Inclusive Urban Design: Public Toilets
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Inclusive Urban Design: Public Toilets Clara Greed
AMSTERDAM BOSTON HEIDELBERG LONDON NEW YORK OXFORD PARIS SAN DIEGO SAN FRANCISCO SINGAPORE SYDNEY TOKYO
Architectural Press An imprint of Elsevier Linacre House, Jordan Hill, Oxford OX2 8DP Copyright © 2003, Clara Greed. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced in any material form (including photocopying or storing in any medium by electronic means and whether or not transiently or incidentally to some other use of this publication) without the written permission of the copyright holder except in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 or under the terms of a licence issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency Ltd, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1T 4LP, UK. Applications for the copyright holder’s written permission to reproduce any part of this publication should be addressed to the publisher. Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Science and Technology Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone: (+44) (0) 1865 843830; fax: (+44) (0) 1865 853333; email:
[email protected]. You may also complete your request on-line via the Elsevier homepage (http://www.elsevier.com), by selecting ‘Customer Support’ and then ‘Obtaining Permissions’. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloguing in Publication data A catalogue record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. ISBN 0 7506 5385 X For information on all Architectural Press publications visit our website at www.architecturalpress.com Typeset and designed by Keyword Typesetting Services Limited Printed and bound in Great Britain
CONTENTS
Contents Foreword
vii
Preface
ix
Acknowledgments
xi
List of Figures
xiii
List of Tables
xvii
PART ONE: THE
PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
Section One: The background Chapter One: Introduction: background and context
3
Chapter Two: Conceptualising the problem of public toilets
17
Chapter Three: The historical development of public toilets
31
Chapter Four: The development of toilet provision within its legal context
51
Section Two: Differing perspectives on the problem Chapter Five: Cultural attitudes: separating or mixing
71
Chapter Six: Medical perspectives: incompetence or incontinence
95
Chapter Seven: Environmental aspects: global and local
111 v
CONTENTS
PART TWO: THE
SOLUTIONS
Section Three: Design and policy change Chapter Eight: Planning for toilets: city-wide macro level
133
Chapter Nine: Disability or dis-enablement
155
Chapter Ten: Universal urban design: district level
173
Chapter Eleven: Toilet design considerations: micro level
195
Section Four: Creating change
vi
Chapter Twelve: Management, maintenance and finance
235
Chapter Thirteen: Creating change: user and provider groups
257
Chapter Fourteen: Routeways to change
277
Appendix: Toilet standards and guidance
295
Bibliography
307
Toilet terms and acronyms
329
Web links
333
Toilet legislation
337
FOREWORD
Foreword In recent years, thanks to various global meetings such as the World Toilet Summits and Asia Pacific Toilet Symposiums, the issue of Public Toilets has evolved from being an embarrassing subject to one that is gaining widespread awareness and generating lively discussions. Toilet is culture; we visit the toilet several times a day. To enjoy our lives, we need to develop good toilet culture. This culture is made up of many diverse and inter-related issues including Provision, Planning and Design, Cultural Attitude, Behaviour, Public Health, Social Graciousness, Safety, Cleaning Skills and Methods, Building Maintenance, Disabled Accessibility, Setting Norms and Standards, Policy and Legislation, Management, Research and Development, Technologies, Public Education and Environmental issues such as water and sewage treatment and recycling. These issues are also different in each kind of building. A factory’s toilet serves different visitors from that of a shopping centre, or a school, a hospital, an office, a coffee shop, a swimming club or a hotel, and these issues differ again in varying urban, suburban and rural locations. The degree of development or affluence in each location also plays an important role in determining needs and priorities. The needs of the toilet user are also varied. Demands and provision must be different for a man, a woman, a child, an elderly person, an infant and different kinds of physically disadvantaged people like those with visual impairments, incontinence sufferers and the wheelchair bound. Furthermore, cultural differences need to be taken into account, especially in view of rapid globalisation. Clara’s book is an important document that comes at an important time. Due to the long neglect of this subject, the global community, including the commercial sector, governments and non-government organizations are now realising there is an urgent need to address toilet issues and search for new answers and solutions. This book nourishes their searching minds. Many have discovered that good toilet facilities are not only an essential service but can in fact offer healthy returns on investment. Toilets are disease prevention tools. They help reduce the cost of public health provision, and improve people’s quality of life, productivity and morale. As evident by the ‘Loo of the Year Award’ in Britain, shopping centres and hotels alike are finding that providing good toilets earns them good dividends in the form of increased shopper traffic and occupancy rates. Enterprises, like the Great World City shopping precinct and the Singapore Zoo, feature their toilets as an important attraction to
vii
FOREWORD viii
visitors. Beijing, through the Beijing Tourism Bureau, is a fine example of how a city can increase tourism income by improving its image with better public toilet facilities. Clara has taken great effort in meticulously capturing the plight of toilet goers. Reading this book, I felt the title could alternatively be called All you wanted to know about public toilets but dare not ask. The book provides a deep understanding of toilet issues and many useful suggestions. It is an eye-opener for all those concerned with the current toilet situation. Architects, industrial designers, building owners, facility managers and government officials everywhere will do well to study it. This book marks another milestone to the continuous global awareness of public toilets. I am certain it will be a strong catalyst in breaking the ‘taboo’ on this subject. Jack Sim World Toilet Organisation (WTO) Singapore November 2002
PREFACE
Preface In previous research I have investigated the planning of cities (Greed, 2000a), urban design (Greed and Roberts, 1999), urban governance issues (Greed, 1999a); gender issues (Greed, 1991, 1994a) and cultural factors (Greed, 2000b). My observations of dissatisfaction with the urban situation among the general public, and puzzlement at the apparent lack of awareness in the built environment professions of the urban spatial deficiencies highlighted by the women and planning movement, and by other minority and community groups, initially led me to investigate ‘why’ this was so and to undertake detailed research on the needs of women in cities in particular (Greed, 1991, 1994a). In spite of all the verbal diarrhoea advocating equal opportunities, women’s rights, better health and environmental sustainability, the lack of public toilets, and the contempt in which the subject is held, may be seen as the true indicator of the lack of progress that has been achieved, especially in respect of women’s position in society. In this book my emphasis is upon a key ‘micro’ level, detailed component of the built environment – namely toilets – whereas my previous work has been on wider ‘macro’ level policy issues. I chose this topic for further research for two main reasons. Firstly, in the course of undertaking research on ‘women and planning’, many respondents declared, ‘it all comes down to toilets in the final analysis’. Women, especially those with small children, and the elderly, explained how their use of the city was limited by the availability, or not, of public conveniences. The situation has become unsatisfactory for everyone, both men and women, of all ages because of accelerated closure rates, an ageing population and a lack of investment in public facilities. Secondly, I chose this topic because, in my extensive travels by train for my research work, I often could not find a toilet when I myself needed one, and when I did I encountered queues, filthy conditions, plugs which did not pull, and dangerous steep steps; but, occasionally, a cheerful lavatory attendant, innovative designs, and a freshly picked sprig of plastic flowers by the washbasin. My concern with public toilets came to a head in 1994 when I found that a turnstile had been installed at the entrance to the Ladies at Paddington railway station. The toilets had been closed for several months because of refurbishment, but were now reopened. To my horror I found that, in spite of spending millions of pounds, the toilets were still down some awkward stairs when they could have easily have been put at platform level, so much easier for people with luggage. Worst of all, now one had to pay 20p to go through the turnstile, which is 151/2 inches (40 cm) across, hardly enough room for luggage, and the average pushchair is at least
ix
PREFACE x
18” (46 cm) across. As the Consumers Association commented (Which magazine, January 1991: 52–3), British Rail seemed to assume that the average passenger is carrying nothing more than a rolled-up newspaper (and little has changed, see Which, 2001). Mothers with pushchairs at railway stations may be told they are not allowed to use the disabled toilets which may constitute the only passengeraccessible toilets with an adequate width entrance now that turnstiles have been installed. Most mainline London terminus railway stations have toilet turnstiles including Paddington, Euston and King’s Cross, and most are located downstairs. On phoning the Station Manager at Paddington about the problem, I met with an amused and disrespectful response. He told me, ‘you could always go behind a hedge’ (in Central London?). It was then that I decided it was time to become passionate about public toilets and gradually over the years I have picked up speed on this topic, so that now it has quite taken over my life. My initial concern with the lack of public toilets in our urban and rural areas inevitably led into looking at ways and means of ameliorating the situation, and into campaigning for policy and legislative change. In this process I came across a whole world of researchers, campaigners, toileteers and interest groups, who were championing different aspects of ‘toilets’, such as the campaign group as will be explained in subsequent chapters. Much of my inspiration came from All Mod Cons (AMC), the pressure group set up by Susan Cunningham in Cardiff for better public toilets in the 1980s, whose voice continues to be heard within the context of its successor the British Toilet Association (BTA), of which I am an honorary member and avid devotee. So I cannot claim personal neutrality but have nevertheless sought to maintain a more neutral perspective in undertaking academic research on toilets (Greed and Daniels, 2002). I argue with passion that public toilets are essential for creating accessible, sustainable and equal cities, and that they are a vital factor in getting people out of their cars and back to walking, cycling and using public transport. I also argue that the reinstatement of public toilets is a key component in mainstreaming gender into planning policies. Toilet rearmament cannot be done lightly; it involves fundamental cultural change, considerable financial investment, legislative change and a whole set of different priorities which will result in better lives for everyone. We need a restroom revolution, a toilet transformation – indeed, our lives depend on it. Clara Greed Professor of Inclusive Urban Planning UWE, Bristol March 2003
Most of the photos and drawings are my own work unless otherwise stated. I would like to thank Ray Fowler for the photos (see captions for acknowledgments). Thanks to Richard Chisnall and the BTA (British Toilet Association) for their inspiration. Thanks to Paul Revelle and Chris Wade for assistance with finalising my illustrations on disc. 1.6
Ray Fowler for urinal photo
3.1
Isobel Daniels for photo
3.5
Photo from web, courtesy of the Crossness Society
6.3
Baby-changing photo, courtesy of Ray Fowler
6.4
Photos of museum exhibit taken by author with permission of the Gladstone Pottery Museum
8.5
Ray Fowler for Meadowhall photos
10.5
Isobel Daniels for photo
11.5
Women’s Design Service (WDS), Sue Cavanagh, for plan of ideal toilet
11.9
Blueprint of corner style disabled toilet, courtesy of Danfo
11.15
Plan of adult-changing unit, courtesy of PAMIS (Profound and Multiple Impairment Service)
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Acknowledgments
xi
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
FIGURES
Figures Chapter 1 Figure Figure Figure Figure
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4
Closed toilet at terminus of bus route out from Bristol People queuing at London Eye: all who might need a toilet Typical Public toilet in seaside resort Typical urinal: men have more places to pee
Chapter 3 Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure
3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8
Public toilets at Killerton house, Devon Ancient Greek drainage piping at Ephesus Underground toilets do not provide equality of access Typical nightsoil hatch at end of backyard Bazalgette’s 1865 Cross Engines, near Woolwich Sewage repair van: conserving the heritage beneath the city streets Park Row Toilets, Bristol, washbasin, external view, toilet seat Larkhall Toilets, Conservation Area, Bath
Chapter 4 Figure Figure Figure Figure
4.1 4.2 4.3 4.5
Horfield Common Men’s Urinal, Bristol The Ladies next to the Urinal at Horfield 1960s utilitarian toilet block Broadmead, Bristol Law Courts, The Strand, London with toilets nearby
Chapter 5 Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure
5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7
Global Toilet Debates (powerpoint guiding document) A Range of logos reflecting stereotypes and societal divisions German tourist bus with disabled toilet logo in back window A range of JC Decaux toilet designs Schoolgirl’s drawing of how big she imagines the toilets to be Danfo butterfly male street urinal, London Urilift in Reading marked by circle on pavement.
Chapter 6 Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure
6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5
Ordinary people in the park at lunchtime Caring for the Elderly in the community Baby changing at Milton Keynes Exhibits from Gladstone Pottery Museum, Stoke on Trent Typical low level squat toilet layout
xiii
FIGURES
Chapter 7 Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure
7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7 7.8 7.9
Deffinitions of sustainability and the cycle of decomposition Recycling skips beside an APC sending out the wrong image Sanpro Bin Close to Bowl Sanpro bin away from bowl An old sanpro disposal incinerator Bin for dog dirt, Somerset Scandinavian doggy toilet: coming to the UK soon Typical Moslem toilet in Singapore Basic Third World toilet behind a curtain
Chapter 8 Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure
8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 8.6 8.7 8.8
People arriving at Paddington station: where will they ‘go’? Central coffee cart Bristol: what goes in must come out Good Signage in Tourist Areas showing WCs in City of London Toilets Spatial Strategy Sector Diagram Bus passesengers at Meadowhall shopping Mall find good toilets Department stores still provide main source of shopper toilets Bicycles propped against closed toilet, Smithfield, London Ideal city level toilet distribution strategy diagram
Chapter 9 Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure
9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.6 9.7 9.8
of wheelchair accessible cubicle: could you reach the toilet roll? Young chap in wheelchair test-driving disabled toilet It’s all relative steps down how inaccessible can you get? Up and down the steps at Moorgate? Is this accessible? Haymarket centre, Bristol steps and slopes with pushchairs Accessible toilets recommended by Joint Mobility Unit (JMU) Smithfield Toilet Options, London. Locked RADAR key toilet with night-time security gate
Chapter 10 Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure
10.1 District level toilet location principles 10.2 Toilets in seaside resort conveniently alongside the carpark 10.3 Dunster, Somerset, small village with many tourist toilets 10.4 Post office, caspoint and APC Moorgate, London 10.5 Town square with new toilet beside supermarket 10.6 Block level toilet principles 10.7 Piers Gough Toilets Ladbroke Grove, Notting Hill 10.8 Inside Ladbroke Grove, 20p for babychanging 10.9 Toilets beside Banbury Cross in townscape context 10.10 Internet facilities and telephone kiosks but no toilets 10.11 Ideal family toilets Thatcham, West Berkshire
Chapter 11 Figure 11.1 The Ideal Toilet Palace for a busy location Figure 11.2 Plan for a uniblock for a local centre Figure 11.2 Aviemore toilets, Scotland xiv
11.4 Oy Shippax APCs 11.5 Women’s Design Service ideal toilet block 11.6 Existing door clearances from Bristol survey 11.7 Comparitive clearance areas in cubicle 11.8 Ideal size of cubicle with cordon sanitaire 11.9 Corner Triangle disabled toilet by Danfo 11.10 Taps, hand-dryers and basins 11.11 Different height washbasins for children 11.12 Range of locks and handles 11.13 Danfo Panopticon Approach to street toilets 11.14 Very basic baby changing facilities in Manchester 11.15 Adult changing room by PAMIS 11.16 Singapore: open air toilet washroom 11.17 Singapore: Chinese mural in the Ladies 11.18 Singapore: Jungle mural in the Gents 11.19 English aluminium toilet bowl 11.20 General view of urinals in Milton Keynes 11.21 Toto Japanese automatic toilets
FIGURES
Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure
Chapter 12 Figure 12.1 Figure 12.2 Figure 12.3 Figure 12.4 Figure 12.5 Figure 12.6 Figure 12.7 Figure 12.8 Figure 12.9 Evesham
Golden triangle of provision Lavatory cleaner keeping the triangle working Opening Times in Bristol Insides of an APC typically without a proper seat Workings of an APC inside and out out of order APC in City of London A huge sanpro bin at Parkway Station Bristol Vandalised toilet block in Bridgwater Somerset Service duct area between the Ladies and the Gents in public toilet in
Chapter 13 Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure
13.1 13.2 13.3 13.4 13.5 13.6 13.7
BTA delegates at Banbury, ‘wot no women?’ Delegates at BTA conference inspecting public toilets Delegates at a Japanese conference inspecting public toilets Group Photo of BTA members, user and provider groups Cartoon of men having important meeting in the Gents Planets Diagram: Forces of change in the toilet world Singapore and Seoul World Toilet Summit conferences
Chapter 14 Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure
14.1 14.2 14.3 14.4 14.5
Restroom revolution: Japanese toilets Invisible Toilets: Millennium Square, Bristol Remedial Signs in the Tea Room by Millennium Square Burnham Toilets: changing facilities, enduring inequality Dark Turnstiles forebodings for the future
xv
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
TABLES
Tables Chapter 3 Table 3.1 Population growth 1801–1901 UK Table 3.2 Urban growth 1801–1901 Table 3.3 Comparisons for UK
Chapter 4 Table 4.1 National public toilet provision Table 4.2 Example: US high school designed for 900 students
Chapter 9 Table 9.1 Differences: Planning and building control processes
xvii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
part one . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
The Problem of Public Toilets
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
LOSE OUT
chapter one . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Introduction: background and context The problem of public toilets and its relevance to architects This book investigates the problem of inadequate public toilet provision and discusses the role of urban design in contributing towards a solution. Public toilet provision has become increasingly unsatisfactory, because of closure of existing facilities and a general neglect and marginalisation of toilet issues by urban policy-makers.1 Why are public toilets of relevance to architects, or to the creation of Great Architecture? Architects are increasingly taking on the roles of urban designer, regenerator and policy leader, as legitimated by the Urban Taskforce agenda (Rogers, 2000). New Urbanism and urban renewal policies demand that architects contribute to meeting social needs through enlightened design. Public toilets are a necessary component for users of the built environment in enabling user-friendly, sustainable, safe, equitable and accessible cities. While writing predominantly for a built environment specialist audience, the areas of health, sustainability and equality also feature strongly in this study as key considerations in achieving better toilet provision. Government policy is putting greater emphasis upon the need to create sustainable cities, by means of reducing the use of the private car and encouraging people to walk, cycle and use public transport. Such a shift creates a need for a concomitant increase in public toilet provision, as mobility patterns change. Likewise, the expansion of the evening economy and 24-hour city puts pressure on toilet facilities and, in particular, the growth of street urination in town centres has brought the issue to media attention. The renaissance in urban design, whose agenda nowadays includes attention to user needs as well as aesthetic considerations, demands a more holistic ‘joined-up-thinking’ approach to meeting public need. Public toilets should be included in the new vision of the city, as valued components of modern townscape, rather than being hidden behind some bushes where they are likely to be vandalised.
CHAPTER ONE • INTRODUCTION: BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT
SECTION ONE: THE BACKGROUND: PUBLIC
3
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
This book is written from the premise that public toilets should be seen as an integral and important component of modern urban design and town planning policy, at city-wide, local area and individual site level. Designing toilets has been seen by some architects as the equivalent of doing latrine duty in the Army. The provision of public toilets should not be seen as an unpleasant low status function, typically in with local authority cemeteries, allotments and waste disposal departments and carried out, albeit with good intentions, by the public works and plumbing fraternity alone. There is no shortage of existing toilet manuals which provide the details and dimensions of internal layout, plumbing fixtures and fittings. Such precepts appear detached from the wider world of urban design and policy. They deal with internal specifications for individual toilet blocks in isolation from the surrounding environmental situation, locational context and modern user needs. In spite of all this technical guidance, there is considerable dissatisfaction with the end product in terms of building design, levels of provision, location, crime and safety factors, hygiene, layout, disabled toilet 2 requirements and accessibility, and so the time is right for a rethink of the existing government standards. Many have argued (BTA, 2001) that the emphasis upon meeting the minimal requirements of British Standards and Building Regulations encourages little consideration of how the location, level of provision and external appearance
Figure 1.1 Closed toilet in Portishead at terminus of bus route out from Bristol. This closed toilet is at a bus terminus. Well located (and open) toilets are necessary to meet the needs of would-be public transport users in outer Bristol. Subsequently demolished in late 2002. 4
Form follows bodily function This book is not another technical manual – although, of course, ‘plumbing’ is always an important determinant in toilet detail; rather, this book is concerned with the way in which toilet planning can meet users’ needs, within the wider context of urban design. This book is written from the perspective of seeing public toilet provision as part of the solution to urban problems, as an integral component of strategic policy, town centre management, and the urban design agendas. It does not present one ideal architectural blueprint for a universalist, totally inclusive toilet as there are so many local situational variables involved which make it impossible to prescribe ‘one size fits all’ design solutions. The study seeks to present principles, guidelines and ideals to inform the design process in all situations. Throughout, greater emphasis is put upon ‘public’ on-street conveniences as an essential component of creating sustainable cities, rather than majoring on ‘off-street’ privately provided public toilets. While the latter may have a complementary role, they are not necessarily open to everyone and therefore truly ‘public’. Nowadays, toilets in shops or fast food outlets are often cited as a viable alternative, or excuse for municipal under-provision, when in reality access may be quite restrictive in terms of physical barriers, times, and ‘glares’. This book combines social aspects and physical design considerations in developing public toilet guidance. We live in a material and visual world in which toilets are an important concrete physical element meeting vital user needs. Good toilet design is sensitive to the architectural axiom that ‘form follows function’, to quote a truism, and in this case ‘bodily function informs form’, in the guise and design in which public toilets manifest themselves within the built environment. One such social issue is ‘gender’ in respect of the differential levels of provision for men and women. The book incorporates a universalist approach to providing public toilets for everyone (Goldsmith, 2000), but it gives greater emphasis to the challenges created by the under-provision and poor design of women’s toilets. The toilet issue affects all ‘users’, but particularly women, who comprise 52% of the population (ONS, 2002). Men on average have twice as much provision as women, as they have urinals as well as closets and a greater number of Gents toilet blocks overall. Anyone out and about in the streets in the daytime doing the shopping, or undertaking other essential caring tasks, may find themselves without the benefit of a convenient office or hotel to nip back into should they need ‘to go’ while away from home (BTA, 2001). Women are
CHAPTER ONE • INTRODUCTION: BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT
exacerbate the problems associated with toilets, such as crime, lack of access, urban incivility and depressing, threatening environs. On the other hand, there is nothing worse than disembodied policies and abstract sociological discussion and analysis ‘floating in a spaceless vacuum’ (Harvey, 1975:24).
5
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS 6
likely to need public toilets more often, and for a greater range of reasons, because of biological differences. While the majority of user groups are female, the majority of providers and policy-making groups are male, and according to women toilet campaigners ‘it simply does not occur to them, it’s not important to them, they don’t find it a problem’. Women have seldom been consulted about toilet design (Cavanagh and Ware, 1991). It is only in recent years with the increase in the numbers of women in architecture and urban design that women have begun to participate in the design process on a professional basis. When the fact that women have fewer public toilets than men is raised, someone is always likely to say, ‘well they could always use a pub’. For a range of cultural, practical, legal and safety reasons, women are less likely than men to go into a ‘strange’ pub to use the toilet, and they are legally forbidden to do so if accompanied by babies or small children. Many ethnic minority and religious women would not enter a premises serving alcohol or fastfood chains selling non-halal (non-kosher) food. Even with liberalisation of opening hours, pubs are unlikely to be open before 11.00 am, thus limiting availability. As public provision is reduced to the minimum, and pubs sport notices stating ‘Toilets strictly for the use of patrons only’, more men as well as women are beginning to notice there is a problem. In other words, most of the population is affected by this issue (Greed, 1996a). The needs of children, the elderly, tourists, public transport users and drivers, postal workers, van drivers and disabled people are not adequately met either by the present situation (Shaw, 2001). The focus of this book is British toilets. Some of the problems are shared internationally but some are peculiar to the British situation, while others are common to the Anglo-Saxon and North European cultural contexts. It used to be said, ‘Britain has the best toilets in the world’, but nowadays many other countries have much better levels of provision. In seeking inspiration and solutions international comparisons and examples will be included, not least from the Far East which is currently in the throes of a toilet revolution. Japan is generally acknowledged to be the ‘toilet leader’ of the world. Other societies’ ideal toilet designs may not be our preferred solution – e.g. the international toilet world is divided over the ‘sit or squat’ debate, the former being a particularly western solution to toilet design. Material from recent World Toilet Conferences in Japan (JTA, 1996a), Singapore (WTO, 2001) and Korea (WTO, 2002) is drawn upon to provide a wider perspective on ‘British’ public lavatory problems. Not only is there a lack of facilities, those that are provided are often substandard. The toilet problem is heightened because of bad design, poor maintenance and management of existing facilities, and lack of toilet attendants. These factors result in insanitary facilities, anti-social behaviour, and an unsuccessful battle against the problems of crime and vandalism that so beset public toilets. Limited opening hours, unequal distribution and inappropriate location of facilities result in ordinary people declaring ‘there’s never a public toilet when you want one’. Unlike buses, three do not come along at once if
CHAPTER ONE • INTRODUCTION: BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT
Figure 1.2 People queuing at the London Eye. Millions of tourists visit this attraction and all of these people, from all age groups, able and disabled, male and female, might need a toilet. The nearest toilets are down steps, thus immediately excluding many of those in this queue.
you wait long enough! Unlike mobile phones, you can’t buy one and take it with you. Not only are facilities poor within toilets, but getting into the toilet in the first place remains a major issue, as highlighted by a wide range of user groups. Small, narrow cubicles with inward opening doors, leaving only a small gap between the toilet bowl and the door, make public toilet use almost impossible for many. The introduction of environmental requirements for disposal containers for sanpro3 to be placed in every cubicle in the Ladies has further reduced space and created an unhygienic situation with the container rubbing right up against the toilet pan and inevitably the user’s leg. Other factors that reduce accessibility for both the disabled and the abled include steep slippery steps down to underground toilets, installation of ‘pay to pee’ turnstiles, and the expansion of the dreaded APC (Automatic Public Convenience) which is not popular with the public. Yet, some North American cities are very proud of their APCs and see them as a major tourist plus point. In San Francisco a tourist promotion film put them in the same ‘fabulous’ category alongside their historic tramcars! They are larger models, with disabled access, and the toilet bowls have automatically cleaned 7
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
seats which make them a bit more bearable for women. Public toilets are being closed down in many American states, not least California, because of a crackdown on drugs and cottaging (male homosexual activity in toilets, sometimes known as cruising). In contrast with Britain, there are still likely to be more available to the public in North American department stores, banks and food outlets. In Britain the municipal public toilet is likely to be the only option available in many areas and when that goes there are few ‘private’ off-street public toilet alternatives compared with those found in mainland Europe within cafés and restaurants. In contrast, in late Victorian times and the Edwardian era public toilet provision had a much higher status which was reflected in the quality of provision. Right up to the 1950s, public toilet provision continued albeit often in the shape of basic provision. Provision was mainly for ‘Gentlemen’, and ‘Ladies’ toilets were the minority. This unequal situation was enshrined in legislation that required men to be given approximately twice as much provision as women, and the difference has not yet been made up. This book recommends that women should be provided with not just ‘equal’ provision but ideally twice as many facilities, because women use on-street public toilets more frequently because of a range of biological and sociological reasons. Men take an average of 35 seconds to go and women take 91 seconds because of anatomical differences and different clothing (Kira, 1976; Asano, 2002); therefore, in the US there has been a move towards ‘potty parity’ between women and men (Soifer, 2001). Unequal provision is untenable in the light of modern advances in the fields of equality, under both Equal Opportunities (EO) and European Union (EU) law.
The scope of the book ’Toilets’ is a topic linking to a range of issues, including (in no particular order) crime and vandalism; sexuality (of all types); the environment, water conservation and global sustainability; health, hygiene and medicine; women’s issues, childcare, breastfeeding and sanpro disposal3; public transport and private travel; leisure, tourism and sport; continence, disability and ageing; architecture, engineering and design; sewerage, drainage and plumbing; religion, culture and taboo. In fact, ‘all human life is there’4, and it was a major task to disentangle the various strands as all the issues are interconnected and overlap. All these topics will be found, inter alia, in this book. Doing research involves investigating the cultural, statutory and attitudinal factors that result in this lack of acknowledgment of such a basic human need among those who design and manage our lives and environment5. While much of my work has gravitated towards the realms of social town planning, urban design and women’s issues, it must be stated that the only subject I came top in at university was ‘sewerage and drainage systems’. Yet it has always puzzled me 8
when standing in the queue for the Ladies loo, why other women in the queue do not protest about the situation, especially in these days of so-called sexual equality and girl power. In spite of all the verbal diarrhoea of equal opportunities policy, little seems to have been achieved at the most basic level of toilet provision. Clearly it is time for a toilet revolution. As a result of lack of provision, a range of medical, environmental, social equity and access issues are aggravated and intensified. In spite of the current government’s protestations as to its commitment to social inclusion, equality, health and environmental sustainability, nothing has changed. It has always seemed so ‘obvious’ (to me at least but apparently not to others) that public toilets are a basic necessity, and therefore it is time to write down the reasons and arguments for better toilet provision. After all, ‘everyone has got to go sometime…’. Someone arriving from Mars would not get this impression, for one can search in vain for any mention of public toilets on street maps and tourist guides; in official documents on urban issues; and within ‘serious’ academic and professional work one would find a glaring lacuna (gap) and deafening silence. A woman who came to Britain from mainland China told me when she first arrived in London she was desperate to find a toilet, and seeing piles of dog dirt on the pavement concluded that perhaps these were human faeces and this was the local custom. Fortunately she was directed to a toilet before deciding to follow
CHAPTER ONE • INTRODUCTION: BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT
Figure 1.3 Realms concerned with toilets.
9
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
suit and squat on the pavement. So the book relates to the needs of a wide range of types of people who compose society.
The style of the book The purpose of this book is to investigate the factors which have shaped and determined the ‘problem’ of the nature and currently poor level of public toilet provision in Britain and, second, to identify those factors, change agents and processes which might ameliorate the situation, increase provision and provide a ‘solution’, and to suggest improved design standards and means of providing better toilets. Arguably one cannot effectively design public toilets unless one understands the reasons and background to the problems to be addressed. Otherwise one ends up with a mechanistic application of set rules and generalised standards, often with disastrously inappropriate results. Relatively speaking, in the first part of the book ‘the problem’ – that is, the reasons and issues resulting in poor provision – are investigated, while in the second part of the book emphasis is put upon identifying design solutions and policy guidelines. The situation and solutions are looked at from both user and provider perspectives throughout. So, in summary, the contents of the book may be seen as running along two main continua:
Contents Part I, ‘The problem’, comprises Sections I and II, sets out the cultural and attitudinal factors that contribute to the problem, and gives reasons why it is vital that the situation should be improved, because one cannot design something unless one understands the needs and issues involved first. Part II, ‘The solution’, comprises Sections III and IV, gives policy and design guidance that might improve the situation, and means of achieving change, respectively. Albeit Part II inevitably has to refer (back) to the problems identified in Part I, as the debate is always a tense dualism revolving around the key questions of ‘what is the problem?’ and ‘what can be done about it?’. The book seeks to give both ideal (maximum) and pragmatic (minimum) solutions in view of the hostile state of toilet funding. Since building toilets is only half the battle, attention is given to man10
agement, maintenance, financial and organisational issues too. These are all components of the modern urban agenda of maintaining the regenerated city in a sustainable state. Ideal solutions to solving the problem would involve major investment, cultural and political change, and a whole new way of looking at the toilet situation. Therefore, where possible, the book provides both ‘best solutions’ and more pragmatic interim solutions and designs that take into account the realities of the present funding climate. Section I comprises Chapters 1–4 and provides the conceptual, historical and legal context to the ‘problem’ of public toilets. Following the introductory Chapter 1, Chapter 2 provides the conceptual perspective to the study, in order to place ‘toilet provision’ as a valid subject within academic study and professional activity (skip this chapter if you are not academically inclined). Chapter 3 looks at the historical development of public lavatory provision as a means of understanding how we got to where we are now, and in order to learn from the past examples of provision. Toilets from the past comprise a substantial component of the modern built environment and are part of the living fabric of the modern city. Chapter 4 continues the story with particular emphasis upon the legislative context that has shaped the unequal and inadequate levels of provision across the twentieth century. A major problem is that the laws governing local authority provision of public toilets are ‘permissive’ rather than ‘mandatory’ – that
CHAPTER ONE • INTRODUCTION: BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT
Figure 1.4 The range of public toilet user groups.
11
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS 12
is, local authorities ‘may’ provide toilets if they so wish, but there is no requirement that they ‘must’. Legislative change is essential in order to enable the provision of better designed, more equal and accessible toilet provision. Section II comprises Chapters 5–7 and considers three of the most dominant perspectives, or sets of worldviews on the toilet problem, which strongly influence the chances, or not, of achieving better provision, and the type of design solutions likely to be adopted. While this book will cover many of the details and practicalities of public toilet facilities and design, it has to be concerned with deeper causal and cultural factors which shape the level of provision and the wider nature of our towns and cities and likely levels of comfort within the built environment. There is no point in providing new and better toilets if they are soon vandalised and closed because underlying social attitudes remain unchanged and unregenerated within society. Chapter 5 considers the cultural aspects of toilet provision, looking at societal attitudes towards bodily functions, human waste, sex and ‘dirt’. To investigate these vexed issues one has to draw upon a diversity of academic and professional realms, including anthropology, history, sociology, religion and feminism, but also plumbing, sewerage, public health, town planning, architecture, sanitary engineering, environmentalism and urban governance, in order to make sense of it all. In Chapter 6 the medical dimensions of public toilet provision are considered within the context of an increasingly ageing population who generally ‘need to go more often’, and women’s so-called ‘special needs’ owing to our ‘different’ biological functions. It addresses both clinical and public health reasons – that is, at both the curative and preventative arguments, for increased toilet provision. Toilet provision and related sewerage and disposal systems have become the subject of considerable debate within the world of environmentalism, sustainability, public health and the new healthy cities agenda. Chapter 7 provides an opportunity to discuss the global context and to make international comparisons with particular reference to other advanced developed nations and in respect of developing Third World nations. Many developing countries do not have water-based sewage systems, and many would argue that it is inappropriate to promote the Western ‘flush and forget’ approach to waste disposal. Instead, a ‘recycle and remember’ approach is more sustainable. Thus by the end of Parts I and II the reader will be aware of the global spectrum of toilet issues likely to impinge upon the design agenda. The second part of the book, comprising Sections III and IV, is concerned with solutions, with presenting urban policies and design guidance in respect of achieving better public toilet provision; and with the means of achieving change respectively. In Section III, Chapters 8, 9 and 10 are concerned with the design aspects of public toilets, working down through the city-wide level issues to local urban design aspects including the siting and configuration of toilet blocks, and thus down to the layout of facilities and design of cubicles and everything there-
CHAPTER ONE • INTRODUCTION: BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT
in. Thus the debate ranges from high level urban spatial strategy to the question of where to put the toilet roll. Although Section III is more prescriptive in style, unlike ‘toilet manuals’ it retains a more discursive policy guideline approach which seeks to explain and give reasons for the principles presented. Chapter 8 gives a city-wide ‘macro’ perspective on the question of ‘where will they go?’ – that is, on people’s needs for decent toilets within urban space. People of all sorts need to go to the toilet ‘away from home’ (BTA, 2001), not ‘just’ disabled people. As people travel further and spend more time away from home as a result of modern decentralised, car dependent, segregated land uses, a range of improved back-up services is needed. Alternative perspectives and solutions will be discussed which have put an emphasis on ‘planning for the city of everyday life’ (Eurofem, 1996). Emphasis is put upon seeing the public toilet as a strategic component of spatial planning, not a marginalised townscape feature. Chapter 9 looks in more detail at the problem of toilets within the context of the factors that limit people’s access to the city, especially people with disabilities. It is acknowledged fully that dedicated disabled facilities are needed, and far more than at present, but the ways in which this is approached, not least the question of the segregation between abled/disabled facilities and the need for a more inclusive agenda, are also explored. Chapter 10 moves on to looking at toilet provision at the ‘meso’ level in terms of the location, siting and distribution of public toilets at the local, district and neighbourhood level, and highlights the urban design considerations involved. Chapter 11 centres on the detailed ‘micro’ aspects of internal toilet design, of the toilet block, the cubicle and all the components that go to make up the public toilet, and thus comprises the longest and most design orientated chapter. Because of the plethora of information involved, additional checklists of key points and priorities are provided at the end of the chapter in an aidemémoire box. Diagrams are provided to illustrate key design considerations and principles rather than as prescriptive exact architectural drawings. Having set out what needs to be done, the last two chapters look at the means of achieving change. Chapter 12 discusses management, maintenance and finance issues. It is one thing to build toilets, it is quite another to keep them in good working order, open and not vandalised. There are many related issues as to who pays, who maintains them and how their management is incorporated, or not, into the running of public toilets. There is no doubt that sanitary ware manufacturers want more public toilets as it increases their sales, but local authorities are more cautious because of the huge ongoing costs of maintaining toilet provision. In the course of my toilet research I have often come across hard pressed, but well intentioned, local authority toilet supervisors who want to provide better toilets but do not have the power, the policy brief, or the money to generate change. Thus they get all the blame while valiantly trying to fight off vandalism
13
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
Figure 1.5 Typical public toilet in a seaside resort, at Watchet, Somerset. This toilet is in a centrally located car park – ideal for visitors wanting an easy-to-find public loo at journey’s end.
and building deterioration in order to continue to provide a service to the public. Significantly, most departments responsible for running toilets are completely separate from the strategic planning departments in their local authorities, which means that they have neither the resources nor the means of mainstreaming toilet provision into strategic policy-making. Clearly the problem has to be addressed and dealt with at a much higher level, as an integral component of national governmental policy, as left to themselves the typical ‘parks, allotments and public conveniences’ department of the local municipality can never be expected to solve such huge problems on its own. To achieve this, major change is required. Therefore Chapter 13 identifies likely change agents, and outlines the agendas of both key provider groups (including enlightened public sector and private commercial providers) and key user groups including community, pressure and special interest groups who are all campaigning for better toilets from a range of perspectives, including concerns with access, childcare, equality, health, elderly people, women’s issues, and the environment. The final chapter (Chapter 14) identifies promising means of bringing about such change and comprises a drawing together of the whole study. It is one thing to say what should be done, how better facilities might be provided and that ‘the government should do something’. It is quite another matter to implement policy and create actual change. It is argued that in order to effect concrete policy change it is vital to create a cultural change within the hearts and minds of toilet 14
providers. Potentially useful areas of government policy and changing legislation will be identified, ranging from Millennium funding, European spatial planning to local government finance reforms. A range of other legislative and governmental means will be discussed in this last chapter. The wider context in respect of Britain’s place within Europe and the likely effects of European harmonisation and subsidiarity upon urban form, legislation and fundamental ways of life will be discussed. Changing demographics and the development of a more culturally and ethnically diverse population create needs for a more varied and flexible approach to toilet provision. Many of the problems seem to recur in society – there is nothing new and it all seems so obvious – but people have to be reminded again and again. So this book will bear testimony to what needs to be done. ‘Plus ça change, plus c’est le même chose’.
CHAPTER ONE • INTRODUCTION: BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT
Figure 1.6 Men have more places to pee, as they have the urinals as well as the cubicles, although many facilities are very basic. (Photograph courtesy of Ray Fowler).
Notes 1.
The word toilet is used as it is widely understood internationally. In Britain the term public lavatory is more common, and public conveniences (uses of words will be discussed later). Lavatory originally related to the washbasin 15
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
2. 3. 4. 5.
rather than the toilet itself. Lavatory is still used in Britain as a less affected, ‘non-U’ or ‘naff’ term than ‘toilet’. Personally I prefer the term ‘lav’. ‘Disabled toilets’ is used for ‘toilets for people with disabilities’ and does not imply there is something faulty or disabled with the toilet plumbing! Sanpro is short for sanitary protection products (including sanitary towels, tampons, napkins etc.) (Tallantire and Carroll, 1996). The phrase ‘all human life is there’ used to be a slogan used by the Sunday People, a British tabloid newspaper. We found this when we undertook Nuffield-funded research on ‘User and provider perspectives in public toilet provision’ based on a small case study of a sector stretching out from the centre of Bristol across North Somerset to Weston Super Mare (Greed and Daniels, 2002). The research continues. Under the EPSRC SUE Consortium, Vivacity 2020: ‘Urban Sustainability for the 24 hour city’, Dr Julienne Hanson (UCL) invited Dr Clara Greed (UWE) to act as expert advisor in the team for Work Package 9, ‘A sustainable strategy for the provision of public conveniences in city centres’ based on a national study of a range of city centre locations (EPSRC, 2003).
Principles for integration into urban design agenda
16
➥
Joined up thinking
➥
Holistic approach
➥
From the strategic to the detailed
➥
From the uttermost to the guttermost
➥
Equality and demographics
➥
A global perspective
➥
Access and environment
Conceptualising the problem of public toilets
Placing the study The purpose of this chapter is to provide a conceptual background to the study. The chapter seeks to place ‘toilets’ in a research and policy context. Those who are not academically inclined please skip this chapter. It considers theories and taboos that might help explain ‘why’ the public toilet situation is in such a sorry state, and ‘why’ the policy-makers and government bodies who are meant to be responsible for provision are not particularly concerned – when ‘everyone’ is demanding better toilets. Unless the underlying ‘social’ attitudes are identified and dealt with, it will be impossible to achieve long-term, sustainable change in the physical reality of public toilet design. One reason is that it is still ‘not done’ to talk about toilets and the functions that take place in them. While there has been a sexual revolution, there has not been a commensurate ‘defecation revolution’ (Aglionby, 2001). It is important to look at the aspatial (social) factors that shape and determine spatial (architectural and urban design) realities (Foley, 1964:37) in investigating the toilet problem and its likely solutions. Thus this study is interested in the ‘reproduction over space of social relations over space’ (Massey, 1984: 16), in this case the imprint of cultural taboos and especially gender relations upon the built environment (Greed, 1991: 5) in relation to the chances of public toilet provision in our towns and cities. One of the objectives of the study is to make a small contribution to answering another part of the classic urban question of ‘who gets what, where, and why?’ (Pinch, 1985) (not a lot), and consequently to make recommendations for changing the situation. I include material in the second part of this chapter on the processes of governance, policy-making and potential change. There is no point in coming up with new designs for better toilets without also looking at the chances of implementation and installation of improved provision, as so strong are the taboos that some sorts of solutions are culturally unacceptable. At the close of the chapter a brief summary of method-
CHAPTER TWO • CONCEPTUALISING THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
chapter two . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
17
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS 18
ology used is included and, finally, a set of key dualisms (opposites) is presented around which the toilet debate revolves.
Levels of engagement It was helpful to divide up the key toilet issues and causal factors into different categories, at the macro, meso and micro levels, which for the purposes of this study are defined as follows. ‘Macro’ refers to the big issues, to the overall situation, and to national and large-scale factors affecting toilet decision-making as a whole. Likewise, discussions of the built environment, the city-wide perspective, urban master planning, urban society itself and the power of the built environment professions as a whole are all macro issues. This high policy level is extremely important to this research as it fundamentally shapes the chances of toilet issues being taken seriously and included in discussions of funding, resource allocation and urban regeneration priority formulation. In contrast, ‘micro’ refers to personal and detailed issues and, for example, includes the experience of a particular minority individual, the problems of a specific building, maintenance problems, incidences of vandalism, ‘where to put the toilet roll’ and the individual prejudices of the ‘jobsworth’ toilet official. Yet quite small changes at the micro level of daily life (such as increasing the clearance between the toilet bowl and the inward opening door within the toilet cubicle by a few centimetres) require monumental and concerted effort at the highest ministerial level, at the macro level of governmental policy-making. One soon finds that ‘everything is linked to everything else’ and one has to embark on a long and complex quest to get to the root of the problem (Greed, 1994a, 1999a, 2000a and b). There are some ‘macro’ level issues which overarch and influence everything at all other levels, and these are so important in shaping toilet policy that the next chapter is devoted to underlying cultural issues. These include deep-seated attitudes held within society towards excretion, the body and sexuality, which are generally negative and which contribute to the low status and taboo mentality which is often associated with toilet issues. There is already a considerable range of literature on cultural taboos and the obsession for separating out clean/dirty components. A list of key dualisms mentioned in the book as a whole is included at the end of this chapter. ’Meso’ is more difficult to explain, as it contains the idea of movement and transmission between macro and micro levels. In urban terms the ‘meso’ (middle) level is the in-between level, and comprises the local district and neighbourhood level between the whole city and the individual site or toilet location. Organisationally the meso level contains the individual professions, institutions and people that transmit macro level societal attitudes and cultural hang-ups ‘down’ into the micro level of actual policy and design standards. This relationship and process may be represented in a simple one-line flow diagram as follows:
‘Macro’ and ‘micro’ are sometimes used with the disability agenda to mean something different. For example, according to Goldsmith (2000), a macroist viewpoint ‘means’ that disabled people should be treated the same as everyone else – they are mainstream customers and a ‘universalist’ approach should therefore be adopted. In contrast, according to Goldsmith’s definition, a microist approach is based on the view that disabled people are special and should be treated differently and as welfare recipients. In comparison in North America, a macroist approach ‘sees’ disabled people as citizens and equal consumers with constitutional rights. Goldsmith certainly favours the macroist approach, arguing that all facilities should be improved so that everyone benefits. Advocates of the needs of women, children, babies, the elderly and tourists inter alia, argue the same, as so many people find the ‘normal’ toilet cubicle too small to get into if accompanied by pushchairs, luggage, shopping etc. as they jealously eye the disabled toilet provision. So overall my approach is macroist too in this sense, as well as inclusive and universalist, with the proviso that while all facilities should be accessible to everyone, especially women, in some cases additional ‘special’ provision is needed too – e.g. for the users of wider powered wheelchairs, or for those adults who require changing tables because of advanced incontinence and mobility problems.
CHAPTER TWO • CONCEPTUALISING THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
A universalist approach
Social exclusion One of the problems limiting change is the fact that provider groups, especially local and central government bodies, seldom seem to hear let alone see the needs of user groups. It is as if we are invisible. When it comes to public toilets, 19
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS 20
the professionals and providers and the users and pressure groups seem to be ‘talking past each other’, manifesting complete mutual incomprehension and lack of awareness of each other’s perceptions of reality (Hillier, 1999). To understand why this is so, it is helpful to see the world of ‘toilets’ as possessing its own professional subculture. ‘Subculture’ is taken to mean the cultural traits, beliefs and lifestyle peculiar to ‘the plumbing fraternity’. One of the most important factors appears to be the need for a person to ‘fit in’ to the subculture. I have argued in previous research that the values and attitudes of the subculture, as held by its members, have a major influence on their professional decision-making. These ultimately influence the level and nature of provision – that is, ‘what is built’ (or, more likely in the case of toilets, what is left unbuilt and considered unimportant). Thus professional socialisation may be seen as a major factor affecting both men and women, resulting in pressure to conform and ‘not to rock the boat’ if they want to progress up the jobs ladder. Anyone talking toilets in the wrong circles may find this is a bad career move leading to humiliation, sexism and potentially social exclusion from the professional group. Indeed such are the powers of professional socialisation that women architects, planners and designers may not necessarily hold different views from men on gendered issues such as toilet design (Greed, 1994b). Gender is a major consideration in understanding ‘who’ receives what sort of treatment; so are class and ethnicity. For clarification, ‘gender’ is normally taken to mean the social role of women in different cultures. This is in contrast to ‘sex’ which is taken to mean the biological characteristics of women. For example, in all societies only women give birth to children, but the gender role of caring for them may differ somewhat between societies and social classes. In the case of public toilets both gender and sex are key factors in understanding the very ‘different’ needs that women have in respect of the design and provision of public toilets. My previous research on the built environment professions, including the world of surveyors, engineers and other construction practitioners, has shown that quantitatively less than 5% of construction professionals and clients are women (Greed, 1999b, 2000c). It is argued that, although their professional decisions are meant to be impartial, neutral and purely informed by technical and policy factors, the individual life experience, age and health characteristics of the decision-makers are major constraints on their worldview and thus on the professional decision they make. Of course there are many other ‘actors’, apart from those on the standard setting committees involved in the wider urban development process (Kirk, 1980: 38–41; Ambrose, 1986: 68–69), including architects, town planners, local councillors and central government level politicians, all of whom have an impact on ‘what is built’ and how budgets are set. Financial institutions and private property developers have a major impact too, not only on private sector schemes, but also on public sector development, particularly if the provision of public conven-
CHAPTER TWO • CONCEPTUALISING THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
iences is part of so-called ‘community benefit’ or ‘planning gain’ within the negotiations for a new shopping development. The power of different actors in the process varies according to the particular situation. Although all these actors in the development process might not be on the ‘same side’, nevertheless they are mainly likely to be male and not particularly concerned with the question of either public lavatories or, for that matter, childcare provision, crèches or disabled access, unless statutory requirements exist as an issue. Instead, [male] toilet agenda issues predominate, such as crime, cottaging, and [male] street urination and cost cutting. It is not contested there are other overarching ‘macro level’ economic, social and political factors which shape urban space too. Design and development decisions cannot always be accounted for by purely financial, political, practical or technological constraints. Matters related to the gender, race, disability and cultural perspective of the professional decision-makers undoubtedly influence the end product, and the way it is produced. While everyone pleads the importance of the ‘cost factor’ and ‘time constraints’, it may be argued that in fact the subcultural peculiarities of the ‘plumbing fraternity’ actually create additional expense and difficulties. As will be illustrated in later chapters, in some instances less profitable and less practical solutions are made because of ignorance of the needs, potential contribution and the economic significance of minority groups. Stories of committees spending hours discussing the dimensions of a new cistern while remaining completely blind to the impractically small size of the toilet compartment and the general under-provision for women are legendary in toilet campaign circles. Women who try to get involved in the development process and to influence events may feel isolated. The need for identification with the values of the subculture would seem to block out the entrance of both people and alternative ideas that are seen as ‘different’. The concept of ‘closure’, and the social exclusion that results, as discussed by Parkin (1979: 89–90) and first developed by Weber (1964: 141–52, 236) in relation to the power of various sub-groups protecting their status, is a key theme. This is worked out on a day-to-day basis at the interpersonal level, with some people being made to feel awkward, unwelcome and ‘wrong’, and others being welcomed into the subculture, made to feel comfortable and encouraged to progress to the decision-making levels within it. While policy-makers are predominantly male, middle class and apparently unlikely to be using public transport or having childcare responsibilities, those who are the subject of toilet policy – that is, those who need them most – are likely to be so-called minorities, namely women, especially women with children and elderly women, disabled people and those who use public transport and are dependent on local facilities. Significantly tourists also need public toilets; and they may, in their own countries, be of ‘higher’ social significance but as shortterm ‘foreigners’ in Britain they too are unlikely to receive much attention to their needs. Not only are public toilets seen as a low status area of policy concern but
21
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS 22
the users too are not seen to be of any importance. In reality virtually everyone nowadays pays rates and taxes, and so-called minorities constitute, together, the majority of the population whom the professionals and policy-makers are meant to be serving. Clearly it is all a matter of perceptions and ‘how’ they see the world. It is argued that to change policy one must change the policy-makers, and there are no quick answers.
The urban problem The ‘problem’ for women in particular is that although they are significant users of the built environment, e.g. as workers and public transport passengers, and they comprise 52% of the population, the majority of the elderly population and 60% of all potential voters, the built environment is mainly designed by men, who comprise over 95% of built environment professionals and still the majority of politicians and decision-makers at central and local government levels. Women utilise the built environment differently from men because, even today, they are the main carers, often combining childcare and homemaking with work outside the home. This may result in quite different travel patterns and landuse requirements. For example, for many women the ‘journey to work’ is not a mono-destination trip but may consist of ‘trip-chaining’ as they travel from home, to the childminder, to the school gates, to the office, to the shops and back again. All this will often involve a lot of hanging about at cold bus stops if the woman does not have the use of a car. For many women the ideal design would be the city of short distances, of mixed land uses with increased proximity between home and work locations, and a high level of dispersal of local facilities, amenities, shops, and schools. This ideal city form, pioneered by leading European town planners, is called ‘the city of everyday life’ which, incidentally, would also be a highly environmentally sustainable city (Eurofem, 1996). Thus women and those they are caring for require a different pattern of toilets, including a greater number at different locations (Greed, 1999a; WGSG, 1997a,b; Booth et al, 1996; Little, 1994; Darke et al, 2000). Likewise buildings, and the components within, are designed around standards based on the height of the average man (De Graft-Johnson, 1999). In the case of toilet design it would seem that the starting point has been to design around male requirements and then adapt the standards to female needs rather than acknowledging that both biologically and socially women’s use of toilets is likely to be so different from those of men that this requires a totally different approach to design. Not only are women’s needs unrecognised but disabled people (who constitute around 5 million people, the size of the population of Norway) and ethnic minority groups (constituting majority populations in several inner city locations within London and the Midlands) have not had sufficient voice in the toilet debate. Women, disabled, elderly, and ethnic minorities are not mutually exclu-
Urban governance perspectives While my own research has been particularly concerned with the role of the professional bodies, especially those within the built environment and engineering professions in shaping policy, as stated earlier there are other important actors in the process, not least governmental agencies, civil servants and politicians at central and local government levels. Julia Edwards has undertaken parallel studies of the toilet situation in relation to the role of these groups, drawing on her own background in public policy, management, health service and local government research, adopting both a feminist, health and disability related perspective (Edwards and McKie, 1996a). Since her work is of such great value in understanding ‘why’ public toilet provision remains a neglected area some of her key concepts are presented below. Edwards argues that much local government policy-making, that is meant to be serving the needs of the citizen, is in fact misdirected and unsatisfactory. She describes policy-making, in respect of public toilet provision, as ‘organised irresponsibility’ (Edwards, 1998a). She cites Beck (1992) who coined this concept and originally applied it to the ineffectiveness of governmental policy-making in respect of controlling global risks such as oil pollution and drug trafficking, but subsequently the concept has been applied to a wide range of macro level policy-making situations. She also discusses Ham and Hill’s work (1993) on the concept of responsible policy-making within the US. Ham and Hill argue that bad publicity and negative public feedback along the ‘links’ within the governmental policy-making machinery will act as a check and balance to right bad policy-making. She argues that in the British situation policy-making is fragmented and there is no mutual accountability between government departments, so that no such links exist and nothing will change. Edwards applies these conceptual insights to the problem of public toilets for women. She argues that the powers that be can always make much of the deficiencies in women themselves, such as the loss of muscle tone and the effects of age on contributing to incontinence, rather than ‘making’ local authorities culpable for contributing to the problem by closing public toilets. It would seem that loss of public conveniences means that women develop strained bladders. Meanwhile local authorities apparently remain ignorant of
CHAPTER TWO • CONCEPTUALISING THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
sive groups and in some circumstances – e.g. in rural villages in the South West – the most ‘typical’ citizen may be female and elderly, and not the young male worker whose image is so often used to represent ‘everyone’. Likewise, in many inner city areas the average citizen, statistically, is the middle-aged woman of Afro-Caribbean descent working part-time in the care industry. Women’s ‘different’ needs in respect of toilets in the city of men are discussed later in the context of city planning assumptions.
23
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS 24
their role in creating this medical crisis, and more money is instead put into the NHS incontinence services (or not). Thus the problem becomes one of incompetence rather than incontinence. Similar scenarios could be developed to explain why disabled people are likewise ‘blamed’ for the woes of the toilet world, or why American tourists are seen as over-demanding when all they want are simply ordinary decent public toilets when they come to see England. So there is a blatant lack of ‘joined-up thinking’, fragmentation and accountability which all adversely affects women, yet women themselves are likely to be ‘blamed’ and their complaints medicalised rather than solved through public convenience provision. Edwards comments that Beck suggests democratic feedback and testing are put into effect before policies are implemented, and, as explained later, I have found that others have argued for more accountability and consultation before closures take place. In the case of women this is difficult to implement as they are generally left out of the political forum of consultees to start with, but the British system is highly fragmented and unaccountable in any case. How can such organised irresponsibility be overcome? Beck says the burden of accountability and proof that the policy changes (closures) will not cause health risks should be put upon the instigators of the new policies and not vice versa to prove the ‘technical safety’ and ‘concrete safety’ of the proposals. A reversal of the burden of proof would require local authorities to prove there were no harmful effects to closure before they did so, and she cites Seatown as an example which she has studied. There are problems with this solution as toilet closure is never promoted as a new definitive policy, rather it is often the thoughtless result in a stealthy process of finding soft options to attack in order to save money. Much of the problem revolves around shortcomings in existing toilet legislation which is permissive and discretionary (they may) rather than compulsory and obligatory (they must) under the 1936 Public Health Act. In parallel no special money is allocated or ringfenced for toilet provision and this in turn results in the toilet area of policy being open to attack and defunding. Edwards argues that to change the discourse much is expected of toilet users’ groups, especially women, as in terms of power they are clearly not equal to the government agencies they are confronting. She points out that they are fragmented, under-funded, voluntary and weak as a group. Women, generally, do not speak the language of science or of the policy-makers they must confront. Their voice is fragmented and stretched over a range of policy areas, including disability, childcare, incontinence and safety issues. From a town planning viewpoint, the lack of strategic policy in respect of public toilet provision is extremely serious. The decline in public toilet provision has been initially slow and by stealth. Unlike the Beeching cuts to the railway network in the 1960s, when so many branch lines and their stations were closed, toilet-culling has been more gradual and without any great government
Collaborative community-based approaches to decision-making The question of how to achieve effective and responsive policy-making within both central and local government has been the subject of much discussion, particularly in the realms of town planning and urban policy-making. A set of theories concerning what are known as collaborative, communicative and institutionalist approaches to planning became popular in the 1990s and may be helpful in effecting change. In summary, all these theories focused upon the importance of working with and through social and community networks, agencies and social institutions to facilitate policy change (Healey, 1997: 5). An institutionalist approach takes into account the diversity of the ‘planned’ and stresses the need for participation of a range of stakeholders in the planning process. The emphasis is upon participatory democracy within a pluralistic society. The approach to doing planning is based upon negotiation, networking and liaison with community groups, rather than upon autocratic direction and coercion. Such a collaborative approach may be seen to be at work in the world of public toilets, with the BTA comprising a key ‘institution’ acting as an important link between the private sector toilet producers, local authority providers, local authority policy-makers and planners, and voluntary campaign groups representing users. There are considerable problems with collaborative planning approaches, not least the fact that town planners often speak a different language to that of ‘the planned’. The issues that community and pressure groups consider important may seldom even figure in the discussions of plan-makers – not least the importance of public toilets. Minority groups have expressed concern that the stakeholders are not necessarily dissaggregated in such a way that would allow space for the consideration of the differing needs within the community on the basis of class, race, gender and age. Concern is expressed that many policymakers are ill-equipped to operate a more communicative egalitarian planning
CHAPTER TWO • CONCEPTUALISING THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
pronouncement. There has been no policy as such – it has happened by default. Just because people travel by car more nowadays and less by public transport and foot does not mean they need fewer toilets; arguably they need more. The present government makes much of the empowerment of the people, of combatting social exclusion, developing responsive policies to people’s needs and getting more people walking, cycling and using public transport. The implications of all this for public toilet policy seem to be lost upon the planners. The final section offers some further insights on the nature of policy-making, drawing on current town planning theory with a view to addressing the key issue of how to generate change.
25
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
system, when they do not understand the basic principles of equal opportunities policy and lack social awareness or understanding of the needs of the issues that concern ordinary people. This is especially so when the planners and other local government policy-makers come from technical and engineering backgrounds and lack awareness of social issues and practical problems that affect people’s lives. Real collaborative planning requires accountability because ‘the planned’ are now to be seen as citizens, customers, clients and stakeholders, rather than as the masses who have to be planned ‘for’ and placated. Statutory planning is seen as a service, and one that must be shown to be efficient, economical and rapid. Thus a series of initiatives have been introduced to speed up and improve the planning service, such as Audits and Best Value initiatives (Greed, 2002a, 2000b), which are intended to increase accountability. In reality, in many cases there is no right of consultation, participation and referral when major policy decisions are being made that affect a large majority of the population, such as the closure of public toilets.
Methodology When undertaking the various research studies upon which this book is based, I sought to identify key themes, problems, contacts, concepts, questions and potential means of change in order to help understand and make sense of the situation. In tandem I always sought to incorporate all that was best in terms of standards, design guidance, regulations, urban design principles, town planning policies, etc. One must pay equal attention to the social, political and cultural driving forces enabling or blocking public toilet provision, but at the same time one must deal with the realities of the modern world and plainly state what is needed and how it should be designed, thus weaving together the ‘invisible’ aspatial forces with the very visual, concrete, and potentially aesthetic issues regarding the form that public toilets physically take as components of the built environment. In other words I have sought to take into account both the ‘airy fairy’ and the ‘nitty gritty’ issues (as my students put it) in approaching the question of the design of public toilets. All this involved an extensive literature review across a range of academic and professional realms, looking at both contemporary and historical material. I sought to identify the main groups involved in the toilet world, namely user and provider groups and to discuss the issues with them. Other toilet studies (few though they be) have used interviewing and open-ended questioning. Llewelyn in his study of Welsh public toilets (Llewelyn, 1996) undertook 100 street interviews and visited 265 toilets in 18 towns in conjunction with the Welsh Consumer Council (1996). There have been a range of studies by the various interest groups, usually undertaken by volunteers and local activists. AMC and BTA have 26
CHAPTER TWO • CONCEPTUALISING THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
undertaken studies of different issues but have kept a weather eye on what is going on. The information gathered by BTA members from visits and ‘undercover’ work for the Loo of the Year Award is a source of useful toilet information to build up a national picture, as published in reports such as 50 of the Best Loos in Britain (BTA, 2000a). I was particularly interested in any studies that included a spatial, mapping element as to the distribution and location of public toilets. As mentioned, studies have been undertaken by transport user groups focused on station and termini provision (Midwinter, 1994). Various disability groups have produced maps and guides of the location of toilet facilities (such as RADAR, 1998). ITAAL (Is There An Accessible Loo), a group concerned with more and better toilets for people with disabilities, has been undertaking an Atlas Guide Project of the whole of Britain showing where disabled toilets of all sorts and locations might be found (ITAAL, 2001). A guide to Exmoor National Park (Pitman, 2001), produced by a voluntary local group, covers all the villages and thoughtfully includes all sorts of details. There has been a long history of desperate guidebooks trying to steer people around our cities – e.g. ‘Access in London’ (Couch et al, 1984) – which show how few and far between toilet facilities are in modern cities. WDS has also investigated toilets in London and carried out ad hoc studies of the London boroughs, usually again in response to complaints or observations from members (WDS ongoing). Some national mapping companies include toilets on their maps but often they are just the disabled ones as with the A–Z. Individual local authorities have undertaken surveys such as Cheshire (1993), a renowned hotspot of toilet activism and WI (Women’s Institute) involvement. Some local authorities have produced their own toilet maps (such as the excellent map produced by the Corporation of London) but to our surprise some did not have any map of the location of their toilets, or any written policies at all. Presumably the main supervisor knew where they all were in his or her head! Newer versions of A–Zs are now showing all toilets, whereas previously they showed none, or only disabled toilets. Likewise, AA street maps, Ordnance Survey street maps (not grid maps) are showing conveniences at last. In the course of undertaking the research for the book, I was successful in obtaining a small Nuffield grant and, with my research assistant Isobel Daniels at the UWE, we undertook a cameo study of 8 provider groups and 8 user groups in North Somerset. The purpose of the research was to investigate the differences between user and provider perspectives in public toilet provision. User expectations and concerns with access, distribution and quality of facilities were found to be very different from provider concerns with saving money while protecting and maintaining toilet buildings. In this study we used a qualitative, indepth approach which sought to go beyond looking at ‘what’ to considering ‘why’, ‘how’ and ‘when’ in respect of current and future provision of public toilets. Methodologically this was an illustrative study using open-ended questions while
27
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
generally adopting an ethnographic stance to the culture of the organisation in question (Atkinson et al, 2001). While a few examples from this study are included in this book, the full account of the research findings has been produced as a Faculty occasional paper (Greed and Daniels, 2002).
Dualisms Since the toilet world seems to be so riven and divided by different perceptions of the issues and problems, it was helpful to draw up a series of dualisms, or opposites, that have shaped toilet policy and design in order to help make sense of it all. For example, the public/private distinction is crucial in terms of who is doing the providing. As discussed later, the question of whether toilets are onstreet (publicly provided) or off-street (privately provided by the developer or owner of the building in question) and the related insides/outsides dualism was a helpful organising concept. This list is arguably useful as it delineates and structures the proscribed aspects of toilet agenda, which structure and internally control our thoughts, residing deep in the culture. The taboo on talking toilets is strong, and will be pursued further in the chapter on cultural constraints on toilet provision.
Dualisms • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 28
abled/disabled access/fortress accessible/defensible black/white body/spirit brown/blue café/toilet children/adults clean/dirty clean/decent complain/campaign curative/preventative daytime/evening decent/indecent East/West flush/recycle form/function free/pay gay/straight
• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •
gendered/generic green/gendered help/hindrance hot/cold hygienic/ecological Islamic/Christian insides/outsides (uchi/soto in Japan) Ladies/Gentlemen but Unisex macro/micro male/female man/nature mandatory/permissive manufacturers/suppliers may/must metal/ceramic middle class/working class modest/blatant night/day
paper/water planning/building posh/common preventative/curative primary/secondary privatised/collectivised providers/users public health/clinical practice public/private pure/impure pure/dirty red/green religious/secular shiny/matt
• • • • • • • • • • • • •
sit/squat sit/hover stand up/sit down toilets stand/sit suppliers/managers town planning system/building regulations underground/overground urinals/closets urination/defecation/menstruation virgin/whore water/electricity women/children women/men
Issues to be aware of ➥
Need to engage in toilet debate at many levels, macro, meso, micro
➥
Toilets should be seen as part of wider urban policy debate
➥
Links to social inclusion, urban regeneration, urban design
➥
Many social dimensions, gender, age, race, ability, religion
➥
Huge cultural taboos and constraints on design and provision
➥
Problem of organised irresponsibility and fragmentation of policy
➥
Tendency to blame the individual not the system
➥
Role of decision-makers as against users, and links to urban governance
➥
Always going to be conflicting, even opposite views, on just about every toilet design issue
CHAPTER TWO • CONCEPTUALISING THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
• • • • • • • • • • • • • •
29
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
The historical development of public toilets Studying the passed This chapter constitutes a brief history of ‘public conveniences’ up to the start of the twentieth century to show how the present day toilet problem results from deeply held taboos and mores embedded in our civilisation that affected assumptions and decisions made about location, design, likely users and propriety in the past. Historic toilets are important architectural artefacts and townscape components and often the subject of urban conservation policy (Bath, 1993, 1997; Greed, 1996a). The story will then be taken forward into the twentieth century in the next chapter, which discusses the legal context of public toilet provision, which has so constrained subsequent development. Public toilets are part of the heritage industry. This study is mainly centred upon urban development, because this is where greater need has arisen owing to the pressure of numbers of people. Local studies such as a history of Cotswold privies by Harris (1998) provide a parallel account of conditions in rural areas, where the problem of waste disposal was less fraught. One could simply build a privy over the local stream, or spread the nightsoil on the fields as fertilizer (Binding, 1999). Many a quaint, pretty privy is to be found in rural areas, such as the one owned by the National Trust at Killerton House, Broadclyst, Exeter, which has pink walls and a thatched roof. But some quaint toilets are not as old as they appear to be. For example, in Poole Park, Dorset, a refurbished 1930s public loo has been provided with a dovecote in the pitched roof, and looks truly medieval (AMC Newsletter, Winter 1995). Also of interest is the Theatre of Small Convenience, a council-owned building in the Malverns, which seats about 10 people and is nowadays used as a theatre by the owner who runs one-actor plays. Quaint historical examples, although fascinating, are the exception rather than the rule, and part of the whole ‘eccentric Britain’ heritage that is of such interest to tourists (Le Vay, 2000). But we should always be thankful for public
CHAPTER THREE • THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF PUBLIC TOILETS
chapter three . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
31
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
Figure 3.1 Public toilets at Killerton House, Devon. This thatched toilet, maintained by the National Trust, is not typical of public toilet reality but provides a light relief. Rural toilets are a major component of toilet provision for the tourist industry. (Photograph courtesy of Isobel Daniels).
toilets of all sorts, great and small. Such romanticised rural toilets should not be seen as a true reflection of the hell hole many a cottage-dweller used at the bottom of the garden, albeit environmentally sustainable (Pudney, 1954). Let us now trace the history through the ages.
The ancient world There have always been public toilets. Public latrines, as against private dwellingbased closets, were the normal, and only, form of provision for most, except the rich, until the nineteenth century (Cavanagh and Ware, 1991: 9–17). In India this is still the case in many villages (Pathak, 1994), as discussed later. Ancient cities such as Pompeii and Herculaneum contained public latrine blocks, the seats consisting of a continuous slab of stone with, on average, eight holes for users. A shared sponge was passed around as ‘toilet paper’. Such arrangements were generally used only by males. One of the earliest existing latrines in Britain is at Housesteads Fort on Hadrian’s Wall, which provided communal provision for 20 soldiers (Hart-Davis, 1995, 2001). Roman cities and villas were famed for their advanced sewerage, drainage and heating systems. There was a gap of many centuries from 410AD when the Romans left Britain (they arrived in 56BC) before sewerage and plumbing came back into their own again 32
in the nineteenth century. Devotees of Cloacina, Roman goddess of the sewer (and sewerage), would be puzzled by the demand for ‘privacy’ and individual facilities, and by negative modern attitudes towards ‘the sable streams which below the city glide’ (commented on in Trivia Part II, Gay, 1975, originally 1716). Ceremonies in Spain honouring ‘Our Lady of the Sewers’ christianise such ancient deities (Richardson, 2001). ’Studying the passed’ – that is, ancient excrement – is a growing specialism in archaeology, as its contents give information on human settlement, diet and life style. Dr. Miles Russell, lecturer in archaeology at Bournemouth University, organised a session on the ‘Origin of faeces’ at the Theoretical Archaeological Group Conference held at Oxford University in December 2000 (Times Higher, 12.01.01: 19).
CHAPTER THREE • THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF PUBLIC TOILETS
Figure 3.2 Ancient Greek drainage piping, Ephesus, Turkey. Most ancient Classical cities had sewerage and drainage. It was many centuries before Western Europe was to reach such standards again.
The Middle Ages In medieval times, public communal latrines were common and 13 have been identified in London, mainly sited over rivers. There was an 84-seater in Greenwich Street called Whittington’s Longhouse after Dick Whittington, Mayor of London, who apparently frequented this establishment in 1480. Communal bath-houses were developed, often with unsavoury reputations. Queen Mathilda, wife of Henry I, ordered a latrine to be erected for the use of the 33
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
citizens in Queenhithe, a quay near London Bridge. In 1355 the River Fleet in central London choked up altogether from effluent from latrines overhanging this tributary of the Thames. It was customary to empty chamber pots out of upstairs windows by throwing their contents into the street, ideally, calling out ‘gardez l’eau!’ which made this anti-social action legal (hence the word loo from l’eau). Many medieval houses were designed with overhanging upper floors to protect passers by from this unsavoury downfall. As the public toilets were located over rivers and many town centres were focused around the main bridges, the toilets were centrally placed and accessible. Presumably shared toilet facilities engendered a sense of community among users that would be the envy of modern town planners trying to regenerate the inner city. Anyone, including women, still has the right under medieval statutes to squat in the gutter within the boundary of the Ancient City of London, provided they first call out ‘en paine’. It is rumoured that women did this at the time of the great suffragette marches at the beginning of the twentieth century (which attracted half a million marchers) (Tickner, 1987) and others did so at the time of the Coronation of Queen Elizabeth II in 1953. It is still legal for a taxi-driver to relieve himself on the inner wheel of his hackney carriage (taxi-cab). Likewise the law still requires all cab-drivers to carry a bale of hay (for the horse); this law has not been enforced or put to the test for many a year but, in theory, still applies (although Westminster City Council has been seeking to bring in strict anti-street urination laws in 2002). Nowadays large processions in London can result in complaints of urination in front gardens, shop doorways and alleyways, because of lack of public toilet provision. At the time of the midnight Millennium celebrations, most of the public toilets were closed in central London. Some underground toilets had been closed because of the need to extract soil for the excavation of the Jubilee Line, and have not been reopened since. In creating the inclusive, regenerated 24hour city, it is most important that such facilities should be copiously provided as an integral component in urban regeneration.
The nineteenth century Urbanisation and public health At the beginning of the nineteenth century, Britain was undergoing major economic and social change (Ashworth, 1968). Industrialisation was accompanied by the expansion of towns and cities, and population growth, all of which put greater pressure for better sewerage and drainage systems. Disease, overcrowding, lack of clean water, and insanitary conditions and smells led to demands for greater state intervention and town planning controls (Cherry, 1988; Greed, 2000a). Methods of human excrement disposal, which might have worked for a 34
small village of a few hundred people, such as dropping it in the river, or piling it up outside the house, could create major public health problems when repeated by hundreds of thousands of people in close cramped urban streets. The rapid rate of urban growth and the parallel urban concentration of populations are shown in Tables 3.I, 3.2 and 3.3. Victorian prudery and obsession with hygiene had not yet kicked into people’s consciousness. Most people continued to dispose of their sewage by piling it up outside in the garden in a midden or waiting for the nightsoil man to collect it. Cesspools were commonplace within London. In rural areas everything
CHAPTER THREE • THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF PUBLIC TOILETS
Figure 3.3 Underground toilets do not provide equality of access, especially for those with pushchairs or wheelchairs. These toilets are located at the Monument, in the City of London, where there is a very heavy footfall of commuters and office workers, many of whom nowadays are women.
Table 3.I: Population growth 1801–1901 UK Date
Total Population
1801
8.9 million
1851
17.9 million
1901
32.5 million
(See Ashworth, 1968: 7, for fuller details)
35
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
had been spread on the fields and used as manure. Then with urbanisation, before sewers, many ‘better’ houses had earth closets, some with trap doors to collect it all underneath. This waste was called ‘nightsoil’ and ‘nightmen’ came around every night and collected it. Human excrement was a valuable commodity for agriculture and industry. Even as late as post-World War 2 times, nightsoil men were active in some areas, particularly in colonial cities. For example, the television presenter, Clive James, recounts how nightsoil used to be collected in the suburbs in the outskirts of Melbourne, Australia, before mains sewerage was installed. It was also the main means of collection in Japan before World War 2 (1939–45) (JTA, 1996). An interesting account of nightsoil removers in County Durham is given by Kilroy (a descendant of the ‘Kilroy was here’ chap who did exist) (Kilroy, 1984: 43). He recounts carts going along the alleyways between the backs of the houses at night collecting the soil from the hatch under each outhouse at the bottom of each backyard. Many people in working-class communities considered it dirty to have a toilet in the house. Such approaches were to prove unsanitary and impractical with the growth of urbanisation. Laporte (1968) gives a French version of excretion history. The following table shows the tremendous rate of urban growth which was occurring in the new industrial towns and cities, which were doubling and tripling in size.
Figure 3.4 Typical nightsoil hatch at the end of the backyard in terrace houses. Nightsoil collection, rather than the flush toilet, was a common feature of nineteenth century industrial cities. (Diagram courtesy of Paul Revelle and Chris Wade.) 36
Date
Birmingham
Manchester
Leeds
1801
71,000
75,000
53,000
1851
265,000
336,000
172,000
1901
765,000
645,000
429,000
(See Ashworth, 1968, for fuller details of many towns)
While there was an overall growth, there were also, as stated, large movements of population from one part of the country to another, on a regional basis, and a migration to the towns from the countryside. This may be summed up in the following table (from Greed, 2000a).
Table 3.3: Comparisons for UK 1801 – 80% of the population was rural. 2001 – 80% of the population is urban.
Not only were there changes in the quantity of people in towns and cities, but inevitably there was a decline in the quality of their lives owing to disease and overcrowding (Ravetz, 1986). Conditions and standards were not that different from the situation in rural areas of the time but, as stated, although people could get away with fairly elementary methods of sewage disposal in small villages, the sheer concentration of numbers in the new cities increased the likelihood of disease developing in the crowded alleyways and tenements. Presumably people were culturally tolerant of such practices and smells and thought nothing of it at the time, prior to the development of the modern public health movement.
CHAPTER THREE • THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF PUBLIC TOILETS
Table 3.2: Urban growth 1801–1901
The sewerific roots of modern town planning Sanitation problems could not be solved by personal individual efforts but required civic initiatives and national solutions, as well as ‘town planning’, which might coordinate both land use patterns and provide a framework for massive public infrastructural investment in new sewerage and drainage systems. The spread of cholera and other fatal diseases made intervention necessary, there being a major outbreak in 1832 (and another in 1849). To implement reform there was a need for an effective, administrative structure. The 1835 Municipal Corporations Act laid the foundations for this, enabling the creation of locally elected urban councils, i.e. local authorities, which had the powers to levy rates from householders and 37
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS 38
businesses, and to use the money to employ professional and administrative staff, in order to carry out these improvements and building programmes. State intervention and provision became more acceptable because of the need to establish a city-wide drainage programme to stamp out diseases such as cholera. In 1840 a Select Committee, headed by Chadwick, on the ‘Conditions in Towns’ was established, leading to the ‘Report on the Sanitary Conditions of the Labouring Population’, and on ‘the Means of its Improvement’ (Chadwick, 1842). In 1843 this was followed by the establishment of a Royal Commission on the Health of Towns (Hall, 1989). In 1844 the Health of Towns Association was founded, and drainage and sewerage reforms were seen as an integral component of town planning for disease control. Much early town planning was defensive legislation against disease, and the early rudimentary sewerage and drainage measures were comparable to the ‘sites and services’ approach adopted in third world shanty-town emergency situations nowadays. Early planning reformers saw ‘the urban problem’ in terms of germs and disease, often combining this with a classist, even eugenic, desire to clean up the lifestyle and breeding habits of the working classes (Greed, 1994b:90–1). In the early twentieth century, more severe forms of this thinking were advocated by Poetz, a racial hygiene engineer in Nazi Germany (Green, 1990). The words unhygienic and immoral seemed to be used interchangeably when describing the lower orders, especially ‘fallen’ women. Concepts of public health and social hygiene were closely linked (Jones, G, 1986; Wright, 1960) as were immorality and assumed unsanitary conditions. Significantly, laws against public (male) urination both in Britain and North America were generally the result of not wishing to offend public decency, rather than concerns with hygiene or the convenience of women (Kira, 1976, Ostler, 1996). The roots of modern town planning are firmly in the sewers. Curiosities such as Dr. Richardson’s model town plan, ‘Hygeia’, took the concept of efficient, germless living to the limits as described by Bell and Bell (1972: 284), but appear entirely logical when seen against the wider public health context of the time and its often condemnatory equating of immorality of the lower orders with lack of hygiene. The problems occurred chiefly in areas where there was a concentration of large numbers of working-class people in poorly built housing around the new factories and mills. They located there because, at the beginning of the Industrial Revolution, there was very little money or time for commuting and the transport systems had not yet developed, so people were huddled together in proximity to their workplace (Ashworth, 1968). Many local builders cashed in on building substandard tenements and terraces. The 1847 Sanitary Act required sewers and drains to be provided in all new residential areas. The 1848 Public Health Act was the first to give local authorities general powers for the provision of public toilets. This Act also intervened into domestic hygiene arrangements for the first time, with emphasis on healthy design in the construction of houses. It put an end to
Under the city streets The Victorians put a vast amount of investment ‘under the city streets’ in the forms of sewers and drains, within the context of public health reforms. Likewise the city fathers, having made their pile out of the Industrial Revolution, could sit back and distribute their bounty in the form of public works (Bell and Bell, 1972). Civic pride and public building works went hand in hand with reform as manifested in ‘gas and water socialism’ – that is, investment in public works to build up the necessary infrastructure. No expense was spared: public toilets were built of the finest stone, with expensive fixtures and fittings, and designed by famous architects, reflecting the technological and cultural achievements of the era. Flushing toilets were a symbol of scientific and technological progress in the nineteenth century, like computers nowadays (Edwards and McKie, 1995). In 1858, there was a particularly hot summer, known as ‘The year of the big stink’; Parliament closed because of the whiff from the adjacent Thames, and it was decided to do something drastic about the situation (Halliday, 2001). In 1865 the Crossness Engines, beyond Woolwich on the southern bank of the Thames, were opened to discharge London’s waste out to the sea (see http://crossness.org.uk and http://www.tanton.ndirect.co.uk/crossness/). These were built by Joseph Bazalgette, the sanitary engineer, who was responsible for much of the re-sewering of London (Halliday, 2001; Clayton, 2000: 51). As Peter Bazalgette, great-great-grandson of the engineer, has commented, the Victorians’ pride in these four steam engines overcame their prudery and they were named after Victoria, Albert and two of the royal children. The Royal Family, with a range of dignitaries, bravely dined in the new building as part of the opening celebrations. The engines are housed in a magnificent Romanesque building, a cathedral to sewage, which is now a Grade 1 listed building. Bazalgette was responsible for establishing the modern sewerage system in London at a time
CHAPTER THREE • THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF PUBLIC TOILETS
back-to-back houses by requiring a back alleyway for ventilation and nightsoil collection purposes, thus sanitation reform helped shape urban design. Subsequently, the 1868 Artisans’ and Labourers’ Dwellings Improvements Act (the Torrens Act) increased government controls further, but the need for citywide rather than just individual dwelling orientated reforms was seen to be primary in stemming disease. Another Artisans’ and Labourers’ Dwellings Improvement Act in 1875 further increased local authority powers to deal with whole areas, as against individual buildings (Ashworth, 1968). Cholera was a waterborne disease, which was no respecter of persons; although it might originate in working-class districts, it could spread anywhere along the unsanitary water systems of the city. As Peter Hall points out (1989: 27), in 1854 a Dr. Snow showed the relationship between a major cholera outbreak and a single polluted pump in the Soho district of London. Increased state intervention and investment in public works was needed to provide better sewerage and drainage systems to prevent the spread of disease (Cherry, 1988).
39
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS 40
when most people depended upon nightsoil collection. On the Continent many other major capital cities invested in sewers, e.g. Paris’s magnificent spider’s web pattern of squares and boulevards designed by Haussmann was mirrored underground by a splendid new system of sewers and drains (Sutcliffe, 1970). A Royal Sanitary Commission was established between 1869 and 1871 which resulted in a series of further acts and improvements. The Metropolitan Water Act 1872 established the principle that the London sewerage system should be water-based, resulting in further major sewer construction and changes in toilet design.
Flushing it away In 1596 Sir John Harrington had invented the first modern lavatory using water (the self-emptying slop pan); in 1775 Alexander Cummings, a watchmaker, patented the U-Bend and the S-bend. In the nineteenth century, Sir Thomas Crapper perfected and widely marketed modern WCs with siphonic cisterns with evocative names like the Deluge (Reyburn, 1989). Such devices are included in a museum exhibit of historic public toilets entitled ‘Flushed with Pride: the Story of the Toilet’ at the Gladstone Pottery Museum, Stoke on Trent, as this is the heartland of traditional ceramic sanitary ware (toilets) manufacture (Blair, 2001). This was established with a Lottery Grant of 1.3 million pounds (15.1.2001), plus European money and manufacturer sponsorship. This grant caused anger locally, as at the same time vital local public conveniences were being closed in the area because of lack of money. Many a museum has suffered from inadequate public toilets, especially for women (Candlin, 2001). In contrast, successful ‘heritage’ sites incorporate good toilets as a high priority in wooing visitors. The 1996 Loo of the Year Award went to Portsmouth Historic Dockyard public toilets. The National Trust, too, has made a valuable contribution to setting standards for visitor toilets (National Trust, 2000) (see Appendix). The 1872 Act was a turning point for Crapper, increasing the demand for his government-approved flushing system as water-based sewerage systems were adopted as government standard. But at the same time the shift from cesspools to flush toilets led to the sewers and water courses being swamped with human effluent, resulting in the need to build yet more sewers to cope with the increase. Subsequently huge programmes of sewerage and drainage system construction ensued in London in the wake of ongoing legislation (Clayton, 2000, Chapter 3). The 1875 Public Health Act is a landmark in the development of state intervention into the built environment. This important Act set minimum and more stringent standards on the design of houses and also on the layout of streets, so it is in a sense one of the first true town planning acts. This was achieved by giving local authorities themselves the power to introduce by-laws controlling the layout of new streets and housing schemes. It contained many provisions related to sewers, drains, toilets and water supply. The 1875 Act was to cast its shadow
CHAPTER THREE • THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF PUBLIC TOILETS
Figure 3.5 Bazalgette’s 1865 Cross Engines, near Woolwich, London (used by permission of the Crossness Society). Victorian civic pride and creative genius expressed itself in sewerage systems and pumping stations.
Figure 3.6 Sewage repair van: conserving the heritage beneath the city streets. Nowadays there is a constant battle to repair and renew the infrastructure inherited from the Victorians; sewerage systems need constant maintenance.
41
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
right over the twentieth century in introducing baseline standards and principles in all sanitation matters, some of which are quite discriminatory towards women by today’s standards, as elements of this Act have never been superseded or repealed to this day. Once the commitment had been made to water-borne systems, there was no turning back. Vast sewerage systems, pumping stations, and sewage works were being built throughout the land. Many cities are still dependent on Victorian sewers, and the Victorians left an immeasurable heritage of public investment which has not been continued into the present day, in spite of increased state intervention and national wealth. In the nineteenth century, public health, housing, sanitation, municipal engineering, surveying, and town planning were all nascent professions which still overlapped and interlinked (Greed, 1991: 50–1). ‘Sanitation and drainage’, ‘gas and water socialism’ and related ‘public health’ issues were key components of the agenda of nineteenth-century town planning (Wohl, 1983; Dyos, 1968: 334).
The emergence of modern public toilets Within this context it was inevitable that public toilets should also contain waterbased flushing systems, and that they should be conceived as an integral component of the great sewerage and drainage revolution of the nineteenth century. This gave the public toilet movement greater strength than it has today as provision was part of the wider sewering process, whereas today public conveniences seem to be dealt with in isolation from mainstream municipal policy. The Victorian enthusiasm for building large public buildings such as museums, libraries and art galleries, plus their fondness for exhibitions and fairs, all led to greater demands for better public toilets. The first public toilets were at the Great Exhibition in 1851 at Crystal Palace, London, and were provided by the toilet manufacturer and inventor, George Jennings. He was also the inventor of the fiendish ‘penny in the slot’ lock for Ladies toilets, hence the phrase ‘got to spend a penny’. Apparently, public provision was not initially provided for women, only men, and a meeting of the RSA (Royal Society of Arts), the organising body, was hurriedly convened to provide more (AMC, 1997 Newsletter, January). Likewise, in the 1898 Great Exhibition in Paris (of which the then new Eiffel Tower was a centrepiece) there were major queues for the public toilets. After the success of the Great Exhibition, the RSA sought to establish a system of public lavatories in London for health reasons. In 1851 it set up a committee of ‘noblemen and gentlemen’ to establish this. Such toilets were supplied with a superintendent and two attendants each, and comprised two classes of toilets, for gentlemen and the masses, and with a separate charge for washing and brushing. The RSA requested that the police visit these establishments from time to time. Mr. Minton (the China manufacturer) donated some of the sanitary hardware for the venture. Under this scheme, in February 1852, the first flushing 42
CHAPTER THREE • THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF PUBLIC TOILETS
public toilet for ‘ladies’ opened at 51, Bedford Square. It was strongly ‘classed’ with poorer ‘women’ being offered a cheaper option of standing or squatting over a ‘hole in the ground’ behind a curtain known as a ‘urinette’, whereas ‘ladies’ might sit upon mahogany lavatory seats in imperial splendour. The ‘sit or squat’ debate continues in the world of public toilet provision and will be returned to in later chapters, as will the infamous history of the ‘urinette’ and the possibility of women ‘standing’ over a hole rather than sitting or squatting. Sitting on the same seat that someone else has just sat on is seen as dirty by many, unless there is a servant attendant who will rush in after the user and clean the seat. A public lavatory just for men followed at 95, Fleet Street, with an entrance fee of tuppence. (Significantly men had to pay too, presumably to keep the lower classes out.) These facilities were politely called ‘public waiting rooms’ a phrase still used occasionally in North America for public toilets. The River Fleet had exploded (alongside Fleet Street) in 1846, and this had clearly been a busy location since medieval times when it also exploded in 1355 because of the build up of noxious fumes. It was found that these private ventures could not pay their way, although they served as valuable advertising sites for new products. To this day manufacturer support and sponsorship is still an important component in the fight for public toilets. As to location, and divisions between public and private provision, it should be noted that men already had a vast array of ‘private’ facilities in clubs and pubs according to their social class. There were several other private schemes built in the second part of the nineteenth century. For example, a public toilet established in 1900 in Leicester Square provided 27 urinals and 13 cubicles for men, but only three urinettes and 7 cubicles for women. Likewise one in St. Martin’s Lane, London, provided 5 compartments for women, and 25 urinals and 12 compartments for men (Robinson, 2001: 5). In parallel, a range of street works and improvements were being made throughout the early nineteenth century, in respect of lighting, paving, and ‘watching’ (emergent ‘police’ patrols). Civic improvements included provision of public parks, public benches, signage, refuse collection, bandstands, horse troughs inter alia (albeit the latter was chiefly the result of early animal rights campaign activities). In 1807, Pall Mall was the first street in the world to be gas lit and others rapidly followed, creating more hospitable city streets. Clearly the rightful ‘place’ for public toilets was to be under the auspices of local government too. It was left to the City Engineer, William Haywood, to establish a system of underground conveniences (BTA, 2001: 6), thus funding the modern system of ‘public facilities’. The 1891 Public Health (London) Act gave local authorities the power to use the subsoil of any road for the purpose of building public lavatories, and most of the underground ones date from 1884 to 1925. The 1891 Act stipulated that the area of the ‘subsoil’ beneath the public highway should be used for such toilet facilities and for sewer routing. This has created great inconvenience for generations of women, especially for the disabled and those with pushchairs (Cavanagh and Ware, 1991).
43
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS 44
Nevertheless, the Victorians should be commended as builders of palatial public lavatories and proponents of improved sanitation standards and toilet technology (Lambton, 1978). Because, in Victorian times, public health had the status of a prestige science, sanitary engineering too was highly regarded, and this is reflected in the resources and detail which is lavished upon the building and design of public toilets. They constituted a new and worthy component within the built environment. History repeated itself in the 1960s when some new public toilets were built underground as part of motorway and pedestrian underpass programmes, such as at Centre Point in London, but these along with many others were subsequently closed ostensibly because of tramps and homeless people settling in the access areas. Incredibly, underground lavatories in the 1960s were built by Westminster City Council in order to build underpasses, as they had a statutory authority to build underground loos but not pedestrian underpasses, as supported by the precedent of the case Westminster Corporation v London and North Western Railway Company 1905 Act 38 (Appeal Case, House of Lords). But in provincial cities, such as Bristol and Bath, for example, many public toilets were built on the surface, and they were designed in a classical style to complement the surrounding Victorian or Edwardian architecture, with no expense spared. Nowadays some public conveniences are listed buildings, for example in Park Row, Bristol, an edifice which still retains its original porcelain sanitary ware. Mid-twentieth century toilets tended to be more utilitarian in design (Smedley, 1978). The Park Row toilets, although right beside the University and on the tourist circuit, were left to fall into a state of disrepair. Subsequently, in the late 1990s, they were renovated as part of conservation area improvement, and they are now designated Grade 1 listed buildings. They were closed in early 2001 to be used for an art exhibition of items from the Arnolfini, which were displayed in the Gents. At present (2001) the Ladies is frequently closed while the Gents remains open. In historic Bath, so strong is the urban conservation movement that, when the 1930s Larkhall public conveniences were refurbished, their appearance was changed from that of a twentieth-century municipal ‘concrete block’, functional edifice to a Georgian ‘conservation area’-style pavilion. The fountain set into the exterior and proudly declaring construction in 1907 was in fact moved back into the wall from an adjacent free-standing location (Stringer, 1994: 27–9). In this case money was found for cosmetic ‘lavatorial gentrification’ of the toilet block when usually ‘lack of money’ prevents even the most basic maintenance. Since there were inadequate public toilets for women, other alternatives grew up. Lyons Corner House restaurants, and ‘tea rooms’ in general, were popular with women because they provided toilets, in the days when women would not go into a pub or traditional restaurant on their own. Lyons served the purpose that McDonalds does nowadays in this respect. The first permanent public toilets for women, and men, were built in 1893 opposite the Royal Courts of Justice in the Strand, London.
CHAPTER THREE • THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF PUBLIC TOILETS Figure 3.7 The Park Row toilets, Bristol, built in 1904 by Walters and Sons for £1,079, with an additional charge of £514 for the Twyfords sanitary fittings. Top: corner washbasin in the Ladies. Middle: external view. Bottom: mahogany wood toilet seat.
45
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
Figure 3.8 Larkhall Toilets, Larkhall Conservation Area, Bath. When the Larkhall toilets were refurbished, the conservators incorporated in the front wall a previously free-standing fountain. They ‘aged’ the building from being a wholly modern block to a Georgian-style one to fit into the surrounding conservation area.
Changing land use and transport patterns Demand for public toilets is a component of wider town planning, transportation policy and overall urban design agendas. The Industrial Revolution was accompanied and facilitated by a parallel transport revolution, for both goods and people. Following Watt’s invention of the steam engine (significantly a water-based power system), the first main passenger railway constructed was the Stockton to Darlington which opened in 1825. Growth continued, until at the peak in the 1870s there were nearly 16,000 miles of railway (there is less than half that amount today). Increasingly people lived further from their work and distinct residential, industrial and business districts developed within cities, generating a greater need to travel, and the likelihood that people would be away from their homes, and toilets, for many hours at a time. Birth rates were high, as were infant mortality levels, in the new industrial towns. Housing for workers typically consisted of two up and two down terraced houses for many families of six or more with a toilet out the back if they were lucky (Ravetz, 1986). Presumably there was a greater tolerance towards children simply ‘going’ in the gutter in those days when both private and public toilet provision was limited. Early state schools were likely to have poor toilet provision too, with toilets ‘outside’ on the other side of the playground, a common arrangement in the ‘Triple Decker’ Board schools built in London towards the end of the century. A 1998 survey found that there were still over 600 primary schools 46
CHAPTER THREE • THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF PUBLIC TOILETS
in England without inside toilets, still waiting to be improved a hundred years later, and the smell of school toilets (and often the bullying experienced in them) was a significant aspect of the modern school child’s growing up experience (Greed et al, 2001). Increasing numbers of women worked in factories and went ‘out’ to work like the men. The emphasis in early town planning upon zoning, separating out and decentralising land uses resulted in the creation of the ‘journey to work’ and made it more difficult for women to combine home and work duties in spatial proximity. The need for public conveniences for women was greater than before as more women were travelling about in the city, commuting to work over long distances. But paradoxically, as moral standards and ‘manners’ became more prudish, women, in particular, were inconvenienced. Robinson (2001) comments that it was considered an abomination and an assault to decency for women to be provided with public toilets. Early ‘feminist’ groups such as the Ladies’ Sanitary Association established in the 1850s campaigned for better toilets. In 1884 the Ladies Lavatory Company opened its own private public conveniences at Oxford Circus for ladies who had to spend the whole day in London (Adburgham, 1989:231). The campaign for public lavatories for women was a key component of the Suffragette Movement, almost with equal importance to attaining the vote. Julia Edwards, from her research on the evolution of public toilets, concluded that campaigners for toilets have always tended to be women because of this blatant inequality. But at least in Victorian times, despite the prudery on such matters, there was a climate of willingness to build public toilets as there was a celebration of sanitation as the new technology. Public toilets were seen as a sign of modernity and technological advancement like computers nowadays. Thus it may be argued that women benefited as ‘citizens’, albeit to a lesser degree, with men, from public works inspired by civic pride and gas and water socialism (Edwards and McKie, 1995). Therefore the women’s agenda coincided with men’s and they made progress, although nowadays this is not necessarily the case (Saunders, 1995). Women had difficulty being ‘heard’ in governmental circles as few women were involved in decision-making bodies. In the nineteenth century, patriarchal, male sanitary engineers predominated. The situation would be much worse today for women were it not for the ceaseless efforts of ‘sewers and drains feminists’ (Greed, 1987: 279) such as members of the Ladies’ Sanitary Association, who campaigned for public lavatory provision and sought to change the discourse from one of ‘plumbing’ and ‘disease’, to that of ‘amenity’ and ‘health’ (Cavanagh and Ware, 1991: 14). Cheap mass travel, especially on the new railways, generated further demand for better facilities for all. Many early railway stations provided wrought iron urinals at platform level for men, but women received less. Some railway companies quite intentionally refused to provide them for women (Richards and Mackenzie, 1986: 139, and Chapter 13). There used to be an 800 ft-long gents
47
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
toilet at Waterloo Station equipped apparently with a plenitude of urinals (this is now the rush hour passageway to the Northern Line). There was more limited ladies toilet provision at Waterloo with different toilets and waiting rooms for first class ‘ladies’, and second and third class ‘women’. Clearly the railway station builders imagined the commuters they were serving to be predominantly male, and women were not made welcome – an attitude which arguably persists today. In contrast, the WC&P (Weston, Clevedon and Portishead Railway) south of Bristol, up until it was closed by the Beeching cuts in 1965, provided Ladies and Gents wooden toilets on its small rural platforms (Vincent, 1983). In other countries there was a much wider array of station facilities including a crèche at one of the Moscow stations, and kennels for hunting dogs in some Scandinavian stations (Richards and Mackenzie, 1986: 285).
Domestic toilet culture It is not the purpose of this book to get side-tracked into the intricacies of plumbing, nor to get caught up in domestic housing toilet issues. But before proceeding to the next chapter and the modern day, some cultural issues need to be discussed briefly as what people have in their homes, and think is ‘normal’, affects what they expect to be provided with in public toilets. It is significant that nowadays the flush lavatory, with a sit-down toilet bowl, is seen as the ‘normal’ type of domestic toilet. But such arrangements were a long time coming. Water-based flush lavatories and other ‘mod cons’ are extremely recent in terms of historical perspective. Alternative means of disposal, and quite different moral attitudes and manners, resulted in quite different approaches to ‘going to the toilet’. A more ‘natural’ easy-going approach prevailed for centuries, and the coming of urbanisation, industrialisation, ‘progress’ and more restrictive attitudes towards bodily functions created problems that had not existed previously. Answering nature’s call was not such a problem for centuries until it became culturally unacceptable to ‘go’ anywhere except in the public toilet, and then matters were made even worse by such facilities being closed down with no alternative being provided. Prior to the coming of Victorian concepts of hygiene and prudery, it was common for gentlewomen with large hooped skirts simply to stand or squat over the gutter when they wished to urinate (a personal Portaloo!). Apparently no-one saw this as unladylike. So wide skirts were no extravagance but another case of form (and fashion) following bodily function. With long skirts being the norm, the wearing of knickers was not a social priority in the past. Even Victorian ladies were likely to wear pantaloons with a split crotch arrangement, as can be seen from studying exhibitions of underwear of yesteryear at the Victoria and Albert Museum in London. While water-based flushing systems were very popular and the established way ahead adopted in Britain, there were always other alternatives based on dry, non-water systems, usually using sand, soil/earth and/or ash. For example, Henry
48
CHAPTER THREE • THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF PUBLIC TOILETS
Moule of Dorchester patented an earth closet in 1859 which absorbed and neutralised human waste after three days. Incidentally, although his toilet was rejected, he has a street named after him on a housing estate in Dorchester (Hart Davis, 2001). Nevertheless, earth closets using dry systems do crop up again and again in the history of toilets, sometimes in the most unlikely places – for example, Australian outback picnic sites. Some Russian high-rise flats still run on the dry earth toilet system with earth chutes provided to serve all floors. Modern plastic backings to sanpro products imported from the West in post-Communist Moscow are non-biodegradable and make this system increasingly unhygienic. Further accounts of the horrors of wet and dry systems are to be found in the toilet classic, The Specialist (Sale, 1930). After 200 years of assumed progress based on water-based systems, as discussed later, environmentalists are now re-evaluating the worth of traditional dry systems. In the Victorian home, the provision of inside toilets (and bathrooms) in domestic dwellings was increasingly seen as essential (among the middle classes, if not the working or upper classes), and an absolute necessity in the New World of the United States of America (Kira, 1976, Ostler, 1996; de Bonneville, 1997). In Victorian England, toilets inside the dwelling would protect the modesty of ‘ladies’ and save individuals the trek ‘out the back’ in the rain and the dark. There were always some who considered the idea of having toilets inside the house as most unhygienic, and there was much opposition to the early public health acts in working-class areas. Owners of large country houses liked to have ‘the gentleman’s garden’ for guests to relieve themselves. In France, Versailles had no internal plumbing to speak of as was the case in many a château too. Many a smart French lady would carry a bourdelieu (a lady’s travelling pot). Such items are nowadays valuable antiques. Traditional methods of disposal that had worked well for gentry and peasantry in the countryside did not work in the context of large urban populations in the new industrial cities. As many a foundational town planning book, or book on the evils of nineteenth-century social conditions, recounts, it was not uncommon in working-class tenements for 200 people to share one privy, so increasingly housing legislation required individual ‘closet’ provision for the labouring classes too. But privies were not an absolute necessity; one did not have to join a queue with 200 of one’s neighbours every morning as the use of chamber pots among the working classes, and commodes among the more affluent, was commonplace. Lord Lever, philanthropic town planner and designer of Port Sunlight garden city near Liverpool, was also an advocate of improved commode design, and collected commodes and chamber pots (see Wood, 1994). Lever (1851–1925) had bought 52 acres on Merseyside, built his Sunlight soap factory there in 1888, and then started his model village in 1889, which was not completed until 1934. The scheme follows garden city principles but he appeared ambivalent about the value of internal toilets or, for that matter, separate kitchens replete with a sink. It was common to have a separate kitchen, scullery and wash-house, often with
49
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
the water supply outside, a far cry from the modern fitted kitchen when ‘fire and water’ (ovens and sinks) (and, for that matter, water and electricity) are integrated alongside each other. He is an influential figure in the field of urban design, endowing the first Chair of Town Planning at Liverpool University (Cherry, 1988; Ashworth, 1968). Incidentally, in 1997 Lord Irving, the Lord Chancellor of the new Labour government, had his official apartments refurbished and spent £3000 on an Arts and Crafts medieval-style toilet with carved oak panelling which bears a resemblance to fin-de-siècle commode design. The nineteenth century was a period of a vast amount of house building, and this included the construction of middle-class villas, town houses and substantial terraces which still occupy large tracts of our cities. But internal toilet provision was not necessarily equally provided for women as well as men. A Bristol Women’s Architects Newsletter September 1994 shows a ‘gentlemen’s room in the ideal suburban Edwardian villa downstairs with a water closet, small dressingtable and cloak-stand’, but no such facility for the women as designed by the architects, W&G Audsley, in 1894. Some such housing was built with upstairs bathrooms and inside toilets, and provided a ready market for sanitary ware and plumbing fixtures and fittings. Also, there were large areas of better quality, skilled artisan and respectable workingclass housing consisting of miles of little terraced houses built on a grid layout, albeit much of it built with outside toilets but with potential for future installation of ‘all mod cons’ (inside toilets and water supply, plus gas and electricity) (Ravetz and Turkington, 1995). It is significant, therefore, that the public toilet pressure group set up in the 1980s to campaign against the decline of provision should be named ‘All Mod Cons’ (AMC), until it was renamed the British Toilet Association (BTA), mainly because AMC was an incomprehensible term to foreign toileteers. In the next chapter, the story of public toilet provision is taken up to the present day with particular reference to the legal context which so constrains progress.
Principles ➥ Respecting the past ➥ Conserving toilets as part of wider townscape and fabric of the city ➥ Seeing public toilets as architectural features in their own right ➥ Using existing patterns of toilet provision as template for refurbishment ➥ Seeing public toilets as a valid component in urban design and streetscape ➥ Avoiding steps down, replacing facilities at grade in situ where possible ➥ Not removing them altogether but adapting old toilets to new standards 50
The development of toilet provision within its legal context Twentieth-century provision Overground and everywhere This chapter continues the story of the development of public toilet provision, identifying en route the cultural, gender, design and locational factors that have contributed to present day problems. In the early twentieth century, public toilets continued to be built in London by the London County Council (LCC, 1928) and by many of the provincial municipal local authorities. There appeared to be no question that they needed to be provided. To complement the underground toilets of the late nineteenth century, the ‘overground’ toilet was introduced. These were often built at bus and train termini, in parks, near market places and off shopping streets, and were plentiful in large provincial towns and cities. Many of these very useful, yet ugly, little buildings are being closed. In the past one would find several within a mile of each other within the town centre. But fixed distribution standards as to their location were rare, the decision being based on common sense according to demand. New toilets in the 1940s and 1950s in Bristol were located in relation to heavily used bus routes and football venues before the growth of motorcar ownership.
For all the family?
CHAPTER FOUR • THE DEVELOPMENT OF TOILET PROVISION WITHIN ITS LEGAL CONTEXT
chapter four . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Some pre-war public toilets included purpose-built children’s toilets, with drinking fountains outside, perhaps to encourage family use, especially in parks. Baby-changing facilities were unheard of, but there might be a bowl of water for the dog outside some public loos. Many had lavatory attendants ensconced in some dark cubby hole within the bowels of the building. While there were facilities for women, many more Gents-only toilets were built, such as on traffic islands along busy thoroughfares, or in highly industrialised areas such as the South Wales Valleys to meet the needs of the breadwinner on his journey to work. 51
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
Overall toilet block locations tied in with male travel needs rather than women’s convenience. Likewise, in those days, definitions of social class were entirely based on the male head of the household and women’s work was invisible in public policy-making (Greed, 1991). The 1936 Public Health Act, Section 87, sub-section 3, gave local authorities the right to build and run on-street ‘public conveniences’ and to charge such fees as they thought fit ‘other than for urinals’ (see Appendix for all toilet legislation). (The 1848 Public Health Act was the first act to deal with the topic.) This meant that women could be charged and men not, and condoned a lower level of provision for women which was viewed as an additional expense. Payment was made either by penny in the slot or by controlled turnstile entry at the entrance to the Ladies. Turnstiles blocked the entrance of pushchairs, prams, and small children without the money, height or the strength to work the turnstile. Mrs Tobe Aleksander and Joan Robins headed the Chain Reaction Campaign which was started in the 1950s to abolish turnstiles. After a heated campaign the turnstiles were eventually outlawed under the 1963 Public Lavatories (Turnstiles) Act. The rules outlawing turnstiles never did apply to ‘private’ conveniences, only ‘public’ ones, and they never applied to railway stations – hence the installation of turnstiles at most central London railway termini stations, much to the inconvenience of travellers. Large people in New York have campaigned against new narrower turnstiles at the entrances to the NY Tube (subway). Turnstiles are everywhere nowadays, in private premises operated by swipe cards to protect from theft, at a range of railway stations, in public libraries and universities, in sports arenas and even the Glastonbury festival which is equally renowned for its appalling temporary toilets. Interestingly, the 1936 Act renders illegal the fact that men too, nowadays, are being charged to use pub-
Figure 4.1 Horfield Common Men’s urinal, Bristol. In 1900 there were 90 urinals in Bristol, but few for women. At least these Victorian urinals have a screen around them compared with current examples which are right out on the pavement. 52
lic, or at least quasi-public, facilities in some public places, including having to pay for ‘Superloos’.
Municipal functionalism In the post-war reconstruction period, public toilets became more functional and economical in appearance and in the use of modern materials such as concrete and steel which persisted through to the early 1970s. They were usually built in an unassuming, municipal, ‘modern’ style using concrete walls with glass brick blocks for windows, and were replete with white or green tiles inside. A trend towards ‘modern abstract’ architecture was used as an excuse to provide no-frills cheap buildings. Thankfully these were not built underground, but they were often badly positioned, hidden behind trees, down steps, in underpasses, or up unsavoury side streets. Propriety and modesty demanded that they be hidden, and apparently the risks of this increasing the chances of mugging, cottaging and rape were not dominant issues at the time. Many rapidly descended into a bad state of repair, not least because of the use of concrete, the enthusiasm for rendering buildings in white or eau de nil, and the use of high maintenance painted wood exterior surfaces. Poor materials combined with poor maintenance and limited attendance and surveillance were a recipe for disaster. From the late 1970s, a new era of government cutbacks and closure gathered pace under the New Right Thatcher government which appeared to be governed by the principle, ‘there’s no such thing as a free lunch’ and certainly there
CHAPTER FOUR • THE DEVELOPMENT OF TOILET PROVISION WITHIN ITS LEGAL CONTEXT
Figure 4.2 This Ladies toilet in Horfield has been closed owing to ‘criminal activity’ but the urinal next door remains open. Often when the Gents is closed because of cottaging the Ladies is closed too through no fault of their own.
53
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
was to be no such thing as a free pee either (Friedman, 1991). This mentality has continued to the present day. Few new toilets were built and many were closed in an attempt to save money (for, as the saying goes, ‘they knew the price of everything and the value of nothing’). Toilets have rarely featured in any of New Labour’s many urban regeneration programmes, and toilet provision remains a blind spot for many politicians although arguably they should be key components in developing a local area. Present day public toilets are the subject of later chapters. In summary there are two contrasting trends in modern toilet provision. First there is the fortresslike, vandal-proof, unsupervised on-street public toilet, epitomised by the APC, constructed in vandal-proof metal. Second, much more accessible off-street, privately-provided ‘public’ toilets are to be found in shopping malls, some of the best being at Blue Water Park (shopping mall), near Dartford on the outskirts of London, and at the Milton Keynes central shopping mall. Many incorporate every design principle advocated by those concerned with the needs of women, children, elderly and disabled people. But both these types (the fortress and the modern mall toilet) are relatively rare, because they are new-build. Between these two extremes there is a huge gulf, and a general day-to-day urban lacuna of under-provision of any sort of decent public toilet in many areas, although these are the ones the general public rely upon the most.
Counting toilets The zenith of enthusiasm and commitment to public toilet provision occurred in late Victorian and early Edwardian times and they were not considered an unnecessary extravagance at that time. Since then it has all been downhill, as charted by the following surveys. A 1928 survey of toilet provision in the Inner London boroughs (LCC, 1928) found that there were 233 toilet blocks for men and 184 for women, in which there were 1260 cubicles for men plus 2610 urinals but only 876 cubicles for women. Men also had the benefit of toilets in clubs and pubs. Many a pub toilet had its entrance straight off the street, ‘public’ (albeit maleonly) use being officially agreed between the local authority and the brewery (Robinson, 2001). The next survey of London’s public toilets was undertaken in 1961 by Graham Don, senior lecturer in public health at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine (Don, 1961). At that time he found that 281 (53%) of public toilets were pre-1918; 178 (34%) were inter-war and only 71 were built since 1940. 60% of the full total were beneath ground level. Incredibly there has been no subsequent London survey, although it was expected that the Greater London Council (GLC) would have conducted one had it not been abolished in 1985/6. The present Greater London Authority (GLA) is certainly aware of the issue, but public toilet provision is not a statutory matter for their concern in developing a Spatial Planning Strategy for the conurbation. 54
Audit Commission The first modern governmental survey of public toilets was undertaken by the Audit Commission, commencing in the mid-1990s, under the requirements of the 1992 Local Government Act to meet the needs initially of the Citizen’s Charter. The Citizen’s Charter is meant to make the government more accountable – to the citizen – in terms of the levels of provision of key public goods and services. Thus an account must be given of the number of public conveniences provided by a local authority, but not the ratio of male to female (see ‘Staying the Course’, Section J: The Local Environment, paras 3 a and b, Audit Commission, 1994, and see Carroll, 1996). This survey has been repeated annually but under confusingly varying criteria. The exercise has been criticised for simply counting what is there (as if that by itself will create more toilets) without setting any benchmarks as to expected levels of service. It can only identify the best among a bad bunch of alternatives, rather than producing a definitive standard to which local authorities must aspire. The results are puzzling. The Audit Commission declares that the best figures are for Westminster where few people actually live. Likewise it implies that Brighton is relatively well-endowed, when in reality there has been public outcry at the closure of public toilets along Brighton Seafront which are vital to the millions who flock there for day trips and holidays. Paradoxically Brighton won an
CHAPTER FOUR • THE DEVELOPMENT OF TOILET PROVISION WITHIN ITS LEGAL CONTEXT
There has been no national survey of public toilet provision for many years. In the 1990s Women’s Design Service (WDS) provided an overview of women’s toilets (Cavanagh and Ware, 1991), while Eric Midwinter’s study (1994) gave a snapshot of available public toilets at London railway and Underground stations. A national survey was attempted by Welsh MP Jon Owen Jones, who has always been keen to support groups campaigning for toilet improvements (see Chapter 14), by writing to all local planning authorities. His study concluded that both the present-day proportion and amount of public toilet provision for women had declined progressively from the peak reached over a hundred years ago (Jones, 1994). According to Jones’ survey, 42% of local authorities had only 1 public convenience per 5–10,000 people, and the situation has since deteriorated down to 30% according to BTA investigations (Jones, 1994; BTA, 2000a,b). Individual local authorities kept their own records of provision, while a range of interested organisations made their own surveys, such as the Institute of Wastes Management (IWM). Various sanitary engineering companies, disability groups and tourist organisations have kept a watchful eye over the situation. So there is evidence of continuing decline. Over the 10 years prior to 1994, 771 conveniences had been closed in 180 local authority areas (Bartlett, 1994: 1–4) and the rate has picked up even further over the last 10 years, so that there are now large ‘toilet deserts’ where local authorities have closed all their local public toilets (cf Shaw, 2001). The situation has worsened since – over 50% of all public toilets have closed since 1995.
55
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
award from the Civic Trust for improvements to the Seafront in 2001. The Audit Commission has been criticised for its lack of consideration of the relative levels of male/female provision, and clearly gender is not mainstreamed into the exercise. To help matters along, the BTA through its membership, its own surveys and its extensive contacts within local government has sought to produce an augmented overview of the national situation by local authority area (BTA, 2001). Although there is no gender breakdown in the above figures, according to observations men still have approximately two-thirds more provision than women (BTA, 1999/2000). So all the figures above should be divided accordingly. There is a disparity of provision, ranging from one facility per 35 men and 86 women in the best local authority area, to one facility per 6427 men and 11,248 women in the worst. Within each toilet block women are likely to have half as much provision as men and over two-thirds of public toilet blocks are likely to offer less than four toilet cubicles for women. There are in England (only) around 7000 public local authority run toilets, of which around 3500 have disabled access to one or more of their toilets. But there are around 5000 individual RADAR accessible toilets with access including offstreet facilities presumably. Only around 1000 public toilets have baby-changing facilities. In addition, according to the BTA, there are around 1000 public toilets in Wales, 1500 in Scotland and 500 for Ireland (with similar levels of disabled and baby care provision) which gives us around 10,000 local authority public toilets for the whole of the UK. Although no definitive figures exist, it is estimated by BTA that, if all privately provided public toilets are added to this, the total is nearer 14,000 in all. For example, there are around 2500 in railway stations, but very few nowadays in bus stations, 21 airports all with toilets, 60 seaports with public toilet facilities, around 200 national park and leisure facility toilets, and around 200 motorway and service station area toilets, plus shopping malls, theatres, cinemas, sports facilities etc. Significantly, there are now locations
Table 4.1: National public toilet provision SITUATION 1999
Total toilets
Disabled access
London Boroughs
700
350
125
Metropolitan Areas
650
300
75
Counties
5000
2750
900
Scotland
1300
400
130
Wales
1000
350
100
10,000
3500
1330
TOTAL
(Based on BTA’s findings as informed by the Audit Commission)
56
Baby changing
Legal requirements Divide and rule In Britain the provision of public conveniences can take two forms: on-street provision by the local authority, or private off-street provision by the developer or owner of a shopping centre or other private building to which the public has access (such as a department store, shopping mall, or bus station) (Barritt, 1996). The phenomenon of on-street public toilets may be seen as a particularly British solution to the problem, although such provision is found in many other developed countries too, but it is not necessarily the primary, or only, form of provision. In North America public toilet provision has been increasingly moving ‘off-street’ and ‘inside’, being provided as a component of shopping mall development, whereas in some European countries provision is provided within cafés. While some people from overseas, including tourists, expect to find public toilets in England, others may not; but they are still likely to assume that other alternatives will be available, for example in cafés, and will be disappointed and confused when they are not. British Standard BS6465 (Parts I and 2), and the Linked Approved Document G of the Building Regulations have provided the national guideline standards for toilet provision since 1985 and for on-street and off-street public toilets since 1984 (BSI, 1996; DoE, 1992a,b,e, updated 1996 [see www.bsi.org.uk and www.bsi-global.com]). These regulations, until the 1996 revision, made it a legal requirement for men to be provided with approximately a third more provision per set of toilets than women, because men are given about the same number of cubicles as in the ‘Ladies’ plus urinal provision. The 1996 revision has only marginally improved the situation for women1. No wonder there are always queues for the Ladies!
CHAPTER FOUR • THE DEVELOPMENT OF TOILET PROVISION WITHIN ITS LEGAL CONTEXT
where disabled toilets are provided but none for the rest of the general public, while in the past one was more likely to find only a Gents toilet and none for the Ladies. One of the problems of doing toilet research is that there is no complete set of data which incorporates all categories of public toilet, but a mish-mash of partial surveys by a range of bodies, and this is clearly an area where more research is needed. In comparison, there are many thousands of public toilets in Japan and Sweden which seem to have them on every street corner, whereas there are no public toilets at all in some South American countries. Looking at other essential components of the local street environment, for comparative purposes, there were 78,000 BT pay phones before privatisation, and as at March 2001 there were 28 million road vehicles, 18,000 post offices, 112,000 red post boxes, 20,000 black taxi cabs in London, 60,000 pubs in Britain, and 4225 caravan parks in the UK (with, in 1999, half a million caravans) (see current Social Trends, ONS, 2002).
57
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS 58
Retail development In off-street locations such as shopping malls, some facilities are miles better but some older locations remain inadequate. I was informed by one developer that he did not like providing public conveniences for women beside food courts as they generated queues, but he did not seem able to grasp the obvious remedy to this problem – more, not less, provision. Even in enclosed shopping centre development, even when 80% of shoppers are women, it is quite ‘normal’ still to provide ‘equal’ provision for men when fewer men are likely to be around to use them. Private developers have had no legal obligation to provide for shoppers, only shop workers, under the current legislation, and local authority provision need only be ‘sufficient’ (as they think fit), a word which is frequently used but poorly defined in much of the legislation covering the provision of both public and private conveniences (cf S.43 of the 1936 Public Health Act, S.28 of the 1984 Building Act and successive legislation). Private developers and retailers have not been required to provide for shoppers, only shop workers, until very recently (Cunningham and Norton, 1993: 1; BSI, 1985, revised 1996). In March 1995, following considerable pressure by groups such as AMC, minimal standards were introduced for customer toilets, based on one male toilet, one male urinal, one unisex toilet for disabled people, and two female toilets for every 1000–2000 square metres of retail floor space (and so forth in proportion to total net sales area)2. At last one began to see customer toilets incorporated in new large store developments and refurbishment schemes – for example, some large branches of Marks and Spencer now have toilets, a glaring omission for many years, although they had them in their European stores. Branches of British Home Stores and Littlewoods generally have toilets because they have customer restaurants and thus fall under other arcane legislation. Although these new standards have improved the situation nationally, they are actually lower than those achieved by some progressive local authorities. Many London boroughs and the GLC (under its Public Entertainment Licence Requirements) previously had much higher and more equitable standards, and prior to the establishment of these new national standards were free to impose them. It requires quite a large retail store to achieve the minimum floor space. A traditional ‘high street’ shop of 660 square feet is only 60 square metres. From a reasonably sized supermarket or, say, a bigger Marks and Spencers of 3000–8000 square feet, we can now expect several toilets. A typical old 1960s shopping precinct of say 300,000 square feet or the huge Metro Centre in Gateshead of 1.55 million square feet (c. 144,000 square metres) should yield many toilets. In these days of intense retail competition it is in the interests of shopping centres and malls to provide good toilets to attract more customers regardless of what the minimum standards might be.
CHAPTER FOUR • THE DEVELOPMENT OF TOILET PROVISION WITHIN ITS LEGAL CONTEXT
Some department stores, such as Debenhams, have always provided facilities (Lane-Jones, 2001) while newer chain stores seeking to attract family shoppers, such as Mothercare, IKEA and Children’s World, have found provision increases sales. IKEA, the Scandinavian furniture store, is renowned for above average facilities including a shoppers’ crèche and toilet provision, being one of the few stores located in mainly out-of-town locations to provide such facilities. Attitudes change. Ten years ago, a major supermarket chain objected to the wording of toilet requirements given by one London borough planning department that ‘in major developments which attract large numbers of visitors, such as shopping centres and leisure facilities, the council will expect developers to provide an adequate amount of accessible, good quality sanitary accommodation’ (Planning Week, 5.5.94: 7). Ten years later the big supermarkets like to give the impression they invented the idea of customer toilets because they care for their patrons. The problem is now going full cycle, as some such toilets that were opened with great publicity are now being closed and not replaced in certain ‘big name’ supermarkets. Currently improved standards are being formulated for retail by the BS6465 Part I revision committee drawing on existing best practice. Standards required by clients, and set by leading architects and design teams, for prestige commercial office, leisure, entertainment and retail development nowadays are often much higher than the minimum set by BS6465 both in terms of overall provision and ratio of women’s toilets (LDSA, 1999; BCSC, 2003; Chapman Taylor, 2003).
Figure 4.3 1960s utilitarian toilet block, Broadmead shopping centre, Bristol. These were included in the post-war redevelopment of the shopping centre, as it was rightly not assumed that off-street store toilets were available. There seemed to be an assumption in the 1950s and 1960s that there should obviously be toilets provided, unlike today when keeping toilets open is a battle. 59
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS 60
Leisure facilities Discrepancies in provision are evident in relation to leisure and recreation related provision. BS6465 (Part I) recommended that toilets in public houses should be provided upon a 75:25 ratio in favour of men, but gave no standards for sports stadia. Sporting authorities suggest calculating that provision at football stadia and sporting facilities should be on a 90:10 basis, in spite of the fact that many such venues are used by mixed audiences for pop festivals, religious gatherings and public events (Inglis, 1993). John and Sheard (2000: 149) suggest 80:20 as the club standard and apparently see no problem with this. The Sports Council’s consultative document ‘Toilet Provision in Stadia Planning, Design and Types of Installation’ suggests 85:15. Inglis (1993) advised it is better that clubs should research their own ratio as appropriate to local demand rather than apply outdated rules. The lack of awareness of the need for the provision of public toilets to be linked to sport planning, especially in view of the numbers of visitors, tourists and spectators generated, is epitomised by the fact that Manchester closed over two-thirds of its public toilets during the very same period that it was making itself out to be the ideal European city to hold the Olympic Games. Presumably cutback in toilet provision was one of the many prices to pay for the diversion of vast amounts of public money spent on promoting and reconstructing the city’s sports facilities for the Olympics3. Bookmakers (betting offices) are the only non-food retail outlets where it is required throughout England and Wales that customers’ toilets are provided, but as a male planning colleague helpfully commented, ‘well they would do it on the street otherwise wouldn’t they?’. Incredibly both male and female toilets are meant to be provided but few women have tested the implementation of this regulation for themselves. So if a shop sells food and drink which is consumed on the premises, or if the premises is a betting office, both male and female toilets must be provided currently under S.20 of the 1976 Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act. The licensing laws governing places of entertainment, dancing and where alcohol is consumed affect toilet accessibility. When the lack of public conveniences for women and children is raised, someone is bound to say ‘well they could always go into a pub’ (public house or bar). Under the 1933 Children and Young Persons Act it was made illegal for children under 14 to be in a bar, this restriction being incorporated into S.168 of the 1964 Licensing Act (Glover, 1994). This effectively limited the mobility of women with small children, barring them (literally) from the public house, and from the ‘service station role’ of the inn. In late 1994, ‘children’s certificates’ were introduced to allow children into some bars in a few selected locations. In early 1995 a new system of ‘children’s certificates’ was introduced by the Government, enabling a limited number of pubs to allow under-age children into bars with their parents. Apparently the reason for this was to create a ‘family atmosphere’ to deter violence rather than pri-
CHAPTER FOUR • THE DEVELOPMENT OF TOILET PROVISION WITHIN ITS LEGAL CONTEXT
marily to reflect the needs of women and children. Divisive legislation has ensured that children, and thus effectively women and families, have been kept out of many pubs, and prevented from benefiting from the original purpose of inns to provide rest and refreshment for travellers. These days few parents would dream of leaving children outside unattended, and so either a parent (usually the mother) has to ‘wait outside’ with them or they simply stay at home (Roberts, 1995; The Guardian, 1995). With increased car ownership and tourism, many rural pubs now provide gardens, play areas and other family facilities, and some premises are providing disabled provision too. The only good point about the licensing laws vis-à-vis toilets is that unlike the Building Regulations they can require retrospective improvement to existing premises. There are over 60,000 pubs in the UK and each one is effectively a gents’ lavatory. While many such premises provide minimal provision, some take a pride in the quality of provision and may use their toilets as an added attraction. For example, in 1997 a pub installed goldfish in its toilet cisterns in Barn Hunting in Stratford on Avon which, following concerns by fish lovers, was approved by RSPCA officials, and now the trend has caught on with many other pubs too. The situation is little better for those who want culture. Glyndebourne Opera House provides inadequate toilets for women. The current liberalisation of the UK licensing laws to allow 24-hour opening is exacerbating the situation in 2003 (Greed, 2002a; CCI, 2002). In contrast, the Covent Garden Opera House. renowned for its queues for the Ladies (Gaffin, 1994), has now been refurbished with a higher level of provision. The Liverpool Philharmonic Hall was refurbished in 1995 with twice the number of toilets for women, another success. There are also many sporting and cultural events held outdoors during the summer and all these, in theory, should be governed by Health and Safety Regulations which require minimal toilet provision, but ‘portaloos’ are often low on the agenda, let alone disabled accessible ones. Higher standards of provision for all, and more realistic gender ratios, for theatre toilets are nevertheless being applied by some more enlightened designers and providers (BTTTPC, 2003) and by local authorities that can still exert powers under the licensing regulations (LDSA, 1999). Recommendations based on a 60:40 female/male ratio, for example, are proposed by these bodies.
Workplace public toilets Similar unequal principles govern workers’ toilets as embedded in the 1936 and 1961 Public Health Acts, the various Building Acts, and the 1963 Offices, Shops and Railway Premises Act (the latter being replaced, but not necessarily improved upon, by the provisions of the European-derived Work Place Directive). The problem remains that developers tend to build to minimum standards as set out in the regulations to save space and both capital and running costs. For example, some Computer Aided Design (CAD) computer programs for architects 61
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
a
b
Figure 4.4 Comparison of (a) female and (b) male toilets at Glyndebourne Opera.
and designers have incorporated an off-the-peg ‘toilet cubicle and block module’ which is far too small and arguably virtually below current standards, as there are always grounds for negotiation and re-interpretation of the original standards to mean something else altogether. Given the under-provision for women in the first place, it is unhelpful that the cleaner’s cupboard and other space-consuming storage areas are often located in the women’s toilet area, using up limited space. Perhaps it is assumed women won’t complain and most cleaners seeking access to these areas are likely to be women. Another field of controversy surrounding work toilets is ‘time to pee’ – that is, rest breaks and toilet breaks. This is a sore point in North America and increasingly a problem at call centres in Britain and the rest of Europe, when even two minutes away from the computer screen can hold up the system, although women taken on average 98 seconds to use the toilet. Apparently some women 62
workers on North American assembly lines wear incontinence pads because of lack of opportunity to relieve themselves, and one call centre manager in Britain was anonymously reported for telling his women workers to wear nappies (Linder and Nygaard, 1998). Thus people need both the time and the place to urinate in the course of the day. Women in traditionally male-dominated employment areas such as building sites suffer even more from generally disgusting toilet conditions and no hot water (Construction Manager Journal, Nov. 2000: 22–4). A woman reported she faced a 40-minute round trip to the nearest Ladies toilet when working on a building site (New Civil Engineer, 19.11.98: 18). In my previous research on women in construction, I came across many a story of inadequate toilets and of male managers, bosses and foremen who kept the key to the women’s toilet and expected women workers to beg for it. Many campaigns have taken place to make provision better on the basis ‘2 and 1’ – that is, to provide one Ladies to every two Gents on building sites, where no provision has previously existed for women construction workers. Another major workplace for children and young people is their school. Many school toilets are badly maintained, unhygienic and the site of bullying.
CHAPTER FOUR • THE DEVELOPMENT OF TOILET PROVISION WITHIN ITS LEGAL CONTEXT
Figure 4.5 Law Courts, The Strand, London, with convenient toilets in the foreground. Law governs every aspect of toilet provision, even inequality. The toilets in the foreground have been used by generations of people visiting the courts. It is only relatively recently that law courts have been provided with adequate toilets for the public.
63
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
School standards are unequal for girls and boys, and this seems to be a feature common to many countries as explored in a cross-national study by Huang and Wang (2001) which particularly compares North America with China and other Far East countries. Even in the glamorous world of Californian high schools the situation is likely to be unequal:
Table 4.2: Example: US High school designed for 900 students Based on Section 2902, UBC code, California, based on female ratio of 1 toilet per 45 students, and based on 1 toilet per 100 male students plus one urinal per 30 students. Sex
m
f
Required toilets
9
20
Required urinals
30
–
Total places to pee
39
20
Current UK government guidance (DfEE, 2001) on creating inclusive school design and accommodating pupils with special educational needs and disabilities within mainstream schools has given attention to toilets for all, while the BSI standards set out guidance for schools, with under-provision for female students and staff. In our previous Nuffield research on inclusive school design, we found that girls often imagined there to be more girls’ toilets than boys’ ones and appeared unaware of the inequality (Greed et al, 2001). Changes to access are required under the 2001 Special Educational Needs and Disability Act 2001. Curiously, schools (and strangely post offices) were not ‘bound’ by the Building Regulations until changes were made in 2001 (Schools and Further Education [Amendment, England] regulations 2001 and Postal Services Act [Modifications] No.1. Order 2001). The Education (School Premises) Regulations 1999 sets out basic (and vague) current standards for UK school toilets. Hospital toilets are also problematic, particularly in shared wards where privacy is violated. But some workplaces are awash with toilet provision for their employees. For example, there are 600 loos in the Bank of England building! If one counts all the toilets in the buildings all around one in areas where there are no public toilets, it is a staggering under-used resource. The general public have got wise to this and may seek to use an office block loo. In my travels I have found that some office toilets now have security combination number locks on them, very inconvenient if you are in a hurry. I recently happened to visit a magazine distribution company where there was a Ladies and Gents visibly right beside the Reception area but the Ladies (only) was locked. In contrast, some countries encourage the use of office toilets. For example, in Singapore (2001) 64
Railways and travel Railway operators appear to be oblivious to the good design guides on accessibility produced by women planners, architects and disability groups. Mainline railway stations in London, such as Paddington, Euston and King’s Cross, now have turnstiles at the entrances to female (and some male) toilets, all of which are located downstairs. (Railway stations were exempt from the 1963 Act.) Yet, London Bridge Station, which serves as a busy interface between the Tube and commuter trains, is remarkable in having free toilets at ground level on nearly every platform. At British mainline stations with turnstile toilets, a charge of 20p is made. This is high compared with the usual ‘penny’, but it is low compared with some other countries. Frankfurt Station used to charge 1DM (33p), but this has since risen to around 50p with the coming of the Euro. Finland has the most expensive public toilets in railway stations in the world at around £1 a go. Yet one gets conflicting views from different bodies. In 1997 there was talk of Railtrack refurbishing 2500 stations by 2001, but little improvement is to be found and the trend towards toiletless stations continues. Just a few stations stand out as good – for example, London Bridge Station. In 2002 the Labour government promised more investment in railway toilets, but this commitment has to be set against the virtual collapse of the entire system of which toilets are but one problem. Turnstiles and payment systems create barriers. They restrict the way in which people use land, and their access to vital transportation systems, and force people to use cars, or not travel at all, because of the impossibility, for many, of using public transport. Fire evacuation risk is increased with turnstile installation. Any locking system on lavatories is potentially dangerous for those who get locked inside, as history has proved: In 1958 a lady got locked in a penny-in-theslot toilet and was injured climbing on the toilet roll holder to get out (Sayers v Harlow, 1958). Indeed toilets are dangerous places – for example, in 1997 a 33year-old disabled man was electrocuted at Belmear in the Isle of Wight by a 240volt wire hanging down from the ceiling in a stainless steel toilet, but, as he survived, the council was only fined £18,000. Perusing the local press will result in numerous stories of people getting stuck in the loo as toilets are generally inadequately designed and in particular too small. As other buildings or facilities become privatised, and thus move out of the control of legislation covering public buildings to that covering private premises,
CHAPTER FOUR • THE DEVELOPMENT OF TOILET PROVISION WITHIN ITS LEGAL CONTEXT
the three ‘Ls’ of Lobby, Lift, and Lavatories were accepted as essential in designing business premises, especially where air-conditioned underground walkways connect shopping centres and give access to the entrance lifts for business offices. There is no such tradition within British cities, and people are more used to expecting on-street than off-street toilets.
65
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
additional controls will be difficult. Toilet turnstiles are being introduced into a range of privatised public facilities, including shopping malls and, significantly, bus stations. In the privatised bus station in Bristol where there are now turnstiles, the toilets have been moved downstairs and there are now private security guards patrolling the bus station, while at Bath bus station the toilets have been closed altogether. At Bristol there is a baby-changing area at ground level, but it is alongside the disabled toilet and can only be accessed through a door with a RADAR key lock. At the time of finalising this book, the toilets at Bristol bus station had been closed altogether because of a fire started by vandals, and the inconvenience caused was widely discussed on local radio and television but with no early solution except for a row of temporary Portaloos (which were disgustingly unusable).
Further Building Regulation developments By 2000 another phase of revision of the Building Regulations had begun, starting with revisions of the Building Act 1984 – Review of Part H (Drainage and Solid Waste) of the Building Regulations 1991 and associated legislation. In the wake of the Disability Discrimination Act (DDA) 1995, a range of other Building Regulation changes have occurred, in spite of resistance by bulk house builders. Extensions and amendments to Part M (disability aspect) require level entrance and downstairs toilets in new houses (CAE, 1992; Adler, 2000). Under DDA Part III, from December 1996 it has been illegal to treat disabled people less favourably, and from October 1999 service providers have been required to make reasonable adjustments for disabled people. By October 2004, under a Code of Practice for Part III of the Act, all buildings will have to be accessible to people with disabilities, including churches, those housing ‘service providers’ and shops. This includes provision of public toilets for disabled people and in the process churches, for example, are providing toilets for all. In anticipation in June 2001, the first addition to Ely Cathedral in 450 years was dedicated in summer 2001, namely a new cloister with new toilets and facilities for disabled people (from Ely Standard, 28.6.01, at BTA conference of that date). There have been other small amendments. The Building Regulations from July 2000 require all toilets over 8 square metres to be fitted with escape lighting, except parts of school buildings with natural light, used during normal school hours, while the DfEE (2001) has produced guidance on inclusive school design. Meanwhile major changes were introduced under the new BS 8300: 2001, ‘Design of buildings and their approaches to meet the needs of disabled people: Code of Practice’ introduced in September 2001, in which Section 12.4.3 deals with disabled toilets. These will be introduced in due course by 2004 to tie in with other changes in disability legislation. Part M of the Building Regulations, ‘Access to and use of buildings’, is also being revised in this respect. 66
Examples of better practice can be found north of the Border. Under the 1982 Local Government and Planning (Scotland) Act, Section 26, sub sections 1 and 2, local authorities ‘may make such reasonable charges as they may determine for the use of such conveniences’, and section 2 states conveniences means ‘waterclosets, or urinals and washing facilities for use in connection therewith’, which gives a form of equality in that everyone has to pay. Note the Act only says ‘may’ provide, equip and maintain fixed or moveable public conveniences in such places as appear to them (the local authority) to be suitable. Like the English solution, it is only discretionary but apparently the official expectation is higher that local authorities will still provide public toilets in Scotland. According to Hamish McHenderson, senior lecturer in Scots law, University of Edinburgh, this section follows the recommendations of the Stodart Report, para 197, and the working party on (improving) civic government, para XVII.1 (Stodart, 1981). The 1981 Stodart Report of the Committee of Inquiry into Local Government in Scotland made recommendations upon modernising and tidying up Scottish local government legislation and powers, updating many Victorian acts and archaic functions in relation to markets, fairgrounds and street cleansing. Its recommendations were the basis for this 1982 Act which replaces the antiquated provisions in the Burgh Police (Scotland) Act of 1892 and the Public Health (Scotland) Act of 1897, as well as local legislation, with a simple grant of discretionary power to islands and district authorities (that is all local authorities in Scotland) to provide, equip, and maintain public conveniences and charge for their use. In Scotland, the standard set by BS 6465 on toilet provision in different categories of buildings has been upped by 20–30% in some cases, according to the new Scottish standards accessible at www.scotland.gov.uk/development/bc. In Scotland toilet requirements are established by categorising buildings according to different types of ‘purposes and groups’ (Schedule 3), with the proviso that a survey must be undertaken of likely users before finalising provision, and with disabled provision guidance being integrated into the guidance document (Scotland, 2003). It has also been recommended by the Scottish government that designers should advise building control officers imposing standards control of the likely numbers and composition of people actually using a building at any one time – surely a much more progressive approach. This Scottish act is similar to English local government legislation in that the requirements are not mandatory but implementation depends upon discretionary powers. Likewise, there is no law that says local authorities must provide decorative flowerbeds, fountains, public art installations, or even public parks and open space! Many of them do so and the cost factor is not approached in such a restrictive manner as is the case with public lavatories. In Scotland, the fact that such discretionary powers are linked to the policy-making powers of planning authorities possibly gives
CHAPTER FOUR • THE DEVELOPMENT OF TOILET PROVISION WITHIN ITS LEGAL CONTEXT
Comparative legislation
67
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS 68
greater chances of good toilet policy being implemented as part and parcel of mainstream urban policy. If anything, the Scots seem to be more concerned about the erosion of powers over their sewers than pubic toilets. In 1996, the transfer of certain sewerage controls from local planning authorities to new sewerage authorities (Planning Week, 9.1.96:7) which now have permitted rights (without applying for planning permission) for underground installations and other infrastructural developments ‘means’ that the planners have less control over such lavatorial matters. Similar problems exist in Wales, which has been covered by generic legislation for ‘England and Wales’ except in the case of specifically ‘Welsh’ boundary and function changes, such as the 1994 Local Government (Wales) Act. But since the creation of the Welsh Assembly, albeit without revenue levying powers, there is an opportunity for change. The Celtic countries may provide interesting possibilities. For example the Northern Ireland Good Friday agreement includes an Equal Opportunities and Town Planning section in among other more mainstream legislation, which gives the impression that gender considerations must be taken into account in determining policy. Apparently in seeking to establish religious equality between Protestant and Catholic groups, gender, disability and ethnicity also crept into the drafting of the legislation, potentially to the advantage of all (NI, 1998; Reeves, 2000). Unequal provision between women and men is widespread. But some other countries have sought to remedy the situation. In 1976 a New York court ruled that it was illegal to charge women and not men as women could not use the urinals (Bernstein, 1994), but this ruling did not have much effect for it was not until the ‘Potty parity’ law of 1989 in New York, introduced by Governor Mario Cuomo, that equal numbers of toilets for women and men were required by law. This followed a long campaign in which Denise Wells was arrested for using the Gents to draw attention to the problem (and as a result of her experiences went on to become a lawyer (Woo, 1994:7). But equal provision often proves inadequate, and therefore the Massachusetts State Plumbers Board, for example, decided in 1994 that a 2-to-1 toilet ratio for women to men in heavily used facilities should be introduced (Ms. Magazine, July/August 1994:95). Nowadays many American cities are closing both their male and female public toilets because of drugs, crime and cottaging problems, so such successes do not necessarily result in more, better toilets. In Australia the Minister for Planning, Robert Maclennan, in 1994 amended the toilet provision regulations under Class 9, ‘Buildings—management of sanitary facilities’, to require that women’s toilets should be provided at the rate of 1.7 women’s toilets to one of men’s, thus updating the 1993 Building Act, Section 188. This followed a concerted campaign and the publication of research findings from RMIT on the lack of ladies’ toilets in theatres in Melbourne (Wallace, 1997). Likewise in Japan 2:1 provision is now common. The Japan Toilet Association is pressing for 3:1 provision whilst in Britain we remain at a 1:2 ratio
Conclusion We have inherited weak toilet legislation, inadequate toilet standards and generally poor toilet building provision from the past. The chances of achieving adequate toilet provision depend greatly upon underlying legal powers. There is a strong discretionary element given to local government to decide which particular policies and facilities to support and prioritise. Clearly any change in legislation will require the replacement of the word ‘may’ with ‘must’ and must be backed with adequate funding. The continuing story of the battle for equal and better toilet provision will be recounted in subsequent chapters and the legal aspects will be pursued further within the context of creating and implementing change.
Notes 1. 2.
3.
The author is a member of the BS6465 Part I revision committee, currently updating the standards. CONVERSION: Re floorspace provision: 1 square foot = 0.09 square metres, and 10.764 square feet = 1 square metre; i.e. divide or multiply by ten approximately. In contrast, in Suwon, Seoul, Korea, 60:40 male/female ratio of football stadia toilets is provided, with FIFA approval. Currently the Football Foundation in the UK is revising stadia facilities standards, especially for disabled spectators, with additional provision for baby changing to attract more families (Football Foundation, 2003).
CHAPTER FOUR • THE DEVELOPMENT OF TOILET PROVISION WITHIN ITS LEGAL CONTEXT
in favour of the Gents (Kobayashi, 1995). Under the New Zealand Building Code (NZBC, 2003) since 1995 it has been stipulated that ‘no more than 10% of the people wanting to use a sanitary fixture should wait more than 60 seconds’.
69
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS 70
Principles ➥
Need for fundamental change in the law to make toilets provision mandatory
➥
Need to change centuries of gender discrimination in levels of provision
➥
Need to provide adequate controls, money and regulation to make this happen
➥
Need for more progressive approach than always designing to minimum standards
➥
Need to revise existing standards including BSI and Building Regulations
➥
Need to use opportunity of European Union standards harmonisation for positive change
ON THE PROBLEM
chapter five . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Cultural attitudes: separating or mixing
Cultural constraints This chapter continues the conceptual background to the problem of toilets by looking at the cultural factors that inform policy-making and investigating fundamental attitudes. The chances of adequate public toilet provision are hindered by the subcultural values and attitudes held by professional and governmental decision-makers. Public toilets are seen either as a joke or as ‘dirty’, and as centres of crime, sex, perversion and vandalism (Laporte, 1968; PCS, 2002). Women’s toilets are likely to be seen as either unimportant, embarrassing or the source of smutty jokes. Such a mentality reflects deep cultural taboos about the place of woman in the city of man. A range of historical, philosophical, geographical and sociological perspectives needs to be drawn upon which helps to explain such attitudes. To get the subject taken seriously it is essential to take the joke out of toilets.
CHAPTER FIVE • CULTURAL ATTITUDES: SEPARATING OR MIXING
SECTION TWO: DIFFERING PERSPECTIVES
Divide and rule Many of the beliefs which have shaped western urban form and society can be traced back to classical Greek and Roman cities which strongly manifested spatial divisions between male and female realms. These were expressions of associated public/private and inside/outside divisions. The respectable woman lived her life inside the home rather than out in the public places of square and street (Greed, 2000b; Boulding, 1992: 227) but if she went outside she was just a ‘woman on the street’ of questionable morals. The belief in the need for ‘zoning’ for separating out different land uses to create sanitary and organised cities has been a key theme governing the development of modern town planning in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries (Greed, 1994b). Land use zoning enforced distinct employment zones and residential areas – that is, work and home – the public and the private were 71
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
kept apart. This may also be interpreted as one means of circumscribing the role and sphere of women’s activities in modern society and keeping women ‘off the streets’. In the nineteenth century a woman who was out on her own ‘fancy free’ in the streets might be assumed to be a prostitute. There is no female flaneuse equivalent to the flaneur (the man about town) (Greed, 1994b). It was assumed that respectable women would be unlikely to move around the city, or travel on the railways, as much as equivalent men. They were less likely to need public toilets, which might encourage immorality attitudes and ‘unsanitary’ conditions. The words ‘zoning’ and ‘sanitary’ are etymologically linked (consider cordon sanitaire = quarantine zone) and urbs sana (the healthy city). Women who move around ‘outside’ the home, i.e. out in the city, have traditionally been seen as ‘out of control’, a phrase significantly also used of the prostitute, and both urologically and morally ‘incontinent’ (a word with many meanings). Their presence may be seen as a threat to the maintenance of public/private boundaries of social life within urban space (Greed, 1994a: 80–1).
The need for cleanliness and hygiene There is an enduring disgust with body wastes, urine, faeces and blood, all of which show that ‘man’ is not just a pure spirit but a dirty body too. This desire for separation from the earthly realm and flying off in the spirit may be echoed in science fiction and space travel. Star Trek First Contact (1996) was the first film in the popular science fiction series to have any mention of going to the toilet in the script. Clearly ‘man’s’ quest ‘to boldly go where no man had gone before’ could not exclude the fact that he had to ‘bodily’ go too. ‘Out of this world toilets’ have always presented major problems for astronauts (Bathroom Today, June 2002: 62). Communal public facilities such as toilets and, for that matter, swimming pools, health centres, holiday camps and cinemas have all been seen both by municipal authorities and by mothers as potentially dangerous places where germs are lurking which need to be strictly controlled and strongly disinfected. The obsession with sanitation in the nineteenth century was as much concerned with ‘social hygiene’ – that is, with morality – as it was with actual germs (Jones, 1986), but it still informs our attitude to toilets and bodily functions at the personal and micro policy level of toilet design, and the perceived fight against disease, dirt and crime therein. A spate of anthropological and sociological books deal with the impact that the need to separate clean and decent (Wright, 1960; Spock, 1969; Douglas, 1966; Reynolds, 1943) has had not only on our wider society but also specifically upon attitudes towards toilets and the accompanying bodily functions. In relation to confused cultural messages about sex and/or toilets, it is significant that Lucinda Lambton’s revised edition of her book Temples of Convenience: Chambers of Delight (Lambton, 1978) 72
CHAPTER FIVE • CULTURAL ATTITUDES: SEPARATING OR MIXING
was confiscated by Customs officials when it arrived from printing overseas, and impounded as too lewd. The equating of excretion with ‘dirtiness’ is not universally held, nor the linking of ‘sex’ with ‘dirtiness’ either, although most cultures have rules and taboos to prevent bacterial contamination. At the Japan Toilet Association (JTA, 1996b) International Conference in Toyama, North Japan in 1996, where the conference theme was environmental waste, I encountered a totally different set of cultural values. Japanese delegates explained that human excreta was highly valued in the past, and that it was seen as ‘brown gold’ that was spread on the fields as an essential component in fertility. Annual ceremonies used to be held in some Shinto temples in the villages where the Brown Gold was offered to the gods, the equivalent of our Harvest Festival! Likewise in Ancient Rome, the Emperor Vespasian taxed people for the right to clean the public toilets, because the waste was highly valued as fertilizer. The word ‘dirty’ has two linked meanings, namely unhygienic and sexual. It is a word frequently used by respondents in describing public toilets but one cannot specify exactly what percentage of each meaning is included in each use. For example, children are wisely warned to look out for ‘dirty old men’ when using public toilets. The poor are frequently described as ‘dirty’ but whether this refers to personal hygiene or morals is unclear. In the nineteenth century concern was expressed by ‘public health’ (and that’s a term to dissect) officials at the poor living in insanitary conditions. In fact this may have ‘meant’ concern about mixedsex overcrowding of a hundred people sharing the same privy! The public health
Figure 5.1 Global toilet debates. 73
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS 74
agenda has always been a cultural manifestation of the mores of society (Armstrong, 1993).
Separation or mixing There appears to be a deep-seated need in society to separate everything into good/evil and pure/impure categories, whether it be the sexes, social classes, races or land uses. Does there always need to be a negative to justify and sanctify the positive? According to Durkheim, if there were no evil there would be no good, and so certain activities would need to be criminalized to justify the existence of the justice system and righteous individuals (Durkheim, 1948, 1970). There is a deeper cultural uneasiness about ‘mixing’ regarding cross-cultural divides. Mary Douglas, the anthropologist, described how the tribes she studied in the South American Rain Forest were very concerned about the flying fox, a creature that seemed to be half bird and half furry mammal; they could not categorise it, so they did not eat it and considered it taboo. She concluded that ‘dirt is matter out of place’ (Douglas, 1966). Toilet symbols and language are indicative of cultural divisions. In Saudi Arabian airports it appears, at first sight, that there are no toilets for men, just two ‘Ladies’ symbols with long dresses, but the long black dress signifies ‘Women’ and the long white dress symbolises ‘Men’. On such occasions it is best to wait and see who goes into which door! The Ladies can be much worse than the Gents in some Middle Eastern countries, especially away from tourist areas, where the Gents might be to western standards, but there is only a hole in the ground for women, and no Ladies facilities at all in public and government buildings. Nowadays, the proliferation of disabled toilet logos suggests that there are now three sexes, male, female and disabled. The disabled sign is exclusionary as it suggests only (people in) ‘wheelchairs’ (a small proportion of all people with disabilities) are worthy to use the facilities. Interestingly one does not see Men, Women, and Gay as an alternative, but certainly this has been considered as a means of managing cottaging. While APCs might be a welcome port in a storm in an emergency, they are looked upon with apprehension and you seldom see a queue for an APC. People are frightened of being locked in, swept away in the cleaning cycle, inter alia. People are also concerned that ‘anyone’ might use them as they comprise the ultimate mixed toilet, used by men, women, and in some locations by cottaging couples. Likewise, many ordinary people want mixed hospital wards phased out, not least because of the toileting arrangements. Women may feel acutely embarrassed, stared at, and ill at ease, and this may affect their rate of recovery. The argument that such arrangements create a family atmosphere seem ill-placed when sharing with complete strangers who are not members of their family. This is particularly the case when toilet and washing facilities are shared between the
CHAPTER FIVE • CULTURAL ATTITUDES: SEPARATING OR MIXING Figure 5.2 A range of logos reflecting stereotypes and societal divisions. Male, Female and Disabled: Three Sexes? Male, Female, Disabled, Elderly, Baby: Five Sexes? 75
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
Figure 5.3 German tourist bus spotted in London: note the disabled toilet logo and other signs in the back window, truly a total mobile life-support system for all, a loomobile.
sexes on hospital wards. Many people are concerned with the poor design and condition of hospital toilets in general, many of which are surprisingly inaccessible and often dirty (Cavanagh, 1994). Clearly mixing boundaries does not work unless women’s needs are prioritised. A scientific study of queuing theory based on observations of public toilet queues recommended that unisex toilets would reduce the queue problem for the Ladies (Matthews, 2000). No account was taken of the fact that women had less provision to start with in the sites chosen for his survey and that everyone would queue longer unless full provision was made for both women and men, including facilities for children and the elderly, who were seen as slowing things down. In general, unisex toilets reduce, not increase, toilet provision. Unisex toilets are ostensibly breaking the zoning and segregation taboos that have so restricted women’s urban lives – but not necessarily in a positive way to the benefit of women, because arguably ‘to be male is to occupy space’ (WGSG, 1984). Men tend to take over and the women hold on and suffer bladder problems as a result, particularly within our culture where people are embarrassed about bodily noises and smells (would you be willing to move your bowels with your boss outside the toilet door?). Some young women are concerned about the noises they might make while urinating or evacuating their bowels. A Japanese company has produced a toilet that plays music to cover the sounds of urination and evacuation, and this is apparently proving popular in Europe too. Most toilets flush in E flat. Islam does not favour unisex toilets or, for that matter, 76
CHAPTER FIVE • CULTURAL ATTITUDES: SEPARATING OR MIXING
mixed washbasin facilities either, and many Moslem women are very concerned about this modern trend (Hamzah and Hooi, 2001). In spite of people’s ambivalence about unisex toilets, they are featured as the centre of social life in the television series Ally McBeal. Unisex staff toilets are perceived as modern and likely to be popular with younger people, especially by bosses of computer firms, but women of all ages are unhappy with such an arrangement (Daily Mail, 26.4.2000: 5). Clients visiting such offices may also feel uneasy. There are unisex toilets in the Ark, Hammersmith, office building, and fashionable ‘cool’ office developments in the London Docklands. Interlocked arms are displayed on the toilet logo to show that the toilets at the entrance to the new Royal Town Planning Institute (RTPI) headquarters are shared. When one opens the door one finds just a very large disabled toilet, yet there is no disabled symbol on the door. Town planning is still a very male-dominated profession and fortunately there are separate facilities on other floors. Likewise, in coffee chain outlets one typically finds one ‘mixed’ toilet in the form of an ill-equipped ‘disabled toilet’ that is intended to be used by customers, suggesting that the abled are gradually recolonising disabled toilet provision. Alternatively there will be a separate Gents and expectation that the disabled will share their toilet with the Ladies, with no alternative being offered as is the case in many a public building (in crematoria for example). With the requirements of the DDA 1995 progressively coming into force, it is likely that to meet the law’s requirements we will see more, not less, sharing of toilets between abled and disabled, in the form of the unisex, uni-able ‘disabled toilet’ to meet the minimum requirements of the law.1 Racial mixing in toilets has been a major concern in some societies. In South Africa and the Southern States of the US, separate toilets, water fountains and waiting rooms were commonplace. There would not only be a queue for the White Ladies toilet, provision was even poorer in the Black women’s toilets, whereas the White Gentlemen’s toilet had the highest level of provision. By comparison, as late as the 1950s in port towns in Britain, including parts of the London Docklands, one might find three signs on toilets used by the crew of merchant shipping – namely, ‘Officers, Men and Asians’. Sometimes several hygiene and zoning protocols make clashing demands within a particular location. In 1997 an illegal encampment of gypsies in a children’s play area beside a high-rise council block of flats in Bristol was provided by the council with a portaloo under the public health acts, although their presence there infringed other statutory controls. A fear of gypsies, foreigners, homeless and travellers – that is, ‘outcasts’ – using public toilets and mixing with ‘respectable’ people remains a topical issue, albeit unspoken in these politically correct times. There are class dimensions to be considered too. In Wales, for example, at Swansea railway station, one must choose between Dynion (Men) or Merched (Women). In class-ridden England, overseas visitors may hesitate as to whether their social position entitles them to use the Ladies or Gentlemen’s toilets, or
77
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
whether they should go and find those more democratically labelled ‘Women’ or ‘Men’. Do the rich use public toilets at all nowadays? A Which Magazine survey (2001) stated that only 50% of the public use public toilets, but no indication was given of who was asked in terms of class, gender, life stage and location. Other studies (by men) suggest that on-street public toilets are toilets of last resort – ones in shops, restaurants and pubs being preferred. Such facilities are not necessarily readily available to those travelling out of hours, or with luggage or pushchairs. There is such snobbery associated with public toilet usage, and so many male/female differences, that such statistics should be treated with great caution.
Zoning colours Zoning has affected high-level urban policy approaches, but a dualistic mentality has also affected details of toilet design and societal attitudes towards ‘individuals’ and ‘others’ including black people and women (not mutually exclusive categories). Thus a zoning mentality has both racial and aesthetic implications. In particular the black/white dualism is of significance. ‘Black’ was traditionally seen as the colour of ‘sin’, evil, disease, dirt, and pollution in the West, but sometimes conversely of modernity and high fashion. Whereas Henry Ford had said in respect of his Model T Ford cars ‘you can have any colour as long as it’s black’, in the case of underwear and toilet sanitary ware for many years it seemed you could have ‘any colour as long as it’s white’. Black does not show the dirt and stains so would be so much more practical, although admittedly in hard water areas it will stain and it will still have the same germs as white. Most fridges and washing machines continue to be white, apparently ‘meaning’ they are ‘cleaner’ than their coloured counterparts. In contrast, in industrial kitchens and food producing factories, such equipment is more likely to be black or shiny aluminium, not white. Digressing, I do wonder why computer equipment has always been the colour of rice pudding, or sick. A helpful chap at a major computer chainstore told me he thought this was because this colour showed the dirt quickly and looked faded and old, thus encouraging people to buy new machines. Perhaps if a computer looks ‘off colour’ it appears ‘unhygienic’ and ‘ill’ or possibly ‘diseased’, like a dirty lavatory, creating an illogical desire to replace it. Clearly we do go by appearances and judge a toilet by its colour. Sanitary towels and other sanpro are traditionally white, and nowadays often bleached sparkling white with dangerous chemicals (WEN, 1993) when brown is the real colour of unbleached cotton. Some are also made using GM cotton which has caused great concern. British soldiers coats were red, so as not to show the blood (even if it did make them sitting targets showing up so much). Likewise hospital and ambulance blankets used to be red not to show the blood, and a ‘red cross’ is a sure sign of ‘hygiene’, health and hospitals. So why is menstrual blood ‘blue’ in pantiliner advertisements on the television and not red? One is
78
Who is entitled to respond to the call of nature in public? The problem with public toilets is that they transgress public space and bring into the public arena private functions, potentially sexual activities, and women’s private functions. Culturally men have far more freedom of movement, and public space and facilities are built around their needs and travel patterns. It is more acceptable for a man to relieve himself in public. Just like male dogs, any tree or wall will do for male humans (especially walls belonging to pubs [public houses, bars, inns], closed public conveniences, car parks, and football grounds), regardless of the legality of the situation. Inglis (1993) refers to anti-social behaviour such as urinating on the terraces, even by men who would not normally behave like this, and once in the toilet in the washbasins or on the floor if there are not adequate urinals. Once normal behavioural boundaries have been breached, the way is opened for further criminal behaviour (Inglis, 1993). Likewise, once ‘outside’ street urination becomes acceptable, it is a slippery slope down to other forms of incivility and potential crime. Such attitudes start young. I was walking up Park Street, a main shopping street in Bristol, and observed a mother directing her small bursting son of around 5 years old to a convenient buddleia bush between buildings. As the boy peed, I heard his little sister cry out, ‘Mummy, Mummy, I want to go too’, a plea which met with no response whatsoever from the mother. Was the mother doing her a favour teaching her ‘self control’ for as she gets older she will find Ladies toilets are few and far between? This is a vicious circle, as female restraint confirms the entrenched attitude in the professional world of municipal plumbing
CHAPTER FIVE • CULTURAL ATTITUDES: SEPARATING OR MIXING
reminded of how a feminist group produced a spoof advertisement in the 1980s on this topic which ended up looking like a chain saw massacre – realistic but socially unacceptable. In 2001 a range of slimline sanitary towels available in black as well as white was advertised, but not red yet. Blue symbolises ‘hygiene’ and nowadays one will find washing-up liquid, wet wipes and disinfectant with blue dye added. Blue is also the colour of peppermint but, just to confuse matters, in some other European countries blue is the colour of hazelnut confectionary. Blue and green are also the colours of stuff you put down the loo to kill 99% of all known germs. Yet putting ‘blue down the loo’, that is putting harmful chemicals down the lavatory pan to ‘clean’ it, is much condemned by environmental groups as this toxic mixture of coloured chemicals will eventually end up in the ocean or on the land killing off valuable micro-organisms (National Trust, 2000). Visually disabled groups are concerned about the whiteness of toilet tiles and apparently it is difficult to find the door or the rail or the bowl if everything is gleaming white, designers take note. Colour and contrast need to be taken seriously in creating accessible toilet design (Bright, 2002).
79
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
that women do not ‘need’ to go as often as men. But the effects of under-provision for women are far more deadly, health-wise than the more visible problem of male street urination. Some women do not like transgressing the public/private divide and going ‘in public’, or at least going in a public toilet. Many ‘nice’ women still consider it rather ‘uncouth’ or possibly ‘unhygienic’ to use public facilities, and believe that it is a sign of virtue to go very infrequently, resulting in distended bladders, pain and a masochistic mentality. Likewise frequent bowel movements may be seen as ‘unladylike’ while the current obsession with slimming and reduction in food intake all create an incorporeal woman who has inwardly digested the cultural opprobrium of society towards women’s bodies. Such self-policing on the part of women reduces the demand for more women’s toilets. Why is putting food into the body not seen to be as dirty as excreting it at the other end? This theme was developed in the film, The Phantom of Liberty by Luis Bunuel, which centres around a dinner party scene where eating food is indecent, and everyone sits on loos to eat. This surrealist French comedy occasionally appears on Sky television late at night, and it is worth watching as it seeks ‘to make the familiar strange’ and challenges our assumptions about ‘normality’ (last seen 18.4.96, 1.35 am, Sky Movies Gold). Possibly eating food is disgusting to some people such as those suffering from bulimia and anorexia. People eat in mixed company, eating out is seen as a cultural event, not a shameful disgusting activity. Significantly, in some cultures women eat separately from, and after, the men. Since men ‘can’ go in public and there are more male toilets too, they are less likely to be ‘caught short’ (Birmingham, 1991) or declared incontinent. Clochemerle is the story of the installation of a pissoir (male public urinal) in the village of that name in the Beaujolais region of Southern France. Chevalier comments ‘only males are privileged to overflow on the public highway’ (Chevalier, 1993: 97, originally 1936). Clochemerle is now a tourist attraction in its own right (Derhy, 1996). The pissoirs of France have been notorious in making public provision for men and not for women. There are only two vespasiennes left in Paris now and they are listed buildings, with one used as a newspaper kiosk. Such oddities may be found by consulting the French web page: www.parisnet.com/ english/city/unusual/toilet/poesie.htm. The APC is known in French as the sanisette (little sanitary convenience), while the original pissoirs are known as vespasiennes, goules en vogue, and by many slang terms.
Eurination Nowadays in France, the pissoir has been replaced by the APC, the Superloo. The APC was first pioneered in Paris by Jean Claude Decaux’s company in 1980 and now Jean François Decaux the son runs a multi-million pound, international business which produces all sorts of street furniture, bus shelters, advertising 80
CHAPTER FIVE • CULTURAL ATTITUDES: SEPARATING OR MIXING
hoardings, seating, etc., as well as APCs. The first British Decaux APC was established in South Kensington, London in 1992 in the form of an advertising column, while their first fully accessible APC was established in 1995 in Russell Square in Camden. In 2001 a combined bus shelter toilet was built by Decaux in Notting Hill, London, designed by the famous architect Sir Norman Foster, just to the left of the Underground (outside 50 Notting Hill Gate) with another at 261 Kensington High Street, outside the Odeon and opposite the Commonwealth Centre. JC Decaux has installed thousands of APCs worldwide including nearly 1000 in the UK (Decaux, 2001). Having now become obsessed with public toilets, France has leapfrogged from a hole in the ground approach to developing the most modern contraptions, bypassing the Victorian sanitary engineering stage altogether. In France nowadays, the Cleanomat ‘no touch’ system is popular, which has a seat that opens automatically with a new paper cover coming out for each user. This has won the Toilette d’Or (Golden Toilet) Prize in France from the French Toilet Association (FTA). (Sadly the FTA is currently disbanded). The flush is activated when 37ºC temperature is sensed (body heat of urine), so it is all very vandalproof and there is no contamination by hand. In France, on-street public toilets, including APCs, are still relatively few in number compared with Britain. Many French ‘public’ toilets are to be found offstreet in cafés and restaurants. The standards and variety of provision varies considerably according to the class and expectations of the clientèle of the establishment. In theory, under French law, any member of the public has the right to use a café toilet without necessarily buying anything, a principle not welcomed by café owners if anyone tries to do so. Overall, Continental European attitudes to toileting seem to be more open. Anecdotally, everyone informs me that if you ask a French policeman, ‘where is the toilet?’, he will look puzzled and shrug his shoulders and gesture to show that the whole of France can be used as a toilet. In Belgium the Brussels Manneken-Pis celebrates male urination, and has its own museum and tourist following. There is also a female version of the statue a few streets away but, significantly, this is seldom mentioned. The Germans are generally known as having a more earthy approach to toilets, and Das Klo restaurant in Berlin is designed around a lavatorial theme (klopapier = toilet paper in German). The equating of scheiss (shit) with geld (gold) in German culture has often been highlighted, not least in Freud’s theories of anal retention (as discussed, for example, by Professor Alan Dundes of California and Dr. Val Curtis, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, on the Anatomy of Disgust Channel 4 TV programme of 15.8.2000). You can judge a nation’s culture by its toilets. Many German toilet bowls have a ledge on which to inspect the outcome before flushing it away. In contrast North American toilets have powerful flushes that get rid of it all in one go, with no built-in viewing ledge. French toilets, before the French toilet revolution set
81
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
(a)
(b) Figure 5.4 Combined bus shelter and toilet, Notting Hill (a) designed by Sir Norman Foster and manufactured by JC Decaux. A very high level of design using international architects has been a mark of recent Decaux products. The Decaux UK Headquarters (b) are appropriately housed in an Art Deco building refurbished by Sir Norman Foster in 2000, located in the Great West Road, Brentford, West London. Bus shelters, advertising hoardings and other street furniture are all design co-ordinated [(c) and (d) next page].
in, were traditionally a ‘hole in the ground’ and it is no coincidence that a huge perfume industry developed in France. Britain’s attitudes are culturally somewhere between the two extremes of North America and Europe, ranging from 82
CHAPTER FIVE • CULTURAL ATTITUDES: SEPARATING OR MIXING
(c)
(d) Figure 5.4
(continued).
modern and efficient to unpredictable and earthy. In spite of the dreadful condition of many British public loos, some are still admired by foreign tourists. The German Embassy announced that ‘Germans like British toilets’ (press release Evening Standard, 3.6.97). A report was given (18.5.1997) in The Times about how the Russian envoy saw British toilets as a sign of the world’s most civilised nation! More commonly, every nation seems to think that other nations smell and theirs is the best system in the world, so for one nation to commend the toilets of another is praise indeed. 83
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS 84
Our American cousins Britain, relatively speaking, shares an Anglo-American culture with North America, in spite of attempts to harmonise us with the rest of Europe where toilet attitudes are freer. Prudery has been more embedded in North American society. 1950s films had no toilets in their bathrooms and only single beds in marital bedrooms. The 1999 film, Pleasantville, a skit on the hypocrisy of the soaps of the 1950s, includes a scene in which one of the female travellers from the 1990s goes to the Ladies restroom only to find all the compartments are void of toilets. Americans seem to be edgy about their public toilets, and are famed for leaving a large gap (specified as 9 inches or 12 inches in some states) between the bottom of the door and the floor, to prevent anything from ‘going on’ in the compartment, which can put some men off going altogether. Apparently in the past (1930s) many US public cubicles had no door, and nowadays in army barracks, prisons and other institutions there are rooms full of toilet pans for the inmates in the open without any cubicles or walls. Clearly the design of men’s public toilets needs improving too. American words for going to the lav such as ‘using the bathroom’ (where there is no bath!) have a strong association with ‘washing’ and ‘cleaning’, perhaps reflecting the puritan origins of American-English which lacks the coarseness of vernacular Anglo-Saxon terminology of some aspects of English-English (see Acronyms for a list of equivalent words). The American term, ‘I’ll go wash up’ causes confusion if a British person responds ‘I’ll help you wash up’. Likewise, ‘I’m going to wash up in the kitchen’ really means in English-English ‘I am going to do the dishes after the meal’. Clearly the situation is culturally complex. Other American terms include restroom, John, and comfort station. English-English terms include loo, lav, bog, W.C. (water closet) and the wonderfully neutral phrase, public convenience. I have used the slang word ‘go’ to include all trips to the toilet for whatever reason, but acknowledge that this is a particularly English-English term. While some families members will enthusiastically ask of each other, ‘have you had a bowel movement?’, in more refined families people resort to phrases such as ‘I wouldn’t go in there for a little while if I were you’. Yet perhaps we are in good company as Prince Charles in his book Old Man of the Isles (Prince Charles, 1986) talks about the importance of moving one’s bowels after breakfast. Why is toilet talk often equated with being common, with slang and lack of education? Why is low-status dirty work seen as ‘shit work’, an accolade that might be better used to describe high-status, creative valuable activity? A straightforward approach is so much healthier. A recent documentary on the army showed that new recruits were awakened at 5.00 am and given the official command to ‘Shit, shave and shower’ and all within 20 minutes! An army may march on its stomach but it may be hindered by its bowels! Other curiosities include the endearing term ‘dunny’ in Australia. Some of the words used for public toilets suggest affection rather than revulsion. The
Toilet art Public toilets have become cultural artefacts in their own right. Because in our society excretory functions, like sex, are seen as ‘dirty’, it is inevitable that the avant garde, seeking to shock, will use toilets as ‘art’, often in association with depictions of ‘sex’. I am alarmed by those women artists who appear to have bought into the whole ‘male thing’ about the ‘dirtiness’ of bodily functions and, as a manifestation, the ‘ladette’ who mistakenly imagines ‘girl power’ to be like the boys seeking to shock their audiences. (But when it comes to attitudes to street urination presumably they find they are not really one of the lads after all.) The artist, Sarah Lucas, included a full toilet bowl in her exhibition at the Arnolfini Bristol (featured on television, BBC2, 30.11.96, 9.30 pm) while Tracy Emin has taken this trend even further. ‘Disgust’ is the operative word infusing such art, not its antonyms ‘delight’ and ‘pleasure’ which are words seldom associated with excreta. Lucas’s work was part of an exhibition entitled ‘Minky Manky’. This oeuvre was entitled TX: Two Melons and a Stinking Fish, no doubt alluding to the fact that many men say that women’s genitals smell of ‘stale fish’. In reality many women clean out toilets, put down lav seats, wipe the bottoms of the very young and very old, and clean up after male, elderly and/or careless family members. So such ‘art’ is merely annoying to ordinary women who do not have the luxury of being disgusted either by sights or by smell, but simply have to get on with it (Curtis, 2000). Other artists of this genre include Stewart Ridley, ‘anti-hygiene artist’, and Steve Pippin who produced a video made in 1998 entitled The Continuing Saga of an Amateur Photographer. The video shows, in real time, the journey from London to Brighton by train, during which time he goes into the toilet, sets up a camera and darkroom and photographs the toilet bowl, and then packs up all his equipment and walks out of the toilet on arrival at Brighton. No wonder train toilets are always ‘Engaged’! This genre of art has its precedents in the origins of ‘Modern Art’ in the early twentieth century – for example, in DuChamp’s painting of a urinal from 1917 entitled The Fountain. DuChamp saw himself as an anti-art artist (see exhibition ‘DuChamp’s Suitcase’, 30.8.2000). More extreme is the work of Herman Nicht, an Austrian, who undertakes public performance art involving blood and entrails, and also Damien Hirst and his sawn-up sheep. Is this their way of resolving the
CHAPTER FIVE • CULTURAL ATTITUDES: SEPARATING OR MIXING
Spanish, for example, sometimes refer to public toilets as necessidades (necessities), as well as having more basic descriptors (Muro, 1994). The Japanese ‘kangi’ symbols for ‘toilet’, ‘ka-awa’, mean river house = flush toilet in Japanese; a similar idea being conveyed by the symbols ‘chan se’ in Chinese. In spite of all these colourful terms, members of official government committees on ‘toilets’ are far more restrained – yet again creating a cultural barrier and desensitising participants from daily realities.
85
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
clean/dirty dualism? Efficient sanitation and investment in public toilets would seem a better way to do so. The work of the late Helen Chadwick is far more healthy (Cullis, 1993: 23–4). In 1991 she produced a series of sculptures entitled Piss Flowers. These consisted of bronze casts of the fantastic shapes created by her pissing in the snow in Canada, and were intended to be both beautiful and a way of breaking down taboos about it being dirty or naughty for women to urinate in public (or urinate at all!). Avant garde artist Andy Warhol also went through a phase of producing ‘oxidisation paintings’ based on himself and his friends pissing on canvas and chemically treating the stains to create interesting patterns. In contrast there is a vast popular toilet art and culture of the ‘dirty postcards’ ‘Carry On’ films variety within which many a true word is spoken in jest concerning the nature of British toilet humour – for example, in Carry On at Your Convenience (1971) and Carry On Marshal, the story of a plumbing engineer from Chipping Sodbury who is mistaken for a US marshal in the Wild West.
Sexualising toilets There is an underworld of ‘toilet culture’ that centres around their sexual, rather than excretory, usage. I visit every public convenience I come across (not necessarily to go) but to inspect the premises, to watch how the users tackle the challenge of the building design and, if there is one, to chat to the attendant, ‘as all human life is there’. If I find lost people who are looking for the toilets, I direct them and I complain loudly to all around when toilets are closed, in order to raise consciousness. Looking for background material, I stumbled into a contrasting alien world of sociological literature and contacts centred around the ‘goings on’ in male public toilets. I found an obsession with covert, ethnographic research (social anthropology studies) by male sociologists to observe ‘cottaging’ which takes place in ‘tearooms’ (male toilets) (Warwick, 1982; Flowers et al, 2000). These sociologists’ choice of topic reflects a tendency I found in a range of literature on ‘toilet provision’, namely for men toilet providers, researchers and designers to be incapable, in their minds, of separating toilet provision from sexual activity. There is far more sociological literature on cottaging than there is on toilets’ value for excretion purposes. This is expressed in the world of the built environment professions too in a school-boyish, smutty mentality, and much sexual innuendo, when the topic of toilets is raised, but also in genuine embarrassment, especially when discussing women’s requirements. Even my mature post-graduate male students, some of them members of the rugby club, went bright red when I sought to discuss public convenience provision with them. I found very little on whether a female version of cottaging occurred in women’s toilets, except in erotic s/m lesbian literature such as by Califia (1989: 223 as commented upon by Jeffries, 1994: 159). Elizabeth Wilson, in discussing 86
CHAPTER FIVE • CULTURAL ATTITUDES: SEPARATING OR MIXING
the future (questionable) progress of women, ponders upon the phenomenon of some women seeing it as their ‘feminist’ right to emulate and ape men in seeking sex in public toilets (Wilson, 2000: 200). Cottaging is not an issue in women’s toilets; rather, most women are more concerned about accessible toilets that they can use simply as toilets. It is a completely different culture. Men’s sexual activities, straight and gay, influence toilet design solutions, reduce access and inconvenience women greatly. Local residents’ groups express concern to the police about public toilets being left open all night as it is believed it ‘encourages’ young people to have intercourse in them. I was told by male local government officials and private security firm representatives that women’s public toilets should not be open in the evenings as it ‘encouraged’ prostitutes and the homeless to use them! Nowadays, many public toilets close at 6.00pm. But women commuters and late shoppers need them. Concern is expressed by women customers and station managers at women prostitutes using motorway (freeway) service station toilets (not about male commercial travellers loitering around Ladies’ toilet entrances). Toilets in shopping malls were seen as encouraging shoplifting. Fears of prostitution, theft, underage sex, drug trafficking, graffiti and vandalism, were quite enough excuse for some operators to feel justified in permanently closing or reducing facilities for women (thus saving running and maintenance costs in the process) (Jones, 1994). A sign appeared on the Horfield Ladies toilets (by the urinal, fig 4.1) when they closed stating ‘these toilets are closed following complaints from the public concerning criminal (sexual) activity’. A council official told me that the notice actually referred to activities in the male toilets, so women were inconvenienced through no fault of their own. No-one suggested that the Ladies must stay open because of complaints about the criminal lack of public toilets for women in that area. Male toilets used for cottaging, or for drug trafficking, would be more likely to get police surveillance than be closed, as was the case with vandalised women’s toilets. ‘Discouragement of use’ seems to be the main policy basis which providers operate upon in dealing with imagined ‘problems’ in women’s toilets. As a result of such closures some women are deterred from going out in the evenings, a culture of incivility builds up and the streets can be taken over by marauding hordes of lager louts who pee where they wish. A balance of women and men of all ages on the city streets in the evenings would create a more wholesome atmosphere, a greater sense of public ‘ownership’ of urban spaces, and this may prove the best deterrent against misuse of public toilets in the long run. The omnipresent concerns of women about the state of public toilets and the problems with using them were not reflected in sociological literature, nor in municipal plumbing manuals, nor in the cultural concerns of the plumbing fraternity. They were to be found in a range of ‘women and the built environment’ sources and many conversations. Many women are uneasy about the fact that many public conveniences are located in pairs with Ladies and Gents facilities
87
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS 88
directly alongside, typically with badly lit entrances, hidden by trees and bushes which block visibility. In this case women want more, not less, separation and zoning. Concern about facilities for children are often expressed by parents, especially mothers, when discussing public toilets, both in respect of the design and scale of facilities; and ‘culturally’ over the question of whether to send a young boy or girl into the ‘other’ toilet on their own. Some young men seemed quite homely in their concerns, and more worried about the lack of changing facilities for babies in the Gents, and the problems of whether to take their small daughters in with them or to find a kindly lady to take them into the Ladies for them, than with the potential for exciting sexual acts in the loos. Where there is a public toilet, mothers may be unwilling to let their little boys into the Gents. In the Galleries shopping centre in the middle of Bristol, I observed (30.8.2000) a woman with two little boys of around 6 and 9 shepherding them into the Ladies, but the older boy kept veering off towards the Gents door. The mother scolded him saying. ‘It’s men’s not boy’s’ but he still ran off in there, and I observed an anxious wait until he returned to her side. Cultural attitudes are stronger than brick walls in shaping toilet use. Some men felt uneasy about using men’s public toilets, and expressed concern about using public urinals; some wished there were more cubicles, and some even preferred the privacy of the APC. Older men expressed fears of violence from ‘lager louts’ once their back was turned, while others were concerned about a humiliating lack of disposal facilities for their incontinence pads, or were worried about slipping over on wet floors especially where there was a step up to the urinal trough. Of course not all men are ‘the same’ and some men fear other men as much as some women fear men. Did the male toilet-based sociologists of yesteryear never ‘see’ any of these problems experienced by incontinent, elderly, disabled men, and those with childcare responsibilities, while spending hours in public conveniences? Significantly, William Whyte, the famous American sociologist and author of Street Corner Society, was a great campaigner for the provision of public restrooms (Whyte, 1981, originally 1964). While many members of the general public are ‘put off’ by homosexual activities in toilets, several high profile cases, such as George Michael being ‘caught’ in a men’s loo in April 1998 in Los Angeles by an undercover policeman, and a subsequent pop video based on the event, plus a more lenient attitude towards gay rights by New Labour, have resulted in a certain risky ‘glamour’ being attached to cottaging. If gay sex is relatively more legal and commonplace nowadays why do they still choose to do it in the public toilets? Culturally it is significant that one of the arguments for including babychanging facilities in both male and female toilets is that it will apparently create a ‘family atmosphere’, the same argument that has been used about allowing babies and children into pubs as a means of diluting the lager lout culture. That is putting a great deal of responsibility upon children, babies and their carers in
Socialising toilets
CHAPTER FIVE • CULTURAL ATTITUDES: SEPARATING OR MIXING
what are often unhygienic, smelly and threatening surroundings. A baby becomes a political football in this scenario. Also there have been considerable differences of opinion expressed about the question of breastfeeding in public toilets. From a patriarchal perspective this is the ultimate act of private domestic activities invading public space, but from a woman’s perspective it may be seen as a means of asserting women’s rights or as a second-best solution. Dr. Spock, the American childcare guru, suggested that women might breastfeed their babies in public toilets; in this case, therefore, fear of pollution by women’s private bodily functions in public was given greater precedence than the usual fear about infants being endangered by germs in that age of hygiene. Would you want to eat your dinner in the toilet? (Leach, 1979). Generally the view has been that baby-changing facilities, disabled facilities, breastfeeding facilities and ‘ordinary’ toilets should all be provided in separate compartments or sections of public toilet facilities as they do not mix. Curiously, in our society public display of breasts for feeding purposes may be seen as ‘disturbing the peace’ when undertaken in public places, but pornographic literature is everywhere (Greed, 1996d). While men are still free to urinate unopposed wherever they wish, women’s functions are not accepted so readily, even though depriving a baby of its feed may be a life-threatening action. By the way, why are abandoned babies often left in public toilets? Public toilets are places to be born in and to die in. There are all sorts of interesting cultural issues here.
Much of the culture of toilets is off putting. Men are known for making little eye contact with other men in the toilet, and apparently their visit is likely to be undertaken in silence for fear of being thought ‘queer’, although in contrast ‘toilet clubs’ might exist among gay patrons. Nowadays the embarrassed silence may be shattered by some man chattering away in a compartment. But he’s not cottaging, just answering his mobile phone. Schoolboys’ toilets are more lively places, a popular location for bullying, intimidation and sexual inquiry. In contrast, women’s toilets appear to be much more sociable locations. Women frequently talk to their friends, and even strangers, while urinating, perhaps because they do not want to waste valuable time. In a classic American study Brent (1981) undertook research on the sociable use of restroom lounges in department stores by elderly women, who treated the waiting room attached to the toilets rather in the same way elderly men might treat a park bench, somewhere to sit and chat and watch the world go by. Such sociable use of toilets is an unlikely luxury when the facilities on offer are disgusting, the floor is awash and the whole place smells badly. Apparently men don’t notice the smell, or they won’t admit it, and they may imagine the toilets of the opposite sex smell worse. Likewise girls’ toilets in schools tend to be more sociable, a place to try out new 89
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
Figure 5.5 Schoolgirl’s drawing of how big she imagines her toilets to be.
hairstyles and discuss fashion, but nowadays they are likely to be poorly maintained, dirty and provided with fewer toilets than the boys’ loos. Nevertheless girls may not realise this. They may imagine their toilets are much larger than they are, as we found in our Nuffield schools project (cf Huang and Wang, 2001). Nightclubs are a spawning ground for lavatorial innovations in the name of art, culture, youthfulness and modernity. The Coconut Nightclub (previously known as the Destiny and Elite Nightclub) in Derby in 2000 installed ‘twobicles’ (rather than cubicles) in the Ladies so that women could go to the toilet together and carry on talking. In 1994 Club Velvet in Barcelona had ‘waterfalls’ running down the walls of its unisex toilets (and it wasn’t broken pipes). A New York nightclub called the SoHo Bar, featured in the journal Interior Design in June 1996, earned the title ‘a wash90
CHAPTER FIVE • CULTURAL ATTITUDES: SEPARATING OR MIXING
room for voyeurs’ and was designed by architects Kathyrn Ogawa and Gilles Depardon. It provided separate male/female toilets but the design brief was specifically that the ‘bathrooms be sexual’, which says it all. Splendid the toilets, and vibrant the 24-hour city: the trouble is that the nightclubs close, the people leave, the cold air hits their bladders and the streets are awash. Creating the 24-hour city (Bianchini, 1991) and the European city of culture has to be backed by provision of adequate social facilities including toilets. The very cultural foundations of the nation will be eroded away, literally, for according to Westminster City Council young men waiting for buses in Trafalgar Square after a night on the town have been using the walls of the National Gallery to pee against and rotting the stonework. As a result temporary urinals were installed for weekends only, to be followed on 12 October 2002 by permanent ones (called Butterfly urinals) provided by Danfo, but for men only. Another version of the Urilift was also installed first in Reading in Spring 2002, and later in London too. This was justified as ‘additional’ provision to counter street urination rather than as a blatant form of discrimination against women who already have less provision and were offered no alternative facilities. But it is questionable whether male street urinals substantially reduce street urination or whether they are another assertion of male control of public space. They certainly do nothing to deal with complaints about men urinating in public (and the related indecency aspects), rather they increase the opportunity. The results of the night-time economy have put more people off coming into cities in the evening and reduced the range of types of people who do frequent the city streets at night, according to recent research (JMU, 2001); families, elderly and disabled people are clearly not welcome.
Figure 5.6 Danfo ‘Butterfly’ Male street urinal, designed to counter street urination behind St Martins in the Fields, by Trafalgar Square, London. 91
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
a
b Figure 5.7 (a) Urilift in Reading opposite a pub, as the author films a documentary. (b) The Urilift back in the ground, marked only by the circle in the pavement. 92
1.
Current research is finding that rather than making existing abled toilets accessible for disabled people as required by the DDA Act, many local authorities are simply closing their existing toilets thus inconveniencing everyone and avoiding the requirements of the law (EPSRC, 2003).
Questions to ponder ➥
What taboos determine toilet policy?
➥
Unisex, mixed or separate?
➥
Religious and cultural implications of new designs?
➥
Women’s needs secondary?
➥
‘Who’ is imagined to be the ‘normal’ toilet user?
➥
Urinary equality?
➥
Attitudes to street urination?
➥
Advertising pays?
➥
Need for stronger social infrastructure to support evening economy?
CHAPTER FIVE • CULTURAL ATTITUDES: SEPARATING OR MIXING
Notes
93
Medical perspectives: incompetence or incontinence
Medical perspectives In this chapter the attitudes and perceptions of medicine towards toilet issues, as informed by its companion modern science, will be discussed. The cultural agenda identified in the previous chapter, of separating clean from dirty, informs much medical literature in relation to toilets. While this book seeks to emphasise the positive health benefits of adequate toilet provision, the medical discourse is more negative with toilets and excretion often being seen as a source of disease. Within a dominant macho-medical culture a war must be waged against germs, disease, bacteria and dirt in the name of hygiene, using all the power and technology of modern science. In reality it is vital that there are benign bacteria in the gut to break down our food and naturally to immunise us against a range of diseases. From Victorian times a huge ‘killer potion’ industry has grown up to zap germs, be they in our bodies or lurking under the rim of the toilet seat. For example, during the nineteenth century Jeyes Fluid was invented (1871), while Lister invented Listerine, and even such innocuous ‘scents’ as 4711 Eau de Cologne were originally intended to guard against diseases and distempers.
CHAPTER SIX • MEDICAL PERSPECTIVES: INCOMPETENCE OR INCONTINENCE
chapter six . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Figure 6.1 Ordinary people in the park at lunchtime. People of all age ranges, including the ‘normal’ and the ‘young’ need public toilets because otherwise they may develop urinary problems later. Holding it in never did anyone any good. Public toilets are needed by everyone not just people who are disabled or incontinent. 95
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
The medical profession has considerable power over society in shaping attitudes, and filling individuals with a sense of personal blame, fear and shame, for societal issues that can only be solved by public health intervention or cultural change. A division must be put between sacred and profane, clean and dirty, to please Hygeia the goddess of Health. Although this divine female is held in high regard, mere mortal women are more likely to be blamed for all manner of disease, weakness, illness and impurity, rather than praised for all their caring efforts in creating and sustaining Earth’s population.
Public and private perspectives A crucial distinction is made in this chapter between the role of private medicine and public health respectively1. It is concerned with the influence of clinicians (be they GPs, hospital specialists or surgeons dealing with the ‘internal plumbing’ problems of individuals) as against the role of ‘public health’ specialists dealing with entire cities and their populations. Parallel dualisms in health include primary/secondary (healthcare), preventative/curative, privatised/collectivised, public/private and public health/clinical practice. Being a public health specialist is generally seen as less glamorous than ‘being a doctor’2. The former’s regulatory and preventative roles arguably have a greater effect upon the nation’s health while some of the greatest municipal sanitary engineers remain unsung heroes. Nowadays environmentalists and urban planners continue to promote this dimension through the healthy cities movement, and the World Health Organisation (WHO) (Barton and Tsourou, 2000; Brand, 1999). Public health covers a wide range of issues concerned with creating a healthy environment and society. Matters as diverse as sewerage and drainage, food poisoning, water pollution, sexually transmitted diseases (STD), noise abatement, rat infestation, cleaning and waste disposal may all come under the auspices of public health at local authority level (Robinson, 2001). Many a public toilet door contains notices warning people about STD and inviting sufferers to attend their local clinic; these give a further sexual presence to the public lavatory, and add to its seedy ‘dirty’ image and the belief that one might pick up other people’s germs by sitting on the seat or touching the door bolt.
Clinical medicine Gendered priorities Emphasis is given in this section to women’s needs because they seem to have suffered the most from medical prejudices and because they generally need to go to the loo more often as they have a wider range of biological functions. There is a range of ‘problems’ only encountered by women which have featured in feminist literature and the media in recent years, most of which never 96
CHAPTER SIX • MEDICAL PERSPECTIVES: INCOMPETENCE OR INCONTINENCE
used to be spoken about. These include the effects of childbirth and epidurals on continence, the impact of female circumcision, and the effects of rape and thoughtless sex. Women have also been the subject of much of the high-tech impetus in medicine, possibly because as ‘the maternal environment’ (but not as human individuals) they are seen as a key link in the reproduction process. Childbirth has been subject to increasing medicalisation, high-tech screening and genome projects (Oakley, 1980; Spallone and Steinberg, 1987; Doyal, 1995; Stanworth, 1987). Women visit the toilet more frequently because of pregnancy, periods and cystitis; to check on worries about vaginal discharge (or to check ‘constantly’ on one’s ‘whites’ if one is using natural birth control to determine fertile days), and simply to check if one’s knickers (pants) or tights are about to fall down, or if one’s period has actually started; because they feel ill, are about to give birth or die; to pray; to cry and to get away, to think and be quiet; to escape from the city of man; or for baby-changing, breastfeeding (as a last resort) or to assist the elderly, children and disabled people. All these uses and visits require good ‘access’, lots of public toilets, plenty of internal space and a welcoming atmosphere. This is quite a different agenda from the cultural priorities dominating male toilets, which appear chiefly concerned with creating a ‘fortress’, defended against drugs, vandalism, cottaging and criminal activity. While women’s problems ‘down below’ have been dealt with within the context of reproductive medicine, the field of urology has been far from gender neutral, and for many years was predominantly concerned with men’s complaints (Kursch and McGuire, 1994). It is only in recent years that women’s specific problems have received greater attention. As in veterinary practice, for many years cats were treated as little dogs and there was no specific feline specialism. Likewise, women were treated as little, and imperfect, men, and there was limited female specialisation. Urology appears often to be a euphemism for ‘STD’ or for male sexual problems. Women’s urinary issues seem to fall between the realms of reproductive/childbirth specialisms and STD/sexual specialisms. While in the city of man, women have half as much public toilet provision as men, in the world of medicine and health, women’s ‘different’ anatomy still receives far less attention or it is tacked on to other pre-existing specialisms as an afterthought. Much medical research to test the side-effects of drugs is undertaken on men only, even when intended for women, because women’s physiology is seen to be ‘too unreliable’, being subject to biological cycles. There is little allowance in this climate for acknowledgment of women’s menstruation and how urination demands might change within the monthly cycle (ORWH, 1991). Periods (monthly cycles) have been seen by medical experts as an illness, and by religious authorities as unclean. Public toilet providers are obsessed with the ‘inconvenience’ of sanpro disposal, especially since environmental controls require sanpro bins to be provided in each compartment, making women’s toilets even ‘dirtier’,
97
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS 98
whereas in the old days sanitary towels were not left to fester but were burnt in small wall-hung incinerators in the Ladies.
Excretory uniformity There is a vast range in what is considered ‘normal’ as to how many times a day a person should urinate, according to ‘who’ is speaking (be they toilet user, toilet manufacturer or medical expert), and especially according to whether the person under scrutiny is male or female. Figures between 3 and 15 times a day are quoted as the average by different ‘reliable’ ‘scientific’ sources, with more than 8 times a day being seen as problematic. Women have often been blamed for going ‘too often’. The average bladder holds 500 ml = 3 cups of tea. What is normal? Every three to four hours? In comparison, popular women’s magazines’ ‘friendly doctor’s advice’ pages are less condemnatory, and suggest that women should urinate every couple of hours to flush out the system to discourage the lingering of ‘germs’, to reduce acidic build up, to help with cystitis, and to prevent toxic shock from leaving tampons in too long (Dawson, 1994; Kilmartin, 1994). Overall changing lifestyles result in changing excretion patterns nationally. Certain forms of diabetes are affected by diet and weight problems, and increased urination is one symptom. Urination frequency may also be increased because of the popularity of diuretic canned drinks of the cola variety. Increased visits may reflect a healthier lifestyle as people consume more roughage and move their bowels more frequently. Moving one’s bowels every day is considered ideal but some people go twice a day, especially men, and some leave it for days at a time without necessarily considering themselves constipated (Heaton, 1998). Half the nation is probably constipated, and bowel cancer is the second largest killer cancer in Britain after lung cancer. Is the concept of averages and standardised normality a meaningful concept in the twenty-first century or a throw-back to Victorian taxonomy? Women are more likely to be condemned as abnormal (relative to men?) and defined as incontinent, when research shows that men drink more fluids than women and ‘go’ more often because there is a higher level of public toilet provision for men. So they may never experience this as a problem of wanting to go and finding there is no loo (Goldsmith, 1992). When late night male street urination occurs no-one says young men are suffering from incontinence or are defective human beings, they are simply ‘pissed’ (a curious term deriving from the ancient custom of the poor drinking the urine [piss] of drunks to get drunk themselves, rather like re-using tea bags?). Incontinence may be defined as unwanted, inconvenient, excessive or uncontrollable urination. Various sources confirm that 1 in 17 children wet the bed, 1% of adults wet the bed, 1 in 3 women have some post-birth incontinence, and 1 in 3 men over 50 experience some problems; altogether 1 in 10 men and
1 in 4 women have some form of incontinence. As the population ages. incontinence increases. It is hard to give precise statistics as incontinence is a grey area, under-reported by some individuals, but over-diagnosed in respect of women. Incontact (www.incontact.org) estimates that 6 million people in the UK suffer from bladder problems. There are varying degrees ranging from mild stress incontinence (an occasional dribble when sneezing) which affects many women from time to time, to constant flow as experienced by some very elderly women when ‘their plumbing has completely gone’. Double incontinence of both bowel and bladder is a more challenging situation, especially for carers, while irritable bowel syndrome adds unpredictability to modern life. This variation is reflected in the range of incontinence pads, from wafer thin to super strength jumbo pads (all of which may end up on the public toilet floor if disposal facilities are not adequate). Dealing with incontinence has become a multi-million multinational industry affecting the environment and individuals’ lives. In contrast some people suffer from not being able to go at all, as they suffer from Shy Bladder Syndrome (paruresis – that is, ‘piss shy’) a complaint particularly experienced by American males (Soifer, 2001). Estimates suggest that
CHAPTER SIX • MEDICAL PERSPECTIVES: INCOMPETENCE OR INCONTINENCE
Figure 6.2 Caring for the elderly in the community. With an ageing population and the elderly being cared for by relatives, unisex disabled toilet provision is essential. Sometimes the male may be the carer for an elderly female relative, thus unisex disabled toilets are essential.
99
THE PROBLEM OF PUBLIC TOILETS
around 5–10% of the male population suffer from this problem at some time in their lives in the US, with 90% of sufferers being male. Piss-shyness (paruresis) may prevent sufferers from using a public restroom. Paruresis can be a jobthreatening issue if compulsory employee drug testing requires an instant urine sample. Most sufferers have experienced the p