Intermetallic Chemistry
PERGAMON MATERIALS SERIES
Series Editor: Robert W. Cahn FRS Department of Materials Science and Metallurgy, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK Vol. 1 Vol. 2 Vol. 3 Vol. 4 Vol. 5 Vol. 6 Vol. 7 Vol. 8 Vol. 9 Vol. 10 Vol. 11 Vol. 12
CALPHAD by N. Saunders and A. P. Midownik Non-Equilibrium Processing of Materials edited by C. Suryanarayana Wettability at High Temperatures by N. Eustathopoulos, M. G. Nicholas and B. Drevet Structural Biological Materials edited by M. Elices The Coming of Materials Science by R. W. Cahn Multinuclear Solid-State NMR of Inorganic Materials by K. J. D. MacKenzie and M. E. Smith Underneath the Bragg Peaks: Structural Analysis of Complex Materials by T. Egami and S. J. L. Billinge Thermally Activated Mechanisms in Crystal Plasticity by D. Caillard and J. L. Martin The Local Chemical Analysis of Materials by J. W. Martin Metastable Solids from Undercooled Melts by D. M. Herlach, P. Galenko and D. Holland-Moritz Thermo-Mechanical Processing of Metallic Materials by B. Verlinden, J. Driver, I. Samajdar and R.D. Doherty Phase Transformations Examples from Titanium and Zirconium Alloys by S. Banerjee and P. Mukhopadhyay
Intermetallic Chemistry
R. Ferro and A. Saccone Department of Chemistry, University of Genoa, Italy
Amsterdam • Boston • Heidelberg • London • New York • Oxford Paris • San Diego • San Francisco • Singapore • Sydney • Tokyo Pergamon is an imprint of Elsevier
Pergamon is an imprint of Elsevier The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington, Oxford OX5 1GB, UK Radarweg 29, PO Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands First edition 2008 Copyright © 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior written permission of the publisher Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Science & Technology Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone (44) (0) 1865 843830; fax (44) (0) 1865 853333; email:
[email protected]. Alternatively you can submit your request online by visiting the Elsevier web site at http://elsevier.com/locate/permissions, and selecting Obtaining permission to use Elsevier material Notice No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress For information on all Pergamon publications visit our web site at books.elsevier.com Typeset by Charon Tec Ltd (A Macmillan Company), Chennai, India www.charontec.com Printed and bound in Great Britain 08 09 10 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 ISBN: 978-0-08-044099-6
Contents Editorial Foreword Preface
xxiii xxv
CHAPTER 1 Introductory survey 1.1. A presentation of the book and remarks on its contents CHAPTER 2 Phase diagrams in alloy systems 2.1. Preliminary remarks 2.2. Some characteristic, T vs. x, binary phase diagrams 2.2.1 Mutual solid solubility of the component metals in alloy systems 2.2.1.1 Mutual solid-state solubility: a simple structural representation – order/disorder 2.2.1.2 Trends in mutual solid solubility 2.2.1.3 Electronegativity, Mendeleev number, Miedema parameters 2.2.1.4 Partial mutual solubility in the solid state 2.2.2 Inter-crossing of two-phase equilibria 2.2.2.1 Phase rule, ‘Building Blocks’ in binary system diagrams, Invariant equilibria 2.2.2.2 Solubility Diagrams: effects of atomic properties on mutual solubility 2.2.3 Trends in mutual liquid solubilities 2.2.4 Formation of intermediate phases in alloy systems 2.2.4.1 Trends in the formation capability of binary compounds 2.3. Examples of more complex phase diagrams 2.3.1 Ternary phase diagrams 2.3.2 Variable pressure phase diagrams 2.3.2.1 Partial pressure as a variable 2.3.3 Equilibrium and reaction rate 2.3.3.1 Stable, metastable and unstable states: a simple analogy v
1
7 8 8 10 11 12 21 22 24 28 30 33 38 40 41 45 48 51 54
vi
Contents
2.3.3.2 Spinodal decomposition Remarks on phase diagram determination and evaluation 2.4.1 Experimental determination of phase diagrams 2.4.1.1 Polythermal methods 2.4.1.2 Isothermal methods 2.4.1.3 Recent developments and prospects of X-ray powder diffraction methods 2.4.1.4 The diffusion couple technique in phase diagram determination 2.4.1.5 The characterization and 3D representation of materials microstructure 2.4.2 Assessment and calculation of phase diagrams 2.4.2.1 Assessment of phase diagrams 2.4.2.2 Calculation, thermodynamic optimization of phase diagrams References
2.4.
CHAPTER 3 Sructural characteristics of intermetallic phases 3.1. Preliminary remarks 3.2. Liquid intermetallic phases 3.2.1 Recent investigations on liquid alloys 3.3. Intermetallic compound chemistry in the solid state 3.4. Identification of the intermetallic (solid) phases 3.5. Composition and compositional formula of the intermetallic phase 3.5.1 Order of citation of element symbols in the formula 3.5.2 Indication of constituent proportions 3.6. Crystal structure of the solid phase and its standard representation 3.6.1 General remarks, unit cell description 3.6.1.1 Crystallographic nomenclature (Bravais lattices, crystal classes, space groups) 3.6.1.2 The unit cell content 3.6.1.3 Common crystal–chemical formulae. Unit cell volumes and interatomic distances 3.6.2 Shortened version of the standard description: structural types 3.6.3 Structure types and unit cell Pearson symbol 3.7. Alternative and complementary descriptions of the crystal structures of the solid phases 3.7.1 Lattice complexes
56 58 58 59 59 62 64 66 67 67 68 75
81 82 85 87 88 89 89 90 94 94 96 101 105 113 115 116 116
Contents
3.7.2 3.7.3
3.8.
3.9.
Alternative structural descriptions and symbols Coordination and dimensionality symbols in the crystal coordination formula 3.7.3.1 Coordination number and packing geometry 3.7.4 The concept of coordination number 3.7.5 Atomic environment definition (and symbols) and corresponding coordination numbers and polyhedra 3.7.6 Layer stacking sequence description and symbols 3.7.7 The cP4-AuCu3 type: an example of the use of alternative and complementary structural notations and symbols 3.7.8 Structure trivial names and Strukturbericht symbols Structure families: degenerate structures, derivative structures, ‘superstructures’ 3.8.1 Defect and filled-up derivative structures 3.8.1.1 Tetrahedral and octahedral holes in closepacked structures 3.8.2 Order–disorder transformation 3.8.3 Examples of substitutional superstructures 3.8.4 Examples of interstitial superstructures: Hägg phases 3.8.4.1 Interstitial hydrides 3.8.4.2 Interstitial carbides and nitrides 3.8.4.3 Hägg rules 3.8.4.4 Miscellaneous examples of interstitial superstructures 3.8.5 Remarks about a ‘second kind’ of superstructures Structure families: ‘recombination structures’, modular aspects of crystal structures 3.9.1 Modular aspects of crystal structures 3.9.2 Homeotect structure types, polytypic structures 3.9.2.1 Close-packed element structure types 3.9.2.2 Equiatomic tetrahedral structure types (Carborundum structure types) 3.9.2.3 Laves phases 3.9.2.4 A few general remarks about homeotect structures 3.9.3 Assembly of polyhedra 3.9.3.1 Tetrahedrally close-packed structures. Frank–Kasper structures 3.9.3.2 Structures based on frameworks of fused polyhedra: Samson phases 3.9.4 Recombination structures, intergrowth structure series
vii
121 122 125 126 130 136 145 150 151 155 156 158 160 162 162 164 165 166 167 168 168 170 171 171 171 172 173 174 184 185
viii
Contents
3.10. Group–subgroup relations between space groups for the representation of crystal–chemical relationships 3.11. Quasi-periodic crystals 3.11.1 Modulated structures 3.11.2 Composite crystals 3.11.2.1 Nowotny phases, chimney-ladder structures 3.11.2.2 Combination of commensurate and incommensurate periodic ‘substructures’ 3.11.3 Quasicrystals 3.11.3.1 Notes on the crystallography of quasiperiodic structures 3.11.3.2 Types of quasicrystals and examples of alloy systems showing their formation 3.11.3.3 Structural relations between quasicrystals and other intermetallic phases 3.12. Amorphous alloys, metallic glasses 3.12.1 Structure of metallic glasses 3.12.2 Examples of metallic systems with glass-forming capability References
CHAPTER 4 Intermetallic reactivity trends in the Periodic Table 4.1. Introduction 4.2. The Periodic Table and its structure 4.2.1 The Periodic Table and the electron configurations of the elements 4.2.1.1 Remarks about the structure of the Periodic Table 4.2.1.2 The electronic structure of the atoms 4.2.2 Blocks and subdivisions of the Periodic Table 4.2.2.1 ‘Blocks’ of the Periodic Table 4.2.2.2 Comments on some trends and on the ‘Divides’ in the Periodic Table 4.2.2.3 ‘Geochemical’ subdivision of the Periodic Table 4.2.2.4 Superconducting elements in the Periodic Table 4.2.2.5 ‘Technological’ subdivision of the Periodic Table 4.3. Trends in the Periodic Table: the role of the atomic dimensions as a factor controlling the structure of intermetallic phases
189 190 190 193 193 197 198 200 203 204 206 209 211 212
219 219 219 223 224 228 228 229 233 235 235 236
Contents
4.3.1 4.3.2
4.4.
Introduction Atomic dimensions, interatomic distances in the intermetallic phases 4.3.2.1 Atomic radii and volumes. (Pauling’s rule, Vegard’s and Biltz-Zen’s formulae) 4.3.2.2 Relationship between formV and formH for selected groups of alloys. Gschneidner’s formulae 4.3.2.3 Atomic dimensions and an example of stability multi-diagrams 4.3.2.4 Partial molar (atomic) volume 4.3.2.5 Geometrical considerations about intermetallic crystal structures Remarks on the chemical bond factor and valence-electron counting rules 4.4.1 Introduction 4.4.2 Normal valence compound rule 4.4.2.1 ‘Tetrahedral structures’ 4.4.2.2 Valence compounds: notes for a classification (VEC and partial VEC) 4.4.3 Polyanionic compounds 4.4.3.1 Zintl phases: an introduction 4.4.3.2 Zintl phases: remarks on their definition 4.4.4 ‘Cluster’ compounds 4.4.4.1 Cluster compounds: introductory remarks 4.4.4.2 Cluster compounds and remarks on the ‘2e, 2c bonding scheme’ 4.4.4.3 Wade electron counting rules: borane-like cluster nomenclature 4.4.4.4 Electron-precise, electron-deficient and electron-rich clusters 4.4.4.5 Interstitial atoms in clusters 4.4.4.6 Condensed and high nuclearity cluster compounds 4.4.4.7 From clusters towards solid state intermetallics 4.4.4.8 Problems in the relations between complex intermetallic alloys and clusters 4.4.4.9 Thermochemistry of cluster compounds
ix
236 238 238
243 244 251 254 262 262 263 264 265 267 267 269 271 271 273 275 278 278 279 281 291 293
x
Contents
4.4.5 4.4.6 4.4.7
‘Hume–Rothery phases’ and VEC VEC and stability multi-diagrams. Brewer diagrams New developments in electronic counting in intermetallic compounds 4.4.7.1 Stability maps and correlation diagrams
References
CHAPTER 5 Elements of alloying behaviour systematics 5.1. Introductory notes 5.1.1 Symbols and nomenclature 5.2. Alloys of hydrogen 5.2.1 Introduction 5.2.2 Intermetallic chemistry of hydrogen 5.2.2.1 Remarks on the systematics of hydrogen reactivity with the elements 5.2.2.2 Examples of phase diagrams of metal–hydrogen systems 5.2.2.3 Comments on the crystal structures of typical hydrogen–metal phases 5.2.2.4 Notes on the application of metal hydrides 5.3. Alloys of the alkali metals (1st group metals) (Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs, Fr) 5.3.1 Introduction 5.3.2 The alkali metals: a summary of their atomic and physical properties 5.3.3 The alkali metals: remarks about their general chemical properties and reactivity 5.3.4 Intermetallic chemistry of the alkali metals 5.3.4.1 Phase diagrams of alkali metal alloys 5.3.4.2 Melting point trend in the binary alkali metal alloys 5.3.4.3 Remarks on the crystal chemistry of the alkali metal alloys 5.3.4.4 A glance through complex intermetallic compounds of the alkali metals 5.4. Alloys of the alkaline earth metals and of the ‘divalent’ rare earth metals (Ca, Sr, Ba, Ra, Eu, Yb) 5.4.1 Introduction 5.4.2 The alkali earth metals and Eu and Yb: a summary of their atomic and physical properties
296 299 306 307 312
319 320 323 323 325 325 329 331 331 335 335 338 340 341 341 343 344 344 347 347 350
Contents
5.4.3
5.5.
5.6.
The alkali earth metals and Eu and Yb: remarks about their general chemical properties and reactivity 5.4.4 Intermetallic chemistry of the alkaline earth metals and of Eu and Yb 5.4.4.1 Phase diagrams of the alkaline earth metals and of Eu and Yb 5.4.4.2 Melting point trend in the binary alkaline earth metal alloys 5.4.4.3 Remarks on the crystal chemistry of the alloys of the alkaline earth metals and of Eu and Yb Alloys of the metals of the 3rd group of the Periodic Table (Sc, Y, La, Ln, Ac, An) 5.5.1 Introduction 5.5.2 Lanthanide and actinide concept, lanthanide contraction 5.5.3 Rare earth metals 5.5.3.1 Rare earth metals: occurrence and preparation 5.5.4 Actinides 5.5.4.1 Actinides: occurrence and preparation 5.5.5 The 3rd group metals: a summary of their atomic and physical properties 5.5.5.1 The rare earth metals 5.5.5.2 The actinides 5.5.6 The 3rd group metals: remarks about their general chemical properties and reactivity 5.5.6.1 The rare earth metals 5.5.6.2 The actinides 5.5.7 Intermetallic chemistry of the 3rd group metals 5.5.7.1 Phase diagrams of the 3rd group metals 5.5.7.2 Remarks on the stability of the binary alloys of the 3rd group metals (melting point and formation enthalpy trends) 5.5.7.3 Further remarks on the actinide alloys 5.5.7.4 Remarks on the crystal chemistry of the alloys of the 3rd group metals Alloys of the metals of the 4th group of the Periodic Table (Ti, Zr, Hf) 5.6.1 Introduction 5.6.2 The 4th group metals: a summary of their atomic and physical properties 5.6.3 The 4th group metals: remarks about their general chemical properties and reactivity
xi
350 351 351 352 353 356 356 357 359 361 362 365 366 366 370 370 370 376 377 377
383 387 390 393 393 394 395
xii
Contents
5.6.4
5.7.
5.8.
5.9.
Intermetallic chemistry of the 4th group metals 5.6.4.1 Phase diagrams of the 4th group metals 5.6.4.2 Melting point trend in the binary alloys of the 4th group metals 5.6.4.3 Remarks on the alloy crystal chemistry of the 4th group metals 5.6.4.4 Notes on the applications of the 4th group metals Alloys of the metals of the 5th group of the Periodic Table (V, Nb, Ta) 5.7.1 Introduction 5.7.2 The 5th group metals: a summary of their atomic and physical properties 5.7.3 The 5th group metals: remarks about their general chemical properties and reactivity 5.7.4 Intermetallic chemistry of the 5th group metals 5.7.4.1 Phase diagrams of the 5th group metals 5.7.4.2 Melting point trend in the binary alloys of the 5th group metals 5.7.4.3 Remarks on the alloy crystal chemistry of the 5th group metals Alloys of the metals of the 6th group of the Periodic Table (Cr, Mo, W) 5.8.1 Introduction 5.8.2 The 6th group metals: a summary of their atomic and physical properties 5.8.3 The 6th group metals: remarks about their general chemical properties and reactivity 5.8.4 Intermetallic chemistry of the 6th group metals 5.8.4.1 Phase diagrams of the 6th group metals 5.8.4.2 Remarks on the melting point trends in the binary alloys of the 6th group metals 5.8.4.3 Notes on the alloy crystal chemistry of the 6th group metals Alloys of the metals of the 7th group of the Periodic Table (Mn, Tc, Re) 5.9.1 Introduction 5.9.2 The 7th group metals: a summary of their atomic and physical properties 5.9.3 The 7th group metals: remarks about their general chemical properties and reactivity
396 396 398 400 402 404 404 406 406 407 407 408 409 413 413 415 417 417 417 417 418 421 421 423 423
Contents
5.9.4
Intermetallic chemistry of the 7th group metals 5.9.4.1 Phase diagrams of the 7th group metals 5.9.4.2 Remarks on the alloy crystal chemistry of the 7th group metals 5.10. Alloys of the metals of the 8th, 9th and 10th groups of the Periodic Table (Fe, Co, Ni, Ru, Os, Rh, Ir, Pd, Pt) 5.10.1 Introduction 5.10.1.1 Metals of the iron family 5.10.1.2 Metals of the platinum family 5.10.1.3 Platinum family metals preparation 5.10.2 The metals of the 8th, 9th and 10th groups: a summary of their atomic and physical properties 5.10.3 The metals of the 8th, 9th and 10th groups: remarks about their general chemical properties and reactivity 5.10.4 Intermetallic chemistry of the metals of the 8th, 9th and 10th groups: general remarks 5.10.4.1 Phase diagrams of the iron family metals 5.10.4.2 Phase diagrams of the platinum family metals 5.10.4.3 Remarks on the alloys crystal chemistry of the metals of the 8th, 9th and 10th groups 5.10.4.4 Notes on the application of the metals of the 8th, 9th and 10th groups and their alloys 5.10.4.5 Iron and steel: Steel production, the Fe–C phase diagram, TTT diagrams, martensite 5.11. Alloys of the metals of the 11th group of the Periodic Table (Cu, Ag, Au) 5.11.1 Introduction 5.11.2 The 11th group metals: a summary of their atomic and physical properties 5.11.3 The 11th group metals: remarks about their general chemical properties and reactivity 5.11.4 Intermetallic chemistry of the 11th group metals 5.11.4.1 Phase diagrams of the 11th group metals 5.11.4.2 Remarks on the alloy crystal chemistry of the 11th group metals 5.11.4.3 Notes on the applications of the alloys of the 11th group metals
xiii
425 425 425 429 429 429 430 431 432 432 435 439 439 439 448 450
457 457 459 460 460 460 464 466
xiv
Contents
5.12. Alloys of Be, Mg, Zn, Cd and Hg 5.12.1 Introduction 5.12.2 Be, Mg, Zn, Cd and Hg: a summary of their atomic and physical properties 5.12.3 Be, Mg, Zn, Cd and Hg: remarks about their general chemical properties and reactivity 5.12.4 Intermetallic chemistry of Be, Mg, Zn, Cd and Hg 5.12.4.1 Phase diagrams of the Be, Mg, Zn, Cd and Hg alloys 5.12.4.2 Remarks on the melting point trends in the binary alloys of Be, Mg and of the 12th group metals 5.12.4.3 Remarks on the crystal structures of selected alloys of Be, Mg and of the 12th group metals 5.12.4.4 Notes on the application of Be, Mg, Zn, Cd, and Hg alloys 5.12.4.5 Magnesium alloys: standard ASTM alloy designation 5.13. Alloys of the elements of the 13th group of the Periodic Table (B, Al, Ga, In, Tl) 5.13.1 Introduction 5.13.2 B, Al, Ga, In, Tl: a summary of their atomic and physical properties 5.13.3 The 13th group elements: remarks about their general chemical properties and reactivity 5.13.4 Intermetallic chemistry of the 13th group elements 5.13.4.1 Phase diagrams of the 13th group elements 5.13.4.2 Remarks on the crystal chemistry of the triel elements (Al, Ga, In, Tl) 5.13.4.3 Notes on the applications of aluminium alloys 5.13.4.4 Remarks on some commercial aluminium alloys 5.14. Alloys of the elements of the 14th group of the Periodic Table (C, Si, Ge, Sn, Pb) 5.14.1 Introduction 5.14.2 The 14th group elements: a summary of their atomic and physical properties 5.14.3 Intermetallic chemistry of the 14th group elements 5.14.3.1 Phase diagrams of the 14th group elements 5.14.3.2 Remarks on the alloy crystal chemistry of the 14th group elements
467 467 469 470 471 471
473 473 476 478 479 479 482 484 485 485 486 491 492 494 494 500 501 501 502
Contents
5.14.3.3 Notes on some peculiar applications of diamond 5.14.3.4 Joining processes: tin-containing soft solders 5.15. Alloys of the elements of the 15th group of the Periodic Table (N, P, As, Sb, Bi) 5.15.1 Introduction 5.15.2 The 15th group elements: a summary of their atomic and physical properties 5.15.3 Intermetallic chemistry of the 15th group elements 5.15.3.1 Phase diagrams of the 15th group elements 5.15.3.2 Notes on the crystal chemistry of selected alloys and compounds of the 15th group elements 5.16. Alloys of the elements of the 16th group of the Periodic Table (O, S, Se, Te, Po) 5.16.1 Introduction 5.16.2 The 16th group elements: a summary of their atomic and physical properties 5.16.3 Intermetallic chemistry of the 16th group elements 5.16.3.1 Phase diagrams of the 16th group elements 5.16.3.2 A few notes about simple binary compounds of the 16th group elements 5.17. General remarks on the systematics of the binary alloys of the metals 5.18. Complex alloys: a few notes and remarks about their systematics References
CHAPTER 6 Laboratory preparation of intermetallic phases 6.1. Introduction 6.2. Notes about procedures and instruments frequently used in an intermetallic chemical laboratory 6.2.1 Heating, thermal treatments 6.2.1.1 Laboratory furnaces 6.2.1.2 Crucibles, refractory materials 6.2.2 Miscellaneous, special processing techniques and heat treatments 6.2.2.1 Quenching (from the solid state) 6.2.2.2 Super-Quenching (quenching from the liquid) 6.2.2.3 Thixoforming, semi-solid processing 6.2.2.4 Temperature measurements 6.2.3 Laboratory equipment: a few additional remarks
xv
505 506 507 507 509 509 509 510 514 514 516 516 516 517 520 522 524
531 531 531 532 539 542 544 545 546 546 551
xvi
6.3.
6.4.
6.5.
Contents
Purity problems, the role of impurities 6.3.1 Introductory remarks 6.3.2 Formation of impurity-stabilized phases 6.3.3 Examples of preparation of high-purity materials 6.3.3.1 Silicon 6.3.3.2 Rare Earth metals 6.3.4 Effects of impurities on alloy properties and on the synthesis control 6.3.5 Effects of interstitial impurities on phase equilibria Direct synthesis of the intermetallic phases 6.4.1 Introduction 6.4.2 Melting (reaction in the liquid state) 6.4.2.1 Examples of reactions and synthesis by melting 6.4.3 High-temperature liquid intermetallic solution growth of single crystals and quasicrystals 6.4.4 Solid-state synthesis 6.4.4.1 Direct synthesis from component powders 6.4.4.2 Direct synthesis from the solid components by ‘mechanical alloying’ 6.4.4.3 Combustion synthesis 6.4.4.4 Field-activated, self-propagating, hightemperature synthesis 6.4.4.5 Co-reduction of mixed oxides 6.4.4.6 Fast, solid state, microwave-assisted, synthesis 6.4.4.7 ‘Extraction’ of a phase from a mixture Synthesis in solvents (under fluxes) 6.5.1 Synthesis of intermetallic phases in liquid sodium 6.5.2 Synthesis in mercury solution 6.5.3 Synthesis in liquid aluminium 6.5.3.1 Al as solvent: the synthesis of beryllides as an example 6.5.3.2 Synthesis in liquid Al: Al as a reactive solvent 6.5.4 Synthesis in liquid gallium (reactive solvent) 6.5.5 Synthesis in liquid indium 6.5.6 Synthesis in tin flux 6.5.7 Synthesis in lead flux 6.5.8 Single-crystal preparation and growth by NaCl/KCl flux reaction 6.5.9 Synthesis in alkali chalcogenide reactive flux 6.5.10 Synthesis in alkali poly-chalcogenide flux
552 552 553 553 553 554 556 560 560 560 561 563 565 566 566 567 569 573 573 573 574 575 577 577 578 578 578 579 579 580 580 581 581 581
Contents
6.5.11 Synthesis in liquid NH3 Reactions with the gas phase 6.6.1 Physical vapour deposition 6.6.2 Chemical vapour deposition 6.6.3 Vapour phase transport 6.6.4 Chemical transport reactions as a new variant of the phase composition control 6.6.5 Single-crystal preparation by means of chemical transport reactions. (Ni–Sn–S compounds as an example) 6.6.6 Synthesis of metastable Al and Ga monohalide solutions and subsequent preparation of large Al and Ga clusters 6.7. Synthesis of intermetallic phases by exchange reactions (metathesis reactions) 6.7.1 Metathesis (exchange) reactions 6.7.1.1 Solid-state metathesis reactions 6.7.1.2 Metathesis reactions in solution 6.7.2 Coupled reductions 6.7.2.1 Oxide coupled reduction with a metal and hydrogen 6.7.2.2 Preparation of ‘base’ metals by coupled reduction with platinum group metals 6.7.2.3 Oxide coupled reduction with boron and sulphur 6.8. Electrodeposition and electrolytic reduction (electrowinning) 6.8.1 Electrochemical reduction 6.8.2 Electrodeposition of alloys. Ag–Bi alloys as an example of electro co-deposition 6.8.3 Preparation of amalgams: electrochemical reduction on an Hg cathode 6.8.4 Preparation of transition metal compounds with non-metals by electrolytic reduction of fused salts 6.9. Special techniques 6.9.1 Sono-chemical techniques 6.9.2 Shock-induced and shock-assisted reactions in powder mixtures 6.9.3 Sputtering 6.9.4 Pulsed laser ablation deposition technique (PLAD technique) 6.10. Synthesis of nano-structured metals and alloys 6.10.1 Synthesis of nano-structured alloys by the inert gas evaporation technique
6.6.
xvii
582 582 582 583 584 585 585 586 586 587 587 589 589 589 590 590 591 591 591 592 592 593 593 594 594 595 595 597
xviii
Contents
6.10.2 Synthesis of nano-structured alloys via mechanical deformation 6.10.3 ‘Precursor’ preparation by solution chemistry 6.10.4 Synthesis of nano-structured alloys by chemical vapour deposition and chemical vapour condensation 6.10.5 Synthesis of nano-structured alloys from organometallics 6.10.6 ‘Nanowires’ 6.10.7 ‘Nano-structures’: comments on an example of extreme microstructure 6.11. Examples of preparation routes of groups of compounds with non-metals 6.11.1 Borides 6.11.1.1 Borothermic reduction of oxides enhanced by electron-beam bombardment 6.11.1.2 Borides from metallic fluxes 6.11.1.3 Application of carbo-thermal reduction 6.11.2 Carbides 6.11.3 Phosphides and polyphosphides 6.12. The synthesis of InAs: examples of alternative routes of preparation 6.12.1 Introduction 6.12.2 Preparation of InAs by direct synthesis from the elements 6.12.3 InAs equilibrium with the liquid 6.12.4 Synthesis of InAs (and III–V semiconductors) by solid-state metathesis 6.12.5 Synthesis of InAs by reaction of indium halides 6.12.6 Synthesis of InAs by hydrothermal route 6.12.7 Single source precursors in the synthesis of triels monopictides 6.12.8 The liquid-encapsulated Czochralski process and the growth of III–V crystals References CHAPTER 7 Families of intermetallic structure types: a selection 7.1. Introduction and statistical remarks 7.2. A prototype directory of selected intermetallic structures 7.2.1 On the schematic representations of crystal structures 7.2.1.1 Structure and structure component sections: the tI2-αPa, cI2-W, cF8-ZnS and tI8-NbAs types as examples
597 597 598 598 598 599 600 600 602 602 602 603 604 606 606 607 607 607 608 608 609 609 610
617 620 623
623
Contents
7.2.1.2
7.3.
7.4.
Structure and structure component projections: the cP1-Po, cI2-W and hP3-AlB2 type structures as examples 7.2.2 Examples of common structure types and of their characteristic fragments 7.2.3 Polyhedra projections Unary structures 7.3.1 General remarks 7.3.2 Metallic element structures 7.3.2.1 The close-packed element structure types (Mg, Cu, La, Sm types) and simple derivative types 7.3.2.2 The body-centred cubic W-type structure 7.3.2.3 Two body-centred tetragonal structures (In- and Pa-type structures) 7.3.2.4 Special structural types of selected metals 7.3.2.5 A few comments about uranium and plutonium elemental structures 7.3.3 A selection of non-metallic elemental structures 7.3.3.1 Boron: remarks on its crystal structure 7.3.3.2 The 8 – eat rule 7.3.3.3 Typical structures of elements of the 15th group (As, Sb, Bi) 7.3.3.3.1 As, hR6, structural type 7.3.3.4 Comments on other structures of 15th group elements 7.3.3.5 Typical structures of 16th group elements 7.3.3.6 Remarks on the structures of 17th group elements (I2) Binary structures: a selection of common prototypes 7.4.1 Preliminary remarks 7.4.2 Simple 1:1 prototypes and derivative structures 7.4.2.1 Introduction 7.4.2.2 cP2-CsCl, cF8-NaCl and cF16-NaTl types and NaTl-related structures 7.4.2.3 Simple binary tetrahedral structures and polytypes (ZnS-sphalerite, cF8-ZnS and ZnS-wurtzite, hP4-ZnO, structural types) 7.4.2.4 hP2-WC and hP4-NiAs types and examples of NiAs-derivative structures
xix
625 626 630 632 632 633
633 637 639 639 642 643 643 644 648 648 649 650 651 652 652 653 653 653
658 662
xx
Contents
7.4.2.5
7.4.3
7.4.4
oS8-CrB and oP8-FeB structure types (two triangular prism-based structures, similar in coordination) 7.4.2.6 AuCu(I), tP2, and AuCu(II), oI40, structural types (ordered derivatives in the Cu–Au system) 7.4.2.7 oS16-CeAl and oP16-DyAl structure types 7.4.2.8 FeSi, cP8, structural type 7.4.2.9 The tI8-NbAs type (and related structures) and the tI8-NbP type Remarks on structures of some 1:2 compounds 7.4.3.1 Introduction 7.4.3.2 CaF2 type (and its ordered AgMgAs-derivative structure) 7.4.3.3 Laves phases 7.4.3.4 tI6-CaC2 and MoSi2-type structures 7.4.3.5 oI12, CeCu2 and KHg2 structural descriptions (an exercise on isotypism and ‘normalization’ of crystal structure data) 7.4.3.6 Co2Si (PbCl2), oP12, and TiNiSi, oP12, structural types 7.4.3.7 CuAl2, tI12, structural type 7.4.3.8 Cu2Sb, tP6, structural type 7.4.3.9 Fe2P, hP9, structural type 7.4.3.10 TiSi2, oF24, structural type 7.4.3.11 UPt2, oS12, structural type 7.4.3.12 MoPt2, oI6, structural type 7.4.3.13 FeS2, cP12, structural type (pyrite) 7.4.3.14 The AlB2, hP3, type and its structural family 7.4.3.15 αThSi2, tI12, and LaPtSi, tI12, structural types 7.4.3.16 Rge2x (rare earth ‘digermanides’): an example of a family of compounds with structures related to the ‘coordination similar’ AlB2 and ThSi2 types Examples of structure types with a 1:3 stoichiometry 7.4.4.1 Introductory remarks 7.4.4.2 A polytypic structure family consisting of close-packed stacking of layers composed of triangular and kagomè nets (the hP8-Ni3Sn, cP4-AuCu3, hP16-TiNi3, hP24-VCo3, hP24-PuAl3 and hR36-BaPb3, types)
666 668 669 671 671 673 673 674 676 680
680 683 685 685 686 687 687 687 688 688 697
701 703 703
703
Contents
The βTiCu3, oP8, structural type (a Ni3Sn-type related structure) 7.4.4.4 The tP4-Ti3Cu, tI8-TiAl3 and tI16-ZrAl3 type structures: tetragonal derivatives of the cP4AuCu3 type 7.4.4.5 Cr3Si, cP8, structural type: an example of ‘tetrahedrally close-packed’ phases 7.4.4.6 Na3As, hP8, structural type (and the ‘bond factor’) 7.4.4.7 Fe3Co, P16, structural type A Selection of more common intermetallic prototypes having more complex stoichiometries and structures 7.5.1 Examples of protoypes corresponding to high stoichiometric ratios 7.5.1.1 Th6Mn23, cF116, structural type 7.5.1.2 Fe4N, cP5, structural type 7.5.1.3 BaAl4, tI10, structural type and BaAl4derivative types 7.5.1.4 MoNi4, tI10, structural type 7.5.1.5 CaCu5, hP6, structural type 7.5.1.6 CaB6, cP7 structural type (a cross-reference note) 7.5.1.7 Th2Ni17, hP38, structural type 7.5.1.8 Th2Zn17, hR57, structural type 7.5.1.9 BaHg11, cP36, structural type 7.5.1.10 ThMn12, tI26, structural type and ThMn12derivative types 7.5.1.11 NaZn13, cF112, structural type 7.5.1.12 Relationships among prototypes with high stoichiometric ratios 7.5.2 γ-brass: Cu5Zn8, cI52 structural type 7.5.3 Tetrahedrally close-packed phases, Frank–Kasper phases (cross-reference note) 7.5.3.1 Zr4Al3, hP7, structural type (a tetrahedrally close-packed phase) 7.5.3.2 σ Cr-Fe, tP30, structural type (a tetrahedrally closepacked phase) 7.5.3.3 W6Fe7, hR39, structural type (μ phase) (a tetrahedrally close-packed phase) 7.5.4 Samson phases (a cross-reference note) 7.5.5 Chevrel phases, structures containing Me6X8 clusters (cross-reference note)
xxi
7.4.4.3
7.5
708
709 711 712 713 714 714 714 715 715 721 721 723 723 724 725 726 727 728 728 729 729 730 731 731 731
xxii
Contents
7.5.6
A miscellany of stoichiometries and prototypes (short notes) 7.5.6.1 Selected structures corresponding to a binary 5:4 stoichiometry 7.5.6.2 Selected structures corresponding to a binary 5:3 stoichiometry 7.5.6.3 A selected structure corresponding to the binary 3:4 stoichiometry 7.6. Remarks about the crystal structures of a few oxygen compounds. Examples of oxides and minerals 7.6.1 Introduction 7.6.2 Ta4O, oP5, structural type 7.6.3 Al2O3, hR30, structural type (and derivative FeTiO3, ilmenite type) 7.6.4 TiO2, tP6, structural type (rutile) 7.6.5 ReO3, cP4, structural type 7.6.6 CaTiO3, cP5, structural type (perovskite) 7.6.7 BeAl2O4, oP28, structural type (chrysoberil) 7.6.8 Garnet, yttrium iron garnet, cI160, structural type 7.6.9 MgAl2O4, cF56, structural type (spinel) 7.6.10 Olivines References Appendix Index
731 732 734 737 738 738 738 738 739 741 742 743 744 745 747 748 751 757
Editorial Foreword The draft of this remarkable book reached me in the mid-December 2006. As I was reading through it, a message from Prof. Saccone informed me that Prof. Ferro had died suddenly and unexpectedly on 28 December. The two authors of the book, Prof. Ferro and Saccone, had been close scientific collaborators for many years. I first came to know them when, in the early 1990s, I was advised to invite them to contribute a chapter on intermetallic compounds to the fourth edition of my Physical Metallurgy, which duly appeared in 1996. Since then I have come to appreciate fully the remarkable team of solid-state chemists built up in Genoa by Prof. Ferro and Saccone. Their approach to the borderlands of crystal chemistry and metallurgy is unique and very impressive. This book, Intermetallic Chemistry, which has been several years in preparation, encapsulates their joint approach, and I regard its publication as a fitting memorial to a truly remarkable man. Robert W. Cahn (Series Editor) January 2007
On December 28, 2006 Professor Ferro suddenly died. After working for so many years under his direction, I feel indebted not only for his valuable scientific advice, but above all for the precious example he gave me through his dedication to science and teaching. Intermetallic compound chemistry, the subject matter of this book, is the focal point of Prof. Ferro’s scientific activity and the subject to which he has dedicated his professional life. Assisting Prof. Ferro in the preparation of this book has been for me a great honour. It is my hope that this book will be able to convey to the reader not only a systematic view of a complex matter, but also a feeling of the human touch given to it by Prof. Ferro. Adriana Saccone February 2007
Preface This book is an attempt to give an introductory account of the intermetallic chemistry of the elements for both undergraduate and graduate students. Intermetallic chemistry is strictly related to, or even a part of, both inorganic chemistry and solid-state physics. These subjects are dealt with and discussed in depth in a number of treatises. We have therefore decided to give pride of place to specific chemical phenomena and to the factual, experimental basis of our theme. We are not aware, indeed, of any other book especially dedicated to these subjects. The decision to write this book arose as a consequence of our being involved, since the beginning of our activity at the University of Genoa, in intermetallic chemistry both as researchers and teachers. In this university, indeed, for 70 years or so, several research groups have been studying and continue to study various aspects of alloy physical chemistry, creating an environment in which the handling of metals is natural and spontaneous, and for which we are very grateful to all the colleagues who made it possible. The founder of this line of activity was Aldo Iandelli, and we wish, on this occasion, to express our thanks to him for his teaching and for having introduced us to various aspects (preparative, structural, etc.) of alloy and phase diagram sciences. R.F. would also like to express his gratitude in memory of the late Ostwald Kubaschewski, who encouraged him to consider experimental thermodynamics in the investigation of alloys and helped to insert him in a broad European scientific community. We are very much indebted to the Series Editor, Robert W. Cahn, for his patience, continuous encouragement and precious suggestions. The responsibility for any errors in the book is naturally ours. However, the prestige and competence of R.W. Cahn have been an important point of reference and guidance. His scientific contributions to Materials and Intermetallics Science, his teaching and organizing ability have established an authoritative scientific activity in which we are very proud to be involved. Riccardo Ferro Adriana Saccone (Dipartimento di Chimica Università di Genova)
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 1
Introductory Survey
1.1. A PRESENTATION OF THE BOOK AND REMARKS ON ITS CONTENTS
Intermetallic science has a long and interesting history. Several interrelated topics can be considered within this subject, both from a basic viewpoint and with a view to their potential for future applications. These topics are closely connected with, or even part of, other disciplines such as physics, chemistry, metallurgy, materials science and technology, engineering. Emphasis will be given in this book to the chemical aspects of this science, that is to the mutual reactivity of the metals, and to the formation and characteristics of intermetallic compounds. Intermetallic chemistry is closely connected to the subject matter of inorganic chemistry: several groups of substances, for instance, may be conveniently presented in the systematic descriptive sections of both subjects. There are, however, several distinctive features which justify separate specific treatment. We just underline here a few characteristics of intermetallic chemistry which, we believe, are peculiar to the domain of descriptive chemistry and to which special chapters are dedicated in this book. In first place the relevance of the phase equilibria aspects in the description of the alloying behaviour of the elements (that is, of the mutual reactivity among metals) has to be underlined. It is typical indeed of many intermetallic systems to form several compounds (generally not obeying common simple stoichiometric rules), often homogeneous in a certain range of compositions. The stability and extension of these phases in terms of temperature and composition (that is their saturation limits or, in other words, their coexistence equilibria with other phases) are important points in their characterization and are given a convenient presentation and rational description through phase diagrams. The same diagrams are a useful tool in discussing preparation and purification methods (crystallization processes, solid-state synthesis, etc.). On the other hand, these phase diagrams are also a necessary reference point in the description of the conditions and processes which may result in the formation of alloys not in a true equilibrium state (metastable alloys, glassy (amorphous) alloys, quenching processes, etc.). A chapter about phase diagrams of alloy systems has therefore been included. It is not of course intended to fully discuss this subject and its theoretical basis and systematics: several chapters in various textbooks and specialized treatises are available on this matter. It is intended as a 1
2
Intermetallic Chemistry
presentation of the subject through a collection of examples and a presentation of some typical aspects of alloying behaviour mainly concerning the mutual reactivity of the metals involved. This behaviour may result in the formation of more or less extensive (terminal and/or intermediate) solid solutions, of stoichiometric intermetallic compounds, etc. An indication is given of the regularity that we notice when comparing the appearance of a specific phase diagram type with the position in the Periodic Table of the elements involved. A short description of some effects of transformation rate is included in the same chapter. Finally we draw attention to the fact that problems concerning phase diagram determination, assessment and thermodynamic optimization have a rapidly increasing relevance in several fields of materials science and especially in intermetallic chemistry. A few notes and references to these points conclude this chapter. Another characteristic point is the special attention that in intermetallic science, as in several fields of chemistry, needs to be dedicated to the structural aspects and to the description of the phases. The structure of intermetallic alloys in their different states, liquid, amorphous (glassy), quasi-crystalline and fully, three-dimensionally (3D) periodic crystalline are closely related to the different properties shown by these substances. Two chapters are therefore dedicated to selected aspects of intermetallic structural chemistry. Particular attention is dedicated to the solid state, in which a very large variety of properties and structures can be found. Solid intermetallic phases, generally non-molecular by nature, are characterized by their 3D crystal (or quasicrystal) structure. A great many crystal structures (often complex or very complex) have been elucidated, and intermetallic crystallochemistry is a fundamental topic of reference. A great number of papers have been published containing results obtained by powder and single crystal X-ray diffractometry and by neutron and electron diffraction methods. A characteristic nomenclature and several symbols and representations have been developed for the description, classification and identification of these phases. In one chapter (Chapter 3) general definitions are included, general structural characteristics of intermetallic phases are presented and some of their features discussed. Attention is given to nomenclature and to alternative and complementary methods of presenting crystal–chemical data, which could be especially useful in underlining peculiar structural features. Concepts such as coordination and linkage type and dimensionality of the structure (3D network, 2D layers or slabs, 1D fibres or individual molecules or atoms) are presented and discussed together with different criteria used in the description (analysis) of several groups of intermetallic structures. Examples are reported of structures described in terms of atomic layer stacking or of packing of atomic clusters or polyhedra or in terms of atomic environment types. It is also underlined that several intermetallic phases are known which have the same (or a similar) stoichiometry and crystallize in the same structure type,
Introductory Survey
3
which is generally named after the formula of the first representative identified: the ‘prototype’. A brief account, moreover, is given of such fundamental concepts such as derivative and degenerate structures (and superstructures), modular aspects of crystal structures (recombination structures) and a short description of a few special groups of alloys (quasicrystals, amorphous alloys). In another chapter concerning the intermetallic crystallochemistry (Chapter 7), a number of selected structural prototypes are described presenting some of their typical features and commenting on their distribution among different types of alloys. Attention is especially given to relationships between different prototype structures, and examples of their possible grouping in structural ‘families’ are underlined. This chapter, therefore, could possibly be used as a first draft of a gazetteer of intermetallic structure types and could be considered as an introduction (partial and provisional indeed!) to the descriptive systematics of intermetallic crystal chemistry. Another chapter (Chapter 4) is entitled ‘Intermetallic reactivity trends in the Periodic Table’. The Periodic Table, indeed (or Periodic Law or Periodic System of Chemical Elements), is acknowledged to play an indispensable role in several different sciences. Especially in inorganic chemistry it represents a fundamental classificatory scheme and a means of systematizing data with a clear predictive power. Inorganic chemists have traditionally made considerable use of the Periodic Table to understand the chemistry of the different elements. With a few exceptions (as detailed in the same chapter), metallurgists and intermetallic chemists have made little use of this Table to understand and describe the properties of metals and alloys: we believe, however, that it may be a useful tool also in the systematics of descriptive intermetallic chemistry (as exemplified in the subsequent chapter (Chapter 5)). In several paragraphs of Chapter 4, therefore, different aspects of the Periodic Table and of its characteristic trends are summarized. Attention is especially given to a few selected elemental parameters (and to their changes along the Table) which may act as reference factors in the definition and classification of the intermetallic behaviour, that is in the determination of phase structures, phase equilibria, etc. in the various alloys. To illustrate these points a number of graphs, ‘stability maps’ and ‘correlation diagrams’ have been used. Parameters such as ‘atomic dimension’ or ‘electronegativity’ have been considered. Especially relevant parameters, however, strictly related to the structure and layout of the Periodic Table are represented by electron configuration, valence electron number, group number, etc. of the different elements. Some attention is consequently given to these concepts. As an example the relationships between crystal structure and the number of valence electrons per atom (or per formula) in various classes of compounds (or solid solution phases) observed by Hume-Rothery, Brewer, Parthé, Zintl, Mingos, Hoffmann are considered. These rules, which may also serve as an introduction to a theoretical treatment of bonding, represent one of the criteria used in the
4
Intermetallic Chemistry
description and classification of some ‘families’ of intermetallic compounds. It will often be noticed, however, that in a certain family several compounds may be grouped, having for instance similar crystallographic features, but showing different properties and bonding mechanisms (we could say with different ‘percentages’ of a metallic or ionic–covalent character). A connection therefore between intermetallic chemistry and other sections of inorganic chemistry becomes evident. To this end the particular role played by the Zintl phases and ‘cluster’ chemistry is underlined. The alloying behaviour systematics of intermetallic systems is then discussed in a special chapter (Chapter 5), presenting a description of the intermetallic reactivity of each element, or group of elements, in the order of their position in the Periodic Table. It was not possible, of course, to give a complete treatment for all the elements; some particular aspects have therefore been selected together with information about general trends. An aspect of the alloying behaviour which may be considered relevant for each pair of metallic elements is their capability to form intermediate phases (intermetallic compounds); schemes (maps) giving summaries of this capability have been prepared for different elements and collected in Chapter 5. The trends of these maps, observed on passing through the different families of metals, and of similar diagrams concerning the mutual solubility in the liquid and solid states have been discussed. Owing to the complexity of an in-depth description of the intermetallic chemistry of all the groups of elements, generally only the simplest combinations (the binary ones) have been described in some detail. Nevertheless, without any claim to completeness, a few indications have also been presented about some families of more complex alloys (ternary or multi-component systems and compounds). These are especially intended to give at least a rough idea of the richness and variety of a disciplinary approach by no means as yet fully investigated and exploited. In the same chapter (Chapter 5), as an introduction to the paragraphs dedicated to the various groups of metals, the values relevant to a number of elementary properties have been collected. These are atomic properties (such as metallic and ionic radii, ionization energies, electronegativities, Mendeleev number, chemical scale, Miedema parameters, etc.), crystal structure and lattice parameters data of the allotropes of the elements, and selected thermodynamic data (melting and boiling temperatures and enthalpies, etc.). All these data indeed represent reference values in the discussion of the alloying behaviour of the elements. A chapter dedicated to the laboratory (small scale) preparation methods of intermetallics has then been included (Chapter 6). In the preparation of intermetallic phases, indeed (or, more generally, of alloys), in comparison to other chemical compounds a number of interesting and significant peculiarities are pointed out, for instance, those related to their high melting points, insolubility in many common solvents, etc. The presentation of selected examples of preparative methods, therefore,
Introductory Survey
5
can be useful for discussing some general points on the reactivity and chemical properties of metals and alloys. In a number of cases special references must be made to the phase diagram characteristics of the alloys involved and to considerations based on kinetic principles. Examples of the effects of different heat treatments are considered and mention is made of the preparation of metastable alloys, glassy alloys, etc. As a conclusion to this introductory survey we underline a few points which are probably already clear for the reader. Intermetallic science includes so many topics and is related to so many fundamental and applied problems that a different content selection and sequence could be easily envisaged for a book on this subject. We hope that the reader, who of course is forced to accept the book structure we adopted, will be at least partially helped by the lists of general cross-references and reading suggestions that we have inserted.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 2
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
2.1. PRELIMINARY REMARKS
In the field of inorganic chemistry an important group of substances and transformations is represented by the intermetallic compounds (or phases) and by the reactions among metallic elements. As for many other materials, phase diagrams are roadmaps not only for the description of these substances and of their reactions, but also for their processing and for research and development planning. The systematic experimental determination of phase diagrams, their assessment and compilation and their thermodynamic optimization and calculation are the essential steps in the development of materials science and make up one of the bases of the intermetallic disciplines. A few general and introductory remarks about these topics will follow, discussing the aspects of typical (binary and more complex) phase diagrams. As pointed out for instance by Pelton (1991), many thermodynamic variables may be used and plotted on phase diagrams to show equilibrium states: on this basis he presented and discussed general rules for classifying phase diagrams. It is well known that in material science and metallurgy the diagrams based on plots of temperature vs. composition (T vs. x) are commonly used. By using these diagrams it is possible to summarize and explain many aspects of the alloying behaviour of mixtures of two, three or more metals. A short collection of (T/x) phase diagrams of binary intermetallic systems, generally taken from the well-known Massalski et al. (1990) and Okamoto (2000) compilations, will be described here in order to present the types of mutual reactivity in such systems. Characteristic types of phase diagrams will be discussed and a preliminary indication will be given of their occurrence in the alloys of different metal groups. On this basis it will be feasible to establish a starting point for a possible classification of the different alloys. In particular, mainly by using special maps (Pettifor maps), a summary will be given of the diagram types formed by the different pairs of metals. Of course it will be impossible, in a few pages, to give a complete description of phase diagram science, and only an outline of some noteworthy aspects will be presented. Notice that the phase diagrams presented first are equilibrium diagrams. These represent an important reference point and describe the final state (stable state) which can be reached in a reaction of the substances involved. Slow (or very 7
8
Intermetallic Chemistry
slow) establishment of the equilibrium state can however be observed in several circumstances, resulting often in non-equilibrium phase transformations and also giving rise to real diagrams showing deviations from the equilibrium diagrams (see § 2.3.3). 2.2. SOME CHARACTERISTIC, T VS. x, BINARY PHASE DIAGRAMS
The diagrams that will be mainly considered are those concerning the behaviour of the alloys in the liquid and solid states; that is, melting and solid-state transformation diagrams. A number of different diagram types can be defined and classified on the basis of the different mutual solubility of the components (in the liquid and in the solid state with the formation of more or less extended liquid and/or solid solutions) and of their reactivity, resulting in the formation of various, so-called ‘intermediate phases’. 2.2.1 Mutual solid solubility of the component metals in alloy systems The systems V–Mo and Cs–Rb presented in Fig. 2.1 are a first example of phase diagrams. The first system concerns refractory (high melting) alloys, the second one very low melting (close to room temperature) alloys. However, both diagrams are representative of the melting behaviour of binary systems in which the two components are mutually and completely (in all proportions) soluble with each other in the liquid and in the solid state. The composition/temperature field is subdivided into three regions, as for instance in Fig. 2.1(a), at low temperature there is a single phase field (S) where all the temperature and composition values are collected for which only one solid phase is stable (a continuous solid solution field between Mo and V). In a similar way, another single-phase field (L) exists at high temperature: the two components show, indeed, a mutual complete solubility in the liquid state also. For intermediate temperatures there is a third region corresponding to a twophase field (coexistence of the solid and liquid phases): this defines for each composition the temperature range in which one phase transforms into the other. A similar aspect (complete solubility both in the liquid and in the solid state) is shown by the system Cs–Rb, for which however, owing to a larger deviation from the ‘ideal solution’ behaviour, a different trend of the melting temperatures can be noticed (see Fig. 2.1(b): in this case the melting temperatures decrease down to a minimum by adding one component to the other). Also in this case, at higher temperatures, a continuous single-phase field is present from one component to the other, corresponding to the liquid phase, as well as complete solid solubility at
9
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems (b) 2623
Temperature (°C)
Temperature (°C)
(a)
2500 L 2300 S
2100 1910
20
40
60
40 L
28.39 20
S
10
80
V
39.48
20 Mo
40
60
Cs
80 Rb
at.%
at.%
Temperature (°C)
(c) 842
L
769 700
β
547 443
400 300
α 20
40
60
Sr
80 Ca
at.%
Figure 2.1. Examples of melting phase diagrams of binary systems showing complete mutual solubility in the solid and in the liquid states (L liquid field, S solid field). The melting behaviour of the Mo–V, Cs–Rb and Ca–Sr alloys is presented. Notice the different ranges of temperature involved. The melting points of the pure metal components are shown on the corresponding vertical axes. The Cs–Rb is an example of a system showing a minimum in the melting temperature. In the Sr–Ca system complete mutual solid solubility is shown in both the allotropic forms α and β of the two metals.
lower temperatures. For intermediate temperatures, depending on the concentration, the two-phase region of coexistence (transformation) of the two phases (melting of the alloys) can be seen. Notice that according to a commonly employed nomenclature, the curve limiting the liquid field is called the liquidus. Similarly the other curve is called the solidus. Fig. 2.1(c) shows a similar, but slightly more complex diagram. It is the diagram of the alloys formed by Ca and Sr: these metals are completely soluble in the liquid state and crystallize in a solid phase forming a solution in the complete range of compositions. These two elements, however, besides being mutually completely soluble in their high-temperature forms (βCa and βSr), dissolve together completely in their low-temperature modifications also (see the structural data of the
10
Intermetallic Chemistry
elements in Chapter 5). In the diagram, therefore, we have in this case the region corresponding to the continuous liquid solution and two regions corresponding to the two solid, α and β, solutions. Between the mentioned single-phase fields, the two two-phase fields (very narrow in this case) correspond to the liquid–solid (β) equilibrium and, respectively, to the solid-state α–β transformation. 2.2.1.1 Mutual solid-state solubility: a simple structural representation – order/ disorder. In a number of systems such as the previously described V–Mo and Cs–Rb, continuous solid solutions are formed in the whole range of compositions, characteristics and structures of which will be discussed in more detail in Chapter 3. These result from two metals having the same crystal structure, which is maintained for all the intermediate compositions, due to a continuous random substitution of the atoms of one kind for another and vice versa. Fig. 2.2 gives a schematic two-dimensional (2D) representation of this random substitution. In Fig. 2.2(a) and (b) two ‘substances’ are presented, formed by white and black atoms, having however the same structure (the same arrangement of the atoms). In Fig 2.2(c) and (d) the same structure, in which, however about 20% and 50% respectively of white atoms have been replaced by black ones, can be seen. An equivalent representation is given in Fig. 2.2(e) and (f) in which the random distribution of the two species in all the positions is simulated by the intensity of the
(a)
(c)
(e)
(b)
(d)
(f)
Figure 2.2. 2D models of crystalline metals.
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
11
colour (intermediate between those of the pure elements) assigned to the ‘atoms’. All the discs are equivalent: each one corresponds to the same probability (20%, 50%, etc.) of being black or white. This random distribution can be related to the possibility of gradually changing the overall composition while maintaining the same structure. Therefore, in this case, it is possible to find a continuous solid solution, ranging from 0% to 100% B (in all the intermediate alloys there is equivalence of all the atomic sites whose average occupation gradually changes from pure A to pure B). This generally corresponds to the fact that both A and B have the same crystal structure, which is maintained along the complete composition range, and similar values of the atomic radii (for instance 134.6 and 140.0 pm in the specific case of V and Mo, both bodycentred cubic) and of the Mendeleev number (54 for V, 56 for Mo), etc., so that they can play a similar role inside the structure and substitute each other. The simple structural models built by collections of discs can also be useful for the description of other frequently found behaviour: Fig. 2.3(a) and (b) present cases in which we still have substitution of the two atoms but in an ordered way, causing in Fig. 2.3(a) the formation of atomic ‘clusters’ and in Fig. 2.3(b) the formation of a new substance (a ‘solid compound’) of a well-defined composition and not of a phase field having a continuously changing composition. In Fig. 2.4, finally, different types of solid solutions (and intermediate phases) are modelled. The solid, metallic, structure of an element A is simulated in Fig. 2.4(a), while the molecular (diatomic) structure of a non-metal B in the gas phase is given in Fig. 2.4(b). The interstitial (ordered and disordered) introduction of the small atoms B in the interstices of the structure of element A is indicated in Fig. 2.4(c) and (d). 2.2.1.2 Trends in mutual solid solubility. On the basis of the similarities generally shown by the elements involved in the formation of continuous (substitutional) (a)
(b)
Figure 2.3. Schemes of ordered substitutions. (a) Model of cluster formation. (b) Ordered distribution of the two types of atoms.
12
Intermetallic Chemistry (a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
Figure 2.4. Interstitial formation of a solid phase. The dissolution in the interstices of the structures of the metal (a) of the atoms of the gas (b) gives a solid solution (c) or an ordered phase (d).
solid solutions, it is possible to identify the element pairs which form phase diagrams such as those shown in Fig. 2.1. The map shown in Fig. 2.8, where the elements are ordered according to their ‘Mendeleev number’, summarizes this behaviour by means of codes. All the element pairs forming simple phase diagrams are represented by square boxes. Emphasis has been given in this map to the metal combinations showing complete mutual solid solubility (black boxes). Notice that these pairs crowd around the diagonal line where elements, having similar element parameter values, combine with each other. For the meaning of the Mendeleev number, see § 2.2.1.3. 2.2.1.3 Electronegativity, Mendeleev number, Miedema parameters. A few semi-empirical ‘parameters’ and ‘scales’ which are useful as reference data in the systematic description (or even prediction) of the alloying behaviour of the different metals will be presented here also as an introduction to the following paragraphs. The closely related basic concepts of chemical periodicity and electron configurations will be reminded in Chapter 4. Electronegativity and the so-called Mendeleev number are two parameters, basically empirical at least in their initial definitions, which, however, proved to be very
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
13
useful for simple classifications of the chemical behaviour of the elements, for a preliminary evaluation of bond energies, etc. The definition of electronegativity dates back to 1932 to an analysis carried out by Pauling of the energies of covalent–ionic bonds. More recent was the proposal by Pettifor (1984) of the introduction of a ‘chemical scale’ of the elements based on a new parameter, the Mendeleev number, which is useful, mainly in intermetallic chemistry, in the systematic description of the structures of compounds and of the types of phase diagrams adopted by the different metals. The Miedema’s parameters and the Miedema model and formula proved to be useful in an approximate evaluation of the formation enthalpy of alloys, in the estimate of the formation capability of intermetallic compounds, etc. 2.2.1.3.1 Electronegativity. Electronegativity was first defined by Pauling (1932) who also suggested a method for its determination. In the words of Pauling himself (Pauling 1967) it may be pointed out that the values of the difference Δ between the energy D(A–B) of the bond between two atoms A and B and the energy expected for a normal covalent bond, assumed to be the arithmetic mean of the bond energies D(A–A) and D(B–B) increases as the two atoms A and B become more and more unlike with respect to the qualitative property that chemists call electronegativity, the power of an atom in a molecule to attract electrons to itself. Thus Δ increases rapidly in the sequence HI, HBr, HCl, HF in which the halogen changes from iodine, which is recognized by its general chemical properties to be only a little more electronegative than hydrogen, to fluorine, the most electronegative of all the elements. Pauling found that the bond energy, in kcal/mol, for a bond A–B is given approximately by the equation: Δ D(A–B) 1⁄2 [D(A–A) (B–B)] 23(ηA ηB)2 (It would be 96.49 (ηA ηB)2 in kJ/mol) In this equation ηA and ηB are values of electronegativity assigned to atoms A and B. In the original formulation of the electronegativity scale, the electron volt was used as the unit of energy: this use accounts for the approximate factor 23 in the equation. (1 eV 1.60217653(14) 1019 J, Avogadro number 6.0221415(10) 1023 mol1). On the basis of this equation, systematically considering all the available thermochemical data and arbitrarily assigning to the most electronegative element, fluorine, a value of about 4, Pauling was able to prepare a complete electronegativity scale. This is shown in Table 2.1. Several definitions of electronegativity have since been proposed and various methods for its evaluation suggested. A reliable compilation extensively used in discussing metallurgical behaviour is that by Teatum et al. (1968).
14
Intermetallic Chemistry
Table 2.1. The electronegative scale as reported by Pauling (1967). H 2.1 Li Be 1.0 1.5
B 2.0
C 2.5
N O 3.0 3.5
F 4.0
Na Mg Al 0.9 1.2 1.5
Si 1.8
P S 2.1 2.5
Cl 3.0
K Ca 0.8 1.0
Sc 1.3
Ti V Cr 1.4 1.6 1.6
Mn 1.5
Fe Co 1.8 1.8
Ni Cu Zn Ga Ge 1.8 1.9 1.6 1.6 1.8
As Se 2.0 2.4
Br 2.8
Rb Sr 0.8 1.0
Y 1.2
Zr Nb Mo Tc 1.4 1.6 1.8 1.9
Ru Rh 2.2 2.2
Pd Ag Cd In Sn 2.2 1.9 1.7 1.7 1.8
Sb Te 1.9 2.1
I 2.5
Cs Ba 0.7 0.9
La–Lu Hf Ta W 1.1–1.2 1.3 1.5 1.7
Re 1.9
Os Ir 2.2 2.2
Pt Au Hg Tl Pb 2.2 2.4 1.9 1.8 1.8
Bi Po 1.9 2.0
At 2.2
Fr Ra 0.7 0.9
Ac 1.1
Np–No 1.3
Th Pa U 1.3 1.5 1.7
2.2.1.3.2 The Mendeleev number and a ‘scale’ for ordering the chemical behaviour of the elements. In order to stress the chemical character of the elements and to simplify the description of their behaviour, Pettifor (1984, 1985, 1986) created a new chemical scale (χ) which orders the elements along a simple axis. The progressive order number of the elements in this scale (the so-called Mendeleev number) may also be considered. The Mendeleev numbers M (which, of course, are different from the atomic numbers) start, according to Pettifor, with the least electronegative elements He 1, Ne 2, … and end with the most electronegative ones … N 100, O 101, F 102 up to H 103. The Mendeleev number (M) and the correlated ‘chemical scale χ’ are shown in Table 2.2. The chemical meaning of these parameters may be deduced not only by their relation to the Periodic Table. By using them, in fact, excellent separation of similar structures is achieved for numerous AmBn phases with a given stoichiometry within single 2D MA/MB maps (see Fig. 2.5). The same parameters are also very useful for a systematic presentation of some general trends in the alloying behaviour (see the maps shown in Figs. 2.8, 2.22 and 2.23). Notice, however, that in more recent papers, on the basis of a progressive improvement of the structure maps, slightly different versions of the chemical scale were reported without however any substantial modification to its meaning and application. On the basis of the Pettifor scale, the suggestion has also been made that in the formulae of the compounds the element E with a lower value ME (or χE) is quoted first. This will generally be adopted here (see § 3.5).
15
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems Table 2.2. Chemical order of the elements, according to Pettifor (1986). (a) Mendeleev number of the elements arranged in alphabetical order Ac 48 Ag 71 Al 80 Am 42 Ar 3 As 89 At 96 Au 70 B 86 Ba 14 Be 77 Bi 87
Bk 40 Br 98 C 95 Ca 16 Cd 75 Ce 32 Cf 39 Cl 99 Cm 41 Co 64 Cr 57 Cs 8
Cu 72 Dy 24 Er 22 Es 38 Eu 18 F 102 Fe 61 Fm 37 Fr 7 Ga 81 Gd 27 Ge 84
H 103 He 1 Hf 50 Hg 74 Ho 23 I 97 In 79 Ir 66 K 10 Kr 4 La 33 Li 12
Lr 34 Lu 20 Md 36 Mg 73 Mn 60 Mo 56 N 100 Na 11 Nb 53 Nd 30 Ne 2 Ni 67
No 35 Np 44 O 101 Os 63 P 90 Pa 46 Pb 82 Pd 69 Pm 29 Po 91 Pr 31 Pt 68
Pu 43 Ra 13 Rb 9 Re 58 Rh 65 Rn 6 Ru 62 S 94 Sb 88 Sc 19 Se 93 Si 85
Sm 28 Sn 83 Sr 15 Ta 52 Tb 26 Tc 59 Te 92 Th 47 Ti 51 Tl 78 Tm 21 U 45
V 54 W 55 Xe 5 Y 25 Yb 17 Zn 76 Zr 49
(b) The elements (El) arranged in the Mendeleev number (M) order and related chemical scale χ M
El
χ
M
El
χ
M
El
χ
M
El
χ
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
He Ne Ar Kr Xe Rn Fr Cs Rb K Na Li Ra Ba Sr Ca Yb Eu Sc Lu Tm Er Ho Dy Y Tb
0.00 0.04 0.08 0.12 0.16 0.20 0.23 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 0.48 0.50 0.55 0.60 0.645 0.655 0.66 0.67 0.675 0.6775 0.68 0.6825 0.685 0.6875
27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52
Gd Sm Pm Nd Pr Ce La Lw No Md Fm Es Cf Bk Cm Am Pu Np U Pa Th Ac Zr Hf Ti Ta
0.69 0.6925 0.695 0.6975 0.70 0.7025 0.705 0.7075 0.71 0.725 0.715 0.7175 0.72 0.7225 0.725 0.7275 0.73 0.7325 0.735 0.7375 0.74 0.7425 0.76 0.775 0.79 0.82
53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78
Nb V W Mo Cr Re Tc Mn Fe Ru Os Co Rh Ir Ni Pt Pd Au Ag Cu Mg Hg Cd Zn Be Tl
0.83 0.84 0.88 0.885 0.89 0.935 0.94 0.945 0.99 0.995 1.00 1.04 1.05 1.06 1.09 1.105 1.12 1.16 1.18 1.20 1.28 1.32 1.36 1.44 1.50 1.56
79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103
In Al Ga Pb Sn Ge Si B Bi Sb As P Po Te Se S C At I Br Cl N O F H
1.60 1.66 1.68 1.80 1.84 1.90 1.94 2.00 2.04 2.08 2.16 2.18 2.28 2.32 2.40 2.44 2.50 2.52 2.56 2.64 2.70 3.00 3.50 4.00 5.00
16
Intermetallic Chemistry
Figure 2.5. Simplified version of Pettifor’s map for AB compounds. The component elements are arranged along the axes according to their Mendeleev number (M). As an example, the existence regions of the NaCl, CsCl and cubic ZnS type phases are evidenced.
2.2.1.3.3 Miedema’s model and parameters and ‘prediction’ of compound formation capability. A semi-empirical approach to the evaluation of the compound formation capability and of the heats of formation of alloys was proposed by Miedema and co-workers. This resulted in a model which became very popular and, especially because there was scarcity of experimental data, was frequently used in the evaluation, even if approximate and several times incorrect, of the formation enthalpies. The model suggested for energy effects in alloys is well known: essentially it is based on the definition of two parameters. By assigning two coordinates
17
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems 7
Work function of the elements
6
5
4
3
2 Non-transition element Transition element 1 0
1
2
3
Electronegativity (Pauling scale)
Figure 2.6. The approximate linear relationship between Φ* (Miedema 1973) and the electronegativity η (Pauling scale) as illustrated by de Boer et al. (1988).
(ϕ and nWS, to be defined below) to each transition element it was possible to build a map in which a clear separation was observed between all those binary alloys with positive heats of formation and those with negative values (Miedema 1973). Successive steps in the formulation of the model have been described, for instance, by Niessen et al. (1983) and by de Boer et al. (1988). The enthalpy of formation of solid and liquid binary alloys was described as proportional to the expression: f [P(ΔΦ*)2 Q(ΔnWS1/3 ) 2 R] where f is a concentration (and molar volumes) dependent function, ΔΦ* Φ*A Φ *B where Φ*i is the work function of each element, closely related to its electronegativity (see Fig. 2.6) (the values initially tabulated by Miedema, however, have been slightly readjusted by amounts comparable to the experimental uncertainty of work function values), nWS is the electron density at the boundary of the Wigner–Seitz cell for each element. P, Q and R are constants for specific groups of elements (their values are related to the position in the Periodic Table of the
Table 2.3. Miedema model. The values of the model parameters Φ*, nws1/3 and V 2/3. H 5.20 1.50 1.42 Li 2.85 0.98 5.53
El Φ* n ws1/3 V 2/3
Be 5.05 1.67 2.88
Na 2.70 Mg 3.45 0.82 1.17 8.27 5.81 K 2.25 0.65 12.77
Ca 2.55 0.91 8.82
Al 4.20 1.39 4.64
Si 4.70 1.50 4.20
P 5.55 1.65 4.15
S
Ga 4.10 Ge 4.55 1.31 1.37 5.19 4.60
As 4.80 1.44 5.20
Se
Cr 4.65 1.73 3.74
Rb 2.10 Sr 2.40 0.60 0.84 14.65 10.48
Y 3.20 1.21 7.34
Zr 3.45 1.41 5.81
Nb 4.05 1.64 4.89
Mo 4.65 Tc 5.30 1.77 1.81 4.45 4.21
Ru 5.40 Rh 5.40 Pd 5.45 1.83 1.76 1.67 4.06 4.10 4.29
Ag 4.35 Cd 4.05 1.36 1.24 4.72 5.53
In 3.90 1.17 6.28
Sn 4.15 1.24 6.43
Sb 4.40 1.26 6.60
Te
Cs 1.95 0.55 16.86
La 3.17 1.18 7.98
Hf 3.60 1.45 5.65
Ta 4.05 1.63 4.89
W 4.80 1.81 4.50
Os 5.40 Ir 5.55 1.85 1.83 4.15 4.17
Au 5.15 Hg 4.20 1.57 1.24 4.70 5.83
Tl 3.90 1.12 6.67
Pb 4.10 1.15 6.94
Bi 4.15 1.16 7.20
Po
Ce3 3.18 Pr 3.19 Nd 3.19 Pm 3.19 Sm 3.20 1.19 1.20 1.20 1.21 1.21 7.76 7.56 7.51 7.43 7.37 Th 3.30 1.28 7.32
Pa 3.60
U 3.90 Np 3.85 Pu 3.80 1.51 1.44 5.57 5.26
Zn 4.10 1.32 4.38
O
V 4.25 1.64 4.12
Pt 5.65 1.78 4.36
Cu 4.45 1.47 3.70
N 6.86 1.65 2.56
Ti 3.80 1.52 4.82
Re 5.20 1.85 4.28
Co 5.10 Ni 5.20 1.75 1.75 3.55 3.52
C 6.24 1.77 2.20
Sc 3.25 1.27 6.09
Ba 2.32 0.81 11.32
Mn 4.45 Fe 4.93 1.61 1.77 3.78 3.69
B 5.30 1.75 2.80
Eu3 3.20 Gd 3.20 Tb 3.21 Dy 3.21 Ho 3.22 Er 3.22 1.21 1.21 1.22 1.22 1.22 1.23 7.36 7.34 7.20 7.12 7.06 6.98
Tm 3.22 Yb3 3.22 Lu 3.22 1.23 1.23 1.24 6.90 6.86 6.81
Ce4 3.25 1.34 6.36
Eu2 2.50 0.88 9.43
Yb2 2.58 0.92 8.52
19
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems Average number of intermediate phases ΔH 75 75 ΔH 40 40 ΔH 20 20 ΔH 10 10 ΔH 4 4 ΔH 0 0 ΔH 5 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Figure 2.7. The relation, suggested by de Boer et al. (1988), between the average number of stable intermediate phases in a binary system and the formation enthalpy predicted for the equiatomic composition.
elements involved). In the same model (Miedema and Niessen 1982) the volume variation during the formation of the intermetallic compound is evaluated as proportional to (ΔΦ*)[(Δ(nWS)1]). Miedema’s parameters are collected in Table 2.3. The existence of an approximate relation between the average number of stable intermediate phases in a binary system and the calculated extreme values of the enthalpies of formation was also suggested (see Fig. 2.7). Although the way to predict formation enthalpies of alloys was introduced as an empirical one and several discrepancies may be noticed between calculated and measured values, it is important to observe that the model incorporates basic physics. A quantum-mechanical interpretation of Miedema’s parameters has already been proposed by Chelikowsky and Phillips (1978). Extensions of the model to complex alloy systems have been considered. As an interesting application we may mention the discussion on the stabilities of ternary compounds presented by de Boer et al. (1988). In the case of the Heusler-type alloys XY2Z, for instance, the stability conditions with respect to mechanical mixtures of the same nominal composition (XY2Z, XY2Z, XYYZ, etc.) have been systematically examined and presented by means of diagrams. The Miedema’s parameters, ΔΦ*, Δn WS1/3, moreover, have been used as variables for the construction of structural maps of intermetallic phases (Zunger 1981, Rajasekharan and Girgis 1983). According to Rajasekharan and Girgis on a ΔΦ*, Δn WS1/3 map, considerable resolution is obtained among the binary systems in which different structure types occur. The points corresponding to the systems in which the Laves phases (or the phases of types such as Cr3Si, TiAl3, etc.) occur show linear relationships on the
20
Intermetallic Chemistry
Figure 2.8. A map presenting the mutual solubility in the solid state of the different metals. A selection of the elements is ordered along the two axes according to their values of the Mendeleev number. Each square box identifies a metal pair. The meaning of the codes inserted in the boxes is explained by the diagrams on the right. Notice that the crowding of the metal pairs showing complete solid solubility is along the diagonal of the figure corresponding to close values of their Mendeleev numbers.
map. The good separation, moreover, between the line connecting the Cr3Si-type phase points and that of the Laves phase points, can be related to the almost total exclusion of the Cr3Si-type phases from the 250 binary systems containing Laves phases and that of the Laves phases from the 90, or so, binary systems in which a Cr3Si-type phase occurs.
21
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems (b)
1100
1064.43
900 700 500 300 Ni
20
40
60
80
Temperature (°C)
Temperature (°C)
(a) 1455 1300
1769.0 1600 1400 1200 1000 800 600
Au
20
Pt
40
at.%
Au
(d) 842
800 727 600 500
443
400 300 20
40
60
at.%
80
Ca
Temperature (°C)
Temperature (°C)
80
at.%
(c)
Ba
60
0
Tc Ti
2
1 α A
3
β x2 4
x1
B
at.%
Figure 2.9. Examples of melting phase diagrams of binary systems showing complete mutual solubility in the liquid state and, at high temperature only, in the solid state. By lowering the temperature, however, the continuous solid solution decomposes into two phases. In (d) a schematic representation of NiAu or PtAu type diagrams is shown as formed by two generic components A and B.
As a conclusive comment to the Miedema model, especially with reference to the enthalpy evaluation, we have to underline that while it may be useful in order to define a reference behaviour, however, its approximate (in a way qualitative) character cannot be forgotten. A critical discussion on the application and limits of this model has been published for instance by Chen et al. (2004); see the comments on the thermochemistry of the Laves phases in § 3.9.3, see also a few more remarks on this subject in § 4.4.7.1. 2.2.1.4 Partial mutual solubility in the solid state. Fig. 2.9 shows different examples of binary systems for which there is still a complete miscibility in the liquid state, but only a limited mutual solubility in the solid state, depending on the temperature. The Ni–Au system, for instance, still has complete mutual solid solubility but only at high temperature, that is, by decreasing the temperature, de-mixing
22
Intermetallic Chemistry
into two different solid phases occurs from the homogeneous solid solution field in the whole composition range. Actual phase diagrams are presented in Fig. 2.9(a)–(c). A schematic representation of this behaviour for a generic A–B pair of metals is shown in Fig. 2.9(d). For a curve such as 3-1-0 (and/or 4-2-0) the name solvus is often used. At T Tc (Tc is the critical consolute temperature) it is possible through a single-phase field, by continuously changing the composition, to move from A to B, without cutting any equilibrium line. At lower temperature, for instance Ti, the single-phase alloys α phase (A-based solid solution of B in A) and β phase (B-based single-phase alloy) exist for x x1 and for x x2, respectively. For the intermediate compositions the equilibrium structure corresponds to heterogeneous alloys consisting in mechanical mixtures of two different solid phases: mutually saturated α phase (A-based) and β phase (B-based) having (at the Ti temperature) the x1 and x2 compositions, respectively. A few remarks about the decomposition mechanism will be found in § 2.3.3 and Fig. 2.38, where there are also a few notes about the so-called spinodal decomposition. A similar behaviour (complete mutual solubility in the liquid state and partial solubility in the solid state) is presented also by the Pt–Au and Ba–Ca systems (Fig. 2.9(b) and (c)). Notice in the Pt–Au diagram the closeness (mainly for compositions near 40 at.% Au) between the melting and the de-mixing equilibria. The Ba–Ca diagram has a different appearance because Ca (in its high-temperature form) and Ba are completely mutually soluble, while only a partial solid solubility is observed for Ba in the low-temperature modification of Ca.
2.2.2 Inter-crossing of two-phase equilibria The diagrams shown in Fig. 2.10 exemplify a slightly more complex behaviour (for the corresponding nomenclature see the following § 2.2.2.1). In these cases the demixing equilibria involving the solid solutions cross the melting equilibria. As a consequence, at a certain well-defined temperature a three-phase, invariant, equilibrium is established while, in the solid state, completely separated terminal phases (A-based and B-based solid solutions) are found (see for instance the Cubased and the Ag-based terminal solid solutions in the Cu–Ag system of Fig. 2.10(a)). In this system there is the eutectic solidification of a liquid (having 61.1 at.% Ag at 779°C) into two solid phases respectively Cu-rich (4.9 at.% Ag) and Agrich (85.9 at.% Ag). In the Ru–Ni system there is a peritectic transformation involving the liquid and the two, Ru-based and Ni-based, solid solutions; in Fig. 2.10(c) the peritectic transformation involves the liquid and two solid solutions: one based on the high-temperature form of Co and the other corresponding to the solution between Re and the low-temperature form of Co. In the system Ti–W the continuous solid solution stable at high temperature decomposes on lowering the temperature through a eutectic-type reaction into
23
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems (b) 2334
1084.87 1000
Temperature (°C)
Temperature (°C)
(a)
961.93
800 600 400
Cu
20
40
60
80
2000 1600
1455
1200 800
Ag
20
Ru
at.%
40
60
80
(c)
(d) 3422 Temperature (°C)
Temperature (°C)
3186 2500 2000 1495
1500 1000 500 Re
Ni
at.%
422 20
40
60
80
3000 2500 2000 1670 882
Co
20
Ti
at.%
40
60
80
W
at.%
Temperature (°C)
(e) 1855
1755 1600 1360 1000
863
600 200 Th
20
40
60
80
Zr
at.%
Figure 2.10. Examples of binary systems characterized by complete mutual solubility in the liquid state and, depending on temperature and/or composition, partial solubility in the solid state and presenting (in certain composition ranges) an invariant (three-phase) reaction (eutectic in the Cu–Ag, peritectic in the Ru–Ni and Re–Co and eutectoidal in Ti–W (one) and in Th–Zr (two)).
nearly pure Ti and a solid solution of Ti in W. In Fig. 2.10(e) (Th–Zr system) there are, in the solid state, two subsequent eutectic-type decomposition reactions of a solid solution into two solid phases. Notice that the name eutectoid is used for a three-phase eutectic-type reaction involving three solid phases.
24
Intermetallic Chemistry (b)
(a) Temperature (°C)
1414 1300 1064.43 900 700 500 300 Au
20
40 60 at.%
80
1900 1700 1500 1300 1135 900 776 668
Si
1863
U
20
40 60 at.%
80
Cr
Figure 2.11. The Au–Si diagram is an example of a simple eutectic system with complete mutual solubility in the liquid state and no (or negligible) solubility in the solid state; at a temperature of 363°C the liquid having the composition of 18.6 at.% Si solidifies with the simultaneous crystallization of the practically pure gold and silicon mechanically mixed. In the Cr–U system a slightly more complex situation due to the solid-state transformations of uranium is shown.
Extreme cases of solid solubility are shown in Fig. 2.11. In particular notice the system Au–Si for which, owing to a negligible solubility in the solid state, the terminal phases are practically coincident with the pure elements. Several pairs of elements show the behaviour exemplified by these figures. These have also been collected in the map of Fig. 2.8. 2.2.2.1 Phase rule, ‘Building Blocks’ in binary system diagrams, Invariant equilibria. Previously we made some remarks about specific features of the phase diagrams and the existence of ‘invariant’ equilibria, mainly referring to the diagrams of Fig. 2.10. A short summary of these items and of the relevant nomenclature is given here. To this aim a well-known starting point is the phase rule (Gibbs phase rule). (a) Phase rule, variance The phase rule is: VCP2 where V is the variance (the number of degrees of freedom) of the system, C is the number of the so-called ‘independent’ components (the minimum number of species needed to define the composition of all the phases of the system) and P is the number of phases in equilibrium. An explanation of this rule can be summarized as follows. The description of a thermodynamic system formed by C components present in P phases needs the specification of temperature, pressure and composition of all the P phases.
25
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
1
a b
T
2
T
1
c
V at.% Mo a = liquid; b = liquid + solid; c = solid
V
Mo
at.%
1
a b
2
d
c e
T
1
i
h
Pt
2
T
f g
2
1
2
at.%
Ag
2
1
Pt
at.%
Ag
a = liquid; b = liquid + (Pt); c = (Pt); d = liquid + (Ag); e = (Pt) + (Ag); f = (Ag); g = (Pt) + Ag15Pt17; h = Ag15Pt17; i = (Ag) + Ag15Pt17
a
1 d
b
c
e T
f
l m Zr
h
1 T 2
g
n at.%
V
2
2
i
1 Zr
2
1
2
1
2
2 at.%
V
a = liquid; b = liquid + (βZr); c = liquid + (V); d = liquid + ZrV3; e = (βZr); f = (βZr) + ZrV3; g = (V) + ZrV3; h = ZrV3; i = (V); l = (βZr) + (αZr); m = (αZr); n = (αZr) + ZrV3 1 = single-phase fields;
2 = two-phase fields
Figure 2.12a. ‘Building blocks’ of binary phase diagrams: examples of single-phase (two-variant) and two-phase (mono-variant) fields. In the figure the indication is given of the phases existing in the various fields and respectively of their number. The phase equilibrium composition in the twophase fields is defined by the boundary (saturation) lines of the single-phase regions. (Pt), (Ag), (V, Mo), etc. are short symbols for indicating solid solution phases based on Pt, Ag, etc.
The composition of each phase is known when the concentrations of C 1 components in the phase have been defined. Thus, for all the phases, there are P(C 1) concentration variables. In principle, we have to add P values for the temperature of the different phases and P values of pressure to obtain the total number,
26
Intermetallic Chemistry The two-phase fields correspond to two types Transformation
Mixing–de-mixing
α α
T1
Ti
T2
Tm β
Tf
α′
x1
β′
α′ + α″
x 2′ x 1′
x 1′′ x 2′′
Figure 2.12b. ‘Building blocks’ of binary phase diagrams: examples of two-phase (mono-variant) reactions. On the left the transformation, on cooling, from the α phase to β is shown. For the composition x1 in equilibrium conditions the transformation starts at temperature Ti and ends at Tf. Notice that at an intermediate temperature as Tm only a partial transformation has been carried out: a certain quantity of α (having the composition corresponding to α ) will coexist with β ( of composition β ). On the right, the α phase undergoes, on cooling, a de-mixing in the two α and α phases having at temperature T1 the compositions x 1 and x1, at temperature T2 the compositions x 2, x2, etc.
P P P(C 1) P(C 1), of variables. For equilibrium conditions to exist, however, several relationships between the stated variables must occur. Each of the P phases must be at the same temperature and pressure so there are P 1 equalities of temperature and P 1 of pressure. As for the concentration, the C values of each component in each phase must be related to the corresponding C values in the other phases (technically this means the same activity of each component in all the phases): so C(P 1) relations are found. The total number of equilibrium conditions, therefore, is given by: (P 1) (P 1) C(P 1) (P 1)(C 2) The variance (V, degree of freedom) of the system is defined as the maximum number of variables which may be independently altered without disturbing the equilibrium state of the system. It is given by the difference between the total number of variables and the total number of equations among these variables defined by the equilibrium conditions. Therefore: V P(C 1) (P 1)(C 2) C P 2
27
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems The three-phase equilibria correspond to two types of reactions, represented by the following equations conventionally written in order to indicate (from left to right) the transformation occurring on cooling. α → ← β+γ
λ+ϕ→ ←χ
1st class equilibrium
2nd class equilibrium
α γ
β
ϕ
λ
χ
2
3
1
T Hf
at.%
Ru Zr
at.%
V
Three 1st class equilibria Two 1st class equilibria One 2nd class equilibria
Ca
at.%
Pb
Three 1st class equilibria Two 2nd class equilibria
Figure 2.13. ‘Building blocks’ of binary phase diagrams: examples of three-phase (invariant) reactions. In the upper part the general appearance, inside a phase diagram, of the two types of invariant equilibria is presented, that is, the so-called 1st class (or eutectic type) and the 2nd class (or peritectic type) equilibria. In the lower part the various invariant equilibria formed by selected binary alloys for well-defined values of temperature and composition are listed. In the Hf–Ru diagram, for instance, three 1st class equilibria may be observed, 1: (βHf) : (αHf) HfRu (eutectoid, three solid phases involved), 2: L : βHf HfRu (eutectic), 3: L : HfRu (Ru) (eutectic).
The reader interested in a more complete and rigorous demonstration of the Gibbs rule may consult for instance the books by Gokcen and Reddy (1996) or Hillert (1998) where a classification of the different systems (reacting, non-reacting, etc.) to which the rule can be applied is also presented. (b) Phase rule and the ‘building blocks’ in the T/x diagrams of binary systems. In the specific case of binary (C 2) systems, V 4 P. If, however, we consider systems at constant pressure (isobaric conditions), as is usual when studying solidification, melting processes, the number of variables decreases by one and the variance decreases to V C P 1, that is, for a two-component system, V 3 P.
28
Intermetallic Chemistry
As a consequence in a two-component phase diagram, at constant pressure, it is possible to have: – single-phase, bi-variant (P 1, V 2) fields; – two-phase, mono-variant equilibria (P 2, V 1); – three-phase, invariant (zero-variant) equilibria (P 3, V 0). Negative values of V will correspond to non-equilibrium systems. The aspects of these fields and equilibria are characteristic; they can be considered the fundamental ‘building blocks’ of each phase diagram (see Figs. 2.12(a) and 2.12(b) and 2.13). Each phase diagram, indeed, can be described as an assembly, subjected to well-defined rules, of a certain number of such blocks. 2.2.2.2 Solubility Diagrams: effects of atomic properties on mutual solubility. The effect on mutual solubility of the atomic properties of the components (and therefore of their relative positions on the map shown in Fig. 2.8) may be considered on the basis also of different diagrams. An introductory example to this subject is the well-known diagrams developed by Darken and Gurry (1953) for solid solution prediction. In such a diagram (as shown in Fig. 2.14) all elements may be included. The two coordinates represent the atomic size, generally the radius corresponding to the coordination number (CN) 12, and the electronegativity of the elements. The electronegativity, previously introduced in § 2.2.1.3, is a characteristic elemental parameter which may be used as a convenient chemical coordinate. In the original Darken and Gurry diagram (Fig. 2.14) the values proposed by Gordy (1946) were used. In order to classify the solid solubility of the different elements in a given metal, in the Darken and Gurry map, the region with the selected metal (Mg, for instance, in Fig. 2.14) in the centre is considered. Generally, elements having high solubility lie inside a small region around the selected metal. As a rule of thumb an ellipse is drawn in the diagram, with the selected metal in the centre, for instance with 0.3 electronegativity unit difference on one axis and 15% atomic radius difference on the other axis. For those elements for which there is a low or a negligible solubility, a larger region has to be considered. In the original chapter by Darken and Gurry a number of discrepancies between mapped and observed values were also discussed. For a review of the application of the Darken and Gurry method to predict solid solubility see Gschneidner Jr. (1980). An improvement of the method by means of simultaneous use of rules based on the electronic and crystal structures of the metals involved is also presented. Notice that, in a way, the Darken and Gurry diagram corresponds to a row, or to a column, of the map reported in Fig. 2.8.
29
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
Au
3.0
0 –5 at.% 5 –10 at.% >10 at.%
Mu
Electronegativity
2.5
2.0
B
1.5
1.0
Cu Cr Mo As Ni V Ag Nb Sb Bi Fe Ge Sn Ti Zr Pb Be In Ga Al Ti Y La Zn Sc Mg Cd Ca Sr Hg Ba Na Li
0.5
100
150 200 Radius (CN 12) (pm)
Figure 2.14. Darken and Gurry diagram. In a map of the electronegativity vs. radius, the different metals are collected. For a selected metal (Mg in this example) a region corresponding to a range of 0.3 electronegativity units and 15% atomic radius difference is evidenced. The different symbols corresponding to a more or less large solubility in Mg are shown on the right of the figure.
In the general case a complex behaviour may be expected for the extension of the terminal solid solutions which, for a pair of metals M1, M2, also depends on the stoichiometry and stability of the M1 (or, respectively, M2) richest phase. However a certain regularity of the dependence of the mutual solid solubility on the position of the metals involved in the Periodic Table may be observed. This can be related to the so-called Hume-Rothery rules (1931): First rule: Effect of the size factor. If the atomic sizes of the two components differ more than 15%, extended solid solution formation is not expected. Second rule: Effect of the electrochemical nature. If the electrochemical characteristics of the two elements are similar, solid solution formation may be expected, otherwise compound formation is more probable. Third rule: Effect of the valence electrons. Generally a higher-valence metal is more soluble in a lower-valence metal than the contrary. A combination of the effects of the three factors should, of course, be considered in order to make reliable predictions. As for the third rule (about the valence-electron
30
Intermetallic Chemistry Metal Y 11
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
Cu Ag Au Ni Pd Pt Co Rh Ir Fe Rn Os Mn Tc Re Cr Mo W V Nb Ta Ti Zr Hf Ti
4
Zr Hf V
5
Nb Ta Cr
6
Mo W
Metal X
Mn
7
Tc Re Fe
8
Ru Os Co
9
Rh
Alloy X–Y Larger solid solubility in Y
Ir
10
Ni
Larger solid solubility in X
Pd
Similar solid solubility in X and Y
Pt
11
Cu
Negligible solid solublity
Ag
Complete mutual solid solubility (at least at HT)
Au
Figure 2.15. Relative extent of the mutual solid solubility in binary alloys of transition metals, ordered according to their group number in the Periodic Table. The group number is reported on the left and on the top of the figure.
factor) this has been discussed by Goodman et al. (1983) considering the trend summarized in a map such as that shown in Fig. 2.15. As for different concepts introduced by Hume-Rothery, see also § 4.4.5. 2.2.3 Trends in mutual liquid solubilities All the phase diagrams reported above show a complete mutual solubility in the liquid state. The formation of a single phase in the liquid state corresponds to behaviour frequently observed in intermetallic (binary and complex) systems. Examples, however, of a degree of immiscibility in the liquid state are also found in selected intermetallic systems. Fig. 2.16 shows a few binary systems in which such immiscibility can be observed (existence of miscibility gaps in the liquid state). All the three
31
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
Temperature (°C)
(a)
(b) 1800
300 250 200 150 100
271.442 2L
600 29.7741 Ga
20
40 60 at.%
80
200
Bi
29.7741 Be
(c)
Temperature (°C)
2L
1400 1289 1000
20
40 60 at.%
80
Ga
(d) 2L
700 600 500 400 300 200 97.8
660.452
1200 1064.43 1000
2L 2L
800 600 400
221
200 Na
20
40 60 at.%
80
Al
Au
20
40 60 at.%
80
Se
Figure 2.16. The diagrams presented in this figure show certain ranges of de-mixing in the liquid state. We see in the Ga–Bi system a miscibility gap that, at the temperature of 222°C extends from 8.5 to 61.5 at.% Bi. A much larger region of existence of two liquids is observed in the Be–Ga system. In the Na–Al system finally the immiscibility region practically includes the whole composition range from 0% to 100%. In this case the two metals are completely insoluble in the liquid state (as well as in the solid state). The melting temperatures of the two metals (Na and Al in this example) are practically unaffected by the addition of the other component. The diagram consists of three superimposed two-phase fields corresponding to the coexistence of solid Na with solid Al, liquid Na with solid Al and liquid Na with liquid Al. For (d) see the text.
simple diagrams Ga–Bi, Be–Ga and Na–Al show practically negligible solid solubility and also immiscibility in the liquid state. The diagram Na–Al in Fig. 2.16(c) corresponds to extremely small solubilities: the solubility of Na in Al has been evaluated in less than 0.002 at.%, while that of Al in Na is practically zero. A summary of all the metal pairs showing partial or complete immiscibility in the liquid state is presented in the map of Fig. 2.17. In the same figure metal pairs giving solid–gas equilibria are also shown. The solid–gas equilibria are especially observed in systems in which there is a large difference in the boiling points of the components (see for instance the systems formed by the alkali metals with refractory metals such as Cr, Mo, V, etc.). Several groups of systems forming miscibility
32
Intermetallic Chemistry MB Rh Pa Li Be Tb Ga Si S U La P Pd Co Ca Zn Na Y Cu Cd Pt O Ge B As Se Ti V Cr Mn Os Al Tm Ce Np Sr K Ag Hg Sb Te Ac Hf Nb Mo Tc Ru Sm Pu Ni Ba Eu Lu Rb N In Sn Cs C Po Ra Yb Sc Au Mg Bi Tl Gd Am Ir Th Zr Ta W Re Fe Pb H C Po Bi
Te Sb
N Se As
O S P
B Si Ge Sn Ga Al In Tl Be Zn Cd Hg Mg Cu Ag Au Pd Pt Ni Ir Rh Co Os Ru Fe Mn Tc Re Cr Mo W V Nb Ta Ti MA Hf Zr Ac Th Pa U Np Pu Am La Ce Sm Gd Tb Y Tm Lu Sc Eu Yb Ca Sr Ba Ra Li Na K Rb Pb
(a)
(b)
L L1 L2
LG
L1 B
GA
T
AL
AB A
G
AB B
A
B
Figure 2.17. Liquid–liquid and solid–gas equilibria in intermetallic systems. In a map based on the so-called Mendeleev number coordinates the different binary combinations are represented. Only those combinations have been coded for which the existence of liquid miscibility gaps (or of solid–gas equilibria) is known. (In the same systems, other equilibria, the formation of compounds, etc. may be present). For many systems data are lacking: probably in the bottom-left corner of the figure many more boxes could be added to those representing miscibility gap. Notice that the solid–gas equilibria are relevant to systems formed by metals with a large difference between their boiling temperatures.
gaps can be noticed: such as many systems of the alkali metals and several systems given by the alkali-earth and rare-earth metals (see in the systematic part, in Chapter 5, the description of the interesting behaviour of ytterbium). Another group of systems showing a liquid miscibility gap is given by the combinations
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
33
with several semi-metals or non-metals (see the right-hand side of the map). Among these systems there are a few characterized by the formation of two miscibility gaps (generally placed on the two sides of some intermediate compounds): these are generally sulphur or selenium systems such as Ag–S, Al–S, Au–Se, Co–Se, Cr–S, Cu–S, Cu–Se, Ga–S, Hg–S, Hg–Se, In–Se, K–S, Na–S, P–Sn, S–Sb, S–Sn, S–Tl, S–W, S–Zn, Se–Tl. In these systems three different liquid phases can be defined: two terminal phases which include as limit composition one of the components and one intermediate phase. This behaviour may be related to the change vs. the composition of the bond characteristics: covalent bond for the molecular element on one side of the system, metallic on the other side and ionic–covalent for the intermediate compounds. At high temperature we generally have the closure of the immiscibility and the continuous liquid solution. An example of this type of diagram is given in Fig. 2.16 (d). At high temperature the gold-rich and the selenium-rich liquid phases and around 50 at.% another liquid phase are highlighted. At low temperature the peritectic formation of AuSe can be noticed. These different bonds, at least up to a certain temperature, are maintained in the liquid state, which also favours de-mixing. The Te–S system is peculiar: it is a simple eutectic-type diagram and shows (like an island completely surrounded by the single-phase field of the liquid) a small ‘oval’ insolubility region situated between 37 and 41.5 at.% S and between two critical temperatures (upper Tc 740°C and lower Tc 690°C). This behaviour (often observed for instance in organic systems) among the different pairs of elements has been described only for Te–S. The diagrams of Fig. 2.16 may be considered examples of systems showing not only small (or very small) solubility in the solid state, but also a degree of insolubility in the liquid state (existence of miscibility gaps in the liquid state). The diagram shown in Fig. 2.16(c) corresponds to the extreme case where practically complete insolubility exists both in the solid and in the liquid state. 2.2.4 Formation of intermediate phases in alloy systems A different, more complex, alloying behaviour is illustrated in a number of figures (Figs. 2.18–2.21) where several examples of alloy diagrams are presented which are typically characterized by the formation, through a range of different mechanisms, of intermediate phases. In the field of solid-state chemistry an important group of substances is represented by the intermetallic compounds and phases. In binary and multicomponent metal systems, in fact, several crystalline phases (terminal and intermediate, stable and metastable) may occur. A few introductory remarks about these substances will be presented in relation to the mentioned figures. Simple schematic phase diagrams of binary alloy systems are shown in Fig. 2.18 in which the formation of one intermediate solid phase may be noticed. In these
34
Intermetallic Chemistry (b) 1064.43 1000
938.3
800 650
Mg
20
40 60 at.%
80
Temperature (°C)
Temperature (°C)
(a)
800
400
Ge
Au
20
40 60 at.%
80 Sb
(d) 1064.43
961.93
20
40 60 at.%
80
Temperature (°C)
Temperature (°C)
(c) 1769 1600 1400 1200 1000 800 600 Pt
630.755
600
800 600 400 271.442
200
Ag
Au
20
40 60 at.%
80
Bi
Temperature (°C)
(e) 1200 1000 800 600 400 Zn
20
40 60 at.%
80
Te
Figure 2.18. Examples of binary phase diagrams in each of which one stoichiometric phase is formed. In the Mg–Ge system we have the congruently melting Mg2Ge (33.3 at.% Ge); in Au–Sb, AuSb2 is formed through a peritectic reaction. In the Pt–Ag system one compound at 47 at.% Ag with stoichiometry Pt17Ag15 is formed via a solid state reaction (Pt) (Ag) : Pt17Ag15. In the Au–Bi system the compound Au2Bi is stable in a restricted range of temperature only: it is formed by a peritectic reaction (371°C) and, at a lower temperature (116°C), it is decomposed according to the eutectoidal reaction: Au2Bi : (Au) (Bi). In the Zn–Te system, finally, we have the congruently melting compound ZnTe. In this system a miscibility gap in the liquid state may also be noticed.
35
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems (b)
800 700 600 500 400 300
449.57
231.9681
Sn
20
40 60 at.%
80
Temperature (°C)
Temperature (°C)
(a) 2400 2231 2000 1743 1600 1400 1200 1000
Hf
Te
20
40 60 at.%
80
Ru
(d) 1910
1855 1600 1400 1200 1000 863 20
40 60 at.%
80
V
Temperature (°C)
Temperature (°C)
(c)
Zr
2334
3020 2600 2200 1910
1800 1400 1000 Ta
20
40 60 at.%
80
V
Figure 2.19. Examples of systems in which intermediate phases corresponding to small composition ranges are formed. These are SnTe (congruent melting), HfRu (congruent melting), ZrV2 (peritectic formation) and TaV2 (formed through a solid-state reaction).
diagrams we observe the formation of an intermediate phase, which generally crystallizes with a structure other than those of the constituent elements, and which has a negligible homogeneity range. Thermodynamically, the composition of any such phase is variable. In a number of cases, however, the possible variation in composition is very small. Invariant composition phases or stoichiometric phases, or ‘compounds’ proper, also called ‘point compounds’ in binary alloys, are represented by a point on the composition axis. In Fig. 2.19, on the contrary, we observe that intermediate solid phases with a variable composition are formed (non-stoichiometric phases). In the diagrams shown here we see therefore examples both of terminal and intermediate phases. (For instance, the Hf–Ru diagram shows the terminal solid solutions of Ru in α and βHf and of Hf in Ru and the intermediate compound containing about 50 at.% Ru). These phases are characterized by homogeneity ranges (solid solubility ranges), which, in the case of the terminal phases, include the pure components and which, generally, have a variable temperature-dependent extension.
36
Intermetallic Chemistry (b)
2400
Temperature (°C)
Temperature (°C)
(a)
2092
2000 1600 1135 776 668 U
20
40 60 at.%
80
1200 1000 842 600 400 200
327.502
Ca
B
20
40 60 at.%
80
Pb
(c) 1455
Temperature (°C)
1400 1300 1200 1100 1000 900 819 20
Yb
40 60 at.%
80
Ni
(d) 1200 1084.87
Temperature (°C)
1064.43
800 (Au, Cu)
AuCuII
400
AuCu3II AuCuI
AuCu3I
Au3Cu Au
20
40
60 at.%
80
Cu
Figure 2.20. Examples of systems in which several intermediate phases are formed. In the U–B system there are the three congruently melting compounds UB2, UB4, UB12, in the Ca–Pb system Ca2Pb and CaPb3 (congruently melting), Ca5Pb3 and CaPb (peritectic formation). The Yb–Ni system shows quite different interactions in the different parts of the phase diagram: in the Yb-rich region we have no compounds and a miscibility gap in the liquid state, while several point compounds are formed in the Ni-rich region. Completely different is the Au–Cu system in which the continuous solid solution, stable at high temperature, gives on cooling various ordered intermediate phases through ordering processes.
37
800 400
Au
Temperature (°C)
Temperature (°C)
1200
20
40 60 at.%
80
Mn
1200 1000 800 600 400 200 Mn
20
40 60 at.%
80
Ga
1800 1600 1400 1200 1000 800 Er
Temperature (°C)
Temperature (°C)
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
20
40 60 at.%
80
20
40 60 at.%
80
Ge
1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 Mn
Ni
Figure 2.21. Phase diagrams of the systems Au–Mn, Er–Ge, Mn–Ga, Mn–Ni.
More complex situations will be shown in the following and some typical examples of ternary (or multi-component) alloy phase diagrams presented. In Figs. 2.20 and 2.21 a selection of binary alloy systems which give various types of phase diagrams characterized by the formation of intermediate phases is given. These systems and their phase diagrams have been arranged in order of their increasing complexity. A few specific comments may be helpful. In the U–B and in the Ca–Pb systems we notice the formation of several stoichiometric compounds (UB2, UB4, UB12 and, respectively, Ca2Pb, Ca5Pb3, CaPb, CaPb3, possibly having quasi-polar, salt-like, bonds). In the Yb–Ni system we have the formation of a number of compounds in the Ni-rich region, no compounds and a miscibility gap in the liquid state in the Yb-rich region. The Au–Cu system is a typical example of formation of intermediate phases by ordering in the solid state: at high temperature we have a continuous solid solution. Fig. 2.21 shows a few examples of very complex systems characterized by the formation of several (point and solution range) intermediate phases often involved in a number of different formation and decomposition reactions. The crowded sequence of intermediate compounds of interrelated structures is noteworthy in the Au-rich region of the Au–Mn system. A similar situation (however, not yet well defined) may
38
Intermetallic Chemistry
be observed in the Ge-rich region of the rare earth–germanium systems (for instance Er–Ge). The Mn–Ga and Mn–Ni systems show a number of solid-state reactions involving several solid solution intermediate phases. 2.2.4.1 Trends in the formation capability of binary compounds. A few general comments about the formation of intermediate phases in binary alloy systems can be made by using maps similar to those previously employed in Fig. 2.8 in order to give a summary of the mutual solubility. In Figs. 2.22 and 2.23 all the binary combinations are mapped as a function of the Mendeleev numbers of the two elements involved. The compound formation capability is represented in Fig. 2.22 by means of a few codes, whereas in Fig. 2.23 an indication is given of the thermal stability of the intermediate phases. To this end, values correlated to the so-called Raynor Index (Raynor 1972, 1974) are coded in this figure. This index IR is defined as follows (for a generic phase or compound having the composition AxB(1x)):
IR
Tm ( Ax B(1 x ) ) xTm ( A) (1 x )Tm ( B )
In the formula Tm(S) is the melting point in Kelvin of the substance S. The pairs of elements forming compounds have been mapped; both those having at least one compound with IR 1 and those for which IR 1. An outline of the intermediate phase formation and behaviour may be obtained through a look at both maps. All the systems, for instance, shown in Figs. 2.1 (V–Mo, Cs–Rb, Sr–Ca), 2.9 (Ni–Au, Pt–Au, Ba–Ca), 2.11 (Au–Si, U–Cr) and 2.16 (Ga–Bi, Be–Ga, Na–Al) will be represented as non-compound systems in the map of Fig. 2.22. The system Au–Cu (Fig. 2.20(d)) corresponds to the formation of a certain number of intermediate phases (in Fig. 2.22) and low values of IR in the Fig. 2.23. The system Ca–Pb (Fig. 2.20(b)) on the contrary is represented by the existence of several intermediate phases and high values of IR, etc. As already suggested and discussed by several authors, such as Pettifor (1984, 1986), Villars et al. (1989), etc., these maps highlight a regular trend in the formation of binary compounds. In the lower-left corner of the map those systems are represented obtained by combinations among elements of the first four groups of the Periodic Table. No intermediate compounds are generally observed in these systems. On the other hand, several compounds are observed in systems given by elements having high
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
39
MB Rh Pa Li Be Tb Ga Si S U La P Pd Co Ca Zn Na Y Cu Cd Pt O Ge B As Se Ti V Cr Mn Os Al Tm Ce Np Sr K Ag Hg Sb Te Ac Hf Nb Mo Tc Ru Sm Pu Ni Ba Eu Lu Rb N In Sn Cs C Po Ra Yb Sc Au Mg Bi Tl Gd Am Ir Th Zr Ta W Re Fe Pb H C Po Bi
Te Sb
N Se As
O S P
B Si Ge Sn Ga Al In Tl Be Zn Cd Hg Mg Cu Ag Au Pd Pt Ni Ir Rh Co Os Ru Fe Mn Tc Re Cr Mo W V Nb Ta Ti MA Hf Zr Ac Th Pa U Np Pu Am La Ce Sm Gd Tb Y Tm Lu Sc Eu Yb Ca Sr Ba Ra Li Na K Rb Pb
The phase diagram has been determined and no intermediate phase has been observed. Only one intermediate phase is formed (either by crystallization from the liquid or by ordering in the solid state). Several intermediate phases are formed ( 2).
Figure 2.22. Compound formation capability in binary systems. The different element combinations are mapped on Mendeleev number coordinates and those systems are indicated in which the formation of intermediate phases has been observed (either from the liquid or in the solid state). Blank boxes indicate systems for which no certain data are available. Notice that the compound-forming alloys are crowded in a region corresponding to a large difference in the Mendeleev numbers of the elements involved (for instance, basic metals with semi-metals).
electronegativity differences, such as those reported in the higher (left and central) part of the map. Similar information about the mutual reactivity of the different types of elements may be obtained from Fig. 2.23, where, with a similar format, an indication of the Raynor Index is mapped.
40
Intermetallic Chemistry
Figure 2.23. Raynor Index map. In this map only the systems forming intermediate phases are coded. The two diagrams show the codes used in the map. In the first diagram the index IR for all the compositions is less than 1 (the melting points in the diagram are lower than the averaged melting points of the components). In the second diagram, for a certain range of compositions IR is higher than 1. Notice that the high values of the Raynor Index correspond to the metal pairs showing high compound formation capability (compare with Fig. 2.22).
2.3. EXAMPLES OF MORE COMPLEX PHASE DIAGRAMS
In the preceding paragraphs we have seen a few examples of phase equilibria occurring in binary systems represented by means of 2D diagrams built, at constant pressure (isobaric), on temperature/composition axes for which the phase rule
41
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems C
C (a)
(b)
a b
b′ b
a
P1 P2
X c = 0.5
b
c′ c
P3
a
P
c A
a′
P4
X c = 0.25
c B X
a ′+ b ′+ c ′ = CX a +b + c = AB = AC = BC
A
XA /XB = 1 XA /XB = 1 / 3
B
P 1 = A 0.25 B 0.25 C 0.5 ( = ABC 2) P 2 = A 0.125 B 0.375 C 0.5 ( = AB 3C 4) P 3 = A 0.375 B 0.375 C 0.25 ( = A 3 B 3C 2) P 4 = A 3B 9C 4
Figure 2.24 The Gibbs triangle for the representation of the composition in a ternary system.
reduces to V 2 P 1 3 P. More complex systems and representations may be considered in several cases. Just as an indication a few examples will be given here. 2.3.1 Ternary phase diagrams More complex representations are needed when considering more than two components. In the three-component case, the so-called Gibbs triangle is employed for the representation of the composition (see Fig. 2.24(a)). On the vertices the pure components (A, B, C) are represented, on the edges the binary compositions pertaining to the systems A–B, B–C, and C–A. In the interior of the triangle the ternary compositions are defined for a given point according to two coordinate systems. In the so-called contravariant system, distances are measured parallel to the sides of the triangle (a b c AB, taken as unit); in the other system, the covariant one, the quantities are measured by the perpendicular distances from point P to the sides (a b c CX, which is taken as the unit). Examples of compositions and their representation in the Gibbs triangle are shown in Fig. 2.24(b). Notice that along a straight line parallel to one axis (for instance A–B), the concentration of the third component (C) is constant. On the other hand, straight lines radiating from one vertex (C in this case) correspond to a constant ratio of the components placed in the two other vertices (A and B). If we consider three-component (ternary) systems, for instance, we have C 3 and, according to the phase rule, the variance is given by V C P 2 5 P or in
42
Intermetallic Chemistry
Temperature
(a)
T2 TE
A
C
T1
B
α
(b) A
C ∗
γ
α
(c) A
C
∗
∗
T = T2 β
γ
T = T1
β B
B (d) A
C E
B
Figure 2.25. A hypothetical ternary diagram presenting a ternary eutectic (at temperature TE) is shown in (a); two isothermal sections (at T2 and T1) are presented in (b) and (c) where the shaded regions represent single-phase fields, the ruled ones represent two-phase fields and those marked by an asterisk three-phase fields. The segments shown in the two-phase fields are supposed to be ‘tie-lines’ (co-nodes) connecting the points representing the compositions (experimentally determined) of the two phases in equilibrium at the given temperature. The three-phase fields are triangles (tie-triangles) the vertices of which correspond to the compositions of the three coexisting phases. In (d) a projection of the ‘liquidus’ is shown. The projections of the valleys meet in the ternary eutectic (LE : α β γ).
43
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
the simpler and very common case of an investigation carried out at constant pressure V C P 1 4 P. In Fig. 2.25 a perspective view of a 3D temperature/ composition diagram is given. Isothermal sections of the diagram are given in Fig. 2.25(b) and (c), and a projection of equilibrium lines in Fig. 2.25(d). In the case of a ternary system, the formation of several, binary and ternary, stoichiometric phases, and different types of variable composition phases can be observed. One may differentiate between these phases by using terms such as ‘point compounds’ (or point phases), that is, phases represented in the composition field by points, ‘line phases’, ‘field phases’, etc. A simple example of a real ternary diagram is shown in Fig. 2.26, where the isothermal section, determined at 200°C, of the Al–Bi–Sb system is shown together with the relevant binary diagrams: Al–Bi showing a miscibility gap in the liquid state and complete insolubility in the solid state, Bi–Sb with complete mutual T (°C)
600 1000
1000 500
900
400
600
800 700
300
600
Al
10
30
50
70
90
at.% Bi
Bi
Bi
10
30
50
70
90
at.% Sb
Al
Sb
10
30
50
70
at.% Sb
90
Sb
Bi
80
20
60
40
40
∗
60
+
20
80
Al
20
40
60
80
Sb
AlSb
Figure 2.26. Isothermal section of the Al–Bi–Sb phase diagram at 200°C. In the triangle marked by the asterisk, three phases (coincident with the two elements Al and Bi together with the compound AlSb) are observed. In the other triangle two-phase alloys are formed. A few tie-lines are shown. The alloy marked by ‘’, for instance, contains the compound AlSb together with a (Bi, Sb) solid solution of composition marked by ‘䊊’.
44
Intermetallic Chemistry
T (°C) 1300
1300 600
900
900
500
500
400 307 200
Al
10
30
50
70
90
at.% Si
Si
Si
10
30
50
70
90
at.% Zn Si
Zn
Al
30
50
70
at.% Zn
90
Zn
80
20
60
40
40
60
∗
∗ 20
80
Al
10
20
40
60
80
Zn
Figure 2.27. Isothermal section at 307°C of the Al–Zn–Si diagram. The boundary binary systems are shown. The isothermal section at 307°C is marked on the binary Al–Zn diagram. The corresponding single-phase (thick segment) and two-phase regions are indicated in the base edge of the triangle. By additions of Si (immiscible in the solid state in the other two elements) two- and three-phase fields are formed. (*) three-phase region. In the two-phase region on the left examples of tie-lines are presented.
solubility in the solid and liquid states and Al–Sb presenting the formation of only one intermediate compound and no appreciable solid solubility. No ternary intermediate phases are present. The ternary Al–Bi–Sb triangle is composed by two triangular regions. The first, Al–Bi–AlSb, includes all the compositions corresponding to AlSb with additions of Al and Bi, that is, AlSb mixed with an excess of elemental (unreacted) Al and Bi. The second triangle, AlSb–Bi–Sb, includes compositions corresponding to AlSb with additions of Bi and Sb. In this case the resulting alloys are two-phase, that is, AlSb together with the second phase represented by the solid solution (Bi, Sb). The Al–Zn–Si is another example of simple ternary system; its isothermal section at 307°C is shown in Fig. 2.27 together with its boundary binaries. Si, in the solid state, is practically insoluble in Al or in Zn and in their binary solutions. In the
45
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems O
20 80
Mg
∗
τ1
SiO2
τ2
60
O
∗
MgO ∗
60
%
at. %
∗
∗
a t.
40
∗ 40
80
∗
20
MgO+ L+ Gas
Mg
20
∗
40
60
80
Si
at.% Si
Figure 2.28. Isothermal section of the Mg–Si–O diagram at a temperature of 1280°C and a pressure of 105 Pa. Two ternary point compounds are formed (τ1 Mg2SiO4, forsterite, and τ2 MgSiO3, protoenstatite). Notice along the Mg–Si edge, owing to the high temperature, the large range of the liquid phase (thick line). The three-phase regions are marked by ‘*’. A few tielines are indicated in the two-phase field (MgO liquid). The two-phase regions between point phases are represented by segments (linear regions of negligible thickness). In the oxygen-rich region gaseous O2 is present in equilibrium with the solid phases MgO and τ1, or τ1 τ2, or τ2 SiO2.
different fields of the ternary Al–Zn–Si composition triangle we have the binary (single or two phase) Al–Zn alloys with the mechanical addition of solid Si. Examples of isothermal sections of more complex, not only intermetallic, ternary systems are presented in Figs. 2.28 and 2.29. These systems show several point, line and field compounds. The isothermal sections are subdivided into numerous single, two- and three-phase regions. The three-phase regions, marked by an asterisk, are triangles (tie-triangles) the vertices of which give the compositions of the three coexisting phases either point compounds or saturated solid solutions. 2.3.2 Variable pressure phase diagrams Hydrostatic pressure is a variable that obviously affects phase equilibria. Atmospheric pressure may generally be considered negligible and therefore neglected in
46
Intermetallic Chemistry Al (a)
10 90
∗
Mg
30
τ
Al2Er
∗
∗
%
Al3Mg2 ∗ 50 ∗
∗
∗
AlEr ∗
∗
70
Al2Er3 AlEr2
∗
∗
30
∗
90
∗
10
∗
10
Mg
Al
Al12Mg17
Al3Er a t.
at. %
∗
30
50
70
90
Er
Er5Mg24 ErMg2 ErMg at.% Er Cu
(b) 20
∗
at.
τ4
Al
20
Al3Ti
∗
40
CuTi2 ∗
60
AlTi
20
∗
∗
40
Cu
τ1 τ2
CuTi
∗
∗
80
∗
Cu3Ti2
∗
∗
∗
60
∗
∗
60
Al2Cu
∗
τ3
%
AlCu
∗
Cu4Ti
at.
%
Al
∗
40 Al2Cu3
80
80
Ti
AlTi3
at.% Ti
Figure 2.29. Isothermal sections of ternary phase diagrams: (a) Al–Er–Mg system at 400°C, Saccone et al. (2002) and, (b) Al–Cu–Ti system at 540°C from Villars et al. (1995). A number of single-phase regions (dark grey) may be noticed, both extending from binary compounds and as ternary intermediate phases (τ) in the Al–Er–Mg system and the four phases τ1 τ2 τ3 and τ4 in the Al–Cu–Ti system. The three-phase fields are marked by an asterisk, in the Al–Er–Mg system a few tie-lines are indicated in the two-phase fields.
47
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems (a)
(b)
0
Solid −2 Gas Triple point
−3
15 Pressure (GPa)
−1 log10P (bar)
ε
Liquid
γ
10
5
α
L
δ −30
0
30
Temperature (°C)
500
1000 1500 2000
Temperature (°C)
Figure 2.30. Typical one-component systems: (a) Room temperature, room pressure region of the well-known P/T phase diagram of water (notice the logarithmic scale of pressure). (b) P–T phase diagram of elemental Fe. The fields of existence of the different forms of Fe are shown: α (body-centred cubic Fe), γ (face-centred cubic), δ (body-centred cubic, high-temperature form isostructural with α), ε (hexagonal close packed), L (liquid Fe). The gas phase field, owing to the pressure scale and the not very high temperatures considered, should be represented by a very narrow region close to the T axis.
the construction of metallurgical phase diagrams. There are diagrams, however, in which the state variable pressure is explicitly considered, such as those concerning alloys of volatile components, especially those at high or very high temperatures, and, of course, those related to investigations under great pressure. A few figures are here presented as a kind of ‘aide-memoire’ on this subject. Figs. 2.30 and 2.31 show diagrams in which the state variable pressure is explicitly considered. Fig. 2.30 shows two typical one-component systems. In Fig. 2.31(a) and (b), on the other hand, the equilibria relevant to a simple two-component system are represented. As an example of more complex systems and descriptions, the Ni–Mg system is shown in Fig. 2.32 (adapted from Levinsky 1997). In (a) an isobaric section of the diagram is shown (a low pressure has been considered in order to have a certain extension of the gas phase which consists essentially of Mg vapour). In Fig 2.32(b) there is an isothermal section of the diagram at 700°C. Notice, for different values of pressure, the change in the sequence of phases stable at different compositions. A value of the pressure close to atmosphere is approached at the top of the figure. In Fig 2.32(c) the usual T/x diagram is shown. This can be considered an isobaric phase diagram if pressure is relatively low but still higher than the sum of the equilibrium partial pressures of the components.
48
Intermetallic Chemistry (a)
(b)
SB, LB Pressure
Pressure
,G
L α,
G S B,
SA, LA
G+L
S+ L
,G LB
,G LA
G S A,
G+ S Temperature A
Compo
sition
e
mp
B Te
ure rat
Figure 2.31. Schematic representation of the P/T equilibria in a simple two-component system (forming continuous solid and liquid solutions). In (a) a perspective view of the P–T–X diagram is shown; in (b) its projection on the P/T plane. Notice the two single-component systems represented, for instance, for the component B by the three lines SB/G (sublimation line of B representing the gas/solid equilibrium), SB/LB (melting equilibrium of B) and the boiling line LB/G. The solid solution is indicated by α. Notice in (a) the isobaric and isothermal sections of the diagrams (compare with Fig. 2.1).
For a discussion of the role of non-hydrostatic pressure in phase equilibria investigations, the effects of applied stress and their consequences in metallurgy, geology, etc. see Cahn (1989). 2.3.2.1 Partial pressure as a variable. As mentioned in § 2.1, many types of thermodynamic variables may be used in the construction of phase diagrams. The various rules of construction, based on the laws of chemical thermodynamics, which apply to the different types of phase diagrams have been discussed in several books and papers (for instance, Pelton and Schmalzried 1973, Okamoto 1991, Pelton 1991). Following a classification proposed by Pelton, the various, bidimensional, phase diagrams may be subdivided into three types as follows: Type 1 are potential/potential phase diagrams. The potentials considered in chemical thermodynamics are: temperature (thermal potential), pressure (mechanical potential) and the chemical potentials of the N components μ1, μ2, μ3, …, μN. The P/T diagrams are examples of type 1 diagrams.
49
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems (a)
NiMg2
800
Ni2Mg
T (°C)
1000
600
400
Ni
20
40
60
80
at.% Mg
Mg
NiMg2
(b)
2
Ni2Mg
log p (Pa)
3
1
Ni
20
40
60
80
Mg
at.% Mg (c)
1000
600
200
20
NiMg2
Ni2Mg
T (°C)
1400
40
60
Ni
80
Mg at.% Mg
Figure 2.32. (a) Ni–Mg system. Isobaric section of the diagram at p 103 Pa (from Levinsky 1997). (b) Ni–Mg system. Isothermal section of the diagram at 700°C (from Levinsky 1997). (c) Ni–Mg system. T/x diagram at a pressure nearly constant and equal to the ambient.
50
Intermetallic Chemistry
Type 2 are represented by the plotting of one potential vs. the composition (for instance T vs. x at constant P or P vs. x at constant T, etc.). Type 3 are composition/composition phase diagrams, such as the isobarothermal sections of ternary systems shown in Figs. 2.25–2.27. Another example of type 2 diagrams may be represented by chemical potential/ composition diagrams. A version of such diagrams, useful with systems in which gaseous components are involved, is given by partial pressure vs. composition diagrams. A simple case, taken from Pelton and Thompson (1975), is shown in Fig. 2.33, where isothermal equilibria in the ternary system Ni–Co–O are presented. The plot of log pO2 vs. the molar fraction nCo/(nCo nNi) describes the oxidation behaviour of the alloys formed by Co and Ni, showing a complete mutual solid solubility. The oxidation product, formed at high values of pO2 is made up of the solid solution of NiO and CoO, also showing a complete mutual solubility. Notice that the general features of this diagram are similar to those of the diagram presented in Fig. 2.1(a) and in the first example of Fig. 2.9. In both cases we have two single-phase fields separated by a twophase field; the passage through them depends on the value of the ‘potential’ (thermal potential, temperature in one case, partial pressure of oxygen in the other). In both
− 6.6
3
log pO2 (atm)
(Ni, Co)O (s) − 7.0
2
y − 7.4
− 7.8
Ni
1 (Ni, Co) (s)
20
x1
40
60
x2
80
Co
at.% Co
Figure 2.33. Ni–Co–O phase diagram (isothermal section at 1600 K). log pO2 (oxygen partial pressure) is plotted against the molar fraction in the metallic alloy. The metallic alloy, (Ni, Co) solid solution is stable in (1) and the mixed oxide (Ni, Co)O solid solution in (3). In the intermediate region (2) we have coexistence of alloy and oxide. For the value of the partial oxygen pressure corresponding to y, within the two-phase field, we will have the alloy of composition x1 in equilibrium with an oxide containing the two metals in the ratio x2.
51
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
cases the two-phase field is delimited by two boundary lines (saturation curves) and within this field horizontal segments (tie-segments) connect the points (on the boundary lines) representing the two coexisting phases. 2.3.3 Equilibrium and reaction rate In previous paragraphs, a description has been given of equilibrium diagrams and transformations. Phase diagrams have come to be of great help in the preparation and investigation of alloys, ceramic materials, etc. Increasing attention is dedicated worldwide to the experimental determination of phase equilibria data, to their computation, compilation and assessment. For a given system a detailed description of the different phases and of their stability ranges of temperature and composition is indeed essential information for the evaluation of both basic and applicative properties. Notice, however, that in real situations, if for instance an alloy is subjected to a rapid change of temperature, it is possible that transformations occur which do not correspond to a sequence of true equilibrium states. It is possible that some transition will be missed or shifted to a different temperature or that a phase stable in a certain range of temperature (or pressure) will be retained in different conditions. In Table 2.4, as an aide-memoire, an indication is given of how the rate of temperature
Table 2.4. Average cooling rate as a parameter for material formation in different states. Cooling rate (Ks1)
Type of process
Materials
Method of realization
1010
Very slow crystallization
Minerals single crystals
Geological processes
107–104
Controlled crystallization
Natural and synthetic single crystals
Crystal growth from solutions, gels and by coarsening of solids
102–1
Common cooling
Metals, alloys, etc.
Furnace cooling
1–103
Quenching
Oxides, silicates, chalcogenides, metals, alloys
Casting, immersion
105–108
Freeze-in by ultrafast cooling
Metals
Melt splatting or spinning techniques
1011
Disordering on surfaces
Layers on materials
Vapour deposition, laser surface melting, ion beam modification
52
Intermetallic Chemistry 100
Temperature (K) (arbitrary scale)
E K
M
0
0
0.5
1.0
Molar fraction
Figure 2.34. For a hypothetical binary system, possible trends of equilibrium (E) and kinetic (K) phase diagram are shown. (M) indicates the appearance of transformations which could be observed in a metastable situation (adapted from Chvoj et al. 1991).
change in a material may be a deciding factor for the formation of a given structure and the acquisition of a certain set of properties. These points will be considered further on in Chapter 6, about alloy preparation methods. In some cases comprehensive information about the real behaviour is included in the phase diagrams themselves, obtaining the so-called kinetic and metastable phase diagrams. Following Chvoj et al. (1991), an example of such diagrams is presented in Fig. 2.34. The kinetic phase diagram (K) can correspond to a shift of the equilibrium phase diagram (E) to a lower temperature (under-cooling of the system). A metastable phase diagram (M) changes the character of the phase transitions. It would be possible, during its realization, to prepare new materials with new properties which cannot be obtained in near equilibrium conditions. A real example of such diagrams is reported in Fig. 2.35. Fig. 2.35 shows the equilibrium phase diagram of the system In–Pb (continuous lines) together with a metastable diagram. The procedure adopted in the determination of this phase diagram is briefly described here: it may be useful as an example
53
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
20
40
Mass% Pb 60
80
Temperature (°C)
300
250
200
150 (In) In
δ 20
(Pb) 40
60 at.% Pb
80
Pb
Figure 2.35. In–Pb diagram. The equilibrium diagram is shown (continuous line) together with a metastable solidus (dotted line).
of the significance of such diagrams and also of the difficulties often met in this kind of experimental investigation. The diagram was determined by Evans and Prince (1978). While performing thermal analysis they obtained a precise reproducible determination of the liquidus during solidification with a cooling rate of 1–1.5°C/min. They underlined the problems encountered in determining the solidus. During cooling from the liquidus, solidus temperatures were indeed obtained initially which do not correspond to the equilibrium curve (see the dotted line in Fig. 2.35). The solidified alloys were then annealed for several hours just below their measured solidus. On reheating, melting was observed at a higher temperature than previously measured. The samples were then re-annealed just below the new observed temperature before reheating. This cycle was repeated until the solidus temperature became reproducible (continuous line in Fig. 2.35). Metastable phases and equilibria may be obtained by fast cooling.
54
Intermetallic Chemistry
Temperature (°C)
1000
AuSb2
500 Es
Em1
ζ
Π
Em2
0 −100 20
Au
(Au)
60
40 at.% Sb
ζ
AuSb2 Π
80
Sb
Sb
Figure 2.36. Au–Sb system. The continuous line represents the (equilibrium) phase diagram containing the peritectic melting AuSb2 compound and a eutectic equilibrium (Es). Dotted lines represent equilibria (and phases) which may be observed on rapid cooling. The sequence of phases (ζ, AuSb2, π) detected in fast-quenched alloys and their composition ranges are shown in the lower part of the figure.
Considerations about metastable diagrams involving very rapid quenching from the liquid state date back to the work by Duwez (1967). An interesting contribution to this subject is summarized in Fig. 2.36. It shows the equilibrium diagram of the Au–Sb alloys and the sequence of phases observed by fast quenching (Giessen and Willens 1970, Massalski 1989). 2.3.3.1 Stable, metastable and unstable states: a simple analogy. A simple mechanical model is shown in Fig. 2.37: a block on a stand may be in different equilibrium states. In A and C the centre of gravity (G) of the block is lower than
55
Gravitational potential energy
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
B
B C′
A′
C
A′
A
A Position G
A
A′
B
C C′
B
A′
A
Figure 2.37. A simple mechanical system and its equilibrium states. Different positions of a block on a stand and the corresponding values of the gravitation potential energy are shown. Point G is the centre of gravity of the block. In A there is stable equilibrium, in C metastable, in B unstable. In A e C a transformation is taking place.
in any nearby position: the gravitational potential energy is a minimum. If the block position is slightly disturbed it will spontaneously (natural process) revert to its previous position (corresponding to a stable equilibrium). In B, on the contrary, G is higher than in any nearby position: the gravitational potential energy is a maximum and this corresponds to an unstable equilibrium. Position C does not correspond to the lowest minimum of the energy: following a small displacement, the block will return to the initial position whereas large displacements will move the block to the more stable position A. In A there is an (absolutely) stable equilibrium and in C a metastable equilibrium. For this mechanical system the stability conditions and the trends of spontaneous (natural) processes are related to minima (relative or absolute) of the gravitational potential energy. For physico-chemical systems, with materials in a closed system considered at constant temperature and pressure, the role of equilibrium indicator is played by the Gibbs free energy. The free energy of a multiphase system is given by ΣniGi where n i is the number of moles of the ith phase and Gi its molar free energy. The molar Gibbs free energy of a phase is related to its molar enthalpy Hi, molar entropy S i and absolute temperature T: Gi Hi TS i. The equilibrium state of the system corresponds to the minimum of the ΣniGi function.
56
Intermetallic Chemistry
2.3.3.2 Spinodal decomposition. An important kind of transformation involving non-equilibrium states corresponds to the so-called spinodal decomposition. This can be observed in phase diagrams such as those previously presented in Fig. 2.9(a), (b), (d), and may be described by the scheme shown in Fig. 2.38. In Fig. 2.38(a), a possible trend of the Gibbs energy of mixing in the solid state is shown for various temperatures (T1, T2, T3, T4): the corresponding de-mixing equilibria (miscibility gap) are presented in the lower part of the same figure. A curve of the ΔmixG such as that shown for T Tc (for instance T4) corresponds to minimum values for all the compositions. The single-phase alloy is stable. As T decreases, the ΔmixG values become less and less negative (however, they are always negative as xA : 1 and xB : 1) so the curves (below the critical, consolute, temperature Tc) show a peculiar trend with two minima. Common tangent lines (b1 b1 , b2 b2 , etc.) to these two parts of the curves define segments, the points of which correspond to ΔmixG values lower than those of the curves themselves. These tangent lines, therefore, define regions for which a two-phase, solid–solid, alloy is more stable than a singlephase one (in other words they define the ends of the tie-lines in the miscibility gap, the binodal points). These points connected by a continuous line in the lower part of 2.38(a) result in the miscibility gap itself. The inflection points we notice in the curves (points S) are the spinodal points; if we plot these points in the phase diagram we obtain the spinodal curve (dotted line in Fig. 2.38(a)). It is not part of the phase diagram but it gives important information on the phase transformation kinetics. Single-phase alloys, as obtained for instance by quenching from the one-phase region, within the two branch of the spinodal curve are unstable, while in the regions between the spinodal and the equilibrium (binodal) curves they are metastable. A simple explanation for this behaviour can be understood from an examination of Fig. 2.38(b) and (c). On the right (in Fig. 2.38(b)) a complete phase diagram is shown of alloys which, at low temperature in the solid state, are involved in a demixing equilibrium. Both the miscibility gap and the spinodal curve are represented. On the right, in the lower part of the figure (Fig. 2.38(c)) an enlarged portion of the ΔG vs. composition curve for a given temperature is shown. Notice the different composition scale in comparison with Fig. 2.38(a) and (b). We may now consider the different behaviour, on cooling from the single-phase field, of alloys placed in different ranges of compositions within the miscibility gap. To this end, on the ΔmixG curve, on both sides of the inflection point S, short segments connecting two points placed close to each other have been drawn (xm1 xm2 and xu1 xu2 respectively). The points of these segments represent the ΔmixG of two-phase alloys. In the composition range between the maximum and the spinodal (xs) a two-phase alloy, such as a mixture xu1 xu2, has therefore an overall free energy lower than that of any single-phase alloy of an intermediate composition, which is therefore unstable.
57
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems (a)
(b)
T1 b1
b1
S1
S1
T2
A
T3
b1
b1 S1
S1
xB
Free energy
Temperature
Tc
b2
b2
A
xb xs
B
xB
(c)
T4
T2 T1
α
b2
b2
T4 T3
L+α
Temperature
ΔG mixing (arbitrary units)
L
Δu S
t
Δm
B xb xm1 xs xm2
xu1 xu2
xB
Figure 2.38. Miscibility gap in the solid state. A possible trend of the Gibbs energy of mixing in the solid state is shown in (a) for various temperatures. The points b1 b1 , b2 b2 , etc. (and the corresponding binodal tangent lines) define the stable two-phase equilibrium and the corresponding tie-line. Plotting these points in the phase diagram results in the de-mixing curve (miscibility gap) presented in the lower part of the figure and in (b). The inflection points of the curves (points S) are the ‘spinodal points’; these points plotted in the phase diagram give the ‘spinodal curve’ (dotted line). On the right, a part of the Gibbs free energy of mixing curve is shown with the spinodal inflection S; xm1 and xm2 correspond to two compositions within the metastable region, xu1 and xu2 to two compositions in the unstable region. Δm, Δu are the free energy changes (increase or decrease) for an initial de-mixing process (t is a part of the line tangent to the minima b and b ).
In the region between the spinodal and the binodal points, on the contrary, the algebraic summation of the Gibbs free energies of two points such as xm1 and xm2 is higher than that of a single alloy of intermediate composition. At atomic scale, however, random shifts in the positions of atoms may result in local regions of compositional inhomogeneity, eventually leading to macroscopic phase separation.
58
Intermetallic Chemistry
The energy increase related to a compositional fluctuation resulting in a two-phase splitting may be considered as an energy threshold of activation of the de-mixing process. The spinodal curve thus defines a kinetic limit, not a phase boundary line. 2.4. REMARKS ON PHASE DIAGRAM DETERMINATION AND EVALUATION
The definition of the phase diagrams of different groups of substances such as the various alloy systems is an important step both in basic and applied sciences (materials science, metallurgy). Several interconnected activities may be related to this point such as experimental determination of phase diagrams, calculation (and prediction) of phase diagrams, their assessment, compilation, etc. A large number of reviews and books concerning different aspects of theory, measurement and application of phase diagrams and several compilations of binary and ternary system diagrams have been published; a selection of them is given in the reference list. 2.4.1 Experimental determination of phase diagrams The experimental methods of determining phase diagrams will be only briefly commented upon, in order to give an idea of the problems involved and of the connection between phase diagram science and other disciplines. A few special points will be considered in Chapter 6, dedicated to the preparation of intermetallics. It must however be pointed out that a sound experimental definition of a phase diagram can be obtained from the results of a number of concerted investigations such as thermal analysis, thermodynamic analysis, micrographic examination and phase analysis and identification by means of techniques such as X-ray diffraction measurements, microprobe analysis, etc. Among these methods, the old ‘classical’ thermal analysis techniques play a relevant role. This has been illustrated by different authors. Examples taken from the investigation of binary systems, rather than complex ones, are more frequently considered. This is because of the easier interpretation in such cases of the observed thermal effects and of the prominent role that thermal analysis methods may play in the definition of simple systems, while the ever-increasing complexity of systems being investigated requires the use of more and more auxiliary complementary techniques even if thermodynamic modelling may be very useful in simplifying the time-consuming experimental work. Emphasis has already been placed on the different experimental methodologies, for instance by Hume-Rothery et al. (1953) who stressed the need to use different complementary techniques in the definition of ternary or more complex systems. The necessity of combining thermal analysis with microscopic techniques was especially highlighted, for example, in the determination of solid ← → liquid equilibria.
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
59
In any case, going back to the beginning of the past century we may mention the pioneering investigation carried out by Parravano and Sirovich (1912) and Parravano (1914) in the determination by thermal analysis of the phase diagrams of quaternary alloy systems, such as Cu–Fe–Mn–Ni, Bi–Cd–Pb–Sn, Ag–Au–Cu–Ni. Considering now a few common methods and techniques for the experimental definition of a phase diagram, it may be useful to refer to their usual classification into two groups: polythermal and isothermal methods. 2.4.1.1 Polythermal methods. The temperature of an alloy sample is progressively changed, generally at a well-defined and controlled heating or cooling rate, as some properties of the sample itself are continuously measured. This could be either the volume, or the length, of the sample, or its electric conductivity, or its X-ray diffraction pattern, etc. A continuous trend is generally observed within a certain phase field, while some discontinuity or trend change may be noticed on crossing one of the characteristic lines of the diagram. One of the main techniques of this group is thermal analysis in which the cooling or heating curves themselves are analysed and of which several variants are known (thermal analysis proper, differential thermal analysis, differential scanning calorimetry, etc.). A scheme of such a technique is presented in Fig. 2.39. In principle two similar crucibles containing respectively a sample of the alloy under investigation and an inert reference specimen are cooled (or heated) together in a furnace. By means of conveniently inserted thermocouples it is possible to follow: (1) the continuous reference temperature trend of the reference specimen, (2) the temperature trend of the specimen under examination and (3) the temperature difference (ΔT ) between the two. If, at a certain temperature, there is a change in the structure of the sample (that is, if a boundary line in the corresponding phase diagram is crossed), a variation in the slope of the temperature vs. time curve is recorded. As a consequence the ΔT vs. time curve (or vs. temperature) shows a deviation from the baseline. The temperatures at which such deviations are observed are used to build the phase diagram. For the Cu–Mg alloy system, as an example, the phase diagram is shown in Fig. 2.40 together with the corresponding T/ΔT graphs obtained from the thermal analysis of two selected alloys. 2.4.1.2 Isothermal methods. In principle these methods imply the preparation of a certain number of alloy specimens of different compositions and their examination at the same given temperature. Important methods are those based on observations carried out under a microscope. An example of such an analysis is given in Fig. 2.41 where the photomicrographs of two alloys of the Cu–Mg phase diagram are shown. These pictures, taken with a reflection microscope, allow identification
60
Intermetallic Chemistry (a)
(b) To T R
S
Temperature (T )
TS
R
F Time (t ) (c) t (or T ) TR
0 TS −TR
TS
Figure 2.39. A sketch of a type of differential thermal analysis ‘head’ is shown in (a). The two small crucibles (internal diameter 4–6 mm) contain the sample (S) and the reference (R, inert material). The junctions of two thermocouples (TS, TR) are inserted in the crucibles. They give the temperature of the sample and the ΔT between sample and reference. The DTA head is inserted inside a furnace (F), the heating and cooling regime of which may be conveniently controlled. In (b) typical trends of temperature vs. time are presented: T0 is the controlled furnace temperature trend, TR is the T trend of the inert reference specimen, TS is the trend observed for a sample undergoing some transformation. The corresponding differential curve (ΔT vs. time (or vs. temperature)) is shown in (c).
of the phases and their morphology which may be related to the specific transformations undergone by the alloy. For the alloy marked ‘1’, on cooling, the liquidus curve was intercepted at a relatively high temperature and there was a fair temperature interval during which for the Mg crystals it was possible to grow within the remaining part of liquid. The solidification finally ended at the eutectic temperature. At this temperature the eutectic crystallization occurs (L ← → (Mg) Cu2Mg) in isothermal conditions, where the simultaneous separation of the two solid phases results in a fine mixture
61
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems 1084.87
2
1 797
800
725 568 485
500 400
(Mg)
0 10 Mg
20
30
552 MgCu2
700 650 600
2
Temperature
1
(Cu)
900
Mg2Cu
Temperature (°C)
1000
40 50 60 at.% Cu
70
80
90 100 Cu
ΔT
Figure 2.40. Phase diagram of the Mg–Cu alloy system. For the alloys marked (1) (at 5 at.% Cu) and (2) (at 20 at.% Cu), the DTA curves are shown on the right. Notice that, on cooling, a sharp thermal effect due to the invariant eutectic transformation is observed. At higher temperature the crossing of the liquidus curves is detected. (The coordinates of the eutectic point are 485°C and 14.5 at.% Cu.)
(a)
(b)
Figure 2.41. Microscopic examination of Mg–Cu alloys. The micrographs of the same two alloys considered in Fig. 2.40 are shown. Small pieces of the alloys were polished by using finer and finer abrasive powders (Al2O3, diamond) in order to obtain a shiny surface. This appears as a continuous white surface under a metallographic reflection microscope. When the sample, however, is gently etched by using a convenient reactant (in this specific case a dilute water–alcoholic solution of HNO3) phases of different chemical composition (here Mg and the compound CuMg2) are differentiated. The more reactive phase (in this case Mg) is more deeply etched, losing its brilliance, and it appears dark under the microscope.
62
Intermetallic Chemistry
of intermixed small crystals of the two solids. For the alloy marked ‘2’, notice the primary crystallization of Cu2Mg (white crystals) in small amounts, owing to the proximity of the alloy to the eutectic composition. Notice the larger quantity of ‘eutectic mixture’ which is identical to that observed in Fig. 2.41(a). The composition of alloy 2 is indeed closer to the eutectic than that of alloy 1. The above comments also highlight the fact that alloy morphology could provide information about the aspect of the phase diagrams and the type of transformation to which the alloy was subjected. A rich bibliography is available, as also are atlases. The observation under a light microscope may be complemented by examination under an electron microscope, possibly equipped with microanalysis devices to analyse point by point the composition of the sample and of its constituent phases. Several different methods are available for carrying out an analysis of the samples. Among the different techniques employed in solid-state physical chemistry, the diffractometric ones certainly play a relevant role; powder X-ray diffractometry, for instance, has been and is systematically used not only for the determination of the crystal structure of the various phases, but also, as an analytical tool, for their identification in complex samples. In the diffraction patterns obtained from a series of alloys having gradually changing compositions, it is indeed possible, even in a routine investigation, to recognize the groups of reflections characteristic of each phase and to follow their appearing or vanishing at certain compositions. Moreover, small changes in the diffraction angles of these reflections, characteristic of each single phase, are due to progressive variations of the unit cell dimensions and may be related to the formation of solid solution ranges. On the other hand, an accurate analysis of these diffraction patterns, possibly combined with single crystal diffractometry (and/or electron diffractometry, etc.), will give information about the formation mechanism of the solid solution phase (ordered or disordered substitution, structure modulation, etc.). Isothermal examination can be more easily carried out at room temperature. However, special instruments (microscopes, diffractometers, etc.) and techniques can be used for high- (or low-) temperature work. In a number of cases, an investigation carried out on samples annealed at the selected temperature, and then quenched, could be an alternative to direct hightemperature examination. It is possible indeed that the structure which is stable at high temperature is maintained on quenching. 2.4.1.3 Recent developments and prospects of X-ray powder diffraction methods. In the preceding paragraph a few comments have been made about diffractometry and its uses in the analysis of materials. However it is not possible to give here an account of this subject: its principles and underlying theories, its experimental techniques and
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
63
related interpretation and application methods are fully described in several treatises, such as the book series edited by the International Union of Crystallography (IUCr), while references are often contained in books of General or Physical Chemistry, Materials Science, etc. In this paragraph, therefore, we will give only a few reading suggestions with special attention to the powder diffraction methods. Recent developments and prospects of these methods have been discussed in a chapter by Schneider et al. (2001). It was underlined that these methods are widely applied for the characterization of crystalline materials (phase identification, quantitative analysis, determination of structure imperfections, crystal structure determination and analysis of 3D microstructural properties). Phase identification was traditionally based on a comparison of observed data with interplanar spacings and relative intensities (d and I) listed for crystalline materials. More recent search–match procedures, based on digitized patterns, and Powder Diffraction File (International Centre for Diffraction Data, USA.) containing powder data for hundreds of thousands substances may result in a fast efficient qualitative analysis. The determination of the amounts of different phases present in a multi-component sample (quantitative analysis) is based on the so-called Rietveld method. Procedures for pattern indexing, structure solution and refinement of structure model are based on the same method. The Rietveld method (1967, 1969) was originally conceived as a method of refining crystal structures using neutron diffraction data. The powder diffraction data are recorded in digitized form, that is, as numerical intensity values, yi at each of several thousands equal increment in the pattern. Depending on the method the increments may be for instance in the scattering angle 2θ, typically with a step size from 0.01° to 0.05°, for the fixed wavelength X-ray technique. A best (leastsquares) fit to all the yi is sought; the quantity minimized, by means of a suitable computer program, in the least-square refinement is the residual: Sy Σiwi(yi yci)2 where wi 1/yi, and yi observed intensity at the i step and yci calculated intensity at the i step, and the sum is over all data points. The calculated intensities depend on several parameters which may be refined and defined: these include the structural characteristics (the cell parameters, see Chapter 3) of the phase, its quantity in a multiphase sample, etc. In a paper by Albinati and Willis (1982) the application of the Rietveld method in neutron and X-ray powder diffraction was discussed considering the different experimental techniques of obtaining the diffraction patterns. For a detailed description of the method and its applications see a reference publication (Young 1995). See also Jenkins and Snyder (1996). A frequently used calculation program for the
64
Intermetallic Chemistry
quantitative Rietveld refinement of the X-ray and neutron diffraction data is the ‘FULLPROF’ program (Rodriguez-Carvajal 1993, Roisnel and RodriguezCarvajal 2001) whereas general program packages for handling diffraction data are for instance SHELXL-97 (Sheldrick 1997) and the Nonius Kappa package (1998). Notice, finally, that from an instrumental point of view the development of diffraction methods may be based on the availability of fast detectors and high brightness X-ray (and also neutron) sources. By using synchrotron X-ray radiation owing to its high intensity it is possible to study reactions on a sub-second time-scale and for instance follow the transformation kinetics in a self-propagating solid-state ‘combustion’ reaction. Various applications and expected breakthrough have been discussed by Schneider et al. (2001). 2.4.1.4 The diffusion couple technique in phase diagram determination. Several techniques and methods based on different experimental arrangements and relying on the measurement of various properties have been devised and applied to the determination of phase diagrams. Many of them have a long history, well-founded basis and have been used in the analysis and definition of thousands of phase diagrams. Short outlines of some important methods have been reported in the previous paragraphs; as a conclusion to this subject just another technique will be mentioned in the following. It is the elegant diffusion couple technique which has become more and more popular due to the improvement and increased availability of methods (such as the EPMA, electron probe micro-analysis) for point microanalysis. This technique proved to be a reliable tool in the investigation of isothermal sections of ternary systems by itself or in combination with more traditional methods of equilibrated alloys. In principle the preparation of a solid-state diffusion couple consists in bringing two (or more) materials in such intimate contact that, when maintained at a conveniently high temperature, each diffuses into the other. To this end, small blocks (discs for instance) of the component materials are polished flat on the bonding surfaces and clamped together. They are then annealed, in vacuum or inert atmosphere, at the selected temperature and eventually quenched. The resulting morphology which develops during the solid-state inter-diffusion and reaction can be examined by using standard metallographic methods. A schematic illustration of the method, and of the correlation between binary phase diagram and the one-phase layers formed in a diffusion couple, is shown in Fig. 2.42 adapted from Rhines (1956). The one-phase layers are separated by parallel straight interfaces, with fixed composition gaps, in a sequence dictated by the phase diagram. The absence, in a binary diffusion couple, of two-phase layers follows directly from the phase rule. In a ternary system, on the other hand (preparing for instance a diffusion couple between a block of a binary alloy and a piece of a third
65
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
T (°C)
1200
800
β (Cu)
γ
(Cu)
ε
β′
400
Cu
δ
20
40
60
80
at.% Zn
γ
ε
Zn
(Zn)
Figure 2.42. The Cu–Zn system: phase diagram and microstructure scheme of the diffusion couple obtainable by maintaining Cu and Zn blocks in contact for several days at 400°C. Shading indicates subsequent layers, each one corresponding to a one-phase region. The two-phase regions are represented by the interfaces between the one-phase layers (adapted from Rhines 1956).
component), it is possible to develop two-phase areas in the diffusion zone because of the higher degree of freedom. A systematic description of the diffusion couple technique and of its application to phase diagram determination has been presented by Kodentsov et al. (2001). The use of different modifications of the method and of its applications to the investigation of ternary systems are described and discussed. A summary is also given of the experimental procedures and of the micro-analytical techniques to be used in the determination of concentration profiles along a diffusion couple sample and in the local analysis of small areas of interest. Different measurement techniques have been mentioned such as the Auger electron spectroscopy, the secondary ion mass spectrometry, the Rutherford backscattering spectrometry, the glancing angle X-ray diffraction, EPMA and analytical electron microscopy. Especially interesting for the examination of bulk diffusion couple is the EPMA.
66
Intermetallic Chemistry
With this technique, under an especially equipped electron microscope, highenergy electrons are focused on a fine probe and directed at the point of interest in the specimen. The electrons interacting with the sample atoms cause the emission of the characteristic X-rays, which are detected and identified for qualitative analysis and used, generally through suitable standardization, to perform also a quantitative analysis. As concluding remarks about these techniques, their increasing interest and the advantages of their combination with other techniques, we may mention, as an example, that within the European research project COST 535, concerning the ‘Thermodynamics of Alloyed Aluminides’, a meeting (Düsseldorf, December 2004) was dedicated to ‘The Diffusion Couple Technique’, presenting the principles of the method and the results obtained in the examination of several alloy systems. Zhao (2004) has developed an efficient variant of the diffusion couple technique (the ‘diffusion multiple approach’). A general treatment of a diffusion-controlled growth of a stoichiometric intermetallic in reaction between two two-phase alloys has been introduced by Paul et al. (2006). A reaction couple in which a layer of Co2Si is formed during interdiffusion from its adjacent saturated phases was used as a model system. In the discussion it has been emphasized that the diffusion couple is undoubtedly one of the most efficient and versatile techniques in solid-state science: it is therefore desirable to have alternative theories that enable us to deduce the highest possible amount of information from the data that are relatively easily attainable in this type of experiments. 2.4.1.5 The characterization and 3D representation of materials microstructure. Concerning micro-analytical techniques and their improvement, and their application to microstructural material investigation, interesting developments have been discussed and reported (Uchic et al. 2002) in the proceedings of a symposium dedicated to the characterization and representation of materials microstructure in 3D. Materials structure was intended to mean not only morphological and topological information, but also chemical and crystallographic information on various dimensional scales. It was observed that a common practice is to examine 2D planar sections of a material microstructure and then to make inferences (using stereological procedures) about the true spatial morphology, distribution and connectivity of the microstructure elements. It was underlined, however, that the need for inference could be reduced if one can obtain a direct 3D sampling of the microstructure. Advances towards this end in both destructive and non-destructive techniques have been described and discussed. The following are examples of methods which have been considered: 3D characterization by serial sectioning; focused ion beam tomography; X-ray micro-tomography; 3D X-ray crystal microscopy; computer
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
67
reconstruction of 3D microstructure based on orthogonal observation sections; new stereological methods of analysis.
2.4.2 Assessment and calculation of phase diagrams 2.4.2.1 Assessment of phase diagrams. Selection, designing and planning of materials are relevant subjects from a fundamental point of view but, of course, are also interrelated basic topics in material science and engineering. Study and classification of preparation methods and of constitutional and fundamental properties followed by an investigation of application and performance characteristics are essential aspects of such topics and procedures. Among the basic properties of a given material the constitutional characteristics play a special preliminary role: indeed the structural and thermodynamic properties define the existence and the stability conditions (stability ranges of temperature, of composition, etc.) of the various phases of which the material consists. In other words, this means that one essential requirement in the evaluation and prediction of the performance of a material is the knowledge of its phase diagram, and we actually notice an ever-increasing attention to several aspects of phase diagram science in metallurgy but also in ceramurgy, polymer science, etc. A first problem, after the experimental analyses, is related to the collection (critical collection, assessment) of the experimental data. Different problems however have to be faced in the assessment procedures (data availability and reliability, agreement among data obtained by different authors and by using different methods, coherence of experimental data and trends with general principles and rules, etc.). Notice that a presently accepted version of a phase diagram generally is the result of a comparison and selection among the (often partial) data published for the given systems in several tens (in some cases hundreds) of papers. This of course is a problem common to several disciplines; as regards however alloy systems and related topics, such as intermetallic structures, a wide bibliography is available, a selection of which is collected in the reference list. Important steps towards an optimization of the procedures in order to make available to the community of chemists, physicists and material scientists sound databases for metallic phase description, transformation and equilibria have been performed in the course of time. A significant indication of this fact is given, for instance, by the growth in the number of publications, reference books and journals in which data relevant to phase diagrams are systematically reported and assessed, such as ‘Constitution of Binary Alloys’ Hansen and Anderko (1958), Elliott (1965), Shunk (1969), ‘Binary Alloy Phase Diagrams’ Massalski et al. (1990), ‘Phase Diagrams for Binary Alloys, Desk Handbook’ Okamoto (2000), ‘Multicomponent Alloy Constitution Bibliography 1955–1973’ Prince (1978), ‘Handbook of Ternary Alloy Phase Diagrams’ Villars
68
Intermetallic Chemistry
et al. (1995), Pauling File (Villars et al. 2004 and subsequent editions), etc. Another clear indication of the relevance of these data and of their reliability is given by the different actions, often organized on an international basis, devoted to the assessment and critical evaluation of phase equilibria data. We may mention the activity of several institutions and bodies such as IAEA (International Atomic Energy Agency, Vienna) which, in special issues of its ‘Atomic Energy Review’ dedicated to various metals of nuclear interest, has published critical collections of physico-chemical properties of their compounds and alloys. APDIC, that is the Alloy Phase Diagram Commission which coordinates an international program on the subject and periodically publishes reports on the Journal of Phase Equilibria (now Journal of Phase Equilibria and Diffusion), MSIT® that is the Material Science International Team under the direction of G. Effenberg (MSI, Stuttgart) systematically organizes the collection, assessment and publication of the data (phase diagrams, phase crystal structures, thermodynamics) of large groups of ternary alloys. Several, critically evaluated, ternary alloy systems which have undergone a thorough review process have been previously published in the series ‘Ternary Alloys – A Comprehensive Compendium of Evaluated Constitutional Data and Phase Diagrams’; promoted by Petzow and Effenberg (1988 et seq., 19 volumes) and are now under publication in the New Series of ‘Landolt-Börnstein’ (Effenberg and Ilyenko 2004). A systematic contribution to the metals and alloys properties is given by the multi-volume ASM Handbooks (ASM International). See also in the following paragraphs on ‘Thermodynamic calculation’ (§ 2.4.2.2), some information concerning international efforts in critically collecting data about intermetallic systems. As a conclusion to these notes on the assessment and compilation of intermetallic data, we mention a few examples of papers in which criteria to be followed in order to ‘extract’ from literature data the ‘best’ version of a phase diagram have been discussed. These are Morral and Gupta (1991) (a figure of merit for predicted phase diagram), Okamoto and Massalski (1991, 1993) (thermodynamically improbable phase diagrams and guidelines for binary phase diagram assessment). See also various comments in several chapters in Cahn (2001). 2.4.2.2 Calculation, thermodynamic optimization of phase diagrams. The knowledge of phase equilibria, phase stability, phase transformations is an important reference point in the description and understanding of the fundamental properties of the alloys and of their possible technological applications. This interest has promoted a multi-disciplinary and multi-national effort dedicated not only to experimental methods, but also to techniques of optimization, calculation and prediction of
69
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
phase diagrams, that is to the so-called CALPHAD methods (CALculation of PHAse Diagrams) (see Figure 2.43). Several approaches to this problem have been considered starting from the first calculations carried out by van Laar (1908) and the contributions given by Meijering
THEORETICAL CALCULATIONS Quantum mechanics, statistical thermodynamics, etc.
ESTIMATES According to CHEMICAL CRITERIA Periodic properties, Pettifor stability maps, Gschneidner relations, etc.
EXPERIMENTS Phase identification and characterization: Optical and electron microscopy, X-ray diffractometry, dilatometry, resistometry, etc.
Optimization
First principles or semiempirical calculations
Selection of suitable THERMODYNAMIC MODELS (with adjustable parameters) for the phases
EXPERIMENTS Thermal analysis, calorimetry, emf, vapour pressure measurements
EVALUATION OF PARAMETERS by error minimization procedures Models cannot reproduce input data: NEW MODELS NEEDED
Data added to DATA BASES, BOOKS, etc.
Analytical expression of THERMODYNAMIC FUNCTIONS of the phases
Calculation CALCULATED THERMODYNAMICS AND PHASE EQUILIBRIA
Input data insufficient for determination of adjustable parameters: NEW EXPERIMENTS NEEDED
EVALUATION OF PARAMETERS by error minimization procedures GRAPHICAL PRESENTATION of phase diagrams, thermodynamic functions, etc.
APPLICATIONS
Figure 2.43. Optimization, calculation, prediction of phase diagrams: an indication of the working scheme of the CALPHAD method is shown.
70
Intermetallic Chemistry
(1963). Since the systematic introduction of electronic computers, however, and with special attention to metal systems, it is worth mentioning the pioneering work and the comprehensive summary already presented by Kaufman et al. (see Kaufman and Bernstein 1970) and the more recent discussion by Massalski (1989). The role of a thermodynamic approach is well known: a thermodynamic check, optimization and prediction of the phase diagram may be carried out by using methods such as those envisaged by Kubaschewski and Evans (1958), described by Kaufman and Nesor (1973), Ansara et al. (1978), Hillert (1981) and very successfully implemented by Lukas et al. (1977, 1982), Sundman et al. (1985). The knowledge (or the prediction) of the intermediate phases which are formed in a certain alloy system may be considered as a preliminary step in the more general and complex problem of assessment and prediction of all the features of phase equilibria and phase diagrams. See also Aldinger and Seifert (1993). It should be remembered that the CALPHAD approach is based on the hypothesis that, for all the phases and structures existing across the complete alloy system, entire Gibbs energy vs. composition curves may be constructed even by extrapolation into regions where they are unstable or metastable. A particular case concerns the pure component elements for which the relative Gibbs energy for the different crystal structures (the so-called lattice stabilities) must also be established and defined as a function of temperature (and pressure). Evidence relevant to the phase stability problem has been given by Massalski (1989). The so-called compound energy formalism was constructed by Hillert and Staffansson (1970) in order to describe models of the thermodynamic properties of phases with two or more sublattices showing a variation in composition, which therefore belong to the class of solution phases. A review of this formalism and a summary of its applications have been recently published by Hillert (2001) and Frisk and Selleby (2001). Finally, the significant progress and the limits of the ab initio, first-principle, calculations (Hafner 1987, 1989, Colinet 2003, Pettifor 2003), and the usefulness of a number of semi-empirical approaches have to be pointed out. Several schemes and criteria have been suggested to forecast and/or optimize the data concerning certain properties. In the following a short outline will be reported on some prediction methods based on selected correlations between elemental properties and structure formation. A significant review of several aspects of the phase diagram computation (phase diagram calculations in teaching, research and industry) has been published by Chang (2006). The relationship between the characteristic features of a phase diagram and the relative thermodynamic stabilities of the phases involved has been there underlined and exemplified. Representative examples of binary, ternary and highorder alloy systems have been presented. Moreover a number of applications have
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
71
been illustrated. A first example was concerned with a rapid and efficient approach for generating a thermodynamic description of the quaternary Mo–Si–B–Ti system for identifying potential alloy compositions possibly exhibiting desirable microstructures for high-temperature applications. A second example concerned computations intended to define optimum compositions of Ti additions to glass-forming quaternary (Al, Cu, Ni, Zr) alloys in order to improve their glass-forming ability. The identification, through computational thermodynamics, of potential binary alloys with a tendency to form, via rapid quenching processes, glass or amorphous alloy thin films was also presented together with a discussion of possible applications of such materials. Another example examined consisted in the use of computational thermodynamics for selecting convenient filler metals to minimize cracks in welding multi-component aluminium alloys, and finally it was shown that computational thermodynamics can replace experimentation in procedures such as the certification of alloys for commercialization. (The alloy Ti6Al4V, that is, the Ti-based alloy with 6 mass% Al and 4 mass% V, was especially employed to illustrate this point.) Another relevant aspect of Chang’s review and of the included description of the CALPHAD approach is also the presentation of the continuing need to improve the thermodynamic phase models and a summary of the most useful ones. (i) Ab initio, first-principle calculations. The ab initio calculations are intended to obtain for the compounds their total energies, having only as input data the atomic numbers of the component elements and their atomic positions in the unit cell of a given crystal structure. From the computed energies, heats of formation, lattice parameters, relative stabilities of their structures, etc. may be derived for the compounds. Major problems are presented by calculations concerning liquid alloys and disordered solid solutions. From a combination of these results the calculation of first-principle (binary) phase diagrams could also be performed. Several relevant examples of review papers dedicated to this subject are available. See for example: Pettifor (1977), Saunders et al. (1988), Hafner (1992), Miodownik (1992), Turchi and Sluiter (1993), Carlsson and Meschter (1994), Turchi (1994), Pettifor et al. (1995), de Fontaine (1996). The state of the art has been summarized by Colinet (2003) who reported a description of the ab initio calculation methods of energies of formation for intermetallic compounds and a review of the aluminium-based compounds studied. In its conclusions, this paper underlined that the complete ab initio calculation of complex phase diagrams is not close at hand. However, calculation of phase diagrams in systems, where experimental data are missing, could, in the future, be performed by combination of CALPHAD routines and ab initio calculations of formation energies or mixing energies.
72
Intermetallic Chemistry
A relevant contribution to the presentation of ab initio methods and of their application is a paper by Curtarolo et al. (2005). In the introduction the work by de Fontaine (1994) and the paper by Sluiter et al. (1988) are mentioned which contain full bibliographic references to the ab initio studies on binary and ternary phase stability until that date and, respectively, the earliest complete ab initio computation of a binary phase diagram. Curtarolo et al. (2005) presented the results of a first-principle study for 80 binary systems comparing these data with those contained in experimental compilations. According to their introductive remarks, 14 080 total energies on 176 crystal structures in these 80 binary alloys were computed. The energies were computed in the so-called local density (LDA) or generalized gradient approximation (GGA) to density functional theory which were considered standard approaches to first-principle studies on solids. As general references, see for instance: Perdew and Zunger (1981), Perdew and Wang (1992), Vanderbilt (1990), Kresse and Furthmuller (1996), Kresse and Joubert (1999). The formation energy for each structure was determined with respect to the most stable structure of the pure elements. It was underlined that to determine the ground state of a system one needs to find as a function of composition, the ordered compounds that have energy lower than any other structure or any linear combination of structures corresponding to the given composition. The set of ground state structures forms, in a energy vs. composition diagram, a convex hull (all other structures have an energy that falls above the set of tie-lines connecting the energy of ground states). This convex hull may be considered a representation of the Gibbs free energy of the alloy at zero temperature. As a specific example mention can also be given to the work carried out by Ghosh on the alloys of the fourth group metals (Ghosh and Asta 2005, Ghosh et al. 2006). In Fig. 2.44 the ab initio calculated enthalpy of formation of the Ti–Zn intermetallics is shown. The following introductive sentences may be quoted from the abstract of this work: ‘The total energies and equilibrium cohesive properties of 48 intermetallics in the Ti–Zn system are calculated from first principle employing electronic density functional theory, ultra-soft potentials and the GGA. Selected experiments are also performed to determine the heat of formation by direct reaction calorimetry and to measure the isotropic elastic moduli by pulse-echo technique. In alloys containing 50 at.% or less Ti, where it was possible to synthesize nearly single-phase specimens, the calculated heats of formation agree within a few kJ/mol of the direct reaction calorimetry data, while the calculated isotropic elastic constants agree within 5% of the experimental values’. (ii) Semi-empirical methods and rules. The prediction of the phase diagram aspect and/or of the thermodynamic function values has been the subject of a number
73
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
Enthalpy of formation (ΔH f) (kJ/atom)
10
5
0
6
−5
−10 5
1 2
−15
−20 Ti
3 20
40
60 at.% Zn
4 80
Zn
Figure 2.44 The Ti–Zn system. The calculated enthalpy of formation of the intermetallics and the resulting convex hull are shown according to Ghosh et al. (2006). Experimental values of about 22–19 kJ/mol of atoms were measured in the composition range 50–75 at.% Zn. The calculations yield a ground state convex hull defined by the following structures: (1) Ti3Zn–L12; (2) Ti2Zn–C11b; (3) TiZn–B19; (4) TiZn3–L12; (5) Ti3Zn22–tP100; (6) TiZn16–oS68.
of papers. Several empirical or semi-empirical rules and formulae have been proposed which may be useful in order to have a first, even if approximate, description of the characteristics of a given system. Notice that this kind of relations may be substantially more convenient when used in the description (in the comparison) of the properties of well-defined limited groups of similar alloys. Examples of such relations have been presented in § 2.2.1.3 describing the Pettifor parameters and maps, the evaluation of the heat of formation according to Miedema, etc. A few more examples have been collected in Chapter 4. (iii) Thermodynamic calculation. In the last few years several improvements and developments in phase properties ‘modelling’, together with an increasing availability of numerical methods and computer software, have allowed a systematic application of thermodynamic analysis to phase diagrams. As sketched in the scheme presented in Fig. 2.43, it is possible to perform an assessment of all the available experimental data (phase diagram measurements, but also thermodynamic data) to represent the Gibbs energy of all the phases (as function
74
Intermetallic Chemistry
of temperature and composition) by means of ‘optimized equations’. An optimized version of the phase diagrams can then be calculated from these equations. The data can be interpolated and extrapolated, it is also possible to obtain an estimate of ternary and more complex diagrams, starting from the optimized data of the binary systems involved. These techniques, generally known as CALPHAD methods, minimize the number of experimental determinations to be carried out for a full phase diagram definition, and are therefore important in the analysis of complex systems. There are several computer programs available for performing the CALPHAD optimization, starting from the cited work by Kaufman and Bernstein (1970). A detailed presentation of the CALPHAD method with the description of thermodynamic models, computational methods and a discussion of the extensions and applications of these methodologies is available as an authoritative reference book by Saunders and Miodownik (1998). A very recent treatise on this subject is ‘Computational Thermodynamics’ by Lukas et al. (2007). Some guidelines for thermodynamic optimization of phase diagrams have been published by Kumar and Wollants (2001). One of the first programs is the Lukas program described by Lukas et al. (1977, 1982), which has modules to perform thermodynamic optimization of phase diagrams. A short reference list of recent frequently used programs (generally available for a fee) is given below: ● Thermo-Calc (Sundman et al. 1985, Andersson et al. 2002). It features a wide spectrum of thermodynamic models, databases and modules making it possible to perform calculations on most problems involving phase equilibria (phase transformation, stable and metastable equilibria, etc.). The calculations are performed using databases produced by an expert evaluation of experimental data. There are thermodynamic databases available for many different systems and applications. ● DICTRA (Diffusion simulation software) (Borgenstam et al. 2000). DICTRA (coupled with Thermo-Calc) is a software for the simulation of diffusion in multi-component alloy systems (processes which can be simulated are for example the homogenization of alloys, micro-segregation during solidification, carburizing, and decarburizing, of steels, etc.). © ● FactSage (Bale et al. 2002) which resulted from the fusion of the FACTWin/F*A*C*T and the ChemSage/SOLGASMIX (Eriksson and Hack, 1990) thermochemical packages (see www.crct.polymtl.ca and www. gtt-technologies.de). ● Pandat software package and applications (Chen et al. 1993). Pandat is a software package for multi-component phase diagram calculations. Given a set of thermodynamic parameters for all phases in a system and a set of user constraints, Pandat automatically calculates the stable phase diagram without
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
●
●
75
requiring prior knowledge of the diagram. Details and applications have been described by Chen et al. (2002, 2003): in particular, as an example, an application using PanEngine (the calculation engine of Pandat) was given for coupling micro-modelling to predict microstructure and micro-segregation of aluminium alloys. MTDATA (Dinsdale et al. 1988, Davies et al. 2002). It is a software/database package for calculating multi-component phase diagrams. Depending on the data available, it finds applications in chemistry, metallurgy, geochemistry, materials science (interactions for instance between liquid and solid alloys, matte, slag and gas phase can be treated) (www.ues-software.com/mcpa/ homepage.htm). DATABASES (thermodynamic and diffusion). The calculations require a database for the material systems of interest. For the commercially important materials, databases have been developed by teams of experts critically assessing all experimental phase equilibria and thermodynamic data and, for the complex systems relevant for applications, by extrapolating from binary, ternary and quaternary subsystems. Databases, generally available for a fee, often together with software packages, have been prepared for several types of materials and systems. Typical examples are: a database developed for Fe-rich alloys containing data for up to 15 components, and 55 types of phases or similar databases for Mg-rich, Al-rich, Ni-rich, Ti-rich alloys. Other databases are available for different types of materials: semiconductors, solder alloys, ceramic systems, slag, molten salts, etc. The thermodynamic optimization of a complex system (with the implied assessment of its subsystems) generally requires the cooperative complementary lasting commitment of several experts. An answer to this request has been given by a number of international research projects; as an example, a few so-called European COST projects (European COoperation in the field of Scientific and Technical research). COST actions active in the specific field are, for instance, the COST 531 and 535 Actions. The former is dedicated to the investigation of Pb-free soldering alloys, that is, of low melting alloy systems which, for soft soldering, could replace the alloys of Pb owing to the toxicity of this element. The latter is dedicated to the experimental and computational investigation of complex aluminium alloy systems.
REFERECES
Albinati, A. and Willis, B.T.M. (1982) J. Appl. Crystallogr, 15, 361. Aldinger, F. and Seifert, H.J. (1993) Z. Metallkd, 84, 2.
76
Intermetallic Chemistry
Andersson, J.-O., Helander, T., Höglund, L., Shi, P.F. and Sundman, B. (2002) Calphad, 26, 273. Ansara, I., Bernard, C., Kaufman, L. and Spencer, P. (1978) Calphad, 2, 1. Bale, C.W., Chartrand, P., Degterov, S.A., Eriksson, G., Hack, K., Ben Mahfoud, R., Melancon, J., Pelton, A.D. and Peterson, S. (2002) Calphad, 26, 189. Borgenstam, A., Engström, A., Höglund, L. and Ågren, J. (2000) J. Phase Equilib., 21, 269. Cahn, R.W. (1989) Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. Adv. Mater., 28, 1128. Cahn, R.W. (2001) The Coming of Materials Science, Pergamon Materials Series, Vol. 5 (Pergamon, Oxford). Carlsson, A.E. and Meschter, P.J. (1994) Ab initio calculations. In: Intermetallic Compounds. Vol. 1: Principles, eds. Westbrook, J.H. and Fleischer, R.L. (J. Wiley & Sons, Chichester), p. 55. Chang, Y.A. (2006) Metall. Mater. Trans. B, 37B, 7. Chelikowsky, R. and Phillips, J.C. (1978) Phys. Rev., B17, 2453. Chen, S.-L., Chou, K.C. and Chang Y.A., (1993) Metall. Trans., B21, 287. Chen, S.-L., Daniel, S., Zhang, F., Chang, Y.A., Yan, X.-Y., Xie, F.-Y., Schmid-Fetzer, R. and Oates, W.A. (2002) Calphad, 26, 175. Chen, S.-L., Zhang, F., Daniel, S., Xie, F.-X., Yan, X.-Y., Chang, Y.A., Schmid-Fetzer, R. and Oates, W.A. (2003) JOM, 55, 48. Chen, X.Q., Wolf, W., Podloucky, R. and Rogl, R. (2004) Intermetallics, 12, 59. Chvoj, Z., Sestak, J. and Triska, A. (ed.) (1991) Kinetic Phase Diagrams. Non Equilibrium Phase Transitions (Elsevier Science, Amsterdam). Colinet, C. (2003) Intermetallics, 11, 1095. Curtarolo, S., Morgan, D. and Ceder, G. (2005) Calphad, 29, 163. Darken, L.S. and Gurry, R.W. (1953) Physical Chemistry of Metals (McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York). Davies, R.H., Dinsdale, A.T., Gisby, J.A., Robinson, J.A.J. and Martin, S.M. (2002) Calphad, 26, 229. de Boer, F.R., Boom, R., Mattens, W.C.M., Miedema, A.R. and Niessen, A.K. (1988) Cohesion in Metals, Transition Metal Alloys (North-Holland, Amsterdam). de Fontaine, D. (1994) Solid State Physics, eds. Ehrenreich, H. and Turnbull, D., (Academic Press, San Diego), Vol. 47, p.33. de Fontaine, D. (1996) MRS Bull., 21 (8), 16. Dinsdale, A.T., Hodson, S.M., Barry, T.I. and Taylor, J.R. (1988) Proceedings of 27th Annual Conference of Metallurgists, Vol. 11 (CIM, Montreal), p. 59. Duwez, P. (1967) Trans. ASM Quart., 60, 605. Effenberg, G. and Ilyenko, S. (ed.) (2004) Landolt-Börnstein, Numerical Data and Functional Relationships in Science and Technology, Physical-Chemistry. Ternary Alloy Systems: Phase Diagrams, Crystallographic and Thermodynamic Data. Critically evaluated by MSIT® (Springer Verlag, Berlin). Elliott, R.P. (1965) Constitution of Binary Alloys, 1st Supplement (McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York). Eriksson, G. and Hack, K. (1990) Metall. Trans., B21, 1013.
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
77
Evans, D.S. and Prince, A. (1978) Metal Sci., 12, 600. Frisk, K. and Selleby, M. (2001) J. Alloys Comp., 320, 177. Ghosh, G. and Asta, M. (2005) Acta Mater., 53, 3225. Ghosh, G., Delsante, S., Borzone, G., Asta, M. and Ferro, R. (2006) Acta Mater., 54, 4877. Giessen, B.C. and Willens, R.H. (1970) Phase Diagrams, ed. Alper, A.M. (Academic Press, New York), Vol. 3, p. 103. Gokcen, N.A. and Reddy, R.G. (1996) Thermodynamics, 2nd Edition (Plenum Press, New York). Goodman, D.A., Bennett, L.H. and Watson, R.E. (1983) Scripta Metall., 17, 91. Gordy, W. (1946) Phys. Rev., 69, 604. Gschneidner Jr., K.A. (1980) Theory of alloy phase formation, Proceedings of 108th AIME Annual Meeting, ed. Bennett, L.H. (New Orleans, LA, USA). Hafner, J. (1987) From Hamiltonians to Phase Diagrams (Springer, Berlin). Hafner, J. (1989) Cohesion and Structure, ed. Pettifor, D.G. and de Boer F.R. (NorthHolland, Amsterdam) Vol. 2. Hafner, J. (1992) Electron Theory in Alloy Design, ed. Pettifor, D.G. and Cottrell, A.H. (Institute of Materials, London). Hansen, M. and Anderko, K. (1958) Constitution of Binary Alloys (McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York). Hillert, M. (1981) Physica B, 103, 31. Hillert, M. (1998) Phase Equilibria, Phase Diagrams and Phase Transformations (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge). Hillert, M. (2001) J. Alloys Comp., 320, 161. Hillert, M. and Staffansson, L.-I. (1970) Acta Chem. Scand., 24, 3618. Hume-Rothery, W. (1931) The Metallic State (Oxford University Press, New York). Hume-Rothery, W., Christian, J.W. and Pearson, W.B. (1953) Metallurgical Equilibrium Diagrams, The Institute of Physics (Chapman & Hall Ltd., London). Jenkins, R. and Snyder, R.L. (1996) Introduction to X-ray Powder Diffractometry (J. Wiley & Sons Inc., New York). Kaufman, L. and Bernstein, H. (1970) Computer Calculation of Phase Diagrams with Special Reference to Refractory Metals (Academic Press, New York). Kaufman, L. and Nesor, H. (1973) Ann. Rev. Mater. Sci., 3, 1. Kodentsov, A.A., Bastin, G.F. and Van Loo, F.J.J. (2001) J. Alloys Comp., 320, 207. Kresse, G. and Furthmuller, J. (1996) Comput. Mater. Sci., 6, 15. Kresse, G. and Joubert, D. (1999), Phys. Rev., B59, 758. Kubaschewski, O. and Evans, E. (1958) Metallurgical Thermochemistry, 3rd Edition (Pergamon Press, New York). Kumar, K.C. and Wollants, P. (2001) J. Alloys Comp., 320, 189. Levinsky, Y. (1997) Pressure Dependent Phase Diagrams of Binary Alloys, (ASM International, Materials Park, OH, USA), Vol. 2. Lukas, H.L., Henig, E.-Th. and Zimmermann, B. (1977) Calphad, 1, 225. Lukas, H.L., Fries, S.G. and Sundman B. (2007) Computational Thermodynamics (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
78
Intermetallic Chemistry
Lukas, H.L., Weiss, J. and Henig, E.-Th. (1982) Calphad, 6, 229. Massalski, T.B. (1989) Metall. Trans., 20A, 1295. Massalski, T.B., Okamoto, H., Subramanian, P.R. and Kacprzak, L. (1990) Binary Alloy Phase Diagrams, 2nd Edition (ASM International, Materials Park, OH, USA), Vols. 1–3. Meijering, J.L. (1963) Philips Res. Rep., 18, 318. Miedema, A.R. (1973) J. Less Common Met., 32, 117. Miedema, A.R. and Niessen, A.K. (1982) Physica, 114B, 367. Miodownik, A.P. (1992) Structural and Phase Stability of Alloys, eds. Moran-Lopez, J.L. et al. (Plenum Press, New York), p. 65. Morral, J.E. and Gupta, H. (1991) Scripta Metall., 25, 1393. Niessen, A.K., de Boer, F.R., Boom, R., De Chatel, P.F., Mattens, W.C.M. and Miedema, A.R. (1983) Calphad, 7, 51. Nonius Kappa CCD Program Package (1998) Nonius, Delft, The Netherlands. Okamoto, H. (1991) J. Phase Equilib., 12, 623. Okamoto, H. (2000) Phase Diagrams for Binary Alloys, Desk Handbook (ASM International, Materials Park, OH, USA). Okamoto, H. and Massalski, T.B. (1991) J. Phase Equilib., 12, 148. Okamoto, H. and Massalski, T.B. (1993) J. Phase Equilib., 14, 316. Parravano, N. (1912) Gazz. Chim. Ital., 42, 593. Parravano, N. (1914) Gazz. Chim. Ital., 44, 279. Parravano, N. and Sirovich, G. (1912) Gazz. Chim. Ital., 42, 1630. Paul, A., Kodentsov, A.A. and van Loo, F.J.J. (2006) Intermetallics, 14, 1428. Pauling, L. (1932) J. Am. Chem. Soc., 54, 3570. Pauling, L. (1967) The Chemical Bond, 3rd Edition (Cornell University, Ithaca). Pelton, A.D. (1991) Thermodynamics and phase diagrams of materials. In: Phase Transformations in Materials, Vol. 5: Materials Science and Technology: A Comprehensive Treatment, eds. Cahn, R.W, Haasen, P. and Kramer, E.J. (VCH, Weinheim). Pelton, A.D. and Schmalzried, H. (1973) Metall. Trans., 4, 1395. Pelton, A.D. and Thompson, W.T. (1975) Prog. Solid State Chem., 10, 119. Perdew, J.P. and Wang, Y. (1992) Phys. Rev., B45, 13244. Perdew, J.P. and Zunger, A. (1981) Phys. Rev., B23, 5048. Pettifor, D.G. (1977) Calphad, 1, 305. Pettifor, D.G. (1984) Solid State Commun., 51, 31. Pettifor, D.G. (1985) J. Less Common Met., 114, 7. Pettifor, D.G. (1986) J. Phys. C: Solid State Phys., 19, 285. Pettifor, D.G. (2003) Acta Mater., 51, 5649. Pettifor, D.G., Aoki, M., Gumbsch, P., Horsfield, A.P., Nguyen-Manh, D. and Vitek, K. (1995) Mat. Sci. Eng., A192/193, 24. Petzow, G. and Effenberg, G. (eds.) (1988 et seq.) Ternary Alloys. A Comprehensive Compendium of Evaluated Constitutional Data and Phase Diagrams (VCH, Weinheim). Prince, A. (1978) Multicomponent Alloy Constitution Bibliography 1955–1973 (The Metals Society, London). Rajasekharan, T. and Girgis, K. (1983) Phys. Rev., B27, 910.
Phase Diagrams in Alloy Systems
79
Raynor, G.V. (1972) J. Less Common Met., 29, 333. Raynor, G.V. (1974) J. Less Common Met., 35, 285. Rhines, F.N. (1956) Phase Diagrams in Metallurgy: Their Development and Application (McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York). Rietveld, H.M. (1967) Acta Crystallogr., 22, 151. Rietveld, H.M. (1969) J. Appl. Crystallogr., 2, 65. Rodriguez-Carvajal, J. (1993) Physica, B192, 65. Roisnel, T. and Rodriguez-Carvajal, J. (2001) J. Mater. Sci. Forum, 378–381, 118. Saccone, A., Cacciamani, G., De Negri, S. and Ferro, R. (2002) J. Phase Equilib., 23, 29. Saunders, N. and Miodownik, A.P. (1998) Calphad: Calculation of Phase Diagrams. A Comprehensive Guide, Pergamon Materials Series, ed. Cahn, R.W., (Pergamon, Elsevier Science, Oxford, UK) Vol. 1. Saunders, N., Miodownik, A.P. and Dinsdale, A.T. (1988) Calphad, 12, 351. Schneider, J., Kaindl, G., Kunz, C., Dosch, H., Louër, D. and Mittemeijer, E.J. (2001) European White Book of Fundamental Research in Materials Science, eds. Rühle, M., Dosch, H., Mittemeijer, E.J. and Van de Voorde, M.H. (Max-Planck Institut für Metallforschung, Stuttgart), p. 238. Sheldrick, G.M. (1997) SHELXL-97, Program for Crystal Structure Refinement, University of Göttingen, Germany, Windows version by McArdle by National University of Ireland, Galway, Ireland. Shunk, F.A. (1969) Constitution of Binary Alloys, 2nd Supplement (McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York). Sluiter, M., Turchi, P.E.A., Zezhong, F. and de Fontaine, D. (1988) Phys. Rev. Lett., 60, 716. Sundman, B., Jansson, B. and Andersson, J.-O. (1985) Calphad, 9, 153. Teatum, E.T., Gschneidner Jr., K.A., and Waber, J.T. (1968) Compilation of Calculated Data Useful in Predicting Metallurgical Behavior of the Elements in Binary Alloy Systems, Report LA-4003, UC-25, Metals, Ceramics and Materials, TID-4500 (Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, New Mexico, USA). Turchi, P.E.A. (1994) Electronic Theories of Alloy Phase Stability. In: Intermetallic Compounds. Vol. 1: Principles, eds. Westbrook, J.H. and Fleischer, R.L. (J. Wiley & Sons, Chichester), p. 21. Turchi, P.E.A. and Sluiter, M. (1993) Computer Aided Innovation of New Materials, Vol. 1, eds. Doyama M. et al. (Elsevier Science, Amsterdam), p. 1449. Uchic, M.U., Kral, M.V., Spanos, G. and Dimiduk, D.M. (eds.) (2002), Proceedings of the Symposium on Characterization and Representation of Material Microstructure in 3D, Columbus, October 2002, published (2004) Metall. Mater. Trans., 35A, 1925. Vanderbilt, D. (1990) Phys. Rev., B41, 7892. van Laar, J.J. (1908) Z. Phys. Chem., 63, 216; 64, 257. Villars, P., Mathis, K. and Hulliger, F. (1989) Environment classification and structural stability maps. In: The Structures of Binary Compounds, eds. de Boer, F. and Pettifor, D. (North-Holland, Amsterdam), Vol. 2, p. 1. Villars, P., Prince, A. and Okamoto, H. (eds.) (1995) Handbook of Ternary Alloy Phase Diagrams (ASM International, Materials Park, OH, USA), Vols. 1–10.
80
Intermetallic Chemistry
Villars, P., Berndt, M., Brandeburg, K., Cenzual, K., Daams, J., Hulliger, F., Massalski, T., Okamoto, H., Osaki, K., Prince, A., Putz, H. and Iwata, S. (2004) J. Alloys Comp., 367, 297. Young, R.A. (ed.) (1995) The Rietveld Method, International Union of Crystallography (Oxford University Press, New York, USA). Zhao, J.-C. (2004) J. Mater. Sci., 39, 3913. Zunger, A. (1981) Structure and Bonding in Crystals, eds. Keeffe, M.O and Navrotski, A. (Academic Press, New York), Vol. I.
Chapter 3
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
3.1. PRELIMINARY REMARKS
In the previous chapter some questions concerning intermetallic systems were analyzed by using as examples various types of phase diagrams. We have seen in many systems the formation, in the liquid and/or in the solid state, in stable or metastable conditions, of different types of phases: non-stoichiometric phases, homogeneous in certain ranges of composition, which in the case of terminal phases include the constituents themselves, and/or stoichiometric phases. Large fields of homogeneity (extensive solubility) are generally met in the liquid state, for which the most frequent behaviour in metallic systems corresponds to the formation of a ‘continuous’ solution ranging from one component to the other. See for instance the singlephase field of the continuous liquid solution in a variety of phase diagrams such as those depicted in Figs 2.1 and 2.9. In a few cases, at least for certain temperature ranges, more than one liquid phase may be formed in a given system. See for instance Figs 2.16 and 2.18(e). The situation in the solid state is generally more complex. Several examples of binary systems were seen in which, in the solid state, a number of phases (intermediate and terminal) are formed. See for instance Figs 2.18–2.21. Both stoichiometric phases (compounds) and variable composition phases (solid solutions) may be considered and, as for their structures, both fully ordered or more or less completely disordered phases. This variety of types is characteristic for the solid alloys. After a few comments on liquid alloys, particular attention will therefore be dedicated in the following paragraphs to the description and classification of solid intermetallic phases. In this chapter, general aspects and structural properties of crystalline solid phases are described, and a short introduction is given to modulated and quasicrystal structures (quasi-periodic crystals). Elements of structure systematics with the description of a number of ‘structure types’ are presented in the subsequent Chapter 7. Finally, both in this chapter and in Chapter 6, dedicated to preparation techniques, characteristic features of typical metastable phases are considered with attention to amorphous and glassy alloys. 81
82
Intermetallic Chemistry
r (μΩ cm)
400
300
200
100
Li
20
40
60
at.% Pb
80
Pb
Figure 3.1. Li–Pb system: averaged values (in the temperature range between 400°C and 800°C) of the resistivity of the liquid alloys (Van der Lugt 1996).
3.2. LIQUID INTERMETALLIC PHASES
A summary of the general alloying behaviour in the liquid state for the different binary alloys was presented in the previous chapter and described with the map shown in Fig. 2.17. Very often a single liquid phase exists with a continuous trend of properties in the complete range of compositions from one component to the other. However, in several cases, for certain compositions, extrema in the physical properties of the liquid are observed when these are plotted as a function of the composition. According to Van der Lugt (1996) a liquid compound can be identified at these points. See the trend of the resistivity of the liquid Li–Pb alloys presented in Fig. 3.1: a sharp peak is observed at 21 at.% Pb and the formation of an octet compound, Li4Pb has been suggested. In the Li–Pb phase diagram a number of solid compounds are formed around 20 at.% Pb. Notice that the ‘octet rule’ is a concept of the chemical bonding description based on the assumption that, in the formation of compounds, atoms exhibit a tendency for their valence shell either to be empty or to have a full complement of eight electrons (octet) as in Li4Pb (4 1 1 4) : 8 electrons (see also Chapter 4). Further evidence of the peculiar behaviour of the liquid at this composition may be obtained by measuring several other properties. Enthalpies of mixing of liquid Li–Pb alloys were determined by Predel and Oehme (1979) over the entire concentration range through calorimetric investigations (see Fig. 3.2).
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
83
xPb
ΔH (kJ/mol at)
Li
0.2
0.4
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
0.6
0.8
Pb
–10
–20
–30
50
dΔH /dx
0
–50
–100
–150
Li
xPb
Pb
Figure 3.2. Li–Pb system: trend of the mixing enthalpy, ΔH, of the liquid alloys (after Predel and Oehme 1979) and dΔmixH/dx vs. composition.
A minimum is observed for xPb 0.22. The deviation of this system from regular behaviour was explained by the existence of associates in the alloy melts. An associate having this composition (Li7Pb2) was assumed and a good agreement was obtained between the values calculated on this basis and the experimental values. In a more general way, according to Sommer (1978, 1982), it may be noticed that thermodynamic quantities show peculiar trends in the same concentration ranges where solid-state intermetallic phases or compounds exist. It has been suggested that this behaviour can be described by considering the liquid alloy as
84
Intermetallic Chemistry
consisting of some ‘associated atoms’ which are in dynamic equilibrium in a number of binary alloy melts with compound-forming tendency and with anomalies in their concentration dependence. These are for instance a more or less clearly defined triangular shape of the mixing enthalpies vs. concentration, a temperature dependence of ΔH values associated with positive ΔCp values, etc. A comparison between the behaviour in the liquid and in the solid state is schematically presented in Fig. 3.3 for a number of alloys of the alkali metals with Tl
Sn
Pb
Bi
Li
Na
K
Rb
Cs
A
2L
at.% Me
2L
2L
2L
2L
A
Me
A
Me
A
Me
Me
Figure 3.3. Schematic representation of the diagrams for the alkali metals with a selected number of elements of the p-block. In each box the solid intermediate phases are represented in the positions approximately corresponding to their compositions (long bars: congruent melting phases; short bars: non-congruent phases). In the top part of each box every mark corresponds to a characteristic composition of the liquid phase for which the formation of an ‘associate’ (‘liquid compound’) may be suggested, for instance by the presence of an extremum in the trend of some property of the liquid phase. The symbol 2 L shown for certain ranges of compositions in a few diagrams indicates the presence of a miscibility gap in the liquid state, that is: two liquid phases.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
85
a few elements of the last groups of the periodic table (13th and subsequent groups) called p-block elements. General characteristics of alloys such as those presented in Fig. 3.3 have been discussed by Fässler and Hoffmann (1999) in a paper dedicated to ‘valence compounds at the border of intermetallics (alkali and alkaline earth metal stannides and plumbides)’. Examples showing gradual transition from valence compounds to intermetallic phases and new possibilities for structural mechanisms and bonding for Sn and Pb have been discussed. Structural relationships with Zintl phases (see Chapter 4) containing discrete and linked polyhedra have been considered. See § 3.12 for a few remarks on the relationships between liquid and amorphous glassy alloys. A number of features and characteristics of liquid alloys have been discussed in a review by Van der Lugt and Verkerk (2002). It was underlined that the molten, so-called, Zintl phases make up an interdisciplinary subject with three main components: crystal chemistry of Zintl ions, the physics of liquids and the electron theory in disordered materials. According to van der Lugt and Verkerk (2002), Zintl ions (see also § 4.4.3) are polyanions formed by anion clustering in ionic alloys and two categories may be distinguished: those that fit the so-called Zintl–Klemm concept and those that are electron deficient. The Zintl–Klemm ions (octet compounds) may be described as formed by an electronegative element of the nth group which accepts an electron (from the electropositive component) obtaining the electron configuration typical of an element of the (n 1)th group. Typical examples described are for instance KPb, RbPb containing the (Pb4)4 ion analogous, isoelectronic, with P4, As4. In NaSb, KSb, infinite Sb chains may be identified similar to Te chain. As an example of an electron-deficient structure Me8Tr11 compounds are considered (containing some Me K, Rb, Cs metals and (Tr11)7 ions with Tr Ga, In, Tl. Physical properties and detection of liquid Zintl compounds have been discussed and problems of gradual development of stoichiometries in non-clustering liquid ionic alloys, and their agreement with those persisting in the solid, have been considered. Neutron diffraction techniques and the results of their applications (Ga, Tl, alkali alloys) have been described.
3.2.1 Recent investigations on liquid alloys In a special issue (4/2006) of the International Journal of Materials Research (formerly Zeitschrift für Metallkunde) a number of papers have been collected which have been dedicated to liquid alloys and their properties. A short summary of these, even without any claim to be systematic, highlights some research problems into liquid metals and alloys.
86
Intermetallic Chemistry
Liquid–liquid interfacial tension, and density difference, in the immiscible (monotectic) alloy (Al34.5Bi65.5)95Si5 (mass%) have been measured by Kaban and Hoyer (2006). Addition of Si to the binary Al–Bi alloy increases the interfacial tension between the Al-and Bi-rich liquid phases. Surface tension and density of liquid alloys have been studied by Moser et al. (2006). Measurements by maximum bubble pressure and dilatometric techniques were carried out in an extensive range of temperatures on liquid alloys close to the ternary eutectic Sn3.3Ag0.76Cu with different Sb additions, which decrease surface tension and density. The experimental data were discussed in comparison also with values calculated on the basis of different models. The velocity of sound has been measured (Tsuchiya 2006) as a function of temperature to investigate structural changes in molten As–Sb alloys. The velocity of sound was measured with a standard pulse technique: piezoelectric ceramic, operated at about 8.8 MHz, were used to produce and detect the sound pulse. The overall profile of temperature dependence of the sound velocity in the different alloys changes smoothly from Sb to As. The results indicate that a tendency to change structures in the super-cooled state develops with increasing As fraction. The results are in agreement with previous observations that molten As changes rapidly its structure in the under-cooled state and it is already in the high-temperature side of an assumed liquid–liquid transition at the melting point. Trends, in the periodic table, for liquid–liquid transition have been summarized and discussed. By using a thermodynamic model based on the formation of self-associates, as proposed by Singh and Sommer (1992), Akinlade and Awe (2006) studied the composition dependence of the bulk and surface properties of some liquid alloys (Tl–Ga at 700°C, Cd–Zn at 627°C). Positive deviations of the mixing properties from ideal solution behaviour were explained and the degree of phase separation was computed both for bulk alloys and for the surface. A first-principle approach has been used by Singh and Ali (2006) in a study of liquid Na–Cd alloys. The Na–Cd diagram is characterized by the formation of two congruently melting compounds (Na2Cd11, melting point 364°C, and NaCd2, 384°C). As for the liquid alloys (at, say, 400°C), it has been observed, and confirmed by several experimental and theoretical investigations, that these alloys exhibit transformation to an ordered phase at large contents of Cd. The entropy of mixing vs. composition variation is S-shaped: it is negative towards the Cd-rich region and positive towards the Na-rich region. Previously (Singh et al. 1991) a description of liquid Na–Cd alloys (close to the melting temperature) in terms of chemical complexes (Na 2Cd M NaCd2) was proposed and employed to give an explanation of the composition-dependent asymmetry of the thermodynamic properties. A first-principle approach based on a pseudo-potential perturbation scheme (with the Gibbs–Bogoliubov variation technique) was used by Singh and Ali (2006); they
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
87
found that the deepening of the structural part of the entropy around the composition xNa 0.33 is responsible for the S-shaped entropy and suggests the existence of short-range order in the liquid. Finally, a paper may be mentioned concerning surface and transport properties of Au–Sn liquid alloys (Novakovic et al. 2005). The surface tension measurements on molten Au and Au–Sn alloys over the whole composition range were performed by using a special drop method (Passerone and Ricci 1998). The sample, placed in a special sapphire crucible, was introduced at the centre of a chamber, in a horizontal furnace heated by a high-frequency generator coupled to a graphite heater. The surface tension was measured by decreasing the temperature step by step in the range 1200–1000°C. Resting on a levelled substrate, the sample was illuminated by an aligned light source and its image analysed by means of specific software which allows fast automatic acquisition of the surface tension data and other parameters (temperature, oxygen partial pressure). The temperature dependence of the surface tension of the liquid alloys exhibits a negative trend for all compositions. The thermodynamic functions of mixing show an asymmetrical behaviour at the equiatomic composition that corresponds to the energetically favoured compound AuSn. The applicability of the ‘complex formation model’ was examined and discussed in the framework of statistical mechanical theory in conjunction with ‘quasi-lattice theory’ to describe surface and transport properties of Au–Sn liquid alloys.
3.3. INTERMETALLIC COMPOUND CHEMISTRY IN THE SOLID STATE
In the previous chapter we looked at some questions concerning solid intermetallic phases both terminal (that is solubility fields which include one of the components) and intermediate. Particularly we have seen, in several alloy systems, the formation in the solid state of intermetallic compounds or, more generally, intermetallic phases. A few general and introductory remarks about these phases have been presented by means of Figs. 2.2–2.4, in which structural schemes of ordered and disordered phases have been suggested. On the other hand we have seen that in binary (and multi-component) metal systems, several crystalline phases (terminal and intermediate, stable and also metastable) may occur. Several phase diagrams of binary alloy systems have been shown (see for instance Fig. 2.18) in which the existence of intermediate phases may be noticed. In these systems we have seen the formation of AmBn phases, which generally crystallize with structures other than those of the constituent elements, and which have negligible homogeneity ranges. Thermodynamically, the composition of any such phase is variable. In a number of cases, as those exemplified in Fig. 2.19, the possible variation in composition is very small (invariant composition phases or
88
Intermetallic Chemistry
stoichiometric phases, or ‘compounds’ proper, also called ‘point compounds’ in binary alloys). In Fig. 2.21, on the contrary, we observed in a number of systems that solid phases with a variable composition were formed (non-stoichiometric phases). In the reported diagrams we saw examples of both terminal and intermediate phases. These phases are characterized by homogeneity ranges (solid solubility ranges) which, in the case of the terminal phases, include the pure components and which, generally, have a variable temperature-dependent extension. In the older literature, stoichiometric and non-stoichiometric phases were often called ‘daltonides’ and ‘berthollides’, respectively. These names, however, are no longer recommended by the Commission on the Nomenclature of Inorganic Chemistry (International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry, IUPAC), Leigh (1990). More complex situations were shown in Figs. 2.26 and 2.27, where some typical examples of isobarothermal sections of ternary alloy phase diagrams were presented. In the case of ternary systems, several binary and ternary stoichiometric (Fig. 2.28) phases and/or different types of variable composition phases (Fig. 2.29) may be found. We may differentiate between these phases by using terms such as: ‘point compounds’ (or point phases, that is, phases represented in the composition triangle, or more generally in the composition simplex by points), ‘line phases’, ‘field phases’, etc. As a starting point in the description of the solid intermetallic phases it is useful to recall that their identification and classification requires information about their chemical composition and structure. To be consistent with other fields of descriptive chemistry, this information should be included in specific chemical and structural formulae built up according to well-defined rules. This task, however, in the specific domain of the intermetallic phases, or more generally in the area of solidstate chemistry, is much more complicated than for other chemical compounds. This complexity is related both to the chemical characteristics (formation of variable composition phases) and to the structural properties, since the intermetallic compounds are generally non-molecular in nature, while the conventional chemical symbolism has been mainly developed for the representation of molecular units. As a consequence there is no complete, or generally accepted, method of representing the formulae of intermetallic compounds. Some details and questions about these points will be discussed in the next paragraphs. These will then be used for a description of selected common phases and a presentation of a few characteristic features of intermetallic crystal chemistry. 3.4. IDENTIFICATION OF THE INTERMETALLIC (SOLID) PHASES
The identification and characterization of an intermetallic solid phase requires the determination and analysis of a number of points, which in the following paragraphs will be defined and discussed with a few details, starting with attention to
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
89
crystalline phases, while glassy alloys, quasi-periodic structures, quasicrystals will be briefly presented in § 3.11 and 3.12. A number of points are relevant for a full crystallochemical characterization; for each of them a few noteworthy remarks will be presented in the following. To this end, crystallographic conventions, nomenclature and symbols will be used. For a summary of these and of the corresponding definitions the most important reference book is International Tables for Crystallography (Hahn 2002). The following features and aspects will be considered: (a) Chemical composition (and the homogeneity composition range and its temperature and pressure dependence). (b) Structure type (or crystal system, space group, number of atoms per unit cell and list of occupied atomic positions). (c) Values of a number of parameters characteristic of the specific phase within the group of isostructural phases (unit cell edges, occupation characteristics and, if not fixed, coordinate triplets of every occupied point set). (d) Volumetric characteristics (molar volume of the phase, formation volume contraction or expansion, space-filling characteristics, etc.). (e) Interatomic connection characteristics (local atomic coordination, long-distance order, interatomic distances, their ratios to atomic diameters, etc.). (f) Relationships with other phases and structure types (comparison of the phase structural data with those relevant to other isostructural phases; comparison of the crystallochemical characteristics of the phase with those of other compounds formed by the same elements). Clearly, not all the data relevant to the aforesaid points are independent of each other. The strictly interrelated characteristics listed under (d) and (e), for instance, may be calculated from the data indicated in (b) and (c), from which the actual chemical composition of the phase can also be obtained. 3.5. COMPOSITION AND COMPOSITIONAL FORMULA OF THE INTERMETALLIC PHASE
As in the other fields of inorganic chemistry, simple compositional formulae are often used for intermetallic phases; these, for instance, Mg2Ge, ThCr2Si2, etc., are useful as quick references, especially for simple, stoichiometric, compounds. The following remarks may be noteworthy. 3.5.1 Order of citation of element symbols in the formula The symbol sequence in a formula (LaPb3 or Pb3La) is of course arbitrary and, in particular cases, it may be a matter of convenience. Alphabetical order has often
90
Intermetallic Chemistry
been suggested (for example by the IUPAC, Leigh 1990) and may be especially convenient in phase indexes, directories, etc. A symbol sequence based on chemical properties, however, may be more useful when, for instance, compounds with analogous structures have to be compared (Mg2Ge and Mg2Pb). A symbol quotation order based on a parameter introduced by Pettifor (1984, 1986) has been suggested (see for instance Petzow and Effenberg 1988 et seq.) and will also be used here. In fact, in order to stress the chemical character of the elements and to simplify their description, Pettifor (1984, 1985, 1986), as described in the § 2.2.1.3 and in the enclosed tables, created a new chemical scale (χ) which orders the elements along a simple axis. The progressive order number of the elements in this scale, the so-called Mendeleev number, can also be considered. These Mendeleev numbers M, which, of course, are different from the atomic numbers, start, according to Pettifor, with the least electronegative elements He 1, Ne 2, … and terminate with the most electronegative ones … N 100, O 101, F 102 up to H 103. On the basis of the Pettifor scale, the suggestion has been made that the element E with a lower-value ME (or χE) is quoted first in the formulae of its compounds. This will be generally adopted here and, therefore, we will prefer formulae such as PbCl2, ZnS, NiAs, MnCu2Al, etc. (instead of, for instance, Cl2Pb, AsNi, etc.). Notice, however, that for a quick reference the alphabetical order has been used in the formula index of Chapter 7.
3.5.2 Indication of constituent proportions No special comments are needed for stoichiometric compounds (LaPb3, ThCr2Si2, etc.). A more complex notation is needed for non-stoichiometric phases. Selected simple examples are given below, and more detailed information will be reported when discussing crystal coordination formulae: (a) Ideal formulae: While considering a variable composition phase, it is often possible to define an ‘ideal composition’ (and formula) relative to which the composition variations occur (or are considered to occur). This composition may be that for which the ratio of the numbers of different atoms corresponds to the ratio of the numbers of the different crystal sites in the ideal (ordered) crystal structure (as suggested by IUPAC, Leigh 1990). These formulae may be used even when the ‘ideal composition’ is not included in the homogeneity range of the phase (Nb3Al for instance shows a homogeneity range included between 18.6 and 21.5 at.% Al at room temperature and which hardly reaches 25 at.% Al at 1940°C). At the peritectic formation temperature of 2060°C the composition of the phase is about 22.5 at.% Al.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
91
(b) Approximate formulae: A general notation which has been suggested by IUPAC when only little information has to be conveyed, and which can be used even when the composition variation mechanism is unknown, is to put the sign (read as ‘circa’ or ‘approximately’) before the formula; for instance In2Bi. (c) Variable composition formulae: (Ni,Cu) or NixCu1x (0 x 1) are the equivalent representations of the continuous solid solution between Ni and Cu, homogeneous in the complete range of compositions; other examples are: Ce1xLaxNi5 (0 x 1); (Ti1xCrx)5Si3 (0 x 0.69 at 1000°C); etc. Similar formulae may also be used in more complicated cases to convey more information: AmxBnxCp (… x …) (phase involving substitution of atoms A for B). A1xB may indicate that there are A-type vacant sites in the structure. LaNi5Hx (0 x 6.7) indicates the solid solution of H in LaNi5 (d) Site occupation formulae: According to the Recommendations of the Commission on the Nomenclature of Inorganic Chemistry (Leigh 1990), additional information may be conveyed by using a more complex symbolism; suggestions have also been made about the indication of site occupation and of their characterization. These points will be discussed in more detail in the following sections. However for the indication of site occupation, the following criteria have been suggested by the Commission. The site and its occupancy are represented by two right lower indexes separated by a comma. The first index indicates the type of site; the second one indicates the number of atoms in this site. (AA, for instance, means an atom A on a site occupied by A in the ideal structure, whereas AB represents an atom A in a site normally (ideally) occupied by B). A formula such as: MM,1x NM,xMN,xNN,1x or (M1xNx)M(MxN1x)N represents a disordered alloy, whereas the ideal composition is MN with an ideal MMNN structure and in which the ‘M sites’ are occupied by (1 x) M atoms and xN atoms. In this notation vacant sites may be represented by 䊐 or by v. A species occupying an interstitial site, which is unoccupied in the ideal structure, is indicated by the subscript i. The following examples of alloy formulae have been reported: MgMg,2xSnMg,xMgSn,xSnSn,1x indicates a partially disordered alloy (related to the ‘ideal’ formula Mg2Sn) with some of the Mg atoms on Sn sites, and vice versa; (Bi2xTex)Bi(BixTe3x)Te indicates the composition changes from the ideal Bi2Te3 formula; AlAl,1PdAl,xPdPd,1x䊐Pd,2x shows that in the phase (corresponding to the ideal composition PdAl), every Al is on an Al site, but x Pd atoms are on Al sites, (1x) Pd atoms in Pd sites and 2x Pd sites are vacant.
92
Intermetallic Chemistry
This type of description and formulae may be especially useful when considering thermodynamic properties of the phase, and when dealing with solid solution models and quasi-chemical equilibria between point defects. More details about this point may be found in the book on the calculation of phase diagrams by Saunders and Miodownik (1998). In their description of ‘thermodynamic models for solution and compound phases’ they presented the sublattice model reminding us that, to this end, a sublattice phase can be envisaged as being composed of interlocking sublattices on which the various components can mix. It is usually crystalline in nature, but the model can also be extended to consider ionic liquids when mixing on particular ionic sublattices is considered. The model, as used in applied thermodynamics, is phenomenological in nature and does not define any crystal structure within its formulation. However, it has been noticed that the fruitful extension of this concept to the modelling of complex intermetallic phases, such as the so-called σ, μ, χ and Laves phases, may be simplified if a coherent crystallographic approach is used and due consideration is given to the classification of the possible sites corresponding to the sublattices presumed on the basis of their symmetry, coordination, etc. (Ansara et al. 1997, Ferro and Cacciamani 2002) and to the differentiation of their occupation on the basis, for instance, of their atomic dimensions. (e) Polymorphism descriptors: Several substances may change their crystal structure because of external conditions such as temperature and pressure. These different structures (polymorphic forms) may be distinguished by using special designators of the stability conditions. If the various crystal structures are known, explicit structural descriptors may obviously be added. According to a simple but systematic notation, the different temperature modifications are indicated by lower case letters in parenthesis behind the phase designation, with (h) high-temperature modification, (r) room temperature modification and (l) low-temperature modification; h1, h2, etc. represent different high-temperature modifications. In the description of a number of modifications which are stable at different temperatures, the letters are used in the sequence h2, h1, r, l1, l2, …, corresponding to the decreasing stability temperature. Similarly a form stable only under high pressure can by described by the symbol HP. Table 3.1 shows a few examples of this notation. In this case, of course, the temperature and composition ranges of stability explicitly indicated for all the phases give additional or more detailed information. The Greek letters assigned to the phases of the systems may be considered as arbitrary (‘pseudonyms’ of the formula or synonyms). Similarly to what can be observed for several common alloys of practical interest, these symbols often date back to the first investigation of the
93
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
Table 3.1. An example of crystallochemical description of an alloy system. Binary solid phases in the Al–Cu system. Phase/ ideal formula/ temperature range (°C)
Pearson symbol/ prototype
Lattice parameters (pm) (composition at.% Cu)
Maximum composition range (at.% Cu)
(Al) 660.452 Θ, Al2Cu 592 η1, AlCu 624–560
cF4 Cu tI12 Al2Cu o*32
a 404.96 (at 298 K)
0–2.5 32.05 to 32.6
η2, AlCu 563
mC20
ζ1, Al4Cu5 590–530
oF88 (83.3)
ζ2, Al4Cu5 570
oI24 (20.5)
ε1, Al4Cu5 958–850 ε2, AlCu1x 850–560 δ, Al3Cu2 686 γ0, Al4Cu9 1040–800 γ1, Al4Cu9 900 β AlCu3 1049–567 α2 AlCu3 363 (Cu) 1084.6
c**
a 606.7 (at 33 at.%) c 487.7 a 410 b 1202.4 (at 49.8 at.%) c 865 a 1206.6 b 410.5 (at 49.8 at.%) c 691.3 β 55.04° a 812.7 b 1419.9 c 999.3 a 409.7 b 703.1 c 997.9 –
hP6 (6x) Ni2In hR*
a 414.6 (at 57.4 at.%) c 506.3 –
55.0–61.1
cI52 Cu5Zn8 cP52 Al4Cu9 cI2 W Related to the tI8 TiAl3 type cF4 Cu
–
63–69
a 870.23 (at 68 at.%)
62.5–68.5
a 294.6
69.5–82
a 366.8 c 368.0 a 365.4 (at 85 at.%) a 361.46 (at 100 at.%) (at 298 K)
76.5–78
49.8–52.4
49.8–52.3
55.2–56.8
55.2–56.3
59.4–62.1
59.3–61.9
80.3–100
alloy involved when the precise identification and the chemical and crystallographic definition of a phase were much more uncertain. In several cases, however, Greek characters, sometimes assigned in alphabetical order according to the composition, are still used as short alloy symbols (see § 3.7.8). In connection with this
94
Intermetallic Chemistry
group of descriptors other indicators such as (am), (vt), etc. for amorphous, vitreous substances are sometimes used. For instance: SiO2(am) amorphous silica; Si(am)Hx amorphous silicon doped with hydrogen. For general remarks on amorphous, glassy metastable phases (see § 3.12).
3.6. CRYSTAL STRUCTURE OF THE SOLID PHASE AND ITS STANDARD REPRESENTATION
3.6.1 General remarks, unit cell description The characterization, the full identification, of a phase requires a complete and detailed description of its structure. As examples, consider the data, obtained from X-ray diffraction experiments, reported in Table 3.2 for stoichiometric and variable composition phases. An explanation of the various symbols used will be given in the following paragraphs. For a general reference to symbols, definitions and
Table 3.2a. Examples of crystallographic description of phase structures: stoichiometric or nearly stoichiometric compounds. Cell dimensions in picometres. CsCl (stoichiometric compound) – Primitive cubic; a 411.3 pm; space group Pm 3m, N. 221 1 Cs in (a): 0, 0, 0 1 1 Cl in (b): ⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 The two special (a) and (b) Wyckoff positions have no free coordinate parameter. The two occupancy parameters are 100%. The Pearson symbol is cP2. Mg2Ge (stoichiometric compound) – Face-centred cubic; a 638.7 pm; space group Fm 3m, N. 225 1 1 1 1 1 1 Atomic positions: (0, 0, 0; 0, ⁄2, ⁄2; ⁄2, 0, ⁄2; ⁄2, ⁄2, 0) 4 Ge in (a): 0, 0, 0 1 8 Mg in (c): ⁄4, 1⁄4, 1⁄4; 1⁄4, 1⁄4, 3⁄4 No free parameters in the atomic positions of Mg and Ge. In this case the two occupancy parameters have been found to be 100%. The Pearson symbol is cF12 (CaF2 is considered the prototype of this structure). MoSi2 (nearly stoichiometric compound) Body-centred tetragonal; a ⫽ 319.6–320.8 pm and c 785–790 pm, according to the composition; space group I4/mmm, N. 139 Atomic positions: (0, 0, 0; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2) 2 Mo in (a): 0, 0, 0 4 Si in (e): 0, 0, z; 0, 0, z–; (z 0.333) The Si position has the free parameter z, for which, in this particular case, the value 0.333 has been determined; the two occupancy parameters are 100%. The Pearson symbol is tI6.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
95
nomenclature see ‘The International Tables of Crystallography’ (Hahn 2002). These data, their symbolic representation, and the table itself correspond to what may be called the normal (reference) description. It is adopted in all the compilations and atlases of crystal structures. From this description, however, alternative (and/or complementary) presentations of the structure and different symbolic representations can be deduced. These are often differently defined for specific groups of compounds and may be useful to obtain a clearer view of the atomic assembly and/or to make an easier comparison between different compounds. In other words it must be underlined that there is no ideal way of describing all structure types. The most appropriate way of description depends on the structure itself but also on a number of points we are interested in emphasizing (comparison with other structural types, comparison with other compounds of the same element, etc.). These points will be discussed in a few subsequent sections after the presentation of the ‘conventional’ description.
Table 3.2b. Examples of crystallographic description of phase structures: non-stoichiometric compounds. Cell dimensions in picometres. Mo2N (non-stoichiometric phase, partial occupancy) Body-centred tetragonal; a 420.0 pm, c 801 pm; space group I41/amd, N. 141. Atomic positions (0, 0, 0; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2) 4N in (a): 0, 0, 0; 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄4 (occupancy parameter 0.75) 8 Mo in (e): 0, 0, z; 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄4z; 1⁄2, 0, 3⁄4z; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2z; (occupancy parameter 1) The occupancy parameter of N is 75% that is three atoms are statistically distributed in the four positions. The real stoichiometry corresponds to Mo2N0.75 and in the unit cell there are 11 atoms instead of the ideal value of 12. The Mo position has the free parameter z for which, in this particular case the value 0.258 has been determined. The Pearson symbol is tI12 (11). Pt3Cd0.6Zn4.4 (Pt5CdZn7) (non-stoichiometric phase with partial substitution of Cd and Zn atoms) Hexagonal, a 705.0 pm, c 279.2 pm; space group P31 m, N. 157. 1 2 Me1 in (b): ⁄3, 2⁄3, z; 2⁄3, 1⁄3, z; (occupancy parameter 1) 3 Me2 in (c1): x, 0, z; 0, x, z; x–, x–, z; (occupancy parameter 1) 3 Pt in (c2): x, 0, z; 0, x, z; x–, x–, z; (occupancy parameter 1) The (b) and (c) positions are statistically occupied by mixtures of Cd and Zn atoms indicated as Me1 and Me2 and estimated to have the average composition 12 at.% Cd and 88 at.% Zn. The 5 (Me1 Me2) atoms correspond therefore to about 0.6 Cd atoms and 4.4 Zn atoms. All the positions have free parameters and there are two sets of atoms in one type of Wyckoff positions (the position c). These two sets (here marked c1 and c2), however, are different owing to the different values of the free parameters x and z. The following values of the parameters have been determined: z 0.50 for the (b) position, x 0.735 and z 0.5 for the first group of c (c1 occupied by Me2); x 0.358 and z 0.0 for the position c2 (occupied by Pt atoms). The Pearson symbol is hP8.
96
Intermetallic Chemistry
3.6.1.1 Crystallographic nomenclature (Bravais lattices, crystal classes, space groups) The following information is generally included in a ‘usual’ crystallographic description: ●
●
Crystallographic system It defines the coordinate system (and metrical relationships between the lattice parameters of the adopted unit cell: for instance, cubic: a b c, α β γ 90°; tetragonal: a b c, α β γ 90°, etc.). The specific values (in picometres, for instance) of the unit cell dimensions are related to the crystal system (see Table 3.3 and Fig. 3.4). The absolute value of the unit cell edges and of related quantities such as interatomic distances, atomic diameters, etc. are generally given in nanometres (1 nm 109 m) or picometres (1 pm 1012 m). In the past a non-SI unit, the angstrom was usually employed by crystallographers. (1 Å 1010 m). Bravais point lattice type The space lattice of a crystal is a representation of its translation repetition. The parallelepiped built upon the three translations selected as unit translations is defined as the unit cell. The lattice may be built up by setting unit cell on unit cell in an infinite framework of unit cells, all the corners of which form a point lattice. These points may be considered also as endpoints of vectors radiating from the origin of the coordinate system and resulting from a combination of the basis vectors a, b and c. If no other lattice points are contained in the interior of the unit cell this is said to be primitive. In the non-primitive lattices other lattice points exist resulting from the so-called centring translations characteristic of the different lattice types: these are C (base centred): 1⁄2 (a b), I (body centred): 1⁄2 (a b c), F (face centred: 1⁄2 (a b), 1 ⁄2 (a c), and 1⁄2 (b c) and R (rhombohedral cell on a hexagonal basis): 1 ⁄3 (a b c) and 1⁄3 (a 2b c). The centring translations are summarized by the following triplets, which have to be added to the representative coordinate of any point in order to obtain all the translational equivalent points: C: I: F: R:
(0, 0, 0), (1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0) (0, 0, 0), (1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2) (0, 0, 0), (1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0), (1⁄2 , 0, 1⁄2), (0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2) (0, 0, 0), (2⁄3, 1⁄3, 1⁄3), (1⁄3, 2⁄3, 2⁄3)
(double-primitive cell) (double-primitive cell) (four-fold primitive cell) (triple-primitive cell)
The combination of the point lattices constructed on the basis of the crystallographic systems with the possible centring translation results in the 14 so-called Bravais lattice type, illustrated in Fig. 3.4. Substituting (decorating) each lattice
Table 3.3. Classification of space groups (from Hahn 2002). Crystal family
Symbol
Crystal system
Crystallographic point groups (crystal classes)
Number of space groups
Triclinic (anorthic)
a
Triclinic
– 1, 1
Monoclinic
m
Monoclinic
2, m, 2/m
13
Orthorhombic
o
Orthorhombic
222, mm2, mmm
59
Tetragonal
t
Tetragonal
Hexagonal
h
Trigonal
– 4, 4 , 4/m – 422, 4mm, 4 2m, 4/mmm – – 3, 3, 32, 3m,3m
2
Cubic
c
Cubic
– 6, 6 , 6/m – 622, 6mm, 6 2m 6/mmm – 23, m3 – 432, 43m, m3m
Restriction on cell parameter None b-unique setting α γ 90° α β γ 90°
Bravais lattices
Parameters to be determined (*) a, b, c α, β, γ a, b, c β a, b, c
aP mP mS (mC, mA, mI) oP oS (oC, oA, oB) oI oF tP tI
68
ab α β γ 90°
a, c
18
ab α β 90°, γ 120° abc αβγ ab α β 90°, γ 120° abc α β γ 90°
a, c
hP (hexagonal axes)
a, α
hR (rhombohedral axes) hP
7 Hexagonal
Conventional coordinate system
27
36
a, c
a
cP cI cF
According to Hahn (2002), mS and oS are the standard setting independent symbols for the centred monoclinic and the one-face-centred orthorhombic Bravais lattices. Symbols between parentheses oC, oA, etc. represent alternative settings of these Bravais lattices. (*) is the angle between the y and z axes (b, c parameters) and the angle between the x and z axes (a, c parameters) and the angle between x and y axes (a, b parameters).
98
Intermetallic Chemistry
c P
t P
c I
t I
o P
h P
o I
m P
c F
h R
o C
m C
o F
a P
Figure 3.4. The crystal systems and the Bravais lattices illustrated by a unit cell of each. All the points which, within a unit cell, are equivalent to each other and to the cell origin are shown. Notice that, in the primitive lattices the unit cell edges are coincident with the smallest equivalence distances. For the rhombohedral lattice, described in terms of hexagonal axis, the symbol hR is used instead of a symbol such as rP. In the construction of the so-called Pearson symbol (§ 3.6.3), oS and mS will be used instead of oC and mC.
point with an atom, or a group of atoms, results in a periodic array of atoms (atom groups) that is in a (periodic) crystal structure. Criteria adopted in the choice of the unit cell are illustrated by the bi-dimensional example reported in Fig. 3.5. The different unit cell types, and the corresponding crystal systems and lattice types, are listed in Table 3.3, and illustrated in Fig. 3.4.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases B
a (a)
α
99
(c)
A
a a (b)
α a
Figure 3.5. A bi-dimensional lattice of points is shown which can be built on the basis of the translation units a (the shortest one) and the corresponding unit cell. The origin of the cell is arbitrary (for inst. (a) or (b)): it contains 1 point. A more symmetric cell (c) may be built with the edges A and B, however it is double primitive centred rectangular, containing two equivalent points.
In the following a few selected formulae useful in common crystallographic calculations have been collected. ●
Space groups The space group describes the spatial symmetry of the structure on a microscopic (atomic) level, and is represented by means of the Hermann–Mauguin symbol composed of a letter representing the lattice type (P primitive; I body centred, etc., see Table 3.3 and Fig. 3.4) followed by the symbols of the symmetry elements ordered according to their positions relative to the axes (for – instance Pm3 m is the symbol of the space group of the CsCl structure). As usual, – the space group is also identified by the serial number (221 for Pm3m) listed in several compilations and atlases such as the International Tables, which is the fundamental reference book for crystallography (Hahn 2002). It may be mentioned that in 2D and 3D the possible rotations (the symmetry axes) that superimpose an infinitely periodic structure on itself are limited to angles 360°/n with n 1, 2, 3, 4 or 6. Notice that for non-periodic, noncrystalline, quasi-crystalline structures, other symmetry axes are possible. See § 3.11.3 and Fig. 3.45 on quasi-periodic crystals.
The numbers 2, 3, 4 and 6 are used as symbols of the corresponding axes of – – – symmetry while the symbols 3, 4 and 6 (3 bar, 4 bar, etc.) are used for the threefour- and six-fold (roto) inversion axes, corresponding to a counter-clockwise rotation of 360°/n around an axis followed by an inversion through a point on the axis. – The centre of symmetry (inversion through a point) is represented by 1 and the plane of symmetry (mirror symmetry) by the letter m. The inversion operation
100
Intermetallic Chemistry
and the ‘mirror operation’ are called improper symmetry operations, because they do not relate congruent asymmetric objects but change the hand (chirality) of the objects turning from the right-hand form to the left-hand one. Notice that any asymmetric object (that is which has no symmetry itself) can exist in both a right-handed and a left-handed forms. Any two thus related objects are called enantiomorphous. All the possible combinations of these symmetry elements result in 32 crystallographic point-group symmetries or crystal classes; their symbols are listed in Table 3.3. Notice that in putting together the symbols to denote the symmetries of any crystal classes the convention is to give the symmetry of the principal axis – first: for instance 4 or 4 , for tetragonal classes. If there is a plane of symmetry per– pendicular to the principal axis, the two symbols are associated as in 4 m or 4/m (4 over m), then the symbols for the secondary axes, if any, follow, and then any other symmetry planes. In a symbol such as 4/mmm, the second and third m refer to planes parallel to the four-fold axis. Notice that the symmetry operations of each point group by continued repetition always bring us back to the point from which we started. Considering, however, a space crystalline pattern, additional symmetry operations can be observed. These involve translation and therefore do not occur in point groups (or crystal classes). These additional operations are glide planes which correspond to a simultaneous reflection and translation and screw axis involving simultaneous rotation and translation. With subsequent application of these operations we do not obtain the point from which we started but another, equivalent, point of the lattice. The symbols used for such operations are exemplified as follows: a, b or c (axial) glide reflection through a plane with a glide vector 1⁄2 a, 1⁄2 b or 1⁄2 c. n (diagonal) glide reflection through a plane with a glide vector such as 1⁄2(a b). d (diamond) glide reflection through a plane with a glide vector such as 1⁄4(a b). np (n sub p) n-fold screw axis: 21, 31, 32, 41, 42, 43, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65. Right-handed screw rotation of 360°/n around an axis, with screw vector (p/n)t, where t is the shortest lattice translation vector parallel to the screw axis. Conventionally a righthanded axis is one whose screw motion is clockwise when looking up along the – axis. An illustration of the 41, 42 and 43 axes in comparison with the axes 4 and 4 is shown in Fig. 3.6. Notice that pairs of axes such as 31 and 32, 41 and 43 or 61 and 65 are identical except for the sense of the screw motion; such pairs are therefore enantiomorphous. Taking into account these symmetry operations together with those corresponding to the translations characteristic of the different lattice types (see Fig. 3.4), it is possible to obtain 230 different combinations corresponding to the 230 space groups which describe the spatial symmetry of the structure on a microscopic
101
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases 4
4
41
42
43
t
y, x x, y x, y y, x 4
x,y, z
y, x, z
x, y, z
y, x, z
4 41 42 43
x,y, z x,y, z x,y, z x,y, z
y, x, z y, x, z + y, x, z + y, x, z +
x, y, z x, y, z + x, y, z x, y, z +
y, x, z y, x, z + y, x, z + y, x, z +
Figure 3.6. An indication is given of the equivalent points generated (from a generic point of – coordinates x, y, z) by the action of the axes 4 and 4 and of the 41, 42 and 43 screw axes. A perspective view of the graphical symbols used in the International Tables (Hahn 2002) for the different axes is shown. (t is the shortest translation vector in the direction of the axes). The projection (along these axes) on the base plane of the equivalent points is also shown: notice that the same projection is obtained in all the cases illustrated. The coordinates of all the equivalent points in the different sets are listed. Notice that the x, y, z coordinates are fractional coordinates: they indicate the positions along the corresponding directions as fractions of the constants a, b and c (in these examples c t).
level. The numbers of space groups associated with each crystal class are given in Table 3.3. 3.6.1.2 The unit cell content. To complete the description of the crystal structure, the list of the atoms contained in the unit cell and their coordinates (fractional coordinates related to the adopted system and unit cell edges) are then reported. These are usually presented in a format such as M El in n: x, y, z. In the MoSi2 structure, also reported in Table 3.2, and in Fig. 3.7, for instance, four silicon atoms
102
Intermetallic Chemistry d/pm
1
785 = c 654
0.83
523
0.67
393
0.5
262
0.33
131
0.17
Z
d/pm 638 = c
1 0.91
579 378
0.59
260
0.41
0
0
MoSi2 Mo or Ca
59 0
0.09 0
CaC2 Si or C
Figure 3.7. Unit cell schematic representations of the isopointal structures of MoSi2 and CaC2 (see also Chapter 7). Absolute and fractional rounded values of the vertical coordinate are shown. Notice that due to the different values of the c/a ratios and of the z parameters the two structures (corresponding to the same space group and the same occupation of Wyckoff positions) result in different coordination and atomic grouping. In CaC2 we have the formation of C—C, dumbbell, discrete groups. The C—C distance corresponds (see text, § 3.6.2) to (1–2z) c 0.1864 638 pm 118.9 pm. This distance and the corresponding C radius of 59.5 pm are in good agreement with the bond length for bond order 3, found for instance in acetylene.
(that is: M El 4 Si) are in the position set coded as e (in the so-called Wyckoff notation) and corresponding, in this specific case, to the four positions (the four coordinate triplets) 0, 0, z; 0, 0, –z ; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 z; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 z. Such entries correspond to one of the Wyckoff positions characterized by well-defined site symmetry and by a multiplicity M. For each Wyckoff position, M is the number of equivalent points (positions) in the unit cell with the same site symmetry. Notice, indeed, that a ‘space group’ is a group of symmetry elements. If an atom is placed in a quite general position in the unit cell it is multiplied by the symmetry elements and thus other atoms, exactly equivalent to the first, are found at other positions precisely related to those of the first. Each space group has its own characteristic number of equivalent general positions. This is the highest multiplicity Mmax of the given space group and corresponds to the lowest site symmetry (each point is mapped onto itself only by the ‘identity operation’). In this ‘general position’ the coordinate triplets of the Mmax sites include the reference triplet indicated as x, y, z (having three variable parameters, to be experimentally determined). In a given space group, moreover, it is possible to have several special positions. In this case, points (atoms) are considered which
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
103
are located on symmetry elements (without translations) or at the intersection of several such symmetry elements. Each point will be mapped onto itself by at least one of these symmetry operations: we will have as a consequence a reduction in the number of different equivalent points in the unit cell generated by all the characteristic symmetry operations. The multiplicity of these positions will be lower than Mmax (M in a special position is a divisor of that of the general position). Specific constraints are imposed on the coordinates of each point of a special position leading to triplets such as x, y, 0 (that is z 0) or x, x, z (that is x y), with two variable parameters, or x, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 or x, x, 0 (with one variable parameter) or 0, 0, 0 or 1 ⁄2, 1⁄2, 0 (with no variable parameter). In the International Tables of Crystallography, for each of the 230 space groups the list of all the Wyckoff positions is reported. For each of the positions (the general and the special ones) the coordinate triplets of the equivalent points are also given. The different positions are coded by means of the Wyckoff letter, a, b, c, etc., starting with a for the position with the lowest multiplicity and continuing in alphabetical order up to the general position. In the examples reported in Table 3.2 it is also shown that, for the positions with free parameters, the specific values of the parameters themselves (experimentally determined) should be given in order to present a complete description of the structure. Notice that, for instance in the case of the MoSi2 structure, the different atomic positions in the unit cell (in the space group I4/mmm) are the following: 2 Mo in 0, 0, 0 and in 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 and 4 Si in 0, 0, z; in 0, 0, –z ; in 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 z and in 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 z corresponding (on the basis of the experimental value z 0.333) to 0, 0, 0.333; 0, 0, 0.667; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0.833; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0.167. These positions have been described, according to the International Tables of Crystallography conventions, explicitly indicating the centring translations (0, 0, 0; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2), characteristic of body-centred lattices (I-space groups), before representative coordinate triplets. The symbol means that, in order to obtain the complete set of Wyckoff positions, the components of these centring translations have to be added to each of the listed triplets. A similar presentation has been used for the Mg2Ge structure description. Notice that in the description of the content of the unit cell, the atomic coordinates are given for the first cell from the chosen origin, and are formulated modulo 1: thus, for instance, x, y, z is written (x–, –y , –z ) rather than 1 x, 1 y, 1 z and the following equivalences could be considered as typical examples: — 1 1⁄4 1⁄4; 1⁄2 3⁄4 1⁄4; 0.1 0.1 1 0.1 0.9; 1 0 Notice however that in the analysis of a given structure, in order to evaluate coordination and atomic distances, the atomic positions in several adjacent cells may be relevant, and therefore values of x, y, z higher than 1 or lower than 0 should be
104
Intermetallic Chemistry (a)
(b)
(c)
0
0 1/2
0 0
(d)
(e)
(g) (f)
Figure 3.8. Crystal structure of CsCl. The positions of the centres of the atoms in the unit cell are shown in (a). In (b) the same cell is described by means of its characteristic sections taken at the height 0, 1⁄2, and 1 of the third axis. In (c) a projection of the cell on its square basis is presented: the values of the third (fractional) coordinate are indicated. In (d) the shortest interatomic distances are shown: dCs–Cl a3/2 411.3 0.866025…. 356.2. In (e) the subsequent group of interatomic distances (d a 411.3) involving six atoms in the adjacent cells is presented. A group of eight cells is represented in (f) to suggest that the actual structure of CsCl corresponds to a threedimensional infinite repetition of unit cells and to show that the coordination around the white atoms is similar to that around the black ones shown in (d). The unit cell of the CsCl structure is shown as a packed spheres model in (g).
considered (see § 3.7.7). Finally, in Table 3.2 some more examples are reported as an introduction to more complex, partially disordered, structures (random distribution of different atom types in the same positions, partial occupancy of certain positions). Considering now the simple structure of CsCl as an illustration, we see that the ‘crystallographic description’ reported in Table 3.2 corresponds to the atom arrangement shown, with alternative representations, in Fig. 3.8. More generally, from
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
105
descriptions such as those reported in Table 3.2, the interatomic distances may be computed and, consequently, the coordinations and grouping of the various atoms may be derived. An example of this computation will be presented in § 3.7.7. A systematic listing of the crystal data relevant to all the known phases has been reported in a number of fundamental reference books such as Pearson (1967), Landolt-Börnstein (1971), Villars and Calvert (1985), Villars and Calvert (1991), etc. or crystal structure databases. For the criteria to be followed in the preparation and presentation of coordinate lists, especially when complex structures are involved, see Parthé and Gelato (1984). Their paper describes a proposal for a standardized presentation of inorganic crystal structure data with the aim of recognizing identical, or nearly identical, structures from the similarity of the numerical values of the atom coordinates. Different, equivalent, but not easily recognizable, descriptions could, in fact, be obtained by shift of origin of the coordinate system, rotation of the coordinate system, inversion of the basis vector triplet (see also Parthé et al. 1993). As an example of different descriptions of the same structural type see the KHg2, oI12 structural type in Chapter 7. The description of KHg2, as obtained from the original literature data, is reported; it is also shown that this structure is isotypic with the CeCu2 type, for which an apparently different description was given in the literature. 3.6.1.3 Common crystal–chemical formulae. Unit cell volumes and interatomic distances. In the analysis and description of a structure some calculation may be useful. A few common formulae are collected here. 3.6.1.3.1 Volume of the unit cell (Vcell ). This may be calculated from the unit cell constants by using the following formulae. From this the density (ρ) of the compound may be obtained: ρ Mcell/Vcell, where Mcell is the mass of the matter in the unit cell, that is the sum of the masses of all the atoms contained. The mass of an individual atom is calculated in grams by the ratio of the atomic molar mass and the Avogadro number. General case (Triclinic):
Vcell abc 1 cos2 α cos2 β cos2 γ 2 cos α cos β cos γ
Monoclinic:
Vcell abc sin β
Rhombohedral: Vcell a3 1 3 cos2 α 2 cos3 α Hexagonal:
Vcell a 2 c
Orthorhombic: Vcell abc
3 2
106
Tetragonal: Cubic:
Intermetallic Chemistry
Vcell a2c Vcell a3
3.6.1.3.2 Examples of alternative descriptions of the unit cell In a number of cases, in order for instance, to compare a given atomic distribution and arrangement with several others, it may be useful to use different descriptions of the same structure (to refer to different, but obviously equivalent, unit cells). The transformations (of the unit cell constants and, consequently, of the coordinates of the atomic positions) are described, for the general case, for instance, in the International Tables (Hahn 2002). A few, frequently used, transformation formulae of the unit cell constants are reported here. Description of a rhombohedral unit cell in terms of the equivalent, triple-primitive, hexagonal cell (see Fig. 3.9). (Rhombohedral axes: ar and α; Hexagonal axes: ah and ch) Rhombohedral → hexagonal
ah ar 2 1 cos α 2ar sin
α 2
ch ar 3 1 2 cos α Cell volume
Vh 3Vr
Hexagonal → rhombohedral
ar sin
1 (3ah2 ch2 ) 3 3
α 2 2 3 ch2 ah2
0
0 2 3
1 3
ch ar ah
ar
1 3
0
0
2 3
ar
ah
0
ah
0
2 3
1 3
0
Figure 3.9. The relation between a primitive rhombohedral cell and an equivalent tripleprimitive hexagonal cell is shown. The cell orientations have been selected according to the criteria adopted by the International Tables (Hahn 2002).
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
107
A detailed example of the alternative descriptions of a given compound, both in terms of its hexagonal unit cell and of the corresponding rhombohedral primitive cell is presented in Chapter 4: the rhombohedral compound Mo6PbS8 (the prototype of the family of the so-called Chevrel phases) is described and unit cell constants and atomic positions are listed for its conventional hexagonal cell and for the rhombohedral primitive cell. The rhombohedral cell has a nearly cubic shape (αr 90°) when ch/ah (3/2) 1.2247… Description of a hexagonal unit cell (ah, ch cell edges) in terms of an orthohexagonal cell (equivalent orthorhombic cell a0, b0, c0) (see Fig. 3.10). Hexagonal : ortho-hexagonal
a0 ah b0 ah 3 c0 ch
Cell volume
Vh a2hch
3 2
V0 a0b0c0 V0 2Vh Number of atoms in the cell
N0 2Nh
a0
ah
b0
Figure 3.10. The relation between a hexagonal cell and an equivalent orthorhombic cell is shown by means of their projections on the a, b plane.
108
Intermetallic Chemistry
Description of a cubic (primitive, body centred or face centred) unit cell (ac) in terms of the equivalent, primitive rhombohedral, (ar, ) and triple-primitive hexagonal, cells (ah, ch). See Fig. 3.11. Primitive cubic:
ar ac
α 90°
ah ac 2 Cell volume
Vr Vc
ch ac 3 ch/ah 1.225 … Vh 3Vc 3Vr
Number of atoms in the cell
Nr Nc
Nh 3Nc 3Nr
Body-centred cubic (doubly primitive):
ar ac
3 2
ah ac 2 Vr
Number of atoms in the cell
Nr
Face-centred cubic (quadruply primitive):
ar ac
ar
ch ac
1 V 2 c
Cell volume
α 109°28 12
Vh
1 N 2 c 2 2
Nh
3 2
ch/ah 0.612
3 V 3Vr 2 c 3 N 3N r 2 c
α 60°
ar ar ac
Figure 3.11. Relation between a face-centred cubic cell (of edge ac and quadruple primitive) and its equivalent primitive rhombohedral cell
ar ac
2 2 , α 60º.
109
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
ah ac Cell volume
Vr
Number of atoms in the cell
Nr
2 2
1 V 4 c
ch ac 3 Vh
1 N 4 c
Nh
ch/ah 2.449 …
3 V 3Vr 4 c 3 N 3N r 4 c
Transformation (deformation) of a face-centred cubic unit cell into a body-centred cubic cell. A face-centred cubic cell (having a unit edge a0), ‘compressed’ along an axis, when the reduction corresponds to a face-centred tetragonal cell with a c/a ratio a 1/ 2 , becomes a body-centred cubic cell with an edge: a 0 (see Fig. 3.12). 2
Notice that, in the tetragonal system, there is no face-centred lattice: if, to a simple tetragonal lattice, we add extra lattice points at the centres of the cell faces, the lattice (and the cell) obtained may be described in terms of a body-centred unit cell with a square base whose edges are 1/ 2 times the length of the original (pseudoface-centred) cell (see Fig. 3.12). Some ambiguity may be found in literature concerning this point; for a few compounds, indeed, descriptions in terms of the two cells have been reported. A description of what possibly is the first example of such a misunderstanding has been vividly described in the brilliant book The Coming of Materials Science by Cahn (2001). M. Polanyi, in an account of his own
ac = c t
at ac
Figure 3.12. A face-centred cubic cell (edge ac) can be described in terms of a body-centred tetragonal cell with a c/a ratio having the value 2 (at ac 2 /2, ct ac). By a convenient compression along the c axis, the body-centred tetragonal cell can be transformed into a body-centred cubic cell.
110
Intermetallic Chemistry
research, described how he in 1923, together with H. Mark, determined the crystal structure of white tin (βSn, tI4). Just after this study they received a visit from a colleague, who had independently determined the same structure. The colleague strongly maintained that Polanyi’s structure was wrong. And, in Polanyi’s words: ‘only after hours of discussion did it become apparent that his structure was actually the same as ours, but looked different because he represented it with axes turned by 45° with respect to ours’. Nevertheless it may be observed that, in some specific cases, reference to a pseudo-face-centred tetragonal cell may be useful, for instance to compare the structure under examination with a face-centred cubic structure. 3.6.1.3.3 Interatomic distances. Relevant data in the description and evaluation of the characteristics (coordination) of a structure are the values of the interatomic distances. A summary of the formulae to be used for their calculation is given here. In the general case, the distance d1–2 between points (atoms) 1 and 2 having, in the unit cell, along the axes x, y, z the fractional coordinates x1, y1, z1 and x2, y2, z2 may be calculated, from the crystallographic constants a, b, c, α, β, γ (defined as in Table 3.3) according to the following equation: 2 a2(x2 x1)2 b2(y2 y1)2 c2(z2 z1)2 2ab(x2 x1)(y2 y1)cos γ d12 2bc(y2 y1) (z2 z1)cos α 2ca(z2 z1) (x2 x1)cos β
(triclinic axes) which simplifies to: d 212 a2(x2 x1)2 b2(y2 y1)2 c2(z2 z1)2 2ca(z2 z1)(x2 x1)cos β (monoclinic axes) and respectively to: d 212 a2[(x2 x1)2 (y2 y1)2] c2(z2 z1)2 a2(x2 x1) (y2 y1) (hexagonal axes) (γ 120°) that is: d 212/a2 [(x2 x1)2 (y2 y1)2 (x2 x1) (y2 y1)] c2/a2(z2 z1)2 (hexagonal axes)
111
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
or to: d 212 a2[(x2 x1)2 (y2 y1)2 (z2 z1)2] 2a2[(x2 x1) (y2 y1) (y2 y1) (z2 z1) (z2 z1) (x2 x1)] cos α (rhombohedral axes) For orthoclinic axes (rectangular) we have: d 212 a2(x2 x1)2 b2(y2 y1)2 c2(z2 z1)2
(orthorhombic)
d212 a2[(x2 x1)2 (y2 y1)2] c2(z2 z1)2
(tetragonal)
that is: d212/a2 [(x2 x1)2 (y2 y1)2] c2/a2(z2 z1)2
(tetragonal)
and: d 212 a2[(x2 x1)2 (y2 y1)2 (z2 z1)2]
(cubic)
that is d 212/a2 (x2 x1)2 (y2 y1)2 (z2 z1)2 (constant for fixed parameter positions). 3.6.1.3.4 Plane and direction indices. Reference to the three coordinate axes (crystallographic axes) must also be made, in order to indicate (to identify) the position of a plane and the direction of a line. A plane is identified by its equation or by three parameters. These are related to the plane intercepts on the three chosen crystallographic axes (z, y, z) with reference to their own unit lengths (a, b and c). The three indices, generically defined by the three letters h, k and l are defined by the ratios: h: k : l aA : Bb : Cc : where a, b and c are the unit cell edges and A, B and C are the plane intercepts (see Fig. 3.13). The symbol of the plane is (hkl) with the three indexes (reduced to the smallest relative prime integers) within round brackets. If a plane is parallel to an axis the corres-ponding index is zero. So the indices (100), (010) and (001) represent the faces of the unit cell. The direction of a line, passing through the origin, is indicated by a similar symbol [uvw], within square brackets, defined by: u: v: w xa : yb : zc where a, b and P P P c are the unit cell edges and xP, yP and zP are the coordinates of an arbitrary point on the line. So [010] is the symbol of the direction (of the axis) y.
112
Intermetallic Chemistry (a)
z C=c
B=1 2b b
y
A=a x ∞
z
(b) ∞
c
y B=b
A=a x
∞
z
(c) ∞
c +u y
A=a
−u
B=b=a
x
Figure 3.13. Crystallographic index of a plane. The plane shown in (a) has the intercepts: A a, B –12 b and C c. Its symbol is (121). The plane (110), parallel to the z-axis, is shown in (b). In (c) the plane (110) is shown in the hexagonal system. The full index h, k, i, l, with reference to the axes – x, y, u (all coplanar) and z, is (1120). Notice the negative intercept on the axis u. See text.
Notice that, for reasons of symmetry, in the hexagonal system a somewhat redundant index type may be used for plane identification. It is customary to define an auxiliary axis u at 120° to x and y and 90° to z (and with the same unit length of the x and y axes). As a consequence instead of indices (hkl) for a face, indices (h, k, i, l) are used, where the index i is related to the axis u in the same way
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
113
as h and k are related to the axes x and y (see Fig. 3.13 (c)). It can be shown that the index i is not independent from h and k and that h k i 0. In a way, it is therefore a matter of personal choice whether three or four symbols are used.
3.6.2 Shortened version of the standard description: structural types Several intermetallic phases are known which have the same (or a similar) stoichiometry and crystallize in the same crystal system and space group with the same occupied point positions. Such compounds are considered as belonging to the same structure type. About 30 000 intermetallic phases have been described. These, however, may be grouped in about 2800 types. The reference to the structure type may be a simpler and more convenient way of describing the structure of the specific phase. The structure type is generally named after the formula of the first representative identified: the ‘prototype’. Expressions such as: ‘KCl has the NaCl structure type’ are frequently used. Trivial names and symbols may also be found in several cases. The various representatives of a specific structure type generally have different unit cell edges, different values of the occupancy parameters and of the free coordinates of the atomic positions and, in the same atomic positions, different atoms. However, if these differences are small, the general pattern of the structure may be considered unaltered. On the other hand, of course, if these differences become larger, it might be more convenient to describe the situation in terms of a ‘family’, instead of a single structural type, of different (more or less strictly interrelated) structural (sub) types. According to Parthé and Gelato (1984), some structures may not really be isotypic but only isopointal, which means that they have the same space group and the same occupation of Wyckoff positions with the same adjustable parameters, but different unit cell axial ratios and/or different values of Wyckoff free parameters and different atom coordinations. An interesting example may be given by the structures of MoSi2 (reported in Table 3.2a) and CaC2. In this compound, Ca and C are respectively in the same positions as Mo and Si in the same space group I4/mmm: 2 Ca in (a): 0, 0, 0; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 4 C in (e): 0, 0, z; 0, 0, –z ; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2, z; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 z. The unit cell dimensions, however, correspond to a 388 pm, c 638 pm (c/a 1.644 instead of 2.463 as in MoSi2) and the free parameter z has the value 0.4068 (instead of 0.333). These differences result in two different space arrangements (see Fig. 3.7). Diatomic groups, such as C2, clearly evident in CaC2 and in a number of isostructural dicarbides and peroxides, are not formed in MoSi2. Very
114
Intermetallic Chemistry
interesting general comments and definitions on this question have been proposed, for instance, by Pearson (1972), and more recently by Lima de Faria et al. (1990). According to these authors, two structures are isoconfigurational (configurationally isotypic) if they are isopointal and similar with respect to the corresponding Wyckoff positions and their geometrical interrelationships (same or similar positional coordinates, same or similar values of the unit cell axial ratios, c/a, a/b, b/c and cell angles α, β, γ). Isotypism is found particularly with inorganic compounds. This behaviour has been discussed by Parthé et al. (1993). It has been underlined that it is not always simple to explain why two compounds adopt the same atom arrangement. The following examples have been presented: ●
●
●
●
The isotypism of Gd4Ni6Al23 and Y4Ni6Al23 may be easily explained because Gd and Y (elements of the same group of the Periodic Table) have comparable electron configuration and nearly the same atomic dimensions. Li2SiO3 and LiSi2N3 are isotypic, even if not in a rigorous sense, owing to slightly different distortions of the coordination polyhedra. They adopt an adamantine structure type, for which particular values of the electron concentration may be relevant even if obtained with elements from different parts of the Periodic Table. GdNi and NiB represent another couple of isotypic compounds. The role (the position in the crystal structure), however, of the same atom, Ni, in the two compounds is exchanged. In NiB, the Ni atoms are those centring the trigonal prism formed by Gd atoms. A reason for the existence of this structure type could possibly be related to the atomic size difference of the elements involved or, perhaps, to their relative position in the Pettifor chemical scale. The last and most intriguing example reported by Parthé et al. (1993) is the couple of compounds Pu31Rh20 and Ca31Sn20. For the present, the isotypism of these compounds of unusual stoichiometry is unexpected and cannot be explained.
As a conclusion to these comments, we may mention that two structures are defined as crystal-chemically isotypic if they are isoconfigurational and the corresponding atoms (and bonds) have similar chemical/physical characteristics. These concepts and their historical development were summarized in a contribution by Laves (1944), translated and reported by Hellner (1979), in which conditions for calling crystal structures ‘equal’ (isotypism), ‘similar’ (homeotypism) or ‘different’ (heterotypism) are discussed and exemplified. Finally we have to observe that, when considering phases having certain polar characteristics (salt-like ‘bonding’), the concepts type and antitype may be useful.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
115
Antitypic phases have the same site occupations as the typical ones, but with the cation–anion positions exchanged, or more generally some important physical/ chemical characteristics of the corresponding atoms interchanged. As examples, the structure types CaF2 and CdI2 and their antitypes (exemplified by Na2S and Ti2O, respectively) may be considered. Notice, however, that for a structure such as the CsCl type, it does not matter whether we describe it as 1 Cs in 0, 0, 0 and 1 Cl in 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2, or as 1 Cs in 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 and 1 Cl in 0, 0, 0. In this case the two descriptions are undistinguishable (see Fig. 3.8): they correspond to a mere shift of the origin of the reference axes. The CsCl type is its own antitype. Similar considerations are also valid for other structures such as the NaCl, ZnS types, etc.
3.6.3 Structure types and unit cell Pearson symbol The use of the so-called Pearson notation (Pearson 1972) is highly recommended (IUPAC, Petzow and Effenberg 1988 et seq, Leigh 1990, Villars et al. 1995) for the construction of a compact symbolic representation of the structure of the phase. As far as possible, it should be completed with a more detailed structural description by using the prototype formula which defines, as previously mentioned, a certain structure type. The Pearson symbol is composed of a sequence of two letters and a number. The first (small) letter corresponds to the crystal system of the structure type involved; the second (capital) letter represents the lattice type (see Table 3.3). The symbol S is generally adopted to indicate ‘side centred faces’ instead of the C used in the past. The symbol is completed by the ‘ideal’ number of the atoms, corresponding to the full occupation of all the sites, in the unit cell. This is possibly followed, within brackets, by the real number of atoms present, due to vacancies, in the cell. A symbol such as tP10 represents a structure type, or a group of structure types, corresponding to 10 atoms in a primitive tetragonal cell. A symbol such as tI12 (11.5) represents a structure corresponding to a body-centred tetragonal unit cell ideally containing 12 atoms when all the sites are fully occupied, but in which however, on average only 11.5 atoms are present, due to a partial occupation of some atomic positions. In this book, the Pearson symbol will be used throughout and the convention has been adopted indicating in every case the number (ideal or effective) of atoms contained in the chosen unit cell. In the case, therefore, of rhombohedral substances for which the data of the (triple primitive) hexagonal cell are generally reported, the number of atoms is given which is in the hexagonal cell and not the number of atoms in the equivalent rhombohedral cell (Ferro and Girgis 1990). So, for instance,
116
Intermetallic Chemistry
at variance with Villars and Calvert (1985, 1991), hR9 (and not rP3 or hR3) is given for the Sm-type structure. If the structure is not known exactly, the prototype indication cannot be added to the Pearson symbol. In some cases, moreover, only incomplete Pearson symbols (such as o?60, cF?, etc.) can be used. Criteria similar to Pearson’s for the unit cell designation were used by Schubert (1964) and Frevel (1985). According to Parthé et al. (1993), a standardization procedure is necessary in the presentation of the relevant data characteristic of a crystal structure (see also Parthé and Gelato 1984). A convenient description of the structure types is then possible using the ‘Wyckoff sequence’ (the letters of the occupied Wyckoff sites). This allows a finer classification of structure types and offers suggestions not only for recognizing isotypic structures but also possible structural relationships like substitution, formation of vacancy or filled-in structure variants.
3.7. ALTERNATIVE AND COMPLEMENTARY DESCRIPTIONS OF THE CRYSTAL STRUCTURES OF THE SOLID PHASES
…..O, be some other name! What’s in a name? That which we call a rose By any other name would smell as sweet; ….. (Shakespeare, ‘Romeo and Juliet’ 2, II, 41–43).
In the previous paragraphs a brief account has been given of the fundamental aspects of the crystallographic description of the structures and structure types of solid phases. A number of symbols and names have been defined and their application to intermetallic compounds exemplified. It must, however, be underlined that both for historical reasons and for the need to improve classification and interpretation of the structural characteristics of intermetallic phases, other symbols and nomenclature criteria have been invented. Some of them have a mathematical basis, others are more colloquial. A selection of these criteria will be given in the following. 3.7.1 Lattice complexes A description which in some simple cases could be considered alternative to those exemplified in Table 3.2 is based on the lattice complex concept. Listing the symbols of the lattice complexes occupied by the different atoms in a structure (for instance, symbol P for the point 0, 0, 0 and its equivalent points), provides in fact
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
117
a means of describing and classifying structures. This may be especially convenient for relatively simple structures particularly in the cubic system. A lattice complex may be defined as an arrangement of equivalent points that are related by space group symmetry operations including lattice translations (Pearson 1972). The same lattice complex may occur in different space group types and may have more than one location in regard to a chosen origin for the unit cell. The number of degrees of freedom of a lattice complex, normally, is the same as that of any of its Wyckoff positions and is the number of coordinate (free) parameters x, y, z, that can vary independently. According to its number of degrees of freedom a lattice complex is called invariant, uni-, bi- or tri-variant. The invariant lattice complexes in their characteristic Wyckoff positions are represented mainly by capital letters. Those with equipoints at the nodes of the Bravais lattice are designated by their appropriate lattice symbols. Lattice complexes, from different crystal families that have the same coordinate description for their characteristic Wyckoff positions, receive the same symbol: for instance, lattice complex P corresponding to coordinate 0, 0, 0. In such a case, unless it is obvious from the context which lattice is meant, the crystal family may be stated by a small letter, preceding the lattice complex symbol as follows: c cubic, t tetragonal, h hexagonal, o orthorhombic, m monoclinic, a anorthic triclinic. Other invariant complexes are designated by letters that recall some structural features of a given complex, for instance D from the diamond structure, E from the hexagonal close-packing. Examples of two-dimensional (2D) invariant complexes are G (from graphite layer) and K (from kagomé net). A short list of invariant lattice complex symbols is reported in the following. For a complete list, for a more systematic description and formal definition, see the International Tables of Crystallography, Hahn (2002). ●
●
●
●
Lattice complex P: (multiplicity 1; multiplicity is the number of equivalent points in the unit cell) Coordinates 0, 0, 0. (crystal families: c, t, h, o, m, a). Lattice complex I: (multiplicity 2) Coordinates 0, 0, 0; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 (crystal families: c, t, o). Lattice complex J: (multiplicity 3) Coordinates 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 0, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0 (crystal families: c). Lattice complex F: (multiplicity 4) Coordinates 0, 0, 0; 0,1⁄2, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 0, 1⁄2; 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 0 (crystal families: c, o).
118 ●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
Intermetallic Chemistry
Lattice complex Y: (multiplicity 4) Coordinates 1⁄8, 1⁄8, 1⁄8; 7⁄8, 5⁄8, 3⁄8; 5⁄8, 3⁄8, 7⁄8; (crystal families: c). Lattice complex W: (multiplicity 6) Coordinates 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄4; 1⁄2, 1⁄4, 0; 1⁄4, 0, 1⁄2; (crystal families: c). Lattice complex D: (multiplicity 8) (D from ‘Diamond’) Coordinates 0, 0, 0; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0; 1⁄2, 0, 1⁄2; 1 ⁄4, 1⁄4, 1⁄4; 3⁄4, 3⁄4, 1⁄4; 3⁄4, 1⁄4, 3⁄4; (crystal families: c, o). Lattice complex S: (multiplicity 12) Coordinates 3⁄8, 0, 1⁄4; 1⁄4, 3⁄8, 0; 0, 1⁄4, 3⁄8; 7 ⁄8, 1⁄2, 3⁄4; 3⁄4, 7⁄8, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 3⁄4, 7⁄8; (crystal families: c) Lattice complex T: (multiplicity 16) Coordinates 1⁄8, 1⁄8, 1⁄8; 3⁄8, 1⁄8, 3⁄8; 1⁄8, 3⁄8, 3⁄8; 5 ⁄8, 5⁄8, 1⁄8; 7⁄8, 1⁄8, 7⁄8; 1⁄8, 7⁄8, 7⁄8; 3 ⁄8, 7⁄8, 5⁄8; 3⁄8, 5⁄8, 7⁄8; 5⁄8, 7⁄8, 3⁄8; (crystal families: c, o). Lattice complex E: (multiplicity 2) Coordinates 1⁄3, 2⁄3, 1⁄4; 2⁄3, 1⁄3, 3⁄4 (crystal families: h). Lattice complex G: (multiplicity 2) (G from ‘Graphite’ layer) Coordinates 1⁄3, 2⁄3, 0; 2⁄3, 1⁄3, 0 (crystal families: h). Lattice complex R: (multiplicity 3) Coordinates 0, 0, 0; 1⁄3, 2⁄3, 2⁄3; 2⁄3, 1⁄3, 1⁄3 (crystal families: h).
⁄8, 7⁄8, 5⁄8
3
0, 1⁄2, 3⁄4;
⁄2, 3⁄4, 0;
1
⁄4, 0, 1⁄2
3
0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 1 ⁄4, 3⁄4, 3⁄4
1
⁄8, 0, 3⁄4; 5 ⁄8, 1⁄2, 1⁄4;
3
⁄8, 3⁄8, 1⁄8; 7 ⁄8, 7⁄8, 1⁄8; 7 ⁄8, 3⁄8, 5⁄8;
1
3
⁄4, 1⁄8, 0; 0, 3⁄4, 1⁄8 1 ⁄4, 5⁄8, 1⁄2 1⁄2, 1⁄4, 5⁄8
⁄8, 5⁄8, 5⁄8; 7 ⁄8, 5⁄8, 3⁄8;
⁄8, 1⁄8, 5⁄8 5 ⁄8, 3⁄8, 7⁄8 5
The coordinates indicated in the reported partial list of invariant lattice complexes correspond to the so-called ‘standard setting’ and to related standard representations. Some of the non-standard settings of an invariant lattice complex may be described by a shifting vector, defined in terms of fractional coordinates, in front of the symbol. The most common shifting vectors also have abbreviated symbols: P⬘ represents 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 P (that is the coordinates which are obtained by adding 1 ⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 to those of P, that is: coordinates 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2), J⬘ represents 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 J (coordinates 1⁄2, 0, 0; 0, 1⁄2, 0; 0, 0, 1⁄2); F ⬙ represents 1⁄4, 1⁄4, 1⁄4 F (coordinates 1⁄4, 1⁄4, 1⁄4; 1⁄4, 3⁄4, 3⁄4; 3 ⁄4, 1⁄4, 3⁄4; 3⁄4, 3⁄4, 1⁄4) and F ⬙⬘ represents 3⁄4, 3⁄4, 3⁄4 F. It can be seen, moreover, that the complex D corresponds to the coordinates F F ⬙.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases 0
0
0
0 4
0
0
4 4
0
0
0
P
4
I 0
4 0
0 26
7
5 5
1
3
4
4
26 0
0 26 0
Y∗
3
6
5
1
3
5
7
6
7
3
1
5
3
1
7
5
2
3
7
5
1
5
7
1
3
6
5
1
3
7
7
5
3
1
2
37 4
0
15 0
4
37
T
2
6
6
2
04 04
0
04 04
P2
0
4
04
4
4
04
0
04
0
4
04
4
6
2
2
6
J∗ 1
3
0
4 7
4
0
1
1
2 6 2 6
15 4
0
37 0
S∗
4
15
04
6
2
2
6
6
2
2
6
15 0
4
37 4
0
15
04 26
26
26
26
04
2 6
4 3
V
6 2 6 2
37 0
4
15 4
V∗
0
37
04
2 6 2 6
04 26
04 26
04
P2′
2
5
26 04
04
6
+
S
3
04
7
6
3
7
04
4 2
0
4
5
Y ∗∗
1 0
2
1
F″
4
4 26 4 W∗
+
4
D
0
4
4
2
0
4 26 4 3 7
6
W
1
0
6 0
4
3
4
F
2 4
4
+Y
0
0
4
4
5 7
4
J
26 1
4
0
119
04 26
04
04
I2
Figure 3.14. Projections of unit cells are shown which correspond to cubic invariant complexes in their standard setting. The numbers indicate, in eighths of the unit cell edge a, the positions of the points along the third axis (perpendicular to the drawing). Therefore: four represents a point at a height of 4/8 (1⁄2 a) and 26 represents two superimposed points at heights respectively of 2/8 and 6/8 of the edge. A few examples of representations with enlarged cells are shown (P2, P2 , I2). Notice that with reference to these cells the shifting vector between P2 and P2 is 1⁄4, 1⁄4, 1⁄4.
The signs and as superscripts in front of the letters (for instance Y, Y ) indicate enantiomorphic forms. The superscript * (‘star’) indicates a complex that may be built up as a combination of two complexes of the same kind shifted against each other by 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 (W* W 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 W W W ) or as a combination of two enantiomorphic forms (see the examples shown in Fig. 3.15). Other representations may be obtained by subdividing the unit cell into a number of similar subcells. In the cubic system the subdivision is made along the three axes by the same factor which is used as a subscript in the new lattice complex
120
Intermetallic Chemistry 7 3 1 5 5
7
3
1
3
−
Y′
1
5
7 −
Y∗
5 1 3
1
5
7
3
7
3
1
5
3
7
5
1
5
1
3
7
Y
∗∗
7 −
Y 3
7 5 1 1
3
7
5 7
5
1
3
+
Y∗
+
Y′
1 5 7 3 +
Y
Figure 3.15. An example of relations between invariant lattice complexes with the symbols of their representations.
symbol: P2, P4, I2, etc. In the cubic system where all axes have to be changed by the same factor, we have P222 P2, etc. A schematic representation of cubic lattice complexes is given in Figs 3.14 and 3.15; this could also be useful as an indication of possible combinations and ‘splitting’. Such relations may be useful while comparing different structures and studying their interrelations and possible transformations (order–disorder transformations, etc.) A short list of examples of structure descriptions in terms of combination of invariant lattice complexes is here reported. (Compare with the structure descriptions in Chapter 7.) CsCl-type structure: P P (Cs in 0,0,0; Cl in 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2); NaCl-type structure: F F ; ZnS (sphalerite) type structure: F F; NaTl-type structure: D D ; AuCu3-type structure: P J; CaF2-type structure: F F F F P ; 2 Fe4Ntype structure: P J P ; Li3Bi-type structure: F F F F F F P ; 2
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
121
Cr3Si-type structure: W I; AgMgAs-type structure: F F F; CaTiO3-type structure: P P J; Cu2Mg-type structure: T D. For a few element structures: Cu type structure: F; W-type structure: I; α-Po-type structure: P; Mg-type structure: E; C-diamond-type structure: D. As a simple example of transformations, the β M β transformation in the Cu–Zn system may be mentioned. At high temperature the equiatomic alloy has the cI2-W-type structure with Cu and Zn atoms distributed at random in the two equivalent positions. On cooling, the stable structure corresponds to an ordered disposition of the two species in the two positions (no longer equivalent) of the cell assuming the cP2-CsCl type structure. In terms of lattice complexes the transformation may be represented by the equation I : P P⬘. Similarly the ordering into the AuCu3-type structure of a disordered Cu-25 at.% Au solid solution (facecentred cubic cF4-Cu type) corresponds to the equation: F : P J. The reported combinations of original or transformed invariant lattice complexes are also indicated as connection patterns or construction patterns or frameworks (or Bauverbände in the German literature, according to Laves 1930). These patterns are homogeneous if they may be described by the parameters of one point position; heterogeneous if, for their description, the parameters of two or more independent point positions are necessary. This terminology may give a short informative description of the crystal structure and it is especially useful for cubic substances. For its use in a systematic description and classification of cubic structures see Hellner (1979). For non-invariant complexes and/or in crystal systems with symmetry lower than cubic, the geometrical configuration of the complex (and the coordination) may change significantly with free parameter values and with axial ratios and angles between the crystal axes. 3.7.2 Alternative structural descriptions and symbols All the requisite structural information for a solid phase is contained (either explicitly or implicitly) in the description of its unit cell. A number of features, however, which are especially relevant for chemical–physical considerations, such as local coordination geometries, the existence of clusters of atoms or chains or layers, etc., are not self-evident in the aforementioned structural descriptions and can be deduced only by means of a more or less complicated series of calculations. Another point which should be underlined is that the same structure can be differently viewed and described (Parthé and Gelato 1984, Franzen 1986). The simple rocksalt structure, for instance, can be viewed as a cubic close-packed set of anions with cations in octahedral holes, as XY6 octahedra sharing edges, as a stacking sequence of superimposed alternate triangular nets, respectively, of X and Y atoms
122
Intermetallic Chemistry
or as a cubic-close-packed structure of a metal with non-metals in octahedral interstices. As a further example the cubic Cu structure, for instance, could be conveniently compared with those, hexagonal, of Mg, La and Sm, or from another point of view, with the tetragonal AuCu, and cubic AuCu3 structures. In the two cases, one could choose a different description and representation of the aforementioned Cu structure. In the different cases, some criteria may therefore be useful in order to give explicit information on the characteristic structural features in a systematic and simple way. In the following sections some details will be given on a few complementary, alternative notations.
3.7.3 Coordination and dimensionality symbols in the crystal coordination formula Several attempts have been made at designing special formulae which (possibly in a convenient linear format) may convey explicit information on the connections and coordination of each atom. One interesting approach was aimed at giving information about the local coordination geometry. A detailed discussion of these attempts and of their development (through the work, inter alios, of Niggli 1945, 1948, Machatschki 1938, 1953, Lima de Faria and Figueiredo 1976, 1978, Parthé 1980, Jensen 1984) may be found in a review by Jensen (1989), who presented and systematically discussed a flexible notation for an interpretation of solid-state structures. A short description of Jensen’s notation will be given below. A report by the International Union of Crystallography Commission on Crystallographic Nomenclature (Lima de Faria et al. 1990) presents a concise description of similar alternative notations, a summary of which is in Table 3.4. The symbols suggested by Jensen, based on Niggli’s proposals, describe the ‘local coordination’ by means of coordination number ratios. For instance, a formula AEm/n will indicate a binary compound where m is the coordination number (defined as the nearest-neighbour number (NNN)) of atoms E around A and n is the similarly defined coordination number of A around E. However, for alternative definitions of coordination and coordination numbers, see the following paragraphs. In simple binary structures, in which no other relevant coordinations (or bonds) can be considered, the ratio m/n will be equal to the stoichiometric compositional ratio. For instance, we will write NaCl6/6 to represent the hexa-coordination (in this case octahedral coordination) of Cl around Na (and vice versa) in sodium chloride. Similarly we will have: ZnS4/4; PH3/1; CsCl8/8; CaF8/4; UCl9/3; etc. Moreover, it is possible to add modifiers to the coordination numbers in order to specify not only topological but also geometrical characteristics of the primary coordination sphere.
123
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases Table 3.4. Suggested notations for common coordination geometries (from Lima de Faria et al. 1990). Coordination polyhedron around atom A Single neighbour Two atoms collinear with atom A Two atoms non-collinear with atom A Triangle coplanar with atom A Triangle non-coplanar with atom A Triangular pyramid with atom A in the centre of the base Tetrahedron Square coplanar with atom A Square non-coplanar with atom A Pentagon coplanar with atom A Tetragonal pyramid with atom A in the centre of the base Trigonal bipyramid Octahedron Trigonal prism Trigonal antiprism Pentagonal bipyramid Monocapped trigonal prism Bicapped trigonal prism Tetragonal prism Tetragonal antiprism Cube Anticube Dodecahedron with triangular faces Hexagonal bipyramid Tricapped trigonal prism Cuboctahedron Anticuboctahedron (twinned cubooctahedron) Icosahedron Truncated tetrahedron Hexagonal prism Frank – Kasper polyhedra with 14 vertices 15 vertices 16 vertices
Complete symbol
Alternative simplified symbols
[1l] [2l] [2n] [3l] [3n] [4y]
[1] [2] [2] [3] [3] [4]
[4t] [t] [4l] or [4s][s] [4n] [5l] [5y]
[4] t [4] s [4] [5] [5]
[5by] [6o] [o] [6p] [p] [6ap] [ap] [7by] [6p1c] [6p2c] [8p] [8ap] [8cb] [cb] [8acb] [acb] [8do] [do] [8by] [6p3c] [12co] [co] [12aco] [aco]
[5] [6] [6] [6] [7] [7] [8] [8] [8] [8] [8] [8] [8] [9] [12] [12]
[12i] [i] [12tt] [12p]
[12] i [12] [12]
[14FK] [15FK] [16FK]
[14] [15] [16]
o p ap
cb acb do
co aco
124
Intermetallic Chemistry
A set of symbols was proposed by Donnay et al. (1964) who suggested adding one or two letters to the coordination number, to indicate the geometry: y, pyramidal; l, planar; c, cubic; etc. Detailed descriptions of the coordination polyhedra are obtained by means of the Lima de Faria et al. (1990) symbols presented in Table 3.4. An advantage of the Lima de Faria symbolism is the existence of two alternative, complete and simplified sets of symbols. The simplified symbols give only a numerical indication, without any distinction between different geometries; the complete symbols, clearly distinguishable from the previous ones, contain a description of the coordination polyhedron beside the numeric indication. A selection of the Lima de Faria symbols, together with Jensen’s suggestions, will be used here. According to Jensen, the dimensionality of a structure (or of a substructure of the same) is indicated by enclosing its compositional formula in square brackets d and prefixing an appropriate symbol . The dimensionality index, d, may be: d 0 for a discrete molecular (cluster, ring) structure, d 1 for a 1D, infinite chain structure, d 2 for a 2D, infinite layer structure and d 3 for an infinite 3D, - framework structure. More complex symbols such as d_d or d d d will represent intermediate dimensionality (between d and d⬘) or, the dimensionality indexes of different substructures (d ⬘ and d ⬙ ) followed by that of the overall structure (d). A few examples: Molecular structures
0 [HI],
Linear structures
1 [BeCl ] 2
Layer structures
2 [C]
graphite, 2 [As]
Framework structures
3 [C]
diamond
Substructures
0 Ca[CO ] 3 1 K[PO ] 3
0 [CO ] 2
(finite ions)
(infinite anionic PO 3 chain), etc.
If, in an A–B structure, one wishes to show not only the A/B coordination but also the B/B, or A/A, self-coordinations, this is done, according to the suggestion by Jensen, via the use of a composite dimensionality index and the relative positions of the various ratios and brackets in the formula, with the last un-bracketed ratio always referring to the B/A coordination. So, for instance, 0_ 3 [( H 2O)4/4 ] is 03 a compact form for [( H 2O)(H 2O)4/4 ] to indicate the molecular packing in the 323 ice structure. The formula 23 Al[B3 / 3 ]12 / 6 or [Al8 by / 8 by ][B31 / 31 ]12 p/6p
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
125
corresponds to a more or less detailed description of the AlB2-type structure where the coordination of B around Al is 12 (12p: hexagonal prismatic) and that of Al around B is 6 (6p: trigonal prismatic). The self-coordinations are bipyramidal for Al/Al (8by: hexagonal bipyramidal) and trigonal-planar (3l) for B/B (the B atoms form a 2D hexagonal net). Considering as a further example the compounds AB having the CsCl- type structure, according to Jensen, the two descriptions 3 [AB 333 [A 8 / 8 ] (with and without the indication of the self 6 / 6 ][B6 / 6 ]8/8 and coordination) may also be used to suggest the bonding type (metallic if the A–A and B–B interactions substantially contribute to the overall bonding, ionic or covalent, if mainly A–B interactions have to be considered). More complex examples of the use of this notation may be given by the structures of typical fluorides for which ionic-type coordination formulae are here reported: oP16-YF3:
3 [YF F ] 8 / 3 1/ 3
hP8-LaF3:
3 [LaF F ] 8/ 4 3/ 3
cF16-BiF3:
3 [BiF F 8 / 4 6 / 6 ].
In all these cases the sum of the numerators of the coordination ratios gives the total coordination (of two groups of F atoms) around the metal atom. The sums of the ratios give the stoichiometric coefficients. Another example is represented by the hP6-Ni2In structure ( 3 [InNi6 / 6 Ni5 / 5 ]) described in Chapter 7. A detailed example (AuCu3) of the application of the aforementioned notation to the description of a simple intermetallic structure will be presented in § 3.7.7. A few more examples will be included in the following descriptions of a number of typical structures (see Chapter 7). 3.7.3.1 Coordination number and packing geometry. On the basis of the previous definition of the coordination number (as the number of first neighbours), and of the corresponding coordination geometries (as listed in Table 3.4) some additional remarks may be useful for the particular case of packing of hard sphere atoms. If we have N hard spheres (of radius rS) forming a close-packed polyhedron, another sphere (of smaller radius rC) can fit neatly into the central hole of the polyhedron if the radius ratio has a well-defined value (see also § 3.8.1.1). The ideal radius ratio (rC/rS) for a perfect fit is: 0.225.. (in a regular tetrahedron, CN 4), 0.414.. (regular octahedron CN 6), 0.528.. (Archimedean trigonal prism CN 6), 0.645… (Archimedean square antiprism CN 8), 0.732.. (cube CN 8), 0.902… (regular icosahedron CN 12), 1 (cuboctahedron and twinned cuboctahedron CN 12).
126
Intermetallic Chemistry
For hard spheres, coordination numbers higher than 12 require smaller spheres to cluster around a larger one. Hard spheres of the same radius however, will not fit exactly with all the neighbours in these clusters: two or more types of surrounding spheres (with slightly different values of rS) are needed. It is only possible therefore to define an average rC/rS radius ratio for the best fit. This average ratio is higher than 1 and ranges from 1.2 to 1.3 for CN 14–16.
3.7.4 The concept of coordination number In the description of ‘crystal coordination formulae’ a coordination number was introduced, defined as the NNN of atoms X around the atom Y under consideration. It may be underlined indeed that the determination of the local coordination geometry of an atom in a structure is clearly an important point in the definition of that atom’s contribution to the bulk material properties and in the characterization of the structure itself. Several properties, for instance, atomic size, atomic valence and magnetic properties and species stability and reactivity, are known to be coordination, and coordination number, dependent. However, it can be noticed that the term coordination number (CN) may be used in two ways in crystallography (Frank and Kasper 1958). That is, according to one definition, the coordination number, as previously mentioned, is the number of nearest neighbours to an atom. According to the other, the definition of the coordination should be based on an ‘interpretation’ of the structure, which depends not only on an evaluation of the interatomic distances to assign bonding vs. non-bonding contacts, but on considerations on the bonding mechanism (Jensen 1989). These considerations are particularly important when thinking of metallic phases where it may be difficult to make distinctions between X–X, X–Y or Y–Y contacts. So, for instance, when considering the bodycentred cubic structure of the W-type, some authors define the coordination number as 8, in agreement with the nearest-neighbours definition, but others prefer to regard it as 14 (including a group of six atoms at a slightly higher distance). More generally, in many cases of intermetallic compounds, unlike a high number of covalent compounds (compare for instance with the illustrative example of a carbon atom in the diamond structure), we cannot speak of ‘bonds’ of an atom ‘directed’ to (and ‘saturated’ with) a well-defined group of atoms. As a consequence the coordination number (or ligancy) of a central atom which is easily obtained by enumerating the neighbours (and which, of course, has an important role in the description of the crystal structure and of its geometrical characteristics), very often is not clearly and immediately related to the bonding mechanism of the intermetallic phase. In other words, there are many cases in which the enumeration procedure alone gives only a very partial representation of the bonding. Moreover, there are numerous cases where the criteria for the enumeration
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
127
(a)
d2
3/4 c
1/4 c a
a
(b)
z = 1/4
d1
z = 3/4
(c) Cd Zn
hp2-Mg type
R = d 2 /d1
1.10
1.05
1.00
0.95
Mg
e Fe(HP) a Ti
Re
a Yb
a Li
b AI(HP) a Tl a Be b Ba e Co 1.60
1.70 c /a
1.80
1.90
Figure 3.16. The hexagonal unit cell (edges a and c) of Mg is shown in (a). The cell contains two atoms in the positions: 1⁄3, 2⁄3, 1⁄4 and 2⁄3, 1⁄3, 3⁄4. Around each Mg atom there are 6 Mg on the same plane (at a distance d1) forming a regular hexagon, six other near atoms are at a distance d2 (three on each of the over and underlying layers). The value of the first distance is given by d1 a, and the second –– 1 by d2 (a2/3 c2/4) ⁄2; if c/a 8/3 1.632993… then d1 d2. In (b) at level 1⁄4 c and 3⁄4 c, sections of nine adjacent cells are shown. In (c), the ratio d2/d1 is given as a function of c/a for several hexagonal, Mg-type, elements. Notice the clustering of the points round the ideal value and the deviation shown by Zn and Cd.
procedure may be ambiguous. For an introductory description of this point, see for instance: Carter (1978), O’Keeffe (1979). Another example may be represented by the hexagonal close-packed hP2-Mg type structure where, according to the first —– definition, CN is 6 unless the axial ratio c/a has exactly the ‘ideal’ value (8/3)
128
Intermetallic Chemistry
(1.63299…), in which case it is 12. See Fig. 3.16 and the arrangement of the white balls around the black one in the scheme 12-d of Fig. 3.18. In the previously mentioned example of the Mg-type structure (Fig. 3.16), the mentioned definition of CN is seldom applied with rigour, that is, the CN in the hP2-Mg type structure is generally regarded as 12, even with c/a slightly different from the ‘ideal’ value, as not only the first group, but also the very close second group of distances are considered together. More difficulties arise in less symmetrical structures and when there is a high coordination number. Near neighbours with slightly different interatomic distances are often found, and it may be difficult to determine unambiguously how many atoms should be considered as coordinating the central one. As regards the second method of coordination evaluation, several schemes for the calculation of an ‘effective’ coordination have been proposed. According to Frank and Kasper (1958), the computation of the coordination number can be based on the definition of the ‘domain’ of an atom in a structure. This is the space in which all points are nearer to the centre of that atom than to any other. It is a polyhedron (Voronoi polyhedron, Voronoi cell, Wigner–Seitz cell), each face of which is the plane equidistant between that atom and a neighbour. Every atom whose domain has a face in common with the domain of the central atom is, by the Frank–Kasper definition, one of its neighbours. The counting of the faces of the domain polyhedron gives the number of neighbours: the set of neighbours is the ‘coordination shell’. The coordination polyhedron, of course, is the polyhedron whose edges are the lines joining all the atoms in the coordination shell. The domain (Voronoi) polyhedron and the coordination polyhedron, therefore, stand in dual relationship, each having a vertex corresponding to each face of the other. According to the Frank–Kasper definition, the coordination number is unambiguously 12 in the hexagonal close-packed metals and assumes the value 14 in a body-centred cubic metal. Generally in several complex metallic structures this definition yields reasonable values such as 14, even when the nearest-neighbour definition would give 1 or 2. According for instance to O’Keeffe, however, this definition may lead to some difficulties. The value 14 for the body-centred cubic structure, higher than that of closest packing, does not seem entirely reasonable; the difficulty becomes more acute in a structure such as that of diamond for which a very high value, 16, is computed according to the mentioned definition. For a better quantification of the coordination number, several alternative schemes have been proposed. For example, a simple procedure is to identify a gap in the list of interatomic distances and to add atoms up to this gap. A similar procedure (O’Keeffe 1979) may be to add atoms to the coordination polyhedron in order of increasing interatomic distances and to stop when the next addition would
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
129
result in a non-convex polyhedron. Brunner and Schwarzenbach (1971) suggested cutting off the coordinating atoms at the largest gap in the list of the interatomic distances (maximum gap rule). This rule was used by Daams et al. (1992) and Daams and Villars (1993, 1994, 1997) to define the so-called atomic environment type (AET) (see § 3.7.5) and to identify the atoms which are assumed to form the coordination polyhedron. We should however mention another more complex suggestion, which is to weight the contribution of the atoms according to a weight that decreases with interatomic distances (Bhandary and Girgis 1977) or according to a bond strength of the Pauling type (Brown and Shannon 1973). More complex relations are used, and non-integral coordination numbers may of course be obtained. In relation to the previously reported Frank–Kasper proposal, O’Keeffe (1979) suggested that coordinating atoms contribute faces to the Voronoi polyhedron around the central atom, and their contributions are weighed in proportion to the solid angle subtended by that face at the centre. By using this definition, increasing values of the (weighted) CNW coordination number are obtained for the structures: diamond (4.54), simple cubic (6), bodycentred cubic (10.16), face-centred cubic (12) (in agreement with the increasing packing density). A more refined weighting scheme has been suggested by Carter (1978) on the basis of the following assumptions. The interactions of a central atom with its neighbour are considered as being measured by a certain parameter Ai (ΣAi Atot, finite). The CNW as a function of all the Ai should satisfy the following conditions: ● ● ●
● ●
●
CNW(Ai) is dimensionless and 1 if any neighbours with non-zero Ai exists; CNW(Ai) is a continuous function of the Ai (its slope may not be); if N interactions exist such that A1 A2 … AN, for all neighbours with nonzero Ai, then CNW(Ai) N; if some of the Ai are unequal, then CNW(Ai) N; if m of the Ai are equal and large and N ⫺ m are equal and small, then: m CNW(Ai) N; The formula proposed by Carter for the quantification is: 1/CNW ΣNl (wiAi /Σ wjAj)2
(where wi are finite weighing factors). Definitions and measures of Ai might include bond strengths, bond energies, bond orders, etc. As an example, the structure of the CsCl-type has been discussed by Carter using several criteria of evaluation of Ai. In a geometrical approach a weighted coordination number as a function of atomic radii difference was described.
130
Intermetallic Chemistry
We may finally mention the so-called ‘effective coordination number’ ECoN, proposed by Hoppe (1979) and Hoppe and Meyer (1980) computed by means of a rapidly converging function of the distances. According to Hoppe’s scheme, which can be related to Brunner’s suggestions previously mentioned, individual contributions ECoNj of all neighbours to the coordination number are summed together. Each contribution ECoNj quickly becomes small to the point of vanishing with increasing atomic distances dj according to an expression such as ECoNj exp(1 (d j/dm)6), where dm is a reference distance (the ‘mean fictive’ atomic size) which has to be determined beforehand from the structure. The trend of the ECoN has, for instance, been discussed as a function of the axial ratio c/a for the hexagonal closest packing of spheres (hP2-Mg structure). Values of ECoN ranging from, for example, 11.94 (for c/a 1.57 as Ho or Er) to 12.02 (for the ‘ideal’ c/a value, 1.633...) and to 11.02 (c/a 1.856, as for Zn) or to 10.74 (c/a 1.886, as for Cd) have been computed. ECoN for different Laves phases have been presented. For a number of NaCl- and CsCl-type compounds, moreover, values have been given to show the dependence of ECoN as a function of varying ionic radii. For a discussion on the ‘effective coordination number’, its relation to atomic size, bond strength, Madelung constant, etc., see also Simon (1983). For a computation of the heats of formation based on the so-called effective coordination, see a formula by Kubaschewski and Evans (1958), and for a discussion on its application and limits, see Borzone et al. (1993).
3.7.5 Atomic environment definition (and symbols) and corresponding coordination numbers and polyhedra With reference to some questions discussed in the previous paragraph and with special regard to the problem of an ‘efficient’ and simple definition of coordination and of an ‘optimal’ description of the local geometric characteristic, some details and aspects of the contributions given by Daams et al. (1992) and Daams and Villars (1993, 1994, 1997) in a series of reviews may be considered. They faced the problem of the classification of intermetallic structural types, reporting a complete description of the geometrical atomic environments found in the structural types of cubic, rhombohedral, hexagonal and tetragonal intermetallic compounds, respectively. As mentioned in the previous paragraphs, to define an atomic environment they used the maximum gap rule. The Brunner–Schwarzenbach method was considered, in which all interatomic distances between an atom and its neighbours are plotted in a histogram such as those shown in Fig. 3.17. The height of the bars is proportional to the number of neighbours, and all distances are expressed as reduced values relative to the shortest distance. In the specific case of CsCl, having a 411.3 pm,
131
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases Interatomic distances (pm) in CsCI (from CI in Atom
x
y
z
Distance
Cs Cs Cs Cs Cs Cs Cs Cs Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl
0 1 0 0 1 1 0 1 1/2 1/2 1/2 1/2 −1/2 3/2
0 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 1/2 1/2 −1/2 3/2 1/2 1/2
0 0 0 1 0 1 1 1 −1/2 3/2 1/2 1/2 1/2 1/2
356.2 356.2 356.2 356.2 356.2 356.2 356.2 356.2 411.3 411.3 411.3 411.3 411.3 411.3
,
,
)
25 20 15 n 10 5 0 1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
2.0
2.5
d /d min
Interatomic distances (pm) in CsCI (from Cs in 0, 0, 0) Atom
x
y
z
Distance
Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl Cs Cs Cs Cs Cs Cs
1/2 1/2 1/2 −1/2 1/2 −1/2 −1/2 −1/2 0 −1 0 1 0 0
1/2 1/2 −1/2 1/2 −1/2 1/2 −1/2 −1/2 0 0 0 0 −1 1
1/2 −1/2 1/2 1/2 −1/2 −1/2 1/2 −1/2 1 0 −1 0 0 0
356.2 356.2 356.2 356.2 356.2 356.2 356.2 356.2 411.3 411.3 411.3 411.3 411.3 411.3
25 20 15 n 10 5 0 1.0
1.5 d /d min
Figure 3.17. Interatomic distances in CsCl. The distances are given for the CsCl compound (cubic, cP2-CsCl type, a 411.3 pm) with Cs and Cl in the representative positions 0, 0, 0, and 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 respectively, white and black atoms in Fig. 3.8. In the tables the first two groups of distances (in pm) are given as positions of each atom around the reference atom. Notice that not only atoms in the reference cell but also those in the adjacent cells must be considered (see Figs. 3.8 (d)–(f)). At the right side, the corresponding histograms using the ‘reduced distances’ d/dmin are shown: the first two ‘bars’ summarize the data contained in the table.
the minimum distance is that between positions such as 0, 0, 0 and 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2, that is dmin (a3)/2 356.2 pm. The subsequent interatomic distance is 411.3 pm (see Fig. 3.8e). In the histograms similar for the two atoms, we have 8 atoms at d1 dmin 356.2 pm (d1/dmin 1), 6 atoms at d2 a(d2/dmin 2/3 1.1547…), etc.
132
Intermetallic Chemistry
In most cases a clear maximum gap is revealed (here the gap between the second and the third bar). The atomic environment is then constructed with the atoms to the left of this gap (8 6 in the example of CsCl). To avoid in particular cases bad or ambiguous descriptions, however, a few additional rules have been considered. When for instance two (or more) nearly equal maximum gaps were observed, a selection was made in order to keep, in a given structure type, the number of different AET as small as possible. A convexity criterion for the environment polyhedron was also considered. The coordination polyhedron has to be defined as the maximum convex volume around only one central atom enclosed by convex faces with all coordinating faces lying at the intersections of at least three faces. This rule was especially used where no clear maximum gap was detectable. The different AET were characterized by a polyhedron code based on the number of triangles, squares, pentagons, hexagons, etc. that join each other at the different vertices (coordinating atoms). The polyhedron code gives the number of equivalent vertices with the number of faces in the above-mentioned sequence as an exponent. For example, a quadratic pyramid has four corners adjoining two triangles and one square (no pentagons or hexagons) and one corner adjoining four triangles: its code, therefore, is 42.1.0.014.0.0.0 (or briefly 42.114.0 with coordination number 5). The cube, eight equivalent vertices, adjoining three squares, has the code 80.3, the octahedron 64.0 and the so-called Frank–Kasper polyhedra have the codes 125.0; 125.026.0; 125.036.0 and 125.046.0 (with coordination numbers, CN, 12, 14, 15 and 16, respectively). Several polyhedra occurring in intermetallic crystal structures are shown in Fig. 3.18. Daams et al. (1992) have analysed all the cubic structure types reported in Villars and Calvert (1985), after excluding all oxides and a few types with improbable interatomic distances, thus leaving 128 structure types representing 5521 compounds. Their analysis showed that these cubic structure types have 13 917 atomic environments (point sets). Of those environments, 92% belong to one of the 21 most frequently occurring AET, which are those reported in the following list (see also Fig. 3.18): 43.0 (tetrahedron); 42.114.0; 64.0 (octahedron); 35.034.013.0; 80.3 (cube); 65.034.0; 5.0 4.0 6.0 3.0 2.2 0.3 5.0 4.0 6.0 8 2 ; 6 4 ; 9 2 ; 8 2 1 ; 125.0 (icosahedron); 122.2 (c.p. cubic) and 122.2 (c.p. hexagonal) (the same code describes the cubic as well as the hexagonal atomic environment of the ideal close-packing); 102.225.0; 105.026.014.0; 112.224.1; 125.026.0; 80.360.4; 125.036.0; 125.046.0; 126.064.0. Of the 5521 compounds crystallizing in the mentioned 128 structure types, 46% belong to a single-environment group (structures in which all atoms have the same type of environment), 37% have two environment types, 9% three and the rest four or more environments (98% of the cubic compounds crystallize in structure types with 1, 2, 3 or 4 AET).
133
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
1#a
1 2#a
4#a
4
4-a
2
43.0
3#a
3
5-a
42.114.0
6-a
64.0 8-a
80.3
8-b
83.1
8-d
45.044.0 9-a
65.034.0
9-b
45.043.114.0
Figure 3.18a. AET (According to Daams and Villars 1992, 1993, 1994, 1997). The polyhedra corresponding to frequently observed AET are shown together with their codes. The Frank–Kasper (FK) polyhedra are indicated (see § 3.9.3.1). Notice the same code 122.2 of the two polyhedra describing the cubic (c) as well as the hexagonal (h) atomic environments of the two ideal close-packed structures.
In another paper (Daams and Villars 1993), the results of a similar classification of the rhombohedral intermetallic structure types were shown. The 195 rhombohedral structure types reported in Villars and Calvert (1991) were analysed; 51 types had improbable interatomic distances or correspond to oxides with no intermetallic representatives and were excluded. The remaining 144 types (corresponding to 1324 compounds) were considered. It was observed that 14 AET are greatly
134
Intermetallic Chemistry
10-c
85.024.0
11-b
85.024.016.0
12-a
125.0
FK 12-b
122.2(c)
12-d
122.2(h)
13-a
105.026.014.0
14-a
125.026.0
14-b
80.360.4
15-a
125.036.0
FK 16-a
125.046.0
FK 17-d
125.056.0
20-a
125.0 86.0
FK
Figure 3.18b. (Continued)
preferred. Out of 6356 investigated point sets 71% belong to one of these 14 frequent AET, which are those reported in the following list: 3 (loose triangle); 43.0; 64.0; 61.2 (trigonal prism); 80.3; 65.034.0; 64.043.0; 92.220.3; 125.0; 122.2 (cubic type); 105.026.014.0; 125.026.0; 80.360.4; 125.046.0. Compare this list with the previous one of the cubic compounds: notice that several AET are reported in both lists. Of the 1324 rhombohedral compounds crystallizing in one of the 144 types, 19% belong to a single-environment group, 15% combine two environment types, 25% three environments, 34% four, and the remaining 7%, five or more environments (93% of the rhombohedral compounds crystallize in structure types with 1, 2, 3 or 4 environment types).
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
135
The results of a similar analysis of the intermetallic hexagonal structure types have been reported by Daams and Villars (1994). Of 442 structure types, 315 (clearly intermetallic and correctly refined) were considered. In this case too it was observed that a small group of atomic environments is greatly preferred. The 23 AET most frequently occurring in the 315 hexagonal structure types are reported in the following list (to be compared with those previously reported for cubic and rhombohedral structure types): 3; 43.0; 4; 64.0; 61.2; 35.034.013.0; 80.3; 65.034.0; 64.043.0; 65.034.016.0; 92.220.3; 85.024.015.0; 125.0; 122.2 (cubic); 122.2 (hexagonal); 105.026.014.0; 64.133.032.219.0; 125.026.0; 122.226.0; 65.063.029.0; 125.036.0; 125.046.0; 125.086.0. The 3 and 4 codes correspond to ‘irregular’ AET. The reference atom is not included in the plane (volume) of the polygon (polyhedron) formed by the 3 (4) coordinating atoms. Out of 20 131 point sets investigated (belonging to 5646 compounds crystallizing in one of the aforementioned 315 hexagonal structure types), 81% (16 392) belong to one of these 23 AET. Of the 5646 compounds, 14% belong to a singleenvironment group; 35% combine two environment types; 32% three; 11% four and the rest (7%) five or more (93% of the hexagonal compounds crystallize in structure types with 1, 2, 3 or 4 AET). The results of the analysis of the intermetallic tetragonal structure types have also been reported and described by Daams and Villars (1997); 404 structure types were analysed. The analysis showed that 294 (clearly intermetallic and correctly refined) were possible with 4264 compounds and 17 157 point sets. In this case too it was observed that a small group (23) of atomic environments is greatly preferred. The 23 AET most frequently occurring in the 294 tetragonal structure types are reported in the following list (to be compared with those previously reported for the other systems): 1; 2; 3; 43.0; 4; 42.114.0; 64.0; 80.3; 83.1; 45.044.0; 65.034.0; 45.043.114.0; 85.024.0; 5.0 4.0 6.0 8 2 1 ; 125.0; 122.2 (cubic); 105.026.014.0; 125.026.0; 80.360.4; 125.036.0; 125.046.0; 125.056.0; 125.086.0. Out of 17157 point sets investigated, 83% (14 194) belong to one of these 23 AET. Of the 4264 compounds crystallizing in one of the mentioned 294 structure types, 16% belong to a single-environment group (that is to structures in which all atoms have the same type of environment); 17% combine two environment types; 42% three; 13% four and the rest (12%) five or more (88% of the tetragonal compounds crystallize in structure types with 1, 2, 3 or 4 AET). As a result of these analyses, several relations between structure types have been shown and discussed. Emphasis has been given to the fact that apparently, in all the structure types considered, ‘Nature prefers one of the most symmetrical AET. Remarkably these AETs are often found equally in single-environment and polyenvironment groups, meaning that even in complex structures, symmetrical
136
Intermetallic Chemistry
arrangements are preferred’. The formation of the geometrically simplest structure types containing a small number of different AET was also noted. The results of these analyses can be compared with the Stability Principles stated by Laves (§ 4.3.2.5). Concluding this section, we may mention a paper by Daams and Villars (1993) concerning an atomic environment classification of the chemical elements. Critically evaluated crystallographic data for all element modifications (and recommended atomic volumes) have been reported. Special structural stability diagrams were used to separate AET stability domains and to predict the structure (in terms of environment types) of hitherto unknown high-pressure and high-temperature modifications. Reference to the use of AET in thermodynamic (CALPHAD) modelling and calculation has been made by Ferro and Cacciamani (2002). A summary of this analysis of the atomic environments is shown in Fig. 3.18, where the most common frequently occurring AET are depicted with their symbols and codes. References to the so-defined AET and the corresponding coordination number, indicated as CNE, are reported for various prototype structures listed in Chapter 7. As a final remark we have to observe that the numbers of compounds, point sets, environment types, etc. evaluated at a certain time are continuously increasing, nevertheless they are sufficiently large to justify the general conclusions drawn.
3.7.6 Layer stacking sequence description and symbols A large group of structures of intermetallic phases can be considered to be formed by the successive stacking of certain polygonal nets of atoms or, in more complex cases, by the successive stacking of characteristic ‘slabs’. There are layer structures, for instance C graphite, CdI2, etc., in which bi-dimensional substructures formed by one or more atomic planes may be identified because distances between atoms of different slabs are clearly larger than those within each slab, and structures (for instance cubic, hexagonal close-packed structures) which can be conveniently regarded and described as a number of close-packed atomic planes piled one on top of the other. These structural characteristics can be easily represented by using specific codes and symbols, which can be very useful for a compact presentation and comparison of the structural features of several structures. Many different notations have been devised to describe the stacking pattern (for a summary see Parthé 1964, Pearson 1972). A few of them will be presented here. As an introduction to this point we consider Figs 3.19 and 3.20 where typical simple close-packed structures are shown and described as built from the
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases B
C B
137
C
A
A A
I
II
III
Figure 3.19. Close-packed bi-dimensional arrangement of equal spheres. Their centres, marked by A, are in the nodes of a triangular net. The points B and C may correspond to the nodes of similar triangular nets in different relative positions. On the right a few spheres of three superimposed layers in the hexagonal close-packing are shown. In this structure the spheres of the layer III are just above those of the layer I. A lateral view of the same arrangement is shown in Fig. 3.20.
superimposition of close-packed atomic layers. If spheres of equal sizes are packed together as closely as possible on a plane surface, they arrange themselves as shown in Fig. 3.19. Their centres are in the nodes of a triangular net. Each sphere is in contact with six others. Such layers can be stacked to give 3D close-packed arrays. If we label the positions of the centres of the spheres in one layer as A, then an identical layer can be superimposed on the first so that the centres of the spheres of the second layer are vertically above the positions B (for two layers, it is insignificant whether we choose the positions B or the equivalent position C). When we superimpose a third layer above the second (B), we have two alternatives: the centres of the spheres may be above either the A or the C positions. The two simplest sequences of layers will thus correspond to the superimpositions ABABAB… and ABCABCABC… (more complex sequences may of course be considered). The sequence ABAB…, corresponding to the so-called hexagonal close-packed structure (hP2-Mg type structure), is shown in Fig. 3.20. The sequence ABCABC… having a cubic symmetry is shown in Fig. 3.21. It is the cubic (face-centred cubic) close-packed structure, also described as cF4-Cu type structure. A more complete representation of different layer sequences, which can be used not only for the description of close-packed structures, may be obtained by using
138
Intermetallic Chemistry A A
C
B
B
A
A
B
C
A
B
B
1 3/4
A
1/4 0
B
c
A
A
1
C
2/3
B
1/3
A
0 Cu
Mg A
1
A
B
0.89
C
A
0.78
A
B
0.67
B
C
0.55
A
1
B
0.45
C
3/4
C
0.33
A
1/2
A
0.22 0.11 0
c
B
1/4
C
A
0
A
La
ch
c
Sm
Figure 3.20. A lateral view of different stacking sequences of triangular nets. They correspond to some typical close-packed structures. The first layer sequence shown corresponds to a superimposition according to the scheme ABABAB… (equivalent to BCBCBC… or CACACA… descriptions) characteristic of the hexagonal close-packed, Mg-type, structure. With reference to the usual description of its unit cell, the full stacking symbol indicating the element, the relative B position of the superimposed layers and their distance is Mg1/4 MgC3/4.The other sequences correspond to the schemes: ABC.ABC…. (Cu, cubic), ABAC.ABAC…. (La, hexagonal), ACACBCBAB…. (Sm, hexagonal). For Cu the constant ch of the (equivalent, non-conventional) hexagonal cell is shown which may be obtained by a convenient re-description of the standard cubic cell (see § 3.6.1.3). ch ac3, body diagonal of the cubic cell.
layer position symbols (stacking symbols) together with the indication of the relative spacings between the layers. Fig. 3.22 shows a network of atoms which can be considered as a triangular net, T net that is the 36 net. We may incidentally notice that the Schläfli Notation PN
139
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
Figure 3.21. The face-centred cubic close-packed structure (Cu type). On the left a block of eight cells is shown (one cell darkened). On the right a section of the structure is presented: it corresponds to a plane perpendicular to the cube diagonal. Notice that the plane is the same presented on the left in Fig. 3.19. The sequence of the layers in this structure is shown in Fig. 3.20 in comparison with other close-packed elemental structures. a1
a2
C
B
A
A : 0,0
B:
1 3
,
2 3
C:
2 3
,
1 3
Figure 3.22. The triangular, 36, net of points and the corresponding bi-dimensional cell. The selected coordinate system corresponds to an inter-axial angle of 120°. The conventional order used in labelling the unit cell edges along the equivalent x and y axes (a1, a2) is indicated. On the right different positions (relative to the cell origin) are shown for the point net with the corresponding coding (stacking symbols). A: the representative point in the x, y plane (a, b plane with b a) has the coordinate 0, 0; B: the plane coordinate doublet of the representative point is 1⁄3, 2⁄3; C: the coordinate doublet of the reresentative point is 2⁄3, 1⁄3.
140
Intermetallic Chemistry
describes the characteristics of each node in the network, that is the number N of P-gon polygons surrounding the node. In the reported 36 net all the nodes are equivalent: their polygonal surrounding corresponds to 6 triangles. More complex symbols are used for nets containing non-equivalent nodes: for instance, the symbol 32434 3242 (2:1) means that, in the given net, two type of nodes, 32434 and 3242, occur with a relative 2:1 frequency. A symbol such as 3242 means that the given node is surrounded, in this order, by two triangles and two squares. In the case of the simple 36 triangular net, the symbols A, B, C relate the positions of the nodes to the origin of the cell, which is defined as in Fig. 3.22. In the layer stacking sequence full symbol, the component atoms occupying the layers are written on the base line, with the stacking symbols as exponents and the layer spacings in the form of suffixes, denoting the fractional height of the repetition constant along the direction perpendicular to the layers. In the case of Mg, for instance, with reference to the standard choice of the unit cell origin (two equivalent atomic positions for the two Mg atoms in 1⁄3, 2⁄3, 1⁄4 and 2⁄3, 1⁄3, 3⁄4), the symbol will be MgB1⁄4 MgC3⁄4 (which, with a zero point shift, is equivalent to MgA0 MgB1⁄2). a1
a2
c
b
a
a:
2 3
,
1 3
;
1 3
,
2 3
b : 0, 0 ;
2 3
,
1 3
c : 0, 0 ;
1 3
,
2 3
Figure 3.23. Hexagonal, 63, net of points. a, b and c are the codes corresponding to the different positions relative to the cell origin. Notice that the unit cell contains two points (every point in a corner is in common with four adjacent hexagonal cells). The coordinate doublets of the points are reported.
141
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
The symbol CuA0 CuB1⁄3 CuC2⁄3, on the other hand, represents the cubic Cu structure as a stacking sequence of triangular layers viewed along the direction of the unit cell diagonal, which is perpendicular to the layers themselves. A few other nets, based on the hexagonal cell, are of frequent structural occurrence. Following Pearson’s suggestions (Pearson 1972), the corresponding sequences of stacking symbols which have a wide application are here presented. Fig. 3.23 shows the hexagonal (honeycomb) 63 net (H net) and the stacking symbols (a, b, c) used for relating the different positions of the nodes to the cell origin. Notice that two nodes are contained in the unit cell. A simple structure which can be described in terms of superposition of (even if far away, not close-packed) hexagonal layers is that of graphite: Cb1⁄4 Cc3⁄4. The hexagonal net is also called ‘graphitic’ net. Fig. 3.24 shows the three-way bamboo weave net, known as kagomé, a net of triangles and hexagons (K net, the 3636 net of points). The different positions of the nodes (three nodes in the unit cell) are represented by the symbols (α, β, γ) shown. Fig. 3.25 shows the similarly defined nine primed symbols (A , B , C , a , b , c , a1
a2
α
β
γ
α:
1 2
, 0; 0,
1 2
;
1, 1 2 2
β:
1 6
,
1 3
;
2, 5; 1 3 6 6
,
5 6
γ:
1 3
,
1 6
;
5 6
,
1 6
;
5 6
,
2 3
Figure 3.24. The ‘kagomé’, 3636, net of points. The codes α, β, γ corresponding to the different positions of the net (relative to the hexagonal cell origin) are shown. Notice that the unit cell contains three points of the net (every point in an edge belongs to two adjacent cells). For the different positions the coordinate doublets of the three points are reported.
142
Intermetallic Chemistry a2
a1
c′
C′
B′ b′ A′
C′
1 3
2 3 2 3 2 3
, 1 ; 0, 2 ;
B′ 0,,
3 1; 3
3
1 , 0; 3 1, 2; 3 3
A′ 0, 0;
,0 , ,
a′
2 3 1 3 1 c′ 0, 0; 0,, 3 ;
1, 3
0;
1 3
, 2;
2 3
, 1;
2 3
,
2 3
2 b′ 0, 0; 0,, 3 ;
2, 3
0;
1 3
, 1;
1 3
, 2;
2 3
,
1 3
1 3
1, 3
0;
2, 3
1 3
, 1;
2 3
,
2 3
a′ 0,,
β′
γ′
1 2 1 3
, 0; 0,, ,
1; 6
5, 6
1 6
,
2; 3
0,,
5; 6
1 6 2 3
;
1, 1 2 2
;
;
2, 5 3 6
;
2, 1 3 6
;
1, 1 6 6
;
1, 5 2 6
;
1, 1 3 2
;
1 6 1, 2 2 3
;
1, 2 1, 3
;
, 0; 0,, ,
1; 2
1 2 1 6
;
3
3
0;
3 3 3
a2
a1
α′
; 0,, 2 ;
3
1 6 5 6
;
1 6 5 6
,
1; 3 2 3
1, 5; 6 6
5 6 1 2
, 0;
5, 1; 6 2
,
1 3
1 6 5 6
,
1; 2 5 6
,
,
5, 1; 6 3
α′
β′
γ′
Figure 3.25. Stacking symbols applicable to larger unit cells. A , B , C : three nodes in the unit cell of a triangular net; a , b , c : six nodes of a hexagonal net in the unit cell; α , β , γ : nine nodes of a kagomé net in the unit cell. The coordinate doublets are indicated.
α , β , γ ) used for larger cells containing, respectively, 3, 6 and 9 atoms of the 36, 63 and kagomé nets. Several structures, especially hexagonal, rhombohedral and cubic ones, may be conveniently described in terms of stacking triangular, hexagonal and/or kagomé layers of atoms. Examples will be given in the following sections. The specification
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
143
of the spacing between the layers is useful in order to compare different structures, to recognize the close-packed ones (A, B, C symbols with appropriate layer distances) and to deduce atomic coordinations. We have to notice, however, that the A, B, C notation previously described is not the only one devised. Several different symbols have been suggested to describe stacking patterns. For a description of the more frequently used notations see Parthé (1964), Pearson (1972). A very common notation is that by Jagodzinski (1954). This notation involving h and c symbols is applicable only to those structure type groups which allow not more than three possible positions of the unit layer (or more generally of the ‘unit slabs’; see also the polytypic structures in the following paragraph). The h and c notation cannot therefore be applied, for instance, to disilicide types. The letters h and c have the following meaning: ●
●
the letter h is assigned to a unit slab, whose neighbouring unit slabs (above and below) are displaced sideways, in the same direction by the same amount: for instance ABABA or CBCBCB hhh hhhh (h comes from hexagonal: this is the stacking sequence of the simple hexagonal structures such as hP2-Mg, hP4-ZnS wurtzite and hP12-MgZn2 types). the letter c, on the other hand, is assigned to unit slabs whose neighbouring slabs have different sideways displacements: for instance ABCABC or CABCAB cccc cccc (c comes from cubic: this is the stacking sequence found in cubic structures such as cF4-Cu, cF8-ZnS sphalerite and cF24-Cu2Mg types).
To denote the stacking sequence of the different structures it is sufficient to give only one identity period of the h, c symbol series. For instance: cF4-Cu, c (instead of ABC); cF8-ZnS sphalerite, c; hP4-ZnS wurtzite, h; hP4La, hc; hR9-Sm, hhc. As can be seen from the previously reported examples, the identity period of the h, c symbols is generally shorter than the A, B, C, … letter sequence. The h, c, … symbols may be condensed, for example, hcchcchchc to (hcc)2(hc)2. If the number of c letters in a Jagodzinski symbol is divided by the total number of letters one obtains the percentage of ‘cubic stacking’ in the total structure. Another common notation for describing stacking of close-packed 36 nets (T nets) is that devised by Zhdanov (1945) (a number notation equivalent to Jagodzinski’s notation). A short description of the Zhdanov symbol is the following: a ‘’ is assigned if the order between a layer and its previous partner follows the
144
Intermetallic Chemistry
sequence corresponding to any two subsequent layers in the face-centred cubictype structure, that is A : B, B : C, C : A. Otherwise a ‘’ is assigned. For instance, the sequence ‘ ’ (shortened 33) corresponds to ABCACB. Finally, as another simple example of description (and symbolic representation) of structures in terms of layer stacking sequence, we now examine structures which can be considered as generated by layer networks containing squares. A typical case will be that of structures containing 44 nets of atoms (Square net: S net). The description of the structures will be made in terms of the separation of the different nets, along the direction perpendicular to their plane, and of the origin and orientation of the unit cell. Fig. 3.26 shows the different symbols, in this case numbers, suggested by Pearson (1972) which will be used to indicate origin and orientation of the nets. These numbers will be reported as exponents of the symbols of the atoms forming the
a
a′
a′
a
1
2
0, 0
0,
5
1 2,
0; 0,
3
1 2
6
1 2
1 1 3 3 4, 4 ; 4 , 4
4
1 2,
0
7
3 1 1 3 4, 4 ; 4 , 4
1 1 2, 2
8
0, 0;
1 1 2, 2
Figure 3.26. The bi-dimensional square, 44, net of points. Different numerical codes are shown for the different positions of the representative point in the unit square (bi-dimensional unit cell). In 1–4 the unit square contains one point. In 5–8 a larger square cell is considered with axes at 45° to the net alignment (and edges equal to 2 times the repeat unit of the net): it contains two representative points. For the different positions the corresponding bi-dimensional coordinate doublets are reported.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
145
different nets. In this case too the relative height of the layers will be indicated by a fractional index. A few symbols of square net stacking sequences are the following: Po01: the simple cubic cell of Po (containing 1 atom in the origin) corresponds to a stacking sequence of type 1 square nets. W10W41/2: the body-centred cubic structure of W (1 atom in 0, 0, 0 and 1 atom in 1 ⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2) corresponds to a sequence of type 1 and type 4 square nets at the heights 0 and 1⁄2, respectively. Note, however, that for a full description of the structure, either in the hexagonal or the tetragonal case, the inter-layer distance must be taken into account not only in terms of the fractional coordinates (that is, the c/a axial ratio must be considered). For more complex polygonal nets, their symbolic representation and use in the description, for instance, of the Frank–Kasper phases, see Frank and Kasper (1958) and Pearson (1972). 3.7.7 The cP4-AuCu3 type: an example of the use of alternative and complementary structural notations and symbols As a conclusion to the nomenclature and symbols defined in the preceding paragraphs and as an introduction to their application in the description and discussion of selected crystal structures, it may be useful to underline some of their characteristics by means of an example. The structural type cP4-AuCu3 will be used to this – end. AuCu3 is primitive, cubic. The space group is Pm3m (N. 221 in the International Tables for Crystallography, Hahn 2002). In the unit cell there are 4 atoms in the following positions: 1 Au in (a) 0, 0, 0; 3 Cu in (c) 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 0, 1⁄2; 1⁄2 1⁄2, 0; Its structure can be described as derivative of that of Cu (face-centred cubic, – cF4) for which, in the space group Fm3m (N. 225), four Cu are in the positions (a): 0, 0, 0; 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 0, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0. On passing from Cu to AuCu3 we have the splitting of the four Cu equivalent positions into two sets of positions (1 3), the structure is no longer face centred (cP4 instead of cF4) and corresponds to another space group. (In the lattice-complex symbolism this ‘splitting’ corresponds to the equation F : P J, as described in § 3.7.1.) Several phases are known to have this structure; a short selection is presented in the following list with indicative values of the lattice parameter (unit cell edge length): HfPt3 LaIn3 La3In Mn3Pt MnZn3 Ni3Al
a 398.1 pm a 473.9 pm a 511 pm a 383.3 pm a 386 pm a 360.9 pm
Ti3Hg TiZn3 UPb3 USn3 YAl3 Y3Al
a 416.5 pm a 393.2 pm a 479.1 pm a 460.3 pm a 432.3 pm a 481.8 pm
146
Intermetallic Chemistry (a)
(b)
(c)
0, 1, 1
(d)
0, 0, 1
1 1 1• 2, 2,
1, 1, 1
1, 0, 1
0, 1, 0 1 1 , 2 2
1, 1, 0
0, 1, 1
1 1 1• 2, 2,
1, 1, 1
0, 0, 0 1 1 , 2 2
,0 • 1, 0, 0
0, 2, 1
1 3 1• 2, 2,
1, 2, 1
0, 1, 0 1 3 , 2 2
,0 • 1, 1, 0
0, 2, 0
,0 • 1, 2, 0
Figure 3.27. Unit cell of the cP4-AuCu3 type structure. In (a) a ‘packing’ model, in (b) the positions of the atom centres, in (c) the same unit cell viewed along the cube diagonal are illustrated. In (d) as an introduction to the exercises reported in the text, a selection of the relevant coordinate triplets is shown both in the cell at the origin and in two adjacent cells.
Notice that for this structure type, examples are known of compounds, such as Y3Al and YAl3, in which the same elements alternatively occupy either the (a) or the (c) Wyckoff positions and exchange their roles in the structure. As for the prototype itself, AuCu3, a 374.84 pm. In the following, while discussing the characteristics of this structural type, reference to this value will be made. Its unit cell is shown in Fig. 3.27, by using different drawing styles and in different perspective views. The structure is shown in Fig. 3.28, where the 3D sequence of the atoms is suggested by presenting a small group (eight) of contiguous cells. The subsequent Figs. 3.29 (a)–(d) correspond to an analysis of the structure carried out in order to show the different local atomic arrangements (coordinations around the atoms in the two crystal sites). In the analysis of a structure, however, it is also necessary to take into consideration the values of the interatomic distances. It may be useful to consider both
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
147
Figure 3.28. cP4-AuCu3 type structure. A block of eight unit cells is shown (Au: white; Cu: grey). (a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
Figure 3.29. Analysis of the cP4-AuCu3 type structure. Typical fragments of a few adjacent cells are depicted in order to show the different coordinations (Au: white; Cu: grey). (a) and (b) coordination around Au, (c) and (d) coordination around Cu. (a) octahedral coordination of 6 Au around Au, (b) cuboctahedral coordination of 12 Cu around Au (c) tetragonal prismatic coordination of 8 Cu around Cu, (d) square coordination of 4 Au around Cu. Notice that the overall coordination of 8Cu 4Au around Cu (c) and (d) is similar to the coordination of 12 Cu around Au (b).
148
Intermetallic Chemistry
absolute and so-called ‘reduced’ values of the interatomic distances. In the case of the AuCu3 phase, the minimum interatomic distance corresponds to the Au–Cu distance (Au in 0, 0, 0 and Cu in 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2) which is the same as the Cu–Cu distance between Cu in 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 and Cu in 1⁄2, 0, 1⁄2. This distance is given by (a2)/2. For the AuCu3 phase a 374.8 pm and, therefore, dmin 265.0 pm. This value (absolute value of the interatomic distance) could be compared, for instance, to the value 272 pm, sum of the radii of Cu and Au, as defined for a coordination number of 12, or to the value 256 pm of the Cu–Cu distance in the metal (Cu atomic ‘diameter’). Reduced interatomic distances (dr d/dmin) may be defined as the ratios of the actual distance values to the minimum value. A first set of interatomic distances (and the corresponding coordination, taken as the number of nearest-neighbour atoms) which can be considered in the AuCu3 phase is that related to the Au coordination around Au atoms (see Fig. 3.29(a)): Considering Au in 0, 0, 0 as the reference atom, the next neighbours Au atoms are the six Au shown in Fig. 3.29(a), corresponding to the same Wyckoff position – and having, in comparison with the reference atom, the coordinates 0, 0, 1; 0, 0, 1; – – 0, 1, 0; 0, 1, 0; 1, 0, 0; 1, 0, 0, all at a distance d a 374.8 pm, that is at a reduced distance dr d/dmin 1.414. Notice that in the analysis of the structure it may be necessary to consider not only the positions of the atoms in the reference cell but also those in the adjacent cells. Notice also that, in a simple cubic structure without free positional parameters such as the AuCu3 type, the reduced distances are independent of the values of the lattice parameters and are the same for all the isostructural compounds. In the same group of Au–Au interatomic distances a subsequent set is represented by distances such as those between Au0, 0, 0 and Au0, –1, 1 (or Au0, –1,1–, Au0, 1, –1, Au1,0,1, etc.). This set corresponds to 12 atoms (all at an absolute distance of a2 530.1 pm, that is, at a reduced distance dr d/dmin 2.000). A second set of interatomic distances (and coordination) corresponds to the Cu coordination around Au atoms. Considering as the reference atom, the atom Au in 0, 0, 0, the next neighbours Cu atoms are the 12 Cu reported in Fig. 3.29 (b), in the – – – – – – – – coordinates: 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 0, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 0, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 0, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 0, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0; – – – – – 1 ⁄2, 1⁄2, 0; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0, all at a distance d a 2 /2 265.1 pm, corresponding to a reduced distance d/dmin 1.000. The subsequent sets of Au–Cu distances correspond to 24 atoms at d 459.1 pm (dr d/dmin 3 1.732), 24 Cu at d 592.7 pm (dr 2.236), etc. A third group of interatomic distances (and coordination) is that corresponding to the Cu coordination around Cu atoms. Selecting among the Cu atoms (all equivalent to each other) the atom Cu in 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0 as the reference atom, the next
149
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
neighbouring Cu atoms are the eight Cu atoms in: 1⁄2, 0, 1⁄2; 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 1, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 1, 1⁄2; – – – – 1 ⁄2, 0, 1⁄2; 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 1, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 1, 1⁄2 (see Fig. 3.29(c)); all at a distance d a— 2/2 265.1 pm, corresponding to a reduced distance d/dmin 1.000. The subsequent sets of Cu–Cu distances correspond to six Cu atoms, in coordinates such – as: 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1; 3⁄2, 1⁄2, 0; etc. at a distance d 374.8 pm (dr 1.414), 16 Cu atoms at d 459.1 pm (dr 1.732), 12 Cu atoms at d 530.1 pm (dr 2.000), 16 Cu atoms at 592.7 pm (dr 2.236), etc. The fourth (and last) type of interatomic distances (and coordination) characteristic of the AuCu3 structure is given by the Au coordination around the Cu atoms. Considering as the reference atom one of the three equivalent atoms Cu in the Wyckoff position (c), for instance, the atom in 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0, the next neighbours Au atoms are 4 Au in 0, 0, 0; 1, 0, 0; 0, 1, 0 and 1, 1, 0 (see Fig. 3.29 (d)); all at a distance d a2/2 265.1 pm, that is, at a reduced distance d/dmin 1.000. Subsequent sets of Cu–Au distances correspond to a group of 8 Au atoms (in coordinates such as 0, 0, 1; 1, 0, 1; 0, 1, 1; etc.) at a distance d 459.1 pm (reduced distance d/dmin 1.732), to a group of 8 Au, at a distance d 592.7 pm, d/dmin 2.236, etc. Considering now all the atoms (Cu and Au) surrounding an Au atom (or respectively a Cu atom) we may prepare characteristic histograms such as those in Fig. 3.30 where, the number of surrounding atoms is plotted as a function of the reduced interatomic distance from a given atom. Lists of coordinating atoms, with distances from the references atom, coordination polyhedra, and next neighbour histograms are presented systematically by Daams et al. (1991) for all the known prototypes. 25
Cu
25
Cu
20
Au
20
15 n
Au
Au
Cu 10
Cu
Cu
15 n
Cu
Au 10
5
Au
0 1.0
1.5
Cu 5
2.0
2.5
0 1.0
Cu
1.5
2.0
d /dmin
d /dmin
Coordination around Au
Coordination around Cu
2.5
Figure 3.30. Analysis of the cP4-AuCu3 type structure. Coordination and interatomic (reduced) distances. The total number (n) of near-neighbour atoms around Au and Cu are plotted as a function of their reduced distances from the reference atom. The symbols of the surrounding atoms are indicated. Notice the similarity between the two histograms.
150
Intermetallic Chemistry
As a conclusion to the description of the different coordinations, we may observe that those corresponding to the first distance sets are summarized in the 333 symbol 333 [A6/6][B8/8]12/4 ( [Au6/6][Cu8/8]12/4 for the prototype or, in more detail, 333 [Au6o/6o][Cu8p/8p]12co/4l). In terms of polyhedra packing, therefore, this structure may be described as a 3D arrangement of cubo-octahedra. On terms of atomic environments, on the other hand, according to the definitions adopted in § 3.7.5 we have the following data for the types of polyhedra surrounding each atom, and the nature of their vertices. Around Au in (a) a polyhedron 122.2 made up of 12 Cu atoms (that is a coordination CNE 12). Around Cu in (c) a polyhedron 122.2 made up of 8Cu 4Au atoms (that is a coordination CNE 12). In Fig. 3.27 (c), on the other hand, it is suggested that, for the same structure, an alternative description may be obtained and, according to Pearson, symbolized. In this figure the structure is viewed along the cube diagonal: it corresponds to a stacking sequence of triangular and kagomé nets, with the symbol AuA0Cuα0 AuC1/3Cuγ1/3AuB2/3Cuβ2/3. In this symbol we have the same number of triangular (A, B, C) Au atom nets and of kagomé (α, β, γ) Cu atom nets. These two net types are characterized by the presence of 1 and 3 points (atoms) in the unit ‘tile’ (Figs. 3.22 and 3.24). This, of course, corresponds to the overall 1:3 stoichiometric ratio. The same structure, viewed along the unit cell edge direction, corresponds to a square net stacking sequence (see Fig. 3.26). The stacking symbol is Au10Cu40Cu51/2. These different symbols may be useful when comparing this structure with other structural types: for instance with the cF4-Cu type or the tP2AuCu(I) type (Au10Au40Cu51/2 as square net stacking) or the hP8-Ni3Sn type (SnB0.25Niβ0.25 SnC0.75Niγ0.75 as triangular and kagomé net stacking). With reference to a description in terms of lattice-complex combination, the AuCu3-type structure corresponds to a combination of P and J complexes (AuCu3: P J). According to Hellner (1979), this structure may be considered as pertaining to an F-family as a consequence of the particular splitting, previously described, of the points of the F complex. A few other comments on the AuCu3-type structure and some remarks on the relationship with other structural types will be reported in the following Chapter 7.
3.7.8 Structure trivial names and Strukturbericht symbols As a conclusion to the presentation of the rational nomenclature and symbolism of the intermetallic phases, it must be mentioned that a number of trivial names and symbols have been used and, due to historical reasons, are still in use both as indicators of a single phase in specific systems, or as descriptors of certain structural types or of families of different interrelated structural types.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
151
Trivial symbols and names. Among these, Greek (and Roman) letters have been used; often in order to indicate actual phases in specific systems, for instance in a given binary system, phase α, β, γ, etc., in alphabetical order according to the increasing composition from one component to the other, while in unary systems α, β, etc., symbols have been used to denote different allotropic forms. Obviously this notation (or other similar ones such as τ1, τ2, τ3, denoting ‘1st’, ‘2nd’, etc., phase) may be useful as a quick reference code while discussing and comparing phase properties of alloys in a single specific system, but in general cannot be used as a rational criterion for denoting structural types. In a few cases, however, certain Greek and Roman letters have assumed a more general meaning as symbols of groups of similar phases: for instance, the name ‘γ phases’ which is an abbreviation of a sentence such as ‘phases having the γ-brass (the γ-Cu–Zn) type structure’. In a number of cases such a general meaning has been attributed also to names of scientists as in: Laves-type phases, Heusler phases, etc. A short list of these names and letters, in alphabetical order, is included in the formula index in Chapter 7. Strukturbericht symbols. These correspond to a pre-war designation adopted by the editors of the Strukturbericht publications (and later Structure Reports) in abstracting crystal structure determination. This designation is no longer recommended by the IUPAC, but it is still used, especially in papers concerning thermodynamics and phase diagram studies. According to this designation, each structure type is represented by a symbol generally composed of a letter (A, B, C, etc.) and a number. The letter is related to the stoichiometry; A: unary phases (or believed to be unary); B: binary compounds having a 1:1 stoichiometry; C: binary 1:2 compounds, etc. In every class of stoichiometries, the different types of structures are distinguished by a number and/or a letter. An equivalence table between the Strukturbericht designation and the Pearson symbol especially relevant to intermetallic phases can be found in Appendix at the end of Chapter 7.
3.8. STRUCTURE FAMILIES: DEGENERATE STRUCTURES, DERIVATIVE STRUCTURES, ‘SUPERSTRUCTURES’
As clearly pointed out, for instance, by Bärnighausen (1980), one of the main objectives of crystal chemistry is to order the profusion of structure types and to show the general principles involved. To this end relations between cognate structures evidently play an important role. The structures corresponding to different types may often be interrelated on the basis of some transformation or construction schemes. These schemes can be used as criteria for classifying structure types and showing structural relationships.
152
Intermetallic Chemistry
A few selected types of such relationships between different structures will be presented in this paragraph and in the following ones (§ 3.9 and 3.10). Examples will be considered of possible (virtual and/or real) transformation mechanisms from one structure type to another (degenerate, derivative structures); examples will also be discussed of groups of structures interrelated because based on the assembly of similar blocks and fragments (recombination structures). A derivative structure can be considered as being obtained from a reference structure by ordered atomic substitution, subtraction or addition processes or by unit cell distortions (or both). The opposite kinds of transformation correspond to the so-called degeneration processes. A derivative structure has fewer symmetry operations than the reference structure (a degenerate structure has more). A derivative structure has either a larger cell or a lower symmetry (or both) than the reference structure. It is possible, for instance, that a set of equipoints of a certain structure (considered as the reference structure) has to be subdivided into two (or more) subgroups in order to obtain the description of another (‘derivative’) structure. The structure of the Cu type (cF4 type), for instance, corresponds to four Cu atoms in the unit cell, placed in 0, 0, 0; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0; 1⁄2, 0, 1⁄2; 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2, whereas in the cP4-AuCu3 type structure the same atomic sites are subdivided into two groups with an ordered distribution, in another space group, of the two atomic species (1 Au atom in 0, 0, 0, and 3 Cu atoms in 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0; 1⁄2, 0, 1⁄2; 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2). (See also in § 3.7.1 the corresponding description in terms of lattice complexes.) The AuCu3-type structure can, therefore, be considered as a derivative structure of the Cu type. On the other hand, if we consider the AuCu3 type as the reference structure, we may describe the Cu type as a degenerate structure. The aforementioned subdivision of a set of equipoints in more groups can be described in this case in terms of similar cubic cells both of the original and of the derivative structures. Notice, however, that in the case of Cu the conventional cubic cell is face centred. It is not primitive: it corresponds to four (rhombohedral) primitive cells, whereas, in the case of AuCu3 the primitive unit cell is larger and it is identical to the cube. Because of the observation that these ordering processes may lead to a cell larger than the original one, they are also referred to as forming superstructures (also called superlattices) (Barrett and Massalski 1966) of the original structure. An example where, due to ordering, we observe perhaps in a more immediate way, the increase of the unit cell size (formation of a multiple cell) is the MnCu2Altype structure (representative of the so-called Heusler alloys) which can be considered a derivative structure (superstructure) of the cP2-CsCl type, which in turn is a superstructure of the W-type structure, corresponding to a non-primitive cubic cI2
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
153
(a)
(b) Al Mn Cu
Figure 3.31. cF16-MnCu2Al type structure (representative of the ‘Heusler type’ alloys). The unit cell is shown in (a), an eighth of the cell is shown in (b). It degenerates into a cP2-CsCl type cell if the atoms at the cube corners (Mn and Al) are equivalent. If all the atoms were equivalent there would be a further degeneration into the cI2-W type.
cell (see Fig. 3.31). Notice that the ordering may not lead to a multiple cell, if the symmetry of the ordered structure is reduced relatively to the original one. Nevertheless the name superstructure is generally used, especially when we have a disordered solid solution involved, regardless of whether there is multiplication of the edges of the cell or not. A contribution to the study of order–disorder interrelations between structures and to their classification into two groups on the basis of the presence/absence of a difference in the translational symmetry (unit cell edge variations) has been made by Wondratschek and Jeitschko (1976) and by Albering et al. (1994). The detectability of the two types of ordering by means of X-ray diffraction studies has also been discussed. Albering et al. (1994) especially studied the hP3-AlB2 type structure and its derivatives. A few of these are presented in Fig. 3.32. The main features of several deformation and substitution derivatives of the AlB2 type were discussed by Gladyshevskii et al. (1992). A more complex case of structure interrelation
154
Intermetallic Chemistry (a)
(b) AlB2 Al
B
(c) ThAuSi Au
Si
(d) Er2RhSi3 Rh
Si
Figure 3.32. hP3-AlB2 type and derivative structures. (a) Two sections of the AlB2 unit cell at the height 0 (Al atoms) and 1⁄2 c (B atoms) are shown. (b) The corresponding hexagonal net of the B atoms is presented; a projection, on the plane a, b, of the unit cell is superimposed. (c) The hexagonal net (at z 1⁄2) of the atoms Au and Si in the hP3-ThAuSi type cell. (d) The hexagonal RhSi3 net (at z 0) in the hP24-Er2RhSi3 cell: notice, in comparison with AlB2 the larger unit cell and compare this hexagonal net with those shown in (b) and (c).
which can be presented in terms of, albeit ‘formal’, substitution is that which can be exemplified by considering structures such as those of NaCl (Fig. 3.33) and FeS2 or CaC2 (see the description of the CaC2 structure and a comparison with that of MoSi2 in § 3.6.1.2).
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
155
Figure 3.33. cF8-NaCl type structure. The positions in the unit cell of two types of atoms are indicated. Notice that interchanging the positions of Na and Cl corresponds to a shift of the origin: the two dispositions are undistinguishable; the NaCl type is its own antitype.
These structures may be compared. The cP12-FeS2 type may be described as having Fe atoms in the sodium ion positions and the centres of the discrete S2 dumb-bell groups at the chlorine ion positions. The passage from one structure containing spherical atoms to another in which atomic groups substitute single atoms will generally result in a symmetry reduction. A clear example is the tI6-CaC2 type which can also be compared with the NaCl type: the positions of Na and Cl atoms may be related to those of calcium and of the C2 groups, respectively. In this case, however, the long axes of the C–C groups are all aligned in one direction so that the unit cell is tetragonal instead of cubic. In a similar way, for instance, the K2PtCl6 structure may be considered essentially the same as the CaF2 antitype: the K ions are in the F ion positions and the centres of the PtCl6 octahedral groups are in the Ca ion positions.
3.8.1 Defect and filled-up derivative structures Derived structures may also be formed by the ordered introduction of vacant sites. As an example, consider the hP3-CdI2 type structure (see Chapter 7) which can be related to the hP4-NiAs type structure in which the set of equivalent points 0, 0, 0 and 0, 0, 1⁄2 is considered as being subdivided into two groups (each of one site) 0, 0, 0 (occupied by one atomic species) and 0, 0, 1⁄2 (vacant). We can therefore regard the hP3-CdI2 type structure as a defect derivative form of the hP4-NiAs type (see § 7.4.2.4.3). Similar considerations may be extended to include (besides substitution and subtraction) ordered addition of atoms. In this case stuffed or filled-up derivative
156
Intermetallic Chemistry
structures are considered in which extra atoms have been added in an ordered way, on sites unoccupied in the reference structure. The hP6-Ni2In structure, which is a stuffed derivative structure of the previously mentioned NiAs structure is an example. Another interesting example is the face-centred cubic-derivative interstitial cP5-Fe4N phase. It may be described as corresponding to the following atomic – – positions in the Pm3m (or P4 3m) space group: 1 Fe in (a): 0, 0, 0; 1 N in (b): 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 and 3 Fe in (c): 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 0, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0. This filled-up superstructure may therefore be described in terms of the occupation by N of an interstice (centred in 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2) of a Cu-type (or AuCu3-type) structure. The N atom is octahedrally surrounded by 6 Fe atoms. This structure could also be described as a deficient NaCl-type derivative structure: the Fe atoms are in the same positions as the Na atoms in NaCl and one out of the four Cl positions is occupied by the N atoms. As a footnote to these observations, we also have to mention that frequently structural distortions (axial ratio and/or inter-axial angle variations) accompany the formation of derivative structures, especially because of the ordered distribution of atoms of different sizes or of vacant sites. 3.8.1.1 Tetrahedral and octahedral holes in close-packed structures. Derivative structures may be obtained from a parent structure by ordered substitution or by ordered addition of atoms. For a systematic description of the derivative structures which can be obtained from the close-packed structure by ordered filling-up, it may be useful to consider that in the closest packing of equal spheres there are, among the spheres themselves, essentially two kinds of interstices (holes). These are shown in Fig. 3.34. The smallest holes surrounded by a polyhedral group of spheres are those marked by T. An atom inserted in this hole will have four neighbours whose centres lie at the vertices of a regular tetrahedron (tetrahedral holes). The larger holes (octahedral holes) are surrounded by octahedral groups of six spheres. In an infinite assembly of close-packed spheres the ratios of the numbers of the tetrahedral and octahedral holes to the number of spheres are, respectively, 2 and 1. Considering the Cu-type structure (in which the four close-packed spheres are in 0, 0, 0; 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 0, 1 ⁄2; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0) the centres of the tetrahedral and octahedral holes have the coordinates: Four octahedral holes in: ⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 0, 0; 0, 1⁄2, 0; 0, 0, 1⁄2;
1
Two sets of 4 tetrahedral holes in: ⁄4, 1⁄4, 1⁄4; 1⁄4, 3⁄4, 3⁄4; 3⁄4, 1⁄4, 3⁄4; 3⁄4, 3⁄4, 1⁄4;
1
and in: ⁄4, 3⁄4, 3⁄4; 3⁄4, 1⁄4, 1⁄4; 1⁄4, 3⁄4, 1⁄4; 1⁄4, 1⁄4, 3⁄4.
3
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
157
O
T
T
O
Figure 3.34. Holes in the closest packing of equal spheres. Two superimposed layers of spheres are shown (continuous and dotted lines). Tetrahedral (T) and octahedral (O) holes are indicated.
Several cubic structures, therefore, in which (besides 0, 0, 0; 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 0, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0) one or more of the reported coordinate groups are occupied could be considered as filled-up derivatives of the cubic close-packed structures. The NaCl, CaF2, ZnS (sphalerite), AgMgAs and Li3Bi-type structures could, therefore, be included in this family of derivative structures. For this purpose, however, it may be useful to note that the radii of small spheres which fit exactly into tetrahedral and octahedral holes are, respectively, 0.225.... and 0.414... if the radius of the close-packed spheres is 1.0. For a given phase pertaining to one of the aforementioned types (NaCl, ZnS, etc.) if the stated dimensional conditions are not fulfilled, alternative descriptions of the structure may be more convenient than the reported derivation schemes. Notice, moreover, that one face-centred cubic cell of atoms X in which all the interstices are occupied (the octahedral by X and the tetrahedral by Z atoms) is equivalent to a block of 8 XZ, CsCl-type cells (see Fig. 3.31). This relationship (and others with other structures such as Li3Bi and MnCu2Al) should be kept in mind when considering, for instance, phase transformations occurring in ordering processes. Similar considerations may be made with reference to the other simple closepacked structure, that is to the hexagonal Mg-type structure. In this case two basic derived structures can be considered: the NiAs type with occupied octahedral holes and the wurtzite (ZnS) type with one set of occupied tetrahedral holes (compare with the data given with an origin shift in § 7.4.2.3.2). For a few more comments about ‘interstices’ and interstitial structures see § 3.8.4. See Fig. 3.35.
158
Intermetallic Chemistry 1/2
0
1/2
0
1/2
0
1/4 , 3/4 1/4 , 3/4 0 1/2
0
1/2
0
1/ 2
1/2
0
1/4 , 3/4 1/4 , 3/4
0
1/2
Four c.p. spheres in:
Eight tetrahedral holes in: , , , ,
0, 0, 0 , 0, 0, , , ,0
, , , ,
, , , ,
0
1/2
Four octahedral holes in:
, , , ,
0, 0, , 0, 0 0, , 0 , ,
y 0, 1/2
x
0, 1/2
5/8, 7/8
1/4 1/8, 3/8
3/4
0,1/2 Two spheres in: , ,
, ,
Four tetrahedral holes in: , ,
, 8 , 58
, ,
, 8 , 78
0,1/2 Two octahedral holes in: 0, 0, 0 0, 0,
Figure 3.35. Position of the holes in closest packing. Unit cell projections are shown for the cubic and hexagonal sphere closest packing. Coordinates of the spheres and of the tetrahedral and octahedral holes are given. The values indicated inside the drawing correspond to the third coordinate (along the vertical axis); when two values are given, these correspond to two positions along the same vertical line.
3.8.2 Order–disorder transformation In a number of metal systems for a given range of compositions, depending for instance on temperature, it is possible to observe alloys having both a certain degenerate structure and a corresponding (more or less) ordered derivative structure. The transformation from one structure to the other corresponds to a real process (order–disorder transformation). A large number of solid solutions become ordered at low temperature. In the specific case, for instance, of the Au–Cu system, an alloy with the AuCu3 composition at high temperature has the disordered cF4-Cu type structure. The two atomic species are equally distributed in
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
159
the four atomic sites, which are therefore equivalent: each one is occupied by Au with a 25% probability and by Cu with a 75% probability. This random distribution may also be related to the possibility of gradually changing the overall composition of the alloy while maintaining the same structure and giving the formation of solid solutions. For the Au–Cu alloys we have, at high temperature, a continuous solid solution ranging from Au to Cu, both having the same cF4-Cu type structure: in all the intermediate alloys we have the equivalence of all the atomic sites whose occupation gradually changes from pure Cu to pure Au. By lowering the temperature we have ordering processes corresponding to a change from a nearly random distribution of atoms among the structure sites into more ordered arrangements where certain sites are predominantly occupied by one kind of atom. In the specific case of the AuCu3 composition we have the transformation from the cF4-Cu type into the described derivative type (cP4-AuCu3 type) structure. Typical examples of ordering processes are also the transformation from the β to β phases in the Cu–Zn system (from cI2-W type to cP2-CsCl type) and the ordering of the FeAl phase in the CsCl-type structure. Notice that ordering in these metallic phases may be an extremely sluggish process requiring slow cooling and/or long annealing of the alloys. Alloy samples with different degrees of ordering can be obtained by quenching at various cooling times. As a consequence, the effects of ordering on a number of properties have been studied. Alloys such as AuCu3 and Fe3Al have been the subject of many of these studies. The Au–Cu system, in particular, was the first system for which a superstructure was shown to exist (Johansson and Linde 1925). As a result, a very large volume of work has been carried out on the ordered AuCu and AuCu3 phases. The description of the Au–Cu system, reported by Okamoto et al. (1987) (see Fig. 2.20 (d)), can be considered as a reference for the review and assessment, not only of the specific system, but also of the investigation methods and discussion criteria of general interest. The following topics are covered in the paper by Okamoto et al. (1987). Au–Cu phase diagram, Au3Cu, AuCu, AuCu3 ordered phases (phase boundaries determination by X-ray studies, electrical resistometry, electron microscopy), crystal structure determination by X-ray and electron diffraction methods, nature of ordering transformation in AuCu, short-range order, anomalous behaviour in AuCu3 at high temperatures (specific heat, thermal expansion measurements, etc.). Kinetic studies carried out by measuring gradual shift and intensity variation of the X-ray lines from a disordered to an ordered (superlattice) structure on samples after different quenching and annealing are also reported. For a review on site preference of substitutional additions to CsCl-type intermetallic compounds see Kao et al. (1994). In this work dilute additions to NiAl, FeAl and CoAl are especially discussed. The addition of a third element to ordered Ni3Al (cP4-AuCu3 type) occurring in different ways (Ochiai et al. 1984) is another
160
Intermetallic Chemistry
example where Sb, Si, Ge and Ga atoms replace preferably Al, while Cu and Co replace Ni. For a discussion on the trends of lattice parameter and volume changes consequent on disordering some types of structure see Bhatia and Cahn (2005). They observed that, when the more electropositive constituent of the alloy is a simple metal, a strong correlation may be observed between the volume increase on disordering and the formation volume of the ordered alloy. As a conclusion to this section, notice that a systematic description of ordering processes in alloys and of the superstructures which can be generated has been presented, for instance, by Khachaturyan (1983) in the framework of a theoretical treatment of structural transformation in solids. Two groups of superstructures have been specially considered: substitutional and interstitial.
3.8.3 Examples of substitutional superstructures A first group of superstructures, described in several paragraphs of this chapter and of Chapter 7, must be mentioned; these include the types tP2-AuCu(I), cP4AuCu3 and tP4-Ti3Cu which can be considered face-centred cubic-based substitutional ordered superstructures. A few more interrelated structures that may be described as substitutional superstructures of the cP4-AuCu3 type are schematically shown in Fig. 3.36. A full description of these different prototypes is given in the specific paragraphs of Chapter 7. In this figure characteristic projections of their unit cells are collected: in addition to AuCu3 itself, the tI8-TiAl3, tI16-ZrAl3, oI6-MoPt2 and tI10-MoNi4 types are depicted. tI8-TiAl3 (c/2a 1.12) has a unit cell composed of two distorted, AuCu3-type related, subcells stacked one above the other along the c direction. tI16-ZrAl3 (c/4a 1.08) has a unit cell corresponding along the c direction to four superimposed face-centred cubic subcells. oI6-MoPt2 (b/a 3.00) also is a close-packed superstructure based on pseudoface-centred cubic sub-cells. The tI10-MoNi4 type is another superstructure based on face-centred cubic pseudo-cells. In the projection shown in Fig. 3.36, inside the true cell, the pseudocubic subcell (aps 362 pm, cps 356.4 pm) has been evidenced by dotted lines. Close-packed layers can be identified in this structure: they are stacked in a 15 close-packed repeat sequence. Like the Au–Cu system, also the alloy system Cu–Pt is characterized by a phase diagram with the face-centred cubic continuous solid solution stable at high temperature and, for different composition ranges, a number of ordered superstructure phases stable at lower temperatures. CuPt(I), for instance, is a complex, slightly
161
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases Au Cu
AuCu3
0
.5
0
.5
0
.5 Zr
.5
0
.5
0
.5
0 Al
0
.5
0
.5
0
.5
0
.5
0
Ti Al
TiAl3
0
.5
0
.5
0
.5
.5
0
.5
0
.5
0
0
.5
0
.5
0
.5
.5
0
.5
0
.5
0
0
.5
0
.5
0
.5 ZrAl3
Mo Ni
.5
0
0
.5
0
.5
0
.5
0
.5
0
.5 0
MoNi4
.5
0
.5
0
.5
0
.5
0
.5
Pt .5
Mo
.5
MoPt2
Figure 3.36. cP4-AuCu3 type structure and examples of its substitutional superstructures. The projections of the unit cells of a number of interrelated structures are shown. cP4-AuCu3 projected on the face a, a; tI8-TiAl3 projected on the face a, c; tI16-ZrAl3 projected on the face a, c; tI10MoNi4 projected on the face a, a; oI6-MoPt2 projected on the face a, b. The values of the fractional coordinates along the third axis are indicated: notice, however, as reported in the text, the different c/a values.
distorted superstructure made up of eight face-centred cubic pseudo-cells (it is hR96 type with 32 atoms in the corresponding primitive rhombohedral cell which is slightly distorted in comparison with the original face-centred cubic cell: αrh 90°–91° according to the composition). In the same system other superstructures have been described for compositions around Cu3Pt5 (also called rhombohedral CuPt(II) type), Cu3Pt (cP4-AuCu3 type for compositions from 9 to 24 at.% Pt and tP8-Cu3Pd type at 23 to 28 at.% Pt), CuPt3 (orthorhombic), etc.
162
Intermetallic Chemistry
Another example of a superstructure based on a close-packed structure but related to the hexagonal close-packed one is that corresponding to the hP8-Ni3Sn prototype. Just as the AuCu3 type can be derived by ordering the Cu-type structure, so the Ni3Sn type can be obtained from the hP2-Mg type. Details of this structure and of some stacking variants are described in Chapter 7. 3.8.4 Examples of interstitial superstructures: Hägg phases In previous paragraphs it was observed that derivative structures may be obtained by the addition of atoms to certain parent structures. It was also mentioned that these extra atoms may be added on sites unoccupied in the reference structure, obtaining stuffed or filled-up derivative structures. The particular case of unoccupied sites corresponding to holes (interstices) in a structure was previously presented while discussing the example of the holes (tetrahedral and octahedral) in close-packed structures. In addition to what was reported in § 3.8.1.1 about the radii of small spheres which exactly fit into tetrahedral and octahedral holes, the values relevant to other polyhedral environments are given in Table 3.5. It must be underlined, however, that these are geometry-based considerations and concepts which may be very useful for the description of the structure types and their comparison and for classification purposes, but do not necessarily correspond to real chemical processes, even if in some cases (with certain elements) the insertion of atoms in the interstices of clusters or of a sphere packing can actually be performed. In the metal chemistry field, the uptake of hydrogen by some metals giving metal hydrides is an important example of an effective interstitial insertion. 3.8.4.1 Interstitial hydrides. A few different kinds of compounds may be obtained from the reaction of hydrogen with the metals (see Chapter 5). The term interstitial hydrides generally concerns non-stoichiometric phases with variable hydrogen content. During the absorption of hydrogen by a certain metal, a change in the properties of the metal itself occurs, which often may result in a phase change so Table 3.5. Radii of the cavities formed at the centres of some polyhedral metal arrangements where the metal atoms are hard spheres of radius 1.000 (the metal–metal bond lengths, that is the polyhedral edges, are 2.000). Tetrahedron Trigonal prism Square antiprism Cube Icosahedron Anticubooctahedron
0.225 0.528 0.645 0.732 0.902 1.000
Octahedron Capped octahedron Dodecahedron Tricapped trigonal prism Cuboctahedron
0.414 0.592 0.668 0.732 1.000
163
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
that the packing of the metal atoms in the final hydride may be different from that in the pure metal, generally being however still one of the packings characteristic for metal structures. Hydrogen compounds of the elements from the 3rd to 5th transition metal groups, including lanthanides and actinides, and of Cr, Ni, Pd and possibly Mg can be considered interstitial hydrides. The packing density of H atoms is generally very high in the hydrogen-rich metal hydrides. In some cases it is higher than in pure liquid hydrogen (for instance MgH2). A number of metals such as Mg (and alloys as LaNi5 and its ternary derivatives) easily take up and release hydrogen: so they can be used as reservoirs for hydrogen storage. The Pd–H system. Quoting from the detailed and comprehensive review by Manchester and Pitre (1994) it can be said that this system is the paradigm of metal hydrogen systems, the longest studied, the easiest to activate for hydrogen absorption and probably the richest in the number of physically interesting phenomena observed. A T/x projection from the P–T–x surface is shown in Fig. 3.37. The separation between the two phases (so-called α and α phases) and the twophase field may be noticed. The mutual saturation limits at room temperature are
Mass percent hydrogen 0.05
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6 0.7
T = 293°C Critical point: X = 22.5 at.% H = 0.27 mass% H
350 300 Temperature (°C)
250 200
α
α′
150 100 50 0 −50 5
10
15 20 25 30 Atomic percent hydrogen
35
40
Figure 3.37. Pd–H phase diagram. T–X projection (onto a plane at constant pressure P 100 Pa) obtained from the experimental P–x isotherms. Because of hysteresis the data obtained in absorption or desorption experiments are slightly different.
164
Intermetallic Chemistry
2 at.% H and 37.5 at.% H, respectively. There is no difference between the α and α phases above the critical temperature where we have a region of continuous solid solutions. Ordered phases stable at low temperature (200°C to 230°C) have been described also for this system. 3.8.4.2 Interstitial carbides and nitrides. Metals such as thorium, uranium, titanium, zirconium, hafnium, vanadium, niobium, tantalum, chromium, molybdenum, tungsten give carbides and nitrides, generally corresponding to solid solution phases around compositions such as Me2X and MeX, which are generally described as typical interstitial phases. Their similar packing geometry is characteristic. These carbides (and nitrides) frequently give together extended fields of solid solutions. Brewer type diagrams (see Chapter 4) for combinations of 4th and 5th column transition metals with 2nd period p-elements were presented by Engel (1969). For several monocarbides (MeC or, more generally, MeC1x) and mono-nitrides (MeN or MeN1x) a cF8-NaCl type crystal structure has been described corresponding to two sets of four sites (F F in the lattice-complex symbolism) occupied, respectively, by the Me atoms and, with a more or less large number of vacancies, by the C atoms. The atomic arrangement of one of these sets of positions is the same as that of the close-packed cF4-Cu type structure. The other set corresponds to the coordinates of the octahedral holes existing in the Cu-type structure. If the second elemental species (the non-metal) has sufficiently small atomic dimensions, an alternative description of the structure is therefore that of considering a certain number of atoms X inserted in a disordered or more or less ordered way in the interstices (holes) of a close-packed Me structure. The mentioned MeC1x(and MeN1x) compounds are characterized by very strong bonds; their hardness is very high (values close to that of diamond have been observed) and they have very high melting points (among the highest known) corresponding, for instance for the 1:1 compositions, to: TiC (3070°C), ZrC (3430°C), HfC (3950°C), VC (2660°C), TaC (3970°C), Ta2N (3000°C), ZrN (decomposes in liquidgas at 3410°C). A few more details about these systems are summarized in the following data as taken from the compilation by Okamoto (2000). Ti–C: In this system one intermediate phase is formed with a homogeneity range extending, depending on temperature, between 32 and 50 at.% C, in short named TiC (or, better, TiC1x) and having a NaCl-type structure. Zr–C: One intermediate phase ZrC (36–50 at.% C) NaCl type. Hf–C: One intermediate phase HfC (34–49.5 at.% C) NaCl type. V–C: Several intermediate phases: VC (37.4–48 at.% C), NaCl type, a few V2C phases (in the range 27–34 at.% C) and V4C3, V6C5, V8C7.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
165
Nb–C: Two intermediate phases NbC (37.7–49 at.% C), NaCl-type and Nb2C (29–33.5 at.% C), NiAs-type. Ta–C: Two intermediate phases TaC (38–49 at.% C), NaCl type and Ta2C (28–33 at.% C) hP3-Fe2N type. Ti–N: The system is complex with several intermediate phases; among them TiN (28 to 50 at.% N), NaCl-type. Zr–N: The system shows the ZrN phase, homogeneous in the 40–50 at.% N composition range with the NaCl-type structure. Solid solutions of N in αZr (up to 25 at.%) and in βZr (up to 5 at.%) have been described. Hf–N: The system is complex with several intermediate phases Hf3N2, Hf4N3, HfN (40–52.5 at.% N), NaCl-type. V–N: The system contains two intermediate phases: VN (that is VN1x, homogeneous between 38.4 and 50 at.% N), NaCl-type and the hexagonal hP9 V2N1y (28–34 at.% N). The VN1x phase, at high temperature (up to the melting point 2340°C), shows a large homogeneity field (33–50 at.% N). The composition changes result from variation in the number of vacancies on sites in the N sublattice, with x being the fraction of sites randomly vacant. At lower temperature, in the composition range 43–46 at.% N, an ordering of the N atoms has been observed, resulting in a tetragonal superstructure containing 32 V atoms and 26 N atoms in the unit cell. A number of metastable phases have been also described. Nb–N: The system contains the intermediate phases: NbN (TiAs-type), Nb2N (V2N-type) and the tetragonal Nb4N3. Ta–N: The system contains the so-called δ phase (high-temperature phase homogeneous between 40 and 50 at.% N, NaCl-type), Ta2N (21–35 at.% N, Fe2N-type) and TaN (CoSn-type). W–N: The so-called γ phase (29.5 to 41.5 at.% N) is stable between 283°C and 1875°C and has the NaCl-type structure. WN (50 at.% N) has the hP2-WC type structure. Several other phases, probably metastable, have been described. 3.8.4.3 Hägg rules. It was Hägg (1930, 1931) who remarked that a number of hydrides, borides, carbides, nitrides and oxides could be described in terms of metal atoms in sphere packing with the smaller B, C, N, O atoms in the octahedral interstices or the still smaller H atoms in the tetrahedral interstices (see § 3.8.1.1). He empirically found, on the basis of the atomic radius ratio, RX/RMe, between the non-metal and metal atoms, a number of regularities in the formation of several hydrides, borides, carbides and nitrides. The generally non-stoichiometric compounds are now called Hägg phases. Considering a large number of transition elements Me, he observed that: ‘Alle untersuchten Phasen, wo RX/RMe 0.59 ist, zeigen einfache Strukturen’ that is: All the phases studied for which RX/RMe 0.59 show ‘simple’ structures. A number of these ‘simple’ structures have been described
166
Intermetallic Chemistry
6.00
Density (g/cm3)
5.60
5.20
4.80
0.2
0.6
Ti2O3
TiO
Ti2O
4.40
1.0 TiOx (x)
1.4
1.8
Figure 3.38. Experimental densities of titanium oxides (continuous lines). The upper dotted line gives the values computed for a 100% occupancy of the cation sites in the NaCl structure type (from Hyde and Andersson 1989).
in the previous paragraphs. The different behaviour generally noticed for the oxides was attributed to their different bonding (ionic) mechanism. In the Ti–O system, as an example, γTiO (high-temperature form, homogeneous in the composition range 35–55 at.% O) has the NaCl-type structure. Other forms of the monoxide βTiO, αTiO, βTi1xO, αTi1xO have ordered structures based on γTiO. In the structure there are atoms missing from some of the sites. According to what is summarized by Hyde and Andersson (1989), in TiO0.64 36% of the oxygens are missing, in TiO1.26, which can be represented also with the stoichiometry Ti0.79O, 20% of the Ti atoms are missing and in TiO both kinds of atoms are missing (15% of each) (see Fig. 3.38). As a final example, we may mention the NaCl-type phases formed in the V–O systems. The VO1 x phase is homogeneous in the composition range 42–57 at.% O. Lattice parameter determination in combination with density measurements evidenced that, in the structure, vacancies occur in both V and O sublattices through the entire range of composition. At the stoichiometric composition VO there are 15% of sites vacant in each sublattice. 3.8.4.4 Miscellaneous examples of interstitial superstructures. tP3-FeNiN, a 283.0, c 371.3 pm, c/a 1.312. Space group P4/mmm, N. 123. 1 Fe in (a) 0, 0, 0; 1 N in (c) 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0 and 1 Ni in (d) 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
167
This structure can be considered a superstructure of the AuCu(I) type with 1 N atom inserted in an octahedral interstice. This structure, as the previously described cP5-Fe4N type, can be considered an interstitial ordered phase. oP5-Ta4O: a 719.4, b 326.6, c 320.4 pm. Space group Pmmm, N. 47. 1 Ta in (a): 0, 0, 0; 1 Ta in (b): 1⁄2, 0, 0; 1 O in (h): 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 2 Ta in (l): x, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 and –x , 1⁄2, 1⁄2 (with x 0.225). The cell can be described as formed by two superimposed slightly distorted body-centred cubic subcells of the metal atoms. The O atom is surrounded by a slightly compressed Ta atom octahedron.
3.8.5 Remarks about a ‘second kind’ of superstructures In the preceding paragraphs examples of a number of so-called superstructures have been considered. Generally, it has been observed that a derivative structure has fewer symmetry operations than the reference structure: it has either a larger cell or a lower symmetry (or both) than the reference structure. Typically the passage from the reference structure to the derivative structure (superstructure) may be related to the fact that a set of equipoints of a certain structure (the reference one) has to be subdivided into two (or more) subsets in order to obtain the description of the other structure. The structure of the Cu type (cF4 type), for instance, corresponds to 4 Cu atoms in the unit cell, placed in 0, 0, 0; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0; 1⁄2, 0, 1 ⁄2; 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2, whereas in the cP4-AuCu3 type structure the same atomic sites are subdivided, in another space group, into two sets with an ordered distribution of the two atomic species (1 Au atom in 0, 0, 0 and 3 Cu atoms in 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0; 1⁄2, 0, 1⁄2; 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2). Apart from this type of superstructure, which could then be described as superstructure of the first kind, another type of structure derivation can be considered: an example could be given by the relation between the CaCu5 and the CeCo3B2 structures. Both hP6-CaCu5 and hP6-CeCo3B2 structures are hexagonal, in the same space group (P6/mmm, N. 191), with the following occupation of the same sites: 1 Ca, or respectively, 1Ce 2 Cu, or respectively, 2 B 3 Cu, or respectively, 3 Co
in (a) 0, 0, 0; in (c) 1⁄3, 2⁄3, 0; 2⁄3, 1⁄3, 0; in (g) 1⁄2, 0, 1⁄2; 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 1⁄2;
For the two compounds the lattice parameters are a 508.2 pm (CaCu5), a 505.7 pm (CeCo3B2), c 407.8 pm (CaCu5), c 303.6 pm (CeCo3B2), c/a 0.802 (CaCu5), c/a 0.600 (CaCo3B2)
168
Intermetallic Chemistry
We notice that in the second structure we have the occupation of the same sites and a similar shape of the unit cell. The CeCo3B2-type structure can therefore be considered as a superstructure of the second kind of the CaCu5 type (Gladyshevskii and Bodak 1995). Other examples of pairs of structures having the same space group and the same assembly of Wyckoff sites orderly occupied but with a different atomic distribution (different stoichiometric ratio) are given by: cI58-α-Mn : cI58-Ti5Re24(χ phase); cI58-α-Mn : cI58-Mg17Al12; hP12MgZn2 : hP12-U2OsAl3. Notice that not in all the compilations and not by all the researchers are such structural variants considered as separate structure types. It seems however useful to speak of, say, the cI58-Ti5Re24 type structure when the elements are orderly distributed in selected sites of the Mn type, whereas it could really be more appropriate to speak of the cI58 α -Mn type even in the case of a binary combination (a solid solution) in which all the sites of this structure are occupied, at random in the same proportion, by the different components. 3.9. STRUCTURE FAMILIES: ‘RECOMBINATION STRUCTURES’, MODULAR ASPECTS OF CRYSTAL STRUCTURES
Tantum elementa queunt permutato ordine solo, T. Lucreti Cari Liber primus De Rerum Natura, 827 (So much may be obtained by changing only the component arrangement) (Titus Lucretius Caro ‘On the nature of Things’)
3.9.1 Modular aspects of crystal structures A very general, mainly geometric, approach to the description and classification of the different inorganic structures can be based on a systematic construction of complex structural types by means of a few operations applied to some building units. As suggested by Andersson and Hyde (1982), Hyde and Andersson (1989) a formal description and classification of the various crystal structures could be obtained in terms of a classification of the building units and of the construction mechanism. Building units correspond to packets of points (atoms) (blocks, clusters, bounded in three dimensions) or to groups of lines (rods, columns bounded in two dimensions, infinite in the third) or to groups of planes (slabs, sheets, layers, lamellae bounded in only one dimension, infinite in the other two). Structures may then be constructed from such portions by discontinuous symmetry operations (translation, reflection or their combinations) repeated in a parallel way or by similar symmetry operations repeated in a cyclic way, involving rotation (see, for instance, Figs. 3.39(a)–(d)).
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
169
Figure 3.39. AlB2-type derivative structures generated by cyclic repetition of blocks of AlB2-type columns. The projections of the unit cells (all having nearly the same c parameter) on the x, y plane are presented. (a) hP22-Ce6Ni2Si3 (a 1211.2 pm, c 432.3 pm); (b) The arrangement of the building blocks of the hP22-Ce6Ni2Si3 structure around the z axis (63 symmetry axis). (c) hP40Ce5Ni2Si3 (a 1612.0 pm, c 430.9 pm); (d) hP64-Pr15Ni7Si10 (a 1988.1 pm, c 425.5 pm); rare earth atoms (Ce, Pr): white circles; Si (and Si Ni): black circles; small circles: atoms at level z 1⁄4, large circles at level z 3⁄4. Ni atoms at level 0 and level 1⁄2: double circles; Ni atoms at level 1 ⁄4, 3⁄4: grey circles.
Emphasis to a similar approach has been given by Zvyagin (1993). He pointed out that many crystal structures can be represented as a composite of certain standard ‘construction modules’ and various combinations, distributions and arrangements of these. The simplest example of a modular structure is the densest packing
170
Intermetallic Chemistry
of identical atoms; the atomic planes represent the construction modules forming various structures owing to a variation of the two possible placements of the successive plane relative to the preceding one. A classification of the different structures can be based on: ● ● ● ● ●
module types (sheets, rods, blocks); dimension of the modules; variety of module type (single or mixed-module structures); relative number of module types; arrangement of adjacent modules (variations in these arrangements, periodicity/ aperiodicity of successive variations, etc.).
Principles and types of modular series have been summarized in a book by Ferraris et al. (2004). A hierarchical classification of structure has been introduced as well as the application of modularity to structure description and modelling. The order/disorder theory has been presented as fundamental to developing a systematic theory of polytypism, dealing with structures based on both ordered and disordered stacking of one or more layers. The structures of a great number of compounds (minerals, complex oxides, salts, etc.) have been described and discussed. Strictly related to this kind of description are the concepts of Recombination Structures and of Intergrowth Structure Series, to be discussed in the following see § 3.9.4. 3.9.2 Homeotect structure types, polytypic structures According to Parthé (1964), two different structure types of the same formula XmYn are called homeotect structure types if every X atom has the same number of nearest X neighbours and the same number of nearest Y neighbours, and, conversely, if every Y atom has the same number of nearest X and Y neighbour atoms. It is possible for several structure types to have this feature. All the different structure types of equal composition, which have (for corresponding atoms) the same kind of surroundings, form a set of homeotect structure types. The term polytypic structure is also used to denote the relationships observed with homeotect structures. According to Parthé (1964) all structure types which belong to a homeotect set can be described as different stacking variants of identical structural unit slabs (minimal sandwiches). All structure types of a set are constructed by stacking identical unit slabs one on top of another. The various types differ only in the relative horizontal displacement of these units. The vertical unit cell edges of the different types are integer multiples of a common unit which is the height of the unit slab characteristic for the homeotect structure type set. All structure types which belong to a homeotect set have the same space-filling curve (see § 4.3.2.5).
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
171
A few important examples of groups of homeotect structure types will be described in the following sections. A short list follows, in which the Jagodzinski–Wyckoff notation of the stacking pattern has been inserted according to the previously given indications. 3.9.2.1 Close-packed element structure types. The structures of the close-packed metals are a simple well-known example of homeotect structure types. We have seen that the following metals can be considered as reference types. Mg type (h), Cu type (c), La type (hc), Sm type (hhc). (See § 3.7.6 and Figs 3.20, and 3.21). Their polytypic nature may be represented by a series of close-packed stacking variants of similar triangular atomic nets (A, B, C nets) corresponding to the following symbols: hP2-Mg type: MgB0.25MgC0.75. That is BCBCBC..... or CACACA in short: (BC) cF4-Cu type: Cu0ACuB0.33CuC0,67 (ABC) B A C hP4-La type.: LaA (ABAC) 0 La 0.25La 0.5La 0.75. A C A hR9-Sm type: Sm0 Sm 0.11Sm 0.22SmC0.33SmB0.45SmC0.55SmB0.67 (ACACBCBAB) SmA0.78SmB0.89 Details about these structure types and lists of metals belonging to them are presented in § 7.3.2.1. 3.9.2.2 Equiatomic tetrahedral structure types. (Carborundum structure types). To this group pertain the diamond-type structure, the wurtzite (h) and the sphalerite (c) types, and the large family of SiC polytypes (such as hc, hcc, hccc, hcchc, … (hcc)5(hccc)(hcc)5hc … (hchcc)17(hcc)2, … (hcc)43hc…). These are all examples of a family of ‘tetrahedral’ structures which have been described by Parthé and will be briefly presented in Chapters 4 and 7. The cF8-C (diamond) structure type, and the cF8-ZnS (sphalerite), hP4-ZnO (ZnS wurtzite) are described in §7.3.3.2 and 7.4.2.3, respectively. 3.9.2.3 Laves phases. hP12 MgZn2 type (h), cF24 Cu2Mg type (c), hP24 Ni2Mg type (hc), Laves polytypes (hhc, hhccc, etc.). The Laves phases form a homeotect structure type set (a family of polytypic structures). In all of them, described in terms of a hexagonal cell, three closely spaced 36 nets of atoms are followed (in the z direction of the same cell) by a 3636 net. The 36 nets are stacked on the same site as the kagomé 3636 nets which they surround. For instance: β-BAC-γ-CAB in the ‘two slabs’ MgZn2-type (h) structure, β-BAC-γ-CBA-α-ACB in the ‘three slabs’ MgCu2-type (c) structure,
172
Intermetallic Chemistry
α-ABC-γ-CBA-α-ACB-β-BCA in the ‘four slabs (hc)’ Ni2Mg-type structure, etc. However, the Laves phases, like Frank–Kasper structures (see Table 3.6), can also be described by alternative stacking of pentagon-triangle main layers of atoms and secondary triangular layers, parallel to (110) planes of the hexagonal cell. Layer stacking symbols (K 3T slabs formed by kagomé and triangular nets) of the main types of Laves phases: hP12-MgZn2 (two slabs type structure (h) β-BAC-γ-CAB) γ B β B A C C ZnA 0 Mg 0.06Zn 0.25Mg 0.44Zn 0.50Mg 0.56Zn 0.75Mg 0.94 cF24-Cu2Mg (three slabs type structure (c) β-BAC-γ-CBA-α-ACB) MgA0Cuα0.13MgA0.25CuC0.29MgB0.33Cuβ0.46MgB0.58CuA0.63MgC0.67Cuγ0.79MgC0.92CuB0.96 hP24-Ni2Mg (four slabs type structure (hc) α-ABC-γ-CBA-α-ACB-β-BCA) Niα0MgA0.09NiB0.13MgC0.16Niγ0.25MgC0.34NiB0.37MgA0.41Niα0.50MgA0.59NiC0.63MgB0.66 β Ni0.75 MgB0.84NiC0.87MgA0.91 Details about general crystallography of the Laves phases and alternative descriptions and their polytypes and variants are given in § 7.4.3.3 whereas some information about their occurrence and thermodynamics is reported in § 3.9.3.1.3. 3.9.2.4 A few general remarks about homeotect structures. Other important sets of homeotect structure types are those related to disilicide structure types (MoSi2, CrSi2, etc.), cadmium halide structure types, etc. (See Parthé 1964, Hyde and Anderson 1989), or presented by certain groups of compounds such as rare earth trialuminides (Van Vucht and Buschow 1965). From a general point of view, polytypism may be considered a special case of polymorphism: the 2D translations within the layers are essentially preserved whereas the lattice spacings normal to the layers vary between polytypes and are indicative of the stacking period (Guinier et al. 1984). As evidenced by Zvyagin (1987), various forms of polytypic structures may be distinguished, including, besides close-packing of like and unlike atoms, polytypes of tetrahedral, octahedral and prismatic layers packed according to the laws of closest packings. Complex silicate structures, for instance, may be considered, which are characterized by a great variety in the orientation and displacements of the layers and also structures in which 2D layers are conjoined with 1D bands and island groups. The aforementioned papers (Guinier et al. 1984, Zvyagin 1987) also contain suggestions and recommendations on the nomenclature and symbolism for use in the general case of either simple or complex polytypic structures. Another method for describing polytypic structures has been suggested by Bokii and Laptev (1994). The polytypic structures, described by means of special unit
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
173
cell diagrams and crystal–chemical formulae, are distinguished by the number and type of Wyckoff positions. 3.9.3 Assembly of polyhedra Several intermetallic phase structures can be described in terms of an assembly of building blocks consisting of a collection of coordination polyhedra. A classification of types of intermetallic structures based on the coordination number, configurations of coordination polyhedra and their method of combination has been given by Kripyakevich (1963). According to Kripyakevich, a coordination polyhedron of an atom is the polyhedron, the vertices of which are defined by the atoms surrounding this atom: a coordination polyhedron should have a form as close as possible to a sphere, that is, it should be convex everywhere and have the maximum number of triangular faces. At the vertices of a coordination polyhedron of a given atom (in addition to atoms of different elements) there can also be atoms of the same kind. A considerable variety of coordination polyhedra exists. In some cases, plane coordination polygons have to be considered. The number of vertices may vary from 3 to 24. Generally, the structure consists of atoms with different coordination numbers; according to Kripyakevich, structures are most conveniently classified according to the type of coordination polyhedron of the atoms with the lowest coordination number. An important contribution to the structure analysis of intermetallic phases in terms of the coordination polyhedra has been carried out by Frank and Kasper (1958). They described several structure types (Frank–Kasper structures) as the result of the interpenetration of a group of polyhedra, which give rise to a distorted tetrahedral close-packing of the atoms. Samson (1967, 1969) developed the analysis of the structural principles of intermetallic phases having giant unit cells (Samson phases). These structures have been described as arrangements of fused polyhedra rather than the full interpenetrating polyhedra. The principle of describing structures in terms of polyhedron packing has been considered by Girgis and Villars (1985). To this end they consider, in a given structure, the coordination polyhedra of all the atomic positions; structures are then described by packing the least number of polyhedra types. All the atoms in the unit cell are included in the structure-building polyhedra. The polyhedra considered should not penetrate each other. According to Girgis and Villars (1985) structures are then classified mainly on the basis of the following criteria: ● ● ●
Number of polyhedra types employed in the description of the structure. Characteristics of the polyhedra (number of vertices, symmetry). Types of polyhedra packing (either 3D distribution of discrete polyhedra sharing corners, edges or faces, or layer-like distribution of polyhedra).
174
Intermetallic Chemistry
Examples of structures described by packing of one polyhedron type are: cP4-AuCu3 type, 3D arrangement of cubooctahedra (coordination number, CN, 12) and tP30-σ(Cr,Fe) type, layer-like arrangement of icosahedra (CN 12). For a general approach to the problem of structure descriptions in terms of polyhedron packing, a paper by Hawthorne (1983) should also be consulted. The following hypothesis is proposed: crystal structures may be ordered or classified according to the polymerization of those coordination polyhedra (not necessarily of the same type) with the higher bond valences. The linkage of polyhedra to form ‘clusters’ is then considered from a graph-theoretical point of view. Different kinds of isomers are described and their enumeration considered. According to Hawthorne, moreover, it has to be pointed out that many classifications of complex structures recognize families of structures based on different arrangements of a fundamental building block or module (see § 3.9.4). If this building module is a tightly bound unit within the structure it could be considered, for instance, as the analogue of a molecule in an organic structure. Such modules can be considered the basis of structural hierarchies that include, for instance, simple and complex oxides and complex alloy structures. These modules can be considered as formed by polymerization of those coordination polyhedra that are most strongly bonded and may be useful for a classification and systematic description of crystal structures. As a conclusion to this section it is worth mentioning the ‘atomic environments’, defined and coded by Daams et al. (1992). A short description of this topic has been given in § 3.7.5 together with some remarks about the classification of AET and their description and coding in terms of coordination polyhedra. 3.9.3.1 Tetrahedrally close-packed structures. Frank–Kasper structures. A number of structures of several important intermetallic phases can be classified as tetrahedrally close-packed structures. According to Shoemaker and Shoemaker (1969), in packing spheres of equal size the best space filling is obtained in the cubic or hexagonal close-packed structures, or in their variants. In those arrangements there are tetrahedral and octahedral holes (see the comments on this point reported in the description of the cF4-Cu-type structure in § 3.8.1.1). The local mean atomic density (the average space filling) is somewhat higher at the tetrahedral holes than in the larger octahedral ones. A more compact arrangement might, therefore, be obtained if it were possible to have only tetrahedral interstices. It is, however, impossible to fill space with regular tetrahedra throughout. By introducing some variability in the sphere dimensions it is possible to obtain packing containing only tetrahedral holes. The tetrahedra are now no longer regular: the ratio of the longest tetrahedron edge to the shortest, however, need not exceed about 4/3 in a given structure. The corresponding crystal structure can be considered to be obtained from the space filling
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
175
of these tetrahedra which share faces, edges and vertices. In structures containing atoms of approximately the same size and within the aforementioned limits of edge-length ratio, the sharing of a given tetrahedron edge (that is, an interatomic link ligand) either among 5 or 6 tetrahedra has to be considered the most favoured situation, according to the systematic analysis of these structures carried out by Frank and Kasper (1958, 1959). On the assumption that only 5 o 6 tetrahedra may share a given edge, the number of tetrahedra that share a given vertex is limited to the values 12, 14, 15 and 16. The 12 (or 14, 15, 16) tetrahedra that are assembled around a point share this point as a common vertex, and form, around this point, a coordination polyhedron with triangular faces. The radii of this polyhedron are the edges shared among 5 or 6 component tetrahedra and connect the central atom with the polyhedron vertices, five-fold or six-fold vertices, that is vertices in which 5 or 6 faces meet. The four possible Frank–Kasper coordination polyhedra are included in Fig. 3.18 (and coded 12a, 14a, 15a, 16a) and correspond to the following properties: Coordination 12 (regular, or approximately regular, icosahedron): 12 vertices (12 five-fold vertices) and 20 faces. Coordination 14: 14 vertices (12 five-fold and 2 six-fold) and 24 faces. Coordination 15: 15 vertices (12 five-fold and 3 six-fold) and 26 faces. Coordination 16: 16 vertices (12 five-fold and 4 six-fold) and 28 faces. For symbols used in the coding of the vertex characteristics see § 3.7.5. Several structures (Frank–Kasper structures) can be considered in which all atoms have either 12 (icosahedral), 14, 15 or 16 coordinations. These can be described as resulting from the polyhedra included in Fig. 3.18. These polyhedra interpenetrate each other so that every vertex atom is again the centre of another polyhedron. All structures in this family contain icosahedra and at least one other coordination type. Frank and Kasper demonstrated that structures formed by the interpenetration of the four polyhedra contain planar or approximately planar layers of atoms: primary layers made by tessellation of triangles with hexagons and/or pentagons, and intervening secondary layers of triangles and/or squares. For a classification and coding of the nets and of their stacking, see Pearson (1972) and also Shoemaker and Shoemaker (1969) or Frank and Kasper (1958, 1959). A short summary of structural types pertaining to this family is reported in Table 3.6; for a few of them some details or comments are reported in the following § 7.5.3. 3.9.3.1.1 cP8-Cr3Si type structure. This structure is also called W3O or β-W type (it was previously believed to be a W modification instead of an oxide) or A15 type.
176
Intermetallic Chemistry
Table 3.6. Examples of tetrahedral close-packed structures. Structural type
Unit cell dimensions (rounded values) for the reported prototype (pm)
Percentage of atoms in the centre of a polyhedron with CN 12
14
15
16
cP8-Cr3Si (also called β-W (W3O) type or A15 type phase)
a 456
25
75
tP30-σCr46Fe54* σ phases
a 880 c 456
33
53
13
hR39-W6Fe7 μ phases
a 476 c 2562
55
15
15
hP7-Zr4Al3
a 543 c 539
43
28
28
oP52Nb48Ni39Al13* M phases
a 930 b 493 c 1627
55
15
15
15
oP56Mo21Cr9Ni20* P phases
a 1698 b 475 c 907
43
36
14
7
hR159Mo31Cr18Co51* R phases
a 1090 c 1934
51
23
11
15
cI162-Mg11Zn11Al6* Bergman phases
a 1416
61
7
7
25
a 704 a 522 c 856
67 67
a 482 c 1583
67
Laves Phases: cF24-Cu2Mg hP12-MgZn2 hP24-Ni2Mg
15
33 33 33
* For these phases the reported formulae generally correspond to an average composition within a solid solution field. This also in relation to a (partially) disordered occupation of the different sites.
– Cubic, space group Pm3n, N. 223. Atomic positions: 2 Si in (a) 0, 0, 0; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 6 Cr in (c) 1⁄4, 0, 1⁄2; 3⁄4, 0, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 1⁄4, 0; 1⁄2, 3⁄4, 0; 0, 1⁄2, 1⁄4; 0, 1⁄2, 3⁄4. This structure type is observed for many phases formed in the composition ratio 3:1 by several transition metals with elements from the III, IV, V main group (or with Pt metals or Au). Phases having this structural type are, for instance, Mo3Al,
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
177
Nb3Al, V3Al, Ta3Au, Ti3Au, Cr3Pt, Cr3Os, Cr6AlSi, V6AlSn, Nb6GaGe, etc. A number of compounds with this structure have been found to have significantly high superconducting transition temperature, Tc (among the highest known, before the discovery of the families of superconducting complex oxides, such as Ba2YCu3O7x or Bi2(Ca,Sr)3Cu2O9x,etc.). Examples of superconducting, Cr3Si type, phases are: Nb3Ge (Tc 23.2 K, sputtered films), Nb3Ga (Tc 20.7 K, bulk), Nb3Sn (Tc 18.1 K), V3Si (Tc 16.8 K), V3Ga (Tc 14.1 K), Nb3Au (Tc 11.5 K), Nb3Pt (Tc 9.2 K), Mo3Ir (Tc 8.8 K), etc. The Cr3Si-type structure does not always remain stable in these materials down to 0 K, yet the change in crystal structure, when it occurs (for instance, with a tetragonal structure formed at low temperature as a result of a martensitic transformation) does not seem to be correlated with Tc. Solid solutions in general have lower Tc values than the stoichiometric compounds. Other superconducting intermetallic phases belonging to different structural types are, for instance, LuRh4B4 (Tc 11.7 K, YPd5B3Cx (Tc 23 K), quaternary lanthanum nickel boro nitrides, etc. See Cava et al. (1994a, b). Another recently discovered (Nagamatsu et al. 2001) superconductor (with a remarkably high transition temperature, Tc 39 K) is MgB2 (AlB2 type, a 308.5 pm, c 352.3 pm, c/a 1.142). 3.9.3.1.2 σ-phase type structure (tP30-σ Cr–Fe type). In the space group P42/mnm, N. 136, the two atomic species, Cr and Fe, are distributed in several sites with a nearly random occupation. Also owing to different preparation methods and heat treatments, different atom distributions have been proposed in the literature. The following distribution is one of those reported in Daams et al. (1991): two atoms in sites (a) (with a 12% probability for Cr and 88% for Fe), 4 atoms (75% Cr, 25% Fe) in sites ( f ), 8 atoms (62% Cr, 38% Fe) in a set (i), 8 atoms (16% Cr, 84% Fe) in another set (i) and 8 atoms (66% Cr, 34% Fe) in ( j). The structure can be considered as made up of primary hexagon-triangle layers containing 3636 3262 and 63 nodes (in a 3:2:1 ratio) at height 0 and 1/2 separated (at height 1/4 and 3/4) by secondary 32434 layers (that is layers, in which every node is surrounded, in order, by: 2 triangles, 1 square, 1 triangle and 1 square). As pointed out by Pearson, by studying the near-neighbours diagrams (see § 4.3.2.5), the σ phase structure is a good example of a structure which is controlled by the coordination factor: all the known phases are closely grouped around the intersection of lines corresponding to high coordination numbers. The most favourable radius ratio for the component atoms is included between 1.0 and 1.1. It is also possible that the electron concentration plays some role in controlling the phase stability. The different phases are grouped in the range 6.2–7.5 electrons (s, p and d) per atom.
178
Intermetallic Chemistry
3.9.3.1.3 Laves phases and derivative structures: cF24-Cu2Mg (and cF24Cu4MgSn and cF24-AuBe5), hP12-MgZn2 (and hP12-U2OsAl3) and hP24Ni2Mg types. Many binary and complex solid solutions Laves phases are known. They form one of the largest groups of intermetallic compounds. Their fundamental and applicative properties have been object of extensive researches: some space will therefore be dedicated to this group of compounds. A crystal–chemical description of the main Laves structure types and of some of their derivatives is included in Chapter 7 and summarized in Table 3.7. A few data on their occurrence, stability, etc. are discussed in this paragraph. General remarks. In a description of the principal Laves types, a few more remarks can be made concerning higher-order Laves polytypes. An interesting example is given by the Li–Mg–Zn alloys (Melnik and Kripyakevich 1974, Mallik 1987). This system is one of the richest in Laves phases among the known ternary systems. It contains, besides MgZn2, eight ternary compounds Ln (the index n denotes the number of slabs) in the following sequence: L2: MgZn2 L8: Mg(Li0.07Zn1.93) L14: Mg(Li0.11Zn1.89) L9: Mg(Li0.20Zn1.80) L10: Mg(Li0.23Zn1.77) L4: Mg(Li0.25Zn1.75) L 4: Mg(Li0.50Zn1.50) L 3: Mg(Li0.56Zn1.44) L3: Mg(Li0.77Zn1.23)
(hP), (hP), (hP), (hR), (hP), (hP), (hP), (hR), (cF),
a 521.4 pm; a 521.3 pm; a 521.5 pm; a 522 pm; a 522.3 pm; a 522.7 pm; a 1046 pm; a 1051 pm; a 522.6 pm;
c 856.3 pm (2 428.1) c 3422 pm (8 427.8) c 5989 pm (14 427.8) c 3841 pm (9 426.8) c 4278 pm (10 427.8) c 1709 pm (4 427.3) c 1705 pm (4 426.3) c 1285 pm (3 428.3) c 1290 pm (3 430)
Notice that the structures with n 3 and 4 exist not only in an ordinary form L4, Ni2Mg, and L3, Cu2Mg-type cubic (a 744.8 pm, here described in terms of an equivalent set of hexagonal axes), but also with doubled unit cell edge a (Ni2Mg type and Cu2Mg type superstructures L 4 and L 3). It may be useful to mention that depending for instance on the temperature, different Laves-type structures can be observed in the same chemical system. An example is the Ti–Cr system for which three different structures have been described: αTiCr2 (MgCu2 type, homogeneous in the composition range 63–65 at.% Cr), stable from room temperature up to 1220°C; βTiCr2 (MgZn2 type, homogeneous from 64 to 66 at.% Cr), high-temperature phase stable from 800°C up to 1270°C. Notice that the α and β forms, which can coexist in the temperature range from 800°C up to 1220°C have slightly different compositions and are stable with an excess of Ti atoms.
Table 3.7. Summary of the crystal structure data of the three most important Laves phases (see § 7.4.3.3). Pearson symbol and prototype
Space group symbol and number
Lattice parameters (pm)
Wyckoff positions (WP)
Representative coordinates x, y, z of the 1st WP
Occupancy
Coordination polyhedron code
Average polyhedron radius (pm)
AET
cF24 Cu2Mg
Fd-3 m 227
a 699.0
8a 16d
0, 0, 0 5/8, 5/8, 5/8
Mg Cu
125.0, 46.0 125.0
293.0 268.5
16-a 12-a
hP12 MgZn2
P63/mmc 194
a 517.0 c 850.0
2a 4f 6h
0, 0, 0 1/3, 2/3, .063 0.830, 0.660, 1/4
Zn Mg Zn
125.0 125.0, 46.0 125.0
282.4 306.9 281.5
12-a 16-a 12-a
hP24 Ni2Mg
P63/mmc 194
a 480.5 c 1577.0
4e 4f(1) 4f(2) 6g 6h
0, 0, 0.094 1/3, 2/3, 0.844 1/3, 2/3, 0.125 1/2, 0, 0 0.167, 0.334, 1/4
Mg Mg Ni Ni Ni
125.0, 46.0 125.0, 46.0 125.0 125.0 125.0
285.3 285.3 261.3 261.4 261.4
16-a 16-a 12-a 12-a 12-a
180
Intermetallic Chemistry
A γTiCr2 (Ni2Mg type, 65–66 at.% Cr) form has also been described either as a high temperature phase (stable from 1270°C up to the melting point, 1370°C) or, probably, as a metastable phase occurring only in quenched samples. Typically, binary Laves compounds AM2 are formed in several systems of A metals such as alkaline earths, rare earths, actinides, Ti, Zr, Hf, etc., with M Al, Mg, VIII group metals, etc. Laves phases are formed also in several ternary systems either as solid solution fields extending from one binary phase (or possibly connecting the binary phases of two boundary systems) or as ‘true ternary’ phases, that is forming homogeneity fields not connected with the boundary systems. Examples of true ternary phases may be observed in systems such as Nb–Ni–Al, Ta–Ni–Al, where no Laves phases exist in any of the boundary binary systems and a MgZn2-type phase Ta(Ni,Al)2 (or Nb(Ni,Al)2) is formed within the composition range Ta(Ni1xAlx)2 (with 0.15 x 0.75). Laves phases: stability, occurrence. The importance of the geometrical factor in determining the stability of these phases has been pointed out (Pearson 1972). In a simplified description, Laves phases AM2 of the MgCu2 type may be presented as cubic face-centred packing of large spheres A which form tetrahedral holes that are occupied by tetrahedra of smaller spheres M. The ideal value of the radius ratio rA/rM is 1.225. The values experimentally observed for the various Laves types range from 1.05 to 1.7. The role of the electron concentration in controlling the differential stability of the different Laves phase types has also been suggested. By studying, for instance, solid solutions of Cu2Mg and MgZn2 with Ag, Al, Si (Laves and Witte 1936, Klee and Witte 1954), it was observed that for an average VEC (valence electron concentration) between 1.3 and 1.8 e/a (s, p, electrons per atom) the Cu2Mg structure is generally formed, and for VEC values in the range from 1.8 to 2.2 e/a, generally the MgZn2-type structure is obtained. The Ni2Mg type can be observed for intermediate values of VEC between 1.8 and 2.0. Notice, however, that such a simple correlation (or similar ones for transition metal Laves phases) is only valid for a restricted number of alloy systems. A systematic analysis of structure and stability of binary and ternary Laves phases, or Friauf–Laves phases, has been performed by Stein et al. (2004, 2005). By reviewing a large number of experimentally determined phase diagrams with Laves phases, a number of general conclusions have been obtained. These may be summarized in the following points: ●
If in a binary system, at a specific composition, both a cubic and a hexagonal Laves phase are formed, and then generally it is the Cu2Mg type which is stable at low temperature and the MgZn2 (or Ni2Mg) type at higher temperature.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases ●
●
●
181
If in a binary system, at a given temperature but different compositions, both a cubic and a hexagonal Laves phase are formed, then generally the Cu2Mg- type occurs around the stoichiometric composition and the other polytypes at offstoichiometric compositions. The hexagonal Ni2Mg-type phase generally occurs in a binary or ternary system as an additional phase together with a Cu2Mg and/or a MgZn2-type phase. Laves phases occurring in ternary systems, the binary subsystems of which contain no Laves phases, generally pertain to the hexagonal MgZn2-type structure.
Stein et al. (2005) observed also that, in binary and ternary systems, the homogeneity regions of different Laves phases are generally separated by two-phase fields which are very narrow and of difficult determination. Laves phases, stability, thermodynamics, thermodynamic modelling. A review of the data concerning the enthalpies of formation of binary Laves phases has been reported by Zhu et al. (2002) and subsequently commented by Chen et al. (2004). For the different main types of binary Laves phases, Zhu et al. (2002) reported the radius ratio of the involved metals, the axial ratio c/a of the hexagonal phases and the experimental data available (ΔH and ΔS of formation). According to their analysis, the examination of the experimental data indicate that both geometric and electronic factors are important in stabilizing Laves phases and that in these phases there are metallic, covalent and ionic bonds or a mixed metallic–covalent–ionic bond. They claimed, moreover, that the enthalpies of formation for binary transition metal lanthanide Laves phases as calculated by the semi-empirical Miedema model (see § 2.2.1.3) are found to be in good agreement with the available experimental data. In the paper however by Chen et al. (2004), objections were raised especially to the suggestion that the Miedema model is suitable for a quantitative prediction of the formation enthalpies of the Laves phases. It was observed that discrepancies in the order of 20–80 kJ/mole are common. As an alternative route, ab initio calculations based on density functional theory were suggested to provide accurate enthalpies of formation for Laves phases. As for the thermodynamic modelling of Laves phases, this has been successfully performed for several alloy systems. Especially using the sublattice model (see § 2.4.2.2) a number of phase diagrams containing Laves phases have been calculated taking into account homogeneity ranges and polytypism. A few details will be reported here giving special attention to the Cu2Mg type. According to an analysis performed by Ferro and Cacciamani (2002), the preferential site occupancies observed in MgCu2-type phases are summarized in Table 3.8. The atoms preferentially present in each site type are indicated.
Table 3.8. cF24-MgCu2 type Laves phases. (preferential site occupancies). Reference element
Atoms in the Wyckoff position 8a
Atoms in the Wyckoff position 16d
Cs,Rb,K Na Li Ba Sr Ca Yb Eu Sc Y Ln(III) An Zr Hf Ti Ta Nb
Cs,Rb,K Na Li Ba Sr Ca Yb Eu Sc Y Ln(III) An Zr Hf Ti Ta Nb
Bi Ag,Au,Pt Pt Al,Pd,Pt Al,Ir,Pd,Pt,Rh Al,Ni,Pd,Pt,Rh Al,Co,Fe,Ir,Ni,Pt,Rh Al,Ir,Ni,Pd,Pt,Rh Al,Co,Fe,Ir,Ni Al,Co,Fe,Ir,Mn,Pt,Rh Al,Co,Fe,Ir,Mg,Mn,Ni,Os,Pt,Rh,Ru Al,Co,Fe,Ir,Mn,Ni,Os,Pt,Rh,Ru,Zn Co,Cr,Fe,Ir,Mo,Ni,V,W,Zn Co,Cr,Fe,Mo,Ni,V,W,Zn Be,Co,Cr Be,Co,Cr,V Be,Co,Cr
V W Mo Cr Mn Fe Ru Os Co Rh Ir Ni Pt Pd Au Ag Cu Mg
Hf,Ta,Zr Hf,Zr Hf,Zr Hf, Nb,Ta,Ti,Zr An, Ln(III),Y An,Hf,Sc,Ln(III),Y,Yb,Zr An,Ln(III) An,Ln(III) An,Hf,Nb,Sc,Ta,Ti,Ln(III),Y,Yb,Zr An,Ca,Eu,Sr,Ln(III),Y,Yb An,Eu,Sc,Sr,Ln(III),Y,Yb,Zr An,Ca,Eu,Hf,Sc,Ln(III),Yb,Zr An,Ba,Ca,Eu,Li,Na,Sr,Ln(III),Y,Yb Ba,Ca,Eu,Sr Bi,Na,Pb Na Mg Ln(III)
V W Mo Cr Mn Fe Ru Os Co Rh Ir Ni Pt Pd Au Ag Cu Mg
Ag Cu Mg
Ag Cu Mg
Be Be Cu
Zn Be Al
An,Hf,Zr Ag,Cu,Nb,Ta,Ti An,Ba,Ca,Eu,Sc,Sr,Ln(III),Y
Zn Be Al
Pb Bi
Pb Bi
Au Au
Bi
Cs,K,Rb
Bi
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
183
For a number of elements, listed in the first column according to their chemical order, their MgCu2-type compounds are reported. (Ln(III) and An mean trivalent lanthanides and actinides, respectively). For all the compounds an indication is given of the preferential occupancy of the different Wyckoff Position (WP) by the metals involved. (for example Na preferentially occupies the Wyckoff Position 8a when combined with Ag, Au or Pt, that is in NaAg2, NaAu2 and NaPt2). It results that atoms belonging to the earlier groups of the Periodic Table and, more precisely from group 1 to the Nb group (including lanthanides, actinides and Pb), generally occupy the positions with higher coordination (that is, in MgCu2, the Wyckoff Position 8a with an environment coordination CNE 16). On the other hand, elements from V to Au and Zn, Be and Al prefer to occupy the lower coordination sites. A few atoms (Ag, Cu, Mg and Bi) are found to occupy either positions with CNE 12 or 16, depending on the partner element. In multi-component systems, elements preferentially occupying the same site are generally allowed to substitute each other forming more or less extended substitutional solid solutions. Similar considerations have been found to be valid for the hP12-MgZn2 and hP24-Ni2Mg structures. Only two different AET (see § 3.7.5) and, correspondingly, two different coordination polyhedra are present in each structure. Moreover, in the three structures the same 1:2 ratio is found between sites with coordination 16 and 12 and, finally, polyhedra with the same AET and the same average radius are preferentially occupied by the same element. A sublattice model suggested by this structure analysis is reported in Table 3.9 where sublattices are denoted by the symbols identifying the characteristic AET (16-a and 12-a in this case) and sorted according to the decreasing coordination. Sublattice ratios are determined by the ratio between the total multiplicities of the WPs included in each sublattice. This model can be considered as a crystallographic justification of the long time adopted model simply based on stoichiometric considerations. It is also in agreement with the analysis carried out by Ansara et al. (1997) who examined the same problem by a similar, although less general, approach. Stein et al. (2005) observed on the basis of their systematic analysis that the site occupancies in ternary Laves phases cannot be predicted simply from the atomic Table 3.9. A sublattice model suggested for the main Laves phase types. Sublattice model MgCu2 WPs included: MgZn2 WPs included: MgNi2 WPs included: WP means Wyckoff Position.
(16-a)1
(12-a)2
8a 4f 4e 4f(1)
16d 2a 6 h 4f(2) 6g 6h
184
Intermetallic Chemistry
dimensions; a comparison of the shape of the phase fields of several ternary Laves phases evidenced the role played by electronic factors. In conclusion to this paragraph we quote a paper by Yan et al. (2006), in which, by means of several experimental and theoretical techniques, a thorough study was performed on a ternary Laves phase alloy system and which is also a good example of the contemporary and complementary use of various investigation methods. The Ti(Fe1xAlx)2 Laves phase with the hP12-MgZn2 type structure was studied. X-ray and neutron diffraction were employed in order to establish the atom site distribution. The Rietveld refinement of the diffraction data revealed that Ti atoms occupy the 4f sites whilst Fe and Al atoms randomly share the 2a and 6 h sites. Ab-initio calculations for various compositions agree well with the experimentally defined site preferences and lattice parameters. Enthalpies of formation were obtained by a comparison of the heat effect obtained in an isoperibolic calorimeter by dropping samples of Al and of the alloys in a liquid bath of initially pure Al. The calculated enthalpy of formation and the magnetic phase diagram were in good agreement with experimental data. 3.9.3.2 Structures based on frameworks of fused polyhedra: Samson phases. In addition to the Frank–Kasper phases, other structures may be considered in which the same four types of coordination polyhedra prevail, although some regularity is lost. Many of these structures, and in particular the giant cell structures studied by Samson (1969) can be described as based on frameworks of fused polyhedra rather than on the fully interpenetrating polyhedra. Among the most important polyhedra, the truncated tetrahedron can be related to the CN 16 polyhedron (Friauf polyhedron). The two polyhedra can be transformed into each other by removing (adding) the 4 six-fold vertices of the CN 16 polyhedron, corresponding to positions out from the centre of each of the four hexagons of the truncated tetrahedron. Several other coordination polyhedra occur in giant cell structures in addition to the Frank–Kasper polyhedra and to the truncated tetrahedron. The most important are polyhedra corresponding to CN between 11 and 16. The following phases represent a few examples of structures to which the aforementioned considerations especially apply. cI58-α-Mn (a 891.4 pm) type structure (and its binary variants, cI58-Ti5Re24 or χ phase and cI58-γ-Mg17Al12), cF1124-Cu4Cd3 type (a 2587.1 pm); cF1192NaCd2 type (a 3056 pm); cF1832-Mg2Al3 (a 2823.9 pm), etc. In the giant cell structures partial disorder and/or partial occupancy in some atomic positions have generally been reported; for cF1124-Cu4Cd3, for instance, the structure was described as corresponding to the occupation, in several Wyckoff positions, of 388 atomic sites by Cd atoms, 528 by Cu atoms and of 208 by Cu and Cd atoms in substitutional disorder. For complex intermetallic structures and their description, see also the paragraphs (in Chapter 4) dedicated to clusters and cluster compounds.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
185
3.9.4 Recombination structures, intergrowth structure series Some of the previously reported relationships between structures may be included in the general term ‘recombination’ structures. Such a term (see Lima de Faria et al. 1990) can be considered when topologically simple parent structures are periodically divided into blocks, rods or slabs. It means that structure portions, which are finite or infinite in one or two dimensions, are recombined into derivative structures through one or more structure building operations. The most important operations are: unit cell twinning, intergrowth of blocks, rods or slabs of different structural types (for instance, intergrowth of cF24-MgCu2 type and hP6-CaCu5 type slabs to obtain the hP36-Ce2Ni7 type structure), periodic out of plane, anti-phase boundaries (AuCu(II), as an example), rotation of rods or blocks and crystallographic shear planes. For a definition and examples of crystallographic shear planes see § 7.6.4 and Fig. 7.54 where a number of TiO2 derivative structures are especially described. The frequency of structure building operators and, therefore, the size of undisturbed structure portions, can vary by well defined increments, so that many phases may occur as members of homologous series. A few considerations about possible schemes of relationships between inorganic crystal structures based on a systematic ‘construction’ of complex structural types by means of a few operations (symmetry operations, topological transformations) applied to some building units (point systems, clusters, rods, sheets), have been previously reported in § 3.9.1, following criteria suggested, for instance, by Hyde and Andersson (1989) and by Zvyagin (1993). Within the ‘recombination’ scheme, a very interesting method of describing, interpreting and interrelating complex structures is that based on the aforementioned ‘intergrowth’ concept (Kripyakevich et al. 1972, 1976, 1979, Grin’ et al. 1982, 1990, Parthé et al. 1985, Lima de Faria 1990, Pani and Fornasini 1990, Daams 1995). According to this concept, selected structure types can be considered as belonging to certain intergrowth structure series. The different structure types of an intergrowth series are described as being constructed from structure segments of more simple structures (the so-called parent structures). Said in another way, according to this approach the construction modules, instead of being defined on a mere geometrical basis, are selected with reference to specific crystallochemical criteria. To this end, groups (series) of similar complex structures are analysed in order to recognize ‘fragments’ which could be identified as structure segments of more simple structural types. The structure series are then classified according to the kind of fragments and the method of construction. On the basis of the kind of fragments the structure series is described as homogeneous or inhomogeneous: the homogeneous intergrowth structures consist of identical fragments; the inhomogeneous intergrowth structures consist of segments, differing in composition and/or coordination, belonging to
186
Intermetallic Chemistry
different parent structures. According to the method of construction, the intergrowth structure series can be classified into 1D (linear), and 2D or 3D series. In a linear series we have 1D stacking (along one direction) of 2D, infinite segments (slabs) of the parent structures. The different structures of a 2D intergrowth series, on the other hand, are built up by aggregations of several 1D fragments (infinite rods, columns). Finally, the structures of a 3D intergrowth series are constructed from (zero-dimensional, finite) parent structure blocks stacked in three dimensions. It has been pointed out (Grin’ 1992) that slicing the parent structure into segments can be done in different ways. When predicting the composition and symmetry for the members of a particular structure series, the segment to be used in that series should fulfil a number of requirements. The segments should contain certain symmetry elements (in a linear series, for instance, all the segments used for the description usually contain some symmetry elements, mostly parallel to the stacking direction, which are retained in any stacking sequence, and represent the ‘minimal symmetry’ of the series). The segment interfaces necessarily pass through atom centres. The composition of the segment is proportional to the stoichiometry of the parent structure: by addition it is possible to obtain the compositions of all possible structures of the series. The segments, moreover, selected from different parent structures, must have, at least, one topologically equal interface in order to make the intergrowth possible. Additional requirements are necessary when the atomic arrangement on the interface permits more than one possibility of intergrowing and when more complex (2D, 3D) series are studied. Considering, for instance, the particular case of the ‘linear intergrowth structure series’, many binary and ternary intermetallic phases can be considered members of those series, both homogeneous and inhomogeneous. A representative of a structure belonging to a linear inhomogeneous series is shown in Fig. 3.40. In this case, the parent structures are the oS8-CrB and oS12UPt2 types. The intergrowth structure presented is the oS28-W3CoB3 (or Y3Co3Ga) type. Its unit cell contains a segment arrangement corresponding to two repetitions of a sequence containing a UPt2 fragment followed by two CrB-type fragments. A simple code of this structure may be (2CrB1UPt2)2. Other members of the series have been described; for instance: 1CrB1UPt2 (corresponding to the oI10-W2CoB2 type); 3CrB1UPt2 (corresponding to the mS18-Y4Co4Ga type); (4CrB1UPt2)2 (corresponding to the oS44-Y5Co5Ga type). It is interesting to observe that many real representatives of this series may be found in the Y–Co–Ga system. This is considered an example of the fact that, often, several members of a certain intergrowth series have representatives in the
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
b
187
b a
c x=0
x=0 Cr x = 0.5
x = 0.5
z=0
z=0 Pt
B
U z = 0.5
z = 0.5
c b
x=0 W x = 0.5 x=0 Co x = 0.5 x=0 B x = 0.5
Figure 3.40. The oS28-W3CoB3 type structure as resulting from the intergrowth of the oS8-CrB and oS12-UPt2 types. Projections of two cells of each structure are shown: the values of the third coordinate (along the direction perpendicular to the drawing plane) are indicated. Typical blocks of the parent structures are marked in the resulting structure. The unit cell of this one contains twice a sequence formed by an UPt2 fragment together with two CrB-type fragments (2CrB1UPt2)2.
same binary and ternary alloy system. In the same system, or in chemically analogous systems, representatives of the parent structures may also be found. In the example reported, for instance, YCo has the CrB-type structure. The interest of a crystallochemical description based on the intergrowth concept is thus evident.
188
Intermetallic Chemistry
As a further simple example, we may mention the structure of the oS16NdNiGa2 type belonging to the series BaAl4-AlB2. Its unit cell contains indeed two BaAl4-type segments and two AlB2-type segments. The previously considered simple code will be (1BaAl4 1AlB2)2. Notice, however, that in a more complex and detailed notation, superscripted indexes may be added to the formulae of the segments in order to specify, for instance, their symmetry (Grin’ et al. 1982, Parthé et al. 1985). General compositional formulae are often used for representing a series (Grin’ 1992). MemnX5m3nY2n, for instance, may be the overall formula of a series consisting of intergrown CaCu5- and CeCo3B2-type slabs. (For the hP6-CaCu5 type and its ordered variant hP6-CeCo3B2 type structures, see § 3.8.5.) Members of this series are the following structure types: hP12-CeCo4B (corresponding, in the aforementioned formula, to m 1, n 1), hP18-Ce3Co11B4 (m 1, n 2), hP24Ce2Co7B3 (m 1, n 3), hP18-Nd3Ni13B2 (m 2, n 1) and hP30-Lu5Ni19B6 (m 2, n 3). We may notice, in this case too, the close chemical analogy among the alloy systems (rare earth, nickel or cobalt, borides) forming structures corresponding to the different members of a given series. Within the intergrowth concept several ternary compounds can be considered as the result of a chemical or structural ‘interaction’ between the binary compounds. This could be reflected also in some regularity in the characteristics of the equilibria and phase diagrams (trends of the tie-lines, for instance). An analysis of some formal aspects of the isothermal sections of several R–T–X systems (R rare earth metal, T transition metal, X Si,Ge) has been carried out by Morozkin and Seropegin (1996). A number of stoichiometries have been evidenced (such as RT2X2, RTX3, RTX2, RTX, R2TX3) frequently found in those systems. These compounds define the ‘main’ equilibria line on which they lay and which generally connect two binary compounds or one binary compound with the third component. In many cases this seems to be in agreement with the types of ‘interactions’ (recombination of structure fragments) deduced by crystallographic analyses and comparisons. More comments and examples on these points are reported in Chapter 7. Relevant comments on the concept of intergrowth and the underlying principles have been presented by Nesper (1991) in a review about bonding patterns in intermetallic compounds. It has been observed that this type of structure formation can be considered as an extension to one or two dimensions of structures with isolated clusters. Notice that this author, following the analysis and the treatment performed by Andersson (1983), names these arrangements ‘chemical twinning’. As a consequence, it is suggested that the building of complex structures could be described theoretically with two approximations. One of these must define the chemical bonding in the interior of the partial structure, while the other should consider the chemical bonding at the surfaces. An improvement of these concepts could be the
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
189
use of the ‘Atomic environments’ (see § 3.7.5) in the descriptions of the slabs because it would show more directly the relations between the combining slabs and the structures in the series (Daams 1995). 3.10. GROUP–SUBGROUP RELATIONS BETWEEN SPACE GROUPS FOR THE REPRESENTATION OF CRYSTAL–CHEMICAL RELATIONSHIPS
According to the presentation given by Bärnighausen (1980), if two structures are topologically equivalent, their interrelation can be conveniently expressed by group–subgroup relations between their space groups. Graphic representation of these relations leads to hierarchic ordering resembling a family tree. At the top of the tree there is the so-called aristotype (a highly symmetrical structure). From the aristotype the other structures of the tree may be derived along specific routes of symmetry reduction. In order to obtain a well-defined description, the symmetry reduction is presented in terms of minimal steps, that is, a given structure is followed by another whose space group is a so-called maximal subgroup (M) of the space group (G) of the former structure (see Hahn 2002). The minimal steps of symmetry reduction can be classified according to the following terms: Lattice equivalent (‘translationengleich’, abbreviation: t). M contains all the translations of G, the crystal class of M is of lower symmetry than that of G. Class equivalent (‘klassengleich’, abbreviation: k). M and G have the same crystal class but belong to different space-group types: M has lost translational symmetry, that is, the primitive cell corresponding to M is larger than that of G. Crystallographically equivalent (abbreviation: e). G and M belong to the same space group type, that is, as in the previous case, M has lost translational symmetry. The abbreviations t, k, e are generally accompanied by a number related to the symmetry reduction in the transformation. The structural relationship between diamond and sphalerite types (see § 7.4.2.3), for instance, may be described as– lattice equivalent, t, in the form: Diamond type (space group Fd3m, N. 227) : t2 : sphalerite type (space group – F4 3m, N. 216). Several examples concerning the inorganic crystallochemistry have been described by Bärnighausen (1980); among intermetallic phases, the structural relationship between NiAs and MnP types, between Rh5Ge3 and Ca5Sb3 and the order–disorder transition of MoNi4 are highlighted. As a further example of application of the Bärnighausen formalism, a number of ternary fluorite related phases in the systems Li–Pt–Sn (and Li–Pd–Sn) have been analysed and discussed by Hoffmann et al. (2003) on the basis of a group–subgroup
190
Intermetallic Chemistry
scheme. The cF16-Li2PtSn compound may be related to the binary BiF3 type (a filled CaF2 type), where Bi forms an face-centred cubic arrangement, and the two different fluorine sites occupy the tetrahedral and octahedral voids on 4b and 8c in – the space group Fm3m, respectively. In comparison with CaF2, the two Li atoms replace 4/8 of the fluorine positions in an ordered manner, with a consequent symmetry reduction. The structure becomes non-centro-symmetric in the space group – – F4 3m, a translationengleich subgroup of index 2 of the group Fm3m. A number of other ternary Li–Pt–Sn compounds adopt superstructures of the CaF2 type with the doubling of the three axes of the subcell. In the chemically similar system Li–Pd–In, the compound LiPdIn2 has a structure which is a ternary ordered variant of the BiF3 type.
3.11. QUASI-PERIODIC CRYSTALS
According to Yamamoto (1996) quasi-periodic structures belong to the following structure kinds: ●
●
●
Modulated structures, corresponding to substances in which there is an average structure with a three-dimensional periodicity showing modulated perturbations. Composite crystals, in which the structure can be described as resulting from two or more substructures (related to two or more sets of three dimensional lattices) having different periodicity along at least one direction (chimney-ladder structures, vernier structures, misfit-layer structures, etc.). See the scheme presented in Fig. 3.42. Quasicrystals, the diffraction patterns of which show non-crystallographic symmetry.
3.11.1 Modulated structures These structures are represented by substances in which some atomic parameter and/or the partial occupancy of some sites of the average structure vary periodically through the structure. The periodicity may or may not be commensurate with the unit cell of the basic structure; that is, the ratio between the repetition length of this parameter and the lattice constant may or may not correspond to the ratio between two integer numbers (commensurate and incommensurate modulated structures). Generally, the diffraction patterns of such substances present a group of prominent, strong reflections (main reflections), related to the 3D basic structure, accompanied by weak satellite reflections related to the weak perturbation from the average structure.
191
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
Different kinds of modulations can be considered: the displacive modulation is related to the shift of the atom position from the average structure; the occupational (or substitutional) modulation is related to the changes of the atomic occupation probability depending on the position. Generally, in alloys, displacive modulation is small but not negligible (Yamamoto 1996) whereas substitutional modulation often occurs. Several non-stoichiometric compounds present such modulations among which various binary and complex sulphides and tellurides, FeSx, Yb3–xS4, etc. Various modulated structures have also been considered, for instance, for the NiAs-type structure (see Chapter 7). An interesting case of magnetic modulated structure is that reported for EuCo2P2 (Reehuis et al. 1992). The positional structure of the atoms (of the atomic nuclei, nuclear structure) corresponds to the tI10-ThCr2Si2 type. A magnetic structure has also been determined, which is related to the ordering of the magnetic moments of the Eu atoms. These moments are oriented perpendicular to the c-axis and form an incommensurate spiral with the turning axis parallel to the c-axis. The magnetic moments lie in the basal planes and they order parallel within these planes. Along the c-axis, from one basal plane to the next one, there is a periodic rotation of the moments. The ratio, along the c-axis, of the characteristic lengths of the magnetic and nuclear structures is slightly dependent on temperature. At 64 K it is close to 5/6 (that is: there are 5 translation lengths of the magnetic cell for 6 translation lengths of the nuclear structures). At 15 K the ratio was found to be close to 6/7. If this magnetic structure is maintained at still lower temperatures, it may correspond to the exact 6/7 value. The ground state may then be called a commensurate structure with this ratio. A special case of long-period structure to be considered is the oI40-AuCu(II) type structure which has 1D substitutional and displacive modulations (Fig. 3.41). We must first mention that ordering of the Au–Cu face-centred cubic (cF4-Cu type) solid solution, having a 50–50 atomic composition, re-distributes Cu and Au atoms
c at b
Figure 3.41. The oI40-AuCu(II) structure. This superstructure contains 10, slightly distorted, tP4-AuCu( I) pseudo-cells. The long-period ordering corresponds to a periodic shift of the structure (every five cells along the orthorhombic b-axis) by 1⁄2 (at c) in the at, c plane. The anti-phase domain contains 5 AuCu(I) pseudo-cells.
192
Intermetallic Chemistry
alternatively on two layers, resulting in a tetragonal structure, tP2-AuCu(I) with the c-axis perpendicular to the layers (see Chapter 7). The more complex structure, oP40-AuCu(II) type, is obtained by a long-period ordering which results in an orthorhombic cell containing 10 slightly distorted AuCu(I) pseudo-cells. This ordering corresponds to a periodic shift (every five cells along the orthorhombic baxis) of the structure by: 1⁄2(at c) in the at, c plane. That is, by shifting a group of five cells along the direction of the diagonal, by a half diagonal step. This out-of-step shift corresponds to a so-called anti-phase boundary. An anti-phase domain may correspondingly be defined; in this case it contains five AuCu(I) type pseudo-cells. This structure, therefore, is an example of a commensurate modulated structure with a 1D modulation. Several examples of 1D long-period structures found in 1:1 and 1:3 alloys and of 2D long-period structures (characterized by two different domain periods and two-step shifts) found in 1:3 alloys have been presented by Pearson (1972); the role of the valence electron concentration in defining the superstructure period has also been discussed. A general presentation of several antiphase boundaries, not only planar, but also cylindrical, and related structure groups may be found in the book by Hyde and Andersson (1989). Long-period structures in A3B alloys (like TiAl3, Ag3Mg, PdCu3) have been studied by Selke (1989) and compared with the Axial Next Nearest Neighbour Ising (ANNNI) model. Anti-phase domain boundaries play an important role in phase changes and microstructural stability of ordered alloys and intermetallics also affecting mechanical behaviour. The origin of anti-phase domain boundaries has been examined and discussed by Morris (1992). Emphasis has been given to the differences between a sharp boundary, as produced by crystal shear, and a relaxed fault structure. The kinetics of relaxation of a shear produced fault have been examined and it was shown by Morris (1992) that fast relaxation may affect the movement of dislocations by creating locking stresses as well as affecting cross slip behaviour which in turn has a significant effect on mechanical properties. An important point in this study, as far as the origin of the anti-phase domain boundaries are concerned, is the principle that a disordered crystal exists initially, which subsequently becomes ordered. According to Cahn (1987), the observation of grown-in domain network is proof that the material existed, even if momentarily, in a disordered crystalline state before becoming ordered. In agreement with this, domain networks are commonly observed in weakly ordered alloys, for example AuCu3, FeNi3 and sometimes FeAl, but not in strongly ordered intermetallics such as Ni3Al and TiAl. A review on the interactions of ordering and recrystallization has been published by Cahn (1990), and a more specific study on the morphology of the anti-phase domains during recrystallization of heavily rolled AuCu3 by Yang et al. (1996). Aspects of recovery and recrystallization in the L12 (Co0.78V0.22)3V ordered alloy have been reported by Gialanella and Cahn (1993).
193
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases 1
1+2
2
Figure 3.42. Schematic representation of a double layer composite structure. Two substructures (1 and 2) are sketched. The composite structure (1 2) resulting from the mutual intermingling of the two substructures has a period corresponding to six subcells 1 commensurate to seven subcells 2.
3.11.2 Composite crystals A group of crystals show diffraction patterns in which two or more 3D lattices having periods commensurate or incommensurate to each other may be recognized. In other words, the crystal consists of two or more interpenetrating substructures (two or more different atom sets) with different periods at least along one direction (see Fig. 3.42). Names such as composite crystals, vernier structures, misfit-layer structures, and chimney-ladder structures have been used for this group of structures. 3.11.2.1 Nowotny phases, chimney-ladder structures. The Nowotny chimneyladder phases are an example in alloy field chemistry of composite structures. They are a series of intermetallic TnXm compounds formed by transition metals T from the 4th to 9th groups with p-block elements X from the 13th to the 15th groups. In these phases, the unit cell (superstructure cell, super-cell) contains along the c-axis n pseudo-cells of T atoms and m interpenetrating pseudo-cells of X atoms. These phases (Nowotny phases) have been called chimney-ladder phases because they contain rows of atoms X (the ‘ladder’), with variable interatomic spacing from one compound to another, which are inserted into channels (‘chimneys’) in the T array. The T metals in all of the superstructures form a β-Sn-like array (see Chapter 7) with the number of T metal atoms in the formula of the compound corresponding to the number of β-Sn-like pseudo-cells stacked in the c direction of the super-cell. The arrangement of the atoms in these phases can be compared to that found in the structure of TiSi2. The following is a list of some chimney-ladder phases (more complex phases containing as many as 600 atoms in the unit cell have been described). – tP20 Ru2Sn3 (space group P4 c2, a 617.2 pm, c 991.5 pm, c/(2a2) 0.568). The Ru atoms form a β-Sn-like array with two pseudo-cells along the c direction of the super-cell.
194
Intermetallic Chemistry
– tP32-Ir3Ga5 (space group P4 n2, a 582.3 pm, c 1420 pm, c/(3a2) 0.575) – tP36-Ir4Ge5 (space group P4 c2, a 561.5 pm, c 1831 pm, c/(4a2) 0.576) – tP120-Mn11Si19 (space group P4n2, a 552.0 pm, c 4820 pm, c/(11a2) 0.561 – tI156-Rh17Ge22 (space group I4 2d, a 560.4 pm, c 7845 pm , c/(17a2) 0.587 – tP192-V17Ge31 (space group, P4n2, a 591 pm, c 8365 pm, c/(17a2) 0.589). In V17Ge31, for instance, there are 17 β -Sn like pseudo-cells of V atoms and 31 Ge pseudo-cells stacked along the c-axis. Examples of the atomic arrangements in a few chimney-ladder phases are shown in Fig. 3.43 and compared with that found in TiSi2. This compound has an orthorhombic cell oF24-TiSi2 type with a0 826.7 pm, b0 480.0 pm, c0 855.1 pm. It can, however, be approximately described in terms of a smaller bodycentred tetragonal pseudo-cell, shown in Fig. 3.43 (a) having: a⬘ a0/2 c0/2; c⬘ b0 and c /a0 0.58, close to the ‘ideal’ value 1/3 0.577… More recently the structural characteristics of this family of compounds have been thoroughly analysed and discussed by Hoffmann and co-workers (Fredrickson et al. 2004a, b). In a number of papers a brilliant presentation of the Nowotny structures is given beginning with figures such as that shown in Fig. 3.44 which is also used to underline ‘the intriguing and beautiful structural features of these phases’ characterized by ‘a helix within a helix’. It may indeed be noticed that the transition metals form four-fold helices (in the shape of chimneys), inside of which the X metals form separate helices: see the three-fold helix of the X atoms in the Ru2Sn3-type structure, as an example. Two empirical rules, moreover, have been enunciated. The first rule concerns the number of valence electrons: for the Nowotny, TnXm, phases formed by the late transition metals, it is that the total number of valence electrons per T atom is 14. With reference to previously cited phases we have, for instance: Valence electron number per T atom (2 8 3 4)/2 14 Ru2Sn3 (4 9 5 4)/4 14 Ir4Ge5 (10 9 17 3)/10 14.1 Rh10Ga17 (11 7 19 4)/11 13.9 Mn11Si19 (17 9 22 4)/17 14.2 Rh17Ge22 (1 8 2 3)/1 14 OsGa2 The fact that the electron concentration appears to play some role in the control of this family of structures was noted by Nowotny (Schwomma et al. 1964a, b, Jeitschko and Parthé 1967, Flieher et al. 1968a, b, Parthé 1969) and reported by Pearson (1972). The second rule, discernible in the electron diffraction of the TnXm Nowotny chimney-ladder phases, is the appearance, along the c-axis of a
195
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
(a) TiSi2
(b) Ru2Sn3
(c) Mn11Si19
(d) Rh17Ge22
Figure 3.43. Examples of chimney-ladder structures (b)–(d) and the reference oF24-TiSi2 type structure (a) presented in terms of a tetragonal pseudo-cell (12 atoms in the pseudo-cell). Notice that the metal atoms (black circles) form sequences of βSn like cells.
196
Intermetallic Chemistry
c cn
cm
Figure 3.44. Views, according to Fredrickson et al. (2004a, b), of the Ru2Sn3 structure type, an example of the chimney-ladder Nowotny phases. On the left, a lateral view of the Ru helix (black balls) and of the Sn helix (white balls). The periods of the two helices (cn and cm) are given together with the lattice parameter c.
pseudo-periodicity with a spacing cps which is directly related to the stoichiometry and to the lattice parameter c by the relation: c (2n m)cps In short the TnXm Nowotny chimney-ladder phases are viewed as twinned structures consisting of building blocks of the ‘RuGa2’ type of thickness cps/2 with the successive layers rotated relative to each other by 90°. To complete this description, at the interfaces between layers the deletion of sterically encumbered X atoms was considered. The creation of more interfaces reduces therefore the ratio of the X to T atoms in the different Nowotny phases. According to Fredrickson et al. (2004a, b) this is controlled by the 14 electron rule. A theoretical explanation for these rules was also given in the mentioned papers and the connection discussed with electron number rules of organo-metallic complexes. A description of the Nowotny chimney-ladder phases in terms of slab stacking had been proposed by different authors. Grin (1986) showed that structures and space group symmetries of the phases of this family may be accounted for, considering, along c, linear combinations of T2X2, T2X4 and T3X4 layers.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
197
In the book by Hyde and Andersson (1989), the Nowotny phases are presented as a special case of a group of ‘1D, columnar misfit structures’ which also include compounds such as Bam(Fe2S4)n and other complex sulphides. Layer misfit structures, such as those of some oxide-fluorides, arseno-sulphides, etc., are also presented and classified with reference to a concept of structure commensurability based on the recognition that (along one or more axes) the ratios between the different repeat units of various interpenetrating substructures can (or cannot) be represented as ratios between integer numbers. 3.11.2.2 Combination of commensurate and incommensurate periodic ‘substructures’. An example of non-periodic sequence is obtained by superimposing two periodic 1D sequences having incommensurate periods; for instance, following Giacovazzo et al. (1992), a sequence A, having period a, and the sequence T, having period aτ/2, where τ is defined as τ (1 5)/2 1.6180339… (τ, an irrational number, is the solution of the equation τ 1 1/τ; τ 1 is the ‘golden’ section of the unit. The number τ is also associated with the geometries of pentagon and icosahedron: It is: τ 2 cos(π/5)). The resulting (A T) sequence is perfectly ordered (its diffraction pattern would be built by ‘peaks’) but it is not periodic (the two periods a and aτ/2 are incommensurate) (See Fig. 3.45). Approximations to this composite structure may be built considering the representation of τ through a continuous infinite fraction: τ = 1+
1 1+
1 1+
1 1+
1 1+ ----------
According to this formula, successive approximations of τ are: τ0 1, τ1 2, τ2 3/2, τ3 5/3, τ4 8/5, etc. (In these different fractions, in the numerator and in the denominator, we have the subsequent ‘Fibonacci numbers F’ defined as 1, 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13, 21, … Fn Fn1 Fn2. We have: Lim (n : ) Fn/Fn1 τ.) By substituting in the sequence T (having period aτ/2) the values: τ0, τ1, τ2, etc., we obtain the periodic structures T0 (period a/2), T1 (period a), T2(period a3/4), T3 (period a5/6), T4 (period a8/10), etc. These structures superimposed to (combined with) structure A give rise to a series of (periodic, commensurate) approximants of
198
Intermetallic Chemistry A + T0 A + T1 A + T2 A + T3
A + T∞
A
T
Figure 3.45. A Ti composite structures. The period of A is ‘a’ and that of Ti is ‘t’. The t/a is approximated by 1⁄2 for A T0, 1 for A T1, 3⁄4 for A T2, 5⁄6 for A T3 and is τ/2 (0.809017.....) for A T. The ‘structures’ A T0, A T1, A T2, … etc., are approximants of the quasiperiodic structure A T.
the non-periodic incommensurate A T structure (see Fig. 3.45); notice that better periodic approximations of a periodic structure may be obtained by higherorder approximants. By using slightly different words, approximants are translationally normal crystal compounds generally with large unit cells that contain condensed, highly symmetric building blocks such as dodecahedra and icosahedra and have compositions close to those of related quasicrystals. 3.11.3 Quasicrystals In a famous paper by Shechtman et al. (1984) electron diffraction patterns were shown of rapidly quenched and solidified aluminium-manganese alloys. Sharp diffraction peaks, suggesting long-range translational order, were observed with the presence however of five-fold symmetry (that is of a non-crystallographic symmetry see § 3.6.1.1). By different orientation of the specimen five-fold axes (in 6 directions), three-fold axes (in 10 directions) and two-fold axes (in 15 directions) were identified; with the subsequent observation of the existence also of an—inversion centre the assignment of this phase to the icosahedral point group, m35, was defined.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
199
Figure 3.46. A non-crystallographic sphere packing with five-fold symmetry.
Later, in several alloy systems, a large number of phases showing noncrystallographic symmetries were discovered. Besides the icosahedral ones, phases have been observed with diffraction symmetries 8/mmm (octagonal phases), 10/mmm (decagonal phases) and 12/mmm (dodecagonal phases). Compare with the definitions given in § 3.6.1.1 and notice that the same criteria are used to build these symmetry symbols. As for a general classification of all crystalline and noncrystalline 2D and 3D point groups see Hahn (2002). According to some comments included in a systematic structural description by Wells (1970) (one of the forerunners), an interesting example of a sphere packing with five-fold symmetry is shown in Fig. 3.46. This may be the model of a 3D packing possessing a unique five-fold axis. This can be described as obtained by the superimposition (with their five-fold axes coincident) of layers, of an indefinite bi-dimensional extension, formed by concentric pentagons alternatively having even or odd numbers of spheres along their sides. This packing is periodic only in one dimension, in the direction coincident with the five-fold axis. Its density is only slightly lower than that of the closest packing: the space-filling parameter is 0.7236 in comparison with the value 0.7405 of the close-packed structure (see § 4.3.2.5). 2D examples of quasi-periodic structures are shown in Figs 3.47 and 3.48. They are based on two kinds of rhombi with equal sides which have to be fitted together according to a ‘matching rule’. The first is a representation of a ‘Penrose tiling’ built up by rhombi having angles of 72° (360°/5) and 108°, and respectively of
200
Intermetallic Chemistry
Figure 3.47. Example of Penrose tiling. A few years before the discovery of quasicrystals the mathematician R. Penrose showed that if two shapes of tiles are allowed, tiling can be made which is nearly periodic and shows almost five-fold symmetry. This example is based on two kinds of rhombi with equal sides (with angles of 72° and 108° and respectively 36° and 144°) which have to be fitted together according to a ‘matching rule’: the arrows indicated on the edges of the single rhomb when fitting the rhombi together must be of the same kind (single or double) and in the same direction.
36° and 144°. The second figure is a tiling model of an octagonal phase. It is constructed by rhombi having angles of 45° (360°/8) and 135° and squares. In concluding this section in which some properties of modulated structures and of quasicrystals have been considered, we underline that the characteristics of these two types of structures do not coincide. Incommensurately modulated structures show main and satellite diffractions, an ‘average structure’ and crystallographic point symmetry. The quasicrystals have no average structure, non-crystallographic point symmetry, and give one kind of diffraction only. 3.11.3.1 Notes on the crystallography of quasi-periodic structures. A general way to face the problems related to the interpretation of quasi-periodic structures (modulated structures, quasicrystals) is based on the introduction and application of higher-dimensional crystallography (de Wolff 1974, 1977, Janner and Janssen 1980, Yamamoto 1982, 1996, Steurer 1995).
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
201
Figure 3.48. Example of a bi-dimensional quasicrystal lattice obtained from squares and rhombi (with angles of 45° and 135°).
A modulated crystal does not have a 3D lattice periodicity: its Euclidean symmetry is not represented by a 3D space group. It is possible, however, to obtain a space-group symmetry by building a periodic structure in a higher-dimensional space, (3 d)D, such that a 3D section of it may correspond to the crystal under consideration (Janner and Janssen 1980). The higher-dimensional space is the superspace and its periodic structure is the supercrystal. The additional d dimensions define the so-called internal space (generally indeed they correspond to internal degrees of freedom as the phase of the modulation). The 3D subspace is called position space or external space (the positions in the modulated crystal are defined in this space). The (3 d)D space groups coherent with the role of the position space (admitted groups) are called the superspace groups. The relation between a higher-dimensional periodic structure and a lower-dimensional non-periodic structure can be illustrated by an example of projection from a higher-dimensional space. Fig. 3.49 shows the projection from a 2D square lattice to obtain a 1D nonperiodic structure. A number of commensurate and incommensurate modulated structures have been analysed in terms of 4D crystallography, starting with Van Aalst et al. (1976). The structures of the commensurate composite crystals BaxFe2S4 (x 10/9 and 9/8) have also been refined by using a 4D formalism (Onoda and Kato 1991) by using single-crystal diffraction data. Similarly the anti-phase domain structure of AuCu II (previously described, see § 3.11.1 and Fig. 3.41) has been analysed (Yamamoto 1982) on the basis of a 4D space group, regarding the structure as having a 1D (density and displacive) modulation. The same approach was followed in
202
Intermetallic Chemistry W
XII
X⊥
Figure 3.49. Projection from a 2D periodic square lattice to obtain (on XII) a 1D non-periodic crystal. The projection space XII is inclined with an irrational slope (1/τ) to the square lattice axes. The window W (the strip) parallel to XII is chosen so that a structure with a physically reasonable density is obtained (Kelton 1995). The points contained in the ‘window’ are projected.
the analysis of polytypes of SiC and ZnS, regarded as modulated structures, the symmetry of which was described by a space group in 4D space (a 4D space group was considered including, as a subgroup, the 3D space group of the polytype under consideration). A more complex example may be represented by TaSe2: its modification called 2H-TaSe2 is hexagonal (space group P63/mmc, with two formula units in the unit cell). This layered compound shows a displacive 2D modulation (defined by two vectors); its symmetry may be therefore described in terms of a supergroup in a 5D superspace (Janner and Janssen 1980). A general point is therefore denoted by the 5 parameters x, y, z, t, u, and a position vector by the five components xa yb zc td ue of the superspace, with a, b, c basis in the ‘position space’ and d and e in the ‘internal subspace’. As far as quasicrystals are concerned, an important and numerous group of these substances is represented by those quasi-periodically ordered in two dimensions forming layers periodically stacked in the 3rd direction. According to their diffraction symmetries, octagonal, decagonal and dodecagonal quasicrystals have been described. In these cases too, the embedding of their structures in higher-dimensional space resulted in a more compact and ‘economical’ description. The structure solution in 5D space (3 2 order parameters) of the decagonal Co6.7Ni22.7 Al70.6 has been reported by Cervellino and Steurer (2002). It has been found that the atoms fill the space forming recurrent structure motifs, the spatial arrangement of
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
203
which is perfectly quasi-periodic. A summary has also been given of the different Al-rich Co–Ni–Al phases and a comparative analysis of the different structural models proposed for the decagonal phase by different authors. Several icosahedral quasicrystals have been described: the indexing of their diffraction patterns is conveniently done, in a 6D representation, in terms of six unit vectors, which can be defined in terms of the three unit vectors of the external space, and three of the internal space. A list of relevant space super groups with highest symmetries has been reported by Yamamoto (1996) for 5D and 6D spaces. For the 5D space, the octagonal (primitive, P, and body centred, I), the decagonal (only primitive lattice exists) and the dodecagonal (only primitive) space groups are shown (examples are P8/mmm, I8/mmm, P10/mmm, P12/mmm). For the 6D space, the icosahedral space groups are reported which are subdivided among three lattice types (primitive, P, body centred, I, and face centred, F): typical examples may be P235, I235, F235. In the same paper (Yamamoto 1996) an authoritative description is given of several interrelated topics such as: super-space group determination, structure determination, indexing of diffraction patterns of quasicrystals, polygonal tiling, icosahedral tiling, structure factor calculation, description of quasicrystal structures, cluster models of quasicrystals. 3.11.3.2 Types of quasicrystals and examples of alloy systems showing their formation. A short description of the main types of quasicrystals and of their occurrence is given here below (Kelton 1995, Steurer 1996). Decagonal quasicrystals. Their structures can generally be described in terms of columnar clusters quasi-periodically packed. The clusters are periodic along the ten-fold axis with a translation period of 400 pm (or a multiple up to 3600 pm) and a layered structure corresponding to the stacking of flat or puckered atomic layers having a thickness of 200 pm. According to Steurer (1996) three principal decagonal types may be considered: deca Al–Co–Cu, deca Al–Mn and deca Al– Fe–Pd types. Deca Al–Co–Cu type, found in the stable phases Co15Cu20Al65, Rh15Ni15Al70, Co15Ni15Al70, etc. has a two layer structure with a translation period (c) of about 400 pm (In the space group P105/mmc for d-Co15Ni15Al70 c 408.1 pm and, for d-Co15Cu20Al65 c 414.8 pm). A related crystal (approximant) structure is that of the monoclinic mS93-Co4Al13. Deca Al–Mn type, found in the metastable phase Mn22Al78, in the Pd-stabilized Mn16.5Pd13Al70.5, and in Cu20Cr7Fe8Al65 has a translational period along the 10-fold axis in the order of 1200 pm (for d-Mn16.5Pd13Al70.5, space group P105/mmc, c 1240 pm). Approximant structures are those of MnAl3 and of μ –MnAl4.12
204
Intermetallic Chemistry
(MnAl3 oP160-MnAl3 type is orthorhombic, space group Pnma, a 1480 pm, b 1240 pm, c 1260 pm). Deca Al-Fe-Pd type has been observed in the stable phases T10Pd10Al80 (T Fe,Ru,Os). It shows a translational periodicity along the 10-fold axis of 1600 pm; the crystalline approximant structure is the Fe4Al13 type. Dodecagonal quasicrystals. Dodecagonal, generally metastable phases have been observed in Cr71Ni29, V3Ni2 alloys and similar systems. The translational period along the 12-fold axis is in the order of 450 pm. These structures are closely related to that of the tP30–σCrFe phase. Icosahedral quasicrystals. Many icosahedral phases (both stable and metastable) have been identified in several systems, mainly Al-based but also Mgbased, Ti-based, etc. According to Steurer (1996) two main groups of icosahedral quasicrystals can be considered. Icosahedral Al–Mn type with a quasi-lattice constant of about 460 pm and a concentration of free electrons of about 1.75 electrons per atom. Phases pertaining to this type are, for instance, Cr15Al85, Mn14Al86, Cr19Al62Si19, Cr15Cu20Al65. As further examples, we may mention Mn21Al73Si6 (described with a primitive hypercu–– bic cell, in the 6D super-space group Pm35 with ar 460 pm) and Fe15Cu20 Al65 (with a face-centred hypercubic unit cell, ar 445 pm, in the super-space–– group Fm35). Icosahedral Al–Mg–Zn type with a quasi-lattice constant of about 520 pm and a concentration of free electrons of about 2.1 electrons per atom. Examples are –– represented by Li3CuAl6 (ar 504 pm, super-space-group Pm35), Li3AuAl6, Pd13Mg44Al43, CuMg4Al6, Mg32Zn52Ga16, Y–Mg–Zn and Y–Zr–Mg–Zn alloys, etc. 3.11.3.3 Structural relations between quasicrystals and other intermetallic phases. As discussed in several sections of the review published by Kelton (1995) on quasicrystals and related structures, numerous studies and observations indicate structural similarities between non-periodic quasicrystal phases with crystalline phases and also, on the other hand, with amorphous, glassy and liquid phases. Crystal approximants. Several crystalline phases contain more or less closely packed atomic assemblies (polyhedra, clusters) which have been considered fundamental constituents of several quasicrystals, metal glasses and liquids. Such crystalline phases (crystal approximants), as reported in the previous paragraph, are often observed in the same (or similar) systems, as those corresponding to the formation of quasicrystals and under similar preparation conditions. Crystalline phases closely related to the quasicrystals (containing similar building blocks) have generally complex structures; as approximants to the ico-quasicrystals we may, for instance, mention the Frank–Kasper phases (previously described in § 3.9.3.1).
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
205
These are typically found in transition metal alloys with smaller atoms generally in icosahedral sites and the larger ones in non-icosahedral coordination. Among the polyhedral clusters found in related structures a fundamental one is the so-called Mackay cluster formed by 54 atoms, and consisting (in ico-Al–Mn quasicrystals) of an inner icosahedron of 12 Al atoms, with a vacant centre, surrounded by a double-sized icosahedron with Mn in the 12 vertices and 30 Al atoms located slightly out of the middle of the Mn icosahedron edges. The mentioned considerations have been more recently underlined by Lin and Corbett (2003). They observed that to date there is still no general set of rules for predicting which alloys, and which compositions, are prone to form quasicrystals. They observed, however, that in the search for new icosahedral quasicrystals a sound reference is found in the known quasicrystals plus their presumed approximants. These are generally normal crystalline compounds with large unit cells containing highly symmetric building blocks (icosahedral, dodecahedral) having compositions close to those of quasicrystals and useful for modelling the quasicrystal structure. They, moreover, underline, that, for instance, alkaline metal compounds with Ga, In, Tl contain several examples of building blocks related to icosahedra (isolated, centred, interbridged, fused) and may represent another route to the exploration for new quasicrystals, also considering substitution by better network-forming cations such as Mg, Ca, Zn, Cd, etc. (considered among the so-called ‘icosogen metals’). An interesting example of such relations is found in the binary ytterbiumcadmium system, where the first stable binary quasicrystal was identified (Tsai et al. 2000). As a reference point, the phase diagram of these alloys is shown in Fig. 3.50. This was determined by Palenzona (1971). Several compounds exist in this system, especially in the Cd-rich region; among them a congruently melting phase with an approximate formula YbCd5.7 (that is about 85.1 at.% Cd) was identified; its crystal structure was not determined, only an indication was obtained of a complex structure with a large unit cell. In this system the Cd-richest phase is YbCd6 (that is a phase with the composition of 85.71 at.% Cd very close to the previous one). This one to six stoichiometry is observed in nearly all the alloy systems of Cd with the rare earth metals (R). Even higher Cd/R atomic ratios however are present in the compounds of the light lanthanides such as LaCd11, La2Cd17, CeCd11, etc. A complex structure was described for the RCd6 phases and reported as YCd6-cI184(168) or YbCd6-cI176(168). In a reassessment of the isostructural compound CeCd6, the composition Ce6Cd37 (86.05 at.% Cd) was proposed and a structure Ce6Cd37cP188(172) type suggested (Armbrüster and Lidin 2000). All these types correspond to similar descriptions of the structure which cannot be easily represented in terms of isolated polyhedra, but is better described in terms of successive polyhedral shells. It was therefore realized (Tsai et al. 2000) that YbCd6 could be what in the jargon of quasi-crystallography is called an approximant and (considering also
206
Intermetallic Chemistry
the various stable quasicrystals found in R–Mg–Cd systems) that the very close YbCd5.7 was an excellent candidate for a quasicrystal. A preparation of samples of these alloys and their examination (electron microscopy, X-ray diffraction) confirmed that this stable congruently melting phase is a quasicrystal with 3D icosahedral symmetry. Structural relations with liquid and glasses. Several observations suggest the existence of a structural similarity between liquid and glasses and quasicrystals especially the icosahedral ones (Kelton 1995). The so-called total and partial radial distribution functions, describing the atomic pair correlations in the structure, constructed for metallic glasses (see § 3.12.1) and icosahedral phases show common characteristics. It has been underlined that, in certain alloy systems, depending on the cooling rate from the liquid, different phases may be obtained. For a low cooling rate it is possible to have crystallization, that is to have a 3D ordered periodic array, even giving rise to complex crystalline phases (Frank–Kasper phases for instance). If the cooling rate is too rapid, the various atomic substructures may become entangled and produce a glass. If the cooling is at an intermediate rate, it is possible to maintain, from the under-cooled liquid, a long-range icosahedral order, without obtaining the crystalline order. 3.12. AMORPHOUS ALLOYS, METALLIC GLASSES
Among the different solid phases which may be observed in metallic systems, an interesting group is represented by the amorphous alloys or glassy alloys. 819
796
800
703
462 400
Yb
20
40
60 at.% Cd
80
∼YbCd6
200
Yb3Cd8 Yb14Cd51 YbCd5.7
321 αYbCd2
Temperature (°C)
655 636 600
Cd
Figure 3.50. The Yb–Cd binary phase diagram. The congruently melting compound YbCd57 is the first stable binary quasicrystal identified.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
207
Authoritative reviews on this subject have been published by Buschow (1984) and Cahn and Greer (1996). These alloys can be defined as solids lacking long-range 3D atomic periodicity. When subjected to diffraction experiments (X-ray, neutron or electron diffraction) these alloys generally show a small number of diffuse holes with the absence of sharp peaks. The thermodynamic formation functions (Δf H, Δf G) of amorphous alloys are less negative than those of the crystalline alloys of the same composition; they are metastable and tend to transform into the stable crystal phases, either directly or via metastable crystalline phases. The crystallization kinetics, however, is often very sluggish, so several metastable alloys may be kept for an indefinite time even at temperatures substantially higher than room temperature. An indication of this behaviour can be obtained from the TTT (time–temperature–transformation) diagrams such as that shown in Fig. 3.51. In this figure a complete TTT diagram (described by Löffler 2003) is shown for a bulk metallic glass (Pd40Ni10Cu30P20). The typical ‘C’ shape of the diagram is due to the fact that the thermodynamic driving force for crystallization increases with increasing under-cooling, while the atomic mobility in the liquid decreases. Basically, indeed, a glass (either metallic or of a different nature) may be considered a ‘frozen’ liquid. In order to obtain a glass, crystallization must be avoided on cooling. This may be achieved by quenching.
Temperature (°C)
550 460
Tliq = 550°C
440 420 N
400 380 360 340
Tg = 310°C
320 300 0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Time (s)
Figure 3.51. TTT diagram of the bulk metallic glass Pd40Ni10Cu30P20 (adapted from Löffler 2003). Tliq: melting temperature; Tg: glass temperature. Crystallization of the alloy will occur if, during the cooling from Tliq, the T/t curve passes through the shaded area. The position of the ‘nose’ (N) in the diagram determines the ‘critical cooling rate’ to be used in order to obtain the glass (to avoid crystallization).
208
Intermetallic Chemistry
The so-called glass transition temperature, Tg, must be considered: below this temperature the liquid configuration is frozen in a structure corresponding to equilibrium at Tg. Around Tg a rather abrupt change is observed of several properties as a function of temperature (viscosity, diffusion, molar volume). Above Tg, for instance, viscosity shows a strong temperature dependence; below Tg only a rather weak temperature dependence is observed, approximately similar to that of crystal. Notice that Tg is not a thermodynamically defined temperature: its value is determined by kinetic considerations; it also depends on the quenching rate. Several rapid or very rapid quenching techniques have been devised: an outline of several methods of liquid quenching and of other related techniques (vapour quenching, solid-state amorphization processes, etc.) is given in Chapter 6. Starting from the first experiments made by Duwez and co-workers (Klements et al. 1960) by using a variety of methods and investigating several types of alloys, new glassforming compositions have been found that have small critical cooling rates (less than 100 K/s) and can be obtained in the glassy state in dimensions of several centimetres (see Fig. 3.52). These ‘bulk metallic glasses’ are also of increasing importance for technological applications: the relevant mechanical properties of these materials (high-strength materials) are promising for applications as are those based on the superior magnetic properties of magnetic glasses.
Critical casting thickness (cm)
102 101
9 5
8
1
6 7 4
3
10−1 10−2
10
2
1
10−3 1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
2010
Year
Figure 3.52. Historical development of metallic glasses and of their maximum preparation thickness (adapted from Löffler 2003). 1: Au–Si, 2: Pd–Cu–Si, 3: Fe–Pd–P, 4: Au–Pb–Sb, 5: Ni–Pd–P, 6: La–Ni–Al, 7: Y–Cu–Mg, 8:Zr–Ni–Cu–Al, 9: Zr–Ti–Ni–Cu–Be, 10: Ni–Pd–Cu–P.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
209
3.12.1 Structure of metallic glasses In amorphous solids there is a considerable disorder and it is impossible to give a description of their structure comparable to that applicable to crystals. In a crystal indeed the identification of all the atoms in the unit cell, at least in principle, is possible with a precise determination of their coordinates. For a glass, only a statistical description may be obtained: to this end different experimental techniques are useful and often complementary to each other. Especially important are the methods based on diffraction experiments: only these will be briefly mentioned here. The diffraction pattern of an amorphous alloy does not show sharp diffraction peaks as for crystalline materials but only a few broadened peaks. Much more limited information can thus be extracted and only a ‘statistical’ description of the structure may be obtained. The so-called radial distribution function is defined as: RDF(r) 4πr2ρ(r) where ρ(r) is the number of atoms in a spherical shell of radius r and thickness dr. Often the reduced radial distribution function G(r) is deduced which is given by: G(r) 4πr[ρ(r)–ρ0] where ρ0 is the number of atoms per unit volume of the sample. The radial distribution function which may be obtained from a given diffraction pattern is the total one in which the different types of atoms are not distinguished. For a binary alloy, containing the elements X and Y, it is also important to obtain the partial radial distribution functions: 4πr2ρxx(r), 4πr2ρyy(r) and 4πr2ρxy(r). The first two functions describe the correlations between similar atoms, the third one the correlation between different atoms. To obtain the three partial functions, at least three different scattering experiments must be performed in such conditions that, in each experiment, sufficiently different atomic scattering factors are shown by X and Y. Different methods are, in principle, available in order to change the relative scattering powers of X and Y. It is possible to use different radiations (performing X-ray, neutron and electron diffraction experiments) or, for instance, to make isotopic substitution. This leaves the glass structure unaltered but may change the neutron scattering factor. From the partial functions it is possible to determine the nearest-neighbour coordination numbers and the nearest-neighbour distances. A few typical data are listed in Table 3.10 for a few easy glass-forming systems and compared with the values obtained for crystalline phases of similar compositions.
210
Intermetallic Chemistry
Table 3.10. Examples of coordination and interatomic average distances in crystalline and amorphous alloys (Buschow 1984). System
Crystalline phase
Gd–Fe
GdFe2 cF24-Cu2Mg type
Y–Ni
YNi2 cF24-Cu2Mg type
Atoms involved Fe–Fe Gd–Fe
6 12
261 306
Gd–Gd Ni–Ni
4 6
320 254
Y–Ni
12
298
Y–Y
4
311
4.8 2.4 6 12
245 249 287 318
Co–Co Gd–Co
a b
GdCo5 hP6-CaCu5 type
NNNa Distance (pm)
Gd–Co Gd–Gd
Amorphous phase (am)Gd0.36Fe0.64
(am)Y0.33Ni0.67
Atoms CNb Distance involved (pm) Fe–Fe Gd–Fe
6.5 6.5
2.54 3.04
Gd–Gd Ni–Ni
6 2 4 9 3
3.47 2.40 2.55 2.71 3.05
Y–Ni
Ni–Y Y–Y Co–Co (am)Gd0.18Co0.82
4.5 2.71 1.5 3.05 4 3.40 7.2 247
Gd–Co
12
297
Gd–Gd
3
340
NNN: nearest neighbour number. CN: coordination number.
Thermodynamic approach to evaluation of amorphization tendency. In a paper by Zaitsev and Zaitseva (2005), it is observed that the search for new glass-forming systems is generally performed on the basis of a certain number of criteria. Three groups of criteria are generally considered: thermodynamic (enthalpy of formation, coordinates of deepest eutectics, etc.), kinetic (nucleation regularity, crystal phase growth, etc.) and structural (liquid and glass structures, atomic dimensions, etc.). A fundamental criterion, of course, is also based on the chemical properties of the substances involved and the nature of the chemical interactions. Special attention was dedicated in this paper to thermodynamic considerations: on this basis it was stated that key properties that control the capacity of molten metallic alloys for transition into an amorphous state are the excess entropy and heat capacity of the liquid. Chemical short-range order in liquids exhibiting various tendencies to glass formation was analysed in terms of the associated solution theory; an interrelation was established between association and characteristics (viscosity, crystallization) that determine the amorphization possibility and glass state stability.
211
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
1405 1400 β Al11La3
875
918 865
800 640
0 Al
10
20
30
AlLa3
200
400 AILa
400
530 520 Al2La
660 600
α Al11La3 Al3La
Temperature (°C)
1000
Alx La
1240 1200
40
50 at.% La
60
70
80
90
100 La
Figure 3.53. The La–Al phase diagram. The composition ranges corresponding to easy glass formation are marked.
3.12.2 Examples of metallic systems with glass-forming capability Several groups of binary and complex systems have been identified in which amorphous alloys may be obtained. The formation of amorphous alloys by vapour quenching may generally be obtained in a large composition range, possibly with the exception, in a binary system, of the two extreme composition regions. The preparation of amorphous alloys, usually by liquid quenching is possible in more restricted ranges of composition (the so-called ‘easy glass-forming ranges’).Very often these regions correspond to alloys forming ‘deep’ eutectics, both binary and complex. See an example in Fig. 3.53. In a number of cases more than one glassforming region may be observed in a given system. Besides the quenching rate and the preparation methods, a number of factors have been considered as governing the glass formation; among these, favourable factors are the atomic radius ‘mismatch’ between the components (a critical radius mismatch of 15% is generally considered), and a negative deviation of the volume of the liquid with respect to the ideal volume of mixing. A detailed discussion of the different factors and the construction of ‘glass-forming ability’ maps have been presented by Cahn and Greer (1996).
212
Intermetallic Chemistry
As for the types of glass-forming alloys, according to Cahn and Greer (1996), the following examples of representatives groups of alloys can be considered: Metal-nonmetal alloys: Ti80–85Si20–15; W80N20; Re65Si35 Fe75–88B25–12; Ni18B82 Ni59–69B41–31; Pd78–86Si22–14; Pt64–66Sb36–34 (and alloys pertaining to ternary systems such as Fe–Ni–B; Fe–Ni–B–P; Fe–Co– Si–B; Fe–P–C; etc.) Fe-, Co-, Ni-based alloys of this group are also commercially important for their soft-magnetic properties. The Ni–Pd–Cu–P family of alloys shows among the metallic systems the highest glass-forming ability known to date (Inoue et al. 1997, Löffler 2003). Early transition metal–late transition metal: Zr9Fe91; Zr75Fe25; Zr10Ni90; Zr33–80Ni67–20 Zr25–60Cu75–40; Nb30–60Ni70–40; Ta30–60Ni70–40 Alkaline earth-based alloys: Mg68–75Zn32–25; Ca52–88Al48–12; Y10Cu25Mg65 Aluminium-based alloys: Ni15Al70Si15; V10Cu15Al70; Zr5Ni10Al85, La5Fe10Al85 The Al alloys, mainly with a lanthanide and a late transition metal, generally exhibit good mechanical properties. Lanthanide- and actinide-based alloys: Gd50–68Fe50–32; La66–72Al34–18; La78–83Ge22–17; La74–82Au26–18; La55Ni20Al25; U60–74Co40–26 The ternary alloys of a lanthanide with Al and a late transition metal have very high glass-forming ability and low critical cooling rate: bulk samples may be cast. REFERENCES
Akinlade, O. and Awe, O.E. (2006) Int. J. Mater. Res (formerly Z. Metallkd.), 97, 377. Albering, J.H., Pöttgen, R., Jeitschko, W., Hoffmann, R-D., Chevalier, B. and Etourneau, J. (1994) J. Alloy. Comp., 206, 133. Andersson, S. (1983) Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 22, 69. Andersson, S. and Hyde, B.G. (1982) Z. Kristallogr., 158, 119.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
213
Ansara, I., Chart, T.G., Fernàndes, A., Hayes, F.H., Kattner, U.R., Pettifor, D.G., Saunders, N. and Zeng, K. (1997) Calphad, 21, 171. Armbrüster, M. and Lidin, S. (2000) J. Alloy. Comp., 307, 141. Bärnighausen, H. (1980) Match (Comm. Math. Chem.), 9, 139. Barrett, C.S. and Massalski, T.B. (1966) Structure of Metals, 3rd Edition (McGraw Hill, New-York). Bhandary, K.K. and Girgis, K. (1977) Acta Crystallogr., A33, 903. Bhatia, M.L. and Cahn, R.W. (2005) Intermetallics, 13, 474. Bokii, G.B. and Laptev, V.I. (1994) Crystallogr. Rep., 39, 409. Borzone, G., Parodi, N. and Ferro, R. (1993) J. Phase Equilib., 14, 485. Brown, I.D. and Shannon, R.D. (1973) Acta Crystallogr., A29, 266. Brunner, G.O. and Schwarzenbach, D. (1971) Z. Kristallogr., 133, 281. Buschow, K.H.J. (1984) Hydrogen absorption in intermetallic compounds. In: Handbook on the Physics and Chemistry of Rare Earths, eds. Gschneidner Jr., K.A., and Eyring, L. (North-Holland, Amsterdam), Vol. 6, p. 1. Cahn, R.W. (1987) Antiphase domains, disordered films and the ductility of ordered alloys based on Ni3Al’. In: High-Temperature Ordered Intermetallic Alloys II, eds. Stoloff, N.S., Koch, C.C., Liu, C.T. and Izumi, O. (MRS, Pittsburgh), Vol. 81, p. 27. Cahn R.W. (1990) Recovery, strain-age-hardening and recrystallization in deformed intermetallics. In: High Temperature Aluminides and Intermetallics, eds. Whang, S.H., Liu, C.T., Pope, J.O. and Stiegler, J.O. (TSM, Warrendale), p. 245. Cahn, R.W. (2001) The Coming of Materials Science, Pergamon Materials Series, Vol. 5 (Pergamon, Oxford). Cahn, R.W. and Greer, A.L. (1996) Metastable states of alloys. In: Physical Metallurgy, eds. Cahn, R.W. and Haasen, P. (North Holland, Amsterdam), Vol. II, p. 1723. Carter, F.L. (1978) Acta Crystallogr., B34, 2962. Cava, R.J., Takagi, H., Batlogg, B., Zandbergen, H.W., Krajewski, J.J., Peck Jr. W.F., van Dover, R.B., Felder, R.J., Siegrist, T., Mizuhashi, K., Lee, J.O., Eisaki, H., Carter, S.A. and Uchida, S. (1994a) Nature, 367, 146. Cava, R.J., Zandenbergen, H.W., Batloog, B., Eisaki, H., Takagi, H., Krajewski, J.J., Peck Jr. W.F., Gyorgy, E.M., and Uchida, S. (1994b) Nature, 372, 245. Cervellino, A. and Steurer, W. (2002) Acta Crystallogr., A58, 180. Chen, X-Q., Wolf, W., Podloucky, R. and Rogl, P. (2004) Intermetallics, 12, 59. Daams, J.L.C. (1995) Atomic environments in some related intermetallic structure types. In: Intermetallic Compounds, eds. Westbrook, J.H. and Fleisher, R.L. (John Wiley and Sons Ltd, Chichester), Vol. 1, p. 363. Daams, J.L.C. and Villars, P. (1993) J. Alloy. Comp., 197, 243. Daams, J.L.C. and Villars, P. (1994) J.Alloy. Comp., 215, 1. Daams, J.L.C. and Villars, P. (1997) J.Alloy. Comp., 252, 110. Daams, J.L.C., Villars, P. and van Vucht, J.H.N. (1991) Atlas of Crystal Structure Types for Intermetallic Phases (Materials Park, Oh 44073: American Society for Metals), Vol. 1–4. Daams, J.L.C., van Vucht, J.H.N. and Villars, P.(1992) J. Alloy. Comp., 182, 1. de Wolff, P.M. (1974) Acta Crystallogr., A30, 777.
214
Intermetallic Chemistry
de Wolff, P.M. (1977) Acta Crystallogr., A33, 493. Donnay, J.D.H., Hellner, E. and Niggli, A. (1964) Z. Kristallogr., 139, 246. Engel, N.N. (1969) Alloy phase stability criteria. In: Developments in the Structural Chemistry of Alloy Phases, ed. Giessen, B.C. (Plenum Press, New York), p. 25. Fässler, T.F. and Hoffmann, S. (1999) Z. Krystallogr., 214, 722. Ferraris, G., Makovicky, E. and Merlino, S. (2004) Crystallography of Modular Materials, International Union of Crystallography, Oxford Sci. Publ. (Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK). Ferro, R. and Cacciamani, G. (2002) Calphad, 26, 439. Ferro, R. and Girgis, K. (1990) J. Less Common Metals, 158, L41. Flieher, G., Völlenkle, H. and Nowotny, H. (1968a) Monatsh. Chemie, 99, 877. Flieher, G., Völlenkle, H. and Nowotny, H. (1968b) Monatsh. Chemie, 99, 2408. Frank, F.C. and Kasper, J.S. (1958) Acta Crystallogr., 11, 184. Frank, F.C. and Kasper, J.S. (1959) Acta Crystallogr., 12, 483. Franzen, H.F. (1986) Physical Chemistry of Inorganic Crystalline Solids (Springer-Verlag, Berlin). Fredrickson, D.C., Lee, S., Hoffmann, R. and Lin, J. (2004a) Inorg. Chem., 43, 6151. Fredrickson, D.C., Lee, S. and Hoffmann, R. (2004b) Inorg. Chem., 43, 6159. Frevel, L.K. (1985) Acta Crystallogr., B41, 304. Giacovazzo, C., Monaco, H.L., Viterbo, D., Scordari, F., Gilli, G., Zanetti, G. and Catti, M. (1992) Fundamentals of Crystallography, ed. Giacovazzo, C. (Oxford University Press, Oxford). Gialanella, S. and Cahn, R.W. (1993) Mat. Eng., 4, 407. Girgis, K. and Villars, P. (1985) Monatsh. Chemie, 116, 417. Gladyshevskii, E.I. and Bodak, O. (1995) Topologically close-packed structures. In: Intermetallic Compounds Principles and Practice, eds. Westbrook, J.H. and Fleischer, R.L. (J. Wiley & Sons, Chichester, England), Vol. 1, p. 403–418. Gladyshevskii, R.E., Cenzual, K. and Parthé, E. (1992) J. Alloy. Comp., 189, 221. Grin, Yu.N. (1986) Monatsh. Chemie, 117, 921. Grin’Yu.N. (1992) Modern Perspectives in Inorganic Crystal Chemistry, a NATO Advanced Study Institute, Director Erwin Parthe’, Lecture Notes of 19th Course, Ettore Majorana Centre for Scientific Culture, Erice, Trapani, Italy. Grin’, Yu.N. and Akselrud, L.G. (1990) Acta Crystallogr., A46 Suppl., C338. Grin’, Yu.N., Yarmolyuk, Ya.P. and Gladyshevskii, E.I. (1982) Sov. Phys. Crystallogr., 27, 413. Guinier, A., Bokij, G.B., Boll-Dornberger, K., Cowley, J.M., Durovic, S., Jagodzinski, H., Krishna, P., De Wolff, P.M., Zvyagin, B.B., Cox, D.E., Goodman, P., Hahn, Th., Kuchitsu, K. and Abrahams, S.C. (1984) Acta Crystallogr., A40, 399. Hägg, G. (1930) Z. Phys. Chem. (B), 11, 152. Hägg, G. (1931) Z. Phys. Chem. (B), 12, 413. Hahn, T. (ed.) (2002) International Tables for Crystallography (Springer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands). Hawthorne, F.C. (1983) Acta Crystallogr., A39, 724.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
215
Hellner, E.E. (1979) The frameworks (Bauverbande) of the cubic structure types. In: Structure and Bonding (Springer-Verlag, Berlin), Vol. 37. Hoffmann, R-D., Wu, Z. and Pöttgen, R. (2003) Eur. J. Inorg. Chem., 3425–3431. Hoppe, R. (1979) Z. Kristallogr., 150, 23. Hoppe, R. and Meyer, G. (1980) Z. Metallkd., 71, 347. Hyde, B.G. and Andersson, S. (1989) Inorganic Crystal Structures (J. Wiley & Sons, New York). Inoue, A., Nishiyama, N. and Kimura, H. (1997) Mater. Trans. JIM, 38, 179. Jagodzinski, H. (1954) Acta Crystallogr., 7, 17. Janner, A. and Janssen, T. (1980) Acta Crystallogr., A36, 399. Jeitschko, W. and Parthé, E. (1967) Acta Crystallogr., 22, 417. Jensen, B. (1984) Communicating Solid-State Structures to the Uninitiated (Rochester Institute of Technology, Rochester). Jensen, B. (1989) The Structures of Binary Compounds. Cohesion and Structure, eds. de Boer, F.R. and Pettifor, D.G. (North-Holland, Amsterdam), Vol. 2, p. 105. Johansson, C.H. and Linde, J.O. (1925) Ann. Phys., 76, 476. Kaban, I. and Hoyer, W. (2006) Int. J. Mat. Res (formerly Z. Metallkd.), 97, 362. Kao, C.R., Pike, L.M., Chen, S.-L. and Chang, Y.A. (1994) Intermetallics, 2, 235. Kelton, K.F. (1995) Quasicrystals and related structures. In: Intermetallic Compounds Principles and Practice, eds. Westbrook, J.H. and Fleischer, R.L. (J. Wiley & Sons, Chichester, England), Vol. 1, p. 453–491. Khachaturyan, A.G. (1983) Theory of Structural Transformations in Solids (John Wiley & Sons, New York). Klee, H. and Witte, H. (1954) Z. Phys. Chem., 202, 352. Klements, W.J., Willens, R.H. and Duwez, P. (1960) Nature, 187, 869. Kripyakevich, P.I. (1963) A systematic classification of types of intermetallic structures: J. Struct. Chem., 4. Kripyakevich, P.I. (1976) Sov. Phys. Crystallogr., 21, 696. Kripyakevich, P.I. and Gladyshevskii, E.I. (1972) Acta Crystallogr., A28, Suppl., S97. Kripyakevich, P.I. and Grin’, Yu.N. (1979) Sov. Phys. Crystallogr., 24, 41. Kubaschewski, O. and Evans, E.LL. (1958) Metallurgical Thermochemistry (Pergamon Press, London). Landolt-Börnstein (1971) Structure Data of Elements and Intermetallic Phases, eds. Hellwege, K.H. and Hellwege, A.M. (Springer, Berlin), Vol. 6. Laves, F. (1930) Z. Kristallogr., 73, 303. Laves, F. (1944) Die Chemie (Angewandte Chemie, neue Folge), 57, 30. Laves, F. and Witte, H. (1936) Metallwirtschaft, 15, 840. Leigh, G.J. (ed.) (1990) Nomenclature of Inorganic Chemistry. Recommendations 1990, Issued by the Commission on the Nomenclature of Inorganic Chemistry (Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford). Lima de Faria, J. and Figueiredo, M.O. (1976) J. Solid State Chem., 16, 7. Lima de Faria, J. and Figueiredo, M.O. (1978) Garcia de Orta, Série Geologia, 2, 69.
216
Intermetallic Chemistry
Lima de Faria, J., Hellner, E., Liebau, F., Makovicky, E. and Parthé, E. (1990) Acta Crystallogr., A46, 1. Lin, Q. and Corbett, J.D. (2003) Inorg. Chem., 42, 8762. Löffler, J.F. (2003) Intermetallics, 11, 529. Machatschki, F. (1938) Naturwissenschaften, 26, 67. Machatschki, F. (1953) Spezielle Mineralogie auf Geochemischer Grundlage (Springer, Wien), p. 1 and p. 298. Mallik, A.K. (1987) J. Alloy Phase Diagram., 3, 12. Manchester, F.D. and Pitre, J.M. (1994) J. Phase Equilib., 15, 62. Melnik, E.V. and Kripyakevich, P.I. (1974) Kristallografiya, 19, 645. Morozkin, A.V. and Seropegin, Yu.D. (1996) J. Alloy. Comp., 237, 124. Morris, D.G. (1992) Ordered Intermetallics – Physical Metallurgy and Mechanical Behaviour, eds. Liu, C.T., Cahn, R.W. and Sauthoff, G. (Klewer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht). Moser, Z., Gasior, W., Pstru´s, J., Ohnuma, I. and Ishida, K. (2006) Int. J. Mat. Res. (formerly Z. Metallkd.), 97, 365. Nagamatsu, J., Nakagawa, N., Muranaka, T., Zenitani, Y. and Akimitsu, J. (2001) Nature, 410, 63. Nesper, R. (1991) Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 30, 789. Niggli, P. (1945) Grundlagen der Stereochemie (Birkhuser, Basel), p. 125. Niggli, P. (1948) Gesteine und Minerallagersttten, (Birkhuser, Basel), Vol. 1, p. 42. Novakovic, R., Ricci, E., Gnecco, F., Giuranno, D. and Borzone, G. (2005) Surf. Sci., 599, 230. O’Keeffe, M.O. (1979) Acta Crystallogr., A35, 772. Ochiai, S., Oya, Y. and Suzuki, T. (1984) Acta Metall., 32, 289. Okamoto, H. (2000) Phase Diagrams for Binary alloy, Desk Handbook (ASM International, Materials Park, OH). Okamoto, H., Massalski, T.B., Chakrabarti, D.J. and Laughlin, D.E. (1987) The Au–Cu (gold–copper) system. In: Phase Diagrams of Binary Gold Alloys, eds. Okamoto, H. and Massalski, T.B. (ASM International, Materials Park, OH), p. 76. Onoda, M and Kato, K. (1991) Acta Crystallogr., B47, 630. Palenzona, A. (1971) J. Less-Common Met., 25, 367. Pani, M. and Fornasini, M.L. (1990) Z. Kristallogr., 190, 127. Parthé, E. (1964) Crystal Chemistry of Tetrahedral Structures (Gordon and Breach Publishers, New York). Parthé, E. (1969) The concept of a partial electron concentration value and its application to problems in crystal chemistry. In: Developments in the Structural Chemistry of Alloy Phases, ed. Giessen, B.C. (Plenum Press, New York), p. 49. Parthé, E. (1980) Acta Crystallogr., B36, 1. Parthé, E. and Gelato, L.M. (1984) Acta Crystallogr., A40, 169. Parthé, E. Chabot, B.A. and Cenzual, K. (1985) Chimia, 39, 164. Parthé, E., Cenzual, K. and Gladyshevskii, R.E. (1993) J. Alloy. Comp., 187, 291. Passerone, A. and Ricci, E. (1998) High Temperature Tensiometry: Drops and Bubbles in Interfacial Research, eds. Möbius, D. and Miller, R. (Elsevier, Amsterdam), p. 475.
Structural Characteristics of Intermetallic Phases
217
Pearson, W.B. (1967) A Handbook of Lattice Spacings and Structures of Metals and Alloy, (Pergamon Press, Oxford). Pearson, W.B. (1972) The Crystal Chemistry and Physics of Metals and Alloys, (WileyInterscience, New York). Pettifor, D.G. (1984) Solid State Commun., 51, 31. Pettifor, D.G. (1985) J. Less-Common Metals, 114, 7. Pettifor, D.G. (1986) J. Phys. C: Solid State Phys., 19, 285. Petzow, G. and Effenberg, G. (eds.) (1988 et seq.) Ternary Alloys. A comprehensive Compendium of Evaluated Constitutional Data and Phase Diagrams (VCH, Weinheim). Predel, B. and Oehme, G. (1979) Z. Metallkd., 70, 450. Reehuis, M., Jeitschko, W., Müller, M.H. and Brown, P.J. (1992) J. Phys. Chem. Solid., 53, 687. Samson, S. (1967) Acta Crystallogr., 23, 586. Samson, S. (1969) Structural principles of giant cells. In: Development in the Structural Chemistry of Alloy Phases, ed. Giessen, B.C. (Plenum Press, New York), p. 65. Saunders, N. and Miodownik, A.P. (1998) Calphad Calculation of Phase Diagrams: A Comprehensive Guide, Pergamon Materials Series (Pergamon, Oxford). Schubert, K. (1964) Kristallstrukturen Zweikomponentiger Phasen (Springer Verlag, Berlin). Schwomma, O., Nowotny, H. and Wittmann, A. (1964a) Monatsh. Chemie, 95, 1538. Schwomma, O., Preisinger, A., Nowotny, H. and Wittmann, A. (1964b) Monatsh. Chemie, 95, 1527. Selke, W. (1989) Long period structures in alloys-statistical mechanics in the ANNNI model and related concepts. In: Alloy Phase Stability, eds. Stocks, G.M. and Gonis, A., NATO ASI Series, Series E: Applied Sciences (Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston, USA), Vol. 163, p. 205. Shechtman, D., Blech, I., Gratias, D. and Cahn, J.W. (1984) Phys. Rev. Lett., 53, 1951. Shoemaker, C.B. and Shoemaker, D.P. (1969) Structural properties of some σ-phase related phases. In: Development in the Structural Chemistry of Alloy Phases, ed. Giessen, B.C. (Plenum Press, New York), p. 107. Simon, A. (1983) Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 22, 95. Singh, R.N. and Ali, I. (2006) Int. J. Mat. Res. (formerly Z. Metallkd.), 97, 382. Singh, R.N. and Sommer, F. (1992) Z. Metallkd., 83, 553. Singh, R.N., Jha, I.S. and Sinha, S.K. (1991) J. Phys. Cond. Matter, 3, 2787. Sommer F. (1978) Calphad, 2, 319. Sommer, F. (1982) Z. Metallkd., 73, 77. Stein, F., Palm, M. and Sauthoff, G. (2004) Intermetallics, 12, 713. Stein, F., Palm, M. and Sauthoff, G. (2005) Intermetallics, 13, 1055. Steurer, W. (1995) Experimental aspects of the structure analysis of aperiodic materials. In: Beyond Quasicrystals, eds. Axel, F. and Gratia, D. (Les Editions de Physique-Springer, Berlin, Germany), p. 203. Steurer, W. (1996) The structure of quasicrystals. In: Physical Metallurgy, eds. Cahn, R.W. and Haasen, P., 4th edition (North Holland), p. 371. Tsai, A.P., Guo, J.Q., Abe, E., Takakura, H. and Sato, T.J. (2000) Nature, 408, 537. Tsuchiya, Y. (2006) Int. J. Mat. Res (formerly Z. Metallkd.), 97, 371.
218
Intermetallic Chemistry
van Aalst, W., den Hollander, J., Peterse, W.J.A.M. and de Wolff, P.M. (1976) Acta Crystallogr., B 32, 47. van Der Lugt, W. (1996) Polyanions in liquid ionic alloys. In: Chemistry, Structure, and Bonding of Zintl Phases and Ions, ed. Kauzlarich, S.M. (VCH Publishers Inc., New York). Van der Lugt, W. and Verkerk, P. (2002) Molten Zintl alloys. In: Inorganic Chemistry Highlights, ed. Meyer, G., Naumann, D. and Wesemann, L. (Wiley, VCH, Weinheim), p. 1 Van Vucht, J.H.N. and Buschow, K.H.J. (1965) J. Less Common Met., 10, 98. Villars, P. and Calvert, L.D. (1985) Pearson’s Handbook of Crystallographic Data for Intermetallic Phases 1st Edition (American Society for Metals, Materials Park, OH 44073), Vol. 1–3. Villars, P. and Calvert, L.D. (1991) Pearson’s Handbook of Crystallographic Data for Intermetallic Phases 2nd Edition (American Society for Metals, Materials Park, OH 44073) Vol. 1–4. Villars, P., Prince, A. and Okamoto, H. (1995) Handbook of Ternary Alloy Phase Diagrams (ASM International, Materials Park, OH). Wells, A.F. (1970) Models in Structural Inorganic Chemistry (Clarendon Press, Oxford). Wondratschek, H. and Jeitschko, W. (1976) Acta Crystallogr., 32A, 664. Yan, X., Chen, X-Q., Grytsiv, A., Witusiewicz, V.T., Rogl, P., Podloucky, R., Pomjakushin, V. and Giester, G., (2006) Int. J. Mat. Res. (formerly Z. Metallkd.), 97, 450. Yamamoto, A. (1982) Acta Crystallogr., B38, 1446. Yamamoto, A. (1996) Acta Crystallogr., A52, 509. Yang, R., Botton, G.A. and Cahn, R.W. (1996) Acta Mater., 44, 3869. Zaitsev, A.I. and Zaitseva, N.E. (2005) J. Phase Equilib. Diff., 26, 240. Zhdanov, G.S. (1945) C. R. Acad. Sc., USSR, 48, 39. Zhu, J.H., Liu, C.Y., Pike, L.M. and Liaw, P.K. (2002) Intermetallics, 10, 579. Zvyagin, B.B. (1987) Sov. Phys. Crystallogr., 32, 394. Zvyagin, B.B. (1993) Crystallogr. Rep., 38, 54.
Chapter 4
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
4.1. INTRODUCTION
Just as it is effective in the other fields of inorganic descriptive chemistry, the Periodic Table is an essential reference point in intermetallic chemistry too. The general alloying characteristics of the different metals, their reactivity towards the other metals, the variety of their intermetallic derivatives usually are very complex and cannot be easily explained and rationalized on the basis of a few concepts and data. Nevertheless a sound first criterion for a description and classification of the intermetallic behaviour of the various metals lies in their position in the Periodic Table. On the basis of the Periodic Table, topics of intermetallic systematics will be presented in the next chapter. In the present chapter the Periodic Table will be revisited and its structure and subdivisions summarized. In relation also to some concepts previously presented, such as electronegativity, Mendeleev number, etc. described in Chapter 2, typical property trends along the Table will be shown. Strictly related concepts, such as Periodic Table group number, average group number and valence-electron number will be considered and used in the description and classification of intermetallic phase families.
4.2. THE PERIODIC TABLE AND ITS STRUCTURE
4.2.1 The Periodic Table and the electron configurations of the elements The Periodic Table of the elements is shown in Fig. 4.1, in one of its most popular versions. Special names for families of elements are indicated in Fig. 4.2. In particular, notice that the elements having atomic numbers from 58 to 71 together with La (atomic number 57) pertain to the lanthanide family, and those from Z 90 to Z 103, together with Ac, Z 89, to the actinide family. In the Periodic Table of Fig.4.1, which is commonly used, the elements La and Ac, together with Sc and Y, are placed in their proper positions of the 3rd column (3rd group) of the Table. The other lanthanides and actinides are reported separately at the bottom of the figure. 219
220
Intermetallic Chemistry 1
18 1
1
H
2
Li
2
2 3
11
13 4
19
K 37
5 Rb 55
6 Cs 87
7
Fr
5
Be
B
12
3 Na Mg 4
13
3
20
Ca
21
Sc
38
Sr
39
Y
56
Ba
57
La
5
4 22
23
V
Ti 40
Zr
41
72
73
Ta
Lanthanides
Ce
Actinides
Th
88
6 24
Cr 42
Nb Mo
Hf
Ra
14
74
W
7 25
Mn 43
Tc 75
Re
8 26
Fe 44
Ru 76
Os
9
10
27
Co
28
Ni
45
Rh
46
Pd
77
Ir
78
Pt
11 29
Cu
30
Zn
47
Ag
31
6
C
48
49
In
80
81
Hg
Tl
7
33
17
Cl
34
Se
51
35
Br
52
Sb
82
9
F
16
S
As
50
Pb
8
15
Te
83
84
Bi
He
17
O
P
32
Sn
16
N
14
Si
Ga Ge
Cd
79
Au
Al
12
15
Po
53
I
10
Ne 18
Ar 36
Kr 54
Xe 85
At
86
Rn
89
Ac 58
90
59
Pr 91
Pa
60
61
62
63
Nd Pm Sm Eu 92
U
93
Np
94
95
64
Gd
65
Tb
96
66
Dy
97
Pu Am Cm Bk
98
Cf
67
Ho 99
Es
68
Er
69
70
Tm Yb
100
101
102
Fm Md No
71
Lu 103
Lr
Noble gases
Halogens
Chalcogens
Transition metals
Pnicogens
Y
Triels
Sc
Tetrels
Alkali metals
Alkaline earths
Figure 4.1. The Periodic Table of the elements, in which symbols and atomic numbers of the different elements are reported. On the left the progressive numbers of the rows (of the periods) and on the top the numbers of the columns (the groups) are indicated.
La Ac Lanthanides Actinides
Figure 4.2. The Periodic Table: special collective names. The informal symbols of these families of elements are: A alkali metals, Ae alcaline earth metals, Ln lanthanides; R rare earth metals Sc Y lanthanides, An actinides, Hal halogens, Chal chalcogens, Pn pnicogens, Tr triels, Tt tetrels.
221
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
A survey of the trends of some atomic and physical properties of the different elements against their atomic number is summarized in Figs. 4.3–4.5. In Fig. 4.3 the energies of 1st and 2nd ionization are reported. The first stage ionization energy of the element M is the energy required to remove the least tightly bound electron from the neutral atom in the gas phase, that is, to perform the following reaction: Mgas : Mgas e Notice in the corresponding graph the maxima for the inert noble gases and the minima for the alkali metals. The second stage ionization energy corresponds to the reaction Mgas : M gas e , that is to a reaction involving an atom deprived of one electron, and therefore isoelectronic with the neutral atom of the previous element. Notice the resulting shift of one place in this graph (in comparison with the previous one) of the positions of the minima and maxima and the similar shapes of the two graphs underlining the similar electron configuration for a given number of electrons. 8000 Li
First ionization energy Second ionization energy
Ionization energy (kJ/mol)
7000 6000 5000
Na
4000 K
3000
Rb He
2000
Cs
Ne Ar
Kr
Xe
1000 0 0
20
40
60
80
100
Atomic number
Figure 4.3. Ionization energies of the elements. The values of the energies (in kJ/mol of atoms) of 1st and 2nd ionization are shown. Notice the ‘periodic’ character of these values as a function of the atomic number. Notice the similar trends of the two graphs when the same number of electrons are considered: the maxima, for instance, are observed for the 1st ionization of He and the 2nd ionization of Li, for 1st and 2nd ionization of Ne and Na, respectively (having both 10 electrons), etc.
222
Intermetallic Chemistry
Melting temperature (°C)
4000
C W
3000
Mo V
2000
Th
Si Ge
1000
0 −273 0
20
40
60
80
100
Atomic number
Figure 4.4. Melting temperatures (ºC) of the elements plotted against the atomic number. Notice, within the different periods of the Periodic Table, the similar trends of the values. Those elements have been indicated for which a very high melting point and a clear maximum have been observed.
300
Fr
Cs Rb K
Atomic radius CN 12 (pm)
250 Na
200 Li 150 100 50 0 0
20
40
60
80
100
Atomic number
Figure 4.5. Atomic radius (pm, CN 12) of the elements ordered according to their atomic number. Notice the high values corresponding to the alkali metals, the progressive decrease along each period, and the abrupt increase at the beginning of the next period. Notice also the progressive lengthening of the different periods due to the occurrence of the transition elements in the periods starting from K, Rb, Cs and of the lanthanides in the Cs period. In the Cs period, within the lanthanides, observe the peaks of Eu and Yb with the high values of their radii, corresponding to a divalent metal state.
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
223
Similar shifts and trends may be noticed considering the much higher values, and their trends of the energies of the 3rd, 4th, etc. ionizations. Figs 4.4 and 4.5 show the trends of the melting temperature and of the atomic radius of the elements vs. their atomic number. The ‘rhythmic’ (periodic) aspect of the graphs is apparent and corresponds to the ‘rhythmic’ variations of the ground valence-electron configurations along the Periodic Table. It is well known, indeed, that the structure of the Periodic Table and the positioning of the different elements in it, are strictly related to the electronic structure of the atoms of the elements themselves and to the changes in this structure from one element to the next one. These arguments are fully and systematically treated in the books of general chemistry, inorganic chemistry, physical chemistry, etc. Only a few notes will be reported here mainly to remind the reader of the different nomenclature and symbols generally used. As for the properties of the different elements, and especially those relevant to their alloying behaviour, a selection is reported in the specific paragraphs of Chapter 5. 4.2.1.1 Remarks about the structure of the Periodic Table. The elements, written in sequence of their atomic number, are arranged in the Table in horizontal rows (periods) and vertical columns (groups). Notice that two rows, the lanthanide and the actinide series, are placed in a special position outside the main body of the Table. This arrangement, which is related to the electronic structure of the atoms, illustrates and reflects the occurrence among the elements of similarities in the properties and analogies in their behaviour. In general, elements in the same column display similar chemical properties, possibly smoothly changing along the column, while along a period there is a progressive variation in the chemical behaviour, with an abrupt change at the borders. As a consequence it is possible to recognize natural subdivisions into several ‘families’ of the different elements. These points are briefly discussed in the subsequent paragraphs and related figures. The history of the Periodic Table, its layout and interpretation is well known, starting with Mendeleev and his precursors (de Chancourtois, Newlands, Odling, Hinrichs, Meyer) up to the insertion of the lanthanides, actinides, and transuranium elements and heavy and super-heavy elements. This history is closely related to fundamental stages in the development of chemistry (for instance, the identification and preparation of new elements, the discovery and application of a number of rules and concepts in descriptive inorganic chemistry) and physics, by the work of Bohr, Moseley, Schrödinger, etc. up to the final clarification of the Periodic Table through quantum mechanics. Broad reference to the above-mentioned topics may be found in a book containing the proceedings of an international conference with the contributions of several authors, edited by Rouvray and King (2004).
224
Intermetallic Chemistry
4.2.1.2 The electronic structure of the atoms. The electronic structure of the atoms of the different elements and their relation to the characteristics of the Periodic Table are based on a number of experimental data and theoretical models which are fully discussed in many elementary and advanced texts of inorganic chemistry such as Cotton et al. (1999), Greenwood and Earnshaw (1997), Huheey et al. (1997), Wells (1984). Only a few relevant points about the atomic structures are summarized in the following. Table 4.1 collects basic data about the fundamental physical constants of the atomic constituents. Neutrons (10n) and protons (11p), tightly bound in the nucleus, have nearly equal masses. The number of protons, that is the atomic number (Z), defines the electric charge of the nucleus. The number of neutrons (N), together with that of protons (A N Z) represents the atomic mass number of the species (of the nuclide). An element consists of all the atoms having the same value of Z, that is, the same position in the Periodic Table (Moseley 1913). The different isotopes of an element have the same value of Z but differ in the number of neutrons in their nuclei and therefore in their atomic masses. In a neutral atom the electronic envelope contains Z electrons. The charge of an electron (e) is equal in size but of opposite sign to that of a proton (the mass ratio, me/mp) is about 1/1836.1527). Elementary charge, e 1.60217653(14) 1019 C The unified atomic mass unit (u), previously symbolized as AMU or amu, is defined to be 1/12 of the mass of one atom of isotope 12 of carbon. Therefore, 1 u 1.66053886(28) 1027 kg A concept strictly related to the Avogadro Number (NA) is that of ‘mole’. It is the amount unit of a substance and it is defined as an NA of entities (to be specified, if not clearly implied). A mole of atoms of 12C, for instance, corresponds by definition, to NA atoms of 12C that is to 12 g of 12C. Similarly a mole of atoms of oxygen (15.9994 g) corresponds to NA atoms of oxygen and a mole of molecules of oxygen (31.9988 g of oxygen) corresponds to NA molecules O2 and as a final example, Table 4.1. Fundamental physical constants (adapted from Nist Codata, Mohr and Taylor (2005)). Mass (kg)
Mass (atomic mass unit, u)
Charge (e)
Electron
9.1093826(16) 1031
5.4857990945 (24) 104
1
Proton
1.67262171 (29) 1027
1.00727646688 (13)
1
27
1.00866491560 (55)
0
Neutron
1.67492728 (29) 10
Symbol 0 1e 1 1p 1 0n
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
225
a mole of sodium chloride is an NA of formula NaCl which corresponds to 58.4425 g of sodium chloride. The recommended value for Avogadro’s number is: NA 6.0221415(10) 1023 mol1 1 u 1/(NA) g 1/(1000 NA) kg The arrangement of the electrons in an atom, that is the electron configuration of an element in the ground state of its free neutral atom, is in direct and simple correspondence to the form of the Periodic Table and the position in it of the element under consideration. The so-called quantum approach to the Periodic Table is based on the following principles (Ostrovsky 2004): The quantum numbers n and . Multi-electron atoms can be characterized by a set of principal and orbital quantum numbers {n, } which labels one-electron wave functions (orbitals). The Pauli Exclusion Principle. No two electrons in an atom may have the same four quantum numbers n, , m, ms where m and ms are respectively the magnetic and spin quantum numbers. The Aufbau (building up) Principle. One-electron orbitals are filled (occupied) by electrons sequentially, in the order of increasing energy. With reference to the previously reported statements a summary of the role of the quantum numbers is in the following. The principal quantum number n may be considered the principal determinant of an electron energy level. Electrons corresponding in an atom to the subsequent possible values n 1, 2, 3, 4, etc. are also referred to as pertaining to the ‘shells’ K, L, M, N, etc.; the orbital quantum number defines the shape and the symmetry of the electron charge distribution and its orbital angular momentum. For atoms, or ions, containing more than one electron, the energy also depends to some extent on . The number of possible values for depends for a given electron on the value of n, its principal quantum number; n different values are possible from 0 up to n 1. Orbitals (electrons) with 0, 1, 2, 3, etc. are designated, respectively, as s, p, d, f, … orbitals. Notice that, in an atom, the sequence of increasing energy levels is in the order of increasing n values (between 2 electrons with the same n value, the one with a smaller value of n is more tightly bound). This rule (Madelung 1936) has been especially noted by Ostrovsky (2004) who underlined that it is not only a mnemonic device but has deep roots in quantum theory and links together many subjects. The ordering of one-electron levels (the definition of their energy sequence) is crucial for the application of the Aufbau principle.
226
Intermetallic Chemistry
The general filling order, therefore, is: 1s : 2s : 2p : 3s : 3p : 4s : 3d : 4p : 5s : 4d : 5p : 6s : 4f : 5d : 6p : etc. This means that 3d (for which n 3 2 5) is filled after 4s (n 4 0 4), 4d (n 4 2 6) after 5s (n 5 0 5), 4f (n 4 3 7) after 6s (n 6 0 6), 5d (n 5 2 7) after 4f (n 4 3 7), etc. As for the third and fourth quantum numbers, in agreement with what is generally mentioned in textbooks on chemistry, such as, for instance, Greenwood and Earnshaw (1997) we may say that: The magnetic quantum number m is related to the fact that only in an applied magnetic field it is possible to define a direction within the atom with respect to which the orbital can be directed. In general for a value of the orbital quantum number we have 2 1 possible values of the magnetic quantum number (which are 0, 1, 2, … up to ). To an s orbital, for instance, for which 0 and is spherically symmetrical, only one value corresponds for the magnetic quantum number (m 0). For p orbitals ( 1) we have three possibilities (m 1, 0, 1) corresponding to three orientations (generally assumed as the x, y, z directions in Cartesian coordinates). Similarly we have five possibilities for d orbitals ( 2) (that is m 2, 1, 0, 1, 2), seven for f orbitals ( 3), etc. The spin (angular momentum) quantum number ms. In their interpretation of many features of atomic spectra Uhlenbeck and Goudsmit (1925) proposed for the electron a new property called spin angular momentum (or simply spin) and assumed that only two states of spin were possible. In relativistic (four-dimensional) quantum mechanics this quantum number is related to the symmetry properties of the wave function and may have one of the two values designated as 1⁄2. However, while one-electron quantum numbers n and might be ascribed to an atom even in an approximate sense, the two other numbers m and ms generally cannot be associated with an atomic state in any valid approximation. They however are quite often used not as physical quantities but as mere counters. All electrons in atoms can be described by means of these four quantum numbers and, as first enunciated in 1926 by Pauli in his Exclusion Principle, each electron in an atom must have a unique set of the four quantum numbers. A summary of the electron ‘shells’ and of the corresponding maximum numbers of orbitals, and electrons, is shown in Table 4.2 where each shell is defined by the value of the principal quantum number (K 1, L 2, etc. according to X-ray spectroscopy nomenclature). This description of the electronic structure can be related to the form of the Periodic Table. Hydrogen with a nucleus having a charge 1 and only one electron
227
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table Table 4.2. Numbers of orbitals and maximum numbers of electrons in the electron shells. Shell
Quantum numbers
K L
n 1 2
M
3
N
4
m 0 0 0 0 1 1, 0,1 0 0 1 1, 0,1 2 2,1, 0, 1,2 0 0 1 1, 0,1 2 2,1, 0, 1,2 3 3,2,–1, 0,1,2,3
No. of orbital
1 1 3 1 3 5 1 3 5 7
Type of orbital
s s p s p d s p d f
Maximum number of e in the group of orbitals 2 2 6 2 6 10 2 6 10 14
Maximum number of e in the shell
2 8 18
32
is the first element and, in the ground state (the lowest-energy state), has the electronic configuration represented by 1s1 (that is n 1 and 0 with zero orbital angular momentum). Helium (Z 2, two electrons in the neutral atom) has the configuration 1s2: this completes the first period; no other value combination exists for n 1, 0 (m 0, ms 1⁄2). With the next element, lithium, Z 3, the least tightly bound electron has the configuration 2s1 (the complete Li electron configuration is 1s22s1, which in a way corresponds to the ‘addition’ of a third electron to a He type configuration, that is [He]2s1) and this corresponds to the beginning of the second period. Notice that in all the reported configurations we have symbols of the type nx y, where n is the principal quantum number, x is the letter (s, p, d or f ) corresponding to the different values of the orbital quantum number () and the exponent y is the number of electrons in the given orbital (or group of orbitals). The maximum value of y is defined by the number of alternative permitted combinations of different m and ms values. It corresponds, in the different cases, to s2, p6, d10 or f 14. For a few elements following lithium, the electron configurations corresponding to the progressive attribution of electrons to the different orbitals according to the energy increase are: Be (Z 4): 1s22s2; B (Z 5): 1s22s22p1; C (Z 6): 1s22s22p2; N (Z 7): 1s22s22p3; O (Z 8): 1s22s22p4; F (Z 9): 1s22s22p5; Ne (Z 10): 1s22s22p6; Na (Z 11): 1s22s22p63s1; etc.
228
Intermetallic Chemistry
With Na, the electron configuration of which may also be described as [Ne]3s1, the third period begins. A similar situation is found for each of the other periods in the Table: the number of the period is the principal quantum number of the least tightly bound electron of the first element (an alkali metal) of the period. A few more details of these questions and the characteristics of special points in the Periodic Table are discussed in following paragraphs. The electron configurations of all the elements are given in Chapter 5. 4.2.2 Blocks and subdivisions of the Periodic Table Different regions in the Periodic Table, that is, different grouping of elements, can be identified, having some analogies in the elemental properties and behaviour, useful as reference framework in a systematic description of the different chemistry fields. 4.2.2.1 ‘Blocks’ of the Periodic Table. On the basis of the nature of the orbitals to which the valence electrons are assigned in the different elements (in their ground states), a subdivision into ‘blocks’ of the Periodic Table is commonly made (see Fig. 4.6). The block s, on the left of the Table, contains the alkali and alkaline earth metals. Each atom of these metals possesses an inert gas core and one or two electrons in the s orbital of the valence shell, that is, an ‘external’ electron configuration ns1 or ns2 where n is the value of the principal quantum number, and also the period number in the Periodic Table. Notice however that He, owing to its general chemical inertness and to the behaviour similarity with the other noble gasses is generally placed at the far right of the Table. The p block contains elements corresponding to electron
s
p
s d
f
Figure 4.6. Blocks of the Periodic Table. The names (symbols) of the so-called blocks are indicated. In the p block two types of elements can be considered, roughly separated by the Zintl line: semi-metals in the left-hand part and non-metals in the right-hand part.
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
229
configurations from ns2 np1 to ns2np6. These elements may be considered as semimetals (in the bottom left-hand part of the block) or non-metals (in the top right-hand part): the separation, in this block, between semi-metals and non-metals is roughly indicated in the Table by a ‘diagonal’ line (the so-called Zintl line or Zintl border). Inserted within the s and p blocks, there are the d block elements (metals) having valence-electron configurations (n 1)d x ns0,1,2 corresponding to a number of electrons included between 1 and 10 in d orbitals and 1 or 2 (or no) electrons in the external s orbital (see in Chapter 5 the detailed description of the electron configurations of all the elements). The d block metals are also called transition metals. The 1st transition series is made up of the elements from Sc to Zn, the 2nd of the elements from Y to Cd, the 3rd of the elements from La to Hg. The 3rd transition series however is longer, and in it another set of elements is included: an inner transition series, corresponding to the metals of the f block from Ce to Lu, for which there is a progressive occupation of the 4f orbitals by the valence electrons. A similar description could be made for the subsequent row (7th period) containing the heaviest metals of the s block known (francium, Fr, and radium, Ra) and for another transition series, which starts from actinium (Ac) and includes the metals of the f block involved in the occupation of the 5f orbitals. Compare with Fig. 4.1 and, for an alternative nomenclature of the various families of elements, with Fig. 4.2. 4.2.2.2 Comments on some trends and on the ‘Divides’ in the Periodic Table. It is clear that, on the basis also of the atomic structure of the different elements, the subdivision of the Periodic Table in blocks and the consideration of its groups and periods are fundamental reference tools in the description and classification of the properties and behaviour of the elements and in the definition of typical trends in such characteristics. Well-known chemical examples are the valence-electron numbers, the oxidation states, the general reactivity, etc. As far as the intermetallic reactivity is concerned, these aspects will be examined in detail in the various paragraphs of Chapter 5 where, for the different groups of metals, the alloying behaviour, its trend and periodicity will be discussed. A few more particular trends and classification criteria, which are especially relevant in specific positions of the Periodic Table, will be summarized here. Lanthanide contraction. This effect, which is the progressive decrease of the atomic dimensions of the LnIII ions, is due (as discussed in § 5.5.2) to the imperfect shielding from the nuclear charge of 4f n electrons. A similar overall reduction is observed in the metal radii with the exceptions of Eu and Yb (containing larger LnII) and of Ce (containing slightly smaller atoms in an oxidation state a little higher than 3). An important effect of this trend is observed in the post-lanthanide elements: we have indeed a dimension reduction of the atomic structures also in
230
Intermetallic Chemistry
the next metals of the 3rd transition series (Hf, Ta, W, …) and this results in very similar sizes and properties with the corresponding metals of the 2nd transition series (Zr, Nb, Mo respectively). This means that, for instance, the hafnium chemistry will follow very closely that of zirconium. d block contraction. This effect, similar in principle to the lanthanide contraction, is due to the fact that, for instance after the end of the 1st transition series, differently from Al, we have the insertion of the 3d10 electrons in the atomic structure of Ga. The 10d electrons do not completely shield the corresponding extra positive charge of the nucleus. This results in a higher ‘effective’ nuclear charge which causes an increase in the attraction for the whole electron cloud, with a relative size contraction and an increase of the ionization energy. In the 13th group of the Periodic Table for the sequence B, Al, Ga, In and Tl, we have therefore an apparently irregular trend of several properties due to the influence of the 3d electrons (Ga), and then of the 4f electrons (Tl). Relativity: heavy transition metal species. Relativistic effects and their impact on the Periodic Table have been recently summarized by Balasubramanian (2004). Emphasis has been especially placed on gold. Au has the atomic number 79, so the inner 1s electron is subjected to the field generated by the 79 charge of the nucleus. In order to have equilibrium the electron has to move faster: it has been estimated that its speed is about 60% of the speed of light. As a consequence the relativistic mass of the electron, given by m m0/ (1 (2/c2) (where m0 is the stationary mass of the electron, its average speed and c the speed of light), is about 25% larger than m0. This results in an increase of the electron (kinetic) energy and in a consequent contraction of the orbital extension. This contraction is relevant for the core electrons, but it is also not negligible for the valence electrons. A relativistic contraction of the 6s orbital follows, with an increase of its stability (an increase of the energy needed to remove it). A comparison of the ionization potential of the elements of the 11th group Cu, Ag and Au does not show a monotonic decrease, as could be expected since the outermost electron is further from the nucleus. A decrease is only observed on passing from copper to silver; gold can be considered an anomaly since its ionization potential is higher than both silver and copper. The relativistic stabilization of the 6s orbital is also observed for other 6th row elements. Several peculiar properties (in the 12th group) of mercury in comparison with Zn and Cd have been related to this fact. The gradual decrease of the atomic radii from La to Lu (the lanthanide contraction), mainly attributed as previously mentioned to an incomplete screening of the 4f shells, has been shown to be partially due to relativistic effects. See the detailed discussion reported by Balasubramanian (2004).
231
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
Diagonal relationships. A number of analogies exist between element pairs, generally light elements in the upper left region of the Table, which in the Periodic Table are placed in a relative diagonal position; that is, there is a certain similarity between an element and the one to its lower right. A typical example is represented by Li and Mg, for which the similarity of the size of their ions Li (r 76 pm) and Mg2 (r 72 pm) may be relevant. Similarity in charge density of the ions has also been considered related to a resemblance in chemical behaviour: charge density (Rayner-Canham 2004) is defined as the ion charge (number of charge units times the proton charge in coulomb) per unit ion volume (in cubic millimetres). Other element pairs for which this kind of relationship has been underlined are: Be and Al, B and Si, N and S. ‘Divides’ in the Periodic Table. A particular scheme of subdivision of the Periodic Table has been presented by Stone (1979) and applied to the classification of alloying tendencies: it is summarized in Fig. 4.7. In this figure, a number of vertical lines, termed ‘divides’, have been drawn in particular positions of the Table. These are so placed that any element near a divide, and on one side of it, will form a compound or compounds with a counterpart element at the other side of that divide or, in other words, will form compounds with a specific bonding mechanism. The ‘ionic divide’, at group 18, separates elements at its immediate right, which easily form positive ions (cations), from those (halogens, chalcogens) which easily form negative ions (anions). Group number 4
Ti
5
6
V
Cr
7
8
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
1
2
H
He
Li
Be
Na Mg
B
C
N
O
F
Ne
Al
Si
P
S
Cl
Ar
K
Ca
Mn Fe
Co
Ni
Cu
Zn
Ga Ge
As
Se
Br
Kr
Rb
Sr
Rh Pd
Ag
Cd
In
Sb
Te
I
Xe
Cs
Ba
Zr
Nb Mo
Tc
Hf
Ta
Re Os
W
9
Transition metal divide
Ru
Ir
Pt
Sn
Au Composite divide
Covalent divide
Ionic divide
Figure 4.7. The metallurgist’s Periodic Table showing the four ‘divides’ proposed by Stone (1979). Notice that the position of the different groups has been shifted, in comparison with the conventional presentation of the Table, in order to give special emphasis to the ionic divide.
232
Intermetallic Chemistry
He
H Be
B
C
N
O
F
Ne
Na Mg
Al
Si
P
S
Cl
Ar
Li
Cr
Mn
Fe
Co
Ni
Cu
Zn
Ga Ge
As
Se
Br
Kr
Zr
Nb Mo
Tc
Ru
Rh
Pd
Ag
Cd
In
Sn
Sb
Te
I
Xe
Hf
Ta
W Re
Os
Ir
Pt
Au
Hg
Tl
Pb
Bi
Po
At
Rn
K
Ca
Sc
Ti
Rb
Sr
Y
Cs
Ba
La
Fr
Ra
Ac
V
Transition metal divide
Composite divide
Ionic divide
Tb
Dy
Ho
Er
Tm Yb
Lu
Pu Am Cm Bk
Cf
Es
Fm Md No
Lr
Ce
Pr
Nd Pm Sm Eu
Th
Pa
U
Np
Covalent divide
Gd
Figure 4.8. The metallurgist’s Periodic Table shown in the conventional layout. In comparison with Fig. 4.7, some of the divides have been slightly modified in their lower parts in order to better account for the properties of the heavier metals (Stone 1979, King 2004b).
As underlined by King (2004a), in addition to the noble gas divide, that is the ‘ionic divide’, at group 18, the ‘covalent divide’ at group 14 (C, Si, Ge, Sn, Pb) is also familiar in conventional chemistry: it separates ‘hyperelectronic’ elements like nitrogen, forming molecules with lone pairs from ‘hypoelectronic’ elements like boron, giving molecules with multi-centre bonding. The remaining two divides: the so-called transition metal divide at group 6 (Cr, Mo, W) and the composite divide at group 12 (Zn, Cd, Hg) were introduced by Stone on the basis of the alloying behaviour of the metals close to the divides themselves. For these divides too, the compound formation capability was related to the same rule. According to Stone, moreover, if two metals are near to, but on the same side of, such divides, no compounds are formed and some different phase diagram types, from solid solubility to liquid immiscibility, are observed. So, for instance iron, which is on the right of the transition metal divide, forms compounds with metals on the left of the same divide. On the other hand, considering the composite divide, metals close to it or to its right (such as Cu, Ag, Cd, Hg, In, Tl, Pb, Bi) do not form any compound with a metal, such as Fe, on the left of the same divide (compare with Fig. 5.25). In a more conventional representation of the Periodic Table, the Stone subdivision is shown in Fig. 4.8. However, in this figure, according to the so-called s–d shear
233
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table He
H Be
B
C
N
O
F
Ne
Na Mg
Al
Si
P
S
Cl
Ar
Li
Cr
Mn
Fe
Co
Ni
Cu
Zn
Ga Ge
As
Se
Br
Kr
Zr
Nb Mo
Tc
Ru
Rh
Pd
Ag
Cd
In
Sn
Sb
Te
I
Xe
Hf
Ta
Re
Os
Ir
Pt
Au
Hg
Tl
Pb
Bi
Po
At
Rn
K
Ca
Sc
Ti
Rb
Sr
Y
Cs
Ba
La
Fr
Ra
Ac
V
W
True metals
Meta-metals
Nonmetals
Tb
Dy
Ho
Er
Tm Yb
Lu
Pu Am Cm Bk
Cf
Es
Fm Md No
Lr
Ce
Pr
Nd Pm Sm Eu
Th
Pa
U
Np
Semimetals
Gd
Figure 4.9. The Periodic Table division suggested by Klemm (1950).
hypothesis proposed by Stone, slight deviations from vertical lines were introduced. This arrangement of the composite and of the transition metal divides is in better agreement with the general alloying behaviour of the metal families involved, and may be discussed in terms of their atomic and ionic electronic configurations. As we are considering this kind of subdivision of the Table, we turn our attention to the classification depicted in Fig. 4.9, introduced by Klemm (1950), and based on the tetra-partition of the elements into metals (true metals), meta-metals, semimetals and non-metals. According to King (2004b), typical properties of the four types of elements are the following: True metals: alkali, alkaline earth metals, Al, Cu, Ag, Au, etc., having a high specific electrical conductivity (Ohm1 cm1): κ 105–106 and crystal structures of high symmetry and coordination numbers (CN 8–12). Meta-metals: Be, Zn, Cd, Hg, In, Tl, Pb, etc., κ 104–105, crystal structures with small deviations from high symmetry (and CN 6 6, 8 4). Semi-metals: Si, Ge, Sn, As, Sb, Te, etc., κ 102–106, CN 2–4. Non-metals: N, O, S, Se, Halogens, etc., κ 106, low coordination numbers, molecular structures. 4.2.2.3 ‘Geochemical’ subdivision of the Periodic Table. The Goldschmidt’s geochemical classification of the elements in the Periodic Table is presented in Fig. 4.10
234
Intermetallic Chemistry He
H Be
B
C
N
O
F
Ne
Na Mg
Al
Si
P
S
Cl
Ar
Li
Cr
Mn
Fe
Co
Ni
Cu
Zn
Ga Ge
As
Se
Br
Kr
Zr
Nb Mo
Tc
Ru
Rh
Pd
Ag
Cd
In
Sn
Sb
Te
I
Xe
Hf
Ta
W
Re
Os
Ir
Pt
Au
Hg
Tl
Pb
Bi
Po
At
Rn
Ce
Pr
Nd Pm Sm Eu
Gd
Tb
Dy
Ho
Er
Tm Yb
Lu
Th
Pa
U
K
Ca
Sc
Ti
Rb
Sr
Y
Cs
Ba
La
V
Lithophile
Siderophile
Chalcophile
Atmophile
Figure 4.10. Geochemical classification of the elements in the Periodic Table, after Faure (1991). For a few elements (Tc, Pm, Pa) not indicated in the Table, no relevant data are available.
(Goldschmidt 1954, Faure 1991). The element subdivision siderophile (iron-loving), lithophile (rock-loving), chalcophile (copper-loving, implying however coppersulphide-loving, that is, sulphur-loving) and atmophile (atmosphere-loving) was proposed by Goldschmidt on the basis of systematic analyses of meteorite materials and sulphide ore smelting products. An interpretation of this classification scheme may be obtained by making reference to a complex system in which three melts (molten Fe–Ni alloy, sulphide and silica magma) are in equilibrium. It may be expected that a lithophile element (such as K) will be enriched in the silica magma, and therefore in the Earth’s crust, whereas a siderophile element (such as Pt, Au) will be especially enriched in the Fe–Ni melt, and therefore in the Earth’s core. The clustering in the Periodic Table of elements having similar behaviour is evident. Notice, however, the approximate character of this subdivision in which, for instance, no consideration has been given to the elemental valences. A typical example is the element chromium, which in a reducing ambient, that is as Cr3, is clearly a chalcophile, whereas in oxidizing conditions, as (CrO4)2, is a lithophile. This classification may of course be useful as a reference, when considering the occurrence in nature of the various elements and/or their preparation methods.
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
235
Figure 4.11. Superconducting elements in the Periodic Table (adapted from Cheetham and Day (1992)).
4.2.2.4 Superconducting elements in the Periodic Table. A further example of the applications of the Table is shown in Fig. 4.11, where for the different elements an indication is given of their superconductivity behaviour. A correlation exists between this behaviour and the position in the Periodic Table. 4.2.2.5 ‘Technological’ subdivision of the Periodic Table. As a concluding remark, we identify in the Table some classes of the most commercially important metals for which widespread common names are used. As an example, the following groups of important technological metals can be evidenced on the basis of their properties and applications (see Fig. 4.12). Notice also their clustering in the Table. Light metals (Densities are given in g cm): Be (1.845), Mg (1.738), Al (2.699), Ti (4.50). Alkali metals, especially Li (0.534), Na (0.97) may be considered as additional alloying metals to light alloys. Refractory metals (Melting point, in °C, are given): Zr (1855), Hf (2231), V (1910), Nb (2469), Ta (3020), Mo (2623), W (3422), Re (3186).
236
Intermetallic Chemistry
L
L
L
L
L L
R F
R R
F R
F
F
R F
R
F R F
R
F
C
P
P
P
P
P
P
P C P C
S S
S
S
S
S
Figure 4.12. The position in the Periodic Table of a few classes of commercially important metals. L: Light metals, R: Refractory metals, F: Ferro alloy metals, P: Precious metals, C: Coinage metals and S: Soft solder metals.
Precious metals Ag, Au, and the Pt group metals. Indicative prices (in euro g1), as listed in July 2006, are: Au: 10.68, Ag: 0.19, Pd: 5.24, Pt: 22.2, Rh: 38.7. Coinage metals Cu, Ag and Au Soft solder metals (Melting point, in °C, are given): Ga (29.8), In (156.6), Sn (231.9), Pb (327.5), Sb (630.7), Bi (271.4). Ferro alloy metals Cr, Fe, Mn, Mo, Nb, V, Ti, W. Notice however that, in the different categories, the use of some metals (for instance, Be, Pb) has been discouraged or banned for their high toxicity. 4.3. TRENDS IN THE PERIODIC TABLE: THE ROLE OF THE ATOMIC DIMENSIONS AS A FACTOR CONTROLLING THE STRUCTURE OF INTERMETALLIC PHASES
4.3.1 Introduction A systematic description of bond characteristics in intermetallic phases involves several different approaches. A bond characterization in intermetallics, as related to thermodynamic properties and considerations concerning the stability of intermetallic phases, has been reported by Ellner and Predel (1995). On this subject we observe the peculiar properties of alloys of extraordinary stability formed by
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
237
elements such as Al, Ti, Zr, Hf and the rare earth metals with the transition metals Re, Ru, Os, Rh, Ir, Pd, Pt, characterized by very high formation heats and discussed by Brewer (1973, 1990) as examples of generalized Lewis acid–base interactions in metallic systems. A general presentation and discussion of the origin of structure of crystalline solids and of the structural stability of compounds and solid solutions was given by Villars (1995) and Pettifor (1995). For an introduction to the electronic structure of extended systems, see Hoffmann (1987, 1988). In this chapter a brief sampling of some useful semi-empirical correlations and, respectively, of methods of classifying (predicting) phase and structure formation will be summarized. The search for regularities and criteria for the synthesis of new representatives of particular structure types has been carried out by many authors. Several factors have been recognized to be important in controlling the structural stability, and some of these were used as coordinates for the preparation of ‘classification and prediction maps’ in which various compounds can be plotted and separated into different structure domains. Intermetallic phases could be classified following the most important factor which controls their crystal structure (Pearson 1972, Girgis 1983, Hafner 1989, Westbrook and Fleischer 1995, Cahn and Haasen 1996). As a recapitulation of these points we may again refer to Pearson (1972), who underlined the role of the following factors in the classification of intermetallic phases: ● ● ● ●
Geometrical factor, Size factor. Chemical bond factor. Electrochemical factor (electronegativity difference). Energy band factor (electron concentration).
Some aspects of the mentioned relationships have been presented in previous chapters while discussing special characteristics of the alloying behaviour. The reader is especially directed to Chapter 2 for the role played by some factors in the definition of phase equilibria aspects, such as compound formation capability, solid solution formation and their relationships with the Mendeleev Number and Pettifor and Villars maps. Stability and enthalpy of formation of alloys and Miedema’s model and parameters have also been briefly commented on. In Chapter 3, mainly dedicated to the structural characteristics of the intermetallic phases, a number of comments have been reported about the effects of different factors, such as geometrical factor, atomic dimension factor, etc. on these characteristics. In the following paragraphs a few more remarks will be made on this matter. Emphasis, however, will be especially given to those aspects which are more directly related to the positions in the Periodic Table of the metals involved, and reference will be made to this in the presentation of systematic alloying behaviour schemes.
238
Intermetallic Chemistry
4.3.2 Atomic dimensions, interatomic distances in the intermetallic phases 4.3.2.1 Atomic radii and volumes. (Pauling’s rule, Vegard’s and Biltz-Zen’s formulae) With reference also to the previous paragraphs, some comments about the atomic dimension concept will help to present some characteristic parameters and diagrams, such as space-filling parameters, reduced strain parameters, nearneighbours diagrams, etc. As an introduction to this subject, it is necessary to mention the fundamental contribution by Viktor M. Goldschmidt (Goldschmidt 1928): mineralogist, geochemist and one of the founders of crystal chemistry. By considering the data concerning the crystal structures of several metals, the distance of closest approach of the atoms was assumed equal to twice the radius of hypothetical tangent spheres. In a body centred cubic cI2-type structure this distance is a3/2; in a cF4-type structure it is a2/2, where a is the unit cell edge, etc. Such direct comparison was made for a number of elements, in their stable crystalline forms, and completed with an analysis made by extrapolation of the interatomic distances found in alloys, in order to deduce the interatomic distances for unstable crystalline forms. As a result, Goldschmidt found for a given metallic element that in general the interatomic distance is about 3% less when the CN is 8 than when it is 12, it is 4% less when CN is 5 than when it is 12, and 12% less when it is 4 than when it is 12. Twice the radius for coordination 12, determined directly or deduced by extrapolation, is called the Goldschmidt atomic diameter. We underline these results and the implied concepts quoting from a comprehensive review on this subject (Simon 1983). We remember indeed that, ever since it was experimentally possible to determine atomic distances in molecules and crystals, efforts have been made to draw conclusions about the nature of the chemical bonding, and to compare interatomic distances (dimensions) in the compounds with those in the chemical elements. Distances between atoms in an element can be measured with high precision. As such, however, they cannot be simply used in predicting interatomic distances in the compounds. In a rational procedure, reference values (atomic radii) have to be ‘extracted’ from the individual (interatomic distances) measured values. Various functions have been suggested for this purpose. In the specific case of the metals it has been pointed out that interatomic distances depend primarily on the number of ligands and on the number of valence electrons of the atoms (Pearson 1972). Pauling has found empirically that there was a simple logarithmic relationship between the bond length R and the bond order Θ, namely: RΘ R1 A log10Θ
(4.1)
where A is a constant that depends on the particular element. For example, as well known, the single, double and triple carbon–carbon bond length decreases from
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
239
151 to 134 to 120 pm as the bond order increases from 1 to 2 to 3. In order to account for fractional bonds that arise due to resonance in carbon systems or metals, Pauling defined the resonant bond order by Θ N/z where N is the number of valence electrons per atom available for forming resonating electron-pair bonds between the z neighbours. Pauling showed that the above logarithmic relationship was valid not only for organic systems but also for transition metals, where A took the value of 0.6 Å, provided N was suitably chosen across the transition metal series. The quantifications of the valence-bond concept, of the bond order within the molecular-orbital framework, and a theoretical recovery of the empirical logarithmic relationship were discussed by Pettifor (2000). Pauling’s rule (Pauling 1947): Rn R1 30 log10 n (pm)
(4.2)
it relates the radius for bond order (bond strength) n (number of valence electron per ligand) to that of strength 1. It gives a mean of correcting radii for coordination and/or for effective valence. It has been shown (Pearson 1972, Simon 1983) that, no matter what the limitations may be of any particular set of metallic radii (or valences) that is adopted, Pauling’s relation appears to be reliable, giving a basis for comparing interatomic distances in metals. According to Simon (1983) slightly better results could be obtained by changing Pauling’s formula to: Rn R1(1 A log10 n)
(4.3)
where A is not a constant, but can be represented as a function of the element valence. The next point is to select a set of atomic radii which can be used when discussing interatomic distances. The radii given by Teatum et al. (1968), and reported in the different paragraphs of the Chapter 5 dedicated to the specific metals together with the assumed ‘valences’, are probably the most useful for discussing metallic alloys. These radii have been reported for a CN of 12; they were taken from the observed interatomic distances in the f.c. cubic cF4-Cu type structure and in the hexagonal close-packed hP2-Mg type structure (averaging the distances of the first two groups of six neighbours, if the axial ratio does not have the ideal (8/3) 1.633 … value) or from the b.c. cI2-W type. Since the coordination is 8 in the cI2-W type structure, for the elements having this structure the observed radii were converted to coordination 12 by using a correction given by the formula: RCN 12 1.0316 RCN 8 0.532 (pm)
(4.4)
240
Intermetallic Chemistry
which was empirically obtained from the properties of elements having at least two allotropic modifications, cI2-W type and either cF4-Cu type or hP2-Mg type. The radii in the two structures, calculated at the same temperature by means of the known expansion coefficients, were compared and used to construct the reported equation. For the other metals, that is for the more general problem of the radius conversion from any coordination to CN 12, a percentage correction was applied by using a curve which ranges from about 3% for the conversion from CN 8 to CN 12 to about 20% for the conversion from CN 3 to CN 12, as suggested by Laves (1956) in a detailed paper dealing with several aspects of crystal structure and atomic sizes (see Fig. 4.13). As for covalent-ionic bonding, we mention a formula reported by Shomaker and Stevenson (1941) which gives the shortening of covalent bond length with increasing ionic bonding character according to: dA–B RA RB 0.09 |Δη|
(4.5)
where Δη is the electronegativity difference.
18 16
Percent correction
14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 2
4
6
8
10
12
14
Coordination number
Figure 4.13. Atomic radii of metals and their dependence on the CN. In order to obtain the value corresponding to coordination 12, the given percent correction has to be added to the radius observed for a given CN.
241
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
For an indication of the values of the atomic radii of the different elements and of their trend along the Periodic Table, see Figs 4.5 and 4.14. Notice the variations along each period (each horizontal sequence in Fig. 4.14) and the smaller values (and their small changes) for the metals in the middle of the transition block. Notice also in the lanthanide sequence the greater dimensions of the ‘divalent’ Eu and Yb. While dealing with atomic dimension concepts, atomic volumes may also be considered. A value of the volume per atom, Vat in a structure can be obtained from the room temperature lattice parameter data by calculating the volume of the unit cell and dividing by the number of atoms within the unit cell. An equivalent atomic radius could be obtained by computing, on the basis of the space-filling factor of the structure involved, the corresponding volume of a ‘spherical atom’, and then using the relationship Vsph 4πR3/3 (see the space-filling concepts in § 4.3.2.5). In the cP2-W type (CN 8) structure Vsph is 0.68 Vat (only a portion of the available space is occupied by the atomic ‘sphere’). In the cF4-Cu type and in the ‘ideal’ hP2-Mg type (CN 12) structures, Vsph is 0.74 Vat. Considering now the previously reported relationship between RCN 12 and RCN 8, we may compute for a given element very little volume (Vat) change in the allotropic transformation from a form with CN 12 to the form with CN 8, because the radius variation is nearly
Group number 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
Figure 4.14. Atomic dimensions of the elements. In this scheme each element, represented in its position of the Periodic Table, is indicated by a circle the diameter of which is roughly proportional to the atomic radius for coordination 12 (Teatum et al. 1968).
242
Intermetallic Chemistry
counterbalanced by the change in the space-filling. This is generally in agreement with the experimental observations (Pearson 1972). We will see that on the basis of the atomic dimensions of the metals involved, expressed, for instance, as RX–RY or RX/RY, many characteristic structural properties of an XnYm phase may be conveniently discussed and/or predicted (size factor effect). As a comment to the atomic dimensions concept, two ‘rules’, Vegard’s and BiltzZen’s rules, formulated for solid solutions, and to a certain extent for ordered compounds can be mentioned here. These rules, mutually incompatible, are very seldom obeyed; they may however be useful either as approximations or for defining reference behaviours. The first one, Vegard’s rule (1921), corresponds to an additivity rule for interatomic distances (or lattice parameters or ‘average’ atomic diameters). For a solid solution AxB1x (x atomic fraction) between two components of similar structure it takes the form (dAB interatomic distance, dA and dB atomic diameters): dAB xdA (1 x)dB
(4.6)
The Biltz (1934) or Zen (1956) rule has been formulated as a volume additivity rule: VAB xVA (1 x)VB
(4.7)
These rules are only roughly verified in the general case. For the evaluation of interatomic distances weighted according to the composition and for a discussion on the calculation and prediction of the deviations from Vegard’s rule, see Pearson (1972) and Simon (1983). According to Goldschmidt (1928) the two ‘rules’ may be represented by only one more general expression: dABn xdAn (1 x)dBn
(4.8)
where n (1 or 3 in the two mentioned hypotheses) has to be determined in the different cases. As contributions to the general issue of predicting the variation of the average atomic volume in alloying a few different approaches can be mentioned. Miedema and Niessen (1982) calculated atomic volumes and volume contractions on the basis of the same model and parameters used for the evaluation of the formation enthalpy of the alloy (see § 2.2.1.3). In a simple model proposed by Hafner (1985) no difference of electronegativity and no charge transfer were considered. Volume and energy changes in the alloy formation were essentially related to elastic effects. Good results have been obtained for alloys formed between s and p block-elements. An empirical approach has been suggested by Merlo (1988). Deviations from the
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
243
Biltz–Zen trend have been discussed and represented as a function of a ‘charge transfer atomic parameter’ which correlates with Pauling’s electronegativity. This approach has been successfully employed for groups of binary alloys formed by the alkaline earths and the divalent rare earth elements. In a review on this subject (Fornasini and Merlo 2006), the binary phases MeXn formed by Me Ca, Sr, Ba, Eu and Yb with Li, Be and with the elements from the groups 7th to 15th (X) were considered. For some details on these alloys see § 5.4.4.3. For several series of this group of alloys, the experimental trend vs. composition of the average atomic volume (Vexp) was compared with the reference linear trend of the alloy volume (Vcal) additively calculated. Generally a volume contraction (ΔV Vcal Vexp) was observed. Fornasini and Merlo studied the so-called ‘integral volume effect’ represented in the V vs. x diagram by the area contained between the calculated and experimental lines and given by: 1
ΔVint
∫
(Vcal Vexp )dx
(4.9)
0
For the group of alloys considered, the trend of this quantity vs. the position in the Periodic Table of the partner element X was discussed. High values were observed for the alloys of Ni, Pd, Pt, Hg and a roughly regular trend was noticed from a minimum within the region of the Cu, Ag, Zn, Cd alloys to a maximum for the As, Sb and Bi compounds. For a given X element, the highest ΔVint values were generally shown by the Sr and Ba alloys, while lower (and comparable) values were observed for the Ca, Eu and Yb phases. Empirical correlations for the prediction of the ΔVint values were discussed and possible relations examined between volume changes and heats of formation. As previously remarked, negative experimental deviations from additive rules and values of the volume contractions have sometimes been considered as an approximate indication of the formation of strong bonds and related to more or less negative enthalpies of formation. Kubaschewski (1967), for instance, discussed several ideas on the relationships between volume changes (and coordination changes) and heats of formation. However, the indication obtained is only very poor in the general case. For selected groups of alloys, the existence of a correlation between the formation volume and (ΔformV and ΔformH) has been pointed out, even if only as an evaluation of relative trends. 4.3.2.2 Relationship between ΔformV and ΔformH for selected groups of alloys. Gschneidner’s formulae. With reference to the previous considerations, for particular groups of alloys relationships between ΔformV and phase stability may be suggested. This is the case of the rare earth (R) alloys. As noticed by Gschneidner
244
Intermetallic Chemistry
(1969), considering the trivalent members of the lanthanide series, we may compare the decreasing atomic volume observed in the metals (R) (lanthanide contraction) with the decreasing of the average atomic volume measured in a series of RMeX compounds with a metal Me. If this diminution is more (less) severe in the compounds than in the R metal series, this is considered an indication that the bonding strength in the RMeX compounds increases (decreases) as we proceed along the series from La to Lu; the heats of formation are expected to increase (decrease) in the same order. To make this comparison, the unit cell volumes of the compounds are divided by the atomic volumes of the pure metals. The volume ratios for the series of compounds are then divided by that corresponding to a selected rare earth, giving a relative scale. If the resultant values increase with the atomic number of the rare earth, then the lanthanide contraction is less severe in the compounds in comparison to the rare earth element, and a decrease of the heat of formation is expected. Conversely, if the relative volume ratio decreases, an increase of the heat of formation (more negative enthalpy of formation) is expected. Examples of this correspondence are examined in Fig. 4.15. 4.3.2.3 Atomic dimensions and an example of stability multi-diagrams. The role of atomic dimensions in defining the alloying behaviour can be highlighted considering characteristic ‘families’ of metals and alloys, such as, for instance, a selected group of alloys of the rare earths. The rare earth metals (R metals), that is, Sc, Y and the lanthanides, and especially the so-called ‘trivalent’ ones, that is with the exception of the ‘divalent’ europium and ytterbium, form a characteristic group of elements within which several properties change according to systematic well-defined patterns. A few details on this point are given in Chapter 5, in the paragraphs dedicated to this family of metals. This behaviour is reflected in a number of regularities that can be noticed when examining the alloy systems formed by the different rare earth metals with a given element, and when considering the progressive change of the constitutional properties of these alloys on passing from one lanthanide to the next one. The binary (R–Mg) and ternary (R –R–Mg) magnesium alloys with one or two different rare earth metals form a group of systems which may be particularly illustrative as an example of a special alloying behaviour and also as an application of a method (the multi-diagrams) which can be convenient for a compact and systematic presentation of the general alloying behaviour of alloy families. A multidiagram is just an assembly of different phase diagrams arranged according to certain rules, conveniently summarizing the behaviour of several alloys systems. In a number of favourable cases, this may give an indication of factors on which the alloy stability depends. Figs. 4.16 and 4.17 show a summary of the alloying behaviour of Mg with the different rare earths through a selection of the various binary diagrams. As far as the trivalent rare earths are concerned, on passing from one rare
245
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
Volume ratio relative to Cerium
ΔHf (kJ/mol of atoms)
(a) −30
RIn3
RTl3
−40 −50 −60 (b) 1.1 1.0 0.9 (c)
Reduced melting temperatures
1.3 1.1 0.9 0.7 0.5
Ce Nd Sm Gd Dy La
Pr
Pm Eu
Tb
Er
Yb
Ho Tm
Lu
Ce Nd Sm Gd Dy La
Pr
Pm Eu
Tb
Er
Yb
Ho Tm
Lu
Figure 4.15. Gschneidner’s plot for two groups of rare earth alloys (RIn3 and RTl3 compounds). The following data are reported as a function of R atomic number: (a) formation enthalpy; (b) volume ratio relative to cerium; (c) reduced melting temperature TR. This is the ratio (K/K) of the melting point of the phase and of the melting point of the involved metal (( ) experimental values and (䊊) hypothetical values (reference values) of TR computed for compounds assumed to have a constant melting point). The difference between the experimental and computed slopes of the TR curves is considered to be an indication of the thermal stability variation of the phases along the series. In these cases, all the diagrams show, for the two groups of alloys, decreasing phase stability for an increase of the atomic number.
•
earth to the next we have a progressive change in the shape of the equilibrium curves and a more or less gradual change in the stoichiometries of the compounds. These changes may be compared with the progressive change of the melting point of the lanthanide which becomes higher and higher on moving from the first to the last one. The similarity between the Y–Mg system diagram and those given by the first heavy earths is remarkable. This may be related to the similar atomic dimension of Y and Dy or Ho. On the other hand, the different behaviour of the divalent
246
Intermetallic Chemistry
1500
1500
1000
1000
500
500
La
Mg
Pr
1500
1500
1000
1000
500
500
Gd
Mg
Dy
1500
1500
1000
1000
500
500
Er 0
50
Mg
Mg
Y
100
0
Mg
Mg 50
100
Figure 4.16. Rare earth–magnesium binary systems. A few selected diagrams of ‘trivalent’ lanthanides are shown. Notice the progressive regular changes on passing from the ‘light’ to the ‘heavy’ lanthanides. Notice also the similarity of the Y–Mg diagram with those of the heavy lanthanides.
lanthanides and their analogy with another divalent metal, such as the alkaline earth calcium, can be noticed when comparing the Yb–Mg and Ca–Mg diagrams. As for the trivalent lanthanides (and Y) their compounds with Mg correspond to the following formulae and structure types: RMg12 (oI338-CeMg12 type, R La and Ce and tI26-ThMn12 type for Ce and Pr); R2Mg17 (hP38-Th2Ni17, R La, Ce); R5Mg41 (tI92-Ce5Mg41, R La, Ce, Pr, Nd, Sm);
247
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table 1500
1500
1000
1000
500
500
Yb 0
50
Mg
Ca
100
0
Mg 50
100
at.% Mg
Figure 4.17. The binary phase diagrams of the magnesium alloy systems with the divalent metals ytterbium and calcium (Ca is a typical alkaline earth metal and Yb one of the divalent lanthanides). Notice, for this pair of metals, the close similarity of their alloy systems with Mg. The compounds YbMg2 and CaMg2 are isostructural, hexagonal hP12-MgZn2 type.
RMg5 χ1 (cF448-GdMg5 type, R Sm, Gd, Tb); R5Mg24 χ2 (cI58 αMn, Ti5Re24 type, R Y, Tb, Dy, Ho, Er, Tm, Lu) having a composition very close to that of previous χ1; RMg3 (cF16-BiF3 type, R La, Ce, Pr, Nd, Sm, Gd, Tb, Dy); RMg2 (cF24-Cu2Mg type R La, Ce, Pr, Nd, Sm, Gd stable only at high temperature for La, Ce, Pr, Nd, or hP12-MgZn2 type R Y, Tb, Dy, Ho, Er, Tm, Lu); RMg (cP2-CsCl type R Y, La to Lu); R2Mg (high temperature phase, cI2-W type R Ho, Er, Tm). These data are summarized and collected in the multi-diagram of Fig. 4.18, prepared as a collection of isothermal sections of the different R–Mg phase diagrams. In Fig. 4.18 the La–Mg, Ce–Mg, Pr–Mg, etc. segments representing these sections have been placed side by side in a triangle with the Mg vertices in common. The points corresponding to the different R have been placed on the opposite side of the triangle in positions corresponding to their atomic dimensions. The values of the ionic radii (R3) resulted in a convenient measure of these dimensions. The intermediate phases formed in the various binary systems have been represented, in a first approximation, as point compounds. The points, which in the different binaries correspond to phases having the same composition and structure, have then been connected, defining multi-component ternary stability fields (in this case, line fields). On each horizontal line of this multi-diagram triangle the same overall composition is found (the same Mg content and the same total
248
Intermetallic Chemistry Mg R2Mg17
χ1
80
χ2
RMg12 R5Mg41 ~RMg5 RMg3
Mg
HT
c
h
RMg2
at.
%
60
RMg 40 HT
~R2Mg
20
103.2
101
99 98.3
97
95.8 94.7 93.8 92.8
La
Ce
Pr Nd Pm Sm
Gd Tb
Eu(3 +)
91.2 90.1
Dy
89
88 86.8 86.1
Ho Er Tm Y
Lu
Yb(3+)
Figure 4.18. Multi-diagram of the Mg alloys of the trivalent rare earths. Isothermal sections of the different R-Mg diagrams (La–Mg, Ce–Mg, Pr–Mg, etc.) are arranged in a triangle with Mg placed at the common vertex. On the multi-element side of the triangle, the trivalent lanthanides (and yttrium) have been placed according to their atomic dimensions, which, in this case, are appropriately represented by the radii of the trivalent ions. The values, in pm, of the radii are shown. The horizontal segments inside the triangle connect the isostructural phases of the different binary systems. Notice nearly on the same line the two separate, but overlapping, fields of the χ1 and χ2 phases. In the case of Tb both structures have been observed. The symbol HT on the RMg2 and R2Mg lines represents phases stable only at high temperature; c and h indicate the cubic and the hexagonal Laves phases RMg2.
content of rare earth metal). Notice, for instance, the formation of the RMg phases (cP2-CsCl type) with all the rare earths. The stability regions of these structures include the complete range of the atomic dimensions depicted. For the Laves type RMg2 compounds, the cubic type is given by the light R (for the first ones, only as high-temperature stable phases); the hexagonal Laves type, on the other hand, is formed with the heavy R. For different composition values notice also the intersecting stability fields of χ1 and χ2 formed for an R/Mg ratio close to 1/5.
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
249
In the limits of an alloying behaviour almost solely dependent on the atomic dimension parameter, it should not be relevant how a certain value of the atomic dimension is obtained, that is, either as the characteristic elemental value of a pure metal (a pure lanthanide) or as the resulting averaged value of a mixture of various metals (two different lanthanides). In the specific case of the lanthanides, this behaviour may be related to the concept of pseudo-lanthanides introduced by Gschneidner (1980). A pseudo-lanthanide is defined as a material which contains in a given ratio two rare earth metals (except Sc and the divalent ones Eu and Yb) and which may be expected to display physical (constitutional) properties similar to those of the specific true lanthanide which is being simulated. A typical pseudo-lanthanide may be prepared, for instance, by alloying La and Lu. Alloys containing increasing quantities of Lu will progressively simulate the behaviour of Ce, Pr, Nd, etc. The sequence of crystal structures observed in these pseudo-lanthanides, their polymorphic transformations and melting temperatures are generally in agreement with those of the true rare earth metals. It must be noted, however, that certain physical properties which depend directly on the 4f electrons, such as the optical properties, cannot be duplicated in the pseudo-lanthanides. The behaviour, moreover, of the ‘divalent’ rare earths, Eu and Yb, which is different from that of the other ‘normal’ rare earths, cannot be simulated by a mixture of trivalent lanthanides. The multi-element side of the triangle shown in Fig. 4.18 can therefore represent (simulate) not only the pure trivalent lanthanides, but also all their mixtures. A mixture for instance of La and Gd, the representative point of which is placed somewhere between the La and Gd points, may be considered a ‘simulation’ of Pr or Sm (or even of another mixture for example of Pr and Nd) depending on its composition and on the corresponding average atomic radius. These considerations can be extended to the entire triangle of Fig. 4.18, the internal points and regions of which may be considered simulations of specific, more complex, ternary alloys and systems prepared by combination of Mg with a mixture of two lanthanides. An application of these concepts is shown in Fig.4.19 where a simulation of the diagram Y–Pr–Mg (Giovannini et al. 1995a) is obtained from the multi-diagram and compared with the experimental diagram of the same system. In the two cases (the portion of the multi-diagrams included between Pr and Y and the experimental Y–Pr–Mg diagram) we have on the Y–Pr base side a similar sequence of atomic dimensions; in the first case this corresponds to the decreasing radius of the intermediate lanthanides; in the other case to the decreasing average radius of the various Y–Pr mixtures. On the basis of the predominant role played in this case by the atomic dimensions, which defines the alloying behaviour of the lanthanide with Mg, each of the two diagrams may be considered a ‘simulation’ of the other. Notice indeed that a similar arrangement of the various single-phase fields may be observed in the two triangles.
250
Intermetallic Chemistry Mg
Mg
RMg12
PrMg12
R5Mg41
10 Pr5Mg41 Pr
χ1
at.
%
20
c
h
∗
40
RMg
Y5Mg24
∗
80
∗
PrMg3 30
RMg2
τ
Mg
RMg3
∗
90
∗
70 YMg2
∗
λ∗
60
PrMg
99 98.3
95.8
93.8 92.8 91.2 90.1
Pr Nd
Sm
Gd Tb
Dy
%
χ2
∗
a t.
~RMg5
∗
YMg 10
20
30
40
at.% Y
Y
Figure 4.19. The Y–Pr–Mg region, as ‘extracted’ from the multi-diagram of Fig. 4.18, is shown on the left. The experimentally determined isothermal section of the ternary system Y–Pr–Mg is shown on the right. (The significant regions corresponding to a Mg content higher then 50 at.% are displayed). Notice the qualitatively similar arrangement of the different phases in the two diagrams. With an increasing Mg content the following phases are observed in the two diagrams: CsCl-type phase (corresponding to the PrMg–YMg continuous solid solution); Laves phases (c and h and, in the experimental diagram, the λ phase, cubic and the hexagonal YMg2-based solid solution); RMg3 (PrMg3-based solid solution in the experimental diagram) partially extending into the ternary field; the χ1 and χ2 phases and, in the experimental diagram, the corresponding GdMg5-type ternary phase (τ) and the Y5Mg24-based solid solution and, in the Mg-richest region, the R5Mg41 and RMg12 phases partially extending in the ternary field.
Especially noteworthy is the behaviour of the χ1-phase, ideally corresponding to the cF448-GdMg5 type, which seems to be stable only for an intermediate value of the lanthanide radius. In the binary systems it is indeed observed only with Sm, Gd and Tb, but neither with Pr nor with Y. This behaviour is observed however for ternary Mg alloys with both Pr and Y, a mixture of which, with its value of the average atomic radius, simulates a lanthanide having an intermediate value of the atomic radius. Similar results have also been obtained in the investigation of a number of other Mg ternary systems with two different lanthanides: Y–La–Mg (Giovannini et al. 1995b), Y–Ce–Mg (Flandorfer et al. 1997), Y–Gd–Mg (Giovannini et al. 1997). The schemes described are useful for collecting experimental data, preparing crucial experimental work and giving some ‘predictions’, at least for selected groups of
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
251
alloys and phases; even though not always valid and subject to experimental verification. As ‘prediction maps’ (see § 4.4.7.1), the mentioned diagrams can provide additional guidelines for planning the preparation of complex alloys and for designing their characteristics and composition. A description of other groups of alloys performed with similar maps, even if based on different parameters, is given in § 4.4.6. 4.3.2.4 Partial molar (atomic) volume. Another useful and general way of discussing the actual trend in an alloy system of the average molar dimensions, as represented for instance by the molar (average) volumes, is through the definition and use of the partial molar (atomic) volume. The partial molar quantity of a molar quantity Q, related to the component A, is – generally written as QA and is defined by: ⎛ ∂Q ⎞⎟ ⎟⎟ QA ⎜⎜⎜ ⎜⎝ ∂nA ⎟⎠ T , P,n ,n i
(4.10) A
The following rules generally apply to the partial molar quantities: Σi xi Qi Q
(4.11)
(where xi is the molar fraction of species i) and, on differentiation, Σi xi dQi 0
(4.12)
In a binary A–B system, from the graph of the integral quantity vs. composition, the partial values may be obtained, for each composition z, from the intercepts on the A and B axes of the tangent, at the composition z, to the integral curve. The construction is very simple in the special case that, in a certain range of compositions, the curve of the integral quantity is close to a straight line. As an example for the specific case of vanadium alloys with palladium, the trend of the average atomic volume of the alloys is shown in Fig. 4.20 and compared with the phase diagram. These data were obtained by Ellner (2004) who studied the solid solutions of several metals (Ti, V, Cr, Mn, Fe, Co and Ni) in palladium. The alloys were heat treated at 800°C and water-quenched. From the unit cell parameters measured by X-ray diffraction methods, the average atomic volume was obtained Vat a3/4 (see Table 4.3). These data together with those of the literature were reported in a graph, – and the partial molar (atomic) value of the vanadium volume in Pd solid solution (Vv)
252
Intermetallic Chemistry (a)
Temperature (°C)
1910
1600 1555
1200 (Pd)
(V)
Pd
10
20
PdV3
Pd2V
Pd3V
800
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
V
at.% V
Average atomic volume (V/pm3 × 106)
(b) 14.5 14.0
Vat,V
13.5 VV
13.0 12.5
Pd
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
V
at.% V
Figure 4.20. Palladium–vanadium system. In (a) the phase diagram is shown: the phase sequence at 800°C is indicated. The corresponding trend of the average atomic volume is shown in (b). For – pure vanadium the value of the partial atomic volume in Pd solution is indicated (Vv, as obtained by extrapolation from the Pd-rich alloys) and, as a reference, the elemental atomic volume (Vat,V) of the pure metal.
was obtained by extrapolation (see Fig. 4.20). This value is reported in Fig. 4.21 together with those similarly obtained for other metals. The partial atomic volumes are compared, in the same figure, with the atomic volumes of the pure non-alloyed metals. Notice that for Sc, Ti, V and Cu, Zn, Ga there is a ‘lattice compression’ in alloying – (VMe VMe), whereas for Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni there is an expansion. The relation between this trend and the values of the partial molar enthalpy of formation (measured or computed) for the metal Me dissolved in Pd has also been discussed. Generally
253
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table Table 4.3. Unit cell parameters and average atomic volumes for palladium and Pd(V) solid solution (adapted from Ellner (2004)). Composition (at.%)
Unit cell parameter (face centred cubic cF4) (a/pm)
Average atomic volume (Vat /pm3 106 Vcell/4)
Average molar volume (NA Vat /cm3 mol1)
Pd Pd98V2 Pd96V4 Pd94V6 Pd92V8 Pd90V10 Pd85V15 Pd80V20
389.11 (1) 389.09(2) 388.46(2) 388.14(2) 387.84(1) 387.51(2) 386.95(1) 386.50(1)
14.728 14.726 14.655 14.619 14.585 14.548 14.484 14.434
8.869 8.868 8.825 8.804 8.783 8.761 8.772 8.692
24
Atomic volume (Å3 )
22 20 18 16 14 12 Sc
Ti
V
Cr
Mn
Fe
Co
Ni
Cu
Zn
Ga
Figure 4.21. Solid solutions of transition metals (Me) in palladium. The elemental atomic volumes of the pure metals (VMe, open circles) and their partial atomic volumes in Pd solid – solution (VMe, filled circles) are shown (adapted from Ellner (2004)).
– increasing values of ΔHMe have been observed for an increasing value of the ‘lattice deformation’ (compression or expansion). The methodology for obtaining the partial atomic volume and its application as a ‘realistic’ measure of atomic size in metals and alloys has been discussed by Bhatia and Cahn (2005): they illustrated its use as a powerful tool in understanding the behaviour of solid solutions in both ordered and disordered states.
254
Intermetallic Chemistry
4.3.2.5 Geometrical considerations about intermetallic crystal structures. When discussing the factors which control the structures of the metallic elements, Laves (1956) proposed three interrelated principles that are mainly geometric in character and also related to the atomic dimensional characteristics: (i) The principle of highest symmetry (symmetry principle). (ii) The principle of the greatest number of connections (connection principle). (iii) The principle of efficient (economical) use of space (space-filling principle). These principles may be considered to be valid to a certain extent for the intermetallic phase structures and not only for the metallic elements. (See also some comments on this point as a result of the atomic environment analysis of the structure types summarized in § 3.7.5.) 4.3.2.5.1 The principle of highest symmetry (symmetry principle). According to Laves, a tendency to build configurations with high symmetry is evident. This tendency is particularly clear in metallic structures, especially in the simple ones. However, according to Hyde and Andersson (1989), for instance, the validity extension of this principle is difficult to evaluate. As time passes, crystallographers are able to solve more and more complex crystal structures, and these tend to have low symmetry. The symmetry principle could be restated by observing that a crystal structure has the highest symmetry compatible with the efficient use of space and the specific requirements of chemical bonding between nearest neighbours. For a discussion on the ‘symmetry principle’, its alternative formulations and the history of its development, papers by Brunner (1977) and by Bärninghausen (1980) may be consulted. In these papers a number of statements are reported which may be considered equivalent. When considering close sphere packings, the following statements are especially worthy of mention. (a) A tendency to form arrangements of high symmetry is observable. (b) Points are disposed around each point in the same way as around every other. (c) Atoms of the same type tend to be in equivalent positions. 4.3.2.5.2 The principle of the greatest number of connections (connection principle). To understand the meaning of this principle it may first be necessary to define the concept of connection. To this end we consider a certain crystal structure and imagine connecting each atom with the other atoms present in the structure by straight lines. There will be a shortest segment between any two atoms. We will
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
255
then delete all links except the shortest ones. After this procedure, the atoms that are still connected constitute a ‘connection’. The connection is homogeneous if it consists of structurally equivalent atoms; otherwise it is a heterogeneous connection. Such connections may be finite or 1, 2, 3 dimensionally infinite and are respectively called islands, chains, nets or lattices. Symbols corresponding to the letters I, C, N, L (homogeneous connections) or i, c, n, l (heterogeneous connections) have been proposed. (See also the dimensionality indexes reported in § 3.7.3.) As pointed out by Laves (for instance, Laves 1967) metallic elements and intermetallic phases show a tendency to form multidimensional, possibly homogeneous, connections (connection principle). 4.3.2.5.3 Space-filling principle. The tendency to use space economically (to form structures with the best space-filling), which is especially exemplified by the closest packing of spheres, is considered to be the result of a specific principle which operates in metal structures (and also in ionic and, to a lesser degree, in Van der Waals structures). This principle is less applicable to covalent crystals because, for these crystals, the characteristic inter-bond angles are not necessarily compatible with an efficient use of space. Among the metallic elements, 58 metals possess a close-packed arrangement (either cubic or hexagonal) which, in the assumption that the metal atoms are non-deformable spheres having fixed diameters, corresponds to the best space-filling; 23 of the remaining metals crystallize in another highly symmetric structure, the body centred cubic, which corresponds to a slightly less efficient space-filling. The space-filling concept has been analysed and discussed by several authors, among which Laves (1956), Parthé (1961) and Pearson (1972). A short summary of this discussion will be reported in the following, together with some considerations on the atomic dimension concept itself. 4.3.2.5.4 Space-filling parameter (and curves). The space-filling parameter introduced by Laves (1956) and by Parthé (1961) is an index which may be useful in studying the relationships between atomic dimensions and structure. For a compound it is defined by the ratio between the volume of atoms, assumed as spheres of well-defined radii in a unit cell, and the volume of the unit cell itself. ϕ (4π/3) ΣiniRi3/Vcell
(4.13)
(ni, Ri are number and radius of type i atoms). To calculate the space-filling value for a specific compound, one has to know the radii of the atoms and the lattice constant. Neither of these is needed for the construction of a space-filling curve of a crystal structure type: it is sufficient to know the point positions of the atoms and the axial ratios. The curve is based on a hard sphere
256
Intermetallic Chemistry
model of the atoms: the cell edges are expressed as functions of the atomic radii (RX and RY for a binary system) for the special cases of X–X, X–Y and Y–Y contacts. The parameter can then be given (and plotted) as a function of the RX/RY ratio. Considering, for instance, the cF8-ZnS-sphalerite type structure (containing 4 Zn 4 S in the unit cell) the space-filling (Parthé 1964) can be given by: ϕ [4π/3(4R 3X 4R 3Y)]/a3
(4.14)
where a is the cubic cell edge and RX and RY are the radii of the atoms in the (a) and (c) positions in the unit cell (4 Zn in 0,0,0;0, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 0, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 0; and 4 S in 1⁄4, 1⁄4, 1⁄4; 1⁄4, 3⁄4, 3⁄4; 3⁄4, 3⁄4, 1⁄4; 3⁄4, 1⁄4, 3⁄4; respectively). See the structure description in Chapter 7. In the case that the two atoms (or, more accurately, the hard spheres) occupying the Zn and S sites are touching each other, then the sum of the two radii must be equal to one-quarter of the cubic cell diagonal: RX RY a 3/4
(4.15)
By expressing the unit cell volume as a function of the sum of the radii: ϕ (4π/3)(4R X3 4 R Y3)/[(43/33)(R X R Y)3]
(4.16)
Introducing the radius ratio ε RX/RY: ϕ (–3π/4) (ε3 1)/(ε 1)3
(4.17)
This equation describes the middle section (0.225 ε 4.44) of the space-filling curve for the sphalerite type structure plotted (with log scales) in Fig. 4.22. The other sections, 0 ε 0.225 and 4.44 ε l correspond to the cases in which Y–Y atoms or X–X atoms are touching. In the ϕ vs. ε diagram every structure type is generally characterized by its own individually shaped space-filling curve. The space-filling curves, however, of all binary structures belonging to one homeotect structure set coincide with one curve (see § 3.9.2). By assuming appropriate values for the radii RX and RY it is possible to compare the points representing the actual compound with the specific curve of a given structure. Generally a good agreement is found for ionic structures (and/or compounds) while it is often observed that the ϕ vs. ε points for particular metallic phases lie above the space-filling curves, indicating a denser packing and emphasizing the lack of unique radii associated with X–X, X–Y, etc. contacts (compressible
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
257
0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6
CsCI
j
NaCI
0.5
0.4 NaTI 0.225
0.3 0.2
ZnS 0.414
0.3 0.4
0.731
1.365
0.6 0.8 1.0
2.42
2.0
4.44
3.0 4.0 5.0
ε = Rx /Ry
Figure 4.22. Space-filling curves for compounds having the NaCl, CsCl, NaTl or ZnS type structures. For the different structures, the ratio ϕ between the volume of atoms (assumed as spheres of well-defined radii) contained in the unit cell and the volume of the unit cell itself is shown as a function of the ratio between the radii of the two atom types. (Notice the log scales.)
atom model) (Pearson 1972). In the specific case of unary structures (element structures), providing that there are no variable atomic positional parameters or axial ratios, there is a unique space-filling parameter (independent of atomic size for every structure type). For the cF4-Cu type structure, for instance. ϕ (4π/3)(4R3/a3)
(4.18)
Assuming the atoms to be hard spheres a 22 R, then ϕ π/(32 ) 0.740 (which is the highest value for an infinite collection of close-packed hard spheres of the same radius). Typical space-filling parameters of elemental structures are the following: cF4-Cu type ϕ 0.740 hP2-Mg type ϕ 0.740 (for the ‘ideal’ value, c/a 1.633.., of the axial ratio, ϕ 0.65 in the case, for instance, of Zn, for which c/a 1.86) cI2-W type ϕ 0.680 tI4-β Sn type ϕ 0.535 (for c/a 0.5456) cP1-Po type ϕ 0.524 cF8-Diamond ϕ 0.340
258
Intermetallic Chemistry
Several other considerations and applications of the space-filling concept can be found in Parthé (1961), for instance: space-filling diagrams of ternary structures, applications of space-filling concept for discussing and predicting possible pressure structures, etc. Volumetric Index A treatment similar to that previously described has been made by Liu and Bassett (1986) defining a special ‘volumetric index’ α, considering that the molar volume V of a crystal must be a linear function of the cube of the nearest neighbour interatomic distance dmin 3 V αd min
(4.19)
where α is a function of the axial ratio, axial angle(s) and positional parameters of a crystal structure. Within a group of isostructural substances, small variations are therefore generally observed in the α-value. If dmin is given in nm and V in cm3/mol (moles of atoms or moles of formulae), the following α-values may be mentioned. 425.9 (cF4-Cu); 425.9 to 485.0 (hP2-Mg for 1.633 c/a 1.86); 463.6 (cI2-W); 589.7 (tI4-βSn, c/a 0.5456); 602.2 (cP1-Po); 927.2 (cF8-diamond); 927.1 (cP2CsCl); 1204.4 (cF8-NaCl); 1843 (hP4-C graphite); etc. The α-values are the slopes in the plots of molar volume vs. the cube of interatomic distances for given types of structures such as those illustrated in Fig. 4.23. These indexes (as the space-filling parameters) may be useful for instance in a systematic description of the effect of pressure on the phase transformations which may be observed for a given compound. In a discussion of high-pressure phases of elements, oxides and silicates, with implications for the Earth’s interior, Liu and Bassett (1986) presented data relevant to several families of compounds in a number of graphs such as those of Fig. 4.23. The transformations at increasing pressure from C graphite to diamond, from Si and Ge diamond type to βSn type, the modifications of a number of 1:1 compounds from NaCl to CsCl type structure and also for elements, such as Cd and Zn, the preservation of the same structure, but with c/a approaching the ‘ideal’ 1.633 value, can all be effectively summarized in this graph type. More complex considerations, however, are necessary when a change in the ‘valence’ of specific atoms and significant changes in their own volume occur as a function of pressure. Reduced dimensional parameters (strain parameters and near-neighbours diagrams) By comparing the space-filling theoretical curves and the actual values of intermetallic phases it has been observed that an incompressible sphere model of the atom gives only a rough description when discussing metallic structures.
259
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
3
3′ z
4 5 ′′
5′
5
-C s P2
8 -N aC I an
dc
cF
hp4 -C
d) on
40
20 4-
cF
Po =1 1/a cP g c M 2.63 hP =1 /a c -W Mg cI2 2hP d an
Cu
0.05 3
d min
n
βS 4-
t1 .86
ia m (d
2
60 C
y
cF 8-
Molar volume
1
Molar volume (cm3/mol)
80 x
CI
(b) (gra phit e)
(a)
0.10
3
d min (nm3)
Figure 4.23. Molar volumes, VM, of selected groups of phases as a function of nearest neighbours interatomic distances (dmin). On the left a schematic trend is shown for hypothetical X, Y, Z, structural types. Generally a single straight line corresponds to each structure. The range of values assigned to Y could represent a structure for which, for instance, owing to different c/a axial ratios, different values of VM may correspond to the same dmin. The arrows 1 : 2, 2 : 3 or 2 : 3 , etc. represent different structure transformations observed by increasing pressure. On the right, the trends calculated for a group of common crystal structure types are shown.
Pearson (1972) suggested the use of a model which allows the atoms of a binary X–Y alloy to be compressed until, according to the structure geometry, X–X, X–Y are Y–Y contacts are established. The contacts are considered to occur when the X–X, X–Y and Y–Y interatomic distances in the compound structure, dX, dXY and dY are equal to 2 RX (DX), RX RY and 2 RY (DY) (RX, RY, DX, DY are the atomic radii and diameters, respectively). According to Pearson, the metallic radii chosen are those appropriate for the coordination of the atoms. The distances between all the close atoms in the structure may be expressed in terms of the cell (and atomic site) parameters. As an example, see the phases XY3, AuCu3 type, described in §3.7.7 and in Figs. 3.27 through 3.29. In these phases around each X atom there are 6X atoms at a distance equal to the unit cell edge dX a. Around the X atoms there are 12Y atoms at a distance dXY a2/2, and around the Y atoms 8Y and 4X atoms at the same distance dY a2/2. All these distances may then be expressed as a function of one of them, selected as a reference. In the case of the AuCu3 type phase, for instance: dXY dX 2/2,
dY dX 2/2
(4.20)
260
Intermetallic Chemistry
A reduced strain parameter is then defined with reference to an arbitrarily selected set of contacts. With reference to the dX distances the strain parameter may be defined as: S (DX dX)/DY. This parameter gives an indication of the atomic dimension compression. It is computed, as a function of the ratio ε DX/DY RX/RY, for the different kinds of interatomic contact. In the aforementioned AuCu3-type phases, we have three cases corresponding to X–X, X–Y and Y–Y contacts. If X–X atoms are touching dX DX, then the strain parameter SXX will be (DX dX)/DY 0
(4.21)
– for all the ε values. If X–Y atoms are considered to be in contact, dXY dX2/2 will be equal to 1⁄2(DX DY) so we will have: SX–Y DX/DY dX/DY DX/DY dXY2/DY DX/D Y (1⁄22Dx 1⁄22Dy)/DY
(4.22)
If, on the other hand, the Y–Y atoms are those which are considered to be in contact we will have: dY dX2/2 DY; dX DY2
(4.23)
SYY DX/DY 2Dy/DY DX/DY 2
(4.24)
and:
The values of the strain parameters are then plotted, according to Pearson (1972), as a function of ε RX/RY. Several straight lines are obtained (see Fig. 4.24). The lines corresponding to the reference contacts are horizontal and set at zero. What matters is only the relative position of the different straight lines (which does not change by taking another contact as the reference one: a rotation will only be obtained of the whole diagram). The diagram is called near-neighbour diagram. In the diagram, points may also be plotted which represent actual phases. To this end the experimental dX, dXY, etc., values will be used. According to Pearson (1972), when a point representing a specific phase has a larger value of the strain parameter than that of a particular contact line, then the contacts corresponding to that line are to be considered compressed, on the basis of the DX and DY assumed for the components. If, on the other hand, the experimental points lie below a line then those contacts have not been established. Fig. 4.24(a)–(c) represent the data and the trends for a few structure types. For compounds having the cF8-ZnS sphalerite structure it can be seen that the X–Y (Zn–S)
261
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table (a) XY3 (AuCu3 type)
8
Y Y− X−X
Strain parameter
0
6
−0.2
X−Y
12−4
−0.4
−0.6 0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
1.6
e = Rx /Ry (b)
(c) XY2 (Cu2Mg type)
XY (ZnS type) 12
Y–
Y
0.4
0.6
0.2
Y–
Y X– 12–6 0.2
X–X
0
Strain parameter
Strain parameter
6 Y
0.4
X–X
0
12
−0.2 −0.4
4–4
4 −0.6
1.0
1.2
1.4
e = Rx /Ry
1.6
X–Y
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
1.6
e = Rx /Ry
Figure 4.24. Near-neighbour diagrams for binary phases calculated according to Pearson (1972) for a few structural types. The lines calculated for the different interatomic contacts are shown. The numbers of contacts X–Y, Y–X, X–X, etc. are indicated. The experimental values determined for the various compounds are contained, for each structure type, within the hatched fields. (a) XY3 compounds belonging to the cP4-AuCu3 structural type; (b) XY2 Laves phases of the cF24-Cu2Mg type; (c) XY compounds of the cF8-ZnS structural type. Notice the importance of the high coordination contacts in the more metallic phases, whereas in the ZnS-type compounds the role of the chemical bond factor is clearly relevant.
262
Intermetallic Chemistry
bonds, corresponding to a tetrahedral coordination, are the most important in controlling the structural characteristics. The different experimental points, representing actual compounds, are very close indeed, for a wide range of diameter ratios and of electronegativity differences, to the line corresponding to the X–Y contacts (the X–X and Y–Y contacts are not formed). The structure can, therefore, be considered as formed by a skeleton of presumably covalent X–Y bonds (directional in character). An X–Y chemical bond can similarly be recognized as important in several compounds having cF12-CaF2 type (or antitype), cF16-Li3Bi, hP3-CdI2, hP8-Na3As, etc., type structures. The different behaviours of more ‘metallic’ phases can be seen in Fig. 4.24(a) and (b). The AuCu3 type near-neighbour diagram (Fig. 4.24(a)) shows the importance of contacts corresponding to high coordinations. A similar trend can be observed for the XY2 Cu2Mg-type Laves phases (see Fig. 4.24(b)) for which, moreover, a certain compression of the X–X contacts generally results. The X–X curve is, for ε 1.25, far below the data points. Many near-neighbour diagrams have been presented by Pearson (1972) and systematically discussed for several structure types in order to show the importance of parameters such as geometrical or chemical bond factors in controlling the occurrence and structural characteristics of different phases. For an analysis of the meaning and the applications of these diagrams, see also Simon (1983). A representation of structure families for alloy phases with given XYn compositions has been presented, in generalized near-neighbour diagrams, and discussed. 4.4. REMARKS ON THE CHEMICAL BOND FACTOR AND VALENCE-ELECTRON COUNTING RULES
… …the name is BOND, Chemical bond… …. (Paraphrase of Fleming’s 007 saga)
4.4.1 Introduction A chemical bond factor can be considered to control the structure when interatomic distances, and as a consequence unit cell dimensions, can be said to be determined by a particular set of chemical bonds. Two extreme situations can be taken into consideration (these are especially well defined when small atomic groups are involved): (i) Bonds having high ionic characteristics: these are largely non-directional; the larger anions tend to form symmetrical coordination polyhedra subjected to limitations related to the anion/cation atomic size ratio and the stoichiometry of the compounds is controlled by the balance of the ionic electric charges.
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
263
(ii) Bonds having covalent character: the localized covalent bond has generally a short range of action (where generally there is a strong bond) extending only from one atom to the next one. The directional and ‘saturation’ characteristics related to this bonding mechanism tend to determine the structural and stoichiometric arrangements in the phase. 4.4.2 Normal valence compound rule To an increasing weight of the chemical bond factor (ionic and/or covalent bonding) will correspond, as an extreme case, the formation of valence compounds. According to Parthé (1980), a compound CmAn can be called a normal valence compound if the number of valence electrons of cations (eC) and anions (eA) correspond to the relation meC n(8 – eA) (normal valence compound rule, octet rule)
(4.25)
If we consider only the s and p block elements without the noble gases, the number of valence electrons of the elements is included between 1 and 7. In this case, considering that no anions are formed from the elements of groups 1, 2 and 3, the following formulae can be deduced for the normal valence compounds, formed in binary systems with large electronegativity difference between elements: – 144 – 224 – 3443 – 135 – 2352 – 35 – 4354 – 126 – 26 – 3263 – 462 – 5265 – 17 – 272 – 373 – 474 – 575 – 676 In these formulae each element is indicated by a number corresponding to its number of valence electrons; for instance: 17 indicates NaCl or KCl, KBr; 3263 indicates Al2O3, etc. In the more general case where some electrons are also considered to be used for bonds between cations or between anions we have: m(eC eCC) n(8 – eA – eAA) (general valence compound rule)
(4.26 a)
In this formula, which can only be applied if all bonds are two-electron bonds and additional electrons remain inactive in non-bonding orbitals (or, in other words, if the compound is semiconductor and has non-metallic properties), eCC is the average number of valence electrons per cation which remain with the cation either in nonbonding orbitals or (in polycationic valence compounds) in cation9cation bonds; similarly eAA can be assumed to be the average number of anion9anion electron-pair bonds per anion (in polyanionic valence compounds).
264
Intermetallic Chemistry
Notice, moreover, that the last equation may be rewritten in the form: m(eC – eCC – eip) n(8 – eA – eAA) (general valence compound rule) (4.26b) if we wish to explicitly indicate the number of not available electrons, eip, such as the inert pair 6s2 in Tl. When one component in a binary alloy is very electropositive relative to the other, there is a strong tendency to form compounds of high stability in which valence rules are satisfied (Pearson 1972). Such alloys are considered to show a strong electrochemical factor. 4.4.2.1 ‘Tetrahedral structures’. In a more limited field than that of the previously considered general octet rule, it may be useful to mention the ‘tetrahedral structures’ which form a subset of the general valence compounds. According to Parthé (1963, 1964, 1991), if each atom in a structure is surrounded by four nearest neighbours at the corner of a tetrahedron, the structure is called ‘normal tetrahedral structure’. In accordance with Parthé (1964), a few more details about these structures are introduced. In a normal tetrahedral structure every atom has 4 near neighbours at the vertices of a surrounding tetrahedron. The shape of such a tetrahedron will determine regular and distorted tetrahedral structures. In a defect tetrahedral structure not all the four vertices are occupied by an atom. A filled tetrahedral structure contains extra-atoms inserted in a normal tetrahedral structure. The bonding mechanism, however, may be different from that of the other tetrahedral structures and, generally, less simple relations are observed between the number of valence electrons and structure. The general formula of the normal tetrahedral structure, for the compound CmAn, is: (meC neA) 4(m n)
(4.27)
that may be considered a formulation of the so-called Grimm and Sommerfeld Rule (1926). For the same elements previously mentioned the possible combinations are: 4X4Y (all compositions, for instance, C, Ge, SiC) 35 (BP, AlSb, etc.), 26 (BeO, MgTe, ZnS), 17 (CuBr, AgI), 326, 337, 252 (ZnP2, ZnAs2), 2372, 153 and 1263.
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
265
For instance, for a compound 2372 we have, according to the formula reported (3 2 2 7) 4 (3 2) Ternary or more complex combinations may be obtained by a convenient addition of different binary formulae; for instance: 14253 (153 44): for instance CuGe2P3 1362 (1263 326)/2: CuAlS2, CuInTe2, etc. 122464 (1263 26 4): for instance Cu2FeSnS4 (FeII), etc. The aforementioned rule may be extended to include the ‘defect tetrahedral structures’ where some atoms have less than four neighbours: (meC neA) 4(m n) NNBO(m n) (general tetrahedral structure) (4.28) In this formula NNBO is the average number of non-bonding orbitals per atom. By adding the symbol 0 (zero) to the described notation, vacant tetrahedral sites can be represented. Examples of formulae of defect tetrahedral structures are: 40374 (SiI4, SnI4); 4062 (GeS2); 3605463 (Ga6As4Se3), 1252064 (CuSbS2); etc. Notice that the aforementioned compositional scheme is a necessary condition for building the tetrahedral structures, but not every compound that fulfils this condition is a tetrahedral compound. The influence of other parameters, such as the electronegativity difference, has been pointed out. By means of diagrams, such as that reported by Mooser and Pearson (1959) (average principal quantum number vs. electronegativity difference) the separation of tetrahedral structures from other structures can be evidenced. 4.4.2.2 Valence compounds: notes for a classification (VEC and partial VEC). In several compounds, the so-called Valence-Electron Concentration (VEC) proved to be a parameter relevant to their composition, structure and stability. For a compound CmAn the VEC parameter is defined by: VEC
meC neA mn
(average valence -electron numb ber per atom) (4.29)
where m and n are the composition indexes in the formula and eC and eA the numbers of valence electrons of the elements C and A.
266
Intermetallic Chemistry
Notice that for the alkali and alkaline earth metals and all the elements to the right of the 10th group the valence-electron numbers are 1, 2 and, respectively assumed to be given by the group number minus 10. For the transition elements, various assumptions have been used in some cases. For certain families of compounds it may be convenient to separate the VEC into partial VEC values. It is possible to define the following partial VEC values (Parthé 1969) relative to the ‘cationic’ and ‘anionic’ components: VECC
meC neA m
(4.30a)
VEC A
meC neA n
(4.30b)
and
According to the conventional simple chemical definition, the valence compounds are those in which individual atoms are assumed to reach a ‘filled valence shell’ by accepting, donating or sharing electrons. This definition was first applied to the compounds (normal valence compounds) where the cations may donate the exact number of electrons to complete the valence shells (particularly the octet shells) of every anion. In this case we have: VECA (VECanion) 8
(normal valence compound)
(4.31)
This concept was then extended to include compounds having anion9anion or cation9cation bonds, that is, the so-called polyanionic or polycationic valence compounds, assuming: VECanion 8
(polyanionic valence compounds)
(4.32a)
VECanion 8
(polycationic valence compounds)
(4.32b)
and
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
267
These relations may be included in the following general formula (Parthé 1969, compare with (4.25)): VECanion 8
m e eAA n CC
(4.33)
in which eCC is the average number of cation9cation bonds per cation (the average number of electrons per cation not involved in cation9anion bonds) and eAA is the average number of anion9anion bonds per anion. This equation can be applied if all bonds are two–electron bonds and additional electrons are inactive in non-bonding orbitals of cations and anions. These compounds are therefore semiconductors; the equation is not applicable to compounds of metallic character. Similar classification criteria may be made by using the total valence–electron concentration previously defined (see equation 4.27) and defining, according to Parthé (1995) the tetrahedral structure equation: meC neA VEC 4 N NBO mn
(4.34)
According to Parthé (1995) a convenient description and classification of several structures of several tetrahedral compounds may be performed as in the following: VEC 4: a tetrahedral structure cannot be formed. VEC 4: a normal tetrahedral structure is formed with NNBO 0. VEC 4: a compound with a defect tetrahedral structure may be obtained with NNBO 0. 4.4.3 Polyanionic compounds 4.4.3.1 Zintl phases: an introduction. The Zintl phases are a large number of substances which in a way may represent a bridge, a transition, between the ionic and the intermetallic compounds. The expression ‘Zintl Phases’ was introduced by Laves (1941) in recognition of the work carried out by E. Zintl. In papers describing new compounds of this family, Jiang et al. (2005), Jiang and Kanzlarich (2006) reminded that Zintl phases are valence-specific compounds formed between electropositive elements, such as alkali metals, alkaline earth metals, or rare earth elements, and the main group elements. There are a significant number of Zintl compounds of the alkali or alkaline earth metals with the elements of the 13th through 16th groups. Although less is known about the rare earth compounds, Jiang et al. (2005) underlined a recent flurry of research on them because of their promising thermoelectric properties. Superconductivity has been discovered in
268
Intermetallic Chemistry
several Zintl compounds. Moreover unique magnetic, electronic, magneto-resistive properties have been observed in several new compounds. A comprehensive book on chemistry, structure and bonding of Zintl compounds has been edited by Kauzlarich (1996); in this book several aspects of Zintl phases such as structural patterns, molecular transition complexes of Zintl ions, transition metal Zintl compounds are deeply discussed. A traditional example of a Zintl phase is represented by NaTl which may be considered as a prototype of the Zintl rules. The structure of this compound (face centred cubic, cF16, a 747.3 pm) can be described (see also § 7.4.2.2.) as resulting from two interpenetrating diamond type lattices corresponding to the arrangements of the Na and Tl atoms respectively (Zintl and Dullenkopf 1932). Each Tl atom therefore is coordinated to other four Tl at a distance a3/4 747.33/4 323.6 pm which is shorter than that observed in elemental thallium (d 341–346 pm in αTl, hP2-Mg type, CN 6 6) and d 336 pm in β Tl, (cI2-W type, CN 8). NaTl was described by Zintl as NaTl with Tl corresponding to a diamondlike framework 3 [Tl4/4] isostructural and isoelectronic with diamond 3 [C4/4]. The Na ions, owing to their small dimensions (r 97 pm) can be considered isolated and inserted in the holes of the Tl framework. The electron transfer from the alkali metal to the other element, which assumes a partial structure similar to that of the electron-richer elements of the next group, has also been assumed for other compounds (Klemm and Busmann 1963). It is now defined as Zintl–Klemm concept the assumption of the formation of negatively charged ions (anions) resulting in partial structures which are identical to those of the (neutral) main group elements having the same number of valence electrons. In NaSi, for instance, the structure (monoclinic, side-centred mS32) contains regular tetrahedra of Si atoms between which the Na atoms are situated. Accordingly we have the overall composition NaSi in which, however, the silicon ions have a discrete (molecular like) tetrahedral structure Si44similar and isoelectronic to the typical molecules P4 or As4 present in white phosphorus or yellow arsenic. The distances Si9Si in a tetrahedron are 240–249 pm; the Na–Si distance is about 292 pm and the Na9Na distance about 322 pm. The NaSi structure may also be compared with that of NaGe (mP32) in which tetrahedra of Ge atoms are contained (and Na in the intervening space) even if there is a somewhat different arrangement of the tetrahedra. As another example, CaSi2 (hR18), which could be considered as Ca2 Si2 2 , may be examined. The structure can be regarded as a filled-up As-like arrangement. The silicon atoms, described as having an average charge Si, form rumpled double layers (again as found in the next group elements black phosphorous and grey arsenic). These Si layers form 63 nets which are arranged in the sequence abc and are interleaved with 36 nets of Ca atoms. Typical interatomic distances in this structure are: Si9Si: 251–252 pm, Ca9Si: 298–311 pm, and Ca9Ca: 389 pm.
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
269
More complex examples of Zintl phases are given by ternary compounds in which the anionic part of the structure may be compared for instance to molecular halides. This point is illustrated by Ba4SiAs4 which can be described as (Ba2)4(SiAs4)8 in which the (SiAs4)8 group is isostructural to the tetrahedral molecule SiBr4. A similar description may be used for Ba3AlSb3 considered as (Ba2)6(Al2Sb6)12 in which the (Al2Sb6)12group is isostructural to the dimer molecule Al2Cl6 formed by two Al-centred Cl tetrahedra having a common edge (2Cl atoms). See Fig. 4.25. As an indication, however, of the limits of the Zintl interpretation and with reference to the prototypal NaTl structure, notice that the description of the filled tetrahedral structures given by Zintl cannot be considered valid generally (with all the elements). An example is the occurrence of this structure in compounds such as LiZn or LiCd in which the diamond-like framework of Zn and Cd atoms cannot obtain the four electrons necessary to give sp3 hybrids. 4.4.3.2 Zintl phases: remarks on their definition. We have seen that the Zintl phases may be considered as a group of compounds formed by an electropositive (cationic) component (alkali, alkaline earth metal, lanthanide) and an anionic component (for instance a main group element of moderate electronegativity). The anionic part of the structure may be described in terms of normal valence combination. In a review, Van der Lugt (1996) observed that a number of liquid alloys (K–Pb, Rb–Pb, Cs–Pb, K–Sn, Rb–Sn, Cs–Sn, K–Te) behave as if all the anions were in the form of perfect simple Zintl anions like tetrahedra and dumbbells: this being suggested by the behaviour of many physical properties (resistivity, thermodynamic properties, etc.) as a composition function. In this context a simple Zintl ion was defined as a polyanion that assumes the same configuration as a neutral isoelectronic element. A similar definition was reported by Van der Lugt and Verkerk
Al
Sb
Figure 4.25. Structure of the (Al2Sb6)12 ion (isostructural with the Al2Cl6 molecule) identified in the Zintl compound Ba3AlSb3. Another important compound having this structure, consisting of two-centred tetrahedra with a common edge, is the simple di-borane (B2H6).
270
Intermetallic Chemistry
(2002): Zintl ions are polyanions formed by anion clustering in ionic alloys. Two categories were considered: those that fit the so-called Zintl–Klemm concept and those that are electron-deficient. In a more detailed description and according to Nesper (1990), the criteria for defining the Zintl phases may be summarized in the following points: (i) The Zintl phases can be described within the group of normal valence compounds and a well-defined relationship can be assumed within their electronic and chemical structures. (ii) Zintl phases should be semiconductors (energy gaps less than 2 eV) or, at least, they show increasing electrical conductivity with increasing temperature. (iii) Zintl phases are mostly diamagnetic, but they can be paramagnetic. However they should not show temperature independent (Pauli) paramagnetism as observed for normal metals. As underlined by Miller et al. (2002) in a comprehensive review about structure and bonding around the Zintl border of the Periodic Table, the Nesper criteria imply that Zintl phases (as valence compounds) are generally point compounds and may have a semi-metallic behaviour. A review about the Zintl phases has been published by Sevov (2002); from the introduction of this publication we quote a few remarks. It was preliminary observed that the number of Zintl phases has increased many-fold since Zintl’s time and that the definition of a ‘Zintl phase’ has never been very exact: often compounds that include non-metals have been considered in this family. The paper by Sevov is mainly dedicated to clearly intermetallic Zintl phases (that is phases containing main group metals, semi-metals or semiconductors only). Attention has therefore been dedicated to compounds of alkali metals with the elements of the 13th, 14th and 15th groups (without B, Al, C, N and P). To this end the following definitions and statements have been considered. Zintl phases are compounds that: (i) contain an alkali (or alkaline earth) metal and a p block element (a metal, semi-metal or small-gap semiconductor), (ii) are closed-shell compounds (electronically balanced, that is the number of electrons given by the constituents is that needed for covalent bonding in the structure), (iii) are point compounds, (iv) are brittle, (v) are semiconductors (or poor conductors), (vi) are diamagnetic or display very weak, temperature independent, paramagnetism.
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
271
According to these definitions, making full reference to his own vast investigation, Sevov presented typical groups of Zintl phases. These are: (i) Zintl phases with delocalized bonding: corresponding to isolated clusters, mainly of the elements of the 13th and 14th groups such as Cs4Ge9 where the clusters Ge94 are monocapped square anti-prismatic, nido deltahedra, or, as another example, the substituted , hetero-atomic, 11-atom clusters of group 13 represented by [In10Hg]8, [Tl9Au2]9, [Tl8Cd3]10. (ii) Zintl phases with interconnected (homo- and hetero-atomic) clusters mainly given by alkali metals and 13th group elements. Generally in these compounds two types of bonding are combined: delocalized within the clusters (endo-bonds) and localized (2c,2e exo-bonds) between them. Several Ga compounds have been described. (iii) Zintl phases with localized bonding. Compounds containing only 2c,2e (two centres–two electrons) bonds between the p-elements (generally at least two different p-elements). In the introduction to this group of phases attention has been especially given to compounds containing tetrahedral units often formed by one of the p-elements and centred by the other. Examples may be: isolated Sn-centred Sb tetrahedra in Na8SnSb4, corner and edge shared Ga- (or In) centred As tetrahedra in K3Ga3As4, K3In2As3, etc. 4.4.4 ‘Cluster’ compounds 4.4.4.1 Cluster compounds: introductory remarks. The word ‘cluster’ was introduced by F.A. Cotton in the early 1960s to describe compounds containing metal– metal bonds. However its meaning has progressively changed to include other substances containing element9element bonds, such as main group polyhedra, and any molecule containing metal9metal bonds. For a detailed historical account, see Cotton and Walton (1982). Clusters have become progressively important in a variety of fields which include inorganic chemistry, organo-metallic and bio-inorganic chemistry, and several subjects of solid state and of intermetallic chemistry. Quoting from ‘Highlights in inorganic chemistry over the last 100 years’ by McCleverty (2004), significant landmarks in the history of the chemistry of cluster compounds are mentioned in the following. The chemistry of small metal atoms cluster compounds grew naturally out of metal carbonyl chemistry (Lewis, Johnson 1970s onward), but the discovery that high nuclearity metal carbonyl clusters could be isolated caused an explosion in the field. Possibly key discoveries in this area were made by the Chini group (late 1970s) with the noble metals (especially Rh, Pt). The rationale synthesis of these complexes, using simple techniques and readily available starting materials, is a beautiful example of creative inorganic chemistry at its best (see
272
Intermetallic Chemistry
for instance Longoni and Chini 1976). Further noteworthy developments in the chemistry of all the metals of the 8th, 9th, 10th groups were supported by the theories of cluster bonding (Wade, Mingos) and by the application of the isolobal principle (Hoffmann 1982). This principle states that two molecular fragments are isolobal if the number, symmetry properties and approximate energies of their frontier orbitals are the same; they may or may not also be isoelectronic. It was also observed that in the development of the chemistry of various types of cluster compounds, including for instance the Chevrel phases, the role of the X-ray crystallography cannot be underestimated. Considering now the authoritative treatise by Cotton and Wilkinson (1988), the following assertions can be stated: ●
●
The formation of polyhedral cages and clusters is a widespread phenomenon; examples can be found in nearly all parts of the Periodic Table. A cluster may be considered, in a sense, the antithesis of a complex even if there are many similarities between the two groups of compounds due to common symmetry properties. In both cases a set of atoms defines the vertices of a polyhedron; in the complex, however, these atoms may be considered as bound to another, central, atom and not to each other. In the cluster, on the other hand, there is not necessarily a central atom and the atoms at the vertices can be described as directly connected to each other.
As underlined by Mingos and Wales (1990), according to Cotton and Walton (1982) the following statement can be considered as a first-approach working definition: a metal cluster compound may be defined as a group of two or more metal atoms where ‘direct and substantial’ metal9metal bonding is present. The presence of such metal9metal bonding could be deduced by a comparison between the metal9metal bond lengths with the sum of the covalent radii which should not be exceeded by, say, more than 15%. Examples may be given by the following series of compounds for which the metal9metal distance (d) is reported together with the sum of the metal radii (Σ): [Mo6Cl8]4 (d 2.62, Σ 2.80), [Co(C5H5)(μ2PR2)]2 (d 2.56, Σ 2.50). This concept, however, may be ambiguous and problematic especially when the metal atoms are connected to bridging ligand atoms and also because variations in the metal9metal bond length may be observed between different compounds having a similar bonding scheme. Nevertheless a formal metal9metal bond designation may be assumed in order to underline a relation with the simple bonding schemes based on the inert gas rules (‘octet’ rule). It has been noticed moreover that in metal cluster chemistry a difference in quality is observed when the sizes of the clusters being progressively characterized are
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
273
sufficiently large to make meaningful comparison of properties with either bulk metals or metal surfaces. A point worth indeed to be underlined is that clusters can be considered intermediate in character and structure between molecules and solids. The shapes of many clusters are based on polyhedra such as the tetrahedron and octahedron. These polyhedra have triangular faces: a feature also common in the structures of metals. The close packing in many metals leads to the occurrence of tetrahedra and octahedra. Having particularly in view intermetallic substances (crystals, quasicrystals) a critical discussion by Steurer (2005) on several questions concerning clusters (definition, stability, etc.) is especially interesting (see also § 4.4.4.8). Two books to which the present authors are greatly indebted and which represent a comprehensive introduction to different aspects of the chemistry of clusters and their applications are Introduction to Cluster Chemistry by D.M.P.M. Mingos and D.J. Wales (1990) (presenting several theoretical and experimental aspects and a classification of different types of clusters) and Applications of Graph Theory and Topology in Inorganic Cluster and Coordination Chemistry by R.B. King (1993) in which the mathematical background, principles from topology, graph and group theories, atomic orbitals and their hybridization are presented with their applications to cluster chemistry. 4.4.4.2 Cluster compounds and remarks on the ‘2e, 2c bonding scheme’. A formal metal–metal bond designation may be introduced having as reference the simple bonding schemes based on the inert gas rules (‘octet’ rule). A reference picture for the bonding between atoms is indeed related to the electrons which are needed for an atom to obtain the electron configuration of the next noble gas in the Periodic Table. In the specific case of a pair of electrons shared by two atoms, each atom gains one electron in its valence shell. The energy decrease of the shared electron pair ‘links’ the two atoms (the two centres) and we speak of a ‘two electron-two centre bond’ (2e, 2c bond). According to Müller (1994), a cluster may be defined as an accumulation of three or more atoms of the same element (or of similar elements) directly linked with each other. If there is a sufficient number of electrons in the cluster to have an electron pair for every connection between two adjacent atoms, then to each of these connections a 2e, 2c bond can be assigned, as in a normal valence-bond compound. Assuming moreover that, through the formation of such bonds, the atoms at the vertices of the (ring or polyhedron) cluster achieve an ‘inert gas configuration’ (8 valence electrons for a main group element and 18 for a transition element), we will have a kind of reference cluster structure with limiting values of the bond and electron numbers.
274
Intermetallic Chemistry
In this case the total number of valence electrons (Σe) in the cluster will be given by: Σe 8n 2B (main group elements) or by Σe 18n 2B (transition elements) where n is the total number of atom (vertices) in the metal cluster (Mn) and B the number of 2-electron bonds (number of edges in the cluster skeleton). In a ring cluster (a ring molecule) the number of edges is equal to the number of vertices (atoms) B n, so we have: Σe 8n 2n 6n
(main group element ring)
or Σe 18n 2n 16n
(transition metal ring)
For triangular clusters, for instance, this means 18 or 48 electrons. A classic example may be the Os3 triangular group in the carbonyl compound Os3(CO)12 in which 4 CO are connected to each Os (to each triangle vertex). Each Os atom contributes 8 valence electrons whereas the CO group acts as a 2-electron donor so: Σe 3 8 2 12 48 in agreement with the result obtained from the previously reported formula. More complex cluster structures may correspond to a higher number of bonds (edges) converging on each vertex: the symbol nx may be defined indicating the number of vertices (of degree x) at which x edges (metal–metal bonds) meet. The previously reported formulae can be rewritten:
or:
Σe 6n2 (2e, 2c bound main group element ring) Σe 16n2 (2e, 2c bound transition metal ring)
More generally: Σe 7n1 6n2 5n3 4n4 (2e, 2c bound main group element cluster) or: Σe 17n1 16n2 15n3 14n4 (2e, 2c bound transition metal cluster) (nx for x 4 are not indicated, because vertices of higher degrees have generally never been observed in such clusters).
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
275
For a tetrahedron, for instance, there are 4 vertices in each of which 3 edges meet: it is an example of three-connected cluster. Therefore:
or:
Σe 5n3 5 4 20 (2e, 2c bound main group element tetrahedral cluster) Σe 15n3 15 4 60 (2e, 2c bound transition metal tetrahedral cluster)
Examples may be: Ir4(CO)12 (3 CO attached to each Ir vertex). The electron count based on 9 electrons for Ir atom and 2 electrons for CO group, corresponds to Σe 4 9 12 2 60, in agreement with the computation made on the basis of the mentioned tetrahedral structure. K4Ge4, can be described as a polyanionic compound (as a Zintl phase also) containing the ion Ge44. This tetrahedral ion can be considered a naked (that is without any ligands bounded to the vertices) tetrahedral cluster formed by a main group element (that is Σe 5n3 5 4 20). The electron count, on the basis of the Ge valence electrons and of the ion charge results in Σe 4 4 4 20. Molecules such as P4, As4, Sb4 may also be considered in this context and described according to this formalism. Notice however that the reported formulae are valid only in the limiting case of clusters having all the edges corresponding to 2e, 2c bonds; cluster compounds having other (higher or lower) numbers of electrons are frequent, and, as a consequence, various different classes of clusters may be defined. 4.4.4.3 Wade electron counting rules: borane-like cluster nomenclature. On initially studying compounds such as boranes (boron hydrides) and carboranes (or carbaboranes boron9carbon hydrides), Wade (1976) proposed a number of rules which have then been extended to several compounds and which relate the number of skeletal electrons with the structure of deltahedral clusters. A polyhedron which has only Δ-shaped, that is triangular, faces is also called a deltahedron. The following nomenclature is generally used: Closo-cluster: (a cage) a complete deltahedral group. Nido-cluster: (a nest) a deltahedral structure with one missing vertex. Arachno-cluster: (a spider-web) a deltahedral structure with two missing vertices. Hypho-cluster: (a net) a deltahedral structure with three missing vertices. The following optimum electron numbers have been defined on the basis of the so-called ‘Polyhedral Skeletal Electron-Pair Theory (PSEPT)’. Closo, nido, arachno, hypho deltahedral clusters based on n main group vertex atoms are characterized by 4n 2, 4n 4, 4n 6 and 4n 8 total valence electrons respectively. The corresponding optimum VEC for closo and nido deltahedra
276
Intermetallic Chemistry
Valence electron concentration
5
15
4.8
14.8
nido
4.6
14.6
4.4
14.4
closo
4.2
14.2
4
14 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
n (number of vertices)
Figure 4.26. Optimum values, in accordance with Wade’s rules and as summarized by Miller et al. (2002), of the valence electron concentration VEC (total number of electrons divided by the cluster atom number) as a function of the number of cluster atoms for closo and nido deltahedra. On the left the values computed for the main group elements and on the right those relevant to the transition metals.
is shown, according to Miller et al. (2002), in Fig. 4.26. For the analogous clusters based on n transition metal atoms the valence-electron numbers are 14n 2, 14n 4, 14n 6 and 14n 8 respectively. Examples of the application of the mentioned rules to a few naked metal clusters according to Mingos and Wales (1990) are reported in Table 4.4. For each species the valence electron (s and p) count is made both on the basis of the component valences by adding/subtracting one electron for each negative/positive charge, and on the basis of the geometry and the number of vertices. In addition to the rules reported, a relation between the total electron count (TEC) and the number of ‘skeletal’ electrons (SE) may be mentioned. This may be summarized as follows (Wade 1976): TEC 4n 2/14n 2 : SE 2n 2 TEC 4n 4/14n 4 : SE 2n 4 TEC 4n 6/14n 6 : SE 2n 6 TEC 5n/15n : SE 3n
closo nido arachno
277
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table Table 4.4. Electron count for some typical naked clusters. Cluster
∑e
Structure of the cluster
Electron count Total (TEC)
Skeletal (SEC)
P4, As4, Sb4
4 5 20
Tetrahedral, three-connected
Bi42
4 5 2 22
Square planar
arachno 4n 6 4 4 6 22
2n 6 14
Ge52, Pb52
5 4 2 22
Trigonal bipyramid
closo
4n 2 4 5 2 22
2n 2 12
Sn94, Pb94
9 4 4 40
Capped square antiprism
nido
4n 4 4 9 4 40
2n 4 22
TlSn93
3 9 4 3 42 Bicapped square closo antiprism
4n 2 4 10 2 42
2n 2 22
Se42
4 6 2 22
Square planar
arachno 4n 6 4 4 6 22
2n 6 14
Bi53
5 5 3 22
Trigonal bipyramid
closo
4n 2 4 5 2 22
2n 2 12
Bi82
8 5 2 38
Square antiprism
arachno 4n 6 4 8 6 38
2n 6 22
5n 5 4 20
3n 12
These two groups of rules are an example of a description of the cluster structure (of a complex cluster structure as in a polyanionic compound) as consisting of two parts: an interior, for which a certain number of skeletal electrons are required, and an exterior which interacts with its surroundings via exo-bonds, generally twoelectron two-centre bonds. A lone electron pair may be assigned to an exo-orbital of a cluster atom having no exterior linkage. Different types of skeletal bonding are found in various clusters: according to King (1993) the two extreme types of skeletal chemical bonding in molecules formed by polygonal or polyhedral clusters of atoms, including planar aromatic hydrocarbons and polyhedral boranes and metal clusters, can be defined as edge-localized or globally delocalized respectively. In an edge-localized polyhedron, or polygon, along each edge there is a two-electron two-centre bond. In the other extreme type of cluster, a multi-centre bond involves all the vertex atoms resulting in a fully aromatic system, such as the polygonal, bidimensional benzene or a three-dimensional deltahedral borane anion. A classic example of the application of the above-mentioned rules is given by the borane series B6H62 (octahedron, closo), B5H9 (square pyramid, nido) and B4H10 (butterfly, that is two triangles joined by sharing an edge, arachno). The total electron counts (TEC) result in the three clusters 26, 24 and 22 whereas the skeletal electron
278
Intermetallic Chemistry
count (SEC) gives for all these species the same value 14 (2 6 2, 2 5 4 and 2 4 6 respectively). The nido and the arachno species may be described as generated by successive removal of B9H vertices from the parent, octahedral, structure. The same rules may be applied to the Zintl anion B62 observed in compounds such as CaB6 and corresponding to a framework of corner-sharing boron octahedra as described in the following § 4.4.4.7. 4.4.4.4 Electron-precise, electron-deficient and electron-rich clusters. A cluster classification often adopted in several books, and related to the rules previously presented, corresponds to a subdivision into three categories: electron-precise, electron-deficient and electron-rich types. The electron-precise clusters may be considered as reference structures. Electron-precise clusters are defined according to the following requirements (Mingos and Wales 1990): ●
● ● ●
A simple localized 2c, 2e bond treatment is adequate: there are sufficient electrons for all the connections to be made by electron pairs. Each cluster atom obeys the octet rule. Each cluster atom has a lone pair or it is bonded to an exocyclic group. Each vertex is three coordinate.
The implication of these rules is that: An electron-precise n-atom cluster will have 5n (15n) electrons, of which 3n are used to bond the cluster (to form 3n/2 skeleton electron pairs). Notice that the total number of electrons in a cluster is given by the sum of the electrons on cluster vertex atoms plus the electrons, on vertex atoms, from covalent bonds with exocyclic groups. A simple, previously mentioned example may be represented by the tetrahedral molecule P4. In this structure there are 4 vertex atoms (n 4) and there are no exocyclic groups. On the other hand, P has 5 valence electrons, so the number of cluster electrons is 4 5 20 electrons. This number (20) is therefore related to the number of vertices by the condition 20 5n. The cluster is electron-precise. According to McGrady (2004), however, a ‘continuum view’ of the different types of clusters may be considered as illustrated in Fig. 4.27, which shows the relations between vertex count and electron count in main group clusters. 4.4.4.5 Interstitial atoms in clusters. As the size of clusters increases (and also that of their central cavity) the insertion of atoms becomes easier and easier. In particular for 12-atom clusters having a cubo-octahedral structure, the insertion of an atom having the same radius as that of the peripheral atoms is possible. Notice that this arrangement can be compared with those of the metallic cubic and hexagonal, close-packed structures.
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
279
38 36 4n 8
Valence electron number
34
4n 6
32
4n 4
o
ph
30
hy
ido
n
28
Electron-rich 5n Electron-precise
Electron-deficient
4n 2 4n
26 o
hn
24
c ara
Hypoelectronic o
s clo
22 20
4
6 5 Vertex number
Figure 4.27. Valence electron count and vertex count in main group clusters. Notice, according to McGrady (2004), that the different classes of clusters (electron-rich, electron-precise, etc.) simply occupy different domains in a continuum defined by the two variables (electron and vertex counts).
Typical examples are: carbon interstitial carbonyl clusters such as the octahedral Co6C(CO)132, the trigonal prismatic Co6C(CO)152 and its isoelectronic (mononegative) nitrogen interstitial Co6N(CO)15 or the icosahedral cluster Ni12Ge(CO)222 with the interstitial atom (Ge or Sn) in the centre of a Ni icosahedron. 4.4.4.6 Condensed and high nuclearity cluster compounds. In different fields of inorganic chemistry, from organo-metallic to intermetallic chemistry, a huge variety of compounds are known, the complex (or very complex) structures of which may be described as derived from some of the cluster types previously presented. Several derivation mechanisms could be considered, and some concepts underlined when studying typical relations between groups and families of structures such as ‘modular’ and ‘intergrowth’ structures (see § 3.9), which may possibly be applied and also extended to cluster chemistry. An important mechanism consists of joining clusters to form large building blocks, which are to form condensed clusters. Relevant contributions to this field have been carried out especially by Simon (see, for instance, Simon 1981, 1988, 1995) and Corbett (Corbett 2000, Liu and Corbett 2004). Among the condensed clusters those obtained by linking octahedra are an interesting example. Fig. 4.28 shows
280
Intermetallic Chemistry (a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 4.28. Schemes of octahedral cluster condensation. (a) Vertex-sharing, (b) edge-sharing and (c) face-sharing. In these examples octahedra centred by interstitial atoms are shown.
possible condensation schemes between octahedra (centred octahedra in these examples) having one common vertex or two adjacent vertices (an edge) or three (a common face). More complex structures can be obtained by repeated condensation processes: chains, for instance, may result by merging opposite vertices (or edges) of an octahedra sequence. Some general comments on the solid-state chemistry (‘From a molecular view on solids to molecules in solids’) have been reported by Simon (1995); emphasis was especially placed on the structural chemistry of metal-rich compounds formed by the metals in groups 1 to 6 and it was underlined that it is largely based on discrete and condensed clusters. In the chemistry of metals in low oxidation states, the residual valence electrons can be used for metal9metal bonding. Metal-rich compounds lie between normal valence compounds and the elemental metals themselves, with respect to their compositions, and often also with respect to their structures: fragments of usual metal structures (close-packed, b.c.c., etc.) are often component units in the structures of metal-rich compounds. As for the electron count in a condensed cluster, a ‘condensation principle’ has been enunciated (Mingos and Wales 1990). It can be summarized in the following sentences: the TEC of a condensed cluster is given by the sum of the electron counts for the parent clusters minus the electron count characteristic of the atoms, pair of atoms or face of atoms common to both polyhedra. In the transition metal
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
281
chemistry, these characteristic electron counts are 18 for a shared metal vertex, 34 for a common edge (a shared pair of atoms), 48 for a common triangular face and 62 for a common square face. In the (less common) main group condensed polyhedra, the corresponding numbers are 4 for a shared vertex, 12 for a shared edge and 18 for a shared triangular face. An example of vertex-sharing condensed cluster which obeys the mentioned rules is given by Os5(CO)19, the structure of which corresponds to two triangles with a common vertex. Reference may be made to the cluster Os3(CO)12 for which we have an electron count of 3 8 12 2 48. For the resulting vertexcondensed cluster we calculate 2 48 18 78, and the electron count for Os5(CO)19 is 5 8 19 2 78. An example of an edge-sharing cluster is [Ru10C2(CO)24]2 (condensation of two octahedral clusters of the type [Ru6(CO)18]2); another example may be the structure of the ion [Re4(CO)16]2 which can be described as the edge-sharing condensation of two triangular structures of the neutral cluster type Os3(CO)12. Several examples of complex clusters are reported in the literature, not all of them however conforming to the reported rules. 4.4.4.7 From clusters towards solid state intermetallics. In the preceding paragraphs a few types of complex inorganic compounds, mainly molecular however, have been reported, and some rules concerning their composition and structure exemplified. It is interesting to underline the ‘continuity’ between several topics of general inorganic chemistry and intermetallic chemistry, so a look will be given, albeit with few details, to some connections between cluster chemistry and solidstate chemistry. The scheme of cluster condensation or cluster fragment condensation leads eventually to structures observed in bulk metals. Particularly through extensive condensation of tetrahedral and octahedral clusters, arrangements closely related to the hexagonal and cubic close-packed structures can be obtained. Condensation also of icosahedral five-fold symmetrical clusters may be related to crystalline and quasicrystalline metallic structures. The variety, the richness, the beauty of the countless collection of known solid state intermetallic structures must be declared even if, unfortunately, only a few examples of the above-mentioned concepts can be covered here. Notice moreover that, on passing from cluster compounds to intermetallics, we may possibly consider several steps with more or less sharp sequential changes in the properties (changes in the interatomic distances and in the presence of different groups of interatomic distances, in the bonding characteristics, etc.). In this paragraph, through a few examples, attention will be especially given to structural and geometric characteristics. In a way, the reader may compare this approach with that previously adopted in the presentation of modular aspects
282
Intermetallic Chemistry
of crystal structures, in the analysis of their characteristic fragments and in the description of recombination structures and intergrowth structure series (see § 3.9.1 to 3.9.4). However notice that, on passing from a mere, more or less convenient, geometric description of a certain atomic arrangement to considerations about the physical meaning of such a description, ambiguities and problems may arise. A few remarks about some aspects related to the relations between clusters and complex intermetallic structures will be included in the following § 4.4.4.8. 4.4.4.7.1 Calcium hexaboride. An introductory example is represented by the calcium boride (CaB6) in which, however, boron octahedra are not condensed with each other but connected via normal (2e, 2c) bonds. A scheme of the structure is – shown in Fig. 4.29. It is cubic, space group, Pm 3m, N.221 with: 1 Ca in (a) 0, 0, 0; – 1⁄2, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, x, 1⁄2; 1⁄2, x, – 1⁄2; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, x; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, x– 6 B in (f) x, 1⁄2, 1⁄2; x, (a 414.5 pm and xB 0.207).
Figure 4.29. CaB6 structure. The B6 octahedra and their interconnections are outlined. Eight unit cells with a common (Ca) vertex are partially shown. Notice that the Ca atom is placed at the origin of the conventional cubic cell (position 0, 0, 0) and the centres of the boron octahedra are in the positions 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 (and equivalent).
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
283
Environment data: Ca (a) CNE 24: 241.0.0.0.0.2 B (f) CNE 5: 42.114.0 From a geometrical point of view only, this structure could be compared with that of CsCl, with 1 Ca in place of Cs, and the centre of a 6 B octahedron in place of the Cl atom (in the centre of the cell with its axes parallel to the cell axes). Ca is surrounded by 24 B in a regular truncated cube (octahedra and truncated cubes fill space). A number of hexaborides (of Ca, Sr, Ba, Y and several lanthanides and Th, Np, Pu, Am) have been described as pertaining to this structural type. CaB6 can be described in terms of the Wade rules. In this compound the B6 octahedra are linked with each other via 2e, 2c bonds; six electrons per octahedron are required for these bonds, together with the 2n 2 (14) electrons for the octahedron skeleton. This adds up to a total of 20 valence electrons. The boron atoms give 3 6 18 of these and calcium the remaining two. 4.4.4.7.2 Chevrel Phases. These phases were first synthesized by Chevrel et al. (1971) and are of great interest owing also to their noteworthy superconducting properties discovered by Matthias et al. (1972). The Chevrel phases are represented by a series of ternary molybdenum chalcogenide compounds and have the general formula Mo6MxX8 with M alkaline, alkaline earths, lanthanides, actinides or a metal such as: Ag, Cd, In, Sn, Pb, and X S, Se, Te. Most of these compounds crystallize in a rhombohedral structure with αrh 90° and space – group R3 (and related to the Mo6PbS8, hR45 type). The building blocks of the Chevrel-phases crystal structure are M element atoms and Mo6X8 clusters; each Mo6X8 unit is a slightly deformed cube with the X atoms at the corners and the Mo atoms at the face centres. Their comparatively simple crystal structures may be described as a primitive packing of quasi-molecular units, and, in a way, they represent the border line between molecular and infinitely extended units in a solid (Cheetham and Day 1992). The Mo6 type core is completely surrounded by X atoms and inter-cluster bonding essentially occurs through the Mo–X interactions. The Mo9Mo bonding between clusters is very weak. – 4.4.4.7.3 Mo6PbS8. It is rhombohedral (hR45), space group R 3, N.148, with the following atomic positions (45 atoms in the triple primitive hexagonal cell): (0, 0, 0; 1⁄3, 2⁄3, 2⁄3; 2⁄3, 1⁄3, 1⁄3) 3 Pb in (a) 0, 0, 0 (with a 0.92 occupancy) 6 S in (c) 0, 0, z; 0, 0, –z;
284
18 S in (f) 18 Mo in (f)
Intermetallic Chemistry
– z; x, – –y, –z; y, y x, –z; x y, x, –z; x, y, z; –y, x y, z; y x, x, – – – –y, –z; y, y x, –z; x y, x, –z; x, y, z; y, x y, z; y x, x, z; x,
with the following values of the positional free parameters: zS(c) 0.2436 xS(f) 0.9662, yS(f) 0.6747, zS(f) 0.4168 xMo(f) 0.8255, yMo(f) 0.8398, zMo(f) 0.4018 The constants of the triple primitive hexagonal cell are: a 921.3 pm, c 1144.0 pm, c/a 1.2417. The constants of the corresponding simple, primitive, cell in rhombohedral setting are aR 654.5 pm, α 89.47°, corresponding therefore to a nearly cubic shaped cell. (Notice that this can be an exercise for the application of the hexagonal–rhombohedral transformation formulae presented in the § 3.6.1.3.2). The equivalent sets of atomic positions (15 atoms) in this rhombohedral cell are: 1 Pb in (a) 0, 0, 0 (with a 0.92 occupancy) 2 S in (c) x, x, x; –x, –x, –x; 6 S in (f) x, y, z; z, x, y; y, z, x; –x, –y, –z; –z, –x, –y; –y, –z, –x; 6 Mo in (f) x, y, z; z, x, y; y, z, x; –x, –y, –z; –z, –x, –y; –y, –z, –x; with the following values of the positional free parameters (related to this rhombohedral unit cell): zS(c) 0.2436 xS(f) 0.3830, yS(f) 0.1253, zS(f) 0.7421 xMo(f) 0.2273, yMo(f) 0.4162, zMo(f) 0.5620 The nearly cubic, rhombohedral unit cell of Mo6PbS8 is shown in Fig. 4.30. The bonding between different clusters in the crystal structure of the Chevrel phase Mo6PbS8 is indicated in Fig. 4.31. 4.4.4.7.4 Cu4Mo6Se8. The triclinic structure of these compounds has been described by McGuire et al. (2006). It contains nearly regular Mo6 clusters; the Cu atoms fully occupy four sites between faces of two adjacent Mo6Se8 clusters. This compound is a member of a series of MexMo6X8 Chevrel phases. Preparation and properties have been discussed. A Cu intercalation apparatus was built for
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
285
Figure 4.30. The, nearly cubic, rhombohedral unit cell of Mo6PbS8 is shown. with the Pb atoms (black) at the origin. The Mo6S8 cluster consisting of a Mo6 octahedron inscribed in a S8 cube is in evidence. Compare with Fig. 4.31 where the spatial arrangement of the clusters is shown.
Figure 4.31. Crystal structure of the Chevrel phase Mo6PbS8. Portions of four rhombohedral unit cells with one common Pb atom (black) are shown. The bonding between different clusters is suggested by the Mo9S inter-cluster links.
adding Cu to a Chevrel phase Cu2Mo6Se8 which was prepared by synthesis from the elements. 4.4.4.7.5 Mo6S8 and Mo6Se8 clusters. These clusters have been identified in several ternary Mo chalcogenides often together with other structural units, for instance, with Mo12S14 in Tl2Mo9S11, that is Tl4(Mo6S8)(Mo12S14), Potel et al. (1980). Mo9Se11
286
Intermetallic Chemistry
building blocks together with Mo6Se8 have been identified in In3Mo15Se19 (Grüttner et al. 1979). The binary Mo chalcogenides Mo3S4 and Mo3Se4 (hR42-Mo3Se4 type) contain the same structural blocks present in the Chevrel phases. Their main crystal structural data, in the hexagonal and in the rhombohedral settings, are the following: Mo3S4: a 920.0 pm, c 1088.0 pm, c/a 1.183 (aR 643.2 α 91.32°) Mo3Se4: a 954.5 pm, c 1121.1 pm, c/a 1.175 (aR 665.8 α 91.57°) – The space group is R3, N.148 with 42 atoms in the (triple primitive) hexagonal cell (14 atoms in the equivalent, primitive, rhombohedral cell). The atomic positions, in the hexagonal cell of the prototype Mo3Se4, are: (0, 0, 0; 1⁄3, 2⁄3, 2⁄3; 2⁄3, 1⁄3, 1⁄3) 6 Se in (c) 0, 0, z; 0, 0, –z; 18 Se in (f ) x, y, z; –y, x y, z; y x, –x , z; –x, –y, –z; y, y x, –z; x y, x, –z; 18 Mo in (f ) x, y, z; –y, x y, z; y x, –x, z; –x, –y, –z; y, y x, –z; x y, x, –z; with the following values: zSe(c) 0.2137 xSe(f ) 0.9621, ySe(f) 0.6724, zSe(f) 0.4171 xMo(f ) 0.8290, yMo(f) 0.8479, zMo(f) 0.3940 It can be easily checked that these atomic positions are nearly identical to those of S and Mo in Mo6PbS8: Pb is not present, but we have the same structure for the groups Mo6X8. Preparation of the compounds Mo6 X8 . According to McGuire et al. (2006), Mo6Te8 can be prepared by direct reaction of the elements while Mo6S8 and Mo6Se8 cannot. It is therefore common to prepare partially Cu-filled Chevrel phases CuxMo6X8 and then to remove Cu to obtain the unfilled Mo6X8. The compound CuxMo6X8 (x 2) is synthesized from the powder of the elements, sealed in evacuated silica tubes and slowly heated up to 1000–1100°C. As for the removal of Cu from the ternary compound one way in which this may be done is through reaction with iodine dissolved in acetonitrile. The phase reacts with the I2 in solution and forms CuI, which is soluble in acetonitrile. 4.4.4.7.6 Mo and W halides. Structures similar to those previously presented are found in several other compounds; for instance in the halides of Mo and W in the formal oxidation state 2 of these metals. The key structural unit is an octahedron of metal atoms surrounded by a cubic array of halogen atoms: it is shown in Fig. 4.32. A formula such as [Mo6Cl8]4 applies to this unit, which may be observed in the
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
287
structures of MoCl2. See Fig. 4.33, where a layer formed by the linking of Mo6Cl8 clusters via extra Cl atoms is shown. The ion [Mo6Cl14]2 is shown in Fig. 4.34. The related structure of M6X12 groups, such as found in [Nb6Cl12]2 or in [Ta6Cl12]2 clusters, is shown in Fig. 4.35.
Figure 4.32. The key structural unit [Mo6Cl8]4 is shown (Cl atom black), which is found in molybdenum (and similarly in tungsten) halides. The edges of the Cl8 cube (around the Mo6 octahedron) have not been indicated: emphasis has been given to the interatomic connections.
Figure 4.33. Layer formed by the linking of Mo6Cl8 clusters via extra Cl atoms (4 links per cluster). Each of these Cl atoms is shared between two clusters so, on average, 4/2 2Cl are added to each Mo6 group. Considering also the two unshared Cl atoms linked to each Mo octahedron we have an overall stoichiometric ratio of 6 Mo to (8 2 2) Cl corresponding to the di-halide Mo6Cl12. An isolated group formed by the 6 Mo octahedron with all (14) the surrounding Cl is shown in the next figure.
288
Intermetallic Chemistry
Figure 4.34. The cluster [Mo6Cl14]2 is shown. Numerous compounds are known which contain this group as a negative ionic cluster. Six Cl atoms were added to the six vertexes of the white octahedron shown in Fig. 4.32.
Figure 4.35. The structure of the [Nb6Cl12]2 and [Ta6Cl12]2 clusters.
4.4.4.7.7 Pentatitanium tetratelluride (vertex-sharing octahedra). The structure of Ti5Te4 (tI18, structural type) gives an example of cluster condensation. The reference cluster has a structure (and a formula, Me6X8) similar to that previously considered in the Chevrel phases. The body centred tetragonal structure of Ti5Te4 corresponds to the following data: Space group I4/m, N.87, with the following atomic positions: (0, 0, 0; 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2) 2 Ti in (a) 0, 0, 0; 8 Ti in (h) x, y, 0; –x, –y, 0; –y, x, 0; y, –x, 0; with x 0.3144 and y 0.3752 8 Te in (h) x, y, 0; –x, –y, 0; –y, x, 0; y, –x, 0; with x 0.0589 and y 0.2797
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table (a)
289
(b)
Ti
Te
Figure 4.36. The body centred tetragonal structure of Ti5Te4. (a): perspective view of three superimposed unit cells. A Ti5Te4 chain passing through the centres of the cells is outlined. Inside see the clusters Ti6Te8. In every unit cluster, the Ti6 octahedron and the Te8 cube are shown. (b) projection on the x, y plane of the structure. The projections of parallel Ti5Te4 chains passing through the centre and the vertices of the cell may be noticed.
The constants of the b.c. tetragonal cell are: a 1016.4 pm, c 377.2 pm, c/a 0.371. Me5X4 compounds with this structure are known with Me Ti, V, Nb, Ta, Mo and X S, Se, Te, As, Sb. A perspective view of this structure and a projection of the unit cell are shown in Fig. 4.36. Notice the chain structure resulting from the condensation of Ti6Te8 clusters. Similar groups (such as Mo6S8) are found, as building units, in several compounds. According to a discussion reported by Müller (1994), it may now be underlined that joining clusters to form larger building blocks may relieve the existing deficiency of binding electrons. Among the condensed Me6X8 clusters, a substructure consisting of Me6 octahedra linked with each other may be noticed. When joining Ti6Te8 units via common vertices of the metal octahedra (that is, merging the vertex metal atoms with one another) it is necessary for some X atoms to merge too. In the condensation scheme shown in Fig. 4.36 merging of the opposite vertices of the octahedra results in an average number of 5 Ti atoms in each unit of the chain. On the other hand, the sharing of 4 Te atoms by two cubes results in an average content per cube of 4 Te, giving an overall composition ratio Ti5Te4. In the same book,
290
Intermetallic Chemistry
Müller introduces and discusses examples of more complex compounds, in which extended condensation processes of Mo6X8 and Mo6X12 clusters are observed. 4.4.4.7.8 Edge-sharing and face-sharing poly-condensed clusters. Polyhedra interconnection and condensation constitute a basic mechanism for the description and interpretation of several complex structures. As suggested by the examples shown in Fig. 4.28, condensation and poly-condensation may correspond to the sharing of one or more vertices, edges or faces. Using as a reference a paper by Simon (Simon 1992), other examples of the Mo chemistry may be examined, and several derivatives of the molybdenum Mo6 octahedral group considered. Cluster condensation via opposite faces of the Mo6X8 type clusters have been examined, and oligomeric units describable as resulting from the decomposition of the parent cluster into Mo3X4 fragments with the insertion of Mo3X3 groups have been described. Several ternary molybdenum chalcogenides, containing such groups, have been discussed; among them: Cs2Mo12S14 (Mo3X4[Mo3X3]2Mo3X4)2, Rb4Mo18Se20 (Mo3X4[Mo3X3]4Mo3X4)4, Cs6Mo24Se26 (Mo3X4[Mo3X3]6Mo3X4)6; Cs8Mo30Se32 (Mo3X4[Mo3X3]8Mo3X4)8, up to Tl2Mo6Se6 containing the infinite ionic structure 1[Mo3X3]. As an example of a structure derived from the union of different polyhedra, the structural motif resulting from the connection of two trigonal prisms (around a Co atom), and a distorted rectangular prism (around an Al atom) has been identified by Richter et al. (2005) in the monoclinic phase Co4Al7xSi2x; this motif is shown in Fig.4.37. 4.4.4.7.9 Concentric polyhedral clusters. Among the various contributions made by Corbett and co-workers to the different aspects of cluster science, special attention may be given to the investigations (preparation, structural description, electronic classification, etc.) carried out on phases containing multi-hedral, concentric polyhedral, clusters. An interesting example is represented by the investigation of a phase, approximant to the icosahedral quasi-crystalline phase Sc3Cu2.1Zn15.9, and which is homogeneous in the region Sc3CuxZn18x(0 x 2.2) (Lin and Corbett 2004). It is – body centred cubic (space group Im3, a 1383.1–1375.3 pm, cI184(168)-type) basically isostructural with the RCd6 phases known for many rare earth metals. The structure is a body centred array of interpenetrating triacontahedra (30 faces, 72 vertices polyhedra) of Zn atoms. These large polyhedra contain successive concentric atomic shells around their centres (in the origin and in the 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2 position of the cell) consisting of a disordered Zn tetrahedron followed by a pentagonal dodecahedron of Zn Cu atoms (20 atoms), an icosahedron of Sc atoms (12) that cap the pentagonal faces of the internal dodecahedron, and an icosidodecahedron of 30 Zn
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
Co
AI
291
AI, Si
Figure 4.37. A view of the atomic arrangement in mS26-Co4Al7xSi2x according to Richter et al. (2005). Atomic clusters containing trigonal prisms centred by Co and distorted rectangular prisms centred by Al are evidenced.
atoms. It has been observed that, in the homogeneity composition range, to an increasing Cu quantity corresponds a reduction of the electron count per atom (to 2.04) and of the average atomic dimensions, until increasing quantities of Zn-poor quasicrystals separate along with the described crystalline approximant phase. Another contribution is represented by an investigation of a cubic thallium cluster phase of the Bergmann type Na13(TlxCd1–x)27 (0.24 x 0.33) (Li and Corbett – 2004). For this phase too the body centred cubic structure (space group Im 3, a 1587–1599 pm) may be described in terms of multiple endo-hedral concentric shells of atoms around the cell positions 0, 0, 0, and 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2. The subsequent shells in every unit are an icosahedron (formed by mixed Cd–Tl atoms), a pentagonal dodecahedron (20 Na atoms), a larger icosahedron (12 Cd atoms); these are surrounded by a truncated icosahedron (60 mixed Cd–Tl atoms) and then by a 24 vertices Na polyhedron. Every atom in the last two shells is shared with those of like shells in adjacent units. A view of the unit cell is shown in Fig. 4.38. According to Li and Corbett (2004), it may be described as an electron-poor Zintl phase. A systematic description of condensed metal clusters was reported by Simon (1981). 4.4.4.8 Problems in the relations between complex intermetallic alloys and clusters. After the previous short survey of cluster structures and some comments
292
Intermetallic Chemistry
Figure 4.38. The body centred cubic cell of Na13(TlxCd1x)27 (adapted from Li and Corbett (2004)). The large, interpenetrating, polyhedra contain concentric atomic shells and are centred around 0, 0, 0 and 1⁄2, 1⁄2, 1⁄2.
about their possible relevance to intermetallic structures, a few summarizing observations taken from a critical contribution by Steurer (2005) may now be considered. Steurer observed that, without doubt, the cluster approach has been a very successful and useful tool for describing and modelling the structure of quasicrystals. Open questions however are: how stable these clusters are, in what way they contribute to the stability of the quasicrystals and what physical properties they have. Several remarks have been made about the definition and the nature of clusters. In the introduction to the paper Steurer remarked that most models of quasi-periodic structures and their approximants are based on one or more structural units commonly referred to as clusters. The term ‘cluster’, however, may denote a purely geometrical pattern (a structure motif ), a structural building block, a quasi-unit cell, a complex coordination polyhedron, possibly with some chemical stability; finally, in terms of electronic stabilized entities, a cluster, with reference to the so-called jellium model, can be considered a kind of soft super-atom. These concepts have been further considered in a discussion edited by Henley et al. (2005). Different meanings often given to the word ‘cluster’ and consequent problems in an unambiguous definition of cluster were examined. In particular, considering
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
293
definitions of clusters connected to binding or physical properties it was remarked that a distinction, by the degree of binding, between a cluster and the remaining parts of the system may be significant for covalently bonded structures but generally not for metals, including complex intermetallics and quasicrystals, where a sufficiently localized meaning cannot be ascribed to a binding concept. An energetic distinction between the inter-cluster and intra-cluster interactions and those between clusters and their environment will be especially problematic with structures for which a geometrical description in terms of interpenetrating overlapping clusters seems to be convenient. 4.4.4.9 Thermochemistry of cluster compounds. In this short summary of cluster structures and their bonding, a few remarks on their thermochemical behaviour are given, in view of a possible relationship with the intermetallic alloy properties. To this end we remember that for molecular compounds, as for several organic compounds, concepts such as bond energies and their relation to atomization energies and thermodynamic formation functions play an important role in the description of these compounds and their properties. A classical example is given by some binary hydrocarbon compounds. Before carrying out such an examination, however, it is necessary to underline that thermochemical quantities, even if in principle accurate and significant, in practice are affected by experimental errors, and often by inaccuracies, due to the need to obtain relatively small values as differences between large values. As a consequence, the reader may find in books and treatises differences in the values of the specific bond energies as large as 5% to 10%. Taking methane, CH4, as a reference compound, its standard enthalpy of formation is defined by the reaction: C(graphite) 2H2(g) : CH4(g) for which the value ΔfH 74.9 kJ mol1 has been reported. Considering now the sublimation enthalpy of graphite (evaluated for the sublimation to monoatomic C gas) and the dissociation energy of hydrogen: C(graphite) : C(g) H2(g) : 2H(g)
ΔH 0 713.4 kJ mol1 ΔH 0 436.3 kJ mol1
we have: C(g) 4H(g) : CH4(g) 74.9 (713.4 2 436.3) 1661 kJ mol1 corresponding to the so-called atomization energy.
294
Intermetallic Chemistry
On the basis of the CH4 structure corresponding to four identical 4 C9H bonds, the C–H bond energy can be assumed to be 1660/4 415 kJ mol1. A similar calculation performed on the next hydrocarbon, C2H6, takes into account its formation enthalpy given by the reaction: 2C(graphite) 3H2(g) : C2H6(g) ΔHI0 85.0 kJ mol1 from which the atomization energy may be obtained by considering, as previously highlighted, the graphite sublimation energy and the hydrogen dissociation energy: 2C(g) 6H(g) : C2H6(g) ΔH 85.0 (2 713.4 3 436.3) 2821 kJ mol1 Considering the C2H6 structure schematically indicated as H3C9CH3, the C2H6 atomization energy corresponds to the breaking of six C9H bond and one C9C bond, that is to the sum of 6 C9H 1 C9C bond energies. Therefore, the C9C bond energy is 2821 6 415 331 kJ mol1. The interest of these calculations and of the determination of the bond energies lies for instance in the fact that with only the two values of C9C and C9H bond energies it is possible to compute the atomization energies, and consequently the formation enthalpies, of a high number of hydrocarbons, while also confirming their structures. This kind of calculation, by using convenient definitions, has also been satisfactorily extended to different kinds of covalent compounds containing various elements (oxygen, sulphur, halogens, etc.) and characterised not only by single bonds like C9C, but also by double and triple bonds or by ‘aromatic’ groups. Notice also that the formation of compounds such as the hydrocarbons cannot be obtained by a direct synthesis reaction. The formation enthalpy therefore must be determined through a reaction cycle, by comparison for instance with the combustion reactions of C (graphite), H2 and the compound itself. The procedure is exemplified below: C(graphite) O2(g) : CO2(g)
ΔH II0 394 kJ mol1
H2(g) 1⁄2O2(g) : H2O(l)
ΔH III0 286 kJ mol1
C2H6(g) 7/2O2(g) : 2CO2(g) 3H2O(l) ΔHIV0 1561 kJ mol1 2C(graphite) 3H2(g) : C2H6(g)
ΔHI0
ΔHI0 2ΔHII0 3ΔHIII0 ΔHIV0 ΔHI0 2(394) 3(286) (1561) 85.0 kJ mol1 Similar thermochemical aspects have been considered also in cluster compounds.
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
295
Taking for instance a metal carbonyl cluster Mm(CO)n a ‘disruption’ enthalpy (ΔdH) can be defined (Connor 1977, 1981, Mingos and Wales 1990) according to the following reaction: Mm(CO)n (g, 298 K) : mM (g, 298 K) nCO (g, 298 K) which may be obtained from the following standard thermochemical data: ΔdH mΔf H°(M,g) nΔf H°(CO,g) Δf H°(Mm(CO)n,g) If, moreover, the cluster structure is described in terms of a number of localized bonds: metal9CO terminal bonds (T bonds), metal9CO bridging bonds (B bonds) and metal9metal bonds (M bonds) and the assumption is made that the bond – – – enthalpy contributions T, B and M are transferable, these may be estimated and aver– aged. As for the M value the data (kJ/mol) obtained from a number of carbonyls – – (MCO) are compared, in Table 4.5, with those ( Mmet) obtained considering the bulk – metal, its atomization energy ΔatH and its CN, according to Mmet 2ΔatH/CN. From the thermochemical data some general, albeit approximate, assertions have been obtained (Mingos and Wales 1990) and in particular: – – (i) A comparison between the bond enthalpies Mclu and Mmet in cluster and in metal, which follow a similar trend along the Periodic Table, seems to support the hypothesis of a similarity (in type and strength) of the metal–metal bonding in clusters and in bulk metals. (ii) As observed also by Schäfer and Schnering (1964), metal9metal bonding should be frequent with those metals which have the highest heat of sublimation. – Mmet approaches a maximum toward the centre of the transition series where the d and s bands are half filled. Table 4.5. Average values (kJ/mol) of the metal9metal bond – enthalpies estimated from metal carbonyls (MCO) and from – bulk metals (Mmet) (adapted from Mingos and Wales (1990)). M9M bond
– M CO
– M met
Mn9Mn Fe9Fe Ru9Ru Os9Os Co9Co Rh9Rh Ir9Ir
67 82 117 130 83 166 110
71 104 108 132 71 93 112
296
Intermetallic Chemistry
This may be related (Simon 1992) to the very stable metal clusters formed with the elements placed in the middle of the Periodic Table (Nb, Ta, Mo, W, Re). – Notice that the cluster bond enthalpy contribution, Mclu, increases in a given column of the Periodic Table on passing from the light to the heavy elements.
4.4.5 ‘Hume–Rothery phases’ and VEC An important class of intermetallic phases (generally showing rather wide homogeneity ranges) are the Hume–Rothery phases, which are included within the so-called ‘electron compounds’. These are phases whose stable crystal structures may be supposed to be mainly controlled by the number of valence electrons per atom, that is, by the previously defined VEC. The Hume–Rothery phases constitute an interesting and ubiquitous group of binary and complex intermetallic substances; it was indeed Hume–Rothery who, already in the twenties, observed that one of the relevant parameters in rationalizing compositions and structures of a number of phases is the average number of valence electrons per atom (ne/nat). An illustration of this fact may be found in Table 4.6, where a number of the Hume–Rothery structure types have been collected, together with a few more major structure types relevant to transition metal alloys. For each phase the corresponding VEC has been reported as ne/nat ratio, both calculated on the basis of the s and p electrons and of s, p and d electrons. In a first hypothesis (s and p electrons, according to Hume–Rothery), the following valence-electron numbers have been assumed: Transition elements with non-filled d-shells 0; Cu, Ag, Au 1; Mg, Zn, Cd, Hg 2; Al, Ga, In 3; Si, Ge, Sn 4 and Sb 5. In the calculation based on s, p and d electrons the following values are considered: Mn 7; Fe 8; Cu, Ag, Au 11; Mg 2; Zn, Cd, Hg 12; Al, Ga, In 13. The Hume–Rothery types listed in Table 4.6 include structures of different complexity ranging from the simple close-packed (fcc and hcp) and bcc structures to the more complex Mn-type and γ-brass type structures. As for the hexagonal hcp structures, notice that for this type several variations are known: three branches of this structure are generally considered. The ζ-hcp corresponds to the true closest packing with the value of the axial ratio c/a close to the ideal one (8/3) 1.6329 ... (see § 3.7.4 and Fig. 3.16). The ε-hex corresponds to c/a ranging around 1.55 to 1.58 and the η phase to c/a values of about 1.77 to 1.88. As observed by Lee and Hoistad (1995), the various hexagonal types can be considered genuinely different. The types listed in Table 4.6 include several groups of isostructural phases, each group corresponding to a given value of the VEC. Particular emphasis has generally
297
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
Table 4.6. Structure types and valence electron concentration. Examples of intermetallic phases Phase conventional name and symbol, Pearson symbol fcc
cF4
(*)
ζ hcp
hP2
Example and composition range (Okamoto 2000) Cu–Zn Cu–Al Cu–Sn Cu–Sb Au–Zn Au–Al Au–Sn Ag–Al Ag–Ga
Cu–Cu61.7Zn38.3 Cu–Cu80.3Al19.7 Cu–Cu90.9Sn9.1 Cu–Cu94.2Sb5.8 Au–Au66.5Zn33.5 Au–Au87Al13 Au–Au93.4Sn6.6 Ag–Ag79.6Al20.4 Ag–Ag82Ga18
Ag–Cd Ag–In Ag–Sn Ag–Sb Au–In Au–Sn
Ag50.5Cd49.5–Ag44Cd56 Ag75In25–Ag54.1In45.9 Ag88.2Sn11.8–Ag77.1Sn22.9 Ag91.5Sb8.5–Ag83.6Sb16.4 Au87.8In12.2–Au77.6In22.4 Au90.9Sn9.1–Au82.4Sn17.6
c/a axial ne/nat s,p ratio electrons (#) Villars et al. (1995) 1–1.38 1–1.39 1–1.27 1–1.23 1–1.335 1–1.26 1–1.20 1–1.41 1–1.36 1.615–1.609 1.62–1.58 1.633–1.607 1.634–1.617 1.648–1.640 1.646–1.633
ne/nat s,p,d electrons
-------------------------------------------
1.49–1.56 1.50–1.92 1.35–1.68 1.34–1.66 1.24–1.45 1.27–1.53
------------------------------------
bcc (β-phase)
cI2
Ag–Zn Ag–Cd Ag–Al Cu–Be Cu–Zn Cu–Al Cu–Si Cu–Sn Au–Al
Ag63.5Zn36.7 –Ag41.4Zn58.6 Ag60Cd40–Ag45Cd55 Ag79.5Al20.5–Ag70.2Al29.8 Cu77.5Be22.5–Cu56.7Be43.3 Cu63.9Zn36.1–Cu44.2Zn55.8 Cu82Al18–Cu69.5Al30.5 Cu85.8Si14.2–Cu82.8Si17.2 Cu86.9Sn13.1–Cu84.3Sn15.7 Au81.2Al18.8–Au80Al20
1.37–1.59 1.40–1.55 1.41–1.60 1.22–1.43 1.36–1.56 1.36–1.61 1.43–1.52 1.39–1.47 1.38–1.40
11.37–11.59 11.40–11.53 --------------11.36–11.56 --------------11.39–11.47 --------
βMn (μ-phase)
cP20
Ag–Al Al–Au
Ag79Al21–Ag76Al24 Au4Al
1.42–1.48 1.40
--------
c152 cF1124 cP52 cP52 cI52 cI52 cP52 cI52 cI52 cP52 cI52
Cu–Zn Cu–Cd Cu–Al Cu–Ga Ag–Zn Ag–Cd Ag–In Au–Zn Mn–Zn Co–Zn Pd–Zn
Cu43Zn57–Cu30Zn70 Cu55.9Cd44.1–Cu58.2Cd41.8 Cu62.5Al37.5–Cu68.5Al31.5 Cu70.5Ga29.5–Cu65.3Ga34.7 Ag42Zn58–Ag35.3Zn64.7 Ag43Cd57–Ag37.5Cd62.5 Ag68.9In31.1–Ag66.4In33.6 Au37.5Zn62.5Au24Zn76 Mn23Zn77–Mn15.2Zn84.8 Co31Zn69–Co14.6Zn85.4 Pd24Zn76–Pd14.5Zn85.5
1.57–1.70 1.44–1.42 1.75–1.63 1.59–1.69 1.58–1.65 1.57–1.62 1.62–1.67 1.62–1.76 ----------------------
11.57–11.70 11.44–11.42 11.75–11.63 11.59–11.69 11.58–11.65 11.57–11.62 11.62–11.67 11.62–11.76 10.85–11.24 11.07–11.56 11.52–11.71 (Continued)
298
Intermetallic Chemistry
Table 4.6. (Continued) Phase conventional name and symbol, Pearson symbol
Example and composition range (Okamoto 2000)
c/a axial ne/nat s,p ratio electrons (#) Villars et al. (1995)
ne/nat s,p,d electrons
ε hcp
hP2
Cu–Zn Ag–Zn Au–Zn Ag–Cd Li–Cd
Cu22Zn78–Cu12Zn88 Ag34Zn66–Ag11Zn89 Au16Zn84–Au11Zn89 Ag35.5Cd64.5–Ag19Cd81 Li29Cd71–Li20Cd80
1.568–1.554 1.587–1.567 1.557–1.555 1.582–1.556 ~1.586
1.78–1.88 1.66–1.89 1.84–1.89 1.645–1.81 1.71–1.80
11.78–11.88 11.66–11.89 11.84–11.89 11.65–11.81 --------
η
hP2
Ag–Zn Au–Zn Ag–Cd Cu–Zn
Zn–Ag0.05Zn0.95 Zn–Au0.075Zn0.925 Cd–Ag0.07Cd0.93 Zn–Cu0.025Zn0.975
1.86–1.76 1.86–1.75 1.89–1.83 1.86–1.81
2–1.95 2–1.92 2–1.93 2–1.97
12–11.95 12–11.92 12–11.93 12–11.97
(*) χ σ
cI58 tP30
Ti–Re Ti5Re24 Al–Mg Al56.8Mg43.2–Al37.7Mg62.3 Cr–Fe Cr–Co Ir–W Os–Ta
Cr44.5Fe55.5–Cr50Fe50 Cr53.6Co46.4–Cr67Co33 Ir26W74–Ir22W78 Os46Ta56–Os22Ta78
6.49 2.57–2.38 ~0.518 ~0.512 ~0.518
7.11–7.0 7.39–6.99 6.78–6.66 6.48–5.66
(*) terminal solid solutions (#) c/a values general refer to a composition range smaller than (and included in) that given in the previous column
been given to three main categories of Hume–Rothery phases: those corresponding to VEC values (based on s and p electrons) of 3/2 (that is three valence electrons every two atoms), 21/13 and 7/4, respectively. ‘Ideal’ simple formulae, representative of these groups of Hume–Rothery phases are the following: VEC 3/2, body centred cubic, (cI2-W type): CuZn, Cu3Al, Cu5Sn, etc. VEC 3/2, complex cubic, (cP20-β Mn type): Cu5Si, Ag3Al, etc. VEC 21/13 (1.62), complex cubic, 52 atoms in the unit cell (or superstructures); cP52: Cu9Al4, Cu9Ga4, Ag9In4, Co5Zn21, etc.; cI52: Cu5Zn8, γbrass, Ag5Cd8, Ag5Zn8, Ru3Be10, etc.; cF408: Fe11Zn40, etc. VEC 7/4 (1.75), hexagonal close-packed, (hP2-Mg-type or superstructures): AgZn3, Ag5Al3, etc. The given ratios and compositions are short indications of solid solution ranges, which can even overlap. It has to be noted, moreover, that the number of electrons to be considered may be uncertain. The VEC values, therefore, indicate only a composition range where one of the aforementioned structure types may occur.
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
299
According to Girgis (1983) the existence field of the electron phases may be especially related to the combinations of d elements with the elements of the Periodic Table columns from 11 to 14 (from the Cu to Si groups). It can also be observed that, for several alloy systems, the dependence of the structures (structure types) on the electron concentration (instead of on the composition) may be clearly illustrated by well-known diagrams such as those shown in Fig. 4.39. Notice, for instance, the similar shape of the β phase field: in all three systems the β phase is the cI2-W type structure. A review of different approaches to theoretical interpretations of these correlations may be found in Kauzlarich (1996). Cahn (2001), Lee and Hoistad (1995) described how a modified tight-binding method, based on second moment scaling of the electronic density of states, can be used to rationalize both crystal structure and electron counting rules. Several electron counting rules were considered including the Hume–Rothery rules for metals and alloys (Fig. 4.40). A number of papers on the ‘evolution’ of the Hume–Rothery rules and concepts may be found in the proceedings (edited by Turchi et al. 2000) of a symposium held in St. Louis (USA) in 2000. The following titles may be mentioned: ‘Hume–Rothery Rules Revisited’ (by T.B. Massalski), ’From Hume–Rothery 8-N Rule to Valence Electron Rules for Zintl Phases and their Extensions’ (by E. Parthé), ‘The Hume–Rothery Parameters and Bonding in the Hume–Rothery and Transition-Metal Alloys’ (by R.E. Watson, M. Weinert, L.H. Bennett), ‘Controversial Concepts in Alloy Theory Re-visited’ (by D.G. Pettifor).
4.4.6 VEC and stability multi-diagrams. Brewer diagrams For certain well-defined groups of metals a compact presentation of the ‘stability regions’ of structural types in the phases of their alloys was proposed by Brewer (1965) as a function of VEC. Special attention was dedicated by Brewer to the transition metal alloys; for most of these elements the atomic sizes are reasonably close to each other, making extended solid solubility ranges possible. The VEC (valenceelectron number per atom) can often be replaced by the (averaged) group number (column number of the Periodic Table) of the components of the alloys. Brewer type diagrams for transition metals of the 6th period (6th row, 3rd transition series metals) are shown, as an example, in Fig. 4.41. The elements Ta (of the 5th group), W (6th group), Re (7th group), Os (8th group), Ir (9th group) and Pt (10th group) have been considered and their alloys with Cr, Mo and W are shown. In this figure, three composite diagrams (Brewer multi-diagrams) have been represented. To this end, isothermal sections of the diagrams of the alloys of Cr, Mo and W, with Ta, W, Re, Os, Ir and Pt, have been combined in three schemes. In the specific case of the Mo alloys, the construction of the Brewer multi-diagram is illustrated. As an example,
Temperature (°C)
1
e /a 1.5
2
1
1200
1200
1000
1000
800
b
e /a 3
1
1.5
2
3
4
1200 g0
b
1000
800
800 g1
g
600
e /a 2
1.5
b
e
600
600
400
400
400
200
200
200
g e
e
Cu
40 at.%Zn
80
Zn
Cu
20
40
60
at.%Al
80
AI
Cu
20
40
60
80
Sn
at.%Sn
Figure 4.39. The phase diagrams of the binary Cu systems with Zn, Al and Sn are shown. In order to highlight their similarities the phase equilibria have been plotted with different scales of the atomic composition in order to have the same extension for a scale based on the average v.e.c. in the alloys (number e/a of electrons per atom). Notice the consequent change of length of the at.% scale. The values 1, 2, 3, 4 have been assumed for the valence electron numbers of the metals Cu, Zn, Al and Sn.
301
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table Theoretical fcc z -hcp bcc b -Mn g -brass z ,e -hcp h -hcp
Theoretical s -phase c -phase hcp
Experimental
fcc Experimental bcc s -phase c -phase hcp fcc 7
8
9 e/a
10
11
fcc z -hcp bcc b -Mn g -brass z ,e -hcp h -hcp 11.0
11.4 e/a
11.8
Figure 4.40. Valence electron (s, p, d) concentration ranges for different types of phases as reported by Lee and Hoistad (1995). Experimental average values are compared with those computed. (For the conventional names of the phases, compare with Table 4.6.) On the left transition metal binary alloys, on the right the Hume–Rothery electron phases are shown.
the binary Mo–Pt and Mo–Os diagrams and their isothermal sections are shown in Fig. 4.41; these sections consist of horizontal lines from Mo to the other metal and contain a sequence of single and two-phase regions. The sections are reported in the multi-diagram, where they are arranged according to the positions, in the Periodic Table, of the second metals, that is, according to their ‘Group Numbers’ (from 5 for Ta to 10 for Pt). Notice that in order to have a higher coherency among the different systems, we selected the temperatures of the different isothermal sections not on the basis of absolute values but as ‘reduced’ values of the ‘average’ melting temperatures (even if the reduction was made in a rather arbitrary way) defining, for a Me–X alloy: Tred 0.7(Tmelt,Me Tmelt,X)/2 (in K)
(4.35)
In the diagrams obtained in this way, the composition limits of each phase have been connected from one binary system to the next. A number of single-phase fields (shaded regions) have thus been obtained. These correspond to well-defined structure types, which are listed in the figure.
302
Intermetallic Chemistry Pt
W G
Ir
W E
Os
W
T (°C)
C Re
W A W
W
W
Ta
2623 2200 1800
at.%
1455
1769.0
1400 1000
Mo
H
F Mo
Mo
Ir D
Os C
Mo
B
at.%
3033
2623
W
1800
Ta
1400
1898
Mo Cr Cr
at.%
Pt
Pt D
Ir E
Cr
Os C
Cr
Re
A Cr Cr
Pt
3000
2200
A
Mo
Re
at.%
T (°C)
E
Mo
Mo
Pt G
W at.%
A: cI2-W (A2) B: cI58-a Mn, c phase (A12) C: tP30-s (Cr−Fe) (D8b) D: cF8-Cr3 Si (A15) E: hP2-Mg (A3) F: hP8-Ni3 Sn (D019) G: cF4-Cu (A1) H: oI6-MoPt2
Ta
Figure 4.41. Brewer type multi-component diagrams for 6th period transition metals. Isothermal sections of the diagrams of the alloys of Cr, Mo and W, with Ta, W, Re, Os, Ir and Pt, are combined in three composite diagrams. The hatched fields are the single-phase stability regions, corresponding to the structure types listed. The binary diagrams reported on the right-hand side (Mo–Pt and Mo–Os) show the way the composite diagrams are built. In the Mo–Os system, for instance, along the selected isotherm (see the text), the following single-phase fields (segments) may be identified: Mo solid solution (cI2-W type, 0–13 at.%Os), Mo3Os (Cr3Si-type, 24.5–25.5 at.%Os), σ-phase (30–39at.%Os) and Os solid solution (hP2-Mg type, 54.5–100 at.%Os). These single-phase segments are marked on the Mo–Os horizontal line of the Mo composite diagram (in the fields labelled (A), (D), (C) and (E) respectively).
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
303
Notice, moreover, that the multi-element lateral axis of each multi-diagram may be considered as corresponding to the sequence of sections of the inter-transition metal binary systems: Ta–W, then W–Re, Re–Os, etc. The role played also for this group of alloys by the electron number (or better by the average group number) may be noticed by the fact that on the same axis we find, not only a schematic representation of the binary systems formed by two adjacent metals, but also of those given by non-adjacent elements (see Fig. 4.42). In this figure, indeed, the phase sequences formed for instance in the isothermal sections of the W–Re, Re–Os, as well as in the W–Os system, are in agreement with the reported ‘multidiagram’. Therefore every point in the lateral axis represents all the binary mixtures corresponding to the same average group number. A point for instance halfway between W and Re should ideally correspond to a mixture of 50 at.% W and 50 at.% Re, but also to a mixture of 25 at.% Os with 75 at.% W and, say, to a mixture of 12.5 at.% Pt and 87.5 at.% W, etc. All these mixtures correspond indeed to an average group number 6.5 (that is 6 0.5 7 0.5; 6 0.75 8 0.25; 6 0.875 10 0.125). Similar considerations could be extended from the right-hand axis to the entire diagram, the internal points of which will represent ternary mixtures formed, in the example shown in Fig. 4.42, by Mo with various combinations of two of the other metals.
Pt
Mo F
H
G Ir
Mo D
E Os
Mo C
Mo
B
Re
A Mo
W
Mo
Ta
Figure 4.42. Mo alloys multi-diagram. Notice that along the vertical axis, from Ta to Pt, the sequence of the isothermal sections Ta–W, W–Re, Re–Os, etc. is shown. In the same axis an approximate representation is also suggested for the other binary combinations (Ta–Re; Ta–Os, Ta–Ir, etc., W–Os, W–Ir, etc.). A confirmation of the (even partial) validity of this representation is given by the phase sequences observed in the W–Re and Re–Os systems in comparison with that of the W–Os system. (For the symbols see Fig.4.41).
304
Intermetallic Chemistry Mo
6
7
8
9 Pt 10 9 8.5
Mo
Ir
9
8 7.5 Mo
Mo
Mo
7 6.5
Os 8
Re 7
6
W 6 5.5
Mo
Ta 5
Figure 4.43. Trends of the isoelectronic curves in the different Mo–Me systems and in their combinations (curves of constant average group number of the atoms involved). The values of the average electron number per atom are indicated.
Fig. 4.43 shows for all such combinations the curves corresponding to a constant ‘average group number’ (in a way, ‘isoelectronic’ lines). Notice that their shapes are, more or less, similar to that of the boundary lines, shown in the previous figures for the various phase stability regions. A different version of these diagrams is presented, according to Ferro and Cacciamani (2002), in Fig. 4.44, where sections of the binary and ternary systems formed by Mo are collected in a triangle with Mo at one vertex. The construction criterion is similar to that adopted in § 4.3.2.3 for the rare earth-magnesium multi-diagrams. The triangle is built by connecting to this vertex the different segments representing the sections of the various binary Mo–Me diagrams. As in the previous example, the different transition metals are arranged on the third side according to their group number. Notice that in this representation the isoelectronic curves (not reported in figure) would be straight lines parallel to each other and to the segment Mo–W which corresponds to six electrons per atom. Notice now that, on the assumption that the alloying behaviour is essentially dependent on the value of the electron concentration, the multi-diagram may be considered to contain a representation (and a ‘simulation’ and a ‘prediction’) not only of the binary diagrams but also of the ternary ones.
305
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table (a)
(b)
Pt
Pt
Ir
Ir
G H
Os
Os E
F
Re
E D C
B
Re C
W
D
W
A
A Ta
Mo Os
(c)
Mo
Ta
(d)
E Os E
C
D
C
W
D A Mo
A W
Mo
Figure 4.44. Isothermal multi-diagram, at the reduced temperature Tred (see text), of the Mo–Me and Mo–Me1–Me2 systems formed by Mo with a number of transition metals (T ) of the 6th row. Single-phase fields are represented by the hatched regions. For the phase symbols see Fig.4.41. (a) The sections of the different Mo binary systems are reported along the Mo–Me1 segments with the common Mo point at one vertex of the triangle. In this representation, the isoelectronic curves (not shown) are straight lines parallel to each other (and to the segment Mo–W which corresponds to six electrons per atom). (b) The simulation of the Mo–W–Os system is shown as it is contained in the multi-diagram. Notice that in this ‘simulation’ the Re point simply represents a composition (a mixture) having an average number of seven electrons per atom. (c) The experimental isothermal (1600°C) section of the Mo–W–Os diagram (Villars et al. 1995). (d) The same experimental Mo–W–Os diagram is presented with a convenient reduction (compression) of the W–Os axis in order to make the comparison with the simulated diagram of (b) easier.
In Fig. 4.44, as a specific example, the simulation of a ternary Mo diagram (in this case the Mo–W–Os diagram) ‘extracted’ from the multi-diagram is compared with the experimental version of the same system. A general agreement may be noticed; this may highlight the relevance, and the limits, of the role played by the average valence-electron number per atom
306
Intermetallic Chemistry
(or average group number) in the stabilization of a phase with a well-defined structure and composition. The advantages of a compact representation such as that of the multi-diagrams are clear. In this case, it highlights the role of the VEC, whereas in the previously reported (§ 4.3.2.3) example of the magnesium alloys of the rare earths, the role of the (average) atomic dimensions was singled out. Similar criteria have been successfully applied to the description of several groups of alloys; Engel (1969) for instance presented Brewer type diagrams also for the combinations of the fourth and fifth column transition metals (Ti, Zr, Hf, and V, Nb, Ta) with B, C, N, O. 4.4.7 New developments in electronic counting in intermetallic compounds It has been recently underlined (Grin 2006) that the understanding the nature of intermetallic compounds is still not complete, mainly due to the strong bias imposed by applications research and to insufficient comprehension about their chemical bonding. Grin even remarked that some questions cannot be definitely answered, for instance: why some intermetallic compounds form only at distinct compositions, why others give homogeneity ranges, why some structural motifs are stable and can be often found among intermetallics, while others appear very rarely. Moreover it must be realized that attempts to find causal links between properties and chemical bonding in this class of inorganic substances are often frustrated by the lack of reliable information on bonding and properties and therefore on their relationship. He remarked that the ‘chemical bonding in intermetallic compounds is a rather open question : the local environment of atoms in the crystal structures of intermetallic compounds is difficult to describe by means of traditional molecular orbital pictures as well as by means of the free electron gas model. The atomic coordination is usually more complex as in other inorganic compounds and not necessarily may be derived from the closest sphere packing motifs characteristic or instance for structure of elemental metals’. (See also Kohout et al. 2002, Kohout 2004; Alekseeva et al. 2006, Ormeci et al. 2006a). The bonding analysis in real space is a promising way to reach a clearer comprehension of the subject. A number of quantum chemical functions are being considered and developed as tools for the analysis of the electron density and for the examination of bonding problems in the chemical compounds in the direct space. The ‘electron localization function’ has been especially considered: this function, originally defined in the framework of Hartree–Fock theory (Becke and Edgecombe 1990), and later developed for ‘density functional theory’ (Savin et al. 1992), belongs to the so-called bonding indicators in the real space (position space). The electron localization function (an approximation of the more general function ‘electron localization indicator’, Kohout 2004) represents a charge distribution of electron pairs,
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
307
and thus is a suitable tool for the analysis of chemical bonding in terms of the Lewis theory, in which the pair formation has a central role. An application of the electron localization function together with electron density gives a way of electron counting for a large group of intermetallic compounds. Full references and computation details have been reported. Crystal structure refinement and chemical bonding description in a number of substances have been obtained such as in LaMe2Ge2 (Kohout et al. 2002), diamond, elemental metals (Ormeci et al. 2006b), Eu5Ga9. For MgB2 (Grin 2006), which is not a Zintl phase, a bond order of 1.25 was derived in the graphite-like boron nets of Mg0.96B2, slightly smaller compared to 1.33 in Al0.9B2 (which is in agreement with the Zintl count). The crystal structure of the ternary boride Mg8Rh4B (Alekseeva et al. 2006) was identified as a boron stabilized, filled variant of the cF96-Ti2Ni-type structure, and was described in terms of covalently bonded [Rh4B]3 anions embedded in a cationic magnesium matrix. 4.4.7.1 Stability maps and correlation diagrams. As a concluding remark to some topics considered in this chapter and a recapitulation of procedures often employed in the description and classification of intermetallic systems, a little additional information about ‘correlation diagrams’ is included here. Several authors indeed have tried to classify and order the numerous data concerning the different intermetallic substances by using two (or three) dimensional structure maps (stability, existence diagrams). General comments on several correlation diagrams, maps and functions and their ‘predictive’ applications and use as a tool for data-driven material design have been reported in literature (See a systematic description for instance in the ‘Pauling File’ (Villars et al. 2004)). Maps and correlation diagrams have been prepared by selecting coordinates based on those parameters (generally properties of the component elements) which were considered to be determining factors of the structural stability and phase formation control. These concepts have been previously introduced (especially in § 2.2.1.3 and in the following paragraphs). A few more remarks will be reported here; particular reference will again be made to the Pettifor’s chemical scale and structure maps. 4.4.7.1.1 Pettifor’s structure maps: additional remarks. We have seen that in a phenomenological approach to the systematics of the crystal structures (and of other phase properties) several types of coordinates, derived from physical atomic properties, have been used for the preparation of (two-, three-dimensional) stability maps. Differences, sums, ratios of properties such as electronegativities, atomic radii and valence-electron numbers have been used. These variables, however, as stressed, for instance, by Villars et al. (1989) do not always clearly differentiate between chemically different atoms.
308
Intermetallic Chemistry
As already mentioned, Pettifor (1984–1986) created a chemical scale (χ) which orders the elements along a single axis. This scale, and the progressive order number of the elements in this scale, the so-called Mendeleev number M, starts with the least electronegativity element and ends with the most electronegative one (see Table 2.2). We have seen that for binary X–Y alloys, two-dimensional χX, χY (or MX , MY ) maps may be prepared which are useful for instance in the classification of compound-forming (or non-forming) systems. Similar MX , MY maps may be prepared for binary compounds XnYm (with a given n:m ratio). It has been proved that by using this ordering of the elements, an excellent separation may be obtained between the different structure types of the binary compounds of various stoichiometries (n:m 1:1, 1:2, 1:3, 1:4, ...., 1:13, 2:3, 2:5, ..., 2:17, 3:4, ..., etc.) (Pettifor 1986). See also Villars et al. (1989) who have updated the Pettifor maps for several stoichiometries. An extension of the application of these maps to the systematic description of certain groups of ternary alloys has been presented also by Pettifor (1988a, b). Composition averaged Mendeleev numbers can be used, for instance, in the description of pseudo-binary, ternary or quaternary alloys. All these maps show well-defined domains of structural stability for a given stoichiometry, thus making the search easier for new ternary or quaternary alloys with a particular structure type (and which, as a consequence, may have the potential of interesting properties and applications (Pettifor 1988a, b)). 4.4.7.1.2 Savitskii–Gribulya–Kiselova method (cybernetic computer-learning prediction system). A powerful formulation and planning of a rational description of intermetallic and, more generally, inorganic chemistry was suggested by Savitskii et al. (1980). Cybernetic computer-learning methods were proposed for predicting the existence of intermetallic phases with a given structure and/or with certain properties. The computer learning, in this case, is a process of collecting experimental evidence on the presence (or absence) of a property of interest in various physicochemical systems (defined by means of a convenient selection of the properties of the components). As a result of machine learning a model is produced of the characteristic exhibition of a property (for instance, the formation of a particular type of chemical compound) which corresponds to a distribution ‘pattern’ of this property in the multidimensional representative space of the properties of the elements. The subsequent pattern recognition corresponds to a criterion for the classification of the known compounds and for the prediction of those still unknown. Examples of this approach reported by Savitskii are the prediction of the formation of Laves phases, of CaCu5 type phases, of compounds XY2Z 4 (X, Y any of the elements, Z O, S, Se, Te), etc. (Data on the electronic structures of the components were selected as
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
309
input.) The main principles and applications for the cybernetic prediction of inorganic substances which would have pre-defined properties have been summarized and discussed by Kiselyova (1993). 4.4.7.1.3 Analysis of the dependence of the behaviour of alloy systems on the properties of the component elements. In an examination of the binary structure types containing more than five representatives, Villars and Girgis (1982) observed that 85% exhibited the following regularities: (a) linear dependence of interatomic distances on concentration weighted radii; (b) narrow ranges of the space-filling parameter and of the unit cell edge ratio c/a (and b/a) for the representatives of a given structure type; (c) dependence between the position of the elements in the Periodic Table (in the s, p, d and f blocks) and their equipoint occupation in the structure; (d) narrow grouping of the phases pertaining to a given structure type, in isostoichiometric diagrams based on the positions of the components in the Periodic Table. These relationships have been used to predict the existence and/or the structure type (and the unit cell characteristics) of binary intermetallic compounds. By using a systematic procedure to find the relevant element properties representing the alloying behaviour of binary systems, Villars (1983, 1985) defined three expressions for atomic properties which enable systems that form compounds to be separated from those that do not. A similar procedure was also used by Villars to find atomic property expressions which could be used to distinguish the crystal structures of intermetallic compounds; 182 sets of tabulated physical properties and calculated atomic properties were considered. These were combined, for binary phases, according to the modulus sums, differences and ratios. The best separations were obtained by using threedimensional maps, which, for a binary AxBy, x y compound, were based on the following variables (Villars and Hulliger 1987, Villars et al. 1989). ΣVE, averaged sum of the valence electrons of the elements A and B, defined by ΣVE (xVEA yVEB)/(x y),
(4.36)
ΔX, electronegativity difference, according to the Martynov and Batsanov (1980) scale defined by ΔX [2x/(x y)] (XA XB)
(4.37)
310
Intermetallic Chemistry
Δ(rs rp)Z, difference of Zunger’s pseudo-potential radii sum (Zunger (1981), defined by Δ(rs rp)Z [2 x/(x y)][(rs rp) Z,A (rs rp)Z,B]
(4.38)
Several structural types, corresponding to about 5500 binary compounds and alloys, were considered; 147 structure types were classified as 97 coordination types. The applications of these maps, which, in the most favourable cases make it possible to predict not only the CN and polyhedron but also the structure type or a limited number of possibilities, were discussed. The possible extension to ternary and quaternary phases was also considered. As an example of an investigation on a selected group of ternary alloys, a paper by Hovestreydt (1988) can be mentioned. In analogy with the work of Villars, a three-dimensional structure stability diagram was constructed. For the equiatomic RETX compounds formed by the rare earth metal (RE) with transition metal (T) and Ga, Si or Ge (X) the variables considered were: the difference in atomic radii rX rRE, the Martynov–Batsanov electronegativity of the T metal and the expression GT GX PX, related to the position in the Periodic Table of the T and X elements, where G is the group and P the period number. A good separation was obtained for the 8 structural types considered (corresponding to 202 compounds). Special, modified, structure stability diagrams have been used for the elements by Villars and Daams (1993). Maps were built by using the variables, valenceelectron number and Zunger pseudo-potential radius and reporting the atomic environment types (see § 3.7.5) found in the element structures. A simple separation into different stability domains was observed. By including the high-temperature, highpressure crystal structure data, a prediction was made of the atomic environment modifications, hitherto unknown for several elements, to be found under highpressure, high-temperature conditions. An empirical relation between band gap and Zunger’s orbital electronegativity in sp-bonded compounds has been determined by Makino (1994a) using a formula derived from the bond orbital model. Based on the bond orbital model and Zunger’s orbital electronegativity, new structural maps of AB, AB2 and AB3 compounds between transition metals have been successfully constructed (Makino 1994b). The relevant data concerning the different elements have been reported in the specific paragraphs of Chapter 5. 4.4.7.1.4 Prediction of the properties of selected families of alloys: Gschneidner’s relations as an example. Stability maps and/or correlation diagrams
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
311
may be especially simple and easy to handle for selected groups of similar alloys; for instance, alloys of the elements of the same group of the Periodic Table. The alloys of the rare earth metals, especially the ‘trivalent ones’, are a good example. It is well known that, within this family of elements, several properties change according to well-recognized and systematic patterns. The atomic number itself can be used in this case as a simple and convenient chemical parameter. In several instances it has been pointed out that a systematic consideration of the crystal structures and of the phase diagrams of alloys formed by analogous elements (such as those of the trivalent rare earth family) enables a number of empirical regularities to be deduced and theoretical statements to be made. See a general discussion on this subject by Gschneidner (1969) Gschneidner and Mc Masters (1971), the comments by Yatsenko et al. (1979, 1983), Colinet et al. (1984a, b) on alloy thermodynamics, the papers by Massalski (1989) on the applications of this behaviour to phase diagram assessment, by Parthé and Chabot (1984), Rogl (1984) and by Iandelli and Palenzona (1979) for a systematic crystal-chemical description. See Sereni (1984) for examples and a discussion of the properties of the rare earth metals themselves. See also some comments on this point in § 4.3.2.2. Criteria based on the mentioned characteristics have been used in assessment procedures and in the prediction of phase diagrams and of phase and structure type formation. Fig. 4.15 may be considered as an example of such typical trends and of their correlations. Special applications (prediction of Pm-alloys) have been described by Saccone et al. (1990). The applicability of similar criteria to the assessment and prediction of phase equilibria in selected groups of ternary rare earth alloys, containing two different rare earth metals, has been exemplified by Giovannini et al. (1995a, b) in the description of complex Mg–R alloy systems. Considering other families of similar compounds, the contributions given by Guillermet and Frisk (1992), Guillermet and Grimvall (1991) (cohesive and thermodynamic properties, atomic average volumes, etc. of nitrides, borides, etc. of transition metals) are other examples of systematic descriptions of selected groups of phases and of the use of special interpolation and extrapolation procedures to predict specific properties. 4.4.7.1.5 Miedema’s theory and structural information. The Miedema model for energy effects in alloys, presented in § 2.2.1.3 has been very useful in an evaluation, albeit approximate, of the formation enthalpies and in the ‘prediction’ of compound formation capability. For an example of the application and limits of this model, see the comments on the thermochemistry of the Laves phases reported in § 3.9.3. However notice that the general usefulness of the Miedema approaches has diminished with time, both for its inherent approximation and for
312
Intermetallic Chemistry
the increasing number of experimentally determined and available values of the formation enthalpy. In any case, just for the sake of completeness we remind here that the two main Miedema parameters, ΔΦ* and ΔnWS1/3, have also been used (Zunger 1981, Rajasekharan and Girgis 1983) as variables for the construction of structural plots of intermetallic phases (stability maps, correlation diagrams). REFERENCES
Alekseeva, A.M., Abakumov, A.M., Leithe-Jasper, A., Schnelle, W., Prots, Yu., Chizov, P.S., van Tendeloo, G., Antipov, E.V. and Grin, Yu. (2006) J. Solid State Chem., 179, 2751. Balasubramanian, K. (2004) Relativity and the Periodic Table. In The Periodic Table into the 21st Century, eds. Rouvray, D.H. and King, R.B. (Research Studies Press Ltd., Baldock, Herfordshire). Bärninghausen, H. (1980) Match (Comm. Mathematical Chemistry), 9, 139. Becke, A.D. and Edgecombe, K.E. (1990) J. Chem. Phys., 92, 5397. Bhatia, M.L. and Cahn, R.W. (2005) Intermetallics, 13, 474. Biltz, W. (1934) Raumchemie der Festen Stoffe (Voss-Verlag, Leipzig). Brewer, L. (1965) High Strength Materials, ed. Zackay, V.F. (John Wiley & Sons, New York). Brewer, L. (1973) Metall. Trans., 4, 83. Brewer, L. (1990) J. Phys. Chem., 94, 1196. Brunner, G.O. (1977) Acta Crystallogr., A33, 226. Cahn, R.W. (2001) The Coming of Materials Science, ed. Cahn, R.W. (Pergamon Materials Series, Pergamon, Amsterdam). Cahn, R.W. and Haasen, P. eds. (1996) Physical Metallurgy (North-Holland, Amsterdam). Cheetham, A.K. and Day, P. (1992) Solid State Chemistry Compounds (Clarendon Press, Oxford). Chevrel, R., Sergent, M. and Prigent, J. (1971) Solid State Chem., 3, 515. Colinet, C., Pasturel, A., Percheron-Guegan, A. and Achard, J.C. (1984a) J. Less-Common Met., 102, 167. Colinet, C., Pasturel, A., Percheron-Guegan, A. and Achard, J.C. (1984b) J. Less-Common Met., 102, 239. Connor, J.A. (1977) Topics. Curr. Chem., 71, 71. Connor, J.A. (1981) Transition Metal Clusters, ed. Johnson, B.F.G. (John Wiley & Sons Inc., New York), p. 345. Corbett, J.D. (1996) Zintl phases of the early p-block elements. In: Chemistry, Structure, and Bonding of Zintl Phases and Ions, ed. Kauzlarich, S.M. (VCH Publishers; New York), Chapter 3. Corbett, J.D. (2000) Inorg. Chem., 39, 5178. Cotton, F.A. and Walton, R.A. (1982) Multiple Bonds between Metal Atoms (John Wiley & Sons Inc., New York). Cotton, F.A. and Wilkinson, G. (1988) Advanced Inorganic Chemistry, 5th Edition (John Wiley & Sons Inc., New York).
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
313
Cotton, F.A., Wilkinson, G., Bochmann, M. and Murillo, C. (1999) Advanced Inorganic Chemistry, 6th Edition (Wiley International, New York). Ellner, M. (2004) Metall. Mater. Trans., 35A, 63. Ellner, M. and Predel, B. (1995) Bond characterization from thermodynamic properties. In: Intermetallic Compounds. Principles and Practice, eds. Westbrook, J.H. and Fleischer, R.L. (John Wiley & Sons Ltd., Chichester), Vol. 1, p. 91. Engel, N.N. (1969) Alloy phase stability criteria. In: Developments in the Structural Chemistry of Alloy Phases, ed. Giessen, B.C. (Plenum Press, New York), p. 25. Faure, G. (1991) Principles and Applications of Inorganic Geochemistry (MacMillan Publishers Company New York). Ferro, R. and Cacciamani, G. (2002) Chemical criteria in the assessment of alloy constitutional properties. In: CALPHAD and Alloy Thermodynamics, eds. Turchi, P.E.A., Gonis, A. and Shull, R.D. (TMS The Minerals, Metals & Materials Society), Warrendale, PA., p. 177. Flandorfer, H., Giovannini, M., Saccone, A., Rogl, P. and Ferro, R. (1997) Metall. Trans., 28A, 265. Fornasini, M.L. and Merlo, F. (2006) Z. Kristallogr., 221, 382. Giovannini, M., Saccone, A. and Ferro, R. (1995a) J. Alloys Compd., 220, 167. Giovannini, M., Saccone, A., Marazza, R. and Ferro, R. (1995b) Metall. Trans., 26A, 5. Giovannini, M., Saccone, A., Flandorfer, H., Rogl, P. and Ferro, R. (1997) Z. Metallkde., 88, 372. Girgis, K. (1983) Structure of intermetallic compounds. In: Physical Metallurgy, 3rd Edition eds. Cahn, R.W. and Haasen, P. (North-Holland, Amsterdam), p. 220. Goldschmidt, V.M. (1928) Z. Phys. Chem., 133, 397. Goldschmidt, V.M. (1954) Geochemistry, ed. Muir, A. (Oxford University Press, London). Greenwood, N.N. and Earnshaw, A. (1997) Chemistry of the Elements, 2nd Edition (Pergamon, Oxford). Grimm, H.G. and Sommerfeld, A. (1926) Z. Physik, 36, 36. Grin, Yu. (2006) Proceedings XXII National Congress of the Italian Chemical Society, Firenze Italy, 10–15 September INO-PL-4, p. 295. (see also: http://www.cpfs. mpg.de/ELF). Grüttner, A., Yvon, K., Chevrel, R., Potel, M., Sergent, M. and Seeber, B. (1979) Acta Crystallogr., B35, 285. Gschneidner Jr., K.A. (1969) J. Less Common Met., 17, 1. Gschneidner Jr., K.A. (1980a) From infinity to zero and back again to infinity (from mixed rare earths to ultrapure metals to pseudolanthanides). In: The Rare Earths in Modern Sciences and Technology, ed. McCarthy, G.J., Rhyne, J.J. and Silber, H.B. (Plenum Press, New York), Vol. 2, p. 13. Gschneidner Jr., K.A. (1980b) Theory of Alloy Phase Formation, ed. Bennett, L.H. (The Metallurgical Society of AIME, New York), p. 1. Gschneidner Jr., K.A. and McMasters, O.D. (1971) Monatsh. Chem., 102, 1499. Guillermet, A.F. and Frisk, K. (1992) Proceedings of the CALPHAD XXI, 14–19 June, Jerusalem, Israel, p. 38. Guillermet, A.F. and Grimvall, G. (1991) J. Less Common Met., 169, 257.
314
Intermetallic Chemistry
Hafner, J. (1985) J. Phys. F, 15, L43. Hafner, J. (1989) The Structures of Binary Compounds. Cohesion and Structure, ed. de Boer, F.R. and Pettifor. D.G. (North-Holland, Amsterdam), Vol. 2, p. 105. Henley, C.L., de Boissieu, M. and Steurer, W. (2005) Proceedings 9th International Conference on Quasicrystals, Ames, 22–26 May, http://www.icq9.ameslab.gov Hoffmann, R. (1982) Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 21, 711. Hoffmann, R. (1987) Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 26, 846. Hoffmann, R. (1988) Solids and Surfaces (VCH Publishers, New York). Hovestreydt, E. (1988) J. Less Common Met., 143, 25. Huheey, J.E., Keiter, E.A. and Keiter, R.L. (1997) Inorganic Chemistry: Principles of Structure and Reactivity, (Prentice Hall). Hume-Rothery, W. (1926) J. Inst. Met, 35, 295. Hyde, B.G. and Andersson, S. (1989) Inorganic Crystal Structures (John Wiley & Sons Inc., New York). Iandelli, A. and Palenzona, A. (1979) crystal chemistry of intermetallic compounds. In: Handbook on the Physics and Chemistry of Rare Earths, eds. Gschneidner Jr., K.A. and Eyring, L. (North-Holland, Amsterdam), Vol.2, p. 1. Jepsen, O., Burkhardt, A. and Andersen, O.K. (1999) The program TB-LMTO-ASA Version 4.7 (Max-Planck Institute für Festkörperforschung, Stuttgart). Jiang, J. and Kauzlarich, S.M. (2006) Chem. Mater., 18, 435. Jiang, J., Olmstead, M.M., Kauzlarich, S.M., Lee, H., Klavins, P. and Fisk, Z. (2005) Inorg. Chem., 44, 5322. Kauzlarich, S.M. ed. (1996) Chemistry, Structure, and Bonding of Zintl phases and Ions (VCH Publishers, New York). King, B. (1993) Applications of Graph Theory and Topology in Inorganic Cluster and Coordination Chemistry (CRC Press Boca Raton, Ann Arbor). King, R.B. (2004a) The metallurgist’s Periodic Table and the Zintl-Klemm concept. In: The Periodic Table into the 21st Century, eds. Rouvray, D.H. and King, R.B (Research Studies Press Ltd, Baldock, Hertfordshire), p. 189. King, R.B. (2004b) Dalton Trans., 3420. Kiselyova, N.N. (1993) J. Alloys Comp., 197, 159. Klemm, W. (1950) Angew. Chem., 62, 133. Klemm, W. and Busmann, E. (1963) Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem., 319, 297. Kohout, M. (2004) Int. J. Quantum Chem., 97, 651. Kohout, M., Wagner, F.R. and Grin, Yu. (2002) Theor. Chem. Acc., 108, 150. Kubaschewski, O. (1967) Phase Stability in Metals and Alloys, eds. Rudman, P.S., Stringer, J. Jaffee, R.I. (McGraw-Hill, New York), p. 63. Laves, F. (1941) Naturwissenschaften, 29, 244. Laves, F. (1956) Theory of Alloy Phases (American Society for Metal., Cleveland, OH). Laves, F. (1967) Phase Stability in Metals and Alloys, eds Rudman, P.S., Stringer, J. and Jaffee, R.I. (McGraw-Hill, New York), p. 85. Lee, S. and Hoistad, L. (1995) J. Alloys Compd., 229, 66. Li, B. and Corbett, J.D. (2004) Inorg. Chem., 43, 3582.
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
315
Lin, Q.-S. and Corbett, J.D. (2004) Inorg. Chem., 43, 1912. Liu, L.-G. and Bassett, W.A. (1986) Elements, Oxides, and Silicates – High Pressure Phases with Implications for the Earth’s Interior, Oxford Monographs on Geology and Geophysics, N.4 (Oxford University Press, New York). Liu, S.-F. and Corbett, J.D. (2004) Inorg. Chem., 43, 2471. Longoni, G. and Chini, P. (1976) J. Am. Chem. Soc., 98, 7225. Madelung, E. (1936) Die Mathematischen Hilfsmittel des Physikers, 3rd Edition (SpringerVerlag, Berlin). Makino, Y. (1994a) Intermetallics, 2, 55. Makino, Y. (1994b) Intermetallics, 2, 67. Martynov, A.I. and Batsanov, S.S. (1980) Russ. J. Inorg. Chem., 25, 1737. Massalski, T.B. (1989) Metall. Trans., 20A, 1295. Matthias, B.T., Marezio, M., Corenzwit, E., Cooper, A.S. and Barz, H.E. (1972) Science, 175, 1465. McCleverty, J.A. (2004) Highlights in inorganic chemistry over the last 100 Years In: Annual Reports on the Progress of Chemistry, Inorganic Chemistry, eds. Berry, F.J. and Jones, C.J. (Royal Society of Chemistry, H.Charlesworth & Co. Ltd., Wakefield), Vol. 100, Section 4, p. 3. McGrady, J.E. (2004) J. Chem. Educ., 81, 733. McGuire, M.A., Ranjan, C. and Di Salvo, F.D. (2006) Inorg. Chem., 45, 2718. Merlo, F. (1988) J. Phys. F: Met. Phys., 18, 1905. Miedema, A.R. and Niessen, A.K. (1982) Physica, B114, 367. Miller, G.J., Lee, C.-S. and Choe, W. (2002) Structure and bonding around the Zintl border. In: Inorganic Chemistry highlights, eds. Meyer, G., Naumann, D. and Wesemann, L. (Wiley VCH, Weinheim), p. 21. Mingos, D.M.P. and Wales, D.J. (1990) Introduction to Cluster Chemistry (Prentice Hall International Inc., Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey). Mooser, E. and Pearson, W.B. (1959) Acta Cryst., 12, 1015. Mohr, P.J. and Taylor, B.N. (2005) Rev. Mod. Phys., 77, 1. Moseley, H.G.J. (1913) Phil. Mag., 26, 1024. Müller, U. (1994) Inorganic Structural Chemistry 2nd Edition (John Wiley & Sons Ltd., Chichester). Nesper, R. (1990) Prog. Solid State Chem., 20, 1. Okamoto, H. (2000) Phase Diagrams for Binary alloys, Desk Handbook (ASM International, Materials Park, OH). Ormeci, A., Rosner, H., Wagner, F.R., Kohout, M. and Grin, Yu. (2006a) J. Phys. Chem., A110, 1100. Ormeci, A., Koepernik, K. and Rosner, H. (2006b) Phys. Rev. B, B74, 104119. Ostrovsky, V. N. (2004) The Periodic Table and Quantum physics. In: The Periodic Table into the 21st Century, eds. Rouvray, D.H. and King, R.B. ( Research Studies Press Ltd., Baldock, Hertfordshire), p. 331. Parthé, E. (1961) Z. Krystallogr., 115, 52. Parthé, E. (1963) Z. Krystallogr., 119, 204.
316
Intermetallic Chemistry
Parthé, E. (1964) Crystal Chemistry of Tetrahedral Structures (Gordon and Breach, New York). Parthé, E. (1969) The Concept of a partial electron concentration value and its application to problems in crystal chemistry. In: Developments in the Structural Chemistry of Alloy Phases, ed. Giessen, B.C. (Plenum Press, New York), p. 49. Parthé, E. (1980) Valence and Tetrahedral Structure Compounds, ed. Parthé, E. (Summer School on Inorganic Crystal Chemistry, Geneva). Parthé, E. (1995) Wurtzite and Zinc-Blende Structures. In Intermetallic Compounds Principles and Practice, eds. Westbrook, J.H. and Fleischer, R.L. (John Wiley & Sons Ltd., Chichester), Vol. 1, pp. 343–362. Parthé, E. and Chabot, B. (1984) Crystal structures and crystal chemistry of ternary rare earth-transition metal borides, silicides and homologues. In: Handbook on the Physics and Chemistry of Rare Earths, ed. Gschneidner Jr., K.A. and Eyring, L. (North–Holland, Amsterdam), Vol. 6, p. 113. Pauling, L. (1947) J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 69, 542. Pauling, L. (1960) The Nature of the Chemical Bond (Cornell University, Ithaca, New York). Pearson, W.B. (1972) The Crystal Chemistry and Physics of Metals and Alloys (WileyInterscience, New York). Pettifor, D.G. (1984) Solid State Commun., 51, 31. Pettifor, D.G. (1985) J. Less Common Met., 114, 7. Pettifor, D.G. (1986) J. Phys. C: Solid State Phys., 19, 285. Pettifor, D.G. (1988a) Physica B, 149, 3. Pettifor, D.G. (1988b) Mat. Sci. Technol., 4, 675. Pettifor, D.G.(1995) Structure mapping. In: Intermetallic Compounds-Principles and Practice, eds. Westbrook, J.H. and Fleischer, R.L. (John Wiley & Sons Ltd., Chichester), Vol. 1, pp. 419–438. Pettifor, D.G. (2000) Controversial concepts in alloy theory revisited. In: The Science of Alloys for the 21st Century, eds. Turchi, E.A., Shull, R.D., Gonis, A. (TMA, The Minerals, Metals and Materials Society, Warrendale, Pennsylvania), p. 121. Potel, M., Chevrel, R. and Sergent, M. (1980) Acta Crystallog., B36, 1319. Rayner-Canham, G.W. (2004) The richness of periodic patterns. In: The Periodic Table: Into the 21st Century, eds. Rouvray, D.H. and King, R.B. (Research Studies Press Ltd., Baldock, Hertfordshire), p. 161. Rajasekharan, T. and Girgis, K. (1983) Phys. Rev. B, 27, 910. Richter, K.W., Prots, Y. and Grin, Y. (2005) Inorg. Chem., 44, 4576. Rogl, P. (1984) Phase equilibria in ternary and higher order systems with rare earth elements and boron. In: Handbook on the Physics and Chemistry of Rare Earths, eds. Gschneidner Jr., K.A. and Eyring, L. (North-Holland, Amsterdam), Vol. 6, p. 335. Rouvray, D.H. and King, R.B. eds. (2004) The Periodic Table into the 21st Century (Research Studies Press Ltd., Baldock, Hertfordshire, UK). Saccone, A., Delfino, S. and Ferro, R. (1990) CALPHAD, 14, 151. Savin, A., Flad, H.J., Flad, J., Preuss, H. and von Schnering, H.G. (1992) Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 31, 187. Savitskii, E.M., Gribulya, V.B. and Kiselyova, N.N. (1980) J. Less Common Met., 72, 307.
Intermetallic Reactivity Trends in the Periodic Table
317
Schäfer, H. and Schnering, H.G. (1964) Angew. Chem., 76, 833. Schomaker, V. and Stevenson, D.P. (1941) J. Am. Chem. Soc., 63, 37. Sereni, J.G. (1984) J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 45, 1219. Sevov, S.C. (2002) Zintl phases. In: Intermetallic Compounds, eds. Westbrook, J.H. and Fleischer, R.L, (John Wiley & Sons Ltd, Chichester, England), Vol. 3, Chapter 6, p 113. Simon, A. (1981) Angew. Chem. Int. Ed Engl., 20, 1. Simon, A. (1983) Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 22, 95. Simon, A. (1988) Angew. Chem. Int. Ed Engl., 27, 159. Simon, A. (1992) Metal-rich compounds. In: Solid State Chemistry (Compounds), eds. Cheetham, A.K. and Day, P. (Clarendon Press, Oxford, England). Simon, A. (1995) J. Alloys Comp., 229, 158. Steurer, W.(2005) Stable clusters in quasicrystals – fact or fiction? Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on Quasicrystals, Ames, 22–26 May, http://www.icq9.ameslab.gov Stone, H.E. (1979) Acta Met., 27, 259. Teatum, E.T., Gschneidner Jr., K.A. and Waber, J.T. (1968) Compilation of Calculated Data Useful in Predicting Metallurgical Behavior of the Elements in Binary Alloy Systems, Report LA-4003, UC-25, Metals, Ceramics and Materials, TID-4500, Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory. Turchi, E.A., Shull, R.D. and Gonis, A. eds. (2000) The science of alloys for the 21st century: A Hume–Rothery symposium celebration, Proceedings of a Symposium Held During the Fall Meeting St. Louis, October 2000 (TMS). Uhlenbeck, G.E. and Goudsmit, S. (1925) Naturwiss., 13, 925. Van der Lugt, W. (1996) Polyanions in liquid ionic alloys. In: Chemistry, Structure and Bonding of Zintl Phases and Ions, ed. Kauzlarich, S.M. (VCH Publisher, New York), p. 183. Van der Lugt, W. and Verkerk, P. (2002) Molten Zintl alloys. In: Inorganic Chemistry Highlights eds. Meyer, G., Naumann, D. and Wesemann, L. (Wiley, VCH, Weinheim), p. 1. Vegard, L. (1921) Z. Physik, 5, 17. Villars, P. (1983) J. Less Common Met., 92, 215. Villars, P. (1985) J. Less Common Met., 109, 93. Villars, P. (1995) Factors governing crystal structures. In: Intermetallic Compounds Principles and Practice, eds. Westbrook, J.H. and Fleischer, R.L. (John Wiley & Sons Ltd., Chichester), p. 227. Villars, P. and Daams, J.L.C. (1993) J.Alloys Compd., 197, 177. Villars, P. and Girgis, K. (1982) Z. Metallkd., 73, 455. Villars, P. and Hulliger, F. (1987) J. Less Common Met., 132, 289. Villars, P. Mathis, K. and Hulliger, F. (1989) The Structures of Binary Compounds. Cohesion and Structure, eds. Boer, F.R. and Pettifor, D.G. (North-Holland, Amsterdam), Vol. 2, p. 1. Villars, P., Prince, A. and Okamoto, H. ed. (1995) Handbook of Ternary Alloy Phase Diagrams (ASM International, Materials Park, OH), Vol.1–10. Villars, P., Berndt, M., Brandeburg, K., Cenzual, K., Daams, J., Hulliger, F., Massalski, T., Okamoto, H., Osaki, K., Prince, A., Putz, H. and Iwata, S. (2004) J. Alloys Comp., 367, 297.
318
Intermetallic Chemistry
Wade, K. (1976) Adv. Inorg. Chem. Radiochem., 18, 1. Wells, A.F. (1984) Structural Inorganic Chemistry, 5th Edition (Clarendon Press, Oxford). Westbrook, J.H. (1977) Metall. Trans., 8A, 1327. Westbrook, J.H. and Fleischer, R.L. eds. (1995) Intermetallic Compounds. Principles and Practice (John Wiley & Sons Ltd., Chichester). Yatsenko, S.P., Semyannikov, A.A., Semenov, B.G. and Chuntonov, K.A. (1979) J. Less Common Met., 64, 185. Yatsenko, S.P., Semyannikov, A.A., Shakarov, H.O. and Fedorova, E.G. (1983) J. Less Common Met., 90, 95. Zen, E.-An. (1956) Amer. Min., 41, 523. Zintl, E. and Dullenkopf, W. (1932) Z. Phys. Chem., B16, 195. Zunger, A. (1981) Structure and Bonding in Crystals, eds. O’Keeffe, M. and Navrotski, A. (Academic Press, New York), Vol. 1, p. 73.
Chapter 5
Elements of Alloying Behaviour Systematics
5.1. INTRODUCTORY NOTES
This chapter describes typical aspects of the alloying behaviour of the different metals, with reference to the general topics previously discussed. The metals will be considered according to their order in the Periodic Table and to their reactivity towards the other elements. The Pettifor scale and the so-called Mendeleev number have been used in previous chapters as an introduction to some aspects of the alloying systematics. Owing to the considerable amount of available information relevant to the numerous intermetallic phases and simple and complex alloy systems studied, only a selection of these data is presented here. Although our treatment is by no means exhaustive and not all the alloy systems or intermetallic systems will be dealt with, the main aim is to give examples of the systematic alloying behaviour of the metals and of the typical aspects of intermetallic chemistry. Close attention is devoted to the crystal chemistry of the intermediate phases and to the mutual reactivity of different metal pairs as depicted by their phase diagrams. Analogies among various alloys are drawn, and the trend of their properties along the Periodic Table is particularly highlighted. The uses and applications of some common metals and of their alloys are briefly discussed. Binary systems and intermetallic phases are considered. For a few metals, however, examples of complex alloys are described in order to present some aspects of general interest and/or on the basis of the variety of compounds and applications known. Generally, each paragraph of this chapter is dedicated to a group (or column) of the Periodic Table. The introduction and the initial part of each paragraph describe the metals of the group and provide general information and reference data, such as their reference electron configurations, their occurrence and preparation, a few of their atomic and physical properties and their general chemical properties and reactivity. Numerical values for some properties of the elements and, in some cases, of the compounds are reported. Selected atomic and physical properties like atomic radii, melting and boiling temperatures of the elements and the related transformation enthalpies are considered. Solid-state data of the elements are also given including the structures of the different allotropic forms, their temperature (and pressure) stability ranges, the corresponding lattice parameters, as well as the relevant values of the average atomic volume in the solid (as obtained 319
320
Intermetallic Chemistry
from the cell volume divided by the number of atoms in the cell), the corresponding molar volume (atomic volume multiplied by the Avogadro number) and the calculated density (instead of the experimental density which often depends on the particular mechanical treatments to which the metal has been subjected). Concerning the ionization energies, in order to avoid very long lists, only two or three values, from the first to the last, relevant to the valence electrons and the lowest value of the core electrons are given. For the above-mentioned data, we are indebted to a number of fundamental treatises and publications of inorganic chemistry to which the interested reader may refer for a thorough examination of the subject. These data will play a significant role in defining and discussing the alloying behaviour of the metals involved. With regard to the values reported in the tables, we are more concerned with the general order of magnitude rather than with the precise values. In literature, slightly different values appear, owing to the variety of preparation and measurement techniques or often, for a given phase, to the existence of not so well-defined homogeneity ranges. The tables are therefore intended to provide a general idea of the behaviour of the elements, and particularly of the compounds, as well as of the trends of quantities such as melting and transformation temperatures, enthalpies, lattice parameter data, etc. However, accurate and more recently assessed individual values of such parameters and quantities should be found in the original literature. 5.1.1 Symbols and nomenclature Besides the crystallographic and chemical symbols and nomenclature previously introduced, a few special symbols have been used in this chapter. Generally, for nearly all the metals (Me), a summary is given of their reactivity with the other elements. This is outlined in the text and in figures representing the Periodic Table. In some cases, more than one table is provided for each element. The different binary systems Me–X are identified by the position in the Table of the element X, and their characteristics are briefly described by one of the following symbols inserted in the corresponding box: : This indicates the element being described. : Some intermediate phases formed either from the liquid or, for instance, by ordering in the solid state, have been identified in the system considered. See several examples shown in Figs 2.18 and 2.19 as well as that in Fig. 2.20 where a continuous solid solution is formed, but ordered phases (intermediate compounds) at different temperatures may also be observed. Notice, however, that in many cases, compounds have been identified by preparative and crystallographic studies only, even without being defined by a phase diagram investigation.
Elements of Alloying Behaviour Systematics
321
Contradictions and disagreements may therefore be found in the literature. In the tables included in this chapter, intended to describe the reference stable behaviour, attention has been especially dedicated to the results of phase diagram studies. : The formation of intermediate phases has been suggested but not confirmed. : The system has been studied and no intermediate phases have been found. The phase diagram resulted, for instance, in a simple peritectic or eutectic type or in an extended monotectic type. The only solid phases existing in the system are the terminal phases. See the examples of Ag–Cu, Au–Si, Ga–Bi in Figs 2.10, 2.11 and 2.16, respectively. : No reliable information on the phase diagram and/or any intermediate phases. The formation of at least one solid solution phase extending from one component to the other has been identified in some Me–X phase diagrams. This phase may either be stable in the complete temperature range or only in a limited temperature interval. (See the V–Mo and Ni–Au diagrams in Figs. 2.1 and 2.9, the Ta–V diagram in Fig. 2.19 and the Au–Cu system in Fig. 2.20.) Elements X, forming diagrams characterized by extensive solid solutions with a given metal Me, are generally close to each other in the Periodic Table and to the metal Me. Further tables show such cases. A similar layout has been generally adopted in the preparation of the various tables and schemes relevant to the different groups of elements. However, from one group to another a few changes may be noticed: this may be due to the more or less complete availability of the relevant data or to some peculiar characteristics of the element properties (and/or of their trends). Typical examples are: the description of the alloying behaviour of a group of ‘divalent’ metals (Ca, Sr, Ba together with Eu and Yb) as discussed in the introductions of § 5.4 and 5.12), the presentation of the lanthanides and actinides (§ 5.5), and the description of the metals of the 8th, 9th, and 10th groups (‘iron family’ and ‘platinum family’ metals and alloys in § 5.10). Commercial alloys: composition, nomenclature. A simple and general way of identification of a commercial alloy (or of a group of similar alloys) consists of a ‘label’ which gives (as rounded values) the mass% contents of the main components indicated by their chemical symbols. The alloy, for instance, Ti–6Al–4V, is a titanium-based alloy typically containing 6 mass% aluminium and 4 mass% vanadium. Notice however that for several common metal alloys (Mg, Al, Fe, etc.) special designation codes are used. As an example of the standard ASTM designation system, the codes used for the commercial magnesium alloys are shown in § 5.12.4.5.
322
Intermetallic Chemistry
A complete reference to this subject may be found in the ASM Handbook Series published by ASM International (USA). Alloy crystal and thermal data symbols. A number of tables show, for selected alloys, the highest melting points observed in the systems considered, as well as the mechanism of formation (p peritectic melting, syn synthetic reaction, s.s.r. solid-state reaction, est. estimated melting point, etc.), the value of the Raynor Index (1, 1 or 1). The question mark means that no reliable data are available. A selection of the crystal data is generally given in tables where examples of the most frequent structural types found in the alloys of the concerned metals are listed. The Pearson symbols and the coordination environmental symbols are given. The accompanying texts underline some characteristics of the structure types observed in the alloys of the given group of metals. However, for the crystallography and general characteristics of each structure (coordination, relations with other structure types, occurrence, etc.), reference should be made to Chapter 7 where a number of common structural types have been collected and described. In several cases, without attempting to give an exhaustive description, an indication is given of the homogeneity ranges for various solid solution phases. At a given stoichiometry, several intermediate compounds may exist as different polymorphs depending on temperature; this means that different crystal structures may be listed in the tables for the same stoichiometry. For simplicity, the different polymorphs are reported in the tables without the indication of their respective temperature ranges of existence. Additional information on this subject may be found in Chapter 7 and in the collections of phase diagrams and crystal structure data in the literature sources reported below. Alloys of the p-block elements. In this chapter a look is given at the alloys and compounds of nearly all the elements from the metals of the 1st group up to the semimetals and non-metals of the 16th group. This is especially to show the gradual change in properties and behaviour on passing through the full extension of the Periodic Table. However, since particular attention is given to the intermetallic systems, a much more reduced description is presented for the elements of the last groups. Sources of the specific data given in the tables were from the following authors: Barin and Knacke (1973); Chase (1998); Freeman and Keller (1991); Gschneidner and Calderwood (1982); Massalski et al. (1990); Okamoto (2000); Shannon (1976); Teatum et al. (1968); Villars and Calvert (1991); Villars et al. (1995).
323
Elements of Alloying Behaviour Systematics 5.2 ALLOYS OF HYDROGEN
Hydrogen, H
5.2.1 Introduction Hydrogen: (H, 1s1), name and symbol from the Greek υδωρ ´ -γενναω ´ (water forming). First identified as an element by Henry Cavendish (1766). Odourless, colourless gas, flammable and explosive. Hydrogen atomic number 1, atomic relative mass 1.00794. Occurrence. Hydrogen is the most abundant element of the universe. It is the tenth abundant element (in mass%) of the earth’s crust, after O, Si, Al, Fe, Ca, Na, K, Mg, Ti. Isotopes of hydrogen. Three isotopes of hydrogen are known 1H, 2H (deuterium or D), 3H (tritium or T). Isotope effects are greater for hydrogen than for any other elements (and this may by a justification for the different names), but practically the chemical properties of H, D and T are nearly identical except in matters such as rates and equilibrium constants of reactions (see Tables 5.1a and 5.1b). Molecular H2 and D2 have two forms, ortho and para forms in which the nuclear spins are aligned or opposed, respectively. This results in very slight differences in bulk physical properties: the two forms can be separated by gas chromatography. Deuterium. Naturally occurring hydrogen contains 0.0156 at.% D. Deuterium as D2O is separated from H2O by fractional distillation or electrolytic enrichment of normal water. Table 5.1a. Atomic properties of hydrogen and its isotopes. Property
H
D
T
Relative atomic mass Nuclear spin quantic number Radioactive stability 1st ionization energy/kJ/mol
1.007825 1/2 Stable 1312.0
2.014102 1 Stable
3.016049 1/2 βt1/2 12.35y
324
Intermetallic Chemistry Table 5.1b. Physical properties of hydrogen and its isotopes. Property
H2
D2
T2
Melting point/K Boiling point/K ΔHmelting/kJ/mol ΔHboiling/kJ/mol Critical temperature/K Critical pressure/MPa
13.957 20.39 0.117 0.904 33.19 1.315
18.73 23.67 0.197 1.226 38.35 1.665
20.62 25.04 0.250 1.393 40.6 1.83
Tritium. In natural hydrogen it occurs in amounts of 1 in 1017–1018. It is continuously formed in nuclear reactions induced by cosmic rays, and it is radioactive. It may be made, from lithium, in nuclear reactors by the thermal neutron reaction 6 Li(n,α)3H. Preparation. Many reactions and processes are available for the preparation of hydrogen. Among the large-scale processes, the catalytic steam hydrocarbon reforming process can be mentioned. After de-sulphurization, natural gas (or oil-refinery feedstock) is mixed with steam and, at 700–1000°C, passed over a nickel-based catalyst. The irreversible reaction occurs: CnH2n2 nH2O : nCO (2n 1)H2 together with reversible reactions corresponding to the equilibria: CO H2O N CO2 H2 CO 3H2 N CH4 H2O Further treatments of the gases mainly involve cooling, conversion of CO into CO2 and H2, absorption of CO2, etc. Generally such processes are carried out in integrated plants where hydrogen is used for instance for ammonia synthesis, petrochemical work, etc. Hydrogen is also obtained as a by-product of brine electrolysis for the production of chlorine and sodium hydroxide. Small electrolytic plants (hydrogen generators) are often used for in situ applications when small quantities of hydrogen are required at remote locations. For the purification of hydrogen, and its separation from mixed gases, its interaction with palladium may be used. A large quantity of hydrogen may be absorbed by metallic palladium; it is first chemisorbed at the surface of the metal but at
Elements of Alloying Behaviour Systematics
325
increased pressure it enters the metal lattice forming the so-called α and β hydrides: hydrogen has a high mobility within the lattice and diffuses rapidly through the metal. This behaviour is highly specific to hydrogen (and deuterium), palladium being impervious to all other gases (even to helium). Both laboratory and large industrial installations operate on this basis. In these operations the formation of the H-richer β-hydride must be avoided since it results in distortions and hardening, and possibly splitting, of the palladium diffusion membrane. This may be obtained either maintaining the temperature above 300°C or, possibly better, using palladium alloyed with about 20% Ag which, moreover, results in an increase of the permeability to hydrogen. The gas mixture containing hydrogen is passed through a diffuser separator composed of a large number of small diameter thinwalled Pd–Ag tubes packed in a stainless steel case. The emerging hydrogen is pure and dry. Atomic hydrogen. Di-hydrogen has the strongest element–element single bond. It is therefore difficult to obtain atomic hydrogen thermally. At ambient pressure at 2000°C there is 1% of atomic hydrogen in hydrogen gas and at 3000°C about 10%. The dissociation of H2 into radicals is so difficult to achieve that a very intense energy source (light arc) is necessary: recombination of H to give H2 releases a very large amount of energy that can generate temperatures up to 6000°C.
5.2.2 Intermetallic chemistry of hydrogen 5.2.2.1 Remarks on the systematics of hydrogen reactivity with the elements. The binary combinations of hydrogen with the various elements (and, more so, ternary and more complex combinations) correspond to several types, various structures and bonding mechanisms and form a vast number of compounds having a variety of quite different stability and reactivity characteristics. A number of broad sections of chemistry (inorganic chemistry, organic chemistry, etc.) could be included in this topic. As an introduction to this subject and in the prospect of giving special attention to metallic (metal-like) combinations, Fig. 5.1 may be considered. In this figure an indication of the reactivity of hydrogen with the different elements and of the characteristics of the hydrides formed is given. According to the scheme shown in this figure we can subdivide (even with some uncertainties) all the elements in a few categories defined by the reactivity with hydrogen. A short description of these different hydride categories will be given here below. However, before going any further, it may be useful to quote from Greenwood and Earnshaw (1997) a few remarks which may be relevant also when considering the description and the classification of other families of compounds. Greenwood and Earnshaw underlined that one criterion usually adopted for grouping the binary
326
Intermetallic Chemistry
hydrides of the elements into various classes is the presumed nature of their bonding: ionic, metallic, covalent, polymeric and ‘borderline’ (intermediate). They pointed out that this is unsatisfactory because the nature of bonding is but poorly understood in many cases and the subdivision in different classes may obscure the relevant point that there is an almost continuous gradation in properties (and in bonding mechanism) between the members of the different classes. Moreover the various bond types cannot be considered mutually exclusive. They finally observed that this behaviour is not unique to hydrides but it is also well known for several other binary compounds such as oxides, sulphides, halides, etc. A summary of the various ‘families’ of hydrides is reported in the following. A first group of hydrides (ionic hydrides) is formed with the more electropositive elements of the s-block of the Periodic Table. This group of hydrides includes the salt-like MeH (MeH) NaCl-type compounds of the alkali metals and the di-hydrides (Co2Si-type) formed by the divalent metals Ca, Sr, Ba and also by Eu and Yb. The thermal stability of these hydrides decreases from Li to Cs and from Ca to Ba; the chemical reactivity on the contrary increases from Li to Cs and from Ca to Ba. While the reaction of NaH with water is very violent, the reaction of LiH or CaH2 can be used for a portable source of hydrogen. With the metals of the following groups (d-block, f-block metals), in a number of cases, phases of variable composition (solid solutions) are formed. Typically in the hydrogen systems with the lanthanides and actinides, besides more or less extended solid solutions of hydrogen in the different crystal forms of the metals, solid solution phases, generally homogeneous for composition ranges around 60– 70 at.% H or around 75 at.% H, have been identified. The crystal structures of these phases correspond to the CaF2-type (identified in the hydrides of Sc, Y, Pr, Nd, Sm, Eu, Gd, Tb, Dy, Ho, Er, Tm, Lu, Np, Pu), or to the Co2Si-type (as previously remarked for the divalent Eu and Yb), or ThH2 , and, for higher H contents for hydrides having about 75 at.% H, to the HoH3 type (for Y, Sm and heavier lanthanides) and Na3As-type (Dy, Np, Pu). Phases identified in these systems and corresponding to other structures and compositions are for instance those defined by the following approximate stoichiometries: Pr3H7, Th4H15, etc. These hydrides have a more or less clear metallic character especially for compositions around 1:2; with increasing H content, a decrease of the electric conductivity is observed. Uranium hydrides (of composition 1:3), which when finely powdered are very reactive, may be used as a starting product for the preparation of uranium compounds. With the metals of the 4th group (Ti, Zr, Hf), solid solution phases are observed which, for the limiting composition 1:2, have the CaF2-type structure and (through solid state reactions) the tI6-ThH2-type. The systems of hydrogen with the 5th group elements (V, Nb, Ta) are very complex and show several phases generally stable at not high temperatures and with variable H contents up to the 1:2 composition.
Elements of Alloying Behaviour Systematics
327
With the following elements up to the metals of the 12th group, only a few intermediate phases are observed with Cr (NiAs and CaF2 types), with Mn (wide solid solution NiAs-type) or, in a number of cases (with Fe, Co, Ni, Cu) appreciable solid solutions in the different crystal forms of the metal. A special behaviour is shown by Pd with which, at T 300°C, hydrogen forms a large solid solution field (0 to 50 at.% H) that decomposes on cooling in two phases (see the phase diagram in Fig. 3.37). The crystal structure of the solid solution, with the progressive increase of the H content, can be described as passing from the Cu-type (Pd) to a more or less ordered and deficient NaCl-type. Moving towards the other groups of the Periodic Table, after a gap in the hydrogen compound formation capability, a new class of hydrides is encountered. In the right part of the Table hydrides having covalent characteristics are observed. For the elements of the last groups several covalent hydrogen compounds are known: numerous compounds are given by B, C, Si, Ge, N, P, O, S, Se. In the usual ambient conditions, as it is well-known, the carbon chemistry is especially rich of hydrides (that is of several series of hydrocarbons). In this class of compounds more or less complex molecules and structures are found: the catenation (chainforming) tendency is a characteristic shown by several elements in this portion of the Periodic Table. The following is a short collection of examples of such hydrides: Chalcogens: H2O, H2O2, H2S, H2S2, H2Sn, H2Se, H2Te, (H2Po). Compounds such as H2Sn (sulphanes, containing chains!S!S!) are thermodynamically unstable with respect to the reaction: H2Sn (liq.) : H2S (gas) (n 1)S (sol.) (which however is generally slow). The di-hydrides H2X may be obtained from the chalcogenides with dilute acids; their thermal stability and bond strength decrease down the group. H2Se is stable up to about 280°C, H2Te and H2Po are thermodynamically unstable with respect to the elements. Pnicogens: NH3, N2H4, PH3, AsH3, SbH3, BiH3. The stability of these compounds falls down the group. SbH3 and BiH3 are thermally very unstable, AsH3 readily decomposes to As and H2. Ammonia (boiling point 239.7 K), the important synthesis equilibrium of which is well-known, resembles in the liquid state water, in its physical behaviour. Carbon, tetrels. The unusual stability of the catenated carbon compounds must be underlined. This may be related to the intrinsic strength of the C!C bond and, as regards stability towards oxidation, to the relative strengths of C!C and C!O bonds. As a reference, the following average values (kJ/mol) of some bond energies may be considered: C!C 331; C!O 360, C!H 415; Si!Si 222; Si!O 452; Si!H 318. Catenation is a special characteristic of the 14th group elements, but in Si (and Ge, etc.) it is not as extensive as in carbon. SiH4, Si2H6 are indefinitely stable at ambient temperature, higher silanes decompose. Germanes (GeH4, Ge2H6,
328
Intermetallic Chemistry
Ge3H8) less flammable than silanes, are rapidly oxidized in air. Stannane (SnH4) decomposes rapidly even at 0°C; plumbane (PbH4) has a doubtful existence. Boron, triels. Boranes are molecular compounds of low thermal stability. They are generally endothermic and their free energy of formation is also positive: their thermodynamic instability may be related, rather than to the weakness of the B–H bond, to the very strong interatomic bonds in elemental boron and hydrogen. The simplest borane B2H6 provides the prototypal example of three-centre two-electron (3c, 2e) bonds. It consists indeed of two BH2 groups connected by two hydrogen bridges (corresponding to two 3c, 2e B!H!B bonds), this structure is the same as that of Al2Cl6 shown in Fig. 4.25. Boranes are generally very reactive and flammable in air; several preparative methods are now known. Borane chemistry started in 1912 with the classic work by Alfred Stock (1933): he prepared several hydrides by the action of acid on magnesium boride, MgB2, obtaining a mixture of volatile compounds. In order to handle, separate, etc. these compounds, he developed special vacuum techniques based on the use of vacuum manifold glass lines. This chemistry now represents an important chapter in various Inorganic Chemistry books to which the reader is referred. The complexity and richness of the borane chemistry resulted also in the creation of a special nomenclature which was also applied to several families of compounds (neutral and ionic clusters, etc.). Five main series of boranes (neutral, anionic, corresponding to deltahedral, triangular-faced polyhedra) can be considered: (i) Closo-boranes (name derived form Greek κλωβóς, clovos, a cage) have complete closed polyhedral clusters of boron atoms. (ii) Nido-boranes (form Latin nidus, nest) have non-closed structures in which the nB atoms of the Bn cluster occupy n vertices of a (n 1) vertices polyhedron (that is polyhedra that lack one vertex). (iii) Arachno-boranes (from Greek αρ ´ αχνη, ´ aracne, spider’s web) have structures corresponding to polyhedra from which two adjacent vertices are missing. (iv) Hypho-boranes (from Greek υϕ ´ η, ´ hyphe, a net) have a more open structure corresponding to a polyhedral fragment obtained by removing three contiguous vertices. (v) Conjuncto-boranes (from Latin coniungo, to join together) have structures in which two or more fragments of the preceding types are linked. Several subtypes may be defined according to the connection scheme (for instance: by sharing a B atom, by sharing 2B in a common edge, by sharing 3B as a common face of the interconnected clusters, etc.).
Elements of Alloying Behaviour Systematics
329
Wade rules. A set of semi-empirical rules relating structure and composition of boranes of formula BnHmx, (m n, x 0) have been presented by Wade (1976). These can be summarized as follows: ●
●
●
●
For a BnHnx borane, the preferred structure is a closo structure with a preferred charge of 2 (there are (n 1) pairs of skeleton electrons). For a BnHn4 borane, a nido structure is preferred (with nB at n vertices of an (n 1) vertices polyhedron) when in the corresponding anion BnHn4 there are (n 2) pairs of framework electrons. For a BnHm borane based on an anion BnHn6, an arachno-structure is preferred with B at n vertices of an (n 2) vertices polyhedron; (n 3) pairs of framework bonding electrons are required. For a BnHm borane based on an anion BnHn8, a hypho-structure is preferred. B is at n vertices of an (n 3) vertices polyhedron requiring (n 4) pairs of framework bonding electrons.
These rules can be extended to isoelectronic anions, carbaboranes, metalloboranes, etc. (see also § 4.4.4 ff). The following notes conclude this description for the remaining elements: AlH3 has several crystalline and amorphous forms; it appears as a non-volatile solid instable above 150°C. In α-AlH3, aluminium is octahedrally surrounded by 6 hydrogen atoms. (GaH3)n has been described as a viscous liquid that decomposes at room temperature. Formulae such as InH and InH2 have been reported for the questionable indium hydrides. BeH2, an amorphous white solid, has been described which evolves hydrogen at 250°C; no compound, however, is contained in the proposed Be–H phase diagram. As a conclusion to this point, and in order to illustrate the variety of behaviour in the reactions of the different elements with hydrogen, a few phase diagrams of binary hydrogen systems can be considered. 5.2.2.2 Examples of phase diagrams of metal–hydrogen systems. The scheme shown in Fig. 5.1 gives an indication of the general characteristics of the phase diagrams and of the different phase types formed in the binary combinations of hydrogen with the various elements. In order to give a look at this subject, a selection of characteristic diagrams is shown in Figs 5.2–5.5 which have generally been re-drawn according to Okamoto (2000).
330
Intermetallic Chemistry 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
Ionic hydrides
Intermediate hydrides
No hydrides
Metallic hydrides
Covalent hydrides
Unknown
Figure 5.1. Hydrogen combinations of the different elements. An approximate scheme of the complex reactivity behaviour of hydrogen is shown. Notice that in most cases, especially at the right part of the Table, every box may correspond to a large variety of reactions and products, possibly with the formation of a large number of stable and/or metastable compounds.
Fig. 5.2 concerns an element (Sr) at the left in the Periodic Table: a temperature range higher than the ambient is shown. There is a small region of Sr-rich solid solution (γ phase) and the formation of a nearly stoichiometric compound, SrH2, the formula of which corresponds to the ionic valences of the two elements. The two subsequent figures, Figs 5.3 and 5.4, show parts of the phase diagrams formed by two transition metals. In the Mo–H system, for which only the high-temperature region is shown, the equilibria between hydrogen and elemental (solid and liquid) molybdenum may be noticed. In the Nb–H system, on the contrary, for which several multi-disciplinary investigations have been carried out at low and very low temperatures, a complex sequence of equilibria and solid-state transformations has been assessed (Smith 1983). An enlargement of the central region only of this system is shown in Fig. 5.4. A phase diagram formed by hydrogen with an element at the right side of the Periodic Table is shown in Fig. 5.5. This is the hydrogen–oxygen phase diagram and it is the only example of a low-temperature phase diagram with the right-hand side elements that we have found in literature. It is probable that similar diagram shapes and behaviour may be found in the low-temperature regions of systems of hydrogen with other elements (nitrogen, phosphorus, sulphur, etc.) with which it forms stable and/or metastable covalent compounds. Ammonia, NH3, is a well-known example of a species in thermodynamic equilibrium with the elements
331
Elements of Alloying Behaviour Systematics Mass% H 0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0 2.5
L
900
(β Sr)
700 600 500
γ
SrH2
Temperature (C)
800
400 300 200 (α Sr) 100 0
Sr
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
at.% H
Figure 5.2. The phase diagram of the Sr–H system. An intermediate phase, stable in a range of temperature and composition values (solid solution γ) is formed in the Sr-rich region. The other phase (practically a stoichiometric compound) corresponding to the formula SrH2 may be considered a representative of the ‘ionic’ hydrides. The low-temperature form of this compound has the oP12-Co2Si-type structure.
(H2 and N2). The complexity, however, of a diagram such as that of the system C–H, of its (stable and metastable) compound multitude and of its possible sequences of reactions can barely be guessed. 5.2.2.3 Comments on the crystal structures of typical hydrogen–metal phases. A few general remarks about a group of metal–hydrogen phases have been included in § 3.8.4.1 where interstitial hydrogen solutions in metallic structures have been described. However, as previously observed, a number of intermediate phases are also formed in several systems. A short summary of these is shown in Table 5.2 where their formulae very often have only an indicative character and several structure types correspond to more or less extended solid solution ranges. Notice that most of the indicated prototypes correspond to structures frequently found not only in intermetallic phases but also in ionic compounds. 5.2.2.4 Notes on the application of metal hydrides. The study of the hydride formation in metallic systems is important not only in view of the (often deleterious)
332
Intermetallic Chemistry Mass% H 1
2
5
10 20
4600
Temperature (C)
G 4200 3800 Mo(liq) + G 3400 3000 2600 (Mo) + G 10
20
30
40
Mo
50
60
70
80
90
at.% H
H
Figure 5.3. The high-temperature region of the Mo–H system is shown. In this temperature range the negligible solubility of hydrogen in solid and liquid molybdenum can be noticed. Mass% H 25
Temperature (C)
−25
0.75
0.80
0.85
0.90
0.95
1.00
1.05
β −39
−48
−75 λ −125
ν
ε
−175
? γ
−225
41
Nb
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
at.% H
Figure 5.4. The niobium–hydrogen system. A small part (from 40 to 50 at.% H) of the diagram is shown in the low- and very-low-temperature region. Notice the complex equilibria and the high number of intermediate solid solution phases. Other phases are formed in the composition ranges not shown in figure: the η (11 to 39 at.% H) and θ (21 to 41 at.% H) solid solutions in the Nb-richer part and the nearly stoichiometric δ phase (NbH2, cF12-CaF2-type).
333
Elements of Alloying Behaviour Systematics Mass% O 89
90
91
92
93
94
0
0
−20
HO
−30
L
H2 O
Temperature (C)
−10
−40
−50.2
?
H3O2
−50 −60 34
H
36
38
40
42
44
46
48
at.% O
Figure 5.5. The oxygen–hydrogen system as reported by Okamoto (2000). Notice in the phase diagram the formation of the well-known covalent hydrogen–oxygen compounds.
effects that H uptake and dissolution may have on the properties of metals and alloys, but also for the research and development of metal hydride systems suitable for hydrogen storage. This point, indeed, is an essential step for planning and increasing hydrogen-based energy production and distribution. Among various hydrogen storage materials, several metal–hydrogen systems appear attractive from the point of view of high volumetric density and safety. As summarized by Pande et al. (1994), the desired properties of hydrogen storage materials are: (1) high hydrogen retentive capacity, (2) low temperature (typically 100°C) of dissociation, (3) high rate of hydrogen uptake and discharge, (4) low heats of formation, (5) light weight, (6) stability towards oxygen and moisture and (7) low cost of the alloy. The preparation and experimental and theoretical properties of several alloys (Ni–Mg, Ti–Fe, Pd) and their behaviour with hydrogen are discussed in the mentioned paper. In this respect, Mg-based alloys are particularly interesting for their high capacity, light weight and low cost (De Negri et al. 2005), although up to now limitations exist due to the low sorption kinetics. On the other hand, La–Ni alloys are good candidates for increasing hydrogen capacity. The La–Ni–Mg alloys therefore are especially promising materials for the hydrogen-based energetic technologies. In the
334
Intermetallic Chemistry
Table 5.2. Structures of a few selected hydrogen–metal compounds. The formulae very often have only an indicative character. Solid solution ranges are frequently observed. Structure type cF16-BiF3
Examples of isostructural phases Composition ranges at.% H MeH3: Me La(60–80H), Tb, Yb
hP8-Na3As
MeH3: Me Dy, Np, Pu( 74H), Am, Bk
hP24-HoH3
MeH3: Me Y, Sm, Ho(73–75H), Tm, Lu
cF12-CaF2
MeH2: Me Sc, Y, Ce, Pr, Nd, Sm, Gd, Tb, Dy, Ho(66–69H), Er, Tm, Lu, Ac, Np, Pu(63–73H), Am, Ti, Zr, Hf, V, Nb, Ta, Cr(55–67H)
oP12-Co2Si
MeH2: Me Ca, Sr, Ba, Eu, Yb
cF8-NaCl
MeH: Me Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs, Pd(0 50H)
hP4-NiAs
MeH: Me Cr(47–50H), Mn
mentioned paper, crystal structures and phase equilibria in the La–Ni–Mg system are studied. A number of questions concerning alloy hydriding and the formation of complex hydrides had been discussed by Van Mal et al. (1974) and Buschow et al. (1975). Special attention was dedicated to CaCu5-type compounds among which the behaviour of LaNi5, with its favourable absorption properties, was underlined. It absorbs hydrogen to a density of nearly twice that of liquid hydrogen (that is up to about 6.2 1022 atoms/cm3). Several related compounds were investigated (LnNi4Me, Me Cr, Fe, Co, Pd, Cu, Ag and La0.8R0.2Ni5, R Y, Nd, Gd, Er, Zr, Th). The equilibrium pressure was studied in the two-phase regions associated with the hydrogen absorption or desorption at a given temperature. This pressure can be considered as a measure of the stability of the hydride. It was observed that, for series of isostructural compounds, the stability of ternary hydrides can be related to the heat of formation of the parent compounds. It was observed that it may be generally expected that in the formation of ternary hydrides, the more stable the binary compound one commences with, the less stable the ternary hydride will be (rule of reversed stability). In the evaluation of the capacity of an intermetallic compound to absorb large quantities of hydrogen at room temperature it was also concluded that it is necessary that the compound contains a metal which forms a hydride which should be more stable than the intermetallic compound. Quantitative predictions about the heats of formation of hydrides of intermetallic compounds have been discussed by Shilov et al. (1989); they studied reversible and irreversible transformations in intermetallic compound-hydrogen systems and observed that four basic types of P/T diagrams exist for these systems.
Elements of Alloying Behaviour Systematics
335
5.3. ALLOYS OF THE ALKALI METALS (1ST GROUP METALS)
Lithium, Li; sodium, Na; potassium, K; rubidium, Rb; caesium, Cs; francium, Fr
5.3.1 Introduction Lithium (Li, [He]2s1), name and symbol from the Greek lithos (stone). Discovered (1817) by J. August Arfvedson, isolated (1818) by Sir H. Davy (1821) and by William T. Brande. Silvery, white, soft, easily cut, metal. Atomic number 3, atomic relative mass 6.941. For lithium, as for a few other elements (noble gases), modified isotopic compositions may be found in commercially available material because it has been subject to undisclosed isotopic fractionation: commercially available lithium specimens have atomic weights that range between 6.939 and 6.996: if a more accurate value is needed it must be determined for the specific material. Occurrence. Its most important minerals correspond to alumino-silicates: LiAlSi2O6 (spodumene), LiAlSi4O10 (petalite), lithium mica (lepidolite), LiAlSiO4 (as the rare eukryptite). Preparation. Li is currently produced by electrolysis of molten LiCl, the melting point of which (614°C) is lowered by addition of KCl. The salt mixtures used (not very different from the eutectic one) contain about 45–55 mass% LiCl: the electrolysis is carried out at 400–460°C. The cells commonly used resemble the cell used for the production of sodium (Downs cells). Main uses of lithium alloys. Li additions often change completely the properties of metals to which it is added, for instance hardness of Al and Pb (addition of Li to Pb results in the formation of Pb solid solution and a eutectic at 15.7 at.% Li with LiPb) and ductility of Mg. Al-alloys can be of great interest in aerospace industry: Li (as Be) simultaneously reduces the density of Al and increases its modulus of elasticity. Each 1 mass% Li up to the solubility limit (4.2 mass%) reduces density by about 3% and increases modulus by 5%. Precipitates homogeneously distributed of spherical LiAl3 in diluted Li-alloys during heat treatment may improve strength.
336
Intermetallic Chemistry
The designation of typical commercial Li–Al alloys are (approximate data in mass%): weldalite 049 (5Cu, 1.3Li, 0.4Ag, 0.4Mg: for propellant tanks in space launch systems), alloys 2090 and 2091 (2–2.7Cu, 2–2.2Li, 0.1Zr), alloy 8090 (2.5Li, 1.3Cu, 0.9Mg, 0.1Zr, low-density high-modulus damage tolerant medium-strength), alloy CP276 (2.7Cu, 2.2Li, 0.5Mg, 0.1Zr). Li addition can be used in metallurgy as a reducing agent, and de-oxidizing, de-sulphurizing agent for Co, Ni alloys. A rapidly growing application of lithium metal is in sacrificial anodes in batteries. Sodium (Na, [Ne]3s1), name from the English word soda, perhaps from the Latin word sodanum (glasswort), symbol from the Latin natrium (sodium carbonate). Identified and isolated (1807) by Sir Humphry Davy. Silvery white, soft metal. Atomic number 11, atomic relative mass 22.989768. Occurrence. It occurs as NaCl (as the main component of the sea water salts and as rock salt), Na2CO3 (trona), NaNO3 (Chile saltpetre), Na2SO4 (thenardite), Na2B4O7 (borax). Preparation. Sodium can be produced by electrolysis of a mixture of NaCl (40%) and calcium chloride, CaCl2 (60%), melting at about 580°C. The electrolysis is carried out as a melt in a ‘Downs cell’, producing also calcium metal as well, which is solidified in a collection pipe and returned back to the melt. Since 1950 a modified Downs cell has been used with an electrolyte consisting of a ternary mixture of NaCl, BaCl2 and CaCl2. Main uses of Na alloys. Hypoeutectic Al–Si alloys (from 5 mass% Si to the eutectic) through the so-called modification (structural modification of the normally occurring eutectic) achieve somewhat higher tensile properties and improved ductility. Modification is obtained by the addition of elements such as Na (or Sr, Ca, Sb) and results in a finer lamellar or fibrous eutectic. Phosphorus, which reacts with sodium, interferes with the modification mechanism. Sodium can be used as the reductant of several chlorides in the preparation of metals such as Ti (Hunter process), Zr, Hf, Nb, Ta. Na–K alloys are used in heat-exchange systems. Ternary alloy 10.1 at.% Na, 47.4 at.% K and 42.5 at.% Cs (L K (Cs) (K) (CsNa2, KNa2)) probably has the lowest known melting point (76°C) of all the metallic systems. Sodium amalgams, owing to their reducing properties, can be used in chemical synthesis processes. Potassium (K, [Ar]4s1), name from the English word potash (pot ashes), symbol from the Latin word kalium (alkali). Identified and isolated (1807) by Sir Humphry Davy. Silvery white, soft metal. Atomic number 19, relative atomic mass 39.0983.
Elements of Alloying Behaviour Systematics
337
Occurrence. Potash salt deposits were formed by evaporation of ancient lakes and sea beds. Main minerals are sylvite (KCl), carnallite (KMgCl3 6H2O), polyhalite (K2MgCa2[SO4]4 2H2O), langbeinite (K2Mg2[SO4]3), kainite (KMg[ClSO4])4 11H2O). Preparation. It is obtained by the reaction of metallic sodium with molten potassium chloride at 850°C: KCl Na N NaCl K The equilibrium is rapidly established, at high temperature, between Na, K, NaCl and KCl. The equilibrium shifts to the products when K is continuously removed by distillation through a packed column. During operation, KCl is melted and introduced through a trap to the column. Molten Na is fed to the bottom of the column (the lower portion of which acts as a reactor whereas the upper portion is a fractionator). K vapour is fractionated and condensed in an air-cooled condenser, with the reflux pumped back to the column. Waste NaCl is continuously removed from the bottom of the column. Other reactions such as: K2CO3 2C : 3CO 2K; 2KCl CaC2 : CaCl2 2C 2K; 2KN3 : 3N2 2K are used at laboratory scale. Main uses for K alloys. Intercalation compounds with graphite are powerful solid reducing agents. See Na for Na–K alloys. Rubidium (Rb, [Kr]5s1), name and symbol from the Latin rubidius (deep red, the colour of its main spectral lines). Discovered (1861) by Robert Bunsen and Gustav Kirchhoff. Atomic number 37, atomic relative mass 85.4678. Silvery white, soft metal. Occurrence. Unlike its homologues Li and Cs, Rb is not a major component of any mineral. It is found mainly in association with K (similarity of their ionic radii) and also with other alkali metals (with Li in lepidolite, with Cs in pollucite). Preparation. It is made by the reaction of metallic sodium with hot molten rubidium chloride. Na RbCl N Rb NaCl Under these conditions the rubidium is highly volatile and removed from the system.
338
Intermetallic Chemistry
Caesium (Cs, [Xe]6s1), name and symbol from the Latin caesius (sky blue, the colour of two bright lines in its spectrum). Discovered (1860) by Robert Bunsen and Gustav Kirchhoff. Soft, silvery gold metal, liquid around room temperature. Atomic number 55, atomic relative mass 132.90543. Occurrence. The most important mineral corresponds to an alumino-silicate, pollucite, (Cs4Al4Si9O26 H2O) typically containing about 20 mass% of caesium oxide. Preparation. As amalgam by electrolysing Cs concentrated salt solutions on Hg cathode. More important are the reduction of CsCl with Ca or Ba and the removal of Cs by vacuum distillation. Main uses. Caesium metal is used in the production of vacuum tubes as a scavenger to reduce residual gaseous impurities after the tubes have been sealed. Cs may be generated in situ by heating a pellet of caesium chromate mixed with a metal powder (Zr, Ca, Ba). Cs metal is used as the propellant in ion thrusters (employed in satellites for orientation control): it is ionized in a vacuum chamber, the Cs are then accelerated through a nozzle (high specific impulse because of high atomic mass). Francium (Fr, [Rn]7s1), name and symbol, after France, the country where it was prepared (Curie Institute in Paris). Discovered (1939) by Marguerite Perey. Very rare in nature, artificially prepared, highly radioactive. Atomic number 87, atomic relative mass 223.019731 (nuclidic mass of the longest half life isotope). Francium occurs as a result of the disintegration of actinium. Francium is found in uranium minerals, and can be made artificially by bombarding thorium with protons. It is the most unstable of the first 101 elements.
5.3.2 The alkali metals: a summary of their atomic and physical properties The main atomic and physical properties of the alkali metals are summarized in Tables 5.3 and 5.4. Their typical electron configurations correspond to the outermost ns1 electron. Consequently, the first ionization energy is relatively low, and the second stage ionization energy is very high (see Fig. 4.3). This explains the reactivity of these elements and their oxidation state never exceeding 1. The large values of the atomic radii, in comparison with the other elements of the same rows of the Periodic Table, may also be noticed and related to the low densities of these
339
Elements of Alloying Behaviour Systematics Table 5.3. Alkali metals: selected atomic and physical properties. Property
Li
Na
K
Rb
Cs
r/pm, metallic, CN 12 [‘Metallic valence’] r/pm, ionic, M+1, CN 6 1st ionization energy/kJ/mol 2nd ionization energy/kJ/mol Tmelting/°C Tboiling/°C ΔHmelting (at Tmelting)/kJ/mol ΔfH 0 of Me1 gas at 298.15 K/kJ/mol
156.2 [1] 76 520.2 7298.1 180.6 1342 3.0 159.3
191.1 [1] 102 495.8 4562.4 97.8 883 2.6 107.3
237.6 [1] 138 418.8 3052 63.71 759 2.3 89.0
254.6 [1] 152 403.0 2633 39.48 688 2.2 80.9
273.1 [1] 167 375.7 2234 28.39 671 2.1 76.5
Table 5.4. Alkali metals: crystal structures, lattice parameters of their allotropes, calculated densities. Element (allotrope) Temperature range/°C Pressure/GPa
Crystal structure
Lattice parameters/pm a
c
Atomic volume, Vat/106 pm3
Molar volume/ cm3/mol
Density/ g/cm3
αLi βLi
Lithium 193° 193° to 180.6°
hP2-Mg cI2-W
311.1 350.93
509.3
21.34 21.61
12.85 13.01
0.54 0.53
αNa βNa
Sodium 233° 233° to 97.8°
hP2-Mg cI2-W
376.7 429.06
615.4
37.81 39.49
22.77 23.78
1.01 0.97
K
Potassium 63.71°
cI2-W
532.1
75.38
45.36
0.86
αRb βRb γRb
Rubidium 39.48° 1.08 GPa 2.05 GPa
cI2-W
570.5
92.84
55.91
1.53
cI2-W cF4-Cu cF4-Cu
614.1 646.5 580.0
115.79
69.73
1.91
Caesium αCs 28.39° βCs 2.37 GPa β Cs 4.22 GPa γCs 4.27 GPa
metals (lithium has the lowest density of any solid at room temperature). These data, together with the low values of the melting and boiling temperatures and of the heats of sublimation and vapourization, may be considered an indication also of the weak bonding in the solid state of the single valence electron.
340
Intermetallic Chemistry
The alkali metals are soft and have a high lustre when freshly cut. Lithium is the least fusible and volatile, the least dense and soft. The values of these properties change regularly down the 1st column of the Periodic Table. Notice, however, the trend of the density. Their normal crystal structure, at ambient conditions, corresponds to the bodycentred cubic cI2-W-type structure. At very low temperatures, the close-packed hexagonal hP2-Mg-type structure has been observed for Li and Na, while for Rb and Cs the face-centred cubic close-packed cF4-Cu-type structure is known at high pressure. No polymorphic transformation has been reported for potassium. 5.3.3 The alkali metals: remarks about their general chemical properties and reactivity All the alkali metals are extremely reactive chemically. Both for safety reasons and for protection from heavy contamination they should be handled with care, under an inert atmosphere or protective media. The alkali metals are easily tarnished by air and combined with most elements. Lithium alone combines directly with nitrogen and is relatively inert towards oxygen and the halogens. The other metals of this group react with oxygen increasingly as the atomic number increases, forming oxides such as Na2O and Na2O2 (peroxide) and, in the case of the heavier metals, superoxides, such as KO2. They react violently with water giving the soluble hydroxides and hydrogen, which generally ignites. The reaction with the halogen, often with inflammation and explosion, results in the formation of the halides. With hydrogen, the alkali metals form the mono-hydrides MeH, having salt-like properties and a partially ionic, MeH, NaCl-type structure. They are colourless crystalline solids having a fairly negative ΔH of formation. The mono-hydrides react with water. They may be prepared from hydrogen and the metal (heated at 700–800°C for Li, 350–400°C for the others) or through the reaction of hydrogen with the alkali mono-oxide, nitride, etc. Interesting is the reaction of the alkali metals with ammonia; with gaseous NH3, when heated, they generally form the amide MeNH2, with liquid ammonia they give an electrically conductive often deep blue solution. The electric conductivity of a saturated Na solution in liquid NH3 is about half that of metallic mercury. These solutions react forming the amides; the time required for this reaction, however, is several days for Li and Na, about an hour for K and minutes for Rb and Cs. Several reactions with the alkali metal can be carried out using their ammonia solutions. The reaction, for instance, of K with metal oxides may result in the reduction to a lower valence state (for instance CuII to CuI, MoVI to MoIII) or in the precipitation of the metal or of its alloys with K. Reactions of the alkali–ammonia
341
Elements of Alloying Behaviour Systematics
solutions with S, Se, Te, P, As, Sb, Bi, Pb, Hg may result in the formation of several compounds such as: Li2S, Li2Sx, Na2S, Na2Sx, Na2Se, Na2Se2, Na2Se6, K2Te, K2Te3, K3As, Na3Sb5, Na3Bi, NaPb, NaPb2, NaHgx, etc. 5.3.4 Intermetallic chemistry of the alkali metals 5.3.4.1 Phase diagrams of alkali metal alloys. The pattern of the intermetallic reactivity of these metals is shown in Fig. 5.6, where the compound formation capability with the different elements is summarized. The overall reactivity pattern summarized in this figure fits well within the general alloying behaviour shown by the metals pertaining to the first columns of the Periodic Table, as confirmed in the following paragraphs 5.4 (alloys of the representative metals of the 2nd group), 5.5 (alloys of the metals of the 3rd group), etc. A few comments about Fig. 5.6 may be useful. According to their reactivity with the alkali metals all the elements X can be divided, even with a few uncertainties, into three principal categories: (i) The metals of the block s. These metals form with the alkali metals only a few compounds (Li with Ca (Li2Ca), Sr (Li23Sr6, Li2Sr3, LiSr3), Ba (Li4Ba), Na
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Li
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Na
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
K
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Rb
Cs
Compound-forming element
Phase diagram known; no intermediate phases formed
No information available
Questionable compound forming capability
Figure 5.6. Compound formation capability in the binary alloys of alkali metals. The different elements, the binary combinations of which with Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs are considered, are identified by their positions in the Periodic Table. No reliable data have been found about the stable equilibrium phases in the Na–P and Cs–As systems: compound formation is, however, probable.
342
Intermetallic Chemistry
with K (KNa2), with Cs (CsNa2) and Ba with Na (NaBa s.s., Na4Ba), K with Cs (CsK2) or continuous solid solution fields (Rb–K, Cs–K, Cs–Rb systems), even if only at high temperature with subsequent de-mixing or compound formation (Cs–K system) at lower temperature. In the inter-alkali alloys, eutectic equilibria have been observed in a number of systems: very low melting points have been determined for instance in the Rb–Na system (L N (Rb) (Na), at 82.5 at.% Rb and 4.5°C) and even lower melting temperatures have been observed in ternary systems. Binary sodium–potassium alloys, liquid at room temperature (at 25°C in a composition range of about 15–70 at.% Na, about 7–57 mass% Na), have a good thermal conductivity and a wide temperature range where they are liquid; they may be used in heat-exchange systems. Their extremely high chemical reactivity must of course be taken into account. (ii) The transition metals of the 3nd to 8th–10th groups. These metals are characterized by a very low reactivity with the alkali metals. No intermediate phases are formed (low electronegativity difference) and between the components there are very large, or complete, regions of immiscibility (great difference in the atomic dimensions). This type of phase diagram applies to the metals included between the 3rd up to the 7th (Li) or up to the 9th (Na) or to the 10th (K, Rb, Cs) groups. (iii) The last transition metals and the p-block elements. The diagrams of the alkali metals with this set of elements (last transition metals, semi-metals and nonmetals of the p-block) are generally characterized by the formation of a number of intermediate phases, both line and point compounds, very often showing a high thermal stability and high melting points. In a number of cases this tendency to form compounds may be compared also with the behaviour in the liquid state where the formation of ‘associates’ has been considered (see § 3.2). The strong electronegativity difference between these elements and the alkali metals may be therefore underlined. Solubility of metals in liquid alkali metals. During an investigation of the properties of low-melting metals, a specific aspect of the alloying behaviour of the alkali metals has been studied by Guminski (1989, 1990), who compiled and discussed the data concerning the solubility of the different elements in these metals. Solubility data at 600°C have been plotted and discussed as a function of the atomic number: curves showing periodic variations were obtained with trends very similar to each other. Elements showing, at 600°C, a low or very low solubility in liquid lithium, taking this metal as an example, are Ti, V, Cr, Fe, Co, Y, Zr, Nb, Mo, Hf, Ta, W, Re whereas a high solubility (which at 600°C may result in the existence
Elements of Alloying Behaviour Systematics
343
of a continuous liquid solution) is shown by Ca, Zn, Ga, Sr, Pd, Ag, Cd, In, Ba, Au, Hg, Tl, etc. A similar trend is shown for the solubility in liquid sodium. 5.3.4.2 Melting point trend in the binary alkali metal alloys. The intermetallic reactivity of the alkali metals and the stability of their alloys are further testified by the values of the melting points observed in the compound-forming systems of the alkali metals. To this end, Table 5.5 shows the sequence of systems with different metals along one row of the Periodic Table (the 5th in this example) through the different groups. For each alkali metal-M system, the formula and melting temperature of the highest melting compound is reported (p means peritectic melting, s.s is a short-hand indication that around the given formula there is a solid solution range). The indication is also given whether the Raynor Index (IR, see § 2.2.4.1) is higher or lower than 1. Nearly all the compounds listed show IR 1. The high melting points of the compounds of the noble metals may be noticed. With elements of the groups from Ag to Te, alkali metal compounds are formed
Table 5.5. Highest melting points in the alloys of alkali metals (A) with compound-forming elements of the 5th row of the Periodic Table. See the introduction for the meaning of the symbols. System
Li compounds
Na compounds
K compounds
A–Ru
LiRu3
Na–Ru no compounds
K–Ru no compounds
A–Rh
LiRh 1800°C est., IR 1
Na–Rh no compounds
K–Rh no compounds
A–Pd
LiPd7 1500°C est., IR 1
NaPd2 797°C, p, IR 1
K–Pd no compounds
A–Ag
βs.s. Li0.6Ag0.4 317°C, p, IR 1
NaAg2 322°C, p, IR 1
K–Ag no compounds
A–Cd
LiCd s.s 549°C, IR 1
NaCd2 384°C, IR 1
KCd13 487°C, IR 1
A–In
LiIn s.s 632°C, IR 1
Na5In8 441°C, IR 1
KIn2 s.s 478°C, IR 1
A–Sn
Li7Sn2 783°C, IR 1
NaSn 578°C, IR 1
K2Sn3 860°C, IR 1
A–Sb
Li3Sb 900°C, IR 1
Na3Sb 857°C, IR 1
K3Sb 813°C, IR 1
A–Te
Li2Te 1204°C, IR 1
Na2Te 953°C, IR 1.
K2Te 920°C, IR 1
344
Intermetallic Chemistry
which have an increasing ionic covalent character of the bonding mechanism and increasing melting temperatures. 5.3.4.3 Remarks on the crystal chemistry of the alkali metal alloys. Several intermediate phases are formed in a number of binary systems of the alkali metals. It may be remarked that these phases cover a very large range of compositions from high alkali contents as in Li9Ag, Li6Hg, Li5Pt, Na6Tl, Na15Pb4, K3Sb up to very high contents of the partner as in LiCx (x 18, 36, 40, 72), LiPt7, NaZn13, NaSn6, KHg11, KCd13, etc. A selection of frequent stoichiometries and common structural types found within the binary intermetallic compounds of the alkali metals is given in Table 5.6. Several 1:1 compounds are formed, generally corresponding to simple symmetric structures: especially notice the CsCl and the NaTl types. Among the compounds given by the alkali metals with the chalcogens, the ionic-like CaF2-antitype structure may be mentioned for the ‘normal valence’ 2:1 compounds, whereas, within the pnictides, several 3:1 compounds are observed with the Na3As-type structure, in which the chemical bond factor has been underlined. Laves phase type structures are observed in a few inter-alkali phases and in a few compounds with some noble metals. Examples of phases corresponding to high stoichiometric ratios are some CaCu5-type compounds and the characteristic NaZn13-type compounds formed with Zn and Cd. Stoichiometries such as 1:11, 1:12, 1:13 generally correspond to the cP36-BaHg11, tI48-BaCd11, tI26-ThMn12, cF112-NaZn13 structure types characterized by high coordination numbers around an atom of large dimension (such as alkali, alkaline earth metals, etc.). See in § 7.5.1.9–7.5.1.11, under the descriptions of the BaHg11 and NaZn13 structural types, some general remarks on the characteristics of these ‘size factor’ controlled phases. 5.3.4.4 A glance through complex intermetallic compounds of the alkali metals. The formation of large (with hundreds of atoms) clusters has been observed in mass spectrometric studies of alkali metals in molecular beams (Mingos and Wales 1990). The atoms of such large clusters do not lie on a single spherical surface. The structure of such clusters may be described as multi-spherical; the geometries adopted may be related to close-packed arrangements or to shells with icosahedral symmetry. It has been observed that certain cluster nuclearities are formed in greater abundance, indicating the high relative stability of these fragments. In molecular beam experiments with sodium, for instance, the following atom numbers (magic numbers) have been especially observed: 8, 20, 34, 40, 58, 92. For the heavier alkali metals, cluster compounds mainly based on octahedra have been discovered especially due to the systematic work by Simon (for instance, Simon 1973, 1979, 1988). The sub-oxides, for instance, Rb9O2 and Cs11O3 contain groups formed by the connection (by sharing one or two faces, respectively) of centred
Elements of Alloying Behaviour Systematics
345
Table 5.6. A selection of formulae and structure types of intermediate phases in the alkali metal binary alloys (CNE coordination number around the A alkali metal). Structure type
CNE (A)
Examples of isostructural phases Li compounds
Na, K, Rb and Cs compounds
cF16-BiF3
14
Li3X: X Au
Cs3X: X Sb, Bi
hP8-Na3As
9–11
Li3X: X P, As, Sb
Na3X: X P, As, Sb, Bi K3X: X P, As, Sb, Bi Rb3X: X As, Sb, Bi
cF12-CaF2 (antitype)
10
Li2X: X O, S, Se, Te
Na2X: X O, S, Se, Te, Po K2X: X O, S, Se, Te Rb2X: X O, S, Se
Li2X: X Ca
hP12-MgZn2
12
oP12-Co2Si
13
cP2-CsCl
14
cF8-NaCl
6
Cs2X: X S, Se, Te LiX: X Pd(40–41Pd), Ag, Au, Hg(37–62Hg), Pb(50–53Pb), Tl
RbX: X Au CsX: X Au
LiX: X H
NaX: X H KX: X H RbX: X H CsX: X H NaX: X Sn, Pb KX: X Si, Ge, Sn, Pb RbX: X Si, Ge, Sn, Pb CsX: X Si, Ge, Sn, Pb
tI64-NaPb
11–12
cF16-NaTl
14
hP12-MgZn2
16
cF24-Cu2Mg
16
hP6-CaCu5
18
KX5: X Au RbX5: X Au CsX5: X Au
cF112-NaZn13
24
NaX13: X Zn KX13: X Zn, Cd RbX13: X Zn, Cd CsX13: X Zn
LiX: X Zn(50–54Zn), Cd, Al(45–55Al), Ga(43–50Ga), In(23–55In)
NaX: X In, Tl
KX2: X Na, Au, Pb CsX2: X Na, K LiX2: X Pt
NaX2: X Pt, Ag, Au(60–68Au) KX2: X Bi RbX2: X Bi CsX2: X Bi
346
Intermetallic Chemistry
M6O octahedra (see Fig. 4.28). The solid-state structure results from the packing of such groups. The inter-cluster distances are similar to those found in the metals. According to Simon, these compounds could be described as ([Rb9O2]5, 5e) and ([Cs11O3]5, 5e) with the five electrons donated to a conduction band, both interand intra-cluster metal–metal bonding, in agreement with the metallic conductivity of these compounds. Another interesting group of alkali compounds contain, together with the alkali metal, more or less complex ‘substructures’ (clusters, etc.) formed by the atoms of the other components. In the compound (Na, K)10Tl13 (Cordier and Müller 1994) the alkali metals form a framework of truncated octahedra, whereas the 13 Tl atoms are arranged in Tl12+1 icosahedra (centred by Tl) and separated by each other by alkali metal atoms. Notice that the Tl13-centred icosahedra represent a structural feature characteristic of intermetallic phases, such as those pertaining to the NaZn13 (CaCu6.5Al6.5, etc.) type. In a review by Corbett (1996), many families of Zintl phases are described; especially those containing triels and tetrels, that is elements of the 13th group (Al family) and elements of the 14th group (Si family). Especially compounds of the alkali and alkaline earth metals have been considered, and a systematic description of the triel and tetrel atomic groups (clusters, networks, etc.) contained in such compounds was given. In the case of the triels derivatives starting from compounds such as LiAl, LiGa, LiIn, NaIn and NaTl, all having the NaTl-type structure, a sequence of more and more complex structures has been identified. A few examples are: Rb2In3 in which a network was identified formed by In octahedra interbridged at four equatorial vertices into square nets (2[In 4 6 ]), K3Ga13 containing closo-Ga12 and nido-Ga11 clusters interconnected by Ga atoms, the Ga alloy K3Ga13, etc. Considering more complicated structures and stoichiometries, we may directly quote Corbett: ‘We will close this section with an indium example that exhibits another step forward in complexity and, perhaps, beauty but a step backward in our ability to readily understand details of bonding and properties’. The example reported corresponds to ‘carbon-free indium fullerenes’. Interesting is a ternary Na–In compound containing a small quantity of Ni, that is: Na96In97Ni2 (Sevov and Corbett 1993, Corbett 1996). The basic (inter-bonded and condensed) structural components of this compound are multiple, onion-like, endo-hedral cluster constructions formed by In74 units containing Na39 polyhedra, which in turn contain a partially disordered In10 unit centred by a single Ni atom, corresponding to the symbolic description: Ni@In10@Na39@In74. In several cases, complex structural patterns such as, for instance, homo- and hetero-nuclear anions in Zintl phases are observed not only in the solid, but also in the liquid state. This can be related, for the liquid phase of several systems, to the
Elements of Alloying Behaviour Systematics
347
particular trends of various properties as a function of the composition and to the consequent identification, at certain compositions, of a ‘peculiar behaviour’, leading to the definition of ‘liquid intermetallic compounds’. This point was discussed in § 3.2, reporting a number of examples concerning alkali metal alloys (with Tl, Sn, Pb, Bi). 5.4 ALLOYS OF THE ALKALINE EARTH METALS AND OF THE ‘DIVALENT’ RARE EARTH METALS
Calcium, Ca; strontium, Sr; barium, Ba; radium, Ra; europium, Eu; ytterbium, Yb
5.4.1 Introduction Calcium, strontium, barium and radium, the alkaline earth metals proper, are the typical elements of the 2nd column (the 2nd group) of the Periodic Table. In the first places of this column, however, two other metals are present, beryllium (Be) and magnesium (Mg), which, on the basis of their properties and alloying behaviour, will be presented in § 5.12, together with the metals of the 12th group (zinc, Zn, cadmium, Cd, and mercury, Hg). On the other hand it may be noticed that some aspects of the chemistry and alloying behaviour of Ca, Sr and Ba could be conveniently compared with those of the ‘divalent’ rare earth metals europium and ytterbium. In this chapter, therefore, together with Ca, Sr, Ba (and Ra) a short presentation will also be given of Eu and Yb. A few more details on the Eu and Yb chemistry are given in § 5.5 in comparison with the trivalent lanthanides. Calcium (Ca, [Ar]4s2), name and symbol from the Latin word calx (lime). Identified and isolated (1808) by H. Davy. Silvery white, soft metal. Atomic number 20, atomic relative mass 40.078. Occurrence. It is the fifth most abundant element in the earth’s crust. It is found in many naturally occurring minerals such as limestone (CaCO3), dolomite (MgCO3 CaCO3), gypsum (CaSO4 2H2O), anhydrite (CaSO4), fluorspar (CaF2), apatite (CaF2 3Ca3(PO4)2) as well as silicates.
348
Intermetallic Chemistry
Preparation. Previously, electrolysis of fused CaCl2 was used; today the process used is the thermal reduction of lime with Al. The reactants, lime and Al powder, are briquetted and charged into a high-temperature alloy retort. The reaction vessel is evacuated to 0.1 Pa, or less, and then heated to 1200°C. Al reduces the lime producing Ca metal vapour: this is removed from the reaction chamber by condensation, thus allowing the reaction to continue. High purity Ca requires highly purified lime and Al and, generally, a further vacuum distillation step. Main uses. Calcium is important in steel production. It has a strong ability to alter the oxides and sulphides. Treatment with calcium modifies the melting points of inclusions which rapidly float out of the steel. Calcium is important in one method of producing a neodymium–iron alloy which is a neodymium ferro boron raw material (through, for instance, the reaction Nd2O3 Ca Fe : NdFe byproducts). Calcium is important also in the purification of Pb through the de-bismuthizing process. Calcium metal is used in the reduction of zirconium fluorides, thorium and uranium oxides to obtain the metals. Strontium (Sr, [Kr]5s2), name and symbol from Strontian, the town in Scotland where it was discovered by the Irish scientist A. Crawford (1790). Silvery yellowish metal. Atomic number 38, atomic relative mass 87.62. Occurrence. Strontianite (SrCO3) and celestite (SrSO4) are the only minerals of economic importance. Preparation. Strontium metal can be obtained by electrolysis of the fused chlorides or by reduction of the oxide by aluminium. Uses. Strontium master alloys are used in Al foundry practice. As an addictive to Al–Si alloys, it enhances mechanical properties and machining performance; it modifies the morphology of the eutectic from coarse acicular plates of Si to a fine interconnected fibrous morphology, resulting in higher tensile strength and greatly improved ductility. .. Barium (Ba, [Xe]6s2), name and symbol from the Greek βαρυ (heavy). The pure element was discovered (1808) by H. Davy. Atomic number 56, atomic relative mass 137.327.
Elements of Alloying Behaviour Systematics
349
Occurrence. Barium occurs mainly as witherite (BaCO3) and baryte or heavy spar (BaSO4). Preparation. On industrial scale Ba metal is produced in a vacuo by reduction of its oxide with Al or Si (higher temperature is required in this last case). The overall reactions are for instance: 4BaO 2Al : 3Ba BaAl2O4 3BaO Si : 2Ba BaSiO3 In the case of reduction by Al, the intermediate formation, however, of BaAl4 has been considered with a longer series of reactions. Uses. It is used as a getter: it has a relatively low vapour pressure and is very reactive towards H2, O2, N2, CO2, H2O, etc., even removing inert gases by inclusion. It is used as de-oxidizer for steel, etc. and also as modifying agent of Al–Si eutectic alloys (as Na and Sr). Radium (Ra, [Rn]7s2), name, and symbol, after Latin radius (ray). Discovered (1898) by Marie and Pierre Curie. Silvery white, soft metal, radioactive. Atomic number 88, atomic relative mass 226.025403 (nuclidic mass of the longest half life isotope). Occurrence. Radium is found naturally in uranium ores such as pitchblende (mostly UO2). One tonne of pitchblende might yield about 0.15 g of radium. Preparation. The element was isolated in 1911 by Mme. Curie and A. Debierne by the electrolysis of a solution of pure radium chloride, employing a mercury cathode. By distillation in hydrogen atmosphere this amalgam yielded the pure metal. Radium is currently prepared by reduction of the oxide by Al at 1200°C in vacuum. Uses. The main use of radium is the preparation of 227Ac, via neutron capture in a nuclear reactor. Europium (Eu, [Xe]4f 76s2), name and symbol after Europe. Discovered (1901) by E.A. Demarcay. Silvery white, metallic. Atomic number 63, atomic relative mass 151.964. Occurrence, preparation: see § 5.5.
350
Intermetallic Chemistry
Table 5.7. Alkaline earth metals: selected physical properties. Property r/pm, metallic, CN 12 [‘metallic valence’] r/pm, ionic, M2 r/pm, ionic, M3, CN 6 1st ionization energy/kJ/mol 2nd ionization energy/kJ/mol 3rd ionization energy/kJ/mol Tmelting/°C Tboiling/°C ΔHmelting (at Tmelting)/kJ/mol ΔfH0 of Me1 gas at 298.15 K/ kJ/mol
Ca
Sr
Ba
197.4 [2]
215.1 [2] 223.6 [2]
100 CN 6
118 CN 6
135 CN 6
589.8 1145.4 4912.4 842 1484 8.5 177.8
549.5 1064.2 4140 769 1382 7.4 164.0
502.9 965.3 3600 727 1898 7.1 179.1
Ra
Eu
229.4 [2] 204.1 [2] 179.8 [3] 148 117 CN 8 CN 6 94.7 509.3 546.7 979.1 1085 – 2404 700 822 – 1597 – 9.2 – 175.3
Yb 193.9 [2] 174.1 [3] 102 CN 6 86.8 603.4 1176 2415 819 1194 7.7 152.1
Ytterbium (Yb, [Xe]4f 146s2), name and symbol after the village of Ytterby (Sweden). Discovered (1878) by J. de Marignac. Silvery white, metallic. Atomic number 70, atomic relative mass 173.04. Occurrence, preparation: see § 5.5. 5.4.2 The alkali earth metals and Eu and Yb: a summary of their atomic and physical properties Main atomic and physical properties of the alkali earth metals are summarized in Tables 5.7 and 5.8. Their typical electron configurations correspond to the outermost ns2 electrons. Alkali earth metals show relatively low 1st and 2nd ionization energies: this can be related to the fact that almost without exception both the external s electrons take part together in bond formation whether the bond is ionic or covalent. 5.4.3 The alkali earth metals and Eu and Yb: remarks about their general chemical properties and reactivity Calcium, strontium and barium are strongly chemically reactive. For safety reasons and for protection from contamination their handling must be carried out under dry inert conditions wearing goggles, shields, etc. The high radioactivity of radium requires special handling techniques and precautions. Its high radioactivity is far more important than any chemical toxicity but from a chemical point of view its hazards are similar to those of barium.
351
Elements of Alloying Behaviour Systematics Table 5.8. Alkaline earth metals: crystal structures, lattice parameters of their allotropes and calculated densities. When not differently indicated the allotropic transformations refer to room pressure. Element (allotrope) Temperature range/°C Pressure/GPa
αCa βCa αSr βSr β Sr αBa βBa γBa Ra Eu αYb βYb γYb
Calcium 443° 443° to 842° Strontium 547° 547° to 769° 3.5 GPa Barium 727° 5.33 GPa 23 GPa Radium 700° Europium 700° Ytterbium 3° 3° to 795° 795° to 819°
Crystal structure
Lattice parameters/pm a
Atomic volume, Vat/106 pm3
Molar volume/ cm3/mol
Density/ g/cm3
c
cF4-Cu cI2-W
558.84 448.0
43.63 44.96
26.28 27.07
1.52 1.48
cF4-Cu cI2-W cI2-W
608.4 487 443.7
56.30 57.75
33.90 34.78
2.58 2.52
cI2-W hP2-Mg
502.27 390.1
63.36
38.15
3.60
cI2-W
514.8
68.27
41.08
5.50
cI2-W
458.27
48.12
28.98
5.24
hP2-Mg cF4-Cu cI2-W
387.99 548.48 444
41.63 41.25 43.76
25.07 24.84 26.4
6.90 6.97
615.4
638.59
Europium and ytterbium are very readily oxidizable and react with O2, and especially with moist air. They rapidly dissolve in dilute mineral acids. Eu and Yb and the alkaline earth metals form, like the alkali metals, deep blue strongly reducing solutions in liquid ammonia. 5.4.4 Intermetallic chemistry of the alkaline earth metals and of Eu and Yb 5.4.4.1 Phase diagrams of the alkaline earth metals and of Eu and Yb. The general trend, along the Periodic Table, of the phase diagram types is similar for the three metals Ca, Sr and Ba. With the exception of the light elements of the first two groups (H, Li, Be, Mg and Na with Ba) no compound is formed with the metals of the groups from 1 to 8. A very similar pattern is shown by Eu and Yb (for which however the no-compound region includes only the metals of the groups up to the 6th). For all these elements no compounds are known with the metals of the
352
Intermetallic Chemistry
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Ba
Sr
Ca
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Eu
Compound-forming element
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Yb
Phase diagram known; no intermediate phases formed
No information available
Figure 5.7. Binary compound formation capability of Ca, Sr, Ba and of Eu and Yb. Those elements are marked for which compounds with the mentioned ‘divalent’ metals are known.
lanthanide and actinide series. A summary of the binary compound formation capability of these metals is given in Fig. 5.7 where a sharp subdivision of the Periodic Table is evident. Even clearer may be the subdivision of the elements between those forming and those not forming compounds with the alkaline earth metals when considered in the order of the Mendeleev Number as indicated in Fig. 2.22. A comparison between Figs 5.6 and 5.7 may be useful in order to underline a certain similarity in the alloying behaviour of the metals of the first two groups. 5.4.4.2 Melting point trend in the binary alkaline earth metal alloys. Table 5.9 reports the values of the melting points observed in the compound-forming systems of the alkaline earth metals, with the elements of one row of the Periodic Table. Reference is made to the 4th row elements, but only examples concerning the 5th row metals are given, due to the limited data available. For the different alkaline earth metals–Me systems formulae and melting temperatures of the highest melting compounds are shown (p means peritectic melting, s.s is a short-hand indication that around the given formula we have a solid solution range). The indication is also given if the corresponding values of the Raynor Index (IR, see § 2.2.4.1) are higher than 1. Notice that, generally, IR is higher than 1 in the systems with the elements (semi-metals, non-metals) of the right-hand part of the Periodic Table. The very high thermal stability of compounds with the elements representative of the 15th to 16th groups such as the antimonides, tellurides, etc. may be underlined.
353
Elements of Alloying Behaviour Systematics Table 5.9. Highest melting points (T (°C)) in the alloys of the ‘divalent’ metals (Me) with compound-forming elements of the 4th or of the 5th row of the Periodic Table. The 5th row elements are marked by an asterisk. See the introduction for the meaning of the symbols. System
Ca compounds
Sr compounds
Ba compounds
Me–Ni
CaNi5 SrNi no compounds 1230°, p, IR 1 860°, p, IR 1
Me–Cu
CaCu5 951°, IR 1
Eu compounds
Yb compounds
EuNi5 YbNi3 1440°, est. IR 1 1310°, IR 1
SrCu5 BaCu13 845°, p, IR 1 758°, p, IR 1
EuCu5 847°, IR 1
Yb2Cu9 937°, IR 1
Me–Ag* Ca2Ag7 725°, IR 1
SrAg5 783°, IR 1
BaAg2 770°, IR 1
s.s. EuAg2 792°, IR 1
Yb2Ag7 749°, IR 1
Me–Zn
CaZn11 724°, IR 1
SrZn13 830°, IR 1
BaZn13 885°, IR 1
EuZn2 750°, IR 1
YbZn11 755°, IR 1
Me–Ga
CaGa2 990°, IR 1
s.s. SrGa2 1045°, IR 1
BaGa4 1016°, IR 1
EuGa2 1030°, IR 1
YbGa2 1100°, IR 1
Me–Ge
Ca2Ge 1380°, IR 1
SrGe 1165°, IR 1
BaGe 1155°, IR 1
EuGe 1220°, IR 1
Yb3Ge5 1080°, IR 1
Me–Sb* Ca11Sb10 1123°, IR 1
SrSb 935°, IR 1
Me–Te*
SrTe 1490°, IR 1
Yb4Sb3 1500°, IR 1 BaTe 1470°, IR 1
s.s. EuTe 1526°, IR 1
YbTe 1730°, IR 1
s.s.: solid solution field close to the formula indicated.
These data may be compared with those typical of more electronegative elements of these groups (for instance, CaO 2600°C, BaO 2010°C, BaSe 1780°C, Eu2O3 2300°C, EuS 2200°C, Ca3N2 1450°C, Ba3P2 1340°C, CaC2 2200°C, CaSi 1325°C). A clear indication of the various intermediate phase stability may be obtained from the values of their ΔfH (ΔfG). The enthalpies of formation, in the liquid and in the solid state, of divalent metal alloys with Pb, as a typical element in the p-block, have been measured, and their trend discussed, by Sommer et al. (2006). The most exothermic values observed, for instance, in the Ca–Pb and Ba–Pb systems, correspond (for the solid compounds, in kJ/mol of atoms, at 300 K) to 62 2 (for Ca2Pb) and 73 2 (for BaPb). A relevant compound forming tendency was observed also for the liquid alloys, for which the association model (see § 3.2) was successfully applied confirming the existence of strong chemical short-range order. 5.4.4.3 Remarks on the crystal chemistry of the alloys of the alkaline earth metals and of Eu and Yb. A review of the binary MeXn intermetallic phases formed by Ca, Sr, Ba, Eu and Yb (Me) with Li, Be and 7th to 15th group elements (X) has
354
Intermetallic Chemistry
been published by Fornasini and Merlo (2006): nearly 570 intermediate phases were considered, distributed over 50 comp