H ANDBOOK OF M ATHEMATICAL F LUID DYNAMICS Volume I
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
H ANDBOOK OF M ATHEMATICAL F LUID DYNAMICS Volume I Edited by
S. FRIEDLANDER University of Illinois-Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA
D. SERRE Ecole Normale Supérieure de Lyon, Lyon, France
2002 ELSEVIER Amsterdam • Boston • London • New York • Oxford • Paris • San Diego • San Francisco • Singapore • Sydney • Tokyo
ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V. Sara Burgerhartstraat 25 P.O. Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands © 2002 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. This work is protected under copyright by Elsevier Science, and the following terms and conditions apply to its use: Photocopying: Single photocopies of single chapters may be made for personal use as allowed by national copyright laws. Permission of the Publisher and payment of a fee is required for all other photocopying, including multiple or systematic copying, copying for advertising or promotional purposes, resale, and all forms of document delivery. Special rates are available for educational institutions that wish to make photocopies for non-profit educational classroom use. Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier Science Global Rights Department, PO Box 800, Oxford OX5 1DX, UK; phone: (+44) 1865 843830, fax: (+44) 1865 853333, e-mail:
[email protected]. You may also contact Global Rights directly through Elsevier’s home page (http://www.elsevier.com), by selecting ‘Obtaining Permissions’. In the USA, users may clear permissions and make payments through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA; phone: (+1) 978 7508400, fax: (+1) 978 7504744, and in the UK through the Copyright Licensing Agency Rapid Clearance Service (CLARCS), 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P 0LP, UK; phone: (+44) 207 631 5555; fax: (+44) 207 631 5500. Other countries may have a local reprographic rights agency for payments. Derivative Works: Tables of contents may be reproduced for internal circulation, but permission of Elsevier Science is required for external resale or distribution of such material. Permission of the Publisher is required for all other derivative works, including compilations and translations. Electronic Storage or Usage: Permission of the Publisher is required to store or use electronically any material contained in this work, including any chapter or part of a chapter. Except as outlined above, no part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission of the Publisher. Address permissions requests to: Elsevier Science Global Rights Department, at the mail, fax and e-mail addresses noted above. Notice: No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made.
ISBN: 0-444-50330-7 First edition 2002 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Handbook of mathematical fluid dynamics/edited by S.J. Friedlander, D. Serre. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-444-50330-7 1. Fluid dynamics. I. Friedlander, S. J. II. Serre, D. (Denis) QA911 .H34 2002 532’.05–dc21 2002019382 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Handbook of mathematical fluid dynamics Vol. 1 edited by S.J. Friedlander, D. Serre 1. Fluid dynamics – Mathematics I. Friedlander, Susan, 1946 – II. Serre, D. (Denis) III. Mathematical fluid dynamics 532’.05’0151 ISBN: 0444503307 ∞ The paper used in this publication meets the requirements of ANSI/NISO Z39.48-1992 (Permanence of Paper).
Printed in The Netherlands.
Preface
The motion of fluids has intrigued scientists since antiquity and we may say that the field of mathematical fluid dynamics originated more than two centuries ago. In 1755 Euler [2] gave a mathematical formulation of the principle of conservation of mass in terms of a partial differential equation. In 1823 Cauchy [1] described conservation of linear and angular momentum by PDEs. Material symmetry and frame invariance were used by Cauchy [1] and Poisson [9] to reduce the constitutive equations. The dissipative effects of internal frictional forces were modeled mathematically by Navier [8], Poisson [9], SaintVenant [11] and Stokes [12]. In the 19th century no sharp distinction was drawn between mathematicians and physicists as we sometime see in more recent times. The formulation of the equations of fluid motion could be considered as either mathematics or physics. The first work in fluid dynamics that has a “modern” mathematical flavor may have been done by Riemann in 1860 on isothermal gas dynamics [10]. He raised and solved the eponymous problem. Riemann recognized the mathematical nature of the entropy. This notion led him to his duality method for solving the non-characteristic Cauchy problem for linear hyperbolic equations. Surprisingly, his paper did not generate the immediate interest of his contemporaries. What we now call the Cauchy problem for a PDE and the search for its solution did not have the significance that it is accorded nowadays. Even Poincaré did not raise that kind of question in his Théorie des tourbillons. For this reason, the birth of Mathematical Fluid Dynamics, in the sense that is commonly accepted nowadays, must be dated circa 1930. Local-in-time existence of solutions for the Euler equation of incompressible perfect fluids is proved by Lichtenstein [5] in 1925/28. Then in 1933 Wolibner [13] proves their persistence. Last, Leray’s fundamental analysis of the Navier–Stokes equations for an incompressible fluid is published in 1934 [3]. As much as Riemann, Leray developed new mathematical tools which proved to have independent interest: e.g., weak solutions (that we now call Leray’s solutions in this context) and topological degree (a joint work with Schauder [4]). Since the 1930s, the interest that mathematicians devote to fluid dynamics has unceasingly increased. Leading people, such as J. Hadamard, A.N. Kolmogorov, J. von Neumann and J. Nash made decisive contributions. In 1994, P.-L. Lions was awarded a Fields medal after his breakthrough on the Boltzmann equation (with R. DiPerna) and on the Navier–Stokes system of an isentropic fluid (see, for instance, [6]). Today, the topic displays such a variety of models and questions that thousands of scientists, among them many mathematicians, focus their research on fluid dynamics. v
vi
Preface
Because of the intense activity and the rapid increase of our knowledge, it appeared desirable to set up a landmark. Named “The Handbook of Mathematical Fluid Dynamics”, it is a collection of refereed review articles written by some of the very best specialists in their discipline. The authors were also chosen for the high quality of their expository style. We, the editors, are much indebted to our colleagues who enthusiastically accepted this challenge, and who made great efforts to write for a wide audience. We also thank the referees who worked hard to ensure the excellent quality of the articles. Of course, the length of these articles varies considerably since each topic can be narrow or wide. A few of them have the appearance of a small book. Their authors deserve special thanks, for the immense work that they achieved and for their generosity in choosing to publish their work in this Handbook. At the begining of our editorial work, we decided to restrict the contents to mathematical aspects of fluid dynamics, avoiding to a large extent the physical and the numerical aspects. We highly respect these facets of fluid dynamics and we encouraged the authors to describe the physical meaning of their mathematical results and questions. But we considered that the physics and the numerics were extremely well developed in other collections of a similar breadth (see, for instance, several articles in the Handbook of Numerical Analysis, Elsevier, edited by P. Ciarlet and J.-L. Lions). Furthermore, if we had made a wider choice, our editing work would have been an endless task! This has been our only restriction. We have tried to cover many kinds of fluid models, including ones that are rarefied, compressible, incompressible, viscous or inviscid, heat conducting, capillary, perfect or real, coupled with solid mechanics or with electromagnetism. We have also included many kinds of questions: the Cauchy problem, steady flows, boundary value problems, stability issues, turbulence, etc. These lists are by no mean exhaustive. We were only limited in some places by the lack, at present, of mathematical theories. Our first volume is more or less specialized to compressible issues. There might be valid mathematical, historical or physical reasons to explain such a choice, arguing, for instance, for the priority of Riemann’s work, or that kinetic models are at the very source of almost all other fluid models under various limiting regimes. The truth is more fortuitous, namely that the authors writing on compressible issues were the most prompt in delivering their articles in final form. The second and third volumes will be primarily devoted to problems arising in incompressible flows. Last, but not least, we thank the Editors at Elsevier, who gave us the opportunity of making available a collection of articles that we hope will be useful to many mathematicians and those beyond the mathematical community. We are also happy to thank Sylvie Benzoni-Gavage for her invaluable assistance. Chicago, Lyon September 2001 Susan Friedlander and Denis Serre
[email protected] [email protected]
Preface
vii
References [1] A.-L. Cauchy, Bull. Soc. Philomathique (1823), 9–13; Exercices de Mathématiques 2 (1827), 42–56, 108– 111; 4 (1829), 293–319. [2] L. Euler, Mém. Acad. Sci. Berlin 11 (1755), 274–315; 15 (1759), 210–240. [3] J. Leray, J. Math. Pures Appl. 12 (1933), 1–82; 13 (1934), 331–418; Acta Math. 63 (1934), 193–248. [4] J. Leray and J. Schauder, Ann. Sci. Ecole Norm. Sup. (3) 51 (1934), 45–78. [5] L. Lichtenstein, Math. Z. 23 (1925), 89–154; 26 (1926), 196–323; 28 (1928), 387–415; 32 (1930), 608–725. [6] P.-L. Lions, Mathematical Topics in Fluid Mechanics, Vols. 1, 2, Oxford Univ. Press (1998). [7] J. Nash, Bull. Soc. Math. France 90 (1962), 487–497. [8] C.L.M.H. Navier, Mém. Acad. Sci. Inst. France 6 (1822), 375–394. [9] S.D. Poisson, J. Ecole Polytechnique 13 (1831), 1–174. [10] B. Riemann, Gött. Abh. Math. Cl. 8 (1860), 43–65. [11] B. de Saint-Venant, C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris 17 (1843). [12] G.G. Stokes, Trans. Cambridge Philos. Soc. 8 (1849), 207–319. [13] W. Wolibner, Math. Z. 37 (1933), 698–726.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
List of Contributors Blokhin, A., Sobolev Institute of Mathematics, Novosibirsk, Russia (Ch. 6) Cercignani, C., Politecnico di Milano, Milano, Italy (Ch. 1) Chen, G.-Q., Northwestern University, Evanston, IL (Ch. 5) Fan, H., Georgetown University, Washington DC (Ch. 4) ˇ Praha, Czech Republic (Ch. 3) Feireisl, E., Institute of Mathematics AV CR, Galdi, G.P., University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA (Ch. 7) Slemrod, M., University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, WI (Ch. 4) Trakhinin, Yu., Sobolev Institute of Mathematics, Novosibirsk, Russia (Ch. 6) Villani, C., UMPA, ENS Lyon, Lyon, France (Ch. 2) Wang, D., University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA (Ch. 5)
ix
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Contents Preface List of Contributors
v ix
1. The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics C. Cercignani 2. A review of mathematical topics in collisional kinetic theory C. Villani 3. Viscous and/or heat conducting compressible fluids E. Feireisl 4. Dynamic flows with liquid/vapor phase transitions H. Fan and M. Slemrod 5. The Cauchy problem for the Euler equations for compressible fluids G.-Q. Chen and D. Wang 6. Stability of strong discontinuities in fluids and MHD A. Blokhin and Y. Trakhinin 7. On the motion of a rigid body in a viscous liquid: a mathematical analysis with applications G.P. Galdi
1
Author Index Subject Index
71 307 373 421 545
653
793 807
xi
CHAPTER 1
The Boltzmann Equation and Fluid Dynamics C. Cercignani Dipartimento di Matematica, Politecnico di Milano, Milano, Italy
Contents 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. The basic molecular model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. The Boltzmann equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Molecules different from hard spheres . . . . . . . . . . 5. Collision invariants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. The Boltzmann inequality and the Maxwell distributions 7. The macroscopic balance equations . . . . . . . . . . . . 8. The H-theorem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9. Model equations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10. The linearized collision operator . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Boundary conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12. The continuum limit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13. Free-molecule and nearly free-molecule flows . . . . . . 14. Perturbations of equilibria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15. Approximate methods for linearized problems . . . . . . 16. Mixtures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17. Polyatomic gases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18. Chemistry and radiation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19. The DSMC method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20. Some applications of the DSMC method . . . . . . . . . 21. Concluding remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
HANDBOOK OF MATHEMATICAL FLUID DYNAMICS, VOLUME I Edited by S.J. Friedlander and D. Serre © 2002 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved 1
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3 4 5 9 10 12 13 17 18 21 22 25 33 36 38 43 46 52 57 61 63 63
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
3
1. Introduction We say that a gas flow is rarefied when the so-called mean free-path of the gas molecules, i.e., the average distance covered by a molecule between to subsequent collisions, is not completely negligible with respect to a typical geometric length (the radius of curvature of the nose of a flying vehicle, the radius of a pipe, etc.). The most remarkable feature of rarefied flows is that the Navier–Stokes equations do not apply. One must then resort to the concepts of kinetic theory of gases and the Navier–Stokes equations must be replaced by the Boltzmann equation [43]. Thus the Boltzmann equation became a practical tool for the aerospace engineers, when they started to remark that flight in the upper atmosphere must face the problem of a decrease in the ambient density with increasing height. This density reduction would alleviate the aerodynamic forces and heat fluxes that a flying vehicle would have to withstand. However, for virtually all missions, the increase of altitude is accompanied by an increase in speed; thus it is not uncommon for spacecraft to experience its peak heating at considerable altitudes, such as, e.g., 70 km. When the density of a gas decreases, there is, of course, a reduction of the number of molecules in a given volume and, what is more important, an increase in the distance between two subsequent collisions of a given molecule, till one may well question the validity of the Euler and Navier–Stokes equations, which are usually introduced on the basis of a continuum model which does not take into account the molecular nature of a gas. It is to be remarked that, as we shall see, the use of those equations can also be based on the kinetic theory of gases, which justifies them as asymptotically useful models when the mean free path is negligible. In the area of environmental problems, the Boltzmann equation is also required. Understanding and controlling the formation, motion, reactions and evolution of particles of varying composition and shapes, ranging from a diameter of the order of 0.001 µm to 50 µm, as well as their space-time distribution under gradients of concentration, pressure, temperature and the action of radiation, has grown in importance, because of the increasing awareness of the local and global problems related to the emission of particles from electric power plants, chemical plants, vehicles as well as of the role played by small particles in the formation of fog and clouds, in the release of radioactivity from nuclear reactor accidents, and in the problems arising from the exhaust streams of aerosol reactors, such as those used to produce optical fibers, catalysts, ceramics, silicon chips and carbon whiskers. One cubic centimeter of atmospheric air at ground level contains approximately 2.5 × 1019 molecules. About a thousand of them may be charged (ions). A typical molecular diameter is 3 × 10−10 m (3×10−4 µm) and the average distance between the molecules is about ten times as much. The mean free path is of the order of 10−8 m, or 10−2 µm. In addition to molecules and ions one cubic centimeter of air also contains a significant number of particles varying in size, as indicated above. In relatively clean air, the number of these particles can be 105 or more, including pollen, bacteria, dust, and industrial emissions. They can be both beneficial and detrimental, and arise from a number of natural sources as well as from the activities of all living organisms, especially humans. The particles can have complex chemical compositions and shapes, and may even be toxic or radioactive.
4
C. Cercignani
A suspension of particles in a gas is known as an aerosol. Atmospheric aerosols are of global interest and have important impact on our lives. Aerosols are also of great interest in numerous scientific and engineering applications [175]. A third area of application of rarefied gas dynamics has emerged in the last quarter of the twentieth century. Small size machines, called micromachines, are being designed and built. Their typical sizes range from a few microns to a few millimiters. Rarefied flow phenomena that are more or less laboratory curiosities in machines of more usual size can form the basis of important systems in the micromechanical domain. A further area of interest occurs in the vacuum industry. Although this area existed for a long time, the expense of the early computations with kinetic theory precluded applications of numerical methods. The latter could develop only in the context of the aerospace industry, because the big budgets required till recently were available only there. The basic parameter measuring the degree of rarefaction of a gas is the Knudsen number (Kn), the ratio between the mean free path λ and another typical length. Of course, one can consider several Knudsen numbers, based on different characteristic lengths, exactly as one does for the Reynolds number. Thus, in the flow past a body, there are two important macroscopic lengths: the local radius of curvature and the thickness of the viscous boundary layer δ, and one can consider Knudsen numbers based on either length. Usually the second one (Knδ = λ/δ), gives the most severe restriction to the use of Navier– Stokes equations in aerospace applications. When Kn is larger than (say) 0.01, the presence of a thin layer near the wall, of thickness of the order λ (Knudsen layer), influences the viscous profile in a significant way. This and other effects are of interest in both high altitude flight and aerosol science; in particular they are all met by a shuttle when returning to Earth. Another phenomenon of importance is the formation of shock waves, which are not discontinuity surfaces, but thin layers (the thickness is zero only if the Euler model is adopted). When the mean free path increases, one witnesses a thickening of the shock waves, whose thickness is of the order of 6λ. The bow shock in front of a body merges with the viscous boundary layer; that is why this regime is sometimes called the merged layer regime by aerodynamicists. We shall use the other frequently used name of transition regime. When Kn is large (few collisions), phenomena related to gas-surface interaction play an important role. They enter the theory in the form of boundary conditions for the Boltzmann equation. One distinguishes between free-molecule and nearly free-molecule regimes. In the first case the molecular collisions are completely negligible, while in the second they can be treated as a perturbation.
2. The basic molecular model According to kinetic theory, a gas in normal conditions (no chemical reactions, no ionization phenomena, etc.) is formed of elastic molecules rushing hither and thither at high speed, colliding and rebounding according to the laws of elementary mechanics. Monatomic molecules of a gas are frequently assumed to be hard, elastic, and perfectly smooth spheres. One can also consider these molecules to be centers of forces that move
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
5
according to the laws of classical mechanics. More complex models are needed to describe polyatomic molecules. The rules generating the dynamics of many spheres are easy to describe: thus, e.g., if no body forces, such as gravity, are assumed to act on the molecules, each of them will move in a straight line unless it happens to strike another molecule or a solid wall. The phenomena associated with this dynamics are not so simple, especially when the number of spheres is large. It turns out that this complication is always present when dealing with a gas, because the number of molecules usually considered is extremely large: there are about 2.7 · 1019 in a cubic centimeter of a gas at atmospheric pressure and a temperature of 0 ◦ C. Given the vast number of particles to be considered, it would of course be a hopeless task to attempt to describe the state of the gas by specifying the so-called microscopic state, i.e., the position and velocity of every individual sphere; we must have recourse to statistics. A description of this kind is made possible because in practice all that our typical observations can detect are changes in the macroscopic state of the gas, described by quantities such as density, bulk velocity, temperature, stresses, heat-flow, which are related to some suitable averages of quantities depending on the microscopic state.
3. The Boltzmann equation The exact dynamics of N particles is a useful conceptual tool, but cannot in any way be used in practical calculations because it requires a huge number of real variables (of the order of 1020). The basic tool is the one-particle probability density, or distribution function P (1) (x, ξ , t). The latter is a function of seven variables, i.e., the components of the two vectors x and ξ and time t. Let us consider the meaning of P (1) (x, ξ , t); it gives the probability density of finding one fixed particle (say, the one labelled by 1) at a certain point (x, ξ ) of the six-dimensional reduced phase space associated with the position and velocity of that molecule. In order to simplify the treatment, we shall for the moment assume that the molecules are hard spheres, whose center has position x. When the molecules collide, momentum and kinetic energy must be conserved; thus the velocities after the impact, ξ 1 and ξ 2 , are related to those before the impact, ξ 1 and ξ 2 , by ξ 1 = ξ 1 − n n · (ξ 1 − ξ 2 ) , ξ 2 = ξ 2 + n n · (ξ 1 − ξ 2 ) ,
(3.1)
where n is the unit vector along ξ 1 − ξ 1 . Note that the relative velocity V = ξ1 − ξ2
(3.2)
V = V − 2n(n · V),
(3.3)
satisfies
6
C. Cercignani
i.e., undergoes a specular reflection at the impact. This means that if we split V at the point of impact into a normal component Vn , directed along n and a tangential component Vt (in the plane normal to n), then Vn changes sign and Vt remains unchanged in a collision. We can also say that n bisects the directions of V and −V = −(ξ 1 − ξ 2 ). Let us remark that, in the absence of collisions, P (1) would remain unchanged along the trajectory of a particle. Accordingly we must evaluate the effects of collisions on the time evolution of P (1) . Note that the probability of occurrence of a collision is related to the probability of finding another molecule with a center at exactly one diameter from the center of the first one, whose distribution function is P (1) . Thus, generally speaking, in order to write the evolution equation for P (1) we shall need another function, P (2) , which gives the probability density of finding, at time t, the first molecule at x1 with velocity ξ 1 and the second at x2 with velocity ξ 2 ; obviously P (2) = P (2) (x1 , x2 , ξ 1 , ξ 2 , t). Hence P (1) satisfies an equation of the following form: ∂P (1) ∂P (1) + ξ1 · = G − L. ∂t ∂x1
(3.4)
Here L dx1 dξ 1 dt gives the expected number of particles with position between x1 and x1 +dx1 and velocity between ξ 1 and ξ 1 +dξ 1 which disappear from these ranges of values because of a collision in the time interval between t and t + dt and G dx1 dξ 1 dt gives the analogous number of particles entering the same range in the same time interval. The count of these numbers is easy, provided we use the trick of imagining particle 1 as a sphere at rest and endowed with twice the actual diameter σ and the other particles to be point masses with velocity (ξ i − ξ 1 ) = Vi . In fact, each collision will send particle 1 out of the above range and the number of the collisions of particle 1 will be the number of expected collisions of any other particle with that sphere. Since there are exactly (N − 1) identical point masses and multiple collisions are disregarded, G = (N − 1)g and L = (N − 1)l, where the lower case letters indicate the contribution of a fixed particle, say particle 2. We shall then compute the effect of the collisions of particle 2 with particle 1. Let x2 be a point of the sphere such that the vector joining the center of the sphere with x2 is σ n, where n is a unit vector. A cylinder with height |V · n| dt (where we write just V for V2 ) and base area dS = σ 2 dn (where dn is the area of a surface element of the unit sphere about n) will contain the particles with velocity ξ 2 hitting the base dS in the time interval (t, t + dt); its volume is σ 2 dn|V · n| dt. Thus the number of collisions of particle 2 with particle 1 in the ranges (x1 , x1 + dx1), (ξ 1 , ξ 1 + dξ 1 ), (x2 , x2 + dx2), (ξ 2 , ξ 2 + dξ 2 ), (t, t + dt) occuring at points of dS is P (2) (x1 , x2 , ξ 1 , ξ 2 , t) dx1 dξ 1 dξ 2 σ 2 dn|V2 · n| dt. If we want the number of collisions of particle 1 with 2, when the range of the former is fixed but the latter may have any velocity ξ 2 and any position x2 on the sphere (i.e., any n), we integrate over the sphere and all the possible velocities of particle 2 to obtain: l dx1 dξ 1 dt = dx1 dξ 1 dt
R 3 B−
P (2) (x1 , x1 + σ n, ξ 1 , ξ 2 , t)|V · n|σ 2 dn dξ 2 ,
(3.5)
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
7
where B − is the hemisphere corresponding to V · n < 0 (the particles are moving one toward the other before the collision). Thus we have the following result: L = (N − 1)σ 2
R 3 B−
P (2) (x1 , x1 + σ n, ξ 1 , ξ 2 , t)(ξ 2 − ξ 1 ) · n dξ 2 dn. (3.6)
The calculation of the gain term G is exactly the same as the one for L, except for the fact that we have to integrate over the hemisphere B + , defined by V · n > 0 (the particles are moving away one from the other after the collision). Thus we have: G = (N − 1)σ 2
R 3 B+
P (2) (x1 , x1 + σ n, ξ 1 , ξ 2 , t)(ξ 2 − ξ 1 ) · n dξ 2 dn. (3.7)
We can now insert in Equation (3.4) the information that the probability density P (2) is continuous at a collision; in other words, although the velocities of the particles undergo the discontinuous change described by Equations (3.1), we can write: P (2) (x1 , ξ 1 , x2 , ξ 2 , t) = P (2) x1 , ξ 1 − n(n · V), x2 , ξ 2 + n(n · V), t if |x1 − x2 | = σ.
(3.8)
For brevity, we write (in agreement with Equations (3.1)): ξ 1 = ξ 1 − n(n · V),
ξ 2 = ξ 2 + n(n · V).
(3.9)
Inserting Equation (3.8) in Equation (3.5) we thus obtain: G = (N − 1)σ 2
R 3 B+
P (2) (x1 , x1 + σ n, ξ 1 , ξ 2 , t)(ξ 2 − ξ 1 ) · n dξ 2 dn (3.10)
which is a frequently used form. Sometimes n is changed into −n in order to have the same integration range as in L; the only change (in addition to the change in the range) is in the second argument of P (2) , which becomes x1 − σ n. At this point we are ready to understand Boltzmann’s argument. N is a very large number and σ (expressed in common units, such as, e.g., centimeters) is very small; to fix the ideas, let us consider a box whose volume is 1 cm3 at room temperature and atmospheric pressure. Then N ∼ = Nσ 2 ∼ = 104 cm2 = 1 m2 is a sizable = 1020 and σ ∼ = 10−8 cm. Then (N − 1)σ 2 ∼ quantity, while we can neglect the difference between x1 and x1 + σ n. This means that the equation to be written can be rigorously valid only in the so called Boltzmann–Grad limit, when N → ∞, σ → 0 with Nσ 2 finite.
8
C. Cercignani
In addition, the collisions between two preselected particles are rather rare events. Thus two spheres that happen to collide can be thought to be two randomly chosen particles and it makes sense to assume that the probability density of finding the first molecule at x1 with velocity ξ 1 and the second at x2 with velocity ξ 2 is the product of the probability density of finding the first molecule at x1 with velocity ξ 1 times the probability density of finding the second molecule at x2 with velocity ξ 2 . If we accept this we can write (assumption of molecular chaos): P (2) (x1 , ξ 1 , x2 , ξ 2 , t) = P (1) (x1 , ξ 1 , t)P (1) (x2 , ξ 2 , t)
(3.11)
for two particles that are about to collide, or, letting σ = 0 P (2) (x1 , ξ 1 , x1 + σ n, ξ 2 , t) = P (1) (x1 , ξ 1 , t)P (1) (x1 , ξ 2 , t) for (ξ 2 − ξ 1 ) · n < 0.
(3.12)
Thus we can apply this recipe to the loss term (3.4) but not to the gain term in the form (3.5). It is possible, however, to apply Equation (3.12) (with ξ 1 , ξ 2 in place of ξ 1 , ξ 2 ) to the form (3.8) of the gain term, because the transformation (3.9) maps the hemisphere B + onto the hemisphere B − . If we accept all the simplifying assumptions made by Boltzmann, we obtain the following form for the gain and loss terms: P (1) (x1 , ξ 1 , t)P (1) (x1 , ξ 2 , t)(ξ 2 − ξ 1 ) · n dξ 2 dn, (3.13) G = Nσ 2 L = Nσ
R 3 B−
2 R 3 B−
P (1) (x1 , ξ 1 , t)P (1) (x1 , ξ 2 , t)(ξ 2 − ξ 1 ) · n dξ 2 dn.
(3.14)
By inserting these expressions in Equation (3.6) we can write the Boltzmann equation in the following form: ∂P (1) ∂P (1) + ξ1 · ∂t ∂x1 (1) = Nσ 2 P (x1 , ξ 1 , t)P (1) (x1 , ξ 2 , t) R 3 B−
−P
(1)
(x1 , ξ 1 , t)P (1) (x1 , ξ 2 , t) (ξ 2 − ξ 1 ) · n dξ 2 dn.
(3.15)
We remark that the expressions for ξ 1 and ξ 2 given in Equations (3.1) are by no means the only possible ones. In fact we might use a different unit vector ω, directed as V , instead of n. Then Equations (3.1) is replaced by: 1 ξ 1 = ξ¯ + |ξ 1 − ξ 2 |ω, 2 1 ξ 2 = ξ¯ − |ξ 1 − ξ 2 |ω, 2
(3.16)
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
9
where ξ¯ = 12 (ξ 1 + ξ 2 ) is the velocity of the center of mass. The relative velocity V satisfies V = ω|V|.
(3.17)
The recipes (3.13) and (3.14) can be justified at various levels of rigor [36,113,39,47]. We finally mention that we have for simplicity neglected any body force acting on the molecules, such as gravity. It is not hard to take them into account; if the force per unit mass acting on the molecules is denoted by X, then a term X · ∂P (1) /∂ξ 1 must be added to the left-hand side of Equation (3.8).
4. Molecules different from hard spheres In the previous section we have discussed the Boltzmann equation when the molecules are assumed to be identical hard spheres. There are several possible generalizations of this molecular model, the most obvious being the case of molecules which are identical point masses interacting with a central force, a good general model for monatomic gases. If the range of the force extends to infinity, there is a complication due to the fact that two molecules are always interacting and the analysis in terms of “collisions” is no longer possible. If, however, the gas is sufficiently dilute, we can take into account that the molecular interaction is negligible for distances larger than a certain σ (the “molecular diameter”) and assume that when two molecules are at a distance smaller than σ , then no other molecule is interacting with them and the binary collision analysis considered in the previous section can be applied. The only difference arises in the factor σ 2 |(ξ 2 − ξ 1 ) · n| which turns out to be replaced by a function of V = |ξ 2 − ξ 1 | and the angle θ between n and V ([39,35,42]). Thus the Boltzmann equation for monatomic molecules takes on the following form: ∂P (1) ∂P (1) + ξ1 · ∂t ∂x1 (1) P (x1 , ξ 1 , t)P (1) (x1 , ξ 2 , t) =N R3
−P
(1)
B−
(x1 , ξ 1 , t)P (1) (x1 , ξ 2 , t) B θ, |ξ 2 − ξ 1 | dξ 2 dθ dε,
(4.1)
where ε is the other angle which, together with θ , identifies the unit vector n. The function B(θ, V ) depends, of course, on the specific law of interaction between the molecules. In the case of hard spheres, of course B θ, |ξ 2 − ξ 1 | = cos θ sin θ |ξ 2 − ξ 1 |.
(4.2)
In spite of the fact that the force is cut at a finite range σ when writing the Boltzmann equation, infinite range forces are frequently used. This has the disadvantage of making the integral in Equation (4.1) rather hard to handle; in fact, one cannot split it into the difference of two terms (the loss and the gain), because each of them would be a divergent
10
C. Cercignani
integral. This disadvantage is compensated in the case of power law forces, because one can separate the dependence on θ from the dependence upon V . In fact, one can show [39, 35] that, if the intermolecular force varies as the n-th inverse power of the distance, then B θ, |ξ 2 − ξ 1 | = β(θ )|ξ 2 − ξ 1 |(n−5)/(n−1),
(4.3)
where β(θ ) is a non-elementary function of θ (in the simplest cases it can be expressed by means of elliptic functions). In particular, for n = 5 one has the so-called Maxwell molecules, for which the dependence on V disappears. Sometimes the artifice of cutting the grazing collisions corresponding to small values of |θ − π/2| is used (angle cutoff). In this case one has both the advantage of being able to split the collision term and of preserving a relation of the form (4.3) for power-law potentials. Since solving of the Boltzmann equation with actual cross sections is complicated, in many numerical simulations use is made of the so-called variable hard sphere model in which the diameter of the spheres is an inverse power law function of the relative speed V (see [43]). Another important case is when we deal with a mixture rather than with a single gas. In this case we have n unknowns, if n is the number of the species, and n Boltzmann equations; in each of them there are n collision terms to describe the collision of a molecule with other molecules of all the possible species [43,39]. If the gas is polyatomic, then the gas molecules have other degrees of freedom in addition to the translation ones. This in principle requires using quantum mechanics, but one can devise useful and accurate models in the classical scheme as well. Frequently the internal energy Ei is the only additional variable that is needed; in which case one can think of the gas as of a mixture of species [43,39], each differing from the other because of the value of Ei . If the latter variable is discrete we obtain a strict analogy with a mixture; otherwise we have a continuum of species. We remark that in both cases, kinetic energy is not preserved by collisions, because internal energy also enters into the balance; this means that a molecule changes its “species” when colliding. This is the simplest example of a “reacting collision”, which may be generalized to actual chemical species when chemical reactions occur. The subject of mixture and polyatomic gases will be taken up again in Section 16.
5. Collision invariants Before embarking in a discussion of the properties of the solutions of the Boltzmann equation we remark that the unknown of the latter is not always chosen to be a probability density as we have done so far; it may be multiplied by a suitable factor and transformed into an (expected) number density or an (expected) mass density (in phase space, of course). The only thing that changes is the factor in front of Equations (3.1) which is no longer N . In order to avoid any commitment to a special choice of that factor we replace NB(θ, V ) by B(θ, V ) and the unknown P by another letter, f (which is also the most commonly used letter to denote the one-particle distribution function, no matter what its
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
11
normalization is). In addition, we replace the current velocity variable ξ 1 simply by ξ and ξ 2 by ξ ∗ . Thus we rewrite Equation (4.1) in the following form: ∂f ∂f +ξ · = ∂t ∂x
B−
R3
(f f∗ − ff∗ )B(θ, V ) dξ ∗ dθ dε,
(5.1)
where V = |ξ − ξ ∗ |. The velocity arguments ξ and ξ ∗ in f and f∗ are of course given by Equations (3.1) (or (3.15)) with the suitable modification. The right-hand side of Equation (5.1) contains a quadratic expression Q(f, f ), given by: Q(f, f ) =
R3
S2
(f f∗ − ff∗ )B(θ, V ) dξ ∗ dθ dε.
(5.2)
This expression is called the collision integral or, simply, the collision term and the quadratic operator Q goes under the name of collision operator. In this section we study some elementary properties of Q. Actually it turns out that it is more convenient to study the slightly more general bilinear expression associated with Q(f, f ), i.e.: 1 Q(f, g) = 2
R3 S 2
(f g∗ + g f∗ − fg∗ − gf∗ )B(θ, V ) dξ ∗ dθ dε.
(5.3)
It is clear that when g = f , Equation (5.3) reduces to Equation (5.2) and Q(f, g) = Q(g, f ).
(5.4)
Our first aim is to indicate a basic property of the eightfold integral: Q(f, g)φ(ξ ) dξ R3
1 = 2
B−
R3 R3
(f g∗ + g f∗ − fg∗ − gf∗ )φ(ξ )B(θ, V ) dξ ∗ dξ dθ dε, (5.5)
where f, g and φ are functions such that the indicated integrals exist and the order of integration does not matter. Simple manipulations (see [43,39,35]) give the following result: Q(f, g)φ(ξ ) dξ R3
1 = 8
R3 R3
B−
(f g∗ + g f∗ − fg∗ − gf∗ )
× (φ + φ∗ − φ − φ∗ )B(θ, V ) dξ ∗ dξ dθ dε.
(5.6)
12
C. Cercignani
This relation expresses a basic property of the collision term, which is frequently used. In particular, when g = f , Equation (5.6) reads Q(f, f )φ(ξ ) dξ R3
=
1 4
R3
R3
B−
(f f∗ − ff∗ )(φ + φ∗ − φ − φ∗ )B(θ, V ) dξ ∗ dξ dθ dε. (5.7)
We now observe that the integral in Equation (5.6) is zero independent of the particular functions f and g, if φ + φ∗ = φ + φ∗
(5.8)
is valid almost everywhere in velocity space. Since the integral appearing in the left-hand side of Equation (5.7) is the rate of change of the average value of the function φ due to collisions, the functions satisfying Equation (5.8) are called “collision invariants”. It can be shown (see, e.g., [39]) that a continuous function φ has the property expressed by Equation (5.8) if and only if φ(ξ ) = a + b · ξ + c|ξ |2 ,
(5.9)
where a and c are constant scalars and b a constant vector. The assumption of continuity can be considerably relaxed [5,40,6]. The functions ψ0 = 1, (ψ1 , ψ2 , ψ3 ) = ξ , ψ4 = |ξ |2 are usually called the elementary collision invariants; they span the five-dimensional subspace of the collision invariants. 6. The Boltzmann inequality and the Maxwell distributions In this section we investigate the existence of positive functions f which give a vanishing collision integral: Q(f, f ) = (f f∗ − ff∗ )B(θ, V ) dξ ∗ dθ dε = 0. (6.1) R 3 B−
In order to solve this equation, we prove a preliminary result which plays an important role in the theory of the Boltzmann equation: if f is a nonnegative function such that log f Q(f, f ) is integrable and the manipulations of the previous section hold when φ = log f , then the Boltzmann inequality: log f Q(f, f ) dξ 0 (6.2) R3
holds; further, the equality sign applies if, and only if, log f is a collision invariant, or, equivalently: f = exp a + b · ξ + c|ξ |2 . (6.3)
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
13
To prove Equation (6.2) it is enough to use Equation (4.11) with φ = log f : log f Q(f, f ) dξ R3
=
1 4
R3
B−
log(ff∗ /f f∗ )(f f∗ − ff∗ )B(θ, V ) dξ dξ ∗ dε
and Equation (6.2) follows thanks to the elementary inequality (z − y) log(y/z) 0 y, z ∈ R + .
(6.4)
(6.5)
Equation (6.5) becomes an equality if and only if y = z; thus the equality sign holds in Equation (6.2) if and only if: f f∗ = ff∗
(6.6)
applies almost everywhere. But, taking the logarithms of both sides of Equation (6.6), we find that φ = log f satisfies Equation (5.8) and is thus given by Equation (5.9). f = exp(φ) is then given by Equation (6.3). We remark that in the latter equation c must be negative, since f must be integrable. If we let c = −β, b = 2βv (where v is another constant vector) Equation (6.3) can be rewritten as follows: f = A exp −β|ξ − v|2 , (6.7) where A is a positive constant related to a, c, |b|2 (β, v, A constitute a new set of constants). The function appearing in Equation (3.7) is the so called Maxwell distribution or Maxwellian. Frequently one considers Maxwellians with v = 0 (nondrifting Maxwellians), which can be obtained from drifting Maxwellians by a change of the origin in velocity space. Let us return now to the problem of solving Equation (6.1). Multiplying both sides by log f gives Equation (6.2) with the equality sign. This implies that f is a Maxwellian, by the result which has just been proved. Suppose now that f is a Maxwellian; then f = exp(φ) where φ is a collision invariant and Equation (6.6) holds; Equation (6.1) then also holds. Thus there are functions which satisfy Equation (6.1) and they are all Maxwellians, Equation (6.7). 7. The macroscopic balance equations In this section we compare the microscopic description supplied by kinetic theory with the macroscopic description supplied by continuum gas dynamics. For definiteness, in this section f will be assumed to be an expected mass density in phase space. In order to obtain a density, ρ = ρ(x, t), in ordinary space, we must integrate f with respect to ξ : ρ= f dξ . (7.1) R3
14
C. Cercignani
The bulk velocity v of the gas (e.g., the velocity of a wind), is the average of the molecular velocities ξ at a certain point x and time instant t; since f is proportional to the probability for a molecule to have a given velocity, v is given by 3 ξ f dξ v = R R 3 f dξ
(7.2)
(the denominator is required even if f is taken to be a probability density in phase space, because we are considering a conditional probability, referring to the position x). Equation (7.2) can also be written as follows: ρv =
R3
ξ f dξ
(7.3)
or, using components: ρvi =
R3
ξi f dξ
(i = 1, 2, 3).
(7.4)
The bulk velocity v is what we can directly perceive of the molecular motion by means of macroscopic observations; it is zero for a gas in equilibrium in a box at rest. Each molecule has its own velocity ξ which can be decomposed into the sum of v and another velocity c=ξ −v
(7.5)
called the random or peculiar velocity; c is clearly due to the deviations of ξ from v. It is also clear that the average of c is zero. The quantity ρvi which appears in Equation (7.4) is the i-th component of the mass flow or, alternatively, of the momentum density of the gas. Other quantities of similar nature are: the momentum flow mij =
R3
ξi ξj f dξ
(i, j = 1, 2, 3);
(7.6)
the energy density per unit volume: w=
1 2
R3
|ξ |2 f dξ ;
(7.7)
the energy flow: 1 ri = 2
R3
ξi |ξ |2 f dξ
(i, j = 1, 2, 3).
(7.8)
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
15
Equation (7.6) shows that the momentum flow is described by the components of a symmetric tensor of second order. The defining integral can be re-expressed in terms of c and v. We have [43,39,35]: mij = ρvi vj + pij ,
(7.9)
where: pij =
R3
ci cj f dξ
(i, j = 1, 2, 3)
(7.10)
plays the role of the stress tensor (because the microscopic momentum flow associated with it is equivalent to forces distributed on the boundary of any region of gas, according to the macroscopic description). Similarly one has [43,39,35]: 1 w = ρ|v|2 + ρe, 2
(7.11)
where e is the internal energy per unit mass (associated with random motions) defined by: 1 ρe = 2
R3
|c|2 f dξ ;
(7.12)
and: ri = ρvi
3 1 2 |v| + e + vj pij + qi 2
(i = 1, 2, 3),
(7.13)
j =1
where qi are the components of the heat-flow vector: qi =
1 2
ci |c|2 f dξ .
(7.14)
3
The decomposition in Equation (7.13) shows that the microscopic energy flow is a sum of a macroscopic flow of energy (both kinetic and internal), of the work (per unit area und unit time) done by stresses, and of the heat-flow. In order to complete the connection, as a simple mathematical consequence of the Boltzmann equation, one can derive five differential relations satisfied by the macroscopic quantities introduced above; these relations describe the balance of mass, momentum and energy and have the same form as in continuum mechanics. To this end let us consider the Boltzmann equation ∂f ∂f +ξ · = Q(f, f ). ∂t ∂x
(7.15)
16
C. Cercignani
If we multiply both sides by one of the elementary collision invariants ψα (α = 0, 1, 2, 3, 4), defined in Section 4, and integrate with respect to ξ , we have, thanks to Equation (1.15) with g = f and φ = ψα : ψα (ξ )Q(f, f ) dξ = 0, (7.16) R3
and hence, if it is permitted to change the order by which we differentiate with respect to t and integrate with respect to ξ : ∂ ∂t
ψα f dξ +
3
∂ ξi ψα f dξ = 0 ∂xi
(α = 1, 2, 3, 4).
(7.17)
i=1
If we take successively α = 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 and use the definitions introduced above, we obtain ∂ρ ∂ + (ρvi ) = 0, ∂t ∂xi 3
(7.18)
i=1
∂ ∂ (ρvj ) + (ρvi vj + pij ) = 0 ∂t ∂xi 3
(j = 1, 2, 3),
(7.19)
i=1
∂ 1 2 ρ|v| + ρe ∂t 2
3 3
1 2 ∂ + ρvi |v| + e + vj pij + qi = 0. ∂xi 2 i=1
(7.20)
j =1
The considerations of this section apply to all the solutions of the Boltzmann equation. The definitions, however, can be applied to any positive function for which they make sense. In particular if we take f to be a Maxwellian in the form (5.7), we find that the constant vector v appearing there is actually the bulk velocity as defined in Equation (7.2) while β and A are related to the internal energy e and the density ρ in the following way: β = 3/(4e),
A = ρ(4πe/3)−3/2.
(7.21)
Furthermore the stress tensor turns out to be diagonal (pij = ( 23 ρe)δij , where δij is the so-called “Kronecker delta” (= 1 if i = j ; = 0 if i = j )), while the heat-flow vector is zero. We end this section with the definition of pressure p in terms of f ; p is nothing else than 1/3 of the spur or trace (i.e., the sum of the three diagonal terms) of pij and is thus given by: 1 p= |c|2 f dξ . (7.22) 3 R3
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
17
If we compare this with the definition of the specific internal energy e, given in Equation (3.11), we obtain the relation: 2 p = ρe. 3
(7.23)
This relation also suggests the definition of temperature, according to kinetic theory, T = ( 23 e)/R, where R is the gas constant equal to the universal Boltzmann constant k divided by the molecular mass m. Thus: T=
1 3ρR
R3
|c|2 f dξ .
(7.24)
8. The H-theorem Let us consider a further application of the properties of the collision term Q(f, f ) of the Boltzmann equation: ∂f ∂f +ξ · = Q(f, f ). ∂t ∂x
(8.1)
If we multiply both sides of this equation by log f and integrate with respect to ξ , we obtain: ∂H ∂ + · J = S, ∂t ∂x
(8.2)
where H=
f log f dξ ,
(8.3)
ξ f log f dξ ,
(8.4)
log f Q(f, f ) dξ .
(8.5)
R3
J=
R3
S=
R3
Equation (8.2) differs from the balance equations considered in the previous section because the right-hand side, generally speaking, does not vanish. We know, however, that the Boltzmann inequality, Equation (5.2), implies: S 0 and S = 0 iff
f is a Maxwellian.
(8.6)
Because of this inequality, Equation (8.2) plays an important role in the theory of the Boltzmann equation. We illustrate the role of Equation (8.6) in the case of space-
18
C. Cercignani
homogeneous solutions. In this case the various quantities do not depend on x and Equation (8.2) reduces to ∂H = S 0. ∂t
(8.7)
This implies the so-called H -theorem (for the space homogeneous case): H is a decreasing quantity, unless f is a Maxwellian (in which case the time derivative of H is zero). Remember now that in this case the densities ρ, ρv and ρe are constant in time; we can thus build a Maxwellian M which has, at any time, the same ρ, v and e as any solution f corresponding to given initial data. Since H decreases unless f is a Maxwellian (i.e., f = M), it is tempting to conclude that f tends to M when t → ∞. This conclusion is, however, unwarranted from a purely mathematical viewpoint, without a more detailed consideration of the source term S in Equation (8.7), for which [47] should be consulted. If the state of the gas is not space-homogeneous, the situation becomes more complicated. In this case it is convenient to introduce the quantity H=
H dx,
(8.8)
Ω
where Ω is the space domain occupied by the gas (assumed here to be time-independent). Then Equation (8.2) implies dH dt
J · n dσ,
(8.9)
∂Ω
where n is the inward normal and dσ the surface element on ∂Ω. Clearly, several situations may arise (see [43] and [47] for a detailed discussion). It should be clear that H has the properties of entropy (except for the sign); this identification is strengthened when we evaluate H in an equilibrium state (see [43,39, 35]) because it turns out to coincide with the expression of a perfect gas according to equilibrium thermodynamics, apart from a factor −R. A further check of this identification is given by an inequality satisfied by the right-hand side of Equation (8.9) when the gas is able to exchange energy with a solid wall bounding Ω (see Section 11 and [43,39,47]).
9. Model equations When trying to solve the Boltzmann equation for practical problems, one of the major shortcomings is the complicated structure of the collision term, Equation (4.2). When one is not interested in fine details, it is possible to obtain reasonable results by replacing the collision integral by a so-called collision model, a simpler expression J (f ) which retains only the qualitative and average properties of the collision term Q(f, f ). The equation for the distribution function is then called a kinetic model or a model equation.
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
19
The most widely known collision model is usually called the Bhatnagar, Gross and Krook (BGK) model, although Welander proposed it independently at about the same time as the above mentioned authors [14,173]. It reads as follows: J (f ) = ν Φ(ξ ) − f (ξ ) ,
(9.1)
where the collision frequency ν is independent of ξ (but depends on the density ρ and the temperature T ) and Φ denotes the local Maxwellian, i.e., the (unique) Maxwellian having the same density, bulk velocity and temperature as f : Φ = ρ(2πRT )−3/2 exp −|ξ − v|2 /(2RT ) . Here ρ, v, T are chosen is such a way that for any collision invariant ψ we have ψ(ξ )Φ(ξ ) dξ = ψ(ξ )f (ξ ) dξ . R3
(9.2)
(9.3)
R3
It is easily checked that, thanks to Equation (9.3): (a) f and Φ have the same density, bulk velocity and temperature; (b) J (f ) satisfies conservation of mass, momentum and energy; i.e., for any collision invariant: ψ(ξ )J (f ) dξ = 0; (9.4) R3
(c) J (f ) satisfies the Boltzmann inequality log f J (f ) dξ 0
(9.5)
R3
the equality sign holding if and only if, f is a Maxwellian. It should be remarked that the nonlinearity of the BGK collision model, Equation (9.1), is much worse than the nonlinearity in Q(f, f ); in fact the latter is simply quadratic in f , while the former contains f in both the numerator and denominator of an exponential, because v and T are functionals of f , defined by Equations (6.2) and (6.27). The main advantage in the use of the BGK model is that for any given problem one can deduce integral equations for ρ, v, T , which can be solved with moderate effort on a computer. Another advantage of the BGK model is offered by its linearized form (see [43, 113,35]). The BGK model has the same basic properties as the Boltzmann collision integral, but has some shortcomings. Some of them can be avoided by suitable modifications, at the expense, however, of the simplicity of the model. A first modification can be introduced in order to allow the collision frequency ν to depend on the molecular velocity, more precisely on the magnitude of the random velocity c (defined by Equation (6.5)), while requiring that Equation (9.4) still holds. All the basic properties, including Equation (9.5), are retained, but the density, velocity and temperature appearing in Φ are not the local ones of the gas,
20
C. Cercignani
but some fictitious local parameters related to five functionals of f different from ρ, v, T ; this follows from the fact that Equation (9.3) must now be replaced by
R3
ν |c| ψ(ξ )Φ(ξ ) dξ =
R3
ν |c| ψ(ξ )f (ξ ) dξ .
(9.6)
A different kind of correction to the BGK model is obtained when a complete agreement with the compressible Navier–Stokes equations is required for large values of the collision frequency. In fact the BGK model has only one parameter (at a fixed space point and time instant), i.e., the collision frequency ν; the latter can be adjusted to give a correct value for either the viscosity µ or the heat conductivity κ, but not for both. This is shown by the fact that the Prandtl number Pr = µ/cp κ (where cp is the specific heat at constant pressure) turns out [39,35] to be unity for the BGK model, while it is about to 2/3 for a monatomic gas (according to both experimental data and the Boltzmann equation). In order to have a correct value for the Prandtl number, one is led [87,62] to replacing the local Maxwellian in Equation (9.1) by Φ(ξ ) = ρ(π)−3/2 (det A)1/2 exp −(ξ − v) · A(ξ − v) ,
(9.7)
where A is the inverse of the matrix A−1 = (2RT / Pr)I − 2(1 − Pr)p/(ρ Pr),
(9.8)
where I is the identity and p the stress matrix. If we let Pr = 1, we recover the BGK model. Only recently [3] this model (called ellipsoidal statistical (ES) model) has been shown to possess the property expressed by Equation (9.5). Hence the H -theorem holds for the ES model. Other models with different choices of Φ have been proposed [151,35] but they are not so interesting, except for linearized problems (see [43,39,35]). Another model is the integro-differential model proposed by Lebowitz, Frisch and Helfand [114], which is similar to the Fokker–Planck equation used in the theory of Brownian motion. This model reads as follows: J (f ) = D
1 ∂ + (ξk − vk )f , RT ∂ξk ∂ξk2
3 2
∂ f k=1
(9.9)
where D is a function of the local density ρ and the local temperature T . If we take D proportional to the pressure p = ρRT , Equation (9.9) has the same kind of nonlinearity (i.e., quadratic) as the true Boltzmann equation. The idea of kinetic models can be naturally extended to mixtures and polyatomic gases [151,127,81,43].
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
21
10. The linearized collision operator On several occasions we shall meet the so-called linearized collision operator, related to the bilinear operator defined in Equation (5.3) by Lh = 2M −1 Q(Mh, M),
(10.1)
where M is a Maxwellian distribution, usually with zero bulk velocity. When we want to emphasize the fact that we linearize with respect to a given Maxwellian, we write LM instead of just L. A more explicit expression of Lh reads as follows M∗ (h + h∗ − h∗ − h)B(θ, V ) dξ ∗ dn, (10.2) Lh = B+
3
where we have taken into account that M M∗ = MM∗ . Because of Equation (4.10) (with Mh in place of f , M in place of g and g in place of φ), we have the identity: MgLh dξ
3
1 =− 4
3
3 B+
(h + h∗ − h − h∗ )(g + g∗ − g − g∗ ) × B(θ, V ) dξ ∗ dξ dn.
(10.3)
This relation expresses a basic property of the linearized collision term. In order to make it clear, let us introduce a bilinear expression, the scalar product in the Hilbert space of square summable functions of ξ endowed with a scalar product weighted with M: ghM ¯ dξ , (10.4) (g, h) =
3
where the bar denotes complex conjugation. Then Equation (1.7) (with g¯ in place of g) gives (thanks to the symmetry of the expression in the right-hand side of Equation (10.3) with respect to the interchange g ⇔ h): (g, Lh) = (Lg, h).
(10.5)
(h, Lh) 0
(10.6)
Further:
and the equality sign holds if and only if h + h∗ − h − h∗ = 0, i.e., if and only if h is a collision invariant.
(10.7)
22
C. Cercignani
Equations (10.5) and (10.6) indicate that the operator L is symmetric and non-positive in the aforementioned Hilbert space.
11. Boundary conditions The Boltzmann equation must be accompanied by boundary conditions, which describe the interaction of the gas molecules with the solid walls. It is to this interaction that one can trace the origin of the drag and lift exerted by the gas on the body and the heat transfer between the gas and the solid boundary. The study of gas-surface interaction may be regarded as a bridge between the kinetic theory of gases and solid state physics and is an area of research by itself. The difficulties of a theoretical investigation are due, mainly, to our lack of knowledge of the structure of surface layers of solid bodies and hence of the effective interaction potential of the gas molecules with the wall. When a molecule impinges upon a surface, it is adsorbed and may form chemical bonds, dissociate, become ionized or displace surface molecules. Its interaction with the solid surface depends on the surface finish, the cleanliness of the surface, its temperature, etc. It may also vary with time because of outgassing from the surface. Preliminary heating of a surface also promotes purification of the surface through emission of adsorbed molecules. In general, adsorbed layers may be present; in this case, the interaction of a given molecule with the surface may also depend on the distribution of molecules impinging on a surface element. For a more detailed discussion the reader should consult [39,110] and [41]. In general, a molecule striking a surface with a velocity ξ reemerges from it with a velocity ξ which is strictly determined only if the path of the molecule within the wall can be computed exactly. This computation is very hard, because it depends upon a great number of details, such as the locations and velocities of all the molecules of the wall and an accurate knowledge of the interaction potential. Hence it is more convenient to think in terms of a probability density R(ξ → ξ ; x, t; τ ) that a molecule striking the surface with velocity between ξ and ξ + dξ at the point x and time t will re-emerge at practically the same point with velocity between ξ and ξ + dξ after a time interval τ (adsorption or sitting time). If R is known, then we can easily write down the boundary condition for the distribution function f (x, ξ , t). To simplify the discussion, the surface will be assumed to be at rest. A simple argument ([43,39,35]) then gives: f (x, ξ , t)|ξ · n| ∞ = dτ 0
ξ ·n<0
R(ξ → ξ ; x, t; τ )f (x, ξ , t − τ )|ξ · n| dξ
(x ∈ ∂Ω, ξ · n > 0).
(11.1)
The kernel R can be assumed to be independent of f under suitable conditions which we shall not detail here [39,110,41]. If, in addition, the effective adsorption time is small compared to any characteristic time of interest in the evolution of f , we can let τ = 0 in
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
23
the argument of f appearing in the right-hand side of Equation (3.4); in this case the latter becomes: f (x, ξ , t)|ξ · n| R(ξ → ξ ; x, t)f (x, ξ , t)|ξ · n| dξ = ξ ·n<0
(x ∈ Ω, ξ · n > 0),
(11.2)
where R(ξ → ξ ; x, t) =
∞
dτ R(ξ → ξ ; x, t; τ ).
(11.3)
0
Equation (11.2) is, in particular, valid for steady problems. Although the idea of a scattering kernel had appeared before, it is only at the end of 1960’s that a systematic study of the properties of this kernel appears in the scientific literature [35,110,41]. In particular, the following properties were pointed out [36,35,110, 41,34,108,48,109,37]: (1) Non-negativeness, i.e., R cannot take negative values: R(ξ → ξ ; x, t; τ ) 0
(11.4)
and, as a consequence: R(ξ → ξ ; x, t) 0.
(11.5)
(2) Normalization, if permanent adsorption is excluded; i.e., R, as a probability density for the totality of events, must integrate to unity:
∞
dτ 0
ξ ·n0
R(ξ → ξ ; x, t; τ ) dξ = 1
(11.6)
and, as a consequence:
ξ ·n0
R(ξ → ξ ; x, t) dξ = 1.
(11.7)
(3) Reciprocity; this is a subtler property that follows from the circumstance that the microscopic dynamics is time reversible and the wall is assumed to be in a local equilibrium state, not significantly disturbed by the impinging molecule. It reads as follows: |ξ · n|Mw (ξ )R(ξ → ξ ; x, t; τ ) = |ξ · n|Mw (ξ )R(−ξ → −ξ ; x, t; τ )
(11.8)
and, as a consequence: |ξ · n|Mw (ξ )R(ξ → ξ ; x, t) = |ξ · n|Mw (ξ )R(−ξ → −ξ ; x, t).
(11.9)
24
C. Cercignani
Here Mw is a (non-drifting) Maxwellian distribution having the temperature of the wall, which is uniquely identified apart from a factor. We remark that the reciprocity and the normalization relations imply another property: (3 ) Preservation of equilibrium, i.e., the Maxwellian Mw must satisfy the boundary condition (11.1):
∞
Mw (ξ )|ξ · n| =
dτ 0
ξ ·n<0
R(ξ → ξ ; x, t; τ )Mw (ξ )|ξ · n| dξ
(11.10)
equivalent to: Mw (ξ )|ξ · n| =
ξ ·n<0
R(ξ → ξ ; x, t)Mw (ξ )|ξ · n| dξ .
(11.11)
In order to obtain Equation (11.10) it is sufficient to integrate Equation (11.8) with respect to ξ and τ , taking into account Equation (11.6) (with −ξ and −ξ in place of ξ and ξ , respectively). We remark that one frequently assumes Equation (11.10) (or (11.11)), without mentioning Equation (11.8) (or (11.9)); although this is enough for many purposes, reciprocity is very important when constructing mathematical models, because it places a strong restriction on the possible choices. A detailed discussion of the physical conditions under which reciprocity holds has been given by Bärwinkel and Schippers [10]. The basic information on gas-surface interaction, which should be in principle obtained from a detailed calculation based on a physical model, is summarized in a scattering kernel. The further reduction to a small set of accommodation coefficients can be advocated for practical purposes, provided this concept is firmly related to the scattering kernel (see [43, 39,47] for further details). In view of the difficulty of computing the kernel R(ξ → ξ ) from a physical model of the wall, frequently one constructs a mathematical model in the form of a kernel R(ξ → ξ ) which satisfies the basic physical requirements expressed by Equations (11.5), (11.7), (11.9) and is not otherwise restricted except by the condition of not being too complicated. One of the simplest kernels is R(ξ → ξ ) = αMw (ξ )|ξ · n| + (1 − α)δ ξ − ξ + 2n(ξ · ξ ) .
(11.12)
This is the kernel corresponding to Maxwell’s model [121], according to which a fraction (1 − α) of molecules undergoes a specular reflection, while the remaining fraction α is diffused with the Maxwellian distribution of the wall Mw . This is the only model for the scattering kernel that appeared in the literature before the late 1960’s. We refer to original papers and standard treatises for details on more recent models [110,41,34,108,48,109,37, 10,121,135,91,100,112,99,68,174,38,54,53,22,43,39], among which the most popular in recent years has been the so-called Cercignani–Lampis (CL) model. It is remarkable that, for any scattering kernel satisfying the three properties of normalization, positivity and preservation of equilibrium, a simple inequality holds. The
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
25
latter was stated by Darrozès and Guiraud [70] who also sketched a proof. More details were given later [37,39]. It reads as follows Jn =
R3
ξ · nf log f dξ −(2RTw )−1
R3
ξ · n|ξ |2 f dξ
(x ∈ ∂Ω).
(11.13)
Equality holds if and only if f coincides with Mw (the wall Maxwellian) on ∂Ω (unless the kernel in Equation (11.2) is a delta function). We remark that if the gas does not slip upon the wall, the right-hand side of Equation (11.13) equals −qn /(RTw ) where qn is the heat-flow along the normal, according to its definition given in Section 5. If the gas slips on the wall, then one must add the power of the stresses pn · v to qn . In any case, however, the (w) (w) right-hand side equals qn , where qn is the heat-flow in the solid at the interface, because the normal energy flow must be continuous through the wall and stresses have vanishing power in the solid, because the latter is at rest. If we identify the function H introduced in Section 8 with −η/R (where η is the entropy of the gas), the inequality in Equation (11.13) is exactly what one would expect from the Second Principle of thermodynamics.
12. The continuum limit In this section we investigate the connection between the Navier–Stokes equations and the Boltzmann equation by using a method, which originated with Hilbert [85] and Enskog [74]. The discussion is made complicated by the various possible scalings. For example, if we denote by (¯x, t) the microscopic space and time variables (those entering in the Boltzmann equation) and by (x, t) the macroscopic variables (those entering in the fluid dynamical description), we can study scalings of the following kind x¯ = ε−1 x,
(12.1)
t = ε−α t,
(12.2)
where α is an exponent between 1 and 2. For α = 1, this is called the compressible scaling. If α > 1, we are looking at larger “microscopic” times. We now investigate the limiting behavior of solutions of the Boltzmann equation in this limit. Notice first that the compressible Euler equations, ∂t ρ + div(ρv) = 0, 2 ∂t (ρvi ) + div ρvvi + ρeei = 0, 3
1 2 1 2 5 + div ρv |v| + e = 0, ∂t ρ e + |v| 2 2 3
(12.3)
26
C. Cercignani
are invariant with respect to the scaling t → ε−1 t, x → ε−1 x. Here, ei denotes the unit vector in the i-th direction and p is related to ρ and e = 3RT /2 by the state equation for a perfect gas. To investigate how these equations change under the scalings (12.1)–(12.2), let vε (x, t) = εγ v ε−1 x, ε−α t , ρ ε (x, t) = ρ ε−1 x, ε−α t , T ε (x, t) = T ε−1 x, ε−α t ,
γ = α − 1, (12.4)
where (ρ, v, T ) solve the compressible Euler equations (12.3). We easily obtain ∂t ρ ε + div ρ ε vε = 0,
(12.5)
1 ∂t vε + vε · ∂x vε = − ε ∂x pε · ε2(1−α) , ρ
(12.6)
2 ∂t T ε + vε · ∂x T ε + T ε ∂x · vε = 0. 3
(12.7)
The scaling of the bulk velocity field vε in (12.4) is done in a dimensionally consistent way. We expect that the continuum limit of the Boltzmann equation under the scaling (12.1)– (12.2) will be given by the asymptotic behavior of (ρ ε , vε , T ε ), satisfying (12.3), in the limit ε → 0. We will now investigate this limit. To this end, let η = ε2(α−1) and expand vη ≡ vε = v0 + ηv1 + η2 v2 + · · · , ρ η ≡ ρ ε = ρ0 + ηρ1 + η2 ρ2 + · · · , T η ≡ T ε = T0 + ηT1 + η2 T1 + · · · . If we collect the terms of order η−1 in (12.4), we have ∂x p0 = 0
(12.8)
and the terms of order η0 give ∂t ρ0 + div(ρ0 v0 ) = 0, ∂t v0 + (v0 · ∂x )v0 = −
∂x p1 , ρ0
2 ∂t T0 + (v0 · ∂x )T0 + T0 div v0 = 0. 3
(12.9)
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
27
From (12.8) and the perfect gas law p0 = ρ0 T0 , which we assume to hold at zeroth order, it follows that ρ0 T0 is constant as a function of the space variables. The first and third equations in (12.9) now imply 2 ∂t (ρ0 T0 ) + div(ρ0 T0 v0 ) = − ρ0 T0 div v0 . 3
(12.10)
As ρ0 T0 is only a function of t, say A(t), Equation (12.10) implies that 3 div v0 = − A (t)/A(t). 5
(12.11)
Under suitable assumptions, Equation (12.11) implies that A (t) = 0 and then div v0 = 0. This is the case, for example, if we are in a box with nonporous walls, because then the normal component of v0 is 0 and we can use the divergence theorem. A similar argument applies to the case of a box with periodicity boundary conditions; or if we are in the entire space 3 and the difference between v0 and a constant vector decays fast enough at infinity. Assuming that we have conditions which imply that div v0 = 0, we easily get from the continuity equation that ρ0 will be independent of x if the initial value is, and the same for T0 . But with this knowledge Equations (12.9) then actually entail that ρ0 and T0 are constant. Therefore, if the initial conditions are “well prepared” in the sense that vε (x, 0) is a divergence-free vector field and ρ ε (x, 0), T ε (x, 0) are constant, we expect as a first-order approximation for ρ ε , vε , T ε the solution of the equations div v0 = 0, ∂t v0 + (v0 · ∂x )v0 = −
∂x p1 , ρ0
(12.12)
which are the incompressible Euler equations. This limit, known as the “low velocity limit”, is well known at the macroscopic level. We refer to Majda’s book [120] for references and a detailed discussion. The variable η−1 enters into the theory as the square of the speed of sound. If this parameter is large compared to typical speeds of the fluid, then the incompressible model is well suited to describe the time evolution, provided that the initial velocity field is divergence-free and the initial density and temperature are constant. The incompressible fluid limit was met in the last section in connection with the Stokes paradox. In fact, it seems that this limit and the derivation of the steady incompressible Navier–Stokes equations from the Boltzmann equation were first considered in connection with the flow past a body at small values of the Mach number [32]. We remark that in the steady case div v0 = 0 and ρ0 and T0 turn out to be constant without using the boundary conditions. Let us examine the kinetic picture as described by the Boltzmann equation. The above discussion suggests that if α ∈ (1, 2), then in the scaling (12.1)–(12.2) the solutions of the Boltzmann equation will converge to a local Maxwellian distribution whose parameters satisfy the incompressible Euler equations. This assertion can actually be proved rigorously [71,9].
28
C. Cercignani
For α = 2 something special happens. Of course, the incompressible Euler equations are invariant under the scaling (12.1)–(12.3); however, for α = 2 the incompressible Navier– Stokes equations, ∂t v + (v · ∂x )v = −∂x r + ν∆v, ∂x · v = 0
(12.13)
(where r = p/ρ and ν = µ/ρ is the kinematic viscosity) are also invariant under the same scaling. It is therefore of great interest to understand whether the Boltzmann dynamics “chooses” in this limit the Euler or the Navier–Stokes evolution. We can expect that the answer is Navier–Stokes. In other words, considering larger times than those typical for Euler dynamics (ε−2 t instead of ε−α t, α < 2), dissipation becomes nonnegligible. We can see an illustration of this behavior in the following example: consider two parallel layers of fluid moving with velocities v and v + δv. Suppose that we want to decide whether there is any momentum transfer between these layers (which is expected for the Navier–Stokes equations, but not for the Euler equations). The momentum transfer can in principle be affected by the trend to thermalization typical of the Boltzmann collision term, but a scaling argument shows that it is proportional to εα−2 δv, with the consequence that it remains only relevant for α = 2. These considerations can be put on a rigorous basis, and, of course, the viscosity coefficient can be computed in terms of kinetic expressions (see [43,39,35]). The incompressible Navier–Stokes equations can be derived from the Boltzmann equation if the time interval is such that smooth solutions of the continuum equations exist. The tool which yields this result is a truncated Hilbert expansion and one gets local convergence for the general situation [71] or global and uniform convergence if the data are small in a suitable sense [9]. Let us consider now the cases in which compressibility is not negligible. If we scale space and time in the same way, the scaled Boltzmann equation becomes: 1 ∂t f ε + ξ · ∂x f ε = Q f ε , f ε . ε
(12.14)
We will use the abbreviation Dt f := ∂t f + ξ · ∂x f . Of course, we expect that εDt f ε → 0
as ε → 0,
(12.15)
and if f ε → f 0,
(12.16)
the limit f 0 must satisfy Q f 0 , f 0 = 0.
(12.17)
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
29
This implies, as we know, that f 0 is a local Maxwellian distribution: ρ(x, t) |ξ − v(x, t)|2 f (x, ξ , t) ≡ M(x, ξ , t) = exp − . (2πRT (x, t))3/2 2RT (x, t) 0
(12.18)
The fields (ρ, x, T ), which characterize the behavior of the local Maxwellian distribution M in space and time, are expected to evolve according to continuum equations which we are going to derive. First, let us emphasize again that these fields are varying slowly on the space-time scales which are typical for the gas described in terms of the Boltzmann equation. From the conservation laws (I.12.36) ψα Q(f, f ) dξ = 0 (α = 0, . . . , 4),
(12.19)
we readily obtain, as we know, ψα (∂t f + ξ · ∂x f ) dξ = 0.
(12.20)
This is a system of equations for the moments of f which is in general not closed. However, if we assume f = M and use the identities (for M they are identities; for a general f they are definitions given in (I.12.3–7), where e = 32 RT ) ρ=
M dξ ,
(12.21)1
ρv =
Mξ dξ ,
1 3 1 w ≡ ρRT + ρ|v|2 = 2 2 2
(12.21)2 ξ 2 M dξ ,
(12.21)3
we readily obtain from (12.20) that ∂t ρ + div(ρv) = 0,
(12.22)
Mξ ξi = 0, ∂t (ρvi ) + div
(12.23)
∂t
1 3 1 ρRT + ρ|v|2 + div Mξ |ξ |2 = 0. 2 2 2
(12.24)
These equations are nothing but Equations (12.19)–(12.21), specialized to the case of a Maxwellian distribution. This is of crucial importance if we want to write
30
C. Cercignani
Equations (12.23) and (12.24) in closed form. To do so we have to express Mξ ξi and Mξ |ξ |2 in terms of the fields (ρ, v, T ). To this end, we use the elementary identities:
M(ξj − vj )(ξi − vi ) dξ = δij ρRT , (12.25) M(ξ − v)|(ξ − v)|2 dξ = 0,
which transform Equation (12.23) into ∂t (ρvi ) + div(ρvvi ) = −∂xi p,
(12.26)
p = ρRT .
(12.27)
with
Equation (12.27) is the perfect gas law. Obviously, the quantity p defined by Equation (12.27) has the meaning of a pressure. Recalling that the internal energy e is related to temperature T by 3 e = RT , 2
(12.28)
using this and Equation (12.25) we transform Equation (12.24) into: 1 2 1 2 ∂t ρ(e + |v| + div ρv e + |v| = −div(pv). 2 2
(12.29)
The set of Equations (12.22), (12.26) and (12.29) express conservation equations for mass, momentum and energy respectively and can be rewritten as the Euler equations (12.3). For smooth functions, an equivalent way of writing the Euler equations in terms of the field (ρ, v, T ) is ∂t ρ + div(ρv) = 0, ∂t v + (v · ∂x )v +
1 ∂x p = 0, ρ
(12.30)
2 ∂t T + (v · ∂x )T + T ∂x · v = 0. 3 However, in this form we lose the conservation form as given in (12.3), in which the time derivative of a field equals the negative divergence of a current which is a nonlinear function of this field. Before going on, some comments on our limits are in order, because one might suspect an inconsistency in the passage from a rarefied to a dense gas. Recall that the Boltzmann equation holds in the Boltzmann–Grad limit (Nσ 2 = O(1)). In the continuum limit, we
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
31
have to take Nσ 2 = 1/ε → ∞. This, at first glance, seems contradictory, but there is really no problem. The Boltzmann equation holds for a perfect gas, i.e., for a gas such that the density parameter δ = Nσ 3 /V , where V is the volume containing N molecules, tends to zero. The parameter Nσ 2 1 = 2/3 = N 1/3 δ 2/3 Kn V
(12.31)
may tend to zero, to ∞ or remain finite in this limit. These are the three cases which occur if we scale N as δ −m (m 0), for m < 2, m > 2 and m = 2 respectively. In the first case the gas is in free-molecular flow and we can simply neglect the collision term (Knudsen gas), in the second we are in the continuum regime which we are treating here, and we cannot simply “omit” the “small” term, i.e., the left-hand side of the Boltzmann equation, because the limit is singular. In the third case the two sides of the Boltzmann equation are equally important (Boltzmann gas) and this is the case dealt with before for solutions close to an absolute Maxwellian distribution. In spite of the fact that we face a singular perturbation problem, Hilbert [85] proposed an expansion in powers of ε. In this way, however, we obtain a Maxwellian distribution at the lowest order, with parameters satisfying the Euler equations and corrections to this solution which are obtained by solving inhomogeneous linearized Euler equations [85,43, 39,35]. In order to avoid this and to investigate the relationship between the Boltzmann equation and the compressible Navier–Stokes equations, Enskog introduced an expansion, usually called the Chapman–Enskog expansion [74,39,35]. The idea behind this expansion is that the functional dependence of f upon the local density, bulk velocity and internal energy can be expanded into a power series. Although there are many formal similarities with the Hilbert expansion, the procedure is rather different. As remarked by the author [35,39], the Chapman–Enskog expansion seems to introduce spurious solutions, especially if one looks for steady states. This is essentially due to the fact that one really considers infinitely many time scales (of orders ε, ε2 , . . . , ε n , . . .). The author [35,39] introduced only two time scales (of orders ε and ε2 ) and was able to recover the compressible Navier–Stokes equations. In order to explain the idea, we remark that the Navier–Stokes equations describe two kinds of processes, convection and diffusion, which act on two different time scales. If we consider only the first scale we obtain the compressible Euler equations; if we insist on the second one we can obtain the Navier–Stokes equations only at the price of losing compressibility. If we want both compressibility and diffusion, we have to keep both scales at the same time and think of f as f (x, ξ , t) = f εx, ξ , εt, ε2 t .
(12.32)
This enables us to introduce two different time variables t1 = εt, t2 = ε2 t and a new space variable x1 = εx such that f = f (x1 , ξ , t1 , t2 ). The fluid dynamical variables are functions
32
C. Cercignani
of x1 , t1 , t2 , and for both f and the fluid dynamical variables the time derivative is given by ∂f ∂f ∂ =ε + ε2 . ∂t ∂t1 ∂t2
(12.33)
In particular, the Boltzmann equation can be rewritten as ε
∂f ∂f + ε2 + εξ · ∂x f = Q(f, f ). ∂t1 ∂t2
If we expand f formally in a power series in ε, we find that at the lowest order f is a Maxwellian distribution. The compatibility conditions at the first order give that the time derivatives of the fluid dynamic variables with respect to t1 is determined by the Euler equations, but the derivatives with respect to t2 are determined only at the next level and are given by the terms of the compressible Navier–Stokes equations describing the effects of viscosity and heat conductivity. The two contributions are, of course, to be added as specified by (12.33) in order to obtain the full time derivative and thus write the compressible Navier–Stokes equations. It is not among the aims of this article to describe the techniques applied to and the results obtained from the computations of the transport coefficients, such as the viscosity and heat conduction coefficients, for given molecular interaction. For this we refer to standard treatises [64,86,75]. The results discussed in this section show that there is a qualitative agreement between the Boltzmann equation and the Navier–Stokes equations for sufficiently low values of the Knudsen number. There are however flows where this agreement does not occur. They have been especially studied by Sone [154]. New effects arise because the no-slip and no temperature jump boundary condition do not hold. In addition to the thermal creep induced along a boundary with a nonuniform temperature, discovered by Maxwell, two new kinds of flow are induced over boundaries kept at uniform temperatures. They are related to the presences of thermal stresses in the gas. The first effect [154,153,138] is present even for small Mach numbers and small temperature differences and follows from the fact that there are stresses related to the second derivatives of the temperature (see Section 15). Although these stresses do not change the Navier–Stokes equations, they change the boundary conditions; the gas slips on the wall, and thus a movement occurs even if the wall is at rest. This effect is particularly important in small systems, such as micromachines, since the temperature differences are small but may have relatively large second derivatives; it is usually called the thermal stress slip flow [154,153,138]. The second effect is nonlinear [101,155] and occurs when two isothermal surfaces do not have constant distance (thus in any situation with large temperature gradients, in the absence of particular symmetries). In fact, if we assume that in the Hilbert expansion the velocity vanishes at the lowest order, i.e., the speed is of the order of the Knudsen number, the terms of second order in the temperature show up in the momentum equation.
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
33
These terms are associated with thermal stresses and are of the same importance as those containing the pressure and the viscous stresses. A solution in which the gas does not move can be obtained if and only if: grad T ∧ grad |grad T |2 = 0. (12.34) Since |grad T | measures the distance between two nearby isothermal lines, if this quantity has a gradient in the direction orthogonal to grad T , the distance between two neighboring isothermal lines varies and we must expect that the gas moves. These effects may occur even for sufficiently large values of the Knudsen number; they cannot be described, however, in terms of the local temperature field. They rather depend by the configuration of the system. They should not be confused with flows due to the presence of a temperature gradient along the wall, such as the transpiration flow [139] and the thermophoresis of aerosol particles [162]. Numerical examples of simulations of this kind of flow are discussed in [43]. 13. Free-molecule and nearly free-molecule flows After discussing the behavior of a gas in the continuum limit, in this section we consider the opposite case in which the small parameter is the Knudsen number (or the inverse of the mean free path). By analogy with what we did in the previous section, we might be tempted to use a series expansion of the form (12.2), albeit with a different meaning of the expansion parameter. This, however, does not work in general, for a reason to be presently explained. The factor ξ multiplying the gradient of f in Equation (5.1) takes all possible values and hence also values of order ε; thus we should expect troubles from the molecules travelling with low speeds, because then certain terms in the left-hand side can become smaller than the righthand side, in spite of the small factor ε. This is confirmed by actual calculations, especially for steady problems. Let us now consider the limiting case when the collisions can be completely neglected. This, by itself, does not pose many problems. The Boltzmann equation (in the absence of a body force) reduces to the simple form Dt f = ∂t f + ξ · ∂x f = 0.
(13.1)
Since the molecular collisions are negligible, the gas-surface interaction discussed in Section 11 plays a major role. This situation is typical for artificial satellites, since the mean free path is 50 meters at 200 kilometers of altitude. The general solution of Equation (13.1) is in terms of an arbitrary function of two vectors g(·, ·): f (x, ξ , t) = g(x − ξ t, ξ ).
(13.2)
In the steady case, Equation (13.1) reduces to ξ · ∂x f = 0,
(13.3)
34
C. Cercignani
and the general solution becomes: f (x, ξ , t) = g(x ∧ ξ , ξ ).
(13.4)
Frequently it is easier to work with the property that f is constant along the molecular trajectories than with the explicit solutions given by Equations (13.3)–(13.4). The easiest problem to deal with is the flow past a convex body. In this case, in fact, the molecules arriving at the surface of the wall have an assigned distribution function f∞ , usually a Maxwellian distribution with the density ρ∞ , bulk velocity v∞ , and temperature T∞ , prevailing far away from the body, and the distribution function of the molecules leaving the surface is given by the boundary conditions. The distribution function at any other point P , if needed, is simply obtained by the following rule: if the straight line through P having the direction of ξ intersects the body at a point Q and ξ points from Q towards P , then the distribution function at P is the same as that at Q; otherwise it equals f∞ . Interest is usually confined to the total momentum and energy exchanged between the molecules and the body, which, in turn, easily yield the drag and lift exerted by the gas on the body and the heat transfer between the body and the gas. In practice, the temperature of a body is determined by a balance of all forms of heat transfer at the body surface. For an artificial satellite, a considerable part of heat is lost by radiation and this process must be duly taken into account in the balance. The results take a particularly simple form in the case of a large Mach number since we can let the latter go to infinity in the various formulas. One must, however, be careful, because the speed is multiplied by sin θ in many terms and thus the aforementioned limit is not uniform in θ . Thus the limiting formulas can be used, if and only if, the area where S sin θ 1 is small. The standard treatment is based on the definition of accommodation coefficients, but calculations based on other models are available [39,50,49]. The case of nonconvex boundaries is, of course, more complicated and one must solve an integral equation to obtain the distribution function at the boundary. If one assumes diffuse reflection according to a Maxwellian, the integral equation simplifies in a considerable way, because just the mass flow at the boundary must be computed [39]. In particular the latter equation can be used to study free-molecular flows in pipes of arbitrary cross section with a typical diameter much smaller than the mean free path (capillaries). If the cross section is circular the equation becomes particularly simple and is known as Clausing’s equation [39]. The perturbation of free-molecular flows is not trivial for steady problems because of the abovementioned non-uniformity in the inverse Knudsen number. If one tries a naïve iteration, the singularity arising in the first iterate may cancel when integrating to obtain moments (cancellation is easier, the higher is the dimensionality of the problem, because a first-order pole is milder, if the dimension is higher). The singularity is always present and, although it may be mild, it can build up a worse singularity when computing subsequent steps. The difficulties are enhanced in unbounded domains where the subsequent terms diverge at space infinity. The reason for the latter fact is that the ratio between the mean free path λ and the distance d of any given point from the body is a local Knudsen
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
35
number which tends to zero when d tends to infinity; hence collisions certainly arise in an unbounded domain and tend to dominate at large distances. On this basis we are led to expect that a continuum behavior takes place at infinity, even when the typical lengths characterizing the size of the body are much smaller than the mean free path; this is confirmed by the discussion of the Stokes paradox for the steady linearized Boltzmann equation (see [43,39,35]). Both difficulties are removed by the so-called collision iteration: the loss term is partly considered to be unknown in the iteration, thus building an exponential term which controls the singularity. The presence of the latter is still felt through the presence of logarithmic terms in the (inverse) Knudsen number. In higher dimensions this is multiplied by a power of (Kn)−1 which typically equals the number of space dimensions relevant for the problem under consideration in a bounded domain. In particular the dependence upon coordinates will show the same singularity (we can think of local Knudsen numbers based on the distance from the nearest wall); as a consequence first derivatives will diverge at the boundary in one dimension and the same will occur for second, or third derivatives, in two, or three, space dimensions, respectively. In an external domain we have, in addition to the low speed effects, the effect of particles coming from infinity, which actually dominates. In particular in one dimension (half-space problems) the terms coming from iterations are of the same order as the lowest order terms; actually for a half-space problem there is hardly a Knudsen number (the local one is an exception). In two dimensions the corrections in the moments are of order Kn−1 log Kn. In three dimensions a correction of order Kn−2 log Kn is preceded by a correction of order Kn−1 . Care must be exercised when applying the aforementioned results to a concrete numerical evaluation, as mentioned above. In fact, for large but not extremely large Knudsen numbers (say 10 Kn 100) log Kn is a relatively small number, although log Kn → ∞ for Kn → ∞. Hence terms of order log Kn/Kn, though mathematically dominating over terms of order 1/Kn are of the same order as the latter for practical purposes. As consequence, the two kinds of terms must be computed together if numerical accuracy is desired for the aforementioned range of Knudsen numbers. Related to this remark is the fact that any factor appearing in front of Kn in the argument of the logarithm is meaningless unless the term of order Kn−1 is also computed. This is particularly important when the factor under consideration depends upon a parameter which can take very large (or very small) values (typically a speed ratio). Thus Hamel and Cooper [70,85] have shown that the first iterate of the integral iteration is incapable of describing the correct dependence upon the speed ratio and have applied the method of matched asymptotic expansions [81] to regions near a body and far from a body. In particular, for the hypersonic flow of a gas of hard spheres past a two-dimensional strip, they find for the drag coefficient
ε log ε , CD = CDf.m. 1 + 2π
(13.5)
where the inverse Knudsen number ε is based on the mean free path λ = π 3/2 σ 2 n∞ Sw (σ is the molecular diameter and Sw = S∞ (Tw /T∞ ), whereas n∞ and S∞ are the number density at infinity).
36
C. Cercignani
If we consider infinite-range intermolecular potentials, then we have fractional powers rather than logarithms. All the considerations of this section have the important consequence that approximate methods of solution which are not able to allow for a nonanalytic behavior for Kn → ∞ produce poor results for large Knudsen numbers.
14. Perturbations of equilibria The first steady solutions other than Maxwellian to be investigated were perturbations of the latter. The method of perturbation of equilibria is different from the Hilbert method because the small parameter is not contained in the Boltzmann equation but in auxiliary conditions, such as boundary or initial conditions. The advantage of the method is that we can investigate problems in the transition regime, provided differences in temperature and speed are moderate. Let us try to find a solution of our problem for the Boltzmann equation in the form f=
∞
εn fn ,
(14.1)
n=0
where at variance with previous expansions ε is a parameter which does not appear in the Boltzmann equation. In addition f0 is assumed from the start to be a Maxwellian distribution. By inserting this formal series into Equation (5.1) and matching the various orders in ε, we obtain equations which one can hope to solve recursively: ∂t f1 + ξ · ∂x f1 = 2Q(f1 , f0 ),
(14.2)1
..., ∂t fj + ξ · ∂x fj = 2Q(fj , f0 ) +
j −1
Q(fi , fj −i ),
(14.2)j
i=1
..., where, as in Section 4, Q(f, g) denotes the symmetrized collision operator and the sum is empty for j = 1. Although in principle one can solve the subsequent equations by recursion, in practice one solves only the first equation, which is called the linearized Boltzmann equation. This equation can be rewritten as follows: ∂t h + ξ · ∂x h = LM h,
(14.3)
where LM denotes the linearized collision operator about the Maxwellian M, i.e., LM h = 2Q(M, Mh)/M, h = f1 /M (see Section 10). We shall assume, as is usually done with
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
37
little loss of generality, that the bulk velocity in the Maxwellian is zero and we shall denote the unperturbed density and temperature by ρ0 and T0 . Although the equation is now linear, and hence all the weapons of linear analysis are available, it is far from easy to solve for a given boundary value problem, such as Couette flow. Yet it is possible to gain an insight on the behavior of the general solution of Equation (14.3) (see [43,39,35]). This insight gives the following picture for a slab problem, provided the plates are sufficiently far apart (several mean free paths). There are two Knudsen layers near the boundaries, where the behavior of the solution is strongly dependent on the boundary conditions, and a central core (a few mean free paths away form the plates), where the solution of the Navier–Stokes equations holds (with a slight reminiscence of the boundary conditions). If the plates are close in terms of the mean free path, then this picture does not apply because the core and the kinetic layers merge. One can give evidence for the above statements just in the case of the linearized Boltzmann equation, but there is a strong evidence that this qualitative picture applies to nonlinear flows as well, with a major exception. In general, compressible flows develop shock waves at large speeds and these do not appear in the linearized description. As already remarked, these shocks are not surfaces of discontinuity as for an ideal fluid, governed by the Euler equations, but layers of rapid change of the solution (on the scale of the mean free path). One can obtain solutions for flows containing shocks from the Navier–Stokes equations, but, since they change significantly on the scale of the mean free path, they are inaccurate. Other regions where this picture is inaccurate are the zones of high rarefaction, where nearly free-molecular conditions may prevail, even if the rest of the flow is reasonably described in terms of Navier–Stokes equations, Knudsen layers and shock layers. The theory of Knudsen layers can be essentially described by the linearized Boltzmann equation. The main result concerns the boundary conditions for the Navier–Stokes equations. They turn out to be different from those of no-slip and no temperature jump. In fact, the velocity slip turns out to be proportional to the normal gradient of tangential velocity and the temperature jump to the normal gradient of temperature. When one can use the Navier–Stokes equations but must use the slip and temperature-jump boundary conditions, one talks of the slip regime; this typically occurs for Knudsen numbers between 10−1 and 10−2 . Subtler phenomena may occur if the solutions depend on more than one space coordinate. The most important change with respect to traditional continuum mechanics is the presence of the term with the second derivatives of temperature in the expression of the stress deviator and of the term with the second derivatives of bulk velocity in the expression of the heat flow. These terms were already known to Maxwell [121]. In recent times, their importance has been stressed by Kogan et al. [101] and by Sone et al. [155] (as already mentioned in Section 12). Even in fully three-dimensional problems the solution of the linearized Boltzmann equation reduces to the sum of two terms, one of which, hB , is important just in the Knudsen layers and the other, hA , is important far from the boundaries. The latter has a stress deviator and a heat flow with constitutive equations different from those of Navier– Stokes and Fourier. In spite of this, the bulk velocity, pressure, and temperature satisfy the Navier–Stokes equations when steady problems are considered. In fact, when we take
38
C. Cercignani
the divergence of the heat flow vector a term proportional to the Laplacian of v vanishes, thanks to the continuity equation, and thus just a term proportional to the temperature gradient survives; then, taking the divergence of the stress, a term grad(∆T ) vanishes, because of the energy equation. Yet, the new terms in the constitutive relations may produce physical effects in the presence of boundary conditions different from those of no-slip and no temperature jump. In fact, we must expect the velocity slip to be proportional to the shear stress and the temperature jump to the heat flow.
15. Approximate methods for linearized problems Linearization combined with the use of models lends itself to the use of analytical methods, which turn out to be particularly useful for a preliminary analysis of certain problems. Closed form solutions are not so frequent and are practically restricted to the case of halfspace problems [43,39,35]. The latter, in turn, are useful to investigate Knudsen layers and compute the slip and temperature jump coefficients. The use of BGK or similar models permits reducing the solution of Boltzmann’s integrodifferential equation in phase-space to solving integral equation in ordinary space. This is obtained because in the BGK model the distribution function f occurs only in two ways: explicitly in a linear, simple way and implicitly through a few moments (appearing in the local Maxwellian and the collision frequency). Then one can express f in terms of these moments by integrating a linear, simple partial differential equation; then, using the definitions of these moments and the expression of f one can obtain integral equations for the same moments [43,39,35]. These equations can be solved numerically in a much easier way than the Boltzmann equation. This is particularly true in the linearized case. The integral equation approach lends itself to a variational solution. The main idea of this method (for linearized problems) is the following. Suppose that we must solve the equation: Lh = S,
(15.1)
where h is the unknown, L a linear operator and S a source term. Assume that we can form a bilinear expression ((g, h)) such that ((Lg, h)) = ((g, Lh)), for any pair {g, h} in the set where we look for a solution. Then the expression (functional): ˜ = (h, ˜ Lh) ˜ − 2 (S, h) ˜ J (h)
(15.2)
has the property that if set h˜ = h + η, then the terms of first degree in η disappear and ˜ reduces to J (h) + ((η, Lη)) if and only if h is a solution of Equation (15.1). In other J (h) words if η is regarded as small (an error), the functional in Equation (15.2) becomes small of second order in the neighborhood of h, if and only if h is a solution of Equation (15.1). Then we say that the solutions of the latter equation satisfy a variational principle, or make the functional in Equation (15.2) stationary. Thus a way to look for solutions of Equation (15.1) is to look for solutions which make the functional in Equation (15.2) stationary (variational method).
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
39
The method is particularly useful if we know that ((η, Lη)) is non-negative (or nonpositive) because we can then characterize the solutions of Equation (15.1) as maxima or minima of the functional (15.2). But, even if this is not the case, the property is useful. First of all, it gives a non-arbitrary recipe to select among approximations to the solution in a given class. Second, if we find that the functional J is related to some physical quantity, we can compute this quantity with high accuracy, even if we have a poor approximation to h. If the error η is of order 10%, then J will be in fact computed with an error of the order ˜ from J (h) is of order η2 , as we have seen. of 1%, because the deviation of J (h) The integral formulation of the BGK model lends itself to the application of the variational method [58]. Thus in the case of Couette the functional is related to the stress component p12 which is constant and gives the drag exerted by the gas on each plate. Thus this quantity can be computed with high accuracy [58,43]. This method can be generalized to other problems and to the more complicated models [39]. It can also be used to obtain accurate finite ordinate schemes, by approximating the unknowns by trial functions which are piecewise constant [44]. In the case of the steady linearized Boltzmann equation, Equation (14.3), a similar method can be used. Let us indicate by Dh the differential part appearing in the left-hand side (Dh = ξ · ∂x h for steady problems) and assume that there is a source term as well (an example of a source occurs in linearized Poiseuille flow, see [43,39,35]) and write our equation in the form: Dh − Lh = S.
(15.3)
If we try the simplest possible bilinear expression (g, h) =
L 0
3
g(x, ξ )h(x, ξ ) dx dξ
(15.4)
and we use it with Lh = Dh − Lh we cannot reproduce the symmetry property ((Lg, h)) = ((g, Lh)). It works for Lh but not for Dh. There is however a trick [33] which leads to the desired result. Let us introduce the parity operator in velocity space, P , such that P [h(ξ )] = h(−ξ ). Then we can think of replacing Equation (15.3) by P Dh − P Lh = P S
(15.5)
because this is completely equivalent to the original equation. In addition, because of the central symmetry of the molecular interaction P Lh = LP h and the fact that we had no problems with L is not destroyed by the fact that we use P . On the other hand we have by a partial integration: (g, P Dh) = (P Dg, h) + g + , P h− B − P g − , h+ B .
(15.6)
40
C. Cercignani
Here g ± denote the restrictions of a function defined on the boundary to positive, respectively negative, values of ξ · n, where n is the unit vector normal to the boundary. In addition, we have put
g ± , h±
B
= ∂Ω
±ξ ·n>0
|ξ · n|g(x, ξ )h(x, ξ ) dξ dσ.
(15.7)
In the one-dimensional case, the integration over the boundary ∂Ω reduces to the sum of the boundary terms at x = 0 and x = L. Clearly the last two terms in Equation (15.6) do not fit in our description. We have two ways out of the difficulty. We first recall a property of the boundary conditions, discussed in Section 11. The boundary conditions must be linearized about the Maxwellian distribution M and this gives them the following form (see below): h+ = h0 + Kh− .
(15.8)
Because of reciprocity (Equation (11.9)), we have (P g − , Kh− ) B = (Kg − , P h− ) B .
(15.9)
Hence, if we assume that both g and h satisfy the boundary conditions, we have
g + , P h− B − P g − , h+ B = (h0 , P h− ) B − (P g − , h0 ) B + (Kg − , P h− ) B − (P g − , Kh− ) B = (h0 , P h− ) B − (P g − , h0 ) B . (15.10)
We remark that we can modify the solution of the problem by adding a combination of the collision invariants with constant coefficients. This does not modify the Boltzmann equation but can be used to modify the boundary conditions. Usually it is possible to dispose of the constant coefficients to make ((h0 , P h− ))B = 0 (and, at the same time, of course, ((h0 , P g − ))B = 0). We assume that this is the case. Using this relation and Equation (15.9), Equation (15.10) reduces to
g + , P h−
B
−
− + Pg ,h B = 0
(15.11)
and the variational principle holds with the operator Lh = P Dh − P Lh and the source P S. This variational principle is correct but not so useful, because it can be used only with approximations which exactly satisfy the boundary conditions and it can be complicated to construct these approximations. Thus we follow another procedure by incorporating the boundary conditions in the functional. It is enough to consider ˜ = (h, ˜ P D h˜ − P Lh) ˜ − 2 (P S, h) ˜ J (h) + (P h˜ − , h˜ + − K h˜ − − 2h0 ) B .
(15.12)
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
41
In fact, if we let h˜ = h + η, we find that the terms linear in η disappear from J and the variational principle holds. In agreement with what we said before, it is interesting to look at the value attained by J when h˜ = h. Equation (15.12) becomes (15.13) J (h) = − (P S, h) − (P h− , h0 ) B . This result acquires its full meaning only when we examine the expressions for h0 and S. In general S = 0 (an important case in which this is not true, is linearized Poiseuille flow). If we let S = 0, then we must look at the expression of h0 . The boundary source has a special form because it arises from the linearization, about a Maxwellian distribution M, of a boundary condition of the form: f+ = Kw f− ,
(15.14)
where Kw is an operator which has several properties, including Mw+ = Kw Mw− .
(15.15)
Now, if let f = M(1 + h) in Equation (15.14), we have: h+ =
Kw M− h− Kw M− + − 1. M+ M+
(15.16)
This relation is exact. We can now proceed to neglecting terms of order higher than first in the perturbation parameters. We can replace in Kw the temperature and velocity of the wall by those of the Maxwellian M (i.e., T0 and 0) and obtain a slightly different operator K0 . Thus we obtain the operator K, which we used before, by letting K0 M− h− /M+ = Kh− . Concerning the source, we have, using Equation (15.15): h0 =
Kw M− Kw M− Kw Mw− −1= − . M+ M+ Mw+
Since Mw and M differ by terms of first order, we can replace Kw by K0 because their difference is also of first order and would produce a term of second order in the expression of h0 . h0 =
K0 M− K0 Mw− K0 Mw− − =1− . M+ Mw+ Mw+
(15.17)
Now, if we neglect terms of higher than first order in the speed of the wall and the temperature difference Tw − T0 , we have Mw = M(1 + ψ), where (recalling that Mw is determined up to the density that we can choose to be the same as in M) ψ can be explicitly computed to give: |ξ |2 3 Tw − T0 ξ · vw + − ψ= RT0 2RT0 2 T0
(15.18)
42
C. Cercignani
and, finally, neglecting again terms of order higher than first: h0 = ψ+ − Kψ− .
(15.19)
Then Equation (15.13) with S = 0 gives J (h) = − (P h− , ψ+ ) B + (P h− , Kψ− ) B = − (P h− , ψ+ ) B + (Kh− , P ψ− ) B = − (P h− , ψ+ ) B + h+ − ψ + + Kψ − , P ψ− B = − (P h− , ψ+ ) B + h+ −, P ψ− B + Kψ − − ψ + , P ψ− B .
(15.20)
The last term is a known quantity, whereas the first and the second can be combined to give unknown quantities of physical importance. In fact, if we take into account the expression of ψ (Equation (15.18)), we obtain: − (P h− , ψ+ ) B + h+ −, P ψ− B ξ · vw =− ξ · nh(x, ξ )M dξ dσ RT0 3 Tw − T0 |ξ | − ξ · nh(x, ξ )M dξ dσ + 2RT0 2 T0 1 Tw − T0 =− dσ . pn · vw dσ + q(n) RT0 T0
(15.21)
Here pn is the normal stress vector and qn the normal component of the heat flow. The fact that the mass flow vanishes at the wall has been taken into account. Because of the linearity of the problem, it is possible and convenient, without loss of generality, to consider separately the two cases vw = 0 and Tw = T0 . Then the two terms in the expression above occur in two different problems. For some typical problems vw vanishes on just one part of the boundary, whereas it is a constant on the remaining part of the latter; then the factor multiplying this constant is the drag on the corresponding part of the boundary. Similarly one can consider the case in which the factor in front of qn vanishes on just one part of the boundary, whereas it is a constant on the remaining part of the latter, and relate the value of the functional to the heat transfer. The two variational principles which have been discussed are related to each other [39]. The integral equation approach and the variational method have been applied with great success to many linearized problems [43,39,35]. Among the most interesting results we mention the calculation of the minimum in the flow rate for Poiseuille flow [30,61,31, 44], first experimentally discovered by Knudsen [98], and the calculation of the drag on a sphere (at low Mach numbers) where the results agree very well [59] with the semiempirical formula derived by Millikan from his experimental data [126].
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
43
16. Mixtures As is well known, air at room pressure and temperature is a mixture, its main components being two diatomic gases, nitrogen and oxygen. This immediately calls for an immediate change in our basic equation, Equation (5.1), which is only suitable for a single monatomic gas. A remarkable feature of aerodynamics at the molecular level is that the evolution equations change in a significant way, when dealing with polyatomic rather than monatomic gases. This is not the case when the gas is treated as a continuum, where, at least at room conditions, only a few changes in the equations occur, the most remarkable being the change of the ratio of specific heats γ . If we consider a mixture of monatomic gases, the differences between the various species occur in the values of the masses and in the law of interaction between molecules of different species; in the simplest case, when the molecules are pictured as hard spheres, the second difference is represented by unequal values of the molecular diameters. In the mathematical treatment, a first difference will be in the fact that we shall need n distribution functions fi (i = 1, 2, . . . , n) if there are n species. The notation becomes complicated, but there is no new idea, except, of course, for the fact that we must derive a system of n coupled Boltzmann equations for the n distribution functions. The arguments are exactly the same, with obvious changes, and the result is ∂fi ∂fi ∂fi +ξ · + Xi · ∂t ∂x ∂ξ n
= (fi fk∗ − fi fk∗ )Bik (n · V, |V|) dξ ∗ dn, 3 k=1 R B+
(16.1)
where Bik is computed from the interaction law between the i-th and k-th species, while in the k-th term in the left-hand side, V = ξ − ξ ∗ is the relative velocity of the molecule of the i-th species (whose evolution we are following) with respect to a molecule of the k-th species (against which the former is colliding). The arguments ξ and ξ ∗ are computed, as before, from the laws of conservation of mass and energy in a collision with the following result: 2µik n (ξ − ξ ∗ ) · n , mi 2µik ξ ∗ = ξ ∗ + n (ξ − ξ ∗ ) · n , mk
ξ = ξ −
(16.2)
where µik = mi mk /(mi + mk ) is the reduced mass [39]. To prepare some material for the description of polyatomic gases and chemical reactions, we remark that Equation (16.1) can be rewritten as follows [39]: ∂fi ∂fi ∂fi +ξ · + Xi · ∂t ∂x ∂ξ
44
C. Cercignani
=
n
3 3 3 k=1 R ×R ×R
(fi fk∗ − fi fk∗ )Wik (ξ , ξ ∗ |ξ , ξ ∗ ) dξ ∗ dξ dξ ∗ .
(16.3)
Now ξ , ξ ∗ , ξ , ξ ∗ are independent variables (i.e. they are not related by the conservation laws) and Wik (ξ , ξ ∗ |ξ ξ ∗ ) = Sik n · V, |V| δ(mi ξ ∗ + mk ξ ∗ − mi ξ − mk ξ ∗ ) × δ mi |ξ ∗ |2 + mk |ξ ∗ |2 − mi |ξ |2 − mk |ξ ∗ |2 ,
(16.4)
where n = (ξ − ξ )/|ξ − ξ | and Bik (n · V, |V|) Sik n · V, |V| = (mi + mk )3 mi mk . 2n · V
(16.5)
Conservation of momentum and energy is now taken care of by the delta functions appearing in Equation (16.4) [39]. With a slight modification, Equation (16.3) can be extended to the case of a mixture in which a collision can transform the two colliding molecules of species j , l into two molecules of different species k, i (a very particular kind of chemical reaction). In this case the relations between the velocities before and after the encounter are different from the ones used so far, but we may still write a set of equations for the n species: ∂fi ∂fi ∂fi +ξ · + Xi · ∂t ∂x ∂ξ n
lj = (fl fj ∗ − fi fk∗ )Wik (ξ , ξ ∗ |ξ , ξ ∗ ) dξ ∗ dξ dξ ∗ , 3 3 3 k,l,j =1 R ×R ×R
(16.6)
where Wik gives the probability density that a transition from velocities ξ , ξ ∗ to velocities ξ , ξ ∗ takes place in a collision which transforms two molecules of species l, j , respectively, into two molecules of species i, k, respectively. It is clear how the previous model is included into the new one when the species change does not occur. The idea of kinetic models analogous to the BGK model can be naturally extended to mixtures and polyatomic gases [151,127,81]. A typical collision term of the BGK type will read lj
Ji (fr ) =
n
j =1
Jij (fr ) =
n
νij Φij (ξ ) − fi (ξ ) ,
(16.7)
j =1
where νij are the collision frequencies and Φij is a Maxwellian distribution to be determined by suitable conditions that generalize Equation (9.4). There are some important changes concerning the collision invariants and the definition of macroscopic functions in the case of mixtures. First of all, the collision invariants in
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
45
the case of n species have n components and are defined as follows: ψi (i = 1, . . . , n) is a collision invariant if and only if
i
R3
ψi Qi dξ = 0,
(16.8)
where Qi denotes the right-hand side of Equation (16.1). There are n + 4 rather than 5 linearly independent collision invariants. There are 3 invariants related to momentum conservation, ψ(n+α)i = mi ξα (α = 1, 2, 3), and one related to energy conservation, ψ(n+4)i = mi |ξ |2 ; the remaining n invariants are related to the conservation of the number of particles of each species ψij = δij (i, j = 1, . . . , n). This, of course, applies when there are no chemical reactions. Concerning the macroscopic quantities and their relation to the moments of the distribution functions, we remark that in the case of mixtures it is more convenient to think that the distribution function is normalized as a number density (this has been already taken into account when giving the expression of the collision invariants). Then the number densities of the single species are given by: n(i) =
fi dξ
(i = 1, . . . , n)
(16.9)
and the mass density ρ (i) is given by mi n(i) . The number and mass densities for the mixture are given by: n=
n
n(i) ,
(16.10)
ρ (i) .
(16.11)
i=1
ρ=
n
i=1
It is convenient to define the bulk velocities of the single species and the bulk velocity of the mixture as follows: 3 ξ fi dξ v(i) = R (i = 1, . . . , n), (16.12) R 3 fi dξ ρv =
n
ρ (i) v(i) .
(16.13)
i=1
It is usual to define the peculiar velocity c = ξ − v.
(16.14)
46
C. Cercignani
The stress tensor for the i-th species is given by: (i) pj k
= mi
cj ck fi dξ
(i = 1, . . . , n; j, k = 1, 2, 3);
(16.15)
R3
and the stress tensor for the mixture is the sum of the various stresses: pj k =
n
pj(i)k
(j, k = 1, 2, 3).
(16.16)
i=1
It is to be remarked that, though these definitions are the most common and natural, they are not used by all the authors. One might, e.g., define a peculiar velocity for each species and use it to define the partial stresses. Then it is no longer true that the stress tensor for the mixture is the sum of the partial stresses. Similarly the thermal energy per unit mass (associated with random motions) is defined for each species by: (i) (i)
n e
1 = 2
R3
|c|2 fi dξ
(i = 1, . . . , n)
(16.17)
and for the mixture by: ρe =
n
ρ (i) e(i) .
(16.18)
i=1
A similar procedure can be applied to the heat flow. The pressure is, as usual, 1/3 of the trace of the stress matrix and is related to the temperature by p = nkB T . Please remark that there is not a constant R such that p = ρRT .
17. Polyatomic gases A possible picture of a molecule of a polyatomic gas, suggested by quantum mechanics, is as follows [172]. The molecule is a mechanical system, which differs from a point mass by having a sequence of internal states, which can be identified by a label, assuming integral values. In the simplest cases these states differ from each other because the molecule has, besides kinetic energy, an internal energy taking different values Ei in each of the different states. A collision between two molecules, besides changing the velocities, can also change the internal states of the molecules and, as a consequence, the internal energy enters in the energy balance. From the viewpoint of writing evolution equations for the statistical behavior of the system, it is convenient to think of a single polyatomic gas as a mixture of different monatomic gases. Each of these gases is formed by the molecules corresponding to a given internal energy, and a collision changing the internal state of at least one molecule is considered as a reactive collision of the kind considered above,
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
47
Wik (ξ , ξ ∗ |ξ , ξ ∗ ) giving the probability density of a collision transforming two molecules with internal states l, j , respectively, and velocities ξ , ξ ∗ , respectively, into molecules with internal states i, k, respectively, and velocities ξ , ξ ∗ , respectively. This model is amply sufficient to discuss aerodynamic applications. We want to mention, however, that it requires nondegenerate levels of internal energy, if there are, e.g., strong magnetic fields which can act on the internal variables such as (typically) the spin of the molecules. In that case, if the molecule has spin s, the distribution function f becomes a square matrix of order 2s + 1 and the kinetic equation reflects the fact that matrices in general do not commute and, as remarked by Waldmann [170,171] and Snider [152], the collision term contains not simply the cross-section but the scattering amplitude, which may not commute with f . It is appropriate now to enquire why we started talking about quantum rather than classical mechanics. The main reason is not related to practice, but rather to history. Classical models of polyatomic molecules are regarded with suspicion since 1887 when Lorentz found a mistake in the proof of the H theorem of Boltzmann [23] for general polyatomic molecules. The question arises from the fact that when one proves the H theorem for a monatomic gas one usually does not explicitly underline (because it is irrelevant in that case) that the velocities ξ and ξ ∗ are not the velocities into which a collision transforms the velocities ξ and ξ ∗ , but the velocities which are transformed by a collision into the latter ones; this is conceptually very important, but the lack of a detailed discussion does not lead to any inconvenience because the expressions for ξ ∗ and ξ are invariant with respect to a change of sign of the unit vector n, which permits an equivalence between velocity pairs that are carried into the pair ξ ∗ , ξ and those which originate from the latter pair, as a consequence of a collision. The remarkable circumstance which we have just recalled is related to the particular symmetry of a collision described by a central force, which allows to associate to a collision [ξ ∗ , ξ ] → [ξ ∗ , ξ ] another collision, the socalled “inverse collision” [ξ ∗ , ξ ] → [ξ ∗ , ξ ], which differs from the former just because of the transformation of the unit vector n into −n. When polyatomic molecules are dealt with, the states before and after a collision require more than just the velocities of the mass centers to be described (the angular velocity, e.g., if the molecule is pictured as a solid body). Let us symbolically denote by [A, B] the state of the pair of molecules. Then there is no guarantee that one can correlate an “inverse collision” [A , B ] → [A, B], differing from the previous one just because of the change of n into −n with the collision [A, B] → [A , B ]. Now in the original proof of the H theorem for polyatomic molecules proposed by Boltzmann [23], the assumption was implicitly made that there is always such collision. Lorentz remarked [119,24,26] that this is not true in general. Boltzmann recognized his blunder and proposed another proof based on the so-called “closed cycles of collisions” [119,24,26,166]; the initial state [A, B] is reached not through a single collision but through a sequence of collisions. This proof, although called unobjectionable by Lorentz and Boltzmann [26], never satisfied anybody [167,171]. For a while the matter was forgotten till a quantum mechanical proof showed that the required property followed from the unitarity of the S matrix [171]. A satisfactory proof of the inequality required to prove the H theorem for a purely classical, but completely general, model was given only in 1981 [51]. lj
48
C. Cercignani
For aerodynamic applications all these aspects are not so relevant and, in fact, the main problem is to find a sufficiently handy model for practical calculations. Lordi and Mates [118] studied the “two centers of repulsion” model and found that a rather complicated numerical solution was required for a given set of impact parameters. The lack of closed form expressions makes the model impractical for applications, where the numerical solution describing the collision should be repeated many millions of times. Curtiss and Muckenfuss [132] developed the collision mechanics of the so-called spherocylinder model, consisting of a smooth elastic cylinder with two hemispherical ends. Whether or not two molecules collide depends on more than one parameter; in addition, there are several “chattering” collisions in a single collision event. The loaded-sphere model had been already developed by Jeans [94] in 1904 and was subsequently developed by Dahler and Sather [69] and Sandler and Dahler [146]. Although it is spherical in geometry, the molecules rotate about the center of mass, which does not coincide with the center of the sphere, with the consequence that it has essentially the same disadvantages as the sphero-cylinder model. The only exact model which is amenable to explicit calculations is the perfectly rough sphere model, first suggested by Bryan [28] in 1894. The name is due to the fact that the relative velocity at the point of contact of the two molecules is reversed by the collision. This model has some obvious disadvantages. First, a glancing collision may result in a large deflection; second, all collisions can produce a large interchange of rotational and translational energy, with the consequence that the relaxation time for rotational energy is unrealistically short; third, the number of internal degrees of freedom is three, rather than two, which makes the model inappropriate for a description of the main components of air, which are diatomic gases. One can disregard the first disadvantage and put a remedy to the second by assuming that a fraction of collisions follow the smooth-sphere rather that rough-sphere dynamics; but there is obviously no escape from the third difficulty. In practical calculations, one has learned, since long time, that one must compromise between the faithful adherence to a microscopic model and the computational time required to solve a concrete problem. This was true in the early days of rarefied gas dynamics (and may still be true nowadays when one tries to find approximate closed form solutions or spare computer time) even for monatomic gases, as we discussed in Section 9 (in connection with the BGK model) and shall discuss later (in connection with Direct Simulation Monte Carlo). As a matter of fact, when trying to solve the Boltzmann equation, one of the major shortcomings is the complicated structure of the collision term; if to this problem, present even in the simplest case, one adds the complication of the presence of internal degrees of freedom, any practical problem becomes intractable, unless one is ready to accept the aforementioned compromise. Fortunately, when one is not interested in fine details, it is possible to obtain reasonable results by replacing the collision integral by a phenomenological collision model, e.g., a simpler expression which retains only the qualitative and average properties of the true collision term. As computers become more and more powerful, the amount of phenomenological simplification diminishes and the calculations may more closely mimic the microscopic models. For polyatomic gases, the basic new fact with respect to the monatomic ones is that the total energy is redistributed between translational and internal degrees of freedom at each collision. Those collisions for which this redistribution is negligible are called elastic,
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
49
while the others are called inelastic. The simplest approach would be to calculate the effect of collisions as a linear combination of totally elastic and completely inelastic collisions, the second contribution being described by a model analogous to the BGK model which was described in Section 9. There are, of course, problems related to the molecule spins and their alignment; they are particularly important when we put the molecules in a magnetic field and peculiar phenomena, which go under the general name of Senftleben–Beenakker effects, arise. There is an entire book devoted to this topic [122] and we shall not deal with these problems. Let us now consider in more detail the case of a continuous internal-energy variable. In this case, it is convenient to take the unit vector n in the center-of-mass system and use the internal energy Ei and Ei∗ of the colliding molecules. As usual, the values before a collision will be denoted by a prime. Equation (1.2) is replaced by Q(f, f ) =
R3
dξ ∗
0
E−Ei
× 0
∞
n−2 2
Ei∗ dEi∗
(Ei∗ )
n−2 2
S2
E 0
(Ei )
n−2 2
dEi
dEi∗ (f f∗ − ff∗ )
× B(E; n · n ; Ei , Ei∗ → Ei , Ei∗ ).
(17.1)
Here E = m|ξ |2 /4 + Ei + Ei∗ is the total energy in the center-of-mass system which is conserved in a collision. The kernel B satisfies the reciprocity relation → Ei , Ei∗ ) |V|B(E; n · n ; Ei , Ei∗ = |V |B(E; n · n ; Ei , Ei∗ → Ei , Ei∗ ).
(17.2)
Here we follow a paper by Kušˇcer [111] and look for a one-parameter family of models, assuming that the scattering is isotropic in the center-of-mass system. The second crucial assumption will be that the redistribution of energy among the various degrees of freedom only depends upon the ratios of the various energies to the total energy E, εi = Ei /E, etc. This assumption is valid for collisions of rigid elastic bodies and can be considered as a good approximation for steep repulsive potentials. It is then possible to write B in the following form: → Ei , Ei∗ ) |V|B(E; n · n ; Ei , Ei∗
=
|V |2 σtot (E) θ (εi , εi∗ → εi , εi∗ ; τ ). |V| 4πE n
(17.3)
The denominator on the right takes care of normalization. Then the function θ satisfies the following relations:
1
ε 0
n−2 2
1−ε
dε 0
n−2
ε∗ 2 dε∗ θ (εi , εi∗ → εi , εi∗ ; τ ) = 1,
(17.4)
50
C. Cercignani (1 − εi − εi∗ )θ (εi , εi∗ → εi , εi∗ ; τ ) = (1 − εi − εi∗ )θ (εi , εi∗ → εi , εi∗ ; τ ).
(17.5)
The dependence of σtot on E makes it possible to adjust the model to the correct dependence of the viscosity on temperature. The parameter τ is chosen in such a way as to represent the degree of inelasticity of the collisions. τ = 0 corresponds to elastic collisions: → εi , εi∗ ; 0) = ε− θ (εi , εi∗
n−2 2
− n−2 2
ε∗
= δ(εi − εi )δ(εi − εi∗ ).
(17.6)
τ = ∞ corresponds to maximally inelastic collisions: → εi , εi∗ ; ∞) = ε− θ (εi , εi∗
n−2 2
− n−2 2
ε∗
Γ (n + 2) (1 − εi − ε∗i ). (Γ (n))2
(17.7)
A mixture of the two extreme cases gives the model first proposed by Borgnakke and Larsen [27] in 1975: θ (εi , εi∗ → εi , εi∗ ; τ )
→ εi , εi∗ ; 0) + 1 − e−τ θ (εi , εi∗ → εi , εi∗ ; ∞). = e−τ θ (εi , εi∗
(17.8)
Kušˇcer [111] notices an analogy between this model and Maxwell’s model for gas-surface interaction, as discussed Section 11, and introduces another model, called the theta model, which would correspond to the Cercignani–Lampis model in this analogy. The Larsen–Borgnakke model has become a customary tool in numerical simulations of polyatomic gases. It can be also applied to the vibrational modes through either a classical procedure that assigns a continuously distributed vibrational energy to each molecule, or through a quantum approach that assigns discrete vibrational levels to each molecule. It would be out of place here to discuss this point in more detail, for which we refer to the book of Bird [20]. We also refrain from discussing the interesting recent developments [12, 13] of an old idea of Boltzmann [25,42] to interpret, in the frame of classical statistical mechanics, the circumstance that at low temperatures the internal degrees of freedom appear to be frozen, as due to the extremely long relaxation times for the energy transfer process. The Larsen–Borgnakke model suffers from the limitation that it considers all the collisions as a mixture of the elastic or completely inelastic collisions, disregarding the possibility of a partially inelastic one. In order to construct a more general model we use a procedure which was first used to deal with models for boundary conditions [43,39,35]. We → ε , ε ), which is chosen on the basis start from a sensible approximate kernel θ0 (εi , εi1 i i1 of intuition, but does not satisfy the basic properties (17.4) and (17.5). At this point we add to it some other terms, which ensure that the three fundamental properties are satisfied, as follows: → εi , εi1 ) θ (εi , εi1 = θ0 (εi , εi1 → εi , εi1 )
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
+
51
Γ (n + 2) (1 − εi − εi1 ) 1 − H (εi , εi1 ) 1 − H (εi , εi1 ) /I, 2 (Γ (n))
H (εi , εi1 )=
1 0 0
1−εi
n−2 2
θ0 (εi , εi1 → εi , εi1 ) εi
n−2
εi12 dεi dεi1 ,
Γ (n + 2) (Γ (n))2 1 1−εi n−2 n−2 × (1 − εi − εi1 ) H (εi , εi1 ) εi 2 εi12 dεi dεi1 .
(17.9)
I =1−
0
(17.10)
0
As in the aforementioned case, Equation (17.9) may be interpreted as the linear ) is a sort combination of two normalized kernels θ1 (. . .) and θ2 (. . .), while H (εi , εi1 of accommodation coefficient depending on the energies of the impinging molecules ) must lay in the interval [0, 1]); we write (H (εi , εi1 )θ1 (. . .) + 1 − H (εi , εi1 ) θ2 (. . .), θ (. . .) = H (εi , εi1 ); θ0 (. . .) = θ1 (. . .)H (εi , εi1
θ2 (. . .) =
(17.11)
Γ (n + 2) (1 − εi − εi1 ) 1 − H (εi , εi1 ) /I. 2 (Γ (n))
The expression of θ2 (. . .) is suggested by the requirement that the product (1 − ))θ (. . .) must satisfy reciprocity; the definition of I is chosen in order to get H (εi , εi1 2 the normalization of θ2 (. . .). → ε , ε ; a, b), Cercignani and Lampis [52] proposed the following kernel θ0 (εi , εi1 i i1 containing two parameters a and b. θ0 (εi , εi1 → εi , εi1 ; a, b) =
1/2 ba − n−2 − n−2 − n−2 − n−2 (1 − εi − εi1 ) 4 εi 4 εi1 4 εi 4 εi1 π (1 − εi − εi1 )1/2 2 2 × exp −a(εi − ε ) − a(εi1 − εi1 ) . (17.12)
In order to avoid a singularity in the expression of the kernel (17.12) and therefore also in ), it is assumed that E − E − E = mc 2 /4 > τ , where τ is a little positive that of H (εi , εi1 r i i1 ) are limited. This approximate kernel θ (. . .) for parameter: then θ0 (. . .) and H (εi , εi1 0 , ε , ε ), so that the full kernel given by Equation (10) tends to a → ∞ tends to bθel (εi , εi1 i i1 the Larsen–Borgnakke model. For finite values of a, θ0 (. . .) describes a collision in which ), but may be different, according to εi is not exactly equal to εi (and similarly for εi1 , εi1 a Gaussian distribution. By fitting the theoretical expression for viscosity with some experimental data (from standard handbooks), the aforementioned authors [52] have obtained the values of the parameters in the case of N2 and O2 .
52
C. Cercignani
The aforementioned authors, in a joint paper with J. Struckmeyer [56,57,55], found that a good fitting of some experimental data given in [99] can be obtained. However, they were unable to obtain a unique determination of the parameters a and b. Some examples of possible choices of a and b have been given in [52], in the case of N2 and O2 . In those examples, low values of a, for instance, a = 1, a = 0.1, and for each of them a value of b close to its maximum value, were chosen, but it is also possible to choose much higher values of a. In order to obtain more information about the values of the parameters a and b, an obvious way would be to try to fit a second transport coefficient. Unfortunately, the experimental data for ηv versus temperature are very scanty [141,73]. The bulk viscosity of gases can only be measured by the attenuation and dispersion of an ultrasonic, acoustic signal. Moreover, it is a difficult method subject to experimental error [73]. Because of this, it is not possible to draw conclusions on the range of applicability of the model. In the application of the kernel to the calculation of transport coefficients, everything does work also without introducing the cut-off. The situation may be different in other problems, for instance in the application of DSMC. Therefore a similar model that does not present singularities and does not require a cut-off was introduced [56], based on the following kernel: → εi , εi1 ; a, b) θ0 (εi , εi1
=
2ba − n−2 (1 − εi − εi1 ) − n−2 − n−2 − n−2 4 εi 4 εi1 4 εi 4 εi1 ) π (1 − εi − εi1 ) + (1 − εi − εi1 2 2 ) . × exp −a(εi − ε ) − a(εi1 − εi1
(17.13)
Using this kernel, the authors repeated the calculation of heat conductivity, which follows the same procedure as before. The results given in [52] about heat conductivity versus temperature are identical to those calculated with the new kernel. We end this review of models for polyatomic gases by remarking that a model generalizing the ES model (see Section 9) to polyatomic gases has been discussed by Andries et al. [3], who have also shown that the H -theorem holds for this model for polyatomic gases as well. Concerning the boundary conditions for the distribution function for polyatomic gases, we remark that there is not much material published on this subject, perhaps because the theory is not so different from that holding in the monatomic case. Concerning specific models, one should mention an extension of the CL model to polyatomic molecules proposed by Lord [117] as a generalization of the Cercignani–Lampis model [48].
18. Chemistry and radiation Chemical reactions are important in high altitude flight because of the high temperatures which develop near a vehicle flying at hypersonic speed (i.e., at Mach numbers larger than 5). Up to 2000 K, the composition of air can be considered to be the same as at standard conditions. Beyond this temperature, N2 and O2 begin to react and form NO. At
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
53
2500 K diatomic oxygen begins to dissociate and form atomic oxygen O, till O2 completely disappears at about 4000 K. Nitrogen begins to dissociate at a slightly higher temperature (about 4250 K). NO disappears at about 5000 K. Ionization phenomena start at about 8500 K. As we implicitly remarked when we wrote Equation (16.6), the kinetic theory of gases is an ideal tool to deal with chemical reactions of a particular kind, i.e. bimolecular reactions, which can be written schematically as A + B ↔ C + D,
(18.1)
where A, B, C and D represent different molecular species. We already used the term “molecule”, as usual in kinetic theory, to mean also atom (a monatomic molecule); in this section we shall further enlarge the meaning of this term to include ions, electrons and photons as well, when we have to deal with ionization reactions and interaction with radiation. As long as the reaction takes place in a single step with the presence of no other species than the reactants, it is a well-known circumstance that the change of concentration of a given species (A, say) in a space-homogeneous mixture can be written as follows: dnA = kb (T )nC nD − kf (T )nA nB . dt
(18.2)
We remark that, in chemistry, one uses the molar density in place of the number density used here, the two being obviously related through Avogadro’s number. The rate coefficients kf and kb for the forward and backward (or reverse) reactions, respectively, are functions of temperature and are usually written by a semiempirical argument, which generalizes the Arrhenius formula, in the form: Ea k(T ) = ΛT η exp − , kT
(18.3)
where Λ and η (= 0 in the Arrhenius equation) are constants, and Ea is the so-called activation energy of the reaction. It is clear that these equations, though having a flavor of kinetic theory, are essentially macroscopic and can be assumed to hold when the distribution function is essentially Maxwellian. In fact, the above reaction theory can be obtained by assuming that the distribution functions are Maxwellians, whereas the role of internal degrees of freedom may be ignored and the reaction cross-section vanishes if the translational energy Et in the center-of-mass system is less than Ea and equals a constant σR if the energy is larger than Ea . A more accurate theory is obtained [18–20] by assuming that the ratio of the reaction cross-section to the total cross-section is zero when the total collision energy Ec (equal to the sum of Et and the total internal energy of the two colliding molecules Ei ) is less than Ea and proportional to the product of a power of Ec −Ea and a power of Ec . The exponents and the proportionality factor are essentially dictated by the number of internal degrees of freedom, the exponent of the temperature in the diffusion coefficient of species A in species B and
54
C. Cercignani
the empirical exponent η appearing in Equation (18.3). This theory provides a microscopic reaction model that can reproduce the conventional rate Equations (18.2)–(18.3) in the continuum limit. The model is, however, as in the case of gas-surface interaction and models for polyatomic gases, largely based on phenomenological considerations and mathematical tractability. The ideal microscopic model would consist of complete tabulations of the differential cross-sections as functions of the energy states and n. Some microscopic data, coming from extensive quantum-mechanical computations, supported by experiments, are available, but, unfortunately, not very much is known for reactions of engineering interest. When comparisons can be made, the reaction cross-section provided by the phenomenological model is of the correct order of magnitude. This provides some reasons of optimism about the validity of the results obtained with these models for the highly non-equilibrium rarefied gas flows. Termolecular reactions provide some difficulty to kinetic theory, because the Boltzmann equation essentially describes the effect of binary collisions. They are, however, of essential importance in high-temperature air, where the reverse (or backward) reaction of a dissociation one is a recombination reaction, which is necessarily termolecular, as we shall presently explain. A typical dissociation-recombination reaction can be represented as AB + X ↔ A + B + X,
(18.4)
where AB, A, B and X represent the dissociating molecule, the two molecules produced by the dissociation and a third molecule (of any species), respectively. The latter molecule, in the forward reaction, collides with AB and causes its dissociation. This process is described by a binary collision and is an endothermic reaction, requiring a certain amount of energy, the dissociation energy Ed . The recombination process is an exothermic reaction and it might seem that one could dispense with the “third body” X and consider it as a bimolecular reaction AB ← A + B.
(18.5)
However, one can easily see that the energy balance for this event cannot be satisfied in the presence of energy release. In fact if two molecules form an isolated system and are assumed to interact with a potential energy which is attractive at large distances and repulsive at short distances, they can come close enough to orbit one about the other but the repulsive part will eventually separate them. In fact, they cannot form a stable molecule; this is seen by writing the energy equation in the center-of-mass system. The final kinetic energy in this reference system should be zero for the molecule whereas it was positive when the two molecules approached each other and the potential energy is negative. A third molecule X is required to describe the recombination process. In order to keep the binary collision analysis, appropriate for a rarefied gas, we must think of the recombination process as a sequence of two binary collisions. The first of these forms an (unstable) orbiting pair P , that is stabilized by a second collision of this pair with X, as long as this collision occurs within a sufficiently small elapsed time. One can then extend the previous theory based on a binary collision analysis. If the activation energy is assumed to be zero, then the main change is that the cross section acquires a factor proportional to the number density of the species X.
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
55
This simple theory is based on a molecular interaction that is attractive at large distance and repulsive at short distances. One can assume a highly simplified scheme by taking a hard sphere core with diameter σ and a scattering of the square-well type at some larger distance σ∗ . The potential energy is, say, −Q (Q > 0) between σ and σ∗ . Then if m is the mass of a molecule A, for a distance r > σ∗ , the trajectory of one molecule with respect to the other before the interaction begins, will be a straight line r cos ϑ = b (in polar coordinates), where b is the impact parameter. The condition b < σ∗ must be satisfied if the molecules actually interact. Then, assuming for simplicity that A = B (as in the case of recombination of oxigen) the conservation of energy and angular momentum give
d 1 dϑ r
2 +
1 4Q 1 − = r 2 mV 2 b2
(18.6)
(σ < r < σ∗ ),
where V is, as usual, the relative speed. We easily verify that the trajectory has a corner point at a distance r = σ∗ and the molecule we are following is deflected toward the other by an angle −1
θ0 = cos
b σ∗
−1
− cos
b 4Q −1/2 1+ . σ∗ mV 2
(18.7)
The orbiting pair P has in this case a very simple motion: in fact the molecules A approach each other and then have a hard sphere collision. After that they tend to separate again; and the “molecule” P will disappear and two molecules A emerge again, unless a third molecule X collides with P , which is stabilized into a A2 . The unstable pair P is endowed with an internal energy EB =
m 2 V + Q. 4
(18.8)
This energy is stored to be, possibly, converted into kinetic energy (and hence, from a macroscopic viewpoint, heat of reaction) through the process (18.4). Even for this simple scheme we must write three Boltzmann equations: one for the species A, one for the species A2 and one for the unstable species P ; even if A is monatomic A2 and P are diatomic and hence have an internal energy. The species X used in the above argument can be any of the three aforementioned species. The species A loses particles when colliding with A (formation of P ) and P gains in the same process, but loses in most collisions undergone by a P molecule. This model can be slightly complicated by assuming that there is a potential barrier between σ∗ and σ∗∗ (σ∗∗ > σ∗ ). If the potential energy is Ea > 0 for these distances between the A molecules, then the formation can occur if, and only if, the relative speed V is larger than 4Ea /m. Then Ea plays the role of the activation energy. The resulting system of Boltzmann equations reads as follows: ∂f ∂f +ξ · = −2 ∂t ∂x
R3
B+
r ff∗ BAA dξ ∗ dn +
R3
(f F∗ − fg∗ )BAA2 dξ ∗ dn
B+
56
C. Cercignani
+ +
∂F ∂F +ξ · =2 ∂t ∂x
R 3 B+
R 3 B+
R 3 B+
+ +
∂g ∂g +ξ · = ∂t ∂x
R 3 B+
R3
R 3 B+
F g∗ BBA2 dξ ∗ dn +
R 3 B+
−
(f F∗ − f F∗ )BAA2 dξ ∗ dn,
−
e (f f∗ − ff∗ )BAA dξ ∗ dn
B+
R 3 B+
f g∗ BBA dξ ∗ dn
F g∗ BBA2 dξ ∗ dn (F f∗ − Ff∗ )BAA2 dξ ∗ dn (F F∗ − F F∗ )BA2 A2 dξ ∗ dn,
r f f∗ BAA dξ ∗ dn −
R 3 B+
(18.9)1
gF∗ BBA2 dξ ∗ dn,
(18.9)2
R 3 B+
gf∗ BBA dξ ∗ dn (18.9)3
where f , F , and g denote the distribution functions for species A, A2 , and B, whereas the superscripts r and e are used to discriminate between reactive and elastic collisions when necessary. For simplicity, we have omitted indicating the internal energies of particles A2 and B. The factors 2 take into account the fact that 2 particles of a species disappear or appear at the same time. Models to deal with a chemically reactive gas, akin to the BGK one have been discussed by Yoshizawa [178]. Ionization reactions involve the electronic states and it is unlikely that a purely classical theory will be successful in describing them, because of the selection rules. Yet, one can use the phenomenological approach to provide at least an upper bound for the reaction rates. As mentioned above, one can, in principle, think of interaction with radiation as if it were a reaction involving photons as “molecules”. Here spontaneous emission should also be taken into account. It becomes harder to develop phenomenological models, because one should consider as many species as there are excited levels for each molecule. Photons can be described by means of the so-called radiative transfer (or radiation transport) equation, which looks like a Boltzmann equation. The analogy is, however, in a sense, artificial, because the number of photons is not conserved. ∂f ∂f + cω · ∂t ∂x
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
=
R3
K(x, k → k)f (x, k ) dk − ν(x, k)f (x, k) + s(x, k).
57
(18.10)
Here K is the scattering probability from a wavevector k to a wavevector k. The direction of k is given by ω and its magnitude is the radiation frequency multiplied by the speed of light c, not to be confused with ν(x, k), the total frequency of scattering and absorption events. The term s(x, k) describes the volume radiation source, due to photon emission. If inelastic scattering effects, like fluorescence and stimulated emission, are neglected, then there is no interaction between photons of different frequency and we can replace the arguments by k and k by the corresponding unit vectors ω and ω . The emission term can be expressed as a product of the Planck distribution by the volume emission coefficient ε|k|,T . Boundary conditions for radiation can be described in a way similar to that used for gas-surface interaction. Of course, emission and absorption of radiation occur, along with reflection [149,96]. 19. The DSMC method Kinetic models and perturbation methods are very useful in obtaining approximate solutions and forming qualitative ideas on the solutions of practical problems, but in general they are not sufficient to provide detailed and precise answers for practical problems. Various numerical procedures exist which either attempt to solve for f by conventional techniques of numerical analysis or efficiently by-pass the formalism of the integrodifferential equation and simulate the physical situation that the equation describes (Monte Carlo simulation). Only recently proofs have been given that these partly deterministic, partly stochastic games provide solutions that converge (in a suitable sense) to solutions of the Boltzmann equation. Numerical solutions of the Boltzmann equation based on finite difference methods meet with severe computational requirements due to the large number of independent variables. The only method that has been used for space-inhomogeneous problems in more than one space dimension is the technique of Hicks, Yen and Nordsiek [136,177], which is based on a Monte Carlo quadrature method to evaluate the collision integral. This method was further developed by Aristov and Tcheremissine [4,164] and has been applied with some success to a few two-dimensional flows [165,45]. An additional difficulty for traditional numerical methods is the fact that chemically reacting and thermally radiating flows (and even simpler flows of polyatomic gases) are hard to describe with theoretical models having the same degree of accurateness as the Boltzmann equation for monatomic nonreacting and nonradiating gases. These considerations paved the way to the development of simulation schemes, which started with the work of Bird on the so-called Direct Simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) method [17] and have become a powerful tool for practical calculations. There appear to be very few limitations to the complexity of the flow fields that this approach can deal with. Chemically reacting and ionized flows can be and have been analysed by these methods. A problem which arises in the applications of the DSMC method is the choice of a model for the molecular collisions. The issue is to have simple computing rules by discarding what
58
C. Cercignani
is physically insignificant. In the case of monatomic gases, the relation of the deflection angle to the impact parameter and the relative speed appears to be the most important piece of physics. It turns out, however, that the scattering law has little effect and that the observable effects are strongly correlated with the cross-section change with relative speed. This realization led to the idea of the variable hard-sphere (VHS) model [19] which combines the scattering simplicity of the hard-sphere model with a variable cross-section based on a molecular diameter proportional to some power ω − 1/2 of the relative speed (ω being the power of absolute temperature ruling the change of the viscosity coefficient). This does not produce problems in a single gas, because the heat conductivity varies with approximately the same law as the viscosity coefficient, but problems arise for mixtures. If one wants the correct diffusion coefficient, another modification is needed. Koura and Matsumoto [107] developed the variable soft sphere (VSS) model, which introduces an additional power law parameter and gives the necessary flexibility for mixtures. More complicated models can be devised when the attractive part of the intermolecular force is taken into account [84]. A simpler method has also been proposed [97]. Before discussing the DSMC method and some of its applications in some detail, we remark that, although the DSMC has no rivals for practical computations, some other methods may turn out to be of interest in the future if much more powerful computers will be available. Thus, e.g., discrete velocity models have been an intensely studied subject for many years, before becoming a systematic method of approximating the Boltzmann equation. The DSMC method, the molecular collisions are considered on a probabilistic rather than a deterministic basis. The main aim is to calculate practical flows through the use of the collision mechanics of model molecules. In fact, the real gas is modeled by some hundred thousands or millions of simulated molecules on a computer. For each of them the space coordinates and velocity components (as well as the variables describing the internal state, if we deal with polyatomic molecules) are stored in the memory and are modified with time as the molecules are simultaneously followed through representative collisions and boundary interactions in the simulated region of space. In most applications, the number of simulated molecules is extremely small in comparison with the number of molecules that would be present in a real gas flow. Thus, in the simulation, each model molecule is representing the appropriate number of real molecules, The calculation is unsteady and the steady solutions are obtained as asymptotic limits of unsteady solutions. The flow field is subdivided into cells, which are taken to be small enough for the solution to be approximately constant through the cell. The time variable is advanced in discrete steps of size ∆t, small with respect to the mean free time, i.e., the time between two subsequent collisions of a molecule. This permits a separation of the inertial motion of the molecules from the collision process: one first moves the molecules according to collisionfree dynamics and subsequently the velocities are modified according to the collisions occurring in each cell. The rate of occurrence of collisions is given by (hard spheres): r=
i,j
rij ,
(19.1)
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
rij =
ρ n · (ξ i − ξ j ) dn, Nm B+
59
(19.2)
where N is the number of molecules in the sample and ξ i is the velocity of the i-th molecule (i = 1, . . . , N). Each time a collision occurs, the velocities of a collision pair are modified (and, as a consequence, r also varies). Let Tk be the length of the time interval between the (k − 1)-th and the k-th collision in the time interval [0, ∆t] (t = 0 is the time of the 0-th collision by definition). The time intervals Tk are chosen in this way: after the (k − 1)-th collision, one samples a pair (i, j ) on the basis of the probability distribution pij = rij /r (with a fixed velocity for each pair); then one takes Tk = 2N/[(N − 1)rij ]. Then one samples a direction ω of the post-collisional velocity ξ i − ξ j with the probability + distribution p(ω) = rij /r (fixed i, j and |ξ i − ξ j |) and replaces ξ i and ξ j by ξ + i and ξ j , given by ξ+ i =
1 ξ + ξ j + ω|ξ i − ξ j | , 2 i
(19.3)
1 ξ i + ξ j − ω|ξ i − ξ j | . (19.4) 2 The operation is repeated until k Tk exceeds ∆T. Some variations of Bird’s method have appeared, due to Koura [104], Belotserkovskii and Yanitskii [11], Deshpande [72]. They differ from Bird’s method because of the procedure used to sample the time interval between two subsequent collisions. In particular Koura [104] introduced the so-called “null collision technique”, which uses, for models different from hard spheres, the maximum of the cross-section, when estimating the possible collisions. Then for values of the cross-section less than the maximum, some collisions produce a null effect. A different method was proposed by Nanbu [133]. One does not subdivide ∆t and works with the probability Pi that the i-th molecule collides in [0, ∆t]. One has ξ+ i =
Pi = ∆t
N
(19.5)
rij .
j =1
One starts with rij evaluated at t = 0 and samples a random number ω in [0, 1]. According to whether ω is smaller or larger than Pi , the i-th molecule collides or does not collide in [0, ∆t]. If a collision occurs, one samples a collision partner of the i-th molecule from the probability distribution rij (i) Pj = N
k=1 rik
.
(19.6)
+ Then one samples a direction ω of the post-collisional velocity ξ + i − ξ j with the + probability distribution p(ω) = rij /r (for fixed values of i, j and |ξ + i − ξ j |) and replaces ξ i by ξ + i given by Equation (19.3). Then the procedure is repeated for all the values of i.
60
C. Cercignani
The method of Nanbu was criticized by Koura [103], who asserted that momentum and energy are not conserved by collisions, because one does not change the velocity of the j -th molecule, when one changes the velocity of the i-th molecule. The criticism is not wellfounded, however, because, as Nanbu pointed out [134], the Boltzmann equation requires the overall conservation of momentum and energy of the system at each space point, not the conservation of the same quantities at each single simulated event. What is new in Nanbu’s method is precisely the circumstance that it does not try to simulate the N -body dynamics, but rather the description of the system described by the Boltzmann equation. Nanbu’s method is now well understood, from both a physical and mathematical standpoint and has been rigorously proven to yield approximations to solutions of the Boltzmann equation, provided the number of test molecules is sufficiently large. The relevant theorem reads as follows [7,8]: T HEOREM . If the Boltzmann equation with initial data f0 has a smooth, nonnegative solution f (x, ξ ) ∈ L1 , then the solution fˆ of Nanbu’s method converges weakly in L1 to f , in the sense that, for any test function φ(x, ξ ) ∈ L∞
φ fˆ dx dξ →
φf dx dξ
(19.7)
as N → ∞, ∆x, ∆t → 0. Subsequently, a similar result was proved for Bird’s method [169,142]. The fluctuations inevitably occurring in a DSMC calculation can cause problems if the number of molecules is not large enough to have a representative sample in each area of the flow domain. They can, however, have a physical significance and contain information on those occurring in a real gas. The comparisons between the fluctuations in DSMC and the predictions of fluctuating hydrodynamic theory have been reviewed by Garcia [76] and appear to be consistent with the fluctuations in a real gas. The computing task of a simulation method varies with the molecular model. For models other than Maxwell’s it is proportional to N for Bird’s method, while it is proportional to N 2 for Nanbu’s method. Babovsky [7] found a procedure to reduce the computing task of Nanbu’s method and make it proportional to N . His modification is based on the idea of subdividing the interval [0, 1] into N equal subintervals. If the random number ω lies in the j -th segment, one calculates only Pij = rij ∆t and there is no collision if ω < (j/n) − Pij , there is a collision with the j -th molecule if ω (j/n) − Pij . There is also a condition that Pij must satisfy, i.e., Pij < 1/N , but this is usually automatically verified, given the size of ∆t. Application of Nanbu’s method in the form modified by Babovsky shows that the the computing task is not only theoretically but also practically comparable to that of Bird’s method [80]. This modification eventually evolved into what is called the “Finite-Pointset” method. We remark that one may take advantage of flow symmetries in physical space, but all collisions are calculated as three-dimensional events. As for the boundary conditions, Maxwell’s model of diffuse reflection (see Section 11) is adequate for many problems. There are many cases. The CL model [48] has been
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
61
adapted and extended by Lord [117] for application in DSMC studies. The resulting CLL model [117,150] has been shown to provide a realistic boundary condition with incomplete accommodation [176]. More complicated models would be required to describe chemical reactions which can occur at the surface for high impact energies.
20. Some applications of the DSMC method The first significant application of DSMC method dealt with the structure of a normal shock wave [121], but only a few years later Bird was able to calculate shock profiles [15] that allowed meaningful comparisons with the experimental results then available [16] and with subsequent experiments [147,2]. This long time span is understandable: the method is very demanding of computer resources. In 1964, even with the fastest computers, the restriction on the number of molecules which could be used was such that large random fluctuations had to be expected in the results, and it was difficult to arrive at definite conclusions. Thus the number of simulated molecules and the sample sizes in the computations that could be performed in those years were extremely small in comparison with those that have been routinely employed by an increasing number of workers. The problem of the shock wave structure has continued to be an important test case. Later studies have included comparisons of measured and computed velocity distribution functions within strong shock waves in helium [140]. Early DSMC studies were also devoted to the problem of hypersonic leading edge. This arises in connection with the flow of a gas past a very sharp plate, parallel to the oncoming stream. When the Reynolds number Re = ρ∞ V∞ L/µ∞ , based on the plate length is very large, the picture, familiar from continuum mechanics, of a potential flow plus a viscous boundary layer is valid everywhere except near the leading and the trailing edge. Estimates obtained already in the late 1960s by Stewartson [161] and Messiter [124] showed that the Knudsen number at the trailing edge is of order Ma∞ Re−3/4 , where Ma∞ is the upstream Mach number. As a consequence, kinetic theory is not needed (for large values of Re) at the trailing edge. For the leading edge, the Knudsen number is of order Ma∞ ; hence in supersonic, or, even more, hypersonic flow (Ma∞ 5), the flow in the region about the leading edge must be considered as a typical problem in kinetic theory. In particular, the viscous boundary layer and the outer flow are no longer distinct from each other, although [123,82,95] a shock-like structure may still be identified. It is in this connection that the name of merged-layer regime, mentioned in Section 1, arose. There are several methods based on simplified continuum models, represented by the papers of Oguchi [137], Shorenstein and Probstein [148], Chow [66,67], Rudman and Rubin [145], Cheng et al. [65], and Kot and Turcotte [102], which usefully predict surface and other gross properties in this regime. The good agreement between these approaches and experiment gave new evidence for the the importance of the Navier–Stokes equations. Nevertheless, if we go sufficiently close to the leading edge, the Navier–Stokes equations must be given up in favor of the Boltzmann equation. Huang and coworkers [90,88,89] carried out extensive computations based on discrete ordinate methods for the BGK model and were able to show the process of building the flow picture assumed in the simplified continuum models mentioned above.
62
C. Cercignani
The first DSMC is due to Vogenitz et al. [168] and exhibits a flow structure qualitatively different from the predictions of earlier studies. Their results are supported by the experiments of Metcalf et al. [125]. Validation studies of the DSMC method were also conducted at the Imperial College [83]. Hypersonic flows past blunt bodies were also the object of many simulations, most of the calculations being those made for the Shuttle Orbiter re-entry, for which useful comparisons with measured data were possible [128]. This comparison was concerned with the windward centerline heating and employed an axially symmetric equivalent body. Later comparisons [143] with Shuttle data were for the aerodynamic characteristics of the full three-dimensional shape. Another interesting problem which has been simulated by Ivanov and his coworkers is the reflection on a plane wall of an oblique shock wave generated by a wedge [92,93]. Three-dimensional DSMC calculations have also been made for the flow past a delta wing [29]. The results compare well with wind-tunnel measurements [116] of the flow field under the same conditions. Other important problems are related to separated flows, especially wake flows and flows involving viscous boundary layer separation and reattachment. The first calculations referred to the two-dimensional flow over a sharp flat plate followed by an angled ramp [129]. The results were in a reasonably good agreement with wind tunnel studies, which is not truly two-dimensional because of inevitable sidewall effects. Similar experiments were therefore performed [63] for the corresponding axially symmetric flow, less subject to the aforementioned non-uniformity. The DSMC calculations for these cases [130] show excellent agreement with experimental results. In particular, separation and reattachment of a viscous boundary layer in the laminar regime are correctly predicted. The most remarkable wake flow simulation was for a 70◦ spherically blunted cone model that had been tested in several wind tunnels [1,115]. The results of the calculations [131] of the lee side flow that contains the vortex are in good agreement with the experiments and with Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) studies of the flow based on the Navier–Stokes equations. In the case of polyatomic gases one has several cross-sections, such as elastic, rotational, vibrational, and also reactive, if chemical reactions occur. Koura [105] has extended his null collision technique [104] to these cases and improved it later [106]. He applied this method to simulate the hypersonic rarefied nitrogen flow past a circular cylinder [106], with particular attention to the simulation of the vibrational relaxation of the gas; he also investigated the effect of changing the number of molecules in each (adaptive) cell and the truncation in the molecular levels. The Direct Simulation Monte Carlo method is not only a practical tool for engineers, but also a good method for probing into uncovered areas of the theory of the Boltzmann equation, such as stability of the solutions of this equation and the possible transition to turbulence [156,60,77,78,157,159,158,21,144,160,20]. We finally remark that the Direct Simulation Monte Carlo method has been used even to uncover the analytical nature of a singularity in a limiting solution of the Boltzmann equation, the structure of an infinitely strong shock wave. The latter arises when the temperature upstream of the shock is taken to be zero; then the solution of the Boltzmann equation is the sum of a delta function term and a more regular distribution. The latter was
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
63
approximated by a Maxwellian by H. Grad [79] but turns out to go to infinity [46] when ξ equals the velocity upstream. The DSMC solution gives strong evidence on the nature of the singularity, which is confirmed by a deterministic method [163].
21. Concluding remarks The use of the Boltzmann equation to study rarefied flows has reached a mature stage. The qualitative features are well understood, new phenomena have been uncovered, powerful numerical methods have been developed. Further progress, such as the possibility to indicate that turbulence for gases has features different from turbulence in liquids, depends on the computing power available. The same can be said for the development of deterministic numerical methods as opposed to Monte Carlo. We have not treated all the possible subjects: among the most important omissions, we mention wave propagation, expansion into a vacuum and the application of the Boltzmann equation to the important problems of evaporation and condensation. For these flows, as well as for details on other topics we refer to relevant monographs [43,39] and the literature quoted therein.
References [1] J. Allegre and D. Bisch, Experimental study of a blunted cone at rarefied hypersonic conditions, CNRS Report RC 94-7 (1994). [2] H. Alsmeyer, Density profiles in argon and nitrogen shock waves measured by the absorption of an electron beam, J. Fluid Mech. 74 (1976), 497–513. [3] P. Andries, P. Le Tallec, J.P. Perlat and B. Perthame, The Gaussian-BGK model of Boltzmann equation with small Prandtl number, submitted to Eur. J. Mech. B (2000). [4] V. Aristov and F.G. Tcheremissine, The conservative splitting method for solving the Boltzmann equation, U.S.S.R. Comput. Math. Math. Phys. 20 (1980), 208–225. [5] L. Arkeryd, On the Boltzmann equation. Part II: The full initial value problem, Arch. Rational Mech. Anal. 45 (1972), 17–34. [6] L. Arkeryd and C. Cercignani, On a functional equation arising in the kinetic theory of gases, Rend. Mat. Acc. Lincei 9 11 (1990), 139–149. [7] H. Babovsky, A convergence proof for Nanbu’s Boltzmann simulation scheme, Eur. J. Mech. B 8 (1) (1989), 41–55. [8] H. Babovsky and R. Illner, A convergence proof for Nanbu’s simulation method for the full Boltzmann equation, SIAM J. Numer. Anal. 26 (1989), 45–65. [9] C. Bardos and S. Ukai, The classical incompressible Navier–Stokes limit of the Boltzmann equation, Math. Models Methods Appl. Sci. 1 (1991), 235–257. [10] K. Bärwinkel and S. Schippers, Nonreciprocity in noble-gas metal-surface scattering, Rarefied Gas Dynamics: Space-Related Studies, E.P. Muntz, D.P. Weaver and D.H. Campbell, eds, AIAA, Washington (1989), 487–501. [11] O.M. Belotserkovskii and V. Yanitskii, Statistical particle-in-cell method for solving rarefied gas dynamics problems, Zh. Vychisl. Mat. i Mat. Fiz. 15 (1975), 1195–1203 (in Russian). [12] G. Benettin, L. Galgani and A. Giorgilli, Realization of holonomic constraints and freezing of high frequency degrees of freedom in the light of classical perturbation theory. Part I, Comm. Math. Phys. 113 (1987), 87–103. [13] G. Benettin, L. Galgani and A. Giorgilli, Realization of holonomic constraints and freezing of high frequency degrees of freedom in the light of classical perturbation theory. Part II, Comm. Math. Phys. 121 (1989), 557–601.
64
C. Cercignani
[14] P.L. Bhatnagar, E.P. Gross and M. Krook, A model for collision processes in gases. Small amplitude processes in charged and neutral one-component systems, Phys. Rev. 94 (1954), 511–525. [15] G.A. Bird, Shock wave structure in a rigid sphere gas, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Vol. 1, J.H. deLeeuw, ed., Academic Press, New York (1965), 216–222. [16] G.A. Bird, Aspects of the structure of strong shock waves, Phys. Fluids 13 (1970), 1172–1177. [17] G.A. Bird, Direct Simulation of the Boltzmann equation, Phys. Fluids 13 (1970), 2676–2681. [18] G.A. Bird, Simulation of multi-dimensional and chemically reacting flows, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, R. Campargue, ed., CEA, Paris (1979), 365–388. [19] G.A. Bird, Monte-Carlo simulation in an engineering context, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Part I, AIAA, Washington (1981), 239–255. [20] G.A. Bird, Molecular Gas Dynamics and the Direct Simulation of Gas Flows, Clarendon Press, Oxford (1994). [21] G.A. Bird, The initiation of centrifugal instabilities in an axially symmetric flow, Rarefied Gas Dynamics Symposium 20, Ching Shen, ed., Peking Univ. Press, Beijing (1997), 624–629. [22] R.C. Blanchard, Rarefied flow lift to drag measurement of the Shuttle Orbiter, Paper No. ICAS 86118.10.1, 15th ICAS Congress, London (September 1986). [23] L. Boltzmann, Weitere Studien über das Wärmegleichgewicht unter Gasmolekülen, Sitzungsber. Akad. Wiss. II 66 (1872), 275–370. [24] L. Boltzmann, Neuer Beweis zweier Sätze über das Wärmegleichgewicht unter mehratomigen Gasmolekülen, Sitzungsber. Akad. Wiss. 95 (1887), 153–164. [25] L. Boltzmann, On certain questions of the theory of gases, Nature 51 (1895), 413–415. [26] L. Boltzmann, Vorlesungen über Gastheorie, 2 vols, J.A. Barth, Leipzig (1895–1898). [27] C. Borgnakke and P.S. Larsen, Statistical collision model for Monte Carlo simulation of polyatomic gas mixture, J. Comput. Phys. 18 (1975), 405–420. [28] G.H. Bryan, Rep. Br. Ass. Advant. Sci. 83 (1894). [29] M.C. Celenligil and J.N. Moss, Hypersonic rarefied flow about a delta wing – direct simulation and comparison with experiment, AIAA J. 30 (1992), 2017–2023. [30] C. Cercignani, Plane Poiseuille flow and Knudsen minimum effect, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Vol. II, J.A. Laurman, ed., Academic Press, New York (1963), 92–101. [31] C. Cercignani, Reply to the comments by A.S. Berman, Phys. Fluids 10 (1967), 1859–1860. [32] C. Cercignani, Stokes paradox in kinetic theory, Phys. Fluids 11 (1968), 303–308. [33] C. Cercignani, A variational principle for boundary value problems in kinetic theory, J. Statist. Phys. 1 (1969), 297–311. [34] C. Cercignani, Boundary value problems in linearized kinetic theory, Transport Theory, R. Bellman, G. Birkhoff and I. Abu-Shumays, eds, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI (1969), 249–268. [35] C. Cercignani, Mathematical Methods in Kinetic Theory, Plenum Press, New York (1969; revised edition 1990). [36] C. Cercignani, On the Boltzmann equation for rigid spheres, Transport Theory Statist. Phys. (1972), 211– 225. [37] C. Cercignani, Scattering kernels for gas-surface interactions, Transport Theory Statist. Phys. 2 (1972), 27–53. [38] C. Cercignani, Models for gas-surface interactions: comparison between theory and experiment, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Vol. I, D. Dini et al., eds, Editrice Tecnico-Scientifica, Pisa (1974), 75–96. [39] C. Cercignani, The Boltzmann Equation and its Applications, Springer, New York (1988). [40] C. Cercignani, Are there more than five linearly independent collision invariants for the Boltzmann equation?, J. Statist. Phys. 58 (1990), 817–824. [41] C. Cercignani, Scattering kernels for gas-surface interaction, Proceedings of the Workshop on Hypersonic Flows for Reentry Problems, Vol. I, INRIA, Antibes (1990), 9–29. [42] C. Cercignani, Ludwig Boltzmann. The Man Who Trusted Atoms, Oxford Univ. Press, Oxford (1998). [43] C. Cercignani, Rarefied Gas Dynamics: From Basic Principles to Actual Calculations, Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge (2000). [44] C. Cercignani and A. Daneri, Flow of a rarefied gas between two parallel plates, J. Appl. Phys. 34 (1963), 3509–3513.
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
65
[45] C. Cercignani and A. Frezzotti, Numerical simulation of supersonic rarefied gas flows past a flat plate: effects of the gas-surface interaction model on the flow-field, Rarefied Gas Dynamics: Theoretical and Computational Techniques, E.P. Muntz, D.P. Weaver and D.H. Campbell, eds, AIAA, Washington (1989), 552–566. [46] C. Cercignani, A. Frezzotti and P. Grosfils, The structure of an infinitely strong shock wave, Phys. Fluids 11 (1999), 2757–2764. [47] C. Cercignani, R. Illner and M. Pulvirenti, The Mathematical Theory of Dilute Gases, Springer, New York (1994). [48] C. Cercignani and M. Lampis, Kinetic models for gas-surface interactions, Transport Theory Statist. Phys. 1 (1971), 101–114. [49] C. Cercignani and M. Lampis, Free molecular flow past a flat plate in the presence of a nontrivial gassurface interaction, J. Appl. Math. Phys. (ZAMP) 23 (1972), 715–728. [50] C. Cercignani and M. Lampis, Influence of gas-surface interaction on drag and lift in free-molecular flow, Entropie 44 (1972), 40–46. [51] C. Cercignani and M. Lampis, On the H -theorem for polyatomic gases, J. Statist. Phys. 26 (1981), 795– 801. [52] C. Cercignani and M. Lampis, A new model for the differential cross-section of a polyatomic gas, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Vol. 19, Ching Shen, ed., Peking Univ. Press, Beijing (1997), 731–736. [53] C. Cercignani and M. Lampis, New scattering kernel for gas-surface interaction, AIAA J. 35 (1997), 1000–1001. [54] C. Cercignani, M. Lampis and A. Lentati, A new scattering kernel in kinetic theory of gases, Transport Theory Statist. Phys. 24 (1995), 1319–1336. [55] C. Cercignani, M. Lampis and J. Struckmeier, Applications of a new model for the differential cross section of a classical polyatomic gas, Transport Theory Statist. Phys. 29 (2000), 355–374. [56] C. Cercignani, M. Lampis and J. Struckmeier, New models for the differential cross section of a polyatomic gas in the frame of the scattering kernel theory, Mech. Res. Comm. 25 (1998), 231–236. [57] C. Cercignani, M.C. Lampis and J. Struckmeier, Homogeneous relaxation and shock wave structure for a polyatomic gas, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Vol. II, R. Brun, R. Campargue, R. Gatignol and J.-C. Lengrand, eds, Cépaduès éditions, Toulouse (1999), 61–68. [58] C. Cercignani and C.D. Pagani, Variational approach to boundary-value problems in kinetic theory, Phys. Fluids 9 (1966), 1167–1173. [59] C. Cercignani, C.D. Pagani and P. Bassanini, Flow of a rarefied gas past an axisymmetric body. II. Case of a sphere, Phys. Fluids 11 (1968), 1399–1403. [60] C. Cercignani and S. Stefanov, Bénard’s instability in Kinetic Theory, Transport Theory Statist. Phys. 21 (1992), 371–381. [61] C. Cercignani and G. Tironi, Alcune applicazioni di un nuovo modello linearizzato dell’equazione di Boltzmann, Atti del Congresso Nazionale AIDA-AIR 1965, AIDA-AIR (1967), 174–181. [62] C. Cercignani and G. Tironi, Nonlinear heat transfer between two parallel plates at large temperature ratios, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Vol. I, C.L. Brundin, ed., Academic Press, New York (1967), 441–453. [63] B. Chanetz, Study of axisymmetric shock wave-boundary layer interaction in hypersonic laminar flow, ONERA Report RT 42/4365 AN (1995). [64] S. Chapman and T.G. Cowling, The Mathematical Theory of Non-Uniform Gases, Cambridge Univ. Press, London (1940). [65] H.K. Cheng, S.Y. Chen, R. Mobly and C. Huber, On the hypersonic leading-edge problem in the mergedlayer regime, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Vol. I, L. Trilling and H.Y. Wachman, eds, Academic Press, New York (1969), 1451–1463. [66] W.L. Chow, Hypersonic rarefied flow past the sharp leading-edge of a flat plate, AIAA J. 5 (1967), 1549– 1557. [67] W.L. Chow, Hypersonic slip flow past the sharp leading-edge of a flat plate, AIAA J. 4 (1968), 2062–2063. [68] T.G. Cowling, On the Cercignani–Lampis formula for gas-surface interactions, J. Phys. D. Appl. Phys. 7 (1974), 781–785. [69] J.S. Dahler and N.F. Sather, Kinetic theory of loaded spheres. I, J. Chem. Phys. 38 (1962), 2363–2382. [70] J.-S. Darrozès and J.-P. Guiraud, Généralisation formelle du théorème H en présence de parois. Applications, C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris Ser. A 262, 1368–1371.
66
C. Cercignani
[71] A. De Masi, R. Esposito and J.L. Lebowitz, Incompressible Navier–Stokes equations and Euler limit of the Boltzmann equation, Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 42 (1989), 1189–1214. [72] S.M. Deshpande, Dept. Aero. Engng. Indian Inst. Science Rep. 78, FM4 (1978). [73] G. Emanuel, Bulk viscosity of a dilute polyatomic gas, Phys. Fluids A 2 (1990), 2252–2254. [74] D. Enskog, Kinetische theorie der Vorgänge in mässig verdünnten Gasen. I. Allgemeiner Teil, Almqvist and Wiksell, Uppsala (1917). [75] J.H. Ferziger and H.G. Kaper, Mathematical Theory of Transport Processes in Gases, North-Holland, Amsterdam (1972). [76] A.L. Garcia, Nonequilibrium fluctuations studied by a rarefaction simulation, Phys. Rev. A 34 (1986), 1454–1457. [77] A. Garcia, Hydrodynamic fluctuations and the direct-simulation Monte Carlo method, Microscopic Simulations of Complex Flows, M. Mareschal, ed., Plenum Press, New York (1990), 177–188. [78] A. Garcia and C. Penland, Fluctuating hydrodynamics and principal oscillation pattern analysis, J. Statist. Phys. 164 (1991), 1121–1132. [79] H. Grad, Singular and non-uniform limits of solutions of the Boltzmann equation, Transport Theory, R. Bellman, G. Birkhoff and I. Abu-Shumays, eds, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI (1969), 269–308. [80] F. Gropengießer, N. Neunzert and J. Struckmeier, Computational methods for the Boltzmann equation, Venice 1989: The State of Art in Applied and Industrial Mathematics, R. Spigler, ed., Kluwer, Dordrecht (1990), 111–140. [81] F.B. Hanson and T.F. Morse, Kinetic models for a gas with internal structure, Phys. Fluids 10 (1967), 345–353. [82] P.J. Harbour and J.H. Lewis, Preliminary measurements of the hypersonic rarefied flow field on a sharp plate using an electron beam probe, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Vol. II, C.L. Brundin, ed., Academic Press, New York (1967), 1031–1046. [83] J.K. Harvey, Direct simulation Monte Carlo method and comparison with experiment, Progr. in Astro. and Aero. 103 (1986), 25–42. [84] H.A. Hassan and D.B. Hash, A generalized hard-sphere model for Monte Carlo simulations, Phys. Fluids A 5 (1993), 738–744. [85] D. Hilbert, Begründung der kinetichen Gastheorie, Math. Ann. 72 (1912), 562–577. [86] J.O. Hirschfelder, C.F. Curtiss and R.B. Bird, Molecular Theory of Gases and Liquids, Wiley, New York (1954). [87] L.H. Holway, Jr., Approximation procedures for kinetic theory, PhD thesis, Harvard (1963). [88] A.B. Huang, Kinetic theory of the rarefied supersonic flow over a finite plate, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Vol. I, L. Trilling and H.Y. Wachman, eds, Academic Press, New York (1969), 529–544. [89] A.B. Huang and P.F. Hwang, Kinetic theory of the sharp leading-edge flow, II, IAF Paper RE 63 (October 1968). [90] A.B. Huang and P.F. Hwang, Supersonic leading-edge problem according to the ellipsoidal model, Phys. Fluids 13 (1970), 309–317. [91] F. Hurlbut and F.S. Sherman, Application of the Nocilla wall reflection model to free-molecule kinetic theory, Phys. Fluids 11 (1968), 486–496. [92] M.S. Ivanov, S.F. Gimelshein and A.E. Beylich, Hysteresis effect in stationary reflection of shock waves, Phys. Fluids A 7 (1995), 685–687. [93] M.S. Ivanov, S.F. Gimelshein and G.N. Markelov, Statistical simulation of the transition between regular and Mach reflection in steady flows, Comput. Math. Appl. 35 (1998), 113–125. [94] J.H. Jeans, On the partition of energy in a system of loaded spheres, Q. J. Pure Appl. Math. 35 (1904), 224–238. [95] W.W. Joss, I.E. Vas and S.M. Bogdonoff, Hypersonic rarefied flow over a flat plate, AIAA Paper 68-5 (January 1968). [96] A. Kersch and W.J. Morokoff, Transport Simulation in Microelectronics, Birkhäuser, Basel (1995). [97] A. Kersch, W.J. Morokoff and C. Werner, Selfconsistent simulation of sputter deposition with the Monte Carlo method, J. Appl. Phys. 75 (1994), 2278–2285. [98] M. Knudsen, Die Gesetze der molekular strömung und der inneren reibungströmung der gase durch röhren, Ann. Physik 28 (1909), 75–130. [99] M. Knudsen, The Kinetic Theory of Gases, Methuen, London (1950).
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
67
[100] M.N. Kogan, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Plenum Press, New York (1969). [101] M.N. Kogan, V.S. Galkin and O.G. Fridlender, Stresses produced in gases by temperature and concentration inhomogeneities. New type of free convection, Soviet Phys. Usp. 19 (1976), 420–438. [102] S.S. Kot and D.L. Turcotte, Beam-continuum model for hypersonic flow over a flat plate, AIAA J. 10 (1972), 291–295. [103] K. Koura, Comment on ‘Direct Simulation scheme derived from the Boltzmann equation. I. Monocomponent gases’, J. Phys. Soc. Japan 50 (1981), 3829–3830. [104] K. Koura, Null-collision technique in the direct simulation Monte Carlo technique, Phys. Fluids 29 (1986), 3509–3511. [105] K. Koura, Null collision Monte Carlo method. Gas mixtures with internal degrees of freedom and chemical reactions, Rarefied Gas Dynamics: Physical Phenomena, E.P. Muntz, D.P. Weaver and D.H. Campbell, eds, AIAA, Washington (1989), 25–39. [106] K. Koura, Improved null-collision technique in the Direct Simulation Monte Carlo method: application to vibrational relaxation of nitrogen, Comput. Math. Appl. 35 (1998), 139–154. [107] K. Koura and H. Matsumoto, Variable soft sphere molecular model for inverse-power-law or Lennard– Jones potential, Phys. Fluids A 3 (1991), 2459–2465. [108] I. Kušˇcer, Transport Theory Conference, AEC Report ORO-3588-1, Blacksburgh, VA (1969). [109] I. Kušˇcer, Reciprocity in scattering of gas molecules by surfaces, Surface Sci. 25 (1971), 225–237. [110] I. Kušˇcer, Phenomenological aspects of gas-surface interaction, Fundamental Problems in Statistical Mechanics, Vol. IV, E.G.D. Cohen and W. Fiszdon, eds, Ossolineum, Warsaw (1978), 441–467. [111] I. Kušˇcer, Models of energy exchange in polyatomic gases, Operator Theory: Advances and Applications, Vol. 51, Birkhäuser, Basel (1991), 180–188. [112] I. Kušˇcer, J. Možina and F. Krizanic, The Knudsen model of thermal accommodation, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Vol. I, D. Dini et al., eds, Editrice Tecnico-Scientifica, Pisa (1974), 97–108. [113] O. Lanford, III, The evolution of large classical systems, Dynamical Systems, Theory and Applications, J. Moser, ed., Lecture Notes in Phys., Vol. 35, Springer, Berlin (1975), 1–111. [114] J.L. Lebowitz, H.L. Frisch and E. Helfand, Nonequilibrium distribution functions in a fluid, Phys. Fluids 3 (1960), 325–338. [115] H. Legge, Experiments on a 70 degree blunted cone in rarefied hypersonic wind tunnel flow, AIAA Paper 95-2140 (1995). [116] H. Legge, Force and heat transfer on a delta wing in rarefied flow, Workshop on Hypersonic Flows for Reentry Problems, Part II, Antibes, France (1991). [117] R.G. Lord, Some extensions to the Cercignani–Lampis gas scattering kernel, Phys. Fluids A 3 (1991), 706–710. [118] J.A. Lordi and R.E. Mates, Rotational relaxation in nonpolar diatomic gases, Phys. Fluids 13 (1970), 291–308. [119] H.A. Lorentz, Über das Gleichgewicht der lebendingen Kraft unter Gasmolekülen, Sitzungsber. Akad. Wiss. 95 (1887), 115–152. [120] A. Majda, Compressible Fluid Flow and Systems of Conservation Laws in Several Space Variables, Appl. Math. Ser., Vol. 53, Springer (1984). [121] J.C. Maxwell, On stresses in rarified gases arising from inequalities of temperature, Philos. Trans. Roy. Soc. 170 (1879), 231–256. [122] F.R.W. Mc Court, J.J.M. Beenakker, W.E. Köhler and I. Kušˇcer, Nonequilibrium Phenomena in Polyatomic Gases, Clarendon Press, Oxford (1990). [123] W.J. McCroskey, S.M. Bogdonoff and J.G. McDougall, An experimental model for sharp flat plate in rarefied hypersonic flow, AIAA J. 4 (1966), 1580–1587. [124] A.F. Messiter, Boundary-layer flow near the trailing edge of a flat plate, SIAM J. Appl. Math. 18 (1970), 241–257. [125] S.C. Metcalf, D.C. Lillicrap and C.J. Berry, A study of the effect of surface temperature on the shock-layer development over sharp-edged shapes in low-Reynolds-number high speed flow, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Vol. I, L. Trilling and H.Y. Wachman, eds, Academic Press, New York (1969), 619–638. [126] R.A. Millikan, The general law of fall of a small spherical body through a gas, and its bearing upon the nature of molecular reflection from surfaces, Phys. Rev. 22 (1923), 1–23. [127] T.F. Morse, Kinetic model equations in a fluid, Phys. Fluids 7 (1964), 2012–2013.
68
C. Cercignani
[128] J.N. Moss and G.A. Bird, Direct simulation of transitional flow for hypersonic re-entry conditions, Progr. in Astro. and Aero. 96 (1985), 113. [129] J.N. Moss, C.H. Chun and J.M. Price, Hypersonic rarefied flow about a compression corner – DSMC simulation and experiment, AIAA Paper 91-1313 (1991). [130] J.N. Moss, V.K. Dogra and J.M. Price, DSMC simulation of viscous interactions for a hollow cylinder-flare configuration, AIAA Paper 94-2015 (1994). [131] J.N. Moss, J.M. Price, V.K. Dogra and D.B. Hash, Comparison of DSMC and experimental results for hypersonic external flow, AIAA Paper 95-2028 (1995). [132] C. Muckenfuss and C.F. Curtiss, Kinetic theory of nonspherical molecules. III, J. Chem. Phys. 29 (1958), 1257–1277. [133] K. Nanbu, Direct simulation scheme derived from the Boltzmann equation, J. Phys. Soc. Japan 49 (1980), 2042–2049. [134] K. Nanbu, Reply to a comment on ‘Direct Simulation scheme derived from the Boltzmann equation. I. Monocomponent gases’, J. Phys. Soc. Japan 50 (1981), 3831–3832. [135] S. Nocilla, On the interaction between stream and body in free-molecule flow, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, L. Talbot, ed., Academic Press, New York (1961), 169–208. [136] A. Nordsiek and B. Hicks, Monte Carlo evaluation of the Boltzmann collision integral, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Vol. I, C.L. Brundin, ed., Academic Press, New York (1967), 695–710. [137] H. Oguchi, The sharp leading edge problem in hypersonic flow, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, L. Talbot, ed., Academic Press, New York (1961), 501–524. [138] T. Ohwada and Y. Sone, Analysis of thermal stress slip flow and negative thermophoresis using the Boltzmann equation for hard-sphere molecules, Eur. J. Mech. B 11 (1992), 389–414. [139] T. Ohwada, Y. Sone and K. Aoki, Numerical analysis of the Poiseuille and thermal transpiration flows between two parallel plates on the basis of the Boltzmann equation for hard-sphere molecules, Phys. Fluids A 1 (1989), 2042–2049; Erratum, Phys. Fluids A 2 (1990), 639. [140] G.C. Pham-Van-Diep, D.A. Erwin and E.P. Muntz, Nonequilibrium molecular motion in a hypersonic shock wave, Science 245 (1989), 624–626. [141] G.J. Prangsma, A.H. Alberga and J.J.M. Beenakker, Ultrasonic determination of the volume viscosity of N2 , CO, CH4 and CD4 between 77 and 300 K, Physica 64 (1973), 278–288. [142] M. Pulvirenti, W. Wagner and M.B. Zavelani, Convergence of particle schemes for the Boltzmann equation, Eur. J. Mech. B 7 (1994), 339–351. [143] D.F.G. Rault, Aerodynamics of the Shuttle Orbiter at high altitudes, J. Spacecraft and Rockets 31 (1994), 944–952. [144] D. Reichelman and K. Nanbu, Monte Carlo direct simulation of the Taylor instability in a rarefied gas, Phys. Fluids A 5 (1993), 2585–2587. [145] S. Rudman and S.G. Rubin, Hypersonic viscous flow over slender bodies with sharp leading-edges, AIAA J. 6 (1968), 1883–1890. [146] S.I. Sandler and N.F. Dahler, Kinetic theory of loaded spheres. IV. Thermal diffusion in a dilute gas mixture of D2 and HT, J. Chem. Phys. 47 (1967), 2621–2630. [147] B. Schmidt, Electron beam density measurements in shock waves in argon, J. Fluid Mech. 39 (1970), 361–373. [148] M. Shorenstein and R.F. Probstein, The hypersonic leading-edge problem, AIAA J. 6 (1968), 1898–1902. [149] R. Siegel and J.R. Howell, Thermal Radiation Heat Transfer, Hemisphere Publishing, Washington (1992). [150] R.S. Simmons and R.G. Lord, Application of the C-L model to vibrational transitions of diatomic molecules during DSMC gas-surface interaction, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Vol. 2, J. Harvey and G. Lord, eds, Oxford Univ. Press, Oxford (1995), 906–912. [151] L. Sirovich, Kinetic modeling of gas mixtures, Phys. Fluids 5 (1962), 908–918. [152] R.F. Snider, Quantum-mechanical modified Boltzmann equation for degenerate internal states, J. Chem. Phys. 32 (1960), 1051–1060. [153] Y. Sone, Flow induced by thermal stress in rarefied gas, Phys. Fluids 15 (1972), 1418–1423. [154] Y. Sone, Asymptotic theory of flow of rarefied gas over a smooth boundary I, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Vol. I, D. Dini et al., eds, Editrice Tecnico-Scientifica, Pisa (1974), 243–253. [155] Y. Sone, K. Aoki, S. Tanaka, H. Sugimoto and A.V. Bobylev, Inappropriateness of the heat-conduction equation for the description of a temperature field of a stationary gas in the continuum limit: examination
The Boltzmann equation and fluid dynamics
[156] [157] [158] [159]
[160]
[161] [162]
[163] [164] [165]
[166] [167] [168] [169] [170] [171] [172] [173] [174] [175] [176] [177]
[178]
69
by asymptotic analysis and numerical computation of the Boltzmann equation, Phys. Fluids A 8 (1996), 628–638. S. Stefanov and C. Cercignani, Monte Carlo Simulation of Bénard’s instability in a rarefied gas, Eur. J. Mech. B 11 (1992), 543–553. S. Stefanov and C. Cercignani, Monte Carlo simulation of the Taylor–Couette flow of a rarefied gas, J. Fluid Mech. 256 (1993), 199–213. S. Stefanov and C. Cercignani, Monte Carlo Simulation of a channel flow of a rarefied gas, Eur. J. Mech. B 13 (1994), 93–114. S. Stefanov and C. Cercignani, Taylor–Couette flow of a rarefied gas, Proceedings of the International Symposium on Aerospace and Fluid Science, Institute of Fluid Science, Tohoku University, Sendai (1994), 490–500. S. Stefanov, V. Roussinov, C. Cercignani, M.C. Giurin and J. Struckmeier, Rayleigh–Bénard chaotic convection of a rarefied gas, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Vol. I, R. Brun, R. Campargue, R. Gatignol and J.-C. Lengrand, eds, Cépaduès éditions, Toulouse (1999), 687–694. K.O. Stewartson, On the flow near trailing edge of a flat plate. II, Mathematika 16 (1) (1969), 106–121. S. Takata and Y. Sone, Flow induced around a sphere with a nonuniform surface temperature in a rarefied gas, with application to the drag and thermal force problems of a spherical particle with an arbitrary thermal conductivity, Eur. J. Mech. B 14 (1995), 487–518. S. Tanaka, K. Aoki and C. Cercignani, The velocity distribution function in an infinitely strong shock wave, submitted to Phys. Fluids (2000). F.G. Tcheremissine, Numerical methods for the direct solution of the kinetic Boltzmann equation, U.S.S.R. Comput. Math. Math. Phys. 25 (1985), 156–166. F.G. Tcheremissine, Advancement of the method of direct numerical solving of the Boltzmann equation, Rarefied Gas Dynamics: Theoretical and Computational Techniques, E.P. Muntz, D.P. Weaver and D.H. Campbell, eds, AIAA, Washington (1989), 343–358. R.C. Tolman, The Principles of Statistical Mechanics, Clarendon Press, Oxford (1938). G.E. Uhlenbeck, The Boltzmann Equation. Theory and Application, E.G.D. Cohen and W. Thirring, eds, Springer, Vienna (1973), 107–119. F.W. Vogenitz, J.E. Broadwell and G.A. Bird, Leading-edge flow by the Monte Carlo direct simulation method, AIAA J. 8 (1972), 504–510. W. Wagner, A convergence proof for Bird’s direct simulation Monte Carlo method for the Boltzmann equation, J. Statist. Phys. 66 (1992), 1011–1044. L. Waldmann, Transporterscheinungen in Gasen von mittlerem Druck, Handbuch der Physik, Vol XII, S. Flügge, ed., Springer, Berlin (1958), 484–514. L. Waldmann, The Boltzmann Equation. Theory and Application, E.G.D. Cohen and W. Thirring, eds, Springer, Vienna (1973), 223–246. C.S. Wang Chang and G.E. Uhlenbeck, Studies in Statistical Mechanics, Vol. II, Part c, J. de Boer and G.E. Uhlenbeck, eds, North-Holland, Amsterdam (1964). P. Welander, On the temperature jump in a rarefied gas, Arkiv Fysik 7 (1954), 507–553. M.M.R. Williams, A phenomenological study of gas-surface interactions, J. Phys. D. Appl. Phys. 4 (1971), 1315–1319. M.M.R. Williams and S.K. Loyalka, Aerosol Science. Theory & Practice, Pergamon Press, Oxford (1991). M.S. Woronowicz and D.F.G. Rault, Cercignani–Lampis–Lord gas-surface interaction model: comparison between theory and simulation, J. Spacecraft and Rockets 31 (1994), 532–534. S.M. Yen, B. Hicks and R.M. Osteen, Further development of a Monte Carlo method for the evaluation of Boltzmann collision integral, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Vol. I, A. 12, M. Becker and M. Fiebig, eds, DFVLR-Press, Porz-Wahn (1974), 1–10. Y. Yoshizawa, Wave structures of a chemically reacting gas by the kinetic theory of gases, Rarefied Gas Dynamics, Part I, J.L. Potter, ed., AIAA, New York (1977), 501–517.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CHAPTER 2
A Review of Mathematical Topics in Collisional Kinetic Theory Cédric Villani UMPA, ENS Lyon, 46 allée d’Italie, F-69364 Lyon Cedex 07, France E-mail:
[email protected]
Contents Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2A. General Presentation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. Models for collisions in kinetic theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Mathematical problems in collisional kinetic theory . . . . . . . . . . 3. Taxonomy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Basic surgery tools for the Boltzmann operator . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. Mathematical theories for the Cauchy problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2B. Cauchy Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. Use of velocity-averaging lemmas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Moment estimates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. The Grad’s cut-off toolbox . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. The singularity-hunter’s toolbox . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. The Landau approximation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. Lower bounds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2C. H Theorem and Trend to Equilibrium . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. A gallery of entropy-dissipating kinetic models . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Nonconstructive methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Entropy dissipation methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Entropy dissipation functionals of Boltzmann and Landau . . . . . . . 5. Trend to equilibrium, spatially homogeneous Boltzmann and Landau . 6. Gradient flows . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7. Trend to equilibrium, spatially inhomogeneous systems . . . . . . . . 2D. Maxwell Collisions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. Wild sums . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Contracting probability metrics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Information theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . HANDBOOK OF MATHEMATICAL FLUID DYNAMICS, VOLUME I Edited by S.J. Friedlander and D. Serre © 2002 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved 71
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
73 75 77 95 118 124 130 141 143 147 153 165 180 185 189 191 200 203 208 224 228 235 245 248 249 254 258
72
C. Villani
2E. Open Problems and New Trends . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. Open problems in classical collisional kinetic theory 2. Granular media . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Quantum kinetic theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Bibliographical notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
263 265 272 279 286 287 288
A review of mathematical topics in collisional kinetic theory
73
Introduction The goal of this review paper is to provide the reader with a concise introduction to the mathematical theory of collision processes in (dilute) gases and plasmas, viewed as a branch of kinetic theory. The study of collisional kinetic equations is only part of the huge field of nonequilibrium statistical physics. Among other things, it is famous for historical reasons, since it is in this setting that Boltzmann proved his celebrated theorem about entropy. As of this date, the mathematical theory of collisional kinetic equations cannot be considered to be in a mature state, but it has undergone spectacular progress in the last decades, and still more is to be expected. I have made the following choices for presentation: (1) The emphasis is definitely on the mathematics rather than on the physics, the modelling or the numerical simulation. About these topics the survey by Carlo Cercignani will say much more. On the other hand, I shall always be concerned with the physical relevance of mathematical results. (2) Most of the presentation is limited to a small number of widely known, mathematically famous models which can be considered as archetypes – mainly, variants of the Boltzmann equation. This is not only for the sake of mathematics: also in modelling do these equations play a major role. (3) Two important interface fields are hardly discussed: one is the transition from particle systems to kinetic equations, and the other one is the transition from kinetic equations to hydrodynamics. For both problematics I shall only give basic considerations and adequate references. (4) Not all mathematical theories of kinetic equations (there are many of them!) are “equally” represented: for instance, fully nonlinear theories occupy much more space than perturbative approaches, and the Boltzmann equation without cut-off is discussed in about the same detail than the Boltzmann equation with cut-off (although the literature devoted to the latter case is considerably more extended). This partly reflects the respective vivacity of the various branches, but also, unavoidably, personal tastes and areas of competence. I apologize for this! (5) I have sought to give more importance to mathematical methods and ideas, than to results. This is why I have chosen a “transversal” presentation: for each problem, corresponding tools and ideas are first explained, then the various results obtained by their use are carefully described in their respective framework. As a typical example, and unlike most textbooks, this review does not treat spatially homogeneous and spatially inhomogeneous theories separately, but insists on tools which apply to both frameworks. (6) At first I have tried to give extensive lists of references, but soon realized that it was too ambitious . . . . The plan of the survey is as follows. First, a presentation chapter discusses models for collisional kinetic theory and introduces the reader to the various mathematical problems which arise in their study. A central position is given to the Boltzmann equation and its variants. Chapter 2B bears on the Cauchy problem for the Boltzmann equation and variants. The main questions here are propagation of regularity and singularities, regularization effects,
74
C. Villani
decay and strict positivity of solutions. The influence of the Boltzmann collision kernel (satisfying Grad’s angular cut-off or not) is discussed with care. Chapter 2C considers the trend to equilibrium, insisting on constructive approaches. Boltzmann’s H theorem and entropy dissipation methods have a central role here. The shorter, but important Chapter 2D studies in detail the case of so-called Maxwell collision kernels, and several links between the theory of the Boltzmann equation and information theory. The ideas in this chapter crucially lie behind some of the most notable results in Chapter 2C, even though, strictly speaking, these two chapters are to a large extent independent. Finally, Chapter 2E discusses selected open problems and promising new trends in the field. Apart from the numerous references quoted in the text, the reader may find useful the short bibliographical notes which are included before the bibliography, to help orientate through the huge literature on the subject. Let me add one final word about conventions: it is quite customary in kinetic theory (just as in the field of hyperbolic systems of conservation laws) to use the vocable “entropy” for Boltzmann’s H functional; however the latter should rather be considered as the negative of an entropy, or as a “quantity of information”. In the present review I have followed the custom of calling H an entropy, however I now regret this choice and recommend to call it an information (or just the H functional); accordingly the “entropy dissipation functional” should rather be called “entropy production functional” or “dissipation of information” (which is both closer to physical intuition and maybe more appealing).
CHAPTER 2A
General Presentation Contents 1. Models for collisions in kinetic theory . . . . . . . . . . . 1.1. Distribution function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2. Transport operator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3. Boltzmann’s collision operator . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4. Collision kernels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5. Boundary conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.6. Variants of the Boltzmann equation . . . . . . . . . . 1.7. Collisions in plasma physics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.8. Physical validity of the Boltzmann equation . . . . . 2. Mathematical problems in collisional kinetic theory . . . 2.1. Mathematical validity of the Boltzmann equation . . 2.2. The Cauchy problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3. Maxwell’s weak formulation, and conservation laws 2.4. Boltzmann’s H theorem and irreversibility . . . . . . 2.5. Long-time behavior . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.6. Hydrodynamic limits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.7. The Landau approximation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8. Numerical simulations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.9. Miscellaneous . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Taxonomy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. Kinetic and angular collision kernel . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. The kinetic collision kernel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. The angular collision kernel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4. The cross-section for momentum transfer . . . . . . 3.5. The asymptotics of grazing collisions . . . . . . . . . 3.6. What do we care about collision kernels? . . . . . . . 4. Basic surgery tools for the Boltzmann operator . . . . . . 4.1. Symmetrization of the collision kernel . . . . . . . . 4.2. Symmetric and asymmetric point of view . . . . . . 4.3. Differentiation of the collision operator . . . . . . . . 4.4. Joint convexity of the entropy dissipation . . . . . . . 4.5. Pre-postcollisional change of variables . . . . . . . . 4.6. Alternative representations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.7. Monotonicity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.8. Bobylev’s identities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.9. Application of Fourier transform to spectral schemes 5. Mathematical theories for the Cauchy problem . . . . . . 5.1. What minimal functional space? . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2. The spatially homogeneous theory . . . . . . . . . . 5.3. Maxwellian molecules . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4. Perturbation theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 75
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
77 77 78 79 82 84 86 89 94 95 95 100 101 104 109 111 114 114 115 118 118 119 120 120 121 123 124 124 125 125 126 126 127 128 128 129 130 130 133 134 134
76
C. Villani 5.5. Theories in the small . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 136 5.6. The theory of renormalized solutions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 137 5.7. Monodimensional problems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 139
A review of mathematical topics in collisional kinetic theory
77
The goal of this chapter is to introduce, and make a preliminary discussion of, the mathematical models and problems which will be studied in more detail thereafter. The first section addresses only physical issues, starting from scratch. We begin with an introduction to kinetic theory, then to basic models for collisions. Then in Section 2, we start describing the mathematical problems which arise in collisional kinetic theory, restricting the discussion to the ones that seem to us most fundamental. Particular emphasis is laid on the Boltzmann equation. Each paragraph contains at least one major problem which has not been solved satisfactorily. Next, a specific section is devoted to the classification of collision kernels in the Boltzmann collision operator. The variety of collision kernels reflects the variety of possible interactions. Collision kernels have a lot of influence on qualitative properties of the Boltzmann equation, as we explain. In the last two sections, we first present some basic general tools and considerations about the Boltzmann operator, then give an overview of existing mathematical theories for collisional kinetic theory.
1. Models for collisions in kinetic theory 1.1. Distribution function The object of kinetic theory is the modelling of a gas (or plasma, or any system made up of a large number of particles) by a distribution function in the particle phase space. This phase space includes macroscopic variables, i.e., the position in physical space, but also microscopic variables, which describe the “state” of the particles. In the present survey, we shall restrict ourselves, most of the time, to systems made of a single species of particles (no mixtures), and which obey the laws of classical mechanics (non-relativistic, nonquantum). Thus the microscopic variables will be nothing but the velocity components. Extra microscopic variables should be added if one would want to take into account nontranslational degrees of freedom of the particles: internal energy, spin variables, etc. Assume that the gas is contained in a (bounded or unbounded) domain X ⊂ RN (N = 3 in applications) and observed on a time interval [0, T ], or [0, +∞). Then, under the above simplifying assumptions, the corresponding kinetic model is a nonnegative function f (t, x, v), defined on [0, T ] × X × RN . Here the space RN = RN v is the space of possible velocities, and should be thought of as the tangent space to X. For any fixed time t, the quantity f (t, x, v) dx dv stands for the density of particles in the volume element dx dv centered at (x, v). Therefore, the minimal assumption that one can make on f is that for all t 0, f (t, ·, ·) ∈ L1loc X; L1 RN v ; or at least that f (t, ·, ·) is a bounded measure on K × RN v , for any compact set K ⊂ X. This assumption means that a bounded domain in physical space contains only a finite amount of matter.
78
C. Villani
Underlying kinetic theory is the modelling assumption that the gas is made of so many particles that it can be treated as a continuum. In fact there are two slightly different ways to consider f : it can be seen as an approximation of the true density of the gas in phase space (on a scale which is much larger than the typical distance between particles), or it can reflect our lack of knowledge of the true positions of particles. Which interpretation is made has no consequence in practice.1 The kinetic approach goes back as far as Bernoulli and Clausius; in fact it was introduced long before experimental proof of the existence of atoms. The first true bases for kinetic theory were laid down by Maxwell [335,337,336]. One of the main ideas in the model is that all measurable macroscopic quantities (“observables”) can be expressed in terms of microscopic averages, in our case integrals of the form f (t, x, v)ϕ(v) dv. In particular (in adimensional form), at a given point x and a given time t, one can define the local density ρ, the local macroscopic velocity u, and the local temperature T , by ρ=
RN
f (t, x, v) dv,
ρ|u| + NρT =
ρu =
RN
2
f (t, x, v)v dv, (1)
2
RN
f (t, x, v)|v| dv.
For much more on the subject, we refer to the standard treatises of Chapman and Cowling [154], Landau and Lipschitz [304], Grad [250], Kogan [289], Uhlenbeck and Ford [433], Truesdell and Muncaster [430], Cercignani and co-authors [141,148,149].
1.2. Transport operator Let us continue to stick to a classical description, and neglect for the moment the interaction between particles. Then, according to Newton’s principle, each particle travels at constant velocity, along a straight line, and the density is constant along characteristic lines dx/dt = v, dv/dt = 0. Thus it is easy to compute f at time t in terms of f at time 0: f (t, x, v) = f (0, x − vt, v). 1 For instance, assume that the microscopic description of the gas is given by a cloud of n points x , . . . , x n 1 N in RN . . . , xn , vn ) of x , with velocities v1 , . . . , vn in Rv . A microscopic configuration is an element (x1 , v1 , n N n (RN x × Rv ) . The “density” of the gas in this configuration is the empirical measure (1/n) i=1 δ(xi ,vi ) ; N N it is a probability measure on Rx × Rv . In the first interpretation, f (x, v) dx dv is an approximation of the N n empirical measure. In the second one, there is a symmetric probability density f n on the space (RN x × Rv ) of all microscopic configurations, and f is an approximation of the one-particle marginal P1 f n (x1 , v1 ) = f n (x1 , v1 , . . . , xn , vn ) dx2 dv2 · · · dxn dvn .
Thus the first interpretation is purely deterministic, while the second one is probabilistic. It is the second interpretation which was implicitly used by Boltzmann, and which is needed by Landford’s validation theorem, see Section 2.1.
A review of mathematical topics in collisional kinetic theory
79
In other words, f is a weak solution to the equation of free transport, ∂f + v · ∇x f = 0. ∂t
(2)
The operator v · ∇x is the (classical) transport operator. Its mathematical properties are much subtler than it would seem at first sight; we shall discuss this later. Complemented with suitable boundary conditions, Equation (2) is the right equation for describing a gas of noninteracting particles. Many variants are possible; for instance, v should be replaced 2 by v/ 1 + |v| in the relativistic case. Of course, when there is a macroscopic force F (x) acting on particles, then the equation has to be corrected accordingly, since the trajectories of particles are not straight lines any longer. The relevant equation would read ∂f + v · ∇x f + F (x) · ∇v f = 0 ∂t
(3)
and is sometimes called the linear Vlasov equation.
1.3. Boltzmann’s collision operator We now want to take into account interactions between particles. We shall make several postulates. (1) We assume that particles interact via binary collisions: this is a vague term describing the process in which two particles happen to come very close to each other, so that their respective trajectories are strongly deviated in a very short time. Underlying this hypothesis is an implicit assumption that the gas is dilute enough that the effect of interactions involving more than two particles can be neglected. Typically, if we deal with a threedimensional gas of n hard spheres of radius r, this would mean nr 3 1,
nr 2 1.
(2) Moreover, we assume that these collisions are localized both in space and time, i.e., they are brief events which occur at a given position x and a given time t. This means that the typical duration of a collision is very small compared to the typical time scale of the description, and also quantities such as the impact parameter (see below) are negligible in front of the typical space scale (say, a space scale on which variations due to the transport operator are of order 1). (3) Next, we further assume these collisions to be elastic: momentum and kinetic energy are preserved in a collision process. Let v , v∗ stand for the velocities before collision, and v, v∗ stand for the velocities after collision: thus v + v∗ = v + v∗ , |v |2 + |v∗ |2 = |v|2 + |v∗ |2 .
(4)
80
C. Villani
Fig. 1. A binary elastic collision.
Since this is a system of N + 1 scalar equations for 2N scalar unknowns, it is natural to expect that its solutions can be defined in terms of N − 1 parameters. Here is a convenient representation of all these solutions, which we shall sometimes call the σ -representation: ⎧ v + v∗ |v − v∗ | ⎪ + σ, ⎨v = 2 2 ⎪ ⎩v = v + v∗ − |v − v∗ | σ. ∗ 2 2
(5)
Here the parameter σ ∈ S N−1 varies in the N − 1 unit sphere. Figure 1 pictures a collision in the velocity phase space. The deviation angle θ is the angle between pre- and postcollisional velocities. Very often, particles will be assumed to interact via a given interaction potential φ(r) (r = distance between particles); then v and v∗ should be computed as the result of a classical scattering problem, knowing v, v∗ and the impact parameter between the two colliding particles. We recall that the impact parameter is what would be the distance of closest approach if the two particles did not interact. (4) We also assume collisions to be microreversible. This word can be understood in a purely deterministic way: microscopic dynamics are time-reversible; or in a probabilistic way: the probability that velocities (v , v∗ ) are changed into (v, v∗ ) in a collision process, is the same that the probability that (v, v∗ ) are changed into (v , v∗ ). (5) And finally, we make the Boltzmann chaos assumption: the velocities of two particles which are about to collide are uncorrelated. Roughly speaking, this means that if we randomly pick up two particles at position x, which have not collided yet, then the joint distribution of their velocities will be given by a tensor product (in velocity space) of f with itself. Note that this assumption implies an asymmetry between past and future: indeed, in general if the pre-collisional velocities are uncorrelated, then post-collisional velocities have to be correlated2! 2 See, for instance, the discussion in Section 2.4.
A review of mathematical topics in collisional kinetic theory
81
Under these five assumptions, in 1872 Boltzmann (cf. [93]) was able to derive a quadratic collision operator which accurately models the effect of interactions on the distribution function f : ∂f (t, x, v) = Q(f, f ) (t, x, v) (6) ∂t coll = dv∗ dσ B(v − v∗ , σ )(f f∗ − ff∗ ). (7) RN
S N−1
Here we have used standard abbreviations: f = f (t, x, v ), f∗ = f (t, x, v∗ ), f∗ = f (t, x, v∗ ). Moreover, the nonnegative function B(z, σ ), called the Boltzmann collision kernel, depends only on |z| and on the scalar product z/|z|, σ . Heuristically, it can be seen as a probability measure on all the possible choices of the parameter σ ∈ S N−1 , as a function of the relative velocity z = v − v∗ . But truly speaking, this interpretation is in general false, because B is not integrable . . . . The Boltzmann collision kernel is related to the cross-section Σ by the identity B(z, σ ) = |z|Σ(Z, σ ). By abuse of language, B is often called the cross-section. Let us explain (7) a little bit. This operator can formally be split, in a self-evident way, into a gain and a loss term, Q(f, f ) = Q+ (f, f ) − Q− (f, f ). The loss term “counts” all collisions in which a given particle of velocity v will encounter another particle, of velocity v∗ . As a result of such a collision, this particle will in general change its velocity, and this will make less particles with velocity v. On the other hand, each time particles collide with respective velocities v and v∗ , then the v particle may acquire v as new velocity after the collision, and this will make more particles with velocity v: this is the meaning of the gain term. It is easy to trace back our modelling assumptions: (1) the quadratic nature of this operator is due to the fact that only binary collisions are taken into account; (2) the fact that the variables t, x appear only as parameters reflects the assumption that collisions are localized in space and time; (3) the assumption of elastic collisions results in the formulas giving v and v∗ ; (4) the microreversibility implies the particular structure of the collision kernel B; (5) finally, the appearance of the tensor products3 f f∗ and ff∗ is a consequence of the chaos assumption. On the whole, the Boltzmann equation reads ∂f + v · ∇x f = Q(f, f ), ∂t
t 0, x ∈ RN , v ∈ RN ;
(8)
or, when a macroscopic force F (x) is also present, ∂f + v · ∇x f + F (x) · ∇v f = Q(f, f ), ∂t
t 0, x ∈ RN , v ∈ RN .
3 In the sense that ff = (f ⊗ f )(v, v ), f f = (f ⊗ f )(v , v ). ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗
(9)
82
C. Villani
The deepest physical and mathematical properties of the Boltzmann equation are linked to the subtle interaction between the linear transport operator and the nonlinear collision operator. We note that this equation was written in weak formulation by Maxwell as early as 1866: as recalled in Section 2.3 below, Maxwell [335,337] wrote down the equation satisfied by the observables f (t, x, v)ϕ(v) dv (see in particular [335, Equation (3)]). However Boltzmann did a considerable job on the interpretation and consequences of this equation, and also made them widely known in his famous treatise [93], which was to have a lot of influence on theoretical physics during several decades. Let us make a few comments about the modelling assumptions. They may look rather crude, however they can in large part be completely justified, at least in certain particular cases. By far the deepest assumption is Boltzmann’s chaos hypothesis (“Stosszahlansatz”) which is intimately linked to the questions of irreversibility of macroscopic dynamics and the arrow of time. For a discussion of these subtle topics, the reader may consult the review paper by Lebowitz [293], or the enlightening treatise by Kac [284], as well as the textbooks [149,410] for the most technical aspects. We shall say just a few words about the subject in Sections 2.1 and 2.4.
1.4. Collision kernels Since the collision kernel (or equivalently the cross-section) only depends on |v − v∗ | and v−v∗ , σ , i.e., the cosine of the deviation angle, throughout the whole text we shall on |v−v ∗| abuse notations by writing
B(v − v∗ , σ ) = B |v − v∗ |, cos θ ,
v − v∗ cos θ = ,σ . |v − v∗ |
(10)
Maxwell [335] has shown how the collision kernel should be computed in terms of the interaction potential φ. In short, here are his formulas (in three dimensions of space), as they can be found for instance in Cercignani [141], for a repulsive potential. For given impact parameter p 0 and relative velocity z ∈ R3 , let the deviation angle θ be θ (p, z) = π − 2p
+∞ s0
ds/s 2 1−
p2 s2
− 4 φ(s) |z|2
=π −2 0
p/s0
du 1 − u2 −
4 φ pu |z|2
,
where s0 is the positive root of 1−
p2 s02
−4
φ(s0 ) = 0. |z|2
Then the collision kernel B is implicitly defined by p dp |z|. B |z|, cos θ = sin θ dθ
(11)
A review of mathematical topics in collisional kinetic theory
83
It can be made explicit in two cases: • hard spheres, i.e., particles bounce on each other like billiard balls: in this case B(|v − v∗ |, cos θ ) is just proportional to |v − v∗ | (the cross-section is constant); • Coulomb interaction, φ(r) = 1/r (in adimensional variables and in three dimensions of space): then B is given by the famous Rutherford formula, B |v − v∗ |, cos θ =
1 |v − v∗
|3 sin4 (θ/2)
(12)
.
A dimensional factor of (e2 /4πε0 m) should multiply this kernel (e = charge of the particle, ε0 = permittivity of the vacuum, m = mass of the particle). Unfortunately, Coulomb interactions cannot be modelled by a Boltzmann collision operator; we shall come back to this soon. In the important4 model case of inverse-power law potentials, φ(r) =
1 , r s−1
s > 2,
then the collision kernel cannot be computed explicitly, but one can show that B |v − v∗ |, cos θ = b(cos θ )|v − v∗ |γ ,
γ=
s − (2N − 1) . s−1
(13)
In particular, in three dimensions of space, γ = (s − 5)/(s − 1). As for the function b, it is only implicitly defined, locally smooth, and has a nonintegrable singularity for θ → 0: sinN−2 θ b(cos θ ) ∼ Kθ −1−ν ,
ν=
2 s−1
(N = 3).
(14)
Here we have put the factor sinN−2 θ because it is (up to a constant depending only on the dimension) the Jacobian determinant of spherical coordinates on the sphere S N−1 . The nonintegrable singularity in the “angular collision kernel” b is an effect of the huge amount of grazing collisions, i.e., collisions with a very large impact parameter, so that colliding particles are hardly deviated. This is not a consequence of the assumption of inverse-power forces; in fact a nonintegrable singularity appears as soon as the forces are of infinite range, no matter how fast they decay at infinity. To see this, note that, according to (11),
π 0
B |z|, cos θ sin θ dθ = |z|
π
p 0
dp dθ = |z| dθ
0
pmax
p dp =
2 |z| pmax . 2
(15)
By the way, it seems strange to allow infinite-range forces, while we assumed interactions to be localized. This problem has never been discussed very clearly, but in 4 Inverse power laws are moderately realistic, but very important in physics and in modelling, because they are simple, often lead to semi-explicit results, and constitute a one-parameter family which can model very different phenomena. Van der Waals interactions typically correspond to s = 7, ion–neutral interactions to s = 5, Manev interactions [88,279] to s = 3, Coulomb interactions to s = 2.
84
C. Villani
principle there is no contradiction in assuming the range of the interaction to be infinite at a microscopic scale, and negligible at a macroscopic scale. The fact that the linear Boltzmann equation can be rigorously derived from some particle dynamics with infinite range [179] also supports this point of view. As one sees from formula (13), there is a particular case in which the collision kernel does not depend on the relative velocity, but only on the deviation angle: particles interacting via a inverse (2N − 1)-power force (1/r 5 in three dimensions). Such particles are called Maxwellian molecules. They should be considered as a theoretical model, even if the interaction between a charged ion and a neutral particle in a plasma may be modelled by such a law (see, for instance, [164, Theorem 1, p. 149]). However, Maxwell and Boltzmann used this model a lot,5 because they had noticed that it could lead to many explicit calculations which, so did they believe, were in agreement with physical observations. Also they believed that the choice of molecular interaction was not so important, and that Maxwellian molecules would behave pretty much the same as hard spheres.6 Since the time of Maxwell and Boltzmann, the need for results or computations has led generations of mathematicians and physicists to work with more or less artificial variants of the collision kernels given by physics. Such a procedure can also be justified by the fact that for many interesting interactions, the collision kernel is not explicit at all: for instance, in the case of the Debye potential, φ(r) = e−r /r. Here are two categories of artificial collision kernels: – when one tames the singularity for grazing collisions and replaces the collision kernel by a locally integrable one, one speaks of cut-off collision kernel; – collision kernels of the form |v − v∗ |γ (γ > 0) are called variable hard spheres collision kernels. It is a common belief among physicists that the properties of the Boltzmann equation are quite a bit sensitive to the dependence of B upon the relative velocity, but very little to its dependence upon the deviation angle. True as it may be for the behavior of macroscopic quantities, this creed is definitely wrong at the microscopic level, as we shall see. In all the sequel, we shall consider general collision kernels B(|v − v∗ |, cos θ ), in arbitrary dimension N , and make various assumptions on the form of B without always caring if it corresponds to a true interaction between particles (i.e., if there is a φ whose associated collision kernel is B). Our goal, in a lot of situations, will be to understand how the collision kernel affects the properties of the Boltzmann equation. However, we shall always keep in mind the collision kernels given by physics, in dimension three, to judge how satisfactory a mathematical result is.
1.5. Boundary conditions Of course the Boltzmann equation has to be supplemented with boundary conditions which model the interaction between the particles and the frontiers of our domain X ⊂ RN (wall, etc.) 5 See Boltzmann [93, Chapter 3]. 6 Further recall that at the time, the “atomic hypothesis” was considered by many to be a superfluous
complication.
A review of mathematical topics in collisional kinetic theory
85
The most natural boundary condition is the specular reflection: Rx v = v − 2 v · n(x) n(x), x ∈ ∂X,
f (x, Rx v) = f (x, v),
(16)
where n(x) stands for the outward unit normal vector at x. In the context of optics, this condition would be called the Snell–Descartes law: particles bounce back on the wall with an postcollision angle equal to the precollision angle. However, as soon as one is interested in realistic modelling for practical problems, Equation (16) is too rough . . . . In fact, a good boundary condition would have to take into account the fine details of the gas-surface interaction, and this is in general a very delicate problem.7 There are a number of models, cooked up from modelling assumptions or phenomenological a priori constraints. As good source for these topics, the reader may consult the books by Cercignani [141,148] and the references therein. In particular, the author explains the relevant conditions that a scattering kernel K has to satisfy for the boundary condition f (x, vout) =
K(vin , vout )f (x, vin ) dvin
to be physically plausible. Here we only list a few common examples. One is the bounce-back condition, f (x, −v) = f (x, v),
x ∈ ∂X.
(17)
This condition simply means that particles arriving with a certain velocity on the wall will bounce back with an opposite velocity. Of course it is not very realistic, however in some situations (see, for instance, [148, p. 41]) it leads to more relevant conclusions than the specular reflection, because it allows for some transfer of tangential momentum during collisions. Another common boundary condition is the Maxwellian diffusion, f (x, v) = ρ− (x)Mw (v),
v · n(x) > 0,
(18)
where ρ− (x) = v·n<0 f (x, v) dv and Mw is a particular Gaussian distribution depending only on the wall, |v|2
Mw (v) =
e− 2Tw (2π)
N−1 2
N+1
.
Tw 2
7 Here we assume that the fine details of the surface of the wall are invisible at the scale of the spatial variable, so that the wall is modelled as a smooth surface, but we wish to take these details into account to predict velocities after collision with the wall. Another possibility is to assume that the roughness of the wall results in irregularities which can be seen at spatial resolution. Then it is natural in many occasions to assume ∂X to be very irregular. For some mathematical works about this alternative approach, see [33,272,273].
86
C. Villani
In this model, particles are absorbed by the wall and then re-emitted according to the distribution Mw , corresponding to a thermodynamical equilibrium between particles and the wall. Finally, one can combine the above models. Already Maxwell had understood that a convex combination of (16) and (18) would certainly be more realistic than just one of these two equations. No need to say, since the work of Maxwell, much more complicated models have appeared, for instance the Cercignani–Lampis (CL) model, see [148]. In mathematical discussions, we shall not consider the problem of boundary conditions except for the most simple case, which is specular reflection. In fact, most of the time we shall simply avoid this problem by assuming the position space to be the whole of RN , or the torus TN . Of course the torus is a mathematical simplification, but it is also used by physicists and by numerical analysts who want to avoid taking boundary conditions into account . . . .
1.6. Variants of the Boltzmann equation There are many variants. Let us only mention • relativistic models, see [50,158,199,200,233–235,14]; • quantum models, see [196,328,209] and the references therein. They will be discussed in Section 3 of Chapter 2E. Also we should mention that models of quantum Boltzmann equation have recently gained a lot of interest in the study of semiconductors, see in particular [65,66] and the works by Poupaud and coworkers on related models [386–388,244,360], also [354,355] (in two dimensions) and [15] (in three dimensions); • linear models, in particular the linear Boltzmann equation, ∂f + v · ∇x f = ∂t
RN ×S N−1
− v∗ , σ ) F (v∗ )f (v ) − F (v∗ )f (v) , dv∗ dσ B(v
where F is a given probability distribution. As a general rule, such linear equations model the influence of the environment, or background, on a test-particle (think of a particle in an environment of random scatterers, like in a random pinball game). The distribution F is the distribution of the background, and is usually assumed to be stationary, which means that the environment is in statistical equilibrium. Linear Boltzmann-like models are used in all areas of physics, most notably in quantum scattering [206] and in the study of transport phenomena associated with neutrons or photons [148, pp. 165–172]. A general mathematical introduction to linear transport equations can be found in [157, Chapter 21]; • diffusive models, like the Fokker–Planck equation, which is often used in its linear version, ∂f + v · ∇x f = ∇v · (∇v f + f v), ∂t
(19)
A review of mathematical topics in collisional kinetic theory
87
or in its nonlinear form, ∂f + v · ∇x f = ρ α ∇v · T ∇v f + f (v − u) , ∂t
(20)
where α ∈ [0, 1], and ρ, u, T are the local density, velocity and temperature defined by (1). When α = 1, this model has the same quadratic homogeneity as the Boltzmann equation. Of course it is also possible to couple the equation only via T and not u, etc. A classical discussion on the use of the Fokker–Planck equation in physics can be found in the important review paper by Chandrasekhar [153]. The Landau equation, which is described in detail in the next section, is another diffusive variant of the Boltzmann equation; • energy-dissipating models, describing inelastic collisions. These models are particularly important in the theory of granular materials: see Section 2 of Chapter 2E; • model equations, like the (simplistic) BGK model, see, for instance, [141,148]. In this model one replaces the complicated Boltzmann operator by M f − f , where M f is the Maxwellian distribution8 with the same local density, velocity and temperature than f . Also variants are possible, for instance multiplying this operator by the local density ρ . . . . Another very popular model equation for mathematicians is the Kac model [283]. It is a one-dimensional caricature of the Boltzmann equation which retains some of its interesting features. The unknown is a time-dependent probability measure f on R, and the equation reads 1 ∂f = ∂t 2π
R
dv∗
2π
dθ 0
f f∗
− f,
(21)
where (v , v∗ ) is obtained from (v, v∗ ) by a rotation of angle θ in the plane R2 . This model preserves mass and kinetic energy, but not momentum; • discrete-velocity models: these are approximations of the Boltzmann equation where particles are only allowed a finite number of velocities. They are used in numerical analysis, but their mathematical study is (or once was) a popular topic. About them we shall say nothing; references can be found, for instance, in [230,141,148] and also in the survey papers [384,62]. Among a large number of works, we only mention the original contributions by Bony [94,95], Tartar [416,417], and the consistency result by Bobylev et al. [367], for the interesting number-theoretical issues that this paper has to deal with. We note [148, p. 265] that discrete-velocity models were once believed by physicists to provide miraculously efficient numerical codes for simulation of hydrodynamics. But these hopes have not been materialized . . . . Also some completely unrealistic discrete-velocity equations have been studied as simplified mathematical models, without caring whether they would approximate or not the true Boltzmann equation. These models sometimes have no more than two or three velocities! Some well-known examples are the Carleman equation, with two 8 See Section 2.5 below.
88
C. Villani
velocities, the Broadwell model, with four velocities in the plane, or the Cabannes equation with fourteen velocities. For instance, the Carleman equation reads ⎧ ∂f1 ∂f1 ⎪ 2 ⎪ − f12 , + = f−1 ⎨ ∂t ∂x ⎪ ∂f ∂f ⎪ 2 ⎩ −1 − −1 = f12 − f−1 . ∂t ∂x
(22)
For a study of these models see [230,384,141,148,60,61,108,25] and references included. Of course, these models are so oversimplified9 that they cannot be considered seriously from the physical point of view, even if one may expect that they keep some relevant features of the Boltzmann equation. By the way, as noticed by Uchiyama [432], the Broadwell model cannot be derived from a fictitious system of deterministic four-velocity particles (“diamonds”) in the plane, see [149, Appendix 4C]. Only at the price of some extra stochasticity assumption can the derivation be fixed [117]. All the abovementioned models should be considered with appropriate boundary conditions. These conditions can also be replaced by the effect of a confinement potential V (x): this means that there is a macroscopic force of the form F (x) = −∇V (x) acting on the system. Finally, it is important to note that Boltzmann’s model is obtained as a result of the assumption of localized interaction; in particular, it does not take into account a possible interaction of long (macroscopic) range which would result in a macroscopic mean-field force, typically F (x) = −∇Φ(x),
Φ(x) = ρ ∗x φ,
where φ is the interaction potential and ρ the local density. The modelling of the interaction by such a coupled force is called a Vlasov description. When should one prefer a Vlasov, or a Boltzmann description? A dimensional analysis by Bobylev and Illner [88] shows that for inverse-power forces like 1/r s , and under natural scaling assumptions, • for s > 3, the Boltzmann term should prevail on the mean-field term; • for s < 3, the Boltzmann term should be negligible in front of the mean-field term. The separating case, s = 3, is the so-called Manev interaction [88,279]. There are subtle questions here, which are not yet fully understood, even at a formal level. Also the uniqueness of the relevant scaling is not clear. From a physicist’s point of view, however, it is generally accepted that a good description is obtained by adding up the effects of a mean-field term and those of a Boltzmann collision operator, with suitable dimensional coefficients. Another way to take into account interactions on a macroscopically significant scale is to use a description à la Povzner. In this model (see, for instance, [389]), particles interact 9 As a word of caution, we should add that even if they are so simplified, their mathematical analysis is not trivial at all, and many problems in the field still remain open.
A review of mathematical topics in collisional kinetic theory
89
through delocalized collisions, so that the corresponding Boltzmann operator is integrated with respect to the position y of the test particle, and reads
RN x
dy
RN v
− v∗ , x − y) f (y, v∗ )f (x, v ) − f (y, v∗ )f (x, v) . dv∗ B(v
(23)
now depends on x − y. On the other hand, there is no collision Note that the kernel B parameter σ any more, the outgoing velocities being uniquely determined by the positions x, y and the ingoing velocities v , v∗ . It was shown by Cercignani [140] that this type of equations could be retrieved as the limit of a large stochastic system of “soft spheres”. A related model is the Enskog equation for dense gases, which has never been clearly justified. It resembles Equation (23) but the multiplicity of the integral is 2N − 1 instead of 2N , because there is no integration over the distance |x − y|. Mathematical studies of the Enskog model have been performed by Arkeryd, Arkeryd and Cercignani [24,27,28] – in particular, reference [24] provides well-posedness and regularity under extremely general assumptions (large data, arbitrary dimension) by a contraction method. See Section 2.1 in Chapter 2E for an inelastic variant which is popular in the study of granular material. The study of these models is interesting not only in itself, but also because numerical schemes always have to perform some delocalization to simulate the effect of collisions. This explains why the results in [140] are very much related to some of the mathematical justifications for some numerical schemes, as performed in [453,396].
1.7. Collisions in plasma physics The importance and complexity of interaction processes in plasma physics justifies that we devote a special section to this topic. A plasma, generally speaking, is a gas of (partially or totally) ionized particles. However, this term encompasses a huge variety of physical situations: the density of a plasma can be extremely low or extremely high, the pressures can vary considerably, and the proportion of ionized particles can also vary over several orders of magnitude. Nonelastic collisions, recombination processes may be very important. We do not at all try to make a precise description here, and refer to classical textbooks such as Balescu [46], Delcroix and Bers [164], the very nice survey by Decoster in [160], or the numerous references that can be found therein. All of these sources put a lot of emphasis on the kinetic point of view, but [160] and [164] are also very much concerned with fluid descriptions. A point which should be made now, is that the classical collisional kinetic theory of gases a priori applies when the density is low (we shall make this a little bit more precise later on) and when nonelastic processes can be neglected. Even taking into account only elastic interactions, there are a number of processes going on in a plasma: Maxwell-type interactions between ions and neutral particles, Van der Waals forces between neutral particles, etc. However, the most important feature, both from the mathematical and the physical point of view, is the presence of Coulomb
90
C. Villani
interactions between charged particles. The basic model for the evolution of the density of such particles is the Vlasov–Poisson equation ⎧ ∂f ⎪ ⎨ ∂t + v · ∇x f + F (x) · ∇v f = 0, ⎪ ⎩F = −∇V ,
V=
e2 4πε0 r
∗x ρ,
ρ(t, x) = f (t, x, v) dv.
(24)
For simplicity, here we have written this equation for only one species of particles, and also we have not included the effect of a magnetic field, which leads to the Vlasov–Maxwell system (see, for instance, [191]). We have kept the physical parameters e = charge of the particle and ε0 = permittivity of vacuum for the sake of a short discussion about scales. Even though this is not the topic of this review paper, let us say just a few words on the Vlasov–Poisson equation. Its importance in plasma physics (including astrophysics) cannot be overestimated, and thousands of papers have been devoted to its study. We only refer to the aforementioned textbooks, together with the famous treatise by Landau and Lipschitz [304]. From the mathematical point of view, the basic questions of existence, uniqueness and (partial) regularity of the solution to the Vlasov equation have been solved at the end of the eighties, see in particular Pfaffelmoser [382], DiPerna and Lions [191], Lions and Perthame [318], Schaeffer [402]. Reviews can be found in Glassey [233] and Bouchut [96]. Stability, and (what is more interesting!) instability of several classes of equilibrium distributions to the Vlasov–Poisson equation have recently been the object of a lot of studies by Guo and Strauss [264–268]. Several important questions, however, have not been settled, like the derivation of the Vlasov–Poisson equation from particle systems (see Spohn [410] and Neunzert [356] for related topics) and the explanation of the famous and rather mysterious Landau damping effect. There is no doubt that the Vlasov–Poisson equation is the correct equation to describe a classical plasma on a short time scale. However, when one wants to consider long periods of time, it is necessary to take into account collisions between particles. For this it is natural to introduce a Boltzmann collision operator in the right-hand side of (24). However, the Boltzmann equation for Coulomb interactions does not make sense! Indeed, the collision integral would be infinite even for very smooth (or analytic) distribution functions. 10 This is due to the very slow decay of the Coulomb potential, and the resulting very strong angular singularity of the collision kernel given by Rutherford’s formula (12). A standard remedy to this problem is to assume that there is a screening (due to the presence of two species of particles, for instance), so that the effective interaction potential between charged particles is not the Coulomb interaction, but the so-called Debye potential φ(r) =
e−r/λD . 4πε0 r
(25)
10 More precisely, the natural definition of the collision operator would lead to the following nonsense:
whatever f , Q(f, f ) is an element of {−∞, 0, +∞}, see [450, Annex I, Appendix A].
A review of mathematical topics in collisional kinetic theory
91
Here λD is the Debye length, i.e., a typical screening distance. In the classical theory of plasmas, λD =
ε0 kT , ρe2
where k is Boltzmann’s constant, T is the temperature of the plasma (rigorously speaking, it should depend on x . . .) and ρ its mean density (same remark). The resulting collision kernel is no longer explicit, but at least makes sense, because the very strong angular singularity in Rutherford’s formula (12) is tamed. The replacement of Coulomb by Debye potential can be justified by half-rigorous, halfheuristic arguments (see the references already mentioned). However, in most of the cases of interest, the Debye length is very large with respect to the characteristic length r0 for collisions, called the Landau length: r0 =
e2 . 4πε0 kT
More precisely, in so-called classical plasmas (those for which the classical kinetic description applies), one has r0 ρ −1/3 λD . This means first that the Landau distance is very small with respect to other scales (so that collisions can be considered as localized), and secondly that the plasma is so dilute that the typical distance between particles is very small with respect to the screening distance, which is usually considered as the relevant space scale. By a formal procedure, Landau [291] showed that, as the ratio Λ ≡ 2λD /r0 → ∞, the Boltzmann collision operator for Debye potential behaves as log Λ QL (f, f ), 2πΛ where QL is the so-called Landau collision operator: QL (f, f ) = ∇v ·
R3
dv∗ a(v − v∗ ) f∗ (∇f ) − f (∇f )∗ .
(26)
Here a(z) is a symmetric (degenerate) nonnegative matrix, proportional to the orthogonal projection onto z⊥ : aij (z) =
zi zj L δij − 2 , |z| |z|
and L is a dimensional constant.
(27)
92
C. Villani
The resulting equation is the Landau equation. In adimensional units, it could be written as ∂f + v · ∇x f + F (x) · ∇v f = QL (f, f ). ∂t
(28)
Many mathematical and physical studies also consider the simplified case when only collisions are present, and the effect of the mean-field term is not present. However, the collision term, normally, should be considered only as a long-time correction to the meanfield term. We now present a variant of the Landau equation, which appears when one replaces the function L/|z| in (27) by |z|2 , so that aij (z) = |z|2 δij − zi zj .
(29)
This approximation is called “Maxwellian”. It is not realistic from the physical point of view, but has become popular because it leads to simpler mathematical properties and useful tests for numerical simulations. Under assumption (29), a number of algebraic simplifications arise in the Landau operator (26); since they are independent on the dimension, we present them in arbitrary dimension N 2. Without loss of generality, choose an orthonormal basis of RN in such a way that
RN
f dv = 1,
RN
f v dv = 0,
RN
f |v|2 dv = N
(unit mass, zero mean velocity, unit temperature), and assume moreover that RN
f vi vj dv = Ti δij
(the Ti ’s are the directional temperatures; of course with matrix (29) can be rewritten as
i
Ti = N ). Then the Landau operator
(N − Ti )∂ii f + (N − 1)∇ · (f v) + S f.
(30)
i
Here S stands for the Laplace–Beltrami operator, S f =
|v|2 δij − vi vj ∂ij f − (N − 1)v · ∇v f, ij
i.e., a diffusion on centered spheres in velocity space. Thus the Landau operator looks like a nonlinear Fokker–Planck-type operator, with some additional isotropisation effect due to the presence of the Laplace–Beltrami operator. The diffusion is enhanced in directions
A review of mathematical topics in collisional kinetic theory
93
where the temperature is low, and slowed down in directions where the temperature is high: this is normal, because in the end the temperature along all directions should be the same. Formulas like (30) show that in the isotropic case, and under assumption (29), the nonlinear Landau equation reduces (in a well-chosen orthonormal basis) to the linear Fokker–Planck equation! By this remark [447] one can construct many explicit solutions (which generalize the ones in [296]). These considerations explain why the Maxwellian variant of the Landau equation has become a popular test case in numerical analysis [106]. Let us now review other variants of the Landau equation. First of all, there are relativistic and quantum versions of it [304]. For a mathematically-oriented presentation, see, for instance, [298]. There are also other, more sophisticated models for collisions in plasmas: see, for instance, [164, Section 13.6] for a synthetic presentation. The most famous of these models is the so-called Balescu–Lenard collision operator, whose complexity is just frightening for a mathematician. Its expression was established by Bogoljubov [90] via a so-called BBGKY-type hierarchy, and later put by Lenard under the form that we give below. On the other hand, Balescu [46,47] derived it as part of his general perturbative theory of approximation of the Liouville equation for many particles. Just as the Landau operator, the Balescu–Lenard operator is in the form
∂ ∂f ∂f∗ dv∗ aij (v, v∗ ) f∗ −f , (31) ∂vi R3 ∂vj ∂v∗j ij
but now the matrix aij depends on f in a strongly nonlinear way: aij (v, v∗ ) =
ki kj 1 δ k · (v − v∗ ) dk, |k|4 |ε|2 k∈R3 ,|k|Kmax
(32)
where ε is the “longitudinal permittivity” of the plasma, 8π 1 k · (∇f )∗ dv∗ . ε=1− 2 k · (v − v∗ ) − i0 |k| Here δ is the Dirac measure at the origin, and 1 1 1 = lim =P + iπδ x − i0 ε→0+ x − iε x is a complex-valued distribution on the real line (P stands for the Cauchy principal part). Moreover, Kmax is a troncature parameter (whose value is not very clearly determined) which corresponds to values of the deviation angles beyond which collisions cannot be considered grazing. This is not a Debye cut! Contrary to Landau, Balescu and Lenard derived the operator QL (26) as an approximation of (31). To see the link between these two operators, let us set k = µω, µ 0, ω ∈ S 2 ; then one can rewrite (32) as
S2
dω δ ω · (v − v∗ ) ωi ωj
Kmax 0
dµ . µ|ε|2
(33)
94
C. Villani
But S2
dω δ(ω · z)ωi ωj =
zi zj π δij − 2 . |z| |z|
So one can replace the operator (31) by the Landau collision operator if one admits that the integral in dµ in (33) depends very little on v, v∗ , ω. Under this assumption, it is natural to replace f by a Maxwellian,11 and one finds for this integral an expression of the form 1 + (µ2D )/µ2 , where µD has the same homogeneity as the inverse of a Debye length. Then one can perform the integration; see Decoster [160] for much more details. In spite of its supposed accuracy, the interest of the Balescu–Lenard model is not so clear. Due to its high complexity, its numerical simulation is quite tricky. And except in very particular situations, apparently one gains almost nothing, in terms of physical accuracy of the results, by using it as a replacement for the Landau operator. In fact, it seems that the most important feature of the Balescu–Lenard operator, to this date, is to give a theoretical basis to the use of the Landau operator! There exist in plasma physics some even more complicated models, such as those which take into account magnetic fields (Rostoker operator, see, for instance, [465] and the references therein). We refrain from writing up the equations here, since this would require several pages, and they seem definitely out of reach of a mathematical treatment for the moment . . . . We also mention the simpler linear Fokker–Planck operator for Coulomb interaction, derived by Chandrasekhar. This is a linear operator of Landau-type, which describes the evolution of a test-particle interacting with a “bath” of Coulomb particles in thermal equilibrium. A formula for it is given in Balescu [46, §37], in terms of special functions.
1.8. Physical validity of the Boltzmann equation Experience has shown that the Boltzmann equation and its variants realistically describe phenomena which occur in dilute atmosphere, in particular aeronautics at high altitude, or interactions in dilute plasmas. In many situations, predictions based on the Navier–Stokes equation are not accurate for low densities; a famous historical example is provided by the so-called Knudsen minimum effect in a Poiseuille flow [148, p. 99]: if the difference of pressure between the entrance and the exit of a long, narrow channel is kept fixed, then the flow rate through a cross-section of this channel is not a monotonic function of the average pressure, but exhibits a minimum for a certain value of this parameter. This phenomenon, established experimentally by Knudsen, remained controversial till the 1960’s. Also the Boltzmann equation cannot be replaced by fluid equations when it comes to the study of boundary layers (Knudsen layer, Sone sublayer due to curvature . . .) and the gas-surface interaction. Nowadays, with the impressive development of computer power, it is possible to perform very precise numerical simulations which seem to fully corroborate the predictions based on the Boltzmann equation – within the right range of physical parameters, of course. 11 This is the natural statistical equilibrium, see Section 2.5.
A review of mathematical topics in collisional kinetic theory
95
All these questions are discussed, together with many numerical simulations and experiments, in the recent broad-audience survey book by Cercignani [148] (see also the review paper [136] by the same author in the present volume). 2. Mathematical problems in collisional kinetic theory In this section, we try to define the most interesting mathematical problems which arise in the study of Boltzmann-like equations. At this point we should make it clear that the Boltzmann equation can be studied for the sake of its applications to dilute gases, but also as one of the most basic and famous models for nonequilibrium statistical mechanics. 2.1. Mathematical validity of the Boltzmann equation In the last section, we have mentioned that, in the right range of physical parameters, the physical validity of the Boltzmann equation now seems to be beyond any doubt. On the other hand, the mathematical validity of the Boltzmann equation poses a more challenging problem. For the time being, it has been investigated only for the hard-sphere model. Let us give a short description of the problem in the case of hard spheres. But before that, we add a word of caution about the meaning of “mathematical validity”: it is not a proof that the model is the right one in a certain range of physical parameters (whatever this may mean). It is only a rigorous derivation of the model, in a suitable asymptotic procedure, from another model, which is conceptually simpler but contains more information (typically: the positions of all the particles, as opposed to the density of particles). Of course, the Boltzmann equation, just like many models, can be derived either by mathematical validation, or by direct modelling assumptions, and the second approach is more arbitrary, less interesting from the mathematical point of view, but not less “respectable” if properly implemented! This is why, for instance, Truesdell [430] refuses to consider the problem of mathematical validity of the Boltzmann equation. The validation approach to be discussed now is due to Grad [249], and it is particularly striking because the starting point is nothing but the model given by Newton’s laws of classical mechanics. It was not before 1972 that Cercignani [139] showed Grad’s approach to be mathematically consistent, in the sense that it can be rigorously implemented if one is able to prove some “reasonable” estimates on the solutions.12 Grad’s approach. The starting point is the equation of motion, according to Newton’s laws, for a system of n spherical particles of radius r in R3 , bouncing elastically on each other with billiard reflection laws. The state of the system is described by the positions and velocities of the centers, x1 , v1 , . . . , xn , vn , and the phase space is the subset of (R3x × R3v )n (or (X × R3 )n ) such that |xi − xj | r (i = j ). On this phase space there is a flow (St )t 0 , well-defined up to a zero-probability set of initial configurations, which is neglected. We now consider symmetric probability densities f n (x1 , v1 , . . . , xn , vn ) on the phase space 12 This remark is important because many people doubted the possibility of a rigorous derivation, see the discussion in Section 2.4.
96
C. Villani
(symmetry reflects the physical assumption of undiscernability of particles). Of course, the flow (St ) on the phase space induces a flow on such probability densities, the solution of which is denoted by (ftn )t 0 . Moreover, by integrating ftn over all variables but the k first position variables and the k first velocity variables, one defines the k-particle distribution function Pk f n (x1 , v1 , . . . , xk , vk ) (think of Pk as a projection operator). In probabilistic terminology, P1 f n is the first marginal of f n . Assume now that (i) n → ∞, r → 0 (continuum limit) in such a way that nr 2 → 1 [the gas is sufficiently dilute, but not too much, so that only binary interactions play a significant role, and a typical particle collides about once in a unit of time. This limit is called the Boltzmann–Grad limit]; (ii) P1 f0n → f0 , where f0 is a given distribution function [this assumption means that the one-particle function at time 0 can be treated as “continuous” as the number of particles becomes large]; (iii) P2 f0n → f0 ⊗ f0 , and more generally, for fixed k, Pk f0n → f0 ⊗ · · · ⊗ f0
(34)
[this is the chaos assumption at time 0]; the problem is then to prove that P1 ftn → ft , where ft = ft (x, v) is the solution of the Boltzmann equation with hard-sphere kernel, and with initial datum f0 . This problem seems exceptionally difficult. The main result in the field is the 1973 Lanford’s theorem [292]. He proved the result for small time, and under some strong assumptions on the initial probability distributions Pk f0n : they should be continuous, satisfy appropriate Gaussian-type bounds, and converge uniformly13 towards their respective limits. Later his proof was rewritten by Illner and Pulvirenti, and extended to arbitrarily large time intervals, under a smallness assumption on the initial datum, which enabled to treat the Boltzmann equation as a kind of perturbation of the free transport equation: see [275, 276] and the nice reviews in [149,394,410]. For sure, one of the outstanding problems in the theory of the Boltzmann equation is to extend Lanford’s result to a more general framework, without smallness assumption. Another considerable progress would be its extension to long-range interactions, which is not clear even from the formal point of view (see, for instance, Cercignani [137]). The Boltzmann–Grad limit is also often called the low-density limit, and presented in the following manner [149, p. 60]: starting from the equations of Newtonian dynamics, blow-up the scales of space and time by a factor ε−1 (thus ε is the ratio of the microscopic scale by the macroscopic scale), and require the number of particles to be of the order of ε−2 , then let ε go to 0. In particular, the density will scale as ε2/3 since the volume will scale as ε−3 , and this explains the terminology of “low density limit”. Remarks about the chaos assumption. 1. Heuristically, the relevance of the chaos assumption in Boltzmann’s derivation can be justified as follows: among all probability distributions f n which have a given marginal 13 On compact subsets of (R3 × R3 )k , which is the set obtained from (R3 × R3 )k by deleting all configurations = with xi = xj for some distinct indices i, j .
A review of mathematical topics in collisional kinetic theory
97
f = P1 f n , the most likely, in some sense which we do not make precise here,14 is the tensor product f ⊗· · ·⊗f . And as n → ∞, this distribution becomes by far the most likely. Thus, Boltzmann’s chaos assumption may be justified by the fact that we choose the most likely microscopic probability distribution f n which is compatible to our macroscopic knowledge (the one-particle distribution, or first marginal, f ). 2. In fact, the chaos property is automatically satisfied, in weak sense, by all sequences of probability measures (f n ) on (R3 × R3 )n which are compatible with the density f . More precisely: let us say that a microscopic configuration z = (x1 , v1 , . . . , xn , vn ) ∈ (R3x × R3v )n is admissible if its empirical density, 1
δ(xi ,vi ) , n n
ωz =
i=1
is a good approximation to the density f (x, v) dx dv, and let (f n )n∈N be a sequence of symmetric probability densities on (R3x × R3v )n respectively, such that the associated measures µn give very high probability to configurations which are admissible. In a more precise writing, we require that for every bounded continuous function ϕ(x, v) on R3 × R3 , and for all ε > 0,
n µn z ∈ R3x × R3v ;
ϕ(x, v) ωz (dx dv) − f (t, x, v) dx dv > ε −−−→ 0. n→∞ 3
R3x ×Rv
Then, (f n ) satisfies the chaos property, in weak sense [149, p. 91]: for any k 1, Pk f n −−−→ f ⊗k n→∞
in weak-∗ measure sense. This statement expresses the fact that f n is automatically close to the tensor product f ⊗n in the sense of weak convergence of the marginals. However, weak convergence is not sufficient to derive the Boltzmann equation, because of the problem of localization of collisions. Therefore, in Lanford’s theorem one imposes a stronger (uniform) convergence of the marginals, or strong chaos property. 3. This is the place where probability enters the Boltzmann equation: via the initial datum, i.e., the probability density (f n )! According to [149, p. 93], the conclusion of Lanford’s theorem can be reformulated as follows: for all time t > 0, if ftn is obtained 14 This is related to the fact that the tensor product f ⊗n has minimal entropy among all n-particles probability distribution functions f n with given first marginal f , and to the fact that the negative of the entropy yields a measure of “likelihood”, see Section 2.4 below. [In this review, the entropy of a distribution function f is defined by the formula H (f ) = f log f ; note the sign convention.] For hard spheres, a subtlety arises from the fact that configurations in which two spheres interpenetrate are forbidden, so f n cannot be a tensor product. Since however the total volume of the spheres, nr 3 , goes to 0 in the limit, it is natural to assume that this does not matter. On the other hand, contact points in the n-particle phase space play a crucial role in the way the chaos property is propagated in time.
98
C. Villani
from f0n by transportation along the characteristics of the microscopic dynamics, and if µnt is the probability measure on (R3x × R3v )n whose density is given by ftn , then for all ε > 0, and for all bounded, continuous function ϕ(x, v) on R3x × R3v , µnt
n z ∈ R3x × R3v ;
R3x ×R3v
ϕ(x, v) ωz (dx dv) − ft (x, v) dx dv > ε −−−→ 0, n→∞
where ft is the solution to the Boltzmann equation with initial datum f0 . In terms of µn : µn
n z ∈ R3x × R3v ;
R3x ×R3v
ϕ(x, v) ωSt z (dx dv) − ft (x, v) dx dv > ε −−−→ 0. n→∞
In words: for most initial configurations, the evolution of the density under the microscopic dynamics is well approximated by the solution to the Boltzmann equation. Of course, this does not rule out the existence of “unlikely” initial configurations for which the solution of the Boltzmann equation is a very bad approximation of the empirical measure. 4. If the chaos property is the crucial point behind the Boltzmann derivation, then one should expect that it propagates with time, and that ∀t > 0,
Pk ftn → ft ⊗ · · · ⊗ ft .
(35)
However, this propagation property only holds in a weak sense. Even if the convergence is strong (say, uniform convergence of all marginals) in (34), it has to be weaker in (35), say almost everywhere, see the discussion in Cercignani et al. [149]. The reason for this weakening is the appearance of microscopic correlations (under evolution by the microscopic, reversible dynamics). In particular, if the initial microscopic datum is “very likely”, this does not imply at all that the microscopic datum at later times should be very likely! On the contrary, it should present a lot of correlations . . . . 5. In fact, one has to be extremely cautious when handling (35). To illustrate this, let us formally show that for t > 0 the approximation P2 ftn (x, v; y, w) ft (x, v)ft (y, w)
(36)
cannot be true in strong sense, uniformly in all variables,15 as n → ∞ (the symbol here means “approaches, in L∞ norm, uniformly in all variables x, y, v, w, as n → ∞”). Indeed, assume that (36) holds true uniformly in x, y, v, w, and choose y = x + rσ , 15 Constrained by |x − y| r.
A review of mathematical topics in collisional kinetic theory
99
v − w, σ > 0, i.e., an ingoing collisional configuration in the two-particle phase space. Then, presumably P2 ftn (x, v; x + rσ, w) ft (x, v)ft (x + rσ, w) ft (x, v)ft (x, w)
(37)
as n → ∞. But from the specular reflection condition, for any t > 0, P2 ftn (x, v; x + rσ, w) = P2 ftn (x, v ; x + rσ, w ), where v and w are post-collisional velocities, v = v − v − w, σ σ,
w = w + v − w, σ σ.
Applying (36) again, this would result in P2 ftn (x, v; x + rσ, w) = P2 ftn (x, v ; x + rσ, w ) ft (x, v )ft (x, w ), which is not compatible with (37) (unless ft solves Equation (53) below). This contradiction illustrates the fact that (36) cannot be propagated by the dynamics of hard spheres. It is actually property (37), sometimes called one-sided chaos, which is used in the derivation of the Boltzmann equation, and which should be propagated for positive times: it means that the velocities of particles which are just about to collide are not correlated. But it is a very difficult problem to handle Equation (37) properly, because it involves the restriction of f n to a manifold of codimension 1, and may be violated even for initial data which satisfy the conditions of Lanford’s theorem! So an appropriate generalized sense should be given to (37). Lanford’s argument cleverly avoids any discussion of (37), and only assumes (36) at time 0, the approximation being uniform outside collisional configurations. So he plainly avoids discussing one-sided chaos, and does not care what is propagated for positive times, apart from weak chaos.16 To sum up: the physical derivation of the Boltzmann equation is based on the propagation of one-sided chaos, but no one knows how this property should be expressed mathematically – if meaningful at all. An easier variant of the validation problem is the derivation of linear transport equations describing the behavior of a Lorentz gas: a test-particle in a random pinball game, with scatterers randomly distributed according to (say) a Poisson law. Under a suitable scaling, the law of this test-particle converges towards the solution of a linear Boltzmann equation, as was first formalized by Gallavotti [226], before several improvements appeared [409, 91]. See Pulvirenti [394] for a review and introduction of the subject. The convergence actually holds true for almost all (in the sense of Poisson measure) fixed configuration of scatterers, but fails for certain specific configurations, for instance a periodic array, as shown in Bourgain, Golse and Wennberg [102]. We also note that Desvillettes and Pulvirenti [179] are able to rigorously justify the linear Boltzmann equation for some interactions with infinite range. 16 This is possible because he uses a perturbative proof, based on an iterative Duhamel formula, in which everything is expressed in terms of the initial datum . . . .
100
C. Villani
Kac’s approach. To conclude this section, we mention another line of approach towards the mathematical justification of the Boltzmann equation. It goes via the construction of some many-particle stochastic system, such that the first marginal of its law at a given time t should be an approximation of the solution to the Boltzmann equation if the initial datum is chaotic. This subject was initiated by Kac17 [283], and developed by Sznitman [412] in connection with the problem of propagation of chaos. Recent progress on this have been achieved by Graham and Méléard [256,344]. The main conceptual difference between both approaches lies in the moment where probability is introduced, and irreversibility18 as well. In Lanford’s approach, the starting point is a deterministic particle system; it is only the particular “chaotic” choice of the initial datum which leads to the macroscopic, irreversible Boltzmann equation in the limit. On the other hand, for Kac the microscopic particle system is already stochastic and irreversible from the beginning. Then the main effect of the limit is to turn a linear equation on a large n-particle phase space, into a nonlinear equation on a reduced, one-particle phase space. Of course Kac’s approach is less striking than Grad’s, because the starting point contains more elaborate modelling assumptions, since stochasticity is already built in. Kac formulated his approach in a spatially homogeneous19 setting, while this would be meaningless for Grad’s approach. In fact, it is as if Kac wanted to treat the positions of the particles (which, together with ingoing velocities, determine the outgoing velocities) as hidden probabilistic variables. Then, all the subtleties linked to one-sided chaos can be forgotten, and it is sufficient to study just propagation of (weak) chaos. Moreover, Kac’s approach becomes important when it comes to make an interpretation of the Monte Carlo numerical schemes which are often used to compute approximate solutions of the Boltzmann equation. These schemes are indeed based on large stochastic particle systems. See Pulvirenti [394,453,396] for references about the study of these systems, in connection with the validation problem. We do not develop here on the problem of the rigorous justification of numerical schemes, but this topic is addressed in the companion review [136] by Cercignani.
2.2. The Cauchy problem From the mathematical point of view, the very first problem arising in the study of the Boltzmann equation is the Cauchy problem: given a distribution function f0 (x, v) on N N RN x × Rv (or X × Rv ), satisfying appropriate and physically realistic assumptions, show that there exists a (unique) solution of ∂f + v · ∇x f = Q(f, f ), ∂t f (0, ·, ·) = f0 . 17 See Section 1.5 in Chapter 2E. 18 See Section 2.4. 19 See Section 5.2.
(38)
A review of mathematical topics in collisional kinetic theory
101
Needless to say, the Boltzmann equation seems impossible to solve explicitly,20 except in some very particular situations: semi-explicit solutions by Bobylev [79], Bobylev and Cercignani [81]; self-similar solutions of