectly acceptable rate of exploitation in another. To complicate matters, in some arid areas major recharge only occurs once a decade or even less frequently.7 In this circumstance, defining a sustainable abstraction rate is difficult. Adding to this, climate changes impact on the dynamic balances of groundwater resources, and these are not easily predictable.
1.3.1.2
Falling and Rising Water Tables
Over-abstraction and subsequent fall of the water table may lead to severe damage linked to ground subsidence, which is caused by water draining from the pores in underground strata, causing the rock to compact. Unconsolidated strata, especially clays which have high water content, are particularly susceptible to this phenomenon. Conversely, circumstances such as over-irrigation of land may lead to rising of the water table, leading to waterlogging of agricultural land which is often associated with salinisation. This is due to two causes: a rising water table that brings saline water into contact with plant roots; and the evaporation of irrigation water by sun, leaving the salt behind. Another occurrence of rising water table is observed in urban areas where urban recharge rates may be higher than natural (pre-natural) ones. This is not so problematic when cities consume large quantities of water (thus balancing the high recharge rates) but it may be so when groundwater is not abstracted any more, which increasingly happens owing to contaminated groundwater beneath the cities. Rising water tables under cities may lead to urban flooding, with associated costs (need to pump water out, etc.).
General Introduction: The Need to Protect Groundwater
1.3.1.3
9
Saltwater Intrusion
Under natural conditions, coastal aquifers discharge freshwater into the sea. However, in case of (over)abstraction of groundwater in areas that are close to the coastline, this process may be reversed, leading to salt water moving inland and polluting the aquiferw. Examples of such occurrences can be found in many places of the world.7 The problem may be severe on islands where the freshwater aquifer is only a few metres thick (e.g. composed of highly permeable sediments) and surrounded by salt water; in this specific case, aquifer abstraction has to be particularly well managed.
1.3.2 1.3.2.1
Links to Associated Ecosystems Links to Associated Aquatic Ecosystems
In many areas, it is groundwater that makes the use of surface water sources possible during dry seasons. Groundwater provides the base flow to many of the world’s rivers, and this flow continues throughout the year, regardless of weather conditions. Many rivers would dry up in hot and dry summers if they would not be fed by groundwater. This is particularly important in both humid and arid regions where precipitation is highly variable. Between precipitation events, groundwater and return flows from agricultural, domestic and other users are the primary source of flows in rivers. Since return flows generally have higher pollution loads than groundwater flow, the groundwater contribution is important to both the quantity and quality of dry-season flow in surface watercourses. An evaluation of quantitative aspects of groundwater–surface interactions is described in Chapter 9.3 of this book. Productivity in coastal ecosystems is also highly dependent on the balance between freshwater inflows from surface water, groundwater discharge and saline ocean water. Disruption of this balance through diminution of groundwater contributions to base flow could have major effects on the coastal environment.
1.3.2.2
Links to Dependent Terrestrial Ecosystems
Wetlands are some of the most productive and biologically diverse inland ecosystems. In many if not most cases, water availability in wetlands depends on high groundwater levels. Consequently, the fall of the water table may have a direct impact on wetlands as the land is drying out. In this respect, a number of the world’s major wetland areas, which are sensitive ecosystems supporting a large number of plant and animal species, are now under threat due to overabstraction. In addition, groundwater pollution also represents a major threat not only to the habitat of many rare species but also in affecting the purifying role of the wetlands with respect to inland lakes. w
Note that the term ‘‘pollution’’ is appropriate when saltwater intrusion is indeed due to overabstraction, i.e. due to human activity.
10
Chapter 1
Besides wetlands, groundwater levels and quality directly influence surface vegetation communities. Phreatophytes, plants that derive a major portion of their water needs from saturated soils, can be the dominant vegetative species in ecosystems where groundwater levels are shallow. They often form critical wildlife habitat and may serve as important sources of food and timber. This vegetation also uses substantial amounts of water. Removing these species can reduce evapotranspiration and hence the demand on groundwater resources, which may cause levels to rise and thereby lead to waterlogging and other environmental problems.
1.3.3 1.3.3.1
Groundwater Pollution Introduction
Once polluted, groundwater is extremely difficult to clean up owing to its inaccessibility, its huge volume and its slow flow rates. The three major pollution threats, namely urbanisation, industrial activities and agriculture, are discussed in the following paragraphs. Let us distinguish here pollution impacts related to either human uses or the environment. In the first instance, pollutants found in groundwater are listed according to their toxic impacts on drinking water quality according to, for example, WHO drinking water quality guidelines or EU legislation (Drinking Water Directive). Pollutants may also be distinguished according to their ecotoxicological impacts, i.e. substances which are detrimental to the environment such as those pollutants listed in the EU Water Framework Directive (see Chapter 3.1). This distinction is important in that the ‘‘pollution impact’’ should be assessed differently whether it is related to a particular use of the water resource or to an impact on the aquatic or terrestrial environment. As noted in Section 2.4, groundwater may contain high concentrations of chemical substances that are present naturally (due to interactions of the groundwater with the soil or surrounding rocks) and which as such does not correspond to a pollution (i.e. due to human activities) but which may hamper the use of the groundwater for drinking water abstraction; this does not mean, however, that the groundwater is of ‘‘bad environmental quality’’. These two aspects of groundwater quality and related needs for protection against pollution are further discussed in the policy context in Chapters 3.1 and 3.2. Furthermore, issues of natural attenuation, risk assessment at contaminated sites (including megasites), remediation and prevention are extensively described in Chapters 5.4, 5.6, 5.7, 7.1–7.3).
1.3.3.2
Urbanisation and Related Discharges
Urbanisation introduces many changes to the aquifers that lie under cities. Natural recharge mechanisms are modified or replaced and new ones are introduced. Leakages and seepages from mains water and sanitation systems become an important part of the hydrological cycle in the urban environment. In this respect, many sub-city aquifers are polluted with human wastes,
General Introduction: The Need to Protect Groundwater
11
particularly where there is insufficient connection to mains sewerage. In Europe, the situation has improved with the implementation of the Urban Wastewater Treatment Directive, but in many developing countries, septic tanks, cesspits and latrines are still common in major cities. Septic tanks, when properly operated, produce an effluent of acceptable quality in areas of low population density. In practice, they are, however, often overloaded and operate inefficiently. Effluent is often discharged directly into inland waterways, whence pollutants find their way into the underlying aquifer.7 This pollution leads to increasing occurrence of pathogens in groundwater (in particular helminths, protozoa, bacteria and viruses), which may have a direct impact on the bacteriological quality of water abstracted for human consumption (in particular when drinking water is provided by shallow private boreholes with insufficient sanitary controls). Domestic effluents are also responsible for increasing nitrate concentrations in groundwater. It should be noted, however, that while sewage and urban wastewater is generally regarded as a major source of pollution, it is also considered as a large and important resource, i.e. in many arid areas, it is used with minimal, if any, treatment to irrigate crops, including some intended for direct human consumption.7 The water used also supplies crops with essential elements such as nitrogen and phosphate which would otherwise have to be added as artificial fertiliser. This re-use is often debated as regard to its safety, and many experts consider that a better use for urban wastewater is probably to recharge the aquifer from which it came. During the recharge process, the water is considerably purified. If it is required for irrigation, it can then be abstracted either from irrigation wells or from streams whose flows has been increased by the recharge. Letting sewage water stand in shallow surface ponds and filter down through the soil and the aquifer below can be an effective means of treatment. The more slowly this is done, and the more that the surface ponds are rested between treatments, the more complete will be the treatment. Allowing ponds to dry out regularly leads to a breakdown of nitrates in the sewage, with the release of harmless nitrogen gas. With careful control, nitrogen concentration in the recharge water can be reduced to below 5 mg L 1. At the same time, most bacteria and protozoa are eliminated, and levels of organic compounds and phosphates are greatly reduced. This infiltration treatment, although it uses land areas, presents the advantage of providing a cheap underground storage system from which water can be pumped for non-potable uses.7 Solid waste disposals represent another source of major urban groundwater pollution. The worst risks occur where uncontrolled tipping, as opposed to controlled sanitary landfill, is practised, and where hazardous industrial wastes, including drums of liquid effluents, are disposed of at inappropriate sites which are selected on the basis of their proximity to where the waste is generated rather than their suitability as landfill sites. Often no record is kept of the nature and quantity of wastes disposed of at a given site and abandoned sites represent a potential hazard to groundwater for decades. To make matters worse, disposal is often on low ground where the water table is high and direct contamination of shallow groundwater likely.7
12
1.3.3.3
Chapter 1
Industry
Nearly all industries produce liquid effluents, which according to legislation have to be properly treated before they are allowed to be discharged to a water course. There are, however, still many illegal discharges (in particular from small industries producing paper and textiles, processing leather, metals and other materials and repairing vehicles, as well as small service industries such as metal workshops, dry cleaners, photo processors, etc.), e.g. of acids, oils, fuels and solvents which have a direct impact on water courses, particularly canals, or disposed into the ground and finding their ways to groundwater. Chlorinated solvents are particularly insidious pollutants because of their persistency, toxicity and the way they travel in aquifers. In this respect, many groundwater supplies are contaminated by such substances, a common cause of which is leaking storage tanks. Unfortunately, cleaning up a polluted aquifer— usually by removing contaminated soil and continuous pumping of the aquifer—is extremely difficult, very costly and takes a great deal of time.7 Industrial effluents also often contain high levels of metals such as iron, zinc, chromium and cadmium, many of which are highly toxic, even carcinogenic. A specific industrial pollution is related to mining and petroleum extraction. Quarrying and open-case mining, for example, remove the protective layer above an aquifer, leaving it more vulnerable to pollution. Deep mines or oil fields may produce fluids that are disposed of at the surface and may therefore pollute shallow aquifers, and pollutants from spoil heaps may leach into groundwater. Finally, rising water levels in abandoned mines produce acid mine drainage with subsequent mobilisation of oxidised metal ores, leading to increasing concentrations of sulfate, iron, manganese and other metals, which can cause serious groundwater pollution. Details on risk assessment of industrial pollution can be found in Chapters 5.6 and 7.1.
1.3.3.4
Agriculture
Agriculture is responsible for one of the main pollution groundwater threats. The main source arises from the intensive use of nitrogen-rich fertilisers and of pesticides, a problem that has spread from the industrialised countries to developing ones. The high levels of nitrate and, in some areas, pesticides in groundwater are clearly linked to agricultural activities. This pollution is generally worse where the soil is very permeable, allowing agricultural chemicals to be quickly washed down to underlying aquifers. However, not all nitrates in groundwater are due to agriculture, as we have seen that much of it also originates from untreated sewage. Monitoring techniques can hardly distinguish between the different agricultural and sewage nitrates (besides isotopic measurements). The leaching of nitrate from fields not only leads to pollution but is also a serious source of waste: nitrate that percolates down into aquifers has done nothing to stimulate plant growth. Other components of fertilisers, including potassium and chloride, also find their way from fields to aquifers.
General Introduction: The Need to Protect Groundwater
13
Regarding pesticides and herbicides, substances currently in use are designed to be toxic and, sometimes, persistent. There is no doubt that pesticides are leached through the soil and carried down to underlying aquifers (see Chapter 9.2). In some circumstances, soils can adsorb or immobilise a large fraction of such agricultural chemicals. Many pesticides and herbicides, however, break down slowly under aquifer conditions and, as a result can persist over long time periods. In any case, groundwater pollution data are generally scarce, and the extent of pollution in Europe is hence not accurately known. Further considerations on diffuse groundwater impacts from agricultural land use are discussed in Chapters 7.3 and 8.2.
1.4 Groundwater Risk Assessment: Implications for Policy 1.4.1
Groundwater Protection Needs
Public and policy-maker perceptions of groundwater represent an important root cause of emerging problems.8 In many cases, regardless of the degree of formal education individuals have had, perceptions of groundwater resource dynamics are partial at best. Groundwater is often viewed, for example, as an inexhaustible resource, cleaned by the filtering action of aquifers and held, as in a ‘‘bowl’’ or ‘‘lake’’, or ‘‘underground river’’. These perceptions do not reflect reality, and often result in use patterns that cause unanticipated problems. Most misunderstandings relate to the scale of aquifer systems, the distribution of groundwater within them and the timescales on which groundwater systems function (see Chapter 5.5). Groundwater protection relies on two closely interlinked components:7 (i) land surface protection, based on hydrogeological concepts and information particularly regarding aquifers and vulnerability; and (ii) groundwater protection responses for potentially polluting activities, giving guidelines on the acceptability of the activities, investigation requirements and, where appropriate, the likely planning or licensing controls. Groundwater protection schemes enable authorities to take account of (i) the potential risks to groundwater resources and sources; and (ii) geological and hydrogeological factors, when considering the control and location of potentially polluting activities.7 Although groundwater is one of the world’s key natural resources, it is still not sufficiently well protected and poorly controlled. In many instances, the extent of groundwater pollution still remains to be evaluated or even detected, given the slow rates of groundwater movement and the volume of storage involved. In 1996, UNEP indicated that what we know of pollution levels in aquifers may only be the tip of an underground iceberg,6 which consideration is still valid ten years later. There is, in any case, no doubt that this important resource needs to be better protected from both over-exploitation and pollution. This is the aim of the developing groundwater legislation which is described in Chapter 3.1.
14
1.4.2
Chapter 1
Assessment, Prevention and Control
Assessment and appropriate controls of major threats are highly necessary particularly in areas subject to irreversible side effects such as saltwater intrusion and land subsidence (in the case of over-abstraction), but also in the case of high aquifer vulnerability, taking into account pollutant loads (in the case of pollution). Vulnerability assessments and controls require a number of legal and administrative steps, examples of which are described in the light of the EU Water Framework Directive and associated Groundwater Directive (see Chapter 3.1). In the case of pollution, there is a need to distinguish between point sources of pollution, such as landfills and specific industrial discharges, and diffuse sources of pollution linked to agricultural activities and to a lesser extent atmospheric deposition. Efforts should be made to reduce pollution from pollution sources, paying particular attention to practices in areas where aquifers are highly vulnerable. This means that land-use planning regulations have to be enforced in the most sensitive areas. This also concerns of course agricultural practices (see Chapter 8.2). A key step in assessing pollution risks is based on the analysis of the groundwater vulnerability (ease with which groundwater may be contaminated by human activities). It depends on the time of travel of infiltrating water (and contaminants), the relative amount of contaminants and the contaminant attenuation capacity of the geological materials through which the water and contaminants infiltrate (see further discussion in Chapters 5.4 and 9.2). As all groundwater is hydrologically connected to the land surface, it is the effectiveness of this connection that determines the relative vulnerability to contamination. Groundwater that readily and quickly receives water (and contaminants) from the land surface is considered to be more vulnerable than groundwater that receives water (and contaminants) more slowly and in lesser quantities. The travel time, attenuation capacity and quantity of contaminants are a function of the following natural geological and hydrogeological attributes of any area: (i) the subsoils that overlie the groundwater; (ii) the type of recharge, whether point or diffuse; and (iii) the thickness of the unsaturated zone through which the contaminant moves. In general, little attenuation of contamination occurs in bedrocks via fissures, and high attenuation will be possible in subsoils (sands, gravels, glacial tills (or boulder clays), peat, alluvial silts and clays). Groundwater is most at risk where the subsoils are absent or thin and, in areas of karstic limestone, where surface streams sink underground at swallow holes. Vulnerability may be mapped according to the elements in Table 1.1. Establishing such maps is an important part for deciding upon a groundwater protection scheme and an essential element in the decision-making on the location of potentially polluting activities.7 Firstly, the vulnerability rating for an area indicates, and is a measure of, the likelihood of contamination. Secondly, the vulnerability map helps to ensure that a groundwater protection scheme is not unnecessarily restrictive on human economic activity. Thirdly, the vulnerability maps help in the choice of preventive measures and enable developments, which have a significant potential to contaminate, to be located
15
General Introduction: The Need to Protect Groundwater
Vulnerability mapping guidelines (adapted from Ref. 7).
Table 1.1
Hydrogeological conditions Vulnerability rating
Extreme High Moderate Low
Subsoil permeability (type) and thickness
Unsaturated zone
Kast features
High permeability (sand/gravel)
Moderate permeability (e.g. sandy subsoil)
Low permeability (e.g. clayey subsoil, clay, peat)
(Sand/gravel aquifers only)
(o30 m radius)
0–3 m 43 m N/A N/A
0–3 m 3–10 m 410 m N/A
0–3 m 3–5 m 5–10 m 410 m
0–3 m 43 m N/A N/A
– N/A N/A N/A
Risk to Groundwater
Hydrogeological Factors
Vulnerability to contaminants
Figure 1.1
Groundwater Value
Other Factors
Contaminant Loading
Preventive Measures
Factors under consideration for groundwater risk assessment.
in areas of lower vulnerability. This assessment strongly relies on proper characterisation of groundwater settings and related risks, an issue that is discussed in Chapter 5.1. In this respect, the risk depends on (i) the hazard afforded by a potentially polluting activity, (ii) the vulnerability of groundwater to contamination, and (iii) the potential consequences of a contamination event. The hazard depends on the potential contaminant loading. The natural vulnerability of the groundwater dictates the likelihood of contamination if a contamination event occurs. The consequences to the target depends on the value of the groundwater, which is normally indicated by the aquifer category (regionally important, locally important or poor) and the proximity to an important groundwater abstraction source (e.g. a public supply well). The risk assessment encompasses geological and hydrogeological factors and factors that relate to the potentially polluting activity. This is illustrated in Figure 1.1. In the light of the above, prevention of groundwater contamination is of critical importance and must be a key aim for the following reasons:7 Once groundwater contamination occurs, the consequences last far longer than surface water contamination (months, years and sometimes
16
Chapter 1
decades) because groundwater moves slowly through the soil and unsaturated zone of the aquifer. Remediation is frequently not practical or is very expensive. Also, it is both impractical and a poor environmental strategy to provide comprehensive treatment to remove certain pollutants, such as pesticides and other trace organics. It is therefore preferable to prevent or reduce the risk of groundwater contamination than to deal with its consequences. Groundwater is an important resource used for drinking water, industry and agriculture, and should be protected for present and future usage. Groundwater provides the base flow (i.e. the water which feeds rivers year-round, and upon which flood flows are superimposed) to surface water systems, many of which are used for water supply and recreational purposes.
1.4.3
Monitoring
The assessment and controls of groundwater quantity and quality have to be supported by representative and reliable monitoring data. Groundwater monitoring is largely a national responsibility but, because groundwater does not respect national boundaries, monitoring has to be conceived at national, regional and international levels. This is exactly the principle of the Water Framework Directive (see Chapter 3.1). Improved monitoring systems are needed to provide information not only on groundwater quantity and quality in the light of its use as drinking water resources, but also for the evaluation of its environmental quality in relation to associated aquatic and directly dependent terrestrial ecosystems. In particular, existing monitoring networks hardly provide early warning of pollution, and networks are needed to include monitoring of pollution loads, particularly in vulnerable recharge areas. Recommendations have been given by UNEP in this respect6 (see Table 1.2). Groundwater quality monitoring has at least four objectives that need to be carefully distinguished in the design of monitoring systems: definition of the extent of groundwater pollution (analysis of pressures and impacts); quality control of groundwater used as drinking water (drinking water supply surveillance); early discovery of groundwater pollution from a given activity (offensive detection monitoring); and provision of advance warning of the arrival of polluted water at important sources of supply (defensive detection monitoring). Detailed monitoring guidelines in support of policy implementation, more specifically to the EU Water Framework Directive and new Groundwater Directive (see Chapter 3.1), have been developed and are summarised in Chapter 6.1.
a
FC: faecal coliforms.
Chlorinated hydrocarbons, other organic compounds, metals
Cl, NO3, NH4, SO4, FC
Domestic wastewatera Industrial effluent
Pollution indicators
High
Bacteriological Monitor at water table
High
Chemical
Pollution risk
Early warning monitoring required
Hours to weeks
Fractured
Unconfined
Aquifer type
Cl, NO3, NH4, SO4, FC Metals, range of organic compounds
Monitor at water table
Moderate
High for mobile compounds
Days to months
Thin unsaturated zone
Granular
Persistent organics (metals)
Cl, NO3, NH4, SO4, FC
(1) Monitor unsaturated zone and (2) at water table
Low
High for mobile and persistent compounds
Years to decades
Deep unsaturated zone
Key elements in an early warning monitoring strategy (adapted from Ref. 6).
Travel time from surface to saturated aquifer zone
Table 1.2
Persistent organics (metals)
Cl, NO3, NH4, SO4
Monitor semiconfining layer and aquifer
Moderate for persistent compounds only Very low
Decades +
Semi-confined
General Introduction: The Need to Protect Groundwater 17
18
Chapter 1
1.5 Conclusions Groundwater protection is essential in relation to the intrinsic water resource quality for various uses, and its environmental value. Basic environmental principles include the following: Sustainable development principles, seeking to ensure that economy and society can develop to their full potential within a well-protected environment, and with responsibility towards present and future generations and the wider international community. Precautionary principle, requiring that emphasis should be placed on dealing with the causes, rather than the results, of environmental damage and that, where significant evidence of environmental risk exists, appropriate action should be taken even in the absence of conclusive scientific proof of cause. Polluter pays principle, of which the objective is to allocate correctly the costs of pollution, consumption of energy and environmental resources, and production and disposal of waste to the responsible polluters and consumer, rather than to society at large or future generations, which in turn provides an incentive to reduce pollution and consumption.
References 1. J. Gibert, in Groundwater Ecology: A Tool for Management of Water Resources, ed. C. Griebler, D. L. Danielopol, J. Gibert, H. P. Nachtnebel and J. Notenboom, European Commission, EUR 1987, 2001, p. 413. 2. S. Heidrich, M. Schirmer, H. Weiss, P. Wycisk, J. Grossmann and A. Kaschl, Toxicology, in press. 3. P. Grathwohl, Diffusion in Natural Porous Media, Contaminant Transport, Sorption/Desorption and Dissolution Kinetics, Kluwer Academic, 1998. 4. G. Teusch, H. Ruegner, D. Zamfirescu, M. Finkel and M. Bittens, Land Contamin. Reclam., 2001, 9, 1. 5. EEA, Groundwater Quality and Quantity in Europe, Environmental Assessment Report 3, Copenhagen, 2000. 6. UNEP, Groundwater: a threatened resource, UNEP Environment Library 15, Nairobi, Kenya, 1996. 7. Irish EPA, Groundwater Protection Schemes, 1999 (ISBN 1-899702-22-9). 8. J. J. Burke and M. H. Moench, Groundwater and Society: Resources, Tensions and Opportunities, United Nations, 2000 (ISBN 92-1-104485-5).
2. Science–Policy Integration Needs
CHAPTER 2.1
Science–Policy Integration for Common Approaches Linked to Groundwater Management in Europew PHILIPPE QUEVAUVILLER European Commission, DG Environment (BU9 3/142), Rue de la Loi 200, BE-1049 Brussels, Belgium
2.1.1
Introductory Remarks on Science–Policy Integration Needs
It is now well recognised that a better understanding of environmental problems requires an improved awareness of multidisciplinary scientific developments.1 Awareness by itself is, however, not sufficient, and a better research integration is also required at the various stages of policy developments (design, development, implementation and review). Ideally, the relevant research for any environmental policy should be feeding the policy-making process directly in a ‘‘tailor-made fashion’’ so that results may be used in the right way at the right time (in relation to the policy agenda). In many instances, however, this is still far from being the case. In the sector of European Union (EU) water policies, on-going discussions are taking place among the scientific community (representatives of research consortia and of the European Commission’s Research Directorate-General) and the policy-making community (representatives of EU member states’ environment agencies or ministries and the European Commission’s Environment Directorate-General) to examine research–policy coordination needs. These discussions have highlighted the key importance of improving/increasing the information and communication flow within and between these w
The views expressed in this chapter are purely those of the author and may not in any circumstances be regarded as stating an official position of the European Commission.
21
22
Chapter 2.1
communities.2 On the one hand, the implementation of existing policies and the development of new ones are constantly fed by scientific inputs, which must fulfil specific thematic and timing requirements in order to be of direct value to the policy-making process. On the other hand, research and technological development (RTD) activities aiming to support relevant environmental policies have to take into account the policy-making agenda and its specific needs to adapt the objectives and the scope of their related work programmes. Experience has shown, however, that this interrelationship is not as efficient as it could/should be, owing to a lack of a clear coordination mechanism. In fact scientists view the end-user in the research project as the ‘‘legitimate’’ client for their research results, but on the ground there is a significant lack of transfer mechanisms that would allow passing on of the relevant information to other stakeholders or policy makers.2 The latter often do not have the time, the capacity to translate research results into policy, or even simple access to specific technical journals and thus relevant information mostly remains within the specialised scientific community. Communication difficulties are also linked to the different ‘‘jargon’’ used in the different communities. One problem hampering proper science–policy integration is related to different timing concepts of research and policy. Policy tends to operate on the short or medium term with clearly defined milestones, while science is generally developed on a long-term basis. In addition, policy tries in most instances to achieve an acceptable (political) compromise (which is, sometimes somewhat critically, labelled as the ‘‘least common denominator’’), whereas the scientific community strives to obtain objective, scientific facts and wants to understand a phenomenon to the greatest possible detail. In addition, scientific career reviewing schemes rarely give credit to works for the integration of knowledge to fulfil policy objectives. As a result, scientists are not sufficiently motivated to perform this type of work and in most cases they may not be aware about the specific research issues needed at a certain time to effectively support policy development.2 In many instances, knowledge is available but is either not widely known or is insufficiently transferred from the scientific community to the other relevant parties. Furthermore, policy-makers, planners and implementers are often not sufficiently ‘‘entrepreneurial’’ with respect to the selection and use of state-of-the-art research projects that would directly feed the policy objectives (which is essentially due to time pressures and lack of streamlined information). As is discussed below, this is often due to a lack of dialogue or an inappropriate communication of relevant information. In the best case, policy-makers are able to define a list of open questions and then, on this basis, open a discussion with the scientific community in order to understand if the questions are addressing the actual research needs or whether the subject matter has already been treated sufficiently in the past so that responses may be obtained from readily available results. Such a mechanism, however, is certainly not straightforward and often not sufficiently operational. The development of environmental policies mixes legal requirements with issues of technical feasibility, scientific knowledge and socioeconomic aspects and requires intensive multi-stakeholder consultations. In this context, the
23
Science–Policy Integration for Common Approaches POLICY IMPLEMENTATION POLICY DEVELOPMENT
RESEARCH, SCIENTIFIC PROGRESS, POLICY INTEGRATION
POLICY REVIEW
DESIGN OF POLICY
Figure 2.1.1
Integration of scientific progress into the policy-making process.
consideration of scientific progress represents one of the key aspects for the design of new policies and the review of existing ones. Within the EU, this consideration is fully embedded into the Sixth Environmental Action Programme which stipulates that ‘‘sound scientific knowledge and economic assessments, reliable and up-to-date environmental data and information, and the use of indicators will underpin the drawing-up, implementation and evaluation of environmental policy’’.3 This requires, therefore, that scientific inputs constantly feed the environmental policy process. This integration also involves various players, namely the scientific and policy-making communities but also representatives from industry, agriculture, non-governmental organisations etc. (Figure 2.1.1). The problem of non-coincidence of research and policy agendas depends upon the stage of development of the policy. It is more acute at the starting phase of policy design such as thematic strategies defined by the EU 6th Environment Action Programme (e.g. Soil Thematic Strategy).3 In comparison, the Water Framework Directive (WFD),4 along with its related Common Implementation Strategy (see Chapter 4.1), provides a stable platform which allows the building of strong partnerships among policy and scientific communities. In the context of the WFD, we may distinguish R&D needed in support of policy development (e.g. background information required for designing ‘‘daughter directives’’ such as the new Groundwater Directive; see Chapter 3.1) and R&D directly feeding implementation (short- or medium-term research and demonstration projects supporting specific milestones such as e.g. monitoring, integrated management). Long-term R&D is of course also necessary for reviews and possible improvement of the legislation (such as the technical adaptations covered by the WFD and the review periods under the River Basin Management plans). At the present stage, efforts are lacking for presenting results of research and demonstration projects in a form that policy-makers can easily use, e.g. ‘‘science-digested’’ policy briefs. Adversely, one may stress that the consideration of research results by the policy-making community is not straightforward, mainly for political reasons and difficulties in integrating the latest research developments in legislation. The difficulty is enhanced by the fact that the policy-making community is probably not defining its role as ‘‘science
24
Chapter 2.1
customer’’ sufficiently well. In other words, the dialogue and communication are far from being streamlined to allow for an efficient flow of information. In this respect, improvements could be achieved through the development of a ‘‘science–policy interface’’ based on a coordination of relevant programmes/ projects with direct relevance to the WFD implementation. This issue is discussed in Chapter 11.3. Integration in a broad sense, as perceived for the environmental policy sector, goes of course beyond the science–policy issues. It concerns the need to consider the environment as it appears in all relevant policies, interactions of various environmental compartments, socioeconomic aspects, etc. This chapter actually focuses on integration of scientific and technological progress into the policy-making and implementation process, in particular in the groundwater policy sector, illustrating the necessity and complexity of the knowledge-based approach. The above considerations are largely inspired by recent papers discussing this issue.2,5
2.1.2
Science Integration in the Light of Groundwater Management
When dealing with groundwater science and policy, the interdependent nature of hydrological, hydrogeological and water-use systems makes the continuum between data, information and knowledge of particular importance.6 Understanding systemic interactions is essential as a basis of identifying groundwater management options and generating sufficient social consensus to implement them. Developing this understanding requires a steady flow of hydrological data as well as data on water use. It also requires continuous refinement of the scientific foundation, both physical and social, upon which policy and management solutions rely. Examples of this type of progressive approach to groundwater information needs are quoted by Burke and Moench:6 e.g. the Groundwater Forum in the UK7 and the Groundwater Foundation in the USA represent initiatives to address, respectively, groundwater research needs and public education. Another example is the Working Group on Groundwater of the Common Implementation Strategy of the WFD, which is described in Chapter 4.1. Lack of data and scientific understanding of groundwater resources often represents a critical gap undermining the development of groundwater management approaches and institutions.6 The absence of data often limits the degree to which hydrogeologists are able to quantify and describe complex aquifer dynamics. Equally important are the ways in which raw data and information are treated, presented and used. Information is only useful if it used. For this to occur, the information must be accessible to potential users and presented in a manner they can understand. This is discussed in Chapter 11.3 with regard to the development of the EU Water Information System for Europe (WISE). In many instances, however, the absence of information (or the non-use of essential information) creates situations in which emerging
Science–Policy Integration for Common Approaches
25
problems and management options are poorly understood. As a result, the essential nature of basic data and research on hydrogeology should be clear. Generating the technical information required to meet emerging groundwater management needs depends on at least three types of scientific data collection and analytical activities:6 long-term baseline monitoring for understanding the dynamics of hydrogeological systems and providing warning of emerging problems; targeted research on basic processes; and site-specific analysis of problems and management options at local levels. Technicians often make a strong plea for more data, and when they obtain them, they frequently present tentative, difficult-to-interpret scenarios and request financing to collect more data in order to strengthen their interpretations.6 Policy-makers and the general public, on the other hand, often have unrealistic expectations regarding the ability of technical and scientific analyses to provide straightforward answers, particularly given the general paucity of groundwater data and the limited means with which to gather and analyse them. Hydrogeological systems are rarely simple. The importance of bridging this gap between the data available and their policy implications relates directly to some of the fundamental challenges facing the development of management institutions.
2.1.3
Examples of Projects in Support of Groundwater Policy
As highlighted in Section 1, the relevant research for any environmental policy should ideally be feeding the policy-making process directly in a ‘‘tailor-made fashion’’ so that results may be used in the right way and at the right time (in relation to the policy agenda).2 In many instances, however, this is far from being the case. This paragraph lists some RTD projects directly or indirectly related to EU groundwater policy and examines how they were related to policy implementation (Directive 80/68/EEC8 and/or Water Framework Directive) or development (proposal for the new Groundwater Directive described in Chapter 3.1).9 Details on the RTD funding mechanisms and on the priorities under which the projects discussed below have been funded are given in Chapter 11.3. It should be noted that the examples given below do not prejudge about the way project outputs were effectively transferred to the user community (an impact assessment analysis has not been done so far to enable this issue to be concretely discussed), nor do they pretend to provide an exhaustive list of ongoing and terminated projects.
2.1.3.1
Risk Assessment
Research supporting improvements of groundwater (pollution) risk assessment has been flourishing over the past few years (from 1998 onward). Examples are
26
Chapter 2.1
illustrated in several chapters of this book. Most of these projects directly or indirectly support groundwater characterisation needs as well as the future programmes of measures required under the WFD.4 They concern, for example, studies of contaminant spreading in fractured underground reservoirs leading to conceptual geological modelling and database development for organic pollutants in groundwater (TRACE Fracture project; contact:
[email protected]) (see Chapter 5.6); and groundwater risk assessment at contaminated sites leading to guidelines (GRACOS project; contact:
[email protected]).
2.1.3.2
Groundwater Remediation
Examples of projects of direct applicability to groundwater remediation concern, for example, integrated concepts for groundwater remediation, including guidelines and studies on natural attenuation of organic pollutants in groundwater (INCORE project; contact:
[email protected]) (see Chapter 5.8); on-site remediation of groundwater contaminated by polar organic compounds using a new adsorption technology (OROGONATE project; contact:
[email protected]); and protection of groundwater at industrially contaminated sites (PURE project; contact:
[email protected]).
2.1.3.3
Diffuse Pollution
Linked to groundwater analyses of pressures and impacts, some projects examine issues such as, for example, actual status and scenarios of pesticides in European groundwaters (PEGASE project; contact:
[email protected]), integrated soil and water protection from diffuse pollution (SOWA project; contact:
[email protected]), etc. The two projects are described, respectively, in Chapters 9.2 and 5.7.
2.1.3.4
Management Issues and Information Tools
R&D projects also support groundwater management and information tools that are directly or indirectly in support of the WFD river basin management planning. Examples concern, for example, the development of an online portal in the form of a web-based information platform for soil, groundwater and contaminated land (EUGRIS project; contact:
[email protected]); integrated management system (IMS) for the prevention and reduction of contamination at large-scale contaminated sites (WELCOME project; contact:
[email protected]) (see Chapter 7.1); tools for management and control of hazardous compounds in water catchment areas (WATCH project; contact:
[email protected]) (see Chapter 8.3); etc. The scientific basis for improved river basin management through a better understanding of the river– sediment–soil–groundwater system as a whole, at different temporal and spatial scales, is studied in an integrated project, the AQUATERRA project (contact:
[email protected]) (see Chapter 2.2).
Science–Policy Integration for Common Approaches
2.1.3.5
27
Relevant Networks
Besides research projects, networks involving the scientific community, industrial stakeholders, representatives of international associations, NGOs, etc. are directly or indirectly contributing to networking activities that are relevant to groundwater policy development and implementation. Examples of such networks provide exchange of innovative know-how in the field of applied research for contaminated land and groundwater issues (ANCORE network: www. ancore.org); develop technical recommendations for sound decision-making on the rehabilitation of contaminated sites in Europe (CLARINET network: www.clarinet.at); and discuss issues of industrially contaminated land in Europe (NICOLE network: www.nicole.org). Other networks are focused on training, e.g. on innovative management of groundwater resources in Europe (IMAGETRAIN project: www.image-train.net), or on the coordination of national research programmes, e.g. on sustainable management of soil and groundwater under the pressure of soil pollution and soil contamination (SNOWMAN project; contact:
[email protected]) (see Chapter 11.1).
2.1.4
A Project ‘‘Tailor-Made’’ to Support the New EU Groundwater Directive: BRIDGE
The BRIDGE (background criteria for the identification of groundwater thresholds) project was designed to develop a common methodology, intended for possible use by member states, on ‘‘how to derive groundwater threshold values’’. The project was developed in 2004–2006 and has just been concluded. It has been carried out at European level, involving a range of stakeholders and efficiently linking the scientific and policy-making communities. The different objectives were: To evaluate and assemble scientific outputs to set out criteria for the assessment of the chemical status of groundwater. These criteria are data for characterisation of natural and anthropogenic pollutants, parameters indicative for pollution, data for characterisation of groundwater bodies as hydrologic and hydrogeological parameters. To derive a plausible general approach, how to structure relevant criteria appropriately with the aim to set representative groundwater threshold values scientifically sound and defined at national river basin district or groundwater body level. To check the applicability and validity of this approach by means of case studies at the European scale, and to carry out an environmental impact assessment taking into account the economic and social impacts. The final methodology for the derivation of environmental thresholds for pollutants at a national or regional level of groundwater bodies or river basins has been developed in close consultation with representatives from member
28
Chapter 2.1
states’ environment ministries and agencies, and stakeholders from the CIS Working Group on Groundwater. It had to take due considerations of the negotiation of the new Groundwater Directive which was running at the same time, which represented an additional challenge above the sole scientific one. The final meeting was held in Paris on the 15 December 2006. The proposed method for deriving groundwater threshold values will now be directly communicated to the member state experts for policy discussions and expected adoption before summer 2007. The research will therefore fulfil one of the requirements of the new Groundwater Directive, requiring member states to establish groundwater threshold values by the end of 2008, following a common methodological approach. More details on the project are given in Chapter 9.1. The project was terminated at the end of 2006 and a CD-ROM provides a copy of the different findings and workpackage reports to interested stakeholders. Contact: AnneMarie Fouillac (email:
[email protected]).
2.1.5
Conclusions: Some Research Needs
Some basic research needs in support of groundwater management and policy have been expressed by Burke and Moench6 and are outlined below. Basic hydrological and hydrogeological data collection and research, including long-term monitoring of groundwater (levels and quality) and surface water (flows and quality); the synthesis of background information (hydrogeological and socioeconomic data); and detailed investigations in areas where indicators signal the emergence of specific problems. Operational and basic research activities are also essential in order to document and evaluate the results of management attempts and in order to understand key elements of the hydrogeological processes that underpin various management options. Monitoring the resource use and potential sources of pollution. Basic information on how groundwater resources are being used and who is using them is as essential for management as scientific data on the aquifer system itself. Without understanding how groundwater resources are being used, particularly for irrigated agriculture, it is impossible to identify points of management leverage. Devising management systems requires detailed knowledge of such factors as the actual locations where groundwater extraction is occurring, the efficiency with which it is used and its role in agriculture and other water-use systems. Programmes for registering wells and estimating, either directly or indirectly, the amount of groundwater extracted are essential steps. Similarly, it is important to identify, as far as possible, other activities that could have substantial impacts on groundwater conditions. This includes the basic information on potential point and non-point sources of pollutants arising from industry, domestic sewage and agricultural chemical use.
Science–Policy Integration for Common Approaches
29
Besides these research needs, which are still valid at the time of publication of this book, other issues have been highlighted during the development of the new Groundwater Directive, in particular: research on groundwater ecosystems (see Chapter 11.2), and on interactions among groundwater and associated aquatic and dependent terrestrial ecosystems to strengthen the knowledge about environmental groundwater quality; research on groundwater conceptual modelling, georeferencing system, visualisation, vulnerability assessment, enabling to better assess quantitative and qualitative pressures on groundwater systems, as well as the effectiveness of programmes of measures; improved risk assessment and characterisation methods (e.g. support to standardisation of assessment methods for pollutant mobilisation from different types of pollution sources), integrated management approaches, innovative measures for a better protection of groundwater against pollution, etc.; R&D linked to improved programmes of measures, including integration of requirements of different regulations (see Chapter 3.1), and considering identified pressures and the way to tackle them with technically feasible, cost-effective and socially acceptable measures complying with current legislation; and development of new monitoring methods (e.g. in situ techniques, field monitoring) and improvement of data quality and comparability, and pre-normative research related to operationally defined operations (e.g. sampling) and parameters (e.g. extractable contents of chemical substances), etc. The EU 7th Framework Programme of Research and Technological Development10 will take some of these considerations into account in the Theme 6 ‘‘Environment’’. Research outputs will then need to be efficiently transferred to policy-makers, along the principles described in Chapter 11.3.
References 1. UK Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, Science Meets Policy in Europe, DEFRA Report, London, 2005. 2. Ph. Quevauviller, P. Balabanis, C. Fragakis, M. Weydert, M. Oliver, A. Kaschl, G. Arnold, A. Kroll, L. Galbiati, J. M. Zaldivar and G. Bidoglio, Environ. Sci. Pol., 2005, 8, 203. 3. European Commission, 6th Environment Action Plan 2001–2010, 2001. 4. Directive 2000/60/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 October 2000 establishing a framework for Community action in the field of water policy, Official Journal of the European Communities, L 327, 22.12.2000, p. 1. 5. Ph. Quevauviller, J. Environ. Monitor., 2005, 7(2), 89.
30
Chapter 2.1
6. J. J. Burke and M. H. Moench, Groundwater and Society: Resources, Tensions and Opportunities, United Nations, 2000 (ISBN 92-1-104485-5). 7. D. R. C. Grey et al., Groundwater in the United Kingdom. A Strategic Study. Issues and Research Needs. Groundwater Forum Report FG/GF 1, Foundation for Water Research, Marlow, UK, 1995. 8. Council Directive 80/68/EEC of 17 December 1979 on the protection of groundwater against pollution, Official Journal of the European Communities, L 20, 26.1.1980, p. 43. 9. Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on the protection of groundwater against pollution and deterioration, 2006. 10. 7th Framework Programme for Research and Technological Development (2006–2013), European Commission, rue de la Loi 200, B-1049 Brussels, 2006.
CHAPTER 2.2
Transferring Scientific Knowledge to Societal Use: Clue from the AQUATERRA Integrated Project PHILIPPE NE´GREL,a DOMINIQUE DARMENDRAILa AND ADRIAAN SLOBb a
Bureau de Recherches Ge´ologiques et Minie`res (BRGM), 3 avenue Claude Guillemin, FR-45060 Orle´ans ce´dex 2, France; b TNO Environment and Geosciences, Dept Innovation & Environment, Van Mourik Broekmanweg 6, PO Box 49, NL-2600 AA Delft, The Netherlands
2.2.1
Introduction
Scientific knowledge and data are of significant importance in a global information society. They should both be used for promoting innovation and economic development, for efficient and transparent decision-making, particularly at the governmental level, and for education and training. However, scientific data and information should be as widely available and affordable as possible. The more people are able to share them, the greater the positive effects and returns to society will be. Scientific knowledge is a ‘‘public good.’’ The inherent function of scientific investigations is to carry out a comprehensive questioning of nature leading to further knowledge. It is this new knowledge that allows cultural and intellectual enrichment and leads to the technological advances and benefits arising from science. Promoting fundamental research is a priority towards achieving development and progress. There can be no applied science if there is no science to apply and thus science is for knowledge; knowledge is for progress as stated by the World Science Forum (2003; http://www.sciforum.hu/index.php). In the field of water resources management, policy plays a key role. The policy approach is becoming more holistic and the trend is to address the whole 31
32
Chapter 2.2
groundwater–river–sediment–soil system. This widens the quite narrow defined issue of groundwater to a variety of related issues, like nature conservation, the use of space, and economic and social issues. It also confronts groundwater policy with new stakeholders that were not involved in groundwater issues before. So new stakeholders with interests from nature conservation to entrepreneurial interests are entering the policy arena. The until now usual technical approach of the groundwater issue does not fit with these developments, so a new policy approach as well as new ways of involving science in policy are needed. River basins are facing different types of pressures, such as impacts of agriculture, industries or urban waster water treatments. The drivers–pressures–state–impact–response (DPSIR) approach as illustrated by Figure 2.2.1 gives insight into environmental processes and the links between human activities and their impact on the environment. Economic activities (driving forces), such as industry, agriculture and tourism, lead to increasing pressures on the natural environment as these activities result in use of natural resources and/or emissions (accidental or controlled) of waste to water (surface and/or groundwater), soil and sediment. The use of resources and/or emissions will change the state of these environments in quantity and/or quality: sediment, water and soil resources are depleted and/or they are loaded (contaminated) with hazardous substances originating from economic activities. Above a certain level of depletion and/or contamination the environment may be impacted, i.e. loss of biodiversity, vulnerability to floods and landslides, decreased chemical and/or ecological water, soil or sediment quality and/or a shortage of these resources. Thus the DPSIR framework provides a helpful, conceptual framework for further improvement of system understanding.
Figure 2.2.1
Pressures on river basins.
Transferring Scientific Knowledge to Societal Use
33
In the past, water quality studies and monitoring in the major river basins1 have developed according to: (i) the water demand, which is increasing exponentially; (ii) the development of key issues, such as eutrophication, acidification, salinisation; (iii) new pressures (radionuclides since the 1950s, pesticides since the 1980s, endocrine disruptors and pharmaceuticals more recently); and (iv) the development of new technical tools such as analytical chemistry, in situ monitoring or models. Management of river basins will certainly benefit from an increased scientific understanding of the functioning of the biophysical system (i.e. water–sediment–soil interactions) and of its relation to the societal system like the application of scientific knowledge in river basin management and in policymaking and implementation. This chapter deals with the preliminary results issued from the 6th Framework Programme (FP) Integrated Project AQUATERRA and the transfers from the scientific research area to a policy and societal use.
2.2.2
Overview of the AQUATERRA Project
The European Commission (EC) anticipated the need to improve our common understanding of the functioning of river systems, especially in relation to changes in land use and climate. Hence, under their RTD Framework Programmes several research projects have been funded, aimed at improving this understanding, and at supporting the Water Framework Directive (WFD) implementation. AQUATERRA, the full title of which is ‘‘Integrated modelling of river– sediment–soil–groundwater systems: advanced tools for the management of catchment areas and river basins in the context of global change,’’ is one of the first Integrated Projects within the 6th European Union (EU) Framework Programme (see website at http://www.eu-aquaterra.de/ for detailed information). AQUATERRA, including a multidisciplinary team of 45 partner organisations in 12 EU countries (researchers, but also practitioners and end-users such as policy-makers, river basin managers and regional and urban land planners), has been active since 1 June 2004 and will run until May 2009. AQUATERRA aims to provide the scientific basis for an improved river basin management through a better understanding of the river–sediment–soil– groundwater system as a whole, by integrating both natural and socioeconomic aspects at different temporal and spatial scales.2 This should be applicable to European contexts facing modifications or changes due to climate change, land use and pollution of soil and water. The principal task of AQUATERRA is to provide the foundations for an improved understanding of the behaviour of environmental pollutants in order
34
Chapter 2.2
to better evaluate the evolution of water quality at different scales, from local to global scales. New field and laboratory as well as historical data will be assembled and addressed in four European river basins (Ebro, Meuse, Elbe and Danube) and a small French catchment (Bre´villes). Based on these biogeochemical, climatological and material flux data, new simulation models will help to outline trends and pollutant transport behaviour with respect to soil functioning and the water cycle. These models will integrate key biogeochemical and hydrological processes from the laboratory to the river basin scale. AQUATERRA is divided in ten sub-projects with different functions to provide information and logistical support to each other as illustrated in Figure 2.2.2. Note that the whole project is presented in a flyer (available at http:// www.attempto-projects.de/aquaterra/uploads/media/Flyerfinal_13_10_05.pdf). Some sub-projects have a scientific focus (i.e. TREND, FLUX, COMPUTE, BIOGEOCHEM, BASIN, HYDRO, MONITOR) while others are more focused on the social sciences and European policies (i.e. EUPOL and INTEGRATOR). Finally, KNOWMAN has the role of knowledge transfer and dissemination. Some new developments have been done in INTEGRATOR and EUPOL sub-projects which combine hard (hydrogeology, chemistry, geochemistry, etc.) and soft (policy, socioeconomics) sciences. Using two of the five river basins studied in AQUATERRA as case studies, we will explore the new role of science in the societal information use and the development of the Environment Policy, and in particular the Water Resources legal framework.
Impact of Global Change on Soil and Water
TREND Future trends and impacts
HYDRO Global climate Water cycle
FLUX Intercompartement mass fluxes BIOGEOCHEM Key processes Transport functions
Figure 2.2.2
BASIN - Applications • Brevilles • Ebro • Meuse • Elbe • Danube EUPOL - Policies • EU policy framework • R & D requirements INTEGRATOR • Economic and social aspects • Stakeholder needs
Bench scale
MONITOR Screening tools Pollutants
Catchmentscale
COMPUTE Integrated soil-water numerical models
Basin scale
Scientific Methodology
KNOWMAN • Dissemination activities • Knowledge transfer
The ten sub-projects of AQUATERRA working on different levels and scales.
Transferring Scientific Knowledge to Societal Use
2.2.3
Environmental Policies
2.2.3.1
Four Generations of Environmental Policies
35
Environmental policies have been developed continuously from the 1960s, when environmental problems were recognised. Various authors have described the development of environmental policy.3–5 In this chapter we distinguish four generations of environmental policies that developed subsequently.6 These generations are all needed to tackle environmental problems and thus are not replacing or competing with each other but are complementary. The first generation started in the 1960s/1970s. Because of poor environmental conditions and health problems in some regions, an environmental consciousness awoke in the public, and governments adopted new sets of environmental regulations and rules. For the most part, environmental measures involved end-of-pipe techniques to reduce emissions. The focus of environmental policies in the first generation was on regulatory measures: laws and rules. At the beginning of the 1980s, awareness increased that regulatory measures on their own were not enough to tackle the environmental problems adequately. This cleared the way for voluntary measures. The second generation of environmental policies focused strongly on prevention of environmental damage by a mix of voluntary measures and regulations. The focus of these voluntary and regulatory measures was, for example, on energy saving and waste reduction. Environment had become a topic in quality and safety systems of businesses and environmental management systems had become quite popular. So in the second generation of environmental policies, the attention shifted from end-of-pipe techniques to process-integrated measures designed to prevent pollution being emitted to the environment. In the 1990s, attention shifted from prevention within the factory to prevention of emissions within the whole production–consumption chain. Product oriented policies and chain management are typical examples of the third generation of environmental policies. The environmental aspects of products were measured during their entire life cycle and incorporated in chain management and the product design process. Major efforts were put into the communication with external stakeholders concerning the environmental performance. The policy instruments that were being used were of a voluntary nature, sometimes supported by legislative and/or financial measures. In the beginning of the 2000s even new strategies were needed because persistent environmental problems still were present. Some problems like acidification had been tackled quite well, but more persistent problems, like the emission of CO2 or the spreading of chemicals in the environment, were harder to tackle. So in the beginning of the present century the need for a fourth generation of environmental policy was derived. Although this generation of environmental policies is still developing, we can see already contours of it. In the last Dutch Environmental Policy Plan 4 (2001) ‘‘transition management’’ is presented as a key concept to tackle persistent environmental problems. The policy approach is rather process-oriented instead of contentoriented and has an interactive character.
36
Chapter 2.2
Table 2.2.1 presents an overview of the four generations of environmental policies. When we examine the characteristics of the generations more closely, a clear trend becomes apparent. We can see an increasing complexity of the environmental problems which is reflected in an increasing complexity in environmental policies. Where in the first generation goals are set quite straightforwardly, legislative instruments are being used and the number of actors is limited, in the fourth generation goals are discussed and formed with societal actors over a long period, participation is the most important instrument and the number of actors is numerous. Whereas the policy in the first generation is directly aimed at cleaning the environment in a straightforward way, in the fourth generation this aim has shifted towards upgrading environmental quality by means of system innovations and societal change.
2.2.3.2
Science in the Four Generations of Environmental Policies
What does the development of environmental policies described above mean for knowledge production in the four generations of environmental policy? In the first generation the demand for knowledge comes only from government, and is quite technical in nature. In the fourth generation, the strategy is directed towards societal change to diminish environmental damage and the number of actors involved is quite numerous. The demand for knowledge comes now from different actor groups. Therefore, the new policy approach in the third, but especially in the fourth, generation will call for a new way of dealing with knowledge in the policy process. This fits well with the ideas of Gibbons et al.7 who reflected on the role of science in society. According to them, science is undergoing a major shift from mode 1 science—the traditional way of production of scientific knowledge—to mode 2 science. In this mode 2, the societal context is very important for knowledge production. Mode 2 science has five characteristics that distinguish it from mode 1 science (see Table 2.2.2). Mode 2 science is generated in the context of application, whereas mode 1 science is produced in the ‘‘classic’’ academic environment. ‘‘The context of application describes the total environment in which scientific problems arise, methodologies are developed, outcomes are disseminated, and uses are defined.’’8 Furthermore, mode 2 science is produced in a ‘‘trans-disciplinary’’ way, ‘‘by which is meant the mobilisation of a range of theoretical perspectives and practical methodologies to solve problems. But, unlike inter- or multidisciplinarity, it is not necessarily derived from pre-existing disciplines nor does it always contribute to the formation of new disciplines.’’8 Mode 1 science is produced in the academic setting (one place, a certain time), is organised in a hierarchical way and involves academic peers to control the quality of the output. Mode 2 science is developed close to the place of application, is organised in a heterarchical manner and quality control is performed by societal actors. Mode 2 science matches quite well to the fourth generation of environmental policy because of the social accountability, the
Staff member
Legislation and external pressure New technology, registration, monitoring
Low
Actors involved
Drivers for actors
Complexity
Actions
Substances, emissions
Process changes, communication (internal and external) Moderate
Efficiency
Whole company
Processes
Regulation, voluntary measures
Legislation and regulation
Scope
Prevention
Second generation
Clean-up operations
First generation
Characteristics of four generations of environmental policies.
Means to reduce environmental damage Policy instruments
Table 2.2.1
High
Product design, balanced scorecard, covenants, etc.
Companies and stakeholders, consumers Strategic performance
Voluntary measures, financial instruments, regulations Products, production chain processes
Chain management
Third generation
Very high
Sustainability, licence to operate Societal dialogue, institutional change, etc.
Sustainability, societal processes, system innovations Societal groups
Participatory instruments
Network management
Fourth generation
Transferring Scientific Knowledge to Societal Use 37
38
Chapter 2.2
Table 2.2.2
Characteristics of mode 1 and mode 2 science.7
Knowledge developed Knowledge production Place and way of knowledge production Organisation Quality control
Figure 2.2.3
Mode 1
Mode 2
Academic context (Mono)disciplinary Homogeneous (one place, a certain time)
Context of application Transdisciplinary Heterogeneous (knowledge developed close to the place of application) Heterarchical, transient
Hierarchical, preserves form Academic, peer review
Socially accountable, reflexive
General map of the Ebro basin and its distribution within the Communinades Automonas (FR, France; AND, Andorra; CV, Valencia; PV, Pais Vasco; CM, Castilla la Mancha; CN, Galicia; AR, Arago´n; CA, Catalun˜a; CL, Castilla y Leon; Na, Navarra; LR, La Rioja).
fact that it recognises the importance of stakeholder views and, more generally, because of the emphasis on the context of application.
2.2.4
AQUATERRA Case Studies
2.2.4.1
The Ebro Case study
2.2.4.1.1
Context
The Ebro river basin is located in northeast Spain (Figure 2.2.3). The river itself is approximately 930 km long and drains a basin of approximately 85 500 km2 in area, or 17.3% of the surface area of Spain. The total basin area is drained by 347 main tributaries with a combined length of approximately 12 000 km. The
39
Transferring Scientific Knowledge to Societal Use
river ends at the Ebro delta, one of the most important wetlands in Europe, covering an area of about 320 km2 of sediments with wetlands and coastal lagoons, which are valuables in terms of natural resources and related economic activities. The total mean annual runoff is approximately 6.837 106 m3 and the total water storage capacity of the 187 reservoirs that regulate the water flow is around 57%. The northern tributaries provide a greater contribution to the discharge than those in the south because the former drainage basins are located in higher rainfall areas. Monthly water discharge is quite irregular, with a significant decrease during the 20th century attributed mainly to increased water use for human activities (agricultural irrigation, reservoirs, electricity production and domestic consumption). Large hydroelectric power plants in the Ebro system supply 50% of Spain’s electricity. Irrigation is responsible for an important hydraulic deficit. An average of 300 m3 s1 is taken off the river: its natural flow in the early 20th century (1914–1935) was around 590 m3 s1, whereas in the last few decades (1960–1990) it was 430 m3 s1, i.e. a 28% reduction.9 A summary of the present and potential future drivers and pressures acting upon different economic areas in the Ebro basin (agriculture, industry and tourism) is shown in Table 2.2.3.
Table 2.2.3
Present Agriculture Industry
Tourism Other Future Agriculture
Summary of main drivers and pressures in the Ebro basin Drivers
Pressures
Increased productivity Abandonment of agricultural land in high altitude zones Increased use of hydroelectricity
Water supplies Soil quality
Chemicals, metals and manufacturing industries Influx of tourists during summer months Recreational use of waters Population concentration in urban areas/ depopulation in rural areas Increased production of non-food crops Increase in agrochemical applications
Industry Tourism Other
Increase in irrigated area Growth in metals, chemicals, construction and manufacturing industries Potential increase in tourists Population concentration in urban areas/ depopulation in rural areas
Water supply downstream Sediment loads Water supplies Water quality Water supplies Water quality Water supply Land use Water supply Soil quality Water quality Water supply Water quality Water supply Water supply Water quality Water supply
40
Chapter 2.2
2.2.4.1.2
Management Structure at the River Basin Level
Overall responsibility for water resources in Spain belongs to the Ministry for the Environment. Individual river basins are controlled by the relevant river basin authority, the Confederacion Hidrografica del Ebro, created in 1926 (website http://www.chebro.es/). Under the Water Law dated 1985, the responsibilities of the local water authorities are as follows: Planning: – implementation, monitoring and revision of the Hydrological Plan for the basin as appropriate. Management: – administration and control of public works and water supply, – administration and control of uses which are in the general interest or which affect more than one Communinade Automona. Investment: – planning and construction of works appropriate to the organisation and approved by the state.
2.2.4.1.3
Problems Encountered in the Management of Groundwater Resources
The key issues in this river basin are the following. Water scarcity. The quantity of water available is insufficient to meet the agricultural, industrial, commercial and domestic needs of the population within the basin. Many irrigation facilities in the basin are old and inefficient, but the cost of improving them would not be offset by increased yields and reduced water demand. The construction of large dams to retain limited water resources has altered the hydrological regime of the basin dramatically, which has resulted in many ecological impacts. Salinisation. The abstraction of ground and surface water and widespread irrigation has increased the deterioration of water and soil quality. High levels of salts in both the soil and underlying geology have resulted in high levels of salts in the available water supply. This is compounded by groundwater abstraction, which concentrates salts and increases invasion of aquifers by marine water. Water, soil and sediment quality. The surface waters of the Ebro basin are of poor quality due to high levels of industrial and agricultural chemicals from both point and diffuse sources. High levels of mercury and DDT are a particular problem, as are levels of nitrates in soil and groundwater. Soil erosion. Intense agriculture on saline soils leads to a deterioration in soil structure and quality, which in turn leaves the soil more susceptible to erosion. The areas most susceptible to soil erosion in the basin are in the Catalan Chain to the south of Fraga, Lleida, Alcaniz and Caspe.
Transferring Scientific Knowledge to Societal Use
41
Ecological issues. The ecology of the delta is under pressure from two key areas. First is the poor water quality as described above, which leads to a deterioration of habitats, with consequences for the wildlife which depends upon it for survival. Second are the reductions in water flow and sediment transport caused by dam construction, which results in erosion of the Ebro delta, a nature reserve of European importance. This is of less importance for groundwater issues.
2.2.4.1.4
Main Contributions of AQUATERRA in the Ebro Basin
A workshop managed by AQUATERRA was held on 7 April 2006 in Barcelona with stakeholders from representatives of unions and water authorities, through academics, industry representatives and students, agricultural community and water distribution companies involved in the Ebro river basin. Aims of the workshop were (i) to discuss the key environmental issues affecting the water–sediment–soil–groundwater system in the Ebro river basin; (ii) to discuss the evolution of these issues in the context of the DPSIR model used throughout AQUATERRA, with a view to establishing a suitable area for an economic case study; (iii) to inform stakeholders from the Ebro river basin about the work being undertaken by AQUATERRA within the basin area and to engage stakeholders in the work of AQUATERRA; and (iv) to interest them in further activities aimed at interaction with the project. Having identified the key issues for the basin, the concept of DPSIR was thus applied to assess what the drivers, pressures, impacts and responses to key environmental issues were and suggesting how they might change in the future. For the drivers (e.g. the factors of change), the main confirmed ones were the WFD and other water-related policies, the planning of water management by the Confederation Hidrogra´fica del Ebro and the demographic developments within and beyond the basin, especially on the coast, including the concentration of the population in the urban areas and the development of industry in zones with a limited water supply. For the pressures, agriculture is the main one within the basin, as it affects both salinity and water quantity and quality problems. Some isolated pressures from local industries are also significant in terms of water quality. A less important, but nonetheless significant pressure is exerted by large urban areas and tourist zones on the coast, both within and beyond the basin due to water transfers. In this basin, a large range of contaminants are encountered and should be monitored at different scales. For the impacts, those on flora and fauna and ecology are the most significant. For the responses, e.g. the measures taken or to be taken in order to respond to impacts, the reduction of water consumption in general would be the only efficient, long-term, sustainable solution to the current situation. The activity most directly and immediately affected by this change would be agriculture; industry and urban areas would also be affected by water economy. Within AQUATERRA, the sub-project MONITOR aims to provide, develop and validate analytical tools necessary for the monitoring of organic and
42
Chapter 2.2
inorganic pollutants in water/sediment/soil compartments with the final objective to identify those present at relevant concentrations. In the Ebro basin, studies started on the occurrence and the distribution of contaminants in the river basin. Numerous compounds have been analysed (trace metals, pesticides, PAHs, BTEX, PCBs, etc.). High concentrations were detected in some areas describing situations where the environmental impact is high (i.e. with fluoranthene, benzo[a]pyrene, benzo[b]fluoranthene). But in the field of environmental monitoring, the information of interest is spread over time and space. Therefore the choice of monitoring locations can be a key issue in terms of global costs. Optimisation of the sampling network is currently done in an effective and economic way (by improving on time intervals for sample retrieval and analysis of selected compounds). The environmental assessment of the Ebro river basin will be improved by the coupled use of chemometrics modelling of monitoring data, various sampler devices, Geographical Information System (GIS) and remote sensing information systems.
2.2.4.1.5
Problems to be Solved in the Future
The identification and validation of major issues within the Ebro basin as a whole lead to the problems that should be solved in the future in the context of progress resulting from knowledge. One of the most important problems to be solved is that of water abstraction. A reduction of water consumption in agriculture would have positive consequence on both the quantity of water consumed and soil quality, as an excess of stagnant water left on fields after irrigation increases soil salinity through water evaporation. For agriculture the improvement of the water efficiency of irrigation systems should be urgently solved. One solution would be the reuse of affected groundwater. Reuse of water would also improve the perception of agriculture by the population in general. A further alternative solution to the lack of water is desalinisation of seawater. Although this was only considered as a temporary solution, it was nevertheless considered preferable to water transfers from the Ebro to southern regions outside the basin. In the case of very acute localised problems, the compulsory purchase of agricultural land in order to avoid cultivation has been suggested, although this would clearly have a significant economic impact for those directly affected and is not a widely supported proposal for the long term. Changing to less water-intensive crops could also be undertaken, potentially at a large scale, although the economic viability of producing a different crop must be considered. At a very large scale this measure should be carefully evaluated and would only be possible under technical and market conditions.
2.2.4.1.6
The Lessons Learned
Discussions have been conducted with the major stakeholders with a common agreement on the fact that drinking water is the priority use in the basin and that future planning should aim to maintain the quantity and quality of the
Transferring Scientific Knowledge to Societal Use
43
supply. More general problems arising in the management of the basin are (i) the fact that water is free or not charged at it true value, (ii) the implementation of water management policy is not optimal across the basin, (iii) the extent of irrigated areas is continuously increasing requiring an evaluation of the impact of these new areas before improving the irrigation systems of existing areas (to be done at the river basin level to be efficient) and (iv) there is an imbalance in the quality of water treatment between that which is treated and exported to users outside the basin and that which is produced for use within the basin; consequently there is less investment in water within the basin. AQUATERRA and future research projects should investigate some of these areas in the future, like defining decision-making tools for solving identified specific important problems relevant to the river–sediment–soil–groundwater system and socioeconomic analysis of the impacts and responses (like in the Coordination Action Risk-Base of the 6th FP). These tools could be relevant for a policy directive like the WFD. But in many ways, the River Ebro is unique, with its specific management administration system, its combination of distinct climatic issues and some specific problems (such as salinisation). Therefore the Ebro does not easily fit into a standard ‘‘model’’ of a European catchment.
2.2.4.2 2.2.4.2.1
The Meuse Case Study Context
The Meuse river basin is one of the smallest international districts in Europe. The Meuse has its source in the Langres Plateau in France and flows from Belgium and the Netherlands to the North Sea. A part of the Meuse river basin belongs to Germany and Luxembourg even though the river itself does not cross these countries. The Meuse is about 950 km long and its basin represents between 30 000 and 35 500 km2 according to the various information sources (Figure 2.2.4). The rivers of the Meuse basin are mainly plain rivers, characterised by broad valleys and weak medium slopes. Belgium is a central country for the Meuse management since it contains 41% of the total area of Meuse basin (5% in Flanders and 36% in Wallonia) and the basin represent 46% of the whole country area (Figure 2.2.4). The remaining area belongs to the Scheldt river basin. France is the second country, representing 26% of the Meuse river basin (9% in Champagne-Ardennes region, 3% in Nord-Pas-de-Calais and 14% in Lorraine region) whereas the Meuse basin only represents less than 1% of French territory. One-fifth of the basin is located in the southern part of the Netherlands (14% in NoordBrabant region, 6% in Limburg and less than 1% in Zuid-Holland) and the Meuse basin represents 22% of the country. The German Nordrhein-Westfalen (NRW) land covers 11% of the basin (6% of Du¨sseldorf region and 5% of Ko¨ln) and the Meuse basin represents only 1% of the German area. Around 5 to 10% of the Luxembourg area is also included in the basin but it represents less than 300 km2.
44
Figure 2.2.4
Chapter 2.2
Meuse basin (source: IMC11,12).
The Meuse river basin can be characterised by a low runoff coefficient. Rivers are dominated by a rainfall–evaporation regime and the annual runoff is generally about 258 mm per year in the River Meuse. The long-term average discharge is 250 m3 s1 and total volume per year is 7.6 km3 on average. However, since the Meuse is a rain-fed river, the maximum flow can be as
Transferring Scientific Knowledge to Societal Use
45
high as 3000 m3 s1 in the winter and the minimum flow as low as 10 m3 s1 in the summer. The main land uses in the Meuse river basin are distributed as shown in Figure 2.2.5. The most industrialised regions and those having the most intensive agriculture are also those having the highest population density. A summary of the present and potential future drivers and pressures acting upon different economic areas in the Meuse basin (agriculture, forestry, industry and urban development) is shown in Table 2.2.4.
2.2.4.2.2
Management Structure at the River Basin Level
In the 15th and 16th centuries, the present Dutch and Belgian territories and some parts of France formed one country, the 17 Dutch provinces. But until the independence of Belgium in 1839, both countries began to formulate their own policies, particularly about transport, industrial and agricultural activities in the Scheldt and Meuse basin.10 Diverging interests arise concerning waterways and sharing availability of water (quality, quantity) for drinking water production. In the 20th century there were several attempts to have an international agreement concerning the Meuse basin and finally an agreement was signed in 1994. Thus, collaboration between the basin states of the Meuse is in its infancy compared to that of the Rhine.11 The main agreements concerning the Meuse basin signed to date are: 1992 1994
1995
2002
w
Agreement about the protection and use of transboundary watercourses and international lakes signed 17 March 1992. Agreement on the protection of the Meuse (France, the Walloon region, the Flemish region, the Brussels Region and the Netherlands) signed 26 April 1994 in Charleville-Me´zie`res. Meuse Discharge Treaty (Netherlands and the Flanders region). Equal sharing of water by both partners during low-water periods and a common responsibility for the Border Meuse.w Creation of the International Commission for the Protection of the Meuse (ICPM). The agreement on the flood protection action plan for the Meuse. The ministers of the riparian states declared in Arles (France) the necessity to reduce the flood risk and harmonise flood-reducing measures. They particularly stressed the harmonisation of spatial planning, land use and water management in the river basin. International agreement on the Meuse (Germany, Belgium, the Brussels, Walloon and Flanders regions, France, Luxembourg and the Netherlands) signed 3 December 2002 in Gand.
For further information about the Border Meuse management, see ‘‘River management and low flows in the river Meuse in the Netherlands’’.
46
Chapter 2.2
59% 28% 11%
1%
Figure 2.2.5
Table 2.2.4
Urban areas
Agricultural areas
Others
Water areas
1%
Forest areas
Land use in the Meuse basin (adapted from9).
Summary of main drivers and pressures in the Meuse basin.
Present Agriculture
Forestry Industry
Urban development
Others
Future Agriculture Industry Urban development Other
Drivers
Pressures
Increased productivity: cereals, maize and meadows Intensive farming systems like horticulture, glasshouse cultivation and breeding Increased sylviculture activities Increased industrial discharges Accidental and hazardous pollution Increased water abstraction volumes
Water supplies Water quality Soil quality
Energy, mining, chemistry, metals, construction and agro-food industries Population concentration in urban areas Increased water abstraction Water sanitation (discharge of wastewater) Fluvial transport (numerous navigable rivers and canals) Leisure and tourism versus discharge of wastewater Increased of agrochemical applications Increased in glasshouse cultivation Growth in some of the main industrial activities Population growth and concentrations, increased density Increased leisure demands
Water quality Sediment loads Water supply downstream Water supplies Water quality Water supplies Water supply Water quality Water quantity Water quantity Water quality Soil quality Water quality Water quantity Soil quality Water quantity and quality Water Supply Water sanitation Water quantity and quality
Transferring Scientific Knowledge to Societal Use
47
Actually, the International Meuse Commission (IMC) plays an important role in international consultations. Its purpose is to obtain sustainable integrated water management in the international basin of the Meuse. From its creation, the IMC has established three action programmes: the preliminary programme (1995–1997), the short-term programme (1998–2003) and the longterm programme (2003–2010). The important targets of the Meuse short-term programme included:12
reduction of urban and industrial discharges; reduction of diffuse pollution; prevention form accidental and hazardous pollution; monitoring water quality; sediment management; ecological improvement of water quality; and knowledge exchange between countries.
The present action program (2003–2010) also includes flood prevention and protection and has a main target to contribute to the implementation of the WFD.
2.2.4.2.3
Problems Encountered in the Management of Groundwater Resources
The key issues in this river basin are the following. Water scarcity. The quantity of water available could be insufficient to meet the needs of the different activities within the basin (agriculture, industries and domestic uses). In some areas, water exploitation is concentrated in specific surface or ground waterbodies, causing large problems for water availability and localised environmental problems to the water ecosystems. A significant example is the Tournaisis aquifer (Hainaut, Wallonia), where water is extracted at rate higher than the aquifer recharge capability. The Netherlands is also strongly dependent on the surface water of the Meuse for its drinking water production. Groundwater quality. Even if the groundwater system does not have a homogeneous network of measures all along the Meuse river basin, its quality seems to become degraded from the upper to the lower stretch of the river basin, in particular with nitrates and pesticides. Other contaminants are also brought by point-source pollution from industry (hydrocarbon fuels, solvents, but also chloride, iron bore and heavy metals from mines in France). Bad quality of the past mining reservoirs may affect the groundwater quality of the Meuse Dogger aquifer: – by the rising of saline water from the mines reservoirs towards the bottom of the aquifer, and/or – by the infiltration of surface water contaminated by the waters out flowing from the flooded mines.
48
Chapter 2.2
The hydromorphology modification of the Meuse. Since 1883, the Meuse has been largely managed by humans to support navigation, economic development and flood protection. The major interventions involved the building of river control structures (weirs, dams and sluices, particularly in Walloon and Dutch parts) and banks (training walls, quays, etc.) and modifying the river bed by regular dredging of sediment. Such modifications to river imposed changes to the morphology (river fragmentation) and to the hydrological regime which have an impact on other factors including: – Flooding: the extent of zone liable to extreme flooding (over the protection designed) is limited and hence the water volume that may be naturally stored in floodplains is also limited. – Sedimentation and transport: when the level discharge is low, the sedimentation transport is greatly reduced behind weirs. As the discharge increases, the deposited sediments are carried again and the volume load is greater than without weirs. According to IMC,11 the amount of sediments transported have tripled because of the hydromorphological modification. – Ecological function: as a consequence, biodiversity became poor in certain stretches and migration routes for fish have been disturbed. Diffuse pollution. Agriculture, industrial activities and household discharges all contribute to diffuse pollution on soil and water bodies. The main pollutants are nitrates, fertilisers, manure and pesticides (like diuron and atrazine) which may induce the eutrophication of the river and thus that of the North Sea. The total concentration of diffuse pollutant in the water system is very important from a drinking water perspective as the River Meuse is a source of drinking water for more than 6 million inhabitants. Some new dangerous chemicals like endocrine disruptors, and new medicines from pharmaceutical industry have recently appeared. When looking at effects on water quality, all pollutants should be considered together for understanding their impacts on the ecology of the system.
2.2.4.2.4
Main Contributions of AQUATERRA in the Meuse Basin
The main study objects in the Meuse basin are: (i) contaminated floodplain sediments; (ii) soil–sediment–groundwater–river interaction in the catchment of the Dommel (a tributary to the Meuse); (iii) groundwater quality effects by river–groundwater interaction in the Belgian part of the Meuse system, more specifically near Lie`ge (Fle´malle cookery site) and in the Geer basin; (iv) quantification of coupled ecotoxicological effects of contaminants from sediment, suspended solids and freshwater on aquatic organisms at a number of Walloon locations; and (v) socioeconomic aspects of global change. This needs
Transferring Scientific Knowledge to Societal Use
49
integration of multiple disciplines, from geosciences, environmental engineering and chemistry to socioeconomic sciences, from the catchment to the regional scale, as is done in AQUATERRA. The main AQUATERRA contributions in the Meuse presented during the 2nd International Meuse Symposium in Sedan (18–19 May 2006) organised under the auspices of the IMC13 (http://www.meuse-maas.be/) concerned: metal speciation and bioaccumulation in floodplain soil and sediment; nitrate trends in the chalk aquifer of the Geer sub-basin in Belgium; breakdown of leaves as an indicator for sediment quality and ecosystem functioning; ecotoxicological effects of contaminants on aquatic organisms in the River Meuse; metal availability in the Dommel sub-catchment; and measurement of metal concentrations (Cd, Zn, Cu, Fe, Ni) in soil and earthworms in the Dommel sub-catchment. In parallel with the work done in BASIN, the sub-project FLUX investigates the temporal and spatial trends of suspended matter pollution in the Meuse River. Spatial and temporal differences in suspended matter (SPM) quality in the Dutch part of the Meuse can be attributed to point sources contribution, variation in river discharge and sedimentation processes. The large fluctuations in metal content during summer indicate an irregular contribution of point sources from the upstream area, most likely from the Liege industries; to control the high pollution levels of suspended matter, this contribution from Belgian industrial areas should be reduced. The spots of contaminated suspended matter deposition in the summer should be traced back to reduce the risks of higher contamination levels on floodplain areas by re-suspension of contaminated river bed sediment and possible long-term exposure of contaminated bed sediment in the river environment during dry periods.
2.2.4.2.5
Problems to be Solved in the Future
Among the major issues for the Meuse River, the sanitation in the Walloon part of the Meuse basin is one of the most important. Although 95% of the population is connected to a collective sewage system, collective treatment capacity (1.1 million IE) only represents 37% of the urban and industrial wastewater volume (respectively 2 and 1 million IE) that had to be treated in 2002. Figure 2.2.6 shows that numbers of treatment plants are under construction, granted or under study, but 18% remain non-existent. Moreover the whole Walloon stretch is considered as a ‘‘sensitive area’’ under the Council Directive 91/271/EECz: all treatment plants with capacity exceeding 10 000 IE have to ensure a treatment against phosphorus and nitrates (tertiary treatment). z
Council Directive 91/271/EEC of 21 May 1991 concerning urban wastewater treatment.
50
Chapter 2.2 non existent plants 18% plants in study 9%
existing plants 37%
projected plants 1% granted plants 24%
Figure 2.2.6
plants in construction 11%
Treatment plants in the Walloon stretch in 2002: distribution of IE to be treated.
Treatment capacity rates vary within the Walloon stretch from 13% in the ‘‘Meuse aval’’ sub-basin to 73% in the ‘‘Vesdre’’ sub-basin.
2.2.4.2.6
The Lessons Learned
Discussions have been conducted with the major stakeholders of the Meuse river basin and have shown that building a global scenario for managing the basin at the river basin scale remains a challenge for several reasons: The stakeholders have limited knowledge and information on possible future changes in the key drivers and their trends. The identified drivers, the economic activities, are really comprehensive and need to be disaggregated to be more issue-specific (e.g. for agriculture, irrigation drainage, fertilisers and pesticide uses) to be sufficiently analysed and used for decision-making. The complexity of the management system needs to be simplified by developing accurate indicators based on basic simple figures, still to be identified. There are different decision-making levels (local, regional, national and international in the case of the Meuse river basin) and the important issues at one of these levels are not necessarily viewed as important at another, in particular at the river basin scale. Stakeholders concerned by environmental problems have a perception coming from societal pressures that differs from the scientifically based approach based on detailed factual information. Even the time horizon taken into consideration by both is different, being shorter for the stakeholder issues. Developing scenarios for the sediment–soil–water system is very complex, with multiple possible entries: (i) system components (soil, sediment, groundwater and surface water); (ii) drivers and factors of change (climate, economic and policy changes); (iii) spatial scale of analysis (local/small area, regional, national, sub-basin and basin levels);
Transferring Scientific Knowledge to Societal Use
51
(iv) temporal scale (short, medium and long term); (v) potential issues at stake (organic pollution, diffuse pollution by nitrate, sediment contamination, water pollution by heavy metals, etc.). Therefore, defining longterm scenarios for some specific issue at case study scale should be more appropriate than global management scenarios.
2.2.5
Discussions of the Contributions of AQUATERRA to Societal Use Related to Groundwater Resources Management
As shown in the case studies discussed above, human activities have greatly modified the water resources systems through climate change, land use changes, water engineering and releases of wastes and pollutants in the aquatic systems (Table 2.2.5). Nevertheless, aquatic systems have also high natural spatial heterogeneity. Therefore, understanding and modelling the degree of heterogeneity of water systems will be different and will depend on the scale of interest (Table 2.2.6). The sediment–soil–water issues have to be addressed at different levels, i.e. local, regional, national or international. An important issue at the regional/ national level is not necessarily viewed as an important issue at the river basin scale. The response and management concerns may also vary between the different levels, especially for a transboundary river basins such as that of the Meuse. This complexity of the studied system induces some key elements for the new modern ways of knowledge production. Knowledge production should be socially accountable and should acknowledge the multiple rationalities and different viewpoints that are brought in by the variety of stakeholders that are involved. This means that the research methods should contain the following key elements. Multi- and/or transdisciplinary research methods – Acknowledge the disciplines that should be involved in the research to give more insight in the policy issue, the problem framing and the solutions. – Work together in multidisciplinary teams and emphasise the process of interaction between the disciplines and evaluate these processes. – Take time to develop new theoretical multidisciplinary scientific frameworks. Involvement of the stakeholders in the research process – Develop methods to involve stakeholders and to deal with their viewpoints and values in the research process. – Appreciation of the values, interests and viewpoints of involved stakeholders ask for development of new research methods to develop
x x x x
x
x X
x x
x
x
A
X x x x
x x x
x
x
x x
x
x X X x
x x
x
X
x x x
x
X
C
x
B
x
x
x x
x
x
x
X X x
X
D
x
x
x
x
x
x x x x
E
A: human health; B: hydrological cycle balance; C: water quality; D: global carbon balance; E: fluvial morphology; F: aquatic biodiversity; G: coastal zone impacts.
6. Irrigation / water transfer
5. Urban waters
4. Industrialisation and mining
3. River damming and channelling
2. Land use changes
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
1. Climate variability and changes
development of non-perennial rivers segmentation of river networks changes in flow regimes development of extreme flow events changes in wetlands distribution/function changes in chemical weathering changes in soil erosion salt water intrusion in coastal groundwater salinisation through evaporation wetland filling or draining changes in water pathways changes in sediment transport urbanisation alteration of first-order streams nitrate and phosphate increase pesticides increase nutrient and carbon retention retention of particulates loss of longitudinal and lateral connectivity creation of new wetlands increases of heavy metals and POPs Acidification of surface waters salinisation sediment sources nitrate and phosphate increase enhancement of waterborne diseases organic pollution heavy metals and POPs increase partial to complete decrease of river fluxes salinisation (evaporation and percolation)
Local to regional changes of environmental states
Global impacts
x
x
X
X x
X x
x x
x x
x x x x x
F
Major global pressures on continental aquatic systems and the mapping of local- to regional-scale impacts.1
Pressures
Table 2.2.5
x x
x x
X
x x x x x X x
x x x x x
x
G
52 Chapter 2.2
53
Transferring Scientific Knowledge to Societal Use
Table 2.2.6 Scale level Plot scale
Heterogeneity of the water systems, natural and anthropogenic issues according to the scale level. Natural issues
distribution of root sys
Small catchment scale
tems lateral transfer of water
groundwater aquifer upstream–downstream flow structure
biogeochemistry parameters of environment compartments
Anthropogenic issues
land cover changes diffuse atmospheric pollution
land
River basin scale
river flow regimes, links
between groundwater and surface waters sediment supply and transfer water quality linked to climate
cover and use changes land management micro-climate changes artificial modifications of water bodies diffuse and local pollutions
water uses and demands impacts of urbanisation impacts of human activi-
ties such as agriculture, industries, mining
and share knowledge. The instrument of joint fact finding14 is already available, but it should be developed further. – Testing of scientific results with stakeholder panels is another direction of development.
Emphasis on learning in policy – Learning between stakeholders, between scientists, between stakeholders and scientists, etc., and on different levels (individual, team and organisation) have a central role in the fourth generation and deserve special arrangements. – Organisation of reflection, feedback and evaluation of the goal achievement of the policy is needed.
As ground water policy is getting involved in a much broader policy field, one can expect that these trends will also relate to groundwater policy. In effect, the AQUATERRA research project is an example of the above mentioned trend of multidisciplinary research. As stakeholder involvement and policy learning are other policy trends, the next sections will go into these topics.
54
Chapter 2.2
2.2.5.1
Stakeholder Involvementy
For stakeholder involvement with respect to groundwater policy there are several arguments. Apart from the basic fact that stakeholders have an impact on the quality and quantity of groundwater, the main arguments can be grouped into three themes: obstructive power, enrichment and fairness. The early involvement of stakeholders reduces the risk of the use of obstructive power by them, and thus the policy not being carried out. On the other hand, stakeholders possess resources, like money or knowledge required for the design planning and implementation of sophisticated policies, which governments do not possess. Knowledge is distributed among several stakeholders and government. So stakeholders should be involved to get all the (pieces of the puzzle) together. Stakeholder involvement can provide good ecological practices in this way. The last argument for stakeholder involvement is fairness. It is fair to involve actors affected by a certain policy, and give them a say in the decision-making process. But who are the stakeholders and how can one involve them? Derived from Slob et al.,15 we can make this definition: (stakeholders are all those people or organisations who have an effect on or are affected by groundwater policies.) We can make a distinction between two types of stakeholders: Organisations and people that have a direct impact on groundwater quality or are directly affected by the relevant policies. This group includes: industries using groundwater, farmers, water authorities, regulators on the local, regional, national and international level and citizens that are directly affected by the measures planned or taken. Organisations and people that have an impact on the relevant decisionmaking. This group covers citizens, landowners, homeowners, insurance companies, NGOs such as Greenpeace and the WWF, scientists and drinking water companies. A process of stakeholder involvement requires an independent chairperson or process manager. The first step for the process manager in the organisation of stakeholder involvement is to find out which stakeholders should be involved. Next, it is vital to collect information about the goals, ambitions and problem definitions (from the various perspectives) of the stakeholders. The process manager should ensure that all these interests are heard and acknowledged in the course of the process. The mobilisation of the stakeholders is an important issue. It is the duty of the manager to let stakeholders realise what the benefits are. Why should they join the process? A sound and deliberate consideration of interests might persuade less interested parties to join and will be a signal to dominant forces not to overreact. To create more certainty into the process, the process requires ‘‘rules of the game,’’ that contain rules for entering the process in later stages, y
This section is an excerpt of a chapter about stakeholder involvement in one of the (SedNet) books.15
Transferring Scientific Knowledge to Societal Use
55
how decisions are made, how information is brought into the process, etc. These ‘‘rules of the game’’ should be discussed and should be approved by the involved stakeholders. The process of involvement can be arranged with different goals: information: providing information to the stakeholders; consultation: ascertaining what stakeholders think must be done; advising: letting stakeholders advise on the policy and taking their recommendations into account; co-producing: stakeholders are regarded as equal policy-makers but decision-making remains in the political domain; and co-deciding: decision-making power is handed over to stakeholders. Every situation is unique and therefore the level should be chosen that fits the specific situation.
2.2.5.2
Learning Approaches in Policy-making
With the whimsicality of the fourth generation of environmental policies, the policy approach that fits best for the (local) groundwater issue is not ‘‘standard’’ and not known beforehand. This means that the policy approach required should be developed with the involved stakeholders specific for the local groundwater issue, and should be ‘‘tailor made.’’ To do this effectively an adaptive approach should be followed, in which actions are deliberated with the stakeholders, and will be followed up by their implementation. Then, to see the results of the actions, it is needed to follow quite closely how the groundwater system responds to these actions with all stakeholders involved. If the actions do not give the desired results, new or extra actions should be deliberated and undertaken. In this manner the way the system responds will be followed and the understanding of the system will grow. Continuously monitoring of the groundwater system plays a key role in sustaining the ‘‘learning approach’’ of groundwater policy and to find the best local approach to the groundwater issue. A summary of this learning approach could be as follows. Discussion on the groundwater issue with involved stakeholders, the problem (for instance with the DPSIR model) and the shared ambitions to solve the problem. Discussions on the actions that should be undertaken to reach the ambitions. Monitoring of the results and the way the system responds to the actions. Discussion on the results: does the system respond to the actions as was foreseen? Are new or extra actions needed? And so on. Implementation of these (extra) actions and monitoring of these results. Then the cycle starts all over again. In this way actions will be found that match best with the articulated ambitions.
56
2.2.6
Chapter 2.2
Conclusions
In this chapter, we present the preliminary results of the Integrated Project AQUATERRA in the framework of policy and societal use. AQUATERRA fits fully with part of the general conclusions given at the end of the World Science Forum16 (http://www.sciforum.hu/index.php). For example, conclusion 1 stated that ‘‘Scientific research is having a more immediate societal influence and facing an increasing set of requirements on the part of the public. As a result of internal scientific development and societal need, new research priorities emerge, requiring the cooperation of various disciplines. Therefore an integration of the natural and social sciences is taking place for problem-solving. Such an integration reinforces the need for establishing interdisciplinary frameworks. This is to be reflected in the institutional structures of science and of science policy as well.’’ This was clearly evidenced throughout this chapter. In the not too distant future, the main developments in AQUATERRA will certainly agree with another conclusion of the World Science Forum (2003) that stated that ‘‘the development of science and the demands of society will remove the rigid boundaries between theoretical and applied research, between the academic and innovation sector, . . . and scientific communities shall communicate the achievements of science and shall support decision-making . . . ,’’ especially within the COMPUTE sub-project (by setting a modelling tool box to assess impacts on water quantity and quality at different investigation scales: bench, catchment, river basins) and INTEGRATOR sub-project (by elaborating operational tools for the stakeholders, including a first assessment of social and economic impacts of policies in a scientific basis decision-making system). Finally, we showed that such an Integrated Project is in full agreement with the most important conclusion of the World Science Forum16 stating that ‘‘There exist appropriate scientific guidelines for improving the quality of life. Solutions offered by science are generally delayed by socio-economic patterns and inappropriate information transfer. It is the common responsibility of politicians, scientists and decision-makers to ensure the proper implementation of knowledge to improve the quality of life.’’
References 1. M. Meybeck, Hydrol. Proc., 2005, 19, 331. 2. M. H. Gerzabek, D. Barcelo´, A. Bellin, H. H. M. Rijnaarts, A. Slob, D. Darmendrail, H. J. Fowler, Ph. Negrel, E. Frank, P. Grathwohl, D. Kuntz and J. A. C. Barth, J. Environ. Manag., 2007, 84, 237–243. 3. F. Boons, L. Baas, J. J. Bouma, A. de Groene and K. LeBlansch, The Changing Nature of Business, International Books, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 2000. 4. H. Spliethof and J. van der Kolk, Environmental management: developments and interactions between technology and organisation, in Technology and Environmental Policy, [Technologie en milieubeheer],
Transferring Scientific Knowledge to Societal Use
5. 6. 7.
8. 9.
10. 11. 12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
57
ed. A. P. J. Mol, G. Spaargaren and A. Klapwijk, SDU, The Hague, 1991 [in Dutch]. G. Keijzers, J. Clean. Prod., 2000, 8, 179. L. Simons, A. Slob, H. Holswilder and A. Tukker, Environ. Qual. Manag., 2001, 11, 51. M. Gibbons, C. Limoges, H. Nowotny, S. Schwartzman, P. Scott and M. Trow, The New Production of Knowledge, Sage Publications, London, 1994. H. Nowotny, P. Scott and M. Gibbons, Minerva, 2003, 41, 179–194. N. Geilen, B. Pedroli, K. Van Looy, L. Krebs, H. Jochems, S. Van Rooij and T. Van Der Sluis, Final Report of the IRMA/SPONGE Project, no 9, 2001. R. J. Batalla, C. M. Gomez and G. M. Kondolf, J. Hydrol., 2004, 290, 117–136. IMC, Proceedings of the First International Scientific Symposium on the River Meuse, Maastricht, The Netherlands, 2002. IMC, Rapport interme´diaire du programme d’action ‘‘Meuse’’: Mise en oeuvre de la 1e`re phase et pre´paration de la 2e`me phase. Commission Internationale de la Meuse, Lie`ge, 2001. J. Joziasse, J. Vink, D. Slijkerman, E. Foekema, J. Brils, J. Batlle Aguilar, P. Orban, S. Brouyere, A. Poot, E. Bleeker, C. van der Wielen and M. He´mart, AquaTerra research activities in the Meuse river basin, 2nd International Meuse Symposium, Sedan, 18–19 May 2006. J. R. Ehrmann and B. L. Stinson, Joint fact-finding and the use of technical expertise, in: The Consensus Building Handbook, ed. L. Susskind, S. McKearnan and J. Thomas Larmer, Sage Publications, London, 1999. A.F.L. Slob, L. Gerrits and G. J. Ellen, Sediment management and stakeholder involvement, in Sediment Management on the River Basin Scale, ed. Ph. Owens, Elsevier, in press. World Science Forum, Budapest, 8–10 November 2003; available at http:// www.sciforum.hu/index.php2003.
CHAPTER 2.3
Groundwater Management and Planning: How Can Economics Help? JEAN-DANIEL RINAUDOa AND PIERRE STROSSERb a
Bureau de Recherches Ge´ologiques et Minie`res (BRGM), 1034 rue de Pinville, FR-34000 Montpellier, France; b ACTeon, Le Chalimont, BP Ferme du Pre´ du Bois, FR-68370 Orbey, France
2.3.1
Introduction
Public water managers and stakeholders involved in the design of groundwater management are increasingly aware of, and concerned by, the economic implications of the technical choices they promote. The definition of sustainable groundwater quality objectives as well as the identification of technical actions needed to achieve these objectives require investigating trade-offs between economic and environmental considerations. It also requires balancing interests between economic sectors through proportioning constraints imposed to sectors generating pollution or depletion with costs incurred by sectors depending on groundwater quality. Although the economic (and political) dimension of groundwater management might be taken into consideration implicitly by water planners in the large majority of European countries, it is rarely explicitly considered and quantitatively assessed. The promulgation in 2000 of the European Union (EU) Water Framework Directive (WFD) has drastically improved this situation by clearly integrating economics into water management and policy. This directive promotes the application of economic principles such as the polluter pays principle. It recommends applying economic methods such as cost-effectiveness analysis to support the identification of measures to achieve the environmental objectives of the directive. And it calls for a wider consideration of economic instruments (e.g. water pricing, charges and taxes) to provide adequate (financial) incentives for reducing pressures exerted on water resources.
58
Groundwater Management and Planning: How Can Economics Help?
59
Clearly, the recognition of the need for more systematic and robust economic assessments to support water management programmes is not the sole result of the changing regulatory context. Indeed, it reflects an increasing demand by actors and economic interests for more robust economic justifications to water protection decisions, choices and orientations. More attention is given to the efficient use of limited financial resources allocated to environmental protection. And the assessment of the economic impacts of constraints imposed on economic sectors by environmental regulation (e.g. restriction or ban of dangerous substances in industry) is increasingly called for: as it may result in competition distortion with non-EU producers and may generate losses of competitiveness, income and employment. In this context, the assessment of these costs, the proof that they are minimised and fairly distributed between sectors and, in certain cases, the demonstration that they generate proportionate social benefits, are elements that can help policy makers to justify decisions and gain social acceptance. Groundwater planners can expect three distinct types of contributions from economists. The first one is the description of the hydro-economic system to better capture the interactions between, and dynamics of, economic activities and groundwater resources. This involves the construction of indicators characterising the economic significance of water uses (in terms of employment, turn over, added value, etc.). It also requires understanding plausible futures for economic activities and resulting pressures on groundwater resources. In some cases, this description might benefit from the assessment of financial flows between economic sectors and water users, or the evaluation of the damage costs imposed on third parties because of the degradation of groundwater resources (pollution or depletion). The second type of contribution from economists consists in assessing and comparing the economic cost and/or benefits of different groundwater management options. The role of economics can either be to identify the least costly way to achieve a given environmental objective (cost-effectiveness analysis) or to assess the net benefit (i.e. total benefits minus total costs) of alternative management options (cost–benefit analysis). It is important to point out that the ranking between different policy options based on economic criteria is only one element provided to support a policy decision, not the decision itself. The third type of contribution consists in the design of economic instruments such as prices, charges (abstraction/pollution) or taxes that might influence water users’ behaviour. The need to influence users’ behaviour for enhancing the sustainability of groundwater resources is increasingly recognised by water planners. And they call for the design and implementation of economic instruments aimed at regulating water demand or pollution. The main purpose of this chapter is to show how practical economics can help provide some light on these different demands. In its first section, the chapter demystifies key economic principles, concepts and methods. It then presents four concrete applications of economic methods applied to groundwater management. It then discusses the potential role of economic instruments to enhance the sustainability of groundwater resources. The chapter concludes
60
Chapter 2.3
by discussing the needs for, and challenges in, integrating economics with technical expertise and knowledge, an element that is essential to the relevance of economics for policy-making in the field of (ground-) water management. The conclusion also identifies gaps between policy demand and the economics toolbox where further research is needed to enhance the potential effectiveness of economics in supporting groundwater management and policy decisions.
2.3.2
Economic Methodologies and Tools: Four Possible Ways of Supporting Groundwater Management and Planning
Economics as a science, its underlying theoretical principles as well as its operational tools and methodologies are not always given due considerations in groundwater management discussions and processes. This section presents a short overview of the economic methods and tools that can be mobilised to support groundwater management and to help answer the groundwater policy demand briefly presented above.
2.3.2.1
Economic Characterisation of Water Uses
Characterising the economic dimension of groundwater use has both static and dynamic dimensions. First, assessment can be made to identify how important groundwater use is today for the economy, e.g. what are the economic weights in terms of turnover, value added, employment, economic value, etc., that one can attach to different abstractors and polluters of groundwater resources. Integrated with information on pressures and/or impacts on the state of the groundwater aquifer, it helps obtaining first insights into the trade-offs between economic development and groundwater protection—and into possible economic impacts that might occur as a result of stricter groundwater protection. The information can be used to justify how essential groundwater protection is for key economic sectors for which development is directly linked to groundwater quality—or because groundwater of adequate quality has a high economic value that justifies its protection. Second, economics can help capturing the dynamics of the system and identifying future groundwater protection challenges. Indeed, static situations in terms of pressures and impacts on groundwater are rare. Changes in sector policies, the internal dynamics of economic sectors (influenced, for example, by global changes and world trade) or the implementation of current environmental legislation is expected to impact on economic development and thus on pressures imposed on groundwater resources. In some cases, improvements in groundwater quality might result from the implementation of existing environmental legislation or from changes in economic sector policies favouring less polluting input and production processes. In other cases, urban development and the opening of new markets for industrial products might lead to increased abstraction. And understanding the dynamics of groundwater
Groundwater Management and Planning: How Can Economics Help?
61
systems and connected users is essential in the search for solutions and measures aimed at improving the protection of groundwater resources. The characterisation reports prepared by EU member states in line with the requirements of Article 5 of the WFD provide very diverse illustrations of economic characterisation of water uses. Few of these reports, however, clearly link economic indicators to water use or to groundwater use.1 Investigating today’s situation and plausible socioeconomic futures for given groundwater systems requires collating economic information (often available in statistical systems complemented whenever necessary by surveys of citizens or economic operators), developing links between economic and technical (groundwaterrelated) information or applying foresight methods. Because of the scarcity of information directly available, it builds on exchange and interaction with stakeholders of the groundwater system considered.
2.3.2.2
Methods to Assess Environmental Costs
Recent studies have clearly shown that impacts on water quality and quantity of human activities are becoming significant at the European level2,3 as well as elsewhere in the world.4 As a result of increasing nitrates and pesticides concentrations, chlorinated hydrocarbons contamination or salt water intrusion (to quote only selected problems), different segments of society are incurring economic losses, referred to as damage costs hereafter. An assessment of the significance of these damage costs—which could be avoided through appropriate action—is information policy-makers might use to justify the relevance of engaging into costly groundwater protection actions. Four different types of damage costs can be distinguished: (i) cost of disease when the population is exposed to unsafe levels of substances in water; (ii) avoidance costs for water users who have to undertake averting or corrective actions (treatment of water, purchase of bottled water, etc.) in response to groundwater deterioration; (iii) ecological damage of surface ecosystems and subsequent loss of recreational value, when groundwater contamination has an impact on surface ecosystems (rivers, wetlands); and (iv) loss option value (possibility to use groundwater in the future) and non-use value (bequest value). Different economic methods have been developed to assess these costs. The cost of illness method aims at assessing costs generated by exposure to contaminants in drinking water, e.g. the cost of foregone wages for victims of contamination and the cost of treating the illness.5,6 This approach may be relevant in cases where health effects are the major cost component, as is the case with arsenic groundwater contamination in Bangladesh for instance.7 It does not seem relevant to pollution in Europe where concentrations of harmful substances found in drinking water very rarely reach a very high level (apart for some rural areas in Romania and Bulgaria, for example). The illness cost due to pollution with pesticide and some selected dangerous organic compounds could be significant, but the lack of epidemiological studies does not allow any evaluation of these costs.
62
Chapter 2.3
The avoidance cost method, or averting expenditure approach, consists in assessing the costs of actions undertaken to prevent or mitigate the adverse effects of contamination. Rooted in the household production function model, this approach assumes that consumption of goods or services can substitute for groundwater quality change. The implementation of this method offers a means to generate lower-bound estimates of an important component of the cost of groundwater pollution, namely the use of groundwater as a drinking water source. The averting behaviours reported include purchasing bottled water, monitoring of private borehole water quality and installation of filtering devices. Their estimated cost ranges between US$125 and US$330 per year and per household.8 The contingent valuation method aims at assessing the value that households assign to the preservation of groundwater quality. It builds on household surveys during which respondents have to state their willingness to pay (WTP) for hypothetical groundwater protection (or restoration) scenario. The stated WTP contains both use and non-use values, since households may want to preserve groundwater for their present or future consumption, for the consumption of future generations and/or for the resource as such. The estimated WTP for groundwater protection can be considered as an estimate of the cost of groundwater degradation. Contingent valuation is by far the most widely used method for assessing the benefits of water protection. Household WTP values reported in the literature range from less than h20 to h550 per household per year.9,10
2.3.2.3
Economic Methods for Appraisal of Groundwater Projects and Policies: Cost-effectiveness and Cost–Benefit Analysis
Due to the large number of economic sectors having an impact on groundwater, groundwater overexploitation or pollution problems can almost systematically be solved using different technical options or focusing on different sectors generating pressures. Consider for instance an overexploited aquifer where total water abstraction exceeds groundwater recharge, resulting in a sustained drop of the water table. The hydrological balance can be restored by reducing water abstraction, through artificial rechargew or a combination of both. The reduction of water abstraction can be achieved through the development of alternative water resources (inter-basin transfers, creation of reservoir dams, desalination), improvement of irrigation efficiency, the development of recycling technologies in industry or wastewater re-use. To identify the cheapest way to restore the hydrological balance, different combinations of measures can be compared in terms of their costs and their effects: an approach referred to as ‘‘cost-effectiveness analysis’’. A concrete example of cost effectiveness w
Procedure in which water supplies, sometimes using treated waste water, are pooled over highly permeable aquifers for increased infiltration. In some applications, injection wells can be used to recharge water to deeper aquifer levels or into less pervious aquifers.
Groundwater Management and Planning: How Can Economics Help?
63
analysis of water scarcity management can be found elsewhere.11 An additional example of cost-effectiveness analysis applied to a water pollution remediation is further detailed in Section 4 below. The problem can be even more complex when the different technical groundwater management options envisaged do not lead to the same environmental outcome. This can be the case, for instance, when different levels of contaminated site remediation are envisaged, or when the targeted pollutant concentration is not fixed by law. In such situations, water planners may be interested to assess not only the costs of alternative groundwater remediation options but also their benefits or net benefits (i.e. the difference between total benefits and total costs of actions). Cost–benefit analysis thus provides a rational and systematic framework for identifying and assessing in monetary terms all positive and negative effects of alternative options. In some cases, it involves the translation into monetary terms of non-marketed environmental, social and other impacts using some of the methods described in Section 2.2. An example of cost–benefit analysis applied to groundwater remediation is presented in Section 5.
2.3.2.4
Economic Behavioural Models
Behavioural models aim at simulating how changes occurring in the economic, regulatory or natural environment affect decisions of economic agents (farmers, households, industrialists) using water (groundwater abstraction) and/or impacting on its quality (pollution). Two broad types of behavioural models can be distinguished: decision-based models and statistical models. Decision-based models aim at representing the decision process that determines water use or pollution emission. Such models have been, for example, extensively applied for simulating farmers’ choice in terms of cropping patterns, water use (irrigation) or fertiliser use. Two types of models can be distinguished: optimisation models and rule-based models. Optimisation models assume that farmers select the combination of crops which maximises their income under a set of technical, regulatory and economic constraints; these models estimate crop choices, input consumption (fertiliser, labour, energy) and farm income for different input parameter values (agricultural prices and subsidies, input prices, minimum set aside constraint, etc). Optimisation models have also been developed for households to investigate households’ groundwater use.12 Rule-based models assume that individual decisions result not only from an economic optimisation process but also from interactions between various categories of actors and social objectives which may overrule the profit maximisation objective. Such models are often formulated using agent-based modelling techniques and implemented using object-oriented programming language,13 for an example applied to groundwater management. Statistical models aim at exploring the relationships between (ground) water use behaviour and socioeconomic characteristics of a panel of water users. Such models have been extensively used following the seminal work of Howes and Linaweaver14 for modelling drinking water demand and assessing the
64
Chapter 2.3
sensitivity of water use to price increase.15 More recently, statistical models have also been applied to the farming sector, using positive mathematical programming which investigates relationships between farm crop choices and factors determining production choices.16,17
2.3.2.5
Selected Illustrations
In the following sections, practical case studies are presented to illustrate how the methods and tools described above can be implemented in practice, and which results they deliver. The first case study focuses on the assessment of pollution damage costs due to agricultural diffuse pollution with nitrates and pesticides (Section 3). The second example, based on a Slovenian case study, illustrates how cost-effectiveness analysis can be used to identify the least costly way to reduce groundwater pollution (Section 4). Section 5 presents the results of assessments of costs and benefits of alternative groundwater protection scenarios from a practical case study conducted in Latvia. In Section 6, we illustrate how economic and groundwater models can be integrated to simulate long-term global change scenarios.
2.3.3
Assessing and Simulating Current and Future Socio-Economic Impact of Groundwater Deterioration
The first example focuses on the assessment of socioeconomic impact of groundwater pollution with nitrates and pesticides in the upper Rhine valley aquifer. The demand for this economic assessment emerged in the early 2000s following publication of the results of a trans-boundary groundwater quality survey showing a steady increase of nitrate concentration in very large areas of the aquifer, combined with a drastic increase in the pesticide detection frequency. Reversing this trend would require a drastic reinforcement of groundwater protection measures, in particular for the agriculture sector. But regional policy-makers feared that this would lead to significant opposition and protest from the farm lobby. To improve the social acceptance and the legitimacy of groundwater protection measures, they decided to launch a research project to quantify in monetary terms past and future socioeconomic impacts of groundwater pollution. The first part of the study consisted in assessing socioeconomic impacts of nitrate and pesticide pollution which had occurred during the last 15 years. The analysis was based on a consultation of experts, review of archives of financial actors and interviews with municipalities and industry representatives. The results showed that one-third of drinking water utilities, representing 177 municipalities and 432 000 inhabitants, had been directly concerned by nitrate or pesticide pollution during the 15 years period. And investments made to respond to this pollution were estimated at h26 million resulting in an average increase by h0.2 per cubic metre of the drinking water price (or h30 increase of
Groundwater Management and Planning: How Can Economics Help?
65
the water bill per household per year). This increase would have been twice as high if investments made by drinking water utilities had not been heavily subsidised. Groundwater pollution also contributed to eroding population trust in tap water and to increasing bottled water consumption, generating total additional costs estimated at h165 million over the 15-year period considered.18 The second part of the study consisted in estimating future costs that would occur in the absence of additional groundwater protection measures. It required developing a tool that would enable the simulation of future groundwater quality changes, combined with an economic method for assessing damage costs that would be incurred by water users as a result of groundwater quality changes. The evolution of water quality was simulated using geostatistical methods, assuming trends in water quality observed in the recent past could be extrapolated to the 2015 time horizon.19 The results of the extrapolation (Figure 2.3.1) showed that the estimated average nitrate concentration would increase up to 26.3 mg l1 by 2015 (against 25.7 mg l1 in 2003) with the area where drinking water threshold value for nitrates is exceeded (50 mg l1) being doubled (10% of total area in 2015 versus 5% today). Concerning pesticides, the evolution would differ from one substance to another, with the concentration of atrazine and its metabolites decreasing while metolachlore and alachlore concentrations would increase. Overall, the study showed that 33 drinking water wells belonging to 21 public drinking water utilities would be contaminated by 2015 (mainly by pesticides). Moreover, 68 additional drinking water wells would be at risk as pesticide
2003
2015
Pesticide concentration
Pesticide concentration
2015
Newly affected areas
Sum of all pesticide concentration < 0,05 µg/l Sum of all pesticide concentration > 0,05 µg/l & drinking water threshold values not exceeded Drinking water threshold values exceeded for one individual substance of the sum of substances
Figure 2.3.1
Maps of pesticide concentration for 2003 and 2015.
66
Chapter 2.3
concentration for these wells would be above 0.05 mg l1 in 2015, i.e. 50% of the drinking water threshold value, thus with the possibility that drinking water thresholds are occasionally exceeded. The damage costs associated with the contamination of the 33 wells were estimated assuming that all concerned water utilities would install activated carbon filter treatment units for eliminating pesticides. In addition, collaborative agreement with farmers would be established to further reduce input of pesticides and nitrates in the nearby aquifer wells. Total costs, including treatment cost (h0.07 per m3) and compensations paid to farmers (h230 per hectare and per year), were estimated at h1.75 million per year in 2015.
2.3.4
Cost Effectiveness Analysis of Groundwater Protection Measures: Finding the Least Costly Way to Reduce Nitrate Pollution to Groundwater
The second example, based on a Slovenian case study, focuses on the identification of the least costly way to reduce nitrate pollution in groundwater. The aquifer selected for this case study is the Krsko kotlina aquifer located near the Croatian boarder in Slovenia.20 This aquifer faces increasing nitrate and pesticide pollution originating mainly from agriculture and municipal wastewater collection and treatment. If current pressures remain as they are today, nitrate concentration in groundwater is expected to rise above the 50 mg l1 drinking water threshold value. Pesticides are present at all monitoring locations, with the concentration of some pesticides increasing and being sometimes above threshold values specified in relevant legislation. Potential measures for reducing groundwater pollution and their cost-effectiveness were investigated in the context of a pilot project aimed at testing methodologies for supporting the implementation of the EU WFD.20 For the agriculture sector, measures considered included adopting agri-environmental measures with lower fertiliser use, the replacement of cropped area by meadows, in particular in water resources protection zones, better management of farm yard manure on farm or the shift to organic farming. For the municipal sector, measures identified included the installation of new sewage and wastewater treatment facilities, the renewal of leaking sewage, the connection of disconnected households to public sewage networks or the installation and efficient management of sceptic tanks. The expected effects in terms of reduction in nitrate leaching to the groundwater were estimated for individual measures. Costs that were considered included direct investment costs, operation and maintenance costs and in some cases indirect economic costs imposed on economic sectors (e.g. differences in farm income/value added when shifting from today’s agriculture to organic farming). All costs were annualised based on the expected time life of investments and the distribution of (direct, indirect) costs over time, using a discount rate of 7%. Table 2.3.1 presents estimates obtained for different measures and used for building the cost-effective
70 ha
2163 ha
4800 ha 2088 ha
0 ha
1431 ha
2400 ha
696 ha
40 ha 348 ha
0 ha
Shift to meadows in water protection zone 1 for Drnovo and Brege abstraction wells Limits imposed on fertiliser use (170 kg N ha1) in water protection zone 2 (both wells) Best management practice for agriculture Winter green cover
Buffer zones Ecological farming
Stricter limitation of fertiliser use in the Brege water protection zone 2 (100 kg ha1) 497 ha
139 ha 1044 ha
Maximum coverage
Potential measures 960 084 SIT ha1
797 SIT ha1
897 SIT ha1 28 997 SIT ha1 1764 SIT ha1 45 397 SIT ha1 1 104 097 SIT ha1
0.00652 mg l1 ha1
0.00056 mg l1 ha1
0.00056 mg l1 ha1 0.00119 mg l1 ha1
0.00596 mg l1 ha1
0.00585 mg l1 ha1 0.00176 mg l1 ha1
Annualised costs
Reduction in nitrates (in absolute terms)
0.0054
3.3172 0.0388
0.0410
0.6243
0.7023
0.0068
Cost effectiveness ratio (mg l1 SIT1)
Coverage, costs and effectiveness of potential measures (PE ¼ population equivalent).
Actual coverage (already implemented)
Table 2.3.1
10
1 6
5
4
3
9
Ranking based on costeffectiveness ratio
Groundwater Management and Planning: How Can Economics Help? 67
(continued )
Wastewater treatment and sewage for groups of houses with less than 50 PE Wastewater treatment and sewage for small villages (50 o PE o 2000) Wastewater treatment and sewage for larger settlements (PE 4 2000)
Stricter limitation of fertiliser use in the Drnovo water protection zone 2 (100 kg ha1) Improved septic tanks
Potential measures
Table 2.3.1
50 ha
10 194 PE 297 PE
1019 PE
8115 PE
2548 PE
0 PE
0 PE
0 PE
Maximum coverage
0 ha
Actual coverage (already implemented) 917 SIT ha1
26 042 SIT PE1 19 094 SIT PE1 10 115 SIT PE1 8941 SIT PE1
0.00184 mg l1 ha1
0.00010 mg l1 PE1
0.00017 mg l1 PE1
0.00017 mg l1 PE1
0.00010 mg l1 PE1
Annualised costs
Reduction in nitrates (in absolute terms)
0.0190
0.0168
0.0052
0.0038
0.0067
Cost effectiveness ratio (mg l1 SIT1)
7
8
11
12
2
Ranking based on costeffectiveness ratio
68 Chapter 2.3
Groundwater Management and Planning: How Can Economics Help?
69
programme of measures aim at stabilising average nitrate concentration in groundwater at 50 mg l1.20 The activity undertaken as part of the Krka pilot project had a clear methodological focus and was not aimed at delivering results as part of a decision-making process. However, the assessments showed that the most costeffective programme for reaching the 50 mg l1 threshold for nitrate concentration would require changes in agriculture for 5400 hectares, with measures for reducing municipal sector pollution targeting around 9100 Population Equivalent.20 Total costs of such a programme were estimated roughly at 340 million SIT (or h1.5 million), equivalent to an average cost of around h200 per hectare for the entire aquifer area. The analysis emphasised that implementing in priority basic measures required for the implementation of existing legislation (Wastewater Treatment Directive, Nitrate Directive), independently of their cost-effectiveness ratio, would lead to significantly higher costs for groundwater protection up to h370 per hectare.
2.3.5
Cost–Benefit Analysis of Groundwater Protection: Finding the Economically Optimal Level of Groundwater Protection
The fourth example illustrates how cost–benefit analysis can be applied to assess whether proposed quality objectives or threshold values proposed for groundwater protection can be justified from an economic point of view. It is based on the results of a case study developed in Latvia as part of the EUfunded BRIDGE research project (see Ref. 21 for more details). The case study investigated the economic consequences of two alternative groundwater quality objectives for petroleum products in the shallow groundwater aquifer underlying the capital city of Riga. There are two main types of pressures on the aquifer that explain pollution by petroleum products: historical pollution sources linked to former military zones, industries, the past operation of fuel filling stations and tanks or highly contaminated sites that are officially registered; and current sources of pollution such as fuel filling stations and tankers, parking places or car disposal places (car cemeteries) that represent potential sources of pollution. The latter has clearly a marginal impact on the existing pollution by petroleum products, with the former representing around 90–92% of the observed pollution. Some pollution in the shallow aquifer also originates from street runoff and unused wells. While the area polluted with petroleum products might appear rather small (97 polluted sites representing 70 hectares out of a total of 30 500 hectares for the entire city of Riga), extremely high concentrations in petroleum products can be found, exceeding the existing (environmental) water quality threshold value of 0.2 mg l1 set in the legislation by 100 to 1000 times. This does not impose threats on human health as shallow groundwater is rarely used for drinking water purposes (drinking water for the city of Riga comes from an upstream dam on the Daugava River). But it creates a permanent floating layer
70
Chapter 2.3
of petroleum products that, for contaminated sites close to surface waters, imposes a risk to connected surface water ecosystems. Some petroleum product pollution in the Daugava River crossing the city of Riga (close to its outfall into the Gulf of Riga) is, for example, directly coming from the connected shallow aquifer. Highly contaminated sites in the middle of the city also impose constraints on urban and economic development: as new owners of such sites need to clean (groundwater and soil) pollution (from mainly historical sources for which they have no responsibility) whenever new urban developments are proposed. Environmental policies and urban planning strategies are already in place for dealing with petroleum product pollution in shallow aquifers. The review of planning and strategic documents stressed that financial resources have already been secured for cleaning four highly polluted sites in the coming years. In addition, good management practices are compulsory for fuel filling stations, petrol stations and parking places. Clearly, however, these measures will not be sufficient for restoring good shallow groundwater quality in the entire aquifer. The analysis investigated in some details the economic implications of two different objectives or scenarios. Scenario 1 considers cleaning all sites polluted with petroleum products up to the actual 0.2 mg l1 threshold for 30 sites out of 97 that are highly polluted and (i) connected to surface water ecosystems or (ii) located in a current or future residential area. Scenario 2 is more ambitious and considers cleaning all (97) sites polluted with petroleum products. Different actions and measures that would help reducing petroleum product pollution were identified. These include pumping up existing floating layers, treating contaminated soils or directly shallow groundwater, building rain water collectors or installing and operating rain water pre-treatment facilities. Based on individual cost figures (investment, operation and maintenance costs) for each measure, total costs (annualised, using a 4% discount rate) were estimated for each scenario assuming that measures would be implemented by 2015 in both scenarios. Cost ranges were estimated at h26–30.5 million and h50–58.6 million for scenarios 1 and 2, respectively. The benefits accruing to urban and economic development were estimated, assuming these benefits would be equal to the total area cleaned under each scenario multiplied by surrounding land property values existing for new developments. Benefits were estimated by summing up the cadastral value of properties in Riga for each site multiplied by the concerned area of each site. Total benefits (annualised, using a 4% discount rate) accruing to urban and economic development were estimated at h1.9 million and h4.3 million for scenarios 1 and 2, respectively. To estimate total benefits resulting from groundwater quality improvements, a contingent valuation survey was carried out in the case study area. Overall, 510 citizens from the city of Riga and neighbouring areas were interviewed to capture the total value people attach to groundwater quality improvement and to the elimination of petroleum product pollution. Average WTP for removing petroleum products from shallow groundwater was estimated at h24.5 per household per year, with no significance difference between the WTP for
Groundwater Management and Planning: How Can Economics Help?
71
different levels of groundwater quality improvement corresponding to scenarios 1 and 2. This WTP value applied to all inhabitants of the city of Riga leads to total benefits at around h68 million (for more details, see Ref. 21), thus significantly higher than the benefits accruing from urban development presented above. This stresses the importance of the non-use value people attach to groundwater. The comparison between total (annualised) costs and benefits showed that both scenarios can be justified from an economic point of view—with the first scenario yielding a better economic outcome (total benefits minus total costs) than the second (more ambitious) scenario. This results mainly from the very high population (density) in the area (Riga is the capital city of Latvia and hosts nearly one-third of the entire population of the country) to which WTP values for groundwater quality improvements are applied. Further analyses investigated the time dimension of groundwater improvement programmes. If proposed measures are delayed and implemented for a longer time period to account for the availability of financial resources and budgetary constraints, annualised costs are lower. As annualised benefits are also lower (because benefits are obtained after a longer time period), net benefits would be higher than those calculated for a faster implementation time. This could be the basis to justify a longer implementation period for measures: a result which clearly is very site and pollutant specific and that cannot be extrapolated!
2.3.6
Integrating Economic and Groundwater Models for Simulating Nitrate Pollution in the Upper Rhine Valley Aquifer
The fourth example illustrates how economic and groundwater models can be integrated to investigate the environmental impact of changes in economic sectors/sector policy. The example is based on the results of the MONIT InterReg project conducted by French, German and Swiss partners in the upper Rhine valley aquifer.22 The objective of the project was to develop a modelling tool capable of simulating future evolution of nitrate concentration corresponding to different global (economic and environmental) change scenarios. The approach developed recognises that the dynamics of groundwater systems mainly depends on economic drivers influencing activities generating pollution (e.g. farming), and, subsequently, that the processes governing this economic activity must also be represented and analysed in an integrated model. A farm sector economic model was developed to assess the extent to which levels of pollution emission generated by the farming sector could change depending on global change scenarios. The economic model is developed using linear programming (LP). LP models assume that farmers select the combination of crops which maximises their income under a set of technical, regulatory and economic constraints.23 The models simulate crop choices, input
72
Chapter 2.3
consumption (fertiliser, labour, energy) and farm income for different input parameter values (agricultural prices and subsidies, regulatory constraints, changes in the price of input such as energy, fertiliser, labour, minimum setaside constraint, etc.). The models incorporate constraints related to crop rotations, labour availability, production quotas (sugar-beet and milk quotas), manure storage and management (for livestock-oriented farms). Risk is also integrated in LP models to account for the variability of output prices and yields. A crop production function (for corn only) is also introduced in the model to capture the crop yield response to nitrogen input. The LP models representing production choices of twenty selected representative farms were calibrated for sample farms by comparing simulation results with current cropping patterns. The output of the economic model (area under each crop, nitrate use) provides input data to a large-scale nitrate balance model which calculates nitrate leaching for the entire aquifer. This nitrate balance model is developed using the STOFFBILANZ software.23 Some parameters of STOFFBILANZ are adjusted through the use in simulation of a process-oriented nitrate input model developed at a plot scale (soil-plant-model STICS) to determine the nitrate input into the groundwater as a function of crop type, management practice, fertilising practice and climate. The output of the nitrate balance model feeds into the groundwater flow model coupled with a transport model, developed using MODFLOW and MT3D (for more details, see Ref. 23). The economic and soil–groundwater models were then used to simulate the impact of three global change scenarios developed by a group of experts. Given the uncertainty associated with future changes, three contrasted scenario were developed, a baseline scenario and two variants inspired from the scenario developed by the International Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).24 The baseline scenario assumes that the corn root worm detected since 2003 in the region extends over large areas, forcing farmers to increase crop rotation and limiting corn area to less than 50% of the total cultivable area. Energy prices (gazoil) are supposed to increase by 6% per year on average (2015 prices are twice those of 2003). And it is assumed that no financial compensation mechanism is implemented by national governments. As a result of energy price growth, fertiliser price increases by 1.5% per year. Due to the European enlargement, temporary labour force increases significantly (+66% in twelve years), reducing the profitability of vine, fruit and vegetable crops (in particular in Germany where foreign labour force is significantly used for harvesting of these crops). In France, it is assumed that the reform of the Water Act establishes a new water abstraction tax of h0.025 per m3. In Germany, the tax called Wasserpfennig is maintained at its 2003 level (i.e. h0.05 per m3). In both countries, farmers are allowed to produce bio-diesel for their own farm use only. And the bio-fuel industry develops but only for producing ethanol using corn (no bio-diesel industry). The second scenario, called ‘‘A1’’ with reference to IPCC emission scenario A1,24 depicts a more liberal future. Agriculture development aims at maximising competitiveness in markets which tend to function without protectionist
Groundwater Management and Planning: How Can Economics Help?
73
barriers and with minimal environmental constraints: taxes on water abstraction are eliminated in Germany and not introduced in France. Liberalisation favours the full implementation of the decoupling principle promoted by the Common Agriculture Policy reform in France, which result in a drastic change in crop gross margins and relative profitability. Energy price increase is compensated by a fiscal stabilisation mechanism and limited to 40 and 68% in Germany and France, respectively. Significant technical means are mobilised by government agencies to fight against the corn root worm (pesticides are sprayed by helicopter). And the biofuel industry develops, representing new market opportunities for farmers. The third scenario, inspired from the B2 IPCC emission scenario, corresponds to a vision of the future where agriculture evolved under the double pressure of increasing input prices (energy, fertiliser) and more stringent environmental constraints. Water abstraction taxes are established at the level of the baseline scenario. A tax on fertiliser is introduced at h0.15 per kg in France and h0.26 per kg in Germany. Due to high energy price and an active governmental support to bio-fuel development, crops used for bio-fuel production represent a very attractive market. The proliferation of the corn root worm compels farmers to reduce the area under corn. And financial support is granted to fruit and vegetable farms to invest in machinery and compensate for the increase of temporary labour costs. The consequences of these three global change scenarios were assessed using the chain of models described above. The results show that future nitrate concentration in the aquifer will not significantly differ from one scenario to the other in the short term (estimated at 19 mg l1 for the baseline and A1 scenarios, and 19.5 mg l1 for the B2 scenario). More significant differences are expected in the longer term (average concentration of 16 mg l1 for baseline and A1 scenarios, 18.2 mg l1 for the B2 scenario). The model shows that the area where nitrate concentration exceeds drinking water thresholds (50 mg l1) will drastically fall from 17 000 hectares in 2005 to around 4000 ha for the baseline and A1 scenarios, and to 6000 ha for the B2 scenario (Figure 2.3.2). Surprisingly, scenario B2 which depict a world with more stringent environmental constraints is also the worst scenario in terms of water pollution due to the increase in areas under industrial crops used for producing bio-fuels.
2.3.7
Designing Economic Instruments for Groundwater Management
As indicated above, recent policy developments have also put emphasis on the potential role economic instruments might play in enhancing the sustainability of water resources. In parallel to requesting EU member states to undertake economic assessments for supporting the selection of measures, the EU WFD also promotes a sounder application of the polluter pays principle, an adequate recovery of the costs of water services and water pricing that provides an incentive to more efficient water use. Furthermore, economic instruments such
74
Chapter 2.3 17000 Baseline
Area where [NO3] > 50 mg/l (ha)
15000
A1 B2
13000
11000
9000
7000
5000
3000 2005
Figure 2.3.2
2015
2025
2035
2045
Simulated evolution of the area (in ha) where nitrate concentration exceeds 50 mg l1 (adapted from Ref. 22).
as water charges/taxes and systems of tradable water rights can be considered when developing programmes of measures. Indeed, economic instruments that provide financial incentives to reduce groundwater abstraction might be relevant options when the ecological consequences of groundwater depletion (e.g. sea water intrusion in coastal areas, drying up of wetlands or reduced discharges of river springs) cannot be mitigated by technical solutions alone. The following paragraphs investigate the two main types of economic instruments: environment taxes and tradable groundwater licences/rights.
2.3.7.1
Environment Taxes and Charges
Environmental taxes and charges can be imposed on users who abstract groundwater as an incentive for reducing water use and thus pressures on the aquatic ecosystem. The higher the taxes, the lower abstraction is expected to be. Designing an environment tax system is, however, not trivial. From a theoretical point of view, the tax level should be such that it covers all costs generated by groundwater use, including external costs caused to third parties and to the environmentz. In practice, the design of a tax system consists in finding a z
Environmental costs can be significant where groundwater overexploitation leads to irreversible environmental and economic damages costs (e.g. abandonment of drinking water wells in case of sea water intrusion in coastal aquifer, destruction of natural habitat in wetlands).
Groundwater Management and Planning: How Can Economics Help?
Table 2.3.2
Unitary rates for abstraction taxes and charges for selected member states of the European Union (2004 values: in Ref. 27).
Country France (basic rate of the Seine Normandie river basin)
Estonia
75
Sources of water to which the Tax/charge unitary tax/charge is applied rate (h per m3) Surface water: on volume abstracted Surface water: on volume consumed Groundwater: on volume abstracted Groundwater: on volume consumed Surface water Groundwater
Hungary
All sources of water
Slovenia
All sources of water
0.00071 0.04 0.024 0.04 0.013–0.016 0.016–0.048 depending on use 1.147 for mineral water 0.007–0.02 depending on use 0.03
compromise between economic efficiency and social acceptability: the latter criterion being of utmost importance as taxes will generally be resisted by water users who consider water as a free resource.25,26 And the full cost recovery principle promoted by current policies (e.g. the EU WFD of 2000, the 1994 water reform in Australia) is in fact never implemented in practice. As a result, external costs and damages remain borne by economically less sensitive sectors (frequently households). Environmental taxes and charges are more widely used in Europe than in the USA for instancey. Such taxes or charges for water abstraction are rather common as illustrated in Table 2.3.2. When different rates are proposed for surface water and groundwater abstraction, those for groundwater are usually higher emphasising the higher status groundwater protection might have in the field of water policy. However, a closer look at current tax and charge levels shows that they remain very low as compared to other production costs or value added.28 In some cases, tax exemption is also given to economic sectors to limit its expected negative impact on competitiveness. This situation is illustrated by the Netherlands, where a groundwater tax system was introduced in 1995 as part of an effort to broaden the tax base by shifting the emphasis of revenue generation from conventional taxes to environmental taxes other than energy taxes. The amount of the tax payable is based on the volume of groundwater abstracted with a tax rate of h0.1785 per m3 (2004 figures). Companies could, however, obtain a significant tax rebate (h0.1495 per m3) when infiltrating water back y
See Ref. 25 for a discussion of water pollution taxes versus pollution discharge rights.
76
Chapter 2.3
into the aquifer. Furthermore, small groundwater abstractors were exempted. Although small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) and industries faced a water price increase ranging from 40 to 113% when the groundwater tax was first introduced, the revenue collected by the groundwater tax amounted to 0.03 and 0.08% of the industry turnover and value added, respectively. This was equivalent to 0.33% of pre-tax profits in the industrial sector,28 thus unlikely to impair the competitiveness of Dutch industry. Overall, environmental taxes and charges are often justified on environmental grounds, i.e. as an incentive to economic sectors to limit water use or reduce pollution. In practice, however, existing taxes and charges do have limited incentive effects. They mainly play a revenue-raising role, revenues that in some cases (when they are earmarked to environmental protection) can help support financially the implementation of groundwater protection programmes and projects.
2.3.7.2
Tradable Groundwater Licences and Rights
The establishment of tradable groundwater abstraction licences or rights is another type of economic instrument that might play a role in groundwater management. Based on hydrogeological knowledge, the total maximum volume that can be abstracted from an aquifer (or sustainable yieldz) can be estimated and converted into a number of individual water abstraction licences or property rights which can be allocated to individual water users. Individual rights can be expressed in volume or in percentage of a sustainable aquifer yield, which can be reassessed every year to account for climatic variability and the effect of past abstractions. Whereas licences are issued for a specific period and can be revised or cancelled, water (property) rights are granted on a permanent basis. The initial allocation of licence or rights can be based on historical consideration (first in time, first in right) or on economic consideration (through an auction mechanism, for example, to allocate groundwater to its highest marginal values). Following the initial allocation, water licences or rights can be leased or sold among users. The underlying assumption is that water users will accept to sell part or whole of their licence/right if the financial compensation (price) they can obtain for the transfer exceeds the benefits they would derive from using their water directly. In theory, market forces ensure that water is (re-)allocated to the most efficient users, that waste is minimised and that the total economic value of water use is maximised. Water markets have been established in the USA, leading to the reallocation of surface and groundwater resources from one region to another, and from one economic sector to another.29,30 For a detailed description of groundwater markets in Texas and Arizona, see Ref. 31. Similar markets also function in well-regulated river basins in arid area of Chile.32,33 Following the successful z
Sustainable aquifer yield is defined as the groundwater extraction regime, measured over a specified planning time frame that allows acceptable levels of environmental impact on associated ecosystems and protects the higher value uses that have a dependency on the water.
Groundwater Management and Planning: How Can Economics Help?
77
development of water market in the Murray–Darling basin in the mid1980s,33,34 Australian authorities have also promoted the development of groundwater licence trading as an alternative to the ‘‘command and control’’ approach to moving water use to areas with higher economic value and efficiency.35 In Europe, although trading of water use rights has locally been functioning for centuries within irrigation systems in Spain,30 they are rarely considered as measures in water management and policy. As an exception, tradable water permits (quotas) were considered as possible measure for reducing overabstraction for the Beauce aquifer (central France) at the end of the 1990s.36 However, they were never implemented because of the drastic legislation change they would have required. The EU WFD refers also to tradable water rights as possible measure for reaching its environmental objectives. But no EU member state is expected to make use of this type of economic instrument at least in the short and medium term.
2.3.8
Conclusions
This chapter has provided examples of the role economics can play in supporting decisions in the field of groundwater management and planning. At the same time, the illustrations presented above clearly show that economics cannot answer policy issues and questions alone. Indeed, supporting groundwater management and planning decision requires multidisciplinary approaches where economics and technical knowledge must be well integrated. Integration between economics with hydrogeology is required for the development of scenarios of plausible futures described for example in Sections 3 and 6. In developing scenarios, economic assessment or modelling can either be used ‘‘upstream’’ or ‘‘downstream’’ from hydrogeological assessment and modelling. An ‘‘upstream’’ use of economics is important when a significant evolution of economic activities generating pressures on groundwater (abstraction or pollution) is expected to occur during the time horizon considered. As illustrated in Section 6, an economic model can then help in simulating likely future evolution of economic activities and resulting pressures affecting the state of groundwater resources, under different assumption of global economic change (e.g. changes in agriculture policy, demographic growth, changes in energy prices), environmental change (e.g. climate change) or policy action scenario (e.g. implementation of an environmental tax). A ‘‘downstream’’ use of economics is relevant to situations with significant economic interests depending on the state of groundwater resources. As illustrated in Section 3, this can help assess the economic consequences (e.g. in terms of economic sector production and value added, employment, competitiveness) of expected future groundwater status changes obtained from hydrogeological model simulation. Multidisciplinary approaches which integrate economics with hydrogeology are also essential to the evaluation of alternative groundwater management
78
Chapter 2.3
options, in line with the requirements of the EU WFD. Whether the evaluation requires a cost-effectiveness analysis (as illustrated in Section 4) or a cost– benefit analysis (presented in Section 5), economic assessments must build on a robust understanding of the impact of possible management actions on groundwater status. And such understanding requires hydrogeological knowledge or modelling. However, studies where specific groundwater models and economic assessment are conducted together remain rare.37,38 This leads to a relatively high uncertainty associated with cost-effectiveness or cost–benefit estimates: an issue that requires further investigation by the research community. Although the need for multidisciplinary research is increasingly recognised by scientific and policy-making communities,39 the actual development of multidisciplinary research work in that field is somewhat impaired by the fact that academic evaluation (in both the hydrogeology and economics fields) rarely gives credit to such multidisciplinary approaches. The search for more multidisciplinary work reinforces the issues of scale. On the one hand, it questions the extrapolation to larger scales of results from innovative economic methods developed and applied at local case study level, in particular in the domain of environmental cost and benefit valuation (e.g. contingent valuation). The issue of aggregation of values obtained from contingent valuation studies for estimating total benefits of a given management option and environmental quality change at the river basin scale remains a challenge. Whether the same protocol should apply for building contingent valuation surveys at local or large scale is also a research question that might require further attention. On the other hand, economists are faced with the need to link global economic models representing entire economies (partial equilibrium models or general equilibrium models) to impacts on water and groundwater resources at the macroscale. This implies linking macroeconomic models with groundwater models at regional or national level, a scale at which hydrological functioning is difficult to simplify (and might not have much meaning). Another key challenge for economists working on groundwater management is the need to enhance the appropriation of economic principles, tools and results by policy-makers and stakeholders involved in the preparation of groundwater management plans and programmes. Whereas policy actors might be, by tradition, more familiar with the knowledge mobilised by hydrogeologists, there is still a limited understanding of the role economics can play in supporting their decision—although it is clear that policy-makers are very sensitive to economic arguments. In Europe, this situation is slowly changing with the implementation of the EU WFD gaining momentum and more economic analyses being undertaken and discussed among policy-makers and stakeholders at the national and river basin district scales. Also, one can observe an emerging demand for economic assessments of water management options at the local level (for instance in the Arde`che river basin in France). But we are still at the infancy of more systematic applications of economic assessments. Also, how the results of economic analyses will be used for supporting policy decisions (if used at all) remains to be seen.
Groundwater Management and Planning: How Can Economics Help?
79
A better appropriation of economic concepts and methods by policy-makers and stakeholders will require specific efforts by the economic community in awareness raising and information, including on the strengths and weaknesses of assessments, on underlying uncertainties and on the demonstration of the added value of the integration between economics and technical expertise. In some cases, it might also require a drastic change in the economists’ thinking and discourse, away from the assumption that individuals are acting purely along the simplified concepts and principles that are the basis of the microeconomic theory. The real-life application of economic assessments that will be produced in the coming years in the context of the implementation of the WFD and of its daughter groundwater directive will be instrumental in enhancing the shared knowledge between economists, hydrogeologists, policy-makers and stakeholders.
References 1. World Wide Fund for Nature and European Environment Bureau, EU Water Policy: Making Economics Work for the Environment. Survey of the Economic Elements of the Article 5 Report of the EU Water Framework Directive, report prepared by the World Wide Fund for Nature and the European Environment Bureau, Brussels, 2006. 2. A. Scheidleder, J. Grath and G. Winkler, Groundwater Quality and Quantity in Europe, European Environmental Agency, Copenhagen, 1999. 3. S. Nixon, Z. Trent and C. Marcuello, Europe’s Water. An Indicator Based Assessment, Topic Report 1/2003, European Environmental Agency, Copenhagen, 2003. 4. T. Shah and D. Molden D, The Global Groundwater Situation: Overview of Opportunities and Challenges, International Water Management Institute, Colombo, 2000. 5. W. Harrington, J. Krupnick and W. A. Spofford, J. Urban Econ., 1989, 25, 116–137. 6. P. Dasgupta, Environ. Develop. Econ., 2004, 9, 83–106. 7. A. H. Smith, E. O. Lingas and M. Rahman, Bull. World Health Organ., 2000, 78, 9. 8. C. W. Abdalla, Am. J. Agricul. Econ., 1994, 76, 1062–1067. 9. A. Stenger and M. Willinger, J. Environ. Manag., 1998, 53, 177–193. 10. B. Go¨rlach and E. Intervies, Economic Assessment of Groundwater Protection: A Survey of the Literature, Ecologic, Berlin, 2003. 11. A. Gerarsidi, P. Katsiardi et al., Cost-effectiveness analysis for water management in the island of Paros, Greece, International Conference on Environmental Science and Technology, Lemnos Island, Greece, 2003. 12. M. Montginoul, J.-D. Rinaudo, P. Garin, Y. Lunet delajoncquie`re and J. P. Marchal, Water Policy, 2005, 7, 523–541. 13. S. Feuillette and F. Bousquet et al., Environ. Model. Software, 2003, 18(5), 413–427.
80
Chapter 2.3
14. C. W. Howes and F. P. Linaweaver, Water Resour. Res., 1967, 3(1), 13–32. 15. F. Arbue´s and M. A. Garcia-Valinas et al., J. Socio-Econ., 2003, 32(1), 81–102. 16. R. E. Howitt, Am. J. Agricul. Econ., 1995, 77, 329–342. 17. L. Judez and J. M. de Miguel et al., Math. Comput. Modell., 2002, 35(1–2), 77–86. 18. J.-D. Rinaudo, C. Arnal, R. Blanchin, P. Elsass, Meilhac and Loubier, Water Sci. Technol., 2005, 52(9), 153–162. 19. J.-D. Rinaudo, P. Elsass, R. Blanchin, C. Arnal and Meilhac, Assessing the Social and Economic Impact of Nitrate and Pesticide Contamination of the Alsatian Aquifer: Synthesis Report [in French], report Brgm/RP-53172FR.Orle´ans, BRGM, 2006. 20. Selecting Measures to Improve Water Status in the Krka River Sub-Basin, technical report of the Krka Pilot Project, Ljubljana, 2006. 21. K. Pakalniete, H. Bouscasse and P. Strosser, Assessing Socio-Economic Impacts of Different Groundwater Protection Regimes. Latvian Case Study Report, research report developed under the EU-funded BRIDGE research project, ACTeon, Orbey, 2006. 22. LUBW, Simulating Nitrate Groundwater Pollution in the Upper Rhine valley [in French and German], Monit Intergreg IIIA project, final report, LUBW, Karlsruhe, 2006. 23. P. B. R. Hazell and R. D. Norton, Mathematical Programming for Economic Analysis in Agriculture, Macmillan, New York, 1986. 24. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Emissions Scenarios: Summary for Policy Makers, IPCC special report, 2000. 25. C. W. Howes, Environ. Res. Econ., 1994, 4, 151–169. 26. A. Dinar, The political economy context of water pricing reforms, in The Economics of Water Management in Developing Countries, ed. P. Koundouri, P. Pashardes, T. Swanson and A. Xepapadeas, Edgard Edwards, Cheltenham, UK, 2003. 27. P. Strosser and S. Speck, Environmental Taxes and Charges in the Water Sector. A Review of Experience In Europe, technical report, Catalan Water Agency, Barcelona, 2004. 28. Ecotec et al., Study on the Economic and Environmental Implications of the Use of Environmental Taxes and Charges in the European Union and Member States, report for the European Union, European Commission, Brussels, 2001 (http://europa.eu.int/comm/environment/enveco/taxation/ environmental_taxes.htm). 29. T. Anderson and P. J. Hill, Water Marketing: The Next Generation, Rowman and Littlefiel, New York/London, 1997. 30. P. Strosser, Analysing alternative policy instruments for the irrigation sector: an assessment of the potential for water market development in the Chishtian sub-division, Pakistan, PhD thesis, Wageningen Agricultural University, 1997. 31. C. W. Howes, Environ. Develop. Econ., 2002, 7(2), 605–616.
Groundwater Management and Planning: How Can Economics Help?
81
32. C. J. Bauer, Against the Current: Privatization, Water Markets and the State in Chile, Kluwer, Boston MA, 1998. 33. H. Bjornlund and J. McKay, Environ. Develop. Econ., 2002, 7(2), 769–795. 34. S. Thoyer, Int. J. Sust. Develop., 2006, 9, 2. 35. ARMCANZ, Allocation and Use of Groundwater: A National Strategy for Improved Groundwater Management in Australia, policy position paper for advice to states and territories, Agriculture and Resource Management Council of Australia and New Zealand, Task Force on COAG Water Reform, Sustainable Land Water Resources Management Committee, 1996. 36. N. Kosciusko-Morizet, H. Lamotte and V. Richard, What can we expect from the establishment of transferable water entitlements in France: the case of irrigated agriculture [in French], Conference on Irrigation and Collective Water Resource Management in France and in the World, SFER, Montpellier, 19–20 November 1998. 37. J.-D. Rinaudo and S. Loubier, Cost benefit analysis of large scale groundwater remediation in France, in Cost Benefit Analysis and Water Resources Management, ed. R. Brouwer and D. Pearce, Edgard Edwards, Cheltenham, UK/Northampton, MA, 2005, pp. 290–314. 38. R. Brouwer, S. Hess, M. Bevaart and K. Meinardi, The Socio-Economic Costs and Benefits of Environmental Groundwater Threshold Values in the Scheldt Basin in the Netherlands, case study report produced under the BRIDGE research project, IVM report R06-05, Institute for Environmental Studies (IVM), Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, 2006. 39. Ph. Quevauviller, P. Balabanis, C. Fragakis, M. Weydert, M. Oliver, A. Kaschl, G. Arnold, A. Kroll, L. Galbiati, J. M. Zaldivar and G. Bidoglio, Environ. Sci. Pol., 2005, 8, 203–211.
3. Groundwater Regulatory Framework
CHAPTER 3.1
European Union Groundwater Policyw PHILIPPE QUEVAUVILLER European Commission, DG Environment (BU9 3/142), Rue de la Loi 200, BE-1049 Brussels, Belgium
3.1.1
Introduction
The European Union (EU) regulatory groundwater framework was developed at the end of the 1970s with the adoption of Directive 80/68/EEC on the protection of groundwater against pollution caused by certain dangerous substances. This directive provides a groundwater protection framework by preventing the (direct or indirect) introduction of high-priority pollutants into groundwater and limiting the introduction into groundwater of other pollutants so as to avoid pollution of this water by these substances. In 1982, a major assessment of groundwater resources was carried out in Europe, which consisted of a general survey (Groundwater Resources of the European Community: Synthetical Report) of groundwater quantity. Since it was published, attention has turned in Europe (and the USA) to quality, and not only have groundwater quality monitoring programmes been greatly expanded but many groundwater protection schemes have been put into place. The declaration of the ministerial seminar on groundwater held at The Hague in 1991 recognised the need for further action to avoid long-term deterioration of the quality and quantity of freshwater resources and called for a programme of actions to be implemented by the year 2000, aiming at sustainable management and protection of freshwater resources. This was followed by the elaboration of an action programme for integrated protection and management of groundwater in 1996, in which the Commission pointed to the need to establish procedures for the regulation of abstraction of freshwater and for the monitoring of freshwater quality and quantity. These w
The views expressed in this chapter are purely those of the author and may not in any circumstances be regarded as stating an official position of the European Commission.
85
86
Chapter 3.1
considerations coincided with the request made by the European institutions to the Commission to come forward with a proposal for a directive establishing a framework for a European water policy. They were hence naturally embedded into the development of this large policy framework development, which resulted in the adoption of the Water Framework Directive (WFD) 2000/60/ EC on 23 October 2000. This chapter summarises the different elements described above, and provides background information about parent legislation which has also to be considered within an enlarged groundwater regulatory framework.
3.1.2
The 1980 Groundwater Policy Framework
In the context of Directive 80/68/EEC on the protection of groundwater against pollution caused by certain dangerous substances,1 groundwater is defined as ‘‘all water which is below the surface of the ground in the saturation zone and in direct contact with the ground or subsoil.’’ This directive provides a groundwater protection framework by preventing the (direct or indirect) introduction of high-priority pollutants (List I) into groundwater and limiting the introduction into groundwater of other pollutants (List II) so as to avoid pollution of this water by these substances (Table 3.1.1). Indirect discharges have to be understood as ‘‘the introduction into groundwater of substances in lists I or II after percolation through the ground or subsoil’’ while direct Table 3.1.1 List I
List II
Lists of substances regulated under Directive 80/68/EEC.
This list contains eight groups of substances, exception being made of substances which are considered inappropriate on the basis of low risk of toxicity, persistence and bioaccumulation: (1) organohalogen compounds and substances which may form such compounds in aquatic environment; (2) organophosphorus compounds; (3) organotin compounds; (4) substances which posses carcinogenic, mutagenic or teratogenic properties in or via the aquatic environment (if this is the case for certain substances of List II, they are included under this category); (5) mercury and its compounds; (6) cadmium and its compounds; (7) mineral oils and hydrocarbons; and (8) cyanides. This list contains individual or groups of substances which could have a harmful effect on groundwater, in particular: (1) metalloids and metals and their compounds such as zinc, copper, nickel, chrome, lead, selenium, arsenic, antimony, molybdenum, titanium, tin, barium, beryllium, boron, uranium, vanadium, cobalt, thallium, tellurium, silver; (2) biocides and their derivatives not appearing in List I; (3) substances which have a deleterious effect on the taste and/or odour of groundwater, and compounds liable to cause formation of such substances so as to render water unfit for human consumption; (4) toxic or persistent organic compounds of silicon, and substances which may cause the formation of such compounds in water, excluding those which are biologically harmless or are rapidly converted in water into harmless substances; (5) inorganic compounds of phosphorus and elemental phosphorus; (6) fluorides; and (7) ammonia and nitrites.
European Union Groundwater Policy
87
discharges correspond to ‘‘an introduction without percolation.’’ Pollution is defined as ‘‘The discharge by man, directly or indirectly, of substances or energy into groundwater, the results of which are such as to endanger human health or water supplies, harm living resources and the aquatic ecosystems or interfere with other legitimate use of water.’’ In this framework, consequences of pollution that has already occurred have to be checked or eliminated as far as possible (Article 1). This implies the following. With regard to List I substances, direct discharges are prohibited, whereas indirect discharges (due to disposal or tipping for the purpose of disposal) of these substances are prevented, which is linked to an authorisation procedure preceded by a thorough investigation on a caseby-case basis. In this respect, all appropriate measures have to be taken to prevent any indirect discharges due to either disposal or other activities on or in the ground other than disposal. With regard to List II substances, direct discharges have to be limited and appropriate measures have to be taken to limit any indirect discharges of these substances due to either disposal or other activities on or in the ground other than disposal. An authorisation procedure preceded by a thorough investigation is required in the case of direct discharge or disposal or tipping for the purpose of disposal of these substances. The authorisation is only granted if all the technical precautions for preventing groundwater pollution by these substances are observed. It should be noted that this directive does not apply to discharges of domestic effluents from isolated dwellings not connected to a sewerage system and situated outside areas protected for the abstraction of water for human consumption. In addition, it does not apply to discharges of List I and II substances which are found in a quantity and concentration so small as to obviate any present or future danger of deterioration in the quality of the receiving groundwater, nor does it apply to discharges of matter containing radioactive substances. Another derogation clause concerns the authorisation of discharge of List I substances in groundwater which has been revealed as being permanently unsuitable for other uses (especially domestic or agricultural), providing that their presence does not impede exploitation of ground resources. These authorisations can only be granted if all technical precautions have been taken to ensure that these substances cannot reach other aquatic systems or harm other ecosystems. In addition, authorisation (after prior investigation) may be granted for discharges due to re-injection into the same aquifer of water used for geothermal purposes, water pumped out of mines and quarries or water pumped out for civil engineering works. Finally, artificial recharges for the purpose of groundwater management are subject to a special authorisation on a case-by-case basis, which may only be granted if there is no risk of groundwater pollution. The directive provides specific requirements regarding
88
Chapter 3.1
the authorisation procedures, distinguishing direct discharge and indirect discharge. In the above context, monitoring is required only for those specific cases of authorisation for the purpose of compliance checking and for assessing the effects of discharges on groundwater. Application of measures relevant to this directive may on no account lead, either directly or indirectly, to pollution of groundwater. Finally, where appropriate, one or more member states may individually or jointly take more stringent measures than those provided for under this directive. From the above description, it can be concluded at first sight that Directive 80/68/EEC ensures a stringent groundwater protection regime against pollution for all the activities that present a risk of groundwater deterioration through direct or indirect discharges of a wide range of pollutants. The implementation of this directive is, however, sometimes faced with the difficulties of a lack of groundwater quality data and objectives. In other words, infringement cases may be difficult to judge in some instances in the absence of clear information on background groundwater quality levels in the zone affected by discharges, and of quality objectives on the basis of which deterioration may unambiguously be identified. This directive will be repealed in 2013 under the WFD (2000/60/EC),2 after which the protection regime should be continued through the WFD and the new Groundwater Daughter Directive,3 which are further discussed below.
3.1.3
Preliminary Assessment (1982)
In 1982, the Directorate-General for the Environment, Consumer Protection and Nuclear Safety of the European Community carried out a major assessment of groundwater resources within its (then) nine member states. It consisted of a general survey (Groundwater Resources of the European Community: Synthetical Report) and individual reports from each member state.4 This report dealt with four major themes:
the aquifer inventory: location and type; groundwater hydrology: flows within these aquifers; groundwater abstraction; and groundwater availability by area.
The study concluded that the Community had enough groundwater to meet most of its needs but that in most countries abstraction rates were already high: Belgium was abstracting some 70% of its available groundwater resources, Denmark 40%, France 25–50%, Italy 50%, Luxemburg 37%, the Netherlands 62% and the UK at least 25%. Only Ireland, which was abstracting some 3% of its groundwater resources, had major untapped resources. This assessment was mainly concerned with groundwater quantity. Since it was published, attention has turned in Europe (and the USA) to quality, and not only have groundwater quality monitoring programmes been greatly
European Union Groundwater Policy
89
expanded but many groundwater protection schemes have been put into place. These considerations have progressively led authorities to reflect on the need to develop a more integrated protection regime for groundwater, both quantitatively and qualitatively. These steps are summarised below.
3.1.4
The Groundwater Action Programme (1996)
The declaration of the ministerial seminar on groundwater held at The Hague in 1991 recognised the need for further action to avoid long-term deterioration of the quality and quantity of freshwater resources and called for a programme of actions to be implemented by the year 2000, aiming at sustainable management and protection of freshwater resources. The final declaration stated that: groundwater is a natural resource with both ecological and economic value, which is of vital importance for sustaining life, health, agriculture and the integrity of ecosystems; groundwater resources are limited and should be protected on a sustainable basis; and it is essential to protect groundwater resources from over exploitation, adverse changes in hydrological systems resulting from human activities, and pollution, many forms of which can produce irreversible damage. The declaration stressed that the objective of sustainability should be implemented through an integrated approach, meaning that: surface water and groundwater should be managed as a whole, paying equal attention to both quality and quantity aspects; all interaction with soil and atmosphere should be taken into account; and water management policies should be integrated within the wider environmental framework as well as with other policies dealing with human activities such as agriculture, industry, energy, transport and tourism. Requests made by the Council in 1992 and 1995 in the form of resolutions recommended an action programme and a revision of Directive 80/68/EEC to be undertaken. This was followed up by the presentation by the Commission of a proposal for a Decision of the European Parliament and of the Council on an action programme for Integrated Protection and Management of Groundwater,5 which was adopted on 25 November 1996, and in which the Commission pointed to the need to establish procedures for the regulation of abstraction of freshwater and for the monitoring of freshwater quality and quantity. The action programme was designed along four main lines of action which are summarised below. (i) Action line 1. Planning and management principles: protection and use of groundwater is conceived here in the context of integrated planning and management of fresh water resources, i.e. groundwater is seen as an
90
Chapter 3.1
integral part of the hydrological cycle dynamically interacting with surface water in terms of quantity as well as quality aspects. Protection measures related to (over)exploitation, pollution prevention and integrated planning are described at member state and at Community levels. (ii) Action line 2. Abstraction of freshwater: in this action line, a rational regulatory framework for the abstraction of freshwater in large urban, industrial and agricultural areas, and tourist centres is discussed. Recommendations are expressed on how to secure an appropriate quantity management of groundwater and surface water within each river basin. Here again, actions are defined at member state and Community levels. (iii) Action line 3. Diffuse sources of pollution: environmental challenges from diffuse sources of pollution are discussed, highlighting the difficulty of identifying individual polluters, in particular for groundwater pollution where the time-lag between application or release of polluting substances and the possibility for detection of their presence in the groundwater may span up to several decades. The action distinguishes diffuse sources from agricultural and industrial activities, traffic and urbanisation either through local impacts or long distance via atmospheric deposition. It provides recommendations to reduce and where possible avoid threats to groundwater from diffuse sources in the form of policy recommendations linked to environmental sustainability of agriculture, environmental challenges from nitrates and other mineral emissions and from the use of sewage sludge. (iv) Action line 4. Control of point-source pollution from activities and facilities which may affect groundwater quality: completing action line 3, the recommendations focus on protection from activities and installations producing liquid and solid effluent and/or representing a potential risk of accidental pollution of groundwater resources. Point sources are in principle traceable to specific activities and may be prone to measures at the source to avert or limit spreading of polluting substances. The action line refers to member states’ responsibilities with regard to authorisation regimes in place in parent legislation (e.g. the Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control Directive) and actions at Community level. The action programme clarifies the role of the Commission, and provides a framework for national action programmes, implementation and review. Considerations expressed in this communication coincided with the request made by the European institutions to the Commission to come forward with a proposal for a directive establishing a framework for a European water policy. They were hence naturally taken into account in the development of this large policy framework development, which resulted in the adoption of the WFD 2000/60/EC on 23 October 2000 (see Section 4). Some of them, however, have still not been taken on board, and are still to be considered in the integrated groundwater management under development within the WFD and the new Groundwater Directive.
European Union Groundwater Policy
3.1.5
91
The Groundwater Policy Framework Under the WFD
The WFD (Directive 2000/60/EC) took the 1996 action programme into account and was set to complement the Directive 80/68/EEC by stipulating that member states should implement the measures necessary to prevent or limit the input of pollutants into groundwater and to prevent the deterioration of the status of all bodies of groundwater. In this context, member states have to protect, enhance and restore all bodies of groundwater, ensure a balance between abstraction and recharge, with the aim to achieve good groundwater (chemical and quantitative) status by 2015, following the definitions given in Table 3.1.2. These requirements include a range of derogation clauses which are summarised in Table 3.1.3. An overview of the different articles and annexes of the directive is given in Appendix I. The WFD also requires the implementation of measures necessary to reverse any significant and sustained upward trend in the concentration of any
Table 3.1.2
Definitions of good quantitative and chemical status.
Ref. WFD
Good status
Good quantitative status (Annex V.2.1.2)
The level of groundwater in the groundwater body is such that the available groundwater resource is not exceeded by the long-term annual average rate of abstraction. Accordingly, the level of groundwater is not subject to anthropogenic alteration such as would result in: (a) failure to achieve the WFD environmental objectives for associated surface waters, (b) any significant diminution in the status of such waters, and (c) any significant damage to terrestrial ecosystems which depend directly on the groundwater body. Alterations to flow direction resulting from level changes may occur temporarily, or continuously in a spatially limited area, but such reversals do not cause saltwater or other intrusion, and do not indicate a sustained and clearly identified anthropogenically induced trend in flow direction likely to result in such intrusions. The chemical composition of the groundwater body is such that the concentrations of pollutants do not exhibit the effects of saline or other intrusions (as determined by changes in conductivity) into the groundwater body, do not exceed the quality standards applicable under other relevant Community legislation in accordance with Article 17 of the WFD and are not such as would result in failure to achieve the WFD environmental objectives for associated surface waters nor any significant diminution of the ecological or chemical quality of such bodies nor in any significant damage to terrestrial ecosystems which depend directly on the groundwater body.
Good chemical status (Annex V.2.3.2)
92
Table 3.1.3
Chapter 3.1
Derogation clauses.
Article (WFD)
Derogation
4.4
Extensions may be granted when improvements of status cannot be reasonably achieved within the timescales for reasons of technical feasibility, disproportionate costs or natural conditions. The extension request has to be explained in the river basin management plan under Article 13, as well as a summary of measures required under Article 11 and the reason for the delay in making these measures operational. Extensions are limited to a maximum of two further updates of the RBMP (2027) except where the natural conditions are such that the objectives cannot be achieved within this period. Less stringent environmental objectives may be set out for specific bodies of water when they are so affected by human activity (as determined by the analysis of pressure and impact under Article 5), or their natural condition is such that the achievement of these objectives would be infeasible or disproportionately expensive and that (a) the environmental and socioeconomic needs served by such human activity cannot be achieved by other means; (b) member states ensure the least possible changes to good groundwater status considering that impacts could not have reasonably been avoided due to the nature of the human activity of pollution; (c) no further deterioration of the affected body of water occurs; (d) the establishment of less stringent objectives and the reasons for it are specified in the RBMP and this is reviewed every six years. Derogation also concerns temporary deterioration due to natural causes or force majeure which are exceptional or not foreseeable (e.g. extreme floods or droughts, accidents), providing that (a) all practicable steps to prevent further deterioration are taken, (b) the circumstances are declared in the RBMP, (c) measures are included in the programme of measures, (d) an annual review is undertaken and all practical restoration measures are taken in order to recover the initial status, and (e) a summary of effects of the circumstances and measures are included in the next update of the RBMP. Member states will not be in breach of the directive when failure to achieve good groundwater status or to prevent deterioration in the status of a body of groundwater is the result of alterations to the level of bodies of groundwater, providing that (a) all practical steps are taken to mitigate the adverse impact on the status of the body of water, (b) the reasons for those alterations are set out and explained in the RBMP, (c) the reasons for those alterations are of overriding public interest and/or the benefits of the alterations outweigh those of achieving the WFD environmental objectives, and (d) the beneficial objectives served by these alterations cannot be achieved by other reasons for reasons of technical feasibility or disproportionate costs. The application of the above derogation clauses should not exclude or compromise the achievement of the directive objectives in other bodies of water within the same river basin district, and is consistent with the implementation of other Community environmental legislation.
4.5
4.6
4.7
4.8
European Union Groundwater Policy
93
pollutant resulting from the impact of human activity in order to progressively reduce groundwater pollution. Under this directive, the framework for groundwater protection imposes the following on member states. Delineate groundwater bodies within river basin districts to be designed and reported to the European Commission by member states, and characterise them through an analysis of pressures and impacts of human activity on the status of groundwater in order to identify groundwater bodies presenting a risk of not achieving WFD environmental objectives. This characterisation work had to be carried out in 2004–2005 and reported to the European Commission following requirements summarised in Tables 3.1.4 and 3.1.5. A report giving a synthesis of member states’ reports has been prepared by the European Commission and made available on the europa website in March 2007. Establish registers of protected areas within each river basin districts for those groundwater areas or habitats and species directly depending on water, which had to be carried out in 2004–2005. The registers have to include all bodies of water used for the abstraction of water intended for human consumption6 and all protected areas covered by the Bathing Water Directive 76/160/EEC,7 vulnerable zones under the Nitrates Directive 91/676/EEC8 and sensitive areas under the Urban Wastewater Directive 91/271/EEC,9 as well as areas designated for the protection of habitats and species including relevant Natura 2000 sites designated under Directives 92/43/EEC10 and 79/409/EEC.11 Registers should be reviewed under the River Basin Management Plan (RBMP; see below) updates. In this context, vulnerable zones are defined as ‘‘all known areas of land in member states territories which drain into the waters affected by pollution and waters which could be affected by pollution and which contribute to pollution.’’ For these vulnerable zones, action programmes are required under the Nitrates Directive to reduce pollution caused or induced by nitrates and prevent further pollution. Based on the results of the characterisation phase, establish a groundwater monitoring network providing a comprehensive overview of groundwater chemical and quantitative status, and design a monitoring programme that had to be operational by the end of 2006. Monitoring will have to be reported, following requirements summarised below and detailed in Chapter 6.1. Set up a RBMP for each river basin district which will include a summary of pressures and impact of human activity on the groundwater status, a presentation in map form of monitoring results, a summary of the economic analysis of water use, a summary of the programme(s) of protection, control or remediation measures, etc. The first RBMP is scheduled to be published at the end of 2009. A review is then planned by the end of 2015, and every six years thereafter. By 2010, take account of the principle of recovery of costs for water services, including environmental and resource costs, having regard to
94
Chapter 3.1
Table 3.1.4
Characterisation.
Annex II.2 (WFD)
Characterisation
Initial characterisation (par. 2.1)
The initial characterisation concerns all groundwater bodies, assessing their uses and the degree at which they are at risk to meet WFD environmental objectives. This analysis may use existing hydrological, geological, pedological, land use, discharge, abstraction and other data, identifying: the location and boundaries of the groundwater body or groups of bodies, the pressures to which the groundwater is subject to (diffuse and point sources of pollution, abstraction, artificial recharge), the general character of the overlying strata in the catchment area from which the groundwater body receives its recharge, and those groundwater bodies for which there are directly dependent surface water ecosystems or terrestrial ecosystems. It concerns the groundwater (or groups of) bodies which have been identified as being at risk, and aims to establish a more precise assessment of the significance of such risks and the identification of any measures top be required under the WFD Article 11. This characterisation has to include relevant information on the impact of human activity and, where relevant, on geological characteristics of the groundwater body (including the extent and type of geological units), hydrogeological characteristics (including hydraulic conductivity, porosity and confinement), characteristics of the superficial deposits and soils in the catchment from which the groundwater body receives its recharge (including the thickness, porosity, hydraulic conductivity, and adsorptive properties of the deposits and soils), stratification characteristics of the groundwater, an inventory of associated surface systems (including terrestrial ecosystems and bodies of surface water, with which the groundwater body is dynamically linked), estimates of the direction and rates of exchange of water between the groundwater body and associated water systems, sufficient data to calculate the long-term annual average rate of overall recharge, and characterisation of the chemical composition of the groundwater (including specification of the contribution from human activity—member states may use typologies for groundwater characterisation when establishing natural background levels for these bodies of groundwater).
Further characterisation (par. 2.2)
the economic analysis conducted under Article 5 of the WFD, and in accordance with the polluter pays principle. Establish a programme of measures for achieving WFD environmental objectives (e.g. abstraction control, prevent or control pollution measures) by the end of 2009, to be operational by the end of 2012. Basic
European Union Groundwater Policy
Table 3.1.5
95
Review of impacts on groundwater and authorisations.
Annex II.2 (WFD)
Reviews of impacts
Impact of human activity (par. 2.3)
For transboundary groundwater bodies (crossing the borders of two or more member states) or bodies identified at risk following the initial characterisation, additional information, where relevant, will have to be collected and maintained for each groundwater body: (a) location of points in the groundwater body used for the abstraction of water (with the exception of points providing less that 10 m3/day or points for abstraction of water intended for human consumption providing less than 10 m3/day or serving less than 50 persons); (b) the annual average rates of abstraction from such points; (c) the chemical composition of water abstracted from the groundwater body; (d) the location of points in the groundwater body into which water is directly discharged; (e) the rates of discharges at such points; (f) the chemical composition of discharges to the groundwater body; and (g) land use in the catchment (or catchments) from which the groundwater body receives its recharge, including pollutant inputs and anthropogenic alterations to the recharge characteristics such as rainwater and run-off diversion through land sealing, artificial recharge, damming or drainage. Bodies for which lower objectives are to be specified (see Table 3.1.2) have to be identified by member states, including consideration of the effects of the status of the body on (i) surface water and associated terrestrial ecosystems, (ii) water regulation, flood protection and land drainage, and (iii) human development. Similarly, bodies of groundwater for which lower objectives are to be specified under Article 4.5 of the WFD (see Table 3.1.2) have to be identified as a result of the analysis of impact of human activity (Article 5.1).
Impacts of change in groundwater levels (par. 2.4)
Impact of pollution on groundwater quality (par. 2.5)
Article (WFD)
Authorisations
11.3( j)
Authorisations concern: (a) reinjection into the same aquifer of water used for geothermal purposes; (b) injection of water resulting from hydrocarbon extraction or mining activities into geological formations which for natural reasons are permanently unsuitable for other purposes; (c) reinjection of pumped groundwater from mines and quarries or associated with the construction or maintenance of civil engineering works; (d) injection of gas or liquefied petroleum for storage purposes into geological formations which for natural reasons are permanently unsuitable for other purposes, or where there is an overriding need for security of gas supply and where the injection is such as to prevent future deterioration of the receiving groundwater; (e) construction, civil and building works or similar activities on or in the ground which come into contact
96 Table 3.1.5
Chapter 3.1 (continued )
Article (WFD)
Authorisations with groundwater, in accordance with general binding rules developed by the member states; (f) discharges of small quantities of substances for scientific purposes, providing that such discharges do not compromise the achievement of environmental objectives established for that body of groundwater.
measures include, in particular, controls over the abstraction of groundwater, controls (with prior authorisation) of artificial recharge or augmentation of groundwater bodies (providing that it does not compromise the achievement of environmental objectives). Point-source discharges and diffuse sources liable to cause pollution are also regulated under the basic measures. Direct discharges of pollutants into groundwater are prohibited subject to a range of provisions summarised in Table 3.1.5. The programme of measures has to be reviewed and if necessary updated by 2015 and every six years thereafter. Strategies to prevent and control pollution of groundwater are covered by Article 17 of the WFD, which requires the establishment of criteria for assessing good groundwater chemical status and for the identification of significant and sustained upward trends and for the definition of starting points for trend reversals, considering the following. The characterisation of bodies of groundwater as detailed in Annex II.2 of the WFD (see Table 3.1.4). Good status definitions as detailed in Table 3.1.2, which are based on groundwater level regime (quantitative status) and conductivity and concentrations of pollutants (chemical status). Monitoring requirements to respond to the needs of obtaining a comprehensive overview of groundwater status and to detect the presence of long-term anthropogenically induced upward trends in pollutants. In this respect, surveillance monitoring is aimed at supplementing and validating the impact assessment procedure (carried out under Article 5 of the WFD) and provide information for use in the assessment of long-term trends both as a result of changes in natural conditions and through anthropogenic activity, while operational monitoring should be undertaken in the periods between surveillance monitoring programmes in order to establish the chemical status of all groundwater bodies or groups of bodies determined as being at risk and to establish the presence of any long-term anthropogenically induced upward trend in the concentration of any pollutant. Further details are given in Section 5. Monitoring results should be used to identify long-term anthropogenically induced upward trends in pollutant concentrations and to set up starting points for reversing these trends.
European Union Groundwater Policy
97
Article 17 requests the European Commission to present a proposal based on the above requirements. This proposal of a new groundwater directive was issued in 20033 and resulted in the new Groundwater Directive of which the main orientations are described in the next section.
3.1.6
The New Groundwater Directive 2006/118/EC
While quantitative status requirements are clearly covered by the WFD, it does not include, however, specific provisions on chemical status, i.e. the different conceptual approaches to groundwater protection did not allow achieving an agreement on detailed provisions within the WFD at the conciliation. As mentioned in Section 5, this justified including a provision, Article 17, requesting the Commission to come forward with a proposal of specific measures to prevent and control groundwater pollution. This proposal was adopted by the Commission on 19 September 2003 (COM(2003)550 final) and was adopted after a conciliation phase among the European Parliament and the Council on 12 December 2006.12 Directive 2006/118/EC is based on the following three main pillars. (i) Criteria linked to good chemical status evaluation, which are based on compliance with EU existing environmental quality standards (nitrates, plant protection products and biocides) and to ‘‘threshold values’’ (playing the same role as EQS) for pollutants representing a risk to groundwater bodies. The latter category of standards has to be established by member states, using common methodological criteria (which were the basis of research developments under the BRIDGE project; see Chapter 9.1), at the most appropriate scale (national, regional or local), taking account hydrogeological conditions, soil vulnerability, types of pressures, etc. They will have to be reported to the Commission by the end of 2008, and will be used as quality objectives for further compliance checking. (ii) Criteria for the identification of sustained upward trends of pollutants in groundwater bodies characterised as being at risk. These include measurement principles and requirements regarding trend reversals. (iii) Requirements on the prevention/limitation of pollutant inputs to groundwater, which will ensure a continuity of Directive 80/68/EEC after its repeal in 2013, i.e. the same principle of prevention of hazardous substances introduction and limitation of other pollutants so as to avoid pollution will apply. Other elements concern clarifications about the groundwater use as drinking water (albeit this is well covered by Article 7 of the WFD) and its relation with the present directive, which relates to WFD environmental objectives. Recommendations to undertake research on groundwater ecosystems are also expressed in a recital, which illustrates the awareness for required scientific integration. Finally, review of technical annexes of the directive (in particular concerning the establishment of groundwater threshold values and methods for
98
Chapter 3.1
identifying and reversing pollution trends) is requested, taking into account scientific progress, before the end of 2012 and every six years thereafter. This review will have to be carried out following ‘‘comitology’’ rules, i.e. adoption of possible decisions by a regulatory committee composed of member states. Since 2006, these rules imply that the European Parliament will have right of scrutiny on adopted decisions. An evaluation of the functioning of the directive in the light of consistency with parent legislation (see Section 7) is also foreseen. In summary of Sections 2, 5 and 6, the WFD2 (including the new ‘‘daughter’’ groundwater directive3) will complement and ensure a continuity of the Directive 80/68/EEC protection regime.1 This will be achieved through a systematic analysis of pressures and impacts (not done under Directive 80/68/EEC), and requirements related to good chemical status and pollutant trend identification/ reversal backed up by surveillance and monitoring programmes. The programme of measures also sets out provisions that are aimed at replacing the existing protection regime. The new groundwater directive aims to provide the necessary common criteria regarding chemical status evaluation, identification and reversal of significant and upward trends in pollutant concentrations, as well as specific clauses regarding direct and indirect inputs of pollutants into groundwater to make sure that the existing protection regime will be appropriately strengthened. An overview of the different articles and annexes of the directive is given in Appendix II.
3.1.7
Policy Integration
One of the key aspects of environmental integration in the light of the EU Sustainable Development Strategy is linked to policy coordination and integration. With regard to the groundwater policy framework, this policy integration appears to be quite complex since it concerns a range of various directives as illustrated in Figure 3.1.1. This section examines how various relevant directives interact with the groundwater policy under the WFD and Directive 80/68/EEC.
3.1.7.1
Nitrates Directive
The Nitrates Directive8 aims to reduce water pollution caused or induced by nitrates from agricultural sources and to prevent further such pollution. It obliges member states to designate vulnerable zones which correspond to all known areas of land in member state territories which drain into the waters (including groundwater) affected by pollution and waters which could be affected by pollution and which contribute to pollution. A reference is made to action programmes to reduce pollution caused or induced by nitrates and to prevent further pollution, and to requirements for identifying groundwater vulnerable zones as ‘‘those waters which contain more than 50 mg l 1 or could contain more than 50 mg l 1 nitrates if an action programme is not undertaken.’’ The link with groundwater policy is clear in that respect, i.e. nitrate
99
European Union Groundwater Policy Policy integration Seveso, IPPC
Env. Impact assessment Birds, Habitats
URBAN SECTOR
DRINKING WATER
AGRICULTURE
INDUSTRY
Drinking water
Sewage sludge landfill Urban waste water, Construction Products Bathing water
Pesticides, Nitrates, biocides
groundwater
WFD
Figure 3.1.1
The overall groundwater policy framework: integration needs.
contamination levels should not be over the trigger value set at 50 mg l 1 (this argument has been used for proposing this value as an EU groundwater quality standard for groundwater in the new Groundwater Directive (see Section 6). The Nitrates Directive8 requires the implementation of suitable monitoring programmes to assess the effectiveness of action programmes at selected measuring points, making it possible to establish the extent of nitrate pollution in the waters from agricultural sources. The designation and monitoring of vulnerable zones is to be carried out at regular intervals at sampling stations which are representative of groundwater aquifers, taking into account the provisions of the Drinking Water Directive.6 The monitoring has to be repeated at least every four years, except for those sampling stations where the nitrate concentration in all previous samples has been below 25 mg l 1 and no new factor likely to increase the nitrate content has appeared (in which case the monitoring programme needs to be repeated only every eight years). The directive also stipulates that reference methods of measurement have to be used. This, however, concerns freshwaters, coastal waters and marine waters (i.e. no specific mention is made of groundwater).
3.1.7.2
Urban Wastewater Treatment Directive
The Urban Wastewater Directive9 aims to protect the environment from the adverse effects of discharges of urban wastewater and wastewater from certain industrial sectors. In this context, the identification of ‘‘sensitive areas’’ relates essentially to freshwaters, estuaries or coastal waters which are found to be eutrophic, lakes and streams reaching lakes/reservoirs/closed bats with poor water exchange and surface freshwaters intended for the abstraction of drinking water which could contain more than 50 mg l 1 nitrates. This directive is
100
Chapter 3.1
indirectly relevant to groundwater (protection of receiving groundwaters from possibly contaminated wastewaters originating from freshwater sources). The Urban Wastewater Directive9 monitoring obligations are directly related to verifications of appropriate treatment, prior regulations and/or specific authorisations of discharges from urban waste treatment plants to freshwaters and estuaries. In the framework of this directive, monitoring will have to focus on discharges from urban wastewater treatment plants to verify compliance with requirements set out in the directive (corresponding to criteria concerning different types of discharges) and following control procedures laid down in the annex (reference monitoring methods and evaluation of results). These requirements focus on flow-proportional or time-based 24-hour sample collection at welldefined points in the wastewater treatment plant outlet and if necessary in the inlet in order to monitor compliance with the directive’s requirements for discharged wastewater. They include an obligation to apply good international laboratory practices in order to minimise the degradation of samples between collection and analysis. Note that these monitoring obligations do not concern groundwater.
3.1.7.3
Plant Protection Products Directive
The Plant Protection Products Directive13 concerns the authorisation, placing on the market, use and control within the Community of plant protection products in commercial form. Regarding groundwater, authorisations are only granted when plant protection products have no harmful effect on humans or human health, directly or indirectly, or on groundwater, and they have no unacceptable influence on the environment, particularly contamination of water including drinking water and groundwater. The ‘‘uniform principles’’ set out in the directive specify that no authorisation shall be granted if the concentration of the active substance or of relevant metabolites, degradation or reaction products in groundwater, may be expected to exceed, as a result of use of the plant protection product under the proposed conditions of use, the lower of (i) the maximum permissible concentration laid down by Directive 80/778/ EEC,7 or (ii) the maximum concentration laid down by the Commission when including the substance listed in the directive, on the basis of appropriate data (in particular toxicological data), or where that concentration has not been laid down, the concentration corresponding to one tenth of the ADI (acceptable daily intake) laid down when the active substance was included in the directive. The monitoring obligations concern the authorisation regime imposed by the member states according to the directive’s provisions. Decision-making provisions are included in the annex to the directive. The granting of authorisations has to take account of the agricultural, plant health or environmental (including climatic) conditions in the areas of envisaged use (this implicitly concerns groundwater, even if this is not specifically mentioned). These considerations may result in specific conditions and restrictions of use and, where necessary, in authorisation being granted for some but not other areas within the member state. The control measures are obviously linked to the current analytical knowledge (and authorisation may be limited to a limited period if limitations
European Union Groundwater Policy
101
in analytical science and technology are recognised), with requirements regarding the method’s reproducibility. As mentioned in Section 6, the directive makes a direct reference to groundwater contamination (with drinking water standards not allowed to be exceeded), which therefore requires monitoring. There are no specific monitoring criteria in this respect other than the mention that analytical methods must reflect the state of the art, and analytical criteria on the method’s performance as set out in the annex.
3.1.7.4
Biocides Directive
The Biocides Directive14 concerns the authorisation and the placing on the market for use of biocidal products. Similarly to Directive 91/414/EEC,13 authorisation of biocidal products may only be granted if the products have no harmful effect on humans or human health, directly or indirectly, or on groundwater, and they have no unacceptable influence on the environment, particularly contamination of water including drinking water and groundwater. Similar principles as the ‘‘uniform principles’’ of Directive 91/414/EEC are set out, which means that the 0.1 mg l 1 quality standard of 80/778/EC6 plays a role of maximum concentration for all groundwater, but that lower standards may be established following the procedure for including the active substance in Annex I of the directive. The decision-making provisions of the annex to the Biocides Directive14 follow the same lines as that described above (related to the Plant Protection Products Directive) with respect to groundwater. Monitoring obligations are closely linked to the authorisation regime which requests a prior risk assessment for which criteria are defined in the evaluation provisions of the same annex. This risk assessment has to take into account any adverse effects arising in any of the three environmental compartments—air, soil and water (including sediment)—and of the biota. The analytical work has, therefore, to focus on the properties and potential adverse effects of the active substances present in the biocidal product for its classification. In case this classification is not possible, information on bioaccumulation potential, persistence characteristics, information from toxicity studies, etc., have to be taken into account. If appropriate, adequately measured exposure data, likely pathways to environmental compartments, potential for adsoption/desorption and degration, etc., have to be evaluated. This obviously includes effects on groundwater. Specific monitoring requirements are, however, not included, except the mention that testing should be carried out according to Community guidelines if these are available and applicable. Where appropriate, other methods can be used (e.g. ISO, CEN or other international standard method, national standard method or other methods accepted by the member state) and if relevant field data exist, these can also be used.
3.1.7.5
IPPC Directive
The Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control (IPPC) Directive15 concerns integrated pollution prevention and control, which lays down measures designed to prevent or reduce emissions in the air, water and land from a range of
102
Chapter 3.1
activities listed in Annex I of the directive. It establishes provisions for issuing permits for existing and new installations, and makes a specific reference to groundwater, indicating that the permits shall include appropriate requirements ensuring protection of the soil and groundwater on the basis of emission limit values for pollutants which may be supplemented or replaced by equivalent parameters or technical measures based on best available techniques. The permit procedure under the IPPC Directive15 includes a provision for suitable release monitoring, specifying measurement methodology and frequency, evaluation procedure and obligation to supply data required for checking compliance with the permit. The directive includes a provision for installations that may have significant negative effects on the environment of another member state. Monitoring is focused on the releases, the results of which have to be regularly submitted by the operator to the competent authority (and without delay in the case of any incident or accident significantly affecting the environment). There are no specific monitoring requirements for groundwater, but the directive’s provisions obviously imply that risks to groundwater be appropriately monitored.
3.1.7.6
Landfill Directive
The Landfill Directive16 concerns the landfill of waste, which aims to provide for measures, procedures and guidance to prevent or reduce as far as possible negative effects on the environment, including groundwater. Similarly to the IPPC Directive,15 the directive establishes provisions for issuing permits based on a range of conditions including impact assessment studies. Regarding groundwater, site characteristics have to locate groundwater and geological and hydrogeological conditions in the area, prevent groundwater from entering into the landfilled waste, take appropriate measures to collect/treat contaminated water and leachate and prevent pollution of the soil, groundwater or surface water using appropriate technical precautions (e.g. combination of geological barrier and bottom liner). The directive establishes criteria for waste testing and acceptance, taking due consideration on the protection of the surrounding environment, including groundwater. The Landfill Directive16 imposes control and monitoring procedures with a frequency which is to be defined by the competent authority (and in any event at least once a year) and on the basis of aggregated data, in order to demonstrate compliance with permit conditions. The corresponding article notifies that the quality control of the analytical operations of the control and monitoring procedures are carried out by competent laboratories. Further requirements are provided in the annex. They include reporting obligations for meteorological data (volume of precipitation, temperature, wind, evaporation, atmospheric humidity) to check whether leachate is building up in the landfill body or whether the site is leaking. Sampling of leachate and surface water is also required to be collected at representative points (for surface water, no less than two points, i.e. one upstream from the landfill and one downstream). A separate section on the protection of groundwater is included, which requests the provision of information on groundwater likely to be affected by the discharging
European Union Groundwater Policy
103
of waste, with at least one measuring point in the groundwater inflow region and two in the outflow region (this number can be increased on the basis of a specific hydrogeological survey and the need for an early identification of accidental leachate release in the groundwater). Sampling has to be carried out in at least three locations before the filling operations in order to establish reference values for future sampling (following the requirement of the ISO 5667 standard Sampling Groundwaters, Part 11, 1993). The parameters to be analysed in the samples taken must be derived from the expected composition of the leachate and the groundwater quality in the area, with account of mobility in the groundwater zone and a frequency adapted to the local conditions. Adverse effects are considered to have occurred when an analysis of the groundwater sample shows a significant change in water quality as defined by a trigger level which should be determined by the competent authority (taking account of the specific hydrogeological formations in the location of the landfill and groundwater quality) and laid down in the permit whenever possible.
3.1.7.7
Sewage Sludge Directive
The Sewage Sludge Directive17 seeks to encourage the use of sewage sludge in agriculture and to regulate its use in such a way as to prevent harmful effects on soil, vegetation, animals and humans. To this end, it prohibits the use of untreated sludge on agricultural land unless it is injected or incorporated into the soil. Treated sludge is defined as having undergone ‘‘biological, chemical or heat treatment, long-term storage or any other appropriate process so as significantly to reduce its fermentability and the health hazards resulting from its use.’’ The directive also requires that sludge should be used in such a way that account is taken of the nutrient requirements of plants and that the quality of the soil and of the surface and groundwater is not impaired. It sets out requirements for the keeping of detailed records of the quantities of sludge produced, the quantities used in agriculture, the composition and properties of the sludge, the type of treatment and the sites where the sludge is used. Limit values for concentrations of heavy metals in sewage sludge intended for agricultural use and in sludge-treated soils are given in annexes to the directive. In the framework of the Sewage Sludge Directive,17 monitoring requirements are focused on specifies rules for the sampling and analysis of sludges and soils, i.e. there are no specific requirements concerning groundwater.
3.1.7.8
Other Directives
Article 4 of the WFD18 also requires that waste be recovered or disposed of without endangering the environment, which may have an (indirect) effect on protecting groundwater. Finally, the Construction Product Directive19 concerns regulatory provisions for construction products. It indirectly concerns groundwater in that construction products for construction works have to be fit for their intended
104
Chapter 3.1
use and respond to requirements regarding hygiene, health and the environment; in particular there should be no threat to the hygiene or health of occupants or neighbours as a result of pollution or poisoning of the water or soil. The directive focuses on conformity aspects of construction products, taking into account possible risk to water environments (in particular release of dangerous substances to water). As such, the directive does not provide for specific groundwater monitoring other than the requirement than a verification that the construction work is designed and built in such a way that it will not generate pollution of the water or soil. Conformity testing of construction products is generally carried out at the factory or on site from a batch which is ready for delivery. The surveillance concerns the factory production and product testing rather than monitoring possible effects on the environment.
3.1.8
Conclusions: The Need for Worldwide Cooperation
Groundwater protection regimes against pollution and overexploitation are established worldwide either in the form of national laws or regional, national or international conventions, as illustrated by a recent compilation of treaties and other legal instruments produced by FAO/UNESCO.20 These regulatory frameworks should ensure that appropriate actions are being undertaken to protect, enhance and restore the quantitative and quality status of groundwaters. However, much remains to be done to actually effectively implement the different legal instruments. The UN International Law Commission (ILC), which is the UN body in charge of the progressive development and the codification of international law, adopted at first reading in June 2006 a set of draft articles on the law of transboundary aquifers.21 The ILC has sent the draft articles to states, requesting them to provide comments and observations by 1 January 2008. In Europe, efforts linked to the WFD Common Implementation Strategy22 enable exchange of experiences, discussion of difficulties and finding possible solutions in the framework of an international participatory approach (see Chapter 4.1). This certainly constitutes an excellent platform for implementing groundwater protection under the WFD, the new Groundwater Directive and parent legislation at the EU scale, but this will require a constant coordination and accompanying efforts to make this happen. The example could be extended to international cooperation, and initiatives are already under way, e.g. in the Mediterranean basin, leading to shared recommendations.23 Finally, international programmes such as the UNESCO International Hydrological Programme24 offer excellent opportunities to disseminate expertise and experiences, and participate in worldwide harmonisation of groundwater protection regimes and education. UNESCO-IHP has contributed to the work of ILC mentioned above on the draft articles on transboundary aquifers by providing the Special Rapporteur with scientific and technical support and assistance on the science of hydrogeology (more details can be found at www.isarm.net).
European Union Groundwater Policy
105
References 1. Council Directive 80/68/EEC of 17 December 1979 on the protection of groundwater against pollution, Official Journal of the European Communities L 20, 26.1.1980, p. 43. 2. Directive 2000/60/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 October 2000 establishing a framework for Community action in the field of water policy, Official Journal of the European Communities L 327, 22.12.2000, p. 1. 3. Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on the protection of groundwater against pollution, COM(2003)550 final. 4. Groundwater Resources of the European Community: Synthetical Report, European Commission, 1982. 5. Proposal for a European Parliament and Council Decision on an action programme for integrated groundwater protection and management, Official Journal of the European Communities C 355, 25.11.1996, p. 1. 6. Council Directive 80/778/EEC of 15 July 1980 relating to the quality of water intended for human consumption, Official Journal of the European Communities L 229, 5.12.1998, p. 32. 7. Council Directive 76/160/EEC of 8 December 1975 concerning the quality of bathing water, Official Journal of the European Communities L 31, 5.2.1976, p. 1. 8. Council Directive 91/676/EEC of 12 December 1991 concerning the protection of waters against pollution caused by nitrates from agricultural sources, Official Journal of the European Communities L 375, 31.12.1991, p. 1. 9. Council Directive 91/271/EEC of 21 May 1991 concerning urban waste treatment, Official Journal of the European Communities L 135, 30.5.1991, p. 40. 10. Habitats Directive 92/43/EEC, Official Journal of the European Communities L 206, 22.7.1992, p. 7. 11. Birds Directive 79/409/EEC, Official Journal of the European Communities L 103, 25.4.1979, p. 1. 12. Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 December 2006 on the protection of groundwater against pollution and deterioration, Official Journal of the European Communities, L 372, 12.12.2006, p. 19. 13. Council Directive of 15 July 1991 concerning the placing of plant protection products on the market, Official Journal of the European Communities L 230, 19.8.1991, p. 1. 14. Directive 98/8/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 February 1998 concerning the placing of biocidal products on the market, Official Journal of the European Communities L 123, 24.4. 1998, p. 1. 15. Council Directive of 24 September 1996 concerning integrated pollution prevention and control, Official Journal of the European Communities L 257, 10.10.1996, p. 26.
106
Chapter 3.1
16. Council Directive 99/31/EC of 26 April 1999 on the landfill of waste, Official Journal of the European Communities L 182, 16.7.1999, p. 1. 17. Sewage Sludge Directive 86/278/EEC, Official Journal of the European Communities L 181, 8.7.1986, p. 6. 18. Waste framework directive 75/442/EEC amended by Directive 91/156/ EEC. 19. Council Directive of 21 December 1988 on the approximation of laws, regulations and administrative provisions of the member states relating to construction products, Official Journal of the European Communities L 040, 11.12.1989, p. 12. 20. S. Burchi and K. Mechlem, Groundwater in International Law, FAO Legislative Study, FA0/UNESCO, 86, 2005. 21. Report of the International Law Commission, 58th session, A/61/10, 2006, p. 185 (http://www.un.org/law/ilc/). 22. Common Implementation Strategy for the Water Framework Directive, European Communities, 2003 (ISBN 92-894-2040-5). Final CIS document available at: http://europa.eu.int/comm/environment/water/waterframework/implementation.html. 23. Technical Report on Groundwater Management in the Mediterranean and the Water Framework Directive (http://www.emwis.org/GroundwaterHome. htm). 24. UNESCO, International Hydrological Programme (http://www.unesco. org/water).
CHAPTER 3.2
US Drinking Water Regulation: The Ground Water Rulew CRYSTAL RODGERS-JENKINS US EPA, 1201 Constitution Avenue NW, MC-4607M, Washington, DC 20460, USA
3.2.1
Introduction
The United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) finalised the Ground Water Rule (GWR) in 2006.1 The EPA established the GWR due to concerns related to faecal contamination in groundwater systems (GWSs). The occurrence of faecal contamination in groundwater sources is an indication that viral and bacterial pathogens may also be present. The goal of the GWR is to provide Americans that drink water from public groundwater sources with water that is safe for human consumption. The GWR is the first federal drinking water regulation in the USA that requires GWSs, not under the influence of surface water, to monitor their groundwater sources for faecal indicators. In addition to source water monitoring, the GWR requires periodic sanitary surveys of GWSs to inspect for significant deficiencies that may lead to contamination. The rule requires GWSs that have an indication of faecal contamination and GWSs with significant deficiencies to take corrective action to ensure that the drinking water from groundwater sources is safe for human consumption. Prior to the GWR, the only microbial US drinking water regulations that applied to GWSs were the Total Coliform Rule (TCR) and, in part, the Surface Water Treatment Rule (SWTR). The TCR applied to all public water systems and the SWTR applied to public water systems using surface waters or groundwaters under the direct influence of surface water. The TCR and SWTR were published in 1989.2,3 The TCR requires that each GWS monitor its distribution system for total coliforms and faecal coliforms/E. coli; no monitoring w
The views expressed in this chapter are those of the individual author and do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the US Environmental Protection Agency.
107
108
Chapter 3.2
is required at the groundwater source. All GWSs are required to comply with the TCR provisions, although for some GWSs with pristine groundwater sources—for which the system can demonstrate it has a protected groundwater source and has no history of total coliform presence—the State may allow a reduced distribution system monitoring frequency. Under the TCR, periodic sanitary surveys must also be performed at small GWSs;2 however, the frequency and scope of the TCR sanitary surveys differ from the GWR requirements. The sanitary survey frequency and scope are discussed in Section 3.2.4. The SWTR requires that all GWSs under the direct influence of surface water to disinfect and achieve at least 3- and 4-log removal and/or inactivation of Giardia and viruses, respectively. Since 1989 the EPA has finalised five other microbial drinking water rules for surface water systems: the Information Collection Rule,4 the Interim Enhanced Surface Water Treatment Rule,5 the Filter Backwash Recycling Rule,6 the Long Term 1 Enhanced Surface Water Treatment Rule7 and the Long Term 2 Enhanced Surface Water Treatment Rule.8
3.2.2
Federal Statutory Authority
The GWR was established pursuant to the 1996 amendments to the Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA). In the 1996 SDWA amendments, US Congress authorised the EPA to require disinfection, if necessary, as a treatment technique for GWSs and to establish criteria for determining when disinfection is needed. The GWR applies to all public water systemsz that use groundwater sources, in whole or in part (including consecutive systems that receive finished groundwater from another public water system). Public water systems that combine all of their groundwater with surface water prior to treatment at a surface water treatment plant or groundwater under the direct influence of surface water are not required to comply with GWR. These systems must comply with the Surface Water Treatment Rule.3 Private wells are not regulated under the GWR or by the EPA.
3.2.3
Challenges in Developing the GWR
In 2000, the EPA published the proposed GWR9 for public review. The EPA received several thousand comments on the proposed regulation. The EPA, water industry and States shared a common interest: public health protection. However, the three entities had various perspectives on which requirements would be necessary to protect public health. In general, the water industry focused on minimal capital and operational and maintenance costs which translates to fewer rule requirements; and States—oftentimes struggling with implementing existing regulations due to limited personnel and financial z
Public water systems are systems that provide drinking water to the public through pipes or other constructed conveyances, if such system has at least 15 service connections or regularly serves an average of at least 25 people per day at least 60 days out of the year.
US Drinking Water Regulation: The Ground Water Rule
109
constraints—emphasised the need for greater flexibility. The EPA’s goal in developing the GWR was to meet the federal statutory requirement through a scientifically sound, flexible and cost-effective regulation. The EPA met numerous challenges in achieving this goal. Some of the main challenges were: the number of GWSs: approximately 150 000 systems; the number of very small GWSs: more than 60% of the GWSs serve r500 people; the lack of a single, comprehensive national microbial occurrence study of GWSs in the USA; and limited data on public health risks related to exposure to microbial pathogens in groundwater.
3.2.3.1
US Groundwater System Demographics
A total of approximately 150 000 GWSs are unevenly spread across the country’s extensive (over 3.7 million square miles (over 9.6 million km2))10 and extremely varied landscape. The water quality of the public wells that provide groundwater to GWSs also differs throughout the US regions. In some geographical areas in the USA, the raw groundwaters from public wells are clean and safe to drink or the GWSs may need to provide very little treatment prior to human consumption. US groundwater occurrence data and information on the waterborne disease outbreak in groundwater systems suggest this is not the case for other areas in the USA. The nearly 150 000 GWSs supply drinking water to approximately 114 million people. The EPA divides public water systems into three categories: community water systems (CWS), non-transient non-community water systems (NTNCWS) and transient non-community water systems (TNCWS).y Nontransient non-community water systems and transient non-community water systems account for about 70% of the total number of GWSs in the USA. A relatively small percentage of the population (13%) consumes groundwater supplied by NTNCWSs or TNCWSs. About 70% of NTNCWS and TNCWSs serve o100 people and over 60% of CWSs serve o500 people. During implementation of the GWR, GWSs that serve very small populations (e.g. o500 people) will have the greatest economic impact compared to larger GWSs due to economies of scale. The GWR requires systems of all sizes to adhere to rule requirements intended to ensure the same level of public health protection. The EPA addressed the challenges of the large number of GWSs and the substantial percentage of very small GWSs through GWR’s risk-targeted strategy. This strategy targets the subset of the total number of GWSs that are susceptible to y
Community water systems serve at least 25 people year round. Non-transient non-community water systems provide water to the same 25 people for at least six months per year (e.g. schools). Transient non-community water systems serve 25 persons per day for 60 days per year (e.g. restaurants).
110
Chapter 3.2
Table 3.2.1
Ground Water Rule population and system baselines.
System size (population served) CWS r100 101–500 501–1000 1001–3300 3301–10 000 10 001–50 000 50 001–100 000 100 001–1 million 41 million National total NTNCWS r100 101–500 501–1000 1001–3300 3301–10 000 10 001–50 000 50 001–100 000 100 001–1 million 41 million National total TNCWSs r100 101–500 501–1000 1001–3300 3301–10 000 10 001–50 000 50 001–100 000 100 001–1 million 41 million National total Grand total
Total population
Total number of ground water systems
749 084 3 377 075 3 310 229 10 867 911 16 242 873 29 704 225 10 889 872 21 334 033 3 933 533 100 408 836
12 843 14 358 4649 5910 2884 1444 167 103 3 42 361
476 998 1 527 684 1 274 145 1 109 731 376 195 207 644 66 000 110 000 – 5 148 396
9456 6758 1894 715 73 10 1 1 – 18 908
2 461 310 3 360 731 1 242 779 828 502 371 291 299 629 51 850 125 000 – 8 741 092 114 298 324
64 448 18 993 1940 585 74 19 1 1 – 86 061 147 330
Note: detail may not add to totals due to independent rounding. Source: Ref. 14.
faecal contamination and requires these at-risk systems to take corrective action. The strategy is discussed in greater detail later in Section 3.2.4. The population and system baselines of the GWR are summarised in Table 3.2.1.
3.2.3.2
Occurrence Data
Occurrence data play a major role in risk assessments conducted for drinking water regulations. Some regulations, for example the Long Term 2 Enhanced Surface Water Treatment Rule, are based on comprehensive occurrence
US Drinking Water Regulation: The Ground Water Rule
111
studies—the Information Collection Rule (ICR) and the ICR Supplemental Surveys—conducted specifically for that regulation.11 Groundwater is a vital natural resource in the USA; however, there are a limited number of studies that assess the groundwater quality. The final GWR risk assessment relied on occurrence data from multiple studies due to lack of a single study on groundwater systems across the USA. The EPA’s GWR risk assessment analyses data from 15 occurrence studies to obtain an estimate of the national occurrence of viral pathogens and faecal indicators, specifically evaluating the occurrence of enteroviruses based on culture methods, and E. coli.12 When the EPA proposed the GWR, it based the estimate of the national occurrence of pathogenic viruses and faecal indicators on two occurrence studies although 16 studies were evaluated. The two studies were more comprehensive than the other 14 studies and were selected because they provided a relatively large amount of occurrence data among different geographical areas: one of the studies included data from 17 States and 2 US territories, the other study analysed groundwater sources in 35 States and 2 US territories. The remaining 14 studies were more limited in scope and mostly individual State occurrence studies. The EPA intended to use the two datasets selected for the proposed GWR risk analysis to estimate the national occurrence of pathogenic viruses and faecal indicators. The EPA did not include bacterial pathogen data in the risk analysis due to the lack of available occurrence data. Based on the objectives and scope of the studies, the EPA preliminarily concluded that the two sets of data represent the national pathogenic virus and faecal indicator occurrence and concentrations in US groundwater sources.9 The EPA received adverse comments during the public comment period for the proposed GWR related to the EPA’s reliance on two studies to represent national pathogenic virus and faecal indicator occurrence in US groundwater sources. Therefore, the EPA re-evaluated the 16 occurrence studies cited in the proposed GWR and several other studies that became available after the GWR was proposed.13 The EPA faced the challenge of using multiple studies with varying objectives and scopes to estimate that national pathogenic virus and faecal indicator occurrence. To address this challenge, the EPA convened a two-day statistical workshop in 2005 to obtain advice from expert statisticians on a scientifically sound and meaningful way to select relevant studies and combine data from multiple studies to model the occurrence of pathogenic viruses and faecal indicators in public water wells.12 The statisticians recommended that EPA use all available data unless it was aware of data quality assurance problems or the well contamination situation was outside the realm of normal operation of public wells in the USA. The EPA followed the statisticians’ recommendations and used all available and relevant US groundwater studies that had enterovirus cell culture and E. coli data. The modelling approach used to combine data from the studies used in the GWR risk analysis is outside the scope of this chapter; however, detailed information about the modelling approach can be found in Economic Analysis for the Final Ground Water Rule.14
112
3.2.3.3
Chapter 3.2
Public Health Risks
Some individuals may be at risk due to exposure to viral and bacterial pathogens because the pathogens and/or faecal indicators may occur in GWSs that provide no treatment, provide less than optimal treatment (o4-log treatment of viruses) or have treatment deficiencies/failures. EPA estimates that GWSs serve untreated groundwater to 20 million people. About half of the 20 million people receive their water from CWSs and the other 50% from NTNCWSs and TNCWSs. Waterborne disease outbreak data (Table 3.2.2) indicate that GWSs that do not disinfect may be susceptible to faecal contamination. The data also show that waterborne disease outbreaks have occurred at disinfecting GWSs due to treatment deficiencies and failures. Waterborne disease outbreaks in GWSs demonstrate that individuals have been exposed to pathogenic viruses and bacteria,1 although the EPA believes that the data underestimates a significant number of waterborne disease outbreaks and cases of illness due to underreporting. Gastrointestinal illness is the commonly reported illness in waterborne disease outbreaks. In healthy individuals the illness may cause mild symptoms like mild diarrhoea, fever and vomiting which is usually treated at home without seeking medical attention. In infants the illness may be more severe and, in some cases, life-threatening.
Table 3.2.2
Sources of waterborne disease outbreaks in groundwater systems, 1991–2000.
Cause of contamination Community water systems Untreated groundwater Treatment deficiency Distribution system deficiency Miscellaneous/unknown Total Non-community water systems Untreated groundwater Treatment deficiency Distribution system deficiency Miscellaneous/unknown Total Combined Untreated groundwater Treatment deficiency Distribution system deficiency Miscellaneous/unknown Total Sources: Refs. 15–19.
Number of outbreaks
Outbreaks (%)
Cases of illness
Illness (%)
Cases per outbreak
5 7 5
26 37 26
167 1,624 803
6 58 29
33 232 161
2 19
11 100
183 2777
7 100
92 146
23 19 6
47 39 12
4057 3264 442
50 40 5
176 172 74
1 49
2 100
386 8149
5 100
386 166
28 26 11
41 38 16
4224 4888 1245
39 45 11
151 188 113
3 68
4 100
569 10 926
5 100
190 161
US Drinking Water Regulation: The Ground Water Rule
113
Prospective epidemiological studies and pathogen dose–response information are needed to assess the endemic ‘‘baseline’’ level of health risk related to human consumption of contaminated water from GWSs. The actual endemic risk level associated with consumption of contaminated groundwaters is difficult to ascertain because in many situations the illnesses that may result do not rise to the level of medical attention. In addition, there are very few epidemiological studies conducted in communities where the people drink water solely from GWSs. In addition, dose–response data for pathogenic viruses are available but are also limited. Pathogenic bacteria dose–response data are not considered due to lack of bacterial pathogen occurrence information. Therefore, the quantitative risk analysis is underestimated because it is based solely on viruses. The reader is referred to the Economic Analysis for the Final Ground Water Rule14 for more information on the health effect predictions for the GWR. Because of the limited epidemiological studies and dose–response information, the EPA believes that the GWR risk analysis understates the viral illnesses and deaths that are related to GWSs. The estimated endemic level is also underestimated because illness and deaths due to exposure to bacterial pathogens, e.g. E. coli O157:H7, in groundwater are not quantified in the GWR risk analysis due to data limitations. E. coli O157:H7 causes kidney failure and possibly other severe illnesses. The EPA dealt with the challenges related to estimating the viral baseline illness and risk reductions (benefits due to the number of avoided illness and deaths that would result from the GWR) by quantifying the risk using dose– response information for rotavirus and echovirus in the GWR quantitative risk analysis. Also, the Economic Analysis for the Final Ground Water Rule14 includes a detailed discussion on unquantified benefits, for example benefits due to avoided bacterial illness and deaths.
3.2.4
The Risk-Targeted Approach
In the final GWR, EPA established the risk-targeted approach to focus the GWR requirements on GWSs that are susceptible for faecal contamination. The intent of the risk-targeted approach is to target a subset of the 150 000 GWSs that have groundwater sources that may be vulnerable to faecal contamination and to require those GWSs to take corrective action. The proposed GWR established a multiple barrier approach. The multiple barrier approach and the final GWR risk-targeted strategy involve the same concept: identification and corrective measures for GWSs at risk of faecal contamination. The multiple barrier approach included five provisions: sanitary surveys, triggered source water monitoring, hydrogeological sensitivity assessments/routine source water monitoring, treatment technique requirements and compliance monitoring. The main difference between the two strategies is that the multiple barrier approach included a hydrogeological sensitivity assessment (HSA) requirement
114
Chapter 3.2
to determine if the GWSs obtain water from sensitive aquifers (e.g. ka