Handbook of Magnetic Materials, Volume 3 North-Holland Publishing Company, 1982 Edited by: E.P Wohlfarth ISBN: 978-0-444-86378-2
by kmno4
PREFACE This H a n d b o o k on the Properties of Magnetically Ordered Substances, Ferromagnetic Materials, is intended as a comprehensive work of reference and textbook at the same time. As such it aims to encompass the achievements both of earlier compilations of tables and of earlier monographs. In fact, one aim of those who have helped to prepare this work has been to produce a worthy successor to Bozorth's classical and monumental book on Ferromagnetism, published some 30 years ago. This older book contained a mass of information, some of which is still valuable and which has been used very widely as a work of reference. It also contained in its text a remarkably broad coverage of the scientific and technological background. One man can no longer prepare a work of this nature and the only possibility was to produce several edited volumes containing review articles. The authors of these articles were intended to be those who are still active in research and development and sufficiently devoted to their calling and to their fellow scientists and technologists to be prepared to engage in the heavy tasks facing them. The reader and user of the H a n d b o o k will have to judge as to the success of the choice made. Each author had before him the task of producing a description of material properties in graphical and tabular form in a broad background of discussion of the physics, chemistry, metallurgy, structure and, to a lesser extent, engineering aspects of these properties. In this way, it was hoped to produce the required combined comprehensive work of reference and textbook. The success of the work will be judged perhaps more on the former than on the latter aspect. Ferromagnetic materials are used in remarkably many technological fields, but those engaged on research and development in this fascinating subject often feel themselves as if in strife for superiority against an opposition based on other physical phenomena such as semiconductivity. Let the present H a n d b o o k be a suitable and effective weapon in this strife! The publication of Volumes 1 and 2 took place in 1980 and produced entirely satisfactory results. Many of the articles have already been widely quoted in the scientific literature as giving authoritative accounts of the modern status of the
vi
PREFACE
subject. One book reviewer paid us the compliment of calling the work a champion although with the proviso that the remaining two volumes be published within a reasonable time. The present Volume 3 goes halfway towards this event and contains articles on a variety of subjects. There is a certain degree o f coherence in the topics treated here but this i s not ideal due to the somewhat random arrival of articles. The same will be the case for the remaining Volume 4 as such, although this will then complete the work so as to finally produce a fully coherent account of all aspects of this subject. Three of the authors of Volume 3 are members of the Philips Research Laboratories, Eindhoven and, as already noted in the Preface to Volumes 1 and 2, this organization has been of immense help in making this enterprise possible. The North-Holland Publishing Company has continued to bring its professionalism to bear on this project and Dr. W. Montgomery, in particular, has been of the greatest help with Volume 3. Finally, I would like to thank all the authors of Volume 3 for their co-operation, with the profoundest hope that those of Volume 4 will shortly do likewise! E.P. Wohlfarth
Imperial College
TABLE OF CONTENTS Preface
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
v
T a b l e of C o n t e n t s
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
vii
List of C o n t r i b u t o r s
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
ix
1. M a g n e t i s m a n d M a g n e t i c M a t e r i a l s : H i s t o r i c a l D e v e l o p m e n t s a n d P r e s e n t R o l e in I n d u s t r y a n d T e c h n o l o g y U. E N Z . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. P e r m a n e n t M a g n e t s ; T h e o r y H. Z I J L S T R A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. T h e S t r u c t u r e a n d P r o p e r t i e s of A l n i c o P e r m a n e n t M a g n e t A l l o y s R.A. McCURRIE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. O x i d e S p i n e l s S. K R U P I C K A a n d P. N O V A K . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. F u n d a m e n t a l P r o p e r t i e s of H e x a g o n a l F e r r i t e s with M a g n e t o p l u m b i t e Structure H. K O J I M A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. P r o p e r t i e s of F e r r o x p l a n a - T y p e H e x a g o n a l F e r r i t e s M. S U G I M O T O . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7. H a r d F e r r i t e s a n d P l a s t o f e r r i t e s H. S T J i d ~ L E I N . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8. S u l p h o s p i n e l s R.P. V A N S T A P E L E . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9. T r a n s p o r t P r o p e r t i e s of F e r r o m a g n e t s I.A. CAMPBELL and A. FERT . . . . . . . . . . . .
1 37 107 189
305 393 441 603 747
Author Index
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
805
Subject Index
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
833
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
845
Materials Index
vii
chapter 1 MAGNETISM AND MAGNETIC MATERIALS" HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENTS AND PRESENT ROLE IN INDUSTRY AND TECHNOLOGY
U. ENZ Philips Research Laboratories Eindhoven The Netherlands
Ferromagnetic Materials, Vol. 3 Edited by E.P. Wohlfarth © North-Holland Publishing Company, 1982
CONTENTS Introduction 1. F r o m l o d e s t o n e to f e r r i t e : a s u r v e y of t h e h i s t o r y of m a g n e t i s m . . . . . . . . . 2. T h e r o l e of m a g n e t i s m in p r e s e n t - d a y t e c h n o l o g y a n d i n d u s t r y . . . . . . . . . . 3. D e v e l o p m e n t o f s o m e classes of m a g n e t i c m a t e r i a l s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. I r o n - s i l i c o n a l l o y s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. F e r r i t e s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. G a r n e t s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4. P e r m a n e n t m a g n e t s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. T r e n d s in m a g n e t i s m r e s e a r c h a n d t e c h n o l o g y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1. M a g n e t i s m r e s e a r c h b e t w e e n p h y s i c s , c h e m i s t r y a n d e l e c t r o n i c s . . . . . . . . 4.2. T r e n d s in a p p l i e d m a g n e t i s m . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3. O u t l o o k a n d a c k n o w l e d g e m e n t . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . : References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
3 3 6 10 10 12 20 24 30 30 31 34 35
Introduction
In this contribution we attempt to trace a few main developments of the history of magnetism and to give an account of the present role of ferromagnetic materials in industry and technology. The treatment of a subject as broad as the present one must necessarily be limited and incomplete; nevertheless, we may give an impression how the large body of knowledge on magnetism accumulated in the past, and how important it is at present. The first section gives a short sketch of some early historical developments and inventions. Such a flash back to history may be useful to place the m o d e r n activities and achievements in a wider context. The next section deals with the role of magnetism and magnetic materials in modern technology, especially in the context of power generation and distribution, telecommunication and data storage. Some statistical figures on the economic significance of magnetic materials are included. The third-section gives a somewhat more detailed account of the development lines~i~f a few selected classes of materials, whereas in the last section an attempt is made to indicate the trends in applied magnetism.
1. F r o m lodestone to ferrite: a survey of the history of m a g n e t i s m
The notion of magnetism dates back to the Ancient World, where magnets were known in the form of lodestone, consisting of the ore magnetite. The name of the ore, and hence that of the whole science of magnetism, is said to be derived from the G r e e k province of Magnesia in Thessaly, where magnetite was found as a natural mineral. It seems very likely that the early observers were fascinated by the attractive and repulsive force between lodestones. Thales of Miletus (624-547 BC) reports that the interaction at a distance between magnets was known before 800 BC. Another, probably m o r e apocryphal account is due to Pliny the Elder, who ascribes the n a m e magnet to its discoverer, the shepherd Magnes "the nails of whose shoes and the tip of whose staff stuck fast in a magnetic field while he pastored his flocks". From such modest beginnings grew the science of magnetism, which may be represented as a tree on whose growing trunk new shoots and branches continuously appeared (see fig. 1). The trunk represents the mag-
4
u. ENZ
netic materials such as metals, alloys or oxides, because history shows that the use and study of materials have been the main sources of discoveries and progress. T h e new branches which developed in the course of time f o r m e d scientific fields in themselves. A brief account of s o m e of these d e v e l o p m e n t s is given in the following pages (Encyclopedia Britannica: Magnetism; see also, Mattis (1965)). Magnets f o u n d their first application in compasses, which were m a d e from a lodestone b u o y a n t on a disc of cork. W e k n o w that the compass was used by Vikings and, of course, by Columbus, but the art of navigation guided by compasses m a y be much older. T h e invention is p r o b a b l y of Italian or A r a b i c origin. T h e earliest extant E u r o p e a n reference to the compass is attributed to the English scholar A l e x a n d e r N e c k a m (died 1217). T h e influence of this simple device was far-reaching in every respect: it m a d e it possible to navigate on the high seas. T h e principle of the compass has r e m a i n e d unchanged, the device is still in full use. T h e invention of the compass is characteristic of m a n y later developments in magnetism: seemingly marginal effects turned out to be very i m p o r t a n t and to have had a t r e m e n d o u s impact on later technological developments. A milestone in the history of magnetism was William Gilbert's De Magnete, electro- high neutroncritical materials spin structures magnetic fields diffr, phenom metals semi- amorphous micromagnetism radiation , magn. M6ssbauer para- alloys cond. mogn. J spin I domains I inductio~ moment ;NI~R ;mogn. gl~ss ~'
;sp;e'Ig° ne i
ro~
I
I I bb,es
leomac netism stellar magnetism
F?Curi~
I Jalloys
I L oxides
Maxwell
~
~-
~
I
Faraday,
A~ere,1 8 0 O r ~ ert' tedr2[lmeognete 1269 Peregrinus de Maricourt 1200 Neckarn describes compass
J J J 800 b ~ r l d
: magnesian stones
Fig. 1. Development of the modern branches of magnetism from a common root. A few names and dates are indicated to mark some of the most crucial moments in this development. The modern fields of magnetism, ranging from basic entities like magnetic fields and particles to more complex ensembles, emanate in quite a straightforward way from a few basic branches. A central position is reserved to the various classes of materials, reflecting the central position of materials in magnetism research.
MAGNETISM AND MAGNETIC MATERIALS
5
Magneticisque Corporibus, et de Magno Magnete Tellure (1600, "Concerning Magnetism, Magnetic Bodies and the Great Magnet Earth") which summarized all the available knowledge of magnetism up to that time, notably that of Petrus Peregrinus de Maricour (1269). In addition Gilbert describes his own experiments: he measured the direction of the magnetic field and its strength around spheres of magnetite with the aid of small compass needles. For this purpose he introduced notions like magnetic poles and lines of force. Gilbert found that the distribution of the magnetic field on the surface of his sphere or terella ("microworld") was much like that of the earth as a whole and concluded that the earth is a giant magnet with its two magnetic poles situated in regions near the geographical poles. This observation made him the founder of geomagnetism. Gilbert's work not only strongly influenced the later development of magnetism, but also contributed to the development of the idea of universal gravitation: it was believed, for some period of time before Newton, that the planets were held in their orbits by magnetic forces in some form or other. Gilbert also discovered that lodestone, when heated to bright red heat, loses its magnetic properties, but regains them on cooling. In this way he anticipated the existence of the Curie temperature. For more than two centuries after Gilbert little progress was made in the understanding of magnetism, and its origin remained a mystery. The early nineteenth century marked the beginning of a series of major contributions. Hans Christian Orsted discovered in 1820 that an electric current flowing in a wire affected a nearby magnet. Andr6 Marie Amp6re established quantitative laws of the magnetic force between electric currents and demonstrated the equivalence of the field of a bar magnet and that of a current-carrying coil. Michael Faraday discovered magnetic induction in 1831, his most celebrated achievement, and introduced the concept of the magnetic field as an independent physical entity. Guided by his feeling for symmetry and harmony he suspected that an influence of magnetic fields on electric conduction should exist as a counterpart to Orsted's magnetic action of currents. After a long period of unsuccessful experiments with static fields and stationary magnets, he discovered the induction effects of changing fields and moving magnets. This line of investigation culminated in Maxwell's equations, establishing the synthesis between electric and magnetic fields. Progress in the understanding of the microscopic origin of magnetism was initiated by Amp6re, who suggested that internal electric currents circulating on a molecular scale were responsible for the magnetic moment of a ferromagnetic material. Amp6re's hypothesis enabled Wilhelm Eduard Weber to explain how a substance may be in an unmagnetized state when the molecular magnets point in random directions, and how they are oriented by the action of an external field. This idea also explained the occurrence of saturation of a magnetic material, a state reached when all elementary magnets are oriented parallel to the applied field. This line of thinking led to the studies of Pierre Curie and Paul Langevin on paramagnetic substances, and also to the work of Pierre Weiss (1907) on ferromagnetic materials. Pierre Curie described the paramagnetic substances as an en-
6
u. ENZ
semble of uncoupled elementary magnetic dipoles subjected to thermal agitation, the orienting action of the external field being counteracted by the thermal agitation. Such a description was also applied successfully to ferromagnetic materials at temperatures higher than the Curie temperature. The modern discipline of critical phenomena is, for the time being, the end point of this branch. Weiss, in turn, postulated the existence of a hypothetical internal magnetic field of great strength in ferromagnets, resulting in a spontaneous magnetization even in the absence of an external field. Amongst his other contributions is the notion of a magnetic domain, a small saturated region inside a ferromagnet, and the notion of domain walls. Weiss's work can be viewed as the starting point of the branch leading to the modern disciplines of micromagnetism and domain theory, and also as the point of departure of N6el's work on interactions, leading to the fields of ferrimagnetism and antiferromagnetism, including the actual disciplines of spin structures and spin glasses. A branch of its own, the study of the magnetic aspects of particles is perhaps a less obvious offshoot from the common source, but it nevertheless forms a very important part of magnetism. Indeed fields like electron spin resonance and nuclear spin resonance, M6ssbauer spectroscopy and structure analysis by neutron diffraction are at the same time indispensable tools and important disciplines of magnetism. The modern disciplines of magnetism as represented at the top of fig. 1 range from the fundamental entities like fields and particles on the left to more complex systems on the right. Critical phenomena, magnetic phase diagrams and spin structures in various materials including spin glasses are important fields of modern research. The classical discipline of domains, domain walls and micromagnetism is still being actively studied, and has even received renewed attention stimulated by the modern investigations on bubbles. The various materials appear in the centre of the three, thus confirming their central role in magnetism. The few materials that are named represent just a very small fraction of the magnetic materials known at the present time. The study of the magnetic properties of materials is the subject of the present handbook, and the present article is intended to give a general introduction to the remaining chapters of this work.
2. The role of magnetism in present-day technology and industry Having outlined the early developments of magnetism as well as the subsequent accumulation of knowledge on magnetic phenomena and materials, we now turn to the description of the role of magnetism in present-day technology and industry. Magnetic materials occupy a key position in many essential areas of interest to society. The most important of these, which depend in an essential way on magnetic materials, are the generation and distribution of electrical power, the storage and processing of information, and of course communication in all its forms, including telephony, radio and television. Apart from these major fields, many other industrial machines and devices, including motors for numerous applications, depend on magnetic materials or magnetic forces. Figure 2 gives a
MAGNETISM AND MAGNETIC MATERIALS
7
Industrally and economicallyrelwant fields of application of matlneticmaterial= Function
Physicaleffect, important parameters
power generators, power transformers magnetic induction, recording heads, medium frequency transformers, inductors, particle accelerator electric motors, small motors with permanentmagnets
Material classes
high induction material, silicon-iron sheet, oriented sheet
Permalloysheet, amorphousmetals, ferrites I ~
[ magnetomotive ~ior~teS~linduction
permanentmagnets, Ticonal, Ferroxdure~ SmCo-magnets
latching devices, levitation (trains) television,radio, resonantband pass filters
self-induction, high Q
ferrites
unidirectional microwavedevices gyrators
ferromagnetic resonance, low damping
garnet crystals, hexagonal ferrites
storageof digital information in cores, plated wires
squarehysteresis loop, fast switching time
l smallparticlesof
massstorage in magnetic tapes, magnetic discs and floppy discs
information storage in magneto-optic stores compact digital massstorage
I square-loop ferrites, plated wires, permalloy
remanenceand coerciveforce of small particles and thin magnetic films
1
3'- Fe203, CrO2, Fe
thin metallic films, Co-based
high Faradayand Kerr effect
amorphous films, MnBi, GdFe
stability and mobility of bubbles
monocrystalline garnet films
Fig. 2. Industrially and economically relevant fields of application of magnetic materials. T h e central column lists the basic physical effects together with the important parameters. T h e left-hand column gives the useful functions and the right-hand one the classes of materials most commonly used to fulfil these functions. The arrows indicate the various interrelations.
8
u. ENZ
survey of the use of magnetic materials in various areas of application. The left-hand column shows the type of application or the function realized with the aid of magnetism. The central column lists the various physical effects and the parameters most relevant to a specific application. The right-hand column displays the classes of materials used to accomplish the various functions. The variety of physical effects, applications and materials is impressive, even in this necessarily incomplete survey. Most of the applications are based on magnetic induction, magnetomotive forces or the specific properties of the hysteresis loop such as squareness or coercive field, but other effects like ferromagnetic resonance or the Faraday effect also find their applications. The useful materials are in general restricted to those classes which are ferromagnetic or ferrimagnetic at room temperature and which possess a sizable saturation magnetization. Although magnetic materials are indispensable for the listed and for many other applications, their role remains to some extent hidden because the ultimate practical function is not associated with magnetism. The public at large is often unaware of the role of magnetism in everyday life. Occasionally one gets the impression that the same holds even for some professionals! The economic impact of magnetism is very considerable. Jacobs (1969) estimates the total value of processed magnetic material produced in the United States in 1967 at about 680 million dollars, which represents about 0.1% of the American gross national product. In 1976 the corresponding amount was 2140 million dollars (Luborsky et al. 1978, Snyderman 1977). These figures apply to magnetic materials as such and do not take into account that magnetic materials are nearly always components of more elaborate products such as electric motors, transformers, loudspeakers, microwave isolators or computer memories. Jacobs estimates that for such products a "multiplication factor" of the order of 15 is appropriate, so that the total economic impact of magnetism was of the order of 1.5% of the American gross national product in 1969. This figure has not changed much since, and probably applies to other economies as well. In table 1 some economic data on magnetic materials are given, split up into various classes of materials to be discussed below. The largest quantities of magnetic material enter the field of electric power generation and distribution, a field which is historically the major application of magnetism. For this function the aim is to reach the highest possible saturation magnetization and the lowest possible total loss, properties which are best met in iron-based alloys such as silicon-iron sheet and grain-oriented sheet. More recently amorphous metals have become competitive for some specific applications in this field. Although power generation and distribution have now achieved the status of well-established and mature technologies, progress towards reduced losses is still going on. As a result the amount of power handled by a transformer of constant size has increased continuously, resulting in the last 40 years in a tenfold increase in power-handling performance. A second area of great and rapidly increasing importance is that of magnetic materials for information storage and processing. The amount of material involved in these fields is much smaller, but their economical significance is larger
MAGNETISM AND MAGNETIC MATERIALS TABLE 1 Annual magnetic materials market in millions of dollars (not corrected for inflation) 196%1968 US Electrical steel Magnetic recording tapes Magnetic discs and drums Soft ferrites (communication, entertainment and professional) Square-loop ferrites Permanent magnets
World (17
1976-1977 US
World 07
180(27
4400)
180(27
45007
1300(3/
100(~)
900(37
3000(37
110(2) 55(2) 55(27
130 70(67
535(4)
1 5 0 (3,6)
1979-1980 US
World 07
148 57(7) 170(5)
600(4) 960(5)
(1/Western world including Japan. (2)Jacobs (1969). (3)Luborski et al. (1978). (4)De Bruyn and Verlinde (1980). (s)Hornsveld (1980). (6)Snijderman (1977). (7)Electronics, 3, Jan. 1980.
than that of electrical steels. T h e leading e c o n o m i c position was taken over by information storage about ten years ago. A m o n g s t information-storing materials, magnetic tapes and discs are the most i m p o r t a n t groups. T a p e and disc techniques are both based on the same physical principle, the association of a bit of information with the direction of the magnetization in a small area of the material. T h e merits of this storage principle are simplicity, p e r m a n e n c e (or non-volatility) of information, and a high information density per unit surface of the (film-like) material. T h e progress of these techniques has been entirely directed towards higher information densities and thus towards lower prices per bit of information, and further progress in this direction is expected. Square-loop ferrites or bubble d o m a i n m e m o r i e s are also based on the association of inf o r m a t i o n with the direction of the magnetization in the material, in the f o r m e r case in a small sintered core, in the latter case in a single domain, a bubble, which is able to m o v e in a single-crystal film. Magnetic cores have been the basic m e t h o d of information storage in c o m p u t e r s for m o r e than 25 years, but have now r e a c h e d a level of saturation, which is i m p o s e d by the limitations of handling ever smaller (and faster) cores. T h e bubble d o m a i n memories, on the o t h e r hand, are in full d e v e l o p m e n t and m a y find a p e r m a n e n t position in the hierarchy of information storage. N u m e r o u s other magnetic information storage principles have been p r o p o s e d and realized, including thin permalloy films and permalloyplated wire, but their total e c o n o m i c impact has r e m a i n e d small. C o m m u n i c a t i o n is the third i m p o r t a n t field of application of magnetic materials. This field includes telephony, radio and television broadcasting and receivers, and radar, all of which techniques use m e d i u m to very high frequencies. D u e to their
10
u. ENZ
high resistivity and consequently low eddy-current losses, ferrites are the best suited materials for communication. In telephony the medium frequency channel filters are based on resonant circuits using high-O ferrite cores, one of the first applications of ferrites and the standard technique till now. Every broadcast receiver contains many ferrite parts, such as inductors, deflection units, line transformers and antenna rods.
3. Development of some classes of magnetic materials
In this section the development of a few selected classes of magnetic materials is described. These case histories relate to iron-silicon alloys, ferrites, garnets and permanent magnets. The emphasis will be on the chronology of events, the improvement of performance and the technical relevance.
3.1. Iron-silicon alloys Electrical grade steel is the magnetic material produced in the largest quantities of all; hundreds of thousands of tons are annually needed by the electrical industry. The bulk of this material is used for the generation and distribution of electrical energy and for motors. High magnetic induction and low losses are of prime importance in these applications. Alloys of iron and silicon meet the above conditions well and therefore take a prominent position with the product category of electrical steels. Here we confine ourselves to some historical remarks and to give some recent figures on silicon-iron alloys. The starting point of the development of silicon-iron alloys of suitable quality is marked by the work of Barrett et al. (1900). These authors found that the addition of about 3% of silicon in iron increased the electrical resistance and reduced the coercive force as compared to unalloyed iron. The slight reduction in saturation magnetization due to silicon was far outweighted by the improvement in the other properties. Some years later, in 1903, the industrial production of these alloys started in Germany and in the U n i t e d States. The promotion and subsequent improvement of this technique is, to a considerable extent, the merit of Gumlich and Goerens (1912). The material was used in the form of hot rolled polycrystalline sheets having random grain orientation. Due to the higher permeability and the reduced hysteresis and eddy-current losses, iron-silicon sheet replaced the conventional materials within a few years, in spite of the initial difficulties of production and the higher price, and was used in this form for about three decades. However, these random oriented materials were still imperfect because saturation was only reached by applying magnetic fields well above the coercive field, which limits the useful maximum induction to about 10 kG. The hysteresis loops of single crystals or of well oriented samples, on the other hand, are nearly rectangular. Fields slightly higher than the coercive field are therefore sufficient to drive the core close to saturation. The useful maximum induction is thus higher,
MAGNETISM AND MAGNETIC MATERIALS
ll
reaching 15 to 1 7 k G (1.5 to 1.7Wb/m 2) (fig. 3). An ideal transformer would consist of single crystal sheets oriented such that a closed rectangular flux path along [100] directions, the preferential directions, results. Progress towards this goal was achieved by Goss (1935) who showed that grain oriented sheets can be obtained by certain cold rolling and annealing procedures. This so called Goss texture is characterized by crystallites having their [110] planes oriented parallel to the plane of the sheet, with common [100] direction in this plane. The magnetic properties of such materials are characterized by coercive fields around 0.1 Oe and maximum permeabilities up to 70.000 (fig. 3). Data obtained by Williams and Shockley (1949) on a oriented single crystal frame of high purily 3.85% silicon iron with limbs parallel to [100] directions are included in fig. 3 for comparison. The coercive field of this single crystal was as low as 0.028 Oe (2.2 A/m) and the maximum permeability exceeded 10 6. Grain orientation contributed to a further decrease of the magnetic core losses. Loss figures dropped to about 0.6 Watt per kg at 60 cycles and an induction of 10 kG (1 Wb/m 2) for commercial grade oriented silicon-iron sheet. An additional advantage was that maximum induction up to 17 kG (1.7 Wb/m 2) became practical. Another more recent step towards higher quality is related to even more perfect crystalline orientation combined with the introduction of a controlled tensile stress in the sheet (Taguchi et al. 1974). The composition of the material remained unchanged i.e. the silicon content is still around 3%. The tensile stress is introduced by a surface coating consisting of a glass film and an inorganic film applied on both surfaces of the sheet. This procedure leads, by magnetoelastic
Magnetization (kG) 18
Br.=17 kG
~kO
t
'°r i/ill'
l I
-0.2
0
0.2
I
I
I
0.L
0.6
Magnetic field (Oe)
Fig. 3. Static hysteresis loops of grain oriented silicon-iron sheet (Goss texture). For comparison the loop of a single crystal (broken line, Williams and Shockley 1949) is shown (after Tehble and Craik 1969).
12
U. E N Z
interactions, to improved properties of the hysteresis loop and thus to still lower magnetic losses. The improvement of the quality of electrical grade steel since 1880 is shown in fig. 4. In a time span of 100 years the core loss decreased from 8 W/kg to about 0.4 W/kg for an induction of 10 k G and a frequency of 60 Hz. The innovations described above clearly show up as marked steps: the introduction of silicon-iron alloys after 1900, causing the loss figure to drop from 8 to 2 W/kg and also the use of grain-oriented material in the late thirties. The latter innovation enabled higher induction ratings: new branches with maximum induction of 15 kG and 1 7 k G appear after 1940. The dramatic increase of the power handled by a transformer of equal size is also shown. co. e toss ( W a t t / k g )
transforrnator power { MVA)
6 4.
17 kG 15kG
2
1000
! 10 kG
1 0.8 0.6
I ' /t
o.4
/ 0.2
50
//
If
188o
1900
1920
194.0
I
/
I I
1960
I
1980
2000 year
Fig. 4. Core loss of electrical grade steel (after Luborsky et al. 1978). Since 1880 the core loss decreased from 8 W / k g to 0 . 4 W / k g at an induction of 1 0 k G and a frequency of 6 0 H z . T h e introduction of textured sheet around 1940 led to the use of higher m a x i m u m induction (up to 17 k G (1.7 Wb/m2)). T h e broken line shows the increase in power handled by a transformer of constant size.
3.2. Ferrites Ferrites are mixed oxides of the general chemical composition MeOFe203, where Me represents a divalent metal ion such as Ni, Mn or Zn. The crystallographic structure of ferrites, and also that of the closely related ore magnetite (FeOFe203) is the spinel structure. Ferrites can therefore be seen as direct descendants of magnetite (see fig. 1). Many simple or mixed ferrites are magnetic at room temperature, but due to their ferrimagnetic character the saturation magnetization is only a fraction of that of iron. The outstanding property of ferrites, which makes them suitable for many applications, is their high electrical resistivity as compared to that of metals. Their specific resistivity ranges from 102 to 101° f~ cm, which is up to 15 orders of magnitude higher than that of iron. In most high frequency applications of ferrites eddy currents are therefore absent or negligibly small, whereas at such frequencies eddy currents are the main drawback of
MAGNETISM A N D M A G N E T I C M A T E R I A L S
13
metals, even in laminated form. Such intrinsic properties make the ferrites indispensable materials in telecommunications and in the electronics industry, where frequencies in the range of 109 to 1011Hz have to be handled. The potential usefulness of magnetic oxides for high frequency applications was realized as early as 1909 by S. Hilpert, who investigated the magnetic properties Of various oxides including some simple ferrites. In 1915 the crystallographic structure of ferrites, which had remained unknown until then, was determined independently by W.H. Bragg in England and S. Nishikawa in Japan. Contributions to the understanding of the chemistry of ferrites were also made by Forestier (1928) in France. All of this early work remained without a direct follow-up; at that time there was apparently no technological need yet for such materials. The situation remained unchanged until 1933, when Snoek of the Philips Research Laboratories started a systematic investigation (Snoek 1936) into the magnetic properties of oxides. In the same period of time ferrites were independently investigated by Takai (1937) in Japan. Snoek's working hypothesis in his search for high permeability materials was to look for cubic oxides which, for symmetry reasons, could be expected to have a low crystalline anisotropy. Simultaneously he aimed at finding materials with low magnetostriction values to minimize the adverse effects of the unavoidable internal stresses present in polycrystalline materials. Snoek's approach turned out to be fruitful: he found suitable materials in the form of mixed spinels of the type (MeZn)Fe204, where Me is a metal of the group Cu, Mg, Ni or Mn. Permeabilities up to 4000 were reached (Snoek 1947). Snoek's achievement may again have remained of more academic interest, but this time there was a clear demand for magnetic materials from the telephone industry, which felt the need to improve the load coils of their long-distance lines and to use bandpass filters based on low-loss magnetic materials. Ferrite inductors proved to be well suited for these purposes, and so ferrites and telephone technology developed in close cooperation. Six (1952) was the inventive and leading promotor of this development, which did not, however, proceed without a great deal of effort from chemists, physicists and electrical engineers, who cooperated in achieving adequate material properties and practical technical designs. Before 1948, when most of this work was done, little was known about the cause of the low saturation magnetization of ferrites or of the origin of their anisotropy. This changed when N6el (1948), who had already explained the behaviour of antiferromagnets, introduced his concept of partially compensated antiferromagnetism, which he called ferrimagnetism. The essential point of N6el's explanation is the antiparallel orientation of the spins of the ions in the two sublattices, octahedral and tetrahedral, of the spinel structure. N6el's model revealed directly the cause of the low saturation of ferrites. The work of Verwey and Heilman (1947) on the distribution of the various ions over these lattice sites was undoubtedly of great help. N6el's model was directly verified by neutron diffraction work done by Shull et al. (1951) only a few years after the invention of this powerful method of analysis. Further proof was derived from a study of the temperature dependence of the saturation magnetization in some spinel ferrites
14
u. ENZ
(Gorter et al. 1953). A n o t h e r fundamental mechanism, ferromagnetic resonance, was extensively studied in ferrites (Snoek 1947) shortly after its discovery by Griffiths (1946). The main difficulty encountered in the early use of ferrites was their high level of magnetic losses and disaccommodation. It was found that even in the absence of eddy currents there were still appreciable residual losses, which prevented the design of high quality resonance circuits. It is now well known that quite a large number of electronic and ionic relaxation processes can cause magnetic aftereffects in magnetic materials subjected to alternating fields. These processes are the main cause of the losses in magnetic cores. Snoek (1947) tried to minimize these after-effects by controlling the presence of relaxing ions with the aid of special sintering procedures in suitable oxidizing or reducing atmospheres. A n important insight concerning the use of ferrites in resonant filter circuits was that the relevant quantity to be considered is the ratio between the loss factor tan6 and the initial permeability/x rather than tan~ as such. This ratio can be controlled by introducing air gaps in the magnetic circuits. Therefore a high initial permeability is as important as a low loss factor. A reduced loss level in the ferrite material made it possible to reduce the physical size of the inductors, a successful development vizualized in fig. 5. Ferrite cores having about equal quality factors are shown in a sequence ranging from 1946 to 1974. The volume of the inductors was reduced by a factor of 32 during this time span. Compared with an air coil of
Fig. 5. Development of pot cores between 1946 and 1974. Reduction of the loss level of ferrite materials led to the reduction of the physical size of these components, all of which fulfil the same technical function. The quality factor Q of the ferrite components remained, as indicated, about constant during this time span. An air coil and a Fernico coil of much lower quality, representing the state of the art in 1936 and 1939, are shown for comparison. The total reduction in volume is nearly a factor of 400.
MAGNETISM AND MAGNETIC MATERIALS
15
much lower quality representing the state of the art in 1936, the reduction in volume is nearly a factor of 400. Similar, albeit less spectacular progress was also made in another ferrite application, i.e., that in power transformers where a high saturation induction and low hysteresis losses are of principal importance (see fig. 6). The total losses are shown to be reduced by a factor of three, while the maximum usable inductance nearly doubled in the indicated period of time. This type of material, a high saturation MnZn ferrite, is at present finding increasing application in switched-mode power supplies for small to medium power levels. loss P (Watt cm-3)
\
0.2
Induction 8 (kG)
"°"3c'3c5 ...---tt
I
"~..3c8 2
0.1
J
1950
L
i
1960
1970
0
1980 year
Fig. 6. Reduction of loss factor and increase of usable maximum induction of ferrite cores for power applications from 1950 to 1980.
A new and rather unexpected application of ferrites emerged with the invention of the gyrator, a non-reciprocal network element. The impedance of signals passing through such an element in the forward direction differs from that in the backward direction. The gyrator was conceived by Tellegen (1948) on theoretical grounds as a possible but not yet realized network element. Hogan (1952) was the first to realize a non-reciprocal microwave device consisting of a ferrite-loaded waveguide. The physical effect on which the device is based is analogous to the well-known Faraday effect, i.e., the rotation of the plane of polarization of a light wave passing through a magnetized body. One form of the non-reciprocal device thus consists of a circular wave-guide carrying a central ferrite rod magnetized along its axis. If the rotation of the plane of polarization of the microwave equals 45 ° and coupling in or out also occurs with an offset angle of 45 ° the microwaves pass through the device in the forward direction while propagation in the backward direction is suppressed. A similar device functions as a microwave switch (see fig. 7) controlled by the bias field. Other devices based on this principle, which have found wide application in microwave technology, are circulators, resonance isolators and power limiters. The discovery that some polycrystalline spinel ferrites can have a rectangular hysteresis loop and therefore can be used as computer memory elements was of paramount importance for computer technology. Until 1970 nearly all main-frame
16
U. E N Z
Rectangular waveguide Cylindrical waveguide'-k~" ~ IX Rectangular ~ ~..,/', waveguide -x~.r~.~ ~ ,.~1"~,, !/
". L~ ~ I t ', , "':."l'-'~4"-"
]
I I I L___ I
Fig. 7. Microwave switch based on the rotation of the plane of polarization of microwaves propagating along the magnetized ferrite rod in the central cylindrical part of the device.
Fig. 8. Core array of a ferrite core m e m o r y in 3D organization showing word, bit and sense lines. T h e ferrite core matrix is shown together with the preceding storage technology, based on electron tubes, and the succeeding technology, the semiconductor memory.
MAGNETISM AND MAGNETIC MATERIALS
17
computer memories consisted of ferrite cores, so that it is fair to say that the whole computer development was closely connected with the development of the ferrite core memory. A r o u n d 1968 the yearly,world production of ferrite cores was about 2 x 10 l° cores (Jacobs 1969). J.W. Forrester and W.N. Papion, both at that time at MIT, are generally considered to be the inventors of the principle of coincident current selection of a core (Forrester 1951). The first square-loop cores consisted of nickel-iron alloys, the switching speed of which suffered from an inherent limitation due to eddy currents. Both Forrester and Rajchman (1952) suggested the use of non-metallic cores to avoid this shortcoming. At about the same time, Albers-Schoenberg (1954) observed the square-loop properties of some ferrite compositions. A link with system requirements was immediately made. This revolutionary challenge materialized in Whirlwind I, the first experimental computer based on a ferrite core memory, built at the Lincoln laboratory at MIT in 1953. Figure 8 shows a wired ferrite core matrix consisting of 1024 ferrite cores. A stack of such matrix planes forms the memory. Two individual cores are shown in fig. 9. Ferrites also p l a y e d an unexpected role in particle accelerators constructed to study elementary particles (Brockman et al. 1969). The operation of these large
Fig. 9. Two individual ferrite memory cores (20 mil and 14 mil) are shown on the wings of a fly.
18
U. E N Z
machines is based on accelerating units consisting of large transformers designed as resonance cavities. These elements accelerate the charged particles (protons) by feeding energy into the particle beam circulating in the machine. The stations act in such a way that the particle beam represents the secondary winding of the transformers. During one acceleration sequence the increasing frequency has to be followed by controlling the self-induction of the core of the transformer with the aid of a bias field. Again, the demand for low losses, especially low eddy current losses, favoured ferrites above other materials for this application, and so ferrites entered this field as essential elements and played a continued role in the subsequent stages of the development of these machines. Figure 10 shows an acceleration unit of the alternating gradient synchrotron in Brookhaven. The synchrotron contains 12 of such cavities, and each unit Contains about 500 kg of ferrite.
Fig. 10. Accelerator unit of the alternating gradient synchrotron at Brookhaven, containing a hollow cylindrical ferrite core assembled from a large number of rings. The total weight of the core is about 500 kg (after Brockman et al. 1969).
Apart from these few examples of specific implementations of ferrites we recall that the bulk of ferrite material is used in telecommunication and consumer applications, with roughly equal turnover in these two fields. The main consumer products are television and radio sets, in which such parts as line transformers, deflection coils, tuners and rod antennas contain ferrite materials. About 0.7 kg of ferrite enters a black-and-white television set, and about 2 kg a colour set. Figure 11 gives an impression of the diversity of ferrite products for such applications.
MAGNETISM AND MAGNETIC MATERIALS
19
Fig. 11. Various ferrite componentsas used in radio and televisionsets.
Hand in hand with the implementation of ferrites and with the tailoring and perfection of their technically relevant parameters, the investigation of their fundamental properties continued, resulting in a considerable deepening of the understanding of their chemical and physical properties. The main lines of investigation concerned: (a) crystal structures, chemical miscibility regions and preferential site occupation of the various ions in the spinel lattice; (b) the experimental determination of data relating to spontaneous magnetization, Curie temperature, anisotropy and magnetostriction constants; (c) micromagnetic properties such as domain walls and domain configuration in polycrysta!line and monocrystalline materials; (d) the dynamics of the magnetization process, and damping and resonance phenomena; and (e) the theoretical description, discussion and understanding of these properties in atomic terms, i.e., the arrangement of the ionic magnetic moments in sublattices, the quantum mechanics of magnetic interactions between localized moments, the spin-orbit interaction and dipole-dipole interaction as a cause of anisotropy. These methods of studying the properties of ferrites have acquired ~he status of a scientific standard, i.e., a paradigm, which has since been applied to many other materials. Garnets and hexagonal ferrites are examples of materials of industrial importance discovered and investigated along such lines. Other compounds of as yet more academic interest include sulphospinels and rare-earth chalcogenides.
20
U. ENZ
3.3. Garnets
The prototype of the family of garnets is the compound Mn3A12Si3012, a mineral and esteemed gemstone occurring in nature. The crystal structure of garnets is cubic with three different types of sublattices occupied by the three metals of the above compound. The garnets existing in nature often contain other ions as well and are in most cases non-magnetic. It is interesting to note that it was precisely the ferrimagnetic properties, discovered by Pauthenet (1956) and Bertaut et al. (1956) of some synthetic rare-earth iron garnets that attracted attention and opened up a new field of research in magnetism. Since then, a wealth of scientific and technological information on garnets has been produced. For more than two decades, publications on garnets have been appearing at a rate of about 200 papers a year, so that garnets and especially yttrium iron garnet (YIG), are now amongst the best known magnetic materials. One may agree with J.H. van Vleck who compared the role of Y I G for magneticians to that of the fruit fly to geneticists. Pioneering work on the chemical, crystallographic and magnetic properties of garnet was done by Geller et al. (1957), while Pauthenet (1957) investigated the magnetism of mixed rare-earth iron garnets, Re3FesO12, some of which were found to have compensation temperatures of the magnetization. These findings demonstrated directly their ferrimagnetic character and indicated that the magnetic moment of the rare-earth sublattice is oriented oppositely to the resulting moment of the two iron sublattices. The total magnetization of garnets is therefore relatively low as compared with that of magnetic metals or ferrites. The Curie temperatures, dominated by the iron-iron interaction, are of the order of 300°C, reflecting the same type of interaction mechanisms as those active in ferrites. Because the magnetization of garnets is lower than that of ferrites, garnets have not found bulk applications competing with ferrites, such as in transformers, coils, etc. One of the outstanding properties of YIG, which was discovered by Spencer et al. (1956) and Dillon (1957) shortly after the publication of the first papers on garnets, is its extremely low ferromagnetic resonance linewidth. Values of the linewidth A H of some oersteds were then measured, but subsequent improvements of crystal quality and purity yielded figures as low as A H = 0 . 1 0 e (8 A/m) at 10 MHz for carefully polished samples of Y I G (LeCraw et al. 1958). These exceptional resonance properties made Y I G very useful as a microwave device material, with loss figures one or two orders of magnitude lower than those of corresponding spinel ferrites. Moreover, Y I G also proved to have acoustic losses lower than quartz, thus opening up prospects for magneto-acoustic devices such as adjustable delay lines. Small amounts of rare-earth ions substituted into Y I G produced a dramatic increase in both anisotropy and linewidths. Such substituted materials were ideal objects on which to study the fundamentals of anisotropy (Kittel 1959) and relaxation processes (Dillon 1962, Teale et al. 1962), studies which contributed considerably to progress in the understanding of these mechanisms.
MAGNETISM AND MAGNETIC MATERIALS
21
Garnets are also outstanding in their optical properties: Y I G shows a low optical absorption in the range of visible light, so that layers up to several microns thick are transparent. With the aid of the magneto-optical Faraday effect, domain structures can be directly observed (Dillon 1958). Y I G m o r e o v e r exhibits a "window" of extremely low optical absorption in the infrared region. Optical absorption coefficients as low as c~ = 0.03 cm -1 for wavelengths between A = 1.2 ~ m and A = 4.4 p~m have been observed. The Faraday rotation of some garnets is large enough to m a k e the material suitable for magneto-optical devices such as light modulators and magneto-optical memories. In particular, garnets containing bismuth show a very high specific Faraday rotation, e.g., 0 = 3°/~m at A = 0.5 ~m for Y2.6Bi0.4Fe4Oa2 (Robertson et al. 1973). Bismuth-doped garnets have also proved to be suitable for use as fast switching magneto-optical display components (Hill et al. 1978). The non-magnetic yttrium aluminium garnet (YAG), was found to be an excellent laser host (Geusic et al. 1964). Garnets, especially Si-doped Y I G , are also interesting for their photomagnetic properties, i.e., the light-induced change of magnetic properties as a consequence of a light-stimulated redistribution of electrons or Fe 2+ ions (see Teale et al. 1967, Enz et al. 1971). Even greater prominence was achieved by the granets in their application as the leading magnetic bubble device material. Two basic contributions, both m a d e by Bobeck, opened up this new field. The first was the invention of the principle of high-density information storage with the aid of bubble domains (Bobeck 1967); the second was his observation of a growth-induced uniaxial anisotropy energy in garnets (Bobeck et al. 1970). B o b e c k ' s basic idea was to associate a bit of information, a digital one or zero, with the presence or absence of a bubble at some defined location and time. Bubbles are cylindrical domains of reversed magnetization occurring in nearly magnetized thin films having a sufficiently large uniaxial anisotropy. The dimensions of bubbles are mainly determined by the length l = trw/47rM2s, a material constant depending on the specific Bloch wall energy O-w and the saturation magnetization Ms. By controlling the magnetization of the garnet material the bubble diameters can be adjusted in a wide range from submicron size to tens of microns. The first observation of stable bubbles, which were in fact submicron bubbles, was made by Kooy et al. in 1960 in the hexagonal material BaFe120~9, a material with a rather high magnetization and a large uniaxial anisotropy. D u e to the microscopic dimensions of the bubbles, the packing density of the bubbles and thus the density of information can be very high; values of 1 0 6 bits cm -2 have been achieved, and densities higher than 1 0 7 bits c m -2 a r e considered to be attainable in the future. An extensive review of the physical and chemical properties of garnets has been given by Wang (1973) and a survey of garnet materials for bubble devices has been published by Nielsen (1976). The advent of bubble domain devices stimulated work in the field of crystal growth, both of bulk garnet crystals and of thin monocrystalline films grown by liquid phase epitaxy, known as the L P E method. Flux-grown bulk crystals were
22
U. E N Z
first prepared by Remeika in 1956, mainly for the purpose of studying fundamental properties. This art developed rapidly and the growth of large crystals of high perfection was finally mastered (Tolksdorf et al. 1978). L P E growth experienced a similar evolution, starting with the work of Shick et al. 1971, who grew films suitable for bubble devices. This method of preparation, which is an extension of flux growth, has now become the standard method of growing bubble device films. The growth procedure is as follows: a carefully polished wafer of a non-magnetic garnet crystal is immersed in a liquid consisting of a flux and the dissolved garnet. If the lattice misfit is controlled, the magnetic garnet grows isostructurally and without dislocations on the substrate. The films made in this way meet high standards of quality and reproducibility: composition and film thickness can be controlled within narrow limits and the remaining level of defects is low, which is reflected in the low values of the coercive fields achieved. Figure 12 shows bubbles and stripe domains in a Y G d T m epitaxial garnet film as observed with the aid of the Faraday effect. Figure 13 shows an overlay Y-bar structure of a shift register as processed on a garnet film (Bobeck and Della Torre 1975). A second scientific discipline which was greatly stimulated by the success of bubbles is that of the dynamics of domain walls and bubbles. Domain wall motion
U •
•
•
• •
•
•
•
•
..
i •
•
Fig. 12. Bubbles and stripe domains in a Y G d T m epitaxial garnet film 7 Ixm thick. The bias field is near to the run-out field. The bubble diameter is about 7 ixm (after Bobeck and Della Torre 1975).
MAGNETISM AND MAGNETIC MATERIALS
23
Fig. 13. Bubbles moving in a Y-bar pattern of a bubble shift register. Some propagation loops and the bubble generator (heavy black square) are shown (after Bobeck and Della Torre 1975).
has been studied in the past in the context of magnetization processes of magnetic bodies caused by domain wall displacements. A detailed understanding of the dynamic wall properties had not been reached along such lines owing to the extreme complexity of the process. This situation changed when perfect monocrystalline layers of garnets for bubble devices became available, which made it possible to study the motion of domain walls and bubbles by direct optical observation. As a result of this development, the body of experimental data on wall dynamics has greatly increased and the theoretical understanding of the mechanisms involved has deepened considerably. Amongst the new results is the insight that there is an upper limit to the velocity of a domain wall, a velocity limit which also marks a limit to the speed, i.e., the data rate of bubble devices. Extended reviews on the subject of wall and bubble dynamics have been published by Malozemoff and Slonczewski (1980) and also by de Leeuw et al. (1980).
24
U. ENZ
3.4. Permanent magnets
Permanent magnets, i.e., the magnesian stones, marked the beginning of magnetism. It is interesting to observe that, at present, permanent magnets are still being investigated, improved and increasingly applied. They are essential to modern life as components of a wide variety of electromechanical and electronic devices. It has been estimated that the average home contains more than fifty permanent magnets and every car uses an average about eight of them. The applications of permanent magnets range from loudspeakers, small electric motors and generators, door latches and toys, to ore separators, water filters, electric watches and microwave tubes. The function of a permanent magnet in these and other applications is to generate a magnetic field in an air gap of a magnet system. The air gap may either be fixed to accommodate moving electric conductors which exert external forces, a function performed by loudspeakers and electric motors, or it may be variable as it is in movable armatures on which the magnet exerts the force. The latter application is found in door latches, relays, telephone sets, magnetic levitation and contactless couplings between rotating shafts. Another typical application of permanent magnets is the alignment of an object by exerting a magnetic torque on it, as in a compass. A special application is found in electron tubes where permanent magnets are used for controlling the orbits of electron beams or for focussing them. Table 2 shows a number of functions performed by permanent magnets together with the corresponding applications. The four functions described cover the main applications of permanent magnets; they include the conversion of electrical into mechanical energy and vice versa, and the exertion of mechanical forces on material bodies and on moving charge carriers. Figures 14 and 15 give an impression of two of the most common applications of permanent magnets, the loudspeaker and the small motor (after Zijlstra 1976). The early development of permanent magnet materials proceeded entirely by trial and error. Nevertheless 100 years ago bar and horseshoe magnets made from TABLE 2 Typical functions and applications of permanent magnets with some examples of machines, devices and components (after Zijlstra 1974) Function
Application
Conversion of electrical into mechanical energy and vice versa
Small electric motors, dynamos, loudspeakers, microphones, eddy-current brakes, speedometers, magnetos
Exerting a force on a ferromagnetically soft body
Relays, couplings, bearings, clutches, magnetic chucks and clamps, separators (extraction of iron impurities, concentration of ores)
Alignment with respect to a field
Positioning mechanisms (e.g. stepping motors), compasses, some ammeters
Exerting a force on moving charge carriers
Magnetrons, travelling-wave tubes, some cathode-ray tubes, Hall plate
MAGNETISM AND MAGNETIC MATERIALS
25
Fig. 14. Cut-away view of a loudspeaker containing a Ferroxdure ring.
Fig. 15. Cut-away view of a windscreen wiper. The stator field is provided by two Ferroxdure segments.
26
U. ENZ
carbon steel were well known and widely used. Since then an unparallelled development has taken place; new permanent magnet materials have been discovered and the existing ones improved. The foundations for the scientific understanding of permanent magnets have also been laid in this period. The relevant figure of merit expressing the quality of a permanent magnet is its maximum energy product (BH).... This figure describes the ability of a permanent magnet to withstand the influence of a counteracting magnetic field. Moreover the energy product is a measure of the useful magnetic flux that can be produced by the magnet in a given volume. Figure 16 shows the magnetic flux density B plotted as a function of the magnetic field H, i.e., the well-known hysteresis loop. The shaded area represents the (BH)max product; the optimum working point of the loop is that which defines the largest area. As an illustration of the achievements of the past, the energy product is plotted in fig. 17 as a function of time, starting in 1880. Since then, the (BH)max values have increased by a factor of more than 100. This great achievement was not realized by improving a single material, but rather by the discovery of new classes of material. Each new finding was followed by a period of technological improvement, which in turn was followed by a new discovery. The figure gives the top values reached in any year. The sequence starts with carbon steels and tungsten steels at the end of the last century and is continued with cobalt-containing steels around 1920. A major advance in magnetic materials was made in 1932, when the development of the Alnico magnets started with Mishima's AINiFe alloy (Mishima 1932). In the illustration the various members of this family are indicated as Tic II, Tic G (Jonas et al. 1941) etc. The coercive force of Alnico magnets was essentially doubled as compared with earlier materials; these magnets were the first to be truly p e r m a n e n t under adverse conditions such as stray fields, shock and elevated temperature. The magnetic and mechanical hardness of the Alnico alloy is due to
Fig. 16. Hysteresis loop showing the optimum working point of a permanent magnet. The hatched rectangle represents the maximum energy product of the material.
MAGNETISM AND MAGNETIC MATERIALS
27
(BHlrnax (MG Oe) 100
// / /
50
/
20
(Sin, Pr) Cos (.1/ Sm C o 5 / ~
10 5 // 2
//
/
oFxd 330
tlTic lI
//M is~j.I, el* FxdlO0
1
0.5 0.2
,/ I W-steel C-steel
0.1 i
i
i
i
/
I
1880 1900 1920 19~0 1960 1980 = year Fig. 17. Development of the maximum energy products of permanent magnets between 1880 and 1980. Most data are due to Van den Broek and Stuijts (1977). 7
a thermal treatment leading to the precipitation of a second phase in a finely dispersed form. This development culminated with Ticonal XX, an Alnico alloy hardened in the presence of a magnetic field which leads to the precipitation of oriented second-phase particles of elongated shape (fig. 18). The maximum energy product reached was about 11 M G O e (90 kJm -3) (Fast a n d r e Jong 19591)/. The next breakthrough in the development of high energy product materials was made with rare-earth transition metal compounds. The systematic investigation of the physical and magnetic properties of these alloys and compounds started around 1960 at Bell Laboratories (Nesbitt et al. 1961). However it was Strnat who realized the potential of these compounds for high energy-product magnets and vigorously promoted their development (Strnat et al. 1966). In 1969, Das of the Raytheon Company announced that he had made a magnet having an energy product of 20 M G O e (160 kJm -3) by sintering SmCos. Even higher values, up to 35 M G O e (280 kJm-3), were recently reported to have been obtained in a related material of the formula (RE)2(CoFe)17 (Wheeler report, 1979)*. This quasi-binary intermetallic phase was again prepared by sintering. It is interesting * Wheeler Associates, Inc., 1979, Rare Earth-Cobalt permanent magnets, Elizabethtown, Kentucky, USA.
28
U. ENZ
Fig. 18. Micrograph of Ticonal XX (after De Vos, thesis, Delft, 1966). to note in fig. 17, that the energy product, plotted as a function of time, follows an approximately linear dependence throughout the period reported. The material quoted last yields the top value of the energy product reached up till now. It is possible to reach still higher values of (BH)max? Rathenau (1974) discussed this 1 2 question in detail and showed that the limit of (BH)max is given by ~Bs for any material, provided the coercive field and the anisotropy can be made strong enough. The saturation magnetization of iron or iron cobalt alloys is high enough to allow for a further increase of (BH)max by a factor of four. In addition to the materials discussed, which follow a straight line, fig. 17 also contains materials indicated as Fxd 100 and Fxd 300. The energy products of these materials fall clearly below the general trend. They are typical representatives of the family of low cost permanent magnet materials having a medium energy product, the hexagonal oxides. If we plot the price per unit energy product of various materials (fig. 19) we observe another systematic correlation, the continuous progress made in improving the economy of permanent magnets. In this plot the hexagonal oxides occupy a leading position and are the end point of a long development. The importance of ferrimagnetic hexagonal oxides for permanent magnets was first pointed out in 1952 by Went et al. A detailed account of these magnetically hard materials, called Ferroxdure, and their history has been given recently by Van den Broek and Stuijts (1977). The opinion expressed at the time of discovery was that these new materials were of great economic importance. That opinion has been fully confirmed: the total world production of magnetically hard f e r r i t e s - which, in composition and crystal structure, all belong
MAGNETISM A N D M A G N E T I C M A T E R I A L S
l
100
29
T S'mCo5
50 price per unit of energy 20
' P t Co I Tic xx /
C-steel
•___. W.-steel •~ ,~,~ Co-steel
10 Q
%
5
Tic ff X
2
Tic
1
0.5
Tic GG
\NPZFxd 100 \ \ \ \ ~ F x d 330 \
0.2 0.1
1800 '90 1900 '10
'20
'30
%0 '50
'60 '70 '80 '9 2 = year
0
Fig. 19. Price per unit of energy product (after Rathenau 1974). to the same g r o u p - is now estimated at about 100,000 tonnes a year (1980), with a value of some 400 million dollars. Figure 20 shows how these ferrites have acquired an ever increasing share of the world production of p e r m a n e n t magnets, measured in tonnes per annum. C o m p a r e d with other materials for p e r m a n e n t magnets, Ferroxdure is characterized by an exceptionally high coercivity, combined with a r e m a n e n c e which, though not very high, is valuable for practical purposes. With such a material it became possible to produce magnets of shapes such that would have almost completely demagnetized themselves if made of a different material. Typical shapes were flat ring magnets, magnetized perpendicular to the plane of the ring, or transversely magnetized rods with m a n y north and south poles closely adjacent to each other. Ferroxdure is also highly resistant to external demagnetizing fields, as encountered in D C motors, for example. These novel properties were exploited on a large scale, e.g., for making flat loudspeakers and compact D C motors (see figs. 14 and 15). The great economic success of Ferroxdure is due in the first place, however, to the low price per unit of available magnetic energy (fig. 19). The material is therefore mainly used not so much as a technical i m p r o v e m e n t but m o r e as a substitute for m o r e expensive components, such as Ticonal magnets in loudspeakers or stator coils of windscreen-wiper motors. Ferroxdure is inexpensive because it does not contain any rare material such as nickel or cobalt, and it is relatively easy to manufacture: it is only necessary to "mix a few cheap oxides" and to " b a k e them to the right shape". Finally, Ferroxdure - an oxide - has a high electrical resistivity, so that there are
30
U. ENZ
)roduction (kt) 100
tot 20
10
//~lloys
5
I
L
I
I
I
I
L
I
1900 '10 '20 '30 '/.0 '50 '60 '70 '80 year Fig. 20. Estimate of the world production of permanent magnets (after Rathenau 1974). hardly any eddy-current losses. This is an important advantage in radio-frequency applications and also in certain types of electric motors. A disadvantage is the relatively high temperature coefficient of the remanence and the coercivity. This makes the material less suitable for certain professional applications. In 1954 the material was substantially improved by orienting the crystallites (Stuijts et al. 1954, 1955). In isotropic material the magnetic moments of the crystallites, in zero field after saturation, are randomly distributed over a hemisphere. In anisotropic Ferroxdure, on the other hand, which is the material now most widely used, the c-axes and hence the moments after saturation are approximately parallel. Consequently the remanence is about twice as great and (BH)max is about four times higher. At the time it was a surprise that the attempts to produce crystal-oriented Ferroxdure were so successful. It was feared, quite reasonably, that the orientation of the crystallites, achieved with much difficulty in the compacted product, would be lost during sintering. The result exceeded all expectations: the texture was not only preserved but was even greatly improved.
4. Trends in magnetism research and technology
4.1. Magnetism research between physics, chemistry and electronics On studying the ways to progress in magnetism one observes that magnetism research has an interdisciplinary character and depends in an essential way on the
MAGNETISM AND MAGNETIC MATERIALS
31
cooperation of scientists and engineers working in fields quite different from each other. The various disciplines relevant for magnetism research range from fundamental theoretical physics through chemistry to electric and electronic engineering. The cooperation of these disciplines is of such a type that the preparation and chemical or crystallographical study of new materials may stimulate physical work, or alternatively that the discovery of a physical effect in one material may stimulate the search for other classes of material showing analogous effects. A similar mutual relation is observed between engineering efforts facing material problems and basic material studies concentrating on the relevant critical parameters. Last but not least, and most commonly recognized, the discovery of new materials or of new physical effects may stimulate new engineering applications. This special character of magnetism research has consequences for the organization of research and development laboratories. An organizational structure concentrating the various disciplines in multidisciplinary units or groups is probably the most adequate form. Indeed, the study of the case histories of m a j o r innovations seems to show that those research laboratories which have such an organization are most likely to produce outstanding results. This applies equally for university laboratories organized as "material centers", government institutes and industrial laboratories. In the last category the multidisciplinary approach has an even stronger weight as engineering aspects are included. Examples of research successes obtained by the cooperation of experts in different disciplines are easily at hand. In fact some have already been described in this chapter. The early industrialization of ferrites is an example in which chemistry, crystallography, physics and telecommunication technology were equally indispensable for success. Other examples are the discovery of garnets, the invention of the gyrator or the development of bubble devices. In all cases the study of materials played a central role. Some remarks concerning the growth of magnetism research may be made here. Before the second world war only few laboratories were active in this field, and with some famous exceptions, magnetism was not usually a subject of research at universities. Since then the n u m b e r of laboratories occupied with magnetism has largely increased. In particular many new or existing university institutes turned to studies in this field. As a consequence the n u m b e r of investigations has much increased and more and more detailed studies of materials were made. The industrial laboratories, on the other hand, did not much grow in n u m b e r or size, so that their share, especially concerning fundamental studies, has diminished. The few government or national research centers which were traditionally active in magnetism research maintained their position and continued their important role.
4.2. Trends in applied magnetism In this outlook into the future of applied magnetism we try to indicate some trends which are discernable at this m o m e n t and which will probably be of importance for some time to come (see, Wijn 1976). We have seen that magnetic materials
32
U. ENZ
are used for a wide variety of different functions such as transformers, various types of inductive elements or m e m o r y cores. C o m m o n to most of these applications is the use of materials prepared separately in bulk form. The processed material is then assembled into the magnetic device as a separate part. Since some years, however, there seems to be a tendency towards the use of materials as an integrated part of the device. In m a n y cases the magnetic material is present in the form of a thin layer, having a monocrystalline, polycrystalline or amorphous structure. The layers are often structured or shaped by methods known from integrated circuit technology. The purpose is to reach a miniaturization also in the case of magnetic materials and to give it its shape in situ. Modification or control of the local compositions and the local magnetic properties of a thin film, e.g., by means of ion implantation, is another aspect of the tendency described here. A second development is aimed at the control of the position and displacement of individual domain walls in monocrystalline or oriented polycrystalline layers. The bubble devices are a good example for this tendency. Such devices depend, apart from a successful miniaturization, in an essential way on the mastering of the material properties, the material perfection and the internal stress distribution. Some examples of these tendencies in device development will now be given, starting with the magnetoresistive reading heads used in magnetic recording. Reading of the information recorded on a magnetic tape is usually achieved by picking up the stray flux passing the air gap of an inductive reading head. T h e electric signal induced in the windings of the head is proportional to the rate of change of the flux. In the magnetoresistive reading head proposed some time ago (Hunt 1971), the flux itself is measured with the aid of the magnetoresistive effect in a thin film of Permalloy. The effect depends on the angle 0 between the direction of the current flowing through the film and the direction of the magnetization. The latter is modulated by the stray flux of the tape. To obtain a linear characteristic the equilibrium angle 0 should be 45 °. An elegant solution is achieved in the so-called " B a r b e r pole configuration" (Kuijk et al. 1975) in which the direction of the current flow is forced into the desired direction with the aid of parallel conductor strips (see fig. 21).
i Ni'Fe
// z - - current flow
Fig. 21. Magnetoresistive reading head based on the "Barberpole configuration". The magnetization of the NiFe film is parallel to the vector M, the current is forced, by conducting bars, into a direction parallel to the vector I. The optimum angle 0 is 45° (after Kuijk et al. 1975).
MAGNETISM AND MAGNETIC MATERIALS
33
Closely related to this example are the thin film integrated recording heads of the inductive variety. Here the emphasis is on reading and writing many tracks on the tape or disc simultaneously. Accordingly the heads are made in large number in integrated form by a batch process using thin film and photolithographic techniques (Romankiw 1970). In combination with solid state integrated circuits a new and very attractive approach of magnetic recording becomes feasible in such a way (fig. 22). A similar development toward miniaturization can be observed with inductors. The L-chip, a miniaturized self inductance based on multiple coils printed on ferrite substrates, is being developed at present. The second main trend, the control of magnetic domain walls and domain structures at a micromagnetic level is manifest in bubble domain devices and domain control in Fe-Si sheet. Both fields have already been discussed in the present survey. Also thermomagnetic recording can be viewed as an example of this line. The basic idea of this storage principle has been proposed long ago (Mayer 1958), but new interest has arisen recently (Berkowitz and Meiklejohn 1975). The information is stored in small regions of reversed magnetization in a thin magnetic film. Unlike the situation with bubbles, these domains remain fixed. Reversal of the magnetization is achieved by reducing locally the coercive force of the film by heating with the aid of a focussed light beam. The information is read by using the Faraday effect. The bits of information are accessed by mechanical motion. Film materials include GdFe, MnBi and garnet films. The
Fig. 22. Array of integrated recording heads shown in a fabrication stage prior to cutting off the front part. The individual heads carry 6 windings (courtesy of W.F. Druyvesteyn, Philips Research Laboratories).
34
U. ENZ
large Faraday effect of some substituted garnets is also used in a different type of device, proposed recently (Hill 1980), the integrated light modulation matrix. The matrix consists of isolated islands etched from a garnet film (fig. 23), which can be switched individually by a cross bar system. The switching of an island occurs by a single Bloch wall, and is initiated by local heating of the island. These examples sufficiently demonstrate the trend mentioned and show that magnetic materials provide an environment in which rather naturally we can build and control certain kinds of objects having dimensions in the micron or submicron range, a region which is generally not readily accessible. The examples also show that applied magnetism is still very much alive.
~ranspareniresis]Gnce,J
q
d
'
I
subsirate
y-bus
Fig. 23. Light modulating matrix based on switching cells of iron garnet single crystal films, with x-y addressed resistance network (after Hill 1980).
4.3. Outlook and acknowledgement In this contribution we have sketched the early historical lines leading to the present edifice of magnetism, and indicated its importance for modern industry and society as a whole. Some material classes received more detailed attention in both the way they developed and their achievements. These materials represent only a very small fraction of those which have been studied. Moreover, many achievements in the explanation of material properties and their theoretical understanding have hardly been touched upon. In this context we note that the amount of knowledge and detailed information on the properties of magnetic
MAGNETISM AND MAGNETIC MATERIALS
35
m a t e r i a l s has a c c u m u l a t e d t o s u c h a d e g r e e , t h a t it is b e c o m i n g i n c r e a s i n g l y difficult t o k e e p sight o n t h e w h o l e of i n f o r m a t i o n . P e r h a p s it is w o r t h w h i l e t o c o n s i d e r t h e f e a s i b i l i t y of t h e i n s t a l l a t i o n of a d a t a b a n k c o n t a i n i n g i n f o r m a t i o n o n magnetic materials. T h e a u t h o r w o u l d l i k e to t h a n k P r o f . G . W . R a t h e n a u , P r o f . H . P . J . W i j n , D r . R . P . v . S t a p e l e , D r . D . J . B r e e d a n d D r . P . F . B o n g e r s of this l a b o r a t o r y , f o r a d v i c e a n d c r i t i c a l r e a d i n g of t h e m a n u s c r i p t of this c o n t r i b u t i o n .
References Albers-Schoenberg, E., 1954, J.A.P. 25, 152. Barrett, W.F., W. Brown and R.A. Hadfield, 1900, Sci. Trans. Roy. Dublin Soc. 7, 67. Berkowitz, A.E. and W.H. Meiklejohn, 1975, IEEE-MAG 11,997. Bertaut, F. and F. Forrat, 1956, C.R. Acad. Sc. 242, 382. Bobeck, A.H., 1967, Bell Syst. Tech. J. 46, 1901. Bobeck, A.H. and E. Della Torre, 1975, Magnetic Bubbles (North-Holland, Amsterdam). Bobeck, A.H., E.G. Spencer, L.G. van Uitert, S.C. Abrahams, R.L. Barnes, W.H. Grodkiewicz, R.C. Sherwood, P.H. Schmidt, D.H. Smith and E.M. Waiters, 1970, Appl. Phys. Lett. 17, 131. Bragg, W.H., 1915, Phil. Mag. 30, 305. Brockmann, F.G., H. van der Heide and M.W. Louwerse, 1969, Philips Tech. R. 30, 323. Das, D.K., 1969, IEEE-MAG 5, 214. De Bruyn, R. and G.J. Verlinde, 1980, Philips Elcoma Division, Eindhoven, private communication. Dillon, J.F., 1957, Phys. Rev. 105, 759. Dillon, J.F., 1958, J.A.P. 29, 539. Dillon, J.F., 1962, Phys. Rev. 127, 1495. Enz, U., R. Metselaar and P.J. Rijnierse, 1971, J. de Phys. 32, C1-703. Fast, J.D. and J.J. de Jong, 1959, J. de Phys. Radium 20, 371. Forestier, H., 1928, Ann. de Chim. 10e srr. 9, 316. Forrester, J.W., 1951, J.A.P. 22, 44. Geller, S. and M.A. Gilleo, 1957, Acta Cryst. 10, 239. Geusic, J.E., H.M. Marcos and L.G. van Uitert, 1964, Appl. Phys. Lett. 4, 182. Gorter, E.W. and J.A. Schulkes, 1953, Phys. Rev. 90, 487. Goss, N.P., 1935, Trans. Am. Soc. Metals, 23, 511.
Griffiths, J.H.E., 1946, Nature, 158, 670. Gumlich, E. and P. Goerens, 1912, Trans. Farad. Soc. 8, 98. Hill, B., 1980, IEEE-ED 27, 1825. Hill, B. and K.P. Schmidt, 1978, Philips J. Res. 33, 211. Hilpert, S., 1909, Ber. Deutsch. Chem. Ges. Bd 2, 42, 2248. Hogan, C.L., 1952, Bell Syst. Tech. J. 31, 1. Hornsveld, L., 1980, Philips Elcoma Division, private communication. Hunt, R.P, 1971, IEEE-MAG 7, 150. Jacobs, I.S., 1969, J.A.P. 40, 917. Jonas, B. and H.J. Meerkamp van Embden, 1941, Philips Tech. Rev. 6, 8. Kittel, C., 1959, Phys. Rev. Lett. 3, 169. Kooy, C. and U. Enz, 1960, Philips Res. Rep. 15, 7. Kuijk, K.E., W.J. van Gestel and F.W. Gorter, 1975, IEEE-MAG 11, 1215. LeGraw, R.C., E.G. Spencer and C.S. Porter, 1958, Phys. Rev. 110, 1311. Leeuw, F.H. de, R. van den Doel and U. Enz, 1980, Rept. Progr. Phys. 43, 689. Luborsky, F.E., P.G. Frischmann and L.A. Johnson, 1978, J. Magn. Mag. Mat. 8, 318. Malozemoff, A.P. and J.C. Slonczewski, 1979, Physics of magnetic domain walls in bubble materials (Academic Press, New York). Mattis, D.C., 1965, Theory of Magnetism (Harper and Row, New York). Mayer, L., 1958, J.A.P. 29, 1454. Mishima, T., 1932, Iron Age, 130, 346. N6el, L., 1948, Ann. de Phys. 3, 137. Nesbitt, E.A., H.J. Williams, J.H. Wernick and R.C. Sherwood, 1961, J.A.P. 32, 342 S. Nielsen, J.W., 1976, IEEE-MAG 12, 327. Nishikawa, S., 1915, Proc. Tokyo Math. Phys. Soc. 8, 199. Pauthenet, R., 1956, C.R. Acad. Sc. 242, 1859. Pauthenet, R., 1957, Thesis, Grenoble, France.
36
U. ENZ
Rajchman, J.A., 1952, RCA Rev. 13, 183. Rathenau, G.W., 1974, Proc. 3rd Eur. Conf. on Hard Magn. Mat., Amsterdam (Bond voor Materialenkennis, P.O. Box 9321, Den Haag, The Netherlands) p. 7. Remeika, J.P., 1956, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 78, 4259. Robertson, J.M., S.W. Wittekoek, Th.J.A. Popma and P.F. Bongers, 1973, Appl. Phys. 2, 219. Romankiw, L.T., I.M. Croll and M. Hatzakis, 1970, IEEE-MAG 6, 597. Shick, L.K. and J.W. Nielsen, 1971, J.A.P. 42, 1554. Shull, C.G., E.O. Wollan and W.C. Koeler, 1951, Phys. Rev. 84, 912. Six, W., 1952, Philips Tech. Rev. 13, 301. Snoek, J.L., 1936, Physica, 3, 463. Snoek, J.L., 1947, New Devel. in Ferromagn. Materials (Elsevier, Amsterdam). Snyderman, N., 1977, Electronics News, 28 November. Spencer, E.G., R.C. LeCraw and F. Reggia, 1956, Proc. IRE 44, 790. Strnat, KJ., G.J. Hoffer, W. Ostertag and I.C. Olson, 1966, J.A.P. 37, 1252. Stuijts, A.L., G.W. Rathenau and G.H. Weber, 1954/1955, Philips Tech. Rev. 16, 141. Taguchi, S., T. Yamamoto and A. Sakakura, 1974, IEEE-MAG 10, 123. Takai, T., 1937, J. Electrochem. Japan, 5, 411.
Teale, R.W. and D.W. Temple, 1967, Phys. Rev. Lett. 19, 904. Teale, R.W. and Tweedale K., 1962, Phys. Lett. 1,298. Tebble, R.S. and D.J. Craik, 1969, Magnetic Materials (Wiley, London) 520. Tellegen, B.D.H., 1948, Philips Res. Rep. 3, 81. Tolksdorf, W. and F. Welz, 1978, Crystal growth of magnetic garnets from high temperature solutions, in Crystals Vol. 1 (Springer, Berlin). Van den Broek, C.A.M. and A.L. Stuijts, 1977, Philips Techn. Rev. 37, 157. Verwey, E.J.W. and E.L. Heilmann, 1947, J. Chem. Phys. 15, 174. Vos, K.J. de, 1966, Thesis, Delft. Wang, F.Y., 1973, in: Treatise on Materials Science and Technology, ed., H. Herman (Academic Press, New York) 279. Weiss, P., 1907, J. Phys. 6, 661. Went, JJ., G.W. Rathenau, E.W. Gorter and G.W. van Oosterhout, 1951/1952, Philips Techn. Rev. 13, 194. Wijn, H.P.J., 1970, Proc. Int. Conf. Ferrites, Kyoto. Wijn, H.P.J., 1976, Physics in Industry (Pergamon, Oxford) 69. Williams, H.J. and W. Shockley, 1949, Phys. Rev. 75, 178. Zijlstra, H., 1974, Philips Tech. Rev. 34, 193. Zijlstra, H., 1976, Physics in Technology (May), 98.
chapter 2 PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
H. ZlJLSTRA Philips Research Laboratories Eindhoven The Netherlands
Ferromagnetic Materials, Vol. 3 Edited by E.P. Wohlfarth © North-HollandPublishing Company, 1982 37
CONTENTS 1. I n t r o d u c t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.1. G e n e r a l p r o p e r t i e s a n d a p p l i c a t i o n s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2. T h e h y s t e r e s i s l o o p . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Suitability criteria for a p p l i c a t i o n s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1. T h e e n e r g y p r o d u c t . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2. T h e m a g n e t i c free e n e r g y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. M a g n e t i c a n i s o t r o p y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. A n i s o t r o p y field a n d coercivity a s s o c i a t e d w i t h m a g n e t i c a n i s o t r o p y . . . . . 3.2. S h a p e a n i s o t r o p y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. M a g n e t o c r y s t a l l i n e a n i s o t r o p y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. F i n e p a r t i c l e s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1. Critical r a d i u s for s i n g l e - d o m a i n particles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2. B r o w n ' s p a r a d o x . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. C o e r c i v i t y a s s o c i a t e d w i t h s h a p e a n i s o t r o p y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1. P r o l a t e s p h e r o i d . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2. C h a i n of s p h e r e s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. C o e r c i v i t y a s s o c i a t e d with m a g n e t o c r y s t a l l i n e a n i s o t r o p y . . . . . . . . . . 6.1. M a g n e t i z a t i o n r e v e r s a l by d o m a i n wall p r o c e s s e s f o r / * 0 / / A > Js . . . . . . 6.2. T h e 180 ° d o m a i n wall . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2.1. E n e r g y a n d w i d t h of a 180 ° d o m a i n wall . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2.2. T h e e x c h a n g e e n e r g y coefficient A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.3. I n t e r a c t i o n of d o m a i n walls w i t h cavities a n d n o n - f e r r o m a g n e t i c i n c l u s i o n s 6.3.1. D o m a i n - w a l l p i n n i n g at l a r g e i n c l u s i o n s . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.3.2. N u c l e a t i o n of r e v e r s e d o m a i n s at l a r g e i n c l u s i o n s . . . . . . . . . 6.3.3. D o m a i n - w a l l p i n n i n g at small i n c l u s i o n s . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.4. D o m a i n - w a l l n u c l e a t i o n at surface defects . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5. I n t e r a c t i o n of d o m a i n walls w i t h the crystal lattice . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.1. W a l l p i n n i n g at r e g i o n s w i t h d e v i a t i n g K and A . . . . . . . . . 6.5.2. P i n n i n g of a d o m a i n wall by an a n t i p h a s e b o u n d a r y . . . . . . . . 6.5.3. N u c l e a t i o n of a d o m a i n wall at an a n t i p h a s e b o u n d a r y . . . . . . . 6.5.4. T h i n - w a l l c o e r c i v i t y in a perfect crystal . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.5. P a r t i a l wall p i n n i n g at d i s c r e t e sites . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7. I n f l u e n c e of t e m p e r a t u r e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
38
39 39 4O 42 42 46 49 49 52 53 55 55 6O 6O 60 64 66 66 67 67 69 74 76 78 78 80 81 81 88 93 94 98 100 104
1. Introduction
1.1. General properties and applications The appearance of permanent-magnet materials such as alnico (Jonas et al. 1941) and hexaferrite (Went et al. 1951) with much better properties than materials previously in use was followed by a great increase in the applications of the permanent magnet. Compared with electromagnets (including power supplies) permanent magnets offer the advantage of a larger ratio of the useful magnetic field volume to the volume of the magnet system. Their usefulness is of course particularly apparent where a constant magnetic field is required. As is widely known, the constancy of the externally generated field is related to the magnetic "hardness" of the material, that is to say the extent to which the material retains its magnetization in opposing fields. In this way the p o l a r i z a t i o n - a n d therefore the external f i e l d - of a p e r m a n e n t magnet is maintained. A particular example of an opposing field is the internal field of the poles of the magnet itself. In this case the demagnetizing action is again unable to destroy the polarization of the magnet. The present increasing interest in the further development of hard magnetic materials is explained in part by the growing demand for miniaturization in modern technology. The problem of heat dissipation is inseparable from miniaturization, and the substitution of permanent magnets for electromagnets obviously goes a long way towards solving that problem. To ensure the most effective development it is desirable to start by investigating the likely applications of permanent magnets. The next step is to decide on the criteria that indicate suitability for these applications. These criteria can then provide a pattern for the production of tailor-made magnetic materials. This calls for insight into the effects that variation of such properties as remanence and coercivity has on the suitability of the materials for a particular application, and it also requires knowledge of the physical background. This will be the main subject of the present chapter. Table 1 lists various machines, devices and components in which permanent magnets are nowadays used. The classification is based on four principles: - m e c h a n i c a l energy is converted into electrical energy (or vice versa) in the magnetic field; - t h e permanent magnet exerts a force on a ferromagnetically soft body; 39
40
H. ZIJLSTRA
TABLE 1 Examples of machines, devices and components using permanent magnets, classified by four functions which the magnet can perform. Function
Application
Conversion of electrical in'~o mechanical energy and vice versa
Small electric motors, dynamos, loudspeakers, microphone% eddy-current brakes, speedometers, magnetos
Exerting a force on a ferromagneticaUy soft body
Relays, couplings, bearings, clutches, magnetic chucks and clamps, separators (extraction of iron impurities, concentration of ores)
Alignment with respect to a field
Positioning mechanisms (e.g., stepping motors), compasses, some ammeters
Exerting a force on moving charge carriers
Magnetrons, travelling-wave cathode-ray tubes, Hall plates
tubes,
some
- t h e permanent magnet is subjected to a directional force exerted by a magnetic field; - t h e permanent magnet exerts a force on moving charge carriers, e.g., a beam of electrons in a vacuum. In sections 2.1 and 2.2 the two main suitability criteria are discussed which together cover almost the entire field of applications. They are the maximum energy product and the maximum change in the magnetic free energy. Applications not covered by these criteria can be found among the positioning mechanisms in table 1. Apart from the fact that the existing applications provide an incentive to search for better magnetic materials, the converse is of course equally true: better magnets lead to applications that had not previously been thought of or did not seem feasible.
1.2. The hysteresis loop Permanent magnet materials are characterized by high coercivities and high remanent magnetizations. Before proceeding with the discussion of the structural parameters that determine the hard magnetic properties, we must first define the parameters that are generally used to specify the magnetic properties of permanent magnets. We employ the International System of Units (SI) in which the magnetic flux density B is expressed as either B =/~o(H + M ) , or
B =/~oH + J ,
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
41
where M and J are are the local material contributions to the flux density, respectively called magnetization and magnetic polarization, and H is the con: tribution from all other sources and is called magnetic field strength. The quantities H and M are measured in A m -1 (1 A m -1 = 4~r x 10 - 3 0 e ) . The quantities B and J are measured in Vsm -2 or tesla (1 T = 10 4 Gauss). The vacuum permeability ~0 is equal to 47r x 10 -7 V s A -1 m -t (or Hm-1). Both expressions for B will be used in this chapter. Although magnetic polarization is the official n a m e for J it will often be called magnetization. If the magnetization M or J of a p e r m a n e n t magnet material is plotted as a function of the applied field H a hysteresis loop is obtained in which the magnetization is not a unique function of H, but depends on the direction and magnitude of previously applied fields. A typical hysteresis loop is shown in fig. 1. The initial magnetization curve starting at the origin is obtained when the material is in a thermally demagnetized state. If the m a x i m u m applied field H m is sufficient to saturate the material the loop is referred to as a saturation loop. When the applied field is reduced the magnetization decreases to the r e m a n e n t magnetization J,, which is generally less than the saturation magnetization Js. In an efficient p e r m a n e n t magnet material Jr is usually 0.8-1.0Js. If the material is subjected to a demagnetizing field (i.e. a negative applied field H ) the magnetization is gradually reduced and at a critical field - H = jHc the magnetization is zero. This critical field jHc is known as the magnetization coercivity and is defined as the reverse field required to reduce the net magnetization of the material to zero in the presence of the field. The latter qualifying statement is necessary because if the field is r e m o v e d the specimen may return to a small positive r e m a n e n t magnetization J; < Jr. Instead of J we can plot the magnetic
/Z jHc k
/]I//] .,11] /
Fig. 1. Saturation hysteresis loop for magnetic flux density B as a function of H (drawn) and for magnetization J as a function of H with initial magnetization curve (dashed).
42
H. ZIJLSTRA
flux density B = / x 0 H + J as a function of H (drawn line in fig. 1). We then obtain the flux hysteresis loop with remanence Br = Jr and with a smaller value of the coercivity which is here called the flux coercivity ~Hc. Note that by these definitions the coercivities are positive numbers quantifying negative field strengths. It should be emphasized that the coercivities jHc and BHc are assumed to correspond to demagnetization of the saturated material, though we shall see later that permanent magnet materials are rarely if ever absolutely saturated even in exceptionally high fields. Unless otherwise stated, it can usually be safely assumed that the values of Hc quoted in the various scientific journals, books and papers refer to the "saturation" values as defined above. In the following the prefix J will be omitted when jH~ is discussed.
2. Suitability criteria for applications 2.1. The energy product
The extent to which a material will be suitable for applications in which electrical energy plays a part (the first groups in table 1) depends on the amount of magnetic flux linkage per metre squared and the maximum opposing field that can be tolerated without loss of polarization. The product of the flux density B and the associated opposing field H, referred to as the energy product, is a useful measure of the performance of a particular magnet, since it is proportional to the potential energy of the field in the air gap. It is useful only, however, when the magnet is not disturbed by fields from another source. To determine the energy product it is of course necessary to have information about the hysteresis loop of the material (fig. 2). A permanent magnet that is subject only to the influence of its own field will be in a state represented by a working point in the second (or the fourth) quadrant of the hysteresis loop. In these quadrants the field is opposed to the flux density, and is referred to as the demagnetizing field. It can be shown quite generally that the occurrence of a magnetic field outside the permanent magnet does in fact relate to a field inside the magnet with B and B
Fig. 2. Part of a magnetic hysteresis loop for magnetic flux density B; the shaded area is equal to the maximum energy product (BH)....
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
43
/ - / i n opposition. To do this, we have to apply Maxwell's equations to a situation in which there are no electric currents (apart from the circular currents on an atomic scale, which are the carriers of the magnetization of the material). The magnetic field strength H then satisfies curl H = O, and for the flux density B we always have div B = 0. For a permanent magnet of finite dimensions we may therefore deduce (Brown 1962a)
fn(H.
B ) d V = 0,
(2.1)
where the integration is performed over the complete space R. If this integral is written as the sum of the integral over the volume (Rrnagn) of the permanent magnet and the integral over the rest of the complete space (Rrest), then
~Rmagn (/~r B)
dV
= --fRrest(H- B) dV.
Assuming that the space Rrest is " e m p t y " , i.e., contains no magnetic substances, then the flux density there is given by B =/x0H. The right-hand side of the last equation is then negative, which is possible only if B and H inside the magnet are of opposite sense or at least include an obtuse angle at least somewhere. This result is not affected if Rrest contains soft magnetic material in which B and H always have the same direction. It can also be shown directly from what we have said above why the product is a good criterion of quality for the applications considered in this section. If we assume that any field present in soft magnetic material is negligible, we may write:
BH
fRmagn(lt.B)dV=-tXo f nrestH2dV.
(2.2)
The right-hand side of this equation is twice the potential energy of the field outside the magnet (i.e. in the air gap). This is proportional to H • B. The exact location of the operating p o i n t - a n d hence the value of the energy p r o d u c t - d e p e n d s on the relative dimensions of the magnet and the magnetic circuit in which it is used. In the limiting cases of an infinitely long needle of a closed circuit ( H = 0) or of an infinitely extensive plate (B = 0) the energy product is equal to zero; then there
44
H. Z I J L S T R A
is no external field. Between these two extremes a situation exists in which the energy product has its maximum magnitude. In the case of the needle-shaped magnet the demagnetizing field is very weak and the working point is close to the point Br in fig. 2. The value of the flux density at this point is the remanence. If the magnet is made shorter and thicker, the working point then moves along the loop in the direction of the point sHe, which it reaches if the magnet is given the form of a thin plate magnetized perpendicular to its plane. The demagnetizing field then has its maximum value and exactly compensates the magnetization. In a properly dimensioned design the energy product will thus assume a maximum value, ( B H ) .... which is determined solely by the material used. The suitability criterion sought has thus been found. The product can be represented by the area of the shaded rectangle in fig. 2; its magnitude is equal to twice the total potential energy of the field produced outside the magnet divided by the volume of the magnet. The higher the remanence, the greater the coercive force and the more convex the hysteresis loop, the greater is the value of the product. For an ideal magnet, i.e., a magnet that maintains the saturation value Js of its polarization in spite of the presence of an opposing field H, the hysteresis loop in the second quadrant is formed by a straight line going from the point where H = 0, i.e., where B = Br = Js, to the point where - H = BHc = Js/l~o. The maximum energy product is then given by: 1 (BH)max = 4/x~ j 2 .
(2.3)
To reach this maximum it is sufficient if the magnet maintains its saturation until the opposing field reaches the value -½JJl~o. A further improvement in the energy product is then only possible with materials that have a higher saturation value J~. The highest known saturation value at room temperature is shown by an FeCo alloy (2.4 T); from this value the theoretical energy product could be as much as 1150 kJm -3 (144 MGOe). However, the coercive force of this alloy is very low, which makes it unsuitable for permanent magnets. Figure 3 shows the improvements achieved in maximum energy products over the years, the record values being indicated on a logarithmic scale. It is interesting to note how closely the curve approximates to an exponential development. Once the material and thus the hysteresis loop and the (BH)max value are given, the magnet system has to be designed to make optimum use of the material parameters. Very schematically this is done as follows: Consider a permanent magnet system as drawn in fig. 4. The magnet has a length Im and cross-sectional area Sin. The air gap has a length Ig and crosssectional area Sg. The pole pieces are assumed to have infinite permeability ( H = 0 at finite B). The fields H and B are assumed to be uniform in the magnet body and in the air gap. For simplicity the field spread outside the magnet and the air gap is taken to be zero, although this is certainly not true in the given arrangement. We then have from flux continuity BmSm = - B g S g ,
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY I00C k Jim 3 50C
45
// /
/
j11
20C (BH)mox 100
,
50
j
~10
zt ~
20 10 //
5
/
/
/
//
1 I
880 19'00 1920 19 0,960 1 80 Fig. 3. Historical trend of the maximum energy product (BH)mx achieved experimentally since the year 1880; (1) carbon steel, (2) tungsten steel, (3) cobalt steel, (4) Fe-Ni-AI alloy, (5) 'Ticonal II', (6) 'Ticonal G', (7) 'Ticonal GG', (8) 'Ticonal XX' (laboratory value, Luteijn and de Vos 1956), (9) SmCos, (10) (Sin, Pr)Co5 (laboratory value, Martin and Benz 1971), (11) Sm2(Co0.85Fe0.11Mn0.04)17 (laboratory value, Ojima et al. 1977). The energy in MGOe is found by dividing the value in kJm -3 by 7.96.
1 Ig
s/[ Fig. 4. Permanent magnet system with pole pieces. S m and Sg are the cross-sectional areas of the magnet and the air gap respectively, and Im and lg their respective lengths.
46
H. ZIJLSTRA
and, since no currents are present, Hmlm - G i g = O,
where the positive direction for H and B is taken to the right. From these equations it is easily found that H m = Hglg/Im,
and B m = - tzoHgSg/ Sm B m / H m = - tZoSglm / Smlg .
The latter expression shows that the reluctance of the system and hence the working point of the magnet is entirely determined by the dimensional ratios of the yoke. Allowance for finite permeability of the pole pieces and for flux leakage can be made by factors o~ (resistance factor) and /3 (leakage factor) so that the equations for magnetomotoric force and the flux in the air gap are written as HgLg = otHmLm,
BgSg = - /3BmSm .
For good designs c~ may have values between 0.7 and 0.95 and/3 between 0.1 and 0.8. Detailed discussions of these factors have been published by Edwards (1962) and by Schiller and Brinkmann (1970). 2.2. T h e m a g n e t i c free energy
In applications involving clamping ability, lifting power or pull of the magnet (ponderomotive force, the second category in table 1) the working point is also in the second quadrant of the hysteresis loop. Whereas in the previous group of applications it was the location of the working point that mattered, the important thing now is how the working point moves. If, for example, the application is of a cyclical nature, it is usually necessary for the working point to "stay well on the loop" during the cyclical motion, so that good reversibility is important. The amount of mechanical work spent in going anticlockwise round part of the loop and completely recovered on going back again is used as a criterion for measuring the performance of a magnet system for applications of this type. In these applications there is generally a particular configuration of permanent magnets and magnetizable objects, which are capable of relative movement. Leaving aside the work required to overcome friction, the mechanical work required to produce an isothermal change in the configuration is equal to the increase in its magnetic free energy. Conversely, a decrease in the magnetic free energy will result in the same amount of mechanical work becoming available.
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
47
According to the first law of thermodynamics (conservation of energy) a system in which a reversible process takes place can be described by the equation TdS
+ dA = dU.
The term T dS, the product of the absolute temperature T of the system and the change of its entropy S, is equal to the amount of heat supplied to the system from the environment. In addition the environment performs on the system an amount of mechanical work dA, taken as positive. This sign convention for the mechanical work performed is employed for systems in which magnetic effects occur. Both amounts of energy are spent on the increment d U of the internal energy of the system. The free energy F of the system is defined by F=U-TS.
It follows from these two relations that dF = dA- S dT. If the state of the system changes isothermally (i.e. d T = 0), then dF = dA. In a system that contains magnetic material the main problem is to find the correct expression for the mechanical work. The criterion used for the suitability of a magnetic material for applications of the type we are now considering is the maximum possible reversible change of its magnetic free energy. This value is usually calculated per unit volume of the magnet. The mechanical work d A associated with an infinitesimal change of the configuration is equal to dA
½f_
(H. dS - S . d H ) d V, magn
where the integration is performed over the part Rmagn of the space occupied by the material. T o derive this expression for the mechanical work, let us imagine a number of bodies of various magnetizations arranged in a particular configuration. We assume that the bodies are situated in each other's magnetic field and that their temperature remains constant. A slight change in the configuration causes a change in the fields and hence in the polarizations. For each body the increase in the magnetic free energy consists of a quantity dFp, connected with the build-up of the polarization in the material, and a quantity of interaction energy dF~, since in a field H a piece of material with the polarization vector J possesses the potential energy, - ( J • H). For the body considered we can now write: d F = dFp+ d E = H . d d - d ( J - H ) .
48
H. ZIJLSTRA
T o find the change in the free energy of the whole system we must perform a summation over all the bodies. The contributions from the interaction energy would then be counted twice, but putting a factor 1 in front of them corrects for this. The total increase in the free energy is therefore dFsystem = E
dVp+½E
dFi,
where both summations are made over all the bodies. Using the above expressions for dFp and dF~ and applying the expression d F = d A for isothermal changes, we obtain the required expression for the mechanical work, calculated per unit volume of the material. W e should note here that the energy change H - d J is positive, because the structure of the material offers a certain resistance to the change of the polarization. The interaction energy, - ( J • H ) , has a minus sign because it is customary to take this energy by definition equal to zero for two bodies that are an infinite distance apart. If the polarization vector in the expression for the mechanical work is replaced by the equivalent quantity B -/~0H, then, after integration, d A = ½fu
( H . dB - B . dH) d V. magi
T o evaluate this integral it is necessary to bear in mind that during a change in the configuration the working point moves along the hysteresis loop in the second quadrant from P to Q (fig. 5). It is then found that the work d A is equal to the area of the sector O P Q . One configuration (point P) cannot move farther to the right than point Br, where H is zero, and therefore the magnetic circuit must be closed. The other configuration (point Q) cannot m o v e farther to the left than the point BHc, where B and the force exerted are zero. W h e r e possible, cyclical processes will be carried out in such a way that the working region in the second quadrant extends to the vertical axis (Br). T h e magnetic circuit there is closed, which corresponds to a state of lowest energy. In general the material chosen for
B/ P
Br
S Fig. 5. Part of a B hysteresis curve in the second quadrant. The area of the sector OPQ represents the change in magnetic free energy when the working point moves from P to Q.
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
49
these applications is one in which the working point can move reversibly from remanence over the greatest possible extent of the hysteresis loop. For an ideal magnet, where the complete (linear) hysteresis branch in the second quadrant is transversed reversibly, the maximum mechanical work made available per unit volume during a change of configuration is given by: ½B~BH~ = (1/2/Xo)J 2 • It will be evident t h a t the magnet must be capable of maintaining its saturation polarization Js until the opposing field reaches the value -JJtxo. This imposes a stronger requirement on the coercivity than when the magnet is used for static field generation. The hexaferrite materials with their (for that time) high coercivity of the order of 3 x 10SAm -a ( ~ 4 k O e ) made many of these dynamic applications possible. Today there are many materials with much higher coercivities, notably the rare-earth alloys, whose coercivities are of the order of 106 A m -1 (104 Oe).
3. Magnetic anisotropy
3.1. Anisotropy field and coercivity associated with magnetic anisotropy Consider a single-crystal sphere of a material with uniaxial magnetic anisotropy, uniformly magnetized to saturation parallel to the easy axis of magnetization. We assume that changes in the magnetization occur by a uniform or coherent rotation of the magnetization Ms and that the anisotropy energy density is given by Wk = K sin 2 q~, where ~0 is the angle between the easy axis and the magnetization vector. In the presence of a f i e l d / - / a l o n g the easy axis we assume that the magnetization vector is rotated through an angle ~p as shown in fig. 6. In this state the total magnetic energy is 1 2 W = g/x0Ms + K sin 2 q~ +/x0HMs(1 - cos q~).
Note that the first term, which is the magnetostatic energy of the magnetized sphere, is independent of the angle q~ because the demagnetization factor of the sphere is isotropic and equal to ½. For a minimum in the energy W corresponding to a stable position of the magnetization vector we require dW d~ - 0
and
d2W > 0. d~ 2
Thus q~ = 0 is a stable position of Ms when
H. ZIJLSTRA
50
easy
axis
Ms
Fig. 6. Uniaxial crystal with easy axis for the magnetization.
H > -2K/IxoMs. However, if the field H<-2K/l~oMs the position q~ = 0 is unstable and the magnetization reverses discontinuously to ~0 = ~-. The critical field 2K/~oMs is defined as the anisotropy field HA. It is important to note that the coercivity/arc of this model of uniform rotation is equal to HA. W e shall see later that in real materials the coercivity is smaller than HA and depends on the microstructural features of the magnetic crystals. However, in any case the anisotropy field is the upper limit for the coercivity, and magnetic anisotropy is therefore a prerequisite for coercivity to occur. When the easy axis does not coincide with the field direction the magnetization reverses by a reversible rotation followed by an irreversible jump. The hysteresis loop is no longer rectangular and the coercivity depends on the orientation angle of the easy axis. These cases have been calculated by Stoner and Wohlfarth (1948) and are summarized in fig. 7. The hysteresis loop of an array of non-interacting identical particles with uniaxial anisotropy oriented at r a n d o m is given in fig. 8. The coercivity of this array is Hc = 0.48HA if coherent rotation is assumed. Magnetic anisotropy can have various causes. The most important in p e r m a n e n t magnet materials are: (a) shape anisotropy, associated with the geometrical shape of a magnetized body; (b) magnetocrystalline anisotropy, associated with the crystal symmetry of the material. They are discussed in sections 3.2 and 3.3. A p a r t from these types of anisotropies, there are a few of less importance for p e r m a n e n t magnets, but nevertheless worth mentioning. At the surface of a crystal the atoms are in a position of deviating symmetry as compared with the
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY -1 I
I
I
0 r
I
I
51 1
I
I
I
I
I
I
[
0
I
0,10,90
1
M/M s
T
¢'
0
I
-1
0
0,10,90 I
I
I
I
I
-1
I
I
0
I
~
I
h
I
I
1
Fig. 7. Hysteresis loops for uniform rotation of the magnetization in a crystal with one easy axis for the magnetization, with the orientation angle (in degrees) between easy axis and direction of applied field as a parameter (Stoner and Wohlfarth 1948).
1.0
Sf
-0.5
-1.0 :-1.5
Y
f
0.5
f -1.0
M/Ms
J ~ 0..=
0
0.5
1.0
1.5
Fig. 8. Hysteresis loop and initial curve for an array of non-interacting identical particles with one easy axis, oriented at random (Stoner and Wohlfarth 1948).
52
H. ZIJLSTRA
interior. This may give rise to a magnetic anisotropy experienced only by these superficial atoms, causing the spins to be oriented normal to the surface, or in other cases, tangential to the surface. In a non-spherical crystal this leads to a net anisotropy effect which, of course, becomes smaller with increasing size of the crystal. The underlying theory has been treated by N6el (1954) and the effect may contribute somewhat to the shape anisotropy of heterogeneous elongated particle magnets like alnico. A similar kind of "surface anisotropy" has been observed by Berkowitz et al. (1975) on fine ferrite particles covered with a monomolecular layer of oleic acid. Another interfacial type of anisotropy was discussed by Meiklejohn and Bean (1957), namely, exchange anisotropy. It occurs when an antiferromagnetic crystal with high anisotropy and a ferromagnetic crystal constitute one solid body such that the spins on either side of the interface are coupled by exchange forces. The (non-magnetic) antiferromagnetic crystal then imparts its anisotropy to the ferromagnetic crystal. The effect has been observed with small cobalt spheres covered by an anisotropic antiferromagnetic oxide layer.
3.2. Shape anisotropy Shape anisotropy refers to the preference that the polarization in a long body has for the direction of the major axis. The effect, which does not arise from an intrinsic property of the material, can easily be described in the case of a prolate ellipsoid. It is assumed that the ellipsoid is homogeneously magnetized in a direction that makes an angle ~0 with the major axis (fig. 9). The demagnetizing / /
I
I
÷
I I !
I I I
Fig. 9. Magnetized prolate spheroid.
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
53
field Ha due to the magnetic poles at the surface is also homogeneous within the ellipsoid. Along each of the three principal axes of the ellipsoid we can apply one of the relations
I.l"ondi = -- NiJi , where i is the number of the principal axis; the coefficients N~ are the demagnetization factors. In the case of a prolate spheroid we have the "parallel" demagnetization factor NIl for the direction parallel to the axis of revolution and two "perpendicular" demagnetization factors Na, which, for reasons of symmetry, are identical. Using eq. (2.1)
f
(H.B) dV=O,
it can easily be shown that the energy Em of the demagnetizing field, which is given by
Em = II.~OIR n 2 d V , depends in the following way on the parameters that describe the situation: Em = ~ 0 {]~lJ2 + (NL - ]~l)J 2 sin 2 ~p}Rmagn • In this expression Rmagnis the volume of the ellipsoid. The coefficient of the directionally dependent part of the equation describes the shape anisotropy. For small values of the angle ~0 we find from this an effective anisotropy field HA = (N±-
Nfl/~0
•
In the case of a long bar (needle) this field HA approximates to the value J/2l~o. If the bar consists of iron (Js ~ 2 Wbm -2) it follows from the foregoing that HA 106Am -1 (~104Oe). This is the value of the coercive force when the magnetization is rotated uniformly. Magnetic materials which derive their hardness from shape anisotropy consist of a fine dispersion of magnetic needles in a matrix of non-magnetic or weakly magnetic material, like alnico (fig. 10).
3.3. Magnetocrystalline anisotropy There are three situations that give rise to magnetic anisotropy as an intrinsic crystal property. The first and most important one is that in which the atoms possess an electron-orbital moment in addition to an electron-spin moment. In
54
H. ZIJLSTRA
Fig. 10. Microstructure of an alnico magnet. The alloy consists of a precipitate of elongated particles (approx. composition FeCo, average thickness 30 nm) in a matrix of approx, composition NiA1. Left: plane of observation parallel to the easy axis. Right: perpendicular to the easy axis. (Electron micrograph of 'Ticonal XX' magnet steel (De Vos 1966).) such a situation the spin direction may be coupled to the crystal axes. This arises through the coupling between spin and orbital moments and the interaction between the charge distribution over the orbit and the electrostatic field of the surrounding atoms. There will then be one or more axes or surfaces along which magnetization requires relatively little work. The crystal will then be preferentially magnetized along such an easy axis or plane. The second situation is encountered in non-cubic crystal lattices. In these crystals the magnetostatic interaction between the atomic moments is also anisotropic, which may give rise to easy directions or planes of magnetization. The third possibility of crystal anisotropy is found in the directional ordering of atoms as described by N6el (1954). This typically involves solid solutions of atoms of two kinds, A and B, linked by the atomic bonds A - A , A - B and B-B. In the presence of a strong external magnetic field the internal energy of these bonds may be to some extent direction-dependent. Given a sufficient degree of atomic diffuson - as a result of raising the temperature, for example - a certain ordering can be brought about in the distribution of the bonds; in this way it is possible to " b a k e " the direction of this field into the material as the easy axis of magnetization. In addition to these sources of magnetocrystalline anisotropy mechanical stresses may contribute through the magnetoelastic (magnetostrictive) properties of
55
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
the crystal. This contribution, however, is considered to be negligible in hard magnetic materials. Examples of materials with magnetocrystalline anisotropy are Ba- or Sr-hexaferrite with H A ~ I . 3 X 106Am -1 (17kOe), MnAI with HA ~ 3.2 X 106 A m -1 (40 kOe) and SmCo5 with H a ~ 24 x 106 A m a (300 kOe).
4. Fine particles
4.1. Critical radius for single-domain particles In section 3.1 the coercivity is calculated in a model assuming uniform rotation of the magnetization. The result Hc = HA however is in disagreement with experiment, as illustrated by a few examples in table 2. Obviously the assumption of uniform rotation is not realistic and we have to consider other modes of reversal. This section deals with the conditions under which uniform magnetization is stable and with the non-uniform states that may occur otherwise. Consider a uniformly magnetized sphere. It contains a certain amount of magnetostatic free energy due to its magnetic dipole field. This energy can be reduced by allowing a non-uniform magnetization. By this the magnetic field acquires multipole components at the expense of the dipole field with a general reduction in magnetostatic energy. The field even vanishes altogether when the magnetization vectors form closed loops inside the sphere. However, non-uniform magnetization requires work due to the exchange interaction and the magneti c anisotropy, and the trade-off of these energies with the magnetostatic energy determines which mode of magnetization the sphere will have. In general the mode depends on the radius of the sphere, and in some cases a critical radius can be calculated below which a sphere is uniformly magnetized in its lowest state. A rigorous determination of the critical radius for a uniformly magnetized sphere using the micromagnetic equations (Brown 1957, Frei et al. 1957) would be extremely difficult because the micromagnetic theory contains non-linear differential equations. However, a simplified approach to the problem has been made by Kittel (1949) who calculated approximate values of the critical radius Rc while Brown (1969) calculated exact values for the upper and lower bounds for TABLE 2 Comparison of anisotropy field HA and coercivityshe of various permanent magnet materials. HA
Material Ticonal 900 Ferroxdure SmCo5 MnAI
jnc
(kAm-1)
(kOe)
(kAm-l)
(kOe)
370 1200 24000 3400
4.6 15 300 40
100 400 5500 400
1.3 5 70 5
56
H. ZIJLSTRA
Re. T h e following calculations are based on B r o w n ' s a p p r o a c h with the following assumptions: (1) T h e m a g n e t i z a t i o n is continuous with the magnetic polarization IJs[ constant (2) T h e energy density due to the e x c h a n g e coupling is (see section 6.2.1): We = A(V~p) 2 . (3) T h e f e r r o m a g n e t i c material is uniaxial and the magnetocrystalline anisotropy energy density is (apart f r o m a constant term): W r = K sin 2 ~ , w h e r e ~0 is the angle b e t w e e n the easy axis of magnetization and the magnetization vector. According to B r o w n the critical radius Rc0 b e l o w which a sphere is certainly uniformly m a g n e t i z e d is / I.l,o A \ 1/2
Rco = 5.099~-~s2 )
•
If we assume that for iron (Kittel 1949) A ~ 2 x 10 -11Jm -1 , we find that Rc0(iron) = 13 n m (130 ~ ) .
O
b
Fig. 11. Demagnetization modes of a sphere. (a) Magnetization curling. (b) Two-domain state.
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
57
In order to calculate the critical radius above which the magnetization is nonuniform we must distinguish between two cases: (1) The material has a low magnetocrystalline anisotropy energy density. In this case the energy associated with the uniform magnetization state is compared with the non-uniform magnetization state known as "curling". The latter is considered to have the l o w e s t energy because the curling mode (shown in fig. ll(a)) minimizes the sum of the magnetostatic, anisotropy and exchange energies. (2) The material has a high magnetocrystalline anisotropy energy density. In this case the energy associated with the uniform-magnetization state is compared with the two-domain state having a single plane wall as shown in fig. ll(b). Unfortunately the micromagnetic theory does not generate the magnetization configuration that has the lowest energy, so that the non-uniform states as mentioned have been chosen on the assumption that they have the lowest energy. Simple calculations suggest that this is probably correct. (1) Low magnetocrystalline anisotropy energy density. According to Brown (1969) this condition is defined by
K
K < 1.0686Wm, Wm =
where
(1/6/x0)J 2 .
The latter expression, Win, is of course the magnetostatic energy of a uniformly magnetized sphere. If the above condition is satisfied the curling mode has a lower energy than the uniform magnetization mode provided that the particle radius R >
RCl ,
where 64053 ~---~ m 1 - 5 . 6 1 5 0 ~ 2 K ) -1 If K = 0 then Rcl = 1.2562Rc0. If K = 0.1781JsZ//x0 then Rcl = ~. (2) High magnetocrystalline anisotropy energy density. According to Brown (1969) this condition is defined by K > 0.1781J~/~0, in which case the two-domain state shown in fig. 11(b) has a lower energy than the uniformly magnetized state provided that the particle radius
58
H. ZIJLSTRA
R > Rc2, where /x0A ~/: /x0K Rc2= 56.129 ( J~s ) ( --77-+ Js 1.5708)
1/2
Note that when R > Rc2 the two-domain state has a lower energy than the uniformly magnetized state even when the material has a low magnetocrystalline anisotropy density. When K = 0, R c l = 1.2562Rc0 and Rc2 = 13.7965Rc0 ; when K = 0.1781J~//z0, Rcl = ~ and Rc2 = 14.5576Rc0 ; when K = 0.1627J~/Iz0, Rca = Rc2 = 14.5Rc0. and R c j R c 0 as functions of the parameter Graphs of the ratio R c l / R c o are shown in fig. 12. The calculations of the critical radius made by Kittel (1949) are also shown for comparison. Kittel's calculations are based on a comparison of the approximate energy of a two-domain sphere having a plane wall through the centre with the energy of a x = txoK/J~
102
two doma ~s
b
10
curling
1o.2
lo-~---~ x =.uo K/J~
10
Fig. 12. Ratios of upper bounds beyond which magnetization curling occurs, Rcl (curve a) or the two-domain state has the lowest energy, Rc2 (curve b), both with respect to the lower bound Rc0, below which the uniform state is stable, as a function of the reduced magnetocrystalline anisotropy x = t.LoK/J~. T h e critical radius separating uniform from non-uniform behaviour (Kittel's approximation) is also given as its ratio with Rc0 (curve c).
PERMANENTMAGNETS;THEORY
59
uniformly magnetized sphere. H e finds the latter to have lowest energy when #0A 1/2 /z0K 1/2
R<9tx°2Y Js =36(js)~
(Js)
where the domain wall energy 3' = 4X/A-K. H e has assumed that the magnetostatic energy of the two-domain state is approximately half of that of the uniformly magnetized state. The critical radius as determined by Kittel (1949) can be compared with Rc0 as determined by Brown as follows: R (Kittel) _ 3 6 / x 0 X / ~ / 5 . 0 9 9 ~ / / x 0 A Re0 " / Z / p, o K \ 1/2
= 7.06~-2 )
.
The ratio R(Kittel)/Rco is also shown in fig. 12 and plotted as a function of the parameter x = t~oK/J~. This line fits reasonably well between Brown's upper and lower bounds but is certainly incorrect for values of x < 0.02. Note that in all the above calculations of ratios of Rc~, Re2 and R (Kittel) with respect to Rc0 no assumption has been made about the value of A. From the above discussion it will readily be appreciated that single domain particles, i.e., particles with radius R < Rc0, are necessarily uniformly magnetized but that particles with R >Rc~ or R > R c 2 are not necessarily non-uniformly magnetized. Although the latter particles can be uniformly magnetized, the energy of that state is higher than that for the non-uniform state. Thus the uniformly magnetized state may persist if there is an energy barrier between this and the non-uniform state. This is true for a perfect single crystal in which the nucleation of a domain wall requires a finite energy for nucleation (see section 4.2). It is also possible for particles with R < R c 0 to contain domain walls provided they contain lattice defects where the domain wall energy is lower than that in the surrounding matrix. The coercivity is determined by the height of the nucleation energy barrier and hence by the presence of lattice defects and the particular magnetic spin structure of the material (see section 6.5.3). The presence of superficial features, such as scratches and sharp edges, may also influence the coercivity owing to the associated local demagnetizing fields, which may assist domain wall nucleation (see section 6.4). The coercivity can also be determined by domain wall pinning at the lattice defect (see section 6.5.2). The behaviour of the sphere for radii between Rc0 and Rcl or Rc2 is unknown, but it cannot be excluded that the magnetization alternates from the uniform to the non-uniform states. The region between Rc0 and Rcl or Rc2 is associated with the upper and lower bounds to the magnetostatic energy of the non-uniform states (Brown 1962b). If this energy is zero as is indeed the case for a cylindrical bar which demagnetizes by the curling mode, the calculation is exact, and Rc0 and Rc~ coincide and therefore correspond to a single critical rod radius (Frei et al. 1957) (see also section 5.1).
60
H. ZIJLSTRA
4.2. Brown's paradox For high anisotropy a supercritical (R > Rc2) sphere has the non-uniform multidomain mode as the lowest energy state. However, if the particle happens to be in a uniform state it cannot spontaneously transform to the lower energy state. For this a wall has to be nucleated, which means that one or several spins must start rotating. Consider one particular spin. It is subjected to an effective field H which is composed of H = HA + Hw+ Ha+ He, H A is the anisotropy field; Hw is the Weiss field, accounting for the exchange interaction between the spin and its neighbours; Ha is the demagnetizing field; He is the externally applied field. For instability of the spin it is required that
where
- (Ha + He) > HA + H w .
Now Hw is of the order of 10 9 A m -1 which far outweighs any practical value that Ha or He could reach. The conclusion is that the uniform magnetization is maintained under all circumstances and that when - H e > HA the magnetization reverses by uniform rotation. The coercivity of a spherical crystal is thus always H~=Ha, which is in obvious contradiction with experiment (see table 2). This inconsistency which is referred to as "Brown's paradox" (Shtrikman and Treves 1960) is solved by considering that lattice defects are able to reduce Hw considerably and even reverse it locally. Also HA can be influenced by a defect as the symmetry of the crystal is disturbed locally. Finally sharp edges and scratches can locally increase Ha. These matters are discussed in more detail in sections 6.4 and 6.5.
5. Coercivity associated with shape anisotropy
5.1. Prolate spheroid From calculations using micromagnetic theory Frei et al. (1957) and Aharoni and Shtrikman (1958) have shown that magnetization reversal of a prolate spheroid may occur by three basic mechanisms. These are:
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
61
(a) Uniform rotation of the magnetization for which the coercivity is equal to the anisotropy field Ho = HA = !
/Xo
(N. - N)J~,
(5.1)
where N~ and N]I are the demagnetization factors perpendicular and parallel to the major axis of the spheroid (see also sections 3.1 and 3.2). (b) Magnetization curling (see figs. l l ( a ) and 13(a)) for which the coercivity is Hc=k
Js 1 2/Zo p2,
(5.2)
where p = R/Ro, R is the minor half axis of the spheroid, R0 is a fundamental length defined by R0 = (47rtxoA/J2)1/2 and A is the exchange energy coefficient as discussed in sections 4.1 and 6.2.1. The factor k depends on the axial ratio of the spheroid and is equal to 1.08 for the infinitely long spheroid or the infinite cylinder. For the sphere k = 1.39. However, a sphere will rotate its magnetization uniformly under any applied field. Therefore its coercivity is zero. The sphere can perform a transition in zero applied field from the uniformly magnetized state to a non-uniform one by the curling process under its own demagnetizing field. The condition for this is
Js > 1 . 3 9 Js 1 3tZo 2/Xo p 2,
(5.3)
where the left-hand member is the self-demagnetizing field of the sphere and the
£1
b
c
Fig. 13. Demagnetization modes of the infinite cylinder: (a) curling; (b) twisting; (c) buckling.
62
H.' ZIJLSTRA
right-hand member follows from eq. (5.2) with k = 1.39. This is rewritten as p2 > 2.09, or
/ lzoA \ 1/2
R > 5.121--=~/
which is about the result obtained by Brown (1969) for the critical radius of a sphere (see section 4.1). It is interesting to note the similarity between the quantity R0 and the thickness of a domain wall. As discussed in section 6.2.1, the wall thickness 6 is determined by the exchange energy competing with the anisotropy energy, so that 3 c~ ~/--A/K. In the present discussion we deal with a balance between exchange energy and magnetostatic self-demagnetization energy, the latter being proportional to J2/iXo. If we substitute this for K in 6 we obtain
{ l~oA "ll/2 6 oc\ j2 ] o:Ro. (c) Magnetization buckling. This mechanism of magnetization change is shown in fig. 13(c) and is degenerate with magnetization twisting (fig. 13(b)) as first described by Kondorsky (1952). Both of these mechanisms are nearly degenerate with uniform rotation of the magnetization of an infinite cylinder with R < R0 and represent a higher energy barrier than curling does for R > R0. This is illustrated in fig. 14 where the coercivities of an infinite cylinder due to these mechanisms is shown as a function of R/Ro. The buckling and twisting mechanisms will be ignored in the present discussion. When the magnetization changes by uniform rotation the associated anisotropy energy is entirely of magnetostatic origin, whereas for magnetization curling the associated energy is entirely due to changes in the ferromagnetic exchange energy. In the latter case there is no magnetic flux leakage from the surface of the spheroid so that the magnetostatic energy is zero. This result implies that for the curling mode the coercivity is independent of the particle packing density. For the uniform rotation of the magnetization the coercivity depends on the particle packing density p (p is the ratio of the volume occupied by the particles compared with the total volume of the specimen) i.e., for a system of parallel infinite cylinders Hc = ~
1
/-/xo
Js(1 - p ) .
(5.4)
For a derivation of this result see Compaan and Zijlstra (1962). Thus in any assembly of particles the hysteretic behaviour will be determined by the magnetization reversal mechanism which has the lowest coercivity (see fig. 14). In all the above cases the particles remain uniformly magnetized until the reverse field
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
63
2 Uniform r o t a t i o n
Buckling or twisting 0.2
HC/HA
l
o,
Curling
0.05
0.02 ~- R / R o
0.01 0.2
I 0.5
i 1
i 2
t 5
10
20
50
Fig. 14. R e d u c e d coercivity He/HA due to various demagnetization m o d e s of the infinite cylinder as a function of reduced radius R/Ro.
nucleates an instability in the magnetization, which is then reversed either by a sudden uniform rotation or a curling of the magnetization. In this case the nucleation field is the same as the coercivity and the hysteresis loops are all symmetrical and rectangular. Which mechanism of magnetization reversal occurs depends on both R and p. The uniform rotation mode changes to the curling mode for a system of parallel infinite cylinders when R e > I ~~13.6 ( ~ 2A ) ,
(5.5)
which is obtained by putting Hc of eq. (5.4) greater than Hc of eq. (5.2). The critical radius for an isolated cylinder is / i,~oA \ l/2
Rc = 3.68~---f{-2)
.
If we assume that for iron A = 2 x 10-'1 Jm -1 (Kittel 1949) and Js = 2 T, the critical radius for an isolated infinite cylinder is 9 x 10-9m. For an assembly of iron cylinders with a packing density p = 2 (as it occurs for example in alnico 5) Rc ~ 16 x 10-9 m. The measured coercivity Hc for alnico 5 is about 5.5 X 104 A m -1.
64
H. ZIJLSTRA
F r o m measurements with a torque m a g n e t o m e t e r the anisotropy field H A -~ 2 x 105Am -1. The latter value is the coercivity which would be expected for uniform rotation of the magnetization. According to measurements m a d e by D e Jong et al. (1958) the rod diameters in alnico 5 are about 3 x 10 -8 m, which is too close to the calculated critical diameter to determine whether the difference between HA and Hc is due to curling or to the fact that the elongated particles are not regular in shape. More convincing evidence in support of the above theory has been provided by Luborsky and Morelock (1964) who measured the coercivities of Fe and FeCo whiskers of various diameters. The coercivities varied from 4 x 104Am -1 to 25 × 10 4 A m -1 for whisker diameters in the range 65 nm to 5 nm and are in very good agreement with the theoretical curve for the curling mechanism. For whiskers with larger diameters the experimental results deviate from the theoretical curve, due presumably to the presence of a finite magnetocrystalline anisotropy energy and to the non-circular cross section of the whiskers.
5.2. Chain of spheres The appearance of electrodeposited particles in a mercury cathode, as observed by Paine et al. (1955), inspired Jacobs and Bean (1955) to investigate theoretically the hysteretic properties of a chain of ferromagnetic spheres, consisting of an intrinsically isotropic material. The spheres touch each other but have only magnetostatic interaction. Two mechanisms of reversal are considered: (a) symmetric fanning, and (b) parallel rotation.
a
b
c
Fig. 15. Demagnetization modes of the chain of spheres: (a) symmetric fanning; (b) parallel rotation. For comparison the uniform rotation mode of the prolate spheroid of the same dimensional ratio is also indicated (c).
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
65
The coercivities of these models are compared with those of prolate spheroids of the same length-to-diameter ratio. The three models are shown in fig. 15. The symmetric fanning appears not to provide the lowest energy barrier owing to end effects that have been ignored. Taking these into account leads to a modified fanning process, called asymmetric fanning. The results of the calculations for a system of non-interacting elongated particles oriented at random are given for the various mechanisms mentioned as a function of the length-to-diameter ratio (fig. 16). The experimental points refer to samples consisting of electrodeposited elongated particles (Paine et al. 1955) with diameters lying between 14 and 18 nm. Coercivities are in good agreement with the asymmetric fanning model. However, this might be a fortuitous agreement, since the experimental spheres have certainly more than a point-like contact, and possibily exchange interaction between the spheres has to be reckoned with. The mechanism must then be something between symmetrical fanning and magnetization buckling as described in section 5.1.
a
b 0
T I
I
I
~- Elongation
Fig. 16. Coercivity of fine-particle iron oriented at random as a function of particle elongation. Chain of spheres model: (a) parallel rotation; (b) symmetric fanning; (c) asymmetric fanning. Prolate spheroid model: (d) uniform rotation. The points refer to experiments (Jacobs and Bean 1955).
66
H. ZIJLSTRA
The magnetization reversal in elongated particles has been thoroughly analyzed theoretically by Aharoni (1966).
6. Coercivity associated with magnetocrystalline anisotropy 6.1. Magnetization reversal by domain wall processes for tXoHA > Js The fundamental requirements for magnetization reversal by domain wall processes are: (a) The nucleation of a domain wall (or a reverse domain) by a nucleation field Ha which may be either positive or negative, though for high coercivities we require Ha to be large and negative.
Hn
~H
IHnl>lHpl
b
J Hp
Hn
~H
J
IHnl
Fig. 17. Hysteresis loops in relation to nucleation field H. and pinning field Hp: (a) Coercivity determined by H.; (b) Coercivitydetermined by Hp.
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
67
m
,~ B
-115
-1.10
C
P
oo-o.--=
':"
I
0.~
H 1'10
L (MA/rn) 1.5
Fig. 18. Hysteresis loop of a SmCo5 particle of 5 i~m size. After magnetizing in a strong positive field a wall is nucleated at an applied field of about -0.6MAre -1 (point A) or at an internal field of -0.8 MAm-1 (due to the self-demagnetizing field of -0.2 MAm-1). The internal curve measured after applying a weaker positive field reveals wall nucleation at zero applied field and subsequent wall detachment at about -0.35 MAre-1 applied field (point B) which means a pinning field of 0.55 MAm-~ for this particular pinning site. The curve C demonstrates the absence of strong pinning sites in a large part of the crystal (Zijlstra 1974). (b) T h e d i s p l a c e m e n t of the wall by a reverse field, if necessary by d e t a c h i n g it from its p i n n i n g sites, in which case a reverse field Hp k n o w n as the p i n n i n g field m u s t be applied. T h e resulting hysteresis loop d e p e n d s o n which of these two processes is d o m i n a n t . Schematic hysteresis loops for m a t e r i a l s in which the coercivities are principally d e t e r m i n e d by d o m a i n wall n u c l e a t i o n a n d p i n n i n g are s h o w n in fig. 17(a) a n d (b) respectively. A hysteresis loop which shows m a g n e t i z a t i o n changes c o n t r o l l e d by either n u c l e a t i o n or p i n n i n g is s h o w n in fig. 18.
6.2. The 180" domain wall 6.2.1. Energy and width of a 180 ° domain wall C o n s i d e r a 180 ° d o m a i n wall in a uniaxial f e r r o m a g n e t as d e p i c t e d in fig. 19. T h e o r i e n t a t i o n angle of the m a g n e t i z a t i o n is 0 at x = -co a n d 7r at x = +oo. T h e x-axis is n o r m a l to the wall plane. T h e m a g n e t i z a t i o n has its easy axis along the z-axis. T h e c e n t r e of the wall is at x = 0. Inside the wall the m a g n e t i z a t i o n vectors deviate from the easy axis by an angle ~, giving rise to an a n i s o t r o p y e n e r g y density WK = K sin 2 q~,
(6.1)
w h e r e ~0 d e p e n d s o n x a n d K is the a n i s o t r o p y constant. T h e m a g n e t i z a t i o n inside
68
H. Z I J L S T R A
easy axis I I
Fig. 19. Perspective view of 180 ° domain wall.
the wall is not uniform, giving rise to an exchange energy density
We=A/d ] 2
(6.2)
where A is the exchange energy coefficient. Here it is assumed that no higher terms than K occur in the anisotropy energy and that the ferromagnetic coupling is adequately described by nearest neighbour interaction. The wall energy per unit area then is Y = f_7=(W~; + We) dx,
(6.3)
with ~0 depending on x in such a way that the energy is a minimum. By using variational calculus (see e.g. Margenau and Murphy 1956), we find the Euler equation as the minimizing condition for this problem to be
d2~
K sin 2q~ - 2A ~
= 0,
stating that the torque is zero everywhere. Multiplying by dq~/dx and integrating from -oo to x we find K s i n 2~0=
A{d~] 2 \~-x] '
(6.4)
stating that the energy density due to magnetic anisotropy equals that due to exchange interaction everywhere. The relation between q~ and x follows by integration to be tan ½~o= e ~'/~ ,
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY ------7------
69 y~
Y 0 6
Ii-
Fig. 20. Distribution of spin orientation angle q~across a 180° domain wall (schematic). The width 6 of the wall is defined after Lilley (1950). where x0 = X/--A/K is called the wall thickness parameter. According to this relation a wall is infinitely thick. However, the m a j o r part of the orientation change and hence the energy is concentrated near x = 0. Following Lilley (1950) we define the wall thickness 6 as the distance between the intersections of the tangent to ~ at x = 0, with ~p = 0 and ~ = zr (fig. 20). We then find
6 = 7r~/~4/K = 7rXo.
(6.5)
The wall energy is calculated by substituting WK for We in eq. (6.3) and shifting from x to ~0 as a variable using eq. (6.4): y = 2V'A-K
L
sin ~ dq~ = 4X/A--K.
(6.6)
Equations (6.5) and (6.6) are derived under the assumption m a d e in eq. (6.2) that the magnetization is continuous, i.e., the discreteness of the lattice of magnetic atoms is ignored. This is generally allowed provided that x0 is large c o m p a r e d with the lattice p a r a m e t e r or the distance between magnetic nearest neighbours. However, this approximation gives rise to errors when x0 approaches the lattice p a r a m e t e r a, i.e., when a2K becomes comparable with A. This case of very strong anisotropy is treated in section 6.5.4. When a wall is pinned an applied field causes a contribution to the wall energy which is treated in section 6.5.2.
6.2.2. The exchange energy coefficient A 6.2.2.1. Determination of the exchange energy coefficient A fro m the Weiss internal field model of ferromagnetism. The Weiss internal field model describes the ferromagnetic interaction between localized spins in a regular lattice. A particular spin i is aligned with its nearest neighbours by an effective field per nearest neighbour j H,,j = N M / Z ,
70
H. Z I J L S T R A
where N is the Weiss field constant, M the magnetization of the crystal and Z the n u m b e r of nearest neighbours or coordination number. Consider the spin pair i, L each spin having a magnetic m o m e n t / z . They differ in orientation by an angle Aq~. The exchange energy change associated with this orientation difference can be written as wij = ~ j ~ (1 - c o s a ~ ) =
(NM/Z)tx (1 - cos 2~q~),
which for A~ ~ 1 approaches
N M , ,t ,,2 wi~ = ~ - / x t a q ~ ) . Suppose an angular gradient d~p/dx is to be present along the x direction. With a distance ~ between the two spins and an angle h between their connecting line and the x-axis we then have
NM wij = - ~ -
*2 ~t
[d~o'~2 c o s 2 ,~ \ ~ x x ]
"
This expression will be applied to various crystal lattices: (a) Body-centred cubic (bcc, fig. 21). For a bcc lattice the n u m b e r of nearest neighbours is 8, all with cos2A = ½ if the x-axis is coinciding with a cube edge.
13
Fig. 21. Body-centred cubic crystal lattice. With a being the lattice p a r a m e t e r we have ~2 = 3a2 and NM a 2 [dq~ ,~2 w,j = ---fg- ~ T Td;x ] " Per unit cell of volume a 3 there are 8 such pair interactions and two atoms contributing with 2~//z0 to the magnetization M. Substituting this and dividing by the cell volume results in the exchange energy density We due to the angular gradient d~/dx:
N M 2 az{d~ ~2
We= ~ o ~
\~xl "
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
71
Cl Fig. 22. Face-centred cubic crystal lattice.
(b) Face-centred cubic (fcc, fig. 22). For an fcc lattice the n u m b e r of nearest neighbours is 12, of which 8 with cos2A = ½ and 4 with cos2A = 0. The nearest neighbour distance is ~: = ½a~/2 in all cases. Per unit cell there are 24 pair interactions and 4 atoms. Weighting the interactions with their proper values of cos2A we find the exchange energy per unit volume NM 2
We =/z0 ~
2/d~\ 2 a I~x-x,] .
(c) Simple cubic (sc, fig. 23). For an sc lattice the n u m b e r of nearest neighbours 9i i i i i O--
•
i i - :g-'-
Q,,
PF -
-O
~×
6 Fig. 23. Simple cubic crystal lattice.
is 6, of which 2 with COS2A = 1 and 4 with COS2A = 0. The nearest neighbour distance ~: = a in all cases. Per unit cell there are six half interactions (the other halves to be attributed to adjacent cells) and only one atom. The exchange energy per unit volume is then NM 2
We = ~ o - i ~
a2{d~o'~2 \dx-x/ "
(d) Hexagonal close-packed (hcp, fig. 24). For an hcp lattice the coordination n u m b e r is 12. The nearest neighbour distance sc = a in all cases. Per unit cell there are 23 pairs, which are tabulated below together with the proper value of cos2A and the part p for which they have to be attributed to the unit cell under consideration (table 3). There are two atoms in this cell contributing 2/x/~0 to the
72
H. Z I J L S T R A
-~ - -..-- - i- ; . ~
O- . . . . .
-O-/- - / f ' -
0 /
~\ ¢_~J
\
~X
Fig. 24. Hexagonal close-packed crystal lattice.
magnetization. With these data we find for the exchange energy density
N M 2 a2[ d~o,~2 w° = ~°-J3--
\TX-x] "
If we express We in terms of the nearest neighbour distance ~: rather than the lattice p a r a m e t e r a we obtain for all four structures the same result (N6el 1944a)
NM2.2{d~ \2 we
=
.
This is not the case when we expand the structures along the vertical axis in order to obtain tetragonal symmetries from the cubic structures or to deviate from the close packing in the hexagonal case. In all these cases, however, the expressions TABLE 3 Interactions in an hcp cell. Location in cell
Number
cos2A
p
Contribution
F r o m centre plane to upper and lower planes
4
¼
1
1
2
0
1
0
In centre plane
3 2 2
1 ¼ ¼
1 ~ 1 _2
1 g 1
2 g
1 ¼
g ½
In upper and lower planes
3
1
Total contribution
3
1 1
4
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
73
for We in terms of a remain unchanged, because the expansion is perpendicular to the x-axis. If we introduce the Weiss-field energy
Ew = ½1~oNM2 we have for the coefficient A of eq. (6.2): bcc: A = ~a2Ew = l~2Ew, fcc:
A = ~2a2Ew= ~2.Ew ,
sc:
A = la2Ew = ~2Ew,
hcp:
A = {a2Ew = {sC2Ew.
6.2.2.2. Determination of the exchange energy coefficient A from the Heisenberg model of ferromagnetism. According to the Heisenberg model the ferromagnetic coupling between two spins is expressed as w~j = -2J$~ • ~ , where St and Sj are spin vectors of two neighbouring atoms and J is a coefficient called the exchange integral. For J > 0 parallel spins have minimum energy, resulting in ferromagnetic coupling. We suppose an angular gradient d~/dx to be present along the x-axis. The coupling energy between spins i and j can then be written as (d~'~ 2 Wi] = J S 2 ~ 2 COS2 a \ ~ X ] '
where sc is the distance between the spins, A is the angle between their connecting line and the x-axis, and the moduli of the spin vectors are assumed equal. In the same way as in the previous section these energy contributions are added for the various spin pairs in a crystallographic unit cell. We then find for the exchange energy density, 2 J S 2 {d~o'~ 2 bcc: We = - - 7 - ',~X ] '
4JS z {d~o"~2
fcc:
We = - - 7 - - \d--x-x) '
SC:
JS 2 {dq~'~2 we = --a- \ ~ x x j , JS22~/ 2 [ d~o'~2
hcp: W e -
a
k~xx] "
Expansion by a factor a of the vertical axis divides the coefficient of (dq~/dx) 2 by
74
H. ZIJLSTRA
the same factor a, as only the cell volume increases by this factor and the rest remains the same. The coefficients thus derived are usually written as A, e.g., by N6el and Kittel, or as C = 2A by Brown. They are associated with the Curie t e m p e r a t u r e Tc and can be determined by calorimetry, spin-wave resonance m e a s u r e m e n t s or t e m p e r a t u r e dependence of magnetization. A difficulty is that the models discussed here are based on nearest neighbour interaction, although there is much experimental evidence that interactions at a longer range cannot be ignored. Therefore determination of A will seldom be better than an indication of the order of magnitude. Using the approximate relation A~105~ZTc,
(SI),
with A in J/m, ~ the nearest neighbour distance in meters and Tc the Curie temperature in Kelvin, fulfills most requirements in the present context. In cgs units we have A in erg/cm, ~ in cm and Tc in Kelvin, for which the relation becomes A ~ 106~2Tc,
(cgs).
6.3. Interaction of domain walls with cavities and non-ferromagnetic inclusions Consider an array of non-ferromagnetic spheres on a simple cubic lattice as shown in fig. 25, and assume that the spheres have a radius p and occupy a fraction a of
radius p
0 © ©
0 0
) d
0
) t
Domain Wall
Fig. 25. Cubic array of spherical cavities interacting with a rigid domain wall.
PERMANENT
MAGNETS; THEORY
75
the total volume of the material. The n u m b e r n of spheres per unit volume is
3 n = 0, 4 . / r p 3 ,
so that the n u m b e r of spheres which are intersected by a (100) plane is given by /./2/3= { 3 ~ 2/3 0,2/3 \4~r/ p2 " The distance d between the centres of the spheres on any (100) plane is given by /4,B-'~ 1/3
If we assume that a (100) plane of these spheres is intersected by a domain wall and that the wall m a x i m u m pinning force per sphere is fm, the m a x i m u m pinning force on the wall is F = r~ .~2/3g Jm
•
If the wall is m o v e d through an infinitesimally small distance dx in the presence of an external field H, the change in magnetostatic energy is 2J~H dx. The total change in energy is d W = n2/3fm dx + 2J~H d x . T h e wall will actually m o v e if d W / d x <~O, i.e., if H ~ < - H e where
( 3 )2/3fm0,2/3 ~.
Hc = \~-~]
(6.7)
The above model has been used by Kersten (1943) as the basis of a simple theory of coercivity. Kersten assumed radii of the spheres to be much larger than the domain wall width, i.e., p ~> 6, so that the wall can be regarded as a plane of zero thickness. When a sphere is intersected by a planar domain wall, which is also assumed to be rigid, the pinning force is due to the change in the wall energy which occurs because an area ~rp2 is r e m o v e d when the wall intersects a sphere through a diameter. However, it should be appreciated that the pinning force is a m a x i m u m at the edge of the sphere where the rate of change of the wall energy with position d y / d x is a maximum. For a sphere of radius p the area of intersection with a plane domain wall changes at a m a x i m u m rate of 2~p so that the m a x i m u m pinning force fm per sphere is f~ = 2~-py.
76
H. Z I J L S T R A
Hence the coercivity for a simple cubic lattice of these spheres is given by _
He=
3 )2/3 ~-y _
4~r
_
_
^
2/3
pJs 'x
"
(6.8)
Unfortunately the above result does not agree with the experimental values for ferromagnetic materials which contain dispersions of non-ferromagnetic particles, principally because the effect of the magnetostatic energy due to the surface poles has been omitted. When the spheres, each of volume V, are not intersected by a domain wall the magnetostatic energy is 1 2 m = g/toMs V,
but when they are intersected across their major diameters the above magnetostatic energy is reduced by a factor of about 2 (N6el 1944b). This magnetostatic energy variation may not be negligible in comparison with the change in the domain wall energy. Furthermore the assumption that the domain walls are rigid is unrealistic and makes the model strongly dependent on the shape of the inclusions. 6.3.1. D o m a i n - w a l l p i n n i n g at large inclusions
N6el (1944b) has extended Kersten's theory and has developed a theory of the coercivity of an array of identical non-ferromagnetic spheres which includes the effects of their magnetostatic energies. The resulting expressions for the coercivities depend on the size of the inclusions compared with the width 6 of the domain wall. We consider large inclusions first (p >>6). Consider a non-ferromagnetic sphere in a uniformly magnetized material. The associated magnetostatic energy of the sphere due to the magnetic charges on its surface is W m = l g/x0Ms47rp/3. 2 3
When the sphere is intersected by a plane domain wall through its centre the above magnetostatic energy is reduced by a factor of about 2, i.e., AW m
. # 2s P 9171"[.ZoIVl
3•
A rigid wall moving through the crystal will have minimum energy when it intersects the spherical hole just through the centre. The force required to move it away from the centre is
f = d(Wm+ W~) dx where W~ is the contribution of the wall energy to the total energy. N6el (1944b) has numerically calculated the energy Wm as a function of wall position x and the
PERMANENT MAGNETS; T H E O R Y
77
maximum value of its derivative with respect to x, d Wm')
dx
= 0.600 j2p2,
,/max
/~0
which maximum is attained when the wall is just tangent to the sphere• With eqs. (6.7) and (6.8) we then find for the rigid wall pinned by a cubic array of spheres He = 0 385o:2/3(0 3Ms+ •
\ "
"rr'y "~
(6.9)
/xopMs]"
Note that the magnetostatic term is independent of sphere radius and that the wall energy term is inversely proportional to p. There is a critical radius pc, below which the surface energy term is dominant, and thus Kerstens theory becomes applicable. Above pe the magnetostatic term is dominant and N6eI's theory must be applied. The critical radius is pe ~
~o~/Y~
•
This value is exactly the same as that derived by Kittel (1949) for the radius below which a ferromagnetic sphere is uniformly magnetized in its lowest state (see section 4.1). In order to test the validity of eq. (6.9) we substitute the parameter values of a typical rare-earth magnet and of iron (see table 4). We then obtain for the rare-earth magnet, with a = 0 . 1 and p = 1 0 - 6 m , H e ~ 1 0 4 A m -1, which is by several orders of magnitude too low as compared with experiment. The coercivity of these magnets is obviously not determined by wall pinning at large inclusions• More likely models are discussed in sections 6.3.3 and 6.5. For iron with the same dispersion of inclusions we find He ~ 105 Am -1, which is far too high. A possible explanation for the latter discrepancy is discussed in the next section.
TABLE 4 Intrinsic properties (order of magnitude) of a typical hard magnetic material (lanthanide-cobalt alloy) and a soft magnetic material (iron). La--Co Anisotropy field HA 107 Anisotropy constant K 5 × 106 Saturation magnetization Js 1 Saturation magnetization Ms 106 Exchange parameter A 10-11 Wall energy 3' 5 x 1 0 -2 Wall thickness 6 5 x 10 -9
Fe
(SI)
La-Co
Fe
(cgs)
5 × 104 5 × 104 2 2 × 106 10-11 5 x 1 0 -3 5 x 10-8
(Am -1) (Jm -3) (T) (Am -1) (Jm -1) (Jm -2) (m)
10s 5 × 107 103
5 x 102 5 x 105 2 × 103
(Oe) (erg cm -3) (erg Oe -1 cm -3)
10-6 10-6 50 5 5 × 10-7 5 × 10 -6
(erg cm -1) (erg cm -2) (cm)
78
H. ZIJLSTRA
Fig. 26. Spherical cavity in a ferromagnetic crystal with reverse-domain spikes. The arrows indicate the domain magnetization. Concentrations of surface charges are indicated by their respective signs.
6.3.2. Nucleation of reverse domains at large inclusions If the spherical cavity is larger than the critical radius it becomes energetically favourable to provide it with a pair of reverse domain spikes as shown in fig. 26. The (dominant) magnetostatic energy is then appreciably reduced at the expense of some wall energy. The latter energy becomes less important the larger the sphere. Therefore in the magnetized crystal reverse domains may occur spontaneously at non-ferromagnetic inclusions or cavities. N6el (1944b) has shown that these reverse domains expand indefinitely when the applied field H = -H~, where Hc = 1.23y/tzopMs.
(6.10)
For the same two examples of the previous section (table 4) we calculate the nucleation coercivity at an inclusion of radius p = 10-6m and find Hc(La-Co) 5 × 104Am -1 and H c ( F e ) ~ 103 A m -1. The nucleation at an inclusion in a hard magnetic material is thus relatively easyl Inclusions of cavities should therefore be avoided or indefinite expansion of a nucleated domain should be prevented by some pinning mechanism. The spike formation at a cavity is analogous to the formation of reverse domain spikes at the flat end face of a long magnetized crystal, where as mentioned in section 6.4 the local demagnetizing field is Hd = -½Ms (see also fig. 29). 6.3.3. Domain-wall pinning at small inclusions If the inclusions are small (p ~ ~), the pinning force is due to the change in the energy of a wall which occurs when part of its volume is occupied by nonferromagnetic inclusions. Consider a spherical cavity of volume V and radius p in the magnetized crystal. If this is located inside a wall the wall energy is reduced by the following quantities: (a) (b)
exchange energy
We = a ( dq~'~2 \ d x ] V; magnetocrystalline anisotropy energy
WK = K V s i n 2 ~ .
The inhomogeneous magnetization requires a correction Wn of the order which may be neglected here since p ~ 6.
p2/t~2,
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
79
The presence of the sphere adds a certain amount of magnetostatic energy, calculated by N6el (1944b) to be (c)
2_ 2//dq~ 2] g Wa = _~/x0Ms2[1-25P \ dx ] J '
where the second term is due to the inhomogeneous magnetization with angular gradient dq~/dx. Outside the wall the magnetization is uniform and oriented along the easy axis. Hence the energies WK and We are zero and
1 2 Wd = gtx0Ms V. The difference in energy between the two situations: sphere outside wall and sphere inside wall then is
[
A W = - / K sin 2 ~0 + A
-~
dq~ 2
or using eqs. (6.3) and (6.5),
A W
=
-
[
2K +
75
B21 V sin 2 q~.
Under the present approximations, K > / x 0 M ~ and p ~ B, we may ignore the second term and find A W = -2KV
sin 2 q~.
The pinning force (using eq. (6.3) for the relation between ~0 and x) is f-
d(zX dxW ) _ 4 K V 3 / K~ sin 2 p cos p .
This is maximum for cos 2 ~ = ½so that with eq. (6.5)
sV5 K V Im-- ~ - - 'TT~-Substituting this result into eq. (6.7) we find the coercivity due to a cubic array of spheres with radius p ~ 8 as 2 K a2/3 V 1 Hc = 0.47-----0-~s p 28 = 1.95/-/1 ~ ol 2/s , where H a = 2K/~oMs, the anisotropy field.
(6.11)
80
H. ZIJLSTRA
The numerical factor of 1.95 depends on the geometry of the inclusions and their distribution, but is expected to be of the same order of magnitude for a variety of probable inclusion shapes and distributions. Using the parameters of the two examples mentioned in section 6.3.1 (table 4), we find for a dispersion of inclusions with a radius of 10 -9 m, occupying 0.1 of the material Volume H c ( L a - C o ) ~ 106Am -1 and H c ( F e ) ~ 5 0 0 A m -1. Both orders of magnitude agree well with experiment, which suggests that pinning at small inclusions might be an explanation for the observed coercivities. For this pinning mechanism it is assumed that the wall is rigid and moves through a cubic array of spheres (see fig. 25). A non-rigid wall in a random distribution of spheres is able to arrange itself so that it contains a maximum number of inclusions. The latter, a more likely picture of a pinned wall is expected to obey eq. (6.11) as well.
6.4. Domain-wall nucleation at surface defects Domain-wall nucleation may occur at surface defects such as pits, protrusions, scratches or sharp edges, where the magnetization reversal is assisted by the locally increased demagnetizing fields (Shtrikman and Treves 1960). Consider, for example, a surface defect such as a pit (fig. 27) in the form of a truncated cone with an apex semi-angle ~b, base radius r± and face radius r2. It can be shown (Zijlstra 1967) that the axial demagnetizing field Ha at the apex point P is Ha = 1Ms sin 2 q5 cos ~b ln(rl/r2).
,,//I////////////l z
\
\
Fig. 27. Surface defect.
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
81
At an infinitely sharp point, i.e., when r2 = 0, the demagnetizing field at the point P is infinite. However, as pointed out by Aharoni (1962), this is physically unrealistic since a point cannot be sharper than the atomic radius --~10-1° m. For a conical pit with a base radius of 1 p~m and sin 2 ~p cos ~b = 0.4 (i.e. ~b ~ 60 °) Ha ~ 1.8Ms. Similar demagnetizing field concentrations arise at sharp corners and edges and at the bottom of cracks and scratches. Although they are appreciably stronger than the overall demagnetizing field of a magnetized body and perfectly capable of explaining the persistence of reverse domains in soft magnetic materials (De Blois and Bean 1959) they are not sufficient to account for nucleation of reverse domains in hard magnetic crystals. However, there is experimental evidence that sharp edges do play a role in nucleating reverse domains, as demonstrated by the following experiments on SmCo5 and related compounds. Becker (1969) has measured a coercivity of 8.3kAm -1 (105 Oe) on a YCo5 powder made by mechanical grinding. Subsequent treatment in a chemical polishing solution increased the coercivity to 266 kAm -1 (3340 Oe). Becker attributed the increase to the rounding off of the initially sharp edges of the powder particles, which he observed by microscope. Ermolenko et al. (1973) prepared a single-crystal sphere of 8mCo5.3 of about 2 mm diameter. After chemical polishing the sphere had a coercivity of 460 kAm -1 (5800 Oe). Scratching the sphere reduced the coercivity to practically zero (Shur 1973) and subsequent polishing restored it again. The influence on the nature of the hysteresis loop was shown by Zijlstra (1974) who compared the hysteresis loops of two single particles taken from a ground SmCo5 powder before and after annealing (fig. 28). The coercivity of the particle as ground appeared to be determined by easy nucleation and subsequent pinning of domain walls. For the annealed particle the nucleation proved much less easy. The annealing process may have removed internal defects which also have their influence on the hysteresis. However, McCurrie and Willmore (1979) have ~hown that a similar behaviour is obtained when the particles are smoothed by chemical polishing rather than by heat treatment. A special case is the long body with a flat end face. The local demagnetization factor equals ½ at this end face, although the average demagnetization factor approaches zero for longitudinal magnetization. The associated superficial demagnetizing field may give rise to homogeneous nucleation of reverse domains as shown in fig. 29. 6.5. Interaction of domain walls with the crystal lattice 6.5.1. Wall pinning at regions with deviating K and A The nucleation of domain walls at regions with reduced K has been treated by Aharoni (1960, 1962) and Brown (1963) using micromagnetic theory, but although a nucleation field Hn of the order of one tenth of the anisotropy field HA could be derived, their model was not able to explain the many orders of magnitude
H. ZIJLSTRA
82
r~
e..
""
O
,-
©
E
o~
~E
E
r.~
r~
O
=2 o
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
83
/
/ a
Fig. 29. End surface of a magnetized body. (a) The body in cross section. Reverse-domain spikes penetrate from the surface into the body (schematic). The arrows indicate the domain magnetization. (b) Micrograph of a Sm2Co17single-crystal surface with the spikes seen from above. reduction of Hn with respect to HA f o u n d experimentally. Calculations of the pinning of d o m a i n walls at regions with r e d u c e d K and A were m o r e successfully carried out by A h a r o n i (1960), Mitzek and S e m y a n n i k o v (1969), Hilzinger (1977) and Craik and Hill (1974). W e will discuss the p r o b l e m on the basis of the t h e o r y by Friedberg and Paul (1975) of d o m a i n wall pinning at a planar defect region. Consider the crystal shown in fig. 30 in which there are three distinct regions a, b and c defined by a f r o m - ~ to Xl , b f r o m xl to x2, c from x2 to + ~ . Their magnetic properties J, K and A are identified by subscripts i = a, b and c where
Ja=Jc¢Jb, A a = A~ ¢ A b ,
g . = K ~ gu.
84
H. ZIJLSTRA Z
I
I
x
,/
c ,¸ , /
b
I a
,
\
I X2
I I Xl
Fig. 30. Domain wall distributed in three zones a, b and c of the ferromagnetic crystal.
The easy axis of the uniaxial crystal is along the z-axis; the planar defect is in the yz plane. A field H is applied along the z-axis. A 180 ° domain wall parallel to the planar defect has an energy per unit area of
f~[Ai\{d~2 d x ] + Ki sin 2 ~ - H J / c o s ~ ] dx,
Y = -~ L
(6.12)
where ~ is the angle between the magnetization vector and the z direction, and the subscript i applies to the appropriate region where the wall is located. Minimizing Y by variational calculus and integrating Euler's equations in the three regions yields the following three equations: - A i ( d ~ ' ~ 2 + Ki sin 2 ~ - HJ~ cos ~p = C~, \dx]
(6.13)
for i = a, b and c, where C~ are constants to be determined by the boundary conditions. Imposing the conditions ~ ( - ~ ) = 0 and ~p(+~)--~- and noting that d~/dx = 0 at x = _+0%determines Ca = -HJa and Cc = HJa. The'continuum approach inherent in micromagnetic methods requires continuity of ~ at the interfaces at xl and x2, where ~ has the values ~1 and q2 respectively. Stability of the wall requires zero torque everywhere and thus minimum local energy density. This requirement implies continuity of A d~/dx at the interfaces xl and x2, which can be seen from the following argument. Consider the interface of xl and a narrow zone of width Ax on either side (fig. 31). The value of z~x is so small that dq/dx may be taken as constant in each zone. The energy content of this slab is then (to a first approximation) A T = A a (~Pl - ~0a)2 ~. ( K a sin 2 f~l -- HJa c o s ~/)1) A x
Ax
+ Ab (~Pb-- ~)2 4- (Kb sin 2 ~p~-- HJb cos ~1) Ax. Ax
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
85
i i [ I
i I
i
1
I I
I I
×
Fig. 31. Orientation angle ~0as a function of distance x near the interface between zone a and zone b. Minimizing this with respect to q~l with fixed values of ~0a,~b and Ax and subsequently letting Ax approach to zero, yields
A.(~x) = Ab(~-~-~X)b at x= Xl. The difference ~ b - ~Oahas a fixed value for fixed Ax, since it determines the local exchange energy density. This must be equal to the anisotropy energy density, which is fixed by ~1 lying between ~0, and q~b,which interval can be taken arbitrarily small. Continuity of q~ and A d~p/dx at the interfaces xl and x2 produces four equations from which dq~/dx and Cb are eliminated to give a relation between q~ and ~02 with coefficients expressed in the parameters A, K, J and H : H(AaJ~ - A J b ) ]2
[cos ~, + ~ -
A--/~uJ -
[cos
H ( A a J , - AbJb) ]2
~,2 ~ 2(--X~Ka- A---~3]
(6.14)
2HAaJa - O. AaKa - AbKb
This equation describes a hyperbola shown in fig. 32. Only the upper right hand branch applies to our model. For H = 0 this curve degenerates to its asymptote cos ~j = cos ¢2. The width of the defect determines which point of the curve represents the actual situation. Narrower defects shift the point to the right. In the small-deviations approximation, A a ~ . A b , K a ~ K b and Ja-~Jb, eq. (6.14) can be written as
7)/t-x-+-k-)j = -4h
/(A_k- ,,÷) +
,
-
[cos
K,12I (6.15)
86
H. ZIJLSTRA cos %
J cos "P2 -p
\ \\
Fig. 32. The hyperbola (cos ¢1 + p)2 _ (cos ~2 + p)2_ Q = 0.
w h e r e A A = A b - - Aa, A K = Kb = K a , A J = J b - - J a and h = H/HA with H A = 2KJJa, the anisotropy field of the undisturbed crystal. T h e relation b e t w e e n go1, go2 and the width x 2 - xl of the defect is calculated by integrating eq. (6.13) for i = b:
f
x: dx = f~i2 dgo [A~ sin z go - ~
Cb 1-1/2 ' cos go - AbJ
(6.16)
dX 1
with -- AaKa sin2 gol -- ~H (AbJb -- AaJa) cos ~1 - H AAabJ Cb - AbKb Ab
H o w e v e r , this integral cannot be solved analytically and has to be approximated. First consider the case H = 0. F r o m eq. (6.14) we see that cos: go1= cos 2 go2,which means that for finite width of the defect go1 = ~ ' - ~ 2 and the wall is located symmetrically with respect to the defect (see fig. 33). Since the width of the defect is not specified this m e a n s that in zero field a wall finds an equilibrium position at a defect of any size different f r o m zero; there is no critical size for defects of this kind. M o r e o v e r this m e a n s that a field, h o w e v e r small, is n e e d e d to detach the wall f r o m the defect. N o w assume that the width D of the defect is small c o m p a r e d to the wall width 6 defined by eq. (6.5). T h e angular gradient dgo/dx m a y then be assumed constant inside the defect. F r o m eq. (6.4) in section 6.2.1 we see that d_~_~= 4 K b dx ~ sin ~ ,
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY "it-- --
--
--
87
[
0 . . . . .
I
XI
X2
--
~ X
Fig. 33. Orientation angle ~0 as a function of x of a pinned d o m a i n wall in zero field (drawn line) and
in a small positive applied field (dotted line). w h e r e we take for ~0 the average value 1(~1 + ~pz). Integrating this gives
(Abl Kb) 112 D
=
x2 -
Xl =
sin
(6.17)
l ( ~ o I -it- ~D2) (~2}2 - - ~ 0 1 ) "
N o w suppose that a small field H ~ HA is applied. F r o m eq. (6.15) we see that in the small-field, small-deviations a p p r o x i m a t i o n
COS2 ~1 -- COS2 ~2 =
-4h
/?A ~
+T
"
T h e small-defect-width a p p r o x i m a t i o n w h e r e ~92~'~-~1 allows cos 2 q~l - cos 2 ~2 ~ (~02- ~pl) sin(~j + ~2), so that by substituting this into eq. (6.17) we find
h-
7r D / A A
AK\
~- 6b t--A---+--K--) sin(qh + ¢2)sinl(qh+ ~2).
(6.18)
L o o k i n g at fig. 33 we see that u n d e r increasing field h the wall will shift to the right thus steadily decreasing the average angle of orientation ~p inside the defect. Starting from ~p = ~-/2, the position at H = 0, we see that the angular function of eq. (6.18) starts at zero and increases to a m a x i m u m of the o r d e r o n e at a certain critical value of h. F u r t h e r increase of h will give no solutions for ~1 and ~2 so that no stable wall will exist. W e identify this critical field with the unpinning field or coercive force (6.19)
88
H. ZIJLSTRA
The minus sign in eq. (6.18) implies that pinning occurs only if the form between brackets in eq. (6.19) is negative, i.e., the wall energy inside the defect is lower than if the defect were not present. If the form in brackets is positive a wall will be repelled, and the defect will form a barrier rather than a trap. It should be noted that eq. (6.19) is valid only in the small-field, small-deviations, small-defect-width approximation. If deviations become larger the symmetry in AA and AK will be lost. In particular a substantial lowering of A will contract most of the wall inside the defect so that the condition 6 >> D is no longer satisfied. This particular situation is discussed in secion 6.5.2. In the small-deviations approximation ~b may be replaed by 6a, the wall thickness in the undisturbed crystal. Note that hc falls within the small-field approximation as a direct consequence of the small-defect-width, small-deviations approximation. In this approximation a deviation of J has no influence on he. In the case where D >> ~b the wall will be almost entirely within the defect region at H = 0. With field increasing from zero we deal with a wall penetrating from region b into region c, i.e., a wall pinned by a phase boundary. Using eq. (6.13) with i = b, we impose boundary conditions ~ = 0 and d~/dx = 0 for the far left-hand end of the wall, which yields Cb = -HJb. Similarly we find with q~(+~) = 7r and d p / d x ( + ~ ) = 0 in eq. (6.13) with i = c the integration constant Cc = HJa, recalling that region c has the s a m e properties as region a. Eliminating d~o/dx from these equations we find H=
(KaAa - KbAb) sin 2 q?2 (AaJa - AbJb) COS q~2+ (AaJa -{-AbJb) '
which in the small-deviations approximation becomes
(AA/A + AK/K) sin 2 ~2 H = ½Ha(b) 2 + (AA/A + AJ/J)(1 + cos ¢2)" Looking at fig. 33 we expect that the highest rate of energy change will be found at about ¢2 = ~-/2, so that the coercivity becomes _
hc
He
HA(b)~
AK\ ~-A--+--K--)'
1/AA
(6.20)
which is the pinning force exerted upon a wall that penetrates from a phase with low A and K into a phase with high A and K. In a material as SmCo5 with HA = 2.5 x 1 0 7 A m -1 (300 kOe) this pinning mechanism could account for a coercivity of the order of 1 0 6 A m i (~104 Oe) with a 10% variation in A and K.
6.5.2. Pinning of a domain wall by an antiphase boundary This section treats a theoretical model of the interaction of a plane domain wall with a certain type of plane lattice defect, namely the antiphase boundary (APB). The A P B occurs in ordered crystals where the atomic order on either side of the
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
89
I
X X X I0 0 0 I~ I~ I~III'IX'XI'X ~ X I
x x × f×?×?×?×
~x~x~×~?x?x?×? x I
APB Fig. 34. Ferromagnetic ordered crystal with magnetically active antiphase boundary (APB). A P B is opposite in phase. This is clarified in fig. 34 for a two-dimensional binary crystal consisting of A atoms (circles) and B atoms (crosses). The crystal lattice is continuous, but on the right-hand side of the defect B atoms occupy what would have been A sites without the presence of the APB, and vice versa. Suppose now that only the A atoms carry a magnetic m o m e n t and that these are coupled ferromagnetically in the undisturbed crystal. However, across the A P B the much shorter A - A distance might give rise to antiferromagnetic coupling, thus dividing the crystal into two ferromagnetic parts which, in the lowest state and zero field, are antiparallel as indicated in fig. 34. It has been suggested by Zijlstra (1966) that such magnetically active A P B s are responsible for the easy nucleation of reverse domains in MnA1 crystals. On the other hand it was expected that moving domain walls would encounter strong pinning, which was indeed found to exist in MnA1 crystals (Zijlstra and Haanstra 1966). Consider a magnetic domain wall as described in section 6.2.1 with its plane parallel to an A P B as described above. T h e orientation angle of the magnetization is 0 at x = - ~ and ~r at x = + ~ . The A P B is located at x = 0 and coincides with the y z plane. The ferromagnet has uniaxial anisotropy with the z-axis as easy axis. The energy densities due to anisotropy and to exchange interaction are described by eqs. (6.1) and (6.2), respectively. T h e coefficients K and A are assumed to be the same throughout the crystal, except for the APB. The situation at the A P B is described as two layers of atoms, at a distance ~, one belonging to the left-hand side of the crystal and the other to the right-hand side. The coupling energy density between these two adjacent lattice planes, is different from the coupling energy density in the undisturbed crystal owing to shorter A - A distance and is given by At w~ = g ~ - [1 - c o s ( ~ , 2 - ~ , ) ] ,
(6.21)
where pl is the orientation of the left-hand layer and ~2 that of the right-hand layer. The coefficient A ' is different from A and can be negative, in which case antiparallel coupling across the A P B is favoured. The structure of the wall in an arbitrary position with respect to the A P B is shown in fig. 35 by the orientation
90
H. Z I J L S T R A
J
0
-×
Fig. 35. Orientation angle p as a function of distance x normal to a domain wall pinned at APB.
angle q~ as a function of x. T h e wall energy per unit area can then be written as 3' = 2X/)-K(1 - cos q~,) + 2 X / ~ ( 1
+ cos q~2)
+ (A'/sc)[1 - cos(~2 - ~01)] nt- ½K~(sin 2 ~, + sin 2 (P2).
(6.22)
T h e first two terms follow by integrating eq. (6.6) from 0 to ~1 and f r o m q~2 to ~, respectively. T h e third term is the exchange coupling energy in the slab of thickness ~ at the A P B and the last term accounts for the anisotropy energy in the same slab. N o w approximating to continuous magnetization with the A P B as a mathematical plane of zero thickness (~: ~ 0) where the j u m p in p is concentrated, we can ignore the anisotropy energy term and write (omitting constant terms) 3' = x/)-g
2(cos q~2- cos ~1) - r/cos(r/2
-- ~1)
(6.23)
where the coefficient r / = A'/~X/--A-K can take values f r o m -oo to 0 for antiparallel coupling, and f r o m 0 to +o0 for parallel coupling across the A P B . F o r r / ~ oo the difference between q~l and q~2 vanishes and we have the undisturbed wall with 3' = 4X/A--K following from eq. (6.22). Using standard differential calculus with respect to the two variables ~pl and q~2 we find for r / > 1 stability at cos qh = l/r/ and cos ~0z = - l / r / , i.e., the wall is pinned with its centre coinciding with the A P B . F o r r / < 1 the wall collapses into the A P B with q~l = 0 and ~2 = ~r. Such a d e g e n e r a t e d wall will still be called a wall here. T h e energy of the pinned wall follows f r o m eq. (6.22) with the a p p r o p r i a t e values of cos ~01 and cos q~2 substituted as
y = 4 ( 1 - 1/2r/)N/)--K,
for
and T=2r/X/A--K,
for
r/
r/> 1
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
91
-5
I
1'0
"-5
--10
Fig. 36. Energy ~/of domain wall pinned at A P B in zero field as a function of the coupling p a r a m e t e r ~7 across the APB.
These relations are shown in fig. 36. N o t e that there is no discontinuity at r / = 1, neither in value, nor in slope. Since we have chosen the uniformly magnetized state with q~l = ~02 = 0 as the g r o u n d state with zero energy, the wall e n e r g y goes to - ~ when ~ / ~ - ~ . This m e a n s that eventually the pinning b e c o m e s infinitely strong. T h e d o m a i n wall is thus pinned at the A P B for any value of r/ in zero field. To calculate the field that must be applied to detach the wall, we first have to see h o w the pinned wall behaves in an applied field.
Energy of a pinned wall in an applied field. Consider a part of a wall stretching f r o m x = - w where q~ = 0, to x = 0 w h e r e q~ = ~00. T h e angle ~0 is kept fixed and the wall e n e r g y is calculated as a function of the f i e l d / - / a p p l i e d along the positive z direction. T h e energy of this partial wall is Y(~o, H ) =
F[
K sin e ~ + HJ(1 - cos ~ ) + A [ d~'~2]
\ d x ] J dx,
(6.24)
where J is the saturation magnetization and the o t h e r symbols are as m e n t i o n e d before. With variational calculus we find the condition for m i n i m u m energy to be
d2~p
2 K sin ~ cos ~ + H J sin ~p - 2 A ~
= 0,
which states that the t o r q u e is zero everywhere. Multiplication by dq~/dx and integration f r o m - ~ to 0 give
92
H. ZIJLSTRA
{dq~ ,~2 K sin 2 q~0+ HJ(1 - cos q~0)= A \d-x-x] " Substituting this into eq. (6.24) and switching f r o m x to ¢ as variable we have Y(q~o, h) = 2 ~/ A K
(1 - -
fO~°
COS 2 ~ - -
2h cos q~ + 2h) u2 d~o
= -2{[cos 2 Po + 2(h + 1) cos q~0+ 2h + 1] 1/2- 2(h + 1) 1/2 + h ln[(cos 2 ~o + 2(h + 1) cos q~o+ 2h + 1) 1/2 + cos ¢o + h + 1] - h In[2(h + 1) 1/2+ h + 2]}, where h
=
(6.25)
H/HA, and HA = 2 K / J is the anisotropy field.
Detachment of a pinned wall. Consider the wall in zero field symmetrically pinned at x = 0 with q~2= ~" - qh. A field applied along the z axis will rotate ~Pl and q~2 towards 0, i.e., the centre of the wall will be shifted from x = 0 to the right in fig. 35. If the field is varied f r o m zero to increasing positive values, the force exerted on the wall will increase, at first being in equilibrium with the rate of change of wall energy. But as the latter quantity reaches a m a x i m u m a further increase of the field detaches the wall from its pinning site and makes it travel to infinity. T h e total energy of the wall when pinned is
3' : 3'(~1, h)+ 3'(¢2, h ) - n V ~
cos(~2- ~1),
where 7(qh, h) follows from eq. (6.25) with qh substituted for q~0, and 7(qh, h) follows by substituting 7r - q~2 for ~0 and - h for h. T h e m i n i m u m of 3' with respect 1
0.5
\
\
0.2
0.1
\
\
0.05
\
\
0.02
\
0.01 0.1
0.2
0.5
1
2 _
F i g . 37. R e d u c e d
c o e r c i v i t y h0 =
5 ~
Ho/HA d u e
10
20
50
100
r]
to pinning at APB
a s a f u n c t i o n o f 7.
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
93
to the independent variables ~01 and ~02 is sought and the critical value h~ of h where this extreme ceases to be a minimum is determined. This critical value h~ is identified with the unpinning field or the coercivity and its relation with r/ is shown in fig. 37. The curve applies only to positive values of ~7. At negative 7/ the zero field values of q~l and ~2 are 0 and ~-, respectively, and it would take a stronger field than h = 1 to detach the wall. However, at h = 1 uniform rotation occurs and the whole concept of wall detachment becomes irrelevant. 6.5.3. Nucleation of a domain wall at an antiphase boundary Consider the crystal of fig. 34 with the coupling p a r a m e t e r ~7 at its A P B smaller than zero. If a strong positive field is applied a situation occurs as depicted in fig. 38(a). This is a m o r e or less saturated state which is stable, though not always of the lowest energy, for all positive values of h including zero. If a counter field of increasing strength is applied tO this state there is a critical value hc of - h at which the symmetric configuration becomes unstable and a wall is emitted from the defect, leaving the defect itself with an antiparallel magnetization orientation as given in fig. 38(b). The relation between the critical field hc and the coupling constant is calculated in the following. Consider the configuration of fig. 38(a) in a field h. Near the A P B there are two partial domain walls separated by an angle (~;2-~pl). The energy of this configuration is T = Y(~I, h ) + T(q~2, h ) - 7/N/A--K cos(~2 - ~1), where ~/ is a negative n u m b e r and Y(q~l, h) and 7(q~2, h) are given by eq. (6.25) with @1 and q~2 respectively substituted for ~P0. For equilibrium the partial derivatives of y with respect to the independent variables ~/91and q~2 must be zero. Since in equilibrium q)l --@2 for symmetry reasons, these two conditions reduce to one: ~
2(1 - cos 2 q~l- 2h cos ~pl+ 2h) 1/2+ ~ sin 2q~1 = 0.
(6.26) q~
q01
-~ x
r
a Fig. 38. (a) Magnetization orientation near A P B after saturation in a strong positive field. (b) Wall emitted from A P B by a negative field moves to the right, leaving the A P B in antiparallel configuration.
94
H. Z I J L S T R A
The value of q~a in the remanent state (h = 0) is given by cos ¢~ = 1
for
0 > 7 > -1
cosqh=-l/7
for
7<-1-
By investigating second derivatives we find that the equilibrium of eq. (6.26) loses its stability when cos q~l + h ~<0. This gives a simple relation between the critical field hc and the critical angle qh: he
=
cos q~l •
Elimination of ~1 from this formula and eq. (6.26) then gives the relation between hc and 7 as shown in fig. 39. The nucleation described here occurs only for negative values of 7 and at a negative field which approaches zero for large negative values of 7/. The Lorentz microscope observations by Lapworth and Jakubovics (1974) and by Van Landuyt et al. (1978) of the APBs in thin slices of MnA1 crystals being always decorated by a domain wall are explained by assuming that a strong negative coupling at the APB is present. 6.5.4. Thin-wall coercivity in a perfect crystal In crystals with a very high magnetocrystalline anisotropy constant K, comparable to the energy density A / a 2 due to the exchange coupling, the wall thickness t~ = 7r~v/A/K according to eq. (6.5) becomes of the order of the lattice parameter a. In this case we must abandon the continuum approach of section 6.2.1 and take into account the discreteness of the crystal lattice. It then turns out that there is a difference in energy between a wall with its centre coinciding with a lattice 1 0.5
02
\
ho l
0.1
"..
0.05
0.02 0.01
0.1
\ 0.2
0.5
1
2
5
10
20
50
100
Fig. 39. R e d u c e d c o e r c i v i t y hc d u e to n u c l e a t i o n of a wall at A P B as a function of - 7 .
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
9_
95
b
Fig. 40. Spin orientation in domain wall of fig. 19 viewed along a row of atoms normal to the wall plane. (a) High-energy transitional position. (b) Low-energy stable position. plane and a wall with its centre just b e t w e e n two lattice planes. T h e two situations are shown in fig. 40(a) and (b), where the (b) configuration has the lowest energy. T h e energy difference gives rise to pinning of the wall (Zijlstra 1970a). T o calculate the wall e n e r g y we divide the wall along its thickness into three zones: two continuous zones away from the centre, where the angle b e t w e e n adjacent spins is small, and a central zone of N + 2 discrete magnetic m o m e n t s . T h e continuous zones end in the first (or, as the case m a y be, the last) discrete m o m e n t (fig. 41). T h e energy of this wall in a field h along the z-axis is 7 = y(q~0, h ) + ')/(~DN+I,h)
hK(2- cos q~0- cos q~N+I) + ~, [aKsin2~i+2~A{1-cos(¢i-~oi-1)}+2 h K ( 1 - cos ~i)l + laK(sin2 q~0+ sin 2 q~N+l)+
i=1
-1-
a
2A a
{1 -- COS(@N+
I
i
i
I
t
1
(6.27)
1 -- qON)} ,
I
I
I
I
x\
Fig. 41. Domain-wall model consisting of centre part with discrete spins sandwiched between continuous zones.
96
H. Z I J L S T R A
where y(q~0, h) is given by eq. (6.25) and 7(~Pl, h) follows from eq. (6.25) by substituting (Tr - ~N+I) for ¢P0 and - h for h. The third term accounts for half of the anisotropy energy of the spins 0 and N + 1, the other half being included in the continuous zones. Similarly the fourth term accounts for the magnetostatic energy of the same spins in the field h = HJ/2K (where J is the saturation magnetization per unit volume). The fifth term is the sum of the anisotropy energy and the magnetostatic energy of the spins 1 to N and the exchange-coupling energy between spins 0 to N. The last term adds the exchange-coupling energy between spins (N + 1) and N. The energy difference between the two spin configurations of fig. 40 in zero field has been calculated by Van den Broek and Zijlstra (1971) by minimizing eq. (6.27) with h = 0 for variations of ~i. The result is given in fig. 42 where the energy barrier is plotted as a function of ~7 = a2K/A. The angle between the two central spins of the wall in its lowest state is shown in fig. 43 as a function of ~7. For values of ~7 greater than 4 the wall collapses to a configuration with one part of the spins oriented in the + z direction and the rest in the - z direction. The critical field hc required to let the wall pass the energy barrier is calculated by minimizing eq. (6.26) and finding the value of h for which the equilibrium becomes unstable. The result is given in fig. 44 where log hc is plotted as a function of r/. With increasing ~7 we see that a sharp rise occurs at r / ~ 1. This phenomenon is indeed found to occur in a family of lanthanide-transition metal compounds investigated by Buschow and Brouha (1975) and Brouha and Buschow
v
10-1 aK
10-2
10.3
10-~
10-5 t o
1
2
3
/.
_-~rt
Fig. 42. Energy difference between configurations of fig. 40(a) and (b) as a function of ~t =
a2K/A.
PERMANENT
MAGNETS;
THEORY
97
TC
3
&,.p
1
0
I
I
I
I
I
I
1
I
~
~
I
2
~-rt F i g . 43. A n g l e b e t w e e n
t h e t w o c e n t r a l s p i n s in t h e c o n f i g u r a t i o n field.
o f fig. 4 0 ( b ) as a f u n c t i o n o f r/ a t z e r o
1
f 0.5 hc 0.2
j
O.OE
0.02
O.Ol o.1
0.2
0.5
5
1
10
20
50
100
Dq.
F i g . 44. R e d u c e d
c o e r c i v i t y hc =
He~HA as a f u n c t i o n o~ r/.
(1975). Their results are summarized in fig. 45, in which the coercivities of various compounds measured at 4 K are plotted as a function of HA/Ixs, where /zs is the magnetic m o m e n t per formula unit. This variable can be rewritten as HAI.~J~, in which expression the n u m e r a t o r is proportional to K and the denominator is proportional to A. There is only qualitative agreement since the proportionality factor between K/A in the model and HA/I~ in the experiment is not known.
98
H. ZIJLSTRA 30 - [kOe)
/A
o y (Co,Ni)s x Th {Co,Ni)s ,, Lo (Co,Ni)5
/
/ / /
2c
I I,,
"1
ac
I ~o
I I 4 I
°o
i
10
°° ':'~
x ~
I
2 50 30 0 (kOe/jaB ) HA/-IJs / F.U./
20
"
Fig. 45, Coercivity of various lanthanide-transition metal compounds at liquid helium temperature, as a function of HA/t~s, which variable is proportional to ~7 (Buschow and Brouha 1975, Brouha and Buschow 1975). Thin-wall pinning is a homogeneous process where the wall is stationary below the critical field and moves to disappear beyond this field. This gives rise to typical rectangular hysteresis loops as observed by Barbara et al. (1971) on Dy3A12 and by Buschow and Brouha (1975). The similarity between thin-wall pinning at the atomic lattice and the Peierls force in the description of moving dislocations in crystals has been discussed by Weiner (1973) and by Hilzinger and Kronmfiller (1973). Thin-wall pinning in dysprosium crystals was observed and discussed by Egami and G r a h a m (1971). Hilzinger and Kronmfiller (1972) applied the model to the lattice of RCo5 compounds (R = rare-earth element) taking into account various orientations of the wall plane with respect to the crystal axes. Quantitative comparison with experiment is h a m p e r e d by insufficient knowledge of the magnitude of A and is particularly difficult when m o r e than one kind of magnetic atom or m o r e than one nearest neighbour distance is present. Also exchange coupling between other than adjacent atoms, which is not u n c o m m o n in intermetallic compounds, complicates the matter considerably. 6.5.5. Partial wall pinning at discrete sites When a wall is pinned at discrete sites with the parts in between free to move like a stretched m e m b r a n e the coercivity is determined by the competition between the magnetic pressure on the entire wall and the local pinning forces at the pinning sites. Consider a wall pinned at certain sites (fig. 46). Between the pinning sites the wall is free to move under the influence of a field H to form cylindrical
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY
99
Q7 Fig. 46. Wall pinned at discrete sites and bulging under the pressure of an applied field. surfaces if it is pinned to parallel line defects, or look like a padded surface if it is pinned to point defects. In both cases its area S varies by an amount (per unit S ) ,
A S = o l ( x / a )2
where x is the m a x i m u m displacement, a is the distance between the pinning sites, and a is a geometrical factor of the order one. At the same time a volume A V reverses its magnetization direction: AV=/3x
(per unit S),
where /3 is another geometrical factor of the order one. The energy of the magnetic system varies by AE
= yAS
- 2HJ
= ay(x/a)
A V
2 - 2flHJx,
(6.28)
where J is the saturation magnetization and y is the wall energy. If the wall is not parallel to the magnetization direction a magnetostatic term is contributed to the wall energy. This situation occurs with the " p a d d e d surface" and also with cylindrical surfaces whose axes deviate from the magnetization direction. However, when the anisotropy field is large compared with the demagnetizing field, i.e., K > 210 J2 ,
100
H. ZIJLSTRA
as is the case in the hard magnetic materials discussed here, the magnetostatic contribution is small compared with the wall energy and may be ignored (Zijlstra 1970b, Hilzinger and Kronmfiller 1976). The equilibrium position of the wall follows by minimizing h E with respect to x for fixed H : (6.29)
x = HYa2/y,
where a and/3 are taken equal to one. When H is increased until it reaches the pinning field strength Hp the wall is about to leave its pinning sites. The force exerted on these sites by the wall is determined by the wall energy y and by the boundary angle ~0 (see fig. 46). This angle is geometrically connected with the ratio x/a, and the pinning field strength Hp can thus be related to a critical value (x/a)~rit which is a property of the pinning sites. The coercivity H~ then follows from eq. (6.29)
Hc = ~aa
(x)
crit"
(6.30)
This formula is not to be taken too seriously in view of the many assumptions made. However, the inverse proportionality of Hc with the distance a between the defects implies n c o( /,/1/3
where n is the density of point defects distributed in a regular array. If the defects are distributed at random one might expect different results. Hilzinger and Kronmiiller (1976) have made computer simulations of a moving wall pinned by randomly distributed centres and found empirical proportionalities of Hc with n x, with x ranging from 0.5 for weak pinning to 1.5 for strong pinning. Any distribution of the inter-defect distance will give rise to a lowest unpinning field, at which the wall will be detached somewhere. In the new wall position there will again be a lowest unpinning field, which is not necessarily stronger than the previous one. By this the observed coercivity will be lower than which follows from the average a. Moreover, thermal fluctuations will cause wall creep at fields weaker than the coercivity. Small applied-field fluctuations may have the same effect. For this reason permanent magnets with their coercivity based upon wall pinning at point or line defects must be considered as less stable than other magnets. Substantial wall creep has been observed in copper-containing rare-earth permanent magnet alloys which, indeed, have their coercivity determined by wall-pinning at precipitates (Mildrum et al. 1970).
7. Influence of temperature In the foregoing sections relations between coercivity and intrinsic properties like anisotropy, magnetization and exchange coupling energy have been discussed.
PERMANENT
MAGNETS;
THEORY
101
The t e m p e r a t u r e dependence of the coercivity can be determined by measuring the t e m p e r a t u r e dependences of the relevant intrinsic properties and using these in the appropriate equations. However, by this procedure the discussion remains essentially at zero t e m p e r a t u r e in the sense that thermal agitation of magnetization orientation or wall position is ignored. This thermal agitation may lower the coercivity and, moreover, give rise to time effects like wall creep or magnetic viscosity. These time effects render a magnet unstable and should thus be avoided. In this section we shall discuss and estimate roughly where the danger zones are. For a critical review of theories pertaining to magnetic fluctuations the reader is referred to Brown (1965, 1979). The n u m b e r of thermally excited events to occur per second is given by p = v e -aE/kr,
(7.1)
where v is a frequency factor, indicating how m a n y times per second the event could occur and AE is the energy barrier which the system under consideration has to overcome for the event to occur. The barrier AE is c o m p a r e d with the average energy of thermal motion kT, where k is Boltzmann's constant and T the absolute temperature. At r o o m t e m p e r a t u r e k T ~ 4 x 1 0 -21 J. First we consider the case of an isolated particle with shape or magnetocrystalline anisotropy as discussed in sections 3.2 and 3.3. The thermal motion of the magnetization orientation is expected to have peak amplitude at the precessional resonance of the magnetic vector in the anisotropy field. This field will be of the order of 105-107 A m -1, thus giving rise to ferromagnetic resonance at 101°-1012 s -1. W e take these frequencies as the frequency v in eq. (7.1). W e now compare two situations: a highly unstable one with p = 10 s-1 and a practically stable one with p = 1 0 . 7 s -1. For these situations we calculate the required barrier height AE using the values for u and k T mentioned (table 5). There are two points worth noting: (a) The value of AE is not sensitive to the choice of v and (b) p has a very strong dependence on AE, establishing a critical value AE-~ 10 19j below which the system is thermally unstable at r o o m t e m p e r a t u r e and beyond which it is stable. The barrier A E against rotation of the magnetization vector is associated with the anisotropy constant K and the particle volume v AE = Kv.
TABLE 5 I n s t a b i l i t y of m a g n e t i c particle d u e to t h e r m a l a g i t a t i o n at r o o m t e m p e r a t u r e .
p (S 1) 10 10 -7
/,' (s-l) 101° 1012 101° 1012
AE (j) 0.8 1.0 1.6 1.7
x 10 -19 X 10 19 X 10 -lv x 10 -19
102
H. Z I J L S T R A
For shape anisotropy K = 1 0 6 J m -3, which determines a lower limit for v = 10 -25 m 3 for stability. In alnico the elongated precipitates have a v o l u m e of the order of 10 -24 m 3, which is above the critical value. H o w e v e r , Street and W o o l l e y (1949) have o b s e r v e d viscosity effects in alnico which might be ascribed to this relaxation effect. In any case, the barrier is lowered by an applied counter-field as discussed in section 3.1 and b e c o m e s zero at He. So viscosity effects, h o w e v e r small, are to be expected near the coercive field strength. F o r magnetocrystalline anisotropy, K ~ 107jm -3, which determines a lower limit of v = 10-26m 3 for stability. M a g n e t s based on magnetocrystalline anisotropy always consist of fine powders, often sintered to a dense body. T h e crystallite size of these magnets is typically 10-7-10 -6 m, which means a particle volume of 10-21-10 -18 m 3, well a b o v e the critical volume. A n o t h e r case to consider is the thermal activation of wall displacement. A wall pinned over its entire area has in its potential well a resonance frequency given by
{dZY/m)l/2 w = \dx2 / ,
(7.2)
where 3' is the wall energy as a function of the distance x from its pinning site and m is the wall mass associated with the precessional m o t i o n of spins inside a moving wall. For 3' we write arbitrarily
y(x) = a70
+ (1 - a ) y 0 ,
(7.3)
which means that 3' is lowered by a fraction a at the pinning site and is equal to its undisturbed value 3'o when it is displaced by half the thickness 6 of the undisturbed wall. T h e effective mass of a wall has been discussed by D 6 r i n g (1948). F r o m his work we have the relation
47r/z0 (
m - 2c~26
1
)
= 2 a 2 6 , cgs ,
(7.4)
where a is the g y r o m a g n e t i c ratio of the spins in the wall. Substituting eqs. (7.3) and (7.4) into eq. (7.2) and using eqs. (6.5) and (6.6) we have o) ~- ( a o l 2 K X 106) 1/2 ,
where K is the magnetocrystalline anisotropy constant. With K = 107 Jm -3, a = 2 × 105 m A -1 s -1 and a = 0.1 we calculate w ~6x
10 ~°s -~,
or ~ 10 lo s-1 ,
P E R M A N E N T MAGNETS; T H E O R Y
103
to be used in eq. (7.1). Now consider a part of the wall of area S displaced by a distance ½6 from its pinning site (fig. 47). This excitation requires an energy of A E = 7 ( a S + 28X/S),
(7.5)
in which the second term accounts for the peripheral wall that has to be made. W e may safely assume that an excitation with S < 62 will not give rise to an increasing unpinning of the wall. We thus take the energy of an excitation with S = 62 as the minimum 2~E for wall detachment and see whether this may occur at r o o m temperature. The activation energy for this excitation is A E = 23/6 2 ~ 20A6,
where the fraction a is ignored with respect to 2 and y6 is replaced by the exchange p a r a m e t e r A times 10 (eqs. (6.5) and (6.6)). With A ~ 10 -11Jm -1 and a ~ 10 -s m, as it is in highly anisotropic materials like SmCos, we have AE 10 -18 J. Substituting this into eq. (7.1) with the value of v = 10 l° s -1 we obtain the n u m b e r of these excitations per second: p=
10 -207S 1,
which means that in this example no thermal instability will occur. In materials with extremely high anisotropy we have very thin walls of the order of the lattice p a r a m e t e r as discussed in section 6.5.4. These walls are pinned by the atomic lattice and we consider the excitation of a wall area with S large
\, UFeU
S
pinning site Fig. 47. Part of wall area S displaced by half its thickness ~ from its pinning site.
104
H. ZIJLSTRA
c o m p a r e d with the lattice p a r a m e t e r squared, S>> ~2. W e e s t i m a t e the wall r e s o n a n c e f r e q u e n c y . T h e e n e r g y as a f u n c t i o n of wall position x is, to a first approximation,
[2X\ 2
3'(x) = a3"o~--~.-) + (1 - a)3'0 ,
(7.6)
a n a l o g o u s to eq. (7.3) b u t n o w with half the lattice p a r a m e t e r ~: as the excursion for which 3' has the value 3'0. W i t h 6 = 10 -9 m, ~ = 3 x 10 -20 m, 3'0 = 10 -2 J m -2 a n d a = 0.1 we calculate, using eqs. (7.2), (7.4) a n d (7.6), that w ~ 3 x 10 22s -1 or 1-'~'1012S 1. T h e activation e n e r g y for the excitation is
A E = a3"oS, which has to b e smaller t h a n 10-29J to p e r m i t m o r e t h a n o n e excitation per second. W i t h the a s s u m e d values for a a n d 3'0 this gives a m a x i m u m value for the wall area i n v o l v e d of S = 10-27 m 2 , which is by two orders of m a g n i t u d e m o r e t h a n ~2 a n d thus c o n s i s t e n t with o u r p r e s u p p o s i t i o n . T h e c o n c l u s i o n is that in materials with thin wall coercivity t h e r m a l excitations m a y well occur that give rise to wall creep. Such creep has b e e n observed, a.o., by B a r b a r a a n d U e h a r a (1976) a n d H u n t e r a n d T a y l o r (1977). E g a m i (1973) has w r i t t e n an extensive theoretical t r e a t m e n t of the creep of thin walls, taking into a c c o u n t b o t h t u n n e l l i n g a n d t h e r m a l excitation.
References Aharoni, A. and S. Shtrikman, 1978, Phys. Rev. 109, 1522. Aharoni, A., 1960, Phys. Rev. 119, 127. Aharoni, A., 1966, Phys. Stat. Sol. 16, 3. Aharoni, A., 1962, Rev. Mod. Phys. 34, 227. Barbara, B., B. B6cle, R. Lemaire and D. Paccard, 1971, J. Physique, C1-1971, 299. Barbara, B. and M. Uehara, 1977, Physica (Netherlands) 86-88 B + C, 1477, (Proc. Int. Conf. Magn., Amsterdam, 1976). Becket, J.J., 1969, IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-5, 211. Berkowitz, A.E., J.A. Lahut, I.S. Jacobs, L.M.
Levinson and D.W. Forrester, 1975, Phys. Rev. Lett. 34, 594. Brouha, M. and K.H.J. Buschow, 1975, IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-11, 1358. Brown Jr., W.F., 1957, Phys. Rev. 105, 1479. Brown Jr., W.F., 1962a, Magnetostatic Principles in Ferromagnetism (North-Holland, Amsterdam). Brown Jr., W.F., 1962b, J. Phys. Soc. Japan, 17, Suppl. B-I, 540. Brown Jr., W.F., 1963, Micromagnetics (Interscience/Wiley, New York).
PERMANENT MAGNETS; THEORY Brown Jr., W.F., 1965, in: Fluctuation Phenomena in Solids, ed., R.E. Burgess (Academic Press, New York) p. 37. Brown Jr., W.F., 1969, Ann. New York Acad. Sci. 147, 463. Brown Jr., W.F., 1979, IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-15, 1196. Buschow, K.H.J. and M. Brouha, 1975, AIP Conf. Proc. 29, 618. Compaan, K. and H. Zijlstra, 1962, Phys. Rev. 126, 1722. Craik, D.J. and E. Hill, 1974, Phys. Lett. 48A, 157. De Blois, R.W. and C.P. Bean, 1959, J. Appl. Phys. 30, 225S. De Jong, J.J., J.M.G. Smeets and H.B. Haanstra, 1958, J. Appl. Phys. 29, 297. De Vos, K.J., 1966, Thesis Tech. Univ. Delft. D6ring, W., 1948, Z. Naturf. 3a, 373. Edwards, A., 1962, Magnet Design and Selection of Material, in: Permanent Magnets, ed., D. Hadfield (Iliffe, London) p. 191. Egami, T. 1973, Phys. Status Solidi (13) 57, 211. Egami, T. and C.D. Graham Jr., 1971, J. Appl. Phys. 42, 1299. Ermolenko, A.S., A.V. Korolev and Y.S. Shur, 1973, Proc. Int. Conf. on Magn., Moskow, 1973, Vol. I(2), p. 236. Frei, E.H., S. Shtrikman and D. Treves, 1957, Phys. Rev. 106, 446. Friedberg, R. and D.I. Paul, 1975, Phys. Rev. Lett. 34, 1234. Hilzinger, H.R., 1977, Appl. Phys. 12, 253. Hilzinger, H.R. and H. Kronmfiller, 1972, Phys. Status Solidi (B) 54, 593. Hilzinger, H.R. and H. Kronmfiller, 1973, Phys. Status Solidi (B) 59, 71. Hilzinger, H.R. and H. Kronmfiller, 1976, J. Magn. Magn. Mat. 2, 11. Hunter, J. and K.N.R. Taylor, 1977, Physica (Netherlands) 86-88 B + C (1), 161 0aroc. Int. Conf. Magn., Amsterdam, 1976). Jacobs, I.S. and C.P. Bean, 1955, Phys. Rev. 100, 1060. Jonas, B. and H.J. Meerkamp van Embden, 1941, Philips Tech. Rev. 6, 8. Kersten, M., 1943, Phys. Z. 44, 63. Kittel, C., 1949, Rev. Mod. Phys. 21, 541. Kondorsky, E., 1952, Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR, 80, 197 and 82, 365. Lapworth, A.J. and J.P. Jakubovics, 1974, Proc. 3rd. Eur. Conf. on Hard Magn. Mat., Amsterdam, 1974, p. 174. Lilley, B.A., 1950, Phil. Mag. 41, 792.
105
Luborsky, F.E. and C.R. Morelock, 1964, J. Appl. Phys. 35, 2055. Luteijn, A.I. and K.J. de Vos, 1956, Philips Res. Rep. 11, 489. McCurrie, R.A. and L.E. Willmore, 1979, J. Appl. Phys. 50, 3560. Margenau, H. and G.M. Murphy, 1956, The Mathematics of Physics and Chemistry (2nd ed.) (Van Nostrand, Princeton) p. 198. Martin, D.L. and M.G. Benz, 1971, Cobalt No. 50, 11. Meiklejohn, W.H. and C.P. Bean, 1957, Phys. Rev. 105, 904. Mildrum, H., A.E. Ray and K. Strnat, 1970, Proc. 8th Rare Earth Research Conf., Reno, 1970, p. 21. Mitzek, A.I. and S.S. Semyannikov, 1969, Soviet Physics-Solid State 11, 899. N6el, L., 1944a, Cahiers de Physique, No. 25, 1. N6el, L., 1944b, Cahiers de Physique, No. 25, 21. N6el, L., 1954, J. Phys. Radium 15, 225. Ojima, T., S. Tomizawa, T. Yoneyma and T. Hori, 1977, Japan J. Appl. Phys. 16, 671. Paine, T.O., L.I. Mendelsohn and F.E. Luborsky, 1955, Phys. Rev. 100, 1055. Schiller, K. and K. Brinkmann, 1970, Dauermagnete (Springer, Berlin) p. 74. Shtrikman, S. and D. Treves, 1960, J. Appl. Phys. 31, 72 S. Shur, Y.S., 1973, private communication. Stoner, E.C. and E.P. Wohlfarth, 1948, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. (London) 240A, 599. Street, R. and J.C. Woolley, 1949, Proc. Roy. Soc. (London) A62, 562. Van den Broek, J.J. and H. Zijlstra, 1971, IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-7, 226. Van Landuyt, J, G. van Tendeloo, J.J. van den Broek, H. Donkersloot and H. Zijlstra, 1978, IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-14, 679. Weiner, J.H., 1973, IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG9, 602. Went, J.J., G.W. Rathenau, E.W. Gorter and G.W. van Oosterhout, 1951/52, Philips Tech. Rev. 13, 194. Zijlstra, H., 1966, Z. Angew. Phys. 21, 6. Zijlstra, H., 1967, Experimental Methods in Magnetism, Vol. I (North-Holland, Amsterdam) p. 135. Zijlstra, H., 1970a, IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-6, 179. Zijlstra, H., 1970b, J. Appl. Phys. 41, 4881. Zijlstra, H., 1974, Philips Tech. Rev. 34, 193. Zijlstra, H. and H.B. Haanstra, 1966, J. Appl. Phys. 37, 2853:
chapter 3 THE STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS
R.A. McCURRIE School of Materials Science and Technology University of Bradford Bradford, W Yorks BD7 1DP UK
Ferromagnetic Materials, Vol. 3 Edited by E.P. Wohlfarth © North-Holland Publishing Company, 1982 107
CONTENTS 1, Isotropic alnicos 1-4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.1. Fe2NiA1 and the isotropic alnicos 1-4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2. Microstructure and origin of the coercivity in Fe2NiA1 and the isotropic alnicos 1-4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2, Anisotropic alnicos 5 and 6 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1. Thermomagnetic treatment of anisotropic alnico 5 . . . . . . . . . . 2.2. Cyclic heat treatment of alnico 5 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3. Anisotropic cast alnico 5 with grain orientation (alnico 5 D G or alnico 5-7) . 2.4. Shape anisotropy of alnico 5 and alnico 5 D G (alnico 5-7) . . . . . . . . 2.5. Magnetostriction of alnico 5 and alnico 5 D G (alnico 5-7) . . . . . . . 2.6. Microstructures of alnico 5 alloys . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.7. Alnico 6 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Anisotropic alnicos 8 and 9 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. Thermomagnetic treatment of anisotropic alnico 8 . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. Extra high coercivity alnico 8 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3, Anisotropic alnico 9 with fully columnar grains . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4. Shape anisotropy of alnicos 8 and 9 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5. Microstructures of alnicos 8 and 9 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. M6ssbauer spectroscopy of alnicos 5 and 8 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. Sintered alnicos . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. Moulded, pressed or bonded alnico magnets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7. Effects of thermomagnetic treatment on the magnetic properties of alnicos 5-9 7.1. Factors controlling development of am particle shape anisotropy . . . . . 7.2. Relationship between the preferred or easy direction of magnetization and the direction of the applied field during thermomagnetic treatment 7.3. Dependence of the magnetic properties on the direction of the applied field during thermomagnetic treatment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8. Effects of cobalt on' the magnetic properties of the alnicos . . . . . . . . . 9. Effects of titanium on the magnetic properties of the alnicos (mainly 6, 8 and 9) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10. Dependence of the magnetic properties on the angle between the direction of measurement and the preferred or easy axis of magnetization . . . . . . . 11. Relationship between magnetic properties and crystallographic texture . . . . . 12. Effects of particle misalignment on the rcmanence and coercivity of the anisotropic field-treated alnicos . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.1. Remanence . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.2. Coercivity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 108
111 111 113 121 121 129 129 131 133 134 137 137 137 141 142 145 146 148 148 149 149 149 151 151 154 155 158 161 161 161 163
13. Determination of the optimum volume fraction of the F e - C o rich particles 14. Interpretation of the magnetic properties in terms of the Stoner-Wohlfarth theory of hysteresis in single domain particles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15. Interpretation of the magnetic properties in terms of magnetization reversal by the curling mechanism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16. Magnetostatic interaction domains in alnicos . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17. Comparison of the N6el-Zijlstra and Cahn theories of magnetic annealing in alnico alloys . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.1. N6el-Zijlstra theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.2. Cahn's theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.3. Discussion of the N6el-Zijlstra and Cahn theories . . . . . . . . . . 18. Rotational hysteresis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19. Anhysteretic magnetization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20. Magnetic viscosity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21. Temperature dependence of magnetic properties . . . . . . . . . . . . 22. Dynamic excitation (AC magnetization) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23. Prospects for impi-ovement in the magnetic properties . . . . . . . . . . 24. Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
109
164 166 169 170 171 172 173 174 177 179 179 181 181 181 182 184
1. Isotropic alnicos 1-4
1.i. Fe2NiAl and the isotropic alnicos 1-4 The alnicos are an important group of p e r m a n e n t magnet alloys. They contain Fe, Co, Ni and A1 with minor additions of Cu and Ti. The first m e m b e r s of the series, which do not contain cobalt, were discovered by Mishima (1932) and are known as the Mishima alloys. They have a composition in the range 55-63% Fe, 25-30% Ni and 12-15% A1, an energy product of ~ 8 kJm -3 and a coercivity of 4.8 x 1 0 4 A m which is m o r e than twice the coercivity of the magnet steels which were available in 1931. Because of their commercial importance the alnico alloys have been studied in great detail by m a n y researchers. Burgers and Snoek (1935) found that when an alloy containing 59% F e - 28% N i - 1 3 % A1 was slowly cooled at a controlled rate from 1200°C to 700°C the coercivity rose to a m a x i m u m of about 48 k A m 1 (600 Oe) as the cooling time was extended and then decreased to about 16 k A m -~ (200 Oe) as the cooling time was prolonged. X-ray investigation showed that in the o p t i m u m high coercivity state a precipitation reaction had occurred. F r o m m e a s u r e m e n t s of the internal demagnetization coefficient Snoek (1938, 1939) suggested that the alloys were heterogeneous and that in the optimum high coercivity state there were two ferromagnetic phases a~ and c~2. The phase segregation process in Fe2NiAI has been investigated by Sucksmith (1939) who measured the magnetization versus t e m p e r a t u r e curves of the single and two-phase alloy. The latter was formed by quenching from 800°C and the magnetization versus t e m p e r a t u r e curve showed a dip at 450°C which indicated that the alloy was indeed two-phase. Sucksmith (1939) found that the phase segregation occurred according to the reaction: 3.25 FesoNi25A125~ Fe9sNizsAlz5 + 2.25 Fe30Ni35A13s, and that the saturation magnetizations of the two phases are, respectively 2 1 2 J T -1 kg -1 (212emu/g or 212erg Oe -1 g-a) and 6 1 J T 1 kg 1(61emu/g or 6 1 e r g O e -1 g-l). Since the densities of the two phases were not known the saturation magnetic polarizations in teslas (T) could not be determined. Details of the o p t i m u m composition and heat treatment of these isotropic iii
112
R.A. M c C U R R I E
Fe-Ni-A1 alloys have been given by Betteridge (1939). The best properties were obtained for an alloy containing 59.5% F e - 2 7 . 6 % Ni and 12.9% A1 which had been quenched at 28°Cs I from the single phase state at l l00°C and then tempered for 4 hours at 650°C. This treatment gave a coercivity BHc = 4 1 k A m - 1 ( 5 1 5 O e ) and a maximum energy product ( B H ) m ~ = 1 0 . 8 k J m -3 (1.35 x 106G Oe). The coercivity was shown to depend very critically on the A1 content while the remanence depended more on the Ni content. Betteridge (1939) also investigated the effects of adding Cu to the Fe-Ni-A1 alloys and found a Cu addition of 3.5% increased (BH)max to 12kJm -3 (1.5 x 1 0 6 G O e ) after quenching from above 950°C and tempering at 550°C. The Cu addition increased the rate of precipitation so that the Fe-Ni-A1-Cu alloys required more rapid cooling or quenching. The effects of elastic stress on the precipitation and magnetic properties of Fe-Ni-A1 alloys with additions of Cu and Ti have been investigated by Yermolenko and Korolyov (1970) who obtained improved optimum permanent magnet properties of ( B H ) m a x = 16.8 k J m -3, BHc = 63 kAm 1 and Br = 0.67 T. The permanent magnet alloys with compositions close to Fe2NiA1 are usually prepared commercially by cooling from above 1250°C at an approximately controlled rate. Rapidly cooled castings can be improved by annealing at 600°C for several hours. These alloys, which usually have small additions of Cu, are known as alni or alnico 3, in spite of the fact that they contain no cobalt; they are still produced in small quantities. Betteridge (1939), Zumbusch (1942a) and others also found that the magnetic properties of the Fe-Ni-A1 alloys could be significantly improved by the addition of cobalt as shown in fig. 1. The increase in remanence follows the increase in the saturation magnetic polarization of the alloys while the larger relative increase in the coercivity BHo can be attributed to an increase in the difference between the
100 -
1"Or
20 Br
~ 80- 0"8I
16
~6o -,-°= ~.6
12 "J
,ff
BH(max)
g 8
40 -
0-4 f
20 -
0.2
0
--0
0
E
I
-r Ill
4
5
10 15 Wt % Cobalt
20
25
Fig. 1. Dependence of coercivity, remanence and energy product on cobalt content (after Zumbusch 1942b).
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS 113 saturation magnetic polarization of the F e - C o rich precipitate particles and the Ni-A1 rich matrix. The addition of cobalt has the further beneficial effect of raising the Curie temperature. The cobalt-containing alloys are produced by controlled cooling from above !250°C and subsequent annealing for several hours in the range 600-650°C. Since cobalt decreases the rate of precipitation of the c~1 and ~2 phases it was found essential to add small quantities of copper (Betteridge 1939) and to reduce both the nickel and aluminium contents as the cobalt content was increased. It was also shown (Betteridge 1939, Edwards 1957) that the magnetic properties of these isotropic alloys (alnicos 1, 2, 3 and 4) could be significantly improved by the addition of 4-5% Ti provided that the cobalt content was increased to 17-20%. These extra high BHc isotropic alnicos (alnico 2) have coercivities in the range 60-72 kAm 2 compared with 36-56 kAm -1 for the isotropic alnicos 1, 2, 3 and 4. The energy product of the high coercivity form of isotropic alnico 2 is also slightly higher. Although the Ti addition reduces the remanence this is more than compensated by the much higher coercivities. Details of the optimum composition and heat treatments of the isotropic alnicos have been given by Betteridge (1939) and Edwards (1957). The magnetic properties and compositions of the alnicos 1-4 are summarized in table 1 and typical demagnetization B - H curves are shown in fig. 2.
0.8 0.6
lib
>2
0"4
u) "0 X -I m
0.2 u.
I1
60
I
50
/
!
I
I
I
I
40 30 20 Applied field,H (kAm-1)
I
10
0
0
Fig. 2. Demagnetization curves for isotropic alnicos 1, 2, 3 and 4.
1.2. Microstructure and origin of the coercivity in Fe2NiAl and the isotropic alnicos 1--4 The compositions of the alnicos are complex and the F e - N i - A I system is the only one for which the phase diagram has been investigated in detail. Bradley and Taylor (1938a, b) and Bradley, (1949a, b, 1951, 1952) established the positions of the phase boundaries and the general metallurgical behaviour of the Fe-Ni-A1 system and showed that the alloys with potentially interesting permanent magnet properties lay close to the line from Fe to NiA1 and were centered round the
114
R.A. M c C U R R I E
~
_'2
~
t--
©
,q.
tt~
t--
e., ©
©
©
c~ <
0
"~
©
iq
0
?
0
©
0 e~ 0
c,.) _=
<
?
ii
<
5 II E"
z
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS 115 composition Fe2NiAI. The isothermal section of the Fe-Ni-A1 phase diagram at 750°C is shown in fig. 3. D e Vos (1966, 1969) has suggested that for the alloys which are of most interest as permanent magnets the phase diagram for the alnicos can be considerably simplified if it is assumed that they are pseudobinaries of Fe and NiA1 or F e - C o and Ni-AI. Marcon et al. (1978a) have shown that in the Fe-Ni-A1 system this is not strictly correct because of the extension of the a + T phase boundary below 9 1 0 ° C - t h e a ~ 7 allotropic transformation temperature for Fe. The approximate pseudo-binary phase diagram shown in fig. 4 (Marcon et al. 1978a) is that for a vertical section cut through the line with full circles in the phase diagram shown in fig. 3. Since the permanent magnet alloys contain at least 50 wt % Fe it can be seen from fig. 4 that below about 800°C alloys containing 25-75% Fe are two-phase (al and a2). When the sub-division into the al and o~2phases occurs on a sufficiently fine scale the Fe or F e - C o rich particles have a significant shape anisotropy, which gives rise to high coercivities according to the Stoner and Wohlfarth (1948) model in which the magnetization is assumed to reverse by coherent rotation, though we shall see later that this simple process is unlikely to occur.
The Fe or F e - C o rich particles (o~1phase) and the non-ferromagnetic or weakly ferromagnetic Ni-A1 rich matrix (c~2phase) have bcc structures and are formed by spinodal decomposition (Cahn and Hilliard 1958, 1959, Cahn 1961-1963, 1968, Hillert 1961) rather than a nucleation and growth process. We shall see that this has important effects on the microstructure and magnetic properties of the alloys. The spinodal decomposition of the c~ phase into the c~ and c~2 phases, although spontaneous, is of course diffusion limited and can occur only at relatively high temperatures ~850°C. The concentrations of the Fe or Fe and Co atoms in the two phases vary periodically (assumed to be sinusoidal by Cahn (1962)) and the
Ni
7 5 0 °C
70 80
Fe
to
20
3o
~o
so
so
m
so
9o
AI
At % AI
Fig. 3. Ternary equilibrium phase diagrams for Fe-Ni-A1 at 750°C (after Bradley 1949, 1951, 1952).
116
R.A. McCURRIE
1800[ 1 6 0 1400~--~
0
\
0oov/ oor/ oor/'
o
o,.o
oor/' O0 02 I.
Fe
~
=
0'I 4
i
Composition
01.6
I
01.8
I NiA
Fig. 4. Pseudo binary equilibrium phase diagram for Fe-NiA1 (after Marcon et al. 1978a). amplitudes of the composition fluctuations increases with time until the phase separation is complete; the whole process takes a very short time - seconds or minutes. Cahn (1962) has demonstrated theoretically that for alloys in which the elastic constants obey the relation 2C44 -
C l l ~- C12 > 0 ,
the spinodal decomposition waves are parallel to the three {100} planes. This results in an initial microstructure which consists of a simple cubic array of regions rich in one component (e.g. Fe or Fe-Co) connected along the (100) directions by rods similarly enriched. The 'body centres' of this array are regions enriched in Ni-A1 and are connected by similarly enriched (100) rods. This produces two interlocking 3 dimensional systems of (100) rods, one enriched in Fe or F e - C o and other enriched in Ni-A1. Such a micros~ructure is typical of the periodic distribution of the phases in spinodally decomposed systems and may be contrasted with the irregular distribution of the phases in systems which decompose by nucleation and growth. Cahn (1962) also predicted that the relative volume fractions of the two phases also affects the final microstructure. If the volume fraction of one phase is much smaller than the other the final microstructure will consist of nearly equiaxed particles aligned along (100) directions. As the volume fraction of this phase increases elongated particles are formed with their axes of elongation parallel to the (100) directions, and these are of course the directions of easy magnetization, though the alloys are macroscopically isotropic. Since the
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS
117
volume fraction of the al phase is usually in the range 0.5-0.7, the observed microstructures (figs. 6 and 7 and De Vos, 1966, 1969) are in very good agreement with those predicted by Cahn's (1962) theory. The formation and growth of the particles to their final shape and size occurs almost entirely during the spinodal decomposition at 800-850°C. The driving force for this reaction is of course the reduction in the interracial energy between the particles (~1) and the matrix (a2). Although the interfacial energy is small 10-3-10 -1Jm -2 (1-102erg cm -2) this is sufficient to favour particle growth. The principal effect of the heat treatment at 600°C is to increase the difference between the saturation magnetic polarization of the Fe or F e - C o rich particles and the surrounding matrix (Ni-A1 rich) by a continuous change in their composition due to the diffusion of Fe and Co atoms to the particles. The spinodal decomposition into two phases does not, however, produce a very large shape anisotropy in the ferromagnetic o~ phase particles and since the difference in the saturation magnetizations of the a~ particles and the matrix is relatively small the effective shape anisotropy field of the particles (proportional to Js(al)-Js(o~2)) is also small in spite of the elongation (e.g. fig. 6 (De Vos 1966, 1969)). Further heat treatment is necessary in order to increase the shape anisotropy and hence to obtain the highest coercivities and the best permanent magnet properties. This heat treatment usually consists of an anneal at about 600°C for several hours, though this is sometimes omitted in the case of the cobalt free alnico 3 alloys with compositions close to Fe2NiA1. The variation of the intrinsic coercivity (He) with composition and heat treatment for Fe-NiA1 alloys (De Vos 1966, 1969) is shown in fig. 5. The coercivities were measured (a) after quenching and tempering to give the optimum coercivity and (b) after continuous controlled cooling of the alloys. Since the interfacial energy depends on the crystallographic orientation of the boundary between the a~ and o~2 phases the particle growth is anisotropic (though
Fe-NiAI ~'~6 I E <¢
a
b
*¢
24 O
2
o
i
I
o Fe
20
40 60 8O Composition, At.%
lOO NiAI
Fig. 5. Dependence of coercivity of Fe-NiAI alloys on composition and heat treatment (a) after quenching and tempering for optimum properties (b) after continuous cooling (after De Vos 1969).
118
R.A. McCURRIE
only slightly so in Fe2NiA1) which results in an elongation parallel to the {100) directions. The microstructures of the alnicos have been studied in considerable detail by D e Vos (1966, 1969) who used replication electron microscopy. An example of the microstructure of Fe2NiA1 after o p t i m u m cooling ( H c ~ 56 k A m -1) is shown in fig, 6 though the shape anisotropy is not very pronounced. If the alloy is given an isothermal heat treatment for 2 h a t 850°C followed by quenching the preferential particle growth along the {100) directions is clearly visible (fig. 7), though this microstructure does not give o p t i m u m p e r m a n e n t magnet properties because the particles are too coarse and hence magnetization reversal occurs by curling (see Zijlstra, chapter 2 of this handbook) or by a m o r e complex mechanism. F r o m fig. 7 we may assume that the particles are mainly rod-like (~500 nm long and 100 nm in diameter) though particle coalescence and the presence of plate-like particles gives rise to the observed more complex microstructure. Since the Bloch-Lifshitz domain wall width in Fe or F e - C o alloys is of the order of 200 nm the particles are probably 'single domains' though they are not expected to
Fig. 6. Electron micrograph of the oq + a2 structure in an arbitrary plane, for an alloy containing 50 at. % Fe, 25 at. % Ni and 25 at. % AI, after optimum cooling (magnification 45000 x) (De Vos 1969).
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS
119
Fig. 7. Electron micrograph of the o~l + ~e2 structure for an alloy containing 50 at. % Fe, 25 at. % Ni and 25 at. % A1, after annealing for 2 h at 8500C followed by quenching (magnification 30000 x) (De Vos 1969).
behave as ideal isolated single domain particles with uniaxial shape anisotropy. Even if Bloch-Lifshitz domain walls could be nucleated in the alloys it seems most unlikely that they could move freely in such a complex interconnected microstructure, so, even this mechanism of magnetization change could lead to significant coercivities. Assuming that the relatively high coercivities and remanences in the alnicos l - 4 are due principally to shape anisotropy of elongated Fe or F e - C o rich particles in a non-ferromagnetic matrix the Stoner-Wohlfarth (1948) theory (for a summary see e.g. Zijlstra, chapter 2 of this handbook) predicts that the coercivity is proportional to the saturation magnetization, Ms, of the Fe or F e - C o rich particles and to a factor related to the difference in the effective demagnetization factors perpendicular (Dz) and parallel (Dx) to the preferred direction of magnetization in the particles, i.e., Hc = f(O)(Dz - D x ) M ~ ,
where f(O) is an averaging factor which takes account of the various orientations of the preferred axes of the particles with respect to the direction of measurement
120
R.A. McCURRIE
of He. According to Stoner and Wohlfarth (1948) the coercivity of a random array of non-interacting uniaxial single domain particles which reverse their magnetization by coherent rotation of the magnetization vector Ms is Hc = 0.479(Dz -
D,)Ms.
However, since the microstructures of Fe2NiA1 and the cobalt containing alnicos 1, 2 and 4 - p r e s u m a b l y similar to those of FezNiA1-are so complex, a detailed quantitative interpretation of the magnetic properties has not yet been attempted. In any case it is clear that a simple Stoner-Wohlfarth coherent rotation mechanism of magnetization reversal is very unlikely to occur. Although the particles have dimensions small enough to be single domains they are close to the size where magnetization reversal is likely to occur by curling. The irregular shape anisotropy of the interconnected particles may result in more complex mechanisms of magnetization reversal due to the complex spatial variation of the associated demagnetizing fields. The magnetization reversal is further complicated by particle interactions (Wohlfarth 1955), interaction domains (Bates et al. 1962) and the ferromagnetism of the Ni-AI rich a2 phase (see section 16). The suggestion by Stoner and Wohlfarth (1947, 1948) that the relatively high coercivities of the alloy FezNiA1 and the other isotropic alnicos, could be due essentially to the shape anisotropy of elongated single domain particles has been confirmed by Nesbitt et al. (1954). The magnetic behaviour of the material was simulated by embedding fine wires of Ni-Fe-Mo permalloy (which have a predominant shape anisotropy) in a non-magnetic matrix, with their axes in the three mutually perpendicular (100) directions viz. [100], [010] and [001]. By comparing the field dependence of the torque curves for single crystals of Fe2NiA1 with those of the simulated specimen Nesbitt et al. (1954) were able to show that the structures of the two materials were essentially the same although the interpretation of the results was complicated by the magnetocrystalline anisotropy of the FezNiA1. Further complications arise because the particles in Fe2NiA1 often coalesce to form very complex structures and shapes, as shown in figs. 6 and 7. Since the microstructures of the cobalt-containing alnicos are very similar to those observed in Fe2NiA1 it seems reasonable to assume that the coercivities of these alloys are also due to shape anisotropy. Apart from the dipole field interactions between the particles which depend on the volume fraction p, the magnetic behaviour is further complicated by the fact that in some alnico alloys the Ni-A1 rich a2 matrix phase is weakly ferromagnetic so that there is an exchange coupling between the Fe-Co rich al phase and the Ni-A1 rich a2 phase. Thus magnetization change may occur by some kind of 'wall motion' through the complex interconnected al and Og2 phases. The domain walls may of course only be 'interaction domain walls' as described in section 16 rather than Bloch-Lifshitz walls, but the motion of these interaction domain walls still requires magnetization reversal in the individual al phase particles and in view of the particle interaction effects this itself will be a co-operative process. The magnetization reversal may occur by an incoherent process such as curling but in
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS 121 view of the complex shapes of the particles and the exchange coupling to the matrix phase even more complex reversal processes may occur. In the high cobalt and high titanium alloys where the particles are very regular in shape and are isolated single domains embedded in a non-ferromagnetic matrix (c~2 phase), it seems that magnetization reversal is likely to occur by the curling mechanism in individual particles although these are still expected to act co-operatively and hence give rise to domains or regions of reversed magnetization interaction domains. A fuller discussion of the physical concepts briefly described here is given in sections 14, 15 and 16 as well as by Zijlstra, in chapter 2 of this handbook.
2. Anisotropic alnicos 5 and 6
2.1. Thermomagnetic treatment of anisotropic alnico 5 The most important advance in the technology of alnico magnets was the discovery by Oliver and Shedden (1938) of the beneficial effect of thermomagnetic treatment and its development by Jonas and Meerkamp van E m b d e n (1941). Oliver and Shedden (1938) found that when an alloy containing 54% Fe, 18% Ni, 10% A1, 12% Co and 6% Cu was cooled from 1200°C in a magnetic field of 352 kAm -1 the resulting magnet was anisotropic and that the value of (BH)max was increased from 12 kJm -3 (1.5 x 106 G Oe) in the isotropic alloy to 14.4 kJm -3 (1.8 x 106G Oe) parallel to the field direction. Perpendicular to the field (BH)max decreased to 10.8 kJm -3 (1.35 x 1066 Oe). The anisotropy in (BH)max was due entirely to changes in the remanence and fullness factor ((BH)max/BrHc) of the demagnetizing B - H curves; the coercivity remained isotropic. Following this discovery by Oliver and Shedden (1938), Jonas and Meerkamp van Embden (1941) heat treated an alloy with a higher cobalt content (viz. 51.5% Fe, 14% Ni, 8.5% A1, 23% Co and 3% Cu) by cooling from 1200°C to 600°C in a magnetic field of 240 kAm -1 and then annealing for several hours at 600°C. They obtained a maximum energy product of 41.6 kJm -3 parallel to the field direction and only 5.6 kJm -3 perpendicular to it. For an isotropic alloy of the same composition the maximum energy product was 17.6 kJm -3. Most of the improvement in the energy product parallel to the field direction could be attributed to an increase in the fullness factor though there was also a significant increase in the remanence from 0.87 T to 1.24 T. The increase in the coercivity BHc was s m a l l - f r o m 47 kAm -1 to 52 kAm -1. Jonas and Meerkamp van Embden (1941) also found that the application of a magnetic field during the anneal at 600°C had no beneficial effect. More detailed investigations of these anisotropic alnico 5 alloys were made by Jellinghaus (1943) who studied the effects of varying the aluminium content in alloys with the composition Fe, 15% Ni, 5.7-16.6% A1, 23% Co and 3% Cu. H e found that good magnetic properties could be obtained only in the narrow range of A1 content, about 8-9%, where the coercivitY , remanence and maximum energy product were all high and that at the composition 50% F e - 23% C o - 15%
122
R.A. McCURRIE
N i - 9 % A 1 - 3 % Cu the application of a magnetic field during cooling increased (BH)max very substantially from 12 kJm -3 (no field) to 40 kJm -3 (with field). The dependence of (BH)m~x on the aluminium content and the effect of the thermomagnetic field is shown in fig. 8. This conclusion is supported by Lange (1968). The presence of the deleterious fcc Y phase (Jellinghaus 1943) was detected only for very low A1 contents and was absent above 6% A1 where the whole alloy had a bcc structure. Extensive investigations of alnico 5 alloys were made by Zumbusch (1942a, b) who studied alloys with a wider range of compositions including an addition of up to 4% Ti. H e found that the best magnetic properties were obtained for alloys with compositions in the range Fe, 14-15.5% Ni, 7.8-9.2% A1, 21.5-23.5% Co, 3-4% Cu and less than 1% Ti. The heat treatment recommended by Zumbusch (1942a, b) consists of cooling fro.m 1250°C at about l°Cs -1 to 500°C in a field well above 160 kAm -1, followed by tempering at 550°C for 10 hours. The precipitation processes in alnico 5 have been investigated by Heimke et al. (1966) who measured the saturation magnetic polarization, the remanence and coercivity as a function of tim e using a modified thermomagnetic treatment. They concluded that when the O/1 (Fe-Co) particles are first formed they are spherical but just below the Curie temperature and under the influence of the applied field they soon become elongated and form larger interconnected particles with their long axes parallel to the applied field direction. Later or at lower temperatures more cross links are formed between the particles. The effect of the Cu content of alnico 5 has been investigated by Van der Steeg and De Vos (1964) who showed that increasing the Cu content raised the homogenization temperature, stabilized the 3' fcc phase and lowered the Curie temperature and hence the temperature for effective heat treatment in a magnetic field. They also found that the annealing process was accelerated by the addition 40 O o
"~" 30 I E ~=
(b)
¢x 20 E 10 -
//
0
~1 6
4.
(a)
8 10 12 Wt % AluminFum
14
16
i 18
Fig. 8. Dependence of maximum energy product on the aluminium content of alloys containing Fe-23% Co-15% Ni-3% Cu (a) without thermomagnetic treatment (b) with thermomagnetic treatment (after Jellinghaus 1943).
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICOPERMANENTMAGNETALLOYS
123
of copper and that above 2.5% Cu the coercivity increased. Ritzow and Ebert (1957) have shown that the presence of Cu decreased the rate of cooling through the y fcc region necessary to prevent the precipitation of the magnetically deleterious y fcc phase which must be avoided if the best magnetic properties are to be obtained. All the anisotr0pic alloys (including alnicos 6-9) are single phase above about 1200°C but if they are held in the temperature range 1000-1200°C for more than a very short time the resulting magnetic properties are inferior due to the precipitation of the ~ fcc phase. The formation of the latter phase is favoured if the composition deviates significantly from the 'ideal' or if the alloys are incompletely homogenized by soaking at 1250-1300°C. The a-~ y phase transformation has been investigated by Koch et al. (1957, 1959), Koshiba and Nishinuma (1957, 1960), Pater et al. (1963), Van der Steeg and De Vos (1964), Planchard et al. (1964a-1966a), Heimke and Kohlhaas (1966). Koch et al. (1957, 1959) have shown by high temperature X-ray studies that the fcc y phase can coexist with the bcc a phase in the temperature range 1250-800°C and that on cooling below 800°C this fcc y phase transforms, by an apparently diffusionless reaction to another bcc phase c~. The magnetic properties of alnico 5 as a function of heat treatment have also been measured by many other authors (see e.g. Clegg and McCaig (1957), Tenzer and Kronenberg (1958), Yermolenko and Shur (1964), De Vos (1966, 1969), Bronner et al. (1968-1970)). The temperature dependence of the coercivity of alnico 5 (Clegg and McCaig 1957) after various heat treatments is shown in fig. 9. Curves (c) and (g) represent specimens with optimum permanent magnet properties. The saturation magnetic polarization of these specimens decreased almost linearly by 20-35% in the temperature range 0-550°C. Above 550°C up to the Curie temperature (--~850°C) the decrease in Js was very rapid. For heat treatments above about 500°C the magnetic properties are not reversible on cooling because at high temperatures fundamental structural changes occur. The temperature stability of alnico alloys is discussed in section 21. By considering magnetization versus temperature curves (for a review of this technique see e.g. Berkowitz (1969)) Tenzer and Kronenberg (1958) concluded that in the optimum permanent magnet state alnico 5 (52% Fe, 23% Co, 14% Ni, 8% A1, 3% Cu) consists of two ferromagnetic phases, one is mainly Fe2Co with some A1, Ni and Cu (Js ~ 1.4 T) in solid solution and the other is mainly NiA1 with a small Fe content. By means of a similar study on alnico 5 (51% Fe, 24% Co, 14% Ni, 8% A1, 3% Cu) Yermolenko and Shut (1964) concluded that in the optimum state the saturation magnetic polarizations of the ~1 (Fe-Co) and a2 (Ni-A1) phases were respectively 1.6 T and 0.1 T. De Vos (1966, 1969) found that when the controlled cooling was terminated by quenching from different temperatures the resulting magnetic properties were nearly independent of the quenching temperature, provided the latter was below about 775°C. The variation of the coercivity of alnico 5 with quenching temperature before and after tempering at 585°C is shown in fig. 10.
124
R.A. M c C U R R I E
0
0
0
0
,! O
o
o
~
(L-tu~M) °H8
~.~
~ - , r,- O
OE
~b N
~N
0
0
0
(~-,,,~) 0~
0
;" +
"~
~sU
s~
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS 125 6
c
r.
~
~
5
Alnico 5 •
After for
tempering 14
hr
r- 2 o
1 !
500
600
700
800
900
Quenching Temperature (°C )
Fig. 10. Dependence of coercivity of alnico 5 on quenching temperature before and after tempering at 585°C (De Vos 1969).
Wittig (1962) attempted to obtain high energy product, titanium-free alnico 5 magnets by isothermal heat treatment in a magnetic field at temperatures between 800 and 870°C for 2-20 min but found that the (BH)max products were lower than those obtained with the conventional thermomagnetic treatment in agreement with the earlier results obtained by Koch et al. (1957). However, Wittig (1962) also found that a (BH)max = 40 kJm -3 (equal to that obtained by the conventional thermomagnetic treatment) could be obtained if the alnico 5 was given a twostage isothermal heat treatment in a magnetic field as follows: (1) 4 rain at 860°C in a magnetic field (presumably of saturating strength) (2) 2min at 830°C in a magnetic field (3) tempering for 2 h at 650°C (4) tempering for 16 h at 585°C. The heat treatment of alnico 5 varies according to the composition and manufacturer; a typical heat treatment is as follows (Marcon et al. 1978b): (1) Homogenization at 1350°C to obtain the a phase. (2) Fast cooling at 4 ° C s -1 down to about 900°C to prevent the parasitic precipitation of the fcc 3' phase. (3) Controlled cooling in a magnetic field (ideally of saturating strength ~320 kAm -1) down to 600°C. This treatment results in the spinodal decomposition of the a phase into the al (Fe-Co) and (1' 2 (Ni-A1) phases and the formation of elongated a~ (Fe-Co) particles. (4) Tempering for 6 h at 650°C followed by 24h at 550°C. This treatment produces the equilibrium al and a2 phases which have a maximum in the difference between their saturation magnetic polarizations AJ = J~l - JR. Many variations in the above process can be made without producing significant changes in the magnetic properties; e.g., average cooling rates in the range 0.5-4°Cs -1 have b e e n quoted by many authors (see, e.g., Nesbitt and Williams 1957, Clegg and McCaig 1957, Povolotskii et al. 1963, Marcon et al. 1978b). Marcon et al. (1978b) have also investigated the effects of varying the applied
126
R.A. M c C U R R I E
field during cooling (from 900 to 600°C) over the range 0 - 5 7 6 k A m -1. They found that for polycrystalline alnico 5 (50.6% Fe, 13.9% Ni, 8.2% AI, 24.3% Co, 3% Cu) the optimum permanent magnet properties could be obtained by cooling in a field of 80kAm-1; cooling in larger fields up to a maximum 5 7 6 k A m -1 produced no significant improvement in Br, BH¢ or ( B H ) . . . . The thermomagnetic treatment of the alnico 5 alloys is most effective when they contain about 23% Co or more. The high cobalt content is essential because it raises the Curie temperature to about 850°C so that when the spinodal decomposition occurs in the temperature range 700-850°C the shape and growth of the particles can be influenced by the applied field because they are already ferromagnetic. The effects and theory of magnetic annealing and the relationship between the preferred direction of magnetization in alnico 5 and the applied field during cooling are discussed later in sections 7 and 17. The improvement in the magnetic properties of alnico 5 occurs only in the direction of the applied field and there is an accompanying deterioration of the properties in other directions. These alloys, though polycrystalline, are anisotropic owing to the preferential growth of the particles along the field direction or as near to it as possible depending on the orientation of the [100] directions in the grains. We can see from table 2 that the improvement in the remanence and energy product of alnico 5 compared with those alnicos 1-4 (table 1) is very significant. A typical demagnetization curve for alnico 5 (random grain) is shown in fig. 11: (the demagnetization curves for columnar and single crystal alnico 5 are also shown in fig. 11). In dynamic applications of alnico 5 where the working point of the magnet
B. 80
(kJn -3) 60 40
11.4
..~"
H
1.0~ >~
"
16.1"~~~
0-40"6"o; •'=
-%
Alnico 5
80
I
70
I
~ i
'
60 50t''- 40 30 20 Applied field, H (kAm-1)
'
10
0-2 0
0
Fig. 11. Demagnetization curves for various forms of alnico 5: (a) equiaxed alnico 5, (b) grain orientated alnico 5-7, (c) single crystal alnico 5.
S T R U C T U R E A N D P R O P E R T I E S OF A L N I C O P E R M A N E N T M A G N E T A L L O Y S
tt3 k~
"7
"2.
m.
"7
©
E C~
6
C4
~5 '~ eq
0 eq
03 eq
eq ¢¢3
P~ ¢¢3
eq
tt~
~
,.~
tt~
tt3
0
H ,....,
-4
.,
e~
o
b~
0 oq.
zq.
p.,
p..
r--
r--
oq.
l
G,
If
Go
<
tt')
T
C~
d
z
0
q;
tl
"-6 t:'-6 ~. , " ~ ~'rca ~ k~
127
128
R.A. McCURRIE
changes, details of the recoil hysteresis loops and the recoil energy contours are essential if the material is to be used efficiently. Hysteresis loops and their associated recoil curves for various alnico alloys have b e e n published by Stfiblein (1968). T h e recoil energy c o n t o u r s for various alnicos can be f o u n d in the b o o k by Parker and Studders (1962). Typical recoil loops for alnico 5 are shown in fig. 12 which also shows various load lines and working points. T h e recoil energy contours for alnico 5 are shown in fig. 13. N o t e that the recoil energies given in
29~2~ I
J
r
=
2
~
BIT] 11"0 0.8 0"6 0"4 0"2
60
0 0
40 20 H I kAm-l]
Fig. 12. Typical recoil loops for alnico 5, and various load lines and working points (after Stiiblein 1968).
B (T) 1.2 1.0 0-8 0.6 0.4 0-2 -5
-4
-3 -2 -1 H (10 4 Am - 1 )
0
0
Fig. 13. Recoil energy contours for alnico 5 (after Parker and Studders 1962).
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS 129 fig. 13 (usually referred to as the useful recoil energies) are those obtained by using the more practical definition used by permanent magnet designers (Edwards 1962, Parker and Studders 1962, Schiller and Brinkmann 1970) rather than the fundamental definition given by Zijlstra in chapter 2 of this handbook. The technological importance of alnico 5 alloys is reflected by the large number of published papers which have appeared since their discovery. For further details the reader is referred to the papers by Bronner et al. (1967-1969, 1970a) and Gould (1971) who have attempted to interpret the magnetic properties in terms of the Stoner-Wohlfarth (1948) theory. Kolbe.and Martin (1960) have shown that alnico 5 can be successfully shaped into rod, wire or strip by hot working at high temperatures. They have also shown that alnico 5 can be extruded swaged and rolled.
2.2. Cyclic heat treatment of alnico 5 Hansen (1955) showed that the magnetic properties of alnico 5 were impaired by heat treating at 620-790°C but could be restored by re-tempering at 585°C provided the spoiling heat treatment temperature was below 675°C. After spoiling heat treatment above this temperature the coercivity could only be partially restored. Similar observations were made by Koch et al. (1957) and Fujiwara and Kato (1960). D e Vos (1966) investigated the microstructures of an alnico 5 alloy after it had been given the following treatments: (1) after optimum cooling in a magnetic field (BHc = 44 kAm -1) (2) treatment (1) followed by spoiling at 750°C for 3 min (Uric = 8.8 kAm -1) (3) treatments (1) and (2) followed by re-tempering at 585°C (BHc = 54 kAm-1). By observing the microstructure in a plane parallel to the direction of the field during cooling, De Vos (1966, 1969) found that there was no significant change in the morphology of the structure after each stage of the above cyclical heat treatment. According to De Vos ( 1 9 6 6 ) t h e best magnetic properties of alnico 5 are obtained when optimally field cooled magnets are aged below 600°C. The magnetic properties as a function of heat treatment in the range 550-750°C have been tabulated by De Vos (1966). H e found that the optimum permanent magnet properties: (BH)~ax = 48 kJm -3, BHc = 52 kAm -1, Br = 1.3 T and Bs = 1.4 T can be obtained by optimum field cooling followed by heat treatment for 8 h at 585°C.
2.3. Anisotropic cast alnico 5 with grain orientation (alnico 5 D G or alnico 5-7) It has been established by Ebeling and Burr (1953) and Zijlstra (1956) that the best magnetic properties of alnico 5 are obtained when single crystals are given a thermomagnetic treatment with the applied field parallel to one of the [100] directions. Hoselitz and McCaig (1949b) showed that a further improvement in the magnetic properties of field cooled polycrystalline alnico 5 can be obtained if the grains have a preferred orientation so that the al (Fe-Co) particle axes in the whole alloy are as nearly aligned as possible. Fortunately, if iron-base alloys such as the alnicos are allowed to solidify on a
130
R.A. McCURRIE
cold surface the [100] axes tend to grow preferentially perpendicular to the cold surface so that the desired grain orientation or columnar grain structure can be produced relatively easily. Thus when alnico 5 alloys are cast with a columnar crystallization or preferred grain orientation thermomagnetic treatment with the applied field parallel to the preferred or columnar axis results in a significant improvement in the magnetic properties compared with the alnico 5 alloys with randomly oriented grains. This result can be readily appreciated by comparing the demagnetization curves shown in fig. 11. In order to obtain well oriented columnar magnets it is necessary to use pre-heated or exothermic moulds and to cast the magnets on steel or copper slabs (preferably water cooled). A typical columnar grain structure of an alnico 5-7 casting is shown in fig. 14 from which it can be seen that there is a high degree of alignment but this is by no means fully columnar. The production and magnetic properties of alnico 5-7 have been described and investigated by Ebeling and Burr (1953), McCaig and Wright (1960), Makino (1962), Makino et al. (1963), Makino and Kimura (1965), Lindner et al. (1963) and Gould (1964, 1971). The compositions and magnetic properties of alnico 5-7 columnar alloys (laboratory specimens) are shown in table 3. Unfortunately magnets with energy products as high as 70 kJm -3 do not appear to be available commercially. Typical magnetic properties of commercial alnico 5-7 are shown in table 3. Alnico 5 and alnico 5-7 or their equivalents are among the most widely used permanent magnet alloys. Many millions are used as loudspeaker magnets, though
Fig. 14. Typical columnar grain structure of alnico5 D G (alnico 5-7) (Gould 1971). (Magnification: ~2x.)
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS
131
TABLE 3 Magnetic properties of alnico 5-7 (columnar) alloys (after Gould 1964). Composition (wt %) Fe
Ni
Co
Al
Cu
Br
BH¢
(BH)m.x
Nb
(T)
(kAm ~)
(kJm -3)
51
14
24
8
3
-
1.33
56
51
50.7
13.5
24
8
3
0.8
1.33
59
57
50.3
13.8
24.3
8.4
3.2
-
1.33
58
64
49.7
13.5
25
8
3
0.8
1.43
62
70
49.7
13.5
25
8
3
0.8
1.35
63
65
49.7
13.5
25
8
3
0.8
1.38
57
58
50.5
13.5
25
8
3
-
1.4
56
64
49.7
13.5
25
8
3
0.8
1.4
60
69
48.5
13.5
25
8
3
2.0
1.37
66
69
47.3
17.7
24
8
3
-
1.4
59
64
N.B. 1 T = 104 G; 1 A m -a = (4~-/1000) Oe; 1 Jm -3 = 407r GOe.
they are gradually being replaced in this application by oriented BaFel20~9 and SrFe~2019 magnets, which are very much cheaper. It can be seen from fig. 11 that the demagnetization curve for single crystal alnico 5 gives the best magnetic properties with an energy product of 80 kJm -3 compared with ~60 kJm -3 for columnar alnico 5-7 and ~42 kJm 3 for equiaxed polycrystalline alnico 5 (Cronk 1966). By using a technique involving secondary recrystallization of large grained alnico 5 (~51% Fe, 24% Co, 14% Ni, 8% A1, 3% Cu, contaminated with 0.08% C or 0.35% Mn) Steinort et al. (1962) succeeded in obtaining a single crystal of mass ~0.11 kg with a maximum energy product of 88 kJm -3. From fig. 11, demagnetization curve (c), it is clear that the single crystal alnico 5 has significantly better magnetic properties than alnico 5 and alnico 5-7, but unfortunately single crystals are difficult to produce on a commercial scale.
2.4. Shape anisotropy of alnico 5 and alnico 5 D G (alnico 5-7) From torque curve measurements on alnico 5 and alnico 5 D G (i.e. alnico 5 with a columnar grain structure also known as alnico 7) Hoselitz and McCaig (1951, 1952) have concluded that the materials are magnetically uniaxial with an anisotropy coefficient of Ku ~ 105 Jm -3 (106 erg cm-3). A similar result was obtained by
132
R.A. McCURRIE
Nesbitt and Heidenreich (1952). From electron micrographs and torque curve measurements on single crystals of alnico 5 Nesbitt and Williams (1955) concluded that the high coercivity was due to the shape anisotropy of small elongated particles (approximately 0.41xm long and 0.061xm in diameter) and that the magnetocrystalline anisotropy was negligible. Typical torque curves for a disc with a (110) plane as surface are shown in fig. 15 from which can be concluded that the uniaxial shape anisotropy coefficient Ku is 1.08 x 105 Jm -3 with [001] as the easy direction of magnetization. Similar torque curve measurements of the anisotropy constants Ku for various thermomagnetic treatments of single crystals of alnico 5 have been made by Yermolenko et al. (1964). Instead of the conventional thermomagnetic treatment (i.e. controlled cooling in a magnetic field) they used isothermal heat treatment for various times in a field of 720 kAm -1 (9000 Oe) on specimens which had been quenched from 1300°C. This procedure followed by more complex tempering schedules did not produce specimens with optimum permanent magnet properties. However, for an alnico 5 alloy which had been heat treated in a field parallel to the [001] direction (which became the preferred direction) they obtained from the torque curve in the (110) plane a value of Ku = 0.84× 105jm -3, Sergeyev and Bulygina (1970) investigated the magnetic properties and the magnetic anisotropy at various stages in the heat treatment of single crystals of alnico 5. Some of their results are summarized in table 4 from which it can be seen that the increases in the coercivity and the energy product after tempering are accompanied by an increase in the anisotropy constant Ku, which can be attributed to an increased elongation of the particles and to changes
12 8
Alnico 5
[E 4 O m-
I,,.
0
= O I---4
-8
I
|
i
20
40
60
/
I /
801
i
I
100
120
Angle 0 from
o i
I
b
140
160
180
01]
Applied field = I ' 6 M A m
-1
-12 I
Fig. 15. Torque curve in the (ll(I) plane of a single crystal of alnico 5 (after Nesbitt and Williams 1955).
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS
133
TABLE 4 Magnetic properties and anisotropy constant Ku at various stages in the heat treatment of alnico 5 single crystals. Heat treatment A
Homogenization at 1300°C, followed by cooling to 9 0 0 ° C at a rate of 3.5°Cs-1.
1 A and cooling in a field from 900°C to 600°C at a rate of 0.5oCs i.
B (T) .
BHc (kAm-1) .
.
(BH)max (kJm-3)
Ku (Jm 3)
.
1.4
38.4
38.4
1.07
1 and tempering at 640°C for 2 h.
1.38
.47.2
43.2
1.30
3 2 and tempering at 560°C for 10 h.
1.37
52.8
60
1.52
2
N.B. 1 T =
10 4
G; 1 Am-1 = (4~r/1000) Oe; 1 J m
-3 =
407r GOe.
in their composition and hence the difference in the saturation magnetic polarizations of the al particles and the matrix, i.e. A J = Jal - Ja2. M o r e recently T a k e u c h i and I w a m a (1976) cooled a single crystal of alnico 5 (containing 51.31% Fe, 14.04% Ni, 7.69% A1, 23.88% C o and 3.08% Cu) in a magnetic field of 6 4 0 k A m -1 parallel to the [100] direction (which of course b e c a m e the preferred direction of magnetization) and obtained a value of Ku = 1.56× 105 Jm -3 and an associated magnetocrystalline anisotropy constant K1 = 0.15 × 105 J m -3, a result which suggests that the p e r m a n e n t m a g n e t properties of alnico are due principally to the shape anisotropy of the a~ ( F e - C o ) particles and that the contribution f r o m the magnetocrystalline anisotropy is relatively small. A technique for determining the magnetic anisotropy energy of alnico magnets has been developed by Allec (1971). This is based on a m e t h o d originally used on single crystals by Guillaud (1953) and enables the anisotropy constants to be d e t e r m i n e d f r o m the magnetization curves in various directions for single crystal, c o l u m n a r and polycrystalline specimens.
2.5. Magnetostriction of alnico 5 and alnico 5 D G (Alnico 5-7) T h e magnetostriction in alnico 5 has been investigated in considerable detail by Hoselitz and McCaig (1949) and McCaig (1949). T h e y m e a s u r e d the magnetostriction as a function of the direction of magnetization and the direction of m e a s u r e m e n t for specimens of alnico 5-7 which had been cooled from 1300°C in a magnetic field (a) parallel to the c o l u m n a r crystal axis and (b) perpendicular to the c o l u m n a r axis. T h e saturation magnetostriction, hs, was shown to d e p e n d very strongly on the particular set of angular relationships (angles were either 0 ° or 90 °)
134
R.A. McCURRIE
between the columnar axis, the field direction during cooling, the direction of magnetization and the direction of m e a s u r e m e n t of &. The observed values of A~ (McCaig 1949) ranged from - 6 1 x 10 -6 to 54 x 10 -6. McCaig (1949) also made measurements of As as a function of the direction of magnetization and the direction of m e a s u r e m e n t for alnico 5 specimens with (a) columnar crystals (anisotropic) and (b) randomly oriented crystals (isotropic) which had n o t been cooled in a magnetic field. The observed values of A~ for (a) also depended very strongly on the angular relationship (angles either 0 ° or 90 °) between the columnar axis, the direction of magnetization and the direction of m e a s u r e m e n t of As and ranged from - 7 . 5 × 10 .6 to 34.2× 10 .6 . For the (b) specimen with randomly oriented crystals (i.e. isotropic) the longitudinal saturation magnetostriction was 20 x 10 .6 while that measured perpendicular to the direction of magnetization, i.e., the transverse saturation magnetostriction was --8 X 10 -6. An extensive investigation of the magnetostriction of alnico alloys has been made by Nesbitt (1950) who showed that for polycrystalline alnico 5 alloys the saturation magnetostriction constants As depended very strongly on the heat treatment; the observed values of As were in the range 2.5 to 43 x 10 -6 which includes both longitudinal (i.e. parallel to the direction of the field applied during cooling) and transverse measurements of &. The low longitudinal value (2.5 × 10 -6) is due to the fact that the magnetization vectors in most of the interaction domains (see section 16) are either parallel or antiparallel to the applied field and hence at an angle of 180 ° to the domain magnetization and therefore do not contribute to a change in length of the specimen as a whole. The high transverse value (43 x 10 -6) is due to the fact that after cooling in a transverse field (i.e. in the direction perpendicular to that in which the magnetostriction is measured) most of the magnetization vectors of the interaction domains are perpendicular to the direction of m e a s u r e m e n t of As and so after magnetization in the measuring field each domain contributes to the overall change in length of the specimen. For an alnico 5 which was cooled from 1300°C at 2°Cs -1 (i.e. at the rate necessary to give o p t i m u m p e r m a n e n t magnet properties) the saturation magnetostriction & after tempering was 35 x 10 -6, whereas a specimen of alnico 5 which was given the commercial thermomagnetic and tempering treatment for o p t i m u m permanent magnet properties was found to have a saturation magnetostriction ),s of only 7.5 × 10 -6. 2.6. Microstructures of alnico 5 alloys The first attempts to determine the microstructures of alnico 5 alloys were made by Heidenreich and Nesbitt (1952) who used an oxide replica technique and electron microscopy. Unfortunately they were unable to resolve the microstructure in the optimum permanent magnet state. The microstructures and particle dimensions which they reported were obtained from specimens which had been over-aged by heat treatment at 800°C in order to m a k e the microstructure visible. Heidenreich and Nesbitt (1952) observed a rod-like precipitate which
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS
135
tended to grow along (100) directions and to group into plate-like arrays. When there was no applied field during the heat treatment the cubic symmetry of the rods (i.e. their long axes were parallel to the (100) directions) was very clearly discernible. However, when the alnico 5 was heat treated in an applied field the long axes of the particles were confined to a single (100) direction when the field was parallel to that direction. By extrapolating their results to zero time at 800°C, Heidenreich and Nesbitt (1952) estimated that the particle dimensions were 7.5 × 7.5 × 40 nm. They also concluded that the particles were F e - C o rich and had a Curie temperature higher than that of the Ni-A1 rich matrix. By using very thin thermally grown oxide replicas and electron microscopy Kronenberg (1954) was able to observe the microstructure of alnico 5 in the optimum permanent magnet state but the results were inconclusive. Fahlenbrach (1954, 1955, 1956) used a refinement of the oxide replica technique and was able to show that after cooling in a magnetic field and tempering to give optimum permanent magnet properties the particles (Fe-Co) were rods 40 nm in diameter and 100rim long. Similar results were also obtained by Schulze (1956) who estimated the particle dimensions to be 36nm in diameter and 120nm long. Further improvements were made by Haanstra et al. (1957) and de Jong et al. (1958) who obtained very clear electron micrographs of alnico 5 and alnico 8 in the optimum permanent magnet state by using carbon replicas. They also concluded that the F e - C o rich particles were rods (approximately 30 nm x 30 n m × 120 nm) and that their long axes were parallel to the [100] direction which was closest to the direction of the applied field during the thermomagnetic treatment. The most comprehensive study of the microstructures of the alnicos (including Fe2NiA1) has been made by D e Vos (1966, 1969) who confirmed all the above conclusions concerning the microstructure of alnico 5 - an example of the latter is shown in fig. 16, from which it can be seen that the particles are about 150 nm long and about 40 nm in diameter. De Vos also showed that the higher coercivities which are observed in alnicos 8 and 9 can be attributed to the very high degree of particle elongation, perfection and alignment which results from the higher Co content and hence their greater sensitivity to thermomagnetic treatment (Zijlstra 1960-1962). Further confirmation of these microstructures has been made by Granovsky et al. (1967) and Pashkov et al. (1970). The microstructures of alnico 5 alloys have also been investigated by Pfeiffer (1969), Bronner et al. (1967), Mason et al. (1970), Nicholson and Tufton (1966) and Kronenberg (1960, 1961) who used transmission electron microscopy. From the above electron microscopy studies of alnico 5 it can be concluded that the volume fraction, p, of the o~1 (Fe-Co) phase is in the range 0.6-0.7, and that the degree of elongation (i.e. the ratio of the length to the diameter of the particles, l/d) is in the range ~ 4 - 6 . The observed values of p and I/d depend of course on the composition, thermomagnetic treatment and the temperature and time for which the alloys are annealed. According to Arbuzov and Pavlyukov (1965) both the c~1 (Fe-Co) and O~2 (Ni-A1) phases are ordered and have the bcc structure. However, Granovsky et al. (1967) and Pashkov et al. (1969) have shown by very careful X-ray diffraction
136
R.A. McCURRIE
H
l a
b Fig. 16. Microstructures of alnico 5; (a) in a plane parallel to applied field H and (b) in a plane perpendicular to H (magnification 45500 x) (De Vos 1966).
studies t h a t b o t h t h e a~ a n d og2 p h a s e s a r e very slightly t e t r a g o n a l . F o r alnico 5 the l a t t e r a u t h o r s f o u n d for t h e a l ( F e - C o ) p h a s e a = 0.2876 nm, c = 0.2872 n m a n d c/a = 0.998 a n d for t h e a 2 (Ni-A1) phase, a = 0.2870 nm, c = 0.2872 n m a n d c/a = 1.001. H o w e v e r , f r o m t r a n s m i s s i o n e l e c t r o n m i c r o s c o p y Pfeiffer (1969) a n d B r o n n e r et al. (1967) c o n c l u d e d , in d i s a g r e e m e n t with the X - r a y diffraction results, t h a t only the a2 ( N i - A I ) p h a s e is o r d e r e d a n d that the a l ( F e - C o ) p h a s e is a d i s o r d e r e d solid solution. F r o m m e a s u r e m e n t s of t h e m a g n e t i c p r o p e r t i e s of alnico 5 S e r g e y e v a n d B u l y g i n a (1970) a n d B u l y g i n a a n d S e r g e y e v (1969) c o n c l u d e d t h a t t h e v o l u m e fraction, p, of the c~1 ( F e - C o ) p h a s e a r e in the r a n g e 0.62-0.67, d e p e n d i n g on t h e t h e r m o m a g -
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS 137 netic heat treatment, and hence are in excellent agreement with those observed directly from the electron microscopical studies.
2.Z Alnico 6 This is a high coercivity form of random grain alnico 5. The higher coercivity is due to a Ti or Nb addition but is achieved, unfortunately, at the expense of a lower energy product (see table 2). A typical demagnetization curve for alnico 6 is shown in fig. 17. 1"2
I-
Alnicos 6,7,8
d 0"8
0"4 6
-12
-8
- 4 H (~104Am - 1 )
0
0
Fig. 17. Demagnetization curves for anisotropic alnicos 6, 7 and 8.
3. Anisotropic alnicos 8 and 9
3.1. Thermomagnetic treatment of anisotropic alnico 8 The high energy products of alnico 5-7 (alnico 5DG, alnico 7) are achieved principally as a result of" the increased remanence parallel to the 'thermomagnetic field' direction and the preferred or columnar crystal axis. The coercivity on the other hand remains almost the same as that in alnico 5 with randomly oriented grains. It can be seen from fig. 11 that the various forms of alnico 5 all have nearly rectangular demagnetization curves so that the alloys are used at m a x i m u m efficiency only if the load line or load permeance B / H intersects the demagnetization curve at a point corresponding to the (BH)maxenergy product. A slight shift of the load permeance results in a significant decrease in the available energy. Since the composition of the alloy limits the m a x i m u m remanence to about 1.4T, further squaring of the demagnetization curve will not result in a significant increase in the m a x i m u m energy product. In view of this limitation considerable research effort has been expended to increase the coercivity, and this has been achieved by increasing the cobalt content to 32-36wt % and adding
138
R.A. McCURRIE
4-5 wt % titanium. The addition of Ti alone was found to increase the coercivity but this was, unfortunately, accompanied by a decrease in the remanence (Honda 1934). To compensate for the latter Koch et al. (1957) found that it is necessary to increase the cobalt content to ~ 3 5 % . Koch et al. (1957) found that if the alnico 8 alloy containing 35.5% Fe, 34% Co, 14.5% Ni, 7% A1, 5% Ti, 4% Cu was cooled from 1260°C in a saturating magnetic field and subsequently tempered at 585°C the following properties were obtained: Br = 0.85 T, BHc = 92 kAm -1 and (BH)max--28 kJm -3. When the same alloy was given an isothermal heat treatment at ~800°C for several minutes (precise details not specified) in a saturating magnetic field there was a significant improvement in the magnetic properties to: Br = 0.9 T, BH~ = 112 k A m -1 and ( B H ) ~ = 40kJm -~. Koch et al. (1957) concluded that for Ti-containing alnicos the best magnetic properties are obtained by isothermal heat treatment in a saturating magnetic field (~200-300 kAm -1) followed by tempering for several hours at 585°C. De Vos (1966, 1969) suggested that because the Ti ion has a large radius it has a low rate of diffusion and therefore requires a longer time at high temperatures for the phase separation to occur. From electron microscopy Koch et al. (1959) showed that for alnico 5 which had been isothermally heat treated in a magnetic field the a l (Fe-Co) particles were much more elongated than those which had been given the conventional thermomagnetic treatment (i.e. cooling in a magnetic field). Koch et al. (1959) also found that even higher coercivities could be obtained with a cobalt content >34% Co and a Ti content > 5 % Ti. For alnico 8 alloys with 34-40% Co and 5-8% Ti, Wyrwich (1963), Stfiblein (1963), Planchard et al. (1964b), Bronner et al. (1966a, b) and Vallier et al, (1967), Livshitz et al. (1970a) have shown that coercivities BHc --~ 176 kAm -1 and energy products up to ~48 kJm -3 can be obtained. Bronner et al. (1966a, b) found that the energy product of 48 kJm -3 was constant up to about 45% Co. Wright (1970) and Bronner et al. (1970a) have shown that the addition of niobium as well as titanium also has beneficial effects on the magnetic properties of alnicos 5, 6, 8 and 9, though alnico 5-7 should contain a small addition of niobium only. Typical compositions and magnetic properties of alnico 8 alloys are given in table 5. Koch et al. (1959) found that for the alloy 35.5% Fe, 34% Co, 14.5% Ni, 7% A1, 4% Cu, 5% Ti, the homogeneous bcc ce phase is stable only above about 1250°C and that between 1250°C and 845°C it decomposed to form another bcc c~ phase and an fcc y phase with lattice parameter, a0 = 0.365nm. In the range 845-800°C, the c~ phase decomposes spinodally to form a bcc F e - C o rich al phase and a bcc Ni-A1 rich a2 phase. A small amount of the y phase is also present at this stage but below 800°C this transforms by an apparently diffusionless reaction to another bcc phase, c~v with lattice parameter 0.359 nm. Ritzow (1963) suggested that the difficulties encountered in controlling the heat treatment of the high Ti alloys is probably due to the fact that the Curie temperature is practically in the y region (see section 9) so that the isothermal thermomagnetic treatment temperature is very critical. Julien and Jones (1965a, b)
S T R U C F U R E A N D P R O P E R T I E S OF A L N I C O P E R M A N E N T M A G N E T A L L O Y S
139
TABLE 5 High coercivity field-treated anisotropic alnico 8 alloys. Composition Fe
Ni
A1
Co
Cu
Ti
Nb
B, (T)
BHc (kAm -l)
(BH)max (Jm -3)
40.8
14.6
6.9
28.5
3
4.2
2
0.95
97
40
35
14.9
7
34
4.5
5
-
0.96
103
41
34.5
14.3
6,9
34
3.8
5.5
1
0,88
117
41
36
14
7,5
34
3
5
0.5
0.93
119
46 48
35
13
7.5
34
3
6
1.5
0.83
/ ' 150
29.5
14
7.5
38
3
8
-
0.74
167
48
35.5
14
7.5
34
3
4.5
1.5
0.8
162
48
33
15
7.5
34
3
7
0.5 Hf
0.8
154
49
N.B. 1 T = 10 4 G ; 1 A m -~ = (4:7/1000) Oe; 1 Jm -3 = 40~ GOe.
have shown that if an alloy of alnico 8 with 32% Co and 6.5% Ti is held at 900°C for about 15 rain the 3' phase is produced which lowers the (BH)max product by 50% compared with the same alloy which had not been annealed at 900°C, They also found that the tendency to precipitate the 3' phase was increased when the Cu content was increased (a similar effect was observed in alnico 5) while the Ti suppressed its formation. The homogenization temperature was just below the melting point. If alnico 8 alloys are cooled too slowly the appearance of the 3' phase results in a deterioration in magnetic properties which manifests itself in a concave demagnetization curve just as occurs in alnico 5 (see fig. 18). Such concave demagnetization curves can be synthesised from three normal demagnetization curves. The effects of the a~ phase on the hysteresis loops have also been discussed by Julien and Jones (1965b). In view of the tendency of Ticontaining alnico 8 alloys to form the fcc Y phase their heat treatment must be Carefully controlled in order to obtain optimum magnetic properties. This inevitably increases the cost of their p r o d u c t i o n - though this is largely due to the high cobalt content. The kinetics of the a ~ 3, transformation in alnico 8 (and alnico 5) alloys have also been investigated by Planchard et al. (1964a, 1965, 1966a). A study of the influence of cobalt on the c~ ~ 3, transformation has been made by Marcon et al. (1971) who showed that for alnicos containing more than 28% Co it is practically impossible to avoid the precipitation of the deleterious y phase during thermomagnetic treatment unless appropriate amounts of a-stabilizing elements such as silicon or titanium are added. A typical heat treatment for alnico 8 alloys is as follows. After controlled
140
R.A. McCURRIE
1"2
Alnico 5
1.0
0.8 ~ m 0.6 O "O
0"4 x
_= I.I.
0"2
t
0
60
50
40 30 20 10 Applied field,H (kAm-1.)
0
Fig. 18. Demagnetization curve for alnico 5 showing deleterious effect of the presence of the o~ fcc phase on the shape of the curve.
(BH) max (k Jrn-3) 80 60 40 //
/I
¢I
~
//
1.2
/I
,
/ i/./
1-4
i
1I
//
1"0 ~ "
ii
0"8
m ¢n c
0.6 ¢~ qD X
0.4 0.2 !
160
140
120 100 80 Applied field, H
60 40 CkAm-1)
I
20
0
Fig. 19. Demagnetization curve for alnicos 8, 9 and 5-7. The latter two curves are given for comparison. The alloy 8(b), which has the highest coercivity is also known as sermalloy A1 (Bronner et al. 1966b). c o o l i n g f r o m a b o v e 1250°C, t h e a l l o y is h e a t t r e a t e d f o r a f e w m i n u t e s at a b o u t 820°C in a s a t u r a t i n g m a g n e t i c field ( ~ 3 0 0 k A m -1) a n d t e m p e r e d f o r a b o u t 6 h at 650°C f o l l o w e d by a b o u t 24 h at 550°C.
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS 141 A typical B - H demagnetization curve for alnico 8 is shown in fig. 19, the compositions and magnetic properties of various alnico 8 alloys are given in table 5.
3.2. Extra high coercivity alnico 8 A higher coercivity field-treated random grain form of alnico 8 can be produced by increasing the cobalt and titanium contents still further to 37-40% Co and 7-8% Ti. Sometimes a little (0.5 to 1.5%) of the titanium is replaced by niobium. The maximum coercivity of these extra high coercivity alnico 8 alloys is about 180 kAm -1 which is higher than that of any other alnico. The production and properties of extra high coercivity alnico 8 alloys have been described and investigated by Wyrwich (1963), Planchard et al. (1964b, 1966b), Bronner et al. (1966a, b), Vallier et al. (1967) and Bronner et al. (1970a). Planchard et al. (1964b) and Bronner et al. (1966a) studied the dependence of the magnetic properties on the Ni, Ti, A1 and Cu content for alloys containing 40% Co. Planchard et al. (1964b) obtained a maximum coercivity BHc = 161 kAm -1 with Br = 0.71 T and (BH)m~ = 44 kJm -3, for an alloy containing 27.5% F e - 4 0 % C o - 14% N i - 8 % A 1 - 7 . 5 % T i - 3 % Cu. The alloy was homogenized at 1250°C for 1 h and then heat treated isothermally for 5 minutes at 810°C in a magnetic field of 336 kAm -1. After this treatment the alloy was annealed for 6 h at 650°C and then for 24 h at 550°C. In a later investigation Bronner et al. (1966b) developed an alloy containing 29.5% F e - 3 8 % C o - 1 4 % N i - 7 . 5 % A 1 - 8 % T i - 3 % Cu with a coercivity BHo = 168 kAm -I with Br = 0.74 T and (BH)max = 48 kJm -3. These properties were obtained by homogenization at 1250°C in a neutral or reducing atmosphere followed by cooling in compressed air to 600°C in order to avoid the precipitation of the deleterious 3, phase. The alloy was then isothermally annealed for a few minutes at 820°C in a magnetic field ~336 kAm 1 and then tempered for 6 h at 640°C and finally for 24 h at 550°C. This alloy, which is an extra high coercivity alnico 8, is also known as sermalloy A1. Apart from its high coercivity and energy product, sermalloy A1 has high useful recoil energy (a maximum Erec ~ 20 kJm -3) and a high Curie temPerature Tc = 874°C so that it is very stable under demagnetizing conditions and at temperatures up to about 550°C. An alloy, with almost identical properties to sermalloy A~, also known as hycomax IV has also been developed by Harrison and Wright (1967). A typical demagnetization curve for this special alnico 8 alloy (A1) is shown in fig. 19. Koch et al. (1957) investigated the effectiveness of Ti and Nb additions in increasing the coercivity of alnico 8 alloys and concluded that Ti was more effective. However, Bronner et al. (1970a) and Bronner (1970) found that the addition of Nb (0.5-2.0%) to alnico 8 alloys containing 4.5-6.5% Ti could be beneficial. For example the alloy 35.5% F e - 34% C o - 14% N i - 7.5% A 1 - 4.5% T i - 3 % C u - 1 . 5 % Nb B H c = 1 6 2 k A m -1, B r = 0 . 8 T and (BH)max=48kJm -3. Bronner (1970) reported that the addition of hafnium was also beneficial and found that the alloy 33% F e - 3 4 % C o - 15% N i - 7.5% A 1 - 7% T i - 3% Cu with 0.5% Hf had a coercivity td-/c = 154 k A m -1, a Br = 0.8 T and a (BH)m~ = 49 kJm -3.
142
R.A. McCURRIE
Similar investigations of extra high coercivity alnico 8 alloys have been made by Livshitz et al. (1970a) who used a wide variety of thermomagnetic and tempering treatments. They obtained magnetic properties in the ranges Hc = 160-176 kAm -1, Br = 0.65-0.75 T and (BH)m~x = 36-44 kJm -3 for alloys containing 38% Co and 8.0-8.5% Ti after optimum thermomagnetic and tempering treatments. The compositions and magnetic properties of some typical extra high coercivity alnico 8 alloys are given in table 5. A simplified heat treatment, using continuous cooling, rather than isothermal heat treatment in a magnetic field (240 kAm -1) for alnico 8 alloys has been developed by Wright (1970). He showed that by cooling alloys with compositions in the range 34-35% Co, 14-15% Ni, 6.8-7.2% A1, 5-5.4% Ti, 0.8-1.1% Nb, 3 - 4 % Cu, balance Fe from 1250°C (at average rates of 2, 1.2, and 0.6°Cs -I from 1200-600°C) in a magnetic field of 240 kAm 1 followed by tempering for 4 h at 640°C and then for 16h at 570°C, magnetic properties better than Br = 0.85 T BHc = l l 2 k A m -~ and (BH)max = 36kJm -3 can be obtained. Wright (1970) also showed that if 0.25% S is added to the alloys, magnets with columnar crystals can be produced by casting in a mould with heated sides and chilled at the end faces. For these columnar magnets typical properties are, Br = 1.03 T, BHc = 118 kAm -~, and (BH)max = 58 kJm -3. Columnar alnico 8 alloys i.e. alnico 9 alloys are discussed in section 3.3.
3.3. Anisotropic alnico 9 with fully columnar grains Alnico 9 is produced by the columnar crystallization of alnico 8. Unfortunately, the high Ti content of the latter reduces the grain size (Luteijn and De Vos 1956) so that columnar crystallization of alnico 8 is difficult. Luteijn and De Vos (1956) succeeded in producing a grain oriented alnico 9 magnet by using special techniques. For the alloy containing 35% Fe, 34% Co, 15% Ni, 7% A1, 5% Ti and 4% Cu by weight, they obtained a magnet with Br = 1.18 T, BHc =- 105 kAm -1 and (BH)max = 88 kJm -3. These very high values were obtained by using very pure starting materials and isothermal heat treatment parallel to the [100] axis of the columnar grains. The demagnetization curves for the alloy are shown in fig. 19. Gould (1964), Makino and Kimura (1965), Wittig (1966) and Harrison and Wright (1967) have shown that these difficulties in producing fully columnar alnico 9 magnets can be overcome by the addition of small quantities of S, Se or Te. Alnico 9 can be prepared as follows. After melting an alnico 8 alloy with a small addition of S, Se or Te (sometimes two of these elements are added) the fully columnar structure is obtained by casting the alloy in a heated or exothermic mould in which the end faces are chilled so that grains with (100) axes grow perpendicularly to the chilled surfaces. The alloy is then solution treated at 1250°C cooled at a controlled rate and heat treated in a saturating magnetic field (~300 kAm -1) for a few minutes at about 820°C and finally given a two-stage tempering treatment for several hours at 650°C and at 550°C. The grain structure of a fully columnar alnico 9 magnet is shown in fig. 20.
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS 143
Fig. 20. Grain structure of fully columnar alnico 9 (Gould 1964) (magnification: ~2x).
The production of columnar alnico 9 has also been described and investigated by Fahlenbrach and Stfiblein (1964), Naastepad (1966), Harrison (1966), Hoffmann and Stfiblein (1966, 1967, 1970), Palmer and Shaw (1969), Dean and Mason (1969), Hoffmann and Pant (1970) and Pant (1974). Hoffmann and Pant (1970) produced magnets (containing 7.7% Ti) with coercivities up to a m a x i m u m of Uric = 1 7 1 k A m -1, iHc = 1 7 9 k A m -l, B r = 0 . 8 7 T and (BH)max = 7 7 k J m -3. They also produced a magnet (containing 7.1% Ti) with an energy product (BH)max = 98 kJm -3 in combination with ~Hc = 136 k A m -1, i S c ~ 138 k A m -~ and Br = 1.03 T. Pant (1974) produced alnico 9 magnets having diameters ~ 1 5 - 8 0 m m with a columnar crystallization length of ~120 m m for which (BH)max ~ 90 kJm -3 (with BHo = 150 k A m -1) and (BH)max ~ 80 k J m -3 (with BHc ~ 160 kAm-1). Although the coercivity of alnico 9 is nearly the same as that of alnico 8 the higher energy product is due to the increased remanence parallel to the columnar axis i.e. [100]. The improved properties of alnico 9 parallel to the columnar axis are of course achieved at the expense of those perpendicular to the columnar axis but in many applications this is not a serious disadvantage. Demagnetization curves for alnicos, 8 and 9 are shown in fig. 19 from which it can be seen that the magnetic properties of alnico 9 are considerably better than those for alnico 8; the m a x i m u m energy products for alnico 9 are typically in the range 60-75 kJm -3. The higher energy products of alnicos 8 and 9 compared with alnico 5-7 are, unfortunately, obtained at the expense of a reduced remanence. T h e relationship between the magnetic properties and the crystal textures of alnico 9 alloys have been investigated by Higuchi and Miyamoto (1970) and D u r a n d - C h a r r e et al. (1978). T h e latter used Schulz's (1949) X-ray diffraction method and found that the observed metallurgical texture could be correlated with the solidification rates. Grain growth by solid state recrystallization in various alnico 9 alloys has been
144
R.A. M c C U R R I E
investigated by Wright and Ogden (1964) but although some large crystals were grown the technique was not considered to be very successful. The dependence of the magnetic properties of columnar alnico 9 on the angle between the columnar axis and the direction of thermomagnetic treatment, and the angle of measurement is discussed in section 7.3. The development and chronology of alnico magnets are shown in fig. 21 (Cronk 1966). The best magnetic properties are of course obtained for single crystal alnicos. Naastepad (1966) showed that a single crystal containing 35 wt % Fe, 34.8% Co, 14.9% Ni, 7.5% A1, 5.4% Ti and 2.4% Cu had a coercivity 8He of 122kAm -1 and an energy product (BH)max of 107kJm -3. The latter energy product is the highest yet reported for any alnico. A summary of the magnetic properties and compositions of columnar alnico 9 alloys is given in table 6. 120 Alnicos DG -- Directed grain MC - Monocrystal
100 ¢0 I
E
-~
MC9
MC5
80
5-7 x
60
5DG
E
.,p m
40
2
20
II I I 1940 1950 Calendar year
o
1930
!
I
1960
1970
Fig. 21. Development and chronology of alnico magnets (after Cronk 1966),
TABLE 6 Compositions and magnetic properties of anisotropic field-treated alnico 9 columnar alloys. Composition Fe
Ni
A1
Co
Cu
Ti
Nb
Others
26.1
14.7
6.8
40.3
2.9
8,2
-
35.2 35 36.1 29
14.8 15 14.5 14
7 7 7 7
33.1 34 34 38.9
4.5 4 3 3,5
5.5 5 5.2 7.1
-
35
14.9
7.5
34.8
2.4
5.4
-
0.77 Te O.22 S 0.22 S 0,2S 0.45 S 0.05 C -
N.B. 1 T
=
10 4
G; 1 A m -1 = (4~'/1000) Oe; 1 Jm -3 = 40~r GOe.
Br (T)
BEe (kAm -1)
(BH)max (kJm -3)
0.895
160
67
1.095 1,18 1.11 1.03
123 104.5 129 136
83.5 87.5 91.5 97
1.15
121
106
STRUCTURE
AND PROPERTIES
OF ALNICO PERMANENT
MAGNET
ALLOYS
145
3.4. Shape anisotropy of alnicos 8 and 9 The effects of varying the cobalt and titanium contents on the induced shape anisotropy constant K. of alnico alloys have been studied by Takeuchi and Iwama (1976) (see also section 2.4). They found that for an alnico 8 alloy (29.5% F e - 39% C o - 14% N i - 7% A1- 7.5% T i - 3% Cu) Ku = 2.4 × 105 Jm -3 and a magnetocrystalline anisotropy constant K1 = 0.26 x 105 Jm -3, thus confirming that the anisotropy and hence the coercivity of alnico alloys is due predominantly to the shape anisotropy of the individual Fe-Co rich particles. The induced anisotropy constant K. was of course measured on single crystal specimens in which the individual particles were almost fully aligned by the thermomagnetic treatment. TABLE 7
Compositions of single crystal alnicos. Specimen No.
Fe
1
51.4
2
Ni
Al
Co
Cu
Ti
14
7.7
23.9
3
0
47.9
14.4
7.9
26
2.5
1.3
3
43.5
14
7.6
29
2.9
3
4
29.5
14
7
39
3
7.5
TABLE 8
Apparent anisotropy constants Ku and K,] ( x 104 J m -3) determined by torque measurements, volume fraction, p, particle diameter d, elongation l/d intrinsic coercivity iHc and flux coercivity BHc (K" = Ku/p) (Takeuchi and Iwama 1976). Specimen No.
Ti (wt % )
Ku (104Jm -3)
p
d (nm)
lid
inc (kAm-1)
BH¢ (kAm-1)
K" ( 1 0 4 j m 3)
1
0
15.6
0.68
44
4-5
57
-
22.9
2
1.3
16.1
0.67
42
6-7
59
-
24
3
3.0
17.3
0.63
37
8-12
67
-
27.5
4
7.5
24.2
0.46 ~
30
30-50
167
-
52.6
Alnico 5*
0.0
15.2
0.67
40
4-6
-
53
22.7
Alnico 8*
5.0
23
0.54
30
13-16
-
114
42.6
Alnico 8"*
7.5
-
-
20
30-35
-
147
-
*Sergeyev and Bulygina (1970) and **Granovsky et al. (1967). N.B. 1 T = 104 G ; 1 A m -1 = (47r/1000) O e ; 1 J m -3 = 40~" G O e .
146
R.A. McCURRIE
This is clearly shown by the electron micrographs obtained by Takeuchi and Iwama (1976). Their value of Ku = 2.4 x 105 Jm -3 is in very good agreement with that obtained by Sergeyev and Bulygina (1970) who found a Ku = 2.3 x 105 Jm -3 for an alnico 8 alloy containing 26.5% F e - 40% C o - 1 4 % N i - 7.5% A 1 - 7.5% T i - 4 . 5 % Cu. The alloy was homogenized at 1240°C, cooled to 800°C at 5°Cs -1 and then annealed for about 12 rain at 820°C in a magnetic field of 160 kAm -1 after which the alloy was tempered for 5 h at 650°C and 20 h at 560°C. The compositions and properties of the alloys used in the above investigations are summarized in tables 7 and 8. The high coercivities of alnico 8 (and alnico 9) can be attributed to the increased shape anisotropy energy resulting from the high cobalt content and the addition of titanium. The effects of cobalt and titanium contents on the magnetic properties are discussed in sections 8 and 9 respectively.
3.5. Microstructures of.alnicos 8 and 9 Replication electron micrographs of the highly oriented microstructure of an alnico 8 alloy were obtained by De Vos (1966, 1969). Typical microstructures in planes parallel and perpendicular to the thermomagnetic field direction are shown in figs. 22(a) and (b). The regular distribution of the precipitated particles in both orientations is characteristic of a system in which phase separation has occurred by spinodal decomposition. From measurements on the electron micrographs the average dimensional length to diameter ratio 1/d is >10 and from the application of quantitative metallography (Hilliard 1962, 1967, 1968, Hilliard and Cahn 1961, Underwood 1970, 1973, Saltykov 1970) the volume fraction of the particles is ~0.65. Although the volume fraction of the particles is comparable to that of the other alnicos there is a marked increase in the dimensional ratio, degree of particle alignment and particle perfection; all of these factors contribute to the increased coercivity of the alnico 8 alloys compared with alnico 5 alloys. Since alnico 9 alloys have similar compositions to the alnico 8 alloys (alnico 9 is simply a columnar crystallized alnico 8) it may be assumed that the microstructures are similar to those of alnico 8. The microstructures of alnico 8 alloys have also been investigated by Bronner et al. (1967), Granovsky et al. (1967), Pfeiffer (1969), Mason et al. (1970), Livshitz et al. (1970b), Iwama et al. (1970) and Takeuchi and Iwama (1976). From the electron micrographs obtained by the above authors it can be seen that the F e - C o rich particles have length to diameter ratios l/d in the range 10-50 where l ~ 400-1000 nm and d is in the range 20-40 nm. The application of quantitative metallography to the electron micrographs shows that the volume fraction of the F e - C o rich particles is ~0.65. Although the volume fraction of the particles in alnico 8 is comparable to that in the other alnicos, there is a marked increase in the elongation (l/d), the degree of particle alignment and particle perfection; all of these factors contribute to the increased coercivity of alnico 8 alloys compared with alnico 5 alloys. By using X-ray electron diffraction Pashkov et al. (1969) measured the lattice parameters of the bcc a~ and a2 phases in three alnico 8 alloys containing
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS
147
Fig. 22. Electron micrograpti of the al + ~2 structure of alnico 8 after an isothermal heat treatment at 800°C for 9 min; (a) in a plane parallel to the direction of the applied field during heat treatment, (b) in a plane perpendicular to the field direction (magnification 45500 ×) (after De Vos 1966).
TABLE 9 Lattice parameters of the bcc oq and c~2 phases in alnico 8 alloys (A). c~1 phase (Fe-Co) Alnico 8
a
c
35% Co, 5% Ti
2.909
2.873
40% Co, 7% Ti
2.909
42% Co, 8% Ti
2.915
c~2 phase (Ni-A1) c/a
a
c
c/a
0.99
2.855
2.873
1.006
2.872
0.987
2.850
2.872
1.008
2.872
0.985
2.852
2.872
1.007
148
R.A. McCURRIE
respectively, 35, 40, 42% Co and 5, 7, and 8% Ti; their results are shown in table 9, from which it can be seen that both the eel and O~2 phases are very slightly tetragonal with c/a < 1 and c/a > 1 respectively.
4. M6ssbauer spectroscopy of alnicos 5 and 8
From M6ssbauer spectroscopy measurements on alnico 5, Shtrikman and Treves (1966) have concluded that in the optimum permanent magnet state, the alloy consists of two phases one of which is an Fe-rich ferromagnetic phase and the other is a Ni and Cu rich paramagnetic phase. M6ssbauer measurements on alnico 8 made by Albanese et al. (1970) show that 7-8% of the total Fe content is paramagnetic. From the quadrupole splitting of the M6ssbauer spectra it was also concluded that the two phases have a small tetragonal distortion in agreement with the X-ray work of Bulygina and Sergeyev (1969). Van Wieringen and Rensen (1966) also detected the presence of Fe in both the al and Og2 phases. They have also shown that after continuous cooling of alnico 5 all the Fe atoms have a ferromagnetic environment suggesting that both the c~1 and O~2 phases are ferromagnetic, whereas after tempering (Ho = 50 kAm -1) 5% of the total iron content is in a non-ferromagnetic phase. The M6ssbauer spectra of alnico 5 and alnico 8, particularly the latter, have also been investigated in detail by Makarov et al. (1967), Belova et al. (1969), Povitsky et al. (1970), Belozersky et al. (1971) and Makarov et al. (1972). A short review of M6ssbauer measurements on the alnicos has been published by Schwartz (1976).
5. Sintered alnicos
The alnico alloys whether isotropic or anisotropic can also be made by mixing suitably fine metal powders, pressing to a green compact followed by a sintering heat treatment at about 1250-1350°C to produce a homogeneous solid with low porosity. The solid compact is then given a heat treatment appropriate to the particular composition. The resulting magnetic properties of the sintered alloys are comparable, though slightly inferior, to those of the cast alloys. The energy product for anisotropic sintered magnets may sometimes be as much as 20% lower than that for the cast magnets but for isotropic cast magnets the difference is usually smaller than this. A comparison of the magnetic properties of various sintered and cast alnicos has been given by Bronner et al. (1970b). Typical demagnetization curves for four sintered alnicos are shown in fig. 23. The advantage of the sintering process is that very small magnets of intricate shape can be made which is not possible or very expensive by the usual casting and grinding process. However, sintered alnicos have a very small share of the market. The production and magnetic properties of sintered alnicos have been discussed by Schiller (1968), Schiller and Brinkmann (1970) and Heck (1974).
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS 149 - 1-2
Sinteredalnicos/~~
1.0
6
0.8~ 0.6
D'4
(D "0
I,I.
D.2 n 70
0 60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Applied field, H (kAm-1) Fig. 23. Typical B-H demagnetization curves for sintered alnicos 2, 5, 6 and 8.
6. Moulded, pressed or bonded alnico m a g n e t s
Alnico alloys can be milled to fine powders without a marked deterioration in their magnetic properties. If the powders are then bonded into a thermosetting resin they can be accurately pressed or moulded to the required magnet shape. The properties of the bonded magnets are inferior (Dehler 1942, Heck 1974) to those of the cast or sintered magnets. This is due to the fact that the volume fraction of the powder cannot exceed about 60% so that there is a corresponding reduction in the remanence.
7. Effects of t h e r m o m a g n e t i c t r e a t m e n t on the magnetic properties of alnicos 5 - 9
7.1. Factors controlling development of Ol 1 particle shape anisotropy The factors which control the development of the magnetic anisotropy of alnico 5 during thermomagnetic treatment have been studied in detail by Zijlstra (19601962) following a suggestion made by N6el (1947b). H e found that the rate of elongation of the particles is related to the difference between the decrease in the magnetic free energy of the particles in the magnetic field and the simultaneous increase in the interfacial or surface free energy. The equilibrium value of the elongation is high when the magnetic free energy is large compared with the interfacial free energy between the particles and the matrix. Since the former is measured as energy per unit volume and thus independent of particle size and the
150
R.A. McCURRIE
latter is a surface energy and hence inversely proportional to the particle size, the particles will always become considerably elongated when they are sufficiently large. The efficacy of the thermomagnetic treatment on alnico 5 can be attributed to the particularly low value of the interfacial energy or surface free e n e r g y typically this is ~10-3Jm -2 (1 erg cm-2). This enables the particles to become elongated when they are still small enough to display single domain behaviour and thus to form a magnet with high shape anisotropy together with a high coercivity. Zijlstra (1961) suggested that the same reasoning leads to the conclusion that the Mishima alloy Fe2NiAI, which is usually not considered to respond to magnetic annealing owing to its much larger interfacial free energy, may be expected to do so only when the particles are large enough. He verified this conclusion by heat treating a specimen of Fe2NiA1 in a magnetic field for two weeks at 725°C during which it developed a uniaxial magnetic anisotropy of 4.5 x 10 4 Jm 3 which is of the same order of magnitude as that observed in alnico 5. This Fe2NiA1 alloy did not, however, have a high coercivity because after the long thermomagnetic treatment the particles were too large to be single domains. Thus it appears that the function of the cobalt in the alnico alloys, apart from increasing the saturation magnetic polarization and the Curie temperature, is to decrease the interfacial free energy between the Fe-Co rich particles and the Ni-A1 rich matrix and hence to enable the alloys to respond to thermomagnetic treatment with a resulting improvement in their magnetic properties. If the magnetic field is applied only during the cooling over the narrow temperature range 840-790°C with subsequent tempering at 600°C without an applied field, the resulting magnetic properties are only slightly inferior to alloys which have been given the full thermomagnetic treatment. If the field is applied only below 790°C the anisotropy is less than half that of the fully thermomagnetically treated specimens. If the specimen is cooled to 790°C in the presence of the field and then allowed to cool with the field off, the maximum energy product is lower than the value obtained by quenching the alloy from 790°C. The decrease is due presumably to a partial destruction of the shape anisotropy by inhomogeneous demagnetizing fields and thermal fluctuations. The most effective temperature range for the particle elongation and alignment in a magnetic field is therefore 840°C to 790°C; the lower limit is particularly critical. Nesbitt and Williams (1957) suggested that in the temperature range 850-790°C only nucleation takes place, while particle growth occurs at 600°C. However, Zijlstra's (1960-1962) and De Vos' (1966, 1969) experiments showed that in the field cooling treatment the final particle shape is attained in the very first stage (i.e. in the range 850-790°C) and that subsequent heat treatments did not alter the shape or size of the particles. As was mentioned earlier tempering at 600°C increases the difference in the saturation magnetic polarization between the c~1 (Fe-Co rich) and c~2 (Ni-A1 rich) phases and leads to an increase in the coercivity and remanence.
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS 151
7.2. Relationship between the preferred or easy direction of magnetization and the direction of the applied field during thermomagnetic treatment The relationship between the orientation of the particles and the direction of the magnetic field during heat treatment has been investigated by Heidenreich and Nesbitt (1952). They found that the orientation of the particles is not strictly bound to the (100) directions, but could be forced into other directions by the thermomagnetic treatment. In a later paper Nesbitt and Heidenreich (1952a) deduced from magnetic torque measurements that the magnetic anisotropy of alnico 5 was a maximum when the magnetic field was directed along a (100) direction of a single crystal sample during the thermomagnetic treatment. If the field was applied in another direction the anisotropy was lower and the preferred direction of magnetization appeared to lie between the field direction and the nearest (100) direction. Similar results were obtained by Hoselitz and McCaig (1951) but they found that the preferred direction of magnetization was closer to the [100] direction than was indicated by the experiments of Heidenreich and Nesbitt (1952). These differences may be attributable to difference in the magnitudes of the applied fields which were chosen for the thermomagnetic treatments. In another series of experiments McCaig (1953) found that the uniaxial anisotropy of alnico 5 was approximately 105 Jm 3 and that for normal cooling rates (~l.4°Cs -1) and angles less than about 45 ° between the crystal and field directions, the easy direction of magnetization was close to the columnar axis. However, for faster cooling rates, larger angles and less than optimum heat treatments the easy direction of magnetization may be closer to the field direction with a correspondingly lower value of the anisotropy coefficient. An extensive investigation has also been made by Yermolenko et al. (1964) who found that when the thermomagnetic field was parallel to the [100] direction the O/1 (Fe-Co) particles were elongated parallel to this direction but for other angles between the applied field and the [100] direction, the axes of elongation of the particles were not parallel to the field direction. They concluded in contrast to the theory proposed by N6el (1947b) and later developed by Zijlstra (1960-1962) that the axes of elongation are not entirely determined by the minimization of the magnetic and interface energies of the particles in the thermomagnetic field but that their shapes and orientations are partly determined by their elastic energies. It should be mentioned that Yermolenko et al. (1964) used isothermal heat treatment in a magnetic field (720 kAm 1) but this enabled them to study the microstructures of the alloy at different stages in the formation and growth of the particles.
7.3. Dependence of the magnetic properties of the alnicos on the direction of the applied field during thermomagnetic treatment The dependence of the magnetic properties of columnar and single crystal alnico 5 (and alnico 6) on grain orientation and the direction of the thermomagnetic field have been investigated in detail by Ebeling and Burr (1953). They found that the
152
R.A. McCURRIE
best magnetic properties are obtained when the direction of the thermomagnetic field is as close as possible to the [100] direction in the single crystals or to the long axis of the columnar single crystals- i.e., approximately parallel to the [100] direction. When the thermomagnetic field was applied at other angles to [100] or to the [100] columnar axis the maximum energy product decreased according to the cosine of the angle between the thermomagnetic field direction and the [100] or the [100] columnar axis:
(BH)max(O)=
(BH)max(0)cos 0.
The variation of (BH)max with the angle 0 for various sintered single crystals of alnico 5 is shown in fig. 24. From measurements of the energy products of single crystal alnico 5 (51 wt % F e - 24% C o - 14% N i - 8% A 1 - 3% Cu) after heat treatment in a magnetic field parallel to the directions [100], [110] and [111] Zijlstra (1956) showed that the energy product could be expressed as a power series of the direction cosines/31,/32 and/33 measured with respect to the cube axes of the crystal. This was used to calculate the energy product for polycrystalline alnico 5 as a function of crystal orientation. The columnar texture of the magnet was represented by assuming that there was a constant density of [100] axes inside a cone of revolution around the measuring direction which enclosed an angle 2,/. By averaging the above power series for (BH)max Zijlstra obtained an expression for (BH)max in terms of r/. The energy product was shown to decrease almost linearly from 60.8 kJm -3 for ~7 = 0° to 40 kJm -3 for r / = 45 °. The calculated value of the energy product for a
50-
0
~3o
\cosO
"--"20
0
I 0
I
I 30
I
I 60
90
Angle 0 °
Fig. 24. Dependence of (BH)max energy product on the angle between the field applied during thermomagnetic treatment and the [100] preferred or easy axis of magnetization (after Ebeling and Burr 1953).
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS
153
polycrystalline alnico 5 magnet (i.e. one for which ~/= 180 °) was 39.2 kJm -3 which was in good agreement with experiment and suggests that the analysis was essentially correct. An expression for the energy product as a function of ~/ was also developed for magnets in which the crystals are radially oriented in a plane perpendicular to the magnet axis. Magnets with this texture are significantly better than those with randomly oriented grains. The magnetic properties of equiaxed and columnar alnico 5 have been investigated in detail by Makino et al. (1963) and Makino and Kimura (1965). They measured the demagnetization curves parallel and perpendicular to the columnar axis (a) as a function of the angle 0 between the columnar axis and the direction of the 'thermomagnetic field', and (b) as a function of the angle 0' (0' = 90 - 0) between the direction of measurement perpendicular to the columnar axis and the direction of the thermomagnetic field. The results of these measurements are shown in fig. 25 from which it can be seen that the maximum coercivity (58 kAm-1), remanence (1.35 T) and energy product (64 kJm -3) are obtained when the 'thermomagnetic field' is applied parallel to the columnar axis. For the measurements in the direction perpendicular to the columnar axis the maximum coercivity (50kAm-1), remanence (1.32 T) and energy product (42 kJm -3) are obtained when the thermomagnetic field is parallel to the direction of measurement, i.e., perpendicular to the columnar axis. Although the maximum energy product for (b) of 42 kJm -3 is lower than that of 64 kJm -3 for (a) the fact that such a high value was obtained for (b) is an important result because it provides further evidence for the theory that - 1-4
~
0=0¢
I
60
50
1
40 30 Applied field, H
.
20
2
10
(kAm-1}
0
Fig. 25. B - H demagnetization curves measured in the direction M of the columnar axis after heat treatment in a magnetic field at an angle 0 to the columnar axis c (after Makino and Kimura 1965 and Makino et al. 1963).
154
R.A. McCURRIE
15
45
~"~'I0
.
[010] . H ~ ~ . , . 4 ~...Ku " ~
/
/
ool 0~ 0
30
e.ol, I
1 15
I
I 30
I
I 0 45
Angle [30
Fig. 26. Variations of uniaxial anisotropy constant Ku and its direction o~ with direction/9 of the heat treatment field H.
the preferred direction of magnetization is largely determined by the direction of the thermomagnetic field (N6el 1947(b), Zijlstra 1960, 1961) and that crystallographic anisotropy is of secondary importance. Zijlstra (1960, 1961) has shown by experiments on Fe2NiA1 that the time for which the alloy is subjected to the thermomagnetic field treatment is also of fundamental importance in determining the results. (The theories of the effects of thermomagnetic treatment of the alnicos are discussed in section 17.) Iwama et al. (1976) measured the anisotropy constant Ku of single crystal alnico 5 after cooling in a magnetic field at angles 0 °, 15°, 30 ° and 45 ° to the [100] direction. The results are shown in fig. 26; Ko decreased from 15.6× 104Jm -3 parallel to the [100] direction to 4.5 x 104 Jm s at 45 ° to [100]. Figure 26 also shows the variation of the angle a between the preferred axis of Ku and the [100] direction as a function of the angle/3 between the direction of the heat treatment field and the [100] direction. It can be seen that only when /3 = 45 ° does the preferred direction of magnetization (i.e. the Ku axis) follow that of the heat treatment field, i.e., a 2 4 5 °. At lower values of /3 the Ku axis lies between the direction of the heat treatment field and the [100] direction. These results are in good agreement with those obtained by McCaig (1953).
8. Effects of cobalt on the magnetic properties of the alnicos
The addition of cobalt to both the isotropic and anisotropic alnicos has several beneficial effects. In the isotropic alloys it increases the saturation magnetic
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS 155 polarization Js and hence the remanence Jr. Since the cobalt is precipitated in the c~1 phase particles (i.e. the F e - C o rich phase) this increases the difference between the magnetic polarizations of the al and a2 phases and hence increases the coercivity due to the resulting increase in the shape anisotropy. The same improvements are also observed in the anisotropic alnicos 5-9 but in these alloys the cobalt content is in the range 23-40%. The high cobalt content also increases the Curie temperature Tc which has the beneficial effect of increasing the sensitivity (of the alnicos 5-9) to magnetic annealing. This is due to the fact that the spinodal decomposition temperature Ts is then further below Tc so that the magnetic polarization of the particles at Tc is higher, and therefore increases the elongation of the particles in the magnetic field direction because their magnetic free energy is thereby lowered. Cahn (1963) has shown the magnetic energy is proportional to the square of the rate of change of the saturation magnetic polarization with composition i.e. (OJs/Oc)2 and that the latter is very large when the spinodal decomposition temperature is close to the Curie temperature. Thus heat treatment in a magnetic field is expected to be most effective when T~ is close to but lower than To. According to Zijlstra (1960, 1961) the high cobalt content also decreases the interfacial energy ,,/between the F e - C o rich c~i phase and the Ni-A1 rich a2 phase so that the increase in the total surface energy which results from the particle elongation is reduced. N6el (1947b) and Zijlstra (1960, 1961) have suggested that the sensitivity of alnico alloys is proportional to (A J)2~3, where AJ is the difference between the saturation magnetic polarizations of the F e - C o rich c~ phase and the Ni-A1 rich a2 phase. Thus when AJ is high and 3' low the rate of elongation of the particles in the thermomagnetic field is high. This results in an increase in the coercivity, the remanence and the energy product parallel to the direction of the applied field. From tables 2, 3, 5, and 6 it can be seen that there is a substantial improvement in BHc, Br and (BH),nax in the cobalt containing alloys compared with the original F e - N i - A I alloy (table t). Unfortunately the increased cobalt content, particularly in the anisotropic alnicos 5-9, favours the precipitation of the magnetically deleterious fcc phase so that more carefully controlled cooling through the range 1200°C to 850°C is required. Detailed investigations of the effects of cobalt on the magnetic properties of the alnicos have been made by many authors, see e.g., Betteridge (1939), Jellinghaus (1943), Zumbusch (1942a, b), Bronner et al. (1966a-1970). According to Wyrwich (1963) the best magnetic properties are obtained with a cobalt content -~38%.
9. Effects of titanium on the magnetic properties of the alnicos (mainly 6, 8 and 9) The effects of titanium additions on the magnetic properties of the alnico 8 are summarized in fig. 27 from which it can be seen that titanium increases the coercivity and the energy product and the time required to form the undesirable fcc 3, phase at 1050°C, though there is unfortunately a rapid decrease in the remanence with increasing Ti content (Vallier et al. 1967). Similar results were obtained by Iwama et al. (1970) who also showed that the Curie temperature of
156
R.A. M c C U R R I E oO. 120
m
1 " 1 --
O O
1"0--
~" E
4~,16
3C
®
0-9 - ~
3 E
Br
12 0
0
o
toO'8
2
= 8
C
E
[~'mlc
c
0"7-
1 ® E
0 . 6 [-
0
I--
2
4 6 Wt % Ti
8
I
[0
Fig. 27. Effects of titanium additions on the magnetic properties of alnico 8 (41% F e - 3 4 % C o - 15% N i - 7% A I - 3% Cu) (after Vallier et al. 1967).
the Ni-A1 rich OL2 phase decreased linearly with increasing Ti content as shown in fig. 28 from which it can be seen that if the alnico 8 alloy containing more than 5% Ti is annealed at 600°C the Curie temperature falls below room temperature. This increases the coercivity because in normal use (~20°C) the F e - C o rich
6 0 0 I-
.
~,AnneaEed
o
for 48hr at T C
I "~
0 "~_
0.200
0
I
I
I
I
2
4
6
8
Wt % titanium Fig. 28. Variations of Curie temperature of the Ni-AI rich o~2 phase with Ti content for alnico specimens annealed at various temperatures (after Iwama et al. 1970).
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS 157 particles are then surrounded by a non-ferromagnetic matrix and are not therefore in exchange contact so that the difference between the saturation magnetic polarizations of the F e - C o rich al phase and the Ni-AI rich ~2 phase is as large as possible; the latter therefore increases the shape anisotropy energy of the particles and hence the coercivity. The effects of Ti additions on the magnetic properties of various thermomagnetically treated alnico single crystals have been investigated by Takeuchi and Iwama (1976). They measured the anisotropy coefficient Ku, the volume fraction of the F e - C o rich particles, p, the particle diameter d, the elongation l/d and the intrinsic coercivity iHc. Their results are summarized in tables 7 and 8. The latter includes results obtained by Sergeyev and Bulygina (1970) and Granovsky et al. (1967) for comparison. These results show that the anisotropy Ku (and K ' , the anisotropy per unit volume of the F e - C o rich particles), the particle elongation l/d and the coercivity increase as the Ti content increases. The increase in coercivity is also accompanied by a decrease in the volume fraction p and the particle diameter d. If we can assume that the coercivity dependence on the packing fraction is given by, He(p) = He(0)(1 - p ) , an increase in Hc is to be expected if p decreases. The increase in the coercivity due to the titanium addition can also be partly attributed to an increase in the elastic and surface energy associated with the spinodal decomposition which increases the smoothness, perfection and regularity of the particle s p a c i n g - s e e e.g. electron micrographs of alnico 8 (fig. 22(a), (b)) obtained by De Vos (1966, 1969), and those obtained by Granovsky et al. (1967) and Takeuchi and Iwama (1976). While Ti inhibits the a ~ y transformation Vallier et al. (1967) have shown that it restricts the temperature ranges for homogenization and thermomagnetic treatment so th~it the choice of the heat treatment schedule is critical. De Vos (1966, 1969) has suggested that the necessity to give titanium containing alnicos an isothermal anneal in a magnetic field is due to the fact that the Ti 2+ ion has a large radius and a low rate of diffusion so that longer times are required for the phase separation and particle elongation to occur. Marcon et al. (1971) have shown, for alnicos containing more than 28% Co, that it is practically impossible to avoid the precipitation of the deleterious y phase during thermomagnetic treatment unless appropriate amounts of a-stabilizing elements such as silicon or titanium are added. Unfortunately titanium inhibits the formation of the columnar grain structure. However, Gould (1964), McCaig (1964) and Harrison and Wright (1967) have shown that the addition of small quantities of sulphur, selenium or tellurium facilitates the formation and growth of columnar grains. Thus the addition of titanium to the alnicos, although beneficial, means that much more careful control of the composition and heat treatment of the alloys is required. It is for this reason and the higher cobalt content that the high coercivity alnicos 8 and 9 are generally more expensive than the other alnicos. The effects of additions of Ti, S, Nb, and other elements on the magnetic and metallurgical properties of the
158
R.A. McCURRIE
alnicos have been investigated by Clegg (1966, 1970), Palmer and Shaw (1969), Higuchi (1966), Hoffmann and St/iblein (1970) and Wright (1970).
10. Dependence of the magnetic properties on the angle between the direction of measurement and the preferred or easy axis of magnetization The variation of the coercivity with angle 0 to the preferred axis in alnico 9 and ticonal 900 (single crystal) has been measured by McCurrie and Jackson (1980) who observed small maxima at 0 = 60 ° followed by a rapid decrease to zero at 90 ° (fig. 29). According to Shtrikman and Treves (1959) the reduced coercivity hc as a function of the angle of m e a s u r e m e n t 0 and the reduced radius for infinitely long cyclindrical rods with shape anisotropy only is given by Hc hc = 2XMs- $2[(1 _
1.08(1- 1.08S 2) ( 1 - 2.16S -2) sin 2 0] 1/2'
1.08S_2)2
where S = R/Ro (Ro = (4"n't.zoA/JZs)1/2) and 0 is the angle between the easy axis of magnetization (i.e., the axis of the cylinder) and the direction of m e a s u r e m e n t of He. Comparison of the results shown in fig. 29 with the theoretical curves obtained from the above relation shown in fig. 30 suggests that the observed angular variation of Hc in these alloys is due to magnetization reversal by the curling mechanism. The coercivities of alnico 9 and ticona1900 are - 0 . 2 5 H A (HA is the anisotropy field) which are in good agreement with the values to be expected if the magnetization reverses by curling (Shtrikman and Treves 1959). The angular variation of the r e m a n e n c e coercivity Hr (Hr is the reverse field required to reduce the r e m a n e n c e to zero) showed even m o r e pronounced maxima at 0 ~ 80 ° followed by a rapid decrease to zero at 0 ~ 90 °. Unfortunately no detailed theory of the variation of Hr with 0 is available for comparison, though Kneller (1966, 1969) has suggested that Hr(O)/Hc(O) varies between the limits:
1 (0 = 0 °) <~H,-(O)/Hc(O) ~< o~ (0 = 90°). Paine and Luborsky (1960) have measured the angular variation of the intrinsic coercivity of alnico 5DG, columnar alnico, which was found to be almost independent of the angle up to about 40 ° after which Hc decreased and at 0 = 90 ° it was about half the value at 0 = 0 °. For a specimen of alnico 9 the coercivity decreased with the angle 0 and at 0 = 90 °, it was about a quarter of the value at 0 = 0 °. Bate (1961) found that for partially aligned y-Fe203 particles Hr(O)/Hc(O) increased from 1.25 at 0 = 0 ° to 2.3 at 0 = 90 °. The dependence of the magnetic properties on the crystal orientations (i.e., crystallographic texture) in columnar alnico 5-7 has been investigated in considerable detail by McCaig and Wright (1960), Makino and Kimura (1965) and
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS AHrT tXHrA • HcT
3,0
10 I 0-9
i 2.5 E
0"8 ~ S < 1 O'7 ~
,~,
3
2.0 0.6
"r" e-
159
j¢
1"5
..r" ~, 1.0
S=1"47
o,+
0"3
>
o= 0.5 0~ O
o.1 0
+ I I I I 15 30 45 60 75 90 Angle 0 ° from easy axis in degrees
Fig. 29. Dependence of the coercivity Hc and remanence coercivity Hr on the angle 0 between the preferred axis and the direction of measurement for columnar alnico 9 (A) and single crystal alnico 9 (T) (McCurrie and Jackson 1980).
S--6,0
0
0
_
.
~
I
I
1
I
[
I
I
I
\ ~1
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
0o Fig. 30. Reduced coercivity hc for an aligned array of infinitely long single domain cylindrical particles with shape anisotropy only as a function of the angle 0 between the easy axis (i.e. the cylindrical axis) and the direction of measurement. S is the reduced particle radius. (S ~ R/Ro where R0 = (4~A)l/2//z~/2Ms and A is the exchange constant.) The curve for S < 1 is identical to that for the Stoner-Wohlfarth coherent rotation theory (after Shtrikman and Treves 1959).
M o o n (1974), M c C a i g a n d W r i g h t (1960) h a v e m a d e m e a s u r e m e n t s of t h e m a g netic p r o p e r t i e s at v a r i o u s angles to the p r e f e r r e d d i r e c t i o n in t h r e e c o l u m n a r alnico m a g n e t s (49.7 wt % F e - 25% C o - 13.5% N i - 8% A 1 - 3% C u - 0.8% N b ) a n d h a v e s h o w n t h a t t h e d e c r e a s e in r e m a n e n c e with angle is in g o o d q u a l i t a t i v e a g r e e m e n t with results p r e d i c t e d f r o m t h e S t o n e r - W o h l f a r t h (1948) t h e o r y . F o r an a l i g n e d a s s e m b l y of e l o n g a t e d p a r t i c l e s t h e r e m a n e n c e at an angle 0 to t h e p r e f e r r e d d i r e c t i o n of m a g n e t i z a t i o n , i.e., t h e c o l u m n a r a x i s - n o m i n a l l y p a r a l l e l to the [100] d i r e c t i o n , is given by B~ : L = J+ cos O.
F o r angles > 7 5 ° t h e m e a s u r e d v a l u e s of Jr ( M c C a i g a n d W r i g h t 1960) are l a r g e r t h a n t h o s e p r e d i c t e d by t h e a b o v e e x p r e s s i o n (fig. 31). T h e v a r i a t i o n of t h e c o e r c i v i t y with t h e a n g l e b e t w e e n t h e p r e f e r r e d d i r e c t i o n a n d t h e d i r e c t i o n of m e a s u r e m e n t is shown in fig. 32 f r o m which it can b e seen that the coercivities are a l m o s t c o n s t a n t up to an angle of 20 ° . T h e l a t t e r lack of a g r e e m e n t with t h e
160
R.A. McCURRIE
1 0 0 ~ l ~ ~ o C o l u m n a r alnico5 r,
.\ '
60
°~ =
E 20 0
.~
- ~-~sw
~
Theory
'~ r
SW Theory ~ , ,
0
I
I
~
I
30
, ~
6O
~ ~
v ~--'~R41
90
Angle e °
Fig. 31. Variation of remanence Br and maximum energy product (BH)max with angle 0 to the preferred axis in columnar alnico, 5DG (alnico 5-7) and comparison with Stoner-Wohlfarth (1948) theory (after McCaig and Wright 1960).
100 8O 60 m
•~- 4O ._> @ O
(3 20
0
0
30
60
90
Angle e °
Fig. 32. Variation of coercivity ~ with angle 0 to the preferred axis in columnar alnico 5DG (alnico 5-7) and comparison with Stoner-Wohlfarth (1948) theory (after McCaig and Wright 1960).
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS 161 Stoner-Wohlfarth (1948) theory is due to incomplete alignment of the particles, magnetostatic interaction between the particles and to incoherent magnetization reversal by curling (see Zijlstra, chapter 2 of this handbook). The variation of the (BH)ma~ product with angle to the preferred direction is shown in fig. 31 from which it can be seen that the decrease in (BH)r~ax with increasing angle is much less rapid than that predicted from the Stoner±Wohlfarth (1948) theory.
11. Relationship between magnetic properties and crystallographic texture The relationship between the crystal texture and the magnetic properties of alnico 8 (33 wt % F e - 36% C o - 1 5 % N i - 7% A 1 - 5 % T i - 4% C u ) h a s been studied by Higuchi and Miyamoto (1970). The magnets were solution heat treated for 30 min at 1250°C and then annealed in a magnetic field of 240 kAm -1 for 8 min at 810°C, after which they were given a two-step anneal at about 600°C. Unlike the previous studies discussed above the crystal textures of the specimens were determined from their magnetization curves assuming that changes in the magnetization occurred by coherent rotation of the magnetization vector. Higuchi and Miyamoto (1970) showed that there was very good agreement between the measured values of Br, Hc and (BH)m~x and the values calculated from their model. The highest observed energy product was 89 kJm -3. The relationship between magnetic properties and crystallographic texture of alnico 5 has also been investigated by Moon (1974). In this work measurements of the orientation (by an X-ray diffractometer) and magnetic properties were made on several specimens from a series of columnar magnets with a nominal composition 50.4wt % F e - 2 4 . 5 % C o - 1 3 . 5 % N i - 8 % A 1 - 3 % C u - 0 . 6 % Nb. The magnets were cooled from 1250°C at 1.2°Cs -1 in a magnetic field - 2 2 0 kAm -~ parallel to the direction of solidification, annealed at 590°C for 48 h and then annealed for a further 48 h at 560°C. Moon showed that the energy product (BH)max decreased rapidly with increase in the standard deviation of the angle 0 between the [100] direction and the axis of the magnet and suggested that small improvements in the casting techniques and hence the crystallographic texture might lead to a significant improvement in the (BH)ma× product.
12. Effects of particle misalignment on the remanence and coercivity of the anisotropic field-treated alnicos 12.1. R e m a n e n c e
Although the magnetic properties of the alnicos depend on the degree of particle alignment, a considerable deviation from complete alignment can be tolerated without a very significant deterioration in the magnetic properties. Suppose that the axes of elongation of the particles in a given specimen all lie within a cone of
162
R.A. M c C U R R I E Z
0
~X
Fig. 33. Definition of solid angle dO for determination of r e m a n e n c e of an array of uniaxial single domain particles whose preferred axes of magnetization lie within the cone with semi-vertical angle 0.
semi-solid angle 0 m a s shown in fig. 33 where 0 m is the maximum deviation from the preferred axis. The number of particles with their axes at an angle 0 is proportional to the solid angle contained within the interval 0 and 0 + dO viz. 27r sin 0 dO. So that the remanence is given by IOOm27r sin 0 cos 0 dO Jr=L"
_ Js(1 + cos 0m)
or.
(1)
fo 2~- sin 0 dO so that even when 0m = 30 °, Jr/Js = 0.933. Unfortunately it is difficult to compare this simple theory with experimental measurements because of the difficulty in obtaining samples which have their particle axes included in a suitable range of measurable 0m angles. Furthermore the cosine function is relatively insensitive to changes in 0m (fig. 34). McCurrie (1981) has suggested that a more accurate
Jr
1.0
Js 0.8 0.6
0-4
0.2
0
I
0
I
I
I
I
30
I
60
I
I
I
90
Angle e m Fig. 34. D e p e n d e n c e of r e m a n e n c e on m a x i m u m angle of'deviation 0m of the particle axes from preferred axis of magnetization (McCurrie 1981).
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS
163
estimate of the degree of alignment can be o b t a i n e d by measuring the saturation r e m a n e n c e at 90 ° to the preferred or easy axis. In this case,
Jr _ (Om -- 1 sin 2Ore) J~ vr(1 -- COS Om) ' or
J~/Js ~ ~ sin Ore. These functions, which are shown in fig. 35, are m u c h m o r e sensitive to changes in 0m than the function given in eq. (1). 0.5
_~sinem,,,~,/
Js
,,;,/
0'3
/ g ~
/,,/\ (.em~ _ ~ ' .~Sin2ern) _ 2
,~'
0-1 0
0
' i
~1 2c-'~SOm) !
!
30
i
I
l
60
|
!
i
90
Angle 0 m Fig. 35. D e p e n d e n c e of r e m a n e n c e m e a s u r e d perpendicular to preferred axis and the m a x i m u m angle of deviation 0m of the particle axes from the preferred axis of the magnet (McCurrie 198l).
12.2. Coercivity
T h e coercivity is also decreased when the axes of elongation of the particles are at angles in the range 0 to 0m to the preferred axis. F r o m the S t o n e r - W o h l f a r t h (1948) theory of hysteresis in single domain particles it can be shown that for a single particle whose axis of elongation is at an angle 180-0 to the applied field (i.e. a demagnetizing field) the coercivity is given by: Hc = (Dz - Dx)Ms (1 - tan 2/3 0 + tan 4/3 0) 1/2 ( 1 + t a n 2/30) ,
for0<0~<45 ° ,
and He = }(Dz - Dx)Ms sin 20,
for 45 ° ~ 0 ~< 90 ° .
164
R.A. McCURRIE
The variation of the coercivity with angle 0 is shown in fig. 32, where the ordinate has been plotted in reduced units (% of He at 0 = 0°). From fig. 32 it can be seen that the coercivity decreases rapidly for 0 up to about 15° after which the decrease with increasing 0 is m u c h less rapid. For a reasonably well aligned array of particles in an alnico alloy 0 is unlikely to be greater than about 30 ° at the maximum.
13. Determination of the optimum volume fraction of the F e - C o rich particles
Since the F e - C o rich particles are required to be elongated single domains they must not be precipitated in a quantity sufficient to cause coalescence. This means that the composition of the alloys must be chosen so that the volume fraction of the F e - C o rich cq phase is surrounded by the non-ferromagnetic or weakly ferromagnetic Ni-A1 rich ~2 phase. A further restriction is placed on the volume fraction, p, of the F e - C o rich al phase because the coercivities of the alloys are reduced by particle interaction effects which are usually assumed to be proportional to ( 1 - p). If we assume that for a packing fraction p and coherent magnetization reversal, the coercivity is given by (see for example, Ndel 1947a, Kittel 1949, Kittel and Galt 1956, Brown 1962, Compaan and Zijlstra 1962): H e ( p ) = H~(O)(1 - p ) ,
where He(0) is the extrapolated coercivity when p = 0, then the value of p for which the energy product is a maximum can be determined as follows. Since the maximum possible coercivity Hc(0) is given by He(p) = [(Dz - Dx)(1 - p ) M ~ ] / p , and taking (Dz - Dx) ~ ½, 1
1
He(p) - 5(1 - p ) M ~ _ (1 - p) Js, p 2p, o where Ms~ is the average or overall saturation magnetization of the alloy and Js is the saturation magnetic polarization of the particles. (Note that if the magnetization reversal occurs entirely by curling then Hc is independent of p because curling produces no interaction fields (Kneller 1969)i) However, since magnetostatic interaction domains (section 16) are observed during the demagnetization of the alnicos it appears that the particles do produce interaction fields so that some coherent magnetization reversal must also occur. Thus for the present approximate calculation it seems that the use of the above relation for He(p) is justified. Consider an alnico alloy with a rectangular M - H hysteresis loop with an
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS
165
intrinsic coercivity H¢(p) as shown in fig. 36(a). The corresponding B - H demagnetization curve is shown in fig. 36(b). The flux coercivity ,Hc = He(p) because the M - H loop is rectangular so that the discontinuous magnetization and flux reversals take place in the same reverse field. The maximum energy product for this B - H demagnetization curve is given by the area OPQR, i.e., (BH)max = (PJs - ½(1 - p)Js)(1 - p)Js/ZI-Lo. Note that the saturation magnetic polarization of the alloy as a whole is Jm = PJs. From the above expression we find that (BH)m,x = (J~/4tzo)(-3p 2 + 4p - 1), which has a maximum value when
d(BH)max/dp = 0
and
d2(BH)m,x/dp 2< O,
i.e., when 6p=4,
or
p=2.
Thus (BH)max is equal to J~/12/x0. This value of (BH)max is obtainable only when the intrinsic coercivity, He, satisfies the condition H~ = (1 - p)JJ2/x0. For the magnetically annealed alnicos the absolute maximum in the (BH)max product is obtained when p = 0.6-0.7 which is in good agreement with both the
i
~
Mr=Ms
B Br=Jm=PJs
-H
Hc
?,
H / / / /
/
/ Z
'H
(a)
/ He
R BHc
O
(b)
Fig. 36. (a) Ideal rectangular M - H hysteresis loop with intrinsic coercivity iH¢. (b) Corresponding B - H demagnetization curve for M - H loop in (a). (NB: The flux coercivity BHc=iH¢, the intrinsic coercivity because the M - H loop is rectangular.)
166
R.A. McCURRIE
above theories. The packing fraction p can be determined by quantitative metallography (see for example, Hilliard 1962, 1967, 1968, Hilliard and Cahn 1961, Underwood 1970, 1973, Saltykov 1970) of the two phases which are clearly visible on the replication electron micrographs such as those shown in figs. 22(a) and (b). Another estimate of p can be obtained from the measured value of the saturation magnetic polarization, Jm, of the magnet alloy as a whole if it is assumed that the individual particles have a saturation magnetic polarization Js, equal to that of FeCo and by using the relationship Jm = PJ~.
For field heat treated grain oriented alnico 5-7 the saturation magnetic polarization is approximately 1.4 T. Since Js = 2.4 T for FeCo we find that p = 0.6 which is very close to the values determined by quantitative metallography (De Vos 1966, 1969, Granovsky et al. 1967, Takeuchi and Iwama 1976) and from magnetic measurements (Bulygina and Sergeyev 1969, Sergeyev and Bulygina 1970). Apart from the reduction in the coercivity due to the packing fraction p of the particles (H~(p)= H~(0)(I-p)), Kondorsky (1952a, b) and Aharoni (1959) have shown that the critical diameter for infinitely long single domain particles is given by:
Re(p) = Re(0) (1 - p)-l/e, so that R~(p) increases with the packing fraction. For materials such as the alnicos in which the coercivity is due almost entirely to the shape anisotropy of elongated single domain particles of Fe-Co the critical radius Re(0) (for an infinitely long cylinder) is given by Rc(0) = (1.08/2Dz )1/2(47"rtzoA/J2s)1,2 , i.e., Rc(0) = 1.04(4 7"rtzoA/J~) ~/2 , since the demagnetization factor Dz for an infinitely long cylinder is 0.5. In the above relation A is the exchange energy coefficient, Js the saturation magnetic polarization and/z0 = 47r x 10 -7 Hm -1 is the magnetic constant. A more detailed discussion of the critical sizes for single domain particles is given by Zijlstra in chapter 2 of this handbook.
14. Interpretation of the magnetic properties in terms of the Stoner-Wohifarth theory of hysteresis in single domain particles The magnetic hysteresis of non-interacting single domain particles with uniaxial shape anisotropy has been investigated theoretically by Stoner and Wohlfarth (1948). They investigated the behaviour of a single domain ellipsoid of revolution when subjected to increasing magnetic fields at various angles to the easy axis of
S T R U C T U R E A N D P R O P E R T I E S O F A L N I C O P E R M A N E N T M A G N E T ALLOYS
167
magnetization of the ellipsoid assuming that changes in magnetization occurred by coherent rotation of the magnetization vector. The relationship between the applied field, the easy axis and the magnetization is shown in fig. 37. For a particle with a saturation magnetization of Ms the total magnetic free energy is 1 2 E = ½1xo(Dz - D x ) M 2 sin 2 ~ + gl.xoDxMs + IxoHMs cos qS.
(2)
where Dx and Dz are the demagnetization factors parallel and perpendicular to the axis of elongation of the particle. The particle is assumed to be a prolate ellipsoid of revolution so that Dy = D~ and Dy > Dx. Thus in a given field H the stable positions of the magnetization vector are those which correspond to the minima of eq. (2). The solutions, for various values of the field and the angle 0, have been tabulated by Stoner and Wohlfarth (1948) who have also plotted several representative hysteresis loops notably those for 0 = 0, 45 ° and 90 °. For a survey of the results the reader is referred to Zijlstra, (chapter 2 in this handbook). One of the most important conclusions from the Stoner-Wohlfarth theory is that the coercivity of an aligned assembly of identical non-interacting (i.e., infinitely dilute) single domain particles with uniaxial shape anisotropy is Hc = (D: - D x ) M s ,
i.e., the coercivity is directly proportional to the saturation magnetization and to the difference in the demagnetization factors perpendicular and parallel to the easy axis. For a randomly orientated array of such particles the coercivity is reduced to Hc = 0.479(Dz - D x ) M s . The dependence of ( D z - Dx) on the degree of elongation, i.e., the ratio of the lengths of the x- and z-axes of the particle, is shown in fig. 38. It has already been mentioned in section 1.2 that in view of the complex microstructures and particle shapes in the isotropic alnicos 1-4 it is not possible to give a quantitative comparison or interpretation of their magnetic properties in terms of the StonerWohlfarth (1948) theory though their magnetic properties can be understood Ms
H
Fig. 37. Relationship between the applied field, easy axis and magnetization vector in a prolate ellipsoidal single domain particle with uniaxial shape anisotropy.
168
R.A. M c C U R R I E
0.5 0"4
Dz
~0-3 I
N
0'2
Dx
0"1 0
1
I
I
2
3
I
I
4 5 Dimensional
I
I
6 7 8 ratio m = a / b
I
I
9
10
Fig. 38. Difference (Dz- Dx) between demagnetization factors perpendicular and parallel to the preferred axis of magnetization as a function of the particle elongation or dimensional ratio m = a/b, where a is the semi-major and b the semi-minor axis of the prolate ellipsoid of revolution.
qualitatively. In any case in the alnicos 1-4 both the al and a2 phases are ferromagnetic so that magnetization changes by domain wall movement may also occur.
From the electron micrographs of alnico 5 and alnico 5-7, the precipitated F e - C o rich particles are rod-like (i.e., they approximate to prolate ellipsoids of revolution) and have dimensions ~150 nm long and ~40 nm in diameter. From fig. 38 the corresponding value of Dz - Dx is ~0.5 and hence if we take the saturation magnetization of the particles Ms = 1.7x 106Am -1 which is considerably larger than the observed value of 60 kAm -1. Although the particles are not fully aligned this is insufficient to account for the difference in the two values. Since the coercivity depends on the presence of demagnetizing fields it is clear that particle interactions cannot be neglected. Many authors (see e.g., N6el 1947a, Compaan and Zijlstra 1962) suggest that the effects of particle interactions on the coercivity are best described by the relation
He(p)= H o ( O ) ( 1 - p ) , where He(p) is the coercivity for a particle packing fraction p and He(0) is the coercivity for a packing fraction of zero. Thus if the effects of particle interactions are included the coercivity of a fully aligned array of single domain particles with uniaxial shape anisotropy is Ho= (1-p)(Dz -Dx)Ms,
(3)
or
Hc = (1 - p ) ( D z - Dx)M's/p, where M'~ is the average saturation magnetization of the alloy. The packing factor
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS 169 p is usually in the range 0.6-0.7 and (Dz-D~) approaches 0.5 so that the theoretical value of Hc ~ 300 kAm -~. Thus even if particle interaction effects are included there is still a very significant difference between the theoretical and observed coercivities (-~60 kAm-1). Baran (1959) has derived a more general expression for the coercivity of a fully aligned array of particles which takes account of the reduction in coercivity due to particle interactions and the possibility that the matrix is also ferromagnetic, viz. Hc = p(1
-
p)(Dz
-
Dx)(MI
-
M2)2/M's,
(4)
where p is the volume fraction of the most strongly ferromagnetic phase, M1 and M2 the saturation magnetizations of this phase and the matrix phase respectively, M's the overall saturation magnetization of the alloy and Dz and Dx are the demagnetization factors Of the particles perpendicular and parallel to the axis of elongation respectively. For the maximum coercivity it is clear from eq. (4) that the difference M 1 - M 2 should be as" large as possible. If it is assumed that the alloy is fully heat treated, i.e., sufficient time has been allowed for all the Fe and Co atoms to diffuse to the precipitated particles, then the matrix saturation magnetization M2 ~ 0 and the saturation magnetization of the Fe--Co rich particles M1 = Ms = M's/p, so that eq. (4) reduces to eq. (3). From the electron micrographs of alnico 8 shown in figs. 22(a) and (b) (De Vos 1966, 1969) the F e - C o rich particles are very long rods and approximate to prolate ellipsoids of revolution with length to diameter ratios l/d ~-16 corresponding to D z - D~--~ 0.5. Quantitative metallography shows that the volume fraction of the F e - C o rich particles p ~ 0.65. Since there is a very high degree of particle alignment we may calculate the coercivity from eq. (1). If Ms is taken to be at least equal to the value for pure iron viz. 1.7 MAre -1 (the saturation magnetization for Fe-30% Co is about 10% higher than that of pure iron) the theoretical coercivity as derived from eq. (3) is ~300 kAm -1 which compares very favourably with the highest experimental value of 180 kAm -~ for alnico 8. The discrepancy between the observed value of the coercivity and that calculated according to the Stoner-Wohlfarth (1948) theory suggest that the assumption that changes in the magnetization occur by coherent rotation is invalid (see Zijlstra, chapter 2 in this handbook).
15. Interpretation of the magnetic properties in terms of magnetization reversal by the curling mechanism According to calculations by Kondorsky (1952a), Brown (1957, 1963, 1969), Frei et al. (1957) and Aharoni and Shtrikman (1958) magnetization reversal by coherent rotation in infinitely long cylinders with shape anisotropy only, should occur only when the cylinder radius R is less than a critical radius R0 = (4zrA)llZ/Izaol2Ms where A is the exchange constant,/z0 is the magnetic constant 4~- × 10 -7 H m -1 and Ms the saturation magnetization. Above this radius magnetization reversal occurs by the curling mechanism (apart from a very small range of radii for which magnetization
170
R.A. McCURRIE
reversal occurs by a process known as buckling). According to Aharoni and Shtrikman (1958) the dependence of the coercivity on the cylinder radius R is given by Hc = 1.08(Ro/R )ZMs/2 ,
(5)
where it is of course assumed that D z - Dx has its maximum value of 0.5 for an infinitely long cylinder. The curling mechanism is discussed in chapter 2 of this handbook by Zijlstra who has also included a diagram showing the configuration of the magnetic Spins during the reversal process. From measurements on the electron micrographs of alnico 8 obtained by De Vos (1966, 1969) (see figs. 22(a) and (b)) the particles have radii ~15 nm. Although the particles are obviously not infinitely long cylinders their length to diameter ratio l/d ~ 16 so that assuming magnetization reversals occur by curling we may estimate the coercivity from eq. (5) from which we find that Hc ~ 2.4 × 105 A m -1 (McCurrie and Jackson 1980). The highest observed flux coercivity for alnico 8 BHo ~ 1.8 × 105 A m -1 (this is slightly less than the intrinsic coercivity He) so that the theoretical and observed coercivities are in reasonable agreement. When the magnetization reversal occurs entirely by curling there are no particle interaction effects so that the coercivity is independent of the packing fraction p. However, the appearance of magnetostatic interaction domains (discussed below) during demagnetization suggests that some interparticle interaction does occur. From measurements of the angular variation of the coercivity and rotational hysteresis in columnar and single crystal alnico 9 (see sections 10 and 18) McCurrie and Jackson (1980) have concluded that magnetization reversal does occur by the curling mechanism and that the quantitative results are in reasonable agreement with those predicted on the basis of the theory proposed by Shtrikman and Treves (1959).
16. Magnetostatic interaction domains in alnicos Magnetization reversal in the alnicos is further complicated by the formation of magnetostatic interaction domains which are due to interparticle interactions. Although it is well established that the alnicos contain single domain particles, macroscopic surface domain structures known as magnetostatic interaction domains, can sometimes be observed by the Bitter colloid technique, as shown by Nesbitt and Williams (1950), Bates (1955), Bates and Martin (1955), Kussmann and Wollenberger (1956), Schulze (1956), Andr/i (1956), Kronenberg and Tenzer (1958), Bates et al. (1962) and Iwama (1968). This apparently contradictory observation can be explained as follows. Consider the demagnetization process of an alnico magnet. As the magnetization of the particles is gradually reversed we should expect that as a result of the long-range interaction fields, particles in a particular region which have already reversed their magnetization will tend to assist the reversal of those in adjacent regions. Thus in the demagnetized state, when just half the total magnetization has been reversed, the magnet is effectively
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS 171
Fig. 39. Magnetostatic interaction domains in alnico 5 (Bates et al. 1962). divided up into a domain structure as shown in fig. 39. At the boundaries between the various regions or interaction domains there are stray magnetic fields and gradients which attract the colloidal particles and so delineate the domain structure. These boundaries are of course quite different from the conventional Bloch-Lifshitz walls (Kittel 1949, Kittel and Galt 1956). Similar magnetostatic interaction domains have also been observed on elongated single domain magnets by Craik and Isaac (1960). For detailed discussions of magnetostatic interaction domains and the mechanism of their formation the reader is referred to the papers by Craik and Lane (1967, 1969). The effects of particle interactions have also been discussed by Wohlfarth (1955).
17. Comparison of the N6ei-Zijlstra and Cahn theories of magnetic annealing in alnico alloys The improvements in the magnetic properties of alnico alloys by heat treatment in a magnetic field were first observed in alnico 5 (see section 2) but the following discussion also includes the effects which are observed when alnicos 6, 8 and 9 are given an isothermal heat treatment in a magnetic field.
172
R.A. McCURRIE
17.1. Ndel-Zijlstra theory In the theory of magnetic annealing proposed by N6el (1947b) and later developed by Zijlstra (1960-1962) the spinodal decomposition at high temperatures results in the formation of very small spherical particles and is considered to be complete before the elongation of the particles begins. If the decomposition takes place in a magnetic field the spherical particles develop into ellipsoids with their axes of elongation parallel to the applied field thereby reducing their total magnetic free energy. During the thermomagnetic treatment the particles increase their size and elongation very rapidly because at high temperatures the rate of atomic diffusion is high. The applied field should of course be sufficient to saturate the Fe-Co rich particles in order to achieve the maximum possible alignment during the relatively short thermomagnetic heat treatment. The relevant counteracting energies are the interfacial energy F~ between the a~ and a2 phases and the difference in the magnetostatic energy Fm between the decomposition waves parallel and perpendicular to the applied field. During the elongation of the particles there is arl increase in the interfacial energy but this is accompanied by a larger reduction in the magnetic energy of the particles in the applied field. Thus the elongation is energetically favourable when the ratio Fm/Fs is large. In the N6el-Zijlstra theory F~ is defined as the product of the interface tension and the amount of interface per unit volume. Thus the ratio Fm/Fs will increase in a coarsening structure so that the interfacial free energy is of great importance in determining the efficacy of magnetic annealing. According to Zijlstra (1960-1962) the rates of elongation and coarsening of the particles are proportional to the square of the difference in the saturation magnetic polarizations of the OgI and a2 phases (AJs)2 and inversely proportional to the interfacial energy Y, i.e., the efficacy of the thermomagnetic treatment is proportional to (AJs)2/T. This theory explains why thermomagnetic treatment is most effective in alnico alloys with a high cobalt content (i.e. alnicos 5-9) which raises the Curie temperature and AJs and lowers the interfacial energy Y. From measurements on alnico 5 Zijlstra (1960) concluded that 3' ~0.1 Jm -2, a result which confirms an earlier suggestion by Kittel et al. (1950) who also suggested that since the interfacial energy is small the particles should develop a shape anisotropy in order to minimize their magnetic energy in the applied field. Thus according to the N6el-Zijlstra theory the axes of elongation of the particles should be parallel to the applied field irrespective of its orientation relative to particular crystallographic directions in the alloy. This conclusion suggests that the shape anisotropy for finite annealing time at a given temperature should give the same result for both polycrystalline and single crystal specimens. However, Zijlstra's (1960) experiments show that the anisotropy of the single crystal specimens is considerably larger than that for the polycrystalline specimens. Zijlstra (1960) suggested that this difference could be due to a contribution from magnetocrystalline anisotropy, but the magnitude of the difference makes this unlikely.
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS 173 17.2. C a h n ' s theory
The spinodal decomposition of the alnico alloys into two phases al and Ol2 occurs because it is accompanied by a reduction in the total free energy FT of the alloy. The effect of the magnetic field in producing elongated particles with their axes of elongation parallel to the field direction has been investigated theoretically by Cahn (1963). He suggested that the effect of the magnetic field is to suppress the spinodal decomposition waves along the magnetic field direction and that this is due to the difference in the magnetic energy Fm of the spinodal waves parallel and perpendicular to the field direction which favours the formation of long rods parallel to the field direction. In the absence of the magnetic field the spinodally decomposed system consists of three mutually perpendicular spinodal decomposition waves, i.e., a cubic array of isotropic particles. Cahn (1963) stated that the two main sources of anisotropy are the magnetic and elastic energies. The former favours compositional waves parallel to the internal field direction while the latter favours compositional waves parallel to particular crystallographic directions. Waves parallel to the (100) directions in the {100} planes in cubic crystals are favoured when 2C44- Cl1+
C12>0
,
where the Cii coefficients are elastic energy constants from the stress tensor. If the anisotropy in the magnetic energy is much larger than the anisotropy in the elastic energy then the geometry of the decomposition will be independent of the crystallographic orientation so that the axes of elongation of the particles will be parallel to the applied field direction. However, if the anisotropy in the elastic energy predominates then the axes of elongation of the particles will be parallel to the crystallographic direction which minimizes the elastic energy. When the elastic and magnetic anisotropy energies are of comparable magnitude the axes of elongation of the particles lie between the field direction and the nearest (100) direction. In particular if the applied field is parallel to a (100) direction then the axes of elongation of the particles are parallel to the chosen (100) direction. Cahn (1963) also suggested that for a solid solution with a composition fluctuation ( x - x 0 ) where x0 is the average composition, the anisotropy in the magnetic energy is proportional to (OJs/Ox) 2 where Js is the saturation magnetic polarization of the precipitated particles. The quantity (OJs/Ox) 2 is expected to vary rapidly with temperature and to be very large near the Curie temperature, To, so that thermomagnetic treatment will be most effective when the spinodal decomposition temperature T is at, or just below, the Curie temperature. If the alloy is cooled to lower temperatures the effectiveness of the field diminishes rapidly. The anisotropy in the elastic energy depends on two factors: (1) it is proportional to (d In a / d x ) 2 where 'a' is the stress-free lattice parameter, and (2) it is proportional to the variation in the elastic energy coefficient with crystallographic direction; the latter can be approximated by Ay = ]71100]- 71111][. Cahn
174
R.A. McCURRIE
(1963) estimated that the elastic energy is much greater than the magnetic energy except near the Curie temperature. Thus according to Cahn's (1963) theory a large ratio of Fm/F-r favours the elongation of the particles when they are heat treated in a magnetic field. The shape of the particles is established during the first stages of the decomposition and the magnetic shape anisotropy can be further increased only by a subsequent increase in their saturation magnetic polarization by diffusion of atoms between the two phases al and a2 without thereby changing their shape, though their wavelength is increased by this process.
17.3. Discussion of the Ndel-Zijlstra and Cahn theories Electron micrographs of alnico 8 (De Vos 1966, 1969) which had been given an isothermal heat treatment in a magnetic field show that even in the initial stages of the spinodal decomposition the three (100) decomposition waves are developed which have practically the same wavelength, a result which disagrees with Cahn (1963) who suggested that the (100) decomposition waves perpendicular to the magnetic field direction are suppressed from the beginning of the spinodal decomposition. De Vos's (1966, 1969) electron micrographs of alnico 8 also show that elongated Fe-Co rich particles with their axes of elongation parallel to the (100} directions develop even in the absence of an applied field; this result is also in disagreement with Cahn's (1963) theoretical predictions. According to the discussion in section 7.2 of the relationship between the field direction and the preferred direction of magnetization Heidenreich and Nesbitt (1952) and Nesbitt and Heidenreich (1952a, b) found that when the field direction was parallel to a principal crystallographic direction, i.e., [100], [110] or [111], the easy or preferred direction of magnetization is parallel to the field direction. However, Heidenreich and Nesbitt (1952), Nesbitt and Heidenreich (1952a, b), Hoselitz and McCaig (1951), McCaig (1953) and Yermolenko et al. (1964) showed that when the thermomagnetic field is applied at an angle to a (100) direction, the direction of easy magnetization lies between the field direction and the chosen (100) direction. The above authors also found that the magnetic anisotropy (at room temperature) has a maximum value when the field is parallel to a (100) direction. Thus from the results presented in section 7.2 and the short summary of these given above there is strong evidence that in addition to the magnetic and interracial energies the anisotropy of elastic energy has some effect in determining the orientation of the elongated Fe-Co rich particles during thermomagnetic treatment. This conclusion is also supported by the microstructural observations made by De Vos (1966, 1969). Although Cahn's (1963) suggestion that the anisotropy of the elastic energy is important in determining the nature of the spinodal decomposition waves does not agree with the electron microscopic observations of De Vos (1966, 1969) it is clear that the orientation of the particles is affected by the anisotropy of the elastic energy. The experiments performed by Zijlstra (1960-1962) and De Vos (1966, 1969) show that the Ndel-Zijlstra theory of thermomagnetic treatment or magnetic annealing is in better agreement with the experimental results than that
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS
175
proposed by Cahn (1963). Strong support for this conclusion is provided by the following three experiments carried out by Zijlstra (1960-1962): (1) A specimen of alnico 5 (51% Fe, 24% Co, 14% Ni, 8% A1 and 3% Cu by weight) was heat treated in a magnetic field of 128 kAm -1 parallel to the [100] direction for 7 h at 748°C and subsequently a part of the same specimen was annealed for 24h at the same temperature with the field parallel to the [010] direction. A part of this specimen was then annealed for a further 24 h at 748°C. Electron micrographs of each of the three thermomagnetic treatments (actually thermal magnetic anneals) are shown in figs. 40(a), (b) and (c) from which it can be seen that when the alloy is annealed in a field perpendicular to the initial field direction, the particles become elongated in the new field direction thus reducing their magnetic free energy, in agreement with the N6el-Zijlstra theory. The electron micrographs shown in figs. 41(a) and (b) also confirm that in the initial stages of the phase separation the Fe-Co rich particles are spherical (fig. 41(a)) and that they are elongated by heat treatment in the magnetic field-the direction of elongation being parallel to the field direction as shown in fig. 41(b). (2) A polycrystalline specimen (disk) of alnico 5 with the same composition as that given above was heat treated in a non-inductively wound furnace for 7 h at
i~
a
b t
i~ i~
C ....!
Fig. 40. Microscopical demonstration of crossed-field annealing of a single crystal: (a) after heat treatment for 7 hours at 748°C with field along the [100] direction; (b) after subsequent heat treatment for 24 hours at 748°C with field along the [010] direction; (c) after final heat treatment for 24 hours at 748°C with field along the [010] direction. All three micrographs are made of the (001) plane (after Zijlstra 1960).
176
R.A. McCURRIE
a
I
b
2pm Fig. 41. (a) Electron micrograph of an alnico showing that in the initial stages of the phase separation the Fe-Co rich particles are spherical. (b) Electron micrograph after heat treatment in a magnetic field. The direction of elongation of the Fe-Co rich particles is parallel to the direction of the field (after Zijlstra 1962).
755°C in the absence of an applied field. After this treatment the specimen was shown to be isotropic but when it was subsequently heat treated in a magnetic field of 6 4 0 k A m -t at the same t e m p e r a t u r e it became anisotropic with an anisotropy energy approximately equal to that of a polycrystalline alnico 5 specimen which had been given a m o r e conventional thermomagnetic heat treatment, i.e., Ku ~ 8 x 104 Jm -3. (3) A specimen of polycrystalline Mishima alloy, Fe2NiA1, which is not usually considered to respond to thermomagnetic treatment was heat treated in a field of 640 k A m -1 for 2 weeks at 725°C after which it became magnetically anisotropic with an anisotropy energy K ~ 6 × 104 Jm73 which is comparable to that of alnico 5. After this treatment, however, the particles are too large to be single domains so that the coercivity is correspondingly low ~10 k A m -1 parallel to the preferred direction, i.e., the field direction. None of the above three results is to be expected according to the theory proposed by Cahn (1963). However, it should be emphasized that Zijlstra's (1960-1962) results were obtained by heat treatment times much longer than those used in commercial practice so that it seems likely for shorter thermomagnetic heat treatments (e.g. in cooling of alnico 5) that the orientation of the axes of
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS
177
elongation are partly determined by the anisotropy in the elastic energy but there now seems to be little doubt that the N6el-Zijlstra theory of the thermomagnetic treatment of the alnicos is in good general agreement with the experimental results.
18. Rotational hysteresis The rotational hysteresis energy W~(H) in a field is defined as the energy required to rotate the specimen through 360 °, i.e., Wr(H)
= f~'~ F(O) dO.
It can also be conveniently obtained by measuring the area enclosed by the 360 ° clockwise torque curve and the 360 ° anticlockwise torque curve (McCurrie and Jackson 1980); the rotational hysteresis energy W~(H) is equal to half this area, i.e.,
W~CH)= ½
Fc(O) dO +
/'Ac(O) dO , JO
where Fc(0) and FAt(0) are the torque curves in a given field for clockwise and anticlockwise rotation in the applied field. The clockwise and anticlockwise torque curves corresponding to the maximum value of Wr(H) for single crystal alnico 9 are shown in fig. 42. McCurrie and Jackson (1980) have measured the rotational hysteresis energies of alnico 9 and single crystal alnico 9 as a function of the applied field and their results are shown in fig. 43. Note the very rapid variation in W~(H) for applied fields close to the coercivity. From the value of the rotational hysteresis integrals, defined by
j~ where Wr(H) is the rotational hysteresis energy observed in a field H, R can therefore be obtained from the area under the Wr(H)/Js vs 1/H curve (Bean and Meiklejohn 1956, Jacobs and Luborsky 1957, Luborsky 1961, Luborsky and Morelock 1964). McCurrie and Jackson (1980) have concluded that magnetization reversal in alnico 9 and ticonal 900 occurs by curling. This conclusion is also supported by their measurements of the angular variation of the coercivity discussed in section 10. The rotational hysteresis energy of single crystal alnico 8 as a function of the applied field has also been measured by Livshitz et al. (1970c). They also observed a very sharp peak in the rotational hysteresis energy but in contrast to the results obtained by McCurrie and Jackson (1980) they observed a smaller peak in a higher applied f i e l d - about 2.5 times the field corresponding to the first sharp peak.
178
R.A. M c C U R R I E
1"00 I Ha= 188 kAm -1
0'751-
H c = 138 kAm -1
0"50 I
E 0.25
.-j
Acw w
0
90
270
12( Angle 0 °
0
~0.25
~0-50
Ticonal 9 0 0 (100) plane
- 0-75
-1.00 uFig. 42. Torque curves showing rotational hysteresis in a single crystal of alnico 9 (ticonal 900) in an applied field of 188 k A m -1 (McCurrie and Jackson 1980). T h e rotational hysteresis energy Wr(H)can be determined by halving the area enclosed between the two curves: C W - c l o c k w i s e rotation; A C W anticlockwise rotation.
2"0
E
1.5 • Ticonal 9 0 0
1.0
0-5
0 .P~ 0
2
I , ~--..-.-~ 4 6 8 H ~'105Am -1)
I 10
Fig. 43. Variation of rotational hysteresis energy of columnar alnico 9 and single crystal alnico 9 (ticonal 900) with applied field (McCurrie and Jackson 1980).
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS 179
19. Anhysteretic magnetization The anhysteretic magnetization of a ferromagnetic material is the magnetization which results from the application of a static field H and a superimposed alternating field Ha > H which is gradually reduced to zero while the static field H is still on. The anhysteretic magnetization c u r v e - s o m e t i m e s referred to as the ideal magnetization c u r v e - r i s e s much more steeply than the conventional curve and if the specimen has a low or zero external demagnetization factor the initial slope of the anhysteretic magnetization curve is known as the anhysteretic susceptibility Ka. A simple general theory of anhysteretic magnetization curves has been presented by Ndel (1943) and N6el et al. (1943) but for a short review the reader is referred to Kneller (1969). The reciprocal K21 is known as the internal demagnetization factor. Dussler (1927) has shown that the geometrical demagnetization factor Dg of open magnetic circuits also depends on the structural details of the material. The demagnetizing field HD for a uniformly magnetized ellipsoid is given by HD = D g M ,
but for non-uniformly magnetized particles such as occur in the alnicos it has been found by experiment that Ka 1 = D,
where
D > Og.
The difference D i = AD = D - D g has been attributed to internal interaction effects arising from the structure of the materials. Unfortunately, Di is not a constant, characteristic of the material, but also depends on Dg as one would expect since the shape and structural effects are due fundamentally to magnetostatic interactions. Bulgakov (1950) found that for alnico 5 that the values of Di parallel and perpendicular to the preferred axis of magnetization were respectively 0.02 and 0.4. Similar measurements were also made by Gould and McCaig (1954) on alnico 5 who obtained values of 0.01 and 0.5 for D~. They suggested that the precipitated particles were oriented parallel to the thermomagnetic field and separated by a non-ferromagnetic matrix, but they stressed that their measurements of D~ did not enable them to make any really firm conclusions.
20. Magnetic viscosity In all the above discussions of coercivity theory it has been assumed that after saturation of a ferromagnetic material in the forward direction the demagnetization curve represents instantaneous and stable values of B or M as a function of the reverse applied field H. However, if a steady reverse field less than the coercivity is applied after
180
R.A. M c C U R R I E
saturation, the magnetization decreases with time t after the application of the field H. This time dependent change of the magnetization in an applied field is known as magnetic viscosity. The magnetic viscosity of cast alnico 2 (54% Fe, 18% Ni, 12% Co, 10% A1, 6% Cu) as measured by Street and Woolley (1949) is shown in fig. 44. Measurements on the same alloy which had been heat treated at 1250°C for 20 minutes and then allowed to cool at about 2°C per second gave similar results to the cast alloy. According to Street and Woolley (1949) the magnetic polarization at time t is given by the empirical relation
J=C-Slnt, where C is a constant and S is a parameter which depends on the temperature T and the applied field H. Since a similar effect also occurs when the applied field is positive, the phenomenon of magnetic viscosity is a general property of all ferromagnetic materials, though its presence is not always readily observable. The above equation suggests that the magnetization reversal by the field H involves the thermally activated surmounting of energy barriers in the material. For further details on the magnetic viscosity in the alnicos the reader is referred to the papers by Bulgakov and Kondorsky (1949), Street and Woolley (1949, 1950, 1956), Street et al. (1952a, b), Phillips et al. (1954) and Barbier (1954).
0"20 _
Alnico
2
~
523°K
0-15
-ff <~ 0.10
0"0,'
--
-I
30
~
86°K
60
120
300
Time
600
1200
I
t in s e c
Fig. 44. C h a n g e in net magnetic polarization as a function of time at various temperatures for alnico 2 (after Street and Woolley 1949) 54% Fe - 18% Ni - 12% C o - 10% Al - 6% Co. Cast alloy cooled from 1250°C held at this temperature for 20 rain and then cooled at 2°Cs -1, followed by 2 h at 600°C. Not in o p t i m u m p e r m a n e n t magnet state. However, the fully heat treated alloy gave similar magnetic viscosity results.
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICOPERMANENTMAGNETALLOYS 181
21. Temperature dependence of magnetic properties The effects of temperature on the magnetic properties of the alnicos are complicated and depend on the previous heat treatment of the alloys. Clegg and McCaig (1957) investigated the temperature dependence of the saturation magnetic polarization, the coercivity BHc and the remanence of alnico 5 after various heat treatments. The temperature dependence of the coercivity for various specimens is shown in fig. 9. Curves (c) and (g) represent specimens with optimum permanent magnet properties and may therefore be regarded as typical. The temperature dependence of the magnetic properties of alnicos has also been investigated by McCaig (1968), Dietrich (1966a, b, 1967), Clegg and McCaig (1958), Roberts (1958), Clegg (1955), Pawlek and Reichel (1955), Bulgakov (1949) and Jellinghaus (1943).The effects of low temperatures on alnico 5 and alnico 5-7 alloys have been studied by Clegg (1955). In a different type of investigation Bates and Simpson (1955) measured the heat changes which occur when the alnicos are cycled through a hysteresis loop. For general discussions of the temperature dependence and stability of the magnetic properties of permanent magnets the reader is referred to Gould (1958, 1962), Parker and Studders (1962), Schiller and Brinkmann (1970), Heck (1974), Joksch (1975) and McCaig (1977), Gould and McCaig (1954).
22. Dynamic excitation (AC magnetization) Very few studies have been made on the effects of applying alternating fields to alnico magnets. The response of the magnets is complex due to the effects of magnetic viscosity and eddy currents and therefore depends on the frequency and magnitude of the applied fields. Sabir and Shepherd (1974) have studied the behaviour of alnico 5 in sinusoidal fields in the frequency range 50-350 Hz. The energy loss per unit volume was obtained by measuring the areas under the dynamic B - H loops and agreed with direct wattmeter measurements and also with theoretical calculations. Eddy current losses were found to be negligible at 50 Hz and even at 350 Hz were only about 10% of the total loss. The total loss at a fixed field was found to be almost a linear function of the frequency. The dynamic excitation of alnico 5 has also been studied by Shepherd et al. (1974).
23. Prospects for improvement in the magnetic properties Since the observed coercivities are only ~0.3HA (the anisotropy field H A = (Dz- Dx)Ms) even in the most favourable cases there is certainly some room for improvement in He. This could be achieved by reducing the particle thickness to avoid curling and to make the particles more regular in shape to prevent parasitic nucleation of magnetization reversal. However, the attainment of these objectives is likely to present considerable metallurgical difficulties.
182
R.A. McCURRIE
Since the coercivity depends on the difference in the demagnetization factors Dz and Dx it can readily be appreciated from fig. 38 that when the length to diameter ratio (m) of the particles is greater than about 10, the coercivity is about 94% of the theoretical m a x i m u m for a given Ms and p so that there is little to be gained by any further increase in rn resulting from more elaborate thermomagnetic treatment. No way has yet been found to increase Ms of the Fe-Co-rich particles significantly so it appears that there is little prospect for any further i m p r o v e m e n t in the coercivities of the best alnicos, 8 and 9. The p e r m a n e n t magnet properties of single crystal alnico 8 and 9 are of course significantly better than those of the fully columnar alnico 9 owing to the higher degree of particle alignment but any prospective i m p r o v e m e n t in their properties is similarly limited by the factors already discussed. From table 3 it can be seen that in a highly oriented columnar magnet, remanences Jr ~ 1.43 T can be achieved so that the m a x i m u m possible energy product (BH)ma× is (BH)max = B~/4tXo = J~/41Xo = 400 kJm
3,
provided of course that the intrinsic coercivity Hc satisfies the condition: Hc > Jd2/z0, i.e., Hc > 570 k A m -~ . However, in view of the requirements mentioned above there seems to be little prospect of increasing the coercivity Hc much beyond about 180 k A m 1 without reducing the remanence. The best laboratory properties of alnico p e r m a n e n t magnets have been obtained by Naastepad (1966) for a single crystal of an alloy containing 35 wt % Fe, 34.8% Co, 14.9% Ni, 7.5% A1, 5.4% Ti and 2.4% Cu which had a coercivity of 122 k A m 1 and an energy product (BH)max of 107 kJm -3. Unfortunately these exceptionally high values of the m a x i m u m energy product cannot be obtained on a commercial scale, but it is possible to obtain a commercial alnico 9 with BHc = 120 k A m -1 and a (BH)max of 75 kJm -3. It appears that the alnicos, which have been available since 1931, have now reached the zenith of their development and there is little prospect that any further substantial i m p r o v e m e n t in their magnetic properties can be made.
24.
Summary
The relatively high coercivities of the alnicos are due to the shape anisotropy of Fe or F e - C o rich single domain particles which are precipitated in a weakly ferromagnetic or non-ferromagnetic N i - A I rich matrix. After cooling from about 1200°C at a controlled rate ~30°Cs -I the isotropic
S T R U C T U R E AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO P E R M A N E N T M A G N E T ALLOYS
183
alnicos 1-4 are subsequently tempered for several hours at about 600-650°C. The anisotropic alnicos 5, 6, 7 and the grain oriented alnico 5DG are produced by controlled cooling from 1250°C in a saturating magnetic field ~200-300 kAm 1 and then tempered for several hours at about 600°C. The high coercivity alnicos 8 and 9 are also cooled from about 1250°C and then annealed isothermally in a saturating magnetic field ~200-300 kAm 1 for a few minutes at about 820°C after which they are given a two-stage tempering treatment usually for several hours at about 650°C and then at 550°C. The phase separation takes place by spinodal decomposition at 800-850°C as the alloys are cooled. The final shapes and sizes of the particles are determined in the very early stages of the spinodal decomposition and microstructural investigations have shown that the Fe or F e - C o rich particles are elongated parallel to the (100) directions in the matrix. In the isotropic Fe2NiA1 and Fe-Ni-Al-low cobalt containing alloys the particles often have mixed rod-like and plate-like shapes which form a complex three-dimensional interconnected structure in which preference for particle axis alignment with the (100) directions is not well defined. Microstructural studies of the anisotropic field treated alnicos 5-9 show that the precipitated F e - C o rich particles are rod-like, and preferentially aligned parallel to the field direction during thermomagnetic treatment. In these alloys the higher coercivities can be attributed to an increase in the shape anisotropy of the precipitated particles though there is evidence to show that the magnetization reversal occurs by the incoherent mechanism known as curling, rather than coherent rotation of the magnetization vector. In the crystal oriented alnicos 5-7 and 9, the direction of the applied field during the thermomagnetic treatment should be as close as possible to a particular (100) columnar axis in order to maximize the remanence, coercivity and energy product. In order for the thermomagnetic treatment to be effective the Curie temperature must be above the spinodal decomposition temperature. Furthermore the ratio of (2xJ)2/-/ (where AJ is the difference between the saturation magnetic polarizations of the cq and c~2 phases and 3' is the interracial energy) between the F e - C o rich particles and the matrix should be as high as possible so that the particles can be elongated (by minimization of their magnetic free energy) in the field direction. All of the above requirements can be satisfied if the cobalt content is in the range 24-42 wt %. This high cobalt content also has the beneficial effects of increasing the remanence and the coercivity (He ~ Js). The addition of Ti to alnicos 8 and 9 lowers the saturation magnetic polarization and Curie temperature of the matrix, but increases the perfection and elongation of the particles. Titanium also increases the time required for the thermomagnetic treatment to be effective and it is for this reason that alnicos 8 and 9 are given an isothermal heat treatment in a magnetic field at about 820°C for a few minutes. The principal effect of the tempering heat treatment is to increase the difference •J in the saturation magnetic polarization between the F e - C o rich particles and the Ni-A1 rich matrix. This increases the shape anisotropy field of the precipitated particles which is proportional to AJ and hence increases the coercivity. The shapes and the sizes of the particles do not change significantly during this heat treatment. The optimum volume fraction of the particles p ~ 0.6-0.7.
184
R.A. McCURRIE
References Aharoni, A., 1959, J. Appl. Phys. Suppl. 30, 70 S. Aharoni, A. and S. Shtrikman, 1958, Phys. Rev., 109, 1522. Albanese, G., G. Asti and R. Criscuoli, 1970, IEEE Trans. Magn., MAG-6, 161. Allec, G., 1971, Cobalt, No. 52, 156. Andrfi, W., 1956, Ann. Phys. (Leipzig) 19, 10. Arbuzov, M.P. and A.A. Pavlyukov, 1965, Fiz. Met. Metalloved. 20, No. 5, 724 (Engl. Transl., Phys. Met. Metallog. 20, No. 5, 83). Baran, W., 1959, Tech. Mitt. Krupp, 17, 150. Barbier, J.C., 1954, Ann. Phys. (Paris) 9, 84. Bate, G., 1961, J. Appl. Phys., Suppl. 32, 239 S. Bates, L.F., 1955, Research, 8, 462. Bates, L.F. and D.H. Martin, 1955, Proc. Phys. Soc. Lond. B68, 537. Bates, L.F. and A.W. Simpson, 1955, Proc. Phys. Soc. Lond. B68, 849. Bates, L.F., D.J. Craik and E.D. Isaac, 1962, Proc. Phys. Soc. Lond. 79, 970. Bean, C.P. and W.H. Meiklejohn, 1956, Bull. Amer. Phys. Soc., Set. II, 1, 148. Belova, V.M., V.I. Nikolaev, S.Yu. Stephanovich and S.S. Yakimov, 1969, Fiz. Tverd. Tela, 11, 3662. Belozersky, G.N., Yu.N. Grinblat and A.I. Shapiro, 1971, Fiz. Met. Metalloved. 32, No. 2, 301. (Engl. Transl., Phys. Met. MetaIlog. 32, No. 2, p. 75). Berkowitz, A.E., 1969, Constitution of Multiphase Alloys, ch. VII of 'Magnetism and Metallurgy', A.E. Berkowitz and E. Kneller, eds. (Academic Press, New York, London) Vol. 1, p. 331. Betteridge, W., 1938, J. Iron and Steel Inst. 139, 187. Bradley, A.J., 1949a, J. Iron and Steel Inst. 163, 19. Bradley, A.J., 1949b, Physica, 15, 175. Bradley, A.J., 1951, J. Iron and Steel Inst. 168, 233. Bradley, A.J., 1952, J. Iron and Steel Inst. 171, 41. Bradley, A.J. and A. Taylor, 1938a, Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A166, 353. Bradley, A.J. and A. Taylor, 1938b, Magnetism (Institute of Physics, London) 89. Bronner, C., 1970 IEEE, Trans. Magn. MAG-6, 301. Bronner, C., E. Planchard and J. Sauze, 1966a, Cobalt, No. 31, 63; 1966b, Cobalt, No. 32, 124.
Bronner, C., J. Sauze, E. Planchard, J.M. Drapier, D. Coutsouradis and L. Habraken, 1967, Cobalt, No. 36, 123. Bronner, C., J.-P. Haberer, E. Planchard, J. Sauze, J.M. Drapier, D. Coutsouradis and L. Habraken, 1968, Cobalt, No. 40, 131. Bronner, C., J.-P. Haberer, E. Planchard, J. Sauze, J.M. Drapier, D. Coutsouradis and L. Habraken, 1969, Cobalt, No. 42, 14. Bronner, C., J.-P. Haberer, E. Planchard, J. Sauze, J.M. Drapier, D. Coutsouradis and L. Habraken, 1970, Cobalt, No. 48, 111. Bronner, C., J.-P. Haberer, E. Planchard and J. Sauze, 1970a, Cobalt, No. 46, 15. Bronner, C., J.-P. Haberer, E. Planchard and J. Sauze, 1970b, Cobalt, No. 49, 187. Brown, Jr., W.F., 1957, Phys. Rev. 105, 1479. Brown, Jr., W.F. 1962, Magnetostatic Principles in Ferromagnetism (North-Holland, Amsterdam) p. 117. Brown, Jr., W.F., 1963, Micromagnetics (Interscience/Wiley, New York) p. 79. Brown, Jr., W.F., 1969, Ann. New York Acad. Sci. 147, 461. Bulgakov, N.V., 1949, Dokl. Akad. Nauk (SSSR) 69, 627. Bulgakov, N.V., 1950, Dokl. Akad. Nauk, (SSSR) 70, 205. Bulgakov, N.V. and E. Kondorsky, 1949, Dokl. Akad. Nauk. (SSSR) 69, 325. Bulygina, T.I. and V.V. Sergeyev, 1969, Fiz. Met. Metalloved. 27, No. 4, 703. (Engl. Transl., Phys. Met. Metallog. 27, No. 4, 132). Burgers, W.G. and J.L. Snoek, 1935, Physica, 2, 1064. Cahn, J.W., 1961, Acta Met. 9, 795. Cahn, J.W., 1962, Acta Met. 10, 179. Cahn, J.W., 1963, J. Appl. Phys. 34, 3581. Cahn, J.W., 1968, Trans. Met. Soc. AIME, 242, 166. Cahn, J.W. and J.E. Hilliard, 1958, J. Chem. Phys. 28, 258. Cahn, J.W. and J.E. Hilliard, 1959, J. Chem. Phys. 31,688. Clegg, A.G., 1955, Brit. J. Appl. Phys. 6, 120. Clegg, A.G., 1966, Z. Angew. Phys. 21, 77. Clegg, A.G., 1970, IEEE, Trans. Magn. MAG-6, 201. Ciegg, A.G. and M. McCaig, 1957, Proc. Phys. Soc. Lond. B70, 817. Clegg, A.G. and M. McCaig, 1958, Brit. J. Appl. Phys. 9, 194. Compaan, K. and H. Zijlstra, 1962, Phys. Rev. 126, 1722.
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS Craik, D.J. and E.D. Isaac, 1960, Proc. Phys. Soc. 76, 160. Craik, D.J. and R. Lane, 1967, Brit. J. Appl. Phys. 18, 1269. Craik, D.J. and R. Lane, 1969, Brit. J. Appl. Phys. (J. Phys. D. Appl. Phys.) Ser. 2, Vol. 2, 33. Cronk, E.R., 1966, J. Appl. Phys. 37, 1097. Dean, A.V. and J.J. Mason, 1969, Cobalt, No. 43, p. 73. Dehler, H., 1942, Stahl u Eisen, 47, 983. De Jong, J.J., J.M.G. Smeets and H.B. Haanstra, 1958, J. Appl. Phys. 29, 297. De Vos, K.J., 1966, Doctoral Thesis, Technical High School (Eindhoven, The Netherlands). De Vos, K.J., 1969, 'Alnico Permanent Magnet Alloys', ch. 9 in: Magnetism and Metallurgy, A.E. Berkowitz and E. Kneller, eds. (Academic Press, New York, London) p. 473. Dietrich, H., 1966a, Cobalt, No. 30, 3. Dietrich, H., 1966b, A. Angew. Phys. 21, 125. Dietrich, H., 1967, Cobalt, No. 35, 78. Durand-Charre, M., C. Bronner and J.-P. Lagarde, 1978, IEEE: Trans. Magn. MAG-14, 797. Dussler, E., 1927, Z. Phys. 44, 286. Ebeling, D.G. and A.A. Burr, 1953, J. Metals, 5, 537. Edwards, A., 1957, Elect. Energy, 1, 146, 178. Edwards, A., 1962, Magnet Design and Selection of Material, ch. 6 of Permanent Magnets and Magnetism, D. Hadfield, ed. (Iliffe Books Ltd., London; Wiley, New York) p. 191. Fahlenbrach, H., 1954, Tech. Mitt. Krupp, 12, 177. Fahlenbrach, H., 1955, Naturwissenschaften, 42, 64. Fahlenbrach, H., 1956, Tech. Mitt. Krupp, 14, 2. Fahlenbrach, H. and H. Stfiblein, 1964, Proc. Intern. Conf. Magnetism (Inst. Phys., Nottingham, UK) p. 767. Frei, E.H., S. Shtrikman and D. Treves, 1957, Phys. Rev. 106, 445. Fujiwara, T. and T. Kato, 1960, J. Japan. Inst. Metals, 24, 526. Gould, J.E., 1958, Instrum. Practice, 12, 1083. Gould, J.E., 1962, Magnetic Stability, ch. 10 of Permanent Magnets and Magnetism, D. Hadfield, ed. (Iliffe Books Ltd, London; Wiley, New York). p. 443. Gould, J.E., 1964, Cobalt, No. 23, 82.
185
Gould, J.E., 1971, Cobalt Alloy Permanent Magnets (Centre d'Information du Cobalt, Brussels). Gould, J.E. and M. McCaig, 1954, Proc. Phys. Soc. Lond. B67, 584. Granovsky, B., P.P. Pashkov, V.V. Sergeyev and A.A. Fridman, 1967, Fiz. Met. Metalloved. 23, No. 3, 444 (Engl. Transl., Phys. Met. Metallog. 23, No. 3, 55). Guillaud, C., 1953, Rev. Mod. Phys. 25, 64. Haanstra, H.B., J.J. de Jong and J.M.G. Smeets, 1957, Philips Tech. Rev. 19, 11. Hansen, J.R., 1955, Proc. Conf. Magnetism and Magnetic Materials (Pittsburgh, Pa, USA) p. 198. Harrison, J., 1966, Z. Angew. Phys. 21, 101. Harrison, J. and W. Wright, 1967, Cobalt, No. 35, 63. Heck, C., 1974, Magnetic Materials and their Applications (Butterworths, London). Heidenreich, R.D. and E.A. Nesbitt, 1952, J. Appl. Phys. 23, 352. Heimke, G. and R. Kohlhaas, 1966, Z. Angew. Phys. 21, 73. Heimke, G., H. van Kempen and R. Kohlhaas, 1966, IEEE, Trans. Magn. MAG-2, 411. Higuchi, A., 1966, Z. Angew. Phys. 21, 80. Higuchi, A. and T. Miyamoto, 1970, IEEE, Trans. Magn. MAG-6, 218. Hillert, M., 1961, Acta Met. 9, 525. Hilliard, J.E., 1962, Trans. AIME, 224, 1201. Hilliard, J.E., 1967, Determination of Structural Anisotropy, Proc. 2nd Intern. Congress for Stereology, H. Elias, ed. (Springer, New York) p. 219. Hilliard, J.E., 1968, Measurement of Volume in Volume, ch. 3 of Quantitative Microscopy, R.T. DeHoff and F.N. Rhines, eds. (McGraw-Hill, New York, St. Louis, San Francisco, Toronto, London, Sydney) pp. 4576. Hilliard, J.E. and J.W. Cahn, 1961, Trans. Amer. Inst. Min. Engrs. 221, 344. Hoffmann, A. and H. St~blein, 1966, Tech. Mitt. Krupp, Forsch. Ber. 24, 113. Hoffmann, A. and H. St~iblein, 1967, Z. Angew. Phys. 23, 182. Hoffmann, A. and H. Stiiblein, 1970, IEEE, Trans. Magn. MAG-.6, 225. Hoffmann, A. and P. Pant, 1970, Tech. Mitt. Krupp, Forsch. Ber. 28, 117. Honda, K., 1934, Metallwirtschaft, 13, pp. 425427.
186
R.A. McCURRIE
Hoselitz, K. and M. McCaig, 1949a, Proc. Phys. Soc.. Lond. B62, 163. Hoselitz, K. and M. McCaig, 1949b, Nature (Lond.) 164, 581. Hoselitz, K. and M. McCaig, 1951, Proc. Phys. Soc. Lond. B64, 549. Hoselitz, K. and M. McCaig, 1952, Proc. Phys. Soc. Lond. B65, 229. Iwama, Y., 1968, Trans. Jap. Inst. Metals, 9, 273. Iwama, Y., M. Inagaki and T. Miyamoto, 1970, Trans. Jap. Inst. Metals, 11,268. Iwama, Y., M. Takeuchi and M. Iwata, 1976, Trans. Jap. Inst. Metals, 17, 481. Jacobs, I.S. and F.E. Luborsky, 1957, J. Appl. Phys. 28, 467. Jellinghaus, W., 1943, Arch. Eisenhfittenw. 16, 247. Joksch, C., 1975, Physica, 80B, 199. Jonas, B. and H.J. Meerkamp van Embden, 1941, Philips Tech. Rev. 6, 8. Julien, C.A. and E G . Jones, 1965a, J. Appl. Phys. Suppl. 36, 1173. Julien, C.A. and F.G. Jones, 1965b, Cobalt, No. 27, 73. Kittel, C., 1949, Rev. Mod. Phys. 21, 541. Kittel, C. and J.K. Galt, 1956, Solid State Physics, vol. 3, F. Seitz and D. Turnbull, eds. (Academic Press, New York, London) pp. 437-564. Kittel, C., E.A. Nesbitt and W. Shockley, 1950, Phys. Rev. 77, 839. Kneller, E., 1966, Handbueh der Physik, S. Fl/igge, ed., Ferromagnetism, vol. XVIII pt. 2, H.P.J. Wijn, ed. (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York) p. 512. Kneller, E., 1969, Fine Particle Theory, ch. VIII of Magnetism and Metallurgy, A.E. Berkowitz and E. Kneller, eds. (Academic Press, New York, London) vol. 1, p. 365. Koch, A.J.J., M.G. van der Steeg and K.J. de Vos, 1957, Proc. Conf. Magnetism and Magnetic Materials (Amer. I.E.E., Boston, Mass., USA) p. 173. Koch, A.J.J., M.G. van der Steeg and K.J. de Vos, 1959, Berichte der Arbeitsgemeinschaft Ferromagnetismus (Riederer, Stuttgart) p. 130. Kolbe, C.L. and D.L. Martin, 1960, J. Appl. Phys., Suppl. 31, 84 S. Kondorsky, E., 1952a, Izvest. Akad. Nauk SSSR, 16, 398. Kondorsky, E., 1952b, Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR, 82, 365.
Koshiba, S. and T. Nishinuma, 1957, J. Jap. Inst. Metals, 21, 166. Koshiba, S. and T. Nishinuma, 1960, J. Jap. Inst. Metals, 24, 433. Kronenberg, K.J., 1954, Z. Metallk. 45, 440. Kronenberg, K.J., 1960, J. Appl. Phys. 31, 80 S. Kronenberg, K.J., 1961, J. Appl. Phys. 32, 196 S. Kronenberg, K.J, and R.K. Tenzer, 1958, J. Appl. Phys. 29, 299. Kussmann, A. and J.H. WoIlenberger, 1956, Z. Angew. Phys. 8, 213. Kussman, A. and O. Yamada, 1956, Arch. Elektrotech. 42, 237. Lange, G., 1968, Deutsche Edelstahlwerke, Tech. Ber. 8, 209. Lindner, E., R. Wittig and K. Prissier, 1963, Neue Hfitte, 8, 557. Livshitz, B.G., B.A. Samarin and V.S. Shubakov, 1970a, IEEE, Trans. Magn., MAG-6, 242. Livshitz, B.G., E.G. Knizhnik, G.S. Kraposhin and Y.S. Linetsky, 1970b, IEEE, Trans. Magn., MAG-6, 237. Livshitz, B.G., V.I. Sumin and A.S. Lileev, 1970c, IEEE, Trans. Magn., MAG-6, 169. Luborsky, F.E., 1961, J. Appl. Phys. Suppl. 32, 171 S. Luborsky, F.E. and C.R. Morelock, 1964, J. Appl. Phys. 35, 2055. Luteijn, A.J. and K.J. de Vos, 1956, Philips Res. Repts. 11, 489. Makarov, E.F., V.A. Povitsky, E.B. Granovsky and A.A. Fridman, 1967, Phys. Status Solidi, 24, 45. Makarov, V.A., E.B. Granovsky, E.F. Makarov and V.A. Povitsky, 1972, Phys. Status Solidi, 14, (A) 331. Makino, N., 1962, Cobalt, No. 17, 3. Makino, N. and Y. Kimura, 1965, J. Appl. Phys. 36, 1185. Makino, N., Y. Kimura and I. Yamaki, 1963, J. Jap. Inst. Metals 27, 582. Marcon, G., C. Bronner and R. Peffen, 1971; Cobalt, No. 51, 99. Marcon, G., R. Peffen and H. Lemaire, 1978a, IEEE, Trans. Magn., MAG-14, 685. Marcon, G., R. Peffen and H. Lemaire, 1978b, IEEE, Trans. Magn., MAG-14, 688. Mason, J.J., D.W. Ashall and A.V. Dean, 1970, IEEE, Trans. Magn., MAG-6, 19l. McCaig, M., 1949, Proc. Phys. Soc. Lond. B62, 652. McCaig, M., 1953, J. Appl. Phys. 24, 366.
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF ALNICO PERMANENT MAGNET ALLOYS McCaig, M., 1966, Z. Angew. Phys. 21, 66. McCaig, M., 1968, Cobalt, No. 41, 196. McCaig, M., 1977, Stability of Permanent Magnets, ch. 5 of Permanent Magnets in Theory and Practice (Pentech Press, London, Plymouth) p. 155. McCaig, M. and W. Wright, 1960, Brit. J. Appl. Phys. 11, 279. McCurrie, R.A., 1981, J. Appl. Phys. 52, 7344. McCurrie, R.A. and S. Jackson, 1980, IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-16, 1310. Mishima, T., 1932, Ohm, 19, 353. Moon, J.R., 1974, J. Phys. D: Appl, Phys. 7, 1233. Naastepad, P.A., 1966, Z. Angew. Phys. 21, 104. N6el, L., 1943, Cahiers Phys. 17, 47. N6el, L., 1947a, Comptes Rendus Acad. Sci. (Paris) 224, 1550. N6el, L., 1947b, Comptes Rendus Acad. Sci. (Paris) 225, 109. N6el, L., R. Forrer, N. Janet and R. Battle, 1943, Cahiers Phys. 17, 51. Nesbitt, E.A., 1950, J. Appl. Phys. 21, 879. Nesbitt, E.A. and H.J. Williams, 1950, Phys. Rev. 80, 112. Nesbitt, E.A. and R.D. Heidenreich, 1952, J. Appl. Phys. 23, 366. Nesbitt, E.A. and H.J. Williams, 1955, J. Appl. Phys. 26, 1217. Nesbitt, E.A. and H.J. Williams, 1957, Proc. Conf. Magn. and Magn. Materials (Amer. I.E.E., Boston, Mass., USA) p. 184. Nesbitt, E.A., H.J. Williams and R.M. Bozorth, 1954, J. Appl. Phys. 25, 1014. Nicholson, R.B. and P.J. Tufton, 1966, Z. Angew. Phys. 21, 59. Oliver, D.A. and J.W. Shedden, 1938, Nature (Lond.) 142, 209. Paine, T.O. and F.E. Luborsky, 1960, J. Appl. Phys. Suppl. 31, 78 S. Palmer, D.J. and S.W.K. Shaw, 1969, Cobalt, No. 43, 63. Pant, P., 1974, Proc. 3rd Europ. Conf. on Hard Magnetic Materials (Amsterdam, 17-19 September, 1974) H. Zijlstra, ed. (Bond voor Material en Kennis, P.O. Box 9321, Den Haag, The Netherlands) p. 186. Parker, R.J. and R.J. Studders, 1962, Permanent Magnets and their Applications (Wiley, New York, London). Pashkov, P.P., A.A. Fridman, Ye.B. Granovsky, V.V. Sergeyev and R.Ya. Larichkina,
187
1969, J. Appl., Phys. Suppl. 40, 1308. Pashkov, P.P., A. Fridman and E. Granovsky, 1970, IEEE, Trans. Magn., MAG-6, 211. Pater, M., R. Bloch and E. Krainer, 1963, Z. Angew. Phys. 15, 261. Pawlek, F. and K. Reichel, 1955, Z. Metallk. 46, 308. Pfeiffer, I., 1969, Cobalt, No. 44, 115. Phillips, J.H., R. Street and J.C. Woolley, 1954, Phil. Mag. 45, 505. Planchard, E., R. Meyer and C. Bronner, 1964a, Z. Angew. Phys. 17, 174. Planchard, E., C. Bronner and J. Sauze, 1964b, Proceedings of the Journ6es Internationales des Applications du Cobalt (Brussels, 9-11th June, 1964)pp. 134-511. Planchard, E., C. Bronner and J. Sauze, 1965, Cobalt, No. 28, 132. Planchard, E., C. Bronner and J. Sauze, 1966a, Z. Angew. Phys. 21, 63. Planchard, E., C. Bronner and J. Sauze, 1966b, Z. Angew. Phys. 21, 95. Povitsky, V.A., E.B. Granovsky, A.A. Fridman, E.F. Makarov and P.P. Pashkov, 1970, IEEE, Trans. Magn., MAG-6, 215. Povolotskii, E.G., Ya.M. Dovgalevskii and V.K. Baitina, 1963, Metal Science and Heat Treatment, 11, 631. Ritzow, G., 1963, Neue Hiitte, 8, 282. Ritzow, G. and W. Ebert, 1957, Deutsche Elektrotechnik, 11, 527. Roberts, W.H., 1958, J. Appl. Phys. 29, 405. Sabir, S.A.Y. and W. Shepherd, 1974, Proc. IEE, 121, No. 8, 907. Saltykov, S.A., 1970, Stereometric Metallography (Metallurgizdat, Moscow) 3rd ed. Shepherd, W., H. Gaskell and P. Rashid, 1974, IEEE, Trans, Magn., MAG-10, 50. Schiller, K., 1968, Deutsche Edelstahlwerke, Tech. Ber. 8, 147. Schiller, K. and K. Brinkmann, 1970, Dauermagnete, Werkstoffe und Anwendungen (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York). Schulz, L.G., 1949, J. Appl. Phys. 20, 1030. Schulze, D., 1956, Exptl. Tech. Phys. 4, 193. Schwartz, L.H., 1976, Ferrous Alloy Phase Transformations, ch. 2 in: Applications of M6ssbauer Spectroscopy, R. Cohen, ed. (Academic Press, New York, San Francisco, London) vol. 1, pp. 58-61. Sergeyev, V. and T.Y. Bulygina, 1970, IEEE, Trans. Magn., MAG-6, 194. Shtrikman, S. and D. Treves, 1959, J. Phys., Radium, 20, 286.
188
R.A. McCURRIE
Shtrikman, S. and D. Treves, 1966, J. Appl. Phys. 37, 1103. Sixtus, K.J., Kronenberg, K.J. and R.K. Tenzer, 1956, J. Appl. Phys. 27, 1051. Snoek, J.L., 1938, Probleme der Technischen Magnetisierungskurve (Springer, Berlin) p. 73. Snoek, J.L., 1939, Physica, 6, 321. Stfiblein, H., 1963, Tech. Mitt. Krupp, Forsch. Ber. 21, 171. Stfiblein, H., 1968, Tech. Mitt. Krupp, Forsch. Ber. 26, 1. Steinort, E., E.R. Cronk, S.J. Garvin and H. Tiderman, 1962, J. Appl. Phys. Suppl. 33, 1310. Stoner, E.C. and E.P. Wohlfarth, 1947, Nature (Lond.) 160, 650. Stoner, E.C. and E.P. Wohlfarth, 1948, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. (Lond.) A240, 599. Street, R. and J.C. Woolley, 1949, Proc. Phys. Soc. Lond. A62, 562. Street, R. and J.C. Woolley, 1950, Proc. Phys. Soc. Lond. B63, 509. Street, R. and J.C. Woolley, 1956, Proc. Phys. Soc. Lond. B69, 1189. Street, R., J.C. Woolley and P.B. Smith, 1952a, Proc. Phys. Soc. Lond. B65, 461. Street, R., J.C. Woolley and P.B. Smith, 1952b, Proc. Phys. Soc. Lond. B65, 679. Sucksmith, W., 1939, Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A171, 525. Takeuchi, M. and Y. Iwama, 1976, Trans. Jap. Inst. Metals, 17, 489. Tenzer, R.K. and K.J. Kronenberg, 1958, J. Appl. Phys. 29, 302. Underwood, E.E., 1 9 7 0 , Quantitative Stereology (Addison-Wesley; Reading, Massachusetts, Menlo Park, California, London. Don Mills, Ontario). Underwood, E.E., 1973, Applications of Quantitative Metallography, in: Metals Handbook
(Amer. Soc. Metals, Metals Park, Ohio, USA, 1973) 8th ed., vol. 8, pp. 37-47. Vallier, G., C. Bronner and R. Peffen, 1967, Cobalt, No. 34, 10. Van der Steeg, M.G. and K.J. de Vos, 1964, Z. Angew. Phys. 17, 98. Van Wieringen, J.S. and J.G. Rensen, 1966, Z. Angew. Phys. 21, 69. Wittig, R., 1962, Z. Angew. Phys. 14, 248. Wittig, R., 1966, Z. Angew. Phys. 21, 98. Wohlfarth, E.P., 1955, Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A232, 208. Wright, W., 1970, Cobalt, No. 48, 115. Wright, W. and R. Ogden, 1964, Cobalt, No. 24, 140. Wyrwich, W., 1963, Z. Angew. Phys. 15, 263. Yamada, O., 1955, Z. Phys. 142, 225. Yermolenko, A.S. and Ya.S. Shur, 1964, Fiz. Met. Metalloved. 17, No. l, 31 (Engl. Transl., Phys. Met. Metallog. 17, No. 1, 31). Yermolenko, A.S., E.N. Melkisheva and Ya.S. Shur, 1964, Fiz. Met. Metalloved. 18, No. 4, 540 (Engl. Transl., Phys. Met. Metallog. 18, No. 4, 63). Yermolenko, A.S. and A.V. Korolyov, 1970, IEEE, Trans. Magn., MAG-6, 252. Zijlstra, H., 1956, J. Appl. Phys. 27, 1249. Zijlstra, H., 1960, Doctoral Thesis, University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Zijlstra, H., 1961, J. Appl. Phys. Suppl. 32, 194 S, Zijlstra, H., 1962, Z. Angew. Phys. 14, 251. Zijlstra, H., 1966, Z. Angew. Phys. 21, 6. Zingery, W.L., W.B. Whalley, E.B. Romberg and F.W. Wheeler, 1966, J. Appl. Phys. 37, 1101. Zumbusch, W., 1942a, Arch. Eisenhfittenw. 16, 101. Zumbusch, W., 1942b, Electrotechnik-Maschinenbau, 60, 522.
chapter 4 OXIDE SPINELS*
S. KRUPI(~KA AND P. NOVAK Institute of Physics Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences Prague Czechoslovakia
* For accounts of specifically non-microwave and microwave ferrites see chs. 3 and 4, Vol. 2, by P.I. Slick and J. Nicolas. For an account of garnets, see ch. 1 Vol. 2, by M.A. Gilleo.
Ferromagnetic Materials, Vol. 3 Edited by E.P. Wohlfarth © North-Holland Publishing Company, 1982 189
CONTENTS 1. C r y s t a l s t r u c t u r e a n d c h e m i s t r y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.l. D e s c r i p t i o n of t h e c r y s t a l s t r u c t u r e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2. C a t i o n s e n t e r i n g t h e o x i d e spinels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3. T h e r m o d y n a m i c s t a b i l i t y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1A. C r y s t a l field a n d c o v a l e n c y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5. C r y s t a l e n e r g y , c a t i o n d i s t r i b u t i o n a n d site p r e f e r e n c e s . . . . . . . . . 1.6. O r d e r i n g a n d d i s t o r t i o n s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. M a g n e t i c o r d e r i n g . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1. E x c h a n g e i n t e r a c t i o n s in spinels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2. M a g n e t i c o r d e r i n g : t h e o r y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3. M a g n e t i c o r d e r i n g : e x p e r i m e n t . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.1. Spinels w i t h o n e m a g n e t i c s u b l a t t i c e o n l y . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.2. Spinels w i t h m a g n e t i c i o n s in b o t h s u b l a t t i c e s . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.3. T h e effect o f d i a m a g n e t i c s u b s t i t u t i o n s . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.4. T e m p e r a t u r e a n d field d e p e n d e n c e s . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4. S p i n w a v e s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. M a g n e t i c p r o p e r t i e s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. A n i s o t r o p y a n d m a g n e t o s t r i c t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1.1. I n t r o d u c t o r y r e m a r k s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1.2. M i c r o s c o p i c origin: a n i s o t r o p y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1.3. M i c r o s c o p i c origin: m a g n e t o s t r i c t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. M a g n e t i c a n n e a l a n d r e l a t e d p h e n o m e n a . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.1. O r i g i n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.2. E x a m p l e s o f local a n i s o t r o p i c c o n f i g u r a t i o n s . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.3. K i n e t i c s , m a g n e t i c a f t e r - e f f e c t s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.4. S u r v e y of e x p e r i m e n t a l r e s u l t s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. D y n a m i c s of m a g n e t i z a t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. O t h e r p h y s i c a l p r o p e r t i e s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1. E l e c t r i c a l p r o p e r t i e s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.1. D C e l e c t r i c a l c o n d u c t i v i t y a n d S e e b e c k effect . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.2. D i e l e c t r i c c o n s t a n t . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.3. O p t i c a l a n d m a g n e t o o p t i c a l s p e c t r a . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2. M e c h a n i c a l a n d t h e r m a l p r o p e r t i e s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2.1. I n f r a r e d s p e c t r a . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2.2. E l a s t i c c o n s t a n t s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2.3. H e a t c a p a c i t y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2.4. T h e r m a l c o n d u c t i v i t y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2.5. T h e r m a l e x p a n s i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix: Intrinsic magnetic properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
190
191 191 194 196 202 206 211 216 217 221 224 224 226 227 229 231 233 233 233 235 238 245 245 247 249 251 256 260 26O 261 275 276 284 284 285 287 288 289 291 298
1. Crystal structure and chemistry The spinel structure is one of the most frequently encountered with the MM~X4 compounds. X represents oxygen or some Chalcogenic bivalent anion (S2-, Se 2 , Te ~ ) which may be partly substituted by proper monovalent anions (F , I-, Br-); M, M' are metallic ions (or a combination of them) whose valencies have to fulfil the electroneutrality requirements. Due to the large electronegativity of oxygen the ionic type of bonds prevails in almost all oxide spinels. As a consequence, the electrical resistivity is usually high and we are allowed to classify these compounds as insulators even though sometimes the term low-mobility semiconductors would apply. This is not the case with the other bivalent anions (S, Se, Te) possessing considerable lower electronegativities. They behave more like semiconductors or even metals and, therefore, they are treated separately (see Van Stapele, ch. 8).
1.1. Description of the crystal structure The spinel structure is called after the mineral spinel MgAI204. It is formed by a nearly close-packed fcc array of anions with holes partly filled by the cations. There are two kinds of holes differing in coordination: tetrahedral (or A) and octahedral (or B). From all these sites available in the elementary cube containing 32 anions, only 8 of the A-type and 16 of the B-type are occupied by cations. The geometry of the occupied interstices may be seen from fig. 1, where the primitive cell containing 2 formula units MM~X4 is shown. The symmetry is cubic and corresponds to the space group O7(Fd3m). A small displacement, defined by a single parameter u, of the anions from their ideal position is allowed along the corresponding body diagonal (fig. 2) which enables a better matching of the anion positions to the relative radii of A and B cations. The coordinates of ions in spinel are summarized in table 1. For the ideal close-packed anion lattice u equals 2. In real oxide spinels usually u ¢ ~ and in the model of hard spheres it should increase linearly with (rA-- rB)/a (fig. 3). The local symmetry of the cation sites is cubic in the A positions and trigonal in B, the trigonal axis being one of the body diagonals (fig. 1); note that the trigonal symmetry is due to both the configuration of neighbouring cations and the distortion of the anion octahedron if u ¢ ~. Each of the four body diagonals 191
S. KRUPI(~KA A N D P. N O V ~ K
192
/
//
~C"
l~
//
I
I
,~"/X " /
f,'"
I I
/
/ /
t"-",_,tT/'~
I
a
2
z ~
I
I
I
i~.
r I
I I
t I
I I
j_L___T___~ia___
I
~_C
~
. . . . . . . .
2.£
p
r
I I
I I
I
I r
.
. . . . . . . . .
/a . . . .
~
/
L/ @ 0
2-
A B
Fig. 1. Primitive cell of the spinel structure.
TABLE 1 Coordinates of ions in the elementary cell of spinel structure (in fractions of the lattice parameter ). i
8 ions in A-sites 16 i o n s in B - s i t e s
1
_5 5 5~; 5L ~, 7 ~; 7 L7 5g, g; 7 ~, 7 ~, 7 858, ~, 1
32ionsX
Coordinates
I
0, 0, 0; ~, ~,
1
1
1
1
1
u, u, u; u, ~, ~; 8 - u, ~ - u , ~ - u; ~ - u, ~ + u , ~ + u
1 1 1 + U~ 1 ~, U, t2; t~, ~, U; ~ + U, ~-- U, ~+U, of remaining
ions are obtained
(0, ½,1), (½, O, ½), (½,1~, 0).
by translations
ah, /
a(u-~)I3"
5
Ir - - ,
~
~,
i
,I
-.
i
1 I
1
I
~_}_1 U~ i ~--U
~
~
Q_ 4-
Fig. 2. Environment of the anion in spinel.
O X I D E SPINELS
2-3 type
0.39
4-2 type
• Go 3.
13 Ge 4.
+ AL 3.
o .,or)4*
•
193
+
V 3÷
• C r 2÷ . A Fe 3~
•
0.38
0.37
Na2~O~ Ag2~o04
0.36 I
I
-0.06
I
I
-0.04
I
I
-0.02
I
/
o
I
~-~ (2
Fig. 3. D e p e n d e n c e of the p a r a m e t e r u on t h e reduced difference of radii of A and B ions.
belongs to just one of the B cations in the primitive cell in fig. 1. Hence, these cations are non-equivalent differing in their local symmetry axis and each of them may be taken as representing one fcc sublattice with the lattice constant a. On the other hand, the local symmetry of the A positions remains cubic even if u # 3, so that both sublattices represented by A sites in the primitive cell are mutually equivalent. When considering some aspects for which the local symmetry is irrelevant, all the B positions may be treated as belonging to only one sublattice (octahedral or B) in the same way as the A positions may be unified to form one tetrahedral sublattice (A). Both translational and local symmetries corresponding to the O 7 space group strictly apply only if each sublattice contains only one kind of cations, i.e., if all M ions in MM~X4 are in tetrahedral and all M' in octahedral positions. The spinel is then called normal. It was early established by X-ray diffraction (Barth and Posnjak 1932), and later by neutron diffraction (Hastings and Corliss 1953) as well, that besides this, another cation distribution exists in many spinels called inverse: here, one half of the cations M' are in A positions and the rest, together with the M ions are randomly distributed among the B positions. There are also many examples of intermediate cases between a normal and an inverse spinel (mixed spinels). Therefore, in order to characterize fully the spinel structure, a further parameter is needed describing the degree of inversion. The chemical
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOVAK
194
formula may then be explicitly written as
(1)
MaM~-~[MI-~M~+a]X4,
where the cations on B sites are in brackets. Note that 6 = 1 means a normal spinel, 6 = 0 an inverse one. If there are different cations coexisting in equivalent interstices (partial or full inversion, solid solutions) the symmetry is perturbe~d. Nevertheless, new symmetry relations may appear when the different cations order regularly (section 1.6). The symmetry of the spinel structure may also be changed by a spontaneous distortion due to the cooperative Jahn-Teller effect (section 1.6). It has been pointed out on the basis of far infrared spectra and calorimetric measurements (Grimes 1972, 1974, Grimes et al. 1978) that in some spinels the octahedrally coordinated cations might be shifted a little out of their central positions ("off centre ions") which would also change the space group. The attempts to prove this conclusion by a direct diffraction study have given controversial results until now (Rouse et al. 1976, Hwang et al. 1973, Thompson and Grimes 1977). 1.2. Cations entering the oxide spinels
The,electroneutrality considerations lead to 3 basic spinel types, according to the cation valency combinations in MM~O4:M2+M~3+O4 2- (2-3 spinels), M4+M~2+O2(4-2 spinels) and M6+M~+O 2- (6-1 spinels). Other possible types may be deduced from these by formal substitutions (e.g. Nf+~½(M"> + M '3+ giving ~,,l+~,3+c~2Iv-to.5 -tvx2.5 '~.J4 , 3+ M2+~[]~/3 .± . .~.4 12/3 leading to so-called y - M ~ O 3 defect sesquioxide phase, etc.). The basic binary spinel types are listed in table 2a together with relevant cations and their ionic radii. Additional spinel types derived by substitutions of the basic ones are listed in table 2b. It is seen from tables 2a and 2b that practically any cation with radius within the limits 0.4 to = 1 ~ may be incorporated into the spinel structure and most of them can occur in both octahedral and tetrahedral positions. The smallest cations with valency />4, however, are found in the tetrahedral coordination only, while the large monovalent cations occurring mainly in 6-1 spinels are confined to the octahedral sites. Besides the geometrical factors, the distribution of cations among A and B positions is influenced by many others, as briefly discussed in section 1.5. The interstices available for cations in the spinel structure have radii RA = (u - ~)aX/5- r(O>);
R , = (~- u ) a - r(O2-).
(2)
In table 3, these are compared with corresponding ionic radii as listed in table 2, using the experimental values for a and u. The agreement is satisfactory though a small but rather systematic contraction of the ionic radii, up to a few percent, is observed. On the other hand, a comparison of experimental a and u values with the calculated ones based on the eq. (1) (table 4), where the ionic radii from table 2 are inserted for RA, RB, shows that this contraction concerns the lattice
195
O X I D E SP1NELS
5
J oo
c5 + • eq
0 "0
.x. ~
~
+
~
•
~
c~
..
~ + + e~
+
+
~
~+
o
r-I
r~ ~'-~
+
t~
,..<
2
~-
+
+
=L
o~
O
c5
t"q
+~
"'.c~ r--
+
r~
~h ~
oq O + ~"
+ ea
t~
+
3-
O
oz-
+ O
c5
,'6 ©
~5
E
+
~5
m
+~ c'4
e~
..~
O~
© +
c5 "7
% N~
6c m
g.
q~
O
E
O., y,
O
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOV.~A~
196
TABLE 3 Radii of A and B interstices, R, and corresponding ionic radii RM (all in A). A Spinel ZnFezO4 NiFe204 MnFe204 Fe304 MnCrzO4 FeV204 CoFe204 Mg2TiO4 Na2WO4
B
R
RM
R
Rra
0.715 0.632 0.722 0.616 0.77 0.731 0.653 0.75 0.62
0.74 0.63 0.766 0.63 0.80 0.77 0.64 0.71 0.56
0.762 0.775 0.783 0.801 0.732 0.76 0.778 0.745 1.08
0.785 0.808 0.785 0.853 0.755 0.78 0.787 0.773 1.16
TABLE 4 Comparison of experimental values of a and u with those calculated using eqs. (2) and table 2. Lattice o parameter (A) Spinel ZnFe204 MnFe204 CoFe204 NiFe204 ZnCr204 MnCr204 Fe304 Co2GeO4 Mg2TiO4 Na2WO4
Distribution of ions ZnZ+[Fe3+] Mn2+ Fe3+ rMn3+ 1 0.82 oast 0.18Fe2+ 0.18Fe3+ a.641 3+ 2+ 2+ 3+ Fe0.ssCo0.12[Co0.88Fea.12] Fe3+[Ni2+Fe3+] Zn2+[Cr~+] Mn2+[Cr~+] Fe3+[Fe2+Fe3+] Ge4+[Co~+] Mg2+[Mg2+Ti4+] W6+[Na~]
u
exp.
calc.
exp.
calc.
8.433 8.50 8.38 8.33 8.321 8.437 8.394 8.3175 8.441 9.1297
8.533 8.611 8.384 8.423 8.453 8.545 8.543 8.223 8.453 9.255
0.3852 0.3848 0.3818 0.3822 0.3863 0.3889 0.379 0.375 0.3875 0.369
0.3853 0.3861 0.3808 0.380 0.3866 0.3892 0.3777 0.3757 0.3846 0.3635
p a r a m e t e r a a n d h e n c e the whole structure, leaving u u n c h a n g e d . A n overall view of the g e o m e t r i c a l relations in various types of spinels m a y be acquired from fig. 3; the e x p e r i m e n t a l u values follow quite well the linear d e p e n d e n c e on the r e d u c e d difference of ionic radii ( r ( B ) - r(A))/a.
1.3. Thermodynamic stability T h e oxide spinels m a y usually be p r e p a r e d at e l e v a t e d t e m p e r a t u r e s by a direct solid state r e a c t i o n b e t w e e n the simple oxides. T h e r e l e v a n t t e m p e r a t u r e r a n g e is a b o u t 800 to 1500°C, d e p e n d i n g o n the type of cations. T h e t h e r m o d y n a m i c stability of spinels c o m p a r e d to the simple oxides is given by the G i b b s free
OXIDE SPINELS
197
e n e r g y of f o r m a t i o n A G c o n n e c t e d with t h e r e a c t i o n M O + M~O3 ---)MM~O4.
(3)
B y c o m b i n i n g A G with t h e e n t h a l p y of f o r m a t i o n AH, t h e e n t r o p y c h a n g e A S c o r r e s p o n d i n g to r e a c t i o n (3) m a y b e e s t i m a t e d . I n s t e a d of A G , A H d a t a a r e s o m e t i m e s u s e d w h e n c o m p a r i n g t h e r m o d y n a m i c stability for v a r i o u s spinels. T h e values of A G , A H a n d A S for s o m e s e l e c t e d spinels a r e given in t a b l e 5 a n d t h e A H ' s for 2 - 3 spinels a r e d i s p l a y e d in fig. 4 as d e p e n d i n g on t h e t y p e of d i v a l e n t cation. T h e r e l a t i v e l y g r e a t stability of o x i d e spinels is c o n n e c t e d with t h e s t r o n g l y ionic c h a r a c t e r of t h e b o n d . T h e spinels with a n i o n s possessing s m a l l e r e l e c t r o n e g a t i v i t i e s t h a n o x y g e n (S, Se, T e ) a r e m o r e c o v a l e n t a n d b e c o m e also less stable. This m a n i f e s t s itself in a d e c r e a s e d n u m b e r of such spinels, t h e i r s m a l l e r m u t u a l solubility a n d m o r e r e s t r i c t e d n u m b e r of c a t i o n s e n t e r i n g t h e s t r u c t u r e . T h e r e is s t r o n g c o m p e t i t i o n b e t w e e n spinel and, e.g., n i c k e l a r s e n i d e s t r u c t u r e , a n d s o m e s u l p h o s p i n e l s can b e t r a n s f o r m e d i n t o t h e l a t t e r u n d e r high p r e s s u r e ( B o u c h a r d 1967). T h e o x i d e spinels, on t h e o t h e r h a n d , f o r m solid s o l u t i o n s a l m o s t w i t h o u t
TABLE 5 AG, AH and AS values for selected spinels; after Navrotsky and Kleppa (1968). Spinel
AG*
AH(970 K)t
AS:~
MgAI204
1273 K: -8.4 1673 K: -8.4
-8.72 ± 0.29
0
MgFe204
1273 K: -5.3
-4.93 - 0.24
+0.3
Fe304
1000 K: -7.5
1000 K: -5.1
+2.2
CoFe204
1273 K: -9.4 1473 K: -8.2
-5.89 + 0.21
+2.7
NiFe204
1273 K: -6.0
- 1.22 ± 0.22
+3.8
ZnFe204
1400 K: -6.5
-2.67 ± 0.23
+2.7
FezTiO4
1073 K: -7.2
Co2TiO4
1073 K: -6.7
-6.04 ± 0.19
+0.7
Co2GeO4
- 14.1 ± 0.4
* Equilibrium measurements. t Calorimetric measurements. :~High temperature values calculated at the temperature for which AG is taken.
S. KRUPI(~KA AND P. NOV~id{
198 aH
i
i
i
/-,'
L m-~r_/
o
-~4
I I i
/I
\\
i
\
I I
-12
t I
\~1
[ I
I
,",
~ I
•
\
]
,
!
~
~
\
I
Xi\\\
i Ill
I 4---1"-----I
/
I
~
o
-4.
I
i
i~/."
-I0
-6
/
x
\
\
/
]
.~'l'~ll
-+ - - - --~ ~ "%%
\
ll' It
t t
'~. ,,', \
o ,
,
,
I
\\
I I
]
~ .l'i
fill?
%1 [] t
I ] II I I I/
,
I ii I If
",t\1,~ ',,t I !,i'~ I,"",. I "\ ~,, , ~, , ,, \.
2
t I1
MAt20`
", ".~' ,'
+ MFe204
~ f'~t,
•
4
,/I
'l ~
A Mg 2+
MMn204 Mn 2+ Fe 2.
/
I \
~ Co 2+ Ni 2`
Cu 2+ ZD 2+
C 2+
Fig. 4. Enthalpy of formation AH for 2-3 spinels (Navrotsky and Kleppa 1968, Jacob and Walderraman 1977). restriction and the competing structures are of other t y p e s - i n the first place olivine and phenacite structures. They usually appear if one of the cations is very small (Si4+, Ge4+). The situation may be elucidated on the basis of the hypothetical phase diagram in fig. 5. We may infer from it that under normal conditions all germanates are spinels except Zn2GeO4 having the phenacite structure, while the silicates are olivines. Most of the latter ones can be transformed into spinels under high pressure and/or elevated temperatures. Both olivine and phenacite structures are less densely packed compared with spinels, the typical volume change being - 8 % and +19% for the olivine--> spinel and olivine-->phenacite transformation, respectively. The thermodynamic relations among olivine, spinel and phenacite structures in silicates and germanates are discussed by Navrotsky (1973a, b, 1974, 1975), Navrotsky and Hughes (1976) and Reinen (1968). The AG values for both groups of oxides are shown in fig. 6. With large cations, e.g., large divalent cations (Ca 2*, Ba 2+, etc.) in M2+M~>O4, the spinel structure becomes also unstable and other structures (hexagonal) appear. The mutual relations to spinel have not yet been established. Hitherto no attention was paid to the chemical stability of the oxide spinels against the oxidizing or reducing influence of the atmosphere. This may be justified if the incorporated cations have fixed valencies that cannot be changed
OXIDE SPINELS
F .
.
.
.
.
199
.
i~Geq [co~Geq jn2Geq I L
. . . . .
,Fe~SJO~ iI A+~'
•
'
. . . . . 1 ' N~S~Oj ' Z ISjO ; , , ylic%j ', ,In92vq ', l'J I'---~---~' ' , f ~ ~ ',n~2sJq', . . . . .
J
L
. . . . .
3
I
L. . . . F . . . . .
"
31
I
z~Geq! L . . . . .
A
Temperature Fig. 5. Phase relations between spinel, olivine and phenacite; after Navrotsky (1973). i
i
i
i
,
,
Hg 16
14
~9
~8
I
-I0
I
-8
-6
I
-4
I
I
-2
0
Germanates a G ~kcaL/moLJ Fig. 6. Gibbs free energy of transformation olivine-spinel in germanates and silicates; after Navrotsky and Hughes (1976).
200
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOV/~d~ TABLE 6 Valencies and ground states of 3d" ions. Number of 3d electrons
Valency
0
1+ 2+ 3+ 4+ 5+ Ground term
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Cr Mn Fe
Mn Fe Co
Fe Co
Co Ni
Cu
Cu Zn
Ti V
V Cr Mn
Ni
Sc Ti V
Ti V Cr
1S
2D
3F
4F
69
58
5D
4F
3F
2D
IS
within wide limits of the oxygen pressure. In the case of transition metal ions, however, this certainly is not a plausible approach, because these ions usually exist in several valency states (see tables 2a and 6). As a consequence the thermodynamic stability has then to be considered for both the crystal and gaseous phases in mutual contact. This leads to definite deviations from chemical stoichiometry of the ideal spinel depending on both the temperature T and the partial oxygen pressure Poz. If this deviation exceeds some critical value (depending on T and po~) the spinel structure may become unstable. The situation is illustrated in figs. 7 and 8. Note that in air the transition metal oxides with spinel structure melt often incongruently, which makes it difficult to prepare single crystals of an arbitrary composition from their own melt. Also the fact that at a given temperature the spinel of a definite composition is in thermodynamical
i
~~'~4~
600
hematite[I o.o 5 3
1400
1200
,pc]
1000
Fig. 7. Phase diagram for system Fe-O (Tretyakov 1967); projection into temperatureiequilibrium pressure of oxygen plane is shown. The heavy lines define the borders of the stability regions of the respective phases. The thin lines are the lines of constant 3' in the formula Fe304+~.
OXIDE
201
SP1NELS
•~
.~<~
'~
e-
•.
/,
i
~
'~t'-I
~
~ ~
/
<~ s
/ \
•~
÷
{~. ~
~
~
\
"~
~0~
~ - ~ .~
Z-
~,<~
,~ ~. ~
~'~o~ 0
0
<:)
~'~
i
(=3 (:~
o i::::)
(:b e~l
~ e',,l 0",1
i:::) ~ ¢',1
C) ~ .
.
(::) co
.
.
~ N'-
~ ¢M
.
.~ ~ ~ ' ~
<:) <::)
l::i
~
~
~
~
i,-i
<~L~ !
~
~
~ -
-
7
I
'" ~
/
i
/
" i " ~ --~ , --"P-~
,
/111
!
'
~-+---~<..'~.,~.,.--C7~o~ '< ~, ,
o~ o~
o°O~
\ i ~ .#. ,' " , ~
.__
21)
:A<<~-~"~, . , , "
i.~
-
~
"~.
'~
'
#
~L_L_
~1
"Ill
o:~:'~"~ - i ' o ' i
"-/o~ , ~." *\ , ; ~*
' ~ ,
•
~
~
I
i
i ~ LiP ' ~.~b.¢',/9
~
I
11# ''~ , '
l i V ~,:'~.~,"r.
' ,', ,' ,' ~
A.
~1o,...>
">~z / o~ " * _
°O~
•
"~
"
?
~
';
i
\: I
, ,.x , ~ ! ~ Z : / ' 7 '%
--
~--o
~
: - ~
,.s~ll
i
,\
,
ii
.
[
,
~\,
,\, ..+ "v-Gb% I - , . ; ; \ " "; PA' <::> ~ ' - < \ " " i . ~ ,\ ,~ c< ..,. "..~.~<..\, " < \ ~r,~ -<
~
ix.
~
,\,
,
~x
\ ~
0
%
%
©
0
~,\:\I\ "-l~'i
9--' 0 .-~
l.i..
il
Q:: ~..
J
[
• ~
£ o
~J_
ba
.
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOV~d,~
202
equilibrium only if the partial oxygen pressure has a definite value, is very important for the production of these materials. On the other hand, when cooling the material rapidly or under equilibrium conditions in a controlled atmosphere to room temperature (or more precisely to temperatures at which the ionic diffusion is ineffective) we can preserve the original spinel structure even at this temperature under non-equilibrium condition, e.g. in air.
1.4. Crystal field and covalency With respect to the magnetic properties the interest is primarily in transition metal ions, particularly those of 3d" group (table 6). The outer d-electrons of these ions may be regarded as practically localized in almost all oxide spinels so that the crystal (or better ligand) field theory applies. From the energy spectra determined by this theory the low lying levels are decisive for the magnetic behaviour. Note that the origin of the ligand field splitting of levels is to be seen in both the electrostatic crystal field and the covalency between the cation and the surrounding anions (ligands). Both these effects also contribute to the stabilization of cations in the given surrounding (crystal or ligand field stabilization energy = lowering of the ground level with respect to the ground level of the free ion). Although the local symmetry is trigonal in octahedral sites (point group D3d) and cubic in tetrahedral ones (point group Td), the prevailing part of the ligand field in both cases is cubic (point group Oh and Td, respectively). As a rule, the cubic ligand field strength, which is characterized by the cubic field splitting parameter A = 10Dq, corresponds to the so-called intermediate ligand field: it is weaker than the correlation between equivalent d-electrons but definitely stronger than the spin orbit coupling, i.e., /~correl > A >
AL_ S .
The only exceptions exhibiting characteristics of the "strong" crystal field (low spin state) are Co 3+, possibly Ni 3+ and the ions from the 4d n group. The splittings of the ground state terms of ions d" in the intermediate octahedral cubic fields are shown in fig. 9; in the tetrahedral case the sequence of levels is reversed which corresponds to A < 0. In table 7 the experimental data on the splitting parameter A in both B and A positions for various ions and spinels are summarized; for comparison and/or completion the data of some other oxides are included. The trigonal field in the octahedral positions leaves the orbital doublet in fig. 9 unsplit while the triplets T are split into a doublet and singlet. It depends on the type of ion and possibly, on other circumstances which of them is lower. The singlet is usually lower for Fe 2+ and the doublet for Co 2+. Note that this does not automatically apply to other structures, e.g. garnets. The splitting by the trigonal component of the ligand field in spinels is about one order of magnitude smaller than that in cubic field. Unfortunately, there are only few experimental data available; the examples are given in table 8. Sometimes they have been estimated
OXIDE SPINELS
203
i 6Dq
' 4Dq 7"29(3) I
-4Dq k i d ~and d~
T2y(3)
-6Dq
*I
E9(2) d~and d 9
A~9(1)
/
12Oq ~ 2Dq 729(3) Ii -6Dq
*
d2and d 7
t-I
i 5Dq
t -I
I
T~9(3)
~9(3)
i - 12Dq v
~g(3) A2g(O
d 3 and d 8
Fig. 9. Splitting of the ground multiplets of 3d" ions in octahedral field. The orbital degeneracy is given in parenthesis.
in a more or less indirect way, e.g., using the temperature dependence of the nuclear quadrupole splitting which, for ions with L > 0 , reflects the spatial distribution of the electronic cloud (EibschLitz et al. 1966). In the presence of the Jahn-Teller ions (see section 1.6) the local symmetry may be tetragonal in both types of sites. This symmetry splits both the E doublets and T triplets. The latter is split similarly as in a trigonal field, i.e., into a doublet and a singlet. If the symmetry is orthorhombic, the T level is additionally split so that only singlets appear. Note that due to partial disorder (inverse spinels, solid solutions) the local fields often possess fluctuating components with lower symmetries. In early work on d-level splitting in insulators only the effect of electrostatic crystal field was considered. This leads among others to the conservation of the centre of gravity of the split d-levels which makes it easy to determine the crystal field stabilization in terms of 10 Dq (Dunitz and Orgel 1957, McClure 1957). This was frequently used in evaluating the relative preferences of cations for A and B positions in spinels (section 1.5). It appeared, however, that this simple picture is inadequate because it entirely neglects the covalency whose effect has been shown to be of comparable magnitude. Due to covalent mixing of states the centre of gravity of 3d levels is generally shifted upwards, while the energy of the (p, s) valency band is lowered (fig. 10). As a consequence, a contribution to the stabilization energy appears which is difficult to estimate (Goodenough 1963, Blasse 1964).
204
S. KRUPICKA A N D P. NOV/kK
e-,
..,.d ©
~
cq
t.-,
.t::l
II
II
~D
° ° ~', t"q ¢q
¢q
I
I
[
II
II
,...,
t'q
-'T I
E
I
I
I
I
I
I
©
v~
.% +
©.--,
+
+
+
O
~D
% re)
o
I
0"5
~
+
OXIDE SPINELS
205
[~ ~
~.~
t"q
r.i
dd
Z ~5 ~
t"¢3
r¢3
.~
,~
~5
206
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOV~J( TABLE 8 Trigonal field splitting of energy levels of Cr 3+ and Fe 2+ ions. Parameters v, v' are defined in the usual way: v = (t2gA] Vtrigltzga) - (t2gE[Vtriglt2gE); I)' = (t2gE] VtriglegE). The splitting of the ground state triplet T2g of Fe 2+ is ~v, while for Cr3+ the splitting of 4T 1 is ~'~'I/9+ /)t and that of 47"2is -~v/2 (excited states). Ion Cr3+ Cr 3+ Cr3+ Fe z+
Spinel MgA1204 ZnGa204 Li0.sGazsO4 GeFezO4
o (cm-1)
v' (crn 1)
Ref.
- 200 -650 -400 - 1145
- 1700 -1100 2400
1 2 3 4
1. Wood, D.L. et al., 1968, J. Chem. Phys. 48, 5255. 2. Kahan, M.H. and R.M. Macfarlane, 1971, J. Chem. Phys. 54, 5197. 3. Szymczak, H. et al., 1975, J. Phys. C8, 3937. 4. Eibsch/itz, H. et al., 1966, Phys. Rev. 151, 245.
2p 2s
without covaLency
~¢ith covatenoy
Fig. 10. Effect of the covalency on the energy levels of transition metal oxide (schematically). A p r o m i s i n g d i r e c t m e t h o d f o r d e t e r m i n i n g t h e r e l a t i v e p o s i t i o n s of t h e d l e v e l s in A a n d B sites of f e r r i m a g n e t i c spinels s e e m s to b e t h e p h o t o e m i s s i o n m e t h o d c o m b i n e d w i t h t h e m e a s u r e m e n t of e l e c t r o n spin p o l a r i z a t i o n ( A l v a r a d o et al. 1975, 1977).
1.5. C r y s t a l energy, c a t i o n distribution a n d site p r e f e r e n c e s T h e far l a r g e s t c o n t r i b u t i o n to t h e crystal e n e r g y in o x i d e spinels is t h e C o u l o m b e n e r g y of t h e c h a r g e d i o n s ( M a d e l u n g e n e r g y ) :
OXIDE SP1NELS
207 (4)
Ec = -(e2/a)AM,
where e is the charge of electron, a the lattice p a r a m e t e r and AM the Madelung constant. AM m a y be expressed as a function of the mean electric charge qA of the cations in A positions and of the oxygen p a r a m e t e r u. It was calculated by several authors (De Boer et al. 1950, Gorter 1954, D e l o r m e 1958, T h o m p s o n and Grimes 1977b) with slightly differing results. H e r e we give the formula based on the generalized Ewald method used by T h o m p s o n and Grimes (1977b): AM = AM(qA, U) = 139.8 + 1186A, -- 648332, --(10.82 + 412.2A, - 1903A ])qA + 2.609q~,
(5)
where au = u - 0 . 3 7 5 . The dependence of AM on qA for different values of the oxygen p a r a m e t e r u is given in fig. 11. With increasing AM the stability of the spinel increases. Therefore, owing to its dependence on qA, the Coulomb energy will generally play an important role in the equilibrium distribution of cations among A and B positions, even though in some cases other energy contributions may become important. The Born repulsion energy is difficult to estimate in a direct way and it is usually deduced from the simple oxide data (Miller 1959). The polarization energy appears as a consequence of the deformation of the spherical electron cloud of ions in the local electric field in the crystal. A t t e m p t s to calculate it in the classical way lead apparently to an overestimation (Smit et al. 1962, Smit 1968), so that only qualitative conclusions are usually used (Goodenough 1963). In the quantum mechanical picture it is difficult to distinguish this effect f r o m
o~
138LL
o
\pS \
i
0.3F5 0.3F8 0.381
134
- "
0,384 0.38F 0,390
130 -
2 % Fig. 11. Dependence of Madelung constant on the average ionic charge qA of A-site ions for several values of the parameter u.
208
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOV.Ad(
covalency. The last relevant contribution is the ligand field energy treated in the preceding paragraph. As already mentioned in section 1.2, the spinels may have various degrees of inversion, according to the formula MaM~-a [M>aM~+a]04. If the energy difference for two limiting cases 6 = 0, 8 = 1 is not very large, we expect the distribution of cations to be random at high temperatures (i.e. 6 = ½) due to the prevailing influence of the entropy term - T S in the free energy. When the temperature is lowered, the spinel tends to be more or less normal or inverse depending on the sign and amount of energy connected with the interchange of cations M, M' in different sublattices. The equilibrium distribution is determined by the minimum of the Gibbs free energy, i.e., dG dH d6 - d ~
dS T~=0.
(6)
If we restrict ourselves to the configurational entropy of cations and supposing total randomization in both sublattices, S may be approximated by S = Nk[-8
In 8 + 2 ( 6 - 1) l n ( 1 - 8 ) - (8 + 1) 1n(6 + 1)].
(7)
Defining further AP = d H / d 6 we find
8(1 +
6) _ exp(-AP/RT)
(l - 8) 2
(8)
which determines the equilibrium value 6 at the temperature T. Generally, Ap depends on 8 and frequently a linear expression A p = 14o + 1-116
(9)
is being used to describe the experimental results (fig. 12). Here, H0 and H0 +/-/1 may be interpreted as energies connected with the interchange of ions M, M' from different sublattices in the case of completely inverse and normal distribution, respectively. It may be shown that the linear dependence (9) is obtained when the short-range interactions between pairs of ions are considered (Driesens 1968). Sometimes, an entropy term - T S o is added to the exponent in eq. (8) (Driesens 1968, Reznickiy 1977). The representative values of /-/0, H1 are given in table 9. When Ap ~< 5 kcal/mol, a mixed type spinel is usually observed; otherwise the energy difference between normal and inverse structure is sufficient to attain the one o r the other in practically pure form. The achievement of the equilibrium depends on the rate of cation migration. As this is a thermally activated process, the time constant changes exponentially with temperature and if T ~< 500 K, the
OXIDE SPINEI~
209
o.J +8
o
Ng Fe20~
o
0
0.2
I
FO0
J
f
~
I
900
~
o
1100
13~00 r ~
Fig. 12. Dependence of the degree of inversion 6 on temperature. Data for MgFeaO4 are taken from Pauthenet and Bochirol (1951) (A), Kriessman and Harrison (1956) (rT), Mozzi and Paladino (1963) (©) and Faller and Birchenall (1970) (+), those for MnFe204 are from Jirfik and Vratislav (1974). The full lines correspond to formulae (8) and (9) with Ho, H1 given in table 9. For MnFe204 also the time t, necessary for establishing the equilibrium distribution of ions at given temperature, is shown.
•m i g r a t i o n b e c o m e s t o o slow to allow any o b s e r v a b l e c h a n g e in cation d i s t r i b u t i o n . S o m e t i m e s , t h e t e m p e r a t u r e d e p e n d e n c e of t h e m i g r a t i o n r a t e is so s t e e p that, d u e to t e c h n i c a l r e a s o n s , t h e 6 v a l u e s can b e v a r i e d o n l y in n a r r o w limits. This is t h e case, e.g., of t h e M n - F e spinels (Simgovfi a n d Simga 1974). T h e ~ v a l u e s a r e usually d e t e r m i n e d by diffraction m e t h o d s ( B e r t a u t 1951, Jirfik a n d V r a t i s l a v 1974), m e a s u r e m e n t s of t h e s p o n t a n e o u s m a g n e t i z a t i o n ( P a u t h e n e t a n d B o c h i r o l 1951), o r by M 6 s s b a u e r effect ( S a w a t z k i et al. 1969). It is i m p o r t a n t to r e a l i z e t h a t t h e e n e r g y A P c o n c e r n s t h e crystal as a whole. T h e m a i n c o n t r i b u t i o n s to A P c o m e f r o m t h e M a d e l u n g e n e r g y (4), B o r n r e p u l s i o n e n e r g y ,
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOV~K
210
TABLE 9 Values of H0 and H1 for some spinels. Spinel MgFe204 MnFe204 MgMn204 NiMn204
T (K) 573-1473 603-1443 T < 1050 298-1213
g 0.1 < 0.763< 0.78 < 0.74 <
6 < 0.28 6 < 0.94 6 < 0.99 6 < 0.93
/40 (kcal/mol)
/-/1 (kcal/mol)
3.83 0.4 10.3 3.64
-8.63 -8.1 - 18.4 -9.6
Ref. 1 2 3 4
1. Average value of /40, //1 taken from Pauthenet and Bochirol (1951), Kriessman and Harrison (1956), Mozzi and Palladino (1963). 2. Jirfik, Z. and S. Vratislav, 1974, Czech. J. Phys. B24, 642. 3. Manaila, R. and P. Pausescu, 1965, Phys. Status Solidi 9, 385. 4. Boucher, B., R. Buhl and M. Perrin, 1969, Acta Crystallogr., B25, 2326. and further, from polarization and ligand field effects. T h e attempts to explain the observed degree of inversion on the basis of only the M a d e l u n g energy have not been successful. T h e only conclusion we m a y draw on the basis of fig. 11 is a prediction that the stability of the normal structure increases with increasing u for 2-3 spinels and vice versa for 4 - 2 spinels. This m e a n s that the 2-3 spinels with largest bivalent cations (Mn 2+, Cd2+), as well as 4 - 2 spinels with smallest tetravalent cations (Si 4+, G e 4+) are expected to be normal in a g r e e m e n t with what has been f o u n d experimentally. In other (intermediate) cases such reasoning does not lead to satisfactory results which shows that other energy contributions b e c o m e important in controlling the equilibrium distribution of cations. T h e problem with all energies included is too involved to be solved without serious simplifications. O n the basis of systematic studies of cation distributions in various spinels it has been recognized early, however, that some regularities exist in them pointing to the possibility to connect the distribution to individual site preferences of cations. In such a case, the energy 2xP in eq. (8) could be expressed as a difference AP = P(M)- P(M')
(10)
of individual preference energies P of cations M and M'. O n c e P ( M ) was k n o w n for all relevant cations, the distribution of ions in arbitrary spinel could be predicted. T h e attempts were m a d e to determine P ( M ) s f r o m the ligand field stabilization (with or without covalency effects) (Dunitz and Orgel 1957, M c C l u r e 1957, Blasse 1964) and taking also M a d e l u n g and Born repulsive energies into account (Miller 1959, G o o d e n o u g h 1963). T h o u g h the latter p r o c e d u r e suffers from approximations that do not fully c o r r e s p o n d to the real situation, the results agree at least qualitatively with the experimental data. A n alternative a p p r o a c h was chosen by N a v r o t s k y and Kleppa (1967) based on empirical distribution data and t h e r m o d y n a m i c relations. T h e results of both procedures are c o m p a r e d in fig. 13. N o t e that the reliability of these data is better if they are applied to a definite class of spinels, e.g., the 2-3 type. T h e approximative character of the concept of
OXIDE SPINELS
211
/
3O P(H)
[k~at/~ot]
Phen0 mendo gioaL ~heory [26,21]/• /
•
+ Determined from / thermodynamic data [39] /
20
/
•
,
+
/
÷?~+~+--+ -10
/
/ \/\./jz
10
0
+ /
/
/
/
i
I
[
'
I
I
I :
I
Lri4t
E
:
',
,
:'Mn, 4 '
• GO 4* r--.~ 2, i
Fig. 13. Preference energies P. The cations are arranged according to increasing empirical octahedral site preferences (+). The approximate positions of several other ions within this sequence are indicated, as judged from the experimental distribution data.
individual preference energies may be seen among others from the fact that it requires /-/1 = 0 in eq. (9) in contradiction with experiment (table 9). Additional difficulties arise if the cations do not possess a fixed valency and/or in the presence of some short-range or long-range order. 1.6. O r d e r i n g a n d d i s t o r t i o n s
It follows from the preceding discussion that the spinels are often found with other than normal distribution of cations. When more than one kind of cations is present on an equivalent sublattice, a tendency generally exists to decrease the internal energy by ordering the cations. In most cases such ordering would be only short range, if any, but when the ratio between the numbers of different cations is suitable and if the corresponding energy gain is sufficiently large, a long-range order may develop. As a rule, some symmetry elements are lost and in most (but not all) cases the appearance of the superstructure destroys the overall cubic symmetry. The basic types of such ordering in spinels together with some of their characteristics are summarized in table 10. In all cases the main contribution to
212
S. KRUPI(~KA AND P. NOV~G( TABLE 10 Types of ordering in spinels.
Type
Sublattice
Characteristics
Symmetry* of ordered phase
1:1
A
Every ion M surrounded by four ions i~ and vice versa
F743m
Li0.sFe0.5[Cr2]O4
1: 1 a
B
P41 32
Zn[LiNb]O4
1: 1 fl
B
Immb
Zn[LiSb]O4
i :3
B
The rows of B-ions in [i10] and [110] have succession -M'-/('I'-M'- while those in [101] etc.-M'-M'-M'-M'Succession of (001) planes of B sublattice occupied alternatively by M' and l~I' ions In the [110] and [110] rows of B sites each fourth ion lVI', others M'
Example
(Fe304)
P43212
Fe[Li0.sFeLs]O4
* Symmetry of the ordered phase is taken from C. Haas, 1965, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 26, 1225.
t h e d r i v i n g f o r c e is b e l i e v e d to h a v e a M a d e l u n g c h a r a c t e r a n d t h e s t a b i l i z a t i o n of t h e s u p e r s t r u c t u r e s h o u l d t h u s i n c r e a s e with i n c r e a s i n g d i f f e r e n c e b e t w e e n t h e c h a r g e s of t h e i n e q u i v a l e n t c a t i o n s ( t a b l e 11). A n analysis, w h i c h is s i m i l a r to t h e o n e of e q u i l i b r i u m d i s t r i b u t i o n of c a t i o n s (section 1.5) c a n b e m a d e c o n c e r n i n g t h e t e m p e r a t u r e d e p e n d e n c e of o r d e r i n g . A t sufficiently high t e m p e r a t u r e s t h e e n t r o p y t e r m stabilizes t h e d i s o r d e r e d state. W h e n t h e s a m p l e s a r e q u i c k l y c o o l e d , this state m a y f r e e z e as t h e m i g r a t i o n of TABLE 11 Energy gained by ordering of cations (in units of eZ/a). The values which are taken from Blasse (1964), De Boer et al. (1950) and Gorter (1954) cannot be taken too literally. Being based on the point charge model they largely overestimate the real values. Type of ordering Difference of ion;s valencies
1:1; fl; B
1:3; B
I:I;A
1 2 3 4 5
1.0 4.0 9.0 16.0 25.0
0.7 2.8 6.3 11.2
0.5 2.0 4.5
OXIDE SPINELS
213
ions (which is necessary for the superstructure to appear) is negligible below 400°C. Consequently the spinels with the same composition may have profoundly different properties depending on their thermal history. A similar situation to that described above exists in magnetite Fe3+[Fe2+Fe3+]O4. H e r e the superstructure arises due to the ordering of the d-electrons of Fe 2+ and Fe 3÷ ions located at B sublattice. The activation energy is much lower compared to the case of ordering of different ions, the phase transition is sharp and appears at ~120 K. This transition attracted much attention during the last years (Evans 1975, Buckwald et al. 1975, Iida et al. 1977) and it turned out that it is much more complicated than originally proposed by Verwey and Haaijman (1941). In the oxide-spinels another type of ordering, called the cooperative J a h n Teller effect, is relatively frequently encountered. The necessary condition for this effect to appear is the presence of transition metal ions which have an orbitally degenerate electronic ground state (for the orbital degeneracy of electronic states see fig. 9). The interaction between the degenerate states and the lattice vibrations leads to an effective coupling between electronic states on different cations. When this coupling is sufficiently strong and the concentration of active cations exceeds a certain critical value, the electronic states order and simultaneously a structural phase transition from cubic to lower symmetry appears. The phase with lower symmetry is stable only below a critical t e m p e r a t u r e Tc. In most cases the system undergoes a first order transition at To, though a second order transition was also observed. The dependence of the order p a r a m e t e r c / a on the reduced tern-
,0
o -
o"-~ o
ok
E
L
.3
2. o5
0.15
2.85
;4
,5 o.2s
I
o
o.2s
I
o',s
/%
Ozs
Fig. 14. Temperature dependence of the ordering parameter se in some spinels exhibiting the cooperative Jahn-Teller effect. ~: is defined as the ratio (c/a - 1)r/(c/a - 1)0. The data are taken from McMurdie et al. (1950) (Fe0.15Mnz8504), Ohnishi et al. (1959) (CuFe204, CuFel.7Cro.304)and Pollert and Jirfik (1976) (CrMn204).
214
S. KRUPIOKA AND P. NOVAK
perature for some spinels is shown in fig. 14. A typical dependence of the lattice parameters c and a on the concentration of active cations is displayed in fig. 15. In the past much experimental and theoretical effort has been exerted in order to understand various aspects of the cooperative Jahn-Teller effect in spinels. For a review see Englman (1972), Gehring and Gehring (1975). In the B site, there are two ions (namely Mn > and Cu 2+) both having doubly degenerate ground state of Eg type, which exhibit the Jahn-Teller effect. The corresponding distortion is always tetragonal with c/a > 1. With the active cations in the A sublattice the situation is more varied. The cations with the triplet ground state TI(Ni>), Tz(CU 2+) as well as those with the doublet state E (Fe > ) give rise to the Jahn-Teller ordering, though in the latter case the effect need not be very much pronounced. Tetragonal symmetry with both c/a > 1 and c/a < 1 may occur and in mixed spinels Fe3-xCrxO4 and NiFexCr2 ~O4 an orthorhombic deformation was
I
I
0
9.4
0
9.3 0 2+
9.2
3+
3+
o
9.1 9 8.9 8.8
~.
Ucu h
+
Cltetray
o
C
o
u VI/3
o o
8.7
o o
8.6
o o
o
8.5
z~mo A
[]
[] D ° r l
z~
++ + +
8.4f
+ -I- .t-
8.3 82
+ + +
0
0:2
'
'
0:0
'
018
'
;
X
Fig. 15. Room temperature values of the lattice parameters in the spinel system (Holba et al. 1975).
~VInl+2xCr2_2xO 4
OXIDE SPINELS
215
observed. Data concerning the cooperative Jahn-Teller are summarized
effect in the binary spinels
in t a b l e 12, w h i l e t h e v a l u e s of t h e c r i t i c a l c o n c e n t r a t i o n
of active
c a t i o n s i n s o m e m i x e d s p i n e l s a r e g i v e n in t a b l e 13. W h e n t h e c o n c e n t r a t i o n o f t h e a c t i v e c a t i o n s is less t h a n t h e c r i t i c a l , t h e m a c r o s c o p i c s y m m e t r y is c u b i c , b u t still the local deformations connected with the Jahn-Teller effect persist (Krupi~ka et
TABLE 12 Cooperative Jahn-Teller effect in binary spinels.
Spinel Mn304 CdMn204 ZnMn204 MgMn204 CoMn204 FeMn/O4 CrMn204 7-Mn203 CuFe204* CuCr204 CuRh204 NiCr204 NiRh204 FeCrzO4 FeV204
Distribution of ions
Active ion
c/a
Tc (K)
Ref.
normal normal normal 0.78 < 6 < 0.79 normal 8 - 0.15 inverse uncertain 0.06 < 6 < 0.24 normal normal normal normal normal normal
Mn 3+ 03) Mn 3+ 03) Mn 3+ 03) Mn 3+ 03) Mn 3+ 03) Mn 3+ 03) Mn 3+ 03) Mn3+03) Cu 2+ 03) Cu 2+ (A) Cu2+(A) Ni 2+(A) Ni 2+ (A) Fe 2+(A) Fe 2+ (A)
1.162 1.191 1.142 1.15 1.15 1.045-1.064 1.049 1.16 1.06 0.913 0.91 1.04 1.04 0.986 1.014
1443 670 1298 1200 1173 470 569
1-5 2, 6, 7 1, 2, 8 3, 9 2, 3, 4 2, 10 11 12 14-16 13, 14 12 17 18, 19 20 21
633 903 833 275 360 135 127
* Samples rapidly quenched from high temperatures are cubic. 1. Romein, F.C., 1953, Philips Res. Rep. 8, 304, 321. 2. Sinha, A.P.B., N.R. Sinjana and A.B. Biswas, 1957, Acta Crystallogr. 10, 439. 3. Miyahara, S. and K. Muramori, 1960, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 15, 1906. 4. Wickham, D.G. and W.J. Croft, 1958, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 7, 351. 5. Brabers, V.A.M., 1971,J. Phys. Chem. Solids 32, 2181. 6. Robbrecht, G.G. and C.M. Henriet-Iserentant, 1970, Phys. Status Solidi 41, K43. 7. Day, S.K. and J.C. Anderson, 1965, Philos. Mag. 12, 975. 8. Nogues, M. and P. Poix, 1972, Ann. China. 7, 308. 9. Irani, K.S. et al., 1962, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 23, 711. 10. Finch, G.I., A.P.B. Sinha and K.P. Sinha, 1957, Proc. Roy. Soc. A242, 28. 11. Holba, P., M. Nevfiva and E. Pollert, 1975, Mater. Res. Bull. 10, 853.
12. Sinha, K.P. and A.P.B. Sinha, 1957, J. Phys. Chem. 61, 758. 13. Bertaut, E.F. and C. Delorme, 1954, Compt. Rend. 239, 504. 14. Ohnishi, H. and T. Teranishi, 1961, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 16, 35. 15. Bertaut, E.F., 1951, J. Phys. Rad. 12, 252. 16. Prince, E. and R.G. Treuting, 1956, Acta Crystallogr. 9, 1025. 17. Tsushima, T., 1962, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 17, Suppl. B-l, 189. 18. Miyahara, S. and S. Horiuti, 1964, Proc. Int. Conf. Magnetism, Nottingham, p. 550. 19. Horiuti, S. and S. Miyahara, 1964, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 19, 423. 20. Whiple, E. and A. Wold, 1962, J. Inorg. Nucl. Chem. 25, 230. 21. Rogers, D.B. et al., 1963, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 24, 347.
216
S. KRUPI~KA AND P. NOV~,K TABLE 13 Critical concentration of the Jahn-Teller ions in some spinel systems.
Spinel
Active ion
c/a for x > xt
xt
Ref.
Mn3+(B) Mn3+(B) Mn3+(B) Mn3+(B) Mn3+ (B) Mn3÷(B) Mn3+(B) Mn3+(B) Cu2+(B) Cu2+(B)
>1 >1 >1 >1 >1 >1 >1 >1 >1 >1
0.40 0.48 0.6 0.59 0.6 0.57 0.55 0.65 0.32 0.37
1 2 3 3 3 5 4 4 3 3
Cu2x+M2-+x[Cr3÷]O4 M = Mg, Co, Zn, Cd
Cu2+ (A)
<1
0.5
3
Ni~+Zn~+~[Cr3+]O4 Fe~+Co~2x[Cr3+]O4
Ni2+(A) Fez+ (A)
>1 <1
0.6* 0.7¢
6 7
3+ 3+ Mn2+ [Mnz~Cr2-2x]O4 3+ 2+ 3+ 3+ Mny2+ Fel-y[Fel-yFea+y-zxMn2x]04
Co2+[Co~+-2xMn~+]04 Mg2÷[Al~-+2xMn~+]O4 Zn x2+Ge4+x[MnZ+zxMn~+]O4 Co2+[Crz3+zxMn23+]O4 ZnZ+[Cr3-+2xMn3x+]O4 Zn2+f[ Fe 23+ - 2 x Mn3+~¢-~ 2xP.J4 3+ 2+ 2+ ' 2 + 3+ Fel-sCu8 [Cu2xNli-2x 8Fe1+8104 3+ 2+ 3+ 2+ 2+ Fe1-~Cu~ [Fel+sM~-2x-sCu2x]O4 M = Mg, Co
* extrapolated to 0 K ?for T - 9 0 K 1. Holba, P., M. Nevf'iva and E. Pollert, 1975, Mater. Res. Bull. 10, 853. 2. Brabers, V.A.M., 1971, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 32, 2181. 3. Goodenough, J.B., 1963, Magnetism and the Chemical Bond (Wiley, New York, London). 4. Shet, S.G., 1969, Thesis, Univ. of Poona. 5. Mansour, B. et al., 1973, Compt. Rend. 277, 867. 6. Kino, Y., B. Liithi and M.E. Mullen, 1972, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 33, 687. 7. Arnon, R.J. et al., 1964, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 25, 161. al. 1964, K u b o et al. 1969, K o z h u h a r et al. 1973). M o r e o v e r , the i n t e r a c t i o n b e t w e e n the J a h n - T e l l e r ions seems to lead to a clustering of these ions (Blasse 1965, K r u p i r k a et al. 1968, B r a b e r s 1971) at least in s o m e spinel systems.
2. Magnetic ordering Spinels r e p r e s e n t a classical e x a m p l e of a crystal structure allowing a special type of m a g n e t i c o r d e r called f e r r i m a g n e t i s m . Neglecting m i n o r differences we m a y consider all o c t a h e d r a l l y c o o r d i n a t e d cations to form o n e sublattice only (B) a n d similarly the t e t r a h e d r a l sites to c o m p o s e the o t h e r sublattice (A). T h e s e sublattices are crystallographically i n e q u i v a l e n t a n d if they b o t h c o n t a i n p a r a m a g n e t i c ions in sufficiently high c o n c e n t r a t i o n the f e r r i m a g n e t i s m (i.e. the antiparallel o r i e n t a t i o n of the two sublattice m a g n e t i z a t i o n s MA, M s ) m a y occur p r o v i d e d the i n t e r s u b l a t t i c e e x c h a n g e i n t e r a c t i o n s are a n t i f e r r o m a g n e t i c a n d some requirem e n t s c o n c e r n i n g signs a n d strengths of the i n t r a s u b l a t t i c e i n t e r a c t i o n s are
OXIDE SPINELS
217
fulfilled (see section 2.2). I n fact, spinels were the first materials where the existence of such magnetic ordering was recognized and for which the first molecular field theory was elaborated by N6el (1948). Until the discovery of ferrimagnetism the magnetic properties of the few magnetic spinels known, mainly those of magnetite, were classified as ferromagnetic. It was difficult, however, to understand the low magnetic moments and some other peculiarities of these materials, e.g., the deviations from the Curie-Weiss law (Serres 1932, Kopp 1919). The departures from a normal ferromagnetic behaviour were excellently explained by the N6el theory. If the magnetic cations occupy only one of the sublattices their magnetic moments usually order antiferromagnetically, though there are also some few cases of pure ferromagnetism.
2.1. Exchange interactions in spinels As already pointed out by N6el the cations in spinels are mutually separated by bigger anions (oxygen ions) which practically excludes a direct contact between the cation orbitals, making any direct exchange at least very weak. Instead of it, super exchange interactions appear, i.e., indirect exchange via anion p orbitals that may be strong enough to order the magnetic moments. It is well known that apart from the electronic structure of cations this type of interactions strongly depends on the geometry of arrangement of the two interacting cations and the intervening anion. Both the distance and the angles are relevant. A survey of the main super exchange interactions in spinels is given in fig. 16. Usually only the interactions within the first coordination sphere (both cations in contact with the anion) are supposed to be of importance and the others are often disregarded (see further). In the N6el theory of ferrimagnetism the interactions are taken as effective inter- and intra-sublattice interactions A-B, A - A and B-B. The type of magnetic order depends on their relative strength. The theory of super exchange interactions (Anderson 1959, 1963) and the semi-empirical rules of Goodenough (1958) and Kanamori (1959) yield some predictions concerning the sign and strength of the super exchange interactions. As they were originally formulated for the 180° and 90° configurations a direct application is possible only for the B-B interaction with the angle M-O-M' ~ 90° (table 14a). The case of the A-B interaction with the angle ~125 ° is more complicated. The usual way is to interpolate between the 180° and 90° case
6. AB(nn)
BB(nn)
AB(nnn) BB(nnn)
AA(nn)
Fig. 16. Main super exchange interactions in spinel structure.
218
S. K R U P I ( ~ K A A N D P. NOVi~d~[
T A B L E 14a Prediction of the exchange interaction for nn cation pairs in the B sublattice. d 3 - d3 d 5 - ds d 8_ d 8
tt or ]'$ * ]'~,weak
d ~- d 8 d 5 - d8 d 3- ds
~'~,w e a k I'1'or 1"$ ]'~weak
* Direct exchange between cations orbitals; it is of c o m p a r a b l e magnitude with the s u p e r exchange which is ferromagnetic here.
T A B L E 14b Prediction of the exchange interaction b e t w e e n cations in A and B sublattices. angle M - X - M ' A
B
180 °
90 °
d2 d5 d5 d5 d7 d7 d7
d3 d3 ds d8 d3 ds d8
i'J,weak ~t weak ]'~strong ]'J,strong T]'weak ~'~strong ~'~strong
]'$ or 1't w e a k t~,m e d i u m (weak) ]'~m e d i u m 1'$m e d i u m (weak) ]'$m e d i u m (weak) ~'~m e d i u m (weak) ]'~ or 1]'weak
125 °* uncertain I'$ (uncertain) ~'~ ]'$ T$(uncertain) ]'~, ]'~,
* Interpolation.
supposing that the change is smooth. This is indicated in table 14b for pairs of cations with the non-degenerate orbital ground state. If signs of the 180 ° and 90 ° interactions are opposite such interpolation does not give a definite result and the experiment is to be consulted. The A - A interactions are weak and do not influence the type of magnetic order as far as there is sufficient number of magnetic B ions. Quantitatively, the exchange interactions may be characterized by the appropriate exchange constants (integrals); usually the Heisenberg type isotropic exchange, ~ex = -- 2J~jS~Sj,
( 11)
between nearest neighbours is sufficient even though biquadratic exchange and sometimes anisotropic terms or exchange between more distant ions are also considered. The exchange integrals may be deduced from various experiments: directly from the paramagnetic resonance spectra and/or optical spectra of pairs of ions in diamagnetic host crystals; from the dispersion relations of magnons measured by inelastic neutron scattering; by analyzing the magnetic data, particularly the temperature dependence of the total magnetization and/or sublattice magnetizations. The most detailed results (obtained by EPR and optical investigations) have been published for Cr3+-Cr 3+ pairs in octahedral positions (fig. 17, tables 15(a) and (b)). The results obtained indirectly in magnetically concentrated systems have to be regarded with some caution because of the simplifications usually made (only nearest neighbour isotropic exchange, eq. (11), is considered, usually the molecular field approximation is used, often the collinear spin structure is assumed even when it is not fully justified etc.). Some of these results are listed in table 16.
OXIDE SPINELS
219
o Oxygen ions Bj
B2
Bo Fig. 17. Labelling of the B sites for table 15a.
TABLE 15a Bilinear exchange integrals for Cr3+ in ZnGa204 spinel according to Henning (1980). For labelling of the sites see fig. 17.
Pair
Distance (,~)
Exchange integral (cm-1)
Bo-B1 Bo-B2 Bo-B3 Bo-B4 Bo-B5 Bo-B6
2.947 5.104 5.894 5.894 6.589 8.335
-11.1 (5) -0.470 (5) -0.610 (5) -0.400 (5) -0.225 (5) -0.275 (5)
TABLE 15b Bilinear (J) and biquadratic (j) exchange integrals for nn Cr3+ pairs.
System Lio.sAlzsO4 MgA1204 Lio.sGaz.sO4 ZnGa204
Distance B0-B1 (A)
J (cm-1)
j (cm-1)
Ref.
2.79 2.86 2.90 2.95
-25 14.2 (10) -13.5 (5) 11.1 (3)
1.3 2.1 (7) -0.6 (13) -1.7 (4)
1 2 3 4
1, Szymczak, H. et al., 1973, Proc. Int. Conf. Magnetism, Moscow 1973, vol. 5, p. 425. 2. Henning, J.C.M. and H. van den Boom, 1977, Physica B + C 86-88, 1027. 3. Gutowski, M., 1978, Phys. Rev. B18, 5984. 4. Henning, J.C.M. et al., 1973, Phys. Rev. B7, 1825.
S. K R U P I C K A
220
AND
P. N O V A K
o I q
e'
b., O
,,-.¢
b,, 0a ui
~
b.,
=
~_o
~:~
I
<~.
o
<
< 0)
2 ~4,d ~D
.,=
t'-t"-
t--:
od
t'--
~. tq. c t",l t~
t-,¢-,: t ~
,4 '--~ r" ',1 ' ~
I
I I
I
e'.
t"- . ~
.=_. ~D
+
+
~+~+
~m+l t"-
ca
~.,
~+<
÷ ¢-i< m
O
O
(
cc la
~
(
C
© % ~+,4'
;:,..
¢~
~5
~t-.-
e,';
~5 ~e
.,I
,q
<
~=
..-
• 0a
OXIDE SPINELS
221
2.2. Magnetic ordering: theory
If both sublattices contain magnetic ions, the collinear ferrimagnetic arrangement (fig. 18(a)) occurs provided (i) the A - B interaction is antiferromagnetic and, (ii) each of the A - A and B-B interactions is either ferromagnetic, or antiferromagnetic but weak compared with the A - B interaction. This is a typical magnetic structure for many spinels, particularly inverted ferrospinels. The approximate behaviour of a ferrimagnetic spinel follows from the molecular field type theory given by N6el (1948). The molecular fields hA, hB acting on magnetic ions in A and B sublattices are sums of two molecular fields corresponding to inter-sublattice and intra-sublattice exchange, respectively:
hA = n(aMA -- MB), n> 0
(12)
hB = n(--MA + flMB), w h e r e MA, MB are the sublattice magnetizations and n, na, n/3 are the molecular field coefficients for A-B, A - A and B-B interactions respectively; they are related to the corresponding exchange integrals by,
n = NA 1 ~
--2Jo/(gAgBtz~),
j~A(i~B) na
= N A1
nfl = NB 1
(13)
E -- 2 J i j / ( g A l Z B ) 2 , jEA(i~j, iEA) E -j~B(i~j,i~B)
2Sij/(gBlzB)2 ,
where NA(NB) is the number of A(B) sites in the volume to which the magnetization is referred. For a description of the statistical behaviour of magnetic moments in both sublattices we have now two equations: IMAI = MAoBsA(gASAmBIH + hAI/kT),
IMBI= MBoBss(gBSB/~s]H + hsl/k T)
,
T a
b
c
d
Fig. 18. Basic types of the spin ordering in spinels: (a) Collinear ferrimagnetism (N6el configuration); (b) Canted ferrimagnetism (Yafet-Kittel configuration; (c) Antiferromagnetism; (d) Spiral structure.
222
s. KRUPICKA AND P. NOV,~K
that have to be simultaneously solved to obtain /]4fA, Ma and the total magnetization M = M A + MB as functions of temperature and magnetic field. Bs(x) is the Brillouin function. The main conclusions drawn from the solution are as follows: (i) In the paramagnetic region a hyperbolic dependence of 1/X on T,
1TX
O CA + Ca
;~ T- O"
(14)
is obtained instead of the Curie-Weiss law. In eq. (14)
0 = [CACB/(CA+ C B ) ] n ( - 2 + O~CAICB+/3CalCA), 0 '= [CACa/(CA+ Ca)]n(2 + a +/3), CA, Ca are Curie constants for the A and B sublattices respectively
CACa n2[Ca(1 + a ) - CB(1 +/3)12.
( - (CA + Ca) 3
(ii) The paramagnetic Curie temperature Tc following from eq. (13) for 1/X = 0, depends on all interactions present, viz. Tc = ½n{CAC~ + CB/3 + [(CAa -- CB/3)2 + 4CACB] 1/2} ;
(15)
(iii) For T < Tc, the temperature dependence of MA generally differs from
MB(T) which leads to a variety of possible types of temperature dependence M(T), depending on a and/3 (see fig. 19). Some of them are very different from the "normal" behaviour of ferromagnetics (non-monotonic curves, compensation point, etc.); (iv) At T = 0 the collinear ferrimagnetic arrangement (called often the Ndel configuration) with both sublattices magnetically saturated is predicted to be stable if c~ > --MB(O)/MA(O) and/3 > --MA(O)/MB(O). In other regions of the (c~/3) plane the simple theory predicts one or both sublattices to be unsaturated (partly or fully disordered). This conclusion has proved to be not correct due to the oversimplifications included in the model: (1) only two sublattices were considered instead of 6 (six cations in the primitive cell), and (2) the magnetic moments in each sublattice were a priori assumed to be parallel. The removal of the restriction (1) by Yafet and Kittel (1952) led to the so-called triangular arrangement (fig. 18(b)) in which the spins in one of the sublattices (say B) are canted and divided into two groups B1, B2 with opposite canting angles; the corresponding sublattice magnetization MB = MB1 + MB2 is then antiparallel to the spins in the other sublattice A. This configuration should have replaced the Ndel solution with one sublattice unsaturated. As shown by Kaplan (1960) and Kaplan
OXIDE SPINELS
223
/'4B
Ns
"K "~5
~g Of
c~p = i
/
~ y~///~/////////,, .
/
/
Paramagnetic region
Subtattice B unsaturated
Fig. 19. Division of (aft) plane into regions with different magnetic behaviour. For the ordered regions the type of the M ( T ) dependence is indicated. et al. (1961), h o w e v e r , it d o e s not r e p r e s e n t a state with m i n i m u m e x c h a n g e e n e r g y in cubic spinels, w h e r e o t h e r m o r e c o m p l e x c o n f i g u r a t i o n s of t h e spiral t y p e p o s s e s s i n g l o w e r e n e r g y exist (fig. 20). In t h e i r t h e o r e t i c a l study, which is u p to n o w t h e m o s t c o m p l e t e o n e c o n c e r n i n g t h e g r o u n d s t a t e m a g n e t i c c o n f i g u r a t i o n in spinels within t h e classical limit, e v e n r e s t r i c t i o n (2) was r e m o v e d . O n t h e o t h e r h a n d t h e A - A i n t e r a c t i o n s w e r e n e g l e c t e d a n d only n e a r e s t n e i g h b o u r inter-
U
8/9 2 o E
4
6
8
~I/E ' .......... I
10
12
14
,
EL Ua I
-20
K,TTEC
-60
-
80
LOWER BOUND
~
~
~
'
~
~
~
~
Fig. 20. Dependence of the normalized energy ~ = E / J ~ S A S B N of various spin configurations in spinel on the parameter u = 4JBBSB/3JABSA; after Kaplan et al. (1961).
224
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOVfid(
actions were taken into account. They also found an improved criterion for the stability of the N6el configuration as expressed by the critical value uo = ~ of a single parameter u = 4JBBSB/3JABSA describing the relative strength of the B-B and A - B interactions. For u t> u0 the collinear structure is expected to change continuously into a ferrimagnetic spiral (fig. 18(d)). Nevertheless, the Yafet-Kittel type configurations may become stable in tetragonally deformed spinels (Mn304, CuCr204). Note that in this case 5 generally different exchange integrals between nearest neighbour cations have to be considered (including JAA which is usually taken ~0). Even the collinear ferrimagnet may become canted under the influence of a strong magnetic field whose torque is sufficient to compete with the exchange torques. The effect was theoretically studied in the molecular field approximation (Tyablikov 1956, Schl6mann 1960) and it was found that two critical fields Ha = n ( M B - MA), /-/2 = n(MB + MA) exist so that the overall magnetization M is constant and equal to ]MB- MA] for H < Ha and equals MA + M~3 for H > H2. In the intermediate region M linearly increases with H. As the molecular fields are rather high for most of the ferrimagnetic spinels, this effect is expected to become observable only in the region of the compensation point, i.e., when MA --~MB.
2.3. Magnetic ordering: experiment The results included in this section are mostly based on direct neutron diffraction determinations of the magnetic structure and completed by magnetic measurements.
2.3.1. Spinels with one magnetic sublattice only If only the A sublattice is occupied by magnetic ions, an antiferromagnetic arrangement appears in all known cases. As JAA is small, the corresponding N6el temperature, TN, is l o w (table 17). Two sublattices A1, A2 with mutually antiparallel spin alignment were found to be identical with the crystallographical ones (section 1.1) (Roth 1964). The situation for spinels with magnetic ions in the B sublattice only is more complex. As pointed out by Anderson (1956) the octahedral sublattice possesses a peculiar topology which prevents a long range order to be stabilized by nearest neighbour (n.n.) antiferromagnetic interactions only. Hence the interactions between more distant ions have to be considered. A number of different arrangements may then appear as discussed by Plumier (1969), Aiyama (1966), Akino and Motizuki (1971) and Akino (1974). The complexity may be somewhat reduced if the symmetry of the crystal structure is lowered either by the cooperative Jahn-Teller effect or due to the magnetic interactions. Note that large single ion anisotropy of some ions (Co >, Fe E+, Ni 2+) may strongly influence the resulting magnetic structure; this is believed to be the case, e.g., for normal 4-2 spinels G e 4+ [M2+]O42-, M = Fe, Co, Ni (Plumier 1969). In few cases the ferromagnetic ordering occurs. Only typical examples with magnetic ions in B sublattice together with the relevant data are listed in table 18.
O X I D E SPINELS
225
T A B L E 17 Spinels with magnetic ions in the A sublattice only. The A - A interactions seem to be enlarged by the presence of the transition metal ions Co 3+, Rh 3+ in the B sublattice even though their spin is zero. Spinel
Tr~ (K)
Mn2+Al~+O4 * Mn2+Rh~+O4 Fe2+A13+O4* . Co2+Al3+O4 * Co 2+Rh 32+O4 Co2+Coz3+O4 Ni2+Rh3+O4 CuZ+Rh~+O4
6 15 8 4 27 46 18 25
~ga(K)
-25
- 30 -50 -20 -70
Ref. 1 2 1 1 3 2 2, 3 2
* 5 to 15% inverse spinel. 1. W.L. Roth, 1964, J. Phys. Rad. 25, 507. 2. G. Blasse, 1963, Philips Res. Rep. 18, 383. 3. G. Blasse and D.J. Schipper, 1963, Phys. Lett. 5, 300.
T A B L E 18 Spinels with the magnetic ions in the B sublattice only.
Spinel Mg2+[Cr~+]O4
Crystallographic structure
cubic at 10 K, weakly tetragonal at 4.2 K cubic at 77 K, Mg2+ [ V 3 + ] 0 4 tetragonal at 4.2 K tetragonal Zn 2+[Mn 3+]O4 cubic Zn2+[Fe3+]O4 cubic Gen+[Fe~+]O4 Ge 4+[Ni2+]O4 cubic 4+ cubic C u + [NI•2+ 1/2Mn3/2]O4 Cu +rM~2+ cubic [ N 1/2Mn 4+ 3/2J10 4
Magnetic structure
TN or Tc (K)
Ref.
complex antiferromagnet
-350
14
1
antiferromagnet
-750
45
1
antiferromagnet complex antiferromagnet antiferromagnet antiferromagnet ferromagnett ferromagnet
-450 -50 - 15 -6 -20 -75
200* 9 10-11 15 150 57
2 3 4 4, 5 6 6
* Different N6el temperature TN = 50 K was reported in ref. (7). t Magnetic moments of Ni 2+ antiparallel to the Mn 4+ moments. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
~9a (K)
Plumier, R., Theses, Paris 1968. Aiyama, Y., 1966, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 21, 1684. K6nig U. et al., 1970, Solid State Commun. 8, 759. Blasse, G. and J.F. Fast, 1963, Philips Res. Rep. 18, 393. Bertaut, E.F. et al., 1964, J. Phys. (France) 25, 516. Blasse, G., 1966, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 27, 383. Gerard, A. and M. Wautelet, 1973, Phys. Status Solidi a16, 395.
226
S. K R U P I C K A A N D P. N O V i ~ K
2.3.2. Spinels with magnetic ions in both subIattices The A - B interaction was always found to be antiferromagnetic. For many inverse or almost inverse ferrospinels this interaction is predicted to be strong (table 14b) and, accordingly, a collinear ferrimagnetism is expected to appear (section 2.2). This was confirmed experimentally-representative data are given in table 19. T A B L E 19 Examples of spinels with the collinear ferrimagnetic spin arrangement. riB(A) System
nB(B)
nB
theor,
neutrons
theor,
neutrons
theor,
neutrons
experiment
Fe3+ [Fe3+Fe2+]O4
5
5
9
9
4
4
4.03-4.2
Fe3+[Ni2+Fe3+]O4
5
5
7
5 (Fe 2.3 (Ni3+) 2÷)
2
2.3
2.22-2.40
Fe3+ [Li~.sFe~]O4
5
-
7.5
-
2.5
-
2.6
Mn0.98Fez0204*
5
4.99
9.74
9.72
4.74
4.73
4.52-4.84
* Partially inverse spinel with 6 = 0.13 (see Jir~ik, Z. and J. Zajf~ek, 1978, Czech. J. Phys. B28, 1315). A s s u m e d ionic distribution M n 2+ 3+ [Mn o. 3+13Fe3+ 2+13] 04. 0.85Feo.z5 1.74Feo.
When the A - B interaction becomes comparable with one (or both) of the intra-sublattice interactions the collinear structure is destabilized and complicated structures with canted spins are observed. Spiral structures were reported in several chromites and Yafet-Kittel-like structures in manganites, vanadates and some chromites (see table 20). In some of these compounds transitions between various spin arrangements have been observed. Note that the non-collinear structures may be also very sensitive to substitutions (Vratislav et al. 1977). T A B L E 20 Examples of spinels with the non-collinear spin structure. nB exp.
Low temperature magnetic structure
2.54
-1.88
Y-K-like structure in the B sublattice
1
2.52 (B1) 2.8 (B2)
1.02
-2.28
spiral in both A and B sublattices
2
2.44
5.88
3.44
0.2
spiral in the B sublattice
3
4.24
2.2
Y - K structure in the 13 sublattice
3
System
riB(A)
nB(B)
Mn304
4.34
3.64 (B1) 3.25 (Bz)
MnCr204
4.3
CoCr204
MnV204
nB N6el
-2.04
-2.74
1. Jensen, G.B. and O.V. Nielsen, 1974, J. Phys. C7, 409. 2. Vratislav, S. et al., 1977, J. Mag. Magn. Mat. 5, 41. 3. Plumier, R., 1968, Thesis, Paris.
Ref.
OXIDE SPINELS
227
A special group is formed by the inverse 4-2 spinels, examples being the titanates M2+[Ti4+M2+]O2 or stannates M2+[Sn4+M2+]O2- (for summary of experimental data see Landolt-B6rnstein 1970). In these compounds the spin moments are compensated at 0 K as far as the arrangement is strictly collinear. Nevertheless, finite magnetic moments may appear due to the unequal orbital contribution of the M 2+ ions in A and B positions. The measurements on ulv6spinel Fe2TiO4 indicate further a possibility of a weak ferromagnetic moment to appear due to a small canting of spins (Ishikawa et al. 1971).
2.3.3. The effect of diamagnetic substitutions In principle, diamagnetic ions may enter either one of the sublattices only, or both, depending on the relative site preferences of the ions present. The diamagnetic substitutions in A sublattice probably represent the most clear-cut case, the Zn substituted ferrites being a well known example. Because of JAA = 0 only the A - B interactions are effectively weakened. If the number of substituted ions is not too high, however, (usually up to 30 or 40%) the overall ferrimagnetic arrangement is not destroyed for T ~ 0 K even though some loosely bound spins may become locally canted or disordered at higher temperatures T < Tc. For larger substitutions the A - B interactions may become comparable to, or even weaker than the B - B interactions. In this way the collinear ferrimagnets often change to canted ones. Both local canting and long-range non-collinear structures were reported (e.g. Piekoszewski et al. 1977, Zhilyiakov and Naiden 1977 and the references therein), the interpretation of experimental results being, however, often controversial. Finally, above a certain critical concentration of diamagnetic ions both sublattices are practically decoupled and only the B sublattice becomes magnetically ordered (usually antiferromagnetically). While the diamagnetic substitution as a rule lowers the ferrimagnetic Curie temperature, the saturated magnetic moment at 0 K may increase. This is shown for Zn substituted ferrites in fig. 21. If the ferrimagnetic order could be retained even when approaching ZnFe204 the magnetic moment at 0 K should increase steadily up to the limit 10/ZB per molecule; the breakdown in the vicinity of 50% substitution may be interpreted in terms of spin canting mentioned above. For a more detailed description the statistical methods (Gilleo 1958, 1960, Rosencwaig 1970) originally developed for diamagnetically substituted garnets, may be used. Diamagnetic substitution in the B sublattice weaken both A - B and B-B interactions simultaneously and hence the collinear ferrimagnetic structure need not be so strongly affected, only Tc is always decreased. The examples often quoted are the A1 substituted ferrites (for experimental data see Landolt-B6rnstein 1970). As the net magnetization in simple ferrites is parallel to the sublattice magnetization MB, the B substitutions lower the saturated magnetic moment and a compensation point (M = 0) may appear. Note that the change in JBB/JAB and MA/MB ratios generally modify the form of the M versus T curve (see section 2.3.4). The lowering of the sublattice magnetic moments found in some neutron diffraction experiments (e.g. K6nig et al. 1969) may be due to the local spin canting.
S. KRUPICKA AND P. N O V ~ K
228
, , / 10
na
..-i~~
..>?.~C';" .-'S:"~JS:"
M
8
o~'g""" ~ o
o~ ' ' ; ' "
o~ . ~ - ' ~ o
% , /o.:>~o/o..~/
°\
\o
co
6
%
",o.
%
Ni"
\
- -
ob
o
ot~
oi~
MFe204
2
o.8
~.o
x
ZnFe204
Fig. 21. Dependence of the saturated magnetic moments of ZnxMl-xFe204 ferrites on x. Data are taken from Gorter (1954) (©) and Sobotta and Voitl~inder (1963) (+).
~"'+'°'~.o.~. X = '0 50 ~ O's
o' experi'men~al + at 90° K o a~ RT
o.. u
%\
J
emulg I 40 i.
o~ %
0--'°-oooQ "O,o\ ° \
so ~ + ° - o . o 0.50
\
%
½
"13.0
0
I
\
,or-----+.. "%. \ ~o4 }I,_ U.O,~/ ,~o,~°--o0.60 % \ \1 ~ ~'0 + ~0~0..~ o
0~0 ~o. o
-----÷000.00.75
'~" 0.~.0 ~ ~
"o,.~
o-~.o.~ ~O_o~O.~
0~--O--o.._o~2oZll ~--+o-o-o-o-o.o_o_o_o:oO~Oo~-/[ + o-o-o-o-o-o~ ~'~'O~o -,0 ~__._~_ ,~ o..O>° / -~-o........... -/ I .._...~.
_
x =/.00
-20 ~ + ' ° ~ 0 ~ 0 ~ 0 " 0 ~ 0
0
0.2
0.4
~_...o/
I
~°~
0.6
0.8
%
1,0
Fig. 22. Temperature dependence of the saturated magnetization of NiFe2-xVxO4 sYstem, after Blasse and Gorter (1962).
OXIDE SPINELS
229
2.3.4. Temperature and field dependences The constraint of antiparallel orientation of the sublattice magnetizations reduces the freedom of the individual m o m e n t s in a collinear ferrimagnet which results in deviations from the normal statistical behaviour as expressed by the Brillouin type t e m p e r a t u r e dependences of MA and MB. The same is of course true for the overall magnetization M = MB -- MA for which the different characteristic types of M = M ( T ) curves were predicted by the N6el theory (see fig. 19). All of these types were found experimentally. In fig. 22 the curves for the system of V substituted nickel ferrites are shown; all 3 types of M ( T ) dependence appear when the V content is gradually increased. A lot of neutron diffraction, M6ssbauer and N M R data are available concerning also the t e m p e r a t u r e course of i
1.0
1.0
-o "-, ~'o
~"
-,.\
0.8
~ % o
MB/M8 (0) 0.8
\~ xo
,xo 0.6
0.6
0.4
0.4
0.2
0.2 i
I
i
o12 o,~ o'6 o.8
~0
't 012 o'.~ o'.6 o18 1.o
7.0
r/rc i
1.0
Msms(# 0.8
-° ~'~o~
",oN,° o\
0.6
k o~ ~\°~ o
0.4
"~"b~'o
0.2
~o
o'.2 o'.4 o16 o.'8
,.o r/re
Fig, 23. Comparison ot experimental and theoretical temperature dependencies of Ms, MA and MB for the Li ferrite (Prince 1965). Full curves were obtained by taking the biquadratic exchange into account. Dashed lines correspond to the simple N6el model with the zero intra-sublattice exchange. Good agreement of the N6el model with the experimental Ms(T) may be also achieved if appropriate intra-sublattice interactions are assumed. Then, however, calculated Ma(T) and MB(T) for 0.4~ T/Tc ~ 0.9 are considerably smaller than those determined directly by neutrons (Prince 1964).
230
S. KRUPICKA AND P. N O V ~ K
individual sublattice magnetization (K6nig et al. 1969, Sawatzki et al. 1969, Prince 1964, Yasuoka 1962). Note that their interpretation in terms of molecular field coefficients usually leads to an overestimation of JAA; this difficulty may be removed, however, when biquadratic exchange is taken into account (see fig. 23). In spinels with non-collinear magnetic structure the canting angle represents the necessary additional degree of freedom for the system of magnetic moments to make their statistical behaviour Brillouin-like (within the limits of molecular field theories). For this it is irrelevant whether the non-collinearity is due to competing exchange interactions or induced by a strong external magnetic field. It holds also for all canted structures that the canting angle depends on the applied magnetic field, even for T ~ 0 K. As a consequence the net magnetization increases with increasing magnetic field even when technical saturation has been reached. This behaviour was experimentally found for many ferrimagnetic spinels possessing non-collinear magnetic structures, such as manganites, chromites and others, including systems with diamagnetic substitutions. Examples are given in fig. 24. Jacobs (1959) analyzed the data assuming a triangular spin configuration. He found for this special case that the increase of saturation magnetization at low temperatures may be related to the molecular field coefficient n/3 for the B-B interaction by the simple equation
AM
=
HintS.
(16)
The behaviour in the paramagnetic region was found to be similar in all ferrimagnetic spinels, and corresponds to the predictions of the N6el theory (eq.
(]4)). 560
[
.
.
.
520 L/" ° ~ ° - - ° - ,~.
.
.
.
°-- °~°~°~°--°
Mn Fe2 0,;
,7F°K
24O 200
za
160 _~/,~.... ~ ~
Zx
~'
~
z~ . . . . - - z a
4.2OK
(Mnj/c,'Aq
120 -I 80
a
[]
o
u~d u~
4.2 K
2'0 ~'o ~'o 8'0 ~'oo ~o ~4o (koe)
Fig. 24. Dependence of the magnetization on an applied magnetic field for three spinel systems (Jacobs 1959, 1960). While there certainly exists a non-collinear spin arrangement in Mn[FeCr]O4 and Mn[Cr2]O4, the spin structure of MnFe204 is not yet unambiguously determined.
OXIDE SPINELS
231
2.4. S p i n w a v e s
The simplest quantum mechanical approach to the ferrimagnetism in spinels uses the two sublattice model (Kaplan and Kittel 1953). As a consequence two magnon b r a n c h e s - o n e acoustical and one o p t i c a l - a r e obtained. An important result of this model is that for small values of the wave vector k, the energy of the acoustical magnons is quadratic function of k, E = if0 + ~ k 2 ,
(17)
with _ 2JAAS 2 + 4JBBS~ - I I J A B S A S B a2 ' 16ISA - 2SB[ where a is the lattice constant, JAA, JBB and JAB are the exchange integrals. The dispersion relation (17) yields the well known r 3/2 dependence of magnetization and specific heat at low temperatures M(T)/M(O)
~- 1 - ~'(3/2)0 3/2 ,
(18)
C~ -~ ( 1 5 / 4 ) k B [ M (O)/ ge~p.B];',(5/2)O 3/2 ,
with 0 = [g~dM(O)]3/2kBr/(4~), M (O) = Nola.B(gASa -- 2gBSB), ge~ = ( g A S A - g B S B ) / I S A - SBI ,
kB is the Boltzmann's constant, gA, gB are the g factors of magnetic ions in A and B sublattices respectively, No is the number of A cations, and ~'(x) is the Riemann ~" function. More sophisticated spin wave calculations in spinels (Kaplan 1958, Kowalewski 1962, Glasser and Milford 1963) take into account that there are six sublattices of cations (section 1.1). Accordingly six magnon branches appear. The quadratic form (17) of the dispersion relation for acoustical magnons still applies and therefore both magnetization and the specific heat should follow the r 3/2 dependence at low temperatures. Experimentally most attention was directed towards magnetite Fe304 where magnon dispersion curves were determined by several authors (Watanabe and Brockhouse 1962, Torrie 1967, G r o u p e de diffussion des neutrons 1970) (fig. 25) using neutron scattering. Some experimental data are also available for M n - F e (Wegener et al. 1974, Scheerlinck et al. 1974), Co (Teh et al. 1974) and Li (Wanic 1972) ferrites. By fitting the spin wave theory to these experiments the exchange
232
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOV~K 120
~
,
L
,
,
,
,
,
E
/~0v]
1o0 ~
90
* /-+~
50
/
40 %
20
o
-
o .+
o/+
30
10 4
(5)a.a(6)
0/4-
/
I
/ 0.2
&
o'6
o18
a__Eo[ool]
2IF
Fig. 25. Dispersion curves of spin waves in magnetite (six branches). Data taken from Groupe de diffusion des neutrons (1971) (+) and Watanabe and Brockhouse (1962) (©). integrals may be estimated. Both the sign and the magnitude of the inter-sublattice exchange integral obtained by such procedure agree with the expected ones (compare tables 14, 16). The same cannot be said about the intra-sublattice integrals-e.g, the ferromagnetic B-B coupling and rather large values of JAg were found in Fe304. Such contradictory results may be connected either with approximations made in the spin wave calculations (consideration of only isotropic bilinear exchange between nearest neighbours, introduction of effective exchange integrals etc.) or with insufficiency of the G o o d e n o u g h - K a n a m o r i rules. The T 3/2 dependence of the magnetization and specific heat predicted by the spin wave theory was observed in several ferrite systems (Kouvel 1956, Heeger and Houston 1964). An example of the results obtained is shown in fig. 26. Several authors reported the observation of spin wave resonance in single crystal (Ivanov et al. 1972, Baszynski and Frait 1976, Sim~ovfi et al. 1976) and polycrystalline (Gilbart and Suran 1975) spinel ferrite thin films. From the resonance fields the value of constant @ in eq. (17) may be determined. This procedure is somewhat obscured by the unclear way in which the spins are pinned at the surfaces.
OXIDE SP1NELS
233 T(K)
.~
50
(Mc/s) ~
o
100
158
200
'
'
'
800
1ooo
2400
250
3200
4000
r ½ (K3,~) Fig. 26. Temperature dependence of the Mn55 NMR frequency ~ in MnFe204 (Heeger and Houston 1964). ~, is propotional to the sublattice magnetization.
3. Magnetic properties 3.1. A n i s o t r o p y a n d magnetostriction 3.1.1. Introductory r e m a r k s The anisotropy constants are usually defined with respect to the free energy F of the system. For cubic symmetry,
(20)
F = Fo + K l s + K2p + K3s 2 + . • • ,
where 2 2 S = 0/la2-1-
2 2 2 2. 0/10/3"}- 0 / 2 0 : 3 ,
~2 2~2 p = tXl0/2~ 3 ,
a l , 0/2, 0/3 are the direction cosines of magnetization, and K1, K2, K 3 . . . are the familiar anisotropy constants. In addition, expressions corresponding to the tetragonal symmetry and sometimes-also to the orthorhombic one may be relevant to spinels,
F = Fo+ K l a n + K z a ~ + K3(a4+ 0 / 4 ) + . . .
(tetragonal),
(21) F = Fo + K l a ~ + K ~ ( a ~ - 0/~) + . • •
(orthorhombic).
There are several complications connected with such definitions of anisotropy constants. First, as a rule, the anisotropy is determined from measurements at constant temperature and external stress so that the experimentally determined K 1 , / £ 2 . . . refer to the Gibbs potential and not to the Helmholtz free energy. The difference between the two sets of constants is due to the magnetostriction. The
234
S. K R U P I O K A
AND
P. N O V / i d ~
detailed analysis as well as the formulae connecting Ki and /£~ are given, e.g., by Carr (1966). For cubic crystals, /£1 =
K1
+ h2(Cll - -
C12) - - 2 h 2 c 4 4 - 3hoh3(C~l + 2 c 1 2 ) -}- " • " ,
(22)
g 2 = K 2 - 3 h l h 4 ( C l l - c12) - 1 2 h 2 h s c 4 4 + • • • ,
where Cll, c12, c44 are the elastic constants and coefficients hi characterize the magnetoelastic coupling. To define hi the Gibbs free energy G is to be expanded in powers of the stress tensor 0-,
(23)
G=Go-A~-½~g~,
g being the elastic compliance tensor. The components of the tensor A are further written as series in powers of m , Ai~ = h0 + hl(O~ 2
- -
1) +
h3s +
h4(o¢ 4 +
2s/3
- 13) + "
",
(24) A i j = h2ofio~j + hsoqce].
The last two formulae yield the definition of the hi. The magnetostriction e in a direction specified by the direction cosines /31, /32, /33 is related to the tensor A through the relation e = ~'~ Aij/3i/3j.
(25)
/,j
Combining eqs. (24) and (25) the connection between the parameters hi, the commonly used magnetostriction constants A100, Aln is established, 3-100= 2 h i 3 ;
/~111= 2h2/3 .
h2
and
(26)
One point to note in eq. (22) is the t e r m - 3 h o h 3 ( c n + 2 c 1 2 ) which corresponds to the contribution of the isotropic strain. This correction depends upon the choice of the unstrained volume, in particular it vanishes if the state of zero volume stress is defined by setting h0 = 0. Some authors take as unstrained volume the volume of a hypothetical crystal with magnetic interactions switched off. Isotropic strain term may then contribute substantially to anisotropy, e.g., for synthetic magnetite Birss (1964) estimated this contribution to be - 2 8 % . The disadvantages of such an approach are: (i) constant h0 may be estimated only indirectly; (ii) it is difficult to determine h 3 with sufficient precision. It seems therefore more convenient to refer the free energy to the volume of the real (magnetized) crystal, in which case the contribution of the isotropic strain vanishes identically. The contribution of the anisotropic strain to magnetocrystalline anisotropy of spinels is, with few exceptions, small. The relevant data for several spinels are given in table 21.
OXIDE SPINELS
235
TABLE 21 Magnetostrictive contribution AK~ to the first anisotropy constant. Temperature (K)
K1 x 10-5 (erg/cm3)
Fe304
300
- 1.1
Li0.sFe2.504
300
-0.9
0.004
300 77
-0.7 5.8
0.053 52
System
(disordered) NiFe204 TiFe204
AK1x 10 s (erg/cm3) - 0.24
The second complication in defining the anisotropy constants is connected with the possible dependence of the magnitude of magnetization on its direction with respect to the crystallographic axes (anisotropic magnetization). Effectively it leads to the dependence of anisotropy constants on external magnetic f i e l d - for a corresponding analysis see, e.g., Aubert (1968). Up to now the experimental results in spinels were analyzed without taking this contribution into account. Finally, note that in the presence of the relaxation effects (section 3.3) the anisotropy measured by static methods generally differs from the one determined by FMR. In the following two subsections the microscopic origin of the anisotropy and magnetostriction will be discussed. A survey of the experimental data will be given in the Appendix.
3.1.2. Microscopic origin: anisotropy The dominant source of the magnetocrystalline anisotropy in spinels is to be sought in the interplay of the ligand field, spin-orbit coupling and the exchange interaction of the magnetic ions. The magnetic dipole-dipole energy may also contribute in tetragonal or orthorhombic spinels. In most cases the single ion model (Yosida and Tachiki 1957, Wolf 1957) is sufficient to describe semiquantitatively the magnitude and temperature dependences of the anisotropy constants K1, K2. In this model the magnetic ions contribute additively to the macroscopic anisotropy effects; their interactions are approximated by effective fields (ligand and exchange) and the anisotropy appears as a result of the dependence o f their individual energy levels on the direction of magnetization. T o deduce the low lying levels (i.e. those which may be thermally populated) the properly chosen effective Hamiltonian is usually used. For ions with orbitally non-degenerate ground states this reduces to the familiar form of the spin Hamiltonian (S ~<~): 1 4 4 1 = IXBHexgS+D[S}-½S(S+ 1)] +~a[S~ S z4 - ~S(S + S,+ + 1)(3S 2 + 3 S - 1)]
+ ~6F[7S~- 6S(S + 1)S~ + 5 S ~ - 6S(S + 1) + 3S2(S + 1)2].
(27)
This Hamiltonian applies to a cubic crystal field (axes x, y, z) with an axial (e.g.
236
S. KRUPI(~KA AND P. NOV/~G(
trigonal or tetragonal) component along axis (. It may be used, for the 6S ions Fe 3+ and Mn 2+ (S = I) and also for Mn a+ and Fe z+ (S = 2) in octahedral coordination supposing that the splitting by the crystal field of lower symmetry results in an orbital singlet ground state. For S ~<-~the quartic terms with constants a and F can be dropped out of the spin Hamiltonian. The possible anisotropy of the g tensor corresponds to the anisotropic exchange interactions. For ions with orbitally degenerate ground state the effective Hamiltonian contains the terms depending on the orbital momentum and in general its form is more complicated compared with eq. (27). The ions, which in cubic symmetry have the orbital triplet lowest, were treated, e.g., by Slonczewsk! (1958), Baltzer (1962) and Novfik (1972). As an example we quote the effective Hamiltonian corresponding to Co 2+ ion situated at the B site of the spinel structure (only the most important terms are retained): E{ =
oqA6Sz + a±A(lxSx + lySy) + DI~
+
(28)
g~BtIexS.
Here ! = - a L is the pseudoangular momentum (1 = 1), z is the trigonal axis, the term Dl 2 reflects the presence of the trigonal crystal field. For Co 2÷ ion D is negative; this corresponds to a situation where the trigonal field splits the ground orbital triplet into lower doublet and higher singlet. The orbital moment is not quenched but it is confined to lie along the local trigonal axis. Due to the spin-orbit interaction the spin is then also coupled to the trigonal axis (see fig. 27), which is the source of the large single ion anisotropy. To obtain the single ion contribution ki(T) (i = 1, 2 . . . . ) to the cubic anisotropy constants Ki the free energy per ion is to be evaluated using the partition function relevant to the energy spectra of the effective Hamiltonian (Wolf 1957, Yosida and Tachiki 1957, Slonczewski 1958). For microscopic theory to be compatible
~rig
%
g
fl
•¢.__.~t xx/
Exci~ed sfa~e
~xGround ,
0 a
:El2
0
YC
b
Fig. 27. Origin of the anisotropy due to the B site Co2÷ ion. (a) Coupling of the spin of Co 2+ to the local trigonal axis. Co) Dependence of the lowest two levels of Co2+ on the angle between magnetization and the trigonal axis (assuming /zBH~x>>spin--orbit coupling). The effect of higher order terms is indicated by weak lines.
OXIDE SPINELS
237
with the macroscopic description put forward in section 3.1.1 (i.e. with /(i corresponding to the Gibbs free energy) the terms depending on strains must be added to the Hamiltonian (see section 3.1.3, eq. (30)). Note that averaging over inequivalent sites must be performed when calculating ki(T). In the cases where the Hamiltonian (27) applies the contribution to the cubic first anisotropy constant is (with the F term neglected): kI(T) = at(y) + 7[DE/(kT)]t(y),
(29)
where y = exp[-glzBHex/(kT)], r(y) and t(y) are functions depending on S (Wolf 1957), and 3/ is a constant which equals 4 for ~"--- [111] (four non-equivalent axes) and - ~ for ~--- [100] (three non-equivalent axes). The latter may be, e.g., the case in the presence of the local Jahn-Teller distortions. For T ~ 0
k~(O) = -½S(S - 1)(S - 1)(S - ~)a + 23,S(S - ½)(S - ~)D2/(glXBHex), so that for ions with $ 4 3 the a term does not contribute to anisotropy. The temperature dependence (29) may be fitted to the experimental curve KI(T) to evaluate the constants a, D, gHex (see figs. 28(a) and (b)). On the other hand these values may be compared with those deduced from an independent experiment (most often E P R in doped diamagnetic crystals) or estimated on the basis of the ligand field theory. In many ferrimagnetic spinels, in particular ferrites, the first term in eq. (29) was found to predominate (Yosida and Tachiki 1957, Wolf 1957). The second term becomes important if either S ~<3 or the ratio D2/gtZBHex is of the same order of magnitude as a. The representative values of the parameters D, a and F are given in table 22. The one ion character of corresponding contributions to the anisotropy is illustrated in figs. 29(a) and (b). The anisotropy contribution of ions with the orbitally degenerate ground state is considerably greater as a rule. The most often encountered example is that of Co 2+ in octahedral positions mentioned above. It is well known that even very small concentration of Co in magnetite or in other ferrites substantially influences their anisotropic behaviour (figs. 30(a) and (b)). The analogous model is believed to apply also to V 3+ ion in the B sublattice. For Fe 2+ ion the trigonal field in the B site usually splits the ground triplet into lower singlet and higher doublet, so that the conventional spin Hamiltonian (27) may be used. The ions Mn 3+ and Cu E+ which possess doubly degenerate ground state Eg in octahedral symmetry exhibit a strong Jahn-Teller effect (section 1.6). This, combined with presence of the local strains, leads to lowering of local symmetry and to splitting of the ground doublet so that eq. (27) applies as well. From ions in tetrahedral sublattices which have an orbitally degenerate ground state the case of Ni 2÷ ion was discussed in detail (Novfik 1972, Pointon and Wetton 1973). The single ion anisotropy is strong here though the spin-orbit coupling contributes to it only through the second order terms of perturbation theory.
238
S. KRUPIOKA AND P. NOV~d4 I
i
i
I
i
I
I
I
I
a
o.oO/°~°~
-s~
-I0~
-
:< ::;;i;:'o,:
150 [
0
100
I
I
200
I
I
300
I
I
400
I
500
T(K)
oo -to
too 3~/
T(K) 20o 3oo___ x~(Fe3+)
I// ~ -30t~ °
-5o~
o o o Experiment x = 1.55
b
Fig. 28. Two examples of the determination of the spin Hamiltonian parameters by fitting the theoretical Ka(T) dependence to the experimental data. (a) Li0.55Fe2.4504 (Follen 1960). S is the order parameter, i.e., S = 1 (0.1) corresponds to ordered (almost disordered) Li ferrite. Resulting spin Hamiltonian parameters are a(Fe~+) = 0.024 cm 1, a(Fe~+)= -0.012 em 1. (b) MnL55Fel.4504 (Krupi6ka and Novfik 1964). Parameters a(Fe3+) = 0.012cm -I, tzBHex(Mn~+)=28cm a, D(Mn3+)= _1.77cm-1. The D value is to be taken as the effective one due to the non-collinear spin structure; the corrected value is D = -2.8 cm 1.
3.1.3. Microscopic origin: magnetostriction In p r i n c i p l e t h e m a g n e t o s t r i c t i o n m a y b e u n d e r s t o o d u s i n g H a m i l t o n i a n s a n a l o g o u s t o eqs. (27) a n d (28), t o w h i c h t h e e l a s t i c e n e r g y of t h e c r y s t a l is a d d e d . T h e p a r a m e t e r s of t h e e f f e c t i v e H a m i l t o n i a n s a r e t a k e n to b e f u n c t i o n s o f strain, b u t u s u a l l y o n l y c o n s t a n t t e r m s a n d t e r m s l i n e a r in strain a r e r e t a i n e d . F o r i o n s w i t h
239
O X I D E SPINELS
0.1
-5
0.15
0.2
6"
• 4.2K • 77K
-10 K,
-15
i
i
°/°/°/
"-E" 0.1 o
E ,
0.05
0
i
\o ~ _ . 1
0.3
0.2
,~
0'.4-
-0.05 Mn3+
-0.
o
b
\
Fig. 29. Additive character of the single ion contributions to anisotropy. (a) Dependence of KI on the inversion degree 6 in MgFe204 (Arai 1973). (b) MgxMn0.6Fez.4-xO4 (Gerber and Elbinger 1970). 2+ 3+ Anisotropy contributions AK~(FeB ) and AKI(MnB ) are shown as functions of concentration A~ in the molecule of Fe2+ and Mn3+ at temperature T ~ 0.
an orbital singlet g r o u n d state the r e l e v a n t effective H a m i l t o n i a n m a y b e w r i t t e n in t h e form (Callen 1968):
011) Se, ix,] Y~ = Y((e = O) + ~,~' ~_, [ S ~ O (gH¢x)eix,., + S aeix~, + fourth o r d e r terms + 1 ~ cm,e 2gix .
(30)
tx
H e r e YC(e = 0) is the spin H a m i l t o n i a n (27). T h e q u a n t i t i e s OD/Oe,,, form a fourth r a n k tensor, which in cubic (trigonal) local s y m m e t r y has 9 (18) i n d e p e n d e n t components.
240
S. KRUPI(~KA AND P. NOV,~K
25 -ff-~
-
co .,j °
M~
15 _ 10
~NiZn
~~MgFe,
\
FeNiZn
5 0
50
100
150
200
250 300 T(K)
~0
,,,,
(~m-,)
5O 40, 30
~izn ',, .... \
Ni ~. X',
\ \
20 10 s~
16o
I~o
eoo
2so
so0 T (K)
Fig. 30. Co 2÷ contribution to Kl(a) and K2(b) for various ferrites of composition Mel-xCoxFe204 (Broese van Groenou et al. 1968). The symbols indicate the host ferrite as follows: Fe: Fe304, Mn: MnFe204, MnTi: MnTio.1sCoo.15Fei.704, MgMn: (Mgo.TsMno.25)Mno.29Fel.7104,MgFe: (Mgo.9~Feo.09)Coo.olFel.9904,Ni: NiFe204, NiZn: Nio.67Zno.33Fe204, NiZnFe: (Nio.46Zno.29Feo.25)Fe204, Co: CoFe204.
OXIDE SPINELS
241
g-.
0
=8~dZ~o_' o ,,0.001
g--,
-40
~7
-80
'
2x
0.003 3 -0.005
•~ -120
-
160
C Fig. 30c. Dependence of AK1 and AK2 on cobalt content in ordered samples of Lio.5-xl2Fezs-xlzCOx04 (Seleznev et al. 1970) (1) 4.2 K; (2) 77 K; (3) 300 K.
There is an important distinction when calculating magnetostriction in comparison with the determination of a n i s o t r o p y - namely in cubic systems the terms bilinear in spin ( - - O D / O e ~ K ) contribute to magnetostriction constants already in the first order of the perturbation theory. The same holds for the dipole-dipole interactions, which consequently must also be considered. On the other hand the bilinear terms are as a rule much larger than the fourth order terms, and the latter may therefore be neglected. Given the form of the spin Hamiltonian (30) the calculation of the magnetostriction proceeds similarly as the one of anisotropy. Broadly speaking two types of contributions may be distinguished: (i) the single ion terms, (ii) two ion terms. To the second category belongs the contribution of the dipole-dipole interaction (table 23); this may be determined without difficulty once the lattice geometry, magnitude of the magnetic moments and the elastic constants are known. Much more complicated is the reliable calculation of the single ion contribution. Here the main obstacle is the determination of the derivatives OD/Oe~,,. In principle relevant information may be obtained from E P R under pressure; however, no such experiments have been yet performed in spinels. Moreover, an assumption must be made that the local elastic properties are the same as the macroscopic ones. An empirical way of determining the single ion contributions to magnetostriction in spinels was worked out by Arai and Tsuya (Arai and Tsuya 1973-1975, Arai 1973). These authors used the measurements of magnetostriction
S. K R U P I C K A A N D P. N O V f i d (
242
T A B L E 22 Values of the spin Hamiltonian parameters.
System
Ion
ZnGa204 ZnAl204 MgA1204 Li0.sAlz504 ZnAI204 ZnGa204 ZnAI204
Fe~÷ Fe 3+ Fe 3+ Fe~+ M n ~+ Cr 3+ Cr 3+
MgxMn0.6Fez4-x O4
Fe~+ Mn 3+ Fe~+
( a - F ) x 102 (cm -I)
a × 102 (cm -1)
3.53 4.71 4.58 _+1.66 -
4.44 5.75 4.77 1.0" 0.075 -
D (cm -~) -0.2442 -0.3402 -0.2467 0.104 0.524 0.891
2.0
Ref.
Method
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
EPR
8 3 (3.5,-4.0)
Anisotropy
MgFe204
Fe 3+ Fe~+
2.9 - 1.8
9
Li0.sFe2.504
Fe~+ Fe 3+
2.4 - 1.2
10
* Preliminary result. 6. Kahan, H.M. and R.M. Macfarlane, 1971, J. Chem. Phys. 54, 5197. 7. Drumheller, T.E. and K. Locher, 1964, Helv. Phys. Acta 37, 626. 8. Gerber, R. and G. Elbinger, 1970, J. Phys. C3, 1363. 9. Arai, K.I., 1973, Rep. Res. Inst. Electr. C o m m u n . T o h o k u Univ. 25, 79. 10. Folen, V.J., 1960, J. Appl. Phys. 31, 166S.
1. Krebs, J.J. et al., 1979, Phys. Rev. B20, 2586. 2. Gerber, P. and F. Waldner, 1971, Helv. Phys. Acta 44, 401. 3. Brun, E. et al., 1961, C.R. Colloque A M P E R E 10, 167. 4. Folen, V.J., in Paramagnetic Resonance, vol. 1, ed. W. Low (Academic Press, New York, 1963), p. 68. 5. Soulie, E. et al., 1973, Solid State C o m m u n . 12, 345.
T A B L E 23 3 3 Magnetoelastic coupling constants L = -gA~00(cll - ca2) and M = -gAulC44; the calculated dipole~zlipole contribution is to be subtracted from the experimental value to obtain a contribution due to other mechanisms (single ion). L (cm-I/molecule)
System MnFe204 Fe304 CoFe204 NiFe204
Calculated dipole~tipole coupling -
14 12 l1 10
M (cm-1/molecule)
Measured coupling
Calculated dipole-dipole coupling
Measured coupling
15 12 300 27
6.5 8 7.5 7
-4 -69 - 150 19
OXIDE SPINELS
243
on Mg ferrites with different degree of inversion to determine the single ion contributions of Fe 3~ ion in both A and B sublattices (the dipole-dipole interaction was taken into account by subtracting its contribution f r o m the experimental results). Supposing that the Fe 3+ contribution is the same in various spinels the single ion contributions of Cu 2+ (Arai and Tsuya 1974) and Ni 2÷ (Arai and Tsuya 1975) ions were d e t e r m i n e d from m e a s u r e m e n t s on CuFe204 and Nil-xZnxFe204 spinels respectively. These results are s u m m a r i z e d in table 24. Ions with an orbitally d e g e n e r a t e g r o u n d state have a m o r e direct coupling between the lattice and magnetic m o m e n t s and the corresponding contribution to magnetostriction is large. Similarly, as with anisotropy, most attention was d e v o t e d to the octahedral C o 2÷ ion (Slonczewski 1960, G r e e n o u g h and Lee 1970). T o calculate the contribution of Co 2÷ ion to magnetostriction the elastic energy and a term ~_~ V ~ , e ~ , , ix,t~,
which describes the change of the ligand field induced by strain is a d d e d to Hamiltonian (28). T h e r e are only a few i n d e p e n d e n t matrix elements of V,~,; using s y m m e t r y a r g u m e n t s and making some approximations in the calculation of the e n e r g y levels their n u m b e r is r e d u c e d to two. Leaving these two p a r a m e t e r s free and changing the o t h e r p a r a m e t e r s of the effective H a m i l t o n i a n (28) within reasonable limits a g o o d fit of experimentally observed t e m p e r a t u r e d e p e n d e n c e s of A100(r), }till(T) m a y be o b t a i n e d ( G r e e n o u g h and Lee 1970) (fig. 31). T h e Ni 2÷ in tetrahedral sublattice gives also a large contribution to magnetostriction and TABLE 24 Single ion contributions to the magnetostrictive constants (sublattice fully occupied by a given ion). Ion
Site
Temperature (K)
hi00×
10 6
AlllX 106
A
4.2 77 300
71.1 50 8.6
--15.1 - 13.2 12.6
B
4.2 77 300
-79 -61 -21.4
24.9 2.3 -2.5
B
4.2 77 290
-36 -36 -33.5
-19.6 - 19.6 - 18
A
4.2
B
4.2
Fe3+
Ni2+
-1690
-370
Cu2+ 350
100
244
S. K R U P I C K A A N D P. N O V t ~ ( T(K) 0
100 ,
200
300
i
,
400 rO-e
, - 5ol
'
25
_,oo
20
E N - 150
15
&
% -200
I0
-250 x 10-e -30C
a i
i
i
ibo
2bo
3bo T(K)
Fig. 31. Contributions Aha, Ah2 of Co 2+ ions to the magnetostriction constants hi, h2 in CoxMnl-xFe204 ferrites (Greenough and Lee 1970) for x = 0.038 (A) and x = 0.078 (B). Full curves were calculated using the single ion model Ahl is given for x = 0.038 only.
may be treated similarly as the octahedral C o 2+ ion (Lioliossis and Pointon 1977). Anomalously large magnetostriction was observed in the spinels Fe3-xTixO4 when x is close to 1 (ulv6spinels) (Isbikawa and Syono 1971a, b, Ishikawa et al. 1971, Klerk et al. 1977). For almost stoichiometric (x = 0.95) ulv6spinel A100= 4.8 × 10-3 at 77 K, which is almost an order of magnitude larger than A100 of Co ferrite. The explanation is based on the presence of Fe z+ ions in the tetrahedral sites. These ions would produce a cooperative Jahn-Teller distortion at temperature T~ lying slightly below the Curie temperature. Long-range magnetic order seems to suppress the cooperative Jahn-Teller effects; nevertheless a softening of the crystal as T~ is approached is observed (fig. 32). Due to the small value of c n - c~2 the magnetostriction of Fe z+ in octahedral sites is then enhanced. The dependences of A100 and Alll for the system Fe3_xTixO4 on the content of Ti are shown in fig. 33. The distortion of the crystal is due to the exchange striction. In the discussion of the origin of magnetostriction we have disregarded the term in Hamiltonian (30) corresponding to the dependence of the exchange on strain (exchange striction). Though it generally gives a non-zero contribution to the magnetostriction constants, it is believed that in spinels with the collinear spin structure it plays only a minor role. In systems with the non-collinear arrangement, however, its presence is of importance as it often leads to a change of the crystal symmetry below the ordering temperature. The possibility of a symmetry lowering always exists when the system of spins has a symmetry lower than the crystal lattice. Experimentally the tetragonal deformation of the cubic lattice
OXIDE SPINELS 6
i
i
o
-o'--~o~...oOo.
@
5
x
4
3 .£
i
-o8~ D
245 i
i
o
o"~-.o.~ o
C,,+,+
o.~.
°~o°
~AttenuatJon(c11_
• BaLsam
012
•
o Norlaq
o
iiI
LU
E o
)
Cli -- Ct2
\o
.2
80
60
•
.g,o-~-'-° •
.%-'~~.~
40
I°
. ,,,"
o~
20 i
I
i
i
200 Temperature (K)
0
300
Fig. 32. Softening of Fe2TiO4 as T~ is approached (Ishikawa and Syono 1971a).
o~ x
A '<10e
/ x
AIO0
• A.;,
/
1000
I
05
~o.+ * / . i..~.......--~,/_......
0
05
0.8
x
Fig. 33. Al00and Am vs Ti content x for Fe3-xTixO4 system (Klerk et al. 1977) for the values of indicated in the figure.
T/Tc
below the ordering temperature was observed, e.g., in MnV204 (c/a = 0.99), MgCr204 (c/a = 0.998) and MgV204 (c/a = 0.994) (Plumier 1969).
3.2. Magnetic anneal and related phenomena 3.2.1.
Origin
Magnetic annealing effects appear as the result of some directional ordering of defects or local anisotropic configurations in the crystal. In spinels, these usually
246
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOVAdK
are cation vacancies, substituted ions (impurities), anisotropic short-range order configurations (pairs or groups of ions) or local Jahn-Teller distortions. A typical example (even though not the simplest one) is an inverted spinel having cations of two kinds in crystallographically equivalent octahedral positions. In order to achieve some kind of directional order of the imperfections with respect to the direction of magnetization two conditions must be fulfilled, however: (i) an anisotropic coupling exists between the magnetization vector and the local configurations (defects), and (ii) in some range of T < Tc these imperfections are allowed to move or to transform into other ones with a lower energy of their coupling to magnetization. In such a way the magnetic anneal reflects the ability of the crystal to adapt itself by an inner rearrangement in the lattice to the given magnetic state and to stabilize this state by lowering its free energy. If the magnetization is homogeneous a macroscopic anisotropy results (induced anisotropy). For cubic crystals it is described by (N6el 1954, Penoyer and Bickford 1957): ;K, = - F
+-..,
o i
(31)
i,~j
where direction cosines/3i and c~i refer to the orientation of magnetization during the annealing process and anisotropy measurement respectively. For polycrystals we obtain by averaging FKI = K , cos 2 0,
(32)
with
0 being measured from the direction of the annealing field. The anisotropic coupling responsible for local directional order is of the same origin as that leading to the magnetocrystalline anisotropy: dipole-dipole interactions, single ion anisotropies and anisotropic exchange (and perhaps further interactions) in pairs or clusters. Special types of the induced anisotropy may occur in systems with a noncollinear spin arrangement. In such systems there exist as a rule several distinct configurations of spins possessing the same exchange energy. For a given direction of magnetization the configuration with the lowest anisotropy energy is stable. When the magnetization is rotated, the energy of another configuration may become lower. Nevertheless, if the relaxation time of the spin system is sufficiently long the initial configuration is temporarily retained and an induced anisotropy is observed. Besides the usual terms (31), it may also possess a unidirectional part. Krupi6ka et al. (1977), (1980) reported such anisotropy in manganese chromites MnxCr3 xO4 (x I> 1). It may be noted that the relaxation of this anisotropy is realized by the rearrangement of the spin system itself.
OXIDE SPINELS
247
3.2.2. Examples of local anisotropic configurations Cation vacancies
Many spinels, particularly those nominally containing Fe 2+, often exhibit deviations from the oxygen stoichiometry (oxygen excess) which leads to the presence of cation vacancies. If their concentration on B sites with the [111] local trigonal axis differs from those in other octahedral positions the dipole-dipole interactions contribute an axial anisotropic term of the form (Yanase 1962):
E dip = AdipNu (/x -
(33)
~..L' ) ( ~ 1 0 £ 2 -~- ~20L3 -~ ~'30£1) ,
with/x', Ix denoting the average magnetic moments sites, respectively. N is the number of B sites 4 x 10 -18 erg/cm 3 as estimated on the basis of the leads to the induced anisotropy of a G type (i.e. F
in the [111] sites and the other per unit volume and Adip--~ geometrical parameters. This = 0) with
G ( T., T) = ND(16A2dip/k T)(gS)4[M (T)/M(O)]2[M (Ta)/M (O)I2 ,
(34)
N[] is the number of vacancies per unit volume, Ta and T are the temperatures of annealing and measurement, respectively, and gS the average magnetic moment in /xu. In principle, a similar anisotropy might be introduced by an unequal distribution of non-magnetic substitutional impurities among four types of the B positions. Note that such an anisotropic distribution of vacancies and/or nonmagnetic ions also causes the distribution of magnetic ions (i.e. Fe 3+, Fe 2+ etc.) to be non-uniform which results in an active contribution of these ions to the induced anisotropy via the mechanism of single ion anisotropy or anisotropic exchange (Krupi~ka and Zfiv6ta 1968). Co 2+ in B positions
In the range of low concentrations the Co 2+ ions may be viewed as isolated. In the presence of exchange their low lying levels corresponding to the spin Hamiltonian (28) are anisotropic and hence their equilibrium distribution among the four types of B positions will depend on the direction of magnetization. The resulting induced single ion anisotropy is again of a G type with (Slonczewski 1958): a = nN[(X/3] o~A[/2) tanh(V'3laA ]/2kT) - (ah)2/4/XBH~x], n = (Nm + Nm - Nm- Niil)/N,
(35)
where T is the temperature of measurement, N the total number of Co 2+ in the B sites, N1~1 their equilibrium number in positions with local axis in [111] etc., A the parameter of spin-orbit coupling and a a numerical factor, 1 < a <3. In the special case of Co substituted magnetite laA] = 132cm -1 and IXBH~x--320cm -1
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOV_rid(
248
were estimated (Slonczewski 1958). Equation (35) applies also to other ions for which eq. (28) may be used. Single ion contributions to the induced anisotropy arising from the preferential distribution in the B sites are also expected from ions with a singlet orbital ground state, via the D term in the spin Hamiltonian (27). These anisotropies are usually weak but in special cases (Fe 2+) they may achieve a considerable strength (Watanabe et al. 1978). If the concentration of Co 2+ (or other active ions) is increased these ions cannot be considered as isolated and contributions of more complicated local configurations including pairs and eventually larger groups of active ions become important (Iida and Inoue 1962, Iida and Miwa 1966). As an example a cluster containing an isolated Co2+-Co 2+ pair is shown in fig. 34; note that there are 6 inequivalent orientations of this pair corresponding to 6 face diagonals (110). If the occurrence of differently oriented pairs is unequal, an induced anisotropy appears depending quadratically on the Co 2+ concentration. Experimentally this was found to be almost a pure F - t y p e anisotropy ( G = 0) (fig. 35). The source of the anisotropy
Fig. 34. The simplest configuration necessary for the description of the Co2+-Co2+ pair contribution to induced anisotropy (Iida and Inoue 1962, Iida and Miwa 1966). 15 x 105
i
i
10
i
o
o
~E
Oe) x
F (.9
u~
5
o ~°~.
,.~'" 0.05
o~ ,
,
0.10
0.15
x
'.20
Fig. 35. Induced anisotropy constants F and O for Co-substituted magnetite CoxFe3-xO4,measured at room temperature after annealing in a magnetic field at 375 K (Penoyer and Bickford 1957).
OXIDE SPINELS
249
may be sought in both the anisotropic exchange and a local modification of the ligand field changing the single ion contributions of each ion within the pair (Tachiki 1960).
Mn3+-distorted octahedra If a small part of octahedral positions is occupied by Mn 3+ ions the overall symmetry of the crystal remains cubic, but local Jahn-Teller distortions may appear (section 1.6). Assuming these to be static (or quasistatic) the local ligand field of Mn 3+ lowers its symmetry which usually becomes tetragonal. The D term in eq. (27) then yields uniaxial anisotropy of F~type (G = 0) provided a preferential distribution of the distortion axes may be created by magnetic anneal (Nov~k 1966). Let us note that due to local stresses and other defects often only a small part of the distortions is expected to be free to move and to take part in the process (No%k 1966, Krupi~ka et al. 1980).
3.2.3. Kinetics, magnetic after-effects In order to achieve thermodynamic equilibrium in the magnetic annealing process (by establishing a local directional order) some rearrangements in the lattice are necessary. Hence any change of the imposed conditions (change in the direction of magnetization and/or its spatial distribution in the magnetic specimen) will be followed by a relaxation process leading to accommodation of the magnetic system to the new situation. This manifests itself in relaxation of the induced anisotropy and in various so-called after-effects summarized, e.g., by Krupi6ka and Z~v6ta (1968). The microscopic mechanism underlying the relaxation processes mentioned above usuallly possesses the character of a diffusion process (migration of ions and/or vacancies, electron hopping) and it is thermally activated. The relevant relaxation times then depend exponentially on temperature according to the Arrhenius relation ~- = a e x p ( - O / k T ) ;
(36)
the constant A depends on the type of the diffusion process and O is the activation energy. Except for a few simple cases when isolated ions or vacancies rearrange, two or more relaxation times usually exist. The distribution of relaxation times is often continuous due to some disorder in the lattice. In practice, the so-called logarithmic distribution of r (i.e. log r uniformly distributed between limits log rl, log ~'2) is considered as a good approximation. Large dispersion of relaxation times has been found in processes involving electron hopping and/or reorientation of Jahn-Teller distortions. The diffusion may be usually described as a selfdiffusion process, i.e., without taking into account the driving forces due to magnetization; this is illustrated in fig. 36. Then [Ei - Ejl = Io,j - oj l
o0
o,
from which eq. (36) follows provided [Ei -Ei[ ~ kT.
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOVd~¢
250
-- ~l ~
:/ I
-U-]OjI
Ei
_ _
i
i
Fig. 36. Dependence of the particle energy on the position r relevant to the relaxation process. If the diffusion in question concerns the ions, the activation energies Q are typically between 0.7 and 2.5 eV depending on the type of ions and type of the process. Generally, the presence of cation vacancies makes the diffusion process faster, the factor Q is lowered and the preexponential factor A in eq. (36) becomes inversely proportional to the vacancy concentration within certain limits. A detailed analysis of the vacancy assisted diffusion of Co 2+ ions in Co substituted magnetite was made by Iida and lnoue (1962) and by Iida and Miwa (1966). In particular, one relaxation time should exist for isolated Co 2+ ions (the G term) and two different times for reorientation of Co2+-Co 2+ pairs (the F term). The effect of the size of the migrating ion on the diffusion rate and the activation energy was calculated by G e r b e r (1968) on the basis of a simple model. When the local anisotropic configurations refer to anisotropic distribution of electronic charge (e.g. the distribution of Fe z+ and Fe 3+ valency states) a migration of electrons is sufficient for the rearrangement process. The activation energy is then 4 0 . 7 eV and it is often very low (<0.1 eV). The mechanism of the electron motion is similar to electrical conductivity (hopping). The spinels with coexisting Fe 2+ and Fe 3+, or Co 2+ and Co 3+ ions are examples of materials possessing this type of relaxation. A special case is represented by the local Jahn-Teller distortions. They are connected with the ordering of partly filled orbitals and their reorientation does not need any diffusion even though some thermal activation is necessary in order to overcome an energy barrier. A p a r t from this process the distortions are usually stabilized by some defects and the mechanical stresses connected with them; they reorient only if these defects move. This seems to be the case of low t e m p e r a t u r e magnetic anneal in Mn-rich Mn ferrites where the distortions of Mn 3+ octahedra may be stabilized by some extra electrons placed at the neighbouring ions (Krupi6ka and Zfiv6ta 1968). Apart from thermal activation an optical process may take place in some particular cases of electronic processes. Effects similar to photomagnetic anneal
O X I D E SPINELS
251
originally discovered in Si doped Y I G (Teale and Temple 1967) were observed in Mg, Li, Li-Mn and other spinel ferrites (Holtwijk et al. 1970, Marais and Merceron 1974, Hisatake and Ohta 1977, Bernstein and Merceron 1977).
3.2.4. Survey of experimental results Most of the information on induced anisotropy effects comes from torque measurements. In some cases additional knowledge may be obtained from the study of disaccommodation and other relaxation effects (see, e.g., Braginski 1965, Krupi'~ka and Zfiv6ta 1968). C o 2+
containing spinels
As the anisotropic effect of Co 2+ is strong it usually outweighs other possible contributions to the induced anisotropy. The magnetic annealing effect of Co 2+ ions was first observed in CoxFe3_xO4 by Kato and Takei (1933) and later on frequently studied in this system by several authors (Penoyer and Bickford 1957, Slonczewski 1958, Iida 1960, Iida and Inoue 1962, Iida and Miwa 1966, Palmer 1960, Iizuka and Iida 1966). For low cobalt concentration x the results may be interpreted in terms of local ordering of both isolated Co 2+ ions and Co2+-Co 2+ pairs in octahedral sublattice (figs. 34 and 35). The presence of vacancies does not change the magnitude of the induced anisotropy but the rate of ordering ~.-1 was found to be proportional to the vacancy concentration provided this is >~10 5. For lower concentrations of cation vacancies the activation energy is increased from the usual value ~1 eV to ~ 2 eV indicating a more difficult diffusion mechanism. In Ni-Co (Perthel 1962, Glaz et al. 1980), N i - F e - C o ferrites (Michalk 1968) and N i - Z n - C o ferrites (Michalowski 1965) similar effects appear. The induced anisotropy is usually lowered due to fluctuations in the local symmetry which primarily concerns the G term. In table 25 the room temperature values of G and F found for the system CoxNi0.46_xZn0.29Fe22504+ 7 after magnetic anneal at 350°C are compared with those reported for CoxFe3-xO4. Let us note that the coexistence of more kinds of ions yields possibilities for new anisotropic configurations to appear. In Co substituted Li0.sFe2.504 a substantial reduction of the induced anisotropy was observed when the B sublattice becomes ordered (lvanova et al. 1979). In spinels containing both Co 2+ and Co 3+ ions in octahedral sites a preferential T A B L E 25 Constants of induced anisotropy in Co containing ferrites. System CoxFe3-xO4 CoxNi0.a6-xZn0.29Fez2504+~
F (105 erg/cm 3)
G(105 erg/cm 3)
Ref.
101 x 2 0.06 + 100 x 2
92.5 x 7x
1 2
1. Penoyer, R.F. and L.R. Bickford Jr., 1957, Phys. Rev. 108, 271. 2. Michalowsky, L., 1965, Phys. Status Solidi 8, 543.
252
S. KRUPII)KA AND P. N O V ~
occupation of certain positions by Co 2+ may be achieved by the electron transfer between Co 2+ and Co 3+ ions. If the concentration of Co ions on equivalent sites is sufficient for a direct electron exchange Co2+ ~,~-Co3+, the activation energy is low ~ 0 . t e V . This is, e.g., case of cobalt rich C o - F e and C o - F e - N i spinels investigated by Iizuka and Iida (1966)- see figs. 37(a) and ( b ) - or Co 3+ containing Co ferrite (Marais et al. 1970). Low temperature torque m e a s u r e m e n t s would be necessary here to get the full frozen-in induced anisotropy. More often the spinels with low concentration of both Co 2+ and Co 3+ are quoted in the literature (Sixtus 1960, Marais and Merceron 1959, Mizushima 1965). The Co ions are then separated by many other ions, e.g. Fe 3+, so that the electron transfer involves also these ions as intermediary. This results in rather high activation energy up to ~0.6 eV. r
,
,
,
,
J
i
,
i
-o-o- be¢ore rec~ucUon -×-x- al~er ~ o
20
°d,, \°i
15
x
10
~
.\ ,,
'
!
~Z
×
o /
0
~ttl,~.,,.
0.'2
0.'4
O.6
0.8
1.0 X
Fig. 37. The dependence of induced anisotropy on the composition in the system CoxFe3-xO4(Iizuka and Iida 1966). The reduction decreases the concentration of Co3+ ions.
N i - F e and other iron rich spinels
Induced anisotropy and various after-effects were studied in several systems containing Fe 2+ ions usually simultaneously with cation vacancies. Typical examples are iron rich Ni and Mg ferrites including magnetite (Motzke 1962, 1964, G e r b e r and Elbinger 1964, Wagner 1961). In pure magnetite with a slight oxygen excess an induced anisotropy of G type was observed (Knowles 1964) possessing a relaxation time ~ 2 0 s at room t e m p e r a t u r e . This is compatible with the preferential occupation of certain octahedral positions by vacancies. The magnitude and temperature dependence of G may be brought into reasonable agreement with the mechanism of a vacancy dipole-dipole contribution (eq. 34). In a m o r e recent study (Kronm/iller et al. 1974) the corresponding after-effect was shown to be composed of two processes which were attributed to different distributions of Fe 2+ and Fe 3+ around the vacancy. Only recently Brtining and Semmelhack (1979) have also reported F ¢ 0 and directly proportional to the cation vacancy concen-
OXIDE SPINELS
253
tration in their magnetite single crystal. The ratio F / G was practically independent of vacancy concentration ( F / G = ½). In mixed spinels, particularly Ni-Fe and Mg-Fe ferrites, the relaxation spectrum corresponds to two distinct magnetic annealing processes (fig. 38). One of them (observable around room temperature) is similar to that discussed above; in addition to the G term it possesses also an F term proportional to p x ( 2 - x ) , x and p denoting the concentration of Ni 2+ (or Mg 2+) ions and vacancies, respectively. This indicates the active role of vacancy-Ni 2+ pair ordering. The other process with the annealing temperature -300°C was usually found to be of pure F type with F proportional to x2(2- x) 2. It does not depend on p. This points to an ion pair ordering while the role of vacancies is believed to be similar as previously discussed for Co 2+ substituted magnetite, i.e., they increase the diffusion rate and lower the annealing temperature. For historical reasons these processes are usually denoted as III (lower temperature process) and I in the literature. An additional effect (II) lying in the region between I and III and reported in some papers was shown to be due to cobalt impurities. The magnetic annealing spectra of Mn-Fe spinels are a little more complicated (fig. 39) and were discussed, e.g., by Krupi~ka and Vilim (1957), Krupi~ka (1962), Marais and Merceron (1965) and Braginski and Merceron (1962). In particular, an additional effect labeled as IV with lower activation energy was observed below room temperature. It was ascribed to vacancies forming some complexes, e.g., with Mn 3+ and Fe 2+ ions. A similarly positioned induced anisotropy effect was observed in Ti or Sn substituted magnetite and ferrites (Knowles and Rankin 1971, Knowles 1974) where formation of some Me 4+ containing complexes (e.g. Ti4+-Fe 2+ pairs) may influence both the vacancy migration rate and the resulting induced anisotropy. For Ti substituted magnetite the corresponding anisotropy was found to be of G type (Knowles 1974). Let us note that by properly adjusting the concentration of Ti 4÷, Fe 2+ and cation vacancies the effect III may be suppressed so that practically only IV remains (fig. 40); this is important for the ferrite materials design.
1000
f
"~ 800
i
/
~<- 600
o
/
400 o o. . . . .
200
~-o-o-
/o /
...~o/
o
0
100
200
300
400 T(°C)
Fig. 38. The dependence of induced anisotropy in Ni0.4Fe2.604 on the annealing temperature Ta. Measurements were performed at -75°C after 10 minutes anneal at 7". (Motzke 1962 and 1964).
254
S. KRUPI(~KA AND P. NOVAK i
~,o"
,
,
0.4
i
i
i
,,, r~o
0.3
4,
Pf \
0.2
I',°,x
,vii>: \/7!,o
0.1
o-o-~-n,0 ',,,100 200,°'W,300 400 .,: '~
-200 -100
T(K) i
/o,,oo-O-'E
. . . .
i
5000 0
0~00 ~ 0 _ 0 . 0 #"
I
o
3000
[ 0
! 1000
oO.oop ~ 0~
-200 -100
I
I
0
I00
200 300
400 T (K)
Fig. 39. Comparison of the disaccommodation spectrum and the induced anisotropy for M n 0 . 2 F e 2 . 8 0 4 . 0 i (Marais and Merceron 1965).
~l~Ip(°lo)
/
III O.6 -
~
0.4
J
0.2 -50
4
~
~
/
~
iis/II
\k N 0
+50
+I00 Temperature °C
Fig. 40. Disaccommodation spectra for two Ti substituted MnZn ferrites; (A) Mno.68Zno.32+ " 3+ . Fe0.11Tlo.09Fe18204, (B) Mn0.64Zn0.3Fe~lTio.osFe3~O4;after Knowles and Rankin (1971). The DA maximum for MnZn ferrites without Ti is indicated by a dashed line.
OXIDE SPINELS
255
A further process was reported to appear at higher temperatures (350°C ~< T, ~< 450°C) in Mn and Zn substituted magnetite and was ascribed to reorientations involving also the ions in tetrahedral sites, i.e., Mn 2+ and Zn 2+ (Maxim 1969). The activation energies are rather high here, approximately 2 to 2.5 eV. In all processes mentioned above the presence of Fe 2+ ions is important because they may considerably enhance the induced anisotropy by their own contribution. As they coexist with Fe 3÷ ions in iron rich spinels they may also give rise to induced anisotropy and after-effects of electronic origin via the redistribution of valencies Fe2+ ~--Fe 3÷. A C magnetic losses are usually used for study of this effect (e.g. Kienlin 1957, K6hler 1959). Unless the concentration of Fe 2+ is too low, the activation energy is rather small, of the order of 10 -2 to 10 1 e V , and the kinetics is interpreted in terms of the electron hopping mechanism. Spinels containing M n 3+ and
C u 2+
Besides valency redistribution these ions may contribute to the magnetic annealing process by reorientations of local Jahn-Teller distortions (section 1.6). The most detailed study was p e r f o r m e d on the MnxFe3 xO4 system (Krupi6ka and Vilim 1957, Merceron 1965, Zfiv6ta et al. 1966, G e r b e r et al. 1966, Broese van G r o e n a u 1967, Broese van G r o e n a u and Pearson 1967, Marais and Merceron 1967, Krupi~ka and Zfiv6ta 1968, Y a m a d a and Iida 1968, Iida et al. 1968). The induced anisotropy measured on two series of samples given as a function of Mn content (fig. 41) demonstrates convincingly the effect of Mn 3+. The same effect is reflected in the part denoted as C of the magnetic loss factor spectra (see fig. 42). The corresponding activation energies lie between ~0.3 eV and 0.5 eV, close to the activation energy deduced from the electrical conductivity which supports the interpretation based on reorientation process correlated with the electron motion (Krupi6ka and Zfiv6ta 1968). The peaks B and A in fig. 42 may be attributed to
1000
,
800
200
, '
, ~
x
Ij
1.0
i
1.2
i
14
l
1.6
1.8 X
Fig. 41. Dependence of the induced anisotropy of MnxFe3-xO4+~, on the manganese content (Gerber et al. 1966). Samples were annealed at 1200°C at 760 mm Hg (a) and 10-2 mm Hg (b).
256
S. KRUPI(~KA AND P. NOV/~'(
0.4
~
B
.8~.
C
I
III I~
'
Ill/
',
lltt
A~
~
I
o
I s+
0.81
I
\1
X ebo
I \
/
/
lbo
I
\
\1 '1
ado
r (K)
Fig. 42. Magnetic losses vs T for MnxFe3 xO4+7 system. Figures show manganese concentration x; 1+ and 1- correspond to x = 1 with 3' positive and negative respectively (Z~v~ta et al. 1966, 1968).
Fe 2+~--Fe 3+ valency redistribution and to reorientation of free Mn 3+ distortions (i.e. not stabilized by electrons or other defects) respectively. The coexistence of peaks B and C in certain compositional range points to the coexistence of Fe > and Mn 3+ ions. Relaxation peaks similar to C were also found in other Mn and/or Cu containing spinels: M n - Z n (Okada and Akashi 1965, Giesecke 1959), Mn-Mg (Krupi6ka 1960), M n - C u (Krupi~.ka and Z/w6ta 1968). In Mn substituted Li ferrite (Marais et al. 1972) the magnetic annealing effect of Mn 3+ ions was found to be enhanced by clustering of these ions. 3.3. D y n a m i c s o f magnetization
Many ferrimagnetic spinels may be treated as collinear two sublatice ferrimagnets. In such systems the theory of ferrimagnetic resonance (e.g. Keffer 1966) predicts two resonance frequencies to+, w to occur. Neglecting the effects of anisotropy and demagnetization field, the lower one is given by (37)
to+ = y e f f H ,
with Ye~ = ( M , - M2)/(M~/y,
Mz/y2),
where MI, M2 are the sublattice magnetizations, and yl, 3/2 are respective gyromagnetic ratios. It is analogous to the simple ferromagnetic mode, except that the effective value Yen has to be substituted for the gyromagnetic ratio 3/. The higher resonance frequency to_ is related to the so-called exchange resonance frequency toex = n (72M1 - yIM2) ,
where n is the intersublattice molecular field coefficient.
(38)
OXIDE SPINELS
257
For H ~ AHex = n(M1 - M2), w_ = Wex-- y2~H,
(39)
with "Year= [T2(M1/3'1)- y1(M2/'Y2)]/(M1/yl- M2/T2), which demonstrates the dependence of both we× and o) on the strength of the inter-sublattice exchange. As this is rather strong in most of spinel ferrites ~Oexis expected to fall into the infrared rather than microwave region. This is presumably one of the reasons why the exchange resonance was not yet unambiguously detected in spinel ferrites. M o r e o v e r the exchange resonance may be excited only if Y~ ~ Y2 (Schl6man 1957). The effective gyromagnetic factor ")/eftin eq. (37) is connected with the effective spectroscopic splitting factor gen through the relation Yen = e/(2mc)ge~r = e / ( 2 m c ) ( M l - M 2 ) l ( M 1 / g l - M21g2).
(4o)
For S-state ions (Mn 2+, Fe 3+) g is close to its free electron value 2.0023. In other cases the spin-orbit coupling modifies the value of g. Effective g factors as obtained from F M R in several spinels are given in table 26. The width A H of the resonance line is in most ferrites of the order of several tens Oe. Nevertheless in very pure Li, Mg and Ni ferrites AH--~ 1 - 2 0 e was observed (Yakovlev et al. 1971). On the other hand, values of A H up to 1000 Oe may occur in ferrites containing Fe 2+ in the B sublattice. The values of A H in ferrimagnetic spinels are summarized in table 27. T h e r e are several relaxation processes which are responsible for the linewidth in spinel ferrites (for detailed discussion see Sparks 1964, Patton 1975). In materials containing magnetic inhomogeneities such as surface roughness, grain boundaries or atomic disorder the two-magnon scattering is important. In many ferrites, however, the effect of so-called slowly relaxing impurities dominates. This is supposed to be the case, e.g., for systems containing Fe 2+, Co 2+ or Mn 3+ in the B sublattice or Ni 2+ ion in the A sublattice. Relevant mechanism requires the presence of two or more low lying anisotropic levels. The magnetization precession then modulates the energy separation between the levels. As a consequence, the thermal equilibrium population for each level changes with a period of precession. The induced transitions between the anisotropic levels then give rise to the relaxation effect. Note that a similar mechanism applies to the valence exchange Fe 2+ ~--Fe 3+ (Clogston 1955, Teale 1967). In this case the energy levels are connected with the hopping of a Fe 2+ ion between the B sites having different orientation of the local trigonal axis. The linewidth corresponding to the slowly relaxing impurities is strongly t e m p e r a t u r e dependent exhibiting one or two maxima (fig. 43).
S. KRUPICKA AND P. N O V ~ K
258
TABLE 26 Values of the g factor from FMR studies. System Fe304
T (K)
A (cm)
130 293
g
Ref.
3.35 1.25 3.35
2.08 2.09 2.17
1
1.25
2.13
3.2 3.2 3.2
2.060 2.019 (3) 2.004 (2)
2
2.00
3
2.6 (2) 2.7 (3) 2.27
4 5
MnFe204
4.2 77 300
(Mn, Zn)Fe204
4.2-300
1.25-10
295-310 363 473
0.37-0.64 1.25 1.25
CoFe204
NiFe204
293
1.25
2.19
6
Nio.95Fe2.os04
4.2-290
1.25
2.2
7
Nio.75Fe2.2504
4.2 85 290
1.25 1.25 1.25
2.16 2.19 2.13
7
CuFe204
77 300
1.25 1.25
2.44 2,09
8
MgFe204
77 473
1.25 1.25
2.04 2.005
9
Lio.sFezsO4
300
1.25
2.005
10
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10.
Bickford, L.R., 1949, Phys. Rev. 76, 137. Dillon, J.E. et al., 1955, Phys. Rev. 100, 750. Schl6mann, E., Conf. Magnetism Magn. Materials, Boston, 1956. Assadourian, L. and L. Silber, 1976, AIP Conf. Proc. 29, 684. Tannenwald, P.E., 1955, Phys. Rev. 99, 463. Yager, W.A. et al., 1950, Phys. Rev. 80, 744. Yager, W.A. et al., 1955, Phys. Rev. 99, 1203. Miyadai, T. et al., 1965, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 20, 980. Kriessman, C.S. and H.S. Belson, 1959, J. Appl. Phys. 30, 170. Schnitzler, A.D. et al., 1962, J. Appl. Phys. 33, 1293.
OXIDE SPINELS
259
TABLE 27 Values of AH in spinel ferrites. System
T (K)
h (cm)
AH (Oe)
Ref.
Lio.sFe2.504
134 300
6 6
0.88 1.68
1
Mno.4zMgo.61Fel.9504
290
6.1
2.5
2
MnFe204
20 300
1.25 1.25
Mnl.03Fel.9704
15 290
3.2 3.2
Mno.asZno.55Fe204
290
CuFe204
20 80
3
173 38
4
1.25
35
5
290 300
1,25 1,25
120 60
6
NiFe204
290 290
1,25 3,2
35 2
7 8
Ni0.95Fe20504
4.2 85 290
1.25 1.25 1.25
30 55 50
9
Nio,vsFe2.2504
4.2 85 290
1.25 1.25 1.25
40 120 140
9
MgFe204
290
6.1
Fe304
290
1.25
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10.
2.3
4300
Remark Ordered state
Direction [111]
8
Inversion = 0.89
10
Direction [100]
Remeika, J.P. and R.L. Comstock, 1964, J. Appl. Phys. 35, 3320. Lyukshin, V.V. et al., 1976, Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR Neorg. Mater. 11,285. Heeger, A.J. et al., 1964, Phys. Rev. 134A, 399. Watanabe, Y., 1974, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 37, 637. Gait, J.K. et al., 1951, Phys. Rev. 81, 470. Miydai, T. et al., 1965, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 20, 980. Yager, W.A. et al., 1950, Phys. Rev. 80, 744. Yakovlev, Y.M. et al., 1971, Fiz. Tver. Tel. 13, 1151. Yager, W.A. et al., 1955, Phys. Rev. 99, 1203. Bickford, L.R. Jr., 1950, Phys. Rev. 78, 449.
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOV./d{
260 aH
(Oe)
i
o DI,)
800
600
\
•
Doo]
20O
5'o
1~o
1~o
260
2~o
T(X)
~bo
Fig. 43. Temperature dependence of the FMR linewidth for MsI1.46Fel.5404system (Zfiv6ta and Novfik
197a).
4. Other physical properties 4.1. Electrical properties 4.1.1. D C electrical conductivity and Seebeck effect Most of the oxide spinels not containing transition metal ions are very good insulators at room temperature. The A13+ spinels MgA1204, ZnA1204 and others may be mentioned as examples possessing electrical conductivity of the order of 10-6O-~cm -1 even at temperatures ~900°C (Bradburn and Rigby 1953). This behaviour may be understood as due to a large energy gap (often of several eV) between the occupied valence band primarily formed by the oxygen 2p states and the empty conduction band. The actual values of electrical conductivity and the activation energies are then usually controlled by impurity levels within the gap. With the presence of the transition metal ions additional energy levels and/or narrow bands are introduced usually also lying in the gap. This need not necessarily change the picture of the electronic charge transport very much provided that transport within the partly occupied d levels (bands) themselves does not d o m i n a t e . In particular, many oxide spinels with 3d n ions in the A positions only possess a very low conductivity (fig. 44). The same is true for pure stoichiometric spinels having only one kind of ions on equivalent crystallographic sites such as the normal spinels ZnFe204 and CdFe204, or ordered Lio.sFezsO4. A considerable increase of the electrical conductivity is usually connected with the combined effect of disorder and the presence of cations able to change easily their valency states or actually coexisting with different valencies in the material.
OXIDE SPINELS
600
700
261 T °C 900 1000
800
'//!
,
/
104.5
(bV ×
R(#)
%/.o/
105.0
/
105.5
./
I×
.n~ . ~ ° I !,'o x
/o. /
106.0
/ /
// /
106.5
tOzo
x
17
lh
•
./ /
I
~%'b
./'.k_~Y"
f/
Zv
D
b
I 0 7 T ( K "1)
Fig. 44. Temperature dependence of the resistance for some Al spinels (Bradburn and Rigby 1953).
Typical examples are bivalent and trivalent Fe or Co ions in the B positions. The charge transfer may then be effectuated by hopping of electrons or holes between equivalent ions (valency exchange) which is a rather easy process (see, e.g., Verwey i951). The sign of the Seebeck coefficient (thermopower) is often helpful in clarifying the nature of the dominating charge carriers and the mechanism of their motion. A special case seems to be the vanadium spinels where besides hopping a nearly band-like conductivity may occur characterized by a drop of both resistivity and activation energy when the distance between neighbouring vanadium ions in B sites approaches (or decreases below) certain critical value (table 28, Rogers et al. 1963). A metallic conductivity was found in LiVzO4 ( V - V separation ~2.91 A, Rogers 1967). The most relevant for the scope of this book and perhaps the most often studied are the electrical transport properties of Fe spinels (ferrites) and their solid solutions. We shall start with magnetite Fe3+[Fe3+Fe2+]O] - which represents a rather singular case due to its high R T value of the DC conductivity (~250 fV~cm -1) and the peculiar character of the conductivity versus temperature dependence. Other ferrites may be regarded as belonging to systems of solid solutions MxFe3-xO4 where M stands for (usually bivalent) cations substituting Fe 2+ in magnetite or for combinations of such ions. Some of the substituting cations may also exist in higher valency states, e.g., Mn 3+ or Co3+; the relevant systems are then to be extended to include the mixed spinels with x > 1. In spite of a large amount of existing experimental data only few of them which have been obtained on well defined single crystals may be used to draw quan-
262
S. KRUPI(~KA AND P. NOVfid~
TABLE 28 Crystallograplaic and electrical conductivity data for vanadium spinels (after Rogers 1967 and Rogers et al. 1967).
Formula Mn[V2]O4 Fe[V2]O4
Mg[V2]O4 Zn[V2]O4 Li[V;]04
Lattice constant (A)
V-V separation (A)
Activation energy of electrical conductivity (eV)
8.522 8.454 8.418 8.410 -
3.014 2.990 2.974 2.973 2.91
0.37 0.25 0.18" 0.16 metallic*
* single crystal. titative conclusions about the n u m b e r of carriers, their mobility, activation energies etc. The other ones, particularly those related to polycrystalline samples, are to be taken with caution and may be explored mainly in a qualitative way. The discussion of the electronic transfer will be limited to conductivity and Seebeck effect. The evaluation of the Hall mobility is usually difficult due to a large contribution of the spontaneous magnetization for which no reliable theory seems to be available. Moreover, it has been argued that in the case of small polaron hopping which probably is the predominant transport mechanism in ferrites and related spinels no simple relation exists between Hall and drift mobilities (Adler 1968). It is usually admitted that the drift mobility is rather low, ~0.1 to 1 c m W - l s -1 for magnetite and much lower (10 -4 to 10-Scm2V-Is 1) for compositions approaching the stoichiometric ferrites (Klinger and Samochvalov 1977). As a rule, these values are deduced from conductivity or Seebeck effect measurements on the basis of some model, and no reliable independent method has been used for their determination. Even the magnetoresistance experiments though occasionally reported in the literature have not been interpreted from the point of view of electrical transport mechanisms (for a review see, e.g., Svirina 1970). M a g n e t i t e a n d substituted magnetite
The log o- versus T -1 plots for magnetite covering a broad t e m p e r a t u r e region are shown in figs. 45a and 45b. The Hall coefficient and mobility are displayed in fig. 46. At elevated temperatures (1500 K > T ~> Tc = 858 K) magnetite exhibits a semiconductive behaviour with thermally activated conductivity, which may be fitted (Parker and Tinsley 1976) by the formula: ~r = A T -~ e x p ( - q / k T ) ,
(41)
with A = 490 f~-lcm-lK and q = (99-+3)× 10 3eV. Note that eq. (41) can also explain the m a x i m u m in cr versus T observed at ~1100 K. In the vicinity of Tc (usually somewhat below) o- begins to depart from eq. (41); in a certain tem-
OXIDE SPINELS 103
.
.
.
.
102 ooooo-O--o~ o~ o~. 10~
263
250 ~ - p ~
.
"-O~ojO
~ 200
0.0~ 0
~(858K)
. . . . . .
I ~ 1oo~5°r o
O,lS eVJ" X
I0-'
I
. 50
i Lo~/ ternperef;ure transition
10-2
o
°"~t
' 4o0 . .800 ...
12oo (K)00',6
10-3 o
104
\o
10 -5
°~o
10-6 10-7 0
,
,
i2
14
f.o3e~,~o.. /6
18
20 loao/r
22
24
(K-')
Fig. 45a. Conductivity vs temperature for a single crystal of Fe304 (Miles et al. 1957).
-200 I
-205
"-•-210
~o
\2
o...-
o
-215
~o o
-220 o
-225
[! \ '%/ ?
-230
/
'°
o
-235
NO
~°,,o 4 i
r~
2
- ~ o - o - o . ~
3
4
-240
1ooo/T (K-~) Fig. 45b. Resistivity vs temperature for several specimens of magnetite (Parker and Tinsley 1976); (1) Stoichiometric single crystal, (2) oxygen defficient polycrystalline specimen Fe300.3988, (3) stoichiometric polycrystalline specimen, (4) single crystal according to Smith (1952).
264
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOV/~K
10~ & i0 ~ (cmalc)
///
10 1
o~
bo
rv
1o-1 lo-2 10-3 O_ o
104 0.50
--0 I
t
I
I
I
i
i
i
E
~u 0.20
(cm2/VS)o 1o o~ 0.05
["
0-. 4 I
0.02 2
I
[
I
IO00/T (K 4) Fig. 46. Ordinary Hall coefficient R0 and Hall mobility/zH vs temperature (Siemons 1970).
perature interval it behaves metal-like with negative temperature coefficient and in the vicinity of room temperature it passes a new maximum. At Tv = 119 K magnetite undergoes a phase transition (the Verwey transition ) accompanied by a sudden decrease of conductivity of about two orders of magnitude. Below this it behaves like a semiconductor with a temperature dependent activation energy, at least down to ~10 K. Attempts have been made (fig. 47) to fit the or versus T dependence in this region to Mott's formula; o" = A e x p ( - B / T W 4 ) ,
(42)
derived for variable range hopping (Mott 1969). It was early recognized (Verwey and Haayman 1941) that the transition in magnetite at 119 K is connected with some kind of electronic charge ordering and a model was proposed for it based on regular arrangement of Fe 2+ and Fe > ions in rows parallel to [110] and [110] directions, respectively (Verwey ordering). The more recent models, partly based on new neutron diffraction, NMR and M6ssbauer data either abandon the presumption of definite ionic valencies (Cullen and Callen 1973) or correspond to more sophisticated ordering schemes of Fe 2+
OXIDE
265
SPINELS
~
T(K) n
2
n
I
I
n
I
o0%0
0
%%
o
.t%o
-2
"to
%
E
o
,o, %
t~ -6
'oo
c3
oI
-8
q
-10
o
-12 %
-14
~o
\%%o OoooO
O.2
Oi3
0 .'4
0'e 05 T@ (K)@
Fig. 47. log cr as a function of T -1/4 for Fe304 single crystal, after Drabble et al. (1971).
and Fe 3+ (Hargrove and Kfindig 1970, Fujii et al. 1975, Shirane et al. 1975, Iida et al. 1976-1978, Umemura and Iida 1979). These models assign the low temperature phase rather as monoclinic than orthorhombic. It is clear that any model explaining the electronic conductivity in magnetite also has to explain (or at least to be compatible with) the Verwey transition and vice versa. It must also account for the anisotropy of o- below this transition (Chikazumi 1975, Mizushima et al. 1978). The common feature of recent models of conduction in magnetite is the splitting of electronic 3d 6 levels of Fe2+(B) in the ordered phase by an energy gap of ~0.1 eV; only states below this gap are populated at 0 K because the number of Fe 2+ is half the number of the octahedral sites. The electronic charge transport is then effectuated by carriers either created by thermal activation across the gap or introduced by impurity atoms or oxygen non-stoichiometry. The separated levels are usually supposed to form some kind of narrow subbands that overlap above the Verwey transition. In the simplest case a tight-binding scheme combined with Coulomb repulsion was used which leads to a Hubbard-type Hamiltonian for description of the situation (Cullen and Callen 1970, 1973, Fazekas 1972). More refined theories include also polaronic effects (electron-phonon interaction) and other short-range energy contributions, included spin correlation and exchange effects (Haubenreisser 1961, Klinger 1975, Klinger and Samochvalov 1977 and ref. therein, Buchenau 1975).
266
S. K R U P I C K A A N D P. N O V A K
Due to the polarization effect upon their surroundings the electrons are usually supposed to be not entirely free to move below the transition and their transfer is described as a polaron hopping process, perhaps except at the lowest temperatures (<10 K) where polaron coherent tunelling might dominate the conduction. Above the Verwey transition the long-range order disappears and the energy gap between both subbands collapses accompanied by a sudden increase of the carrier number. The complicated temperature course of cr is then believed to result from a combination of narrow band conduction, short-range correlation of polarons and scattering processes connected with spatial charge and spin fluctuations. The loss of magnetic order at Tc seems to modify also the electronic structure (Parker 1975). The recent M6ssbauer study (Lu-San Pan and Evans 1978) indicates that at T > Tc the Fe z+ valency states may appear also in the A sublattice which may play a role in changing the character of the conduction process. The effect of small substitution or oxygen non-stoichiometry is twofold: The ordered phase becomes imperfect which lowers the temperature of the Verwey transition and makes it disappear for a certain critical impurity concentration. Besides, the ratio [Fe2+]/[Fe3+] is changed which introduces carriers into one of the split subbands (holes into the lower filled band or electrons into the empty higher one depending on the kind of impurity). In fig. 48 the thermopower versus temperature is plotted for single crystals with various degrees of oxidation. The
"~l
40
-40g
~"
-oi ~/,~ l
•
•
I
...
-
Ill
I,IIII
~-~,~
•
"
C
_,of \O.o/ o/ -200
/
'
"o
eo
s2o
1so
200
2~o
80
I2o
T(K)
Fig. 48. Absolute thermoelectric power vs temperature; after Kuipers (1978). (a) Experimental data for various magnetite single crystals. T h e lines are only meant as a guide to the eye. T h e vacancy concentration decreases from A to E. (b) Calculated values according the model of Kuipers and Brabers (1976), T denotes the cation vacancy concentration per formula unit.
OXIDE SPINELS t
,
i
267
,
,~ x : 8 . 1 0 -3 x x=3xlO v
-3
×=O
+ x' = 10 -4
0
~: : 1 0
"a
o x : 4 x l O -4 ,,?
\;:<:\ 0,% *,-o,
-2
,%\\
-3
-4
a i
i
I0
L
i
I°x
12
14
16
103/T (K -') 60 (lJ V. g -~ 2~ 0 )
-20
:~
t
-60
o Q.
£ co
- I00 ox:O
. x = l O -4
~,~. '~ ~. ~L PA
F..
,~ x = 4 . 1 0 -4 • x= 10 -3 x x : 3 ~ 10 -3
j - 180
/ 4.
b -22o
+ x = 8~10 -3
~o
1~o
1~o
I
2bo
240 T(K)
Fig. 49. Electrical properties of Ti-substituted magnetite Fe3-xTixO4 (Kuipers 1978). (a) Conductivity vs temperature relation. (b) Absolute thermoelectric power vs temperature.
268
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOV,~K
tendency of the Seebeck coefficient to become positive toward low temperatures is in agreement with the presence of positive charge carriers (holes) introduced into filled Fe 2+ subband by increasing the oxygen content and with possible temperature variations of their mobility. This also demonstrates the sensitivity of the ordered phase upon the oxygen non-stoichiometry; above the transition, on the other hand, the influence is poor because both subbands overlap and the relative change in the carrier number is very small. The impurity ions have similar effect as the cation vacancies: cations with valencies 1 or 2 diminish the number of Fe 2÷ and introduce holes; cations with higher valencies act as donors. But in both cases the effect is again small above the transition temperature. As an example of the higher valency substitutions the behaviour for Ti substituted magnetite is given in fig. 49. The lowering of the transition temperature introduced by various dopants is demonstrated in fig. 50. The critical concentration for the disappearance of the Verwey transition is usually about 0.1 per formula unit.
o\! 8
o
Ni
~, Co • AL • Cr
z~T
-5
-5
-10
-I0
-15
-15
o.b7
doe
0.03
Oa
M9
•
Zn
"'"
(K)
(K)
•
o
\ o
0.01
?.02
X
0.'03
Fig. 50. Lowering of the transition temperature Tv by various dopants (Miyahara 1972).
Stoichiometric and iron rich ferrites If the concentration of ions substituted in magnetite increases the resultant fluctuations of the electrostatic potential make the free motion of electronic carriers more and more difficult. With certain critical concentrations practically all carriers, i.e. the Fe 2+ valency states, are localized in local potential minima for T ~ 0 K. This is called the Anderson localization (Anderson 1958, 1970, Klinger and Samochvalov 1977). At finite temperatures, however, they may be thermally
O X I D E SPINELS
269
activated to hop to other places (ions) and contribute in this way to the electrical transport. The existence of hopping in the Fe2+-Fe 3÷ pairs in condition of a fluctuating local potential was demonstrated in M6ssbauer spectra of Ti substituted Zn ferrites (Van Diepen and Lotgering 1977). The o- versus T dependence may usually be fitted by the exponential law o-= A T -~ e x p ( - q / k T )
/3 = 0, 1
or
_3 2~
(43)
in a fairly broad temperature region. For bivalent substitutions the activation energy q varies from several hundredths of eV for Fe 2+ content to ~0.2 to 0.6 eV for compositions close to stoichiometric ferrites MFe204 (fig. 51). As was shown by Miyata (1961) the preexponential factor A is almost fully determined by the Fe 2+ content and practically does not depend on the kind and concentration of the other cations present. At low temperatures an application of eq. (43) to the experimental dependences would lead to gradually diminishing the effective activation energy which in the low temperature limit can be approximated by the Mott formula ( 4 2 ) - s e e , e.g., Simga and Schneeweiss (1972), Kuipers (1978). Representative room temperature values of electrical conductivity are given in table 29. According to the small T A B L E 29 Representative room temperature electrical data of spinel ferrites. Composition Fe304 (") Lio.sFe2.504 (a) Mno.5Fe2.504 (a) Mnl.0Fe2.oO4 (a) Mn12Fe1.804(~) Ni0.67Fe2.2304(a) Ni0.96Fe2.0404(a) CoFea.94Ti0.0304 (a) Co0.99Fez0104 (b) Cot.01Fel.9904 (b) Cu0.97Fe2.03O4(b) MgMn204 c°)
(r (~-1 cm a) 250 3.6 39.8 0.45 1.6 × 10-4 6.65 0.016 0.13 1.4 x 10-3 8.0 x 10-8 0.01 2.5 × 10-5
q (eV) nearly metallic 0.17 0.06 0.08 0.35 0.08 0.28 0.14 0.22 0.56 0.15 0.36
a (~VK l) -48
1
-500 - 118 -350 - 1000 - 328 -210 - 558 -460 +800 -- 40 +97
2 3 3 3 4 2 5 6 6 7 8
(~)single crystals (b) polycrystals 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
Ref.
Kuipers, A.J.M., Thesis, Technical Univ. Eindhoven (1978). Austin, I.G. and D. Elwell, 1970, Contempt. Phys. 11, 455. Simga, Z. et al., 1972, Proc. 11th ICPS Warsaw, p. 1294. Yamada, T., 1975, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 38, 1378. Yamada, T., 1973, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 35, 130. Jonker, G.H., 1959, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 9, 165. Rosenherg, M. et al., 1966, Phys. Status Solidi 15, 521. Rosenberg, M. and P. Nicolau, 1964, Phys. Status Solidi 6, 101.
270
S. KRUPI(~KA AND P. NOV/MK b-
0 "a
x. x x o xx x
o
o
= ;.=
q
~~
0,-
["-:" ]
-,% °\°,,.
"
\o 0%
xu ~'o
--o
Xx
\
0 ~
o,.,
qb~ O ~
E
0
x
h
~\
h \
&
-0\,%, °
'q
>~
4-
xx
o,
¢.~
~ 0
,q
-,,
~X °\
%
~
h\
\
"°\ °
~o
h h
N×
h h
\ X
[]
i
i
i
i
""
~'
,'7
,'?
i
i
i
i
~i
i
.
'
-4i
i
i
'
%1
o
~?1
z:Z~
A
•=
~"
~
t"-
i
Oo/, I,/
ob
,.~
+~
o
~E
~N.. ~ ~ 0 0
!I
~' o/
~
l---.B II
o
o
~;
/.Oo
o.O°o'~
II
oqo
I
oo / .
~
/ i
o--i
*o
Io, - / o l . o / t
'
~ o, ,o/iA,o~/,~ / o io,/o~,%.,o~ ~1
/
d°
,6
i,%o.O /
i
,po
i
~
P /
P
o
,o
/o 7, ??b%" :o -o'~
o ,d
%
,
/
/
l o / ¢ / /.o~ z
Io
~o ~,
.7V.
o
op
~ 1 ~ '-~
_o
io .,~.
/
/
oo/iO _o.O.O "-~" o ---°°°~ -
oo~.Oi~
~
i
I
I
~,
+ +
+o ~o
,--4 ~ . ~
~
~ZN
,-
OXIDE SPINELS
271
polaron hopping model which is believed to be relevant for the conduction mechanism of ferrites, the activation energy q is the sum of the energy qn needed for removing the electron from an Fe 2+ (i.e. the binding energy of the polaron) and of the mobility activation energy q~ connected with transferring an electron between Fe 2+ and Fe 3+ ions. q. may be directly deduced from the Seebeck coefficient versus T -1 dependence; examples of these dependences are given in fig. 52. ].0
i
~Oo
E
a
b.6
ox~o
0.4
-o
\
io
~
o~o-o ........
O. 2 ~-,,~o..~o.-e..o _o.
[~7 r
4 ~ ° '''~"
0~°~0
o.o_o.o-o--o--
&
O,
o--O--°
L
100
3
o~ o - o - - o _ o _ c-.- 4
~
300
I
500
700
900 T(K)
4
o CoFe~.9~Tioo30~ x Nio.e~.Fe2.330,~ ~' Mn°~Fezs04 o MnFe2q
.o"
Ioc
2.3
)
/ °'°
°°
/o 3
o
/
/°
o
a
/e ~
x~O X /
a
a
X
X
X
X
2 ~ -×I" / x~ ~.i
z&
z~
z~
x
z~
b o
'
~
'
;
'
~
'
8
'
1'o ' 1~ lOa/T (K -1) Fig. 52. Seebeck coefficients vs temperature relation for ferrites with various Fe 2+ content. (a) Polycrystalline samples (after Klinger and Samochvalov 1977): (1) Ll0.sFe0.0olFezsO4, " 2+ 3+ . (5) N"10.sFe0.2Fe2 2+ 3+04; (2) (N10.3Zn0.7)o.99Fe0.mFe2" 2+ 3+04 ,. (6) Ni0.6Fe0Z74Fe~+O4; (3) (N10.3Zn0.7)0.964Fe0.036Fe2" 2+ 3+O4," (7) Zn0.4Fe02+6Fe~+O4; (4) (N10.3Zn07)0.89Fe0.nFe2' 2+ 3+O4,. (8) Fe~+Fe3+O4. (b) Single crystals, measurements by Y a m a d a (1973) (©), Y a m a d a (1975) (x), Simga et al. (1972) (A), (Eli).
272
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOV~d( 12
tog ~ 10
O-
9
O~D,...,,~ - D - -
8
6
/ a
I
I
0.02
o.o~
0.'o6
o.b8
o.'1
E,
Fe2 +
f,.,,/r~2 + 6o 2+ Ni 2÷
b Fig. 53. (a) Influence of Mn and Co additions on the resistivity of Mg and Ni ferrites (Van Uitert 1956a, b, 1957): (1) MgFel.aMnxO4; (2) NiFel.gMnxO4z; (3) NiFel.gCoxO4_*. (b) The relevant level diagram (Elwell et al. 1963).
O X I D E SPINELS
273
When approaching stoichiometric ferrites MFe204 (M bivalent) both resistivity and activation energy are increased due to the lack of Fe 2+. This is because the energy levels of M 2+ ions are usually situated below those of Fe z+. From experiment we have the following sequence of levels: N i 2+ < C o 2+ < M n 2+ ~ F e 2+ ,
which at least at low temperatures prevents the occupation of an Fe 2+ state unless lower lying levels of M 2÷ are filled up (Lord and Parker 1960, Parker and Smith 1961, Elwell et al. 1963, 1966). This has been exploited in preparation of high resistivity ferrites using small additions of Co or Mn to, e.g., Mg or Ni ferrites (see fig. 53; Van Uitert 1956a, b, 1957). MnxFe3-x04 and CoxFe3-x04 systems
Some transition metal ions, e.g. Mn or Co, may exist in spinels like iron with various valency states. This enables us to extend the MxFe3-~O4 systems (M = Mn, Co) into their iron deficient regions. The relevant dependences are given in figs. 54-56. In CoxFe3-xO4 the Seebeck coefficient changes its sign at x = 1 where the valency exchange Fe2+~--Fe 3+ is replaced by Co2+~-~--Co3+; while the first corresponds to the electron (n-type) transport in the second one the Co 3+ holes hop from one Co 2+ to another. In MnxFe3 ~O4 the situation is more complicated because together with x the degree of inversion also changes (see section 1.5). F e 3 0 4 is an inverse spinel but MnFe204 is an almost normal one. It follows that there are still enough Fe ions in the B sublattice for 1 < x ~< 2 to play an active role in the conduction mechanism; it is only necessary to create carriers by exciting some electrons to Fe 2+ levels. This is the reason why the Seebeck coefficient does not change its sign at x = 1.
I0 8 6
(kT) 4 2 0 -2 -,~ -6 -8 -10 -12 -14 It) °Co
5
0
S
lO %Fog
Fig. 54. Thermopower e~-= e0T for COl-xFe2+xO4; 0.1 > x > - 0 . 1 (Parker 1975). Measurements of Jonker (1959) taken near 370 K. The full line was calculated by Parker.
274
S. KRUPICKA AND P. N O V ~ 8
i
~
i
z
t
i
~...x.°l i..>o
In R
o"
o.z
oO }
qCov)
6
0.6 _o.-~
5
__._....-..'"
~o~'~i ~1
0,5
/I
e
"~" ~'O~'o_
oe
1
0
o.1 L
I
I
I
1.10
~05
1.00
0.95
I
0.90 x
Fig. 55. Room temperature resistivity p and activation energy q for
i
0.5
" o x
q (ed
z~
CoxFe3-x04 (Jonker
1959).
I
Miyata
/
Lof:gering
Sim[a
o
1961 1964
/
1972
0.4
/ /o 0.3
z~
t°
0.2
0.1
05
10
15 x in Mn, Fea_~O~
Fig. 56. Activation energy of conductivity for MnxFe3-xO4 (Lotgering 1964, Simga et al. 1972).
OXIDE SPINELS
275
4.1.2. Dielectric constant
There are not many reliable data on dielectric constant E of ferrites and related spinels measured on the single crystals. The intrinsic E values were usually found to lie between 8 and 20. The very high dielectric constants often observed at low frequencies (fig. 57) have been ascribed to the effect of heterogeneity of the samples, i.e., pores and/or surface layers on grains, causing poor electrical contact between them (Koops 1951, Heikes and Johnston 1957, Krausse 1969). Sometimes some electronic polarization effect is supposed to be connected with the conduction hopping mechanism itself (and with some microscopic inhomogeneities related to it) which also could contribute to the low frequency dispersion of E (Rabkin and Novikova 1960, Rezlescu and Rezlescu 1974). For a general outline see Bosman and Van Daal (1970). At higher frequencies (cm wavelengths) the measured values may be regarded as insensitive to both of these contributions and they are usually taken as actual intrinsic dielectric constants corresponding to normal ionic and electronic polarizations. Some typical E values are given in table 30. In the frequency region of the lattice vibrations the ionic polarization becomes slow and damps out (infrared absorption) while the electronic polarization is fast enough to persist to the region of electronic excitations in near infrared and visible parts of the spectrum (crystal field and charge transfer transitions). To estimate the relative contribution of ionic and electronic polarizations, E measured in the near infrared and at microwave frequencies have to be compared. For NiFe204 the near infrared value is e ' = 7.0-+ 0.5 at A ~ 5 ~m (Miles et al. 1957). Taking E ~ 10 for the microwave region (see table 30) the contribution of ionic polarization would be ~3. As far as the temperature dependence is concerned, E usually increases with increasing temperature together with the electrical conductivity (Ioffe et al. 1957). Some Cu containing spinels were reported to show anomalies, however, in both temperature and frequency
i
1o5
!
.104
i
i
2
103
3
102 -
I0
6 1
10 2
103
1
104
1
105
t
10 6
1
10 z
108
Fr'equeney in els
Fig. 57. Dielectric constant e for various polycrystal]ine ferrites measured as a function of frequency (Van Uitert 1956b): (1) M n - Z n , (2) Cu-Zn, (3) N i - Z n , (4) NM1350, (5) N1250, (6) NM1250.
276
S. KRUPI(~KA AND P. N O V ~ TABLE 30 Microwave values of complex dielectric constant for some ferrites. Formula
Frequency (GHz)
E'
E"
Ref.
4.5
13.40
3.520
1
4.5
8.88
0.155
1
10 9.2 4.5
15 12.17 9.30
1 1.38 × 10-4 0.475
2 3 1
NiFe204 quenched NiFe204 slowly cooled Ni0,sZn0.sFe204 Ni0.gZn0.tMn0.02Fe204_+ MnFe204
1. Okamura, T., T. Fujimura and M. Date, 1952, Sci. Repts. Res. Inst. Tohoku Univ. A4, 191. 2. Miles, P.A., W.B. Westphal and A. von Hippel, 1957, Rev. Mod. Phys. 29, 279. 3. Kankowski, E.F. (unpublished)-after Von Aulock, Handbook of Microwave Ferrite Materials (Academic Press, New York, 1965).
dependences (Rezlescu and Rezlescu 1974). Note that relaxation maxima were observed in the temperature and frequency courses of the dielectric loss factor in the kHz r e g i o n - s e e fig. 58 (Kamiyoshi 1951). The interpretation is not entirely clear, however. The correlation of the relaxation maxima to the Fe z+ content and to the relevant electron hopping is demonstrated in fig. 59 (Samochvalov et al. 1967, see also Mizushima and Iida 1967, Mizushima et al. 1978). Z5
~ rj
Q) o
o" '
tab
~o '
I
- 50
0
100
50
r (°C) Fig. 58. tan 6 vs temperature at various frequencies f o r a slowly cooled CoFe204 (Kamiyoshi ]95]).
4.1.3. Optical and magnetooptical spectra The difference between the dielectric constant measured at microwaves and the one determined from the refractive index in the near infrared is typically ~ 3 to 10. It primarily corresponds to dispersion due to the phonon excitations w h o s e
O X I D E SPINELS 40 30
E', E'"
I
/,°
oO oo°
ooo°°°
15
30
C'
277
.°°e/ o
oT
U 2.o
/
o
o/
¢. 2 6 I oo°1 o ° 50 I00 T(K)
2.' o~'~ olo
c
o/ d
/o
2o
~o o-'1
o'
/o/~
"re/
/
Z,/' ..oy,o I -2" \o 10
~
__ol
o.o~ -o-
_"o°-- o- °~~ °o'-°o
"o,., ~ o~ /o / o o x
i..~o- io-c,-
~C~c - / / o
c,*
13
3"o
o_o=OL.oJ 0 ~°o9.~8°--#-°6"~cr°, 200
-
, ZOO
,
600
r(K) Fig. 59. Temperature dependence of the complex dielectric constant of magnetite (in the insert) and ferrites (Ni0.3Zn0.7)>xFe{+Fe204; (1) x = 0.085; (2) x = 0.049; (3) x = 0.01 (Samochvalov et al. 1967).
frequencies are lying in the far infrared. As we are dealing here with electronic excitations we postpone the discussion of the phonon spectra to the next paragraph and discuss first the near infrared and visible regions. The absorptions due to optical phonons are situated mostly below 0.1 eV. At photon energies above this limit a region of relative transparency occurs in most oxide spinels that are electrical insulators. This optical "window" is particularly broad and clear if the crystal contains no paramagnetic cations. The presence of transition metal ions (3d"), especially in magnetically ordered state, makes possible various electronic transitions that involve the crystal field split levels of these ions. These transitions modify the absorption edge, usually defined by the onset of interband transitions, by extending it towards the lower energies and adding several more or less distinct peaks. The situation is similar to that one in garnets, particularly Y3FesO12 (YIG), that is perhaps the most thoroughly investigated ferrimagnetic oxide as far as the optical properties are concerned (see e.g. Scott 1978). The possible types of transitions in YIG are schematically indicated in fig. 60. The Y3FesO12 garnet contains two Fe 3+ sublattices with octahedral and tetrahedral coordinations, respectively, and with mutually antiparallel magnetizations. Hence the inverse spinel ferrites not containing other transition metal ions except Fe 3÷ are expected to exhibit optical properties analogous to YIG. The examples are Li0.sFe2.sO4 and MgFe204; their absorption spectra in the near infrared are given in fig. 61 together with NiFe204. It seems that the presence of Ni 2+ brings no qualitative changes in this spectral region. Between 1 and 2 eV there do not exist enough reliable data due to the poor transparency of the
278
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOVekK
,p
~p (FO
4s (Fe)
aa (Fe 2,) "t
4 r, ~
2p (0 2-) tetrahearat
oclaheolral
Fig. 60. Schematic density-of-states plot for Y3FesO12 showing examples of various types of the optical transitions: (A) crystal field, (B) intersublattice Fe 3+ pair transitions, (C) 2p-+ 3d charge transfer, (D) 2p ~ 4s charge transfer, (E) 3d ~ 4d charge transfer; after Scott (1978).
samples. But the similarity to YIG may again be followed above 2 eV in fig. 62 where the diagonal elements of the dielectric function are plotted for both Li ferrite and YIG. Region 0.1 to i e V
The "window" between ~0.15 and 0.4 eV in fig. 61 is clearly indicated though it is not so deep and broad as in YIG. This may be at least partly due to imperfections (chemical non-stoichiometry, impurity ions, crystallographic defects). In particular, the optical absorption seems to be strongly influenced by the presence of octahedral Fe 2+ forming electronic charge carriers (see section 4.1.1). A good piece of evidence has been obtained by Sim~a et al. (1979, 1980) who studied the optical constants of MnxFe3_xO4 single crystals by reflectance and ellipsometric methods down to 0.5 eV and extended the spectra further to lower energies by Kramers-Kronig analysis. Figure 63 shows the spectral behaviour of the real and imaginary parts of the dielectric function. The peak in the vicinity of 0.5 eV which is very strong in magnetite (x = 0) diminishes with decreasing Fe 2÷ concentration (increasing x) and finally disappears for x ~> 1.1 where practically no Fe z+ is expected. The comparison with theoretical predictions points to the small polaron model which is adequate for describing this effect (Sim~a 1979). Similar low energy peaks were observed in magnetite also by other a u t h o r s - B u c h e n a u and Mfiller (1972) and Schlegel et al. (1979); the interpretation in the latter case was different, however, being based on the analogy with photoemission spectra.
OXIDE SPINELS
279
200 ! Log oc
(cmt)
2.0 \~. A
100 80
ii°sF°25
60
.__MgFe204
40 20 10 8 6 I I
I I
o.'12 o.~s
05
o'.~ o.'5 O.L6 0.1?0!8
05
E
(w)
Fig. 61. Near infrared absorption spectra of several spinel ferrites as compared with YIG (after Zanmarchi and Bongers 1969).
5
E,;'
,
",-,,
co'
~o
2
1
/
,/
....
YSo, o,~
-'--.
~Fe2.504
zo
i
a'o
i
42o
/~;
2
" ' ' ' Q i
51o
i
8.o
~o(eV) Fig. 62. Comparison of diagonal elements of the dielectric functions of Li ferrite and YIG (after Vigfiovsk!) et al. 1979b).
S. KRUPI(2KA AND P. NOVAK
280
14 12
l I t
I | I
10
I
8 6 4 2 I
i
I
i
I
I
~
I
I
"rT
__~~/~_ i
i
i
i
[
i
i
i
i
t
E;
7
",
/
~
.
Hn,,Fe.~G
Mno,~ Fe2,q
~
i
6 5 4 \
3
%
2 E(eV) i
i - -
E(eV) i
i
14, -r,
12-; ",
Fe~O,
Mno.5 Fe 2 5 O~
10 8
6
i
i
i
i
i
i
r
J
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
I
i
2
3
1
E (eV)
2
3
4-
E (~V)
Fig. 63. Real and imaginary parts of the dielectric function vs energy for Mn=Fe3-xO4spinels (Sim~a et al. 1979).
O X I D E SPINELS
281
Region 1 to 2 eV The transitions observed in this spectral range are usually identified as transitions between 3d levels split by the crystal field. For example, the steep increase of the absorption in NiFe204 in the vicinity of l e V (fig. 61) was ascribed to the Ni 2+ crystal field transition 3A2~3T2. This peak can be observed in the spectrum of NiO ()~ = 1.15 Ixm) and manifests itself also in a Faraday rotation dispersion of NiFe204 (Zanmarchi and Bongers 1969); its energy should be equal to the crystal-field splitting parameter zl = lODq. This transition, like all crystal field transitions in octahedrally coordinated ions, is parity-forbidden but may be allowed due to statical or dynamical violation of the local inversion symmetry. The parity restriction is not valid for tetrahedral cations (symmetry Td). On the other hand, the crystal field transitions in many cations including the important case of Fe 3+ are also spin-forbidden. The fact that in spite of the selection rules many of these transitions appear in the spectra can be understood when allowing a simultaneous excitation of a magnon so that AStot = 0 remains valid (see, e.g., Scott 1978). Another model uses the admixture of higher states via spin--orbit coupling (Clogston 1959); the spin is no longer a good quantum number and the spin constraint is automatically removed. But in most cases this fails to account for the observed oscillator strengths and some other effects (Scott et al. 1974, Dillon 1971). For assignment of various crystal field transitions the diagrams of crystal field levels for transition metal ions are being used (Sugano et al. 1970). The possible Fe 3+ crystal field transitions in YIG that should also occur in inverse spinel ferrites are listed in table 31. Note that the oscillator strengths are larger for tetrahedral coordination where the parity constraint is absent. T A B L E 31 Crystal field transitions in YIG at 77 K (after Scott 1978). Transition energy (eV) 1.372 1.804 2.000 ~ 2.100 2.445 2.568 2.652
2.792 2.994
Assignment 6Alg(65) --~4Tlg(4G) 6Alg(6S) ---->4T2g(4G) 6A1(6S) ~ *ra(4G) 6A 1(6S) ~ *r2(4G) 6A1(65)---)4E, 4Al(4G ) 6Alg(68) ~ 4Eg, 4Alg(4G) 6Alg(6S)-~ 4T2g(4D) 6A1(65) --~4T2(4D)
Site B B A A m B B A
Oscillator strength 2× 2× 8x 1.6 x 3.2 × 2x 1x 6x
10-5 10-5 10-5 10-4 10-s 10-s 10 -4 10-s
Region above 2 e V The spectra in this region are ascribed to charge transfer transitions, the most probable mechanism being the intersublattice transfer (Blazey 1974, Scott et al. 1975, Wittkoek et al. 1975), e.g.,
282
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOVSd~ (Fe 3+) + [Fe 3+] + hu -+ (Fe 4+) 5~ [Fe2+]
(see fig. 60). Other possibilities are biexciton transitions, i.e., simultaneous crystal field transitions in both sublattices with AStor= 0 (Blazey 1974, Krinchik et al. 1977) or charge transfer between 02- and Fe 3+ (fig. 60). But the oscillator strengths depending on Fe 3+ concentration and the fact that the diamagnetic dilution in any sublattice influences all absorptions (Krinchik et al. 1979) indicate the first model involving [Fe3+]-(Fe 3+) pairs is correct. At still higher energies (above 3-4 eV) also orbital promotion ( 3 d ~ 4s) or interband (2p ~ 4s) transitions become important.
Magnetooptical effects Unfortunately there are only scarce experimental data on spinels which can be directly compared with the above conclusions. One of them is the Li ferrite, studied by Malakhovsky et al. (1974) and Vigfiovsk~ et al. (1979, 1980a, b). The other ones are Mn-Fe spinels including magnetite, systematically investigated by Simga et al. (1979, 1980), and Ni and Co ferrites studied, e.g., by Kahn et al. (1969), Westwood and Sadler (1971), Krinchik et al. (1977, 1979) and Khrebtov et al. (1978). On the other hand, the assignment of various transitions can be often supported and completed on the basis of the magnetooptical data. They include the Faraday rotation - mainly in the near infrared (up to 1 eV) and both polar and transversal Kerr rotations above l e V . Actually, many of the references given above are partly or fully devoted to the magnetooptical studies. Sometimes also the reflectance circular dichroism has been examined from which both Faraday and Kerr rotations may be calculated (see, e.g., Ahrenkiel et al. 1974a, 1975). All magnetooptical effects are intimately related to the off-diagonal elements of the dielectric tensor function; both diagonal and off-diagonal elements are complex so that besides the index of refraction and absorption coefficient two additional independent measurements are necessary for determining the whole dielectric function (e.g. Kerr rotation and Kerr elipticity). Examples of the magnetooptical spectra of Li0.sFe2.504 and some other simple ferrites as compared with those of YIG are given in figs. 64(a) and (b). The spectral dependences are similar but the sign of rotation in spinel ferrites opposes that in YIG due to the opposite mutual orientation of sublattice and total magnetizations in both types of materials. As the magnetooptical effects depend on both diagonal and off-diagonal elements of the dielectric tensor function their strengths (magnetooptical activity) generally does not simply correspond to the oscillator strengths of the underlying optical transition. In order to obtain large magnetooptic effects the transition has also to be highly circularly polarized. An example of strong magnetooptical activity are spinels containing Co 2+ in A positions (Ahrenkiel et al. 1974b). This has been ascribed to the crystal field transitions 4A2(F)--+ 4T2(F ) and 4A2(F)--+ 4TI(P ) of CO2+(A). In fig. 65 the spectral dependence of the reflectance circular dichroism for some of such spinels measured on polycrystalline layers are shown.
OXIDE SPINELS
283
200 Io/°
.o.o.t_e.o-m-- o----re.
,,:,~.~"
~gFe, o~
,%0
E
-200
-400 c_
,,'/
iJ "o/ /
T = 300°K • o experimenf.a~
--
calculated
~- - 6 0 0
,i -800 a
~
- 100~
,~
~-
~
'
~,avel.eng~.h X (~m)
i
i
O.04
i r.,~,
b
i •" i ; ',,. i ' "',,o~..~,,'-. ,
:d !
~
....":":: '~
i
i
\~ .~ / . , . / - E; L F "~.J ~.-- :,, y/:. ~:/~ ~' /
i
~;
"£
~'J
.
"
..
,. ...... ...... f"
•
..~ ,' /
C; Y / G ~ '
" ' iI
2
.
',.0....'!, \ :, : ,,'I ',, ,. "../'"..... \ "~" ,' / ' , ~'x ." -~;z_~_J;( ;.~- \ :'.-.Z.g '- .>q
-0.04
b
.
: "
i
y". .
-I'
r.
•-~
i
~-
"/ ,.
4
....
-
' Ie
~ phol;on energy (eV)
Fig. 64. Comparison of magnetooptical behaviour of Fe spinels and YIG. (a) Faraday rotation in near infrared (Zanmarchi and Bonders 1969). (b) Spectral dependence of the complex off-diagonal element for YIG and Li ferrite (Vi~fiovsk~) et al. 1979b).
S. KRUPI(~KA AND P. NOV/~d,~
284
~
~
T - - T - - T - - r - -
4
20
~
ReD (%)
Rco(o/o)
_ _ Co Rh, 5 Feo 50,; j ' .
12
2 ,,
,,
0
0 l
-4
-e ,,,,
\
ll~l
0.6
- 12
0.8
~
[0
1.2
~
1.4
~
¢.6
~
1.8
-20
Fig. 65. Reflectance circular dichroism of CoRhl.sFe0.sO4 and CoCr204 at 80 K (Ahrenkie] and Coburn
1975).
4.2. Mechanical and thermal properties 4.2.1. Infrared spectra The first important paper on the infrared spectra of spinels was published by Waldron (1955). To explain the experimental data obtained for seven ferrite spinels Waldron refers to a rhombohedral unit cell containing only 14 ions (for a normal spinel MFe204 it consists of two MO4 tetrahedra and one Fen tetrahedron). Four modes were found to be infrared active. Two of them, having the higher frequency, were supposed to arise from the motion of the oxygen ions, the remaining two were assigned to the motions of the cations only. Group theory, taking the full cubic crystallographic unit cell into account, was applied to the vibrational problem by White and De Angelis (1967) and by Lutz (1969). Waldron's conclusion that only four modes are infrared active in an ideal normal spinel was proved to be right, the origin of modes was, however, found to be more complex. Very thorough experimental investigation of infrared spectra of normal spinels, performed by Preudhomme and Tarte (1971a, b, 1972) confirmed the complexity of the problem. Typical infrared patterns for normal 2-3 spinels are shown in fig. 66, the observed frequencies are summarized in table 32. It is to be mentioned that Grimes (1972b) suggested an entirely different explanation of infrared spectra of spinels based on the two-phonon processes. The calculation of the force constants of thiospinels was performed by Brtiesch and D'Ambrogio (1972), Lutz and Haueuseler (1975) and Lauwers and Herman (1980). The last authors made corresponding analysis also for MgA1204 and ZnGa204 spinels. When the symmetry of the spinel structure is lower than cubic or/and supplementary ordering of cations exists, more infrared bands may appear (White and De Angelis 1967). A splitting of one infrared band is observed in some spinels containing octahedraUy coordinated Jahn-Teller ions Mn 3+ and Cu 2+ (table 33). It is to be noted that the bands may be split also due to the presence of two different kinds
OXIDE SP1NELS i
i
i
i
i
285 i
i
~
i
80 60 o~ 40 20 4° #_
_
i
__
8O 60 40 20
80 60 40
Zn Fe2 04
20 800
'
600
4bo
Cm-1
' 2bo
Fig. 66. Typical infrared patterns for three normal 2-3 spinels (Preudhomme and Tarte 1971b). of ions in the same sublattice. Such a splitting exists, e.g., in the system ZnAlxCr2-xO4 ( P r e u d h o m m e and Tarte 1971b). 4 . 2 . 2 . JUlastic c o n s t a n t s
There are only few spinels for which all the elastic constants are known. Corresponding values at room temperature together with the anisotropy factor A = 2 c 4 4 / ( c l l - cl2) are summarized in table 34 (for an isotropic material A = 1). It is seen that NiCr204 and to some extent TiFe204 differ markedly from other spinel systems as far as the elastic constants are concerned. This anomaly is connected with the cooperative Jahn-Teller effect (section 1 . 6 ) - f o r NiCr204 the corresponding critical t e m p e r a t u r e TjT is close to room temperature. In the vicinity of Trr the elastic response of the system is sensitive to the t e m p e r a t u r e - t h e crystal softens (at least to some extent) as TIT is approached. For the system NixZnl_xCr204 this softening is demonstrated in fig. 67. A similar situation exists also in TiFezO4 (see section 3.1.3) and FeCrzO4, the corresponding temperatures TjT are low, h o w e v e r , compared to NiCr204. For spinels which do not contain Jahn-Teller ~ions the elastic constants depend only weakly on the t e m p e r a t u r e (e.g. Kapitonov and Smokotin 1976).
S. KRUPIOKA AND P. NOV~6d~2
286
TABLE 32 Infrared absorption bands of several spinels.
System
Absorption bands (cm-1) /21 v2 /23 iv4
Fe304 NiFe204 CoFe204 MnFe204 ZnFe204 CdFe204 CoCr204 MgAI204 Fe2GeO4 NizGeO4
570 593 575 545 552 548 630 688 688 690
390 404 374 390 425 412 530 522 402 453
268 330 320 335 336 319 402 580 319 335
178 196 181
Ref. 1 1 2 3 4 4 4 4 5 5
166 197 309 178 199
1. Grimes, N.W. and A.J. Collet, 1971, Nature (Phys. Sci.) 230, 158. 2. Waldron, R.D., 1955, Phys. Rev. 99, 1727. Mitsuishi, A. et al., 1958, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 13, 1236. 3. Brabers, V.A.M. and J. Klerk, 1974, Solid State Commun. 14, 613. 4. Preudhomme, J. and P. Tarte, 1971, Spectrochim. Acta 27A, 1817. 5. Preudhomme, J. and P. Tarte, 1972, Spectrochim. Acta 28A, 69.
TABLE 33 Splitting of the /24 band in three spinels exhibiting the cooperative Jahn-Teller effect (after Siratori 1967). Compound ZnMn204 Mn304 CuCr204
/2~ ,
/22 t
/24 $
c/a
265 cm-1 247 135
167 cm -1 165 194
232 cm -1 220 155
1.14 1.16 0.91
* Stronger line of the split v4. + Weaker line of the split /24' $ Weighted mean of the two lines.
I n t a b l e 35 t h e d a t a o n t h e e l a s t i c m o d u l i a n d t h e c o m p r e s s i b i l i t y m e a s u r e d o n polycrystalline ferrites at r o o m t e m p e r a t u r e are given. W e n o t e t h a t in a n a l o g y t o t h e m a g n e t i c r e l a x a t i o n , a n e l a s t i c r e l a x a t i o n w a s o b s e r v e d in s o m e s p i n e l f e r r i t e s ( G i b b o n s 1957, I i d a 1967) c o n n e c t e d w i t h d i f f u s i o n a n d r e a r r a n g e m e n t p r o c e s s e s in t h e l a t t i c e .
OXIDE SP1NELS
287
TABLE 34 Elastic constants of several spinels (in units of 10-11 dyn/cm) at room temperature. A is the anisotropy factor (see text). System
cx
MgA1204 Fe304 NiFe204 Lio.sFez504 ZnCr204 FeCr204 NiCr204 TiFe204
c~2
27.9 15.3 27.5 10.4 21.99 10.94 24.07 13.41 25.57 14.23 32.2 14.4 17.5 17.1 cu cm = 2.65
c44
A
Ref.
15.3 9.55 8.12 9.29 8.46 11.7 5.86 3.96
2.43 1.12 1.47 1.74 1.49 1.31 24.1 2.99
1 2 3 4 5 6 5 7
1. 2. 3. 4.
Lewis, M.F., 1966, J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 40, 728. Doraiswami, M.S., 1947, Proc. Indian Acad. Sci. A25, 413. Gibbons, D.F., 1957, J. Appl. Phys. 28, 810. Kapitonov, A . M . and E.M. Smokotin, 1976, Phys. Status Solidi a34, K47. 5. Kino, Y. et al., 1972, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 33, 687. 6. Hearmon, R.F.S., 1956, Adv. Phys. 5, 323. 7. Ishikawa, Y. and Y. Syono, 1971, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 31, 461.
vt3 f x=O
(krns")
2
?
o.~"
x : 0.37
TN oo• °
J
f
•
x = 0.73
."
e •
F
r.
(X) Fig. 67. Soft mode sound velocity Vt=[(Cll--Cl2)/2p] lj2 as a function of temperature in a NixZnl-xCr204 system. Ta, TN are the critical temperatures for cooperative Jahn-Teller transition and the N6el transition respectively (Kino et al. 1972).
4.2.3. H e a t capacity In f e r r i m a g n e t i c s p i n e l s t h e specific h e a t at l o w t e m p e r a t u r e s ( T < Tc, OD) is d o m i n a t e d by t h e m a g n e t i c c o n t r i b u t i o n . T h e t e m p e r a t u r e d e p e n d e n c e of Cp is t h e n w e l l d e s c r i b e d by t h e spin w a v e t h e o r y , w h i c h p r e d i c t s Cp ~ T a/2 ( s e c t i o n 2.4). A t h i g h e r t e m p e r a t u r e s t h e l a t t i c e c o n t r i b u t i o n ( p r o p o r t i o n a l t o T s f o r
S. KRUPI(~KA A N D P. NOV_,~d(
288
T A B L E 35 Elastic moduli of several polycrystalline ferrites; after Seshagiri Rao et al. (1971).
System
X-ray density (g/cm 3)
MgFe204 CoFe204 NiFe204 ZnFe204
Elastic moduli (1011 dyn/cm 2) E n k
4.52 5.29 5.38 5.33
19.73 17.34 15.59 18.64
7.34 6.54 5.89, 7.27
21.17 16.62 14.69 14.27
/3 × 1013 (cm2/dyn)
Poisson ratio
4.72 ,6.02 6.81 7.01
0.34 0.33 0.32 0.28
T < OD) prevails. An example of the temperature dependence of Cp is shown in fig. 68. In table 36 the values of C. at room temperature are summarized together with the values of Debye temperatures OD deduced from the low temperature measurements. Venero and Westrum (1975) noted that at elevated temperatures the lattice part of Cp for spinels may be well described by Kopp's rule based on the component oxides. For example for normal 2-3 spinels: Cp(AB204) = Cp(AO) + Cp(B203). T(K) 100
200
300
400
40
.-.
i....-- ............
,-"
"-'20
•
_~°~ /
//
/
t
~
,
,~
0
03
I
o"°
: / 0 L-'-'~°
600
mm.m.m"m "ww~m" mrm m m'm''m'm'am~
-~ 30
,o
500
~
10
/"
dO, "~
./ o/°/-Io,I ~o k
,
20
,
3'0
,
T(K)
I
40
Fig. 68. Heat capacity vs temperature for Li0.sFe2.504(O) and Lio.sAlzsO4 (O) (Venero and Westrum 1975).
4.2.4. Thermal conductivity Thermal conductivity is a composite e f f e c t - i n magnetic spinels besides phonons, both electrons and magnons may participate in the transfer of heat. It was shown,
OXIDE SPINELS
289
TABLE 36 Thermal properties of several spinels. Cp
K
ff x 10 6
(K-1)
(cal/K moo
Fe304 NiFe204
36.18 34.81
660 625(7)*
0.015 0.009
CoFe204 MnFe204 CuFe204 ZnFe204 MgFe204 Li0.sFe2.504
36.53
584 (10)*
0.015 0.017 0.015 0.015
MgAI204
Oo (K)
(cal/s cm K)
System
33.22 34.43 27.79
762 (15)* 512(5)
0.015 0.036
8
12 7.5 12 4.61t 5.905
Ref. 1, 5, 6 3, 4, 7, 12 3, 4, 9 8, 12 9 1, 6, 11 4 2, 4, 9, 14 3, 10, 13
* Nonstoichiometric samples. ~ Natural spinel. Synthetic spinel. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14.
Bartel, J.J. and E.F. Westrum, Jr., 1975, J. Chem. Thermodyn. 7, 706. Venero, A.F. and E.F. Westrum, Jr., 1975, J. Chem. Thermodyn. 7, 693. King, E.G., 1956, J. Phys. Chem. 60, 410; 1955, Ibid 59, 218. Kouvel, J.S., 1956, Phys. Rev. 102, 1489. Polack, S.R. and K.R. Atkins, 1962, Phys. Rev. 125, 1248. Smit, J. and H.P. Wijn, 1959, in: Ferrites (Wiley, New York) p. 225. Kamilov, I.K., 1963, Sov. Phys-Solid State 4, 1693. Suemune, Y., 1966, Jap. J. Appl. Phys. 5, 455. Smit, J. and H.P. Wijn, 1954, Physical Properties of Ferrites, in: Advances in Electronic and Electron Physics (Acad. Press, New York) vol. 6, 83. Slack, G.A., 1964, Phys. Rev. 134A, 1268. Weil, L., 1950, Compt. Rend. 231, 122. Bekker, Y.M., 1967, Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR Neorg. Mater. 3, 196. Singh, H.P. et al., 1975, Acta Crystallogr. A3I, 820. Brunel, M. and F. de Bergevin, 1964, Compt. Rend. 258, 5628.
however, that in spinels the role of m a g n o n s is n e g a t i v e ( D o u t h e t a n d F r i e d b e r g 1 9 6 1 ) - they cause a scattering of p h o n o n s thus r e d u c i n g the t h e r m a l conductivity. T h e c o n t r i b u t i o n of electrons to the heat transfer is b e l i e v e d to be small in spinels (Slack 1962). T h e c o n d u c t i v i t y is very sensitive to the i m p u r i t i e s particularly to the t r a n s i t i o n m e t a l ions with an orbitally d e g e n e r a t e g r o u n d level (fig. 69). I n table 36 the t h e r m a l c o n d u c t i v i t y at r o o m t e m p e r a t u r e for several spinels is given.
4.2.5. T h e r m a l expansion F o r most spinels the t e m p e r a t u r e d e p e n d e n c e of the lattice p a r a m e t e r a m a y b e well a p p r o x i m a t e d by a = ao+ b o T + b~T 2.
290
S. KRUPIOKA AND p. NOVzid<
,'I / J
"d
,o'°""o,.
o
\
°\ \
~o.2°o '~ /
•
\
o
-6 E
/
24×I0-
'.0
o
30
~oo 300 ¢ooo T(K)
Fig. 69. Temperature dependence of the thermal conductivity for Mg~_xFe~A/204system (Slack 1964). Substitution of Fe 2+ ions into the A sublattice (orbital/y degenerate 2E ground state with a weak Jahn-Teller coupling) leads to pronounced reduction of the conductivity.
20
~'103
x =-
15
0.9 1.0 0.6
0.8 0.Tj,.Y~~
5
400
500
T (K) Fig. 70. Linear expansion coefficient ee vs temperature for Ni, Znl-xFe204 ferrites (after HenrietIserentant and Robbrecht 1972). The extrema of a appear at To
OXIDE SP1NELS
291
However, the onset of ithe magnetic order causes an anomaly in the temperature dependence of a connected with the volume magnetostriction-this is demonstrated for the example of the\NixZnl_xFe204 system in fig. 70. Values of the linear expansion coefficient a
Og
--
1 Oa a OT-
bo/a + (2bJa)T+...
are given in table 36.
Appendix: Intrinsic magnetic properties In this part some additional data mainly concerning the. intrinsic magnetic properties of the most important ferrimagnetic spinels are given. For more complete or detailed information the reader should consult the following literature: (a) Books and tables: Landolt-B6rnstein tables, New Series, ed., K.H. Hellwege and A.M. Hellwege (Springer Verlag 1970) vol. 4, part b. J. Smit and H.P.J. Wijn: Ferrites (Wiley, New York, 1959). S. Krupi6ka: Physik der Ferrite und der verwandten magnetischen Oxide (Academia Praha-Vieweg, Braunschweig, 1973). Handbook of Microwave Ferrite Materials, ed., W.H. von Aulock (Academic Press, New York and London, 1965). A. Oleg et al.: Tables of Magnetic Structures determined by Neutron Diffraction (Inst. of Nuclear Techniques, Krakow, 1970). (b) Papers: E.W. Gorter: Philips Res. Rep. 9 (1954), 295, 321, 403 (crystal chemistry and ferrimagnetism). 120
'i
~
~
'
100
8o
co/ ~
-273-200-100
~
0
ZOO 200
300
400 500 600 T(°C)
700
Fig. 71, Temperature dependence of magnetization of several ferrites (Smit and Wijn 1959), the measurements were made by Pauthenet (1950), (1952).
292
S. KRUPI~KA AND P. NOVI~K
26L' ......... i o o o o'o : OOOOooo ~-
°OOoo
~
a
4I 1
co
~, ,~~-
.%b
Kb o O ooo o°°
81
~,,
=
Kbb
2~oo8888o'~ ................ OI eKCIG °°°o °O Ooo
Ku°°o °°°°
-
f 20
40
60
80
I00 120
T(K) Fig. 72. Temperature dependence of the anisotropy constants of magnetite below the Verwey transitions (Chikazumi 1975). The free energy is expressed as: F = Fo + Kaoe~ + Kba 2 -guog211 q- gaaOd4 + KbbOL4 + KabOg2aOL2 where aa, oq,, oem are the direction cosines of the magnetization with respect to the monoclinic a, b axes and [111] respectively.
15
x~x
.KI .iO 4
×
\
./;./ I°!2,,s F%04
°-,~,.k."~-~,a04
4 0/25
_1~i ! -155~' :I." -185 °C I 0,'50
0/75
NiOFe203
Fig. 73. NixFe3-xO4 system. First anisotropy constant K1 plotted for several temperatures as a function of Ni-content x (Elbinger 1962).
OXIDE SPINELS
293
n
i
n -
~o
%
.~ -40
O. ~ o ~
o ~
o--
O.z~ ° " - " e ~
o - - - o ~
o--o
o...___.. °
,N--O
0 o ~ £ O ~
O~
J"'~ 0 ~ 8
O'O-- O - - O - -
O ~ O ~
O_O
-2o ~
O~
I ' ~
O ...........~ O ......~ O ~
0
E 0
3bo T(K) i
i
80
0 " "
/./,.-"0"-""
x
/ 60
/
/"
,o n~
0.2
. /
.....
-::
,,.z%.-........ o;
E
,0
0
,~'0
0.8
o--o--O--O--
-20
.o--o
1~o
~bo
, o--o--o
e'5o
' ebo
abo r(K)
Fig. 74. NixFe3-xO4 system. Magnetostrictions A]00 and An1 plotted against temperature for several Ni-concentrations x (Brabers et al. 1980). 0.5
-0.5
~
,
,
,
,
~ / / / i " :~~ ' ~ ' , o ~
~/////
? _,,o
~--.o ~,/ -e.s
,
\\i
,
o
,
,
~ o~ ~
\llx/o~
,
.
.x
'°°
\~o/ o.t11"
o.'2 o'.~ o:e o:e /o I.? I.? 7.'6 ~.'o X
Fig. 75. MnxFe3-,O4 system. First anisotropy constant Kx plotted for several temperatures as a function of Mn-content x (Penoyer and Shafer 1959).
S. K R U P I C K A A N D P. N O V A K
294
tO0 80
°'~°~°'°°'o
120 x
E
60
/°/°
~'%~Du
+
-A ~oo" I0 ~
& ..< 40
°I
/i
~ ,
o oo_o.o~o,o
20
o¢~''\o
.~,~ I.F
100 •...a. o
1.0
A!oo
1.9
oo
80
0
-20
- - % - co-o- 0-°--% "o ~ o _ .o~ 2o ~. °. . .
-40
, ~ ' ' ' - ~- ' ~ o ' ~ . ,.........,..-~
~o /
x o
-60
e
0.85
0.40
*
0.95
-150 -lO0
"~ 0 . ¥ 5
•
1.05
o tt
60
,, e , i ,, i -I..,.+,~, x ~ - X . x . I ..~l
-50 T (°C)
b
t
,t sI
20
-5'0
/:{
40
a
\
I
x
O. tO
•
o,
x
"\ %-
\
'~a
X~x~
+"4-
I
\.
~
~4-
•
\
'A'~'a ×,~.
o.o.o-
L
i
02
0;4
i
de
i
018 r/rc
Fig. 76. MnxFe3 xO4 system. Temperature dependence of magnetostrictions ,~100, Zlklll- (a) x ~< 1.05 (Miyata and Funatogawa 1962); (b) 1.9~> x i> 1 (Brabers et al. 1977); Am is small and negative ( - 5 x 10-6~
1.
G. Blasse: Philips Res. Rep. (1964), Suppl. no. 3 (crystal chemistry and ferrimagnetism). A. Broese van Groenou, P.F. Bongers and A.L. Stuyts: Mater. Sci. Eng. 3 (1968/69), 317 (review paper).
/4
I
\
CO,:Fe3_xO4
\
~3 f... cb
2
% x=O.04
\÷ o
\+
~x=oofo~ "%+
+-
0%0 °~Oo 4"°~°'~"oo °~°e°°'°°
o. . . . . . . . . .
i~,OCLo_o..____%_o
x=O
%0
i
200
5o0 T(K)
Fig. 77. Temperature dependence of K1 for Co-substituted magnetite (Bickford et al. 1957).
OXIDE SPINELS
100 K,.lO-~rg/cm3 I 50!
295
':N'°'o-%\ R@, \4,
0
i
o
50
,A
" "o.
-50
t
"o\o% ~ 150 Q~
o..%~ %
~" ~ ' > ' ~ - o - o _ ~ ; . . . . . .Q,,o-O ~ z ~ / ~ t k . ~~a'~:-.~.~'°--~o ~" o ~ o
-150
~
i
i
250
300
...o.o°
r/~/~ [~ .
i X = 02
l e t ~'-~
~... ~ /o
-I00
,
200
~/~o.~
_ o ~ . x:o.8 b~=o.o
~2~.~o~_o-/o
~= 0.2
~o o..o- ~-o.1 \'o~--o-°"°'...K~ *"~-a~,~ ~,~ I r ~ ' ~ - ¢ /(= 005 "
Fig. 78. Temperature dependence of K1 for MgxFe3 xO4 system (Brabers et al. 1980).
10
4t0.1
0.15
0.2 * 4.2K • 77K
-IO A
,o -20
~
~
~
~
A 300K
~-
" ; i
×
-30 L
t
Fig. 79. Dependence of magnetostrictions Am0, /~111 for MgFe204 on the degree of inversion 8 (after Arai 1973).
296
S. K R U P I C K A A N D P. N O V / k K
•
t"- q'3
r',- oo
oq
t"q t"q
d
),(
~5
z
oq. q3
t"q ,,.~
I
oo'~,
O e'~
I
o
o'3 ~,~
I
~D
I
I
I
I
I
I
X
/'q
u'3 t",,I ~-.a ee3
er~ eel
I
I
I
I
',,O P,-
I
X
q3
P'-
~,o
~
oq
eq I
I
,-.t
_=
o0
;>
I
e,,
.'= E O
?
,-...
¢e3
x~
I
t"'- t"q
~rq.
~5
"O
I
.,o e¢3 e-.
7
02
I
×~ (,.q
c5 I
t",- G', tt~
I
I
I
I
I
]
I
I
r~
o. t"q
I
I
I
I
,...-~ , ~
t'e3 e¢3
¢¢3 ee)
02
o (",,I
'~" 0 ~ e¢3 0'3
O 02 P-,- o o
~ ) tt3 q3 tr3 ~1~
1"-,-
17-,-
tt3 p--
oo
G'~ ©
E
q eq
o .¢)
eq
¢)
2
e~
r)
OXIDE
o
~
SPINELS
u
297
~
0
b
o
0
0
r~
©
u:
x
= -=
oo
r~
d 'E
©
.= :0 0 "O
~
M
~.,~ •
©
'.~
,
~~ ~ ~~ ~:~
~'~
~ ~=~
&
N
eg~e
~e~g
a
~
t---
~
...-k
0
© e.
~ ' - ~ ..~ . ~
..
~
~,o 0
a
~mN
,~
©
<
.~
= .~ .~ .~
~.~ ~-~ ~.~ --
a) ; ~ ' ~
~
~oo~, Nco~
,._;
~.~
N
~g
- ~ 2~
,. •~ .r.
..o r.,4 ~ ~ >: •
~ i ~ ~ ~~ ~ '~
S. KRUPI(~KA AND P. NOVAK
298
TABLE 38 Hyperfine magnetic fields in kOe at an A-site Fe 57 nucleus, a B-site iron nucleus with six nearest neighbor A-site iron ions, and the average field at the B-site iron nuclei in various ferrimagnetic spinels (van der Woude and Savatzky 1971). Ferrite MgFe204(sc) MgFe204(q) MnFe204 NiFe204 CoFezO4(sc) CoFe204(q) Li0.sFez.sO4 ZnFe204
Hhpf(A)
Hhpf(B,6nn Fe)
Hhpf(B)
-500 - 509 - 512 - 515 - 511 - 511 -518 -
-537 - 540 - 550 - 555 - 545 550 -545 - 557 (a)
-530 - 525 - 520 - 555 - 541 - 536 -545 - 485
(a) Obtained by adding supertransferred hyperfine field to Hhpf, sc and q indicate slowly cooled and quenched samples respectively.
Acknowledgement The authors acknowledge valuable discussions and the help of Dr. Simga when p r e p a r i n g t h i s c h a p t e r . G r a t i t u d e is a l s o e x p r e s s e d t o D r . Z f i v 6 t a f o r his c r i t i c a l r e a d i n g of t h e m a n u s c r i p t .
References Adler, D., 1968, Insulating and Metallic States in Transition Metal Oxides, in: Solid State Physics, eds., Seitz, F., D. Turnbull and H. Ehrenreich (Academic Press, New York, London) vol. 21, pp. 1-113. Ahrenkiel, R.K. and T.J. Coburn, 1975, IEEE Trans. Magn., MAG-11, 1103. Ahrenkiel, R.K., T.J. Coburn and E. Carnall, Jr., 1974a, IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-10, 2. Ahrenkiel, R.K., T.J. Coburn, D. Pearlman, E. Carnall, Jr., T.W. Martin and S.L. Lyu, 1974b, AIP Conf. Proc. 24, 186. Ahrenkiel, R.K., S.L. Lyu and T.J. Coburn, 1975, J. Appl. Phys. 46, 894. Aiyama, Y., 1966, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 31, 1684. Akino, T., 1974, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 36, 84.
Akino, T. and K. Motizuki, 1971, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 31, 691. Alvarado, S.F., W. Eib, F. Meier, D.T. Pierce, K. Sattler, H.C. Siegmann and J.P. Remeika, 1975, Phys. Rev. Lett. 34, 319. Alvarado, S.F., M. Erbudak and P. Munz, 1977, Physica 86--88B + C, 1188. Anderson, P.W., 1956, Phys. Rev. 102, 1008. Anderson, P.W., 1958, Phys. Rev. 109, 1492. Anderson, P.W., 1959, Phys. Rev. 115, 2. Anderson, P.W., 1963, Exchange in Insulators, in: Magnetism, eds., Rado, G.T. and H. Suhl (Academic Press, New York, London) vol. 1, pp. 25-86. Anderson, P.W., 1970, Comments Solid State Phys. 11, 193.
OXIDE SPINELS Arai, K.I., 1.973, Rep. Res. Inst. Electr. Commun. Tohoku Univ. 25, 79. Arai, K.I. and N. Tsuya, 1973, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 34, 431. Arai, K.I. and N. Tsuya, 1974, Phys. Status Solidi b66, 547. Arai, K.I. and N. Tsuya, 1975, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 36, 463. Aubert, G., 1968, J. Appl. Phys. 39, 504. Baltzer, P.K., 1962, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 17, Suppl. B-l, 192. Barth, T.F.W. and E. Posnjak, 1932, Z. Kristallogr. 82, 325. Baszyfiski, J. and Z. Frait, 1976, Phys. Status Solidi b73, K85. Bernstein, P. and T. Merceron, 1977, J. Phys. (France) 38, C1-211. Bertaut, F., 1951, J. Phys. Rad. 12, 252. Bickford, L.R., J.M. Brownlow and R.F. Penoyer, 1957, Proc. Inst. Electr. Eng. 104B, 238. Birss, R.R., 1964, Symmetry and Magnetism (North-Holland, Amsterdam) ch. 5, §3. Blasse, G., 1964, Philips Res. Rep. Suppl. no. 3. Blasse, G., 1965, Philips Res. Rep. 20, 528. Blasse, G. and E.W. Goner, 1962, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 17, Suppl. B-l, 176. Blazey, K.W., 1974, J. Appl. Phys. 45, 2273. Boshaan, A.J. and H.J. van Daal, 1970, Adv. Phys. 19, 1. Bouchard, R.J., 1967, Mater. Res. Bull. 2, 459. Brabers, V.A.M., 1971, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 32, 2181. Brabers, V.A.M., J. Klerk and Z. Simga, 1977, Physica 86--88B + C, 1461. Brabers, V.A.M., T. Merceron, M. Porte and R. Krishnan, 1980a, J. Mag. Mag. Mater. 15-18, 545. Brabers, V.A.M., J.C.J.M. Terhell and J.H. Hendriks, 1980b, J. Mag. Mag. Mater. 15-18, 599. Bradburn, T.E. and G.R. Rigby, 1953, Trans. Br. Ceram. Soc. 52, 417. Bragiflski, A., 1965, Phys. Status Solidi 11, 603. Bragiflski, A. and T. Merceron, 1962, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 17, 1611. Broese van Groenou, A., 1967, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 28, 325. Broese van Groenou, A. and R.F. Pearson, 1967, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 28, 1027. Broese van Groenou, A., P.F. Bongers and .A.L. Stuyts, 1968, Mater. Sci. Eng. 3, 317. BriJesch, P. and F. D'Ambrogio, 1972, Phys. Status Solidi 50, 513.
299
Briining, S. and H.Ch. Semrnelhack, 1979, Conference on Physics of Magnetic Materials COMECON, Dresden, unpublished. Buchenau, M., 1975, Phys. Status Solidi b70, 181. Buchenau, U. and I. Mfiller, 1972, Solid State Commun. 11, 1291. Buckwald, R.A., A.A. Hirsch, D. Cabib and E. CaUen, 1975, Phys. Rev. Lett. 35, 878. Callen, E., 1968, J. Appl. Phys. 39, 519. Carr Jr., W.J., 1966, Secondary Effects in Ferromagnetism, in: Handbuch der Physik, ed., Fliigge, S. (Springer Verlag, Heidelberg, Berlin, New York) vol. 18/2. Chikazumi, S., 1975, Technical Report ISSP ser. A, no. 737. Clogston, A.M., 1955, Bell Syst. Tech. J. 34, 739. Clogston, A.M., 1959, J. Phys. Rad. 20, 151. Cullen, J.R. and E. Callen, 1970, J. Appl. Phys. 41, 879. Cullen, J.R. and E. Callen, 1973, Phys, Rev. B7, 397. De Boer, F., J.H. van Santen and E.J.W. Verwey, 1950, J. Chem. Phys. 18, 1032. Delorme, C., 1958, Bull. Soc. Fr. Mineral. Crystallogr. 81, 79. / Dillon Jr., J.F., 1971, Magneto-Optical Properties of Magnetic Crystals, in: Magnetic Properties of Materials, ed., Smit, J. (McGrawHill, New York) p. 149-204. Drabble, J.R., T.D. White and R.M. Hooper, 1971, Solid State Commun. 9, 275. Driessens, F.C.M., 1968, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 72, 1123. Dunitz, J.D. and L.E. Orgel, 1957, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 3, 20, 318. Eibschiitz, M., V. Ganiel and S. Strikman, 1966, Phys. Rev. 151, 245. Elbinger, G., 1962, Z. Angew. Phys. 4, 274. Elwell, D., R. Parker and A. Sharkey, 1963, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 24, 1325. Elwell, D., B.A. Griffiths and R. Parker, 1966, Br. J. Appl. Phys. 17, 587. Englman, R., 1972, The Jahn-Teller Effect in Molecules and Crystals (Wiley, New York). Evans, B.J., 1975, AIP Conf. Proc. 24, 73. Faller, J.G. and C.E. Birchenall, 1970, J. Appl. Crystallogr. 3, 496. Fazekas, P., 1972, Solid State Commun. 10, 175. Folen, V.J., 1960, J. Appl. Phys. 31, 166S. Fujii, Y., G. Shirane and Y. Yamada, 1975, Phys. Rev. Bll, 2036.
300
S. KRUPI~2KA AND P. NOV.~d(
Gehring, G.A. and K.A. Gehring, 1975, Rep. Progr. Phys. 38/1, 5. Gerber, R., 1968, Czech. J. Phys. B18, 1204. Gerber, R. and G. Elbinger, 1964, Phys. Status Solidi 4, 103. Gerber, R. and G. Elbinger, 1970, J. Phys. C3, 1363. Gerber, R., L. Michalowsky, K. Motzke and E. Steinbeiss, 1966, Phys. Status Solidi 16, 793. Gibart, P. and G. Suran, 1975, Internat. Coll. Mag. Thin Films, Regensburg. Gibbons, D.F., 1957, J. Appl. Phys. 28, 810. Giesecke, W., 1959, Z. Angew. Phys. 11, 91. Gilleo, M,A., 1958, Phys. Rev. 109, 777. Gilleo, M.A., 1960, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 13, 33. Glasser, M.L. and F.J. Milford, 1963, Phys. Rev. 130, 1783. Glaz, W., H. Szydlowski and S. Pachocka, 1980, Acta phys. polonica A58, 263. Goodenough, J.B., 1958, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 6, 287. Goodenough, J.B., 1963, Magnetism and Crystal Structure in Nonmetals, in: Magnetism, vol. 3, eds., Rado, G.T. and H. Suhl (Academic Press, New York and London), pp. 1~63. Goodenough, J.B., 1963, Magnetism and Chemical Bond (Wiley, New York). Gorter, E.W., 1954, Philips Res. Rep. 9, 295. Gorter, E.W., 1955, Proc. IRE 43, 1945. Greenough, R.D. and E.W. Lee, 1970, J. Phys. D3, 1595. Grimes, N.W., 1972a, Philos. Mag. 26, 1217. Grimes, N.W., 1972b, Spectr. Acta 28A, 2217. Grimes, N.W., 1974, Proc. Roy. Soc. A338, 223. Grimes, N.W., T.J. O'Connor and P. Thompson, 1978, J. Phys. C l l , L505. Groupe de diffusion in61astique des neutrons, 1971, J. Phys. (France) 32, C1-118. Gutowski, M., 1978, Phys. Rev. B18, 5984. Hargrove, R.S. and W. Kiindig, 1970, Solid State Commun. 8, 303. Hastings, J.M. and L.M. Corliss, 1953, Rev. Mod. Phys. 25, 114. /-Iaubenreisser, W., 1961, Phys. Status Solidi 1, 6t9. Heeger, A.J. and T. Houston, 1964, J. Appl. Phys. 35, 836. Heikes, R.R. and W.B. Johnston, 1957, J. Chem. Phys. 26, 582. Henning, J.C.M., 1980, Phys. Rev. B21, 4983. Henning, J.C.M., J.H. den Boef and G.G.P. van Gorkom, 1973, Phys. Rev. B7, 1825.
Henning, J.C.M. and H. van den Boom, 1977, Physica B + C86--88, 1027. Henriet-Iserentant, Ch. and G. Robbrecht, 1972, C.R. Hebd. Seances Acad. Sci. B275, 323. Hisatake, K. and K. Ohta, 1977, J. Phys. (France) 38, C1-219. Holba, P., M. Nevfiva and E. Pollert, 1975, Mater. Res. Bull. 10, 853. Holtwijk, T., W. Lems, A.G.H. Verhulst and U. Enz, 1970, IEEE Trans. Mag. MAG-6, 853. Hwang, L., A.H. Heuer and T.F. Mitchell, 1973, Philos Mag. 28, 249. Iida, S., 1960, J. Appl. Phys. 31,251S. Iida, S., 1967, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 22, 1233. Iida, S. and T. Inoue, 1962, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 17, Suppl. B-l, 281. Iida, S. and H. Miwa, 1966, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 21, 2505. Iida, S., K. Mizushima, N. Yamada and T. Iizuka, 1968, J. Appl. Phys. 39, 818. Iida, S., K. Mizushima, M. Mizoguchi, J. Mada, S. Umemura, K. Nakao and J. Yoshida, 1976, AIP Conf. Proc. 29, 388. Iida, S., K. Mizushima, M. Mizoguchi, J. Mada, S. Umemura, K. Nakao and J. Yoshida, 1977, J. Phys. (France) 38, C1-73. Iida, S., K. Mizushima, M. Mizoguchi, S. Umemura and J. Yoshida, 1978, J. Appl. Phys. 49, 1455. Iizuka, S. and S. Iida, 1966, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 21, 222. Ioffe, V.A., G.I. Khvostenko and Z.N. Zonn, 1957, Soviet. Phys.-J. Tech. Phys. 27, 1985. Ishikawa, Y. and Y. Syono, 1971a, Phys. Rev. Lett. 26, 1335. Ishikawa, Y. and Y. Syono, 1971b, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 31, 461. Ishikawa, Y., S. Sato and Y. Syono, 1971, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 31, 452. Ivanov, B.D., B.A. Kalinikos, O.A. Rybinskij and D.N. Czartorizskij, 1972, Fiz. Tverd. Tela 14, 653. Ivanova, A.V., V.N. Seleznev and A.I. Drokin, 1979, Zhurnal tekhn, fiziki 49, 2493. Jacob, K.T. and J. Walderraman, 1977, J. Solid State Chem. 22, 291. Jacobs, I.S., 1959, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 11, 1. Jacobs, I.S., 1960, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 15, 54. Jirfik, Z. and S. Vratislav, 1974, Czech. J. Phys. B24, 642. Jonker, G.H., 1959, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 9, 165.
OXIDE SPINELS Kahn, F.J., P.S. Pershan and J.P. Remeika, 1969, Phys. Rev. 186, 891. Kamiyoshi, K., 1951, Sci. Rep. Res. Inst. Tohoku Univ. A3, 716. Kanamori, J., 1959, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 10, 67. Kaplan, J. and C. Kittel, 1953, J. Chem. Phys. 21, 760. Kaplan, T.A., 1958, Phys. Rev. 109, 782. Kaplan, T.A., 1960, Phys. Rev. 116, 888. Kaplan, T.A., K. Dwight, D.H. Lyons and N. Menyuk, 1961, J. Appl. Phys. 32, 13S. Kato, Y. and T. Takei, 1933, J. Inst. Electr. Eng. Jap. 53, 408. Keffer, F., 1966, Spin Waves, in: Handbuch der Physik, vol. 18/2, ed., Fliigge, S. (Springer Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York) pp. 1-273. Khrebtov, A.P., A.A. Askochensky and J.M. Speranskaya, 1978, Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR Ser. Fiz. 42, 1652. Kienlin, A.v., 1957, Z. Angew. Phys. 9, 245. Kino, Y., B. Lfithi and M.E. Mullen, 1972, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 33, 687. Klerk, J., V.A.M. Brabers and A.J.M. Kuipers, 1977, J. Phys. (France) 38, C1-187. Klinger, M.I., 1975, J. Phys. C8, 3595. Klinger, M.I. and A.A. Samochvalov, 1977, Phys. Status Solidi, h79, 9. Knowles, J.E., 1964, Proc. Int. Conf. Magnetism, Nottingham, p. 619. Knowles, J.E., 1974, Philips Res. Rep. 29, 93. Knowles, J.E. and J. Rankin, 1971, J. Phys. (France) 32, C1-845. K6hler, D., 1959, Z. Angew. Phys. 11, 103. K6nig, U., Y. Gross and G. Chol, 1969, Phys. Status Solidi 33, 811. Koops, C.G., 1951, Phys. Rev. 83, 121. Kopp, W., 1919, Dissertation (Zurich). Kouvel, J.S., 1956, Phys. Rev. 102, 1489. Kowalewski, L., 1962, Acta Phys. Pol. 21, 121. Kozhuhar, A.Y., G.A. Tsinadze, V.A. Shapovalov and V.N. Seleznev, 1973, Phys. Lett. 42A, 377. Krause, J., 1969, J. Angew. Phys. 27, 251. Kriessman, C.J. and S.E. Harrison, 1956, Phys. Rev. 103, 857. Krinchik, G.S., A.P. Khrebtov, A.A. Askochensky, E.M. Speranskaya and S.A. Belyaev, 1977, Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 72, 699. Krinchik, G.S., K.M. Muchimov, Sh.M. Sharipov, A.P. Khrebtov and M. Speranskaya, 1979, Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 76, 2126. Krupi6ka, S., 1960, Czech. J. Phys. B10, 782.
301
Krupi~ka, S., 1962, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 17, Suppl. B-l, 304. Krupi6ka, S. and P. Novfik, 1964, Phys. Status Solidi 4, Kl17. Krupi~ka, S. and F. Vilfm, 1957, Czech. J. Phys. 7, 723. Krupi~ka, S. and F. Vilfm, 1961, Czech. J. Phys. Bll, 10. Krupi6ka, S. and K. Zfiv6ta, 1968, J. Appl. Phys. 39, 930. Krupi6ka, S., L. Cervinka, P. Novfik and K. Zfiv6ta, 1964, Proc. Int. Conf. Magnetism, Nottingham, p. 650. Krupi~ka, S., Z. Sim~a and Z. Smetana, 1968, Czech. J. Phys. B18, 1016. Krupi~ka, S., Z. Jir~k, P. Nov~k, V. Roskovec and F. Zounovfi, 1977, Physica 86-88B+ C, 1459. Krupi~ka, S., Z. Jirfik, P. Novfik, F. Zounovfi and V. Roskovec, 1980, Acta Physica Slovaca 30, 251. Kubo, T., A. Hirai and H. Abe, 1969, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 26, 1094. Kuipers, A.J.M., 1978, Thesis, Technical University Eindhoven. Kuipers, AJ.M. and V.A.M. Brabers, 1976, Phys. Rev. B14, 1401. Lauwers, H.A. and M.A. Herman, 1980, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 41, 223. Liolioussis, K.T. and A.J. Pointon, 1977, J. Phys. (France) 38, C1-191. Lord, H. and R. Parker, 1960, Nature 188, 929. Lotgering, F.K., 1964, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 25, 95. Lu-San Pan and B.J. Evans, 1978, J. Appl. Phys. 49, 1458. Lutz, H.D., 1969, Z. Naturforsch. 24a, 1417. Lutz, H.D. and H. Haeuseler, 1975, Bet. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 79, 604. Malakhovsky, A.V., I.S. Edelman, V.P. Gavrilin, G.I. Barinov, 1974, Sov. Phys. Solid State, 16, 266. Marais, A. and T. Merceron, 1959, C.R. Hebd. Seanees Acad. Sci. 248, 2976. Marais, A. and T. Merceron, 1965, C.R. Hebd. Seances Acad. Sci. 261, 2188. Marais, A. and T. Merceron, 1967, Phys. Status Solidi, 24, 635. Marais, A. and T. Merceron, 1974, Phys. Status Solidi, a22, K209. Marais, A., T. Merceron and M. Porte, 1969, C.R. Hebd. Seances Acad. Sei. B268, 730. Marais, A., T. Merceron, G. Maxim and M. Porte, 1972, Phys. Status Solidi, 52, 631.
302
S. KRUPICKA AND P. NOV~iJ(
Maxim, G., 1969, Phys. Status Solidi, 35, 211. McClure, D.S., 1957, J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 3, 311. McMurdie, H.P., B.M. Sullivan and F.A. Mauer, 1950, J. Res. Nat. Bur. Stand. 45, 35. Merceron, T., 1965, Ann. Phys. 10, 121. Michalk, C., 1968, Phys. Status Solidi, 27, K51. Michalowsky, L., 1965, Phys. Status Solidi, 8, 543. Miles, P.A., W.B. Westphal and A. yon Hippel, 1957, Rev. Mod. Phys. 29, 279. Miller, A., 1959, J. Appl. Phys. 30, 24S. Miyahara, Y., 1972, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 32, 629. Miyata, N., 1961, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 16, 206. Miyata, N. and Z. Funatogawa, 1962, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 17, Suppl. B-l, 279. Mizoguchi, M., 1978a, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 44, 150~1. Mizoguchi, M., 1978b, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 44, 1512. Mizushima, M., 1963, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 18, 1441. Mizushima, K. and S. Iida, 1967, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 22, 1300. Mizushima, K., K. Nakao, S. Tanaka and S. Iida, 1978, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 44, 1831. Mott, N.F., 1969, Philos. Mag. 19, 835. Motzke, K., 1962, Phys. Status Solidi, 2, K52, K307. Motzke, K., 1964, Phys. Status Solidi, 4, K13. Mozzi, R.L. and A.E. Paladino, 1963, J. Chem. Phys. 39, 435. Navrotsky, A., 1973a, J. Solid State Chem. 6, 21. Navrotsky, A., 1973b, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 19, 471. Navrotsky, A., 1974, J. Solid State Chem. 11, 10. Navrotsky, A., 1975, J. Solid State Chem. 12, 12. Navrotsky, A. and L. Hughes, Jr., 1976, J. Solid State Chem. 16, 185. Navrotsky, A. and O.J. Kleppa, 1967, J. Inorg. Nucl. Chem. 29, 2701. Navrotsky, A. and O.J. Kleppa, 1968, J. Inorg. Nucl. Chem. 30, 479. N6el, L., 1948, Ann. Phys. (France) 3, 137. N~el, L., 1954, J. Phys. Rad. 15, 225. Novfik, P., 1966, Czech. J. Phys. B16, 723. Novfik, P., 1972, Czech. J. Phys. B22, 1134. Ohnishi, H., T. Teranishi and S. Miyahara, 1959, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 14, 106. Okada, T. and T. Akashi, 1965, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 20, 639.
Palmer, W., 1960, Phys. Rev. 120, 342. Parker, R., 1975, Electrical Transport Properties, in: Magnetic Oxides, ed., Craik, D.J. (Wiley, New York) pp. 421-482. Parker, R. and M.S. Smith, 1961, J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 21, 76. Parker, R. and C.J. Tinsley, 1976, Phys. Status Solidi, a33, 189. Pauthenet, R., 1950, C.R. Hebd. Seances Acad. Sci. 230, 1842. Pauthenet, R., 1952, Ann. Phys. (France) 7, 7i0. Pauthenet, R. and L. Bochirol, 1951, J. Phys. Rad. 12, 249. Patton, C.E., 1975, Microwave Resonance and Relaxation, in: Magnetic Oxides, ed. Craik, D.J. (Wiley, New York) pp. 575-649. Penoyer, R.F. and L.R. Bickford, Jr., 1957, Phys. Rev. 108, 271. Penoyer, R.F. and M.W. Shafer, 1959, J. Appl. Phys. 30, 315S. Perthel, R., 1962, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 17, Suppl. B-I, 288. Philips, B., S. Somiya and A. Muan, 1961, J. Am. Ceram, Soc. 16, 167. Piekoszewski, J., J. Suwalski and L. Dabrowski, 1977, Aeta Phys. Pol. A51, 179. Platz, W. and J. Heber, 1976, Z. Phys. B24, 333. Plumier, R., 1969, Theses, Paris. Pointon, A.J. and G.A. Wetton, 1973, AIP Conf. Proc. 10, 1573. Pollert, E. and Z. Jirfik, 1976, Czech. J. Phys. B26, 481. Preudhomme, J. and P. Tarte, 1971a, Spectrochim Acta 27A, 961. Preudhomme, J. and P. Tarte, 1971b, Spectrochim Acta 27A, 1817. Preudhomme, J. and P. Tarte, 1972, Spectrochim. Acta 28A, 69. Prince, E., 1964, J. Phys. Rad. 25, 503. Prince, E., 1965, J. Appl. Phys. 36, 161. Rabkin, L.I. and Z.I. Novikova, 1960, Ferrites (Minsk) p. 146. Rado, G.T. and J.M. Ferrari, 1975, Phys. Rev. B12, 5166. Rado, G.T. and J.M. Ferrari, 1977, Phys. Rev. B15, 290. Reinen, D., 1968, Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem. 356, 182. Rezlescu, N. and E. Rezlescu, 1974, Phys. Status Solidi a23, 575. Reznickiy, L.A., 1977, Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR, Neorg. Mat. 13, 1669. Rogers, D.B., 1967, Cs. 6as. fyz. A17, 398.
OXIDE SPINELS Rogers, D.B., R.J. Arnott, A. Wold and J.B. Goodenough, 1963, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 24, 347. Rogers, D.B., J.L. Gilson and T.E. Gier, 1967, Solid State Commun. 5, 143. Rosencwaig, A., 1970, Can. J. Phys. 48, 2857. Roth, W.L., 1964, J. Phys. Rad. 25, 507. Rouse, K.D., M.V. Thomas and B.T.M. Willis, 1976, J. Phys. C9, L231. Samochvalov, A.A., S.A. Ismailov and A.A. Obuchov, 1967, Fiz. Tverd. Tela, 9, 884. Sawatzki, G.A., F. van der Woude and A.A. Morish, 1969, Phys. Rev. 187, 747. Scheerlinck, D., W. Wegener, S. Hautecler and V.A.M. Brabers, 1974, Solid State Commun. 15, 1529. Schlegel, A., S.F. Alvarado and P. Wachter, 1979, J. Phys. C12, 1157. Schl6mann, E., 1957, J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 2, 214. Schl6mann, E., 1960, Solid State Physics in Electronics and Telecommunication vol. 3 (Academic Press, New York) p. 322. Scott, G.B., 1978, The Optical Absorption and Magneto-Optic Spectra of Y3FesO12, in: Proc. International School on Physics "Enrico Fermi," ed., Paoletti, A. (North-Holland, Amsterdam) pp. 445-466. Scott, G.B., D.E. Lacklison and J.L. Page, 1974, Phys. Rev. B10, 971. Scott, G.B., D.E. Lacklison, H.I. Ralph and J.L. Page, 1975, Phys. Rev. B12, 2562. Seleznev, V.N., I.K. Pukhov, A.I. Drokin and V.A. Shapovalov, 1970, Fiz. Tver. Tela 12, 885. Seshagiri Rao, T., B. Revathi and M. Purnanandam, 1971, Indian J. Pure Appl. Phys. 9, 797. Serres, A., 1932, Ann. Phys. (France) 10, 32. Shannon, R.D., 1976, Acta Crystallogr. A32, 751. Shindo, I. and K. Kohn, 1979, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 47, 1779. Shirane, G., S. Chikazumi, J. Akimitsu, K. Chiba, M. Matsui and Y. Fujii, 1975, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 39, 949. Siemons, W.J., 1970, IBM J. Res. Dev. 14, 245. Simga, Z., 1979, Phys. Status Solidi b96, 581. Simga, Z. and O. Schneeweiss, 1972, Czech. J. Phys. B22, 1331. Simga, Z., J. ~imgovfi and V.A.M. Brabers, 1972, Proc. llth ICPS, vol. 2 (Polish Sci. Publishers, Warsaw) p. 1294.
303
Simga, Z., P. Sirok~, F. Lukeg and E. Schmidt, 1979, Phys. Status Solidi, b96, 137. Simga, Z., P. Sirok~, J. Kolfi~ek and V.A.M. Brabers, 1980, J. Mag. Mag. Mater. 15-18, 775. Simgovfi, J. and Z. Simga, 1974, Czech. J. Phys. B24, 449. Simgovfi, J., M. Marygko and K. Suk, 1976, Phys. Status Solidi, a38, K163. Siratori, K., 1967, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 23, 948. Siratori, K., E. Kito, G. Kaji, A. Tasaki, S. Kimura, I. Shindo and K. Kohn, 1979, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 47, 1779. Sixtus, K.J., 1960, Solid State Physics in Electronics and Telecommunication, vol. 3 (Academic Press, New York) p. 91. Slack, G.A., 1964, Phys. Rev. A134, 1268. Slonczewski, J.C., 1958, Phys. Rev. 110, 1341. Slonczewski, J.C., 1960, J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 15, 335. Smit, J., 1968, Solid State Commun. 6, 745. Stair, J. and H.P.J. Wijn, 1959, Ferrites (Wiley, New York). Smit, J., F.K. Lotgering and R.P. van Stapele, 1962, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 17B-l, 268. Smith, D.O., 1952, Prog. Rep. Lab. Insul. Res. MIT, 11, 53. Sobotta, E.A. and J. Voitlfinder, 1963, Z. Phys. Chem., Frankfurt, 39, 54. Sparks, M., 1964, Ferromagnetic Relaxation Theory (McGraw-Hill, New York). Sugano, S., Y. Tanabe and M. Kamimura, 1970, Multiplets of Transition Metal Ions in Crystals (Academic Press, New York). Svirina, E.P., 1970, Izv. Akad. Nauk USSR, Ser. Fiz. 34, 1162. Szymczak, H., R. Wadas, W. Wardzynski and W. Zbieranowski, 1973, Proc. Int. Conf. Mag. ICM-73 (Moscow) p. 425. Tachiki, M., 1960, Progr. Theor. Phys. 23, 1055. Teale, R.W., 1967, Proc. Phys. Soc. 92, 411. Teale, R.W. and D.W. Temple, 1967, Phys. Rev. Lett. 19, 904. Teh, H.C., M.F. Collins and A.H. Mook, 1974, Can. J. Phys. 52, 396. Thompson, P. and N.W. Grimes, 1972a, J. Appl. Crystallogr. 10, 369. Thompson, P. and N.W. Grimes, 1972b, Philos. Mag. 36, 501. Torrie, B.H., 1967, Solid State Commun. 5, 715. Tretyakov, Yu., 1967, Termodinamika Ferritov (Chimija, Leningrad) p. 41. Tyablikov, S.V., 1956, Fiz. Met. Metalloved. 3, 3.
304
S. KRUPI~KA AND P. NOV_.~K
Umemura, S. and S. Iida, 1979, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 47, 458. Van der Woude, F. and G.A. Sawatzky, 1971, Phys. Rev. B4, 3159. Van Diepen, A.M. and F.K. Lotgering, 1977, Physica 86.-88B + C, 981. Van Uitert, L.G., 1956a, J. Chem. Phys. 24, 306. Van Uitert, L.G., 1956b, Proc. IRE 44, 1294. Van Uitert, L.G., 1957, J. Appl. Phys. 28, 320. Venero, A.F. and E.F. Westrum, 1975, J. Chem. Thermodynamics 7, 693. Verwey, E.J.W., 1 9 5 1 , Semiconducting Materials (Butterworth Sci. Publications, London) p. 151. Verwey, E.J.W. and P.W. Haaijman, 1941, Physica 8, 979. Vi~fiovsk~, S., R. Krishnan, V. Prosser, N.P. Thuy and I. St[eda, 1979a, Appl. Phys. 18, 243. Vi~fiovsk3), S., N.P. Thuy, J. St6p~inek, R. Krishnan and V. Prosser, 1979b, J. Appl. Phys. 50, 7466. Vi~fiovsk~), S., R. Krishnan, N.P, Thuy, J. St6p~inek, V. Pa[izek and V. Prosser, 1980, J. Mag. Mag. Mater. 15--18, 831. Vratislav, S., J. Zaj/6ek, Z. Jir~ik and A.F. Andresen, 1977, J. Mag. Mag. Mater. 5, 41. Wagner, R., 1961, Ann. Phys. 7, 302. Waldron, R.D., 1955, Phys. Rev. 99, 1727. Wanic, A., 1972, Int. J. Mag. 3, 349. Watanabe, H. and B.N. Brockhouse, 1962, Phys. Lett. 1, 189. Watanabe, Y., K. Urade and S. Saito, 1978, Phys. Status Solidi, b90, 697. Wegener, W., D. Scheerlinck, E. Legrand, S. Hautecler and V.A.M. Brabers, 1974, Solid State Commun. 15, 345.
Westwood, W.D. and A.G. Sadler, 1971, Can. J. Phys. 49, 1103. White, W.B. and B.A. De Angelis, 1967, Spectrochim. Acta, 23A, 985. Willshee, J.C. and J. White, 1967, Trans. Br. Ceram. Soc. 66, 548, 551. Wittekoek, S., T.J.A. Popma, J.M. Robertson and P.F. Bongers, 1975, Phys. Rev. B12, 2777. Wolf, W.P., 1957, Phys. Rev. 108, 1152. Yafet, Y. and C. Kittel, 1952, Phys. Rev. 87, 290. Yakovlev, Y.M., E.V. Rubalskaya, L.G. Godes, B.L. Lapovok and T.N. Bushueva, 1971, Fiz. Tver. Tela 13, 1151. Yamada, T., 1973, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 35, 130. Yamada, T., 1975, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 38, 1378. Yamada, N. and S. Iida, 1968, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 24, 952. Yanase, A., 1962, J. Phys. Soc. Jap., 17, 1005. Yasuoka, H., A. Hirai, M. Matsumura and T. Hashi, 1962, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 17, 1071. Yosida, K. and M. Tachiki, 1957, Prog. Theor. Phys. 17, 331. Yshikawa, Y., S. Sato and Y. Syono, 1971, J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 31, 453. Zanmarchi, G. and P.F. Bongers, 1969, J. Appl. Phys. 40, 1230. Z~iv6ta, K. and P. Nov~k, 1971, J. Phys. (France) 32, C1-64. Zftv6ta, K., E.I. Trinkler and F. Zounov~, 1966, Phys. Status Solidi 14, K9. Z~iv6ta, K., F. Zounov~i and E.I. Trinkler, 1968, Czech. J. Phys. B18, 1314. Zhilyakov S.M. and E.P. Naiden, 1977, Izv. V.U.Z. Fiz no. 1, 56.
chapter 5 FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES WITH MAGNETOPLUMBITE STRUCTURE
H. KOJIMA Research Institute for Scientific Measurements Tohoku University, 2-1-1 Katahira, Sendai JAPAN
Ferromagnetic Materials, Vol. 3 Edited by E.P. Wohlfarth © North-Holland Publishing Company, 1982 305
CONTENTS 1. G e r e r a l . . . . . . . 1.1. C h e m i c a l c o m p o s i t i o n
.
. .
. .
. .
. .
. . . .
.
. .
. .
. .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.2. P h a s e d i a g r a m . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2.1. B a O - F e 2 0 3 s y s t e m s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2.2. S r O - F e 2 0 3 s y s t e m s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2.3. P b O - F e 2 0 3 s } s t c m s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3. P r e p m a t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. M c o m p o u n d . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1. BaFe1:.O19, SrFe12019 ~ n d Pb Fe1=O19 . . . 2.1.1. Crystal s t r u c t u r e . . . . . . . . 2.1.2. M a g n e t i c ~,t~ u c t u r e . . . . . . 2.1.3. S a t m atic n me gnet!2 a t i c n . . . . 2.1.4. M a g n e t o c r ~ stalline a n i s o t r c py . . 2.1.5. C o e r c i v e f o l c e 2.1.6. 2.1.7. 2.1.8. 2.1.9. 2.1.10. 2.1.11. 2.1.12. 2.1.13.
.
.
.
.
.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . . .
2.1.14. M e c h a n i c a l proFertie s
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
F a r a m ~ g n e l i c proloert~e s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Magnetic aftereffect . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . FMR . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . NMR . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . M 6 s s b a u e r effe~ t Domain observation Optical pioperties M a g n e l ostriction
.
.
. . . . . .
.
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
2.1.15. H e a t c a p a c i t y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1.16. q h m m a l e x p a n s i c n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1.17. E l e c t r i c a n d dielectric IZrOl:erties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2. Substitute d M c o m p o u n d . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2.1. B a O - S r O - F b O - F e 2 0 3 s y s t e m s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2.2. G t h e r substitutions c f Ba:+ ions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2.3. Substitt t i c n c f Fe3+ l'ons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sub~,titution with A l>, Ga3+ a n d C r3+ icn . . . . . . . . . . . Sub,~ tilution with Sc3+ a n d In 3+ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Substitution of Fe3+ with p a i r e d ions; C o - T i s y s t e m . . . . . . . C t h e r c c m b i n a t i o n s with I I - I V pairs . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2.4. Effect of substitutions on t h e t e m p e r a t u r e d e p e n d e n c e of m a g n e t i z a t i o n 2.2.5. Substitution with a n i c n s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
306
307 307 308 308 312 313 315 317 318 318 323 325 329 334 342 344 345 347 351 354 358 360 361 361 362 364 367 367 368 368 368 375 378 379 38O 384 387
1. General
A group of ferrimagnetic oxides with hexagonal structures will be described in this section'S. Most of these compounds have been developed over the past two decades and it can be said that the first fundamental step of the investigations on the properties of hexagonal ferrites, now seems to be nearly completed. Smit and Wijn (1959) and Wijn (1970) collected comprehensive data on the compounds, and moreover, many authors - such as Schieber (1967), Tebble and Craik (1969), Galasso (1970), Standley (1972), and others-spent a few chapters to treat the magnetic properties or crystal structures of the hexagonal iron oxides in their books.
1.1. Chemical composition ~fhe chemical compositions of the hexagonal compounds are shown in fig. 1" as part of a ternary phase diagram and in table 1 for the BaO-MeO-Fe203 system. Here, Me represents a divalent ion among the first transition elements, Zn, Mg, or a combination of ions whose valency is two. S denotes a cubic spinel MeO.Fe203 and will be explained in detail in ch. 3 of this handbook by Krupi6ka, in vol. 2, ch. 3 by Slick (1979) and in vol. 2, ch. 4 by Nicolas (1979). However, we refer to it here as to one of the major constituent blocks of the hexagonal compounds. M compounds, which have the chemical formulae of BaO.6Fe203 (BaM), SrO.6Fe203 (SrM) and PbO.6Fe203 (PbM) etc., were developed in the initial stage by Went et al. (1952) and Fahlenbrach and Heister (1953) as a typical hexagonal ferrimagnetic oxide for permanent magnet materials. They are isomorphous with the mineral magnetoplumbite, the chemical composition of which is approximately PbzFe15Mny(A1Ti)O38. Other interesting hexagonal compounds are potential industrial magnetic materials in the systems: 2MeO-BaO.8Fe203 (Ba-Me-W), 2MeO-2BaO.6Fe203 (Ba-Me-Y), 2MeO.3BaO.12Fe203 (Ba-Me-Z), 2MeO.2BaO.14Fe203 (Ba-MeX), and 2MeO.4BaO.18Fe203 (Ba-Me-U); they have more complicated crystal structures than BaM, and were originally investigated by Jonker et al. (1954) for ? CGS unit are used in this section. SI units are shown in brackets. * More detailed diagrams of B a O - Z n O - F e 2 0 3 and SrO-ZnO--Fe203 systems were recently reported by Slokar and Lucchini (1978a, b). 307
308
H. KOJIMA
/
°,°%\/\ \~
/ \\\/
\
%
E}00
Fig. 1. BaO-MeO-Fe203 system, showing the relationships of chemical compositions among ferrimagnetic hexagonal compounds (see table 1). use at very high frequencies. They will be described in ch. 6 by Sugimoto, and in vol. 2, ch. 3 (Slick 1979) and in vol. 2, ch. 4 of this handbook (Nicolas 1979). While BaO.Fe203 (B) was reported as an antiferromagnetic hexagonal compound by Okazaki et al. (1961a, b), here, it is rather important as an intermediate phase, when BaM is prepared from Fe203 and BaO (Beretka and Ridge 1958, St~iblein and May 1969, and Wullkopf 1975). In the BaO-Fe203 system, BaO-2Fe203 (T) does not exist as a stable phase at room temperature (Okazaki et al. 1961a) but it is an essential constituent block of Y, Z and U compounds. The constitutions and phase relationships of each compound will be evident from fig. 1 and table 1.
1.2. Phase diagram 1.2.1. BaO-Fe203 systems Numerous compounds have been found in the BaO-Fe203 system, for example, 7BaO.2Fe203 (Batti 1960), 5BaO-Fe203 (Bye and Howard 1971), 3BaO.Fe203 (Okazaki et al. 1961a, Bye and Howard 1971), 2BaO.Fe203 (Erchark et al. 1946), BaO.Fe203 (Okazaki et al. 1955), 2BaO.3Fe203 (Okazaki et al. 1961a, Appendino and Montorsi 1973), 5BaO-7Fe203 (Appendino and Montorsi 1973), BaO-2Fe203 (Okamoto et al. 1975), BaO-6Fe203 (Adelsk61d 1938, Went et al. 1952), 3BaO-4FeO-14Fe203 (Brady 1973), and in an oxidizing atmosphere BaFeO3-x (Mori, 1970), and further in a reducing atmosphere, BaO-FeO.3Fe203 (Braun 1957), BaO.FeO.7Fe203 (Braun 1957) and BaO.2FeO.8Fe203 (Wijn 1952, Neumann and Wijn 1968). Figure 2 is the phase diagram determined by Goto and Takada (1960) under the oxygen partial pressure of Po2 = ~ arm [0.02 MPa] in the solid phase region and
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF H E X A G O N A L FERRITES
t~ tt3
,,D
tt~
¢¢3 ¢¢5 tt~
~o ~=~. ~ = ~
e~ 0
I
I
tt3
d
d o©
e--
m
m
o ©
o66
<
d66666 ~66666 ©
©
©
©
©
Nmm 0
0 0
co
e-
i
ee"
0
*
309
310
H. K O J I M A
0.5
1,0
Fez03 / BoO 1.5 2.0 4.0 6.0 I
I
I
1600
"',~
/
L
1400 o0 1370
I
1565.
/
370 1330
O912oo El. E
(I)
O9
I
(2)
{3)
I000
800
I ~' 40
2BoO'Fe203
i
[
60
8o
~
Ioo
BoO'Fe203 BoO-6Fe203 Fee03 Mole %
Fig. 2. Phase diagram of a BaO-Fe203 system (Goto and Takada 1960). Poz = { atm [0.02 MPa] in the solid phase region and Po2= 1 atm [0.1 MPa] in the liquid phase region. (1) 2BaO.Fe203 + BaO.Fe203; (2) BaO-Fe203 + BaO.6Fe203; (3) BaO-6Fe203 + Fe203.
Po2 = 1 atm [0.1 MPa] above the eutectic temperature. Batti (1960) and Van H o o k (1964) obtained somewhat different phase relations for the same system at Po2 = ½atm [0.02 MPa] and Po2 = 1 arm [0.1 MPa], respectively, which are given in fig. 3 and fig. 4. The main differences among these diagrams around the corn-
/
/
1500
/
/
/ 1474
L 1420
p 1400
1380 / ~
O9
(3)
E I. . . .
1300
BaO
,2,
20):2 2!, 40
,!, 60
Weight
8o,!6
Fe203
%
Fig. 3. Phase diagram of a BaO-Fe203 system (Batti 1960). Po2 = ½atm [0.02 MPa]. (1) 2BaO.Fe203 + BaO.Fe203, (2) BaO.Fe203 + BaO-6Fe203, (3) BaO.6Fe203 + Fe203.
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF H E X A G O N A L FERRITES
1600
311
.--%U Liq
,9,
1500 //" /
1400
/(I)
Q..
E
"'*,% \
i5 (6)1(7) 1495
¢
v
1330
1300
(5) !
%
(I) x
C2)
i /
1315
13) 80
6O
BoO 4 0
(4)
Fe203
Mole %
Fig. 4. Phase diagram of BaO-Fe203 (Van Hook 1964). Po2 = 1 atm [0.1 MPa]: (1) BaO-Fe203+ liq., (2) BaO-6Fe203 + liq., (3) BaO-6Fe203 + BaO-Fe203, (4) BaO-6Fe203 + Fe203, (5) BaO-6Fe203 + Fe304, (6) 2FeO-2BaO-14Fe203 + liq., (7) 2FeO-2BaO-14Fe203 + Fe304, (8) 2FeO.BaO-8Fe2Oa + liq., (9) 2FeO-BaO.8Fe203 + Fe304, (10) Fe304 + liq.
1500 ,~]) [
102
Temperature 1400 II
(°C) 1500 I !
I0 13_ /
0 X
E
io-I ('4
io-Z
i, Io-3 0.54
I
-~BaW (3] 1.58
0.62
I/T
(10 -3 K-~ )
il
0.66
Fig. 5. P - T diagram of Fe304, BaO-6Fe203 (Van Hook 1964), 2FeO-BaO-8Fe~O3 (Neumann and Wijn 1968) and 2FeO.SrO.8Fe203 (Goto et al. 1974).
312
H. K O J I M A
position of BaO.6Fe203 are the solubility limit into the B phase and the existence of a phase transition at high temperatures. Though there is still some ambiguity, the solid solution range is considered to be practically narrower than Fe203/BaO = 5.0-6.0 as shown in fig. 2. According to Batti (1960) and Van Hook (1964) it is within 5.%6.0, and 5.8--6.0 according to Stfiblein and May (1969). Moreover, almost no solubility range is claimed by Reed and Fulrath (1973). As for the liquidus line, it seems to be most probable that BaM dissociates into a liquid phase and 2FeO-2BaO.14Fe203 (Ba-Fe-X) as shown in fig. 4, even when it is heated in air (/°o2 = ½arm [0.02 MPa]). In fact, an incongruent melting will occur in the composition. Figure 5 is the equilibrium diagram of (1) BaO.6Fe203 (BaM) ~- FeO.BaO-7Fe203 (Ba-Fe-X) + liquid + 02 and (2) Fe203 ~- Fe304+x + 02 (Van Hook 1964), and also (3) the stable region of 2FeO.BaO.8Fe203 (Neumann and Wijn, 1968). The latter authors obtained B a - F e - W under the condition of /9o2 = 0.05-0.1atm [5-10x 103pa] at 1400°C as a single phase. But Van Hook (1964) found that BaM is congruently melted in Po2 = 40 atm [4 MPa] as shown in fig. 6. Figure 7 is the phase diagram by Sloccari (1973), which shows the existence of the peritectoid reaction, BaO.Fe203 (B)+ BaO.6Fe203 (BaM)~-2BaO-3Fe203, at 11500-+ 10°C.
1.2.2. SrO-Fe203 systems The phase relations are quite similar to that of the BaO-Fe203 system. Figure 8 is the equilibrium diagram in Po2 = ½atm [0.02MPa] given by Goto et al. (1971,
//
1600,
//
Liq
,j / /
z/
/
/
/
(5)
1 /
/ f/
P
(I)
1400
.......
',
,_2
,/"
.........
(3)
I1)
E I1)
I-
(2)
(1)
(4)
1200
I BaO
6o
8o
Fe203
Mole % Fig. 6. Phase diagram of a BaO-Fe203 system (Van Hook 1964). P o 2 = 4 0 a t m [4MPa]: (1) BaO'Fe203 + liq., (2) BaO.Fe203 + BaO.6Fe203, (3) BaO.6Fe203 + liq., (4) BaO.6Fe203 + Fe203, (5) Fe203 + liq.
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF H E X A G O N A L FERRITES
50 1200 ;
o
D
000, i
0
D
0000
D °
a) r~
(3)
0
/
0-00~.
0
0000
O.
I
iooo
F: 1-
Mole % Fe=O 3 60 70 80 85.71 I[I 1 o,oo~ ?
I100=
313
•
oooe
o
9O0
(2)
i (I) I
80C
I
Ili
//\\
I
ol m
B(:]O/Fe203 Fig. 7. Phase diagram of a BaO-Fe203 system (Sloccari 1973). (1) BaO-Fe203+ 2BaO.3Fe203, (2) 2BaO.3Fe203 + BaO.6Fe203, (3) BaO-Fe203 + BaO-6Fe203, (0) one phase, ((3) two phase.
1974). They insisted from the results of ditterential thermal analysis that there might exist some solubility range of SrM in 3SrO.2Fe203, as indicated with the broken line in fig. 8. SrM is decomposed at 1435°C to SrFe]sOz7 (Sr-Fe-W)+ liquid, and at 1465°C, they change into Fe304 + liquid in air. The stable region of Sr-Fe-W is also indicated by the region (4) in fig. 5 from the results of Goto et al. (1974). Furthermore, they obtained Sr-Fe-X by heat treatment at 1420°C for two hours, but it is decomposed by prolonged heating to a mixed phase containing Sr-Fe-W in air
1.2.3. PbO-Fe203 systems The phase relations obtained by Mountvala and Ravitz (1962) and Berger and Pawlek (1957) are considered as reasonable representations under normally attainable equilibrium conditions. Figure 9 is the diagram by Mountvala and Ravitz (1962). PbM is incongruently melted to Fe203 + liquid at 1315°C (1255°C) *, and below 760°C (810°C) * it is decomposed to FezO3+ PbO.2Fe203. Mountvala * Data by Berger and Powlek (1957).
314
H. KOJIMA
1500 ,,1480 \',,,
Liq
~
,
/
(2) X
1300
o
,,./ ~ " (I0) 1465 (8)
/
,~5 (7)11395(9)
I/
/
(5)
,, (/
(3) ~ 1195
"\
09
~- I 1 0 0 ( I)
(4)
(6)
900
40 SrFeO3-x
60 Mole %
80
I00 Fe203
Fig. 8. Phase diagram of a SrO-Fe203 system (Ooto et al. 1971, 1974). Poz=½atm [0.02MPa]: (1) SrFeO3_x + 3SrO.2Fe203, (2) SrFeO3-x + liq., (3) 3SrO'2Fe203 + liq., (4) 3SrO'2Fe203 + SrO:6Fe203, (5) SrO'6Fe203 + liq., (6) SrO'6Fe203 + Fe203, (7) SrO.6Fe203 + 2FeO-SrO-8Fe203 + (2FeO-2SrO. 14Fe203), (8) 2FeO.SrO.8Fe203 + liq., (9) 2FeO.SrO.8Fe203 + Fe304, (10) Fe304 + liq. 2:1
14oo
1:2
/
2:5
1:5 1:6
/ 1315
13oo /
12oo S o II00
/
/
/
/
1 I I I I I I
/iq (9)
I
I
~
I
i 945
9oo ~-
! ,,/---I 9,ol
(8) (4)
800
(2)
\\\2 /
7ooF.... 7~oq I600 "
0 PbO
!" '
20
1/ I I L_~
(H)
i i i
I000
5
(61
, " 760
750
i (3)
/
(io)
650
60
40 Mole %
80
I00 Fe203
Fig. 9. Phase diagram of a PbO-Fe203 system (Mountvala and Ravitz 1962). (1) PbO + 2PbO.FezO3, (2) PbO + liq., (3) 2PbO.Fe203 + Fe203, (4) 2PbO.Fe203 + PbO-2Fe203, (5) PbO.2Fe203, (6) PbO-2Fe203 + PbO.6Fe203, (7) PbO-6Fe203, (8) PbO.2Fe203 + liq., (9) PbO.6Fe203 + liq., (10) PbO-2Fe203 + Fe203, (11) PbO.6Fe203 + Fe203, (12) Fe203 + liq.
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
315
and Ravitz (1962) also claimed that there is a rather wide solid solution range of Fe203/PbO = 5.0-6.0 between 800°-945°C and proposed a crystal structure for the end member of the solid solution, PbO.5Fe203. It would be reasonable to explain the fact that the lattice parameters were found to be independent of composition in this solid solution range, but the saturation magnetization of PbO.5Fe203 is higher than that of PbO'6Fe203. There seems to be no investigation about the hexagonal phase of P b - M e - W , P b - M e - X etc. in this system.
1.3. Preparation The most typical way to obtain the ferrimagnetic hexagonal oxides as powder or in a sintered polycrystalline state is the solid state reaction of heating the mixtures of constituent oxides or of compounds which are easily changed to oxides by heating. BaCO3, SrCO3, PbO and c~-Fe203 etc. are generally used as starting materials, but oxalates, sulfates, chlorides, nitrates or hydroxides are also used for specific purposes. Proper reaction temperature, atmosphere and cooling conditions should, of course, be chosen according to the phase diagrams. However, single phase M type compounds, for example, can be usually obtained by heating in air (PQ = ~ atm [0.02 MPa]) between 800 ° and 1200°C, and just removing from the furnace. The formation processes of the reactions have been reported by many authors from various points of view. Erchak Jr, et al. (1946), and Erchak Jr. and Ward (1946) investigated the reaction between ferric oxide and barium carbonate and found the formation of BaO.2Fe203 above 550°C and BaO.6Fe203 above 750°C by X-ray diffraction. Sadler (1965) studied the reaction kinetics of BaM, and obtained the activation energy of 73.2 kcal/mol [3.06× 105 J/mol] above 735°C. Wullkopf (1972, 1975) observed the variations of the amount of reaction products, length, weight and grain size for the mixed compact of BaCO3 and 5.5Fe203 during the sintering process and collected the data, as shown in fig. 10. Similar results were also reported by Haberey et al. (1973). Furthermore, Haberey and Kockel (1976) found that SrM is formed from a mixture of SrCO3 and 6Fe203 through the following two endothermal reactions: SrCO3 + 6c~-Fe203 + (0.5 - x) × 102 --~ SrFeO3-x + 5.5a-Fe202 + CO2 SrFeO3-x + 5.5ol-Fe203---> SrO-6Fe203 + (0.5 - x) × ½02. Bowman et al. (1969) investigated the formation mechanism of PbM in the PbO-Fe203 system and concluded that PbM is formed through the intermediate compounds of 2PbO-Fe203 or PbO'2Fe203, depending upon the mixing method, the time and temperature of heating. They used two kinds of co-precipitation methods for mixing, in which the aqueous solution of ammonium bicarbonate was added to the solutions containing lead nitrate and ferric nitrate, or lead nitrate and ferric oxide. The co-precipitation method was also used to obtain a high coercivity BaM or
316
H. KOJIMA
1.0 0.8
(b)
\\k\\\\\ M/
' ~
0.6 .o
\/,/,, \/-
0.4
\/
\
\
/
! !
0
! I
/ 'l
1.0
(0) •~ 0.8 (D
>, 0.6
P "
\
/
0.2
\
0.4
z
//. w
"~ 0.2 rr 0
0
400
800
1200
i./411600
Temperoture (°C) Fig. 10. Changes of BaO-5.5Fe203 compact during heating (Wullkopf 1972, 1975): (a) variation of reaction products, F: Fe203, Bc: BaCO3, B: BaO.Fe203, M: BaO.6Fe203, Y: 2FeO.2BaO.6FezO3, W: 2FeO-BaO-8Fe203, Z: 2FeO-3BaO.12Fe203; (b) variation of length L, weight G, grain size D and saturation magnetization M.
SrM by Mee and Jeschke (1963), Haneda et al. (1974a), Roos et al. (1977) and Oh et al. (1978). Furthermore, Shirk and Buessem (1970) obtained a high coercivity BaM from a glass with the composition 0.265BzO3-0.405BaO-0.33Fe203 in mole ratio. They reported that single domain particles can be crystallized in the fast-quenched glass with this composition by the heat treatment under the appropriate condition (see also table 10). A molten salt synthesis utilizing NaC1KC1 for BaM and "SrM submicron crystals with high magnetic quality was proposed by Arendt (1973). Moreover, Okamoto et al. (1975) applied hydrothermal synthesis with ol-Fe203 suspension in barium hydroxide aqueous solution and obtained BaO.2Fe203 crystals, whose space group was reported as P63/m with the lattice parameter of a = 5.160 A and c = 13.811 A. Kiyama (1976) obtained BaO.6Fe203, BaO.4.5Fe203 and BaO.2Fe203 with Fe(OH)3 or FeOOH and Ba(OH)2 under the similar conditions in an autoclave and studied magnetic properties. Single crystals of M compounds were obtained by cooling a nearly eutectic melt (Kooy 1958); under the high oxygen pressure (Van Hook 1964, Menashi et al. 1973); using various kinds of flux (Mones and Banks 1958, Brixner 1959, Linares
F U N D A M E N T A L P R O P E R T I E S OF H E X A G O N A L F E R R I T E S
317
1962, Suemune 1972, Aidelberg et al. 1974); or discontinuous grain growth (Lacour and Paulus 1968, 1975). B a - Z n - Y , B a - Z n - W , B a - Z n - Z , B a - C o - Z n - W and B a - C o - Z n - Z etc. were also grown by the flux method (Tauber et al. 1962, 1964, Savage and Tauber 1964, AuCoin et al. 1966, Suemune 1972). BaC12, BaO-B203, BaO-B2Og-PbO, Na2CO3 and NaFeO2 were recommended as a flux for these compounds. Takada et al. (1971) found that topotactic reactions among a - F e O O H or ~-Fe203 and BaCO3 or SrCO3 are effective to obtain a grain oriented specimen. The crystallographic relationships of the materials are ( 100 )~-F~OOH//(0001)~,_F~203//(0001)S~O.6Fe203, [010],,-F~OOH//[11,201a -Fe203//[1010]SrO.6F~203 • Hot press or hot forging processes are also useful to prepare a dense oriented sintered body (St~iblein 1973, Haneda et al. 1974a).
2. M compound A Ba 2+ ion in the M compound, BaO-6Fe203 (BaM), can be replaced partly or completely by Sr 2+, Pb 2+ and a combination of, for instance, Agl++ La 3÷ or Nal++ La 3+, without changing its crystal structure. Substitutions of Fe 3÷ and 02ion in the compound are also possible. In all cases, substituted ions would be chosen to keep electrical neutrality and to have similar ionic radii with the original ions (see table 2; a more comprehensive table of ionic radii can be seen, for example, in the book of Galasso (1970)). BaM was at first the only main constituent of M-type oxide magnet, produced on an industrial scale but TABLE 2 Ionic radii of several related ions (Pauling 1960). Element
valence
r (A)
Element
valence
r (A)
Element
valence
r (4)
Ag AI As
+1 +3 +3 +5 +2 +3 +2 - 1 +2 +3 +2 - 1 +2 +3
1.26 0.50 0.58? 0.46t 1.35 0.96? 0.99 1.88 0.72? 0.63? 0.72? 1.36 0.74t 0.64t
Ga Ge In Ir La Li Mg Mn
+3 +4 +3 +4 +3 +1 +2 +2 +3 +4 +1 +5 +2 - 1
0.62 0.53? 0.81 0.68? 1.15 0.60 0.65 0.80? 0.66t 0.60? 0;95 0.70 0.69? 1.40
P
+3 +5 +2 +3 +5 +3 +4 +2 +5 +4 +3 +5 +2 +4
0.44t 0.35t 1.207 0.76? 0.62? 0.81 0.71 1.13 0.68t 0.68 0.95 0.59 0.74 0.80
Ba Bi Ca C1 Co Cr Cu F Fe
? Ahrens (1952).
Na Nb Ni O
Pb Sb Sc Sn Sr Ta Ti T1 V Zn Zr
318
H. K O J I M A
SrO-6Fe203 (SrM) has more recently taken over some part of BaM. PbO.6Fe203 (PbM) is used only as an additional material for oxide magnet purposes at present (see ch. 7 by Stfiblein for the applications). In the following section the fundamental properties of BaM, SrM and PbM are described. The properties of solid solutions among BaM, SrM and PbM, and substituted M compounds are treated separately in this chapter.
2.1. BaFele019, SrFe12019 and PbFea2019 2.1. i. Crystal struclure Adelsk61d (1938) determined the crystal structures of BaM, SrM and PbM, prepared by heating co-precipitated mixtures from the solutions of nitrates. Figure 11 is a perspective drawing of BaM. The 02 ions form a hexagonal close packed lattice, so that its layer sequence perpendicular to the [001] direction is A B A B . . . or A C A C . . . as is shown in the figure. Every five oxygen layers, one O 2 ion is replaced with Ba 2+, Sr 2+ or Pb 2+ in BaM, SrM or PbM respectively and this occurs due to the similarity of their ionic radii as given in table 2. Five oxygen layers
(15) (12)
(11)
A
(10)
C
(9)
A
(8)
C
(7) (6)
B
{5)
(4)
(3) (2)
Fig. 11. Perspective illustration of BaO.6Fe203.
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
319
make one molecule and two molecules make one unit cell. Each molecule shows 180° rotational symmetry around the hexagonal c-axis against the lower or upper molecule. The O z- layer containing Ba 2+ is a mirror plane, being perpendicular to the c-axis. Fe 3+ ions occupy the interstitial positions of the oxygen lattice. The space group of the compound is denoted as P63/mmc (D4h) using H e r m a n n Mauguin's (Sch6nflies') symbols. Figure 12 illustrates more clearly the layer structure of BaM, where z means the layer height along the [001] direction and the layer numbers are the same as in fig. 11. Explanation of the symbols used in the figures are also given here. Wyckoff's notations are adopted for every site in the crystal (Henry and Lonsdal 1952). The positions of each atom are tabulated in table 3 (Galasso 1970). Figure
~ (6) 0.45
C~) 0 -2 {12) 0,95
ion
(~) Be2+ ion
Fe3+(4f2)IOctahedral site (5) 0.35
(11) 0,85
(~ Fe3+(2o)J
T
141 0.25
clot 0.75
~
(~ Fe3+ under the layer Lt~ Fe3+ above the layer T relative orientation of magnetic moment
(5) 0.15
(9) 0.65
(2) 0.05
(8) 0.55
(I) Z=O
(7) 0.50
(13) 1.00
Fig. 12. The layer sequence of BaO.6Fe203.
320
H. KOJIMA TABLE 3 Atomic positions of BaFe120~9 (see fig. 12) (Galasso 1970).
Ion 2Ba 2+
24Fe 3+
3802-
Site
Coordinate
x
z
-
0.028 0.189 -0.108
2d 2a 2b 4fl 4f/ 12k
I, 2, 2; 2, ½, ¼ 0,0,0;0,0,1 0,0,¼;0,0, 3 )l I ±(½, 2, Z; 2, 5,Z ~q_ 1 ___(1, 2, z ; 2, 3,1 ~+z) +(x, 2x, z; 2x, x, Y.; x, 2, z; x, 2x, l - z; 2x, x, ½+ z; £, x, ½+ z)
0.167
4e
+(0, 0, z; 0, 0, 1+ z) 1 2 2 ±(3, 3, z; ~, ½, ½+ z) ±(x, 2x, ¼; 2x, x, 3; x, g, ¼) --+(x, 2x, z ; 2x, x, 2 ; x, 2, z; x, 2x, ~1- z; 2x, x, ~+z; £, x, 1+z) 1 1 1 ±(x, 2x, z ; 2 x , x, 2;x, 2, z ; x , 2 x , ~ - z ; 2 x , x , ~ + z ; x , x , ~ )
0.186 0.167 0.500
4f 6h 12k
-
--
0.150 -0.050 0.050 0.150
13, t h e (110) s e c t i o n of B a M , is a n o t h e r e x p r e s s i o n o f t h e c r y s t a l s t r u c t u r e , s h o w i n g a t o m s a n d s y m m e t r y e l e m e n t s in a m i r r o r p l a n e c o n t a i n i n g t h e c - a x i s ( B r a u n 1957). S a n d R a r e t h e b u i l d i n g b l o c k s of t h e crystal, a n d S* a n d R * i n d i c a t e t h e b l o c k s , o b t a i n e d by r o t a t i n g S a n d R t h r o u g h 180 ° a r o u n d t h e c-axis, as p r e v i o u s l y i l l u s t r a t e d . It can b e said, t h e r e f o r e , t h a t t h e u n i t cell of B a M is 21
63
6 C 6
63
++3++2,
R~
ooz
~'~hz ~U/~z iIz [JTo]
Fig. 13. The (110) cross section of BaO-6Fe203.
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
321
expressed as RSR*S*. Moreover, Townes et al. (1967) refined the crystal structure of BaM by X-ray investigation. They stated two points: o(i) The Fe 3÷ ion in the trigonal bipyramidal site, 2b, is split into half atoms 0.156 A away from the mirror plane, 4e. (ii) Some iron octahedra occur in pairs which share a common face to form Fe209 coordination groups. The former is supported by some M6ssbauer investigators (see ch. 2 section 4.2.1 M6ssbauer effect). Atomic coordinates, interatomic distances and structure factors are tabulated in their paper which gives more accurate results. Figure 14 shows perspective drawing of the R (BaFe6Oll), S (Fe6Os) and T (Ba2FesO14) blocks separately. The T block is related only with the Y, Z and U I-
0
(
Fig. 14. Perspective drawings of building blocks in the hexagonal compounds, T(Ba2Fe8014), S(Fe6Os) and R(BaFe6On).
322
H. KOJIMA j
Qlf
2
j ~ J
Fig. 15. Unit cell of BaO.6Fe20), showing the crystal structure composed of spinel blocks and Ba layers (Gorter I954). TABLE 4 Lattice constants, molecular weights and X-ray densities of M-type compounds. Lattice constant Compound
Molecular weight (g/mol)
a (,~)
c (,~)
c/a
X-ray density (g/cm ~)
Ref.
23.i94 23.20 23.182 23.17
3.936 3.94 3.936 3.943
5.29 5.29 5.30 5.33
(a) (b) (c) (d)
BaFe12019
1111.49
5.893 5.89 5.889 5.876
SrFe12019
1061.77
5.885 5.876 5.864
23.047 23.08 23.031
3.916 3.92s 3.928
5.10 5.11 5.14
(e) (c) (d)
PbFe12019
1181.35
5.877 5.889
23.02 23.07
3.917 3.917
5.70 5.66
(d) (c)
(a) Tauber et al. (1963) (b) Smit and Wijn (1959) (c) Bertaut et al. (1959) (d) Adelsk61d (1938) (e) Routil and Barham (1974)
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
323
c o m p o u n d s but is shown here to illustrate the relationship a m o n g the blocks (see ch. 2 sections 4.l and 4.3). S has the cubic spinel structure with the [ l l l ] axis vertical. In other words, M is synthesized by piling up a Ba layer and a spinel block, whose layer sequence is A B C A . . . . alternatively (see fig. 11). G o r t e r (1954) showed this simply by fig. 15, where spinel block contains four oxygen layers. Molecular weight, X-ray density and lattice constants reported by various investigators are tabulated in table 4.
2. 1.2. Magnetic structure M-type c o m p o u n d s have a typical ferrimagnetic structure, that is, the orientation of the magnetic m o m e n t s of the ferric ions in the crystal are generally aligned along the c-axis in antiparallel with each other. Ndel (1948) and A n d e r s o n (1950) first considered from the theoretical view point that these alignments of magnetic ions can be realized by superexchange interaction through oxygen ions and such a structure has been proved from the experimental results of saturation magnetization, neutron diffraction, M6ssbauer effect and nuclear magnetic resonance etc. Grill and H a b e r e y (1974) calculated the exchange parameters of Fe > ions in BaM, as shown in table 5. H e r e it can be clearly seen that the closer the angle of the F e - O - F e b o n d approaches 18(t°, the larger the exchange p a r a m e t e r b e c o m e s
TABLE 5 Distances and angles of the Fe-O-Fe bonds and calculated exchange parameters in BaFe12Ot,~ (Grill and Haberey 1974). Distance (A)
Angle (degree)
Exchange parameter
Calculated value (K//z~)
'~ Fe(b')-OR2Fe(f2) { ]' Fe(b')-OR2-Fe(f:) ,~
1.886 + 2.060 1.886 + 2.060
142.41 132.95
Jbf2
35.96
{ Fe(f0-Os~-Fe(k) I" ,~Fe(f~)-Os2-Fe(k) ~"
1.897 + 2.092 1.907+ 2.107
126.55 121.00
Jkf~
19.63
]"Fe(a)-Osz-Fe(f~) +
1.997 + 1.907
124.93
Jaf~
18.15
{ Fe(f2)-OR3-Fe(k) ]"
1.975 + 1.928
127.88
Jf2k
4.08
]"Fe(b')-OR,-Fe(k) '[' '["Fe(b")-OR~-Fe(k) 1'
2.162+ 1.976 2.472 + 1.976
119.38 119.38
Jbk
3.69
]"Fe(k)-OR,-Fe(k) 1" ~"Fe(k)-Os,-Fe(k) ~" I"Fe(k)-Os2-Fe(k) ~ '["Fe(k)-OR~-Fe(k) ~"
1.976 + 1.976 2.092 + 2.092 2.107+ 2.107 1.928 + 1.928
97.99 88.17 90.08 98.05
J~k
<0. I
"["Fe(a)-Os2-Fe(k) 1"
1.995 + 2.107
95.84
J~k
<0.1
{ Fe(f2~OR2-Fe(f2) $
2.060 + 2.060
84.64
Jf2f2
<0.1
Bond
324
H. K O J I M A
and when the angle is closer to 90 ° , the p a r a m e t e r becomes negligible small. Thus, arrows in figs. 11 and 13 etc. are the orientation of the magnetic m o m e n t s of each ferric ion as a result of superexchange interaction. One can see in these figures that the S block contains four Fe 3+ of up-spin in octahedral sites and two Fe 3+ of down-spin in tetrahedral sites. In the R block, there exist three Fe 3+ of up-spin in octahedral sites, two Fe 3÷ of down-spin in octahedral sites and one Fe 3+ of up-spin in a trigonal bipyramidal site. Considering the magnetization values of B a M with the Andersons (1950) indirect exchange theory, the exchange scheme of the compound is illustrated in fig. 16, proposed by Gorter (1957), and these relations are tabulated in table 6. Notations of the sublattices commonly used for M6ssbauer or N M R investigations are also shown in the last column of the table.
[20 =l14f, ~ J4f2~ 2
14f2~ b[ [4f2//~12k [[[
I 14f2,2kHt t20--lt4', Fig. 16. Exchange interaction scheme in the unit cell of the magnetoplumbite structure. Each arrow represents the magnetic moment of a Fe 3+ ion (Gorter 1957). TABLE 6 Coordination number and direction of magnetic moment of Fe 3÷ ions in the unit cell of the magnetoplumbite type crystal.
Coordination number
Number of positions
Wyckof's notation
Direction of magnetic moment per mole
Remarks
6 (Octahedral site)
12 4
k f2
I" I" I" I' '~ 1' ~ ~,
I (a) III (d)
2
a
t
v (b)
4 (Tetrahedral site)
4
fl
$ ,~
II (c)
5 (Trigonal bipyramidal site)
2
b
I"
IV (e)
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
325
The total magnetization at temperature T, therefore, is expressed as Ms(T) = 6O-k(T) -- 2o-f~(T) - 2o-~2(T) + O'b(T) + O'a(T),
(1)
where, Ok, O-fl, O'f2, O'b and O'a denote the magnetization of one Fe 3+ ion in each sublattice. Because Fe 3+ has the magnetic moment of 5/~B at 0 K, eq. (1) is calculated as Md0 K) = 5 x (6 - 2 - 2 + 1 + 1) = 20/~B.
(2)
This value agrees well with the experimental result of BaM as described in the next section. The large magnetocrystalline anisotropy of compounds was explained by Smit (1959) from the effect of Fe 3+ in the trigonal bipyramidal site, where a ferric ion is surrounded by five oxygen ions. Fuchikami (1965) also showed theoretically the contribution of Fe B+ in the trigonal site as principally responsible for the uniaxial anisotropy. On the other hand, Van Wieringen (1967) stressed from the M6ssbauer investigations that the contributions to the anisotropy from all of five sublattices should be more or less equally considered.
2.1.3. Saturation magnetization The saturation magnetization per unit volume, Ms, per gram o-s, the number of Bohr magnetons per mole Ns at room temperature or 0 K and the ferromagnetic Curie temperature 0c for BaM, SrM and PbM reported by various authors are collected in table 7. Values of NS at 0 K for these three compounds are about 20/-tB and agree well with the theoretically expected values from their magnetic structures as given by eq. (1) or (2). The temperature dependences of the saturation magnetization Ms near the Curie points are shown for BaM and SrM by Shirk and Buessem (1969) in fig. 17. Figure 18 illustrates the compariso n of Ms for BaM (Rathenau et al. 1952), SrM (Jahn and Mfiller 1969) and PbM (Pauthenet and Rimet 1959a) in a wider temperature range. In addition, fig. 19 and fig. 20 are other reported o-~T relations for BaM and SrM (Shirk and Buessem 1969) and BaM (Tauber et al. 1963, Casimir et al. 1959) respectively. Belov et al. (1965) pointed out that the spontaneous magnetization of BaM along the c-axis is somewhat greater than that in the perpendicular direction to it, and found the difference of 0c between both directions to be as shown in table 8. Similar facts are reported on the paramagnetic Curie points, as described later. Though the reported results are slightly different from author to author, the magnetic characteristics of M-type compounds may be summarized as follows: (i) The saturation magnetization becomes smaller according to the order to SrM, BaM and PbM; (ii) The Curie temperatures also become smaller in the same order; (iii) Saturation magnetization versus temperature curves are almost straight or rather concave with a steep slope in the temperature range of 200 and 600 K.
326
H. KOJIMA
©
÷
k~
s,
d °
(-q d
o.
0
+1 o';
I
+J
['---
8 +~
I
+1 t-,-
t'--
8 o'3 ~
0
tt3
or-e0
I
+1 t~
tt3
t'q
,4~d
p-- ,,o
5
'4~ eq
z
o
r~
F U N D A M E N T A L P R O P E R T I E S OF H E X A G O N A L F E R R I T E S
327
120
80
--(
,
•
'o_ ×
6O
4 0
20
.
700
.
.
.
.
•
.
I
o
680
.
I T
720 740 760 Temperature (K)
780
Fig. 17. Saturation magnetization versus temperature near the Curie points of BaO.hFc_-(% and SrO.6Fe203 (Shirk and Buessem 1969): (1) BaM, (2) SrM. -200
600
-I00
TemperQture (°C) IO0 200
0
300
400
500
(I)
~.
400
x
300
,,¢
x
I
'-" 2 0 0
~
ioo
-
.
-
I'
0 0
200
.
.
.
+
----
.
~
i
\
i
400 Temperafure
600
-
__ 800
(K)
Fig. 18. Saturation magnetization of BaO.6Fe203, SrO.6Fe203 and PbO.6Fe203 as a function of temperature: (1) BaM (Rathenau et al. 1952), (2) SrM (Jahn and Mfiller 1969), (3) PbM (Pauthenet and Rimer 1959a).
TABLE 8 Differences of ferromagnetic Curie temperature 0¢ of BaFe12Ot9 along and perpendicular to the c-axis (Belov et al. 1965). Sample
0c//(°C)
00~ (°C)
0c/j-0ci
Single crystal
440.3
436.5
3.8 °
Polycrystal (oriented)
459.4
453.3
6.1 °
328
H. K O J I M A
I \,
100
~g < E, 80
b x 60 k x 40 03
2O
0
0
200 400 600 Temperature (K)
800
Fig. 19. Plot of saturation magnetization per gram versus temperature for BaO-6Fe203 and SrO.6Fe203 (Shirk and Buessem 1969): (1) BaM, (2) SrM. Temperature (°C) 2O0
0
200
400
I
I
I
100
,E
\
80
b-
'O
x 60 b & 4O ID
C 20
0
400 600 200 800 Temperature (K) Fig. 20. Plot of saturation magnetization per gram versus temperature for BaO.6Fe203: (1) Tauber et al. (1963), (2) Casimir et al. (1959).
0
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
329
2.1.4. Magnetocrystalline anisotropy Villers (1959a) measured the specific magnetization of a PbM single crystal as a function of the applied field. From his results along various measured directions against the c-axis, as shown in fig. 21, a fairly large uniaxial anisotropy can be estimated for the crystal. In fig. 22, magnetizing curves of B a M (Casimir et al. 1959) and P b M (Pauthenet and Rimet 1959a) perpendicular to the c-axis are c o m p a r e d at various temperatures. Magnetocrystalline anisotropy constants K~ as a function of t e m p e r a t u r e are plotted for B a M (Rathenau et al. 1952, Shirk and Buessem 1969), SrM (Jahn and Mfiller 1969, Shirk and Buessem 1969) and PbM (Pauthenet and Rimet 1959a, Villers 1959b) in figs. 23, 24 and 25 respectively. When the direction of the spontaneous magnetization in a hexagonal crystal is expressed by polar coordinates, 0 and ~b with respect to the crystal axis, assuming the z-axis is the c hexagonal axis, then the magnetocrystalline energy E is given by E = K~ sin 2 0 + / ( 2 sin 4 0 + K3 sin 6 0 + / ( 4 sin 6 0 COS 6 (D q-
.
.
.
.
(3)
For M-type compounds,/£2,/(3 . . . . are negligible in comparison with K1 and their 70
I
0=0
otOj,.e_e-e- -
60
/ - T
r
~
Fy
) 5o
/
y,
b 4o ×
H ,x 3 0
vl
,
__.t/#
I
20
/
)
v
b
,o/ 0
0
5
I0
15
20
H (kOe) [ x l O 6 / ( 4 n -) A / m ]
Fig. 21. Magnetization per gram of PbO.6Fe203 single crystal as a function of the magnetic field applied at various angles with respect to the c-axis (Villers 1959a).
330
H. K O J I M A
600 20.4 0 ~ C ' 0 4 2 ~ " 0 " .7 - - - ~ - - - 0 - 0
500
;.~,.
--0-
.
.77.4
K -
K
,~ 2.3-4.2-9,5-15-20.4 K 400
b //
~,l
,~ 300 ×
/
eoo
7SI
~
• JI
tOO
'
'
~
567 K
:4 t
~
:
0
[
!
!
,-----r - ° - 5
0
; I0
I 15
I 20
H (kOe) E x l O e / ( 4 r r )
i 25
G-
30
A/m]
Fig. 22. Magnetization of BaO.6FezO3 and PbO.6Fe203 single crystals at various temperatures as a function of the magnetic field applied perpendicular to the c-axis: ([]) B a M (Casimir et al. 1959), (O) PbM (Pauthenet and Rimer 1959a).
-200
%
4
L
I
Temperofure (°C) 0 I00 200 500
-I00 I
!
r
F
!
r
400
L !
500
i
I L .........
x
~J5
! L
ro
E
/
o
~L × v
~-o
I
T
-
i i
0
200
400 Temperafure
600
800
(K)
Fig. 23. Magnetocrystalline anisotropy constant K~ of BaO-6Fe203 as a function of temperature: (C)) R a t h e n a u et al. (1952), (Q) Shirk and Buessem (1969).
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
331
~ 5 tO -3
4
% ,x, 3
.,
t,3
E 0
"" 2
--
[
X
"-- o
0
200
:
400
Temperafure
600
%800
(K)
Fig. 24. Magnetocrystalline anisotropy constant K~ of SrO.6Fe203 as a function of temperature: (O) Jahn and Miiller (1969), (z~) Shirk and Buessem (1969).
t¢3
E4
4
J
E
s%
%s
X t...a
,<
.-,%.
0
(2) K 2
2 ,n E O
\°Xo ~'~.~
ID
%
O
0
x 0 0
200
400
Temperature
600
x
800
(K)
Fig. 25. Magnetocrystalline anisotropy constant KI and K2 of PbO.6Fe203 as a function of temperature: (O), (O), Kj K2, Pauthenet and Rimet (1959a); (A) K~ Villers (1959b).
values were reported only for PbM, as shown in fig. 25 and table 9. The order of the values of Kj among the three compounds is again, the same as M~, i.e., SrM > BaM > PbM, though the difference between SrM and BaM is not clear in s o m e cases. Now, because HA defines the maximum coercivity as described in the next section, we shall briefly compare HA values among these compounds. Since the magnetocrystalline anisotropy field HA for uniaxial materials is given by Ha = 2KI/Ms,
(4)
we can easily estimate the value of HA from the data of K1 and Ms, described here. Figures 26 and 27 give curves of HA against temperature for BaM (Rathenau et al. 1952, Shirk and Buessem 1969) and SrM (Jahn and M/iller 1969, Shirk and
332
H. KOJIMA
X
x~ ~+~
0
o
~+
©
II
dddd e.
II
×
dd
e-
e.
~
~
e-
¢=
-ff
d +l
~
+1
tt~
t--
~.
x
+1
+i
Ca
e.
¢e)
xa
eqeq
¢q.
Me4
m
+1 t'q
m. +1
+1
ff
o ~7
m
F U N D A M E N T A L P R O P E R T I E S OF H E X A G O N A L F E R R I T E S
-200 ,
20
T e m p e r e f u r e (°C) 0 I00 200 300 i I! I i
-I00 ~
400
333
500
I
i
"..4 < i 5 - -
'~ o
I0
x
o
5
31
i!
0
0
260
i
400 Temper0ture
600
l
800
(K)
Fig. 26. Magnetocrystalline anisotropy field HA versus temperature for BaO.6Fe203: (C)) Rathenau et al. (1952), (A) Shirk and Buessem (1969).
25
20
\
< 15 .........
o
(3)
" - . . ~
""\ \
×
10 o '1-
5
0 0
200
400 Temperature
600
800
(K)
Fig. 27. Magnetocrystalline anisotropy field HA versus temperature for SrO.6Fe203 and PbO'6Fe203. SrM: (1) Jahn and M/iller (1969), (2) Shirk and Buessem (1969). PbM: (3) calculated from the data of Pauthenet and Rimet (1959a).
334
H. KOJIMA
Buessem 1969) respectively. The broken line in fig. 27 shows HA of PbM calculated from the results of Pauthenet and Rimet (1959a). There are broad maxima between 400 and 600 K, except Rathenau's results. Beside the data in figs. 23-27, the reported values of the magnetocrystalline anisotropy constant K~ and anisotropy field Ha are tabulated in table 9. Above all, from these points of view, SrM eventually shows the best properties as the permanent magnet material among the three compounds. 2.1.5.
())ercive force
It can be generally said that the coercive force of ferrite magnets such as sintered or bonded compacts of BaM, SrM or PbM powders, originates in the magnetic behaviour of single domain particles with uniaxial magnetocrystalline anisotropy. Now we shall briefly describe general considerations regarding the coercive force of such materials. The critical diameter of a particle, where a single domain state can be energetically realized, was obtained by Kittel (1946) and Ndel (1947) as D = (9/2¢r)(O-w/m~),
(5)
cr,~ in the equation denotes the domain wall energy per unit area and approximately written by O-w= 4(AK) '/2 .
(6)
Here, A expresses the exchange constant. In table I{L the values of D~, ow and MHc are listed for M compounds.
Since only rotation of magnetization can be expected in a particle of smaller diameter than D~, assuming its demagnetizing factor as N. we can write the coercive force as MHc = 2 K / M ~ - N M ~ .
(7)
For the magnetizing process of a powder assembly, Stoner and Wohlfarth (1948) assumed the coherent rotation mode without any interaction effect, and concluded that the coercivity factor obtained was 0.48 for the randomly oriented powders; then MHc is given by MHc
=
0.48(2K/Ms - NMs) .
(8)
For M compounds, crystals are usually easy to grow along the c plane, so that N affects MHc more unfavourably than spherical particles. However, we still cannot attain the MHc value of eq. (8) experimentally for practical hexagonal ferrite powders. To explain this, various magnetization reversal mechanisms of incoherent type have been proposed. For example, by considering the interaction field of surrounding magnetic dipoles, Eldridge (1961) simply estimated the effect of mutual interaction. Hence, we can
F U N D A M E N T A L P R O P E R T I E S OF H E X A G O N A L F E R R I T E S
335
e~
0
8
©
io<
,=
$
!c ,
t¢3
I
;o II
[,q
X kD kD
5
I
II
II
a O
O
.o
0 ,,=
O
'i
N O
"a
a
!
ff
)
N
1
e~
I
D.
e~ o
6 L)
6 L)
)
~d
8
11
© e~
©
© 0
0
~.~
¢..)
#
&-a
m.
o
uq
~
6
trl
x
~'~
m
O~ ,4
o
o.
~D tt3
t~q
X
d ©
o. O0
e~ ¢-
E
+1 t'4
¢×
O
4
e. o o
o,
~ E
g =N
336
H. K O J I M A
generally express MHc using his results: MHc = MHc(0)- CpMs, with C = 1.7.
(9)
Here MHc(0) and p express the coercive force of ideal coherent rotation and the volumetric packing factor of the powder assembly. Bottoni et al. (1972) deduced the partial existence of chains of spheres with fanning mode from the rotational hysteresis measurements for dry-milled BaM powders. Many researchers, for example, Hoselitz and Nolan (1969), Ratnum and Buessem (1972), Haneda and Kojima (1973a, 1974) besides others mentioned below, have been discussing the causes for the reduction of domain nucleation field and they concluded that domain wall movement should be also considered for the magnetizing process of M compound powders, even though they are sufficiently small compared to Dc in table 10. For instance, lattice defects (Heimke 1962, 1963), different phases (Richter and Dietrich 1968), stacking faults or deformation twins (Rantnam and Buessem 1970), local changes in anisotropy (Aharoni 1962), inhomogeneity of magnetic field in the edge of plate like crystals (Holtz 1970) etc. can be given as factors to be considered as possible causes. Experimental results of packing effects on MHc are illustrated in fig. 28 for BaM (1), (2) by Shimizu and Fukami (1972), BaM (3) by Luborsky (1966) and SrM (4) by Hagner and Heinecke (1974). We can say from these results that the constant C is rather smaller than the value of eq. (9) for BaM or SrM, and this may be caused by their larger Ks and lower Ms values. The last authors especially stressed the importance of the agglomeration effect to verify the dependence of MHc on the packing density. To prevent the agglomeration, they used a soft ferrite to dilute SrM powders and measured MHc above the Curie temperature of the soft
4000
<
3000
g (4)
_o 2 0 0 0 x
o o "1"
I000
0
0
0.2
0.4 Packing
0.6 factor
0.8
1.0
P
Fig. 28. Effect of the packing factor on the coercive force of BaO.6Fe203 and SrO'6Fe203. (1), (2) BaM (Shimizu and Fukami 1972), (3) BaM (Luborsky 1966), (4) SrM (Hagner and Heinecke 1974).
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
337
ferrite. But Tfmfisoiu et al. (1976) reported a very high MHc value of 6500 Oe [5.17x 105A/m], obtained for SrM by the ordinary dispersion method in zirconium oxide powder or an epoxy resin, if the packing factor p ranges from 0.1 to 0.01. Curve (1) in fig. 29 is an example of the change in MHc during the milling process (after Haneda and Kojima (1974)). Though the shape of the curve depends on the grinding conditions, MHc generally increases at first and then decreases with milling time. The first rise is presumably caused by the approach to the single domain behaviour and the following decrease may be explained b y various causes introduced by the prolonged milling process, as mentioned before. Curve (2) in the figure shows MHc obtained by annealing the specimenS of curve (1) at 1000°C for an hour. The remarkable increase may be mainly due to the recovery of various defects. The MHc versus particle diameter relations of BaM are compared in fig. 30. Shirk and Buessem (1971) determined the particle size by X-ray (1) and electron microscope (2), while Sixtus et al. (1956) measured MHc against thickness (3) and diameter (4) of the platelets. Powders larger than 10 .4 c m seem to behave as multidomain particles and below 2 x 10 6cm by X-ray or 6 x 10-6cm by electron microscope, superparamagnetic effects are likely to be predominant. Since superparamagnetic powders do not show a hysteresis loop, MHc abruptly tends to zero in this region. If the particle has volume V and Sc denotes the superparamagnetic critical size, the coercivity factor against V/Sc can be expressed as in fig. 31, according to the calculated results of Shirk and Buessem (1971) for the case of BaM. Hence, one can say the Stoner-Wohlfarth model is valid only under the condition of V ~ 100So, that is roughly larger than 4 x 10-6 cm in diameter for a BaM particle; the agreement of this estimation with the results in fig. 30 is reasonably good.
k
II 1
0
/
~'
--e~e'--
•
O
I
0
0
50
100 Milling time (hr)
150
200
Fig. 29. Milling and annealing effect on the coercive force of BaO.6Fe203 (Haneda and Kojima 1974), (1) as milled powder, (2) after annealing at 1000°C for 1 h.
338
H. KOJIMA 104
<
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I i I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
o
i0 3
O x
I)
(2)
x\
O i0 2
I0
I
I
10-6
I I
I
I
II
I
10-5
I
I I
iO-4
Porficle
I
I
[ I
IO-3
diomefer
I fO-Z
(cm)
Fig, 30. Relation of coercive force and particle size in BaO.6Fe203: (1) diameter as spheres determined by X-ray, (2) by electron microscope (Shirk and Buessem 1971), (3) thickness of platelets determined by optical microscope, (4) diameter (Sixtus et al. 1956).
Figure 32 shows the changes of MHc with temperature; i.e., for SrM (1) and BaM (2) by Mee and Jeschke (1963), BaM (3) by Sixtus et al. (1956), BaM (4) by Rathenau (1953) and SrM (5) by Jahn and Mdller (1969). All results show maxima between 200 ° and 300°C. Rathenau tried to explain the maximum of MHc by assuming a single domain state around 300°C and a multidomain state at room 0.6
i
i
E
~
i
i
i
E
E
i
I
I
i
i
i
I
I
I
0.5
0.4
8 0.3
$ o.2
3
0.1
0
I
I0
10 2
I
03
V/Sc Fig, 31. Coercivity factor against particle size for isotropic powder assemblies (Shirk and Buessem 1971). V: volume of a particle, So: super-paramagnetic critical size; dotted line: Stoner-Wohlfarth model.
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
6
o~
.---o
°'~
''°
.-
339
l
?< 5~
~"
£
!
i
-200
i
0
200 Temperature
I
400
(°C)
Fig. 32. Temperature dependence of the coercive force for BaO-6Fe2Os and SrO-6Fe203. (1) BaM, (2) SrM (Mee and Jeschke 1963), (3) BaM (Sixtus et al. 1956), (4) BaM (Rathenau 1953), (5) SrM (Jahn and M/iller 1969).
9 8
I i i
r
i
i
6
s
j
J 5
-200
0
200 Temperature (*C)
400
Fig. 33. Temperature dependence of ",/~/Ms, which is proportional to the critical diameter of single domain particle (Rathenau 1953).
340
H. K O J I M A
temperature. He reported the temperature dependence of (KO1/2/Msas in fig. 33, to which the critical particle diameter Do would be proportional. His explanation is based on the increase of this quantity with temperature. However, this might only be one reason, because many authors reported maxima of HA in the same temperature range as MHc (see figs. 26 and 27). Craik and Hill (1977) pointed out that the strong domain wall pinning could be expected at grain boundaries of BaM powders without supposing any imperfections and so the role of grain boundaries is important in relation to the coercivity mechanisms. Thus, the magnetization reversal process in hexagonal oxide powders are still open to investigation for some details, even for the particles of critical size. But we may now conclude that all the factors described here should be considered, though the dominant magnetizing mechanism depends perhaps on the preparation method. When the magnetization reversal is achieved by the nucleation and growth of reverse domain, the angular variation of coercive force, plotted as MHc versus 1/cos 0, shows a linear relation. Here, 0 expresses the angle between the applied field and the easy axis of the oriented powder assembly. Ratnam and Buessem (1972) obtained this relation with BaM particles of 100-200 Ixm as shown in fig. 34. However, if particles perfectly follow the Stoner-Wohlfarth model then MHc can be drawn as the curve S-W in fig. 35; here the value of the effective anisotropy field HA is assumed to be 12000 Oe [9.5 × 105 A/m], considering the demagnetizing factor. For practical powders, magnetizing process takes place by both of these mechanisms and thus curve (2) is observed as the angular dependence of ordinary ball-milled BaM powders. For the sample prepared under relatively defect-free conditions, for instance by the chemical co-precipitation 240 o
E 200 <
/
F-
~O -×
160
,¢ ×
120
/
O IO × v
u "r
40
/
/
f
o .
o
0.2
0,4
0,6
0,8
1.0
cos 8 Fig. 34. A n g u l a r dependence of the coercive force for oriented BaO.6Fe203 powders (Ratnam and B u e s s e m /972).
F U N D A M E N T A L PROPERTIES OF H E X A G O N A L FERRITES 12
I
341
/I
~lo \
i
/ K//
tt
I
S-W
2
, ~ Q
/
O ~ Q ~ O
---''-tD'-''~"
~
~ ,
(2) 0 0
0
40 0 (degree}
60
80
Fig. 35. Analysis of magnetizing process in BaO.6Fe;O; powders from the angular variation of coercivity (Haneda and Kojima 1973a): (1) co-precipitated powders, (2) ball-milled powders, (S-W) calculated curve by the coherent rotation model, (K) calculated curve by the magnetizing process with wall motion.
method, they may be magnetized mostly by coherent rotation, as proved by curve (1) in fig. 35, where it completely agrees with curve S - W in the range 4 0 ° < 0 < 90 ° . To see the difference more clearly, magnetizing curves are compared with the theoretical S - W curve in fig. 36. Demagnetizing curves of defect-less powders of BaM (1) and SrM (3) agree well with the calculated curves for coherent rotation, S-W, but ball-milled BaM powders (2) behave rather differently from the S - W model (Haneda and Kojima 1973a, Tfinfisoiu et al. 1976). Ratnam and Buessem
i//
I
f
id " /'"'1
.g ,"
I
I
5
--
,/i~
Fig. 36. Demagnetizing curves of unoriented powder assemblies: (1) co-precipitated BaM, (2) ballmilled BaM (Haneda and Kojima 1973a), (3) wet-milled and annealed SrM (Tfinfisoiu et al. 1976).
342
H. KOJIMA
(1972) and Haneda and Kojima (1973a) proposed methods to estimate the ratio of the two magnetizing mechanisms in a powder assembly from the angular variation of MHc. The highest MHc values obtained hitherto by special preparation methods are listed, together with other experimental conditions, in table 10.
2.1.6. Paramagnetic properties Borovik and Mamaluy (1963) measured the temperature dependence of the susceptibility per gram above the Curie point for M compounds. Figure 37 shows the 1/xg-r relations of BaM (1) (Gorter 1954), SrM (2) and PbM (3) (Borovik and Mamaluy 1963). They also determined N6el's constants for the susceptibility per atom XA; ~r, CA and X0,A in eq. (10) (N6el 1948) by a graphical method from the results of fig. 37. Here, 1 1 T ~ XA Xo,A CA
oT-0'
(10)
and 0 can be given by o = nCAA~
(2 + o~+/?),
(11)
where CA is the atomic Curie constant for Fe3+; A,/x are the numbers of the Fe 3+ ions in the A and B sublattice; n, a and /3 are the molecular field constants connected with the exchange interactions of the AB, A A and BB types. If the T (°C) 600 8
I
I
I
800 iI
IO00 i ] ~ t , ~I I
1
,~.
.o/e
{,9
~.
I 6
[/I/
..
l
~s x 4 3
~o x- 2
1
/ I
1
I
0
II00 1300 T{K) Fig, 37. Temperature dependence of the specific susceptibility above the Curie temperature: (1) BaM (Gorter 1954), (2) SrM, (3) PbM (Borovik and Mamaluy 1963). 700
900
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
343
m o l a r susceptibility XM is used i n s t e a d of XA in eq. (10), t h e n CM can b e o b t a i n e d i n s t e a d of CA. T h e c o n s t a n t s are t a b u l a t e d in t a b l e 11. B o r o v i k a n d M a m a l u y c o n c l u d e d that the c o n s t a n t s X0,A, Cr, CA, a n d t h e r e f o r e the m o l e c u l a r field c o n s t a n t s are r o u g h l y the s a m e for h e x a g o n a l a n d cubic ferrites. A l d o n a r d et al. (1966) m e a s u r e d XM of P b M a n d f o u n d different values for AiM with a p p l i e d m a g n e t i c field parallel a n d p e r p e n d i c u l a r to the c-axis, as s h o w n in fig. 38. T h e y also d e r i v e d t h e following f o r m u l a from the precise m e a s u r e m e n t of the t e m p e r a t u r e c h a n g e in XM in cgs u n i t b e t w e e n 800 a n d 1200 K along the c-axis: 1 XM
1 T 38.21 + 6 5
4367 T-655"
(12)
10 9
I C aXiS
o
H II
•
H .L c oxis /
~7
2
I
.,//
fd-
J/"
!
Az
-~5
~3 "2_ I ///1 0 ////
710
720
7:30 T(K)
740
750
Fig. 38. Temperature dependence of the molar susceptibility of PbM along parallel and perpendicular directions to the c-axis (Al6onard et al. 1966).
TABLE 11 N6el constants of M compounds according to eq. (10) (Borovik and Mamaluy 1963).
Compound
CA cm3K/atom
CM cm3K/mol
BaM SrM PbM
0.0515 0.0475 0.0526
58 51 61
CA: atomic Curie constant of Fe3+ ions, CM: Curie constant obtained from molar susceptibility.
104 (emu/atom) [1/(4zr) × 10 4 S I / a t o m ]
o- x 105 K atom/cm3
5.1 5.8 6.8
26 27 31
l/X0, A X
344
H. K O J I M A
2.1.7. Magnetic aftereffect Diilken et al. (1969) investigated the relaxation phenomena of polycrystal BaM. They measured the complex permeability between 77 and 743 K in the frequency range from 500 Hz to 100 kHz. The real p a r t / x ' and the imaginary part/x" of the initial permeability as a function of temperature T, measured at i kHz for Fe 2+ free BaM, show linear relations with T, as shown in fig. 39(a). However, /x" of BaM with 0.24wt% Fe 2+ measured at 10kHz shows three maxima at - 1 8 5 °, - 1 4 5 ° and +60°C, as shown in fig. 39(b). If k and Q denote Boltzmann's constant and the appropriate activation energy, then the relaxation time ~- is expressed as,
r
=
"r=
exp(O/kT).
(13)
Diilken et al. (1969) determined O for the three maxima as (I) 0.1 eV, (II) 0.2 eV and (III) 0.6 eV, and the relaxation frequency f = 1/2~-~-= as (I), (II) - 101° Hz and ( I I I ) ~ 1 0 1 3 Hz. These relaxation phenomena can be explained by the diffusion process between Fe 2+ and Fe 3+, which is often observed in cubic ferrites.
5
t h.
I
I
--o-c~-c. -o-o-oc - o - o F'
10°5
Io-) l
5
=._o_oj F"
°-% I
t0 -2
(b) I
!.c-.o--~ ~
"ov---o-c-~-.o~
I 1°°5
F'
510-1l
(a) lo-'
lo-2
5 o'o--c-~ -200
~c.o.o~5 -I00
0 Temperature
I00 (°C)
Fig. 39. Temperature variation of the complex permeabi|ity for polycrystal BaO.6Fe203 (Dtinke] ¢t al. 1969): (a) Fe z+ free B a M at i kHz, (b) B a M with 0.24 w t % Fe 2+ at 10 kHz.
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
345
2.1.8. F M R Numerous experiments of ferromagnetic resonance absorption in BaM or SrM have been reported, most of which aim to determine the anisotropy field H A and the effective spectroscopic splitting factor gen against temperature. Several authors also especially investigated the effects by the shape, size or surface roughness of the samples, the existence of domain walls, or the angle between the applied d.c. field and the easy axis, etc. Figure 40 shows the resonance absorption in BaM at various temperatures. Smit and Beliers (1955) showed with a thin single crystal that only the absorption peak excited by a parallel a.c. field is observed at lower temperature, but the perpendicular field peak appears above room temperature and splits into two at 200°C (fig. 40(a)). Grosser (1970) investigated the resonance absorption of an isotropic polycrystal between 21°C (fres= 22.22 GHz) and 465°C @es = 22.03 GHz) as shown in fig. 40(b), where the resonance field at room temperature moves to lower fields with increasing temperature near the Curie
2.5
\ \\ \ \
A t3 (3 03 ..Q
2.0
1.5
b) \ \
I 450*
\
420*
\
1.0 Q.
o J~
4ti~ .-
0.5
0o
4
8 H
50
~/
(kOe)
12
16
I
(a)
200"C
a~ o
40
IP
to
II
..a
30 g "..7-¢.~ 0 o~ t~
<
20
[xlOS/(4~-) A/m]
11
,/i I
I
I/
20
I
'
IJ
I0 0
I
13 15 17 H (kOe) [x106/(4~) A/m]
19
Fig. 40. Ferromagnetic resonance absorption in BaO.6Fe203 versus applied d.c. field at various temperatures: (a) single crystal (Smit and Beljers 1955), (b) isotropic polycrystal (Grosser 1970).
346
H. KOJIMA
points. The ordinate of the figure is illustrated in arbitrary scale but it is proportional to/x". Figure 41 is the relation of resonance frequency and applied d.c. field for a BaM single-crystal, by Silber et al. (1967). The solid lines in the figure express the calculated results for various angles 00 between the c-axis and the applied field, using the following resonance conditions: (o~/y)2 = [Ha(1 - 2 sin 2 0) + Hext cos(0o - 0)]Hext(sin 0o/sin 0),
(14)
sin 0 cos 0/sin(00- 0) = HexdHa.
(15)
and
Here, ~o, y and 0 represent the resonance frequency, gyromagnetic ratio and angle between the c-axis and the magnetization vector, respectively. The effective anisotropy field is generally given by Ha = HA--(NIl- N±)M~. Thus, Silber et al. determined y from the slope and HA from the intersection with the frequency axis of the zero-degree curve in fig. 41. The "knees" in the experimental data
0o
44*
59*
ID
°.o
.........---
. i'
rv
46
42
0
4
Applied
8
field
2
(k0e)
16
20
"xl06/(4=) A/m]
Fig. 41. Relation of resonance frequency and magnetic field applied at various angles to the c-axis of BaO.6Fe203 single crystal (Silber et al. 1967).
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
347
represent the change from the single domain state at higher fields to the multidomain state at lower fields. The resonance frequencies and absorption intensities in BaM specimens with cylindrical domain structure have been calculated by Sigal (1977) and compared with the experimental results, changing the direction of magnetic field with the easy axis. Typical experimental results are summarized in table 12. When the d.c. field is cycled between _-_25kOe [+_1.99 x 106A/m] for BaM milled powder, Hempel and Kmitta (1971) found a microwave absorption peak at about 2 kOe [1.59 x 105 A/m] with f - - 9.4 GHz, which shows a pronounced hysteresis apart from the F M R occurring at about 15 kOe [1.19 x 106 A/m]. They also observed that the low field losses and the line width of the F M R decrease with increasing annealing temperature of the sample. While Roos et al. (1977) found microwave absorption of chemically co-precipitated, polycrystalline BaM at H --HAl2, when the sample was previously saturated; however, no absorption peak in negative fields was found for the conventionally prepared BaM. They obtained three peaks at H = -6.6 kOe [-5.25 x 105 A/m], -8.8 kOe [-7.00 x 105 A/m] and -15.3 kOe [-1.22 × 106 A/m] with f = 11.9 GHz, and concluded from these results that the magnetization in most particles of the chemically precipitated sample is reversed by coherent rotation. Besides such basic investigations, several studies relevant to the applications to microwave devices have been reported. For example, Dixon Jr. and Weiner (1970) obtained H a = 17-5 kOe [13.5-4.0 x 105 A/m] over the frequency range of f = 23.2-37.6 GHz with BaZnxTixFe12 2xO19. De Bitetto (1964) also investigated the F M R of BaO.x(TiCoO3)-(6-x)Fe203 and SrO-xA1203.(6-x)Fe203 systems and determined HA as 17.5-6.6 kOe and 19.3--53.4 kOe [15.442.5 x 105 A/m] respectively. 2.1.9. N M R Streever (1969) obtained the NMR line shapes of Fe 57 in single-crystal powders at 4.2K and resintered single-domain powder at 77 K for BaM, by plotting the spin-echo amplitudes versus frequency as shown in figs. 42(a) and (b). Each line can be assigned on the basis of the changes in relative intensities and shift in external magnetic fields. M6ssbauer data are also useful to analyze the signals and the reverse is naturally also true. The relations of the sublattices and the notations in the figure are identical to those used in table 5. L/itgemeier et al. (1977) measured relaxation rates of Fe 57 nuclei in BaM between 1.2 and 4.2K and proved that the relaxation time is much shorter for the wall signals than for the domain signals due to the influence of the wall excitations. The temperature dependence of NMR frequencies is summarized in fig. 43, after the results of Streever and Hareyama et al. (1970). Though the temperature changes of signal III (sublattice d) and V (b) show some differences between the two papers, the frequency changes of each signal are almost continuous over the whole temperature range. The temperature dependence of signal I (a) from Fe 3+ in octahedral a sites is more remarkable than those of signal II (c), III (d), IV (e) and V (b), while signal IV (e) appears at a lower frequency than the others. These results
348
H. K O J I M A
T A B L E 12 Summarized results of F M R experiments for M-type compounds.
Compound
BaM
BaM
BaM
Experimental condition
fr~s(GHz)
T(°C)
single cryst, disc, d = 1 m m , t = 40 tzm; disc _1_c-axis, Hr~s and ha in basal plane, angle between Hres and ha is 45 °
23.93 23.98 ' 23.98 23.98 23.98
-196 20 112 155 200
2.00 (assumed) 1.98 2.00 2.01 2.02
single cryst, disc, d = 0.083 cm, t = 0.030 cm; Hr~s//disc,
58.2 58.4 58.6 58.8 59.0
R.T.
1.87
25
1.96
R.T.
1.91 1.91
20
2.05
Hre~//c-axis, hr~A_H ~
single cryst, sphere, d = 0.4 m m
53.0-55.3
ge~
Hresffc-axis, h~//c-axis BaM SrM BaM
BaM BaM
oriented polycrist, slab single cryst, disc, d = 2.60 cm, t = 0.01 cm single cryst, sphere, d = 0.036 cm
51-65
single cryst, sphere, d = 0.05 cm
66.6, 120 66.6, 120
R.T.
2.02 ± 0.01
4.2 (K) 20 (°C)
1.99 - 0.03
single cryst, sphere, d = 0.038~.05 cm,
BaM
Hre~~~c-axis
I>52.0 22
BaM
* Spin wave line width (a) Smit and Beliers (1955) (b) W a n g et al. (1961) (c) Mita (1963) (d) D e Bitetto (1964) (e) Burlier (1962)
(f) (g) (h) (i)
Silber et al. (1967) Kurtin (1969) Dixon and Weiner (1970) Grosser (1970)
R.T. 21 200 300 35O 40O
F U N D A M E N T A L P R O P E R T I E S OF H E X A G O N A L F E R R I T E S
349
T A B L E 12 (continued) Hr~ (kOe) [x 106/(4~-)A/ml hrr//'Hres 14.3 15.05 15.40 15.40 15.35
hrr-l-Hres -10 17.15 17.55 17.15 16.85 3.844 3.886 3.964 4.042 4.140 18.7-28.2
HA (kOe) [X 106/(47r)A/m]
A H (Oe) [x llY/(4~)A/m]
16.2 17.0 17.3 17.3 17.3 18.4
0-13
Ref.
47rMs = 6.67 (kG) 4.80 3.90 3.50 3.12
(a)
p = 5.13 (g/cm3) 3'4 = 2.62 (MHz/G)
(b)
17.55
<12
(c)
17.5 19.3
1600 1600
(d)
17.0 2.0-7.0
Remarks
3' = 2.87 (MHz/G)
16.2 16.1 17.1
(e)
(f) ~<10 46
4~'M~ = 5.2 (kO) AHk* = 2 ± 1.5 (Oe)
(g)
17.0
4~'Ms = 4.8 (kG)
(h)
17.0 17.0 15.1 13.1 10.5
Ms = 375 (G) 248 177 142 106
(i)
350
H. KOJIMA I0
(b)
l I I
/,
4 i
=
2
m o_
E
0 I0
:>
(a)
~
8 6
III lI
2 0 58
/
/% 62
66 Frequency
70
74
78
(MHz)
Fig. 42. Plot of the spin-echo amplitudes versus resonance frequency for BaO.6Fe203 (Streever 1969): (a) single-crystal powders at 4.2 K, (b) resintered single-domain powder at 77 K.
78 .........
~ _ ~ i__~__ .~
74 O. . . . . . .
I 70 2;
I I°
66
"7
'~ ~.,~
g62
r
b_
58
~
]7
54 0
I I00
200 Temperofure ( K )
°""°~' 500
Fig. 43. Temperature dependence of NMR frequency: (O) Streever (1969); (O) Hareyama et al. (1970).
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
351
can be understood from the differences of F e - O - F e bonds for each Fe 3+ ions (see table 5).
2.1.10. M6ssbauer effect Van Loef and Van Groenou (1964) investigated the M6ssbauer effect with BaM single crystals and oriented crystallites enriched in Fe 57. Changing the y-ray direction parallel or perpendicular to the c-axis and with or without the magnetic field of 13 kOe [10.3 x 105 A/m], they observed spectra of I + V (sublattice a + b), II (c), III (d) and IV (e); (note that different labelling methods are used by other investigators). The temperature dependence of the sublattice magnetization, anisotropy and dipole fields, and the exchange constant of the Bloch wall as a function of relative magnetization are discussed in relation with the experimental results. Furthermore, in contrast to other authors, an especially high hyperfine field of the sublattice e was reported by Van Loef et al. (1964). Zinn et al. (1964) also observed M6ssbauer spectra in BaM and explained the temperature dependence of the saturation magnetization by the temperature changes of internal fields for each sublattice, although they considered only two kinds of sublattices as a whole. Kreber et al. (1975) did further M6ssbauer study with BaM, an oriented and enriched polycrystal between 4.2 and 200 K, and nonenriched fine powder at 300 and 870 K. They resolved the spectra as I (sublattice a), II + I I I + V (c + d + b) and IV (e) at low temperature, and I (a), I I I + V (d + b), II (c) and IV (e) above 200 K, respectively. Based on the observed large quadrupole splitting of sublattice e and its distinct change near 80 K, they proposed a model in which Fe 3+ occupies randomly one of the two equivalent sites of Wyckhoff's notation 4e instead of 2b at low temperature. Here, 4e sites are located on the trigonal axis and 0.156A away from 2b site on the mirror plane (see also section 2.1.1 on crystal structure). Using their model, they showed that the temperature dependence of the splitting values, which they had observed, and also the anisotropy behaviour obtained by the M6ssbauer data of Rensen and van Wieringen (1969) can be understood by the molecular orbital calculation after Trautwein et al. (1975). As for SrM, Van Wieringen and Rensen (1966) observed spectra for powders, enriched in Fe 57 at room temperature. Four subspectra are assigned as I (sublattice a), II + V (c + b), III (d) and IV (e). Internal field Hi, quadrupole splitting and isomer shift 6 of four subspectra as a function of temperature are illustrated in figs. 44(a), (b), (c) and 45. Van Wieringen (1967) reviewed M6ssbauer data of M compounds and derived the temperature dependence of saturation magnetization from the values of Hi in fig. 44(a). Figure 44(d) shows the result together with directly measured values, expressed with the open circles, which fit quite satisfactorily with the deduced curve. Comparing the results of BaM by Zinn et al. (1964) or Van Loef and Franssen (1963) with the results by Van Wieringen and Rensen (1966) it can be concluded that the M6ssbauer data of SrM are qualitatively the same as those of BaM, but the main quantitative difference concern rather lower values of Hi and e in SrM. M6ssbauer effect measurements of PbM single and polycrystals between 15 and 780 K were reported by Zinn et al. (1964). Differing from BaM, an intense spectral line at v -- 0, arising from the paramag-
352
H. KOJIMA 120 E '
"'---o
;'
I
iI
(d)
l
90
II
'~o 6 0 - -
~.~. 3o o
I (n
E E
0
60
-I
(b)
-j E E
!
uo
6OO
(o) ,---1
500
400
....... ~---~r-- - - ~
.. "~"
0
3OO o
200
z
I00
0 0
200
400
600
800
T (K) Fig. 44. Variations of the internal field (a), quadrupole splitting (b), isomer shift (c) and saturation magnetization (d) of SrO.6Fe203 against temperature (Van Wieringen and Rensen 1966, Van Wieringen 1967).
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
353
f'
6 . 0 x 10 5
5.0 J
I
I
I
I[(c) I
E(d)
IV(e)
I
I I
-I0
4
I
V(b) J
I
I
I
0
-5
v
I
I
I
5
I
I
i
I
I0
( mm/sec
Fig. 45. Assignment of the M6ssbauer spectrum of SrO.6Fe203 at room temperature (Van Wieringen and Rensen 1966, Van Wieringen 1967).
netic phase was observed in PbO.xFe203 (x = 4-6) near the Curie temperature. A signal corresponding to the paramagnetic phase of 30% was obtained at 700 K, though further investigation regarding the effect of the PbO.2Fe203 paramagnetic phase in the sample seems to be necessary to explain these phenomena. As described hitherto, two kinds of labelling for the M/Sssbauer absorption peaks of M compounds seem to be used. That is, Kreber and Gonser (1973) considered one of the lines V (b) with III (d) as an unresolved one, while Van Wieringen and Rensen (1966) recognized peak V (b) overlapped with peak II (c). Since the N M R data at low temperature by Streever (1969) and at higher temperature by Hareyama et al. (1970) proved that the hyperfine fields and their temperature dependence of III (d) and V (b) are almost the same as shown in fig. 43, the assignment of Kreber and Gonser is suggested to be reasonable. However, when we compare the results of N M R and M6ssbauer measurements, we should, of course, realize that the spectra observed by these two experimental procedures are based on different physical origins. In conclusion, Van Wieringen (1967) summarized the results of M6ssbauer studies with M compounds as follows: (1) The iron ions are trivalent in all sublattices; (2) All five sublattices may be expected to contribute to the crystal anisotropy; (3) The rapid drop in the magnetization with increasing temperature is entirely due to Fe 3+ in sublattice a (signal I). The interest regarding the M6ssbauer studies with M compounds also concerns the determination of ion distributions in the substituted compounds as discussed in detail below. For example, Rensen et al. (1971) investigated A1, Cr, ZnTi,
354
H KOJIMA
ZnGe, ZnSn, ZnZr, CuTi, CoTi, CoCr and NiTi substituted M compounds and found that AI firstly enters the 2a site (sublattice b) and then the 12k site (a); Cr also starts by entering the 2a site. In addition, they concluded that there is no indication of Fe 3+ ions in an asymmetric 4e site at low temperature, contrary to the results of Towns et al. (1967) or Kreber et al. (1975). Kreber and Gonser (1973, 1976) reported that As ions occupy preferentially the 2b site (sublattice e), while Ti 4+ + Co 2+ firstly occupy 4fl (c) o r 4f 2 (d) sites and then randomly the 2a (b), 12k (a), and lastly 2b site (e). If Ba 2+ ion in BaM is replaced with a trivalent ion, Fe 3+ may partly change its valency t o Fe z+ to keep the neutrality. LaFe12Oa9 was investigated from this point of view by Drofenik et al. (1973) and also by Van Diepen and Lotgering (1974). In both papers the authors described the difficulty in observing the Fe z+ sublattice, but the latter authors discussed the preference of Fe z+ ion from the intensity ratio of subspectra. Moreover, Drofenik et al. (1973) determined the Curie point as 697 K from the appearance of the paramagnetic Mrssbauer absorption peak. The hyperfine field at Fe 57 nuclei in different sublattices in LaFe12019 as a function of temperature are similar to BaM or SrM but the change in the 12K sublattice (I) is found to be more convex than that of SrM as in fig. 46. This agrees with the more convex o-s-T curve of LaM as compared to that of SrM. 600
<
"~ 4 0 0 0
\\,,,
×
O
-~
200
\\ g \\ g \\ g
"7-
It
II
0
0
200
',
400 600 800 T (K) F i g 46 Temperature dependence of hyperfine field in LaO 6Fe203 (Drofenik et al. 1973)
2.1.11. D o m a i n observation In the earlier days, domain structures were mainly discussed qualitatively in connection with the magnetic properties of the materials, magnetic anisotropy, magnetizing process and so forth. However, as the sophistication of techniques in domain observation and sample preparation improved, more quantitative investigations were attempted. Further, some of the results acquired in this research
F U N D A M E N T A L P R O P E R T I E S OF H E X A G O N A L FERR1TES
355
field have led to the development of the industrial application of bubble domains. Kooy and Enz (1960), for example, observed the plate-like domains in thin layers of BaM, which were peeled off from the surface of single crystals. They discussed the results of the experimental domain period under the influence of magnetic field and compared them with theoretically calculated results. Specific wall energy and critical diameter of cylindrical domain were also reported in the paper as ~rw= 2.7erg/cm 2 [2.7x 10-3j/m 2] at 50°C and Dc = 0.3 Ixm for a 3 Ixm platlet. Figure 47 illustrates the domain period versus the magnetic field applied parallel to the easy axis for (a) BaM (Kooy and Enz 1960), (b) SrO-4.5Fe203-1.5A1203 and (c) SrO-4.2Fe203.1.8A1203 (Rosenberg et al. 1967). The curve for BaM is the
300
(c) 250
o
~o 150 x
c~ I 0 0 .4-
c~
1
I
_jl
200
E
]
(b)
ii
J I
250 '~ 2 0 0
L 2
~5o
+
I00 ~
c:T
5O 0
50
0
0.5
1.0
0
1.5
H (kOe) [xlOS/(4"rr) A / m ]
0
200
400
H (Oe) [xlO3/(4rr) A/m]
12 I0 '-' 8 10 x
+
cE
6
4
0
0
J
J
1__
I
2
3
4
H (kOe) [x106/(4"n") A/m] Fig. 47. Domain period as a function of the applied field: (a) BaM, thickness: 3 x 10 .4 cm (Kooy and Enz 1960); (b) SrO'4.5Fe203'l.SA1203; (c) SrO-4.2Fe203.1.8A1203 (Rosenberg et al. 1967). D1 + D2: width of antiparallel two domains.
356
H. KOJIMA
result of t h e t h e o r e t i c a l curve fitting. ( U n f o r t u n a t e l y , t h e crystal t h i c k n e s s is not c l e a r for (b) o r (c), b u t t h e s a m e a u t h o r s (1966) r e p o r t e d s e p a r a t e l y t h e D - t r e l a t i o n s of t h e s a m e c o m p o u n d s ; as d e s c r i b e d later.) F i g u r e 48 shows t h e c h a n g e s of d o m a i n structures on t h e b a s a l p l a n e of B a M p l a t e l e t b y t h e F a r a d a y effect ( K o j i m a a n d GotO 1965). C y l i n d r i c a l d o m a i n s a r e c l e a r l y seen in t h e h i g h e r field, just b e f o r e t h e s a t u r a t e d state, as s h o w n in (d) a n d (e).
Fig. 48. Changes of domain structures observed by Faraday effect on the basal plane of BaO-6Fe203 (Kojima and Got6 1965): (a) demagnetized state, (b), (c) H = 3600 Oe [2.86 × 105 A/m] parallel to the c-axis, (d), (e) H = 3900 Oe [3.09 x 105 A/m] parallel to the c-axis. 0: set angle of the analyzer from the crossed nicosol state.
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
357
Moreover, it was proved that maze, parallel or honeycomb domains can be realized as a remanent structure for B a M (Kojima and G o t 6 1965) and for P b M (Kacz6r and G e m p e r l e 1961, Palatnik et al. 1975) and for BaM, SrM and P b M (Kojima and G o t 0 1970). H e n c e a specified domain structure among these three can be brought into existence at will by choosing certain angle ranges of applied magnetizing field direction against the c-axis before the remanent state is produced in the crystal. Utilizing these facts, HA and K1 were determined for small single platelets by Kojima and G o t 6 (1964) as shown in table 9(d). The effects of various kinds of defects on the domain nucleation process were discussed by Kojima and G o t 0 (1965), Wells and R a t n a m (1971) for BaM, and Tfinfisoiu (1972) for A1 substituted SrM, Sr(Fe7.2A14.8)O19. Kojima and G o t 6 found that the h o n e y c o m b domains are m o r e likely to appear in a defect-less crystal which can easily be changed to a crystal showing maze remanent domains by water quenching or pricking with a needle. M o r e quantitative relations have been obtained on the variation of domain width D with crystal thickness t. For simple slab domains, the relevant theoretical equation is given by Kittel (1946) as, D = (O-w/1.7Ms)l/2t m •
(16)
For the domains with reverse spikes near the surface, Kaczdr (1964) modified the relation as: D = [0.3751/Ms)(O'wtX/Tr)l/212/3t2/3,
(17)
where [,, = 1 + 8 r r 2 M d K 1 .
G o t 5 (1966) obtained an experimental formulae D = 0.392t °665 for B a M and D = 0.441t °64° for SrM in the thickness range 2 t x m < t < 2 0 txm. On the other hand, Kacz6r and G e m p e r l e (1960) reported D oc t 1/2 for t < 10 txm and D o c t 2/3 for t > 10 Ixm on the domains of PbM. Rosenberg et al. (1966), moreover, obtained the relations for S r O - ( 6 - x)Fe2OyxA1203; D oc t 0.586 at x = 0, D oc t 0-616 at x = 1.0, D oct 0-665 at x = 1.5, D oct °.418 at x = 1.8, D oct 0.ass at x = 1.9 and D o c t 0.431 at x ~ 2.0. For thinner crystals observed by G o t 6 (1966), the results can be rewritten as D = [0.386(t- 1.460)] 1/2 for B a M and D = [0.432(t- 1.1260)] 1/2 for SrM respectively. H e n c e the one half Power law may be valid in this case, though the physical meanings of the constants are not clear. However, if we consider the existence of a surface layer where the Kittel model might b e c o m e unstable, giving a kind of lattice distorted layer, and also the resolution limit in m e a s u r e m e n t s with an optical microscope, the numerical values in these formulae seem to be reasonable. For thicker crystals, the two third power law related to spike domains seems to be valid. Some deviation from the law could be understood by the complicated domain structures and the resulting ambiguity in the measured values of domain widths.
358
H. KOJIMA
The temperature variation of the domain width D in BaM was studied by Kojima and Goff) (1962). They obtained the temperature coefficient of D as 8.9× 10-4/°C and that of O'w as - 2 . 3 × 10 3/°C. Gemperle et al. (1963) also performed similar experiment with PbM and found the thermal hysteresis of the domain width, as Shimada et al. (1973) observed with honeycomb domains. Kacz6r (1972) discussed these results from a theoretical point of view and showed the free energy decreases linearly to zero as T/Oc changes from 0.2 to 1.0, and the domain width almost doubles in the same temperature range. Furthermore, undulating Bloch walls, for which Goodenough (1956) first gave a theoretical explanation, can be seen on the surface of crystals with medium thickness, for instance, 10 fxm < t < 50 txm for BaM. Szymczak (1971) reported the temperature dependence of domain width, wave amplitude and wave length in these domains. The stability with temperature for honeycomb domains was investigated by Gemperle et al. (1963) with PbM and by Shimada et al. (1973) with BaM. The latter authors observed the increase of the nearest neighbour distance among the cylindrical domains during the temperature rise. The honeycomb domains reversibly change to a mixture of honeycomb and stripe domains by the heat treatment from 600 K to room temperature. It was pointed out that the equilibrium distance theoretically predicted by Kaczdr and Gemperie (1961) would be realized only in such a mixed domain structure. Regarding the same phenomenon, Kozlowski and Zietek (1965) showed from a theoretical consideration that the deviation from Kacz6r and Gemperle's equation in these experiments would rapidly increase for thinner specimens. Grundy (1965) observed Kittel type slab domains in PbM of 1000-2000 thickness by Lorentz microscopy and determined the Bloch wall thickness as 250 _+150 A. Grundy and Herd (1973) used the same technique and applied it in an investigation of the nucleation mode of bubble domains. They gave the material length l = Crw/(4~-M2) as 0.03-0.04 Ixm for BaM and PbM. Wall mobility constant ,1 of 0.7× 102cm/s/Oe for BaFe12019 and 1.6× 102cm/s/Oe for BaFeu.aA10.7019 were reported by Asti et al. (1968).
2.1.12. Optical properties The absorption coefficient a (=2~-K/nA) and Faraday rotation &F of BaM measured at 300 K as a function of wavelength from 1 ~m to 8 p~m by Zanmarchi and Bongers (1969) are shown in fig. 49. It is seen that &V changes sign between 2 ~m and 3 ~m. Drews and Jaumann (1969) measured the absorption coefficient K, refractive index n, Faraday rotation &F, Faraday ellipticity ~/v and Kerr rotation against air ~bw and against glass &KC for the same material in the shorter wavelength region of 0.4 ~m-1.7 ~m. The results are illustrated in fig. 50. Kahn et al. (1969) also added the data of the polar Kerr spectra for PbM, showing° a negative peak at 4.43eV (2799,~) and a positive peak at 5.5 eV (2254A). According to their conclusion, charge transfer transitions occurring at about 4 eV (3100 A) and 5 eV (2480 A), associated with Feoct and Fetet complexes, respectively, are responsible for the principal magnetooptical spectra. Blazey (1974) reported on the wavelength-modulated reflectivity spectra of BaM with the minima at 2.2eV (5636A) and 2.6eV (4769 A) corresponding to the internal
150
I00 'E
300
13
200
¢j
E rj
50 I00
0
"o
v
LL
-g. 0 0 2
0
4
6
X
8
'-I00 I0
(Fm)
Fig. 49. Absorption coefficient a(=2~'K/nA) and Faraday rotation ~bF of BaO.6Fe203 in infrared region at room temperature (Zanmarchi and Bongers 1969). xlO 2 I0.0
7.5
1~F
o o~
5.0
-
-
I--
xlO 2
"F]F
-2.0
LL 2.5
--I.0
o E
o
2
g,
~,,
o -
2.5
1.0
-8-
6
-5.0
2.0 I
3
m
r-
i o- 2
2
-
L
10.4
I
0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
X (/~m) Fig. 50. Optical properties of BaO-6Fe~O3 as a function of wavelength. K: absorption coefficient, n: refractive index, OF: Faraday rotation, rTF: Faraday ellipticity, CbKL:Kerr rotation against air, ~bKo: Kerr rotation against glass, t: 4.5 p~m, / 4 : 1 5 kOe [1.19 x 106 A/m]. 359
360
H. K O J I M A
transition of Fetet and at 3.9 eV (3179 A), 4.3 eV (2883 A) and 4.8 eV (2583 A), these being assumed to be charge transfers to Feoct.
2.1.13. Magnetostriction The saturation magnetostriction in a hexagonal crystal is given by Mason (1954) in the form, a = /~A[(OZI~I q- a2~2) 2 -- (O/1]~ 1 q- O~2][~2)@3~3]q- ~.B[(I -- O~2)
x ( I - fl~) ~ - ( o ~ # , + o~=/?~)=] + a d o
- o d ) B 1 - (o~/3, + o~fl=),~,8~]
(18)
+ 4AD(alB1 + o12f12)a3B3,
where al, a2, O~3 and ill, fi2, r3 are the direction cosines of the magnetization vector and measuring direction. Here, the direction cosines are taken with respect to the Crystal axes, the z-axis coinciding the c-axis. Kuntsevich et al. (1968) determined the constants AA, As, Ac and AD in eq. (18) for BaM in measurements with the following geometry: •A:O/1 =/31: 1, AB:OZl= /3== 1, Ac:OZl = J~3= 1, h D : a l = / 3 1 = a 3 = / 3 3 = l/X/2. Thus, they found the constants at room temperature as AA = -- (15 --+0.5) X 10-6, AB = + (16 + 0.5) X 10-6, Ac = + (11 -+ 0.5) X 10-6 and AD = -- (13 --+0.5) X 10-6. For polycrystals, they also obtained the longitudinal and transverse magnetostrictions, hi! = -(9-+ 0.5)x 10 6 and h~ = + (4.5 -+ 0.5) x 10-6. However, these values do not coincide with the values derived by the simple averaging of the formula for a single crystal. The authors explained these results from the effects of the defects in the crystals and the interference of grains during deformation.
K
E
I
8.6
6
E
6.4
15.0
6.3
8.4
6.2 14.5 8.2
6.1
Z
6.0
/ 8.0
"14.0'
I00
200 T (K)
300
5.9
Fig. 51. Temperature dependence of Young's modulus E, rigidity modulus G and bulk modulus K (x 1011 dyn/cm 2) [× 101° N/m 2] (B.P.N. Reddy and P.J. Reddy 1974a).
F U N D A M E N T A L P R O P E R T I E S OF H E X A G O N A L F E R R I T E S
361
2.1.14. Mechanical properties Fundamental studies of the mechanical properties of hexagonal ferrites are quite few. Clark et al. (1976) referred to the following mechanical data for their BaM specimen at room temperature. Density: 5g/cm 3, porosity: 5%, Young's modulus: l a x 106kg/cm2 [1.38x 1011N/m2], Poisson's ratio: 0.28, compressive strength: 4.5 x 103kg/cm2 [4.41x 108N/m2], tensile strength: 5.6x 102kg/cm2 [5.52x 107 N/m2]. Reddy and Reddy (1974a) measured the elastic modulus of sintered BaM with a density of 4.8910 g/cm3. Figure 51 shows the relations of Young's modulus E, rigidity modulus G and bulk modulus K versus temperature. These moduli decrease with temperature, in contrast with those of Ni-Zn or Mn-Zn cubic ferrites. Hodge et al. (1973) investigated the compressive deformation of sintered BaM with 18% porosity in creep and press forging modes in the temperature range 1000° to 1200°C. Figure 52 is the true strain rate against l I T plot for an isotropic compact at 5% true strain. The activation energy for creep was estimated from the experiments as 123-+6kcal/mol [(5.15-+0.25)x 105 J/moll.
-2 (x 13
--<.. ..3
,
~
"
~
-6 6.8
7.0
7.2 I/T
7.4
7.6
7.8
( K -I x l O -4)
Fig. 52. Arrhenius plot of creep by compressive deformation of isotropic BaO.6Fe203 (Hodge et al. 1973). (1) 421.8 kg/cm 2 [4.14 x 104 N/m2], (2) 281.2 kg/cm 2 [2.76 × 104 N/m2], (3) 140.6 kg/cm 2 [1.38 x 104 N/mZ].
2.1.15. Heat capacity Reddy and Reddy (1974b) determined the heat capacity of a BaM sintered rod in the temperature range 80 to 303 K. Cp is plotted versus temperature in fig. 53, giving values of 52.42 cal/mol deg [2.194 x 102 J/mol deg] and 107.56 cal/mol deg [4.502× 102J/mol deg] at 80 and 303K, respectively. Furthermore, the Debye temperature was estimated from the calorimetric measurements at 166 K and from the elastic measurements as 158 K, both of which are rather low compared with the temperatures of Ni-Zn or Mn-Zn ferrites.
362
H. K O J I M A 10
O0
-8 E '-"a
90
Cp
"-S 8 0 .x.
I0
/
8
"e 6
%
70
"o "5
60
-6 u
50
°
:,.,"
2
0
0
I O0
200
300
T(K)
Fig. 53. Heat capacity and thermal expansion coefficient of sintered BaO-6Fe203. Cp: heat capacity (Reddy and Reddy 1974b), (1) o~(Reddy and Reddy 1973), (2) a parallel to the magnetized direction, (3) a perpendicular to the magnetized direction (Clark et al. 1976).
2.1.16. Thermal expansion Reddy and Reddy (1973) also measured the thermal expansion coefficient o~ of sintered B a M by a two terminal capacitance dilatometer. The result is illustrated by curve (1) in fig. 53. They derived the following experimental equation in the t e m p e r a t u r e range of 80 to 300 K: a = 0.572
x 10 7 T -
1.437 x 101° T 2 + 0.175 x 1012 T 3 .
(19)
Clark et al. (1976) gave the values c~ of B a M parallel and perpendicular to the magnetized direction, which are shown as curves (2) and (3) in fig. 53. They also reported the thermal conductivity of their specimen having 5% porosity as 4 W / m deg at r o o m temperature. A b o v e r o o m temperature, Davis (1965) observed the change of lattice constants in B a M up to 1000°C by X-ray diffraction, but the value is fairly high and no noticeable change was found around the Curie point. K 6 m o t o and Kojima (1976) showed the t e m p e r a t u r e variations of the a and c-axis in B a M in fig. 54, where the sharp kinks can be seen at 450°C for both axes, but the value is rather low. In table 13, the expansion coefficients of B a M by several authors are compared. The cause of the discrepancy in the list may be explained by the difference of porosity, grain size, degree of crystal orientation, chemical composition in the specimens, or accuracy of measuring methods.
FUNDAMENTAL
P R O P E R T I E S OF H E X A G O N A L
FERRITES
363
7
A5
7
o X
--4 O
O 3 1D
0
0
200 Temperature
400 (°C)
600
Fig. 54. Variations of the lattice constants in BaO.6Fe203 with temperature (K6moto and Kojima 1976).
T A B L E 13 T h e r m a l e x p a n s i o n c o e f f i c i e n t o f B a M (x 10-6/deg). T (°C)
R.T.
a
0°
27 °
R.T.
8.5 (a)
8.4 c°)
8.8 ~)
11.1 (d)
T (°C)
25-150
150-250
25-250
25-640
~(e)
9.5
T(°C) an (f) ao (f)
10
-
10.5
100
5.7 10.8
6.8 11.0
200
9.8
-
250
8.2 12.1
10.5 13.8
10.2
300
18.6 17.2
350
-
450
20.7 17.2
* By X-ray diffraction (a) H a b e r e y et al. (1973) Co)R e d d y a n d R e d d y (1973) (c>C l a r k et al. (1976)
(d/Davis* (1965) (e) B u e s s e m a n d D o f f (1957) If) K 6 m o t o * a n d K o j i m a (1976).
11.5 7.3
550
364
•
H. KOJIMA
2.1.17. Electric and dielectric properties
Zfiv&a (1963) observed the electrical conductivity of BaM and PbM single crystals and found that the relations among the conductivities are approximately expressed by 100"BaM ~" OrpbM and 10or//~ o-1 for both compounds. Here, o-B~ and O-pbM mean the values of the conductivities with each ferrite, and o-//and o-~ denote the values measured along and perpendicular to the c-axis, respectively. Figure 55(a) and (b) show the conductivities of BaM and PbM, rewritten from these results by Wijn (1970). Z~veta also estimated the activation energy for the temperature dependence of the conductivity and, moreover, reported on the thermoelectric force for the same specimens. He finally concluded that an electron hopping mechanism between Fe ions might reasonably be assumed and so the conductivity
A
TIE I0-I T
b id z
io-3
/o)
A
TE
10-3
",,,.\
T
b 164 II C
id 5
I 2
3
4
5
I/T
(xlO-3/deg K)
6
7
Fig. 55. Temperature dependence of the electrical d.c. conductivity of the single crystals: (a) BaFe12019, (b) PbFe12019. The different marks indicate the measuring points of different crystals (Zfiveta 1963).
F U N D A M E N T A L P R O P E R T I E S OF H E X A G O N A L F E R R I T E S
365
10-2
Ld ~
10-4 IE 0-5
b
10-6
to-T
io-e
j0-9 2
5
4 I/T
5 6 7 (xlO-3/deg K)
8
9
Fig. 56. Temperature dependence of the conductivity of BaFe12019 polycrystal containing 0.022% Fe 2+ by weight. The figures stand for the used frequency in Hz (Haberey and Wijn 1968). 104'
'
I
'
I0
.c,-''~"
I !
IOM
'
---
i!
///
o
1 ,o
-150
-I00
-50
0
50
I00
150
T (°C) Fig. 57. Temperature dependence of the real part of the dielectric constant for the same specimens in fig. 56 (Haberey and Wijn 1968).
366
H. KOJIMA
is related to the presence of Fe 2+. D u l l e n k o p f and Wijn (1969) r e p o r t e d similar experiments in the frequency range of 1 to 8 G H z and b e t w e e n - 5 5 ° and 100°C. T h e specimens were polycrystals containing Fe z+ up to 0.5% by weight. T h e m o d e l of a thermally activated h o p p i n g process again received support in this work. Figure 56 shows the t e m p e r a t u r e d e p e n d e n c e of the conductivity for the p r o p o s e d composition of BaFe12.59019.39 3+ polycrystal, d e t e r m i n e d by chemical analysis, at various frequencies r e p o r t e d by H a b e r e y and Wijn (1968). T h e y also described the t e m p e r a t u r e d e p e n d e n c e of dielectric constants E' for the same specimen, as shown in fig. 57.
TABLE 14 Properties of the magnetoplumbite type compounds substituted Ba ion. Compound
a (A)
c (A,)
o's (Gcm3/g) [x 4zr x 10-7 Wbm/kg]
NB (/xB/mol)
LaFe2÷Fe3+nOig*
-
65 (R.T.)
19.5 (0 K) 13 (300 K)
Na0.5La0.sFe12019
-
69 (R.T.) 113 (0 K)
21.5 (0 K)
Ca0.88La0.i4Fe12019*
5.877
22.91
Ag0.sLa0.sFe12Oi9
5.85
22.85
LaFea2019*
52 (R.T.) 73.4 (77 K)
-
96.2 (0 K)
19.2 (0 K)
LaFei2019* LaFe12019*
Tl0.sLa0.sFea2019 (a) (b) (c) (d)
Aharoni and Schiber (1961) Summergrad and Banks (1957) Ichinose and Kurihara (1963) Laroria and Shinha (1963)
(e) Lotgering (1974) (f) Van Diepen and Lotgering (1974) (g) Drofenik et al, (1973)
F U N D A M E N T A L P R O P E R T I E S OF H E X A G O N A L F E R R I T E S
367
2.2. Substituted M compound 2.2.1. BaO-SrO-PbO-Fe203 systems As already discussed, replacement of Ba 2+ ion with Sr 2+, Pb 2+ or both of them is possible with any mixing ratio without changing the crystal structure. For example, Ba0.75Sr0.zsFea2019 (Borovik a n d Yakovleva 1962a, 1962b) and Sr0.7sPb0.25Fe12019 (Borovik and Yakovleva 1963) attracted special interest owing to the improved properties as permanent magnet materials. Hunty (1963) however, found no improvement of these mixed ferrites. Kojima and Miyakawa (1965)
T A B L E 14 (continued)
KI (erg/cm 3) [x 10 ~J/m 3] 2,5
x
10 6
/(2 (erg/cm 3) [x 10-1J/m 3] --
0c (K)
Composition
695
3.0 x 106
-
713 _+ 10
-
-
718
-
CaO 13.70 Fe203 82.78 La203 2.00 FeO 1.52 (mol %)
708
(10-13) x l0 s (0 K)
0 (293 K) (5-10) x l0 s (77 K)
LaM 86.2 Fe304 10.3 LaFeO3 3.4 (wt %)
NB-T
G-La205
Ref.
(a)
o--T o-j/, o - l - H o-s-La203
(c)
Br = 1600 G MHc = 2450 Oe BHc = 1100 Oe
(d)
o-//,o-±-H o--T
(e)
K1-T
M6ssbauer spect. Hhf-T
(f)
Fe304
M6ssbauer spect.
(g)
removed by 10% H2804
e-T 8-T Hi-T
Fe304 10
(wt %) 697 -+ 2
Other data in the paper
M6ssbauer spect.
(g)
368
H. KOJIMA
investigated the changes of lattice constants, saturation magnetization and Curie points for the Ba-Sr, B a - P b and Sr-Pb binary hexaferrites systems and found that there are no sharp kinks on the curves relating the properties and the composition. These facts suggested that those systems form complete solid solutions between both end m e m b e r s and no special c o m p o u n d can exist at any mixing ratio. Therefore, it is m o r e plausible that the i m p r o v e m e n t s due to the substitutions in the Borovik's papers might be due to the acceleration of the solid state reaction or sintering process etc., and not to the intrinsic properties of a specific compound. Though such non-intrinsic but practically useful effects in the p e r m a n e n t magnet properties of hard ferrites introduced by many kinds of additives were once actively studied the results will n o t be mentioned further, since the details will be discussed in ch. 7 by Stfiblein. 2.2.2. Other substitutions of B a 2+ ions Ferrimagnetic properties of the magnetoplumbite type compounds are naturally based on the superexchange interaction of F e - O - F e , so that no remarkable effect on the magnetic properties would be expected by the replacement of a Ba ion. However, the properties could be influenced to some extent by the changes in the distance or the angle between F e - O - F e arising from the substitution, leading to differences among BaM, SrM and PbM. Table 14 shows the properties of several examples for Ba 2+ substituted ferrites. In some cases m a r k e d * in the table, the partial coexistence of Fe 2+ may be unavoidable in order to keep electrical neutrality?. The examples are so few that no general tendency can be deduced from the table. As described before, when discussing the M6ssbauer effect, Drofenik et al. (1973) concluded from the t e m p e r a t u r e dependence of the hyperfine fields for L a M that a m o r e convex magnetization against t e m p e r a t u r e curve than SrM comes from the difference of the behaviour of the 12k sublattices. It is also pointed out in this p a p e r that in LaFet2019 and T10.sLa0.sFe12019 no Fe 2+ sublattice was observed in the M6ssbauer experiment and the averaged hyperfine fields could originate from a fast electron exchange between Fe 2+ and Fe 3+, or in the process of electron sharing by the six ions in the 12k sites of these compounds. Van Diepen and Lotgering (1974) insisted from a similar study that the substitution of Ba 2+ with La 3+ causes a valency change of Fe 3+ to Fe 2+ at the 2a or 4f2 site, although they also found no subspectrum of Fe 2+. 2.2.3. Substitution of Fe 3+ ions Substitution with A13+, Ga 3+ and Cr 3+ ion. T h e replacement of Fe 3+ in B a M or SrM with AP +, G a 3+ or Cr 3+ has been intensively investigated. Because of the resemblance of their ionic radii with Fe 3+ (shown in table 2) especially the former two ions are easily replaced at any substitution ratio without changing the crystal structure. Figure 58(a) and (b) show the variations of the lattice constants a and c
t Replacements with combinations of a few ions are also cited in the next section.
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
369
23.2
22.8 o,=I
22.6 (j,
22.4
(b 22.2
i 22.0
i
A
o
0
2
4
6 X
8
I0
12
Fig. 58. (a) Lattice parameter a, and (b) c as a function of substituted ratio. (1) BaAlxFe12-,Om, (2) BaGaxFe12-xOm,(3) BaCr, Fe12-xO19,(4) SrCrxFem-xO19(Bertaut et al. 1959), (5) SrAlxFe12-xOt9(Goto and Takahashi 1973). for (1) BaAlxFe12_x019, (2) BaGaxFe12-xO19, (3) BaCrxFe12-xO19, (4) SrCrxFelz-xO19 (Bertaut et al. 1959) and (5) SrAlxFem_xO19 (Goto and Takahashi 1973). Almost the same results as given on line (1) for the Ba-A1-M system by Vinnik and Zvereva (1969) and also on line (5) for SrAlxFe12-~O19 were reported by Florescu et al. (1973). The parameters decrease linearly with the substitution ratio in all cases. Numerical values for the end members were given by Adelsk61d (1938) and Bertaut et al. (1959) as in table 15. This table also contains the results for Ca/Sk112019 by Wisnyi (1967); Ca(AlFe)12019 by MacChesny et al. (1971); BaGaa2019, SrGa~2Oa9 and LaMgGanO19 by Verstegen (1973).
370
H. KOJIMA TABLE 15 Lattice parameters of some substituted M-type compounds with A1, Ga or Gr. Formula
a (4)
c (4)
Ref.
BaA112019
5.577 5.66
22.67 22.285
Adelsk61d (1938) Bertaut et al. (1959)
SrAl12019
5.557
21.945
Adelsk61d (1938)
CaA1~2OI9
5.566
22.010
Wisnyi (1967)
Ca(A1Fe)12019 5.792-+0.004
22.56_+0.04
MacChesneyet al. (1971)
BaGa12019
5.818 5.850 -+0.004
23.00 23.77 _+0.02
Bertaut et al. (1959) Verstegen (1973)
SrGa12Oa9
5.796 -+0.004
23.77 _+0.02
Verstegen (1973)
LaMgGa11019 5.799-+0.003
22.71 -+0.01
Verstegen (1973)
BaCrsFe4Oa9 SrCr6Fe6019
22.82 22.77
Bertaut et al. (1959) Bertaut et al. (1959)
5.844 5.844
Van Uitert (1957), and Van Uitert and Swanekamp (1957) reported 4¢rMs of BaAl~Fe12_xO19, (1) fired below 1400°C and (2) fired above 1400°C, and (3) SrAlxFe12_xOi9 after Rodrigue (1963) as shown in fig. 59(a). Figure 59(b) illustrates (1) BaAlxFe12_xO19; (2) BaGa~Fe12_~O~9 (Mones and Banks 1958); (3) SrAlxFe,2_xO~9 (Rodrigue 1963) and (4) ditto (Gotto and Takahashi 1973). Lines (3) and (4) agree quite well. In figs. 60(a) and (b), Bertaut et al. (1959) summarized NB at 0 K per mole in Bohr magneton and 0c for (1) BaAl~Fe~2_xO~9, (2) BaGa~Fe12_xO19, (3) BaCrxFe~2_xO~9; the m a r k A in (a) relates to SrCrxFe12-~O19. Albanese et al. (1974) estimated 0c for BaAlxFe~2 xO,9 and SrAlxFe~2-xO19 from the M6ssbauer experiments, as shown in table 16. The lines D~ and D2 in fig. 60(a) were drawn on the hypotheses that AP + ions enter the 2a and 12k sites, or G a 3+ the 4fl and 12k sites, respectively (after Bertaut et al. (1959)). With these results, and in addition referring to the X-ray investigations, they came to the conclusion that AI 3÷ and Cr 3+ first occupy 2a sites and then 12k sites, while G a 3+ enters first 4fl and then 12k sites. These assumptions are thoroughly supported by Rensen et al. (1971) by M6ssbauer studies, but in contrast with these results, Suchet (1971) expressed a strong preference of AI 3÷ to the 4f~ and 2a sites. Glasser et al. (1972) observed M6ssbauer and E S R spectra for CaAl12-xFe~O~9 with x <~ 4.8, i.e., mainly on the A1 rich side. They recognized a m a r k e d preference of Fe 3÷ for the tetrahedral 4fl sites from M6ssbauer investigations and interpreted the majority of E S R resonances by supposing Fe 3÷ ions in an axially distorted site. T h e relations of a, Ms, 0c, K, MHc and the critical radius for a single-domain
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
800 1 .(3)
r...<-.,
60 O l ~ ' ~
I
[ i
371
I
i
Ib)
A
,.i
o
400 qb
(.3
200 121
5000
I
(0) 3)
4000
! I i
~', ,,,
~o 3 0 0 0
x.
2000
I==
1000
0
0
2
4
6
I 8
10 12 X Fig. 59. (a) Saturation 4~rM~, and (b) Curie temperature 0c as a function of substituted ratio. (a) 4~-Ms: (1) BaAlxFe12-xO19 fired below 1400°C, (2) ditto fired above 1400°C (Van Uitert and Swanekamp 1957), (3) SrAlxFelz-xO19 (Rodrigue 1963); (b) 0c: (1) BaAlxFelz-xO19, (2) BaGa~Fet2 xO19 (Mones and Banks 1958), (3) SrAlxFel2-xOl9 (Rodrigue 1963), (4) ditto (Goto and Takahashi 1973).
particle Rc etc. versus x for BaCrxFel2 xO19; and BaAlxFel2-xOi9, BaGaxFe12-xO19 and BaCrxFe12_xOx9 were given by Haneda and Kojima (1971 and 1973b). In fig. 61, curves (3), (4) and (5) indicate H A for BaAlxFe12-xO19, BaGaxFei2-xO19 and BaCrxFei2 xO19 (Haneda and Kojima 1973b) besides the marks • and A illustrating HA for SrAlxFe~2_xO19, as obtained by De Bitetto (1964) and Rodrigue (1963). Curves (1) and (2) are drawn with the calculated values of eqs. (20) and (21) by De Bitetto who gave the experimental formulae:
372
H. K O J I M A
800
I
(b) 700 A
•v" 6 0 0 0
500 --
400
300
25
I
(a) 20'~
\2a
D2
\\
D,,\ \ 0
2
,
)--'~,X~L 6
4
8
I0
12
X Fig. 60. (a) Saturation at 0 K and, (b) Curie temperature versus substitution ratio (Bertaut et al. 1959): (1) BaAlxFe12-xO19, (2) BaGaxFeu-xO19, (3) BaCrxFeu-xO19, (A) SrCrxFelz-xO19, D1, D2: calculated values.
T A B L E 16 Curie temperature for the compounds BaAlxFe12-xO19 and SrAlxFelz_xOl9 (AIbanese et al. 1974). BaAlxFei2-xO19
SrAlxFe12-xO19
x
Tc (K)
x
T~ (K)
0 2.5 4
723 -+ 5 595 ---5 518---5
0 1 2
723 -+ 5 658 -+ 5 590---5
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF H E X A G O N A L FERRITES
7O
,
373
I (2)
I
6O
I
I
// °/(I)
,/
5O
/ z~
-g
/ •/ //~e'~
40
131
I// /
~D
o X
0
"1-
~
(51
I0
0 0
I
2
3
4
x
Fig. 61. Anisotropy field HA as a function of substitution ratio: (1) and (2) see text, (0) SrAlxFe12-xO19 (De Bitetto 1964), (A) ditto (Rodrigue 1963), (3) BaAlxFe12-xOxg, (4) BaGaxFex2-xO19, (5) BaCrxFe~z_xO19 (Haneda and Kojima 1973b).
HA(x)/H(o) = (12 - x)/612 - x/2 + (x/6)zss],
(20)
HA(x)/H(o) =
(21)
or (12 - x ) / ( 1 2 - 3 x ) .
Since D e B i t e t t o e x p e r i m e n t a l l y o b t a i n e d a r e l a t i o n for K as a f u n c t i o n of x for SrAlxFe~z-xO19 in t h e f o r m ,
K(x~/K(o) = 1 - x / 1 2 ,
(22)
w e can say that t h e m a g n e t o c r y s t a l l i n e e n e r g y m a y b e r o u g h l y a s s u m e d to h a v e a b o u t t h e s a m e s t r e n g t h for all t h e five sublattices. A s s u m m a r i z e d in fig. 62, t h e M s - x d e p e n d e n c e is r e l a t e d to t h e v a l i d i t y of eq. (20) o r eq. (21). D e B i t e t t o c l a i m e d t h a t an e m p i r i c a l fitting f o r m u l a ,
374
H. KOJIMA 1.0
0.8
1~ O.6
0,4
0.2
0
I
2
3
4
5
6
x
Fig. 62. Variations of normalized saturation magnetization with composition in MAlxFe12-xO19(De Bitetto 1964): (0) Ba (Bertaut et al. 1959), (A) Ba (Mones and Banks 1958), (V) Ba (Van Uitert and Swanekamp 1957), (V) Pb (Bozorth and Kramer t959), (D) Ba, (C)) Sr (Du Pr6 et al. 1958), (&) Ba (Vinnik and Zvereva 1970).
M(x)/M(o) = ~[2 - x/2 + (x/6)zss],
(23)
which is shown by curve (2) in fig. 62, is m o r e plausible than most other authors' results given by curve (1), i.e. by
M(x)/M(o) = 1 - (x/4).
(24)
D a t a by Vinnik and Z v e r e v a (1970) for the B a - A 1 - M system m e a s u r e d at 4.2 K were a d d e d to fig. 62. T h e y concluded that the preference of A13+ seems to agree with the results of Bertaut et al. (1959) and the deviation at x = 3.3 m a y be due to the differences of applied field. H o w e v e r , we would like to point out here that the occupied site with a substituted ion might be different according to the preparation conditions, starting materials and various other factors, although the substitution ratio m a y be perfectly identical. HA was d e t e r m i n e d by D e Bitetto using F M R m e a s u r e m e n t s and the line width A H was also given for the S r - A I - M system between x = 0-1.7. A l b a n e s e et al. (1974) reported H i - T and Hi(T)/I-L(o)--T/Oc relations by M6ssbauer investigations for A1 or G a substituted B a M and SrM. H e i n e c k e and Jahn (1972) studied the angular variation of the nucleation field Hn for single d o m a i n particles of SrA13.sFes.2019 and c o m p a r e d the Hn-O relation with the 1/cos 0 law or the c o h e r e n t rotation model. Interesting investigations of the f o r m a t i o n m o d e of the domain structures on the c-plane of PbA1Fel~O19 were r e p o r t e d by Williams and S h e r w o o d (1958) using a motion picture technique. Tanasoiu (1972) o b s e r v e d r e m a n e n t domain structures on the c-plane of SrAI4.8FeT.2OI9, the main magnetic properties of which were previously d e t e r m i n e d as 4~rMs = 315 G [315 × 10 -4 T], To= 5 1 8 K and Crw= 5 . 8 e r g / c m 2 [5.8× 10-3j/m2]. H e f o u n d that the r e m a n e n t
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
375
structure after thermal demagnetization consists of a great number of domains with irregular shape and are very unstable, while the remanent state by a.c. demagnetization consists of only a few domains. MacChesney et al. (1971) studied the ferrimagnetic phase of the CaO-A1203Fe203 system and, as for the hexagonal magnetic phase, they found the composition range extends from CaAI~20~4 to at least CaA14.2FetsOls.6. The lattice constants of an idealized composition Ca(A1Fe)12019 were already referred to in table 15. The magnetic moment at room temperature for the group varies from 1 to 10 emu/g [12.56 to 125.6 x 10-~ Wbm/kg] according to the Fe content, but they show rather high anisotropy fields of about 60 kOe [4.78 x 10 6 A/m] regardless of the composition. 1 / x - T relations up to 1000 K were determined by Florescu et al. (1973) for SrAlxFe~2-xO19 from x = 2.0 to 9.0 and they estimated N6el's parameters by the graphical method (N6el 1948) from these results. The photoluminescence of BaGa~2019, SrGa120~9 and LaMgGauO~9 with and without Mn 2+ phosphors was reported by Verstegen (1973) who found that the emission strongly resembles that of Mn 2+ in MgGa204. Substitution with Sc 3+ and In 3+. The partial replacement of Fe 3+ with Sc3+ or In 3+ ions in M-type compounds were investigated mainly by research groups in the U S S R with an interest in their specific magnetic ordering. Perekalina and Cheparin (1967) measured the relations of a, c-x, ~rs-T and K ~ - T for BaScxFe~2 xO19 single crystals with x = 1.2-1.8, as shown in table 17 and figs. 63 and 64. Maxima
80 7O •
.~,^
"" o
"~ 6o r
'~~4-O0~5_xS~=~~~ 0~2,03~" 0~ ×
C31
10 0
r 0
200
400 Temperature
I,o 600
(K)
Fig. 63. Temperature dependence of the specific magnetization BaScxFe12-xOa9single crystals (Perekalina and Cheparin 1967): (1) x = 1.2, (2) x = 1.4, (3) x = 1.8.
376
H. KOJIMA
o<
+1
o<
+1
tt3
x
t'¢3 t'e'j
"~"
'~" ¢xl t'xl ('xl ~:7~ t'~ , ~ ,.~j . . . . . . ~.,
tt3 0~ trq
tt3 "~" ,,..~ "
X
uS,.-~o~ ~ u E e 6
b, © X
X
,,~
~
.
.
t¢3 t ~
t'q
e¢3
r~
.= .
.
.
.
.
.
¢¢3 ~D v
.= ~mmmm~m~
e~
FUNDAMENTAL
PROPERTIES
9
OF HEXAGONAL
FERRITES
377
r
(I). 8
/,
I \_
7 6 E 5 o X
4 tO
E
-2 3 03
%2 X
0
-I
-2
I 0
I 200
400
Temperature
600 (K)
Fig. 64. T e m p e r a t u r e d e p e n d e n c e of t h e a n i s o t r o p y c o n s t a n t K1 for BaScxFelz-xO19 ( P e r e k a l i n a a n d C h e p a r i n 1967): x = 1.2, x = 1.4, x = 1.8.
in the O-s-T relations, which shift towards higher temperatures with increasing Sc content, and the change of K1 for BaScl.sFe10.2019 to negative values between 125 and 355 K are in contrast with pure M-type compounds. It was suggested that the t e m p e r a t u r e dependences of ~rs can be explained by N6el'S theory (N6el 1948). Aleshko-Ozhevkii et al. (1968, 1969) determined the magnetic structure by neutron diffraction studies at 77 K in magnetic fields up to 5 k O e [3.89 x 105 A/m] for BaScxFe12-xO19 with x = 1.2-1.8. They showed conclusively that Sc 3+ ions occupy 4fl and 2b sites, so that antiphase conical helixes were formed in certain blocks of the crystal unit cell. In a later p a p e r these authors estimated (i) the periods along the c-axis; (ii) the cone vertex half angle; and (iii) the phase angle of the projection of theo total magnetic m o m e n t s in the basal plane which were, o respectively: (i) 141A, (ii) 30 °, (iii) 150 ° for x = 1.8; (i) 91 A, (ii) 20 °, (iii) 135 ° for x = 1.4; and (i) 70 A, (ii) 12 °, (iii) 120 ° for x = 1.2. Alesko-Ozhevskii and Yamzin (1969) added a detailed explanation of the intensity anomalies of the satellites in the neutron diffraction patterns of BaScxFe12-xO19 on the basis of the superposition of ferro- and antiferromagnetic reflections. Koroleva and Mitian (1971)
378
H. KOJIMA
suggested the possibility of the appearance of these magnetic antiphase helical structure based on Moriya's rule (Moriya 1960). The same behaviour of o-s-T and K1-T plots for single crystals of BaInxFe12_xO19 for x > 1.9 and PbInl.gFemO~9 were observed by Perekalina et al. (1970). Their main data are added to table 17, which can also be understood by the model of two magnetic sublattices with a weak exchange interaction. Bashkirov et al. (1975) carried out M6ssbauer studies for BaIn3FegO19 and showed the presence of an angular magnetic structure, which was presumably caused by the almost full occupation of 2b and 4fi sites with In 3+. Magnetic order-disorder transition of the compound was observed between 300 and 250 K with an external field of H = 16 k O e [1.28 x 10 6 A / m ] and below 100 K in the absence of an external field. The difficulty of realizing the saturated state even in 50 k O e [3.98 x 106 A/m] for BaInz4Fe9.6Oa9 was reported by Perekalina et al. (1970). These anomalous magnetic properties are due to the fact that collinear structures are not realized even at helium temperatures.
Substitution of Fe 3+ with paired ions; Co-Ti system Smit et al. (1960) measured the torque curves of BaCox/zTix/2Felz-x019 for x = 0.9, 1.0 and 1.5 at T = 90 K and H = 32 k O e [2.55 x 10 6 A/m] after thermal demagnetization and suggested from the results that the characteristic details of these curves were due to the effects of incomplete alignment, both on a microscopic and an atomic scale. Rodrigue (1963) pointed out that the effective internal anisotropy fields of B a M could be varied from virtually zero to 17.5 k O e [1.39 × 106 A/m] by substituting with Co-Ti, and this is quite advantageous for applications to microwave devices. In fig. 65, the data in this p a p e r were cited in (a), (b) and (d). De Bitetto (1964) determined the relation of H A with x by r o o m t e m p e r a t u r e microwave ferrimagnetic resonance measurements. The line widths A H of these oriented polycrystalline compounds were all about 2 k O e [1.6× 105A/m]. His results are also plotted in figs. 65 (a), (b) and (c). Lines (1) and (2) in (a) are drawn based on G o r t e r ' s assumption (Casimir et al. 1959): (i) a random distribution of both Co and Ti ions among only the nine octahedral sites (12k, 2a and 4f2), or (ii) both ions are substituted preferentially for some Fe 3+ ions with only the eight favourably oriented moments (12k, 2a, 2b). It seems that D e Bitetto's data are situated on line (1), G o r t e r ' s results on line (2), but that Smit and Wijn's and Rodrigue's data are just between the two lines. The microscopic structure of C o - T i substituted samples were reported by Bonnenberg and Wijn (1968) using an electron microprobe analyser. They found, for instance, that in the composition BaComTimFe~2019, the concentration of Fe, Co and Ba, Ti showed the same distribution tendency in pairs but the opposite tendency in the sintered grains. Investigations of the cation distribution on an atomic scale were reported by K r e b e r and Gonser (1976). They compared the electric quadrupole splitting E and the area of the M6ssbauer spectra for BaCox/2Tix/2Fe12-xO19 sublattices from x = 0 up to x = 11 at temperatures above the corresponding Curie points of each compositions. Their conclusions are as follows: The Fe 3+ ions in 4fl and 4f2 sites are replaced for x ~<4 and the remaining octahedral 2a and 12k sites are substituted randomly for 4 < x < 8. Finally, for x > 8, a weak substitution in the
F U N D A M E N T A L P R O P E R T I E S OF H E X A G O N A L F E R R I T E S 800
I
, _,
I
% x
400"
L
379
i
Idl
I
i (c)
~,0<
E
.2 z.0 %
-×
1.0
~g 18~
(b) 12
E
0 X
o I
r.o~ ~ ~ _
§
o.8
x
0.6
(a)
- ...... --~
0
I
2 x
Fig. 65. Normalized magnetic saturation at room temperature, anisotropy field, anisotropy constant and Curie temperature against composition in Ba(TiCo)xFe12-xO19. (a) M(x)/M(01: (©) De Bitetto (1964) at room temperature, (11) Gorter (Casimir et al. 1959) at 77 K, (A) Smit and Wijn (1959 at 20 K, (3) Rodrigue (1963) at room temperature, (1) and (2) calculated values (see text); (b) Ha: ((2)) De Bitetto (1964), ( 0 ) Rodrigue (1963); (c) KI: De Bitetto (1964); (d) 0o: Rodrigue (1963).
2b site occurs. When comparing these conclusions with the above mentioned results in fig. 65, it should be noticed that the latter observations correspond to the paramagnetic region.
Other combinations with H-IVpairs. D u e to the interest in the effect of substituting ions on the magnetic properties of M compounds, attempts to replace Fe 3+ by non-magnetic ions are still being reported occasionally. Since equal amounts of
380
H. KOJIMA
M2++ M 4+ are simplest for electrical neutrality in these substituted compounds, a number of papers has been published regarding such a substitution. For instance, Tauber et al. (1963) investigated BaZnx/2Irx/zFe~2 xOi9 single crystals with x = 0-0.6 and found that the lattice constant a increased from 5.893-+0.001 A to 5.920-+ 0.001A but that c remained constant at 23.194_+0.002A with increasing I r content. The o-~-T relations for x = 0, 0.32, 1.04 and 1.2, determined by the chemical analysis of total Ir, were given in their paper. Other main results obtained using FMR are summarized in table 18. They showed that the substitution of Ir 4+ causes the spin system in the compound to be pulled down toward the basal plane. Similar FMR measurements have been done by Dixon et al. (1971) with single crystals of BaZnx/zTix/zFelz-x019 for nominal compositions, x = 2.0-5.0. They succeeded in decreasing the resonance line width A H to 36 Oe [2865 A/m] with x = 3.0. The variation of A H versus x at 37.6 G H z was illustrated in their paper. A summary of their results is given in table 18. Rensen et al. (1971) discussed ZnTi, ZnGe, ZnSn, ZnZr, CuTi, CoZr or NiTi substitution pairs. They referred briefly to the cation distributions for each compound from M6ssbauer effect results. Magnetization, anisotropy field and M6ssbauer spectra of BaZnxTiyMnzFe12_x_y_z019 were investigated between 4.2 and 300 K by Mahoney et al. (1972). The o-~-T curves for various nominal x values, H~-x and e - x diagrams and tables of magnetic moments at 0 K and cation distributions were given in their paper. They concluded that Ti 4+ mainly, and Mn 3+ completely occupied 12k and 2a sites, and Z n 2+ w a s primarily assigned to 4fi sites on crystal chemical grounds, but partly distributed on to 12k or 2a sites to fit with the observed magnetic moment. Haneda and Kojima (1973b) measured HA, MHc and Rc as a function of x for BaZnx/zGex/zFe12-x019 and BaZnzx/3Vx/3Felz-x019, BaZn2x/3Tax/3Fe12-~019 and BaZn2x/3Nbx/3Fe12-~O19, also involving M2++ M 5+ pairs. The main problem concerned the changes of MHc with x for these compounds and this was also considered in connection with the changes of H A and also Rc for sintered specimens. o
o
2.2.4. Effect of substitutions on the temperature dependence of magnetization An attempt to improve the temperature dependence of the magnetization of the magnetoplumbite structure, which is inferior by one order than for Alnico magnets, was perhaps reported f o r the first time by Heimke (1960). H e showed that the Ms-T relation could be changed for the M-type compound BaTiO3"5Fe203+ 1.5% CaSiO3, that is, its magnetization varies almost parallel relative to the temperature axis below 0°C, as illustrated by line (1) in fig. 66(a) (using the scale of the right-hand axis). For an explanation of this result, he proposed two kinds of exchange schemes other than the one reported by Gorter (1957). Esper and Kaiser (1972) continued this analysis and obtained interesting results on the changes in the temperature dependence of O-s for M compounds. Their o-s- T relations are shown in fig. 66(b) as curves (2) and (3), with (1) as the normal relation of BaM. Their typical substituted compound has the composition Ba(Sb203)0.25(Fe203)5.75 and the sample of curve (2), having almost the same temperature coefficient a(o-s)= 0.2% per degree and about ~O-s of BaM, was
FUNDAMENTAL
PROPERTIES
OF HEXAGONAL
FERRITES
-g T X
o X ~
X
rO
{IN]{[{
{{
O
8 © r eq
tt3
÷1 k~) tt~ ~
ee)
tt3
0J
~2 t--
e~
¢e5
,<1
© e'~
¢o
t~, ,,o
O r.¢) X ©
cq ¢¢~ ,~1- tt3
.+
+
¢-
N +
+ ¢
~z
rqrd ©
i--.
381
382
H. K O J I M A I00
..L,~
i
(c)
80
60
40
i 20 0 E
I ..Q b--
I0
I00
I
--.
X
b~
(b )
-4) 1
Bo
--.<\-..~ ~.
20
5000
I00
N
8O
i~)-~ I ~_,p~.~,-~-~-~. (5) _
60
(0 ) -
4000
~ . ,
5000
E
~o ×
2000
4O
\
2O
i I
0 0
200
400 Temperature
600
I000
i
o
800
(K)
Fig. 66. Temperature dependence of the saturation magnetization o's for some substituted M compounds. (a): (1) 4~rMs of BaTiO3'5Fe203 with the scale of the right ordinate (Heimke 1960), (2) "4+ 2+ 3+ 5+ 2+ 3+ BaTlo.6Feo.6Felo.8Ol9, (3) BaSbo.sFel.oFelo.5019 (Lotgering 1974); (b): (1) BaM, (2) and (3) Sb-substituted BaM (Esper and Kaiser 1972); (c): (1) SrM, (2) As-substituted SrM (Esper and Kaiser 1972).
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF HEXAGONAL FERRITES
383
p r e p a r e d through the heat treatment in air and below 1300°C. The sample of curve (3) received a secondary heat treatment above 1200 ° in N2 or above 1300°C in air, after the normal solid state reaction. Sb205, i.e., Sb 5+ was used as a starting material in both cases. It was claimed that the anomalous t e m p e r a t u r e dependence of curve (3) was caused by the partial replacement of Fe 3÷ in 4f2 sites with non-magnetic trivalent ions having ionic radius smaller than Fe 3÷. In this case, the crystal structure or the magnetic coupling scheme gradually turns to the Wstructure from M-type, though the sample of curve (2) still has a distorted M structure. In conclusion As and P were r e c o m m e n d e d as the most suitable replacing ions to realize a low t e m p e r a t u r e coefficient around room temperature. A valve c~(o-s)= 0.1% per degree was obtained with As substituted SrM as illustrated with curve (2) in fig. 66(c), in contrast to curve (1) for the normal SrM. On the other hand, Kreber and Gonser (1973) concluded from the M6ssbauer experiments at r o o m t e m p e r a t u r e and 77 K for the same composition, that As ions occupy preferentially 2b sites, although they did not describe the preparation conditions. Lotgering (1974) showed in curve (2) in fig. 66(a) the saturation magnetization measured parallel to the easy direction, o-//, of oriented polycrystalline BaFe2+0.6Ti4+0.6Fe10.8019 and curve (3) for or// of BaFe2+1.0SbS+0.sFe10.sO19, both of which behave very similarly with t e m p e r a t u r e as curve (1) obtained by H e i m k e (1960). Lotgering reported Ti 4+ and Sb s+ to occupy 4f2 sites, which was supported by the X-ray and neutron diffraction investigations. H e stressed the effect of Fe 2+ on a 4f2 site on the t e m p e r a t u r e dependence of the magnetic anisotropy for the substituted compounds, which would be caused by the effect of an Fe 3+, Ti 4+ or Sb 5+ ion on the neighbouring 4f2 site. As described before, Grill and H a b e r y (1974) calculated the exchange parameters of BaM (see table 5) and mentioned that the t e m p e r a t u r e coefficient of the magnetization at room temperature cannot be decreased without decreasing the magnetization, and moreover, the saturation magnetization would only be increased with a diamagnetic substitution on 4f2 sites, measuring the magnetic properties of Bal-xDxPxFe12-x019 with D = K ~+, Bi 3÷ and P = Cu 2+, Ni 2+, Mn 4+ between 180 and 770 K, Grill (1974) practically proved that all the compounds have lower ~r~, 0c and almost the same c~(o-s) values as those of pure BaM. On the other hand, H a n e d a et al. (1974b) studied the effect of replacements of Fe 3+ in M type compounds with (Cu 2+ + Ge4+), (Cu 2+ + Si4+) and moreover with (Cu 2+ + Vs+), (Cu 2+ + Nb 5+) or (Cu 2+ + TaS+). They obtained ~(Br) = 0.1% per degree without reducing other p e r m a n e n t magnetic properties and insisted that ce(Br) can be improved by changing the temperature coefficient a(MHc) or C~(BHC) by such substitutions, instead of improving or(O-s), as proposed by most other investigators. Esper and Kaiser (1975) found that the anisotropy field HA, and accordingly MHc, and also their temperature coefficients can be varied with Sb-substituted BaM by different heat treatments. HA can be changed from 6.3 to 12.6kOe [5001000 kA/m] by varying the preparation conditions, and c~(MHC) was determined to be negative for HA = 6 . 3 k O e [500kA/m] and positive for HA = 12.6kOe [1000 kA/m]?. The results of the studies on the mechanisms of the i m p r o v e m e n t t o~(MHc)=+ 0.28%/°C and o~(BHc)- -0.09%/°C near room temperature for the normal BaM were estimated by Haneda et al. (1974b).
384
H. KOJIMA
of these t e m p e r a t u r e coefficients are fairly confused, but Lotgering's consideration (Lotgering 1974) seems to be most reasonable. H e proposed that the effects of partially existing reduced Fe 2+ ions could be considered to contribute to the temperature change of the anisotropy with any combinations of substituted ions.
2.2.5. Substitution with anions Q u i t e a few researches have been published on the substitution with anions in Mtype compounds. It is presumably more difficult to obtain the specimens with definite concentration of substituted anions than in the case of cations. Moreover, if it is possible to replace O 2- with only anions, this will dilute the ferromagnetic ions, so that the magnetic properties would be unfavourable for most industrial purposes. H e n c e some examples described here concern the substitution of 02with F 1- and some other kinds of cations for the purpose of valency compensation. Because of the resemblance in their ionic radii, F 1- seems to be the only suitable anion (see table 2). Frei et al. (1960) obtained an M-type c o m p o u n d BaFz.2FeO-5Fe203, showing specific gravity p = 5.25 g/cm 3 and saturation magnetization at r o o m temperature o-s = 72 emu/g [9 x 10 -3 Wbm/kg] in comparison with p = 5.25 g/cm 3 and O-s= 67 emu/g [8.4 x 10 -3 Wbm/kg] for BaM. F r o m these experiments, they suggested that the Fe e+ ions are on 4f2 sites and F 1- ions near Ba 2+ ions. C o m p o u n d s intended to give the formula BaCoxFe12-xO19-xFx with x = 0, 0.3, 0.4, 0.45, 0.47, 0.5, 1.0 and 2.0 were prepared by Robbins and Banks (1963) and recognized as single phase magnetoplumbite type by X-ray diffraction for the compositions x <~ 0.47. The estimated magnetization values for randomly oriented powders at 0 K and H = 6 k O e [4.8 x 105 A/m] were: 76, 76.5, 85, 95.2 and 100 emu/g [9.55, 9.61, 10.68, 11.96, 12.57 x 10 -5 Wbm/kg] for x = 0, 0.3, 0.4, 0.45, 0.47 respectively. They also confirmed from torque m e a s u r e m e n t s that the cone angle of the easy magnetization was 10 ° at 77 K for x = 0.3; and 40 ° at r o o m t e m p e r a t u r e and 58 ° between 200 and 77 K for x = 0.47. Robbins (1962) investigated the preferential site of Co 2+, Ni 2+ and Cu 2+ in the hexagonal compounds BaAla2019, BaGa12Oa9 and BaFe12019. Ba 2+ was replaced by La 3+ or O 2- by F ~-, for the charge compensation in these compounds. Referring to the results of Banks et al. (1962) regarding the same compounds we can deduce the following tendency for the preference of bivalent ions: In the BaMZ+Al12_xO~9_xFx system, the order of the tetrahedral preference is Co2+> Zn2+> Ni 2+, while in the BaM2+Galz_xO19_xFx system, it is Co2+> G a 3+ > N i 2+. These results were derived from X-ray investigations and diffuse reflectance measurements for powder compacts. Tables 19 and 20 give lists of the lattice parameters after Robbins (1962) for the BaA112019 and BaFe12019 systems, respectively. Examples of reflectance measurements are illustrated in fig. 67, with curve (1) for BaNi0sGa1150185F0s, curve (2) for BaCo0.sGalLsO18sF05 and curve (3) for BaNi1.sAl10.50175Fls. Assignments of the absorption peaks shown as T or O in the figure have been obtained from the literature values. As for BaM2+xFe~2_,O~9_~F~, Robbins obtained M phase single crystals with a flux of a Fe203 and NazCO3 mixture for the composition x ~< 0.5 for Ni 2+ and Co 2+, and the concentration x = 0-2 for Cu 2+. The bivalent cations in these substituted systems
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF H E X A G O N A L FERRITES T A B L E 19 Lattice parameters of substituted Bamll2019 with M 2+ and F 1- (Robbins 1962). Formula BaAl12019
BaNixAla2-xO19-xFx
B aNio.sZn2A19.sO16.sF2.5
BaCox Al12- x O19-xF x
BaCoZnAlloO17F2 BaCoo.sZn2A19.5Ox6.~F2.5
x
a (A)
c (A)
-
5.577
22.66
0.1 0.4 0.6
5.585 5.597 5.607
22.64 22.64 22.64
0.8
5.610
22.64
-
5.617
22.76
0.1 0.4 1.0 2.0 2.5
5.586 5.598 5.603 5.616 5.622
22.63 22.63 22.63 22.70 22.81
-
5.613 5.616
22.63 22.70
T A B L E 20 Lattice constants of M 2+ and F 1" substituted M compounds (Robbins 1962). Formula
x
a (,~)
c (A)
0.5 0.6 1.0 2.0
5.888 5.892 5.891 5.896
23.15 23.14 23.19 23.21
-
5.882
32.83
BaCuxFe12-xO19-xFx
0.35 0.63 1.14
5.883 5.884 5.885
23.15 23.16 23.19
BaCoxFe12-xO19-xFx
0.3 0.4 0.45 0.47
5.883 5.886 5.886 5.887
23.12 23.12 23.13 23.15
BaNixFe12-xO19-xFx
BaFe22+Nio.ssFels.4201s.42Fo.ss
385
386
H. K O J I M A 8O
7o
/s)
6O
r~i_
/ /~IT~-
(21
50
t j...
I//
t
/
iX
. . . .
1~
.//," (_./
200
.
.
.
.
g I
/i
i~ V1,
,~ ' Io
r,J
+%,.,d;
400
600 .X. ( m,u.m )
800
I000
Fig. 67. Examples of the reflectance spectra for the pellets with some anion substituted M compounds (Robbins 1962). (1) BaNi0.sGall.5Ois.sF0.5, (2) BaCo0.sGall.sO1s.sF0.5, (3) BaNii.sAl10.5017.sF1.5. T and O
are absorption peaks from relevant ions in tetrahedral or octahedral site.
also exhibited a preference for 4fl sites, as was confirmed from the results of magnetic measurements. The magnetic properties at 0 K are listed in table 21, where the saturation values were estimated from the o-s-T relations in a rather higher temperature range compared with the literature value o f BaFei2019 as a standard. Though the Curie temperatures seem to be higher than the other reported values by about 50°C, the increase of O-s and the decrease of 0¢ with increasing substitution ratio are clearly seen. For the higher substitution ratio of Co 2+, x > 0 . 5 , the compound changes to a mixture of M and W phases, then rapidly becomes single W phase with increasing x values, which was confirmed by X-ray and magnetic torque measurements in this paper. T A B L E 21
Magnetic properties of M 2+ and F 1- substituted M compounds (Robbins 1962). KI at R.T. (x 10 6 erg/cm 3) [x 105 J / m 3]
0% at 0 K (emu/g) [x 4~- x 10-7 Wbm/kg]
NB at 0 K (/xB)
0c (°C)
-
100
20
500
3.3
BaNixFe12-xOm-xFx
0.6
113
22.50
475
2.4
BaCuxFe~2-xO19-xFx
0.35 0.63 1.14
108.0 113.5 118.0
21.66 22.72 23.72
460 450 418
3.1 2.9 -
0.3 0.4
105 108.5
21.0 21.7
470 470-
-
Formula BaFez2019
BaCoxFel2-xOx9-xFx
x
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF H E X A G O N A L FERRITES
387
References Adelsk61d, V., 1938, Arkiv Kemi. Mineral. Geol. 12A, 1. Aharoni, A., 1962, Rev. Mod. Phys. 34, 227. Aharoni, A. and M. Schieber, 1961, Phys. Rev. 123, 807. Ahrens, L.H., 1952, Geochim. et Cosmochim. Acta, 2, 155. Aidelberg, J., J. Flicstein and M. Schieber, 1974, J. Cryst. Growth, 21, 195. Albanese, G., M. Carbucicchio and A. Deriu, 1974, Phys. Status Solidi A23, 351. A16onard, R., D. Bloch and P. Boutron, 1966, Compt. rend. B263, 951. Aleshke-Ozhevskii, O.P., R.A. Sizev, V.P. Cheparin and I.I. Yamzin, 1968, Zh. ETF Pis'ma, 7, 202. Aleshke-Ozhevskii, O.P. and I.I. Yamzin, 1969, Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 59, 1490. Anderson, P.W., 1950, Phys. Rev. 79, 350. Appendino, P. and M. Montorsi, 1973, Ann. Chim. (Rome) 63, 449. Arendt, R.H., 1973, J. Solid State Chem. 8, 339. Asti, G., F. Conti and C.M. Maggi, 1968, J. Appl. Phys. 39, 2039. AuCoin, T.R., R.O. Savage and A. Tauber, 1966, J. Appl. Phys. 37, 2908. Banks, E., M. Robbins and A. Tauber, 1962, J. Phys. Soc. Japan, 17, Supplement B-I, 196. Bashkirov, Sh.Sh., A.B. Liberman and V.I. Sinyavskii, 1975, Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 59, 1490. Batti, P., 1960, Ann. Chim. (Rome) 50, 1461. Belov, K.P., L.I. Koroleva, R.Z. Levitin, Yu.V. Jergin and A.V. Pedko, 1965, Phys. Status Solidi, 12, 219. Beretka, J., and M.J. Ridge, 1958, J. Chem. Soc. A10, 2463. Berger, W. and F. Pawlek, 1957, Arch. Eisenhiittenwesen, 28, 101. Bertaut, E.F., A. Deschamps and R. Pauthenet, 1959, J. Phys. et Rad. 20, 404. Blazey, K.W., 1974, J. Appl. Phys. 45, 2273. Bonnenberg, D. and H.P.J. Wijn, 1968, Z. angew. Phys. 24, 125. Borovik, E.S. and Yu.A. Mamaluy, 1963, Fiz. Metal. Metalloved. 15, 300. Borovik, E.S. and N.G. Yakovleva, 1962a, Fiz. Metal. Metalloved. 13, 470. Borovik, E.S. and N.G. Yakovleva, 1962b, Fiz. Metal. Metalloved. 14, 927. Borovik, E.S. and N.G. Yakovleva, 1963, Fiz. Metal. Metalloved. 15, 511.
Bottoni, G., D. Candolfo, A. Cecchetti, L. Giarda and F. Masoli, 1972, Phys. Status Solidi A32, K47. Bowman, W.S., Saturno, F.H. Norman and J.H, Horwood, 1969, J. Can. Ceram. Soc. 38, 1. Bozorth, R.M. and V. Kramer, I959, J. Phys. et Rad. 20, 393. Brady, L.J., 1973, J. Material Sci. 8, 993. Braun, P.B., 1957, Philips Res. Rep. 12, 491. Brixner, L,H., 1959, J, Amer. Chem. Soc. 81, 3841. Buessem, W.R. and A. Doff, 1957, The Thermal expansion of ferrites at temperatures near the Curie point, Proc. 13 Ann. Meeting, Met. Powd. Ass., Chicago, Ill., USA, II, 196. Burlier, C.R., 1962, J. Appl. Phys. 33, 1360. Bye, G.C. and C.R. Howard, 1971, J. Appl. Chem. Biotechnol. 21, 319. Casimir, H.B.G., J. Smit, U. Enz, J.F. Fast, H.P.J. Wijn, E.W. Gorter, A.J.W. Duyvesteyn, J.D. Fast and J.J. deJong, 1959, J. Phys. et Rad. 20, 360. Clark, A.F., W.M. Haynes, V.A. Deason and R.J. Trapani, 1976, Cryogenics, May, 267. Cochardt, A., 1967, J. Appl. Phys. 38, 1904. Craik, D J . and E.H. Hill, 1977, J. Phys. Colloque, 38, C1-39. Davis, R.T., 1965, Thesis, Thermal expansion anisotropy in BaFe120~9, The Penn. State Univ. College of Mineral Ind. De Bitetto, D.J., 1964, J. Appl. Phys. 35, 3482. Dixon, S. Jr. and M. Weiner, 1970, J. Appl. Phys. 41, 1375. Dixon, S. Jr., T.R. AuCoin and R.O. Savage, 1971, J. Appl. Phys. 42, 1732. Drews, U. and J. Jaumann, 1969, Z. angew, Phys. 26, 48. Drofenik, M., D. Hanzel and A. Moljik, 1973, J. Mater. Sci. 8, 924. Dtilken, H., F. Haberey and H.P.J. Wijn, 1969, Z, angew. Phys. 26, 29. Dullenkopf, P. and H.P.J. Wijn, 1969, Z. angew. Phys. 26, 22. Du Pr6, F.K., D.J. De Bitetto and F.G. Brockman, 1958, J. Appl. Phys. 29, 1127. Eldridge, D.F., 1961, J. Appl. Phys. 32, 247 S. Erchak, M. Jr., I. Fankuchen and R. Ward, 1946, J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 68, 2085. Erchak, M. Jr. and R. Ward, 1946, J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 68, 2093. Esper, F.J. and G. Kaiser, 1972, Int. J. Magnetism, 3, 189.
388
H. KOJIMA
Esper, F.J. and G. Kaiser, 1975, Physica, 80B, 116. Fahlenbrach, H. and W. Heister, 1953, Arch. Eisenhtittenw. 29, 523. Florrescu, V., M. Popescu and C. Ghizdeanu, 1973, Int. J. Magnetism, 5, 257. Frei, E.H., M. Schieber and S. Strikman, 1960, Phys. Rev. 118, 657. Fuchikami, N., 1965, J. Phys. Soc. Japan, 20, 760. Galasso, F.S., 1970, Structure and Properties of Inorganic Solids (Pergamon Press, Oxford) p. 226-234. Gemperle, R., E.V. Shtoltz and M. Zeleny, 1963, Phys. Status Solidi, 3, 2015. Glasser, F.P., F.W.D. Woodhams, R.E. Meads and W.G. Parker, 1972, J. Solid State Chem. 5, 255. Goodenough, J.B., 1956, Phys. Rev. 102, 356. Gorter, E.W., 1954, Philips Res. Rep. 9, 295 and 403. Gorter, E.W., 1957, Proc. IEE, 104B, 255 S. Got& K., 1966, Japan. J. Appl. Phys. 5, 117. Goto, Y. and T. Takada, 1960, J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 43, 150. Goto, Y. and K. Takahashi, 1971, J. Japan Soc. Powder and Powder Metallurgy, 17, 193 (in Japanese). Goto, Y. and K. Takahashi, 1973, Japan. J. Appl. Phys. 12, 948. Goto, Y., M. Higashimoto and K. Takahashi, 1974, J. Japan Soc. Powder and Powder Metallurgy, 21, 21 (in Japanese). Grill, A., 1974, Int. J. Magnetism, 6, 173. Grill, A. and F. Haberey, 1974, Appl. Phys. 3, 131. Grosser, P., 1970, Z. angew. Phys. 30, 133. Grundy, P. J., 1965, Brit. J. Appl. Phys. 16, 409. Grundy, P.J. and S. Herd, 1973, Phys. Status Solidi A20, 295. Haberey, F. and A. Kockel, 1976, IEEE Trans. Mag. MAG-12, 983. Haberey, F. and H.P.J. Wijn, 1968, Phys. Status Solidi, 26, 231. Haberey, F., M. Velicescu and A. Kockel, 1973, Int. J. Mag. 5, 161. Hagner, J. and U. Heinecke, 1974, Phys. Status Solidi A22, K187. Haneda, K. and H. Kojima, 1971, Phys. Status Solidi A6, 259. Haneda, K. and H. Kojima, 1973a, J. Appl. Phys. 44, 3760. Haneda, K. and H. Kojima, 1973b, Japan. J. Appl. Phys. 12, 355.
Haneda, K. and H. Kojima, 1974, J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 57, 68. Haneda, K., C. Miyakawa and H. Kojima, 1974a, J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 57, 354. Haneda, K., C. Miyakawa and H. Kojima, 1974b, Improvement of temperature dependence of remanence in ferrite permanent magnets, AIP Conf. Proc. 24, 770. Hareyama, K., K. Kohn and K. Uematsu, 1970, J. Phys. Soc. Japan, 29, 791. Heimke, G., 1960, J. Appl. Phys. 31, 271 S. Heimke, G., 1962, Bet. Deut. Keram. Ges. 39, 326. Heimke, G., 1963, Z. angew. Phys. 15, 217. Heinecke, U. and L. Jahn, 1972, Phys. Status Solidi hl0, K93. Hempel, K.A. and H. Kmitta, 1971, J. Phys. Colloque, 32, C1-159. Henry, N.F.M. and K. Lonsdal, 1952, International Tables for X-ray Crystallography (Kynoch Press, Birmingham) p. 304. Hodge, M.H., W.R. Bitler and R.C. Bradt, 1973, J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 56, 497. Holz, A., 1970, J. Appl. Phys. 41, 1095. Hoselitz, K. and R.D. Nolan, 1969, J. Phys. D, Ser. 2, 2, 1625. Hunty, P., 1963, Fiz. Metal. Metalloved. 16, 132. Ichinose, N. and K. Kurihara, 1963, J. Phys. Soc. Japan, 18, 1700. Jahn, L. and H.G. Mfiller, 1969, Phys. Status Solidi, 35, 723. Jonker, G.W., H.P.J. Wijn and P.B. Braun, 1954, Philips Techn. Rev. 18, 145. Kacz6r, C., 1964, Zh. Eksperim, Teor. Fiz. 46, 1787. Kacz6r, J., 1972, Phys. Lett., 41A, '461. Kacz6r, J. and R. Gemperle, 1960, Czech. J. Phys. BIO, 505. Kacz6r, K. and R. Gemperle, 1961, Czech. J. Phys. Bll, 510. Kahn, F.J., P.S. Pershan and J.P. Remeika, 1969, J. Appl. Phys. 40, 1508. Kittel, C., 1946, Phys. Rev. 70, 965. Kiyama, M., 1976, Bull. Chem. Soc. Japan, 49, 1855. Kojima, H. and K. Got& 1962, J. Phys. Soc. Japan, 17, Supplement B-l, 201. Kojima, H. and K. Got& 1964, Determination of critical field for magnetoplumbite type oxides by domain observation, Proc. Int. Conf. Magn. Nottingham, p. 727. Kojima, H. and K. Got& 1965, J. Appl. Phys. 36, 538. Kojima, H. and K. Got& 1970, Bulletin. Res. Inst.
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF H E X A G O N A L FERRITES Sci. Meas., Tohoku University, 19, 67 (in Japanese). Kojima, H. and C. Miyakawa, 1965, Bulletin, Res. Inst. Sci. Meas., Tohoku University, 13, 105 (in Japanese). K6moto, O. and H. Kojima, 1976, Hard Magnetic Materials, ed., S. Iida et al. (Maruzen, Tokyo) Voi. 3, p. 110 (in Japanese). Kooy, C., 1958, Philips Techn. Rev. 19, 286. Kooy, C. and U. Enz, 1960, Philips Res. Rep. 15, 7. Koroleva, L.I. and L.P. Mitina, 1971, Phys. Status Solidi AS, K55. Kozlowski, G. and W. Zietek, 1965, J. Appl. Phys. 36, 2162. Kreber, E. and U. Gonser, 1973, Appl. Phys. 1, 339. Kreber, E. and U. Gonser, 1976, Appl. Phys. 10, 175. Kreber, E., U. Gonser and A. Trautwen, 1975, J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 36, 263. Kuntsevich, S.P., Yu.A. Mamaluy and A.S. Miln6r, 1968, Fiz. Metal. Metalloved. 26, 610. Kurtin, S., S. Foner and B. Lax, 1969, J. Appl. Phys. 40, 818. Lacour, C. and M. Paulus, 1968, J. Cryst. Growth, 3, 814. Lacour, C. and M. Paulus, 1975, Phys. Status Solidi A27, 441. Laroria, K.K. and A.P.B. Shinha, 1963, J. Pure and Appl. Phys. 1, 215. Linares, R.C., 1962, J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 45, 307. Lotgering, F.K., 1974, J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 35, 1633. Luborsky, F.E., 1966, J. Appl. Phys. 37, 1091. Ltitgemeier, M., A.V. Gonzales, W. Zietek and W. Zinn, 1977, Physica, 86--88B, 1363. MacChesney, J.B., R.C. Sherwood, E.T. Keve, P.B. O'Connor and L.D. Blitzer, 1971, New room temperature ferrimagnetic phases in the system CaO-AI203-Fe203, Ferrites, Proc. Int. Conf. Japan, p. 158. Mahoney, J.P., A. Tauber and R.O. Savage, 1972, Low temperature magnetic properties in BaFe12-x-y-zZnxTiyMnzO19, AIP Conf. Proc. no. 10, part 1, p. 159. Mason, W.P., 1954, Phys. Rev. 96, 302. Mee, C,D. and J.C. Jeschke, 1963, J. Appl. Phys. 34, 1271. Menashi, W.P., T.R. AuCoin, J.R. Shappirio and D.W. Eckart, 1973, J. Cryst. Growth, 20, 68. Mita, M., 1963, J. Phys. Soc. Japan, 18, 155.
389
Mones, A.H. and E. Banks, 1958, J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 4, 217. Mori, S., 1970, J. Phys. Soc. Japan, 28, 44. Moriya, T., 1960, Phys. Rev. 120, 91. Mountvala, A.J. and S.F. Ravitz, 1962, J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 45, 285. N6el, L., 1947, Compt. rend. 224, 1488. N6el, L., 1948, Ann. Phys. (Paris) 3, 137. Neumann, H. and H.P.J. Wijn, 1968, J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 51, 536. Oh, H.J., T. Nishikawa and M. Satou, 1978, J. Chem. Soc. Japan, 1, 42, (in Japanese). Okamoto, S., H. Sekizawa and S.I. Okamoto, 1975, J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 36, 591. Okazaki, C., B. Kubota and S. Mori, 1955, National Techn. Rep. 1, 23 (in Japanese). Okazaki, C., S. Mori and F. Kanamaru, 1961a, National Techn. Rep. 7, 21 (in Japanese). Okazaki, C., T. Kubota and S. Mori, 1961b, J. Phys. Soc. Japan, 16, 119. Palatnik, L.S., L.I. Lukashenko, L.Z. Lubyanyy, V.I. Lukashenko and Yu.A. Mamaluy, 1975, Fiz. Metal. Metalloved. 40, 61. Pauling, L., 1960, The Nature of the Chemical Bond, 3rd ed. (Cornell Univ. Press, Ithaca, N.Y.) p. 514. Paulus, M., 1960, Compt. rend. 250, 2332. Pauthenet, R. and G. Rimet, 1959a, Compt. rend. 249, 1875. Pauthenet, R. and G. Rimet, 1959b, Compt. rend. 249, 656. Perekalina, T.M. and V.P. Cheparin, 1967, Fiz. Tverd. Tela. 9, 217. Perekalina, T.M., M.A. Vinnik, R.I. Zevereva and A.P. Schurova, 1970, Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 59, 1490. Rathenau, G.W., 1953, Rev. Mod. Phys. 25, 297. Rathenau, G.W., J. Smit and A.L. Stuyts, 1952, Z. Phys. 133, 250. Ratnam, D.V. and W.R. Buessem, 1970, IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-6, 610. Ratnam, D.V. and W.R. Buessem, 1972, J. Appl. Phys. 43, 1291. Reddy, B.P.N. and P.J. Reddy, 1973, Phys. Status Solidi A17, 589. Reddy, B.P.N. and P.J. Reddy, 1974a, Phil. Mag. 30, 557. Reddy, B.P.N. and P.J. Reddy, 1974b, Phys. Status Solidi A22, 219. Reed, J.S. and R.M. Fulrath, 1973, J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 56, 207. Rensen, I.G. and I.S. van Wieringen, 1969, Solid State Commun. 1, 1139.
390
H. KOJIMA
Rensen, J.G., J.A. Schulkes and J.S. van Wieringen, 1971, J. Phys. Colloque, 32, C1-924. Richter, H.G. and H.E. Dietrich, 1968, IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-4, 263. Robbins, M., 1962, Thesis, Fluoride-compensated cation substitution in oxides, Polytechnic Inst. Brooklyn, New York. Robbins, M. and E. Banks, 1963, J. Appl. Phys. 34, 1260. Rodrigue, G.P., 1963, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory and Techniques, September, 351. Roos, W., H. Haak, C. Voigt and K.A. Hempel, 1977, J. Phys. Colloque, 38, C1-35. Rosenberg, M., C. Tfinfisoiu and V. Florescu, 1966, J. Appl. Phys. 37, 3826. Rosenberg, M., C. Tanasoiu and V. Florescu, 1967, Phys. Status Solidi, 21, 197. Routil, R.J. and D. Barham, 1974, Can. J. Chem. 52, 3235. Sadler, A.G., 1965, J. Can Ceram. Soc. 34, 155. Savage, R.O. and A. Tauber, 1964, J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 47, 13. Schieber, M.M., 1967, Experimental Magnetochemistry in Series of Monographs on Selected Topics in Solid State Physics, ed. E.P. Wohlfarth (North-Holland, Amsterdam) v01. 8, p. 198-217. Shimada, Y., K. Got6 and H. Kojima, 1973, Phys. Status Solidi A18, K1. Shimizu, S. and K. Fukami, 1972, J. Japan Soc. Powder and Powder Metallurgy, 18, 259 (in Japanese). Shirk, B.T. and W.R. Buessem, 1969, J. Appl. Phys. 40, 1294. Shirk, B.T. and W.R. Buessem, 1970, J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 53, 192. Shirk, B. and W.R. Buessem, 1971, IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-7, 659. Sigal, M.A., 1977, Phys. Status Solidi A42, 775. Silber, L.M., E. Tsantes and P. Angelo, 1967, J. Appl. Phys. 38, 5315. Sixtus, K.J., K.J. Kronenberg and R.K. Tenzer, 1956, J. Appl. Phys. 27, 1051. Sloccari, G., 1973, J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 56, 489. Slokar, G. and E. Lucchini, 1978a, J. Mag. and Mag. Mat. 8, 232. Slokar, G. and E. Lucchini, 1978b, J. Mag. and Mag. Mat. 8, 237. Smit, J., 1959, J. Phys. et Rad. 20, 370 (see Casimir et al. 1959).
Smit, J. and H.G. Beljers, 1955, Philips Res. Rep. 10, 113. Smit, J. and H.P.J. Wijn, 1959, Ferrites (Philips Technical Library, Eindhoven) p. 177-210. Smit, J., F.K. Lotgering and U. Enz, 1960, J. Appl. Phys. Supplement, 31, 137 S. St~iblein, H., 1973, Z. Werkstofftechnik, 4, 133. St~iblein, H. and W. May, 1969, Ber. Deut. Keram. Geselschaft, 46, 69. Standley, K.J., 1972, Oxide Magnetic Materials (Clarendon Press, Oxford) p. 149-160. Stoner, E.C. and E.P. Wohlfarth, 1948, Phil. Trans. A240, 599. Streever, R.S., 1969, Phys. Rev. 186, 285. Suchet, J.P., 1971, Compt. rend. S6ri C, 271, 895. Suemune, Y., 1972, J. Phys. Soc. Japan, 33, 279. Summergrad, R.N. and E. Banks, 1957, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 2, 312. Szymczak, R., 1971, J. Phys, Colloque, 32, C1-263. Takada, T., Y. Ikeda and Y. Bando, 1971, A new preparation method of the oriented ferrite magnets, Ferrites, Proc. Int. Conf. (Univ. Tokyo Press, Tokyo) p. 275. Tfinfisoiu, C., 1972, IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG8, 348. Tfinfisoiu, C., P. Nicolau and C. Micea, 1976, IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-12, 980. Tauber, A., R.O. Savage, R.J. Gambino and C.G. Whinfrey, 1962, J. Appl. Phys. 33, 1381. Tauber, A., J.A. Kohn and I. Bandy, 1963, J. Appl. Phys. 34, 1265. Tauber, A., S. Dixon, Jr. and R.O. Savage, Jr., 1964, J. Appl. Phys. 35, 1008. Tebble, R.S. and D.J. Craik, 1969, Magnetic Materials (Wiley-Interscience, London) p. 359-368. Townes, W.D., J.H. Fang and A.J. Perrotta, 1967, Z. Kristallogr. 125, 437. Trautwein, A., E. Kreber, U. Gonser and F.E. Harris, 1975, J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 36, 325. Van Diepen, A.M. and F.K. Lotgering, 1974, J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 35, 1641. Van Hook, H.J., 1964, J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 47, 579. Van Loef, J.J. and P.J.M. Franssen, 1963, Phys. Lett. 7, 225. Van Loef, J.J. and A.B. van Groenou, 1964, On the sub-lattice magnetization of BaFe12019, Proc. Int. Conf. Magn. Nottingham, p. 646. Van Uitert, L.G., 1957, J. Appl. Phys. 28, 317.
FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF H E X A G O N A L FERRITES Van Uitert, L.G. and F.W. Swanekamp, 1957, J. Appl. Phys. 28, 482. Van Wieringen, J.S., 1967, Philips Tech. Rev. 28, 33. Van Wieringen, J.S. and J.G. Rensen, 1966, Z. angew. Phys. 21, 69. Verstegen, J.M.P.J., 1973, J. Solid State Chemistry, 7, 468. Villers, G., 1959a, Compt. rend. 248, 2973. Villers, G., 1959b, Compt. rend. 249, 1337. Vinnik, M.A. and R.I. Zvereva, 1969, Kristallografiya, 14, 697. Wang, F.F.Y., K. Ishii and B.Y. Tsui, 1961, J. Appl. Phys. 32, 1621. Wells, R.G. and D.V. Ratnum, 1971, IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-7, 651. Went, J.J., G.W. Rathenau, E.W. Gorter and G.W. van Oosterhout, 1951/1952, Philips Techn. Rev. 13, 194.
391
Wijn, H.P.J., 1952, Nature, 170, 707. Wijn, H.P.J., 1970, Landolt-B6rnstein Numerical Data and Functional Relationships in Science and Technology. New Series, III/4b. ed. K.-H. Hellwege (Springer, Berlin) p. 552681. Williams, H.J. and R.C. Sherwood, 1958, J. Appl. Phys. 29, 296. Wisnyi, L.G., 1967, Powder Diffraction File, 7-85. Wullkopf, H., 1972, International J. Magnetism, 3, 179. Wullkopf, H., 1975, Physica, 80B, 129. Zanmarchi, G. and P.F. Bongers, 1969, J. Appl. Phys. 40, 1230. Zfiveta, K., 1963, Phys. Status Solidi, 3, 2111. Zinn, W., S. Hfifner, M. Kalvius, P. Kienle and W. Wiedemann, 1964, Z. angew. Phys. 17, 147.
chapter 6 PROPERTIES OF FERROXPLANA-TYPE HEXAGONAL FERRITES
M. SUGIMOTO Saitama University, Faculty of Engineering 225 Shimo-ohkubo, Urawa 338 Japan
Ferromagnetic Materials, Vol. 3 Edited by E.P. Wohlfarth © North-HollandPublishing Company, 1982 393
CONTENTS
1. C h e m i c a l c o m p o s i t i o n s , crystal s t r u c t u r e a n d spin o r i e n t a t i o n 1.1. BaMezFe16Oz7 ( W - t y p e ) . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2. BaeMeeFel~Oz2 ( Y - t y p e ) 1.3. Ba3MeeFe24041 ( Z - t y p e )
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
1.4. BazMe2Fe28046 ( X - t y p e ) . . . . . . . . . 1.5. Ba4MezFe36060 ( U - t y p e ) . . . . . . . . . 1.6. O t h e r c o m p o u n d s . . . . . . . . . . . 2. P r e p a r a t i o n ~nd f o r m a t i o n kinetics . . . . . . 3. SatuJ atic n r~ a g n e | i z a t i o n . . . . . : . . . . 4. M a g n e t o c r ~ stalline a n i s o t r o p y a n d r e l a l e d p h e n c m e n a
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
395 395 397 399 400 401 401 402 4O4 412 421 425
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
.
.
.
. .
. .
. .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
.
. .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
5. M6ssb~ u e r effect . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. M a g n e l ostriction a n d N M R . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.1. M a g n e t o s l r i c t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . .
. . .
6.2. N M R . . . . . . . . . 7. H i g h f r e q u e n c y m a g n e t i c lzrol:crties 8. E l e c t r i c p r o r erties a n d o l h e r effects
.
.
8.1. Cc n d u c l i v i l y . . . . 8.2. E ieleclric c c n s t a n t . 8.3. J a h r - T e l l e r effect . . 8.4. M a g n e t o - o p t k al effect 8.5. E ' o m a ! n c bse r v a l i o n a n d References . . . . . . .
.
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
.
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . c h e m ; c a l analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
394
. .
. . .
. . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
425 427 428 434 434 435 435 436 436 439
1. Chemical compositions, crystal structures and spin orientation A group of compounds consisting of isotropic materials with spinel structure and higher anisotropic materials with hexagonal structure has been developed by Jonker et al. (1956/57). They are generically referred to as the ferroxplana-type compounds. The general chemical formula of these compounds is denoted by m(Ba2++ Me2+)-nFe203, where Me 2+ represents the divalent metal ions Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Mg and Zn. In the triangle of fig. 1 in ch. 5 the symbols W, Y, Z, X and U represent the compounds with chemical composition BaMezFe16027, Ba2MezFe12022, Ba3Me2Fe24041, BazMezFe28046 and Ba4Me2Fe36060, respectively. If Me 2+ ions in the W-structure, as an example, are substituted by Zn 2+ ions, the composition may be conveniently indicated by the short notation of Zn2W. In the case of substitution of both Zn 2+ and Fe 2+ ions for Me 2+ ions it may be represented by ZnFeW.
1.1. BaMe2Fe16027 (W-type) The unit cell of the W-type compound is built up by superposition of four spinel blocks (S-block) and two blocks containing Ba ions (R-block) as shown in table 1 of ch. 5. Figure 1 shows a cross section of the W-structure having a hexagonal packing, which is closely related to the M-structure (Albanes e et al. 1976b). The only difference is that the successive R-blocks are interspaced by two S-blocks instead of one, as is the case in the M-structure. The crystal structure of R-blocks with chemical composition BaFe6Oll as well as that of S-blocks with chemical composition Me2Fe408 are represented in fig. 14 of ch. 5. In table 1 the number of ions and the coordination of the different cation sublattices in the W-structure are shown (Albanese et al. 1976b). The cations occupy seven different sublattices of 12K, 4e, 4fw, 4fw, 6g, 4f and 2d, in the nomenclature used by Braun (1957). The spin orientation according to the generally accepted collinear model is also indicated. This magnetic classification has been justified by the assumption that the magnetic behaviour of the nearest neighbour cations is determined by superexchange interaction.
395
396
M. S U G I M O T O
W- type Structure 4fly ® 4e © 4f e6g e 12K 4fv I • 2d
R
©o 20
I S*
Ba 2+
I S* R*
Fig. 1. Unit cell of the BaMe2Fe16027, Me2W, compound. T h e anions of O 2 , the divalent barium cation Ba 2÷, the metallic ions in the sublattices 4fw, 4e, 4f, 6g, 12K, 4fvi and 2d are indicated. T h e coordination figures of the metallic ions in the different lattice sites are shown (Albanese et al. 1976b).
TABLE 1 N u m b e r of ions, coordination and spin orientation for the various cations of a W-type c o m p o u n d (Albanese et al. 1976b).
Magnetic sublattice K fw
fvI a b
Sublattice
Coordination
N u m b e r of ions per formula unit
12K 4e 4fry 4fvi 6g 4f 2d
octahedral tetrahedral tetrahedral octahedral octahedral octahedral hexahedral
6 2 2 2 3 2 1
Block
Spin
R-S S S R S-S S R
up down down down up up up
PROPERTIES OF FERROXPLANA-TYPE HEXAGONAL FERRITES
397
1.2. Ba=Me2Fe12022(Y-type) T h e u n i t cell of t h e Y - t y p e c o m p o u n d is b u i l t u p b y t h e s u p e r p o s i t i o n of t h r e e S - b l o c k s a n d t h e so c a l l e d t h r e e T - b l o c k s as s h o w n in fig. 2, in w h i c h t h e d i f f e r e n t
Y - type Structure S
T
3 oVl (I) 6cvl 3 bvi o 1Bhvt o 6Civ
® 6clv O 0 2-
•
BCl 2+
S
T
S
T
Fig. 2. Unit cell of the Ba2Me2Fe12Oz~, Me2Y, compound. The anions of O 2-, the divalent barium cation Ba 2÷, the metallic ions in the sublattices 3avi, 6cvl, 3bvl, 18hw, 6cw and 6c~v are indicated. The coordination figures of the metallic ions in the different lattice sites, together with their spin orientation, are shown (Albanese et al. 1975b).
398
M. S U G I M O T O
lattice sites are distinguished by different symbols (Albanese et al. 1975). The Y-structure has the crystal symmetry characterized by the space group R3m. As shown in fig. 14 of ch. 5, the T-block with Ba2Fe8014 composition is formed by four oxygen layers having hexagonal packing and plays an unique role in the , TABLE 2 Number of ions, coordination and spin orientation for the various metallic sublattices of Y-structure? (Albanese et al. 1975b).
Sublattice
Coordination
Block
Number of ions per unit cell
tetrahedral octahedral octahedral octahedral tetrahedral octahedral
S S S-T T T T
6 3 18 6 6 3
6cw 3aw 18hvi 6cw 6c•v 3by1
Spin down up up down down up
t Sublattices having the same crystalline symmetry but belonging to different blocks are marked by an asterisk. TABLE 3 Strength of the superexchange interactions between Fe 3+ ions in the Y-structure (Albanese et al. 1975b). Interacts with n Fe 3+ ions Each Fe 3+ ion in lattice position 3avi 6Civ
18hvl
0Cvi
6C}'v
3bvl
n 6 6 3 3 9 1 3 2 1 4 6 3 1 3 3 3 6 2
lattice position 6cw 18hvl 6cIv 3avi 18hw 3avr 6clv 6Cvi 6C~v 18hvi 18hvl 6CTv 3bvi 6cw 18hvl 3bvI 6c•v 6Cvi
Strength of the superexchange interaction1 25 0(+) 0(+) 25 26 0(+) 26 30 25 0(+) 30 9(+) 1.7 9(+) 25 77 77 1.7
t The cross indicates interactions between sublattices with parallel spins.
PROPERTIES OF FERROXPLANA-TYPE HEXAGONAL FERRITES
399
Y - s t r u c t u r e . In fig. 2, t h e c o m m o n faces of t h e o c t a h e d r a inside t h e T - b l o c k a r e h a t c h e d . T h e p r e s e n c e of a n i o n o c t a h e d r a with c o m m o n faces is g e n e r a l l y r e s p o n s i b l e for t h e l o w e r stability of t h e s t r u c t u r e , d u e to t h e h i g h e r p o t e n t i a l e n e r g y of t h e s y s t e m as c o m p a r e d with s i t u a t i o n s w h e r e o n l y c o r n e r s a r e s h a r e d a n d t h e c a t i o n s a r e thus f u r t h e r a p a r t . This fact f a v o u r s t h e M e 2+ ions having a m a r k e d p r e f e r e n c e for t h e o c t a h e d r a l c o o r d i n a t i o n of t h e 6Cvi a n d 3bw lattice sites. T a b l e 2 shows t h e spin o r i e n t a t i o n for v a r i o u s s u b l a t t i c e s t o g e t h e r with t h e i r c o o r d i n a t i o n in t h e Y - s t r u c t u r e . A l b a n e s e et al. (1975b) c a l c u l a t e d t h e s t r e n g t h of t h e v a r i o u s s u p e r e x c h a n g e i n t e r a c t i o n s b e t w e e n F e 3+ ions in t h e Y - s t r u c t u r e . T a b l e 3 shows t h e results o b t a i n e d on t h e basis of t h e a s s u m p t i o n t h a t t h e i n t e r a c t i o n e n e r g y follows an e x p o n e n t i a l d e p e n d e n c e on t h e a n i o n - c a t i o n dist a n c e s a n d a c o s 2 0 law for t h e a n g u l a r d e p e n d e n c e . F r o m this t a b l e it a p p e a r s t h a t t h e s t r o n g e s t s u p e r e x c h a n g e i n t e r a c t i o n is t h e o n e b e t w e e n t h e t e t r a h e d r a l ions 6Cfv a n d t h e o c t a h e d r a l ions 3bvi inside t h e T - b l o c k , a n d t h e o n l y a p p r e c i a b l e p e r t u r b i n g i n t e r a c t i o n a p p e a r s to b e t h e o n e b e t w e e n t h e 6C?v a n d 6Cvr ions, b o t h b e l o n g i n g to t h e T - b l o c k .
1..3. Ba3Me2Fe24041 (Z-type) T h e c r y s t a l l i n e s t r u c t u r e of t h e Z - t y p e c o m p o u n d s is s h o w n in fig. 3 ( A l b a n e s e et al. 1976a). T h e unit cell is f o r m e d by the s u p e r p o s i t i o n of f o u r S-blocks, two T-blocks and one R-block, and the divalent and trivalent cations are distributed a m o n g ten different lattice sites. T a b l e 4 shows t h e n u m b e r of ions r e l a t i v e to t h e v a r i o u s c a t i o n sublattices t o g e t h e r with t h e i r spin o r i e n t a t i o n . TABLE 4 Number of ions, coordination and spin orientation of the various metallic sublattices of Z-structuret (Albanese et al. 1976a).
Sublattice 12kv~ 2dv 4fw 4f-}i 4etv 4fiv 12k~}i 2avl 4evl 4f]~v
Coordination octahedral five-fold octahedral octahedral tetrahedral tetrahedral octahedral octahedral octahedral tetrahedral
Block R-S R R S S S T-S T T T
Number of ions per unit cell
Spin
12 2 4 4 4 4 12 2 4 4
up up down up down down up up down down
t Sublattices having the same crystalline symmetry but belonging to different blocks are marked by an asterisk.
400
M. SUGIMOTO
Z - type S t r u c t u r e
R
S
© 12Kvx ® 2dv 4f-Vl ® 4f~ 1 @ 4elv ~ 4fly 12K~,I I) 2clvl • 4evl
T
© 4fly
© 0 zBCI 2÷
R.
T* I S* Fig. 3. Unit cell of Ba3Co2Fe24041, Co2Z, compound. The coordination figures of the metallic ions in the main lattice sites are shown (Albanese et al. 1976a).
1.4. Ba2Me2Fez8046 (X-type) T h e u n i t cell of the X-type c o m p o u n d s consists of f o u r a l t e r n a t e layers of the M - s t r u c t u r e a n d W - s t r u c t u r e , b e l o n g i n g to the space s y m m e t r y g r o u p R3m. F i g u r e 4 shows a cross section of the Zn2X structure, in which the spin o r i e n t a t i o n
PROPERTIES OF FERROXPLANA-TYPE HE XAGONAL FERRITES
401
X - type S t r u c t u r e f~
W
Y3~_
(
A
Q O
-- 0 2 -
Oct.
@ •
/X
A
ZX
-- BQ2÷ -
Tet.
[]
-
Tri.
Fig. 4. A collinear spin model for Zn~X (Tauber et al. 1970).
as well as the coordination figures of all cations are represented (Tauber et al. 1970).
1.5. Ba4Me2Fe3606o (U-type) The unit--cell of the U-type c o m p o u n d is a rhombohedral structure belonging to space group R3m, and is formed by three molecules. The structure is built up by the superposition of two M-blocks and one Y-block along the c-axis. Figure 5 shows a cross section of the Zn2U structure and the spin orientation of all cations (Kerecman etoal. 1968). Referring to hexagonal structure, its lattice p a r a m e t e r s are c = 113.2 A, a = 5.88 A and the X-ray density is 5.36.
1.6. Other compounds Kohn et al. (1964a,b) reported a new hexagonal ferrite with Ba4Zn2Fes2Os4 composition. T h e new structure is made up by the sequence of composite TS- and RS-block. Interleaving the TS- and RS-block at various ratios leads to a structure with unit cells ranging from 18 to 138 oxygen layers; these give rise to hexagonal unit cells with c parameters ranging up to about 1600 A. The expected empirical formulae for this group of compounds are listed in table 5. Kohn and Eckart (1971) discovered a new c o m p o u n d w~th composition, BasZn2Ti3Fe12031, which is a hexagonal structure with a = 5.844 A and c =-43.020 A and contains 18 oxygen layers, indicated by the symbol Zn2-18H.
402
M. SUGIMOTO
U type Structure -
(
)
i
A
0
_
0 2-
-
Oct.
•
M
A
_
Be2*
-
Tet.
[]-
Tri.
Fig. 5. A collinear spin model for Zn2U (Kerecman et al. 1968).
TABLE 5 Chemical compositions and crystallographic properties for new ferroxplana-type compounds (Robert et al. 1964).
Chemical composition
Structural unit (blocks)
Bal0ZnaFes60102 Ba12ZnmFe680124 Ba14Zni2Fes00146
[(TS)4T]3 [(TS)sT]3 (TS)6T
Ba16Zn14Fe920168 Ba4Zn2Fe52084
[(TS)TT]3 [RS2(RS)3]3
2. Preparation
and formation
Number of oxygen layers
Lattice parameter c (A)
Primitive symmetry
Space group
28 x 3 34 x 3 40 46 x 3 22 × 3
203 247 97 334 154
Rhombohedral Rhombohedral Hexagonal Rhombohedral Rhombohedral
P63/mmc P63/mmc R3m
kinetics
The processes for producing the ferroxplana-type compounds are very similar to those for M-type compounds. However, more accurate procedures based on the phase equilibrium are necessary to obtain the ferroxplana-type compounds,
PROPERTIES
OF FERROXPLANA-TYPE
HEXAGONAL
FERRITES
403
.. because their chemical compositions are"very complex. In particular, it is very difficult to produce a crystallographicall'y pure compound containing various amounts of ferrous iron. Neuman and Wijn (1968) shed light on the chemical equilibrium between the oxygen partial pressure o f gas atmosphere and the formation of Fe2W phase. In order to obtain a homogeneous W-compound, the samples must be sintered at 1250° to 1400°C in an atmosphere with a partial oxygen pressure between 2 x 10 .4 and 2 x 10-1 atm. Figure 6 shows the formation temperature and stability range of the phases for the W, Y and Z compounds. The spinel phase appeared as the first major reaction product of the raw oxides at about 555°C. The M phase was detected next by X-ray analysis and followed by the formation of a Y, Z, W phase in turn. Castelliz et al. (1969) also studied the kinetics of phase formation as well as the stability of the phases. Lotgering (1959) evolved a new method for making a sintered crystal-oriented ferroxplana compound. The advantage of crystal orientation is evident from the fact that the permeability of its compounds can be about 3 times larger than that of non-oriented compounds. This method differs essentially in the formation mechanism from that for the M-type compound. A paste or thick suspension consisting of BaFe12019 powder and raw oxides such as ZnO or CoO is poured into a die and then introduced into a static magnetic field. The crystal orientation is made topotactically by compressing the suspension into a pellet. The orientation preserved through the firing at 1100° to 1300°C. Licci and Asti (1979) tried to produce topotactically the crystal-oriented CoZnY compound. The hot-pressing method was performed to obtain a crystal-oriented Co2W compound by Okazaki and Igarashi (1970). A large and nearly perfect single crystal of the ferroxplana-type compounds, t
i
[
I
F
i
[
i
r
0.8
.=-
J
Z
o.z,
\/
/
\
0.2
Co
rr
4
~;oo
600
Boo
~ooo
~2oo
~oo
T('C) Fig. 6. F o r m a t i o n
temperature
a n d s t a b i l i t y r a n g e o f W - , Y-, Z - a n d M - p h a s e s 1964).
(Neckenbiirger
et al.
404
M. SUGIMOTO
which is useful for microwave devices, can be grown relatively easily by the flux method. Tauber et al. (1962, 1964) investigated many kinds of flux materials useful for growing single crystals of ferroxplana compounds. It was found that BaOB203 flUX must be less volatile and less viscous than the NaFeO2 flux to obtain a single crystal with lower ferromagnetic resonance linewidth. In general, the Wand Y-type compounds are easily melted at a lower temperature. The difficulty in growing the crystals of Z-, X-, and U-type compounds may be attributable to the high-melting composition necessitated by the large concentration of Fe203. Stearns et al. (1975) and Glass et al. (1980) have grown single crystal films of ZnzY or Zn2W by the isothermal dipping method of liquid phase epitaxy using a PbO-BaO-B203 flux. Many investigations on microstructures of sintered samples have been presented: Huijser-Gerits and Rieck (1970, 1974, 1976) studied thoroughly the influence of sintering conditions on microstructure; Drobek et al. (1961) observed the microstructures by the Use of electron microscope; both Cook (1967) as well as Landuyt and Amelinckx (1974) observed the stacking sequence by electron microscope.
3. Saturation magnetization Many attempts have been made to improve the saturation magnetization by the substitutions of various kinds of metal ions for cations occupying the octahedral and tetrahedral sites in the oxygen framework structure of the ferroxplana-type compounds. This may be attributed to their unique crystallographical structure as well as their importance as promising materials for technological application in the field of permanent magnets and microwave devices. Smit and Wijn (1959) proposed a formula on the basis of the over-simplification that the number of Bohr magnetons at saturation for the W-type compound is simply equal to the sum of the corresponding number for M- and S-structures, i.e.: (ns)w = (nB)M+ 2(nn)s.
(1)
This concept implies that we treat as different the two S-blocks which are perfectly equivalent. This drastic consequence frequently leads to a discrepancy with the experimental values. For example, the formula gives the value of (ns)w = 20/XB for the ZnzW compound, while Albanese et al. (1976a) and Savage and Tauber (1965) determined it experimentally as 35/x8 and 38.2/XB at 0 K (= 123 G cm3/g and 134 G cm3/g, respectively). The assumption of Smit and Wijn is applicable to the Y-type and Z-type compounds, but problems slightly analogous to that for the W-type compound still remain. The W-structure is characterized by the presence of two additional spinel blocks instead of one, as in the M-structure. Such a structure creates the possibility of changing the magnetic properties by a suitable substitution of the cation. Uitert and Swanekamp (1957) attempted to improve the saturation magnetization of W-type compounds by the substitution of non-magnetic ions for cations in
PROPERTIES OF FERROXPLANA-TYPE H E X A G O N A L FERRITES
405
tetrahedral and octahedral sites, and showed that the saturation magnetization is generally apt to decrease with increasing amount of substitution. In fig. 7, zinc ions seem likely to occupy the tetrahedral sites in BaMe2Fe16027 and a much greater fraction of A1, G a and In ions appears to occupy the octahedral sites. An anomalous behaviour of curve (1) at around zero saturation can be attributed to a lack of homogeneity in the samples. Albanese et al. (1977) reported that the saturation magnetization of BaZn2AlxFe16_xO27 is reduced when the amount of substitution of AP + for Fe 3+ in a-sites is increased, and a compensation point of superexchange interaction results at x = 4. In fig. 8 the saturation magnetization, o-s, for a number of simple and mixed W-type compounds is plotted as a function of temperature. It appears from the figure that almost straight lines are found over a large temperature range, and that zinc ions give higher saturation magnetization at low temperatures. In Zn2W compounds, the Z n 2+ ions may occupy two tetrahedral sublattices 4e and 4f~v (Albanese et al. 1976b), and in Mg2W compounds 90% of the Mg 2+ ions may
4000
E 3000 -x
7 \ ,~ \ \
g "~
2000
w
\ i1
I/1
3" .~
I000
I I
-
E
1000 2
6
B
Fig. 7. Effect of various substitutions on room-temperature saturation magnetization for BaNi2Fe16OzT. X denotes the number of metal ions replaced per formula unit. (1) AI for Fe, (2) Ga for Fe, (3) In or Cr for Fe, (4) Zn for Ni, (5) BaZn2GaFelsOz7, (6) BaZn2Ga3Fe13027 and (7) BaZn2AI3Fe13027 (Van Uitert and Swanekamp 1957).
406
M. S U G I M O T O 120
I
i
I
I
t
I
'
100 ~ ' ~ "
,
~'
ao
"'-Lx,. ~
Me2= ZnFe~
Me 2 W
0Yg
.
N o "k I.-~ 60 '4"
F
LO
Ni
F'
"""'/-c~'~'-.XX~D"'~IL~_
2o
0
l
J
1
-273 -200
I
r
0
,
,a,~
200
~a,z
400
600
T(°C) Fig. 8. Saturation magnetization as a function of temperature for a n u m b e r of c o m p o u n d s with W-structure, m e a s u r e d on polycrystalline specimens at a field of 6600 Oe (Smit and Wijn 1959).
,Zn
60
E
I
i
I
MeY
40 x
/Mg
E 20
0
-273
.d
Ni
I
-200
I
I
I
0
200
400
T [°0)
Fig. 9. Saturation magnetization as a function of temperature for a n u m b e r of c o m p o u n d s with Y-structure measured on polycrystalline specimens at a field of 11000 Oe (Smit and Wijn 1959).
PROPERTIES OF FERROXPLANA-TYPE H E X A G O N A L FERRITES
407
occupy the octahedral sites, and 10% of Mg the tetrahedral sites (Smit and Wijn 1959). Many other reports on the saturation magnetization of W-type compounds have been presented. A study on Fe2W substituted by Ni 2+ and F- (Banks et al. 1962), Fe2W substituted by Co 2+ and F- (Robbins et al. 1963), (NiZn)W and (Nil.6Co0.4)W (Hodges et al. 1964) and (Co165Fe0.35)W (Yamzin et al. 1966). An expected improvement in magnetic moment in the Y-type compounds was proposed by Albanese et al. (1975b). If all cations occupying 3by1 sites in a T-block can be substituted by non-magnetic ions, the magnetic moment might be markedly improved. This is due to the fact that 3bvi sites alone link the upper and lower parts of the unit cell through the strong interaction with six ions 6cw. Furthermore, the inversion symmetry around 3bvi sites might be broken by the partial substitution of iron ions in 6Cvi sites. However, such a drastic change in the magnetic order, has so far not been reported. Figure 9 shows the saturation magnetization of a number of simple Y-type compounds as a function of temperature. In the case of Y-type compounds, zinc ions also give the highest saturation magnetization. Albanese et al. (1975b) reported that in Ba2Mg2Fe~2022(Mg2Y), Mg2+ ions mainly occupy 3bvi and 6Cw sublattices of the tetragonal sites inside the T-block, and this occupation leads to the weakening effect of the superexchange interaction caused by a critical competition of the two exchange interaction 3bvr-6CTv and 6Cvr-6C•v. The temperature dependence of the saturation magnetization parallel and perpendicular to the c-axis of (Ba0.05Sr0.95Zn)Y single crystals is shown in fig. 10 (Enz 1961). We can see from these curves that this compound has a preferential plane. According to Albanese et al. (1975b), since the Co 2+ ions in Ba2Co2Fe12022(Co2Y) have a marked preference for octahedral coordination, 0.9 Co 2+ ions may occupy only the spin-down octahedral sublattice 6Cw, while the residual 1.1 Co 2+ ions probably distribute themselves among the 3avl, 18hvb 3by1 sublattices. In Ba2Zn2-2xCu2xF12022,(Zn2-2xCU2x)Y, the substitution of Zn by Cu resulted in a linear decrease of the saturation magnetization, o-~, as well as a flattening of the o-~ vs. T curve (Albanese et al. 1978). This suggests that for all the compositions nearly 28% of Cu ions enter the spin-down sublattices and the residual 72% occupy the spin-up sites. Among the spin-up sublattices, the 3bvi sites at the centre of the T-block play an important role for the equilibrium of the superexchange interactions in this compound, as already described. In addition, other experiments on Zn2Y by Savage and Tauber (1964), Mn2Y and (MnZn)Y by both Tauber et al. (1964) and Dixon et al. (1965) have been performed. In fig. 11 the saturation magnetization is plotted as a function of temperature for polycrystalline specimens of Z-type compounds. Zn2Z shows the highest saturation magnetization. The distribution of Co 2+ ions in Co2Z was deduced by Albanese et al. (1976a) such that 1.08 Co 2+ ions per unit formula occupy the spin-up sublattice, while the residual 0.92 enter the 4fvi and 4ev~ sublattices which are the only spin-down octahedral lattice sites. The Curie temperatures as seen in fig. 11 are in agreement with their values obtained from M6ssbauer measurements. Petrova (1967) measured the saturation magnetization and Curie temperature of (Co2-xZnx)Z.
408
M. SUGIMOTO BO
( Boo.05 Sr o.g5 Zn)Y 40 H.Lc
~
c
-
(a)
o - - - ' _ ~ T~290 ~K
0
80
I
I
i
F:
% -4"
(b)
40 0
BO
40 t
~
(c)
E
0~
-
80
0
Hllc i
0
5
-r
T=I2OO°K r
10
15
20
H ( k Oe ) [ x 106/(z./T) A / rn ] Fig. 10. Magnetization curves of single crystal of (Ba0.0sSr0.95Zn)Y(Enz 1961).
80 \
E
C o " ~
i
Me=Zn
Me2Z
60
x
/.0
~
2o
0
-273
-200
-100
0
100
200
300
/+00
500
T(*C)
Fig. 11. Saturation magnetization as a function of temperature for compounds with Z-structure, measured on polycrystalline specimens at a field of 11000 Oe for Co2Z and Zn2Z and 18000 Oe for Cu2Z (Smit and Wijn 1959).
PROPERTIES OF FERROXPLANA-TYPE
HEXAGONAL
FERRITES
409
Figure 12 shows the temperature dependence of the saturation magnetization for Ba2Zn2Fe~O46(Zn2X), Ba2Co2Fe2sO46(Co2X) and BaeZn2Fe36060(Zn2U) single crystals (Tauber et al. 1970 and Kerecman et al. 1968). If we assume that the Zn 2+ ions in Zn2X are equally distributed over the sublattices (spin-up and spin-down), the magnetic moment can be calculated as n u = 50.0/XB ( H = % T = 0 ) by reference to the collinear Gorter-type spin model of fig. 4. This calculated value is in excellent agreement with the experimental value 50.4/xB ( H = w, T = 0). However, crystal chemistry would require most of the Zn 2+ ions to be on tetrahedral site, leading to: 20 x 5 - 8 x 5
= 60/x B .
Tauber et al. (1970) explained that this roughly 18% difference between experimental and calculated result in ZnzX may arise because of the spin system is not colinear or because of non-stoichiometry of the crystals. In the case of Co2X, the calculated value 47#B ( H = ~, T = 0) is in good agreement with the experimental value 46/XB. As pointed out by Tauber et al. (1970), the agreement may be fortuitously given by the stoichiometry. The Curie temperatures of 705-+ 3 K for Zn2X and 740_+ 4 K for CozX are the highest values among the ferroxplana-type compounds containing Zn 2+ ions. The magnetic moment of Zn2U was calculated as 60.5/xB from O-s ( H = o0, T = 0 K). The value of the magnetic moment obtained from the sum of those for M- and Y-blocks, 58.4 (Gorter 1957) and 59.2 (Vinnik 1966), is in good agreement with the experimental value. However, a simple Gorter-type model (where all
100
_•
I
l
I
'
r
'
500
4OO 13r}
.x
80 .a
300
~
(:3
~:
6O C)
×
=
x
200
d~ (Co~X)
40
-.t x c9
v
E 100
2O
:~
0 0
200
/-.00
600
T (K) Fig. 12. Saturation magnetization as a function of temperature for Zn2X, Co2X and Zn2U (Tauber et al. 1970, K e r e c m a n et al. 1968).
410
M. S U G I M O T O
Z n 2+ ions are tetrahedral in the layers of Y and M but not all in spinel blocks) gives 60tXa, seemingly in better agreement. The magnetic m o m e n t s in spinels containing large amounts of Zn are lowered by the formation of angles between the m o m e n t s of octahedral ions. T a u b e r et al. described that since this effect is more pronounced in Zn2W than in Zn2Y, the experimental m o m e n t for Zn2U is still less than the value predicted from theory. The Curie t e m p e r a t u r e of Zn2U was given as 673 + 2 K. Figure 13 shows the saturation magnetization of BasZn2Ti3Fe12031(Zn2-18H) and BasMg2Ti3FeI2031(Mg2-18H) as a function of temperature. Zn2-18H could be saturated in 7 k O e fields below 15 K in the easy plane and followed a o's = o-0 + x H law. A magnetic m o m e n t nB ( H = ~, T = 0) = 14.1 ¥ 0.6/XB and Curie t e m p e r a t u r e Tc = 310~-5 K were extracted from the magnetization data. Mg2-18H crystals could not be saturated in 15.5 k O e field applied parallel to either the (0001) plane or [0001] axis below 120 K. A b o v e 120 K the magnetization followed a o%= cro+ x H law. At 300 K, Tc was measured as 391-7-3 K and nB ( H = ~, T = 0 ) = 7 . 8 * 5tXa was obtained by extrapolation from 120 K. Tauber et al. (1971) discussed the magnetic m o m e n t of these compounds as follows: A ferrimagnetic resultant according to the following site arrangement per formula unit, 9°~--~--4tet~--4 °~t was predicted. When this alignment was used to compute the
40
~30 E
B
% ×
~ 20 X
I O0
200
300
~00
T(K) Fig. 13. Saturation magnetization as a function of temperature for Znz-18H and Mg2-18H (Tauber et al. 1971).
P R O P E R T I E S OF F E R R O X P L A N A - T Y P E H E X A G O N A L F E R R I T E S
411
moment for Zn2-18H assuming the following cation distribution, ( 7 . 4 1 F e 3+, l T i 4+, 0 . 5 9 Z n 2+) ~
<-- ( 1 . 4 1 Z n 2+, 2 . 5 9 F e 3+) ~-- ( 2 F e 3+, 2.0Ti4+),
the resultant magnetic moment came to: (37.05/-tB)--~ - ~-- (12.95/xB) - ~-- (10/xB) = (14.1/.t~).
Zn 2+ ions occupation in octahedral sites in Y-blocks was discussed by Townes a n d Fang (1970). For Mg2-18H, one of many possible distributions giving the magnetic moment is: (6.78Fe 3+, 1.22Ti 4+, 2Mg)---~ ~--(4Fe 3+) ~--(1.22Fe 3+, 1.78Ti 4+, 1Mg) × (33.9/xB)2-~- ~ ( 2 0 / x B ) - *--(6.1/.tB) = (7.8/.tB).
In table 6 the saturation magnetizations and Curie temperatures of the ferroxplana-type compounds are shown.
TABLE 6
The saturation magnetization of ferroxplana-type compounds at absolute zero and at 20°C, and Curie point. o-0 (gauss)
0-20 (gauss)
47rMs
T¢
(cm3/g)
(cm3/g)
(gauss)
(°C)
97 98 79 108
59 78 52 73
3900 5220 3450 4800
415 455 520 430
Mn~Y CoaY Ni2Y Zn2Y Mg2Y
42 39 25 72 29
31 34 24 42 23
2100 2300 1600 2850 1500
290 340 390 130 280
Smit and Wijin (1959)
Co2Z CuzZ Zn2Z
69 60 55
50 46 58
3350 3100 3900
410 440 360
Smit and Wijin (1959)
Zn2X Cu2X
107 95
-
4700 3900
432 467
Tauber et al. (1970) Silber and Tsantes (1969)
Zn2U
-
-
3700
400
Kerecman et al. (1968)
37 20 _+2
-
-
37 291
Savage et al. (1974)
Compounds symbol MnzW Fe2W NiFeW ZnFeW
Znz-18H CuNi-18H
Ref.
Smit and Wijin (1959)
412
M. SUGIMOTO
4. Magnetocrystalline anisotropy and related phenomena One of the reasons for the great scientific and technical interest in the ferroxplana-type compounds is their large crystalline anisotropy. In addition, this anisotropy can be modified over a large range of values by the substitution of the transition metal ions for other divalent ions. A simplified description of the crystalline anisotropy energy density, applicable to most ferroxplana-type compounds, is given in ch. 5. The anisotropy constant, K1 = HAMs~2, and the anisotropy field, HA, as a function of temperature for BaZn2Fe16027(Zn2W) are shown fig. 14 (Albanese et al. 1976b). The value of the anisotropy field was deduced from the saturation magnetization. Although Ks of Zn2W is lower than that of BaFea20~9, the saturation magnetization of Zn2W at room temperature is substantially higher than that of any other hexagonal compounds. For this reason, Zn2W has been of interest for special applications as permanent magnet materials (Lotgering et al. 1980). According to Albanese et al. (1977), /{-1 of Zn2W decreases linearly with increasing substitution of AI for Fe in its structure. The experimental values of/{1,
~o.3 X
%U
2
%
i
(a)
X
0
100
200
300
/*00
500
600
T(K)
_<.~15
HA
I
I
x
(b) s
3=
0
~.
~00
200
300
zoo
soo
600
T(K)
Fig. 14. Temperature dependence of the first anisotropy constant KI and of magnetic anisotropy field HA for Zn2W (Albanese et al. 1976b).
PROPERTIES OF FERROXPLANA-TYPE H E X A G O N A L FERRITES
413
/£2 and K3 are shown in fig. 15 as a function of temperature for a BaZnl.38Co0.62Fea6027, (ZnCo)W, single crystal. In addition, there were studies on the crystalline anisotropy of (CoxFe2-x)W by Bickford (1960b), by Lotgering et al. (1961) and Perekalina (1964); on the crystalline anisotropy field of Zn2W, Ni2W, NiZnW, (ZnxNi2-x)W, (Nil.sCo0.4)W and (Nil.26Co0.74)W by Hodges and Harrison (1964), (Ni2_xCo~)W by Rodrique et al. (1962). The dependence of the anisotropy on the Cu content and on temperature for Ba2Zn2-2xCu2,Fe12022, (Zn2-2xCu2x)Y, polycrystalline samples was evaluated by Albanese et al. (1978) assuming the Stoner and Wohlfarth model (1948) using a p a r a m e t e r H A defined as the field at which the magnetization reaches 95.4% of its saturation value in the planar phase or, 91.3% for the axial configuration. The temperature dependence of HA for (Zn2-2xCu2~)Y is shown in fig. 16. The introduction of the Cu ions strongly influenced the magnetocrystalline anisotropy. Smirnovskaya et al. (1978) measured the magnetic anisotropy of Ba2COl.ysZn0.2sFe12022, (Col.75Zn0.25)Y, single crystals in the temperature range 78-290 K. The measurements carried out in various magnetic fields up to 20 kOe for three crystallographic planes; the basal plane, the plane (0110) and (1210). Figure 17 shows the torque curves of (Col.75Zn0.25)Yin the (0110) plane and the basal plane. The torque curve measured in the basal plane at 78 K in a field of 20 kOe is shown in fig. 17(a). It follows from this curve that the easy magnetization directions in the basal plane meet at angles of 60° and that they lie along the crystallographic direction [1010], [1100] and [0110]. Figure 17(b) gives the torque curves obtained at 78, 140 and 175 K in magnetic fields of 5, 10 and 20 kOe in the (0110) plane. Furthermore, there are many experiments on the torque anisotropy measurements for Co2Y and Co2Z by
K;...___ f
E
g o
0
I
gE o
to
o
.,e"
-1
-2
-3
/ 200
40O
6O0
T (K)
Fig. 15. Temperature dependence of anisotropy constants K~, K 2 a n d K3for (ZnCo)W(Asti et al. 1978).
414
M. SUGIMOTO 25
(Z
2-2X C u 2 x ) Y
, X=l
20 \
15
X=7
x
"10 ×=0 1-
0 0
ioo
20o
3o0
T(K)
Fig. 16. Temperature dependence of anisotropy field HA for various x values (Albanese et al. 1978).
Bickford (1960a) as well as the crystalline anisotropy field for Zn2Y, C02Y, Mg2Y and Ni2Y by Smit and Wijn (1959). The temperature dependence of the first-order anisotropy constant/£1 and the second-order constant K: for Ba3Co2Fe24041, CozZ compound is shown in fig. 18. According to Rinaldi and Asti (1976), a positive cubic first-order anisotropy due to Co 2+ ions in octahedral sites probably gives a negative contribution to K1 and a positive contribution to K2. It seems reasonable to assume that K2 is essentially due to cobalt ions, because K2 is nearly zero for all the hexagonal ferrites not containing cobalt. The transition from planar to axial configurations can be interpreted by taking into account the various sublattices whose magnetizations have different temperature dependences for K~, At low temperatures the prevailing contribution to K1 is probably from Co 2+ ions occupying the 2dv sublattice. Figure 19 shows the complete magnetization loop and a section of it with some inner curves of polycrystalline Ba3Co~.75Zn0.2sFe24041, (CoxZn2_x)Z measured at a temperature of 4.2 K. The measurements were carried out in several cycles with increasing field amplitude in the positive field range. The recurrent curves show that irreversible processes occur when the sample is magnetized up to above 13'. Moreover, fig. 20 gives magnetization curves of a grain-oriented sample of the same composition. This constricted Perminvar-type hysteresis loop may be interpreted by a reversible rectifier characteristic induced in single domain particles with conar anisotropy. 13a2Zn2Fe28046(Zn2X) exhibits a uniaxial anisotropy at all temperature and
P R O P E R T I E S OF F E R R O X P L A N A - T Y P E H E X A G O N A L F E R R I T E S
[10~01 I
I
111201 [01101 ]
I
L
]
I
[1210l
I
I
]
415
111001
I
]
(a)
I
0 10 20 30 /.0 50 60 70 80 90100110120 ~P ( d e g r e e )
~
0 -¢.0
~-
-
-ao
o
120 80
J
E
D
, , ~
/.,0 0 -40 -80 -120
t
8090100110
I
L
I
80 90100110 -0" (degree)
\.F I
I
(b)
I
8090 100110
Fig. 17. Torque curves in the (0iI0) plane for Col.75Y. (A) 20 kOe, (B) 10 kOe, (C) 5 kOe, all at T = 78 K, (D) 140 K, (E) 160 K, (F) 175 K, all in H = 20 kOe (Smirnovskaya et al. 1978).
%
3
0
-1 200
z,O0
600
T (K) Fig. 18. Temperature dependence of crystalline anisotropy constants K1 and K2 for Co2Z (Albanese et al. 1976a).
416
M. S U G I M O T O
revemib
,4-"
~
" 250
-
o ";
/
/
/"
<
/
/ /
T=4.2 K
PB'/'~
. ~eversible ~
.
.
/
.
%3 S ~21-
200
150
0
1 H (kOe [,,t061(z, TT) Alrn]
20
Fig. 19. Magnetization curve of isotropic polycrystalline sample (Col.75Zn0.25)Y, T = 4.2 K (Oerling 1970).
Ea=K~sin20. Figure 21 shows the temperature dependence of the magnetocrystalline anisotropy constant K~ for Zn2X or C02X which was obtained by evaluating HAMs~2 (Tauber et al. 1970). At room temperature the c-axis of Ba2Co2Fe28046(Co2X) is the hard direction and (0001) the easy. The anisotropy energy is given as follows: EA = K~ sin 2 0 + K2 s i n 4 0
+
K~ s i n 3 0
c o s 0 c o s 3q~ 2 .
(2)
At about 416 K, however, E A = K 1 sin20 and the c-axis becomes the easy direction and [0001] the hard. Silber and Tsantes (1969) made measurement of the magnetocrystalline anisotropy of single crystals of BazZn2Fe2,O46(ZnzX) and BazCo2FezsO46(CozX) by the ferromagnetic resonance method at room temperature. At room temperature, the one-ion Slonczewski theory (1958) accounted rather well for the change in anisotropy on substitution of cobalt for zinc in X-type compounds. The higher order anisotropy constants observed in the cobalt-bearing samples can be unambiguously attributed to the cobalt ions. In fig. 22 the dependence of the anisotropy constants on temperature for CoZnX is shown. The temperature dependence of the crystalline anisotropy constant/£1 and the anisotropy field HA for Ba4Zn2Fe36Or0(Zn2U) crystal is shown in fig. 23. KI was calculated from H A and Ms at different temperature. A rapid variation of/£1 with increasing temperature is seen. The constancy of H A for a wide range of
PROPERTIES OF FERROXPLANA-TYPE H E X A G O N A L FERRITES
o
417
2
X
(a) L
t
i
[
~
-1
I
2'0
H (kOe) H//c
~
3
~
2
%
IE 1
-26
(b) I
-,'o
I
10 15 20 -1
-2
'~ 3 % 2
H (kOe)
HLc
S
:E I I
-20 -1~5
(c)
I
- 1'0
1(3 15
- 5 -I
-2
J
20
H (kOe)
HAc
-3
Fig. 20. Magnetization curves of grain oriented (Co1.75Zn0.25)Y, T = 4.2 K. (a) a = 0°, (b) a = 45 °, (c) a = 90°. a is the angle between the c-axis and the direction of applied field (Gerling 1970).
418
M. SUGIMOTO 100
~
I
'
I
'
r
r
25
20
8O 1 (C02X)
o
<
~ 6o i.I
2 ~0 o
5
~ 20
o
0 0
400
200
600
T (K)
Fig. 21. Temperature dependence of crystalline anisotropy constant K1 and anisotropy field HA of Zn2X and Coax (Tauber et al. 1970).
1.2
~E 1.0 ~n~
0.2
K1
0.6
:~"
"~ 0.1
0.0 "200
300 T(K)
~
o . o = ~
I
100
2 -0.4
L00
100
200
S00
T (K)
~ L00
-o.6F 100
200
300
,'-00
T (K)
Fig. 22. Temperature dependence of crystalline anisotropy constants for CoZnX (Silber and Tsantes 1970).
P R O P E R T I E S OF F E R R O X P L A N A - T Y P E H E X A G O N A L
FERRITES
2
2 E
419
-g
u~ O ×
-.i"
E
%
oi
x
% O
HA
x
v I
200
400 T
600
(K)
Fig. 23. Temperature dependence of crystalline anisotropy constant K1 and anisotropy field HA for Zn2U (Kerecman et al. 1968).
i
I
i
I
I
4
12 K2
E
0
10
u
E
~o -0.5
z~
8
~
-~.0
\
- 1.5
-~
-zo
HA
6
"~
z,
o
2
:Z" i
0
I
l
100
200 T
L
300
K)
Fig. 24. Temperature dependence of crystalline amsotropy constants K1 and/<2, and anisotropy field HA for Zn2-18H (Tauber et al. 1971).
420
M. SUGIMOTO
temperatures may be due to the proportional change in K1 and Ms. BasZn2Ti3FelzO31(Znz-18H), B asMg2Ti3Fe12031(Mg2-18H), B aSll(Nil.lCUo.4)Ti2.7Fe]z3Mn0.4031(NiCu-18H) and Bas.a(Mgl.3Zn0.7)Ti2.9Fen.7031(MgZn-18H) exhibit an easy plane of magnetization at all temperatures except for N i C u - 1 8 H and their anisotropy energy is EA = K1 sin 2 0 + K2 sin 4 0. T h e anisotropy constants K1 i
i
I
r
i
4
2
,10
K~ "-.
f
go_
7 \ <
8~
x
~-2