Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs
SUSAN YOUENS
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
Viennese composer Hugo Wolf produced one of t...
321 downloads
1356 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs
SUSAN YOUENS
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
Viennese composer Hugo Wolf produced one of the most important song collections of the nineteenth century when he set to music fifty-three poems by the great German poet Eduard Mörike. Susan Youens reappraises this singular collaboration to shed new light on the sophisticated interplay between poetry and music in the songs. Wolf is customarily described as “the Poet’s Composer,” someone who revered poetry and served it faithfully in his music. Yet, as Youens reveals, this cliché overlooks the rich terrain in which his songs are often at cross purposes with his chosen poetry. Wolf and Mörike were very unlike one another and had different aims for their arts. Although Wolf did much to draw the world’s attention to the neglected Swabian poet, his musical interpretation of the poetry was also influenced by his own life, psychology, and experiences. Youens examines selected Mörike songs in detail, demonstrating that the poems and music each tell their own stories which at times intersect but also diverge. This, she argues, is the distinctive strength of lieder. is Professor of Musicology at the University of Notre Dame. Her books include Hugo Wolf: The Vocal Music (1992), Schubert’s Poets and the Making of Lieder (1996), and Schubert, Müller, and Die schöne Müllerin (1997).
This page intentionally left blank
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs
This page intentionally left blank
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs
S U S A N YO U E N S
PUBLISHED BY CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS (VIRTUAL PUBLISHING) FOR AND ON BEHALF OF THE PRESS SYNDICATE OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE The Pitt Building, Trumpington Street, Cambridge CB2 IRP 40 West 20th Street, New York, NY 10011-4211, USA 477 Williamstown Road, Port Melbourne, VIC 3207, Australia http://www.cambridge.org © Susan Youens, 2000 This edition © Susan Youens, 2003 First published in printed format 2000
A catalogue record for the original printed book is available from the British Library and from the Library of Congress Original ISBN 0 521 65159 X hardback
ISBN 0 511 01926 2 virtual (netLibrary Edition)
Contents
List of illustrations Preface
page viii ix
1 “Göttlicher Mörike!”: an introduction to Eduard Mörike and Hugo Wolf
1
2 Peregrina revisited: songs of love and madness
18
3 Agnes’s songs: the fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman
60
4 Sung desire: from Biedermeier erotica to fin-de-siècle lied
100
5 Doubters and believers: case-studies in the geistliche Lieder
140
Notes Select bibliography Index
169 190 199
vii
Illustrations
1 Pastel portrait of Eduard Mörike by Johann Georg Schreiner 2 Drawing by Eduard Mörike to accompany his Schilderung eines Traums
viii
page 101 146
Preface
If music and poetry are the sister arts, so says tradition, they are also the odd couple. They do different things in fundamentally different languages; even where they seem to come together, they have different large tales to tell. It is symptomatic of their dissimilarities that actual collaboration – a poet and composer working together – is a rarity in the history of song. Even those eighteenth- and nineteenth-century poets who desired musical settings of their verse were seldom asked for their assent or consulted about their wishes in the matter; the usual practice was a composer’s appropriation of a poem without even the poet’s knowledge, much less his or her consent. Music’s conventional obeisances to poets and poetry are thus in some measure a guilty façade to conceal a form of theft in which an existing work of art is not only robbed but used and sometimes abused for purposes unimagined by the original creator. No longer poetry per se, it undergoes a sea-change – whether for better or worse is out of the helpless (often dead) wordmonger’s hands. One of the oddest of odd couples is the pairing of Eduard Mörike (1804–75) and Hugo Wolf, despite the fact that they are often cited as “the perfect marriage” of poetry and music. But even a skeletal outline of their lives makes it apparent that their arts issued from very different experiences and perspectives – two more unlike creatures would be difficult to imagine. Mörike was born in Ludwigsburg, still a small town in the kingdom of Württemberg and even smaller then, into a middle-class but far from wealthy family and was educated for the Lutheran ministry. His youth was punctuated by a series of tragedies – his father’s death, his younger brother August’s suicide, a catastrophic love affair – and life did not become easier in adulthood. Unsuited for religious life, he went from vicarage to vicarage and village to village in the late 1820s and early 1830s before finally receiving a pastorate in Cleversulzbach (another small town within the the Stuttgart–Tübingen– Ludwigsburg axis of his life), not in time, however, to save his protracted engagement to his fiancée Luise Rau. The hypochondriac poet, his psychosomatic illnesses exacerbated by detestation of his breadwinning occupation, was finally forcibly retired from the church’s service at age thirty-nine and became a teacher at a girls’ school in Stuttgart. Although he married Margarethe Speeth in 1851, jealousies between his sister Klara, who lived with them, and his wife eventually put an end to the marriage, while one of their two daughters died young. His oeuvre is slim for someone who lived to the ripe old age of seventy-one: the principal works are the novel Maler Nolten (The Artist Nolten) in 1832; a single anthology of poetry first published in 1838 and revised for editions in 1848, 1856, and 1867; ix
Preface and several tales and novellas, including what is perhaps his best-known work, Mozart auf der Reise nach Prag (Mozart on the Journey to Prague). He was just beginning to garner a small modicum of recognition when he died in poverty in 1875. Anyone familiar with the bare facts of Wolf ’s life can recognize numerous points of dissimilarity and difference. And yet, Wolf would become the agent by which Mörike’s fame surpassed its former regional limits to reach a wider public. Wolf ’s spate of fifty-three Mörike songs composed in 1888 constitutes one of the most famous episodes in the history of the lied, and it began the process by which Wolf became known as “the Poet’s Composer,” someone who cared more about poetry, served it more faithfully, delved into it more deeply than other lieder composers. Wolf ’s famous act of citing the poet first on his title pages (Gedichte von Eduard Mörike . . . componirt von Hugo Wolf) supposedly sets the seal on poetry’s primacy in these songs, but it is the verb “componirt,” “composed,” which matters more: these songs consist of something done to the Gedichte von Eduard Mörike. The cliché of the Poet’s Composer misunderstands Wolf by overlooking the rich terrain in which the songs are often at cross-purposes with his chosen poetry. This is not to deny his reverence for his favorite poets, the depth of his poetic understanding, or his capacity to find uncannily exact musical analogues for textual nuances, but he came from a different world than the older poets he preferred to his own generation. He could not help reading these late eighteenth- and earlier nineteenth-century poems in ways that were affected by his own political and historical context, psychology, erotic experience, and notions of spirituality, not Goethe’s or Gottfried Keller’s or Justinus Kerner’s or Eduard Mörike’s – and therein lies this book. Previous scholars, including Eric Sams in the sixth edition of Grove, have pointed out that Wolf ran roughshod over the printed text on occasion, and the ways in which he did so, the whys and wherefores, bear examining. For the benefit of those unfamiliar with the backdrop to Wolf ’s Mörike songs, the first chapter is a summary of that background, with an emphasis on the huge aesthetic gaps between poet and composer. Wolf, one discovers, would have known little, if anything, about Mörike’s life when he composed these songs, and his ignorance had consequences for his shaping of the music. The poems of the Nachlaß and Mörike’s letters, both of which provide invaluable glimpses into the poet’s character, beliefs, events in his life, and so on, only began to emerge in the 1880s and 1890s, and one doubts Wolf encountered what little scholarship there was by 1888. He would later pursue information about Mörike after making the acquaintance of someone with close ties to the Mörike circle, only to reach the conclusion that he might not have liked the poet, had they met. They certainly had divergent likes and dislikes musically; Mörike worshipped Mozart and detested Wagner and Liszt, whom Wolf loved. Even anecdotes about Mörike’s tendencies to torpor and Wolf as someone who always ran up the stairs rather than walking point to different natures. The four chapters which follow this brief introduction each tell of Wolf doing something Mörike would not have sanctioned to various poems and of a rich context surrounding the genesis of both the poems and the music, the composer often being unaware of the poetry’s origins. The first case-history in chap. 2 begins with what little is known of a formative event in Mörike’s life. In 1823, the young poet met a Swiss-born wanderer named Maria Meyer, who seems like a character out of a popular novel and who became x
Preface the stuff of fiction thereafter. When not imprisoned in Swiss workhouses for the poor, she depended upon different men and different menial jobs – tavern waitress, maidservant – for survival; when Mörike found out about her supposed promiscuity, he was devastated and turned her away from his doorstep in the summer of 1824. This cataclysm in his life is both told and revised in the cycle of five Peregrina poems he wrote over a period of many years, but Wolf set only two of the poems to music, for reasons possibly bound up with Wolf ’s own life; it may have been impossible for him to confront the content of the poems he omitted. The differences between the two cycles and speculation about Wolf ’s reduction of the poetic work to a dyad are the subjects of the latter half of the chapter. Maria Meyer is doubled in Mörike’s 1832 novel Maler Nolten, as Peregrina – four of the five poems appear here – and as the psychotic gypsy Elisabeth, the dea ex machina of the work. Elisabeth is not the only madwoman; the title character’s fiancée Agnes goes mad as well, and Mörike carefully traces the course of her mental breakdown from childhood paranoia to insanity and suicide. Here, nineteenth-century notions about hysteria and about women are placed under a literary microscope, and one can glimpse Mörike’s simultaneous critique of and concurrence with those notions. Like Goethe in Wilhelm Meisters Lehrjahre (the younger writer’s model), Mörike fills Maler Nolten with interpolated poetry, some of which Agnes sings en route to madness and from within it – her songs are the subject of the third chapter. One of those songs, entitled either “Rosenzeit! wie schnell vorbei” (the first line of the poem) or “Agnes,” was set to music many times, notably by Brahms in 1873, while other poems had to await the events of 1888. If it is speculatively possible that Wolf devised his setting of “Agnes” in part to “correct” what he found objectionable in Brahms, it is certain that he had Wagner in mind when he set “Seufzer” (Sigh) and “Wo find’ ich Trost?” (Where can I find consolation?), especially the latter, with its quotations from Parsifal. Mörike would not have approved, since he and his friends even contemplated publishing polemics against Wagner, but the reminiscences of Monsalvat are peculiarly appropriate for the poetic content – until the end. Wolf was prone to imaginative extensions of the poem in his postludes, and he provides for one of these songs a “redemptive” ending à la Wagner and not in accord with Mörike, more pessimistic than his best composer. Dyad-cycles, revised endings, and songs with other songs in mind recur in the fourth and fifth chapters. Eroticism is a red thread throughout the second and third chapters, given Maria Meyer’s embodiment of it and Agnes’s fear of it; Mörike’s erotic poems in Wolf ’s hands are the focus of chap. 4. Here, I have arranged four songs along a spectrum from near-pornographic symbolism to fairy-tale eroticism of the lightest, brightest variety and have tried to show what changes Wolf wrought on Mörike’s scenarios and why. Wolf probably found in the invocation of intercourse in “Erstes Liebeslied eines Mädchens” (A Maiden’s First Love-Song) – Mörike’s most startling poem – an antidote to the sexual hypocrisies he decried in his own time and place, but in his delight with the poet’s seeming explicitness, he may have missed the deeper implications of the poem. In his setting of “Der Knabe und das Immlein” (The Boy and the Little Bee) and “Ein Stündlein wohl vor Tag” (An Hour before Daybreak), he avails himself of the Schumannian privilege of putting separate poems together in conjunctions not of the poet’s making and doing so in a manner reminiscent of his Peregrina dyad, while his setting of “Der Gärtner” (The xi
Preface Gardener) is speculatively a correction or revision of Schumann’s earlier setting of the same text. And finally, at the opposite end of the spectrum from eroticism, I examine Wolf ’s treatment of two Mörike poems on religious subjects – “Gebet” (Prayer) and “Auf ein altes Bild” (On an Old Painting) – in the fifth chapter; ironically, Wolf the Nietzschean exCatholic gives Mörike the unhappy Lutheran songs in which the poet’s doubts are converted to redemptive endings, as in “Wo find’ ich Trost.” Wolf could not have realized the full extent of Mörike’s unhappiness with Lutheranism without knowing the Nachlaß and the letters; he might have formed a distorted estimation of the poet’s faith from the religious poems in the anthology, or he could, speculatively, have instilled something of his own non-dogmatic spirituality into these settings. One cannot discuss discrepancies between Mörike and Wolf without also invoking the points of convergence, more numerous by far. Wolf did, after all, recognize sooner than almost anyone else what is golden in Mörike, and he could and did devise complex, sophisticated intersections between this poet’s words and his own music. It is in the polyphony of ideas, his and Mörike’s, that the richness of these songs resides. Anyone writing a book incurs more debts than he or she can repay. I am grateful to the National Endowment for the Humanities for the research fellowship that enabled me to complete this project and to the Graduate School at the University of Notre Dame for their funding of a trip to the Mörike archives at the Deutsches Literatur-Archiv in Marbach. I am grateful both to A-R Editions, which produced the music examples for this book, and to the Institute for Scholarship in the Liberal Arts at Notre Dame, which generously paid for the production costs of those examples. I must also thank the Eda Kuhn Loeb Music Library, Houghton Library, Andover Theological Library, the Fogg Art Library, and Widener Memorial Library at Harvard University for their aid on many occasions, as well as the Music Collection of the Library of Congress, both houses of the Stadtbibliothek zu Berlin, the Österreichische Nationalbibliothek, the Wiener Stadt- und Landesbibliothek, and Regenstein Memorial Library at the University of Chicago. Jonathan and Maureen Boulton of the University of Notre Dame translated a Latin text in chap. 3 for me, and Albert Wimmer and Siglind Bruhn have helped with the daunting task of translating Mörike’s poetry. Students in two lied seminars have challenged, added to, argued with, and helped refine my thoughts about these songs, and friends (principally James McCalla, James Parakilas, and Mary Hunter) have both put up with a fine whine or two as the project wended its way and given me the benefit of their advice. Most of all, my heartfelt thanks go once again to Roger Parker, whose suggestions regarding this manuscript were invaluable. I am lucky to have such a good colleague and friend. Everything I write has been, still is, always will be, dedicated to the memory of Paul Amadeus Pisk, teacher and musician extraordinaire. Wolf ’s settings of “Schlafendes Jesuskind” and “Anakreons Grab” were sung at a memorial service for him when he died in 1990, and I cannot imagine a more fitting tribute for someone who loved Wolf ’s music and shared that love with me.
xii
Chapter 1
“Göttlicher Mörike!”: an introduction to Eduard Mörike and Hugo Wolf
In the summer of 1890, when Hugo Wolf was attempting to explain his philosophy of art to his new friend, the Stuttgart composer Emil Kauffmann (1836–1909), he cited works by Eduard Mörike as a perfect example of the kind of artistic truth he too sought to create:1 And Mörike himself, this darling of the Graces! to what excesses his Muse gave herself up, when she turned her countenance to the daemonic side of truth! The “Erstes Liebeslied eines Mädchens” presents a striking example of this. And what convulsive intimacy, what voluptuous pleasure in pain [welche krampfhafte Innigkeit, welches wollüstige Behagen am Peinlichen] speaks from those inimitable lines: “Erinn’rung reicht mit Lächeln die verbittert / Bis zur Betäubung süßen Zauberschalen; / So trink’ ich gierig die entzückten Qualen” [Memory, smiling, offers me the bitter-anodyne, sweet, enchanted chalice; so I drink avidly of enraptured torments2]. That is written with blood, and such tones can only strike one who, suffering, surrenders his innermost being to deeply truthful knowledge.3
The context for this impassioned passage is distressing – Wolf was trying to prove that Wagner was superior to Brahms (Wolf dubbed his detestation of his older contemporary “my anti-Brahmimentum”) – but the letter is still crucial for what it tells of Wolf ’s attraction to this poetic repertoire. Wolf even mimics Mörike’s Baroque-influenced trafficking in oxymoron, among the devices this poet used to evoke the intensity, complexity, ambiguity, and suffering of life. “That is written with blood,” Wolf declared, but this aesthetic idealin-a-nutshell was far from Naturalism or Realism, literary tendencies Wolf detested. Rather, passion and knowledge of pain are channeled into creations by artists who abjured the confessional gushing Wolf found so objectionable in certain poets of his own day. That the composer claimed Mörike as a kindred spirit, an alter ego, is evident in the letter to Kauffmann, but more than mere admiration is at work. Wolf used the poet for his own purposes, and he necessarily filtered everything in Mörike through the warping mirror of his (Wolf ’s) psychology, musical concerns, and culture, different from those of the poet he venerated. The discrepancies between poet and composer are far more interesting than the hoary legend of Wolf and his poets marching in lock-step, a myth which crumbles upon examination to reveal more intricate processes at work. Wolf was preaching to the converted when he wrote of Mörike as the “darling of the Graces” to this particular correspondent. Emil Kauffmann was the son of Ernst Friedrich Kauffmann (1803–74), a lifelong friend of Mörike’s4 and one of the first composers ever to set the words of this “son of Horace and of a cultivated Swabian lady” – Gottfried Keller’s 1
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs famous capsule characterization of Mörike – to music.5 The friendship between Wolf and Kauffmann began with Kauffmann’s enthusiastic response to Wolf ’s 1889 Gedichte von Eduard Mörike; along with a letter expressing his admiration, Emil sent a princely token of appreciation: the autograph manuscript of Mörike’s “An Longus” (To Longus) of 1841. Perhaps Kauffmann knew from Wolf ’s settings of Mörike’s comic songs that the Viennese composer would relish the verbal demolition of pushy, presumptuous types, or Sehrmänner (“very-men”) in this poem. The gift arrived on Wolf ’s thirtieth birthday, and the composer was delighted: You have unknowingly given me a birthday present, and a more splendid one I could not have wished for. With inner joy, I beheld the poet’s handwriting and, for the first time, discovered that its symmetrical strokes harmonize splendidly with the balanced essence of the poet. The poem, which, to be sure, manifests nothing of the “arch-fantasy” for which Mörike is renowned, is numbered among those I love most. Composable it isn’t, however.6
The passage is revealing. Wolf ’s knowledge of Mörike’s poetry is obvious, and he writes almost as if he were a literary critic, pointing out the poet’s idiosyncratic vein of fantasy and his cultivation of balance, but this connoisseur’s thumbnail sketch of the poet culminates with the omnipresent thought of a poem’s suitability or not for conversion into music. The search for song texts was his entire reason for reading poetry; whatever his appreciation of literary merit, he placed poems that were not composable into a different category than those that were amenable to music – his music. It is a mysterious phenomenon, neither comprehensible nor calculable, when the rediscovery of a poetic repertoire at a certain point in a composer’s life unlocks the door to musical maturity. In February of 1888, after a long, troubled apprenticeship in the art of composition, Wolf returned to the poet whose “Mausfallen-Sprüchlein” (Magic Charm for Mousers) he had set so charmingly six years earlier in 1882. For some reason, the renewed encounter was the catalyst for an explosion of creativity (the same was true of Schubert’s return to Goethe’s poetry in late 1814–15 and of Debussy’s musical rendezvous with Verlaine in 1884). On 24 January 1888, just three weeks before the Mörike outpouring began, Wolf had composed a listless setting of a listless poem by Heine, “Wo wird einst” (which, however, he later published in the 1897 Vier Gedichte nach Heine, Shakespeare und Lord Byron); this would be his last attempt to tune his lyre to that of Schumann’s favorite poet. It seems only appropriate to this tale of transformation that Mörike and Heine heartily disliked one another, representing as they do different approaches to poetry.7 That same day, however, Wolf also set to music Robert Reinick’s “Gesellenlied” (The Apprentice’s Song) about an apprentice whose master continually tells him “Kein Meister fällt vom Himmel” (Masters don’t fall from the sky) and who longs to find a bride and be a master himself. Wolf, who linked the cheeky, attractive apprentice David from Wagner’s Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg with the apprentice in Reinick’s poem, might have seen himself in both of these figures as well and perhaps glimpsed that his own mastery was just around the corner. He was exuberant over his friend Friedrich Eckstein’s services in arranging for the publication in 1887 of the Sechs Lieder für eine Frauenstimme and the Sechs Gedichte von Scheffel, Mörike, Goethe und Kerner – the first appearance in print of Wolf ’s songs – and had moved in mid-January 1888 to the Werner family’s home in Perchtoldsdorf in search of the peace and quiet he needed for composition. It was laugh2
An introduction to Eduard Mörike and Hugo Wolf ter that unleashed the floodgates, and laughter by a greater master than Reinick: Mörike’s “Der Tambour” (The Drummer-boy), composed on 16 February 1888, about a lad on the threshold of adulthood who fantasizes transformations and metamorphoses. How appropriate! – Wolf too was transformed in a way no one yet understands. What happened in those three weeks between “Wo wird einst” and “Der Tambour”? What conjunction between the trajectory of Wolf ’s life and this poet’s words brought “Wölferl’s own howl” into being at that moment in February? How does a poet act as midwife for a composer’s attainment of mastery? Wolf himself could not explain it, indeed, could hardly believe it. The letters he wrote to his friends Edmund and Marie Lang, Eckstein, and his brother-in-law Josef Strasser are hyperbolic, dazed, exuberant reports of what he had just composed and how he felt about each specimen of “Mörikeana,” as he dubbed the growing pile of songs.8 A letter to Lang on 22 January, one week after the start of it all, ricochets from joyful boasting (“A divine song, I tell you! Quite divinely marvelous!”) to an exacerbated state he could only evoke in phrases of oxymoronic ambivalence worthy of Mörike himself (“this condition of inspiration is exquisite torment to me, not pure happiness”). “Am I really one of the elect?”, he asked, and then wrote, “I believe I am mad,” the foreshadowing of his descent into insanity nine years later terrible to read. That February, however, he was at the height of his powers, composing “Der Knabe und das Immlein,” “Jägerlied,” and “Ein Stündlein wohl vor Tag” (The Boy and the Little Bee, Hunter’s Song, An Hour before Daybreak) in a single day. To his circle of intimates, he characterized “Nimmersatte Liebe” (Insatiable Love) as “a regular student’s song” – that students then as now are preoccupied with sex is the implication – and “Zur Warnung” (Warning) as “so weird and strange that I am quite afraid of it.” A leitmotif of the letters is enormous pride at what he was finally able to accomplish, after years of struggle. “Erstes Liebeslied eines Mädchens,” he wrote, “is of such intensity that it would lacerate the nervous system of a block of marble.” “What I write now, dear friend, I write for posterity too,” he said – not hyperbole, but statement of fact. Elective affinities are only partially explicable, if at all, but surely one source of Wolf ’s love for this poet was the nature of creativity as both men experienced it. For them, artistic creation was a matter of inexplicable visitations by an unreliable Muse, incalculable in her arrivals and departures, and both men suffered horribly during her frequent absences. In the poem “Muse und Dichter” (Muse and Poet), Mörike’s weak, ill poetic speaker begs desperately for the return of his lyre and is given only the most equivocal of answers, while Wolf compared life without musical creation to “a frog’s existence . . . not even a galvanized frog”; the Stoic humor of some (not all) of his references to Polyhymnia’s sulky withdrawals could not hide his misery.9 In a letter to his friend Friedrich Vischer in 1832, Mörike writes “I live here in a place that my Muse herself (and I have a very subjective and self-willed Muse) could not have sought out better.”10 Wolf too knew of willful Muses, capable of mocking, shocking, and deserting their hapless human prey; the inebriate tone of his announcements to friends of creativity redivivus are a measure of the relief he felt when the seasons of drought were over. Neither poet nor composer could court his Muse by any inducement; disciplined work-habits and the greatest of desires to create were of no avail in this fealty where she, not they, held the reins. I wonder whether Wolf felt a pang 3
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs of recognition when he read Mörike’s “An einem Wintermorgen, vor Sonnenaufgang” (On a Winter Morning, Before Sunrise), the “flagship poem” in each of the four editions of Mörike’s poetry directed by the poet himself, with its invocation of “eiderdown lightness” and “new worlds” stirring within him (“O flaumenleichte Zeit der dunkeln Frühe! / Welche neue Welt bewegest du in mir?”). The poet’s “bright swarm of images,” bathing in his breast like goldfish in a pond, became for the composer an inner swarm of musical ideas, and Wolf too lived in hope that new music would move and stir within him. For this composer, it was wintry death-in-life when he could not compose and the first day of creation when he could. Another source of Wolf ’s attraction to Mörike’s poetry is surely Mörike’s many-sidedness and slipperiness of categorization. He cannot be pigeonholed as wholly Romantic, neo-classical, Biedermeier-idyllic, or folkish, although he partakes on occasion of each of the above and has an instantly recognizable “voice” in whatever context. He wrote poems of many types, his works encompassing love-sonnets, folksong-like (but with a twist) ditties, free verse, blank verse, Knittelvers, sarcasm, good-natured humor, poetry about poetry, Rollenlieder (“role poems,” in which stereotypical characters speak), ballads of the supernatural, Dinggedichte (“thing poems,” in which vast recesses of meaning are glimpsed in seemingly insignificant objects), eroticism bordering on pornography, occasional poems, religious poetry, fantasy and fairy-tale worlds, Nature poems, and poems which burst the bounds of convention. His love of masks delighted Wolf, who also prided himself on his one-man carnival act, on the variety of characters he could clothe in music. In a letter to Kauffmann of 15 December 1891, Wolf, rejoicing over the initial work on the Italienisches Liederbuch, wrote “It [the songbook] is once again an entirely different world, and you will be not a little astonished at my Proteus-nature, that can now enter this skin.”11 He had already demonstrated his shape-shifting abilities in the Mörike volume, although “Wölferl’s own howl,” as he called it, those harmonic predilections, voice-leading procedures, textures, and so forth that he made his own, is manifest in every song. Perhaps most important, Wolf could claim Mörike as his own discovery for song. This poet came along too late for Schubert’s brief hold on life; while Schumann’s Mörike settings from his later years (including “Die Soldatenbraut” and “Das verlassene Mägdlein,” from the Romanzen und Balladen, op. 64, nos. 1 and 2; “Er ist’s!”, op. 79, no. 23; “Der Gärtner,” op. 107, no. 3; and “Jung Volkers Lied,” op. 125, no. 3) have much that is admirable, Mörike was not Schumann’s alter ego as was Heine, to whose name he is evermore linked. A few earlier composers (mostly close friends of the poet) had set Mörike to music, but despite their virtues, they are not Wolf ’s equal. Mörike was not yet recognized in 1888 as one of Germany’s best poets, although a few critics had begun to point out his significance; it was Wolf who lit a bonfire from the embers of the poet’s modest reputation and broadcast his name as never before. “The good Swabians shall yet come to know their poet!”, Wolf declared in a letter of 9 November 1890 to Emil Kauffmann in which he announced the possibility of a concert tour with the singer Ferdinand Jäger to Dresden, Leipzig, Berlin, Cologne, and Tübingen; two recitals in Tübingen, where Mörike had received his seminary training, would be devoted entirely to Mörike songs.12 When I contemplate the Mörike exhibits at the Schiller-Nationalmuseum or walk along Mörikestraße 4
An introduction to Eduard Mörike and Hugo Wolf in Marbach or visit the Mörike Bookstore in Ludwigsburg, I do so in part because of Wolf ’s actions on Mörike’s behalf. Wolf ’s championship of this poet was hardly disinterested: it was born of gratitude for the music Mörike helped him to create. Between 16 February and 18 May (a mere three months), Wolf composed forty-three songs.13 At the end of May, he had to leave the Brunnergasse house in Perchtoldsdorf because the Werner family wished to use it, and set off on a walking tour before returning to Vienna in July. Shortly thereafter, he joined Eckstein and the Langs near Grinzing, where he occupied himself with rebuilding an old piano. After going to Bayreuth in late August, where he was reportedly moved to tears by a performance of Parsifal, he returned first to Grinzing and then back to Vienna. It was at Eckstein’s house at Siebenbrunnergasse 15 in Vienna that Wolf composed Eichendorff’s “Verschwiegene Liebe” (Secret Love) on 31 August. He had earlier tried and failed to set it to music, and the success of his renewed encounter with the poem impelled him to seek solitude once again in order to compose. This time, he made use of the Eckstein family’s country house at Unterach am Attersee in the Salzkammergut, where he composed ten songs in nine days to complete his Eichendorff project. But he was not yet done with Mörike and wrote nine more songs between 4 and 11 October, beginning with “An den Schlaf ” (To Sleep) and ending with “An die Geliebte” (To the Beloved),14 before beginning his journey home to Vienna on 12 October. The final Mörike song, “Auf eine Christblume II,” was composed some six weeks later at Perchtoldsdorf, where it all began, on 26 November. The end of composition did not spell the end of Wolf ’s reverence for this poet. References to Mörike recur as a leitmotif in Wolf ’s letters for years after the miracle of 1888. On 25 April 1891, during his visit to Swabia, Wolf wrote to his friend Oskar Grohe to say “Today Urach will be visited,” mimicking the title of Mörike’s poem, “Besuch in Urach” (Visit to Urach).15 On 3 March 1893, following the birth of Grohe’s son Helmuth on 27 February, Wolf wrote to say, “Bravo!”, followed by a doggerel mélange of Mozart and Mörike: Das haben Sie einmal gut gemacht – über Nacht. You have done well once more – overnight; Bald werden Sie’s weiter noch bringen – mög’ es soon you will bring forth more – may you be gelingen – successful – Zu Papagenos und Papagenas, jedoch mit Maß. Papagenos and Papagenas, but with moderation. Laut klappert nur einer “im lustigsten Ton,” Only one loudly rattled its beak “in the merriest key,” Hellmutig er grüßt und flieget davon. He salutes you right merrily and flies away. . . . Ihr Hugo Wolf, priv. Kinderweibel und . . . Your Hugo Wolf, private child-nanny Komponist außer Diensten.16 and composer off-duty
The references are to Papagena’s and Papageno’s duet in act 2, scene 9 of Die Zauberflöte (“Es ist das höchste der Gefühle, / Wenn viele, viele Papageno, Papagena / Der Eltern Segen werden sein”) and to Mörike’s comic ballad “Storchenbotschaft” (Storks’ Message), in which a pair of storks herald the arrival of twins. Grohe, the composer teased, may still catch up with his operatic predecessors but should do so “mit Maß,” with Mörike-esque moderation. However, this merry squib has a sad subtext in Wolf ’s inability to compose, due to a compositional block lasting from 1892 to 1895, hence the designation of himself as an “unemployed” or “off-duty” composer. He too wished to give birth, but to more music 5
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs and not “mit Maß.” He had two more years to endure before this season in an arid hell of the mind was over. It was to Kauffmann, however, that Wolf would speak most often of Mörike, since Kauffmann could relay personal anecdotes to Mörike’s latterday admirer and could show his Viennese friend artifacts from the Kauffman family treasure-trove of Mörike memorabilia. (It is due to the efforts of several generations of Kauffmanns that there is so much Mörikeana in Marbach for scholars to study, from the red Hussar’s jacket worn by the fouryear-old future poet to autograph manuscripts and the books in his library.) On 2 April 1892, Wolf wrote to Kauffmann of his desire to own another photograph of Mörike; he had, he told Kauffmann, only the well-known image of the poet in his last years, showing Mörike in profile and reading a book.17 Kauffmann replied with the description of a different daguerrotype, and the composer’s curiosity about “our poet”18 was piqued. “Might I beg for your picture?”, he asked eagerly.19 The obliging Kauffmann sent him the image, and Wolf was duly grateful: Of all the portraits of the poet that I know, this seems the most successful, especially in the refined, sober tone of the execution, the rich modelling with regard to light and shadow on those striking features, over all of which lies the purest expression of thoughtful contemplation and gentleness. Truly, a glorious aspect that brings back to mind all of the wonderful hours that once, blessed by his genius, made me so deeply happy. A thousand, and yet again a thousand, thanks.20
On 26 September 1894, Wolf again wrote of his gratitude for Kauffmann’s gift of a book by Rudolf Krauß on Mörike als Gelegenheitsdichter (Mörike as Occasional Poet) – Kauffmann was sending Wolf books hot off the press21 – and recounts a tale of having taken the book with him on a picnic, intending to read selections from it aloud to his friends, only to find that it must have fallen out of the wagon. Everyone searched, then gave the book up for lost, until a package arrived by post from Wolf ’s friend Hugo Faißt, who had found the missing treasure. “You have gladdened me doubly with the book,” Wolf wrote Kauffmann, “and therefore you deserve double the thanks.” In the same letter, Wolf writes of his belief that from henceforth, biographies of Mörike should include his [Wolf ’s] name as well; Faißt had promised to drop a word to that effect in Krauß’s ear.22 Wolf knew that he would figure prominently in the history of Mörike-reception from that day on, and so he has. But it is perhaps just as well that Wolf only knew Mörike’s poetic works (minus the Nachlaß) and little else when he composed his songs, since his enthusiasm for the poet as a man, not as an artist, dimmed with greater knowledge. When he first encountered Mörike’s letters and heard Kauffmann’s tales, he was deeply moved, writing Kauffmann a letter on 22 November 1892 in which he reminisces about his visit to Tübingen in autumn 1890. On that occasion, Kauffmann had brought out Mörike’s letters to his (Kauffmann’s) father and read them aloud. “What fresh, youthful life breathed forth from these yellowed pages! These were no dead letters: the living word resounded throughout, and all was so full of meaning and feeling, shaped in the fullest image of life,” Wolf wrote.23 But it is an irony of history that, with the exception of the Hermann Kurz – Mörike correspondence published in 1885, Mörike’s letters only began to emerge in print after the composition of Wolf ’s Mörike lieder. On 17 May 1895, Wolf wrote to Melanie Köchert that he had read Mörike’s letters on the train en route to the Lipperheides’ villa at Matzen where he would 6
An introduction to Eduard Mörike and Hugo Wolf work on his opera Der Corregidor. What, one wonders, was he reading? The Mörike – Theodor Storm exchanges published in the Deutsche Rundschau for 1889 or the volume of Mörike’s letters to Moritz von Schwind published in 1890?24 If the latter, as seems likely, did Wolf know of the earlier connection between Schwind and Schubert? Whatever it was, Wolf dismissed the first half as “weak and fairly uninteresting,” the latter half meeting with greater approval, although “I had imagined the letters to be wittier and more original. A certain antiquated tone is all too prominent . . . I suspect we would not have gotten along well after all.”25 He was probably right. The Mörike–Storm and Schwind letters come from late in the poet’s life, not from the youthful years in which Mörike wrote many of the poems Wolf set to music, but Wolf might not have found the earlier letters that much more sympathetic. Mörike was monarchist in what little politics he was willing to espouse and conservative in many of his views, while Wolf was not; Mörike was bound to his family in ways Wolf was not; and Mörike was angst-ridden in matters of love and sex where Wolf was not. Mörike’s anti-Wagnerism would have roused Wolf ’s ire to a surety, and Mörike would have been horrified by Nietzsche and by Wolf ’s partial partisanship of Nietzsche’s philosophy. Even their religious dubieties, seemingly an element in common between poet and composer, were unlike beneath the surface. But in 1888, Wolf could find no fault with “divine Mörike,” and for that, the world of music is fortunate. Protected by historical circumstance from knowledge that might have marred his involvement with Mörike’s poetry, Wolf was able to claim the poet as his own for music. “AU F G O L D N E R TÖ N E L E I T E R ! ” : M Ö R I K E A N D M U S I C
And yet, there is an enormous aesthetic gap between these two men, the gulf exemplified in their differing musical tastes and their uses of music. Wolf would have known from Mörike’s works that the poet loved music (Emil Kauffmann, a musician and the son of a musician, might have told him more of Mörike’s passion for music), but Wolf ’s métier meant something other to the music-loving poet than to the practicing composer. Their opposing stances vis-à-vis Wagner make the point most strongly – had they met in real life, one can imagine their mutual disgust with each other – but Wagner is not the only point of disagreement. Ironically, both looked back to an earlier generation, Mörike to Mozart and Wolf to Schumann and Wagner, but they were attracted to different pasts for different reasons. Mörike, one is forced to conclude, would have neither understood nor liked Wolf ’s settings of his poetry. Despite his love of music, Mörike had limited technical understanding of it; he may even have rejected, consciously or unconsciously, specialized knowledge for fear of how that might affect the operations of music in his writings. To him, music was a Janus-faced phenomenon, both a source of beauty and a dangerous force which could cause listeners to lose their hold on the concrete world, music’s workings thus related to similar effects wrought by Eros and creativity. The seventeen-year-old Mörike wrote the following passage in a letter of February 1822 to his friend Wilhelm Waiblinger: Truly music has an indescribable effect on me – it is a recurrent sickness, but not constant. I tell you, a moving but not necessarily sorrowful piece of music, often a merry one, can sometimes release
7
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs what is innermost in me; then I sink into the most melancholy fantasies, where I want to embrace the whole world, where what is petty and bad is apparent in all its nothingness, where everything appears in a different, transfigured light. When the music breaks off, I want to throw myself from a high wall, I want to die; at those times, it fares with me as with the wandering Harper [Goethe’s Harper in Wilhelm Meisters Lehrjahre].26
If adolescent self-dramatizing is evident in the passage, similar experiences were written into his mature poetry. After the poetic persona hears someone singing in “Auf einer Wanderung” (On a Walk), he is no longer enclosed by an ordered space, with buildings and people in their proper places, but instead is magically transported outside of the town, beyond the bounds of human society, into an incandescent realm in which forms and shapes dissolve. Here, the experience is rapture, a passageway to the Muse’s “breath of love,” but the unanchored state induced by music is also akin to death in its dissolution of the self and hence threatening. The alliance of music with the destructive forces of creation, initial rapture ceding rapidly to illness and annihilation, is as much a leitmotif of the poems as music in its more beneficent guises. In “Josephine,” sacred music in a Catholic church seems to soar into the heavens “like a sun-drunk eagle,” summoning the wind to make the tapers waver and causing the poetic speaker to sicken at heart, while “Evil Greta” of the ballad “Die schlimme Greth und der Königssohn” (Evil Greta and the King’s Son) is a musical demon who “howls a death-song” as she throws the prince’s body into the sea at the end. A more potent compound of music and sexual fear would be hard to imagine. Time itself alters under music’s spell; in a letter of 14 May 1831 to his fiancée Luise Rau, Mörike told of visiting his home town of Ludwigsburg and hearing an Aeolian harp, whose “sweet tones fused the entire past within me.”27 Music was a means to an end for Mörike, and that (non-musical) end was a state conducive to the creation of poetry. In that poetry, he often waxes nostalgic for the late eighteenth-century world of his two gods: Goethe and Mozart. Everything Mörike found compelling in music had its epitome in Mozart, Haydn, and Beethoven, especially the Mozart of the mature operas, and there was little in the music of his own century that he liked.28 For him, Don Giovanni was the ne plus ultra of music, the artistic wholeness of this work and the rest of Mozart’s oeuvre being lost, so Mörike thought, to his own less fortunate generation. (On hearing Don Giovanni for the first time in December 1876, the sixteen-year-old Wolf “liked it very much,” but was already too Wagner-obsessed – he noted the presence of anti-Wagnerians in the audience – to find in Mozart an object of veneration equal to the composer of Parsifal.29) In Mörike’s sonnet “Seltsamer Traum” (Singular Dream), written in 1828 after attending a performance of Le nozze di Figaro in Stuttgart, the poet dreams of springtime gardens in which a hundred miniature Figaros dance with equally diminutive Cherubinos; the scene is espied through a veil of dream-illusion and as if through a reversed telescope, the objects smaller and more distant. Like stars in a far-away firmament, the Mozartian figures are multiplied, visible but not of Mörike’s own world. The poet himself appears in the last line as a Hanswurst, singing on the flowery field; he could only fulfill his desire to belong to Mozart’s realm, to sing with Mozart’s characters, in the disguise of a clown, a clumsy, masked mimicry of earlier authenticity, and then only in dreams.30 Mörike’s opinions about music are a leitmotif of his letters, especially his correspondence with the musically talented members of his circle, Wilhelm Hartlaub (1804–85) and Ernst Friedrich Kauffmann, and with his music-loving family (his brother Adolph 8
An introduction to Eduard Mörike and Hugo Wolf became a piano-builder, and his brother Karl was a composer). In an amusing missive of 6 February 1825 to his mother and older sister Luise, Mörike tells of attending a student orchestra rehearsal at the Lutheran seminary in Tübingen, a rehearsal led by the Stift’s music director, the young Friedrich Silcher (1789–1860) before his fame as a folksong arranger.31 On this occasion, the musicians performed the overture to Die Entführung aus dem Serail, to Mörike’s pleasure, and a “modern” composition by someone named Vogel, first name not supplied and not to the poet’s pleasure. Manuals of concertgoing etiquette should not be based on this incident, except as a negative example; one suspects Mörike exaggerated the story for his family’s entertainment (as we shall see in chap. 2, this event occurred six months after multiple traumas in Mörike’s life, and he was attempting to spare his mother and sister concern for his well-being, to pretend that he was all right): When a bad piece was played, however, full of affected melancholy and plagiarisms, my amusement tempted me into all sorts of secret pantomimes and mockery which, without my noticing it at first, made the neighboring listeners break out in loud and hearty laughter. The laughter grew as it spread through the hall until the uproar brought the melting sighs of the overture to a halt. The angry musicians cast their instruments aside and jumped up, upon which I could hardly slip out the door fast enough. Silcher . . . could no longer keep going. I was both rueful and delighted [Es reute mich und freute mich] over what I had done to the miserable piece. (It was by Vogel.)32
Consigning the wretched composer to a parenthetical afterword is mockery indeed, but it is the dislike of “heart-on-sleeve” emotionalism that one most notes in this letter. He was already averse to Romanticism in music, and he would become more so with age. But emotions unleashed by Mozart were another matter. Although more poet than scholar, Mörike was a classicist who cherished Greek and Roman antiquity, and it is surely in part for that reason that he was so drawn to La clemenza di Tito. In a letter to his friend Johannes Mährlen of 5 June 1832 from Ochsenwang, Mörike describes how a sudden summer thunderstorm had affected him: At the window, I saw a storm draw near from the Teck side; a minute later, I heard the first roll of thunder, and all my life-spirits in delight began secretly to wait for it. With incredible swiftness, the storm broke over our heads. Broad and mighty lightning strikes, one after another, such as I had never seen before in daytime, fell like a shower of roses in our white room. Old Mozart might at that moment have been standing invisibly at my back, beating on my shoulders with his Kapellmeister’s staff. It was as if the devil had let loose the overture to Titus in my soul, so incessant, so glorious, so piercing that with each brassy cry of the Roman trumpet [“römische Tuba,” Mörike writes, punning on the Latin “Tuba mirum spargens sonum” of the Requiem – Mozart yet again], I clenched both fists in rapture.33
In this fantasy, Mozart is still living, grown old but no less powerful, and directing the forces of Nature itself. The equation of music with the diabolical-elemental could not be more vividly expressed. In one summation, La clemenza di Tito tells of someone who is spurred to wrongdoing by erotic passion, but is granted forgiveness for his transgression at the end; Mörike, who was not so fortunate (see chap. 2), was perhaps drawn to Mozart’s last opera for this reason as well. Mörike’s memento mori “Ach, nur einmal noch im Leben” (One Last Time before Dying), written sometime before 4 August 1845,34 has its inception in Sesto’s aria, “Deh, per questo istante solo,” from the second-act confrontation between Tito and Sesto, when Sesto cannot bring himself to reveal that it was Vitellia who plotted against Tito’s life and Tito, believing Sesto responsible for the assassination attempt, condemns him to death. 9
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs The remorseful Sesto implores Tito, “Just for a moment, remember our past affection, for your contempt, your coldness, make me die of grief,” before the guards lead him away. In Mörike’s poem, only the beginning of the aria is given, in seeming whimsy, to a singing garden gate, but the words not sung, the continuation of the German text, linger in the background and confirm the death-haunted atmosphere (“Ach, nur einmal noch im Leben / lass dein Herz mir offen steh’n, / ruhiger, hast du mir vergeben, / werd’ ich dann zum Tode geh’n,” or “Ah, once more in life, let your heart stand open to me; I will go more peacefully to my death if you forgive me”): Ach, nur einmal noch im Leben! (lines 30–54) – Und was, frug ich nach einer kurzen Stille sie, Was denn noch einmal? Sprich! woher, Elegische, Hast du das Lied? Ging etwa denn zu deiner Zeit (Die neunziger Jahre meint’ ich) hier ein schönes Kind, Des Pfarrers Enkeltochter, sittsam aus und ein, Und hörtest du sie durch das offne Fenster oft Am grünlackierten, goldbeblümten Pantalon Hellstimmig singen? Des gestrengen Mütterchens Gedenkst du auch, der Hausfrau, die so reinlich stets Den Garten hielt, gleichwie sie selber war, wann sie Nach schwülem Tag am Abend ihren Kohl begoß, Derweil der Pfarrherr ein paar Freunden aus der Stadt, Die eben weggegangen, das Geleite gab; Er hatte sie bewirtet in der Laube dort, Ein lieber Mann, redseliger Weitschweifigkeit. Vorbei ist nun das alles und kehrt nimmer so! Wir Jüngern heutzutage treiben’s ungefähr Zwar gleichermaßen, wackre Leute ebenfalls; Doch besser dünkt ja allen, was vergangen ist. Es kommt der Zeit, da werden wir auch ferne weg Gezogen sein, den Garten lassend und das Haus. Dann wünschest du nächst jenen Alten uns zurück, Und schmückt vielleicht ein treues Herz vom Dorf einmal, Mein denkend und der Meinen, im Vorübergehn Dein morsches Holz mit hellem Ackerblumenkranz.35
One last time before dying! – And what, I asked it after a short silence, was that all about? Speak! from whence, o elegiac one, came that song? In your time (the nineties, I would guess), did a lovely child, the pastor’s granddaughter, modestly go in and out of here, and did you hear her often through the open window brightly singing to the accompaniment of a green-lacquered, gold-flowered dulcimer? And did you also think of her strict mother, the housewife who took such painstaking care of the garden, how in the evening, after a sultry day, she watered her cabbages; in the meantime, the pastor took some friends from town down the road to see them off; he had entertained them there in the arbor – a dear man, though he loved to ramble on. They are all gone now and will never return! We young ones nowadays do the same things more or less – gallant folk we are, but everyone prefers best of all what is vanished. The time will come when we too will have gone far away, leaving the house and the garden. Then you will sing the olden tune for us as well, and perhaps some true heart will come this way from the village, may think of me and mine in passing, may adorn your crumbling wood with a garland of wildflowers.
A skeleton by Holbein, death is visible behind every word of this poem, from its title to the mouldering wood, evocative of coffins, at the end. In this hall of mirrors, a memory contains yet another memory which in turn tells of still more memories of what is gone: all art is elegy, Mörike says. His singing gate, comic at first glance, is the saddest of symbols. One leaves Edenic Paradises – this one too has a stern guardian – by way of gates which open time as well as space, with art the amanuensis to lead us through corridors of memory and into realms of death. 10
An introduction to Eduard Mörike and Hugo Wolf Mozart’s older and younger contemporaries Haydn and Beethoven were also composers Mörike venerated, although Mozart always came first in his pantheon and late Beethoven was beyond his grasp.36 (Late Beethoven is among the principal influences on Wolf ’s D minor string quartet.) In the postscript to a letter of 2 September 1837 to Hartlaub, Mörike writes of a “piece by Haydn” – which one, he does not say – that he compares to a “Komplimentenmacher” (flatterer) because “it is as if two men, one with hat in hand, took leave of one another at the door, but could not end the matter and continually began conversing all over again from the start. The men wore wigs.”37 It is a charming pictorial fantasy by which Mörike renders visible the developmental processes in Haydn’s music and invokes the bewigged, witty formality of it all. High praise for Beethoven is also a recurring motif in Mörike’s letters, the poet telling Hartlaub in a letter of 12 August 1837 that he (Mörike) had an added inducement for his friend to pay him a visit: “I have copied a facsimile in Beethoven’s handwriting; when you come, you shall have it.”38 The thought of Mörike, whose own handwriting now appears in facsimile reproductions, copying Beethoven’s script is moving. Three years later, Mörike once again begged Hartlaub in a letter of 10 May 1840 to visit him, saying, “Do not forget to bring the & volumes! Here, I also have a new ‘Rohtraut’ along with a pleasant letter from the composer [he refers to his friend Ludwig Hetsch’s setting of Mörike’s “Schön-Rohtraut”]. I naturally have no how to procure a musical performance here and thus will hear the work for the first time through you.”39 One instance of the poet’s Beethoven-veneration is also a demonstration of the way in which Mörike used his experience of music to unleash poetic images that have nothing to do with the music itself. In a letter to his mother and sister Klara on 2 December 1838, Mörike goes into ecstasies about hearing Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony when it was performed at a concert in Stuttgart; his impressions of the various numbers on the program are a window onto his musical tastes: Hideous festival overture by Lindpaintner. Hardegg said afterwards that it was as if one had pasted together a slew of phrases without any sense to them. [Peter Joseph von Lindpaintner, 1791–1856, was a composer in Stuttgart who would, ironically, collaborate with Mörike the next year on a festival-cantata in honor of Schiller, while Hermann Hardegg was a boyhood friend of the poet’s.]40 The quartet [sic! “song and duet”] from the Abduction [Mozart’s Die Entführung aus dem Serail]: “Wer ein Liebchen hat gefunden” sung wonderfully by Pezold, Walbach-Canzi, etc. Quartet from Lachner’s Geisterthurm, charming and individual – beautiful unity. It was heartily applauded, which seemed a good omen to me. [Ignaz Lachner, who gave Mörike the ticket for this concert, set Mörike’s Singspiel libretto Die Regenbrüder to music.] A few others I shan’t name. On the other hand, [there was] a symphony by Beethoven in C minor! How thrilling! (I thought quite involuntarily of spirit-choirs coming together to create a world; they sway and sing, singly and in groups, often in blessed strife with one another, and pour out rivers of light before them, entire oceans!)41
Similar invocations of paradisaical light appear in Mörike’s poem “An Wilhelm Hartlaub” (To Wilhelm Hartlaub), written before April 1842: An Wilhelm Hartlaub (lines 7–14 of 34) Doch plötzlich war dein Spiel wie umgewandt, Nur blauer Himmel schien noch ausgespannt Ein jeder Ton ein lang’ gehaltnes Schweigen.
To Wilhelm Hartlaub Then suddenly your playing was as if transformed; the blue sky only seemed to expand still further, every tone a long-sustained silence.
11
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Da fing das Firmament sich an zu neigen, Und jäh daran herab der Sterne selig Heer Glitt rieselnd in ein goldig Nebelmeer, Bis Tropf ’ um Tropfen hell darin zerging, Die alte Nacht den öden Raum umfing.42
The firmament began to bend down and suddenly the blessed host of stars glided downwards in a golden sea of cloud until drop upon drop brightly dissolved therein; the olden night encircled the bleak room.
One thinks of Gustave Doré’s illustrations for Dante’s Il Paradiso, with their angel throngs and rays of supernal light. To be so dazzled by Beethoven’s Fifth or the Classical keyboard repertoire is commendable anytime, anywhere, but one notes the almost immediate replacement of music by literary images. Mörike would always prefer eighteenth-century music above all else, but he did explore more recent compositions to the degree his limited finances would allow, and he and his circle avidly discussed new arrivals on the musical scene. A few nuggets of nineteenthcentury opera even found their way into his poetry as sources for contrafacta; Mörike, a pastor (albeit a reluctant one), was familiar with the old Lutheran practice of adapting prior music to new words and turned it to secular uses on occasion. His “Wanderlied” (Walking Song, beginning “Entflohn sind wir der Stadt Gedränge,” or “We have fled the press of the city”) should be sung, so the poet directs, to a melody from Daniel François Auber’s La Muette de Portici of 1828 (?); which air, Mörike does not say – he is as mute as Auber’s Fenella on the subject – and the conjunction is a curious one. Another poem, “Lang, lang’ ist’s her!” (Long, long ago), written for the wedding of Mörike’s friend Johannes Mährlen’s daughter, tells of remembered music which is itself about memory, a doubling and trebling of Mörike’s lifelong preoccupation with the workings of remembrance. His source was Thomas Haynes Bayly’s (1797–1839) popular air “Long, long ago” (which appears translated in German songbooks such as Ludwig Erk’s Deutscher Liederschatz):43 Long, long ago (stanza 1 of 3) Tell me the tales, that to me were so dear, Long, long ago, long, long ago: Sing me the songs I delighted to hear, Long, long ago, long ago. Now you are come, all my grief is removed, Let me forget that so long you have roved, Let me believe that you love as you loved, Long, long ago, long ago!
So much that is characteristic of this poet is bound up in his attraction to this tune: nostalgia for bygone melodies and bygone days, the longing for a remedy to heal the wounds inflicted by Eros (that these words lurk in the background of a wedding song seems psychologically fraught), and the obsession with memory. The nineteenth century’s best composers, however, seldom met with his approval. On 20 March 1843, Mörike wrote of hearing Schubert’s “Erlkönig” when the theologian David Friedrich Strauß’s wife Agnes Schebest (a well-known opera singer) and Kauffmann performed it at a domestic musicale. Despite admitting that the lied had things of beauty in it, he thought it strident and shrill, a “display piece” which nullified the character of the poem (Goethe would probably have agreed with him). “The child’s cries could shatter glass,” 12
An introduction to Eduard Mörike and Hugo Wolf Mörike wrote; they can indeed, but Mörike meant the words as disparagement.44 His friend Ludwig Hetsch’s (1806–72) twelve Mörike songs, bland and forgettable, seemed to him worthier stuff than the songs of Robert Franz or Schubert, as Mörike wrote to Hartlaub on 19–20 August 1865 – confirmation, if any were needed, of the poet’s conservatism.45 He made a qualified exception to his dislike of most “new music” for Mendelssohn, telling Hartlaub on 6 May 1838 that he had heard some of the Lieder ohne Worte and had liked them.46 He was evidently moved to explore more of Mendelssohn’s music; on 10 June 1838, he asked whether Hartlaub would like to see his [Mörike’s] copy of the op. 8 songs, even copying out the melody of the “Erntelied” (Harvest Song) for his friend.47 Fifteen years later, in April 1853, he was even more impressed by Mendelssohn’s op. 55 incidental music to Sophocles’s Antigone for male chorus and orchestra: “Countless times I was so struck by the poetic and musical impression together that I felt a shiver down my spine!” But even such praise went hand-in-hand with condemnation of what Mörike dubbed “ticklish oddities” and learned, “great Master” effects (in which works, he does not say).48 Mendelssohn’s younger contemporaries and successors met with still less approbation from the Mörike circle. Whether Mörike ever heard Schumann’s nine songs to his poems, we do not know, but Hartlaub attended a recital in Stuttgart in 1872, three years before Mörike’s death, which included some unspecified Schumann songs; Hartlaub found them not at all to his liking.49 But the foremost target of scorn for Mörike and his friends was the “new German school” of Liszt and Wagner, especially Wagner. Strauß seems to have been the first in the group to encounter Wagner’s music and described Lohengrin in a letter of 1851 to Kauffmann as “mediocre.”50 One year later, he was far more exercised about the matter, telling Kauffmann in a letter of 11 October 1852 that the two of them should work together on a “critique of the Wagnerian ravings about opera, drama, etc.” 51 No such critique ever appeared in print, but in a lengthy letter of 19 March 1853, Kauffmann dubbed the Wagnerians “these false prophets,”52 and Mörike would subsequently borrow those words for a climactic passage in his novella Mozart auf der Reise nach Prag (Mozart on the Journey to Prague). After playing the second-act finale of Don Giovanni for his hosts, the fictive Mozart declares, “Yes truly, in the course of the next sixty or seventy years, after I am long gone, many a false prophet will arise.” The figure of sixty or seventy years was carefully chosen: Mozart’s “future” was the Wagnerian “present” of the novella. In their opposition to Gesamtkunstwerk, the Mörike circle took great delight in a parody written by their friend Bernhard Gugler (1812–80, the rector of the Stuttgart Polytechnic), who entitled his veritable delirium of alliterative and rhyming words “Naturbilder” (Nature Images). A brief excerpt will suffice: Naturbilder (lines 1–12 of 40) Horch! die düstern Rüstern flüstern lüstern dort, Alter Katzen Tatzen kratzen fort und fort. Grauer Wölfe zwölfe raufen, saufen wild, Doch die flinken Finken trinken, sinken mild. Felsen schmelzen, Dohlen johlen, Grillen schrillen keck; Draußen brausen, sausen Straußen durch den Dreck. Hochverstiegen liegen Ziegen faul im Gras, Raben traben, graben, laben sich am Aas.
13
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Die Hyänen gähnen, Eulen heulen gräulich, Storchen horchen, sorgen, brüten, hüten treulich Zweier Reiher Eier; Nattern schnattern traut, Dreier Geier Schleier flattern, knattern laut [and so on].53
A malevolent and noisy Noah’s Ark is assembled to mock Wagnerian notions of Nature, poetry, and music. That the poem makes any sense whatsoever is a virtuosic feat of sorts. Ultimately, Mörike resembles his idol Goethe in his musical tastes. Like Goethe, he welcomed settings of his verses, as long as they were in a style he found acceptable – classicizing or folklike – and did not compete with the poetry for primacy. Given a reputation more modest by far than Goethe’s, it was mostly friends, family, and local composers who provided Mörike with lieder fashioned from his verse, and of their songs, he was happiest with the more modest ones. For example, Mörike’s brother Karl brought Emilie Zumsteeg (1796–1857, Johann Rudolf Zumsteeg’s youngest daughter) to Mörike’s attention, and her subsequent music for Mörike’s “Die Soldatenbraut” (The Soldier’s Bride) particularly pleased the poet. On 3 February 1839, he sent Hartlaub copies of Ernst Friedrich Kauffmann’s setting of “Die traurige Krönung” (The Sad Coronation) and Zumsteeg’s song, saying he preferred the latter; given Kauffmann’s occasional experimentation with Romantic chromaticism of the sort Mörike disliked, one is not surprised that Emilie Zumsteeg’s artful simplicity was more to his taste.54 His friend Ludwig Hetsch’s forgettable, bland diatonicism also pleased him; on 29 December 1837, Mörike copied out revisions to “Die Schwestern” (The Sisters) and the “Lied eines Jägers” (Song of a Hunter) for Hartlaub to convey to Hetsch for musical setting55 and then eagerly anticipated hearing the new songs in February 1839.56 Post-Mozartian music of any real power, from Schubert to Wagner, disturbed him as it had earlier disturbed Goethe. One may regret this inability of a great poet to appreciate the great music of his own time, but it is a reminder that poets and composers are fundamentally different, created works which are intrinsically different, and wanted different things from each other. The poetry more than makes up for Mörike’s inability to comprehend the musical innovations of his day. For the image of the piano keyboard as a skeletal old mare suddenly transformed into an Arabian steed, its fierceness tamed by a pianist’s skill, in “Auf einen Klavierspieler” (On a Pianist), one can forgive Mörike his dislike of Schubert, Schumann, Wagner, and Liszt – Wolf ’s musical gods: Hört ihn und seht sein dürftig Instrument! Die alte, klepperdürre Mähre, An der ihr jede Rippe zählen könnt, Verwandelt sich im Grippe dieses Knaben Zu einem Pferd von wilder, edler Art, Das in Arabiens Glut geboren ward! Es will nicht Zeug noch Zügel haben, Es bäumt den Leib, zeigt wiehernd seine Zähne, Dann schüttelt sich die weiße Mähne, Wie Schaum des Meers zum Himmel spritzt, Bis ihm, besiegt von dem gelaßnen Reiter, Im Aug’ die bittre Träne blitzt – O horch! nun tanzt es sanft auf goldner Töne Leiter!
Hear him and see his shabby instrument! The old, withered nag, on whom you could count every rib, transformed in this boy’s grip into a steed of a wild, noble sort, that was born of Araby’s ardor! It will have neither saddle nor bridle, it rears its body, neighing, shows its teeth, then shakes its white mane, spraying to the skies like the ocean foam, until, vanquished by the patient rider, bitter tears shine in its eyes – Oh listen! now it dances gently on a scale of golden tones!
14
An introduction to Eduard Mörike and Hugo Wolf It is fortunate that Wolf in 1888 knew only poems such as this and nothing of Mörike’s anti-modern intransigence in musical matters when he set so many of this poet’s works to music. “ N O T P O E M S, BU T E N T I R E P O E T S ” : F RO M P O E T I C A N T H O L O G Y TO WO L F
What Wolf knew best of Mörike was the poet’s one medium-sized poetic anthology, a collection with a long history. Emerging from several years of silence to renewed activity, Mörike told his older contemporary Justinus Kerner – whose late poem “Zur Ruh’, zur Ruh’” Wolf would set to music in 1887 – in a letter of 16 August 1836 that he would shortly begin collecting and revising his better poems for the purpose of publishing an anthology.57 The Stuttgart firm of Cotta finally agreed to publish 1,000 copies of the collection in 1838 and to pay Mörike 330 florins; the more famous Swabian poet Ludwig Uhland had received 1,000 florins for 1,000 copies of his poems that same year, and Mörike was not entirely happy with the contract (Uhland’s and Mörike’s literary standing has since reversed). In three subsequent editions, Mörike would revise, delete from, add to, and rearrange his anthology, culminating in the Ausgabe letzter Hand of 1867. By then silenced as a poet, his ineradicable psychological conflicts seldom ceding to creative endeavors, Mörike wrote of this fourth edition to his brother Karl, “It’s just dressed-up old wares,”58 but those “old wares” are both works of self-sufficient poetic beauty and the stuff of fifty-seven lieder by Wolf.59 Eduard Hanslick, not predisposed to like Wolf, once made the acid comment that Wolf composed not poems, but entire poets, and Mörike was the first poet Wolf composed en masse.60 Although this composer’s first two publications were in the “Six Songs”-format typical at the time, he had earlier envisioned a small-to-medium-sized “Song Bouquet” of lieder entirely to poems by Heine; organizing an opus around a single poet had already occurred to him, but not on this scale.61 That he did not set out to compose a compendium of this size seems obvious from his dazzlement at the rapid march through the Mörike volume (Wolf ’s source was probably the posthumously published sixth edition of Mörike’s poetry), and yet this became the model for all of his subsequent song collections; even the three Michelangelo songs of 1897 were originally intended as part of a volume that would be a many-sided portrait of the artist. Late eighteenth-century song composers, most notably Johann Friedrich Reichardt and Johann Rudolf Zumsteeg, had published even larger compendia of Goethe songs and Schiller settings a century earlier, but Wolf ’s singlepoet collections were differently calibrated. In this way, Wolf could “one-up” the large song cycles of Schubert and Schumann with something even bigger and could exercise his operatic dreams even within the sphere of lieder by devising music for a variety of poetic personae. Those operatic ambitions, evident early in Wolf ’s life, doubtless determined his attraction to Mörike’s many Rollenlieder; lovers, hunters, abandoned maidens, an old woman, a drummer-boy, elves and fairies, penitents, a goddess or two, poets, a critic, and more speak from the poems Wolf chose. Looking through Mörike’s and Wolf ’s anthologies side-byside, one can see certain patterns in the composer’s selection of song texts, for example, his liking of Mörike’s vein of fantasy in both comic and menacing manifestations, 15
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs although longer fantasy-poems, such as “Vom Sieben-Nixen-Chor” (From the SevenNixie-Choir), were too large for lieder; so too were lengthy poems on non-supernatural subjects, such as “Die schöne Buche” (The Beautiful Beech-Tree). Other poems were excluded for other reasons; Mörike’s tiniest epigrammatic poems, such as “Vicia faba minor,” were too brief for even the most compressed songs, while his many occasional poems were often too specific to their time and place for transference elsewhere, such as Mörike’s witty apology to a librarian for the late return of a book of Catullus’s poems. Ultimately, one is impressed by Wolf ’s discernment of what is finest in Mörike, by his choice, for example, of ballads such as “Der Feuerreiter” (The Fire-Rider) rather than “Die Schatten” (The Shadows, a tale of supernatural vengeance for sexual transgression), or of “Der Tambour” (The Drummer Boy) rather than the comic “Alles mit Maß” (Everything in Moderation). Both of the latter poems are, in one summation, comic food-fantasies, but the drummer boy is a more complex creation, mingling pathos and humor, than the persona who undergoes a surfeit of roasted pigs’-feet in “Alles mit Maß” in order to preach a sermonette on moderation. In fact, most of the best poems of a length suitable for lieder became song texts in 1888, with certain significant exceptions (see chap. 2). One may mourn the lack of a Wolf setting of such poems as “Im Park” (In the Park) or “SeptemberMorgen” (September Morning), but that would be greedy, given what we have. Both the poetic and the musical anthologies are partially organized by thematic groupings, untitled and unacknowledged in both instances but nonetheless recognizable. Although the poet in 1837 had rejected the notion of subtitles for clusters of poems on similar subjects or of the same type, loosely defined groupings are discernible in all four editions of his anthology (poems on classical themes and in classical meters, a series of sonnets, a grouping of distich-epigrams, and a cluster of humorous poems at the close), and Wolf does likewise. His Mörike songs appeared at a time when larger song-collections were published in multiple Hefte, or little booklets with anywhere from two to six songs in each (Schubert’s Müller-cycles were published in this manner). Wolf evidently devoted considerable thought to the order in which his Mörike songs appeared in these Hefte, so that buyers would recognize a certain coherence operative in each one and would be enticed into acquiring the next in the series. For example, the entire volume begins with a dedicatory hymn of praise, “Der Genesene an die Hoffnung” (The Convalescent’s Address to Hope), which is perhaps an encoded – Wolf speaking through Mörike – announcement of the composer’s recovery from depression brought on by fears that he might never accomplish anything significant in Wagner’s wake. What follows this symbolically placed invocation to the gods is a series of four songs about Eros and separation, each in a different “voice” (a youth, a woman, a hunter, a drummer boy), and the nine Hefte which follow are likewise more or less organized in groups. In Wolf ’s schema, a particularly serious Heft is usually followed by a lightening of the musical landscape at the beginning of the next Heft, which then shades to greater and greater seriousness towards the end. Heft 3, for example, is a cluster of masterpieces having to do with the deepest matters of the soul, with death, withdrawal into oneself, memory, creativity, loss of love and impending loss of sanity (nos. 11–15, “An eine Äolsharfe,” “Verborgenheit,” “Im Frühling,” “Agnes,” “Auf einer Wanderung”), while Heft 4 is a fairy-tale grouping with elves at beginning and end (nos. 16–21, “Elfenlied” and “Auf 16
An introduction to Eduard Mörike and Hugo Wolf eine Christblume I & II”) and “Um Mitternacht” as its center of gravity. At the end of a Heft, Wolf would on occasion anticipate the major themes of the next grouping, as when the fourth set concludes with two religious songs which anticipate the songs in Heft 5 (nos. 22–26, “Seufzer,” “Auf ein altes Bild,” “In der Frühe,” “Schlafendes Jesuskind,” “Charwoche”), a central cluster which starts with a chromatic hell of failed belief and proceeds through calmer meditations on Christianity. Heft 6 (nos. 27–31), also dominated by religious themes, begins – in contrast to Heft 5 – with a song of joyous affirmation (“Zum neuen Jahr”), but doubt already intrudes in the second song, in which an attempt to pray breaks down, and then pervades the remainder of the Heft. The last two songs in the group tell of Eros and Caritas, the poetic persona despairing of human love but ecstatically aspiring to God’s love in “Neue Liebe,” despairing of both and without consolation in “Wo find’ ich Trost.” Ballads of the supernatural are grouped together in the ninth set (nos. 44–48, “Der Feuerreiter,” “Nixe Binsefuß,” “Gesang Weylas,” “Die Geister am Mummelsee,” and “Storchenbotschaft”), with a display-piece at the beginning, an intense “slow movement” in the middle, and a comic ballad at the end; “Storchenbotschaft” furthermore paves the way for the comic lieder of Heft 10 (nos. 49–53). Wolf took his cue from Mörike’s poetic anthology when he grouped the comic songs at the end, even concluding with the poet’s last word: “Abschied.” What poet or composer could resist kicking a fictive critic down the stairs before the real-life practitioners of praise and damnation could have their say? If in this brief introduction to the pairing of Wolf and Mörike, one alternates between emphasis on the distance and difference between the two artists and emphasis on Wolf ’s literary acuity, that is only appropriate to this subject. That Wolf revered Mörike is evident in his famous act of giving the poet pride of place on the title page of the first edition, that he had a sophisticated grasp of Mörike’s ambiguities is apparent in one compositional decision after another, but the nineteenth-century myth of perfect poetico-musical “union” is not to be found here. Mörike knew the myth; when he was asked to be adviser to a men’s chorus in 1850, he wrote to Hartlaub of the director’s desire for works in which “the text and melody live entirely in one another [ganz ineinander leben],” and one doubts he considered the ideal easily attainable, if at all.62 Wolf ’s version of the myth was more complicated. He believed that certain poems had to await a later musical idiom for successful musical setting; implicit in that belief is acknowledgment of discrepancies, of difference, but he also wanted to make audible as many levels of poetic meaning as he could grasp. The myth of “the sisterly arts” seems confirmed where words and music intersect, but where they diverge is perhaps the more interesting story.
17
Chapter 2
Peregrina revisited: songs of love and madness
This chapter is a demonstration-piece of sorts, a laboratory experiment designed to make a point to excess. Only two of Wolf ’s Mörike songs appear in these pages, a dyad-cycle or pair of songs entitled “Peregrina I & II,” but the background to both words and music could fill a book – in fact, the story behind the poetry has filled several. If those books are mostly historical fiction (the noun, as always, taking precedence over the adjective), that is because the documentary record of this incident in Mörike’s life is incomplete; what was left for the curious to investigate later is so startling, despite the gaps in the chronicle, that it invites, and has received, imagination’s embroidery in prose.1 The backdrop to Wolf ’s selection of only two poems from a cycle of five born of this episode and speculative reasons for certain compositional twists and turns in the songs have not been explored at all and are possibly bound up with the composer’s erotic history, very different from Mörike’s. Wolf periodically lamented that he was only a song composer – a guarantee of second-class citizenship in the nineteenth century – and desperately wanted to make a name for himself in the larger genres (opera first and foremost) which brought both greater public recognition and private sense of worth, but small things can and do contain worlds. Unpacking a mere five pages of music, one finds a series of ripples spreading outwards from the small artifact, waves of history, poetry, biography, mythology, politics, art, psychology, assassination, mysticism, and more. Wolf himself was enthralled when he discovered some of the biographical context after he had composed his songs – we know more than he did when he created this music. The backdrop to the songs is, like Everest, there and looms large, but has previously been parceled out to literary critics, without application to the music which issued from it. Mörike’s life and art were irrevocably altered by an event early in his life: his love affair in 1823–24 with a woman named Maria Meyer, an encounter which ranks in literary history with the youthful Goethe’s stay in Strasbourg in 1770–71 or Hölderlin’s arrival at the Gontard household in 1795. Until Easter of 1823 (an ironic time for a reluctant pastor-in-the-making to discover the woman who would be the cause of a death-andresurrection of sorts), he had been little more than a teenage Gelegenheitsdichter with a lively gift for fantasy, but in the wake of suffering we know in part from the rigor with which he banned all mention of it thereafter, he became something extraordinary. (Perhaps he would have become so anyway, but this we shall never know, and the massive presence of the Meyer-episode early in his history is undeniable.) Although he cast Maria 18
Songs of love and madness Meyer out of his life, the poetic veils wrapped around the wound in his soul could not obscure the lurking presence of actuality behind the poetry, his subsequent mythifying never free of flesh and blood. While “actuality” is Goethe’s influence and other factors as well as Maria Meyer, these works must also be understood as repeated attempts to “do something” with an insoluble dilemma. Mörike rewrote the cataclysm that was Maria Meyer over and over again without ever convincing himself that his actions were right, and in the most incandescent of the poems he judges himself guilty beyond reparation. These poems are a hall of mirrors, their untrustworthiness integral to the subject; they issue from a realm where nothing is certain, where one grapples in vain with love and betrayal. Only slippery symbols will do, and it is their very ambivalence which conveys the impression of ultimate truths. In July 1824, the volcanic middle of the crisis, Mörike wrote three poems in free verse: “Ein Irrsal kam in die Mondscheinsgärten” (A Madness Entered the Moonlit Gardens), or what finally became “Peregrina III;” “Aufgeschmückt ist der Freudensaal” (The Hall of Joy Is Bedecked), or what became “Peregrina II;” and “Im Freien” (In Nature). Significantly, “Im Freien,” its autobiographical elements closer to the surface than the other two poems, was never included in Mörike’s poetic anthologies, while the other more mythified poems were. Four years later, possibly in the first half of 1828 (the chronology is a matter of scholarly debate), he revised “Ein Irrsal kam” and “Aufgeschmückt ist der Freudensaal” and wrote three additional poems; it was perhaps at this time that he first thought to put them together as a cycle, ultimately a set of five poems entitled Peregrina, from the Latin peregrinus (vagabond, pilgrim).2 A version of the cycle with only four poems first appeared in Mörike’s Maler Nolten of 1832, a novel containing what Claudia Liebrand calls “the constitutive element of his life’s lie, to which he was thereafter bound”;3 here, Maria becomes “unbehauste Eros,” unhoused Passion, archaic, antique, undomesticated, the antithesis of every Biedermeier ideal. What this primeval power creates around her is a world where no categories are secure, the queasy mixture of Schicksalsroman, Künstlerroman, Schauerroman, and anti-Bildungsroman (novels about destiny, art, horror, and Bildung, or the great German pastime of self-improvement) that is Maler Nolten so filled with mirror images, shadow-plays, masks, Doppelgängers, veils, duplications, and magic lantern mimicry that the dizzied reader hardly knows who is who by story’s end. In this untelling of Wilhelm Meisters Lehrjahre, massive forces indeed press on the characters, as in Goethe, but not for their Bildung and betterment. These events happen in the courtyards of psychosis, and they are inimical to the patriarchal society which Goethe affirmed, societies where Mignons do not belong and must be killed. The Peregrina poems were thus not written for inclusion in Maler Nolten, but had their genesis earlier (in this, as in much else, Mörike reverses Goethe, who created Mignon, the Harper, and their songs expressly for his novel). In a Stuttgart manuscript of 1831 called the Grünes Heft4 (Green Notebook) containing the four poems published in Maler Nolten, “Peregrina III” (“Ein Irrsal kam”) is entitled “Abschied von Agnes” (Parting from Agnes) and the entire group is given the name Agnes, die Nonne (Agnes the Nun); what nuns have to do with it and why Peregrina and Agnes (another character in the novel) are fused/confused in this fashion will be explained in due course. The cycle appears in all four editions of his poetic anthology, each time with revisions that are uncannily appropriate because 19
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs they enact returning, and this saga is fraught with eerie acts of repetition. The fourth poem, or Wolf ’s “Peregrina II,” did not appear in the 1832 novel, although it had already come into being four years earlier, but it seems likely that Mörike intended to place all five poems in their final manifestations in his revision of the novel, a revision he never completed and perhaps never could have completed; he had lived his life from age twenty onwards in the shadow of a myth he himself had created and could not alter in old age. His friend Julius Klaiber, who lacked Mörike’s genius (a tactful understatement), finished the project after the poet’s death and included the whole Peregrina cycle, whose different poetic structures betray its creation-by-accretion over time. In the 1867 fourth edition, Mörike for the first time gives the cycle the subtitle “(Aus: Maler Nolten),” perhaps as a paradoxically truthful red herring; he wanted to distance these poems, born of the rawest event in his life, from biographical interpretation. But the formalist insistence that life and art have nothing to do with one another falls apart when applied to these works, however much Mörike himself wanted them understood as fictive. Other poems also printed in the novel, one notes, were not tagged in this manner in the anthology: the poet felt no similar need thus to misdirect readers. Hugo Wolf probably found the five Peregrina poems (and all the others he set to music) in the sixth edition and dutifully repeated Mörike’s parenthetical indication that the poems come from the earlier novel. Wolf did not, however, set all five poems to music, but omitted nos. II, III, and V, telling Melanie Köchert (1858–1906, the sister of Wolf ’s good friends Edmund and Marie Lang, wife of the Viennese jeweller Heinrich Köchert, and Wolf ’s mistress probably from summer 1884 on) two years later that he was unable to understand at least one of them (no. III) sufficiently for musical composition; one guesses that the incomprehension might also have extended in lesser degree to no. II, with which it is paired in imagery and content. He would not have found any elucidation in the scant secondary literature on Mörike extant in 1888, if he had even looked for such scholarly appendages to the poetry. Although one Hermann Fischer had published a tiny (forty-six-page) biography of the poet in 1881, there is no mention of Maria Meyer to be found – implicit testimony to discretion on the part of Mörike’s friends and to Mörike’s suppression throughout his life of virtually all mention of her.5 When Wolf did discover some of the background, however, it was from a source close to the original events. On a tour of Mörike country in 1890 with his new-found friend Emil Kauffmann, the son of Mörike’s friend Ernst Friedrich Kauffmann, Wolf heard the tale and regaled Melanie with a condensed version in a letter of 15 October 1890 from Stuttgart: On the way to Reutlingen today, Kauffmann gave me wonderful disclosures about Mörike’s love-affair with Peregrina. According to his account, she was named Maria Meyer and was found unconscious on the road to Ludwigsburg by a carter. Revived and taken to Ludwigsburg, Maria Meyer, who refused to say anything about her background or home, caused a great sensation with her marvelous beauty, especially her fascinating eyes. Mörike fell madly in love with her – he was then a student in Tübingen. They wrote each other burning love-letters; his beloved was highly cultivated, and her writing showed a particular resemblance to Jean Paul. The pair eventually considered themselves engaged. – One day Maria disappeared from Ludwigsburg without a trace. For a week, no one knew her whereabouts. Mörike was in despair, then came a notice from Carlsruhe that a certain M. M. had been arrested for unauthorized begging and prostitution. This news came to Kauffmann’s parents, who had sheltered M. M. for a while in their home. Mörike was informed of this and was beside himself. Then suddenly,
20
Songs of love and madness his lost love appeared early one morning on the steps of the house in which Mörike lived; although he still loved her, he cast her away from him, hence, “Ein Irrsal kam in die Mondscheinsgärten / Einer einst heiligen Liebe” (A madness entered the moonlit gardens of a once-sacred love). How much more I understand this poem now! Kauffmann showed me the house where Mörike lived then and so I saw the steps where Peregrina for the last time encountered the unfortunate poet. Isn’t that fascinating?6
In the wording of the phrase “The pair eventually considered themselves engaged” are hints of an affair without the formal machinery of betrothal and official permission. When he was told of Maria Meyer, Wolf, one notices, did not return to the three poems he had bypassed earlier; he had just begun the Italienisches Liederbuch songs in 1890, and the Mörike moment in his life was over. Had he heard this tale sooner, would we now have a larger musical cycle with all five poems? Possibly, but I doubt it. Wolf may have had additional reasons, hidden from conscious knowledge, for omitting those three poems. Wolf retained Mörike’s subtitle “(Aus: Maler Nolten),” and one wonders whether this indication of a larger context (and perhaps also Wolf ’s ravening desire for a librettosource) led him to read the book. If so, when? Before or after he composed the songs? If he did explore the novel, he would have found four of the five Peregrina poems near the end, when the title character Theobald Nolten – an artist unable to reconcile his art with what one scholar drily describes as “the imperatives of a disordered love-life”7 – discovers a group of poems with the collective title Peregrinens Vermählung mit * (Peregrina’s Wedding to *) among his actor friend Larkens’s papers after Larkens’s suicide. Reading them, Nolten realizes that his friend had spun a poetic fantasy of love and loss from Nolten’s obsession with the beautiful but psychotic gypsy Elisabeth (Maria Meyer in another mythic role). The ordering of the four poems is different from that of the cycle in Mörike’s anthologies, and the titles were later eliminated, replaced by stark Roman numerals stating the order and nothing else: Maler Nolten, 1832 Die Hochzeit (The Wedding) – “Aufgeschmückt ist der Freudensaal,” at first entitled “Agnesens Hochzeit” (Agnes’s Wedding) in the Green Notebook, later revised as “Peregrina II.” Only in the novel does Mörike add the footnoted indication “Im Munde des Bräutigams gedacht” (Conceived in the bridegroom’s voice). Warnung (Warning) – “Der Spiegel dieser treuen braunen Augen,” at first entitled “Agnes, die Nonne” (Agnes the Nun) – also the title of the entire small cycle – in the Green Notebook and later revised as “Peregrina I” Scheiden von ihr” (Parting from Her) – “Ein Irrsal kam in die Mondscheinsgärten,” originally entitled “Abschied von Agnes” (Parting from Agnes) in the Green Notebook and later revised as “Peregrina III” Und Wieder (And Again) – “Die treuste Liebe steht am Pfahl gebunden” (The truest love is bound to the stake), later revised as “Peregrina V” One can see from this list that Mörike at one time had Larkens fantasizing about Agnes, Nolten’s fiancée whom Larkens loves and Nolten does not, but altered the focus before publication. The oldest of the poems is no. III in the final ordering (“Ein Irrsal kam in die Mondscheinsgärten”); a stormy first sketch of this poem exists in a manuscript in Wilhelm 21
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Hartlaub’s handwriting dated 6 July 1824, and may have been the product of dictation – still more evidence, if the speculation is correct, of the close “Bruderschaft” that was the Mörike-Kreis.8 “Aufgeschmückt ist der Freudensaal” could also have been written that same terrible summer, in which he returned home after catastrophe only to have his beloved younger brother August commit suicide one month later. The sonnet “Und Wieder” (these words could be Mörike’s motto) in the 1832 novel was included in the manuscript collection Neue weltliche Lieder (New Secular Songs), dated 19 June 1828, under the title “Verzweifelte Liebe” (Despairing Love) and was first published separately in Cotta’s Morgenblatt für gebildete Stände (Morning Paper for the Cultured Classes) of 1829; it appears in the poetic anthologies as “Peregrina V.”9 Wolf ’s “Peregrina II,” or “Peregrina IV” in the final cycle of five poems, was only published for the first time in the 1838 first edition of Mörike’s anthology, although we know that it was written sometime before 2 May 1828 and was included in the Green Notebook containing the “Agnes”-cycle, or poems I–IV. Since I have already invoked Elisabeth as the Maria Meyer figure in Maler Nolten, a few introductory words about her are in order before we revert from fiction to the model in real life. As an impressionable adolescent, Nolten has a fateful encounter with Elisabeth, who turns out at the end to be the illegitimate daughter of Theobald’s uncle Friedrich and the gypsy Loskine: in other words, his cousin from the wrong side of the tracks. Theobald thus repeats his uncle’s erotic crisis of a generation earlier (echoes and Doppelgängertum once again), Mörike rewriting the revelation of Mignon’s incestuous parentage at the end of Wilhelm Meisters Lehrjahre. Despite the fact that Elisabeth is in part a literary trope, one of many paper gypsies who roam throughout nineteenth-century fiction, the analogies with Maria Meyer are unmistakable. Like Maria, Elisabeth disappears and reappears unexpectedly, asserting on her return a pathological bond born of mental illness; if she is untameable Eros whose power cannot be gainsaid, she is also pitiable, desperate, psychotic, and Mörike ensures that we see both faces. The actual and the fictional characters are each outcasts from bourgeois society, neither Maria the Swiss prostitute’s daughter nor Elisabeth the gypsy being stuff from which a middle-class Biedermeier pastor’s wife could be fashioned. Gypsies are venerable emblems of “the Other” in their rejection of conventions other than their own, and they are often depicted as sexually unconstrained – it was, we gather, for her promiscuity that Mörike rejected Maria.10 One notices, however, that there are no sexual transactions of any kind in the novel between Nolten and Elisabeth while they are alive, not even a kiss. Only after both have died are their ghosts seen locked in a despairing embrace, Mörike thus revising what we can infer was physical as well as psychological in his own experience. Ultimately, the actual woman and the literary figure seem most alike in their shadowiness, in the lack of any adumbration of an inner life. Elisabeth is a symbol of Eros, a principle, not a credible human being, and Maria had, as we shall discover, reason to hide her thoughts from her male “protectors.” O F G Y P S I E S, WA N D E R E R S, A N D P O E T S I N T H E I R YO U T H : T H E B I O G R A P H I CA L BAC K D RO P
There are blank spaces at the heart of the tale from its inception. Of the historical Maria Meyer, we know very little, and even that is reportage, much of it embroidered with the 22
Songs of love and madness kind of fictional garlands she both invented and inspired in others. There are no extant letters by her, only testimonials in writing to her cultivation, nor are there any portraits to tell us what she looked like, only encomiums to surpassing beauty. It is from her effect on others that we know her, and that incompletely. Maria’s penchant for fabricating glamorous but false life-histories for herself, her disappearance into obscurity after her youth was over, and Mörike’s silence all conspired to ensure that her background remained shadowy for many years. Shortly after World War I, a Swiss lawyer named Paul Corrodi, intrigued by the connection between Maria Meyer and nearby Schaffhausen, investigated the town archives and published his findings in order to correct misstatements on the part of Mörike’s biographers.11 The story begins in Schaffhausen with a master-butcher named Johann Georg Meyer (1749–1810) and his wife Anna Maria, born Ermatinger (1748–1812), whose third child of eleven was a daughter they named Helena, born 1 September 1777. Helena became a prostitute who bore at least three illegitimate children by three different men, the first child supposedly fathered by a tannery apprentice named Jakob Fried and born on 27 February 1802 – Mörike’s Peregrina.12 Although baptized “Anna Maria” after her grandmother, she later dropped the name “Anna” and was known simply as Maria Meyer. We know little about her childhood, but what we do know is dire. Her mother’s two other children were a son named Johann Georg Meyer, who later served in the Neapolitan army and died in 1834, and a girl named Anna Margaretha, who was raised in Merishausen at the city’s expense. From the records of the suit Helena brought against the third child’s father, it is evident that she was regarded as an infamous prostitute and a discredit to her family, although, given the paucity of possibilities for poor women in the early nineteenth century and our ignorance about her, she might well have been doubly victimized by her circumstances and by small-town Swiss disapproval. Finally, in 1834, she married a farmer named Konrad Weber and in 1852, emigrated with him to Brazil, where all trace of her was lost. Despite the efforts of a group of charitable Schaffhausen ladies and the sporadic intervention of relatives ill-disposed to care for a wayward woman’s bastard children, Helena’s first child Maria, we are told, early developed a taste for pilfering – perhaps motivated by need?13 Even in so sketchy an outline, it is not difficult to imagine why Maria would want to escape the stigmas surrounding her, to go elsewhere and to masquerade as someone else. The fact that she was extremely beautiful – it is always the first thing which those who knew her mention – made the fictions credible, at least for a brief interval, before darker pathologies intervened. In the summer of 1817, a notorious wandering mystic named Barbara Juliane von Vietinghoff, Freifrau von Krüdener, born in 1764 to a wealthy Livlander family and unhappily married for a time to a Russian diplomat, came to Schaffhausen with her band of followers, and Maria reportedly joined their number, although there is no documentary verification. Madame von Krüdener had been transformed under the influence of the south German chiliasts, especially Johann Heinrich Jung-Stilling, from a worldly member of the nobility into a religious mystic; her two-volume epistolary roman à clef entitled Valérie, translated from the original into German in 1804, tells her own tale in fictional guise.14 After the scandal of her divorce in 1796, she began a new life as an itinerant lay religious, preaching the renunciation of earthly goods and the impending end of the world 23
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs in one town after another; through her influence on Tsar Alexander I, she is said to have contributed to the formation of the Holy Alliance between Russia, Austria, and Prussia in 1815. She first came to Switzerland in the autumn of 1815 and attracted both a horde of followers and the attention of the law, which drove her band from one canton to another in rapid succession. On 12 July 1817, she and her disciples arrived in Schaffhausen after stays in Lucerne, Zurich, and Lottstetten, where the swarms of curiosity-seekers, beggars, vagrants, and pilgrims in search of miracle cures had earned her a police escort out of town. The Allgemeine schweizerische Korrespondent for 1817–18 was filled with excited warnings to the populace to resist her ravings and avoid her followers, the disapproving but titillated Swiss journalists describing her camp as a wandering bordello.15 Goethe echoed their opprobrium in his poetic squib “Von Krüdener. Jena, den 4. April 1818”: Von Krüdener Junge Huren, alte Nonnen Hatten sonst schon viel gewonnen, Wenn, von Pfaffen wohlberaten, Sie im Kloster Wunder taten. Jetzt geht’s über Land und Leute Durch Europens edle Weite! Hofgemäße Löwen schranzen, Affen, Hund und Bären tanzen – Neue leidge Zauberflöten – Hurenpack, zuletzt Propheten!
On the Krüdener Woman Young whores, old nuns have already gained much if, well-advised by their priests, they work wonders in the cloister. Now they go over lands and nations through noble Europe’s expanses! Royal courtly lions cringe, Apes, dogs, and bears dance: Modern miserable Magic Flutes – A pack of whores, now prophets!
Goethe’s distaste for mystics (he had earlier devised similar jabs at the self-proclaimed sorcerer Cagliostro) and his strain of misogyny aside, one can note more sympathetically that Juliane von Krüdener sought ways to make the life of the emotions accord with life in the real world where women such as herself, unable to find love in marriage, were subjected to moral umbrage. No wonder Maria Meyer found her message attractive. When Madame Krüdener was forced to leave Schaffhausen on 25 July, it is possible that Maria Meyer joined the Krüdener disciples on further peregrinations to Dießenhofen, Randegg, Radolfszell, the southern banks of the Bodensee, and, on 4 October, AltBreisach. It was perhaps there that Maria left the followers of the “Sonnenfrau” (SunWoman), as Madame Krüdener was dubbed by her believers, since it is known that Maria had returned to Schaffhausen by the end of November 1817.16 By that time, according to her own account, she had fallen in love with Carl Ludwig Sand (1795–1820), who was shortly thereafter to murder the playwright and statesman August von Kotzebue on 23 March 1819, thereby providing Metternich with his rationale for the Karlsbad Decrees, for the suppression of intellectual freedom at universities and elsewhere. Sand left his home in Wunsiedel, Bavaria for Eisenach in order to take part in the Wartburgfest of 18 October 1817 which he had helped to organize, so it is conceivable that he and Maria could have met.17 But was this reality or the fabrication of someone attempting to sensationalize her life? No Maria Meyer, or anyone recognizable as her, appears in the chronicles of Sand’s last years, and she could, as Mörike discovered to his cost, lie. When Maria returned to Schaffhausen after the Krüdener episode, she was consigned to the work-house in the Frauenkloster St. Agnes, where female correctional prisoners 24
Songs of love and madness were kept occupied with knitting and spinning (her mother had been confined to the same institution for two years). This is perhaps one source for her later story that she had been a nun unjustly imprisoned by her family in a Hungarian [!] cloister, although the Swiss work-house was not a Catholic institution but a charity of the Reformed church. What, one wonders, had she been reading? This is not the only time in the chronicle of Maria Meyer that one suspects her of borrowing from works such as Johann Martin Miller’s Siegwart, Eine Klostergeschichte, which influenced Mörike as well; women sequestered against their will in nunneries were a staple of popular fiction in the Enlightenment. At the Frauenkloster, Maria reached age sixteen and was confirmed on Easter Day 1819. Impressed, like so many, by her beauty, her religious instructor Melchior Kirchhofer helped her to obtain release from the work-house on 20 April 1819, and she then left Schaffhausen yet again.18 It seems likely that Maria next went to Rheinfelden im Aargau, where she was taken in by the Münch family. The son of the household, Ernst Hermann Joseph Münch (1798–1841), had recently returned home from the university at Freiburg im Breisgau, where he had studied law at his father’s wish, despite his inclinations to poetry and history (he was a copious practicioner of both in adulthood). His poems have since fallen into the oblivion they deserve but his Erinnerungen, Lebensbilder und Studien aus den ersten sieben und dreißig Jahren eines teutschen Gelehrten (Reminiscences, Portraits from Life, and Essays from the First Thirty-seven Years of a Swiss Intellectual) of 1836 makes lively reading, in particular, his account of Maria’s stay in his father’s household.19 After marvelling at her beauty, he relates that she called herself “Minette” – again, one thinks of bad novels – and fabricated an early history compounded of fact (minimal) and fiction (highly colored) in a manner as moving as it is dishonest. Those who have had wretched childhoods often imagine an upbringing they would have liked but never had, and dramatize their real travails in order to garner sympathy. Maria no doubt had to give some sort of account to the Münch household of her solitary, penniless, unprotected state – according to her, she was the daughter of wealthy parents from “S.” who took great pains with her upbringing and were proud of the results of their care until 1817 or 1818, when a love affair and mysticism à la Krüdener overturned her soul. After her relatives fought fiercely to win her away (how sad that she thus invented caring parents), they cursed her and cast her out forever.20 For all the rodomontade, one can recognize a core of truth in the account. Being cast out may well have been reality and would become so again, each subsequent repudiation possibly an echo of parental rejection. “Minette’s” obsession with Sand, whom she described as the ideal of Germanic manhood and Christian virtue (she was not the only one to think so), was particularly acute at the time of her stay in the Münch household. After Sand’s execution, Maria read, so she told Münch, everything she could find about her hero and was convinced that he was her guardian angel, that his spirit attended her everywhere she went. When she learned that Münch was among Sand’s “friends,” that is, those sympathetic to his political ideals, she drew from her bosom a medallion of Sand with his image, a lock of his hair, and several of his sayings and kissed it repeatedly. Later, Münch relates, when he read her some of his patriotic poems and told her the legends of Charlemagne, she threw herself into his arms, covered him with fiery kisses, and declared him worthy to 25
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs be an adherent of “the Enlightened One.” “Naturally, I was quite glad to let this happen,” writes Münch.21 Maria told Münch that she had been forced to leave the Krüdener troupe, why or how she did not say. When she begged her parents to take her back, they would only do so, she said, if she served as a maidservant for three years and could produce testimonials to her industry and good behavior. However, she was too beautiful “not to entice lustful impulses,” writes Münch, and Maria told him that she had even leapt from windows to escape importunities. Recognizing that her tale was in part a nonsensical farrago, Münch describes her as a “rare mish-mash of truth and irrationality, light and dark, sensuality and morality”; she would kiss him passionately, throw herself into his arms, and say “with a moving naiveté,” “See, I am your maid; command, lord, what you will! But honor your sister, whom God has sent you, as a brother. Perhaps I shall proclaim your works when the time comes that the reaper calls and the sheaves are brought to the threshing floor,” the Krüdener influence possibly responsible for the Biblical turns of phrase. Münch treats the tale as Frenchified farce, a bit of luck come his way, and he records disturbing behavior without taking it seriously as evidence of mental distress. When Münch was reading or working, she would stretch out next to him or sit in his lap, staring at him blankly before bursting into laughter; she would stuff his pipe with a mixture of tobacco and flowers; and she would lapse into melancholy for entire days and sing “highly confused” mystical songs.22 As long as she was willing to regale him with “fiery kisses,” however, he could, and did, dismiss her actions as inconsequential. On one occasion, he tells of coming downstairs during a summer thunderstorm and finding her half-clad, singing mad songs, and flagellating herself while lightning-bolts and thunder raged outside; with lip-smacking pleasure, he dwells on the color contrast of disordered raven-black hair, white skin, and purple lash-marks. (Corrodi felt that Münch might have been influenced in this description by Karl Ludwig von Woltmann’s Memoiren des Freiherrn von S—a of 1815–16, which Münch himself cites in the account – still more of the intertwining of life and literature which pervades this episode.23) The scent of the flowers in the room and the hypnotic effect of the lightning flashes was such that Maria claimed to see the heavens open and Christ and the Virgin looking at her; she had, Münch writes, previously worked herself into such an ecstasy when reading the works of the French mystic Madame Guyon (Jeanne Marie Bouvier de La Motte, 1648–1717) and St. Theresa that she heard heavenly flutes and harps. In her vision during the storm, she found herself, so she said, on a mountain peak, the horizon stretching out endlessly, the planets and stars swaying through the clouds, through which she saw God and Christ together.24 But Münch, however willing to take advantage of her beauty for his own pleasure, was not in love with her. When he accepted a position as professor of history in Aarau, he did not take her with him as a chambermaid, despite her entreaties; he was too practical for continued exposure to such high drama, and he was engaged to someone more comme il faut. The account he gives of Maria in his Erinnerungen is frivolous in tone, with an unpleasant substratum of mockery and disdain. She was not of his social class, and he did not really care what became of her, beyond his use of her to sell books years after her departure from his life. His reminiscences are an even more fictionalized working-up of material he recognized as already semi-fictive, and there is not a trace of the passion she aroused in Mörike. 26
Songs of love and madness After Maria’s departure from Rheinfelden, one loses sight of her until the end of 1820, when she had an attack of – convulsions? a nervous breakdown? a fainting-fit from hunger? in a church in Berne. Corrodi conjectures epilepsy, but there seems to be little corroborating evidence. Perhaps illness brought on by destitution was the explanation, although it is also possible that she staged such scenes in order to attract help. She knew how to embody various roles from popular fiction – gypsy, wanderer, mystic, practitioner of animal magnetism, nun, soothsayer – and her bizarre behavior made it impossible to know who she really was and what she thought and felt. After being tended for a time by a women’s charitable society, they rejected her for what they considered craziness, and she was sent home to Schaffhausen in early 1821. After several months in the work-house, she was granted permission on 14 May 1821 to take a cure at Baden, from which she then escaped Schaffhausen’s control yet again.25 What she did for two years thereafter, no one knows. We next hear of her at Eastertime 1823 in Ludwigsburg – it was there she met Mörike. Mörike later destroyed his and Maria’s letters to one another, so accounts of the matter must be drawn from a scant cache of letters by his older sister Luise (1798–1827) and his close friends Rudolf Lohbauer, Ludwig Bauer, and Rudolf Flad (1804–30), as well as Luise Mörike’s diary and a few letters by Mörike himself to friends and family. It is evident from the record that sexual tensions in the entire group were running high: Bauer was also infatuated with Maria, while Lohbauer was initially attracted both to her and to Luise Mörike before embarking on a literally fiery affair with a young Jewish woman named Julie Michaelis – he burned down their house in late 1823 – at almost the same time as Mörike’s Maria Meyer ordeal, although the latter scandal stayed out of the newspapers and the former did not. But if there was free-flowing sexual tension aplenty, there was also a formidable opponent of passion in Luise Mörike, a woman whose repression and religiosity were more than equal to the task of quashing her brother’s errant inclinations. One anecdote is indicative: in February 1840, Lohbauer told his bride-to-be about an episode earlier in his life in which he lost control, seized Luise, and covered her face with kisses. She endured his impetuosity in stony silence, he wrote, after which, chilled, he no longer pursued her (how his fiancée felt about this confession is not known).26 Certainly Lohbauer’s behavior was condemnable, but Luise’s icy control makes unpleasant reading as well. When Mörike first encountered Maria, he was on vacation in Ludwigsburg, where he was visiting childhood friends, from his theological studies in Tübingen. At the inn Zum Holländer at 13 Bauhofstrasse owned by a brewer named Wilhelm Mergenthaler, they encountered a serving girl – Maria – whom the innkeeper had found unconscious on the road between Stuttgart and Ludwigsburg; again, one wonders whether the repeated scenario was staged or was the product of recurring episodes of poverty and hunger. Mergenthaler knew that she would attract customers to his inn with her beauty, and he was right, all the more so because she seemed so well educated (how and where did this happen?) and could discuss the works of Goethe and Jean Paul with the university students who fell in love with her. Again, she lied about her background, hinting that she came from Austria or Hungary – Münch had told her tales of his travels in Austria, and it is possible that he provided the source for yet another fictional history – and that she had 27
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs fled her home because her parents had wished to make her a nun against her will. Lohbauer recognized her accent as Swiss and realized that her story was in part a fabrication, but this did not hinder him or his comrades from seeing her as a Mignon-figure, a mysterious wanderer driven from her native climes and forced to eat bitter bread among strangers. Six months before the encounter with Maria Meyer, Mörike had written to Hartlaub on 19 September 1822, saying, “I have also thought of you, and more than once. And, oddly enough, for a long time of Mignon. She has never stood so movingly before me. Her song continually runs through my mind,”27 which song, he does not say. He had been looking for his own Mignon, and now he had found her. Lohbauer begged his mother, the widow of the patriotic poet Karl Philipp Lohbauer, to take in the beautiful stranger with whom he had fallen in love. So had Mörike, for whom the experience was overwhelming (his teenage love for his cousin Klärchen Neuffer, over by the end of 1821, was of another order).28 Whenever he sought thereafter to describe Maria’s effect on him, as in the sonnet “An die Geliebte” (To the Beloved) or in Maler Nolten, it was in images of a dizzying fall into cosmic depths, all the way down to the earth’s heart and the beginning of time. In the inset-tale “Ein Tag aus Noltens Jugendleben” (A Day from Nolten’s Youth) in Maler Nolten, Larkens imagines a dialogue between Elisabeth and Nolten – another instance of the Larkens/Nolten Doppelgängertum, of Larkens living vicariously through Nolten – in which “Nolten” says: when I saw you, it was as if I sank deep within myself, as if in an abyss, as if I fainted, falling from deep to deep, through all the nights where I have seen you in a hundred dreams, just as you stand before me now. I flew down into a vortex through all the stages of my life and saw myself as a boy and as a child, near your form, as you are now again risen before me. Yes, I came right to the darkness where my cradle stood and saw you draw back the veil that covered me: then I lost consciousness, I have perhaps slept for a long time, but as if my eyes opened by themselves, I looked into yours as in an endless well in which lay the riddle of my life.29
“As if,” “as if ” – over and over, Mörike reaches for analogies and tells of their inadequacy. This passage epitomizes Mörike’s conception of passion as, paradoxically, both a dizzying confounding of the self and an instrument of self-recognition. The hope was that love would lead to revelation of “the riddle” within the abyss of self, but in order for that hope to succeed, the sibylline mirror/woman had to remain fixed in place so that the lover’s projections did not waver or shatter. For reasons implicated in the riddle of his life, Mörike fell in love with someone whose precarious sense of self made that impossible. At the end of the Easter vacation, Mörike returned to Tübingen and began exchanging letters with Maria, who remained in Ludwigsburg. Luise Mörike in Stuttgart heard unsettling reports of Maria’s behavior and wrote her brother a strongly worded letter in April 1823, warning him against both Lohbauer and Maria. Luise could smell a rat, could sense that being and seeming were two different quantities in Maria, and worried, with reason, about her brother’s well-being, but the lecture she delivers about proper female comportment might well give the present-day reader a chill. Women, she admonishes, should conform to an ideal of “sweet modesty” and “quiet holiness”; Maria’s extravagant, mystical performances were not what Luise considered to be true religion. “Good” women, in her definition, were all alike (the Stepford wives come to mind); external differences were permitted, like ornamentation on a dress pattern, but the pattern itself should not change. 28
Songs of love and madness In her catalogue of the traits one should expect from the eponymous good woman, Luise juxtaposes the words “womanly” and “childlike” – women should maintain a child’s lack of knowledge about sex – in a manner particularly notable because her brother would later portray a woman (Agnes in Maler Nolten) made mad by this contradiction: I cannot yet wholly see through Maria. Apart from those who speak ill of her, her entire being appears to me in a mysterious, dark, I can almost say, in an ambiguous light. What I know of her from R[udolf Lohbauer]’s writing and from you yourself is not enough for me. I must see and observe her myself, in order to evaluate her. In the meantime, my opinion of her must remain the same. Everyone has his own manner by which he is differentiated from all others, even if the fundamental character traits are the same, but these traits must be recognized in their outward manifestations, and a sweet modesty is innate to the truly pious, womanly, childlike soul. Beneath these light veils lies hidden the godly heart . . . only God’s Eye can discern the quiet holiness. Enough – until she herself can allay my doubts, I cannot deem her to be truthful. But I will not trouble you any longer with what my natural feelings say against her. Always heed the high ideals of purity and duty that lend a mighty power to your soul, that can bear it swiftly to heaven! Preserve the image of virtue that is alive within you . . . If she is truly what she appears to be, then she will not forsake God and will untangle the muddled strands of her unfortunate destiny. Then she will forgive me the injustice that comes from concern for a beloved brother’s peace.30
The nineteenth-century critic Friedrich Notter who complained that the gypsy Elisabeth lacked “womanly sweetness” and “moral graces” could have been quoting Luise Mörike on Maria Meyer. 31 For Luise, this was war: in her diary for December 1823, she speaks of the battle waged since “that unfortunate Easter holiday,” and she feared losing the battle. “I saw with unending sorrow how strongly Eduard still believes in his destroyer [Verderber], saw the magic that still binds him so strongly, and the enchanter that seeks to win him, to deceive him – and to destroy him.”32 She need not have feared, as Maria herself would soon put the necessary weapons for conquest in Luise’s hands. Amidst the concatenation of unknowns is the exact time of Maria’s flight from Ludwigsburg, perhaps in late 1823. She went to Heidelberg, where she was again found senseless by the side of the road and was arrested as a vagrant. After appealing to the Mörike circle for help in obtaining her release, the familiar roundelay began all over again: first, she enchanted all and sundry, and then her errant behavior alienated everyone. The landscape painter Christian Philipp Köster (1784–1851), whom Goethe admired – Gottfried Keller describes Köster as dwarfishly short, a mere three-and-a-half feet tall – fell briefly under her spell, but disillusionment set in quickly.33 In a letter of 21 February 1824, Köster wrote to Mörike that Maria had behaved so badly that she would probably have to leave the city soon; she had already, he continued, lost some of her former admirers, and the ground was beginning to quake beneath her feet. Maria had chattered to him of “Eduard and Rudolf and Rudolf and Eduard,” and Köster had even been shown Mörike’s letters, such that he could recognize “your brief happiness and sorrowful dissolution.” In an act of commendable sensitivity, Köster tells Mörike that he [Köster] has taken pains to ensure that Mörike’s letters to her would not be “more widely profaned” (“nicht weiter profanisiert würden”), that is, shown to still other people. Köster was forty years old when he met Maria, twice Mörike’s age, and maturity gave him readier access to an antidote for her poison (his words) than the dazed young poet. “My God, what a creature she is! – as beautiful as her Creator on the outside, but chaos on the inside!”, 29
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Köster wrote in what is surely the single most memorable capsule characterization of Maria Meyer.34 Maria wrote to Mörike from Heidelberg, but he did not answer her, as he told Luise in a letter from Tübingen on 26 January 1824. Reassuring his sister that the matter was over, he wrote, “Why should I not have confided in you regarding Maria? You seemed after your last letter half to doubt it. But I didn’t answer her . . . Her life, this much is certain, has ceased to invade my own any further, except as a dream I had, one which was very useful to me” [italics Mörike’s].35 The words “very useful” seem a two-edged sword, the adjective redolent of pained sarcasm. For his sister, “usefulness” would surely mean lessons about vicarage-worthy womanhood rather than beautiful, unstable vagabonds, while for him, it probably meant poetry and the bitter knowledge of Eros’s treachery. Is there perhaps also implicit in the phrase “a dream I had” recognition that he had projected a poetic ideal upon a reality which turned out to be very different? Köster was right: having worn out her welcome, Maria left Heidelberg sometime in the spring of 1824. She might have gone next to Freiburg im Breisgau in May to find Ernst Münch and implore his protection; reports of a beautiful woman who was looking for him and who had fallen senseless in various town squares preceded her appearance on his doorstep. When she poured out the story of her latest tribulations and begged him to help her, Münch was on the horns of a dilemma: his wedding was planned for early July in Aarau. What would his bride think? He put Maria up temporarily at an inn, but the press of young men who came to gawk at the beautiful stranger and listen to her mystical ramblings was too much for the respectable housewife who ran the guest-house. After being sharply reproved, Maria vanished once more and went to Tübingen, where again, she was found unconscious in a public place. Although she once more sought and found those who would help her, reports of her previous escapades in Heidelberg and Ludwigsburg made the rounds, and she soon became persona non grata. Eventually, a Dr. Gmelin (who said that he would have taken her into his home, but his wife would not stand for it) and others raised the money to send her back to Schaffhausen in August 1824. It should surprise no one that she did not remain there. Few letters by Mörike himself and none by Maria survived the poet’s subsequent holocaust of documents pertaining to her, but one can detect in the extant sources the echoes of an auxiliary crisis between Mörike and Ludwig Bauer and the pained solicitude of his close circle of friends. Maria had evidently sought out Eduard on 10 July, and he had escorted her to a woman who took her in. Mörike, however, refused to have her back. The last paragraph of a brief, undated letter to Hartlaub hints at a decision of some sort, presumably to repudiate Maria, and wild pain at the prospect. “I cannot now put off any longer going to a certain known place,” Mörike told Hartlaub, “but promise me truly that you will not ask me the reason why, that you will not take me for a bad person, and that . . . you will not misinterpret what I do alone.”36 Bauer, who one remembers was also infatuated with Maria, wrote Eduard a letter, undated but surely from 1824, in which he sympathizes with Mörike (“You have lost your goddess, and your heart bleeds”), but reproaches his friend for lack of compassion, for not even giving Maria “a few words on an album-leaf.”37 Out of consideration for his friend’s sorrow, however, Bauer assured Eduard that he would not write further of Maria and did so thereafter only to convey tidbits of factual information. 30
Songs of love and madness Fearful lest he lose his best friend, Bauer had gone to Mörike and begged him to tear down the wall between them; Mörike, moved by the plea, confided his sorrow to Bauer, who promptly turned around and told Luise of the incident in a dramatic letter – the prose is a deep shade of purple – written on 10 July (the same day as Mörike’s penultimate encounter with Maria that year). In Maria, Mörike told Bauer, he had first found, then lost, the mystery of his life, the waking dream of his soul. Deprived of her, he was like “an ocean without waves, reflecting without choice everything equally, heaven and earth, the elevated and the lowly”: Maria, his wandering “I,” knocked again at his heart, abandoned, sick, given over to strangers, without defence, without support, only able to perceive the more beautiful, ethereal side of herself through his eyes. Affected by the wayward spirit of the homeless one, moved to his inmost self, he had either to enter the mysterious creature’s realm or to adhere to feelings already stirred into being earlier . . . with new determination, he drew away from the emotional vortex of that secret dwelling place. So it came that he cried out to me, “I must go home!” and that I so resolutely affirmed, “Yes, you must!”38
In her diary for that same day, Luise states that another letter from her brother had arrived on the heels of a prior missive, the most recent letter written “in a violently painful, almost pathological state of mind” in which he spoke only of his fervent desire to flee Maria.39 Two days later, on 12 July, she received Bauer’s letter and noted that Eduard was indeed coming home, that he was physically ill with grief. On 16 July, he fled home to Stuttgart, accompanied by Bauer and Mährlen, and on 31 July, wrote the royal Konsistorium to ask for four weeks’ leave from his studies, a leave extended for another month in the wake of his brother August’s mysterious death, probably a suicide by poison.40 Bauer had assured Mörike that Maria would “leave us in peace,” but in a letter of 11 August, he wrote to his friend, saying, “With regard to Maria, no one knows anything certain. I saw her once, in all likelihood, go by Bengel’s house at midday, a little summer hat on her head and halfblinking before the unclouded sun”41 (one notes the lingering traces of Bauer’s infatuation and the “literary” tone of the description). Bauer’s next letter on 23 August, mourning August’s death, ends with a brief postscript to say that Maria had left for Schaffhausen the preceding Thursday, in effect, that it was safe for his friend to return to Tübingen.42 From this laconic reference, we infer that Mörike knew Maria’s origins. Luise had won the war, but its effects on her brother frightened her. In her diary for 24 July 1824, one week after Eduard’s return, she wrote at length recounting what she knew of the end of the Maria story – of all the documentary sources, this is one of the most interesting. To give her credit, Luise expresses a modicum of pity for Maria, calling her “Die Arme Ruhe- und Heimatlose!” and writes, “I am often very angry at her, and yet I am sorry for her weakness,” but this is the magnanimity of the victor and therefore qualified, as Luise herself admitted. Maria still retained her “heavenly pure and spotless” image in Eduard’s heart, Luise continues, but only as a shadow of her former radiance. The students at the Stift, whom Luise considered overly susceptible, were kept away from Maria; only Flad saw her, and – once more – Eduard. Of that occasion, Mörike told Luise very little, and she did not press him for particulars, worried as she was about his state of mind. Although he did not wish his family to be troubled and assented willingly to everything they wanted, Luise was not fooled and wrote that a lengthy cure would be necessary.43 Physicians, medicinal 31
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs waters, healing baths, and solicitude were all pressed into service, to little or no effect, until the fresh grief of August’s death took precedence over the aftermath of Maria’s loss. A final measure of Maria’s powers comes from Luise’s diary for 12 August, in which she writes that “The innocent sufferer is now become the beautiful penitent in public,” her vengeful satisfaction evident. The entry continues with Luise’s account of letters just received from Rudolf Flad, a member of the Mörike circle especially favored by Luise for his piety. Flad told Luise – who never saw Maria – that anyone must feel “Amor’s sting” on seeing such a beautiful creature: It seemed to him [Flad] . . . that her eyes [were] holy, pious, but curiously threatening, fixed on him in a dream so that he almost wanted to see her as a creature of darkness, tempting him. He now takes pains to imagine her in fantasy as a hateful hag and will only, like Christ, do for her what he can . . . in a fine turn of events, he also contacted Eduard and condemned the notion which she expressed in one of her letters that Eduard had left her because he [Mörike] had shamed her. He [Flad] reproved her that she should set herself in any particular bond with Eduard and was inclined to lay such worth on her own person. Maria, it appears to me, needs more lies to bind young hearts to her than they all believe. She is too foolish and too feeble to deprive her vanity of this nourishment, and so I believe she will never come to the right road, if time or misfortune does not snatch away from her the magic wand with which she knows so powerfully how to dazzle and confuse them.44
“Because he had shamed her” [“weil er sich ihrer geschämt habe”] . . . “geschämt” has a clear sexual connotation. Luise, one guesses, used Flad in order to deny to herself the possibility of a sexual relationship between Maria and Eduard, but one can infer that her brother and the beautiful Swiss vagrant were lovers in the physical sense of the word. If so, Maria would have had some justification for her reproaches to Eduard, despite her errant behavior, while Flad’s accusation that she was a liar seems doubly unfair. None of those at the heart of this episode emerged unbesmirched, without cause for guilt. Another revelatory document is a distraught letter Mörike wrote to Wilhelm Waiblinger on 13 or 14 August 1824. Mörike attempted to spare his family, especially his beloved brother August, at least some of his misery,45 but the common bond of erotic travail possibly led him to confide in Waiblinger.46 At the beginning, Mörike tells of opening the windows in order to see the fresh rain dripping from the tree branches, but the attempt to find consolation in Nature fails. Mörike does not once refer to Maria by name, but she is clearly the subject of the following passage: The child of whom I spoke to you before would look you lovingly in the eyes, and you perhaps asked yourself softly, Is this then my past or my future? Or you might have thought: what if you had not just had a dream in which all beautiful things dissolved in fire and smoke, and what was in part lost to you, in part sunk down next to you in the ruins, was gone and if only the child could come forth out of the dream into reality, embodied – nothing of what you dreamed of her, so lifelike and filled with love, can or should be left to you . . . from her eyes . . . where only silence and peace and clarity dwell, you would see in the farthest depths the tapestry of a second dream gaze forth, a wonderful, secret transformation back to a time already past!47
That Waiblinger might understand how the lovers were separated, Mörike tells of a dream in which he and his sister Luise entered a pleasingly furnished room. Mörike was enraptured by its charm, but on seeing Luise’s disapproving face, he could not remain any longer. Although he hastens to say that his sister is one of the few people capable of con32
Songs of love and madness verting his customary mixture of “Lust” and “Unlust” into gentler (more properly repressed?) states, it is the image of her silently hostile face and the beautiful room (a female symbol – one thinks of the word “Frauenzimmer”) which linger.48 Even in the midst of the summer 1824 crisis, Maria was already en route to her ultimate transformation into art, and the near-incoherent distress of the letter to Waiblinger was soon distilled into controlled poetry. Mörike’s first poem in free verse, “Im Freien” (In the Open), probably written on 10 July 1824 and published posthumously, tells of a poetic persona who flees to Nature in search of consolation, much like the Natureingang of the letter to Waiblinger, but cannot find surcease from memories of an “unholy love”: Im Freien (stanza 3, lines 21–28) Oder bin ich dir gestorben, Du unsterblicher Geist der Natur? Konnte die weichliche Pein Jener unseligen Liebe Dich mir auf ewig entfremden? Und so verzweifl’ ich jetzt, Weil ich mein Herzblut gab Für einen Schatten?
In the Open Or have I died to you, thou immortal spirit of Nature? Can the soft pain of this unholy love forever alienate me from you? And so I now despair because I gave my heart’s blood for a shadow?
Bauer too was inspired to verse, if not to poetry, by Maria’s departure. His poem “Geheimniß. An E. M. (Nach derselbe seinem Freunde ein merkwürdiges Lebensereigniß anvertraut hatte),” or “Secret. To E[duard] M[örike] (After he confided a noteworthy experience in life to his friend)” is drivel, but nonetheless it documents the effect Maria had on the young artists of the Neckar valley, who made her into a Muse and turned her into words. Given her name, it was perhaps only to be expected that a lesser talent would echo Novalis’s Hymnen an die Nacht at a lower level of creative imagination: Geheimniß. An E. M. (stanzas 1, 3, and 8 of 8) “Zur der des Himmels Glorie sich neigte, Die an die Brust das Götterkind gedrückt, O Du, Maria, hohe, schmerzgebeugte,
Secret. To E. M.
“To one for whom heaven’s glory bows down, who pressed the Child of God to her breast, O thou, Mary on high, bowed down with sorrow, Die Du am Kreuz den Blutenden erblickt! as you saw the bleeding one on the cross! Vor allen Müttern Du so hochbeglückte, Before all mothers thou so highly fortunate, Du Unglückseligste, Du fern Entrückte – thou the most afflicted, thou carried away into O könnt’ ich doch in einem Bilde fassen the distance, O if I could capture in one image Die Gottheit und Dein menschliches Erblassen!” the Godhead and your mortal pallor!” .......... ......... “Ach, daß Du einmal nur sie könntest schauen, “Ah, if you could see her just once, Wenn mit gesenktem Haupt sie schmerzlich lacht! when she sadly laughs with bowed head! Säh’st ihren Blick mit zauberhaftem Grauen, If you had seen her gaze with bewitched terror, Den goldnen Ring in ihres Auges Nacht! the golden ring in the night of her eyes! Hörtest die Melodie der Sprache klingen, If you had heard the melody sounding in her Die Schweizerlaute, die zum Herzen dringen! speech, the Swiss sonority that pierces the heart! Säh’st Du die Sonne, die ein Flor getrübet, If you had seen the sun that saddened the Die heil’ge Sünderin, die ich geliebet! blossoms – the holy sinner that I loved! ....... .......
33
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Das Wunder, dem die Scheiterhaufen rauchen, Sink’ es nur tief in’s Fluthenbad der Zeit! Du siehst es wieder zu Dir aufwärts tauchen Und perlen von dem Thau der Ewigkeit. O dieser Stunde laß uns nie vergessen! Du maßest Dich, und hast die Welt gemessen: O Eduard, nun bist Du ganz der Meine, Du liebest mich, ich liebe all’ das Deine!49
The wonder, which smokes upon the funeral pyre, sink it deep in the floodwaters of time! You see it rise upwards again to you and sparkle with the dew of eternity. O let us never forget this time! you measured yourself and have gauged the world: O Eduard, now you are entirely mine: You love me, I love all that is yours!
Bauer’s juxtaposition of “sinner – woman” may be a theological commonplace of the time, but it is an infuriating one, and distaste for such schlock-versifying is heightened by Bauer’s trumpetings of triumph that Maria was no longer a rival for Mörike’s affections, that Bauer once again had his friend to himself. Their bond was even strengthened, so Bauer thought, because they had shared this secret. Mörike would repeat that same word “secret” as the most oblique of references to Maria in his poem “Nachklang” (Echo) addressed to Luise and probably written in 1826 – before or after 25 April 1826 when Maria returned to Tübingen and begged Mörike in writing to come to the inn where she was staying? He did not respond, so we learn from Ernst Friedrich Kauffmann in a letter to his fiancée Marie Lohbauer. If only he could take “this undeserved sorrow,” Mörike writes in “Nachklang,” and bury it within her [Luise’s] soul, so that she could pronounce a blessing over it, he might then have peace. Is it too fanciful to detect a trace of vengefulness in the poem? Was he hinting, “You caused this . . . you fix it”?50 But Luise died of tuberculosis the following year, and no such appeasement was possible. In the years after Mörike’s rejection of Maria and her departure, Ernst Münch claimed to have had another encounter with her and included the tale in his second volume of reminiscences, the Erinnerungen, Reisebilder, Phantasiegemälde und Fastenpredigten aus den Jahren 1828 bis 1840 (Reminiscences, Travel Images, Fantastic Paintings, and Lenten Sermons from the years 1828 to 1840) published in 1841 before Münch’s sudden death on 9 June of that year.51 According to this patently romanticized story, Münch in 1830 or thereabouts saw a painting of a gypsy, clad in gaudy raiment, with a heavy garnet necklace around her neck and a turban wound about her head.52 Various passions – sorrow, frivolity, melancholy, sentimentality, and impetuosity – were, he writes, stamped on her face, and skin originally fine and white was burnt by long wandering. All of a sudden, a woman whispered in his ear, “Do you recognize her still?”, a woman who bore a striking resemblance to the painting and who stared at him with huge black eyes, then heaved a deep sigh, pressed his hand, and disappeared into the crowd. That night, in the garden of the guesthouse, a group of musicians began to entertain the company, including a singer whose outline he could only dimly discern and who sang “a curious song” for the assembled company: (stanzas 1–2, 4–6 of 7) Ich war ein armes, junges Blut, Da stieß man mich in die Welt, Und niemand hatte auf mich Hut, Da wechselt’ ich zwischen Frost und Glut, Das Herz von Lieb’ geschwellt.
I was a poor, young creature who was cast forth into the world, and no one paid heed to me. So I alternated between frost and fire, my heart swelled with love.
Wär’ mir geblieben der Liebste treu, So stünd ich wohl nimmer allein;
Had my beloved remained true to me, then I would never have stayed alone;
34
Songs of love and madness Doch ist sein Bild mir immer neu, Gefangen auch, blieb ich stolz und frei, Das will ich wohl immer sein. ....... Ich habe gebetet in mancher Stund Zur heiligen Jungfrau rein, Mein Herz, es war so öd und wund, Doch ward mir nimmer und nimmer kund, Wo der Freund wohl möge sein.
but his image is ever renewed to me, even imprisoned, I remain proud and free, this will I always be. ...... I have prayed for many an hour to the pure, holy Virgin; My heart was so barren and wounded, but word never, never reached me of where my friend might be.
Und seh’ ich den Liebsten nur wieder einmal, So will ich verstummen wie einst; Doch leuchtet mir noch ein Hoffnungsstrahl, So zieh’ ich gern über Berg und Tal, Ach, spräch’ er nur tröstend: “Du weinst?”
And if I saw my beloved just once more, I would be mute as before; but a ray of hope still shines for me, so I wander gladly over mountain and valley, ah, if only he said comfortingly, “You weep?”
Die Tränen, die sind mein Testament, Die hab’ ich ihm alle vermacht; Doch, bin ich auch ewig von ihm getrennt, Den Namen sein hab’ ich nie genennt, Gute Nacht, mein Freund, gute Nacht53
Tears are my testament, those have I bequeathed all to him, yet I am eternally parted from him whose name I have never named, Good night, my friend, good night!
In the last verse, she contemplates suicide in one of Switzerland’s deep lakes. When Münch rushed over to see who the singer was, he discovered the apparition from the museum, but she gave a loud cry, threw the guitar from her, and fled without heeding his calls. This is Trivialroman entertainment, not fact. In the end, Münch had only harsh words for Maria. She was, he writes, an adventuress, a rudderless ship on the waves, a creature lacking in all moral sense and a magnet for misfortune. Those who spurned her were right to do so, he asserted, exculpating himself for her misfortunes – Mörike was not so self-righteous. He heard, so Münch says, that she had gone to America with a colony of Swiss settlers and that she had later died in Niagara or Orinoco [!]54 How interesting that someone of siren-like beauty who inspired torrential passions in others would be associated with torrents of water in far-away countries. Removal to the Americas, whether north or south, belongs to the mythologizing of Maria by the poets and would-be writers who knew her; her wanderings invited fictive extensions to her more limited journeys in real life. According to Münch, when Mörike’s Maler Nolten was published two years or so after his [Münch’s] encounter, he was astonished to find the life-history of his mysterious gypsy embodied in the novel’s character Elisabeth, but it seems quite clear that Münch read Mörike first and then cobbled together the confabulation in the 1841 reminiscences (one remembers the word “Fantasiegemälde” in the title). It is a palpable impossibility that Münch would have remembered a song of that length word-for-word on one hearing, and phrases in the poem resemble phrases in Mörike as rendered by a lesser mind. The first line of stanza 2, “Wär’ mir geblieben der Liebste treu,” seems Münch’s permutation of Mörike’s line “Wär’ mein Lieb’ nur blieben treu” from Agnes’s song “Rosenzeit! wie schnell vorbei” in Maler Nolten (note Münch’s trivializing lighter rhythm), while the words “verstummen wie einst” in Münch’s fifth stanza were almost certainly derived from the line “Fremd saßen wir mit stumm verhaltnen Schmerzen” in “Peregrina IV.” And Münch 35
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs knew that Peregrina was Maria Meyer converted into myth, as we discover from a letter Mörike wrote on 20 March 1843 to Wilhelm Hartlaub. In it, Mörike tells of receiving from David Friedrich Strauß an excerpt – the Minette episode – from Münch’s first volume of reminiscences. Despite Mörike’s admission that certain unspecified aspects rang true, he ends by ascribing the “deficiencies and exaggerations” of the account to its author’s conceit. Despite the generally contained tone of the letter, Mörike’s anger is evident: he speaks of Münch as a “Hofrat” (court councillor), refusing to grant him recognition as a writer, and jibes at the title Denkwürdigkeiten (Reminiscences). These were not “worthy” thoughts in his estimation: Since the subject here is my Noli me tangere past, I must also say that Strauß showed me a long passage from the Denkwürdigkeiten (if that is the title) of the deceased court councillor Ernst Münch, in which he told the story of a young visionary from Switzerland and his [Münch’s] youthful experience with her. This is supposed to be one and the same as Maria Meyer before our time. Along with much that is remarkably true to character is just as much in which I could not recognize anything of her at all. But Strauß spoke to Münch about it and confirmed the person’s identity, and therefore the deficiencies and exaggerations of the representation, which bespeak a repugnant conceit on the author’s part and are at times very coarse, were only vexing to me.55
The phrase “my Noli me tangere past” is drenched in corrosive irony. The words are taken from the Vulgate rendering of Christ’s admonition to Mary Magdalen, “Do not touch me [for I have not yet ascended to the Father],” in the Gospel according to St. John 20: 17, part of the dramatic recognition scene in which Mary Magdalen weeps by the empty sepulchre and Christ appears to her. The Magdalen was thus the first witness to the risen Christ, whose words “Noli me tangere” tell her that she should cease thinking of him as corporeal and worship him from henceforth as God. The various guises conferred on her – companion to Christ, apostle to the apostles, and beata peccatrix (holy sinner) – have been the subject of many scholarly studies,56 but always, there is the association with female sexual sin, with tainted beauty which induces vice. That Mörike should appropriate Christ’s words and, by implication, cast Maria as Mary Magdalen is enough to make anyone familiar with the episode dizzy; certainly Maria’s beauty, promiscuity, mystical mumbo-jumbo, fits of penitence, even her speculative mental illness (Mary Magdalen is described in the gospels according to Luke and Mark as once possessed by seven demons, which Christ cast out of her), are easily grafted onto the myth of the beata peccatrix. Mörike, unable to cast out Maria’s demons, cast her out instead; if Christ could forgive sins, he could not. Did he thereafter feel that among the sins Christ bore was his [Mörike’s] indissoluble guilt in the wake of that act? Or is Mörike’s momentary appropriation of Christ’s cloak pained irony from someone unable truly to believe in religion, whatever his sporadic avowals to the contrary? Münch was wrong about Maria’s later fate, as both her adventures and her youth were over by the mid-1830s. Back home in Schaffhausen, she met a carpenter’s apprentice named Andreas Kohler (born 1805 in Nuremberg), whom she married in 1836 and followed to Winterthur, where he worked as a carpenter, she as a milliner. In 1842, the couple moved to Wilen in the canton of Thurgau, where they bought a small house in 1857 – at age fifty-five, Maria the “Heimatlose” at last had a home. Ironically, Mörike and his sister Klara stayed for several months in 1851 in the Thurgau border town of 36
Songs of love and madness Egelshofen bei Konstanz without ever knowing that Maria was nearby. The Kohlers reportedly lived in straitened circumstances and kept to themselves; Frau Kohler did not cultivate friendships with other women in the village, her husband had no apprentices or fellowworkers, and the couple were childless. The days of mysticism were no more: Maria Kohler went infrequently to the Protestant church in nearby Sirnach, had no more seizures (or none that were reported), and neither prophesied nor went into trances. She died of dropsy on 2 September 1865 at age sixty-three, followed ten years later by her husband Andreas, who had sold their former home two years after Maria’s death. All trace of their graves in the cemetery at Sirnach has since been obliterated, a final disappearance which sets the seal on her removal from real life so that a paper phoenix named Peregrina could take her place.57 I N A M I R RO R DA R K LY: T H E P E R E G R I NA P O E M S
Mörike’s conversion of Maria into poetry that bursts the bounds of convention began immediately with “Peregrina III” (one thinks of Claude Monet painting his wife Camille on her deathbed and realizes that a similar phenomenon of life-into-art happened here). Mörike would not approve of this book: he warned against any quest for biography in his poems, and yet the veils of artifice he spun around Maria in the Peregrina poems only heighten the perception of something real at the core. On the back of the title page for the 1828 manuscript anthology Neue weltliche Lieder, which contains “Verzweifelte Liebe” (later, Peregrina V), is the statement, “These pieces, right down to the epigram, belong collectedly within the context of a novella, and there is nothing personal to look for in them,” but his warning actually confirms that which it seeks to deny; anyone reading it would immediately look for what is personal in the poems.58 If what the “slender, magical maiden” became in Mörike’s poetry transcended the personal, it is still indisputable that the poet’s experience of love’s ecstasy and indissoluble guilt was mediated through a mortal agency. The name Peregrina tells of pilgrimage, of the ages-old quest, so often thwarted, for love. Peregrina is both a seeker after love and emblematic of Love itself, homeless by nature and given to restless vagrancy. Throughout the cycle, Mörike establishes a dichotomy between “Haus” and “Welt” (house and world), between security, intimacy, domesticity, and social convention on one side and the dark, unbounded realm of errant Eros on the other.59 Peregrina’s lover, who is the poetic voice throughout all five poems, casts her out into the world and chooses to remain inside the security of his “house” (his family, his society, his religion’s notions of sexual sin), but his safety is purchased at the price of the soul’s devastation. When, overwhelmed by fear, he rejects the realm of sex and death, he rejects love in its essence, and the knowledge that he has done so comes too late. The name Peregrina even hints at the wildness of love in the association for English-speaking readers with peregrine falcons, the gold in Peregrina’s gaze a distant echo of their strange yellow eyes. Before discussing the two Peregrina poems Wolf set to music, I want to point out a few aspects of the poems he chose not to set in order to elucidate what may have made those works seem uncomposable. Mörike and Maria Meyer were never married, and yet Peregrina and the poetic persona do marry in “Peregrina II” (“Aufgeschmückt ist der 37
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Freudensaal”), their bizarre, Orientalizing ritual of union fraught with menace and beauty in equal measure: II Aufgeschmückt ist der Freudensaal. Lichterhell, bunt, in laulicher Sommernacht Stehet das offene Gartengezelte. Säulengleich steigen, gepaart, Grün-umranket, eherne Schlangen, Zwölf mit verschlungenen Hälsen, Tragend und stützend das Leicht gegitterte Dach.
II Bedecked is the hall of joy, Brightly-lit, many-colored in the warm summer night, the garden pavilion stands open. Like columns, green-wreathed brazen snakes rise, coupled, twelve of them with necks intertwined, bearing and supporting the lightly latticed canopy.
Aber die Braut noch wartet verborgen In dem Kämmerlein ihres Hauses. Endlich bewegt sich der Zug der Hochzeit, Fackeln tragend, Feierlich stumm. Und in der Mitte, Mich an der rechten Hand, Schwarz gekleidet, geht einfach die Braut; Schön gefaltet ein Scharlachtuch Liegt um den zierlichen Kopf geschlagen. Lächelnd geht sie dahin; das Mahl schon duftet.
But the bride is still waiting, hidden in her house, in her little room. Finally the wedding processional sets forth, bearing torches, solemnly mute. And in the middle, myself at her right hand, the bride walks simply, clad in black; she wears a scarlet cloth, beautifully folded, around her dainty head. Smiling, she goes inside; the scents of the feast are already wafting in the air.
Später im Lärmen des Fests Stahlen wir seitwärts uns beide Weg, nach den Schatten des Gartens wandelnd, Wo im Gebüsche die Rosen brannten, Wo der Mondstrahl um Lilien zuckte, Wo die Weymouthsfichte mit schwarzem Haar Den Spiegel des Teiches halb verhängt.
Later, amidst the noise of the festivities, we both stole away from the others, wandering into the shadows of the garden, where the roses burned in their bushes, where the moonbeam gleams on the lilies, where the weeping willow with its black hair half overhangs the mirror of the pond.
Auf seidnem Rasen dort, ach, Herz am Herzen, Wie verschlangen, erstickten meine Küsse den scheueren Kuß! Indes der Springquell, unteilnehmend An überschwenglicher Liebe Geflüster, Sich ewig des eigenen Plätscherns freute; Uns aber neckten von fern und lockten Freundliche Stimmen, Flöten und Saiten umsonst.
On the silken lawn, there, oh heart to heart, As if entangled, my kisses smothering her shyer kiss! Meanwhile the fountain, ignoring the rapturous whispers of love, rejoiced eternally in its own plashing; but the friendly voices of flutes and strings teasingly enticed us in vain from a distance.
Ermüdet lag, zu bald für mein Verlangen, Das leichte, liebe Haupt auf meinem Schoß. Spielender Weise mein Aug’ auf ihres drückend, Fühlt ich ein Weilchen die langen Wimpern, Bis der Schlaf sie stellte, Wie Schmetterlingsgefieder auf und nieder gehn.
The light, lovely head lay wearily in my lap, too soon for my desire. My eyes pressed on hers in playful fashion, I felt her long lashes for a while, until they closed in sleep, moving up and down like butterflies’ wings.
Eh’ das Frührot schien, Eh das Lämpchen erlosch im Brautgemache, Weckt ich die Schläferin, Führte das seltsame Kind in mein Haus ein.60
Before the dawn came, before the little lamp went out in the bridal chamber, I awoke the sleeper, led the strange child into my house.
38
Songs of love and madness Virtually every detail is sexually liminal, symbolic of tragedy, or both, and yet there is rapture as well. The pair celebrate their union in a nocturnal garden – an anti-Garden of Eden, already tainted – whose concatenation of multivalent symbols is almost too much, one potent image following another until the reader feels dizzied.61 The snake-caryatids supporting the wedding canopy, for example, are fashioned of a metal evocative of Urantiquity’s idols and bedecked with clinging vines (female joined to male symbolism); they evoke associations not only of Old Testament tempters in gardens of love, but of Artemis, whose emblem was the snake and who had to be appeased at weddings by sacrificial offerings because she was the sworn enemy of Aphrodite. Phallic and female alike, the bronze snakes are coupled, their necks intertwined, and rising as if alive, as if in sexual excitation – an eerie image with which to begin the poem, before anyone human enters the picture. The ceremony is bizarre, its mute processional reminiscent of Oriental harem slaves whose tongues were amputated to ensure their silence and its bride a witchy-dark figure adorned with Mary Magdalen’s red veil of sexual transgression. The lovers consummate their passion out-of-doors, the moonbeam which makes the lily twitch and the burning roses easily decipherable codes for love-making, but they do so near a black-hued weeping willow which leans over the pond in a classical image of absence and grief. It is here, in this first of the Peregrina poems to be written, that Mörike makes of the word “Haus” something powerful and particular to this cycle: before the wedding, the bride waits “hidden away in the little room of her house” (wording which also suggests a sexual meaning), and he leads her “into my house [italics mine]” at the end. If he succumbs to passion outside the bounds of convention, he immediately thereafter wants to domesticate her, to enclose her in his circumscribed life. Even the traditional placement of the bride at the groom’s left hand seems symbolic in this context; she is literally a sinister figure, while he is on the side of right, a right he will soon rue. Of course, poets convert biographical vicissitudes into fiction in part via literary forebears. Adolf Beck has found a model for the Peregrina tale in Justinus Kerner’s eccentric first novel, the 1811 Reiseschatten von dem Schattenspieler Luchs (the fashion for “phantasmagoria,” or magic-lantern shows, is responsible for book and title alike), in which the narrator tells of “the strange maiden” who is mysteriously bound to the sea, for which she longs. The pair come to a garden with a ruined house where once, forty years ago, lived a beautiful madwoman from Nuremberg (that legendary site for necromancy) who awoke briefly from her madness after twenty years, invited her friends to a banquet, took leave of them, and sank again into insanity. The garden, we are told, is the very picture of madness, and it is there that the “strange maiden” draws her hand three times over the narrator’s eyes, casting him into magnetic slumber and then disappears, nevermore to be seen.62 The relationship to the first version of “Peregrina II” is striking. And Gerhart von Graevenitz has pointed out the kinship between Mörike’s wedding poem and Kerner’s graveyard nuptials in the Reiseschatten, each with its roses and lilies, the noise of the festivities, and the lovers’ need for rest:63 Komm, Bräut’gam! kommt, ihr Gäste! Schon steht im Hochzeitkleid Die bleiche Braut bereit, Erwartend euch zum Feste.
Come, bridegroom! Come, guests! Already the pale bride stands ready in her wedding garb, waiting for you to begin the festivities.
39
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Herbei! herbei! Zum Tanz Die bleiche Braut zu führen, – Seht! ihre Haare zieren So Ros’ als Lilienglanz.
Come here! Come here and lead the pale bride in the dance – See! Her hair is adorned with glorious roses and lilies.
So Mond und Sterne kränzen Lichtvoll das dunkle Tal, Lampen im Hochzeitsaal, Die Leichensteine glänzen.
The moon and stars garland the dark valley in light, lamps in the wedding hall, the tombstones gleam.
Und weil nach Tanz und Lauf Der Ruh’ wir nötig hätten, – Schloß ich zu Schlummerstätten Die stillen Gräber auf.
And because we needed rest after the dancing and motion – I unlocked the quiet graves as places to sleep.
Seht! eure Betten kränzet Der Rosen stolze Art, Doch eine Lilie zart Am Bett der Braut erglänzet.
See! your beds are garlanded with the rose’s proud beauty, but a sweet-scented lily gleams on the bride’s bed.
Die Hochzeit ist bereit, Komm, Bräut’gam! kommt, ihr Gäste! Es öffnen sich zum Feste Die schwarzen Tore weit.64
The wedding is ready – Come, bridegroom! Come, guests! The black doors are opened wide for the festivities.
That Mörike knew the Reiseschatten is evident from a letter of 1 September 1824 to Hartlaub, just after the Maria-crisis, when the poet tells his friend that he has not had a single truly happy hour since August’s death (he says nothing of Maria), save for reading his sister “something strange” from Kerner.65 The wedding is followed in “Peregrina III” by Verstoßung, in which a man may cast out, even kill, an adulterous wife, or one suspected of adultery with little or no punishment; if canon law did not allow it, custom in civil society did.66 But justification in the eyes of the law is not always congruent with inner experience; abiding love and Verstoßung can and do go hand-in-hand, says Peter von Matt, who compares the Peregrina poems to Grillparzer’s “Das Kloster bei Sendomir”; in this tale, a man kills his adulterous wife and lives out the rest of his days as a half-mad monk, tormented by a deed in which the law found nothing culpable. With the exception of Ludwig Bauer, Mörike’s friends and family considered him justified in expelling Maria from his life for her supposedly immoral behavior; if they could glimpse earlier circumstances which might have produced her aberrant ways, their occasional sympathetic impulses were not sufficient to redeem her in their eyes. Mörike was not legally married to Maria, but, as we are reminded by Wolf ’s letter of 15 October 1890 to Emil Kauffmann, he considered himself betrothed, bound to her in every way that mattered. That he condemned himself for rejecting her is evident in many details of the language in “Peregrina III,” for example, the phrase “Mit weinendem Blick, doch grausam” in line 4, describing the persona’s aspect as he casts Peregrina out. The opposite phenomenon – dreadful implacability on the outside, weeping on the inside – issues from a more readily comprehensible psychological realm, but weeping to hide inner Grausamkeit is a mask of a different sort, complex and terrible.67 Furthermore, the adjective “verjährten” implies that the unspecified wrong (Mörike could not bring himself to say that it was sexual) is outdated, beyond the statute of limitations. Whatever she did that was 40
Songs of love and madness condemnable had no bearing on her love for the poetic speaker; it belonged to an earlier time, and she should have been forgiven for it. The poet thus invites the reader to judge the speaker harshly, to recognize that he had a cruel streak and acted at its behest: III Ein Irrsal kam in die Mondscheinsgärten Einer einst heiligen Liebe. Schaudernd entdeckt ich verjährten Betrug. Und mit weinendem Blick, doch grausam, Hieß ich das schlanke, Zauberhafte Mädchen Ferne gehen von mir. Ach, ihre hohe Stirn War gesenkt, denn sie liebte mich; Aber sie zog mit Schweigen Fort in die graue Welt hinaus.
III A madness came in the moonlight gardens of a once holy love. Shuddering, I discovered past wrongdoing. And with weeping look, but terrible, I bade the slender, magical maiden to go far from me. Ah, her noble brow was bowed down, for she loved me; but she went silently out into the gray world.
Krank seitdem, Wund ist and wehe mein Herz. Nimmer wird es genesen! Als ginge, luftgesponnen, ein Zauberfaden Von ihr zu mir, ein ängstig Band, So zieht es, zieht mich schmachtend ihr nach! – Wie? wenn ich eines Tages auf meiner Schwelle Sie sitzen fände, wie einst, im Morgen-Zwielicht, Das Wanderbündel neben ihr, Und ihr Auge, treuherzig zu mir aufschauend, Sagte: da bin ich wieder Hergekommen aus weiter Welt!68
Sick since then, wounded and sad my heart. Never will it be healed! As if a magic thread, spun from air, went from her to me, an anxious bond, so it draws, draws me longingly after her! – How? if one day I found her sitting on my doorstep, as before, in the morning’s twilight, her wanderer’s knapsack by her, and her eyes, looking at me trustingly, said: I have come back again from the wide world!
Certain details of the poem are especially compelling. One notices the short lines in the first section when the speaker bids Peregrina leave, as if pain had burned away all superfluity and left only these gasping constructions, in contrast to the longer lines of the fantasy of return in the second section, also the repeated –ei diphthongs of line 2 (“Einer einst heiligen Liebe”), exhalations opening out into infinity. The word “house,” doubly invoked in “Peregrina II,” is replaced here by the doubled invocation of the “world” at the end of each stanza, not Eichendorff’s wide world of spiritual quest but a vast Siberian wasteland through which Love roams without respite. The starkness of that “Welt” is made apparent in the enjambement of lines 11–12 (“Fort in die graue / Welt hinaus”),69 and at the beginning of the second stanza, the trebled devastation of “krank, wund und wehe” (sick, wounded, and sad) precedes the noun “heart.” Pain claims priority. Peregrina’s silence in this poem is an important leitmotif of the cycle. Not once does this allegorical figure of wandering Eros utter words of her own; it is her eyes that speak at the end of the poem, not her lips, and only in fantasy can they say what the speaker wants to hear. Her silence is the measure of her defenselessness in III, but it is also the representation throughout all five poems of her absence, of the void into which these poems speak. Such silences also tell of the degree to which passion depends upon the unsaid and of the manner in which guilt feeds upon fantasies of words one might have uttered to alter the 41
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs irreparable. The single word “– Wie?” in line 19 is another detail of language compressed into white-hot incandescence, even the punctuation laden with meaning; the dash which precedes the monosyllabic interrogative is a symbol of the time in which longing gives rise to the fantasy that she might one day return. Mörike perhaps wrote it because a fullfledged question – “How would it be if I found her one day . . . ?” – would necessitate a question mark at the close of the poem rather than the ecstatic exclamation he places at the end of this dream of reconciliation, but the impossibility of it all seems best encoded in the single syllable. “How” indeed could this be? The ghost who returns in “Peregrina IV” (see p. 47 below) is thus the ghost of the poetic speaker’s wife. But we cannot realize this from the two poems Wolf chose, although he assuredly knew it, whatever his bewilderment over certain aspects of the Peregrina poems he omitted from his volume of Mörike songs. The wedding and the expulsion are at the heart of Mörike’s cycle in its final form, but they do not appear at all in Wolf ’s dyad. Instead, presentiments of sex and death already cast a dark shadow in “Peregrina I,” written as if minutes away from first sexual consummation, while the aftermath of passion in ghosts and guilt follows right after in Wolf ’s “Peregrina II” (Mörike’s IV). The heart of the poetic narrative is not there, and one notes the absence, whether or not the listener is aware of Mörike’s free-verse masterpieces. This is the same model Wolf had already established when he paired “Der Knabe und das Immlein” (The Boy and the Little Bee) with “Ein Stündlein wohl vor Tag” (An Hour before Daybreak), poems Mörike does not pair, such that we hear the anticipation of a sexual affair in the first song and the announcement of betrayal ending the affair in the second, but nothing of what occurs in the middle (see chap. 4). Nor did Wolf set the final poem of the Peregrina cycle in which the poet confronts the irrevocability of his loss. The complex formality of Petrarchan sonnet form – Petrarch too loved and lost and turned the matter into art – sets the seal on closure: V Die Liebe, sagt man, steht am Pfahl gebunden, Geht endlich arm, zerrüttet, unbeschuht; Dies edle Haupt hat nicht mehr, wo es ruht, Mit Tränen netzet sie der Füße Wunden.
V Love, they say, is tied to a stake, is destitute, ragged, unshod; this noble head has nowhere to rest, she washes her wounded feet with her tears.
Ach, Peregrinen hab ich so gefunden! Schön war ihr Wahnsinn, ihrer Wange Glut, Noch scherzend in der Frühlingsstürme Wut, Und wilde Kränze in das Haar gewunden.
Oh, thus I found Peregrina to be! Her madness, her flushed cheeks, were beautiful, still at play in the fury of the spring storms, and wild garlands wound in her hair.
Wars möglich, solche Schönheit zu verlassen? – So kehrt nur reizender das alte Glück! O komm, in diese Arme dich zu fassen!
How was it possible to forsake such beauty? – The olden joy comes back still more sweetly! Oh, come back that I may hold you in my arms!
Doch weh! o weh! was soll mir dieser Blick? But alas, alas! What does this look mean? Sie küßt mich zwischen Lieben noch und Hassen, She kisses me with love still and hate, Sie kehrt sich ab, und kehrt mir nie zurück. she turns away, and never returns to me.
One remembers Münch’s description of Maria weaving flower garlands to wear in her hair. Perhaps Wolf was turned away from music by the overt allegorizing or by the motif of madness or by the finality of it all – we can only guess. His song-dyads of desire, as we shall 42
Songs of love and madness see, are painfully open-ended, devoid of the acceptance one finds in “Peregrina V.” Although the admission is fraught with anguish, the poet is at last able to say that she will never come back to him, to put a halt to dreams of returning, but Wolf ’s bereft lovers, male and female alike, “end” in ambivalence, their tragedies ongoing. Why the composer might have omitted these three Peregrina poems is an issue I will revisit at the close. It is an intriguing possibility that “Peregrina I” might have come into being as the result of Mörike’s later affair with someone else, after Maria’s departure. From the end of February 1828 to the end of May, Mörike went to visit his brother in the town of Scheer on the Danube and then journeyed on to Buchau in the early summer, with a side-trip to Munich. On 20 July, he wrote the following postscript to a letter from Buchau to his friend Mährlen, “ , , ” (In amorous matters, I have, without risking anything, made good strides here). Exactly what that exuberantly capitalized news-flash meant remains Mörike’s secret (what was not at risk? . . . disease, marriage, deeper emotional involvement, a repetition of the Maria catastrophe?), but it seems that the poet had an affair with the Catholic schoolmaster’s daughter in Scheer. It was during this time that Mörike wrote “Erstes Liebeslied eines Mädchens,” “Liebesvorzeichen,” “Josephine,” and the first version of “Im Frühling,” in which the poet states that Love and the winds “have no house,” the house-symbolism of four years earlier reawakened.70 When he left Scheer, Mörike wrote in a letter to Mährlen on 16 May 1828, “I went with my brother to the gates, where, however, I was seized by an unconquerable aversion to all things domestic” [eine unwiderstehliche vor aller häuslichen Atmosphäre].”71 No translation can adequately account for the adjective “häuslichen” in this context, for the irreconcilable duality Mörike perceived between eroticism/passion/sex and “houses” (society, family, domesticity, limits). The other four poems speak boldly of desire given an extra frisson because it comes into being during a mass and of a woman who is sensual, sexually naïve but curious – these are not innocent poems. Like Peregrina, Jorinde’s kisses in “Liebesvorzeichen” can incinerate the soul, the words “kecksten,” “kecklich” (boldest, boldly) a link between “Peregrina I” and its less fraught cousin: Liebesvorzeichen (stanzas 4 -6 of 10) Dann leuchtet dieser Augen Schwärze Mich an in lieb- und guter Ruh’, Sie hört dem Mutwill meiner Scherze Mit kindischem Verwundern zu.
Signs of Love
Dazwischen dacht ich wohl im stillen: Was hast du vor? sie ist ein Kind! Die Lippen, die von Reife quillen, Wie blöde noch und fromm gesinnt!
In between I thought to myself quietly: What are you doing? She’s a child! The lips swelling with ripeness, how bashful still and piously disposed!
Fürwahr, sie schien es nicht zu wissen, Wie mächtig ihr die Fülle schwoll, Und dass sie in den Feuerküssen Des kecksten Knaben brennen soll.
Truly, she seemed not to know how mightily abundance swelled in her, and that she, with her fiery kisses can incinerate the boldest youth.
Then the black depths of these eyes gleam at me in loving and sweet peace; she hears the wantonness of my jests with childish astonishment.
Josephine in the poem given her name is described as having brown eyes, Jorinde dark eyes; Peregrina too is brown-eyed, and yet, the poet cannot trust what he sees reflected in her 43
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs gaze and falls headlong into terrified premonitions of sin and death. Did the erotic experience in Scheer reawaken the memory of Maria Meyer? If so, he knew to convert it immediately into poetry, the result a new “first chapter” to what would become the Peregrina cycle: I Der Spiegel dieser treuen, braunen Augen Ist wie von innerm Gold ein Widerschein; Tief aus dem Busen scheint er’s anzusaugen, Dort mag solch Gold in heil’gem Gram gedeihn. In diese Nacht des Blickes mich zu tauchen, Unwissend Kind, du selber lädst mich ein – Willst, ich soll kecklich mich und dich entzünden, Reichst lächelnd mir den Tod im Kelch der Sünden!72
I The mirror of your faithful brown eyes is like a reflection of inner gold. They seem to absorb the gold from deep within your bosom, where it might thrive in holy sorrow. To plunge into that night of your gaze, unknowing child, you yourself invite me – want me rashly to inflame myself and you, hand me, smiling, death in the chalice of sin!
The original version of “Peregrina I” in the Green Notebook (the version entitled “Agnes, die Nonne”) consisted of two stanzas in ottava rima rather than one. Lines 1–7 were unchanged in the final version, but for line 8, Mörike originally bade his poetic speaker cry out, “Weg, Reue-bringend Liebes-Glück in Sünden!” (Go away, remorse-bringing loverapture in sin!), a line which anticipates the Verstoßung created four years earlier in “Peregrina III”; in Maler Nolten, one recalls, “Peregrina I” was entitled “Warnung” and was placed after “Die Hochzeit” (“Peregrina II”) – that is, after sexual consummation – and before “Scheiden von Ihr” (“Peregrina III”).73 Sometime before publication of his novel, Mörike altered the last line of stanza 1 and omitted the second stanza altogether: (stanza 2 of “Agnes, die Nonne”) Einst ließ ein Traum von wunderbarem Leben Mich sprießend Gold in tiefer Erde seh’n, Geheime Lebens-Kräfte, die da weben In dunkeln Schachten, ahnungsvoll verstehn; Mich drang’s hinab, nicht konnt’ ich widerstreben, Und unten, wie verzweifelt, blieb ich stehn, – Die goldnen Adern konnt’ ich nirgend schauen, Und um mich schüttert sehnsuchtsvolles Grauen.
Once I saw a dream of wonderful life, germinating gold in the deep earth, mysterious life-forces that float in dark gorges, ominously known; it compelled me below, I could not withstand it, and below, as if in despair, I remained fixed – I could no longer see the veins of gold and around me shuddered desire-filled terror.
This stanza is both a mirror image of the first and a progression to the next stage of sexual encounter, in which the speaker attempts unsuccessfully to retain his former image of the beloved as a sacred creature. The gaze deep into the beloved’s eyes becomes the descent into “dark gorges,” devoid of the gold he had thought to mine therein – Freudian meanings are not far to seek in this imagery of abysses and urges that cannot be withstood. (In the first stanza, Mörike underscores the depths at which inner gold might lie buried by switching to a dactylic foot at the beginning of line 3 – “Tief aus dem . . .” – before reverting to the ruling iambs in line 4.) One scholar has speculated that Mörike deleted the stanza because it was too much akin to E. T. A. Hoffmann’s “Die Bergwerke von Falun” (The Mines of Falun) from the Serapions-Brüder tales, and indeed Hoffmann’s gorges and shafts, the hope of finding precious metals in abysses which instead yield only darkness, the symbolic links between mining and love-making, could well be a source for this stanza. But I wonder whether Mörike perhaps also judged the sexual imagery to be too explicit, too personal, and deleted it for those reasons as well.74 44
Songs of love and madness In ottava rima, the same a b rhyme is repeated three times, intensifying with each recurrence and culminating in a rhyming couplet which is usually a summation, an epigrammatic twist, the end of a crescendo. For the Renaissance masters of ottava rima, the form was peculiarly adapted to mixtures of narrative and lyric, the perfect medium for odes to the Virgin, saints, and martyrs – and Mörike was courting a kind of religio-erotic frisson when he first entitled the poem “Agnes, die Nonne”; the martyrdom of St. Agnes, whose breasts were cut off, melds sex/religion/misogyny in an especially graphic way. (Did he envisage at some point sending Agnes into a nunnery in Maler Nolten, one wonders?) Yet Mörike’s mixture is not of poetic modes, but of desire and doubt. The poet is unable from the beginning to believe in the very fidelity he wishes to assert, and hence he tentatively proposes analogies he does not trust, succumbing to terror when the inability to believe proves stronger than the desire to do so. “Wie . . . Gold,” “scheint er’s”, “dort mag,” the poet says in a concatenation of uncertainties, ambivalence born of fear present from the start. Mörike, writes one scholar, is situated historically in a state of Zwischenheit, or “betweenhood”; perhaps the greatest poet of the “no longer” and the “not yet,” he could be certain of nothing.75 The former halcyon unity between the world and the poetic “I” of the sort Mörike located most powerfully in Goethe was a matter of recent loss, and those poets who followed in its wake could only see fragmentary glimmers of former wholeness in the mirror of memory. However beautiful the remembrance or the poem spun from it, awareness that the thing itself was irrefutably gone permeates the work with a sense of loss. The reflection, not the substance: that was his realm, fragile, susceptible to breakage, and not to be trusted. In mirrors, right and left are reversed, being and seeming impossible to distinguish, perception a perilous trick, beauty as transient as the brittle glass which reflects it, the sight of oneself in a mirror a premonition of death. One thinks of the unknown seventeenth-century French artist who painted Justice holding a mirror turned toward the viewer so that we are forced to imagine our own image superimposed on its blank reflective surface, while the skull placed beside the mirror bids us see death in our own faces,76 or of Ingres’s great portrait of Madame Inès Moitessier, whose reflection – inaccurate according to the laws of physics – seems a ghostly-dark Doppelgänger from some netherworld the Second Empire could not banish.77 In the 1827 poem “Besuch in Urach” (Visit to Urach), Mörike writes of memory’s broken mirror transmuting the past into something disorienting, self-alienating, paralyzing: “Aus tausend grünen Spiegeln scheint zu gehen / Vergang’ne Zeit, die lächelnd mich verwirrt” (From a thousand green mirrors, bygone time, which, smiling, threw me into confusion, seemed to go by). The poet’s own image becomes “a strange and gentle face,” and from memory’s chalice, he drinks a draught “bitter to the point of stupefaction” – this was a poem Wolf particularly loved.78 Eyes too are mirrors. In Mörike’s masterpiece “Erinna an Sappho” (Erinna to Sappho), the young poetess – Sappho’s pupil circa 600 BC – looks into doubled mirrors, the silvered glass that reflects her image and her own eyes, and says: Erinna an Sappho (stanza 3, lines 17–22) . . . seltsam betraf mich im Spiegel Blick in Blick. Augen, sagt’ ich, ihr Augen was wollt ihr?
Erinna to Sappho . . . in the mirror, gaze within gaze struck me strangely. Eyes, I said, eyes, what do you want?
45
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Du, mein Geist, heute noch sicher behaust da drinne, Lebendigen Sinnen traulich vermählt, Wie mit fremdendem Ernst, lächelnd halb, ein Dämon, Nickst du mich an, Tod weissagend!79
You, my spirit, today still securely housed there within, intimately wedded to living senses – with alienating seriousness, half smiling, a daemon, how you beckon to me, prophesying death!
The word “behaust” is yet another testament to the symbolic weight of the word “Haus” in Mörike’s poetic world. The historical Erinna, so Mörike tells the reader in a didactic note placed between the title and the poem, died aged nineteen; one remembers that Mörike was nineteen when he first encountered Maria Meyer and guesses that the figure might thereafter have become a “magic number” for him, the age at which deaths of several kinds happen. The young poet from ancient Greece sees her own death in the mirror of her eyes, and so does the persona of “Peregrina I,” who looks into the mirror of the beloved’s eyes and finds, not the golden holiness he tries to see at the beginning, but sin and death. Mirrors infuse the language of this poem, reflecting the dilemma at its heart. Dreading the death sexual fusion might bring, the poet shies away from the pronoun “uns,” but the linked words “mich und dich” in the penultimate line reiterate an old literary motif in which “I” and “thou” are mirror images. The narcissism of passion was made explicit in Gottfried von Strassburg’s Tristan und Isold: “mit liebe also vereinet, / daz ietweder dem anderm was / durchluter alse ein spiegelglas [italics mine]. / sie haeten beide ein herze: / ir swaere was sin smerze, / sin smerze was ir swaere” ( . . . so unified in love that each was to the other as transparent as a mirror. They shared a single heart; her anguish was his pain, his pain was her anguish), a passage in which the language itself is mirrored.80 The phrase “kecklich mich und dich” is among Mörike’s many instances of echoing internal rhyme and mirrored alliteration, such as the doubled –ie and –au sounds of line 1 (“Spiegel dieser . . . braunen Augen”), the inverted -g’s and -m’s of “mag” and “Gram” in line 4, the brightness of “wie” and “Wi-[derschein]” echoing one another at opposite ends of the second line. The word “Widerschein,” which is echoed by “scheint” in line 3, seems peculiarly apt for this context of mirrors and reflections, with its conjunction of “S/schein,” or “seeming,” and “wider,” or against – counter to reality, although the latter implication is lost in translation (“reflection” has its own double-entendre in English, that of mirror images and pensive thought). “Unwissend” in line 6 is followed by “Willst” in line 7, while the adverb “kecklich” is followed in the final line by the assonant noun “Kelch.” The transmutation of suffering into gold, the kinship between the base material and its alchemical transformation, 81 are heightened by the assonance of the -g’s in “Gold” and “heil’ger Gram,” and the beloved’s power over the speaker is evident in the accented, parallel, monosyllabic verbs “willst” and “reichst” placed at the beginning of the final two lines, a rhyming couplet in hexameters – weightier than the iambic pentameters regnant elsewhere (line 3, as noted earlier, begins atypically with a dactyl). By the end, Peregrina becomes something akin to a priestess of sexual desire officiating at an anti-mass, her Communion chalice (the “Kelch der Sünden” a readily-decipherable metaphor for female sexual organs) filled with something other than Christ’s transubstantiated blood and proffered with a seductive smile; well before Baudelaire, Mörike heightens eroticism with hints from religion’s realms. Ironically, Heine would also use the words 46
Songs of love and madness “tauchen” and “Kelch” as similarly laden with sexual implications in “Ich will meine Seele tauchen / in den Kelch der Lilie hinein” (I want to sink my soul into the lily’s chalice) from the Buch der Lieder, roughly contemporaneous with Mörike’s “Peregrina I.” Both poets imbue the sexual object with something of purity – Heine’s is a lily, Mörike’s an “unknowing child” – and yet they are seductive, promising still more sexual passion to follow. The “Kelch der Sünden” echoes in mirrored distortion words from the shadow-play Der letzte König von Orplid in Maler Nolten; at the end of the fourth scene, the fairy queen Thereile, to whom King Ulmon (the last king of Orplid) is bound in erotic servitude, asks him if he can tell the bitter from the sweet in what she lets him taste on the rim of her goblet. He replies: from “Der letzte König von Orplid” Wie hass’ ich sie! Und doch, wie schön ist sie! (für sich) Hinweg! mir wird auf einmal angst und bange Bei dieser kleinen golden-grünen Schlange. Von ihren rothen Lippen träuft Ein Lächeln, wie drei Tropfen süßes Gift, Das in dem Kuß mit halbem Tode trifft.82
from “The Last King of Orplid” How I hate her! And yet, how beautiful she is! (to himself) Away! I become all of a sudden anxious and fearful near this little greeny-golden snake. From her red lips drips a smile like three drops of sweet poison that in a kiss strikes one half-dead.
One recalls the “anxious bond” between Peregrina and the poet in “Peregrina III” and realizes the degree to which sexual passion was permeated with angst in Mörike’s experience. If the “chalice of sins” in “Peregrina I” and the beaker of bittersweet poison in the shadowplay are, in one reading, Peregrina’s and Thereile’s mouths each pursed for a kiss, “chalices” lower down are also implied. “Peregrina IV” apppears in the Green Notebook with the title “Nachklang von Agnes” (Echo of Agnes), where it is she who bursts into tears, not the poetic speaker: IV (Wolf ’s “Peregrina II”) Warum, Geliebte, denk’ ich dein Auf einmal nun mit tausend Tränen, Und kann gar nicht zufrieden sein, Und will die Brust in alle Weite dehnen? Ach, gestern in den hellen Kindersaal, Beim Flimmer zierlich aufgesteckter Kerzen, Wo ich mein selbst vergaß in Lärm und Scherzen, Tratst du, o Bildnis mitleid-schöner Qual; Es war dein Geist, er setzte sich ans Mahl, Fremd saßen wir mit stumm verhaltnen Schmerzen, Zuletzt brach ich in lautes Schluchzen aus, Und Hand in Hand verließen wir das Haus.
IV Why, beloved, do I think of you all at once now, with a thousand tears, and cannot be at peace, my heart swelling to bursting? Ah, yesterday, into the bright nursery, by the flickering light of ornately placed candles, where I forgot my very self in games and bustle, you entered, o image of compassion-beautified suffering; it was your ghost; it sat down to the meal. Like strangers, we sat there with mute, suppressed sorrows. Finally I burst into loud sobbing, and hand in hand we left the house.
All grief asks why, but this “Warum” is more, the speaker querying the operations of memory.83 The last phrase of the question in lines 1–4, “. . . und will die Brust in alle Weite dehnen?”, is virtually untranslatable in its evocation of grief ’s physicality, of the feeling that one’s chest might burst from sorrow, and it also echoes the “weite Welt” into which the poetic speaker sent Peregrina comfortless on her way. Now, too late, his heart swells in 47
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs the desire to be everywhere, to find her. These five poems are arranged along a continuum from the first floods of desire to the sad acceptance of her loss in the last line of the last poem (“Sie küßt mich zwischen Lieben noch und Hassen, / Sie kehrt sich ab und kehrt mir nie zurück,” or “She kissed me between love still and hate; she turned away and never came back to me” – he admits the possibility that she now hates him, but even here, he creates a farewell kiss and lingering remnants of love). In “Peregrina III,” he could imagine her returning to him in the flesh, but by the next poem, the fantasy is no longer possible. Only the guilt represented by all ghosts can and does return, a ghost whom he endows with the compassion he should have given her earlier (“mitleid-schöner” . . . her pity for him heightens her beauty). Mörike’s single twelve-line stanza is divided into time zones of “now” and “yesterday,” but these are not twenty-four-hour days of which he speaks. Time in Mörike’s poems is fluid, spilling over clock- and calendar-bound limits through the operation of memory, and the poet ensures that we understand “then” and “now” as all of a piece by knitting the sections together rhythmically. The shift from lines in tetrameters (lines 1–3) to pentameters (lines 4–12) occurs at the invocation of “alle Weite” – the lines expand with the speaker’s heart – at the end of the question, the iambic pentameters continuing for the remainder of the poem. “Yesterday” is both yesterday and yesteryear: in willed regression, the speaker has retreated to memories of childhood to escape the pain of loss. The phrase “wo ich mein selbst vergaß” (where I forgot my very self) is a psychologically rich formulation, implying that Peregrina is part of the speaker’s very being, that when he tries to forget her by withdrawing into childhood, he abnegates his own Self. The attempt at escape is not even possible. An adult can only recall childhood through the scrim of adult consciousness, whose sorrows infiltrate recollections of youth, and thus Peregrina’s ghost comes unbidden into this vision of a bygone nursery. The slender tapers and the meal transform the remembered nursery into a distant echo of the torches and the wedding feast for man and wife in “Peregrina II,” but they also suggest sacred precincts, a place where Communion and forgiveness might occur. The alienation between former lovers cannot be bridged, however, and her continuing silence becomes his – ironically, the only thing they share. Although he and his ghostly revenant mimic the actions of lovers who unite and go forth into the world together, it is the house of innocence they leave and she is but a ghost. That he does not yet fully accept her loss, even though he has come one step closer to its truth, is at the heart of the poem, evident in the vision of lovers hand in hand. The poem ends there, not with the solitary grief of lines 1–4 – he cannot let her go just yet. I always think of “Peregrina IV” when I read the final section of W. H. Auden’s “Anthem for St. Cecilia’s Day,” with its “dear white children . . . so gay against the greater silences / of dreadful things you did ” and the child enjoined at the end to “weep away the stain, / Lost innocence who wished your lover dead, / Weep for the lives your wishes never led. [italics Auden’s]” The “cry created as the bow of sin / Is drawn across our trembling violin” is Peregrina in essence; if much is unlike, what lies at the core of these two works seems akin. 84 “That what has been may never be again,” both Auden and Mörike declare in their own ways; thereafter, we “continually mark the spot / Where the body of his happiness was first discovered” (Auden again, in “Detective Story”).85 Mörike is justly lauded for his ability to retrace those acts of mind which lead to an altered understanding of life’s larger matters – love, death, 48
Songs of love and madness creation – and he does so here in the Peregrina poems; step by step, the poetic speaker recounts his struggles with the difficult acknowledgment of wrongdoing on his part (a struggle encoded in the compositional process), and the acceptance of permanent loss and guilt. If, in “Peregrina V,” he recognizes his lost beloved’s madness, he nonetheless asks himself how it was possible to abandon such beauty and vulnerability. He never found an answer that would banish guilt or allow more than partial self-expiation, but his bitter statement to Luise that the experience had been “very useful” for poetry could not have been more true. WO L F ’ S P E R E G R I NA : M I R RO R S I N M U S I C
Exactly fifty years after the publication of Mörike’s first poetic anthology, Wolf set Peregrina I and IV (Wolf ’s II) to music in late April 1888, the manuscripts dated 28 and 30 April respectively. Unlike “Auf eine Christblume I & II,” the two songs composed seven months apart (“Auf eine Christblume II” was the last Mörike song Wolf composed), “Peregrina I & II” were clearly conceived from the beginning as a dyad-cycle, with one compositional decision after another predicated on pairing. “Peregrina I” seems a self-contained work, but is not; it stops in a remarkably irresolute manner, continuation beckoning and following. Things only hinted in I unfurl to their full consequences in II. This dyad is an example of progressive tonality in nineteenth-century song, and a singular example at that. Although this was already a familiar phenomenon in Schubert, Wolf customizes the practice to his purposes in a way that glosses over the two omitted poems, or attempts to do so. Specifically, Wolf joins I and II by means of a postlude to I which then becomes the introduction to II, at first repeated on its original E Ü major location but turning to the true G Ü major tonality of II in the final “twist” of the piano’s four introductory bars. Music has often been likened metaphorically to memory in its recollections and transformations, and here Wolf allows us to hear memory’s treadmill in the prelude to II, the speaker mulling wordlessly over the death-haunted carnal sin he first came to know in I until remembrance impels the question, “Warum, Geliebte” (Ex. 2.1). It is significant that the turn to G Ü major, although forecast in the G Üs which darken the postlude of I, happens so quickly, in the last few beats of m. 4 with the query “Warum” crowding immediately on its heels, and that the figure in the postlude/prelude is extended in the body of the song. Where it contracts, movingly, to its former dimensions at a different tonal location in II (mm. 13–14, mm. 41–43), we hear more than mere transposition. Wolf tells us as plainly as possible in the bridge shared between the two songs that the lovers’ parting was brought about by the “Tod im Kelch der Sünden,” although we are not told how and why. The postlude/prelude consists entirely of instrumental echoes of the words “Tod im Kelch der Sünden,” words which are a mirror of the first measure – but at the end of “Peregrina I,” the instrumental motive stops short of the word “treuen” from before. The motive reiterated in mm. 17–19 is ringlike, beginning on the pitch B Ü (the fifth scale-degree of E Ü major) and returning to it at the end, theoretically infinitely repetitious; as we shall see in chap. 4, Wolf would use ring-symbolism in his other Mörike dyad of desire as well. One notices that the words “Tod” and “Sünden” are emphasized on first appearance, “Tod” sustained across the barline and gratingly dissonant with the C Ü in the 49
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Ex. 2.1(a)
Hugo Wolf, Peregrina I, mm. 15–20
nachlassend −− −Ł − Š
15
reichst
!
− ¦ ŁŁ Š − − ¦Ł
Ł ¦Ł
3
ŁŁ ŁŁ
ŁŁŁ Ł \ Ł Ł
Ł ¦ Ł
Ł
la¨ - chelnd mir den
ŁŁ − Ł Ł Ł Ł −Ł Ł Ł
ŁŁ − dim. Ý −− −Ł ¦ − ŁŁ − −Ł
Tod
im
ŁŁŁ ¦ Ł − Ł Ł Ł ¦ Ł −Ł Ł
¦ ŁŁ ¦ ŁŁ
3
ŁŁ ŁŁ
ziemlich bewegt und sehr ausdrucksvoll
rit.
−Ł Ł −Ł −Ł Kelch der
Su¨n
Ł Ł Ł Ł −Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł −Ł Ł 3 \\ dim. ¹ ¦ ŁŁ −ŁŁ ŁŁ ¹ Ł Ł Ł −ð ð −ð ð ritard.
-
Ł
Ł ¦ Ł −Ł Ł Ł ¦ Ł −Ł Ł rit.
ŁŁŁ 3
den!
ŁŁŁ ŁŁŁŁ
3
¹ ¹ − ¹ Š − − ¼ Ł ¦ Ł −−ŁŁ Ł −ŁŁ ý Ł ¼ Ł ¦ Ł −−ŁŁ Ł −ŁŁ ý Ł ¼ Ł ¦ Ł −−ŁŁ Ł ŁŁ −Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł \ ][ ][ \ ][ Ý −− ¼ Łð ý ¦ Ł −ŁŁ ¼ Łð ý ¦ Ł −ŁŁ ¼ Łð ý ¦ Ł −ŁŁ −Ł Ł Ł
17
!
Ł Ł
¦ ððð ýýý ðý \\ ¦ ðð ýýý ðð ý
¼ ¼
bass on the downbeat of m. 16, while the accented first syllable of “Sün-den” is inflected by the darkening dip of G to G Ü (two of the most important pitches in the dyad); even the normally unaccented second syllable of “Sün-den” turns upward to the beginning pitch in slight emphasis, albeit on a weak beat. The same pitches to which these words are sung in mm. 15–16 are reiterated in the postlude, the C Ü in the vocal line of m. 16 now consigned to an inner voice in order to compress the motive as a descending chromatic figure within the bounds of a major third (B Ü –G Ü). This postlude is not “pure” or “abstract” music: we are meant to attach specific words to the instrumental strains and to realize that the persona mulls over the words and what they represent over and over, as if trapped by them.86 The final tonic chord in m. 20 with B Ü in the topmost voice simply stops on what might otherwise be another repetition of the motive in a manner that is markedly un-final-sounding . . . a pause, not an end. It is surely for this reason that Wolf begins “Peregrina I” without any piano introduction. Like Schubert, Wolf was prone to establish the tonality, important harmonic elements, the principal musical material, and the atmosphere of a song in the introduction; on those infrequent occasions when he dispenses with an introduction in the Mörike songs, it is for a reason. For example, “An eine Äolsharfe” begins with recitative so that the song proper might start with the winds’ arrival, while “Auf eine Christblume I” and “Charwoche” perhaps lack introductions so that the solemn acclamations at the beginning (“Tochter des Walds, du Lilienverwandte,” “O Woche, Zeugin heiliger Beschwerde”) can receive greater emphasis. Introductions customarily stand in a carefully plotted relationship – not necessarily repetition – to the postlude, the two instrumental passages forming a frame around the lied; here, the poetic persona refuses to see “death and sin” at 50
Songs of love and madness Ex. 2.1(b)
Wolf, Peregrina II, mm. 1–8 Ziemlich langsam
!
¹ − Š − −−−− ¼ Ł Ł ð ][ ¦ ðð Ý −− − − −− Ł − Š − −−−−
4
Ł ¦ Ł −Ł −Ł ¦ ŁŁ
Wa-rum
!
− Š − −−−− ŁÐ ¦ Ł −ŁŁ ý Ł ðŁ Ł \\ Ł Ý −− − − Ł ŁŁ −−Ł ðð −− − Š − −−−− Ł ý Ł Ł
7
- mal nun
!
¦Ł ¹ Ł
(sehr innig) ¹ Ł Ł ¾ Ł Ł ý
ÿ
¹ Ł Ł ¼ ð ][ ¦ ðð Ł
Ł ¦ Ł ¦−ŁŁŁ ý Ł ðð Ł Ł Ł \\ ŁŁ − ððð ýýý
Ge-lieb
-
te,
denk’
Ł ¦ Ł −Ł Ł −−ŁŁ
Ł Ł −−Ł Ł ich dein auf ein
-
¹ Ł Ł ¦ Ł −Ł Ł ŁŁ −−Ł Ł ¦ Ł −Ł Ł ŁŁ ý −−Ł Łý Ł ¦ Ł ð ¼ ¼ \ Ł Ł Łý Ł ¦Ł Ł Ł Ł −−Ł Ł ð Ł ý Ł Ł
Ł Ł Ł mit tau
Ł Ł Ł
Łý -
send Tra¨
¦Ł -
nen,
− ¹ Ł Ł −−Ł Ł ¦ Ł Ł −Ł Ł ¦ Ł −Ł Ł −−Ł Ł Ł ý ¦ Ł Š − −−−− ¼ Ł Ł Ł ðý ð \ cresc. [ ¦ Ł − Ł Ł Ł ¦ Ł Ł ¦ Ł Ł ¦ Ł Ý −− − − Ł −Ł ðý ¦ð −− Ł
the beginning and can see nothing else at the end. (With hindsight, one looks back at the beginning of the vocal line in mm. 1–2 and realizes both that “death and sin” were there from the start and that the persona dodges them when he evades G Ü on the chromatic linear descent from the same B Ü that bounds “Tod und Sünden” a few moments later; it is en route to the word “treuen,” “faithful,” that the singer bypasses the darkness of G Ü .) A classical relationship between introduction and postlude is not possible in such a poetic world, and Wolf dispenses with an introduction altogether, thereby placing even greater architectural weight on the bridge between songs. In a lied which not only lacks an introduction but also any piano interludes in the body of the song, the postlude is given a status all its own, peculiar to this dyad. Anyone who hears or plays this song is struck by the rhythmic inexorability and seamlessness of the piano part, especially the ritualistic solemnity of mm. 1–12. The slow, measured motion of a religious processional, bearing the worshipper from the outer reaches of the nave towards the sacramental heart of mystery, here leads to sin-stained erotic ecstasy (Ex. 2.2). The vocal prosody coils and winds its way above or within this 51
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Ex. 2.2
Wolf, Peregrina I, mm. 1–8 Sehr getragen
¦ Ł −Ł Ł Ł −Ł Łý Ł Ł ¦ Ł Ł ¹ Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł
(innig) − Š − − ¹ Ł Łý
!
− Š −−
Der Spie
gel die-ser
Łý ŁŁ ýý
ŁŁ −ŁŁ ýý
Łý \ Ý −− Ł ý − Łý − Š −− Ł Ł Ł
Ł ý Ł Ł
Łý −− Ł ý − Š \ Ý −− ŁŁ ýý − Łý
ein Wi
-
Ł ŁŁ ýý Ł \\ ŁŁ ŁŁ ýý Ł Łý
treu-en, brau - nen Au - gen
Ł Łý
Ł ŁŁ
4
!
-
cresc.
der-schein;
Ł Ł ŁŁ Ł
Ł ŁŁ ýý Ł Ł
Łý Łý
ŁŁ ŁŁ ýý ][ ý Ł −Ł ¦ ŁŁ ý
ist wie von in-ner’m Gold
Ł Ł ýý Ł Ł Ł ŁŁ ýý Ł Łý
¹ −Ł Ł Ł ¹ −Ł Ł ¦ Ł −Ł Ł −Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł tief aus dem Bu-sen scheint-er’s an - zu-sau Łý Łý Ł −Ł ý − Ł Ł ý ŁŁ −− ŁŁ ýý Łý Ł −Ł ý −Ł −Ł ý Ł Łý ŁŁ − ŁŁ ýýý ŁŁ −ŁŁ ýýý ŁŁ −− ŁŁ ý ŁŁ ŁŁ ý −− ŁŁŁ ýýý ŁŁŁ −ŁŁŁ ýýý
Ł Ł ŁŁ Ł Ł
gen,
−Ł −Ł ŁŁ ŁŁ
Ł ¹ Ł Ł Ł ²Ł Ł Ł −Ł Ł ý Ł ð dort mag solch Gold in heil’ - gem Gram ge-deihn. −8ŁŁvaýý Ł ŁŁ ýý ŁŁ Ł ý −− ¦ − ŁŁ ýý Ł ý Ł − ð Š ¦ ŁŁ Ł Ł ¦ Ł ŁŁ ýý ŁŁ \\ ŁŁ ýý ŁŁ Ł Ł ýý Ł Ý −− −−ŁŁŁ ýýý ŁŁ −Łð Ł Ł Łý Ł − −Ł ý Ł Łý Ł ð − Š −−
7
!
almost unchanging rhythmic pattern, in which almost every downbeat or mid-measure harmony is repeated as an anacrusis to the next harmony; despite the slow tempo (sehr getragen), the anacruses are engines to drive the song relentlessly forward. Where this dotted rhythmic pattern is altered in m. 8, it is in order to permit cadential resolution of the multiple appoggiaturas in the inner voices, evocative of a Baroque chorale, at the words “heil’gem Gram gedeihn”: holy music for holy sorrow. But cadence – rare in this song – does not mean cessation of motion; this is the only cadence in twenty bars whose resolution is not elided with the beginning of another section (the other two cadential articulations lead to the passage on the dominant beginning in m. 13 and to the postlude), and even here, one notes that Wolf places the B Ü major chords of resolution in the last half of m. 8 in the higher tessitura and with the chord-voicing of the transitional passage in mm. 9–12, not at the lower level of the Baroque-style penultimate harmonies. The shift of 52
Songs of love and madness register and spatial arrangement creates impulsion forward despite the harmonic relaxation of tension. The holiness which the persona had thought to find does not provide more than the briefest place of rest, and the processional rhythm carries us immediately thereafter to still greater destabilization, a barrage of chromatic seventh and ninth and augmented sixth chords “resolving” each time to yet another seventh chord. The inner turmoil aroused by the “night gaze” pervades the processional until it can no longer be maintained. (In deference to Mörike’s prevailing iambic meters, most of the phrases in the vocal line begin after the downbeat. Only in mm. 11, 13, and 15, at the adjective “un-[wissend]” and the verbs “willst” and “reichst” do we hear downbeat emphasis, the effect all the greater for the rarity.) There is no pause for the piano anywhere and no structural repetition, but rather inexorable through-composition in an idiosyncratic formal structure based on transformed reflections; taking his cue from Mörike’s mirrors in which meanings change, Wolf too built mirrors within and between his two songs. For example, the E Ü to B Ü progression in the first section (mm. 1–8) is followed by its mirror image in the second section (mm. 13–20), the prior progression reversed, B Ü to E Ü , and the former holiness, fidelity, and gold transmuted into fire, sin, and death. In “Peregrina I,” the invocation of golden holiness deep within the heart impels harmonic motion to richer, warmer depths, to intensified G Ü major harmonies in mm. 5–6. The third-related harmonic locations, G Ü and B Ü , are both reflected in mirror image in the transitional passage in mm. 9–12, as the persona is drawn deeper into night, while the incendiary (“entzünden”) phrase on the dominant (mm. 13–16) is a harmonic battle zone between tones belonging to the two spheres. G Ü attains its fullest meaning in “Peregrina II” as the principal tonality of the song, and in the sudden turn to this key at the end of m. 4, one can hear something akin to a conversion-experience. The one-bar circular motif from the postlude of “Peregrina I” comes back in “Peregrina II,” not on the rooted tonic chord of E Ü , but on the six-four chord of G Ü in mm. 13–14, once again, in the piano alone. It is to this harmony, Desire itself bound up in a harmonic function which draws close to ending but is not final, that the lovers leave the house of innocence. One detail at the beginning of the song is ironically reminiscent of Brahms, although the contexts are different. In “Von ewiger Liebe” (despite his anti-Brahmimentum, Wolf grudgingly conceded that this was a good song), Brahms sets the word “fester” (stronger) in the maiden’s proclamation “Unsere Liebe ist fester noch mehr” to a harmony that is anything but “fest” – chromatic and destabilizing – in order to underscore the young woman’s self-delusion. The young lout whom she loves has just attempted to ditch her by means of a “noble” offer to abscond, lest her reputation be besmirched, and Brahms tells us in no uncertain terms that “ewig bestehen” is not in the cards. Nor is fidelity a trustworthy quantity in “Peregrina.” The first chromatic harmony in the piano, the C Ü –F tritone between the soprano and bass on the downbeat of m. 2 at the adjective “treuen,” tells of erotico-chromatic deception. So does the descending chromatic line in the voice, evocative of erotic surrender and passion’s complexity; one can assert triadic purity only for the duration of a single measure (m. 1), the piano’s processional chords rising upwards to the heavens, but the voice that sings of mirrors already tells of passion’s “night gaze.” “Peregrina I” is filled with smaller reflections as well. Motivic and intervallic mirrors 53
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs abound: the bass line in mm. 3–4 (C–B Ü –A Ü ) is conjunct with a vocal phrase beginning with the same pitches in reverse, while the “inner gold” E Ü –G in the vocal line of m. 3 is an inverted echo of the right-hand pitches just before it. The G–C–F rising fourths in the right hand of mm. 1–2 are echoed in mm. 3–4 and reflected in the vocal line at the words “ein Widerschein,” lest anyone miss the multiple mirrors already at play. The vocal phrase outlining a G Ü major triad in m. 5 (“tief aus dem Busen scheint er’s”) sounds simultaneously with its retrograde high in the right-hand part, which is then repeated in m. 6; much the same is true of m. 7, in which the vocal pitches B Ü –C–C –D are elided with their retrograde in the right hand, and the bass progression G Ü –F becomes the vocal line at the words “heilgem Gram gedeih’n.” Retrograde and inversion are music’s mirror images, especially where both forms exist simultaneously – which is “real,” one asks, and which mirrored? – and such a concatenation of them is hardly coincidental. As flames leap up in mm. 13–16, banishing the processional rhythms altogether, we hear more mirrors, fragmenting or fusing what came before. The descending chromatic triplet motives in the right-hand part of mm. 13–16 are fragments in rhythmic diminution of “der Spiegel dieser treuen, braunen Augen,” and the vocal gesture of “anzusaugen” in m. 6 is echoed in transposition at the words “ich soll kecklich” in m. 13. The heightened Ü III harmonies are woven into the last half as well; the final vocal phrase, for example, with its magnificent sweep spanning an octave and a half, outlines a tonic E Ü chord (“mir den Tod”) in the interior but surrounds and inflects it with the prominent pitches from the Ü III area (G Ü , C Ü ). And the two descending leaps of a sixth in the vocal line will become, in the next song, two unforgettable ascending leaps of a sixth, always a special gesture in Wolf. Throughout the postlude/prelude, the pitch A recurs as a passing tone in an inner voice. When the introduction to “Peregrina II” (a halt-and-lame prolongation of the onebar figure from the postlude of I into two bars) turns to the new tonic G Ü , A becomes the Ü III of the new key and the tonal location of “gestern” and the brightly lit room within the mind; A major is easier to notate than an inundation of double-flats, and its brightness is in apt contrast with the dark barrage of flats before it. Wolf lifts the piano part into the treble register for the evocation of childhood but restores the low bass at the words “tratst du, o Bildnis mitleid-schöner Qual.” Not only is she the ground and fundament of the persona’s being, but she belongs to adult experience, and the ethereal registers of childhood are no longer appropriate; upon her entrance, we return as well to G Ü major, its reappearance underscored by the pedal-point on low G Ü throughout mm. 25–29 (Ex. 2.3). “Gestern” is a memory, drenched in heightened awareness of her, even when the poet tells how he fled to childhood in the futile attempt to escape her. In his obsessive repetitions of a motive whose contours are always strongly discernible wherever it might be placed, Wolf tells of grief ’s insistence and of the poet’s dependence upon Peregrina’s presence as the essence of his art; that the figure slips downward, that it is pervaded by passing tones as if perpetually en route, seems only apropos. “Peregrina II” is spun entirely from repetitions of the one figure, disposed in an ABA tonal structure in which the returned A section is almost unvaried in the piano. “Tausend Tränen” and “lautes Schluchzen” are thus made parallel, the song a tape-loop of tears which keep coming back. The A section returns at the words “Fremd saßen wir”: this is the “answer” to the question in lines 1–4 of the first stanza/the first A section. At the end, Wolf 54
Songs of love and madness Ex. 2.3
Wolf, Peregrina II, mm. 16–29
² ¦¦¦¦¦¦ ²² ½
− Š − −−−− ½
16
¼
²Ł Ach,
Ý −− − − ððð −− ²² Š ² ¦Ł Ł
!
!
!
² ¦¦¦¦¦¦ ²² ¹ Ł
¦ ðððð
77777777777777777
!
− Š − −−−−
² ¦¦¦¦¦¦ ²² ½
Ł ¦ Ł Ł Ł ² Ł
¹ ¦Ł ge
-
stern
l l l l Ł Ł Ł ²Ł ¦ Ł ²Ł Ł Ł Ł ¹ \\ (einfach) Š ¹ Ł Ł Ł ¦ ŁŁ ² ŁŁ Ł
in den hel - len
¦ ŁŁ ¦ Ł ý Ł ² Ł Ł Łý Ł Ł
¦Ł Ł
¹ Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł ¦¦¦ −−−−−− Ł Ł ¦ Ł Ł Ł Ł Kin - der - saal, beim Flim-mer zier-lich auf - ge-steck-ter Ker - zen, l l l l l l ¦ ²²² ¦ − Ł Ł Ł Ł ¦ ŁŁ −Ł ŁŁ Ł − ² Ł Ł ¦ Ł Ł ² Ł ¦ Ł ¦ − −−−− Ł Š ¦ ŁŁ Ł ŁŁ ¦ Ł ¹ ¹ Ł ²² ¹ ¦¦¦ −−−−−− ¹ Ł Ł −Ł Š ² ð ŁŁ ŁŁ ¦ ŁŁ ŁŁ ¦ ŁŁ ŁŁ ŁŁ ¦ ŁŁ ²Ł Ł ²Ł Ł 22 21 −Ł − Ł −−Ł Ł ¦ Ł Ł Ł Ł ¦ Łý Ł Ł Ł Ł Š − −−−− ¼ wo ich mein selbst ver - gass in La¨rm und Scher - zen, l l l l l l l l Ł Ł ¦ Ł Ł −Ł Ł −− −− − ٹ Ł ¦ Ł Ł −Ł Ł Ł Ł −ŁŁ −−Ł ý Ł −−Ł −ŁŁ ¦ Ł ŁŁ ¦ Ł −Ł ¹ Š − \\ \ − Š − −−−− ¹ ŁŁ −ŁŁ ¦ ŁŁ ŁŁ ŁŁ ¦ ŁŁ ý Ł ¦ ðŁ Ł ¦ Ł ¹ ŁŁ −ŁŁ ŁŁ ŁŁ 25 24 ð − ÿ ¹ −−Ł Łý Ł Š − −−−− ¼ Ł Ł Ł 20 19
Ł Ł
l l −− −− − ŁŁ −−−− ŁŁ Š − − Š − −−−− ¹ −−ŁŁ Ł ŁŁ Ł
l Ł ¦− Ł Ł ¦−¦− ŁŁ ŁŁ Ł Ł ¦− Ł ][ \\ Ý ¹ Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł −−Ł ŁŁ Ð
tratst
¦ Łl − Łl ¦ Ł −Ł
du,
o Bild
-
nis mit - leid -
Ł ¦ Ł −Ł Ł ŁŁ −−−− ŁŁ Ł ¦ Ł −Ł Ł ŁŁŁ ¦ ŁŁŁ ŁŁŁ ŁŁŁ ŁŁŁ −− ŁŁŁ ŁŁŁ ¦ Ł ŁŁŁ ŁŁŁ Ð
55
Łl Ł
−− Ł −− Ł
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Ex. 2.3 (cont.)
−−Ł Ł − Š − −−−− Ł Ł Ł
28
¹
- scho¨ - ner Qual;
!
Łl −− −− − Ł Š − ŁŁ Ý −− − − ¦ Ł −− Ð
¦ Łl ¦Ł
Ł ŁŁ
− Łl −Ł
Ł ŁŁ
¹ −Ł Łý es war
Łl Ł ŁŁ Ł
ÿ
ŁŁ Ł
Ł Ł dein Geist,
l ² Łl ¦ Łl ² Łl −− Ł Ł ¦ Ł −Ł Ł ŁŁ ¦−¦− ŁŁ ¦¦ ŁŁ ²Ł ¦Ł ²Ł −− Ł Ł ¦ Ł −Ł Ł ŁŁ −− ŁŁ ŁŁ ŁŁ ŁŁ \\\ ² ŁŁ ² ŁŁ ¦ ŁŁ ¦ Ł ¹ ² ¦ Ł ¦Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł ¦Ł Ł Ð ¦Ð
sets Mörike’s last words of the poem to the figure as it appears in mm. 13–14 in the piano, the sounding emblem of love and loss. The persona repeats the declamatory repeated low D Ü s of “Fremd saßen wir” for the words “verließen wir das [Haus]” (the end of the section echoes its beginning), but it is the spotlight Wolf shines on the final words “das Haus” that makes the ending unforgettable (Ex. 2.4). Wolf clearly knew that the word “house” was of great significance, but it is my belief that he misread it, if only partially. The yearning leap upwards of a sixth from the fifth degree of the chord to the third degree (avoiding the root of the harmony) at the words “dein Geist” in m. 29 reappears here, a gesture reserved for those two places only, both of the eloquent intervallic leaps set to six-four chords. The equivalence is unmistakable. Hearing this passage, one remembers that the composer could never share a house with the woman he loved; whether this was something he could actually have tolerated, “domestic” not being the first adjective that springs to mind when one thinks of Wolf, he must have longed on occasion for togetherness acknowledged openly and housed under one roof. Perhaps this is why he invests the last two words of Mörike’s fourth Peregrina poem with such intensity. Although Wolf gives the last “word” in the piano to the Peregrina figure, to desire haunted by sin and death (the ending of “Peregrina II” mirrors the end of “Peregrina I” and is just as un-final in its effect), it is that transcendent leap of longing at “das Haus” that we most remember. If it is not Mörike’s meaning, the song was, after all, Wolf ’s to do with as he saw fit, and the beauty of the gesture is its own justification. That it might have a subtext in Wolf ’s own life makes it all the more moving. Why Wolf might have omitted three of the Peregrina poems is a conjecture that begins with a divagation to another Mörike poem drenched in the same guilt originating from the same source. In 1826, Mörike wrote a poem as a new ending for Ludwig Tieck’s drama Leben und Tod des kleinen Rotkäppchens (Life and Death of Little Red Riding Hood), which Mörike’s brother Adolph had staged as a domestic puppet theatre performance.87 The poem does not appear in any of the anthologies and was not published until after Mörike’s death, perhaps because it is an appendage to a play by someone else (Mörike did not even give it a title) and perhaps because it had too much that was personal in it; one wonders whether the family members who took part in the puppet theater, especially Luise, recog56
Songs of love and madness Ex. 2.4
Wolf, Peregrina II, mm. 39–44
Ł − Š − −−−−
39
½
¼
ritard.
½
¼
Ł Ł
Erstes Zeitmaß
¹ Ł Łý
und Hand
¼ Ł ¦ ðŁ Ł ¹ ¦ð [[ Ł Ł ¼ ŁŁ ðý
− Š − −−−− Łý
Ł
ð
das
Haus.
immer ein wenig zuru¨ckhaltend
lie
!
¹ Ł Ł
-
ssen
wir
Ł Ł ¦ Ł −Ł −− −− − ¹ Ł Ł ¦ Ł − Ł ŁŁ −¦ ŁŁ ý Š − \\ Ł Ý −− − − − − Ł Š Łðð −Ł ¦ Ł ŁŁ
ver -
Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł ŁŁ −−Ł ¹ Ł Ł ¦¦ ŁŁ −− ŁŁ ŁŁ −¦ ŁŁ ý \ ŁŁŁ ¦ ŁŁ Ł Ł ŁŁ ¦ Ł ŁŁ Ý Š ŁŁŁ Ł Ł Ł ¦Ł ÿ
½
Ł ¹ 3 Ł Ł ¦ Ł −Ł Ł Ł ¦ Ł Ł ¦ ÐŁ ðð ýý Ł ŁŁ ð ý Ł ¦Ł ¼ \\ Ł Ł − ¦ Ł Ł Ł ð ðð Ý ¼ ðð ð Ð 777777777777777777777
42
in Hand
77777777777
!
¹ Ł Ł ¦ Ł −Ł Ł Ł − Ł ¦Ł Š − −−−− ¼ ð piu` [ Ł Ł −Ł Ý −− − − ¼ ŁŁŁ ŁŁŁ − ŁŁŁ −− ¼ ðý
¹ Ł
nized the origins of the torment pervading this extension of the fairy tale.88 At the beginning, elfin spirits lament the death of Little Red Riding Hood, whose bloodied white hands and feet and red cap they have just buried, but then console themselves that she will soon be among their company, will dance through the woods and the meadows with them. In the second section, the ghost of the wolf, who was shot for his crime, wanders wearily through the forest seeking expiation from his victim’s spirit. It is against his nature, and he does not really want to do this, he says, but desire for rest impels him. When he sees her ghost at the end of the poem, he tells her not to fear him: [Rotkäppchen und Wolf] (section 2, lines 64–70 of 70) “Sieh her! ich bin mein eigner Schatten Und muß vor tiefem Schmerz ermatten. Du aber bist wie eine Blume nun, Die wandelt durch den Wald, wie sel’ge Geister tun Ach gib in deiner Seligkeit Ein Zeichen nur, daß mir dein Geist verzeiht! – Du winkst mir zu? . . .”89
Little Red Riding Hood and the Wolf “See! I am my own shadow and must grow weary from deep sorrow. But you are now like a flower that wanders through the forest, as blessed spirits do. Ah, in your blessedness give me just a sign that your spirit forgives me! – You beckon to me? . . .”
There is no answer, and he cannot tell whether she gestures to him or what it might mean . . . and there the poem ends. This is the Peregrina-guilt, the Peregrina “Unanswered Question,” in mythification so painful it bleeds. One remembers Maria’s accusation that 57
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Mörike had “shamed” her and no longer wonders to find the poet assuming the voice of the most famous sexual predator in fairy-tale lore, the wolf who preys on an “unwissend Kind.” The real Maria Meyer was the antithesis of the Biedermeier ideal – every dangerous, anti-bourgeois passion comes under her sign. The more Mörike banished her from his life, with a rigor not typical of his personality, the more persistent she became in the realm of art, a “Wiedergängerin sui generis.”90 The purpose of Maler Nolten was to assert that Eros can never be socialized, thus sparing Mörike from the subterranean presentiment that failed courage, his family’s influence, and his sexual anxieties might have tipped the scales, but the ploy did not work, and Mörike punished himself from within his own poetry for the rest of his life. In the final analysis, it did not matter that Maria was clearly disturbed and that Mörike was young, that loving her would have required brooking formidable family opposition and society’s disapproval. He did love her, and he did cast her out. What Mörike abjured, Wolf did not. From his different time, place, and personality, the fin-de-siècle composer took on Sexus und Tod in some of their most dangerous (if commonplace) manifestations in late nineteenth-century Viennese life, that is, sex with a prostitute as a young man, followed in adulthood by a longstanding affair with a married woman. Although Bible-thumping, fire-and-brimstone moralists might have condemned Wolf and Melanie Köchert for their affair, the double standard in matters of adultery and the church’s role in limiting or prohibiting divorce put the pair in an impossible bind. When she became Wolf ’s lover, Melanie was a middle-class Hausfrau with daughters to raise (how must she have felt, given the expectation that she inculcate bourgeois sexual morality in her children?), and she knew that the church and society would condemn her if they knew of her love for this man. It must have required great courage not just to embark on the affair but to continue for some nineteen years, and the secrecy, the uncertainty, the mental turmoil caused by flying in the face of convention eventually killed her as surely as syphilis killed Wolf, after more than five years of suffering; the chronicle of his torment from September 1897 to February 1903 makes harrowing reading. A witness to every stage of his agony, Melanie fell prey to guilt and grief following his death, repeatedly calling herself “a bad wife,” a sinner beyond redemption. In 1906, three years after Wolf ’s death, she killed herself by jumping from the third-floor window of her home, leaving the house that was the site of her lawful marriage forever – the free fall of “unbehauste Eros” into Tod. Condemning herself as her husband had not, she enacted her own Verstoßung, the most final of all. When Wolf set the Peregrina poems to music, the affair with Melanie had already begun and was still a secret. Heinrich Köchert did not discover the truth until 1894, and when he did, he was remarkably generous (none of these people was small-minded); he did not subject Melanie to the Peregrina-like Verstoßung of an unfaithful wife, but that was still a possibility in 1888. That Wolf and Melanie were aware of the consequences society could impose on adulterous liaisons is made crystal-clear in a paragraph from one of Wolf ’s “public” letters to Melanie, not the private correspondence destroyed after their deaths, but a letter Heinrich could read. The letter is from 6 October 1894, after the revelation of Wolf ’s and Melanie’s affair: 58
Songs of love and madness How glad I am that I have added something to your pleasure with Stauffer’s letters. Not everyone will, to be sure, agree with such confessions, but we are not numbered among those moral cowards who shrink timidly from every natural emotion and try anxiously to paste fig leaves over all nakedness. Pious souls may lament all they want about how Stauffer blasphemes against customs and morals; he still remains one of the most admirable figures of the fin-de-siècle by virtue of his heroic nature and the tragic fate to which he, an energetic and strong-willed man, was forced to succumb. Even so, one also has to have experienced certain things in order to penetrate with deeper understanding the mysteries of these kinds of psychological occurrences.
In the early morning of 24 January 1891, a Florentine chambermaid found the thirtythree-year-old Swiss artist Karl Stauffer (1857–91) dead of a chloral overdose in his room. Scornful of convention from his youth, he had embarked on a psychologically fraught affair in late 1889 or early 1890 with Lydia Welti-Escher, the wife of one Emil Welti, who was the son of a powerful member of the Swiss Bundesrat. (Did Wolf, I wonder, read about the battles between Lydia and Cornelia Wagner, the latter briefly Stauffer’s fiancée, and find it reminiscent of the similar war between Melanie Köchert and Frieda Zerny, the latter briefly Wolf ’s mistress earlier that same year in 1894?) The vengeful Weltis saw to it that Stauffer was first thrown into the Carceri Nuovi in Rome, then into the madhouse of San Bonifazio in Florence, while Lydia was eventually transferred from a Roman insane asylum to one in Switzerland until divorce set her “free.” Disgraced, poverty-stricken, alone, she killed herself on 12 December 1891 by opening the jet of a gas heater in her hotel bathroom. The cause célèbre riveted much of Europe at the time, all the more so when Stauffer’s prison poetry and letters were published one year after the artist’s suicide by a Berlin writer named Otto Brahm, who had known Stauffer and Lydia personally.91 It was this work which Wolf both read and sent to Melanie after they could perhaps have met the same fate or, at the least, similar disapprobation from society . . . and he knew it. Implicit in the letter to Melanie are gratitude to Heinrich for not acting as the Weltis had done and a loving acknowledgment of Melanie’s courage. Reading this letter and reflecting on its content brings one back, if by a circuitous route, to Peregrina. Was Wolf perhaps psychologically unable to compose the other poems in Mörike’s cycle, not because he found them too mysterious, as he claimed, but because the themes of a “marriage” outside of society’s strictures and the casting-out of a “sinful” wife struck far too close to the bone? Were the poems he did set bound up with echoes from his own experience? Did the brown eyes gleaming with reflections of inner gold and the invocations of sexual sin in “Peregrina I” impel analogies with the brown-eyed Melanie and the adultery which put them both in danger? Did the dream of love’s return in Wolf ’s “Peregrina II,” its grief bursting the bounds of convention, perhaps awaken thoughts of forced separation from Melanie, should their affair be discovered, and the ghost of passion past that might then haunt him? We cannot know, of course, but the sense that Wolf ’s own knowledge of “these kinds of psychological occurrences” informed his compositional decisions with respect to the poems born of Mörike’s love for Maria Meyer is intriguing, to say the least.
59
Chapter 3
Agnes’s songs: the fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman
The fictive insane, male and female, are stock characters in late eighteenth- and nineteenth-century writings across the literary spectrum from highbrow to lowbrow. Goethe’s depictions of insanity in Wilhelm Meisters Lehrjahre and Torquato Tasso join forces with less exalted (but still notable) works such as Christian Heinrich Spiess’s Biographien der Wahnsinnigen (Biographies of the Insane) and downright trashy (but influential) “Gothick” novels populated by Bedlamites galore, many of them inspired by Matthew Gregory (“Monk”) Lewis’s spine-tingler Ambrosio, or, The Monk.1 History was cooperating mightily with the trend, since the French Revolution and the Napoleonic Wars gave Europeans ample opportunity to survey madness writ large over the landscape, and so too was science, which generated an outpouring of hysteria theory and re-conceptualizations of madness during the Enlightenment and the nineteenth century.2 Novelists and poets, opera librettists and playwrights, all took note, among them Mörike, whose character Agnes in Maler Nolten represents certain early nineteenth-century notions of female hysteria leading to madness. That Mörike both subscribed to certain misogynistic characterizations of women and yet understood that women were trapped by the ignorance imposed on them, with terrible consequences for everyone, adds to the novel’s complexity. En route to her death, Agnes sings, and she does so in part because Goethe had made doomed young women sing before her. The creation of an hommage à Wilhelm Meister – published, as coincidence decreed, the year of Goethe’s death – seems an over-determined act for this writer who once told his fiancée Luise Rau that he particularly loved to hear her singing the Mignon songs “So laßt mich scheinen” and “Kennst du das Land.”3 Mörike professed his great admiration for Wilhelm Meisters Lehrjahre on numerous occasions, but the other side of such reverence is competition, whether or not the latterday writer could ever admit it.4 In place of Goethe’s abused child of incest, her behavior disturbed and disturbing,5 Mörike invents not one but two women who go mad in Maler Nolten (to some critics in Mörike’s day, this was de trop6): the gypsy Elisabeth, whom we have already encountered, and a forester’s daughter named Agnes, whose path to madness is traced in detail throughout the novel. Mörike stacks the deck against Agnes: not only is sexual maturation impeded by Protestant ideals of angelic purity before marriage, but she is multiply the victim of a “nervous disorder” (diagnoses of Nervenkrankheit were applied in monolithic fashion for “diseases which nobody chuses to own,” as one eighteenth-century writer put it7), of Elisabeth’s baleful influence, and of calamitous circumstance. She is in 60
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman part typecast from the contemporary medical lexica in which gynecology and psychophysiology joined forces to define every aspect of women’s behavior as sexually liminal; men too could suffer from “nerves” but in masculinized forms (for example, Mörike’s own psychosomatic gastric disorders), whereas women were typically rendered helpless by their hysteria, in a mirror of their social powerlessness. Agnes exemplifies a “worst-case scenario” of the “Hysteric’s Progress” as the medical establishment then defined it, beginning with childhood paranoia and culminating in madness, and her creator denies her any counsel. Without mother, sister, or friend to help her, trapped by strictures on mind and body alike, a disturbed child becomes an even more disturbed woman. Although she does everything in her power to remain “the chaste one,” as the Greek derivation of her name implies, she can only do so at the expense of her sanity. Goethe’s Mignon, crippled of speech, is only expressive in song, and so too is Agnes, who begins to sing as she starts her descent into madness; before it founders, the soul finds a voice. Nolten and Agnes, we learn, were affianced when young, but during his absence at court, her once-blond hair has turned chestnut brown – not the black-brown hair of female sensuality in German folklore, but darker than the blondness of fairytale princesses – and she has learned to sing. Her newfound musical abilities signify, not sexual experience, from which the frightened Agnes shies away, but sexual awareness, and it is in part the suppression of that awareness which drives her mad. Unable to speak of things taboo, the mad Agnes intermingles speech with song in a manner which both imbues the sung words with heightened significance and makes of them works of art. The paradox of fashioning ordered artistic structures from the chaos of reason’s overthrow, suggesting that art and truth well up from the unconscious when civilizations’s bonds are broken, was surely one attraction of “mad songs” for those who wrote them; the horror-struck Laertes, on hearing the flower-bedecked mad Ophelia’s songs, proclaims the paradox in act 4, scene 5 of Hamlet: “Thought and affliction, passion, hell itself, / She turns to favour and to prettiness.” Siren-like, the madwoman holds center stage – and the scenes in which Agnes sings resemble theatrical tableaux – and transmutes into melody what she cannot say, the songs a compound of lamentation and diagnostic recollection. “A document is madness,” Laertes continues, “thoughts and remembrance fitted,” and Agnes sings just such documents en route to her Ophelia-like death by drowning. Agnes sings five songs in Maler Nolten, two shortly before her descent into madness (the songs are untitled in the novel, but later included in the poetic anthologies with the titles “Der Jäger” and “Agnes”) and three from within it (“Lied vom Winde,” “Seufzer,” and “Wo find’ ich Trost?”). One of them – “Der Jäger” (The Hunter) – poses as a pre-existing folk song selected by Nolten for Agnes to sing in company, while the other four are equally divided between secular topoi and tortured variations on geistliche Lieder. Songs of faith are converted into songs of faith’s insufficiency in “Seufzer” (Sigh) and “Wo find’ ich Trost?” (Where Can I Find Solace?), and composers did not flock to them as they did to the lament given her name in Mörike’s anthology and the singular prayer “Gebet” (which Agnes does not sing, but speaks in one of her mad scenes), a poem later augmented for inclusion in the anthologies – see chap. 5 for a discussion of this song. By retaining the character’s name when he transferred the lament from Maler Nolten to the collected poems, Mörike invited curiosity about her identity, and one can speculate that some of the composers who 61
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs set “Agnes” to music, including Wolf, might have known the prose context and shaped their settings accordingly. As with Goethe’s Mignon and Harper songs, the experience of hearing or performing Wolf ’s settings of Agnes’s mad songs is altered when one knows more about the character in the novel and about the early nineteenth-century realities she embodies. But Wolf composed his songs for reasons different from Mörike’s. The writer both challenged Goethe and, in Maria Meyer’s wake, tried to prove that no one of either gender is spared Eros’s destructive power; Goethe salvages his male title character for a useful life to come, but not so his inheritor, as we shall see. Wolf, however, was possibly challenging Brahms when he set “Agnes” to music, and he found in the religio-erotic anguish of “Seufzer” and “Wo find’ ich Trost?” the stuff of Wagnerian echoes, Parsifal in particular. Mörike would not have approved. “ M I R K R A N K E N B L U T W I L L N I C H T S M E H R G E L I N G E N ” : WO M E N, S E X , H YS T E R I A , I N S A N I T Y
In a letter of November 1831 to his brother Karl, Mörike wrote that his hopes for success as a novelist would depend more upon the second half of Maler Nolten than the first. From the end of the interpolated shadow-play Der letzte König von Orplid (The Last King of Orplid) in Part I on, everything was livelier (“lebendiger”), he declared; in particular, the title character Theobald Nolten’s visit to his fiancée Agnes’s home in the forest and “the little songlet [the double diminutive of “kleine Liedchen” is noteworthy] ‘Rosenzeit, wie schnell vorbei’” would, he thought, have great appeal for female readers. The statement is two-edged. The burgeoning female readership for eighteenth- and nineteenth-century novels was often derided for lack of taste, for preferring frivolity and the sensational to serious literature, but male writers paid heed to the market and tuned their works accordingly. And Mörike surely knew that many women would find in Agnes’s story a mirror of their own lot in life, of all that was frightening to women in the prospect of marriage, the consequences of women’s dependency upon men, and the desolation of abandonment. He had reasons for creating such a character – he had, after all, caused a woman to be abandoned – and for tracing the course of female mental illness: he must have wondered what made Maria Meyer into the person he encountered in 1823, and the abandoned woman is thereafter a recurring persona in his poetry. To his brother Karl in 1831, Mörike continues: That the fiancée later becomes newly mad and thereby dies cannot be otherwise. I have prepared it sufficiently beforehand. A certain Dr. Zeller, who is much occupied with psychiatry and will shortly become a physician at just such an institute, has read the novella and found the psychological progression that I have pursued with Agnes from p. 66 on to be quite correct and well established; now I do not regret having treated this part of the history in more detail than I was willing to do in the first draft . . . and perhaps more than the superficial reader will thank me for knowing.8
“Superficial readers” would be, he realized, content with characters catapulted into madness by their creators with no concern for the origins of their insanity. One notes with a certain amusement that the concern with accuracy was ex post facto, that Mörike wrote the novella first, then checked with a psychiatrist, but one also sees the justifiable pride that his depiction was correct. 62
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman Agnes is more the portrait of a dilemma than of an individual, a demonstration of one of the ways in which Eros can kill. Mörike lived at a time when cultured middle-class young men, whatever wild oats they might sow before betrothal, expected marriage to an angel of the household who should be a virgin before her wedding day and a Mary-motherfigure after it. Larkens, in love with Agnes (one thinks irresistibly of Bauer in love with Maria), characterizes her as “das goldreine Christengelsbild” (the golden-pure image of an angel of Christ), not as a flesh-and-blood creature allowed to experience erotic desire, while the adolescent Nolten loved Agnes for her “outward purity of mind, childlike modesty and unbounded submissiveness.”9 The adjective “outward purity” already implies that one cannot expect inner purity, a tell-tale touch of the misogyny Nolten musters as a defense against the prospect of marriage to a person he no longer loves. Mörike knew just such expectations, idealizations, and rationalizations from personal experience; Agnes is in part a re-writing of his adolescent love for his cousin Klärchen Neuffer, a love he tried to recapture in his courtship of the pastor’s daughter, Luise Rau, his fiancée during the creation of Maler Nolten.10 One of Agnes’s names is Luise; the real Luise saw herself and Mörike in the novel and was not pleased. One can hardly blame her. Agnes exemplifies the figure of the Hysterika or female hysteric in German literature, and Mörike carefully traces the etiology of her disorder throughout Maler Nolten.11 Living as he did in the wake of Enlightenment redefinitions of many psychological disorders and doubtless forced by the Maria Meyer episode to confront the phenomenon of emotional dysfunction in the woman he loved, Mörike incorporated psychiatry’s then-current fascination with this variable affliction – it was often anything prejudicial about female sexuality that medical men wished somehow to categorize – into his novel. A pedagogy which dictated that women should be intellectually ignorant and sexually pure (the two are contingent) and that the obligatory purity should be policed by shame led to speech and actions which can be construed as the only expression possible for the “guilty secret” of sexuality. The premium placed on pudeur not only forbade open speech about sexual matters – the loquacity of the hysterical state is a consequence of dammed-up words finding an “out” at last – but even forbade inner recognition of sexuality as pleasurable. Proper women could not admit to themselves, much less to others, awareness of sexual feelings. One sees the proscriptions on awareness spelled out in pedagogical manuals on the proper upbringing of young women, such as Joachim Heinrich Campe’s Väterlicher Rath für meine Tochter (Fatherly Advice for my Daughter), originally published in 1789 and going through seven editions by 1809.12 Campe had earlier written a manual for young men called Theophron, and its popularity had encouraged the author to give equally prolix advice – 703 pages of it – to young women. The floodtide of verbiage is directed at middleclass girls, not aristocrats, who followed other codes of behavior, and it preaches “Kinder, Kirche, Küche” (children, church, kitchen) at great length. To be wife and mother was the only destiny Campe believed proper for middle-class women, whom he enjoined to shun “glittering artistic achievements,” great learning, writing for publication,13 or aping the aristocracy. Only housewifely arts were suitable for this “ewig gegängelte und ewig getäuschte Geschlecht” (ever led about by the nose, ever deceived sex).14 Campe recognized that bourgeois women who thus fulfilled their duty led restricted lives and were subjected to many injustices; far from rosy pictures of “happily ever after,” he invokes the 63
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs thankless tasks, the difficulties of pregnancy, the illnesses and deaths, the troublesome chores of tending small children and educating older ones, but a “pure heart” would, he advised, sustain them in life’s worst storms.15 One can almost hear him thanking God that he was not born a woman. Most of all, Campe preached “Schamhaftigkeit und Keuschheit” (modesty and purity, the word for “modesty” derived from “Scham” or “shame”) as the wellspring of true happiness for women. As if speaking to his own daughter, he wrote, “May that day be the last day of your life and mine, the most sorrowful for you and for me, on which you – but away with this hideous thought!” In a treatise where “under the heart” is the most precise anatomical term allowed, he does not commit to paper the words “pregnant out of wedlock.”16 He was more frank than some because he believed that “young cooks who are told not to mix hemlock into their dishes must be told what hemlock is and how to recognize it,” but frankness had its limits.17 Most women, confronted with the prospect of physical pain in sex and childbirth, would shrink away from the thought of marriage, but God has given humanity, Campe writes, a “Fortpflanzungstrieb” (reproductive drive) to provide sensuous pleasure sufficient to compensate women somewhat for the miseries of bearing children. The consequences of succumbing too soon to this “Naturtrieb,” however, are disease and death. “Have you ever noticed that sickly, sorrowful, withering, nervenkranke [italics mine] maiden who, in what should have been the bloom of her life, sinks down her head, like a young plant attacked by worms, and goes to an early grave?”, he asks, and then invokes the “living corpses” he saw once in Berlin at a “hospital for lewd persons,” doubtless a ward for syphilitics.18 How should young women avoid this dire fate? They should, Campe advises, ban from their souls all thoughts of a sexual nature; maintain utmost purity not only with others but by oneself (this was an age obsessed by the supposed ill-effects of masturbation); avoid the opposite sex; and obliterate bodily awareness by every means possible.19 Agnes does not even receive this much instruction, but is left to struggle with her fears in isolation. Those fears are massive: she does not, we discover, wish to marry Theobald, not because she does not love him but because she is afraid of sex. Hysteria marks a knowledge that does not know itself, and it reaches crisis proportions in Maler Nolten at the prospect of the wedding night. When Nolten and Agnes were first affianced, we are told that Agnes nearly died of her “nervous disorder,” emerging from the shadow of death a changed creature. At times sunk in reflection, at times given to hectic merriment, at times lapsing into sudden fits of crying, she repeatedly tells her father that she is not good enough to marry Nolten.20 Nor does he want to marry her. At the beginning of the novel, Theobald tells Larkens that he [Nolten] is angered by Agnes’s supposed attraction to her cousin Otto; she is sullied in his eyes because she has demonstrated a capacity for sexual feelings not permitted a modest, unmarried maiden.21 He will not convey his displeasure to Agnes directly, however, only to her father, who pleads his daughter’s illness as an excuse. Although he is portrayed as well-meaning, the forester echoes society’s negation of women’s thoughts and feelings, and Agnes has no one to whom she can turn when he fails her. Nolten’s anger, furthermore, is fabricated self-justification. In love with the Countess Constanze von Armond, he is ready to snatch at any excuse to break off the engagement and, in self-serving fashion, to make the rupture her fault. 64
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman One of the most revealing scenes in the novel occurs shortly after Agnes’s nervous breakdown, when she and her father attend a comic play in a nearby town. Agnes, Mörike writes, laughed for the first time in weeks, but that night, she comes to her father’s room and wakes him up. At first unable to speak, she tells him of a dream (theatre in “real life” has unleashed the theatre of the mind) in which Theobald begs her not to leave him, then nearly suffocates her with his kisses. The ambivalence of desire – that she wishes to leave him is the unspoken subtext – and the image of the self smothered by the invading Other finds expression in a classic dream; Freud could not have devised a better example of sexual fear. In tears, Agnes declares that “he [Theobald] will find his happiness with another [Elisabeth]” but she cannot tell him so. Agnes’s father is, astonishingly, reassured, believing that the dream is a sign of renewed longing for her fiancé rather than its opposite. Even when Agnes says, “Theobald must not be my husband, and then I may continue to love him,” he fails to understand, although one could hardly state more forcefully the desire to be saved from sexual experience. The next morning, her father finds her writing a letter to Theobald and insists on reading it; the refusal to allow her any privacy is compounded by his blundering intent to interfere.22 The extent to which the troubled sexual identities of the early nineteenth century were dependent on suppressing the female voice that speaks its needs is all too clear in this episode in which she attempts to make those around her understand, but to no avail. Only in madness is she free to speak, when her encoded truths are considered nothing more than pathetic raving. The trap Mörike constructs around her is indeed impermeable, inescapable. A H A RV E S T O F L A M E N TAT I O N : “ RO S E N Z E I T ! W I E S C H N E L L VO R B E I ”
The scene in which Agnes sings “Rosenzeit! wie schnell vorbei” is a way station before the collapse into madness. Nolten has come to visit Agnes and her father at their home, where Agnes’s thanks for his gift of a little clock (emblematic of time running out for both characters) induce guilt – ”But my soul! what were you thinking?”, Agnes says, “this is an ornament for a Countess, not one of us!”23 The forester tells the young man that he must seize the moment and announce the wedding right away, but Nolten is panic-stricken: “Not yet!”, he cries, “I beg you, Papa, for God’s sake, not now.” When Agnes appears, she is dressed in her finest white dress, “radiant, beautiful, like a young princess,” and with flowers strewn in her hair, a reminiscence both of the white-clad Mignon singing “So lasst mich scheinen” shortly before her death and of the mad Ophelia with flowers in her hair. Taking up the mandoline, Agnes reminds Nolten of an occasion in the past when she had asked him if he was offended by her ignorance of the “beautiful arts” other women knew (music and flower-painting). Although Nolten reassured her, the couple paid a visit to the vicarage a few days later, and Agnes was asked to sing; as she did, she fancied the pastor’s daughter was mocking her and was so distressed that she could hardly finish the song. While someone else played and sang after her, she went to a window where she could not be seen and wept, the episode revelatory of her vulnerability and her longing to be “musically accomplished,” to be like other young women. After her illness, Agnes tells Nolten, she has studied music assiduously, aided by her cousin Otto. 65
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Her father does not want to hear of her distress and requests a happy song, which Agnes obediently sings in a voice “strong and sweet, moving more easily in the low than the high registers,” the lower tessitura evoking both the amateur voice and sensuality (higher voices are construed as celestial, lower voices as more earthly). While she sings, Nolten averts his gaze until she bids him turn and look at her; he does not wish to see her as a musical/sexual being. The second song, “Der Jäger,” comes at Nolten’s request because he expresses a liking for this “folk song,” in which a hunter frets about a quarrel with his sweetheart. Hunters are hyper-masculine creatures in German folklore, but this one swiftly capitulates to his beloved and rushes back to apologize, fantasizing as he goes about the kisses that will end the matter . . . another merry song, but fraught with serious overtones in this context.24 Through the surrogate of music, Nolten seems thereby to signal his desire to rectify his former repudiation of Agnes, to return to her after absence and distance like the hunter in the song, and yet at the same time to pin the blame for erotic distress on woman’s unknowable nature; the hunter’s references to the sweetheart’s “trutzen” and “nagen” are classic designations of shrewish female behavior. That Nolten makes Agnes sing a song about the kind of sexual desire neither one of them is capable of feeling for the other suggests a complicated compound of wish-fulfillment on one hand (he should want to be her hunter, should want to kiss her) and an underlying, unspoken spice of cruelty on the other (“This is how lovers feel about one another, but neither of us feels this way”). Wolf subsequently devised for his setting of “Der Jäger” a left-hand part filled with linear tritone intervals, created by the lower chromatic neighbor note to the fifth degree above the initial bass tone, often varied by other intervals – augmented fifths, minor sixths, even ninths and tenths – but with tritones predominating. If this is a comically exaggerated version of “trutzen” and “nagen,” it is also diabolus in musica repeated over and over, perhaps a hint to the cognoscenti of psychological darkness beyond a mere lovers’ spat. Agnes’s father calls for another song, but Agnes is no longer capable of feigned merriment. Closing the book of folksongs, she speaks softly to Nolten while striking an occasional chord on the harmonium, chords which develop into a sorrowful prelude to the song, “Rosenzeit! wie schnell vorbei.” Here, traditional images are put to sad, startling use in yet another attempt to convey her distress to those who should help her, but do not. The song at an end, Agnes, in tears, flings herself into Nolten’s arms, saying, “Be true! you are mine! I have remained yours!”, but Theobald can only reply, tepidly, “I am yours,” the discrepancy between the magnitude of her distress and the lukewarm quality of his response marked. Mörike not only builds a trap around Agnes, but makes her aware that the walls of an inferno are closing in. If Ophelia and Agnes are akin in some ways, the differences between Elizabethan and nineteenth-century conceptions of female madness are also embodied in these two characters. Unlike Agnes, Ophelia does not sing until she is completely mad, and her fragmentary songs come from someone more spirited and more knowledgeable about sex than Agnes, although Hamlet has infected Ophelia with his sexual revulsion, born not of ignorance but awareness of lust’s seamier side literally too close to home. Accusing all men for their sexual predation and broken promises, the mad Ophelia punishes them with songdeath, transferring to them the fate she is about to inflict on herself, and then mourns them 66
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman wildly before departing to kill herself. Agnes, however, goes mad after diagnosing herself in accord with nineteenth-century notions of female incapacity, attributing her melancholy to causes both external (the beloved’s betrayal) and internal (“sick blood”). Infidelity she can try to deter with her desperate pleas to Nolten, but there was little or nothing she could do about the latter. The phrase “Mir kranken Blut” (“my sick blood”) is Mörike’s variation on an old topos – the abandoned woman’s lament – in accord with medical superstitutions of the day. The excess blood in the female body made women, so said medical lore, susceptible to “nervous disorders,” the uterus supposedly linked to the brain in a two-way traffic whereby cerebral disturbance could cause menstrual disturbance and vice versa. According to the gynecological establishment, female reproductive organs were so precariously poised that little was required to create psychological impairment, and the phrase “sick blood” is thus indicative both of mental illness and female fertility gone awry. The danger of madness is all the greater if a predisposition to nervous disorders is manifest early in life;25 Mörike, determined to allow Agnes no escape, tells of childhood paranoia in which she believed herself watched perpetually by forces in a vast educational project.26 If this is Mörike’s inversion of Goethe’s Tower Society in Wilhelm Meisters Lehrjahre, it is also a moving psychological detail. In the wake of her mother’s death, Agnes appropriates the entire cosmos to watch over her after all possibility of maternal nurture vanishes: Rosenzeit! Wie schnell vorbei, Schnell vorbei Bist du doch gegangen! Wär’ mein Lieb nur blieben treu, Blieben treu, Sollte mir nicht bangen.
Time of roses! How quickly gone by, how quickly you are gone! If my lover had only stayed true, stayed true, I would not be afraid.
Um die Ernte wohlgemut, Wohlgemut, Schnitterinnen singen. Aber ach! mir kranken Blut, Mir kranken Blut Will nichts mehr gelingen.
As they merrily harvest, merrily, the women sing. But alas, my sick blood, my sick blood, will let nothing go right for me.
Schleiche so durchs Wiesental, So durchs Tal, Als im Traum verloren, Nach dem Berg, da tausendmal, Tausendmal Er mir Treu’ geschworen.
So I slink through the valley meadow, so through the meadow, as if lost in dream, to the mountain, where thousandfold, thousandfold, he swore he would be true to me.
Oben auf des Hügels Rand, Abgewandt, Wein’ ich bei der Linde; An dem Hut mein Rosenband, Von seiner Hand, Spielet in dem Winde.
Up there at the edge of the hill, deserted, I weep by the linden tree. On my hat, the rosy ribbon he gave me plays in the wind.
Agnes assumes a traditional identity, “the abandoned maiden,” in this song, and therefore Mörike fashions it from traditional emblems of lamentation. The linden tree where the 67
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs maiden weeps in the last stanza is the archetypal place for lovers’ rendezvous and for bereaved lovers to mourn since the time of Walther von der Vogelweide’s thirteenthcentury Minnesong “Under der linden” (Under the Linden), and roses are the ages-old symbol both of youthful passion and death at a young age, the brief, brilliant blossom quickly vanished. Mörike likens the sudden scattering of a rose’s petals to the death of his brother August in “An eine Äolsharfe” (To an Aeolian Harp), and a similar nexus of Love and Death beckons here as well in the elegiac acclamation “Rosenzeit!” The song is a variation on the antique scenario in which a bereaved lover sings of lost love and Echo responds, the voice mysteriously separated from the persona and assuming its own shadowy identity to mock or mourn (act 5 of Monteverdi’s L’Orfeo comes to mind); from the hilltop or mountain where such scenes take place, the singer can survey time and space, can put the experience of loss in perspective. Here, Agnes is her own Echo, repeating in the refrains those things which most haunt her: the rapidity with which love vanishes, the longing for constancy, the contrast between other people’s health and happiness and her sickness of mind, and the thousandfold oath of fidelity. The starkest refrain is the single word “abgewandt” in the final stanza, with its overtones of alienation, estrangement, and aversion (“Das wolle Gott abwenden,” “God forbid,” one says). Agnes knows herself barred from life’s blessings by powerful forces, and in her song, she isolates the word as she herself is isolated. Mörike echoes more recent literary forebears as well, with trace-elements of Goethe particularly prominent. The “Rosenband” of the last stanza recalls Friedrich Klopstock’s “Das Rosenband” (The Rosy Ribbon, which Schubert set to music in 1815, D. 280), whose lovers are bound for eternity with rose-colored ribbons of love, but here, the ribbon is left to flutter in the wind symbolic of inconstant, destructive passion. Agnes’s word “tausendmal” (a thousand times) is probably an echo from Goethe, who was prone to indicate the innumerable as “tausend” or multiples of “tausend,”27 while Mörike’s line “Schleiche so durchs Wiesental” is another (deliberate?) reminiscence of Goethe, whose Harper tells of a “schleichendes” lover in “Wer sich der Einsamkeit ergibt” (Whoever Surrenders to Loneliness) and sings “An die Türen will ich schleichen” (I Will Creep from Door to Door) in his vision of a bleak, mad future. Agnes is, in one sense, the Harper’s latterday daughter, and she shares with him the furtive motion of those who feel they have no rightful place in the world and cannot claim it in stance or stride, but must slink about, hiding from those more fortunate.28 One of the most evocative details in “Agnes” – the harvesters in stanza 2 – had special significance for Mörike. In a letter to Luise Rau, written from Plattenhardt on the afternoon of 2 September 1829, he told her that the sound of nearby threshers brought back memories of the person he once was and bygone times: In the barn across from my window, I hear threshing: a familiar . . . sound, to whose beat my heart so contentedly accords itself. I always associate an entire throng of bittersweet memories with its tones, going back deep into my childhood. This same monotonous melody, renewed each autumn – how wonderfully it takes me by surprise in these momentous times! It reminds me of everything that happened to me these past twenty years, what I have found and lost, what has changed for me and what is unchanging . . . Still, one is fortunate if one can speak of what has vanished, if all-disillusioning Time has not stripped all the golden surface from the forms, if one dares summon the courage to walk through the old, magic gardens and to lean one’s dreaming forehead on many a crumbled monument . . . So it is with me, so can it be for you too.29
68
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman This was Mörike the didact, teaching the young woman he believed to be teachable (as Maria Meyer was not) the lessons of poeticized life, in which seemingly inconsequential things can open worlds in the mind. Mörike the pastor and Luise the pastor’s daughter both knew the Biblical metaphor of human life as the sowing of seeds which ripen, blossom, then are winnowed in death,30 and so does the pious Agnes, for whom harvest bespeaks a fruition she cannot have. The female “Schnitterinnen” (harvesters) sing as they reap, but she, crippled by pathological fear, can expect no such happy music. Mörike twists the knife in the wound when he immediately thereafter brings back Theobald’s brother-inlaw, happily married to Nolten’s sister Adelheid, who is about to bear her first child. Nolten and Agnes cannot hear enough about the unseen Adelheid (her example is all the more powerful for her absence), especially Agnes for whom Adelheid seems “the very pattern of true womanhood” in her marital bliss and pregnancy. When the pastor whom Nolten and Agnes are visiting improvises a merry song, “Frau Adelheid / Zu dieser Zeit / In ihrem Bettlein reine / Muß ferne sein . . . / Doch ist sie nicht alleine. / Herr Storch hat ihr Besuch gemacht, / Darob ihr süßes Herze lacht” (Mrs. Adelheid at this time must be far away in her clean little bed . . . and yet, she is not alone; Mr. Stork has paid her a visit, which makes her sweet heart smile), in order to awaken the echoes at a well-known spot for such soundeffects along a mountain path, we hear the happy antithesis to Agnes’s echo-song.31 But it was the latter which attracted composers.32 Of more than thirty settings in the nineteenth century, only those by Brahms and Wolf have remained in the standard recital repertoire, although several of the songs by now-forgotten Kleinmeister deserve revival (in particular, Ferdinand Hiller, op. 46, no. 2; Robert Emmerich, op. 12; and Alexis Holländer, op. 6, no. 2). Of the prior settings, Brahms’s op. 59, no. 5 of 1873 is probably the only one to which Wolf paid any heed, and one doubts he liked it. Brahms treats Mörike’s poem as a variation set, each stanza sounding the same music but with the instrumental figuration varied; in the final stanza, the composer floods the otherwise diatonic accompaniment with chromatic passing tones, and the dissonances surrounding the harmonic progressions imbue the end of the song with considerable tension. Brahms would later do something similar in his arrangement of “Maria ging aus wandern,” another lament of a woman’s – the Virgin Mary’s – sorrows, in the 49 Volkslieder; again, the diatonic bedrock suggests the fixity of grief, the songs pinned in place, while the plethora of chromatic passing tones conveys the restlessness of a sorrowful mind. Whether or not Brahms had read Maler Nolten, he understood that the persona in this poem is psychologically disturbed, and he made her “sick blood” manifest primarily in metrical fluctuations. To see a song published in the early 1870s with triple-meter and duplemeter time signatures side-by-side must have been startling for some, and to hear such deliberate instability is still striking. Where Brahms indicates a prolongational accent on the second beat in a triple-meter measure – and he does so often – the sense of rhythmic surety is undermined all the more; bars with strong downbeats are little or no help in such a context of flux. Both as a means of characterization and as a way of emphasizing the metrical contrast, Brahms does not indicate a single rest in the vocal line of stanza 1, but instead crowds triple- and duple-meter measures one after another without pause (Ex. 3.1). The singer must gasp between phrases in order to take in enough oxygen to live through the stanza, which is, furthermore, marked “Con moto.” Claustrophobic panic 69
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Ex. 3.1
Johannes Brahms, Agnes, from the Lieder und Gesänge, op. 59, no. 5 (1873), mm. 1–17.
− Con moto Š − /0 .0
!
− Š − /0 .0 ŁŁ ýý Łý [ Ý −− / . Ł ý 0 0 Łý
!
Ł Łý Ł Ł Łý Ł 5 \ poco [ Ł Ł − Łý Ł − Š Ł − Š − ² ŁŁŁ ýýý \ Ý −− Ł ý Łý
bist
Ł ŁŁ poco [ Ł Ł Ł Ł
Ł ŁŁ Ł
\ Ł Łý Ł
− Ł Š − Ł ý Ł blie - ben treu,
blie - ben treu,
− Ł Š − ŁŁ ýý Ł ² ŁŁ ý Ý −− ŁŁ ý ŁŁ ŁŁ − Š − Ł ý
14
Ł Ł
blie - ben treu,
!
− Łý Š − ŁŁ ýý
Ł Ł Ł ²Ł
ý Ý −− ŁŁ ý
Ł Ł Ł Ł
du
Ł ŁŁ
Ł Ł Ł Ł
9
!
Ł ŁŁ
ŁŁ ŁŁ ýý Ł Łý
schnell vor-bei,
ŁŁ ýý \ý Ł Łý
Łý
poco
ÿ
ÿ
Ł Łý
Ro - sen-zeit,
ŁŁŁ
ŁŁ ýý Łý
² ŁŁŁ
poco
Ł Ł Łý doch
Łý Łý
Ł Ł Ł
Ł
[
Ł
Ł ý Ł Ł
wie
schnell vor-bei,
ŁŁŁ
ŁŁ ŁŁ ýý Ł Łý Ł Łý Ł Łý
² ŁŁŁ ýýý
Ł Ł Ł Ł
Ł Ł
Łý Łý
Ł ŁŁ Ł
Ł
Łý
Ł
Ł
ge - gan - gen!
Ł
Wa¨r mein Lieb
Ł ýý ŁŁ ý
ŁŁ Ł
ŁŁ Ł
² ŁŁŁ
¦ ŁŁŁ
Łý Łý
Ł Ł
Ł Ł
Ł
¦ ŁŁŁ
ŁŁŁ
nur
ŁŁ ýý Łý
ŁŁ ŁŁ
Ł Ł
Ł Ł[ −Ł ý
Ł Ł ¦Ł
Ł Ł Łý
Ł
soll - te mir
nicht ban - gen,
wa¨r mein Lieb
nur
poco
Ł Ł −Ł ýý ŁŁ ŁŁ ŁŁ ý ² ŁŁŁ poco [ Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł \ poco [ Ł Ł Ł ý Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł ²Ł
blie - ben treu,
ŁŁ ýý \ý Ł Łý
[
soll - te
Ł Ł Ł ²Ł
Ł ŁŁ
Ł Ł Ł Ł
poco
Ł Ł
70
[
ŁŁŁ ¦ ŁŁŁ Ł Ł
¼
¦ ŁŁŁ ŁŁŁ ŁŁŁ ýýý
Ł Ł
−Ł ý
Ł
mir
nicht
² ŁŁŁ
ŁŁ −ŁŁ ýý Ł Łý Ł Ł
Ł Ł
Ł ¦ ŁŁŁ ŁŁŁ ŁŁ
Ł Ł
Ł
ŁŁ Ł
ban - gen.
² ŁŁŁ Ł Ł
Ł Ł Ł Ł
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman does not permit amplitude of phrase structure – and this is, of course, a deliberate compositional decision, not naïveté about singing on Brahms’s part. There are other musical indices of anguish as well. Although the harmonic palette is somewhat restricted, Brahms includes numerous unresolved, uncompleted references to C minor in this G minor lied, even beginning the song with C minor chords easily mistaken for tonic (he clarifies the matter in m. 2). The first instance of heightened plagal harmonies occurs at the words “Wär’ mein Lieb’ nur blieben treu” (If my love had only stayed true), as if the subjunctive – the kingdom of wish – had occasioned this brief allusion to another realm (but it too would be a more tragic key) without ever establishing it fully. At the center of each strophe, Brahms fluctuates between tonic and emphasized subdominant harmonies; just when he seems to be back in tonic again and about to end the strophe, the final word of the stanza, “bangen” (to fear), jolts the music away from G minor, the appoggiatura on the downbeat of m. 12 heightening the accented first syllable of the verb like a small shudder of fear. The hoary cliché that Brahms’s lieder are instrumental in conception is disproven by the plenitude of text-driven details, such as the “schleichendes” variation of the piano figuration for the third verse, especially the offbeat bass pitches in mm. 39–40. Furthermore, Brahms treats the echoes as just that, repeating the music of the first statement of the echoed words literally but with a sudden hush to piano, followed by an immediate return to the forte dynamics regnant elsewhere in stanza 1. The sudden alternation between loud and soft heightens the effect of breathlessness. This Agnes is unlike any other in the nineteenth century, with more energy than the stricken creature other composers would have us hear; she can even begin with a fanfare in the piano and sing the initial acclamation in an almost proclamatory manner. Was Wolf ’s setting perhaps in reaction to Brahms – an “unwriting” of op. 59? In place of the earlier Agnes, metrically awry and harmonically somewhat tame, Wolf devises harmonies whose warping – this is a remarkably sour, ambiguous, shifting pitch-world – tells of encroaching madness, while his rhythmic patterns mimic the monotonous rhythmic rocking of the mentally ill. Throughout the song, but especially from m. 16 onward, Wolf simulates rocking motion in the piano, either in the left-hand part (stanzas 1 and 3) or in both hands (stanzas 2 and 4); the listener who is tempted to rock back and forth in time to this music, especially the slurred figures of the even-numbered stanzas, soon realizes how realistic the simulacrum of this symptom is. The fact that the most obvious rocking pattern begins just after the word “bangen,” as if in response to it, is telling. There is never any cessation of motion in the piano part, no place where the quarter-note tactus does not plod wearily on; this slow, nonstop motion in an unchanging tactus seems a rendering in sound of the combined numbness and restlessness in mental illness. In the novel, Agnes precedes her song with a brief instrumental introduction, and so does Wolf. Before a word is sung, one hears extremity in these strains (the mot juste), all the more intense for being muted; pianissimo and piano dynamics are one way to suggest interiority. Wolf fills the five measures of the introduction (the first of many five-bar phrases to come) with minor ninth intervals (C –D Ü ) in the left hand, the semitone emblematic of lamentation inverted, widened, rising and falling through a range of more than four octaves and obsessively repeated throughout mm. 1–10. One notices the asymmetrical slurring of these minor ninth intervals across the barline and against the indicated meter, the latter 71
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Ex. 3.2
Wolf, Agnes, mm. 1–5 Ziemlich langsam, schwermu¨tig
!
− Š − −−
¦ ÐÐ ð
ÿ
\
Ý −− − ¼ −
Ł
ŁŠ
Ł
Ł
Ł ð
¦ ÐÐ ð
ÿ
ð Ý
¼
Ł
ŁŠ
Ł
Ł
ð Ł ð
ÿ Ý
¼
Ł
Ł Ł
difficult for the ear to determine, given the numbed, quarter-note tactus and the lack of an initial downbeat in mm. 1, 3, and 5. Above the yawning ninths are appoggiatura “sighing figures” (the mirror image of the bass, descending minor seconds above ascending minor ninths) and sustained tones, completing the dominant ninth chord which is the sole harmony of the introduction. Two pitches in the bass, a quarter-note tactus, a single harmony fragmented and recombined – and yet one hears dissonant abysses opening in the mind, the sinews of reason splitting open (Ex. 3.2). Agnes is afraid and says so; in Wolf ’s setting, she is additionally afraid of the tonic, as if coming to rest on F minor and staying there might somehow mean capitulation to that which she most fears, to abandonment and death. There is very little incidence of tonic harmony in this song, and even where it occurs, it is only in the piano, after Agnes’s words at the end of stanzas 1, 3, and 4; she cannot bring herself to finish the first verse with resolution in the vocal line to the tonic and shudders away just short of the cadential goal. Wolf lifts the first syllable of the verb “ban-[gen]” a minor third higher in mid-measure (m. 15), the small ascent intensified by a crescendo, then sinks down a semitone to end the word on the last and weakest beat of the measure. Where we expect the deferred tonic at the beginning of m. 11, we are indeed given F in the bass but as a secondary dominant ninth, one which unfurls in fragments throughout mm. 11–13, similar to the treatment of the dominant ninth in mm. 6–10. Even where the tonic harmony does appear, there is little sense of quietus; the rocking motion continues in the piano figuration, and the shifting non-tonic pitches (the supertonic, flatted supertonic, and submediant scale degrees) blur any sense of tonic surety and drive the song onward. That this continues to the end is one notable feature of a song whose “Wahrheit bis zur Grausamkeit” (truth to the point of terror) is uncomfortable to confront, devoid of merely pretty melancholy and lacking the compensations of virtuosity – lied-madness is not opera-madness. The final chord of the song seems a demonstration of how to make a tonic harmony on the downbeat, in root position, and with tonic closure in the topmost voice sound un-final by virtue of what precedes it. In the silence after the last chord, one listens for the music to start again, unsure whether this is really the end. Those who know the novel realize that it is not, in fact, the end, that a dénouement in madness and death follows this song. What most darkens and destabilizes the postlude is the alternation between G and G Ü that one has heard earlier throughout the first and third stanzas. Although the flatted second degree exerts its traditional gravitational pull downward to the tonic, Wolf unsettles the voice-leading at the end in order to refuse the listener any sense of finality; the G Ü sinks as expected to F in the soprano voice, but the bass moves to the fifth scale degree, the 72
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman harmony thus a tonic six-four chord, and the topmost voice moves upward for the next figure rather than staying on the tonic. This tension between different forms of the supertonic first appears in the setting of the first stanza, where Wolf doubles the singer’s B Ü in m. 6 (the first bar of the vocal part) with the lowered second degree G Ü in the piano, creating a passing Neapolitan sixth harmony to darken the sad acclamation of the “Rosenzeit.” G is reinstated in the next measure, but Wolf then repeats the Neapolitan–to–natural progression even more strongly, framing the two-bar phrase in mm. 9–10 (“Bist du doch gegangen”) with G Ü at the beginning and G at the close. The fragmentary implied Neapolitan underscores the present tense (“Bist”) on the downbeat, while the natural second degree belongs to the past (“gegangen”) on the weak beat. When G Ü reappears immediately after in m. 11, at the start of the second half of the first stanza (mm. 11–15), it is stronger still, present in every measure but the last. Wolf caught – it would be hard not to – the resentment in the words “sollte mir nicht bangen” and sends the vocal line marching scalewise up the dark length of a Neapolitan triad, “mir nicht” emphasized by triplet quarter-notes (“This should not be happening to me”), “nicht” angrily accented on the last, ordinarily the weakest, beat. Fear (“bangen”), however, cancels out anger and sends her music back to the dominant and to G (Ex. 3.3). In one sense, the setting of the first stanza is predicated on the tension between these two different forms of the second scale degree and the gathering strength of its darker flatted manifestation. At the end of the song, it is G Ü that has the final say. There are certain details of Wolf ’s “Agnes” that make one wonder whether the composer knew Maler Nolten, since they would seem to suggest knowledge of the larger context. The relationship between the vocal line and the right hand in stanzas 1 and 3 is one such detail: after the piano’s doubling of the voice when the singer first enters in m. 6, the right hand continues to descend in scalewise motion in m. 7, like ground slipping away beneath the maiden’s feet, while the voice branches off from it in contrary motion for the refrain “schnell vorbei.” When the refrain-words are repeated in sequential transposition downward in m. 8, not only is there contrary motion yet again but voice-exchange (F–G–A Ü /A Ü –G–F), and the compound of the two techniques is then reiterated in mm. 9, 13, and 14 of stanza 1. Half of the stanza’s ten bars feature contrary motion between the voice and right hand or contrary motion and voice-exchange combined (and this all recurs in stanza 3). It is perhaps fanciful to hear in this compositional decision the sounding analogue of Mörike’s masks, mirrors, and ghostly doubles, of identities so confounded that Agnes cannot tell them apart, but Wolf is prone to creating just such parallels between textual content and musical device, and it is at least possible that he did so in this instance. Other details of the musical architecture might also suggest the composer’s understanding that Agnes in Maler Nolten struggles to avert tragedy, that she does not succumb to fatalism and “sick blood” without attempting to save herself. Unlike Brahms, Wolf makes of the poet’s first and second stanzas a bipartite musical strophe, the second half spun from the same material as the first but extensively varied (the bipartite strophe is then repeated for stanzas 3 and 4). In this way, he could distinguish the harvesters’ singing from Agnes’s misery and yet filter the invocation of other women’s good fortune through her unhappiness, never absent for a single bar or beat. With the first mention of the harvesters (“Um die Ernte wohlgemut”) in mm. 18–19, Wolf begins shifting to the relative major key of A Ü , 73
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Ex. 3.3
Wolf, Agnes, mm. 6–17
− \ Š − −− Ł Ł Ł Ł
6
Ro - sen - zeit! wie
!
Ł ð
Ł
schnell vor - bei,
− −ŁŁ ŁŁ Š − −− ðð \\ Ł Ý −− − ¼ Ł Ł −
gan - gen!
!
− Š − −− ŁŁ Ý −− − ¼ −
Ł
Ł
[Ł Ł −Ł ð
\\ Ł Ł Ł ð
ŁŁ ŁŁ
][ Ł
¼
3 −−− Łn − Ł − Ł Ł Š −Ł ð
14
soll - te
!
mir nicht ban
− Š − −− −ŁŁ −Łðý Ł Ł Ý −− − ¼ −Ł Ł Ł −
doch
Ł Ł Ł Ł −−ðð
Ł
du
−ŁŁ ŁŁ ð ð Ł Ł ¼ Ł
Wa¨r’ mein Lieb’ nur
¦ Ł ý Ł ¦ Ł ¦ Ł −ð
bist
ŁŁ ¦ ŁŁ ð ð Ł Ł ¼ Ł
¼
− Š − −− Ł Ł ¦ Ł ½
schnell vor - bei
ŁŁ ðð Ł Ł Ł
¦ ¦ ŁŁ
10
3 −Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł
Ł ð
Ł
−Ł
Ł
gen.
ŁŁ ¦ Ł Ł ¦ Ł ¦ Ł −ð Ł Ł ¼ ¦Ł
¦ ŁŁ
−ŁŁ ðð
¼
Ł
blie - ben
treu,
ŁŁ ¦ ŁŁ \\
−Ł
ð ð −Ł
¼ Ł
Ł
Ł
ÿ
ÿ
¹ Ł Ł ŁŁ Ł ŁŁ Ł
¹ Ł Ł ¹ Ł Ł Ł Ł
Ł Ł
Ł Ł
Ł ¦Ł -
blie - ben treu,
ge -
Ł ŁŁ
Ł
Ł Ł Ł
Ł
but the movement towards this tonality sticks momentarily at the word “wohlgemut.” Wolf first arrests the harmonic motion on an incomplete seventh chord on C in m. 19, a harmony conspicuously lacking the third degree (E Ü or E ) that would clarify its function. When Agnes repeats “wohlgemut” in m. 20 in tragic emphasis on what is not, after all, hers to enjoy, the first syllable of the word brings back the E of the dominant in the tonic F minor. She is not “wohl,” and in bitter awareness begins to slip back to the harmonies of stanza 1. But at the second half of the word, E is respelled enharmonically as the flatted sixth degree (F Ü ) of the relative major, resolving to E Ü as a constituent of A Ü major six-four chords in mm. 21–22 (“Schnitterinnen singen”), the brief assertion of another nearby tonal world confirmed by the secondary dominant at the end of m. 22. It is a conscious act by which Wolf ’s Agnes turns away from wormwood-and-gall melancholy so that she, and we, may briefly hear the harvesters as a harmonic climate of warmth, clarity, and peace. That A Ü major is never firmly established, that six-four chords are associated with longing 74
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman elsewhere in the Mörike songs (as we saw in “Peregrina II”), makes the diatonic brightness of these two measures, their almost total lack of dissonance, a privileged place in this song (Ex. 3.4). If the brightness seems less apposite for the words “Wein’ ich bei der Linde” in stanza 4, one can hear that passage as a recollection of the harvest allotted to others but not to her, a loss for which she weeps. The partial respite from pain does not last long. With her admission of “sick blood,” chromatic tensions return in force, evident first in the barrage of “sighing figures” in the inner voice but eventually permeating everything. What those semitone motives do is sour still more the increasingly chromatic harmonies to which they are attached, beginning with the otherwise diatonic D Ü major triads of m. 23 (the “but, alas” measure which begins the departure from the harvesters’ happy world) and warping still further from there until the musical “blood” is very sick indeed. There is a struggle embedded in this chromaticism: at the parallel spot where the enharmony occurred before (the refrain), we find enharmony again, followed by a quiet battle to win back A Ü major – unsuccessful, but intense. All Agnes can manage is an uncompleted return to A Ü minor; it is the piano which finishes the cadence and then clears away the darkened third and sixth degrees of the minor mode (C Ü , F Ü ) in the interlude (mm. 27–29), returning to A Ü major only in the last half of m. 29. But A Ü major, normalcy, happiness, do not belong here and cannot remain. The music of stanza 1 returns immediately, without pause, in m. 30, and the matter-of-fact way in which the harvesters’ tonal realm simply vanishes is sad. That one can find in “Agnes” the skeleton of folkish simplicity twisted into shapes that are far from simple is Wolf ’s distinctive achievement here. “This,” Wolf could have been saying to Brahms while thumbing his nose, “is what one does with the folklike lied nowadays,” and he might also have wanted to “correct” Brahms’s more robust Agnes, replacing her with a character whose “sick blood” is audible in sick harmonies, voice-leading, form, and rhythm. What he does with the songs of full-blown madness is different – affirmation of Wagner rather than negation of Brahms – and it is to Agnes’s tragic end that we now turn. T H E D E AT H O F AG N E S
Mörike’s novella Mozart auf der Reise nach Prag, several of his stories, and many of his poems have been translated into English,33 but Maler Nolten has not, although it is essential for an understanding of its author. The ending to this “grim story of a quadrangular interaction among three neurotic personalities and a psychopath”34 is filled with songs, all of which Wolf set to music. Knowing their context in the novel adds an extra dimension to one’s experience of the music, and therefore a summary of the final episodes of Maler Nolten seems in order. For a short time after Agnes sings “Rosenzeit! wie schnell vorbei,” a delusory calm prevails, but the interlude is broken by a concatenation of deaths. First, the baron who was like a second father to Theobald suddenly dies, and Agnes reacts to the news of his demise with a numbed muteness she recognizes is pathological. “I see all of you weeping,” she says, “but that isn’t possible for me. Oh Theobald, Father, what is this state I am in? It is as if every other feeling but . . . fiery, painful anxiety is consumed.”35 After the burial, Agnes 75
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Ex. 3.4
Wolf, Agnes, mm. 18–29
− Š − −− Ł
18
Um
!
Ł
Ł
die
Ern
Ł
Ł Ł
− Š − −− ¹ Ł ŁŁ Ý −− − Ł − Ł − Š − −− Ł
21
Ł
-
Łý
te
wohl
Ł
Ł Ł
Ł Ł Ł
ð
Ł
− Š − −− Ł
Ł
¹ Ł Ł
Ł
− Š − −− ¹
Ł − ŁŁ
¹
Ý −− − Ł − Ł
Ł
Ł Ł
− Š − −− Ł
−Ł
½
27
lin
-
gen.
Ł Ł
mir
Ł Ł
Ł
¦Ł ¦Ł
Ł
¼
A
Ł
kran - kem ken Blut Blut
−Ł −Ł
¹
Ł ¦¦ ŁŁ
Ł ŁŁ Ł
ge - mut
¹ Ł Ł Ł
−Ł −Ł
Ł
Ł
Ł ¹ Ł ¹ ¹ Ł
Ł
¹ Ł ŁŁ Ł
−−Ł ŁŁ
-
¹ Ł Ł Ł
Ł ¦ð
cresc.
Ł
wohl
Ł Ł
Ł ð
Łý
¹ Ł Ł Ł
gen.
Ł
¹
¦ Ł − ŁŁ
-
¹ Ł Ł Ł
Ł Ł
kran - kem ken Blut, Blut
!
sin
¹ Ł Ł Ł
Ł ¹
ge - mut,
Ł
− Š − −− ¹ Ł ŁŁ \\ Ý −− − −Ł Ł − −Ł 24
!
-
¹ Ł Ł Ł
¹ Ł Ł Ł
Schnit - te - rin - nen
!
Ł Ł
Ł
-
ber,
ach!
mir
¹
−− Ł ŁŁŁ
¹
Ł ŁŁŁ
Ł Ł
Ł
Ł Ł
Ł
\ −Ł
Ł −Ł
will
nichts mehr
¹ \\ ¦Ł ¦Ł
Ł Ł ge
Ł ŁŁ
¹
Ł − ŁŁ
Ł
Ł Ł
¦Ł ¦Ł
ÿ
ÿ
− Š − −− ¹ −Ł − ŁŁ
¹ Ł Ł Ł
¹ −Ł Ł − ŁŁ
¹ Ł Ł ŁŁ
¹ −Ł Ł ¦ ŁŁ
¹ ¦ Ł Ł ŁŁ
Ý −− − Ł − Ł
Ł Ł
Ł Ł
Ł Ł
Ł Ł
Ł Ł
Ł
Ł
Ł
76
Ł
Ł
Ł
-
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman begs to have the wedding put off because she cannot overcome the premonition that something unusual is about to happen. When she and Nolten bid each other goodnight, she asks him if it is true that “the woman” – Elisabeth – will never come again, but the gypsy does return soon thereafter to set the seal on an already catastrophic dénouement to the novel.36 Agnes and Theobald, accompanied by Theobald’s younger sister Nannette, depart for the town where they plan to live when they are married. The travellers spend the night at an inn where Theobald meets the eccentric, talkative barber Sigismund Wispel, who gossips about an odd man recently arrived in the town. It soon becomes clear to Theobald that the man is Larkens, who has tried to renounce acting and live a “genuine” life but has not made a success of it and is in a bad way. When Theobald and Larkens encounter one another on the street, Larkens runs away to his lodgings and kills himself by taking poison. A local official, the “Präsident von K*,” arranges for the dead man’s burial and invites the party of Nolten, Agnes, and Nannette to stay at his villa, where the grief-stricken trio is introduced to the nobleman’s talented daughter Margot and the gardener’s blind son Henni. It is here that catastrophe strikes. Mörike fills the final scenes with symbols on symbols, ghostly doubles, and foreshadowings. On a sultry afternoon, Theobald wanders through a neatly tended maze in his host’s garden until he reaches the clearing at its center. There, at the heart of the labyrinth, he reads Larkens’s sonnets “An L.” (to Agnes, also named Luise), which Nolten wrongly believes have to do with Larkens’s earlier love for “a pastor’s daughter,” and the Peregrina cycle. When Agnes comes out to join him, the couple take refuge from a sudden thunderstorm under the canopy of a garden shed. Agnes wants to comfort her betrothed for his grief over Larkens’s death, but Theobald explodes with grief and guilt, confessing his love for the Countess, his suspicions concerning Otto, the love-letters ostensibly from himself to his fiancée but actually written by Larkens, who had loved Agnes from afar. Devastated, Agnes takes to her room and will say nothing to anyone. Mörike, who knew that present misery is magnified by unresolved past distress, tells us that “in an instant, the maiden’s heart began to bleed again from a thousand old wounds.”37 Because no one can sleep in the aftermath of such distress, their host tells a ghost story – diversion for the midnight hour – of a young woman married against her will to a man who dies soon after the wedding. When she meets a man whom she loves, a merchant who is separated from her by business affairs in North America, the affianced couple conduct an occult wedding ceremony long-distance, but the extinguished tapers in her bedchamber tell of the fiancé’s death abroad.38 This inset-tale is itself a ghost of Agnes’s and Nolten’s situation, an echo of Theobald’s first betrothal to Elisabeth and of a second betrothal that will end in death. Just then, the company hears “a strange song” outside, and Nolten recognizes Elisabeth’s voice. Panic-stricken at the thought of what might happen to Agnes, he runs out of the room to look for her, but she has disappeared; when they find her, she is lying unconscious under a willow tree. A shattering scene ensues between Nolten and Elisabeth, who claims Nolten as hers. Rejecting Elisabeth’s wild embraces, the distraught Nolten rushes into the house, and the gypsy, waving a dagger in her fist to keep the others from seizing her, disappears into the night.39 We learn later that she dies on the road, but we are not told how or why. 77
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs In the wake of this catastrophe, Agnes goes mad. At first, she is cataleptic, watched over by members of the household (except for Nolten and Margot, whom Agnes will not tolerate, since Margot represents the kind of female learning which had earlier elicited Agnes’s insecurities). Nolten, near-mad himself from grief, bursts out in a tirade of self-pity, whereupon he is reproved and left alone to recover his equanimity. At this moment, Agnes comes into the room, her hair disheveled, barefoot, and speaks, her mad loquaciousness even more disturbing than her former muteness – ”Good morning, heathen! Good morning, devil!”, she says to Nolten. The details of this scene and those that follow echo nineteenthcentury medical descriptions of insanity, such as that by the “gloomy giant of late Victorian psychiatry,” Henry Maudsley:40 an attack of acute maniacal excitement, with great restlessness, rapid and disconnected but not entirely incoherent conversation, sometimes tending to the erotic or obscene, evidently without abolition of consciousness; [also] laughing, singing, or rhyming, and perverseness of conduct, which is still more or less coherent and seemingly wilful.41
The insane Agnes is unable to tell Nolten, Larkens, and Otto apart and cannot even believe Larkens’s death, insisting that “an empty coffin lies in the grave, with only a pair of lumpen rags inside.” Short visits are the mode in the aristocratic world, she declares mockingly, and leaves; thereafter, sexual treachery and fluid, untrustworthy identities are the leitmotifs of her speeches. “Do you know why Theobald, my beloved, became an actor?”, she asks Henni as they are reading the New Testament together. “For two years, he came to me disguised as cousin Otto . . . I didn’t know him and caused him great sorrow. For that I can never forgive myself for all eternity.”42 She asks Margot the Latin word for “spark,” then raves that she can see not just sparks but little green flames in her lover’s eyes and tells Margot, whom she accuses of being another of Nolten’s lovers, to look for them the next time they make love. “I beg you, tell me, how is it when you kiss? Has anyone noticed,” she asks wildly, “that he has the devil in his body? . . . A beautiful Countess was there first . . . You don’t believe me that he is betrothed to the gypsy? If I wanted to, I could name the place where the promise was made and the sign pronounced over it, but good Christians don’t speak of such things.”43 One evening, Agnes asks for her betrothed and embraces him passionately, but cannot believe that he is truly Nolten: “What is whispering by you? What are you saying? I hear two voices – help! help! you trickster Satan, away! I have been betrayed! Oh, all is over with me! The liar has deceived me as my beloved, as if I were not an honest maiden, as if I had willingly let this horror kiss me. Oh Theobald, if only you were here so that I could tell you everything! You don’t know what the snakes do to make my mind crazed, your poor, abandoned child!”44 When she is calmer, she speaks of her death. “A good end, that is what everyone wants at the close, an easy, gentle death . . . I am like a ship beached on a sandy bank, a ship no one can help . . . when the grass grows over me, that will be the end of it.”45 When Nolten leaves, she removes her engagement ring, saying that her mother has taken it, then confusedly imagines that “he” (Larkens/Nolten) has it in his grave. She knows now, she tells Henni, that the wedding will not take place. “I always thought so,” she says, “now it may end when it will; my maidenhood is secure, I will take it to the grave. Between us, I have always wished thus and in no other way to come to Heaven. But I must have the ring.”46 78
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman Soon after, Nannette, Margot, and the President listen to Henni play the chapel organ while Agnes sings. “It seemed to be old Catholic church music . . . at times the organ predominated and at times the maiden’s voice,” Mörike tells us. The most striking piece, we are told, is a Latin penitential song, “Jesu benigne,” in E major (this is the key of Ludwig Hetsch’s setting published with Maler Nolten).47 Mörike cites one verse, translated into German in a footnote – this is the text of “Seufzer” – and tells the reader that three more verses follow. Henni’s organ postlude to the penitential hymn leads into another song, beginning “Eine Liebe kenn’ ich, die ist treu” (I know one love which is true), later entitled “Wo find’ ich Trost.” These are the last words we hear from Agnes, who disappears the next morning.48 After a day of frantic searching, they find her drowned in the forest well. When Nolten returns to the villa two days later, old before his time, glassy-eyed and mute, the President attempts to console him, saying that those selected by Fate for the heaviest sorrows are destined for an especially godly hereafter. Nolten rejects such consolation: life and death are indecipherable riddles, he declares, and he wants no more of “yesterday and today and tomorrow.” The night before Agnes’s burial, a storm arises, and Nolten is awakened at midnight by organ music. When he goes to the old chapel, he finds Henni and the gardener and calls for a candle; not a minute later, father and son hear a loud cry, then a fall, and find Nolten stretched out lifeless at the open door. The next day, blind Henni tells of seeing (how, he cannot say) Elisabeth’s and Nolten’s ghosts locked in a passionate embrace. The piercing glance Nolten’s ghost casts on the living youth is full of misery; the incorporeal lips move, but without distinguishable words.49 Compressed in this fashion, the end of Mörike’s novel sounds very grand-Guignol, complete with ghosts, a Fury-figure, and Jacobean heaps of dead, a confabulation too ghoulishly Baroque to take seriously. But what is mythified here was, is, real. Mörike had seen society’s rejection of women on the sexual margins (he had participated in it), and he knew of religious sublimation of sexuality (his sister Luise). In the real world of Vormärz Germany, women were afraid of marriage and abandoned by men. With this novel, Mörike tried to justify his rejection of Maria Meyer by casting erotic passion as a destructive force, at all times; one questions the totality of the characterization, but no one could deny that Eros can kill. Mörike knew from his own experience the failure of belief in God and the anguish of such failure; religion is no comfort for erotic misery in Maler Nolten, and the afterlife glimpsed at the end has nothing to do with Christianity. Behind the literary tropes, the gypsies and ghosts and haunted chapels, are human realities. O F S I G H S, S I N, A N D Q U E S T I O N S : T WO M A D S O N G S
In her last days, Agnes tries (and fails) to find comfort in religion, and therefore her mad songs are cut from religious cloth. “Seufzer” and “Wo find’ ich Trost” are fashioned entirely or in part from Lutheran hymnody, but what is hymned here is the inability to believe and the failure to find consolation for earthly distress in heavenly remedies. The sources are truncated at the point of despair. The text of “Seufzer” has an interesting genesis.50 In a letter to his brother Karl of 22 February 1832, Mörike tells of finding – when, he does not say – a book of devotional 79
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs songs at a village inn somewhere between Nürtingen and Tübingen.51 “The expression of religious sorrow is inimitably great, moving in its simplicity and as if made for musical composition,” he writes, and then begs his brother for a setting of the poem. “Seek out and strike the holiest strings of your soul and compose with that deep fire in which Mozart set down his Requiem,” he commands Karl (an impossibility, given his brother’s musical limitations).52 Agnes is only hours from her end when she sings this song, and Mörike wanted death-music of the highest quality: Jesu benigne! A cujus igne Opto flagrare Et Te amare; – Cur non flagravi? Cur non amavi Te, Jesu Christe? – O frigus triste!
Kind Jesus, in Whose flame I wish to burn, and to love You, why have I not burned? Why have I not loved You, Jesus Christ? Oh, sad coldness!
In the novel, Agnes sings the verse in the original Latin, and Mörike, for the sake of readers with no knowledge of ancient languages, provides a translation-paraphrase in German in a footnote. A revised version of that paraphrase with the title “Seufzer” subsequently appears in the poetic anthologies, where the Latin stanza is printed before the German text and identified only as an “old song” (“Altes Lied”).53 However, in virtually all editions of Wolf ’s songs and many twentieth-century editions of Mörike’s poetry, the Latin strophe is identified as coming from the Passion hymn “Crux fidelis” by the Merovingian poet Venantius Fortunatus (ca. 540 – ca. 600), a somewhat perplexing misattribution. Mörike did indeed translate two stanzas from Fortunatus’s Easter hymn “Pange lingua,” the translation being entitled “Crux fidelis” because it is with those words that the first of Mörike’s two stanzas (first published in the Nachlaß54) begins, but “Jesu benigne” is not from that famous poem. The first edition of the Mörike songs in 1889 mystifyingly attributes the Latin to Fortunatus, and the error has appeared over and over again thereafter.55 Nine years after Maler Nolten, Mörike pointed the way to some of the actual sources for this text. On 22 February 1841, he wrote to Wilhelm Hartlaub about his discovery of Johann Anastasius Freylinghausen’s (1670–1739) Geistreiches Gesang-Buch. Den Kern Alter und Neuer Lieder, Wie auch die Noten der unbekannten Melodeyen und dazugehörige nützliche Register in sich haltend (Spiritual Songbook, Containing Essential Old and New Songs, also the Notes of Unfamiliar Melodies and a Useful Table of Contents) – one of the most important Pietist hymnals – in an edition from the 1730s.56 Scattered amidst the 1158 pages (impressed by its encyclopedic bulk, he tells Hartlaub how long the book is) were a dozen or so Latin hymns, including “Jesu benigne.”57 Mörike did not, it seems clear, find the hymn originally in Freylinghausen, but since he either could not remember the author, compiler, provenance, and title of the book or else deliberately suppressed mention of it, one is grateful for the later naming of a work that makes it possible to trace the poem’s origins in part and to correct the misattribution to Fortunatus. Freylinghausen’s source for “Jesu benigne” was a small anthology entitled Neuer Helicon mit seinen Neun Musen, Das ist: Geistliche Sitten-Lieder von Erkäntnus der wahren 80
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman Glückseligkeit und der Unglückseligkeit falscher Güter (New Helicon with its Nine Muses, That Is: Spiritual Songs of Piety about the Knowledge of True Happiness and the Unhappiness of False Boons) of 1684 by a scholar-poet named Christian Freiherr Knorr von Rosenroth (1636–89). The collection includes both newly written Pietist hymns and translations of Latin devotional poems by earlier poets, “Jesu benigne” (and Fortunatus’s “Pange lingua”) among the latter. Knorr von Rosenroth cites the Latin text, translates the poem into German, and gives the melody to which the German version should be sung, but identifies the original only as “Aus dem Lateinischen” (From the Latin). Whose Latin, he does not say and may not have known.58 Mörike was passionately drawn to the first verse but tells Hartlaub that he found stanzas 2–4 poetically inferior. The Latin is indeed idiosyncratic: Jesu benigne Gentle Jesus (stanzas 2–4 of 4, all four in the meter known as Adonics) 2. Pelle algorem / et da amorem, / te Drive away the cold and give love, I shall love you with deperibo, / et non peribo. / Ignibus abandon and I shall not be lost. I shall glow with fiery gliscam, / ne persentiscam / Dei ardor, that I may not come to know the ultimate pyre amantis, / rogos damnantis. of God who condemns although He loves. 3. Sunt causae mille, / cur velit ille / semper amari, / semper laudari, / Primus amavit, / et viam stravit / ad se amandum, / ad se laudandum.
There are a thousand reasons why He wishes always to be loved, always to be praised. He loved us first and fashioned the way for us to love Him, for us to praise Him.
4. Dum me creavit, / primus amavit, / dum me redemit, / poenis exemit, / Exemplum Dei / amantis mei / sequar amando, / cor dedicando.
When He created me, He loved me first; when he redeemed me, He freed me from torment. The model of God who loves me, I shall follow by loving, by dedicating my heart.
Mörike makes of the first stanza a self-sufficient poem, enclosed in a bell jar of claustrophobic despair. The poetic persona of the complete hymn can envision a future in which the agony at the beginning will be healed and the suffering mortal who sings these words reunited with God, but that is no longer possible for the persona of Mörike’s poem. If Mörike embarked on this translation in order to include it in the novel, the second, third, and fourth stanzas would not have been appropriate for Agnes’s situation at the end, even if he had liked them as poetry, but there might also have been an element of elective affinity in singling out only the first verse. Remembering Mörike’s inability to reassure his dying sister that he loved Christ wholeheartedly, one can imagine that he might have seen his own face in the mirror of this poem. One doubts Mörike ever expended as much energy on his sermons as he did on the translation of these eight brief lines. In the 1832 letter to his brother, he was particularly concerned about the cry “O frigus triste!”, whose rending quality – ”cutting through flesh and bone” – he wished to preserve in the German, and therefore he tinkered obsessively with the ending en route to Wolf ’s text (“O Reueschmerzen!”, “Falschheit im Herzen! / O Höllenschmerzen!” and “War Eis im Herzen / O Höllenschmerzen” are among the earlier alternatives). The statement in Latin, “I have not burned, I have not loved,” becomes in German the gentler failure to tend, to foster, and it is tempting to see the alteration not 81
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs merely as a search for rhyming couplets (pflegen, hegen) but also as psychologically driven: Seufzer Dein Liebesfeuer, Ach Herr, wie teuer Wollt’ ich es hegen, Wollt’ ich es pflegen! Hab’s nicht geheget Und nicht gepfleget, Bin tot im Herzen – O Höllenschmerzen!59
Sigh Thy fire of love, O Lord, how dearly I would foster it, would tend it! I have not fostered it, have not tended it. I am dead in my heart – oh, pains of hell!
One notes the invocations of God’s fire at the beginning and hellfire at the end, bracketing the strophe on either side, and the stress in each line of iambic dimeters on the first accented syllable. Furthermore, every line ends with an unaccented syllable, the rhythmic effect both litany-like and halting, gasping, with a stop imposed after each line (a rhythmic effect lost in musical setting). “I hope that I haven’t, by all this vacillating, deprived the thing of its first fresh fragrance . . . recite the Latin original aloud for a couple of hours, or a night [!], and the bloom will be restored,” Mörike tells his brother, stipulating that he wants a setting for only one, or at the most, two voices. For Wolfians, “Seufzer” is one of this composer’s ne plus ultra creations. There is, for the faithful, no greater torment than to perceive oneself deficient in love for Christ and hence as irreparably sinful; to tell of such hell, Bach filled his cantatas and Passions with writhing chromaticism, while Wagner’s Amfortas and Parsifal went to the ends of the tonal earth. In their wake, Wolf devises the most deep-dyed chromaticism in his oeuvre for this song about impossibility, about the simultaneous desire and inability to love God. The poetic persona’s enclosure in a torment only partially expressible is something Wolf conveys by encasing the texted body of the song in lengthy piano passages: an eightmeasure introduction and seven-measure postlude frame a mere sixteen measures of texted lied. That texted interior is, despite a few gasping rests in the vocal line, virtually nonstop, as if this slow, sustained cry of agony (the langsam tempo intensifies the effect of the pervasive chromaticism by prolonging it) were being compelled from the singer, the stifling airlessness of this lied one of its most powerful aspects. The implication is that inner agony inflicts pain before the poetic persona can find words for it and that the serpent continues to gnaw when the words cease. Indeed, greater pain follows the withdrawal of language, as if intensified by admission in words. But most of the claustrophobia comes from the tonal language, tortured from beginning to end. If it is characteristic of Wolf to delay arrival at the tonic, he does so more intensively here than anywhere else in his oeuvre, and the denial of tonal terra firma in this context is analogous to the inability to love God; the persona is thus deprived of the “feste Burg” (mighty fortress) that Lutheran theology dictated could only be found in God. From the start, one wonders, “What hell is this? Where are we?” Looking at the key signature and the final chord, one deduces a tonal center on E, but this is remarkably difficult, indeed impossible, to hear at the beginning. The D “leading tone” on the first beat moves, appoggiatura-like, upwards to E, but tonal clarity is denied by the left-hand motion to F , which 82
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman then passes through E to E Ü in m. 2 while the right hand moves up to F : a two-bar voice exchange, rhythmically disjunct to increase the already considerable tension, on the pitches D /E Ü , E, and F . Ascending motion in the right hand is, we see, mirrored askew by descending motion in the left hand. We are told from the outset that this is a world of intervallic mirrors and transformations, where nothing is secure and yet everything derives from the same small cell. Wolfians will hear in “Seufzer” a foreshadowing of Wolf ’s Michelangelo song “Alles endet, was entstehet” of March 1897; in fact, the rising, then falling semitones of the topmost voice in the piano in mm. 9–10 (B–C–E–D ) bear an uncanny resemblance to the “cambiata-figure” reiterated and transformed throughout “Alles endet.”60 Both poems hail from a Hell of one sort or another, and both songs trap the listener in claustrophobic chromaticism, the queasiness akin. Somewhat fancifully, one can hear the “push” towards E in m. 1 – one notes the crescendo/forte accent to the flatted II7 with E in the soprano – as the goal of the poetic persona’s desire, but that desire is frustrated, and the composer embarks on a search for some sort of tonal surety. The medieval origins of the text might well have impelled the hints of Phrygian modality one finds from the beginning, especially evident in the emphasis on C, the subfinalis in Phrygian mode, and on F , the semitone relationship between the finalis and the second scale degree one of the most distinctive features of that mode. (Wolf, one remembers, studied late Beethoven assiduously in his youth – more encouragement to mix modal references into his tonal palette.) Did this composer know that Phrygian mode was associated in the ancient Greek ethos of music with the wildest grief? The simultaneity which finally materializes out of the shifting chromatic voice-leading by the end of mm. 2 and 4 could be described as a dominant seventh of B Ü (were there only sufficient context to clarify the matter), a tritone away from where the key signature and the initial figure in the soprano voice indicate we should or might be. The sustained soprano–bass dissonances, especially the major seventh F–E in mm. 1 and 3, tell of pain, and the progression grinds briefly to a halt in irresolution and confusion. When the same initial figure is repeated, it comes to the same clouded conclusion: this is not the way out of the impasse. In the second half of the introduction (mm. 5–8), the musical protagonist tries other means – sequential motion – to arrive at some sure place to be, the tension rising with the sequences. The omnipresent linear chromaticism is marshaled into an inexorable pattern of one-measure units ascending by semitones; if there is no solid ground, the shape-shifting world is nonetheless rigidly organized. Anguish has its own laws. Ironically, the intervallic fifth relationship between the E Ü in the bass with which m. 4 ends and the A Ü in the bass at the beginning of m. 5 would seem to indicate some sort of tonal definition, but that is not what follows. The voice-leading in mm. 5, 6, and 7, or the first three units of the sequence, culminates each time in the formation of an augmented triad at the end of the measure, emphasized still more by the fourth-beat accents – an electric cattle-prod to jar the motion further upward to the next chromatic link in the sequence (D–E Ü –E ). For tonal processes to be twisted as they are in “Seufzer,” they must still be dimly apparent; here, augmented triads retain their traditional connotation as dissonances created by passing motion in the voice-leading, engines to drive the music forward and indices of great tension. 83
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Wolf conceived the introduction as the poetic protagonist thinking anguished thoughts before he or she finds ordered words for them and therefore brings back the introduction in the texted body of the song . . . but only after the first two vocal phrases in mm. 9–12 at the words “Dein Liebesfeuer, / ach Herr! wie teuer . . .,” the statement that God’s love is an incomparable treasure. Because the persona dwells in the introduction on the inner agony caused by spiritual incapacity, the music of such painful thoughts recurs when the failure of belief is made explicit (“Wollt’ ich es hegen, wollt’ ich es pflegen, hab’s nicht geheget”). For the invocation of God’s “Liebesfeuer,” Wolf devises musical symbolism that is truly chilling. Looking at the bass line of the harmonic progression in mm. 9–10, repeated almost literally in mm. 11–12 (C–F –A –B, leading by continued chromatic ascent to C and a restatement of the same figure, from thence to a restatement of mm. 1–4 in the piano), one realizes both that the bass figure is circular and that it is a variation of the bass pitches in mm. 1–2 (C–F–E–E Ü ). The perfect fifth interval C–F is now the tritone C–F , followed by a transposed inversion of the three-note chromatic figure; where before Wolf descends chromatically from the second pitch of the intervallic perfect fifth (F–E–E Ü ), he now ascends chromatically back to the first pitch (A –B–C). The music with which the tortured persona tells of God’s “Liebesfeuer” is a warped mirror image of the original cell-figure. He can see the fires of divine love, can name it, knows God is there but on the other side of a mirrored boundary he cannot cross. (Furthermore, when we hear the conjunct, diatonic ^ in the vocal line of mm. 9–10, we hear another foreshscalewise descent from 5^ to 2 adowing of “Alles endet,” whose vocal line begins similarly.) The mirroring, inversions, and turning, twisting transformations of an intervallic cell dominated by the semitones so often associated with lamentation in Western music – or, closer to home, a Wagnerian hell of desire – are precisely mapped substitutes for the loss of tonal surety. Dante, one remembers, gave Hell a geography as rigorous as that of Heaven (Ex. 3.5). When the introduction returns, it is changed, at first slightly, then more radically. The rhythmic profile of mm. 1–4 is varied in mm. 13–16 such that the second simultaneity occurs on the third beat of the measure rather than the second beat, an alteration probably made in order that Wolf might first place the crucial verb “wollt’” each time on the accented fourth beat of the preceding measure and then sustain it across the barline, while the word “ich” is subsequently placed on the second beat. As the piano continues to sustain the downbeat harmony, “I” can sound more starkly on the weak beat, underscoring the tortured awareness of personal failure. From the same intervals, the same pitches of the basic figure, Wolf constructs a vocal line that both grows from and grates against the simultaneities in the piano; for example, just where one expects the repeated vocal phrase in m. 12 to continue downwards, the leap of a fifth upwards at the adjective “teuer” invests the word with breathtaking urgency. The fervency of the desire to tend, to foster, is apparent when the singer continues to speak in fifths and tritones (the C–F at the verbs “hegen” and “pflegen” echo the bass in the preceding measure), especially given the dotted rhythms that make the fall to the flatted second heavier and wearier. When the second half of the introduction (mm. 5–8) recurs in the texted body of the song, there is a crescendo of alterations to match the crescendo of rising anguish, the chromatic sequence extended to six measures rather than the original four. Although the vocal line doubles various chord tones in the piano, one finds the vocal pitches C , F , and 84
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman Ex. 3.5
Wolf, Seufzer, mm. 1–16 Langsam und schmerzlich
!
² ðý Š ²² ŁŁŁ ðð ýý [ Ł Ý ² Ł ¦ð ¦ ðm 5
!
ŁŁ ýýý ¦¦ ŁŁŁ ŁŁŁ Ł \ −ð ý −ð ý
Ł Ł
ŁŁ ¹ Ł Ł ¹ Ł
rit.
Ł ð ý −ð ý Š ¦ −Ł ðý −ð ý ² Ł ðý ¦ ð ý ¦Ł −Ł ¦ Ł Ł −ð ý ¦ Ł −ð ý ²Ł ¦ðý n n n \\ cresc. dim. ݲ −Ł ¦ Ł ð −Ł ¦ Ł −ð Ł −Ł ¦ ð − Ł ¦Ł ð ¦ ð − − ð Ł −Ł ¦ Ł Ł 9 ² (sehr innig) Ł Ł Ł Ł ¼ Ł Ł ¹ ð Š Ł ð ² Š ¦ ðð ¦ð \\ ݲ ð ð ² Š ²Ł
13
!
ŁŁ ¹ ² ŁŁ ðð ýý Ł ²Ł ð ý [ Ł ¹ Ł ¦ ð Ł ¦ð Ł m
²
Dein Lie
!
Ł Ł
ŁŁ ýýý ¦¦ ŁŁŁ ŁŁŁ Ł \ ðý −ð ý
² Š ²² ððð [ ð ݲ ð
-
bes - feu - er,
ðð ð
² ðð ² ðð ²ð
ð ð
ach
² ðð ² ðð ð
ð
Ł
n Łý ¦ Ł Ł ² Ł
ich
es
he
Ł Ł
ŁŁ ýýý Ł \ −ð ý −ð ý
ðð ð ¦Ł ¦Ł
-
gen,
¦ ŁŁ ŁŁ ¦Ł Ł
Herr!
wie
−Ł −Ł
²Ł Ð ¦ ð ²Ł ¦ð Ł −ð Ł −ð
Ł Ł
Łn
Ł ²ð teu - er
wollt’
ðð ð
ðð ð
¦ ððð
² ðð ð
¦ð ¦ð
ð ð
²ð ²ð
ð ð
Ł
wollt’
ŁŁ ¹ ² ðð Ł ²ð [ Ł ¹ ð ð Ł
ð
Ł
Łý ¦ Ł Ł
ich
es
pfle
ðð ð ¦Ł ¦Ł
Ł Ł
ŁŁ ýýý Ł \ −ð ý −ð ý
-
gen!
¦ ŁŁ ŁŁ ¦Ł Ł
¼ ŁŁ ¹ Ł Ł ¹ Ł
D spelled otherwise in the piano, D Ü , G Ü , and E Ü . While the conflicting spellings are justified by what precedes them or by the direction of the voice-leading (for example, the initial vocal pitches in m. 17, C and F , are outgrowths of the terminal vocal pitches in the preceding phrase, C and F , while the piano duplicates the flatted pitches of m. 5), it is also the case that the visual tension between the piano and voice – which sound conjoined – contributes in an ineffable way to the performers’ understanding of the tensions rending the persona’s soul. Beyond enharmony, the sequence itself is changed. In the introduction, each subsequent one-measure unit after the establishment of the initial unit in m. 5 begins with the bass line retreating downward a half-step while the right hand retains, albeit in 85
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs enharmonic respelling, the chord tones with which the previous measure ended; hence, each measure begins with consonance – given Wolf ’s association of second-inversion triads with longing in Mörike’s poems, it is significant that the consonances are six-four chords each time – and leads to dissonance. But for the anguished admission of failure in mm. 17–22, Wolf only allows consonance at the beginning of each two-bar unit, the augmented triadic dissonances more prominent than ever. Failure of faith leads to Hell, and Hell, in keeping with the warped mirrors of this song, is a variation of “Dein Liebesfeuer.” As in mm. 9–12, the progression leads from “VI” to a culmination on “V” (one only discerns functions through a glass darkly), but now it moves through the Phrygian flatted second rather than F . We are, in a sense, returned to the beginning, to m. 1, for this culminating cry of pain: the sequence rises to D for the dead heart (the enharmonic E Ü of “todt”), leading to the pains of love (mm. 22–23) which begin on E in the topmost voice as the “Liebesfeuer-chorale” returns. There are times when the major mode is more tragic than the minor, consonance more powerful than dissonance; here, “Höllenschmerzen” blazes forth fortissimo on C major (the voice adds the seventh) – it is as if all comes clear at this moment – and F major chords. Wolf understood that there is no end in sight for the “pains of hell,” that a closed ending for the texted body of the song would not do. Chromatic miasma, lack of resolution, deceptive motion – this is how the words “end,” or rather, fail to end. Instead, a “dominant” harmony once again does not proceed to tonic, but moves deceptively back to C in the bass for the beginning of the postlude, and it is a register of deeper despair as the lied shades from words to wordlessness that one perceives these deceptive motions as stronger than before (Ex. 3.6). Throughout “Seufzer,” Wolf makes pervasive chromaticism and enharmony symbolic of the confrontation with something Janus-faced: “Liebesfeuer” and “Höllenschmerzen” are paradoxically both different and the same. That there is no tonal repose in this song is only right, but how is one to end the setting of a poem whose last words are a recognition of unending torment? Wolf was not so much a radical that he would abjure the period at the end of the sentence; it was more in character for him to extend the poetic scenario in the postlude, and he does so again here, but not by repeating the introduction. In this linear hell in which everything changes and yet everything remains the same, the introduction is the wordless quest for a name to put to agony, the body of the song is its naming, and the postlude is its aftermath. When the act of naming is done, the persona continues to pray, but wordlessly. The piano in mm. 25–26 repeats “Thy Love, Thy Love,” that is, the voice-leading and harmonies of “Dein Liebes-[feuer]” from m. 9 twice in what one can only construe as an appeal to that love. In Wolf ’s script, the appeal increases in fervency, then lapses into despair – but not without a struggle. The first one-bar statement of the “Liebe”-figure is marked by the flatted second degree of “Höllenschmerzen,” while the più forte second statement replaces F with F . The third statement begins more strongly still, but it is a long descent to defeat, one in which the modal pitches F / F , C / C battle it out to the cadence. One can hear the sforzando replacement of C with hugely accented C s in mid-measure of m. 29 as an attempt to utter a proper plagal cadence, an “Amen” to divine love, but the attempt collapses immediately. C sinks to C , then to the Phrygian flatted II in root position for the first 86
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman Ex. 3.6
Wolf, Seufzer, mm. 17–31
² \ Š ²Ł
17
Hab’s
!
² Š ¦ −Ł ðý ¦Ł ݲ −Ł −Ł 19 20 ² Š Ł
²ð
Ł
nicht
ge
−ð ý −ð ý
¦Ł
−ð
Š
²
o
! !
−ð
Ł
get,
bin
tot
im
¦Ł ð ð ý ¦Ł ý ðý
² Š ðŁ Ł Ł Ł Ý ² ¦ ððð
Ł -
¦ ðð ¦ð ð ð 28
len -
Ł Ł
−Ł −Ł
¦ð ¦ð
und
nicht
ge
²¦ Ł ð ý ²Ł \ Ł Ł
ðý ðý
¦Ł
get
²Ł [
ÿ
Ł ý ² Ł ð
¦Ł
Ł
¦ð ¦ð
²Ł
ð ð
Ho¨l
-
ð
²Ł
² Ł ð ¦ ð ý −ð ²Ł ¦ðý
cresc.
Ł ð
² ð Š ¦ ðð [[ Ý ² ¦ ðð ðð
he
[ Ł
-
Ý ² ²ð ²ð
ð
−ð −ð
² Š ¦ Ł ð −ð ý ² ð Ł −ð ý
22 23
-
−ð −ð
¦Ł ¦Ł
pfle
!
Ł
Ł Ł
²ð ²ð
Ł Ł
² Łý Her
-
²Ł ð ²Ł
ð ð
¦Ł ¦Ł
²ð ²ð
-
Ł ¹
zen,
² ŁŁ ²Ł
²Ł
Ł ¦ ŁŁ ÿ
½
schmer - zen!
\ð ð ² ðð ²ð
Łð ð Łð ð ¦ ð −ðð ð −𠦲 ðð
ð ¦ ² ðð ð Ý
²Ł ²Ł
ŁŁ ŁŁŁ Ł [[ ðð ð
Ł ð ð ð ¦ Ł Ł ð ð ð ²Ł ¦Ł Ł ð ²Ł Ł ð piu` [ [ ð ð ðð ðð ðð ðð ð ð n ðÐŁ ¦¦ ðð ² ð Ł Ł Ł ^[ n ðÐ ²ð Ð
87
¦ ÐŁ Ł ð Ð \ ¦ Łð Ł ¦¦ ððð ð
ðð ðð
½
\\ ðð ð
½
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs and only time, and finally to E minor, also for the first and only time. From this hell, there is no exit. There is surcease elsewhere . . . but only – as we shall see – in Wolf, not in Mörike. Moreover, Mörike enchains the texts of “Seufzer” and “Wo find’ ich Trost?” in Maler Nolten and places them side by side in the Ausgabe letzter Hand (“Seufzer” dated 1832 and “Wo find’ ich Trost?” “circa 1827”), but Wolf separates them. Wo find’ ich Trost? Eine Liebe kenn’ ich, die ist treu, War getreu, solang’ ich sie gefunden, Hat mit tiefem Seufzer immer neu, Stets versöhnlich, sich mit mir verbunden.
Where can I find solace? One love I know that is faithful, was faithful ever since I found it, that with deep sighs ever renewed, forever forgiving, has bound itself to me.
Welcher einst mit himmlischem Gedulden Bitter bittern Todestropfen trank, Hing am Kreuz und büßte mein Verschulden, Bis es in ein Meer von Gnade sank.
It is He Who with heavenly patience bitterly drank death’s bitter droplets, hung on the Cross and atoned for my fault until it sank into a sea of grace.
Und was ist’s nun, daß ich traurig bin, Daß ich angstvoll mich am Boden winde? Frage: “Hüter, ist die Nacht bald hin?” Und: “was rettet mich von Tod und Sünde?”
And why is it that I am now sad, that I writhe in anguish on the floor? I ask: “Watchman, will the night soon be over?” and: “What will save me from death and sin?”
Arges Herze! ja gesteh es nur, Du hast wieder böse Lust empfangen; Frommer Liebe, frommer Treue Spur, Ach, das ist auf lange nun vergangen.
Wicked heart! confess it truly: you have once again conceived wicked pleasure; pious love, pious fidelity’s trace – alas, that is now long vanished.
Ja, das ist’s auch, daß ich traurig bin, Daß ich angstvoll mich am Boden winde! Hüter, Hüter, ist die Nacht bald hin? Und was rettet mich von Tod und Sünde?61
Yes, that is why I am sad, why I writhe on the floor in anguish! Watchman, watchman, is the night soon over? And what will save me from death and sin?
There is a close relationship between “Gebet” (whose second stanza appears in Maler Nolten as one of the mad Agnes’s prayers – see chap. 5) and “Wo find’ ich Trost”: these personae attempt to pray as true believers, marshalling Scripture and theology to the desire for faith, but fail in the attempt. 62 In the first two stanzas of “Wo find’ ich Trost,” one finds commonplace Christian themes – the assertion of Christ’s love as an eternal verity and the sinner’s consciousness of sin – but Mörike hints from the start that the sins troubling this persona are carnal and that Christ’s love provides no reassurance. The poem is in trochaic pentameters, the length of the lines and the first-beat stresses already telling of heaviness, while the initial phrase should be a red flag to the reader, its syntax convoluted and its poetic rhythms arranged such that we understand Love to exist only in the singular: “One love I know that is true,” the persona says, implying that all other love is false. Wolf took note and adjusted the musical prosody accordingly: “Ei-[ne]” is placed on an offbeat, the composer avoiding a blatant stress on the article but nevertheless prolonging its accented syllable slightly and echoing the piano’s pitch immediately preceding on the downbeat. The emphasis is subtle, but it is there. Only in the second stanza is the faithful love hymned in the first stanza identified with Christ, who “hung on the Cross and redeemed my sin” but is not named directly; “Welcher einst,” we see, not “Jesus Christus,” and the omission suggests that the persona does not 88
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman feel worthy of speaking His name. When Mörike begins stanza 3 with the word “Und,” stressed both by the trochaic accent on the first syllable and by the alliteration in the words “Und was ist’s nun,” he emphasizes the connection between knowledge of Christ’s love and the keener awareness that this is no use in present misery, a “now” in which religious teachings only compound anguish whose physicality is unbearable. “Böse Lust” (“wicked pleasure,” or sexual sensations) is the cause, we learn in stanza 4, and Mörike implies a poetic kinship between the interlacings of sexual congress, the Satan-serpent of original sin winding on the ground, and the writhings of someone in torment. Unable to take any comfort in the thought of Christ’s love, the persona culls desperate appeals for God’s aid from the Bible and from hymnody, the borrowings distilled to the bone. In Luther’s translation of Isaiah 21: 11–12, one finds the immense cry: 11. Man rufft zu mir aus Seir: Hüter, ist die nacht schier hin? Hüter ist die nacht schier hin? 12. Der hüter aber sprach: Wenn der morgen schon kommt, so wird es doch nacht seyn. Wenn ihr schon fraget: so werdet ihr doch wieder kommen, und wieder fragen.63 (They cry to me from Seir: Watchman, is the night almost over? But the watchman said: As the morning comes, so will it be night. As you already asked, so will you come again and ask again.)
The watchman’s invocation of repeated nights of anguish and repeated cries of desperation lurks just behind Mörike’s truncated quotation, haunting it. Mörike substitutes the word “bald” (soon) for Luther’s “schier” (almost), and the small alteration perhaps tells yet again of Goethe’s impress on Mörike. At the end of “Wandrers Nachtlied II,” Goethe writes “Warte nur, balde, / Ruhest du auch” (Only wait, soon you too will rest), words which rank among the most famous expressions of the longing for surcease in the German language. Agnes too longs for “Ruh’,” more desperately and with less hope than Goethe’s wanderer. The chiming -a vowels of “bald” and “Nacht” are more sonorous than Luther’s “Nacht schier hin,” and Mörike may have changed the Biblical wording for that reason, but it is at least possible to speculate that a trace-element of Goethe is to be found in this poem. The cry from Isaiah reappears in various Lutheran hymns, including one beginning “Hüter, wird die Nacht der Sünden / Nicht verschwinden?” (Watchman, will the night of sin never vanish?) by the late seventeenth-century Pietist poet Christian Friedrich Richter (1676–1711):64 Hüter, wird die Nacht der Sünden (stanzas 1 and 7) Hüter, wird die Nacht der Sünden Nicht verschwinden? Hüter ist die Nacht schier hin? Wird die Finsternis der Sinnen Bald zerrinnen, Darein ich verwickelt bin? ...... Das Vernunftlicht kann das Leben Mir nicht geben; Jesus und sein heller Schein, Jesus muß das Herz anblicken Und erquicken, Jesus muß die Sonne sein. 65
Watchman, will the night of sins Watchman, will the night of sins never vanish? Watchman, is the night almost over? Will the darkness of the mind in which I am entangled soon tear asunder? ...... The light of reason cannot give me life; Jesus and His bright light, Jesus must look into the heart and revive it, Jesus must be the sun.
89
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Jesus is the Sun who banishes the darkness of sin if the sinner will only cry out to God the Night Watchman for help and renounce rationalism for faith. The emphatic reiteration of “muß [must] . . . muß,” the images of light in the final stanzas, and the lightness of the second and fifth lines in dimeters – they almost dance – convince us of the hymn-singer’s surety of faith; the hymn is a tunnel which begins in the dark and emerges to bright light at the end. But Mörike’s persona cannot muster such faith. There is neither light nor lightness in the nocturnal world of “Wo find’ ich Trost,” and no rescue. Lutherans in Mörike’s day who read his poem did so against the backdrop of hymns like this one and would have noticed the absence of any saving grace the persona could trust. The cry at the end, “What will save me from death and sin?” (“what,” not “who” one notices), is also paraphrased from Scripture. In the seventh chapter of his epistle to the Romans, Paul laments the sins of the flesh: Romans 7: 5 – Denn da wir im fleisch waren: da waren die sündlichen lüste, welche durchs gesetz sich erregten, kräftig in unsern gliedern, dem tode frucht zu bringen. 7: 18–19 – Denn ich weiß, daß in mir, das ist, in meinem fleisch, wohnet nichts gutes . . . Denn das gute, das ich will, das thue ich nicht: sondern das böse, das ich nicht will, das thue ich. 7: 24 – Ich elender mensch, wer wird mich erlösen von dem leibe diese todes?66 (Because we were of flesh, there were sinful pleasures which, against the commandments, were strongly aroused in our members, bringing death to fruition. For I know that in me, that is, in my flesh, dwells nothing good . . . For the good that I wish to do, that I do not, but the evil that I do not wish, that I do. . . Miserable man that I am, who will save me from this bodily death?)
This hatred of fleshly desires is precisely what afflicts Mörike’s persona. The multiplication of “fromme . . . fromme” (pious), hammering home the dichotomy between agape and eros in the persona’s world, is cheek-by-jowl with the multiplication of “bitter bittern” and the percussive -t’s and -tr’s of “Todestropfen trank,” the language emphatic, apocalyptic, throughout. The entire ocean of Christ’s mercy is not sufficient to outweigh the persona’s sense of sinfulness; in Maler Nolten, the invocation of sin sinking into a sea of grace is in tragic-ironic counterpoint to Agnes’s subsequent suicide by drowning. One of the most significant details of “Wo find’ ich Trost?” is the different punctuation of the two Biblical questions in the last half of stanzas 3 and 5. In stanza 3, Mörike uses colons both to indicate that the words which follow are borrowed and as an echo of Luther’s punctuation in Isaiah 21: 12, “Wenn ihr schon fraget: so werdet ihr doch wieder kommen.” “Frage” too is a stark abbreviation, the indication of self (“ich”) omitted and the act of questioning emphasized by placement at the start of the line. But in Mörike’s final stanza, the word “Frage” and the colons disappear, the verb of questioning replaced by an additional cry to the “Hüter” (the watchman, unresponsive to the first plea, must now be called twice), while the connective “und” at the beginning of the last line merges seamlessly with the plea for rescue. No longer are the questions presented as quotations; rather, the speaker has taken them unto herself, made them hers. Perhaps when he read this poem, Wolf saw something analogous to a formal principle in tonal music: that literal repetition of a previous block of music is both recognized as repetition and yet heard in some way differently because of what has preceded it. This poem traces a mental journey from the statement of religious convictions to the recognition that they provide no comfort and from there to anguish; it is the reverse of the progression in 90
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman Richter’s hymn. Mörike’s persona answers the questions of stanza 3 in stanza 4 and the first half of stanza 5 (“Ja, das ist’s auch”) and then repeats the questions, no longer Biblical but personal. Now we hear them differently, several shades darker, because of the abjuration of piety just before. If “fromme Liebe, fromme Treue” are gone, who indeed can save the persona from death and sin? Wolf ’s structure, with its unusual block-sectional repetitions, is crafted to the poetic content: the music of the introduction and stanza 1 provides the musical material for the rest of the setting in a design one might graph as A B C B C (keeping in mind that B and C are actually variations on A), each section a setting of one stanza. One would expect any composer to take Mörike’s cue to repeat the music of stanza 3 for stanza 5, but Wolf also does likewise for stanzas 2 and 4, explicitly linking Christ’s death agonies on the Cross and the poetic persona’s “böse Lust.” Christ redeems human sin; original sin is sexual; “mein Verschulden” is sexual as well. For Agnes in Maler Nolten, sexual flesh is a Cross to which she is helplessly bound, and the opposition between piety and sexual desire could not be more acutely limned than it is here – except in Parsifal. For a Wagnerite as passionate as Wolf, Mörike’s poem was guaranteed to evoke reminiscences of Wagner’s last opera. The desire for purity brought to defeat by “böse Lust” is a common thread between the giant opera and the small song; Amfortas uses those same words in his memories of the “Wonnegarten” (garden of rapture) where he was pierced in the groin by the same spear with which Longinus wounded Christ’s side and which Klingsor has wrested from Amfortas’s keeping: Die Wüste schuf er [Klingsor] sich zum Wonnegarten, d’rin wachsen teuflisch holde Frauen; dort will des Grales Ritter er erwarten zu böser Lust und Höllengrauen.
He transformed the desert into a garden of wonders in which grew devilishly beautiful women; there he awaits the Grail knights, tempting them to evil pleasure and hellish torments.
There have been few figures in the history of opera as obsessed with the purity of renunciation as Wagner, who had a “Klingsor-like propensity for denying sexuality and, at the same time . . . conjuring up a hell of wanton pleasure.”67 Parsifal and Agnes are even similar in that sexual guilt is something they know more through psychological apprehension than through their actual limited physical experience; Kundry’s and Nolten’s kisses are sufficient to unleash a volcano of suffering and a passion/Passion of renunciation. In Monsalvat and Maler Nolten, sinless carnality is a fairy tale, and no one believes in it. Wolf was surely aware that he was quoting Wagner in this song; it is difficult to imagine that such blatant citations were the product of unconscious processes. The figure of the rising scalewise diminished fourth, repeated sequentially throughout much of the piano part, brings back what earlier Wagnerians called the leitmotif of the Spear.68 This figure is, as many have pointed out, closely related to the conclusion of the Dresden Amen heard so many times in the opera – ”Selig im Glauben,” the boy sopranos sing to that ascending fourth figure at the end of act 1 – but the two figures are rhythmically and harmonically differentiated, the diatonic solidity of the Amen unlike the chromatic stabbing of the spear. In act 2, one hears rising, sequential repetitions of the Spear figure in the orchestra when Kundry is seducing Parsifal by invoking the lad’s dead mother Herzeleid and Parsifal asks himself reproachfully how he could have forgotten her – how apropos for Wolf, who could 91
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Ex. 3.7
Richard Wagner, from Parsifal, act 2
PARSIFAL
Š 00 ½
¹
Sehr langsam 3 Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł Konnt’ ich ver - ges
!
¹ Ł Ł ý Š 00 ¼ ¦ ŁŁ ŁŁ ýý \\ Ý 0 ¾ 3−Ł ¹ ² ŁŁ ŁŁ ýý Ł ð 0Ł ²Ł Ł ~ 3 ¹ Ł ¾ ¹ý Ł Ł −Ł ¦ Ł Š ¼ −Ł Ha!
!
!
Š Ł −Ł Ý Łð ² Ł ¦ Ł ð
Ł
²¦ ŁŁŁ
-
½
sen!
¹
¹ 3 ¦ Ł −Ł ¹ ¼ −Ł
3
¹ý
¼
Was Al-les ver-gass ich wohl noch?
¹ n n n −Ł ý ð ý −Ł Ł Ł
ð
Ł
² Łn Łn Łn Ł ý \\ espr. ¹ ý Ł ² Ł Ł −Ł ½
Ł − ŁŁ
−Ł Wess’
3
−−ððð
ŁŁð ý
Ł
Ł ý −Ł ¦ Ł −Ł ŁŁ
Ł ý ¾ Š Ł ¾ −Ł Ł ¦ Ł Ł −Ł −Ł ¹ ¼ war ich je noch ein ge-denk? n ¹ n −Łn −Ł ¦Ł ý Š ŁŁ −Ł Ł Ł − Łý Ł ²ð − Ł Ł − ŁŁ \ −− ŁŁ Łý Ł Ý −ðð −Ł ¦Ł
not forget Wagner (Ex. 3.7). A few moments later, the same figure returns even more emphatically as Parsifal, overwhelmed by knowledge of Amfortas’s suffering, sings, “Redemption’s rapture, divinely gentle, trembles throughout the far distance in all souls: only here, in my heart, will the pain not soften. There, I understand the Savior’s lament for the profaned sanctuary”. Agnes too sings of “Erlösungswonne” (redemption’s rapture) for all souls save hers and of anguish that His “sea of mercy” cannot assuage. The same spear inflicts the same wound. Wolf even creates a similarly Wagnerian rising sequential development of the Spear figure in his setting of Mörike’s second and fourth stanzas, such that all sense of tonal location is obscured. As in “Seufzer,” hell is chromatic miasma (Ex. 3.8). But before Wagner’s spear stabs another soul in torment, Wolf locates Christ’s love in more diatonic realms, an echo – at a Wagnerian distance – of a Lutheran chorale. The piano introduction is a study in increasing fragmentation and rising intensity which 92
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman Ex. 3.8
Wolf, Wo find’ ich Trost, mm. 12–17
− Š − − Łý
12
Ł Ł
bun
!
-
− Ł Š − − ŁŁ
den.
ŁŁ
− Ł Š − − Ł Ł ¦Ł ¦Ł
!
− ¼ Š − − −ð
li - schem Ge - dul
¦Ł ¦ ŁŁ
[ ¼ Ý −− −ð − −ð
−Ł
− Š − − Ł ¦ Ł
16
!
− ¼ Š −− ð [ ¼ Ý −− ð − ð
¼ −ð [ ¼ −ð −ð
Ł Ł Ł Łn Łn Łn
14
-
Ł ¦ ŁŁ Ł \ ¦ Ł ŁŁ
Ł ý ¦ Ł Ł
- des - tro - pfen trank,
¦Ł ¦ ŁŁ Ł
Ł ¦ ŁŁ Ł \ ¦ Ł ŁŁ
Ł Ł −−Ł
Wel - cher einst
ŁŁ Ł Łn Łn n
ŁŁ \\ Ł Ł
Ý −− ŁŁŁ −
−Ł ý
¼
den
¼ ¦Ł Ł n n ¼ ¦Ł Ł ¦Ł Ł n n
¦Ł n ¦Ł ¦Ł n
¼ ¼ Ł Ł n n ¼ Ł Ł Ł Ł n n
−Ł n −Ł −Ł n
¼ ð
Ł bit
-
Ł Ł
¹ −Ł
[ − ¼ð −ð
ter
−Ł − ŁŁ
[ ¼ð ð
¼ −ð
mit
himm
ŁŁ Ł Ł \ Ł ŁŁ −Ł Ł
−Ł ¹
−Ł -
−−Ł −− ŁŁ
ð
hing
¼ ¦Ł Ł Ł n n n ¼ ¦Ł Ł Ł ¦Ł Ł Ł n n n Ł −Ł
bit - tern
ŁŁ Ł Ł \ Ł ŁŁ Łý
am Kreuz
ŁŁ Ł −Ł
-
ŁŁ Ł Ł \ Ł ŁŁ
To
¼ ¦Ł Ł n n ¼ ¦Ł Ł ¦Ł Ł n n
¼ ¦Ł Ł n n ¼ ¦Ł Ł ¦Ł Ł n n
-
Ł n Ł Ł n Ł und
Ł n Ł Ł n
slumps into quiet grief at the end. The four bars are all spun from m. 1, whose descending ^ –2 ^ –1 ^ in the topmost voice is met by voice-exchange and contrary motion in the motion 3 bass, the voices coming together like walls closing in on a trapped mind. The consequences of this quasi-Baroque Spiegelbild figure are massive. Already chromaticism begins to invade the alto voice, an F passing tone whose enharmonic reincarnations as G Ü are important in the later climactic passages of this song. The chromaticism intensifies in m. ^ –2 ^ –1 ^ figure, 2 as a result of Terzensteigerung, the chromatic constriction of the original 3 and the “sighing figure” semitone motives in the alto and tenor voices, prefiguring the still greater emphasis on the semitone motives in m. 3 (this second measure also foreshadows the two tonal zones of stanza 1, C minor and E Ü major, since the variation of the figure from m. 1 culminates in an appoggiatura-intensified secondary dominant of the relative 93
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs major). With m. 3, the figure is fragmented, the contrary motion of m. 1 multiplied in a virtual concatenation of semitones. With the fourth measure, the tessitura drops like a stone, as if rising tension were suddenly overcome by leaden depression, and we hear the quadrupling of sighing figures en route back to the C minor we never really left. Finally, as the dynamics dim to sad softness, a clear dominant seventh of tonic C minor emerges by the end of the measure, its resolution elided with the return of m. 1 as the body of the song begins. Even before the 1888 Mörike songs, Wolf had already made conflict between the voice and piano a hallmark of his songs. In the setting of stanza 1, there is a subterranean drama played out in the convergence or non-convergence of the piano and the singer in order to make the listener understand that the persona does not really believe her own words of religious affirmation and that the “deep sighs ever renewed” are hers more than they are Christ’s. As she sighs/sings the words “die ist treu” in m. 6, the harmonic progression attempts to pull away from the tragic key of C minor but with the most blatant possible parallel fifths in the bass, filling the entirety of m. 6. The effect of this compositional “no-no” is negation, or at the least, conflict – how can something be true if it is said to parallel fifths? – and hollowness. Aware of imperfect belief, she tries harder, asserting Christ’s faithfulness over time (“War getreu, so lang ich sie gefunden”) to an ascending harmonic sequence in the piano (mm. 7–8) that is a construction in increasing tension. Wolf understood that this poetic persona tries to believe, and he makes of stanza 1 a harmonic battle for a better place to be, a place founded on a bedrock of religious belief. Briefly, she succeeds and wins her way to E Ü major, just after the word “gefunden.” The setting of stanza 1 is thus tonally progressive (as is the entire song). The initial C minor tonality is that of the poetic persona’s grief-clouded world and the closely related (“mit mir verbunden”) key of E Ü , that of Christ’s forgiving love – and Wolf surely knew the Bachian associations of E Ü major with the Trinity, by extension, with Christian faith itself. ^ –2 ^ –1 ^ figure The first phrase on E Ü major in m. 9 is a beautifully spacious variant of the 3 from m. 1, even to the contrary motion voice-exchange between soprano and bass: with a resolution all the more heroic because doomed to failure, the persona attempts to convert grief into the certainty of divine love. The richness of the chords, the short-lived diatonicism, the brightness of major mode, and the breadth of the chord-voicing suggest, not walls closing in, but Christ’s love enfolding and surrounding the persona. Such calm beauty does not last, however. At the word “Seufzen” (sighs), Wolf destabilizes the newlyemergent E Ü major by means of a diminished seventh chord on E – the new tonic is undermined almost immediately. Another sequence is necessary before the persona can find her way back to E Ü major, and one notes that this sequence is characterized by the contrary motion and voice-exchange of “eine Liebe,” varied, transposed, lengthened, reharmonized. The bass of m. 11 (A Ü –A –B Ü ) brings back, in a lower register, the unsuccessful approach to E Ü in the “bass” of m. 2, but this time, the modulation is completed and culminates in a full authentic cadence. There is even tonic closure in the vocal line. Over and over, throughout stanza 1, the persona fights – quietly – to leave her native climate of grief and attain safe harbor in Christ. But the hard-won repose lasts only for the duration of a single eighth note before it is immediately, emphatically, destroyed; indeed, Wolf uses the tonic and leading tone pitches 94
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman of E Ü to lead away from the assertion of Christ’s love and into the realm of death and pain (the latter half of m. 12). As the Parsifalian sword stabs the poetic persona over and over, all tonal surety is lost; from m. 13 through m. 18, no one could say where we are. As in “Seufzer,” hell has its precise topography, however, every note of it appropriately fashioned from the music of stanza 1: Hell is awareness of Heaven’s loss. The first (unharmonized) stroke of the spear leads to premonitory G Ü s, although one cannot yet hear that pitch as a constituent of E Ü minor – that comes later, massively so. The introduction, one recalls, was saturated with appoggiaturas, in evocation of longing and of sighing, and so too is stanza 2; each thrust of the spear is repeated at its former pitch, leading each time to a “sighing” appoggiatura-chord, the first resolving downwards, the second upwards in order to impel the next jab of the spear transposed to a higher level. The chromatic terrain could not be more precisely plotted. Out of torment eventually comes surcease, or so it seems. When the poetic persona sings “bis es in ein Meer von Gnade sank” at the end of stanza 2, the chromatic turmoil of mm. 12–18 subsides into diatonic clarity as into rest after long travail. The six preceding measures are as harrowing as anything in Wolf, and the relief when the stabbing of the Wagnerian spear ceases is something one feels physically, the tension induced by the rising sequence relaxing with such suddeness as to leave the listener limp. But the phrase in mm. 19–20, with its motion back towards the redemptive E Ü major and its increasing diatonicism, ends deceptively on C minor, not E Ü . Wolf ’s poetic persona does not believe that his or her sins have truly sunk into a sea of mercy and sinks instead back into a sea of grief, the piano interlude in mm. 21–22 returning us, like a tape-loop, back to the beginning of stanza 1. This time, however, the battle to sustain belief will end differently. It is with the music of “Eine Liebe kenn’ ich, die ist treu” that the persona asks, “Why am I now so sad?” at the beginning of stanza 3. The listener, remembering the earlier words, hears the larger query, “If I truly know this faithful love, then why am I sad?” in the returning strains and notices that the parallel fifths so prominent in the bass of m. 6 are corrected in m. 24. The hollowness beneath the words “die ist treu,” words she does not truly believe, is no longer necessary when she sings the truth of her sadness (“traurig bin”), and Wolf adjusts the lower voices accordingly. The rising sequence from mm. 7–8 (“war getreu, so lang ich sie gefunden”) is innately tense, but what Wolf does with it upon its recurrence in stanza 3 is a fiery furnace by comparison. This time, it is the piano alone which completes the sequences and rushes headlong into the anguished questions from Isaiah. Wolf takes the eighth note – quarter note – eighth note rhythmic pattern (a favorite of his) at the end of m. 8 – a “drive-to-cadence” quickening – and both diminishes it rhythmically in the right hand and varies it by syncopation. The indication “drängend” seems almost redundant for such built-in harmonic and rhythmic urgency. In the addition of chromatic passing-tones to the broken-chordal figures in the right hand, one notices the prolongational emphasis on G Ü (the third beat of m. 26), premonitory of the arrival at, not E Ü major but E Ü minor. Before, the attempt to assert Christ’s love as a certainty could move the music briefly to a warmer, calmer major mode, but that is no longer possible now. Throughout Parsifal, Wagner contrasts chromatic zones with relatively diatonic zones, although “diatonicism” in late Wagner is always prone to incursion by chromatic extremes. Wolf does likewise, but in a fashion tailored to this text. The anguished questions 95
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs in lines 3 and 4 have a wrenching urgency, the language stripped of all embellishment, and it was perhaps this directness which inspired Wolf to set the questions to pure triadic harmonies; the “Hüter” is God, and Wolf elsewhere invokes supernatural beings with pure triads in unorthodox, “unearthly” progressions.The tessitura, span, and voicing of the chords in m. 27 (“Frage: Hüter, ist die . . .”) are essentially the same as in m. 9, darkened to minor, but in the subsequent three measures of this outcry, Wolf flings the pianist’s hands more widely apart, an abyss opening up in the middle. The voice-exchange and contrary motion from before are now rendered immense. It was Wolf ’s vivid addition to Mörike’s poem that the pianist sounds trumpet fanfares, as if calling the soul to the Last ^ –2 ^ –1 ^ figure, and those fanfares trace a stepwise Judgment, between each iteration of the 3 ascent from E Ü to F and finally to a massive G major harmony. The anguished cries for rescue are poised in tonal mid-air – no longer E Ü minor, not quite C minor – when the words temporarily cease, the persona waiting for an answer during the piano interlude in mm. 31–34 while the last echoes of the trumpets of judgment fade away. The fortissimo dynamics of the anguished questions die down exhaustedly, the piano’s block-chordal harmonies, their wing-span contracting, falling downwards in two stages. As they fall, they heighten G major harmonically, as if turning towards the dominant. But in mid-measure (m. 32), the figure is arrested on a diminished triad on G , sustained throughout much of mm. 32–34 while the inner voice taps out the fanfare figure as a soft ostinato; the root of the prior G major is altered, thrown into doubt. One hears in this moment the poetic persona’s refusal to confess the cause of her anguish; arrested on a chromatic harmony emblematic of open-endedness, instability, and fear, she attempts to defer confrontation with a hideous admission. When she can do so no longer, the D fanfares, appropriately in the inner voice, grow ominously louder and lead directly into the recurrence of stanza 2 as stanza 4. Is there still another echo of Parsifal as well in this piano interlude? When Titurel in act 1 asks Amfortas, “Shall I again today look on the Grail and live? Must I die without my Savior’s guidance?”, his unaccompanied vocal phrases are separated by soft, ominous, fanfare-like triplets in the timpani, figures similar to those in Wolf (Ex. 3.9). Could the words “rettet/Retter” and the fact that both poetic personae are poised on the boundary between life and death have impelled the later composer to this reminiscence? Never, one notes, is there an instant of silence anywhere in the accompaniment. As the sounding analogue to a tormented inner consciousness, it is incessantly active. In Maler Nolten, “Wo find’ ich Trost?” is followed by Henni playing the organ on and on, “as if he could not bring this endless pain to any conclusion in music.”69 “Finally, all was still,” we are told, and those who have been listening outside of the chapel are given a glimpse inside when Henni’s little sister emerges, leaving the door open. What they see is “an image of peace,” with Henni sunk in thought at the organ keyboard and Agnes asleep at his feet. Did Wolf accord his unusually lengthy postlude with the novel, with Henni playing music of “endless pain” in search of closure? If so, there is a complex discrepancy between poem, novel, and song. Mörike resolves the scene, not the fictive music, in momentary peacefulness. He says nothing about how the music ends, only that it does, and the tension-fraught “peace” – its image (Bild), not its reality – is soon followed by catastrophe. By the end of the poem, Isaiah’s questions are rhetorical; the music, unable to resolve “endless pain,” simply stops; and an Agnes convinced that no rescue is possible kills 96
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman Ex. 3.9
Wagner, from Parsifal, act 1
Ý −− − ¼ Ł Ł Ł −
!
− Š − −−
Soll ich den
Ý −− − −
!
Ý −− − −
ÿ
heut’ noch er - schau’n
und le - ben?
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ
Muss ich
ÿ
Gral
Ł ¹ Ł Ł Ł ¹
ÿ
Ý −− − ¼ −ð −−Ł −ð − − Š − −−
Ł Ł −Ł
ð
ÿ ÿ
(Langes Schweigen)
ÿq Ł ¹ Ł Ł3 Ł Ł ¼q
−Ł ý Ł Ł ¦Ł − Ł ½ ¹ Ł Ł Ł
ster - ben,
ÿq
Etwas lebhafter
ÿ
vom Ret - ter un - ge - lei - tet?
ÿ ÿ
ÿ ½
ÿ
3 Ł ¹ ŁŁŁ ð ýý
ð ýý
cresc.
Ł Ł ¾
~
herself. But Wolf devises a closure for his song which is at odds with Mörike’s meanings. The end of the lied is dramatic, it is moving – and it is not Mörike. Wolf had a dilemma on his hands, one which Schubert had confronted before him and also Schumann, a composer known for making endings problematical. When a poetic text ends with an unanswered question, what is one to do to bring about formal closure in a lied? In a similar situation, Schubert, faced with his friend Johann Mayrhofer’s anguished questions, “Wann enden diese Qualen? Wann?” (When will these torments end? When? – the same question that Mörike’s persona asks), at the end of “Fahrt zum Hades” (Journey to Hades), brings back the initial section, a repetition which both “rounds out” the formal structure and grants to the poetic persona a measure of dignity for his last words.70 That is not a possibility here, however, not after the answer in stanzas 4 and 5. One can, and Wolf often does, end the texted body of the song inconclusively and then work out a resolution of the form in the piano postlude, but one must still decide what, if any, poetic meanings the instrumental ending will bear. Wolf devises a conclusion which invites texted associations after a fashion similar to the postlude of “Auf ein altes Bild” (see chap. 5). As before, the repeated-note fanfares lead to momentary halt on a diminished seventh chord, but the continuation does not lead back to words this time. Over the continued ostinato D in the left hand, a fortissimo E Ü major harmony on the downbeat of m. 56 galvanizes the atmosphere like a bolt of lightning, followed by progressively softer (mezzo-forte and piano) C and E Ü dissonances against the bass D in m. 57 until all dissonance melts into the euphony of a bright D major harmony at the close. Because the continuation is so shocking, because it proclaims violent tonal clashes leading to peacefulness, because there are no more words to follow, the listener is virtually 97
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Ex. 3.10
Wolf, Wo find’ ich Trost, mm. 49–60
− Erster Zeitmaߣ Š −− ¹ Ł Hu¨ - ter, n − ŁŁ ŁŁn Ł ŁŁ − Ł − Š −−
49
!
[[ ŁŁ Ý −− ŁŁ − Ł Łn n 52 51 − ¦Ł ý Š − − Ł Ł
Łý Ł Ł Ł Hu¨ - ter, ist
−− ¦ ¦¦ ðððð Ł − Š ¹ ý n n ¹ ý Ł Ý −− ¦ ðð − ¦ð
!
Nacht
n −−− ŁŁŁ 8va
ŁŁn Ł
bald hin?
¦ð ¦ ¦ ððð ¹ý
¹ý ¦ð −− ŁŁŁ −−ŁŁŁ ¦ ¦ ððð Łn n Łý Ł ¹ Ł Ł Ł ¼
ret - tet mich (8va)
die
ðð ð¹ ý Ł Ł Ł Ł n n n n 3 n n n3 n ¹ ý Ł Ł Ł Ł −ð −ðð
−Ł ð
Łý
n Ł Ł Ł −−− ŁŁŁŁ n 3n n n n3 n Ł Ł Ł n −ŁŁ −Ł 8va
Ł
¹ Ł − ŁŁn Ł Ł Ł Ł − ŁŁ n n 3n n n n n3 n Ł Ł Ł Ł Łn ŁŁ 8va
Und
ŁŁn Ł
was
−Łn −ŁŁ
ÿ
von Tod und Su¨n - de?
ŁŁn Ł
¦ð ¦ ¦ ððð ¹ý
−Łn −ŁŁ
¹ý ðð ð
Ł Ł Ł Ł n n 3n n n n n3 n Ł Ł Ł Ł
ŁŁn Ł ðð ² Łn ¹ ý Ł Ł Ł Ł 3 ][ dim. ý n ¹ n ¦ ŁŁ ¦ ŁŁ ¦ ðð 3 Ł Ł ¦ð Ł Ł Ł Ł
− Ý Š −− Ł Ł ð ÐÐ −¦− ÐÐÐ ¦ Łm ¦ Łm ² ð \ [[ 3 3 3 3 3 Ý −− Ł Ł ¦ ¹ðý Ł Ł Ł Ł ŁÐ ¾ Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł ¾ Ł Ł Ł Ł −ŁÐ ¾ Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł ¾ Ł Ł Ł Ł − Ł Ł ð Ð Ð m m 58 57 ÐÐ ðð ½ Ý −− ² Ð ðð ¦ ²¦ ŁŁŁ −ŁŁ ²¦ ÐÐ − \\\ dim. [ \ \\ 3 3 3 3 3 Ý −− ŁÐ ¾ Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł ¾ Ł Ł Ł Ł Ł ¾ Ł Ł Ł Ł ¹ý Ł Ł Ł Ł ¼ ¹ Ł Ł ¼ Ł ¹ − Ð ¦ ÐÐ ðð ½ ÐÐ
55 54
! !
bidden to look for associative meaning in the last half of the postlude. In the thunderbolt at m. 56, one can perhaps hear the instant of the persona’s death, the subsequent softer dissonances symbols of the lessening stabs of pain before all pain ends. When the last E Ü in the inner voice of m. 57 dissolves to the final dying-away D major chords – we end “elsewhere,” in mid-air – and the music ebbs away altogether, the sense of relief is massive (Ex. 3.10). After so many previous references to Parsifal, it is impossible not to hear in this ending a transmuted echo of the prophecy “Durch Mitleid wissend, der reine Thor, harre sein’, 98
The fictional misfortunes and musical fortunes of a nineteenth-century madwoman den ich erkor” (Through compassion made knowing, the pure fool, wait for him, the appointed one) at its first appearance in the opera, in particular, the motion to the E Ü harmony at “Thor” answered by the motion to a cadence on D major at “erkor.” Did Wolf have in his mind’s ear the radiant D major cadence in act 3, when “Mitleid” (compassion) works its magic and Amfortas’s wound is healed by the same spear that wounded him? Wolf, in Wagner’s wake, grants a persona similarly tormented by sensuality surcease at last for anguish born of the flesh. The trumpets of the Lord, calling to judgment, fade away and are subsumed into the ever-softer brightness of the final major harmony; the dwindling fanfare in the inner voice, from four pitches to two to a single note, at the end is among the song’s most eloquent gestures. The night is over, says Wolf, who had already stilled the nocturnal torment of “In der Frühe” (composed some five months earlier on 5 May 1888) with D major chords ebbing away into quietude and does so again for the deeper anguish of “Wo find’ ich Trost.” This is not what Mörike, more pessimistic than Wolf, had in mind. For his poetic persona, death and sin are too overwhelming for alleviation, and the thought of Christ only increases guilt. As the poem unfurls, it answers the question posed in its title and does so in the negative: there is no “Trost” anywhere, no “höchsten Heiles Wunder” (highest miracle of healing) of the sort granted to Amfortas.71 For whatever reason, Wolf rejected the poet’s ending and devised another, more Parsifalian finale. It was Wolf ’s privilege as a composer to extend his chosen poems in the postludes, but the point of divergence between Dichter and Tondichter is, on this occasion, most acute at the end. The Wagner-steeped strains are ironically, given Mörike’s detestation of Wagner, apropos for the hell of concupiscence which causes the persona of “Wo find’ ich Trost?” so much pain. Where poet and composer differ, it is on the not-so-minor matter of redemption, musical and otherwise. Agnes is a fascinating mish-mash of a character, a compound of contemporary psychiatry, supernaturalism, “good girl” piety, references to Goethe, Mörike’s own life, cultural critiques of society, and more. She is portrayed as the product of an upbringing and a society in which “one can hardly speak” (the title of a recent critical study of Maler Nolten72), of circumstances in which the sexual ignorance of middle-class young women of the period was exacerbated to the point of madness. Mörike makes both the odds against Agnes and her struggles to break out of her genetic-cultural-historical trap clear, and he portrays spirited, educated women (Margot) and mature female sexuality (the Countess) in the novel, but it is the mad women who are the major characters; successful women are allotted only minor roles. For those who know something of Mörike’s life, it seems overdetermined that he would explore abnormal psychology, both male and female, and that he might displace his own conflicts onto a fictional woman who had Shakespeare’s and Goethe’s permission to sing of Eros denied. Eros not denied can be equally destructive, as we shall see in the next chapter.
99
Chapter 4
Sung desire: from Biedermeier erotica to fin-de-siècle lied
Looking at a portrait of the twenty-nine-year-old Mörike, one sees what could be the archetypal image of a shy, refined poet (Illus. 1). But twenty-nine-year-olds have usually, then and now, learned the difference between roseate love in literature and the grittier stuff of sex in real life, fraught with contingencies of pain, power, disease, pregnancy, exploitation, and the ephemerality of attraction. If they were writers, they could, and often did, speak of sexuality in their works along a gamut which runs from pornography (its purposes prurient and commercial rather than aesthetic) to high poetic art, the latter inevitably more rare than the former, and what they wrote is a mirror of their own erotic psychology and of the society that shaped them. The balance between frankness and euphemism, fantasy and fact, society’s stereotypes and individuality, varies from one work to another – and there are many works which partake of erotica, even where they are not defined as such. The best writers traffic in what truly matters, and the coupling (or not) of sex with love in heart and mind appears on anyone’s short list of life’s larger concerns. They were certainly fodder for poetry in Mörike’s world because he conceived of a problematic link between eroticism and the making of art, and he wrote of that vexed pairing in multiple literary guises. Those of Mörike’s erotic poems set to music by Wolf and included for discussion in this chapter (“Erstes Liebeslied eines Mädchens,” “Der Knabe und das Immlein,” “Ein Stündlein wohl vor Tag,” and “Der Gärtner”) are arranged along a spectrum from lieder whose sexual content is explicit to those in which sexuality finds other modes of expression, where hints and symbols take the place of more graphic language. But what happens when a citified avatar of fin-desiècle Vienna, in which claustrophobic sexual mores co-exist with psychological probing of sexuality, sets to music earlier investigations of Eros, penned under different circumstances? The composer inevitably reads Mörike from his (Wolf ’s) own view of desire between the sexes, his post-Wagnerian musical concerns, his wish to revise his predecessors. Where Mörike’s erotic poems meet Wolf ’s turn-of-century music is the subject of this chapter. R E - I M AG I N I N G P O R N O G R A P H Y: “ E R S T E S L I E B E S L I E D E I N E S M Ä D C H E N S ”
One of the most startling poems Mörike ever wrote was “Erstes Liebeslied eines Mädchens” (A Maiden’s First Love Song), one of the poems “written with blood” and exemplary of 100
From Biedermeier erotica to fin-de-siècle lied
Illus 1
Pastel portrait of Eduard Mörike by Johann Georg Schreiner, 4 May 1824
“daemonic truth” which Wolf so admired. It is indeed astonishing, so much so that Wolf is one of only two composers in the nineteenth century who set it to music, Mörike’s friend Ludwig Hetsch being the other.1 The poet, perhaps emboldened by his recent sexual adventures (whatever they were), flirted with the boundaries between pornography and high poetic art; sixty years later, a composer living covertly outside the bounds of sexual convention appropriated the poem and gave it his own turn-of-the-century twist. Both poem and lied are bold in different senses, but the poem has a sadder level of meaning as well, one that I believe Wolf missed in his excitement over the poem’s daring evocation of intercourse and its psychological acuity. The genesis of the poem is a window through which we can see how Mörike and his friends, all in their hormone-driven twenties, spoke of sexual matters among themselves – if only from hints in the written record. In 1828, Mörike sent the Green Notebook to his sister-in-law Dorothea Mörike and, on 19 June of that same year, also sent the seven poems collectively entitled Neue weltliche Lieder (New Secular Songs) to Adelheid Mörike, the wife of his cousin Heinrich. Both manuscripts include the “Lied eines Mädchens,” the title of the poem later being made more specific (a maiden’s first love-song) for publication in the Jahrbuch schwäbischer Dichter (Yearbook of Swabian Poets) of 1836 and Mörike’s poetic anthology of 1838; one deduces the poet’s pride in this amazing poem from his display of it in venues both public and private . The complete title of the Neue weltliche Lieder unfurls like a Baroque banner: 101
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Lieder / just nicht / fürs Klavier / aber zum geringen Beweis / dass die Stadt / Buchau / keinen unpoetischen Himmel habe; / wurden nämlich sämtlich gedichtet / im dortigen Park sowie im Badgarten / nunmehr dankbarlich ge- / widmet / der / hochgeschätzten, / lieben Frauen / / von / ihrem Vetter / dem dermalen vagierenden / bei Grazien und Musen / vikarierenden / Vikar/ Eduard Mörike.2 ( Songs / not precisely / for piano / but as a paltry demonstration / that the city / of Buchau / has no unpoetic sky; / [they] were all together written / in the park there, as well as in the spa garden / now gratefully de – / dicated / to the / highly prized, / beloved wife / / from / her cousin / the at present straying / by the Graces and Muses / vicaraging / vicar / Eduard Mörike.)
Here, Mörike invokes music so that he may claim its powers for poetry – words, not music, will work this erotic magic. Released for a while from his hated religious bondage, he converts the word “Vikar” into a neologism for poetic purposes and puts roaming from poem to poem in company with the Muses and Graces ahead of the doubly damned vicarage duties. Mörike was in fact roaming about from one small vicarage to another at the behest of his own restlessness, so the words “vagierenden” and “vikarierenden” were yoked realities as well as designations of the opposition between his breadwinner’s job and his true vocation. The little collection begins, one notices, with a “Bacchanal” – Mörike’s suitably erotic version of the traditional invocation of the gods at the start of a literary enterprise – and ends with this “love”-song, the works in between thus, in one sense, seductions leading up to the deflowering at the close. One notes that these manuscripts were sent to women, albeit married women whose knowledge of sexual reality Mörike could assume, furthermore, members of his own family who would not be offended by such frank evocations. However, he also sent the poem, via a male intermediary, to a young woman on the verge of marriage, hinting that it would become, might indeed already be, an apt description of her deflowering. Writing to Ernst Friedrich Kauffmann on 7 July 1828, Mörike told his friend that he was enclosing a poem which he had hummed the previous day while walking along the path to the vineyards at Schloß Weissenau near Ravensburg, a poem he offers “not as a wedding song but as a love-song” for Marie Lohbauer, Kauffmann’s fiancée and Rudolf Lohbauer’s sister. (The distinction is between the public venue of a wedding song, its representations of love idealized, and a “Liebeslied” which is more intimate and physical.) Kauffmann, Mörike directs, should set it to music and give it to Marie on her “Braut-Morgen” (the morning after the wedding) with a kiss, asking her “when she sings it, if the song does not, to a hair’s breadth [italics Mörike’s], express all of the rapture that you experienced in the first days of your love.”3 “Erstes Liebeslied eines Mädchens” is also a riposte to Goethe in which the younger poet rewrites and “one-ups” the looming literary presence in his life. From the third stanza on, Mörike tells Kauffmann, the poem is “after the melody of ‘Was zieht mir das Herz so,’” implying the Lutheran practice of contrafacta when he actually means something more complex than the adaptation of new words to old music. “Was zieht mir das Herz so” is the opening line of Goethe’s “Sehnsucht,” whose iambic-anapaestic dimeters Mörike echoes for stanzas 3–6 of his “Liebeslied” (the changing rhythms in stanzas 1–3 are one feature of the poem’s virtuosity). Kauffmann had previously cited the opening lines of Goethe’s 102
From Biedermeier erotica to fin-de-siècle lied famous poem as the motto to a letter he wrote Mörike on 15 July 1827, and Mörike had replied on 1 August 1827, telling his friend of a visit to the Neidtlinger valley. There, on seeing a kite abandon itself to the will of the winds, he thought of Goethe’s poem and Marie’s singing voice: Sehnsucht (stanzas 2 and 3 of 5) Nun wiegt sich der Raben Geselliger Flug; Ich mische mich drunter Und folge dem Zug. Und Berg und Gemäuer Umfittichen wir; Sie weilet da drunten, Ich spähe nach ihr.
Longing Now the ravens hover in companionable flight; I join them and follow their course. And mountains and ruins we fly above; she dwells below, I look for her.
Da kommt sie und wandelt; Ich eile sobald, Ein singender Vogel, Zum buschigen Wald. Sie weilet und horchet Und lächelt mit sich: “Er singet so lieblich Und singt es an mich.”
There she comes and walks along; I hurry right away, a singing bird, to the bushy forest. She lingers and listens, and smiles to herself: “He sings so sweetly and sings to me!”
At the end, the poetic speaker returns to his beloved, lies at her feet, and proclaims his happiness, the goal of his longing achieved. The eroticism of flight, birds, song, bushes, and gathering darkness culminates in an open-ended lieto fine, bliss already fulfilled in fantasy and awaiting only physical enactment. Had Kauffmann already married Marie, Mörike asks in the letter of 1827?4 Almost a year later, he recalls their earlier bandying about of Goethean desire and provides a replacement-poem in which Goethe’s male speaker becomes a woman and “Sehnsucht” becomes sexual experience. After longing, sex itself: Erstes Liebeslied eines Mädchens Was im Netze? Schau einmal! Aber ich bin bange; Greif ’ ich einen süßen Aal? Greif ’ ich eine Schlange?
A Maiden’s First Love-Song What’s in the net? Take a look! But I’m afraid! Will I grab hold of a sweet eel? Will I grab hold of a snake?
Lieb’ ist blinde Fischerin; Sagt dem Kinde, Wo greift’s hin?
Love is a blind fisherwoman. Tell your child where to reach out!
Schon schnellt mir’s in Händen! Ach Jammer! o Lust! Mit Schmiegen und Wenden Mir schlüpft’s an die Brust.
It’s already jumping about in my hands! Ah sorrow, ah delight! With its twisting and turning, it is slipping onto my breast.
Es beißt sich, o Wunder! Mir keck durch die Haut, Schießt’s Herze hinunter! O Liebe, mir graut!
How astonishing! It bites me boldly right through my skin and shoots down my heart! O Love, I’m frightened!
103
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs Was tun, was beginnen? Das schaurige Ding, Es schnalzet da drinnen, Es legt sich im Ring.
What should I do, what should I begin? The frightful thing is leaping inside of me, it’s coiling itself up.
Gift muß ich haben! Hier schleicht es herum, Tut wonniglich graben Und bringt mich noch um.
I must be poisoned! It’s crawling around here, digging about rapturously, and it will end by killing me!
In this poem, Mörike concocts a salty stew of literary allusions, compounded of fairy tale motifs, echoes of Shakespeare and themes from Hintertreppenliteratur (“back stairs literature” or pornography) in a unique way; if there are works by the thousands which tell of deflowering virgins, few can claim anything approaching this level of complexity. What this poet borrows, he transforms, and the magpie assemblage of topoi from elsewhere undergoes a sea-change into something rich and strange. In the so-called “animal husband” tales from the fairy story repertoire, a repulsive beast, sometimes a lion or bear, sometimes a slimy water-creature who represents the phallus (such as the “The Frog Prince” in the Grimm brothers’ fairy tales5), metamorphoses into a handsome and loving prince upon further acquaintance; many fairy tales constitute a pedagogy of sexual discovery in which girls are allowed to be desirous of new experience and yet initially repulsed by the strangeness of it all. The ending is usually a happy one in the traditional stories, but not so here. When the “maiden” – the title is ironic – is curious about where to grasp the slippery object invading her, Mörike thereby establishes his persona’s preliminary ignorance of sexual matters, but this is no fairy tale; the phallus does not become friendly, and there is no “happily ever after.” Nor does one find verbal re-enactments stage-by-stage, as if in medias res, of sexual intercourse in Märchen: that belongs to erotica, which this poem both is and is not. In “Erstes Liebeslied eines Mädchens,” Mörike ponders the mixed pleasure and pain in sex, the sadism of arousal by the infliction of suffering, and the solipsism of sexual encounter, possibly as a metaphor for something larger and non-sexual. But one is still left to grapple with the reactions elicited by deliberately shocking content. Mörike plays games with the borderline between what is covert and overt in sexual language; if he uses symbols rather than precise anatomical names, we are nonetheless not allowed to understand the poem as anything innocent. His poetic persona tries to identify the creature she grasps either as a snake or a sweet eel, something poisonous and biting or something sweet to the taste and touch (or perhaps mutating from one to the other), images drawn from tradition. The snake is an echo of the Biblical serpent-tempter in the Garden of Eden, Satan as phallic tempter (and yet, snakes are also female emblems6), but its coupling with a “sweet eel” suggests that watery worlds form the backdrop to this song of sex. In this realm, sea creatures become metonymies of sex organs both male and female in a dissolving world of sensation. Entire schools of ichthyological symbols form the backdrop to Mörike’s eel-and-snake images. Shakespeare devised perhaps the most notorious fishing metaphors in all of literature in the badinage between Cleopatra and her attendant Charmian in act 2, scene 4 of Antony and Cleopatra, just before the messenger enters to tell the queen that Antony and Octavia have wed: 104
From Biedermeier erotica to fin-de-siècle lied : Give me mine angle – we’ll to the river: there, My music playing far off, I will betray Tawny-finn’d fishes; my bended hook shall pierce Their slimy jaws; and as I draw them up I’ll think them every one an Antony, And say, Ah ha! you’re caught. : ’Twas merry when You wager’d on your angling; when your diver Did hang a salt fish on his hook, which he With fervency drew up. : That time, – O times! – I laugh’d him out of patience; and that night I laugh’d him into patience: and next morn, Ere the ninth hour, I drunk him to his bed; Then put my tires and mantles on him, whilst I wore his sword Philippan.7
It would indeed require audacity on Mörike’s part to equal such daring piscine metaphors, complete with cross-dressing at the close. The “tawny” fins, the adjective suggestive of Orientalizing exoticism; the fervent drawing-up of the “hook;” the eroticism of crossing the boundaries between sexes to mimic one’s opposite; and music (“Give me some music; music, moody food / Of those that trade in love,” Cleopatra says) all lend their erotic charge to the scene. Mörike went fishing in the same pool and drew up similarly slimy, leaping creatures both in “Erstes Liebeslied” and in his novella Mozart auf der Reise nach Prag, where the fictive Mozart tells of Neapolitan water games in which a fish danced about, “sometimes here, sometimes there, between the legs of the one, between the chest and chin of another,” as male swimmers approach a barge with a bevy of girls. The maidens break into frightened screams: Eros, Mörike says over and over again, is a god to be feared.8 Mörike would probably have known his fellow Württemberger Christian Friedrich Schubart’s “Die Forelle” of 1782, in which a fisherman, who is condemned by the poetic speaker as a cold-hearted thief, hooks an innocent trout, his “rod” quivering in the pursuit. Lest anyone miss the moral of the tale, Schubart’s final stanza bids young women be wary of men with rods: Die Forelle (final stanza) Die ihr am goldnen Quelle Der sichern Jugend weilt, Denkt doch an die Forelle; Seht ihr Gefahr, so eilt! Meist fehlt ihr nur aus Mangel der Klugheit. Mädchen seht Verführer mit der Angel! Sonst blutet ihr zu spät.9
The Trout To those who linger by the golden springs of sure youth, think of the trout; see its danger, then hurry away! Most of you err only from lack of knowledge. Maidens, see the seducer with his rod! – or else, too late, you will bleed.
The reference to “bleeding too late” is sufficiently explicit that none but the naïve could mistake its drift, although Schubert’s deletion of the final stanza throws open the sexual reading as it throws out the moral.10 One also recalls Heine’s “Du schönes Fischermädchen” from the Buch der Lieder: “Without care, you entrust yourself every day 105
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs to the wild sea,” the cozening poetic speaker says to the fisher-girl with whom he wishes to dally; immersion in wild waters is tantamount to sex in its elemental force, its threat of death, its surrender to fluid sensuality. Fisher-girls know of sex, the speaker implies – how could they not?11 Sea creatures aside, “Erstes Liebeslied eines Mädchens” also belongs to a long tradition of poets writing the occasional erotic poem, including Goethe.12 At the more elevated end of the spectrum, the penultimate poem in Goethe’s Venetian epigrams of 1790 celebrates exclusively male sensations of sex and does so in classical hexameters and pentameters, evoking recollections of Catullus and the Latin erotic epigram. Here, the poet proclaims that it is even better to feel the motions of the penis within the vagina than to hold the beloved in one’s arms, sex being preferable to love when one is on Roman holiday: Epigramm 102 (lines 1–6 of 10) Wonniglich ists, die Geliebte verlangend im Arme zu halten, Wenn ihr klopfendes Herz Liebe zuerst dir gesteht. Wonniglicher, das Pochen des Neulebendigen fühlen, Das in dem lieblichen Schoß immer sich nährend bewegt. Schon versucht es die Sprünge der raschen Jugend; es klopfet Ungeduldig schon an, sehnt sich nach himmlischem Licht.13
Epigram 102 Rapturous it is, to hold the beloved longingly in your arms, when her beating heart for the first time makes you understand love. Even more rapturous, to feel the throbbing of the newly-living one [penis] that in the beloved womb ever nourishingly moves, Already it assays the leaps of brash youth; it already knocks impatiently, yearns for heavenly light.
It is a man, not the woman, whose virginity ends in the epigram, but deflowering maidens was by far the favorite subject of erotica and pornography alike; it was not only Don Giovanni who preferred “la giovin principiante.” As Peter Gay observes, any set of instructions for the nineteenth-century pornographer would include a description of the initial pain for novices, which usually gives way to pleasure as the man drives his always-huge instrument into the receptive woman.14 The added titillation of sexual instruction for those as yet uninitiated provides a writer with an excuse for language, but it is a rarity for that language to be both sexually explicit and literarily worthwhile, for style or wit to come into play. One thinks of Cherubino’s hints of masturbation, if no other relief for raging teenage hormones is at hand, at the end of “Non so più, cosa son” – “Parlo d’amor con me,” he tells the assembled women in the room – and realizes that Lorenzo da Ponte could do more with innuendo in a single phrase than the likes of Johann Gabriel Büschel (1758–1813) could do in an entire poem, its euphemisms concealing nothing (and not meant to). Büschel’s “Erinnerung (An Henrietten),” is doubly obscene by virtue – not the mot juste – both of the content and of the candy-coated grandiloquence of the language. One need not be puritanical to object to this, just a lover of poetry: Erinnerung (An Henrietten) (stanza 5) Noch denk’ ich immer mir die Szene, Wo ich zuerst die heiße Träne Der Wollust in den weichen Schoß Des liebesiechen Mädchens goß.
Memory (To Henrietta) I will always recall the scene when I first poured the hot tears of voluptuousness in the soft lap of the love-sick maiden.
106
From Biedermeier erotica to fin-de-siècle lied Auch du gedenkst gewiß der Stunden, Wo ich dein Heiligtum entdeckt, Und durch die schönste aller Wunden Mit Purpur dein Gewand befleckt, Wo du der Liebe Glück empfunden, Wo deine weiche Lilienhand Zuerst den Pfeil der Liebe fühlte, Und mit der goldnen Locke spielte, Bis daß er schnell vor dir verschwand, Und sich in deinem Schoß versteckte, Und zärtlich von dem Rosenrand Den Tau geheimer Liebe leckte.15
You too surely remember the hour when I disclosed your holiness, and through the most beautiful of all wounds bespotted your gown with red, where you experienced love’s joy, where your soft, lily-white hand first felt the arrow of love, and played with golden hair until it quickly disappeared before you and hid in your womb, and sweetly from the rosy borders the dew of secret love leaked out.
In the fifth of the Zehn Sonette of 1799, attributed to Friedrich Schlegel, the poetic persona revels in the exercise of power, dismissing the woman’s pain more brutally than Büschel. One notes the choice of sonnet, among the most stylized of verse forms, for the impropriety of pornographic verse: So liegst du gut! Gleich wird sich’s prächtig zeigen, So lie there obediently! Straight away it will be Wie klug mein Rat. Ich schiebe meinen Dicken magnificently shown to you how clever is my In dein bemoostes Tor. Man nennt das “Ficken.” counsel. I shove my member in your mossy Du fragst: warum? Davon laß mich jetzt gate. One calls that “fucking.” You ask: why? schweigen! Of that let me for now be silent! Schon seh’ ich Schmerz in deinen blauen Blicken. Das geht vorbei. Du mußt zurück dich neigen, Gleich wird dein Blut dir jubeln wie die Geigen Von Engel . . .16
Already I see pain in your blue gaze. That will pass. You must bend back, your blood will immediately rejoice within you like the angels’ violins . . .
The white limbs and blue eyes, the woman’s pain followed by hints of her sexual insatiability, are all in accord with the dreary conventions of pornography. Angelic violin music is the last straw. Like the sonnet above, “Erstes Liebeslied” purports to be in the present and in the midst of the action, but the woman in this poem is not mute, nor was she invented solely to titillate. (The intent to “épater les bourgeois” is, however, plain to see.) Here, Mörike avails himself of certain conventions of the deflowering topos in order to make complicated use of them. For example, character does not count for much in the usual sorts of erotica, only body parts, nor does narrative richness matter, the personae being devoid of histories, origins, tales to tell. The man’s customary power is evident not only in greater or lesser sexual brutality but in narrative control, male speakers voicing male views and characterizing women according to fantasies few women would recognize as congruent with their own experience. Mörike turns the tables: it is a woman’s voice we supposedly hear, ricocheting back and forth between statements of what the phallus is doing at that moment and her own reactions, dominated by fear and increasing panic. In accord with the conventions of pornography, the lover is nothing but a phallus, without a name, a face, or personal history, and we are told nothing of what led to this act, where they are, or anything of the context. The claustrophobic enclosure of the act and the anonymity of its actors heightens its intensity. But that intensity is artificial, the language of this poem remarkable for its ambiguity of address, audience, and tone. The first stanza seems to be the maiden speaking to the lover, 107
Hugo Wolf and his Mörike Songs to whom she says peremptorily, “Show me!”, but the second stanza is as if narrated by a third party who speaks in allegorical terms, the maiden distancing herself from the action and calling herself “the child” (the standard term of address for a sweetheart, especially a young or virginal girl). From the third stanza on (where the Goethe-meter begins), we understand that the woman speaks to herself, that this is an inner voice which recounts the phallus’s invasion along a crescendo of panic. Or rather, that is the feint. Mörike confounds poetry’s self-conscious pattern-making, its distance from the content it symbolizes, with the pretense of immediacy created by the liberal sprinkling of exclamation marks and questions; the spontaneity thus aped is actually a Janus-faced compound of mockery and terror. Far from stream of consciousness before the fact, Mörike here spoofs the language of erotica, its hokey substitution of grandiloquence for what is often wordless, or at best linguistically limited, in life. What real woman exclaims “Oh, pain, oh pleasure! . . . Oh, wonder!” or conjures up personifications of Love as a “blind fisherwoman” at such a moment unless she is the product of male fantasy à la Büschel or the creation of a poet mocking the literary traditions of erotica? But if the language is not credible as a chronicle of experience, the terror it evokes is; the garden-variety pornographer would end with the woman’s adoration of the man after climax, but not so here. Words need not be naturalistic in order to be psychologically apt. It is also possible that the poetic persona is no maiden at all, but a poet (the “female” voice of a male poet) raped by a Muse (a male rapist substituting for a customarily female allegorical personage). Poetic creation, Mörike says in this poem, can be likened to sexual possession, its violence such as to threaten death. One can read the words of stanza 1 as those of a true innocent who wonders what it is she sees and holds, or one can understand the word “maiden” ironically. With each new poem, each act of possession by the invading creative spirit, one must wonder “what’s in the net,” whether for pleasure or pain. A post-Revolutionary poet with a historically confirmed distaste for the grand passion, Mörike tells in “Erstes Liebeslied,” and elsewhere in his oeuvre, of physical endangerment brought about by passions ricocheting out of control. The quest for new experience, an imperative that cannot be denied, at first releases fantasy, but that same outpouring of intuition and imagery has the potential to overwhelm consciousness, putting the poet in mortal danger. Each creative act brings on this peril, and each time, the poet is a “maiden” yet again. No wonder the poem ends where it does, just short of the brink. The poet still retains the control necessary to continue speaking in verse and rhyme, but one more second, he implies, and that control might vanish. That he has survived the near-fatal encounter is evinced in the poem’s survival. Mörike mimics the threatened loss of control without, for one second, relinquishing it. In the first stanza, the poetic persona believes, wrongly, that she has power over the situation and manifests it by means of imperatives in strongly accented trochees (“Was im Netze? Schau einmal!”), each line end-stopped for further emphasis. The pace quickens in stanza 2, the lines shorte