HOMICIDE A Psychiatric Perspective Second Edition
This page intentionally left blank
HOMICIDE A Psychiatric Perspec...
58 downloads
7479 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
HOMICIDE A Psychiatric Perspective Second Edition
This page intentionally left blank
HOMICIDE A Psychiatric Perspective Second Edition
Carl P. Malmquist, M.D., M.S. Professor of Social Psychiatry, Department of Sociology University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota
Washington, DC London, England
Note: The authors have worked to ensure that all information in this book is accurate at the time of publication and consistent with general psychiatric and medical standards, and that information concerning drug dosages, schedules, and routes of administration is accurate at the time of publication and consistent with standards set by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration and the general medical community. As medical research and practice continue to advance, however, therapeutic standards may change. Moreover, specific situations may require a specific therapeutic response not included in this book. For these reasons and because human and mechanical errors sometimes occur, we recommend that readers follow the advice of physicians directly involved in their care or the care of a member of their family. Books published by American Psychiatric Publishing, Inc., represent the views and opinions of the individual authors and do not necessarily represent the policies and opinions of APPI or the American Psychiatric Association. Copyright © 2006 American Psychiatric Publishing, Inc. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Manufactured in the United States of America on acid-free paper 10 09 08 07 06 5 4 3 2 1 Second Edition Typeset in Adobe’s Futura and Palatino. American Psychiatric Publishing, Inc. 1000 Wilson Boulevard Arlington, VA 22209–3901 www.appi.org Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Homicide : a psychiatric perspective / edited by Carl P. Malmquist.— 2nd ed. p. ; cm. Rev. ed. of: Homicide / Carl P. Malmquist. 1st ed. c1996. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 1-58562-204-4 (pbk. : alk. paper) 1. Homicide—Psychological aspects. 2. Murderers—Mental health. [DNLM: 1. Homicide—psychology. 2. Mental Disorders— psychology. WM 140 H767 2006] I. Malmquist, Carl P. II. Malmquist, Carl P. Homicide. RC569.5.H65M35 2006 616.85'844—dc22 2005032512 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A CIP record is available from the British Library.
CONTENTS Foreword . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . vii Preface to the Second Edition. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ix Preface to the First Edition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xv Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .xvii
1
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide . . . . . . . . . 1
2
Biological Factors in Homicide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 55
3 4 5 6 7
Schizophrenia, Delusional Disorders, and the Prediction Problem Regarding Homicide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 91 Borderline Personality Disorder and Homicide: The Quest for Vindication . . . . 121 Dependent Personality Disorder and Homicide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 157 Narcissism and Homicide. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 177 Masochism and Homicide: The Ultimate Enslavement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 199
8
The Depressed or Bipolar Person and Homicide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 239
9
Juveniles and Homicide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 283
10
Sexual Homicide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 331
11 12
Legal Versus Clinical Views on Homicide: Diagnosis and Voluntariness. . . 363 Homicide in the Twenty-First Century: Where Knowledge Is Needed . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 393 Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 419
FOREWORD The heart has its reasons which reason does not understand.
—Blaise Pascal Newspapers and television hawk a steady stream of homicides. Local television news brings neighborhood homicides into viewers’ homes. Movies, books, plays, and documentaries are replete with homicide depictions. The average American by age 18 years will have viewed 250,000 acts of violence, including 40,000 murders on television. The public has an unquenchable thirst for murder mysteries, real or fictional. Murders sell papers and advertised products. Homicide is a multimillion-dollar media industry. But why is there such an enormous interest in an unfortunately common tragedy? As a forensic psychiatrist, I am convinced that the public’s interest in homicide derives from a deep, dark sense that the capacity for murder is quintessentially human. Blood has stained the fabric of human history. Wars, genocides, inquisitions, and pogroms are well known, despite their deniers. Since Adam and Eve’s fall from grace, the history of the world has been filled with violence. Today is no different. It is evident that many people are both fascinated and appalled by humanity’s dark side. Serial killers especially invoke these feelings by their spectacularly horrendous crimes. People protest and reject the notion that the difference between individuals who are labeled as “bad” or praised as “good” is not one of kind but one of degree. Theodore Reich, a pioneering psychoanalyst, observed, “If wishes were horses, they would pull the hearses of our dearest friends and nearest relatives. All men are murderers at heart.” This sentiment, of course, is not news. The biblical prophet Jeremiah lamented, “The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked; who can know it?” But study it we can. There is no reason for despair. In this book, Dr. Carl Malmquist, a preeminent psychiatrist and forensic psychiatrist, examines homicide through the lens of his experience, his knowledge, and the latest research. The chapters on epidemiology and biological substrata of homicide are disturbingly informative. The role of mental illness
vii
viii
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
in homicide always seems to raise the question of whether the murderer was “mad” or “bad” in insanity defense cases. Here, forensic psychiatry and the law intersect. The application of psychiatry to the law, however, is often an imperfect fit. Chapter 9 (“Juveniles and Homicide”) and Chapter 10 (“Sexual Homicide”) are revelatory. These topics receive much publicity in the media, stirring up heated emotion but shedding little light. Why does an adult child molester sexually abuse a child and then bury her alive with her teddy bear? Why Columbine? Killers, their victims, and lethal circumstances are all highly individualized and multifaceted. Dr. Malmquist presents a balanced, detailed, in-depth psychological analysis of cases that richly inform the reader. We are quickly disabused of any stock answers regarding homicide. This one-of-a kind book will educate and intrigue both laypersons and professionals who want to learn more about homicide—a fit and proper quest for knowledge, not titillation. The final chapter, “Homicide in the Twenty-First Century,” acknowledges that we must know more about homicide. Are there genetic factors operating in murderers? If so, which genes, and how do they first become manifest? The answer would allow for early identification and intervention. Unfortunately, homicides will continue in this century and for centuries to come. It is our inescapable destiny. Dr. Malmquist has written a wonderfully comprehensive and insightful book on homicide that sheds much-needed light on the darker side of humanity. It will undoubtedly help save lives among the living—and those yet to come. Robert I. Simon, M.D. Clinical Professor of Psychiatry Director, Program in Psychiatry and Law Georgetown University School of Medicine, Washington, D.C. Chairman, Department of Psychiatry Suburban Hospital, Bethesda, Maryland
PREFACE TO THE SECOND EDITION
OVER THE COURSE of ten years since the first edition of this book was published, the topic of homicidal behavior remains a major problem in American society. Debate continues about its causes and cures both on a societal level and within the individual. These questions of causes and cures are part of what initially enticed me as a psychiatrist to pursue the study of individuals who carry out homicidal behavior. From these initial questions, the study of homicide has since progressed in an effort to place these individuals “under the microscope” utilizing whatever psychiatric understanding is possessed. The goal is not to bypass the knowledge existing in other fields, such as the social sciences and law, but to add to it. During the time elapsed since the first edition, psychiatrists have become more involved with the problem of homicide. Some of this involvement includes being called on to carry out assessments of homicidal individuals in legal settings and when a courtroom trial looms. The request may also be to provide further understanding of why such behavior occurs beyond the generally available demographic information. Involvement in homicide cases in the forensic area has expanded with legal issues arising at many points: from the accused perpetrator’s point of arrest, while the accused perpetrator awaits trial, during resolution of competency issues regarding proceeding to trial and other decisions that may arise (such as the perpetrator pleading insanity, refusing medications, or arguing his or her own case without a lawyer), and at the level of sentencing. The last item also puts psychiatrists into a testimonial role regarding execution possibilities in those states with capital punishment. At each of these levels, careful assessment of the types of personalities and their functioning is necessary. All too often, I have found that the “homicidal cases” have been viewed as homogeneous entities within the legal system. The legal fo-
ix
x
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
cus then became a matter of classifying the cases into a murder or manslaughter category of a certain degree. An alternative I pursued was to elaborate on the diverse types of personalities and disorders that are possible with a person who commits a homicide, utilizing a psychopathological perspective. Although the large amount of criminological and legal literature on homicide often provided insights from demographic factors and the legal questions raised, as a psychiatrist I felt that something was still lacking from the data to form a fuller picture. What I also realized was the need to address my own disturbing countertransference feelings that were elicited by those who had committed some grisly homicidal acts, such as those involving torture or mutilation. This countertransference became part of my motivation to understand the perpetrators. The overall number and rate of homicides in the United States annually has decreased, and there is concern about whether these numbers and rates will rise again. In the meantime, theories on why the overall numbers of homicides have decreased produce competing explanations, which are discussed in Chapter 1 (“Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide”). Certain topics in homicide have come to the fore over the past ten years. Specificity about different types of homicide is where increased attention will be focused in the future. The following are all topics that I realized needed discussion in an updated volume: • I found myself groping for more knowledge and possible explanations for why one particular type of homicide occurred in contrast to another type. The problem of serial homicides is one such area, and many questions abound. For example, why would a particular individual engage in an assault that leads to a homicide whereas another would engage in a vastly different type of behavior, such as a sexual homicide (Chapter 10, “Sexual Homicide”)? Knowledge has increased about biological and genetic factors operating in serious acts of violence and will continue to do so (Chapter 2, “Biological Factors in Homicide”). Both serial killings and sexual homicides have received increased attention and reveal gaps in our knowledge. There is the lurking question of whether rates of these killings have increased or whether we are just getting better at detecting these homicides. • Postpartum homicides of infants elicit intense passions about the legal blameworthiness of the parent (usually the mother), especially when much publicity surrounds a case (Chapter 8, “The Depressed or Bipolar Person and Homicide”). This is another area being explored in greater depth. The legal issues are only part of the scenario
Preface to the Second Edition
xi
because questions continue to arise about why such acts occur and whether they could have been prevented. • Homicides by those working in the health care fields have stirred an interest that has been neglected until a short time ago (Chapter 7,”Masochism and Homicide”). These homicides are now a matter of increased public concern, and again the question is whether they are increasing or just being detected more accurately. • Although the number and rate of homicides in the United States annually has decreased, concern has increased about the number of youths and juveniles who perpetrate a homicide (Chapter 12, “Homicide in the Twenty-First Century”). These homicides have occurred in contexts varying from gangs, random shootings, and within family settings and have raised questions about peers who have been informed beforehand about such possibilities (Chapter 9, “Juveniles and Homicide”). More recently, a complicating factor has arisen about whether selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) increase the risk of suicide and/or homicidal violence for children and adolescents, and this question is under continuing investigation (Chapter 8, “The Depressed or Bipolar Person and Homicide”). Why young individuals continue to carry out homicidal acts raises broad questions not only about these individuals’ personalities, but the structure of families and our society at this time. One of the personal issues in writing a volume on homicide is deciding which cases to use for illustration and which to exclude. The temptation is to use cases that have gained wide publicity because we have all heard about them to some degree. The problem with using these cases are the limits on the degree and depth of knowledge available, especially from a clinical vantage point. The deciding principle used for this book was to use only case material where there was a legal conviction of guilt, a confession, or adequate clinical material to allow going beyond media-level reportage. Thus, an intriguing case, such as that of O.J. Simpson, is not discussed—not only because of a not guilty–verdict, but also because of an absence of clinical material we would need to elaborate on a man who was charged with killing his former wife, Nicole, and her friend, Ronald Goldman. To use popular cases from the media not only involves speculation, but also raises legal and ethical questions. Such concerns would hold similarly for other high publicity cases, such as that of Robert Blake (“Baretta”) who was found not guilty of murdering his wife. Another provocative, high-publicity case has been that of JonBenet Ramsey, a young girl murdered in 1996. The parents have been suspects, but no one has yet been charged with the
xii
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
crime. In the meantime, the parents wrote a book about the investigation, which they believe was bungled. These types of cases continue to be discussed but do not lend themselves to inclusion in a book dealing with the psychiatric aspects of homicide for the reasons noted. In contrast to the above types of high-publicity cases, postpartum cases, such as that of Andrea Yates, have presented adequate clinical material in the context of an insanity defense trial and commentary. The focus throughout this book continues to be the epidemiological and diverse clinical aspects of homicide where data is available and can be discussed from these perspectives. I have also been aware of the great expansion of the work of other mental health professionals, besides psychiatrists, who have become involved with homicide cases. The pure numbers of those in these fields have expanded faster than the numbers of psychiatrists, let alone forensic psychiatrists. The economic scene has changed in the health care field, in which increasing numbers of psychiatrists, psychologists, and social workers have seen work in the forensic area as an opportunity to try to maintain a private practice within a health maintenance organization world. This effort often has involved them in assessment and forensic work with homicidal individuals with whom they have had minimal experience or training, and I realized that many of them were relying on my book when confronting such cases. It has been personally gratifying to hear from those working in these different professions about the helpfulness of the book. Many have told me that such material either was not covered during their training or was covered only quite superficially. The result was that when readers came to the point of needing to assess firsthand a homicide case, prepare a report with an explanation, and then prepare to testify about someone who had perpetrated a homicide, using my book as a reference was most helpful. In a different vein, it has also been rewarding to be aware of how helpful the book has also been to those in the legal profession. Practicing attorneys in the private and public spheres, as well as judges, have mentioned its helpfulness in supplementing the legal analysis of a particular case and the issues raised. Similarly, the book has found a place in various law school courses or continuing educational seminars for attorneys, as well as those in the correctional field, who often find themselves working over many years with people who have committed a homicide. In courtroom proceedings, attorneys and judges have raised examination questions directly from the book. The hope is that this new edition will continue to be helpful not only to forensic psychiatrists, but to the general psychiatrists whose work
Preface to the Second Edition
xiii
becomes involved with people who commit, or raise a threat, of homicidal-level violence. This hope extends to other mental health professionals and those working in the legal setting. My interest in homicide and its perpetrators has come a long way since an esteemed professor and supervisor in my psychiatric residency days sincerely told me that working in the area of psychiatry and law was something I should postpone until retirement, because that is what retired psychiatrists often did. Perhaps that reality was once true, but it has certainly long passed.
This page intentionally left blank
PREFACE TO THE FIRST EDITION
MANY YEARS AGO, on first becoming involved in forensic psychiatric work and training, I became aware of the paucity of psychiatric materials dealing with the subject of homicide. To be sure, there were several insightful articles dealing with a particular kind or case of homicide, and a greater abundance of them dealing with the subject of insanity, but they did not offer an overall psychiatric perspective on homicidal behavior. Other disciplines, such as sociology and law, had an enormous bibliography of the subject with their own orientations. Bookstores also seemed perpetually filled with volumes dealing with popular crimes or murder mysteries. Yet these never seemed as intriguing as the actual cases I had personally examined on consultation. My approach was to determine whether any psychiatric problems existed and secondarily to become involved in reasoning about the complex legal issues presented. Several things pushed this situation toward a book. During a conversation with my old friend, Jay Katz, M.D., of the Yale Law School faculty, it came out that I had personally evaluated over 500 individuals who had committed a homicide. He urged that I share such experiences, and not merely keep them for my own curriculum vitae or my classes. The next step was a conversation with my colleague, David Ward, Ph.D., a criminologist and chair of the sociology department at the University of Minnesota. We decided to create and teach a course entitled “Killing.” It has been a popular course, and at first it seemed a logical step simply to create an anthology of articles on homicide. However, an anthology lacked a broader coverage of the topic that was based on clinical knowledge that one person could synthesize. It meant raising the types of questions that clinical and research psychiatrists would ask. This necessarily led to questions about the epidemiology of
xv
xvi
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
homicide, different diagnoses, descriptive diagnoses from the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, and how to integrate certain psychodynamic formulations for understanding and explanation. All of the above corresponded to the period of increasing concern about serious violence in the United States. Different people from backgrounds, not only in psychiatry but in psychology, sociology, and law as well, wondered if there was a psychiatric textbook available that could give them some overall insights on how psychiatrists thought about the problem of homicide. I began to realize that there was indeed an audience for such a work. Only a few colleagues indicated that this was a subject outside the province of psychiatry proper. In my thinking, homicide does not seem any more outside the province of psychiatry than suicide, for which psychiatry has never hesitated in accepting the possibility of psychiatric contributions. The subject of murder, in fact and fiction, is not likely to go away. In fact, the boundaries between real murder and novelized murder have become increasingly blurred in the media, such as the efforts to have some executions televised or videotaped for replay. My hope is that this book will shorten the search for other clinicians who have homicide cases, as well as attorneys, and that it will lead to an increase in articles and books in the field of homicidology. In terms of ideas and fruitful interchanges, it would be impossible to list all the people from whom I have benefited through discussions over the years. Besides Jay Katz and David Ward there have been Paul Meehl, Alan Stone, and Yale Kamisar at the University of Michigan Law School, who introduced me to the intricacies of criminal law, and diverse philosophers have all been stimulating. I also express my appreciation to Kate Stuckert for her patience and assistance in the typing of this manuscript in its several forms.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS .. .there ain’t nothing more to write about, and I am rotten glad of it, because if I’d a knowed what a trouble it was to make a book I wouldn’t a tackled it, and ain’t a-going to no more.
—Mark Twain, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn The group of people who initially captivated my interest in homicide— and who continues to do so—should first be given my appreciation. This group is composed of individuals who committed homicide and were seen by me in their roles as defendants or patients. They allowed me to try to understand what had happened in their mental life histories that had led to an outcome of homicide. Although homicide victims and their families are forced to confront the terrible consequences of this crime, the individuals who commit homicide, as well as their own families, also bear the heavy consequences of their actions and thus should not be slighted by clinicians. I continue to be grateful to many of my old mentors, professors, and friends who gave me the incentive to write this book. Among them are Andrew Watson, M.D., from the University of Michigan, now deceased; Jay Katz, M.D., from the Yale Law School; and Alan Stone, M.D., from the Harvard Law School. My continued interaction with my coteacher, Professor Eric Janus, J.D., of the William Mitchell College of Law in Minnesota, has always been fruitful and collegial. My old friend and colleague, Paul Meehl, Ph.D., now deceased, continues to influence my thinking because of his writings, critical mind, and dedication to truthfulness. Students in diverse fields have always provided a catalyst to my work by asking the basic questions that somehow elude us when we become too immersed in a particular subject. I appreciate the opportunity to teach these students from diverse fields over the years, among them psychiatric residents, graduate students, and law students. Without their questions, many areas in my study of homicide would have remained unexplored. Finally, I express my appreciation to Robert E. Hales, M.D., M.B.A., editor-in-chief of American Psychiatric Publishing, Inc., and John McDuffie, editorial director, with whom working has been a pleasant
xvii
xviii
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
and rewarding experience. In my department at the University of Minnesota, my personal thanks for technical assistance with parts of the book go to Karl Krohn, Ph.D., and Ms. Yoonie Helbig for secretarial assistance.
CHAPTER
1 EPIDEMIOLOGICAL ASPECTS OF HOMICIDE HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE ON RATES OF HOMICIDE Trends in deaths from homicides for the twentieth century reveal low rates early in the century, with a peak first reached during the economic depression years of the 1930s. 1 The homicide rate dropped during World War II, followed by a slight increase in the late 1940s and early 1950s. By the end of that decade, the rate had dropped, but it picked up again in the 1960s with a steady climb. The peak rate of 10.2 murders per 100,000 people was reached in 1980. During the 1980s, the homicide rate continued to be among the highest in the twentieth century in the United States. From 1990 to 1994 the rates remained quite high, ranging from 9.0 to 9.8, but then began to drop. In the last years of the century, the rates for serious felonies, including homicide, began to drop and continued to drop into the twenty-first century, with a rate of 5.5 in 2004. Such data are available from the annual publication of the Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program by way of reports to the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and its Supplementary Homicide Reports (SHRs) and are summarized in Table 1–1. The debate has been why these changes occurred. In a report by the National Academy of Sciences,2 it was noted that the annual risk of becoming a homicide victim had risen from 1 in 12,000 in 1987–1988 to 1 in 10,600 by 1990. However, the lifetime risk of homicide was much greater, with the highest lifetime rate in six demographic groups being among black males. Their rate of 4.16 is equivalent to a 1 in 24.1 chance of dying by homicide. For American Indians, the risk is 1 in 57, whereas for white males and females the risk is less than 1 in 100. It must be emphasized that despite the media’s focus on killings of adolescents and young males, less than 25% of one’s lifetime homicide risk is actually incurred by the time that person reaches his or her 25th birthday. Thus the high number of black males dying by age 24 years must be seen in the context of the high homicide rate for black
1
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
2 TABLE 1–1.
Murder and nonnegligent manslaughter in the United States
Year
Population
Number of reported offenses
Rate per 100,000 inhabitants
1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003
231,664,458 233,791,994 235,824,902 237,923,795 240,132,887 242,288,918 244,498,982 246,819,230 249,464,396 252,153,092 255,029,699 257,782,608 260,327,021 262,803,276 265,228,572 267,783,607 270,248,003 272,690,813 281,421,906 285,317,559 288,368,698 290,800,000
21,010 19,308 18,692 18,976 20,613 20,096 20,675 21,500 23,438 24,703 23,760 24,526 23,326 21,606 19,645 18,208 16,974 15,522 15,586 16,037 16,204 16,503
9.1 8.3 7.9 8.0 8.6 8.3 8.5 8.7 9.4 9.8 9.3 9.5 9.0 8.2 7.4 6.8 6.3 5.7 5.5 5.6 5.6 5.7
Source. U.S. Department of Justice: Crime in the United States. Washington, DC, U.S. Department of Justice, 2004.
males at all ages. Arrest data for 2003 indicate that males composed 89.7% of murder arrestees. By race, whites accounted for 49.1% of the murder arrestees and blacks 48.5%, even though only 12% of the population is black. Data from the UCR indicate that a record number of 23,438 overall homicides were committed in 1990.3 However, this figure by itself is relatively meaningless; it must be viewed in relationship to other timemeasured variables to have any meaning. For example, an increase in population could lead to an increase in the number of homicides. This factor has led demographers to study longitudinal trends that include homicide rates. The overall rates can vary significantly over time. In addition, the data may be broken down into rates for various states and regions of the United States and may detail the relationships between the people involved in the killing (e.g., homicide victims being spouses,
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
3
children, and so forth). For example, in the early 1990s, the western United States appeared to supplant the South as the region with the highest overall level of violence among the four regions the UCR program uses. However, by 2003 the southern states, which make up 35.9% of the nation’s population, had regained the position by accounting for 43.6% of the murders in the country.4 Another important variable is the demographics, such as the proportion of those in a high-risk age group for committing homicide at a particular time.
SPECIFIC EPIDEMIOLOGICAL ASPECTS Nine key epidemiological variables have been studied or raised as significant with respect to homicide: age, race, gender, socioeconomic class, method of killing, relationship between the victim and perpetrator (including cases that some interpret as being precipitated by the victim), the perpetrator’s prior arrests, use of alcohol or other drugs, and temporal and ecological factors. One caveat is needed before exploring the individual epidemiological variables. Epidemiological data reflect data on the victims but not on the perpetrators. This omission is interesting in its own right and perhaps signifies that understanding the mind of the murderer requires a clinical or criminological explanation. Thus, in an operational sense, homicide rates can only give the numbers of people killed in any given population unit. Many of the factors discussed in this section overlap, and no scientific presentation can make a claim that any one variable is the cause of a homicide. Instead, a workable model for determining factors leading up to a homicide must elicit significant background factors that under certain precipitating circumstances, predispose an individual to commit a homicide. The inductive search for determining factors must be an empirical one in which the basic premise is that for any one homicide, several factors are necessary but one factor is never a sufficient cause for that homicide. Such a position is compatible with considering the significance of personality attributes and given clinical diagnoses. It is also consistent with the position that when legal questions arise regarding a person’s responsibility for a homicide, no answer can ever be given simply on the basis of a diagnosis. Overdetermination of homicidal actions is the rule.
Age Much publicity has focused on homicides committed by juveniles from the early 1990s onward, when high rates were disproportionately contributed
4
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
by young black males. This accompanied the concern about a drug culture in which homicides might be a part of the trade. A concealed factor then and now is that juvenile homicides are often conducted by more than one party but with only one victim, which skews juvenile offenders in the statistical distribution. Even taking the past 25 years through 2002, only 10% of murderers and victims were under 18 years of age, whereas the 18- to 24year-old group contained about 36% of offenders and 24% of victims.5 Tables 1–2 and 1–3 illustrate the number of murder victims and offenders by age, sex, and race for 2003. Note the relatively high victim rates for infants, which then decrease, with the lowest rate found among those ages 5–12 years. White female infants have had the greatest risk of all white females for dying by homicide, a risk related to acts of infanticide. This topic is discussed further in Chapter 8 (“The Depressed or Bipolar Person and Homicide”). The loading of males as murder offenders is significant in the age groups of 17–19 years and 20–24 years, with especially high numbers of black males distributed in these groups.
Race The racial factor is reflected in fluctuations over time in general, but again, rates for nonwhite homicide victims and perpetrators are higher than for white victims and perpetrators for every age group. Depending on the age group studied, the rate for homicides among nonwhite males can be as high as 10 times that for white males. It should be noted that most studies have focused on larger American cities. In a study of homicide in New York City, Tardiff and colleagues6 found that young black and Latino men were more likely to be homicide victims than men from any other demographic group. In the subset who died within 48 hours, 31% were positive for cocaine metabolites, and 25% of their deaths involved firearms, which suggests a basis for the high death rate. In turn, these variables may be situational and related to poverty. The significance of race in epidemiological studies of homicide cannot be ignored. Yet the deeper question is, what does it mean? Besides the national data noted earlier, other studies have documented that black people are involved at a rate far in excess of their numbers in the population. The studies are also consistent in indicating that such killings are overwhelmingly intraracial. Findings from Wolfgang’s7 early study in Philadelphia, PA, reported that based on 1948–1952 data, 73% of the offenders and 75% of the victims of 588 homicides were black; these findings were consistent with a later study by Hewitt.8 Furthermore, the distribution seems to be continuing even though the overall murder and manslaughter rates have declined from the early 1990s.
Murder victims by age, sex, and race, 2003 Sex
Age (years) Total Distribution (%) Under 18 Under 22 18 and over Infant (under 1) 1 to 4 5 to 8 9 to 12 13 to 16 17 to 19 20 to 24 25 to 29 30 to 34 35 to 39 40 to 44 45 to 49 50 to 54 55 to 59 60 to 64
Total
Male
14,408 100.0 1,333 3,445 12,811 225 307 82 69 369 1,283 2,855 2,148 1,594 1,286 1,114 951 630 365 226
11,167 77.5 905 2,724 10,083 131 164 41 36 293 1,113 2,432 1,826 1,249 973 783 694 463 256 160
Female 3,215 22.3 424 716 2,721 91 142 41 33 76 169 420 322 344 313 330 256 167 109 66
Race Unknown 26 0.2 4 5 7 3 1 0 0 0 1 3 0 1 0 1 1 0 0 0
White
Black
6,913 48.0 660 1,556 6,133 139 165 44 33 150 549 1,165 839 692 636 589 552 382 236 148
6,887 47.8 617 1,749 6,189 73 131 34 34 202 689 1,585 1,234 842 605 484 362 226 113 57
Other 408 2.8 40 100 358 7 6 3 1 14 34 74 54 43 36 32 26 19 12 16
Unknown 200 1.4 16 40 131 6 5 1 1 3 11 31 21 17 9 9 11 3 4 5
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
TABLE 1–2.
5
6
TABLE 1–2.
Murder victims by age, sex, and race, 2003 (continued) Sex
Age (years)
Total
Male
65 to 69 70 to 74 75 and over Unknown
164 153 323 264
113 90 171 179
Female 51 63 152 70
Race Unknown 0 0 0 15
White
Black
Other
122 105 247 120
32 42 61 81
8 4 9 10
Unknown 2 2 6 53
Source. U.S. Department of Justice: Crime in the United States. Washington, DC, U.S. Department of Justice, 2004.
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
Murder offenders by age, sex, and race, 2003 Sex
Age (years)
Total
Male
Female
Unknown
16,043 100.0 813 3,327 9,396 0 0 1 12 432 1,585 2,780 1,641 1,054 800 713 471 277 166 94
10,218 63.7 726 3,049 8,387 0 0 1 9 381 1,470 2,538 1,483 921 672 598 407 242 141 87
1,123 7.0 86 275 997 0 0 0 2 51 114 240 157 129 128 113 63 34 25 7
4,702 29.3 1 3 12 0 0 0 1 0 1 2 1 4 0 2 1 1 0 0
White 5,132 32.0 351 1,366 4,489 0 0 1 7 185 625 1,147 696 533 431 448 266 174 114 71
Black
Other
Unknown
5,729 35.7 433 1,832 4,542 0 0 0 4 229 889 1,542 885 480 340 235 185 91 43 19
308 1.9 21 95 280 0 0 0 0 13 49 76 45 30 23 23 17 9 7 3
4,874 30.4 8 34 85 0 0 0 1 5 22 15 15 11 6 7 3 3 2 1
7
Total Distribution (%) Under 18 Under 22 18 and over Infant (under 1) 1 to 4 5 to 8 9 to 12 13 to 16 17 to 19 20 to 24 25 to 29 30 to 34 35 to 39 40 to 44 45 to 49 50 to 54 55 to 59 60 to 64
Race
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
TABLE 1–3.
8
TABLE 1–3.
Murder offenders by age, sex, and race, 2003 (continued) Sex
Age (years)
Total
Male
65 to 69 70 to 74 75 and over Unknown
66 44 73 5,834
60 43 60 1,105
Female 6 1 13 40
Race Unknown 0 0 0 4,689
White 48 33 61 292
Black
Other
16 9 8 754
1 2 3 7
Unknown 1 0 1 4,781
Source. U.S. Department of Justice: Crime in the United States. Washington, DC, U.S. Department of Justice, 2004.
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
9
These data are depressing and unremitting, and they cry out for an explanation as well as an amelioration of the situation. Young black males and their families take the brunt of this public health problem. When it is realized that blacks account for only about 12% of the U.S. population but disproportionately account for approximately 50% of those arrested for murder and 35% arrested for assaults, obviously there is a problem that has so far remained unsolved. In terms of rates, blacks are six times more likely to be victimized and eight times more likely to commit homicides than whites. Figures 1–1 and 1–2 illustrate the different rates of victimization and offending of blacks and whites for homicide in 2002. It can also be noted that in terms of the years of potential life lost, homicide exerts a greater effect than many other causes of death, including suicide, because homicide victims are from a younger group on average. This in itself would make it a major social problem. Several explanations have been offered for these findings. Traditional explanations have raised the possibility of social and economic inequality, lack of opportunity, racism, and discriminatory practices in the criminal justice system, ranging from the point of arrest to sentencing. Some have argued that such disparities exist for minorities in diverse cultural settings outside the United States as well. Yet although all these factors are relevant, in themselves they do not dispose of the question. To complicate matters, the high-risk group of black males—those in the 14–24 age group—has changed very little in terms of numbers from 1993 to the present overall decline in homicide rates. It is interesting to contrast these data with scholarly studies of why long-term homicide rates have declined in Europe. Explanations are offered in terms of a decline in elite homicide (i.e., homicide by the upper social classes) over a long period and a drop in male-to-male conflicts in public space, but the racial factor is omitted, although noted age and sex patterns remain relatively unchanged.9 Consider the explanation of economic and social deprivation. Both topics are raised as a correlate of homicide that can have some possible causal significance or possibly none at all. In consideration of how these factors may operate, the concepts of poverty as a state of absolute deprivation and inequality as a relative deprivation are relevant. The result is that fewer economic resources are available for those in such a predicament. If the focus is on the relationship between poverty and homicide rates in large American cities, there is a consistent and positive correlation to all homicide rates. What is important is that this correlation exists independently of variables such as race, region, or population size. However, various kinds of inequality do not show an effect on homicide rates, also independent of these same variables.10
Homicide rate (per 100,000)
10
White Black Other
FIGURE 1–1.
Homicide victimization by race, 1976–2002. Rate per 100,000.
Source. Bureau of Justice Statistics: Homicide Trends in the United States. Washington, DC, U.S. Department of Justice, 2004.
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
Year
Homicide rate (per 100,000)
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
White Black Other
Year
FIGURE 1–2.
Homicide offending by race, 1976–2002. Rate per 100,000.
Source. Bureau of Justice Statistics: Homicide Trends in the United States. Washington, DC, U.S. Department of Justice, 2004.
11
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
12
Gender Data from the Bureau of Justice Statistics of the U.S. Department of Justice for a 25-year period ending in 2000 indicated that for all homicides, males were the offenders in 87.9% of cases and victims in 76.4%; females were the offenders in 12.1% of cases and victims in 23.6%. Women were especially at risk for intimate killings, sex-related homicides, and murder by arson or poison. In turn, women were more likely to commit murder as a result of an argument or to murder by poison. These rates can be further broken down as follows: Male offender/Male victim, 65.2% Male offender/Female victim, 25.0% Female offender/Male victim, 7.2% Female offender/Female victim, 2.6% Some of the statistical findings regarding gender can be summarized as follows: 1. At the beginning of the twenty-first century, males were 3.2 times more likely than females to be murdered. 2. Males were 10 times more likely than females to commit murder. 3. Males were more likely to be victim targets of homicides than females. 4. Rates for females as homicide offenders have declined since the early 1980s, whereas rates for males as offenders peaked in the early 1990s and then began to decline. 5. Most males murder men, but most females who murder also murder men. 6. If anything, the gender gap between male and female murderers has seemed to widen and not narrow as we have moved into the twentyfirst century. Regarding perpetrators, in 80% of the cases, men killed nonintimate acquaintances, strangers, or victims of undetermined relationship, whereas women killed nonintimately related people in 40% of cases. When men killed with a gun, they most commonly shot a stranger or nonfamily acquaintance. When women killed with a gun, the victim was five times more likely to be a spouse, family member, or intimate acquaintance. Perhaps this finding reflects men being more conversant with the use of guns as well as more predisposed to use them in arguments. Women prefer a method of killing by such means as arson or
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
13
poisoning and for infanticides, suffocation. Even less common are the situations in which a woman hires someone to murder her lover or spouse, although the scenario makes for good television drama. When the patterns for race and gender are examined, an interesting variation emerges. Rates for men in the white and nonwhite categories are higher than for women in the corresponding racial categories. Rates for nonwhite individuals are higher than those for white individuals, partially based on the fact that homicide rates for nonwhite women are greater than those for white men. Separating the effects of race from those of gender may be difficult and is complicated by the frequent connection between gender and killing. In Wolfgang’s early study,7 82% of the perpetrators of killings and 76% of the victims were male. The race factor is also strongly connected to gender, as witnessed in the homicide offender rates being 41.7 for black males, 7.3 for black females, 3.4 for white males, and 0.4 for white females. From year to year, the UCRs do not show much annual variation in the arrest rates for homicide by gender, which is approximately 90% for males and 10% for females. The 2003 data from the UCR indicate that of the 16,503 homicides, 89.7% of arrestees were male. However, as noted, such statistics cloak differences in the types of homicidal acts committed as well as the clinical differences in such acts. Bartol11 noted that the 9:1 ratio is consistently found in studies for many major American cities as well as for some cities in England and Israel. However, some intriguing cultural differences do emerge. In England, a far higher number of the victims are females (60%) than in the United States (25%). In an Israeli study12 on Jewish homicides, 51% of Jewish victims were female, compared with 34% who were non-Jewish. However, in absolute numbers, these homicides are still fewer in number than in the United States, presumably because of the effects of alcohol, drugs, and crimes related to drugs (e.g., robberies).
Method of Killing As to the circumstances of killing, 2003 data from the UCR indicate that most homicides are committed with a firearm, with the largest subcategory of firearm used being a handgun in 53% of those homicides. Firearms are involved in about 67% of homicides in the United States.13 In addition, some states estimate 5.7 nonfatal gunshot injuries for every homicide.14 However, the risk of death by firearms may be skewed by a particularly high elevation among black male adolescents. Earlier studies, when the homicide rates were peaking, revealed the ratio of indi-
14
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
viduals ages 15–19 years who were victims of gun-related homicide was 7.5 per 100,000 for white males but 83.4 per 100,000 for black males. These data were believed to be correlated with death by firearms, in which the fraction of homicides committed with guns peaked in those ages 15–19 years, with 81% becoming victims by that means.2 The skewing is reflected in the percentage of homicide victims killed with a gun, which increases with age up to age 17 and then begins to decline. The UCR data for 2003 also indicate that knives or other cutting instruments are used next frequently, followed by blunt objects or parts of the body (e.g., hands and feet used as weapons or clubs and hammers). At the bottom of the frequency scale are more unusual measures, such as poison, drowning, strangulation, asphyxiation, arson, or explosives. A comparison of the risk of death versus a nonfatal injury during family and intimate assaults reveals that the use of a firearm is 12 times more likely to result in a death than non-firearm-associated events.15 Therefore, firearms play a significant role not only in homicides committed by men but also in the context of family and intimate assaults where there is access to such a lethal weapon. Another component of the circumstances of the homicide deals with the setting of the homicide. Some of these settings are associated with murders connected to felonies or lesser crimes. The SHRs try to provide details about specific homicides, such as romantic triangles, brawls under the influence of alcohol or narcotics, various types of arguments often unspecified, gang killings, juvenile gang killings, and so on. For the homicides committed in 2003, the circumstances surrounding the killings were actually unknown in 33.9% of cases. The largest identified group of 16.4% was connected to a felony murder, such as during the commission of a robbery or narcotic violation. Among the heterogeneous group not connected to the commission of a felony, arguments were cited as behind 28.6% of the killings. These data provide little specificity in terms of what occurred during the argument between the participants or a group but simply classify the setting of the homicide to the best extent possible.
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN VICTIM AND PERPETRATOR Although the victim–perpetrator relationship in homicides is often one of family ties or intimate relationships, the number of homicides committed by strangers has increased significantly in recent years. As characterized in the UCRs, the majority of homicides occur in the context of what is referred to as primary homicides, with primary referring to a death
15
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
that occurs in a relatively spontaneous fight between people who know each other, often over money or property and fueled by alcohol or drugs. According to the 2004 UCR, 12.5% of perpetrators and victims were members of the same family and another 30.5% were friends, neighbors, and acquaintances. Only 12.5% of homicides occurred among strangers. However, in 44.5% of these cases, the police could not determine whether a prior relationship existed between the perpetrator and the victim. This may be because they cannot discover who the perpetrator was or because there is a lack of evidence to make any connection. There is also a gender difference in victim–offender relationships, in which female victims are more likely to be killed by an intimate or family member. In contrast, male victims are more likely than female victims to be killed by acquaintances or strangers (Table 1–4). If the stranger and undetermined relationship categories are combined, these ratios amount to 51.8% for males and 36.6% for females.
TABLE 1–4.
Victim–offender relationships by victim gender, 1976–2002 Homicide victims by gender,%
Victim–offender relationship
Male
Female
Total Intimate Spouse Ex-spouse Boyfriend/Girlfriend Other family Parent Child Sibling Other family Acquaintance/Known Neighbor Employee/Employer Friend/Acquaintance Other known Stranger Undetermined
100.0 5.5 3.3 0.2 2.0 6.7 1.3 2.1 1.2 2.1 35.9 1.2 0.2 30.1 4.5 15.5 36.3
100.0 30.1 18.6 1.4 10.1 11.4 2.7 5.4 0.9 2.5 21.9 1.3 0.1 17.2 3.2 8.9 27.7
Note. The victims of the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks are not included in this analysis. Source. Bureau of Justice Statistics: Homicide Trends in the United States. Washington, DC, U.S. Department of Justice, 2004.
16
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
It is thus probable that more people are being killed by strangers than ever before. Data from the Bureau of Justice Statistics indicate that the number of homicides in which the circumstances are unknown has tripled since 1976.16 On the other hand, homicides involving adult or juvenile gang violence increased more than sixfold in that time period. In the past, there has been a customary 70%–75% “clearance rate” for homicides, where the police believe they have solved the crime and one or more persons should be arrested. The clearance has been associated with a high rate of reporting, because few homicides are never reported to authorities. By 2003, the clearance rate had decreased to 62.4%, presumably related to the increase in stranger killing. It appears that about 50% of homicides stem from an argument, whereas another 25% occur under the influence of alcohol or drugs. This discussion leads to the broader topic of how an epidemiological approach conceptualizes perpetrator–victim relationships and their potential for heightening the possibility of a homicide. One approach has been to use a victim-precipitation model, which has been criticized as blaming the victim. An alternative approach has focused on the diverse and complex interactional variables in relationships or situations that can have a violent ending. The victim-precipitation model looks at the ways homicide victims played some role in their own future deaths, focusing on situations such as arguments in bars or disagreements between spouses and lovers that escalated into increasing taunts, insults, or physical contact. When the situations were later reconstructed from the available facts, it often seemed that what had pushed matters toward homicide often began with a trivial event or exchange. The presumption in such theorizing is that the individuals, although not necessarily intimates, were interacting with each other, and therefore the killing would not be seen as part of a model for killing by a stranger. This model would thus not be applicable to killings occurring in the context of robberies or burglaries. In an interesting approach that parallels many psychiatric theories of interpersonal violence, criminologists look at the types of interactions between individuals that eventually lead to a death. The difference between this theory and earlier theories about victim-precipitated homicide is the realization of how a homicidal outcome is a “situated” transaction that could easily have many possible outcomes. Frequently, a situation escalates into violence because neither participant allows the other the opportunity to back away while still saving face. These escalations are neither the stuff of dramatic television portrayals nor the act of a deranged killer who could later plead not guilty by reason of insanity. Instead, these types of killings arise in the give-and-take of ordinary transactions between people and comprise a frequently found framework in which homicide is enacted.
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
17
Miethe and colleagues17 conducted a study of situational contexts in homicides, focusing on the interactions among offenders, victims, and elements of the offenses. They relied on data from narrative accounts and the SHRs over three decades using a methodology of qualitative comparative analysis. One of their findings was that categorizing homicides as either instrumental (those carried out for an explicit future goal, such as acquiring money or status) or expressive (unplanned acts of anger, rage, or frustration) is excessively simple. There is so much variance among the nature and prevalence of the offender, victim, and situational factors that the distinction between instrumental and expressive motives is unclear. The configuration of both is required to begin to understand the social processes and triggering mechanisms involved when individuals and situations converge for a homicide. Psychiatry’s major contribution to comprehending how these seemingly commonplace behaviors lead to homicides is in terms of understanding personality vulnerability and functioning and the impact of painful emotions on human beings. These painful emotions are evoked in the course of interactions in which sensitivities or misinterpretations are played out. In some situations, certain personality disorders or traits predispose the individual to overreact or misinterpret. For these people, the sway of emotions then surges to the surface and erupts into some impulsive action. The actors might be spouses or lovers who argue and then progress to shoving and slapping and then to the use of fists, objects, or weapons. Name-calling or taunts are frequent. In some cases, it might be a child’s disobedience or the endless crying of an infant that elicits feelings of helplessness in the adult, who then reacts to the child’s behavior as a provocative challenge that must be handled. At a crucial juncture, the point of no return is crossed. Luckenbill,18 a criminologist, broke down these various types of interactions into a series of stages. In stage one, the future victim performs some type of act or verbalization that is interpreted as an attack on the future perpetrator’s activities or self-esteem. Seen from a psychiatric perspective, this initial stage would reflect the perpetrator’s tendency to distort or overinterpret. For example, an individual with paranoid or borderline personality would be among those likely to overreact. Stage two is an attempt to confirm the meaning of what the potential perpetrator has heard. Other people may be turned to for their interpretation; in fact, it is interesting that a majority of such confrontations occur in the presence of others. By the time stage three is arrived at, the perpetrator is at the point of responding, often by challenging the intended victim or demanding a halt to or retraction of certain statements. Threats may emerge. Stage four is the counterresponse of the intended victim, who at
18
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
that point does not back off but stands his or her ground. Stage five is the emergence of violence, either abruptly or after the perpetrator seeks out and obtains weapons. Stage six involves the reaction of the perpetrator after the killing, such as fleeing or being restrained by others. In this framework, many variables are operating, and indeed are necessary, for the predicted final outcome to occur; these variables involve both instrumental and expressive motivations. One necessary element is the occurrence of an intense interaction in which others are usually present but in which no one intervenes. The ready availability of weapons as a part of a high-risk lifestyle may also be an operating variable. Such a milieu is typically present in places such as bars, entertainment clubs, or street-corner confrontations. Note that through the first four stages of this model, various outcomes are possible.
PERPETRATORS’ PRIOR CRIMINAL OFFENSES There are many difficulties in assessing the significance of prior delinquent or criminal behavior with respect to the later commission of a homicide. A major problem is related to risk assessment or the prediction of such behavior. There is the further complication of moving from the realm of early adult criminal behavior to also encompass the antecedent role of adolescent antisocial behavior and whatever its relationship is to later violence in the form of becoming a future murderer. Specifically, much difficulty is attendant on predicting rare events such as homicides. When a retrospective look is taken after a homicide has occurred, certain variables often appear prominent. However, such retrospective approaches do not allow much sensitivity when it comes to antecedent prediction. A practical problem is that juvenile files are sealed in most states unless the juvenile has been waived to the adult criminal justice system. At that point, and for most young adults, it is usually not their first encounter with the legal system. Such data are not to be interpreted as indicating that most juvenile offenders go on to become violent adult offenders. This is not the case. The data indicate that of the 33%–45% of males in the United States who were once detained by the police or arrested as juveniles, the majority (approximately 65%) were arrested only once or twice and have no subsequent adult record. What these data mean is that a small number of juvenile offenders persist in committing crimes into young adulthood and that those juveniles who engaged in serious crime at an early age form a subgroup of individuals who are more likely to engage in serious violence, such as a homicide, in their 20s.
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
19
The highest rates for victimization and perpetration of a homicide occur among older teens and young adults. The rates for these groups increased dramatically in the late 1980s and early 1990s and then declined, as they did for all ages, as shown in Figures 1–3 and 1–4. In the period from 1985 to 1992, the homicide victimization rates for 14- to 17-year-olds increased almost 170% and then declined to levels similar to those experienced between 1976 and 1985. The highest victimization rates in that period were in the 18- to 24-year-old age group, which replaced the 25- to 34-year-old group. Offending rates of 14- to 17-year-olds increased rapidly after 1985, surpassing the rates of 25- to 34-year-olds, but the latter group has now recovered its higher position over the teenagers. The 18- to 24year-old age group has the highest homicide rate, and from 1985 to 1992 their rates almost doubled; the rates declined since then but still remain higher than their levels prior to the mid-1980s. At the height of these killing rates, the idea of a group of juveniles and young adults who were “superpredators” was broached. The implication was that this would be the group from which future killers would emerge. However, it was realized that many of these killings were not planned acts of homicide but rather impulsive acts often connected with drug dealing. They were thus often gang related and carried out by two or more individuals. Much of the impetus for the killing came from the combination of drug dealing and the easy availability of guns. The phenomenon of group identification and the idea of needing to join in group activities or losing a reputation was often at stake. There have been endless discussions about what contributed to the lowering of rates in this age group. Suggestions included the shift away from crack cocaine, police adopting a mixture of new tactics varying from cracking down to fostering more community involvement, and schools taking on monitoring roles such as checking for weapons. However, the rise and fall of gangs will inevitably continue, as witnessed by gang-related killings in large cities again increasing to a level double that of 1999.19 The early onset of delinquent behavior is often seen as a good predictor of later chronic, serious, and violent criminal acts when the youth becomes a teenager or young adult. When a juvenile’s early offenses include serious violent offenses (e.g., robbery), his or her probability of committing serious crime as an adult is increased. A third predictor variable in the juvenile offender is repetitive property offenses. Delinquency convictions before age 16 years and repeated sentences to juvenile correctional facilities are two other significant variables. When these variables are taken together in a weighted summative manner, the probability increases that a juvenile offender will commit a violent offense—including an increased possibility of committing a homicide—
Homicide rate (per 100,000)
20
Age in years Under 14 14–17 18–24 25–34 35–49 50+
FIGURE 1–3.
Homicide victimization by age, 1976–2002. Rate per 100,000.
Source. Bureau of Justice Statistics: Homicide Trends in the United States. Washington, DC, U.S. Department of Justice, 2004.
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
Year
Homicide rate (per 100,000)
Under 14 14–17 18–24 25–34 35–49 50+
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
Age in years
Year
FIGURE 1–4.
Homicide offending by age, 1976–2002. Rate per 100,000. 21
Source. Bureau of Justice Statistics: Homicide Trends in the United States. Washington, DC, U.S. Department of Justice, 2004.
22
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
as an adult. In Wolfgang’s study7 of 588 homicides, two-thirds of the perpetrators had prior arrest records. It was revealing that most of these arrests had not been for trivial offenses, nor even for property offenses, but for offenses against people that usually had been violent. Meta-analysis has been used to try to get at predictor variables in longitudinal studies of antisocial behavior as related to later violent behavior. Although statistical significance is not the same as practical significance in identifying who is at risk for violent behavior, it is known that only a small number of individuals will engage in homicide-level violence in adolescence or early adulthood. Meta-analysis allows small samples to overcome the low base-rate problem. By this approach, the strongest predictors for later serious violence beginning at ages 6–11 years were committing general offenses and engaging in substance use (chiefly tobacco and alcohol). A second-ranked group of predictor variables was male gender, family socioeconomic status, and antisocial parents. The strongest predictors at ages 12–14 years were lack of social ties, antisocial peers, and committing a general offense. A third-ranked set of variables was aggressive behavior, school attitudes and performance, various psychological conditions, parent–child relations, and physical violence. The conclusion for these groups is that these characteristics can distinguish juveniles who are at risk for violent, serious offending later in the 15- to 25-year age range.20 Of course, such data can never specify who is going to commit a homicide, but only the group who is at higher risk. The psychiatric significance of these data is that they indicate that homicide perpetrators had unresolved conflicts involving family problems and aggression and that there had been a failure to contain that aggression. It can be hypothesized that these conflicts are replayed in later acts of violence against individuals that culminate in a subsequent homicide. Although criminological researchers have not studied just what these psychological or social conflicts might be, this hypothesis points to the need for parallel lines of inquiry. It would also be significant to determine which intervening variables contributed to the remaining one-third in Wolfgang’s study7 later committing a homicide or whether these individuals were just “lucky” that earlier personal violence did not lead to arrests.
ROLE OF PSYCHOACTIVE SUBSTANCES Alcohol or other psychoactive drugs are mentioned so frequently in connection with various incidents of violence, including homicide, that the
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
23
specific role they may play is often not discussed. In fact, the words alcohol and violence are often used together as though they are inseparable, with the implication that alcohol causes the violence. This belief has become almost dogma among many in top political positions and has been reflected in legislative and community decisions involving fiscal distributions. The preconception is that alcohol facilitates the release of aggression. This position is usually based on data and figures that indicate a high percentage of violent acts are perpetrated by individuals under the influence of alcohol, even though in many cases the blood alcohol level of perpetrators was not taken, and the connection was made solely based on observation. The same thinking applies to other drug usage, in which, despite the varying effects of different drugs, the suggestion is that the person imbibed or took a drug shortly before a homicide occurred. Accurate tests to confirm or disconfirm the connection between homicidal violence and alcohol use would need to compare data between perpetrators who have ingested alcohol or psychoactive substances and individuals who have ingested similar substances but have not acted in this manner; these tests would also require control of variables such as when and where the drinking or drug use took place. It is easy to bypass other significant factors involving drug use besides the psychopharmacological effects. There is the resort to crime to get money to buy drugs, which increases the chance of violent encounters. In addition, the drug dealing trade may involve competition and intimidation techniques that can lead to homicides. When such dealings involve gangs, the potential for homicides is magnified. Drug abuse, especially alcohol, is also involved in many vehicular homicides. In the absence of any definitive studies of these factors, a large number of studies suggest a relationship between psychoactive substances and homicide on a biological or sociological level. In Holcomb and Anderson’s study21 of males charged with first-degree murder in Missouri, the authors found that 55% of the perpetrators had ingested drugs, alcohol, or both at the time of the killing. Mayfield22 found that 57% of convicted murderers studied had been drinking at the time of the killing. Greenberg 23 reported that alcoholism was diagnosed in 20%–40% of convicted murderers. A similar figure was noted in a California study of females arrested on homicide charges: 51% had been drinking at the time of the killing.24 Some 60% of violent offenders are estimated to have consumed alcohol at the time of their offenses.25 Roizen26 found that 86% of homicide offenders had been drinking at the time of the offense. Results from such studies support the generalization that about half of homicides occur under the influence of drinking. What the studies do not bring out sufficiently is that in many of these situations, the perpetrator and victim have both been drinking. In Wolf-
24
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
gang’s study,7 only the perpetrators had been drinking in 11% of the homicides, only the victims had been drinking in 9%, but both the perpetrators and victims had been drinking in 44%. Subsequent studies support a figure of close to 50% for the percentage of victims who had been drinking at the time of their deaths.27 However, despite the common assumption that alcohol, in amounts that are not sedative, increases one’s potential for aggression, the action– reaction relationship is not linear. The outcome depends on a host of variables, such as the cultural setting, genetic vulnerability, neuroendocrinological factors, other drugs that may have been taken, and immediate precipitants. Hence, the mechanism for how a violent end-point occurs is not entirely clear. Some studies find little evidence of a simple direct relationship between the psychoactive effects of drugs or alcohol and aggression.28 The pattern of drinking may play a role, such as in the more concentrated style of drinking prevalent in the United States rather than the spaced drinking style prevalent in some European countries. The suggestion of a type of alcohol-facilitated, episodic dyscontrol syndrome arises. Yet results from studies in Scotland29 and the Bordeaux region of France30 have indicated that 55% and 51%, respectively, of those convicted for murder had been drinking at the time of their offense. One persistent source of controversy is the extent to which someone carrying out a homicide under the influence of alcohol is responsible for that act. The answer to this question, in turn, is connected in part with a belief system, neither proven nor disproven, that alcoholism is a disease. The inference is that individuals who are biologically vulnerable to the effects of alcohol should not be seen as responsible for their violent acts committed under the influence. This type of reasoning has often been subjected to critical appraisal.31 In addition, not everyone subscribes to the theory that the loss of inhibition accounted for within a biological disease model of alcohol use is the crucial variable in assessing personal responsibility for behavior. Instead, proponents of a social-cognitive model have focused on the learned expectations of what alcohol supposedly permits one to do. Thus if the expectation is that when someone drinks, his or her control over personal impulses will be lost, then it is more likely that he or she will lose control. Bartol11 summarized the debate from this social-cognitive perspective, in which the consumer’s expectations of the effects of alcohol act as a crucial variable in how he or she will behave when drinking. Those holding to the social-cognitive model see the psychoactive influences of alcohol as learned and situationally determined and thus see the loss of control as related to a cognitive expectancy rather than a disease.
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
25
On the other hand, no one can doubt that alcohol has physiological effects on the nervous system. A correlation exists between low cerebrospinal fluid concentrations of 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid (5-HIAA), a serotonin metabolite, and impulse control problems.32 Impulsivity and disinhibition have consistently been related to individuals with chronic alcoholism as well as related to Cluster B personality disorders.33 Also, the results of genetic work on alcoholism and antisocial personality have raised questions about whether there is some overlap among those who carry one or both diagnoses.34 There also appear to be differences between males and females regarding the connection between alcohol consumption and violent behavior that may be related to different social expectations.35 In this connection, there is an observation that men using cocaine are more likely to perpetrate violent crimes, whereas women using cocaine are more likely to become victims of violence.36 The debate concerning alcohol use and violence may primarily be over what is the prime influence on the violent behavior and whether alcohol is the necessary variable in an event culminating in violence. In a carefully designed research project involving all violent acts witnessed by or perpetrated on a random sample of citizens in a single town, Pernanen37 found that alcohol was involved in 54% of those acts but that the effect of other factors on the violent outcome varied even more than alcohol use by the victims and perpetrators. Some studies have demonstrated the missing effect by giving alcohol or substances purported to be alcohol to study subjects under single-blind conditions.28,38 The researchers then observed the effect of the subjects’ believing they had drunk alcohol as well as the context in which that alcohol had been drunk on the subjects’ behavior. There are limits on how far the cultural setting can influence behavior if alcohol continues to be consumed. Eventually, higher cognitive processes (e.g., attention, concentration) do become impaired. In the end, it is the combined effects of the pharmacological, situational, and cognitive factors that determine the outcome: feelings of being threatened, provoked, or insecure; intrapsychic components (e.g., depression, anxiety); and the influence of alcohol can all contribute to an act culminating in homicide. A similar critical appraisal could be done for the effects of psychoactive drugs on an individual’s potential for extreme violence. In one study, 81% of 275 homicide victims were tested for benzoylecgonine, the major metabolite of cocaine. Forty percent of the victims tested positive for this metabolite, a number much higher than that presumed in earlier studies.39 Although marijuana or opiates may inhibit violent behavior, phencyclidine, lysergic acid diethylamide (LSD), and amphetamines are seen as increasing the potential for violence. The changing patterns of drug us-
26
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
age and drug subcultures, especially in major American cities, need to be assessed at any given time. Drugs vary in popularity at different periods of time. For example, in the 1970s heroin injections were popular, followed by the emergence of cocaine. In the 1980s and 1990s, smoking crack cocaine emerged with its accompaniment of increased violence. In the 1990s, the increased use of methamphetamine began, and it continues into the twenty-first century. A related drug that has emerged is methylenedioxymethamphetamine (MDMA), which is known as “Ecstasy” and is a stimulant and psychedelic that induces emotional lability and surges of energy so a person can stay active for prolonged periods of time. Diverse drugs are still used and different patterns witnessed, such as smoking marijuana in a cigar (a blunt) along with consuming alcohol. All of these have different potentials for violence depending on the vulnerabilities of the individual, the social context, and whether the person is also involved in dealing drugs.
TEMPORAL AND ECOLOGICAL FACTORS Uncontrollable Environmental Factors In one case, a man called a rival, threatened to kill him, and announced that he was driving to this man’s home to carry out his threat. The police were called and were waiting for him, but the man never arrived. Meanwhile, a different police squad was called to help retrieve a car that had skidded off the highway into a snowbank. In the car was the man who had made the threats, with a loaded shotgun by his side; only because of environmental factors was he rendered unable to progress further on his mission. This rather mundane example of an impediment to a homicide illustrates the idiosyncratic variables affecting whether a homicide occurs.
Seasonal, Time of Day, and Other Periodic Factors Seasonal factors have been studied to determine the incidence of violence, including homicides, by calendar month. The UCRs indicate that most homicides occur in the summer, but the months with the highest homicide rates are July and December.13 These high-rate periods may simply reflect periods in which there are greater interpersonal contacts and social mingling (i.e., summer with its long days and good weather, December with its many holidays). Similarly, the day or time of day most likely for the occurrence of a homicide has been noted.40 Saturday evening and early Sunday morn-
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
27
ing appear to be the prime times, which would seem related to the most common time that people are exposed to each other. The search for periodicity in homicide has led to recurring biological factors in homicides. One phenomenon referred to is “premenstrual frenzy,” which is discussed in Chapter 2 (“Biological Factors in Homicide”), under the heading “Premenstrual Syndrome.” Humans’ fascination with the moon has never diminished, even though astronauts have now walked on the moon. In mythology, stories, and song, profound powers have been attributed to the moon. “It is the very error of the moon; she comes more near the earth than she was wont, and makes men mad,” as Shakespeare expressed it in Othello.41 The reasoning is that the human body responds to the moon much in the same way as the sea, especially considering that the body is made up of 80% water, like the earth. The influence of the moon would also be induced via changes in the geophysical environment in weather, earthquakes, and electromagnetic fields. One investigation from this perspective in Dade County, FL, showed a correlation between the lunar phase cycle and homicides and revealed that homicides peaked during a full moon.42
CULTURAL VARIABLES In addition to discussions of different homicide rates within different social groups in a particular society, it must be recognized that cultural settings also influence homicide rates. This is true even when making comparisons among industrialized countries, let alone between industrialized and less industrialized countries. Within the industrialized nations, the United States has the highest murder rate; Japan and Austria have the lowest rates. Some economically developing nations do have higher homicide rates than the United States; the homicide rates per 100,000 in these countries are as follows: Colombia (56.3), El Salvador (38.8), Jamaica (37.2), and Mongolia (24.6); however, it is not clear whether these rates exclude war-related activities.43 The homicide victim rate for most industrialized countries is usually below 3 per 100,000. However, from 1980 onward, the homicide rate in the United States has been more than twice that figure, falling somewhere between 5 and 10 per 100,000. When the rates are broken down in terms of age groupings, the disparity in the rate in the United States compared with most European countries becomes even more glaring, because the rate for young males in Europe lies between 1 and 2 per 100,000. As far as can be determined from existing documentation, the
28
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
murder rate in the United States in the twentieth century has never been as low as 3 per 100,000. It is informative to compare the numbers of homicides in different countries. Interpol data from 1999 to 2000 show rates of homicide per 100,000 for Europe to be 1.59.44 Certain countries stand out, such as Lithuania (10.62), Estonia (10.61), and Latvia (6.47). Russia is listed at a rate of 22.05 and South Africa at 55.86. At the lower end are Spain and Switzerland (1.12), Sweden (1.11), Japan (1.05), and Norway (0.05). Explanations of this striking disparity vary widely. One is that Americans are more tolerant of aggression and violence, including violence with firearms, which are considered to be ever present in American society. (See earlier discussion of gun-related homicides in the section “Method of Killing.”) Another theory is that American society does little to discourage physical aggression among its young male population. Still other theories stress the effects of the media and network television violence on America’s tendency to be a violent nation. The conclusion of some researchers is that the United States is a society that promotes and accepts the extremes of personal aggressive violence but is hypocritical about other standards, such as sexual deviance, as witnessed in discriminatory treatment of those with diverse sexual practices.45
SOCIOLOGICAL VARIABLES Changes in Lifestyle as Increasing Risk for Victimization Some researchers see the question of who is likely to meet death by homicide as a subquestion in the context of a broader, sociological one: why is there more crime and violence in modern society, when material conditions for living are comparatively better than in preceding historical periods (an interpretation of history with which not all agree)? Those who view these questions from a lifestyle approach see the quality of people’s lives and interactions with others in modern society as not being improved and consider the acquisition of more material goods as irrelevant. In fact, some argue that a milieu for increased violent behavior has been created, referring to variables such as the following, among many others: • The breakdown in family structure • Increased number of families in which both partners work outside the home • Minimal time at home • The increasing number of meals people eat out
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
29
• Increased numbers of people living in a state of isolation • Social lives increasingly centered outside the home • The pursuit of entertainment and a social life based on endless shopping malls that are open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week • Increased exposure to violence in various forms of media As a result of these factors, people are placed in locations where they can more often become targets of violence. More perpetrators are then stimulated to capitalize on the more readily available targets.46 Implicit in this theory is that anything that increases the contact between human beings will increase the risk of a homicide. If, because of contemporary lifestyles, people are on the move more often, they are consequently more exposed to the possibility of violence. Hindelang and colleagues47 posited a theory on what factor increases the risk of being victimized because of more contact with people under certain conditions. As a common example, an increased risk of violence accompanies roles certain people play, such as a single person being more likely to go to diverse places and be exposed to unknown people more frequently. It is not only that single individuals do more things alone, and that they do them alone more frequently than before, but also that they expose themselves more to the different phenomena and contexts that this lifestyle provides (e.g., bars, clubs), which in turn increases their risk of becoming a victim of violence. Another factor increasing the risk of homicide is one’s place in the social structure. For example, a cabdriver going on “runs” into a druginfested part of a city increases his or her risk of being killed, just as does a college student’s dabbling in selling drugs. Constraints of race or social class operate within this framework. Of course, a person may try to set limits on these activities by avoiding certain exposures, but depending on the factors just discussed, certain risks may be unavoidable depending on one’s circumstances. Some research has specifically tested these hypotheses. One group evolved an index called the household activity ratio. Married households where the female spouse worked and households headed by a single adult with children were studied in proportion to the total number of households of all kinds. The former group was seen as being in a higher-risk category for being a homicide victim; in fact, the ratio provided by comparing the first two groups with the total households in the entire United States for 1947–1974 had a positive correlate with the rate of homicide.48 A variation on this theory is to see the ratio between the first two groups and the total households as signifying economic inequality, which in itself can lead to an increase in homicides.49 For households in which
30
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
both partners work, that household has double exposure to risk in that both partners leave the home each day; for households headed by a single adult, members of that household are more likely to have a lowered socioeconomic status and be exposed to poverty-like conditions and the accompanying offshoots, with such economic inequalities then placing that household at a greater risk for homicidal violence. These adverse economic conditions have a general adverse influence on individuals and families in a spiraling effect. A common example is the number of people in the lower socioeconomic group living in the inner parts of large cities with limited work opportunities, an increasing minority population concentrated in public housing, and illicit drug dealing that is perceived as a way out with its increased risk of violence.50 In an analysis of individual homicides in New York City, the impact routine activities have on the rate of stranger-committed homicides was confirmed.51 According to this theory, if males are away from home more than females as a part of their daily routines, then they are more likely to become victims of homicides, a tendency that was confirmed in the New York analysis. Continuing with this hypothesis, white individuals would then be more likely than other races to become victims of stranger homicide because their jobs are more likely to take them farther from home or require travel. With increasing numbers of women away from home at present, they are more likely to become victims of stranger-committed homicides.
SUBCULTURE OF VIOLENCE The essence of the theory of a subculture of violence is that certain subgroups in American society hold values conducive to violence and that the socialization process in those groups not only accepts but promotes such behavior. The initial formulation of this theory was not restricted to homicide but rather was applied overall to criminal behavior in which such behaviors were seen as being learned. Through interactions with individuals who approve of crime, norms develop that are conducive to crime within certain subgroups. For example, a subgroup may be more tolerant of violence and likely see it as a legitimate means for the expression of aggression or violent tendencies. If a homicide results, it is seen as unfortunate for both parties but simply an inherent risk in the way life is lived in the subculture. Such an outcome is not seen simply as two individuals interacting but as a reflection of some social groups more often resorting to violence that in turn increases the likelihood of homicide.
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
31
The exposure of members of these subgroups to violence can be intense, from the enormous violence witnessed on television and in films to the subculture’s connection of male identity with expressions of violence. Weapons are readily available for those who believe they need to “even things up” to express their aggression. Going along with the acceptance and promotion of these values is the hypocritical policing of sex in magazines, music, and television in society, which gives a strange mixture of messages in which sex is seemingly regulated but violence promoted. One hope for members of this subculture is that the violence will be channeled into other options (e.g., competitive athletics among these groups). Another hope is that those who are observers and vicarious participants in the subgroups can mitigate the degree of their own need for direct aggression. Of course, the linchpin of the theory that a subculture of violence leads to increased homicides is that those subgroups who have high rates of homicide actually do possess a different set of norms with respect to violence. The reverse—that high homicide rates validate such a culture—cannot be argued; rather, independent empirical validation of the theory is needed. Measuring attitudes toward violence is difficult; even then, expressed behavior may not match verbalized values. For example, almost no one directly states that he or she approves of violence, let alone the killing of someone (with the exception of those involved in political killing and ethnic cleansing). Rather, it is the covert way in which different attitudes toward violence are expressed that would distinguish one group from another. As a result, it is not easy for groups or individuals to be classified as part of a subcultural group or not. It is more likely that they could be classified along a continuum. One group may approve of a good deal of criminal behavior and stand in opposition to many societal values, yet only approve of certain selected killings. In between may be groups that have a mixture of values, some of which may be conducive to violence and others not. On the other end of the continuum may be a group that has values approving of more minor antisocial behavior, such as white-collar or bureaucratic violations, but that sees a homicide that results from such activities as outside the accepted norms. Such continua exist for groups as well as individuals within the group.
Strain Theory Contemporary proponents of the subcultural theory have made many different arguments from those mentioned previously. These pro-
32
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
ponents rely on a strain theory, in which it is hypothesized that when individuals cannot achieve their goals (e.g., monetary gains) through legitimate channels, they are more likely to resort to crime. When involved in frustrating situations, people are at increased risk to act out their anger and rage. Strain theory overlaps with a mixture of interpersonal stress and intrapsychic conflict that psychiatrists deal with. The original writings within this theoretical framework stemmed from the well-known sociologist Robert Merton.52 Subsequently, his work went in various directions, such as focusing on the different goals people pursue, the barriers to achieving such goals, and how and why some individuals operating under strain resort to crime. Some strains are more conducive to homicidal levels of violence. In the context of interactions with others, an individual with poor controls and low social skills is likely to act out in a violent manner. A feeling of being oppressed or treated unjustly would leave an individual more vulnerable to react to these strains with protesting or rebellious behavior. A divisive impact in the work or school milieu would heighten these feelings and leave a residue of irritability and proneness to take offense. Clinical evidence shows an increased prevalence of irritability in major depressive disorders associated with a greater likelihood of suicide.53 The presence of irritability and difficulty modulating anger in borderline personalities is relevant as well. These findings could be raised for homicides. Subsequently, interactions with other “strained” individuals may provide a social support setting and increase the likelihood of group behavior becoming criminal behavior in which violence comes to play a part.54 Parental absences or inadequacies can further accentuate strains in a juvenile or young adult population. A recent addition to the criminal law has been the category of hate or bias crimes, in which the perpetrator’s state of mind and motivation toward the victim are the key. The very same act, such as a homicide, is distinguished from a “parallel” crime simply by virtue of the requisite mental state accompanying the act. Thus, a bias homicide occurs if the person killed was selected based on discrimination or racial animus. In 1990, the Federal Hate Crime Statistics Act provided that the FBI would track offenses in which violent attacks, arson, intimidation, and property attacks were based on “manifest evidence” of prejudice based on race, religion, sexual orientation, or ethnicity. The purpose of the act was to aid in identifying criminal acts in which bias was present. By 1994, a crime bill had been directed to the U.S. Sentencing Commission to promulgate guidelines to enhance penalties for such offenses. Many states have adopted similar legislation to enhance penalties for acts that would have received a lesser penalty otherwise. However, determina-
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
33
tion of the motive in such cases may be difficult and involve a search involving complex interpersonal dynamics. The result of opening this area at sentencing may be confusing. Current efforts to conceptualize and measure hate may prove helpful.55
Other Theories Others have argued that the strain theory is not sufficient to explain certain subcultures of violence. A revision has been offered that some individuals in groups selectively endorse, as well as distort, values of the dominant culture. Matza56 stressed that in some subcultures, the values of toughness, excitement, and pleasure seeking—values taken from the culture at large—are emphasized. Within the context of these prioritized values, violence and homicide are more likely to emerge from the increased risk taking and impulsivity that may be present. Because members of these subcultures see these values exploited in society at large, such as in criminal law procedures or in the corruption of how some businesses operate and rationalize their behavior, they feel they are justified in adhering to their own values, even if it leads to homicide and the exclusion of other values promulgated by society.
FELONY MURDERS In some epidemiological studies, the concept of primary homicide (again, meaning a death resulting from a more or less spontaneous confrontation or fight between individuals or even groups) has been distinguished from the category of felony homicides, meaning killings taking place in the context of another felony (e.g., robberies, sexual killings, executions, violence between rival gangs, murders planned to achieve a certain goal [one gang sending a “message” to a rival gang]). The English common law was originally described as holding felons strictly liable for all deaths caused in the course of felonies. This rule became the rule by default in American jurisdictions and has been described as a myth.57 However, various state statutes were enacted in the nineteenth century that began to incorporate these ideas, although with different principles of liability for a felony murder. Although the number of felony homicides is significantly less than the number of primary homicides, with some estimating their prevalence at only about 20%, they continue to receive much more attention in the media than primary homicides because of their dramatic aspects and because they have greater appeal in terms of being fictionalized. When homicide rates be-
34
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
gan to increase in the 1960s, the proportion of felony homicides also increased. The result was a drop in the clearance rate for homicide because of the increase in these types of felony homicides, which do not have as high an arrest rate. Those who have studied felony homicide often see it as an impersonal and predatory type of murder in contrast to murders committed in the heat of passion by intimates. In a classic work discussing felony homicides, Dietz58 listed their distinguishing characteristics: 1. They are usually enacted by experienced, habitual, or career criminals. 2. The planning and premeditation of a felony homicide are critical parts of the act. 3. Felony homicides may involve multiple victims and multiple offenders. 4. Victims may be forcibly or physically restrained. 5. A specific antecedent (e.g., a relevant argument), as may be present in homicides between intimates, is often lacking. 6. The role of the perpetrator of a felony homicide is hypothesized, tested, and incorporated or rejected as part of the self-concept of the perpetrator. Robbery homicides are the most frequent type of felony homicide; a bank robbery is only one example of this. Dietz hypothesized that robberies occur in distinct stages. First is the planning stage, which usually occurs within a few days of the actual robbery. Sometimes those planning the robbery may specify killings during the robbery, but in other cases not all those to be involved in perpetrating the robbery are informed of this aspect of the plan, whether it is conceived that a killing will occur as a direct consequence of the plan or only as the need arises. One pattern may be that two or more of the group members are informed about the intended killing or make the decision they will do so if needed, with the other members acquiescing in such a decision. The victim or victims are usually regarded as someone impersonal or someone undeserving of respect. During the posthomicidal period, the members may talk about a killing that occurred in the course of a robbery and, in some cases, joke about it. Other variations on felony homicides occur within the context of planned executions, contract killings, or revenge killings and are related to street gangs or planned killings between rivals in organized crime. In some of these situations, a professional, referred to as a “hit man,” is hired to do the killing.
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
35
Although technically considered felony murders, homicides committed during a sexual assault (see Chapter 10, “Sexual Homicide”) differ in many aspects from these types of felony homicides. It should be noted that the concept of felony homicide has also acquired a series of legal meanings connected with cases of who might be tried for a homicide. As this concept was initially conceived, the accomplice of the perpetrator of a homicide that occurred during a bank robbery would also be charged with homicide. That concept has now been expanded so that the person driving the getaway car from a robbery in which a homicide was committed, even though he or she was not present at the killing, would be legally charged with felony homicide. As a further expansion of this concept, if a bank security guard kills one of the bank robbers in the course of the felony or attempted felony, the other members of the group attempting to carry out the felony could be legally charged with being responsible for that death. Apart from sexual killings, psychiatric issues are much less frequently raised with this group of felony murderers than in the primary type of homicide among intimates. Those involved in organized gangs—whether juvenile gangs or more advanced criminal organizations—or those controlling the gang do not wish to explore the intricacies of their psychiatric state at the time of the offense. Such inquiry is not part of their group ethos. Second, their own self-concept is such that they do not wish to be thought of as being deviant in a psychiatric sense, which would be unacceptable, even though social deviance is acceptable. Hence, many of the complex dynamics involved in their lifestyles are never explored.
MULTIPLE-VICTIM MURDERS Mass and serial murders have gained increasing publicity in the United States. Whether they have in fact been more prevalent in recent years, or whether American society is now simply becoming more aware of these types of killings through improved detection and investigation, is not clear. The Bureau of Justice classifies three types of multiple-victim murderers: serial murderers, mass murderers, and spree murderers.
Serial Killers A mass killing is defined by the FBI’s Behavioral Sciences Unit as the murder of four or more victims in a single episode, although some researchers prefer a threshold of three. A serial killer is distinguished from a spree killer simply by the time elapsed, such as whether there has been
36
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
a “cooling off” period between attacks. Serial killings can extend over months or years between the killings, whereas spree killings are seen as a binge extended over a period of hours or days in a continuous pattern. The names of several notorious serial killers come to mind under this definition, each exemplifying different types of killings:59 • Jack the Ripper, who committed several sexual murders in nineteenth-century England. • Ted Bundy, suspected of killing as many as 36 young women across the United States. His saga ended with his conviction in Florida for murdering two female Florida State University students and his subsequent execution. • Jeffrey Dahmer, who killed and cannibalized adolescent males, was convicted and later murdered while in prison. • Two men who ran a “little house of horrors” in Philadelphia, PA, where women were held in the house, abused, tortured, and eventually murdered and then cannibalized.60 • Various individuals who killed elderly people in rooming houses or boarding home situations and then appropriated their pension or Social Security checks. • Dorothea Montalvo Puente, in California, who killed nine elderly people who were her tenants for their Social Security checks and buried them in the lush yard around her house.61 • Aileen Wuornos killed seven men in a 13-month period after having sex for money with them. She pleaded self-defense on the basis of rape. The movie Monster was about her. • Albert DeSalvo, commonly referred to as the Boston Strangler. • David Berkowitz, who had the nickname “Son of Sam” and killed seven women. • The “Hillside Stranglers” of California, who were the cousins Kenneth Bianchi and Angelo Buono. • Richard Ramirez, the “Night Stalker” of Los Angeles, CA, who continued to be sought out by young women even after his imprisonment, an interesting theme in its own right. • Wayne Williams, a black male in Atlanta, GA, who carried out repeated killings of adolescent black males. • Henry Lee Lucas, who confessed to killing 350 people between 1975 and 1983. He subsequently recanted these confessions, which raised challenging issues about the veracity of these individuals and the difficulty in getting scientific data for profiling them. • John Wayne Gacy, who sexually molested his male victims and was convicted of killing 33 people.
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
37
• Ted Kaczynski, an intellectually gifted ex-professor who sent explosive devices in the mail in protest against a technological society. • Other high-publicity cases that have been written about include those of Juan Corona, Herman Mudgett, and Wayne Henley.
Incidence of Serial Killings It is almost impossible to obtain an accurate figure on the number of people who have become victims of multiple killers. Estimates range widely from 3,000 and up and for serial killers from less than 100 to over 500. Part of the difficulty is definitional. Some would exclude mass killings that are done for financial gain; others would exclude those within a family context (familicides). Whether killings involving mobs or drug dealings that involve multiple victims should be included is another issue. Separate records are not kept by the FBI or the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention on serial killings. The only semblance of record keeping is by the FBI’s Behavioral Analysis Unit (formerly the Behavioral Sciences and Investigative Support Unit) at the National Center for the Analysis of Violent Crime, which relies on newspaper wire services.62 Valid estimates are also contaminated by the mass media’s tendency to overplay such a news-catching phenomenon, which is then followed by a sequence of panic reactions on the part of legislators and other policy makers.
Patterns Seen in Serial Killings One difficulty in understanding serial murderers’ patterns is that these killers often drift around the country killing people, making it very difficult for them to be identified because their patterns are not picked up in one community. In addition, some serial killers select victims who are themselves drifters and not stable members of a community, and in that sense it is difficult to sort out the killer’s pattern. The victims in these cases are often people on the margins of society themselves, such as prostitutes, people with alcohol or drug abuse difficulties who are living in public settings, or runaway children and adolescents. Because the victims may be strangers, the usual sources of information to detect the killer, such as members of the family or friends, are not available or produce almost minimal leads because the victims may have been gone from home for some time. Other characteristics have been listed in an attempt to delineate more clearly the patterns of serial killers. The killings often occur at different times and seem to have no apparent connection to one another.
38
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
Some serial killers wander about the country and pursue victims, whereas some are “geographically stable” and stay in their home locale, such as Wayne Williams in Atlanta, GA, or John Wayne Gacy in Chicago, IL, and kill there. Some serial killers may wander simply to make it more difficult to catch them. Determining which subgroup of serial killers, if any, meet clinical criteria for different types of psychotic disorders is also needed. The understanding is that some of these individuals are in the midst of a full-blown psychotic disturbance (e.g., some type of schizophrenic disorder, a major affective disorder), whereas others show evidence of personality disturbances. Serial killers display various behaviors in connection with their killings in terms of how they treat their victims (e.g., using blindfolds, attacking their faces, tying up the victim), dispose of their bodies (e.g., dismembering the body, placing the body in specific positions), and “memorialize” the act (e.g., some take souvenirs from the victim or scene of the crime). Holmes and Holmes63 obtained some information on these variables from interviews with serial murderers and saw their principal motivating factor as a pleasure in killing or the gratification in holding the fate of others in their hands. Blindfolds appear to have significance in terms of whether the perpetrator is comfortable enough to have the gaze of the victim fixed on him or her during the various types of assaultive behaviors that culminate in the killing; the perpetrator could use the blindfold on the victim or on himself or herself. It is hypothesized that attacks on the victim’s face, particularly to blot out the eyes, may be a similar way of eliminating and controlling the shame that partially breaks through the perpetrator’s defenses against affect. Similarly, it has been thought that oral sex that is accompanied by blindfolding in connection with these killings suggests a stranger-perpetrated offense, which relieves the perpetrator from having to view the victim as a fellow human being. The blindfold would serve little purpose with someone who is already known. Use of weapons as part of the torture pattern may involve ritualistic aspects. If weapons are used, a serial killer usually selects one that requires personal contact between the killer and the victim because of a desire to touch or terrorize the victim or because the act may be degrading in terms of the method used, such as strangulation, blunt instruments, and so on. Finally, if a dismemberment takes place, it is seen along the continuum of adding power and control over a powerless victim who is simply carved into pieces or repeatedly stabbed. Similarly, bondage occurs in terms of keeping victims helpless or in a degrading position where they can be tortured or mutilated before their remains are disposed of. Torture and killing of political prisoners or those held
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
39
in captivity raise different questions that are unresolved. Differences in the individual personalities and group influences that operate in such situations differentiate who participates in such acts and who does not. Again, different possibilities exist with respect to the manner in which the bodies of victims are disposed of, reflecting different types of serial killers. It is thought that serial killers who dispose of the bodies of their victims so they are not likely to be discovered would more likely be in the category of a lust, thrill, or power-control type of killer. None of the serial killers appear to be concerned about the families of the victims in terms of how relatives must live with unresolved anxiety and anguish surrounding the disappearance of the bodies. Because victims are seen as nonentities by the perpetrators, it does not cognitively register for them to put themselves in the position of the families of the victims. For some types of serial killers, great care is taken in disposal of the body because that is when they could be most vulnerable to discovery. Thus some victims are buried on the perpetrators’ property to minimize the risk of discovery. Another phenomenon seen in some serial murderers after their apprehension is that they confess to far more murders than have actually been committed. The police may thus “solve” many unsolved cases in this manner. The dynamics of the individual who confesses to more serial killings than have actually occurred are interesting in that they touch on the murderer’s narcissism and grandiosity.
Characteristics of Serial Killers It is difficult with the limited knowledge available to capture exactly what the characteristics of a serial killer are. One problem is that descriptions of serial killings vary among experts. Many workers in the field describe a serial killing as when one or more individuals commit a second murder or a subsequent number in which the victim is “relationshipless” to the killer.64 Others take issue with this requirement, allowing that a relationship might exist between the serial killer and some of the victims. Examples given are those of a professional person in a relationship with a client or patient who subsequently kills him or her, or a landlord who has a series of tenants that are killed over a period of time. (The possibility of people in more intimate familial roles carrying out killings is discussed later [see “Familicide” section]; familicide involves a different conceptual basis than that in impersonal killings.) Most investigators feel that serial killings are not done for material gain but perhaps are associated with a desire to have power over the victims. Some killings may be carried out primarily for the sadistic grat-
40
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
ification from the act of killing itself. A subgroup are seen as a response to a pathological need for attention and sympathy. Other homicides seem to be connected to quasi-cult activities that are ritualistic and brutal, such as those perpetrated by Charles Manson and his gang of followers.65 Other descriptions, instead of focusing on the killer’s motive, stress that the killings may have symbolic value when carried out against victims who are perceived as being defenseless. Another theory is that the killings are the perpetrator’s way of alerting others to the victims’ plight; in essence, the victims are perceived as powerless and without status within their immediate surroundings (e.g., vagrants, migrant workers, children on the run, homosexual individuals, prostitutes, elderly women, captives). More specific documentation is needed to determine whether there is, in fact, a selectivity in terms of victim selection going on with different serial killers. Similarly, some serial killers see themselves as having a mission to rid the world of certain types of individuals. Although this borders close to the class of political killings, in which the killers are similarly motivated to eliminate a certain group of people, serial killers’ victims are chosen simply on the basis of their own cognitive convictions that it is their duty to rid the world of undesirables or a particular class. This motive would appear to be behind some of the killings in which prostitutes or homosexuals are selected as victims; friends of the perpetrator are often stunned to learn the identity of the perpetrator because he or she may come from an “upstanding background.” These types of killings also present some overlap with the new category of hate crimes. The group of “sadistic serial killers” who perpetrate erotized murders have their own characteristics, in which mutilation, torture, dismemberment, or other types of traumatic activity are often connected with the killing. Such killings are not all sexual murders in an overt sense, for a type of hedonistic pleasure can occur with some who perpetrate this type of killing. Some also become labeled cult killings. Neurotic conflict possibly underlies the actions in these cases. Whether having total power over a helpless victim always conveys some type of neurotic basis is not at present a position that can be confirmed or disconfirmed. A related question is whether the serial killer’s behavior tends to escalate (e.g., decreasing time between killings, escalating sadistic brutality in connection with the killings) or whether this escalation only occurs in a subgroup in contrast to serial killers whose behavior does not escalate. The escalation may reflect an increasing momentum and poorer controls, and it also increases the possibility for detection. In Godwin’s66 study of 107 serial killers and 728 victims, it was noted that
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
41
despite differences in social class, IQ, or education, those who remained undetected for prolonged periods of time were usually cunning and skillful at presenting themselves. Such cleverness placed them beyond suspicion and made them difficult to apprehend. In that sense, they were methodical and organized as they went about their business of killing.
Role of Fantasies The role of fantasized images and objects connected with victim selectivity has specific psychiatric significance. There has long been a belief that the serial killer seeks out some type of idealized victim to pursue. Although this may be so in their fantasies, the records from serial killers indicate that what goes on is a type of depersonalization process regarding the victims selected. In their compulsion to carry out a homicidal act, a more generalized object will often do. In fact, the nature of the process is such that the victim selected is not only depersonalized but viewed with some type of contempt or repugnance that seems to facilitate the violence being carried out. This degrading process of the victim was described by one serial killer as follows: “So, he mentally transforms them into hateful creatures, because, in the twisted morality of his own making, it is only against such that he can justifiably and joyfully inflict his manifestly hateful deeds of violence.”63 Determining the origins and vicissitudes of the fantasies to carry out acts of violence in the process of gaining control over victims is a worthy clinical topic in its own right. Some of these fantasies emerge in a nascent form in which they do not originally include the imagery of carrying out the homicidal act but evolve over time. Perhaps the fantasies are elaborations on certain actual experiences or are stimulated by “experiments” conceived in various types of movies or magazines. Some of this material may be integrated into actual sexual experiences or into masturbatory fantasies. A crucial shift occurs when the potential perpetrator begins to elaborate on these fantasies using actual people encountered, perhaps even rarely, in his or her daily life. Why, at a certain juncture, a small group of individuals begins to become discontented, if not anxious, about the frustrations of simply confining themselves to a fantasy level is a key question. At that point, the potential perpetrator plays out in his or her mind how the fantasized activity might actually be committed. This involves the distinct possibility that his or her control systems have become less effective. Once the potential perpetrator actually considers carrying out some type of violence against another human being, a crucial step has been
42
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
taken. At first victims become depersonalized and then are viewed with contempt or anger. This transition seems to be connected with a process in which the potential victims are seen as people who are frustrating the potential perpetrator by not being available for the perpetrator’s purposes when wanted. This defensive elaboration is crucial to the perpetrator’s being able to carry out the type of violence anticipated, for if he or she recognized the victim as simply being an innocent person who has actually done no harm or wrong whatsoever to the perpetrator, it would be difficult for the perpetrator to carry through with the act. There are also indications that when it comes to the final enactment of killings in this sense, the act is related to a sense of utter hopelessness and despair. To a clinician, this may signify the possibility that a severe degree of depression is related to the act of killing. Thus it would seem that the perpetrator puts fantasies into action at the point at which there is an onset of a major depression, if not the threat of suicide. It is in response to the anger and rage they feel that perpetrators contemplate the final “solution,” with the idea that things will be made better by acting out violent tendencies toward helpless victims—the actor survives at the expense of a person who is seen as being worthless and degraded. In that sense, the perpetrator’s self-esteem is temporarily reestablished without his or her experiencing any personal feelings. In light of these proposed dynamics, there is also a possible explanation for the type of sadistic and degrading acts perpetrated in some cases to prolong the victims’ suffering; such degradation allows perpetrators to view themselves as all-powerful and the others as existing solely for the purpose of allowing someone who is superior to use them in such a manner. Hence, all manner of subjugating and torturing a victim may be seen as acceptable. Once there is relief from a state of utter despair and isolation by way of torturing or sadistically using a victim, the victim can be killed and disposed of like any other type of disposable object, because the victim lacks any personal meaning.
Mass Killings A mass murderer as noted is one who kills three or four or more victims at one time as part of an ongoing killing event. It is distinguished from serial killings, which are seen as having a 30-day interval between killings. Many mass murderers may die at the scene as a predetermined part of the act or in a shoot-out with police. Infamous names occur in this regard, each of which would warrant an investigative study in his or her own right. A few examples follow (apart from the political terroristic killings such as the attacks of September 11, 2001).
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
43
• The worst mass killing in earlier times in the United States occurred in 1955 when an explosion on a passenger plane killed 44 people in California. It was later revealed that the son of one of the passengers on board the plane had planted a bomb to collect life insurance on his mother. • In 1966, Richard F. Speck sequentially murdered eight student nurses in their Chicago, IL, apartment. A ninth hid under a bed and was able to report the incident. • Also in 1966, Charles Whitman climbed a tower on the campus of the University of Texas and began shooting the people below. He killed 16 people and wounded 30. He was a former Eagle Scout, Marine, and engineering honor student. The day before he had killed his mother and wife. • In 1983, 13 businessmen and gambling dealers were shot in a Seattle, WA, gambling club. • In 1984, James Huberty entered a McDonald’s restaurant in San Ysidro, CA, shooting everyone in sight, with the result that 21 people were killed and 19 wounded. He was eventually killed by police sharpshooters. • Patrick Henry Sherrill, a mail carrier who was having trouble with his supervisors, opened fire in a crowded post office in Oklahoma in August 1986, killing 14 fellow workers and injuring 7 others before committing suicide. • In 1991, another disgruntled postal worker killed three coworkers and wounded six more in Michigan. • Another major mass murder in the United States occurred on October 19, 1991, when a single individual, George Hennard, entered a cafeteria in Killeen, TX, with two semiautomatic pistols and killed 22 customers and wounded 23 more. It is ironic that the next day, the U.S. House of Representatives voted 247 to 177 to defeat a bill that would have banned 13 types of assault weapons and the high-capacity ammunition clips that make these guns so lethal.67 • On April 19, 1995, the bombing of a federal building in Oklahoma City, OK, by Timothy McVeigh killed 167 people, for which he was found guilty and executed. A question is whether McVeigh’s type of political killing, along with the 3,000-some deaths on September 11, 2001, should be considered a mass killing—which it literally was. However, since the motives and classifications of terrorist killers seem to differ significantly from the above group, they are usually discussed separately.
44
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
Familicide A variation on mass murder is the killing of an entire family by one member. I call this familicide. This type of mass murder has a different type of psychodynamic and psychiatric significance, because it involves an individual killing his or her own family members or loved ones en masse versus killing anonymous people. This distinction is not often made, which blurs an attempt to understand the psychiatric differences in such overt acts.68
Medical Mass Murder Using prisoners for purposes of experimentation, based on certain political or racial beliefs, is referred to as a medical mass murder,69 such as was seen under the Nazis. A variation on this is the cases reported from medical institutions or nursing homes in which an individual supposedly carries out acts of kindness or mercy killing by “putting away” the elderly or those with some disability. These are not acts done in terms of revenge or overt anger but rather are seen by the perpetrators as altruistic acts. Sometimes the acts are carried out on those in the throes of a terminal disease, through overdoses of lethal drugs. This topic is discussed further in Chapter 7 (“Masochism and Homicide”).
Spree Killers In spree murders, a killer goes on a rampage. It is usually defined as three or more people being killed in a 30-day period. The events may all be a part of a contiguous series of killings in which the rampage simply incorporates the killing as part of it. An example would be a series of armed robberies in which the perpetrators shoot and kill various people as they drive away. Other killings may take place in this context in terms of stopping at various places along the way subsequent to some type of felony and killing at those locations as well, such as at gas stations, restaurants, and so on. There is usually a path of violence occurring over several days. For some the killing is part of a plan to go on such a rampage and to evade being caught. The homicides committed by Bonnie Parker and Clyde Barrow (“Bonnie and Clyde”) and by Charles Starkweather are some examples, as are the more recent sniper shootings by 18-year-old Lee Malvo and 42-year-old John Muhammad in the Virginia, Maryland, and Washington, DC, areas in 2002 that killed 10 people and wounded three.
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
45
Terroristic Mass Killings Terrorist killings are another form of mass killings. Such killings come in many packages and often reflect a political, religious, or social reform agenda. These killings do not follow the standard rules of countries at war, because the victims are usually innocent and only symbolic of what is seen as needing to be destroyed. If the terrorists themselves are killed, or suicide in the process, they view their deaths as necessary, if not honorable, in the service of a just cause. Although one side may view the acts as heroic, the other views them as despicable and acts of outright murder. There are innumerable examples of terrorist killings throughout history—more recently, the September 11, 2001, attacks in the United States. Some terrorist killings occur inside the domestic side of a country’s politics, whereas others are international in scope. The majority of studies of such acts have come from the perspective of political scientists, sociologists, or social psychologists, with some philosophers viewing the acts as manifestations of evil or depravity. In many cases, a disparate cultural and religious background needs to be considered. A deficiency of in-depth psychiatric knowledge exists about most terrorists who engage in such killings. The situation is one in which attempts are made to reconstruct the mental state of the perpetrators from disparate sources because there is rarely direct psychiatric material available. Jerrold Post70 is one of the few psychiatrists who have pursued the understanding of terrorists, which involves “assessing leaders at a distance.” The goal is to provide a type of conceptual framework to identify the adaptive style, cognitive functioning, attitudes, affect, and interpersonal predispositions of terrorists. Such profiles are then by necessity based on information and sources outside direct participatory psychiatric assessments. Because terrorism is rarely the act of a sole person, there must be some understanding of how membership in a particular group has evolved. Group membership taps diverse emotions of loyalty, dedication, rage, revenge, guilt, and the possibility of betrayal. In the 1990s, various incidents of domestic terrorism occurred in the United States before the September 11 attacks. One prominent example was the siege in Montana between the FBI and the antigovernment Freeman group. Another was the confrontation between the government and the Branch Davidian sect led by David Koresh in Texas.71 Koresh had changed his name from Vernon Wayne Howell to Koresh, which was the Hebrew name for Cyrus, the Persian king who allowed the Jews to return to Palestine. Through various machinations, Koresh took command of the Waco section of the Davidians and armed the
46
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
compound in preparation for the apocalypse, the final battle between the forces of good against evil. In that battle, the world would be consumed in flames, and Koresh would return as Christ; those who believed in him would find paradise in the New Jerusalem. At the compound, Koresh lived among a harem of young girls who believed he was Jesus Christ and whose duty was to serve him sexually. Married men offered up their wives and daughters to him. The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms and the FBI misread the situation as one of Koresh holding hostages rather than seeing them as committed believers. The result was a 51-day siege. The government viewed Koresh as a psychopath, whereas he seemed closer diagnostically to a borderline individual who was paranoid and delusional at times. The final attack by armored vehicles and tear gas led to a fire, with Koresh and 75 followers dying. The subsequent internationalist terrorist act of seizing domestic airplanes in flight to crash them into the World Trade Center and the Pentagon on September 11, 2001, by Muslim terrorists from al Qaeda eclipsed these earlier domestic events. Most studies of terrorist acts focus on such topics as why the acts occurred or how a particular organization was able to carry out the acts. Such events are followed by discussions and committees to investigate these matters and to assess the consequences of the acts on a society or political system. Unfortunately, any in-depth psychological analysis of the perpetrators is usually omitted. This omission may result from the minimal knowledge available about the perpetrators or from a lack of interest in that aspect of the killings in contrast to the big picture. Rosenfeld72 noted how qualitatively different such acts of terrorist killings are from other kinds of homicidal violence that criminologists study. Terrorist killings do not jibe easily with customary theories of violence such as social control theory or a life-course approach. Hypotheses about terrorism and terrorists are often not testable. Rather, they reflect partial analyses of extremist actions from the political left or right. The difficulty in explaining terrorist acts that result in multiple deaths has been put in terms of explanations lacking a logical comparability and a specification of how the variables relate to each other. There is an absence of knowing how to rank the variables in terms of their explanatory power.73 An explanatory model would have to address what encourages or inhibits individuals in participating in such actions, because the great majority of people in a given social milieu do not join such organizations or engage in terrorist acts and have no desire to do so. The similarity of the mind-set of terrorists to that of certain extremist religious sects has often been observed and has been referred to as killing
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
47
in the name of God, Jehovah, or Allah. Part of this occurs through a progressive isolation from others, accompanied by a professed loyalty and a commitment to a cause that may involve people getting killed. The missionary aspect to convert others to the cause reinforces the terrorists’ own beliefs. According to Stern,74 only two characteristics are crucial for distinguishing terrorist violence from other kinds of violence: the acts are aimed at noncombatants, and there is a dramatic quality to instill fear or dread. Often a sensed need for vengeance is used as the justification for innocent people being killed. In turn, the belief is that the perpetrators are acting virtuously in a just cause and that their own deaths will be avenged by their compatriots. This contributes to less hesitancy in participating in acts of mass killing. When some of the group die in the terroristic acts, the remaining members of the group draw closer, which may allow taking even greater risks. Survivor guilt may make them prone to take more risks to relieve the guilt they are experiencing. Possibly, terrorist killers have a paranoid mind-set that can vary from suspiciousness to psychotic delusional thinking. Post70 described the paranoid worldview of political mass murderers such as Hitler and Stalin as well as Ayatollah Khomeini, who mobilized paranoid rage against the “Great Satan” of the United States. The traits in paranoid personalities easily accommodate to the political world because paranoid themes are the leitmotifs in political life. Being suspicious about others who may be seen as not being honest, questioning the loyalty of supporters, constantly being vigilant about information that can be used against them, reading covert meanings in what is said about events, holding grudges, and interpreting comments as attacks that require action and vengeance are part and parcel of the political milieu. Distrusting others and seeing them as hostile while denying these traits in oneself sets the stage for taking homicidal action against one’s enemies in groups committed to violence. More specifically, it would seem that political terrorists are drawn to killing because of a psychological mind-set. The appeal of terrorism is that it allows the perpetrators to commit acts of violence and then rationalize them.75 Their logic is based on a splitting of “us versus them” without any middle ground. Others are seen as the source of evil and harm and the source of their problems; as such, they must be destroyed. There is not only a sense of rage at the “other” but also a logical conclusion that destroying these others is a desirable, if not a necessary and moral, imperative. However, the conclusion is that major psychopathology does not usually exist in the terrorists. Rather, there is a reliance on mechanisms of splitting and externalization as found in borderline and narcissistic individuals to a high degree.
48
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
WHY HAVE HOMICIDE RATES FALLEN? Historically up until 1965, the homicide rate in the United States was less than 5 per 100,000 population. Over the next 20 years, it increased to a range of 8–10 per 100,000. The homicide rate then declined for a few years, but from 1985 it climbed precipitously, led by juveniles and young adults. This increase was often attributed to the crack epidemic and violence associated with drug distribution. Some of the demographic variables believed to be associated with the increase have been discussed. In the latter part of the 1990s, the rates began to drop to levels between 5.0 and 6.0 in all regions of the United States, with some exceptions in the West. The debate is why this drop occurred. Note that this homicide rate is still far above the rates in most European countries, where the rate has fluctuated between 1.0 and 2.0.44 Theories to explain the drop abound, and they illustrate the diverse influences that have operated.76 Frequently mentioned is the aging population of baby boomers that reached middle age and were beyond the most violence-prone years. The changing scene in many major American cities has also been noted, such as the decrease in barroom killings that were more prevalent in factory towns, especially on payday. The culture of bars itself changed, with more affluent people and females being present. Bar owners always had the power to regulate patrons who drank to excess, but law enforcement began to tighten. Police departments in large cities claimed a major role in lowering the homicide rate because of their more aggressive and imaginative policing. Their approaches varied from the redeployment of police officers to confronting groups of young males loitering about street corners. This approach has sometimes involved community policing, in which a closer relationship between police officers and their precinct populations is fostered. This viewpoint has been criticized for ignoring the effects of increased rates of incarceration.77 Tripling the nation’s prison and jail populations to over 2 million by 2005 is another argument offered on why homicide rates were lowered. The idea is that if people are taken off the streets who might subsequently have committed a murder because of their criminal propensities, the homicide rate will be lowered. By 2004, 10% of all inmates in state and federal prisons were serving life sentences, which cost states about $1 million per inmate serving out the term.78 New gun-control statutes in some jurisdictions may have played some role in reducing homicides, although a countertendency in some states was to pass concealed-gun legislation that could work in the opposite direction.
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
49
The waning of the crack cocaine epidemic also has been seen as lowering the homicide rate because of the lessened effect on individual users and the reduced drug market, in which young dealers were often armed with semiautomatic weapons. Selling the drug may have seemed like an easy way to make a lot of money, but the ravages of crack became more visible in time. However, in some areas of the country, methamphetamine use has increased among the younger population, along with Ecstasy, to take its place. A factor that has been ignored until recently as contributing to the decline in homicide rates is the improvement in medical care. This may be an offspring of bringing techniques from the battlefield to American cities. Trauma centers and the use of 911 telephone lines or cellular phones are combined with helicopters to evacuate the wounded to a medical facility, much like under combat conditions. A deceiving element lurks in this phenomenon: the number of shootings per se may not be decreasing, but rather, more people are surviving after a shooting. In fact, the number of cases of aggravated assault has not decreased dramatically but remained rather stable. An ingenious and controversial economic theory to explain the decline in homicide rates that occurred by the end of the 1990s has been offered on the basis of the legalization of abortion.79 The explanation offered is that in 1973 the U.S. Supreme Court legalized abortion in Roe v. Wade, whereas abortion had only been available in five states until then. The result was a dramatic increase in abortion numbers from 750,000 to 1.6 million by 1980. The idea is that very often these women were unmarried, adolescents, or poor, in which case the children would have been in a group with the highest potential rates for criminal activity. Thus, in the 1990s the groups that were aborted would have been in their late teens when the rates began to drop. It was noted that the crime rate started falling earlier in the five states that already had legalized abortion and that thereafter the states with the highest abortion rates saw the biggest drop in crime, with other factors being controlled. Lowering of domestic killings needs to be noted as another factor in lowering homicide rates. Society became less tolerant of domestic violence, and many states required police to make an arrest if there was any evidence of physical harm to either party. The Bureau of Justice Statistics data show that since 1976 the number of men murdered by intimates (spouses, ex-spouses, boyfriends and girlfriends) dropped by 68%. The number of women killed by intimates was stalled for two decades but then declined after 1993–1995 and has remained stable into the twenty-first century.
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
50
It would be unduly optimistic to think that all these variables will remain constant and that no new factors will arise related to homicidal behavior. Any shift in the variables mentioned can upset the recent decline as well. The cyclic nature of homicides over time is what has seemed most consistent in the long run.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
10. 11. 12. 13. 14.
15. 16.
17.
Holinger PC: Violent Deaths in the United States. New York, Guilford, 1987 Reiss A Jr, Roth JA: Understanding and Preventing Violence. Washington, DC, National Academy Press, 1993 U.S. Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation: Uniform Crime Reports. Washington, DC, U.S. Government Printing Office, 1991 U.S. Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation: Uniform Crime Reports. Washington, DC, U.S. Government Printing Office, 2004 Fox JA, Levin J, Quinet KD: The Will to Kill, 2nd Edition. Boston, MA, Allyn & Bacon, 2005 Tardiff K, Marzuk PM, Leon AC, et al: Homicide in New York City. JAMA 272:43–46, 1994 Wolfgang ME: Patterns in Criminal Homicide. Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania Press, 1958 Hewitt JD: The victim–offender relationship in convicted homicide cases: 1960–1984. J Crim Justice 16:25–33, 1988 Eisner M: Long-term historical trends in violent crime, in Crime and Justice: A Review of Research, Vol 30. Edited by Tonry M. Chicago, IL, University of Chicago Press, 2003, pp 83–142 Kellermann AL, Mercy JA: Men, women, and murder: gender-specific differences in rates of fatal violence and victimization. J Trauma 33:1–5, 1992 Bartol CR: Criminal Behavior: A Psychosocial Approach, 7th Edition. Upper Saddle River, NJ, Prentice Hall, 2005 Laudanu SF, Drapkin E, Arad S: Homicide victims and offenders: an Israeli study. J Crim Law Criminol 65:390–396, 1974 U.S. Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation: Uniform Crime Reports. Washington, DC, U.S. Government Printing Office, 2004 Cook PJ: The technology of personal violence, in Crime and Justice: A Review of Research, Vol 14. Edited by Tonry M. Chicago, IL, University of Chicago Press, 1991, pp 1–77 Saltzman LE, Mercy JA, O’Carroll PW, et al: Weapon involvement and injury outcomes in family and intimate assaults. JAMA 267:3043–3047, 1992 Fox JA, Zawitz M: Homicide Trends in the United States. Washington, DC, Bureau of Justice Statistics, 2004. Available at: http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/ bjs/homicide/homtrnd.htm. Accessed April 28, 2005. Miethe TD, Regoeczi WC, Drass KA, et al (eds): Rethinking Homicide: Exploring the Structure and Process Underlying Deadly Situations. New York, Cambridge University Press, 2004
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
51
18. Luckenbill DF: Homicide as a situated transaction. Soc Probl 25:176–186, 1977 19. Rosenfeld R, Bray TM, Egley A: Facilitating violence: a comparison of gang-motivated, gang-affiliated, and nongang youth homicides. Journal of Quantitative Criminology 15:495–516, 1999 20. Lipsey MW, Derzon JH: Predictors of violent or serious delinquency in adolescence and early adulthood, in Serious and Violent Juvenile Offenders. Edited by Loeber R, Farrington DP. Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage, 1998, pp 86–105 21. Holcomb WR, Anderson WP: Alcohol and multiple drug abuse in accused murderers. Psychol Rep 52:159–164, 1983 22. Mayfield D: Alcoholism, alcohol intoxication and assaultive behavior. Dis Nerv Syst 37:288–291, 1976 23. Greenberg DF: Methodological issues in survey research on the inhibition of crime. J Crim Law Criminol 72:1094–1108, 1981 24. Cole KE, Fisher G, Cole SS: Women who kill. Arch Gen Psychiatry 19:1–8, 1968 25. Van Hasselt VB, Hersen M: Aggression and Violence: An Introductory Text. Boston, MA, Allyn & Bacon, 2000 26. Roizen J: Epidemiological issues in alcohol-related violence, in Recent Developments in Alcoholism. Edited by Galanter M. New York, Plenum, 1997, pp 7–40 27. Welte JW, Abel EL: Homicide: drinking by the victim. J Stud Alcohol 50:197–201, 1989 28. Lang AR, Goeckner DJ, Adesso VJ, et al: Effects of alcohol on aggression in male social drinkers. J Abnorm Psychol 84:508–518, 1975 29. Gillies H: Murder in the west of Scotland. Br J Psychiatry 111:1087–1094, 1965 30. Derville P, L’Epee P, Lazarin HJ, et al: Statistical indications of a possible relationship between alcoholism and criminality: an inquiry into the Bordeaux region. Revue Alcoholisme 7:20–21, 1961 31. Levi M, Maguire M: Violent crime, in The Oxford Handbook of Criminology, 3rd Edition. Edited by Maguire M, Morgan R, Reiner R. New York, Oxford University Press, 2002, pp 795–843 32. Cloninger CR, Siguardsson S, Gilligan SB, et al: Genetic heterogeneity and the classification of alcoholism, in Alcohol Research From Bench to Bedside. Edited by Gordis E, Tabakoff B, Linnoila M. Binghamton, NY, Hayworth, 1989, pp 3–16 33. Sher KJ, Grekin ER, Williams NA: The development of alcohol use disorders, in Annual Review of Clinical Psychology. Edited by Nolen-Hoeksema S, Cannon TD, Widiger T. Palo Alto, CA, Annual Reviews, 2005, pp 493–523 34. U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services: Alcohol and Health: Eighth Special Report to the U.S. Congress. Rockville, MD, National Institute of Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, U.S. Government Printing Office, 1993 35. Wilsnack RW: Antecedents and consequences of drinking and drinking problems in women: patterns from a U.S. national survey, in Alcohol and Addictive Behavior: Nebraska Symposium on Motivation, 1986. Edited by Clayton P. Lincoln, University of Nebraska Press, 1987, pp 85–158
52
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
36. Scott CL, Resnick PJ: Assessing risk of violence in psychiatric patients. Psychiatric Times 19:1–16, 2002 37. Pernanen K: Alcohol in Human Violence. New York, Guilford, 1991 38. MacAndrew C, Edgerton RB: Drunken Comportment. Chicago, IL, Aldine, 1969 39. Hanzlick R, Gowitt GT: Cocaine metabolite detection in homicide victims. JAMA 265:760–761, 1991 40. Hagan FE: Introduction to Criminology: Theories, Methods, and Criminal Behavior, 5th Edition. Belmont, CA, Wadsworth/Thomson Learning, 2002 41. Shakespeare W: Othello, in The Complete Signet Classic Shakespeare. Edited by Barnet S. New York, Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1972 42. Lieber AL: The Lunar Effect. Garden City, NJ, Anchor Doubleday, 1978 43. Interpol: International Crime Statistics. London, Home Office Press, 2003 44. Barclay G, Tavares C: International Comparisons of Criminal Justice Statistics 2001. London, Home Office Press, 2003 45. D’Emilio J, Freedman EB: Intimate Matters: A History of Sexuality in America. New York, Harper & Row, 1988 46. Maxfield MG: Lifestyles and routine activity theories of crime: empirical studies of victimization, delinquency, and offender decision-making. Journal of Quantitative Criminology 3:275–281, 1987 47. Hindelang MJ, Gottfredson MR, Garofalo J: Victims of Personal Crime: An Empirical Foundation for a Theory of Personal Victimization. Cambridge, MA, Ballinger, 1978 48. Cohen LE, Felson M: Social change and crime rate trends: a routine activities approach. Am Sociol Rev 44:588–608, 1979 49. Carroll L, Jackson PI: Inequality, opportunity, and crime rates in central cities. Criminology 21:178–194, 1983 50. Agnew R: Juvenile Delinquency: Causes and Control. Los Angeles, CA, Roxbury Publishing, 2005 51. Messner SF, Tardiff K: The social ecology of urban homicide: an application of the routine activities approach. Criminology 23:241–267, 1985 52. Merton R: Social structure and anomie. Am Sociol Rev 3:672–682, 1938 53. Perlis RH, Fraguas R, Fava M, et al: Prevalence and clinical correlates of irritability in major depressive disorder: a preliminary report from the Sequenced Treatment Alternatives to Relieve Depression study. J Clin Psychiatry 66:159–166, 2005 54. Agnew RS: Why Do Criminals Offend? Los Angeles, CA, Roxbury Publishing, 2005 55. Sternberg RJ: The Psychology of Hate. Washington, DC, American Psychological Association, 2005 56. Matza D: Delinquency and Drift. New York, Wiley, 1961 57. Binder G: The origins of American felony murder rules. Stanford Law Rev 57:59–208, 2004 58. Dietz ML: Killing for Profit: The Social Organization of Felony Homicide. Chicago, IL, Nelson-Hall, 1983
Epidemiological Aspects of Homicide
53
59. Hickey EW: Serial Murderers and Their Victims. Belmont, CA, Wadsworth/Thomson Learning, 2002 60. Johnston T: A little house of horrors: murder in Philadelphia. Newsweek, April 6, 1987, pp 27–28 61. Fox JA, Levin J: Extreme Killing/Understanding Serial and Mass Murder. Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage, 2005 62. Alvarez A, Bachman R: Murder American Style. Belmont, CA, Wadsworth/Thomson Learning, 2003 63. Holmes RM, Holmes ST: Murder in America, 2nd Edition. Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage, 2001 64. Egger S: Serial Murder: An Elusive Phenomenon. New York, Praeger, 1990 65. Fox JA, Levin J, Quinet KD: The Will to Kill, 2nd Edition. Boston, MA, Allyn & Bacon, 2005 66. Godwin GM: Hunting Serial Predators: A Multivariate Classification Approach to Profiling Violent Behavior. Boca Raton, FL, CRC Press, 1999 67. Rutherford A: Crime, Law Enforcement, and Penology. Chicago, IL, Britannica Book of the Year, 1992 68. Malmquist CP: Psychiatric aspects of familicide. Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law 8:298–304, 1980 69. Proctor RN: Racial Hygiene Under the Nazis. Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press, 1988 70. Post JM: Assessing leaders at a distance: the political personality profile, in The Psychological Assessment of Political Leaders. Edited by Post JM. Ann Arbor, University of Michigan Press, 2003, pp 69–104 71. Robins RS, Post JM: Political Paranoia/The Psychopolitics of Hatred. New Haven, CT, Yale University Press, 1997 72. Rosenfeld R: Why criminologists should study terrorism. The Criminologist 27:3–4, 2002 73. Crenshaw M: The causes of terrorism, in Violence: A Reader. Edited by Besteman C. New York, New York University Press, 2002, pp 99–117 74. Stern J: Terror in the Name of God: Why Religious Militants Kill. New York, HarperCollins, 2003 75. Post JM: Leaders and Their Followers in a Dangerous World. Ithaca, NY, Cornell University Press, 2004 76. Blumstein A: Disaggregating the violence trends, in The Crime Drop in America. Edited by Blumstein A, Wallman J. New York, Cambridge University Press, 2000, pp 13–44 77. Conklin JE: Why Crime Rates Fell. Boston, MA, Allyn & Bacon, 2003. 78. Butterfield F: Almost 10% of all prisoners are now serving life terms. New York Times, May 12, 2004, p A15 79. Levitt SD, Dubner SJ: Freakonomics: A Rogue Economist Explores the Hidden Side of Everything. New York, William Morrow, 2005
This page intentionally left blank
CHAPTER
2 BIOLOGICAL FACTORS IN HOMICIDE DILEMMAS IN THE BIOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVES ON HOMICIDE A discussion of homicidal violence cannot proceed without first assessing the biology of such extreme aggressive behaviors. The meaning of aggression itself is controversial because some writers confuse it with competitiveness and assertiveness. One approach is to use the term aggression only for behavior that has a component of intended harm. It can be viewed as premeditated, defensive, or impulsive. Another classification distinguishes whether the acts are affective or instrumental in nature. This delineation permits an inquiry into the basis of aggressive behavior and the potential for harm. Although general and developmental psychologists have stressed such factors as the role of frustration and social learning in aggression, the search for the biological source of such behavior has often been given short shrift. Several key questions are relevant when considering biological aspects of aggression related to a homicidal outcome: 1. Is there a common biological substratum for acts of homicidal violence? If so, is homicide just one point, often reached by chance, along a continuum of violent expressions? 2. What is the extent of the current knowledge about the neurophysiological aspects of aggression and how these aspects are related to homicide? 3. How relevant—and how analogous—are the studies of nonhuman aggression and violence to the study of human homicidal behavior? 4. Are there any major limitations to the conclusions that have been drawn about human beings killing one another from naturalistic settings as well as from the artificiality of laboratory settings? Some initial caveats should be stated about the definitions and models of aggression that are used in experiments with nonhuman subjects, be-
55
56
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
cause such models might be quite different from those applied to humans in a separate milieu. In addition, it is oversimplistic to view nonhuman subjects’ behavior as being programmed in a certain way based solely on genetic underpinnings; sophisticated behavioral geneticists do not espouse such a reductionistic view. Instead, many environmental factors impinge on the behavior of both humans and nonhuman subjects, including their diverse types of social interactions with each other. There is also the role of ritualized and posturing behavior that animals engage in to different degrees. All these considerations need to be factored in before any implications about humans and homicidal violence can be drawn from animal studies. Beyond these asides, in this chapter I do not focus on nonhuman animal displays of aggression or violence in discussing the problem of humans killing. It is commonly believed that biological factors operate in human beings in a dispositional manner—that is, these biological factors are predisposing factors that are seen as being necessary but not always sufficient for a violent outcome of homicidal proportions to occur. As such, these dispositional tendencies stand ready to trigger violent acts framed by environmental events. However, it must be noted that biological fluctuations within individuals can also heighten or lessen the potential for such behavior to be triggered at different times.
EARLY THEORIES OF THE SOURCE OF AGGRESSION Instinctual and Behavioral Theories The search for an instinctual basis for aggression has an uneven history. In the early twentieth century, McDougall1 postulated that humans possess a host of instincts that operate for acquisition, construction, gregariousness, flight, repulsion, curiosity, pugnaciousness, parenting, reproduction, desire for food, self-abasement, and self-assertion. Eventually, however, the theories of behaviorism became the reigning school of psychology in the United States through the 1950s. Believing that scientific validity could be proven only by observable events, behaviorists found McDougall’s unprovable theory about an inner set of processes driving behavior unacceptable and replaced it with a drive theory based on external observable behavior, without reference to the inner state of a person. The emphasis on behavior as being primarily learned dominated psychological thinking at the time; it was felt that the idea of behavior being unlearned and inborn was not testable and as such was therefore not a legitimate part of the contemporary scientific domain. Environmental contributions were seen as always controlling behavior, beyond some basic motor patterns for reflexes.
Biological Factors in Homicide
57
Psychoanalytic Theories Psychoanalysts have formulated general theories on the concept of instinct, focusing on questions such as the number and nature of the instincts, how they should be classified (e.g., energic aspects, libido theory), how they function, and how they could be transformed (e.g., instinctual vicissitudes). A special theory of instincts referred to how instincts develop in any one particular person. Throughout the twentieth century, these theories shifted. Underlying the various theories was the idea that some built-in source for behavior was distinct from the aim of the instincts or the objects on which they were played out. Originally, instincts were divided into the sexual and ego instincts. Freud later ascribed aggressive trends to the ego instincts.2 With the addition of structural theory, aggressivity was no longer regarded as primarily attributed to the ego instincts. Rather, aggression and destruction were postulated as being independent instincts alongside the sexual instincts. It is beyond the scope of this chapter to go into Freud’s speculations about a death instinct based on his need to explain how some behavior was not regulated by the pleasure principle but rather operated under the sway of a repetition compulsion.
Ethological Theories In an entirely different arena of knowledge, European zoologists were laying the groundwork for studying instincts by way of ethology. Their methodology was to investigate animal behavior within animals’ naturalistic settings. From studies of lower animals, it had become difficult to explain how all behavior operated simply on the basis of being learned. This is not to say that such behavior was immune from environmental influences, but rather that the genetic endowment of the animal was seen as interacting with the environment. The ethologists’ reasoning was that instinctive behavior was genetically programmed and therefore related to inheritable characteristics. Rather than referring to instincts, ethologists referred to innate behaviors that were specific to a given species. At times, confusion has resulted from the misrepresentation of the position that the phrase “inherited behavior” simply means that a group of genes can explain all behavior. This reductionistic view of genetic endowment as an explanation of how aggression unfolds—up through acts of killing—omits too many key variables. Rather, the interaction of both genetic factors (the dispositional component) and environmental factors (the precipitating component) is needed for reaching the potentiality of a homicide.
58
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
Much of Lorenz’s3 and Tinbergen’s4 early work, which involved concepts such as a “sign stimulus” and “fixed-action patterns,” has been elaborated on by other investigators. More current research has shown that complex, inborn behavioral patterns are activated by certain environmental stimuli that thereby function as releasers. Different species have different repertoires of fixed-action patterns. In lower species, behavior is released by stimulation of certain command neurons, whereas in mammals it is thought that groups of cells may trigger preprogrammed motor acts. Command systems in turn may be responsive to certain sensory elicitors by innate releasing mechanisms. Although most of the studies of these concepts have not been based on work with human subjects, let alone even mammals, they have provided a framework for thinking about the biological contributions to aggression in its diverse forms. Seeing the influence of genes on behavior sparked the transition from a behavioristic model to one that incorporates an impetus from within the organism. If behavior is regulated by neural circuits, then diverse proteins are required for the development of these circuits. The proteins are coded specifically by genes. Different genes may play a role, with some individual genes becoming more important than others. In essence, the genes are the key to producing the neural circuitry and also to regulating behavior. Genes code the structural proteins necessary to maintain the circuitry as well as the enzymes necessary for synaptic transmission. Genes are also seen as coding peptide hormones and modulations that can trigger or inhibit the discharge of behavior. (Peptides are neurotransmitters that affect specific neurons; these are discussed later in this chapter’s section “Role of Neurotransmitters.”) The complex question of what role innate factors play in determining human behavior remains. The genetic studies that have been done on humans have not found a definitive association among impulsivity, aggression, and reduced serotonin behavior, although rats can be bred for aggressive behavior.5 However, besides studies on the hormonal determinants of gender identity, five lines of evidence are presented in support of how some human behaviors reflect innate factors:6 1. Human behavior, like that in other species, is mediated by genes. Consequently, to some extent, it is under genetic control. 2. Certain emotional expressions are seen as having a strong innate component that cuts across different cultural settings. An example would be that of facial expressions in infants or adults, regardless of those individuals’ home culture. 3. Stereotyped motor patterns exist that resemble fixed-action patterns.
Biological Factors in Homicide
59
4. Certain complex patterns appear to require little or no learning. This is witnessed in humans who have had limited experiences of the environment or in the responses of blind infants who have not had any visual environmental input. 5. The development of language in humans, once viewed as simply learned, is believed to have a major biological predisposition. Children in diverse parts of the world seem to display similar linguistic achievements at the same age. Linguistic universals suggest that language acquisition is biologically programmed. It develops based on the child’s biological predisposition, along with cognitive development and the linguistic environment. In the remainder of the chapter, I focus on the biological—including genetic—factors that influence human aggression.
GENES AND VIOLENCE IN HUMANS Genetic factors are being investigated for their role in diverse kinds of human behavior that have an influence on how aggression may be expressed. One difficulty in such work is separating the role of genetic influences from that of environmental influences. Much of the genetic work in humans stems from the field of molecular genetics, in which techniques are used to localize, characterize, and clone genes believed to be associated with inherited diseases. By use of an oversimplified model, the steps used by molecular geneticists are as follows: First, they locate a precise gene that can determine a genotype (i.e., the genetic constitution of an individual or group). Then they determine the products of a specific defective gene (e.g., alterations of some biochemical product) to reveal the biological mechanisms involved. The hope is that through this process, the underlying pathophysiology of a certain disorder or condition will become clearer and assist investigators in reaching more valid clinical diagnoses. Genes for certain neuropsychiatric disorders (e.g., Huntington’s disease) and certain metabolic diseases are typically cited as evidence for inherited diseases. It is hoped that these DNA methods can be extended to the study of mental illnesses and therefore yield a better understanding of the violent propensities that may accompany some of these illnesses. Traditional approaches to studying genetic transmission have focused on the incidence and prevalence of disorders in families, twins, and adopted children, with the goal of separating genetic from environmental influences to the extent possible. Focusing on the similarities and differ-
60
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
ences in groups that have a similar genetic makeup, this traditional model has been extended beyond the search for causes of mental disorders to a search for those genes that simply express inherited traits. For example, if studies of monozygotic twins with certain traits who were separated at birth were later to reveal that both twins had an increased potential for violence in adulthood, perhaps even something as specific as homicidal violence, questions could be raised about the possibility of genetic influences on violent behavior. In the same vein, if one dizygotic twin separated at birth showed a comparatively lesser incidence of such behavior than the matching dizygotic twin, the same possibility would exist. Studies of chromosomal abnormalities, such as the “supermale” XYY, were another approach, studying whether the extra Y chromosome would be related to increased violence, such as seen in Richard Speck. Speck murdered eight nurses and was an XYY male; however, studies using random populations have failed to confirm the XYY–violence hypothesis.7 Family studies are the weakest line of evidence for genetic transmission because of the obvious loading of similar environmental variables in family rearing patterns. Unfortunately, they are the most prevalent model used for studies of mental disorders. For example, different studies on twins and adopted siblings point to genetic factors having some role in schizophrenia and certain mood disorders. In this connection, using adoption studies, investigators look not only at the mood instabilities present in those with an affective disorder but also at these individuals’ violence potential in comparative studies. As another example, attempts might be made to connect the hereditary components in alcoholism with mood instabilities and to go beyond that into the summative disposition to violence. Research with monozygotic twins indicates a hereditary aspect to aggressive behavior because concordance rates for monozygotic twins were greater than for dizygotic twins.8 Twin studies suggest antisocial behavior in adults may be more related to genetics than to environment. The complexities of investigating genetic components are increasing. For many diagnoses or conditions, researchers are still generating hypotheses, such as a single gene locus versus a multifactorial model involving polygenes in which environmental influences operate. At a molecular level, hypotheses involve the role of neurotransmitter enzymes and metabolites and how they can affect neurophysiological functioning. Even for diagnosable mental disorders or biological traits, such as schizophrenia or mood disorders, the results remain inconclusive. This ambiguity is even greater with traits related to violent behavior. The statistical models do not fit the data to the exclusion of other hypotheses.9 The missing link would be data to show the coinheritance of an illness and a biological trait.
Biological Factors in Homicide
61
In studies of genetic aspects of mental disorders and related traits, the current emphasis is on markers or genetic variations, with the goal being to localize genes. The hope is that molecular techniques can bridge the distance between a marker and a gene by identifying additional markers. Such work forms the basis for reports of linkage between diagnoses of bipolar affective disorder and genetic markers on the X chromosome, which suggests one form of a genetic bipolar illness. The complexities of the approach reveal obscure inheritance patterns and the fluid boundaries existing for many diagnoses. The increasing amount of genetic knowledge about mental disorders raises diverse problems, particularly in the areas of social control and criminal responsibility.10 Questions of determinism and responsibility have been argued endlessly in philosophy. Genetic information may make the public more skeptical of the degrees of freedom an individual has in homicidal behavior. Attempts to use a “genetic defense” in homicide cases may well increase, albeit the legal system may insist that the legal rules do not change for responsibility and punishment, regardless of scientific knowledge. Although there is now increasing knowledge from the twin and family studies about a genetic component in major mental disorders, such as schizophrenia and bipolar disorder, and perhaps in antisocial personality disorder as well, debate continues on how genetic influences operate with respect to violence. Epidemiological studies may suggest an increased incidence of violence compared with a control group of those without a mental disability, but the majority of persons with mental disorders still do not commit acts of serious violence. Research also does not allow us to make such predictions based on an increased predisposition. The difference ultimately may lie in whether juries believe there is now hard scientific evidence that in the absence of a genetic vulnerability, the violence would likely not have occurred. However, this perception of evidence may simply produce arguments that genetic predispositions simply make it more difficult to control one’s impulses, a similar view taken for those persons coming from an adverse social environment. Even if cognitive functioning is adversely affected, it may not affect legal responsibility. The U.S. Supreme Court upheld a statute in a Montana case, in which the jury was instructed that it could not consider an intoxicated condition “in determining the existence of a mental state which is an element of the offense.”11 The failed effort of the defense attempted to show evidence of intoxication negating “purpose” or “knowledge” of the homicide. In an earlier case, the XYY chromosome abnormality was tried as a legal defense, in which it was argued that the abnormality in-
62
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
creased the disposition toward violence. The ruling held that the genetic imbalance must “interfere substantially with the defendant’s cognitive capacity or his ability to understand the basic moral code of his society.”12 Genetic vulnerability is thus handled legally analogous to people who have sustained environmental insults and who thus are more prone to violence—such as persons exposed to serious abuse as children when there was no capacity to influence their damaging childhood; such individuals are held to the same standard of responsibility as other adults. Of course, genetic, as well as environmental, factors may play a role at the sentencing stage after responsibility is established.
PHYSIOLOGICAL HYPOTHESES OF VIOLENCE Because genetic theories of violence currently operate primarily at the hypothesis stage, physiology is often suggested as a more concrete explanation for aggression that can lead to the extreme of killing.
Seizures Work with clinical populations in cases involving seizure disorders when a subgroup has been violent suggests one area for exploration. Early researchers speculated about the possibility of violent eruptions occurring in connection with temporal lobe seizures, positing some type of brain abnormality on an anatomical or physiological level. In the modern era, the search has turned to work on brain functioning for an explanation. In the 1970s, some investigators studying a form of seizure now called complex partial seizures (also called temporal lobe, limbic, or psychomotor seizures) began to advocate the use of neurosurgical techniques to try to control such seizure activity.13 The inference was that if the seizures could be controlled, then associated sequelae of the seizures, such as violence, could also be controlled. However, surgical interventions of this type could not be carried out on large numbers of people without eliciting a large public outcry. Something inherent in the performance of surgical procedures on the brain for the purpose of altering behavior arouses both public and professional anxiety. Part of this concern is associated with the fact that psychosurgery procedures on mentally ill individuals were less well regulated in the past. People also fear that permitting surgery of this type would allow future abuse of the procedure in attempts to control people by overdiagnosing com-
Biological Factors in Homicide
63
plex partial seizures in those prone to violence. The difficulty in diagnosing such seizures because of unclear boundaries in the diagnosis also elicits fears that such a technique could be misused. That neurologists have been able to delineate diverse types of seizures, each of which might have different correlates for different types of violence—perhaps including homicidal violence—raises many potential diagnostic problems but also has implications for assessing violent individuals’ behavior. In Table 2–1, the diverse types of seizures and their characteristics are represented, such as whether they are generalized or partial, differences connected with age at onset, if they are primary or secondary, and the diverse settings in which they can occur. Generalized seizures are those that begin bilaterally; partial seizures have a localized onset, although they may evolve into generalized seizures of the partial complex type (here partial refers to consciousness being retained and complex to an impairment in consciousness). The potential for ambiguity in distinguishing violence due to seizures from associated psychiatric phenomena is evident, and this is magnified when there are legal issues.
Attempts to Link Temporal Lobe Seizures With Violence Early theorizing about temporal lobe seizures was partially correct in that the electrical discharges for these seizures have been found to originate in deep, medially placed limbic nuclei in the temporal lobe, consisting of the amygdala, uncus, and hippocampus. However, the limbic system is not all located in the temporal lobe, and other areas of the brain also affect emotion. It is interesting that some view the limbic system more as a philosophical concept than an actual discrete anatomical or physiological system.14 The epidemiological question of whether people with temporal lobe seizure disorders actually have an increased tendency toward violent behavior has not been satisfactorily resolved. Many times such a link has been implied in best-selling books or movies, such as Michael Crichton’s novel The Terminal Man, in which seizures spark brutal rampages.15 However, authors of more recent studies did not find extreme violence occurring more frequently in the course of complex seizures.16,17 The difficulty is in the reflexive acts, which do not have an intentional component, and are a set of behaviors carried out without any particular goal or purpose in mind. To further complicate the matter, some neurologists have posited that people with temporal lobe seizures may develop behavioral changes involving excess aggression, religiosity, changes in sexual behavior, and a preoccupation with writing or drawing (which some also think promotes creativity).
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
64 TABLE 2–1.
Classification of epileptic seizures
Generalized seizures (bilaterally symmetrical and without local onset) Tonic, clonic, or tonic-clonic (grand mal) Absence (petit mal) Simple—loss of consciousness only Complex—with brief tonic, clonic, or automatic movements Lennox-Gastaut syndrome Juvenile myoclonic epilepsy Infantile spasms (West syndrome) Atonic (astatic, akinetic) seizures (sometimes with myoclonic jerks) Partial, or focal, seizures (seizures beginning locally) Simple (without loss of consciousness) Motor (tonic, clonic, tonic-clonic; Jacksonian benign childhood epilepsy; epilepsia partialis continua) Somatosensory or special sensory (visual, auditory, olfactory, gustatory, vertiginous) Autonomic Psychic Complex Beginning as simple partial seizures and progressing to impairment of consciousness) With impairment of consciousness at onset Special epileptic syndromes Myoclonus and myoclonic seizures Reflex epilepsy Acquired aphasic and convulsive disorder Febrile and other seizures of infancy and childhood Hysterical seizures Source. From “Proposal for Revised Clinical and Electroencephalographic Classification of Epileptic Seizures. From the Commission on Classification and Terminology of the International League Against Epilepsy.” Epilepsia 22:489, 1981.
A different conceptualization interprets the problem not just as a seizure disorder but rather as a dysfunction in the limbic system that is clinically referred to as episodic dyscontrol.18 Neural circuits related to defensive rage behavior respond to inescapable threats and activate the periaqueductal gray of the midbrain and its projections. 19 In turn, limbic and cortical influences on the periaqueductal gray may be direct or may be funneled through the hypothalamus. Activation of the medial hypothalamus or amygdala then facilitates defensive rage. Another approach has been to focus on seizure-prone individuals’ interictal personality. It has been proposed that these individuals are more likely to be prone to violence between seizures rather than in sei-
Biological Factors in Homicide
65
zure states and that such a predisposed personality shows traits of irritability and aggressivity that leave those individuals prone to having violent outbursts or to provoking others. Difficulties thus abound in trying to achieve specificity in the association between complex partial seizures and violence, just as with various psychiatric disorders and aggression.20,21 Some investigators have classified patients as showing increased aggressive behavior. However, in these studies, varying definitions of aggression have been used, and in many of these cases these definitions fall far short of any type of serious violence toward people, let alone any homicidal violence. Whitman and colleagues22 studied 83 children who were diagnosed with anterior temporal lobe epileptiform spike activity. The children showed elevated aggression scores on the Child Behavior Checklist.23 Many variables had only a slight variance to predict behavioral disorder for generalized and partial seizures. The authors eventually focused on situation-centered variables instead of biological variables to try to predict behavioral disturbances. In the early 1980s, Lewis and colleagues24 investigated psychomotor seizures in a group of 97 young offenders. These authors believed that there was an association between the offenders’ seizure disorders and violence. Eleven of the youths were seen as definitely having psychomotor seizures, and 8 were thought to probably have such a diagnosis. The 11 had been seriously assaultive, with 5 described as having committed acts of violence during the seizures. Complicating the clinical picture, however, was the frequency of antecedent central nervous system trauma in the backgrounds of these youths. The group showed a loading of factors, such as complicated perinatal problems, head injuries, central nervous system infections, and histories of some generalized seizures of the grand mal type. Some also had psychotic symptoms as well as a history of severe physical abuse. Given such a matrix of factors, which is often found in such clinical populations, attributing these youths’ increased violence to complex partial seizures is like looking for a needle in a haystack. In another study of a possible relationship between violence and seizures, Hermann and Whitman25 did not find any significant differences in the occurrence of violence between those who did and those who did not have seizures. Study subjects who had seizures were weighted on such variables as socioeconomic status, gender, age, and earlier developmental problems, much as in other studies. It was found that apart from their seizures, these individuals had multiple problems, some of which may have originated in the subjects’ deprived social environment and may have been connected with diagnoses of attention-deficit
66
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
disorder with or without hyperactivity. Their problems took the form of coexisting restlessness, impulsivity, poor attention span, memory deficits, and so on. Some subjects’ history of accident proneness or head injuries may also have left sequelae. Interpretations of the data were complicated by the study subjects’ learning disabilities, soft neurological signs, and a variety of neuropsychiatric deficits that did not fit any one standard accepted diagnosis and may have included other diagnoses as well. It is extremely difficult to sort out diverse factors such as those found in Herman and Whitman’s study from what may be directly connected with the effects of seizures. The brain is not one discrete area but instead encompasses the cortical area of the hippocampus, the frontalorbital area of the cortex, and the cingulate gyrus. There is a high degree of connection between these limbic areas and the temporal lobes, and any hypothesized lesion need not occur in any one area. In fact, the seizure disorder is often ascribed to existing on a physiological basis leading to a dysfunction that is not specifically localized in any one anatomical area. Many would also question the sensitivity of diagnostic instruments and practices to detect what might be associated with limbic seizures. Electroencephalograms (EEGs) are seen as too insensitive to detect abnormalities in subcortical activity, and neuropsychological testing cannot be relied on to differentiate such a diagnosis. Clinical practice relies on the old-fashioned diagnostic approach of history taking and trials of antiseizure medications in the absence of specific ways to validate the diagnosis. If the problems improve with medication, then the diagnosis is retroactively seen as being confirmed. Thus conflicting views have emerged regarding the proneness of those individuals with seizure disorders toward exhibiting extreme violence. At this time, it cannot be confirmed or disconfirmed in principle that these individuals have such a vulnerability, except for citation of specific cases.
Possible Linking Mechanisms Between Seizures and Violent Behavior Supposing for a moment that there is a connection between seizures and violence, how might a homicidal act occur in an individual during a seizure? The primary manifestations of a complex partial seizure begin with an alteration in the individual’s state of consciousness, specifically described as a temporal aura spreading to the limbic system. Stages of impaired consciousness then occur, with degrees of loss of contact within the environment. Sometimes a focal onset progresses to a loss of con-
Biological Factors in Homicide
67
sciousness, or at times a loss of consciousness exists from the beginning. Automatisms may occur that appear quite integrated to an observer but for which the individual has postictal amnesia. The hypothesis is that during automatist states a violent act would occur. Possible automatisms are those involving movements or activities (e.g., chewing, scratching, walking, kicking, undressing) and those described as being responsive to stimuli in the environment (e.g., drinking, resisting movement by others such as when being placed in restraints). In addition, whatever behavior was occurring before the seizure, such as eating or walking, may be continued. These diverse behaviors occurring before and during a complex seizure make it difficult to attribute an act of aggression or violence to the complex seizure. In addition, automatisms sometimes occur after a seizure and at other times in the postictal state. Attributing causation for violence to the seizure is difficult because one would have to reconstruct the perpetrator’s neuropsychological state at the time of the act without the benefit of contemporaneous EEGs or other measurements. Interictal behavior proposed to be associated with an increased tendency to violence, assuming such a correlation has validity, may also be attributable to several possibilities: 1) the personality of the person prone to such seizures, 2) personality changes in reaction to being seizure prone, or 3) a hypothesized, undetected focus. Again, none of these possibilities can be confirmed or disconfirmed. Some hope that the ambiguity may be resolved by stereo EEGs, which involve surgical insertion of wire electrodes into the brain to monitor brain abnormalities. However, this interesting research approach is not likely to attract many volunteers. Psychiatric signs and symptoms connected with the seizures, whatever their cause, provide further complications. Autonomic nervous system involvement can show up in gastrointestinal, cardiovascular, pulmonary, or urogenital symptoms. Affective states of depression, pessimism, anxiety, or euphoria may prevail. A picture of confusion with memory alterations may impair the later recall of details. In some individuals, complex partial seizures evolve to a state of generalized seizures. Repeated seizures in themselves can induce brain injury and associated behavioral changes. Occasional electrical discharges or degrees of undetected discharge could be occurring. From a psychological perspective, the tendency to violence could be explained by the individual’s reaction to having seizures, which are, after all, a disease of the central nervous system. Often, a seizure-prone individual may have a comorbid diagnosis that involves schizophreniform or paranoid-type personality features that are reflected in mood disturbances. The personality features most frequently referred to are hyper-
68
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
religiousness, hyposexuality, hypergraphia, and circumstantiality. Auditory hallucinations and paranoid delusions can also occur. There is a need to determine whether these symptoms are related to schizophrenia. To complicate matters further, the onset of psychotic symptoms may occur years after the onset of the seizures. In one study of 44 epileptic patients, 20 met the criteria for a schizophrenic disorder.26 Most elusive is the attempt to portray a “dyscontrol syndrome” as producing violence from lesions in the limbic system or temporal lobe in the absence of any observable seizures. This hypothesis suggests that there are epileptic types of discharges from the limbic system, based on suggestive evidence from soft neurological signs, electroencephalographic abnormalities, attention-deficit disorders, and so on. This vague group of signs, symptoms, and diverse diagnostic possibilities exhibits diverse types of dyscontrol in terms of frequency and severity. When used in attempts to explain homicidal behavior, this grouping thus appears to be elusive, at present not capable of being falsified as a diagnosis from its elastic boundaries. It is likely that greater diagnostic specificity will be obtained in the future from electroencephalographic work along with more advanced brain imaging techniques. Although large numbers of electroencephalographic studies have attempted to detect significant brain abnormalities in individuals ranging from delinquents and psychopaths to murderers, major problems exist in interpreting these reports.27 The methodological difficulties involve lack of control subjects, the subjective nature of scoring EEGs, lack of blind assessment of the records, lack of agreed-on criteria for defining abnormality, and lack of sensitivity to states of alertness of the subject. Perhaps the newer brain imaging techniques will allow greater specificity, such as pinpointing temporal lobe abnormalities through computed tomography. In one study of 87 patients with diverse psychiatric diagnoses who were referred for neuropsychiatric evaluation, both computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging were performed.28 Twenty-three of the patients were diagnosed as having an organic mental disorder; significantly, the 14 of those 23 who had a history of frequent violent episodes showed lesions in the anterior-inferior temporal lobe, whereas the 9 who were not violent did not show such lesions. In summary, once a seizure-prone individual has carried out a homicide or serious act of violence, several possibilities of the biological cause arise.29 One possibility is that the act might have been caused by the seizure, although such violence as part of an ictal state is quite rare. Another possibility is that a type of cerebral malfunction may be the cause of both the homicide and the seizure disorders. Sometimes the violence may be associated with the confusion of a postictal state. Yet another possibility
Biological Factors in Homicide
69
is that some types of psychological sequelae accompanying a seizure problem may foster resentment and accumulated rage, leaving the person prone to a homicidal outburst, or a mental disorder may have developed as a result of the seizure problem and may have played some contributory role in the homicide. Also to be considered is the background of psychosocial deprivation that can contribute to an individual’s seizure proneness as well as to homicidal behavior. Furthermore, in some of these cases, patterns of violent or provocative behavior, whatever their source, can elicit reactive trauma and the possibility of resultant brain injury from such encounters.
Social and Legal Issues About Seizures and Violent Behavior The potential connection between complex partial seizures and homicidal violence raises complicated social and legal issues beyond those of proper medical diagnoses. The essentials for a criminal act are an actus reus (criminal act) as well as a mens rea (criminal mind or criminal intent). The latter involves the idea of an individual voluntarily choosing to commit a criminal act, in which case his or her behavior is seen as blameworthy. In the absence of such a choice, blaming and punishment would be seen as not only inappropriate but unjust. The possibility of a criminal act occurring in an ictal state raises questions about the perpetrator’s volitional capacity. A more subtle and frequent consideration is whether an individual can be cleared of responsibility for interictal acts of violence, with the act being attributed to the “epileptic personality.” However, in legal settings, questions are not posed in epidemiological terms. Instead, they involve the question of whether, in a particular case, an individual can validate the diagnosis of an epileptic personality and whether the homicidal behavior can be encompassed under the seizure diagnosis. Then, depending on the jurisdiction, different types of legal questions arise with respect to an individual’s capacity to control his or her violent behavior, conform his or her conduct to the requirements of the law, know the difference between right and wrong, and know the nature of the act carried out. A legal distinction is made between an automatism defense and an insanity defense. The former is raised by way of a denial of homicidal responsibility because the actus reus is required to have been voluntary. A homicide occurring during an alleged seizure state could raise the question of whether the mens rea was negated because the perpetrator did not register the requisite cognitive or emotional states. A pure automatism defense would not necessitate proving the presence of a mental disease or defect. If successful, the defense would have a “not guilty”
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
70
outcome in contrast to a “not guilty by reason of insanity” outcome. Hence, the automatism defense would bypass the types of questions raised in using an insanity defense and the types of restrictions normally associated with a successful insanity defense, such as medical or court supervision. One interesting question would be the possibility of a later recurrence of the seizure and potential for violence in the lack of such supervision. Complex legal as well as psychiatric issues arise concerning assertions that voluntariness or its absence in conjunction with a seizure disorder exculpates a defendant for a homicidal act. It seems clear that simply making an assertion of a connection between a seizure disorder and involuntary behavior does not suffice for legal or medical purposes to establish a connection to the act of violence. Furthermore, if medical documentation exists about such a seizure disorder, it may become legally significant when an issue of responsibility is raised. The need to validate the diagnosis by a competent neurologist experienced in the area of seizure disorders is only the beginning. If the accused person is a minor, the diagnostician should be someone who is also experienced in and conversant with the diagnosis in that age group. The question of automatisms needs to be established with electroencephalographic telemetry, and some would add that the testing should occur on closed-circuit television as well. Demonstrations of aggression related to a seizure should be handled by an attempt to induce the seizure and have it on videotape with accompanying electroencephalographic readings. Even if the results were positive, they could still be challenged on the basis that the automatisms were not what actually occurred during the commission of the violent act in question. However, the results would support the claim that analogous behavior did occur. The individual’s history should also indicate past episodes of aggression or violent behavior. For legal purposes, a neurologist or psychiatrist would have to be willing to express an opinion that these factors were related to the seizure disorder and be available for answering other legal questions.
Case Example30 Seth Grant was one among several individuals in a bar. A patron, whom he did not know, and the tavern owner got into an altercation. When the police arrived, the patron was escorted outside. A hostile crowd of about 40 people was cheering the patron when suddenly, Grant, heretofore totally uninvolved, leaped into the air and struck an officer twice in the face. Great force was needed to subdue Grant, who was described as excited, agitated, and upset. In jail 1 hour later, he was observed having symptoms of a grand mal seizure.
Biological Factors in Homicide
71
Grant’s medical history revealed a preexistent diagnosis of psychomotor epilepsy for which he was receiving medication and also verified that he had had a number of violent attacks of varying severity. A previous attack in which Grant assaulted someone with a knife in a hospital had resulted in his being shot in the pelvis and kidney by a police officer. At his current trial, Grant testified that he recalled nothing about the bar episode and had only “woken up” in the hospital 3 days later. His psychiatric expert testified that he had had a psychomotor seizure that “prevented his conscious mind from controlling his actions.” There was conflicting testimony about his being “alert and awake” at the time of the arrest and in jail. A question was also raised about the grand mal seizure in jail, because it would not necessarily mean that he had had a psychomotor seizure while at the bar. The jury was instructed in terms of the Illinois Test for Insanity, which stated that as a result of a mental disease or defect, the defendant would have to lack substantial capacity to either appreciate the criminality of his conduct or conform his conduct to the requirements of the law in order to be found not guilty by reason of insanity. The jury found Grant guilty of aggravated battery and obstructing a police officer, but the court sentenced him only on the former charge. On appeal, it was noted that the insanity question did not distinguish an individual whose behavior was caused by an automatism during which the defendant was not conscious of what he was doing. No instruction had been given the jury involving involuntary conduct, and on that ground the case was reversed and remanded with directions for a new trial.
Apart from other issues, this case example raises the interesting legal dilemma of what instructions should be given in such cases. Cases involving voluntary conduct cause difficulty not only for philosophers and clinicians but also for the legal system, with its need to assess culpability on the basis of an individual performing a voluntary act. The Model Penal Code, which produces recommendations by a scholarly group of attorneys and law professors, lists exclusions from the definition of a voluntary act:31 1) a reflex or convulsion, 2) a bodily movement during unconsciousness or sleep, 3) conduct during hypnosis or resulting from hypnotic suggestion, or 4) a bodily movement that is not a product of the effort or determination of the actor, either conscious or habitual. This scholarly recommendation states that a voluntary act should have an element of conscious control over the behavior but does not attempt to resolve the age-old debate between free will and determinism or how much control. The code is an attempt to exclude, in a crude way, behavior seen as nonvolitional. The rationale on one hand is that a person’s sense of autonomy would be undermined if he or she were held accountable for behavior that he or she could not control. It is also argued that a sense of justice is vitiated in holding such
72
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
people accountable. The problem arises in a broader sense from many people thinking they cannot control themselves. Hence, as a minimum, there is a requirement for some attendant alteration of consciousness. Of course, because an unconscious person cannot carry out any act, there remains a quandary that produces the doctrine of automatism, implying some (but how much?) limitation of the awareness of his or her acts.
Altered States of Consciousness The list of clinical conditions in which automatisms are alleged to occur has been widely expanded from its origins to now include possible problems on a genetic, hormonal, or neurochemical level. Common law cases involving alleged sleepwalking go back to the seventeenth century in England, although it was not until the nineteenth century that juries began to consider such cases as “fractured or suspended consciousness.” Medical texts began to describe such states as “doubly conscious.”32 The idea emerged that some type of suspension of full human agency was present although not delusional at the time of a homicide. The range of diverse conditions tend to blend in with the dissociative disorder group in which no organic pathology is being asserted. This change increases the legal confusion, because it increases the range of medical experts who are willing to testify on opposite sides and render diverse opinions. The possibilities then include seizures, postictal states, and a variety of altered states of consciousness that can either accompany delirium and dementia or exist in their own right. Altered states can also occur from infectious processes, toxins, tumors, head injuries, and various metabolic diseases such as diabetes or Cushing’s syndrome. Dissociative states, whatever the etiology, pose challenging legal questions. Should people who commit homicidal acts while in such states (assuming clinical evaluations support the existence of such states) be held criminally liable to the same extent as someone without such states? Do these mental states provide a basis for a mental illness defense? If not, should the individuals be punished to the same degree as someone committing such acts but without an altered state of consciousness? Questions about hypnotized individuals carrying out criminal acts continue to be argued without a satisfactory resolution. The affirmative argument against liability for these individuals’ behavior is that they are subject to, and dependent on, the hypnotizer. Yet ascribing such helplessness to the individual does not square with current knowledge
Biological Factors in Homicide
73
about the nature of hypnotizability, in that some may choose to submit to such procedures and others may be extremely suggestible by nature. Matters become even more debatable when automatic states related to somnambulistic (i.e., sleepwalking) or hypnagogic states are suggested. Somnambulistic states always raise interesting legal questions about the nature of responsibility for behavior. Excerpts from the King v. Cogdon case illustrate fundamental issues about responsibility for criminal behavior in this regard.33 This unreported case, heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria before Mr. Justice Smith in December 1950, although clear as to its facts and unchallengeable in law, was seen as compelling a reconsideration of some of the basic premises of responsibility for criminal actions.
Case Example Mrs. Cogdon was charged with the murder of Pat, her only child, a 19year-old woman. Pat had for some time been receiving psychiatric treatment for a relatively minor neurotic condition of which, in her psychiatrist’s opinion, she had been cured. Despite this remission, Mrs. Cogdon continued to worry unduly about her daughter. Describing the relationship between Pat and her mother, Mr. Cogdon testified: “I don’t think a mother could have thought any more of her daughter. I think she absolutely adored her.” On the conscious level, at least, there was no reason to doubt Mrs. Cogdon’s deep attachment to her daughter. To the charge of murdering Pat, Mrs. Cogdon pleaded not guilty. Her story, although somewhat bizarre, was not seriously challenged by the Crown and led to her acquittal. She told how on the night before her daughter’s death, she had dreamed that their house was full of spiders and that these spiders were crawling all over Pat. In her sleep, Mrs. Cogdon left the bed she shared with her husband, went into Pat’s room, and awakened to find herself violently brushing at Pat’s face, presumably to remove the spiders. This woke Pat. Mrs. Cogdon told her she was just tucking her in. At the trial, Mrs. Cogdon testified that she had been told and still believed that the occupants of a nearby house bred spiders as a hobby, preparing nests for them behind pictures on their walls. It was these spiders that in her dreams had invaded their home and attacked Pat. Mrs. Cogdon had also had a previous dream in which ghosts sat at the end of her bed, and she said to them, “Well, you have come to take Pattie.” It did not seem fanciful to accept the psychological explanations of these spiders and ghosts as the projections of Mrs. Cogdon’s subconscious hostility toward her daughter, a hostility that was itself rooted in Mrs. Cogdon’s own early life and marital relationship. The morning after the spider dream, Mrs. Cogdon told her doctor about it. He gave her a sedative and, because of the dream and certain previous difficulties she had reported, discussed the possibility of psychiatric treatment. That evening, Mrs. Cogdon suggested to her husband that he attend his lodge meeting and asked Pat to come with her
74
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE to the cinema. After he had gone, Pat looked through the paper, found no tolerable program, and said that because she was going out the next evening, she thought she would rather go to bed early. Later, while Pat was having a bath preparatory to retiring, Mrs. Cogdon went into her room, put a hot water bottle in the bed, turned back the bedclothes, and placed a glass of hot milk beside the bed ready for Pat. She then went to bed herself. There was some desultory conversation between them, and just before she put out her light, Pat called to her mother, “Mum, don’t be so silly worrying there about the war—it’s not on our front doorstep yet.” Mrs. Cogdon went to sleep. She dreamed that “the war was all around the house,” that soldiers were in Pat’s room, and that one soldier was on the bed attacking Pat. This was all of the dream she could later recapture. Her first “waking” memory was of running from Pat’s room, out of the house to the home of her sister, who lived next door. When her sister opened the front door, Mrs. Cogdon fell against her, crying, “I think I’ve hurt Pattie.” In fact, Mrs. Cogdon had, in her somnambulistic state, left her bed, fetched an ax from the wood heap, entered Pat’s room, and struck her two accurate forceful blows on the head with the blade of the ax, thus killing her. Mrs. Cogdon’s story was supported by the evidence of her physician, a psychiatrist, and a psychologist. The burden of the evidence of all three, which was not contested by the prosecution, was that Mrs. Cogdon had a form of hysteria with an overlay of depression and that she was of a personality in which such dissociated states as fugues, amnesias, and somnambulistic acts were to be expected. They agreed that she was not psychotic. They hazarded no statement as to her motives, the idea of defense of the daughter being transparently insufficient. However, the psychologist and the psychiatrist concurred in hinting that the emotional motivation lay in an acute conflict situation in Mrs. Cogdon’s relations with her parents; that during marital life she suffered very great sexual frustration; and that she overcompensated for her own frustration by overprotection of her daughter. Her exaggerated solicitude for her daughter was a conscious expression of her subconscious emotional hostility toward her, and the dream ghosts, spiders, and soldiers were projections of that aggression. The jury believed Mrs. Cogdon’s story and regarded the natural consequences of her acts as being completely rebutted by her account of her mental state at the time of the killing and by the unanimous support given to it by the medical and psychological evidence. She was acquitted. It must be stressed that insanity was not pleaded as a defense—Mrs. Cogdon was acquitted because the act of killing itself was not, in law, regarded as her act at all.
As stated in the case documents, this case “illustrates the impossibility of…satisfactorily…sever[ing] ‘act’ from ‘intention’.…Thus, Mrs. Cogdon’s action not being ‘voluntary,’ no question of criminal liability arose.” Mrs. Cogdon escapes basically because of the state of her consciousness,
Biological Factors in Homicide
75
not because she had no conscious intention or rational motive to kill, a state she shares with many convicted murderers. She was “asleep”; had she been “awake” her only defense would have been one of insanity. However, the difference between being asleep and being awake is not absolute. Consciousness is not like a light, either off or on; it is a finely graded scale ranging from death to the extreme awareness of the artist. Only instruments such as an electroencephalograph can chart certain variations of consciousness between people and in one person at different times. Had Mrs. Cogdon been awake—that is, just a little more conscious, a little more aware of her actions—then her act may have had to be regarded as voluntary. The line is an extremely fine one, as is shown by the fact that in and during her dream Mrs. Cogdon was “aware” of the ax, her daughter, and the soldiers. Not unexpectedly, she could not remember this part of the dream after the event, for often people struggle to repress profoundly disturbing and shocking memory traces. Thus all people dream, but some, for various reasons, remember more than others. Nor would Mrs. Cogdon’s position have been legally different if she could have recalled all of the dream, including the killing. Her exculpation lay not in the state of her memory but in her inability to bring into consciousness her emotional motivations and, consequently, her diminished awareness of the deed.
Hormonal Theories Another group of cases raising issues of altered biology in connection with a homicide are those related to hormonally altered states at the time of the homicidal act.
Premenstrual Syndrome One recent area of disagreement has centered on the diagnosis of premenstrual syndrome (PMS) and its relationship to violence. This is not an official diagnosis in DSM-IV-TR,34 and it is listed in an appendix of categories for which insufficient information exists for inclusion as an official diagnosis. Hence DSM-IV-TR lists PMS as “research criteria for premenstrual dysphoric disorder.” The argument rages as heavily as the hormones themselves are alleged to rage. Those who argue affirmatively hold that PMS is a hormone deficiency state that renders perpetrators unable to control their actions when these symptoms are present. Some now describe PMS as a mental disorder, but this description is contrary to its use as a legal defense.35 The medical profession continues to have diverse views about whether PMS is a syndrome or an illness.
76
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
One analogy drawn is between PMS and the phenomenon described over the centuries as postpartum psychosis and infanticide. Presentations of postpartum psychosis can vary from mild depression to outright delusional states with hallucinations. The occurrence of postpartum symptoms can vary from a few days to months after parturition, which suggests an etiology based on hormonal alterations, although psychosocial stressors cannot be ignored. However, the argument does not stop with the suggestion of hormonal alterations. It is alleged that the behavior from such a physiological disturbance does not fit the pattern of a mental illness, and the acts are more in the nature of automatist acts related to altered states of consciousness. PMS merits further discussion in view of its increasing publicity and in anticipation of its increased future use in legal settings. Medical testimony, as well as critiques by social commentators, will be the deciding factor in its use or abandonment until more definitive court rulings are obtained. Some feminist critiques have raised questions regarding the disease status of PMS. The objection to seeing PMS as a specific hormonal imbalance that can be medically managed is that the explanation is overly simplistic and premature. Such an approach views the problem in terms of a body needing repair rather than someone immersed in a genderbased social system that induces problems. Others challenge that PMS is not a valid clinical entity and that the causal explanations proffered to account for its syndrome status are insufficient. Those arguing in favor of it being viewed as a disorder are seen as biased in their observations and explanations leading toward a linear, reductionist type of thinking. Questions have also been raised about reports cited in support of establishing a premenstrual syndrome. Many of these reports lacked control subjects; some research suggested no difference between hormonal profiles of females alleged to have PMS and those who do not. Other investigators have confused statistical variation connected with premenstrual changes with the presence of an abnormal state. Different studies have produced a seemingly endless list of symptoms compatible with almost any diagnosis, or with no diagnosis in particular. One study listed 150 symptoms categorized into five groups: affective, neurovegetative, central nervous system, cognitive, and behavioral disturbances.36 When any of these occur in the premenstrual period, the supposition is that the symptoms are attributable to the syndrome. In 1961, Dalton37 studied 156 English women who were incarcerated and who had committed a crime in the previous 28 days. She divided the menstrual cycle into seven 4-day segments and found that 49% of the women were either in the premenstrual phase (4 days before menstruation) or menstruating (the next 4 days) at the time of their crimes. Her
Biological Factors in Homicide
77
conclusion was that hormonal changes (e.g., increased aggression, irritability, labile emotions, lethargy, carelessness) either caused the actions or affected the women’s ability to refrain from crime. However, Horney38 challenged this interpretation by arguing that committing the criminal acts, and the stress of arrest and imprisonment, could trigger early menstruation. In addition, she pointed out that 155 of the 156 women had been convicted of nonviolent crimes. The safe conclusion is that the symptoms of PMS as an explanation for violent crime are more correlated with publicity than empirical data.
Other Considerations Regarding Hormonal Factors There is merit in investigating the possibility that some type of hormonal changes occur in relation to an individual’s proneness to violence. However, several impediments also exist in documenting relevant hormonal levels and their effect on an individual’s actions. Investigations into the connection between hormones and violence often attempt to determine whether higher levels of certain hormones are present in those who exhibit violent behavior. However, the simplicity of such research may conceal many of the medicolegal problems that can arise from too-easy causal attributions. For example, establishing a murderer’s hormonal levels at random intervals does not indicate whether the level may actually have been abnormal at the time of the murder. In addition, simply obtaining a hormonal level at any one time does not reflect the totality of the individual’s endocrine functioning; the complex interactions within the hypothalamicpituitary-gonadal system must also be considered, such as concentrations of hormones in the brain, low levels of neurotransmitters, different sensitivities at receptor sites, and postreceptor effects. The confounding influence of alcohol and nonmedical drugs also can alter results of hormonal assays and blood levels of certain sex hormones. Another possibility is the connection between hormonal levels and diverse endocrine diseases (e.g., diabetes with hypoglycemic episodes, Cushing’s syndrome, hyperthyroidism). Results from a Swedish study of “normal” 16-year-old adolescents in which the subjects reported on their verbal and physical aggression in response to what they saw as provocations indicated a significant association between the aggressive behaviors and plasma testosterone levels.39 A few years earlier, investigators had found elevated levels of plasma testosterone in 52 rapists and child molesters.40 The level of testosterone was correlated with the degree of violence and the symptoms self-reported on an inventory. In a later study, some of those same investigators found no
78
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
significant differences in testosterone levels between a control group and a violent group.41 Again, a major deficit in such studies is that the level of hormones at the time of the violent act is not available. Although it may be deemed impossible that such levels could be accurately attained, the inference is nevertheless made by advocates that the hormonal level could have been abnormal at the time of the violence. Critics of any hormone–violence causal relation argue that 1) diverse causes are possible for violence even when altered plasma levels of hormones are found and 2) no causal connection can be drawn between elevated hormonal levels and violence. Perhaps these arguments suggest why authors of many improvised studies using subjects from prison populations have failed to find significant correlations. At a minimum, a baseline level of androgens would have to be established for the participants in these studies. Of those studies that have focused on hormonal levels and violence, at least three have found no connection. One group of investigators found that when a synthetic form of progesterone or estrogen was administered to sex offenders, it had no noticeable effect on their aggressive behavior.42 Another group who studied thousands of hostile patients in state hospitals concluded that there was no difference between men and women in such studies.43 Similarly, researchers in a later study failed to find any differences in androgen levels, particularly testosterone, among murderers, assaulters, and a control group.44 Green,45 in the book Sexual Science and the Law, thoroughly reviewed the simplistic thinking that leads to attempts to control serious sexual violence by way of either surgical or hormonal castration. Proponents of such intervention have argued that if the effects of androgen are blocked, sexual behavior should be blocked and presumably any connected violence. Unfortunately, the degree of aggression and testosterone levels are poorly correlated. Although results from some European studies on surgical castration have indicated less recidivism in castrated sex offenders compared with those who did not undergo such treatment, the results have been variable, especially if the castrations were carried out on young males. There would also be much legal and social objection to such procedures in the United States. As a result, studies in the United States have focused on treating sex offenders with medroxyprogesterone acetate (Depo-Provera) and outside the United States with cyproterone acetate (CPA). One difficulty in discussing this work with respect to homicidal violence is that the legal category of sex offenders is extremely heterogeneous, and only a small number of offenders have acted in homicidal ways. Hence, whether these drugs can reduce homicidal levels of violence in connection with sexual acts is unknown.
Biological Factors in Homicide
79
Critical analyses could similarly be presented regarding other hypotheses about hormonal possibilities, such as those involving the hypothalamic-pituitary axis, the thyroid, or the adrenal glands.
Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Consideration of automatisms possibly related to seizure disorders or altered hormonal states has now been extended to consideration of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) as an exculpating (or at least mitigating) condition in homicidal behavior. The reasoning behind this concept is that some type of traumatic event occurs that alters the physiological, as well as the typical psychological, functioning of an individual (see discussion of abused persons in Chapter 7, “Masochism and Homicide”). A host of symptoms are then said to emerge, such as memory loss, sleep impairment, nightmares, reliving of the traumatic event, intrusive thoughts, exaggerated startle response, decreased emotional responsiveness, feelings of alienation, and dissociative conditions. The idea is that a peritraumatic dissociation may have occurred that elicits a variety of psychophysiological reactions. A dissociative state could be seen as a freezing response in contrast to a fight-or-flight response.46 In the dissociated state, the individual is portrayed as reliving the event as if he or she were once more present as a participant. Such reasoning was promoted originally for veterans of the Vietnam War who had been in combat, were self-medicating themselves with narcotics or alcohol, and subsequently committed violent assaults, including homicides. The automatism defense was often raised in this context using this diagnosis. Although the concept of a traumatic neurosis is not new, its use in this form as exculpatory for homicides is. Individuals involved in diverse types of traumas may have come from unfortunate social backgrounds. These traumas of developmental origin are used in arguing that a homicide occurred during an automatized state because the individual was predisposed to committing violence from childhood traumas. The possible traumas that can be used for legal defense purposes are endless and include past physical altercations that induced a traumatic state; being assaulted; fearing repeated assaults and thus having a need to strike out first; and being abused as a child in either a physical, sexual, or emotional manner. Use of the battered woman syndrome or the battered child syndrome as legal defenses to a homicide may raise the issue of PTSD. To complicate matters, perpetrating a homicide itself can lead to the onset of PTSD. In one study, there was a 58% lifetime prevalence of PTSD after a homicide.47
80
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
The idea of automatized homicides associated with earlier traumas may be extended to include homicides occurring subsequent to the emergence of multiple personalities or brainwashing events. However, assertions that an automatism defense is equivalent to that provided by “a disease of the mind” are questionable. This branches into quite a different pathway in terms of a legal defense, and for what follows if this defense is successful in court against homicide charges. There would be minimal justification, in the absence of any disease, to engage in a civil commitment process and hospitalize someone for a stress syndrome after such an acquittal.
Hypoglycemic States Similar complexities beset the assessment of hypotheses about a connection between hypoglycemic states and violent behavior. Studies of this relationship are often not comparable, with some referring to violent behavior, others to states of aggressiveness, and others to antisocial behavior. Some simply report the presence of irritability associated with hypoglycemic episodes. A distinction is also made between the sources of hypoglycemia, such as from physiological variations after an excessive release of insulin on a postprandial basis (also called functional hypoglycemia) in contrast to a state of fasting hypoglycemia, which may be associated with islet cell tumors or chronic alcohol abuse. The only safe conclusion at present about hypoglycemic states is that such states are only one of many other variables operating in aggressive behavior, including personality variables as well as the entire phenomenon of interpersonal reactions present in many social situations. Although a rare case of extreme violence may be connected with hypoglycemia, it is so entwined with other factors that it is difficult to achieve any causal specificity.
Role of Neurotransmitters Some current hypotheses have focused on serotonergic neurotransmitter processes involving aggression. Since Asberg and colleagues’48 1976 study in which it was found that patients with the lowest cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid (5-HIAA) concentrations (the serotonin [5-HT] metabolites) were most likely to attempt or commit suicide by violent means, there have been subsequent confirmations. Investigators in one study reported CSF 5-HIAA concentrations as being inversely related to the incidence of overtly aggressive behaviors.49 Rather than being used to focus on a specific diagnosis, the question of altered serotonin metabolism has entered the picture in attempts to ex-
Biological Factors in Homicide
81
plain violence. Two other groups assessed CSF 5-HIAA levels in men connected with a homicide and men who had attempted a suicide.50,51 Both groups found that lower levels of CSF 5-HIAA prevailed in those with a history of aggressive behavior as well as suicidal behavior. Maiuro and Eberle52 studied men who had killed or attempted to kill in a cruel manner; the authors first excluded those with diagnoses of schizophrenia or major affective disorders and found that the remainder had a lower level of CSF 5-HIAA. Brown and colleagues53 reported that young adults with low levels of CSF 5-HIAA tended to have a childhood history of aggressive conduct disorder that included acts such as lying, stealing, killing a pet animal in a rage, and impulsive fire setting. Exactly what implications these study results have for homicidal violence are unclear, although intriguing findings continue to be made involving altered serotonin metabolism, as well as altered levels of dopamine and noradrenaline. The basic idea is that something has gone awry with serotonin metabolism, whatever the attached diagnosis might be, and that the serotonergic aberration may represent a state or trait phenomenon. Other factors are seen as indirectly involving 5-HT neurotransmission. The theory is that the propensity for impulsive aggression is associated with activating negative affect. There is then a failure to respond appropriately to anticipated negative consequences of behaving aggressively.54 The key question is, what would make some individuals more vulnerable neurochemically? This neural circuit is composed of several regions (the prefrontal cortex, amygdala, hippocampus, medial preoptic area, hypothalamus, anterior cingulate cortex, insular cortex, ventral striatum) and interconnected regions. These multiple regions are dependent on the actions of neurotransmitters, such as 5-HT. The 5-HT system is seen as regulating aggression in animal models and violent behavior in humans.54 Hence in studies, low concentrations of the metabolite, 5-HIAA, are reflected in impulsivity and aggression. Diverse genetic influences, such as the 5-HT system, and added environmental stressors, such as the frequent influence of drugs or alcohol, are related as well.
Cerebral Hemisphere Dysfunctions The increase in research at the micro level looking for genetic aberrations related to neurochemical difficulties on the macro level is fairly recent; however, research on aberrant functioning in the cerebral hemispheres, in which anatomical and physiological factors relevant to violence have been studied, has had a much longer history. This latter type of research has waxed and waned throughout the 1900s.
82
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
Focusing on the cerebral hemispheres as the site of violent behavior seems to have had its modern origins by way of phrenology. The English forensic psychiatrist W. Norwood East56 pointed out in a 1928 lecture how the influence of Francis Joseph Gall (1758–1828) as a phrenologist emphasized the manifestations of the mind with the development of the brain. The brain was viewed as an aggregate of parts that had special functions. The idea was that the size of particular parts of the brain bore a relationship to the energy associated with particular mental powers. It was hypothesized that if certain “organs” of the brain were large, as deduced from the skull, particularly for such features as combativeness, destructiveness, and acquisitiveness, the organs and dispositions would correspond. This type of thinking led some leading physicians of the nineteenth century to apply these ideas to criminal behavior. East56 pointed out that Philippe Pinel had a patient in 1791 with recurring attacks of an overpowering impulse to assault the first person he saw. It was cited by the phrenologist George Combe as reflecting an “organ of destructiveness” being excited into diseased activity. Combe had compared the conduct of executed criminals with their cerebral development. The idea was that if “organs of the mind” acting through faculties of cerebral origins cannot adequately guide conduct, questions of responsibility for the behavior arise. These issues continued to be debated throughout the century, and by the late nineteenth century Cesare Lombroso (1836–1909) was looking for degeneracy of criminals in their physiognomy. Lombroso was a physician employed in the Italian penal system who founded the school of positivistic criminology. He focused on lateral asymmetries, such as abnormal asymmetries in the face and imbalances in the cerebral hemispheres.57 In fact, the positivist revolution has been extended from its origins in biology to the current state of biological criminology. The failure to confirm this type of theorizing as time went on led to its abandonment and ridicule. However, the idea that something could be impaired in the cerebral hemispheres of someone who committed a violent act such as murder was implanted, to be pursued later in current research and clinical studies. Parallel to these anatomical and physiological formulations about the cerebral hemispheres and violence, clinical findings were documenting changed behavior after cerebral injuries. The case of Phineas Gage in 1848 is often cited as beginning the inquiry. An explosion drove an iron tamping rod through his left cheek and out the top of his head, leaving a 1.5-inch hole in his frontal lobes.58 Previously a conforming, self-contained 25-year-old, Gage became fitful and unrepentant about his actions, showed no deference to others, and became impulsive and hedonistic. In 1994, Damasio and colleagues59 used computer-assisted
Biological Factors in Homicide
83
imaging to reconstruct what had actually happened to Gage, namely a disconnect to most of his frontal cortex that has been referred to as the first accidental lobotomy. Many subsequent clinical cases have been pursued since then, showing that frontal lobe dysfunctioning can be attributed to diverse etiologies, which vary from brain tumors to concussive types of brain injuries, frontal lobe epilepsy, and so on.60 These lesions may leave the individual prone to impulsive and aggressive acts, particularly if there has been damage to the anterior cingulate or orbital frontal cortex. Head injuries can contribute to several adverse consequences involving violence. Increased aggressiveness due to frontal lobe impairment, varieties of episodic dyscontrol as noted earlier, and exaggeration of preexisting antisocial behavior in individuals already vulnerable to antisocial behavior are a few possibilities that can lead to homicidal behavior. Lesions in the anterior part of the hypothalamus are noted for rage reactions, especially in those persons with a low threshold for being provoked. The existence of lesions may indicate a dysfunction in warning these individuals when to avoid certain provocative situations.61 Currently, researchers view biological abnormalities as perhaps one variable among many that can produce an individual vulnerable to violent acts. More recent hemispheric research has delineated differential features between the functioning of the left and right hemispheres, with the left operating in the area of sequential information processing on a verbal level, and the right hemisphere functioning on the level of mediating spatial stimuli. In the early 1970s, Flor-Henry62 questioned whether psychopathy was associated with left hemisphere disturbances. In a subsequent study, Yeudall63 found 72% of violent criminals had left hemisphere dysfunction compared with 79% of nonviolent criminals, who had a right hemisphere dysfunction. Yeudall’s study was subsequently criticized on the basis that the subjects studied were gathered from a criminal population, which would be expected to have a greater loading of individuals with neurological abnormalities, and that the criteria used to diagnose hemispheric dysfunction were not specifically spelled out.64 Along this same line, Nachshon and Denno65 investigated the hypothesis that “delinquent subjects” would show a higher incidence of left-sidedness compared with a control group when measured in terms of hand, eye, and foot preferences. Although delinquent subjects may be a long way from homicidal subjects, one of the six groups Nachshon and Denno studied was classified as very violent. This group showed a significantly higher incidence of left eye preference, interpreted as a left hemisphere dysfunction by the authors. These results did not demonstrate that such a hemispheric asymmetry exists in someone who mur-
84
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
ders; however, these authors’ results and other empirical studies are intriguing because of the paucity of much experimental data dealing with extreme human violence. Although it would be presumptuous to jump to a conclusion that a statistical association between hemispheric dysfunction and certain kinds of violence establishes any kind of causal relationship, certain questions about the meaning of the statistical association are relevant. One possibility is that a right hemisphere dysfunction could impinge on emotionality, which would contribute to impulse control problems. A left-sided hemisphere dysfunction could upset the role and use of language and coping skills in controlling violent impulses. Foresight and anticipation could also thereby be impaired, perhaps as seen in the prevalent diagnosis among male children with attention-deficit hyperactivity disorders. These types of deficits become more ominous as adolescence is approached, and the effects continue into adulthood in some people. The ongoing effect of these deficits may all lead back to questions about frontal lobe syndrome, the effects of head injury, early childhood head injuries, an individual’s proneness to overreact to alcohol, frontal lobe connections to the anterior-temporal cortex, impaired blood flow to parts of the medial and frontal cortex, and hippocampalamygdala areas connected to some type of central nervous system diathesis for violence. Deficits in these processes tend to alter the way an individual perceives the world and uses techniques to adapt and cope. In that sense, these deficits interfere with the effectiveness of psychological mechanisms and defenses and lead to more difficulty in exerting controls. In a primary preventive sense, determining what prenatal, perinatal, and postnatal factors may induce such deficits is crucial for this subgroup. In a secondary preventive sense, social and emotional assets can sometimes limit the effect of these disabilities. Here, traditional emphases have been used on ameliorating socioeconomic conditions, resolution of family conflicts, intervention with special schooling and counseling for those with deficits in cognitive functioning, and supportive therapies. However, the lack of consistent use of these interventions at a high caliber of performance, and over an extended duration of time, has limited their effectiveness in a majority of cases. A variation is the study of cerebral blood flow (CBF) via positron emission tomography in violent psychiatric patients compared with nonviolent groups. These studies show a significant decrease in CBF in the medial temporal and frontal cortex areas compared with a control group.66 Similar findings were made in 16 out of 21 aggressive individuals, indicating a hypoperfusion in the frontal or temporal lobes as
Biological Factors in Homicide
85
shown by single photon emission computed tomography.67 Positron emission tomography studies of CBF in a group of murderers who pleaded legal insanity were conducted by Raine and colleagues,68 and again a finding of lowered CBF in the prefrontal cortex was found in the study group compared with a control group. Reduced prefrontal cortex functioning was later shown to be connected to those showing affective aggression rather than instrumental aggression. Neuropsychological work has shown that only lesions in the orbital frontal and medial frontal cortex, rather than in the frontal cortex more generally, lead to disinhibition of the subcortical circuitry mediating affective aggression.69
CONCLUSION Flaws in most neuropsychological and neuropsychiatric research on violent behavior make generalizations precarious. Moffitt70 has done a thorough analysis of these limitations, which can only be highlighted here. In most research involving crime, the lack of an adequate control group is striking. Certainly this absence is true for studies of extreme degrees of violence, such as homicides. At the other end are clinical reports that at best offer excellent insights and hypotheses. In fact, perhaps congruent with positivistic criminology, the more microscopic the examination of an individual murderer, the more difficult it is to generalize beyond what may seem idiosyncratic. Although killing is still a relatively rare event, it does mean that there is often a conflict between seeking in-depth knowledge about why a particular individual behaved in that manner versus knowledge using larger numbers and listing diverse variables. In empirical studies, which often emphasize methodology and statistical analysis, those included in “violent groups” are almost always males, which parallels their prevalence in any study of crime. However, there is a comparative lack of data for females. A more serious flaw is that there are rarely adequate controls for demographic and environmental data. Some studies do not even give the age, gender, or race of those studied. The range of ages in studies may be enormous. In some communities, race has been eliminated from databases on the premise that collecting such data in itself is an example of racism rather than an attempt to isolate significant variables to remedy the situation. Although socioeconomic status may be given, the impact of this variable on prenatal or perinatal factors is often ignored. What is inescapable in studies of homicidal violence is that studying the perpetrators is always a retrospective event. Although it would be
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
86
possible to do some longitudinal prospective studies, these would focus on certain behaviors and traits related to aggression and violent behavior predicted to be related to homicide. Such studies have been done, but they would be next to impossible to perform for a group of potential homicide perpetrators. The limitations of data obtained from someone awaiting trial for a homicide or raising an insanity defense have long been known. Similar limitations exist for studying those in prisons or mental hospitals who have committed homicides. The result is that most of our studies are retrospective in nature. Where do these quandaries leave us? In one of the most complete models of studying future adult criminality, it was found that biological and environmental variables can predict only 25% of future adult criminality for males and 19% for females.71 I note that although statistical significance was attained in the study, the results still left 75%–81% of the criminal behaviors unexplained. Despite the statistical techniques in that study being as good or better than most social science studies, I question whether varying degrees of free will and determinism must be acknowledged with respect to criminal actions. These factors especially underscore that dichotomies between the biological and social factors are passé. Now the concept of a “biosocial” approach to homicidal violence becomes relevant. The ideal would be prospective longitudinal studies considering general biological and psychosocial influences on serious violence. This endeavor would entail testing specific hypotheses derivable from the theory, focusing on key variables to be studied, and detecting developmental sequences and causes.72
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
McDougall W: An Introduction to Social Psychology. New York, Barnes & Noble, 1960 Bibring E: The development and problems of the theory of the instincts. Int J Psychoanal 22:102–131, 1941 Lorenz KZ: On Aggression. New York, Harcourt, Brace & World, 1966 Tinbergen N: The Study of Instinct. Oxford, England, Clarendon Press, 1951 Hollander E, Posner N, Cherkasky S: Neuropsychiatric aspects of aggression and impulse control disorders, in The American Psychiatric Publishing Textbook of Neuropsychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences. Edited by Yudofsky SC, Hales RE. Washington DC, American Psychiatric Publishing, 2002, pp 579–596
Biological Factors in Homicide 6.
7. 8. 9.
10.
11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17.
18. 19.
20. 21.
22. 23.
24.
87
Kupfermann I: Genetic determinants of behavior and learning and memory, in Principles of Neural Science, 3rd Edition. Edited by Kandel ER, Schwartz JH, Jessel TM. New York, Elsevier, 1991, pp 987–1008 Bioulac B, Benezech M, Renaud B, et al: Biogenic amines in 47, XYY syndrome. Biol Psychiatry 15:917–923, 1980 Cadoret RJ, Yates WR, Troughton E, et al: Adoption study demonstrating two genetic pathways to drug abuse. Arch Gen Psychiatry 52:42–52, 1995 Pardes H, Kaufmann CA, Pincus HA, et al: Genetics and psychiatry: past discoveries, current dilemmas, and future directions. Am J Psychiatry 146:435–443, 1989 Brock DW, Buchanan AE: The genetics of behavior and concepts of free will and determinism, in Genetics and Criminality. Edited by Botkin JR, McMahon WM, Frances LP. Washington, DC, American Psychological Association, 1999, pp 67–81 Montana v Egelhoff, 518 US 37 (1996) People v Yukl, 372 NY2d 313, 319 NY Sup Ct (1975) Mark VH, Ervin FR: Violence and the Brain. New York, Harper & Row, 1970 Pincus JH, Tucker GJ: Behavioral Neurology, 3rd Edition. New York, Oxford University Press, 1985 Crichton M: The Terminal Man. New York, Knopf, 1972 Delgado-Escueta AV, Mattson RH, King L, et al: Special report: the nature of aggression during epileptic seizures. N Engl J Med 305:711–716, 1981 Hermann BP, Whitman S: Behavioral and personality correlates of epilepsy: a review, methodological critique, and conceptual model. Psychol Bull 95:451–497, 1984 Monroe RR: Behavioral Disorders. Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press, 1970 Gregg TR: Cortical and limbic neural circuits mediating aggressive behavior, in Neurobiology of Aggression. Edited by Mattson MP. Totowa, NJ, Humana Press, 2003, pp 1–20 Weiger B, Bear D: An approach to the neurology of aggression. J Psychiatr Res 22:85–89, 1988 Kohn SR, Asnis GM: Aggression in psychiatric disorders, in Neurobiology of Aggression. Edited by Mattson MP. Totowa, NJ, Humana Press, 2003, pp 135–149 Whitman S, Hermann B, Black R, et al: Psychopathology and seizure type in children with epilepsy. Psychol Med 12:843–853, 1982 Achenbach T, Edelbrock C: Manual for the Child Behavior Checklist and Revised Child Behavior Profile. Burlington, VT, Thomas M Achenbach, 1983 Lewis DO, Pincus JH, Shanok SS, et al: Psychomotor epilepsy and violence in a group of incarcerated adolescent boys. Am J Psychiatry 139:882–887, 1982
88
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
25. Hermann BP, Whitman S: Behavioral and personality correlates of epilepsy: a review, methodological critique and conceptual model. Psychol Bull 95:451–497, 1984 26. Mendez MF, Doss RC, Taylor JL: Interictal violence in epilepsy. J Nerv Ment Dis 181:566–569, 1993 27. Raine A: The Psychopathology of Crime: Criminal Behavior as a Clinical Disorder. New York, Academic Press, 1993 28. Tonkonogy JM: Violence and temporal lesion: head CT and MRI data. J Neuropsychiatry 3:189–196, 1991 29. Gunn J: Medical-legal aspects of epilepsy, in Epilepsy and Psychiatry. Edited by Reynolds EH, Trimble MR. Edinburgh, UK, Churchill Livingstone, 1981, pp 165–174 30. People v Grant, 46 Ill App 125, 360 NE 2d 809 (1977) 31. Model Penal Code, Section 2.01, American Law Institute, Philadelphia, PA, 1962 32. Eigen JP: Unconscious Crime. Baltimore, MD, Johns Hopkins University Press, 2003 33. Morris N: Somnambulistic homicide: ghosts, spiders, and North Koreans. Res Judicate 5:29–32, 1951 34. American Psychiatric Association: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th Edition, Text Revision. Washington, DC, American Psychiatric Association, 2000 35. Severino SK, Moline MJ: Premenstrual Syndrome: A Clinician’s Guide (Diagnoses and Treatment of Mental Disorders). New York, Guilford, 1989 36. Moos RH: A typology of menstrual cycle symptoms. Am J Obstet Gynecol 103:390–402, 1969 37. Dalton K: Menstruation and crime. Br Med J 2:1752–1753, 1961 38. Horney J: Menstrual cycles and criminal responsibility. Law Hum Behav 2:25–36, 1978 39. Olweus D, Mattsson A, Schalling D, et al: Testosterone, aggression, physical, and personality dimensions in normal adolescent males. Psychosom Med 42:253–269, 1980 40. Rada RT, Laws DR, Kellner R, et al: Personal testosterone levels in the rapist. Psychosom Med 38:257–268, 1976 41. Rada RT, Kellner R, Stivastava C, et al: Plasma androgens in violent and nonviolent sex offenders. J Am Acad Psychiatry Law 11:149–158, 1983 42. Money J, Dalry J: Sexual disorders: hormonal and drug therapy, in Handbook of Sexology. Edited by Money J, Musaph H. Amsterdam, The Netherlands, Elsevier/North Holland, 1977, pp 1303–1310 43. Tardiff K, Sweillam A: Assault, suicide and mental illness. Arch Gen Psychiatry 37:164–169, 1980 44. Bain J, Langevin R, Dickey R, et al: Sex hormones in murderers and assaulters. Behav Sci Law 5:95–101, 1987 45. Green R: Sexual Science and the Law. Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press, 1992
Biological Factors in Homicide
89
46. Brewin CR: Posttraumatic Stress Disorder: Malady or Myth? New Haven, CT, Yale University Press, 2003 47. Papanastassiou M, Waldron G, Boyle J , et al: Post-traumatic stress disorder in mentally ill perpetrators of homicide. Journal of Forensic Psychiatry and Psychology 15:66–75, 2004 48. Asberg M, Traskman L, Thoren P: 5-HIAA in the cerebrospinal fluid: a suicide predictor? Arch Gen Psychiatry 33:1193–1197, 1976 49. Brown GL, Goodwin FK, Ballenger JC, et al: Aggression in humans correlates with cerebrospinal fluid amine metabolites. Psychiatry Res 1:131–139, 1979 50. Lidberg L, Tuck JR, Asberg M, et al: Homicide, suicide and CSF 5-HIAA. Acta Psychiatr Scand 71:230–236, 1985 51. Linnoila M, Virkkunen M, Scheinin M, et al: Low cerebrospinal fluid 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid concentration differentiates impulsive from nonimpulsive violent behavior. Life Sci 33:2609–2614, 1983 52. Maiuro RD, Eberle JA: New developments in research on aggression: an international report. Violence Vict 4:3–15, 1989 53. Brown G, Kline W, Goyer P, et al: Relationship of childhood characteristics to cerebrospinal fluid 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid in aggressive adults, in Proceedings of World Congress of Biological Psychiatry, Vol 7. Edited by Shagass C, Josiassen R, Bridger W, et al. New York, Elsevier, 1985, pp 177–179 54. Davidson RJ, Putnam KM, Larson CL: Dysfunction in the neural circuitry of emotion regulation: a possible prelude to violence. Science 289:591–594, 2000 55. Lesch KP: The serotonergic dimension of aggression and violence, in Neurobiology of Aggression. Edited by Mattson MP. Totowa, NJ, Humana Press, 2003, pp 33–63 56. East WN: The Relation of the Skull and Brain to Crime. Edinburgh, UK, Oliver and Boyd, 1928 57. Gottfredson MR, Hirschi T: A General Theory of Crime. Stanford, CA, Stanford University Press, 1990 58. Linno LA, Charney DS: The neurobiology of aggression, in Neurobiology of Mental Illness. Edited by Charney DS, Nestler EJ, Bunney BS. New York, Oxford University Press, 1999, pp 855–871 59. Damasio H, Grabowski T, Frank R, et al: The return of Phineas Gage: the skull of a famous patient yields clues about the brain. Science 264:1102– 1105, 1994 60. Stuss DT, Knight RT (eds): Principles of Frontal Lobe Function. New York, Oxford University Press, 2002 61. Niehoff D: The Biology of Violence. New York, Free Press, 1999 62. Flor-Henry P: On certain aspects of the localization of the central systems regulating and determining emotion. Biol Psychiatry 14:677–698, 1979 63. Yeudall LT: A neuropsychological perspective of persistent juvenile delinquency and criminal behavior: a discussion, in Forensic Psychology and Psychiatry. Edited by Wright F, Bahn C, Reiber RW. New York, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1980, pp 349–355
90
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
64. Hare RD: Psychopathy and laterality of cerebral function. J Abnorm Psychol 88:605–610, 1979 65. Nachshon I, Denno D: Violent behavior and cerebral hemisphere function, in The Causes of Crime: New Biological Approaches. Edited by Mednick SA, Moffitt TE, Stack SA. New York, Cambridge University Press, 1987, pp 185–217 66. Volkow ND, Tancreedi LR, Grant C, et al: Brain glucose metabolism in violent psychiatric patients: a preliminary study. Psychiatry Res 61:243–253, 1995 67. Soderstrom H, Tallberg M, Wikkelso C, et al: Reduced regional cerebral blood flow in nonpsychotic violent offenders. Psychiatry Res 98:29–41, 2000 68. Raine A, Buchsbaum MS, LaCasse L: Brain abnormalities in murderers indicated by positron emission tomography. Biol Psychiatry 42:495–508, 1997 69. James R, Blair R, Charney DS: Emotion regulation: an affective neuroscience approach, in Neurobiology of Aggression. Edited by Mattson MP. Totowa, NJ, Humana Press, 2003, pp 21–32 70. Moffitt TE: The neuropsychology of delinquency: a critical review of theory and research, in Crime and Justice: An Annual Review of Research, Vol 12. Edited by Morris N, Tonry M. Chicago, IL, University of Chicago Press, 1990, pp 99–120 71. Denno DW: Biology and Violence: From Birth to Adulthood. New York, Cambridge University Press, 1990 72. Farrington DP: Key issues in studying the biosocial bases of violence, in Biosocial Bases of Violence. Edited by Raine A, Brennan PA, Farrington DP, et al. New York, Plenum, 1997, pp 293–304
CHAPTER
3 SCHIZOPHRENIA, DELUSIONAL DISORDERS, AND THE PREDICTION PROBLEM REGARDING HOMICIDE
THE PROBLEM OF DETERMINING the relationship between homicide and schizophrenia is a subset of the broader problem of the relationship between violence and any type of mental illness. Making valid and reliable predictive statements about such a relationship is an elusive process. Some homicides are bizarre and can only be understood in the context of psychotic thought processes. Schizophrenic individuals or individuals with a blatant delusional system are often thought of as being “crazy,” with the media sometimes helping to foster this image. The connotation is that these people are running loose in the community and likely to be violent. One persistent scientific question, then, is, why does it remain so difficult to predict homicidal violence within this group of individuals who may be so disturbed? It is understandable that it is difficult to predict violence occurring in connection with other types of mental disorders, because individuals with those disorders do not act so strikingly bizarre, but it would seem that it should be easier to make predictions at least in connection with individuals who are exhibiting psychotic symptoms as part of their disorder. However, it is a very difficult process, and even more difficult regarding individuals who live quietly with their psychotic thoughts prior to a homicidal act.
91
92
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
PUBLIC IMAGE OF MENTALLY ILL INDIVIDUALS AS BEING “CRAZY” Males and, to an increasing extent, females who have engaged in various types of killings for which the motive has never been clarified are often simply placed in an amorphous category of “crazy killers.” This popular image of mentally ill people as being violent is shaped by the endless stream of novels involving violence and killing as well as television portrayals that are constructed from or based on actual killings. It is easy to see how this image was reinforced in the twentieth century, at least up through the 1950s, when mentally ill patients were involuntarily committed to psychiatric hospitals, and the public saw them as a group of strange people who needed to be isolated from the rest of the community. However, a study in the late 1990s in the American population found that 61% believed that people with schizophrenia are either “very likely” or “somewhat likely” to do something violent to others.1 One might have thought that by the twenty-first century, as mentally ill patients were gradually moved into communities and being maintained there with psychotropic medications, the public’s increased contact with them might have ameliorated their image problem. In reality, the assumption behind deinstitutionalization—that these patients would be treated effectively in the community setting—has largely remained unfulfilled, with the result that large numbers of homeless, victimized, mentally ill individuals live on the streets of all major American cities and cannot access needed treatment. Thus deinstitutionalization may have had the opposite effect on the public; rather than revising their image of mentally ill patients, members of the public, who lack the tools for understanding the plight of these people, have become more frightened from their increased encounters with the mentally ill in their communities. It should be noted that the image of mentally deranged individuals or “lunatics” being violent evolved in earlier centuries—a good deal earlier than the institution of involuntary hospitalization processes. Hence, it is not likely that the image problem will abate in the near future. The question remains as to whether mentally ill individuals merely carry the image of being crazy people and being more homicidally violent or actually are violent. Depending on the answer to this question, several specific implications are presented. One is whether the social policy and legal decisions that have shifted large numbers of mentally ill people into the community have been correct. If it is established that mentally ill individuals do in fact commit an inordinate number of homicidal acts, then community policies, practices for releasing mentally ill individuals into the community, and current civil commitment criteria will need to be reexamined.
Schizophrenia, Delusional Disorders, and Homicide
93
An interesting paradox arises when a comparison is made between mentally ill individuals who have committed violent acts and nonmentally ill individuals who have committed sexual offenses. Courts have upheld statutes and legislation related to psychopathic individuals who commit sexual crimes that allow them to be detained long after their criminal sentences have expired.2 Their extended confinement is justified on the pretext of a civil commitment process based on their alleged dangerousness, even though they have never been diagnosed with a major mental illness and treatment results for this legal category are questionable. Similar questions may arise about how schizophrenic individuals who commit homicide should be handled by the criminal justice system, even for those who reach a state of remission and then commit homicide. It may be argued that schizophrenic individuals who commit homicide deserve sentences as long as those currently being imposed on other, nonmentally ill individuals convicted of homicide in the United States. This would mean that in the case of first-degree murder, the sentencing under capital punishment should be carried out as provided in the statutes now on the books in 38 states. The public’s desire for retribution, accompanied by assumptions of the schizophrenic individuals’ potential and continued dangerousness, can be a powerful influence on juries and judges deciding punishments in terms of a justdeserts model. Studies of the prevalence of mental illness among homeless individuals have provided widely varying estimates, in part because the definitions of mental illness used are unclear. A further difficulty is that some studies on the prevalence of schizophrenia often exclude “street people” because they are more difficult to reach and include for survey purposes. Nonetheless, the studies that have been conducted seem to indicate that 30%–40% of homeless people may have a major type of mental illness. 3 When bizarre homicidal acts occur in communities, glaring headlines and coverage may focus on this group, with the specious rationalization by civil libertarians that such acts reflect or should reflect community norms of “the right to be crazy.” The New York case of Juan Gonzalez illustrates the problem. Gonzalez had initially told the staff at a Manhattan shelter, “I am going to kill. God told me so. Jesus wants me to kill.” After being sent to a hospital, he was released within 48 hours, and 48 additional hours he later stabbed nine people aboard the Staten Island Ferry, resulting in two deaths. Another case that garnered publicity was that of Jorge Delgado, who clubbed an usher to death at St. Patrick’s Cathedral in New York City after running through the church naked.4 Similar cases, with their dramatization of bizarre homicidal violence, continue to occur in every major American city.
94
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
VALIDITY OF PREDICTING VIOLENCE IN MENTALLY ILL INDIVIDUALS Overextension of Psychiatric Expertise The increasing interdependence of the legal and the mental health systems over time has become a double-edged sword. Psychiatric expertise has been expanded into areas beyond civil commitment and “not guilty by reason of insanity” issues, such as in the areas of diverse competency questions, assessment of sex offenders’ responsibility for their acts, assessment of sex offenders for treatment programs, or matters of sentencing and release from penal institutions or psychiatric hospitals. Psychiatrists, and increasingly other mental health workers, are asked to assess individuals’ dangerousness as well as diagnose any mental illnesses. The consequences of psychiatrists and others being asked to do more than they were obliged to do or might be capable of, in what many consider to be an overextension of their expertise, have been inevitable. For example, psychiatrists have begun to be held legally accountable for missing predictions of homicidal violence in civil cases. Perhaps this turn of events was to be expected, given the legal cases in which psychiatrists (and other mental health personnel in similar roles) have been found to have a duty to warn third parties of possible violence from patients. This legal burden was subsequently expanded to the principle of the “duty to protect” others, in which a psychiatrist was held to a standard of making a prediction of violence so that third parties would not be injured. These types of predictions would then be seen as mandatory exceptions to confidentiality analogous to laws that were enacted requiring physicians, or perhaps mental health professionals, to report certain communicable diseases, gunshot wounds, child abuse cases, or in some states narcotic addiction. The difference is that in cases involving violence potential, the professional may be held liable for not making a prediction. The academic problem of prediction must be distinguished from the practical one. Whether psychiatrists, or anyone else, can theoretically make valid predictions about the future occurrence of homicidal violence should be sharply distinguished from the practical situation of not making such a prediction and then subsequently being held legally liable for violating a duty to warn or to protect the victim.5 The denial of having such predictive talents goes to the issue of attempting to deny legal liability in malpractice cases for erroneous predictions or failure to make such predictions. The latter situation was amply discussed subsequent to the initial California case involving Tatiana Tarasoff, who was murdered by her ex-boyfriend several months after she broke off their
Schizophrenia, Delusional Disorders, and Homicide
95
relationship.6 The mentally ill boyfriend had revealed his murderous thoughts to a psychologist at a student health service; the psychologist then notified the campus police, urging them to hospitalize the man. The police felt they had no basis to hospitalize him, but it was later held that the psychologist and supervising psychiatrist could be considered liable for not warning Tarasoff that her life was potentially in danger. The reasoning, after the fact, was that the clinicians should have been able to predict the homicide, at least to the extent that they should have warned the people who were enmeshed in the patient’s delusional and violent thoughts. The validity of making such predictions has been challenged on both legal and clinical grounds. The initial legal attack was a constitutional one, involving the use of the standard of dangerousness in the civil commitment of mentally ill individuals. The validity of a dangerousness standard of prediction was challenged both on substantive and due process grounds; in the latter arena, it was argued that the process of making such predictions could lead to an unreasonable deprivation of liberty. One by-product of the legal misuse of the prediction of dangerousness standard as the criterion used for civil commitment by courts and legislative enactments from the 1970s onward was the increasing tendency to turn psychiatric hospitals into facilities whose primary purpose was the detention of those who were labeled mentally ill and dangerous rather than the treatment of mentally ill individuals. The result of this change was clearly described by Stone,7 who referred to those “incarcerated” in the hospital system as a modal psychiatric hospital population composed of the mentally ill who were thought to be dangerous. Thus the hospital populations began to consist primarily of males ages 20–40 years who floated among different psychiatric hospitals, prisons, and the community. Many of these individuals presented the problem of having comorbid diagnoses and serious character disorders mixed in with episodes of psychosis. Substance abuse and dependence were also often present. Individuals with these combined psychiatric and social disturbances have an increased potential of being violent as well as being more resistant to neuroleptic medication.
Ability to Achieve Only Weak Predictability However, another initial theoretical denouement regarding clinicians’ predictions of dangerousness came in an article that used calculations to demonstrate that dangerousness was routinely overpredicted.8 A basic problem in dealing with predicting homicidal violence is that such
96
HOMICIDE: A PSYCHIATRIC PERSPECTIVE
violence is a rare event, with a low base rate (i.e., a low incidence in the population). Because homicide itself is a rare event, a greater margin of error accompanies its prediction. Consider a hypothetical case in which the incidence of killing in a community is 1:1,000. Imagine that a test could predict those incidences with 95% accuracy. (Of course, no predictor test exists that is even close to making such accurate predictions, including those based on the best of any available clinicians’ assessments or even actuarial tables.) In this scenario, 100 of every 100,000 people would be killed, and the test would be able to predict 95 of those 100. However, another group of 4,995 people would be identified as potential killers who would not actually kill. To make sure no killer was on the loose, even with the 95% accurate instrument, the 95 plus 4,995 individuals would have to be segregated from the community. This means that 54 harmless people would be detained for every 1 person who was, in fact, dangerous, in order to ensure the community’s safety. Most individuals and groups would see this scenario as unacceptable by legal and social standards. By 1984, a “second generation” of predictors began to emerge who were less zealous in their predictions, recognizing the limits of accurate prediction.9 It had been hoped initially, perhaps too optimistically, that violence prediction could be examined from a relative rather than an absolute moral-political position, in which decisions to incapacitate people are not necessarily being made solely on clinical grounds. Predictions of violence are customarily one of two types: clinical appraisals or statistical-actuarial methods. Clinical appraisals rely on the experience and professional expertise of decision makers. Statistical or actuarial appraisals rely on weighting key characteristics that are specified in advance, then using those scores to make a statistical prediction. Statistical techniques generate rules based on analyses of data from prior cases to measure the accuracy of such rules for those prior cases as well as future cases. To the surprise of many clinicians, the actuarial method comes out ahead as a predictive technique, even over the wisest of clinicians’ judgments. One group of investigators reviewed nearly 100 comparative studies in the social science literature on the relative accuracy of clinical and statistical predictions of violence.10 In every study, the actuarial method equaled or surpassed the clinical method, sometimes by a substantial margin. Those clinicians with some grounding in probability theory try to claim that such group statistics cannot apply to single individuals or events. Yet to say that an individual has unique features not factored into the statistical prediction does not negate the possibility that he or she also has common features that feed into the generation of rules with predictive power.
Schizophrenia, Delusional Disorders, and Homicide
97
The implication of this discussion is that if a bet were to be made about the best way to make predictions, the money should be placed on a statistical-actuarial approach. Such an approach would appear to have the greatest potential for a study of homicide prediction. Of course, even here the limitations on trying to predict that a schizophrenic individual will commit a homicide in the future overwhelmingly weigh against the pr