High Frequency Electromagnetic Dosimetry
For a listing of recent titles in the Artech House Electromagnetic Analysis ...
132 downloads
1895 Views
5MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
High Frequency Electromagnetic Dosimetry
For a listing of recent titles in the Artech House Electromagnetic Analysis Series, turn to the back of this book.
High Frequency Electromagnetic Dosimetry David A. Sánchez-Hernández Editor
artechhouse.com
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalog record of this book is available from the Library of Congress.
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record of this book is available from the British Library. ISBN
978-1-59693-397-2
Cover design by Igor Valdman © 2009 ARTECH HOUSE, INC. 685 Canton Street Norwood, MA 02062 All rights reserved. Printed and bound in the United States of America. No part of this book may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. All terms mentioned in this book that are known to be trademarks or service marks have been appropriately capitalized. Artech House cannot attest to the accuracy of this information. Use of a term in this book should not be regarded as affecting the validity of any trademark or service mark.
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
This book is dedicated to Lucía, Mario, Bruno, Irene, Paula, Marina, Javier, Juan, Pedro, Julia, and Helena, our breed, and to Marien, Sylvia, Marina, Lucía, Ángeles, Ana Belén, Marta, and Ana, our mates and family. They are our daily source of energy for smiling at life.
Contents Foreword
xi
CHAPTER 1 Introduction
1
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6
Introduction 1 Exposure Scenarios 5 The Nature of the Interaction: Rationale for Limiting Exposure to EMF 7 International Scientific Messages 9 Risk Communication and Perception 11 The Reason for Writing this Book 13 References 16
CHAPTER 2 Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter 2.1 Introduction 2.2 Electromagnetic Dosimetry 2.2.1 Definition 2.2.2 Electromagnetic Fields and Matter 2.2.3 Specific Absorption Rate 2.3 Dielectric Properties 2.3.1 Measurement Techniques 2.3.2 Current Knowledge on Dielectric Properties 2.3.3 The Role of Tissue Dielectric Properties and Geometry on Electromagnetic Dosimetry 2.4 Heat Generation 2.4.1 Bioheat Equation 2.4.2 Thermal Properties of Human Tissues 2.5 Conclusions References
21 21 22 22 23 27 29 29 38 46 50 50 56 57 59
CHAPTER 3 Far-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry
67
3.1 Introduction 3.2 Electromagnetic Exposure Evaluation and Compliance Testing 3.3 Human Body and Source Modeling 3.3.1 Human Body Model 3.3.2 Source Modeling
67 69 71 71 76
vii
viii
Contents
3.4 Simulation Techniques References
82 85
CHAPTER 4 Near-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry
93
4.1 Phantom and Source Modeling 4.1.1 Phantom Developments 4.1.2 Source Modeling 4.2 Simulation Techniques 4.2.1 Averaging Strategies 4.2.2 Meshing Strategies References
93 93 100 103 109 110 111
CHAPTER 5 In Situ Measured Exposure Assessment and Compliance Testing
121
5.1 Introduction 5.2 Preevaluation 5.3 Instrumentation for Measurement 5.3.1 Broadband Probes 5.3.2 Narrowband Equipment 5.3.3 Antennas 5.3.4 Digital Mobile Communications Measuring Instrument 5.4 Volunteer Studies 5.5 Accurate Far-Field Compliance Testing for 2G Measurements 5.5.1 Measurement Campaigns 5.5.2 Measurement Procedures 5.5.3 Base Station Activity Determination 5.5.4 Broadband Measurements 5.5.5 Data Acquisition and Evaluation of Compliance with Broadband Probes 5.5.6 Narrowband Measurements 5.5.7 Data Acquisition and Evaluation of Compliance with Narrowband Probes 5.6 Accurate Far-Field Compliance Testing for 3G Measurements 5.6.1 The Need for Measurements 5.6.2 The UMTS Downlink Signal References
147 153 153 154 158
CHAPTER 6 Near-Field SAR Measurements with Automated Scanning Systems
165
6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5
Introduction Dosimetric Assessment System SAR Assessment System Portable SAR Systems Sources of Inaccuracies References
121 124 126 126 128 129 132 132 134 134 137 140 143 144 146
165 167 167 169 171 172
Contents
ix
CHAPTER 7 The Effect of Metallic Objects on SAR Distributions 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7
Introduction Perfectly Conducting Spectacles and Eye Implants Electrodes and Wire-Leads Pins Plates Rings, Piercings, and Auditory Implants Stents References
CHAPTER 8 Worldwide Standardization and Guideline Discrepancies 8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4
Introduction Extremities and Mass- and Time-Averaging Volume Averaging Regulations References
175 175 177 180 183 184 186 202 202
207 207 210 212 213 216
CHAPTER 9 Medical Applications of High Frequency Electromagnetic Energy
221
9.1 Electromagnetic Therapy and Hypothermia 9.1.1 Biological Response and Risk 9.2 Therapeutic Applications 9.2.1 Cardiac Treatments 9.2.2 Urological Pathologies 9.2.3 Gastric Pathologies 9.2.4 Tumor Ablation 9.2.5 Sleep Breathing Disorders 9.2.6 Endometrial Ablation 9.2.7 Assistance to Arthroscopic Surgery 9.2.8 Assistance to Lipoclasty 9.3 Conclusions and Future Research References
221 222 223 224 225 227 227 230 230 231 232 232 233
CHAPTER 10 Conclusions
237
References
240
Acronyms
243
About the Editor
249
About the Contributors Index
249 253
Foreword Since the 1990s there has been an explosive growth of mobile communications, with billions of subscribers around the world. Fourth generation systems are bringing broadband wireless internet access to the mobile user. The safety of electromagnetic fields has been the subject of much debate, originally concerned with fields from power lines and more recently with radiated power from handsets, laptops, and base stations. It is an emotive topic and it is important for protagonists on both sides of the debate to make sure that their opinions are drawn from in-depth study of the topic—it is all too easy to pick on the results of one study that confirm a strongly held personal opinion. Sometimes the press can use scientific terms loosely—for example, failing to make the distinction between electromagnetic fields and ionizing radiation is certain to lead to alarm amongst the public. Even specialists in the study of the effects of nonionizing radiation on the human body have differing opinions, and there are varying exposure limits and standards across the world. This is because the study of the effects of high frequency fields on the human body has many facets; frequencies of interest cover a vast range from HF through microwave to THz and infrared. Biological materials have frequency-dependant properties and the human body is not simple to model. The biological interactions may be thermal, from dielectric heating, or more complex nonthermal bioelectromagnetic effects. It is timely, therefore, to have an extensive treatment of the subject of high frequency electromagnetic dosimetry. The text before you is the result of exhaustive research and includes an excellent overview of the theory and practice of dosimetry systems. Such an authoritative source of information on the science behind, and engineering of, practical dosimetry systems has not been found before in a single volume. You will also find a summary of some of the main opportunities for application of RF and microwave frequencies in medical treatment, from treatment of hypothermia to surgery for cancer therapy. There is no doubt that with a fuller understanding of the interactions between high frequency electromagnetic radiation and the human body, and more precise characterization of such interactions, these applications will develop enormously. Prof I.D. Robertson University of Leeds April 2009
xi
CHAPTER 1
Introduction David A. Sánchez-Hernández
1.1
Introduction Recent decades have witnessed important advances in the technological development of applications with radiofrequency and microwave energy, which have lead to important cost reductions in an ever-increasing number of utilities in industrial, medical, commercial, research, and domestic environments. Nowadays, it is commonplace to find radiofrequency and microwave systems at home, in workplaces, cars, public transport, hospitals, schools, and virtually everywhere else, both outdoors and indoors. The services offered by wired and wireless networks have an ever-increasing complexity. Mobile phones are able to communicate through voice, SMS, pictures, or MMS, and also at high data rate transmissions for financial transactions or even real-time broadband Internet access. This development is seemingly unstoppable, yet at the same time, public fear about possible adverse effects to human health from electromagnetic radiation has also been growing in an exponential increasing reality, with a particular focus on the use of mobile phones and the location of base stations on the top of buildings in urban areas. In spite of social outcry against radioelectric emissions, the use of mobile phones is still exponentially growing around the globe. This is directly reflected in the increasing penetration ratios, with an increasing number of countries witnessing well over 100% penetration ratios in 2008. The general public receives information about new technologies typically from mass media. Sometimes information with little scientific relevance is presented as important, and it is relatively easy to find press and other media references related to radioelectric emissions and public health, an issue that has become recurrent and seems to remain prominent. As influence of mass media has increased in recent years, so has their responsibility when influencing decision-making procedures [1, 2]. Journalists are normally trained to improve the efficiency when broadcasting, controlling, and selling news to the general public, wherein the main aspects include: •
Facts, basic knowledge, and some correlations are presented in a summarized way—that is, in a black and white image, where gray scales are scarce. Scientific and technological discoveries, however, do not conform well to black and
1
2
Introduction
•
•
•
white scenarios as they contain many diverse aspects enriching the discovery in a usually complicated manner. When such discoveries are forced into a simple scenario, sometimes the delivered message is wrong. News can be created from opinions, and since the diversity of opinion is enormous, public opinion may change as the news creation process progresses. News is presented as an entertainment or amusement tool, and due to the inherent characteristics of leisure, bad news, even that which produces fear, is well received by the general public from the commercial point of view. Yet, the news is slow and inefficient in changing permanent habits, notwithstanding their ability to make people desire what other people or companies with responsibilities have to do. This responsibility relocation also happens at the news consuming stage, but with an artificial and virtual distance between the news consumer and the action being described on TV, heard on the radio, or written in the newspaper or on Web pages. Thus, journalists themselves believe their influence on the general public or individuals is not really so important, and that people are clearly able to distinguish between rigorous news and those broadcasted for entertainment.
In this complicated world of roles one has to add, however, that not only a well-trained journalist is required to transmit rigorous scientific news, but also a well-trained scientist/researcher. When delivering biorelated issues, sometimes good journalists have to distinguish between the results of a solo study, which cannot be generalized, and its replica studies, which are the ones from which scientific basis is derived for obtaining conclusions. Yet, the engineering way of doing science is different, and only proven, peer-reviewed and demonstrated facts get published. This diversity, which enriches science from the scientific point of view, makes scientific committees sometimes make decisions by voting, which is not really well understood by the general public or by mass media. Researchers also need to learn on result delivering techniques, not only to scientific and technical journals, which is essential to divulge science and technology, but also in a way that is comprehensible to the general public and the mass media. This includes avoiding technical jargon and complicated descriptions when addressing the mass media. There is certainly a lack of communication and risk perception tools employed in the electromagnetic dosimetry issue. Thus, it is not surprising the feeling of fear that remains in part of the population, who may see the new wireless technologies as a threat. To date, at frequencies and power levels used in mobile communications systems, any causal relationship between radioelectric exposure and adverse health effects has not been established for a continuous use of less than 20 years. Nevertheless, messages from scientific organizations worldwide that reaffirm this lack of causal-effect data for long-term exposure does not seem to get to people in the same proportion as those other messages with less scientific content and more sensationalist content. Governments, local administrations, and, of course, operators and service providers have the responsibility of introducing into mainstream society the appropriate scientific information about the new systems and technological advances.
1.1 Introduction
3
The innate nature of science and its way forward does not help at all. In the biomedical scenario, papers get published based upon hypotheses, and need to be replicated long before medical protocols are established and applied over a specific technique. Even when a technique is well established, only practice in the long term can ensure medical feasibility. There are many operational techniques which are discarded by other more recent and scientific ones. This is not well understood by the general public. It is not the intention of researchers to address the general public with scientific publications, but the wide availability of scientific tests cannot be avoided. This sometimes turns into misinterpretation of published results. The way that epidemiologic science progresses does not help either. When the causal relationship of an effect is not known, it is very important to gather epidemiological data on it. Mankind has obtained many successful advances through observation, such as epidemiologic studies, but the possibility of biasing and the inherent complexity of dealing with statistical data and its boundary conditions over assumptions are not normally considered by the profanes. Observational studies do not adjust to typical laboratory testing, with an absence of random, double blind, and placebo tests, which are considered to be the paradigm of rigorous science based on evidence. It is for this reason that the majority of epidemiological studies include a paragraph about the inherent observational deficiencies. Among the many available research project results, two recently published ones are of special interest, that of the STROBE and INTERPHONE projects. The international 3-year STROBE project [3] was aimed at reinforcing the rigor on both realization and interpretation of epidemiological studies. Specific detailed descriptions (as detailed as laboratory tests) are recommended, focusing the conclusions to be obtained upon the objective being defined, and identifying critical variables which could lead to different results and interpretation of results. Similarly, reference to similar works both reaching and not reaching the same conclusions are recommended to be included in the study, as well as identifying funding sources and possible conflicts of interest. A particular study which has been recognized worldwide as state-of-science and well reputed is that of the INTERPHONE project, for which partial results have being published in 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2008. The INTERPHONE project was intended to clarify whether the radiofrequency radiation emitted by mobile telephones is carcinogenic through large-scale transnational epidemiological studies. The project was also intended to avoid the typical sample and ambiguities problems of previous studies and to break new ground. With highly reputed partners and coordinated by the World Health Organization’s International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), INTERPHONE study results were eagerly awaited. INTERPHONE concentrated on three types of cancer: those associated with the parotid gland, those associated with glial and meningeal brain tissues (gliomas and meningiomas), and those associated with the vestibular part of the eight cranial nerve (acoustic neurinomas). The selection of these types was made because these tumors arise around those tissues that absorb the highest proportion of the RF energy from handheld mobile phones. Results from INTERPHONE are already available [4–12], but have not clearly solved the issue. The studies on the three tumor types have not provided conclusive results. Not all results were consistent with each other. One study found, among
4
Introduction
persons who had used cellular phones for 10 or more years, an increased risk for gliomas but not for meningiomas [5]. The increment was found to be of borderline statistical significance [9], and in the conclusions of the project identified to either causal or artifactual due to recall bias [10], related to differential recall between cases and controls [11]. This was reinforced by the fact that the increase was found for ipsilateral use, but a decrease was also found for contralateral use. Most studies did not found an association between use of a mobile phone, either in the short or medium term. Even in the largest of the INTERPHONE national studies published to date there are not enough cases among long-term users to conclude confidently whether or not there is a link between mobile phone use and any type of head or neck cancer. In consequence, in the latest INTERPHONE update, that of February 2008, the IARC reports little evidence in the main analyses for an overall association between mobile phone use and an increase in the incidence of head and neck tumors. The IARC now estimates that INTERPHONE includes approximately 1,100 acoustic-neurinoma cases, 2,600 glioma, 2,300 meningioma and their matched controls. This is considered sufficient to detect confidently a 50% risk increase linked to mobile phone use beginning 5 years or more before enrollment. So the eager anticipation of INTERPHONE’s results is not over yet. Manuscripts presenting results of the international analyses, based on much larger numbers of long-term and heavy users, are in preparation. If no conclusive association is found, then further studies could be questioned. Even if an association could be encountered for ipsilateral use of more than 10 years, the systems employed then (analog) and the power they used is no longer available for the handset. Consequently, the implications for today’s technologies could not be determined in a straightforward manner. Some authors are already questioning whether the effects of long-term and analog factors are mixed-up in the first handful of meat-analyses results being published [13]. Moreover, even in these and other international studies, it has been demonstrated that exposure assessment methods have a considerable potential for bias through exposure misclassification and may therefore not be valid in studies investigating possibly subtle changes in risk [8]. In this sense, chance findings are not discarded in some results [6]. Moreover, results from the INTERPHONE study have revealed some concern over researchers regarding the exposure assessment method for the epidemiological study. INTERPHONE researchers [8] have questioned both self-reported findings, based on questionnaire data, and findings based upon subscription data provided by network operators to be good enough to allow a detection of possibly only subtle changes in risk, and they have called for advanced techniques in follow-up studies. Other EU-funded research projects include REFLEX, THz-BRIDGE, CEMFEC, RAMP2001, GUARD, PERFORM-A, PERFORM-B, EMFnEAR, and EMF-NET. These and other non-EU projects are of great interest to biologist, engineers, and physicists, yet they are oriented towards the end-result, which is typically biology oriented. When studying the role of engineering in the problem, the WHO clearly identified the need to provide for an accurate exposure assessment that has to be repeatable and reproducible. This role was recently reinforced by a recent study on measured results using volunteers [14], jointly performed by ETH Zurich, University of Zurich, and the Nokia Research Center. Results in [14] show a 500% difference when comparing the exposure conditions in different human volunteers. The
1.2 Exposure Scenarios
5
relationship between exposure values and electromagnetic energy deposed in the body is named “electromagnetic dosimetry.” With such a disparity in exposure conditions, the amount of deposed energy for each study could be extremely different. There are already several guidelines about harmonization of electromagnetic dosimetry when performing research on the issue. Even these guidelines have some divergences [15–20]. This poses a big question on the way the scientific problem has been addressed from the electromagnetic dosimetry point of view. It is precisely this role of electromagnetic dosimetry and the vast amount of information in this area that is the seed of this book. It is the aim of this book to present the recent advances regarding high frequency electromagnetic dosimetry from a scientific and rigorous telecommunications engineering point of view; that is, to obtain advances regarding accurate exposure assessments. The aim is to provide the advanced reader (engineer, scientist, biologist, physicist) with a state-of-science description of the problem at a glance. Most of the potential readers are current scientific leaders in their communities, and many of them are questioned about the issue of EMF and health. While we believe that strong research is the appropriate way to understand the issue, this book is intended for those researchers, scientists, and engineers who are not doing research in the field but are interested in knowing more about it. In addition, any researcher would welcome the availability of an up-to-date compilation text like this one. Readers must not expect, however, detailed biological experiments and results, as only high frequency electromagnetic dosimetry is the key issue of the book. By understanding EMF dosimetry, biological experiments may be made repeatable and comparable, which is a must for science to progress.
1.2
Exposure Scenarios Two different exposure scenarios can be distinguished for mobile communications systems: that of the human head, due to the near-field radioelectric emissions from handsets, and the exposure of the general public or workers due to radioelectric emissions from base station antennas. Exposure to base station radioelectric emissions typically occur in the far-field, but it may also take place in the near-field. The diverse techniques and technical specifications limit the power transmitted by a mobile handset today, but the wide variety of commercial units and their use patterns make the analyses of human interaction with electromagnetic waves a complicated task depending upon many different variables. The fundamentals of electromagnetic field interaction with matter will be covered in Chapter 2. Due to both the popularity of mobile phone use and also the focusing effect of EMF-related risk perception issues on base station antennas and mobile handsets, it has received much more scientific attention than other sources of radioelectric emissions. Measurements carried out over mobile networks up to date all around the world have demonstrated that electromagnetic field levels for the general public at the street level, emitted by base stations transmitters, are some orders of magnitude lower than maximum permissible levels. Electromagnetic dosimetry associated with emissions from mobile phones, on the other hand, is higher than that from base stations due to their proximity to the user, and power limitations have been derived
6
Introduction
specifically for mobile handsets. Since mobile phones emit electromagnetic waves very near of the user’s head and cause a complex exposure environment which is difficult to measure, this problem has received more attention than that of the base station scenario. As it will be described in this book, both problems are equally complex and several different factors have to be taken into account for accurate and rigorous exposure assessment. Yet, while many references can be found in the scientific literature for the handset scenario, the base station scenario has not received comparable attention, and further, particular references to third generation systems are scarce. For the handset scenario, all mobile phones to be commercialized in the European Union or the United States have to undergo strict quality tests, including several wherein specific absorption rate (SAR) levels are evaluated and results have to conform to frequency-dependent preestablished safety limits. In the European Union the SAR evaluation results are normally provided by the manufacturer, while in the United States the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) regularly publishes the results so that users are well aware of this parameter when acquiring their units. For the base station scenario, maximum SAR values have been observed in regions of the human body like the chest or the back [21–23], different to those encountered for the first scenario, mainly due to either direct exposure or to reflections on nearby walls or buildings. In [21], for instance, three different user positions were studied, always at far-field distances, providing peak SAR values of 12.9, 8.2, and 2.45 mW/g, averaged over 1g, 10g, and the whole body, respectively, which is well below the limits recommended by the European Council. A 20-cm safety distance was established in [23] for several GSM1800 base station antennas with an input CW power of 10W when a person was located directly in front of the antenna’s main beam. Depending upon the specific EMF limit under study, near-field safety distances between 1 and 65 cm were found in [24] using automated scanning systems. These systems will be described in Chapter 6. In absolute terms, electric field levels emitted from base stations and evaluated as reference levels on human beings on the street are lower than those from mobile phones. Yet, the concern about base stations is greater than that of mobile phones. The explanation is simple: The nature of both elements is different. People can decide whether or not to use a mobile phone and which one they prefer, but nothing can be decided as far as general public is concerned about the installation of a base station near their home. In addition, people are well aware of the direct benefits of a mobile phone, but they do not perceive the same benefits from a base station installed at a few meters away from their homes. On the contrary, this base station can be the origin of their anxiety or even devaluate the price of their houses, which may be the cause for some of their real feelings, and it is certainly the subject of recent studies. With these arguments, it is understandable that people fiercely oppose the installation of new base stations in the vicinity of their houses, supported by something that can or cannot be guaranteed by scientific investigations. Far- and near-field numerical electromagnetic dosimetry will be explained in Chapters 3 and 4, respectively. Chapter 5 will describe in situ measured exposure assessment and compliance testing.
1.3 The Nature of the Interaction: Rationale for Limiting Exposure to EMF
7
1.3 The Nature of the Interaction: Rationale for Limiting Exposure to EMF Human beings have lived with natural radioelectric emissions from the beginning of time, and with artificial radioelectric emissions for more than one century, starting when Guglielmo Marconi invented the wireless telegraph. Microwaves and radioelectric emissions are presented in nature from the Sun, galaxies, and our own planet Earth. The Earth’s biosphere is characterized by its electric and magnetic fields and also by atmospheric discharges. Any body with a temperature higher than 0K (−273ºC) emits electromagnetic radiation as a result of the accelerations suffered by charged particles due to thermal vibration. This is known as the body’s thermal radiation. For example, the Earth emits a power density of up to 0.3 mW/cm2 at 300 GHz, assuming an averaged temperature of 293K (20ºC). Of course, the human body has a temperature higher than 0K, which means that it emits electromagnetic energy of around 0.3 mW/cm2 within the frequency range of 10 kHz to 300 GHz. Interest in the incidence of this kind of emissions on human health began with the development of the first artificial radioelectric systems. Since then some scientific organizations and institutions have investigated the possible effects (positive, innocuous, and negative) associated to the interaction of electromagnetic waves with human beings, animals, and the environment. Radioelectric emissions from mobile phones and base stations are just part of the story, but they can be evaluated and verified by measurement techniques and procedures established with general character with any source of radioelectric emission. It is well known that exposure to high intensity electromagnetic fields produces biological effects [25]. The diverse recommendations and guidelines established by international scientific committees share the same basis for the setup of a peak SAR limit averaged over the whole body so that exposure does not pose a threat to human health. It was shared knowledge that adverse behavioral effects could be observed in primates for exposure rates over ∼4 W/kg [25]. This limit was associated with the body thermal increment which could not be coped with by the primate’s thermoregulatory system. Assuming similar coupling mechanisms in human beings, a safety factor of 10 was established for workers (occupational exposure), and an additional factor of 5 (making a total of 50) for the general public, thus deriving the SAR limit of 0.08 W/kg, averaged over the whole body. These factors are intended to cover different situations, like preheated situations during exercise, increased thermal environment, humidity, thermal conditions in infants, sensitive people, or even the ingestion of drugs and alcohol. Before the guidelines were developed in the European Union and the United States, some experiments on human volunteers were performed, and this ∼4 W/kg value was confirmed to produce body thermal increments less than 1ºC. This already established averaged thermoregulation capacity for humans was reaffirmed as the correct threshold [26], although temperature measurements were only performed in the surface. Yet, while it is possible to be exposed at frequency values for which only parts of the body are resonant, as in the mobile communications scenario, local temperature increments and SAR values could well exceed those of the limit, yet the whole-body averaged value would not be surpassed and rectal temperature (assumed to equal core body temperature) may remain constant. These minor incre-
8
Introduction
ments were found particularly important in the hypothalamus of the primates [27], wherein only a 0.2ºC to 0.3ºC increment could alter he primate’s thermoregulation system. At the same time, skin could be heated up to ∼45ºC (10ºC to 15ºC increments) to start producing pricking pain [28, 29], and at least an increment of 3.5ºC is required in the brain to lead to physiological damage [30]. In contrast, oncological hyperthermia units try to get cancer cell temperatures rise up to ∼42ºC for an efficient treatment [31]. Thus, local SAR limits were also established. Here, the rationale for deriving local SAR limit values, excellently explained in [32, 33], is different for diverse committees’ guidelines with respect to the averaging in both time and space. Since the ratio of the local peak to whole-body averaged SAR is about 20:1, in the United States the guidelines for a 20-fold peak SAR limit was introduced, giving rise to a local SAR limit of 1.6 W/kg averaged over a cubic shape of 1g in mass (until a change in 2006). In the European Union, however, the restriction on eye effects was employed, which was demonstrated to be around 100 W/kg for the induction of lens opacities in rabbits. Since the human eye weighs approximately 10g, 10- and 50-fold safety factors were made equivalent to imposing local peak SAR limits of 10 and 2 W/kg averaged over 10g for occupational and general public exposure, respectively. This represents a 25-fold increase over the whole-body average SAR limit. Yet, an exception was made for the limbs, wherein a maximum of 4 W/kg was allowed over 10g of contiguous tissue, representing a 50-fold increase over whole-body averaged SAR. Time-averaging is 6 minutes in the European Union and was 30 minutes in the United States until 2006, when a frequency-dependent formula was employed for time averaging. In Canada, for instance, the guidelines of Safety Code 6 provide particular restrictions for the eye. Some specific worker eyesight test examination was originally proposed in Australia. These and other standardization differences will be explained in Chapter 8. In the same pot we have: (a) the diverse revisions to safety limits; (b) the fact that the rationale for limiting local peak SAR is not harmonized to specifically establish limits that ensure that local heating remains below thresholds for the induction of tissue thermal damage, given by a safety factor; and (c) the fact that the restrictions set up by the International Commission for Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection (ICNIRP) were established on the basis of nerve and muscle tissue stimulation by electric currents which are induced in the cells, which was assumed to be thresholded. Consequently, it is not strange that some recent papers are suggesting the establishment of more direct temperature-increase-based safety limits; in other words, to use directly the concept of thermal dose, which is the one directly involved with the potential damage. The idea is backed up by some recent studies providing body thermal increments over 1ºC for maximum allowable plane-wave exposure levels [34] or increments in SAR limits for near-field exposure scenarios [35, 36] when the subject wears specific metallic implants. Special care for these particular situations has recently been suggested, and in consequence the effects of metallic objects on SAR will be described in detail in Chapter 7. The recent availability of refined hybridized electromagnetic and heat- and mass-transfer equations has prompted the possibility for a revision of current safety limits, based on incident field exposure, to more precise thermal-based limits. In this way an enhanced accuracy would be provided for current safety factors and precautionary principle clauses [34]. In order to be able to accurately determine these limits for radiofre-
1.4 International Scientific Messages
9
quency exposure, rigorous exposure assessment methods hybridized to thermal modeling techniques including heat- and mass-transfer mechanisms, which have to include all possible mechanisms, have to be fully developed. Simulated thermal doses could then be compared to those producing tissue damage, and the advance on hybridization techniques, which started with very simple human model and thermal modeling, has achieved a rigorously level comparable to those of current electromagnetic models employed for deriving SAR limits.
1.4
International Scientific Messages Despite initial divergences, which took standardization bodies all throughout the world to propose different safety limits and their subsequent revisions of 1964 (IRPA), 1966 (IRE), 1974 (ANSI), 1982 (ANSI), 1984 (IRPA), 1988 (IRPA), 1998 (ICNIRP), 1999 (IEEE), 2002 (IEEE), 2003 (IEEE), 2004 (IEEE), 2005 (IEEE), and 2006 (IEEE), the different scientific committees have agreed that current whole-body averaged exposure safety limits are currently well settled for human health protection [37–40] and that these limits do not need, according to recent scientific literature, any additional revision. To date, the two main EMF standardization and recommendation bodies, the International Committee on Electromagnetic Safety (ICES) and the International Commission for Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection (ICNIRP), are working towards a single set of worldwide guidelines and standards [33], with the first results providing a put-into-market standard for handsets by the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) [41]. The direction of institutional messages since 1998 is towards ensuring citizens that health protection is well developed by current EMF safety limits; yet research programs are being approved due to the tremendous pressure by consumer associations and the recommendations to maintain research efforts made by the scientific committees themselves, and small amendments are approved for some EMF-related standards as more scientific knowledge becomes known on the issue. The European Commission, within the Vth and VIth Framework Programme, started several international R&D projects regarding electromagnetic fields and human health. Very recently an initiative of the EU has submitted the final report—that of the European Information System on ElectroMagnetic Fields (JRC-EIS-EMF)—which was requested by Directorate General of Health and Consumer Protection (SANCO) and Directorate General Enterprise (ENTERPRISE) to the Physical and Chemical Exposure Unit of the European Joint Research Centre at Ispra (Italy). The overall scope was to provide a common basis for decision makers to increase the coherence of the approaches taken in the various member states, help restore public confidence, and liaise to other initiatives like COST-284 and WHO-EMF. The European Scientific Committee on Toxicity, Ecotoxicity, and the Environment (CSTEE) has reaffirmed the validity of current radiofrequency and microwave EMF safety limits at the 27th plenary meeting (October 2001), the 33rd plenary meeting (September 2002), and the 35th plenary meeting (December 2002). In the last report the CSTEE found insufficient scientific evidence, with regard to thermal and nonthermal effects, for proposing alternatives to the technical annex for the EU
10
Introduction
Council Recommendation setting up basic restrictions and reference levels limiting the exposure to nonionizing radiation. These limits are based on the guidelines published by ICNIRP [25]. Yet, the CSTEE also established as high priority the need for of studies intended to improve the validity of assessment of human exposure—for example, the use of biomarkers—and those for theoretical modeling of possible mechanisms of interaction with biological systems. Upon the request of the European Commission, the Scientific Committee on Emerging and Newly Identified Health Risks (SCENIHR) has recently updated the previous opinion of the CSTEE with respect to whether or not exposure to electromagnetic fields (EMF) is a cause for human health concern [42]. The opinion is divided into frequency (f) bands, namely: radio frequency (RF) (100 kHz < f ≤ 300 GHz), intermediate frequency (IF) (300 Hz < f ≤ 100 kHz), extremely low frequency (ELF) (0 < f ≤ 300 Hz), and magnetic static (0 Hz), with a separate section for environmental effects. In the opinion of SCENIHR, the balance of epidemiologic evidence indicates that mobile phone use of less than 10 years does not pose any increased risk of brain tumor or acoustic neurinoma. Lack of data to derive certain conclusions is claimed for longer use, diseases other than cancer, and studies on children. With the available data, SCENIHR also concludes that: •
•
•
•
•
There is no increased risk for brain tumors in long-term users, with the exception of acoustic neurinoma for which there are some indications of an association. RF exposure has not consistently been shown to have an effect on self-reported symptoms (e.g., headache, fatigue, dizziness, and concentration difficulties) or general well-being. Studies on neurological effects and reproductive effects have not indicated any health risks at exposure levels below the ICNIRP-limits established in 1998. Animal studies have not provided evidence that RF fields could induce cancer, enhance the effects of known carcinogens, or accelerate the development of transplanted tumors. There is no consistent indication from in vitro research that RF fields affect cells at the nonthermal exposure level.
The World Health Organization has promoted the Electro Magnetic Field Project (EMF) where the human health effects from radioelectric emissions are being investigated [43]. WHO has identified the necessity for more investigation to evaluate the health risk and promotes investigations among those agencies with funding capability. To date, the following conclusions have been reached: •
•
Cancer. Evidence shows that it is improbable that exposure to mobile phones and base stations cause cancer. Given the widespread presence of base stations in the environment, it is expected that possible cancer clusters will occur near base stations merely by chance. Moreover, the reported cancers in these clusters are often a collection of different types of cancer with no common characteristics and hence are unlikely to have a common cause. Other effects. Few studies have investigated general health effects in individuals exposed to RF fields from base stations. This is because of the difficulty in
1.5 Risk Communication and Perception
•
•
•
11
distinguishing possible health effects from the very low signals emitted by base stations from other higher strength RF signals in the environment. Most studies have focused on the RF exposures of mobile phone users. No consistent evidence of altered sleep or cardiovascular function has been reported. Electromagnetic interference. The use of mobile phones near some medical devices like pacemakers or defibrillators, or near earrings may possibly cause interference. Risk of interference with navigating systems in aircrafts is also possible. Driving risks. The risk of mobile phone use is not only in the direct interaction of electromagnetic fields with human tissues but also in the appropriate use of these devices; for example, while driving vehicles [44–46]. Some countries have developed specific legislation to prevent the use of mobile phones while driving. Public perception of risks. Some people perceive risks from RF exposure as likely and even possibly severe. Several reasons for public fear include media announcements of new and unconfirmed scientific studies, leading to a feeling of uncertainty and a perception that there may be unknown or undiscovered hazards. Other factors are aesthetic concerns and a feeling of a lack of control or input to the process of determining the location of new base stations. Experience shows that education programs as well as effective communications and involvement of the public and other stakeholders at appropriate stages of the decision process before installing RF sources can enhance public confidence and acceptability.
These and other considerations regarding worldwide standardization discrepancies and regulations are dealt with in Chapter 8.
1.5
Risk Communication and Perception It is important to point out that the generalized use of nonscientific terms when speaking about radioelectric emissions—such as electrosmog and electromagnetic pollution—makes people assimilate ionizing and nonionizing radiation, avoiding the important basic differences between these two radiation types and even between radiations within these two types. One clear example is the differences between the magnetic fields created by high voltage electric lines and high frequency radioelectric emissions (e.g., those emitted by mobile phones, wherein the electric field dominates the interaction mechanism with matter). Other terms such as “electric Chernobyl” to refer to short-wave antenna fields or other nontechnical comparisons may stimulate fear or even catastrophic feelings in general public. The role of terms’ familiarity is important in current Western societies [47]. There is a general scientific culture about electricity since it represents a basic need, but in most countries the electric appliances provide light and not electricity, and the scientific knowledge of the general public about electromagnetic fields is not even that basic. This is due to the fact that electromagnetic fields cannot be touched, seen, or perceived in any way, with rare exceptions like the microwave hearing effect or the hair stimulation when in presence of high level electric fields. It is this hidden nature
12
Introduction
of EMFs which is one of the main reasons for people’s concerns, augmented by the fact that, as we have mentioned before, it is easily confused with other energy types, such as ionizing radiation. This blurred information does not aid the required clarification process for citizens. While the biological effects and the effects on health due to high intensity electromagnetic fields are well known and understood, the basic interaction mechanisms that serve as a basis for hypothetic effects of very low intensity electromagnetic exposure have not even been undoubtedly identified. Controversy over the existence of these low intensity effects is served between scientists, with physicists and engineers generally more skeptical than biologists and epidemiologists. The scientific basis for pursuing standardization and legislative actions, however, must be based on published peer-reviewed evidence, and to date the causal-effect relationship between adverse effects on human health of low intensity electromagnetic fields has yet to be demonstrated [40, 48]. In spite of this, one factor that augments citizen worries is their inability to be able to control the possible, if existent, risk, and the typical unawareness of the exposure. While people can choose when, how, and with which terminal they can make a call, the location of base stations is generally out of their scope. Consequently, risk perception is completely different in spite of a lower exposure generally found for the base station scenario compared to the mobile phone situation. In 1995 and 1996 the Harvard Center for Risk Analysis (HCRA) issued two reports on the variety of risks associated with electromagnetic fields [49]. As reproduced in Table 1.1, electromagnetic fields were perceived as the least suspected of the analyzed risks. The tremendous similarity in perception rates between X-rays and electromagnetic fields revealed a tendency of people to assimilate, even confound, these two, despite their inherent and important differences between the ionizing and nonionizing radiation types that these two energy sources represent. Another interesting conclusion was reached when the Spanish Association Against Cancer (AECC) published a survey regarding the public perception of risk associated to electromagnetic fields in Spain. The survey took place in early 2004 and covered the entire country. The survey was per-
Table 1.1
Risk Perception for Several Daily Activities Percent Top 1 2 Score (7-10) Mean Score
Heavy Smoking
90.0
9.1
Environmental Tobacco 71.9 Smoke
7.7
Ozone Depletion
63.2
7.1
Particles in Air
59.8
7.0
Global Warming
51.4
6.4
Radon
46.7
6.2
Medical X-Rays
38.8
5.6
Electric and Magnetic Fields
38.3
5.5
Relaxing Music
5.2
1.0
1. Percentage of responses equal to 7, 8, 9, or 10 on the 10-point scale. 2. Mean score of the 1,000 respondents.
1.6 The Reason for Writing this Book
13
formed by Demoscopia, a well-reputed survey specialist company. The results were made public by a report in an ad hoc extraordinary congress with a scientific panel of the outmost quality. The main conclusion was that, for the general public, the existence of a mobile communications base station was synonymous with cancer, with percentages that made this association greater the closer a user lived to the BS. Yet, the AECC also concluded that in the light of evidence there was no proven link between the two, that research must continue, and that current legislation is adequate to protect the public health. The interesting observation of the results came when a comparison between the answers to two questions was made. When the public was asked to assert whether living close to a BS poses a risk to human health, 52.1% answered yes. Interestingly enough, this percentage rose to 63.7% when the public was asked to assert whether electromagnetic fields are linked to cancer. This happened despite cancer being just one risk to human health, and a serious one. Or in other words, the first question was more general than the second, but the word “cancer” triggered some positive responses. In this sense several organizations are asking for more epidemiological data on long-term exposure to EMF, yet at the same time, concerns are also being published on the required rigor of these studies and the need to make them comparable and reproducible. At the same time, there are many medical applications that employ microwave energy which are common practice nowadays. The list includes bone healing, dental caries treatment, hyperthermia cancer treatment, and many therapeutic procedures. To obtain the whole picture regarding electromagnetic exposure to EMF, an update on the possibilities of existing therapeutic applications of high frequency electromagnetic energy and a description of future avenues currently under R&D is performed in Chapter 9.
1.6
The Reason for Writing this Book The risk perception about electromagnetic fields, evaluated by the HCRA, has changed in the last few years mainly due to the influence of mass media. In 1999 the National Radiological Protection Board (NRPB) in the United Kingdom provided different data. In the period under analysis, from August to October 1999, the NRPB received one-quarter of all queries related to risks presumably associated with electromagnetic fields, and from these queries a significant 41% were devoted to mobile communications base stations. The recently completed coordinating action by the EU on a “European Information System on Electromagnetic Fields Exposure and Health Impact,” developed through the Joint Research Center at Ispra (Italy), revealed that risk communication in the European Union has been significantly hampered by the absence of a clear strategy to promote cooperation among policy makers to exchange experiences, and to develop common approaches and coordinated communication actions on public health and EMF issues. More research is therefore needed in order to estimate with enhanced accuracy the differences between risk perception related to electromagnetic fields for the general public and for the scientific community. Even for the scientific community risk perception related to EMFs has a large variance [50].
14
Introduction
What is clear is the fact that communication between scientists, governments, telecommunication operators, and the general public has failed, and that new communication tools are required to recover the lost confidence of the general public on official statements by health protection agencies worldwide. The public demands information that can be trusted, and it deserves communication strategies that can make information understandable by cooperative schemes between governments, companies, scientists, researchers, and the general public. Increased dialogue is the way forward, and this book intends to put together some of the latest developments and issues that have been settled for quite some time through numerous papers with the scientific independence of electromagnetic dosimetry research. In this way we intend to address the issue of high frequency electromagnetic dosimetry from a rigorous engineering point of view. We have already mentioned that adverse behavioral effects could be observed in primates for exposure rates over ~4 W/kg, and a safety factor or 10 was established for workers (occupational exposure), and an additional factor of 5 (making a total of 50) for general public, thus deriving the SAR limit of 0.08 W/kg, averaged over the whole body. This general limit is shared by most guidelines worldwide. Yet, there are additional safety factors which are not mentioned for electromagnetic dosimetry. These additional safety factors include the following: 1. The human thermoregulatory model is certainly capable of coping with more absorbed energy that those of primates or rodents (Factor W). 2. The threshold limit was established for observed behavioral effects, which may not be a threat to health (Factor X). 3. The reference levels for evaluating external fields were calculated for the worst-case coupling scenario and plane waves, which is not normally the case (Factor Y). 4. Measurements performed to test whether the external fields conform to the safety limits are normally performed over worst-case traffic scenarios, or even extrapolated to account for technology-variables such as discontinuous transmission or power control [51], which again is not the usual exposure situation (Factor Z). Consequently, the safety factor for human health protection (depicted in Figure 1.1) is really, Safety Factor = W × X × 10 × 5 × Y × Z
(1.1)
Thus, knowing two out of six different safety factors means that there is still a large degree of uncertainty when ruling limits to electromagnetic dosimetry. In fact, the uncertainty lays mainly on hazardous thermal dose induced by EMF exposure. The thermal threshold values for discomfort have already been made dependent upon metabolic rate and weight, as well as on the tube-restrained mice conditions [52]. On top of this, the diverse safety factors help determining safety limits with a large overprotection, intended to cover special cases such as infants (for which the thermoregulatory model and electromagnetic coupling scenario is certainly different from adults), pregnant women [53, 54], or simply more sensitive people. Yet, with the current state of science the uncertainties could be reduced, which does not necessarily mean that the existing limits would be relaxed. In contrast, we could gain knowledge in how large are these safety factors, which in turn could help develop
1.6 The Reason for Writing this Book
15
0.0006 mW/cm2
Average value at street level (100m)
2
0.006 mW/cm Average value close to a BS (7m) 0.06 mW/cm2 0.8 mW/cm2 4 mW/cm2 40 mW/cm2 60 mW/cm2
No exposure Average exposure Average close exposure
Maximum value close to a BS (7m) ICNIRP max. permissible exposure limit Observable behavioral effects on primates Possible cytotoxic effects Possible risk to human health
High-frequency electromagnetic dosimetry
Maximum close exposure Maximum permissible exposure Behavioral effects exposure Potentially hazardous exposure Possible hazardous exposure
Figure 1.1
Safety factors for human health protection on EMF exposure.
novel applications. The use of thermal dose induced by accurate prediction of electromagnetic dosimetry is gaining acceptance for deriving more precise safety limits. In contrast, limits are normally evaluated today in the absence of a person; that is, in terms of external field values. According to the physical principle of the Grotthuss-Draper Law, a physical agent can only have an effect on the human body if it can get into it. Electromagnetic fields can certainly get into the human body. With electromagnetic fields recently having been treated legally as a physical agent in the European Union [55], this book clearly identifies current flaws on safety guidelines worldwide which can help in the reviewing processes. For instance, in a near-field scenario, it is more adequate to measure the amount of energy deposed on the human body and its ratios to the energies absorbed and dissipated through thermoregulation, as well as the specific temperature increments that the exposure to electromagnetic fields can provide, rather than incident electromagnetic fields due to the large amount of energy reflected and scattered. This is done despite the authors’ opinion that current guideline safety limits provide adequate protection levels to the general public with the scientific evidence that exists today, in agreement with numerous official statements. Yet, we believe that scientific rigor is the way to progress in a scientific discipline, and this book also tries to contribute to the response to the recent petitions of CSTEE to continue investigating in the field and of WHO to provide studies with reliable exposure assessments with improved accuracy and validity [39, 56]. With this in mind, this book is intended for engineers, physicists, researchers, biologists, and others who are not necessarily doing research on the field but are either interested by the problem or are frequently asked about it.
16
Introduction
The precise up-to-date compilation of information in this book provides an accurate, independent, and complete source of information at a glance. In addition, this book provides any researcher in the field is a detailed review of the state of science.
References [1] [2]
[3]
[4]
[5] [6]
[7]
[8]
[9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14]
[15]
[16]
[17]
Wartenberg, D., and Greenberg, M., “Epidemiology, the press and the EMF controversy. Public understand,” SCI, Vol.1, pp. 383–394, 1992. Martínez-González, A.M., “Estudio y desarrollo de técnicas de evaluación de dosimetría electromagnética y de niveles de exposición a emisiones radioeléctricas,” Ph.D dissertation, February 2004 (in Spanish). von Elm, E., et al., “The strengthening the reporting of observational studies in epidemiology (STROBE) statement: Guidelines for reporting observational studies,” PLOS Medicine, Vol. 4, No. 10, pp. 1623–1627, October 2007. Berg, G., et al., “The assessment of radiofrequency exposure from cellular telephone daily use in an epidemiological study: German validation study of the international case-control study of cancers of the brain— INTERPHONE-Study,” J. Expo. Anal. Environ. Epidemiol., Vol. 15, No. 3, pp. 217–224, May 2005. Lonn, S., et al., “Swedish Interphone Study Group. Long-term mobile phone use and brain tumor risk,” Am. J. Epidemiol., Vol. 161, No. 6, pp. 526–535, March 2005. Schüz, J., et al., “Cellular phones, cordless phones, and the risks of glioma and meningioma (Interphone Study Group, Germany),” American Journal of Epidemiology, Vol. 163, No. 6, pp. 512–520, Jan. 2006. Sage, C., et al., “Personal digital assistant (PDA) cell phone units produce elevated extremely-low frequency electromagnetic field emissions,” Bioelectromagnetics, Vol. 28, pp. 386–392, 2007. Schüz, J., and Johansen, C., “A comparison of self-reported cellular telephone use with subscriber data: agreement between the two methods and implications for risk estimation,” Bioelectromagnetics, Vol. 28, pp. 130–136, 2007. Lahkola, A., et al., “Mobile phone use and risk of glioma in 5 North European countries,” Int. J. Cancer, Vol. 120, pp. 1769–1775, 2007. Hepworth, S.J., et al., “Mobile phone use and risk of glioma in adults: case-control study,” British Medical Journal, Vol. 15, pp. 883–887, April 2006. INTERPHONE Study, “Results update,” 25 September 2007. Cardis, E., et al., “Distribution of RF energy emitted by mobile phones in anatomical structures of the brain,” Phys. Med. Biol., Vol. 53, pp. 2771–2783, 2008. Rajakesari, S., “Cell phones and brain tumours,” EPIB671 Student Symposium, 2008. Boutry, C.M., et al., “Dosimetric Evaluation and Comparison of Different RF Exposure Apparatuses Used in Human Volunteer Studies,” Bioelectromagnetics, Vol. 29, pp.11–19, 2008. Beard, B.B., and Kainz, W., “Review and standardization of cell phone exposure calculations using the SAM phantom and anatomically correct head models,” Biomedical Engineering OnLine, Vol. 3, pp. 34–44, 2004. Apollonio, F., et al., “Definition and development of an automated procedure for narrowband measurements,” Radiation Protection Dosimetry, Vol. 97, No. 4, pp. 375–381, 2001. Barbiroli, M., et al., “Evaluation of exposure levels generated by Cellular systems: methodology and results,” IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology, Vol. 51, No. 6, pp. 1322–1329, 2002.
1.6 The Reason for Writing this Book
17
[18] Anderson, V., and McIntosh, R., “Guidelines for the RF exposure assessment of metallic implants,” in International EMF Dosimetry Handbook, available at http://www.emfdosimetry.org/. [19] Kuster, N., et al., “Guidance for exposure design of human studies addressing health risk evaluations of mobile phones,” Bioelectromagnetics, Vol. 25, pp. 524–529, 2004. [20] Kuster, N., et al., “Methodology of Detailed Dosimetry and Treatment of Uncertainty and Variations for InVivo Studies,” Bioelectromagnetics, Vol. 27, pp. 378–391, 2006. [21] Bernardi, P.; Cavagnaro, M.; Pisa, S.; Piuzzi, E.; “Human exposure to radio base-station antennas in urban environment,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, 2000, Vol. 48, No. 11, pp. 1996–2002, 2000. [22] Lautru, D., et al., “Calculation of the power deposited in a phantom close to a base station antenna using a hybrid FDTD-MoMTD approach,” 30th European Microwave Conference, Paris, pp. 304–307, 2000. [23] Bahr, A., et al., “Occupational safety in the near field of GSM base stations,” 2000 International Millennium Conference on Antennas & Propagation (AP-2000), Davos, Switzerland, 2000. [24] Cooper, J., et al., “Determination of safety distance limits for a human near a cellular base station antenna, adopting the IEEE standard or ICNIRP guidelines,” Bioelectromagnetics, Vol. 23, pp. 429–443, 2002. [25] International Commission for Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection, “Guidelines for limiting exposure to time-varying electric, magnetic, and electromagnetic fields (up to 300 GHz),” Health Physics, Vol. 74, pp. 494–522, 1998. [26] Michaelson, S. M., and Elson, E. C., “Modulated fields and “window” effects,” Biological Effects of Electromagnetic Fields, Boca Raton, FL, CRC Press, pp. 435–533, 1996. [27] Adair, E.R., Adams, B.W., and Akel, G.M., “Minimal changes in hypothalamic temperature accompany microwave-induced alteration of thermoregulatory behavior,” Bioelectromagnetics, Vol. 5, pp. 13–30, 1984. [28] Hardy, J.D., “The nature of pain,” J. Chronic Dis., Vol. 4, No. 22, 1956. [29] Morita, M., Hirata, A., and Shiozawa, T., “Temperature increases in the human head exposed to EM waves emitted from a dipole antenna at various microwave frequencies,” Proc. OFSET 2000, Osaka, Japan, pp. 283–286, Dec. 2000. [30] Guyton, A.C., and Hall, J.E., Textbook of Medical Physiology, Philadelphia, PA: Saunders, Ch. 73, 1996. [31] Spiegel, R.J., “A review of numerical models for predicting the energy deposition and resultant thermal response of humans exposed to electromagnetic fields,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 32, pp. 730–746, 1984. [32] Lin, J.C., “Safety standards for human exposure to radio frequency radiation and their biological rationale,” IEE Microwave Magazine, pp. 22–26, Dec. 2003. [33] Adair, E.R., and Petersen, R.C., “Biological effects of radio-frequency/microwave radiation,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 50, No. 3, pp. 953–962, March 2002. [34] McIntosh, R.L., Anderson, V., and McKenzie, R.J., “A numerical evaluation of SAR distribution and temperature changes around a metallic plate in the head of a RF exposed worker,” Bioelectromagnetics, Vol. 26, pp. 377–388, 2005. [35] Virtanen, H., Huttunen, J., Toropainen, A., and Lappalainen, R., “Interaction of mobile phones with superficial passive metallic implants,” Physics in Medicine and Biology, Vol. 50, pp. 2689–2700, 2005. [36] Fayos-Fernández, J., Arranz-faz, C., Martínez-González, A.M., and Sánchez-Hernández, D., “Effect of pierced metallic objects on SAR distributions at 900 MHz,” Bioelectromagnetics, Vol. 27, pp. 337–353, 2006. [37] Scientific committee on toxicity, ecotoxicity and the environment (CSTEE), “Opinion on possible effects of electromagnetic fields (EMF), radio frequency fields (RF) and microwave
18
Introduction
[38]
[39]
[40] [41]
[42]
[43] [44] [45] [46] [47]
[48] [49] [50]
[51]
[52]
[53]
[54] [55]
radiation on human health,” Brussels, C2/JCD/csteeop/EMF/RFF30102001/D(01), Oct. 2001. Scientific committee on toxicity, ecotoxicity, and the environment (CSTEE), “Opinion of the CSTEE on effects of electromagnetic fields on health,” Brussels,C2/AST/csteeop/EMF 24092002/D(02), Sept. 2002. Scientific committee on toxicity, ecotoxicity, and the environment (CSTEE), “Opinion of the CSTEE on effects of electromagnetic fields on health-appendix to the opinion expressed on 24 September 2002,” Brussels,C2/VR/csteeop/EMF 17122002/D(02), Dec. 2002. WHO Fact Sheet no. 374, “Electromagnetic fields and public health base stations and wireless technologies,” May 2006. IEC 62209-1, “Human exposure to radio frequency fields from hand-held and body-mounted wireless communication devices, Part 1: procedures to determine the specific absorption rate (SAR) for hand-held devices used in close proximity to the ear (frequency range of 300 MHz to 3 GHz),” February 2005. Ahlbom, A., et al., “Possible effects of electromagnetic fields (EMF) on human health—Opinion of the Scientific Committee on Emerging and Newly Identified Health Risks (SCENIHR),” Toxicology, Vol. 246, pp. 248–250, March 2008. UNEP/WHO/IRPA, “Electromagnetic fields (300 Hz to 300 GHz). Environmental Health Criteria 137,” World Health Organization, Geneva, 1993. Strayer, D.L., Johnston, W.A. & Grison, S., “Driven to distraction: studies of driving and cellular phone use,” Psychonomic Soc., Vol. 4, No. 16 (Conference Abstract), 1999. Brookhuis, K.A, De Vries, G. & Waard, D., “The effects of mobile telephoning on driving performance,” Accid. Anal. Prev., Vol. 23, No. 309, 1991. Violanti, J.M., “Cellular phones and fatal traffic collisions,” Accid. Anal. Prev., Vol. 29, No. 265, 1998. Arbete Och Hälsa Vetenskaplig Skriftserie (National Swedish Institute of Working Life). “Industrial relations and social affairs. Possible health implications of subjective symptoms and electromagnetic fields. A report prepared by a European group of experts for the European Commission, Directorate General V Employment, public health analysis, policy and programme coordination and development,” 1997. WHO, “The international EMF projects: Progress report 2003-2004,” World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland, 2004. Harvard Center for Risk Analysis, “Workers, EMFs and cancer,” Report Vol. 3, No. 2, Boston, Mass, U.S.A., 1995. Covello, V., “Educating and informing the public about radiation risks: A review of obstacles to public understanding,” OECD Workshop on Public Understanding of Radiation Protection Concepts, Paris, 1987. Martínez-González, A.M., et al., “Practical procedure for verification of compliance of digital mobile radio base stations to limitations of exposure of the general public to electromagnetic fields,” IEE Proceedings on Microwaves, Antennas & Propagation, Vol. 149, pp. 218–228, 2002. Ebert, S., et al., “ Response, thermal regulatory threshold and thermal breakdown threshold of restrained RF-exposed mice at 905 MHz,” Phys. Med. Biol., Vol. 50, pp. 5203–5215, 2005. Kainz, W., et al., “Calculation of induced current densities and specific absorption rates (SAR) for pregnant women exposed to hand-held metal detectors,” Phys. Med. Biol., Vol. 48, pp. 2551–2560, 2003. Dimbylow, P., “SAR in the mother and foetus for RF plane wave irradiation,” Phys. Med. Biol., Vol. 52, pp. 3791–3802, 2007. “Directive 2004/40/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29 April 2004 on the minimum health and safety requirements regarding the exposure of workers to the risks arising from physical agents (electromagnetic fields) (18th individual Directive within the meaning of Article 16(1) of Directive 89/391/EEC,” Official Journal of the European
1.6 The Reason for Writing this Book
19
Union, L 159 of 30 April 2004, Corrigenda in Official Journal of the European Union L 184 of 25 May 2004. [56] Repacholi, M.H., and van Deventer, T.E., “WHO policy framework: A case study on electromagnetic fields,” Workshop on Guiding Public Health Policy Options in Areas of Scientific Uncertainty, Ottawa, Canada, 11–15 July, 2005.
CHAPTER 2
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter Alejandro Díaz-Morcillo, Juan Monzó-Cabrera, and Miguel A. García-Fernández
2.1
Introduction Since the seventeenth century, when Otto von Guericke developed the first electrical machine, and with the continuous electronic technology development ever since, human interest in physics as a science and its relation to the electrical phenomena and their biological effects has been increasing. In 1941 a team of physicists and engineers measured the absorbed energy in a patient during a diathermy process, wherein an electrical current was applied to produce heating over the patient’s ill parts, and estimated that this energy was roughly 5%. Results were expressed in absorbed energy per volume (W/liter), which is similar to the magnitude actually employed to quantify the absorbed electromagnetic energy by biological tissues, the specific absorption rate (SAR), expressed in W/Kg and usually normalized to 1W of transmitted power. During the first half of the twentieth century, radiofrequency energy found many applications in industry, science, medicine, communications, transport, and defense, among others. Radiofrequency heating effects have been successfully used in cancer treatment, physiotherapy, and food and industry heating applications such as wood manufacturing, leather drying, or rubber vulcanization processes applied to the automobile or footwear industries. With the arrival of new, more powerful radiofrequency energy sources, the potential risks associated with human exposure to electromagnetic fields also increased, and this brought the necessity of developing appropriate security regulations, as well as standardized measurement and exposure evaluation techniques. In June 1993, David Reynard, of the United States, sued the mobile phone company where his wife bought the mobile phone. According to him, the use of the mobile phone caused or aggravated his wife’s brain cancer, which was the final cause of her death. The David Reynard affair received a large amount of radio, television, and press coverage in the United States, and it is now perceived as the first alarm in modern times of public concern related to human health and the exposure to electromagnetic fields, particularly those produced by mobile phone usage. U.S. courts did not find in his favor, considering that there was no conclusive proof that
21
22
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
associated the use of the mobile phone and the brain cancer developed by his wife. Nevertheless, an important debate began about the health security offered by mobile phones, and the mobile phone and mobile communications industry witnessed a fundamental questioning of the health risks posed by its technology. It is not the aim of this book to raise these issues, but rather to engineer them. Since there is a vast number of papers and books related to the basic fundamentals of human interaction with electromagnetic fields, this chapter will only briefly describe the most important parameters, with specific interest devoted to the role of dielectric properties on final electromagnetic dosimetry evaluation. An advanced reader is referred to the references at the end of the chapter for further details.
2.2
Electromagnetic Dosimetry 2.2.1
Definition
Electromagnetic dosimetry establishes the relationship between an electromagnetic field distribution in free space and the induced fields inside biological tissues, generally the human body. Mobile phones, and other portable devices used in mobile communications systems, emit radiofrequency energy, which may be as low as a few watts (W) in the case of some mobile phone terminals and as high as a hundred of watts for some mobile phone stations. In normal operation conditions, mobile phones cause a higher exposure level than mobile phone stations, although radiated power for these devices is usually lower than 10W. This is mainly due to the immediate vicinity of the radiofrequency (RF) source for mobile phones with users’ vital organs, particularly the brain. For mobile base stations the exposure level is normally reduced by the distance from the user to the source of energy. In Western countries, until 1982 the exposure to radiofrequency electromagnetic fields in the band of 100 kHz to 100 GHz was quantified in terms of the incident power density measured in Watts/m2. Actual exposure to electromagnetic fields in the band of 3 kHz to 300 GHz is quantified in terms of electric field, magnetic field, and incident power density according to several standardization guidelines [1, 2]. The absorption phenomenon is different when exposure occurs in the near-field region or in the far-field region of the electromagnetic fields. In the close vicinity of a radiofrequency source, the fields are complicated and power density is not defined in this situation since only one direction of incidence simply does not exist. Nevertheless, for most user positions, portable devices provide a radiofrequency exposure only a few centimeters away from the source. At locations close to the source, the direction of propagation of radiofrequency energy is not the Pointing vector direction, which is defined in the far-field region as r 1r r P = E × H* 2
(2.1)
r r where E is the electric field intensity and H * the complex conjugate of the magnetic field intensity. Complex numerical tools or near-field probes are required for proper evaluation of the exposure in these scenarios. Exposure in the far-field region is quite different;
2.2 Electromagnetic Dosimetry
23
it is limited in terms of the electromagnetic field that is present in absence of the human body and assuming plane wave interaction and coupling, and has to be evaluated according to some well-defined procedures [3, 4]. For low frequencies, the human body absorption is low. For higher frequencies, the absorbed energy increases up to the maximum value. For an adult human body this occurs at resonance frequency between 30 and 80 MHz (depending upon the height). When an electromagnetic wave arrives at the human body in far-field conditions with linear z-axis polarization, it can induce electric currents when the wavelength is 1.5 to 5 times the individual height depending on the isolation conditions [5, 6]. Thus, in the far-field region, frequency, polarization, and the body dimensions constitute fundamental parameters for evaluating the radiofrequency energy absorption [7]. But since the human body does not have magnetic materials, it does not absorb significant amounts of magnetic energy. The human body is formed basically of water, electrolytes, and molecules with a dipolar momentum which is able to interact with the electric field. Consequently, the human body extracts the energy from an electromagnetic field mainly by its ionic activity [8]. 2.2.2
Electromagnetic Fields and Matter
For an exhaustive analysis of the electromagnetic problem defined by a radiating source and an exposed body, the well-known Maxwell equations must be solved, r r ∂B (2.2) ∇×E= − ∂t r r r ∂D (2.3) ∇×H = J+ ∂t r (2.4) ∇ ⋅D = ρ r ∇⋅B = 0
(2.5)
r r where D is the electric flux density, the magnetic flux density, ρ the volumetric B r density of electric charge, and J the surface density of electric current. These equations relate the electric and magnetic fields, and these with the electric charges and currents in the domain of the problem. Maxwell equations are complemented by the so-named constitutive relations, r r (2.6) D = εE r r (2.7) B = μH which introduce the material electromagnetic properties in the problem (i.e., the electric permittivity ε [F/m] and the magnetic permeability μ [H/m]). Basically, the electric permittivity provides a description of the macroscopic interaction between the electric field intensity vector and the dielectric material, whereas the magnetic permeability describes the interaction of the material with the magnetic field. Tak-
24
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
ing into account these relationships, (2.2) through (2.5) can be rewritten for the frequency domain as r r (2.8) ∇ × E = − jωμH r r r ∇ × H = σE + jωεE
(2.9)
r ∇ ⋅ εE = ρ
( )
(2.10)
r ∇ ⋅ μH = 0
(2.11)
( )
where ω is the angular frequency. By applying the curl operator on (2.8) r r r r ∇ × ∇ × E = jωμ∇ × H = − jωμ J + jωεE
(
)
(
)
(2.12)
(2.8) and (2.9) can be uncoupled, and the problem is set up by means of the vector wave equation with its electric field formulation, r r r ∇ × ∇ × E − ω 2 μεE = − jωμJ
(
)
(2.13)
In the same manner, the application of the curl operator on (2.9) leads to the vector wave equation for magnetic field formulation, r r r J (2.14) ∇ × ∇ × H − ω 2 μεH = ∇ × ε
(
)
Materials involved in dosimetry simulations (human tissues and different clothes: cotton, silk, leather, etc.) are nonmagnetic, and therefore, their magnetic −7 permeability is the vacuum one (μ = μ0 = 4π · 10 H/m). This points out the electric permittivity as the key material property for determining the electromagnetic field distribution in the body under study and, therefore, the power dissipated in it. The negligible anisotropy of human tissues and fabrics simplifies the general tensor form of the electric permittivity into a scalar and complex magnitude, ε = ε 0 ( ε ′ − jε ′′ )
(2.15)
where ε 0 = 8.854 × 10 −12 F/m is the electric permittivity of the vacuum, ε ′ the dielectric constant, and ε ′′ the loss factor. The relative electric permittivity ( r) is often used in the specialized literature, since it is a dimensionless quantity, εr =
ε = ε ′ − jε ′′ = ε ′(1 − j tan δ) ε0
where tan δ is the dielectric loss tangent.
(2.16)
2.2 Electromagnetic Dosimetry
25
It is generally admitted that the dielectric constant expresses the ability of the material to store electric energy and the loss factor (or the loss tangent) describes the energy dissipation due to polarization mechanisms within the dielectric [9]. This dissipation of electromagnetic energy and the resulting heat generation can be explained by the friction of microscopic dipoles at molecular or atomic level, produced when an electric field is applied and the dipoles try to follow the field variations, as Figure 2.1 shows. It is usual to extend the meaning of the electric permittivity in order to take into account not only dielectric dissipation, but also conduction or ohmic losses, since separation of both effects is normally not possible. By applying the Ohm law, r r (2.17) J = σE in (2.13), the homogeneous vector wave equation is obtained, r σ⎞ r ⎛ ∇ × ∇ × E − ω 2 μ⎜ ε − j ⎟ E = 0 ⎝ ω⎠
(
)
(2.18)
By comparing with (2.13) the new or effective electric permittivity is given by ε ef = ε − j
σ ω
(2.19)
Thus, while conduction does not affect the dielectric constant, it modifies the loss factor, ⎛ σ ⎞ ε ef = ε 0 ⎜ ε ′ − jε ′′ − j ⎟ = ε 0 ε ′ef − jε ′′ef ωε ⎝ 0⎠
(
)
(2.20)
where ε ′ef = ε ′
Figure 2.1
Dipole microscopic reorientation in dielectric materials.
(2.21)
26
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
ε ′′ef = ε ′′ +
σ ωε 0
(2.22)
As it is observed in (2.22), the effect of ionic conductivity is inversely proportional to operating frequency. From these new parameters an effective loss tangent can be defined, tan δ ef =
ε ef′′ ε ef′
(2.23)
Usually electric conductivity is preferred to express material losses, mainly for SAR calculations. It is possible to define an effective conductivity that takes into account the dielectric losses by relating it with the effective loss factor, ε ′′ef =
σ ef ωε 0
→ σ ef = ωε 0 ε ef′′ = ωε 0 ε ′ef tan δ ef
(2.24)
These effective parameters will be used throughout the chapter, eliminating the subindex for the sake of simplicity. An interesting phenomenon related to conductivity is the skin effect. It is normally related with electric conductors and can be defined as the tendency of a high frequency electric field to distribute itself within a conductor so that the current density near the surface is much greater than that at its core, with an exponential decrease x
r r −δ p J = J0 e
(2.25)
r where J 0 is the current density at the surface, and δp is the so-named penetration depth. For electric conductors the penetration depth can be obtained as δp =
1 πfμσ
(2.26)
This phenomenon can be generalized to any lossy material, not only conductors. For a lossy dielectric material, the penetration depth is given by δp =
1 2 ⎤ μ0 ε0 ε′ ⎡ ⎛ ε ′′ ⎞ ω ⎢ 1 + ⎜ ⎟ − 1⎥ ⎝ ε′ ⎠ 2 ⎢⎣ ⎥⎦
(2.27)
Taking into account that tan δ < 1 for biological tissues, (2.27) shows that the dielectric constant ε ′ determines the penetration of the wave in the body. Once the electric field distribution in the problem is known, the heat generated per volume unit and time unit [W/m3] by the radiofrequency energy (i.e., the absorbed power per volume unit) can be expressed, from (2.1), as
2.2 Electromagnetic Dosimetry
27
r 2 Q gen ( x , y, z ) = πfε 0 ε ′′( x , y, z ) E( x , y, z )
(2.28)
where x, y, z are the Cartesian coordinates of an arbitrary reference system containing the human body. Alternatively, this power can be obtained from the conductivity of the material as Q gen ( x , y, z ) =
r 2 1 σ( x , y, z ) E( x , y, z ) 2
(2.29)
The total power absorbed inside the object or body can be obtained by integrating throughout the whole object, r 2 P = πfε 0 ∫ ε ′′( x , y, z ) = E( x , y, z ) dV
(2.30)
V
Roughly, the electric field distribution is mainly determined by the dielectric constant ε ′ whilst the quantity of absorbed power for a given electric field distribution depends mainly on the loss factor ε ′′. 2.2.3
Specific Absorption Rate
When dealing with health issues in the near-field between 100 kHz and 10 GHz, and in order to prevent whole-body heat stress and excessive localized heating of tissues, it is usual to provide basic restrictions on specific absorption rate (SAR) values. SAR is defined as the time rate at which energy is deposited in any kind of material per unit of mass; that is, the power absorbed by the tissue per unit of mass. Thus, SAR is the parameter employed to quantify the electromagnetic absorption inside biological tissues like human body. It is also defined as the ratio between the infinitesimal amount of radiofrequency power absorbed in the infinitesimal mass of tissue surrounding a specific point. In other terms, SAR can be seen as the velocity at which the human body absorbs the electromagnetic energy. In practice SAR is normalized to the maximum radiated power and, from (2.29), is related with the electric field by SAR =
σ r2 E ρ
(2.31)
r 3 where ρ is the tissue density [kg/m ] and E refers to the rms electric field value [10]. SAR can also be defined as the time derivative of the absorbed energy by a differential element of mass contained in a differential volume with a known density [11] by SAR =
d ⎛ dW ⎞ d ⎛ dW ⎞ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ = dt ⎝ dm ⎠ dt ⎝ ρdv ⎠
(2.32)
Should total RF absorbed power need to be calculated, the following integral has to be solved:
28
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
P=
∫ SARdm = ∫ SARρdV
M
(2.33)
V
where M is the total mass for the organ under study, which can be the human body. The time integral of SAR is known as specific absorption (SA), and it is evaluated as the relationship between the electromagnetic field energy (EMF) energy [dW] absorbed by a differential mass element (dm). SA =
dW dm
(2.34)
These concepts of SA and SAR have been inherited by medical science, which uses them routinely for the treatment of tumors with ionizing radiation, yet with a dosimetric concept essentially different to the one employed in the radioelectric scenario. SAR also has a relationship to other parameters, such as the induced current density in biological tissues as a consequence of their exposure to electromagnetic energy. Hence, another way of evaluating SAR is by SAR =
J2 ρσ
(2.35)
2
where J is expressed in A/m . Due to the induced currents, the biological tissues suffer a temperature increase. SAR is also related to this increment, and in the linear stage wherein no thermoregulation process takes place, no heat diffusion is accounted for and there is no heat loss, this relationship can be expressed by SAR = c
ΔT ΔT ≅ 4186c H Δt Δt
(2.36)
where c is the specific heat of the tissue in J/kgK, cH is the specific heat capacity in kcal/kgK, 4186 is the figure that converts kilocalories to Joules, ΔT is the temperature increment in K, and Δt is the exposure time in seconds. From all these definitions for SAR it is clear that the RF energy absorption phenomenon in the human body is a very complex issue. On the one hand, tissue conductivity depends on both frequency and tissue constitution [12]. σ = σ( x , y, z, f )
(2.37)
Moreover, conductivity also depends on temperature, as we will see in Section 2.3.2. The volumetric tissue density, on the other hand, also changes with tissue type since it is a water-content dependent variable. The electric field inside the tissue depends upon many other factors, such as the dielectric properties, shape, size, orientation, polarization and frequency, source configuration, and exposure environment, among others. On top of this, (2.31) to (2.35) are only valid for sinusoidal fields in permanent state, and since it is usual that an electric field in mobile communications has a temporal variation different to a continuous wave (CW), and modulated through complex procedures, the above formulas could be used for well-defined worst-case scenarios only. Evaluating the exposure is particularly diffi-
2.3 Dielectric Properties
29
cult for spread spectrum signals, such as in the Universal Mobile Telecommunication System (UMTS), with code division multiple access (CDMA) technology, wherein proper evaluation is only achieved if conductivity values for all employed frequencies are used. Despite these difficulties, SAR is widely accepted by the main normalization and standardization agencies as the magnitude of reference for limiting the exposure to electromagnetic fields in the near-field. Using SAR to limit EMF exposure steals part of the main role of incident electromagnetic fields; that is, it highlights the fact that it is a near-field situation rather than a far-field one. Despite the simplification that could arise from using field imitations in the near-field, the complexity of field values in the near-field region makes this task extremely complicated, and exposure evaluation is then divided into two main scenarios, that of near-field and the far-field. Likewise, both near- and far-field situations can occur at indoor and outdoor scenarios, but SAR is evaluated in the near-field using complicated and unstable equipment at indoor facilities.
2.3
Dielectric Properties As described earlier, the permittivity of human tissues are responsible for both electromagnetic field distribution within the human body and heat conversion of that energy. Therefore, tissues permittivity measurement is a key issue for SAR estimation or prediction. In this section the most popular techniques for permittivity measurement are described, the current knowledge of dielectric properties is reviewed, and the role of these dielectric properties on SAR is also reviewed and discussed. 2.3.1
Measurement Techniques
Dielectric materials are widely used in many applications ranging from communication devices to military satellite services, and therefore, permittivity characterization is a very important task in many technological areas. Because of this, from early 1950s to present day measurement permittivity techniques have been continuously developed and improved [13]. There are many review contributions on complex permittivity measurement methods [14–19]. These methods can be very roughly classified as resonant or nonresonant methods depending on the used measurement cells. The impedance analyzer has been employed for tissue permittivity estimation [12] mainly for frequencies below 1 GHz. This technique is based on the use of a parallel plate and can be used up to 1.8 GHz [20]. The parallel plate method, also called the three terminal method in ASTM D150 [21], involves sandwiching a thin sheet of material or liquid between two electrodes to form a capacitor. The advantages of this method are high accuracy and easy sample preparation. However, the method cannot be used at higher frequencies due to edge fields escaping from the parallel plates. Transmission lines such as coaxial cables, microstrip lines, or waveguides have also been used for permittivity estimation with transmission-reflection techniques. Resonators based on those transmission lines have also been used mainly for estima-
30
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
tion of low-loss material properties. In this last case, resonance frequency and quality factors changes within the resonator are used for permittivity estimation. The dielectric properties of human tissues have called the attention of the scientific community for several reasons. First of all, conductivity is needed for SAR calculations and estimation as shown earlier. Second, permittivity maps for the human body allow for a proper modeling of interaction of EM waves and human tissues. For instance, at millimeter-wave frequencies, the absorption of electromagnetic radiation is mostly due to skin permittivity because of the small penetration depths at these frequencies [22], but at lower frequencies the different tissue layers may interact with each other to provide electric field resonances at certain tissue locations due to impedance mismatch, as shown in [23]. Therefore, a better human tissue permittivity characterization will lead to better SAR estimation and measurement when using phantoms for SAR compliance tests of communication devices. In the following paragraphs we describe and assess the most popular permittivity measurement techniques. Two kinds of measurement methods are reviewed in this section: nonresonant and resonant ones. In the first case, the propagation constant and impedance variations due to the material interaction with the transmission line can be related to the permittivity of the material. In the second one, the dielectric constant and loss factor are derived from changes in resonant frequencies and quality factors of resonant structures such as cavities or dielectric resonators [13]. Both resonant and nonresonant methods can be implemented in different technologies such as waveguides, coaxial, microstrip, or coplanar transmission lines. The election of the measurement cell or method depends on many factors such as availability, material dimensions and mechanization possibilities, accuracy specifications, bandwidth measurement needs, and so on. In the specific case of electromagnetic dosimetry, one has to decide whether to carry out measurements for in vivo tissues or in vitro ones, which also determines the most suitable permittivity measurement method. 2.3.1.1
Nonresonant Methods
Nonresonant methods employ transmission lines such as coaxial or rectangular waveguides as measurement cells which are in interaction with the material to be measured. Two types of approaches are mainly used in nonresonant methods: reflection measurements and transmission/reflection techniques. Reflection Methods
In this case, the material is placed at the end of the transmission line and reflections in the sample-air interface within the transmission line are used to derive its relative permittivity. Two kinds of reflections can again be generated at the end of the transmission lines: open-circuit and short-circuit ones. In open-circuit reflection methods the material is placed at the end of the transmission line and the end of the line is left in an open-circuit configuration. In contrast, in short-circuit reflection techniques the end of the line is short-circuited after the sample. Therefore, a practical implication derives from each approach: in short-circuit methods the sample must be placed within the transmission line, whereas in open-reflection methods the sample is outside the line.
2.3 Dielectric Properties
31
Coaxial Dielectric Probe
Figure 2.2 shows the scheme of the basic measurement configuration of an open-reflection method. In this case, a coaxial line is depicted and the sample is placed at the end of the coaxial open-circuit. As it can be observed, the outer conductor at the open end is usually fabricated into a flange to ensure a proper capacitance and repeatability of sample loading. This configuration is typically called coaxial dielectric probe [24, 25]. Usually coaxial lines are preferred for the implementation of the open-reflection method since they can cover broad frequency bands. In fact, most permittivity measurements for biological tissues are obtained by using the coaxial probe due to this characteristic and to the fact that the coaxial probe can be easily applied directly over the tissue. This method assumes that materials under test are nonmagnetic ones, which is the usual case for human tissues. There are several commercial packages (coaxial probe plus related software for both calibrating and measuring) such as the ones provided by [26] and [27] that automate complex permittivity and permeability measurements with transmission methods. As a disadvantage, low precision measurements are obtained with this method both for dielectric constant and low-loss factor values. In fact, coaxial probe should be used preferably for liquids and biological tissues under very restrictive geometrical and frequency conditions [27]. The analysis of open-ended coaxial probes is very extensive in the literature, although five typical approaches or models can be identified [28]: capacitive model [29], antenna model [30], virtual line model [31], rational function model [32], and full-wave approaches [33]. Due to its simplicity and the fact that the coaxial probe is very often used to measure biological tissues, the capacitance model is described here in detail. A good description of the rest of the approaches can be found in [13]. Capacitive Model of the Coaxial Probe
In this approach the open end of the coaxial line is modeled as two capacitances in parallel. The first capacitance (C( r)) is related to the dielectric properties of the sample, whereas the second one (Cf) is assumed to be independent of the dielectric sample. By changing the dielectric sample by those capacitances one can obtain the complex reflection coefficient at the entrance of the coaxial line as Γ=
( ) (C( ε ) + C )
1 − jωZ 0 C( ε r ) + C f 1 + jωZ 0
r
(2.38)
f
Coaxial flange Coaxial line Dielectric sample
Figure 2.2
Scheme for open-reflection measurement configuration.
32
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
where C( r) = rC0, C0 is the capacitance of the equivalent capacitor filled with air and Z0 is the characteristic impedance of the coaxial line connected to the open-ended probe. By measuring the reflection coefficient and using (2.38), one can derive the complex relative permittivity of the medium that is in contact with the open-end of the coaxial probe as expressed in (2.39). εr =
Cf 1− Γ − jωZ 0 C 0 (1 + Γ ) C 0
(2.39)
Since the two parameters of the model are unknown for a coaxial probe, both Cf and C0 must be obtained by calibrating the probe with a standard sample with known dielectric permittivity such as, for instance, deionized water [28]. Waveguide Measurements
Reflection methods can also be implemented with structures such as rectangular or cylindrical waveguides. The most common configuration consists of a rectangular waveguide short-circuited at its end. Figure 2.3 shows a rectangular waveguide containing a dielectric sample and a short-circuit at the end of the waveguide. In this case, the dielectric sample completely fills the waveguide cross-section. There are several possibilities and methods for sample size and location when using reflection methods in waveguides for measuring complex permittivity of materials. The simplest ones use a dielectric material which completely fills the waveguide cross-section such as the situation depicted in Figure 2.3 but other approaches are possible [34]. In the case of using waveguides as transmission line holders, one has to take into account that current measurement methods assume that only the fundamental mode propagates along the waveguide. For instance, this means for rectangular waveguides that the TE10 mode is the only one propagating in the waveguide [35]. This has practical consequences regarding frequencies where the method can be applied. In fact, permittivity measurements carried out in standard rectangular waveguides can only be applied from the cut-off frequency of TE10 mode to the cut-off frequency of the next mode, usually the TE20 mode. Therefore, if one has to cover a broad frequency range for the permittivity estimation and uses waveguide configurations, several waveguide cells would be necessary to cover this frequency range. On the other hand, commercial methods need the sample introduced in the waveguide to have very restrictive geometries and dimensions, which is not always easy to achieve. This means that the sample very often has to be mechanized to presShort circuit
Waveguide port
Dielectric sample
Figure 2.3 Scheme for a short-circuit reflection measurement configuration with a rectangular waveguide.
2.3 Dielectric Properties
33
ent a rectangular cross-section and consequently this measurement method is destructive. Therefore, the coaxial probe is preferred to waveguide configurations when trying to estimate permittivity on broad frequency ranges. Transmission/Reflection Methods
In transmission/reflection methods the sample is placed within the transmission line and the scattering parameters of the line are used for permittivity estimation. In this case two ports are used in the permittivity measurement and both reflections from the material interface and energy transmission through the material are used to deduce its electrical features. This method is preferred to characterize both low-loss and high-loss materials and has the advantage of providing both permittivity and permeability in just one measurement [36, 37]. Figure 2.4 shows the schematics for a transmission/reflection measurement in a rectangular waveguide. Again, commercial solutions are available for the measurement with this configuration such as the ones provided by [26] or [27]. Impedance Analysis
When using an impedance-measuring instrument to measure permittivity, the parallel plate method is usually employed. In this case, the material or liquid between two electrodes forms a capacitor whose capacitance varies as a function of the material relative dielectric constant [21]. The measured capacitance is then used to calculate permittivity. In an actual test setup, two electrodes are configured with a test fixture sandwiching dielectric material. The impedance-measuring instrument would measure vector components of capacitance (Cp) and dissipation and a software program would calculate permittivity and loss tangent from these data. Several configurations can be used for measuring the capacitance of the material. In fact, the material can be in contact with the material to be measured or not. The contacting electrode method implies that both electrodes touch the material surface as depicted in Figure 2.5. The guard electrode is needed since it absorbs the electric field at the edge of the guarded electrode and, in this way, the capacitance that is measured between the electrodes is only composed of the current that flows through the dielectric material. Therefore, accurate measurements are possible with this configuration. In this method the dielectric constant can be simply related to the capacitance measurement: εr =
t mC p
(2.40)
Aε 0
Waveguide port 2
Waveguide port 1
Figure 2.4
Dielectric sample
Configuration for transmission/reflection measurements in a rectangular waveguide.
34
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter Guard electrodes
Guarded electrode Material under test
tm
Unguarded electrode
Figure 2.5
Contacting electrode method scheme.
where tm is the material thickness, Cp is the parallel plate capacitance, A is the electrode’s surface area, and 0 is the permittivity of free space. The loss tangent can be directly related to the energy dissipation suffered across the parallel plate. The contacting electrode method requires little material preparation and measuring operation is simple. Therefore, it is the most widely used method. However, a significant measurement error can occur if air gap and its effects are not considered when using this method. A more detailed description of this measurement technique and other more precise alternatives can be found at [20]. Inverse Techniques
Sometimes the dielectric samples cannot be mechanized into canonical shapes such as cylindrical or rectangular ones due to their hardness, fragility, and so on. On the other hand, multilayer dielectric materials cannot be handled by traditional methods and they provide an effective permittivity for the whole multilayer structure. In those cases, traditional methods cannot be applied and other measurement approaches must be considered. The improvement of numerical techniques and commercial software in the electromagnetic area during the last decade have allowed the growth of new measurement methods known as inverse techniques. In these inverse techniques the sample shape is just restricted to those shapes that can be handled by the electromagnetic code and consequently the measurement possibilities are expanded when compared to traditional methods. Inverse techniques are based on the comparison of two results: those provided by the measurement cell and those ones provided by the electromagnetic software that exactly reproduces this measurement cell. The error produced during the comparison of both results is used for convergence purposes until both the measured and simulated results show a high correlation. Therefore, inverse techniques are based on optimization processes where the error between the measurement and simulated results must be minimized. Many examples of inverse techniques can be found in the literature, such as the ones shown in [38–41]. In those works the measured and simulated scattering parameters are used for comparison purposes. A common disadvantage of the different inverse techniques is the high computing times required when threedimensional scenarios must be modeled since many optimization cycles are required in order to obtain an acceptable convergence between simulated and measured results.
2.3 Dielectric Properties
2.3.1.2
35
Resonant Methods
Resonant methods use resonant structures such as cavities or dielectric resonators in order to estimate the relative permittivity of materials. Usually they are more suitable for small and low-loss dielectric samples and offer higher accuracies and sensitivities than methods based on transmission lines [13]. Therefore, these techniques are not often used for measuring biological tissues since those materials show high dielectric losses. Nevertheless, they can be useful to characterize the dielectric properties of common objects present at SAR measurements or simulations such as clothes, contact lenses, and glasses, which may present low dielectric losses. The resonance of an electromagnetic structure occurs when both the electric and magnetic energy are equal at a given frequency. Two important parameters define the resonance properties: the resonant frequency and the quality factor. The first one is related to the geometry of the resonator and the dielectric constant of the sample. The second one is related to the losses of the resonant structure, which may be classified as dielectric or metallic losses. Resonant methods may be classified into two groups: resonator methods and resonant-perturbation methods. In the first case, the sample itself behaves as a resonator and, therefore, the resonant frequency and quality factor may be related to its dimensions, shape, permittivity, and permeability. The resonant-perturbation method, on the contrary, uses the dielectric sample to modify the resonant frequency and quality factor of a resonator, which usually is built as a metallic cavity [35]. Rectangular or cylindrical cavities may be used in this case. In this method, the perturbation approximation assumes that the introduction of the sample does not modify the electric or magnetic field distribution of the empty cavity. This obviously introduces a small error in the permittivity measurement. Due to this, dielectric samples are as small as possible when using this technique. The resonant-perturbation method uses the differences of the resonant frequency and the quality factor of both the empty and loaded cavity in order to derive the dielectric properties of the sample. Resonator Method
This method is also called the dielectric resonator method and as explained previously the dielectric sample under measurement serves itself as resonator and the permittivity can be determined from its resonant frequency and quality factor [42]. A possible measurement setup is to place a cylindrical dielectric sample between two circular conducting planes, whose electrical properties are assumed to be known. In this case we are using the so-called Courtney Method since Courtney was the first one to fully analyze and develop it in [43]. The excited mode is usually the TE011 since this mode does not show a transverse electric field between the sample and the conducting planes, which reduces the error in case that a small air gap is present between the sample and the conducting planes [44, 45]. In this method, the dielectric sample dimensions are limited by the frequency, dielectric properties of the sample, dimensions of the shorting plates, and the diameter of the coupling probes. Therefore, a usable range can be established for a particular dielectric resonator fixture [43].
36
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
Resonant-Perturbation Methods
Due to their high accuracy and sensitivity, these methods are widely used for low-loss and small-size samples, powders, and samples of irregular shapes. The most used resonators are hollow metallic cavities although dielectric resonators can also be used. Due to this, they are also called cavity-perturbation methods. There are several types of cavity perturbation: cavity-shape, wall-impedance, and material perturbations. For dielectric materials characterization the last one is more interesting since in this case the dielectric under test is introduced in the cavity, thus changing the resonance frequency and quality factor of the system. The complex permittivity can be determined by using the changes in both the resonance frequency and the quality factor due to the introduction of the sample. From Maxwell’s equations one can derive the changes in the complex angular resonant frequencies of the cavity before and after introducing a dielectric material [13]. Equation (2.41) shows the relationship between the different complex angular resonant frequencies and the electric and magnetic fields after and before inserting the sample in the cavity: r
∫ (ΔεE
Δω ω 2 − ω1 V = =− c ω ω1
2
r r ⋅ E1* + ΔμH 2 ⋅ H 1* dV
r r r ε1 E 2 ⋅ E1* + μH 2
∫(
Vc
) ⋅ H )dV * 1
(2.41)
where ω1 and ω2 are the complex angular resonant frequencies before and after the introduction of the simple, ε1 and ε2 are the complex permittivities of the original medium in the hollow cavity and the sample, μ1 and μ2 are the complex r permeabilities of the original medium in the hollow cavity and the sample, H 1 and r H 2 are the magnetic fields in the cavity before and after the introduction of the samr r ple, E1 and E 2 are the electric fields in the cavity before and after the introduction of the sample, Vc is the region enclosed by the cavity, and Vs is the sample volume. This equation can be simplified if a small object is considered and if it is assumed that the introduction of the sample does not significantly change and r ther electric r r magnetic field distribution within the cavity. In this case, by using E1 ≈ E 2 , H 1 ≈ H 2 , and
1
≈
2
one can obtain: ⎛
r
∫ ⎜⎝ Δε E
2
1
ω 2 − ω1 V ≈− s ω1 ⎛ r ∫V ⎜⎝ ε1 E1 c
2
r 2 + Δμ H1 ⎞⎟ dV ⎠ r 2⎞ + μ1 H1 ⎟ dV ⎠
(2.42)
Equation (2.42) indicates that an increase of both the permittivity and/or permeability inside the cavity will lead to a decrease of the resonant frequency. Additionally, if one assumes that the medium in the cavity is vacuum and that the material to be measured only shows a dielectric behavior, then (2.42) can be further simplified into
2.3 Dielectric Properties
37
r
∫E − 1⎞
1
r ⋅ E 2 dV
ω 2 − ω1 ⎛ε Vs ≈ −⎜ r ⎟ r 2 ⎝ 2 ⎠ ω1 ∫ E1 dV
(2.43)
Vc
where r is the relative complex permittivity of the sample. Since is a complex angular resonant frequency, it can be expressed with a real ( r) and imaginary part ( i) and related to the resonant frequency (f) and quality factor of the cavity (Q) as expressed in (2.44) through (2.46). ω = ω r + jω i
(2.44)
ω r = 2 πf
(2.45)
⎛ω ⎞ Q=⎜ r ⎟ ⎝ 2ω i ⎠
(2.46)
By assuming that 1 ≈ 2, that high quality factors are obtained within the cavity, and i > r, a relationship between the dielectric constant and the resonant frequency decrease can be obtained. Additionally, a relationship between the loss factor of the dielectric material and quality factor changes can also be derived: f1 − f 2 V = ( ε ′r − 1)A s f2 VC
(2.47)
V 1 1 − = Bε ′′r s Q 2 Q1 VC
(2.48)
where ε ′r and ε ′′r are the dielectric constant and the loss factor of the sample, respectively. A and B are constants related to the configuration and working mode of the cavity, sample shape, and location within the cavity. Since its determination is complicated from an analytical study, they are often obtained by calibrating the cavity with a dielectric sample of known characteristics. However, the sample size and shape used for calibration must be of similar values than those samples under test. 2.3.1.3
In Vivo or In Vitro Techniques
One can find in the literature two kinds of procedures to measure the permittivity of tissues. In vivo procedures have been applied to animals and consist of applying the measurement probe directly on the tissues of the living animal. Many times this requires surgery and/or sedation for animals, and that is the main reason why this procedure is not applied on humans [46]. Additionally, efforts have to be made to avoid contamination of the tissue with blood or other substances, and many times suction and dry cotton swabs and buds are used to eliminate excess fluid. In-vitro measurements differ from the previous procedure in the nature of the tissues. In this case the whole organ, or part of it, is excised, cleaned, and, after that, placed in a proper container before its dielectric properties can be measured. Basically, this
38
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
modifies temperature, moisture content, and, obviously, the working conditions of the living organ which may provide different results from in vivo measurements as described in [46]. 2.3.1.4
Permittivity of Usual Materials Worn by People
Several useful permittivity values for materials worn by people and which can be used in SAR simulations or measurements can be found at [9]. Table 2.1 shows some data for these materials. 2.3.2
Current Knowledge on Dielectric Properties
The electrical properties of materials involved in dosimetry evaluations have been reported in the literature, and the typically used values are those of Gabriel [12], who made her study after the contribution of Herman P. Schwan [47]. It has to be mentioned, however, that dielectric measuring techniques may not be very accurate, particularly below 1 kHz, with errors affecting the dielectric parameters by up to a factor of two [12]. A polar dielectric material under an electric field is electrically polarized at the molecular and atomic levels, and the total polarization reaches a steady state as a first-order process when a step field is applied. The total polarization magnitude, characterized by the time constant of the dipolar rotation τ which depends on the physical process, is
(
P = P∞ + (P0 − P∞ ) 1 − e −t
τ
)
(2.49)
where P∞ and P0 are the instantaneous and steady-state polarization, respectively. As we have seen before, in time-varying fields the relative permittivity is a complex function ε$ = ε ′ − jε ′′ = ε ′ − j
σ ωε 0
(2.50)
Table 2.1
Properties of Some Common Industrial Materials Worn by People
Material
Relative Complex Permittivity 7
9
9
10 Hz
10 Hz
3 10 Hz
3.78–j0.0001
3.78–j0.0002
3.78–j0.0002
1.2–j0.01
—
—
Cotton (210 kg/m ), 7% moisture content dry basis
1.5–j0.03
—
—
Natural rubber (25°C)
—
—
2.15–j0.0065
Nylon FM10001 (25°C)
3.24–j0.07
3.06–j0.043
3.02–j0.036
Glass 3
Wool (68 kg/m ), 20% moisture content dry basis 3
Extracted from [9] with permission from IET.
2.3 Dielectric Properties
39
where the real part ε ′ is the dielectric constant (i.e., a measure of the induced polarization per unit field), and the imaginary part ε ′′ is the out-of-phase loss factor associated with it. The frequency response of the first-order system is obtained from the Laplace transformation, which provides the relationship known as the Debye equation [48]. ε$ = ε ∞ +
εS − ε∞ = ε ′ − jε ′′ 1 + jωτ
(2.51)
where εS and ε∞ are known as static and infinite permittivity. This can be obtained easily from the Laplace transformation of (2.49), L[P] =
∫
∞
0
Pe − st dt =
∫
∞
0
(P
∞
(
+ (P0 − P∞ ) 1 − e −t
τ
))e
− st
dt = t =∞
P − P∞ − ( s + 1 τ )t ⎤ ⎡ P dt = ⎢− 0 e − st + 0 e ∫0 ⎥ s s+1τ ⎣ ⎦t =0 1 τ + − − P s P P s ) ( 0 ∞ ) P∞ s + P0 τ P P − P∞ 0( = 0 − 0 = = = s s+1τ s( s + 1 τ) s( s + 1 τ) =
= =
∞
(
P0 e − st − (P0 − P∞ )e
− ( s + 1 τ )t
P∞ ( s + 1 τ ) + P0 τ − P∞ τ s( s + 1 τ)
=
)
P∞ ( s + 1 τ) s( s + 1 τ )
+
(P0 − P∞ ) τ s( s + 1 τ)
(2.52)
=
P − P∞ P∞ + 0 s(1 + sτ ) s
taking into account that $ε = L[P ]/L[E ] and thus dividing (2.52) by the Laplace transformation of the step field applied L[E] = 1/s, the Debye equation is obtained after translating the instantaneous and steady-state polarization to the infinite and static permittivity, respectively. The current density J per unit of field E also follows a first-order law such that J E = σ$ = σ ∞ +
σS − σ∞ 1 + jωτ
(2.53)
where σ$ is the conductivity equivalent of the Debye equation, whereas σS and σ∞ are known as the static and infinite conductivity. Conduction currents can be arisen from, for example, a drift of free ions in static field, and its effect is not included in the Debye expression. It would become ε$ = ε ∞ +
εS − ε∞ σ + S 1 + jωτ jωε 0
(2.54)
This complex permittivity can be broken down in its real and imaginary parts: ε′ = ε∞ +
εS − ε∞
1 + ( ωτ )
2
(2.55)
40
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
( ε S − ε ∞ )ωτ σS + 2 ωε 0 1 + ( ωτ)
ε ′′ =
(2.56)
Likewise, the total conductivity σ is σ = ωε 0 ε ′′ = σ S +
(εS
− ε ∞ )ε 0 ω 2 τ
(
1 + ωτ 2
(2.57)
)
As we can see, the total conductivity σ is made of two terms, the residual static conductivity σS and polarization losses. Only the total conductivity of a material can be measured in practice. σS can be obtained from data analysis or by measurement at frequencies corresponding to ωτ << 1 where the dipolar contribution to the total conductivity can be neglected. Up to this point the dielectric response has been modeled as a first order process, but the presence of complex intermolecular interactions or multiple molecular conformational states may cause the polarization process kinetics of a substance not to be first order. This would cause its dielectric behavior to exhibit multiple relaxation time dispersions, bringing about the need of more complex models to analyze a dielectric response deviated from the Debye expression. The simplest one will consist of more than one Debye terms ε$ = ε ∞ +
Δ ε1 Δε 2 + +K 1 + jωτ1 1 + jωτ 2
(2.58)
where Δεn corresponds to the limits of the dispersion characterized by time constant τn. Another modified version of the Debye expression, known as the Cole-Cole model [49], was proposed in 1941 by Cole and Cole and is one of the most commonly used models, ε$ = ε ∞ +
εS − ε∞
1 + ( jωτ )
1−α
= ε ′ − jε ′′
(2.59)
where α is a distribution parameter in the range 0 ≤ α < 1. For α = 0, the model returns to the Debye equation. This complex permittivity can also be broken down in its real and imaginary parts: ε′ = ε∞ +
(εS
[
− ε ∞ ) 1 + ( ωτ )
1 + ( ωτ )
2 (1 − α )
1−α
+ 2( ωτ )
]
sin( α π 2 )
1−α
sin( α π 2 )
( ε S − ε ∞ )( ωτ) cos( α π 2 ) ε ′′ = 2 (1 − α ) 1−α 1 + ( ωτ ) + 2( ωτ ) sin( α π 2 )
(2.60)
1−α
(2.61)
Another variant of the Debye equation was proposed in 1951 by Davidson and Cole [50],
2.3 Dielectric Properties
41
ε$ = ε ∞ +
εS − ε∞
(1 + jωτ)
(2.62)
β
This differs from the previous one in that an exponent β is applied to the whole denominator, which entails the next expressions for its real and imaginary parts, ε ′ = ε ∞ + ( ε S − ε ∞ ) cos( βφ)( cos φ) ε ′′ = ( ε S − ε ∞ ) sin( βφ)( cos φ)
β
β
(2.63) (2.64)
where φ = arctan(ωτ). When β = 1, this variant returns to the Debye equation. Another expression which combines the variations introduced in both the Cole-Cole and the Cole-Davidson models was proposed by Havriliak and Negami in 1966 [51], ε$ = ε ∞ +
εS − ε∞
(1 + ( jωτ) ) 1−α
(2.65)
β
The Havriliak-Negami variant returns to the previous ones for the appropriate values of α and β. The Debye model and its many variations lend to simple curve-fitting procedures. In particular, the Cole-Cole model is the most used in the analysis of dielectric properties of biological materials, because both ε ′ and ε ′′ are proportional to (ωτ)1−α at the limit of high frequencies, simplifying the Cole-Cole function to a fractional power law. This is at the basis of the universal law of dielectric phenomena developed by Jonscher, Hill, and Dissado [52] for the analysis of the frequency dependence of dielectric data. Jonsher’s universal law can be summarized by the following dependencies for the normalized complex permittivity, for ω < ω p , ε ′′( ω) ≈ ω m and ε ′( ω) ≈ 1 − ε ′′( ω)
(2.66)
for ω > ω p , ε ′′( ω) ≈ ω n −1 and ε ′( ω) ≈ ε ′′( ω) ≈ ω n −1
(2.67)
where ωp is the loss peak radial frequency. The functional form for ε ′′(ω) is ε ′′( ω) =
A
(ω ω ) p
1−n
+ (ω p ω)
m
(2.68)
and its values can be determined numerically from the Kramer-Krönig relations. In 1999, Raicu found that neither approach was good enough over a wide frequency range and thus he proposed a model which combines features form Debye-type and universal dielectric response behavior [53],
42
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
ε$ = ε ∞ +
[
( jωτ)
Δ α
+ ( jωτ)
1−β
]
γ
(2.69)
where α, β, and γ are real constants in the range [0,1], τ is the characteristic relaxation time, and Δ is an adimensional constant, which becomes the dielectric increment (εS − ε∞) when α = 0. The Raicu expression reverts to the previous models for the appropriate values of α, β, and γ. For example, it reverts to Jonsher’s universal response model for γ = 1. Fixing α = 1 − β, in addition to γ = 1, the Raicu expression is β −1 Δ2 ⎛ ω⎞ $ , and becomes the constant phase angle model [54] ε$ = ε ∞ + ε ε = + j ⎜ ⎟ ∞ ⎝ S⎠ ( jωτ)1 − β when a scaling factor S = (Δ/2)1/(1−β)τ−1 is taken. Dissado’s model was successfully used to model the dielectric spectrum of a biological material over five decades from 103 to 108 Hz. More information about the models used to estimate the frequency response of the dielectric properties of matter, as the Debye equation and its variants, treated along this section, can be found in [55]. The objective of the previous models is to allocate dielectric properties to the various tissues of a man or animal model, at all the frequencies to which it can be exposed. These man and animal models have been produced by means of developments in the field of electromagnetic dosimetry. The level of details is such that over 40 tissue types can be identified, so these models have high resolution and are anatomically correct. The application of such models required a consensus on the dielectric data, which came with Gabriel’s project [12], geared towards this objective, in which three experimental techniques were used to measure the dielectric properties of tissue in the frequency range 10 Hz to 20 GHz. The dielectric measurements were performed using automatic swept frequency network and impedance analyzers. For the frequency range 10 Hz to 10 MHz, an HP4192A impedance analyzer was used. An HP8753C covered the frequency range 300 kHz to 3 GHz, and an HP8720 measured from 130 MHz to 20 GHz. Open ended coaxial probes were used to interface the measuring equipment with the samples in all cases. The technique used with the HP8700 series network analyzers has been reported in [56]. The agreement between measurements was particularly good when they were made on the same sample throughout. Over 20 tissue types were measured over the full frequency range and over 10 others measured down to 1 MHz only. Also, internal consistency between the three sets of data was demonstrated in the overlapping frequency regions. When measurements were made on the same sample throughout, the agreement between data sets was particularly good. Moreover, a comprehensive survey of dielectric data published over more than 45 years was carried out in [12] and presented for comparison purposes. The data obtained in the course of Gabriel’s study fell well within the vast body of literature data where available and bridges the gaps within it. Additionally, to facilitate the incorporation of the dielectric data in numerical solutions, their frequency dependence was modeled to a spectrum characterized by four dispersion regions. This model was successfully applied to the experimental data. Finally, the conductivity of tissues below 100 Hz was estimated from the measurements in [12], modified by data from the literature and used to estimate the conductivity of the whole body and of various body parts.
2.3 Dielectric Properties
43
The measurement techniques and associated instrumentation used in [12] gave random reproducibility of about 1% across the frequency range. This statement was based on multiple measurements carried out on standard samples of uniform composition. Biological tissues are inhomogeneous and show considerable variability in structure or composition and hence in dielectric properties. Such variations are natural and may be due to physiological processes or other functional requirements. The spread of values ranged from about ±5% above 100 MHz to ±15% at the lower end of the frequency scale. Care was taken to eliminate all known sources of systematic errors, however, in view of the assumptions made in correcting for electrode polarization it is possible that the dielectric parameters below 1 kHz may be undercorrected. This source of errors may affect the dielectric parameters by up to a factor of two. Three sources of materials were used: excised animal tissue, mostly ovine, from freshly killed sheep; human autopsy tissues; human skin and tongue in vivo. All animal tissues were used as fresh as possible, mostly within 2 hours after death; human material was obtained 24 to 48 hours after death. The conical probe used in conjunction with the impedance analyzer required relatively large samples, at least a cube of 5 cm linear dimension. In view of this requirement not all samples could be measured at low frequencies. As we have just seen, Gabriel extracted the dielectric properties of tissues from the literature of the last half of the past century, particularly from the work of H. P. Schwan and his collaborators [47], and from [32, 57–61] and compared it to the corresponding data from her own measurements. The purpose was to provide an objective basis for the evaluation of the experimental data and to reach a broad-based consensus on the subject. Moreover, data corresponding more closely to living human tissues were selected in preference to any other. Consequently, human tissue and in vivo measurements were selected in preference to animal tissue and in vitro measurements. For in vitro measurements, data obtained at temperatures closest to that of the body and nearest to the time after death were used when available. One of the aims in [12] was to derive models for the frequency dependence of the dielectric properties of the tissues investigated. The basis of the analysis is well-known dispersion mechanisms in the dielectric spectrum of biological materials and their expression as a summation of terms corresponding to the main polarization mechanisms, which have been described before. The spectrum extends from hertz to gigahertz and shows four dispersion regions. The complexity of the structure and composition of biological material are such that each dispersion region is broadened by multiple contributions to it and could be described by a Cole-Cole expression. The model corresponding to the whole spectrum is ε( ω) = ε ∞ +
4
Δε m
m =1
( jωτ m )
∑ 1+
1−α m
+ σi
( jωε 0 )
(2.70)
in which ε∞ is the permittivity in the terahertz frequency range and σi is the ionic conductivity; and for each dispersion region, τm is the relaxation time and Δεm is the drop in permittivity in the frequency range from ωτ << 1 to ωτ >> 1. With a choice of parameters appropriate to each tissue, (2.70) could be used to predict its dielectric behavior over the desired frequency range. The parameters of the model were
44
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
adjusted to correspond to a close fit between the model and the most comprehensive data set available for the particular tissue. This 4-Cole-Cole model can be used with confidence for frequencies above 1 MHz. At lower frequencies, where the literature values are scarce and have larger than average uncertainties, the model should be used with caution in the knowledge that it provides a “best estimate” based on present knowledge. It is important to stress the limitations of the model particularly where there is no data at all to support its predictions. The 4-Cole-Cole analysis was carried out on 44 tissue types and its results are presented in a self-explanatory manner in Table 2.2. Some examples of fitted dielectric properties, using the summation of 4-Cole-Cole expressions as reported in (2.70), are given in Figures 2.6 to 2.8. Dielectric properties of human tissues have also been measured by other authors. For example, human brain tissue was measured at frequencies from 800 to 2,450 MHz in [62]. This work presents results for the dielectric properties of human gray matter tissue based on a sample of 20 brains less than 10 hours postmortem.
Table 2.2 Modeling the Frequency Dependence of the Dielectric Properties to a Four-Dispersion Spectrum: Summary Table of Fitting Parameters
Extracted from [12].
2.3 Dielectric Properties
Figure 2.6
Dielectric properties of skin (dry), muscle, and bone (cortical) tissues.
Figure 2.7 tissues.
Dielectric properties of brain (white matter), brain (gray matter), and cerebellum
45
Compared to data from the literature [12], its results indicated a slightly higher conductivity of human gray matter at body temperature in the frequency range from 800 to 2,450 MHz, even though a closer look at the comparable data from the literature dealing with the dielectric properties of gray matter in the same frequency range shows the general trend that in vivo measurements in animals led to higher values of dielectric properties compared to measurements on excised tissue samples. This is in agreement with studies reporting a postmortem decrease of the dielectric properties of gray matter [63]. Regarding permittivity, it is interesting to note that no significant differences between [62] and published data could be observed; fur-
46
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
Figure 2.8
Dielectric properties of blood, thyroid, and testis tissues.
thermore, conductivity was much more affected by postmortem changes than permittivity. It is important to emphasize that measurement values of dielectric properties are significantly dependent on the origin, handling, and temperature of the tissue and the time when the measurements took place with respect to the time of death. In order to provide reliable dielectric data, which are essential for accurate RF dosimetry, it is therefore most desirable to take into account all the above-mentioned facts. Obtaining data based on human tissue measured as soon as possible after death in combination with corresponding in vivo investigations in large mammals seems to be the best approach for estimating dielectric data of living human body tissue. Application of such a procedure is of course advisable not only for brain tissue, but also for all other types of tissue such as human skull, which was investigated only very rarely in the past and which might play an important role regarding RF power absorption in the human head. Likewise, standard methods for measurement of SAR in order to evaluate the radio frequency safety of mobile phones, including recipes for tissue-equivalent dielectric liquids, have been recently the subject of discussion among international standards organizations. Standards currently recommend glycol-type liquids as tissue-equivalent liquids for frequencies above 1 GHz. Although the ingredients are specified in the recipes provided, some fundamental information, such as the stability of dielectric properties, remains unclear. 2.3.3 The Role of Tissue Dielectric Properties and Geometry on Electromagnetic Dosimetry
The change of dielectric properties with time and with temperature of tissue-equivalent liquids recommended in the standard documents and their effects on SAR has
2.3 Dielectric Properties
47
been measured and evaluated in [64]. The conductivity decreased with increasing temperature in all glycol-type specimens at a rate about 2% per degree. The permittivity, on the other hand, was almost constant. With the evaporation of water, the conductivity and the permittivity decrease, since the material reduces its dipolar nature, as Figure 2.9 shows for two different types of leather [65]. In this figure, the dielectric properties are represented versus the moisture content (dry basis) of the hides for 2.5 GHz. Experimental results in [64] proved that dielectric properties are affected by environmental conditions, and that it is inevitably necessary to adjust the dielectric properties regularly, through the addition of ingredients, in order to follow the standards. The SAR values, however, were not affected significantly by the change in dielectric properties [64]; thus, a larger tolerance of the dielectric properties may be acceptable in practical SAR measurements. Another important effect is the age-dependence of biological tissues, which is not normally considered and also applies to the tissue simulating liquids in measurements, although the latest degrade rather more rapidly that the ageing effects. Some information on age-dependence or simply the variability of dielectric properties is yet becoming available and has already proven to be an important factor for SAR assessment. For example, for small objects compared to the electromagnetic fields wavelength (i.e., wavelength inside material is greater than ten times the dimensions of the object) and for the special condition where permittivity values are proportional (i.e., ε ′ ≈ ε ′′), the whole-object averaged SAR is inversely proportional to the object permittivity [66, 67]. Even though variability in permittivity values do not substantially influence whole-body SAR values, localized SAR values for individual tissues are substantially affected by these changes [68]. Other authors found local differences in the internal field distribution and SAR value, comparing head models including or not an inner auditory system model, as depicted in Figures 2.10 and 2.11. This confirms that only through a tissue-specific and/or organ dosimetry, a better insight of the interactions between external electromagnetic fields and biolog-
Figure 2.9 Variation of dielectric properties with moisture content in leather. (Reproduced from [65] with permission from Elsevier.)
48
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
Semicircular canals
Cochlea Base 12 mm
Utricle 13 mm
Saccule
Apex 14 mm
Figure 2.10 IEEE.)
Modeling of a membranous labyrinth. (Reproduced from [69] with permission from
Near Vestibulus
Far Vestibulus
Figure 2.11 Head model including inner auditory systems. (Reproduced from [69] with permission from IEEE.)
ical structure can be achieved [69]. Likewise, an experimental investigation of the effects of ear shape and head size on SAR, using a cubical head model with various ear shapes [70], shows that the SAR distribution depends on the ear shape. Mochizuki et al. also concluded that there is a large difference (1.5 dB) between the maxima local SAR measured with the various ear models and a cellular-phone model, even though there is no significant difference between the values measured with a dipole antenna [71]. In [72], the different dielectric properties of 10 rat tissues at six different ages from 130 MHz to 10 GHz were measured. The results show that a general decrease in the permittivity and conductivity was found with age, with this trend accentuated in the brain, skull, and skin tissues, and less noticeable for abdominal tissues. The conductivity and permittivity values for a 10-day rat, compared to a 70-day rat, range from 20% to 100% higher.
2.3 Dielectric Properties
49
Moreover, the effect of the higher permittivity and conductivity values was a lower whole-body SAR, except for a region between 110 and 180 MHz. This inverse relationship between permittivity and SAR was also confirmed in [73], but only for whole-body normalized SAR, and when the tissue was muscle-like and around 2 GHz. Likewise, the dielectric properties of whole-brain, skin, and skull were determined experimentally in the frequency range 300 KHz to 300 MHz in [74]. Tissue samples were excised from 10-, 30-, and 70-day-old Wistar strain rats. The data were presented in graphical format and compared to previously published data in the frequency range 100 MHz to 20 GHz [72]. Good agreement was observed between the two data sets, since at frequencies in excess of about 100 MHz the permittivity and conductivity decrease monotonically with increasing age. It is noteworthy that at these frequencies, the γ dispersion is dominant, being that this region is dominated by the dielectric response of the aqueous component. Nevertheless, the opposite effect was observed at 500 MHz in [73]. When all permittivity values were multiplied by 0.5, a decrease on whole-body normalized SAR values was observed. Furthermore, when the multiplication was by a factor of 2.0 the whole-body SAR values increased. It is worth noting that this frequency was near the resonance frequency of the rat model, and also near the frequency range 300 KHz to 300 MHz, the site of the β dispersion, where a change in the frequency dependence of the dielectric parameters was observed in [74], which was most evident in the spectra for brain and skin. This was attributed to changes in the tissue structure. Results in [74], at frequencies from 27 to 2,000 MHz, reveal that the variation in the dielectric properties affect the whole body SAR by less than 5% with the most conservative value (i.e., the highest SAR), which was obtained when properties of the 70-day-old rat tissues were used. Also in [74], the dielectric properties of skin were affirmed to be an important determinant in the coupling efficiency and hence in the intensity of the exposure. This study stated that skin is an animal-specific organ, and thus researchers must exercise caution when using animal skin dielectric data in human exposure studies. Consequently, elaboration of the question of the exposure of children versus adults must await more appropriate dielectric data and also MRI-based numerical models of children. The scientific community is aware of this need, and it will be probably addressed in the near future. Regarding the exposure of children versus adults, it is worth mentioning that there is a controversy on the dosimetry in children’s heads for mobile telephones. Gandhi, et al. [75] reported a considerable increase of the spatial peak SAR in children’s heads, while Kuster, et al. [76] claimed that there was not a significant difference in the SAR between children and adults. In [77], the local peak SAR under the same conditions as those previously employed by Gandhi’s and Kuster’s groups is calculated. Compared to the local peak SAR in the adult head model, a considerable increase in the children’s heads was found when the output power of the monopole-type antenna was fixed, but no significant differences when the effective current of the dipole-type antenna was fixed. This finding suggests that the contradictory conclusions drawn by the above two groups may be due to the different conditions in their numerical peak SAR calculations. In addition, an approximation of the aging effect on dielectric tissue properties for SAR assessment of mobile telephones can be found in [78]. This study stated
50
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
that the dielectric properties for the child head models do not affect significantly the 1- or 10-g averaged spatial peak SAR, being the increased 1- or 10-g averaged spatial peak SAR within 10% even in an extreme case. This could be explained by the cancellation of the increased conductivity and decreased electric field penetrating into tissue. This occurred because of the same degree of increase between the conductivity and permittivity in children compared to adults, as reported in [78] (and since E ∝ 1/ε ′ [66]). Furthermore, the calculation of the penetration depth in child head models exhibits an almost same value as or somewhat smaller value than that in the adult model [78]. More controversy appears when, in [79], some comments are mentioned about different percentage deviations when changing the dielectric permittivity or the tissue conductivity. This study has some interesting conclusions, such as SAR changes are imperceptible for small dielectric constant changes. This is exactly the contrary of what was concluded in [67], wherein local SAR is found to vary greatly with permittivity values, even when whole-body average SAR values are not sensitive. An explanation of these differences could be the different operation frequencies used in each study. A lot of studies can be found in the literature about dependences of SAR on several factors as the dielectric properties themselves (i.e., dielectric constant and conductivity), aging, geometry, and so on. For example, in [80], 100 rats were exposed during a period of 2 years to a brain-averaged SAR of 2 W/kg for a so-called high-dose group, and 0.67 W/kg for a so-called low-dose group. The whole-body averaged SAR was less than 0.4 W/kg. An interesting conclusion is reached in this study, since a relatively large variation of the SAR could be found in the male high-dose group. This finding could be explained by the fact that the whole-body and brain-average SAR can be largely affected by the size or weight of the rats.
2.4
Heat Generation Once the electric field goes straight through the body tissues, the electromagnetic energy turns into heat due to dielectric losses as explained earlier. This means that, as long as the electric field travels across the human body, it decreases its energy and the surrounding tissues increase their temperature. If this energy interchange was isolated from other effects, there would be a direct relationship between electric field distribution within the human body and temperature increments. However, the temperature increase within the human body when electromagnetic energy is present is influenced by other phenomena such as thermal migration, blood perfusion, and convection. In this section we review the main models for estimating the temperature increase within the human body when it is irradiated with high frequency electromagnetic fields. 2.4.1
Bioheat Equation
The bioheat equation was first suggested by Pennes in order to determine steady-state tissue temperature-depth distributions [81]. Basing his analysis on the general differential equation of heat conduction,
2.4 Heat Generation
51
Cρ
∂T = K ⋅ ∇ 2 T + hm + hb ∂t
(2.71)
3
where C [J/(kg·K)] is the specific heat, ρ [kg/m ] is the tissue density, T [K] is the tissue temperature, K [J/(s·m·K)] is the thermal conductivity, hm [J/(s·m3)] is the rate of tissue heat production, and hb [J/(s·m3)] is the rate of heat transfer from blood to tissue. This equation simply equals the temperature increase per unit time multiplied by the thermal capacitance of 1 m3 of tissue, given by the product between the specific heat and the tissue density, to the heat accumulated per unit time and per unit volume in the body. Several papers deal with heat transfer in living tissue on the basis of the so-called bioheat transfer equation. In [82] a fundamental error in this equation is pointed out, arising from the incorrect formulation of the thermal transport by blood, demonstrating the futility of applying the equation, both by physical argument and a numerical example. The equation in question constitutes the local energy balance for a solid at rest. It includes a distributed volumetric source of metabolic heat generation, and a second distributed source accounting for the effect of blood perfusion. This second source term is the term of interest here and is allegedly based on Fick’s principle [83]. The equation is, at first pC
∂T = ∇ ⋅ ( K∇T ) + w b C b Tb , in − Tb , out + q m ∂t
(
)
(2.72)
and simplified, on the assumptions of Tb,in = Ta, Tb,out = T and constant thermal conductivity of the tissue, to yield the so-called bioheat transfer equation: ρC
∂T = K∇ 2 T + w b C b (Ta − T ) + q m ∂t
(2.73)
3
where wb [kg/(m ·s)] is taken to be the volumetric blood perfusion rate in mass of blood per unit volume of tissue per unit time, Cb [J/(kg·K)] is the specific heat of blood, Tb [K] is the temperature of blood, Ta [K] is the temperature of arterial blood, and qm [J/(s·m3)] is the volumetric metabolic heat generation rate. Wulff stated that the correct form of the bioheat transfer equation is ρC
r ∂T = K∇ 2 T − ρ b C bU h ⋅ ∇T + q m ∂t
(2.74)
r where U h is the local mean apparent blood velocity associated with enthalpy flux. r For the blood flowing in the averaged direction of the vector U h , the enthalpy flux enhances or opposes the conductive heat flux −K T, where ρ b hbU h =
1 ( ρ b hb u ) d ω 4π ∫Ω
(2.75)
ρb is the blood density, hb is the specific enthalpy of blood, and u is the actual blood velocity in capillary. In his opinion, the estimate of the local blood mass flux ρbUh
52
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
requires additional considerations, somewhat more complex than the oversimplified assumption of a volumetric blood perfusion rate wb. However, this bioheat equation evolved to a modified version [84], K∇ 2 T + A 0 + Q v − B(T − Tb ) = Cρ
∂T ∂t
(2.76)
In particular, the four terms in the first member of (2.76) represent different ways through which heat is accumulated inside the tissue, specifically: 1. 2. 3. 4.
Heat transfer through internal conduction (K[J/(s·m·K)]); Metabolic heat production (A0[J/(s·m3)]); Heat deposition due to the absorbed microwave power (Qv[J/(s·m3)]); Heat exchange mechanism due to blood perfusion, proportional to the heat-sink strength from tissue volume by blood perfusion (B[J/(s·m3·K)]) and the difference between blood and tissue temperature (Tb − T) [K].
To solve (2.76), a convective boundary condition is applied at the external surface of the body [81, 84, 85]. This condition is obtained imposing the continuity of the heat flow perpendicular to the surface of the body (heat reaching this surface from the interior of the body through conduction must equal the heat exchanged through convection with the surrounding medium or fluid),
[ ( s ⋅ m )]
⎛∂ T⎞ − K ⎜ ⎟ = H(Ts − Te ) J ⎝ ∂t ⎠ S
2
(2.77)
2
where H [J/(s·m ·K)] is the convection coefficient, Ts [K] is the surface temperature, and Te [K] is the fluid temperature. Starting from a SAR distribution, the corresponding induced heating profile could be evaluated by solving the bioheat equation, taking Qv = ρSAR [86]: K∇ 2 T − ρρ b C b m b T + ρSAR = Cρ 3
∂T ∂t
(2.78)
where mb [m /(kg·s)] is taken to be the volumetric perfusion rate of blood in volume of blood per unit mass of tissue per unit time, taking “normal” blood perfusion 3 −6 3 value equal to 40 cm /(100g·min) in his study, that is, 6.66 × 10 m /(kg·s) in the international system of units (IS). In the 26 years following its publication (1949-1974), Pennes’ paper [81] was cited an average of 1.7 times per year. Since 1990 (through 1996), the paper has averaged 25 citations annually [87]. Thus, the bioheat equation has been appearing in numerous publications, but with no significant changes until Bernardi [88], following [81], included a term for the respiratory heat losses in the lungs (RL [J/(s·m3)]) in the bioheat equation and a term to represent heat losses due to sweating in the boundary condition. A clear account of the bioheat equation used in this work can be found in [88].
2.4 Heat Generation
53
Likewise, Yang added a term to the bioheat equation [89] to account for the power density used for tissue internal water evaporation, QE [J/(s·m3)], yielding a modified bioheat equation, ρC
∂T = ∇ ⋅ ( K∇T ) + Q + Q B − Q E ∂t
(2.79)
where Q [J/(s·m )] is the microwave power density and QB = ρBCBωB(TB − T) [J/(s·m3)] is a term which accounts for the effects of perfusion, where ωB [1/s] is the blood perfusion rate and TB [K] is the ambient blood temperature before entering the ablation region. In his study, the metabolic heat generation term A [J/(s·m3)] was considered insignificant with respect to the rest of the heating terms and, therefore, ignored. Moreover, Yang related the power density used for evaporation to the change in water content of tissue as a function of time 3
Q E = −α
dW dt
(2.80)
where α is the water latent heat constant, which is 2,260 [kJ/kg], and W is the tissue water density [kg/m3], which is assumed to be only a function of temperature. From the chain rule, the derivative of W with respect to time is dW ∂W ∂ T = dt ∂T ∂t
(2.81)
Substituting this into (2.80), yields Q E = −α
∂W ∂ T ∂T ∂t
(2.82)
The modified bioheat equation then becomes ρC
∂T ∂W ∂ T = ∇ ⋅ ( K∇T ) + Q + Q B + α ∂t ∂T ∂t
(2.83)
Pulling the last term in the above equation to the left-hand side ∂W ⎞ ∂ T ⎛ = ∇ ⋅ ( K∇T ) + Q + Q B ⎜ ρC − α ⎟ ⎝ ∂T ⎠ ∂t
(2.84)
Examining the above equation, Yang defined an effective specific heat C′ = C −
α ∂W ρ ∂T
which yielded a new modified Pennes bioheat equation:
(2.85)
54
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
ρC ′
∂T = ∇ ⋅ ( K∇T ) + Q + Q B ∂t
(2.86)
Equation (2.86) is in the same format as the original bioheat equation, with an ∂W effective specific heat used instead of the normal specific heat. Since is 0 when ∂T evaporation does not occur and is negative when evaporation occurs, effective specific heat C ′ is never less than normal specific heat value C, which is consistent with it requiring more energy to raise the temperature during a phase change. Tissue effective specific heat [J/(kg·K)] is the only new term in (2.86). It is similar to the normal specific heat as it is defined as the amount of energy required to increase the temperature of a unit mass of tissue by 1K, and includes the water latent heat energy required if tissue water evaporation occurs. For this formulation Yang assumed that the change in tissue water content and tissue effective specific heat were only dependent on tissue temperature. In actuality it is more complex than this. However, Yang implemented a model which, while still not complete, was more accurate than the previous thermal model. Regarding the validation of the Pennes’ bioheat equation, Wissler’s calculations [90], when compared with Pennes’ measurements [81], demonstrate good agreement. This validation of the Pennes’ model is confirmed by other studies. The model has shown consistency with observations when applied to perfused phantoms [91] and to simulating temperature fields in the human brain [92]. Thus, consistency between predictions of the Pennes’ bioheat equation and measurements is truly remarkable when viewed in the context of the gross simplifications inherent to the model. For many practical applications, the simplicity of the Pennes model is appropriate to the required accuracy and the level of detailed anatomic knowledge available [93]. As mentioned above, a lot of papers use the bioheat equation to deal with heat transfer in living tissue. For example, in [94], a modified version of the Pennes bioheat equation is solved in order to evaluate temperature increase for all tissues in a human head model: ρ⋅cp
∂T = ∇ ⋅ ( kT ∇T ) + ρSAR + A0 + B(Tb − T ) ∂t
(2.87)
The in-house thermal model developed in [94] included heat diffusion and convection, metabolic heat production, and heat-sink from tissue volume by blood perfusion. Thermoregulatory control can be achieved in the model in real time, which can keep a constant temperature under no RF exposure but being slightly altered by the heat loss in the body surface due to intimate contact to air, as shown in Figure 2.12. Likewise, temperature results are shown for a hypothetical peak SAR equal to 2 W/kg for the entire head model, for several exposure times, in Figures 2.13 and 2.14. Furthermore, with this SAR, thermoregulatory control can be achieved in the model; that is, the time to rise to 90% of the steady state temperature under an exposure resulting in a hypothetical peak SAR of 2 W/kg is a bit longer than three-quarters of an hour. Both temperatures are shown in Figures 2.15 and 2.16.
2.4 Heat Generation
Figure 2.12
55
Temperature under no RF exposure.
(a)
(b)
Figure 2.13 Temperature after 6 minutes of exposure resulting in a hypothetical peak SAR of 2 W/kg (a) and the equivalent temperature increment over the steady-state temperature under no RF exposure (b).
As we can see, even with basal metabolism and blood flow, thermoregulatory control is achieved for a SAR under the basic restrictions, and steady state is reached. However, this should be different for a harsh exposure, with SAR greater than the maximum specified by the international safety standards, even if the thermoregulatory system is modeled with a variable metabolism and blood flow.
56
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
(a)
(b)
Figure 2.14 Temperature after 30 minutes of exposure resulting in a hypothetical peak SAR of 2 W/kg (a) and the equivalent temperature increment over the steady-state temperature under no RF exposure (b).
(a)
(b)
Figure 2.15 Steady state temperature under an exposure resulting in a hypothetical peak SAR of 2 W/kg (a) and the equivalent temperature increment over the steady-state temperature under no RF exposure (b).
2.4.2
Thermal Properties of Human Tissues
The bioheat equation shows that once the electromagnetic energy has been converted into heat due to dielectric losses this heat travels across the human tissues from hot spots to cold tissues [95]. This thermal migration is particularly important in hyperthermia tests and bioexperiments where high electromagnetic power levels and long exposition times are used [96]. In fact, Moros and Pickard [97] have shown that the thermometrically estimated SAR in tests is influenced by thermal conduc-
2.5 Conclusions
57
(a)
(b)
Figure 2.16 Temperature after the so-called time to rise (a) and the equivalent temperature increment over the steady-state temperature under no RF exposure (b).
tion to a large extent, and in this sense point SAR measurements performed with traditional thermometry methods are subject to significant errors due thermal diffusion [97]. Therefore thermal characteristics are of the utmost importance when trying to compute or infer SAR from temperature simulations or measurements. There are several sources where one can find thermal properties and perfusion properties for human or animal tissues, such as [88, 95, 98–109]. Table 2.3 shows the thermal data for human tissues and organs included in [88]. One can deduce from results that very different thermal properties are found for different tissues or organs due to their different composition, tissue disposition, and water content. Thermal properties of human tissues vary both with water content and tissue temperature. An example of this variation can be found in [109]. In that work, Valvano et al. presented an experimental method to measure the thermal conductivity and thermal diffusivity of biomaterials such as kidney, spleen, liver, brain, heart, lung, pancreas, colon cancer, and breast cancer at different temperatures. Self-heated thermistor probes, inserted into the tissue of interest, were used to deliver heat as well as to monitor the rate of heat removal. Thermal properties were measured for 65 separate tissue samples at different temperature ranging from 3°C to 45°C. The results showed that the temperature coefficient of biomaterials approximated that of water.
2.5
Conclusions Electromagnetic dosimetry establishes the relationship between an electromagnetic field distribution in free space and the induced fields inside biological tissues. Maxwell equations, which govern all electromagnetic phenomena, are the mathematical tools for a rigorous and accurate study of this interaction between electromagnetic waves and the human body. The final goal of dosimetric studies is to
58
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter Table 2.3
Thermal Properties of Most Common Human Tissues Under Basal Conditions 3
3
K[J/(s·m K] A0 [J/(s·m ]
B0[J/(s·m · K]
3900
0.55
0
0
330
0.43
1600
9000
3900
0.0
0
0
Tissue/Organ
C[J/(kg K]
Bile Bladder Blood Bone marrow
2700
0.22
5700
32000
Cancellous bone
1300
0.40
590
3300
Cartilage
3500
0.47
1600
9000
Cerbellum
3700
0.57
7100
40000
Cerebro-spinal fluid
4200
0.62
0
0
Colon
3700
0.56
9500
53000
Cornea
4200
0.58
0
0
Cortical bone
1300
0.40
610
3400
Eye humor
4000
0.60
0
0
Eye lens
3000
0.40
0
0
Eye tissue
4200
0.58
0
0
Fat
2500
0.25
300
1700
Gall bladder
3500
0.47
1600
9000
Glands
3600
0.53
64000
360000
Grey matter
3700
0.57
7100
40000
Heart
3700
0.54
9600
54000
Internal air
1000
0.03
0
0
Kidney
3900
0.54
48000
270000
Liver
3600
0.51
12000
68000
Lung
3600
0.14
1700
9500
Mucous membrane
3300
0.43
1600
9000
Muscle
3600
0.50
480
2700
Nerve–spinal cord
3500
0.46
7100
40000
Pancreas
3500
0.54
7300
41000
Skin
3500
0.42
1620
9100
Small intestine
3700
0.56
13000
71000
Spleen
3700
0.54
15000
82000
Stomach
3600
0.53
5200
29000
Tendon
3300
0.41
1600
9000
Testis
3800
0.53
64000
360000
White matter
3600
0.50
7100
40000
Reproduced from [88] with permission from IEEE.
quantify the electromagnetic absorption of a given organ or the whole human body. This quantity is the specific absorption rate (SAR), defined as the time rate at which energy is deposited in any kind of material per unit of mass. Biological tissues and other materials that usually surround the human body do not have magnetic properties and, therefore, the interaction with electromagnetic fields depends mainly on the electric permittivity. This parameter is a complex number, with a real part (the dielectric constant) that models the capacity of the material to store electric energy,
2.5 Conclusions
59
and an imaginary part (the loss factor) that models the energy dissipation. This dissipation results in a heat generation in the tissue that can be explained by the friction of molecular and atomic dipoles when these dipoles try to follow the variations of the electric field. Therefore, the behavior of the different materials involved in the problem can be completely described by their respective electric permittivities. Alternative parameters like the electric conductivity or the loss tangent are used in the determination of the SAR, but they are strongly related to the electric permittivity. Therefore, it is necessary to estimate the electric permittivity of the different materials involved in the interaction by means of proper measurement techniques. The impedance analyzer and coaxial probe techniques are widely used in the tissue permittivity characterization. The impedance analyzer can be used at low frequencies while coaxial probes allow broader bandwidth measurements. Additionally, the coaxial probe can be used both for in vivo or in vitro measurements while the impedance analyzer is more suitable for in vitro characterization. Cavity resonant techniques can only obtain permittivity values at discrete frequencies and are better for estimation in low-loss materials such as fabrics, plastics, or glass. Inverse techniques for permittivity estimation are based on the comparison of simulating and measuring results. They need optimization algorithms in order to reduce the error between simulations and measurements until good correlations are obtained. However, these techniques should be used only when canonical shapes for the tissue under measurement cannot be obtained or when the tissue is a multilayer dielectric, since they need high computing times depending on the measuring scenario and the chosen optimization strategies. The application of high-resolution, anatomically correct man and animal models from medical imaging data requires the knowledge of the dielectric properties of the different tissues at all the frequencies to which the model is exposed. There was no consensus on these dielectric data until their frequency dependence was modeled by a spectrum characterized by 4 dispersion regions [12]. The main purpose of this model was to compile a database of dielectric properties of tissues for the use of the scientific community in solving electromagnetic interaction problems. This was achieved through measurement in the frequency range 10 Hz to 20 GHz and modeling the frequency dependence of the dielectric properties of over 30 body tissues to parametric expressions for inclusion in numerical solutions. Obtaining the electric field distribution and the resulting energy dissipation is only the first step in the dosimetric analysis, since other phenomena, such as heat conduction or blood thermoregulation must be evaluated. The bioheat equation, first suggested in 1948, takes into account these phenomena and has been evolving into modified versions. These improvements consist of the inclusion of terms to account for the sweating, heat losses in lungs, variable metabolism or blood flow, or even these last two triggered by temperature thresholds in the hypothalamus region.
References [1]
Lin, J.C., “Update of IEEE radio frequency exposure guidelines,” Microwave Magazine, IEEE, Vol. 7, No. 2, pp. 24–28, April 2006.
60
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter [2] ICNIRP, “Guidelines for Limiting Exposure to Time-Varying Electric, Magnetic, and Electromagnetic Fields (up to 300 GHz),” 1998. [3] Martínez-González, A., Fernández-Pascual, A., de los Reyes, E., Gabriel, C., van Loock, W., and Sánchez-Hernández, D., “A practical procedure for the verification of compliance of digital mobile radio base stations to the limitations of exposure of the general public to electromagnetic fields,” IEE Proceedings on Microwaves, Antennas and Propagation, Vol. 149, pp. 218–228, 2002. [4] Olivier, C., and Martens, L., “Optimal settings for narrow-band signal measurements used for exposure assessment around GSM base stations,” IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement, pp. 311–317, 2005. [5] Guy, A.W., Webb, M.D., and Sorensen, C.C., “Determination of Power Absorption in Man Exposed to High Frequency Electromagnetic Fields by Thermographic Measurements on Scale Models,” IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, Vol. 23, No. 5, pp. 361–371, 1976. [6] Gandhi, O.P., “Conditions of Strongest Electromagnetic Power Deposition in Man and Animals,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 23, No. 12, pp. 1021–1029, 1975. [7] Chi-Taou, T., Massoudi, H., Durney, C.H., and Iskander, M.F., “A Procedure for Calculating Fields Inside Arbitrarily Shaped, Inhomogeneous Dielectric Bodies Using Linear Basis Functions with the Moment Method,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 34, No. 11, pp. 1131–1139, 1986. [8] Pethig, R., Dielectric and Electronic Properties of Biological Materials, New York, John Wiley, 1979. [9] Metaxas, A.C., and Meredith, R.J., Industrial Microwave Heating, London: Peter Peregrinus, 1983. [10] Fujimoto, K., Mobile Antenna Systems Handbook, Norwood, MA: Artech House, 2001. [11] “A Practical Guide to the Determination of Human Exposure to Radio Frequency Fields,” NCRP Report No. 119, National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements, Bethesda, MD, 1993. [12] Gabriel, C., “Compilation of the dielectric properties of body tissues at RF and microwave frequencies,” Report N.AL/OE-TR-1996-0037, Occupational and Environmental Health Directorate, Radiofrequency Radiation Division, Brooks Air Force Base, Texas (USA), 1996. [13] Chen, L.F., Onk, C.K., Neo, C.P., Varadan, V.V., and Varadan V.K., Microwave Electronics, Measurement and Materials Characterisation, West Sussex: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., 2004. [14] Afsar, M.U., Birch, J.R., Clarck, R.N., and Chantry, G.W., “The measurement of the properties of materials,” Proceedings of the IEEE, Vol. 74, pp. 183–199, 1986. [15] Baker-Jarvis, J., Janezic, M.D., Grosvenor, J.H., Jr., and Geyer, R.G., “Transmission/Reflection and Short-Circuit Line Methods for Measuring Permittivity and Pearmibility,” NIST Technical Note 1355 (revised), U.S. Department of Commerce, 1993. [16] Guillon, P., “Microwave Techniques for Measuring Complex Permittivity and Permeability of Materials,” in Materials and Processes for Wireless Communications, T. Negas and H. Lings, (Eds.), The American Ceramic Society, Westerville, pp. 65–71, 1995. [17] Krupka, J., and Weil, C., “Recent Advances in Metrology for the Electromagnetic Characterization of Materials at Microwave Frequencies,” 12th International Conference on Microwave and Radar, Vol. 4, pp. 243–253, 1998. [18] Weil, C.W., “The NIST Metrology Program on Electromagnetic Characterization of Materials,” in Materials and Processes for Wireless Communications, T. Negas and H. Lings, (Eds.), The American Ceramic Society, Westerville, 1995. [19] Zaki, K.A., and Wang, C., “Accurate Measurements of Electrical Properties of Dielectric Resonators and Substrate Materials,” in Materials and Processes for Wireless Communica-
2.5 Conclusions
[20] [21]
[22]
[23]
[24]
[25]
[26] [27] [28]
[29]
[30]
[31]
[32] [33]
[34]
[35] [36]
[37] [38]
61
tions, T. Negas and H. Lings, (Eds.), The American Ceramic Society, Westerville, pp. 49–63, 1995. Agilent, “Solutions for Measuring Permittivity and Permeability with LCR Meters and Impedance Analyzers,” Application Note 1369-1. “Test methods for A-C loss characteristics and permittivity (dielectric constant) of solid electrical insulating materials,” ASTM Standard D 150, American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM). Gandhi, O.P., and Riazi, A., “Absorption of millimeter waves by human beings and its biological implications,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 34, pp. 228–235, 1986. Christ, A., Klingenböck, A., and Samaras, T., “The dependence of electromagnetic far-field absorption on body tissue composition in the frequency range from 300 MHz to 6 GHz,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 54, No. 5, pp. 2188–2195, 2006. Li, C.C., and Chen, K.M., “Determination of electromagnetic properties of materials using flanged open-ended coaxial probe—full-wave analysis,” IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement, Vol. 44, pp.19–27, 1995. Stuchly, M.A., and Stuchy, S.S., “Coaxial line reflection method for measuring dielectric properties of biological substances at radio and microwave frequencies – a review,” IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement, Vol. 29, pp. 176–183, 1980. http://www.keycom.co.jp. http://www.agilent.com. Berube, D., Ghannouchi, F.M., and Savard, P., “A comparative study of four open-ended coaxial probe models for permittivity measurements of lossy dielectric biolofical materials at microwave frequencies,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 44, No. 10, pp. 1928–1934, 1996. Stuchly, M.A., Athey, T.W., Samaras, C.M., and Taylor, G.E, “Measurement of radio frequency permittivity of biological tissues with an open-ended coaxial line: part II – experimental results,” IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement, Vol. 30, No. 1, pp. 87–91, 1982. Brady, M.M., Symons, S.A., and Stuchly, S.S., “Dielectric behavior of selected animal tissues in vitro at frequencies from 2 to 4 GHz,” IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, Vol. 28, No. 3, pp. 305–307, 1981. Ghannouchi, F.M., and Bosisio, R.G., “Measurement of microwave permittivity using six-port reflector with an open-ended coaxial line,” IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement, Vol. 38, No. 2, pp. 505–508, 1989. Stuchly, M.A., and Stuchly, S.S., “Dielectric properties of biological substances—tabulated,” Journal of Microwave Power, Vol. 15, No. 1, pp. 19–26, 1980. Panariello, G., Verolino, L., and Vitolo, G., “Efficient and accurate full-wave analysis of the open-ended coaxial cable,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 49, No. 7, pp. 1304–1309, 2001. Catala-Civera, J.M. Canos, A.J. Penaranda-Foix, F.L. de los Reyes Davo, E., “Accurate determination of the complex permittivity of materials with transmission reflection measurements in partially filled rectangular waveguides,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 51, No. 1, pp. 16–24, 2003. Pozar, D. M., Microwave Engineering, Third Edition, New York: Wiley, 2005. Nicolson, A.M., and Rose, G.F., “Measurement of the intrinsic properties of materials by time domain techniques,” IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement, Vol. 19, pp. 377–382, 1970. Weir, W.B., “Automatic measurement of complex dielectric constant and permeability at microwave frequencies,” Proceedings of the IEEE, Vol. 62, pp. 33–36, 1974. Requena-Perez, M.E. Albero-Ortiz, A. Monzo-Cabrera, J., and Diaz-Morcillo, A., “Combined use of genetic algorithms and gradient descent optimization methods for accurate
62
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
[39]
[40]
[41]
[42]
[43]
[44]
[45]
[46]
[47] [48] [49] [50] [51] [52] [53]
[54] [55] [56]
[57] [58]
inverse permittivity measurement,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 54, No. 2, pp. 615–624, 2006. Santra, M., and Limaye, K.U., “Estimation of complex permittivity of arbitrary shape and size dielectric samples using cavity measurement technique at microwave frequencies,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 53, No. 2, pp. 718–722, 2005. Eugene, E., Kopyt, E.P., and Yakovlev, V.V., “Determination of complex permittivity with neural networks and FDTD modeling,” Microwave Optical Technology Letters, Vol. 40, No. 3, pp. 183–188, 2004. Thakur, K.P., and Holmes, W.S., “An inverse technique to evaluate permittivity of material in a cavity,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 49, No. 6, pp. 1129–1132, 2001. Kobayashi, Y., and Tamaka, S., “Resonant modes of a dielectric rod resonator short-circuited at both ends by parallel conducting plates,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 28, pp. 1077–1085, 1980. Courtney, W.E., “Analysis and evaluation of a method of measuring the complex permittivity and permeability of microwave insulators,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 18, pp. 476–485, 1970. Kobayashi, Y., Aoki, T., and Kabe, Y., “Influence of conductor shields on the Q-factors of a TE0 dielectric resonator,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 33, No. 12, pp. 1361–1366, 1985. Krupka, J., Geyer, R.J., Kuhn, M., and Hinden, J.H., “Dielectric Properties of Al2O3, LaAlO3 and MgO at cryogenic temperature,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 42, pp. 1886–1890, 1994. Peyman, A., Rezazadeh, A.A., and Gabriel, C., “Dielectric properties of porcine cerebrospinal tissues at microwave frequencies: in vivo, in vitro and systematic variation with age,” Phys. Med. Biol., Vol. 52, pp. 2229–2245, 2007. Foster, K.R., and Herman, P., “Schwan: A scientist and pioneer in biomedical engineering,” Annual Review of Biomedical Engineering, Vol. 4, pp. 1–27, 2002. Debye, P., Polar Molecules, Mineola, NY: Dover, 1929. Cole, K.S., and Cole, R.H., “Dispersion and absorption in dielectrics. I. Alternating current characteristics,” Journal of Chemical Physics, Vol. 9, No. 4, pp. 341–351, 1941. Davidson, D.W., and Cole, R.H., “Dielectric relaxation in glycerol, propylene glycol and n-propanol,” Journal of Chemical Physics, Vol. 19, No. 12, pp. 1484–1490, 1951. Havriliak, S., and Negami, S., “A complex plane analysis of α-dispersion in some polymer systems,” Journal of Polymer Science: Part C, Vol. 14, pp. 99–117, 1966. Jonscher, A.K., Dielectric Relaxations in Solids, London: Chelsea Dielectrics Press, 1983. Raicu, V., “Dielectric dispersion of biological matter: Model combining Debye-type and ‘universal’ responses,” Physical Review E (Statistical Physics, Plasmas, Fluids, and Related Interdisciplinary Topics), Vol. 60, pp. 4677–4680, 1999. Dissado, L.A., “A fractal interpretation of the dielectric response of animal tissues,” Physics in Medicine and Biology, Vol. 35, No. 11, pp. 1487–1503, 1990. Barnes, F.S., and Greenebaum, B., Bioengineering and Biophysical Aspects of Electromagnetic Fields, Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, pp. 51–100, 2006. Gabriel, C., Chan, T.Y.A., and Grant, E.H., “Admittance models for open ended coaxial probes and their place in dielectric spectroscopy,” Physics in Medicine and Biology, Vol. 39, No. 12, pp. 2183–2200, 1994. Durney, C.H., Massoudi, H., and Iskander, M.F., “Radiofrequency radiation dosimetry handbook,” Brooks Air Force Base, USAFSAM-TR-85-73, 1986. Geddes, L.A., and Barker, L.E., “The specific resistance of biological material—A compendium of data for the biomedical engineer and physiologist,” Medical and Biological Engineering, Vol. 5, pp. 271–293, 1967.
2.5 Conclusions
63
[59] Stuchly, S.S., Sibbald, C.L., and Anderson, J.M., “A new admittance model for open-ended waveguides,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 42, No. 2, pp. 192–198, 1994. [60] Foster, K.R., and Schwan, H.P., “Dielectric properties of tissues and biological materials: A critical review,” Critical Reviews in Biomedical Engineering, Vol. 17, No. 1, pp. 25–104, 1989. [61] Duck, F.A., Physical Properties of Tissue: A Comprehensive Reference Book, San Diego, CA: Academic Press, 1990. [62] Schmid, G., Neubauer, G. and Mazal, P.R., “Dielectric properties of human brain tissue measured less than 10h postmortem at frequencies from 800 to 2450 MHz,” Bioelectromagnetics, Vol. 24, pp. 423–430, 2003. [63] Burdette, E.C., et al., “In situ permittivity of canine brain: Regional variations and postmortem changes,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 34, No. 1, pp. 38–49, 1986. [64] Fukunaga, K., Watanabe, S. and Yamanaka, Y., “Dielectric Properties of Tissue-Equivalent Liquids and Their Effects on Specific Absorption Rate,” IEEE Transactions on Electromagnetic Compatibility, Vol. 46, No. 1, pp. 126–129, 2004. [65] Monzó-Cabrera, J., Díaz-Morcillo, A., Catalá-Civera, J.M., and de los Reyes, E., “Heat and Mass Transfer Characterisation of Microwave Drying of Leather,” Proceedings of the 12th International Drying Symposium, Noordwijk, Holland, 2000. [66] Jackson, J.D., Classical Electrodynamic, Second Edition, New York: Wiley, 1975. [67] Hurt, W.D., Ziriax, J.M., and Mason, P.A., “Variability in EMF Permittivity Values: Implications for SAR Calculations,” IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, Vol. 47, No. 3, pp. 396–401, 2000. [68] Gajšek, P., et al., “Parametric Dependence of SAR on Permittivity Values in a Man Model,” IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, Vol. 48, No. 10, pp. 1169–1177, 2001. [69] Parazzini, M., et al., “Modeling of the Internal Fields Distribution in Human Inner Hearing System Exposed to 900 and 1800 MHz,” IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, Vol. 54, No. 1, pp. 39–47, 2007. [70] Mochizuki, S., et al., “Effects of Ear Shape and Head Size on Simulated Head Exposure to a Cellular Phone,” IEEE Transactions on Electromagnetic Compatibility, Vol. 49, No. 3, pp. 512–518, 2007. [71] Kanda, M., et al., “Effects of ear-connection modeling on the electromagnetic-energy absorption in a human-head phantom exposed to a dipole antenna field at 835 MHz,” IEEE Transactions on Electromagnetic Compatibility, Vol. 44, No. 1, pp. 4–10, 2002. [72] Peyman, A., Rezazade, A.A., and Gabriel, C., “Changes in the dielectric properties of rat tissue as a function of age at microwave frequencies,” Physics in Medicine and Biology, Vol. 46, pp. 1617–1629, 2001. [73] Mason, P.A., et al., “Effects of Frequency, Permittivity, and Voxel Size on Predicted Specific Absorption Rate Values in Biological Tissue During Electromagnetic-Field Exposure,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 48, No. 11, pp. 2050–2057, 2000. [74] Gabriel, C., “Dielectric Properties of Biological Tissue: Variation with Age,” Bioelectromagnetics, Vol. 26, No. S7, pp. S12–S18, 2005. [75] Gandhi, O.P., Lazzi, G., and Furse, C.M., “Electromagnetic absorption in the human head and neck for mobile telephones at 835 MHz and 1900 MHz,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 44, No. 10, pp. 1884–1897, 1996. [76] Schoenborn, F., Burkhardt, M. and Kuster, N., “Differences in energy absorption between heads of adults and children in the near field of sources,” Health Physics, Vol. 74, No. 2, pp. 160–168, 1998. [77] Wang, J., and Fujiwara, O., “Comparison and Evaluation of Electromagnetic Absorption Characteristics in Realistic Human Head Models of Adult and Children for 900-MHz
64
Fundamentals of Electromagnetic Fields Interaction with Matter
[78]
[79]
[80]
[81] [82] [83]
[84] [85]
[86]
[87] [88]
[89]
[90] [91] [92] [93] [94]
[95]
Mobile Telephones,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 51, No. 3, pp. 996–971, 2003. Wang, J., Fujiwara, O. and Watanabe, S., “Approximation of Aging Effect on Dielectric Tissue Properties for SAR Assessment of Mobile Telephones,” IEEE Transactions on Electromagnetic Compatibility, Vol. 48, No. 2, pp. 408–413, 2006. Monebhurrun, V., et al., “A Numerical Approach for the Determination of the Tissue Equivalent Liquid Used During SAR Assessments,” IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, Vol. 38, No. 2, pp. 745–748, 2002. Wake, K., et al., “An Exposure System for Long-Term and Large-Scale Animal Bioassay of 1.5-GHz Digital Cellular Phones,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 55, No. 2, pp. 242–250, 2007. Pennes, H. H., “Analysis of tissue and arterial blood temperature in the resting human forearm,” Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 1, No. 2, pp. 93–122, 1948. Wulff, W., “The Energy Conservation Equation for Living Tissue,” IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, Vol. 21, No. 6, pp. 494–495, 1974. Shepherd, A.P., Steinke, J.M., and McMahan, C.A., “Effect of oximetry error on the diagnostic value of the Qp/Qs ratio,” International Journal of Cardiology, Vol. 61, pp. 247–259, 1997. Bardati, F., Gerosa, G., and Lampariello, P., “Temperature distribution in simulated living tissues irradiated electromagnetically,” Alta Frequenza, Vol. 49, No. 2, pp. 61–67, 1980. Bernardi, P., et al., “SAR Distribution and Temperature Increase in an Anatomical Model of the Human Eye Exposed to the Field Radiated by the User Antenna in a Wireless LAN,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 46, No. 12, pp. 2074–2082, 1998. Riu, P.J., and Foster, K.R., “Heating of Tissue by Near-Field Exposure to a Dipole: A Model Analysis,” IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, Vol. 46, No. 8, pp. 911–917, 1999. Institute for Scientific Information, Inc., Science Citation Index 1956–1996, Philadelphia, PA: Institute for Scientific Information, Inc., 1997. Bernardi, P., Cavagnaro, M., Pisa, S., and Piuzzi, E., “Specific Absorption Rate and Temperature Elevation in a Subject Exposed in the Far-Field of Radio-Frequency Sources Operating in the 10–900-MHz Range,” IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, Vol. 50, No. 3, pp. 295–304, 2003. Yang, D., et al., “Expanding the Bioheat Equation to Include Tissue Internal Water Evaporation During Heating,” IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, Vol. 54, No. 8, pp. 1382–1388, 2007. Wissler, E.H., “Pennes’ 1948 paper revisited,” Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 85, pp. 36–42, 1998. Baish, J.W., Ayyaswamy, P.S., and Foster K.R., “Perfused phantom models of microwave irradiated tissue,” Journal of Biomechanical Engineering, Vol. 108, pp. 239–245, 1986. Stone, J.G., et al., “Direct intraoperative measurement of human brain temperature,” Neurosurgery, Vol. 41, pp. 20–24, 1997. Nelson, D.A., “Invited Editorial on ‘Pennes’ 1948 paper revisited,” Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 85, pp. 2–3, 1998. García-Fernández, M.A., and Sánchez-Hernández, D., “The merging of EM equations and thermal diffusion and convection and its consequences on current knowledge for human protection regarding exposure to EM fields,” Proceedings of the HES-07: International Symposium on Heating by Electromagnetic Sources Induction, Dielectric, Conduction & EMP, Padua, Italy, June 20–22, 2007, pp. 211–218. Samaras, T., Regli, P., and Kuster, N., “Electromagnetic and heat transfer computations for non-ionizing radiation dosimetry,” Phys. Med. Biol., Vol. 45, pp. 2233–2246, 2000.
2.5 Conclusions
65
[96] Sullivan, D.M., “Three-dimensional computer simulation in deep regional hyperthermia using the FDTD method,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Technology, Vol. 38, pp. 204–211, 1990. [97] Pickard, W.F., Straube, W.L., Moros, E.G. and Fan, X., “Simplified model and measurement of specific absorption rate distribution in a culture flask within a transverse electromagnetic mode exposure system,” Bioelectromagnetics, Vol. 20, pp. 183–193, 1999. [98] Grayson, J., “Internal calorimetry in the determination of thermal conductivity and blood flow,” Journal of Physiology, Vol. 118, pp. 54–72, 1952. [99] Chato, J.C., “A method for the measurement of the thermal properties of biological materials,” Thermal Problems in Biotechnology, J.C. Chato, (Ed.), ASME symposium series, American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York, 1968. [100] Cooper, T.E., and Trezek, G.J., “Correlation of thermal properties of some human tissue with water content,” Aerospace Medicine, Vol. 42, pp. 24–27, 1971. [101] Balasubramaniam, T.A., and Bowman, H.F., “Thermal conductivity and thermal diffusivity of biomaterials: A simultaneous measurement technique,” J. Biomech. Engr., Vol. 99, pp. 148–154, 1977. [102] Drane, C.R., “The thermal conductivity of the skin of crocodilians,” Comp. Biochemical Physiology, Vol. 68A, pp. 107–110, 1981. [103] Dumas, A., and Barozzi, G.S., “Laminar heat transfer to blood flowing in a circular duct,” Int. Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, Vol. 27, pp. 391–398, 1984. [104] Holmes, K.R., Ryan, W., and Chen, M.M., “Thermal conductivity and H2O content in rabbit kidney cortex and medulla,” J. Therm. Biol., Vol. 8, pp. 311–313, 1983. [105] Kvadsheim, P.H., Folkow, L.P., and Blix, A.S., “A new device for measurement of the thermal conductivity of fur and blubber,” Journal of Thermal Biology, Vol. 19, pp. 431–435, 1994. [106] Kvadsheim, P.H., Folkow, L.P., and Blix, A.S., “Thermal conductivity of Minke whale blubber,” Journal of Thermal Biology, Vol. 21, pp. 123–128, 1996. [107] McIntosh, R.L., Anderson, V., and McKenzie, R.J., “A Numerical Evaluation of SAR Distribution and Temperature Changes Around a Metallic Plate in the Head of a RF Exposed Worker,” Bioelectromagnetics, Vol. 26, pp. 377–388, 2005. [108] Valvano, J.W., Allen J.T., and Bowman, H.F., “The simultaneous measurement of thermal conductivity, thermal diffusivity, and perfusion in small volumes of tissue,” ASME 81-WA/HT-21, 1981. [109] Valvano, J.W., Cochran, J.R., and Diller, K.R., “Thermal conductivity and diffusivity of biomaterials measured with self-heated thermistors,” Int. Journal of Thermophysiology, Vol. 6, pp. 301–311, 1985.
CHAPTER 3
Far-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry Antonio M. Martínez-González
3.1
Introduction Legislation regarding limitations of exposure of the general public to electromagnetic fields has been approved in most Western countries within the last 10 years [1–29]. Strong research efforts ever since have concentrated on determining accurate near- and far-field exposure assessment through simulation or measurement procedures for either the verification of compliance of wireless transmitting facilities or mobile handsets to these limitations or simply to find out accurate field values for exposure evaluation and/or planning parameters. The importance of an adequate exposure assessment and its standardization is without doubt considering that people can be exposed to the field radiated by transmitting stations for a long time or by wireless handsets. Yet, the exposure levels on urban streets from transmitting stations are generally much lower than those due to mobile handset antennas. In fact, exposure from base stations (BS) is rather different to that of mobile handset antennas. Several studies have found that specific absorption rate (SAR) values are found to be maximum at and around the human ear for mobile handsets [30–36], with reported temperature increases of the ear lobe between 1.0° and 2.4°C after a 20-minute talking phase depending on location and phone type (other phases were stand-by, ringing, and switching off). This heating was attributed not only to SAR, but also to heating from the electronic part of the device, with an important reduction in ventilation due to the presence of the device near the face. Temperature increases were located within the first 5 to 7 minutes, and then gradually decreased. For the case of wireless transmitting facilities, however, there are other regions in the human body like the neck, chest, ankles, knees, trunk, or the back wherein the highest SAR values have been experimentally observed [37–41], mainly due to direct exposure or reflections from the rear building walls. In fact, the highest whole-body SAR when the man model is exposed to a vertically polarized plane wave occurs at around 70 MHz, while in the frequency range from 200 to 600 MHz energy absorption is prominent in the regions surroundings the ankles, knees, and neck [41, 42]. Increasing the frequency augmented the amount of energy depos-
67
68
Far-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry
ited on the skin, while the energy absorption within the brain is maximal between 600 to 800 MHz. The International Commission for Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection (ICNIRP) and other institutions have published guidelines to specify a number of basic restrictions on the amount of electromagnetic energy which can be absorbed by the human body without ill effects [43–48]. Basic restrictions on electromagnetic field exposure are also provided for both the general public and workers exposed in the workplace in terms of SAR values. Taking measurements of basic restriction values on volunteers is not always possible due to the ethical concerns regarding the implantation of deep body temperature probes and the scarcity of volunteers, and experiments on animals are a poor approximation to the “real” human scenario. In view of these difficulties, standardization bodies provide reference levels expressed in terms of electromagnetic field strengths, which are evaluated in the absence of a person. Specified reference levels are developed in a conservative way, in that they have been derived using worst case conditions of electrical coupling, so that by ensuring that the reference levels are not surpassed, providing that there is no focalized exposure, the basic restrictions are not surpassed either, or at least to the knowledge available at the time, as we will see throughout this section. These reference levels, however, are derived from plane-wave incidence exposure, which is limited to far-field situations, and some new discoveries to this effect will be highlighted in this chapter. In an urban scenario, with its rather complex environment, surrounding scattering objects, and multiple reflections and diffractions, the coupling mechanism for deferring reference levels may not occur even at far-field distances. Nevertheless, due to the narrow radiation pattern of most sectored base stations, evaluating compliance to safety limits is usually accomplished by evaluating field levels and comparing these to reference levels in the standards. Hence, the use of reference levels as magnitudes for compliance assessment of transmitting wireless facilities has to consider the fact that exposure does not have to be very localized within the human being subjected to the exposure. This happens at very close distances to the radioelectric sources, where a direct evaluation of basic restrictions is more appropriate. That is, when dealing with health issues in the near-field between 100 kHz and 10 GHz, and in order to prevent whole-body heat stress and excessive localized heating of tissues, it is usual to provide basic restrictions on SAR, described in Section 3.2. For the mobile handset scenario, the exposure region is typically the reactive near-field, and thus either simulations or measurements of SAR are required for evaluating electromagnetic field exposure and compliance to standard safety limits. This evaluation can be extended to the intimate proximity of base station antennas for diverse systems (GSM, UMTS, WLAN, etc.) or wireless devices, as we will also illustrate further on. For the handset scenario, dependence with distance from the source, orientation of the handset, frequency, technology, shape, size, and heterogeneity of the human model are critical parameters when energy absorption inside human tissue is going to be computed [30, 32, 34, 49]. Despite the vast number of publications on the issue, electromagnetic dosimetry is still the subject of many research efforts due to the large number of variables involved in the process and the tremendously wide range of realistic scenarios for handset use in mobile communications or for the wide diversity of base station antennas. In this chapter we will illustrate important issues for simulated far-field
3.2 Electromagnetic Exposure Evaluation and Compliance Testing
69
exposure assessment and compliance testing procedures generally due to transmitting facilities, including some critical parameters such as frequency, phantom and source modeling or numerical artifacts such as averaging and meshing. Some of the most recent developments will be outlined, specific procedures described, engineering rigorous technical recommendations provided, sources of inaccuracies identified, and recommendations for further review highlighted.
3.2
Electromagnetic Exposure Evaluation and Compliance Testing The prediction of exposure to electromagnetic fields emitted by wireless transmitting facilities is very similar to more conventional coverage prediction since both are intended to determine field intensities at a given point or area. The difference arrives when analyzing the intended assessment to be carried out since coverage refers to the offering of a wireless facility with an assigned quality over a given area, which is only investigated by determining whether the predicted field intensity is greater than a given minimum threshold related to the sensitivity of the mobile terminal [50]. Exposure evaluation, on the other hand, is related to the exposition of the human body to the incident electromagnetic field at each time by evaluating unperturbed electric and magnetic field strengths in the near-field and power density in the far-field. Since electromagnetic safety guidelines usually take into account the alternating nature of the fields and are based upon thermal effects, exposure is normally evaluated by averaging instantaneous incident field values in both time and space in the absence of a person. When these values are compared to existing averaged safety limits in order to determine whether the legal requirements to comply with these limits are satisfied, compliance testing procedures are performed. This means that if the purpose of the evaluation is to determine compliance testing, some approximations to either the prediction formulas or the measurements leading to overestimated values are acceptable [51]. Yet, should these approximations be considered, when compliance testing is not achieved, it does not necessarily means that safety limits are surpassed, and more accurate predictions or measurements are required. Simulation tools have a series of advantages over measurements for evaluating electromagnetic dosimetry, with the special ability to study specific individual effects of certain parameters by keeping others constant. Other advantages are an almost free set-up of the computational model for placement of gadgets and objects under study [52] and avoiding the ageing effect of tissue simulating liquids while the simulations run in the background. Early studies use simple uniform plane wave exposure scenarios and free-space formulas [53, 54], also known as spherical-wave models. Yet, simple free-space simulation engines are generally considered to underestimate real far-field values, and the influence of surrounding buildings cannot be neglected [50]. Moreover, although the use of far-field formulas (spherical-wave) for dosimetric analyses can be employed for distances from the source greater than 2D2/λ [55, 56], they also overestimate near-field values for GSM900 systems while underestimating far-field values, and can only be used for compliance testing [57, 58]. For GSM1800 systems, some authors claim that far-field formulas used for near-field distances also slightly overestimate real near-field values [50–57], while some other authors show that there is an underestimation for the
70
Far-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry 2
far-field-based obtained radiated power using EIRP/4πr at distances within the 2 near-field range, but that measured values of an isotropic probe ( E / η) would accurate represent near-field values obtained using the Poynting vector [59]. Yet, both the cylindrical-wave (which will be described later) and spherical-wave models are included in the European basic standard [60, 61] and in other standards. This is so despite recent studies differentiating their ranges of applicability and limiting accuracy [57, 62]. Comparison between FDTD-cylindrical power density predictor for a 6 × 2 array panel at both 900/1800 MHz is shown in Figures 3.1 and 3.2. Therefore, several techniques have been reported to calculate the electromagnetic fields in the vicinity of wireless transmitting facilities and devices, including the method of moments (MoM) [58], finite-difference time-domain (FDTD) [40, 59, 63], finite integration technique (FIT) [64], generalized multipole technique (GMT) [65, 66], and finite element (FE) methods [58]. While FDTD is preferred for small electromagnetic dosimetry problems (i.e., near-field scenarios) [31, 34, 49, 67–69], 100
S (W/m2)
FDTD Far field approach Cylindrical approach
10
D 2/4λ
1
0.6D 2/λ
4
2
6 R (meters)
D 2/λ
8
10
Figure 3.1 Power density versus distance for a 6 × 2 array panel at 900 MHz. Comparison between results from FDTD, far-field, and cylindrical methods. Radiated power 100W. (Reprinted from [55] with permission from John Wiley and Sons.)
FDTD Far field approach Cylindrical approach
S (W/m2)
100
10
0.6D 2/λ
D 2/4λ
2
D 2/λ
4
6
8
10
R (meters)
Figure 3.2 Power density versus distance for a 6 × 2 array panel at 1,800 MHz. Comparison between results from FDTD, far-field, and cylindrical methods. Radiated power 100W. (Reprinted from [55] with permission from John Wiley and Sons.)
3.3 Human Body and Source Modeling
71
its highly demanding computational requirements make it less efficient for large problems [70, 71], particularly when highly heterogeneous models like the human body are included in the computational domain together with the source. Even today, simulations for whole-body models may take up to days, and a common characteristic to all full-wave methods for exposure assessment is the large inherent computational cost and the need to accurately describe and model the array antenna geometry. Thus, full-wave methods are not usually employed for routine evaluation of compliance or for exposure assessment, and some approximations are usually employed to ease calculation.
3.3
Human Body and Source Modeling 3.3.1
Human Body Model
Measurement of SAR and other internal quantities that may give rise to biological effects which are inherently difficult to measure directly and studies to investigate compliance with the exposure restrictions are carried out using physical or numerical models referred to as phantoms [72, 73]. The physical and electrical characteristics of experimental phantoms are manufactured to represent as closely as possible the response of a person to an incident electromagnetic field. First, heterogeneous models of humans for measuring far-field exposure assessment were developed in the 1980s [53, 74, 75] after some measuring methods like the implantable probe technique [76–78] and the thermographic technique [79–81]. One of these first heterogenous models is depicted in Figure 3.3. The development of whole-body models was undertaken since large discrepancies were found between SAR calculated using separate blocks of the human body and measured values with whole-body phantoms [82, 83]. In these first tests the heterogeneous models provided higher SAR values than previous homogenous models. Later, it was proven that SAR values for whole-body models strongly depend on the parameters of the employed tissues and, more important, on the source and its effect on electromagnetic coupling. In some cases homogeneous models provided higher SAR values than heterogeneous models for the same exposure [40]. Moreover, these first tests already showed that the discrepancies for local SAR values were found to be large between heterogeneous and homogeneous models, which included the location of the maxima. A good example of this effect was the study about the fat-layer thickness of a full-scale human body model [84]. In [84] it was shown that in fact fat layers absorbed more power compared to other tissue types despite their lower conductivity due to its presence in a closer position to that of the exciting source (i.e., closer to the human body skin). When taking into account the human body model, lower peak SAR and peak SAR averaged values were obtained. The human body was therefore acting like an electromagnetic absorbent. By now we know that two effects were mixed up in the first studies (and still are in some) regarding the homogeneous and heterogeneous models. In [85] and [86] it was made clear that, despite the above-mentioned importance of source matching, the homogenous models tend to overestimate SAR values with respect to heterogeneous models only if appropriate muscle-like tissues are employed and only when just the head is modeled. Heterogeneous and, more specifically, anatomical models,
72
Far-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry
Figure 3.3 An external view of the heterogeneous model of man. (Reprinted from [53] with permission from IEEE.)
on the other hand, provide higher SAR values than homogeneous ones (as high as double that in [86]) when the whole body is evaluated. Two other clarifying papers regarding matching fat-related effects have recently been published [86, 87]. In [86], it was anticipated that the fat at the body trunk was acting as a matching layer between free space and the other body tissues so as to allow increased energy transmission to those tissues and consequent Joule heating in those tissues. The overall matching effect has finally been discovered in [87] by analyzing 2D cuts of different regions in an anatomical body model (illustrated in Figure 3.4 and derived from the visual human project), particularly in the trunk and limbs regions, and their exposure to the near-field of dipole antennas. Through a tissue sequence study it was found that some tissue sequences lead to standing-wave effects and that the layered tissue could provide some impedance matching effects, which in turn allows a signif→
H
→
E
Skin
SAT
Muscle
→
k
Figure 3.4
Layered planar tissue model. (From: [87].)
Bone
Lung
3.3 Human Body and Source Modeling
73
icant amount of electromagnetic power to enter the tissue, or a constructive interference giving rise to a significant SAR increase in the skin layer. Depending upon the tissue structure and penetration depth, the standing-wave effect can also occur within the body, and this effect could not be compensated by a tissue simulating liquid. In [73], this effect was compensated with a tissue simulating 2/3-muscle, but only compared to a four-tissue head model. Electromagnetic matching was better achieved for a 2/3-muscle tissue homogeneous head phantom, and that translated into different input impedances for the source and higher power absorbed in the tissue than in any other situation for either 1.5- or 5-mm cell size. In fact, the 2/3-muscle situation was better matched for a 5-mm cell size (providing more absorbed power) than any other tissue even at 1.5-mm cell size due to a better representation of the source and a better matching to the heterogeneous model. In [87], the increase was more pronounced for plane-wave incidence at antenna distances at which far-field-like exposure can be assumed. In fact, the overestimation by homogeneous models in the head was confirmed for close distances, and the absorption in the layered model increases with the antenna distance, with a maximum of 200% to 250%, depending upon the frequency employed, which in fact is threatening the validity of tissue simulating liquids defined by current standards for compliance testing when far-fieldlike exposure conditions are evaluated. The increase of the SAR ratio begins at approximately λ/8, and the maximum is reached at a distance between the antenna and the body of approximately λ/3 for all frequencies. In other words, the body-antenna interaction is one single complicated problem, and each specific layered body (including the homogeneous) is a different electromagnetic problem, so that when the impedance of the antenna in the problem converged that of the free-space value, which strongly depend upon source modeling, body structure and body distance, the problem is matched at both ends and the energy coupling is maximum. Since power density decays strongly with distance, the largest SAR values are observed at the closest distance when the source impedance loaded with the body converges to its free space value. This may seem simple, but it was not published until 2006. In Figure 3.5, this effect is shown for 236 MHz, showing that maximum SAR is not yet achieved for an antenna distance of 300 mm (λ/3 ≈ 424 cm); the effect is maximum at around 50 mm at 2,450 MHz in Figure 3.6 (λ/3 ≈ 41 cm). In Figures 3.5 and 3.6, only 10-, 50-, 100-, 200-, and 300-mm distances were evaluated. The matching effect was also envisaged but it was not the object of the study in [88], wherein it was highlighted that the anatomical details of tissue layers located close to the body’s surface can have a significant influence on the whole-body SAR. The matching effect was also observed when measuring exposure values with probes in [89], wherein the relative deviation of measured probe impedance with respect to that of the free-space situation at the operating frequency was found to be larger when the separation between the measurement probe and the transmitting panel antenna was smaller. The variations were also much larger when both the length of the measurement probe and the transmitting antenna were larger than 0.45λ. By 2000, however, 6-mm whole-body models developed from partial head and neck models originally created in 1996 [30] were employed for testing the response
74
Far-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry 150
real homogeneous imag. homogeneous real layered imag. layered
Impedance in ohms
100
50
0
–50 0
50
150 200 100 Antenna distance in mm
250
300
Figure 3.5 Feedpoint impedance of the λ/2-dipole antenna at 236 MHz as a function of the distance. (Reproduced from [87] with permission from IEEE.)
150
real homogeneous imag. homogeneous real layered imag. layered
Impedance in ohms
100
50
0
–50
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Antenna distance in mm
Figure 3.6 Feedpoint impedance of the λ/2-dipole antenna at 2,450 MHz as a function of the distance. (Reproduced from [87] with permission from IEEE.)
to a 835-MHz (typical of GSM) exposure [35]. Due to the required computational costs, original 2 × 2 × 3-mm resolutions were coarsen to get a 6 × 6 × 6-mm model, and the incident electromagnetic field was calculated based upon the assumption
3.3 Human Body and Source Modeling
75
that the mere presence of the body and its distance to the source did not significantly alter the radiation characteristic of the source in order to ease computational convergence. Other studies at the time used a 5-mm cell size human body model [90]. At that time, however, data from the Visible Human Project (VHP) [91, 92] (sponsored by National Institute of Health) and the Yale Human Project (YHP) (depicted in Figure 3.7 [93], and in which partial-body parts were incorporated from the VHP (legs and arms)), were available, both providing male and female 1-mm resolution (in x and y axes only for Yale, with 3.6-mm in the vertical direction) data extracted from the segmentation of the transmission computerized (CT) X-ray thermographs, ultrasounds, or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) slices of human bodies. Some sort of classifying algorithm is used to differentiate between tissues and their properties of interest and under certain conditions allow for these properties to vary with the orientation of the tissue, wavelength, temperature, or other parameters. The VHP model consists of approximately 400 million voxels of 1 mm3 with 44 different tissue types. 3 More recently, finer resolutions of 3 × 3 × 3 mm [41] and 1.974 × 1.974 × 3 3 mm [94] of the VHP have been conducted, as well as new dielectric 2-mm anatomical models (DAM) with 7,880,380 voxels, wherein permittivity and conductivity vary with continuity even within the same tissue, thus reflecting the intrinsic realistic spatial dispersion of such parameters [95], which leads to higher SAR values than those obtained for VHP human body models [96]. In this last study it was also made clear that, on top of antenna and human body modeling, the distance between the whole-body model and the antenna has to be carefully evaluated, taking into account the specific shape and posture of the body model under consideration. Despite all efforts to numerically evaluate exposure due to transmitting facilities, high resolution (<1 mm) models are essential to resolve functional subregions of the brain, and experimental methods are required to verify the simulations and to iden-
Figure 3.7 IEEE.)
Three views of the Yale body model. (Reproduced from [93] with permission from
76
Far-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry
tify the possible shortcomings of the numerical model [97]. Some of the described models are depicted in Figure 3.8. A standardized human model for far-field evaluation is yet to be agreed upon. Considerable more attention has been paid to the development of human models for near-field evaluation of exposure, as will be described in Chapter 4. 3.3.2
Source Modeling
Simulating the coupling mechanism between an electromagnetic wave and a complete human body model for making a safety assessment has only been made possible recently by characterizing the source simultaneously and because of the current computing capacity of modern workstations. Likewise, the wide variety of possible sources makes the standard near-half-wavelength dipole array ideal as a generic source to calculate the power deposition in the human body and to allow for intercomparable studies. Should commercial antenna data be available, however, that would represent much better the electromagnetic field distribution incident on the human body model for that specific model, and thus several analyses have been performed employing arrays of conventional dipoles, cross-dipoles, and microstrip patches [85, 86]. Some close-form approximations have also been derived for specific sources. Circular loop wires were employed to investigate the power absorbed by a human body in the frequency range from 50 to 400 MHz [98], and were found to provide maximum SAR when the loop was x-oriented (human body vertical was z-oriented). A synthetic model and gain-based model were derived for vertical linear arrays using the principle that the field in the whole antenna can be well approximated by the superposition of the fields of subantennas constituting the antenna [99, 100]. In fact, when the source is assumed to be a uniform array, the fact that far-field exposure cannot easily be assumed when measuring or simulating in the vicinity of a base station is alleviated by the more accurate computation of power density on the surface of an imaginary cylinder that extends from the bottom of the lowest element to the top of the highest element [63]. The cylinder has a radius equal to the distance from the antenna at which estimates of power density are desired. The power density near such an antenna, but at distances at least above λ/2, decays with the inverse of the distance from the antenna and can be estimated with a cylindrical model which can be expressed by the relationship, S=
Prad 2 hπ R
(3.1)
Figure 3.8 Some anatomical full-body phantoms. (Reproduced from [72] and [93] with permission from Wiley and IEEE.)
3.3 Human Body and Source Modeling
77
where Prad is the total radiated power by the array (W) and Prad = P 10 , R is the radius from antenna (m), h is the height of aperture (m), and G is the radiating sector panel gain. Geometry is depicted in Figure 3.9. If G is not provided, it can be approximated by that of a uniformly illuminated rectangular aperture for a typical base station sector antenna panel by G(dBi)/10
G=
4π A ef λ2
(3.2)
where Aef is the effective area, which for an uniformly illuminated aperture (ηil = 1), A ef = A ⋅ η il
(3.3)
and, A is the physical area. Although not all the panel size is radiating, if we take A = a ⋅b
(3.4)
where a, b are the height and width of the radome, respectively, the obtained approximated gain value overestimates the antenna gain and hence is valid for compliance testing. Commercial panel antenna gain values range from 10 to 22 dBi.
Figure 3.9
Linear array antenna in cylindrical coordinates.
78
Far-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry
To refine predictions of power density in the near-field of an antenna, and hence source modeling, a more sophisticated model is required. Hence, at high frequencies and very close to the array, but at least a half-wavelength away to avoid contributions from strong reactive fields surrounding the array elements [63], E ρ ( ρ, z ) << E z ( ρ, z )
(3.5)
with a power density, 1 1 Re⎧⎨ E z H *φ ⎫⎬ ≈ Ez η 2 2 ⎩ ⎭
2
(3.6)
Since for cylindrical waves radiated close to broadside, Ez ≈ η o H φ
(3.7)
it is possible to measure or compute real power density in an average sense by accurately measuring or computing the ⎪Ez⎪2 field at any distance from the array greater than ∼λ/2, which is orthogonal to the direction of propagation and in fact tends to 2 slightly overestimate the local power density taken as (1/2ηo)⎪Ez⎪ . This allows for a 2 valid measurement of ⎪Ez⎪ to properly assess compliance to guideline levels up until ∼λ/2 close to the radiating aperture [63, 101]. In [99], however, the minimum distance is estimated to be 3λ, and in [100], gain-based models were found to be accurate above 2λ. This is easily observed by simply simulating an array of cross dipoles fed in phase, depicted in Figure 3.10, as it is usual for mobile communications base station panel antennas, with the MoM NEC code. If we calculate the impedance of the propagating along the broadside direction, illustrated in Figure 3.11, we can see that at short distances the impedance behaves in a strange way (reactive zone), and that when we reach the transition zone a value higher than 120π is determined. This means that at those distances the antenna array is behaving as an “electrical” antenna, thus having a predominant Ez. As was expected, the further from the antenna we calculate the wave impedance, the closer it gets to the free space far-field value of 120π. Z
Y X Figure 3.10
The cross dipole antenna array used in the simulations.
3.3 Human Body and Source Modeling
79
390
385
Impedance (Ω)
380
375
370
365
360
Figure 3.11
20
10
0
30 Distance (m)
40
50
60
Calculated wave impedance along the broadside direction.
A closer look at the calculated power density, depicted in Figure 3.12, demonstrates the previous statements, but even in the far-field zone for a base station antenna the free space propagation impedance can differ significantly from 120π due to the destructive or constructive interference of the array elements [102]. Thus, by carefully analyzing and comparing simulated power density to that obtained simply by applying the free space E × H relationship for far-field, also shown in Figure 3.12, we can conclude that previous hypotheses are confirmed, particularly the 3λ distance, from which the difference between true power density and free space approximation is negligible. 1.2 E×H E2/120π
2
Power density (W/m )
1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Distance/wavelength
Figure 3.12 NEC-calculated power density versus far-field formula power density along the broadside direction.
80
Far-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry
Yet, it is important to outline that for all these gain-based models that, while the main lobe is generally well matched for all subantennas, results at sidelobe directions may show some discrepancies to real measurements. Only when both the gain pattern of the subantennas and the power distribution of the array can be altered in the simulating model do the results provide excellent results inside the measurement sphere that includes all subantennas and for relatively large E field values [103]. There are yet two other spatial restrictions for the gain-based models. The first is the distance at which exposure is not considered very localized, and hence field evaluation and comparison to reference levels is valid according to ICNIRP guidelines and most standards. Simple and common sense defines the reactive field distance to define localized exposure [99]; that is, r 2 > 0385 . D3 λ
(3.8)
Thus, in order to consider ⎪Ez⎪ evaluation as valid for guidelines level compliance assessment, this must be performed at a distance greater than both 2
r≈ λ
(3.9)
r ≈ 06 . D3 λ
(3.10)
and
that is, whichever is greater. Hence, for a prediction for power density in the far-field of the antenna, the regulatory bodies recommend the use of simple formulas based upon an approximation using radiating apertures, plus a truly worst-case prediction of a power density reflection of incoming radiation at or near a surface. Since these equations are generally accurate in the far-field of an antenna but will overpredict power density in the near-field, they could also be used for making a worst-case or conservative prediction in the near-field, as will be discussed later. The power density can then be derived in this way by S=
PG 4πR 2
(3.11)
2
where, S is the power density (mW/cm ), P is the power input to the antenna (mw), G is the power gain of the antenna in the direction of interest relative to an isotropic radiator, and R is the distance to the center of radiation of the antenna (cm), or S=
EIRP 4πR 2
(3.12)
where, EIRP is the equivalent (or effective) isotropically radiated power, or S=
. ERP 0.41ERP EIRP 164 = = 2 πR 2 4πR 4πR 2
(3.13)
where, ERP is the equivalent radiated power referred to a half-wave dipole radiator.
3.3 Human Body and Source Modeling
81
For a truly worst-case prediction of power density at or near a surface, such as at ground-level or on a rooftop, the U.S. Federal Communications Commission (FCC) [104] assumes a 100% reflection of incoming radiation, resulting in a four-fold increase in (far-field equivalent) power density, S=
(2 )
2
PG
4πR 2
=
PG EIRP = πR 2 πR 2
(3.14)
The Australian Communications Authority [105, 106], on the other hand, recommended until 2003 the prediction of power density emitted by the antenna with S=
2.56EIRP 4πR 2
(3.15)
where the 2.56 factor is the power density increase due to the ground reflection, obtained by assuming a maximum factor of 1.6 in field strength, which in terms of power density yields a 1.6 × 1.6 = 2.56. Yet, this is only an approximation that overestimates the near-field real power density for free-of-obstacles radiating apertures, and the previous equations will considerably over-predict the power density produced by an antenna when the point of interest is not in the far-field of the antenna and the near-field is not free of obstacles. When in the near-field of the antenna, the gain of the antenna is effectively reduced. Additionally, the power density decays directly with increasing distance from the antenna rather than the square of the distance as suggested by previous equations. Other authors employ generic sources using omnidirectional in azimuth and vertically symmetrical radiation patterns for predicting exposure values [50], which for far-field values may be sufficient considering that adjacent sector antenna diagrams usually overlap in order to render the resulting field strength level uniform, as it does for an omnidirectional antenna. Despite the radiation pattern employed, when using array elements some field nonuniformities are inherently expected [58, 108]. In most outdoor dosimetry studies, the highest field levels are obtained on nearby buildings on the main beam direction, and they also show a large nonuniformity on field distribution. A simple way to examine field uniformity for typical panel array antennas like the ones depicted in Figure 3.10 is to evaluate the field uniformity using NEC. This is the same simulation that was performed to get Figures 3.11 and 3.12, but this time calculating the field uniformity along the array axis versus distance from the array in the broadside direction (i.e., the x-z plane in Figure 3.10 is shown in Figure 3.13). From Figure 3.13 one can observe that moving ±1.5m away from the array center in the array axis makes calculated E values depend strongly with distance in the z-axis (away from broadside). At a distance of 12m the variation is not so big, which means that should exposure assessment of compliance testing have to be taken close to the source, a vertical (since panel antennas are normally mounted vertically) spatial uniformity factor has to be considered. In fact, most standards specify that should simulated or measured time-averaged field values vary less than ±10%, a single spatial measurement set at a vertical height of 1.5m to 2m (depending upon the specific standard) from the floor, or an equivalent to the human chest height in other possible situations with no floor, has
Far-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry
E (V/m)
82
Offset (m)
Figure 3.13 NEC-calculated field uniformity variation versus distance from the source in the broadside direction.
to be considered. Otherwise, a vertical spatial averaging procedure has to be introduced for proper assessment between 1m and 2m or over an area equivalent to the vertical cross-section of the human body. In this way, the maximum field strengths are evaluated along the main axis of the body in the area of head, chest, and pelvis, at the minimum. It is important to remark that these conclusions and assumptions are valid for a typical antenna array panel, and that for other antennas (i.e., omnidirectional) care must be taken. Field uniformity is further enhanced by environmental reflections [90]. Current base-station antennas can adopt a wide variety of technologies (microstrip, coplanar waveguides, wires, etc.), shapes, beam widths, and polarizations. Thus, the strong dependence of SAR on source characteristics, recently confirmed by measurements in [109], has prompted the need to use simple common generic antennas [96, 110], such as the 0.45λ dipole antenna, to ease comparison between studies, as was commented earlier. Finite-size metal reflectors [35, 58, 100], flanges [96], or other artifacts have also been added to the simple dipole in order to search for specific antenna-related results.
3.4
Simulation Techniques As has been mentioned before, the simplest approximation is to assume far-field exposure, which is called the spherical-wave far-field model, but this is not always the situation and the direct application of far-field patterns to compute near-field power density values also underestimates real magnitudes [59], and more developed refinements are required. Thus, using the far-field formula may be sufficient for compliance testing since far-field formulas tend to overestimate the radiated power density when employed in the close range of the antenna [111], but it is not accurate enough for exposure assessment. For this situation the FCC recommends the use of a cylindrical-wave model [104], which assumes that spatially averaged plane-wave power density values from omnidirectional antennas are equivalent to those provided by dividing the delivered input power by the surface of an imaginary cylinder
3.4 Simulation Techniques
83
surrounding the length on the antenna. For directional antennas, the cylindrical-wave model divides the power by the portion of a cylindrical surface area corresponding to a certain beam width value of the antenna pattern in azimuth. The cylindrical model, however, fails to accurately predict power density values at far-field distances, and some crossover point validation between the two models have been published [111], resulting in crossover validity distances for vertically polarized arrays being dependent upon directional properties of the antenna and its height. A variety of the cylindrical model is the hybrid prediction method which takes advantage of those situations wherein colinear arrays are used as radiating elements to approximate the field by the superposition of the fields of subantennas constituting the antenna, which is described in [50] and [90]. This technique can speed up the simulations and approach validity ranges for as close as nearly one wavelength. Another way to reduce full-wave resources is to combine the spherical waves triples [112] and antenna models [99] with 3D ray tracing propagation models to accurately predict field strength levels in and around the near-field region [113], or use a mixed FDTD-integral equation approach to couple stored FDTD-computed impulse responses of the human body to incident electromagnetic field measured on-site [35]. When accounting for reflections and diffractions, ray-tracing simplification techniques are also useful [114, 115] to be combined with FDTD [90, 116, 117], although their validity is generally limited to the far-field region of the antenna under consideration. Another possibility is to simplify the nearly impossible work of deriving either a close-form or an integral-form expression of the Green’s function for the problem by assuming the exposure to be similar to that of a plane of sources incident on the human body just in front of it, grazing the toes, and calculate the Green’s functions numerically due to a set of spatially narrow pulses selected on the plane of incidence of the field or the source plane [35], as depicted in Figure 3.14. Nevertheless, hybrid simulation engines using full-wave methods combined with ray-tracing or the integral equation [35] for exposure evaluation also tend to overestimate field values, which can be sufficient for compliance testing but rather poor for exposure assessment [50]. This is so despite the combination with ray-tracing still being required to limit the number of reflections and/or refractions to be taken into account and using the far-field radiation pattern of the source and the second with inherent ±10% accuracy. On top of this, ray-tracing techniques also require detailed description of the dielectric properties of materials within the analyzed volume for a correct evaluation of the exposure conditions [90]. Some hybridization between ray-tracing and other techniques for overcoming these drawbacks have been published [50, 90]. Some of the results published in [90] are reproduced in Figure 3.15. Yet, their validity is always limited for distances over the reactive field region; that is, r>>λ and r<2D2/λ. Although hybridized ray-tracing techniques used in the near-field or in the intermediate-field (near- to far-field) regions provide more accurate results than far-field formulas used in the near-field, they still overestimate real near-field values [50]. One good example of this hybridization is the spherical wave concept combined with ray-tracing techniques and the uniform theory of diffraction (UTD) [118] in order to account for building reflections, diffraction, and transmission
Far-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry
Layer no.
84
Layer av. SAR (mWkg)
Figure 3.14 Layer average SAR (6-mm human body model) for a plane-wave exposure obtained by FDTD simulation and sum of previously stored impulse responses. Frequency: 835 MHz; Einc = 61.4 V/m rms. (Reproduced from [35] with permission from IEEE.)
6m
Antenna
8m (a)
Antenna 6m
2m
30m (b)
6m
Antenna
30m
20m 10m
(c)
Figure 3.15 Environment geometry for the three cases studied. Dashed lines represent planes not considered in the simulations. (a) Case I: subject on the building roof. (b) Case II: subject on the balcony. (c) Case III: subject on the street. (Reproduced from [90] with permission from IEEE.)
3.4 Simulation Techniques
85
Base station antenna
Human body z
Distance d
x
Figure 3.16
Hybridized exposure scenario in [88]. (Available at http://www.ursi.org.)
(multipath) for near- to far-field (intermediate) regions, performed with good accuracy [50]—yet, always with some overestimation of real intermediate-field values. Another possibility for accurate predictions in the near-field is to use the spherical wave triplets model [50] combined with geometrical optics (GO) and UTD [107] to account for the different contributions of sections of dipoles and the effect of antenna reflection and diffraction for each point source, which has been employed successfully in [50], but still limited to avoid near-field scenarios with or without obstacles. Thus, hybridized ray-tracing techniques are useful to speed up the simulations when carefully accounting for their inherent drawbacks, particularly their limitation in the near-field region and their overestimation in the intermediate-field region. Today hybrid tools are commonplace for simultaneously solving both the nearand far-field problem of electromagnetic exposure, as in [88], where the hybrid method employed in [119] with the finite element method (FEM), the boundary element method (BEM), and the uniform theory of diffraction is combined with FDTD by the discrete formulation of the equivalence principle inside the Yee-mesh of the FDTD method, as depicted in Figure 3.16.
References [1] [2]
[3]
[4] [5]
Decision 473/85 of the Finish Council of Ministers on high-frequency equipment and control thereof, Finland, 1985. Telecommunication Technology Council (TTC) for the Ministry of Posts and Telecommunications, “Radio-Radiation Protection Guidelines for Human Exposure to Electromagnetic Fields,” Deliberation No. 89, Japan, 1997 (in Japanese). Environmental Health Directorate. Health Protection Branch. Canada, Safety Code 6. “Limits of human exposure to radiofrequency electromagnetic fields in the frequency range from 3 KHz to GHz,” 99-EHD-237, 1991. Decision 1474/91 of the Finish Ministry of Social Affairs and Health on limiting exposure to nonionising radiation, Finland, 1991. BG-Vorschrift, Elektromagnetische Felder (BGV 13), Berfsgenossenschaftliche Vorschrift für Sicherheit und Gesundheit bei der Arbeit, Fachausschu Elektrotechnik’’ der BGZ, Fachausschuentwurf, Dezember 1998 (in German).
86
Far-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry [6] Österreichisches Normungsinstitut ÖNORM S 1120, “Microwave and radio frequency electromagnetic fields - Permissible limits of exposure for the protection of persons in the frequency range 30 kHz to 300 GHz,” Austria, VORNORM, July 1992. [7] Ordinance of the Ministry of Environment, “EMF in living and natural environment,” Slovenia, 1996 (modified in 2004). [8] Ordinance 61/284 of the Prime Minister, “Factors Harmful for Health in Work Environment,” Poland, 1996 (modified by 124/789 in 1997 and 8/108 in 2000). [9] Telecommunication Technology Council (TTC), “Radio-Radiation Protection Guidelines for Human Exposure to Electromagnetic Fields,” TTC Deliberation No.38, Japan, 1990 (in Japanese). [10] Decreto Ministero dell’Ambiente 10/09/1998 n. 381. “Reglamento recante norme per la determinazione dei tetti di radiofrequenza compatibili con la salute umana,” Gazzeta Ufficiale della Repubblica Italiana, Serie Generale n. 257, Nov. 1998 (in Italian). [11] EMEL 1998. “Guidelines for Limiting Exposure to Time Varying Electric, Magnetic and Electromagnetic Fields in the Frequency Range up to 300 GHz,” Department of Health, Directorate Radiation Control, South Africa, 1998. [12] Ordinance 814.710 sulla protezione dalle radiazioni non ionizzanti (ORNI) (relating to Protection from Non-Ionising Radiation (ONIR)), Switzerland, Dec. 1999. [13] Common Ministerial Decision Act No.1105 of the Ministries of Development, Transport and Communications, Health and Welfare and Environment, Physical Planning and Public Works, “Protection measures for the exposure of the general public to all land based antenna stations,” Greece, Sept. 2000. [14] Ordinance 9/2000 of the Ministry of Transportation and Telecommunications, “Installation process of base stations,” Hungary, May 2000 (withdrawn in 2002). [15] Ordinance 32/2000 of the Ministry of Health, “Reference levels of RF emitted by the radio communication masts,” Hungary, 2000 (withdrawn in 2004). [16] Grand-Duche de Luxembourg, Ministère de l’Environnement and Ministère du Travail et de l’Emploi, “Normes les plus strictes en Europe en matière de radiations en provenance des émetteurs de téléphonie mobile,” Luxemburg, Dec. 2000. [17] Ministerio de la Presidencia, Spain, “Real Decreto 1066/2001, de 28 de septiembre, por el que se aprueba el Reglamento que establece condiciones de protección del dominio público radioeléctrico, restricciones a las emisiones radioeléctricas y medidas de protección sanitaria frente a emisiones radioeléctricas,” Boletín Oficial del Estado (BOE), 29 September, 2001, pp. 36217–36227 (in Spanish). [18] Royal Decree, “Koninklijk besluit van 29 april 2001 houdend de normering van zendmasten voor elektromagnetsiche golven tussen 10 MHz en 10 GHz,” gewijzig door het Koninklijk besluit van 21, Belgium, Dec. 2001 (canceled by the State Council on Dec. 2004). [19] Nationaal Antennebeleid NAB (National Antenna Policy), The Netherlands, 2001. [20] General Advice SSI FS 2002:3, “Allmänna råd om begränsning av allmänhetens exponering för elektromagnetiska fält (Advice on the Limitation of Exposure of the General Public to Electromagnetic Fields),” Sweden, 2002. [21] ARIB STD-T56, “Specific absorption rate (SAR) estimation for cellular phone,” Association of Radio Industries and Business, v2.0, January 2002 (in Japanese). [22] Ordinance 294/2002 on limiting exposure of the general public to non-ionising radiation, Finland, 2002. [23] Decree 2002-775, “Implementation of Article L. 32 of the Posts and Telecommunications Code concerning threshold values for public exposure to electromagnetic fields emitted by telecommunication networks equipment and wireless installations,” France, May 2002. [24] Telekommunikationsgesetz BGBl I Nr. 70/2003, Austria, 2003. [25] Decree 2003-961, “Evaluation of the conformity of terminal telecommunication equipment and wireless equipment, as well as conditions for start-up and use,” France, Oct. 2003.
3.4 Simulation Techniques
87
[26] “Radiocommunications Electromagnetic Raditaion - Human Exposure Standard 2003,” Australian Communications Authority, March 2003. [27] Law 2004-669, “Electronic communications and audio-visual communications service (Health safety into telecommunications legislation),” France, July 2004. [28] Law 2004-809, “Public health policy (Enhancing the information and dialogue),” France, Aug. 2004. [29] Ordinance 63/2004 of the Ministry of Health, Social and Family Affairs, “Limits of EMF exposure between 0 Hz- to 300 GHz,” Hungary, July 2004. [30] Gandhi, O.P., Lazzi, G., and Furse, C.M., “Electromagnetic absorption in the human head and neck for mobile telephones at 835 and 1900 MHz,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Tech., vol. 44, pp. 1884–1897, 1996. [31] Okoniewski, M., and Stuchly, M.A., “A study of the handset antenna and human body interaction,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 44, no. 10, pp. 1855–1864, Oct. 1996. [32] Jensen, M.A., et al., “EM Interaction of Handset Antennas and Human in Personal Communications,” Proceedings of the IEEE, vol. 83, no. 1, pp. 7–17, January 1995. [33] Balzano, Q., et al., “Electromagnetic Energy Exposure of Simulated Users of Portable Cellular Telephones,” IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology, vol. 44, no. 3, pp. 390–403, August 1995. [34] Hombach, V., Meier, K., Burkhardt, M., Kühn, E., and Kuster, N., “The dependence of the EM energy absorption upon human head modeling at 900 MHz,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 44, pp. 1865–1873, Oct. 1996. [35] Lazzi, G., et al., “A mixed FDTD-integral equation approach for on-site safety assessment in complex electromagnetic environments,” IEEE Trans. Antennas and Propagation, vol. 48, no. 12, pp. 1830–1836, 2000. [36] Vander Vorst, A., et al., “Cellular telephones: Hazards or not?” 2000 IEEE International Symposium on Microwave Theory and Techniques, pp. 937–940. [37] Bernardi, P., Cavagnaro, M., Pisa, S., Piuzzi, E., “Power absorption and temperature elevations induced in the human head by a dual-band monopole-helix antenna phone,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 49, no 12, pp. 2539–2546, 2001. [38] Lautru, D., et al., “Calculation of the power deposited in a phantom close to a base station antenna using a hybrid FDTD-MoMTD approach,” 30th European Microwave Conference, Paris, pp. 304–307, 2000. [39] Bahr, A., et al., “Occupational safety in the near field of GSM base stations,” 2000 International Millenium Conference on Antennas & Propagation (AP-2000), Davos, Switzerland, 2000. [40] Catarinucci, L., Palazzari, P., and Tarricone, L., “Human exposure to the near field of radiobase antennas—A full-wave solution using parallel FDTD,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 51, no. 3, pp. 935–940, March 2003. [41] Mason, P.A., Hurt, W.D., Walters, T.J., D’Andrea, J.A., Gajšek, P., Ryan, K.L., Nelson, D.A., Smith, K.I., and Ziriax, J.M., “Effects of frequency, permittivity, and voxel size on predicted specific absorption rate values in biological tissue during electromagnetic-field exposure,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 48, pp. 2050–2058, Nov. 2000. [42] Durney, C.H., Massoudi, H., and Iskander, M.F., “Radiofrequency Radiation Dosimetry Handbook,” 4th Ed., USAFSAM-TR-85-73, Brooks AFB, Texas, 1986. [43] IRPA, “Guidelines on limits of exposure to radiofrequency electromagnetic fields in the frequency range from 100 kHz to 300 GHz,” 1988. [44] National Radiological Protection Board (NRPB), “Electromagnetic fields and the risk of cancer, Report of an Advisory Group on Non-ionising Radiation,” Doc. NRPB, 3, No.1, pp.1–138, 1992. [45] UNEP/WHO/IRPA, “Electromagnetic fields (300 Hz to 300 GHz),” Environmental Health Criteria 137, World Health Organization, Geneva, 1993.
88
Far-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry [46] International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection (ICNIRP), “Health issues related to the use of hand-held radiotelephones and base transmitters,” Health Physics, vol. 70, pp. 587–593, 1996. [47] International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection, “Guidelines for limiting exposure to time-varying electric, magnetic, and electromagnetic fields (up to 300 GHz),” Health Physics, vol. 74, pp. 494–522, 1998. [48] European Council, “Council Recommendation of 12 July 1999 on the limitation of Exposure of the General Public to Electromagnetic Fields (0 Hz – 300 GHz),” Official Journal of the European Communities, L199, pp. 59–70, July 30, 1999. [49] Watanabe, S.I., Taki, H., Nojima, T., and Fujiwara, O., “Characteristics of the SAR distribution in a head exposed to electromagnetic fields radiated by a hand-held portable radio,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 44, pp. 1874–1883, Oct. 1996. [50] Barbiroli, M., Carciofi, C., Degli-Esposti, V., and Falciasecca, G., “Evaluation of exposure levels generated by cellular systems: Methodology and results,” IEEE Trans. on Vehicular Technology, vol. 51, no. 6, pp. 1322–1329, 2002. [51] Simunic, D., “Measurements of RF and far fields,” Proceedings of the WHO International Seminar on Biological Effects, Health and Consequences and Standards for Pulsed Radiofrequency Fields, Nov. 1999. [52] Golombeck, M.A., Dössel, O., Staubert, A., and Tronnier, V.M., “Numerical models of the human body applied to EMC-problems in the surgery room for the future,” Compendium of the 4th European Symposium on Electromagnetic Compatibility, pp. 193–198, Sept. 2000. [53] Stuchly, S.S., Kraszewski, A., Stuchly, M., Hartsgrove, G., and Spiegel, R.J., “RF energy deposition in a heterogeneous model of man: Far-field exposures,” IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, vol. 34, pp. 951–957, Dec. 1987. [54] Gandhi, O.P., Gu, Y., Chen, J.Y., Bassen, H.I., “Specific absorption rate and induced current distributions in an anatomically based human model for plane-wave exposure,” Health Physics, vol. 63, pp. 281–290, Sept. 1992. [55] Martínez-Búrdalo, M., Nonídez, L., Martín, A., and Villar, J., “Using a combination of FDTD with a surface integration method for electromagnetic scattering analysis in large regions,” Microwave and Optical Technology Letters, vol. 22, pp. 74–78, 1999. [56] Martínez-Búrdalo, M., Nonídez, L., Martín, A., and Villar, J., “A combination of time-domain versions of PO and PTD with the FDTD method to evaluate human exposure to an electromagnetic field in an urban environment,” Microwave and Optical Technology Letters, vol. 31, pp. 371–374, 2001. [57] Martínez-Búrdalo, M., Nonídez, L., Martín, A., and Villar, J., “On the calculation of safety distances for human exposure to electromagnetic fields from base-station antennas,” Microwave and Optical Technology Letters, vol. 34, no. 5, pp. 364–367, 2002. [58] Meyer, F.J.C., Davidson, D.B., Jakobus, U., and Stuchly, M., “Human exposure assessment in the near field of GSM base-stations antennas using a hybrid finite element/method of moments techniques,” IEEE Trans. on Biomedical Engineering, vol. 50, no. 2, pp. 224–233, Feb. 2003. [59] Blanch, S., Romeu, J., and Cardama, Á., “Near field in the vicinity of wireless base-station antennas: An exposure compliance approach,” IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation, vol. 50, no. 5, pp. 685–692, May 2002. [60] European Committee for Electrotechnical Standardization (CENELEC), EN50361:2001, “Basic standard for the measurement of specific absorption rate related to human exposure to electromagnetic fields from mobile phones (300 MHz – 3 GHz),” Sept. 2001. [61] European Committee for Electrotechnical Standardization (CENELEC) EN50360:2001, “Product standard to demonstrate the compliance of mobile phones with the basic restrictions related to human exposure to electromagnetic fields (300 MHz – 3 GHz),” Sept. 2001.
3.4 Simulation Techniques
89
[62] Karwowski, A., “Evaluating exposure to radio-frequency emissions from base station antennas,” Proceedings of the IEEE Microwaves, Radar and Wireless Communications, International Conference, pp. 1877–1881, 2002. [63] Faraone, A., Roger Yew-Siow Tay, Joyner, K.H., and Balzano, Q., “Estimation of the average power density in the vicinity of cellular base station collinear array antennas,” IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology, vol. 49, no. 3, pp. 984–996, 2000. [64] Cooper, J., Marx, B., Buhl, J., and Hombach, V., “Determination of safety distance limits for a human near a cellular base station,” Proceedings of the 22nd Annual Meeting of the Bioelectromagnetics Society, pp. 16–17, June 2000. [65] Hassanin, A.I.M., “Biological effect of mobile telephone inside the human brain,” Proceedings of the 2001 IEEE Antennas and Propagation Society International Symposium, Vol. 2, pp. 88–91, 2001. [66] Jakobus, U., Ruoss, H.-O., Geisbusch, L., and Landstorfer, F.M., “Hybridisation of MoM and GMT for the numerical analysis of electromagnetic sources radiating in the vicinity of persons with implanted cardiac pacemakers,” Proceedings of the 2nd IEEE AFRICON Conference, vol. 2, pp. 1041–1044, Oct. 1999. [67] Meier, K., Hombach, V., Kästle, R., Tay, R.Y.S., and Kuster, N., “The dependence of electromagnetic energy absorption upon human head modeling at 1800 MHz,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 45, pp. 2058–2062, Nov. 1997. [68] Lazzi, G., and Gandhi, O.P., “Realistically tilted and truncated anatomically based models of the human head for dosimetry of mobile telephones,” IEEE Transactions on Electromagnetic Compatibility, vol. 39, pp. 55–61, Feb. 1997. [69] Bernardi, P., Cavagnaro, M., Pisa, S., and Piuzzi, E., “Evaluation of human exposure in the vicinity of a base station antenna using the multiple-region / FDTD hybrid method,” IEEE International Symp. on Microwave Theory and Techniques, pp. 1747–1750, 2002. [70] Yee, K.S., “Numerical solution of initial boundary value problems involving Maxwell’s equations in isotropic media,” IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation, vol. 14, pp. 302–307, May 1996. [71] Taflove, A., Advances in Computational Electrodynamics: The Finite Difference Time Domain Method, Norwood, MA: Artech House, 1998. [72] Christ, A., Chavannes, N., Nikoloski, N., Gerber, H.U., Pokovic, K., and Kuster, N., “A numerical and experimental comparison of human head phantoms for compliance testing of mobile telephone equipment,” Bioelectromagnetics, vol. 26, pp. 125–137, 2005. [73] Fayos-Fernández, J., Arranz-faz, C., Martínez-González, A.M., and Sánchez-Hernández, D., “Effect of pierced metallic objects on SAR distributions at 900 MHz,” Bioelectromagnetics, vol. 27, pp. 337–353, 2006. [74] DeFord, J.F., Gandhi, O.P., and Hagmann, M.J., “Moment-method solutions and SAR calculations for inhomogeneous models of man with large number of cells,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 31, pp. 848–851, 1983. [75] Spiegel, R.J., “A review of numerical models for predicting the energy deposition and resultant thermal response of humans exposed to electromagnetic fields,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 32, pp. 730–746, 1984. [76] Stuchly, M.A., Kraszewski, A., and Stuchly, S.S., “Exposure of human models in the nearand far-field – A comparison,” IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, vol. 32, pp. 609–615, 1985. [77] Stuchly, S.S., Kraszewski, A., and Stuchly, M.A., “Energy deposition in a model of man in the near-field,” Bioelectromagnetics, vol. 6, pp. 115–130, 1985. [78] Stuchly, S.S., Stuchly, M.A., Kraszewski, A., and Hartsgrove, G., “Energy deposition in a model of man: Frequency effects,” IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, Vol. 33, pp. 702–711, 1986. [79] Guy, A.W., Chou, C.K., and Neuhaus, B., “Average SAR and SAR distribution in man exposed to 450 MHz radiofrequency radiation,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 32, pp. 752–762, 1984.
90
Far-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry [80] Guy, A.W., Webb, M.D., and Sorensen, C.C., “Determination of Power Absorption in Man Exposed to High Frequency Electromagnetic Fields by Thermographic Measurements On Scale Models,” IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, vol. 23, no. 5, pp. 361–371, 1976,. [81] Nojima, T., Nishiki, S., and Kobayashi, T., “An experimental SAR estimation of human head exposure to UHF near fields using dry-phantom models and a thermograph,” IEICE Transactions on Communications, vol. E77-B, no. 6, pp. 708–713, June 1994. [82] Hagmann, M.J., and Levin, R.L., “Accuracy of block models for evaluation of the deposition of energy by electromagnetic fields,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 34, pp. 653–658, 1986. [83] Stuchly, M.A., Spiegel, R.J., Stuchly, S.S., and Kraszewski, A., “Exposure of man in the near-field of a resonant dipole: Comparison between theory and measurements,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 34, pp. 26–30, 1986. [84] Chuang, H.-R., “Numerical computation of fat layer effects on microwave near-field radiation to the abdomen of a full-scale human body model,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 45, no. 1, pp. 118–125, Jan. 1997. [85] Martínez-Búrdalo, M., Martín, A., Anguiano, M., and Villar, R., “On the safety assessment of human exposure in the proximity of cellular communications base-station antennas at 900, 1800 and 2170 MHz,” Physics in Medicine and Biology, vol. 50, pp. 4125–4137, 2005. [86] Cooper, J., et al., “Determination of safety distance limits for a human near a cellular base station antenna, adopting the IEEE standard or ICNIRP guidelines,” Bioelectromagnetics, vol. 23, pp. 429–443, 2002. [87] Christ, A., Klingenböck, A., Samaras, T., Goiceanu, C., and Kuster, N., “The dependence of electromagnetic far-field absorption on body tissue composition in the frequency range from 300 MHz to 6 GHz,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 54, no. 5, pp. 2188–2195, 2006. [88] Hansen, V., Bitz, A., Streckert, J., and El Ouardi, A., “A numerical approach for efficient calculation of human exposure in front of base station antennas,” URSI General Assembly, New Delhi, October 2005. [89] Joseph, W., and Martens, L., “The influence of the measurement probe on the evaluation of electromagnetic fields,” IEEE Transactions on Electromagnetic Compatibility, vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 339–349. [90] Bernardi, P., Cavagnaro, M., Pisa, S., and Piuzzi, E., “Human exposure to radio base-station antennas in urban environment,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 48, no. 11, pp. 1996–2002, Nov. 2000. [91] Sachse, F.B., et al., “Segmentation and tissue-classification of the Visible Man Datasheet using the computertomographic scans and the thin-section photos,” Proceedings of the 1st Users Conference of the National Library of Medicine’s Visible Human Project, pp. 125–126, 1996. [92] The Visible Human Project, U.S. Library of Medicine, available online at http://www.nlm. nih.gov/research/visible/getting_data.html. [93] Dawson, T.W., and Stuchly, M.A., “High-resolution organ dosimetry for human exposure to low frequency magnetic fields,” IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, vol. 34, no. 3, pp. 708–718, 1998. [94] Tinniswood, A.D., Furse, C.M., and Ghandi, O.P., “Power deposition in the head and neck of an anatomically based human body model for plane wave exposures,” Physical Medical Biology, vol. 43, pp. 2361–2378, 1998. [95] Mazzurana, M., Sandrini, L., Vaccari, A., Malacarne, C., Cristoforetti, L., and Pontalti, R., “A semi-automatic method for developing an anthropomorphic numerical model of dielectric anatomy by MRI,” Physical Medical Biology, vol. 48, no. 19, pp. 3157–3170, 2003. [96] Bernardi, P., Cavagnaro, M., Cristoforetti, L., Mazzurana, M., Pisa, S., and Piuzzi, E., Pontalti, R., and Sandrini, L., “Evaluation of human absorption in the near field of a BTS
3.4 Simulation Techniques
[97]
[98]
[99] [100]
[101]
[102] [103]
[104]
[105] [106]
[107] [108]
[109]
[110]
[111]
[112] [113]
[114]
91
antenna,” Proceedings of the IEEE International Symposium on Microwave Theory and Techniques, pp. 1449–1452, 2004. Kuster, N., Schuderer, J., Christ, A., Futter, P., and Ebert, S., “Guidance for exposure design of human studies addressing health risk evaluations of mobile phones,” Bioelectromagnetics, vol. 25, pp. 524–529, 2004. Chen, W.-T., and Chuang, H.-R., “Numerical computation of the Em coupling between a circular loop antenna and a full-scale human-body model,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 46, no. 10, pp. 1516–1520, 1998. Bizzi, M., and Gianola, P., “Electromagnetic fields radiated by GSM antennas,” Electronics Letters, vol. 35, no. 11, pp. 855–857, 1999. Altman, Z., Begasse, B., Dale, C., Karwowski, A., Wiart, J., Wong, M.F., and Gattoufi, L., “Efficient models for base station antennas for dosimetric analysis,” IEEE Transactions on Electromagnetic Compatibility, vol. 44, no. 4, pp. 588–592, Nov. 2002. Balzano, Q., and Faraone, A., “Peak and Average RF Safety Compliance Levels near Radio Base Station Antennas-Prediction Formulas and Numerical Validation,” Proceedings of the International Symposium on Electromagnetic Compatibility, vol. 2, pp. 780–785, 2001. Olivier, C., and Martens, L., “A more accurate method to define exclusion zones,” Proceedings of the IEEE Radio and Wireless Conference (RAWCON), pp. 107–110, 2000. Adane, Y., Gati, A., Wong, M.F., Dale, C., Wiart, J., and Hanna, V.F., “Optimal modeling of real radio base station antennas for human exposure assessment using spherical-mode decomposition,” IEEE Antennas and Wireless Propagation Letters, vol. 1, pp. 215–218, 2002. Federal Communications Commission, OET Bulletin 65, “Evaluating Compliance with FCC Guidelines for Human Exposure to Radiofrequency Electromagnetic Fields,” Ed. 97-01, 1997. “Radiocommunications (Electromagnetic Radiation — Human Exposure) Standard 1999,” Australian Communications Authority, 1999. “Human Exposure to Radiofrequency Electromagnetic Energy,” Information for licensees or operators of radiocommunications transmitters: Evaluation of compliance with the ACA standard, Australia, September 2000. Kouyoumjian, R.G., and Pathak, P.H., “A uniform GTD for an edge in perfectly conducting surfaces,” Proceedings of the IEEE, vol. 62, pp. 1448–1461, Nov. 1974. Sánchez-Hernández, D., and Martínez-González, A., “Aspectos técnicos susceptibles de mejora sobre el protocolo de medición de estaciones base de telefonía móvil: Los trabajos de normalización de CENELEC y JRC-ISPRA en el seno de la Comisión Europea,” Proceedings of URSI National Symposium, 2002 (in Spanish). van Wyk, M., Bingle, M., and Meyer, F.J.C., “Antenna modeling considerations for achúrate SAR calculations in human phantoms in close proximity to GSM cellular base station antennas,” Bioelectromagnetics, Vol. 26, pp. 502–509, 2005. Chen, J.Y., and Gandhi, O.P., “RF currents induced in an anatomically-based model of a human for plane-wave exposures (20 – 100 MHz),” Health Physics, vol. 57, pp. 89–98, 1989. Karwowski, A., “Numerical modeling calculations for evaluating exposure to radio-frequency emissions from base stations antennas,” Proceedings of the IEEE Microwaves, Radar and Wireless Communications, International Conference, pp. 809–812, 2002. Carli, E., Gianola, P., Lombardi, G., Mania, L., and Vescovo, R., “Antenna models for field level evaluation in proximity of GSM base stations,” EPMCC’99, Paris, March 1999. Barbiroli, M., Carciofi, C., Falciasecca, G., and Frullone, M., “Analysis of field strength levels near base station antennas,” Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Vehicular Technology, vol. 1, pp. 156–160, 1999. Liang, G., and Bertoni, H.L., “A new approach for 3-D ray tracing for propagation prediction in cities,” IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation, vol. 46, pp. 853–863, 1998.
92
Far-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry [115] Sáez de Adana, F., “Propagation Model Based on Ray-Tracing for the Design of Personal Communications,” IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology, vol. 49, no. 6, pp. 2105–2112, 2000. [116] Mangoud, M.A., Abd-Alhemeed, R.A., and Excell, P.S., “Simulation of human interaction with mobile telephones using hybrid techniques over coupled domains,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave, Theory and Techniques, vol. 48, pp. 2014–2021, Nov. 2000. [117] Bitz, A., Alaydrus, M., Streckert, J., and Hansen, V.W., “Base station antennas embedded in complex environments: RF exposure in controlled areas,” Proceedings of the 23rd Annual Meeting of the Bioelectromagnetic Society, pp. 49–50, June 2001. [118] Corazza, G.E., Degli-Esposti, V., Frullone, M., and Riva, G., “A characterization of indoor space and frequency diversity by ray-tracing modeling,” IEEE Journal on Selected Areas of Communications, vol. 14, pp. 411–419, 1996. [119] Alaydrus, M., and Hansen, V., “The hybrid(2)-method: Combination of the FE/BE hybrid method with the UTD,” IEEE Antennas and Propagation Int. Symp., Orlando, FL, pp. 1704–1707, 1999.
CHAPTER 4
Near-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry Antonio M. Martínez-González
4.1
Phantom and Source Modeling 4.1.1
Phantom Developments
The RF energy deposition in biological tissue has been studied with a large variety of human and animal models. Homogeneous and heterogeneous models of man were reviewed in 1984 [1], and complemented and improved in 1987 [2] with a CT scan of an anatomically correct model developed from a skeleton with all major bones. Partial anatomically correct models based on the skull were also available in the 1980s [3], depicted in Figure 4.1, and have also been employed until recently, such as the basic layered anatomical shaped model (BLAS) [4], where four different tissues have been incorporated: muscle, brain, cartilage, and humor vitreous. Other examples are the 5-tissue model in [5] extracted from an anatomy atlas with 6.56-mm spatial resolution, the 5-tissue models M4, E1, E2, and E3 in [6], or the 7-tissue head and hand model in [7], also depicted in Figure 4.2. Despite the early availability of partially anatomical models, in the first studies a simple sphere of homogeneous tissue and 105.5-mm radius or a semi-infinite cylinder were considered to represent a simplified average adult head [9, 10] or body [4, 11, 12] model, respectively, and even with an appropriate tissue selection, also considered to provide more conservative results than more detailed models [6, 10, 13–15]. Models tabulated to a 6% at 900 MHz and a 15% at 1,800 MHz can also be found in [16]. Recent studies still use this simple model, but mainly reduced to algorithm validation or comparison purposes since SAR values are not directly linked to head size [17], as in [8] with its entire plain interaction (EPI) model, [18], or [19]. Today, the choice of the equivalent tissue for the homogeneous sphere is still the subject of research [21, 23], since early studies use muscle or 2/3-muscle tissue [11] whereas CENELEC [20] recommends a head simulating liquid (HSL) similar to the brain for compliance testing. This selection is justified by the fact that, for a source position at or above the ear, brain constitutes the most relevant tissue and provides the highest absorption values [22]. Recent studies have demonstrated that the conservative character of the simple sphere can only be valid with appropriate tissue selection if just the head is considered [24] and not for all possible situations
93
94
Near-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry
(a)
(b)
Figure 4.1 Head models used in the experiments in [3] with eye-equivalent tissue placed in eye sockets, and muscle-equivalent tissue placed at appropriate locations on skull surface. Radio with 1/2-wave antenna in tilted position (a), and radio with 1/4-wave antenna in vertical position (b). (Reproduced from [3] with permission from John Wiley & Sons.)
z
y
x
Figure 4.2 The Basic Anatomical Layered Shaped model (BLAS) in [8], the 5-tissue head models (E1, E2, and E3) in [6], and the 7-tissue head and hand model (ATLAS) in [7].
and models [25]. Therefore, more detailed and realistic models have been developed. Other canonical shapes employed include the rectangular box, which is typically used to simulate the human torso [26].
4.1 Phantom and Source Modeling
95
Simple, full-scale human body models have also been employed [27, 29], but their use has been limited. Much more detailed 3D human body models developed from nuclear magnetic resonance imaging were soon made available. The Herschey Medical Center (USA) developed a 132 × 84 × 390 grid of 5-mm cells including 23 different biological tissues, named the REMCOM model since it was adopted by this software brand; and the U.K. National Radiological Protection Board (NRPB) phantom, NORMAN, was derived from a series of continuous partial body (head, thorax, abdomen, thighs, knees, and feet) MRI scans of a single subject. NORMAN (NORmalized MAN) was made by Noah Clinch of Fairfield Imaging (USA) in 1995, and was first interpreted into 38 tissue types and structured in a 3D array of cells and ~2-mm voxels [28] and normalized to be 1.76m tall and 73 kg in weight. These were the values for the reference man of ICRP 66 [30], with tissues extracted from [31] and 4-Cole-Cole dispersion models. NORMAN was later fine-tuned to include organs, which were not discovered in the primary segmentation, such as the prostate or the male breast, and to differentiate diverse organs such as the stomach from its contents: bladder from urine, gall bladder from bile, esophagus from air, and lungs from air. Some secondary segmentation of NORMAN was due to the results obtained with its predecessor, based upon a survey of 20 colleagues [32]. For instance, NORMAN ankles and lower legs, which were rather thick, were tapered and skin and subcutaneous fat were separated from an original solo tissue. NORMAN was also rescaled to reproduce the heights and masses of reference 10, 5, and 1-year old children [33]. The sagittal slices of NORMAN are depicted in Figure 4.3, while Figures 4.4 and 4.5 reproduce the isolated and grounded conditions, respectively, demonstrating that while ~35-MHz resonance frequencies are found for grounded conditions, this is shifted up to ~65 MHz when the model is isolated. Some other MRI-based models were also available in 1995, such as the original Gent head model [34], which had a resolution of 3.9 × 3.9 × 4.7 mm3 (5 mm in the 3 vertical direction), and was later enhanced to 1.1 × 1.1 × 1.4 mm (1.7 mm in the vertical direction) and 26 tissues at Yale University (named the Yale head model [14]), and to a 3-mm head model by Salt Lake City University [36] employing 15 tissues. The University of Utah also developed an anatomical model, originally named 3 Model A and employing a resolution of 1.974 × 1.974 × 3 mm [36]. Model A was later enhanced (Model B) to a resolution of 0.9375 mm for each of the cubical 3 voxels (0.987 × 0.987 × 1 mm ) of 15 different tissue types [37] and a pinna thickness of 14 mm [46]. The Brooks digital anatomical man model employed 3-mm resolution slices [18]. The European female model (FEM40Y-CE) was created from a 40-year-old female volunteer with the ear slightly compressed (4 mm thick). In the ear region, the slices have a thickness of 1 mm, while 3 mm are used elsewhere. A 25-year-old version of the European female model (FEM25Y-CE) was developed by Ericsson Research, but with a slightly compressed pinna thickness of 10 mm and 2-mm slices all throughout the model. Some anatomically correct human body models have also been provided with MRI scans in the Visible Human Project [38, 39], including the adult male head phantom (VHAD) provided by Motorola Corporate EME Research Laboratory, which includes 40 different tissue types, as well as some scaled-down versions, all with 1 × 1 × 1 mm3 resolution. More realistic 3- and 7-year-old children head models obtained from real scanned images of children have also been reported [40–42].
96
Near-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry
Figure 4.3 Sagittal slices of NORMAN. (Reproduced from [33] with permission from Institute of Physics Publishing.)
0.10
SAR, mW kg
−1
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0.00 10
100
1000
Frequency, MHz
Figure 4.4 Whole-body averaged SAR for adult NORMAN under isolated conditions. (Reproduced from [35] with permission from Institute of Physics Publishing.)
4.1 Phantom and Source Modeling
97
0.10
SAR, mW kg
−1
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0.00 10
100 Frequency, MHz
1000
Figure 4.5 Whole-body averaged SAR for adult NORMAN under grounded conditions. (Reproduced from [35] with permission from Institute of Physics Publishing.)
European children head models [40] consisted of 15 different tissues and a spatial resolution of 1 mm with pinna thickness of approximately 4 mm. The Japanese 7and 3-year-old children head models [42], illustrated in Figure 4.6, were scaled down from an adult head model (provided by the Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering of the Nagoya Institute of Technology in Japan). The Japanese adult head model was derived from a 23-year-old Japanese adult male head and segmented into 17 different tissues of a 2-mm spatial resolution model. The Japanese scaled-down children versions, named “childlike” by some authors, employed different scaling factors for different parts of the head, which provided a more realistic approximation of the child’s head than the uniform scaling used in the visible human head models [42], but are also limited by their inherent nonuniform growth of organs [43]. The reason for providing children models was that there was some contradictory findings regarding the possibility of children absorbing more RF energy than Head breadth Bizygomatic breadth Vertex-pupil height
Adult head Bigonial breadth
Scaled head with 7-year-old database
Head length
Pupil-stomion height Stomion-gnathion height
Scaled head with 3-year-old database
Figure 4.6 Japanese anatomical head models in [42]. (Reproduced from [42] with permission from IEEE.)
98
Near-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry
adults [19, 36, 40–42, 44, 46], which lead to a COST281 short-term mission and a joint WHO/EMF-NET/COST281/ICNIRP workshop in 2004. It was concluded in the 2004 workshop—a summary of which has been published as a special issue of Bioelectromagnetics—that there is no direct evidence that children are more vulnerable to EMF. The workshop also concluded that there is little research addressing the issue, which was also stated in [47], and identified this as a key gap in various research agendas worldwide. Collaboration between the National University of Singapore and Johns Hopkins University also produced an anatomical model of the Sprague-Dawley man previously described in [48, 49] but using the VHP images with larger voxel sizes of 3 and 5 mm3 and 39 different tissue types. In 2001 a standardized anthropomorphic head phantom, the specific anthropomorphic mannequin (SAM), was developed to be included in the two different recommended measurement techniques for determining peak spatial-average SAR from wireless communications devices, EN 50361 and IEEE 1528 and 1529. Prior to SAM, the generic twin phantom (GTP) [16] was formerly used for compliance testing [17]. The GTP model was developed from statistics taken from 52 male and female adult volunteers, and its ear is represented by a lossless spacer with a radius of 15 mm and a thickness of 2 mm positioned at the location of the auditory canal, leading to an overall shell thickness of 4.7 mm in the ear region. Except for the ear protrusions, SAM was derived from a subset of the 90th percentile dimensions from a survey of U.S. Army male personnel [44]. The model, which was intended to be used in measurements with a tissue simulating liquid, was considered conservative at the time, yet today several studies are questioning its validity, particularly since new wireless applications with diverse positioning, sometimes away from the head, are becoming commonplace [50]. Some studies found that SAM underestimated SAR by a factor or two or more [46], while others found that SAM overestimated SAR [51, 52]. In 2005 it was demonstrated that results for compliance testing using SAM represented a more conservative approach than those performed with the GTP [17]. A recent study [41] has demonstrated, however, that there were other factors that strongly influenced most previous studies. These include the treatment of the pinna, phone positioning, and the SAR averaging algorithm, among others. Despite these discrepancies, and comparing SAM to other 14 different anatomical models, SAM cannot always be considered a conservative estimate in accordance with ICNIRP guidelines which require inclusion of the pinna in the SAR evaluation or should the evaluation be conducted for contiguous tissue and not for a 10g cube [41]. Similar discrepancies between cube or contiguous (any) 10g tissue averaging methods were found in [53]. SAR values using any 10g averaging volume nearly doubled those using the 10g cube, and even within the same cube the allowed percentage of air inclusion within the averaging tissue strongly affects SAR values [55]. This suggests a maximum permissible air inclusion of 5% to 20% [54], but also states that the cubic-volume method may not define well the mass-averaged SAR at tissue points around a complex shape containing air. This may happen in the exterior layers of various internal human cavities (maxillary or ethmoidal sinus) or small volume regions such as fingers [56]. Different results were also found in [41] depending upon the normalization performed, either to the feed point current or to the power. Some advanced averaging methods have also been proposed [57].
4.1 Phantom and Source Modeling
99
Some French anatomical models of adults (FTRD, COMOBIO) are also available [43], derived from the VHP, and illustrated in Figure 4.7. The French ADONIS program of the RNRT research network is working towards the development of age-dependent children anatomical head models with eight tissues and a millimetric resolution. Other described anatomical models are also depicted in Figure 4.8. In many of these models, pinna is a source of controversy, and this was recently the subject of a detailed intercomparison study between 14 different realistic head phantoms [41] since the definitions in diverse standards diverge. The pinna is defined as the largely cartilaginous projecting portion of the outer ear consisting of the helix, lobule, and antihelix. According to IEC [59, 60], for instance, the exciting source has to be located directly above the ear reference point (ERP), that is, at a lateral distance of 15 mm from Tragion (entrance to the ear canal, EEC). Although only [61] provides a relaxation of limits for the pinna, it also states that this relaxation has to be considered without violating the general provisions. This definition, however, may sustain different physical interpretations. It has been published that if the limited SAR values for the head tissue are met, the values for the pinna treated as
Figure 4.7 Anatomical FTRD adult, childlike, and children head models. (Reproduced from [43] with permission from John Wiley and Sons.)
Figure 4.8 Anatomical head models developed from MRI scanning. (Reproduced from [58] with permission from John Wiley and Sons.)
100
Near-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry
an extremity are intrinsically met as well [17, 58]. Yet, it has also been published that a 6-mm thick smooth plastic pinna, such as the one available in SAM, results in a calculated peak 10g averaged SAR that may be up to two or more times smaller than realistic anatomical models for SAR compliance [50]. To minimize pinna discrepancies when performing the simulations, some models employ an ear completely attached to the head—what has been called “compressed” or “collapsed” pinna. This happens, for example, in the BLAS model in [62] since it was also found that a very thin spacer or no ear would overestimate the exposure in the area above the ear [22] and that when using various ear-connection structures and a thin lossless dielectric spacer to emulate the actual human anatomical condition, the effect on 1g averaged peak SAR was negligible [64]. In this way, the losses in the outer ear are compensated in the measurements by the replacement of the low-loss structure of the inner ear, including bony structure and air cavities, through the lossy tissue simulating material [22]. It has to be mentioned, however, that spatial-peak SAR values averaged over a cube of 10g are much less sensitive to the modeling of the ear and no underestimation on these values is produced due to ear modeling as a spacer in [22]. The spacer is the technique used in the measurement setup for SAM in DASY4. The underestimation of peak SAR averaged over 1g when using a spacer to simulate the ear could be as high as 1 dB [22]. Pinna treatment is the subject of current research and a source of discrepancy between guidelines. Today, a 2-mm resolution is considered sufficient for compliance testing, but sub-millimeter resolution models are available. Cell dimensions as small as 0.5 mm [65], 0.4 mm [63], or 0.25 mm [66] have been published, although these are limited to specific organs. The availability of these models, however, has allowed a very detailed simulation of the eye’s vascularization and its capacity to cope with excess heat. The inherent capabilities of the eye to transfer excess heat away have been found to be higher that initially supposed [66]. Figure 4.9 shows analytical and numerically computed temperature in a 10 cm diameter cylinder exposed to a plane wave of power density 10 mW/cm2. 4.1.2
Source Modeling
The high frequency employed for commercial digital wireless communications systems may require a rather large number of cells for whole-body modeling, creating large computational problems; yet accurate modeling of the source is essential for proper electromagnetic coupling characterization and hence accurate exposure assessment and SAR calculation. Since third generation (3G) systems employ even higher frequencies than 2G systems, this modeling problem is emphasized. Adaptive meshing is sought as the appropriate technique to comply with conflicting requirements of accurate source modeling at an as-low-as-possible computational cost with uniform meshing within tissues for adequate SAR averaging procedures. This has called up again the need for alternatives to FDTD such as the method of moments (MoM) combined with the coupled integral equations (CIE) [27] or coupled to the FEM method [67]. The FEM alternative, however, has a trade-off between its typical tetrahedral representation versus the cubical form of FDTD, which provides less computational requirements for low-frequency problems, and its need to refine the model as frequency increases, which can lead to a factor of eight increase in memory
4.1 Phantom and Source Modeling
101
Figure 4.9 Temperature distribution in the test cylinder at 2-MHz irradiation. Comparison of analytically and numerically computed temperature.
and solution time, while FDTD may remain the same [67]. This has left FEM basically for small-size near-field problems or for hybridization techniques. Special care has to be taken into account when increasing the mesh size around the antenna so that the thin-wire model employed does not appear as an infinitely thick wire. This could stimulate important deviations in resonance frequency and in local SAR values since when employing the thin-wire model these are 18% to 20% higher than those predicted using the thick-wire model [68]. A ∼λ/2 dipole antenna is the most commonly employed source for SAR evaluation [2] in the near-field at diverse positions, orientations, and distances from the human model and with different input powers. For handset exposure, SAR is usually normalized to 1W of antenna input power [2], and since base station antennas can handle different output powers, normalizing to 1W is also useful for these situations [24]. The choice of the ∼λ/2 dipole antenna is due to the necessity to simplify the source structure, since mobile phone design is continuously changing and nowadays it is possible to find a large variety of shapes and sizes for handsets. In fact, a typical exposure for mobile phones does not exist [16]. Other reasons for using the ∼λ/2 dipole antenna is to select a source position with respect to the head that is repeatable and enables interexperimental comparison [69], and to minimize discrepancies of measured values for different phantoms sizes [42] and for differences between homogeneous and heterogeneous head models due to the antenna [70]. Moreover, substituting commercial handset antennas with the dipole allows for a detailed knowledge of antenna impedance and reflected power, which represents a crucial parameter for proper SAR distribution validation and can be directly compared to measurements with the same antenna using the available near-field scanners, which will be described further on.
102
Near-Field Numerical Electromagnetic Dosimetry
The distance between the antenna and the human head model is also another important parameter. When the antenna is mounted on a metal box, this can significantly change depending upon the antenna selection (helix, monopole, integrated, etc.) and its relative position. In fact, axial ratios have been reported to increase with the presence of the human head when circularly polarized antennas such as circular or square helices are used [5]. Additionally, the metal box model is not an accurate model for modern mobile phones, with RF currents differing considerably from real mobile phones, and a simple generic mobile phone model was agreed upon with members of the Mobile Manufacturers Forum (MMF). The generic mobile phone, reproduced in Figure 4.10 [41] is composed of a solid plastic box of 102 × 42 × 21 mm3 with the PCB modeled as a 1-mm thick plate representing a perfect electrical conductor (PEC) embedded in the body of the generic mobile phone. The agreement upon a generic mobile phone is of extreme importance since when no standard dipole source is chosen and the simulation has to be evaluated with the antenna mounted on the phone box, it has been demonstrated that the box size and other parameters have a significant effect on SAR values [37]. It is known that special care has to be taken to accurately evaluate the antenna output power since its settings can constitute a large uncertainty component [68]. Some studies use a sinusoidal current of 250 mA peak amplitude as a feeding signal