HORTICULTURAL REVIEWS Volume 32
Horticultural Reviews is sponsored by: American Society for Horticultural Science International Society for Horticultural Science
Editorial Board, Volume 32 Jianjun Chen Thomas L. Davenport Elias Fereres
HORTICULTURAL REVIEWS Volume 32
edited by
Jules Janick Purdue University
John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
This book is printed on acid-free paper. Copyright © 2006 by John Wiley & Sons. All rights reserved. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey Published simultaneously in Canada No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning, or otherwise, except as permitted under Section 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or authorization through payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, (978) 750-8400, fax (978) 750-4470, or on the web at www.copyright.com. Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, (201) 748-6011, fax (201) 748-6008, e-mail:
[email protected]. Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty: While the publisher and author have used their best efforts in preparing this book, they make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy or completeness of the contents of this book and specifically disclaim any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. No warranty may be created or extended by sales representatives or written sales materials. The advice and strategies contained herein may not be suitable for your situation. You should consult with a professional where appropriate. Neither the publisher nor author shall be liable for any loss of profit or any other commercial damages, including but not limited to special, incidental, consequential, or other damages. For general information on our other products and services or for technical support, please contact our Customer Care Department within the United States at (800) 7622974, outside the United States at (317) 572-3993 or fax (317) 572-4002. Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic books. For more information about Wiley products, visit our web site at www.wiley.com. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data: ISBN-10: 0-471-73216-8 ISBN-13: 978-0-471-73216-7 ISSN: 0163-7851 Printed in the United States of America 10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
Contents Contributors Dedication: Margaret Sedgley
viii xi
Bryan Coombs
l.
Analyzing Fruit Tree Architecture: Implications for Tree Management and Fruit Production
1
E. Costes, P. E. Lauri, and J. L. Regnard I. II. III. IV. V.
Introduction Architectural Analysis Consequences of Tree Architecture for Tree Training, Orchard Management, and Fruit Production Conclusions Glossary Literature Cited
2. Peach Orchard Systems
2 3 29 43 45 47
63
Richard P. Marini and Luca Corelli-Grappadelli I. II. III. IV. V. VI. VII.
Introduction Crop Physiology Light Management Peach Orchard Systems Vigor-Controlling Methods for Peach Trees Limitations to High Peach Yields Future Trends and Direction Literature Cited
64 67 71 73 90 95 99 102
3. Irrigation Scheduling and Evaluation of Tree Water Status in Deciduous Orchards
111
Amos Naor v
vi
CONTENTS
I. II. III. IV. V.
Introduction The Modern Irrigation Scheduling Concept Deficit Irrigation Water Stress Assessment and Timing of Irrigation Concluding Remarks Literature Cited
4. Leucadendron: A Major Proteaceous Floricultural Crop
112 113 115 129 152 154
167
Jaacov Ben-Jaacov and Avner Silber I. II. III. IV. V.
Introduction Botany of the Genus Leucadendron World Industry and Economics Horticulture Crop Potential and Research Needs Literature Cited
5. Chinese Jujube: Botany and Horticulture
168 169 173 176 214 216
229
Mengjun Liu I. II. III. IV. V.
Introduction Botany Physiology Environmental Requirements Horticulture Literature Cited
6. Taxus spp.: Botany, Horticulture, and Source of Anti-Cancer Compounds
230 234 250 262 265 288
299
John M. DeLong and Robert K. Prange I. II. III. IV. V. VI.
Introduction Historical Botany Horticulture Pharmacology of Anti-Cancer Compounds from Taxus Conclusions Literature Cited
300 301 303 306 310 321 322
CONTENTS
vii
7. The Genus Allium: A Developmental and Horticultural Analysis
329
Rina Kamenetsky and Haim D. Rabinowitch I. II. III. IV. V. VI. VII. VIII.
Introduction Taxonomy and Geographical Distribution Genetic Resources and Possible Use of Wild Allium Species Morphological Structures and Comparisons Between Biomorphological Groups Plant Development Propagation Chemical Composition Concluding Remarks Literature Cited
8. The Invasive Plant Debate: A Horticultural Perspective
330 333 335 340 347 361 363 364 366
379
Alex X. Niemiera and Guy Phillips I. II. III. IV. V.
Introduction Perspectives Ecology of Invasive Species Regulatory Matters Conclusion Literature Cited Appendix A
380 393 406 418 430 436 443
Subject Index
447
Cumulative Subject Index
449
Cumulative Contributor Index
473
Contributors Jaacov Ben-Jaacov, Department of Ornamental Horticulture and Floriculture, Agricultural Research Organization, the Volcani Center, P.O. Box 6, Bet Dagan, Israel, 50-250,
[email protected] Bryan Coombe, The University of Adelaide, Australia Luca Corelli-Grappadelli, Dipartimento di Colture Arboree, University of Bologna, 40127 Bologna, Italy E. Costes, UMR 1098—Biologie du développement des Espèces Pérennes Cultivées, Equipe INRA-Agro.M “Architecture et Fonctionnement des Espèces Fruitières”, INRA, 2 Place Viala, 34000 Montpellier Cedex 1, France,
[email protected] John M. DeLong, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, 32 Main St., Kentville, Nova Scotia, B4N 1J5, Canada Rina Kamenetsky, Department of Ornamental Horticulture, The Volcani Center, Bet Dagan, 50250, Israel,
[email protected] P. E. Lauri, UMR 1098—Biologie du développement des Espèces Pérennes Cultivées, Equipe INRA-Agro.M “Architecture et Fonctionnement des Espèces Fruitières”, INRA, 2 Place Viala, 34000 Montpellier Cedex 1, France Mengjun Liu, Research Center of Chinese Jujube, Agricultural University of Hebei, Baoding, 071001, P. R. China,
[email protected] Richard P. Marini, Department of Horticulture, Pennsylvania State University, University Park, Pennsylvania, USA 16802-4200,
[email protected] Amos Naor, Golan Research Institute, University of Haifa, P.O. Box 97 Kazrin 12900, Israel,
[email protected] Alex X. Niemiera, Department of Horticulture, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia 24061, USA,
[email protected] Guy Phillips, Department of Forestry, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia 24061, USA
viii
CONTRIBUTORS
ix
Robert K. Prange, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, 32 Main St., Kentville, Nova Scotia, B4N 1J5, Canada,
[email protected] Haim D. Rabinowitch, Institute of Plant Science and Genetics in Agriculture, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Faculty of Agricultural, Food, and Environmental Quality Sciences, Rehovot, 76100, Israel,
[email protected] J. L. Regnard, UMR 1098—Biologie du développement des Espèces Pérennes Cultivées, Equipe INRA-Agro.M “Architecture et Fonctionnement des Espèces Fruitières”, INRA, 2 Place Viala, 34000 Montpellier Cedex 1, France Avner Silber, Institute of Soil, Water and Environmental Sciences, Agricultural Research Organization, the Volcani Center, P.O. Box 6, Bet Dagan, Israel, 50-250,
[email protected]
Margaret Sedgley
Dedication: Margaret Sedgley This volume of Horticultural Reviews is dedicated to Professor Margaret Sedgley in recognition of her outstanding contributions to horticultural science and to the work of the University of Adelaide. Margaret was born in Oldham, Lancashire, UK and in her late teens was attracted to horticultural science because of the wide range of crops and problems available for study and the promise of applying new and innovative techniques, including microanalysis and molecular biology. Margaret’s university training was at Leeds where she received a B.Sc. (Hons.) in 1970, and in 1974 received her Ph.D. from University of St. Andrews with her work conducted at the Scottish Horticultural Research Institute, Dundee. The rest of her scientific career, from 1974 to the present, has been based in Adelaide. Initially Margaret joined the CSIRO Division of Horticultural Research, attaining the level of Principal Research Scientist in 1985. She then crossed the road to the Department of Plant Physiology of the Waite Agricultural Research Institute, The University of Adelaide, where she became Reader in Horticultural Science. This department was melded with grape and wine researchers from Roseworthy Agricultural College to form the Department of Horticulture, Viticulture and Oenology, of which she was appointed Deputy Head in 1993 and became Head of the Department and Professor of Horticultural Science in 1995. The new arrangements coincided with the mushrooming of undergraduate and graduate student numbers, and an expansion of facilities bringing a heavy administrative load. The scarcity of female professors in the university meant an additional load when sex balancing of committee membership was introduced. Professor Sedgley managed such matters with competence and flair and at the same time handled a huge research program. Summarising her scientific work is a humbling exercise because of its breadth, depth, and sheer volume. This is despite the fact that horticultural industries have been parsimonious in the funding of research. The number of publications that include her name now stands at 528 and is made up of 174 papers in refereed journals, 187 publications and articles, 146 presentations to scientific meetings, 19 chapters, symposia and reviews, and 2 books. She was senior author of a significant proportion of these. In 1981 her work was recognised by the P.L. Goldacre xi
xii
DEDICATION: MARGARET SEDGLEY
award for distinguished research in plant physiology and, in 1983, the Regents Lectureship of the University of California. A scan of Margaret’s publication list reveals a central theme of the reproductive biology of higher plants comprising the pistil-pollen interaction, outcrossing mechanisms, and breeding methodology. But opportunistic topics are evident such as “Anatomical characteristics affecting the musical performance of clarinet reeds made from Arundo donax L.” The number of her publications increased with each successive five-year period; indeed, 323 (61% of the total) were published in the last ten years. In addition, during that same period she received 41 research grants totalling 7.7 million Australian dollars. She has close ties with a large number of industry bodies and also with the Australian Research Council. Margaret considers her major achievements to be elucidation of outcrossing mechanisms of horticultural plants; matching avocado cultivar to climate, based on flowering biology; domestication of Australian native plants, including quandong (Santalum), Banksia, Acacia, Eucalyptus, bush tomato (Solanum centrale); development of the first three cultivars of Banksia for cut stem production; use of Australian native bees for crop pollination; establishment of the first Australian almond breeding programme; and survey of Australian feral olive germplasm for superior genotype; establishment of the first breeding programme in the world of eucalypts for cut flower production; application of molecular techniques to horticultural plant breeding in Australia, including meiotic maps, molecular marker development, and PCR-based virus testing; and investigation of a new and unique bacterial disease of pistachio. One of Margaret’s major strengths is her ability to successfully put together projects involving the coordination of large numbers of research staff. She has a policy of keeping people informed through regular, productive meetings that include all levels of project staff members. They are invariably good-humoured and passers-by of the meeting rooms often hear Margaret’s hearty laughter, a trademark of her relaxed but efficient style of administration. Another quality is her skill in addressing visiting groups or making introductions; no matter how complicated the occasion Margaret conveys, without notes, all points appropriate for the audience. Margaret’s love of horticulture naturally extends to her own garden, a large area in the Adelaide Hills, full of plants representing many horticultural genera. It has often been the site of many a social gathering. Altogether, Professor Sedgley is an inspiring leader and a very productive scientist and we are grateful that she chose to work with us. Bryan Coombe The University of Adelaide
1 Analyzing Fruit Tree Architecture: Implications for Tree Management and Fruit Production E. Costes, P. É. Lauri, and J. L. Regnard UMR 1098—Biologie du développement des Espèces Pérennes Cultivées Equipe INRA-Agro.M “Architecture et Fonctionnement des Espèces Fruitières” INRA, 2 Place Viala, 34000 Montpellier Cedex 1, France
I. INTRODUCTION II. ARCHITECTURAL ANALYSIS A. General Concepts B. Defining Architectural Models of Fruit Tree Species 1. Identifying Shoot Types 2. Analyzing Branching 3. Examples of Architectural Analysis in Fruit Trees 4. Describing the Intra-Species Variability of Tree Architecture C. Quantitative Studies of Fruit Tree Topology 1. Primary Growth 2. Branching Patterns 3. Location of Flowering 4. Meristem and Shoot Mortality D. Describing Fruit Tree Form 1. Measuring a 3D Form 2. Models for Representing Whole Tree or Row Form 3. Modeling Axis Form Changes 4. Models for Representing the Organ Distributions within Canopy III. CONSEQUENCES OF TREE ARCHITECTURE FOR TREE TRAINING, ORCHARD MANAGEMENT, AND FRUIT PRODUCTION A. Initial Choices of the Grower and Young Tree Training 1. Rootstock Effects 2. Tree Development and Initial Fruit Production
Horticultural Reviews, Volume 32, Edited by Jules Janick ISBN 0-471-73216-8 © 2006 John Wiley & Sons 1
2
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
B. Adult Tree Training 1. Fruit Load Effects on Tree Growth, Architecture, and Ecophysiology 2. Consequences for Fruit Thinning 3. Implementation of Adult Tree Training Procedures IV. CONCLUSIONS V. GLOSSARY LITERATURE CITED
I. INTRODUCTION High yield performance of fruit crops results from the integration of various components, which, pieced together, constitute the “orchard system puzzle” (Barritt 1992). They are implemented at two different time scales: a set of initial choices determines the basic components of the orchard during its life-span (support system, tree arrangement and quality, density, rootstock and cultivar), and a set of annual procedures that is closely related to the training system but evolves from one year to the next (pruning, training, and thinning practices). These components are strongly related to each other and they need to be assembled properly to ensure good economic results (Hoying and Robinson 2000). Provided that techniques are compatible, a large range of combinations is possible. In all cases, however, the training system should integrate the following objectives: (1) light capture needs to be optimized at the orchard scale, in order to obtain a high biomass production (e.g., Jackson 1980); (2) canopy porosity to light (Lakso 1994) should be as high as possible to improve light distribution between fruiting structures (Lakso and Corelli-Grappadelli 1992; Wünsche and Lakso 2000) and to lower the variability in fruit quality; (3) biomass must be partitioned to fruiting shoots, as demonstrated in apple (Lespinasse and Delort 1993) or avocado (Thorp and Stowell 2001); and (4) competition with vegetative sinks by inappropriate heading cuts, which stimulates tree growth and vigor as shown in kiwi (Miller et al. 2001), should be avoided. It is therefore of major importance to develop training concepts that optimally combine training and management systems at the orchard scale and training methods at the tree scale (pruning, bending). At both levels, an accurate knowledge of growth, branching, and flowering processes within the tree canopy, i.e., tree architecture, is thus required to optimize tree manipulation adapted to the plant material. In the first section, we will present the main concepts that are used in architectural analysis and illustrate how they have been introduced and applied to fruit species, from both a qualitative and quantitative point of view. The
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
3
second section will present the consequences of fruit tree architectural analysis for tree and orchard management, especially regarding the manipulation of both vegetative and floral organs at the tree level.
II. ARCHITECTURAL ANALYSIS In the last 20 years, architectural analysis of plants has led to the development of new approaches to horticulture from the acquisition of knowledge about tree development to the study of intra-species variations of related characters and, in more applied aspects, to the improvement of fruit tree management at the orchard level. Architectural analysis was introduced in a botanical and forestry context by Hallé and co-workers (Hallé and Oldeman 1970; Hallé et al. 1978) by observing the whole tree with a particular focus on the dynamics of development. From these studies, a general comprehensive framework of the invariant features and rules that are responsible for a tree’s architecture has been extracted. This procedure has been shown to apply to all plant species (Hallé et al. 1978), while the rules are defined at the species scale. Applications developed in horticulture have focused mainly on two within-tree scales: (1) organ arrangement, including both vegetative and floral organs, and their relative equilibrium, and (2) fruiting branches and whole tree behavior. These two scales constitute a basic framework that is then used to interpret the effect of agronomical practices at the tree and orchard scales. A. General Concepts For many years, the diversity of plant morphology has been fascinating scientists and has been extensively studied from both a scientific and philosophic point of view, e.g., Goethe (1790) and Arber (1950). Plant form diversity results from differences in organ morphology and from differences in constructional organization (Bell 1991). The constructional organization of trees, also called architecture, results from the activity of the meristems. All plant organs are made of cells and tissues, which initially organize within a meristematic zone. Thus, a tree, whatever its final size, is initially constructed by the activity of at least two primary meristems (one for the aerial part, one for the root system) or possibly more, and to a lesser extent, by the activity of secondary meristems, which are responsible for the diameter increment of woody axes (Hallé et al. 1978). After observation of the aerial meristem activity in many species, Hallé and co-workers proposed a classification of the aerial organization
4
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
of trees into four main categories. The first two categories separate trees constructed by a single aerial meristem (monoaxial trees) or several meristems (polyaxial trees) (Fig. 1.1). Polyaxial trees are thus split into three subcategories based on the differentiation state of axes produced by meristems: (1) all meristems have a similar activity and produce equivalent non-differentiated axes, (2) different meristems have different potentialities and produce different axis types (i.e., differentiated axes), and (3) a given meristem changes its activity with time and produces mixed axes, i.e., axes whose basal and top parts have different organization. Within these four main categories, finer classes are considered that are named “architectural models” and are dedicated to famous botanists. The model definitions are based on the concept of “axis differentiation,” which combines five main morphological criteria all related to the meristem activity: (1) the growth direction associated with phyllotaxy makes it possible to distinguish plagiotropic from orthotropic axes. Plagiotropic axes are characterized by a horizontal to oblique growth direction with alternate or distic phyllotaxy and a plane symmetry, while orthotropic axes combine vertical growth with a spiral phyllotaxy and axial symmetry; (2) the growth rhythm can be either continuous or rhythmic. In case of rhythmic growth, the portion of axis developed during the same growing period is called a growth unit (GU); (3) the branching mode (monopodial versus sympodial), position (acrotonic versus basitonic, i.e., long shoots located respectively in the top or basal part of the bearer shoot), and dynamics (immediate or sylleptic vs. delayed or proleptic); (4) the sexual differentiation of meristems; and (5) the polymorphism of axes that allows distinguishing between short (brachyblasts), medium (mesoblasts), and long (auxiblasts) shoots. The proposed classification, composed of 23 models, provided a framework for analyzing plant architecture and led to observations of the
(a)
(b)
Fig. 1.1. Example of monoaxial (a) and polyaxial trees (b) belonging, respectively, to Holtum and Troll models (Source: Hallé, Oldman, and Tomlinson. Tropical Trees and Forests, p. 84, 97. With permission of Springer Science and Business Media.)
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
5
developmental dynamics of trees, at the whole tree scale, and the identification of phenomena that are invariant with respect to the environment (Hallé et al. 1978). This approach showed that it was possible to account for the variability of all higher plants by defining a limited number of developmental patterns, defined at the whole tree and axis scales (Edelin 1981; Remphrey and Powell 1987; Caraglio and Edelin 1990; Thorp and Sedgley 1993). In parallel, other concepts emerged from the analysis of plants at both more detailed and more global scales than axes, and from the observation of the repetitive nature of tree construction that results from repetitions of similar organs or sets of organs. At a more detailed scale, a particular focus has been put on metamer or phytomer repetition (White 1979; Barlow 1989) since this entity is composed of a node and its leaf(ves) and axillary bud(s) plus the subtending internode, thereby constituting the basic element of plant construction. However, the repeated entities are not exactly similar and their development was shown to change with their position within the tree structure and during plant development. Different concepts have been proposed to account for the existence of different metamer states and bud fates: “morphogenetic program” and internal correlation (Nozeran 1984), “age state” (Gatsuk et al. 1980), or “physiological age” of the meristems (Barthélémy et al. 1997). Even though the changes in bud fate and entity states are specific to each species and lead to the differentiation of axes (e.g., orthotropic versus plagiotropic axes; short versus long axes, etc.), general rules established for a Rauh architectural tree model are as follows (Barthélémy et al. 1997; Fig. 1.2): (1) an increase in shoot length and in axillary shoot development during an initial period (observed in seedlings and called “establishment growth”); (2) a period of stability during which specific branching gradients can be observed (such as acrotony); and (3) a progressive decrease in shoot length growth and in axillary shoot development towards the final development stage or aging. At the whole-tree scale, two concepts have been introduced in order to define the branching system. First, the concept of “organization plan” has been proposed to account for the hierarchic level between the constitutive axes of a tree (Edelin 1991). The terms hierarchic versus polyarchic were introduced to indicate a hierarchy between main shoots and their laterals, respectively, or conversely the absence of hierarchy. In forest trees, one easily can observe trees that develop in a hierarchic way for a few years before developing a fork and becoming polyarchic. Second, the concept of excurrent versus decurrent trees has been introduced, in relation to apical dominance, in forest trees (Brown et al. 1967). These terms, which refer to a definitive main stem producing lateral
6
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
Fig. 1.2. Schematic representation of architectural gradients in a tree belonging to the Rauh model (Source: Barthélémy et al. 1997).
branches (excurrent) or a main stem that spreads and becomes indistinguishable from the uppermost branches (decurrent), have probably been among the most commonly used in classifications of forest and fruit trees. We will present how these concepts, whether applied at the tree, branching system, axis, or metamer scales, have been used in fruit tree species. First, qualitative concepts will be considered to define the architectural models of several fruit species. Second, quantitative studies will be described to highlight architectural edification rules as well as morphological gradients in fruit species. The following section will thus develop how the architecture of fruit trees has been or can be analyzed. The last section will present how these results were integrated to improve tree training and led to the proposal of new training systems.
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
7
B. Defining Architectural Models of Fruit Tree Species 1. Identifying Shoot Types. The identification of architectural models in a given species first requires identifying the categories of shoots that are observed within the tree structure, on the basis of morphological criteria. As with many other species, fruit trees exhibit a polymorphic development of axes (Fig. 1.3). Usually, two main shoot categories, i.e., short and long shoots, are distinguished by a simple visual observation (Champagnat 1965; Zimmerman and Brown 1971). Champagnat (1965) used three criteria to define short shoots (or brachyblasts): a limited length,
(c) Long shoots
(a) Spurs
(b) Medium shoots Fig. 1.3. Heteroblastic development of shoots in fruit tree: Example of shoot types in an apple branch. (a) Spurs, (b) medium shoots, and (c) long shoots (Original drawing from J. M. Lespinasse reprinted by his courtesy).
8
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
a limited number of organs, and possibly a limited life span. An equivalent definition, based on morphological characters at the metamer level and on shoot growth dynamics, has been proposed (Rivals 1965, 1966, 1967): short shoots are made of organs contained in the resting bud (also called preformed organs), which do not elongate after bud burst. In the horticultural context, different terms have been used for short shoots, according to the species and to their floral or vegetative fate (Champagnat 1954b; Forshey et al. 1992). In pome fruit species, short shoots have been named “dards” when they are strictly vegetative or “spurs” when they are usually floral. In stone fruits they have been named “bouquets de mai” or “clusters” with respect to their early cessation of growth after bud burst. By contrast, long shoots are possibly made of (1) preformed organs solely, whose internodes elongate, or (2) preformed organs followed by neoformed organs resulting from apical growth (Rivals 1965, 1966, 1967). In the first case, the final length is limited and the corresponding shoots often have been considered to be an intermediate category, that of mesoblasts. In a horticultural context, other terms have been used for intermediate shoots according to the fruit species, such as “brindles” in apple or pear, and “chiffonnes” or “mixed shoot” in stone fruit species (Boyes 1922; Champagnat 1954a). In the second case, shoots result from both internodal growth of the preformed shoot and apical growth, which produces a neoformed part, and generally form long shoots. These shoots have been named auxiblasts but occasionally are called “water shoots” in horticulture when growth is extended and/or rate is high. The term “extension shoots” is also widely used for long shoots in both stone and pome fruits. However, most of the horticultural terms have the disadvantage of not strictly fitting with a clearly defined biological phenomenon such as internodal growth and apical growth, or with shoots composed of preformed or neoformed organs. In addition, horticultural terms are often ambiguous with respect to the perennial development of shoots. Indeed, terms can refer either to the result of annual growth or the total growth occurring over several years. For instance, a “spur” can simply be a oneyear-old short shoot or consist of a perennial set of branched shoots, which have all remained short. As a consequence, there is no adequate term in horticulture that can be used to speak of a short annual shoot occurring in the second, third, or fourth year of growth on a long axis. Considering more detailed levels of organization such as growth units (GU) and metamers, even though there are no equivalent horticultural terms, is thus necessary to describe precisely the development of fruit trees over successive years.
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
9
2. Analyzing Branching. In addition to the identification of shoot types, architectural analysis of a tree requires studying whole tree development, analyzing the relative position of the shoots one to another, i.e., tree topology, all over the tree ontogeny. Architectural analysis is made difficult for fruit trees because training systems generally alter tree architecture, often by pruning. Pruning cuts promote local re-growth, which interacts with the natural growth and branching patterns. Thus it appears more convenient, at least as a first step of investigation, to analyze the architectural development of trees grown with minimal training, in particular without severe pruning over several years. The interactions between tree architecture and the agronomic practices then can constitute a second step in the investigations, based on the knowledge of the tree developmental rules. Section III will detail how this second step can be carried out. In temperate climates, investigations of the branching process of fruit trees have focused on one-year-old shoots and on the winter period, because key events, such as apical dominance and bud dormancy, occur at this level of organization and during this period of time. These two main events lead to correlative relationships between buds and dictate the organization of the one-year-old shoot. According to Cline (1997, 2000), apical dominance is defined as the control exerted by the shoot apex on the outgrowth of axillary buds. Its morphological consequence is the inhibition of axillary buds during the growing season when they are formed, often described under the term “bud dormancy.” Research on tree morphogenesis (Crabbé 1980; Champagnat 1989) has initiated the reappraisal of this generic term and led to the differentiation of three different physiological states of the bud—ecodormancy, paradormancy, and endodormancy (Lang et al. 1987)—depending on whether bud inhibition is conditioned on environmental causes or on a correlation with other tree parts, or lies within the bud itself, respectively. Apical dominance involves different correlative mechanisms mediated by auxin and cytokinins (Cline 2000; Sussex and Kerk 2001) and the nutritional status of the axillary buds (Champagnat 1989). However, there are exceptions to the general pattern of apical dominance since some lateral buds can develop during the growing season in which they are formed, producing sylleptic shoots (Champagnat 1954b) (Fig. 1.4). For a review of terms used for branching, see Caraglio and Barthélémy (1997). The capability of axillary buds to develop into sylleptic shoots depends on the parent shoot relative growth rate (Génard et al. 1994; Lauri and Costes 1995) and on the stage of tree maturity. In fruit trees, sylleptic shoots mainly develop during the early developmental years (Crabbé 1987), such as “feathers” in the nursery,
10
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD -1-
-2-
(a)
(b)
(a)
(b)
-3-
(a)
(b)
(c)
Fig. 1.4. Axillary shoot positions and associated terminology regarding branching: 1 (a) monopodial, (b) sympodial; 2 (a) sylleptic, (b) proleptic; 3 (a) acrotonic, (b) mesotonic, (c) basitonic (Source: Caraglio and Barthélémy 1997).
and these branches are considered to be advantageous for young tree establishment (Maggs 1960; van Oosten 1984). Naturally occurring sylleptic shoots have been shown to be naturally located in a median position along the bearing shoot in apple (Costes and Lauri 1995; Costes and Guédon 1997) and peach trees (Lauri 1991; Fournier 1994). This distribution makes it possible to select among these shoots, retaining some of them and pruning those located in the lower part of the trunk or possibly including other criteria for further tree training. Except in the case of sylleptic development, axillary buds develop along the one-year-old shoot, after having passed the three stages of dormancy previously described. In this case, they are called proleptic or delayed shoots (Crabbé 1987), and the axillary shoot development strongly depends on the bud position along the bearer shoot (see Fig. 1.4). In temperate fruit trees, the distribution of laterals most commonly corresponds to an acrotonic distribution, i.e., the longest laterals are located near (just below) the apical (distal) end of the one-year-old shoot (Champagnat 1965; Champagnat et al. 1971). Such a distribution has been described in many species, like apple (Crabbé 1987; Cook et al. 1998b), apricot (Costes et al. 1992), plum (Cook et al. 1998a), and walnut (Solar and Stampar 2003). Quantitative investigations and modeling of lateral distribution are described in section II.C.2 (Branching Patterns).
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
11
3. Examples of Architectural Analysis in Fruit Trees. In the following paragraphs suppress applications of architectural analysis will be illustrated for two main fruit species with contrasting architecture, apple and cherry tree. Complementary elements will also be provided regarding two other Prunus species, apricot and peach tree. For the apple tree, numerous studies in the literature must be compiled to obtain a complete description of its architectural development. Primary growth is usually rhythmic (Zanette 1981; Abbott 1984) and the successive leaves spread along an axis with a spiral phyllotaxy whose angle varies from 3/8 to 2/5 (Abbott 1984; Pratt 1990). Branching remains monopodial before the occurrence of flowering and lateral branches are displayed according to acrotony (Crabbé 1987). Thus, during the juvenile phase, which can be defined in a young seedling tree as a state characterized by the inability to flower (Miller 1988), or during the vegetative state of a non-flowering scion, the apple tree develops according to a Rauh model (Lauri and Térouanne 1995). The different shoot categories that can be identified within an apple tree are often classified into two or three types, based on their length and on their constitutive growth unit types (see Fig. 1.3). Short axes (or spurs) are composed only of short GUs whose constitutive metamers elongate slightly or not at all. As a rule of thumb, the length of each constitutive GU is less than 5 cm. Two types of short GU can be distinguished according to whether the apical meristem is differentiated into an inflorescence (flowering GU) or not (vegetative GU). In the case of floral GU, a leafy basal part is followed by a floral distal part (Fulford 1966a, b; Abbott 1984). This GU, whose diameter is often increased by the presence of an inflorescence and fruit development, is usually named a “bourse.” “Brindle” or medium shoots are constituted of GUs whose lengths reach 6 to 20 cm (Lespinasse and Delort 1993). Long GUs, also called extension shoots, correspond to GUs whose apical meristem has a prolonged activity, leading to the development of neoformed metamers. Floral differentiation, which occurs in the terminal position of axes, ends the monopodial phase. Branching on the floral GUs is immediate and sympodial ( Crabbé and Escobedo 1991). Because of the change in branching mode, from monopodial to sympodial, the architectural model of apple tree evolves from the Rauh to the Scaronne model (Lauri and Térouanne 1995). In addition, adult trees usually exhibit a polyarchic organization resulting from both their sympodial branching and gravimorphic reactions. Indeed, long shoots begin to bend usually after fruiting has begun with long re-growth developing in the upper part of curved axes (Crabbé and Lakhoua 1978). However, this tendency varies greatly among genotypes (Lauri et al. 1995).
12
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
It is worth noting that at least two other fruit species have a roughly similar architectural development to that of apple tree: pear tree, which also belongs to the Rosaceae family, and walnut tree from the Juglandaceae family. Indeed, walnut trees have a rhythmic growth, and a monopodial and acrotonic branching until flowering occurs (Sabatier et al. 1998; Sabatier and Barthélémy 1999; Solar and Stampar 2003). Terminal flowering is a discriminant feature between apple as opposed to Prunus species, since in these latter species flowers differentiate in lateral positions along one-year-old shoots, while the apical bud remains vegetative. Two cases can be distinguished that correspond to cherry or to apricot and peach trees, respectively (Fig. 1.5). In cherry trees, flowers differentiate in lateral buds located on the preformed zone of the oneyear-old shoots. Thus, after bud burst, flowers are located on the basal part of short and long shoots and are clearly separate from vegetative buds. In both apricot and peach trees, floral bud differentiation can occur in meristems located along the one-year-old shoots either directly in an axillary position or on prophylls (i.e., the first two foliar organs of a shoot) of axillary buds (see Fig. 1.6a).
1-year-old shoot
Short shoots
2-year-old shoot
(a)
(b) Flower or inflorescence Vegetative bud
Fig. 1.5. Location of floral differentiation with respect to vegetative buds and shoot organization in two Prunus species: (a) cherry tree—complete separation between floral and vegetative zones; (b) apricot or peach tree—flowers and vegetative buds associated at same nodes.
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
13
Flowering position, combined with the terminal meristem behavior, defines different tree architectures. In cherry and peach trees, the terminal meristem remains alive, leading to a monopodial branching system, while in apricot (or plum) trees the terminal meristem usually dies after each growth period, leading to sympodial branching. Thus, cherry and peach trees both correspond to the Rauh model. In particular, the cherry tree corresponds very strictly to the Rauh model definition, since it is constituted of clearly defined short and long shoots and exhibits a pronounced hierarchic structure. Moreover, the acrotonic gradient is particularly abrupt, leading to long shoots located solely on the uppermost nodes of the annual shoots and thus to a rhythmic distribution of long branches along the main axis. By contrast, in the peach tree, Lauri (1991) observed a more polyarchic organization resulting from the development of basitonic reiterated complexes. The apricot tree also exhibits a polyarchic architecture based on entirely sympodial branching and including a continuum of shoot types between short and long shoots (Costes 1993). The apricot tree provides an example of the Champagnat model, with a definite and rhythmic primary growth, sympodial branching, and long shoots that naturally bend. Shoot bending leads to the development of re-growth from short shoots or latent buds located on the upper side of the curved axes. This pattern has been shown to repeat with tree aging, leading to the formation of successive reiterated complexes whose size decreases from the center to the periphery of the trees (Fig. 1.6). Thus, the polyarchic organization can be exhibited very early in the apricot tree ontogeny. However, this whole tree organization depends on the cultivar, for some apricot cultivars, such as ‘Stark Early Orange’, exhibit a dominant central trunk throughout the life of the tree (Costes et al. 2001a) (Fig. 1.7). 4. Describing the Intra-Species Variability of Tree Architecture. While the aim of architectural studies is to extract invariant features that may adequately define the architecture of a given species, the variability that exists among cultivars in growth, branching, and flowering location must also be explored to propose optimized training methods, adapted to the different behaviors observed within a given species. Different criteria have been used to qualitatively classify cultivars within the different fruit tree species. A pioneer study in this domain was proposed by Bernhard (1961), who first attempted to type apple trees according to both the overall tree growth pattern—i.e., direction of growth of scaffold branches, from upright to weeping—and their fruiting types (types I to IV) (Fig. 1.8). Type I apple cultivars mostly bear fruits on spurs that are branched on “old wood,” whereas type IV cultivars mostly
14
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
Second growth unit: GU2 axillary bud with two flowers on its prophylls
annual shoot n+1
First growth unit: GU1
axillary bud alone
Short twigs (spurs)
(a)
annual shoot n
carrier shoot (annual shoot n) flowering shoots (annual shoots n+1 and axillary short twigs)
(b) Fig. 1.6. Apricot tree architecture. (a) Organization of annual shoots showing the sympodial branching and the location of floral buds; (b) schematic representation of apricot tree at adult stage showing the progressive decrease in size of the successive branching systems with tree aging (Source: Costes 1993).
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
15
Erect Stark Early Orange
Sortilège
Fantasme
Bergeron
Harcot
Comédie
Slender
Shoot slenderness
Goldrich
Shoot bending
Lambertin
Orange Red
Palsteyn
Weeping
Thick
Fig. 1.7. Qualitative classification of apricot varieties observed in France, based on two main criteria represented respectively in X and Y axes: (i) the shoot slenderness, (ii) shoot bending.
ideotype 1
ideotype 2
ideotype 3
ideotype 4
Fig. 1.8. Apple ideotypes from spur (type I) to weeping trees (type IV), as defined by Lespinasse (1992) based on previous studies on “fruiting types” from Bernhard (1961) and Lespinasse (1977).
16
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
bear fruit at the terminal positions on brindle-type shoots. Lespinasse and colleagues (Lespinasse 1977; Lespinasse and Delort 1986) later included a third parameter, the position of the scaffold branches along the trunk from basitonic to acrotonic. Lespinasse (1992) subsequently proposed including all spur-type cultivars in type II, restricting type I to cultivars that exhibit a typical columnar habit (mainly produced by English breeding selection programs; Tobutt 1985, 1994). Thus all spurtype apple cultivars will hereafter be considered to belong to type I/II. These spur-type cultivars are characterized by a temporal and spatial disjunction between vegetative growth and fruiting since they usually have strong, erect shoots with no or little terminal fruiting. By contrast, type IV (tip bearing type) cultivars develop fruit in terminal positions on all types of shoots, including water-shoots. These architectural features are related to fruiting pattern, with alternate vs. regular fruiting patterns, respectively (Lauri et al. 1995, 1997a, b). Between these two extremes, types II and III (standard type) have an intermediate growth and fruiting pattern. Classifications based upon similar criteria, i.e., branch orientation, position of flowering and lateral branches, have been proposed in other fruit species, such as walnut by Germain (1990, 1992). Qualitative classifications also have been proposed on the basis of shoot types or mixing shoot type with branching density, as the phenotypic classes of peach cultivars proposed by Scorza (1984) and further studied by Bassi et al. (1994) or in pear trees by Sansavini and Musacchi (1994). C. Quantitative Studies of Fruit Tree Topology The existence of generic rules and the repetitive nature of plant construction led different scientists to introduce mathematics into plant architectural studies. Different formalisms were proposed to simulate plant growth processes (Borchert and Honda 1984; Fisher and Weeks 1985; Prusinkiewicz and Lindenmayer 1990; Fisher 1992; Prusinkiewicz et al. 1997; Barczi et al. 1997). On the other hand, tree structure was explored in order to quantify the general rules of tree architecture development that were first highlighted from a qualitative and conceptual point of view. Pioneer research in this area was performed on coffee trees by introducing stochastic modeling of meristem activity (de Reffye 1981a, b, c). Four processes were considered: (1) primary growth, i.e., the dynamics of metamer emergence; (2) branching, i.e., the probability of a given axillary meristem to elongate into a shoot; (3) flowering, i.e., the probability of a given terminal or axillary meristem to develop into a flower; and (4) the probability of meristem mortality.
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
17
According to Godin et al. (1999), the measurements made to characterize plant structure and the different organs plants are composed of can be organized into two categories: (1) those dealing with the form or the spatial location of organs and therefore defining the organ geometry and (2) those that enumerate the organs and determine their relative connections, therefore defining tree topology. Topological descriptions have been designed to simultaneously integrate several organization levels using Multi-scale Tree Graph (MTG) as an underlying model (Godin and Caraglio 1998). Specific softwares, such as 3A (Adam et al. 1999) and AMAPmod (Godin et al. 1997), are currently freely available to collect data for plant architectural databases, and explore them with appropriate statistical tools, respectively. 1. Primary Growth. The number of metamers per axis has been modeled by binomial distributions on both orthotropic and plagiotropic axes of coffee trees (de Reffye 1981c). In this approach, the two parameters of a binomial distribution, p and n, represented respectively the probability that a new metamer emerged from the terminal meristem and the total number of leaves that potentially could be developed by a given axis type. This stochastic approach was adapted to fruit trees with rhythmic growth, such as litchi (Costes 1988) and apricot (Costes et al. 1992). In the case of rhythmic growth, the number of metamers developed per growth unit was modeled either by a Poisson distribution, in the case of entirely preformed organs, or by a mixture of two distributions, in the case of growth units composed of both preformed and neoformed organs (de Reffye et al. 1991). For apricot, the mixture included a binomial distribution for preformed organs and a negative binomial distribution for the neoformed part of the shoot. This formalism made it possible to demonstrate that the progressive decrease in annual shoot length over time resulted from a decrease in the number of neoformed organs, while the number of preformed organs remained almost invariant (Costes et al. 1992, Fig. 1.9). This result was consistent with the observations of Rivals (1965), who assumed a constant number of preformed primordia in resting vegetative buds, this number being at the first order specific to the species. However, within a given species, the number of preformed organs was shown to depend on bud location within branching systems (Costes 2003). Similarly, the acrotonic distribution of axillary shoots was shown to correspond to a decrease in the neoformation development of these shoots according to their position from the distal end of the initial shoot. These concepts were useful for explaining the different shoot types in Actinidia (Seleznyova et al. 2002) or the progressive decrease of successive GUs along axes in apple trees (Costes et al. 2003b).
18
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
Number of GUs
Number of GUs 1st GU 1987
2nd GU 1987
1st GU 1988
2nd GU 1988
1st GU 1989
2nd GU 1989
1st GU 1990
2nd GU 1990
1st GU 1991
2nd GU 1991
Number of metamers
Number of metamers
Fig. 1.9. Distributions of the number of metamers per growth unit (GU) during the successive years of growth (from 1987 to 1991) and for two successive GUs. The 1st GUs are represented by a set of histograms on the left and the 2nd GUs by a set of histograms on the right of the figure. For each histogram, the total number of metamers per GU was modeled as a mixture of binomial distribution representing the number of preformed organs of the shoot and a negative binomial distribution for the number of neoformed organs. The number of neoformed metamers decreased progressively with years in both 1st and 2nd GUs (Source: Costes et al. 1992).
2. Branching Patterns. In temperate fruit trees, axillary buds develop during two main periods (during the current growing season producing a sylleptic shoot, or during the following growing period producing a proleptic—or delayed—shoot) and at different locations along the original shoot. The median distribution of sylleptic shoots organizes the branching pattern along the main shoot in three successive zones that are observed from the base to the top: (1) not branched, (2) branched, and (3) not branched zones. In addition, axillary shoots can be divided into three types according to their length (short, medium, and long). Thus, the class of Markovian models was selected, since it emerged as a reference
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
19
for analyzing successions of homogeneous zones in discrete sequences, in both computational molecular biology and plant architecture domains (Guédon et al. 2001). More precisely, hidden semi-Markov chains (Durbin et al. 1998) were used to represent both the succession of zones and the proportion of shoot types within the branched zone. At the first level, a semi-Markov chain represents the succession of zones and the length of each zone, the successive zones being connected by transition probabilities. The second level consists in associating each zone with a discrete distribution representing the different probabilities of different types of axillary shoots. The resulting organization of axillary shoots according to specific zones along parent shoots has been demonstrated and modeled in several fruit species, including apple (Costes and Guédon 1997; Costes et al. 1999; Costes and Guédon 2002), peach (Fournier et al. 1998), and Actinidia (Seleznyova et al. 2002). This modeling approach also has been applied to the distribution of both sylleptic and proleptic axillary shoots in one-year-old apple trees, comparing a set of cultivars belonging to contrasting architectural types according to the classification of Lespinasse (1992). All were shown to present a similar organization in successive branching zones that differed one from the other by their composition of axillary shoot types (Costes and Guédon 2002). Roughly, all the cultivars exhibited six successive zones that could be described from the distal end of the shoot as follows: in the most distal zone, long proleptic shoots were observed mixed with latent buds and short shoots; the second zone was occupied mainly by lateral bourses mixed with latent buds; the third zone corresponded exclusively to sylleptic shoots. These first three zones spread over the upper half of the bearer shoot. The basal half of the shoot comprised the three remaining zones: two unbranched zones flanking a large branched zone where long proleptic shoots and spurs were mixed with latent buds (Fig. 1.10). The different cultivars were shown to differ by the length of each zone and the relative proportion of the axillary shoot types within each zone. The long lateral shoots, which can appear in the nursery, were observed in three zones: the most distal, the median zone (corresponding to the sylleptic zone), and the basal branched zone. Thus, the total number of long shoots as well as their relative position along the trunk differed according to cultivar. On average, all cultivars developed more than ten long laterals, except ‘Wijcik’. Most of the long shoots were located in the proximal zone in ‘Reinette Blanche du Canada’ and in ‘Fuji’. In ‘Belrène’, the long proleptic shoots were located equally in the distal and proximal zones. A high number of long shoots in the distal zone were observed in ‘Granny Smith’, reflecting an acrotonic behavior. ‘Imperial
Fuji (III) 20
0.80 0.20
0.1
Granny (IV)
100
0.93
50
0.07
0.69 100 0.83 0.23 50 0.08 0.92 100
0.08
1
0.93 0.07 1
1
1
50
100
0.94 0.06 1
50
100
0.63
100
50
01234
0.1
1 0.68 0.32 1
50 100 50
50
100
0.75 100 0.25 50 1
50 01234
0.63 100 1 50
1
symbols 01234
(73.93)
50
100
1
50
1
100
0.86 0.14 0.68
50
0.37
50
0.15
100
0.12 100 100
0.37
100
50
0.92
50
50
50
50
0.88 100
100
0.08
1
100
100
Wijcik
100
0.57
50
0.43
0.87 0.13
50
Reinette (II)
100
symbols
(73.00)
symbols
(57.26)
0123 symbols
(75.06) Most probable axillary shoot in the state Latent bud (symbol 0) Spur (symbol 1) Long delayed shoot (symbol 2)
Axillary floral shoot (symbol 3) Sylleptic shoots (symbol 4) Diffuse mixture of spurs and long delayed shoots
Transition probability
Fig. 1.10. Simplified representation of the branching patterns along one-year-old trunks in four apple cultivars: ‘Fuji’ (type III), Granny Smith (type IV), and Reinette Blanche du Canada (type II), and ‘Wijcik’ (type I, compact). Branching patterns are modeled by hidden semi-Markov chains represented as follows: each branching zone is represented as a state and its length is represented by its mean number of nodes; transitions between states are represented by arrows, with transition probability noted nearby; the proportion of latent buds (symbol 0), short (1), long (2), floral (3), and sylleptic (4) axillary shoots within each zone is represented by a histogram attached at the right of the considered zone. The total mean number of nodes per shoot is noted between brackets at the bottom of the diagram (Source: Costes and Guédon. 2002. Annals of Botany, Modeling Branching Patterns on 1-Year-Old Trunks of Six Apple Cultivars, Vol. 89, p. 520, Figure 6. With permission of Oxford University Press.)
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
21
Gala’, ‘Granny Smith’, and ‘Elstar’ exhibited the highest mean values of long shoots in the median zone. In ‘Granny Smith’, however, the zones were densely branched and separated by latent buds, while in ‘Imperial Gala’, the long shoots were more equally distributed and mixed with latent buds (Costes and Guédon 1997, 2002). The branching pattern of ‘Imperial Gala’ along two-year-old trunks seemed more adapted to the further branching organization of the adult tree. 3. Location of Flowering. Plant architectural descriptions previously showed that flowering is often linked to the branching process. In most temperate fruit species, flowers or inflorescences differentiate on leafy shoots a few weeks after metamer expansion (Foster et al. 2003). Thus, flower organogenesis occurs when and where sylleptic shoots can grow (Crabbé 1987). However, they bloom the following year and finally fruits that are currently borne on one-year-old shoots develop at the same time as proleptic shoots. Therefore, flowering distribution along shoots has been modeled according to the same philosophy as branching, exploring the number of flowers associated at each node rank, either with sylleptic shoots (on current year shoots) or with proleptic shoots (on one-year-old shoots). In both peach and apricot trees, because of the axillary position of flowers and the possible vegetative or floral fate of the main axillary bud, two variables must be simultaneously considered in order to represent, respectively, the main axillary bud fate and the number of associated flowers. In the peach tree, long, medium, and short one-year-old shoots were compared by analyzing the number of lateral flowers relative to the central bud fate, as either a sylleptic shoot or as a flower (Fournier 1994, Fournier et al. 1998, Fig. 1.11). Whatever their type, peach tree shoots were highly structured from the base to the top, and this organization was described as a succession of zones. The proximal and distal zones, which contained latent buds and no flowers, were present in all shoot types. Similarly, the zone that contained central buds, which had differentiated into flowers, was always located in the upper half of the shoot. Two median zones contained one associated flower with short sylleptic shoots or vegetative buds. An additional zone, which contained two or more lateral flowers, was observed in the median part of the longest shoots only. This floral zone also contained long sylleptic shoots. Thus, the number of zones that contained associated flowers, as well as the number of flowers per node and the number of sylleptic shoots, increased with shoot vigor. However, the number of flowers also can be affected by rootstocks since an intermediate growth rhythm has been shown to promote
22 X1
0
0
0
0
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
2
2
X2
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
2
2
2
2
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
X1: type of axillary development
(a)
3 sylleptic shoot 2 vegetative bud 1 central flower 0 blind node
(b)
X2: number of lateral flowers
(c) 10
20
30
Number of nodes
Zone with latent buds and no flower Zone with vegetative buds and 0 to 1 lateral flower per node Zone with sylleptic shoots and 0 to 2 lateral flowers per node Zone with vegetative buds and 1 central flower per node Fig. 1.11. Branching patterns of (a) long, (b) medium, and (c) short mixed shoots of peach tree, modeled by hidden semi-Markov chains that associate the number of lateral flowers (X2 variable) to the axillary bud fate (X1 variable). The length of each zone is represented by the mean number of nodes (Source: Fournier, D., Costes, E. and Guédon, Y. 1998. A Comparison of Different Fruiting Shoots of Peach Tree. Acta Hort. (ISHS) 465:557–566 http://www.actahort.org/books/465/465_69.htm).
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
23
more floral differentiation in peach trees grafted on St Julien rootstock than on those grafted on more vigorous rootstocks (Edin 1982). In apricot, the association between flowers and axillary proleptic shoots was only studied on long annual shoots (Costes and Guédon 1996; Costes et al. 1999). As previously, two variables were considered: the number of flowers associated with each node and the type of proleptic axillary shoot that developed at this node. Along these long shoots, only the basal part did not bear any flowers. Two-thirds of the upper part of the shoots were potentially floral. However, the transitions between the number of flowers per node were gradual: they increased progressively from one to three or more flowers, from the base to the top of the shoot, and then decreased symmetrically from three flowers to two and then one flower per node. As previously described in the peach tree, sylleptic shoots were observed more frequently in the zone that contained three flowers or more. Such an increasing gradient was also observed in annual shoots composed of several GUs in apricot trees, with the second and third GUs bearing more flowers than the first GU within annual shoots (Clanet and Salles 1974). 4. Meristem and Shoot Mortality. In all trees, different shoot categories usually exhibit different life spans. Shoot death is a general phenomenon that may occur in large branches in forest trees or, more usually in short shoots, from the year of bud burst to several or many years later (Bell 1991). Meristem mortality has been modeled by an exponential distribution, considering death probability as a constant (de Reffye 1981b). In temperate fruit trees, among the different shoot categories, short shoots usually have the shortest life span. Thus they have been the most studied organs with respect to mortality. These studies were mainly focused on apple by Lauri et al. (1995, 1997a, b), who demonstrated that spur death, also called “extinction,” is a precocious phenomenon in lateral development and depends upon the cultivar. Moreover, spur death was shown to be correlated positively to the capability of each cultivar to bear fruits regularly in the remaining branchlets through the “bourseover-bourse” phenomenon, which is defined as the proportion of fruitful laterals that give rise to a fruitful lateral the following year. This phenomenon was first described in apple (Lauri et al. 1997a; Fig. 1.12) and, more recently, demonstrated in pear (Lauri et al. 2002). Spur extinction was also shown to occur at a constant rate over years and to be higher for spurs on medium shoots than on long shoots in both ‘Fuji’ and ‘Braeburn’ (Costes et al. 2003b). Thus, it appears that spur extinction is an interesting horticultural trait, specific of cultivar.
24
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD 0.35
Granny Smith
0.30
extinction
0.25
Red Winter
0.20 Jonagold
Fuji
0.15
Braeburn
0.10
O. Spur
0.05
Delicious
Melrose
Royal Gala
Golden Delicious R. des Reinettes
0.00 0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
bourse-over-bourse Fig. 1.12. Relationship between bourse-over-bourse and extinction for the various cultivars. Each point represents the mean value for the couples of years 1-2 and 2-3. Bourseover-bourse is defined as the proportion of fruitful laterals that give rise to a fruitful lateral the following year. Extinction is defined as the proportion of laterals that abort (Source: Lauri et al. 1997a. Reproduced with permission of the Journal of Horticultural Science of Biotechnology.)
D. Describing Fruit Tree Form Tree form is another criterion that defines tree architecture, even though little information about plant geometry has been initially included in architectural model definitions. The variability of tree forms within a given species has been described as a continuous phenomenon, from upright to weeping (Bernhard 1961; Lespinasse 1977; Scorza 1984; Sansavini and Musacchi 1994). However, tree and shoot form remains a quite vague concept, and is quite difficult to measure and formally describe, especially when the considered trees do not exhibit an extreme behavior. At the whole tree scale, tree form can be defined according to canopy volume and to the branching organization. It can be evaluated through the overall tree hierarchic organization using the concepts of hierarchy vs. polyarchy introduced by Edelin (1991) and used, for instance, to describe two-year-old apple trees (De Wit et al. 2002). It also can be evaluated through the concepts of excurrent vs. decurrent trees (Brown et al. 1967). At more detailed scales, tree form relies on that of its constitutive organs: for instance, a weeping tree can be viewed as a set of weeping long axes, while an erected tree is a set of erected axes. Stem form and orientation are important components of intra-specific fruit tree architectural diversity and have a qualitative and quantitative impact on fruit production: bending or tilting stems increase flowering, reduce vigor, and modify the branching pattern of the stems (Wareing and Nasr 1958).
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
25
Moreover, taking into account stem form and orientation allows one to tackle problems related to the within tree heterogeneity: (1) when leaves or fruits are considered, spatial position and aggregation are input variables with which to estimate light interception within the canopy; (2) when shoots are considered, it becomes possible to study the geometry of axes and its changes with time. In the following paragraphs, we introduce briefly the techniques that are presently available to collect 3D coordinates of plant organs and we describe the different models of forms that have been proposed to represent either the whole tree, the axes, or the tree organs at more detailed scales. According to the scale considered, applications dealing with light interception or shoot bending prediction are mentioned. 1. Measuring a 3D Form. Different digitizing techniques have been developed involving articulated arms and sonic and magnetic methods to measure the 3D coordinates of plant constituents (Sinoquet et al. 1997). Depending on the study goals, a method based on digital 3D measurements can be applied either to leaves or to axis segments (Fig. 1.13). A further step, which consists of coupling plant topological description to that of constituent geometry, was achieved by coupling a one-scale description of plant topology to sonic digitizing (Hanan and Room 1997)
(a)
(b)
Fig. 1.13. Example of three-dimensional representation of digitized apple trees acquired using a BD magnetic Polhemus digitizer (Adam et al 2001). (a) Branch digitized at leaf scale and visualized with VegeStar software (Source: Massonnet et al. 2004); (b) Whole tree digitized at woody segment scale, and reconstructed by AMAPmod software (Unpublished data from Costes and Sinoquet).
26
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
or by coupling a multi-scale tree graph representation of plant topology to magnetic digitizing (Godin et al. 1999). In both methods, the following softwares are available for data acquisition: 3A (Adam et al. 1999) and Floradig (Hanan and Wang 2004). Despite these software developments, the acquisition of organ 3D coordinates remains time consuming, and simplification procedures are currently under investigation. Casella and Sinoquet (2003) proposed the use of allometric relationships between shoot length, number of leaves, and leaf area to reconstruct 3D architecture from sampling of 3D coordinates. Another solution could be to reconstruct 3D coordinates from stereoscopic photographs coupled to automatic processing that allows an automatic extraction of morphological parameters (Kaminuma et al. 2004). A good correlation between direct 3D measurements of tree canopies and 3D reconstruction has also been recently proposed, which relied upon the calculation of gap fractions from series or peripheral pictures (Phattaralerphong and Sinoquet 2005). 2. Models for Representing Whole Tree or Row Form. The question of whole canopy representation has been developed mainly in the context of physical exchanges between canopy and the environment, especially light interception. In these approaches, canopy structure has been considered at the whole tree, row, or orchard scales, and simple geometrical models are sometimes considered as sufficient (e.g., Li et al. 2002). Jackson and Palmer (1972), who pioneered the calculation of light interception in orchards, first considered solid, non-transmitting, and nonreflecting hedgerows of different forms, latitudes, and times within the year. The hedgerows were considered either as triangular, truncated triangular, or rectangular in cross-section. Palmer and Jackson further refined this modeling approach by considering the tree canopies to be transmitting turbid media according to the law of Beer-Lambert (Palmer and Jackson 1977; Jackson and Palmer 1979; Jackson 1980). Both simpler and more complex models have also been proposed to represent the whole tree canopies. For instance, a two-dimensional (2D) model for representing orchard rows in light interception estimations for different fruit tree species has been proposed by Annandale et al. (2004) (Fig. 1.14). Refinements also have been introduced by considering each tree individually, with tree shape being approximated as conic, parabolic, cylindrical, or as intermediate between a cone and a cylinder (Wagenmakers 1991). Excellent estimations of light interception have been obtained for symmetrical and elliptical canopies, but discrepancies occur with asymmetric canopies or when the assumption of a uniform leaf area distribution was not valid. This drawback can be overcome by a three-dimensional (3D) model that makes it possible to account for
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
27
Fig. 1.14. Simplified ellipsoidal representation of whole tree form and hedgerow used in a 2D solar radiation interception model (Source: Annandale, J. G., N. Z. Jovanovic, G. S. Campbell, N. D. Santoy, and P. Lobit, 2004. Two-dimensional Solar Radiation Interception Model of Hedgerow Fruit Trees, 207-225. With permission of Elsevier.)
canopy asymmetry, such as the model proposed by Cescatti (1997) in a forest context. However, this approach has not yet been applied in a horticultural context. 3. Modeling Axis Form Changes. Except for mutants, in which bending was described during the first year of growth (Monet et al. 1988), main changes in axis form occur in one-year-old shoots when the thin and long to medium shoots are fruiting for the first time. Thus, a weeping habit can be assumed to result from the individual shoot propensity to bend under its own weight and the fruit load. The elaboration of stem form was first studied in a forest context, and is the purpose of tree biomechanics (Castera and Morlier 1991; Fournier et al. 1991a, b; 1994). Stem form depends on several factors related to its growth habit. The first factor is the primary direction of elongation of the apex, which can be modified by subsequent re-orientations of the stem. The weight of wood, axillary shoots, leaves, and fruits causes bending of the stem. The intensity of this bending depends on the amount and location of loads, dimensions of the stem, and mechanical properties of wood. Secondary growth creates an increase in stem rigidity, and the relative dynamics of loading and diameter growth plays an important role in the final shoot form (Fournier et al. 1994). Another effect of diameter growth is active re-orientation of the stem, due to the maturation of new wood layers and more specifically to the action of tension wood (Archer 1986).
28
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
A modeling approach carried out in three contrasting varieties of apricot trees showed that the main factors involved in final shoot form were: (1) its initial geometry (in particular its slenderness and inclination), and (2) the distribution of loads along the shoot (Alméras 2001; Alméras et al. 2002) (Fig. 1.15). The dynamics of cambial growth also impacts reorientation, which corresponds to an up-righting movement after harvest, since lignification stiffens the shoot during the period of maximal curvature due to fruit development. By contrast, the mechanical properties of the wood (i.e., its modulus of elasticity and the presence of tension wood) have a small impact on the final shoot form (Alméras et al. 2004). These results suggest that the variables related to shoot morphology are the first targets to evaluate the propensity of a shoot to bend among different genotypes. Diameter and shoot length constitute elementary variables for characterizing the shoot form, and are putative descriptors of the genetic variability (Kervella et al. 1994), despite the fact that they may be plastic under various environmental conditions (Fournier et al. 2003). Other variables, such as the variation in shoot curvature over two years, shoot slenderness, or branching angles, could also be relevant but need to be confirmed by further studies.
Measured
Measured
Simulated
Simulated
1
1
T0 T0 T0 T0 0.5
0.5
T1 T1
T1 0
T1
0 0
0.5
0
1
0.5
T2
T2 T2
T2 –0.5 0.5
1
–0.5 0.5-
(a)
(b)
Fig. 1.15. Observed and simulated dynamics of long shoot form during the second growth season, from blooming time (T0) to physiological fruit drop (T1) and a few days before harvest (T2). Example of a shoot belonging to (a) ‘Lambertin’ and (b) ‘Modesto’ cultivars (Source: Alméras, 2001).
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
29
4. Models for Representing the Organ Distributions within Canopy. In horticulture, there is a major interest in quantifying the heterogeneity of organ environment within the canopy, especially considering the heterogeneity of leaves and fruits during their development. Indeed, the organs of the same plant may be subject to contrasting environmental conditions, especially for light distribution, and this may result in differential responses, e.g., in terms of carbon assimilation potential of the leaves and fruit coloring. Two main types of plant representations that account for the organ distribution within the canopy have been proposed. Firstly, individual trees can be split into voxels resulting from a spatial discretization of the space occupied by the tree. Leaf area density (LAD) in a voxel is then assumed to be uniformly and randomly distributed and spatial variation of leaf area density is therefore accounted for by the inter-voxel differences in LAD. This approach has been used for modeling light capture with a turbid medium analogy and has been used to compute radiation balance at canopy, plant, and shoot scale (Sinoquet et al. 1991). Secondly, organs can be explicitly described, with their shape, size, orientation, and spatial co-ordinates being taken into account in 3D plant mock-ups. These mock-ups may be provided by either digitizing methods or simulation softwares. Thus, methods based on polygon projection or on Monte Carlo ray-tracing can be used for modeling light capture at the organ scale. These approaches have been recently reviewed by Godin et al. (2005). Finally, the numerous studies that have been carried out on fruit tree architecture provide nowadays a large set of concepts, methods, and techniques to quantify both the tree topology and geometry, with the possibility to choose between different scales according to specific goals. This overall knowledge constitutes a framework that also benefits orchard and tree training systems, since growth, branching, and flowering processes can be explicitly taken into account in their conception.
III. CONSEQUENCES OF TREE ARCHITECTURE FOR TREE TRAINING, ORCHARD MANAGEMENT, AND FRUIT PRODUCTION Training systems have drawn considerable attention over the past 40 years since they must combine different purposes. Those have been revealed to be more or less conflicting, since economic conditions have varied over time. The main purposes, especially in intensive orchards, are the following: (1) a rapid achievement of a developed canopy structure to reach orchard maturity and maximum fruit production within a
30
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
few years; (2) an optimal capture of light to optimize carbon gain and fruit yield per hectare; (3) a fair distribution of intercepted light within the aerial system of the tree to minimize the spatial heterogeneity of local vegetative growth and fruit quality; and (4) management of tree shape and fruit load with minimal pruning, to take advantage of the natural trends of the cultivar and reduce the economic cost of this manual operation. This last point is of major importance since training systems initially conceived to improve light interception by the tree overall may stimulate growth of vigorous water-shoots, i.e., reiterated complexes, on the upper side of scaffold branches. If not removed, these shoots acting mainly as assimilate sinks may also thwart the benefits of high illumination within the tree by decreasing light interception by fruiting shoots. On the other hand, an unpruned tree, in which vigor is well-distributed to fruiting shoots, quickly begins production but, in most cases, results in an overcrowded canopy after some years and eventually fruit size and quality are reduced. Training methods have then been particularly developed at the tree scale to manipulate both the vegetative and the fruiting components. Pruning vegetative shoots at different positions in the tree or/and at different phenological stages is used both for the building of the tree structure, according to a specific tree shape, and to optimize light distribution within the canopy as in cherry (Flore et al. 1996) or in apple (Barritt 1992). Bending or tying down branches is often used with two objectives. One is to maintain the tree in the allotted space in relation with the tree management system. It is preferred to heading cuts for the control of tree growth and shape and is currently used in particular training procedures, as described for Solaxe (see section III B 3). A second objective of bending is to reduce vegetative growth of the branch and promote flowering. However, the effects of bending on flowering and fruiting remain controversial and, depending on the experiment, orienting entire trees or individual branches horizontally or downward either increases (Tromp 1970; Wareing 1970) or does not have a consistent effect (Longman et al. 1965; Mullins 1965) on flower bud formation and fruiting. It has been shown in apple that both the time and genotype influence the branch response to bending (Fig. 1.16) (Lauri and Lespinasse 2001). A. Initial Choices of the Grower and Young Tree Training Reducing the amount of vegetative growth discarded by pruning should be a main objective of training procedures, as shown in both apple and pear (Forshey et al. 1992). Especially during the early stages of tree
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
31
Logarithmic mean of length (cm)
A X.3318 1-year-old wood
B X.3318 2-year-old wood
10.0
10.0
1.0
1.0
23 June 11 July 4 Aug. 22 Jan. Control 0.1
10.0
0
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9
1
C 'Chantecler' 1-year-old wood
0.1 0 10.0
1.0
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9
1
D 'Chantecler' 2-year-old wood
1.0
0.1
0.1 0
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9
1
0
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9
1
Relative position Fig. 1.16. Effects of time of bending and age of wood on logarithmic mean of the length of laterals (vegetative and bourse-shoots) relative to the position on the shoot (0 = basal to 1 = subapical) for genotypes (A, B) X.3318 and (C, D) ‘Chantecler’. Only positions with at least 15 laterals were considered. Vertical bars represent ±1 SE when larger than symbol size (Source: Lauri and Lespinasse 2001).
development, training a tree to obtain a shape different from its natural growth habit may delay initial fruit production and requires considerable care. Attention may also be needed to maintain the framework of the new allotted shape (Preston 1974). Training the tree with less pruning and taking into account the natural growth and fruiting habit of the tree (Lespinasse 1977, 1980; Forshey et al. 1992) or vine (Possingham 1994) is of major importance and may lead to higher yield performance. The consequences of initial management choices on the young tree
32
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
construction is discussed through two examples dealing with the choice of the rootstock and training system. 1. Rootstock Effects. Among the numerous initial decisions faced by growers when establishing an orchard, that of rootstock is crucial. The grafting of scion cultivars on various selected rootstocks allows the grower to increase orchard density and tree productivity (for historical points of view see Fallahi et al. 2002). Indeed, dwarfing rootstocks reduce the whole tree volume and promote earlier flowering (Lockard and Schneider 1981; Larsen et al. 1992; Barritt et al. 1995). A wide range of rootstocks that promote various tree volumes is available in many fruit species, though not in all (Webster 1997). Important efforts have been devoted to comparing rootstock/scion performance in different climatic areas. From the 1980s, several national programs involving evaluation of different apple rootstocks, cultivars, training systems, and planting sites have been established in the USA, such as NC-140 (www.nc140.org; Fernandez et al. 1991; Perry and Fernandez 1993; Barritt et al. 1995; Marini et al. 2001; Robinson 2003), as well as in northern Europe (Callesen 1997), and in New Zealand (White and Tustin 2000). Detailed interpretations of dwarfing rootstock effects on the development of the aerial part of the trees have been made. They addressed two main questions: (1) is the reduction of aerial growth due to a delay of leaf emergence rate or to a shorter period of growth? and (2) what variables are involved in the reduction of shoot length and in the structural changes of branching systems? The first question has been addressed in apple (Costes and Lauri 1995) and peach cultivars (Weibel et al. 2003) grafted on different rootstocks. In both studies, the length of the growing period was shown to be reduced by dwarfing rootstocks. It also has been demonstrated that rootstocks reduce the internode length (Seleznyova et al. 2003; Weibel et al. 2003). However, different results have been obtained regarding the effect of dwarfing rootstocks on the mean number of nodes per shoot. In peach, Weibel et al. (2003) indicated that differences in shoot length were related primarily to internode length rather than to the number of nodes, whereas Seleznyova et al. (2003) attributed the difference in apple branch size to a reduction in both the length of internodes and the number of nodes that are neoformed within long growth units. Average internode length per extension unit depends on unit node number, with internodes being shorter for units with fewer nodes. Rootstock not only affects shoot length and number of nodes but also branching density and location, and branch characteristics. On cherry, Schaumberg and Gruppe (1985) showed that rootstocks from the Giessen series altered the number of flowers per bud but not the number of buds
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
33
per spur of ‘Hedelfinger’ sweet cherry cultivar. More recently Maguylo et al. (2004) showed that the effects of the rootstock on growth and flowering of ‘Hedelfinger’ may be split into two components, vigor and genotype, with an increase in the number of spurs and the number of flowers per spur as vigor increases in the Giessen series, and a decrease in both variables as vigor increases in the other rootstocks. The effect of rootstock on branching pattern was also studied in apple relative to different axis types, with annual shoots sampled on four- to nine-year-old trees (Hirst and Ferree 1995a), three-year-old fruiting branches (Seleznyova et al. 2003), and along six-year-old trunks (Costes et al. 2001b). In all these situations, the percentage of budbreak of axillary buds on extension growth units was unaffected, regardless of the rootstock. Thus, differences in the number of axillary annual shoots per branch were shown to result mainly from that of the number of nodes developed during the previous year (Costes et al. 2001b). This led to the interpretation that the effect of rootstock on aerial growth is cumulative and superimposed year after year. The changes induced in branching patterns, including both the floral and vegetative development of the axillary shoots, are currently being analyzed, such as applying Hidden-Semi Markov chain models to assess the structural differences induced by a range of rootstock/interstock combinations (Seleznyova et al. 2004). Despite the interest in using dwarfing rootstocks to control tree volume and height, counterproductive effects have also been noticed in the case of excessive dwarfing effects, for instance in cherry (Webster and Lucas 1997; Moreno et al. 2001), peach (Layne et al. 1976; Bussi et al. 1995; Bussi et al. 2002), and apple (Marini et al. 2002). Due to cultivarrootstock interactions, the highest yields at the tree scale are usually not obtained in the most dwarfed trees but in larger trees. A positive relationship between rootstock vigor and cumulative yield has been observed (Warrington et al. 1990). Evidence of a positive correlation between shoot growth and flower bud formation has also been provided in apple, at least under specific conditions of water and nutrient supply (Decker and Hansen 1990). Thus, the choice of the growth level, through the use of rootstocks of various vigor, has to be considered with other variables, such as the intrinsic flowering pattern of the scion, to obtain long-term tree efficiency. The possibility of reducing initial orchard investment through less expensive plant material has been explored through the use of micropropagated, own-rooted trees in Malus (Webster et al. 1985; Quamme and Brownlee 1993) and Prunus (Quamme and Brownlee 1993). In Pyrus, it has been argued that this procedure would be interesting to avoid “pear decline,” often related to grafting, or more generally to the
34
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
graft incompatibility phenomenon (Thibault and Hermann 1982), even though this last argument is no longer applicable to OH × F rootstock selections. As a general trend, self-rooted trees are similar in size to trees grafted on a semi-vigorous or vigorous rootstock, with similar delays for beginning fruit production (Hirst and Ferree 1995b). However, great differences exist among scion genotypes. Some own-rooted apple cultivars such as ‘Greensleeves’ have precocious cropping efficiency higher than that of ‘Greensleeves’ on MM.106, although not as high as that of ‘Greensleeves’ on M9 (Webster et al. 1985). For other cultivars (e.g., ‘Cox’s Orange Pippin’), growing own-rooted trees was much less satisfactory (Webster et al. 1985). It is likely that the branching and flowering patterns have to be taken into consideration when evaluating the potential for growing trees on their own roots. A recent study (Maguylo and Lauri 2004) showed that own-rooted apple genotypes belonging to fruiting type IV with downward-oriented branches and a high frequency of bourse-over-bourse may reach similar or higher cumulated yields than grafted trees in the fourth year of growth. For these genotypes, strong vegetative growth before the first crop significantly reduces branch breakage due to overloading and wind, as compared to trees grafted on M9. It thus makes it possible to grow self-supporting trees needing only a minimal support, with a large root system that ensures good anchorage and possibly enhances water and mineral uptake. 2. Tree Development and Initial Fruit Production. The choice of the training system usually is made at the early stage of orchard planting and, in some cases, has early implications in the nursery, in particular through the selection or pruning of long shoots along the trunk. The manipulations to be carried out usually are described step by step via training schemes (Fig. 1.17). Major changes in training systems were introduced in the 1970s when physiological and architectural rules of tree development were integrated progressively to training concepts. Indeed, the training systems proposed at that time strongly differed from older ones that were mainly influenced by esthetic considerations (Loreti and Pisani 1990). Due to the high number of systems proposed, many studies and discussions have been devoted to the comparison of their relative benefits. According to Robinson et al. (1991b), training systems can be roughly divided into two categories according to whether they (1) apply the natural shape of the trees, such as multiple and central leader (Barritt and Dilley 1989), vertical axes (Lespinasse and Delort 1986), and slender spindle forms (Wertheim 1985), or (2) restrict the canopy in a geometric form such as the A, V, or T forms (van den Ende and Kenez 1985; Lakso et al. 1989). Some of these tree training systems have been conceived as
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
35
Fig. 1.17. The Solaxe apple training system during the first four years (Source: Lauri, P. E. and Lespinasse, J. M. 1998. The Vertical Axis and Solaxe Systems in France, Acta Hort. (ISHS) 513:287–296.) http://www.actahort.org/books/513/513_34.htm.
technical strategies to ease harvest or pruning mechanization, e.g., Tatura or MIA. The early development of the canopy, the initial fruit production and the resulting yield efficiency have been compared for many training systems and fruit crops, including apple (Robinson et al. 1991a; Barden and Marini 1998), cherry (Kappel and Quamme 1993), plum (Wustenberg and Keulemans 1997), and peach (Myers 1994). However, it is difficult to make unbiased comparisons because climatic and horticultural conditions usually differ from one experimental site to another (Tustin et al. 1997). It is also difficult to take into account the economic efficiency of these systems (DeJong et al. 1999) without simulating the weight of different inputs (cost of trees, labor) or outputs (fruit prices). Moreover, the genotypic variability of tree habit makes comparisons between training systems difficult, since genotypes may react differently (Bassi et al. 1994; Lauri and Lespinasse 2000). An important goal of young tree manipulations is to reduce the length of the unproductive period for obvious economic reasons. The counterproductive effect of heading the central leader on the early production of the trees has been emphasized by different authors (Lespinasse 1977, 1980; Barden and Marini 1998; Lauri and Lespinasse 2000). By contrast, taking advantage of the natural branching habit and promoting feathering has been demonstrated to be a possible strategy to reduce the duration of the unproductive period. This arose from studies that were
36
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
carried out either during the juvenile period of seedlings, in the context of breeding programs, especially in apple and pear trees (Visser 1965; Visser and De Vries 1970; Zimmerman 1972; Zimmerman 1977), or in young grafted trees (Maggs 1960). As mentioned previously, in the context of commercial fruit production, the development of sylleptic shoots, or feathering, can be promoted by the application of different chemicals (Preston 1968; Quinlan 1978; Wertheim 1978; Miller 1988). The evidence of a relationship between feathering and earlier initial cropping led to the development of “preformed” nursery trees. In pear (Costes et al. 2004), the number of long sylleptic shoots has been correlated with the number of inflorescences developed per tree in the third year of growth, based on a set of cultivars with different habits and durations of the unproductive period. The most accurate predictive variable of initial flower formation was the difference in the number of sylleptic laterals during the first two years of growth. This suggests that management of young trees should take advantage of the genotypic differences in sylleptic laterals during the first years of growth in order to reduce the length of the unproductive period. The combination of a supported central leader having a selection of long sylleptic shoots along the trunk represents a key step towards training systems with early efficiency and low labor cost. B. Adult Tree Training Once the tree structure is established, the main focus of all training systems is to annually balance the fruit number and weight with vegetative growth. In many perennial crops, an excess of fruit at the expense of vegetative growth may lead to irregular cropping, alternating between large and small crops in consecutive years. Thus, training methods at the tree scale (pruning, bending) aim at directing vegetative growth towards fruiting sinks through precocious growth cessation that optimizes the carbon budget of the tree with regard to fruiting (Sansavini and CorelliGrappadelli 1992; Lauri and Kelner 2001) and reduces heterogeneity between shoots (Lespinasse 1996). The balance between the vegetative growth and the flowering/fruiting components also refers to the concept of crop load, which has been recently reviewed by Bound (2001) and Wünsche and Ferguson (2005). Since there is not a unique definition of crop load, various expressions have been proposed: ratio of fruit buds to vegetative buds or number of buds per meter of frame-wood in pear (Helsen and Deckers 1984), number of leaves per fruit in peach (Ben Mimoun et al. 1998), or number of fruit per canopy volume in citrus (Bound 2001). An easy-to-use method for expressing crop load is to consider it the ratio of the number of fruits (or alternatively weight of
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
37
fruits) per trunk cross-sectional area (TCSA) (Abbott and Adam 1978) or even branch cross-sectional area (BCSA) (Abbott and Adam 1978; Lauri et al. 2004b). Wünsche and Ferguson (2005) here prefer the term of “yield efficiency,” and discuss its validity in the context of tree aging. Nevertheless, large variations may be observed in the relationships between the intensity of alternate bearing and values of TCSA, as shown in apple (Goldschmidtreischel 1996), suggesting that TCSA alone is not sufficient and other parameters should be considered, such as canopy spur leaf area (Sansavini and Corelli-Grappadelli 1992; Wünsche et al. 1996; Lakso et al. 1999). 1. Fruit Load Effects on Tree Growth, Architecture, and Ecophysiology. In what follows, fruiting will be considered through its strong effects on individual tree growth and architecture: (1) fruit load modifies the partitioning of available carbohydrates and water economy in a short term, i.e., during annual cycle, and (2) heavy yields affect tree vigor in a longer term by reducing cumulated growth over years (Regnard et al. 2002) and the fruiting potential possibly inducing an alternate bearing. Reaching an equilibrium between both growth and fruiting is thus one of the main objectives of the fruit grower, as noted by Forshey and Elfving (1989). When trees are young, newly formed biomass is allocated preferentially to growth and directed towards the scaffold establishment and the development of the root system. Biomass investment in fruit progressively increases as the tree ages (Cannell 1985). When the orchard reaches its adult phase, and provided that environmental and cultural practices are at the optimum, the fruit yield compared to total annual biomass increment—namely the harvest index—can reach seventy per cent or more in peach (Cannell 1985) or apple (Lakso 1994). In any case, biomass acquisition and utilization should be considered at the whole plant level in terms of functional balance, which requires modeling approaches (e.g., Cannell and Dewar 1994; DeJong and Grossman 1994). Considering the large numbers of flowers or inflorescences that a fruit tree usually bears, regulation of fruit load is needed. This implies: (1) knowledge of the normal rates of fruit set that are compatible with vegetative growth equilibrium, (2) assessment of the fruit set ratio after bloom, (3) a comparison of fruit/leaf ratios, and (4) use of efficient and low-cost practices to thin excess fruitlets. Branch pruning combined with thinning are, in fact, the one key control strategy for regulating fruit load. When trees are overloaded, fruits act as major sinks for carbohydrates (Ho 1988) and divert a major proportion of photoassimilates. This can be detrimental to primary and secondary vegetative growth of the aerial system, and can starve the root system (Lenz 2001). Numerous
38
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
studies have demonstrated that altering growth can result in modifications of tree architecture. In peach, a reduction of primary shoot growth is observed in stems with subtending fruit compared to shoots with no fruit (Berman and DeJong 1997). Furthermore, shoot length and weight decrease exponentially as the crop load increases, while the relative gain in trunk girth decreases linearly (Blanco et al. 1995). In apricot, high fruit loads were shown to affect primary growth rhythmicity and growth resumption during the growing season, and to enhance the acrotonic pattern of branching (Costes et al. 2000). However the long-term effects of the spatial distribution of fruits within the canopy on tree architecture have not specifically been investigated. In three- and four-year-old apple trees, heavy fruit loads led to higher allocation of biomass to fruit, and lower allocation to new shoot growth, which resulted in reduced thickening of branches and less root growth (Palmer 1992). Experimental defruiting of young apple trees can result in higher leaf weight on area basis, longer shoots, and greater increases in TCSA compared to normal fruiting (Erf and Proctor 1987), while the presence of fruits conversely reduces leaf and root dry weight up to 45% (Buwalda and Lenz 1992). In sweet cherry, current-season growth appears to be a greater sink for photosynthates than fruits, but fruiting is recognized as a factor that reduces shoot growth (Kappel 1991). In highbush blueberry, Maust et al. (1999b) demonstrated that high flower bud density decreased vegetative budbreak, new shoot dry weight, leaf area, and leaf area to fruit ratios. Excessive crops can lead to biennial bearing. A classic study carried out in seeded vs. seedless apples by Chan and Cain (1967) demonstrated the specific role played by seeds in inhibiting floral initiation. The effect of seeds, which peaks from 6 to 10 weeks after full bloom, is generally attributed to gibberellin synthesis, which is assumed to counteract the floral process within apical buds of brachyblasts (Crabbé 1987; Crabbé and Escobedo-Alvarez 1991). Excessive fruit load during “on” years also lowers the amount of vegetative growth and consequently potential photosynthesis and C-assimilate supply by sources to sinks, ultimately resulting in decreased floral initiation during the growing season. Moreover, it has been frequently noticed that during the following year, when the return bloom is low (“off year”), the quality of flower buds and the effective pollination period (Williams 1965) are often reduced. Combination of both phenomenons strongly reduces fruit yield. The biennial cycle is then auto-reproducible, high yield and poor growth alternating with low yield and vigorous growth. The propensity for biennial bearing is particularly important in apple (type I and II), pear, plum, olive, and citrus, although there are important differences among cultivars. A thorough analysis of the strong alternate bearing of types I and II apple cultivars was developed by Lauri et al. (1995, 1997a).
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
39
Source-sink relationships and particularly carbon budgets have received considerable attention in fruit trees (Blanke and Notton 1992; Wibbe et al. 1993; Wibbe and Blanke 1995), leading to the development of carbon balance models, e.g., in apple (Johnson and Lakso 1986a; 1986b) and peach (Grossman and DeJong 1994). Distribution of Cassimilates is subject to complex mechanisms involving many aspects, including the distance between sources and sinks as described in both kiwifruit (Lai et al. 1989) and apple (Palmer et al. 1991), the capacity of the translocation system as noted in peach (DeJong and Grossman 1995) and more generally sink strength variations (Ho 1988). Moreover, the stimulation of the assimilation process by the fruit itself has been demonstrated, e.g., in peach (DeJong 1986; Bruchou and Génard 1999) and apple (Gucci et al. 1995; Giuliani et al. 1997; Palmer et al. 1997; Wünsche et al. 2000; Untiedt and Blanke 2001). Relations between crop load and water economy of the tree also must be considered, for it has frequently been shown that high fruit load results in modifying the trade-off between carbon assimilation and transpiration, as the tree meets the increasing sink demand by increasing the assimilation rates and concomitantly transpiring water at a higher rate. Conversely, defruiting or harvesting trees produce a decrease in sink demand that suddenly results in lower assimilation rates and secondarily higher water use efficiency (Chen and Lenz 1997; Pretorius and Wand 2003). Although fruit nitrogen demand is not generally large, except in nut crops, high fruit loads can deplete nitrogen availability during early shoot growth. This in turn can limit the vegetative growth extension rate (Forshey 1982; Sadowski et al. 1995). High crop loads also result in competition between fruits, which affects their development and final size (Denne 1960; Goffinet et al. 1995; Maust et al. 1999a) and generally lowers their quality (Kelner et al. 2000; Link 2000; Wünsche et al. 2000; Bound 2001; Wünsche and Ferguson 2005). Comparing severely thinned vs. unthinned peach trees, Grossman and DeJong (1995) suggested that heavy flower suppression could give a fair estimate of the potential relative growth rate of the remaining fruits, while fruit growth was source-limited on unthinned trees. A similar approach led Lakso et al. (1995) to develop an expolinear model for apple fruit potential growth under non resource-limited conditions. 2. Consequences for Fruit Thinning. In response to the necessity for fruit load regulation, biennial bearing avoidance, and fruit quality improvement, thinning methods have received considerable attention in recent years, as attested by successive reviews (Williams 1979; Miller 1988; Dennis 2000; Bangerth et al. 2000). In apple, where chemical thinning
40
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
has been commonly applied since the 1950s, the suppression of excess fruitlets is performed up to 30 days after full bloom. Thinning effects are optimal during this period because fruit-to-fruit competition for photoassimilates is limited and excess fruits abscise before the detrimental effect of fruit on floral initiation for the next year can be observed. Chemical thinning often operates by anticipating the June drop. Considering the differential genotypic sensitivity of different apple cultivars to thinning agents and also the numerous factors that can affect tree responses, the ultimate choice of a thinning program includes several parameters that must be adjusted by the fruit grower: active ingredient(s), concentration, wetting agents, spray volume per ha, and time of application. Some specific objectives have to be kept in mind and achieved. For example, lateral fruits borne on one-year-old shoots are generally undesirable (and are thinned by chemicals) because their potential growth is much lower than that of fruits borne in terminal positions either on mesoblasts or auxiblasts (Jackson 1970; Lespinasse 1970; Marguery and Sangwan 1993). As chemical thinning procedures to date have not produced totally predictable results, the grower also must decide whether additional manual fruit thinning must be performed. In apple, the strategy of fruiting shoot removal, also called artificial extinction, has proven to be effective in reducing biennial bearing and frequently in improving fruit color and size, and will probably receive increasing attention in the future (see section III B.3). 3. Implementation of Adult Tree Training Procedures. There is interest in developing a better knowledge of tree architecture, i.e., growth and fruiting patterns, to develop training procedures adapted to commercial tree fruit species and cultivars. Over the last four decades, the evolution of cultivation of apple is a good example of how the knowledge of tree architecture can be used to improve tree training. Indeed, pioneering work of Bernhard (1961) and Lespinasse and co-workers (Lespinasse 1977, 1980; Lespinasse and Delort 1986) ranked apple cultivars more or less linearly according to their fruiting type, from type I to IV. In relation to this classification, three fruiting zones have been defined, each corresponding to the successive stages of branch development over time (Lespinasse 1977; Lauri and Lespinasse 2000). Moreover, in the apple tree, terminal flowering greatly varied depending on the cultivar (Lespinasse 1977) and this trait has great consequences on branch bending and consequently on the distribution of vegetative growth on parent branches. The morphological expression of the apple tree architecture is then highly dependent on the cultivar. Similarly, although acrotonic branching is a common trait of all cultivars, the density of branches, espe-
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
41
cially short laterals in median and possibly proximal positions, is related to regularity of bearing (Lauri et al. 1995). The aim of training is therefore to use the variability existing among cultivars in growth, branching, and flowering location to optimize training methods. These studies have led to the introduction of two main improvements in apple tree training in France in the last decades. They involve the regulation of both branch growth and crop load by controlling fruiting lateral density. From Renewal Pruning to the Free Growing Fruiting Branch. Renewal pruning was a cornerstone of the Vertical Axis training system proposed by Lespinasse (1980). However, observations in commercial orchards showed that regular heading back of the branch to develop new shoots may lead to an imbalance between vegetative growth and fruiting, especially under vigorous conditions, and also to an increase in the proportion of fruit on one-year-old wood (Lauri and Lespinasse 2000). An opposing concept has been proposed, involving the removal of competing shoots on the upper-proximal part of the branch to invigorate distal fruiting organs. This new concept was integrated into the Solaxe training system, without any heading of the trunk, and minimal pruning and shoot bending of lateral branches (if necessary) to better control branch growth and tree shape (Lespinasse 1996; Lespinasse and Lauri 1996; Lauri and Lespinasse 2000). Crop Regulation via Artificial Extinction and Centrifugal Training. The positive relationship between natural extinction of some laterals and the increase of bourse-over-bourse trend of other laterals observed in regular bearing cultivars suggested that lateral density in a branch is in some way physiologically related to the development of the other laterals (growth and flowering frequency). From this result, it has been hypothesized that “artificial extinction” practices, i.e., thinning out of young fruiting laterals (Lauri et al. 1997b; Lauri and Lespinasse 2000; Lauri 2002; Lauri et al. 2004b), implemented in alternate bearing, usually spur-bound, cultivars would improve sustainability of the remaining fruiting laterals over the years (Lauri et al. 2004a). Artificial extinction is carried out more specifically on the underside as well as the proximal part of the fruiting branch, and around the vertical trunk where shaded laterals have poor vegetative development and low fruit set and size, color, and soluble solids (Tustin et al. 1988; Rom 1992). This procedure, called centrifugal training (Fig. 1.18), favors fruiting in the peripheral zone of the canopy and significantly improves light interception by fruiting shoots as well as canopy porosity (Willaume et al. 2004). From a biological point of view, centrifugal training does not
42
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
Light well brought about by centrifugal training: extinction is carried out along the trunk and on the proximal part of branches to improve light penetration within the canopy
Fruiting zone in the upper three-quarters of tree canopy
Extinction on the underside of branches to increase light penetration through the canopy
No branching below 1-1.2 m to permit development of the fruiting branches
Fig. 1.18. Centrifugal training concept to improve light distribution (gray arrows) in the tree (Source: Lauri 2002).
act only as a fruit load-regulating technique, since some photosynthate sources (leaves) and sinks (fruits) are removed at the same time. It is therefore not fully comparable to chemical thinning, or hand thinning, of flowers and fruitlets during which only generative organs are removed, while all the leaves are kept. Results on cultivars ‘Gala’ and ‘Braeburn’ showed that centrifugal training improved and homogenized fruit size and return bloom as compared to Vertical Axis or Solaxe systems (Larrive et al. 2000, 2001; Crété
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
43
et al. 2002; Ferré et al. 2002; Lauri et al. 2004a). A possible interpretation of these effects would be the moderate length increase of bourseshoots that are brought about by the decrease of branching density (Lauri et al. 2004b). From a physiological point of view, this manipulation would improve the autonomy of the fruiting shoot with regard to carbohydrate acquisition and allocation, leading to a higher return-bloom potential (Lespinasse and Delort 1993). Implementation of centrifugal training in commercial orchards is now under development and evaluation in various places in France and in other countries (e.g., Italy, Diemoz et al. 2002, Neri and Sansavini 2004; Argentina, Rodriguez 2003) through the impetus of the Mafcot network (Lauri et al. 1999). Artificial extinction and its development as a training procedure through the setting up of centrifugal training is one among several manipulations (artificial bending, pruning methods, etc.) that the grower may use in the orchard. It has been shown that the relevance of centrifugal training depends on the cultivar. Although the “light well” (see Fig. 1.18) is not necessary for ‘Granny Smith’ training, it is recommended for colored cultivars such as ‘Pink Lady®’ (Hucbourg et al. 2004a, 2004b). These changes in training concepts already have practical consequences on the desired nursery tree structure: it is now recommended to plant trees that are unbranched up to 100–120 cm from the ground (Fig. 1.18) in order to keep the branches growing downwards as perennial structures (Lauri 2002). Specific studies are now carried out to end up in an overall “LITE planting system” (Lauri et al. 2004b) that optimally combines rootstock/cultivar material, planting distances, and tree height. This concept of crop regulation through detailed pruning of fruiting shoots, minimizing pruning of structural wood, is now under development in other species, in particular cherry (Claverie and Lauri 2005; Lang et al. 2004a; Lauri and Claverie 2005).
IV. CONCLUSIONS In order to constitute its own “orchard puzzle system,” each grower must consider numerous possible choices. Other criteria than those detailed above will of course be considered, particularly the socio-economic context that is specific to each species and production area. Even though these criteria were not addressed in this review, they may be of major importance and complementary to those related to tree architecture. Similarly, we did not detail all the agronomic practices that can be performed in an orchard or at the tree scale. Our primary aim was to
44
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
demonstrate that any manipulation could be analyzed from an “architectural” point of view. This approach integrates the tree architectural development, the desired equilibrium between vegetative and reproductive organs, and their changes in these relationships over time. This has been demonstrated through specific examples, but this approach could be extended to other agronomic practices or tree manipulations such as mineral and water supply, pest management, etc. This is made possible by the perennial behavior of trees that allows one to “read” their history over time. The approaches presented here also open new perspectives for integrating traits related to morphology and architecture into breeding and selection schemes. Recently, this integration has become a goal in different countries, including France, as a complement to disease resistance and fruit quality, which remain the main selection targets in fruit tree breeding (Laurens et al. 2000). A first step consists of studying the inheritance of morphological traits, and relies on an estimation of the respective effects of the genotype and the environment and their possible interactions. Because the comparison of successive years integrates both different climatic conditions and the evolution of traits with plant development, these effects cannot be easily separated in perennial woody plants. Tree architectural analysis could thus provide a methodological framework for genetic studies in the future, to develop new strategies for the phenotypic description of progenies (Costes et al. 2003a). Quantitative studies that have concentrated on different processes involved in tree architecture development are opening new perspectives in modeling approaches. During the last few decades, strategies have focused on modeling either the tree’s structure—mainly considering each developmental unit separately—or its physiological functions, such as carbon acquisition and partitioning. In the last five years, a new trend has emerged that aims at modeling both structure and function in so-called “functional structural models” (Sievänen et al. 2000) in several species. Results have been presented recently for peach, by integrating the sink-driven PEACH model (Grossman and DeJong 1994) into 3D structure simulations using Lindenmayer L-system formalism (LPEACH, Allen et al. 2004). This new approach allows the simulated distribution of carbon acquisition and partitioning among the individual organs of the tree, while the previous model (Grossman and DeJong 1994) represented all the organs of the tree as belonging to the same component with a single function, for each given function. Research is currently under way to develop different modeling strategies for cherry (Lang et al. 2004b) and apple (Renton et al. 2004). In the latter case, the focus is on the integration of the branching and biomechanical models
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
45
presented above to end up in a full tree simulation. This approach would make it possible to address the issue of model validation by comparing simulated trees to architectural databases on both topological and geometrical characters. In the future, 3D simulations obtained by these different projects could open new perspectives for the use of virtual (computer-based) orchards and to test new assumptions in silico regarding the interactions between tree development and agronomic practices. V. GLOSSARY Acrotonic/mesotonic/basitonic branching. Terms related to the location of long lateral shoots along a one-year-old, or even older, bearer shoot. They correspond to long laterals located in the top, medium, and basal part of the bearer shoot, respectively. Notice that these definitions can be used either at the whole tree or at finer scales, such as annual shoot scale. While acrotony is usually considered to be a consequence of the “apical control,” the physiological bases of basitony are not fully elucidated (Barnola and Crabbé 1991). Apical dominance. Control exerted by the shoot apex on the outgrowth of axillary buds during the first year of growth (Cline 1997). Brachyblast/mesoblast/auxiblast. Short, medium, and long shoots, respectively (Chadefaud and Emberger 1960). Delayed (or proleptic) branching. Discontinuous development of a lateral from a terminal meristem to establish a branch, with some intervening period of rest of the lateral meristem. Proleptic branches have one or more basal bud-scales and usually a series of transitional forms towards the adult leaf (Hallé et al. 1978). Excurrent/decurrent. Form of woody plant determined by the differential elongation of branches. Columnar and cone-shaped trees with a strong apical dominance are termed excurrent, while trees with a weak apical dominance are decurrent (Brown et al. 1967). Gravimorphism. Effects of shoot position, in relation to the gravity, on its growth, branching, and flowering (Wareing and Nasr 1958). Growth unit/annual shoot. Growth units (GU) can be distinguished in plants characterized by their rhythmic growth. A growth unit is the part of an axis that develops during a non-interrupted phase of lengthening (Hallé and Martin 1968; Hallé et al. 1978). Each growth unit comprises a basal part that bears basal cataphylls (ultimately leaving scars) followed by a set of true leaves. In temperate climates, annual growth is the sum of growth units that are produced during a growing season.
46
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
Hierarchic/polyarchic organization. Existence of differentiation between axes with dominance of an axis or absence of a main dominant axis, all the axes being equivalent. These terms apply at the whole tree scale (Edelin 1991). Immediate (or sylleptic) branching. Continuous development of a lateral from a terminal meristem to establish a branch, without an evident intervening period of rest of the lateral meristem. Sylleptic branches lack basal bud scales and generally have an extended basal internode (hypopodium) below the first leaf(ves) (Hallé et al. 1978). Meristematic zone (apical and root meristems). Cellular territories, located at the axis end, which are major sites of cell divisions and provide a source of cells for primary shoot and root growth. In higher plants, one to three layers of meristematic cells are usually observed (named L1, L2, and L3) but other terms and organization have been considered (in particular a tunica-corpus organization) (see Lyndon (1998) and Nougarède (2001) for reviews). Metamer/phytomer. Basic module in plants resulting from the shoot apical activity and composed of a node, its axillary production, leaf(ves), and axillary bud(s), and subtending internode (White 1979). Monaxial/polyaxial. Trees whose aerial part is made of a single axis (derived from a single meristem) or several axes respectively (Hallé et al. 1978). Monopodial branching. The outgrowth of axillary buds occurs as the terminal meristem grows and remains dominant (Bell 1991). Orthotropy. An orthotropic axis is erect with essentially radial symmetry, phyllotaxis spiral or decussate, branching 3-dimensional, often non-flowering. The orthotropy of axis implies self-sustaining of the axis, involving secondary growth process. (Both definitions from Hallé et al. 1978). Phyllotaxy. Overall arrangement of leaves along an axis, frequently expressed as the radial angle between two successive leaves or by an index corresponding to a fraction of 360° between two successive leaves (Jean 1995). For detailed explanations on different phyllotaxy in plants see Bell (1991). Plagiotropy. A plagiotropic axis is more or less horizontal with dorsiventral symmetry, leaves either distichous or secondarily arranged in a plan, branching 2-dimensional, often flowering. Different forms of plagiotropism can be observed: plagiotropism by apposition or by substitution.
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
47
Preformed/neoformed organs. Preformed organs correspond to primordia that were formed but not elongated before the meristem enters into a resting period; neoformed organs correspond to primordia that elongate just after their formation from a meristem, without a resting period (Rivals 1965, 1966, 1967). Rhythmic/continuous growth. Terms related to the rhythm of emission of new leaves from an apical meristem. An axis with a constant delay between the successive leaves during all the year has a continuous growth (can be observed in tropical zones), while an axis with clear periods of rest of the apical meristem has a rhythmic growth (Hallé and Martin 1968). Secondary meristem or vascular cambium. Secondary meristem that derives from the procambium and is responsible of the diametral growth of plants and trees. It is composed of a layer of cells (usually considered as uniseriate) that produces phloem and xylem mother cells (phloem being formed in the outer side and xylem in the inner side of the stem) (Lachaud et al. 1999). Sympodial branching. A new axis develops from an axillary bud situated on the previous axis, which dies or grows very slowly. The resulting series of axes is termed a sympodium, or a sympode; each member of the series is termed a sympodial unit (Bell 1991).
LITERATURE CITED Abbott, D. L., and J. Adam. 1978. Physiology of the apple tree. Long Ashton Res. Sta. Rept. 1977:25–27. Abbott, D. L. 1984. The apple tree: physiology and management. Grower Books, London. Adam, B., H. Sinoquet, and C. Godin. 1999. 3A version 1.0: Un logiciel pour l’Acquisition de l’Architecture des Arbres, intégrant la saisie simultanée de la topologie au format AMAPmod et de la géométrie par digitalisation 3D. Guide de l’utilisateur. ClermontFerrand (France). INRA-PIAF. Adam B., H. Sinoquet, and N. Dones. 2001. VegeSTAR-software to compute light interception and canopy photosynthesis from images of 3D digitised plants. Version 2.0. UNR Piaf INRA-UBP, Clermont-Ferrand (France). Allen, M. T., P. Prusinkiewicz, and T. M. DeJong. 2005. Using L-Systems for modeling source-sink interactions, architecture and physiology of growing trees: The L-Peach model. New Phytologist 166(3):869–880. Alméras, T. 2001. Acquisition de la forme des axes ligneux d’un an chez trois variétés d’abricotier: confrontation de données expérimentales à un modèle biomécanique. Biologie, Diversité et Adaptation des Plantes Cultivées. Ph.D. Thesis. Agro.M. Alméras, T., J. Gril, and E. Costes. 2002. Bending of apricot-tree branches under the weight of axillary productions: confrontation of a mechanical model to experimental data. Trees: Structure and Function 16:5–15.
48
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
Alméras, T., E. Costes, and J. C. Salles. 2004. Identification of biomechanical factors involved in stem form variability between apricot tree varieties. Ann. Bot. 93:455–468. Annandale, J. G., N. Z. Jovanovic, G. S. Campbell, N. d. Sautoy, and P. Lobit. 2004. Twodimensional solar radiation interception model for hedgerow fruit trees. Agr. Forest Meteorol. 121:207–225. Arber, A. 1950. The natural philosophy of plant form. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge. Archer, R. 1986. Growth stresses and strains in trees. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York. Bangerth, F., C. Li, and J. Gruber. 2000. Mutual interaction of auxin and cytokinins in regulating correlative dominance. Plant Growth Reg. 32:205–217. Barczi, J. F., P. de Reffye, and Y. Caraglio. 1997. Essai sur l’identification et la mise en oeuvre des paramètres nécessaires à la simulation d’une architecture végétale. In: J. Bouchon (ed.), Modélisation et simulation de l’architecture des végétaux. INRA Editions, Paris. 74:205–254. Barden, J. A., and R. P. Marini. 1998. Growth and cropping of young apple trees as affected by heading and support of the central leader. HortScience 33:39–14. Barlow, P. W. 1989. Meristems, metamers and modules and the development of shoot and root systems. Bot. J. Linnean Soc. 100:255–279. Barnola, P., and J. Crabbé. 1991. La basitonie chez les végétaux ligneux. Déterminismes et variabilité d’expression. In: C. Edelin (ed.), L’Arbre, Biologie et développement, 2ème Colloque International sur l’Arbre. Montpellier, France. Hors Série. 381–396. Barritt, B. H., and M. A. Dilley. 1989. Evaluating high density orchard systems in Washington State. Good Fruit Grower 40 (2): 17–20. Barritt, B. H. 1992. Intensive orchard management. Good Fruit Grower. Yakima, Washington, USA. 211p. Barritt, B. H., B. S. Konishi, and M. A. Dilley. 1995. Performance of 3 apple cultivars with 23 dwarfing rootstocks during 8 seasons in Washington. Fruit Var. J. 49:158–170. Barthélémy, D., Y. Caraglio, and E. Costes. 1997. Architecture, morphogenetic gradients and physiological age of plants. p. 89–136. In: J. Bouchon et al. (eds.), Modélisation et simulation de l’architecture des végétaux. INRA, Montpellier. Bassi, D., A. Dima, and R. Scorza. 1994. Tree structure and pruning response of six peach growth forms. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 119:378–382. Bell, A. D. 1991. Plant form, an illustrated guide to flowering plant morphology. Oxford Univ. Press, Oxford. Ben Mimoun, M., M. Génard, and J. Besset. 1998. Relationships between shoots and the rest of the tree: effect on fruit growth. Acta Hort. 465:303–308. Berman, M. E., and T. M. DeJong. 1997. Crop load and water stress effects on daily stem growth in peach (Prunus persica). Tree Physiol. 17:467–472. Bernhard, R. 1961. Mise à fruits et alternance chez les arbres fruitiers. p. 91–116. Congrès pomologiques. INRA, Paris. Blanco, A., A. Pequerul, J. Val, E. Monge, and J. Gomez Aparisi. 1995. Crop-load effects on vegetative growth, mineral nutrient concentration and leaf water potential in ‘Catherine’ peach. J. Hort. Sci. 70:623–629. Blanke, M. M., and B. A. Notton. 1992. Light transmission into apple fruit and leaves. Scientia Hort. 51:1–2. Borchert, R., and H. Honda. 1984. Control and development in the bifurcation branch system of Tabebuia rosea: a computer simulation. Bot. Gaz. 145:184–195. Bound, S. A. 2001. Managing crop load. p. 89–110. In: R. N. R. Dris, R. Niskanen, and S. M. Jain (eds.), Crop management and postharvest handling of horticultural products. I—Quality management. Enfield (NH-USA), Plymouth (UK), Science Publishers, Inc.
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
49
Boyes, D. 1922. Notes on the characters of apple tree shoots. J. Pomol. Hort. Sci. 3:36–46. Brown, C. L., R. G. McAlpine , and P. P. Kormanik. 1967. Apical dominance and form in woody plants: a reappraisal. Am. J. Bot. 54:153–162. Bruchou, C., and M. Génard. 1999. A space-time model of carbon translocation along a shoot bearing fruits. Ann. Bot. 84:565–576. Bussi, C., J. C. Huguet, J. Besset, and T. Girard. 1995. Rootstock effects on the growth and fruit yield of peach. European J. Agron. 4:387–393. Bussi, C., J. Besset, and T. Girard. 2002. Effects of peach or hybrid rootstocks on growth and cropping of two cultivars of peach trees (Emeraude and Zephyr). Fruits 57: 249–255. Buwalda, J. G., and F. Lenz. 1992. Effects of cropping, nutrition and water supply on accumulation and distribution of biomass and nutrients for apple trees on ‘M9’ root systems. Physiol. Plantar. 84:21–28. Callesen, O. 1997. Testing twenty apple rootstocks. Acta Hort. 541:137–145. Cannell, M. G. R. 1985. Dry matter partitioning in tree crops. p. 160–193. In: M. G. R. Cannell and J. E. Jackson (eds.), Attributes of trees as crop plants. UK Inst. Terrestrial Ecology. Cannell, M. G. R., and R. C. Dewar. 1994. Carbon allocation in trees: a review of concepts in modelling. Adv. Ecol. Res. 25:59–104. Caraglio, Y., and D. Barthélémy. 1997. Revue critique des termes relatifs à la croissance et à la ramification des tiges des végétaux vasculaires. p. 20–88. In: J. Bouchon et al. (eds), Modélisation et simulation de l’architecture des vegetaux, INRA. Caraglio, Y., and C. Edelin. 1990. Architecture and dynamics of the growth of plane. Platanus hybrida Brot. (Platanaceae) (Syn. Platanus acerifolia (Aiton) Willd.) Bul. Société Botanique de France, Lettres Botaniques 137:279–291. Casella, E., and H. Sinoquet. 2003. A method for describing the canopy architecture of coppice poplar with allometric relationships. Tree Physiol. 23:1153–1170. Castera, P., and V. Morlier. 1991. Growth patterns and bending mechanics of branches. Trees: Structure and Function 5:232–238. Cescatti, A. 1997. Modelling the radiative transfer in discontinuous canopies of asymmetric crowns. 1. Model structure and algorithms. Ecological Modelling 101:263–274. Chadefaud, M., and L. Emberger. 1960. Traité de botanique. Paris, Masson. Champagnat, P. 1977. The formation of the trunk in woody plants. In: P. B. Tomlinson and M. H. Zimmermann (eds.), Tropical trees as living systems. Chap. 17. Cambridge Univ. Press, New York. Champagnat, P. 1954a. The pruning of fruit trees. Londres, Crosby Lockwood and Son. Champagnat, P. 1954b. Recherches sur les rameaux anticipés des végétaux ligneux. Rev. Cytologie Biologie Végétales XV:1–51. Champagnat, P. 1965. Physiologie de la croissance et de l’inhibition des bourgeons: Dominance apicale et phénomènes analogues. Rameaux courts et rameaux longs: Problèmes physiologique. Encycl. Plant Physiol. 15:1106–1171. Champagnat, P., P. Barnola, and S. Lavarenne. 1971. Premières recherches sur le déterminisme de l’acrotonie des végétaux ligneux. Ann. Sci. Forest. 28:5–22. Champagnat, P. 1989. Rest and activity in vegetative buds of trees. Ann. Sci. Forest. 46:9–26. Chan, B. G., and J. C. Cain. 1967. The effect of seed formation on subsequent flowering in apple. Proc. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 91:63–68. Chen, K., and F. Lenz. 1997. Effects of training method, shading, and fruiting on water consumption of apple trees. Gartenbauwissenschaft 62:277–285. Clanet, H., and J. C. Salles. 1974. Contribution à l’étude de la fructification de l’abricotier dans des conditions climatiques différentes. Ann. Amélioration des Plantes 24:97–127.
50
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
Claverie, J., and P. É. Lauri. 2005. Extinction training of sweet cherries in France— Appraisal after six years of experiments at INRA. Acta Hort. 667(2):361–366. Cline, M. G. 1997. Concepts and terminology of apical dominance. Am. J. Bot. 84: 1064–1069. Cline, M. G. 2000. The role of hormones and apical dominance. New approaches to an old problem in plant development. Physiol. Plantar. 90:230–237. Cook, N. C., D. U. Bellstedt, and G. Jacobs. 1998a. The development of acrotony in oneyear-old Japanese plum shoots. J. S. African Soc. Hort. Sci. 8:70–74. Cook, N. C., E. Rabe, J. Keulemans, and G. Jacobs. 1998b. The expression of acrotony in deciduous fruit trees: A study of the apple rootstock M.9. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 123:30–34. Costes, E. 1988. Analyse architecturale et modélisation du Litchi (Litchi chinensis Sonn.) Contribution à l’étude de son irrégularité de production à l’Ile de La Réunion. Ph.D. Thesis. Université Montpellier II. Costes, E., P. de Reffye, J. Lichou, Y. Guedon, A. Audubert, and M. Jay. 1992. Stochastic modelling of apricot growth units and branching. Acta Hort. 313:89–98. Costes, E. 1993. Architecture aérienne de l’abricotier en développement libre. Acta Bot. Gallica 140:249–261. Costes, E., and P. E. Lauri. 1995. Processus de croissance en relation avec la ramification sylleptique et la floraison chez le pommier. In: J. Bouchon (ed.), Architecture des arbres fruitiers et forestiers. INRA Editions 74:41–50. Costes, E., and Y. Guédon. 1996. Modelling the annual shoot structure of the apricot tree ‘Lambertin’ in terms of axillary flowering and vegetative growth. Acta Hort. 416:21–28. Costes, E., and Y. Guédon. 1997. Modeling the sylleptic branching on one-year-old trunks of apple cultivars. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 122:53–62. Costes, E., Y. Guédon, and D. Fournier. 1999. Analysis and modelling of fruit tree axillary shoot and flowering distribution. Fruits 54:431–440. Costes, E., D. Fournier, and J. Salles. 2000. Changes in primary and secondary growth as influenced by crop load effects in ‘Fantasme®’ apricot trees. J. Hort. Sci. Biotech. 75:510–519. Costes, E., D. Fournier, J. C. Salles, J. M. Audergon, G. Clauzel, and J. M. Legave. 2001a. Architectural diversity of apricot cultivars. Acta Hort. XIIth International Symposium on Apricot Culture and Decline, Avignon (France), September 2001. Costes, E., J. C. Salles, and G. Garcia. 2001b. Growth and branching pattern along the main axis of two apple cultivars grafted on two different rootstocks. Acta Hort. 557:131–138. Costes, E., and Y. Guédon. 2002. Modelling branching patterns on 1-year-old trunks of six apple cultivars. Ann. Bot. 89:513–524. Costes, E., P. E. Lauri, F. Laurens, N. Moutier, A. Belouin, F. Delort, J. M. Legave, and J. L. Regnard. 2003a. Morphological and architectural traits on fruit trees which could be relevant for genetic studies: A review. Acta Hort. 663:349–355. Costes, E., H. Sinoquet, J. J. Kelner, and C. Godin. 2003b. Exploring within-tree architectural development of two apple tree cultivars over 6 years. Ann. Bot. 91:91–104. Costes, E. 2003. Winter bud content according to position in 3-year-old branching systems of ‘Granny Smith’ apple. Ann. Bot. 92:581–588. Costes, E., A. Belouin, L. Brouard, and M. Le Lezec. 2004. Development of young pear tree architecture and occurrence of first flowering: a varietal comparison. J. Hort. Sci. Biotech. 79:67–74. Crabbé, J., and H. Lakhoua. 1978. Arcure et gravimorphisme chez le pommier, Mise en évidence d’effets gravimorphiques sur bourgeons isoles, après induction de ces effets en diverses conditions. Ann. Sciences Naturelles Botanique Biologie Végétale 12ème série 19.
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
51
Crabbé, J. 1980. Intervention de la dormance des bourgeons dans le développement de la ramification des végétaux ligneux. Bull. Soc. Bot. France, Actualités Botaniques 127:71–78. Crabbé, J. 1987. Aspects particuliers de la morphogénèse caulinaire des végétaux ligneux et introduction à leur étude quantitative. Bruxelles, Editions IRSIA (Institut pour l’encouragement de la recherche scientifique pour l’industrie et l’agriculture). Crabbé, J., and J. A. Escobedo-Alvarez. 1991. Activités méristématiques et cadre temporel assurant la transformation florale des bourgeons chez le Pommier (Malus × domestica Borkh., cv. Golden Delicious). p. 369–379. In: C. Edelin (ed.), L’Arbre, Biologie et développement, 2ème Colloque International sur l’Arbre. Montpellier, France. Hors Série. Crété, X., P. É. Lauri, and G. Ferré. 2002. Pommier—Influence de la date d’extinction sur les résultats agronomiques. Réussir Fruits & Légumes 206:53–54. Decker, I., and P. Hansen. 1990. Shoot growth-flowering relationships in apples as affected by rootstock and drip irrigation. Gartenbauwissenschaft 55:145–148. DeJong, T. M. 1986. Fruit effects on photosynthesis in Prunus persica. Physiol. Plantar. 66:149–153. DeJong, T. M., and Y. L. Grossman. 1994. A supply and demand approach to modelling annual reproductive and vegetative growth of deciduous fruit trees. HortScience 29:1435–1442. DeJong, T. M., and Y. L. Grossman. 1995. Quantifying sink and source limitations on dry matter partitioning to fruit growth in peach trees. Physiol. Plantar. 95:437–443. DeJong, T. M., W. Tsuji, J. Doyle, and Y. L. Grossman. 1999. Comparative economic efficiency of four peach production system in California. HortScience 34:73–78. Denne, M. P. 1960. The growth of apple fruitlets, and the effect of early thinning on fruit development. Ann. Bot. 24:367–406. Dennis, F. G., Jr. 2000. The history of fruit thinning. Plant Growth Regulation 31:1–16. De Wit, I., J. Keulemans, and N. Cook. 2002. Architectural analysis of 1-year-old apple seedlings according to main shoot growth and sylleptic branching characteristics. Trees: Structure and Function 16:473–478. Diemoz, M., G. Vittone, M. Peano, and T. Pantezzi. 2002. La potatura lunga del melo con diradamento della lamburde. L’informatore Agrario. 25/2002:43–44. Durbin, R., S. R. Eddy, A. Krogh, and G. Mitchison. 1998. Biological sequence analysis. Probabilistic models of proteins and nucleic acids. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, UK. Edelin, C. 1981. Some aspects of the plant architecture of conifers. Bull. Société Botanique de France, Lettres Botaniques 128. Edelin, C. 1991. Nouvelles données sur l’architecture des arbres sympodiaux: le concept de plan d’organisation. p. 127–154. In: C. Edelin (ed.), L’Arbre, Biologie et développement, 2ème Colloque Intern. sur l’Arbre. Montpellier, France. Hors Série. Edin, M. 1982. Contribution à l’étude des relations porte-greffe—variétés chez le pêcher. Fruits 37:181–188. Erf, J. A., and J. T. A. Proctor. 1987. Changes in apple leaf water status and vegetative growth as influenced by crop load. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 112:617–620. Fallahi, E., W. M. Colt, B. Fallahi, and I. Chun. 2002. The importance of apple rootstocks on tree growth, yield, fruit quality, leaf nutrition and photosynthesis with an emphasis on ‘Fuji’. HortTechnology 12:38–44. Fernandez, R. T., R. L. Perry, and D. C. Ferree. 1991. Rooting characteristics of apple rootstocks at two NC-140 trial locations. Fruit Var. J. 45:264–268. Ferré, G., P. É. Lauri, X. Crété, and S. Tarisse. 2002. Pommier—Extinction, branche fruitière et maîtrise de la charge. Réussir Fruits & Légumes 206:54–55. Fisher, J. B., and C. L. Weeks. 1985. Tree architecture of Neea (Nyctaginaceae): geometry and simulation of branches and the presence of two different models. Bull. du Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle, section B Adansonia. 7:385–401.
52
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
Fisher, J. B. 1992. How predictive are computer simulations of tree architecture. International J. Plant Sci. 153:137–146. Flore, J. A., C. D. Kesner, and A. D. Webster. 1996. Tree canopy management and the orchard environment: principles and practices of pruning and training. p. 259–277. In: A. D. Webster and N. E. Looney (eds.), Cherries: Crop physiology, production and uses. CAB Int., Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge. Forshey, C. G. 1982. Effects of fruiting, pruning and nitrogen fertilization on shoot growth of ‘Empire’ apples trees. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 107:1092–1097. Forshey, C. G., and D. C. Elfving. 1989. The relationship between vegetative growth and fruiting in apple trees. Hort. Rev. 11:229–287. Forshey, C. G., D. C. Elfving, and R. L. Stebbins. 1992. Training and pruning apple and pear trees. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci., Alexandria (VA). Foster, T., R. Johnston, and A. Seleznyova. 2003. A morphological and quantitative characterization of early floral development in apple (Malus × domestica Borkh.). Ann. Bot. 92:199–206. Fournier, D. 1994. Analyse et modélisation des processus de croissance et développement qui contribuent aux performances agronomiques du pêcher Prunus persica (L.) Batsch. Sciences Agronomiques. Ph.D. thesis. ENSA Montpellier. Fournier, D., Y. Guédon, and E. Costes. 1998. A comparison of different fruiting shoots of peach trees. Acta Hort. 465:557–565. Fournier, D., E. Costes, J. C. Salles, V. Segura, G. Clauzel, J. M. Audergon, and J. M. Legave. 2003. Analysis of morphological and architectural traits on apricot varieties grown in different environmental conditions. Acta Hort. 663:375–380. Fournier, M., B. Chanson, D. Guitard, and B. Thibaut. 1991a. Mechanics of standing trees: modelling a growing structure submitted to continuous and fluctuating loads. 1. Analysis of support stresses. Ann. For. Sci. 48:513–525. Fournier, M., B. Chanson, D. Guitard, and B. Thibaut. 1991b. Mechanics of standing trees: modelling a growing structure submitted to continuous and fluctuating loads. 2. Tridimensional analysis of maturation stresses. Ann. For. Sci. 48:527–546. Fournier, M., B. Chanson, B. Thibaut, and D. Guitard. 1994. Mesures des déformations résiduelles de croissance à la surface des arbres, en relation avec leur morphologie. Observations sur différentes espèces. Ann. Sci. For. 51:249–266. Fulford, R. M. 1966a. The morphogenesis of apple buds. II. The development of the bud. Ann. Bot. 30:27–38. Fulford, R. M. 1966b. The morphogenesis of apple buds. III. The inception of flowers. Ann. Bot. 30:207–219. Gatsuk, L. E., O. V. Smirnova, L. I. Vorontzova, L. B. Zaugolnova, and L. A. Zhukova. 1980. Age states of plants of various growth forms: a review. J. Ecol. 68:675–696. Génard, M., L. Pagès, and J. Kervella. 1994. Relationship between sylleptic branching and components of parent shoot development in the peach tree. Ann. Bot. 74:465– 470. Germain, E. 1990. Inheritance of late leafing and lateral bud fruitfulness in walnut (Juglans regia L.), phenotypic correlations among some traits of the trees. Acta Hort. 284: 125–134. Germain, E. 1992. Le noyer. In: A. Gallais and H. Bannerot (eds.), Amélioration des espèces végétales cultivées, objectifs et critères de sélection. INRA, Paris. Giuliani, R., L. Corelli-Grappadelli, and E. Magnanini. 1997. Effects of crop load on apple photosynthetic responses and yield. Acta Hort. 451:303–311. Godin, C., Y. Guédon, E. Costes, and Y. Caraglio. 1997. Measuring and analyzing plants with the AMAPmod software. In Michalewicz M. (ed.), Advances in computational life science. Vol. I Plants to ecosystems, Chapter 4, CSIRO, Australia.
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
53
Godin, C., and Y. Caraglio. 1998. A multiscale model of plant topological structures. J. Theor. Biol. 191:1–46. Godin, C., E. Costes, and H. Sinoquet. 1999. A method for describing plant architecture which integrates topology and geometry. Ann. Bot. 84:343–357. Godin, C., E. Costes, and H. Sinoquet. (2005). Plant architecture modelling—Virtual plants and complex systems. In: C. Turnbull (ed.), Plant architecture and its manipulation. Blackwell Publishing, Sheffield, UK: 238–287. Goethe. 1790. La métamorphose des plantes. Triades, Paris. Goffinet, M. C., T. L. Robinson, and A. N. Lakso. 1995. A comparison of ‘Empire’ apple fruit size and anatomy in unthinned and hand-thinned trees. J. Hort. Sci. 70:375–387. Goldschmidtreischel, E. 1996. Fruit set and biennial bearing in apple cv Cox’s Orange and Belle de Boskoop. Swedish J. Agr. Res. 26:147–151. Grossman, Y. L., and T. M. DeJong. 1994. Peach: a simulation model of reproductive and vegetative growth in peach trees. Tree Physiol. 14:329–345. Gucci, R., L. C. Grappadelli, S. Tustin, and G. Ravaglia. 1995. The effect of defruiting at different stages of fruit development on leaf photosynthesis of ‘Golden Delicious’ apple. Tree Physiol. 15:35–40. Guédon, Y., D. Barthélémy, Y. Caraglio, and E. Costes. 2001. Pattern analysis in branching and axillary flowering sequences. J. Theor. Biol. 212:481–520. Hallé, F., and R. Martin. 1968. Etude de la croissance rythmique chez l’Hévéa Hevea brasiliensis Mull.-Arg. Euphorbiacées-crotonoidées. Adansonia 8:475–503. Hallé, F., and R. A. A. Oldeman. 1970. Essai sur l’architecture et la dynamique de croissance des arbres tropicaux. Masson et Cie, Paris. Hallé, F., R. A. A. Oldeman, and P. B. Tomlinson. 1978. Tropical trees and forests. SpringerVerlag, Berlin. Hanan, J., and P. Room. 1997. Practical aspects of virtual plant research. In: M. Michalewicz (ed.), Advances in computational life science. Vol. I Plants to ecosystems, Chapter 2. CSIRO, Australia. Hanan, J., and Y. Wang. 2004. Floradig: a configurable program for capturing plant architecture. p. 407–411. In: C. Godin et al. (eds.), Proc. 4th Int. Workshop on FunctionalStructural Plant Models. Montpellier, France. Helsen, J., and J. C. Deckers. 1984. Fruit set and growth reactions of pear trees, cv. Doyenné du Comice on Quince A, pruned at different ratios of vegetative on generative buds. Acta Hort. 149:145–152. Hirst, P. M., and D. C. Ferree. 1995a. Rootstock effects on the flowering of ‘Delicious’ apple. I. Bud development. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 120:1010–1017. Hirst, P. M., and D. C. Ferree. 1995b. Effect of rootstock and cultivar on the growth and precocity of young apple trees. Fruit Var. J. 49:34–41. Ho, L. C. 1988. Metabolism and compartmentation of imported sugars in sink organs in relation to sink strength. Ann. Rev. Plant Physiol. Molecular Biol. 39:355–378. Hoying, S. A., and T. L. Robinson. 2000. The apple orchard planting system puzzle. Acta Hort. 513:257–260. Hucbourg, B., P. É. Lauri, and J. M. Lespinasse. 2004a. Fiche variétale ‘Pink Lady ®‚’ Réussir Fruits & Légumes 228. Hucbourg, B., P. É. Lauri, J. M. Lespinasse, and M. Ramonguilhem. 2004b. Fiche variétale ‘Granny Smith’. Réussir Fruits & Légumes 226. Jackson, J. E. 1970. Individual fruit size in relation to age of bearing wood on Laxton’s Superb apple trees. Rep. East Malling Research Station for 1969:83–85. Jackson, J. E., and J. W. Palmer. 1972. Interception of light by model hedgerow orchards in relation to latitude, time of year and hedgerow configuration and orientation. J. Appl. Ecol. 9:341–357.
54
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
Jackson, J. E., and J. W. Palmer. 1979. A simple model of light transmission and interception by discontinuous canopies. Ann. Bot. 2:381–383. Jackson, J. E. 1980. Light interception and utilization by orchard systems. Hort. Rev. 2:208–267. Jean, R. V. 1995. Phyllotaxis: the status of the field. Mathematical Biosciences 127:181–206. Johnson, R. S., and A. N. Lakso. 1986a. Carbon balance model of a growing apple shoot: I. Development of the model. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 111:160–164. Johnson, R. S., and A. N. Lakso. 1986b. Carbon balance model of a growing apple shoot: II. Simulated effects of light and temperature on long and short shoots. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 111:164–169. Kaminuma, E., N. Heida, Y. Tsumoto, N. Yamamoto, N. Goto, N. Okamoto, A. Konagaya, M. Matsui, and T. Toyoda. 2004. Automatic quantification of morphological traits via three-dimensional measurement of Arabidopsis. Plant J. 38:358–365. Kappel, F. 1991. Partitioning of above-ground dry matter in ‘Lambert’ sweet cherry trees with or without fruit. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 116:201–205. Kappel, F., and H. A. Quamme. 1993. Orchard training systems influence early canopy development and light microclimate within apple tree canopies. Canad. J. Plant Sci. 73:237–248. Kelner, J. J., J. L. Regnard, and P. E. Lauri. 2000. Crop load and rootstock effects on maturation rate and harvest quality of cv. Braeburn apples. Fruits 55:73–81. Kervella, J., L. Pagès, and M. Génard. 1994. Genotypic differences in the length-diameter relationship of branches of one-year-old peach and nectarine trees. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 119:616–619. Lachaud, S., A. Catesson, and J. M. Bonnemain. 1999. Structure and functions of the vascular cambium. C.R. Acad. Sci. 322:633–650. Lai, R., D. J. Woolley, and G. S. Lawes. 1989. Fruit growth in kiwifruit (Actinidia deliciosa): patterns of assimilate distribution between laterals. Scientia Hort. 40:43–52. Lakso, A. N., T. L. Robinson, and S. G. Carpenter. 1989. The palmette leader: a tree design for improved light distribution. HortScience 24:271–275. Lakso, A. N., and L. Corelli-Grappadelli. 1992. Implications of pruning and training practices to carbon partitioning and fruit development in apple. Acta Hort. 322:231–239. Lakso, A. N. 1994. Apple. In: B. Schaffer and P. Andersen (eds.). p. 3–35. Handbook of environmental physiology of fruit crops. I—Temperate crops. CRC Press Univ. of Florida, Boca Raton, FL. Lakso, A. N., J. Barnard, L. Corelli-Grappadelli, and M. C. Goffinet. 1995. An expolinear model of the growth pattern of the apple fruit. J. Hort. Sci. 70:389–394. Lakso, A. N., J. N. Wünsche, J. W. Palmer, and L. Corelli-Grappadelli. 1999. Measurement and modeling of carbon balance of the apple tree. HortScience 34:1040–1047. Lang, G. A., J. D. Early, G. C. Martin, and R. L. Darnell. 1987. Endo-, para-, and ecodormancy: physiological terminology and classification for dormancy research. HortScience 22:371–377. Lang, G. A., J. W. Olmstead, and M. D. Whiting. 2004a. Sweet cherry fruit distribution and leaf populations: modeling canopy dynamics and management strategies. Acta Hort. 636:591–599. Lang, G. A., J. W. Olmstead, and M. D. Whiting. 2004b. La distribuzione dei frutti e delle foglie nel ciliego dolce: nuovi modelli di gestione e controllo dell’albero. Frutticoltura 66(1):40–45. Larrive, G., P. É. Lauri, J. M. Lespinasse, and M. Ramonguilhem. 2000. Pommier. Conduite centrifuge avec extinctions. Réussir Fruits & Légumes 182:46–48. Larrive, G., J. M. Lespinasse, J. P. Bouziges, B. Crespel, S. Gozlan, P. É. Lauri, C. Miny, N. Rey, F. Perrin, D. Pouzoulet, and M. Ramonguilhem. 2001. Pomme et conduite—Le point sur l’extinction. Réussir Fruits & Légumes 192:82.
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
55
Larsen, F. E., S. S. Higgins, and C. A. Dolph. 1992. Rootstock influence over 25 years on yield, yield efficiency and tree growth of cultivars ‘Delicious’ and ‘Golden Delicious’ apple (Malus domestica Borkh.). Scientia Hort. 49:63–70. Laurens, F., J. M. Audergon, J. Claverie, H. Duval, E. Germain, J. Kervella, M. Le Lezec, P. É. Lauri, and J. M. Lespinasse. 2000. Integration of architectural types in French programmes of ligneous fruit species genetic improvement. Fruits 55:141–152. Lauri, P. É. 1991. Données sur l’évolution de la ramification et de la floraison du pêcher (Prunus persica (L.) Batsch) au cours de sa croissance. Ann. Sci. Naturelles, Botanique, Paris 2:95–103. Lauri, P. É., and E. Costes. 1995. Processus de croissance et ramification anticipée chez le Pêcher (Prunus persica (L.) Batsch.). In: J. Bouchon (ed.), Architecture des arbres fruitiers et forestiers. INRA 74:61–67, Montpellier. Lauri, P. É., and É. Térouanne. 1995. Analyse de la croissance primaire de rameaux de pommier (Malus × domestica Borkh.) au cours d’une saison de végétation. Can. J. Bot. 73:1471–1489. Lauri, P. É., É. Terouanne, J. M. Lespinasse, J. L. Regnard, and J. J. Kelner. 1995. Genotypic differences in the axillary bud growth and fruiting pattern of apple fruiting branches over several years: an approach to regulation of fruit bearing. Scientia Hort. 64:265–281. Lauri, P. É., É. Térouanne, and J. M. Lespinasse. 1997a. Relationship between the early development of apple fruiting branches and the regularity of bearing: an approach to the strategies of various cultivars. J. Hort. Sci. 72:519–530. Lauri, P. É., J. M. Lespinasse, and É. Térouanne. 1997b. Vegetative growth and reproductive strategies in apple fruiting branches: an investigation into various cultivars. Acta Hort. 451:717–724. Lauri, P. É., and J. M. Lespinasse. 2000. The vertical axis and solaxe systems in France. Acta Hort. 513:287–296. Lauri, P. É., and J. J. Kelner. 2001. Shoot type demography and dry matter partitioning: a morphometric approach in apple (Malus × domestica). Can. J. Bot. 79:1270–1273. Lauri, P. É., and J. M. Lespinasse. 2001. Genotype of apple trees affects growth and fruiting responses to shoot bending at various times of year. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 126: 169–174. Lauri, P. É. 2002. From tree architecture to tree training—an overview of recent concepts developed in apple in France. J. Korean Soc. Hort. Sci. 43:782–788. Lauri, P. É., É. Costes, and A. Belouin. 2002. European pear architecture and fruiting branch management. An overview of an INRA French research program. Acta Hort. 596:621–626. Lauri, P. É., and J. Claverie. 2005. Training sweet cherries to improve fruit size and quality—An overview of some recent concepts and practical aspects developed at INRA France. Acta Hort. 667:361–366. Lauri, P. É., X. Crété, and G. Ferré. 2004a. Centrifugal training in apple—appraisal of a twoyear experiment on cv. ‘Galaxy’ in southeast France. Acta Hort. (in press). Lauri, P. É., M. Willaume, G. Larrive, and J. M. Lespinasse. 2004b. The concept of centrifugal training in apple aimed at optimizing the relationship between growth and fruiting. Acta Hort. 636:35–42. Lauri, P. É. et al., 1999. Dossier conduite du pommier—branche fruitière et extinction. Réussir Fruits & Légumes 173:27–34. Layne, R. E. C., G. M. Weaver, H. O. Jackson, and F. D. Stroud. 1976. Influence of peach seedling rootstocks on growth yield and survival of peach scion cultivars. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 101:568–572. Lenz, F. 2001. Roots of dwarfed apple trees as affected by fruit load, water and nutrient supply and pruning date. Apple rootstocks for intensive orchards. Proceedings of the international seminar, Warsaw-Ursynow, Poland, 18–21 August, 1999: Supplement. Warsaw, Poland, Warsaw Agr. Univ. Depart. Pomology:13–14.
56
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
Lespinasse, J. M. 1970. Variation du calibre des fruits de Golden delicious en fonction des caractéristiques et de la position des inflorescences sur l’arbre. Bul. Technique d’Information 250:365–381. Lespinasse, J. M. 1977. La conduite du Pommier. I—Types de fructification. Incidence sur la conduite de l’arbre. I.N.V.U.F.L.E.C. Paris. Lespinasse, J. M. 1980. La conduite du pommier. II—L’axe vertical, la rénovation des vergers (2éme partie). CTIFL. Paris. Lespinasse, J. M., and F. Delort. 1986. Apple tree management in vertical axis: appraisal after ten years of experiments. Acta Hort. 160:120–125. Lespinasse, J. M., and F. Delort. 1993. Regulation of fruiting in apple. Role of the bourse and crowned brindles. Acta Hort. 349:229–246. Lespinasse, J. M. 1996. Apple orchard management practices in France. From the vertical axis to the solaxe. Compact Fruit Tree 29:83–88. Lespinasse, J. M., and P. É. Lauri. 1996. Influence of fruiting habit on the pruning and training of apple trees. Compact Fruit Tree 29:75–82. Lespinasse, Y. 1992. Breeding apple tree: aims and methods. Proc. Joint Conf. of the EAPR Breeding and varietal assessment section and the Eucarpia Potato section: 103–110. Li, F., S. Cohen, A. Naor, K. Shaozong, and A. Erez. 2002. Studies of canopy structure and water use of apple tree on three rootstocks. Agricultural Water Management 55:1–14. Link, H. 2000. Significance of flower and fruit thinning on fruit quality. Plant Growth Reg. 31:17–26. Lockard, R. G., and G. W. Schneider. 1981. Stock and scion growth relationships and the dwarfing mechanism in apple. Hort. Rev. 3:315–375. Longman, K. A., T. A. A. Nasr, and P. F. Wareing. 1965. Gravimorphism in trees. 4. The effect of gravity on flowering. Ann. Bot. 29:459–472. Loreti, F., and P. L. Pisani. 1990. Structural manipulation for improved performance in woody plants. HortScience 25:64–70. Lyndon, R. F. 1998. The shoot apical meristem. Its growth and development. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge. Maggs, D. H. 1960. The effect of number of shoots on the quantity and distribution of increment in young apple-trees. Ann. Bot. 24:345–355. Maguylo, K., G. A. Lang, and R. L. Perry. 2004. Rootstock genotype affects flower distribution and density of ‘Hedelfinger’ sweet cherry and ‘Montmorency’ sour cherry. Acta Hort. 636:259–266. Maguylo, K., and P. É. Lauri. 2004. Growth and fruiting characteristics of eight untrained genotypes assessed on both M.9 and own-rooted trees in southern France. Acta Hort. (in press). Marguery, P., and B. S. Sangwan. 1993. Sources of variation between apple fruits within a season, and between seasons. J. Hort. Sci. 68:309–315. Marini, R. P., B. H. Barritt, J. A. Barden, J. Cline, E. E. Hoover, R. L. Granger, M. M. Kushad, M. Parker, R. L. Perry, T. Robinson, S. Khanizadeh, and C. R. Unrath. 2001. Performance of ten apple orchard systems: ten-year summary of the 1990 NC-140 systems trial. J. Am. Pomol. Soc. 55:222–238. Marini, R. P., J. A. Barden, J. A. Cline, R. L. Perry, and T. Robinson. 2002. Effect of apple rootstocks on average ‘Gala’ fruit weight at four locations after adjusting for crop load. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 127:749–753. Massonnet, C., E. García-Villanueva, E. Costes, and J. L. Regnard. 2004. Integrating apple tree aerial and root architecture in a structure-function approach. Acta Hort. 636: 601–608. Maust, B. E., J. G. Williamson, and R. L. Darnell. 1999a. Effects of flower bud density on vegetative and reproductive development and carbohydrate relations in southern highbush blueberry. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 124:532–538.
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
57
Maust, B. E., J. G. Williamson, and R. L. Darnell. 1999b. Flower bud density affects vegetative and fruit development in field-grown southern highbush blueberry. HortScience 34:607–610. Miller, S. A., F. D. Broom, T. G. Thorp, and A. M. Barnett. 2001. Effects of leader pruning on vine architecture, productivity and fruit quality in kiwifruit (Actinidia deliciosa cv. Hayward). Scientia Hort. 91:189–199. Miller, S. S. 1988. Plant bioregulators in apple and pear culture. Hort. Rev. 10:309–401. Monet, R., Y. Bastard, and B. Gibault. 1988. Etude génétique du caractère port pleureur chez le pêcher. Agronomie 8:127–132. Moreno, M. A., R. Adrada, J. Aparicio, and J. A. Betran. 2001. Performance of ‘Sunburst’ sweet cherry grafted on different rootstocks. J. Hort. Sci. Biotech. 76:167–173. Mullins, M. G. 1965. The gravitational responses of young apples trees. J. Hort. Sci. 40: 237–247. Myers, S. C. 1994. Structuring the young peach tree: Avoid wasteful pruning by following this training strategy. Fruit Grower 94(Nov.):10–13. Neri, D., and S. Sansavini. 2004. Attualità della potatura nella frutticoltura intensiva. Frutticoltura 1:14–23. Nougarède, A. 2001. Le méristème caulinaire des Angiospermes: nouveaux outils, nouvelles interprétations. Acta Botanica Gallica 148:3–77. Nozeran, R. 1984. Integration of organismal development. p. 375–401. In: P. W. Barlow and D. J. Carr (eds.), Positional controls in plant development. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge. Palmer, J. W., and J. E. Jackson. 1977. Seasonal light interception and canopy development in hedgerow and bed system apple orchards. J. Appl. Ecol. 14:539–549. Palmer, J. W., Y. L. Cai, and Y. Edjamo. 1991. Effect of part-tree flower thinning on fruiting, vegetative growth and leaf photosynthesis in ‘Cox’s Orange Pippin’ apple. J. Hort. Sci. 66:319–325. Palmer, J. W. 1992. Effects of varying crop load on photosynthesis, dry matter production and partitioning of Crispin/M.27 apple trees. Tree Physiol. 11:19–33. Palmer, J. W., R. Giuliani, and H. M. Adams. 1997. Effect of crop load on fruiting and leaf photosynthesis of ‘Braeburn’/M.26 apple trees. Tree Physiol. 17:741–746. Perry, R. L., and R. T. Fernandez. 1993. Apple rootstock studies in Michigan. Compact Fruit Tree 26:97–99. Phattaralerphong, J., and H. Sinoquet. 2005. A method for 3D reconstruction of tree canopy volume from photographs: assessment with 3D digitised plants. Tree Physiol. 25: 1299–1242. Possingham, J. V. 1994. New concepts in pruning grapevines. Hort. Rev. 16:235–254. Pratt, C. 1990. Apple trees: morphology and anatomy. Hort. Rev. 12:265–348. Preston, A. P. 1968. Pruning and rootstock as factors in the production of primary branches on apple trees. J. Hort. Sci. 43:17–22. Preston, A. P. 1974. An apple tree shaping and spacing experiment. J. Hort. Sci. 49: 297–300. Pretorius, J. J. B., and S. J. E. Wand. 2003. Late-season stomatal sensitivity to microclimate is influenced by sink strength and soil moisture stress in ‘Braestar’ apple trees in South Africa. Scientia Hort. 98:1–15. Prusinkiewicz, P., and A. Lindenmayer. 1990. The algorithmic beauty of plants. Springer Verlag, New York. Prusinkiewicz, P., M. Hammel, J. Hanan, and R. Mech. 1997. L-system: from the theory to visual models of plants. In: M. Michalewicz (ed.), Advances in computational life science. Vol. I Plants to ecosystems, Chapter 1. CSIRO, Australia. Quamme, H. A., and R. T. Brownlee. 1993. Early performance of micropropagated trees of several Malus and Prunus cultivars on their own roots. Can. J. Plant Sci. 73:847–855.
58
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
Quinlan, J. D. 1978. Chemical induction of lateral branches (feathers). Acta Hort. 65:129–138. Reffye de, P. 1981a. Modèle mathématique aléatoire et simulation de la croissance et de l’architecture du caféier Robusta. Etude du fonctionnement des méristèmes et de la croissance des axes végétatif. Café Cacao Thé XXV:83–104. Reffye de, P. 1981b. Modèle mathématique aléatoire et simulation de la croissance et de l’architecture du caféier Robusta. Etude de la mortalité des méristèmes plagiotropes. Café Cacao Thé XXV:219–230. Reffye de, P. 1981c. Modèle mathématique aléatoire et simulation de la croissance et de l’architecture du caféier Robusta. Etude de la ramification sylleptique des rameaux primaires et de la ramification proleptique des rameaux secondaires. Café Cacao Thé XXVI:77–96. Reffye de, P., E. Elguero, and E. Costes. 1991. Growth units construction in trees: a stochastic approach. Acta Biotheoretica 39:3–4. Regnard, J. L., P. E. Lauri, and W. Moore. 2002. Vigueur. In: Thesaurus de termes de morphologie et de morphogenèse des arbres. Arbres et Sciences 2:55–61. Remphrey, W. R., and G. R. Powell. 1987. Crown architecture of Larix laricina saplings: an analysis of higher order branching. Can. J. Bot. 65:268–279. Renton, M., Y. Guédon, C. Godin, and E. Costes. 2004. Integrating Markov chain models and L-systems to simulate the architectural development of apple trees. Acta Hort. 7th International Symposium on Computer Modeling in Fruit Research and Orchard Management. Denmark, June 2004. Rivals, P. 1965. Essai sur la croissance des arbres et sur leurs systèmes de floraison (application aux espèces fruitières)—I. J. d’Agriculture Tropicale Botanique Appliquée XII:655–686. Rivals, P. 1966. Essai sur la croissance des arbres et sur leurs systèmes de floraison (application aux espèces fruitières)—II. J. d’Agriculture Tropicale Botanique Appliquée XIII:91–122. Rivals, P. 1967. Essais sur la croissance des arbres et sur leurs systèmes de floraison (applications aux espèces fruitières)—III. J. d’Agriculture Tropicale Botanique Appliquée XIV:67–102. Robinson, T. 2004. Performance of Cornell-Geneva apple rootstocks with ‘Liberty’ as the scion in NC-140 trials across North America. Acta Hort. 658(1):241–245. Robinson, T. L., A. N. Lakso, and S. G. Carpenter. 1991a. Canopy development, yield, and fruit quality of ‘Empire’ and ‘Delicious’ apple trees grown in four orchard production systems for ten years. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 116:179–187. Robinson, T. L., A. N. Lakso, and Z. B. Ren. 1991b. Modifying apple tree canopies for improved production efficiency. HortScience 26:1005–1012. Rodriguez, R. O. 2003. Incremento de la calidad de la produccion mediante la extinction artificial en manzanos c.v. Royal Gala, en el alto valle de rio negro, Argentina. Frutticultura Profesional 137:41–46. Rom, C. R. 1992. Spur pruning ‘Delicious’ apple for improved spur quality and yield. Acta Hort. 322:55–67. Sabatier, S., I. Ducousso, Y. Guédon, D. Barthélémy, and E. Germain. 1998. Structure de scions d’un an de moyen commun, Juglans regia, variété Lara, greffés sur trois portegreffe (Juglans nigra, J. regia et J. nigra × J. regia). 11ème Colloque sur les Recherches Fruitières INRA-Ctifl—Architecture et modélisation en arboriculture fruitière. Montpellier, France. Sabatier, S., and D. Barthélémy. 1999. Growth dynamics and morphology of annual shoots, according to their architectural position, in young Cedrus atlantica (Endl.) Manetti ex Carrière (PINACEAE). Ann. Bot. 84:387–392.
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
59
Sadowski, A., F. Lenz, G. Engel, and M. Kepka. 1995. Effect of fruit load on leaf nutrient content of apple trees. Acta Hort. 383:67–71. Sansavini, S., and L. Corelli-Grappadelli. 1992. Canopy efficiency of apple as affected by microclimatic factors and tree structure. Acta Hort. 322:69–77. Sansavini, S., and S. Musacchi. 1994. Canopy architecture, training and pruning in the modern European pear orchards: an overview. Acta Hort. 367:152–172. Schaumberg, G., and W. Gruppe. 1985. Growth and fruiting habit of Prunus avium cv. ‘Hedelfinger’ on clonal cherry hybrid rootstocks. Acta Hortic. 169:227–234. Scorza, R. 1984. Characterization of four distinct peach tree growth types. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 109:455–457. Seleznyova, A. N., T. G. Thorp, A. M. Barnett, and E. Costes. 2002. Quantitative analysis of shoot development and branching patterns in Actinidia. Ann. Bot. 89: 471–482. Seleznyova, A., G. Thorp, M. White, S. Tustin, and E. Costes. 2003. Structural development of branches of ‘Royal Gala’ apple grafted on different rootstock/interstock combinations. Ann. Bot. 91:1–8. Seleznyova, A., M. White, S. Tustin, and E. Costes. 2004. Application of Markovian models to study root/interstock effects on flowering of young apple trees. p. 311–314. In: C. Godin et al. (ed.), 4th International Workshop on Functional-Structural Plant Models. Montpellier, France. Sievänen, R., E. Nikinmaa, P. Nygren, H. Ozier-Lafontaine, J. Perttunen, and H. Hakula. 2000. Components of functional-structural tree models. Ann. Forest Sci. 57:399– 412. Sinoquet, H., B. Moulia, and R. Bonhomme. 1991. Estimating the three-dimensional geometry of a maize crop as an input of radiation models: comparison between threedimensional digitising and plant profiles. Agr. For. Meteorol. 55:233–249. Sinoquet, H., P. Rivet, and C. Godin. 1997. Assessment of the three-dimensional architecture of walnut trees using digitising. Silva Fennica 31:265–273. Solar, A., and F. Stampar. 2003. Genotypic differences in branching pattern and fruiting habit in common walnut ( Juglans regia L.). Ann. Bot. 92:317–325. Sussex, I., and N. Kerk. 2001. Les plantes architectes. Biofutur 213:52–56. Thibault, B., and L. Hermann. 1982. Comportement agronomique de poiriers ‘Williams’ cultivés sur leurs propres racines. PHM—Revue Horticole 230:57–60. Thorp, T. G., and M. Sedgley. 1993. Architectural analysis of tree form in a range of avocado cultivars. Scientia Hort. 523:85–98. Thorp, T. G., and B. Stowell. 2001. Pruning height and selective limb removal affect yield of large ‘Hass’ avocado trees. HortScience 36:699–702. Tobutt, K. R. 1985. Breeding columnar apples at East Malling. Acta Hort. 159:63–68. Tobutt, K. R. 1994. Combining apetalous parthenocarpy with columnar growth habit in apple. Euphytica 77:51–54. Tromp, J. 1970. Shoot orientation effects on growth and flower bud formation in apple. Acta Botanica Neerlandica 19:535–538. Tustin, D. S., P. M. Hirst, and I. J. Warrington. 1988. Influence of orientation and position of fruiting laterals on canopy light penetration, yield and fruit quality of ‘Granny Smith’ apple. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 113:693–699. Tustin, S., D. Ferree, S. Myers, L. Corelli-Grappadelli, A. Lakso, T. Robinson, J. Flore, R. Perry, S. Breitkreutz, B. Barritt, B. Konishi, C. Rom, L. Taylor, A. Webster, C. Atkinson, J. Palmer, and W. Cashmore. 1997. The international apple growth study. Acta Hort. 451:693–699. Untiedt, R., and M. Blanke. 2001. Effects of fruit thinning agents on apple tree canopy photosynthesis and dark respiration. Plant Growth Regul. 35:1–9.
60
E. COSTES, P. É. LAURI, AND J. L. REGNARD
Van den Ende, B., and J. E. Kenez. 1985. The tatura trellis—A high intensity apricot orchard for early and high production. Acta Hort. 192:93–97. Van Oosten, H. J. 1984. Ramification des arbres par voie chimique en pépinière fruitière. Fruit Belge 408:305–312. Visser, T. 1965. On the inheritance of the juvenile period in apple. Euphytica 14:125–134. Visser, T., and E. De Vries. 1970. Precocity and productivity of propagated apple and pear seedlings as dependent on the juvenile period. Euphytica 19:141–144. Wagenmakers, P. S. 1991. Simulation of light distribution in dense orchard systems. Agr. Forest Meteorol. 57:13–25. Wareing, P. F., and T. A. A. Nasr. 1958. Gravimorphism in trees. Effects of gravity on growth, apical dominance and flowering in fruit-trees. Nature 182:379–381. Wareing, P. F. 1970. Growth and its coordination in trees. p. 1–21. In: L. C. Luckwill and C. Cutting (eds.), Physiology of tree crops. Academic Press, New York. Warrington, I. J., D. C. Ferree, and J. R. Schupp. 1990. Strain and rootstock effects on spur characteristics and yield of ‘Delicious’ apple strains. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 115:348–356. Webster, A. D., V. Heather Oehl, J. E. Jackson, and O. P. Jones. 1985. The orchard establishment, growth and precocity of four micropropagated apple scion cultivars. J. Hort. Sci. 60:169–180. Webster, A. D. 1997. A review of fruit tree rootstock research and development. Acta Hort. 451:53–73. Webster, A. D., and A. Lucas. 1997. Sweet cherry rootstock studies: Comparisons of Prunus cerasus L. and Prunus hybrid clones as rootstocks for Van, Merton Glory and Merpet scions. J. Hort. Sci. 72:469–481. Weibel, A., R. S. Johnson, and T. M. Dejong. 2003. Comparative vegetative growth responses of two peach cultivars grown on size-controlling versus standard rootstocks. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 128:463–471. Wertheim, S. J. 1978. Manual and chemical induction of side-shoot formation in apple trees in the nursery. Scientia Hort. 9:337–345. Wertheim, S. J. 1985. Productivity and fruit quality of apple in single-row and full-field planting systems. Scientia Hort. 26:191–208. White, J. 1979. The plant as a metapopulation. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 10:109–145. White, M., and S. Tustin. 2000. New apple rootstock alternatives for the Southern Hemisphere. Compact Fruit Tree 33:112–115. Wibbe, M. L., M. M. Blanke, and F. Lenz. 1993. Effect of fruiting on carbon budgets of apple tree canopies. Trees: Structure and Function 8:56–60. Wibbe, M. L., and M. M. Blanke. 1995. Effects of defruiting on source-sink relationship, carbon budget, leaf carbohydrate content and water use efficiency of apple trees. Physiol. Plantar. 94:529–533. Willaume, M., P. É. Lauri, and H. Sinoquet. 2004. Light interception in apple trees influenced by canopy architecture manipulation. Trees: Structure and Function 18:705–713. Williams, M. W. 1979. Chemical thinning of apples. Hort. Rev. 1:270–300. Williams, R. R. 1965. The effect of summer nitrogen applications on the quality of apple blossom. J. Hort. Sci. 40:31–41. Wünsche, J. N., A. N. Lakso, T. L. Robinson, F. Lenz, and S. S. Denning. 1996. The bases of productivity in apple production systems: the role of light interception by different shoot types. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 121:886–893. Wünsche, J. N., and A. N. Lakso. 2000. The relationship between leaf area and light interception by spur and extension shoot leaves and apple orchard productivity. HortScience 35:1202–1206.
1. ANALYZING FRUIT TREE ARCHITECTURE
61
Wünsche, J. N., J. W. Palmer, and D. H. Greer. 2000. Effects of crop load on fruiting and gas-exchange characteristics of ‘Braeburn’/M.26 apple trees at full canopy. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 125:93–99. Wünsche, J. N., and I. B. Ferguson. 2005. Crop load interactions in apple. Hort. Rev. 31:233–292. Wustenberg, H., and J. Keulemans. 1997. A comparison of 3 plum tree training systems during the first five years of growth. Acta Hort. 451:625–631. Zanette, F. 1981. Recherches descriptives et expérimentales sur la morphogénèse des systèmes aériens et racinaires de quelques porte-greffes de pommier. Ph.D. thesis, Université B. Pascal. Clermont Ferrand, France. Zimmerman, M. H., and C. L. Brown. 1971. Trees: Structure and Function. SpringerVerlag, New York. Zimmerman, R. H. 1972. Juvenility and flowering in woody plants: a review. HortScience 7:447–455. Zimmerman, R. H. 1977. Relation of pear seedling size to length of the juvenile period. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 102:443–447.
2 Peach Orchard Systems Richard P. Marini Department of Horticulture The Pennsylvania State University University Park, Pennsylvania, USA 16802-4200 Luca Corelli-Grappadelli Dipartimento di Colture Arboree University of Bologna 40127 Bologna, Italy
I. INTRODUCTION II. CROP PHYSIOLOGY A. Cycles of Growth 1. Tree 2. Flowering 3. Fruit III. LIGHT MANAGEMENT IV. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS A. Tree Forms B. Tree Form Effect on Yield C. Tree Density Effect on Yield D. Effect of Tree Density Plus Tree Form on Yield E. Meadow Type Systems F. Protected Peach Culture G. Economics of Peach Orchard Systems V. VIGOR-CONTROLLING METHODS FOR PEACH TREES A. Root Restriction B. Deficit Irrigation C. Summer Pruning D. Plant Growth Regulators E. Tree Growth Habit VI. LIMITATIONS TO HIGH PEACH YIELDS A. Rootstocks Affect Partitioning B. Scion Affects Partitioning
Horticultural Reviews, Volume 32, Edited by Jules Janick ISBN 0-471-73216-8 © 2006 John Wiley & Sons 63
64
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
C. Tree Spacing Affects Partitioning D. Training System Affects Partitioning VII. FUTURE TRENDS AND DIRECTION LITERATURE CITED
I. INTRODUCTION Peach is one of the most important deciduous tree fruits, second only to apple, and the annual worldwide production is about 10 million tons (Fideghelli et al. 1998), but annual production is increasing exponentially as land devoted to peach production is increasing at the rate of about 77,000 ha/year (Fig. 2.1) (FAOSTAT 2003). Much of this growth has occurred in China, where peach plantings increased about 426,000 ha from 1995 to 2002. Profit margins for commercial peach orchards have declined, partly because prices have increased less than production costs. Profits may be improved by increasing yield per unit of land area or by reducing labor costs. Orchard system modification may influence both of these factors. Worldwide, peach yield/ha has declined during the past decade (Fig. 2.1), probably because young orchards have not yet reached full production and because a higher percentage of world production is from China, where yields are low. Yield/ha varies greatly from one country to another. During the past 50 years, yield/ha has improved in developed, but not developing countries (Fig. 2.2). The lack of improvement in developing countries is likely due to the lack of research leading to new orchard practices, but even in developed countries average yield/ha has improved little since 1980. Researchers and commercial producers have evaluated a number of stone fruit orchard systems, but the majority of commercial peach orchards have changed little during the past 150 years. For more than a century, the Open-Vase system, with about 250 to 350 trees per hectare, has been the predominant peach tree form, but hedgerow systems have also been grown for many years (Cole 1849; Fitz 1872; Hedrick 1917). In contrast, during the last 40 years, dramatic changes in apple orchard systems have resulted in greatly improved yields. Dwarf rootstocks and spur-type scion cultivars have allowed apple producers to plant highdensity orchards with 700 to 1400 trees per hectare. Combining these genotypes with cultural practices such as shallow planting, slender spindle and North-Holland Spindle systems, very limited pruning in the early years, and cropping as a tool to reduce vegetative vigor in the early years allowed establishment of plantings with 4000 or more trees per ha (Jackson 1989; Sansavini and Corelli-Grappadelli 1997). The benefits of
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
65
Hectares (millions)
2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
1970
1980
1990
2000
1970
1980
1990
Ann. Production (mt)
14 12 10 8 6 4 1960
11
Avg. Yield (mt/ha)
10 9 8 7 6 1960
2000
Year Fig. 2.1. Trends in worldwide peach production from 1960 to 2000: Hectares of peaches planted (Top), average annual production of peaches (Middle), average peach yield per ha (Bottom) (Source: Food and Agriculture Organization Statistics Database, 2003).
66
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI 20 USA
Yield (t/ha)
15
S. Europe
Canada
10
Developing Countries
5
0 1955
Developed Countries
China
1965
1975
1985
1995
2005
Year Fig. 2.2. Yield (t/ha) for different peach-producing regions from 1960 to 2000. Southern Europe includes France, Greece, Italy, and Spain. To avoid large yearly fluctuations, values are actually 3-year means: for example, values for 1980 are the means for 1979, 1980, and 1981 (Source: Food and Agriculture Organization Statistics Database, 2003).
high-density plantings include precocity of bearing, higher early yields, and earlier returns in the critical first years from planting (Goedegebure 1989). Training systems, such as the Vertical Axis (Lespinasse 1980), were also developed to take advantage of the precocity, the variation in disease and insect resistance, and the vigor-controlling characteristics of these rootstocks and cultivars. With such systems, relatively tall trees (3.1 to 4 m tall) produced high yields of quality fruit within 5 years of planting and productivity was maintained for a number of years (Marini et al. 2001a). However, these plantings with tall trees were expensive to prune and harvest due to the need for ladders or expensive picking platforms, an alternative to ladders in intensive South-European orchards. Peach trees may easily reach a similar height because of the species’ intrinsic vigor and lack of vigor-controlling rootstocks. Tall peach trees tend to be more expensive to maintain because more hand labor is required for pruning, and to manage the crop load with hand thinning. Additionally, most peach cultivars ripen non-uniformly and require several spot-pickings. In Spain and France, where emphasis is being placed on harvesting ripe fruit, commercial peach orchards are being harvested as many as 5 to 8 times. Some of the most intensive (i.e., highest tree densities) peach orchard systems, such as the Meadow Orchard (Erez 1978), were designed for mechanical harvest, but they have not yet been successful because of many limitations, primarily mechanization; they may become more economical as harvesting technology improves.
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
67
Researchers and commercial producers have few tools to alter the balance of vegetative and reproductive growth of peach trees. Thus, the primary benefit of intensive peach orchards is the high production of young orchards associated with rapid development of the fruiting canopy. Intensive orchards are sophisticated production units, which require very careful management to retain their performance. Very often, as these orchards mature, yields may decline as shade reduces the productivity of the lower and inner canopy, pushing the productive zone out and upward. The primary challenge with these systems is to maintain high productivity over the life of the orchard. Lacking vigorcontrolling rootstocks or suitable compact/spur cultivars, some researchers have successfully used water stress, root restriction, and root competition to control tree vigor. This review is intended to provide a critical evaluation of peach orchard systems research, and to identify potential areas of future research.
II. CROP PHYSIOLOGY A. Cycles of Growth Before discussing various components of peach orchard systems and techniques employed to manage various systems, it seems appropriate to discuss seasonal growth of the tree and fruit. 1. Tree. Like all deciduous trees, peach trees undergo a dormant period during the winter. During dormancy root growth may continue if soil temperatures are appropriate and buds develop slowly. In late winter the buds develop at an accelerated rate, in response to higher temperatures. Flower buds and vegetative buds break at about the same time, so there are no fully expanded leaves on the tree during bloom. Early-season growth of roots, shoots, fruit, and cambium depend on stored carbon reserves within the woody tissues of the tree. All of these “sinks” compete for a limited supply of reserves. Growing leaves and shoots are sinks until enough leaf area develops on a shoot for the shoot to become a net exporter of carbohydrates; in apple this occurs about 15 to 19 days after bud break (Johnson and Lakso 1986). Fruit growth competes with shoot growth because defruited trees produce more primary stems, more long primary stems, and more and longer secondary shoots than trees with a crop (Grossman and DeJong 1995c). Fruit also compete with trunk growth because trunk growth of an early-season and a late-season cultivar was reduced by the presence of fruit, but trunk growth was reduced more for the late-season cultivar. The sink strength of vegetative organs
68
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
is sufficient to compete with the high sink strength of growing fruit because vegetative growth continued during periods of resource-limited fruit growth (Grossman and DeJong 1995c). Early-maturing cultivars partition a greater amount of dry weight to vegetative growth because there was a shorter period of competition between vegetative growth and reproductive growth (Grossman and DeJong 1995a). Maximum root growth for fruiting and non-fruiting trees occurred after shoot extension ceased and before leaf drop (Williamson and Coston 1989). Root growth apparently is a relatively weak sink, because root growth was low during times of rapid shoot growth. Cropping resulted in a temporary (about 4 weeks) decline in root growth during the last 3 to 4 weeks before harvest and for a short period after harvest (Williamson and Coston 1989). 2. Flowering. Flower bud initiation for the subsequent season commences about 60 days after bloom and continues for up to two months, depending on latitude. Flower bud differentiation begins at the lower nodes and progresses up the shoot as shoots increase in length. Dorsey (1935) reported that flower bud differentiation was first detected about four nodes from the shoot apex. Removing flowers or young fruit reduced the competition between vegetative shoots and fruit and increased the number of flower buds at the basal five nodes of the current season’s shoots (Byers et al. 1990). Not only did early fruit thinning enhance flower bud formation, but also the percentage of flower buds surviving a spring frost was increased and flower bud survival was negatively related to crop load the previous year (Byers and Marini 1994). Three weeks of shade during the period of 10 to 16 weeks after bloom also inhibited flower bud formation (Marini and Sowers 1990). 3. Fruit. Peach fruit growth, measured as fruit diameter, is traditionally divided into three stages (Tukey 1933; Chalmers and van den Ende 1975). The first stage is a period of rapid fruit growth from bloom to about 50 days after bloom, when the pits harden. Fruit growth during this stage is primarily due to cell division, although cell expansion and intercellular space formation begin about 24 days after bloom (Masia et al. 1992). The second stage varies in length depending on the maturity date of the cultivar, being very short (just a few days) in early cultivars, and much longer (up to two months) in late-season cultivars. This stage is characterized by slow diameter increase. Fruit dry weight continues to increase during the second stage due to endocarp development. Because the components of the endocarp have a high construction cost (Corelli-Grappadelli et al. unpublished), this is a time when the tree has a high demand for resources for the growing fruit. The third stage is a period of rapid fruit diameter increase as the mesocarp cells expand.
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
69
This final stage is often called the “final swell” and lasts several weeks before harvest, depending on the time of ripening. Water stress during the final swell reduces fruit growth, regardless of crop load. Dry weight increase was reduced by water stress only on heavy-cropped trees, indicating that late-season water stress affects fruit hydration rather than resource availability when trees are adequately thinned (DeJong 1998). In a series of papers, Grossman and DeJong (1995a; 1995b; 1995c) identified periods of resource-limited fruit and vegetative growth in fruiting peach trees. For an early-maturing cultivar there was one period beginning during stage I, at about 3.5 weeks after bloom, and continuing through harvest (about 12 weeks after bloom). For the late-maturing cultivar, the first period also occurred from about 3.5 to about 12 weeks after bloom, and a second period occurred during the last 4 weeks of the final swell (18 to 22 weeks after bloom). Fruit exposed to resource limitations grew normally when resources became available, indicating that fruit growth caused by resource limitations was only temporary. The patterns of contribution of different leaves to the growth of the fruit during the season have been studied with 14carbon techniques (Corelli-Grappadelli et al. 1996). The extension shoot growing from the tip of a 1-year-old shoot was a very strong sink in the first four weeks after full bloom (WAFB), a time when fruit growth largely depended on reserves and, to a small extent, on carbohydrates produced by the axillary shoot (the lateral shoot growing off the same node bearing a fruit). The axillary shoots without fruit partitioned carbon only to the growing extension shoot tip. By four WAFB, the extension shoot began exporting to the fruits on lower nodes, while the axillary shoot continued to support fruit growth, but the axillary shoot without fruit did not support this growth. Only much later in the season (well after pit hardening) did this shoot contribute to the growth of the fruit. These findings underscore the importance of the axillary shoot for the growth of the fruit, which had been indicated by Manaresi and Draghetti (1915) and by Marini and Sowers (1994). This role of the axillary shoot was confirmed in specific fruit growth studies (Fig. 2.3). Fruits growing on the same node as an axillary shoot were 17% heavier at 60 DAFB than fruits growing on nodes without the lateral shoot. Carbon partitioning to growing fruit was also affected by crop load: active export of fixed carbon from the leaves to the fruit (CorelliGrappadelli and Ravaglia unpublished) was found during stage three of fruit development. In shoots with high crop load, more than 50% of the fixed carbon was translocated out of the labeled leaf within 24 hours. This amount decreased with decreasing crop load (Fig. 2.4). The carbon uptake in the fruits of the high crop load mirrored the export pattern of the leaves: most carbon was imported within 24 hours of labeling (Fig.
70
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
Fruit weight (g)
30
With axillary shoot
20
10
Without axillary shoot
0 20
30
40
50
60
70
Days after full bloom Fig. 2.3. Growth of peach fruits, cv. Elegant Lady, as a function of the presence or absence of an axillary shoot on the same node bearing the fruit, during the first stage of fruit growth. Each point is the mean of a least 30 fruit. Treatment means differ at the 5% level of significance on each of the last three measurement dates.
14C remaining in the labelled leaves (%)
100 High Intermediate Low Average
80 60 40 20 0
0
2
4
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
6
8
10
12
14C Translocation to the fruit (DPM/g dm)
40 30 20 10 0
Days after labelling Fig. 2.4. Patterns of 14C label export from exposed peach leaves, cv. Elegant Lady, as a function of the crop load of the branch to which the exposed shoot was attached. Labeling occurred at the onset of the final swell of fruit development.
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
71
2.4). An understanding of resource allocation throughout the season is critical to the development of techniques to suppress tree vigor, without reducing yield or fruit size. From about 12 to 18 weeks after bloom, resources, even on non-thinned trees, do not limit fruit growth. It seems that this may be the optimum time to suppress vegetative growth. Major increases in yield will probably require development of cultivars that partition a greater portion of resources into fruit rather than wood.
III. LIGHT MANAGEMENT Energy required for the growth of all green plants comes from sunlight and, like most C3 plants, the carbon exchange rate (CER) of peach leaves saturated at about 800 µmol·s–1·m–2 of photosynthetically active radiation (400 to 700 nm) (DeJong and Doyle 1985; Marini and Marini 1983). Whole-tree CER is saturated at about 1600 µmol·s–1·m–2 of photosynthetically active radiation (Giuliani et al. 1998). Specific leaf weight (the ratio of leaf dry weight to leaf area) was lower for shaded than for non-shaded leaves and can be used as a biological integrator of cumulative light exposure for a leaf until mid-season (Marini and Barden 1981). After leaves were exposed to a range of light levels for 18 days, specific leaf weight was linearly related to light level and CER was related to specific leaf weight, even when CER was measured under light-saturating conditions. The CER and specific leaf weight of leaves that were shaded for 18 days and then exposed to full sun for 26 and 4 days, respectively, were similar to non-shaded leaves (Marini and Sowers 1990). DeJong and Doyle (1985) found that leaf nitrogen content was related to the light environment of a leaf, and leaf nitrogen was reallocated from shaded leaves to more exposed leaves of the tree canopy. Their data indicate that the redistribution of leaf nitrogen is a means for maximizing whole-tree carbon gain. Apple yield per unit land area was linearly related to light interception (Lakso 1994; Robinson 1997), so it is critical for young orchards to fill their space quickly to capture light, but in mature orchards light penetration throughout the canopy must be adequate to maintain fruiting wood and to produce quality fruit. In the absence of similar data relating yield to light interception in peach orchards, but considering the reports by Grossman and DeJong (1998) and Giuliani et al. (1998), it seems reasonable to assume that peach yields are also related to the amount of light energy intercepted per unit of land area. Peach fruit quality is influenced by the amount of light intercepted by the fruit and the leaves near the fruit, which is influenced by the
72
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
position of the fruit in the canopy. Critical light levels were identified for various aspects of peach fruit quality by shading portions of trees during the final six weeks before harvest (Marini et al. 1991; Marini and Sowers 1990) and by measuring light interception by fruit during the final swell (Lewallen 2000). Flore and Kesner (1982) also described critical light levels for various aspects of peach tree growth and fruit quality. These critical light levels are presented in Table 2.1. To obtain high yields, fruit orchards must intercept a high proportion of light, but light must also be distributed throughout the canopy at levels adequate to maintain fruiting wood and fruit quality. Levels of interception greater than 70% of available light have been reported for apple, but at such levels light distribution may be inadequate for continued high yields of quality fruit (Jackson 1980). Spurs of pome fruits require a certain level of light to remain fruitful, but leafy peach shoots must be exposed to adequate light to remain alive. Heavily shaded portions of peach canopies are devoid of fruiting shoots because they die during the late summer. Flower bud density was also positively related to light levels from about 50 to 100 days after bloom (Marini and Sowers 1990). Therefore, to maintain high production, light distribution in peach orchards is more important than in apple orchards. Light distribution patterns were reported for various fruit tree forms. In general, when light was measured through a horizontal cross-section of the canopy, light was distributed in a U-shaped pattern for Central
Table 2.1. A summary of critical light levels (% full sun) for various aspects of peach leaf function and fruit quality. Light threshold (% full sun) Parameter
Response to light
Flore and Kesner 1982
Marini et al. 1990 & 1991
Leaf size Leaf thickness Sp. leaf weight Max. CER Cold hardiness Fruit size Fruit color Soluble solids Flesh firmness Flower densityz
negative positive positive positive positive positive positive positive none positive
36 36 36 36 21 — 36 — — —
40 40 40 35 — 10 30 50 No response 23
z
Flower bud formation was most affected by shade during the period 50 to 100 days after bloom.
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
73
Leader trees (Porpiglia and Barden 1980; Marini and Barden 1982), but light was distributed in a W-shaped pattern in Open-Vase type trees (Marini and Marini 1983). Regardless of tree shape, light penetration declined rapidly from the tree periphery towards the tree center and adequate light for high fruit quality was limited to a zone of about 1.5 m thick around the outside of the tree (Marini and Barden 1982; Kappel et al. 1983). Light levels were relatively high in the center of trees (Marini and Marini 1983) and following pruning or shearing of hedgerow systems in the summer (Kappel et al. 1983; Marini 1985a). Génard and Baret (1994) measured the spatial and temporal variation of light transmitted to shoots in peach trees. Some shoots were exposed to light almost all day, while other shoots were in sunlight very little. Well-exposed shoots were mostly located at the top of the tree and were relatively erect. Shoots located in the outer parts of the canopy were slightly but significantly more sunlit than others. About 30% of the shoots received < 30% of the incoming light. Light transmitted to the shoots did not depend on shoot compass direction. Drooping shoots were preferentially shaded by horizontal and erect shoots above and next to their position on the branch. Grossman and DeJong (1998) measured daily patterns of intercepted photosynthetic photon flux (PPF) for peach trees in four training systems in California. The intercepted PPF was relatively constant from 0900 to 1500 hrs for all training systems. The KAC-V (1196 trees/ha) was the highest density system and the Cordon system (919 trees/ha) had the most horizontal canopy, and both intercepted more light than the KACV (919 trees/ha), whereas the open vase (299 trees/ha) system intercepted the least light. The high-density KAC-V and Cordon systems intercepted nearly twice as much light as the Open-Vase system, but no system intercepted much more than 50% of the available light. Robinson and Lakso (1991) also found that Y-shaped apple trees intercepted more light than conical-shaped trees. More information is needed to determine the relationship between light interception and peach yield per ha over a wide range of light levels. Only then can orchard systems be developed that capture the optimum amount of light.
IV. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS An orchard system is the combination of cultivar, rootstock, tree training system, and tree spacing. Because so many factors are involved, evaluating the impact of the individual components of a system is difficult. Training systems and spacing, for example, are tightly interwoven. It is
74
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
impossible to compare an open vase to a Y-trellis at a common tree density because the size of the canopy for these two forms is very different. Tree spacing must be adjusted for the training system to fully exploit the potential profitability of a system. Therefore, comparisons are usually made with reference to orchard area, regardless of the training system/tree density involved. Another consequence of the interplay between the different factors involved in orchard design is that the environmental conditions (climate, soil, length of season), as well as economics, often limit the options available, leaving little room for experimentation. This is also true from a scientific point of view and may explain why there have been relatively few studies dealing with peach orchard design. In addition to the duration and expense of these trials, it is often difficult to train, manage and crop different systems with the same proficiency. The same applies to multi-location studies, particularly when the selected cultivars are unequally suited to the environmental conditions of the different locations. Experiences with international apple trials in Europe have shown this very clearly. Multiple-row layouts, for example, used in northern Europe or south Tyrol in Italy are not suited for vigorous sites where managing multiple rows are difficult (Palmer et al. 1989). Similarly, the vigorous triploid cultivar ‘Jonagold’ was poorly adapted to the high vigor, high light levels in Bologna, Italy where bearing was delayed and fruit quality was poor compared to many apple-growing districts in the world (Tustin et al. 1997). Cooperators in the NC-140 multi-location rootstock trials in North America also learned to adjust tree spacing to site vigor (Marini et al. 2000). Because of these considerations, it is difficult to evaluate orchard systems in a single analysis that is comprehensive of all the factors involved. It is therefore preferable to review the single main factors separately. A. Tree Forms Peach trees have been trained to four basic forms, but there are modifications of each. These modifications have in general been prompted by advancements in growing techniques, or the need to reduce costs in order to maintain profitability. For example, the widespread adoption of the so called “Potatura A Tutta Cima” (no-heading-cuts pruning), reported by Sansavini (1980) and Fideghelli (1990), was one of the turning points for the shift in Italy from the traditional to the more intensive and better producing Palmette. Extension specialists and researchers found that avoiding heading cuts during the training phase induced
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
75
peach trees to start bearing one or two years sooner (Baldassari 1950; 1967). Earlier bearing also shortened the productive life of an orchard. In the intensive peach industries of southern European countries (Italy, Spain, France, and Greece), this is not considered a disadvantage because it is desirable to renew orchards with cultivars with improved fruit quality and that expand the harvest season. In Spain, for example, the introduction of new cultivars expanded the harvest season from May through June in the 1970s and mid 1980s to April through October at the beginning of the 21st century (Table 2.2, Borras Escriba 2001). Open-Vase or Open-Center trees have been most common in commercial orchards for more than 150 years (Cole 1849), but variations of the system evolved differently in different regions. Open-Vase trees in California, USA usually have three primary scaffold branches, each with two secondary scaffolds; mature trees are fairly upright and are about 4 to 5 m tall (Rizzi 1975). In eastern North America, Open-Vase and modified leader trees have three to six primary scaffold branches and bench cuts are used to develop low (2.2 to 3.2 m tall) spreading trees with tree densities of 220 to 550 trees per hectare. The Open-Vase, with about 500 trees per hectare, is the most important training system in Spain (Royo Diaz and Martinez Lopez 1992), France (Hugard 1986), and Greece (Tsipouridis 2003). In Spain, the variants of the Open-Vase include the “Vaso Italiano,” “Vaso de Plataformas,” and “Vaso Californiano.” The main difference is in the angle of the branches and the hierarchy of the secondary branches. Trees of the Italian vase are spaced more widely because the branches are trained less vertical and more horizontal. The “Vaso de Plataformas” has more
Table 2.2. Changes in cultivar composition of the Spanish peach and nectarine industry over the last three decades, expressed as a percentage of harvested fruit per month (adapted from Borras Escriba 2001). 1973–84 Month April May June July August September October
1985–90
1991–95
1997–99
Peach Nectarine Peach Nectarine Peach Nectarine Peach Nectarine — 43.4 54.5 1.0 0.3 0.2 0.6
— 13.4 69.9 16.4 0.3 — —
— 63.3 29.3 0.6 1.1 2.2 3.5
— 32.1 62.3 5.2 0.3 0.1 —
0.9 45.8 29.8 9.6 7.8 4.6 1.5
0.3 28.7 35.0 15.9 10.0 7.5 2.6
2.5 41.0 20.2 15.8 9.2 7.1 4.2
1.5 27.3 30.5 18.8 11.8 7.3 2.9
76
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
upright scaffold branches (35 to 40° from the vertical) and each carries three tiers of secondary branches, up to four in the first tier and descending to two in the top tier. The height of the tree is about 3.0 m. The “Vaso Californiano” features three fairly upright scaffold branches (15 to 20° from vertical), each with two secondary scaffolds (Royo Diaz and Martinez Lopez 1992). In Italy, the Open-Vase has long been one of the most popular training systems, and even today it is second only to the Palmette (Sansavini et al. 2000). The most common vase is called “Delayed” because this tree is trained without heading cuts to stimulate the formation of the whorl of primary branches; only the top of the tree is headed above a high lateral in the winter after the first season. The goal is to weaken the leader, thus stimulating the lowest laterals to take over and naturally spread out and form the main whorl of branches. The leader is removed only after the third season, thus the name, “Delayed.” The number of branches retained may vary, but normally it is 5 to 6, arranged in two whirls. Tree density is about 550 trees per hectare. The vase is rather difficult to maintain low, within 2.2 to 2.5 m from the ground, and it is recommended mostly for low-vigor cultivar/rootstock combinations, or in low-vigor environments. Summer pruning is required during the whole life of the orchard to avoid excessive shading that pushes the vegetative zone out and up, in a doughnut shape. A variant of the vase that is sometimes used in Italy and Spain is the socalled “Forma Libera” or free-shape (Sansavini 1980; Royo Diaz and Martinez Lopez 1992). The tree is left totally unpruned in the first 3 to 4 years, which makes it very productive early on, but in severe need of reform pruning after this initial period. Because the tree develops a bushy appearance, very often it is pruned back to form a vase, which reduces yield. This is the main reason for its limited adoption. Y-shaped trees of several species have been grown for many years. In this training system, the leader is removed and only two primary scaffold branches are retained; they are trained to grow perpendicular to the row axis. Sometimes branches are oriented within the row to form narrow hedgerows referred to as the Parallel-V. The Y-system is suited to high densities. Reports of densities up to 2000 trees/ha exist in the literature, but most common densities range between 900 and 1500 trees/ha (Corelli-Grappadelli et al. 1986; Chalmers et al. 1978; Caruso et al. 1997; Caruso et al. 2003). Although Y-shaped trees had been grown for many years (Baldassari 1950), interest was rekindled by the potential for very high light interception (above 70%, Nuzzo et al. 2000; Corelli-Grappadelli, unpublished). A variant of this system is the socalled V, where trees are planted at an angle from the horizontal and alternated along the row to form a V-shaped canopy perpendicular to the
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
77
row axis (Costa et al. 1989). Tree densities for this system can be quite high, reaching 2000 trees/ha (4 × 1.25 m). The Tatura Trellis (Chalmers et al. 1978) was developed for mechanical harvest of cling peaches, and scaffold limbs are supported with a wire trellis. The Kearney Agricultural Center Perpendicular-V (KAC-V), developed for hand harvest, is not supported (DeJong et al. 1994). Typical tree densities are 900 to 1200 trees/ha and trees are about 5.5 m tall. The M.I.A. trellis is a modification of the V-shaped tree. The A-shaped canopy is developed by orienting the leaders at 60° from vertical and leaning trees in adjacent rows towards each other. The Y-trellis has been adopted in Southern Italy with some modifications, including a wider angle between branches (45°, compared to 35° for the Tatura Trellis), which are allowed to converge and touch each other in the middle of the alley row (Caruso et al. 2003). This system has very high light interception, up to 70% at orchard maturity (Nuzzo et al. 2000), and has very high productivity. Full production yields reported by Caruso et al. (2003) average 67 t/ha per year from the third to the eighth year for “Venus”, a late-season cultivar grafted on the vigorous stock GF677. Plantings of Y-trellis are becoming more widespread in the peach-growing districts of southern Italy, where they are replacing Open-Center trees and Palmettes (Caruso et al. 2003). A version of the Y-trellis, proposed by Caruso et al. (1997) for low-chill early-season cultivars, is a variant of the meadow orchard concept proposed by Erez (1978), but for greenhouse cultivation. The goal was to restrict growth and retain productivity on small non-supported trees. This free-standing Tatura was dubbed the fsTatura by the authors, who adopted a pruning technique involving heading of all the one-year-old wood, above the most proximal lateral shoot. Trees were pruned immediately after harvest, early enough in the season to allow flower bud differentiation on the newly formed shoots, which bloomed and fruited the following season. By using vigorous rootstocks, such as GF 677, this cycle could be maintained. Yields in this system were high, because of the high tree density of 2000 tree/ha. The average for the first three harvest seasons was 18 t/ha, but the yield in the first fruiting season (the third year from planting) was 14 t/ha (Caruso et al. 1997). The Y-trellis is the system used in protected cultivation in southern Italy because this shape fits very well the structure of the tunnels used. In these tunnels, the support arches are set along the row, where there is no vegetation, and the dome of the tunnel is placed above the row-middle where the branches extend. Because tree spacings are reduced (4.5 × 1.5 m), tree densities are fairly high (about 1500 trees/ha), which favors precocity and higher yields. For ‘Armking’ nectarine on seedling rootstock in the Basilicata region of southern Italy, Fideghelli et al. (1988) reported
78
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
yields of 5.0 t/ha in the second season, and up to about 30 t/ha at full production. Hedgerow systems are developed by planting trees fairly closely in the row, and trees can be trained to various forms to develop a solid wall of foliage. The most widespread hedgerow system is the Palmette, which was developed in Italy (Baldassari 1967). This system was more productive and less expensive than the traditional vase (Fideghelli 1969), and was ideally suited to the use of platforms for pruning, thinning, and picking, which greatly improved labor efficiency over the use of ladders needed for the vase. The Palmette is still the most widespread system in the Italian peach industry by a wide margin (Sansavini et al. 2000), although it is quite different than the original concept. Today’s Palmettes (“Free” or “Sprint” Palmette) are planted closer, with typical densities of 600 to 900 trees per ha, and trees are trained with summer pruning. The structure of the tree is rather “free”, meaning the best branches are retained irrespective of their position along the trunk. The angle of branch insertion is reduced, to allow closer spacing in the row. The number of branches is reduced, sometimes to one tier, which is grown out and up to occupy the space between adjacent trees. With the exception of Italy, the desired height, spread, and shape of hedgerows are often maintained with mechanical shearing during the summer (Hayden and Emerson 1988), but the resulting dense layer of foliage at the tops and sides of the hedge must be removed by selective dormant pruning to improve light penetration into the hedge. Central Leader. As the advantages of high-density plantings were being demonstrated with apple, a move towards higher densities occurred in peach as well, with the adaptation of the “Axis Central” to this species in France (Hugard 1981; Belluau and Lemaire 1986), and the introduction of ‘Fusetto”, or Free Spindle, in Italy (Bargioni et al. 1983). Both systems are suited for densities above 1000 to 2000 trees per ha. However, both systems tend to suffer from excessive shading and loss of bearing wood in the lower part of the canopy, particularly after 4 to 5 years from planting, and at the higher densities (Belluau and Lemaire 1986; Loreti et al. 1989). The trees have a single vertical leader and are conical in shape, and are about 3.0 to 3.5 m tall (Bargioni et al. 1983). The trees create a hedgerow, well suited to picking platforms. Both systems feature a leader, with no permanent branches. Fruiting wood is retained on short branches, which are renewed every few years. Since Central Leader trees are closer to the natural growth habit of peach than the Palmette, these training systems require less pruning during training, and their training is much easier. As a result, early yields are normally fairly high, which is their greatest advantage.
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
79
B. Tree Form Effect on Yield Several researchers have compared yield for trees planted at the same spacing but trained to different shapes to evaluate tree performance. It is important to evaluate the inherent bearing potential of a training system, and especially its capacity for early fruit production. In the highly intensive orchards of the south European peach industries, precocity is considered very important. Often the training systems requiring the least initial pruning are most precocious and tend to have higher cumulative yields over the first 4 to 6 seasons. Many trials have demonstrated this advantage for more “natural” systems. The Free Shape, which is nearly nonpruned initially, the Fusetto and sometimes the Delayed Vasette all require less early pruning and are more precocious than systems such as the Palmette or the Y-Trellis (Bargioni et al. 1985; Bassi et al. 1985; Blay Coll 1988; Corelli-Grappadelli et al. 1986; Sansavini et al. 1980; Sansavini et al. 1985; Toribio Mancebo 1993). Many orchard systems trials demonstrated that the initial high yields of the aforementioned systems are temporary and as orchards age the yields are similar to other systems. Bassi et al. (1985) reported yields from an 8-year comparison of six training systems where, despite frost damage in two seasons, after the initial advantage of the Free Shape, yields tended to become equivalent across all the systems. Yields per tree, averaged over the six growing seasons, were highest for the Free Shape and lowest for the Regular and Free Palmette; yields for the three vase-derived systems were intermediate between the Free Shape and the Palmette. These results illustrate that training the tree into a given form can influence yield. The nearly nonpruned Free Shape was most productive early in the life of the orchard, whereas the Vase types or the Palmettes had relatively low early yields due to the pruning required for tree training. Later, as the trees occupied their allotted space, the Free Shape had to be contain-pruned to either a Hedgerow system or to a Vase, and the loss of a large portion of its canopy caused decreased yield. A similar situation exists with Fusetto, which is pruned very little initially, and is capable of high early yields, but excessive growth may cause shading, which reduces wood quality and productivity. In other studies, when trees were planted at the same density, the KAC-V and the Cordon systems produced similar yields per hectare (Grossman and DeJong 1998). When planted at low densities, Open-Vase trees had higher yields per tree, but lower yield per unit of land area under the canopy or per unit of canopy volume than did Central Leader trees (Marini et al. 1995). In another experiment, Central Leader and Open-Vase forms were compared at low density (370 trees per hectare)
80
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
and at moderate density (740 trees per hectare) (Marini and Sowers 2000). The interaction between tree form and tree density was not significant, and tree form had little effect on cumulative yield. Allison and Overcash (1987) compared Central Leader trees to a Palmette Trellis system planted at 1292 trees/ha. Training system did not influence cumulative yield during the first four years. Menzies (1988) compared a Palmette Hedgerow to the Lincoln Canopy, both at 1000 trees/ha: after six years cumulative yield was about 25% greater for the Palmette system. Taylor (1988) compared six different training systems, all with 1680 trees/ha. Low temperatures eliminated the crop in the third year. Yields/ha in the fourth year, ranked highest to lowest, were: Open Vase > Modified Belgian Fence > Tatura Trellis > Perpendicular Fan > Parallel Fan > Central Leader. Results from a number of experiments generally indicate that training system has little impact on peach yield. In apple, Y-shaped trees were 11% and 18% more productive than trees trained as Slender Spindles and Palmette, respectively, and differences in yield were related to light interception, because yield per unit of light energy was similar (Robinson 1997). In agreement with this, Giuliani et al. (1998) found that whole-canopy photosynthesis of peach trees was linearly related to the amount of light intercepted by the tree, irrespective of the training system (Y-trellis, Sprint Palmette, and delayed Vase). The Y-Trellis intercepted more light, it also had the highest photosynthetic rates and, in this trial, it also had the highest yields over nine cropping seasons (Corelli-Grappadelli unpublished). Therefore, when training systems planted at the same density do not show much difference in yield, this should not be surprising if they efficiently fill the allotted space and intercept similar amounts of light. C. Tree Density Effect on Yield Conventional orchards are planned to fit the dimensions of mature bearing trees. As a result, trees require two or more years to fill their allotted space and for the orchard to attain maximum yields, even if the trees are not pruned to hasten their development. Several experiments were performed in which tree density, but not tree form, was varied. After five years for the KAC-V system, increasing the tree density from 919 to 1196 trees/ha (23%), increased cumulative yield/ha and cumulative number of fruit harvested per ha only 14% and 17%, respectively (DeJong et al. 1999). After nine years, when Central Leader or Open Vase tree densities were increased from 370 to 740 trees/ha (100%), cumulative yield and cumulative number of fruit harvested/ha increased only
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
81
40% and 57%, respectively (Marini and Sowers 2000). Giulivo et al. (1984) grew peach and nectarine trees as free spindles at densities ranging from 1250 to 2000 trees/ha and found that yield/ha increased less than proportional to tree density. Hutton et al. (1987) compared three training systems, each at three tree densities and reported cumulative yield after eight years. The effect of tree density on yield varied with the training system. For the Palmette Hedgerow at 865 trees/ha, increasing the tree density by 40% or 100% resulted in increased yields of 38% and 84%, respectively. For Tatura Trellis, increasing the tree density by 45% or 95% resulted in yields 4% greater and 5% less than when trees were planted at 853 trees/ha. For M.I.A. Trellis at 1110 trees/ha, increasing the tree density by 48% or 100% reduced yields by 12% and 5%, respectively. In Texas, yields for Y-shape trees were positively related to tree density from 350 to 700 trees/ha (Reeder et al. 1980). In Ontario, Canada Central Leader (Fusetto) trees were compared at three tree densities (504, 775, and 1291 trees/ha) (Miles et al. 1999). Cumulative yield per ha for the first three years was slightly more than double for the highest-density trees than for the lowest-density trees. While testing the Fusetto at varying tree densities (1250, 1665, and 2500 trees/ha) in Italy, Bargioni et al. (1985) concluded that the density best suited for the environmental conditions (soil type and climate) of the Verona area in Northern Italy was 1665 trees/ha. The 2500 trees/ha had slightly higher yield, but only marginally, and was not economically justified. Since maximum orchard productivity cannot be attained until trees fill their allotted space, the larger that trees are allowed to grow, the farther apart they must be planted, and the longer it will take to reach full production. Tree training can also influence the length of time required to reach full production. With today’s Palmette, for example, trees are seldom headed back to stimulate branch formation, which is completely opposite to the guidelines of 30 years ago. The goal of planting higher tree densities, combined with minimal pruning, is to reap earlier and more abundant yields. Once trees fill the allotted space, the capacity for yield will be limited by the amount of light that can be intercepted. That is why in virtually all the trials there is a poor relationship between the cumulative yield increase and tree density increase, after the first few seasons. Results with apples are similar. In the international training systems trial, involving five European locations during the 1980s, Palmer et al. (1989) compared systems with densities ranging from 2667 to 8889 trees/ha, trained as single-, double-, and triple-row spindles and 6-row beds of full field minitrees. After six cropping seasons, the highest-density system, with 233% more trees/ha, produced only 38% more fruit.
82
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
However, in the first cropping season (the year after planting), the highest-density trees yielded 14 to 20 t/ha, compared to 5 to 11 t/ha for the other systems. From the fourth season on, when the orchards were at full bearing, there were no differences in yield/year across all training systems. Training systems utilizing small trees are more conducive to high densities, and generally tend to have high early yields. Later on this advantage is lost and the risk of losing production due to excessive tree competition becomes a factor to be carefully evaluated. Because of the interaction between tree behavior with site environmental conditions, the ideal tree density will vary with site and training system. Regardless of training system, in most of the studies reported increases in yield were usually relatively small as tree densities increased above 1000 trees/ha. D. Effect of Tree Density Plus Tree Form on Yield As discussed above, the choice of training system dictates the spacing that can be used, and often it also defines the training strategy, i.e., the sequence of summer and winter pruning events that will lead to a fully developed tree. As a result, yield may be dramatically affected by the combination of these two factors. A number of studies have demonstrated this. Hayden and Emerson (1988) conducted one of the first high-density peach trials in North America. In 1969, they compared seven systems with tree densities ranging from 717 to 2392 trees/ha. Frost problems complicated their data, but yields in the third and fifth years were high as long as trees were grown in a hedge form and were maintained by summer pruning. Yields were highest for high-density Pillar (2392 trees/ha) and Belgian Fence (1794 trees/ha) and lowest for low-density Pillar (798 trees/ha); the other four systems had intermediate yields and were high-density Open Vase (717 trees/ha), 2-Scaffold Vase Fan (717 trees/ha), Modified Leader Fan (717 trees/ha), and Pillar (1196 trees/ha). Based on results from three trials, they felt that the ideal system was the flat fan tree wall, with a tree density of 500 to 750 trees/ha, 3.1 m tall, 1.2 m wide at the top, and 1.8 m wide at the bottom, maintained with summer shearing and dormant pruning (Hayden and Emerson 1988). Phillips and Weaver (1975) compared three systems for 9 years. During the first five years compared to Modified Leader (397 trees/ha), cumulative yield was more than double for Palmette trees (1157 trees/ha), and 67% higher for hedgerow trees (868 trees/ha). In the sixth year, yield was similar for all systems, and the Modified Leader trees were most productive in the seventh and eighth years. After nine years,
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
83
cumulative yield was 100, 102, and 113 t/ha for Modified Leader, Hedgerow, and Palmette trees, respectively. Leuty and Pree (1980) continued this trial for another four years, and found that cumulative yields were related to tree density only during the first three fruiting years. After nine years, increasing the tree population from 397 to 1157 trees/ha (290%) resulted in only a 12% increase in cumulative yield/ha. Pruning and thinning costs were also related to tree density, and they concluded that the benefit of high density was mostly in the early years, but high density offered little economic advantage over the life of the orchard. Layne et al. (1981) compared three tree densities at three levels of irrigation for trees trained as Open-Vases. After seven years, cumulative yield increased as tree density increased from 266 to 536 trees/ha. Irrigation improved cumulative yield at high, but not low tree densities. Doubling the tree density increased yield by 75% for non-irrigated trees and 96% for irrigated trees. When four hedgerow systems were compared over a 10-year period, cumulative yields were 125, 111, 104, and 92 t/ha for Oblique Fan (567 trees/ha), Modified Central Leader (606 trees/ha), Canted Oblique Fan (969 trees/ha), and Open Center (381 trees/ha) (Kappel et al. 1983). After six years, Grossman and DeJong (1998) reported that annual clingstone yields of 75.5 t/ha for high-density KAC-V (1196 trees/ha), 56.5 t/ha for KAC-V (919 trees/ha), 53.7 t/ha for Cordon (919 trees/ha), and 41.2 t/ha for Open Vase (299 trees/ha). Menzies (1988) compared five orchard systems, and cumulative yields for six years were highest for Palmette Hedgerow (1000 trees/ha) and Tatura Trellis (2500 trees/ha), yields were lowest for Open Vase (500 trees/ha), and yields were intermediate for Lincoln Canopy (1000 trees/ha) and Central Leader (666 trees/ha). Hutton et al. (1987) compared three tree forms, each at three tree densities. Cumulative yields for the first eight years were highest for the M.I.A. Trellis (1110 trees/ha and 1646 trees/ha) and the Palmette Hedgerow (1732 trees/ha); yields were lowest for Palmette Hedgerow (865 trees/ha); the other combinations had intermediate yields. The optimum tree density appeared to vary with tree form and was 1732 trees/ha for Palmette Hedgerow, 1234 trees/ha for Tatura Trellis, and 1110 trees/ha for M.I.A. Trellis. Four orchard systems were compared for eight years in California (DeJong et al. 1992). The systems included the standard Open Vase with 298 trees/ha, Parallel V with 598 trees/ha, KAC-V with 909 trees/ha, and Central Leader with 909 trees/ha. During the first 2 cropping years the higher density systems had higher yields per ha, but yield was similar for all systems after the third growing season. They concluded that the
84
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
Open Vase system has a physiological yield capacity similar to the Perpendicular V system at orchard maturity, but the two systems differ in their physical ability to support the crop. Open Vase trees required more support than the V-shaped trees and more limb breakage was still observed on Open Vase trees. They concluded that the practical advantages and disadvantages of the high-density systems are probably less related to crop yield than to orchard management considerations such as: tree structural strength, uniformity, access to ladder work, and simplicity of cultural operations. Light interception by Hedgerows can be fairly low because hedge width should be limited to 1.5 to 2.0 m to allow adequate light distribution throughout the canopy (Marini and Barden 1982; Marini and Marini 1983). As a result, more than half the orchard floor is devoid of trees. Stembridge (1977) tried to increase the amount of orchard floor covered with canopy by planting short Hedgerows arranged in a bed system. Compared to traditional Hedgerows, this increased coverage of ground by 50%. The individual Hedgerow had 5 trees oriented diagonally across the 2.3 m-wide beds to provide a row length of 3.7 m. Beds were separated by 3.05 m-wide drive middles to provide 1210 trees/ha. At planting, trees were inclined 45 degrees and oriented down the row to fill the space quickly. Yield the year after planting was 6.5 to 8.6 t/ha and 33.2 t/ha in the third year, compared to only 9.7 t/ha for the traditional orchard. Weed control was difficult in the Hedgerow system. The primary advantage of Hedgerow systems is that the orchard space is filled quickly and yields of young orchards are improved. DeJong et al. (1994) compared the KAC-V (909 trees/ha) with the traditional Open Vase system (298 trees/ha). Cumulative yields for the first three years were about 44 t/ha for the KAC-V and 24 t/ha for the Open Vase, but after eight years yields were 224 and 190 t/ha, respectively. Therefore, the increased yield due to high tree populations is temporary and the economic feasibility of such systems may depend on the cost of trees and the value of new cultivars where supply has not satisfied demand. The training strategy can have a large impact on productivity, especially in the critical early years. The move away from heading cuts demonstrates this. When Vase trees are trained with heading cuts, their initial yields are generally very low, but in the case of the Delayed Vasette, where the tree is left nearly intact initially, early yields are improved. In a comparison of five systems, Delayed Vasette planted at 727 trees/ha was compared to Fusetto and Y-Trellis trees each planted at 727 and 1454 trees/ha. The yield per tree in the second season was similar for the Delayed Vasette and Fusetto at 727 trees/ha, but all other systems had lower yields. The study was terminated after four years, due
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
85
to tree mortality following a winter freeze, but through the third cropping season the Delayed Vasette still had high yields per tree. However, because of the planting density, this form had one of the lowest cumulative yields/ha for the three seasons. Cumulative yields per ha were 52.9, 64.4, and 50.1 t/ha for the Delayed Vasette, Fusetto, and Y-Trellis with 727 trees/ha, respectively. The Fusetto and Y-trellis at 1454 trees/ha had 96.1 and 77.3 t/ha, respectively (Corelli-Grappadelli et al. 1986). For most studies, the high yields associated with high tree density appear to result from early production, which most intensive systems stimulate, and higher number of trees per ha. This advantage may be lost over the life of the orchard, particularly if the orchard is maintained for more than 20 years. For this reason, the choice of training system may have less to do with tree performance than with the equipment on the farm, labor availability, proficiency in training the tree into a given form, the costs of establishing and maintaining various systems, and their impact on fruit size and quality. From this survey it is clear that, although early yields are of utmost interest, the overall performance of the orchard is of equal importance. Therefore, future trials involving training systems and tree spacing should be long-term studies, intended to provide information well past the 10th growing season of the orchard. E. Meadow Type Systems Trees in conventional orchards are spaced to accommodate mature trees. Yields are relatively low until the trees fill their space. As conventional orchards mature, the lower limbs often become less productive and produce low-quality fruit due to within-tree shading. Another shortcoming of traditional trees is that mature orchards are expensive to manage as the fruiting zone moves toward the top of the tree. The “meadow orchard” was conceived to produce vigorous shoot growth, with adequate light exposure, on short trees. The meadow orchard, originally developed by Hudson (1971), was an ultra-high-density orchard for apples intended for mechanical harvest by mowing the trees with their fruit as grass in a meadow. There were about 100,000 trees/ha, on dwarfing rootstocks, and full field cover was obtained with no alleyways for machinery. The tree was allowed to grow and induced to fruit on 1-year-old wood. The following year, the tree set fruit that ripened in fall. At harvest, the tree was cut back to a short stump. A new biennial cycle started in the next year, with a new vegetative flush. Theoretically, the two primary advantages for the meadow orchard are that the yields of young orchards would be high
86
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
because the orchard space is filled quickly, and the fruiting zone would remain near the ground because the tree top would be periodically removed. The apple meadow orchard was not economical because apple trees cropped only every other year. Peaches seem better suited to a meadow orchard system for two reasons: (1) establishment costs are relatively low because peach trees can be produced from rooted cuttings (Couvillon and Erez 1980), and (2) peaches fruit on 1-year-old wood and may crop annually. Erez (1988) evaluated two variations of the meadow orchard in Israel. The “mechanized system” was developed for mechanized harvesting (Erez 1976; 1978). This system involved planting cuttings in winter and a single shoot was allowed to develop the following summer. When shoots were about 60 cm long, they were headed to induce thicker laterals. By the end of the season, tree height was about 1.3 to 2.0 m with many laterals. The second year trees may produce crops similar to mature orchards, especially for early-maturing cultivars. At harvest, the stem was detached to leave a short stump from which regrowth occurred and shoots were thinned to only one per tree. In areas with long growing seasons (4 to 5 months of growing conditions after harvest), early-maturing cultivars regenerated enough shoots with flower buds to crop annually and produce 3 to 4 kg/tree/year (13,333 trees/ha). Orchard longevity is not known, but one orchard cropped for 9 years. The 2 factors related to tree mortality seemed to be desiccation of the stump following tree harvest and nutrient deficiency. Mulching the trees with the shredded tree tops reduced heat stress, and nutritional problems were alleviated with continuous fertigation. Results with prototype machinery for harvesting trees and separating fruit from the trees were encouraging, but are probably too expensive for small-scale orchards (Couvillon and Erez 1980). A modified-mechanized system was tested in Georgia, USA (Couvillon and Erez 1982) with 9810 or 3924 trees/ha. Early-maturing, but not latematuring, cultivars regenerated enough flower buds for annual production. They also noticed that trees became deficient in several elements and constant fertigation was needed to alleviate the problem. Although yields were high for a young orchard, fruit size was too small for today’s markets; the percentage of fruit > 5.7 cm in diameter was only 12%, 46%, and 7% for ‘Redhaven’, ‘Loring’, and ‘Blake’, respectively. The second type of meadow orchard was called the “Intensive System” (Erez 1988). In this system, the tree was trained to 2 main shoots and each winter one of the two shoots was headed back to a short stump to allow regeneration of new growth and flower bud formation during the growing season. Therefore, each side of the tree fruited every second year. Compared to the mechanized system, the intensive system had bet-
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
87
ter flower bud differentiation, fruit set, and yield per tree, especially for late-season cultivars. Although both systems should lend themselves to mechanization, commercial success with the meadow orchard will require new cultivars that are moderately vigorous, have an upright growth habit, have moderate flower density, and have fruit that ripen uniformly. Both systems require some type of summer pruning before harvest to improve fruit color. Optimum tree spacing for the mechanized system is probably about 1.5 to 1.8 m between rows and 0.6 m between trees within the row. For the intensive system, trees should be spaced about 1.5 m × 0.5 m. Although meadow orchard systems have been tested for nearly 30 years, for economic reasons, they have not been commercially adopted. Modifications of the meadow orchard were tested in Florida, USA with 3333 trees/ha, where trees were topped after harvest at 0.75 m above ground to leave the basal portion of scaffold branches (Young and Crocker 1982). This system allowed annual cropping and yields in young orchards were considerably higher than for traditional peach orchards (Crocker et al. 1988). Another alternative to encourage annual cropping was to cut alternate trees in the row after harvest (Evert 1988). In Sicily, a study was conducted on a commercial farm where Meadow Orchard trees were grown under greenhouse cultivation (Bellini et al. 2000). Tree densities were 5000 trees/ha for the Small Vase trees and 3300 trees/ha for Y-Trellis with ‘Maravilha’, a low-chill cultivar. Trees were highly productive: average annual yields during the first four seasons were 25 and 33 t/ha for trees trained as Y-trellis and Small Vase, respectively. The authors indicated that trees could be successfully grown at these very high densities, although maintaining a productive canopy required summer pruning several times per season, particularly with the more densely planted Small Vase. F. Protected Peach Culture During the Renaissance, exotic fruit, especially citrus, were grown in containers in European courts. One of the most famous was the citrus collection maintained over the centuries by the Medici family in Florence (Baldini 2001). The trees were grown outside during the summer, and moved into glass houses to avoid cold damage in the winter and spring frost (Brace 1904). Growing peach trees in containers allows fruit production on land that is otherwise unsuitable for fruit culture. Container-grown trees are also mobile and can be transferred to environmental conditions that are favorable for growth and fruiting in regions that would otherwise be unsuitable for peach production.
88
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
Today, the goals of protected peach cultivation are to reap economic benefits associated with advanced ripening, or to extend the cultivation of peaches to areas of the world where it would be impossible to grow this species outdoors. Protected peach culture prevents winter injury and spring frosts, eliminates Cytospora canker disease associated with cold injury, allows marketing fresh fruit earlier in the summer than normal, allows production of cold-tender cultivars, and increases productivity per ha in regions where peach production is usually not profitable. Peach production in Ontario, Canada is limited to areas close to lake Ontario. Miles and Leuty (1988) attempted to expand the area suitable for peach culture by evaluating the feasibility of growing peach trees planted in the soil in a greenhouse. The house was maintained at about –5 to 7°C during dormancy. The house was cooled with ventilation during the spring, and then the walls of the house were removed to provide ambient climatic conditions. Three training systems were evaluated for four years, and the Tatura Trellis had the highest yields. Compared to similar trees in the field, yields were 40 to 80% higher in the greenhouse. Establishment costs were more than three times higher for protected culture, but due to higher yields and higher prices for early-season fruit, the protected culture system was more profitable than the standard system. Peach culture in Nova Scotia, Canada is marginally profitable due to low winter temperatures and short tree life associated with winter injury, and the growing season is short and cool. To evaluate the commercial feasibility of growing peaches, early-season peach cultivars were grown in large containers and were over-wintered in heated poly-covered houses (Crowe et al. 1987). Average annual yield was about 16 to 19 kg/tree from the third to the seventh year after planting. Although these yields are less than 30% of what would be expected of field-grown trees in traditional peach-growing regions, the system was considered to be profitable in regions where traditionally-grown peaches are normally not profitable. In southern Italy, commercial protected peach production began in the early 1970s (Sansavini 1974), and at that time the first research trials were established (Bellini et al. 1997). Today in southern Italy, apricot, peach, and table grape are grown in greenhouses. The greenhouses used for peach and apricot are normally plastic tunnels with the support arches placed in the row, and trees are trained to the Y-Trellis with tree densities of about 1500 trees/ha (Fideghelli et al. 1988). This training system lends itself quite well to the structure of the tunnel because the supporting arches are placed within the tree rows and the inter-row is free for equipment. The tunnels are covered after completion of the chill requirement, which is normally during January in southern Italy. Following closure of the tunnel, flowering occurs in early February and,
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
89
depending on the cultivar, harvest commences in mid to late April. Thus, fruit can be harvested about a month earlier than in traditional orchards. Yields are satisfactory, especially considering the premium prices received for early fruit. Fideghelli et al. (1988) reported an average yield of 20.9 t/ha over the first four years for 'Armking.' In some areas of Israel, natural chilling is inadequate to grow most commercial peach cultivars (Erez et al. 1998). Erez et al. (1989) planted rooted cuttings in 25-L pots and trained the trees as trees in a meadow orchard. They demonstrated that container-grown trees could be placed in refrigerated rooms or transferred to cooler regions for a period of time to satisfy the chilling requirement. Upon attaining adequate chilling, trees could also be placed in greenhouses to advance maturity and take advantage of high prices for early-season fruit. Yields in this system were 20 to 30 t/ha. Although these systems are feasible, they have not been commercially accepted for economic reasons. In southern Italy, low-cost non-heated PVC-covered tunnels are used because the environmental conditions allow for sufficient natural heating of the greenhouses. If this were not the case, the cost of heating would totally offset the economics of this type of cultivation. In areas where heating is required, the economic feasibility of protected peach culture may depend on the price of fuel to maintain trees at appropriate temperatures. Interest rates on the capital required to build protective structures and the price and availability of imported fruit from other regions may also impact the profitability of these systems. G. Economics of Peach Orchard Systems The success of high-density apple plantings has prompted researchers to evaluate various high-density peach systems. It is difficult to find good data for mature high-density peach plantings and few researchers have reported data from which the profitability of various systems can be compared. Due to the scarcity of data, the discussion of this crucial subject is very brief. Marini et al. (1995) first published the economic impact of different tree forms in Virginia, USA. When planted at low densities, Open-Vase trees had higher yield and crop value per tree, but lower yield and crop value per unit of land area under the canopy or per unit of canopy volume than did Central Leader trees. In another study, Central Leader and Open-Vase trees were compared at two densities (Marini and Sowers 2000). After nine years, cumulative yield was highest for highdensity trees (700 vs. 350 trees/ha), but cumulative yield was not affected by tree form. Income minus costs for the nine years was about $4,200/ha higher, and net present value was about $2,200/ha higher, for
90
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
Open-Vase than for Central Leader trees. Cumulative net present value for the nine years was about $2,660/ha higher for high- than for low-density trees. In California, four spacing/training-systems were compared with a clingstone peach for five years (DeJong et al. 1999). The four systems were: high-density KAC-V (1196 trees/ha), KAC-V (919 trees/ha), Cordon (919 trees/ha), and Open Vase (299 trees/ha). The Cordon system had the highest yield in the second year, but the V systems had the highest returns after five years. Mitchell and Chalmers (1983) did not perform an economic analysis of their study comparing Central Leader trees planted 2.0 × 1.0 m, 4.0 × 1.0 m, and 2.0 × 1.0 m with removal of alternate rows after five years to give a final spacing of 4.0 × 2.0 m. Canning yield/ha was highest in years 2, 3, and 4 for 2.0 × 1.0 m; yields were similar for all densities in the fifth year; and yield was higher for the 4.0 × 1.0 m plots in the sixth year. Cumulative yield for the six years was 21 t/ha more for the higher-density system. If one assumes a wholesale price of $234.58/t and a wholesale price for trees of $5.00/tree, the cumulative crop value minus the cost of trees is $2,426/ha higher for the high-density system. However, if additional costs for pruning and fruit thinning, and the time value of money were taken into account, the differences in net profit would likely be less. Although high-density peach orchards produce high yields, more conclusive economic data are needed before intensive orchard systems can be recommended over traditional Open-Vase systems.
V. VIGOR-CONTROLLING METHODS FOR PEACH TREES Through the years, a number of rootstocks less vigorous than seedling, such as Damas 1869, Saint Julien, GF 665-2, MRS2/5, PSA5, and PSA6, have been tested, but none has provided the same type of vigor control as dwarf apple rootstocks. Because of this, peach orchard intensification is challenging. As peach trees age, fruiting in the lower portion of the canopy is limited by shade and intensive tree management is required to prevent the fruiting zone from moving higher above ground. Several orchard practices have been used, with varying degrees of success, to suppress tree vigor in intensive peach orchards. Below is a brief description of some of these techniques. A. Root Restriction Peach trees exhibit a functional equilibrium between the roots and shoots (Richards 1977, 1986; Richards and Rowe 1977). Vegetative growth was directly proportional to the soil volume of the roots (Tan and Buttery
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
91
1986), whereas fruiting was inversely proportional to the soil volume (Richards 1986). Williamson et al. (1992) evaluated two methods of restricting tree growth in a high-density peach planting (5000 trees/ha). Planting in fabric-lined trenches or narrow herbicide strips reduced shoot diameter and length, and flowering was increased in fabric-lined trenches, but not narrow herbicide strips. Trees in fabric-lined trenches quickly filled their space and developed many of the desirable characteristics of trees on dwarfing rootstocks. Although this method of controlling vegetative growth by restricting root growth appeared promising, the experiment was terminated after only four years, and the evaluation of this approach should be evaluated until the orchard is mature. B. Deficit Irrigation Researchers have been able to partially control assimilate partitioning with judicial irrigation. Chalmers et al. (1981) and Mitchell and Chalmers (1983) developed the concept of regulated deficit irrigation (RDI) for peaches and pears. By applying less water than the plant used at certain times of the season, plant water stress was temporarily induced, which suppressed vegetative growth without reducing fruit growth and yield. They identified an interaction between tree density and irrigation. Depending on the year, when trees were planted 2 × 1 m, partial irrigation during stage I suppressed trunk growth 11% to 18% and partial irrigation during stages I plus II suppressed trunk growth 1% to 11% without adversely affecting average fruit size or yield. When trees were spaced 4 × 1 m, trunk growth was reduced 8% to 30%, and yield was reduced by 6% one year and it was increased by 30% the other year. Proebsting et al. (1989) also found that the effect of restricted irrigated soil volume for apple was similar to that of deficit irrigation. When deficit irrigation was terminated, shoot growth resumed at rates above those of trees with non-deficit irrigation. Deficit irrigation probably has little potential in humid regions where soil moisture cannot be easily controlled. Deficit irrigation has not been widely adapted commercially because the results have usually been disappointing. C. Summer Pruning The world literature on summer pruning of apple and peach trees was summarized in a review by Marini and Barden (1987), so this discussion is a synopsis of how summer pruning affects peach tree growth and fruiting and how summer pruning might be used in intensive peach orchards. Summer pruning has traditionally been thought to induce fruiting, while dormant pruning induces vegetative growth (Saunders 1863; Tukey
92
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
1964), but there are few research data to support these beliefs. Unfortunately, many summer pruning experiments included a non-pruned control rather than a dormant-pruned control, so there are few direct comparisons of pruning trees in the same manner but at different times of the year. Summer pruning removes foliage during the summer, and theoretically reduces the amount of reserve carbohydrate available for earlyseason growth the following year. Although summer pruning reduced late-season root and trunk growth, and reduced the concentration of nonstructural carbohydrates in the bark, shoot extension the following season was as great or sometimes greater than when trees were dormant pruned (Marini and Barden 1987). Since shoot extension, and not trunk enlargement, causes tree crowding and shading in intensive plantings, summer pruning cannot be used to restrict shoot growth. Early-season summer pruning or shearing, before shoot extension ceased, temporarily improved light penetration into the tree canopy. Late-season summer pruning, after shoots had ceased growing, improved light penetration into the canopy for the remainder of the season (Kappel et al. 1983). Summer pruning peach trees during the final swell sometimes improved red color development, but also reduced fruit size and fruit soluble solids concentration. The influence of summer pruning or shearing on yield and fruit quality seems to vary with cultivar and time of treatment. Published data do not conclusively indicate that summer shearing is preferable to winter shearing in various orchard systems. Summer shearing was originally considered by some as a component of peach Hedgerow and meadow orchard systems management to eliminate vigorous, nonproductive, upright shoots and to allow adequate light penetration for the production of high-quality fruit (Chalmers et al. 1978; Young and Crocker 1982; Erez 1982; Hayden and Emerson 1979, 1988; Horton 1985). Some type of summer pruning is generally required for intensive peach orchards to avoid losing fruiting wood in the lower portions of the canopy. Walsh et al. (1989) suggested that shearing at the onset of pit hardening plus reduced irrigation following harvest might be used to suppress vegetative vigor of early-maturing cultivars. This strategy has merit because flower bud formation on peach shoots requires light from about 50 to 100 days after bloom (Marini and Sowers 1990) and this timing would coincide with a time of non-resource limited fruit growth (Grossman and DeJong 1995b). Summer pruning within 3 or 4 weeks before harvest sometimes improves fruit red color development (Marini 2002b). Therefore, summer pruning for color improvement would be too late to improve flower bud development, except for early-maturing cultivars. Summer removal of vigorous upright shoots that shade the tree center should be a standard practice for all vig-
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
93
orously growing peach trees, regardless of tree spacing, to maintain fruiting wood in the lower portion of the canopy (Marini 2002a). Summer pruning is widely used in intensive commercial orchards in Italy, particularly while training the trees, when trees are normally summer pruned more than once per year. Corelli-Grappadelli et al. (1986) reported times required for winter and summer pruning for five training systems at two tree densities. In all cases, summer pruning required more time (up to 5 times as much) than winter pruning in the second year, when most of the tree training was accomplished. Only from the third year, and not for all forms, did winter pruning take more time. For systems such as Fusetto and Delayed Vasette, summer pruning is a recommended practice. Summer pruning becomes increasingly important as the trees age, to avoid losing bearing wood in the lower parts of the tree. Normally pruning is performed after the cessation of shoot growth in late June. For reasons already mentioned, it may have controversial effects on tree performance. D. Plant Growth Regulators For several decades, pomologists have been searching for plant growth regulators to suppress shoot extension and increase cropping or fruit size. Paclobutrazol and flurprimidol are two gibberellin biosynthesis inhibitors that showed great promise for suppressing shoot extension and enhancing peach fruit size (Marini 1986, 1987), but the materials were not registered for edible crops in the United States. There are currently no plant growth retardants registered for commercial peach production in North America. E. Tree Growth Habit One of the challenges with developing new training systems for peach is that the same standard vigorous tree type on a vigorous rootstock must be adapted to all systems. In high-density systems, severe pruning is required to allow adequate light penetration throughout the canopy to maintain a relatively low fruiting zone. Severe pruning induces vigorous growth, and the resulting shade can adversely affect fruit quality and subsequent flower bud formation. Summer pruning can temporarily help alleviate the shade problem, but it does not suppress vegetative vigor and there may not be an economic benefit. Until dwarfing rootstocks or cultivars with different growth and fruiting characteristics are available, researchers and producers will continue to “fight” the natural growth habit of the tree while trying to make it fit a desirable system. There is a great diversity of growth habits within peach, and breeders
94
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
in the United States and Italy have been cooperating to develop new cultivars with a range of tree growth habits that may be suitable for different training systems. There are six distinct naturally occurring growth habits and these can be hybridized to develop intermediate types (Scorza 1984). Peach breeders are attempting to develop different tree forms that produce fruit with commercial quality. Before these different tree forms become commercially important, breeders will have to work with pomologists to develop appropriate training and pruning systems for each form. The six growth forms can be grouped into three horticultural classes (Bassi et al. 1994). The “standard” class consists of standard, dwarf, semidwarf, and spur-type, which are similar in shape with only small differences in height and overall architecture. The second class includes upright and columnar because both have upright canopies. The third class contains the weeping growth habit. A brief description of the tree forms follows. Standard—Commercial peach production relies solely on standard trees with 1-yr-old fruiting branches, moderately strong apical dominance, and vigorous acropetal growth. Dwarf—There are two types of dwarf trees, which usually are less than 2.5 m tall. The “brachytic” dwarf has very short internodes, long leaves, and a dense canopy. High fruit quality brachytic dwarf cultivars were released (Hansche 1989), but the dense canopy presents problems and may not be suitable for commercial production (DeJong and Doyle 1984). Another type of dwarf (A72) was reported by Monet and Salesses (1975) in France, but has received little attention. At this time the fruit quality is poor, but the canopies are more open than the brachytic dwarfs. Compact—Compact trees have relatively short internodes, wide branch angles, and more and longer laterals than standard trees. The trees are smaller than standard, but the canopy is dense. ‘Com-Pact Redhaven’ is an example of a compact cultivar. Spur-type—Peaches with spur-type growth habit have been imported into the U.S. and some are apparently peach-almond hybrids. These trees are not dwarf or compact and there are no commercial cultivars available. Weeping—Weeping peaches have been released as ornamentals. Two breeding programs in Europe are developing commercial fruit quality weeping peach cultivars and this growth habit may be suitable for new training systems. Columnar—The columnar or pillar peach was first developed in Japan as an ornamental. Non-pruned trees grow about 4.5 m tall and about 1.7 m in diameter. Trees have very narrow branch angles and breeders are rapidly improving the fruit quality. Spacing trees about 2 m in the row can rapidly form a tall narrow Hedgerow.
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
95
Mixed growth trees—Hybridizing the naturally occurring growth habits produces new tree types. The “upright” tree is a combination of the columnar and standard forms and is similar to the standard form, but branches tend to grow more upright; this form may have potential in high-density production systems.
VI. LIMITATIONS TO HIGH PEACH YIELDS Yields of mature peach orchards were generally lower than yields of mature apple orchards. Currently, the average yields in the U.S. are only 9 to 10 t/ha for freestone peach, whereas average yields for apple in the U.S. were 18 to 22 t/ha (Scorza et al. 1999). The 10-year average yield (1992–2002) in the more intensive southern European peach-producing countries, was 14 to 18 t/ha (FAOSTAT 2003). In high-density orchards, apple yields of 46 t/ha were not unusual, whereas peach yields rarely exceeded 33 t/ha with quality fruit. One reason for low peach yields in some regions is because yields are reduced by low temperature injury. Another reason for low freestone peach yields is the requirement for aggressive crop load management to obtain large fruit, but clingstone yields of 70 t/ha have been reported in California (DeJong et al. 1999). Yet another reason for low peach yields may be that peach trees partition a relatively low proportion of resources into fruit. Trunk crosssectional area (TCA) is related linearly to aboveground dry weight and fresh weight of apple trees regardless of rootstock (Barden and Marini 2001; Westwood and Roberts 1970). Pomologists use several indices to express carbon partitioning by trees. The most common index of partitioning is “yield efficiency” (YE) and is expressed as yield (kg/tree) per cm2 of TCA or cumulative YE (cumulative kg/cm2 TCA). YE is useful for comparing treatments within an experiment, but not for comparing trees of different ages or different orchards. When trees have filled their allotted space, annual pruning is used to limit canopy size, but trunks continue to enlarge. Values for YE decline each year in mature orchards because yield (the numerator) is fairly constant each year, whereas TCA (the denominator) increases each year. Most likely the reason that YE is so commonly reported is because it is easy to measure, but values for YE must be interpreted cautiously. The amount of fruit produced per land area covered by canopy or yield per unit of light intercepted may also be calculated. “Harvest Index” (HI) is the yield divided by the above- or above- plus below-ground portion of the tree (kg/kg) on a dry weight basis. Other times crop/scion ratio (C/S) is reported and it is calculated as the cumulative yield/tree divided by weight of the scion (kg/kg) on a
96
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
fresh weight basis (Barden pers. comm.). Unless the weights of wood removed by pruning are reported, HI and C/S ratio may have similar limitations as YE in mature orchards. A. Rootstocks Affect Partitioning Although YE is not ideal for comparing partitioning in different studies, YE is the only index of partitioning that is widely available in the literature. For mature freestone peach trees in the eastern U.S., YEs of 0.3 to 0.8 kg/cm2 are typical (Marini 1985b; Marini 2002b), whereas values of 0.4 to 1.4 are common for mature apple trees on vigorous rootstocks (Elfving and Schechter 1993; Marini et al. 1994; Forshey et al. 1983). In a multi-location rootstock trial, cumulative yield efficiencies ranged from 0.19 to 2.12 kg/cm2 for 7-yr-old own-rooted freestone peach trees (Perry et al. 2000). In that trial, Citation, GH 655-2, and Damas-1869 produced small trees and GF- 677 and Halford produced the largest trees. Average cumulative YEs for 7-yr-old trees were 0.88, 0.87, 1.01, 1.05, and 1.13 kg/cm2, respectively, for Citation, GH 655-2, Damas-1869, GF-677, and Halford. In a similar multi-location apple rootstock trial, average cumulative YEs for 10-year-old apple trees were 1.34, 2.73, and 3.34 for trees on seedling, the semi-dwarf M.26, and the dwarf B.9 rootstocks, respectively (NC-140, 1996). YE for 10-yr-old trees on seedling rootstock ranged from 0.49 to 2.55 kg/cm2 (NC-140, 1996). Although location greatly influenced YE, cumulative YEs for 10-yr-old ‘Gala’ apple trees, averaged over 6 locations, was 1.0 for the relatively nonproductive semi-dwarf P.1 and 3.3 for the very dwarfing M.27, respectively (Marini et al. 2001b). In summary, cumulative YEs for peach and apple on vigorous rootstocks seem similar. However, dwarfing rootstocks tend to partition resources into fruit rather than wood for apple, but not for the peach rootstocks that have been evaluated. For apple, cumulative YE tended to be negatively related to TCA, but for peach cumulative YE tended to be positively related to TCA. Reasons for this discrepancy are unknown, but this could be an important area for future research. Based on experiences with apples, many pomologists have assumed that dwarfing peach rootstocks would have higher YEs. Apparently, this assumption may not be valid. B. Scion Affects Partitioning A second factor that could affect partitioning is the scion cultivar. There are few published reports for peach where YE is reported for more than one cultivar in an experiment. Marini (1985b) reported YEs of 0.2, 0.4,
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
97
0.5, and 0.3 kg/cm2 for 5-yr-old ‘Redhaven’, 7-yr-old ‘Cresthaven’, 9-yrold ‘Loring’, and 15-yr-old ‘Sunqueen’ trees, respectively. Grossman and DeJong (1995c) reported the ratio of the dry weight of fruit per tree and the trunk radial increment for the season. Based on these data, the ratio of fruit dry weight (kg/tree) to mm of trunk growth was 0.43 and 2.76 for the early-maturing ‘Spring Lady’ and the late-maturing ‘Cal Red’, respectively. YEs of apple have drastically improved by growing spur-type strains on dwarfing rootstocks. The cumulative YEs for 18-yrold apple trees was influenced by both scion growth habit and rootstock (Barden and Marini 1999). Non-spur ‘Red Prince Delicious’ had YEs only 88% as high as the ‘Redchief’ spur-type strain; trees on the vigorous MM.111 rootstock had YEs 60% as high as trees on the dwarfing M.9. The cumulative YE for ‘Redchief’/M.9 was 6.4, whereas the cumulative YE for ‘Red Prince’/MM.111 was only 3.4. The data of Grossman and DeJong (1995c) indicate that a major reason for the relatively low YEs for peach may be the length of time from bloom to harvest. TCA is typically measured after leaf fall, and trunk growth rate increases after peach harvest, so peach might be expected to have low YEs. To obtain large fruit, early-season peaches must be thinned to low crop loads. However, compared to apple on dwarfing rootstocks, even the YEs reported for the late-season peach cultivars are relatively low. C. Tree Spacing Affects Partitioning Trees planted close together compete for water and nutrients and tended to have smaller trunks than trees in low-density plantings. The effect of tree density on YE was inconsistent. Cumulative YEs were 0.38 and 0.61 kg/cm2 for 9-yr-old ‘Norman’ trees planted at 370 and 740 trees/ha, respectively (Marini and Sowers 2000). Grossman and DeJong (1998) reported that YE (dry weight of fruit) for ‘Ross’ cling-stone peaches was not influenced by spacing V-shaped trees at 919 vs. 1196 trees/ha. The 30% difference in tree density may have been too small to influence YE. YE of 6-yr-old ‘Suncrest’ peach and ‘Redgold’ nectarine declined linearly as density of spindle trees increased from 1250 to 2000 trees/ha (Giulivo et al. 1984). However, Chalmers et al. (1981) reported that YE of 4-yr-old peach trees planted at 4166 trees/ha was 0.43 and YE of trees planted at 2500 trees/ha was 0.34. The effect of tree spacing on partitioning may be influenced by cultivar, climate, or tree age. YE in the experiment performed by Chalmers et al. (1981) showed an interaction between season, irrigation, and tree spacing. During the third year, YE was higher for highdensity trees when trees received deficit irrigation during Stage I or during Stages I & II. However, during the fourth year, YE was significantly
98
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
higher for high-density trees only when trees received deficit irrigation during Stages I & II of fruit growth. More data, from experiments designed to compare tree spacing without differences in tree training, are needed before we will understand how tree spacing influences partitioning. D. Training System Affects Partitioning Training system did not influence YE of peach (Grossman and DeJong 1998; Marini and Sowers 2000). Although tree density varied with system, apple YEs were 2.9 and 3.9, respectively, for 10-yr-old ‘Empire’/M.9 trees when trained to the Slender Spindle or Vertical Axe system, respectively (Marini et al. 2001a). Cumulative YEs for ‘Empire’/Mark were 3.42 (2460 trees/ha), 3.93 (1561 trees/ha), and 4.33 (1111 trees/ha) for Slender Spindle, Vertical Axe, and Central Leader trees, respectively. Robinson and Lakso (1991) and Robinson et al. (1991) compared YTrellis, Slender Spindle, and Central Leader systems for apple. They reported that cumulative yields were correlated to the amount of light intercepted (Y-Trellis > Slender Spindle > Central Leader). When light interception was used as a covariate, the ranking for yield was unchanged, but differences between systems were no longer significant at the 5% level. The Y-Trellis had the highest YE and was the best system for converting light energy into fruit. The differences in yield between orchard systems were largely the result of differences in light interception. Besides differences in light interception, apple orchard management systems could differ in the use of intercepted light energy. Further research is needed to determine if the same is true for peach and to elucidate the physiological bases for these differences. Another way to evaluate partitioning is by calculating the harvest index, which is the ratio of crop weight to tree weight, and is usually reported on a dry weight basis. Apple trees with a light (60% of the previous season’s crop) crop produced 0.22 kg of fruit per kg of wood on a dry weight basis (Forshey et al. 1983) and nonthinned apple trees produced 0.33 to 0.48 kg of fruit per kg of wood, depending on rootstock (Strong and Azarenko 2000). Values of 0.34 and 0.11 were reported for peach trees that were not thinned or thinned to a commercial crop, respectively (Miller and Walsh 1988). Barden and Marini (2001) reported that the cumulative crop-weight-to-final-scion-weight ratio (C/S) of 17yr-old apple trees varied widely with rootstock, but much less with cultivar and strain. Trees on the dwarfing M.9 rootstock had a C/S ratio of about 15, indicating that the average annual production of fruit for each of the 14 fruiting years was equal to the final scion weight. For the more vigorous M.7 and MM.111 rootstocks, the annual yields of fruit were equal to about 50% of the final scion weights. Based on these types of
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
99
data, the partitioning of nonthinned peach trees is similar to apple trees on relatively nonproductive rootstocks; but when trees are thinned to a commercial crop load, peach trees partition less resources into fruit than apple trees. Based on the data of Grossman and DeJong (1995a), where an early-season cultivar had less fruit/wood than the latematuring cultivar, it may be unrealistic to expect peach trees to have harvest indices similar to apple because peaches mature earlier than most apple cultivars. Following harvest, most peach cultivars have more time before leaf fall to produce wood than most apple cultivars. Resource partitioning is influenced by location, scion cultivar, rootstock, cultural practices, crop load, and training system. The most efficient cultural practices and training systems for peach at various locations have probably been identified, but partitioning efficiency for peach remains relatively low, compared to apple. Partitioning efficiency and yields per unit land area in peach seem to be limited by genetic factors. Dramatic increases in apple yields have resulted from growing efficient cultivars on efficient dwarfing rootstocks, and training systems have been developed to take advantage of these characteristics. Major improvements in peach yield will probably not occur until new genotypes for scions and rootstocks are developed that result in more efficient partitioning of resources into fruit. Scorza et al. (1986) compared the dry matter distribution in 3-yr-old limbs of peach trees with four growth habits. The percentages of dry weight partitioned into fruit were 56%, 53%, 38%, and 45%, respectively, for standard, semi-dwarf, compact, and dwarf trees. Although none of these tree types were more efficient than the standard, these data indicate that partitioning can be influenced by growth habit and peach breeders should continue to search for growth habits with efficient partitioning characteristics.
VII. FUTURE TRENDS AND DIRECTION Researchers and commercial producers have extensively evaluated peach orchard systems. Unless new cultivars, rootstocks, or plant growth regulators become available for controlling tree vegetative growth, future orchards will consist of low or moderate tree densities. The two most common tree training systems are the Open-Center in the western hemisphere and the Palmette in some European countries. These training systems will continue to dominate commercial orchards because alternative systems have not proven consistently more profitable. The choice of training system will be determined by factors such as the cost and availability of land and skilled labor, and ownership of previously purchased materials and equipment. In developing countries
100
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
and North America, where land is available and relatively inexpensive, simply planting more land can enhance farm income. In Europe, where new orchard land is largely unavailable, increasing the farm income requires increased returns per unit of land area or per unit of input. In the future, peach orchard systems will likely evolve differently in different parts of the world and economic pressures will drive technical solutions to production problems. Most developing countries with peach industries are located in the southern hemisphere and farmers obtain high wholesale prices for fresh fruit exported to developed countries during their off-season. Both land and labor are widely available and inexpensive, but labor is unskilled. Tree uniformity within an orchard will facilitate standardizing orchard operations performed by nonskilled labor. Orchard systems will evolve slowly unless economic conditions change. Peach trees are easily trained to the Open-Center system and this system will continue to predominate because there is little incentive to obtain high early yields or to make more efficient use of land or labor. More vigorous rootstocks, such as GF667, may become more common as old orchard sites are replanted. Small orchards dominate the peach industry in most of Europe and orchard owners do much of the routine work; in the larger operations, highly skilled resident immigrants and experienced migrant labor are increasingly employed. Farmers must perform most of the orchard operations because labor is very expensive. Land and labor are already being used efficiently, but there will be increasing economic pressure to further improve efficiencies. Intensive orchard practices, performed by highly skilled labor, will be required to improve early bearing and yields per unit of land area. Minimally pruning young trees is but one example of the modern techniques employed to obtain early production. Summer pruning will be used to obtain high-quality fruit and maintain fruiting wood in the lower canopy, as well as to spread out the pruning labor by performing some of the pruning during the growing season. In France, this quest for efficiency can be represented by the concept of “supervised productivism” (productivisme raisonné, Giauque, 2001): devising a system of evaluation of the performance of an individual orchard (in terms of labor used per unit of sellable product) against the best orchard’s and the average values for a given production district. Interestingly, these studies reveal that high yields and high quality can coexist and are not antithetic. Early bearing, high yields over the life of the orchard, and frequent orchard renovation to take advantage of new high-quality cultivars will be necessary, in an economic scenario that is already characterized by high costs and diminishing returns. One of the consequences is that, in many cases, to a large extent the choice of a training system can be
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
101
influenced by the equipment that is on the farm. In the main peach district of Italy, the Romagna region, many farmers have purchased expensive platforms to reduce the cost of orchard operations, such as pruning, fruit thinning, and harvest. Very often these farmers maintain their orchards as Palmettes, to extend the returns on the investment in the platform (these will easily exceed 25 years of operation with normal maintenance). Trees in Palmette systems are typically supported with three or four wires attached to concrete posts, and these posts can be reused as orchards are renovated. Therefore, in Europe, barring new breakthroughs in habitus, pruning, or training techniques, the future trend appears more likely to be one of improving efficiency of existing orchard systems by tweaking the management practices, more than adopting radically different orchard designs (unlikely from current developments in other crops, such as apple). Peach growers in western North America grow mostly fairly upright trees that are 4.0 to 5.0 m tall, and planted at about 300 trees per ha. North American orchards are relatively large and workers are unskilled. Therefore, trees within an orchard will have to be uniform to facilitate orchard worker training. The cost of labor is increasing rapidly and California growers are starting to lower their trees. As land and labor become increasingly scarce and expensive, peach orchard systems likely will evolve towards those found in Europe. Some type of Hedgerow system that allows use of platforms may dominate the peach industry, and where platforms are not used, tree height will be limited to less than 3.0 m. At higher latitudes, where trees grow slowly and winter injury results in early tree mortality, tree densities will increase to allow rapid filling of orchard space. Clingstone orchards have low profit margins because the prices received for raw product and finished goods have not kept pace with inflation. Although yields for processing fruit are high, because large fruit size is not required, processing orchards may become nonprofitable in developed countries. Since the mid 1980s, when subsidization started, Greece has exported increasing amounts of clingstone peaches to European countries and to the United States. The United States is now a net importer of canned peaches. The high cost of production, unfavorable exchange rates, subsidized Greek over-production and low cost Chinese production is a challenge for U.S. exporters of canned fruit (Anonymous 2001). Interest in mechanization will increase in North America as labor costs continue to increase. Many European orchards are too small to justify the cost of expensive equipment and they will rely on skilled labor. It is difficult for researchers to have much impact on commercial growers because growers are locked into systems similar to those currently being used. Large growers in North America and in developing countries
102
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
are reluctant to purchase the smaller orchard equipment required for more intensive orchards. European growers who already own platforms used for several orchard operations and reusable cement posts will likely stick with the trellised Palmettes: after making these investments it would be difficult to change to an entirely new system. Orchard systems being used will certainly continue to be modified to local conditions and to the equipment and labor situations for each orchard. Modifications of existing orchard systems and development of new systems will require research breakthroughs. Rootstocks that provide a range of tree vigor and enhance carbon partitioning, such as those available for apple, may allow development of novel orchard systems. Plant growth regulators to control flowering and vegetative growth, crop load, or fruit ripening could be utilized in new orchard systems. Growers need trees that produce high yields of uniformly high-quality fruit that can be harvested tree ripe. Improvements in other aspects of fruit quality such as fruit size, color, soluble solids concentration, flesh firmness, and high concentrations of health-promoting compounds may improve peach consumption and lead to increased prices. There is a need for long-term studies to determine profitability of various orchard practices and orchard systems. More information on fundamental relationships in peach tree physiology is needed to develop new systems or to modify existing systems. The relationship between light interception and yield per unit land area has yet to be described. Currently peach growers do not have fruit thinning strategies based on sound scientific data, nor practical methods for assessing in real time the progress of the crop and the performance of the orchard. A better understanding of partitioning is needed to develop better strategies for hand-thinning and pruning that may alter carbon partitioning. LITERATURE CITED Allison, M. L., and J. P. Overcash. 1987. Factors affecting hedgerow peach orchard establishment. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 112:62–66. Anonymous. 2001. Canned peach industry situation: A history of EU subsidies and their effect on production and trade. www.fas.usda.gov/htp/highlights/2001/IATR/canftr.pdf. Baldassari, T. 1950. La potatura dei fruttiferi. Proc. II Convegno Provinciale Frutticolo, Ferrara, 16 January 1950:71–76. Baldassari, T. 1967. Frutticoltura industriale con la nuova palmetta. Edizioni Agricole, Bologna. pp. 119. Baldini, E. 2001. Agrumi, frutti e uve alla corte dei Granduchi di Toscana. p. 20–32. In: D. Savoia and M. L. Strocchi (eds.), Le belle forme della natura: la pittura di Bartolomeo Bimbi (1648–1730) tra scienzae “maraviglia”. Bologna, Abacus.
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
103
Barden, J. A., and R. P. Marini. 1999. Rootstock effects on growth and fruiting of a spurtype and a standard strain of ‘Delicious’ over eighteen years. Fruit Var. J. 53:115–125. Barden, J. A., and R. P. Marini. 2001. Comparison of methods to express growth, size, and productivity of apple trees. J. Amer. Pomol. Soc. 55:251–256. Bargioni, G., F. Loreti, and P. L. Pisani. 1983. Performance of peach and nectarine in a high density system in Italy. HortScience 18:143–146. Bargioni, G., P. L. Pisani, and F. Loreti. 1985. Ten years of research on peach and nectarine in a high density system in the Verona area. Acta Hort. 173:299–310. Bassi, D., G. Brighenti, and V. Nardi. 1985. Training systems of Klamt cling peach: performance after 8 years—IV Contribution. Acta Hort. 173:339–348. Bassi, D., A. Dina, and R. Scorza. 1994. Tree structure and pruning response of six peach growth forms. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 119:378–382. Bellini, E., D. Falqui, and O. Musso. 1997. La coltura protetta del pesco. Inf. Agrario (31): 41–50. Bellini, E., D. Falqui, and O. Musso. 2000. Comparison between two training systems in peach protected culture in Sicily. Acta Hort. 513:427–433. Belluau, E., and A. Lemaire. 1986. Bilan de neuf annees d’experimentation sur la conduite du pecher en axe a haute densite dans le sud est de la France. Acta Hort. 160:327–340. Blay Coll, J. 1988. Formación del melocotonero en un solo eje principal (fuseto). Fruticultura Profesional, 15—Mayo/Junio:3–17. Borras Escriba, F. 2001. La peschicoltura spagnola nel mercato globale. Proc. Xxiv Convegno Peschicolo, Cesena, 24–25 February 2000:31–34. Brace, J. 1904. The culture of fruit trees in pots. William Clowes and Son, London and Beccles. 109 pp. Byers, R. E., D. H. Carbaugh, and C. N. Presley. 1990. The influence of bloom thinning and GA3 sprays on flower bud numbers and distribution in peach trees. J. Hort. Sci. 65: 143–150. Byers, R. E., and R. P. Marini. 1994. Influence of blossom and fruit thinning on peach flower bud tolerance to an early spring freeze. HortScience 29:146–148. Caruso, T., D. Giovannini, F. P. Marra, and F. Sottile. 1997. Two new planting systems for early ripening peaches (Prunus persica L. Batsch): yield and fruit quality in four lowchill cultivars. J. Hort. Sci. 72:873–883. Caruso, T., C. Di Vaio, F. Guarino, A. Motisi, and V. Nuzzo. 2003. Le tipologie d’impianto per la peschicoltura intensiva nell’Italia meridionale. Proc. IV Convegno Nazionale sulla Peschicoltura Meridionale, Agrigento, 11–12 September 2003:44–51. Chalmers, D. J., G. Burge, P. H. Jerie, and P. D. Mitchell. 1986. The mechanism of regulation of ‘Bartlett’ pear fruit and vegetative growth by irrigation withholding and regulated deficit irrigation. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 111:904–907. Chalmers, D. J., P. D. Mitchell, and L. van Heek. 1981. Control of peach tree growth and productivity by regulated water supply, tree density, and summer pruning. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 106:307–312. Chalmers, D. J., and B. van den Ende. 1975. A reappraisal of the growth and development of peach fruit. Austral. J. Plant Physiol. 2:623–634. Chalmers, D. J., B. van den Ende, and L. van Heek. 1978. Productivity and mechanization of the Tatura trellis orchard. HortScience 13:517–521. Cole, S. W. 1849. The American fruit book. John P. Jewett, New York, NY. 288 pp. Corelli-Grappadelli, L., G. Brighenti, U. Palara, F. Ravaioli, and S. Sansavini. 1986. Esperienze su forme di allevamento del pesco per medie ed alte densità di impianto. Frutticoltura 12:55–60.
104
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
Corelli-Grappadelli, L., G. Ravaglia, and A. Asirelli. 1996. Shoot type and light exposure influence carbon partitioning in peach (Prunus persica L. (Batsch)) cv ‘Elegant Lady’. J. Hort. Sci. 71:533–543. Costa, G., S. Musacchi, F. Succi, and S. Martelli. 1989. Forme di allevamento del pesco per impianti ad elevata densità di piantagione. Riv. Frutticoltura (1):111–119. Couvillon, G. A., and A. Erez. 1980. Rooting, survival, and development of several peach cultivars propagated from semi hardwood cuttings. HortScience 15:41–43. Couvillon, G. A., and A. Erez. 1982. Production potential and tree regeneration in a peach meadow orchard in southeastern United States. Compact Fruit Tree 15:166–169. Crocker, T. E., W. B. Sherman, M. J. Young, and L. G. McDermont. 1988. An experimental high-density system for low-chill peaches and nectarines. p. 432–434. In: Childers and Sherman (eds.), The peach. Horticultural Publ., Gainesville, FL. Crowe, A. D., D. R. Henniger, W. E. Craig, and R. T. O’Regan. 1987. Containerized peach orchards are profitable and avoid winter injury. Compact Fruit Tree 20:90–94. DeJong, T. M. 1998. Using organ growth potentials to identify physiological and horticultural limitations to yield. Acta Hort. 465:293–302. DeJong, T. M., K. R. Day, and J. F. Doyle. 1992. Evaluation of training/pruning systems for peach, plum and nectarine trees in California. Acta Hort. 322:99–105. DeJong, T. M., K. R. Day, J. F. Doyle, and R. S. Johnson. 1994. The Kearney Agricultural Center perpendicular “V” (KAC-V) orchard system for peaches and nectarines. HortTechnology 4:362–367. DeJong, T. M., and J. F. Doyle. 1984. Cropping efficiency, dry matter and nitrogen distribution in mature genetic dwarf and standard peach trees. Acta Hort. 146:89– 95. DeJong, T. M., and J. F. Doyle. 1985. Seasonal relationships between leaf nitrogen content (photosynthetic capacity) and leaf canopy light exposure in peach (Prunus persica). Plant, Cell and Environment 8:701–706. DeJong, T. M., W. Tsuji, J. F. Doyle, and Y. L. Grossman. 1999. Comparative economic efficiency of four peach production systems in California. HortScience 34:73–78. Dorsey, M. J. 1935. Nodal development of the peach shoot as related to fruit bud formation. Proc. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 33:245–257. Elfving, D. C., and I. Schecter. 1993. Fruit count, fruit weight, and yield relationships in ‘Delicious’ apple trees on nine rootstocks. HortScience 28:793–795. Erez, A. 1976. Meadow orchard for the peach. Scientia Hort. 5:43–48. Erez, A. 1978. Adaptation of the peach to the meadow orchard system. Acta Hort. 65:245–250. Erez, A. 1982. Peach meadow orchard: two feasible systems. HortScience 17:138–142. Erez, A. 1988. Peach meadow orchard: two feasible systems. p. 424–431. In: Childers and Sherman (eds.), The peach. Horticultural Publ., Gainesville, FL. Erez, A., Z. Yablowitz, and G. Nir. 1989. Container-grown peach orchard. Compact Fruit Tree 22:96–98. Erez, A., Z. Yablowitz, and P. Korcinski. 1998. Greenhouse peach growing. Acta Hort. 465:593–600. Evert, D. R. 1988. A modified meadow system. p. 434. In: Childers and Sherman (eds.), The peach. Horticultural Publ., Gainesville, FL. FAOSTAT, data. 2003. http://apps.fao.org/faostat/form?collection=Production.Crops .Primary&Domain =Production&servlet=1&hasbulk=0&version=ext&language=EN Fideghelli, C. 1969. Confronto tra i sistemi di allevamento a vaso ed a palmetta del pesco. Proc. Symposium “Giornate di studio sulla potatura degli alberi da frutto. Florence, 24–27 February 1969:133–147.
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
105
Fideghelli, C. 1990. La potatura e le forme di allevamento del pesco e delle nettarine. Proc. Symposium “La potatura degli alberi da frutto negli anni 90”. Verona, 27 April 1990: 167–194. Fideghelli, C., F. Monastra, and R. F. De Salvador. 1988. Evoluzione delle forme d’allevamento e delle densità d’impianto in peschicoltura. Proc. XVIII Convegno Peschicolo, Cesena, 3 May 1986:63–81. Fideghelli, C., G. Della Strada, F. Grassi, and G. Monica. 1998. The peach industry in the world; present situation and trends. Acta Hort. 465:29–40. Fitz, J. 1872. The southern apple and peach culturist. J. W. Randolf and English, Richmond, VA. 336 pp. Flore, J. A., and C. Kesner. 1982. Orchard design for stone fruit based on light interception. Compact Fruit Tree 5:159–165. Forshey, C. G., R. W. Weires, B. H. Stanley, and R. C. Sem. 1983. Dry weight portioning of ‘MacIntosh’ apple trees. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 108:149–154. Génard, M., and Frédéric Baret. 1994. Spatial and temporal variation of light inside peach trees. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 119:669–677. Giauque, P. 2001. L’ère du productivisme raisonné. Infos-Ctifl/septembre 2001:37–40. Giuliani, R., E. Magnanini, and L. Corelli-Grappadelli. 1998. Whole canopy gas exchange and light interception of three peach training systems. Acta Hort. 465:309–317. Giulivo, C., A. Ramina, and G. Costa. 1984. Effects of planting density on peach and nectarine productivity. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 109:287–290. Goedegebure, J. 1989. Economic aspects of HDP-developments in The Netherlands. Acta Hort. 243:389–397. Grossman, Y. L., and T. M. DeJong. 1995a. Maximum fruit growth potential and seasonal patterns of resource dynamics during peach growth. Annals Bot. 75:553–560. Grossman, Y. L., and T. M. DeJong. 1995b. Maximum fruit growth potential following resource limitation during peach growth. Annals Bot. 75:561–567. Grossman, Y. L., and T. M. DeJong. 1995c. Maximum vegetative growth potential and seasonal patterns of resource dynamics during peach growth. Annals Bot. 76:473–482. Grossman, Y. L., and T. M. DeJong. 1998. Training and pruning system effects on vegetative growth potential, light interception, and cropping efficiency in peach trees. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 123:1058–1064. Hansche, P. E. 1989. Three brachytic dwarf peach cultivars: Valley Gem, Valley Red, and Valley Sun. HortScience 24:707–709. Hayden, R. A., and F. H. Emerson. 1979. Pruning high density peach hedge plantings. Compact Fruit Tree 12:76–78. Hayden, R. A., and F. H. Emerson. 1988. High density plantings for peaches. p. 404–411. In: Childers and Sherman (eds.), The peach. Horticultural Publ., Gainesville, FL. Hedrick, U. P. 1917. The peaches of New York. Rept. New York Agric. Expt. Stat. J.B. Company, Albany, NY. 541 pp. Horton, B. D. 1985. Effects of tree density on mortality of peaches on a short life site. HortScience 20:950–951. Hudson, J. P. 1971. Meadow orchards. Agriculture 78:157–160. Hugard, J. 1980. High density plantings in French orchards: development and current achievements. Acta Hort. 114:300–308. Hugard, J. 1981. Caracteristiques principales des productions fruitieres de la zone Mediterraneenne Francaise. Acta Hort. 160:15–22. Hutton, R. J., L. M. McFadyen, and J. L. Warwick. 1987. Relative productivity and yield efficiency of canning peach trees in three intensive growing systems. HortScience 22:552–560.
106
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
Jackson, J. E. 1980. Light interception and utilization by orchards. Hort. Rev. 2:208–267. Jackson, J. E. 1989. World-wide development of high density planting in research and practice. Acta Hort. 243:17–27. Johnson, R. S., and A. N. Lakso. 1986. Carbon model of a growing apple shoot: I. Development of the model. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 111:160–164. Kappel, F., J. A. Flore, and R. E. C. Layne. 1983. Characterization of the light microclimate in four peach hedgerow canopies. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 108:102–105. Lakso, A. N. 1994. Apple. p. 3–42. In: Schaffer and Anderson (eds.), Handbook of environmental physiology of fruit crops—Vol. I Temperate crops. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL. Layne, R. E. C., C. S. Tan, and J. M. Fulton. 1981. Effect of irrigation and tree density on peach production. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 106:151–156. Lespinasse, J. M. 1980. La conduite du pommier. Liaxe vertical la renovation des vergers (2e partie). Center Technique interprofessionel des Fruits et Legumes, Paris. Leuty, S. J., and D. J. Pree. 1980. The influence of tree population and summer pruning on productivity, growth, and quality of peaches. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 105:702–705. Lewallen, K. 2000. Effects of light availability and canopy position on peach fruit quality. M.S. Thesis, Dept. of Horticulture, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg. (http://scholar.lib.vt.edu/thesis/available/etd-04262000-13090002/) Loreti, F., R. Massai, and S. Morini. 1989. Further observations on high-density nectarine plantings. Acta Hort. 243:353–360. Manaresi, A., and A. Draghetti. 1915. Influenza del germoglio ascellare sullo sviluppo e sulla composizione del frutto del pesco. Boll. Ass. Orticola Professionale Italiana (1):1–4. Marini, R. P. 1985a. Vegetative growth, yield, and fruit quality of peach as influenced by dormant pruning, summer pruning, and summer topping. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 110:133–139. Marini, R. P. 1985b. Sample size estimates for peach tree growth and yield experiments. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 110:604–608. Marini, R. P. 1986. Growth and cropping of ‘Redhaven’ peach trees following foliar applications of flurprimidol and paclobutrazol. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 111:849–853. Marini, R. P. 1987. Growth and cropping of ‘Redhaven’ peach trees following soil application of paclobutrazol. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 112:18–21. Marini, R. P. 2002a. Pruning peach trees. VA Coop. Ext. Pub. 422-020. Marini, R. P. 2002b. Heading fruiting shoots before bloom is equally effective as blossom removal in peach crop load management. HortScience 37:642–646. Marini, R. P., J. L. Anderson, W. R. Autio, B. H. Barritt, J. A. Cline, W. P. Cowgill, Jr., R. M. Crassweller, P. A. Domoto, D. C. Ferree, J. Garner, A. Gaus, G. M. Greene, C. Hampson, P. Hirst, M. M. Kushad, E. Mielke, C. A. Mullins, M. Parker, R. L. Perry, J. P. Privé, G. L. Reighard, T. Robinson, C. R. Rom, T. R. Roper, J. R. Schupp, E. Stover, and R. Unrath. 2000. Performance of ‘Gala’ apple on 18 dwarf rootstocks: Five-year Summary of the 1994 NC-140 Dwarf Rootstock Trial. J. Amer. Pomol. Soc. 54:92–107. Marini, R. P., and J. A. Barden. 1981. Seasonal correlations of specific leaf weight to net photosynthesis and dark respiration of apple leaves. Photosynthetic Res. 2:251–258. Marini, R. P., and J. A. Barden. 1982. Light penetration on overcast and clear days, and specific leaf weight in apple trees as affected by summer or dormant pruning. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 107:39–43. Marini, R. P., and J. A. Barden. 1987. Summer pruning of apple and peach trees. Hort. Rev. 9:351–375. Marini, R. P., B. H. Barritt, J. A. Barden, J. Cline, E. E. Hoover, R. L. Granger, M. M. Kushad, M. Parker, R. L. Perry, T. Robinson, S. Khanizaheh, and C. R. Unrath. 2001a. Performance of ten apple orchard systems: ten-year summary of the 1990 NC-140 systems trial. J. Amer. Pomol. Soc. 55:222–238.
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
107
Marini, R. P., B. H. Barritt, J. A. Barden, J. Cline, R. L. Granger, M. M. Kushad, M. Parker, R. L. Perry, T. Robinson, S. Khanizaheh, and C. R. Unrath. 2001b. Performance of ‘Gala’ apple on eight dwarf rootstocks: ten-year summary of the 1990 NC-140 rootstock trial. J. Amer. Pomol. Soc. 55:197–204. Marini, R. P., and M. C. Marini. 1983. Seasonal changes in specific leaf weight, net photosynthesis, and chlorophyll content of peach leaves as affected by light penetration and canopy position. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 108:600–605. Marini, R. P., D. G. Pfeiffer, and D. S. Sowers. 1994. Influence of European red mite (Acri:Tetranychidae) and crop density on fruit size and quality and on crop value of ‘Delicious’ apples. J. Econ. Entomology 87:1302–1311. Marini, R. P., and D. L. Sowers. 1990. Net photosynthesis, specific leaf weight, and flowering of peach as influenced by shade. HortScience 25:331–334. Marini, R. P., and D. L. Sowers. 1994. Peach fruit weight is influenced by crop density and fruiting shoot length but not position on the shoot. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 119: 180–184. Marini, R. P., and D. S. Sowers. 2000. Peach tree growth, yield, and profitability as influenced by tree form and tree density. HortScience 35:837–842. Marini, R. P., D. Sowers, and M. C. Marini. 1991. Peach fruit quality is affected by shade during final swell of fruit growth. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 116:383–389. Marini, R. P., D. S. Sowers, and M. C. Marini. 1995. Tree form and heading height at planting affect peach tree yield and crop value. HortScience 30:1196–1201. Masia, A., A. Zanchin, N. Rascio, and A. Ramina. 1992. Some biochemical and ultrastructural aspects of peach fruit development. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 117:808–815. Menzies, A. R. 1988. Evolution of peach tree forms in New South Wales, Australia. p. 446–465. In: Childers and Sherman (eds.), The peach. Horticultural Publ., Gainesville, FL. Miles, N. W., R. Guarnaccia, and K. Slingerland. 1999. High density peach production in Ontario. New York Fruit Quarterly 7(4):1–5. Miles, N. W., and S. J. Leuty. 1988. Protected peach culture. p. 380–386. In: Childers and Sherman (eds.), The peach. Horticultural Publ., Gainesville, FL. Miller, A. N., and C. S. Walsh. 1988. Growth and seasonal partitioning of dry matter in eight-year-old ‘Loring’ peach trees. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 113:309–314. Mitchell, P. D., and D. J. Chalmers. 1983. A comparison of microjet and point emitter (trickle) irrigation in the establishment of a high density peach orchard. HortScience 18:472–474. Monet, R., and G. Salesses. 1975. Un nouveau de nanisme chez le pecher. Ann. Amelior Plantes 25:353–359. NC-140. 1996. Performance of the NC-140 cooperative apple rootstock planting II: a 10year summary of TCA, yield and yield efficiency at 31 sites. Fruit Var. J. 50:11–18. Nuzzo, V., B. Dichio, A. M. Palese, and C. Xiloyannis. 2000. Sviluppo della chioma ed intercettazione radiativa in piante di pesco allevate ad Y trasversale ed a vaso ritardato nei primi tre anni dall’impianto. Proc. V giornate Scientifiche S.O.I. Sirmione, 28–30 March 2000: 319–320. Palmer, J. W., G. Bünemann, S. Sansavini, P. S. Wagenmakers, and F. Winter. 1989. The international planting systems trial. Acta Hort. 243:231–241. Perry, R., G. Reighard, D. Ferree, J. Barden, T. Bechman, G. Brown, J. Cummins, E. Durner, G. Greene, S. Johnson, R. Layne, F. Morrison, S. Myers, W. R. Okie, C. Rom, R. Rom, B. Taylor, D. Wolker, M. Warmund, and K. Yu. 2000. Performance of the 1984 NC-140 cooperative peach rootstock planting. J. Amer. Pomol. Soc. 54:6–10. Phillips, J. H. H., and G. M. Weaver. 1975. A high-density peach orchard. HortScience 10:580–582.
108
R. MARINI AND L. CORELLI-GRAPPADELLI
Porpiglia, P. J., and J. A. Barden. 1980. Seasonal trends in net photosynthetic potential, dark respiration, and specific leaf weight of apple leaves as affected by canopy position. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 105:920–923. Proebsting, E. L., P. H. Jerie, and J. Irvine. 1989. Water deficits and rooting volume modify peach tree growth and water relations. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 114:368–372. Reeder, B. D., H. H. Bowen, and W. H. Aldred. 1980. Peach tree training and spacing. HortScience 15:580–581. Richards, D. 1977. Root-shoot interactions: a functional equilibrium for water uptake in peach Prunus persica (L.) Batsch. Annal. Bot. 41:279–281. Richards, D. 1986. Tree growth and productivity—the role of roots. Acta Hort. 175:27–36. Richards, D., and R. N. Rowe. 1977. Root-shoot interactions in peach: the function of the root. Annal. Bot. 41:1211–1216. Rizzi, A. D. 1975. Training and modifying peach trees in California for mechanical handling. p. 214–225. In: Childers and Sherman (eds.), The peach. Horticultural Publ., Gainesville, FL. Robinson, T. L. 1997. Interaction of tree form and rootstock on light interception, yield and efficiency of ‘Empire’, ‘Delicious’ and ‘Jonagold’ apple trees trained to different systems. Acta Hort. 451:427–436. Robinson, T. L., and A. N. Lakso. 1991. Bases of yield and production efficiency in apple orchard systems. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 116:188–194. Robinson, T. L., A. N. Lakso, and S. G. Carpenter. 1991. Canopy development, yield, and fruit quality of ‘Empire’ and ‘Delicious’ apple trees grown in four orchard production systems for ten years. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 116:179–187. Royo Díaz, J. B., and T. Martínez Lopez. 1992. Sistemas de formación en melocotonero. Fruticultura Profesional, 46—Especial Melocotonero:22–31. Sansavini, S. 1974. Indirizzi tecnico-agronomici della peschicoltura romagnola. Proc. XII Convegno Peschicolo Romagnolo, Cesena. L’Italia Agricola, 1-2:1–47. Sansavini, S. 1980. Impianti e allevamento del pesco: analisi e prospettive delle tendenze in atto. Proc. XV° Convegno Peschicolo, Ravenna, 30 August 1980:63–116. Sansavini, S., and L. Corelli-Grappadelli. 1997. Yield and light efficiency for high quality fruit in apple and peach high density plantings. Acta Hort. 451:559–568. Sansavini, S., D. Bassi, and L. Giunchi. 1980. Prove comparative di allevamento del pesco da industria. Proc. XV° Convegno Peschicolo, Ravenna, 30 August 1980:267–278. Sansavini, S., L. Corelli-Grappadelli, and L. Giunchi. 1985. Peach yield efficiency as related to tree shape. Acta Hort. 173:139–158. Sansavini, S., L. Corelli-Grappadelli, G. Costa, S. Lugli, B. P. Marangoni, M. Tagliavini, M. Ventura, D. Abeti, S. Feralli, G. Marani, G. Mascanzoni, P. Molducci, R. Proni, A. Sama, G. Spada, S. Vitali, P. Turroni, A. Minguzzi, and M. Randi. 2000. Ricostituzione degli impianti e nuovi indirizzi produttivi della peschicoltura romagnola. Proc. XXIII Convegno Peschicolo, Ravenna, 12–13 September 1997:62–74. Saunders, W. 1863. “Report of the Commissioner of Agriculture for the Year 1863,” p. 552. USGPO, Washington, DC. Scorza, R. 1984. Characterization of four distinct peach tree growth types. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 109:455–457. Scorza, R., D. Bassi, H. Bima, and M. Rizzo. 1999. Developing new peach tree growth habits for higher density plantings. Compact Fruit Tree 33:18–20. Scorza, R., L. Zailong, G. W. Lightner, and L. E. Gilreath. 1986. Dry matter distribution and responses to pruning within a population of standard, semidwarf, compact, and dwarf peach seedlings. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 111:541–545.
2. PEACH ORCHARD SYSTEMS
109
Stembridge, G. E. 1977. Our experience with high density peach plantings. Compact Fruit Tree 10:48–52. Strong, D., and A. N. Azarenko. 2000. Relationship between trunk cross-sectional area, harvest index, total tree dry weight and yield components of ‘Starkspur Supreme delicious’ apple trees. J. Amer. Pom. Soc. 54:22–27. Tan, C. S., and B. R. Buttery. 1986. Photosynthesis, stomatal conductance, and leaf water potential in response to temperature and light in peach. HortScience 21:1180–1182. Taylor, B. H. 1988. Promising high density peach systems in Illinois. p. 491–498. In: Childers and Sherman (eds.), The peach. Horticultural Publ., Gainesville, FL. Toribio Mancebo, F. 1993. Juntos, pero bien formados. Albear (1):20–27. Tsipouridis, C. 2003. The peach industry in Greece: state of art, research and development. p. 44–48. In: F. P. Marra and F. Sottile (eds.), Proceedings of the first Mediterranean peach symposium. Agrigento, Italy. Tukey, H. B. 1933. Growth of peach embryo in relation to growth of fruit and season of ripening. Proc. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 30:209–218. Tukey, H. B. 1964. Dwarfed fruit trees. Macmillan, New York. Tustin, S., D. Ferree, L. Corelli-Grappadelli, A. Lakso, T. Robinson, J. Flore, R. Perry, S. Breitkreutz, B. Barritt, B. Konishi, C. Rom, I. Taylor, A. Webster, C. Atkinson, J. Palmer, and W. Cashmore. 1997. The International Apple Growth Study. Acta Hort. 451:693–699. Walsh, C., A. Miller, M. Bohning, and D. Chalmers. 1989. Maintaining peach production and quality in the absence of size-controlling rootstocks. Compact Fruit Tree. 22:85–86. Westward, M. N., and A. N. Roberts. 1970. The relationsPhip between trunk cross-sectional area and weight of apple trees. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 95:28–30. Williamson, J. G., and D. C. Coston. 1989. The relationship among root growth, shoot growth, and fruit growth of peach. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 114:180–183. Williamson, J. G., D. C. Coston, and J. A. Cornell. 1992. Root restriction affects shoot development of peach in a high-density orchard. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 117:362–367. Young, M. J., and T. E. Crocker. 1982. Severe postharvest topping of high-density peach and nectarines. HortScience 19:220–222.
3 Irrigation Scheduling and Evaluation of Tree Water Status in Deciduous Orchards Amos Naor Golan Research Institute University of Haifa P.O. Box 97 Kazrin 12900 Israel
I. INTRODUCTION II. THE MODERN IRRIGATION SCHEDULING CONCEPT III. DEFICIT IRRIGATION A. Reproductive Cell Division Stage B. Pit Hardening Stage (Stone Fruits) C. Final Fruit Growth Stage (Stone Fruits) D. Preharvest Deficit Irrigation in Almonds E. Post Reproductive Cell Division Stage (Pip Fruits) F. Flower Bud Differentiation and Development Stage G. Deficit Irrigation and Fruit Quality in Deciduous Fruit Trees H. Partial Root Drying 1. Physiological Basis 2. Field Examination IV. WATER STRESS ASSESSMENT AND TIMING OF IRRIGATION A. Factors Affecting Transpiration and Irrigation Level 1. Intercepted Radiation and Canopy Size 2. Crop Yield 3. Potential Fruit Size 4. Application Efficiency B. The Grower’s Dilemma C. The Use of Water Stress Indicators 1. General Requirements for a Water Stress Indicator
Horticultural Reviews, Volume 32, Edited by Jules Janick ISBN 0-471-73216-8 © 2006 John Wiley & Sons 111
112
A. NAOR
2. Types of Water Stress Indicators Available for Commercial Use 3. The Relevance of Plant Water Stress Indicators D. Response to Moisture and Irrigation Regimes E. Sensitivity of Water Stress Indicators F. Early Detection of Water Stress G. Representing Water Status on an Orchard Basis 1. Within Tree and Root Zone Variability 2. Spatial Variability H. Considerations in Setting Thresholds 1. Minimum Stress Conditions 2. Setting Thresholds for Daily Trunk Shrinkage 3. Setting Thresholds Under Deficit Irrigation Conditions I. Conditions of Limited Response to Irrigation 1. Soil-root Zone Limitations 2. Fruit Pedicle Limitations V. CONCLUDING REMARKS LITERATURE CITED
I. INTRODUCTION Irrigation is a major horticultural activity and is the most intensively practiced operation throughout the season. Its importance depends on the climate, and increases with progress from temperate to drier and to arid zones. Dryland orchards can survive and be productive in temperate zones without irrigation, whereas the survival of deciduous orchards in semi-arid zones depends on the availability of water for irrigation throughout most of the growing season. The performance of deciduous trees, i.e., crop yield, fruit size, fruit quality, storability, and long-term productivity are highly dependent on irrigation, and different species respond differently to irrigation. Worldwide, the amount of fresh water available for agricultural use is decreasing and, since shortages of fresh water are to be expected, there is a need to increase water use efficiency, either by improving genetic performance and horticultural practices, or by improving irrigation scheduling. The level of irrigation of deciduous orchards depends on environmental factors that drive evaporative demand and transpiration, salinity, and electrolyte composition in the soil solution, the resistance of the soil to root penetration and moisture transport, soil aeration, tree hydraulic architecture, and crop load. Irrigation interacts indirectly with the susceptibility of deciduous orchards to diseases and pests, and through the effects of soil moisture on pests. The above-mentioned interactions are beyond the scope of the present review. Irrigation affects the performance of deciduous trees through two major mechanisms: its effects on stomatal conductance and assimilation
3. IRRIGATION SCHEDULING OF DECIDUOUS ORCHARDS
113
rate; and its effects on turgor and expansive growth. This emphasizes the important role of tree-water relations in irrigation, and the reader may refer to a few reviews on that topic (Landsberg and Jones 1982; Jones et al. 1985; Flore and Lakso 1989; Lakso 2003). Whereas earlier reviews covered older studies (Behboudian and Mills 1997; Fereres and Goldhamer 1990), the present review will focus mainly on recent publications. It is divided into two major topics: (1) The effects of deficit irrigation at different phenological stages on productivity and fruit quality and (2) factors affecting irrigation level, water stress assessment, and timing of irrigation.
II. THE MODERN IRRIGATION SCHEDULING CONCEPT Minimum water stress may be the optimal tree water status in certain phenological stages, where a certain degree of stress would be optimal in other phenological stages. Irrigation is applied mainly to maintain optimal availability of assimilates, which is achieved through the control of stomatal aperture, and maintenance of an adequate turgor potential when expansive growth of either the canopy and/or the fruit is expected. The irrigation level used is intended to return to the soil profile the amount of water transpired by the tree and the cover crop (T) in addition to the amount evaporated from the soil surface (E). The sum of these components is called evapotranspiration (ET). Transpiration is a two-step process that starts with conversion of the water from the liquid to the gas phase, a process that requires a significant amount of energy (2.54 MJ kg–1 at 20°C). After the water is vaporized in the stomatal cavities, it diffuses into the free air at a rate controlled by vapor pressure deficit—the difference between saturated vapor pressure at the leaf temperature and the actual vapor pressure at the atmospheric temperature—which is determined by air and leaf temperatures and air humidity. The resistance to this transport process is the sum (in series) of stomatal resistance and the boundary layer resistance, the latter being determined by wind speed, leaf size and shape, and canopy structure. Day-to-day variations in ET are expected because of the significant role of changing weather conditions in transpiration. The modern irrigation-scheduling concept (Allen et al. 1999) assumes: 1. ET of non-stressed crops, reference crop and evaporation from a free-water surface respond similarly to atmospheric evaporative demand.
114
A. NAOR
2. ET increases linearly with intercepted radiation by the crop. 3. Further differences in ET between crops are due to differences in canopy conductance and canopy roughness. Based on these assumptions, the ET of a specific crop under maximum moisture availability (ETa) is defined as ET0·KC, where ET0 is the evapotranspiration of a reference crop that covers the whole surface area, and which can be replaced by the evaporation from a free water surface in a standard pan, and KC (crop coefficient) is a proportion factor that depends on the fraction of the soil surface covered by the crop, the canopy conductance, and the canopy roughness. There are many models of calculating ET0, from empirical to more mechanistic ones where the effect of wind speed on ET is based on empirical relationships. Pan evaporation rates are highly correlated with ET0, but the slopes of these relationships are not unique and may change between types of evaporation pans and between operational standards. Detailed analysis of the methods of calculating ET0, their correlation with data collected in lysimeters, and the relationships between ET0 and pan evaporation rates can be found elsewhere (Jensen et al. 1990). Canopy conductance of deciduous trees during the dormant season is zero and they are not irrigated in spite the fact that the soil evaporation term of ETa is not zero. KC of deciduous trees increases with increasing foliage coverage, and varies according to seasonal changes in canopy conductance that result from changes in tree-water relations and according to crop level (as will be discussed in detail below). Sets of seasonal crop coefficients are available for various crops; they are based on lysimeter or soil water balance measurements (Allen et al. 1999). Irrigation for maximum biomass production requires no stress, while in other crops, including trees, stress may not affect economic yields. In many cases, tree water status attains its optimal value from the horticultural point of view under a certain stress, and ETa must be multiplied by a stress factor (KS), which is expected to change in the course of the season in accordance with the optimal tree water status. The actual irrigation level assuming no water depletion below the root zone (I) is the product of ET0, KC and KS: I = ET0·KC·KS. In cases where there is a risk of high salinity build up during the growing season, a leaching fraction is added. Two major aspects will be covered in the following: the response of deciduous trees to irrigation at different phenological stages, and issues related to timing of irrigation in relation to the degree of water stress. Also addressed will be the proper representation of water status in commercial orchards.
3. IRRIGATION SCHEDULING OF DECIDUOUS ORCHARDS
115
III. DEFICIT IRRIGATION Growers have practiced deficit irrigation for decades. In the past, deficit irrigation was restricted to the postharvest period based on the belief that water stress introduces no problems during phenological stages when no fruit exist on the tree and additional vegetative growth is undesirable; an exception is early cultivars in which the desired shoot growth is not completed by harvest. The effect of severe postharvest water stress on the productivity of stone fruits was studied mainly in early-maturing species such as apricot. Deficit irrigation at phenological stages other than postharvest was proposed in the early 1980s (Chalmers et al. 1981, 1986) as a beneficial irrigation strategy, and since then has been studied extensively. Several different processes are sensitive to water stress, and the times of occurrence of those processes may influence the sensitivity to deficit irrigation: 1. Reproductive cell division—lasts 30–40 days post anthesis. 2. Fruit drop—occurs usually during the first 40 days post anthesis. 3. Canopy growth—occurs mainly at the beginning of the season, but may continue longer if sufficient moisture is available and the crop load is low. 4. Flower bud differentiation and development—starts in midsummer and continues throughout the rest of the growing season. The above-mentioned processes are expected to respond differently to moisture availability. Therefore, the effects of deficit irrigation at each phenological stage will be discussed separately. In the cited reports, different water stress indicators were used, the intensity and duration of deficit irrigation varied, and several different cultivars were studied. These differences among others may result sometimes in inconsistent and contradictory findings. Therefore, the interpretation of the results is not always straightforward and the discussion on the effects of water stress, in most cases, is restricted to general terms such as low, moderate, and severe water stress. The post reproductive-cell division fruit growth stage in stone fruits can be divided into two parts, the pit-hardening stage and the final fruit growth stage, where in pip fruits there is practically a single post reproductive-cell division stage. Therefore, the post reproductivecell division stage of stone fruits and pip fruits will be discussed separately.
116
A. NAOR
A. Reproductive Cell Division Stage Reproductive cell division lasts 30–40 days after full bloom (Westwood 1993) and is accompanied by initial fruit growth. Water stress in the reproductive cell division stage did not affect the number of cells in the fruits (Marsal et al. 2000) but at harvest the cells in the fruits of the stressed trees were smaller, which indicates that water stress during the reproductive cell division stage affects the potential cell size. The proportion of fruit drop in apple increased in response to early water stress (Powell 1974; A. Naor, unpubl.). Water stress in the reproductive cell division stage decreased tree vegetative growth in pear (Mitchell et al. 1984, 1986, 1989; Chalmers et al. 1986; Marsal et al. 2000, 2002a), in which vegetative growth decreased with decreasing irrigation level (Mitchell et al. 1984, 1986, 1989), and decreasing midday leaf water potential (Chalmers et al. 1986) or midday stem water potential (Marsal et al. 2002a). Early water stress led to smaller apple (Failla et al. 1992) and pear (Marsal et al. 2000, 2002a; Naor et al. 2000) fruits; fruit size decreased with decreasing midday stem water potential during the reproductive cell division stage (Marsal et al. 2000, 2002a), and the smaller fruit size persisted until harvest in apple and pear (Marsal et al. 2000; Naor et al. 2000). Early water stress decreased the fruit sizes attained in peach by the end of the reproductive cell division stage (Fig. 3.1) and at harvest (Girona et al. 2002, 2004; Goldhamer et al. 2002). Deficit irrigation during both the reproductive cell division and the pit hardening stages in apricot decreased fruit size at the end of the pit hardening stage, but a significant fruit size recovery was apparent after the water stress was relieved during the final fruit growth stage (Ruiz-Sanchez et al. 2000a; Torrecillas et al. 2000). However, the statistical analysis of final fruit size in these studies is insufficient to conclude that the decrease in fruit size in response to early stages water stress is fully reversible. Contradicting results of increasing final fruit size in response to early water stress was reported for high-density pear (Mitchell et al. 1984; Chalmers et al. 1986), and it could be related to the higher midday leaf water potential in the pre-stressed treatment than in the control after resumption of irrigation (Chalmers et al. 1986). It seems that larger canopies in the control of high-density pear orchard, because of a significant increase in vegetative growth (Mitchell et al. 1984, 1986, 1989; Chalmers et al. 1986), may have increased water consumption and therefore decreased water potential. It may well be that in high-density orchards, the vegetative part invokes a significant competition for assim-
3. IRRIGATION SCHEDULING OF DECIDUOUS ORCHARDS
100
a
a
a
ab
Fruit weight (% of control)
b 90
b
b
80
Control WI Stage I WI Stage II WI Stage III
a
a a
117
c c
70
60
End of Stage I
End of Stage II
End of Stage III
Date of fruit weight measurements Fig. 3.1. Effects of withholding irrigation (WI) in the reproductive cell division (Stage I), pit hardening (Stage II), and final fruit growth (Stage III) stages on peach fruit fresh weight relative to unstressed trees (control). Fruit weights of the control were 41.2, 68.5, and 215 g at the end of stages I, II, and III, respectively (Source: Girona et al. 2002).
ilates, explaining the contradicting results of increased fruit size in early-stressed trees in high-density trees. A multiseason test of the effects of early water stress resulted in increased numbers of pears per tree (Mitchell et al. 1989), similar to the effect of moderate postharvest water stress (Fig. 3.2). This may indicate that moderate water stress improves the completion of flower bud development, resulting in higher flower intensity and fruit set in subsequent seasons. B. Pit Hardening Stage (Stone Fruits) The duration of the pit hardening stage changes with harvest date: the later the harvest the longer the duration of this stage (Westwood 1993). In early-maturing cultivars, the fruits continue to grow during the pit hardening stage, but slightly more slowly, making it hard to distinguish among the different fruit growth stages. The extent of fruit growth in the pit hardening stage decreases with increasing its duration. In practice,
118
A. NAOR
Total crop yield (t/ha)
40
a
30 b b
20
10
0 High
Med.
Low
Post-harvest irrigation level Fig. 3.2. Effects of postharvest irrigation levels in 2001 and 2002 on next-season pear crop yield (cumulative for 2002 and 2003). Midday stem water potentials were –2.8 MPa, –2.4 MPa, and –1.5 MPa in the Low, Med. and High irrigation levels, respectively (A. Naor et al. unpubl.).
the duration of the pit hardening stage in early-maturing cultivars is too short for deficit irrigation to be considered. Water stress during the pit hardening stage reduced fruit size at the end of the stage in peach (Girona et al. 2002) and nectarine (A. Naor, unpubl.), and water stress during both reproductive cell division and pit hardening stages also caused reductions in fruit size by the end of the latter stage in peach (Mitchell and Chalmers 1982) and apricot (RuizSanchez et al. 2000a; Torrecillas et al. 2000). In the above studies, fruit size recovered when irrigation was applied at a minimal-stressing level in the final fruit growth stage. An increase in fruit size in response to water stress in the pit hardening stage was reported in the third year, in a high-density peach orchard (Chalmers et al. 1981); this contradictory response could be a result of higher competition of the dense-shaded canopy for assimilates in minimum-stressed trees compared with stressed trees at that particular high-density orchard. Water stress dur-
3. IRRIGATION SCHEDULING OF DECIDUOUS ORCHARDS
119
ing the pit hardening stage in peach led to a lower percentage of large fruits (Goldhamer et al. 2002), in a study in which there was a 10-mm increase in fruit diameter during the stress period, which could have increased the sensitivity to water stress at this stage. If the designated end of the pit hardening stage in that study had been too late, that could also account for the smaller fruit size. Fruit expansive growth is affected by water stress, and the relative insensitivity of fruit size to water stress in the pit hardening stage is related to the limited fruit expansive growth that is usually apparent in this stage. The start of the pit hardening stage is easy to determine, whereas the end of this stage is not clear and in most cases it can be determined only post factum, on the basis of continuous measurements of fruit weight in the course of the season. In addition, the duration of the pit hardening stage and the date of its end change markedly from one season to another (Girona et al. 2003; A. Naor, unpubl.), therefore the use of a predetermined duration of deficit irrigation during this stage might be risky. In shallow soils both the build-up and the relief of water stress are rapid (Goldhamer et al. 2002), but in a deep heavy soil profile the relief of water stress at the end of pit hardening may take a few weeks, unless a significant extra amount of irrigation water is provided, to fill the soil profile (Naor, unpubl.); this may reduce the amount of annual applied water that can be saved through deficit irrigation at that stage. Shoot growth in grown apricot is almost completed by the end of the reproductive cell division stage (Torrecillas et al. 2000), therefore using deficit irrigation in the pit hardening stage is not beneficial for vegetative control. In peach, on the other hand, active shoot growth continues into the pit hardening stage (Fig. 3.3), therefore water stress in that stage might be beneficial for canopy size control. Improved color in peach that resulted from deficit irrigation in the pit hardening stage was attributed to reduced shoot growth and an improved light regime around the fruit (Gelly et al. 2003, 2004). C. Final Fruit Growth Stage (Stone Fruits) Fruit growth in the final fruit growth stage is highly responsive to irrigation, as a significant proportion of dry and fresh weight is accumulated in the fruit (Pavel and DeJong 1993; Grossman and DeJong 1995a,b; Girona et al. 2004). Water stress in the final fruit growth stage significantly decreased the final fruit size in peach (Besset et al. 2001; Girona et al. 2002), nectarine (Naor et al. 1999, 2001), apricot (Torrecillas et al. 2000), and Japanese plum (Naor et al. 2004). Under water stress, reductions in average fruit weight and yield were found to increase with increasing numbers of fruits per tree in both nectarine (Naor et al. 1999,
120
A. NAOR 60
Shoot extension length (cm)
50
Control NI-SI NI-SII NI-SIII
a a b
40 c
30
20
10 May
Stage-I
Stage II
Stage III
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Date (1996)
Fig. 3.3. Effects of withholding irrigation at stage I (NI-SI), stage II (NI-SII), and stage III (NI-SIII) of peach fruit growth on shoot extension compared with unstressed trees (control) (Source: Girona et al. 2004. This figure is reproduced with permission from the JHSB.).
2001) and Japanese plum (Naor et al. 2004). Under minimum water stress conditions, the nectarine fruit size distribution was shifted towards smaller fruits as the number of fruit per tree increased (Naor et al. 1999), indicating the magnitude of crop the canopy can support is limited and the crop level should not exceed this limit if large fruits are to be achieved. In Japanese plum under minimum stress conditions (Naor et al. 2004), the fruit size distribution was unaffected by the number of fruit per tree, probably because of lower crop yield, which did not introduce significant limitation of assimilates. D. Preharvest Deficit Irrigation in Almonds Preharvest deficit irrigation is a common practice in almond, for technical reasons: to reduce damage to the trunk caused by the shaker, and to simplify collection of the fruit. Withholding irrigation prior to harvest slightly decreased the shaker damage to the trunk (Gurusinghe and Shackel 1995; Goldhamer and Viveros 2000) but, on the other hand, severe water stress increased the proportion of the fruits that remained on the tree, delayed the opening of the hull, and increased the proportion of unopened hulls at harvest (Goldhamer et al. 2004).
3. IRRIGATION SCHEDULING OF DECIDUOUS ORCHARDS
121
Water stress in the final fruit growth stage of almond decreased (Goldhamer and Viveros 2000; Goldhamer et al. 2004; Romero et al. 2004) or did not affect kernel weight (Esparza et al. 2001a; Girona et al. 2005). The kernel size in almond decreased by <20% (Goldhamer and Viveros 2000; Goldhamer et al. 2004) in response to preharvest water stress, compared with reductions of up to 40% in fruit sizes (in peach, nectarine, plum, and apricot) (Naor et al. 1999, 2001, 2004; Besset et al. 2001). Most of the reduction in almond fruit size was restricted to the hull shell (Goldhamer et al. 2004), which is of no economic value. Preharvest water stress in almond slightly increased the number of fruit per tree in subsequent years (Goldhamer and Viveros 2000; Goldhamer et al. 2004); the increase was probably caused by an increased proportion of not fully developed flower buds in well irrigated trees (Forshey and Elfving 1989), similar to the case of pear (Mitchell et al. 1989; Fig. 3.2). The longer the duration of withholding irrigation prior to harvest (or the higher the degree of water stress) the lower the fruit set in the following season, provided postharvest water stress was applied (Goldhamer and Viveros 2000). This may indicate that the functioning of the flowers was damaged, which could also be related to a decrease in non-structural carbohydrate accumulation caused by water stress (Esparza et al. 2001b). Productivity of almond is highly correlated with canopy size in both young (Castel and Fereres 1982; Torrecillas et al. 1989; Girona et al. 1993a; Hutmacher et al. 1994) and grown trees (Esparza et al. 2001a; Romero et al. 2004). Productivity of almond is dependent on shoot growth, since some of the fruits are carried on 1-year-old shoots, and because of the high mortality rate of spurs (60% in three years), irrespective of irrigation level (Esparza et al. 2001a). Preharvest water stress in almond did not affect subsequent season productivity (Goldhamer and Viveros 2000), since most of the shoot growth occurs in earlier stages in the course of the season. On the other hand, preharvest water stress caused the productivity of a young orchard to decrease from year 4 to 7 (Fereres et al. 1981; Girona et al. 2005), because productivity is more dependent on canopy growth in young, not fully developed orchards. E. Post Reproductive Cell Division Stage (Pip Fruits) The fruit growth patterns of apple (Lakso et al. 1995) and pear (Naor et al. 2000) are expolinear—exponential increase during reproductive cell division stage followed by a linear growth pattern thereafter. In many studies the post-cell-division stage, which extends up to harvest, was arbitrarily divided into two sub-stages (early deficit and late deficit), so
122
A. NAOR
only general information was obtained about the sensitivity to water stress in the course of that stage. Moderate water stress up to 102 days after full bloom reduced canopy growth in apple (Behboudian et al. 1998), whereas water stress applied after this period had no effect. This indicates that shoot growth ends within 3 months after bloom (Irving and Drost 1987; Forshey and Elfving 1989). An early deficit created moderate water stress and resulted in a lower return bloom, whereas no reduction in return bloom was apparent in a late-deficit treatment (Kilili et al. 1996a; Behboudian et al. 1998). In another study, deficit irrigation throughout the season did not affect return bloom (Mills et al. 1994), but, in that particular case, water stress did not develop up to 100 days after bloom. Non-stress conditions decreased subsequent season productivity in pear (Mitchell et al. 1989; Fig. 3.2) and stone fruits (Larson et al. 1988; Johnson et al. 1992), probably by delaying flower bud development. Reductions in return bloom and productivity under severe water stress were found in pear (A. Naor et al. unpubl.) and apple (Ebel 1991), as well as in stone fruits (Brown 1953; Uriu 1964; Johnson et al. 1994; Ruiz-Sanchez et al. 1999; Goldhamer and Viveros 2000; Torrrecillas et al. 2000; Girona et al. 2003; Naor et al. 2005); the above-mentioned apple studies that showed lower return bloom did not involve such a high level of water stress (Kilili et al. 1996a; Behboudian et al. 1998). The reduction in the proportion of return bloom in apple trees moderately stressed early in the season can be explained as follows: A vegetative bud (bourse shoot) emerges from apple flower buds, and the longer the bourse shoot the higher the probability for its terminal bud to flower the following year (Lauri et al. 1996; Lauri and Trottier 2004). T