Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
Edited by
Peter A. Williams North East Wales Institute, Wmxham, UK
Glyn 0.Phillips Research Transfer Ltd, Cardifi UK
RSC
The proceedings of the tenth International Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry: The Past, Resent and Future of Food Hydrocolloids conference held at The North East Wales Institute, Wrexham, Wales on 5 - 9 July 1999
Special Publication No. 25 1 ISBN 0-85404-820-0 A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Q The Royal Society of Chemistry 2000
All rights reserved. Apartfrom any fair dealing for the purpose of research or private study, or criticism or review as permitted under the terms of the UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988, this publication may not be reproduced, stored or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of The Royal Society of Chemistry, or in the case of reprographic reproduction only in accordance with the terms of the licences issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency in the UK, or in accordance with the terms of the licences issued by the appropriate Reproduction Rights Organization outside the UK. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the terms stated here should be sent to The Royal Society of Chemistry at the address printed on this page. Published by The Royal Society of Chemistry, Thomas Graham House, Science Park,Milton Road, Cambridge CB4 O W , UK For further information see our web site at www.rsc.org Printed by MF'G Books Ltd,Bodmin, Cornwall, UK
This volume is the 10th in the series, and from the point of view of readership, sales and reviews, the volumes have been universally well received. They have also been widely quoted in the scientific literature. Taken together, therefore, it is fair to say that they have fidfilled an important need in the field of food hydrocolloids.To support this claim let me quote briefly from some of the numerous positive reviews of Volume 9: Food and Nutrition Press....provides a snapshot of the current state of research in the gums and stabilisers area ...definitely worth adding to your boohhelf J. Sci.Food and m c . . . ...a testimony to the new developments made in thefield ... ...a valuable reference to researchers Food Australia... .. . .the series has proved to be of h t i n g value ...is fiequently cited ....and well thumbed copies can be seen on many shelves Nahrung/Food 43( 1999)H.2...... ..it is a very useful book and recommended for scientists as well asfor all persons connected with development of new products. This last comment is particularly welcome, for the Conferences on which the books are based, have sought to bring together scientists, producers and users of food hydrocolloidstogether. The Wrexham Conferencecelebrated its loth birthday in the July 1999 Conference, on which this book is based, which represents some 20 years of discussions on Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry. The fist Conference was held in July 1981 with the Organising Committee having worked together for over a year previously. I have never before used the term “Wrexham Conference”, but on this occasion perhaps you will permit me to use the expression that almost everyone else in the business uses about our Conference. Of course some participants have come and gone. But, by and large, we have had a very loyal membership, with a stream of friends coming to one Conference after another. There are three, apart from myself, who have been ever present from the very first Committee; George Barber ( Treasurer). Peter Williams (Secretary) and Bob Morley, our correspondingmember from the USA. Continuity has nevertheless been provided since the same companies have continued to keep faith with us and ensured that we have senior representatives on our Committee, and of course we have had new companies join us.
Our home over the 20 years has been The North East Wales Institute (NEW for the subject arose naturally out of our research into hydrocolloids. We started on the Cartrefle Campus where the notorious “hospitalitysuites’ were situated! We have now become more fiscally prudent and possibly more respectable ! But I hope that the enjoyment and the welcome are as friendly and as warm. We moved to the new Campus in Wrexham only for the 1997 Conference, due to the change in status of NEW into an exclusively a higher education institution. It was pleasing that the response to that Conference and 10th birthday Conference was even more complimentary than ever before.
iv
Gum and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry I0
In my Introduction to the Proceedings of the first conference, I wrote ‘‘Gums and Stabilisers have not been the most fashionable area to study in recent times” Indeed the purpose of the Conferences has been to focus attention on and inspire new work into this field . As already noted we have sought to encourage a partnership between industrial users, producers and academics working in the field of hydrocolloids. We took a giant step forward in this respect when the FOOD HYDROCOLLOIDS TRUST was formed, which enabled the Conferencesto become a recognised charitable activity, and so provide a vehicle to safeguard the fbture of the Conferences. The papers published in this volume are a testimony to the success of the venture. Between the posters, presentations as Plenary Lectures, Parallel Session talks and Posters there were close on a hundred contributions. The main presentations are published in this book. This does not include the new initiative this year of the “MASTER CLASS’, providing a teach-in for the younger scientists about the production , structure and uses of individual hydrocolloids, which was chaired by a constant friend over the years George Sanderson , who has supplied sense and music to our meetings. We have observed that companies were sending their young new scientists to the Conference to gain an introduction to the field, Thus a structured teach-in on the various hydrocolloids was a great introduction to the field for such individuals. This time I will refrain from previewing the content of this volume and simply reflect on the success of the Conferences without which the books would not have appeared. This book follows in the distinguished tradition of its predecessors and covers the new work in the subject authoritatively. I wish to thank all the contributors and my friends on the Organising Committee for their dedicated service and steadfast support. Glyn 0. Phillips Chairman, Organising Committee and Food Hydrocolloids Trust
Contents
Polysaccharide Characterisation Determination of the distribution of non-esterified galacturonic acid in pectin with endo-polygalacturonase P.J.H. Daas, G.J. W.M. van Alebeek, A.G.J. Voragenand H.A. Schols Multi-angle light scattering estimation of pectin molecular weight and the effect of homogenization L. Wicker, M.Corredig and W.L. Kerr
3
19
Extraction and characterisation of pectin from pomelo fruit peels M.H. Norziah, E.O. Fang and A. Abd Karim
27
Gum Arabic - quality and quantity assured K.A. Karamallah
37
Identification of Gum Arabic using PAGE and IEF S.Motlagh, P. Ravines, Q. Ma and F. Jaksch
53
Relevant structural features of the gum from Enterolobium cyclocarpum G. U o n de Pinto, M. Martinez, 0.Beltrcin, C. Clamens, F. Rincbn and L. Sanabria
59
Preliminary study of the gelling properties of the polysaccharideisolated from the fruit of the Cordia abyssinica M.A.N. Benhura and C. Katayi-Chidewe
69
What is the true amylose content of rice starch? M. Ramesh, J.R. Mitchell, K. Jumel and S.E. Harding
76
The dispersibilityof polysaccharidesin water and water-cadoxan mixtures Q. Wang, P.J. Wood, W. Cui and S.B. Ross-Murphy
82
Polysaccharide Gelation Biopolymer gelation - the structure-property relationship A.H. Clark
91
Vi
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
Rheological and thermal properties near the sol-gel transition of gellan gum aqueous solutions E. Myoshi and K. Nishinari
111
Comparison of texture analyser and rheometer measurements on carrageenan and pectin gels S. Ndoni, B.U. Marr, H. Neilsen, I.-L. Vedersl and L. Borregaard
129
Syneresis of potassium K-carrageenan gels at different KCl and LBG concentrations D. Dunstan, R. Salvatore, M. Jonsson and M-L. Liao
137
Rheological studies of hydroxypropylated and cross-linked potato starch K. Morikawa and K. Nishinari
148
Gelling mechanisms of non-starch polysaccharides (NSP) from pre-processed wheat bran fraction W. Cui, P.J. Wood and Q. Wang
156
Mixed Biopolymer Systems Phase separation in mixed biopolymer systems L. Lundin, I.T. Norton, T.J. Foster, M.A.K. Williams, A.-M. Hermansson and E. Bergstrom
167
Effect of temperature on the rheological properties of starchkarrageenan mixtures C. Loisel, A. Tecante, P. Cantoni and J.-L. Doublier
181
Interactions between K-carrageenan and P-lactoglobulin in gelling and non-gelling aqueous systems N.E. Hotrum, J. Lucey and H. Singh
188
Casein micelles and their interaction with exo-polysaccharides; turbidity and viscosity C.G. de Kruifand R. Tuinier
196
A description of micellar caseink-carrageenan mixed systems by means of calorimetry and rheology S. Bourriot, C. Gamier and J.-L. Doublier
203
Effect of heat treatment on K-carrageenan gelation in milk A, Tziboula and D.S. Home Solvent structure and the influence of anions on the gelation of K-carrageenan and its synergistic interaction with locust bean gum D. Oakenfull, J. Naden and J. Paterson
21 1
22 1
Vii
Contents
Heterotypic interactions of deacetylated xanthan with a galactomannan of high galactose substitution during synergistic gelation F.M. Goycoolea, M. Milas and M. Rinaudo
229
High Solid Systems Hydrocolloids in low water and high sugar environments J.R. Mitchell
243
Effect of sugars on gelatinisation and rheological properties of sago starch F.B. Ahmad and P.A. Williams
255
The rheological properties and enzymatic digestibility of amylose and amylopectin gels in the presence of maltitol E. Vesterinen, P. Forssell, P. Myllarinen and K Autia
262
In vivo and in vitro annealing of starches
270
S.J.J. Debon and R.F. Tester Solvent structure and gelation of polysaccharides in concentrated solutions of simple sugars D. Oakenfull
277
Effect of sugar concentration on the properties of gellan gum gels G. Sworn and C. Johnson
285
Effect of sucrose on milk protein, LBG and their interactions C. Schorsch, M.G. Jones and I. T. Norton
292
Glass transitions in high sugadbiopolymermixtures - some recent developments S.Kasapis and I.M.A. Al-Marhoobi
303
Proteins and Emulsions Recent advances in protein interactions
317
N.K. Howell Surfactant-proteininteractions at air-water and oil-water interfaces observed by atomic force microscopy V.J. Morris, P.J. Wilde, A.R. Mackie and A.P. Gunning
328
Rheological investigations of transient gel in a depletion-flocculated polydisperse emulsion P. Manoj, A.J. Fillery-Travis, D.J. Hibberd, A.D. Watsonand M.M. Robins
337
Gunk and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
Viii
Effect of pH and NaCl on rheological and textural properties of lupin protein emulsions A. Raymundo, J. Empis and I. Sousa Effects of lipid on whey protein gelation S. Ikeda and E.A. Foegeding The influence of different calcium-sequestering salts on the hydration characteristics of rennet casein in a simple model system M.P. Ennis, A. Thornton and D.M. Mulvihill
350
366
313
Recent Developments, Future Trends Commercial requirements and interests: an update P.J. Lillford
387
Genetic engineering as a means to modify polysaccharides G. Tucker
397
Substitution of gelatin in low-fat spread: a rheological characterisation F. Madsen
41 1
Designing galactomannans for the food industry M. Brooks, K. Philp, G. Cooney and L. Horgan
42 1
Hydrolysed and deodorized guar gum including other guar specialty products: functional properties and applications F.M. Ward
429
Mechanical and moisture barrier properties of hydroxypropyl rice starch and hydroxypropyl rice starch-poly(acry1ic acid) graft copolymer film B.M.N. MOM Azemi, I.Z. Arifin, A. R. Mazidah and A. Abd Karim
439
Selectivity of various pectins to heavy metal ions M.T. Kartel, L.A. Kupchik and I.G. Levchenko
452
List of Participants
457
Subject Index
466
Acknowledgements This Tenth Conference owed its success to the diligence and invaluable assistance of the Organising Committee. MEMBERS OF THE ORGANISING COMMITTEE Mr G A Barber (Honorary Treasurer)
Mr P Cowburn
Danisco Ingredients Ltd
Dr T Foster
Unilever Research
Mr D Gregory
D G Associates
Dr I Hodgson (Vice Chairman)
Kelco Alginates
Prof D Howling
Kelloggs
Mr H Hughes (Secretariat)
The North East Wales Institute
Mr D Lloyd
Cerestar UK Ltd
Dr R G Morley
Delphi Consultant Services Inc. USA
Prof J R Mitchell
University of Nottingham
Prof E R Morris
University College Cork, Ireland
Dr V J Moms
Institute of Food Research
Dr P Murphy
National Starch & Chemical Co
Dr J C F Murray
Hercules Ltd
Dr Mei Ong
Nestle Ltd
Ms L Paterson
Du Pont (UK) Ltd
Prof G 0 Phillips (Chairman)
Research Transfer Ltd
Ms V Sharpe
Rhone Poulenc Rorer
Dr R White
Optokem Instruments Ltd
Prof. P A Williams (Secretariat)
The North East Wales Institute
DETERMINATION OF THE DISTRIBUTION OF NON-ESTERIFIED GALACTURONIC ACID IN PECTIN WITH ENDO-POLYGALACTURONASE
P. J. H. Daas, G.J. W.M. van Alebeek, A. G.J. Voragen, andH. A. Schols,
Wageningen University, Department of Food Technology and Nutritional Sciences, Food Chemistry Group, Bomenweg 2, 6703 HD Wageningen. E-mail:
[email protected]
1 INTRODUCTION Pectin is defined as a mixture of heteropolysaccharides consisting predominantly of partially methyl-esterified galacturonic acid residues. Pectins are present in relative large proportions in plant tissue, where they are a part of the cell wall, playing a role in cell growth control and e.g. in the defence against invasions of micro-organisms’. Pectins also play an important role in the physical and sensorial properties of k s h fiuit and vegetables (ripeness, texture) and their processing characteristics (canned h i t s and vegetables, purees, juices, etc.)’. On an industrial scale, pectins extracted from agricultural plant materials (by-products) like apple pomace and lemodlime peel are used in food applications for their ability to form gels under specific conditions or to increase the viscosity of liquids. They are also widely applied as stabilisers in acid milk product^^^^. Increased interest for pectins from a nutritional, medical and pharmaceutical point of view originates fkom the (claimed) role of pectin as e.g. dietary fibre, cholesterol lowering compound and anti-tumour agent‘. 1.1 Chemical structure in general
The main building block of pectin is galacturonic acid (GalA)which can be methylesterified at the C-6 position. The DM @ e w e of Methyl esterification) is defined as the moles of methoxyl groups per 100 moles of GalA residues. Pectins are referred to as ’highmethoxyl pectins’ when the DM is 50% or higher, while ‘low- methoxyl pectins’ have a DM value below 30%’. Acetyl groups may occur as substituents at C-2 and/or C-3 of GalA’. Apart fkom GalA, pectins always contain (varying) amounts of other sugar moieties like rhamnose, arabinose and galactose. Native pectins are considered to consist of rather pure homogalactururonanparts (polymers of a-(1+4)-linked GalA residues) in addition to more complex ’subunits’. Examples of such complex segments of pectic molecules are rhamnogalacturonan I and 11 (RG-I, RG-II)5*6.These highly branched parts of pectin are usually referred to as ‘hairy’ or ramified regions. The homogalacturonan regions are often referred to as ‘smooth’ regions (Figure 1)2.The proportion of ‘smooth’ to ‘hairy’ region can vary greatly depending on the type of tissue or its development stage.
4
Gums and Siabilisers for the Food Indusiry I0
Figure 1 Schematic structure of pectin including the homogalacturonan (smooth region: SR) and the rhamnogalacturonan (hairy region: HR) backbone. To understand the many functionality's of pectin and pectin fractions -both in plants and in industrial applications- it is essential to know their chemical structure. Important characteristics are GalA content, neutral sugar (linkage) composition, amount and distribution of methyl esters (and acetyl groups), and molecular weight. In addition, the ratio between smooth and hairy regions, the length and chemical fine structure of the neutral side chains and the distribution of the various subunits over the backbone may influence the pectins properties as well. Many of these characteristics can be determined by conventional chemical methods', however pectin-degrading enzymes in a pure form in combination with modem spectroscopic techniques have opened new avenues in elucidation of their fine
1.2 Enzymes active on pectin Two families of enzymes active towards pectic polysaccharides can be distinguished: homogalacturonan- and rhamnogalacturonan- modifymgldegrading enzymes. Below, a short summary of the enzymes active on homogalacturonan is given. We have also dedicated substantial research towards the purification and characterisation of the rhamnogalacturonan enzymes. For a description of these enzymes the reader is referred to the review of Beldman et al.''. Homo-galacturonan degrading enzymes are classified according to their mode of attack''"2. Many reviews have been published discussing the mode of action and characteristics of these common pectic enzymes and they will therefore only be discussed briefly. Pectin methylesterase (PE) is able to de-esterify high-methoxyl pectin resulting in low-methoxyl pectins and released methanol. PE may act blockwise (plant PE) or in a more random fashion (fungal PE). Polygalacturonase (PG), pectin lyase (PL), and pectate lyase (PAL) all belong to the class of depolymerases. PG cleaves the linkage between two adjacent non-esterified GalA residues in a hydrolytic way, where PL and PAL split this linkage by a mechanism of R-elimination resulting in a 4,5-unsaturated galacturonosyl residue at the non-reducing end of the degradation product. PL needs high-methoxyl pectins to act on, while PAL splits next to non-esterified galacturonosyl moieties. Both endo- and exo-types are known of PG and PAL. The endo-types can split the pectin chain at random. Exo-PGs split off mono- or dimers from the reducing end of the chain, while exo-PALS split off unsaturated dimers from the non-reducing end''. The sites of attack of endo-PG, endo-PAL and PL are indicated in Figure 2. The availability of the different enzymes in a purified and!or cloned form has accelerated the structural characterisationof pectins and specific pectin fractions.
5
PolysaccharideCharacterisation
PE
endo-PG, endo-PAL
PL
Figure 2 Homogalacturonanf e n t ofpectin and points of attack ofpectic enzymes. 2 STRUCTURAL STUDY OF PECTIN WITH ENZYMES 2.1 Structural elucidation using enzymes
The group of Albersheim was the first to use enzymes in structure elucidation of pectic material. By treatment of suspension-cultured sycamore cell walls with endo-PG and endoglucanase they solubilised RG-I and RG-II”. The isolation and the elucidation of the composition of these structural units by chemical methods has been described in many publications that were conveniently reviewed by O’Neill et al.’. De Vries et al. also used enzymes in structure studies of pectins7. After extensive enzymatic degradation of the galacturonan backbone of pectin and fiactionation of the remaining material with sizeexclusion chromatography (SEC), polymeric fiagments were obtained. These nondegraded fragments contained virtually all of the neutral sugars residues found in the parental pectin. From this work, it was concluded that there is an intramolecular distribution in pectin in which the neutral sugars are concentrated in blocks of more highly substituted rhamnogalacturonan regions (“hairy”), separated by (“smooth”) regions containing almost exclusively D-galactosyluronic residues. The discovery of the rhamnogalacturonandegrading enzymes”, greatly advanced the elucidation of structure of the hairy regionsi4.The use of enzymes in establishing the distribution of methyl esters over the homo-galacturonanbackbone of pectin is the topic of the remainder of this paper and extensively discussed below.
2.2 Overview of the enzymatic study of the methyl ester distribution The methyl ester distribution of pectin has been the subject of study for many years.
This distribution is very complex due to the fact that the methyl ester distribution should be revealed on a intramolecular level (within one molecule) and on a intermolecular level (distribution of methyl esters over various pectin molecules within a mi~ture’’”~. Methods reported until 1982 have been reviewed by Taylor”. The majority of the studies described in this report used a ‘chemical’, an enzymatical, or a combined approach. Crude enzyme preparations were almost exclusively used. By choosing conditions that favored the enzyme reaction(s) desired, the problem of side activity was attempted to be avoided as much as possiblei7. The majority of the studies almost exclusively describe the intramolecular methyl ester distribution. In a chronological order, the various approaches used are discussed. In 1982 Tuerena et al. developed a method that allowed for the study of the intramolecular distribution of h e (non-esterified) carboxyl groups in pectin with enzyme^'^"^. The non-esterified carboxyl groups of pectin were glycolated with ethylene oxide and a mixture of pecticenzymes was used to degrade the polymer. The non-
6
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry I0
degraded glycolated oligomers were separated and the molecular weight distribution was determined by SEC. Computer studies were performed to determine the distributions expected for random methyl esterified samples of varying DM’8*19. The experimental results were in reasonable agreement with the calculated data”. However, because the SEC-technique employed was not able to fully separate the various oligomers produced, the methyl ester distributioncould not be resolved in great detail. The methyl ester distribution of carefully extracted apple pectin was meticulously studied by De Vries et al. with both highly purified pectin lyase and endo-pectate lyase”. Comparison of the SEC patterns of the ‘native’ apple pectin digests with those of enzyme digests of a ‘transesterified’ (an assumed random esterified) apple pectin of similar DM, revealed clear dissimilarities. The ‘native’ and transesterified pectins were also degraded to a different extent. Fractionation of the pectin digests by anion-exchange chromatography enabled the separation and quantification of the oligomers produced according to the number of free carboxyl groups2’. Here, only minor differences were observed, suggesting a similar intramolecular methyl ester distribution”. Ion-exchange fractionation of the undigested ‘native’ apple pectin did reveal the presence of an nonhomogeneous intermolecular methyl ester distribution. Similar results were found for carefully extracted lemon (albedo) pectinI6.Using pectin lyase, de Vries also investigated the methyl ester distribution of commercially extracted lemon, lime, orange peel, and apple pectin2’.Here, data suggesting the occurrence of quite large sequences of methyl esterified GalA in the commercially extracted pectins was obtained. A non-homogeneous intermolecular methyl ester distribution was reported for such pectins as wellz2. Unfortunately, the anion-exchange separation employed was only able to separate the oligomers liberated by their overall negative charge, greatly reducing the information obtained. Kiyohara et al. used purified endo-PG to characterize the methyl-ester distribution of complementary activating pectic polysaccharides extracted from the root of Angelica acutiloba2’. Separation of the extract by anion-exchange chromatography resulted in the isolation of four pure homogeneous fractions (a-d) which were subsequently extensively degraded by the enzyme. Of the four polymeric fiactions purified, one (d) produced much more mono- to octa-GalAs after enzyme action than the others (a-c). The pour degradabilityof the a and b fractions resulted from their much higher methyl ester content. Fraction c, however, had a DM nearly identical to that of the good degradable fraction d. Meticulous analysis and more detailed fractionation demonstrated that the homogalacturonan regions of the polysaccharide d contained much more homogeneous sequences of non-esterified GalA, as opposed to polysaccharide c24.The composition of the oligomeric mixtures was only poorly resolved by the SEC-method employed, again preventing the resolution of the methyl ester distributionin great detail. The methyl ester distribution pattern of commercially extracted lemon and apple pectins of high DM was also investigated by Kravtchenko et a1.2s.Highly purified endoPG was used for the study of the intramolecular distribution of non-esterified GalA. The intermolecular distribution of these pectins was independently determined by both anionexchange and size exclusion chromatographJ6.27. The latter revealed a non-homogeneous intermolecular methyl ester distribution, which mostly resembled that of a mixture of pectic polymers with blocks of non-methyl esterified GalA of various sizes. Highperformance anion-exchange chromatography (HPAEC) of the endo-PG degradation products of the commercial lemon and apple pectins enabled the separation and
Polysaccharide Characrerisation
I
identification of oligomers ranging from DP 1 to 17. Because of the high pH employed during HPAEC separation, the information regarding the methyl ester content of the oligomers produced was lad'. Computer simulation studies revealed that the amount of DP 1-3 oligomers produced after endo-PG degradation of the commercial pectins was much higher than the amount expected for random methyl esterified pectins of identical DM. The amounts of DP 4-17 oligomers found were lower than the amounts expected for random esterified pectins2’. These results again confirmed the non-random methyl-ester distribution of commercially extracted lemon and apple pectin. In general, it was concluded that the commercial lemon and apple pectins investigated contained at least part of the non-esterified carboxylic acids grouped in blocks: sequences of non-esterified GalA residues2’. Unfortunately, Kravtchenko calculated the amount of oligomers of each DP produced assuming a response of the pulsed amperometric detector (PAD) proportional to the amount of HCOH groups present. Particularly for large oligomers, this could result in an underestimation of the exact amount of oligomers detected (Van Alebeek and Schols, unpublished results). Though very exact data was obtained on the size of the oligomers produced, the unavoidable loss of methyl groups during HPAEC analysis at high pH, resulted in the concomitant loss of very important information. 3NEW METHOD FOR THE DETERMINATION OF THE METHYL ESTER DISTRIBUTION
3.1 Detection of methyl esterified galacturonides One important breakthrough of the last years was the development of HPAEC at high pH followed by PAD-detection2’ for the analysis of GalA olig~mers~~*’~*~’. This separation technique has been adapted to elution conditions at lower pH (5-7) to increase the number of oligomers ~eparated’~ or to improve the separation between pectin- and pectate lyase degradation product^'^. This procedure was adapted by us for the examination of the composition of methyl esterified oligomers”. Post-column alkali addition was used to enable PAD-detection. When this method was used to separate an endo-PG digest of a low methoxyl (DM = 30%) pectin at pH 5 , the complex elution pattern of Figure 3 (line a) was obtained. In addition to a series of non-esterified GalA oligomers @P 1,2, 3, and some 4) other compounds were also eluted in a regular fashion. The latter were identified as methyl-esterified oligomers after fiactionation by HPAEC (in absence of post-column detection and alkali addition) and analysis with Matrix Assisted Laser Desorption / Ionisation Time of Flight Mass Spectroscopy (Maldi-Tof MS)’4. The peaks corresponding to the compounds detected are listed in the resolved elution profile of Figure 3 (line b). All peaks but one could be assigned to specific galacturonides’. With the two techniques, methyl-esterified GalA oligomers can be easily detected even when present in complex mixtures. Maldi-TOF-MS can also be used for the identification of the oligomers produced by PL and Unfortunately, quantificationof these components is not yet possible with the MS-technique and forms a topic for future research. With HPAEC, the oligomers can be quantified after determination of the PAD-responsefactors’. This -for the first timeenabled the exact determination of specific structural features related to the methyl-ester distribution of pectin by using enzymes. Recently, techniques have become available that are able to differentiate the various isomers of partially methyl-esterified GalA
8
Gums and Stabilisers f o r the Food Industry 10
3'
4'
5'
72!y
1"1\ 10
15
20
25
30
35
40
40
&-
45
50
55
Tlnu irnln)
I
Figure 3 Separation of an endo-PG digest of a DM 30 pectin with HPAEC at p H 5. Elution profiles before (A) and after integration (B) are shown. The arabic number indicates the DP. The number in superscript denote the number of methyl esters. o l i g o m e ~ s ~(Van ~ , ~ ' Alebeek, unpublished results). In this way, the exact location of the methyl-ester(s) within a GalA oligomer can be determined. This is illustrated in figure 4 in which a (Maldi-TOF MS) post-source decay fragmentation spectrum of (chemically prepared) mono-esterified tri-GalA is shown. By labeling the reducing GalA with '*Owater, fragments originating from the reducing end of the molecule can be identified. From the degradation spectrum it can be concluded that the GalA located at the reducing end of the trimer is e~terified~~. Enzymatically formed oligomers have also been Intensity
40000.
30000.
R-G,1
2c@w
409.7
100
200
300
400
500
M/Z ratio
Figure 4 Post-source decay fragmentation pattern of mono-esterlfied tri-GalA (G31). The GalA at the reducing end of the oligomer is labelled with ' 8 0 . The origin of thefragment is indicated: R for reducing and NR for non-reducing end.
Polysaccharide Characterisation
9
investigated in this way". Both the study of the methyl ester distribution and the study of the composition of the active site of pectin degrading enzymes will greatly benefit from this detailed knowledge. 3.2 Non-esterified regions in pectin For the study of the methyl ester distribution, commercially extracted lemon pectins of varying DMs (17-74%) as well as PE de-esterified (DMs 56-71%), highly esterified (DM 85 and 93%), and random esterified (DMs 30-70%) pectins and polygalacturonic acid were used. Highly esterified pectins were prepared by methanolhlfuric acid treatment, whereas the random esterified pectins were prepared by sodium hydroxide dee~terification~. Endo-PG of Kluyveromyces fragilis was used to extensively degrade the pectic polymers. HF'AEC analysis at pH 5 was employed to identify the components formed. With the exception of the DM 93% pectin digest, non-estenfied mono-, di-, and tri-GalA were always formed. Non-esterified tetra-GalA was never observed in DM > 35% digests and only in small amounts in pectin digests of lower DM. No methyl-esterified oligomers other than the compounds shown in Figure 3 (line b) were found. Upon analysis of pectins that were sequentially de-esterified with tomato PE, we found that large amounts of non-esterified mono-, di-, and tri-GalA were released. The more methyl esters removed with PE, the more non-esterified residues liberated'. Random methyl esterified pectins liberated the lowest amounts of non-esterified GalA, even when the DM was relatively low. In general it could be concluded that, the absolute amount of non-esterified mono-, di-, and tri-GalA residues produced after extended endo-PG degradation of pectin indicates the occurrence of sequences of non-esterified GalA (socalled blocks) in pectin. The more of these blocks present and/or the larger the average size of these blocks, the more non-esterified residues formed. In Figure 5, the HPAEC elution profiles of endo-PG digests of three DM f67% pectins are shown that release different amounts of non-esterified GalA; indicating a clearly different methyl ester
0
10
za
30
4a
Figure 5 Three non-identical pH 5 HPAEC elution patterns ofpectin endo-PG digests of nearly identical DM (- 67%). The elution positions of non-esterified mono-,di-, and tri-GalA are shown. B, blockwise (PE) de-ester$ed; C, commercially extracted.
Gum and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
Figure 6
Percentage of non-esterifed GalA residues liberated by endo-PG versus the DM ofpectin. Random esterified (M93,R70,R32 and PGA; -+-), alkaline de-esterifed (C67,CRS2, CR32; --0--), commercial extracted (C68- C23; --A+,highly esterified (C67,M8S, M93; -V-), and PE deesterified (C77,B71,B63,BS7; +) and C72 (C72,B67,B62,BS6; U) pectins are shown. CR, commercial random de-esterifed; M, additionally esterified; PGA, polygalacturonic acid; R, random esterified.
distribution. For the total amount of non-esterified GalA liberated, expressed as the percentage of the total number of non-esterified GalA residues present in pectin, the term “degree of blockiness” (DB) was introduced’. In Figure 6, the DBs found for pectins of various DM are shown. In this figure, the results of similar series of pectins are connected with lines to better illustrate the information obtained. Pectins having the same DM, but a different DB have a non-identical methyl-ester distribution. The pectin of high DB will have more and/or larger regions of non-esterified residues present. With random methylesterified pectins as a reference, the DB readily reveals to what extent the overall methylester distribution differs from a random one. The DB, however, does not discriminate between the methyl-ester distribution of two pectins (of similar DM) of which one contains a few large and the other more but smaller non-esterified blocks if both release the same amount of non-esterified GalA residues upon enzyme degradation. Information on the average size of the blocks can, however, be obtained from the chromatograms. 3.3 Sue of the non-esterifiedblocks
Even if both the DM and DB were nearly identical, some pectin digests gave dissimilar elution patterns. In Figure 7, the chromatograms of the endo-PG digest of two blockwise de-esterified pectins of DM 56.4 and 57.1% are shown. Both digests contain large amounts of non-esterified mono-, di-, and tri-GalA. Besides the DM, the total amount of GalA residues liberated is also nearly identical; resulting in DBs of 32.7 and 34.4%, respectively. However, from Figure 7, it is clear that the ratio at which the non-esterified mono-, di-, and tri-GalA molecules were produced differed greatly. Varying ratios of mono-, di-, and tri-GalA were also discerned in a lot of the other pectin digests. Inclusion of the small amounts of non-esterified tetra-GalA present in the DM < 35% digests had
Polysaccharide Characterisation
11
Figure 7 HPAECpH 5 elution patterns of 856 and BS 7pectin endo-PG digests.
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Mono-GalA (%)
Figure 8 Ternary graph of the normalized percentages of non-esterijied mono-,di-, and tri-GalA observed in pectin endo-PG digests. Commercial (C69-C30; A), PE deestenjied (B71-BS6; a) and highly esterified A485 @)pectins are shown. The random esterified (R70-R32, PGA; -+) and commercial de-estenjied (C67, CR.52-CR32; --0--) pectin series are connected with lines (see texq.
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
12
no effect and were therefore ignored3’. When the individual amounts of mono-, di-, and triGalA were expressed as the percentage of the total number of non-esterified molecules released clear differences were observed. These differences can best be viewed when plotted in a ternary graph (Figure 8). In this figure, the data for the random esterified samples (R70-R32 and polygalacturonic acid) are connected with lines to better illustrate the information revealed. Overall, a gradual increase in the relative occurrence of mono-, di-, and tri-GalA can be observed for random esterified pectins of decreasing DM. The higher the methyl ester content, the larger the relative percentage of mono- and di-GalA released by the enzyme. For random esterified pectins, it can be calculated that the average size and occurrence of non-esterified blocks decreases with increasing DM3’. As a result, endo-PG will predominantly have to degrade blocks close to the limit of its action in high DM, random esterified pectins (e.g. R70). For the latter this will result in the release of (relative) a lot of small (di- and mono-)GalA molecules. During the degradation of polygalacturonic acid, endo-PG is not hindered by methyl esters and produces mono-, di-, and tri-GalA in a ratio strictly determined by the mode of action of the enzyme. In Figure 8, it can be observed that this “preferred” ratio greatly differs from the ratio observed in most of the pectin digests. Only during the degradation of DM 30 pectins (C30, CR31, and R32) endo-PG is apparently not hindered by any of the substituents. From the above, it is obvious that the ratio in which non-esterified mono-, di-, and tri-GalA are released after endo-PG action indicates the average size of all non-esterified blocks in pectin. Pectins containing (a whole range 00 different sized blocks will produce the non-esterified components in ratios depending on the pre-dominance of one or more of these block sizes. This effect is illustrated in Figure 9, were the endo-PG degradation of three DM 50 pectins with different methyl ester distributions and different average sized
ar Figure 9 Schematic representation of endo-PG action on three DM 50pectins with different methyl ester distributions.Methyl- and non-esterifed GalA are represented by black and open circles. White and black arrows indicate the first and second linkage split, respectively. The non- and methyl-esterrfied GalA molecules released are indicated with solid and dashed underscores. Here, it is assumed that endo-PG needs 4 adjacent none-esterified GalA residues to act.
Polysaccharide Characterisation
13
blocks is shown. Here, it is assumed that the Kluyveromycesfiagilis enzyme employed at least requires a sequence on 4 non-esterified GalA residues to split the chain9.’*.Though all three pectins in Figure 9 release the exact identical amount of non-esterified GalA residues after enzyme action, the amounts of mono-, di-, and tri-GalA released clearly differ. The smaller the average size of the “endo-PG degradable” blocks, the smaller the GalA molecules produced. 3.4 Distribution of non-esterified blocks
Endo-PG action on pectins of similar DM, DB, and non-esterified mono-, di-, and tri-GalA ratio could still result in non-identical elution profiles. This is illustrated in the chromatograms of the R32 and C30 pectin digests of Figure 10. Here, for example, clear differences in the areas of the peaks corresponding to mono-esterified trimer and monoesterified tetramer can be observed. In the C30 digest higher amounts of these components are present. Because the methyl-esterified GalA oligomers were not available in sufficient quantities, no PAD-response factors could be determined. Therefore, no exact quantification of the oligomers was possible so peak areas were used instead. As a means to express the (relative) amount of all esterified components liberated, the area of all peaks corresponding to methyl-esterified oligomers were summarized and divided by the total area of the non-esterified GalA peaks3*.In Figure 11, the ratios obtained are plotted versus the DM of the corresponding pectins. For all digests, the methyl- and non-esterified peak area ratio was highest for random esterified pectins. The information indicated by the methyl- and non-esterified peak area ratio is again best explained by the results of the random esterified pectin series. As expected, the methyl- vs. non-esterified area ratio will be high for pectins releasing large amounts of methyl-esterified oligomers and small numbers of non-esterified GalAs. For random esterified pectins the occurrence of “endoPG degradable” blocks will increase with decreasing DM whereas, simultaneously, the chance of liberating a methyl esterified oligomer after endo-PG action gradually decreases. As a result, starting from a highly, random esterified pectin, the ratio of methyl- vs. non-
Figure 10 Non-identical pH 5 HPAEC chromatograms of C3O and R32 pectin endo-PG digests. Only the peak corresponding to non- and mono-methyl-esterifed GalA are indicated
Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
14
20
18
-
16
Figure 11
0
?I 14 L.
z
t
p
12
f
10
E 2 c
*t 5
08
f
06
04
Ratio of the methyl- versus the non-esterzfted GalApeak areas of pectin endo-PG digests plotted versus the DM. Commercial (C69C30; A), PE de-esterified (B71B56; a) and highly esterijied M85 (0) pectins are shown. The random esterified (R 70-R32,PGA; and alkaline de-esterijied (C67, CR52-CR32; --0--)pectin series are connected with lines as explained in the text.
-+-)
02
00
esterified GalA production will increase up to a specific DM and then gradually decrease. From Figure 11, it can be concluded that this transition occurs at a DM of around 50%. With the HPAEC method employed, esterified oligomers up to DP 10 can be detected’. As a result of this and the composition of the active site of the enzyme, “endoPG degradable” blocks located at distances of more than a certain number of GalA residues (6 with the assumed active site of Figure 9) will not release any detectable methyl-esterified oligomers. Endo-PG digests of pectins with a lot of closely located blocks (so-called clustered blocks), in contrast, will contain large amounts of detectable esterified oligomers. Hence, a high ratio of the total methyl-esterified peak area versus the total non-esterified peak area is indicative for the occurrence of blocks located at distance closer than -6-10 GalA residues3*.These observations are also illustrated in Figure 9. The three DM 50 pectins shown all contain “endo-PG degradable” blocks and release different amounts of methyl-esterified oligomers after enzyme action. Pectin A, releases 2 methylesterified oligomers (a hexamer with 2 methyl esters and an octamer with 4 methyl esters), whereas Pectin B only produces a decamer with 5 methyl esters. Pectin C does not release any esterified oligomers after endo-PG action. The data in Figure 11 demonstrates that all of the commercial lemon pectins, with the exception of the DM 30% and 56 pectins, contain almost no clustered blocks. Random esterified pectins contain considerable amounts of such blocks.
Polysaccharide Characterisation
15
3.5 Combined results With the enzymatic approach developed, three characteristics indicative for the distribution of non-esterified GalA residues in pectin are obtained: i) the degree of blockiness9, ii) the normalized percentages of non-esterified mono-, di-, and tri-GalA liberated-”, and iii) the ratio of the total methyl-esterified peak versus the non-esterified peak area”. These three characteristics all indicate a typical aspect of the non-esterified GalA distribution. By combining these aspects -including the DM- a better and more complete overview of the GalA distribution in pectins can be obtained. Computational techniques commonly employed in the determination of the sequence similarity of DNA and proteins were used to discriminate the various type of distributions found and construct a distance tree. The approach used will be published in detail elsewherem.In Figure 12, the distance tree obtained for the non-esterified sequence similarity data is shown. In the tree, the more closely the GalA distribution resemble one another, the smaller the distance between the pectins. In general, three types of GalA distributions can be discerned: A) random, B) high esterified, and C) blockwise esterified. Group A is almost solely composed of chemically modified pectins. These pectins all have DMs of 30 to 70 and quite high methyl vs. non-methyl esterified peak area ratios (2 0.6), indicative for a random or close to random methyl ester distribution. Group B is solely composed of highly esterified pectins of DMs 2 74. A typical feature of these polymers is the presence of very small non-esterified blocks. Group C pectins have, from left to right, increasing amounts and/or sizes of non-esterified blocks. This group also includes polygalacturonic acid. Preliminairy results indicate that within these groups even some subgroups might be distinguished. Since the distribution of the methyl esters of pectin is very important for its the hctional properties, it is highly conceivable that the three general types of distributions found could be correlated to one or more of the typical applications of pe~tin~~’*~.
Figure 12 Non-rooted tree showing the similarity of the methyl ester distribution in pectin. 7ke letters in parenthesis denote the three groups discerned (see tart).
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
16
4 CONCLUSIONS It can be concluded that as a result of the development of two techniques capable of detecting methyl-esterified GalA oligomers, great progress has been made in the study of the chemical fine structure of pectin. As a result of this, a vast amount of information has become available with respect to the precise distribution of methyl esters over the homogalacturonan backbone of pectin. In our opinion, the same techniques and some of the approaches developed can also be applied to study the physicochemical and catalytic properties of pectic enzymes resolving their mode of action in much more detail. The methyl ester distribution information obtained is essential for understanding the relation between chemical structure of pectins and their hctional properties. When more even information becomes available about the structure of pectin (e.g. inter- and intramolecular distribution of methyl esters / GalA blocks, ramified regions, and/or acetyl groups) specifically suited for specific applications, new strategies for the extraction and the modification of industrial pectins may lead to newly formulated pectin preparations. Also other (food) applications of pectins may be recognised. The obtained knowledge may also contribute to improve the processing conditions of fruit and vegetables and may lead to a better use of agricultural by-products.
Acknowledgement
The work of Piet J.H. Daas was financially supported by Hercules Incorporated. Brigitte Boxma of the University of Nijmegen (the Netherlands) is gratefully acknowledged for her skilfbl assistance in the construction of the pectin distance tree.
References
1. A. Bacic, P.J. Harris, and B.A. Stone. In: i%e Biochemistry of Plants 14, Carbohydrates. J. Preiss (Ed.), Academic Press, London, 1988,297-371. 2. A.G.J. Voragen, W. Pilnik, J-F. Thibault. M.A.V. Axelos, and C.M.G.C. Renard. In: Food polysaccharides and their applications. A.M. Stephen (Ed.), Marcel Dekker Inc., New York, 1995,287-339. 3. C. Rollin and J. De Vries. In: Food Gels, P. Harris (Ed.), Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1996, 401-434. 4. K.W. Waldron and R.R. Selvendran. In: Food and Cancer Prevention, Chemical and bioZogica1 aspects. K.W. Waldron, I.T.Johnson, and G.R. Fenwick (Eds), Royal SOC. Chem. 1993,307-326. 5. M. O'Neill, P. Albersheim, and A.G. Darvill. In: Methods in Plant Biochemistry 2, Carbohydrates. P.M. Dey (Ed.), Academic, London, 1990,415-441. 6. P. Albersheim, A.G. Darvill, M.A. OWeill, H.A. Schols, and A.G.J. Voragen. In: Progress in Biotechnology 14: Pectins and pectinases. J. Visser and A.G.J. Voragen (Eds), Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1996,47-55. 7. J.A. De Vries, F.M. Rombouts, A.G.J. Voragen, and W. Pilnik. Carbohydr. Polym. 2 (1982) 25-33.
Polysaccharide Characterisation
17
8. H.A. Schols and A.G.J. Voragen. In: Progress in Biotechnology 14: Pectins and pectinuses. J. Visser and A.G.J. Voragen (Eds), Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1996, 3-19. 9. P.J.H. Daas, K. Meyer-Hansen, H.A. Schols, G.A. De Ruiter, and A.G.J. Voragen. Curbohydr. Res., 318 (1999) 135-145. 10. G. Beldman, M. Mutter, M.J.F. Searle-van Leeuwen, L.A.M. van den Broek, H.A. Schols, and A.G.J. Voragen. In: Progress in Biotechnology 14: Pectins and pectinuses. J. Visser and A.G.J. Voragen (Eds), Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1996,23 1-245. 1 1 . W. Pilnik and F.M. Rombouts. In: Enzymes and Food Processing. G.G. Birch, N. Blakebrough, and K.J. Parker (Eds), Applied Science Publishers LTD, London, 1981, 105-128. 12. W. Pilnik and A.G.J. Voragen. In: Food Enzymology 1 . P.F. Fox (Ed), Elsevier, London, 1991,303- 336. 13. K. Keegstra, K.W. Talmadge, W.D. Bauer, and P. Albersheim. Plant Physiol. 51 (1973) 188-197. 14. H.A. Schols, J.M. Ros, P.J.H. Daas, E.J. Bakx, and A.G.J. Voragen. In: Gums and Stubilisersfor the Food Industry 9. P.A.Williams and G.O. Phillips (Eds), IRL Press, Oxford, 1997,3-15. 15. J.A. De Vnes, F.M. Rombouts, A.G.J. Voragen, and W. Pilnik. Curbohydr. Polym. 3 (1983) 245-258. 16. J.A. De Vries, F.M. Rombouts, A.G.J. Voragen, and W. Pilnik. Curbohydr. Polym. 4 (1983) 89-101. 17. A.J. Taylor Curbohydr. Polym. 2 (1982) 9-17. 18. C.E. Tuerena, A.J. Taylor, and J.R. Mitchell. Curbohydr.Polym. 2 (1981) 193-203. 19. C.E. Tuerena, A.J. Taylor, and J.R. Mitchell. J. Sci. FoodAgric. 35 (1984) 797-804. 20. S.B. Tjan, A.G.J. Voragen, and W. Pilnik. Curbohydr. Res. 34 (1973) 15-32. 21. J.A. De Vnes, M. Hansen, J. Snderberg, P.E. Glahn, and J.K. Pedersen. Curbohydr. Polym. 6 (1986) 165-176. 22. Glahn and C. Rolin. In: Gums and Stabilizersfor the Food Industry 8. G.O. Philips, D.J. Wedlock, and P.A. Williams (Eds), DRL Press, Oxford, 1996, 393-402. 23. H. Kiyohara, J.-C. Cyong, and H. Yamada. Curbohydr. Res. 182 (1988) 259-275. 24. H. Kiyohara and H. Yamada. Curbohydr. Polym. 25 (1994) 117-122. 25. T.P. Kravtchenko, M. Penci, A.G.J. Voragen, and W. Pilnik. Curbohydr. Polym. 20 (1993) 195-205. 26. T.P. Kravtchenko, A.G.J. Voragen, and W. Pilnik. Curbohydr. Polym. 19 (1992) 115124. 27. T.P.Kravtchenko, A.G.J. Voragen and W. Pilnik. Curbohydr. Polym.18 (1992) 253263. 28. T.P. Kravtchenko. Studies on the structure of industrial high methoxyl pectins. Thesis Wageningen Agricultural University, 1992. 29. Y.C.Lee. J. Chromutogr.A ,720 (1996) 137-149. 30. N.A. Shanley, L.A.M. van den Broek, A.G.J. Voragen, and M.P. Coughlan. J. Biotechn. 28 (1993) 179-197. 31. N.A. Shanley, L.A.M. van den Broek, A.G.J. Voragen, and M.P. Coughlan. J. Biotechn. 28 (1993) 199-218. 32. A.T. Hotchkiss, Jr. and K.B. Hicks. Curbohydr.Res. 247 (1993) 1-7. 33. H.P. Lieker, K.Thielecke, K. Buchholz, and P.J. Reilly. Curbohydr. Res. 238 (1993) 307-3 1 1 .
18
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
34. P.J.H. Daas, P.W. Arisz, H.A. Schols, G.A. de Ruiter, and A.G.J. Voragen. Anal. Biochem. 257, 195-202. 35. R. Komer, G. Limberg, J. Dalgaard Mikkelsen, and P. Roepstorff J. Mass.Spectrom. 33 (1998) 836-842. 36. G.J.W.M. van Alebeek, 0. Zabotina, G. Beldman, H.A. Schols, and A.G.J. Voragen. Carbohydr.Polym. submitted. 37. R. Komer, G. Limberg, T.M.I.E. Christensen, J. Dalgaard Mikkelsen, and P. Roepstorff. Anal. Chem. 71 (1999) 1421-1427. 38. P.J.H. Daas, A.G.J. Voragen, and H.A. Schols. Carbohydr.Res. submitted. 39. E.M.W. Chen and A.J. Mort. Carbohydr.Polym. 29 (1996) 129-136. 40. P.J.H. Daas, B. Boxma, A.M.C.P. Hopman, A.G.J. Voragen, and H.A. Schols. Biopolymers. submitted.
Multi-Angle Light Scattering Estimation of Pectin Molecular Weight and the Effect of Homogenization
LOUISE WICKER, MILENA CORREDIG, AND WILLIAM L. KERR Department of Food Science and Technology,Food Process Research and Development Laboratory, University of Georgia, Athens, GA 30602 USA
ABSTRACT A method has been presented to estimatethe molecular weight of commercial pectin based on separation on linear mix gel permeation chromatographyand multi-angle light scatteringdetection. Although pectin cannot be cleanly separated by GPC, analysis of individual slices of the chromatogramallows some estimation of the heterogeneity of commercial pectins. Although the pectic substances differed in molecular weight, the RMS values were similar. This technique was used to estimate a decrease in pectin molecular weight after high pressure homogenization. Pectin molecular weight was not changed by homogenizationat 17 MPa but was decreased by about 25% by homogenization at 124 MPa. The polydispersity (calculated as M,,./M,,) was not affected by homogenization.
1
INTRODUCTION
Pectin is a heteropolysaccharideof partially esterified u-l,4linked D-galacturonides, containing varying amounts of covalentl attached rhamnose and branches of L-arabinose, D-galactose, D-xylose, and L-rhamnose.7 Pectin functions as a gelling, thickening and stabilizing ingredient in foods. Functionality is related to the molecular weight, degree of esterification, distribution of esterification, presence of non-uronide components and other structural characteristics. In addition, the heterogeneity of pectin may result from the strong tendency to aggregate in solution depending on source, pre-treatment, method of extraction, and concentration. Likewise, elution solvent, temperature, pH, ionic strength, degree of esterification (% DE) and distribution of esterification (DDE) influence the propensity to aggregate. The propensity of pectin to aggregate has resulted in estimates of average molecular weight that are as varied as the methods that were employed. Some of the classical work using gel permeation chromatography(GPC), viscometric with single angle light scattering detection and component anal sis has shown wide variation in estimates of average pectin molecular weight.** ’ ’ ’ ’ Multi-angle light scattering detection was used to observe the removal of large pectate aggregates by successive filtration.’
‘
20
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
Furthermore, it has been shown that the estimation of average molecular weight, % DE and neutral sugar coptent does not necessarily predict performance of pectins in foods.9310 Although pectinmethylesterase (PME) influences charge, charge distribution of pectin and its propensity to aggregate, our laboratory became interested in characterizing molecular weight of pectin because of the increasing evidence that aggregates of pectin effect PME activity. The complex of PME-pectin in the cell wall stabilizes the enzyme.''*'* Cations compete for the carboxylic groups of pectin and displace the enzyme from an inactive PME/pectin ~ o m p l e x . ' ~ ~Cation ' ~ * ' ~type, concentration and pH influence PME acti~ity.'~,''It has been recently shown that the detectable thermostable pectinmethylesterase(TS-PME) was significantly higher in some purified PME fractions than that measured in the heated crude extract.I8The authors suggested that heat solubilizes an inactive form of TS-PME from an insoluble inactive complex possibly composed by pectin." Finally, estimation of pectin molecular weight is necessary to produce and characterize "tailored" pectins. Commercial fractionation of pectins with specific properties and accurate prediction of functionality would be useful for food applications. For industrial application of pectin, it is necessary not only to characterize the structure/functionof the initial ingredient, but also to have a clear understanding of changes which may occur during processing. In a recent report, high shear and turbulence during microfluidizationdecreased the molecular weight of xanthan gum from about 25 to 4 million dalton~.'~ The high pressure, shear treated xanthan gum had lower viscosity and was less pseudoplastic than the untreated sample. Work carried out in our laboratory has demonstrated that high pressure throttling from 3 10 MPa to atmospheric pressure decreases the viscosity of pectin stabilized acidified milk dispersions by 3-4 times and improves the stability of the dispersions?' The objective of this study was to estimate the molecular weight of pectin using linear mix columns in-line with a refractive index and multi-angle light scattering detector and to determine if low pressure homogenization affects pectin molecular weight. 2
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Commercial citrus pectins which varied in methoxyl content and molecular weight were donated by Citrus Colloids (Hereford, UK), Hercules Inc. (Wilmington, DE) and TIC Gums (Belcamp, MD). Pectins were dispersed in water and dialyzed prior to freeze drying. Before analysis, pectins were dissolved based on solids content to obtain 2 to 6 mg/ml and filtered through 0.45 pm or 0.2 pm filters (Acrodisc, Gelman Science) prior to injection. For pectins which were pressure treated a 3.0 mg/ml solution was made in 50 mM sodium nitrate pH 5.8 and hydrated overnight at 4°C. An Avestin Emulsiflex C-5 (Avestin, Ottawa, Canada) was used to homogenize the samples at 17 MPa or 124 MPa for 5 passes through the homogenizer. Samples were immediately transferred in an ice bath. Samples were kept overnight at 4"C, and chromatography analyses was carried out the next day. The HPSEC-multi-angle light scattering (MALLS) was previously described by Corredig et al." The system consisted of a Waters P500 pump with an in-line de-gasser (Waters, Milford, MA), two in-line filters (0.22 pm and 0.1 pn)Millipore (Bedford, MA), a Spectrasystem autosampler with a 50 pl injection loop (AS 3000, Thermoseparation Products, San Jose, CA), and two linear mix ( 8 p n pore size) PL-aquagel-OH columns in series, enclosed in the autosampler oven at 35°C. In-line detectors included a multi-angle
21
Polysaccharide Characterisation
light scattering (LS) detector (DAWN DSP-F) equipped with an F2 flow cell and a He-Ne laser light source (L=633 nm) and a refractive index @ detector I) (Optilab DSP, Wyatt Technologies, Santa Barbara, CA) operating at 633 nm and 40°C. The LS detector was calibrated with 0.2 pm filtered HPLC grade toluene. The specific refractive index increments (dddc) were determined with the RI detector using a syringe pump (Raze1 Scientific, Stamford, CT). Pectins were dispersed in elution buffer (50 mM NaNO3, pH 5.8) and the dddc was estimated using the Wyatt software (dddc version 5.2). Elution data were analyzed using the AstraiEasi SEC software (version 4.1) and molecular weight as number average @In), weight average @Iw), z-average (Mz), root mean square (Rh4S) and polydispersity were determined from Debye plots. Data presented are representative of at least two injections per treatment.
3
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Molecular weight strongly influences pectin functionality as a thickening and gelling agent in foods. Some of the heterogeneity of reported pectin molecular weight is related to the propensity of pectin to aggregate. The data in Figure 1 shows that the GPC columns did not resolve pectin fractions.
0
5
10
15
20
25
Volume (ml)
Figure 1: Light scattering and refiactive index signals of high methoxylpectin (3.6 mdml),filtered using 0.45 p filters, eluted at I mUmin in 50 mM nitrate buffer. However, differences in the LS and RI signals distinctly show the polydispersity of the commercial pectin by the presence of a high molecular weight species at a relatively low concentration. In previous work it was shown that elution conditions such as solvent, flow, concentration, and filtration did not significantly influence the molecular weight for four commercial pectins estimated by LS?' In the RI signal, most of the pectins elute early in the chromatogramand show a distinctive tail at higher elution volumes. The higher LS signal at elution volumes near 11-12 min with a corresponding low RI signal reinforces the concept that commercialpectins are polydisperse with respect to molecular weight. The A S M A S 1 DAWN software allows the independent analysis of slices of the detector signal to further characterize the pectin. Figure 2 depicts the molecular
22
Gums and Stubilisers for the Food Industry 10
weight distributionplot for replicate injections and chromatography for one of the pectins. The slight differences in differential weight fraction with molecular weight are within experimental error.
1.
1.Orlo.
l.Orl0'
1.0x10.
Molecular Weight (g/mOl)
Figure 2: Molecular weight distribution of high methoxyl pectin (replicate samples are shown). Injected concentration 3.0 mg'ml(50 pl loop). Elution was performed with 50 mMsodium nitrate, at aflow rate of 0.5 ml/min. The estimated M,, Mw, and Mzvalues were 84,100,120,000,and 170,700, respectively (Table 1). The M a n ratio was 1.45,indicating the level of polydispersity in molecular weight for this pectin. Because of the angular dependence of the intensity of Table 1. Summary of Molecular Weight calculated by ASTMEASI of a High Methoxyl Pectin before and ajier Homogenization.
x Pal 84,100 120,000 170,700 1.45
x [Dal 91,800 126,700 193,700 1.39
X [Dal 63,600 91,400 168,200 1.44
Control 0
15,000 5,600 9,100 0.209 Pressure at 17 MPa c 7,800 1 1,000 28,700 0.05 Pressure at 124 MPa c 5,900 2,800 9,300 0.10
YOerror 17.8 4.6 5.3 14.4
YOerror 8.5 3 .O 5.5 3.6 % error 9.2 3.0 5.5 6.6
Polysaccharide Characterisation
23
scatteringof light, detection of scatter at different angles can be used to estimate the radius of gyration or root mean square.22Figure 3 illustrates the RI signal of four commercial pectins with elution volume. Figure 3 also depicts the change in RMS with elution volume. The RMS remained near 50-55 nm for the four pectins except at high elution volumes, where the signal to noise ratio was too great for an accurate estimate of RMS.
10.0
12.0
14.0
16.0
18.0
Volume (ml)
Figure 3: Root mean square radius of 4 commercialpectins as afinction of the elution volume. Concentrationofpectin was 3 mg/ml,filtered using 0.45 ,umfilters, eluted at 0.5 ml/min in 50 mMsodium nitrate, pH 5.8. It has been demonstratedthat high pressure homogenization (microfluidization) and shear disrupt aggregates of xanthan gum.I9Changes in molecular weight resulted in changes in the thickening properties of the polysaccharide. In this study, more moderate homogenizationwith a valve type homogenizer also resulted in a decrease of molecular weight. The molecular weight as a function of the elution volume (as RI signal) for pectin homogenized at different pressures is depicted in Figure 4. Very littie effect of homogenizationat 17 MPa was observed compared to the non homogenized control. However, a clear increase in elution volume of pectins was observed after homogenization at 124 MPa. A linear relationship between log Mwand elution volume was observed except at the extremes of the separation. Homogenizationhad no effect on the linear relationship,but altered the relative elution of 124 MPa treated sample. The effect of homogenization is more clearly depicted with a differentialmolecular weight plot (Figure 5). Homogenizationat 17 MPa had no measurable effect on the weight average molecular weight (Mw) distribution of the control and 17 MPa treated pectins, which were not significantly different at 120,000 and 126,700, respectively (Table 1). However, homogenizationat 124 MPa decreased the M, to 91,400. Figure 6 illustrates the RMS and the RI trace (elution volume) of control pectin and pectin homogenized at 124 MPa. The elution profile is shifted towards higher volumes after homogenizationindicating a decrease in molecular weight. The M,JMnratio varied between 1.3-1.7 for all replications and all treatments and was not significantly affected by homogenization. Estimation of RMS was not accurate due to the variation in signal to noise ratio of the scattering detector between the replicate samples.
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
24
8.0
8.0
(0.0
12.0
14.0
18.0
Volume (ml)
Figure 4: Molecular weight and elution volume of high methoxyl pectin at 3.0 mg/ml in 50 mM sodium nitrate, as a finction of homogenizationpressure. (Elution volume for molecular weight is indicated on top ofjgure).
1.0~10'
I.0XlV
Molecular Weight (g/mol)
Figure 5: Differential weight distribution ofpressure treatedpectins and control pectin. Pectin concentration was 3 mglml, eluted with 50 mMsodium nitrate, pH 5.8.
Polysaccharide Characterisation
25
12.0
lw.o
14.0
10.0
t
v)
10.0
2 d
f I
1.o 8.0
10.0
.
*
>
>
!
,
12.0
14.0
10.0
Volume (ml)
Figure 6: Root Mean Square radius and elution volume (XI signal) of control and pectin treated at 124 MPa. Pectin concentration was 3 mgiml, eluted with 50 mMsodium nitrate, pH 5.8.
4
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This work was supported in part by the BARD project IS-2793-96.The contributions of pectins by Citrus Colloids and Hercules are gratefully acknowledged. 5
REFERENCES
1 A.G.J. Voragen, W. Pilnik, J.-F. Thibault, M.A.V. Axelos, and M.G.C. Renard, ‘Food Polysaccharidesand Their Applications’, Marcel Dekker, Inc. New York, 1995,287. 2 M.L. Fishman, P.E. Pfeffer, R.A. Barford, and L.W. Doner. J. Agric. and Food Chem., 1984,32,372. 3 M.L. Fishman, D.T. Gillespie, and S.M. Sondey. Curb. Res., 1991,215,91. 4 M.L. Fishman, P. Cooke, B. Levaj, D.T. Gillespie, S.M. Sondey, and R. Scorza. Arch. Biochem. and Biophy., 1992,294,253. 5 M.L. Fishman, P. Cooke, A. Hotchkiss, and W. Damert. Carb. Res., 1993,248,303. 6 P.D. Hoagland, M.L. Fishman, G. Konja, and E. Clauss, J Agric. and Food Chem., 1993,41,1274-1281. 7 P.D. Hoagland, G. Konja, E. Clauss, and M.L. Fishman, J. Food Sci., 1997,62,69. 8 A. Malovikova, M.Rinaudo, and M. Milas, Carb. Polym., 1993,22,87. 9 T.P. Kravtchenko, A.G.J. Voragen, and W. Pilnik, Carb. Polym., i 992,19, 1 15. 10 T.P. Kravtchenko, G. Berth, A.G.J. Voragen, and W. Pilnik, Carb. Polym., 1992,18, 253. 1 1 L.Wicker, E. Echeverria, and M. Vassallo. J. Food Sci., 1988,53,1171.
26
G u m and Srabilisers for rhe Food Industry 10
12 H. M. Macdonald, R. Evans, and W.J. Spencer. J. Sci FoodAgric., 1993,62,163. 13 L.R. MacDonell, E.F. Jansen, and H. Lineweaver. Arch. Biochem., 1945,6,389. 14 J. Nari, G. Noat, and J. Richard. Biochem. J., 1991,279,343. 15 D. Chamay, J. Nari, and G. Noat. Eur. J. Biochem., 205,711. 16 V.A. Leiting, and L. Wicker. J. FoodSci., 1997,62, 1. 17 D. Sun,and L. Wicker. J. Agric. and Food Chem. 1999,47,1471. 18 M. Corredig, W.L. Kerr, and L. Wicker. J. Agric Food Chem., 1999, submitted. 19 N.Lagoueyte and P. Paquin, Food Hydrocolloiak, 1998,12,365. 20 L. Wicker, R.T. Toledo, J. Moorman and R. Pereyra. Milchwiss., 1999, Accepted. 21 M. Corredig, W.L. Kerr, and L. Wicker, Food Hydrocolloiak, 1999, Accepted. 20 P.J.Wyatt, Analytica Chimica Acta, 1993,272, 1.
EXTRACTION AND CHARACTERISATION OF PECTIN FROM POMELO FRUIT PEELS
M. H. NOniah, E. 0.Fang and A. Abd Karim Food Division, School of Industrial Technology Universiti Sains Malaysia 11800 Penang, Malaysia
ABSTRACT Pectin was extracted from pomelo h i t (Ciaus g r d s ) by three different extraction methods. Pomelo, a tropical h i t which belongs to the citrus family has a very thick skin which can be used as a source of pectin. It is currently widely cultivated in the country but little is known of the properties of pomelo pectin which could be extracted. This work describes the extraction of pectin 6om pomelo fruit peels using ethanol, aluminium salt and acetone precipitation extraction methods. The pectin obtained &om these methods were compared in terms of yield, color and gelling characteristics. Acetone extraction using sodium hexametaphosphate was the best method which yielded 20.8% pectin (dry weight basis) fiom the raw material. The isolated pectin contained 12.7% moisture, 74.9% anhydrouronic acid (AUA), 5.3% methoxyl content, 40.5% degree of esterification and 4.5% ash. The content of AUA indicates the high degree of purity of the pectin isolated. According to the values for methoxyl content and degree of esterification, pectin isolated fiom pomelo peels can be classified as low methoxyl pectin and are of potential use in the manufacture of low sugar products such as low sugar jam and jellies. Gelling properties of pomelo pectin such as setting time, setting temperature and gel strength were studied and compared with those of a commercially available citrus pectin. The effects of temperature, time and pH of extraction on pectin yield and optimum conditions for pectin extraction using response surfice methodology are also discussed. 1 INTRODUCTION
Pectin is a polysaccharide which can undergo gelation and can stabilise emulsions which makes it usehl in the manufacture of food, cosmetics and medicine. Its most important hnctional property is the ability to form gels and thus it is widely used in food formulations. Pectin forms two types of gels i.e. conventional high methoxyl pectin (HMP) gels with 65% or more sugar and low methoxyl pectin (LMP) gels with or without sugar using calcium or other polyvalent cations. Pomelo produces fruit throughout the year with peak seasons between January to February and August to September. Little is known about the properties of pomelo pectin which could be extracted fiom h i t unsuitable for fiesh market use and also fiom immature h i t s removed fiom the trees
28
Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
during the trimming stage to allow for only a limited number of fruits on each tree to filly ripen. Pectin occurs commonly in most plants in the middle lamella. The two main sources of commercial pectin are apple pomace and citrus fruit rinds. Other potential sources of pectin reported in the literature include mango’, sunflower head* and lime peel3. The contents of pectin in various tropical fruits such as mango, banana, pawpaw, orange, cashew apple, guava and lime were reported to be about 1-2% ‘. Several methods of extraction of pectin have been discussed i.e. lab-scale batch extractions as well as continuous, countercurrent extraction’-’. M ~ experimental Y factors can influence the yield of pectin to be extracted. Studies on the effects of extraction variables on yield of pectin have been This paper reports three methods of extraction of pectin from pomelo peels as well as the effects of extraction variables on the yield of pectin extracted by the acetone-HCI precipitation method as a preliminary step to obtaining pectin and characterising the pectin. A response surface methodology approach to the optimization process was used. A mathematical model that can be used to predict the ‘best’ settings of temperature, time and pH to produce the optimum value for percentage yield of pectin extraction from pomelo peels was also developed. 2 MATERIALS AND
METHODS
2.1 Materials
Pomelo fruits (Citrus p u d i s ) were obtained from a pomelo fruit plantation in the northern State of Malaysia. Commercial citrus pectin from Fluka, Switzerland, was used for comparison purposes. Pomelo peels were cut into small cube sizes, treated with hot 95% ethanol for 15 min, washed with water, ressed to remove the excess water and dried following procedures described by Kertesz The dried peels were then ground in a laboratory dry blender for hrther extraction work.
P’.
2.2 Extraction Procedures
Three methods of extraction were initially performed and compared to find the best method for obtaining good yield and quality pectin. Duplicate extractions were carried out for each method. In each of the methods, the pectin precipitate collected was dried in a vacuum oven at 40 “C for a few hours to constant weight and ground finely. The yield obtained was reported as % yield (g dried pectin per 100 g dried peels). This pectin was used for firther analysis. 2.2. I Extraction using Ethanol-HCZ. A modification of the ethanol-HCI method by McCready” was employed. One hundred grams of ground and dried peel were weighed into a tared 2000 mL beaker containing 800 mL distilled water. Twelve grams of freshly ground sodium hexametaphosphatewere then added and initial pH adjusted with 3 N HCI to 2.2 f 0.1. The mixture was heated in a stirred vessel equipped with a propeller type stirrer at 1000 rpm at 75 f 5°C for 1 hour and the pH checked at intervals of 15 mins. Water loss was replaced at intervals except in the last 20 minute of extraction. The extract was vacuum filtered through muslin cloth and the residue washed with 200 mL of warm water. The washings were added to the filtrate, which was concentrated by evaporation on a hot plate to approximately one fifth of its initial volume. The
Polysaccharide Characterisation
29
concentrated pectin solution was cooled to 50 "C and poured into a volume of ethanol in a ratio of 1:3, the ethanol contained 0.5 M HCI. The mixture was stirred for 0.5hour and allowed to stand for one hour. The precipitate was vacuum filtered washed with more ethanol-HCI solution. Finally the extract was washed with acetone to remove traces of HCI and ethanol which could interfere with the methoxyl determination. The precipitate was dried to constant weight. 2.2.2 Extraction of Pectin using Acetone-HCI. Eighty grams of ground pomelo peel were extracted with water and log sodium hexametaphosphateat 75 "C in a stirred vessel as mentioned in the earlier method. The pH was adjusted to 4.0 f 0.5 when necessary using citric acid or sodium hydroxide. Water lost by evaporation was replaced at intervals except in the last 20 min of extraction. The mixture was filtered and the residue was successively extracted. The filtrate was concentrated to one third of its volume and the pectin was precipitated in a solution of acetone in 0.5M HCI. The jelly-like yellowish precipitate was collected, fbrther washed with 70% acetone until it was essentially chloride-ion fiee or the pH was above 4.0, dehydrated further in 500 mL of acetone and then dried.
The method used was a 2.2.3 Extraction of Pectin using Aluminium sulphate. modification to the method by Wiles and Smit13. Samples were treated as the ethanolHCl method except that they were alternatively treated with 1% sodium bisulphite instead of sodium hexametaphosphate and heated at 70-75OC for 1 hour with constant stirring. The extract was filtered through muslin cloth and the residue washed with 100 mL of warm water. The washings were added to the filtrate which was then cooled to 50°C and 1.75% (vh) of aluminum sulphate was added. Immediately thereafter 1.05% v/v of sodium carbonate solution was added and stirred for about 15 seconds whereupon a pectin aluminum complex separated throughout the liquor as a continuous gel which immediately coagulated into curds. The final optimum pH of the mother liquor being 3.9 to 4.2 at 30°C. The solution was centrifbged at 35OOG for 10 mins to separate the coagulated gel fiom the mother liquor. The gel was rinsed in ethanol, drained and fresh 75% alcohol added to make a fluid mixture whereby the pH of the suspension was adjusted to about 5.5 f 0.3, the pectin was then dried. 2.3 Analysis and Characterizationof Pectin
The tests were performed in triplicates and the average values are reported. Moisture was determined according to AOAC method" with 1 g of ground sample weighed and dried at 100°C for 4 hours to constant weight. To determine the ash content, 1 g of pectin was weighed in a tared crucible and ignited slowly, then heated in a muffle fbrnace at 600°C for 4 hours. Residue was cooled in a desiccator and weighed to constant weight". 2.3.I Equivalent Weight. Methoxyl and AUA contents and equivalent weights were determined by the standard methods of Owen". Values for equivalent weight of pectin are used to calculate anhydrouronic acid (AUA). Equivalent weights were done by weighing 0.5 g pectin (moisture fiee) in a 250 mL conical flask, moistened with 5 mL ethanol. 1 g of sodium chloride were added to sharpen the end point. lOOmL of carbon dioxide fiee distilled water and 6 drops of phenol red indicator were added. The pectic substances were stirred rapidly to dissolve, then titrated slowly with 0.1 N NaOH until the colour of the indicator changed (pH 7.5) and persisted for at least 30 seconds. The
30
Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry I0
neutralised solution was saved for methoxyl determination. 2.3.2 Methoxyl content. Methoxyl (MeO) contents were determined by adding 25 mL of 0.25 N NaOH to the neutral solution, mixing thoroughly, and allowing to stand for 30 minutes at room temperature in a stoppered flask. 25 mL, of 0.25 N HCl was then added and titrated with 0.1 N NaOH to the same end point as before.
MeO%=
meq of sodium hydroxide x 3 1 x 100 wt of sample (mg)
Where, 3 1 is the molecular weight of methoxyl. 2.3.3 Arhydouronic acid (A UA). If the equivalent weight and methoxyl content of pectin is known, its AUA can be calculated as follows",
Yo AUA =
~
176 x 100 Z
(2)
Where, 176 is the molecular weight of AUA and
Z=
wt of sample (mg) meq of alkalifor free acid + meq of alkalifor methoxyl
2.3.4 Degree of Ester$cation. The degree of esterification (DE) of pectin can be determined according to the formula given below16. Yo DE =
176 x CHaO% x 100 31xAUAYo
(4)
Where CH3O is % methoxyl content. 2.3.5 Physical Properties. Gelling properties such as setting time, setting temperature and gel strength of pomelo pectin extracted b the acetone precipitation method were determined by method described by Lodge et alh. Gels were formulated to contain 0.2 g pectin and 25 g sugar (pectin concentration of 0.4%, wlw) and adjusted to pH 2.8-3.1 with citric acid solution. The solution having a Brix value of 65" was then poured into a plastic cup and left to stand at room temperature for about 18 hrs before
PolysaccharideCharacterisation
31
being tested for gel strength. The gel strength or penetration force was measured with a stainless steel probe (P/lKSS KOBE 1 cm') forced into the gel to a depth of 4 mm using the Texture Analyzer ZTZ version 5.51 (Stable Micro System) with a cell loading of 5 kg. The gelation or setting temperature and setting time were also determined. A standard Fluka 250 grade citrus pectin (Fluka chemicals) was also tested for gel strength, setting time and gelation temperature for comparison purposes. 2.4 Effects o f Process Variables on Pectin Yield
The effects of temperature, time and pH on pectin yield by the acetone precipitation method were investigated. The temperature, pH and time of extraction were varied according to the experimental design chosen. Statistical design, analysis of variance (ANOVA) and plotting of the response surface were performed using Design Expert version 5.0 (Stat-Ease Inc.) and also Statgraphics PZus (Statistical Graphic Corp.), comprehensive graphic Window-based software for statistical experimental design, analysis and interpretation. The extraction process was assumed to be a system affected by three independent variables or factors, Zi (in this study, extraction temperature, time and pH), which were controlled and measured. It was assumed that the dependent variable, also referred to as response, Y (in this study, % pectin yield) defined the system and was experimentally determined. A mathematical finction, was assumed to describe the relationship between response, Y and the factors, Zi.
The experimental design consisted of three variables at five-levels with 20 runs. 3 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Three methods of extraction were initially compared to determine the yield and characteristics of pectin extracted fiom pomelo h i t peels. A summary of results is shown in Table 1. The gelling properties of pectin gels are shown in Table 2. The extraction of pectin using the acetone-HCI precipitation method gave the best yield (20.8%) and the most desirable colour. Ifthe yield of pectin is greater than lO??,then the source of pectin is considered possible for commercial use. The yield of commercial pectin from apple pomace was reported to be 17%" whereas pectin from Coorg Mandarin peel was 13.2%'*. The ash content is quite low except for pectin extracted by method C which is 16.1%. Ash content also can affect the gelling of pectin. A low ash content is more favorable for gel formation". Commercial high methox I and low methoxyl pectin has been reported to contain about 1.9-5.2% ash content. The equivalent weights obtained were used for the calculations of %AUA and % DE. In all of the extraction methods, %DE in pectin are found to be lower than 50% and the % methoxyl content are also low. This indicates that pectin extracted fiom pomelo peels is of the low methoxyl type (LMP) since LMP is classified as having % DE lower than 50% and % methoxyl content between 0.5-7.0%. The content of methoxyl plays a key role in the ability for gel formation. LMP can form gels with a lower amount of sugar or without sugar in the presence of divalent cations. Hence, this will be more usefil in making of low sugar or
r
32
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
calcium pectate gels. The AUA content obtained from methods A and B are >70% . The content of AUA indicates the high degree of purity of pectin isolated. The AUA content (39.9%) of the pectin extract by aluminium precipitation method indicates that the extract is not pure. Citrus pectin obtained commercially contains about 83% AUA and 10% methoxyl content5. AUA content in pectin was suggested to be not less than 70%”.
Table 1 Yield and Chemical Characteristics of Pectin Extracted and Pectin Gel Formed
Yield of pectin, %
A. Ethanol-HCl precipitation* 19 f 0.2
Moisture, %
13.4 f 0.5
Ash content, % Equivalent weight
B. Acetone-HCI precipitation 20.8 f 0.3 12.7 f 0.2
2.5 f 0.01
9.3 f 0.3
4.5 f 0.02
391.2 f 0.6
Methoxyl content
C. Aluminium surphare precipitation* 12.6 f 1.0 16.1 f 0.6
395.6 f 0.8
738.3 f 0.6
5.3 f 0.3
2.8 f 0.1
5.1 f 0.03
AUA, %
73.9 f 0.2
74.9 f 0.9
39.9 f 1.1
DE, Yo
39.2 f 0.1
40.5 f 0.6
40.3 f 0.1
Brown
Light brown
Light green
Solubility -good, pale yellow
Solubility -good, pale yellow
Solubility - low, Slightly greenish
Colour of pectin Colour (gel)
n = triplicate runs The results given in Table 2 indicate that pectin from pomelo peel is a ‘rapid set’ type whereas the citrus pectin is of the ‘slow-set’ type. The results are consistent with reports by Owens” that pectin with DE >70% is the ‘rapid set’ type; between 50-70% is the ‘slow set’ type but is ‘rapid-set’ again when DE is lower than 50%. The lower the DE for LMP the faster it sets and at higher setting temperature. Table 2 GellingProperties of Pectin Gels Isolatedpectin gel
Citruspectin ( F L U . 250 grade)
75-80
55-60
Setting time (min)
-1
> 10
PH
2.9
2.9
Gel strength (g)
50.0
194.0
Setting temperature (‘C)
Polysaccharide Characterisation
33
Figures 1 and 2 show force vs time curves from texture analysis on the pectin gels prepared. The results show that gel strength was low for the isolated pectin from pomelo (50.0g or OSON) when compared with pectin from standard citrus grade 250 (194.0 g or 1.94 N). Citrus pectin at a concentration of 0.4% formed fm gels but pomelo pectin formed softer gels at this concentration. Thus it estimated that the jelly grade of pomelo pectin is lower than that of citrus pectin grade 250. Response surface methodology was applied for the defined experimental region and used to evaluate the effects of three main extraction variables (temperature, time and pH). A central composite rotatable second-order design with six replicates at the centre point, eight Q3) factorial points and six axial points was chosen for optimisation of extraction conditions. A predicted model for pectin yield was developed as functions of temperature, time and pH i.e. a reduced quadratic equation as shown below,
Y = 18.32 + 3.43 (XI) + 1.74(X2) - 0.27 (X3) - 1.62 (X'I)
Where, XI, XZ, X3 are coded values for temperature, time and pH of extraction respectively and Y is the response ,% yield of pectin. The effects of all three variables (temperature, time and pH) on the yield of the extracted pectin were found to be significant with pH being least significant. Reports by Aravantinos-Zafiris and Oreopoulou9on the optimisation of pectin from orange waste also showed that all three factors, temperature,time and pH had significant effects. There was no significant interaction between the independent variables. Thus the increase in time of extraction was independent of the effect of temperature and pH on pectin yield. A significant quadratic effect of temperature was observed 'which results in a decrease of pectin yield. Among the variables, regression coefficient for temperature is of a higher value indicating the effect of temperature is greater than that for time. A compromise has to be reached between obtaining maximum pectin yield and minimum pectin degradation. High heat enhances rate of reaction and pectin can undergo degradation at temperatures greater than 90°C7. Long time extraction causes more hydrolysis and pectin chains become shorter than short time extraction2'. A verification experiment at the optimum conditions on the yield of pectin was performed. The experimental value obtained is 20.8 f 0.36% yield whereas predicted value is 20.1%. The results showed that the experimental and predicted values are reasonably close. A contour plot and a response surface plot for percentage pectin yield as a function of two most important factors (temperature and time), holding pH at a value of 3.6 are drawn in Figures 3 and 4 respectively. The results indicate that a temperature not greater than 90°C associated with time not longer than 64 min and a low pH value (pH 3.6) lead to a good % yield of pectin. 4. CONCLUSION
In conclusion, pomelo peel was found to be a good source of pectin. The yield obtained is about 20% and pomelo pectin is of the low methoxyl type. The extraction procedure using acetone precipitation was also optimised in which the 'best' conditions for extraction is at a temperature of 90°C, extraction time not longer than 64 min and at low
34
Gums and Stabilisersfor rhe Food Industry 10
Force (N) 0 . m
1
Stable Micro Systems - Texture Expert
3 . 6 4.0
1
5.0
6.0
Time (sec) -0.2000 J
Figure 1 Force vs time curvefor pomelo pectin
Force (N) 2.000 -1
1.750
Stable Micro Systems - Texture Expert
-
1.5001.250 1.2501.000-
0.750 0.500 0.250
-
0.000 -0.0 -0.250’ -0.250
1
1.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
Time (sec)
Figure 2 Force vs time curvefor cilrus pectin
35
Polysaccharide Characterisation
Yield DESIGN-EXPERT Plot Actual Factors: X = Temp Y = Time Actual Constants: pH = 3.60
70.00
76.25
82.50
88.75
95.00
Temp
Figure 3 A mrjime contourplot ofyield as afunction oftemperature and time
-
DESIGKWERT Plot
Actual Factom: X = Temp Y = Time
-
Actual Constants: pH 3.60
,w.w .:.:.:...
40.00 70.00
Figure 4 A 3-a?memiomlpesentation of the response surface for the yield as a function of temperature (“C)andtime (min)
Gums and Siabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
36
pH value of 3.6. Acknowledgement The authors acknowledge the research grant provide by Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang that has resulted in this article. References 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15.
16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21.
A. N. Srirangarajan and A. J. Shrikhande,J. FoodSci.. 1977,42,279. A. Miyamoto and K. C. Chang, J. FoodSci., 1992,57, 1439. R. A. Padival, S.Rangana and S.P. Manjrekar, J. Food Technol., 1979, 14,333. E. C. Nwanekezi, 0. C. G. Alawuba and C. C. M. Mkpolulu, J. FoodSci. Technol., 1994, 31, 159. B. J. Francis, and J. M. K. Bell, J. TropicaZSci.,1975, 17(1), 25. B. K. Simpson, K. B. Egyankor and A. M. Martin, J. Food Processing and Preservation, 1984, 8(2), 63. L. Phatak, K. C. Chang and G. Brown, J. FoodSci., 1988,53(3), 830. J. Wang, D. P. Wiesenborn, J. G. Schwarz, and K. C. Chang, Transactions of the ASAE, 1997,40(6), 1654. G. Aravantinos-Zafiris and V. Oreopoulou, J. Sci. FoodAgric., 1992,60, 127. F. Michel, J. F. Thilbault, C. Mercier, F. Heitz and F. Pouileande, J. FoodSci.,1985, 50, 1499. Z. I. Kertesz, ‘The Pectic Substance’ Wiley (Interscience), New York, 1951. R. M. McCready, ‘Methods in Food Analysis’ Academic Press, New York and London, 1970, 2“ded., p 565. R. R. Wiles and C. J. B. Smit, U.S. Patent 3,622559, Sunkist Growers Inc, Nov 23. 1971. AOAC Association of OWcial Analytical Chemists. ‘Oficial Methods of Analysis’, 13* edition. Washington D.C., 1980. H. S. Owens, R. M. McCready, A. D. Shepard, T. H. Schultz, E. L. Pippen, H. A. Swenson, J. C. Miers, R. F. Erlandsen and W. D. Maclay, ‘Methods used at Western Regional Research Laboratory for Extraction of Pectic Materials’, USDA Bur. Agric. Ind. Chem. 1952, Report No. 340, p9. T. H. Schultz, ‘Methods in Carbohydrate Chemistry’, Academic Press, New York, USA, 1976, Vol5, p189. N. Lodge, T. T. Nguyen and D. McIntyre, A FoodSci., 1987,52(4), 1095. J. S.Pruthi, C. M. Parekh and L. Ghirdari, Food Science, 1961, lO(1 l), 327. F. W. Sosulski, M. J. Y. Lin and E. S.Humbert, Can. Znst. FoodSci. Technol., 1978, 11(3), 113. National Research Council, ‘Food Chemical Codex’, 3d ed., National Academy of Science, Washington, DC, 1987, p 215. K. C. Chang, N. Dhurandhar, X. You and A. Miyamoto, J. Food Sci., 1994, 59, 1209.
Gum Arabic
- Quality and Quantity Assured
K. A. Karamallah
Gandil Agriculture Co. Ltd, PO Box 522, Khartoum, Sudan.
SUMMARY Analytical data have shown that many qualifying indices of such a natural product, as Gum Arabic remained virtually constant over the years. Evidence obtained from the analyses of over 800 authenticated gum samples collected from 12 locations in the Gum belt of Sudan revealed that such factors as soil, rainfall, temperature, age of the tree, site of exudation and picking number had very little or no significant effect on gum quality. Data indicate that Gum Arabic from Acacia senegal is different and distinct botanically, physicochemically and functionally from other Acacia gums e.g. A. seyal gum. It is the only Acacia gum that has been tested toxicologically and proved to be safe (AD1 not specified) as a food additive. A prelimivary toxicological investigation carried out on both seyal varieties (var. seyal and var. fistula) on samples supplied by the Gum Arabic Company (GAC) has indicated some histo-pathological effects (particularly at higher dozes) on rats fed with these two gums. Good quality Gum Arabic is assured in sufficient supply at a reasonable price through good agricultural practices as offered by Gandil Agricultural Co. Ltd. through Acacia senegal plantations on very large scale.
introduction Gum Arabic, a natural exudate of the trees of Acacia senegal has been an important article of commerce for about 4000 years. This gum is widely used in the food, pharmaceutical and cosmetic industries due to its unique physico-chemical and functional properties. It has been subjected to intensive investigations, and systematic approach of research into the characteristics and properties have taken place for about four decades by many workers including Anderson and his colleagues. As a result, there is a wealth of information which clearly indicates that gum from Acacia senegal is a complex proteoglycan acidic salt (mainly Ca, K, Mg and Na) of high molecular weight (average 4 X lo5, Mv). The polysaccharide moeity is composed of D-galactose, L-arabinose, L-rhamnose, D-glucuronic acid and its 4-0-methyl ether together with a proteinaceous com onent. The protein is an integral part of the molecular structure of the gum1 2'3* 4 5,6,$3
38
Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
Qualifying Indices of Gum Arabic Quality means identity and purity of a certain product. Therefore for each product there are certain qualifying indices or parameters, that should be assured before the product is judged suitable for use or application. In the case of gum from Acacia senegal (Gum Arabic), about twenty parameters have been proposed by different author^^^^'^"^'^' This natural product is composed mainly of carbohydrates (ca. 80%), protein (ca. 3%), minerals (ca. 4%) and moisture (ca. 11%). The five most important parameters that can be used to identify raw Gum Arabic (Acacia senegal) and distinguish it from other Acacia gums are: (1) Specific optical rotation, (2) Nitrogen content, (3) Ash content, (4) Moisture content and (5) Absence of tannins. While tannin will be discussed later in the paper, it is interesting to note that there is a distinct relationship between the nitrogen content and specific optical rotation of gum from different Acacia species. Such relationship clearly distinguishes between gums of Acacia species12. Fig. 1 shows that the different species can be clustered into two major groups based on optical rotation. Again, within each group, there is a distinct differentiation between each species based on the nitrogen content. It also shows that there are differences within variants of each Acacia species. Table 1 shows the major physico-chemical properties of different Acacia species of the Sudan. Table 2 depicts the major physico-chemical differences between Gum Arabic from Acacia senegal and gum from Acacia ~ e y a ? ' ' ~ ' ' ~ ,~ For ' ~ ' example, '~'~~ gum from Acacia senegal has a negative optical rotation (mean -31.3"), while that of gum from Acacia seyal has a positive optical rotation (mean +50.1°). Again, gum from Acacia senegal has higher content of rhamnose (12 - 14%) and lower arabinose content (24 - 29%) compared to the rhamnose (3 - 4%) and arabinose content (41 - 45%) of gum from Acacia seyal. Also the nitrogen content of gum from Acacia senegal is nearly three times that of the nitrogen content of gum from Acacia seyal. Gum from Acacia senegal has been shown to have a macromolecular structure that differs significantly in a number of ways from that of gums from Acacia seyal. C13NMR spectral studies clearly indicate the different peaks for rhamnose residues. Such peaks are virtually absent in spectra of gum from Acacia seyal. This clearly distinguishes between the two gums" (Fig. 2). In a very recent studylg, over 1500 authentic and commercial Acacia senegal var. senegal gum samples were analyzed to evaluate existing quality control parameters. This study also objectively assessed the potential of new parameters such as pH, viscosity, viscosity average molecular weight (Mv), equivalent weight and total uronic acid content as additional qualifying indices. The results from this study indicate the following mean values: moisture (10.75%), ash (3.77%), nitrogen (0.328%), specific optical rotation (-31.3'), pH (4.66), equivalent weight (1436) and total uronic acid content (13.71%) (Table 4). No significant variations have been observed in these parameters over the last forty years. The results of this study indicate wide variations in values for intrinsic viscosity and viscosity average molecular weight, indicating that such parameters cannot be used as qualifying indices.
60
30
a
4 0
0
5
+
0
0
+
EP
+
0.5
+
A. sieberana var. sieberana nubica A. tortilis subsp. tortilis 0 A. seyal var. seyal x A. nilotica subsp. nilotica A. laeta o A. mellifera
+A.
A
P 0
Nitrogen (K)
0
_-
0 A. drepanolobium 0 A. seyal var. fistula + A. nilotica subsp. tomentosa A. polyacantha
m A. tortilis subsp. raddiana
-
1.5
A. sieberana var. vennoesenii
1
+
.
-
2
A A. sieberana var. villosa A. tortilis subsp. spimcarpa A.genardii A A. ehrenbergiana 0 A. nilotica subsp. astringens E1 A. senegal
Fig. 1. Relationship between specific optical rotation and nitrogen content of Acacia gums from Sudan.
-50
-40
-30
-20
-10
0
10
i 20
2
.-0 5
40
m 50
g!
0
-
70
80
90
100
a
: Karamallah, 1964. : Khogali, 1977.
0 P
Polysaccharide Characterisation
-
1
180
-
100
1
140
41
I
120
,.
I
100
80
60
40
I
Fig. 2 13CNMR spectra of (a) Acacia senegal and (b) Acacia seyal gums”
20
0
42
Gums and Srabilisers for the Food lndusrry 10
Table 2. Comparitive analytical data for Acacia senegal and Acacia seyal gums collected between 1960 and 1999 in Sudan.
I Arabinose (%)
Rhamnose (YO) Glucuronic acid (%)
24 - 29 12 - 14 16 - 17
I
3-4 11 -12
Another study of 800 authentic samples of gum from Acacia senegal var. senegal collected from thirty two different locations of the gum producing belt of the Sudan, showed that factors such as soil, rainfall, temperature, age of trees, site of exudation and picking sequence had no significant effect on the physico-chemical properties of the gum (Tables 3,4,5,6,7 and 8). Attempts have been made using statistical analysis to show that gums from different Acacia species are the same. When the objective is to distinguish between two species, use of principal components analysis combined with some cluster analysis is highly inappropriate and incomplete. Principal component analysis leads to inherent bias towards equality hypothesis, e.g. because of the linear nature of the principal components, but also because their construction is driven solely by the data. Principal components analysis is over strongly influenced by outlying observations, any non-linearities in the data, and by the way the data are scaled. It also tends to smooth away the key conclusions to be drawn from the data2'. How Safe is Your Gum Arabic
Fifty-two samples of authenticated and commercial Acacia senegal gum (Gum Arabic), from the seasons 1995/96, 1996/97 and 1977/78, were tested for the count of total bacteria, mould, yeasts and coliforms2'. The maximum microbial loads of these samples were about lo6 CFU/gm bacteria, and lo5 CFU/gm of moulds. The microbial loads of processed gum samples were much lower than the loads of raw gum samples and ranged between 4 0 to a maximum of 7.9 X l o 4 CFUIgm. Coliforms and yeasts were not detected in any of the samples tested (Table 9).
43
Polysaccharide Characterisation
Table 3. The effect of soil type on the moisture, ash, nitrogen mntent and specific optical rotation and pH of Acacia senegal var. senegal of Sudan. Parameter
Soil type
Moisture (%)
Mixed Clay Mixed Clay Mixed Clay Mixed Clay Mixed Clay
Ash (%) Nitrogen (%)
Sp. Rotation (degrees) PH
No. of samples
Mean
18 09 18 09 18 09 18 09 18 09
10.77' 10.76' 3.88' 3.05a 0.31' 0.30' -30.91' -31.20' 4.74' 4.52'
~
Table 4. The effect of rainfall on the moisture, ash and nitrogen content and specific rotation and pH of Acacia senegal var. senegal of Sudan.
p. Rotation (degrees)
800
20
Mean values marked with (a) are not significantly different from each other.
Table 5. The effect of season (temperature) on the moisture, ash and nitrogen content, and specific rotation and pH of Acacia -
Mean values marked with (a) are not significantly different from each other.
44
Gums and Stubilisers for the Food Industry I0
Table 6. The effect of age of the trees on the physico-chemical properties of gum from Acacia senegal var. senegal of Sudan. Ash
(Yo)
Nitrogen (%)
pH
Specific rotation
Equivalent weight
1
I
Uronic acid
1
Table 7. The effect of site of exudation (branch, stem) on the physico-chemical properties of gum from Acacia senegal var. senegal of Sudan.
Mean values marked with (a) are not significantly different from each other.
The dominant bacteria contaminating Gum Arabic samples studied were gram (+ve), rod shaped, spore-forming ones. Gram (+ve) non-spore forming rods and gram (+ve) cocci types of bacteria were also detected, but in insignificant amounts. An experiment carried out to simulate the effect of sunlight and UV light on the microbial load of samples resulted in a very clear decrease in the bacteria and mould counts (Table 10). Although the microbial counts are well within the acceptable limits; efforts have been made to develop a' simple technique to reduce such counts. The proposed method of application of UV radiation leaves with the possibility of alterations in the carbohydrate composition of the gum. The possibility of changes in some of the physical characteristics (gummosis) due to elimination of some of the natural micro flora, cannot be ignored.
Polysaccharide Characterisation
45
Table 8. The effect of picking sequence on the physicochemical properties of gum from Acacia senegal var. senegal of Sudan.
Bacteria count (CFUIgm)
Mould count (CFUIgm)
Raw gum 3 X 105
Raw gum
I Processed gum I N.D.
1 . 6104 ~
1 Processed gum 1 N.D.
Table 10. Effect of sunlight* on microbial loads of raw and processed gum from Acacia senegal var. senegal from Sudan.
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
46
Data clearly indicate that processing reduces microbial counts. It appears to be a result of the reduction of the moisture content in the gum. Thus, reducing the moisture content of the natural gum can be readily used as a tenable method of reducing the microbial counts. Gums from Acacia seyal var. seyal; Acacia seyal var. fistula, and Acacia polyacantha were tested for their pathological properties”. Diets of rats were substituted with these gums at various levels for twelve weeks. Preliminary data indicated atrophy of the villi and mucosal glands of the intestine. It was also found that some of the rats, fed on diet containing 50% gum from Acacia seyal var. seyal, showed focal lymphocytic infiltration in the hepatic cells and slight fatty changes. Another post-mortem observation was that the caeci were distended with gases. Rats fed with diets containing various levels of gum from Acacia senegal var. senegal indicated no pathological effects, thus confirming the clinical safety of such gum from Acacia senegal. This study confirms earlier findingsz3. A studyz4of raw gums from different Acacia species of Sudan for their taxonomic classification showed that these Acacia species could be divided into two main groups. Out of the thirteen gums tested, all but one fell into one group. The species falling in the large group showed presence of tannins in their gums. The tannin content ranged between 0.03 to 1.63%. The only gum that did not show presence of tannin was the gum from Acacia senegal var. senegal, thus distinguishing itself distinctly and distantly from other Acacia gums (Table 11). This finding is of significant importance when considering gums as food additives. It is established that tannins are anti-nutritional. Bleaching can remove the colour and off-flavour of gum from Acacia seyal. It can thus become very easy for some to pass off bleached gum from Acacia seyal as gum from Acacia senegal. The property of specific optical rotation can be used here very effectively to identify the gum. The base test, i.e. the addition of NaOH to a 20% solution of the gum can reveal if the gum is from Acacia senegal or from other Acacia species. Bleaching leads to the problem of residues of the bleaching agent staying behind in the bleached gum. Such residues of bleaching agents are harmful.
Gum Arabic
- The Future
The Sudan has been and is still the single largest producer of Gum Arabic (gum from Acacia senegal, var. senegal). The country supplies about 75% of the world needs of Gum Arabic. The other significant suppliers of Gum Arabic are Nigeria Senegal and Mauritania, each with around 5% share of the total production. The other producers, albeit small are Ethiopia, Chad, Mali and Niger. It is of prime significance to note that all of these countries fall within the agro-climatically suitable, traditional and well defined “gum producing belt” of Africa. However, this traditional gum belt has been subjected to devastating droughts, thus affecting Gum Arabic p r o d ~ ~ t i Fig. on~ ~~~ 3. ~ This has finally resulted in high
Polysaccharide Characterisation
41
Acacia species Tannin content A. senegal var. senegal 0.00 A. seyalvar. seyal 0.11 A. seyalvar. fistula 0.09 A. laeta 0.13 A. nilotica subsp. nilotica 0.05 A. nilotica subsp. tomentosa 0.14 A. drepanolobium 0.03 A. gerrardi 0.16 A. polyacantha 0.16 A. tortillis subsp. raddiana ~ _ ._.. -1.63A. mellifera 0.10 A. echrenbergiana 0.17 A. seiberana var. seiberana 0.08 ~
~
~
~
~~~
(YO)
~~
I
--
Production (000 Tons)
-Exports(000
Tons)
Fig. 3 Production and exports of Gum Arabic (Acacia senegal var. senegal) from Sudan (Source: Gum Arabic Company Ltd., Khartoum, Sudan 1998; National Forest Corporation, Khartoum, Sudan 1998)
prices of Gum Arabic. For example, in 1972, raw Gum Arabic was sold at USD 797 per '000 Kg (CIF). While in 1975, it fetched a price of USD 1,625 per '000 Kg (FOB Port Sudan) - an increase of 110% on FOB basis. The years 1973-1974 were years of severe drought in the Sahel region of Africa. Only 12,000 to 15,000 tons of Gum Arabic was produced in the drought years. Consumption of Gum Arabic until then was estimated at about 70,000 tons per annum. This kind of fluctuation in supply and prices forced the end users to come up with alternatives of Gum Arabic. Many large users re-formulated their products and replaced old machinery used for handling Gum Arabic by modern machinery to enable modified starches to be used in their production process.
48
Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry I0
The production of Gum Arabic picked up again in 1976/77 and such high production continued till 1982. lnspite of the higher production, sales of Gum Arabic never exceeded 40,000 tons per annum during this period. This trend can be attributed to the fact that the Sudan failed to reduce the high prices quickly enough, as a result, sales of modified starch continued to increase. The Sahel region was again subjected to severe droughts in 1983-84. Production was severely affected, and export of Gum Arabic from the Sudan in 1985 amounted to only 12,600 tons, at an average price of USD 1,600 per ton (FOB, Port Sudan). Again due to droughts in 1993-94, prices of Gum Arabic increased. In 1995, the average price was estimated at USD 4,200 per ton (FOB, Port Sudan) - an increase of 163% over 1985 prices. During these periods of limited availability, many more users modified their machinery to handle modified starches. In May 1996, the Sudan reduced the price of Gum Arabic to USD 2,200 per ton. But this had no positive effect on the sales of Gum Arabic from Sudan. Exports of Gum Arabic from the Sudan averaged around 10,000 tons per annum. At the same time, it is interesting to note that in 1997, USA, UK, Germany, France, Italy and some other Western European countries together imported about 23,000 tons of Gum Arabic from different sources including the Sudan. Official figures of the Sudan show that only about 11,000 tons of Gum Arabic was exported in 1997, while the total production in Sudan was estimated to be around 35,000 tons in 1997. This is a clear indication that a large quantity of Gum Arabic is smuggled out of the Sudan and reaches the destination countries, primarily through its neighbors. It has already been indicated that Sudan alone produces more than 70% of the world Gum Arabic. This trend is also an indication that modified starches cannot replace Gum Arabic in certain products, due to the superior intrinsic qualities of Gum Arabic. It cannot be claimed that even a near perfect substitute has been found for Gum Arabic - such are the properties and qualities of Gum Arabic. During the early 199Os, some foreign investors realized the potential of Gum Arabic, and decided to put up commercial plantations. As is known, till date, most of the Gum Arabic comes from trees growing naturally, as there were no commercial plantations. The author today is representing a foreign investment company in the Sudan whose main agricultural interest is in Gum Arabic. The company has taken large concessions (0.25 million acres) in the traditional Gum Arabic growing areas (Kordufan and Damazine) of Sudan, Till date, about 47,000 acres have been planted to pure stands of Acacia senegal, var. senegal (Gum Arabic). The company plans to plant 150,000 acres of Gum Arabic by the year 2003. The commercial production is expected from the year 2000. The company is also in the process of setting up Gum Arabic plantations in other African countries, but which fall within the "gum producing belt" of Africa, thus diversifying the production base.
Polysaccharide Characterisation
49
There are a few more investors involved in setting up pure stands of Gum Arabic in the Sudan, as well as in other African countries. It is estimated that the total production of Gum Arabic would be more than 175,000 tons starting from year 2010, due to these commercial plantations. This figure far exceeds the total world consumption of 70,000 tons/annum of the 1960s and 1970s. Production of Gum Arabic from Gandil plantations alone is expected to be around 35,000 tons per annum. Different laboratories from around the world have tested gum from Gandil Gum Arabic plantations, and the analysis results conform to the quality specifications set by CODEX. As Gandil gum is seasonly tested for identity and purity, figures 4a, 4b and 4c show identical C13NMR spectra of gum collected from lst, 2"d and 3'd picking respectively. After spending a fair amount of time on experiments, Gandil Company has developed a technique of direct seeding, thus avoiding nurseries, transplanting etc. This has resulted in huge cost savings. About 81% of the costs of setting up a plantation have been reduced using this technique. To ensure increased survival and better vigour for the plants, deep ploughing and water harvesting techniques were employed, to make maximum use of the rainfall. As a result of water harvesting, 96% survival was obtained in the field, compared to 79% survival where seeds were used under normal conditions. The general health of the plants was better and growth (length of stem and branches) was nearly 2.9 times that of trees of the same age but growing under normal conditions. In addition, weeding is also carried out on time regularly, thereby avoiding any competition for the Gum Arabic trees. It can thus be expected that yields from individual trees would also be high compared to trees in the wild. The overall result would be low cost of production of Gum Arabic. The detailed engineering for a Gum Arabic processing plant (cleaning, kibbling, spray drying) is near completion. This processing plant is expected to go on stream from 2001. While a European team is involved in designing the plant, machinery are expected to be sourced from the US and Europe, and some from Japan. It is worth mentioning here that till 1998, the Gum Arabic Company of Sudan was the only unit allowed to export Gum Arabic from the Sudan. However, since early 1999, the Government of Sudan has practically liberalized the Gum Arabic trade.
To sum up, facing problems of irregular supply of and unstable can be avoided by the large scale production of Gum Arabic in association with different companies like Gandil etc. Thus sufficient and cost effective supplies of pure and good quality Gum Arabic will be assured from Sudan.
Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
50
(4
.I.
I.
.
11.
..
mk*r*;m .h
-oh
Y
A
Fig. 4 13C NMR spectra of Gum Arabic (Acacia senegal) from Gandil Plantation, season 1999: (a) 1st picking; (b) 2nd picking; (c) 3rd picking
Polysaccharide Characterisation
51
REFERENCES 1.
Anderson, D.M.W., Dea, I.C.M., Karamalla, K.A. and Smith, J.F. (1968). Carbohydr. ReS. 6, 97-103.
2.
Anderson, D.M.W., Bridegman, M.M.E., Farquhar, J.G.K. and McNab, C.G.A., (1983). The International Tree Crom 2,245-254.
3.
Anderson, D.M.W. (1986). Food Additives and Contaminants 3,225.
4.
Anderson, D.M.W., Brown Douglas, D.M., Morrison, N.A. and Weiping, W. (1990). Food Additives and Contaminants. 7,303-321.
5.
Lamport, D.T.A., Qui, Wand Fong, C. (1991). Plant physiol. 96,845-855.
6.
Osman, N.E., Williams, P.A., Menzies, A.R. and Phillips, G.O. (1993). J.Agric. Food Chem. 41,71-77.
7.
Osman, M.E., Menzies, A.R., Martin, B.A., Williams, P.A., Phillips, G.O. and Baldwin, T.C. (1995). Phytochemistry, 38,409.
8.
Karamalla, K.A., Siddiq, N.E., and Osman, M.E. (1 998). Food Hvdrocolloids 12,373- 378.
9.
Anderson, D.M.W., Millar, J.R.A. and Weiping, W. (1 991). Biochemistry Systamatic and Ecology 19,447-452.
10.
Jurasek, P., Kosik, M. and Phillips, G.O. (1993a). Food Hydrocolloids 7, 7385.
11.
Jurasek, P., Kosik, M. and Phillips, G.O. (1993b). Food Hvdrocolloids 7, 255280.
12.
Ishaaq, K.E.A. (1 977). M.Sc. Thesis, University ofKhartoum.
13.
Anderson, D.M.W. and Herbich. (1 963). J. Chem. Soc. (1963) 1, 1-6.
14.
Anderson, D.M.W. and Karamalla (1966 b). J.Chem. Soc. (C), 8, 762.
15.
The Gum Arabic Company Ltd. (1994).
16.
Hassan, E.A. (1 994). Unpublished results.
17.
Menzies, A.R., Osman, M.E., Malik A.A. and Baldwin T.C. Food Additives and Contaminants (1996). 13,991-999.
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
52
18.
Astaud, J. (1 982). Analust, 10, 124.
19.
Karamalla (1 999). Unpublished results.
20.
Leonard, T. (1 999). Personel Communication.
21.
Osman, I.M. (1 998). M.Sc. Thesis, University of Khartoum.
22.
Wahbi 1.S. ( 1 998). M.Sc. Thesis, University of Khartoum.
23.
Anderson, D.M.W. (1986). Food Additives and Contaminants 3,225-230.
24.
Zahir, A.S. (1 998). M.Sc. Thesis, University ofKhartoum.
25.
Forest National Corporation (1 998). Khartoum, Sudan.
26.
The Gum Arabic Co. Ltd, (1998). Khartoum, Sudan.
IDENTIFICATION OF GUM ARABIC USING PAGE AND IEF
S. Motlagh', P. Ravines', Q. Ma2 and F. Jaksch3 'Bahh'i World Centre, PO Box 155, Haifa, 31001 Israel 2Archidex,431 Amapola Ave., Torrance, CA 90501 USA 'Phenomenex, 2320 W. 205" St., Torrance, CA 90501 USA
1 INTRODUCTION
The Joint Expert Committee for Food Additives of the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) of the United Nations' defines gum arabic as the gum exudate from Acacia senegal (L. Willdenow) or closely related Acacia species (family Leguminosae). Around 1 100 species of Acacia have been identified2. A. senegal has four varieties3:senegal, Kerensis SchweinJ rostata Brenan, and leiorhachis Brenan. Gum arabic is found in sub-Saharan Africa. The Kordofan province of Sudan is the largest producer and has the best quality gum arabic. Gum oozes from stems and branches of the tree when it is subjected to heat, drought, insect attack or wounding as a viscous sticky liquid that dries to form hard glassy nodules that are collected and sorted by color and size. Gum arabic has been used for thousands of years. In ancient Egypt it was used in the embalming of mummies and in preparing colors for painting4. Today it is used in the food industry for emulsification, texture control, stabilization and flavor or color encapsulation. It is also used in the textile, printing and pharmaceutical industries. Because of its extensive use in food products, and in order to eliminate adulteration of gum arabic by gums which do not fall under the FA0 definition, the authentication of gum arabic is of great interest to the food industry. Historically gum arabic has been used as a binder and medium for colorants and inks. It is still the medium of choice in watercolors and water-soluble carbon-based black inks. It's chemical nature and long tern stability are of interest because libraries, archives and museums contain large collections of old gum in documents, manuscripts and works of art on paper, such as watercolors, in various degrees of preservation. As in the food industry, the characterizationof gum arabic is of interest to the museum and library community in charge of preserving valuable artistic and historic collections of books and works of art. Gum arabic is a mixture of complex carbohydrates. Gum arabic interacts with Yariv reagent5and is therefore classified as an arabinogalactan-protein complex (AGP). The gum has a highly variable composition6and nodules collected from the same tree often have different chemical signatures. Gel filtration chromatographyhas been the most commonly used technique for the separation of the components of the whole gum and has shown' the molecular weights of the complex carbohydrate molecules to be between 1 . 5 ~ 1 and 0 ~ 4x106. Hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC), which has also often been used to fractionate gum
Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
54
arabic, has demonstrated*that the protein content of the various complex carbohydrate molecules composing the whole gum is between 0.7% and 36.8%. Weak anion exchange chromatography using a DEAE-cellulose stationary phase has also been tested'. Several groups have used electrophoresis with varying degrees of success. In a communication, Lewis and Smith" reported a 10 hour-long electrophoretic separation of gum arabic obtained from A. Senegal using glass-fiber paper in conjunction with a 2 M NaOH buffer; however, no mention was made of the possibility of hydrolysis of the gum by the base. Pechanek, et al." encountered problems with the polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) separation of gum arabic. Instead, they used cellulose acetate membranes with a boric acid buffer and obtained one band. Most recently, Osman, et al." performed a SDS-PAGE separation of three HIC fractions of A. Senegal gum and obtained protein bands with molecular masses in the 30 000 to 200 000 range. We have improved the resolution of the SDS-PAGE separation of gum arabic so as to allow it to be used for the authentication and identification of the gum. We have also performed an isoelectric focusing (IEF) separation of gum arabic for the same purpose. 2 EXPERIMENTAL All instrumentation was obtained from Bio-Rad. All reagents were electrophoresis grade and were purchased from Bio-Rad except where otherwise noted. Staining was done using the Bio-Rad silver stain kit. Sarah Taylor of the National Resources Institute, University of Greenwich, UK, provided gum from A . Jischeri (Tanzania), A. nilotica (Zimbabwe) and A. senegal (Uganda). Tessa Nolan-Neylan provided gum from A. senegal (Kenya). C. Nicholson of A.F. Suter & Co., London, provided Sudanese commercial grade gum arabic. The spraydried gum arabic labeled Fluka was purchased from Sigma.
2.1 Polyacrylamide Gel Electrophoresis 2. I . 1 Native PAGE. Buffer composition: 25 mM Tris, 192 mM glycine. Samp!e buffer composition: 62.5 mM Tris-HC1 (ICN), 40 % glycerol (BDH), 0.01 % bromophenol blue. Potential: 200 V (constant). 2.1.2 SDS-PAGE. Buffer composition: 25 mM Tris, 192 mM glycine, 0.1 % SDS. Sample buffer composition: 62.5 mM Tris-HC1,2 % SDS, 25 % glycerol, 0.01 % bromophenol blue, 4% 2-mercaptoethanol, heat for 4 min at 95 O C . Standards: Bio-Rad low and high range silver stain SDS-PAGE standard. Potential: 200 V (constant). 2.2 Isoelectric Focusing 2.2.I Native IEF. Bio-Rad IEF cathode, anode and sample buffers. Standard: BioRad IEF standard. Potential: 1 h at 100 V, 1 h at 250 V, 30 min at 500 V. 2.2.2 Denaturing IEF. Bio-Rad IEF cathode and anode buffers. Sample buffer composition: 4 M urea, 0.012 YOpH 3.5-10 ampholyte solution, 1 % Triton X-100 (Sigma), 0.5 YO2-mercaptoethanol, 0.02 YObromophenol blue. Standard: Bio-Rad 2-D SDS-PAGE standard. Potential: 30 min at 150 V, 2.5 h at 200 V.
Polysaccharide Characrerisarion
55
3 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 3.1 Polyacrylamide Gel Electrophoresis
We were unable to separate gum arabic using native conditions. Separationsof the gum were performed under denaturing conditions (SDS-PAGE) using uniform and gradient gels ranging in concentration from 5% to 20%. The best separations were obtained using uniform 15% gels. In an effort to obtain more information about the sub-unit structure of the proteinaceous part of the molecules by identifying any inter-chain disulfide linkages, parallel samples of gum arabic with and without 2-mercaptoethanolwere run. There were a few minor differences between the two sets of results, indicating the presence of a small number of disulfide linkages. Figure 1 shows a typical SDS-PAGE separation of samples of gum arabic using a 15% Tris-glycine gel. Table 1 displays the molecular weights of the bands. Note that all molecular weights were obtained from Ferguson plots of protein standards. The numbers obtained would be accurate only for protein bands. We suspect the presence of both proteins and glycoproteins. Glycoprotein bands would have to be standardized against glycoprotein standards, since highly glycosylated glycoprotein molecules would have different shapes from protein molecules.
2 2
Figure 1 Separation of several Acacia gums using SDS-PAGE
Protein molecules form narrow bands while glycoprotein and carbohydrate populations form broad bands. The following conclusions can be drawn from Figure 1 : The commercial grade Sudanese gum arabic and the spray-dried powder produced by Fluka
56
Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
share bands at 21 kd and 28 kd. This indicates that the spray-dried gum may have been prepared from Sudanese raw gum. In contrast to the Sudanese gum arabic, both gum samples obtained from A. senegal have very few bands. This may indicate that the latter two samples were obtained from a different variety of A. senegal than the Sudanese gum. Table 1 Molecular weights (in kilodaltons, using protein standards) of Acacia gum fractions obtained by SDS-PAGE using 15% gel concentration
In order to determine if any glycoprotein bands were migrating abnormally and to confirm the homogeneity of the bands obtained on the 15% gel, the above separation was repeated using a 12% gel concentration. The results were essentially similar to those obtained using the 15% gel concentration. This implies that, unlike other glycoproteins that have been separated using PAGEI3, the bands obtained from gum arabic migrate normally. Also, unlike results obtained by other groups,14no significant advantage was seen in the use of gradient gels. A substantial fraction of gum is seen to remain in the stacking gel, this is especially significant in the case of the spray-dried gum and the Sudanese gum. This indicates that both of these samples have higher molecular weight fractions whose molecular weights are not measured. When lower density gels are used, these fractions enter the gel as very diffuse bands that are difficult to quantitate. This technique separates both protein and glycoproteins well. Based on our limited number of samples, it appears that the separations are species specific, i.e. the gums can be identified by their protein and glycoprotein bands. If this were the case, then this technique would be a simple one to use for the identification and authentication of Acacia gums. A comparison between our results and those obtained by Osman, et a1.I2shows that our range of molecular weights of the compounds that are mobile under electrophoretic conditions (i.e. proteins and glycoproteins) are comparable to their range.
3.2 Isoelectric Focusing A gel with a pH gradient of 3-10 was used to perform an IEF separation of three samples of gum arabic (Figure 2). The A. senegal (Uganda) gum sample was separated into three narrow bands at pH 4.4,4.7 and 4.8. The Sudanese and spray-dried samples have poorly focused bands at around pH 7. The Sudanese sample has bands at around pH 3.5 and 4, while the spray-dried sample has a band at around pH 4. Note that the A. senegal sample exhibits one band under SDS-PAGE conditions. Under IEF conditions, however, this sample separates into three bands. This implies that the single SDS-PAGE band has, as shown by IEF, three components of similar molecular weight but differing
PolysaccharideCharacterisation
isoelectric points. 2D SDS-PAGE would confirm this. This also demonstrates the complimentary nature of these two electrophoretic techniques. Preliminary results of denatured IEF experiments are similar to those obtained by native IEF.
Figure 2 Separation of three samples of gum arabic using IEF 4 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
S Motlagh and P Ravines would like to express our gratitude to the following for their support and encouragement: The Universal House of Justice, governing body of the B M i world community; Farshad Mahjoor, president of Phenomenex; Faizy Ahmed, chief of Research and Development, and his staff at Phenomenex; Arie Admon, Biochemistry Department, Technion - Israel Institute of Technology; and our families. References 1. 2. 3. 4.
5. 6.
JEFCA-FAO/WHO, ‘Food Nutrition Paper No. 52, Addendum 3’, FAO, Rome, 1995, p. 83. D.M.W. Anderson and N.A. Momson, Food Hydrocolloids, 1989,3,57. J.J.W. Coppen, ‘Gums, Resins and Latex of Plant Origin’, FAO, Rome, 1995. Herodotus, ‘The History of Herodotus’, Encyclopedia Britannica Inc, Chicago, 1990, pp. 65-66. Y. Akiyama, S.Eda and K. Kato, Agric. Biol. Chem., 1984,48,235. A.M. Islam, G.O. Phillips, A. Sljivo, M.J. Snowden and P.A. Williams, Food Hydrocolloids, 1997,11,493.
58
7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13.
14.
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
O.H.M. Idris, P.A. Williams and G.O. Phillips, Food Hydrocolloids, 1998,12,379. A.K. Ray, P.B. Bird, G.A. Iacobucci and B.C. Clark Jr., Food Hydrocolloids, 1995, 9, 123. M.E. Osman, A.R. Menzies, B.A. Martin, P.A. Williams, G.O. Phillips and T.C. Baldwin, Phytochemistry, 1995,38,409. B.A. Lewis and F. Smith, J Am. Chem. SOC.,1957,79,3929. U. Pechanek, G. Blaicher, W. Pfannhauser and H. Woidich, J Assoc. 08 Anal. Chem., 1982,65,745. M.E. Osman, A.R. Menzies, P.A. Williams, G.O. Phillips and T.C. Baldwin, Carbohydr.Res., 1993,246,303. Q. Shi and G. Jackowski, in ‘Gel Electro horesis of Proteins’, ed. B.D.Hames, Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK, 3r redn., 1998, p. 32. A.T. Andrews, ‘Electrophoresis:Theory, Techniques, and Biochemical and Clinical Applications’, Clarendon Press, Oxford, UK, 2”dedn., 1986, p. 133.
RELEVANT STRUCTURAL FEATURES OF TEE GUM FROM Entemlobium cyclocurpum
G. Le6n de Pinto, M. Martinez, 0. Beltrsln, C. Clamens, F. Rinc6n and L. Sanabria. Centro de Investigaciones en Quimica de 10s Productos Naturales, Facultad de Humanidades y Educaci6n. Universidad del Zulia. Maracaibo. Venezuela. E-Mail:
[email protected].
1 INTRODUCTION
Entemlobium cyclocurprun, a large tree found in the hottest area of Venezuela,' exudes gum easily, three days after the incision is made at trunk level. The average yield is very high (36 g/specimen/week).2The solubility of this gum is not as high as that from Acacia senegul but it has been observed that this parameter increases when the gum is collected
as soon as is exuded.2Analytical data of gum exudates from five Venezuelan specimens of E. cyclociupum showed that the limiting viscosity number (100 mLg-') is comparable to that exhibited for some Combretaceae gums but higher than that reported for any Acuciu gum studied so far.'". The functionality of E. cyclocurpm gum as a stabilising agent for
emulsions in pharmaceutical preparations has been demonstrated'. A comparative study showed that an aqueous solution of this gum (0.75%) has the same rheological properties of that from ~ c u c i usenegd (20%)~' Chemical and I3C-NMR studies of E. qclocurprtm gum and its degradation products have been published.8 Some relevant structural features of the plysaccharide, isolated from this gum, have beem reexamined and are discussed in this work. 2 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The plysaccharide, isolated from Entetolobium qclocutpum, contains galactose, arabinose, glucuronic acid and its 4-0-methyl derivative, Table 1.
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
60
Table 1 Sugar composition of E. eyelocarpurn gum and its degradationproducts, Sugarsa (?A) Yield (?A)
Gal
Ara
Rha
UronicAcids
Original gum
60
49
20
10
21
Autohydrolysis polymer
80
53
19
7
21
Degraded gum A
31
67
6
27
Degraded gum B
1
100
Polysaccharide I
3
69
12
19
Polysaccharide 11
5
63
23
14
Polysacchande I11
8
100
Polymer
*Corrected for moisture.
Methylation analysis, Table 2, of the original polysaccharide shows the presence of terminal and 3-O-arabinofiuanoseresidues, terminal and 3-O-arabinopyranose, 3-0-, 6-0-, 4-0- and 3,6-di-O- substituted galactose, uronic acids and rhamnose as terminal residues. Partial hydrolysis of the polysaccharide led the isolation of the oligomer, Rgal 0.1 I(b), 0.66 (a), [ a ] ~ +94", : which was characterized by acid hydrolysis, methylation acid) analysis and 13C-NMRspectroscopy as 4-O-(4-O-methyl-a-D-glucopyranosyluroNc p-D-galactose. The separation and identification of neutral and acidic components, by column chromatography, confirmed that galactose, arabinose and rhamnose were present in the polysaccharide structure. The acidic components were characterized as 4-0-(4-0-methylacid)-Da-D-glucopyranosylunic acid)-D-galactose and 6-O-(~-D-glucopyranosyluronic galactose. Monitoring of the preparation of the autohydrolysis polymer and degraded gum A led to the removal of rhamnose and arabinose residues. The susceptibility of these
sugars to acid hydrolysis has been observed previou~ly.~*'~ Degraded gum B, obtained from periodate oxidation of degraded gum A, was a p-(1+3) galactan. The main structural features of this gum correspond to an arabinogalactan type 11." A series of three successive Smithdegradation products was prepared. The
polysaccharide I11 showed the same structure of degraded gum B. According to these results, the arabinose sidechains wereup to three units long, comparable to those
61
Polysaccharide Characterisation
Table 2 Methylation analysis of E. cyclocarpum gum Methyl ethers”
T (min)
Linkage
2,3,4-Me~Rha
0.46
L-Rhap-(l+
2,3,5-Me3-L-Ara
0.67
L-Araf-( 1-+
2,3,4-Me3-L-Ara
0.85
L-Amp-( 1+
2,5-Mez-L-Ara
1.26; (2.20)
+3) L-Amf-( 1+
2,4-Mez-L-Ara
(2.20); 2.37
+3) L-Arap-( 1-+
2,3,4,6-Me4-D-Gal
1.65
Galp-( 1-+
2,3,6-Me3-D-Gal
2.50; (3.60) (4.00)
d)-GaIp-(l+
2,4,6-Me3-D-Gal
(3.60) (4.00)
-+3)-Wp-( 1+
2,3,4-Me3-D-Gal
5.67; 6.00
4j)-Galp-(l-+
2,4-Me2-D-Gal
12.22; 13.80
+3,6)-Galp-( 1+
2,3,4-Me3-D-GlcAb
(2.20); 2.75
GlcA-( I+
qelative to methyl 2,3,4,fAetra-O-methyl-fLDglucopyranoside. bAsmethyl ester methyl glycoside.
observed for Acacia xanthophloea: Sw&?tenia mahagoni
l2
and Melicocca bijuga
lo
gums, but shorter than those reported for A. sawgal, where five degradations were
required to obtain the core of the structure.l3 Removal of uronic acid residues from the plysaccharides I and I1 was difficult, which may be related either to hydrogen linkages that involved these sugar residues, which work against periodate oxidation, andor some of them are internal residues. Signal assignments of I3C-NMR spectra was made on the basis of chemical ” ~ ”spectrum ~ of polysaccharide 11, Figure 1, shows the evidence and previous r e ~ u l t s . ~ The resonances due to a (1+3>p-galactan,
4-0-methyl-a-D-glucunic acid and 3-0-p-L
arabinopyanosyl residues, Tables 3-5. The peak at 79.0 ppm, assigned to 4-0-p-Dgalactose
residue^,'^ is according to methylation analysis and the characterization of the
acid)-D-galactose, which aldobiouronic acid 4-0-(4-0-methyl-a-D-glucopyranosyluroNc was isolated from the original gum. These results suggest that the 4-0-methyla-D-
glucuronic acid is present as internal residues in the structure of the gum polysaccharide.
62
Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
Gd
I' I, I
Figure 1 I3C-NMR spectrum ofpolysaccaride I1 There are also resonances of 6-0-linked galactose residues, Table 3, The signals attributed to C-1 (100.5 ppm) and to C-2 (66.50 ppm) of 3-0-P-L-arabinopyranose residues,I6are supported by methylation analysis, Table 2. Signals of a-L-arabinohranose residues were not observed in this spectrum, which suggest the removal of these residues in the preparation of polysaccharide II. The spectrum of plysaccharide I, shows, in addition to the resonances that appeared in the previous spectrum, Figure I , the unequivocal signals due to C-1 (109.2
ppm), C-2 (81.2 ppm), C-3 (76.5 ppm), C-4 (83.8 ppm) and C-5 (61.2 ppm) of a-Larabinofuranose also observed.
residue^.'.'^
The resonances due to p-D-glucuronic acid residues were
63
Polysaccharide Characterisation
Table 3 13C-NMR data" of PD-galactose residues in E. cVcrocarprtrn gum and its degradationproducts. T y p of Iinkage
PoIymer
C-1
C-2
C-3
C-4
C-5
C-6
71.4
81.9
69.1
74.9
60.8
71.0
81.0
69.5
75.2
61.2
103.80 71.9
81.4
68.9
74.2
61.1
+6)P-D-Galp-(l+b~c PolysaccharideI1 103.3 70.1
72.4
67.7
72.4
68.5
DegradedgumA 102.6 70.3
72.6
66.9
72.9
68.5
73.3
67.3
73.3
68.9
4)p-D-Galp(l+h*c Polysaccharide11 104.2 DegadedgumA Originalgum
Original gum
103.5
102.9
70.2
'Values relative to 1,4-dioxane as internal reference (6 66.7 ppm). bRef.[17]. The same signals were observed in the spectrum of polysaccharideI.
The spectrum of the original gum, more complex than the previous ones, contains the resonances due to 3-0-, 6-0- and 4-O-P-D-galactose, terminal and 3-0-a-LP-D-glucuronic acid residues and its arabinofuranose residues, 3-O-P-L-arabinopyranose, 4-0-methyl derivative, Tables 3-5.
Table 4 "C-NMR data" of uronic acid residues in E. cyclocatpum gum and its degradationproducts. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ~ ~ ~ ~
Type of Iinkage
Polymer
C-1
C-2 C-3 C-4 C-5
60.30
Degradedgum A 100.5 72.3 73.5 82.0 70.7
-
Originalgum
-
60.7
4-0-Me-a-D-Gl~A(l-+~"PolysaccharideI1 100.3 72.4
P-D-GlcA-( l-+b,c
-
C.'-6 I-0-Me
81.9 70.9
100.6 71.9 73.4 81.4 70.2
60.4
D e g r a d e d ~ A 104.0 75.8 76.5 73.5 77.1 175.4 5
-
Originalgum
-
104.6 75.5 76.1 73.3 76.1 175.1
'Values relative to 1.4dioxane as internal reference (6 66.7 ppm). k e f [14]. The Same signals wen observed in the spectrum of polysaccharideI.
64
Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
Table 5 '3c'-NMR dutu" of L-urubinose residues in E. cyclocatpum gum and its degrudution products.
c-I
('2
(13
c-4
+3) P-L-Arap(ljb3' Polysaccharide I1
100.5
66.5
74.6
-
Degradedgum A
101.4
66.9
73.6
65.6
61.8
Original gum
100.6
67.7
74.2
-
62.3
a-L-Araf( 1+b2c
Originalgum
109.2
81.4
76.1
84.1
61.1
-+3)a-L-Araf(ljb
Orignal gum
108.5
80.8
83.5
83.5
62.3
Type of Iinkuge
Polymer
c-5
"Valuesrelative to 1.4-dioxane as internal reference (6 66.7 ppm). k e f [8].The same signals were observed in the spectrum of polysaccharideI.
Degraded gum A, obtained by mild acid hydrolysis of the original gum, shows a spectrum, Figure 2A, that contains the same resonances described in the spectrum of the original gum, except those attributed to a-L-arabinokanose residues. Expansion of the anomeric region of that spectrum, Figure 2B, shows the presence of terminal reductor sugars (92.0 ppm),17 a-D-glucuronic acid (98.3 ppm),17 4-0-methyl-a-D-glucunic acid (100.5 ppm)," 3-0-P-L-arabinopyranosylresidues (101.4 ppm)? 3-0- and 6-0-galactose
residues (103.5, 102.6 ppm)8,17and 0-D-glucuronic acid residues (104.0 ppm).14 Dearabinosylation led to a better resolution of the signals due to 3-0-p-Larabinopyranosyl and uronic acid residues. The peak of high intensity at 79.0 ppm, described previously, is resolved in two peaks (79.0,78.2 ppm). Comparison of the spectral data of the original polysaccharide and its degradation products confirmed that the gum is an arabinogalactan Type 11." The backbone structure is a p( 1+3)-galactan with some 6-0-galactose residues. Side-chains are constituted by 30-L-arabinose (furanosyl and pyranosyl) residues, up to three units long. p-D-glucuronic is probably as terminal residues while its 4-0-methyl derivative may be as internal residues. The properties and the structural features of the studied gum indicate that it may be a new source of gum for industrial application.
Polysaccharide Characterisation
65 G-6!
I
morneric linkages
Ya (
'
180
I
'
I
160
'
140
I
'
120
I
'
I
100
'
80
'
60
PPm
Figure 2A 1*7C-NMR spectrum of degraded gum A
p-Ap-1'
a-U-1'
P-u-1'
PPm Figure 2B Expansion of the anomeric region of 13C-NMRspectrum of degraded gum A
66
Gums and Srabilisers for the Food lndusrry 10
3 EXPERIMENTAL 3.1 Origin and Purification of Gum Samples. Gum from E. qclocurpum (Jacq.) Griseb was collected by the authors in MarchApril, 1990, from a tree growing in Maracaibo, Venezuela, South America. Identification
of the voucher specimen was confirmed by Dr.George S. Bilntin, a botanical taxonomist of the Botanical Garden, Maracaibo. The dissolution of gum samples, collected two weeks
after the injury was made, was carried out in a day. The solution clear brown in colour,
was passed through muslin and Whatman No41 paper and dialysed against running H20 for two days. The gum was recovered by freeze-drying (29.4 g 56%). 3.2 General Methods. General standard methods of gum analysis were used. 9~'0 The solvent systems used in paper chromatographicwere as described previou~ly.~*'~ Gas chromatographic was carried out using flame detector ionization with NZflow rates of 40 mL.min" . The glass column (168 x 0.57 cm) used contained 10% (w/w) polyethylene glycol adipate on Chromosorb WHD at 190OC. Retention times are quoted relative to that of methyl-2,3,4,6-
tetra-0-methyl-P-D-glucopyranosidefor the methyl ethers. %NMR
data points were
accumulated overnight at 37°C with complete proton 4ecoupling. Spectra were calibrated by the addition of 1,4 dioxane to the samples. The polysaccharides (100-200 mg) were dissolved in 40 (1 mL). The procedures for partial and total hydrolyses, quantitative analysis of sugars, identification of aldobiouronic acids and methylations of the different oligosaccharides and polysaccharides are described previo~sly.~~'~ 3 3 Autohydrolysis Experiments.
A solution of purified sample (5%) was heated at 100" for 120 h; portions (10 mL) were withdrawn at various intervals, concentrated and analysed by PC. The polymer was isolated by freeze-drying. 3.4 Preparation and Examination of Degraded Gums A and B.
Unless otherwise stated the experimental procedures used for the preparation and examination of degraded gums A and B were the same as those described previously. 9~10
Polysaccharide Characterisation
67
Degraded gum A (2.4 g) was obtained from purified gum (8 g). Preliminary small-scale experiments showed that 96 h were required for the preparation of degraded gum B. 3.5 Smithdegradation Studies.
A series of three sequential Smithdegradations was performed with the pure gum
as starting material (23.3 g) to obtain polysaccharide I (714.7 mg). Polysaccharide I (2.77 g) gave polysaccharide I1 (142 mg) and the latter (660 mg) yielded polysaccharide 111 (50
mg). Experimental conditions for these degradations were in general, as reported. 9 ~ 1 0The preparation of each polysaccharide was repeated three times in order to check the yields and to have enough sample to complete the Smithdegradation process.
Acknowledgement The authors thank The University of Zulia, Consejo de Desarrollo Cientifico y Humanistic0 (C.O.N.D.E.S.),Maracaibo, Venezuela, for financial support.
Referenees 1. L.C. Guevara, Rev. de Fac. Agronom. UCV, 1974,7,109. 2. G. Lehn de Pinto, M. Martinez, C. Clamens and A. Vera, Rev. Fac. Agronom, La
Plata, 1996,101,51. 3. G. Le6n de Pinto and A. Ludovic de Coredor, Acta Cientijica Venezolana, 1986,37, 92. 4. D. M. W. Anderson and P.C. Bell, Carbohydr.Res., 1977,57,215.
5 . D.M.W. Anderson, M.M.E. Bridgeman and G. M n de Pinto, Phytochemistry, 1984, 23,575. 6. D.M.W. Anderson, J.G.K. Farquhar and M.C.L. Gill, Bot. J. Linn. Soc.,1980,80,79.
7 . G. A d a de Avila, D. Attias de Galindez and G. Le6n de Pinto, Acta Cient9ca
Venezolana 1994,45,71. 8. G. Le6n de Pinto, M. Martinez, A Ludovic de Corredor, C. Rivas and E. Ocando,
Phytochemistry, 1996,37,13 1 1. 9. G. M n de Pinto, C’arbofydr. Res., 1991,220,229. 10. G. Le6n de Pinto,
S. Alvarez, M. Martinez, A. Rojas and E. Leal, Carbohydr. Res.,
1993,239,257. 11. A. Clarke, R. L. Anderson and B.A. Stone, Phytochemistry, 1979,25,2807.
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry I0
68
12. G. Leon de Pinto, M. Martinez, N. Gonzhlez de Troconis, A.C. Rojas and E.Leal, An.
Quim., 1992,88,157. 13. A.C. Street and D.M.W. Anderson, Talanta, 1983,30,887. 14. G. Leon de Pinto, M. Martinez and C. Rivas, Curbohydr. Res.,1994,260, 17. 15. N.K. Kochetkov, Chem SOC.Rev., 1990,19,29. 16. H. Joao, G. E. Jackson, N. Ravenscroft and A. M. Stephen, Carbohydr. Res., 1988, 176,300. 17. G. Le6n de Pinto, M. Martinez, 0. Gutidrrez de Gotera, C. Rivas and E. Ocando, Ciencia, 1998,6, 191.
Preliminary Study of the Gelling Properties of Polysaccharide Isolated from the Fruit of CordiaAbyssinica
M. A. N. Benhura and C. Katayi - Chidewe Department of Biochemistry, University of Zimbabwe, P.O. Box MP 167, Mount Pleasant, Harare, Zimbabwe
Summary
Cordiu ubyssinicu is a small tree that grows in riverine bush in Southern Africa. The gum, extracted fiom the fiuit of C. ubyssinicu, by precipitation with ethanol from solutions that contained 0.25 M NaCl, gelled when suspended in water at concentrationshigher than 0.15%. Optimum gel formation occurred at neutral pH and 4 "C when solutions were left overnight. Addition of sucrose or monovalent ions at concentrations up to 10% and 50 mM respectively had no effect on gel formation. Addition of calcium ions or EDTA resulted in poorly formed gels. At concentrationsof calcium ions above 20 mM, no gels were formed. The firmness of the gels depended on whether the gum had been ground into a powder or not with unground material producing firmer gels. Upon heating plain gels or those prepared in the presence of sucrose, the gels melted into viscous masses. On cooling, the melted gels formed lumpy masses with proper gels not reforming. 1. Introduction For some time we have been interested in the polysaccharides that are isolated from a variety of local plants (1). Use of the polysaccharides would be a way of using the plants in a sustainable manner. Such an approach would contribute the use of plants as renewable resources and, it is hoped, would discourage the indiscriminate harvesting of trees for firewood and accompanying degradation of the environment. Cordiu ubyssinicu is a small tree that is found in riverine bush in parts of Southern Africa The fruit, a drupe about 10 mm in diameter, turns yellow and sweet on ripening. The pulp of the fiuit, which is edible but not widely consumed by humans is used by rural people as glue for p a p products and tums semi-liquid upon ripening of the fiuit. Preliminary analysis in our laboratory has shown that the components of the acidic fraction of the polysaccharide include galactose, glucose, arabinose, rhamnose and xylose or fucose. When suspended in water, the polysaccharide from Cordiu ubyssinicu forms viscous solutions and appears to have potential for use in thickening or gelling of aqueous solutions, controlling the flow properties of liquid foods and modifying the deformation qualities of semisolid foods. While working with preparationsof the polysaccharide from Cordiu ubyssinicu, it was sometimes observed that suspensionsof the material in water formed gels.
70
Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
Gels are continuous, rigid, two phase systems of assorted molecules, that resist flow under pressure and retain a f m distinct structural shape. The gel mass consists of a 3-dimensional network of small discrete particles. Gels are formed when segments of otherwise soluble polysaccharides are brought into association as a result of ionic
Figure 1 Maturefiwit of Cordia abyssinica
interactions, hydrogen bonding, hydrophobic interactions or Van der waals forces. The resulting three-dimensional network traps water molecules, which become more or less immobilised. In the formation of gels, polymer-polymer interactions that favour precipitation are balanced against polymer-solvent interactions that favour the formation of solutions. Enhanced interactions among polymer molecules results as the solubility of the polymer molecules decreases (2). The inter-chain associations may break and reform and are influenced by factors, such as electrolytes, that modify the aqueous environment. The cross linkages that occur in gels involve extensive segments from two or more polymer molecules usually in well defined junction zones (3). The formation of junction zones from the association of polymer segments is enhanced when the availability of water molecules for solvating the polysaccharides is restricted. Factors that reduce the availability of solvating water molecules, therefore, would be expected to enhance gel formation. Polysaccharide chains that contain uronic acid groups may be brought into association by divalent ions such as calcium ions. In this case, gelation is favoured by conditions that promote the charged form of the polyuronic polysaccharide. The strength of polysaccharide gels is influenced by substances that compete with water for binding loci, compete with the polysaccharide for water, alter the pH, interact chemically with the polysaccharide or alter the charge distribution on the polysaccharide. Gelling agents that are currently available for use in the food industry include starches, pectin, agar, alginates, carageenan and gellan gum (4). In addition, a number of thickeners can form gels when combined, as for example, when xanthan gum is mixed with locust bean gum. We decided to further investigate the conditions that are required for the formation of gel by the polysaccharides of C. abyssinica.
Polysaccharide Characterisation
71
2. Experimental 2.1 Extraction of the gum Mature but unripe Cordia abyssinica h i t was obtained h m South Eastern Zimbabwe between December and April. Harvested hit,with their calyces on, were stored at room temperature and processed within 72 hrs. The gum was extracted by squashing the h i t to release the stones, which were covered in pulp. The stones, in a strong plastic or stainless steel container, were agitated with a robust wooden rod during which process the pulp separated fiom the stones as a thick sticky mass. The stones were removed and water added to the sticky mass to make a workable mixture, which was centrifuged in a BHG Hermle ZK 401 centrifuge at 6000 rpm for 30 minutes to remove debris. To the supernatant, sodium chloride was added to make a 0.25 M solution and three volumes of ethanol added to precipitate the polysaccharide. The polysaccharide was dried in a preheated oven set at 100°C. The dry gum was broken up into small pieces, which were stored at room temperature until required.
2.2 Preparation of the gel The dry gum (1.5 g) was suspended in 80 ml of water and the mixture heated to dissolve the polysaccharide. The volume was made up to 100 ml and the solutions left overnight at 4 "C. Alternatively, flakes of dry gum were suspended in 100 ml of water and left overnight at 4 "C. The formation of gels and their quality was assessed by visual inspection. 2.3 Determination of the minimum concentration of polysaccharide required for gelation To determine the minimum concentration of polysaccharide that was required for gelation, up to 0.2 g of the polymer was mixed with 10 ml of water. The mixture was allowed to stand overnight at 4 "C before assessment of gel formation. 2.4 Effect of sucrose Solutions containing up to 10Y0w/v sucrose were prepared by dissolving the sugar in distilled water (1 0 ml). The gum (0.15 g) was suspended in the solutions of sucrose and the suspensions were allowed to stand overnight at 4 "C before assessment of gel foxmation. Alternatively sucrose (1 g) was mixed with up to 0.2 g of polysaccharide and the mixture was ground to a fine powder. The ground mixture was placed into vials and water (10 ml) was added. The mixtures were allowed to stand overnight at 4 "C before assessment of gel formation. 2.5 Effect of metal ions and EDTA The polymer (0.15 g) was suspended in solutions containing calcium, potassium and sodium chloride at concentrations up to 50 mM or 100 mM EDTA in 10 ml of distilled water. The suspensions were allowed to stand overnight at 4 "C before assessment of gel formation.
Gwns and Stabilisers for the Foodlndustry 10
12
2.6 Effect of pH The dry polysaccharide was suspended in 10 ml of buffer. The mixtures were allowed to stand overnight at 4 OC before assessment of gel formation. Citrate buffer was used between pH 3 and 6 and phosphate buffer was used at pH 7 and 8.
2.7 Effect of temperature The polymer (0.15%) was suspended in water (10 ml), in vials that were incubated at the temperatures ranging from 4 OC to 96 'C. The vials were allowed to stand overnight before assessment of gel formation. Gels in which the polysaccharide concentrations ranged from 0.75% to 2.00% w/v were prepared and heated in a boiling water bath until melted. The melted gels were allowed to stand at 4 OC overnight after which the formation of gels and their integrity was assessed. The procedure was repeated using the 1.5% gels containing up to 10% concentration of sucrose. 3. Results and discussion 3.1 Determination of the minimum concentration required for gelation As shown in table 1, the minimum concentration of Cordia abyssinica polysaccharide that was required to form a firm gel was 1.5%. The concentration of polymer at which gel formation occurred is similar to the concentrations of 0.5% to 2% at which several polysaccharides gel (2, 6). At low concentrations of polysaccharide, small gel particles were suspended in bulk liquid. As the concentration increased, the size of the gelled masses increased until, at about 0.5%, a continuous firm gelled mass was observed. Increasing the concentrationof polysaccharide resulted in increased f m e s s of the gels.
Table 1 Effect of concentration on the formation of gels by C. abyssinicapolysacchide Polysaccharide Concentration (??A)
Subjective rating of gelling
0.05
0.2
+ +
0.4
++
0.5
I-
1.o
t+H
1.5
*
2.0
I+f.H-H
Comments
Small gelled areas in bulk liquid Small gelled areas in bulk liquid Large gelled areas in a small amount of Loose gel extending throughout the container Loose gel extendingthroughout the container Firm gel extending throughout the container Firmer gel
Polysaccharidc Characterisation
73
3.2 Effect of addition of sucrose Addition of sucrose at concentrationsup to lo??had no observable effect on the formation of the gels. The observation that the addition of sugar was not required for the formation of a gel by the polysaccharide fiom C. abyssinica would be an advantage in the formulationof gelled low calorie products. 3.3 Effect of calcium, potassium, sodium and EDTA At concentratiops below 1 mM, calcium ions had no effect on the firmness of the gels formed but at higher concentrationsfirmness of the gels decreased as shown in table 2. At concentrationsof calcium ions above 20 mM, no gel was formed at all. Inclusion of the monovalent ions, sodium and potassium, at concentrations up to 20 mM had no effect on the formation of gel. At a concentrationof 50 mM, addition of both ions resulted in slightly less firm gels. With increasing concentrations of EDTA in the gel forming suspension, the firmness of the gels formed decreased as shown in table 3. EDTA was added to chelate the metal ions that were present. When EDTA was present at 50 mM or higher concentrations,no gel was formed at all with the material appearing as a hydrated mass. The monovalent ions, sodium and potassium, at concentrations up to 20 mM, had no effect on gel formation by C. abyssinica polysaccharide.
Table 2 Effect of calcium ions on the gelation of aqueous suspensions of C. abyssinica polysaccharide Concentration Subjective rating of calcium ions ( m w of gelation
Comments
Table 3 Effect of EDTA on the gelation of aqueous suspensions of C. abyssinica polysaccharide Concentration
Subjective rating of gelation
Comments
No pel
Hvdrated lumns with no pel
40 50 1nn
Gwns and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
74
3.4 Effect of pH In aqueous suspensions at low pH, a hard insoluble material remained in the suspending medium. Raising the pH resulted, first in the formation of a hydrated material that was not however, recognisable as a gel. At pH 6 and 7 a bonafide gel was formed as shown in table 4. Raising the pH above 7 resulted in small pieces of gel floating in a bulk of liquid. It is clear that control of pH is an important factor in the preparation of gels from C. abyssinica polysaccharide.
Table 4 Effect of pH on the gelation of aqueous suspensions of C. abyssinica polysaccharide
3.5 Effect of temperature The gels formed by the polysaccharide at room temperature were nearly as firm as those formed at 4 "C. At temperatures above 30 "C,the firmness of the gels formed decreased as shown in table 5. The observation that suspensions of the polysaccharide formed gels at room temperature would be an important factor when considering the formulation of food gels. On heating the gels at 100 OC for about 20 minutes, the gels broke up to form viscous masses. Upon cooling of the gels at 4 "C,individual lumps of gel formed but no continuous gel mass was formed. Similar results were obtained for gels that were prepared in the presence of sugar. It appears that gels formed by the polysaccharide from C. abyssinica do not reform easily after being destroyed by heat.
Temperature
eo 4
25
Subjective rating of gelation 1i-H-H
I+H-+
Comments
I Firm gel
I Gel less firmthan at 4OC
Polysaccharide Chamcteris&'on
15
3.6 Effect of physical state on gelation Optimum gel formation occurred when unground material was used and the mixture was not stirred. Grinding of the gum before suspension in water resulted in poorly formed gels. Altering particle size can influence the degree of dispersion because colloidal state depends primarily upon particle size (2). Grinding of the gum from Cordia abyssinica resulted in reduced particle size and increased dispersion of the gum in aqueous solution. The increased dispersion could result in reduced potential for interaction between the polymer chains and related reduced firmness of the gels formed. Acknowledgements
This study was generously supported by grants h m the Research Board of the University of Zimbabwe, the Swedish Agency for Research Corporation with Developing Countries (SAREC) and the International Foundation for Science (IFS). References Benhura, M. A. N. and Mavhudzi-Nyambayo, I. (1999). Depolymerisation of 1. mucilage isolated from ruredzo (Dicerocaryum zanguebarium) by ascorbic acid in the presence of catalysts, Carbohydrate polymers 38: 371-373. 2. Bowers, J. (1992). Water and food dispersions: In"Food theory and Applications", 2"dEd. Macrnillan Publishing Co. New York.pg 11-44. 3. Braek, G.S. Grasdalen, H.and Smidsrrad, 0. (1989). Inhomogenous polysaccharide ionic gels. Carbohydratepolymers 10 : 31-45. 4. Lipatov, Y.S. (1988). Gelation of solutions: Polymer gels, In "ColloidChemistry of Polymers" A.D.Jenkins, Ed., Elservier, New York. pgs 373-406. 5. Nussinovich, A. (1997). Hydrocolloid applications. Blackie Academic and Proffessional, London. 6. Oakenfull, D. (1987). Gelling agents. CRC Critical Rev.: Food Sci. and Nutri. 26(1): 1-25.
WHAT IS THE TRUE AMYLOSE CONTENT OF RICE STARCH ?
M.Ramesh, John R. Mitchell, Komelia Jumel and Stephen E. Harding Food Sciences Division, School of Biological Sciences, University of Nottingham, Sutton Bonington Campus, LE12 5RD, United Kingdom
Introduction
Starch, the major reserve polysaccharide, is of enormous nutritional importance as well as a raw material for various industries. It is used as a thickener, texturiser, stabiliser and fat-replacer in the food industry and in the manufacture of paints, adhesives, paper, textiles, pharmaceuticals and biodegradable plastics. The starch granule is composed of two glucose polymers: amylose, generally regarded as a linear chain of glucose units, and amylopectin, a highly branched and very large molecule. Among the different methods of isolation of amylose and amylopectin, gel permeation chromatography (GPC) has been extensively used to separate starch into a high molecular weight fraction, found to be branched and considered to be amylopectin and a low molecular weight fraction generally designated as amylose’“. The amylopectin was found to contribute to part of the iodine reaction with starch’ and amylose although largely linear has been shown to have some degree of branching ’-I5. Some workers have considered “branched amylose” as a third polysaccharide component’’ intermediate between amylose and amyl~pectin’~-’~. Amylose content of rice starch
GPC of rice starch on Sepharose 2BZ0and Sepharose CL-2BZ1was also reported to yield amylopectin (FrI) and amylose (FrII). Several workers showed that the long-B chains of the amylopectin molecules react with iodine to give a blue colour. Hence the am lose content, as estimated by iodine reaction, was considered to be an overestimate12.ly20.21 Subsequently, the amylose content, as estimated by the classical iodine reaction was designated as ‘apparent amylose’ and more appropriately as ’amylose-equivalent’ (AE)”. These developments lead to a general agreement that the true amylose content of rice starch may be lower than had been generally suggested. From the respective iodine affinities of whole starch, pure amylose and pure amylopectin, the true amylose content was calculated to be in the range of 15-19% for non-waxy rices”. The molecular size of enzymatically debranched starch was determined using SEC-MALLS and the high molecular weight material can be considered as the true “amylose” 22.
Polysaccharide Characterisation
I1
More recently Ramesh and his associatesn fractionated seven rice starches of graded amylose equivalent (AE) on Sepharose CL-2B column into a high molecular weight fraction (FRI) and a low-molecular weight fraction (FRII, M e r sub-divided into FR 11% IIb and IIc). They observed that the polysaccharide-iodine complex,,A of FRII was relatively lower (<630nm), except for the peak tubes (Fig.1). Which should not be the case if FRII were to be true amylose. Therefore, the FRI, IIa, IIb and IIc were debranched (using isoamylase) and fractionated on Biogel P-10. Surprisingly, all the four fractions in all the rice varieties gave a trimodal chain profile (Biogel frl, fk2 and fr3), demonstrating that the low molecular weight fraction (FRII) also contained some molecules which had a similar branching structure to amylopectin (Fig.2). When whole starch was debranched and fractionated on Sepharose CL-ZB, no material eluted at the void volume (FRI), confirming that FRI contained branched molecules alone. Assuming, the pattern of branching in the molecules of FRIIa, IIb and IIc similar to that of FRI, the following ratio (Long-B chains) / (Shorter chains) = (Biogel frl) / (Biogel fr2 + fr3) of FRI was applied to the branched molecules in FRIIa, IIb and IIc, from which the amount of long-B chains were calculated. By subtracting the long-B chain content from their total Biogel frl values the approximate amylose contents for non-waxy nces, in the range 7-1 1% (Table l), were obtained.
IS
2
--
10
::
5
0
0 LOO
'vo
800
1200
1600
LOO
800
1200
1600
2000
'v, Elution volume , ml
Figure 1. Elution profile of Type II(Co 32). IV(Basmati 370), VI(Sukanandi) & VI&T 65) rice starches on Sepharose C L - 2 bThe polysaccharide-iodine complex A- and division of diyerentfiactions are shown 23. (Reprinted with permission)
78
Gums and Srabilisers for the Food Indusrry 10
1
3 2 1
... I(
.
.._.
FRla.
..__
--.
1
-
.,_
:: I
20
I1
500 100
E C
I
I:
--
- 600
....
10
0
-
0
::
3c
2
0
,
”--.._,
FR Ilb
....
Y
- 600
-
1
-0 -400 E 4 -500
x
L
20
h 0 1
IC 0 FR UC
‘5
-. .._-....
- 600 - so0
10
- LOO
10 I I , I 0
Ir1
I
‘,
10
0
lotv
90 0
t
10
90
30
90
30
90
1LO
“I
Elulion volume. ml
Figure 2. Biogel P-10 chromatograms of the debranched Sepharose CL-2Bfi.actions FH, IIa, IIb and IIc of diflerent rice starches. ( 4 Carbohydrate; (---)AE; (...) ,I,-. The division of Biogel fi.1,fi.2 andfi.3 representing Long-B (Y amylose), intermediate-B and A and short-B chains respectively are shown 23 (Reprinted with permission).
We have recently confirmed the above by separating amylose from enzymatically debranched rice starches using SEC-MALLS-RI (Size exclusion chromatography coupled to multi angle laser light scattering and differential refra~tometer)~~, following the method of Ong and her associates22. Starch from four varieties of rice were debranched (using isoamylase) and fractionated on SEC-MALLS-RI. The following columns were used in series for fractionation : one guard column (Phenomenex; 6x40mm) followed by 5 fractionation columns (one TSK GEL G3000 PWXL; 7.8x300mm, two Asahipak GS320H; 7.8x250mm, one TSK (32500 PWXL; 7.8x300mm and one TSK G-oligo PWXL)22. In the chromatogram, the fraction I (FrI) was assumed to be true amylose (Fig.3). Similar
Polysaccharide Characterisation
79
Table 1. Approximate amount of long-B chains (LB) and amylose (Am) in rice 23 Sepharose Chains CL-2B in Fraction Biogel frl
FRI
LB
Approximate amount of LB & Am (% of total carbohydrate in rice)
I1
10.5
10.0
1.9 2.8 1.7 7.6 0.5 0.5 14.6 10.9
1.9 1.9 2.4 2.7 1.6 1.6 6.6 7.7 0.5 0.8 0.5 0.6 14.0 13.1 9.3 11.0
Am
FRIIa
LB Am
FRIIb
LB Am
FRIIc
LB Am
Total
LB Am
Rice quality type I11 IV VI VII VIII
I
8.6 6.7 6.6 5.8
-
-
1.5 1.3 3.6 1.8 1.0 0.8 5.7 4.6 0.4 0.4 0.3 0.3 9.6 9.1 9.6 6.7
2.4
1.3
0.3 2.3 1.0 0.1 4.2 0.2 0.3 0.1 0.7 0.5 8.4 3.3 7.2 0.7
0.30 0.25 0.20
Volume (mL) Figure 3. Representative elution profile of isoamylase debranched rice starch (Jhona20)fiactinated on SEC-MALLS-RI Vstem. (A) laser-light-scatteringprofie (B) Rlprojle. elution profiles has been reported for different starches, refemng the FrI as amylose and the subsequent fractions as the various chain populations of amylopectin22. It is possible that the amylose contained a mild degree of branching which was removed by the enzymatic treatment. The molecules must however, have mostly a long linear portion. In
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
80
the chromatogram a baseline was established and the area under the amylose fraction was calculated from the sum of the area of several Gaussian components fitted to the data using a multiple Gaussian fit (Microcal Origin 3.0, USA). Interestingly, the amylose content, ranged from 7-1 1%, agreed well with the calculated amylose contents23 (Table 2). The amylose values observed in the recent studies23J4are not only lower than obtained by the classical iodine assay applied to whole starch but also lower than the values reported from an iodine assay for chemically separated "amylose"'2. The molecular weight and polydispersity (Mw/Mn)values of the amyloses (Table 2) are in agreement with the values reported for purified rice starch amyloses 25.
Rice
Amylose
Conclusion The above recent reports have indicated that the rice starch contains branched molecules or amylopectin of varied sizes, from vehy big to very small, and the content of amylose is much less than generally stated in literature. A primary aim of future work should be to investigate the true amylose content of starches from other botanical origin by using these approaches to understand whether the low true amylose content is a feature of other starches or is unique of rice starch.
Acknowledgement The award of Nestle Nutrition Scholarship to M.Ramesh by Nestec Ltd., Switzerland, is gratefully acknowledged.
References [I] [2] [3] [4]
R.Ebermann, & R.Schwarz, Stuerke, 27 (1975) 361-363. T.Yamada, & M.Taki, Staerke, 28 (1976) 374-377. C.G.Biliaderis, D.R.Grant, & J.R.Vose, Cereal Chem., 56 (1979) 475-480. C.D.Boyer, P.A.Damewood, & G.L.Matters, Staerke, 32 (1980) 217-222.
Polysaccharide Characterisation
81
J.Y.Yeh, D.L.Garwood, & J.C.Shannon, Sfuerke,33 (1981) 222-230. S.A.S.Craig, & J.R.Stark, Stuerke 36 (1984) 127-131. O.Kjolberg, & D.J.Manners, Biochem. J., 86 (1963) 258-262. W.Banks, & C.T.Greenwood, Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 117 (1966) 674-675. D.J.Manners, & NKMatheson, Curbohydr. Res., 90 (1981) 99-1 10. J.A.Cura, P.E.Jansson, & C.R.Krisman, Sfuerke,47 (1995) 207-209. H.Falk, R.Micura, M.Stanek, & R.Wutka, Sfuerke,48 (1996) 344-346. Y.Takeda, S.Hizukuri, & B.O.Juliano, Curbohydr. Res., 168 (1987) 79-88. Y.Takeda, N.Maruta, S.Hizukuri, & B.O.Juliano, Curbohydr.Res., 187 (1989) 287294. Y.Takeda, T.Shitaozono, & S.Hizukuri, Curbohydr. Res., 199 (1990) 207-214. S.Hizukuri, Y.Takeda, N.Maruta, & B.O.Juliano, Curbohydr.Res., 189 (1989) 227235. Y.Sugimoto, K.Yamada, S.Sakamoto, & H.Fuwa, Sfuerke,33 (1981)112-116. M.Asaoka, K.Okuno, Y.Sugimoto, J.Kawakami & H.Fuwa, Sfuerke,36 (1984)189193. M.Asaoka, K.Okuno, Y.Sugimoto, M.Yano, T.Omura, &t H.Fuwa, Sfuerke, 38(1986) 114-117. N.Inouchi, D.V.Glover, & H.Fuwa, Sfuerke,39 (1987) 259-266. R.Chinnaswamy, & K.R.Bhattacharya, Sfuerke,38 (1986) 51-57. K.R.Reddy, S.Z.Ali, & K.R.Bhattacharya, Curbohydr. Polym., 22 (1993) 267-275. M.H.Ong, K. Jumel, P.F.Tokarczuk, J.M.V.Blanshard, & S.E.Harding, Curbohydr. Res.,260 (1994) 99-117. M.Ramesh, S.Z.AIi, & K.R.Bhattacharya, Curbohydr.Polym., 38 (1999) 337-347. M.Ramesh, J.R.Mitchel1, K.Jume1, & S.E.Harding, Staerke (1999) (in press). Y.Takeda, T.Shitaozono, & S.Hizukuri, Sfuerke,40( 1988) 5 1-54.
The dispersibility of polysaccharides in water and watercadoxen mixtures Wang, Q., 1 Wood, P.J., 'Chi,W. and 2Ross-Murphy, S.B. Southern Crop Protection and Food Research Center- Food Research Program, AAFC,Guelph, Ontario, Canada. 2Division of Life Sciences, King's College London, Franklin Wilkins Building, London SEl 8WA, UK.
ABSTRACT
The effect of added cadoxen on the dispersibility of aqueous solutions of polysaccharides was studied using viscosity measurements. Three neutral polysaccharides, oat p-glucan, detarium xyloglucan and dextran were included in this study. For all three samples, the Huggins constants were found to decrease rapidly when the volume fraction of cadoxen (vcad) increased from 0 to 0.4, then consistently decreased at a much lower rate. This indicates a transition from large aggregates to unimers (or small aggregates) at solvent composition of about O
-
INTRODUCTION
When preparing aqueous solutions of polysaccharides, heating is usually needed to assist the dissolution process. However, excessive heating may induce polymer chain degradation, which is normally undesirable. The molecular weight of polysaccharides can usually be monitored by the measurement of intrinsic viscosity. However, the use -of this method is complicated by the possible aggregation behavior of polysaccharides. Energy provided by heating can disrupt the molecular aggregates, as well as cleaving the polymer
Polysaccharide Characterisation
83
chains. If a reduction in intrinsic viscosity is observed after heating, it is difficult to tell if the change is due to the disruption of the aggregates or the degradation of polysaccharide molecules. There is thus a need to develop a stable and consistent method to distinguish polymer chain degradation from disruption of supramolecularaggregates. Cadoxen is commonly applied as a solvent for cellulose and cellulose derivatives. A recent study (Grimm, 1995), using static light scattering, showed that cadoxen is also a better solvent for barley p-glucan compared to water. The degree of aggregation of barley p-glucan was about 10 times higher in water than in cadoxen. Cadoxen has also been used as solvent for a p -(1+3)-glucan (Zhang, 1997), and aggregation was significantly reduced by the addition of cadoxen to water. In this paper, we compare the dispersibility of three neutral polysaccharides in water-cadoxen mixtures and in water. The objective was to use the difference in the dispersibility between polysaccharide in water and in water-cadoxen mixture as an indicator of polymer degradation or disruption of aggregates. The polysaccharides involved were oat p-glucan, detarium gum and dextran. Oat p-glucan is a linear polysaccharide composed of mainly (1-+3)-linked cellotriosyl and (1+3)-1inked cellotetraosyl units in a molar ratio of 1:(2.1-2.4) (Wood et al., 1991; Cui, et al., 1999). Detarium gum is a xyloglucan type of polysaccharide that is believed to have a low degree of, but long, branching structure (Wang, et al., 1997). The structure of dextran varies from slightly branched to highly branched, depending on the origin. It consists mainly a-D-(1~6)-glucopyranoseas main chain with branching points at C-3 and (2-4.
MATERIALS AND METHODS Materials The p-glucan was extracted and purified by the method described previously (Wood, 1991). The detarium gum was purified by the method of Wang et al. (1996). Another polysaccharide studied in this project was a commercial sample dextran T5OO (Pharmacia Fine Chemicals AB, Sweden). Preparation of sample solutions Polysaccharide solutions were prepared by first dissolving the accurately weighed sample at 80 OC for 1 hour and then leaving overnight at room temperature under constant stirring. The concentration was selected to ensure that the relative viscosity qr fell in the range of 1.2 < q, < 2.2. The solution prepared was filtered through a 0.45 pm syringe filter before any other treatments. The cadoxen solvent was prepared as follows. A 29% aqueous solution of ethylenediaminewas saturated with CdO in an ice-water bath under vigorous stirring and kept overnight. The solution was then filtered through a sand filter and refrigerated until use. The polysaccharide solutions in different volume fractions of cadoxen was made by mixing the filtered aqueous solution with the required volume of cadoxen and stirring for at least 1 hour before measurement was made.
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
84
Intrinsic viscosity measurement The intrinsic viscosity was determined by using a dilution capillary viscometer immersed in a water bath to maintain the temperature at 25 f 0.1"C. The measurement was done in a fume hood because cadoxen is a toxic solvent. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Intrinsic viscosity can be determined according to the Huggins equation (Tanford, 1961): qs&
= [q]
+ k[q]*c + ....
using a capillary viscometer, the reduced viscosity q n d (= q&) is measured at various concentrations (c) in dilute solution and extrapolated to zero concentration to give the value of intrinsic viscosity. k is known as the Huggins constant, and is an indication of the solvent quality for a given polymer. It has been estimated to be 0.5 < k < 0.7 in 0media and to decrease with increasing polymer solvation, to a limiting value of 0.3 in good solvents (Sakai, 1968). The Huggins constant is very sensitive to the formation of molecular aggregates. If cadoxen increased polysaccharide solvation over that of pure water by reducing polymer-polymer interactions (aggregations), then intrinsic viscosity would be less. Opposing this, greater polymer expansion in a good solvent compared to a poor solvent will lead to an increase in intrinsic viscosity. Depending on the relative magnitude of these two effects, three possible results may be produced. When the first factor is predominant, the intrinsic viscosity would fall; if the second factor were predominant, it would increase. The intrinsic viscosity would remain largely unchanged if both factors were in balance.
-
Figure 1 displays the Huggins plots of detarium gum in water and water-cadoxen mixtures. The slopes of the plots were reduced consistently when the volume fraction of cadoxen (Vcd) increased. From the slopes of these plots, the Huggins constants were calculated and plotted against the volume fraction of cadoxen, as shown in Figure 2. The Huggins constants decreased from 0.61 in water to 0.40 in 0.70 (Vcd) water-cadoxen mixture. This indicates that the quality of the solvent was improved by the addition of cadoxen, i.e. the association between polysaccharide molecules was reduced. The intrinsic viscosity of detarium gum also decreased significantly in water-cadoxen mixtures. Figure 3 demonstrates that the intrinsic viscosity of detarium xyloglucan also changes with the volume fraction of cadoxen in water-cadoxen mixtures. As the volume fraction of cadoxen increased, the intrinsic viscosity decreased rapidly at the beginning from 9.3 in water to 5.5 in 0.3 (Vcad) cadoxen, then it continuously decreased slowly when v c a d > 0.3. This suggests that most of the aggregates in detarium aqueous solution break up to form unimers (or small aggregates) in a narrow range of solvent composition (o
-
-
Polysaccharide Characterisation
85
s F
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
Concentration (%) Figure 1 Huggins plots for detarium gum solutions in water and water-cadoxen mixtures with different volume fraction of cadoxen Vcd. -- H 2 0 , A -- 0.1, 0 -- 0.2, o -- 0.3, +K -0.4, A -- 0.5, and G -0.7.
+
0.2 0.1
J 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.0
Volume &tion of cadoxen Figure 2 Huggins constants in relation to the volume fraction of cadoxen in watercadoxen mixtures for detarium xyloglucan (+), oat p-glucan (.) and dextran ( A ).
86
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
l2 n 11
i
en
3 10
W
.29 m
0
.& 2 8 > .& 0 7 m
.9 3
6
uE: 5
0
0.4
0.2
0.8
0.6
Volunr: fixtion of cadoxen Figure 3 Intrinsic viscosity in relation to the volume fraction of cadoxen in watercadoxen mixtures for detarium xyloglucan (*) and oat p-glucan (.). ~
16
5 14 F 12 10
8
4
-r
0
0.02
T
0.04
I
0.06
0.08
0.1
Concentration(%) Figure 4 Huggins plots for oat p-glucan solutions in water and water-cadoxen mixtures with different volume fraction of cadoxen Vcad. 0.4. o -- 0.6.
-- H20, A- 0.05, A -- 0.1, -- 0.2, t --
87
Polysaccharide Characterisation
In the case of oat p-glucan, the effect of added cadoxen on the solvation of the polymer was even more pronounced. The Huggins constant decreased from 0.81 in water to 0.25 in 0.60 cadoxen (Figures 2 and 4). However, the intrinsic viscosity of 0-glucan only decreased slightly on addition of cadoxen (Figures 3 and 4). It can be explained that although the disruption of the p-glucan aggregates in cadoxen leads to a decrease in intrinsic viscosity, the solvation in cadoxen caused an extensive expansion of the polymer chains which leads to an increase in [q]. As a result, the intrinsic viscosity [q] only slightly decreased. Interestingly, dextran behaved in a different way on the addition of cadoxen to the water solution. As demonstrated in Figure 5, the intrinsic viscosity of dextran instead of decreasing, increased significantly, from 0.51 in water to 0.90 in 0.5 (Vcd) cadoxen. However, the Huggins constants decreased to a lesser extent compared to the other two polysaccharides. One possible explanation is that water is a “better than 0” solvent for dextran. Dextran molecules do not aggregate extensively like other polysaccharides do, both perhaps because of the branching structure of the high molecular weight sample, and of the highly flexible nature of the saccharide chain. Consequently, the increase in intrinsic viscosity is most likely caused by the further expansion of the macromolecular chains in cadoxen.
1 n
9 0.8 .-0 B 3 0.6 + .-0m .r(
3 0.4 d
U
0.8 Volunr: fixtion of cadoxen
Figure 5 Intrinsic viscosity of dextran vs. volume fraction of cadoxen.
88
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry I0
CONCLUSIONS In conclusion, water-cadoxen mixture is a better solvent for neutral polysaccharides compared to water alone. The aggregation of polysaccharides can be significantly reduced when the volume fraction of cadoxen V,& -0.4. The difference in dispersibility of polysaccharides in water and water-cadoxen mixture is very useful for distinguishing the polymer degradation from the dissociation of aggregates, although it is only the first stage of a fuller characterisation employing, for example, static light scattering. The application of this approach in this regard will be published later.
ACKNOWLEGMENT The authors thank Mr. John Weisz and Ms Cathy Wang for technical assistance.
REFERENCE Cui, W., Wood, .P.J., Blackwell, B. and Nikiforuk, J. (1999). Physicochemical properties and structural characterization by two-dimensional NMR spectroscopy of wheat P-D-glucan - comparison with other cereal P-D-glucans, Carbohydrate Polymers, In press. G r i m , A., Kruger, E., Burchard, W.(1995). Solution properties of P-D-( 1,3)(1,4)-glucan isolated from beer. Carbohydrate Polymers, 27(3), 205-2 14. Sakai, T. (1968). Huggins constant k’ for flexible chain polymers. Journal of Polymer Science. A-2,6, 1535-1549. Tanford, C. (1961). Physical Chemistry of Macromolecules (pp.392-393). New York: John Wiley and Sons. Wang, Q., Ellis, P.R., Ross-Murphy, S.B. and Reid, J.S.G. (1996). A new polysaccharide from a traditional Nigerian plant food: Detarium senegalense Gmelin. Carbohydrate Research, 284 (2), 229-239. Wang, Q2, Ellis, P.R., Ross-Murphy S.B. and Burchard, W. (1997). Solution characteristics of the xyloglucan extracted from Detarium senegalense Gmelin. Carbohydrate Polymers 33, 115-124. Wood, P.J., Weisz, J. and Blackwell, B.A. (1991). Molecular characterization of cereal PD-glucans - Structural-analysis of oat P-D-Glucan and rapid structural evaluation of P-D-glucans from different sources by high-performance liquidchromatography of oligosaccharides released by lichenase. Cereal Chemistry, 68 (l), 31-39. Zhang, L., Ding, Q., Zhang, P.Y., Zhu, R.P., Zhou, Y.H. (1997). Molecular weight and aggregation behaviour in solution of P-D-glucan from Poria COCOS sclerotium. Carbohydrate Research, 303 (2), 193-197.
Polysaccharide Gelation
BIOPOLYMER GELATION - THE STRUCTURE-PROPERTY RELATIONSHIP
A.H.Clark Unilever Research Colworth Colworth House Sharnbrook Bedford MK44 1LQ UK
1 INTRODUCTION
Biopolymers are described as having functions in foods apart, that is, from their obvious role in nutrition. For example, they can enhance the stability of a food product against physical processes such as emulsion creaming, the breakdown of foams, the ripening of crystal networks, and the sedimentation of particles. They also contribute to mechanical properties (texture), to appearance, and to the rate at which flavours are released. Biopolymers are thus important food ingredients, functioning successfully often in rather small amounts, and sometimes specifically. The functions of biopolymer ingredients in foods are clearly related to their molecular structures, first to primary descriptors of these structures, such as residue sequence and molecular weight, but also to higher levels related to ordered chain conformations and to superstructures based on aggregation of these. For polysaccharides, primary sequences can be relatively simple and analogous to those of synthetic polymers, but for proteins, sequences are usually complex and unique, making globular proteins quite unlike any synthetic counterpart. Their only simplifying feature is perhaps their monodisperse molecular weight character, polysaccharides being usually quite polydisperse. Polysaccharide primary structure can also be complex. Polysaccharides sometimes show irregular statistical distributions of backbone residues or sidechains (e.g. alginate and locust bean gum) which are neither totally random nor totally organised: they sometimes have regular sequences broken periodically by ‘interrupting’ residues (e.g. pectin), which can play a part in their solution behaviour, and they can be highly branched (e.g. amylopectin). If they are closer to synthetic polymers than most proteins, polysaccharides are nonetheless rather complex analogues of their man-made counterparts. Structure and function are thus well-defined aspects of the study of food biopolymers, and both have been extensively examined. There remains a difficulty, however, which is basically a theoretical one, of achieving quantitative links between molecular structure and function. Such a link is clearly desirable as it should lead to more efficient molecular design, selection of ingredients, and choice of processing procedures. The fact that current links of this kind are highly imperfect and rather qualitative, reflects the complex structures of the biopolymers involved, and the nature of the physical properties that any theory or model has to address. It is the purpose of the present review to examine the progress made in this endeavour, particularly in relation to biopolymer gel formation, and to consider opportunities for future progress.
92
Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
2 HYDROCOLLOIDS AS STATISTICAL COILS The normal environment in which hydrocolloids function, is an aqueous one, where they are often present at fairly low concentration. Low water environments are of course also possible but are not examined in the present review. Initially then, a polysaccharide can be considered much as a normal synthetic polymer, but perhaps a bit stiffer than usual, and with water as a solvent. For synthetic polymers, the main features of solution behaviour, such as high viscosity at low concentration, viscoelastic character, solution non-ideality, and a tendency to phase separate in certain conditions, have long been understood in terms of the configurational behaviour of large flexible chains, and models based on their random flight description.1 If the polymer chain is imagined.to consist of N rods, or segments, of length L connected by universal joints, a statistical model can be developed which provides an expected distribution for the end-to-end distance of the chain, and the following root mean square average value for this distance, i.e.
The picture of the polymer molecule in solution is thus one of a randomly coiled structure, occupying an effective volume much larger than its true physical volume. Of course real polymer chains differ from this ideal in that their residues show restricted rotation and can’t pass through one another (excluded volume). The influence of solvent is also important. The intrinsic stiffness of the chains can be taken into account by making L the length of a so-called statistical segment which may involve several of the basic polymer repeat units. N then becomes the number of such segments, and the stiffer the polymer, the larger is the number of residues defining L, and the smaller N. Longer range repulsions between segments, and the influence of solvent on these, are treated by introducing an expansion factor1 which allows the real end-to-end distance to differ from its idealised value. In practice, changing solvent or temperature, causes the expansion factor to vary, but when it does equal unity (as can happen) solvent-induced attraction between segments exactly counterbalances long range repulsion (excluded volume is zero), and so-called theta conditions prevail. A model for the coil expansion factor has been constructed1 by introducing a polymer-solvent interaction parameter x which quantifies an imagined equilibrium involving the weak association of polymer segments in the solvent involved. Arguments have shown that when x = 0.5 the theta condition is achieved (poor solvent conditions), with coil expansion occurring as x falls below 0.5 (good solvent). The significance of the above ideas for hydrocolloid solutions is considerable. High viscosity generation at low concentrations derives from the high effective coil volume, as coordinated rotation of the expanded coil through the solvent dissipates much more energy, than uncoordinated movement of the individual segments.1 In terms of the coil model, this behaviour is clearly related to the value of the parameter x for any biopolymer-solvent combination, and temperature, and on other factors determining the effective coil volume, such as the statistical segment length (intrinsic coil stiffness). To some extent the latter is amenable to molecular modelling calculations2 based on inter-residue interactions, butpredicting x in a similar way is a formidable challenge. Finally, it should be commented that the above is a very simple picture of hydrocolloid behaviour and often needs elaboration, particularly in relation to concentration effects and deviations of the polymer from a simple coil description. The presence of charge (i.e. polyelectrolyte character) has an important influence on chain expansion, and also where chains become really stiff (very large statistical segment length, few segments present per molecule) alternative models based on idealisations such as a ‘wormlike chain’, or extended rod, are required. This is particularly true where polymers have undergone ordering transitions of the kind now considered.
Polysaccharide Gelation
93
3 ORDERING TRANSITIONS
Coiled polysaccharides are intrinsically stiff because of restricted rotation about inter-residue bonds, but when molecular weight is large, they are often describable as random coils in the manner just outlined. In some cases, however, as temperature falls, or other conditions change, such as pH or solvent composition (addition of salts, small molecules, etc), the entropic advantage to be gained from the disordered state becomes outweighed by energy gains offered by an ordered helical state. Single helix formation would be the most obvious transformation but, for polysaccharides, winding of chains into multiple helices is also common (particularly double helices) so that the ordering transition can also be an aggregation process. The importance of ordering transitions (and the reverse process of conformational ‘melting’) in molecular biology prompted the early development of models for their description of which perhaps the most celebrated are those of Zimm and Bragg3 (uncharged coils and helices) and Zimm and Rice4 (charged molecules). In this type of approach chain residues are seen as ordered (h) or disordered (c) and all possible combinations of such states for a chain of defined length are considered, each configuration being assigned a statistical weight. This last is primarily defined in terms of an equilibrium constant ‘s’ related to the free energy difference between isolated helix and coil states. To reproduce the transition sharpness often observed, nearest neighbour correlation is introduced through a co-operativity parameter ‘u‘ which modifies the statistical weight of a helix state at the end of a helical sequence to ‘su‘,i.e. introduces an endeffect penalty. The smaller u is, the sharper is the transition as s varies (temperature change or other change in conditions). The Zimm-Bragg model is successful in describing experimental data for degree of ordering versus temperature for biopolymers and, in its more elaborate ZimmRice form, ion binding is also considered as a driving influence. Disorder-order conformational transitions in polysaccharides are extremely important for their functions in foods, partly because stiffening will promote increased effectiveness in viscosity generation, but mainly because gel network formation often requires transition to the ordered form prior to network assembly. The prediction of such behaviour from molecular structure, which is evidently desirable, is hstrated, however, by the fact that the parameters s and a are dificult to quantify in molecular terms. Some attempts to look at this issue using molecular modelling have been attempted but, at present, this problem seems to be beyond the scope of the approach, though some insights into the origins of helix stability can be obtained.5 4 VISCOSITY GENERATION
This very important property of hydrocolloid solutions is often demonstrated by plotting specific (or relative) viscosity at low shear rate (Newtonian plateau value) versus polymer concentration. When this is done on a log-log basis there is usually an apparent intersection of two straight lines at a concentration C*, the entanglement (or coil overlap) concentration.6,7 Different power law behaviour occurs below and above this threshold, the viscosity increasing more rapidly with concentration as polymer coils interpenetrate and entangle. It is found that C* is related to polymer intrinsic viscosity [q] according to C*[q] = constant, where the latter is close to 4. Since the intrinsic viscosity is actually an effective hydrodynamic volume for the polymer coil (expressed per gm of polymer) it is clear that C* is very much determined by coil expansiodcontraction, a fact confirmed by the well known Mark-Houwink relationship, [q]=KM’ where M is the molecular weight.1 In this, the exponent a is equal to 0.5 for the unperturbed random coil, rises to 0.8 for expanded coils, and can be greater than this for non-coiling extended structures.
94
Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
4
3
2
f
-
[ rlsp
- 1011 0
, -0.5 0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
c*
-41
Figure 1 Viscosity-concentrationmasterplot approach to coil thickenersfrom ref: 6 The decisive nature of the intrinsic viscosity in determining hydrocolloid viscosity generation is indicated in Figure I (data from ref. 6) which shows how experimental data for a range of coil polysaccharides can be reduced to mastercurve form by plotting specific viscosity against reduced concentration C[q]. This procedure illustrates a recurring theme of the present review in which the essential physics of a phenomenon is expressed in the mathematical form of amastercurve, while the absolute behaviour of an individual system requires extra information in the form of values for the reducing parameters (in this case the solvent viscosity and [q]). While theoretical work by Rouse78 Zimm? Graessley,lO,ll, De Gennes12713 and Doi and Edwards14 has explored the basic physics of polymer thickening, including the linear and non-Iinearviscoelastic properties of polymer solutions (e.g. shear thinning of entangled systems), and has given some explanation for the mastercurve form in Figure I , the link to detailed molecular structure remains obscure. Accurate prediction of the intrinsic viscosity from molecular structure would evidently be a main step in this, but is frustrated by difficulties in treating influences such as solvent effects, polyelectrolyte character, and the helix-coil transition (see last Section). Interestingly, the high viscosity which topologically entangled systems can generate (C>C*) often confers ‘gel-like’ properties, and indeed polymer networks of a type are being formed. To explore and define gel behaviour, however, the solid (elastic) character of such systems must be examined, and this is addressed next, through consideration of the viscoelastic character of hydrocolloid solutions, and the influence on it of more and more permanent cross-linking between chains.
Polysaccharide Gelation
95
5 TEMPORARY NETWORKS
The dynamic mechanical response (frequency spectrum) of a typical entangled polymer solution (which might be mistaken for a gel) is shown as (A) in Figure 2 over the frequency range typical of a conventional measuring instrument. Only at higher frequencies is the response ‘solid-like’ with G’ > G” and even then there is a substantial viscous component. The cross-over frequency between liquid and solid response is on short timescales, and will vary with concentration (degree of entanglement). The results reflect the very short lifetimes of topological entanglements and the fact that finite (if high) Newtonian viscosities can be measured. As gels, they are not convincing, being better described as elastic fluids. Hydrocolloid solutions can, however, show more definite ‘solid’ characteristics, hints of this appearing in viscosity plots of the type shown in Figure 1, where increased power law behaviour above C* has been noted, and described 6 7 in terms of so called ‘hyperentanglements’ (extra and longer lived cross-links). Where polysaccharides undergo conformational ordering (e.g. the polysaccharide xanthan) this effect can be pronounced, with difficulty being experienced in establishing a Newtonian viscosity plateau experimentally, and the viscosity showing strong shear-thinning character. 7915 This implies that, in quiescent conditions, a three dimensional gel network can form through chain association, with a much higher level of permanence than the topological network. In terms of the linear viscoelastic spectrum, such systems tend to behave more like Figure 2B, which now indicates almost uniform solid response over the frequency window, consistent with network bond relaxation moving to much longer timescales. The propensity of such systems to network breakdown under increasing applied stress (particularly above a critical threshold or ‘yield stress’ ) shown by their capacity to flow and shear thin, confirms, however, that the bonds present are of limited strength, and are short-ranging, and of still finite lifetime. They are sometimes called weak gels, or temporary networks, the term ‘gel’ reflecting their essentially solid character over ‘normal’ mechanical spectrometer timescales, and ‘weak’ relating to their often quite low elastic moduli, residual viscous character (significant G”) and fluid character (non-linear response).
Figure 2 Typical mechanical spectra for (A) entangled (B) temporary networks Thickeners capable of showing transient network character, and apparent yield stress behaviour, find many industrial applications, and they have attracted much attention from theorists. Models vary between those attempting analytical descriptionl6.17 (basically similar to those applied to entangled networks), to those based on computer simulation.18~19 The new ingredient in such work is of course the introduction of sites or regions of the polymer where specific attraction can occur. Off-lattice simulations~9have succeeded in reproducing much of
96
.
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
the relaxational characteristics of such networks, as reflected, for example, in the frequency spectrum over a wide frequency range. Analytical approaches have had similar successes. A problem with both types of model, however, is that the component polymer chains and their interactions, are highly simplified, and it is difficult to see how results can be re-interpreted at a molecular level.
6 EXPERIMENTAL ASPECTS OF STRONG GEL FOKMATION Strong gels differ from the transient networks (weak gels) just described through their very different non-linear responses to applied stress, i.e. their tendency to stretch elastically, and show failure. Such properties are evidently a consequence of their network cross-links being much stronger, and longer lived than in temporary networks, though the distinction is not sharp. The frequency spectra of strong gels are usually significantly less frequency dependent, and have lower G” values, over comparable frequency intervals. On normal timescales little relaxation occurs and when it does, through bond breaking at large strains, the process is essentially stochastic, depends on network imperfections, and leads to failure. That even the bonds in strong gels have finite lifetimes can be shown, however, in long time creep and stress relaxation experiments.20
Time Figure 3 Typical time evolution of the dynamic modulus for a strongh gelling system showing one estimate of the gel time and the truncation time defining an apparent plateau modulus value
Strong gel formation is of course a classical property of polysaccharide solutions (and gelatin) when these are cooled, andlor specific counterions are added (amylose, agarose, carrageenan, alginate, pectin, gellan, etc), and it is also a property of many globular protein solutions when exposed to heat. For the cold-set gels, strong crosslink formation seems to have its origins in stable multiple helix formation (gelatin triple helix, carrageenan double helix) andlor in a pronounced tendency for such helices as are formed (single or multiple) to aggregate in solution. Amylose and agarose gels provide well-known examples of this latter phenomenon whilst, for the more charged carrageenans, alginates, pectin and gellan, particular counterions may be necessary
Polysaccharide Gelation
97
to achieve the same effect. Carrageenan systems in other situations may have to rely on helix formation alone to build networks, i.e where aggregation is inhibited by charge. In this respect they become more like gelatin gels. In the globular protein case (at pH’s removed from the isoelectric point) initial linear fibril formation generates stable structures, which then interact strongly enough to produce a gel network. The much stronger and permanent nature of cross-links in strong gels has important implications for experimental approaches to their study, particularly in relation to dynamic mechanical spectroscopy. Processes of bond formation in such cases require finite (and sometimes quite long) times to occur (rarely an issue for temporary networks), and delay evolution of the modulus (and other gel properties) in a quenched solution, allowing the dynamic mechanical spectrometer to measure a cure curve (G’ and G” recorded as functions of time - see Figure 3). Cure curve measurement20,21 has in fact become a generic method for characterising the kinetics of gelation, and much modelling and theory has been directed towards explaining its principal features, such as the lag period or gel time (tg), and the apparent limiting modulus value achieved at long but finite truncation times (G’ at ttr). Interest attaches to these quantities in relation to quench conditions such as the final temperature, the concentration ofbiopolymer, and its molecular weight.22 Further important properties of the gels are slow long time processes of modulus growth20 and the temperature dependence of the final modulus (gel melting).22 The frequency dependence is not of great interest over normal frequency ranges for the reason already outlined, but creep or stress relaxation experiments, sometimes attempted, allow access to longer times, and provide further information about cross-link dynamics. The results of cure experiments for different gelling systems are oftensurprisingly similar and may be summarised as follows:
Figure 4 Reduced experimental gel time (Td,and plateau modulus (G 2 - concentration data, compared to cascade theory master plot predictions flor data shown see refs. 22-28) (1) The gel time (Figure 4) appears to diverge at a certain critical concentration but shows power law behaviour above this.22 The power law varies from system to system, being quite large for
98
G u m and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
polysaccharides23~24,25 showing helix aggregation, and for globular proteins26327 forming fibrils, but much lower for gelatin23928 and high methoxy pectin.23 (2) The temperature dependence of the gel time is much less well characterised, but for globular proteins an Arrhenius behaviour has been observed.29 For polysaccharides, gel times23 generally become shorter on cooling, consistent with an ordering process. (3) The apparent limiting gel modulus (obtained after some chosen long truncation time) shows a C2 concentration dependence at higher concentrations, but this dependence continuously increases its power law index as concentration falls, until eventually the modulus diverges logarithmically (goes to zero) at a critical concentration (Figure 4).22
E pa
2 Ogi'
.*
iooa cascade model
500
0
1
0
4
8
Figure 5 Cascade modelling of experimental Young's modulus (E) versus weight average molecular weight (M,) for K-carrageenanfractions (datafrom ref: 30)
(4) The apparent limiting modulus for a system at constant concentration, but varying polymer molecular weight, stays at zero, until a critical molecular weight is reached, then rises rapidly to a plateau value, and then becomes independent of molecular weight (Figure 9.30
( 5 ) The apparent limiting modulus usually falls on raising temperature (Figure 6)20 (or increases on cooling) and in some cases it becomes zero at a critical upper temperature (the gel melting temperature).3 1 Sometimes this melting curve shows temporary modulus increases indicating some form of annealing,32 and for polysaccharides, the melting temperature is sometimes greater than the highest effective setting temperature (hysteresis affect).20,32
(6) The apparent limiting modulus can increase in logarithmic time indicating long-term network instability (particularly for gelatin gels).20 This seems to have little effect on the shape of the modulus-concentration relationship but it does lower the effective critical concentration (very slowly). The effect on gel melting has not been systematically examined. Some modelling exercises aimed at understanding these findings are now discussed.
Polysaccharide Gelation
99
G’P~
21
cascade f=3
_--.-__--.*__.-. _.^__“ _.-.... --*-.>i--
-*a4
.f=100
81
\
PECIW GEL MELTING
t fi
1
4.1
cascade
f=3,100
t “C 10
20
30
0
Figure 6 Cascade modelling of experimental modulus-temperature ‘meltdown’data for gelatin andpectin gels (see reJ31)
7 MEAN FIELD AND OTHER MODEL DESCRIPTIONS A number of model approaches have been developed to describe the formation of strong gels and their properties. These include the mean field model discussed below?3-35 some related approaches,17,23,24,36,37 lattice models such as percolation theory?8-40 and various off-lattice simulations.41-43 The mean field description is largely a development of Flory’s theory of rubber elasticity1 modified to include the physical nature of cross-links in biopolymer gel networks, and the large amounts of solvent within which cross-linking takes place. Further complications include the common need to introduce kinetic processes prior to cross-linking, such as the generation of ordered (or for proteins, disordered) primary gelling units, or even nonrandom clusters of these (protein fibrils, and preliminary semi-crystalline polysaccharide aggregates). A tendency for liquid-liquid demixing (see next Section) can also introduce extra kinetics, but here, where only homogeneous gel networks are considered, this is assumed absent. The presence of solvent in gelling biopolymer systems makes concentration an important physical quantity. In describing their gelation kinetics it is assumed that a starting stable solution of the biopolymer of concentration C (% w/w) is quenched rapidly, either to a higher or to a lower temperature, to set aggregation and gelling in motion. As mentioned above, any complete kinetic model, as well as describing network building, will normally have to address preliminary conformational changes, and/or non-random aggregation events. For the sake of simplification, however, such initial processes will be assumed absent, and the mean field model presented for the case where the initial molecules can begin association as they stand, and where these are essentially molecularly monodisperse.
Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
100
To set up the mode1,33-35 each starting molecule is assigned a number f of potential binding (cross-linking) sites and, as time proceeds, a fraction a (t) of these reacts. Flory’s theory of random cross-linking] suggests that small aggregates alone will form untila = l/(f-I) when the gel point is reached, but then a very large gel molecule will suddenly appear (critical divergence of the weight average molecular weight). After this, the remaining sol fraction becomes increasingly cured into the gel and the modulus rises. The problem is to calculate this modulus as a function of time for any set of gelling conditions, a process which requires the increasing density of elastic or load-bearing chains to be estimated. Flory has provided a method for doing this for a rather restricted range of network types based on covalent cross-linking, but for biopolymer gels Clark and Ross-Murphy20933 preferred a more general approach based on the Case-Scanlan definition of the EANC (elastically-active network chain) and the cascade approach to gelation statistics.44 The approach has been described in detail elsewhere but, in essence, a final expression for the modulus at any time t is given by the expression, G = {Nfa( I-v)2(1-P)/2}aRT
(2)
in which
and
p = (f-l)av/(l-a+av)
(4).
In these expressions v is the so-called extinction probability, which is the probability that a reacted functionality of an arbitrary molecule becomes ‘extinct’, that is fails to connect to the boundaries of the gel. The expression in parentheses in (2) is then the required density of EANCS with N = C/M, the concentration in molar terms, and M the initial molecular weight. Each EANC then contributes aRT to the modulus, where a is a front factor (usually unity for ideal gel networks, but sometimes much higher for biopolymer systems, and sometimes temperature dependent). To apply the model, all that is required is to formulate a(t). Originally, it was proposed that for biopolymer gels, particularly those that were near their melting temperature, a reversible cross-linking process could be assumed, leading to an equilibrium between bond making and breaking at long times ( a dynamic gel state). According to this, some strong gels were still to be regarded as temporary networks, the difference in relation to ‘weak gels’ being one of degree (actual rate of cross-link breaking) rather than kind. This led to a(t) being formulated in terms of rate constants for a second order forward pairwise cross-linking reaction of the bonding sites, and a first order back reaction. Equilibrium was assumed at long curing times (cure curve plateaus out). In many practical situations involving strong gel formation, however, cross-linking is believed to occur irreversibly (strong driving force). Homogeneous gel formation under these conditions becomes decreasingly likely, as increased attraction will engender poor solvent conditions and segregation (see next Section). Uniform network formation in these conditions, when it occurs, is most easily explained by rapid irreversible cross-linking, aggregation outpacingdemixing, and leading to kinetic trapping. In this case further reaction between network sites is inhibited by steric hindrance arising mainly as a result of intramolecular cyclisation events. To treat this case a(t) is taken as the solution of differential equations describing competition between a second order cross-linking event, and a site wastage event assumed first order.35 In both the reversible and irreversible models gelation only begins when a exceeds l/(f-l), the critical branching limit.
Polysaccharide Gelation
101
Using equation (2), and a reversible or irreversible model for a(t), the apparent long time limiting modulus can be calculated as a function of C (constant T and M ), as a function of T (constant C and M), and as a function of M (constant C and T). At the same time, from the conditions defining the gel point, and the kinetic equations for a(t), the gel time can be similarly expressed. Success in relation to experiment may be summarised as follows: (1) Experimental modulus-concentration data can be satisfactorily described (Figure 4), including behaviour suggestive of a critical concentration.20,22,33-35 (2) Gel melting curves can be described by the reversible model (Figure 6 ) in terms of an enthalpy and entropy of cross-linking.22,31,32 Comparison of results at different concentrations for locust bean gum, however, indicate inconsistencies which can only be explained32 in terms of irreversible cross-linking during gel setting at low temperatures, which switches over to reversible cross-link melting only close to the much higher melting temperature. This problem is less apparent for pectin and gelatin gels.3 1 (3) Provided f is proportional to molecular weight, the behaviour of the modulus with respect to molecular weight for certain polysaccharides can be explained (Figure S), including the existence of a critical molecular weight.22 (4) Gel time divergence (Figure 4) can easily be explained35 at the critical concentration, but the high limiting power laws found for certain polysaccharide gels (at higher concentrations) can not. Temperature dependence of the gel time has not been examined closely. (5) Long time processes affecting the apparent limiting modulus have not been explained in detail, but are assumed to arise from various network ripening mechanisms associated (among other things) with some slow reversibility of cross-linking (even in apparently irreversible cases), allowing junction zones to change size, and phase separation to proceed slowly. A model combining reversible intermolecular cross-linking and reversible cyclisation might explain some of this, but would be highly parameterised. In relation to the failure with respect to the gel time behaviour of polysaccharides, two changes to the model can be considered, one being to generalise the cross-linking equilibrium to treat allor-none formation of groups of sites (or junction zones) rather than simply pairwise association, the other to look at more complex kinetic events prior to network formation. The first approach was explored by Oakenfull and Scott23924 using a mean field gel model very similar to the one described here, and this did indeed increase the steepness of gel time concentration log plots, the slope at higher concentrations becoming n-1, where n is the number of sites per junction. However, this result is achieved at the expense of the rather difficult concept of a high nth order forward reaction. An alternative approach is to examine the effect of introducing extra kinetic events prior to (or as part of) network building. For example, if highly aggregated junction zone formation in polysaccharides proceeds by irreversible nucleation and growth, rather than by Oakenfull and Scott’s high order reversible association process, sizeable observed power laws could relate to the number of chains in a critical nucleus. A similar result would be obtained if the crystallisation event, though still rate determining, merely produced primary ordered polysaccharide aggregates which went on to randomly associate and build the network. This mechanism has topological advantages in explaining normal polysaccharide gel formation, and certainly occurs in the formation of colloidal particle gels from maltodextrins.25 Temperature influence on gel times for polysaccharides is also better explained by nucleation and growth controlling aggregation, but here the situation is confused by the fact that chain ordering at a lower molecular level (single or
102
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
double helix formation) is usually also involved and is itself a nucleated process. At present, however, little certainty exists, and one has to admit that the detailed kinetics of polysaccharide gelation, as reflected by gel times, remains somewhat obscure. The properties of the apparent limiting modulus (at longer times), on the other hand, seem to be largely unaffected (Figure 4) by details of the early kinetics, and are much better explained by the random aggregation model in its simplest form. This universality of the modulus-concentration relationship is probably a Straightforward consequence of network building over long distance scales being essentially a random event, unaffected by the exact details of assembly of the primary gelling units. Apart from mean field approaches such as that described here, and those produced by Oakenfull and Scott,23,24 Tanaka36337 and Semenov and Rubinstein,l7 the literature also contains accounts of percolation theory calculations38-40 and off-lattice simulations. 18,19,41-43 Percolation theory has focussed on description of behaviour near the critical gel point (critical exponents) but, so far, few predictions of modulus behaviour, or of gel times, have been presented. Until this is done, its contribution to the problems addressed here seems difficult to assess. Much the same thing can be said about random aggregation models (off-lattice) which have been mainly applied to particle gels (though see work by Groot and Agterofl8,19 for an exception). The fractal description of aggregates and networks which has arisen from this activity, has been related to the gel modulus, and seems to predict a constant power law dependence for this in relation to concentration$5 there being no expected critical concentration. For any given system this powerlaw is related to the appropriate fractal dimension and can vary from gel type to type. This contrasts with conclusions of the mean field approach, which predicts the existence of a critical concentration (often quite a large one), and a non power law master curve for all gel types. So far, practical experimental results for most gels seem to confirm the mean field prediction. Curved modulus-concentration data sets (log-log) are commonly found, and where they are not, the reported constant power laws are often symptomatic of very limited experimental concentration ranges. Currently, simulation approaches19 are beginning to provide values for the gel modulus, rather than relying upon the fractal argument, and it will be interesting to see what modulus-concentration relationships emerge from these. The mean field model is not without its own difficulties, however, particularly where the desire is to connect with molecular properties since, like many of the other models discussed so far, it is expressed in terms of rate constants, enthalpies and entropies of cross-linking, front factors etc, all of which have meaning, but most of which are difficult to relate quantitatively to molecular structure. Simulation approaches may overcome these difficulties, in time, but at present these are not atomistic, and a similar problem of interpreting parameters remains.
8 PHASE BEHAVIOUR OF HYDROCOLLOID SOLUTIONS/GELS Demixing in biopolymer solutions is anticipated from theory, the Flory-Huggins lattice theory 1, for example, for concentrated polymer solutions, suggesting that when the polymer-solvent x value exceeds 0.5, the solution free energy and related component chemical potentials adopt forms which make demixing (into concentrated and dilute polymer phases) inevitable. Increases in x likely to drive this are to be expected as temperature falls, molecules become less charged, or solvent repellent sidechains (e.g. hydrophobic residues) become exposed, and these are of course the conditions which also promote gelation (strong and weak). Gelation and demixing can thus occur together in a quenched system and be intimately related. Where temporary networks form (reversible weak interactions) poor solvent conditions are possible as temperature or solvent conditions vary and phase separation is an issue. Mean field,36937 percolation39 and simulation models18 all suggest an equilibrium phase diagram (T versus concentration, for example) for such systems, in which a miscibility gap is intersected by a critical sol-gel line (Figure 7). This allows homogeneous gels to split into phase-separated
103
PolysaccharideGelation
systems, or even for two gel phases (different concentrations) to equilibrate. Equilibrium conditions should lead to macroscopic phase separation but, even for temporary networks, polymer concentration in the gelled phases, and the lifetime of cross-links, will lead to trapped microstructures which ripen slowly. For the strong gels of the last Section increased cross-linking affinity will emphasise the miscibility gap regions of Figure 7 and make homogeneous gel formation less probable. Kinetic trapping becomes the only way in which high levels of homogeneity can be explained in many situations. It cannot be assumed, however, that such trapping will always be effective, particularly where cross-linking is slow. In such situations, increasing density fluctuations, or even the formation of a network of gelled liquid droplets, will occur as demixing overtakes
T
T
SOL
so L
If
SOL
QC
Figure I General form of phase behaviour of reversibly gelling single biopolymer systems as predicted by meanfield (refs. 36.3 7) and percolation theory (ref: 39). aggregation. Agarose gels, for example, become increasingly heterogeneous46if gelled slowly in conditions close to the ordering temperature, and P-lactoglobulin gels take the form of aggregated spherical droplets47 when heated near the isoelectric point. For strong gels, equilibrium phase diagrams like Figure 7 have little meaning, and are replaced by history dependent ‘state diagrams’ (often very similar, however). Liquid-liquid demixing is also a common feature of ternary biopolymer solutions (two polymers and a solvent) and has a profound effect on the gelling of such mixtures. For these, under most conditions, the Flory-Huggins concentrated solution model predicts (Figure 8) a miscibility gap defined by a binodal boundary and spanned by tielines which will move with temperature. Segregative demixing of a solution, i.e. into two phases rich in the respective polymer components, is promoted by a positive interactive x value (greater than critical) for the polymer pair, by a difference in individual polymer-solvent x values, and by high molecular weight. As Picullel has demonstrated, however, this process is inhibited when a charged and uncharged biopolymer are present, through the ion entropy effect.48 Associative demixing, i.e. formation of a concentrated phase containing both polymers, and a dilute solvent-rich phase, is also possible, this being promoted by an attractive polymer interaction, and polymerx values close to 0.5. Interestingly, the Fdmond-Ogston thermodynamic mode149 for ternary solutions, based on virial coefficients, leads to very similar conclusions, and can readily be applied to mixtures containing globular proteins where the Flory-Huggins theory is inappropriate.
104
Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
Gels based on ternary solutions have become very important in modem food technology, e.g. in the area of fat replacement, and more generally. The phase behaviours of the solutions from which these gels form are quite crucial to the outcomes involved.
POLYMER A
30
30
20
20
10
10
I
10
20
30
POLY YER
B
POLYMER
A
10
20
30 POLYMERB
Figure 8 Calculated binodals and spinodals for ternary Polymer A-Polymer B-solvent systems using Flory-Huggins theory. Much more complete segregation occurs as the polymer-polymer interaction (xA&) is increased, and the polymer-solvent parameters (XA~,,& difler more widely. Ms, MA and MB are molecular weights in segment numbers. Complete segregation was assumed in early models for the modulus of composite gels (see below).
9 MIXED HYDROCOLLOID GELS BASED ON SOLUTION DEMIXING From the nature of typical ternary phase diagrams it is clear that starting solutions for gel formation can be chosen compositionally to lie either within or without the miscibility gap. A common situation is to start inside, and prepare a demixed water-in-water emulsion with, in the segregative case, an internal phase rich in one polymer, and a supporting phase rich in the other.
Polysaccharide Gelation
105
Figure 9 Electron micrograph of a gelled water-in-water emulsion (agar-serum albumin system 1/10% w/w) showing protein inclusions (dark) in polysaccharide gelled droplets (light)-rej34 Gelling can then proceed by temperature quenching, or applying multiple quenches, or temperature ramps. The outcome is usually a composite gel containing gelled droplets of one polymer within a matrix of the other (Figure 9). Because of incomplete initial polymer segregation (quite common) the gelled phases may contain a sub-structure of smaller droplets or heterogeneities produced by further segregation during quenching. Other morphologies are possible too, such as networks of gelled droplets interpenetrated by a liquid (or weakly gelled phase) and bicontinuous mutually interpenetrating gelled phases, if surface tension is low, and the system composition lies close to the centre of a tieline. As Brown et a1.50 have shown such morphology can also be influenced by applied shear. The water-in-water emulsion route introduces kinetic issues additional purely to gelling, associated with the stability of the emulsion to coalescence, bulk phase separation etc, during quenching, and the situation needs careful handling. An alternative procedure is to quench from a homogeneous region of the phase diagram and allow phase separation and gelling to compete. This can generate structures very similar to those just discussed, if a water-in-water emulsion forms before gelling, but factors determining drop size, and spatial distribution, may be different, and depend on quench depth and rate. Alternatively, gelling may arrest the structure in its earliest stages, and produce either a molecularly interpenetrating network (IPN), or a system trapped at the level of incipient phase separation. In this last case the mechanism by which demixing occurs may be important. Demixing from within the so-called spinodal region of the phase diagram proceeds rapidly from an unstable equilibrium position by a process of uniform density fluctuations, and when trapped by gelling, can produce uniform segregated microphase morphologies, or a collection of uniformly sized droplets.51 Demixing from outside the spinodal proceeds from a metastable equilibrium state by nucleation and growth, and is slower, and has somewhat different early characteristics. At later stages, however, the two mechanisms may be indistinguishable.
106
Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
(Nm”) lo7
lo6 GX
t 1.o
0
Figure 10 Upper and lower bound estimates of composite modulus Gc based on series and parallel addition of component phase moduli weighted according to volumefractions (see rej 34) Modelling the above events is of course difficult. Models are available to describe individual elements of the process such as phase diagrams (including spinodals) and demixing and gelling kinetics, but where gel formation involves complex interplay between these factors, combining the models effectively is a formidable task. The extreme situations of complete segregation prior to gelation (factorisation of events) and no segregation (IPN formation) are probably the easiest to treat. The absence of phase separation is considered in the next Section. For the gelling of wellestablished highly segregated water-in-water emulsions, the principal model available34 addresses the linear shear modulus in relation to polymer composition. A phase diagram, in which the miscibility gap encompasses all compositional space, and has parallel tielines, is envisaged (limiting form of the right-hand diagram in Figure 8), and defined by a parameter p closely related to the tieline slope, and ultimately to the difference between individual polymersolvent x values. Partition of water is thus fully described by p, and this ‘avidity parameter’ is then used to calculate effective concentrations and gel moduli (based on pure component data) for the separate phases. These moduli are then added by upper and lower bound (series and parallel) additivity laws to provide an estimate of the composite modulus (Figure 10). The fully segregative model has had a number of successes, but it has serious limitations, and these should be recognised. First, the additivity laws provide only bounds for the modulus. Real microstructures (e.g. bicontinuous phases) may need more sophisticated treatment if a more precise estimate is needed. Also, importantly, segregation within the phases is unlikely to be complete, certainly initially, and tielines are rarely parallel. This makes the idea of defining concentrations by a single parameter rather doubtful, and there is every chance that gelling of the principal polymer in a phase will be affected by residual amounts of the other, making reference to pure component behaviour unsatisfactory. In addition, such gelling will generally involve processes of secondary demixing, or interpenetrating network formation, leading to more complex microstructure than envisaged originally. Finally, from the point of view of relating properties to molecular structure, such a model depends on several Flory-Huggins x values, and these, as has been said previously, are difficult to relate to molecular structure. Alternative
Polysaccharide Gelation
107
approaches to mixed gel formation based on simulation have been performed for mixed particle gels$2 and look promising, but these are still at the earliest stages of development. 10 INTERPENETRATING AND COUPLED NETWORKS
As mentioned above, the opposite extreme to the formation of fully segregated water-in-water
emulsion gels, is the formation of molecularly interpenetrating networks (IPNs to be distinguished from interpenetrating phases or even microphases). This situation is expected to occur when a homogeneous system is quenched under conditions where at least one component gels rapidly, and homogeneously, and/or the composition remains well outside the binodal phase boundary (even at the new temperature, and even when molecular weight increases commence). As was commented earlier, this last situation is likely to be promoted by combining charged and uncharged biopolymers through the ion entropy effect. If the second component gels less rapidly than the first (usually the case) it will aggregate within the pores of the supporting network, and this may involve a form of phase separation, particularly if the second component normally forms a phase separated gel structure (see gellan Paselli SA2 example in Figure 11). Alternatively, a very uniform mixed network may form where it is difficult to distinguish the components (see gellan - agarose example in Figure 1 1). Interpenetrating molecular networks raise interesting questions about modelling. There is no sense in which their polymer components compartmentalise into separate phases so, effectively, they interact with the same solvent, and feel each other’s presence. At the simplest level, one might propose that the component macromolecules will behave as though alone and at their nominal concentrations. One might then obtain a final modulus by straightforward addition of these separate contributions. In practice, however, the additivity law is likely to be more complex, and either polymer may show severely altered gelation kinetics because of the presence
Figure 11 Electron micrographs show Paselli sA2 aggregates embedded in a tenuouspreformed gellan gel network (le#) while agarose and gellan networks mutually interpenetrate (right). Confocal microscopy (le# insert) shows heterogeneous distribution of starch (light areas) within composite. Note: charged-unchargedpolymer combinations inhibit demixing
108
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
of the other. This appears to be more true for the gellan-SA2 example recently studied,52 than for the gellan-agarose,53 but at present the general extent of this effect is difficult to assess. Indeed is quite difficult to study experimentally, i.e. to find techniques which can deconvolute and monitor the gelling behaviour of individual polymers in mixtures. Modelling such effects is also extremely difficult as, for any gelling system, the amount of ‘interfering’ polymer varies with system composition, and more than one of the gelling parameters (rate constants, front factor, f, etc) can be affected. Some suggestions for progress in this area have been made,52 but much remains to be done. Superficially, IPNs appear similar to what have been described as coupled or ‘synergistic’ networks. In fact there is the fundamental difference that the former are believed to contain individual polymer networks which interact minimally with each other (topological entanglement) while the latter show a large attractive interaction between the components, with even the possibility that the individual components don’t gel. The formation of coupled networks must to some extent be related to associative phase behaviour, where the polymer-polymer interaction v i a l coefficient implies attraction. Their interaction may well be more specific and stoichiometric, however, than implied by Flory-Huggins theory. Where associative demixing occurs, one might expect liquid-liquid demixing to generate highly phase-separated structures (coacervate gels) but of course synergistic gel networks are often highly uniform. The subject has not been extensively studied from a polymer compatibility point of view, but presumably the homogeneity of coupled networks reflects factors inhibiting demixing similar to those leading to IPNs.
1 1 CONCLUSIONS
The present article has considered only limited examples of biopolymer function, i.e. those mostly related to thickening and gelling. The models discussed have been confined to describing kinetic Simple mean field models have dominated the events or linear mechanical properties. discussion, but references to other lattice and simulation approaches have been given and some comments made. Although difficulties arise for all the models considered, when questions are asked at a molecular level, the approaches highlighted have been successful in describing much of the phenomenology involved, in terms, for example, of universal relationships, critical concentrations and temperatures, forms of phase diagrams, mechanisms of demixing, etc. It remains clear, however, that their underlying parameters, such as x values, rate constants, equilibrium constants, enthalpies and entropies etc, are difficult to calculate from molecular details. Computer simulations may seem more likely to succeed in this respect, by operating at a more fundamental level and being more generally versatile, but so far, the level attained has proved insufficiently atomistic to provide a real breakthrough. The problem of linking molecules to properties is a familiar one to physical chemists, and it clearly takes on particularly formidable proportions in the context of food systems where kinetic control, many chemical components, and large molecules, are the norm. Nonetheless, the search for solutions particularly via simulations, is likely to continue.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The author thanks colleagues at the Colworth Laboratory and King’s College, London, for many helpful discussions and is particularly grateful to Dudley Ferdinand0 and Jenny Brigham of the Colworth Microscopy Unit for provision of electron and confocal micrographs.
Polysaccharide Gelation
109
References 1. P. J. Flory, ‘Principles of Polymer Chemistry’, Cornell University Press, New York, 1953.
S. G. Whittington, Biopolymers, 1971,10, 1481. B. H. Zimm and J. K. Bragg, J. Chem. Phys., 1959,31,476. B. H. Zimm and S. A. Rice, Molecular Physics, 1060,3,391. N. M. W. Haggett, PhD Thesis, University of Surrey, 1998. E. R. Morris, A. N. Cutler, S. B. Ross-Murphy and D. A. Rees, Carbohydr. Polym., 1981, 1,5. 7. B. Launay, J. L. Doublier and G. Cuvelier, ‘Functional Properties of Food Macromolecules’, Eds. J. R. Mitchell and D. A. Ledward, First Edition, Elsevier Applied Science, Barking, 1986,
2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
1.
8. P. E. Rouse, Jr.,J. Chem. Phys., 1953,21, 1272. 9. B. H.Zimm, J. Chem. Phys., 1956,24,269. 10. W. W. Graessley, J. Chem. Phys., 1965,43,2696. 11. W. W. Graessley, Faraday Symp. Chem. Soc.,1983,18,7. 12. P. G. De Gennes, Macromolecules, 1976,9,587. 13. P. G. De Gennes, ‘Scaling Concepts in Polymer Physics’, Cornell University Press, New York, 1985. 14. M. Doi and S. F. Edwards,J. C. S. FaradayII, 1978,74,1789: 1802: 1818. 15. S.B. Ross-Murphy, V. J. Morris and E. R. Morris, Farad. Symp. Chem. SOC.,1983,18,1 1 5 . 16. F. Tanaka and S. F. Edwards, J. Non-Newtonian Fluids, 1992,43,247:273:289. 17. A. N. Semenov and M. Rubinstein, Macromolecules, 1998,31,1373: 1386. 18. R. D. Groot and W. G. M. Agterof, J. Chem. Phys., 1994,100,1649: 1657. 19. R. D. Groot and W. G. M. Agterof, Macromolecules, 1995,28,6284. 20. A. H. Clark and S. B. Ross-Murphy, Adv. Polymer Sci., 1987,83,57. 21. S.B. Ross-Murphy, J. Texture Stud., 1995,26,391. 22. A. H.Clark and D. B. Farrer, J. Rheol., 1995,39,1429. 23. D. Oakenfull and A. Scott, ‘Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 3’, Eds. G. 0. Phillips, D. J. Wedlock and P. A. Williams, Elsevier Applied , London, 1986,465. 24. D. Oakenfull and A. Scott, ‘Gums ans Stabilisers for the Food Industry 4’,Eds. G. 0. Phillips, D. J. Wedlock and P. A. Williams, IRL Press, Oxford, 1988, 127. 25. A. H.Clark, Faraday Discuss., 1995,101,77. 26. R. K. Richardson and S. B. Ross-Murphy, Int. J. Biol. Macromol.,l981,3,315. 27. G. Kavanagh, Ph. D. Thesis, King’s College London, University of London, 1998. 28. S. B. Ross-Murphy, Rheol. Acta, 1991,30,401. 29. A. Tobitani, PhD Thesis, King’s College London, University of London, 1995. 30. C. Rochas, M. Rinaudo and S. Landry, Carbohydr. Polym., 1990,12,255. 31. A. H.Clark, K. T. Evans and D. B. Farrer, Int. J. Biol. Macromol., 1994,16,125. 32. P. H.Richardson, A. H. Clark, A. L. Russell, P. Aymard and I. T. Norton, Macromolecules, 1999,32,1519. 33. A. H.Clark and S. B. Ross-Murphy, Br. Polym. J., 1985,17,164. 34. A. H. Clark, ‘Food Structure and Behaviour’, Eds. J. M. V. Blanshard and P. J. Lillford, Academic Press, London, 1987, 13. 35. A. H.Clark, Polymer Gels andNetworkr, 1993,1,139. 36. F. Tanaka, Macromolecules, 1990,23,3784:3790. 37. F. Tanaka and W. H. Stockmayer, Macromolecules, 1994,27,3943. 38. D. Stauffer, A. Coniglio and M. Adam, Adv. Polymer Sci., 1982,44,103. 39. A. Coniglio, H.E. Stanley and W. Klein, Phys. Rev. B, 1982,25,6805. 40. M. Adam and M. Delsanti, Conternporq Physics, 1989,30,203. 41. E.Dickinson, J. C. S. F a r d a y Trans., 1994,90,173.
Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
110
42. E. Dickinson, J. C. S. Faraday Trans., 1995,91,51. 43. B. H. Bijsterbosch, M. T. A. Bos, E. Dickinson, J. H. J. Van Opheusden and P. Walstra, Faraday Discuss., 1995, 101,s 1. 44. M. Gordon and S . B. Ross-Murphy, Pure Appl. Chem., 1975,43, 1. 45. L. G. B. Bremer, T. Van Vliet and P. Walstra, J. C. S. Faraday Trans, I, 1989,85,3359. 46. M. Leone, F. Sciortino, M. Migliore, S. L. Fornili and M. B. Palma-Vittorelli, Biopolymers, 26,743. 47. M. Stading, M. Langton and A-M Hermansson, Food Hydrocolloids, 1993,7, 195. 48. L. Picullel, K. Bergfeldt and S. Nilsson, ‘Biopolymer Mixtures’, Eds. S. E. Harding, S.E. Hills and J. R. Mitchell, Nottingham University Press, Nottingham, 1995, 13. 49. E. Edmond and A. G. Ogston, Biochem. J. 1968,109,569. 50. C. R. T. Brown, T. J. Foster, 1. T. Norton and J. Underdown, ‘Biopolymer Mixtures’, Eds. S. E. Harding, S. E. Hills and J. R. Mitchell, Nottingham University Press, Nottingham, 1995,65. 5 I . A. H. Clark, ibid, 37. 52. A. H. Clark, S. C. E. Eyre, D. P. Ferdinand0 and S. Lagarrigue, Macromolecules, 1999,
manuscript submitted. 53. E. Amici and A. H. Clark, 1999, manuscript in preparation.
RHEOLOGICAL AND THERMAL PROPERllES NEAR TRANSITION OF GELLAN GUM AQUEOUS SOLUTIONS
THE
SOL-GEL
Emako Miyoshi* and Katsuyoshi Nishinari**
*Division of Development and Environment Studies, Osaka University of Foreign Studies, Minoo City, Osaka 562-8558, Japan **Department of Food and Nutrition, Faculty of Human Life Science, Osaka City University, Sumiyoshi, Osaka 558-8585, Japan
1 INTRODUCTION Food hydrocolloids have played a significant role in various fields, especially in the food industry and biotechnology, and have been long used as texture modifiers, emulsion stabilisers, water absorption agents, gelling and thickening agents.',* All these functions of food hydrocolloids affect the textural and rheological properties of a product, both immediately after manufacture and during long term storage prior to use. With increasing use of processed and simulated foods, greater efforts have been made to create unique textured food products, and the textural properties of processed and simulated foods are also mainly controlled by these food hydrocolloids.1.2 Many scientists, especially in the industrialiid countries, are now greatly interested in the potential of these polysaccharides as dietary fibre, or in the formulation of low-fat and lowcalorie foods. The biocompatibility of hydrocolloids can be used not only in drug delivery systems3 but also to supply wound dressings and replacements for human tissue,4 therefore the medical applications have been rapidly advanced as a result of the basic research. Recently, with increasing global environmental problems, there has been growing interest and demand for traditional polysaccharides, because polysaccharidesare ecological and biodegradable. Recently, microbial polysaccharides have become of growing commercial importance and are produced on a large scale by industrial fermentation. These microbial polysaccharides can be produced on demand and with consistent quality, so that availability and variability are not a concern.5 Gellan gum, one of the widely used fermentation materials, may offer a solution to many of problems encountered in current gelling agents? because it can form a transparent gel in the presence of multivalent cations, which is resistant to heat and acid. Since gellan gum can provide a wide-range of gel textures by careful
Gums and Stabi1isers.forthe Food Industry 10
112
control of added salts, these gels can give the same texture as other polysaccharide gels or create new textures. For the improvement of existing products and the development of new ones, the basic understanding of the gelation mechanism at the molecular level is required. As mentioned above, gellan gum is a superior gelling polysaccharide, therefore, many research groups have already reported6-23 on the physicochemical properties of gellan gum aqueous solutions. Consequently, the gelation mechanism of gellan gum solutions has been the subject of some controversy, but it is now accepted that gellan gum may undergo a thermallyreversible ordered helix-coil transition, and the junction zones of gellan gum gels are formed by aggregation of double helical gellan molecules, in a way analogous to the gelation of carrageenans. Although gellan gum forms a loose gel by itself, the physicochemical properties of gellan gels are influenced strongly by the presence of cations, moreover, they are related to the nature of the cations; divalent cations promote the gelation milch more strongly than monovalent cations. Gelation is thus sensitive to cation type, as well as valency. Therefore, the gelation mechanism of gellan gum solutions has not been clarified sufficiently. As is well known for polyelectrolytes,electrolyte type and concentration have a strong influence on their solution and gel properties. A sample of the sodium form of gellan gum with high purity was prepared by San-Ei Gen F.F.I. Inc (Osaka, Japan), and distributed to a number of laboratories.24 This sample was pure and was used without further purification, even to estimate the molecular weight of gellan gum by osmotic pressure25 or light scattering measurements.26 In the present work, the rheological and thermal properties near the sol-gel transition in gellan gum aqueous solutions were investigated by rheological measurement and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). The comparison of our results with the other results obtained by our coworkers24is also discussed i n this paper. 2 MATERIALS AND MEI'HODS 2.1. Materials
Purified gellan gum in the sodium form was kindly supplied by San-Ei Gen
EEL. Inc., Osaka, Japan was used in the present work. The contents of the inorganic ions Na+, K+, Ca2+and Mg2" were determined as Na 2.59%, K 0.009%, Ca 0.02% and Mg 0.001%, respectively. LiCl, NaU, KCI, CsCl and C a q used in the present study were extra fine grade reagents (Wako Pure Chemical Industries Ltd., Osaka, Japan), and were used without further purification. The gellan gum solutions were prepared in the same way as described previously.'6,*1 The concentration of gellan gum solutions was varied from 1to 5wt%. For samples containing salts, the concentration of gellan gum solutions was fixed at l.Owt% and the concentration of Licl in solutions ranged from 5 to
Polysaccharide Gelation
113
16OmM, that of NaCl, KCl or CsCl ranged from 5 to 1OOmM and that of CaQ ranged from 0.05 to 14mM. 2.2. Rheological measurements Mechanical spectra and thermal scanning rheological measurements were performed within a linear viscoelastic regime with a Dynamic Stress Rheometer DSR from Rheometrics Co.Ltd., NJ, USA, using a parallel plate of 50mm diameter with radial grooves to avoid gel slippage.16r 18-21 The details of rheological measurements have been described previously.16.21 The steady-shear viscosity was measured at various temperatures under conditions of steady-shear on a RFSlI fluids spectrometer from Rheometrics Co., N.J.USA, using acone and plate geometry of 25mm diameter, over a shear-rate range from 0.01 to 100s-1over lOmin.23 2.3. DSC measurements
Differential scanning calorimetry (Dsc)measurements were carried out using a Setaram micro Dsc-III calorimeter, Caluire, Fran~e.17-2~ The sample and reference pans were placed inside the calorimeter and heated to 110°C and kept for lOmin to make the mixture a homogeneous solution. Then the temperature was lowered to 5°C at O.S"C/min and raised again at the same rate up to 110°C. Finally, the temperature was scanned up and down at the same rate, and the enthalpy profiles were recorded. The details of DSC measurements have been d d b e d previously.17.21 3 RESULTS AND DI!XUSSION 3.1. Rheological and thermal behaviour near the sol-gel transition
As shown in the previous studies,1*-21we have determined two transitions of gellan gum solutions (the coil-helii transition and the sol-gel transition) by thermal scanning rheological measurements. The steepest change of G" was attributed to the coil-helix transition, because this transition temperature was in good agreement with the characteristic temperature observed by circular dichroism (CD)?7 It has been suggested28P29 that the peak around 202nm in the CD spectrum reflects the optically active chemical structure of glucuronic acid unit in the random-coiled gellan. When the optically active high ordered structure of gellan gum chains (double helical structure) is formed during cooling, the CD spectrum is changed to the superposition of the spectrum for the randomcoil and that for the double-helix, so that the change of molar ellipticity at 202nm [ 8 ho2is proportional to the change of population of the random-coil. As for the present sample, the coil-helix transition temperature , T of a 1% gellan gum solution determined rheologically almost coincided with the transition temperature ,T 27' C determined by CD measurement30 at the same scan rate OS'C/min. For gellan gum solutions above 2%, the cross-over of G' and G" was observed on cooling, which was attributed to a sol-gel transition. At
Gums and Stabilisers for the Food Industry 10
114
lower temperatures than the cross-over point, the number of aggregated helices exceeded a critical value.18-21 The coil-helix transition (Tch) and the sol-gel transition (T,) temperatures during cooling as a function of concentration of gellan gum determined by the thermal scanning rheological measurement are shown in Figure 1. As illustrated in this figure, states of gellan gum solutions are dependent on the temperature and concentration, and are classified into three; (1)Sol-I (gellan gum molecules take a single coil conformation); (2)Sol-II (gellan gum molecules take a helix conformation but these ordered structure could not lead to the gel); (3) Gel (the number of aggregates of helices exceeds a critical value on cooling and could form a gel). In both Sol-I and Sol-II states, the mechanical spectra showed a liquid-like behaviour,31-35 while those in the gel state tended toward that of weak gel behaviour.32-35 Gellan gum alone 40-
0 1
30-
M
10-
0
0
1 1 2 3 4 5 Gellan Conc. I w t YO
Temperature Tch(0) at which the loss modulus G" Increased steeply, and the cross-Over temperature of G and G" TBe( 0 )for gellan gum aqueous solutions during COOUW! as a function of concentrationof gellan gum from 0 to 5%.
Figures 2(a)-(d)show the frequency dependence of the storage modulus G' and the loss modulus G" for I%, 22, 336, 3.5% gellan gum aqueous solutions at various temperatures. The data are shifted along both the horizontal and the vertical axes by shift factors a and b, respectively to avoid any overlapping. These mechanical spectra were investigated around both Tchand T, as shown i n Figure 1. In all the cases (Figures 2(a)-(d)), G' and G" at temperatures higher than T, were significantly small, however, both moduli markedly increased on cooling below T, which substantiated the results by osmotic pressure,25 light scattering,26 and SAX96 that the disordered structure was a singlecoiled chain and the ordered structure was a double-helix. At any temperature on cooling from T, the viscoelastic behaviour of a 1%gellan gum solution (Figure 2(a)) is typical of a dilute polymer solution with G'
Polysaccharide Gelation
115
indicated that a 1%gellan gum solution could not form a gel on cooling down even to O'C. Frequency dependence of moduli for this solution at 25'C tended to G'--02, G"--o, which is a characteristic feature of dilute polymer solutions.37 However, for a 1%solution at 15,5 or O'C, both moduli of this solution slightly deviated from this behaviour.3Z 38 Similar phenomena were observed for a fairly concentrated gellan gum solution (5%)at 6O'C,39 although gellan gum
b
d
Po d
+I -1
-
A +? A - u l lo-$o-5la+laSl~ZlW11@
-2
101 I d 108
Id
I@ 1 4
104 l ~
'
'
'
'
'
-2
'
/ '/... -
8"
'
'
'
~ ~ e l ~ ' l ~ ~ ~ s ~lo1 ~ 2I 1 d ~ 1 1 @I@
/rad*s-l
Frequency dependence Of the storage modulus G and the loss modulus G"for 1%. 2%. 2.5% 3% and 35% gelIan gun aqueous solutions at various temperatures. The data are shifted along both the horizontal and the vertical axes by shift factors a and b. respectively to avoid the overlapping. Shift factor;a. b For a 2% gellan gum solution (Figure 2 (b)), T, was observed around 9.4"C, so that the mechanical spectrum at 5°C showed weak gel behaviour. For a 3% gellan gum solution (Figure 2(c)) in the temperature range from TQ to TW, the mechanical spectra were typical of a concentrated polymer solution31-35 which showed a cross-over of both moduli at a certain frequency, and the cross-over point shifted to lower frequencies with decreasing temperature. For a 3%
116
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
solution at 30T, G' and G" were equal over the accessible frequency range, and the slope of double logarithmic plots of both moduli against frequency was approximately 0.5, as would be expected for a critical gel.38 For 3%gellan gum solutions at temperatures lower than T , G' was larger than G" with little frequency-dependence throughout the accessible frequency range, which was classified rheologically as that of a weak ge1.32-35 The gelation mechanism for a 3.5% gellan gum solution showed complicated behaviour. As shown in Figure 1,T, and T, were observed at almost the same temperature (42 "C), so that the mechanical spectra for this solution showed a drastic change around the transition temperature. This solution at temperature slightly higher than the transition temperature showed a liquid-like behaviour, thus, it behaved as a dilute polymer solution at 45T, and. it behaved as a concentrated polymer solution at 43°C. However, at 42T, the behaviour became strikingly different; G' was much larger than G" throughout the experimentally-accessiblefrequency range and both moduli were essentially independent of frequency, as would be expected for an elastic ge1.32-35 These behaviours seem to be close to a true gel, so that these systems could be seen as almost perfect networks. Therefore, the T critical state for a 3.5% gellan gum solution could not be obtained around , Judging from these mechanical spectral change depending on temperature, gellan gum systems were classified into three types rheologically depending on the concentration of gellan gum. The first type (a) includes gellan gum solution at lower concentration (<2%) which showed only a coil-helix transition and could not form a gel (Sol-I-Sol-II). The second type (b) includes the concentrated gellan gum solution (2%-3.5%) in which the coil-helix transition and the sol-gel transition occurred separately (Sol-I-Sol-II-+Gel). The third type (c) includes gellan gum solutions at higher concentrations (>ca.3.5%) in which two transitions occurred concurrently (Sol-I-Gel). As illustrated in Figure 2, gellan gum gels formed in the third type seem to be obviously different from those in the second type. In DSC measurements, for gellan gum solutions of higher concentrations (>4.5%), an endothermic peak on heating split into two peaks, while the cooling curve showed only one main sharp exothermic peak (data not shown). This observation coincides with the result observed by the thermal scanning rheological measurement; the very concentrated gellan gum solutions (>4.5%) showed thermal hysteresis (data not shown). From rheological and Dsc results, more than two kinds of junction zones with different thermal stabilities seem to be formed above 4.5% gellan gum concentrations. It has been observed in the tilting tube method40 that over 4-5% gellan gum solutions formed a turbid gel while below 4% gellan gum solutions formed a transparent gel at any temperature (
Polysaccharide Gelation
117
for 1, 2, 2.5 and 3% gellan gum solutions at various temperatures. The flow behaviour was investigated around Tch as shown in Figure 1. In all the cases (Figures 3(a)-(d)), the gellan gum solutions showed flow behaviour close to Newtonian flow at temperatures higher than T* however, they drastically changed to shear-shinning behaviour at temperatures lower than T, The range of the Newtonian plateau at low shear rate gradually became narrower and the viscosity became more shear-rate-dependent with decreasing temperature. Intermolecular entanglements disrupted by the imposed deformation resulted i n new interactions at low shear rates, however, the rate of disruption becomes greater than the rate of formation of new entanglements, the onset of shear thinning may occur.41 The extent of re-entanglement decreaseswith increasing shear rate, so that the viscosity of the solution may gradually decrease.41 As shown in Figure 3, the steady-shear viscosity measurement indicates that gellan gum solutions tend to show more shear-shinning behaviour with the conformational change from coil to helix because the helix may be more easily oriented along the shear flow than the coil. The range of the Newtonian plateau at low shear rates gradually becomes narrower with development of an ordered structure of the gellan gum solution. 1%GelIan gum
I
6. 10, 16-C
c
2%G e h n Lnm
I
.. 2.6%GelIan sum
shear rate I 8 -3 Shear-rate dependence of the steady-shear viscosity for 1, 2, 25 and 3% gellan gum soluuons at various temperatures.
118
Gums and Siabilisersfor the Food Indusiry 10
In the analyses of SAXS,36 in terms of a molecular model, 18repeating units (72 glucose units) with the straight structure is sufficient to explain the light scattering function, because 72 residues correspond to 39nm according to the molecular weight per unit contour length MLvalue used for the single stranded chain. This value (39nm) seems to be close to the Kuhn segment length of 34nm estimated roughly from the persistence length of 17nm.26 Therefore, the model that the chains behave as a random coil over the contour length of Kuhn length might be reasonable, which fairly coincided with the results obtained Ly SAXS.36 Both the dielectric42 and IHNMR30 measurements have suggested that water is more strongly influenced by gellan gum in the coiled state compared to that i n the helical state, in other words, the interaction between gellan gum molecules was less in the coiled state than in the helical state. This observation could be understood better by the fact that gellan gum molecules behave as a fairly stiff chain even in the disordered state, and gellan gum molecules in the disordered state expand in solution.26 In our rheological results (Figure 3), in any cases, the flow behaviour of gellan gum solution showed a drastic change accompanying the conformational change of gellan gum molecules. Solutions of hyaluronate which take a coil conformation show a pronounced shear-thinning behaviour at any temperature,*3 however, gellan gum solutions in the coiled state showed a flow behaviour much closer to Newtonian flow, even at high concentrations such as a 3% (Figure 3(d)). Graessley and Segal44 have suggested that for polystyrene as the molecular weight becomes greater, the shear-thinning behaviour of solutions becomes more conspicuous. Gellan gum, gellan gum molecules even in the coiled conformation are relatively elongated, so that molecules are less entangled with comparison to flexible molecules. However, the single stranded coil of the substantial stiffness could smoothly associate with another one for the formation of double helices, therefore, the flow behaviour of gellan gum solution seems to show a drastic change over the coil-helix transition. 3.2 Effects of salt on the sol-gel transition
3.2.1 Effects of monovalent cations
In the presence of monovalent cations, for all the cases, the cooling DSC curves showed a sharp exothermic peak shifting to progressively higher temperatures with increasing concentration of added salt. However, during heating, the endothermic peak gradually developed bimodal character and eventually split into multiple peaks upon addition of a certain concentration of salt, and then the endothermic enthalpy at higher temperature gradually increased with increasing In the presence of further sufficient salt concentration of the added salt. (1OOmM KCI or CsCl),a single endothermic peak was observed at markedly higher temperature than the exothermic peak, so the thermal hysteresis was far more modified. The order of effectiveness of the monovalent cations i n
119
Polysaccharide Gelarion
promoting ordered structures (W>K+>Na+>Li+) was correlated with the dynamic hydration number.45 This order is also in good agreement with the effectiveness of the cation in increasing the cross-sectional radius of gyration R , estimated by SAXS.36 The dependence of the exothermic and endothermic peak temperatures for a 1%gellan gum solution on the salt concentration showed a common tendency. At lower concentration of salt, the differences between two transition temperatures were very small, so that the thermal hysteresis was almost negligible. However, upon addition of a certain concentration of salt, the heating Dsc curves began to split into multiple peaks and the thermal hysteresis was observed, and then the thermal hysteresis was gradually modified with increasing concentration of the added salt. Figure 4 shows the exothermic peak temperature T, in the cooling Dsc curves and endothermic peak temperature T,in the heating DSC curves (a), and T, and T, determined by the thermal scanning rheological measurement (b)for 1%gellan gum solutions as a function of the concentration of the added LiCl. As illustrated in Figure 4, the comparison of the rheological results with the DSC results indicated that the onset of detectable splitting in heating DSCarves (the onset of observation of significant thermal hysteresis) was in good agreement with the onset of the observation of two transitions occurring at the same temperature by the rheological measurement. (a) 1% Gellan with LiCl
6o
(b) l%GeUanwithLiCl
6o
mm ""r --iy I rn
I
A
50
:
1
B
I
50
1
C
I
Sol-I
u
Sol-II
'30
H%2 0
-
'"1 0
0
,
10
,
,,;,
,
,
0 20
40 60 80 1 0 0 1 2 0 1 4 0 160
LiCl Conc. / mmol-1
-I
0
20 40 60 80 1 0 0 1 2 0 1 4 0 1 6 0
LiCl Conc. / mmol-1 - I
-4
Exothermic peak temperature T, (0) in the cooling DSC curves and endothermic peak temperature T, (e) In the heating DSC curves (a).the temperature Tch (A) at which G" increased steeply and the cross-over temperature of G and G"Tsg(A)durlng cooling @) for 1% gellan gum solutions as a function of the concentration of the added LEI. Cooling and heating rate :0.5"C Imin.
Figures 5(a)-(h) show the temperature dependence of G' and G" during the cooling and heating processes for 1%gellan gum solutions containing LiCl of
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
120
various concentrations, and cooling and heating DSC curves for these solutions. Upon addition of 20LiCl (Figures 4(a) and (e)), G" for a 1%gellan gum solution showed one step-like change during both cooling and heating, which was attributed to the coil-helix transition, as mentioned above. The cooling or heating Dsc curve for this solution (Figures 4(a) and (e)) showed a single exothermic or endothermic peak, and this transition temperature almost coincided with T, in the thermal scanning rheology. Upon addition of 40mM LiCl (Figures 4@) and (f)), G" for a 1%solution showed two step-like changes, and the lower temperature process at which G' and G" showed a cross-over was attributed to the sol-gel transition, as mentioned before. On further addition of LiCl, both T, and T,, shifted to higher temperatures (Figures 5(c) and (g)), however the shift in Tegwas far more pronounced than that in T,. In the presence of SOmMLiU, eventually, T, and Tsg occurred concurrently, so that during the cooling process, this solution showed one step-like change of G" and the single exothermic peak was observed (Figure 5(d)),which involved both the coil-helix transition and sol-gel transition. However, the thermal behaviour of this solution in the heating process was quite different from that of solutions with less LiU; G" showed a two step-like change and the endothermic peaks split into two peaks, which would be expected for a significant thermal hysteresis (Figure 5(h)). The endothermic peak at lower temperature corresponded with the single exothermic peak in the cooling DSC curve, however, the other one i n the heating DSC curve did not have any corresponding exothermic peak in the cooling process. UILIcl
ML a i
5oLicl
o
104
10
ao
so
40
50
eo
10
10
SO
40
5O
M)
Temperature / 'C
Fieme5 Temperature dependence of G and G" during cooling and heating processes for 1% gellan gum solutions containing LiCl of various concentrations, and cooling and heating DSC curves for these solutions. (0)G'. (amCooling and heating; rate; 05°CImln.
Polysaccharide Gelation
121
From the rheological and DSC results, the gelation mechanism for gellan gum solutions could be schematically explained as follows. At higher temperatures, gellan gum molecules exist as a single coil (Sol-I) (Figure 4(b)). On cooling, gellan gum chains associate by the formation of double helices to form a certain ordered structure, which contributes to the steepest increase of G" in the thermal scanning rheology and the main exothermic peak observed in the cooling DSC curves. However, this ordered structure, in itself, does not lead to formation of a gel network (Sol-II)(Figure4(b)). Gelation occurs with subsequent aggregation of these helices mediated by cations, so that the sol-gel transition appeared at temperatures lower than the coil-helix transition, which corresponds to the cross-over of G' and G" in thermal scanning rheology and the other small exothermic peak observed in the cooling DSC curves (Figure 5(b),(c)). Gellan gum systems, in which two transitions occurred separately (Sol-IOSol-IIOGel) (Figure 4(b):region B), do not show thermal hysteresis in cooling and heating processes (thermoreversible). Thus, the temperature at which T, or T, is observed during the cooling process is almost the same as that during the heating process. The difference between T, and Tsg decreased with increasing concentration of the added salt (or gellan gum). Eventually, for gellan gum i n the presence of sufficient salt or in sufficiently concentrated gellan gum solution, the individual helices are formed and immediately the aggregation of helices occurred in the cooling process so that T, and T, are observed at almost the same temperature (cooliig)(Figure 4@):region C). Moreover, these systems involve the thermally-stable junction zones formed by fairly aggregated helices, so that these solutions show a large thermal hysteresis (Figure 4(a)). The observations by both IHNMR and CD30 essentially coincided with our rheological results. A 1%gellan gum solution with 20mM KCl showed no thermal hysteresis while a gellan gum solution with 40mM KQ or 80mM KCl showed a large thermal hysteresis and showed the two step-like changes on heating. Judging from our results, a 1%gellan gum solution with 20mM KCl was classified as a system in which two transitions occurred separately (Sol40 Sol-IIOGel), although the difference between T, and T, was small (data not shown). However, 1%gellan gum solutions with over 35mM KQ were classified as a system which diredly changed sol to gel around the transition temperature on cooling (data not shown). In the presence of sufficient salt, more than two kinds of junction zones may be formed because G" showed the two step-liie changes during heating and the heating DSC curves showed two endothermic peaks as shown in Figure 5(h). Therefore, during heating the ordinary double helices melted around the main peak temperature and then thermally-stable aggregated helices (mediated by specific binding of cations) melted at further higher temperatures. In the rheological result, the gel structure seems to remain until the thermally-stable junction zones melt, as will be discussed later. Our rheological and Dsc results also indicated that a 1% gellan gum solution with 40mM KCl or 80mM KCl showed the two step-like
122
Gums and Stabilisersfor the Food Industry 10
change and these transition temperatures, and these peak temperatures in the heating Dsc curves and the rheological transition temperatures precisely coincided with the transition temperatures observed by both lHNMR and CD.30 In CD measurements,30 a gellan gum solution with 80mM KCI showed a large delay of the recovery in [ 6 hO2but this value completely returned to the original one during heating up to 70 ' C. However, in IHNMRP01HT2 did not show the temperature dependence during heating and could not return to the original value nevertheless the double helices seemed to disappear in CD. lHNMR results30 have suggested that in the presence of sufficient K+,the hydrogen bonds within gellan gum molecules, which are formed on cooling, are much stronger, so that the stable hydrogen bonds remain even in the random-coils. This might be explained by the possibility that in the presence of sufficient KCl, the specific interaction between K+ and hydroxyl groups in gellan gum molecules occurs i n addition to the effect of electrostatic shielding. Morris et al.46#47 have found the specific interactions of K+ with K-carrageenan by NMR. As for the present sample, in the presence of sufficient KCI, the transition temperature on cooling observed by1HNMR30 was slightly higher than that by CDPO which indicated the hydrogen bonds were formed in random-coils before the formation of doublehelices. Generally, the effect of salt on gelation is explained by the fact that salt influences the conformation and association of polymers through their effects on the solvent properties of water, but potassium ions could directly promote association of carrageenan because of their ion size.45 Therefore, both specific and non-specific ion effects seem to influence the gelation of gellan gum, and especially in the presence of sufficient salt, the specific ion effect becomes more important. Manning et al.14 have shown the schematic representation of a model on the basis of DSC, optical rotation and rheological studies of gellan in the presence of sodium chloride, and a similar model has been suggested by Morris and G ~ n n i n g . ~ 8 They14 have suggested that the lower temperature peak may be caused by the melting of unaggregated helices while the higher temperature peak may be caused by the melting of aggregated helices. Our interpretation may be essentially consistent with theirs,14 however, this interpretation is not applicable to the gelation mechanism of gellan gum in the presence of divalent cation, as will be discussed later. 3.2.2. Effects of divalent cations
Figures 6 (a)-(f) show the temperature dependence of G' and G" during cooling and heating processes for 1%gellan gum solutions containing Cac1, of various concentrations, and cooling and heating DSC curves for these solutions. The thermal behaviour in the presence of divalent cations was virtually different from that in the presence of monovalent cations. On addition of CaQ of a fairly low concentration (lmM), the cross-over of G and G" was observed around 5°C during the cooling process (Figure 6 (a)), which indicated that this
PolysaccharideGelation
123
system could form a gel on cooling. However, the clear exothermic peak corresponding to the sol-gel transition could not be observed in the cooling DSC curve. Durii the heating process, the temperature at which a steep decrease of G" was observed was slightly higher than that of the main endothermic peak observed in the heating DSC curve, moreover, many small peaks were observed at higher temperatures than the main peak (Figure 6(d)). On addition of only 1.2mMCaC4, G" showed one step-like change around 35°C on cooling, and then