.e:::t:I
HBR .ORG
JUNE 2010
~ 40 The Big Idea Start an Entrepreneurial Revolut ion
•
Daniel J . Isenberg 94 Sust ainability
Strategies for Gree n Product Development Gregory Unruh a nd Richard Etten son
•
114 Managing Yourself
Turn the Job You Have Into t he Job You Want Amy Wrzesniewski, Ju stin M. Berg, a nd Jane E. Dutton
, I
il l
ANAGING CHANGE HOW TO DO IT WHEN TO DO IT PAGE 53
Smarter business for a Smarter Planet:
Over 1,500 CEOs are tackling complexity with creativity. See how they're getting it done. More volatile and complex than ever before, the business climate has forever changed.
IBM found that 79% of CEOs expect increased global complexity, yet only 49% feel prepared . But forward-thinking CEOs are actually finding ways to capitalize on this. The findings are in the 2010 IBM Global CEO Study, the largest study of its kind.
From tace-to-tace conversations with over 1,500 CEOs-from companies of all sizesacross 60 countries and 33 industries, IBM identifies four types of organizations and distinguishes what successful ones have in common. Not only does the study give you
access to executive-level thinking, it serves as a roadrnap for smarter, more creative leadership. A smarter business needs smarter thinking . Let's build a smarter planet. Get Capitalizing on Complexity: Insights from the Global Chief Executive Officer Study at ibm.com/ceostudy7. One in a series of C-suite studies.
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
(1M, the (1M ~, tJ'no:rn. ~ FInl iI'Il the pInllX1<1 n ba»".'os rJ lil!li'O) 8 I.\IsQss. Madns Cor'Il. ~ " """Y ~ _ rnqt be ttadem.vl<srJ IlM or ClhetOOffWOl.'S,A(l.fItlnt fIsI rJ IlM tta:lemaflos ~ ~ (W1 the \\\lb at _trn,~,srttm, 0 ~
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
0hI pro).I;l iI'Il _ I\YI'I€I$ Madns ~ 20 10
~
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
WE MERELY HAD TO IMPROVE A FOOD THE WHOLE COUNTRY GREW UP LOVING. NO PRESSURE.
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
-
Next to the revered hamburger, nothing is more classic to fast food than the frenc h fry. So when a major restaurant chain wanted to create french fries with zero grams
I
trans fat per serving , they knew they couldn't change t he taste consumers loved .
They ca lled on Ca rgi ll , w ho worked wit h t hem t o develop a speci al fryi ng oil. Extensive canota seed research, new processing techno logies and an identity preserved
supply ch ain resulted in a cooking oil that performed well for fries , ch icken and fish . Consu mer tests proved ou r approa ch was successful in providing the same great
taste . Now our custo mer serves fries consumers can fee l good about , wh ile s till enjoying that class ic f lavo r. This is how Cargill works w it h customers .
c o l l a b o r a te
food ,
agricultura
&
r isk
>
create
ma nagement
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
>
solutions
s u c c e e d '·
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
June 2010
hbr.org Harvard E-
Business ~~;;. Review ~,-o~ MANAGING CHANGE
_.
IlUW IU L1U"
W>+EN TO 00 IT
•
Aboutthe spotl1lht Artkt Over the past 25years. Antony Gormley has revitalized the human image in sculptu re through a radical investigation of the body asa place of memory and transformation, using his OWll body as subject.
tool. and material. Since 1990 he has expan ded his concern with the human condition to explore the collective body a nd t he relationship between self
and other in large-scale installations. His work has been exh ibited throughout the UKand internationally. Gormley was awarded t he Turner Prize in 1994 and the South Bank Prize for Visual Art in 1999. .~~
Antony Gormle y.
Doma in 'I~l d, 4.76 mm square st ainlO'SS steel bars
I
Varioos siles' 287 eleme nts, derived from molds of loca l inhabitants of Newcas tle · Gatl/'Sr>ead. ux. aged 2.5-84 years Installation vjew-. BALTIC centre for Contemporary Art, Gateshead Commio;sion for BALTIC centre for Contemporary An, Gateshead
54 The Decision-Driven Organization Most CEOs t hink fi nancial performance is tied to company structure, so ifyou want to increase value, you have to reorganize, But in t rut h, most reorgs fall flat , The ones that work best a re built around decisions: Firms that make them faster and better than riva ls get ahead. Marcia W. Blenko, Michael C. Mankins, and Paul Rogers
64 The productivity Paradox: How sony pictures Gets More Out of people by Demanding Less Companies often burn employees out by expect ing them to run like machines- always on and at full t hrottle. Sony Pictures , however, has found that allowing staffers to take t ime out to renew th eir energy boosts t heir perfor mance-and generates impressive fi nancial resu lts. Tony Schwartz 70 Change for Change's Sake Just as seemingly fit people can have high choleste rol, well-pe rforming companies can suffer from a buildup of inflexible networks, unquestioned routines, and overly powe rful units. A corporate "cholesterol test " can reveal how much and what kind of cha nge to consider. Freek Vermeulen, Phanish Puranam, and Ranjay Gulati
HBR.ORG Ma RE aN STRATEGIES FOR A CHANGI NG WORLO
Practical advice to hel p you energize your company, your team. and yourself. hbr.
org/strategies· cha nging·world
June 2010 Harvard Business Review 7 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
HBR.ORG
Feat ures June 2010 THE BIG IDEA
How to Start an Entrepreneurial Revolution As the leaders of Rwanda, Israel, and Chile have seen, entrepreneurship can transform an economy. But creating a breeding -. ground for new ventures isn't simple; you need to get many elements right. Here's what we know works. Daniel J. Isenberg
.
•
Are You a High Potential?
78
High-pot ent ia l managers have distinguishing characteristics and behaviors that companies rout ine ly recognize. l earn what those qualities are- and what you can do to exhibit them-so that you make the list. Douglas A. Ready, Jay A. Conger, and
•
Linda A. Hill
86
The Coherence Premium Rarely is a com pany disci plined enough to focus on "what we do better t han anyone" in making every decision across all its businesses. Rarer still is the company that has aligned its different iating inte rnal capabilities with the right external market posit ion . The firms that do are "coherent," and they reap a reward . Paul Leinwand and Cesare Mainardi
'-..//4
ey respondents top teams ss than 10% of me developing -potent ial leaders.
Growing Green: Three
Smart Paths to Developing Sustainable Products Most executives believe that sustainability is a revenue driver, but t hey're not sure how to make it work for the m. Here are three broad strategies for aligning companies' gree n prod uct goals with thei r capabilities. Gregol}' Unruh and Richard Ettenson
VINEET NAYAR
On inverting the leadership pyramid blogs. hbr.org/nayar
103 THE GLOBE
94
The China Rules A practical guide t o leadi ng a company in the world's t hird-largest economy. Lynn S. Paine 110 HOW I DID IT
A Maverick CED Explains How He Persuaded His Team
to Leap into the Future The CEO of HCl recnnctcgree wanted to tu rn the organizat ion ups ide down -so he put his employees before his customers. Vineet Nay ar
June 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
Most of what expat CEDs learn inChina hasn't made its way into management books or classrooms.
WELLS FARGO
TH E PR IVAT E BA N K
lowe everything I have to hard work.
N ow I want to share
the wisdom I have gained,
so my family can build
on my experience.
I need someone who knows
what it 's like to be me.
Every family deserves a u nique legacy. As your family story evolves, we'll wo rk closely with your trusted advisors, offering objective guidance to help bring your vision to fruition. Generations have built, pre served,
a nd transitioned their wealth with the help of Wells Fargo. So no matter what you r story is. you can rely on our strength, stabi lity and teamwork to help you move forward with confidence. Visit wellsfarqo.com/yourstory
or call 866-460-8465 and talk with us today.
Together we'll go far
Wealth Planning' Banking· Trust- Investments· Insurance - Family Wealth
Investment and Insurance Products: NOT FDIC·lnsured
NO Bank Guarantee
MAY LoS
Wells Fargo Private Bank provides financial services and products through Wells Fargo Bank. N.A. and its affiliates. Deposit and loan products offered ~ through Wells Fargo Bank. NA Member FDIC. Insurance products are available through Insura nce subsidiaries of Wells Fargo & Company IT.;:O and underw ritten by non·affil iated Insurance Companies. Not available in all states. e 2010 Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. All rights reserved. www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
Reacting to the stock market is just investing. Taking stock in the long term is Vanquardinq.
••
-. .-
Vanguard provides services to the Vanguard funds at-cost. For more information about Vanguard funds, including at-cost services, visit www.vanguard.com/different. or call BOO-505-7182, to obtain a prospectus. Investment objectives, risks, charges, expenses, and other important information about a fund are contained in the prospectus; read and consider it carefully before investing. All investments are subject to risk. 2010 The Vanguard Group, Inc. All rights reserved. Vanguard Marketing Corporation, DIstributor. www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
Why try to predict the market when it can't be predicted? Why pay low-cost when you can pay at-cost? Why let profits go to outside interests when they can go back into your funds? At Vanguard we've asked these questions for decades. We realized that buying the market. paying only what it costs us to run the funds. and sticking to a long term plan can be a strategy for success. Vanguard is not different to be different. It's different to be better.
Are you just investing or are you Vanguarding 7 See how at vanguard.com/different or call us at 800-505-7182.
L...-_ _ • •
_
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
Vanguard
HB R.ORG
Departments June 2010 IMAGINING THI FUTURI OF LIADIRSHIP
14 18
From the Ed it or Int eracti on
People may want you, but that doesn't mean they like you.
Idea Watch
page 32
FUIANCEI THI WAY FORWARD
23 FIRST
34 VISION STATEMENT
Why Dinosaurs Will Keep Ruling the Auto Industry
Six Ways to Find Value in Twitter's Noise
Incumbents are best equipped to handle cars' design complexity. PLUS piggybacked IT service, silent employees, social investors, off-ramping women, and more
Ma rket ers, take note. COLUMNS 36 C.K. PRAHALAD
When success factors t urn into orthodoxies 32 DEFEND YOUR RESEARCH
The More People Want Something. the Less They'll Like It Why marketing strategies based on product scarcity often backfire
Craft your job to s uit you page "4
38 DAN ARIELY
The unint ended consequences of measuring performance
Tackling the obvious page]6
Mi ne a stream of co nsum er data in nea r-real ti me page 34
ll4 ~:E.~Y:'~~Fnce Turn the Job You Have into the Job You Want
Feeling stuck in your job? 'Job crafting" can help you redefine and reenergize your work life by organizing tas ks in ways tha t play to your passions and strengt hs. Amy Wrz esniewski, J ustin M. Berg, and Jane E. Dutton
leadership as we know it is over. So. what's next? blogs.hbr. org/ imaginingt he-fut ure-ofleadership
118 CASE STUDY
When the CEO's Personal Crusa de Drives Decisions Should th e HR director step in? Randle D. Raggio 126 RECOMMENDED Review s 128 LIFE'S WORK
Joe Girardi The manager of the New York Yankees on using information to im prove instincts
12 Harllard Business Review June 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
Can we reinvt! nt the financial system? Should we? Join the debate. blogs. hbr.org/ fmancet he-wa.y-forward BEST PRACTICES
HOW to have a disagreement with a coworker blogs.hbr.org/ best-practices .IDI GIRARDI
An extended interlliew with the Yankees' manager on mentoring his successor, confronting his boss. and never missing date night hbr.org/ girardi
L
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
HBR.ORG
From the Editor "Modesty, Humility, and Humanity" he world ofstrategy t hinking has lost a giant. On April 16, C.K. Prahalad died in San Diego after a sho rt illness, He had just turned in his column for this issue, proud that he was apparently the fi rst aut hor in our history to write a piece from t he lCU. We fully expected him to recover and were shoc ked-as were his ma ny friends and admirers- that he passed away at age 68, still in his prime and full of plans for big new projects, I first met C.K. in July 2008 in New York, where, as the deputy man aging editor of Time, I had organized a debate on "creative capitalism"- BillGates's idea for sp reading the benefits ofcapitalism to the billions who have been left out. It's litt le wonder that C.K. was
T C.K. Prah alad 1941-2010
Illustrating this mon th's Spotlight package is Antony Gormley, the British artist whose powerful installations and rooftop sculptures have been t he talk of Manhat tan this spring.
the fi rst person Gates named when I asked him who should be on the panel. C.K. had created a remarkable body of work that included his celeb rated 1990 HBRarticle (with Gary Hamel), which coined the term "core competence;' and his groundbreaking 2004 boo k,
ABOVE Event Horizon, 20 07 27 fiberglass and 4 cast-iron figures 1S9 x53 x 29cm A Hayward Gallery commission, presented by Mad ison Square Park COnservancy, New vcrk, 2010
The Fortune at the Bottom of the Pyramid, which explained how the world's poor could be a valuable market, He could be counted on in any discussion to provide wise, assured, and often blunt insight. During the creative capitalism debate he said, "This movement will not go forward if the media...does not play its part.... The stories from the poor countries need not be only stories ofpoverty and corruption:' We took this as a worthy challenge,
14 Harvard Business Review June 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
Several months later, when I was interviewing for t he posit ion ofHBR editor in chief, C.K. was one of the fi rst people I called . He was generous wit h his time and straigh tfo rward with his views, praising t he magazine where praise was due and pointing out what he saw as its shortcomings, He urged me to compete for the job, adding that he would be a willing sounding board if I landed it. I'm sorry that l-- Hke so many others- have lost the benefit of his wisdom. We chose C,K, as our inaugu ral columnist for the relaunched HBR this past January. No one, we thought, better combined gravi tas with a willingness to pursu e new ideas. His debut column, outlining the duties ofthe "responsible manager," was drawn from a lect ure he first delivered to his students in 1977, It becam e his concluding lecture in every academic year since. "Leadership," he wrote, "is about sel f- awareness, recognizing your failings, and developing modesty, humility, and humanity." These were t he values th at C.K, Prahalad lived by. We at HBR feel very lucky t hat we crossed paths with him so many times during his ext raordi nary journey.
Adi Ignatius, Editor in Chief
Thepower of desktop virtualization. Thousands of virtual desktops and
applications, in any combination, now in your capable hands. Citril' xeonesucc" with
HDX'Mtechnology gives you ~
an effortless way to deliver high-definition Windows desktops
as apersonalized,
on-demand service.
No matter how many devices, users or locations you
them from a single set of secure,
centrally managed images. All from
one convenient location-your fingertips. Think of it as simplicity, delivered.
Simplicity is power. Citrix.
•
CITRIX'
•
Cilrix.comiSimplicitylsPower
C2OOl_SyslIms. ........_ _
~
...
tllX_.. .-..
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
d_S\
~Harvard
Business Review EDITOR IN CHIEF Adi Ignatius EDITOR, HBR Karen Oilton
ARE YOU HAPPY AT WORK? When almost everyone reports being stressed and overworked. turn to the Summer 2010 issue o f Harvard Business Review OnPoim t o gu ide you and your employees toward higher job sat isfaction and higher productiv ity. Our expert authors advise strong leadersh ip to mot ivate people. a focus on building trust, face -to-face communication, and se lf-reflection. What
EDITOR, HBR.ORG Eric Hellweg
EXECUTIVE EDITORS sarah Cliffe paul Michelman (special projects)
DEPUTY EDITOR, HBRGROUP Kat herine Bell
EDITORS AT LA RGE Julia Kir by, Anand P. Raman
ART DI RECTOR, HBR Karen Player
SENIOR EDITORS Alison Beard, David Champion (Paris), JimmyG uterman, JeffKehoe, Daniel McGinn, Melind a Meri no, Gardiner Morse , M. Ellen Peebles, Steven Prokesch SENIOR ASSOCIATE EDITORS SCOtt seooeto. Roberta A . Fusaro ASSOCIATE EDITORS Kathleen Carr, sarah Green, And rew O'Connell. Ania wieckows ki ARTICLES EDITORS Christina aorta. Lisa Burrell, Susan Donovan, Martha Lee Spaulding
dennes your ideal workplace?
ASSISTANT EDITORS Susan Jac kson, Rasika welankiwa r
Articles include:
EDITORIAL COORDINATORS Meghan Ennes, COurtneySChinke
• "HBR Case Study: Why Are We Losing AU Our Good People?" by Edward E. Lawler III • "Management by Whose Objectives?" by Harry Levinson • "The Human Moment at Work" by Edward M. Hallowe ll • "Reawakening Your Passion for Work" by Richard
aoyams.
Ann ie
aceee.
and Daniel Goleman
EOITORIAL DIRECTOR, HBR PRESS Jacqueline Murphy
STAFFASSISTANT Jac k
EDITORIAL DI RECTOR, HBR GROUP Justin Fox
DESIGN DI RECTOR, HBR PRESS Steph ani FinkS
EDITORIAL PRODUCTION DIRECTOR Dana Ussy PRODUCTDEVELOPMENT TEAM Kate Adams, Susan rrarcts, Jane Heifetz, Karen Palmer SENIOR PRODUCTION EDITORS Allison Peter, Jenni fer Waring, Christine W ild er SENIOR ASSOCIATE ART DI RECTOR Chandra Tall man DESIGNER, HBR.D RG SOnya Mead DESIGNER UndsayA.Sweeney PRODUCTION EDITOR
Josette Akresh -Gonzales
cmtsuoec.
SENIOR PRODUCTION SPECIALISTS Donald MacDonald, Oaniet west
CONTRIBUTING EDITORS Bronwyn Frye r, Paul Hemp, Richard Horn ik, Johnr. Land ry. Lew McCreary
PRODUCTION COORDINATOR Adria Reynolds
CONTRIBUTING STAFF ste ven DeMaio , owen Edward s, Lil ith Z,C. Fondulas. Amy L. Haltiday, Amy Meeker, Annie Noonan, Betsy Robichaud, Kristin Murp hy Romano
Plus, from HBR.org. "Top Ten Ways to Find JOy at Work" by Rosabeth Moss Kanter and more ...
SUMMER ISSUE
A NOTE TO READERS The views expresse d in articles are t he authors' and not necessa rily t hose of Harvord Business Review. Harvard Business SChool, or Harvard University. Aut hors may have consulting or other business relationship s with the companies they discuss.
ON NEWSSTANDS
NOW Harvard Bus;ness Review OnPa im (available quarterly on newsstands and at hbr.org) focuses on a single theme each issue, It includes expert·authored art icles from HBIl's rich archives. helpful article summaries. company examples. and suggest ions for further reading,
SUBMISSIONS We encourage prospective authors to follow HBR's~Gu idel ines fo r Authors" before submitting manuscripts. Ioobtain a copy, please go to our website at WWIN.hbr.org or write to The EditC!', Horvord BusiJless Review, 6D Harvard Way, Boston, MA 02163 or send e -mail to hbr_editorial@hbr,org. Unsolicited man uscri pts w ill be returned only if acco mpanied by a self-addressed stam ped envelope. LIBRARY ACCESS Libraries offer online access to cu rrent and back issues of Harvord Business Revie w t hro ugh EBSCO host databases.
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
SUBSCRIPTION SERVICES UNlTEDSTATESAND CANADA 800-274·3214 I fax B13-35 4·3467 Harvord Business Review, P.O. Box 6227D Tamp a, FL 33662 ALL OTHER COUNTRIES 31-20-4874465 I fax3 1-2o-48744 12 Harvord Business Review, P.O. Box 20501 1001 NM Amsterdam, The Net her la nd s ONLINE hbr.org/subscriberservices RATESPER YEAR un ited States, $119 I canada, US$139 International, USU6S I Mexico, US$139 EDITORIAL OFFICES 60 Harvard Way, Boston, MA D2163 617 -7B3-7410 I fax 617-783 ·7493 www.h b r.org Volu me 8 8, Num ber 6,JuJle 20 10 Printed inthe U.S.A . OES IGN cot<SUl TANTS de l.oxe & .t.ssociates
~ Harvard
Business Review GROUPPUBUSHER ~ MadM
VICE PRESIDENT
.SSOClATtGROUP
OF MARKEnNG
PUBLISHER
$aWl McConviUe
HenryJ. Boye
SENIOR DIRECTOR OF CONSUMER
GENERAL MANAGER
MARKmNG
elaine Spent1!r
Edward Crowley DIRECTOR OF
COMMUNlCAn ON S DI RECTOR
W EB MA RKETING Rob Roesler
CathyOlofson
DIRECTOR OF
SEHI DRMANAG ER OF PLANNIN G AN D
WEBTECHHDLOGY KevirlNew man
RmHTlON
•
MANAGIN G
Corrir.eCallahan
DIRECTOR OF ASS ISTANT DIRECTOR ANALYTIC SERVICES DFDPERATIONS AND INTERNATIONAL SPONSORSHIPS GregDaly ONLINE MARKETING
Alex ctemen!e
MANAGER
DIRECTOR OF
William Sinagra
ON LI N E SALES
•
Craig catalano
NEWBUSIH ESS PROManoN
DIRECTOR OF
MANAGER Nicole COSta
-"""'-STRATEGIC
MARK[11NG
ASSISTANT
FULfILt.MENT MANAGER
SENIOR STRATtGIC MAR KEnNG
...--
MANAGER
SENIOR BUS INESS
ANALYST
STRAnGle
MARKETING
GtegSt .~
COMMUNlCAnoNS
..... """"
AS5OaAT<
MANAGER
To thrive in today's marketplace. you require inspiration. l nt ell ect ual stimulation. and fresh perspectives that will allow you to see the world and your business in a new context. Stanford Executive Education programs can help inspire your next breakthrough. Join us.
WORLDWIDE ADVE RTISI NG OFFICES
H EW YORK
75 Rockefe ller Plaza. 15th floor New YOrk, NY 10019 21 2-87 2-9 280 I fax 212·956-
SOutheast
Maria A. Beacom,
Denise Clouse. Business Schools Oaniel Cohen, NewEnglund James H. Patten. Sales Development Director CHI CAGO
10 N. Martingale Road. Suite 400
UPCOMING EXECUTIVE EDUCATION PROGRAMS
Schaumburg.IL 60173
rax
847-466 -1525 I 841-466-1101 James A. Mac;k. centro! US SOles Director DElltOfT
HONG KONG
248 '131-7135
852-231 -52311
lOS ANGElES
INDIA.
323-467-5906
91-11-435Hl811
SAN FRANCISCO
JA PAN
415-986-7162
8HJ3-3S41-4166
AUSTRALIA.
UAE
6 12-92 52 -3-476
971-4-228-7708
FRANCE
UNITEO KING DO M
Manaqlnq Ta lent for Strateqic Advantaqe Influence and Neqotlatlon
streteares Proqram
Leadinq Chanqe and Orqan izational Renewal Customer-focused Innovation
September 12 -17, 2010 October 10 - IS, 2010 October 31 - November 5, 2010 November 7 - 12, 2010
]J"Ol-4643<066 4-4-20-7291'11129 For aU ather inquiries., pease can 212-872-9280. For advertising contact infunnation, p&ez;e visil: ou r website at _.hbradsales.com.
Vi sit www.stdnfordexecutive.com t o learn more.
REPRODUCnON ~
t 2010 HaIvard Ilusiness SChool Publi5hingCOrp(nticln. All rights reserwd.
No part cAthis publJcation may be reproduced or traosmitted in any form or by anymeaos.electronic or mechanical. including photocopy, ~ing. or anyinformation storage and retrieval system. without written permission. ARTICLE REPRINTS
To purchase reprintsof Horvard Business Review a rticles. go to www.hb r.org.
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
Interaction • " Turnmg
•
Doctors mto Leaders HBR article by Thomas H. l ee, April2010
"The problem with health care is people like me;' wrote Thomas Lee, of Harvard Medical School, "who learned medicine when it was more art and less finance:' Costs are rising because of medical progress, and the system is too fragmented and disorganized to absorb the complexity of modern care. "Health care today needs a fundamentally different approachand a new breed of leaders:' Lee makes interesting and cogent points about the state of th e health care system, teamwork, and communication. However, George EngeL (creator of the biopsychosocial model) pointed out a
number of years ago that heating comes fro m pat ient s' being heard and understood.
Teams and systems cannot accomplish t his t ask. Bad doct ors don't listen; good
doctors do. The health care debate would be moot if Dr. Engel's principle had been followed over the past few decades.
Listening to a patient makes much of t he expense associated with medicine
unnecessary. For high-tech procedures.
tech nicians do a great job. But t he art of medicine and t he listening ear have no pa rallel st ructure. We're not heroes, we're doctors; a nd 90% of medici ne is pract iced elsewhere than in t he hightec h world. That is why alternative medical practitioners and nontrad it io nal pract itione rs are so popular. people just want to be heard a nd unde rstood. Joseph A. t roneare, MD, FASAM, Staff Physician, Lancaster General Health I appreciate Lee's ca ndor regarding the role that people "like him" play in t he problem of healt h care today, and Iagree
that medicine is satisfied to practice in a monolithic, independent manner. I also agree t hat t he t ime has come to innovate with new delivery models a nd create "a new breed of leaders." But I was disappointed t hat the article missed t he ma rk by supporting the common belief that "ma nage ment" is "leadership," Over the years, I have queried a large number of physicians as to their definition of leadership. Most of t hem, unfortunately, describe it in management te rms: strategic planning, fi nancial controls, huma n reso urces, ma rketing, a nd so forth. We must , howeve r, acknowledge t hat manage ment is not leade rship. Leadership is about taking people to a place that t hey would not go on t heir own. It is about disrupting the core and upsetti ng the status quo. It is about possessing and utilizing t he proper skills to envision a prefe rred future; having t he ability and comm itment to persistently scan t he horizon for trends that would either negatively or positively impact that future; backcasting by creating strategies t hat lead towa rd and enforce the preferred fut ure; designi ng a nd promoting an environme nt of creativity in order to develop strategies to avoid obstacles to t he preferred future; supporti ng and encouraging the development of disru ptive innovations that foste r, rather tha n impede, the future; leadi ng t he diffusion of those innovations into the general population;
HBR column by Dan Ariely, April 2010
Why Businesses Don't Experiment
~ ~
"Int uit ion is a remarkably bad th ing to rely on," Ariely argued . "Only an experimen t gives you th e evidence you need: ' But companies cont inue to pay overly confi dent consultant s big money t o s upply answers rat her t han gat he r evidence in experiments t o hel p them ma ke their own decisions.
::Cirj
18
Harvard Business Review June 2.010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
I would agree t hat experimentation doesn't get q uite t he attention it deserves in t he postmode rn orga nizational setting. However,l a m of t he opinion t hat Ariely did not give t he credit d ue to t he not-sa-scientific "gut,' He paraphrases what Intuit's founde r, Scott Cook, tells his staff; "whatever happe ns, you' re doing right beca use you've created evidence, which is bette r t ha n anyone's intuition." I say, not so fast when it co mes to discounting the value
HBR.ORG
~
Interact with Us
- - - - - - " MAil : 60 Ha rvardW<.rt. Boston. MA 0'2163 E-MAil:
[email protected] FACEBOOK: facebook.com/ HBR
COo'espoOdence may be edited for
space and style.
You get bad breaks from good shots; you get good breaks from bad shotsbut you have to play the ball where it lies. - BOBBYJONES
integrating change-t heory strategies that move people forward in a unified manner; and mentoring ma nagers and followers along the way to keep them focused on the ends. In the late 1970S and ea rly 19Bos physicians abdicated their responsibility to protect the sacred physician-patie nt relationship. a nd as t he res ult of a lac k of true leade rship from within. the vac uum was fi tted by attorneys, insurance executives . politicians, and ot hers who have "managed " med icine into its present convoluted and deficient condition . Instead of leading med icine into the future. physicians became passive followers who were willing to allow others to determine how they would deliver care to thei r patients. Where within t he present medical ed ucation continuu m do we trai n physicians in the finer points of leade rsh ip studies: strategic foresight . thinking. a nd design; visionee ring; change; global integration; creativity; innovation; and huma n capital developments Ifwe want to c ha nge medicine for the bette r, we need to go beyond management and truly commit to training strategic Leaders from within. Barry A. Oouble stein, MD, Chairman, The Institute fO!' Leadership in Med icine
II1IIII1II
We help' y.ou out ofthe rougn. These days, even the most succes sf ul organizations are facing new and unexpected challenges. Traditional approaches to management that may have worked in a booming economy are no longer sufficient to meet the demands of a changing marketplace. At MIT Sloan. we prepare leaders to address tcday's complexities and seize new opportunities. Participants In our executive education programs gain t he latest insights. strategies. and too ls needed to navigate through uncertain times and get back on the right course.
Upcoming programs include: Ju1 14-15
Managing Complex Product Development Projects
Ju1 21-22
Transforming Your Leadership Strategy
Ju126-27
Developing a Leading Edge Operations Strategy
Ju126-27
Strategic Marketing for the Technical Executive
JuI28-29
Supply Chain Strategy and Management
JuI28-29
Fundamentals of Finance for the Technical Executive
Sep 12-17 Driving Strategic Innovation: Achieving High Performance Throughout the Value Chain
of "a nyone's" intuition. It truly matters whose int uition you're talking a bout. Although clea rly not a mat ch for the methodological rigors involved in experimentation, some individuals possess int uition that is not only highly sought after and regarded as priceless. but has been acutely developed over ma ny years. I suggest that Ariely ad d to his arse nal of valuable teach ings
Sep13-14 Developing and Managing a Successful Technology and Prodoct Strategy
Sep 15 - 16 Understanding and Solving Complex Business Problems
MITSloan 1111111111 Executive Education
CONTINUED"'" NExT !lOGE
http:/ /mitsloan.mit.edu/hbr Phone: +1.617.253.7166 I Email:
[email protected] u www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
HBR.ORG
Interaction with endless betas. We don't nee d to worry a bout mod eLnumbe rs a nd versions. No company has exe mpLified "w hat you see is what you get" better t han Apple. Posted by Vijay Kumar, Vice President of Finance, Southwest Kidney Institute
EnteriPad
HBR blogs, April 2010
HBR .org covered the laun ch of Apple's much-hyped iPad from the st rategic, innovative. and marketing perspectives, and our online community buzzed with commenta ry a nd complaint s. "Apple's Strategic lsaradox" by Umair Haque. "The iPad is a revolution waiting to happen. But the revolution's biggest roadblock is Apple itself." Ifeveryone had a n iPad and then so meone ca me out with the iphone, it would be regarded a s a n "ipad killer" - 98% of the same funct ionality but porta ble a nd a phone, too. So when t he chronology is reversed. why does iPad win big? Who is th e core customer? And why? Posted by Rodrigo Plantagenet Apple has always bee n fundamentally product-Led; t hat's how it ge nerates rea L value . It succeeds in a service-driven world beca use services do n't produce q uite th e same tangible va lue t hat fantastic products d o- a nd Apple p rodu ce s fantastic products better t han a nyone else . Posted by Aditya Anup kumar, Partner-Strategic Planning and Rediffusion, Young & Rubicam
Somehow consultants have concluded that the U.S. would be better off com moditizing CONTI'lUEO fRO'"
~EVIOUS
PAGE
so me focus o n t he a pplication of testing and on honing t he skill of learning how to liste n to your gut. A combination of expe riment and intuitio n may p rove to be more valuable t ha n e xpected. Stuart M. Jackson, CEO, Jackson & Associates
hardware an d focusing on services. But as t he hardware moves offshore, so does the competitive advantage, a nd eve ntually services will be commoditized . It's easy to discount a service unt il it's essentially free ; then it's nearly impossible to raise t he p rice. ccogte d id t his with office software , although it charges b usine sses for ac cess to its office suite. Face boo k is struggling with a business mod eLthat has no subscript ion revenue, a nd it's seeing a revolt from subscribers who refuse to pay for a social netwo rking se rvice . Posted by Ste van Eidson, President, Eizon "Apple's iPad: What Every Business Can Learn" by Peter Merholz. ''Apple is surprisingly cavalier about supplanting an existing cash cow with a next-generation product that responds to how the market is moving.~ Most compa nies are just not co nfident , disciplined, or financia lly stable enough to ta ke t he kinds of risks AppLe ca n and does. Better to innovate yourselves into a new market than to miss one while a nim ble r competitor discovers the next PC. Posted by And rew McFarland, Vice President,
ca.mc. What also distinguishes Apple from other tech nology co mpa nies is strict quality co nt rol. It does n't waste its t ime or ours 20
Harva rd Business Review June 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
"Waiting for the jPad's Twist" by Scott Anthony, "If there isn't any twist, I expect the iPad to.. .[ol/ short of the transformational impact of the iPod and iPhone platforms." It's not the lsad, it's t he category t hat will fail s hould the killer a pp not show up. Where t he KindLe a nd the Nook took the one-trick-pony approac h, Apple has put aLL the ca pa bilit ies in t he iPad that developers an d users now have to fi gure out how to put into action. Alt hough the Kind le solved a problem, it did so without any open expansion ca pabilities. Posted byJohn McElhenney, Digital Produ cer, ClarusAge ncy "Where Most New Product Launches (But Not AppLe's) Go wrong" by JuLia Kirby, "Apple's success isn't a ll a story of building a better mousetrap. It's also about being really good at making the world beat a path to your door." Acom pa ny that is plan ning a product launch sho uld as k not only "How can we ca pture customers' attentio n and whet thei r appetites so as to maximize product sales?" but aLso " How can we genuinely improve things for t he customer t hrough a better-pla nned launc h?" The answer to the first question is to generate mystiq ue. The a nswer to t he second is to reach as man y customers as poss ible at launch an d ensure sufficient suppLy so that t he re are no stockouts and customers ca n get the prod uct without hardship. Focusing exclusively on the first is Li kely to resu lt in a manipulative lau nch rat he r t han one that ge nuinely meets custome rs' nee ds. Apple's magic perhaps lies in its impeccable focus on both . Posted byV.P. Kochikar. Associate Vice President, Infosys recbnotogres
....
To fJ\d oot wtr; VMenne Tam O!I a fan visit WIIo'W, ~ . CXJm ElAt«3I
•
(AN ANSWER SHOULD BE ALONG ANY TIME NOW.) If t here were ever a ti me to take the helm, it's now. Our Leadership programs hone the kind of independent thin king a nimble leader requ ires, prepari ng you wit h the confidence and self -awareness it takes to lead in today's marketplace.
Come to Wharton and develop a strategic, persuasive answer of your own. Select any of our Leadership Programs at ExecEd.Wharton.UPenn.edu. Talk to us at
[email protected]. Or let us tailor a custom program for your organi zation .
Ares1y Institute of becutlve Educati on
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
CLOUD COMPUTING 24
MANAGING PEOPLE 26
DEFEND YOUR RESEARCH 32
DAN ARIELY 38
A revolutionary IT tool, or a bunch of hype?
Why your employees aren't being frank with you
The more customers want it, the less they'Ulike it.
How to get CEOs to care about more than stock price
New Thinking, Research in Progress hbr.org
FIRST
Why Dinosaurs will Keep Ruling the Auto Industry
complexity. Toyota's highly publicized recalls earlier this year were not outliers but, rather, emblematic ofan industry challenge that will only intensify as vehicles integrate ever-more-elaborate hardware, software, Get ready for the complexity revolution. byJohn Paul safety equipment, and creature comforts. Meeting both regulatory and consumer MacDuffie and Takahiro Fujimoto deman ds involves managing inte rdepen de ncies among subsystems. (This is, in a he automobile is a paradox. When will win: the rapidl y increasing complex- way, like operating within the auto world ity of vehicle design in advanced-economy itself, wh ich Peter Drucker famously called you ge t down to basics, it's t he same as it was a hundred years ago: markets. The typical car contains about "an industry of industries.") But companies a metal box on four wheels connected by 2,000 funct ional components, 30,000 parts, and their designers can't do that using current best practices. a suspension and powered by an internal and 10 million lines of software code. combustio n engine, which runs on a petroWhy all the intricacy? Automobiles are che mical fuel. Yet the Tin Lizzie and the heavy, fast-moving objects operating in New solutions Beget Prius are worlds apart in every other way. public space. Making them safe and reduc- New Problems Many companies have long be lieved ing their environmen tal impact are impor- Many product engineers like the simplicity they could emerge as industry leaders by tant concerns mand ated by regulation . At and fl exibility of a modular approach. But placing the right bets on markets to en ter, the same time, their high cost raises con- that works best for products such as con car types to make, and technologies to pur- sumer expectat ions for styling, power, sumer electronics, which are small and un sue. But now there's a trend that eclipses handling, reliability, and am en ities. Satis- obtrusive, operated mostly in private space, those factors in determining which players fyingboth these masters results in massive and relatively cheap, with few negative
T
June 2 010 Harvard Business Review 2 3 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
IDEA W ATCH
What We're Watching in...
cloud Computin Cloud compu t ing is eit her a revolut ionary IT management t ool or a nebulous puff of marketing hype, dependi ng on whom you ask. For now, we're thinking it's puffery- but int riguing developm ents are under way.
A Cloudy Concept costs and reduce energy consu mption. But it t urns out t hat much of the appeat is based on a murky understanding of t he concept. According to research by Gart ner group vice president Mar k McDonald, the percentage of CIOs interested in cloud computing has grown consider-
Rat her than house your own IT servers or rent the maximum processing and storage capacity you'LL ever need, why not pay only for what you use, when you use it? That's the basic idea behind cloud computing-and it's an alluring possibility for many reasons. not least the des ire to contain
abLy, from 5% in 2009 to 37"10 earLier this year. And the bigger the company, the more likely management is to say tha t cloud computing is a top-five IT priority. But three out of fou r respondents who profess interest in cloud computing report littLe to none in three of the
CONTINUED FROM PAGE 23
The typical car contains about 2,000 components, 30,000 parts, and 10 million lines of software code. consequences of ma lfunc tion other than ann oying owners. By contrast, auto design requires intensive coordinat ion to keep track of all its various aspects, and its engineering culture prefers unique (non modular) solutions. Compared with car design's advanced calculus of millions of simultaneous complex equations, the iPad's design is basic arithmetic. Automa kers' efforts to deal with desig n complexity so far have hinged on building capabilities for front-loaded problem solving. They've been aided by d igital design tools and simulations for testing how any of those 2,00 0 compon ents per form u nder stress and for evaluating interactions among them. In addition, companies have been leaning on su ppliers to take on important design and testing work; they 're relying on their partners' deep knowledge about the components they build. All t his h as help ed u ntangle th ings somewhat. Manu facturers have reduced the comp lexity of how t hey design and make cars but no t of the cars themselves (at leas t in develop ed mar kets). The shift to digital design and testing tools has facilitated shor ter product life cycles, bu t this leaves less time up front for problem solv ing and funct ional test ing. Suppliers' increased involvement takes aspects of design out ofthe au tomaker's direct con trol, yet the manufacturer remains accountable 24
wh en safety or ot her issues arise. Witness the steadily growing number of recalls in developed cou ntries. Recalls reflect failures to meet ever-tougher regulatory requ irements, as well as greate r consu me r (and produ cer) sensitivity to de fects. They will continue to increase right along with complexity-not necessarily bad news if that improves quality and safety, but surely evidence ofthe burdens of complexity. No case illustrates the cha llenge ofintegrating many parts, systems, and processes bett er than the recall of Toyota's Prius for a problem caused by interactions among the three eleme nts of its braking sys tem. As part of an effort to improve fuel efficiency, the softwa re that controlled this syste m was tu ned to d raw mo re heavily on the BACK TO THE MANUFACTURER
With more computers controlling functions like braking, annual vehicle recalls related to electrical syste ms have quadrupled in the u.s . since th e ' 970S.
II
regenerative b rakes. The pro blem occu rs when the car hits rough pavement or something slippery. The software automatically switches to anttlock braking (ABS), which gives t he se nsation of a sudden drop in braking power. If the driver quickly hits the pedal, the hyd raulic brakes imm ediat ely kick in; if n ot, th e ABS " takeover" interrupts th e driver's antici pated deceleration, creating a feeling ofspeed increase but not actual accele ration. The real safety risk is zero (the brakes continue to wor k and will stop the car if pressed more fully), but the unease felt by drivers was enough to prompt the recall. Not all automotive recalls have such a complex genesis. Toyota's accele rato r pedal recall, which affected a vast nu mber of vehicles, came down to design flaws in a single, relatively simp le part used on man y models and so urce d from a non Japanese supplier in order to diversify the supply chain and reduce costs. Yet thi s is consistent with the overall product's trend toward higher complexity: Defects appear in u npredictable places, whether in simple hardware parts like the accelerator pedal or in complex software control systems.
Incumbents Have an Edge
.. 5DUR<:E5 BLOOMBERG, NHTSA
Harva rd Business Review June 201 0 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
If complexity tripp ed up Toyota, how will the growing nu mber of challengers fare? Their odds of success are even lower than
HBR.ORG
16% SERVER VIRTUAUZATION
OF CIOS REPORT INTEREST IN CLOUD COMPlITING•••
... BUT FEW CIOS SAY THEY'RE INTERESTEDIN lll E CLOUD A N D ITS KEY TECH NOLOGIES:
g%
SERVICE·ORIE NTED ARCHITECTURE
8% SOFTWARE AS A SERVICE
incu mbents'. Tata's Nano has a com paratively simple design tailored to developingeconomy consumers. It meets India's somewhat relaxed regulatory standards, but it would need to be substantially redesigned to be sold in the U.S. or Europe. Chinese autos will need tremendous improvements in drivability, ride smoothness, cabin comfort and quiet, and body "fit and finish" to fulfill the high quality expectations in developed countries. Electric car start-ups must gain the design and testing capabilities to satisfy regulations and to provide the flawless integration of veh icle functions that drivers expect. Being masters of the new drive-train technology won't be enough. Which com panies are best equi pped to design the cars of the future? Those that have amass ed the systemic knowledge to coordinate all the work and the many partners involved. Few d eveloping-cou nt ry auto makers an d green vehicle start-u ps possess that yet. This doesn't limit the field to incumbents, nor does it guarante e that they will be around in 20 to 30 years. But it does mean that new rivals will have to slog through the long, slow process of catching up with the veterans. Othe rwise, no newcomer can expect anything more tha n niche status in th is industry. What 's more, com panies will have to battle the demon s o f co m plexity for an ete rni ty-or at least as long as consumers demand that cars keep them safe, run relatively clean, perform well, an d are attractive and comfortable. The long-term lesson of Toyota's recalls is that automakers will have to bu ild a m uch better institutional capability for reading faint signals amid
key te chnologies it entails: server virtualization, service-oriented architecture, and software as a service. Further, near ly half t he respondents equate cloud computing with virtuaLization alone, which shows that many executives have an incomplete view of it.
Cloud computing has rapidly risen to what McDonald calls "t he pea k of inflated expectations." And where is it headed next? The "trough of disillusionment," he says. That's because few peo ple can even seem to agree on what cloud computing is, never mind how on earth it should work.
The National Institute of Standa rds and Technology (N IST) IT laboratory's definition, version 15, is more t han 760 words long and includes fi ve characteristics, three service models, four deployment models, and a disclaimer saying, in essence, t hat the defi nition will change again soon.
MORE COMPLEX THAN A FIGHTER JET
Safety regulat ions and consumer demand for perform ance and convenience have led t o an exponent ial spike in cars' software complexity.
10('.., '
..I
LUXURYAUTO AVERAGE
NAVIGAnON SYSTEM IN 2009
ro~;o::,"'< ' ClASs M ERCEDES· BENZ
::::::::::~ LIN ES OF SOFTWARE
6••'Sli
BOEING 787 OREAMUNER
u.s. AIR FORCE F·3S
CODE IN FORO VEHICLES (MIL LIONS) 204M
JOI NT STRIKE FIGHTER
••
l.7 "
us. A IR FORCE F-22RAPTORJET
the "noise" of cons umer experience da ta. As overall vehicle reliability increases, the failures that come will be harde r to forecast and much tougher to trace to root causes, since diagnoses will be made on the basis of rare occu rrences. Given the wide variation in govern ment regulation and consumer demand around the world, automakers targeting advanced markets must do two baste things to survive. First, they'll have to reduce complexity by striving for modularity in whatever limited ways they can and decreasing product line ups, model varieties, and option variants. Second, they must improve their handling of the comp lexity that remains. Fur ther more, a global automaker will want to pursue simple designs for developing markets an d complex ones for the developed wo rld. The trick is to avoid homogeneous designs overengineered for the former and underengineered for the latte r.
SOURC EI IEE, : A<JTOHOTIV' P'SIGNUN'
Consensus on one new domina nt design (say, all-electric vehicles) would mean a simpler world for automakers, yet this is far offat best, and it might never happen given consumer prefe re nces for variety. Most likely, fi rms will need to con tinue producing both simpl e and complex products. Many strategists think that new en tran ts are ready to reinvent the industry. They see the automakers that dominated the twentieth century as dinosaurs: large, slow, and facing extinction. But this is one indust ry in which the dinosaurs-at least those that can successfully wage war on complexityare positioned to beat new challengers for at least the next few decades. " HBR Re p ri nt FlOO6A
John Paul MaeDuffie is a codirector of MIT's International Motor Vehicle Program and an associate professor at the Wharton School. Takahiro Fujimoto is a professor at the University of Tokyo and the executiv e director of its Manufact uring Management Research Center. June 2010 Harvard Business Review 25
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
HBR.ORG
IDEA W ATCH
-
Is the Cloud Greener?
Despite aLL the confusion about cloud computing, the IT laboratory at NIST lays out some ligures that make a compelling environmental case for it . According to one NIST presentation, the number of se rvers in tradit ional data centers in the U.S. doub led from :2 0 01 to :2 0 0 6 . Power consumption per server
MANAGING PEOPLE by
quadrupled in the same time period, even though serve rs typically operate at only 15% of capacity. Yet t hose data centers, according to EPAfi gures cited by NIST, consume 1.5% of all electricity generated in the United States (compared with 0 .6% worldwide in :20 0 0) . Globally, IT produces 2% of C0 2 emissions.
Businesses that go with cloud computing could improve sustainability in two ways. First, companies maximize servers by sharing them, so fewer machines are chugging away. Second, on-demand usage means that firms needn't consume way above their needs during sLow times in order to be ready for busy times.
James R. Detert, Ethan R. Burris , and David A. Harrison
Debunking Four Myths About Employee Silence fyo u're like a lotofmanagers, you pride yourselfon your ope n door and all the other waysyou signal to employees that you welcome their input. And you probably believe that you're actually hearing what's on most people's minds- after all, workers speak up in meetings, chat wit h you in the hall, and copy you on e-mails. Well, you're not hearing as mu ch as you think or as much as you need to. In the latest phaseofour decade's wort h of research on organizational silence, we piggybacked six questions onto the ann ual Corne ll National Social Survey to explore how and when employees hold back. As you'd expect, they dam u p when they're afraid that speaking could get them into t rouble. But surprisingly, the most common reason forwithholding input isa sense of futility rather than fear of ret ributio n. In part because employees do sometimes speak up, bosses are often unaware of t heir workers' self-censorshi p. They imagine they're hearing what's important when in fact they're being met with silence th ey're si mply unaware of. Think of the times you've kept your own mouth shut. There have p roba bly been n umerous instances, even if you're generally candid ("I speak up a lot, but not about that issue, or in that setting, or to that manager"). The combination oftight-lipped employees and oblivious bosses buries constructive criticism, not to mention the unvarnished truth.
I
Most important, it prevents good ideas from bubbling up through the organization. Data from the 439 respondents who work full time and aren 't self-employed allow us to debunk four common myths managers believe abou t the flow of ideas and information from the rank and file.
,..,.............. 1001 ,. . . ,...
MYTH 1 Women and nonprofessional employees wit hhoLd more information than men and .... profess ional staffers because they are more conce rned about consequences or more likely to see s peaking up as futile. There are no statistically significa nt d ifferences between workers of different genders, education levels, or income levels in the likelihood of holding back because of fear or assumptions offutility.
'"
I
.
,
MYTH2 1f my employees are talking openLy t o me, t hey're not holding back. Fully 42% of res pondents report periodically speaking up but also withholding in for mation when t hey feel they have no thing to gai n -or something to loseby sha ring what's on their minds.
26 Harvard Business Review June 20 10 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
Most servers in traditional data centers operate at only 15% of capacity-yet those data centers consume 1.5% of all electricity generated in the United States.
MYTH 3 If employees are n't speaking up, it's because they don't feel safe doing so, despite all my efforts, More than asse say they withhold feedbac k on routine problems and opportunities for improvement to avoid was ting their ti me, not because they fear consequences. MYTH 4 The only issues employees are sca red to raise involve serious allegat ions about illegal or unethical activit ies. About 20% say a fear of consequences has led them to wit hhold suggestions for addressing ordinary problems and maki ng improvements. Such silence on day-to-day issues keeps managers fro m gett ing the information they need to prevent bigger problems- performance and otherwisedown the road. A blog series at blogs.hbr.org/research this month will look at each of these four myt hs in greater detail, using cases an d analysis to explore ways of unleashing good ideas. '::' HBR Repr int Fl006B
J am" A. Detert is an assistant professor of management at Cornell's Johnson School. Eth an R. Burris is an assistant professo r of management at the University of Texas at Austin's MCCombs School of Business. David A. Harri son is the Smeal Professor at Penn State's Smeal College of Business.
barcap.com
I
Because success isn't a destination - it's a journey. Barclays Capital
IS
the partner that
travels with you from point A to point B and beyond. We help drive your success with a full spectrum of best-in-class investment banking products and services. Our teams deliver opportunities through global financing and strategic advisory, comprehensive risk management. groundbreaking analyttcs and award-winning research. All built around you, and designed to take you as far as you want to go.
Earn Success Every Day
Issued by Ba" lays Bank PLC. aulhorized and regulated by Ihe Financial Services Authority and a member of the London Stock Exchange. Barclays Capital is the investment banking division of Barclays Bank PLC. which underlakes US secunl ies bus iness in the name of ils wholly-owned subsidIary Barclays Cap ital Inc. an SIPC and FINRA member. (l2010 Barclays Bank PLC. All righis 'eserved. Barclays Cap ital is" trademark 01 Barclays Bank PLC. www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
HBR.ORG
IDEA W ATCH
-
Hidden Fees in the Cloud?
So the energy benefits are real, but what about costs? Gett ing rid of all those inhouse servers is supposed to save scads of money. Then again, maybe not. Amy speUmann of Optimal Innovations, Richard Gimarc of Hyperformix, and Mark Preston of RS Performance conceived of a hypotheticat retail website
faced with a choice between managing servers in house and signing up for Amazon's cloud-computing service. They projected costs and energy consumption two years out for each option. The verdict: Acloud-based website is less expensive than in-house servers at fi rst but may cost more over time, even after you account
VENTURE CAPITAL/PRIVATE EQUITY
for energy savings. That's because data transfer charges increase as cloud service grows and requires more processing power. Though on a much larger scale, t his seems a Lot like cell phone service, which is reasonably priced until you start incurring all those charges for extra minutes and texting.
A CLOUD· BASED WEBSITE STARTS OFF CHEAPER THAN IN· HOUSE SERVERS BUT QUICKLY BECOMES MORE EXPENSIVE AS DATA-TRANSfER CHARGES ARE PILED ON.
1 2 MONTHS
by David Teten and Chris Farmer
Time for Investors to Get Social enture capital and private equity investors are always hu nting for "tells" -signs that com panies are good prospects . Trad itionally, they've believed that pro prie ta ry knowledge about th ose tells is essential to success. Thei r logic: The more widely disseminated the information, the lower the value for inve tors- because a greater number of bidder will be in play, jacking up prices. So, you would think that open, public forums like social media would be bad tools for investors searching for deals. However, our first-ever study of deal-origination best practices at more than 150 VCand PE firms, along with other research, shows that some of t he top-performing investors increasingly use such technologies to discuss the very information they once held close to the vest. How can that be? The key is deal flow, a critical factor in the highly competitive invest ing realm. An investor in private companies must review 80 opportun ities, on ave rage. to close one deal. In order to make several deals, investors need to examine hundreds of prospects. Sharing details about thei r investment strategy gives them access to opportunities that they otherwise would have missed . Our research indicates that they more than make up for whatever compe titive edge they lose by giving out siders a peek at what they're up to. As a case st udy. we looked at investors in priva te late -stage tech nology companies. Some are agg ressively reaching be-
V
WHY IT PAYS TO SHOW SOME OF YOUR CARDS
OPPORTUNITIES
REVIEW ED
You need to see a lot of deals to
close one.
I
DUEDILI GENCE NVEsTMENT
RE VIEWS
HADE SOURCES _ 'HAll' OATA. E. AlUESERIIE. VW'N CIfUNG. NEHA KuHAR
yond the traditional tech centers of Silicon Valley, New York, and Boston to improve performance. A recent paper by Henry Chen. An na xovner, and HBS professors Paul compere and Josh Lerner shows that although VC funds located in these three centers outperform others, that's primarily beca use they do well with deals in pertpherallocattons - whtch they discove red by casting a wide, public net. We've found that late-stage tech investors with geographically diverse portfolios are consistently among the best performers
28 Harvard Business Review June 20 10 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
and have continued to attract large limited partner commitments, even d uring the challenging period since 2007. Almost all such players have been able to raise at least as much cash as they could previously. By contrast, the funds with traditional origination programs, focused on local networks, have had difficu lty; most haven't raised new capital since late 2005. For all the funds out the re with prcacive origination program s. the most effeclve tactics and too ls include social media, gated web communities. expe rt net works, entrepreneurs or execu tives in residence , travel, trad itio naL face-to-face networks. and dedicated cold-callin g teams. Some 10% to 15% of the 1,00 0 or so active U.S. venture capitalists are blogging and tweeting, according to Flybridge Capital Part ners. Among private equity investors, the Riverside Company is noteworthy for its use of a za-person team of sen ior deal originators to help produ ce to p-qu artile res ults for eight of its last nine funds . Because of how essentia l new relationships a re in investing, firms have been forced to be much mo re transparen t than those in almost any othe r industry. The venture cap ital and private equity kimono is open - quite possibly for good.. " HBR Reprint fl OOGC David Teten is the CEO or rete n Advisors, an Investment bam specializing in sourcing
new investme nts. Chris Farm e r is a manag ing partner at Ignition Search Partners, a hybrid venture search firm. Fo r more research res ults, go to www.teten.com jde als .
Here to help you take the next step forward. As the global economy recovers, new opportunities are appearing in both
established and emerging markets. For many companies. this is the time
tha t matters most. But the lesson of the recent past is clea r - it's also the time to balance ambition with prudence. Never before has understand ing your risks and prepar ing for them sensibly been more important. That's why
we are introducing a range of game-chang ing initiatives, including new insurance offerings for: Manufacturing, Healthcare, Technology, Real Estate,
Financia l Enterprise, Energy, and Management and Professional Liability. With professionals and capabilities in more than 170 countries, and insurance solutions backed by a strong, stable financial position ' . we are here to help you manage your risks and take advantage of the future with confidence.
Download our free w hitepa pe r a nd g uide to choosin g th e right insuranc e
ZURICH
•
ca rrier for yo ur bu siness at www. zurichna.com/chooset heright
Here to help your world .
Because change happenz
• Zu,,,,h f'.... n{~ 1 $eM<e' G'oop. In the Unotod Slate' . ,,,,",,' ago, a'o undo rwfl1ton bv membe' ''''''l'"n"" of Zu'ich in North Ame'ica. ,nelud'ng Zuri< h Ame' ",an In",'anee Company. Co"aon ,,",,,'a9'" not a.a ll_ ,n a ll , tal"'. Some "",.,a9'" may bo wr ilton "" a non·adm,tted l hfOU9h licensed ""pi", 10"", brd. " . In l h. UMed Stat.... n,k on9,"""n"'l """''''... a", provided bv Zu,,,, h $eM<'" Corp"'alion. • For ,nformaboo.>bout the ,abng; of Zurich A.,...'ican In'u'an,. Company. a,ec"" lh. ,a tong; ""boo oIl """"'.l"'och.....com. For more ,omplel. f,....,...,,;.. informatoon aboul1tle Zu'OCh Finane..1 $ervi<:e< Group an
ba,,,
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
•
IDEA WATCH
-
HBR.ORG
Data in 3-D
Compa nies th at move to a cloud computing model may encounter uni ntended positive consequences ifusers take to the CLoud Mouse. This peripheral device- stitt in development-Looks like an egg, works something like a joystick, and aUows you to navigate the data generated by the massive numbe r of users in t he cloud through a dynamic three -dimensional interface (think Th e Matrix minus t he martial arts).
The Cloud Mouse is a project of Microsoft researcher Richard Harpe r and his collaborato rs at Microsoft Resea rch Asia . On th e one hand, t his see ms ki nd of silly- isn't everythi ng going the way of the touch screen anyhow? But on the ot her, imagine a new class of skilled technicians who could move through and whip around 3-D computing data with the ease of an ult rasound s pecialist or a wn player.
MICROSOFT RESEARCH'S CLOUD MOUSE PROTOTYPE
GENDER by Sylvia Ann Hewlett , Laura Sherbin, and Diana Forster
Off-Ramps and On-Ramps Revisited WOMEN \~E WORKFORCE
...and become selfemployed
Women who off-ramp (average time 2.7 years) ow much has the recession shaped women's choice to take more circu itous career pat hs t han men? Not a lot, it tu rns out. Our sur veys from 2004 and 2009 yield surprisingly similar results. More than five years ago, in a ro bust economy, 37% of highly qua lified women told us they were "o ff-ramping"- t hat is, voluntarily leaving the ir jobs for extended time periods. Nearly three-quarte rs were on no nlinear career trajectories, to the detriment oft heir earning potentialand career advancemen t. (See "Off-Ramps and OnRamps: Keeping Talented Women on the Rood to Success;' HBR March 2005.)
H
Off-rampe rs who don't return Last fall, us ing the 2004 qu estionnaire and a co mparable sample of women, we discovered that off-ra m ps and on-ramps are here to stay, though a few things have changed. For ins tance, the pe rcen tage of off-rampers has dropped six points. Howeve r, women who do off-ramp are staying out ofwork longer now, by abou t haifa yea r. Of course, the unemployment rate-which has doubled over the past five years- may ha ve some bearing on that. Women wit h jobs may be more relucta nt to leave, and those wit ho ut are finding it hard to return to work (20% ofwomen currently trying to on- ramp say they're having difficulty because of the economy).
30 Harvard Business Review June 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
Perhaps the most striking change from 20 04 to 2009 is a 28% increase in professional women with nonworking husbands. Are social mores abou t breadwinners changing? Probably not. l.l.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics data ind icate that nonwo rking people can't find jobs. The ave rage nu mber o f weeks u n employed jumped fro m 19 to 27 between surveys; the num be r of ind ividuals u nemployed for more than 27 weeks ballooned from 1.7 million to 5.4 million; and the number of"discour aged" people who've stopped looking for jobs recently exceeded 1 million for the fi rst lime in a decade. Sowomen's earnings ha ve become more impo rta nt to fa mily budgets. The small dip in women who are off-ramping most likely reflects, at least in part, the fact that they can't afford to take time away. Eve n so, the data sets are unca nn ily a ligned overall. A six-point drop in offtampers see ms small given the severity of the economic crisis and th e surge in househo lds with nonworking men . It suggests th at the nonlinear path is no t a luxur y for boom ti m es but t he way many women want to structure their careers regardless HBRReprint F1006D of the economy. 0 Sylvia Ann Hewlett directs the gender and policy program at Columbia University's School of International and Public Affairs. She is the president ofthe Center for Work-life f'olicy and chairs the Hidden Brain Drain taskforce . lau ra Sherbin isthe director of research and Diana Forster isan assistant vice president at the Center for Work-life Policy,
11II Chevron
chevron.com
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
Human Energy-
IDEA W ATCH
Defend Your Research HBR puts some surprising findings to the test
The More People Want Something, the Less The 'll Like It The finding: Denying peo ple access to a prod uct will make th em desire it more a nd work hard er to get it-but will also make t he m less likely to keep it. The study: Uzma Khan a nd he r colleagues Ab Litt a nd s aba Shiv awa rded a gift card t o a n electro nics store to people who completed a word puzzle, Half t he recipients earned th e prize on their fi rst t ry; half had tried to win it before but failed. Before receiving a ca rd, all we re asked how much they'd pay to obtain it. People who'd previo usly been denied the prize were willi ng to pay much more but th en we re more likely to trade their ca rd away when offe red th e chance to exchange it for a diffe rent card. The challenge: 15 the assum pt ion that we wa nt what we like and we like what we want flawed? Wh en a product is hard to obtain, do we lust afte r it more but like it less once we get it? Professor Khan, defend your research. Khan: This jllting effect is big. People who initially failed to win a gift card said they'd pay 43% more to get one than people who hadn't, but only 22% of the initially "jilted" group decided to keep the card instead of trading it. In the group that wasn't previously de nied access, 57%of the people nearly th ree times as many-kept the card. And in a follow-up experiment, the effect transferred to the company's ot he r products. We told halfthe subjects that they could win Guess sunglasses, conti ngent on supplies. They were later told we had ru n out ofglasses. In a product evaluation, those people then rated Guess watches lower and Calvin Klein watches higher than the other halfof the subjects, who hadn't expected to win glasses and didn't
experience the stock-out. Oddly,when we aske d the people who'd been denied the glasses which watch they'd like to rece ive, they chose the Guess watches more often than the Calvin Klei n ones. HBR: They bad -mouthed a product because it was th e same brand as t he glasses th ey didn't get , but th en they wanted it more? That does n't make se nse. It doesn't ma ke sense if you assume that people want and like the same things. That's why we did the study-to challenge this deep-seate d assumption that these two emotions are inextricably linked. They're not. Desire and liking are independent from each other and also inte ract in strange ways . The more we want
32 Harvard Business Review June 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
something, the less we'll actually like it. It's a lusting/loathing thing. Like when a big sports event turns out to be just anot her ga me an d leaves you feeling unsatisfied? Abig sports event is about hype. In our case the desire is increased not through hype but through being denied access. It's more like not getting into an exclusive nightclub . Whe n people can't get access, it becomes especially attractive. They'll work hard to get past the velvet rope. But once they're in, they often say, "This is it?" Maybe t hese effects are short-lived, a nd if I have to wait a few months for a hot video ga me, well, Iget over it after a day? I think it's the op posite. Weactually found it hard to create strong desire in a short experiment. I'd suspect that the longer you desire something and are denied it, the stronger the effect will be. Think about products like the iPad, which you may wait months for and then still face an empty shelfin the store. But the longerterm effect needs to be studied. Whe n the iPad Launched, it wasn't painLess to get your hands on one yet I don't see people revolting against AppLe. But who have we heard from? Reviews are often from people who have n't been jilted. If anything, they make the jilting worse, with the reviewer telling those
,,,
,
f
• •
HBR .ORG
HARVARD BUS I N E S S SCHOOL EXE C UT I VE E D U C AT I O N
who can't ge t the product, "I have it a nd
you don't and it's great."On the other hand, App le may be an outl ier. The effect m ay not be as bad with products that are exceptionally good or hard to replace.Sunglasses a nd video games can be replaced with
other brands that perform about the same. With iPads, substitu tion may not be as easy. Marketers use scarcity as a way t o create b uzz a nd d emand. Is t hat a bad idea? Our results make it clear that marketers
should be cautious about using a strategicshortage to generate demand. It will increase demand right now but can have other costs. It will have implications for other products in your brand, repeat purchases, and loyalty. It comes down to what the goal ofthe company is. Ifit's to make quarterly numbers, denyingaccess may be a useful tool. It could be that marketers know what they're doing and want those short-term gains. But most companies, I think, would rather have a healthy longterm strategy. But what if a compa ny has a real s hortage? What can it do to mitigate the fallout?
Itprobably should focus a little more on customer satisfaction. Itshould increase customer serviceand make public announcements about the situation. This isn't as simple as it sounds. It's easy to get carried awaywhen your product's in high
demand. You feel pretty good and stop worryingabout satisfaction. You assume demand means people must really like you. In fact. they may want you. but that doesn't mean they like you. Where, in a physiological se nse , does t his lust/ loat hing thi ng come fro m?
We've started to look at that. Ab Litt, my research partner, is examining the neurological aspects. Are desire and satisfaction governed differently in the brain? We found, for example. an odd correlation:The lusting/loathing effects were more intense with people who were less emotional, as measured on standard scales. "Emotional" people did not show the effect as strongly. Where eLse are you t a king the researc h?
We're looking at what happens with substitute purchases after stock-cuts. For example. when people can't get the model of camera they want, are they more likely to trade up and buy a camera from the same brand, or to go for an equal-value substitute? It's early, but so fa r we see similar perverse effects . The people who trade up are least satisfied. Maybe this effect explains the co mplexit ies of dat ing, too?
Yes! Your friends always want to go back to the wrong person, the one who dumped them. And how often does that HBR Rep rint Fl 006E work out? I::'
,
People will work hard to get past a nightclub's velvet rope. But once they're in, they often say, "This is it?" www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
Learn more at
www.exed.hbs.edu /pgm/hbr/
IDEA WATCH
Vision Statement Six Ways to Find Value in Twitter's Noise Text by Scott Berinato; data and visualization by Jeff Clark
I
learn about the competitive landscape. Tweets about your product th at include the names of rival brands can reveal a lot about market positioning. Most of the KINDLE tweets didn't focus on t he iPad's bei ng a Kindle killer (or, for that matter, a laptop killer). Instead , they hailed the a rrival ofthe Kindle a pp for t he iPad -alerting Apple that its own book s app will fa ce se rious com petition.
It's easy to dismiss Twitter as jabber, but smart marketers will recognize it as a stream of free consumer data to be mined in near-real time. Online visualizat ion tools can help pinpoint what consumers are reading and sharing, elucidate memes in the chatter. and unearth trends, To show marketers how they can gain insight from Twitter, we captured more than a half million tweets containing the word "iPad" that were broadcast during th e product's launch weekend in April. We then mapped key word s that appeared in th ose tweets on the gra ph below, HBR Reprint f1006Z
The iPad Launch by the Numbers
4 TOTAL TWEETS USING
I:l'!{' TWEETS FLAGG ED AS SPAM (CONTAINING "WI N" OR " FREE;
"I PAD"~I NG
PRODUCT'S LAUNCH WEEKEND
18%
8%
PREDO MINANTLY POSITIVE TWEETS
PR EDOMINANTLY NEGATIVE TWEETS
SATURDAY 12 A.M. PROOUClLAUNCH
34 Harvard Business Review June 2.010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
@j" sfo nl in: 11IeKlndle app makesthe .iPad a lot mo re Interesting to me. @Tom]i,hman: RT @<:herwenka:11Ie IPad Kindle app drl ~ , to Amazon, , kin, Apple" 30% <:llt. No· body" happy except the co n,,,me r. ( Not e: Theoe are a ll act" al t weets.)
2 look for une~pected th~mes. Pe:slsten.t word s pomt to persrstent Ideas . The word CASE became fa r more common right after people started buying iPads. The sources? Offers an d ads for fre e cases, and custome rs trad ing tips abo ut protecting t he ir expensive new gadgets. @o,iod mal<: FYI,some lOW Netbook
, leevea
will work as a perfect .. iPad carrying case.
HBR.ORG Scott Berinato is an editor at HBR. Jeff Clar k is a developer and information visualizer based in Toronto. This stream graph shows tw eet vol ume over t ime. Each rivulet illustrates th e prop ortion of iPad tweets cont aining a given word, such as HELP. COlor is used only to disti nguish rivulets.
2
'E l s p.eedy
Dip deeper into the stream. While stre am graphs give an overall impression of what people are tweeting about.ft's important to know what other words are being used in relation to those in t he stream. A t hin ribbon of tweets containing the word EVIL came not from Apple hat ers but from garners tweeting about t he arriva l of Resident Evi/ 4 for t he iPad. In our chart, it might look as th ough a lot of tweeters were calling t he iPad AMAZING , but in fact . most of this traffic came from users retweeting a joke from comedian Conan O'Brien. @lldmitcheU: LolI RT @Conan OB.ien : Just got t he neWlpad. Thi. amuingdeviCCl has elready revolutionized t ile way I use a calculator.
fa~,! ~ ' ~.trange
TYPING~~per easy
Look for user experiences. Product testing and reviews can't replace user reactions. l ooking at iPad tweets wit h t he words TYPING and KEYBOARD, and then singling out t he most common words in t hose twee ts (see above), gives you feedback fro m t housands of users. The negat ive words could help prioritize marketing messages and prod uct development .
5
Learn why negative words are coming up. Finding negative words is a good way to locate consumers' pain points. Though not frequently. DISAPPOINTED and PROBLEM appeared in tweets t hat focused on product functionality. Customer service could be adjusted to address the most common complaints.
@Jga met: I' m having problem. moving a ppt bet¥oeen SC....en. on my iPad . Anyone el",? @darrmurr:V ery disappointed that the iBook a pp for lpad II not a Uowed for iPhone!iPod. Apple i. trying t o forc e the upgrade.
6
Learn about conversation dominators. Words that suddenly dominate the twee t stream mean something has happened that 's worth learning about. The term JAILBR EAK refers to hackers' use of iPad sourc e code t o run software not authori zed by Appl e. Tweeters were sharing lin ks t o stories, code. and video t utorials on how to hack the device. @oncee: RT @iiarmoc, Hacke... Gained Full
@S;ngha, Methink. .ipad will be ....ally good for re ading stuff- PDFI , NYTimel , so on. Landscape typing was awl<wa . d.
Root Code Ex.e cution
of iPad , Jailb....ak i, Around Comer1
MONOAY 12 A.M.
June 2010 Harvard Business Review 35 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
HBR.ORG
COLUMN
Prahalad
C.K. Prah alad, who died on April 16, was the Paul and Ruth McCracken Distinguished University Professor of Strategy at the University of Mich igan's Ross School of Business.
Why Is It So Hard to Tackle the Obvious?
h e mo re successful companies become, the more difficult it is for them to recognize whe n they must change. We all know tha t many industries, such as entertainment, educat ion, publishing, and financial services, are going to look very different tomorrow -yet today's market leaders will probably be th e las t ones to transform themselves, even if they realize they must in order to survive. Why do companies find it so toug h to tackle the obvious? One reason could be t hat over time success ful ente rprises create distinct business ideologies -such as the Toyota Way and the Xerox Way. These doctrines contain specific ideas about how to com pete, perform an ce measures, organizat ional structures, and whom to reward. The beliefs and practices constitute a com pany's dominant logic. The logic may not always be articulated, but every employee knows: That's the way we do things here. But these
T
During a corporate transformation, the forgetting curve is sometimes
more important than the learning curve. success factors often tum into orthodoxies, and no one challenges the m. Ad hering to o ne best way o f d oing things worked well d uri ng the industrial era, but the forces of globalization, digitization, mobile comm unications, and sustainability pose a d ifferent set of challenges today. However, many executives remain in denial , claiming that consumers don' t change quickly, that existing products are su perior, that peo ple won't give up on familiar experiences, and so on. They don' t accept in time the need for change. Companies should stop look ing at threats and opportunities through the lens
36 Harvard Business Review June 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
of the domina nt logic. Instead , the moment they spot signs of change, executives must decide what they can preserve- and what they must discard - in the dominant logic as they prepare to transform the organization. CEOs can identify sacred cows by asking senior managers: • What do we consider good performance? • Whom do we promote: executives who can extract profits from the current business model or those who can lead the company into new businesses? • Do middle managers focus on change or the status quo? • What is the top management team's experience base? Is there diversity at the top? • What skills do we value in the organization? What skill gaps are emerging? • How rapidly do we impose planning and budget ing systems on new businesses? Tales about unknow n rivals eme rging from the woodwork to tu rn indust ries on their heads are often hyperbole. Competitors usually emerge slowly because of the tim e taken by tec hnology development , bus iness model crea tion, and consumer adoption. However, incumbents acknow ledge rivals only after they have become potent t hreats-cNapster preceded iTunes, if you reme mber-and lose the time needed to bring about transformations in an orderly fashion. To change systems faster than their rivals can create new modes of competition, enterprises must: • Articulate the emerging competitive reality and its implications for the bottom line. • Identify gaps in skillsand fill them quickly. • Change ITsystems because they usually represent old business models. Executives must also remember to focus the organization on t he "forgetting curve," They must identify the behaviors, practices, and beliefs that are increasingly becom ing dysfu nctional or cou nte rproductive and put in place ways of discarding them, Indeed , during a corporate transformation, the forgett ing curve is some times more important than the learning curve. " HBR Reprint Fl006F
! I •
I
--
~
-
-- "
----- " - . -~
-
-
~
.-. --. ---
--•-
!
~
---
.
--
.
--'" ---
~
-- . --- . -~
-- . ----- 51 ----" --- • --
~
~ ~
~
When we built our financial centre, we started with the rules.
Fact : the Gu lf's best regulated finan cial centre is in Bah ra in. Ask any of the 400 Hncncic l institutions
that have made a home the re. Yes, it is a lso the Gu lf's biggest fina ncial centre. And all becau se 40 yea rs ago we la id down the rules. To ~ nd out more, vis it ba hrain.com
businessfr~ www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
COLUMN
Ariel
Dan Ariely (
[email protected]) is the James B. Duke Professor ofBehavioral Economics at Duke University and the author of Predictably Irrational (narpercctuns. 200B).
You Are What You Measure loose con se nsu s has forme d around the idea that basing CEO pay on, say, five years of stock returns would eliminate some ofthe reckless decision making that led to the Great Recession. But Isus pect that even if you could build a compensation plan that focuses on long-term shareholder value, you'd solve only part of the problem. That's because such a scheme still ties CEOs' motivation to one fickle num bercompany share price-and ass umes that pay alone motivates ch ief executives to perform. Any number of th ings ca n mo tivate CEOs-peer recognition, for exa mple, and even a desire to change the world. In fact, CEOs us ually have all t he mon ey they need. Why then does it seem that they care more about stock value and the compensation it produces than those other forms of motivation? The answer is almost uncomfortably simple: CEOs care about stock value because that's howwe measure them. Ifwe want to change what they care about, we should cha nge what we measure.
A
It can't be that simple, you might argue -
but psychologists and economists will tell you it is. Human beings adjust behav ior based on the metrics they're held against. Anything you measure will impel a person to optimize his score on that metric. What you meas ure is what you'll get. Period. This phenomenon plays out time and again in research studies. Give someone frequent flyer miles, and he'll fly in absurd ways to optimize his miles. When I was at MIT, I was measured on my ab ility to handle my yea rly teaching load, usinga complex equation ofteaching points. The rat ing, devised to track performance on a variety of dimensions, quickly beca me an end in itself. Even though I enjoyed teaching, I foun d myself spending less ti me with students because I coul d earn more points doing other things. I began to scrutinize opportu nities according to how many points were at stake. In optimiz-
If we want to change what CEOs care about. we should change what we measure.
I 2
3 ~
5
6 38 Harvard Business Review June 2 0 10 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
ing this measure, I was not striving to gain more wealth or happ iness. Nor did l believe that earning the mos t poi nts would result in more effective learning. It was merely the standard of measure ment given to me, so I tried to do well against it (and I ad mit that I was rather good at it). This phenomenon happens at an orgamzational level, too. States that use standardized education assessment tests prod uce kids who indeed perform we ll on these tests but falter when asked to demonstrate their knowledge of the same material in a different way. Does that make teachers bad at their jobs? No. They're simply behaving the way people do when they 're judged on the basisofa metric. So every mo rning, a CEO arrives in his office and chec ks the number he's judged on: the stoc k price. He'll meet wit h people who have ideas about how to make it higher. Nowand again. he'll buy or sell something, or hire or fire some people, to move the number. All the while, analysts will keep watch, p raising him when t he number goes up and criticizing when it goes down. If you were subjected to such unrele nting sc ruti ny, would n't you do as much as you could to get the number up? Even if you knew your actions would probably come back to bite you in the long run? To change CEOs' behavior, we need to change th e num bers we measure. Stock value metrics that focus on the long term are a start, but even more important are new numbers that direct leade rs' attention to the real drive rs of sustainable success. What are those numbers? Ideally, they'd vary by industry, situation, an d mission, but here are a few obvious choices: How ma ny new jobs have bee n created at your firm? How strong is your pipeline of new patents? Howsatisfied are your customers? Your employees? What's the level oftrust in your company and brand? How much carbon dioxide do you emit? None of these memes is as easy to measure as shareholder val ue. That's part of why we're so fixated on it. But if we measure just what's easy, we'll maximize ju st HBR Reprint F1006G what's easy. 0
i !
I
Introducing the new members of the Palladium Balanced Scorecard Hall of Fame for Executing strategy: Each of these organizations linked strategy and operations to achieve an
Bahrain Electricity & Water Authority
Bahrain Ministry of works Borusan Lojistik
"execution premium"- breakt hrough performance results - that put them
Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation
in a class of their own.
Dongwha Enterprise
Strategy Execution Champions: The Palladium Balanced Scorecard Hall of Fame
Dubai Municipality
Report 2010 shows yo u how t hey did it. To order you r copy, call 800.668.6705
Grupo Acir
(+1.617.783.7474 outside t he US), or order online at www.BSRHOEorg.
Iloilo City
Strategy is important. But it's the execution that counts.
Kiwibank
For more about the Pallad ium Balanced Scorecard Hall of Fame program, please
visit: www.thepalladtumgroup.corn/halloffarne
Korea Customs Service Megasalud Millipore Corporation
t1ARVARD
~ BUS I N ESS PUBLISHING
Volkswagen do Brasil
Palladium Executing St rategy >010 Pallad ium Group, In,
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
. !ffJ ...... .. ••
(
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
Daniel J.lsenbeI'B (djsen@ babson.edu) is a"professor
ofmanagement practice at Babson College and executive director of the Babson Ent repreneurship Ecosystem Project . His most recent HBR article
'=l;;l:;;=:;=:was -ree Global Entrepreneur"/December 2008).
-r-
-
(J n the latest Ease of boing Business ranking from the World B nk, one country made a spectacular leapfrom 143rd on the list to 67th. It was Rwanda, whose population and institutions had been decimated by genocide in the 19905. On the World Bank list. Rwanda catapulted out of the neighborhood ofHaiti, Liberia , and the West Bank and Gaza, and sailed past Italy, the Czech Republic, Turkey, and Poland. On one subindex in the study, the ease of opening a new business, Rwanda ranked 11th worldwide.
...
You can see and even smell the signs of Rwanda's business revolution at costco, one of the retail world's most demanding trade customers, where pungent coffee grown by the nation's small farmer-entrepreneurs is stocked on the shelves. And in Rwanda itself the evidence is dramaticper capita GDP has almost quadrupled since 1995. .. This is the kind of cliange entrepreneurship can bring to a country. As Rwanda's president, Paul Kagame, put it recently, "Entrepreneurship is the most sure way of development." He is not a lone voice:
(J
••
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
THE BIG IDE A HOW TO STA RT A N ENTREPREN EURIAL REVOLUTION
Economic st udies from around the globe consistently link entrepreneurship, particularly the fastgrowth variety, with rapid job creation, GDP growth, and long-term productivity increases. You'll see more palpable evidence of surprising entrepreneurialsuccess stories on the Costcoshelves. Afew steps away from the Rwandan coffee, you can find fresh fish from Chile, which now ranks second only to Norwayas a supplier of salmon. The Chilean fish in America's su permarkets were supplied by hundreds of new fishing-related ventures spawned in the isaos and 1990s. Afew aislesover are memory USBs invented and manufactured in Israel, a country whose irrepressible en trepreneurs have been supplying innovative technologies to the world since the 1970s. And jus t around the corner, the Costco pharmacy sells generic drugs made by Iceland's Actavis, whose meteoric rise landed it, in just 10 years, among the top fiveglobal generics leaders.
As Rwanda's president, Paul Kagame, has put it, "Entrepreneurship is the most sure way of development." He is not a lone voice: Studies consistently link entrepreneurship with job creation and GDP growth.
Rwanda, Chile, Israel, and Iceland all are fertile ground for entrepreneurship -thanks in no small pa rt to the efforts of their governments. Thou gh the companies beh ind the products on Costco's shelves were launc hed by innovative entrepreneurs, those businesses we re all aided, either d irectly or indirectly, by government leaders who helped build environments that nu rture and sustain entrepre neurship. These entre preneurship ecosystems have become a kind of holy grail for governments around the world- in both emerging and developed countries. Unfort unately, many governments ta ke a misguided approach to building entrepreneurship ecosystems. They pursue some unattainable idea l of an ecosystem and look to econom ies that are completely unlike thei rs for best practices. But increasingly, the most effective practices come from remote corners of the ea rth, where resources-as well as lega l frameworks, transparent governance, and democratic values- may be scarce. In these places entrepreneurship has a completely new face. The new practices are emerging murkily an d by trial and erro r. This messiness should not deter leaders-there's too muc h at stake. Governments need to exploit all available experience and commit to ongoing experimentation. They must follow an incomplete and ever-changing set of prescriptions and relentlessly review and refine them. The alternatives-taking decades to devise a model set of gu idelines, act ing randomly, or doing nothi ngall are unacceptable. But the governme nt canno t do everything on its own; the private and nonprofit sectors too must shoulder so me responsibility. In nu mero us instances corporate executives, family-business owners, universities, professional organizations, foundations, labor organizations, financiers, and, ofcourse, entrepreneurs themselves have initiated and even financed entrepreneurship education, conferences, research, and policy advocacy. As we sha ll show later in this article, sometimes pr ivate initiative makes it easier for governments to act more quickly and effectively, and all stakeholders-government and otherwise-should take every chance to show real leadership. To make progress, leaders need practical ifimperfect maps and naviga tional guidelines. From wha t we know from both researc h and practice, here's what seems to actually work in sti mulating thriving entrepreneursh ip ecosystems.
42 Harvard Business Review June 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
HBR.ORG
Idea in Brief The big idea: Governments around the world are recognizing t hat entre preneurship can transform t heir economies. But most of their efforts to spar k venture creation are wasted on trying to achieve the impossible- creating another Silicon valley.
Nine Prescriptions for creating an Entrepreneurship Ecosystem The entrepreneurship ecosystem consists of a set of individual elements-such as leadership, culture, cap ital markets, and open-minded customers-that combine in complex ways. (See the exhibit "Do You Have a Strong Entrep reneurship Ecosystem?") In isolation, each is conducive to entrepreneurship but insufficient to sustain it. That's where many governmental efforts go wrong-they address only one or two elements. Together, however, these elements turbocharge venture creation and growth. When integrating them into one holistic system, government leaders should focus on these nine key principles. St op Emulating sftlccn va ttey, The nearly u niversal amb ition o f becoming another Silicon Valley sets governmen ts up for frustration and failure. There is little argument that Silicon Valley is the "gold standard" entrepreneurship ecosystem, home to game-changing giants such as Intel, Oracle, Google, eBay, and Apple. The Valley has it all: tech nology, money, talent, a critical mass of ventures, and a culture that encourages collaborative in novation and tole rates failure. So it is understandable when public leaders throughout the world point to California and say, "I want that." Yet, Valley envy is a poor guide for three reasons. One is that, ironically, even Silicon Valley could not become itself today ifit tried. Its ecosystem evolved u nder a u nique set of circumstances: a strong local aerospace indust ry, the open California culture, Stanford University'S supportive relationships wit h ind ustry, a mot her lode of inve ntion from Fairchild Semiconductor, a liberal immigration policy toward doctoral students, and pure luck, among other things. All those factors set offa chaotic evolution that defies defi nitive determination ofcause and effect. Fu rth er, Silicon Valley is fed by an overabu nda nce of technology and tec hnical expertise. Devel-
What recen t resea rch a nd experience show: The face of entrepreneurship is cha nging aLL around the world- and best practices are emerging from surprising pLaces. valuable lessons ca n be Learned from what is working.
A better approac h: There's no exact formula for creating an ent repreneurial economy; there are onLy pract ical, jf imperfect , road maps. To jump-start the growth of an entrepreneurial ecosyste m, leade rs should foLLow nine key principles- some counteri ntuitive-that will help build a vi brant business sector.
oping "knowledge-based industry"-cthe ma ntra of governments everywhere -is an admirable aspi ration, but achieving it requires a mass ive, generationlong investment in education as well as the ability to develop world-class intellect ual property. On top of that, a knowledge industry de ma nds an enormous technology pipeline and scrap pile. Consi der that top vent ure capitalists invest in at best 1% of the technology-based businesses they look at, and a significant proportion of that select group fails. Athird limit is that although SiliconValley sounds as if it's a place that breeds local ventures, in reality it's as much a powerful magnet for ready' made entrep reneurs, who flock there from around the globe, often forming their own ethnic subcultures and organizations in what Gordon Moore, one of the Valley's graybeards, calls an "industry of transplants." And difficul t as it is to foster an ecosystem that encourages cu rrent inhabitants to make the ent repreneurial choice and then succeed at it, it is even harder to create an entrepreneur's "Mecca:' Shape th e Ecosystem Around l ocal Conditi ons. If not Silicon Valley, then what entrepreneurial visio n should government leaders aspire to? The most difficult, yet crucial, thing for a gove rnment is to tailor the suit to fit its own local entrepreneurship dimensions, style, and climate. The striking d issimilarities of Rwanda, Chile, Israel, and Iceland illustrate the principle that leaders ca n and m ust foster homegrow n solutions-ones based on the realities oftheir own circumsta nces, be they natural resources, geographic location, or culture. Rwanda's government took a strongly interventionist strategy in the postgenocide years, identifying three local industries (coffee, tea, and to urism) that had proven potential for development. It actively organized the institutions that would support those industries by, for example, training farmers to grow June 2.010 Harvard Business Review 43
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
THE BIG IDEA HOW TO STA RT A N ENTR EPREN EURIAL REVOLUTIO N
The most difficult, yet crucial, th ing for a govern me nt is to t ailor the su it to fit th e loca l entrepreneu rial dime nsio ns, style, and climate.
and package coffee to international standards and connecting the m to ove rseas distribution cha nne ls. Rwanda's immediate priority was to provide gainful employment to millions of people. Its efforts led to about 72,000 new ventures, almost entirely consisting of two- and three- person ope rations, which in a decade tripled exports and reduced poverty by 25%. Chile also focu sed on indu stries where it had copious na tural resources- su ch as fishing. As in Rwanda, the government took a powerfully interventionist app roach to its entrepreneurship ecosystem in Augusto Pinochet's early years, and the dictator's free-market ideology made it easier for Chile's middle class to obtain financing and licenses for fishing operations. The governme nt also weakene d labor (sometimes brutally) to reduce new ventures' input costs and kept Chile's currency inexpensive to maintain competitiveness in export markets. Natural resources often are not a key component ofan ecosystem, however. Frequently, entrepreneurship is stimula ted when such resources are scarce, requiring people to be more inventive. Taiwan, Iceland, Ireland, and New Zealand, resource-poor "islands" far from major markets, all develo ped ecosystems based primarily on huma n capital. So did Israel. In the 1970s and 1980s, its unique ecosystem evolved haphazardly out of a combinatio n of factors, including spillover from large military R&Defforts, strong diaspora con nect ions to capital and customers, and a culture that prized frugality, education, and unconventional wisdom. Engage th e Private Sector from the Start . Government can not bu ild ecosystems alone. Only the private sector has the motivation and perspective to develop selfsustaining, profit-driven markets. For this reason, gove rnment must involve the private sector early and let it keep or acq uire a significant stake in the ecosystem's success. St art wit h a candid conversatio n. One way to involve the private sector is to reach out to its representatives for early, frank advice in reducing st ructural barriers and formulating entrepreneur-friendly policies and progra ms. If the necessary expertise doesn't exis t domestically, it can often be found overseas among expatr iates. In the 1980s the Taiwa nese government engaged with the Taiwanese diaspora, consulting prominent execu tives in lead ing U.S. technology compa nies and establishing ongoing forums to collect their input. The government
actually built progra ms based on the suggestions of these expats, who liked how their ideas were implemented so much that they returned home in droves in the 1990 s, many of them to occ upy prominent policy positions or run the new plants that were establish ed . For example, Morris Chang, the former gro up vice president of Texas Ins truments, came home and eventually set up and ran T5MC, Taiwan's second semiconductor·fabricating plant. Design in self-liq uidat ion. In 1993 the Israeli government created Yozma, a $100 million fun d of funds that in three years spawned 10 venture capital funds. In each one, Yozma, an Israeli private partner, and a foreign private partner with proven fund ma nagement expertise all invested app roximately equal amounts. From the start, the Israe li govern men t gave the private sector partners an option to buyout its interest in the funds at attractive terms-sa fact often overlooked by other governments tha t copy the Yozma model. That option was exercised by eight of the 10 funds, profitably for the government, I might add. Five years after the founding of Yozma, its remaining assets were liquidated by auction. The government's exit served as market proofthat real value had been generated and is oneofthe reasons that the Israeliventure cap ital industry not only became selfsustaining but simultaneously achieved a quant um leap in growth . Favor the High Poten ti als. Many programs in emerging eco nomies spread scarce resources among quanti ties of bottom-of-the-pyramid ventures. And indeed, some of them, such as the Carvajal Foundation in Cali, Colombia, have dramatically increased income for segments of the population. But focusing resources there to the exclusion of high-poten tial ventures is a cru cial mistake. In an era when microfinance for small-scale entrepre neurs has become ma instream, the reallocation orresources to su pport high-potential entrepreneurs may seem elitist and inequitable. But es pecially if resources are limited , programs should try to focus first on ambitious, growth-oriented entrepreneurs who address large poten tial markets. The social economics of high-potential ventures and sma ll-scale employment alternatives are significantly different. Whe reas 500 microfina nced sole proprietorsh ips and one rap idly globalizing goo-person operation create the sa me number of jobs, many experts argue that the wealth creation,
44 Harvard Business Review June 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
'.. . ...
HBR.ORG ~",,~
"
• • •-G,+Cl
.' ,",-,
.\'"'~'.
"i-
',.
Rwanda: Fro~Genocide to costco'is e es Considering that less th an two decades ago, almost one millio n people were slaug htered in Rwanda in 10 0 days, t he country's current standing in global busi ness circles is stun ning. Promot ing entrepreneurs hip has been a key plank of President PauLKagame's agenda for the nation. In 2001 he launched the Rwanda NationaL Innovation and Competitiveness initiative, which, among other efforts,
developed a "nat ional coffee strategy" focused on building a Rwandan Bourbon Spec ialty Coffee brand. With help from OTF Group consuLtants, it also identified over $100 million worth of investments to
power to inspire other start-ups, labo r force enrichment, and reputational value are m uch greater with the latter. One organization that recognizes this is Enterp rise Irela nd, an agency responsible for su pporting the growth ofworld-class Irish companies. It has created a program speci fically to provide mentoring and fi na ncial assistance to high-potential start-ups, which it defi nes as ventu res that are export-oriented, are based on in novative technology, and ca n generate at least €I million in sales and 10 jobs in three years. The global nonprofit Endeavor, which focuses on entrepreneurship development in 10 emerging econom ies, has to date "adopted" some 440 "highimpact entrepreneurs:' who, with Endeavor's rnentoring, are turn ing their successes into role models for their countrymen. Not all h igh-potent ial ve ntures are tec hnology based; in fact, I'd argue that the majority are not. SABIS is a perfect example. An educational manageme nt orga nization founded in Lebanon many years ago as one school, SABIS now is one of the world's largest EMOs, teaching more than 65,000 students in 15 countries, wit h the goal of reaching 5 million students by 2020. Get a Big Win on the Board , It has become dear in rece nt years that even one success ca n have a surprisingly stimulating effect on an entrepreneurs hip ecosystem-by igniting the imagination of the public and inspiring imitators. I call this effect the "law ofsmall numbers:' Skype's adoption by m illions and eventual $2.6 billion sale to eBay reverberated throughout the small nation of Estonia, encouraging highly trained tech nical people to sta rt their own companies. In China, Baid u's market share and worldwide recognition have inspi red an entire generation of new entrepreneurs. Celtel's amazing success as sub-Saharan Africa's leading regional mobile provide r and acquisition
" . '"
',' ~ • •
improve coffee washing, production, ca pac ity, and marketing. A partnership among agricultural institutes in Rwanda , Mich igan State University, and Texas A&M worked to connect local growers to u.s. and European specialty coffee buyers. Two notab le events happened in 2006: Starbucks gave Rwanda's Blue Bourbon brand
. "'_~~.,,;II;)
"."'.
. .,
~
.-. •. '
v'"~''' ~
..
. ;;
of coffee beans its BLack Apron award and introduced it in its stores, and on a visit to the u.s. Kagame met with c ostco's CEO, Jim Sinegal. to promote Rwandan coffee. costco would later become one of the two biggest buyers of Rwandan coffee, purchasing an estimated 2.,5% of the country's premium crop.
by Zain for more tha n $3 billion stirred the region's pride an d helped African govern ments fight "Africa fright" among investors. In Irela nd it was Elan Corporation and lona Technologies , listed on Nasdaq in 1984 and 1997, respectively, th at served as guiding lights to a generation ofbudding entrepreneurs. Early, visible successes help reduce the perception of entrepreneurial barriers and risks, and high -
' : ....
.,...
,..
.. ,.. .
. 0 ;.... '0 .vr-
Even one success can have a surprisingly stimulating effect on an entrepreneurship ecosystem-by igniting the imagination of the public and inspiring imitators. I call this effect the "law of small numbers." June 2010 Harvard Business Review 45
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
THE BIG IDEA
HOW TO STARTANENTREPRENEURIALREVOLUTION
. . Taiwan: Sri
/ \ gmg Expat Entrepreneurs Home
Taiwan is an examp le of how determined governme nt leaders can transform a brain drai n into a brain gain,
As University of California professor AnnaLee Saxenian has reported, that story begins in the 1960s, when engineers left Taiwan in droves to study and work in the United States. puring that decade Taiwan's government leaders rec-
~~
ognized the country's need for entrepreneurship and began sending delegations to Silicon valley to learn about how it had blossomed t here . By the 1970S many Taiwanese engineers had become te chnology executives in the U.S. They
light the ta ngible rewards . Even modest successes can have an impact. Saudi Arabia, a nation with a dear th of entrepreneurial ventures (aside from the powerful family business groups), is fighting hard to tear down the numerous structural and cultural obstacles en trepreneurs face. One young Saud i, Abdullah AI-Munif, left his salaried job, tightened his belt, fought the bureaucracy, and started a business making chocolate-covered dates. He ultimat ely grew the business, Anoosh, into a national chain of 10high street sto res and turned an eye to overseas markets. Now when AI-Munif appea rs as a panelist at entrepreneurship seminars, he is swamped by aspiring Saudi entrepreneurs who ta ke insp iration from his bravery, realizing that neither ca pital, nor technol ogy, nor connections are essential to success. o ve rcel e bra t e t he successes . Governmen ts should be bold about celebrating thriving entrepreneurial ventures. Media events, highly pu blicized awards, and touts in govern ment literature, speeches, and interviews all have an impact . This is not as straightforward as it may see m, because many cultures discourage any public display of success as boastful or an invitation to either bad luck or the tax collector. Whereas in Hong Kong even small-scale entrepreneurs d rive black Mercedes to project their status, in the Middle East flaunting one's success publicly can att ract the envy of neighbors or, worse, the evil eye. Kenya's first int ernational call center, KenCall, fou nded by Nicholas Nesbitt and two pa rtners in 2004, built an international presence by overcoming many bureaucratic and st ructural ba rriers, includ ing the lack of a high-speed optical fiber hookup to the international communications grid. The Kenyan government didn't wait until Ke nCall became big to sing its praises; eve n when it was a fledgling operation, the govern ment brought in foreign delegations for visits, promoted the company in official publica-
5
joined expat indust ry as sociations and met on an ongoing basis wit h policy makers in Taiwan to discuss technical and, tater, policy developments. In the 1980s Premier V.S. Sun established the Science and Technology Advisory Group (STAG),
nons and press releases, and hoste d an international outsourcing conference. Government officials also used KenCall's example to push for reforms, which exped ited the construction of East Africa's fi rst unde rsea optical fiber link- an example of how ent repreneurial success can facilitate structural change, not just the ot her way around. Tackle Cultural Change Head- On. Changing a deepl y ingrai ned culture is eno rmo usly di fficult, but bot h Ireland an d Chile demonstrate that it is possible to alte r sccial norms about entrepreneurship in less than a generation. Until the 1980s employment in govern ment, financialservices, or agriculture was the main aspiration of Ireland's young people. There was zero tolerance for loan defaults, and bankru ptcy was stigma tized . Parents discou raged their children fro m setting out on their own, so few nurtured dreams of starting their own business. But by the 1990s, after successful pioneers paved the way, hundreds ofnew software co mpa nies had been launched in Ireland. Some exported products; some went public. Many achieved healthy sales reven ues. Just as important, entrepreneurs learned that it was possible to fail and regroup to try again. "If you wanted to be respected and take n seriously,you needed to be a founder with a stake in a com pany trying to do something," recalls Barry Murphy, who was national software director at Enterprise Ireland 's predecessor in the 1990S. In her research, University of Minnesota professor Rachel Schurman has described how Chile ans' negative image of entrep reneurs as greedy exploiters was transformed in just one decade, as a direct result of the Chilean government'S concerted effort to liberalize Chile's economy. Until the 1980s, Chile's well-educated middle class was n't ent repreneurial, avoide d opportu nity- driven investment, and p re ferred to consume rathe r than save and invest. But
46 Harvard Business Review June 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
---
_.
----_.-~--
~ which included 15 prominent Taiwanese expats (as well as some non-Taiwanese technology executives), to help t he government build t he scientific and educational infrastructure for an entire generat ion of tech nology ent repreneurs.
HBR.ORG . _ - - - - - _ . _ - _.. _ ...... , . ., ,
STAGand other consultations wit h U.S.based expats were so successfuL in helping the government st rengt hen Taiwan's entrepreneurship ecosystem that the brain drain began to reverse. Between 1988 and
by the 1990s, Chile's new middle-class entrepreneurs were telling Schurman: "Today the youth, everybody, wants to be an entrepreneur. Ifa successful empresario is interviewed in the newspaper, everybody reads it. Why was he successful? How did hedo it? It's a model that never existed before...." The media can play an important role not just in celebrati ng wins but in changing attitudes. In Puerto Rico, El Nuevo Dia, the largest daily newspaper, supported local entrepreneurship by running a weekly page of start-up success stories. On the small island, these stories have quickly become part of the social dialogue and have raise d awareness about the opportun ities entrepreneurship presents, as well as the tools it requires. St res s th e Roots. It's a mistake to flood even high- poten tial entrepreneurs with easy money: More is not necessa rily merrier. New ventures must be exposed early to the rigors of the market. Just as grape growers wit hhold water from their vines to extend their root systems and make their grapes produce moreconcentrated flavor, governments should "st ress the roots" of new ventures by meting out money carefully, to ensure that entreprene urs develop toughness and resourcefulness. Such measures also help weed out opportunists. In 2006 Malaysia's Ministry of Entrepreneur and Cooperative Development awarded 90% of some 21,000 applicants about $5,000 each in business support, strong evidence of the govern ment's commitment to entrepreneurship. The program was part of an affirmative action program largely aimed at indigenous Malays, who were less entrepreneurial than the country's business-minded Chinese imm igrants. Yet Malay entrepreneurs themselves att ribute the disappointing results partly to the fact that fund ing was too loose and eve n stigmatized the Malay
1998, 40,00 0 Taiwanese engineers returned home to pursue- and create-opportunities. Many became senior executives in new companies, heads of government research and t raining institutes, ent repreneurs, or venture
capitalists, forming t he human capital backbone ofTaiwan's burgeoning IT components industry.
recipients as less capable. More broad ly, Malaysian entre preneurship-development programs, considered by many, includ ing myself, to be amo ng the most comprehensive programs in the world, have been criticized for act ually inhibiting entrepreneursh ip among the Malays by u nwittingly reinforcing thei r lack of risk taking. Similarly, recent reports on Sout h Africa's Black Economic Empowerment program have reached the conclusion that BEE has discouraged entrepreneurship among the bul k of black South Africans and has benefited primarily the elite and well-connected. In fact, the hardships of resource-scarce, even hosti le, e nvironments ofte n promote en trep reneurial resourcefulness. New Zealanders call Kiwi ingenu ity "number a wire": In the country's colonial days, the only plentiful resource was a-gauge fencing wire, and New zeala nders learned to fi x and make anything with it. Iceland ic entrepreneurship is built upo n a legacy of "fishing when the fish are there, not when the weather is good." For years incubators or entrepreneurship centers that provide financial help, mentori ng, and often space to start-ups have bee n popular with gove rnments. But I have seen scant rigorous evidence that these expensive programs contribute commensurately to entrepreneurship. One municipality in Latin America established 30 small incubators, but afte r several years only one venture out ofmore than 500 assisted by them had reached annual sales Of$1million. Though Israel's renow ned incubator program has helped lau nch more than 1,300 new ventures, relatively few ofthe m have been big entrepreneurial successes. On the basis ofm y discussions with Israeli officials, I estimate that, among the hundreds of Israeli ventures that have been acquired at hefty valuations or taken public, at bes t 5% were hatched in incubators. And incubators definitely are not a quick fi x. When well conceived and well managed, they
Hardships and hostile environments ofte n promote resourcefulness. Icelandi c ent repreneurship is built upon a legacy of "fishing when th e fish are th ere. not when th e weat her is good."
June 2010 Harvard Business Review 47 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
THE BIG IDEA
HOW TO STARTAN ENTREPRENEURIALREVOLUTION
Perhap s no city has worked hard er to t urn itself a round t han Med ellin, Colombia. which for two decad es was blighted by d rugs a nd homicide. When sergio Fajardo became Medellin's mayor. in 2003, he brought about a revolutionary cultural change, creating a legitimate entrepreneurial business environment. With a coalition of universities. new private equity funds, large
companies such as the Local power utility (EPM). private entrepreneurs. the nonprofit proantioquia Foundation, t he social cooperative Comfama, and some diaspora Medellinians. his administration forged a strategy of inclusive
prosperity. One of Fajardo's focuses was building beautifully designed, technologically advanced public libraries and community centers in the rankest barrios, and setting up microfinance programs to help the poor. Fajardo's other strategies included establishing innovation centers and earmarking a whopping 40% of his
can take 20 years or longer to generate a measurable impact on en trepreneurship. Poorly conce ived and managed. they can be white elephants.
Incubators can take 20 years or longer to generate a measurable impact on entrepreneurship. They can also be white elephants.
Don't o verengineer Clusters; Help Them Grow Organically, No governme nt official ever go t fire d for promoting clus te rsthose concent rations of interconnected compan ies, specialized suppliers. se rvice provid ers, training institutions, and support organizations formed arou nd a technology or end product w ithin one area or region. Popularized by Harvard Business School's Michael Porter, cluster strategies have been promo ted by governments th roughout the worl d, w hich to ut clusters' key role in fostering entrepreneurship and economic competitiveness. Though entrepreneurial clusters do exist na turally and can be important elements ofan ecosystem, there is only questionable anecdotal evidence that governments ca n play a major role in breeding them. In a rare critique ofthe cluster mantra, the Economist reported: "Typically governments pick a promisi ng part of their country, ideally one that has a big university near by, and provide a pot of money that is mea nt to kick-start entrepre neurship und er the guiding hand of benevolent bureaucrats.... 1t ha s been an abysmal failure....Experts at Insead looked at efforts by the German govern ment to create biotechnology clusters on a par wit h those found in California and concluded th at 'Ge rma ny has essentially was te d $20 billion- and now Singapore is well on its way to doing the same.' An assessment by the World Bank of Singapore's multibillion dollar efforts to create a 'biopolis' reckoned that it had only a 50-50 chance of success. Some would put it less than that." The problem is that ove r the yea rs people have mistaken Porter's desc ription of the benefits of clusters for a prescription to go out and bu ild them from scratch. In fact, in a 1998 article in this magazine
budget for education and $17 million a year to stimulate entrepreneurship. They seemed to succeed by driving out drugs, creating opti mism, and reducing vioLence to t he point where Medellin is now statistically safer t han washington, DC, and many other u .s. cities.
("Clusters and the New Economics ofCompetition") Porter himselfan ticipated that the dynamics ofclusters wou ld be misunderstood by governments: "Govern ment...should reinfor ce an d build on existing and emerging clusters rathe r than attempt to create entirely new ones....ln fact, most clusters fo rm independently of governme nt action -and sometimes in spite of it. They form where a foundation oflocational advantages exists. Tojustify cluster development efforts, some seeds ofa cluster should have already passed a market test...." Governments would be better advised to remain sector neutral and to u nleash rather than harness people's entrep reneurial energies. They should observe which di rection entrepreneurs take and "pave the footpath" by ge ntly encouraging supportive economic activity to form around already successful ventures, rather than plann ing new sidewalks, pouring the concrete, and keeping the ent repreneurs off the grass. Yet this unglamorous but practical insight is often lost as cluste r theory gets translate d into government policies that are suspiciously akin to debunked centralized industrial plan ning. Reform Legal. Bureaucratic. and Regulat ory Frameworks. The right legal and regulatory frameworks are critical to thriving entrepreneurship. I have saved the discussion of them for last, however. because they are ofte n the first and exclusive focus ofgovernments, and I've been trying to show that governme nt has a more co mp rehe nsive, holistic role to play. Furthermore, legal and regulatory reforms often take man y years to push th rough, and entrepreneurs hip frequently occurs in their absence. In fact, numerous entrepreneurs have succeeded des pite inhibiting legislation and bureaucracy, and have gone on to use their wealth and status to push for reform. Finally, reform won't be truly effective in the absence of all the
48 Harvard 8usiness Review June 2 010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
HBR.ORG
Do You Have a Strong Entrepreneurship Ecosystem?
"softer" approaches government can take to building ecosystems, such as breaking down cultural barrie rs, ed uca ting entrepreneurs, and promoting success stories. Extensive resea rch points to a num ber of reforms that have a positive impact on venture creation : decriminalizing bankruptcy, shielding s hare holders from creditors, a nd all owing e ntre pre ne urs to quickly start over. Anothe r helpfu l reform is to shift workers' u ne mp loym ent protection from making te rmination difficult to providing support for the unemployed . Creating a nd libe ralizing capital ma rkets, such as the UK's Alterna tive Investment Ma rket, ca n have a sti mulating effect as well. Sim plified ta x regimes and strong a udi ting a nd collection also facilitate e ntrepre neurship. In Pue rto Rico, for example, an ineffective tax regime act ually encourages many e ntrep reneurs to stay small and unde r the radar so tha t they can kee p trea ting many personal e xpenses as business investments; in this, Puerto Rico is far from uniq ue. All else being equal, re moving administra tive a nd legal barriers to ve nture formation is a better way to go than creating incentives to ove rcome barriers. In 20 08 the French govern ment, long frustrated by its business sector's lac k of e ntreprene urial spi rit, implemented the Auto-entre preneur program. It simplified the legal process for creating a small business, allowed entrepreneurs to avoid onerous ta x prepayme nts, a nd eliminated other disincentives. Over 300,000 new businesses have been started in France under the progra m more than 10,000 ne w starts a month. Ad mittedly, the overwhelming majority a re essentially sole pro prie torships, and it remai ns to be seen how many, if a ny, will e volve into true growth compa nies. But as one observer noted, "Perhaps the biggest impact will be to re ve rse long- held negative attitudes in France about starting a small business." And France's bold ex perime nt will be an unmitiga ted success if even one out ofa tho usand auto-e ntrepreneurs launches a growth company.
Experiment Relentlessly Yet Holistically Crea ting a n e ntire ecosyst em is a da unting challenge , but yo u have to jump in an d cover all the bases. Taiwan, for example, strengthened several ele ments of its ecosyste m more or less s imulraneously. 1tencouraged resea rch in integrated-circuit
How do you know if you have the essential ele ments of a n e ntreprene urship ecosystem in place? To help gove rnme nts add ress that questio n, Babson College has launched a gLo bal action-research project , the Ba bson Entrepreneurship Ecosyste m Project. Below is a summa ry of the fra mework BE EP use s to assess the cruciaL eLe ments in a n environme nt , so that gove rnments know whe re to focus their efforts. Each category represe nts a key compone nt of a heaLthy ecosystem. Though not exha ustive, the sample questi ons tisted below wiLL help you gauge where you are. DO PUBLIC LEADERSI
Act as strong, public advocates of entrepreneurs and entreprene urship? Open their doors to e ntrepreneurs and those promoting e ntrepreneurship? DO GOVERNMENTSI
Create effective institutions directly associated with ent repreneurship (research institutes. overseas liaisons. forums for public-private dialogue)? Remove structural barriers to entrepreneurs hip. such as onerous bankruptcy legislation and poor contract enforcement? DOES THE CULTURE AT LARGEI
Tolerate honest mistakes, honorable failure, risk taking, and contrarian thinking? Respect entrepreneurship as a worthy occupation? ARE THERE VISIBLE SUCCESS STORIES THAT:
Inspire youth and would-be entrepreneurs? Show ordinary people that they too can become entrepreneurs? ARE THERE ENOUGH KNOWLEDGEABLE PEOPlE WHO:
Have experience in creating organizations, hiring, and building structures, systems, and controls? Have experience as professional board members and advisers? ARETHERE CA~TAL SOURCESTHAT:
Provide equity capital for companies at a pre-sales stage? Add nonmonetary value, such as mentorship and contacts? ARE THERE NONPRDFITS AND INDUSTRY ASSOCIATIONS THAT:
Help investors and entrepreneurs network and learn from one anothe r?
Promote and ally themselves with entre preneurship (such as software and biotechnology associations)? ARE THERE EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS THAT:
Teach financial literacy and ent repreneurship to high school a nd college stud ents? Allow faculty to take sabbaticals to join start-ups? DOES THE PUBLIC INFRASTRUCTURE PROVIDE SUFFICIENT:
Transportation (roads, airports, railways, container shipping)? Communication (digital, broadband, mobile)? ARI! THERE GEOGRAPHIC LOCATIONS THAT HAVEl
Concentrations of high-potent ial and high-growth ventures? Proximity to universities, sta ndards age ncies, think tanks, vocat ional training, suppliers, consulting firms, and professional associations? ARE THERE FORMAL OR INFORMAL GROUPS THAT LINKI
Entrepreneurs in the country or region and diaspora networks- in particular, high-achieving expatriates? New ven tures a nd local offi ces of multinationals? ARE THERE VENTURE-ORIENTED PROFESSIONALS, SUCH ASI
l awyers, accountants, and market and technical consultants who will work on a contingency basis, or fo r stock? ARE THERE LOCAL POTENTIAL CUSTOMERS WHO ARE:
Willing to give advice, particularly on new products or services? Willing to be flexible with payment terms to accommodate the cash flow needs of young, rapidly growing suppliers? Ju ne 2010 Harvard Business Review 49
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
THE BIG IDE A HOW TO STA RT AN ENTR EPREN EURIAL REVOLUTIO N
The story of Mo Ibrah im illust rates how brute-force entrepreneurial success can have a potentiaUy large impact on an ecosystem.
Ibrahim fou nded a mobile operator, cettet. in su b-Sahara n Africa, which succeeded in buiLding tremendous shareholder vatue in the face of violent conflict, corrupt governments, and the worst global telecommunicat ions invest-
H BR.ORG
ment market in decades. CelteL's shareholders made a kiLling when the owners of Zain acq uired the company in 20 05. Ibrahim used his newfound wealt h to create t he Ibrahim Index to monitor governance in Africa and the $5 million Ibrahim Prize
design and manufactur ing, es tab lished Hsinch u Science Park nea r Taipei, began running integratedcircuit trai ning programs, engaged with U.S.-based Taiwanese technology executives. and passed laws to encourage the development of an indigenous venture capital industry. Israel's Yozma succeeded because it wasembedded in an emerging ecosystem that already induded some two dozen Israeli public technology ventures, two operating venture capital funds. eager ange ls and institutional investors, U.S. investment bankers with local operations, professional su pport services catering to entrepreneurs, and a rich deal flow. In fact, ignoring the interconnected nat ure ofthe ecosystem elements can lead to perverse outcomes. Encouraging young people to have entrepreneurial aspirations, for example, can have a boomerang effect and cause brain drain if those aspirations are foiled by a hostile environment. As Harvard Business School professor Josh Lerner has reported, creating venture capital funds that lack a deal flow and an appropriate incentive structure, like the ones se t up by Canada's Labor Fund Progra m, can actually retard the formation of a private equ ity sector. Easy gove rnment money, ha nded ou t indiscriminately. will flood the market with overvalued, poor-quality deals, making it difficult for private equity investors to make money. Of course. it is neither realistic no r practical to change everything at once. Having a dear map of what an enti re ecosystem looks like will help governments take the fi rst steps without losing sight of what comes next. Effecting such fundamental change in the mids t of so much uncertainty requires endless experimentation and learning, and it is important for governments around the world to learn from one another as well, something tha t does n't happen often enough. And everyone trying to build an ecosystem should
to reward democratic leadership. Already bestowed twice, the prize is sending a loud and positive signal to government Leaders to enact courageous reform.
keep in mind that the work is never reallydone. Two things recently brought this home to me. The fi rst was the lau nch. by the Commonwealth of Massa chusetts and the Cityof Boston, ofa global businessidea competition, MassChallenge. The second was a remark made by an old friend, a prominent Israeli econo mist and one of the pio neering advocates of technological entrepre neurship: "We don 't do enough to promote entrepreneurial growt h in Israel, and if we don't start soon, we will lose our edge:' Now, Massachu setts and Israel are two of the most entrepreneurial places in the world. If they're not satisfied and resting on their laurels. it is a sign that the ho rizon is always receding- that you can never have "enough" entrepreneurship. there are no right answers, and there is no choice but for policy make rs and leaders to continue to experime nt and learn how to enhance their ecosystems. Although the story never ends, the action principles I have listed will help governments move the need le of entrepreneurship in the right direct ion. Engagi ng t he private sector, modifying cultural norms, removing regulatory barriers, encouraging and celebrating successes, passing conducive legislation, being judicious in emphasizing clusters and incubators, subjecting financi ng programs to market rigors, and , above all, approaching the entrepreneurship ecosystem as a whole will allow governments to create economic growth by stimulating self-sustaining venture creation. Ireland's president. Mary McAleese, recognized the ext raordinary effect that cou ld have on a society. In 2003 she said: "Today an educated. self-confident. and achieving generation can see the power of its own genius at work in its own land as a cu lt ure of entrepreneurship transfo rms Ireland's fortunes, creating a new futu re for our children and an eco nomic success story of remarkable proportions." l:'
50 Harvard Business Review June 20 10 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
HBR Reprint RlOO6A
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
, ,, ,,
,, "
'----
"
,, .'
,, ,,
---
"
,,
,, ,, ,, ,,
,, ,, ,, ,
-'-,
,-,'
"""
CHANGE
INNOVATION
MANAGEMENT
DEVELOPING EMP\.OYli:IiOS
,,
,, ,, ,
"'-,
,,,-' ,
EXECUTING
TALENT
$TRATI'GY
,
"
-'
,
"
"
-'---::'--'-, ",
'" ,
,, ,, ,, , -'
BUSINESS SCHOOL FACULTY "
,,-'
,," ,
,, GLOBAL EXECUTIVES
, ,-'
.'" v..
""EMIEA AUTHORS ,
, LEADERS IN TRANSITION
'--,
,, ,, ,, ,
,,
"'-,
"
HIGHPOTfiNTIALS
,,
PEER NETWORk
---
..
.'
-,---,--
--'
,, ,, ,, ,, , '"
.--"
"
--',
--- .' -,---, "'"
.'
"
" "
,, ,, ,, ,,
.>'
-,--"
,, ,, , .-
.,'
"
,, ,, ,, , ,
-.
,, ,, ,
.>'" ,
.,-' "
"
GLOBAL
TEAMS
, "'"
,
,-'
.-,.'
",
,, ,, -'
,' .,'
,,
,, ,, ,, ,
"
,,,-' ,, ,,
,-'
-'
,," ,
DECISION MAKING
MANAGEMENT
-,-,-'
.'
",
,"
,, ,, ,, ,, ,
,,
,
"
"
" , ,"
,, ,, ,, ,, ,
.>'" ,
"
,, ,, ,, ,
'" "
.>'
'" ,
"
"
,, , ,,,
, ,.-'
.,,'
"
'"
,, , ,
"
,, ,
, ,-'
"
'--', ",
,.'
,," ,, ,,
HOW TO CONNECT: THE NEW HARVARD MANAGEMENTOR " ,
Improve performance b y fo rging connec tions-
-'
.' "
---,."., ---
between problems and solutions, managers and expe rts, current and emerging leaders. W it h more than 40 learning
,"
'" ,
,, modules. the new Harvard ManageMentor supports you r ,, ,, cu rrent leaders-and th e next g eneration. ,, , ,-' ,,'''----
,, , -,-",
-_.-'
"
,---
",
,, ,, ,, ,, , ,
, -'
.'
"
,, ,, , .,,' ,
"
-'-, " '"
,,,-' ,
,, ,, ,, "
,, ,, ,, ,
"
,, ,, ,, ,, ,
",
,, ,,
,, ,,
"'"
"'"
.,-,-
,, ,, ,, ,, , ,-' ,"
,
.>»<'--------
www.harvardmanagementor.org
--www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
,, ,, ,, ,, ,, "
" '"
,
,.,'
....ARVARD
~ BU S I N ESS PUBLISHING
,,-'
,, ,, ,, ,, .-
,,'
-.,
HBR.ORG
Spotlight
The Decision-Driven organization 54
by Marcia w: Blenko, Michael C. Mankins, and Paul Rogers
Strategies for a • an ....In
The Productivity Paradox 64 by Tony Schwartz
Change for Change's Sake 70 by Freek Vermeulen. Phanish Pura nam , and Ranj ay Gulati
The new normal means constant change. Companies must reinvent themselves if they want to survive.
! 9
i
,i
I
ARTWORK Antony Gormley. Feeling Material XXXVIf/. :2008, 5 mm square section mild steel bar :200 x aas x 184 em Jun e 2010 Harvard Business Review 53 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
The DecisionDriven Organization Forget the org chart-the secret is to focus on decisions, not structure. by Marcia W. Blenko, Michael C. Mankins, and Paul Rogers
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
i,
-,-a
I www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
SPOTLIGHT ON STRATEGIES FOR A CHANGI NG WORLD
Many CEOs assume that organizational structure-the boxes and lines on a company's org chart-is a key determinant of financial performance. Like generals, they see their job as putting the right collection of troops in the right places. If the battle is about innovation, for example, then the CEO's duty is to create the best possible structure for channeling resources towards innovation. This belief helps explain why reorganizations are so popular with chiefexecutives. In fact, nearly half ofall CEOs launch a reorg duringtheir fi rst two years on the job. Some preside over repeated restructurings. The immediate motives vary. Some are about cu tt ing costs; others are about promoting growth. Some are about sha king up a culture; ot hers are about shifting strategic focus. Whatever the specifics, though, reorgs almost always involve making major structural changes in pursuit of better performance. Despite the fanfare that usually greets them , however, most reorga nizations fall flat. A rece nt Bain & Compa ny study of 57 reorgs between 2000 and 2006 found that fewer tha n one-th ird produced any meaningful improvement in performance. Most had no effect, and some act ually destroyed value. Chrysler, for instance, reorganized its operations three times in the three years preceding its bankruptcy and eventual combination wit h Fiat. Each time, executives proclaimed that the company was on a new pa th to profitability. Each ti me, pe rfor mance didn't improve. Webelieve that this failure is rooted in a profound misu nderstanding about the link between structure and performance. Contrary to popular belief, performance is not determined solely by the nature, scale, and disposition of resources, important t hough they may be. An army's success depends at least as much on the quality of the decisions its officers and soldiers make and execute on the ground as it does on actua l fighting power. Acorporation's st ructure, simila rly, will produce better per formance if and only if it improves the organization's ability to make and execute key decisions better and faster than competitors. It may be that the strategic priority for your compa ny is to become more innovative. In that case, the reorganization challenge is to structure the compa ny so that its leaders can make decisions that prod uce more and better innovation over time. For most companies, this req uires a fun damental rethinking of their approach to reorganization.
Instead of begi nning with an analysis of st rengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats, structural changes need to start with what we call a decision audit. The goals of the audit are to un derstand the set of decisions that are critical to the success ofyour compa ny's strategy and to determine the organizationallevel at which those decisions should be made and executed to create the most value. If you can align your organization's st ructure with its decisions, then the structure will work better, and your company's performance will improve. In this article we set out the basic principles for reorganizing around decisions. Let's begi n by taking a closer look at the link between decisions and performance.
What Drives Your Performance? Organizational st ructure is not the only determinant of performance. In some cases, it is not even particularly important. That's why changing a compa ny's structure to meet a particular strategic goal can actually exacerbate proble ms rat her than help solve them. For example, an organization struggling to innovate may try to gat her mo re and mo re creative input- and end up getting too many peopleinvolved, thereby slowing the pace of decis ion making and stifling innovation. Take the case of Yahoo. In December 2006, thenCEO Terry Semel annou nced a sweeping reorga nizat ion of the company, replacing Yahoo's produ ctaligned structure with one focu sed on users and advertiser customers. Seven product units were merged into a grou p called Audience and ano ther seven moved into a grou p called Advertisers and Publishers. A unit dubbed Technology would pro vide infrast ructure for the two new ope rating groups. The idea was to accelerate growth by exploiting economies ofscope across Yahoo's rich collection of audience and adve rtiser products. Semel's tea m had thought they'd carefully defined roles and responsibilities under the newst ructure, but decision making
56 Harvard Business Review June 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
.
THE
DECISION-DRIVEN ORGAN IZATION HBR.ORG
I dea in Brief
Reorganizations are popular with chief executives, who believe that making big structural changes will lead to better performance. But a Bain & Company study of 57 reorganizations found t hat most rec rgs had no effect-and so me actually destroyed value.
In reality, a company's structure results in better performance only if it improves the organization's ability to make and execute key decisions better and faster than competito rs. Ifyou can sync your organization's structure wit h its decisions, then the structure will work better and performance will improve.
and execution quickly became bogged down. Audience demanded tailored solutions that Technology could not provide at a reasonable cost. Advertisers and Publishers needed its own se t of uniqu e products and so was constantly competing with Audience for scarce developer time. In response, Yahoo executives created new roles and management levels to coordinate the un its. The organization ballooned to 12 layers, product development slowed as decisions stalled, and overhead costs increased. Yahoo's experience shows how a lack of attention to the decision-making process can thwart the best-intentioned reorganization and undermine performance. Ultimately, a com pany's value is no more (and no less) than the sum of the decisions it makes and executes. Its assets, capabilities, and structure are useless unless executives and managers throughout the organization make the essential decisions and get those decisions right more often than not. Our resea rch and experience confirm the tight link between performance and decisions. In 2008, we and ou r colleagues at Bain & Company surveyed executives worldw ide from 760 co mpa nies, most with revenues exceeding $1 billion, to understand how effective th ose co mpanies were at making and exec uting their critical decisions . We used the respon ses to assess decision quality (whe the r decisions proved to be right more often than not), speed (whether decisions were made faster or slower than competitors), yield (how well decisions were translated into act ion), and effort (the time, trouble, and expense req uired for each key decision). Then we calculated a composite score for each company and compared that score w ith eac h fi rm's financial performance. (See the exhibit "Rate Your Decision Effectiveness" to learn how your company com pares with our sample.) We found that decision effectiveness and financial results co rrela ted at a 95% confidence level or
To reorganize around decisions, focus on six steps. First , be clear about which decisions are most important. Second, figure out where in t he organization those decisions need to be made. Third, organize your structure around sources of value. Fourth, figure out the level of authority your decision makers need, and give it to them. Fifth, adjust ot her parts
of your organizational system to support decision making and execution. And sixth, eq uip your managers to make decisions quickly and well.
higher for every co untry, indu stry, and co mpany size in our sa m ple . Indeed, the companies in our sample that were most effective at dec ision making and execution generated average tot al shareholder re turns nearly six percentage points h igher tha n those of ot her firms. We also found that ma ny companies have enormous scope to improve their performance. Top-quintile companies score an average of 71out of100 in decision effectiveness, while companies in the other four quintiles score, on average, 30 and below. This means that the typical organization has the potential to more than double its decision effectiveness. What's more. the research revealed no strong statistical relationship between structure and performance. Survey respondents ' views about the structure oftheir company were not an accurate predictor ofeither decision effectiveness or financial results. The conclusion we draw is simple: In a reorganization, decisions rather than st ructure should be the primary focus. Let's see what that invo lves.
Conducting a Decision Audit Many reorganizations begin wit h a SWOT analysis: What are our organization's strengths, wea knesses. opportunities, and th reats? What are our resources and capabilities? What risks do we face? The idea is to determine if the company has everyt hing it needs to support its st rategy. All this sounds sensible, and in many ways it is. But the risk is that you'll end u p w ith an organization that's misaligned with your strategy, allbecause you have ignored decisions. The proper place for this type of SWOT analysis is not, in fact, as a prelude to organizationalchange but earlier, when you are de te rmining your company's strategy. A better way to begin a reo rganization is with a dec ision audit. The first step in conducti ng one is to iden tify the key dec isions you need to make and execute, given your strategy to create maximum value June 2010 Harvard Business Review 57
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
SPOTLIG HT ON STRATEGIES FOR A CHANGI NG WORLD
Quick Test Rate Your Decision Effectiveness
How do your organizat ion's decision abilities stack up against t he competition? While hardly a f ull-scale survey, this short test can give you a quick-and -dirty assessment of decision strengths and weaknesses.
I" Qua Ity
d ' Id Spee Vie
When looking back on critical decisions, we find that we chose the right course of actio n
We ma ke critical decisions
4 Most of the time 3 Some of the time 2 Infrequently 1 Never
QSCORE
4 Much faster than competitors
w e execute critical decisions as intended 4 Most of the time
3 Somewhat faste r than competitors
3 Some of the time
2 Somewhat slower than competitors
1 Never
2 Infrequently
1 Much slower tha n competitors
__
for your shareholders. The set of key decisions for a growth strategy, for instance, will be different from the set for a return-focused strategy. Of course, this exercise does not presuppose a change in strategy. It may be that the reorganization is an attempt to improvean existing strategy,in which case you'll end up with a comparison between the decisions you ought to be concentrating on and the ones you are actually making. The bigger the difference -and the greater the obstacle presented by your organizational structure-the more aggressive your reorg will need to be. The ongoing turnaround at Ford illustrates the power of explicitly delineating a company's crit ical decisions. When Alan Mulally became CEO at the automaker in 2006, the company was in d ire need of change. Ford had been losing a poi nt or more of market sha re every year since 2000 and was on the verge of collapse. But rather than change the company's structure fi rst and then worry about decisions, Mulallytook the opposite approach. He and his team outlined the decisions that we re critical to a turnaround. Only then did they begin to build the new organization around those decisions. Fixing the company's operations and restoring profitability centered on a schematic depicting Ford's critical dec isions. It spelled out the key decisions that needed to be made at each stage in Ford's value chai n, along with the infrastructure required to execute them effectively. Every week, Mulally and his team tracked their progress in ma king an d execu ting these decisions. They divested noncore brands such as Aston Martin, Jaguar, Land Rover, and Volvo; reduced the number of production platforms; began consolidating bot h suppliers and dealers; and so on. They also reorganized the company, moving from a structure based on regional business units to a global matrix offunctionsand geographies. This new structure enabled Mulally's team to make its most important decisions bett er and faster- creating global car
SSCORE
__
YSCORE
__
platforms, for instance, which had been painfully difficult under the old structure. Set in this context, the reorg made perfect sense and helped restore the company to profitability in early 2010. As you conduct your ow n decision audit, you need to consider two types ofcritical decisions: • Big, one-off decisions that individually have a significant impact . Petrochemical companies, for example, must ma ke periodic mu ltibillion -d ollar investment decision s, such as if, when, or where to build a new ethylene cracker, which is critical to production. If a compa ny builds at the wrong time, in the wrong place, or with the wro ng technology, it will have to live with the consequences for many decades. • Small, routine decisions that cumulatively have a significant impact. Amazon's continuing success can be attributed partly to a host of savvy merchan dis ing decisions, including those related to special prices and shipping disco unts, suggestions for complementary purchases, and targeted e-mail notices about new offerings. None of these dec isions carries much value in anyone instance. Cumulatively, howeve r, they can mean the difference between success and failure. Once you have identified which decisions are critical and categorized t hem, you can figure out where in the organization those decisions should be made. This requires an unbiased assessment of the benefits of scale an d coordination versus the benefits of tailoring to local needs and staying close to the customer. In which decis ions is sca le a critical factor? Which dec isions are bett er made by business units or functions? Which need coordi nat ion across many businesses? Some decisions a re fairly easy to place. Big capital-allocation decisions, for ins tance, are typically best made by the corporate center so that senior leaders can design and execute a coordinated
58 Harvard Business Review Jun e 2 010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
THE DECIS ION -D RIV EN ORGANIZATI ON HBR.ORG
Effort In making and executing critical decisions
4 We put in exactly the right amount of effo rt
3 We put in somewhat too much/too little effort 2 We put in way too much/ nowhere near enough
effort
TO tally your overall score, multiply your scores for quality (Q), speed (S), and yield (Y) to get your QSY. Next , divide your effort (E) score by 4, and multiply t he result by the QSY. If you're putting in exactly the right amount of effort, your QSV wouldn't change. But if you scored effort as a 3, then your score would be 3/4, or 75%. of t he Q5V.
Using our database, you can compare your decisio n score with the performance ranges for each benchmark qu artile. If you score over 25, for example, you are perlorm ing at the level of t he top -quart ile compan ies in our survey. Relative to our sample, your organization would appear to decide and deliver.
More than 25 · You're doing great; keep it up. 21-2 5 . Pretty good. but could be great .
16-20 · Worse than 50% of companies. Time to act. 15 or less . Major decision reboot required.
1 We're off the charts
ESCORE
__
TOTAL SC ORE [Q.
s. Y. (E f411
__
When reorganizing a company, decisions rather than structure should be the focus. portfolio strategy across the company. IT investme nts can usually be left to functions or business units. Decision placement is more of a challenge for product, customer, and channel decisions, wh ich typically involve complex trade-offs. Pricing decisions, for exa mple, need to be coordinated across customer segments and channels. Product decisions must be considered from both an internal and an external perspective. In companies wit h many different products or services, both the critical decisio ns themselves and where they should be made may vary widely across the organization. The Xerox turnaround lau nched in 2001 un der Anne Mulcahy offers a powe rful contrast to the Yahoo story. Unlike Semel at Yahoo, Mulcahy's leadership team took a decision-driven approach to the company's reorganizat ion. Team members went through every set of critical decisions Xerox needed to make and execute to fend off ba nkruptcy, and they made explicit choices about where to locate those decisions. Clarity and simplicity were the guiding principles. In the sales organization, for example, Xerox moved from a global customer structure, in wh ich sales and p ricing decisions were made by global teams organized around industry verticals, to a simpler country structure, where those decisio ns rested with local sales teams. The new structure enabled Xerox to eliminate several layers of middle management, increase local accountability, and take nearly $1 billion out ofthe company's cost structure in just two years. The simpler structure also concentra ted decisions related to the shift from analog to digital technology-critical to Xerox's success in
office products at the time-within the senior lead ership of the Product organization, whic h helped accelerate the pace of new-product introductions in this vital segme nt. The explicit focus on where decisions should be made was critical to the successful turnaround at Xerox. At the end of your audit, you may find that making and executing decisions better and faste r than competitors does n't req uire reorganization and that you can avoid the costly business of structural change altogether. If you find that you are already focused on the right set of critical decisions and you find tha t they are placed where they should be within the organization, then the source of performance problems is unlikely to be structural. Problems may stem instead from other organizational issues. Perhaps there is an incentive problem wit h the sales force. Maybeleaders place too much value on building consensus, at the expense of dec isive action. Whatever the issues, they can probably be fixed without a wholesale structural redes ign, which will take peop le's minds off the competition and may actually add toyour problems. (Seethe exhibit "Do You Really Need to Reorganize?") But for now, we'll assume that your audit does reveal that your st ruct ure needs to change. Let's look at how to go about doing that.
Building the
peeielen-cnven Structure All complex organizations must be broken down into manageable pieces to ensure that roles and responsibilities for making and executing critical decisions June 2010 Harvard Business Review 59
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
SPOTLIGHT ON STRATEGIES FOR A CHAN GIN G W ORLD
-
0~:l! Do You Really Need to Reorganize? Aco mprehensive su rvey of your orga nization can help you understand what's undermining or supporting effective decisions-and whether structure or something else is likely to be the most important issue. But this quick test can serve as an ea rty warning device.
STRUCT1.JRE
Our str ucture helps- rather than hinders-the decisions most critical to our success. 2 3 4 1 St rongty Disagree Agree more St rongly disagree more th an th an agree agree disagree
To get your total score, add up your individual scores. More t ha n 35 . You're doing g reat; keep it up. 31-35 . Good. but
room for improvement.
ROLES
Individuals understand their roles and accountability in our most critical decisions. 1 2 3 4
26- 30 ·
10 -25 . Major org
PROCESSES
transformation required .
Our processes are designed to produce effective, timely decisions and action. 1 2 3 4 I N FORMATION
The people in critical decision roles have t he information they need when and how they need it. 1 2 3 4 MEASURES& I NCENTIVES
Our measures and incentives focus people on making and executing effective decisions. 1 2 3 4 PRIORITIES
People understand their priorities clearly enough to be able to make and execute t he decisions t hey face. 1 2 3 4 DECISION STYLE
We make decisions in a style that is effective (for example. that appropriately balances inclusiveness with momentum). 1 2 3 4 PEOPLE
We put our best people in the jobs where they can have the biggest decision impact. 1 2 3 4 BEHAVIORS
Our leaders at all levels consistently demonstrate effective decision behaviors. 1 2 3 4 CULTURE
Our culture reinforces prompt. effective decisions and action t hroughout the organization. 1 2 3 4 60
Org is serious barrier to decisions.
Compare d with com panies in our data base , a score a bove 35 puts you in the top quartile-mea ning t hat your organization is pretty healthy. A score of 31 to 35 indicates room for improvement. but no immediate signs of organizational breakdown, A score of 30 or below lncrea tes that you defi nitely have some organizational challenges to add ress. If you perform at 2 or less on anyone issue, that pa rticular ailment likely needs atte ntion.
are clea r, A good way to determine what the importa nt decisions are in your com pany is to look at the sources of value in your business and then organize the mac rost ructure around them. Take the case of British Gas. a division ofthe multinational energy and utility com pany Centr ica. In 2006, faced wit h a serious pe rformance crisis, the company's new leade rship team starte d looking at the sources of val ue in its business. Managers began by examining differences in profitability by service, by geographic area, and by customer segment. They discovered that profitability and growth varied much more by customer segment than by any other variable. One segment used large amounts of gas or electricity and paid regularly through gua ranteed di rect debits. Decisions that helped the company retain these customers, such as how to handle home moves and how best to offer additional services, were most important for this segment. Asecond customer segme nt used less energy and paid regularly through a system ofprepayment cards. Here the key decisions related to controlling costs. particularly those associated with processing additional payments and with meter reading. A third segment was n't as consistent in keepi ng u p payments. For that group, the critical decisions related to managing receivables. Recognizing those di fferent so urces of value. managing director Phil Bentley decided th at the best way to structure the company was by customer segment. He established three separate businesses: Premie r Ene rgy. Energy First, and Pay-AS-YOU-Go Energy. This new structure allowed him to place accountability for decisions that directly affected customers. such as service levels, positioning, and product bund ling, in the busi ness un its. Corporate headquarters could focus on noncustomer-facing matters such as IT and finance. The alignment of structure and decisions helped British Gas improve its performance significa ntly. It redu ced custo mer attrition from abou t 20% to less than 10%. Its bad debt fell,and the business began growing for the first time in years. Ifdecision-driven reorganization were just about an audit an d, if necessary, aligning the macrostructure with the sources of value, it would be relatively easy to get your next reorg right. But the messy reality ofbusiness is that big changes need to be followed up wit h a whole host of smaller changes. In most reorgs, this stage of the process usually concentrates on assigning turfand setting out a hier-
Harvard Business Review June 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
THE DECISION-DRIVEN ORGANIZATION HBR.ORG
archy with defined repo rting lines. Once again. this approach is misguided, because it does not use decisions as the unit of analysis. Indeed. a focus on turf often devolves into horse trading: Powerful managers grab decision rights they shouldn't rea lly own while weak ones surrender rights they really should own. People end up with responsibilities that are defined either too broadly or too narrowly, given the decisions they need to make. Responsibilities that are too broad result in insufficient su pervision and limited accountability. Those that are too narrow can create needless hierarchy-too many watche rs an d too few doers-and can encourage rntcroman agement. Without a focus on decisions, these power struggles too often lead to creeping complexity in an organization's infrastructure. The energy giant BP provides an excellent example of the consequences of an overly complex microstructure. Back in 1994, BP had just a handful of geographic and customer units, wh ich were supported by a few central functions. After a period of significant merger and acquisition activity, however, the company added new geographic areas and created new functions. Spans of control narrowed, and the nu mbe r of managem ent layers increased. All of these changes increased the number of "decision nodes"- the interfaces between regions, funct ions, and layers required to make and execute important decisions-from about 500 in 1994 to roughly 10,000 in 2007. Each decision node at the company introduced a different se t of hurdles for new products. business development deals, and even options for reducing costs. The effects were predictable: Decision making and execut ion slowed, and costs mounted . In decision-driven reorganization. the challenge is to determine exactly what authority decision makers need, regardless of their organizational status, if they are to make good decisions and execute them effectively. BPsaw that the people who were best equipped to make decisions had to get too many approvals from higher-ups or from regional heads, which delayed execution. So its new chiefexecutive, Tony Hayward , launched a comprehensive simpli fication progra m designed to return decision rights to the appropriate people. The initiative elimina ted layers of middle management. centralized some operations, and reduced overhead expenses by one-third. It moved the number of decision nodes back toward a target of5.000. Both the company's decision effectiveness and its performance improved. By late 2009,
The Six Steps to Decislon-Drlven Reorganization Identify your organization's key decisions. Determine where in the organization those decisions should happen . Organize the macrostructure around sources of value. Figure out what Level of authority decision makers need. Align other eLements of the organizational system, such as incentives, information flow, and processes, with those reLated to decision making. Help managers deveLop the skills and behaviors necessary to make and execute decisions quickLy and weLL.
BP had eliminated $3 billion in costs and was turning in a profit that beat analysts' expectations by 50%. Anychange in structure may necessitate changes in decis ion roles, incentives, information flow. performance metrics, and processes. AtUD Trucks- formerly Nissan Diesel-a new strategy designed to expand UD's penetration of national accounts requ ired a reorganizat ion of the company. Local bran ch offices were combined into regions, and national accou nt teams were established. To get the most out ofthe new structure, the team at un Trucks clarified dec ision roles between the national accou nt teams and the company's Truck and Serv ice units . Measures and incentives were reset to encourage collabora tion across units and focus the sales force on key accounts. The reorga nization at un Trucks was critical. of course-the new strategy could not have been imple mented without it. But goals, processes, information, measures. and incentives also needed to be aligned to make the new structure work. Finally, you need to help managers develop the skills they need to make decisions quickly and tra nslate them into action consistently. Smart companies mesh individuals' capabilities with the organization's decision-making demands. They invest as needed to ensure that people have the skills required to be better decision makers over time. Agood example of this took place at Hospira, the $3.9 billion pharmaceutical company spun out from Abbott Laboratories in 2004. In 2008, Hospira embarked on a major change program. The program included an effort to build new dec ision capabilities across the company. The top 80 executives att e nded in novative tra ini ng workshops that showed them how to identify an organization's critical decisions and outlined Hospna's new approach to effective. efficient dec ision making and execution. Executives learned to use tools that would help them get the who, what, when. where, and how of each decision right. The workshops also helped leaders learn and adopt the specific behaviors that would be required to make the changes stick. Hospira's senior leaders began to track the company's changes in decision effectiveness at their bimonthly tea m meetings. They also began to gather survey data that could help them assess progress in building and sustain ing decision capabilities. Since 2008, CEO Chris Begley and his team have seen significant improvements in Hospira's financial and stock price performance, which they attrib ute largely to improved decision making. June 2010 Harvard Business Review 61
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
SPOTLIGHT ONSTRATEGIES FOR ACHANGI NG WORLD
HBR.ORG
Ultimately, a company's value is just the sum of the decisions it makes and executes. Adjusting to New Structures
connected arc hitecture, emerging countries, and connected business ope rations. These interlocking councils and boards have enabled Cisco to maintain its leadership position in the complex, fast-moving telecommun ications space and build on the strength of its global functional st ructure. Creating parallel decision-making authorities may appear to be in conflict with our general principles ofsimplicity and clear accountability, but we believe this approach leads to a mo re st reamlined process. Organization overlays suc h as Cisco's cou ncils and boards introduce valuable expertise tha t formal structures cannot easily accommodate. They allow fewer people to be involved in making and executing critical decisions - in effect, reducing the num ber of decision nodes.
A new strategy-or new execution of an existing strategy-can require both macrochanges and microchanges to a compa ny's structure. But any new structure will create new boundaries that people may fi nd hard to cope wit h and that may ma ke effective decision making more difficult. To get around this problem, it may be necessary to overlay your new structure with some connections that help people reach beyond those boundaries. In 2001, faced with the bursting of the dot-co m bubble, Cisco reo rganized. It moved away from the structure that had been in place for much of the company's rise to prominence- a line-of-bu siness structure based on customer segments-and pu t in place a global func tional organization. The logic was simple: Reorganizing around central funct ions would dramatically reduce the company's costs. IT'S EASYto see why so many CEOs are enticed by While the pros of this move outweighed the cons, the temptation ofreorganization. Today's corporate the company's leaders acknowledged that organiz- structures can be inordinately complex. Some date ing around centralized functions could cause Cisco from a day when the demands ofthe business world were quite different than they are today. Simplificato lose customer focus and intimacy. To prevent that, the leadership team has created tion, alignment, modernization, a new vision ofwhat over the past several years a series of corporate coun- the organization should look like- and all of it accils and boards directly under the company's ope rat- complished with the stroke ofa pen. But to focus exing committee, Cisco'smost senior decision-making clusively on structure is to confuse means with ends body. These cross-functional groups formulate and and to assume a connection that may not exist. The evaluate alternatives for each of the company's ma- reo rgs that work best, such as those at Ford, Xerox, jor strategic initiat ives and then make recom menda- and Cisco, focus first on the organization's critical tio ns to senior managemen t. We find that the pro- decisions. Then they build an organization that can cess accelerates decision making without sacrificing make and execute those decisions better and faster decision quality. The structural overlay of cou ncils than the competition. The result is what executives and boards also seems to help funct ional leaders col- always seek from reorgs yet so seldom accomplish: laborate and make effective decisions about budgets improved performance. " HBR Reprint Rl006B and resources. Today, those teams are operati ng at full steam. Marc ia W. SIen ko (
[email protected]) Five "segment councils," for instance, support deci- " ..., leads Bain & Company 's Global Organization Practice sion ma king and execution for the company's enter- and is a pa rtne r in th e firm's Boston office. Michael C. prise, commercial, service provider, small business, Ma nkins (michael.man kinS@bai n.com) leadsBain's and consumer segments. Boards organized around Organization Practice in the Americas and is a partner in San Francisco . paul Rogers {
[email protected])isa specific market opportu nities, such as collaboration pa rtner who lead s Bain's London office; he formerly led and virtualization within the enterpr ise segment, Bain's Global Organization Practice . They are coauthors of develop tailored strategies and oversee execution. the fort hcoming book Deci de and Deliver: Five Steps to Breakthrough Performance in Your Organization (Harvard Finally, fou r cross-segme nt councils focus on the Business Press, 1010) . Portions of this article are adapted arca ne but cri tica l topics of e merging solutions, from the book. 62. Harvard Business Review June 2.010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
Our t hree tiers of com prehensive leaders hip programs cu ltivate success at all leve ls. Eac h offering bri ngs together globa l b usiness leaders to turn visionary ideas into best manag ement p ractices that deli ver results. Email ctpehbs.edu to receive deta iled information . Global Perspect ives. Tangible Business Results. www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
HAR VARD
BUS I N E S S SCHOOL EX E C UT I VE EDU C AT I O N
SPOTLIGHT ON STRATEGIES FOR A CHANGI NG WORLD
Spotlight
, AI\TWORK Antony Gormley, Capacitor, 2 1. Mild steel tubes: 12 mm (old), 5.5 mm (il ). Mild steel rod: 5 mm x various lengths.
Body form : 190 x 48 x 35 cm. Fully extended work : 271 x 242 x 229cm.
-
64 Harvard Business Review June 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
HBR.ORG
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
-----.J~L___,
_
Ton y sehwartl: (tony@ theene rgyprojec t.com)
is the president and CEO of the Energy Project and the author of The Way We're Working Isn't Working: The Four Forgotten Needs That Energize Great Performa nce (The Free Press, 2010). written with Jean Gomes and Cathe rine McCart hy.
The Productivity Paradox How Sony Pictures Gets More Out of People by Demanding Less by Tony Schwartz
I !•
,a
I
THE WAY most of us work isn't working. Study after study has shown that companies are experiencing a crisis in employee engagement. A2007Towers Perrin survey of nearly 90,000 employees worldwide, for instance, found that only21% felt fully engaged at work and nearly 40% were disenchanted or dise ngaged. That negativity has a direct impact on the bottom line. Towers Perrin found that compa nies with low levels of employee engagement had a 33% ann ual decline in operating income and an 11% annual decli ne in earnings growth. Those wit h high engagement, on the other hand, reported a 19% increase in operating income and 28%growth in earnings per share. Nearly a decade ago, the Energy Project, the compa ny I head , began to address wo rk per forma nce and the problem of employee disengagement. We believed that burnout was one of its leading causes, and we focu sed al mos t exclus ively on helping in dividuals avoid it by managing their energy, as opposed to their time. (See "Manage Your Energy, Not Your Time," HBR October 2007.) Time, after all, is finite. By contrast, you can expan d your personal energy and also regularly renew it. Once people understand how their supply of available ene rgy is influenced by the choices they make, they can lea rn new strategies that inc rease
the fuel in their tanks and boost their productivity. If people define precise times at which to do highly speci fic activities, these new behaviors eve nt u ally become automatic and no longer require conscious will and discipline. We refer to them as rituals. They're simple but powerful. They include practices such as shutti ng down your e-mail for a cou ple of hours duri ng the day, so you can tackle important or complex tasks without d istracti ng interruptions, or taking a daily 3 PMwalk to get an emotional and me ntal breat her. What we failed to fully ap preciate in our early work was that once we finished our sessions with employees and sent them back into the work place, they often ran into powerful organizational resistance to the very principles and practices we'd taught the m. Westill believe that enduring organizational change is possible only ifindividuals alter their attitudes and behaviors fi rst . But we've come to understand that it's not possible to generate lasting cult ural change wit hout deeply involving an organization's senior leadership. In this art icle, we'll describe the trans formation we helped initiate at Sony Pictures Enter tainment, a company th at has embraced e nergy-building and -renewing rituals at all levels. Based in Culver J une 2010 Harvard Business Review 65
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
SPOTLIGHT ON STRATEGIES FOR A CHANGI NG WORLD
City, California, Sony Pictures produces, markets, and distributes movies and TVshows. So far, more than 3,000 of the company's 6,300 employees worldwide have gone th rough our energy-management program. This sum mer we'll reach another 1,700 in Europe, Singapore, and Latin America. To date, the reaction to the program has been overwhelmingly positive. Eighty-eight percent of participants say it has made them more focused and productive. More than 90% say it has helped them br ing more energy to work every day. Eighty-four percent say they feel better able to manage their jobs' dema nds and are more engaged at work. Sony's leaders believe that these changes have helped boost the compa ny's performance. Despite the recession, Sony Pictures had its most profitable year ever in 2008 and one of its highest reve nue years in 2009 (though an industrywide collapse in DVD sales forced the company to do a round oflayoffs early in 2010). Aswe have done at many other organiza tions, we encouraged Sony to make two fundamental shifts in the way it manages employees. The first was to stop expecti ng people to operate like computers-at high speeds, continuously, runn ing multiple programs at the same time-and to recognize that human beings perform bes t and are most prod uctive when they alternate between pe riods of intense focus and intermittent renewal. The second was to move from trying to get more out ofemployees and instead to invest in systematically meeting their four core needs, so they're fueled and inspired to bring more of themselves to work every day. These four core needs are physical healfh (achieved through nu trition, sleep, daytime renewal, and exercise), emotional well-being (which grows out offeeling apprecia ted and valued), mental clarity (the ability to focus intensely, prioritize, and think creatively), and spiritual significance (which comes from the feeling of serv ing a mission beyond generating a profit).
Changing Attitudes at the Top The cochairs of Sony Pictures, Michael Lynton an d AmyPascal, were the catalysts for change. Their goal was to create a highly engaged, employee-friendly, h igh-performan ce culture, and they we re willing to beg in the process by looki ng at how their own leadership behaviors affected their staff's energy. The two leaders authorized me to interview their direc t reports and dose colleagues in the industry. I also spoke wit h their friends and eve n their family members. Afterward, I sat down wit h each of
them, shared the feedback, and discussed how they wanted to respond. Through this process, Lynton , who is by nature introverted and private, discovered that his people we ren't sure what he was feeling. To show that he appreciated their good wor k, he instituted a new ritual of calling and writing notes to employees to recognize them for their accomplishments, which boosted their emotional energy. The feedback that most moved Pascal focused on her reluctance to engage in conflicts both inside and outside the organization. It turned out that her failure to be direct made her team members feel uncertain, whic h drai ned their energy. Pascal decided to create a ritual to help herself be more direct: Wheneve r she found herselfin an uncomfortablesituation, she would ask herself a simple question: What is the right thing to do here? She de fi ned "the right thing" as wha tever would se rve Sony Pictures bes t, even if it made her un easy in the shor t term. Often, that meant she had to say no to someone she liked and respected and didn't want to offend . Difficult as this was, Pascal discovered that people appreciated her new directness, eve n when she did n't provide the response they sought, and that she herself felt bette r afte rward. She made a particularly wrenching decision, for example, to pull the plug on Moneyba/l, a film to be based on the Michael Lewis book, even though she had enormous respect for its director, Steven Soderbe rgh. "I'd still work with Steven in a minute," she said at the time, "but in te rms of th is project, he wanted to do the fi lm in a different way than we did." leaders can easily underestimate how their attitudes and behaviors affect the energy levels ot thelr teams. Because energy is contagious, both the quality and quantity of a leader's energy can drain or galvanize a team. In addition, the leader sets the tone for the organization. If people see their company president making it a practice to ta ke a walk every afternoon, t hey feel safer ta king time out for t heir own efforts. To measure your own energymanagement effectiveness as a leade r and get more tips on how to increase it, go to th eene rgyproject, com/ hbr.
Getting Buy-In at the Divisional Level The next step was to get Sony's div ision heads on board. Lynton, Pascal, an d their top 15 executives went through our training, which focused on how specific energy-manage ment practices could improve bo th their personal effectiveness and their leadership. They identified where they were n't fully meeting their energy needs and then created a series of pe rsonal rituals to address problem areas. For example, Jeff Blake, Sony's head of marketing and d istribution, wanted to be more awa re of his emotions . After going through oUT program, he realized that anger and frustration often sapped his energy and had a negative impact on his colleagues. To manage his feelings better, he made it a practice to step away and take walks around the studio lot whenever he felt his frustrat ion begin to mount.
66 Harvard Business Review June 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
THE PRO DUCTIVITY PARAD OX HBR.ORG
Idea in Brief Hu ma n beings don't work li ke compute rs; t hey ca n't o pe rate at high speeds cont inuously, running mult iple progra ms at once.
People pe rform at their peak whe n th ey alternat e between pe riods of intense focus a nd int ermittent renewal.
Employees ca n in crease t heir effectiveness by practicing simple rituals that refuel th eir en ergy, such as t aking a daily walk t o get an e mot iona l breat her or tu rning off e -mail at prescribed times so t hey can concent rat e.
If companies a llow a nd encou rage employees to create and st ick to such rit ua ls, th ey will be rewa rded with a more engaged, prod uct ive, and focused workforce.
Gumpert set aside an uninterrupted 60 to 90 minutes each morning to focus on his top two or three priorities. This ritual helped him relax and get grounded and the n think through more dearly how he wanted to respond. Keith LeGoy. who heads international television dis tribution. had a similar goal. He made it a ritual to take a deep breath rathe r than react immediately when someone said something that irritated him . Once he felt calmer, he made a point of asking himself. How can 1approach this person more collaboratively to get what I want? To improve his ability to focus single-mindedly on d ifficult tasks, Gary Martin, who head s studio operations, established a ritual of turning off his e-mail al together at certain points duri ng the day. David Bishop, who head s home en tertainment, made a commitment to ignore e-ma il while talking to people on the phone and instead devote his full attention to whatever he was doing at any given time. And rew Gumpert, who heads business affairs and administration for Columb ia Pictures, created a new eve ning ritual to ma ke sure he prioritized his work effectively: For five minutes or so after he got home from wor k, he reflected on the two or three most important tasks for the next day. When he arrived at the office the next morning, he set aside an uninterrupted 60 to 90 minutes to focus on those priorities, rather than simply respondi ng to e-mails or putting out whatever fi res had flared up the night before. My colleagues and 1also worked with the senior team to create rituals to promote better collabo ration. The atmosphere at their weekly meetings had always bee n superficially collegial and cordial, bu t
most of the division heads were fiercely protective of information and reluctant to share much with one ano ther. They resisted input from any execut ive outside their areas of expertise. The friction that resulted was counterproductive. Prodded by Pascal and Lynton, the team members institu ted a ritual aimed at pro moting more open dialogue and a greater sense of trust. They agreed to set a dear agenda in advance ofeach week's meeting and to focus only on key strategic issues. All agreed to participate actively in discussions, offer suggestions, and close ranks aroun d decisions made at the meeting. Team members also committed to making decisions based on what best served the company as a whole rather than their personal agendas. To encourage honesty. the group members also came u p with a ritual they named "Code." Saying that single word became a way to surface unspoken feelings and concerns without attack or disparagement. As Pascal explains it, "code" came to serve as shorthand for "I really want to know what you're feeling, so be straight with me." Pascal and Lynton fou nd this ritual par ticularly useful in their relationship. Pascal gives this exam ple: Say that she'd asked Lynton to attend a marketing meeting that she was run ning, and at the last minute he canceled because something else came up. Because both of them were eager to accommodate the ot her, he might say to he r, "Just go ahead without me," and she might say, "OK, fine." Later. Pascal would find he rself won deri ng if Lynton was June 2010 Harvard Business Review 67
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
SPOTLIGHT ON STRATEGIES FOR A CH ANG ING W ORLD
How the To Sets the Tone As a leader, you have myriad opportunities to set the right context for your employees to replenish their energy. It's all about providing examples for others and creating a safe environment. A few dos and don'ts: Take back your lunch.
Cultivate • • creattvrty,
Share your • passion.
Feeling valued is our core emotional need. Write a note of app reciation to someone who works for you once a week. Be very specific about what it is th at you value,
Set aside an informal, relaxing space at work t hat is devoted to creative thinki ng and brainstorming, Schedule a regular t ime- at least once every two weeks-when colleagues gather to brainstorm new ideas, discuss Longerterm projects, or set strategy.
communicate what you stand for and what your larger mission is, beyond profit. Ift hat isn't clear to you, set aside time to reflect on it. What is it that gets you up in the morning? What's the value you're trying to add in the world? Why should others feeLpassionate about doing it , too?
Avoid conflict.
Try to do multiple things at the same time.
Be self-absorbed.
Communicate
your values.
Get away from your desk, and preferably out of the office altogether, so that you come back to work more focused and fueted to face the rest of t he day. It will enco urage your employees to do t he same.
Ignoring a difficult situation typically does more harm than communicat ing directly and honestly about it, The keyto a successfu l conversation is not to assume you're right but to enter into it in a spirit of open ness and curiosity.
Make an effort to give people your fuLL focus and try to listen wit hout inte rrupting. You know you've succeeded if you're capable of repeating back what you just heard.
truly OK about missing the meeting. He might wonde r if Pascal was really fine with his not attending her meeting. Both of them disliked conflict; neither wou ld be inclined to mention an y concerns, "Code" gave th em a simple way toaddress th e issue direc tly. "It's about telling the truth, even when it's hard," Pascal explains, "That's how yo u build a culture of tru st. Today we do n't need to say 'code' m uch anymore:' The ne xt step was to take these ideas and practices to th e 1250r so direct reports ofthesenior team. We also con tinued to meet with the senior leaders for one day every three months to help deepen and ex tend their leadership an d team rituals. At one of
It's easy to make it aLL about you. Try to step beyond your own immediate needs to better serve the needs of those you lead.
those meetings, e-mail became a focus ofdiscussion. The team had already agreed to a ritua l that banned the check ing or sending ofe-mail durin g meetings. A remaining issue was the expectation that team memo bets would reply to e-mail in the evenings and all through the weekends. The result was that they felt perpetually on calL Their inability to let go of wor k was a source of resen tment and an ene rgy d rain for many ofthe leaders. Event ually, th e team agreed on an 8 AM to 8 PM weekday limit on the hours dur ing wh ich they were expected to respond to e-mails from one another. Outside those hours, th ey were free not to respond. The agreement was that ifanyone had an urgen t rea-
68 Harvard Business Review J une 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
THE PRODUCTIVITY PARADOX HBR.ORG
son to reach a colleague, he or she would pick up the phone and call the person. "The expectations have really changed;' says David Hendler, Sony Pictures' CFO. "I'm no longer on my BlackBerrywhen I'm with my wife and kids, and they appreciate that . It also drives more energy at work because I'm not drained or distracted by thinking, 'Oh, I shou ld be spending time with my family.'"
Spreading Energy Management Through the Ranks Once we'd taken the most se nio r leaders through our program, Pascal and Lynton deci ded to cascade it down through the company. Sony co nverted a soundstage into a space where we taught the staffin groups of25 or so, and offered fitness and nutrition consultations, yoga classes, and massage sessions, all as part ofour energy-renewal training. Several co mpanywide initiatives now help employees boost their energy in the four core areas. Sony Pictures has begun subsidizing healthy meals and a salad bar at a new on-stte restaurant that's open to all employees. A dietician is on staffand available to everyone for consultat ions. Sony has also bu ilt a new, fully eq uipped gym and created a large grassy
You build a culture of trust by telling the truth, even when it's hard. place. At all levels ofthe company, employees feel more comfortable taking breaks, turni ng offe-mail at certai n times, and going to the gym during the day. "This has been about believing that the culture of the company is as important as the product;' Pascal explains. "We're not fully there, but we now have a common lang uage and shared principles, and this experience has been enormously bond ing. The culture we' re creating is the adhesive. It's what holds the co mpany together and ma kes you nimble and flexible enough that you're ready for whatever hits you, no matter what's happening in the marketplace. There's no question that this investment we've made in our employees has energized and mot ivated them and helped us stay strong in the midst of very tough HBR Reprint Rl006C times." 0 r-'
commons area where people can hang out and relax. To help employees recharge themselves on a spintual level, the company now offers its employees paid time off each month to volunteer their services to nonprofits and orga nizes specific volunteer opportunities for them. For Pascal and many other leaders, one of the most powerful shifts has been the adoption of a common language around energy and people's core needs. Words and phrases such as "renewal break," "rituals;' "triggers," and "Is that a fact or a story you're telling me?" have become part ofeveryday dialogue. "That triggered me" essentially means "What you said really pushed my emotional buttons." At the same time it's a way for people to acknowledge their own responsibility for their reactions. "Is that a fact or a story?" is a way to remind peo ple that they have a choice about how to interpret a given set offacts, and that it often pays to try to view those facts through a more positive and forgivi ng lens. Employees are also much more attuned to how their energy states are influencing their performance. To help colleagues realize how they're co ming across under stress, they'll as k, "What energy zone are you in?" Simply raising people's awareness can allow them to take back control oftheir emotions and move into a more positive
_
r -
"atec kaerry fight!" June 2010 Harvard Business Review 69
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
Tusciaelecta: Arte Conrempora n San Casciano Water Tower, Italy, ~oo2/wo3
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
,
HBR.ORG
Freek Vermeulen (
[email protected]) is an associate professor at t endon eusness SChool.
,,
Phanish Puranam (
[email protected]) is a professor at London Business School, where he codireets th e Aditya Birla India centre.
Ranjay Gulati (rgulati@ hbs.edu) is the Jaime and Josefina Chua Tiampo Professor at Harvard Business School.
Even successful corporations have to shake things up to stay ahead of the competition. by Freek Vermeulen , Phanish Puranam, and Ranjay Gulati
Change for Change's Sake
disputes that firms have to make organizatio nal changes wh en the business environment de mands them. But the idea that a firm might want cha nge for its own sake ofte n provokes skepticis m. Why inflict all that pain if you don't have to? That is a dangerous attitude. Acompany periodically needs to shake itself up, regardless of the competitive landscape. Even ifthe external enviro nment is not changing in ways that demand a response , the internal environment probably is. The human dynamics within an organ iza tion are constantly shifting-and require the organization to change along with them. Over time, informal networks mirror the formal st ructure, which is how silos develop. Restructuring gets people to start forming new netNO ONE
June :1010 Harvard austness Review 71 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
SPOTLIGHT ON STRATEGIES FOR A CHAN GIN G WO RLD
works, making the organ ization as a whole more creative. It also disrupts all the routines in an organization tha t collectively stifle innova tion and adaptability. Finally, restructuring breaks up the outdated power structures that may be quietly misdirecting a company's resource allocation. All these processes-silo formation, the accretion ofdeadening routines, and the emergence of corporate baronies- take place all the time. But whe n everything is going well, you tend not to notice them, just as many seemingly fi t people don't realize that their arteries are dangerously dogged . We present here a simple questionnaire that can se rve as a kind of cholesterol test for your company, enabling you to see if your regimen needs minor or major adjust-
When and How to Change
Fostering Communication SOLUTION
Use informal networks to compensate for th e limits of th e formal struct ure Be prepared to repeat t he process again and again
Building Agility SOLUTION
Expose peopte t o new aspects of t heir tasks and opportunities for collaboration Be prepared to accept a constant state of mild disruption
Breaking Up Entrenched Interests SOLUTION
Some groups doing critical work have trouble getting the resources they need; resources are concentrated in a few powerfuL groups
Change t he dimension along which resources are allocated Be pre pared to disenfranc hise and even lose ce rtain people
ments. We begi n, thou gh, by looking at the ways that unhealthy structures and patterns can build up, threatening your fi nn's healt h.
The Formation of Silos Most com panies and business units are organized aro und a single criterion-be it function , product, geography, or market. The problem with this is tha t communication and collaboration tend to become trap ped in functional, product, geographic, or othe r silos. As a result, a fu nctionally organized fi rm, for instance, may be slow to recognize product opportunities, while a product-oriented finn may find itself du plicating work. In theory, the solution is to organize as a matrix in order to force interaction across dimensions. But matrix orga nizations are n otoriou sly difficu lt to manage because they blur accounta bility and slow down decision making. Abetter solution, we submit, is to periodically reorient the organization around a different criterion. When a firm reorga nizes in this way, the old networks and culture do not suddenly vanish; employees often maintain their old patterns of interaction for quite a wh ile, as first observed by professors Jackson Nickerson and Todd Zenger of Washington University. So, at least for the near term, employees cooperate along both informal and formal networks. As a consequence, the fi rm gets the best of bot h worlds. Cisco Syste ms is a case in point. From 1997 to 2001, Cisco was organized into three units, representing three lines of business, each focused on a disti nct customer type. Each u nit had its ow n marketing, sales, and R&D orga niza tions. Employees typically worked and had most of their interactions within th eir units. In a major reshuffle following the company's first eve r loss, in 2001, Cisco was reorganized by function. This included the creation ofa centralized R&Dgroup and 11 subgroups to promote more rapid and costeffective technical innovation. In this new structure, engineers who had worked in one of the three units could exchange ideas and collaborate on product develo pment wit h their peers across the com pany. Cisco undertook these changes to foster economies of scale and to st reamli ne an increasingly overla pping prod uct offering. Many feared , however, that the centralized R&D group would lose touch with customers. The fear proved un fou nded - in large part, we believe, because of the strength ofthe old networks and of Cisco's customer-oriented culture.
72 Harvard Business Review June 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
CHANGE FOR CH ANGE'S SAKE
_ _-l_
AseemingLy healt hy, wellperforming company can be more vuLnerabLe than you might think because of a buildup of corporate cholesterol: natural human dynamics that Limit communication, creat ivity, and efficient resource allocation.
When it came to develop ing se rvices and products for customers, it seemed that people still picked up the phone or met with former colleagues to develop optimal, cross-tech nology solutions. Of course, forma l structure and informal networks and culture eventually realign. Over ti me, people have fewer inte ractions wit h their old contacts, and once again their p rimary interactions occur in a silo. The fi rm's management may decide to revisit its organizat ional structure again. That is precisely what Cisco seemed to be doing in 2004, wit h the crea tion of three Business Councils: crossfunctional and cross-technology senior management groups that were meant to be, as one ofthe chairs put it, "the voice of the customer," providing feedback on Cisco's strategy, products, and services. They also represented a part ial revers ion to the old structureeach cou ncil focused on a particular customer type.
The Deadening Impact of Routine Communicat ion and collaboration are not the only victims oforganizational stability.The longer things are done a particu lar way, the harder it is to ada pt when markets sh ift. Worse, the less people in organizations explore and search for new opportunities, the less capable they are ofdoing so. AsJames March of Stanford University famously explained: Exploitation (doing what works today)drives out exploration (seeking out risky but potentially valuable new ways of doing things). Clearly, breaking up silos in the ways we've just described will help an organization avoid getting trapped in its routines. But there's a danger to relying on just one kind of cha nge-which itself can become rout ine. For years Hewlett -Packard oscillated between the centralization of functions, such as sales and marketing and product development, and their subsequen t decentralization into prod uct groups. These periodic alterations initially yielded
Rather than wait for the heart attack to strike, executives should consider changing their fi rm's st ructures, rewards, and processes whiLe performance is still good.
HBR.ORG
Surveying the workforce can help executives determine how urgent t he need is for change and what ki nd of changes to conte mplate. Companies that ta ke charge of change in this way are high performers and popular places to work.
benefits but eventually became a familiar process; exec ut ives got used to simply switching from one set of routines (what they were just doing) to another (what they had been doi ng five yea rs ago). They ended up exchanging one set of deficiencies for ano ther. Ultimately, the company's performance suffered. For that reason, we advise companies to vary the types of change th ey make and the details of their change efforts, as summarized in the exhibit "A Regimen for Change." One year, for exam ple, you might wa nt to emphasize individual rather than group performance in the compensation system. Another year you might rearrange office space so that people in a business uni t are grouped by function instead of customer segment, an d then change back a few years later. Jeffrey Immelt an d his successor, Joe Hogan , took just such an approach to change duri ng thei r respect ive spells as CEO of GE Healthcare (formerly
There's a danger to relying on just one kind of change-which itself can become routine. GE Medical Systems). Following Jack Welch's decision to increase the company's focus on services and customers, Immelt embarked on a series ofchanges aimed at furt hering those goals. In 1997, Immelt restr uc tured GE Healthca re arou nd three geographic centers, a move that combined equipment and service. When Hogan took over, he restructured GEHagain almost immediately, moving service to a new global organizat ion, GE Healthcare Services. Subsequently, the president of June 2010 Harvard Business Review 73
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
SPOTLIGHT ON STRATEGIES FOR A CHA NGI NG WORLD
Healthcare Services, Paul Mirabella, initiated several other changes to reconnect equipment and se rvice. This included the creation of two positions: Enterprise General Managers (EGMs), who looked after major accounts, and Enter prise Development Executives (EDEs), who were tasked with building customer partnerships. Mirabella also altered reporting Jines and shifted the incentive system from a focus on past performance toward a forward -looking mix of indicators. You might think that all this turmoil and variation would cause problems. In fact, the changes enabled GEH to develo p its se rvice business with great success. In 200 4, the new sales organization secured en terprise con tracts with a total val ue of$ l.l billion. In the following year, the new EDEs wo n partnership opport unities wit h a total contract value of $t.2billion.
A REGIMEN FOR CHANGE Companies that change before they have to don't undergo the painful, wholesa le reorganization and restr uctu ring that characterize many large fi rms. In undertaking periodic change initiatives. it's importan t to vary the focus by choosing a different categorystructure. rewards. or processes-and zeroing in on a different aspect for eac h round of change.
STRUCTURE
The Emergence of Entrenched Interests If you avoid making changes for too long, a third problem emerges: Companies gradually become seriously inefficient at allocating resources. The more resources a particular unit acquires, the mo re it can acquire. At first, a unit's power may accurately reflect its importance, bu t over time that power may no longer be justified. The company may be better off assigning a larger proportion of its resources elsewhere. Most com panies faced wit h that problem tinker at the edges, perhaps establishing cross-unit teams, initiating a centralized corporate "fund" to subsidize cross-unit collaborative projects, or creating specific integrator functions (which invariably tum out to be very frustrating jobs). But executives at a powerful business unit who are judged primarily by that unit's performance may not tu rn u p for meetings wit h other u nits and may be late providing information and ot her resources to them. By the time they do anything, the opportunity to strengthen the weaker uni t might well have passed. And as long as the powerful executives deliver on their primary obligations, it's unlikely anyone assessing them will really care. If gro ups have become this strong, you are going to have to initiate fairly dramatic organizational changes to improve matters. You may even need to disband the groups entirely. As long as they exist, eve n if they have been stripped of some authority, their influe nce will hamper progress and renewal. Given the magnitude of change required, the firm
How is your business organized? • Funct ion • Geogra phy • Custo mer type • Produ ct
should be prepared for the possibility that some individuals will leave. Yet this may be necessary- or even des irable -to enable the creation of a new balance within the firm. Consider Jones Lang LaSalle, a globa l commercial real estate mana gement company. JLL was organized into three divisions: the Tenant Representation Group, Corporate Property Services, and Project and Development Services , aimed respectively at leasing, commercial property management, and the provision of se rvices related to the development of new buildings. Theentirecompany revolved arou nd the three divisions, employees generally spent their entire careers withi n one of them, and all company metrics focused on unit measures. The most influential individuals in the compa ny were the three unit heads, who made important decisions on their own. The trouble was tha t the uni ts were not equally strong in specific geographic markets. When one unit was weak in a particular ma rket, the other two sometimes had trouble se rv ing corporate clients who wanted all three se rvices within it. Top man agement had long recognized the shortcomings of the entrenched power structure, but the autonomy of the units was so firmly established that each had limited success in persuading the others to invest in certain geographies. It was difficult to get them to collaborate to develop the fast-growing and profi table market for the provision of integrated se rvices to large mu ltinational firms. Each unit viewed the others as an intrusion and typically collaborated only when it was in the un it's own best interest. The scale of the missed opportun ities became apparent in 2002, when top management created a local organization, se parate from the units, aimed solely at New York City. Withi n a year, the com mercial real estate managed by JLL in New York City had grown nearly 25%, to more than 30 million square feet, ma king it the third-largest commercial property manager in the metropolitan area. In response to the success of this experiment and to the gaps in local expertise elsewhere, the company's incom ing CEOin 2005, ColinDyer, decided to replace the three units with a new st ructure organized around clients and markets: The former handled relationships with large clients, and the latter handled one-off' transactions in large metropolitan areas. In the su bsequent two years, JLL's share price tripled. The structural changes were n't costless. Some senior executives left when their authori ty, budgets, and number ofdirect reports declined sharply. More-
74 Harvard austness Review June 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
CHANGE FOR CH A NGE'S SAKE HBR.ORG
ASSESSMENT
A Corporate Cholesterol Test Distribute th is questio nnaire to aU your co mpany's ma nagers from t ime t o time. Res pondents s hould a nswer with a simple yes or no. To ensu re honest a nswers, t ake steps to p reserve responden ts' anonymity.
""'AL SCOIII 0-1 VIIANIWIIII There's flO need for change just yet.
1-' VIIANIWIIII II's the perfect time for a change. 1 -11.VUANSWIIll
You're late already: your company needs substantial change.
The quality of communication and collaboration Do em ployees interact only wit h people from th eir own group? VIN Are there strong s ubcult ures th at a lign with business groups or divisions? YIN Are there breakdowns in co mmun ication caused by th e formation of silos? YIN Has co llaborat ion between groups decreased over th e past fi ve years? VIN
II!i!i!D
The capacity to adapt Are ma ny people unco mfortable with change? VIN Do people and groups operate according to well-established rout ines? VIN Has it been a long time since your fi rm developed a significant new reve nue st ream? YIN Has th e perce ntage of reve nue from new streams decreased over th e past five yea rs? VIN
II!i!i!D
The balance of power among groups Do influential groups or ind ividuals use most of the co mpany's resources? VIN Is it difficu lt for people outside th e com pany's central group to obtai n resources? VIN Do influen t ial groups or ind ividuals imp ed e decision making? VIN Have t he groups or individ uals th at were influe ntial fi ve years ago extended their influence? YIN
II!i!i!D
over, the transition, like most changes, was time consuming and took the best part ofa year of top management attention. Yet, as onesenlor executive, who saw his number ofdirect reports reduced from 1,800 to two, commented at the time, "What's really good is, we operate better as a division. There is more ofa sense of team. There were always bottlen ecks, and now there are fewer. The restructuring never would have hap pened in the past because I wouldn't have let it. Everybody was preserving the silos, right?" He remains with l LL and ha s watched the com pany's performance soar.
Knowing When to Change Let's suppose that your company is performing well; there's nothing obviously wrong with your bu siness mode l, and Wall Street seems to be happy. Should you continue with your existing diet and exercise regime n, or do you need to contemplate some lifestyle changes? To help you make that determination, we've developed a simple questionnaire, intended for all
senior managers, that can help you get a handle on whether your company's ne tworks have become too stable, whether your employees are falling into unquestioned routines, or,worse, whether powerful executives are chan neling investme nt resources into yesterday's busi ness activities. The questionnaire, whic h we present in the exhibit "A Corporate Choleste rol Test," helps you decide whether it is time to redesign the organization, what kind ofchange to make, and what the scale of that change should be. Each "yes" answer is wor th one point. If you score less than th ree poi nts, your organization doesn't need to change right now. If you score from three to seven, you need to contemplate at least one change soon. And ifyou score more than seven, your need is urgent and probably large scale. To determine what kind of changes you need to make, look at your total in each category. If your highest score is in the first section, then you need to contemplate changing the basis on which the company is organized (suc h as product or function). If you June 2010 Harvard Business Review 75
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
SPOTLIGHT ON T$TRATEGIES FOR A CHANGING W ORLD
HBR .ORG
Periodic changes help companies avoid coronary-inducing reorganization. score most in the second section, you need to make Companies that take the initiative with change in sure that your next change is different from your last the ways we've described will, on the whole, avoid one. If you score high in the final section, then you the coronary-inducing bursts o f massive reo rganeed to make multiple cha nges all at once in order niza tion and restructuring that characterize many large fi rms. Even if they do have to undergo radical to shake up the organizat ion. You can refine this questionnaire by, for example, change, they will be better prepared to survive it. translating the questions into a set of propositions, As Alfred West, foun der and chief executive of the to which respondents indicate their level of agree- asset ma nagement company SEI, puts it: "Change me nt on a scale of, say, one to five. The broad er is not easy, [but] you can't dodge it. It is with you. poin t is that your employees' pe rceptions and ob - And YOU'd better embrace it." West is a serialchanger, servations are generally a good lead ing indicator of constantly tweaking SEI 's structure, rewards, and whether corporate cholesterol is building up in the business processes. Yet despite the organizational organization. Complaints about lack of coope ration uncertainty and disruption this entails, SEI has conand powerful exec utives and units are staple wa- sistently posted earnings growth of 40% per year tercooler topics. There isn't a company in existence and an an nual average return of28%, while featur whose employees aren't quick to complain when tug repeatedly on Fortune's list ofBest Companies to st ructures, rewards, and processes start getting in Work for in America. '" the way of doing a good job. HBR Reprint Rl006D
7
/'
-
<
..........- .
--
"I'm struggling to find that ideal work-work balance." 76 Harvard Business Rev iew June 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
AVAILABLE AT BOOKSELLERS ACROSS INDIA
YOUR GU DE TO BUS N ESS STRAT EGY AND EXE CUT ON N EMERG NG MARK ETS Interested in emerging markets. but not sure where t o focus your efforts?
, www.hbr.org/books
The n Winning in Emerging Markets is a must read fo r you-and a critical tool fo r your business.
-HARVARD
In t he book , rerun Khanna and Kri shna G. satepu outline a practical framework for
developing emerging market strategies based not on broad catego rical defin itions
like geography, but on a structural understan d ing of how these markets really work. Actionable, fiel d-tested, and full of com pany examples, Winning in Emerging Markers is your guide to t ailo ring and executing your company's strategy in market s
from Brazil to India- and beyond.
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
~ BUS I N ESS Press
AreVoua • • • Leaders at your company are constantly wondering that about you, whether they own up to it or not. Here's how to get them to answer yes. by Douglas A. Ready, Jay A. Conger, and Linda A. Hill
www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
HBR.ORG
Douglas A. Ready (dready @icedr.org) is a visiting professor of organizational behaviorat London Business SChool and the founder and president of ICEDR. a global talentmanagement research center in Lexington. Massachusetts.
Jay A. Conger is the Henry R. Kravis Research Professor in Leadership Studies at Claremont McKenna COllege and a visiting professor of organizational behavior at London Business School.
o rne employees are m o r e tale nted t ha n ot hers. That's a fact of organizational life that few executives and HR managers would dis pu te. The more debatable point is how to treat t he people who appear to have the highest potential. Opponents of specia l treatment argue that all employees are talented in some way and, therefore, all should receive equal opportunities for growt h. Devoting a disproportionate amount of energy and resources to a select few, their thinking goes, might cause you to overlook the potential contributions of the many. But the disagreemen t doesn't stop there. Some executives say that a company's list of high potent ials- and the process for creating it - sh ould be a closely
Linda A. Hill is the wallace Brett Donham Professor of Business Administration at Harvard Business School.
guarded secret. After all, why dampen motivation among the roughly 95%of employees who aren't on the list? For the past 15 to 20 years, we've been st udying programs for high potential leaders. Most recently we surveyed 45 companies worldwide about how they ident ify and develop these people. We then interviewed HR executives at a dozen of those companies to gain insights about the experiences they provide for high potentials and about the criteria for gett ing and staying on the list. Then, guided by inpu t from HRleaders, we met with and interviewed managers they'd designated as rising stars. Our research makes clear that highpotential talent lists exist, whether or not companies acknowledge them and whe the r the process for developing them is formal or informal. Of the compan ies we studied, 98% repor ted that they pur pose fully identify high potentials. Especially when resources are constrained, companies do place disproportionate atten tion on developing the people they thin k will lead their organizations into the future.
June 2010 Harvard Business Review 79 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
ARE YOU A HIGH POTENTIAL?
So you might be asking yourself, "How do I getand stay-on my company's high-poten tial list?" This article can help you begin to answer that question. Think of it as a letter to the millions of smart, competent , hardworking, tru stworthy employees who are progressing through their careerswith some degree of satisfaction bu t are still wondering how to get where th ey really want to go. We'll look at the speci fic qualities of managers whose fi rms identified them as having made the grade.
The Anatomy of a High Potential Let's begin with our definition of a high-poten tial employee. Your company may have a different defi n ition or might not even officially distinguish high potentials from other employees. However, our research has shown that compa nies tend to think of the top 3% to 5%of their talent in these terms: "High potentials consistently and significa nt ly outpe rform their peer group s in a variety of settings and circumstances. While achiev ing these superior levels of performance, they exhibit behaviors that reflect their compan ies' culture and values in an exemplary manner. Moreover, they show a strong capacity to grow and succeed throughout their careers within an organization-more quickly and effectively than their peer groups do." That's the basic anatomy ofa high potential. Gaining mem bership in this elite group starts with three essential elements. Deliver strong results-credibly. Making your numbers is important, but it isn't enough. You'll never get on a high-poten tial list if you don 't pe rform with distinction or if your results com e at the expe nse of someone else. Competence is th e baseline quality for high performance. But you also need to prove your credibility. That means building trust and confidence among your colleagues and , thereby, influencing a wide array ofstakeholders. Look at Jackie Goodwin, a bank execut ive cited by her HR department as a high potential. Jackie started out in the insurance division but wanted to switch to banking, wh ich she perceived as a career path with more room for growth. Her general ma nagement skills were highly regarded, and she had a proven track record in fina ncial services wit hin insura nce. The banking side's desi re for new blood and a lack of succession planning in the region positioned her well as an outsider. Indeed, her record was as stro ng - if n ot st ronger-than that of t he insiders.
Anatomy ofa Hi~h Potential High potentials always deliver strong results, master new types of expertise, and recognize that behavior counts. But it's their intangible x factors that truly distinguish them from the pac k.
THE FOUR X FACTORS OF HIGH POTENTIALS
1
2 3
4
Drive to excel Catalytic learning capability Enterprising spirit Dynamic sensors
When Jackie was offered a stretch ass ignment in the banking division - a promotion to vice president and regional operating officer in Germany, the bank's second largest European operation -she accepted it, even though the odds were agai nst her. Nobody there had heard of her, and she knew little about banking. What's mo re, she'd been forced on the regional president, who wanted someone with experience. Her biggest challenge was to gain cred o ibility. The German staff was accustomed to ru n ning its own show, so Jackie fi gured she'd fail if she couldn't get the team on her side. Jackie resolved to make helpin g her new colleagues a priority. In her first three weeks, she met with dozens of managers and openly acknowledged that she faced a stee p learning curve. She also focused on achieving sma ll wins on issues that had lon g been tho rns in their sides. For example, she went ou t of her way to streamline the process for opening new accounts. As for her skeptical boss, she aimed to take as much off his plate as possible. She would ask, "What time-consuming tasks would you liketo see addressed within 90days?"Then she'd get right to work. Forinstance, he disliked confrontation, so Jackie tackled issues with potential for conflict, such as redesigning plan ning processes and resolvingdecision rights. She gained a reputation as a problem solver, and her influence grew steadily. Today, Jackie is the head of all com mercial lending for the bank and is st illconsidered a rising star. Master new types of e xpertise. Early in your career, gett ing noticed is all abo ut mastering the technical expertise that the job requires. As you progress, you need to broaden that expertise. You start by managing an employee or a small group, and then mo ve on to larger teams and posit ions (for instance, at corporate headquarters) that require you to exercise influence despite having limited formal au thority. For examp le, in se nior roles technical excellence might fade in value relative to strategicthinking and motivational skills. At a cer tain point , you will face the challenge of letting go as much as the challenge of adding on. Don't aspire, forexample, to be the best engineer and the bes t design team leade r at the same time. Fo r some, such lessons a re learned the hard way. One exceptionally talented software engineer, whom we'll call Luke, had won many accolades duro ing a relat ively short career. Confident in his poten tial, Luke's managers put him in charge ofa team that was creati nga product extension expected to att ract
80 Harvard Business Review J une 2010 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
HBR.ORG
- - - '-
Nearly all companies identify their high-pote ntial managers. Processes fo r developing lists of high potentials vary, but t he rising sta rs who make the grade are remar kably similar in their core characteristics and behaviors. In a sense, they share a basic anatomy.
a whole new category of users. Luke was well liked and happily took on the challenge, but he failed to recognize that technical skill alone wouldn't suffice. After several missed deadlines, company executives created a face-saving, se nior-level "expert" post for him. Meanwhile, they put another technicallyskilled employee, whoalso had project-management expertise, in charge. Luke, no longer a high potential, went on to have a fairly distinguished career as a tech nical expert, but not in an enterprise leadership role. Recognize that behavior counts, Although your perform ance gets you noticed and promoted early in your career, you r be havio r is what keeps you on the radar as a high potential. Ou tstanding skills never really diminish in importa nce, but they become a given as you are expected to excel in roles with broader reach. Prospective candidates for that coveted high-potential label must demonstrate a behavioral shift from "fi t and affiliation" to "role model and teacher." The rise of general manager Phil Nolan to the executive ranks of h is company, a market leader in laund ry products, was due in large part to his role- model qualities. Phil was placed in charge of the firm's troubled core product, a liqu id detergent whose sales were in a mu ltiyear downward slid e. Two high-vis ibility ma rketing managers had eac h been given a chance to rei nvigorate prod uct sales . Both had tried price-reduction tactics, to no ava iL Then it was Phil's tu rn. But, with a backgrou nd in product development rathe r than marketing, he was the dark horse candidate. Fort unately, corporate executives saw more in Phil, who had engineered a turnaround at a troubled produ ct-development group by fosteri ng cooperative relationships and teamwork. Highly trustworthy, he could engage people in very candid conversations about business challenges . As a result, he was able to get to the core of a pro blem quickly and find vi-
The constitution of a high potentiaLincludes four intangible factors: a drive to excel, a catalytic learni ng capability, an enterprising spirit, and dynamic sen sors that detect opportunities and obstacles. The best exemplars of the high· potential profile exhibit all four in spades.
Getting onto a high potent ial list is extremely desirable, but it can demand great sacrifice. And t he consequences of falli ng off the rolls after having been given the honor can be substantial and permanent.
able solutions. Phil not only was superb at motivating people, but also had a keen eye for patterns and an imp ressive strategic vision. He applied all those skills to the new assignment. Within the first year in h is new role, Phil led his team to grow product sales by 30%. In our interview wit h the company's HR executive, she emphasized Phil's ability to win people ove r: "There is hu mility to him despite the fact that he is now the public face of the bra nd. Phil helps his peers succeed rathe r than threatening them. He is a role model for the organization."
How High Potentials Are Hardwired You' re doing everyt hing right. You're delivering value and early results. You're mastering new areas of expertise as you face increasingly complex challenges. You embrace your organization's culture and values. You exude con fidence and have earned the respect ofothers. Maybe you're regularly putt ing in a 50-hour week and gett ing excellen t rev iews. Nevertheless, high-potential status remains elusive. This can be infuria ting because the real differentlators-cwhat we call the "X factors"-are somewhat intangible and usually don't show up on lists ofIea dersh ip competencies or on pe rformance review forms. Here are those factors, which can tip the scales and help you achieve and maintain that coveted high-potential rating. Half of survey respondent s said t heir t op t eams spend less th an
of the ir time developing high-pot ent ial leaders.
June 2010 Harvard Business Review 81 www.WorldMags.net & www.Journal-Plaza.net
ARE YOU A HIGH POTENTIAL?
You're doing everything right. You're delivering value and early results. But highpotential status remains elusive. Developing your X factors puts it in reach .
XFACTOR #1 A drive to e xcel. High potentials aren' t just high ach ie ve rs. They a re driven to succeed. Good, even very good, isn 't good enough. Not by any stretch. They are more tha n w illing to go that ex tra m ile a nd realize they may have to make sacrifices in their personal lives in order to adva nce. That does n't m ea n they a ren' t true to their values, but sheer ambi tion may lead them to make some pretty hard choices. x FACTOR #2 A c a talytic learning capability. We often think of high pote ntials as relentless learne rs, but a lot ofpeople out the re lea rn continually yet lack an action or results orienta tion. The high potentials we have come across possess what we call a "catalytic learn ing capability." They have the capacity to scan for new ideas, t he cognitive capability to absorb the m, and the common sense to translate that new lea rn ing into prod uctive actio n for their c ustomers a nd their orga nizations. x FACTOR #3 An enterprising spirit. High potentials are always searching for prod uctive ways to blaze new paths. They are ex plorers and, as such, take on the challenges ofleavingtheir ca reer comfort zones periodically in ordertoadvance.1t might mean a risky move-a tricky international assignment, for insta nce, or a cross-unit s hift tha t demands an entirely new set of skills . Given high potentia ls' drive to succeed, you m ight think they'd be reluctant to take such a chance. But most seem to fi nd that the adva ntages-the excitement a nd opportunity -outweigh the risks. x FACTOR #4 Dynamic sensors. Being driven to excel and having an e nterprising spirit, combined wit h the urge to fi nd new approac hes, could actually
become a recipe for career disaster. High pote nt ials ca n get derailed for a numbe r of reasons. They may, for instance, be tempted to impulsively accept what seems like a hot o pportunity, only to find that it's a break (not a stretch) assignment or tha t the re's no long-term ca reer payoff. Ano ther possibilit y of derailment comes from a desire to please. High potentials may avoid o pen disagree ment with the boss or resist giving honest, potentially disappointing feed ba ck to a peer. Successful high pote ntials have wellt uned radar tha t puts a highe r premiu m on qualit y results. Beyond judgment, high potentials possess what we ca ll "dynamic sensors," which e na ble the m to skirt these risks, even if just barely. They have a feel for timing, a n ability to quickly read situations, a nd a nose for opportunity. Their e nterprising spirit might otherwise lead them to make foolish decisions, but these sensors help them decide, for example, when to pursue something and whe n to pull back. High potentials have a knack for being in the right place at the righ t time.
Anatomy of an X Factor Exemplar One of the many high potentials we met was Vineet Kapoo r, described as a ris ing star by his bosses at Swiss medical device company Synthes. This more than $3 billion business manufactures and ma rkets impla nts and blomatertals used in surgery and regeneration ofthe skeleton and soft tissues. In school, long before ending u p at Synthes, vtneet inte nded to pursue scie nce a nd had a pa ssio n for im proving the lives of people in emerging economies such as India. That basic vision remained
Should You Tell Her She's a High Potential? Whether or not a company should ma ke its list of high potentials trans parent is a n evergree n question. In our surveys of 45 company policies and in our work with fi rms during the past 15 to 20 yea rs, we have found a growing tre nd toward transparency. The percentage of compa nies that inform high potentials of t heir status has risen from 70%
about a decade ago to 85% today. Employers, we believe, are coming to see talent as a strategic resource t hat, like other types of ca pital, ca n move a round. Executives are tired of exit inte rviews in which promis ing employees say, "If I had known you had plans for me and were serious a bout following through, I would have stayed."
Nevertheless. making your list of high potentials transparent increases the pressure to do something with the peo ple who are on it . If you tell someone you view h