Contents
PREFACE xiii
PART ONE CYCLE THE HYDROLOGIC CHAPTER1 lntroduction 1.1 t.2
r.3 t.4 1.5 1.6 I.7 1.8
3 Hydrolo...
2517 downloads
10019 Views
90MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Contents
PREFACE xiii
PART ONE CYCLE THE HYDROLOGIC CHAPTER1 lntroduction 1.1 t.2
r.3 t.4 1.5 1.6 I.7 1.8
3 Hydrology Defined 3 A Brief History 5 The Hydrologic Cycle 5 The Hydrologic Budget 11 HydrologicModels 11 HydrologicData 12 Common Units of Measurement Problems to Environmental Application of Hydrology
CHAPTER2 Precipitation 1 5 2.1 2.2 2.3 2,4 2.5 2.6 2.7
15 Water Vapor 17 Precipitation Distribution of the Precipitation Input 27 Point Precipitation 29 Areal Precipitation 34 Precipitation ProbableMaximum 36 Grossand Net PreciPitation
t2
vi
coNTENTS
CHAPTER3 Interception and Depression Storage 3.1 3.2 3.3
Interception 40 Throughfall 44 DepressionStorage
40
45
CHAPTER4 Infiltration 52 4.I 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.8 4.9 4.10
MeasuringInfiltration 53 Calculation of Infiltration 53 Horton's Infiltration Model 57 Green-AMPT Model 64 Huggins-MonkeModel 67 Holtan Model 68 Recoveryof Infiltration Capacity 69 Temporal and Spatial Variability of Infiltration Capacity SCS Runoff Curve Number Procedure 73 76 @Index
70
CHAPTER5 Evaporation and Transportation 82 " 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7
Evaporation 86 EstimatingEvaporation 86 EvaporationControl 95 Transpiration 95 TranspirationControl 100 Evapotranspiration 100 EstimatingEvapotranspiration
103
CHAPTER6 Streamflow 111 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7 6.8
DrainageBasinEffects 111 The Hydrograph 11,2 Units of Measurementfor Streamflow 113 Measuringand RecordingStreamflow 113 Measurements of Depth and Cross-Sectional Area II4 Measurementof Velocity lI4 RelatingPoint Velocity to Cross-SectionalFlow Velocity The Slope-AreaMethod for DeterminingDischarge II7
115
oONTENTS Vii
PART TWO AND MONITORING 121 fT'IEASUREMENTS HYDROLOGIG CHAPTER7 DataSources Hydrologic 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4
123
I23 GeneralClimatologicalData 123 Precipitation Data 124 StreamflowData Evaporationand TranspirationData
I24
CHAPTER8 fnstrumentation126 8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4
126 Introduction 127 HYdrologicInstruments 135 TelemetrySYstems 135 RemoteSensing
CHAPTER9 Networks 144 Monitoring The Purposeof Monitoring 9.r 9.2 9.3 9.4
144
I45 SpecialConsiderations I47 Uie of ComPutersin Monitoring 147 Hydrological-MeteorlogicalNetworks
PART THREE SURFACEWATERHYDROLOGY151 CHAPTER1O Runoffandthe Catchnient 10.1 tO.2 10.3 IO.4 10.5
153
153 Catchments,Watersheds,and DrainageBasins 155 Basin CharacteristicsAffecting Runoff RudimentaryPrecipitation-RunoffRelationships 164 166 StreamflowFrequencyAnalysis 168 StreamflQwForecasting
CHAPTER11 Hydrographs 171 11.1 Il.2 11.3
StreamflowHYdrograPhs 171 FactorsAffecting HydrographShape HydrograPhComPonents 174
172
viii
ooNTENTS lI.4 11.5 11.6 Il.7
BaseFlow Separation I77 HydrographTime Relationships Time of Concentration I82 BasinLae Time I82
181
CHAPTER12 UnitHydrographs 188 l2.I 12.2 12.3 12.4 12.5 12.6
Unit HydrographDefinition 188 Derivation of Unit Hydrographsfrom StreamflowData 190 Unit HydrographApplications by Lagging Methods I94 S-HydrographMethod 198 The InstantaneousUnit Hydrograph 201 SyntheticUnit Hydrographs 205
CHAPTER13 Hydrograph Routing 13.1 13.2 13.3
HydrologicRiver Routing 235 HydrologicReservoirRouting 245 Hydraulic River Routing 248
CHAPTER14 SnowHydrology I4.l I4.2 I4.3 I4.4 14.5 14.6
234
265
Introduction 265 Snow Accumulation and Runoff 267 Snow Measurementsand Surveys 268 Point and Areal Snow Characteristics 269 The SnowmeltProcess 271. SnowmeltRunoff Determinations 284
CHAPTER15 Urbanand SmallWatershedHydrology 309 15.1 15.2 i5.3 15.4
Introduction 309 PeakFlow Formulasfor Urban Watersheds 311 PeakFlow Formulasfor Small Rural Watersheds 33I Runoff Effects of Urbanization 344
CHAPTER16 Hydrologic Design 16.l 16.2
359
Hydrologic DesignProcedures 360 Data for HydrologicDesign 363
CONTENTS
16.3 16.4 16.5 t6.6 16.7 16.8
HydrologicDesign-Frequency Criteria DesignStorms 373 Critical EventMethods 391 Airport DrainageDesign 400 Designof Urban Storm Drain Systems FloodplainAnalysis 409
365
402
PART FOUR GROUNDWATER HYDROLOGY 425 CHAPTER 17 Groundwater, Soils,and Geology l7.l I7.2 I7.3 I7.4 I7.5 I7.6
427
Introduction 427 GroundwaterFlow-General Properties 429 SubsurfaceDistribution of Water 429 GeologicConsiderations 430 Fluctuationsin GroundwaterLevel 433 Groundwater-Surface Water Relations 433
CHAPTER 18 Mechanics of Flow
435
18.1 t8.2 18.3 18.4 18.5 18.6
Hydrostatics 435 GroundwaterFlow 436 Darcy's Law 436 Permeability 438 Velocity Potential 440 HydrodynamicEquations 441 r8.7 ' Flowlines and EquipotentialLines 18.8 BoundaryConditions 447 18.9 Flow Nets 449 1 8 . 1 0 VariableHydraulic Conductivity 1 8 . 1 1 Anisotropy 452 18.t2 Dupuit's Theory 453
CHAPTER 19 Wellsand Collection Devices 19.1 19.2 19.3 19.4 19.5
444
451
460
Flow to Wells 460 SteadyUnconfinedRadial Flow Toward a Well 461 SteadyConfined Radial Flow Toward a Well 462 Well in A Uniform Flow Field 463 Well Fields 465
IX
X
CONTENTS
19.6 I9.7 19.8 I9.9 19.10 19.ll 19.12
The Method of Images 466 UnsteadyFlow 467 Leaky Aquifers 4'13 Partially PenetratingWells 473 Flow to an Infiltration Gallery 473 SaltwaterIntrusion 474 GroundwaterBasin Development 475
CHAPTER20 ModelingRegionalGroundwater Systems 20.I 20.2 20.3 20.4 20.5
RegionalGroundwaterModels 481 Finite-DifferenceMethods 484 Finite-ElementMethods 493 Model Applications 494 GroundwaterQuality Models 500
PART FIVE HYDROLOGIC MODELING
505
CHAPTER 21 Introduction to Hydrologic Modeling 2l.I 2t.2 21.3 21.4
481
5O7
HydrologicSimulation 508 GroundwaterSimulation 509 Hydrologic Simulation Protocol 524 Corps of EngineersSimulation Models
526
CHAPTER22 SyntheticStreamflows 535 22.I 22.2
SyntheticHydrology 536 Serially DependentTime SeriesAnalysis
CHAPTER23 Continuous Simulation Models 23.1 23.2
548
ContinuousStreamflowSimulationModels 549 ContinuousSimulation Model Studies 570
CHAPTER24 Single-Event Simulation Models 24.1 24.2 24.3
539
594
StormEventSimulation 594 FederalAgency Single-EventModels Storm SurgeModeling 625
597
CONTENTS Xi
CHAPTER25 UrbanRunotfSimulation Models 25.1 25.2 25.3
Urban StormwaterSystemModels 63I Urban Runoff Models Compared 659 Vendor-DevelopedUrbanStormwaterSoftware 663
PART SIX METHODS STATISTICAL
669
CHAPTER26 Probability and Statistics 26.1 26.2 26.3 26.4 26.5 26.6 26.7 26.8 26.9
2 6 .r0
671
RandomVariablesand StatisticalAnalysis 672 Conceptsof Probability 673 ProbabilityDistributions 676 Moments of Distributions 681 Distribution Characteristics 682 Types of Probability Distribution Functions 685 ContinuousProbabilityDistributionFunctions 685 Bivariate Linear Regressionand Correlation 690 Fitting RegressionEquations 692 Regressionand Correlation Applications 697
CHAPTER27 Frequency Analysis 27.1 27.2 27.3 27.4 27.5 27.6 27.7
630
708
FrequencyAnalysis 708 GraphicalFrequencyAnalysis 709 FrequencyAnalysis Using FrequencyFactors RegionalFrequencyAnalysis 7I9 Reliability of FrequencyStudies 730 FrequencyAnalysis of Partial Duration Series Flow Duration Analysis 737
APPENDICES 751 INDEX 757
7Il
734
Preface
Watermanagementis taking on new dimensions.New federalthrusts,the growprotecing list of global iisues,and strongpublic sentimentregardingenvironmental forces. driving tion havebeen the principal In the early yearsof the 20th century,waterresourcesdevelopmentand management were focuied almostexclusivd on water supplyand flood control' Today,these the environment,ensuring safe drinking issuesare still important, but protecting -and experiencescompete equally for recriatioinal water, and providing aesthetic consciouspublic is pressingfor environmentally an attentionand funds.Furthermore, with fewer structural compopractices, management greaterreliance on improved of continually striving to notion The problems. water ients, to solve this nuiion'. this preciousnatural husbanding of one by replaced provide more water has been resource. There is a growing constituencyfor allocatingwater for the-benefitof fish and wildlife, for protection-of marshesand estuary areas' and for other natural system uses.But estimatingthe quantitiesof water neededfor environmentalprotectionand for maintainingand/or restoringnatural systemsis difficult, and there are still many unknowns.Scilntific data are ,putt", and our understandingof the complexinteracof an scalesis rudimentary.Indeed,this is a critical issue' tions inherentin ecosystems sincethe quantitiesof water involvedin environmentalprotection can be substantial of and competitionfor thesewatersfrom traditional water usersis keen' The nations are that systems-decisions natural regarding decisions the world are facing major ladenwith significantectnomic and social impacts.Thus there is_anurgencyassociatedwith developinga betterunderstandingof ecologicsystemsand of their hydrologic components. Water policies of the future must thereforetake on broader dimensions'More emphasismustbe placedon regionalplanningand management,and regionalinstitutions to accommodatethis muJt be devised.Watermanagementmustbe practicedat, more andbetween,all levelsof government.Land useand wateruseplanningmustbe tightly coordinatedas well'
XIV
PREFACE
Water scientistsand engineersof tomorrow must be equipped to addressa diversity of issuessuch as: the design and operation of data retrieval and storage systems;forecasting;developingalternativewater use futures; estimatingwater requirementsfor natural systems;exploringthe impactsof climate change;developing more efficient systemsfor applyingwaterin all water-usingsectors;and analyzingand designingwater managementsystemsincorporating technical, economic, environmental, social, legal, and political elements.A knowledgeof hydrologicprinciplesis a requisitefor dealingwith suchibsues. This fourth edition hasbeendesignedto meet the contemporaryneedsof water scientistsand engineers.It is organizedto accommodatestudentsand practitioners who are concernedwith the development,management,and protection of water resources.The format of the book follows that of its predecessor, providing material for both an introductory and a more advancedcourse. Parts One through Four provide the basicsfor a beginninglevel course,while Parts Five and Six may be used for a more advancedcourseon hydrologicmodeling. This fourth edition has been updated throughout, and many solved examples havebeen added.In addition, new computer approacheshave been introduced and problem-solvingtechniquesincludethe use of spreadsheets as appropriate.New featuresof eachchapterincludean introductory statementof contentsand,at the conclusion of the chapter,a summaryof key points. Many sourceshave been drawn upon to provide subject matter for this book, and the authorshope that suitable acknowledgmenthas been given to them. Colleaguesand studentsare recognizedfor their helpful commentsand reviews,particularly the following reviewers. Gert Aron, ThePennsylvaniaStateUniversity JohnW. Bird, Universityof Nevada-Reno IstvanBogardi, Universityof Nebraska RonaldA. Chadderton,VillanovaUniversity RichardN. Downer,Universityof Vermont Bruce E. Larock, Universityof Califurnia-Davis Frank D. Masch,Universityof Texas-SanAntonio Philip L. Thompson,FederalHighwayAdministration A specialnote of thanks is due to Dr. John W. Knapp, Presidentof the Virginia Military Institute,coauthorof previouseditionsof this book, for his pastcontributions andvaluableguidance. WarrenViessman.Jr. Gary L. Lewis
PARTONE
CYCLE THE HYDROLOGIC
L.
Chapter1
lntroduction
I Prologue The purPoseof this chaPteris to: . , . .
Define hydrology. . earth -,.1Lscience' Give a brief niJiory of the evolution of this important Statethe fundamentalequationofhydrology' appliedto supplementdecision Demonstratetrow ffiofogic principle, "urib" management' support systemsfor water and environmental
DEFINED 1.1 HYDROLOGY Hydrologyisanearthscience'Itencompassestheoccuffence'distribution,moveA knowledgeof hydrologyis fundamenr, and propertiesof the watersof the earth. mentaltodecisionmutingp,o.",,e,*he,ewaterisu"ompon"nto.f.th.esystemof inextricably linked' and it is important concern.water and environmentalissuesare toclear$understandhowwaterisaffectedbyandhowwateraffectsecosystem maniPulations'
1.2 A BRIEFHISTORY Ancient philosophersfocusedtheir i flows Production of surfacewater oc"ur."n"e of water in variousstag from the seato the atmosPhereto t early speculationwas often faulty'l of large subterraneanreservoirsth is interestingto note, however'tha *suoeriornumbersindicatereferencesattheendofthechapter.
CHAPTER1
INTRODUCTION
Greek aqueductson both conveyancecrosssectionand velocity.This knowledgewas lost to the Romans,and the proper relation betweenarea,velocity, and rate of flow remainedunknownuntil Leonardoda Vinci rediscoveredit duringihe Italian Renaissance. During the first century s.c. Marcus Vitruvius, in Volume 8 of his treatiseDe Architectura Libri Decem (the engineer'schief handbookduring the Middle Ages), setforth a theory generallyconsideredto be the predecessorof modern notionsof the hydrologiccycle. He hypothesizedthat rain und ,no* falling in mountainous areas infiltrated the earth's surface and later appearedin the lowlands as streamsand springs. In spiteof the inaccuratetheoriesproposedin ancienttimes,it is only fair to state that practical applicationof varioustry-orotogic principleswas often carried out with considerablesuccess.For example,about4000 s.c. u du- was constructed acrossthe Nile to permit reclamation of previously barren lands for agricultural production. Severalthousandyears later a canal to convey fresh water from Cairo io Suezwas built. Mesopotamiantowns were protecteduguinrt floodsby high earthen walls. The Greek and Roman aqueductsand early Chineseirrigation and flood control works were also significantprojects. Nearthe endof the fifteenth century the trend towarda more scientific approach to hydrology based on the observationof hydrologic phenomena becameevident. Leonardo da Vinci and Bernard Palissyindepende-ntly reachedan accurateunderstandingof the watercycle.They apparentlybised theii theoriesmore on our"*iion than on purely philosophicalreasoning.Nevertheless, until the seventeenthcentury it seemsevident that little if any effort was directed toward obtaining quantitative measurementsof hydrologicvariables. The adventof what might be calledthe "modern" scienceof hydrology is usually consideredto beginwith the studiesof suchpioneersasPerrault,Mariotte, and Halley in the seventeenthcentury.r'aPerraultobtainedmeasurements of rainfall in the Seine River drainagebasin over a period of 3 years. Using these and measurements of runoff, and knowing,thedrainage areasize,he showeJthat rainfall was adequatein quantity to accountfor river flows. He also mademeasurements of evaporati,onand capillarity. Mariotte gaugedthe velocity of flow of the River Seine. Recordedvelocities were translatedinto termsof dischirgeby introducingmeasurements of the river crosssection'The English astronomerHalley measuredthe rate of evaporation of the MediterraneanSeaand concludedthat the amountof water evaporated was sufficient to accountfor the outflow of rivers tributary to the sea.Measurements suchas these, althoughcrude,permitted reliable conclusionsto be drawn reggrding the hydrologic phenomenabeing studied. brth numerousadvancesin hydraulic theory zometer,the Pitot tube, Bernoulli's theorem, ples.8 perimental hydrology flourished.Significant ydrology and in the measurementof surface water. Such significantcontributionsas Hagen-Poiseuille'scapillary flow equation, Darcy's law of flow in porous media, und th" Dupuit-Thiem well formula were evolved'e-lrThe beginningof systematicstream guoling can also be traced to this period' Although the basis for modern hydrology wui tirrr establishedin the nine,)
BUDGET 1.4 THE HYDROLOGIC
5
of teenth century, much of the effort was empirical in nature. The fundamentals early the In recognized. or widely established yet well been not physicalhydtotogyhad years of tle twJntieth ""niury the inadequaciesof many earlier empirical formulato tions becamewell known. As a result, interestedgovernmentalagenciesbegan rational 1950, to 1930 about From research' of hydrologic programs developtheir own analysis began to ieplace empiricism.3 Sherman's unit hydrograph, Horton's infiltration theory, und Th"it's nonequilibrium-approachto well hydraulicsare outstandingexamplesof the great progressmade'r2-'o Since 1930 a theoreiical approachto hydrologicproblemshas largely replaced permit a less sophisticatedmethods of ttre past. Advancesin scientific knowledge and ' better understandingofthe physicaibasisofhydrologic relations,and the advent continueddevelopnientof high-speeddigital computershavemadepossible,in both would a practical and an economiciense,extensivemathematicalmanipulationsthat past. in the havebeen overwhelming For a more compiehensivi historical treatment, the reader is referred to the works of Meinzer,Jonls, Biswas,and their co-workers'1'2'4'5'15
CYCLE 1 . 3THE HYDROLOGIC the The hydrologiccycle is a continuousprocessby which water is transportedfrom The exist' subcycles Many sea. the to back landind to the oceansto the atmosphere precipitation over land beforereturnevaporationof inlan-dwater and its subsequent for the global watertransportsystem force driving The example. ingio the oceanis one requiredfor evaporation'Note that energy the furnishes is providedby the sun,which the cycle; for example,sea passage through during changes the water quality also evaporation' through water fresh water is convertedto The completewater cycle is global in nature. world water problems require Practical studieson regional,national,internitional, continental,and global scales.16 earth is the to available water fresh of supply total the that significanceof the fact has limited and very small compared with ihe salt water content of the oceans at the receivedlittle attention.Thus watersflowing in one country cannotbe available u's' same time for use in other regions of the world. Raymond L' Nace of the thatoowaterresourcesare a global problem with GeologicalSurvey has aptly sta=ted are obligated to cope with problems requiring hydrologists local roots."tu Mtdern magnitudedifference.In addition, developing of oider of definition in varying scales careful attention, since climatological receive must weather techniquesto contiol hydrology and therefore the water the affect profoundly can changesin one area resourcesof other regions.
BUDGET 1 . 4 THE HYDROLOGIC Becausethe total quantity of water availableto the earth is finite and indestructible, subsysthe global hydrolojic ,yrt"* may be lookedupon as closed.Open hydrologic system' temsare abundantlhowever,and theseare usuallythe type analyzed'For any ' a water budgetcan be developedto accountfor the hydrologiccomponents'
CHAPTER1
,
INTRODUCTION
FiguresI'I,I.2, and 1.3 showa hydrologicbudgetfor the coterminousUnited States,a conceptualizedhydrologiccycle,andthe distributionof a precipitationinput, respectively.Thesefiguresillustrate the componentsof the water cycle with which a hydrologistis concerned.In a practicalsense,somehydrologicregionis dealtwith and a budgetfor that region is established.Suchregionsmay be topographicallydefined (watershedsand river basinsare examples),politically specified(e.g- couniy or city limits), or chosenon some other grounds. Watershedsor drainagi tasins are the easiestto deal with sincethey sharply define surfacewater boundaries.Thesetopographically determinedareasare drainedby a river/streamor systemof connecting rivers/streamssuch that all outflow is dischargedthrough a single outlet. Unfortunately,it is often necessaryto deal with regions that are not well suitedto tracking hydrologiccomponents.For theseareas,the hydrologistwill find hydrologicbudgeting somewhatof a challenge. The primary input in a hydrologicbudgetis precipitation.Figures 1.1-1.3 illustrate this. Someof the precipitation (e.g.,rain, snow,hail) may be interceptedby trees,grass,other vegetation,and structuralobjectsand will eventuallyreturn to the atmosphereby evaporation.Onceprecipitationreachesthe ground,someofit may fill (becomedepressionstorage),part may penetralethe ground (infiltraie) to depressions replenishsoil moisture and groundwaterreservoirs,and some may become surface runoff-that is, flow over the earth's surfaceto a definedchannelsuchas a stream. Figure 1'3 showsthe dispositionofinfiltration, depressionstorage,and surfacerunoff.
and vegetation
*r-d{i;
I
'1.'
Consumptive use 100bgd
bgd = billion gallons per day
Figure 1.1 Hydrologic budgetof cotermiriousunited States.(U.S. Geologicalsurvey.)
BUDGET 7 1.4 THEHYDROLOGIC Clouds and water vaPor
Clouds and water vaPor
ffi
(
)
" 1 ) t t l l ,
--1vtivv
p\--
P
P
P
P
P
P
E E
E
E
t t E' evaporation;P' Figure 1.2 The hydrologic 'surfac-e cycle: ?, transpiration; flow; and I' groundwater runoff; G, R, p.Sqipi*i"tt inflltration.
L
t Precipitation inPut (hyetogaph)
'l,r\ t SSeamflow (hyclrograPh)
Figure 1.3 Distributionof precipitationinput'
CHAPTER1
INTRODUCTION
water enteringthe ground may take severalpaths.Somemay be directly evaporatedif adequatetransferfrom the soil to the surfaceis maintained.This can easily occur where a high groundwater table (free water surface) is within the limits of capillary transportto the ground surface.Vegetationusingsoil moistureor groundwatei directly can also transmit infiltrated water to the atmosphereby a processknown as transpiration.Infiltrated water may likewise replenishsoil moisture deficiencies and enter storageprovided in groundwaterreservoirs,which in turn maintain dry weather streamflow.Important bodies of groundwaterare usually flowing so that inflltrated water reachingthe saturated,on" muy be transportedfor considerable' distancesbefore it is discharged.Groundwatermovement is subject, of course,to physicaland geologicalconstraints. Water storedin depressionswill eventually evaporateor infiltrate the ground I surface.Surfacerunoff otti-ut"ty reachesminor channels(gullies, rivulets, and the : like), flowsto major streamsand rivers,and finally reachesan ocean.Along the course of a stream,evaporationand infiltration can also occur. The foregoing discussion suggeststhat the hydrologic cycle, while simple in concept,is actually exceedinglycomplex.Pathstaken by particlesof water precipitated in any arcaare numerousand varied before the seais reached.The time scale may be on the order of seconds,minutes,days,or years. A generalhydrologicequationcan be developedbasedon theprocessesillustrated in Figs. 1.2 and 1.3. ConsiderFig. 1.4. In it, the hydrologicvariablesP, E, T, R, G, and l are as definedin Fig. 1.2. Subscriptss and g are introduced to denote vectorsoriginatingaboveand belowthe earth's surface,respectivd. For example,R,
[" Earth's surface Surface channels
R2
Level of plastic rock . (no water below this level)
Figure 1.4 Regionalhydrologiccycle.
BUDGET 1.4 THE HYDROLOGIC
9
signifies groundwaterflow that is effluent to a surface streamoand E, represents evaporationfrom surfacewaterbodiesor other surfacestorageareas.Letter S stands for storage.The regionunderconsiderationspecifiedasA hasa lower boundarybelow which water will not be found. The upper boundary is the earth's surface.Vertical boundsare arbitrarily set asprojectionsof the peripheryof the region.Remembering that the water budgetis a balancebetweeninflows, outflows,and changesin,storage, Fig. 1.4canbe translatedinto the following mathematicalstatements,whereall values are given in units of volume per unit time: 1. Hydrologicbudgetabovethe surface P+R1 -RrIRr-E"-7,-
1:AS"
(1.1)
AS,
(1.2)
2. Hydrologicbudgetbelow the surface I + Gt- G2- Rr- E, - 4:
3. Hydrologicbudgetfor the region (sum of Eqs' 1.2 and 1.3) p - (Rr- R,) - (E" + E) - (r" + Tr) - (Gr- G,) : a(S, + ss), (1.3) If the subscriptsare droppedfrom Eq. 1.3 sothat letterswithout subscriptsrefer to total precipitation and net valuesof surfaceflow, undergroundflow, evaporation, transpiration,and storage;the hydrologicbudgetfor a regioncan be written simply as p_R-G_E_T:LS
(1.4)
This is the basicequationof hydrology.For a simplifiedhydrologicsystemwhereterms G, E, and Z do not apply, Eq. 1.4 reducesto p-R:AS
(1.5)
Equation 1.4 is applicableto exercisesof any degreeof complexity and is therefore basic to the solution of all hydrologicproblems. The difficulty in solvingpractical problemslies mainly in the inability to measure or estimateproperly the various hydrologic equation terms. For local studies, reliableestimatesoften are made,but on a global scaleqqantificationis usuallycrude. Precipitationis measuredby rain or snowgaugeslocatedthroughoutan area.Surface flows can be measuredusing various devicessuchas weirs, flumes,velocity meters, and depthgaugeslocatedin the rivers and streamsof the area.Under goodconditions these measurementsare 95 percent or more accufate,but large floods cannot be measureddirectly by current methodsand dataon sucheventsare sorelyneeded.Soil moisturecan be measuredusingneutronprobesand gravimetricmethods;infiltration can be deterrnined locally by infiltrometers or estimated through the use of precipitation-runoff data. Areal estimatesof soil moistureand infiltration are generilly very crude,however.The extentandrate of movementof groundwaterareusually exceedinglydifficult to determine,and adequatedataon quantitiesof groundwaterare not alwaysavailable.Knowledgeof the geologyof aregion is essentialfor groundwater estimatesif they are to be more than just rough guides.The determinationof the
1O
CHAPTER1
INTRODUCTION
quantities of water evaporatedand transpired is also extremely difflcult under the presentstateof developmentiofthe science.Most estimatesof evapotranspirationare obtainedby usingevaporationpans,energybudgets,masstransfermethods,or empirical relations.A predicamentinherent in the analysisof large drainagebasinsis the fact that rates of evaporation,transpiration,and groundwatermovementare often assumedto be highly heterogeneous. The hydrologicequationis a usefultool; the readershouldunderstandthat it can be employed in various ways to estimate the magnitude and time distribution of hydrologicvariables.An introductory exampleis given here,and otherswill be found throushout the book. EXAMPLE 1.1 In a given year,a 10,000-mi2wabrshedreceived20 in. of precipitation.The average rate of flow measuredin the river drainingthe areawasfound to be 700 cfs (cubicfeet per second).Make a rough estimateof the combinedamountsof waterevaporatedand transpiredfrom the region during the year of record. Solution. Beginningwith the basic hydrologicequation P - R - G - E - Z : A S
(r.4)
and sinceevaporationand transpirationcan be combined, ET:P-ft-G-AS
{4 t:
.+ v' a'E-;.
(1.6)
The term EZ is the unknown to be evaluatedand P and R are specifled.The equation thus has flve variables and three unknowns and cannot tre solved without additional information. In order to get a solution, two assumptionsare made. First, since the drainageareais quite large (measuredin hundredsof squaremiles),a presumption that the groundwaterdivide (boundary)follows the surfacedivide is probably reasonable.In this casethe G componentmay be consideredzero. The vector R, existsbut is included in R. The foregoingassumptionis usually not valid forsmall areasand mustthereforebe usedcarefully.It is alsopresupposed that AS : 0, thus implying that the groundwaterreservoir volume has not changedduring the year. For such short periods this assumptioncan be very inaccurate,evenfor well-wateredregionswith balancedwithdrawalsand good rechargepotentials.In arid areaswheregroundwateris beingmined (AS consistently negative),it would be an unreasonablesuppositionin many cases.Nevertheless,the assumptionis made here for illustrative purposesand qualified by sayingthat pastrecordsof waterlevelsin the areahaverevealedan approximate constancyin groundwaterstorage.Hydrology is not an exact science,and reasonablewell-foundedassumptionsare required if practical problemsare to be solved. Using the simplificationsjust outlined, the working relation reducesto ET:P_R
'I1 1.6 HYDROLOGIC DATA which canbe solveddirectly.First, changeR into inchesper yearsothat the units are compatible: _ ft3 r
\
t
-
r
sec
R _
.
,
1
sec
area (m n-l
yt
,
6
^ :R,in.
II
7 0 0 x 8 6 ; 4 0 0 x 3 6 5 x 1 :2 104x (5280)'
0.95in.
Therefore,ET : 20 - 0.95 : 19.05in./yr. The amountof evapotranspirationfor the year in questionis estimatedto be 19.05in. This is admittedlya crudeapproximationbut could serveasa useful guide for water resourcesplanning. ll
1.5 HYDROLOGIC MODELS Hydrologic systemsare generally analyzedby using mathematicalmodels.'These modelsmay be empirical, statistical,or foundedon known physicallaws.They may be usedfor suchsimplepurposesas determiningthe rate of flow that a roadwaygrate mustbe designedto handle,or they may guidedecisionsaboutthe bestway to develop a river basinfor a rnultiplicity of objectives.The choiceof the modelshouldbe tailored to the purposefor which it is to be used.In general,'thesimplestmodel capableof producinginformation adequateto deal with the issueshouldbe chosen. Unfortunately,most waterresourcessystemsof practicalconcernhavephysical, social,political, environmental,andlegaldirnensions;andtheir interactionscannotbe exactly describedin mathematicalterms. Furthermore,the historical data necessary for meaningful hydrologic analysesare often lacking or unreliable. And when one considersthat hydrologic systemsare generallyprobabilistic in nature, it is easyto understandthat the modeler'stask is not a simpleone.In fact, it is often the casethat the best that can be hoped for from a model is an enhancedunderstandingof the systembeing analyzed.But this in itself can be of great value, leading,for example, to the implementationof datacollectionprogramsthat canultimately supportreliable modelingefforts. For the most part, mathematicalmodels are designedto describethe way a system'selementsrespondto sometype of stimulus(input). For example,a model of 'a groundwater systemmight be developedto demonstratethe effectson groundwater storageof various schemesfor pumping. Equations 1.1 and L2 are mathematical modelsof the hydrologicbudget,and Figure 1.3 can be considereda pictorial model of the rainfall-runoff process.In later chapters,a variety of hydrologicmodelswill be presentedand discussed.Thesemodelsprovidethe basisfor informed watermanagement decisions.
DATA 1.6 HYDROLOGIC Hydrologic dataarc neededto describeprecipitation; streamflows;evaporation;soil moisture; snow fields; sedimentation;transpiration;infiltration; water quality; air, s9i!, and water temperatures;and other variablesor componentsof hydrologicsys-
12
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
tems. Sources of data are numerous,with the U.S. Geological Survey being the primary one for streamflow and groundwaterfacts. The National Weather Service (NOAA or National Oceanicand AtmosphericAdministration)is the major collector of meterologicdata.Many other federal,state,and local agenciesand other organizations also compile hydrologicdata. For a completelisting of theseorganizationssee Refs.3 and 17.
1 . 7 COMMONUNITSOF MEASUREMENT
'
Streamandriver flowsare usuallyrecordedascubic metersper second(m3/sec),cubic feetper second(cfs),or second-feet(sec-ft);groundwaterflowsand watersupplyflo\i/s are commonly measuredin gallons per minute, hour, or day (gpm, gph, gpd), or millions of gallonsper day (mgd); flowsusedin agricultureor relatedto water storage are often expressedas acre-feet (acre-ft), acre-feet per unit time, inches (in.) or centimeters(cm) depth per unit time, or acre-inchesper hour (acre-in./hr). Volumesare often given as gallons,cubic feet, cubic meters,acre-feet,secondfoot-days,and inchesor centimeters.An acre-footis equivalentto a volume of water 1 ft deep over 1 acre of land (43,560 ft3). A second-foot-day(cfs-day,sfd) is the accuinulatedvolumeproducedby a flow of 1 cfs in a24-hr period.A second-foot-hour (cfs-hr) is the accumulatedvolume produced by a flow of 1 cfs in t hr. Inches or centimetersof depthrelate to a volume equivalentto that many inchesor centimeters of water over the areaof concern.In hydrologicmassbalances,it is sometimesuseful to note that 1 cfs-day : 2 acre-feetwith sufficient accuracyfor most calculations. Rainfall depthsare usually recordedin inchesor centimeterswhereasrainfall rates are given in inches or centimetersper hour. Evaporation,transpiration, and infiltration rates are usually given as inchesor centimetersdepthper unit time. Some usefulconstantsand tabulatedvaluesof severalof the physicalpropertiesof water are given in Appendix A at the end of the book.
1.8 APPLICATIONOF HYDROLOGYTO ENVIRONMENTALPROBLEMS It is true that humanscannot exist without water; it is also true that water, mismanaged,or during times of deficiency(droughts),or times of surplus(floods),can be life threatening.Furthermore,there is no aspectof environmentalconcernthat doesnot relate in someway to water. Land, air, and water are all interrelatedas are water and all life forms. Accordingly, the spectrum of issuesrequiring an understandingof hydrologicprocessesis almost unlimited. As waterbecomesmore scarceand as competition for its useexpands,the need for improved water managementwill grow. And to provide water for the world's expandingpopulation, new industrial developments,food production, recreational demands,and for the preservationand protection of natural systemsand other purposes,it will becomeincreasinglyimportant for us to achievea thoroughunderstanding of the underlyinghydrologicprocesseswith which we must contend.This is the challengeto hydrologists,waterresourcesengineers,planners,policymakers,lawyers, economists,and others who must strive to see that future allocationsof water are sufficient to meet the needsof human and natural svstems.
PROBLEMS
13
r summary distribution' moveHydrology is the scienceof water. It embracesthe occurrence, sense,an account-"nt, urii propertiesof the watersof the earth. In a mathematical sothat a history ing may be madeof the inputs,outputs,and waterStofagesof a region of water movementfor the region can be estimated' the hydrologic After reading this chapter you should be able to understand shouldalso You budgetand make a simpleu".ouniing of water transportin a region' to be used facilitate have gained an undersiandingof trow hydrologic analysescan designand managementprocessesfor water resourcessystems'
PROBLEMS of 50 mi2.Convertthis
1.1.. One-half inch of runoff resultsfrom a stormon a drainagearea
amount to acre-feetand cubic meters. surfacearea of t.2. Assume you afe dealing with a vertical walled reservoir having a will it take to hours many How occurs: m3/sec 1.0 of 500,000 m' and that anlnflow raise the reservoirlevel bY 30 cm? time is 15 acre-ft and 1.3. consider that the storageexistingin a river reachat a reference from the reachis outflow the and cfs 500 is reach tie at the sametime the inflow to 650cfs.onehourlater,theinflowis550cfsandtheoutflowis630cfs.Findthe meters' changein storageduring the hour in acre-feetand in cubic walled reservoir was t.4. During a24-hr time period, the inflow to a 500-acre vertical a rise or fall in there in. was 1 was evaporation interval, same the 100 cfs. During centimeters' and in inches surfacewaterelevation?How muchwasit? Give the answer areais 3000 acres' 1.5. The annualevaporationfrom a lake is 50 in. If the lake's surface centimeters? in and acre-feet in rate evaporation daity what would beiire time requiredto raise 1.6. A flow of 10 cfs entersa 1-mi2vertical walledreservoir.Find the the reservoirlevelbY 6 in. Iftheaverageannualrunoffis5l02cfsand areaof4511mi2. t.7. Adrainagebasinhasan lossesfor the areain the averalerainfall is 42.5 in.,estimatethe evaportranspiration is? estimate this you think 1 year. Iiow reliable do Determinethe storage 1.8. The storagein a reachof a river is 16.0acre-ft at a given time. during the hour are outflow and inflow of (u"r"-f""tj t hr later if the averagerates 700 and 650 cfs, resPectivelY. areafor 3 days' (a) L.9. Rain falls atataverage irrtensity of 0.4 in./hr over a 600-acfe the 3-day (b) determine per second; feet Determinethe averagerate ofrainfau in cubic volumeofrainfallinacre-feet;and(c)determinethe3-dayvolumeofrainfallininches of equivalentdepth over the 600-acrearea' 100 acre-ft/day'Deter1.10. The evaporationrate from the surfaceof a 3650-acrelake is year ifthe inflow to the lake a 365-day during lake (feet) in the mine the depthchange is25.2cfs.1s the changein lake depth an increaseor a decrease? acre-feetif the drainage 1.11. One and one-half inchesof runoff areequivalentto how many : ft"') 43,560 areais 25-mi2?lNote: I acte of how many cubic feet L.12. one-half inch of rain per day is equivalentto an averagerate per second? meters many p". ,".ona if the areais 500 acrei?How
14
cHAPTER1 INTRoDUCTIoN
REFERENCES 1. P. B. Jones,G. D. Walker,R. W. Harden,and L. L. McDaniels,"The Developmentof the Scienceof Hydrology," Circ. No. 60-03, TexasWater Commission,Apr. 1963. 2. W. D. Mead, Noteson Hydrology. Chicago:D. W. Mead, 1904. 3. Ven Te Chow (ed)., Handbook of Applied Hydrology. New York: McGraw-Hill,1964. 4. O. E. Meinzer,Hydrology,Vol. 9 of Physicsof the Earth.New York: McGraw-Hlll, 1942. Reprintedby Dover, New York, 1949. 5. P. D. Krynine, "On the Antiquity of Sedimentationand Hydrology," Bull. Geol. Soc. Am. 70. l7 2I - l7 26(1960\. 6. RaphaelG. Kazmann,Modern Hydrology.New York: Harper & Row, 1965. 7. H. Pazwoshand G. Mavrigian, "A Historical Jewelpiece-Discovery of the Millennium Hydrologic Works of Karaji," WaterResourcesBull. 16(6), 1094-1096(Dec. 1980), 8. Hunter Rouseand Simon Ince, History of Hydraulics, Iowa Institute of Hydraulic Re- :. search,State University of Iowa, 1957. 9. G. H. L. Hagen, "Ueber die Bewegungdes Wassersin engen cylindrischenRohren," Poggendorfs Ann. Phys. Chem.16, 423- 442(1839). 10. Henri Darcy, Les fontaines publiques de la ville de Dijon. Paris:.V. Dalmont, 1856. 11. J. Dupuit, Etudesthdoriqueset practiques sur le mouvementdes eaux dans les canauxs dtcouvertset d travers les terrainspermdables,2nded. Paris:Dunod, 1863. 12. L. K. Sherman,"Stream Flow from Rainfall by the Unit-Graph Method," Eng. NewsRec.108(1932). 13. R. E. Horton, "The Role of Infiltration in the Hydrologic Cycle," Trans.Am. Geophys. Union 14, 446- 460(1933). l 14. C. V. Theis,"The RelationBetweenthe Lowering of the PiezometricSurfaceand the Rate and Duration of a Well Using Ground WaterRecharge,"Trans.Am. Geophys.Union 16, 519-524(1935\. 15. Asit K. Biswas,"Hydrologic EngineeringPrior to 600 s.c.," Proc. ASCE J. Hyd. Div., Proc. Paper5431,Vol. 93, No. HY5 (Sept.1967). 16. RaymondL. Nace,"WaterResources:A GlobalProblemwith Local Roots,"Environ. Sci. Technol.1(7) (July i967). 17. D. K. Todd (ed.), The WaterEncylopedia.New York: Water Information Center, 1970.
Chapter2
Precipitation
r Prologue The purposeof this chapteris to: ' Define precipitation, discussits forms, and describeits spatial and temporal attributes. ' Illustrate techniquesfor estimatingareal precipitation amountsfor specific storm eventsand for maximum precipitation-generatingconditions. Precipitation replenishessurfacewater bodies,rbnewssoil moisture for plants, and rechargesaquifers.Its principal forms are rain and snow.The relative importanceof theseforms is determinedby ttre climate of the area under consideration.In many parts of the westernUnited States,the extentof the snowpackis a determiningfactor relative to the amountof waterthat will be availablefor the summergrowing season. In more humid localities, the timing and distribution of rainfall are of principal concern. Precipitatedwaterfollows the pathsshownin Figs. r.2 and,1.3.some of it may be intercepted,evaporated,infiltrated, and becomesurfaceflow. The actual disposition dependson the amountof rainfall, soil moistureconditions,topography,vegetal cover soil type, and other factors Hydrologic modeling and water resourcesassessments dependupon a knowledgeof the form and amountof precipitation occurringin a region of concernover a time period of interest.
2.1 WATERVAPOR The fraction of watervapor in the atmosphereis very small comparedto quantitiesof other gasespresent,but it is exceedinglyimportant to our way of life. Precipitationis derived from this atmosphericwater. The moisture centent of the air is also a significantfactor in local evaporationprocesses.Thus it is necessaryfor a hydrologist to be acquaintedwith waysfor evaluatingthe atmosphericwatervapor contentand to understandthe thermodynamiceffects of atmosphericmoisture.l
CHAPTER2
16
PRECIPITATION
Under most conditions of practical interest (modest ranges of pressureand temperature,provided that the condensationpoint is excluded),water vapor essentialiy obeys the gas laws. Atmospheric moisture is derived from evaporationand transpiration,the principal sourcebeing evaporationfrom the oceans.Precipitation overthe United Statescomeslargelyfrom oceanicevaporation,the watervaporbeing transporatedover the continentby the primary atmosphericcirculation system. Measuresof watervapor or atmospherichumidity are relatedbasicallyto conditions of evaporationand condensationoccurring over a level surfaceof pure water. Considera ilosed systemcontaining approximatelyequal volumesof water and air maintainedat the sametemperature.If the initial condition of the air is dry, evaporation takesplace and the quantity of water vapor in the air increases.A measurement of pressurein the airspacewill reveal that as evaporationproceeds,pressurein the airipaceincreasesbecauseof an increasein partial pressureof the watervapor (vapor preJsure).Evaporationcontinuesuntil vapor pressureof the overlying air equalsthe surfacevapor pressure[a measureof the excessof water moleculesleaving(evaporating from) the water surfaceover thosereturning]. At this point, evaporationceases, and if the temperaturesof the air spaceand water are equal,the airspaceis saidto be saturated.If the containerhad beenopeninsteadof closed,the equilibriumwould not havebeenreached,and all the water would eventuallyhaveevaporated.Somecommonly usedmeasuresof atmosphericmoistureor humidity are vapor pressure,absolute humidity, specifichumidity, mixing ratio, relative humidity, and dew point tem-
,
Perature.
Amount of PrecipitableWater .
Estimatesof the amount of precipitation that might occur over a given region with favorable conditions are often useful. These may be obtained by calculating the amountof water containedin a column of atmosphereextendingup from the earth's surface.This quantity is known as theprecipitable water 14{althoughit cannotall be removed from the atmosphereby natural processes.Precipitable water is usually expressedin centimetersor inches. An equationfor computingthe amountof precipitablewater in the atmosphere can be derived as follows. Considera column of air having a squarebase 1 cm on a side.The total water masscontainedin this column betweenelevationzero and some height z would be
W:
r p*dz
(2.1)
J^
wherep. : the absolutehumidity and IVis the depthof precipitablewaterin centimeters. The integral can be evaluatedgraphically or by dividing the atmosphereinto layersof approximatelyuniform specifichumidities,solvingfortheseindividually, and then summing.Figure 2.1 illustratesthe averageamountof precipitablewater for the continentalUnited Statesup to an elevationof 8 km.2
Geographicand TemporalVariations The quantity of atmosphericwater vapor varieswith location and time. Thesevariations may be attributed mainly to temperatureand sourceof supply considerations. The greatestconcentrationscan be found near the ocean surfacein the tropics, the
2.2 PRECIPITATION
17
Sault Ste.Mtrie Portled
0;7 VCT -NJ 0.8
0.9 1.0
0.8 b.z o.d1'o 1.1 r.2 t.J
Bromsville
Figure 2.L Mean precipitablewater, in inches,to an elevationof 8 km. (U.S. WeatherBureau.)2
concentrationsgenerallydecreasingwith latitude, altitude, and distanceinland from coastalareas. About half the atmosphericmoisturecanbe found within the first mile abovethe earth's surface.This is becausethe vertical transport of vapor is mainly through convectiveaction,which is slight at higher altitudes.It is also of interestthat there is not necessarilyany relation betweenthe amount of atmosphericwater vapor over a regionand the resultingprecipitation.The amountof water vapor containedover dry areasof the Southwest,for example,at times exceedsthat over considerablymore humid northern regions,eventhough the latter areasexperienceprecipitation while the former do not.
2.2 PRECIPITATION Precipitation is the primary input vector of the hydrologiccycle. Its forms are rain, snow,andhail andvariationsof thesesuchasdrizzle and sleet.Precipitationis derived from atmosphericwater, its form and quantity thus being influencedby the action of other climatic factors such as wind, temperature,and atmosphericpressure.Atmosphericmoistureis a necessarybut not sufficient condition for precipitation. Continental air massesare usuallyvery dry sothat mostprecipitationis derivedfrom moist maritime air that originatesoverthe oceans.In North America about50 percentof the evaporatedwater is taken up by continental air and movesback againto the sea.
18
CHAPTER2
PRECIPITATION
Formationof PreciPitation Two processesare consideredto be capableof supportingthe growth of dropletsof sufficient mass(dropletsfrom about 500 to 4000 p'min diameter)to overcomeair resistanceand consequentlyfall to the earth asprecipitation.Theseare known as the process' ice crystalprocessand the coalescence the small cloud dropletsincreasetheir which by process is one The c^oalescence collision. Water droplets may be through droplets other with size due to contact gravitationaland air resistance to both subjected are that bodies falling consideredas are proportional to the (terminal velocities) equilibrium at effects. Fall velocities descendmore quickly will droplets larger the thus the droplet; of squareof the radius overtakenby larger are often droplets smaller result, As a ones. than the smaller increasingly producing the drops, to unite tend collisions resulting droplets,and the into smallup break in diameter) mm (order 7 of drops large largir particles.Very effect. chain of a produce somewhat and process coalescence dropletsthat repeatitre significant generate to produced be may raindrops large In this *unn"r, sufficiently precipitation. This processis ionsidered to be particularly important in tropical regionsor in warm clouds. An important type of growth is known to occurif ice crystalsand waterdroplets -40'C- Under are found toexist togetherat subfreezingtemperaturesdown to about theseconditions,certain particles t saltsserveasfreezingnucleisothat theseconditionsis higher over the t condensationoccurson the surface unevenparticle sizedistributionsde' with otherparticles.This is considet mechanism. The artificial inducementof precipitation has been studied extensively,and thesestudiesare continuing.It has been demonstratedthat condensationnuclei supplied to cloudscan induceprecipitation.The ability of humansto ensurethe produciion of precipitation or to control its geographiclocation or timing has not yet been attained,however' Many legal as well as technologicalproblemsare associatedwith the prospects ..rain-makiig" processes. Of interesthereis the impacton hydrologicestimatesthat of partially controlled artificial precipitation might have. Many uncontrolled oi onty are consideredas statisticalvariatesthat are variables Lydrologic naturally occurring with a random component.If the distribudistributed or either randomty distrlUuted an inferenceasto the frequencyof modeled, can be variable the tion or time seiiesof given magnitude(suchas precipitaa of events hydrologic occurrenceof significant used and if the effectsof these are controls artificial however, If, tion) can be made. prove to be totally unreliable may analyses frequency predicted, cannot be reliably tools.
PrecipitationTyPes Dynamic or adiabaticcoolingis the primary causeof condensationand is responsible for most rainfall. Thus it can be seen that vertical transport of air massesis a requirementfor precipitation.Precipitationmay be classifiedaccordingto the condi-
'1 2.2 PRECIPITATIOI'|9 tions that generatevertical air motion. In this respect,the three major categoriesof precipitation type are convective,orographic, and cyclonic. Convective Precipitation Convectiveprecipitationis typical of the tropicsand is brought about by heatingof the air at the interfacewith the ground. This heatedair expandswith a resultantreductionin weight.During this period,increasingquantities of water vapor are taken up; the warm moisture-ladenair becomesunstable;and pronouncedvertical currents are developed.Dynamic cooling takes place, causing condensationand precipitation.Convectiveprecipitationmay be in the form of light showersor stormsof extremelyhigh intensity (thunderstormsare a typical example). Orographic Precipitation Orographicprecipitationresultsfrom the mechanical lifting of moist horizontal air currentsover natural barriers suchas mountainranges. This type of precipitation is very common on the West Coast of the United States where moistureladen air from the Pacific Oceanis interceptedby coastalhills and mountains.Factorsthat are important in this processinclude land elevation,local slope,orientation of land slope,and distancefrom the moisture source. In dealingwith orographicprecipitation,it is commonto divide the regionunder study into zonesfor which influencesasidefrom elevationare believedto be reasonably constant.For eachof thesezones,a relation betweenrainfall and elevationis developedfor usein producingisohyetalmaps(seeSection2,5). with the movementof Cyclonic Precipitation Cyclonicprecipitationis associated air massesfrom high-pressureregionsto low-pressureregions.Thesepressuredifferencesare createdby the unequalheatingof the earth's surface. Cyclonicprecipitationmay be classifiedasfrontal or nonfrontal. Any barometric low canproducenonfrontal precipitationasair is lifted throughhorizontalconvergenceof the inflow into a low-pressurearea. Frontal precipitation results from the lifting of warm air over cold air at the contact zone between air masseshaving different characteristics.If the air massesare moving so that warm air replacescolder warm air, the front is known asawarmfront; if , on the otherhand,cold air displaces air, the front is saidto be cold.If the front is not in motion,it is saidto be a stationary front. Figure 2.2 illustratesa vertical sectionthrough a frontal surface.
Figure 2.2 Vertical cross-sectionthrough a frontal surface.
20
CHAPTER 2 PRECIPITATION
Thunderstorms Many areasof the United Statesare subjectedto severeconvectivestorms,which are generallyidentifiedasthunderstormsbecauseof their electricalnature.Thesestorms, although usually very local in nature, are often productive of very intenserainfalls that are highly significantwhen local and urban drainageworks are considered. Thunderstormcells developfrom vertical air movementsassociatedwith intense surfaceheatingor orographiceffects.Thereare threeprimary stagesin the life history of a thunderstorm.Theseare the cumulusstage,the mature stage,andthe dissipating stage.Figure 2.3 illustrateseachof thesestages. All thunderstormsbeginascumulusclouds,althoughfew suchcloudseverreach the stage of developmentneededto produce such a storm. The cumulus stageis characterizedby strongupdrafts that often reachaltitudesof over 25,000ft. Vertical wind speedsat upperlevelsare often as greatas 35 mph. As indicatedinFig.2.3a, there is considerablehorizontal inflow of air (entrainment)during the cumulusstage. This is an important elementin the developmentof the storm, as additional moisture is provided.Air temperaturesinside the cell are greaterthart thoseoutside,as indicatedby the convexity of the isothermsviewed from above.The number and size of The duration ofthe cumulusstage the water dropletsincreaseasthe stageprogresses. is approximatelyi0-15 min. The strong updrafts and entrainmentsupport increasedcondensationand the developmentof waterdropletsand ice crystals.Firrally, whenthe particlesincreasein size and number so that surfaceprecipitation opcurs,the storm is said to be in the mature stage.In this stage strong downdrafts are created as falling rain and ice crystals cool the air below. Updraft velocities at the higher altitudes reach up to 70 mptrin the early periodsof the maturestage.Downdraft speedsof over20 mph are
El
o o F
(a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 2.3 Cumulus,mature,and dissipatingstagesof a thunderstormcell. (Department of the Army.)
2.2 PRECIPITATION 21
usual aboveabout 5000 ft in elevation.At lower levels,frictional resistancetendsto decreasethe downdraft velocity. Gusty surfacewinds move outwardfrom the region of rainfall. Heavyprecipitationis often derivedduring this preiod, which is usuallyon the order of 15-30 min. In the final or dissipatingstage,the downdraftbecomespredominantuntil all the air within the cell is descendingand being dynamically heated.Since the updraft ceases,the mechanismfor condensationends and precipitation tails off and ends.
PrecipitationData Considerabledata on precipitation are available in publications of the National WeatherService.a's Other sourcesincludevariousstateand federal agenciesengaged in water resourceswork. For critical regional studiesit is recommendedthat all possibledata be compiled; often the establishmentof a gauging network will be necessary(seealso Chapters7-9).
Precipitation VariabiIity Precipitationvariesgeographically,temporally, and seasonally.Figure 2.4 indrcates the mean annualprecipitation for the continentalUnited States,while Fig. 2.5 gives an exampleof seasonaldifferences.It should be understoodthat both regional and temporal variationsin precipitation are very important in water resourcesplanning and hydrologicstudies.For example,it may be very important to know that the cycle of minimum precipitationcoincideswith the peakgrowing seasonin a particular atea, or that the periodofheaviestrainfall shouldbe avoidedin schedulingcertainconstruction activities. Precipitation amounts sometimesvary considerablywithin short distances. Recordshaveshowndifferencesof 20 percentor more in the catchof rain gaugesless that2Oft apart.Precipitationis usuallymeasuredwith a rain gaugeplacedin the open so that no obstacleprojects within the inverted conical surfacehavingthe top of the gaugeas its apexand a slopeof45'. The catchofa gaugeis influencedby the wind, which usually causeslow readings.Variousdevicessuchas Nipher and Alter shields havebeendesignedto minimize this error in measurement.Precipitationgaugesmay be of the recording or nonrecordingtype. The former are requiredif the time distribution of precipitation is to be known. Information about the featuresof gaugesis readily available.3 Becauseprecipitationvariesspatially,it is usuallynecessaryto usethe datafrom severalgaugesto estimatethe averageprecipitation for an area and to evaluateits reliability (seeChapter27). This is especiallyimportant in forestedareaswhere the variation tendsto be large. Time variations in rainfall intensity are extremely important in the rainfallrunoff process,particularly in urban areas(seeFi g. 2.6a). The arealdistributionis also significantandhighly correlatedwith the time history of outflow (seeFig. 2.6b).These considerationsare discussedin greaterdetail in following chapters.
g
6
o
n
c)
() H
o U) o E t r 9
.n
EF
C) d
Q
.v) C) k
H
h0 A
C)
!
()
n"i c.)
o
€ a
() 6
s o E o
U F
e<
(.) o H 6
o
t^ 0,)
$ 6l
bo
,t, ,Ff
/i E
.;
.t
.o k P)
o
t z
c) H 'ir
@h{
6d
F
O
H 0)
* \ - r ( E
e
1
>r
\
/ ,,--
F
C)
Fi
oooooo a€F€hs
{6d^O
./
t:
j;i.
F o 5 > 6 k
EU)
ts
q
.
-
:
$,-,\ qi g( J:
O r +
F
\
:
( ,E ; \ * \ i \
i< "F
. E
'r
-
"
: R
oooo t
,/
-
\
\ --II--LItr--I-----LIL,]
9999qa9
H S 5
:
5 > H
R F =-Y !2-
au)
€ F € h i -
t
h
J
Ntr
€h+6Nio s
lh '' LH : ,,l..15 r+: H=
!
o L
o ooooo
*odio
?1 ^
CHAPTER2
PRECIPITATION
- 3
5
6
'
7
8
9
Time(x 102sec) (a)
-/'?:;"
Isohyets-lines of equal rainfall depth
-"@l5 Y.s.
E [u
Ashd 1.56
I o R.H.R. i 3.50
t.e+ :.zsin.a'1t
^ 1<
1.55 upl.
N
'k '& &.1 *'uffi Dsn. 1.08
F€,,**
v
s
(b)
Figure 2.6 (a) Rainfall distribution in a convective storm June 1960, Baltimore, Maryland. (b) Isohyetal pattern, storm of SeptemberL0, 195'1, Baltimore, Maryland. O, recording rain gauge.
INPUT 2.3 DISTRIBUTION OF THE PRECIPITATION
25
2.3 DISTRIBUTION OF THE PRECIPITATION INPUT Total precipitation is distributedin numerousways.That interceptedby vegetation and treesmay be equivalentto the total precipitationinput for relatively small storms. Once interception storageis fllled. raindrops begin falling from leavesand grass, where water storedon thesesurfaceseventuallybecomesdepletedthrough evaporation. Precipitationthat reachesthe ground may take severalpaths. Some water will fill depressionsand eventually evaporate;some will infiltrate the soil. Part of the infiltrated watermay strike relatively imperviousstratanearthe soil surfaceand flow approximatelyparallel to it as interflow until an outlet is reached.Other portions may replenishsoil moisturein the upper soil zone, and someinfiltrated water may reach the groundwaterreservoirthat sustainsdry weatherstreamflow.The componentof the precipitation input that exceedsthe local infiltration rate will developa film of water on the surface(surfacedetention)until overlandflow commences.Detention depths varying from I to 1j in. for various conditions of slope and surfacetype havebeen reported.3 Overland flow ultimately reaches defined channels and becomes streamflow. Figure 2.7 ilhxtrates in a generalway the dispositionof a uniform storm input to a natural drainagebasin.Although suchan input is not to be expectedin nature,the indicated relations are representativeof actual conditions. Modifications resulting from nonuniform stormswill be discussedas they arise. In Fig. 2.7anote that the storm input is distributeduniformly over time /o at a rateequalto i (dimensionally intocomponents equalto LT '). This inputis dissected I, through lo, the sum of which is equal to I at any time r. Figure 2.7b illustratesthe manner in which infiltrated water is further subdividedinto interflow, groundwater, and soil moisture. Figure 2.7c showsthe transition from overland flow supply into strearhflow.The mechanicsof theseprocesseswill be treatedin detail in later sections. The nature of the curvespresenteddepictsthe generalrunoff process.It should be realized,however,that actual graphsof infiltration and/or other factorsversustime might appear quite different in form and relative magnitudewhen comparedwith theseillustrations becatrseof the effects of nonuniform storm patterns,antecedent conditions,and other factors. The rate and areal distribution of runoff from a drainagebasin are determined by a combination of physiographicand climatiOfactors. Important climatic factors includethe form of precipitation (rain, snow,hail), the type of precipitation (convective, orographic,cyclonic),the quantity and time distributionof the precipitation,the characterof the regionalvegetativecover,prevailingevapotranspirationcharacteristics, and the statusofthe soil moisturereservoir.Physiographicfactorsof significance includegeometricpropertiesof the drainagebasin,land-usecharacteristics,soil type, geologicstructure,and characteristicsofdrainage channels(geometry,slope,roughness,and storagecapacity). Large drainagebasinsoften react differently from smalleroneswhen subjected to a precipitationinput. This can be explainedin part by suchfactorsas geologicage, relativeimpact ofland-use practices,sizedifferential,variationsin storagecharacteristics, and other causes.Chow definesa small watershedas a drainagebasin whose
CHAPTER2
PRECIPITATION
(a/
\ I I
Soil moisture \a
Int".flot
Mechanics of surface runoff
(c)
Figure 2.7 The runoff process:(a) dispositionof precipitation, (b) componentsof infiltration, and (c) dispositionof overland flow supply.
27 PRECIPITATION 2.4 POINT characteristicsdo not filter out (1) fluctuationscharacteristicofhigh-intensity, shortduration storms;or (2) the effectsof land managementpractices.6On this basis,small basinsmay vary from lessthan an acre up to 100 mi2. A large basin is one in which channelstorageeffectively filters out the high frequenciesof imposedprecipitation and effectsof land-usepractices.
2.4 POINTPRECIPITATION Precipitation eventsare recordedby gaugesat specificlocations.The resulting data p"rmit determinationof the frequency and charactei of precipitation eventsin the vicinity of the site. Point precipitation data are used collectively to estimateareal variability ofrain and snowand are alsousedindividually for developingdesignstorm characteristicsfor small urban er other watersheds.Design storms are discussedin detail in Chapter 16. Point rainfall data are usedto deriveintensity-duration-frequencycurvessuch as those shown in Fig. 2.8. Such curves are used in the rational method for urban storm drainagedesign(Chapter 25); thek constructionis discussedin Chapter27 'ln applyingthe rational method,a rainfall intensityis usedwhich representsthe average intensity of a storm of given frequencyfor a selectedduration.The frequencychosen should reflect the economics of flood damage reduction. Frequenciesof up to 100 yearsare commonlyusedwhereresidentialareasare to be protected.For highervaluedistricts and critical facilities,up to 500 yearsor higherreturn periodsare often selected.Local conditionsand practicenormally dictatethe selectionof thesedesign criteria. (ExecutiveOrder 11988,Floodplain Management,I97 7).
\ 00-yr frequency 50-yr frequency I -20-yr frequencyf, 10-yrfrequency
\ \
t\ B. a
\
7 ,
\
\1
\
5-Yr,frequencl
tl=.t
Y
120 Duration (min)
Figure 2.8 Typical intensity-duration-frequencycurves for Baltimore, Maryland, and vicinity.
28
CHAPTER2
PRECIPITATION
Figure 2.9 Four quadrants surrounding precipitation stationA.
It is occasionallynecessaryto estimatepoint rainfall at a given location from recordedvaluesat surroundingsites.This can be doneto completemissingrecordsor to determinea representativeprecipitation to be used at the point of interest. The National WeatherServicehasdevelopeda procedurefor this which hasbeenverified on both theoreticaland empiricalbases.T Considerthat rainfall is to be calculatedfor point A in Fig. 2.9. Establisha set of axes running through A and determinethe absolutecoordinatesof the nearest surroundingpoints B, C, D, E, and F. These are recorded in columns 3 and 4 of Table 2.L The estimatedprecipitationat A is determinedas a weightedaverageof the other five points.The weightsarereciprocalsof the sumsof the squaresof AX and AY; that is, D2 : LX2 + LYz, and W : llDt. The estimatedrainfall at the point of interestis given by I (P x W)/> I{. In the specialcasewhere rainrall is known in only two adjacentquadrants(e.g.,I and II), the estimateis given asI (p x lV). This has the effect of reducing estimatesto zero as the points move from an area of TABLE 2.1 DETERMINATIONOF POINT RAINFALLFROM DATA AT NEARBY GAUGES
t1) Point
(2) Rainfall
(3) AX
(4) AY
(5) (D')
4 1 3 3
2 6 2 3 2
20 37 1,3 18 8
(6) wx103
(7) PxWx103
(in.)
B C D E F Sums
r.60 1.80 1.50 2.00 r .
7
0
?
*Note.'Estimatedprecipitation(P) at A = 567.7/334.5; P = 1.70 in.
50 27.O 76.9 55.6 125.0
,TT3
80.0 48.6 115.4 111,.2 2t2.5 567.7
_l
29 PRECIPITATION 2.5 AREAL precipitation to one with no records.This is consideredto be the most logical procedure for handlingthis unusualcase.7The estimatedresult will alwaysbe lessthan the greatestand greaterthan the smallestsurroundingprecipitation. For specialeffects suchas mountain influences,an adjustmentprocedurecan be applied.
2.5 AREALPRECIPITATION For most hydrologicanalyses,it is important to know the areal distributionof precipitation. Usually, averagedepths for representativeportions of the watershedare determinedand used for this pwpose. The most direct approachis to use the arithmetic averageof gaugedquantities.This procedureis satisfactoryif gaugesare uniformily distributedand the topographyis flat. Other commonly usedmethodsare the isohyetalmethodand the Thiessenmethod.The reliability of rainfall measuredat one gaugein representingthe averagedepth over a surroundingareais a function of (1) the distancefrom the gaugeto the centerof the representativearea,(2) the sizeof the area,(3) topography,(4) the natureofthe rainfall ofconcern (e.g.,stormeventversus For more information on meanmonthly), and (5) local stormpatterncharacteristics.8 errorsof estimation,the readershouldconsultRefs.7 and 8. Chapter27 alsocontains a discussionof areal variability of precipitation. Figures 2.10 and 2.11 illustrate how the measuredrainfall at a single gauge relatesto the averagerainfall over a watershedwith changein ( 1) the relativeposition of the gaugein the watershedand (2) the time period over which the averageis calculated.In the first caseit is clearthat the more centralthe gaugelocation,the more closely its observationswill match the averagefor a representativearea, providing that the regionis not too large.Figure 2.11 shows,not surprisingly,that areal averages
o bo o >
o >
?
€
o
o
2, *, d
a
J
9
b 9 d
1
9
n
B.E
3.=
/ k
O
l
,.1:i'j
(n 1
2
3
Storm rainfall at one gauge in inches (a)
1
2
3
Stormrainfall at one gaugein inches (b)
Figure 2.L0 Errors resultingfrom useof a singlegaugeto estimatewatershedaverage (giuge location effect, Soil ConservationService),(a) Watershedarea is 0.75 mi2 and gaugeis near the center. (b) Watershedareais 0.75 mi2 and gaugeis 4 mi outsidethe watershedboundary.
30
PRECIPITATION
CHAPTER2
d bo
o, bI) o >
6 o
2 o a
b 9
d
EE 2
a
220
5 . =
'a d
,/ 10
l
r
I
U)
v) 1
)
{
Storm rainfall at one gauge in inches
(a)
1
2
3
Stormrainfall at one gaugein inches
(b)
estimatewatershedaverage Figure 2.L1 Errors resultingfrom use of a singlegaugeto areais 5'45 mi2 and the (aiWatershed Service). ConserVation (time period effect, Soil gaugeisontheboundary.(b)Watershedareais5.45In|zandthegaugeisonthe boundarv. to conform more closely over long time periods, in this case one year, may be expected event' This suggests storm to a single guog" uu"ruge than those for an individual space and time both with tempered that the Oerlgn-of guuging networks should be considerations.
lsohyetalMethod are the isohyetal The two principal methodsfor determiningareal averagesof rainfall on interpolation based method and the Thiessenmethod. The isohyetal method is surveyingand in between gauges.It closely resemblesthe calculation of contours gauge plot the^rain to -upptng."Tf" first step in developingan isohye?1..-up is an Next' (Fig' 2'I2)' locationson a suitablemap and to reJord the rainfall amounts increselected at interpolation betweengaugesis performed and rainfall amounts connectedto form mentsare plotted.tdenticaldepthsfrom eachinterpolationare then averageof weighted the isohyets(lines of equal rainfall depth)' The areafaverageis isohyetal The isohyets' depthsbetweenisohyets,that is, the meanvaluebetweenthe over an precipitation method is the most accurateapproachfor determiningaverage topographic to attention area,but its proper oserequir#a skilled analystand careful the represenand other tactori that impact on areal variability. Figure 2. 13 illustrates tationofamajorstormeventinNorthCarolinabyanisohyetalmap.
ThiessenMethod method'In this is theThiessen Anothermethodof calculatingarealrainfallaverages ascenters' usingraingauges intopolygonalsubareas theareais subdivided procedure depth'Thiessen average areusedasweightsin estimitingthewatershed Thesubareas as shownin Fig. i.t+. fnis procedureis not suitablefor diagramsare constructed
2.5 AREAL PRECIPITATION
31
Average
precipitation for area A4 is 4.25 in.
----x------*
-*!fl1
A2 --^ 3 in'
Average preciPitation = 2 A i P i \ i for entire basin
(c)
of an isohyetalmap:(a)locateraingaugesand Figure 2.12 Construction and(c) plot isohyets' betweengauges; pdt values;(b) interpolate network is fixed mountainousareasbecauseof orographicinfluences'The Thiessen any gaugesare if io, u glu"o gaugeconfiguation, and polygonsmustbe reconstructed relocated.
AccuracY locatior\of the Irrespectiveof the methodusedfor estimatingareal precipitation,the of the estimate application of point tothe guu* orra in derivingthe estimaterelative may be distances vertical lbcattieso mustbe takeninto consideration.In mountainous are spacings horizontal gentle landscapbs, For -ft" irnpottant than horizontal ones.
32
CHAPTER 2 PRECIPITATION a . !.1 a.l - o
oo> a
I I t-
h
a ( h w t
I
i-
o 'r-r
-a)
r'.
!?+
? z
+ r Q
r E € I
f.\
o ( g 9 - 's o ( )
c R o >
sz'
\ s
g € d . a
o
o
h
c..l &
o
€
Q
-
r
c]
(f)x !-l
+i
N i 4
e-H
TH
!
Averagedepthoverentirewatershed =
+t Figure 2.14 Constructionofa Thiessendiagram:(a) connectrain gaugelocations;(b) draw perpendicularbisectors;and (c) calculate Thiessenweights l,er, ,qr, A3). (d) A completednetwork. the most important. when a precipitation gauging network is to be developed, both spacing and arrangement of gaugei must be considered.
EXAMPLE 2.1 $yen 1rrcdrainagearea of Fig. 2.r5 and the rainfall data displayedin column 3 of Table2.2, calculatethe averagerainfall over the areausing tne arithmetic mean, 1aj and (b) the Thiessenpolygonweighting system.
Figure 2.15 Thiessendiagram for Example 2.1.
34
CHAPTER2
PRECIPITATION
TABLE 2.2 DATA AND THIESSEN POLYGON FOR EXAMPLE2,1. CALCULATION (1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
GaugeNo.
"/" Area
Precip.-in
(2) x (3)
1.56
0.08
2
4
2.95
0.12
3
3
3.44
0.10
t5
2.91
0.44
ll
4.17
0.46
6
19
4.21
0.80
7
4
2.'|
0.11
8
7
2.45
0.17
9
21
3.88
0.81
10
6
3.98
0.24
ll
5
2.51
0.13
Total
100
3.45
Solution. a. Identify thosegaugesfalling within the areaboundary.They includegauges 1, 4 through 6, 8, and 9. Averagingthe valuesfor thesesix gaugesyields an estimatedmean areal rainfall of 3.20 inches. b. Followine the Thiessen method as described in Section 2.5, construct polygonsusingtrianglesto connectgaugepoints. Thesepolygonsare shown with each on Fig. 2.15. Calculatethe percentof the total area associated gaugeandrecord asin column2 of Table2.2.The Thiessenweightedaverage is obtainedby multiplying the valuesin column 2by the yaluesin column 3. The Thiessenaverageis computedas 3.45 inchesof rainfall. The use of a spreadsheet(Table 2.2) facilitates computations and aids in organizing data. lr
2.6 PROBABLEMAXIMUMPRECIPITATION The probablemaximum precipitation (PMP) is the critical depth-duration-arearainfall relation for a given areaand seasonwhich would result from a storm containing the most critical meteorologicalconditionsconsideredprobable.eSuch storm events are used in flood flow estimatesby the U.S. Corps of Engineersand other water resourcesagencies.The critical meteorologicalconditions are basedon analysesof air-mass properties(effectiveprecipitablewater,depthof inffow layer,wind, temperature, and other factors),synoptic situationsduring recorded stormsin the region, topography,season,and locationofthe area.The rainfall derivedistermedprobable maximumprecipitation sinceit is subjectto limitations of meteorologicaltheory and data and is basedon the most e_ffectiwcqmbination of factors controlling rainfall
) {) H
o q) k C)
9.'T\):
.> o
E
(.)
o
k
q
U o
N
8
o
L*
C)
- N r
,r) ri s c'l
N
F
N k
o
o o H
X
o
H g
\o ol I b0 It
q6
,/
) {) H
o q) k C)
9.'T\):
.> o
E
(.)
o
k
q
U o
N
8
o
L*
C)
- N r
,r) ri s c'l
N
F
N k
o
o o H
X
o
H g
\o ol I b0 It
q6
,/
36
CHAPTER2
PRECIPITATION 1000 800 600 400
$ zoo 9?
E
1oo
st r o9u 9 4 4 0 20 10 l0
20 30 40 50 6Q 70 80
90 100 110 120 130 140 150
Percentageof 200 miz, 24-hr values
Figure 2.17 Seasonal variation, depth-area-duration relations; percentage to be applied to 200 ni2-24 hr probable maximum precipitation values for August in Zone 6. (U.S. Department of Commerce,National WeatherService.)
intensity.eAn earlierdesignationof "maximumpossibleprecipitation" is synonymous. Additional information on PMP is given in Chapter 16. The seasonalvariation of PMP is important ip the designand operation of multipurposestructuresand in floodingconsiderationsthat may occurin combination with snowmelt. In both of these cases,annual probable maximums might be less important than seasonalmaximums.Figures2.16 and,2.r7 display24-hr pMp for the easternhalf of the United Statesfor 200-ffi2 watershedsduring the month of August (similar figuresare availablefrom the National WeatherService).
2.7 GROSSAND NETPRECIPITATION The net (excess)precipitation that contributesdirectly to surfacerunoff is equivalent to the gross precipitation minus lossesto interception, storm period evaporation, depressionstorage,and infiltration. The relation betweenexcessprecipitationP" and grossprecipitation P is thus P":P.-Ilosses
(2.2)
where the lossesinclude all deductionsfrom the grossstorm input. The paths that water precipitatedover an areamay take can be representedby flow diagramsof the type given in Fig. 1.3 and by equationsof the form ot&q. 2.i. Modelssuchastheseare the basisfor most hydrologicinvestigations,and muchbf the contentof this book is devotedto the conceptualizationof individual componentsof the various hydrologicprocessesand to synthesizingthesecomponentsinto holistic representationsof hydrologicevents.
PROBLEMS 37
r Summary precipitation is the sourceof fresh waterreplenishmentfor the planetEarth. Too much or too little canmeanthe differencebetweenprosperityand disaster.In betweenthese extremesare the normal precipitation eventsthat are experiencedwith a frequency and intensity relatedmainly to geographicposition and topographicfeatures' After reading this chaptei you should understandthat both the timing and considamountof precipitition occuiring over anareaareimportant and that thereis areal erable g"olrapttic variability in precipitation. You should be able to estimate process precipiLtiin amountsfrom gaugedata and conceptualizesimplehydrologic shed models.It shouldbe recognizedihataveragevaluesofprecipitation for a region uses, some light on the quantiiy of water that might be made availablefor various are while a i<nowledgeof tne time-aistribution and time-dispositionof precipitation requisitesfor developingmanagementplans for periods of excessand shortage' PROBLEMS 2.1.
average,estimatethe amount of rainfall for gaugeX' artdc compute the rainfall for gaugeX in Problem 2.1 if the storm readingsat A, B, 'werc respectively' 3.7,4.I, and4'8 in., 2.3. compute the meanannualprecipitationfor the watershedin the following figureusing The the arithmetic mean, the'itri"*"n polygon method, and the isohyetalmethod.
"r)
38
CHAPTER2 PRECIPITATION gaugereadingsfor gaugesA-K, respectively,are: 29.79,34.97,25.6,24.2i,24.6, 42.61,42.35,15.51,39.99,43.04,and28.41. 2.4. Computethe meanannualprecipitationfor the watershedin the figurefor Problem2.3 using the arithmetic mean and the Thiessenpolygonmethod.The gaugereadingsfor gaugesA-K, respectively,are: 28.1, 33.7, 25.6, 23.9, 24.6, 40.1, 41.3, 37.2, 38.7, 41.1,and29.3. 2.5. The chart from a rain gaugeshown in the sketchrepresentsa record that you must interpret.Find the averagerainfall intensity (rate)between6 e.r'1.and noon on August 10. Find also the total precipitation on August 10 and August 11.
d
0.30 o.25 0.20 0.15 0.10 0.05 0
Aus. l 0
/
Midnight 6 a.m.
6 p.m. Midnight 6 a.m.
Ais..I7
Noon
6 p.m. Midnight
Time
2.6. Refer to the chart of Problem 2.5. Calculate the rainfall intensity for the period between6.q..1u.and noon on August 11. Would you considerthis to be a period of intenserainfall? 2.7. Use the map of Fig. 2.6 andfrom it constructa setof Thiessenpolygons.Using these, estimatethe mean rainfall for the region. 2.8. A meandraft of 100mgd is producedfrom a drainageareaof 200 mi2.At the flow line the reservoiris estimatedto cover 4000 acres.The annualrainfall is 37 in., the mean annualrunoff is l0 in., and the mean annual lake evaporationis 30 in. Find the net gain or lossin storage.Computethe volume of water evaporated.How significantis this amount? 2.9. A meandraft of 380,000m3/dayis producedfrom a drainageareaof 330 km2.At the flow line, the reservoiris estimatedto cover about 1600hectares.The annualrainfall is 96.5 cm, the meanannualrunoff is 22.8 cm, and the meanannuallake evaporation is 77.1 cm. Find the net gain or loss in storageand compute the volume of water evaporated. Calculatevolumesin m3. 2.10. Drainage areas within each of the isohyetal lines for a storm are tabulated for a watershed.Use the isohyetal method to determinethe averageprecipitation depth within the basin for the storm. Make a conceptualsketch.
lsohyetalinterval(in.)
Area (acres)
0-2
2700 1900 1000 0
a
i
4-6 6-8
2.11. ReworkProblem2.10 if the valuesin the secondcolumn of the table are2,500, 2,100 1,200, and 300, respectively,
REFERENCES 39 2.12. Discusshow you would go about collectingdata for analysisof the water budgetof a region.What agencieswould you contact?What other sourcesof information would you seekout? 2.13. For an areaof your choice,plot the meanmonthly precipitation versustime. Explain how this fits the pattern of seasonalwater usesfor the area.Will the form of precipitation be an important consideration?
REFERENCES I
2. 3. A
5. 6. ,1
8. 9.
TennesseeValley Authority, "Heat and Mass TransferBetweena Water Surfaceand the Atmosphere,"Lab. Rep. No, 14, TVA EngineeringLab. Noiris, TN, Apr. 1972. A. L. Shands,"Mean PrecipitableWater in the United States," U.S. WeatherBureau, Tech.PaperNo. 10, 1949. R. K. Linsley, Jr., M. A. Kohler, and J. L. H. Paulhus,Applied Hydrology. New York, McGraw-Hill, 1949. D. W. Miller, J. J. Geraghty,and R. S. Collins, WaterAtlas of the United States.Port Washington,NY Water Information Center, 1963. U.S. WeatherBureau,Tech. Papers1-33. Washington,DC: U.S. GovernmentPrinting Office. Ven Te Chow (ed.), Handbook of Applied Hydrology. New York, McGraw-Hill,l9&. Staff, Hydrologic ResearchLaboratory, "National WeatherServiceRiver ForecastSystem ForecastProcedures,"NOAA Tech. Mem. NWS HYDRO 14, National Weather Service,SilverSpring,MD,Dec. 1972. V. Mockus, Sec.4, in SCSNational EngineeringHandbookon Hydrology,Washington, DC: Soil ConservationService, A:ug.1972. J. T. Riedel, J. F. Appleby, and R. W. Schloemer,"SeasonalVariation of the Probable Maximum Precipitation East of the 105th Meridian for Areas from 10 to 1000 Square Miles andDurationsof 6,12,24,and48 Hours,"Hydrometeorological Rept.No. 33, U.S. WeatherBureau,Washington,D.C., 1967.
Chapter3
Interception and Depression Storage
r Prologue The purposeof this chapteris to: . Define interception and depressionstorqge. ' Define the roles theseabstractingmechanismsplay in affectingthe amountof precipitatedwater ultimately availablefor other distribution. ' Providesomeapproachesto estimatingthe quantitiesof waterinterceptedand storedin depressionsduring precipitation events. Figure 1.3indicatesthe pathsthat precipitatedwatermay take asit reachesthe earth. The first encountersare with interceptingsurfacessuch as trees,plants, grass,and structures.Waterin excessof interceptioncapacitythen beginsto filI surfacedepressions.A film of water alsobuilds up overthe ground surface.This is known as surface detention.Once this film is of sufficientdepth, surfaceflow toward definedchannels commences,providing that the rate at which water seepsinto the ground is lessthan the rate of surfacesupply.This chapterdealswith the first two mechanismsby which the grossprecipitation input becomestransformedinto net precipitation.
3.1 INTERCEPTION Part ofthe stormprecipitationthat occursisinterceptedby vegetationandotherforms ofcover on the drainagearea.Interceptioncanbe definedasthat segmentofthe gross precipitationinput which wets and adheresto abovegroundobjectsuntil it is returned to the atmospherethrough evaporation.Precipitation striking vegetationmay be retained on leavesor blades of grass,flow down the stemsof plants and become stemflow,or fall off the leavesto becomepart of the throughfall. The modifying effect that a forest canopycan haveon rainfall intensity at the ground (the throughfall) can be put !o practical use in watershedmanagementschemes. The amountof waterinterceptedis a function of ( 1) the stormcharacter,(2) the species,age,and densityofprevailingplantsandtrees,and (3) the seasonofthe year. Usually about 10-20 percentof the precipitationthat falls during the growing season
41 3.1 INTERCEPTION is interceptedand returned to the hydrologiccycle by evaporation.Water lossesby interceptionare especiallypronouncedunderdenseclosedforest stands-as much as 25 percentof the total annualprecipitation.Schomakerhasreportedthat the average annualinterceptionlossby Douglasfir standsin westernOregonand Washingtonis about24 percent.l A lO-year-oldloblolly pine plantation in the South showedlosses on a yearlybasisof approximately14 percent,while Ponderosapine forestsin California were found to intercept abort 12 percent of the annual precipitation. Mean interception lossesof approximately 13 percent of gross summer rainfall were reported for hardwoodstandsin the White Mountainsof New Hampshire.Additional information given in Table 3.1 includes some data on interception measurements obtainedin Maine from a mature spruce-firstand, a moderatelywell-stockedwhite and gray birch stand,and an improved pasture.r Lull indicatesthat oak or aspenleavesmay retain as much as 100 drops of wdtter.zFor a well-developedtree, interception storageon the order of 0.06 in' of precipitationcould thereforebe expectedon the basisof an averageretentionof about CATCH OFSTANDARD PRECIPITATION TABLE 3,1 WEEKLYAVERAGE IN LOCATED RAINGAUGES BUREAU.WPE U,S.WEATHER A SPRUCE-FIR STAND, A HARDWOOD STAND, AND A PASTUREDURINGTHE WINTER OF 1965_1966
Measuring date'
tl/9t65 11tL6/65 ru23t65 12tr0t65" 12n7 t65 12/30t65 lt4t66 1tr2t66 U18t66 U25t66 2tr/66 2t8t66 2n1t66 2n5t66 2t21t66 3t2t66 3t7t66 3t15t66 3t29t66 Total
Weekly average precipitationcatch (in. ot equivalentrain)
Spruce-fir 0.24 1.01 1.01 1.41 0.55 0.66 0.20 0.36 Trace 0.25 1.38 0.05 0.29, 0.76 0.17 0.86 0.76 0 0.73 10.69
Birch
0.33 r.25 r.23 1.65 0.81 0.95 0.25 0.55 Trace 0.58 l.9l 0.07 0.02 0.81 0.22 l -za
0.84 0 1.13 13.83
Pasture 0.39 L45 r.36 t.79 0.87 1.08 0.26 0.61 Trace 0.59 1.96 0.06 Trace 0.98 0.22 t.45 0.97 0 1.27 15.31
Percent interception by forest cover
Spruce-fir
Birch
38 30 26 2l 37 39 23 4l
l5 l4 10 8 7 l2
58 30 l7
2
A
10
J
t6
4l 22
t7 0 I6 13
43 30.2
1l 9.5
22 ZJ
" The period betweenmeasuringdatesis 7 days,exceptwhen precipitation occurred on the seventhday. In this event, measurgmentwas postponeduntil precipitation ceased. bMeasurementswere delayeduntil a method was devisedto melt frozen precipitation on the site. 'This measurementin the spruce stand was the result of foliage drip during a thaw from previously intercepted snow. "The Effect of Forest and Pastureon the Disposition of Precipitation," Source: Aftet C, E. Schomaker, Maine Farm Res.(July 1966).
42
oHAPTER s rNrER;;-;;rr;-.r,o*
"ro*ou=
20 drops per leaf. For light showers(where gross precipitation P < 0.01 in.) 10t percentinterceptionmight occur, whereasfor showerswhereP > 0.04 in., lossesin the rangeof 10-40 percentare realistic.3 Figure 3.1 illustratesthe generaltime distribution pattern of interceptionloss intensity.Most interceptionlossdevelopsduring the initial stormperiod and the rate of interception rapidly approacheszero thereafter.l-6Potentialitorm interception lossescan be estimatedbv usins2'3,6 Zi:,S+KEt
(3.1)
where . L, : the volume of water intercepted(in.) S : the interceptionstoragethat will be retainedon the foliage againstthe forcesof wind and gravity (usuallyvariesbetween0.01 and 0.05 in.) K : the ratio of surfaceareaof interceptingleavesto horizontal projection:, of this area E : the amountof waterevaporatedper hour duringthe precipitationperiod ' (in.) : r time (hr)
i= it+i2+4+i4
Figure 3.1 Disposition of rainfall input in terms of interception, depressionstorage,infiltration, and overlandflow.
3.1 INTERCEPTION 43 Equation3.1 is basedon the assumptionthat rainfall is sufficientto fully satisfy the storageterm S. The following equationwas designedto accountfor the rainfall amountT-e L;:S(1 -e-P/s)+KEt
(3.2)
whereP : rainfall and e is the baseof natural logarithms.Note in Eqs. 3.1 and 3.2 that the storm time duration t is given in hours, while ,L,, S, and E are commonly measuredin in. or mm. It is important to recognizethat forms of vegetationother than trees can aiso interceptlarge quantitiesof water. Grasses,crops,and shrubsoften haveleaf-areato ground-arearatios that are similar to thosefor forests.Table3.2 summarizessome observationsthat havebeen madeon crops during growing seasonsand on a variety of grasses.Interceptedamountsare aboutthe sameasthosefor forests,but sincesome of thesetypes of vegetationexist only until harvest,their annualimpact on interception is generallylessthan that of forestedareas. Precipitationtype, rainfall intensityand duration,wind, and atmosphericconditions affecting evaporationare factors that serve to determineinterception losses. Snow interception,while highly visible,usually is not a major loss sincemuch of the interceptedsnowfall is eventuallytransmittedto the ground by wind action and melt. Interceptionduring rainfall eventsis commonly greaterthan for snowfall events.In both cases,wind velocity is an important factor. The importanceof interceptionin hydrologicmodelingis tied to the purposeof the model. Estimates of loss to gross precipitation through interception can be significantin annual or long-term models,but for heavy rainfalls during individual storm events,accountingfor interceptionmay be unnecessary.It is important for the modeler to assesscarefully both the time frame of the model and the volume of precipitation with which one must deal. TABLE3.2 OBSERVED PERCENTAGES OF INTERCEPTION BY VARIOUSCROPSAND GRASSES'
Vegetation type Crops Alfalfa Corn Soybeans Oats Grassesb Little bluestem Big bluestem Tall panic grass Bindweed Buffalo grass Blue grass Mixed species Natural grasses
Intercepted(%)
Comments
36 16 15 7 50-60-.1
s7 l s 7 f 17 l ) 31 17
Water applied at rate of ] in. in 30 min
Pdor to harvest
)A
t4-t9
"Valuesroundedto nearestpercent.Data for table were obtainedfrom Refs.2,4, and 5, 'Grass heightsvary up to about 36 in.
44
CHAPTER3
INTERCEPTIONAND DEPRESSIONSTORAGE
Equations3.1 and 3.2 canbe usedto estimatetotal interceptionlosses,but for detailedanalysesofindividual storins,it is necessaryto dealwith the areal variability of suchlosses.Generalequationsfor estimatingsuchlossesare not available,however. Most researchhas been related to particular speciesor experimentalplots strongly associatedwith a given locality. In addition, the lossfunction varieswith the storm's character.If adequateexperimentaldata are available,the nature of the varianceof interceptionversustime might be inferred. Otherwise,common priictice is to deduct the estimatedvolumeentirelyfrom the initial period of the storm(initial abstraction). EXAMPLE 3.1 Using the following equationsdevelopedby Horton6for interceptionby ash and oak trees, estimatethe interception loss beneaththesetrees for a storm having a total precipitationof 1.5 in. Solution 1. For ashtrees.
L ; : 0 . 0 1 5+ 0 . 2 3 P : 0.36in. : 0.015+ 0.23(1.5) 2. For oak trees,
L;:0.03+0.22P : 0.36in. rl : 0.03+ 0.22(1.5)
3.2 THROUGHFALL A numberof relationshipsfor estimatingthroughfall for a variety of foresttypeshave been developed.ntt Deiermining factors for throughfall quantities include canopy coverage,total leaf area,numberand type of layersof vegetation,wind velocity, and rainfall intensity.The arealvariability ofthesefactorsresultsin little or no throughfall in somelocationsand considerablethroughfall in others.In general,prediction equations for throughfall mustincludemeasuresof canopysurfaceareaand coverasprime variables.An example of a throughfall relationship for an easternUnited States hardwoodforest follows.l2 For the growing season T n : 0 . 9 0 1 P- 0 . O 3 l n
(3.3)
For the dormant season T n : 0 . 9 I 4 P- 0 . 0 1 5 n where ?1,: throughfall (in.) P : total precipitation (in.) n : number of storms
(3.4)
3.3
DEPRESSIONSTORAGE
45
3.3 DEPRESSION STORAGE Precipitationthat reachesthe ground may infiltrate, flow over the surface,or become trappedin numeroussmall depressionsfrom which the only escapeis evaporationor infiltration. The natureof depressions, aswell astheir size,is largely a funition of the original land form and local land-usepractices.Becauseof extremevariability in the nature of depressionsand the paucity of sufficient measurements,no generalized relation with enoughspecifiedparametersfor all casesis feasible.A rational model can, however,be suggested. Figure 3.1 illustratesthe dispositionof a precipitationinput. A studyof it shows that the tate at which depressionstorageis filled rapidly declinesafter the initiation of a precipitationevent.Ultimately, the amountof precipitation goinginto depression storagewill approachzero,given that thereis alargeenoughvolume of precipitation to exceedother lossesto surfacestoragesuch as inflltration and evaporation.Ultimately, all the water stored in depressionswill either evaporateor seep into the ground.Finally, it shouldbe understoodthat the geometryof a land surfaceis usually complex and thus depressionsvary. widely in size, degreeof interconnection,and contributingdrainagearea.In general,depressionsmay be looked upon as miniature reservoirsand as suchthey are subjectto similar analytical techniques. According to Linsley et a1.13 the volume of water storedby surfacedepressions at any given time can be approximatedusing Y:Sd(l
-e-kP")
r? 5)
where V : the volume actually in storageat sometime of interest S, : the maximum storagecapacityof the depressions P" : the rainfall excess(grossrainfall minus evaporation,interception,and infiltration) k : a constantequivalentto l/So The valueof the constantcan be determinedby consideringthat if P" : 0, essentially all the water will fill depressionsand dv/dp" will equal one. This requires that k : r/Sa. Estimatesof s, may be securedby making samplefleld measurementsof the areaunder study.Combiningsuchdata with estimatesof P" permits a determination of V. The mannerin which Vvarieswith time must still be estimatedif depression storagelossesare to be abstractedfrom the grossrainfall input. One assumptionregarding dVldt is that all depressionsmust be full before overlandflow supply begins.Actually, this would not agreewith reality unlessthe locationsof depressionswere gradedwith the largestonesoccurring downstream.If the depressionstoragewere abstractedin this manner, the total volume would be deductedfrom the initial storm period suchas shownby the shadedareain Fig.3.2. Such postulateshave been used with satisfactory results under special circumstances.ra Depressionstorageintensitycan alsobe estimatedusingEq. 3.5. If the overland flow supplyrale oplus depressionstorageintensityequali - /, wherei is the rainfall intensity reachingthe ground and/is the infiltration rate, then the ratio of overland flow supply to overlandflow plus depressionstoragesupply can be proved equal to
i - f
(3.6)
46
CHAPTER 3 INTERCEPTION ANDDEPRESSION STORAGE
o b0 o
!t o
E
d
4
8
1
2
16
20
Time (min)
Figure3.2 Simpledepression storageabstraction scheme. This expressioncan be derivedby adjudging c : i - f - o (3.7) i - f i - f and noting that o is equal to the derivativeof Eq. 3.5 with respectto time. Then )
o:fiso1t_e-kP")
(3.8)
u : (Soke-kg#
(3.e)
It was shown that k : 1/S, so that
u : ,-o'"d!" dt
(3.10)
The excessprecipitationP, equalsthe grossrainfall minus infiltrated water, and since the derivativewith respectto time canbe replacedby the equivalentintensity(i * f), the intensity of depressionstoragebecomes o:e-or.(i-f)
a
i - f
(i-f)*G-f)e-."" i - f
(3.11)
(3.r2)
o.125
o.25
0.50(turf)
0.315
Mass overlandflow and depressionstoragesupply ( P - F)
0.0625 All depressions filled before overland flow supply begins -= :\
----l
0.0938
0.125(pavements) 1.00
I
on
d
-
9)-
RO
0.80
E
l-
bl I
o "
7
n
Exponential relationship a
tl
i,t
-\
-lP-F)tS, " = -I - e I
F
I
,
i 6 0 6
o b!
OGEE sumrnationof the standardprobability curve
o
g
n5n
a
B o E
a
{ .:
-
o.7o I
-
40
6
B
9 d J U
o
o o0
s2 o
6zo
I o
!)
E
t
o
o
0
50
100
150
200
Mean depth as a percentage of overall depth of depression storage
Figure 3.3 Depth distributioncurve ofdepressionstorage.Enter graph from top, readdown to selectedcurve, and project right or left as desired.(After Tholin and Kiefer.r5) and
o
i * f
-
:(i
:
f)(I
- e-kP")
i - f |
-
g-kP"
(3.13) (3.r4)
Figure 3.3 illustratesa plot of this function versusthe massoverlandflow and depressionstoragesupply(P - F), whereF is the accumulatedmassinfiltrationl5 and
48
CHAPTER3
AND DEPRESSION STORAGE INTERCEPTION
P is the grossprecipitation.In the plot meandepthsof 0.25 in. for turf and 0.0625in. for pavementswere assumed.Maximum depthswere 0.50 and0.125in., respectively. The figure also depictsthe effect on estimatedoverlandflow supplyrate, which is derivedfrom the choiceof the depressionstoragemodel. Three modelsare shown in the figure: the flrst one assumesthat all depressionsare full before overlandflow begins.For a turf area having depressionswith a mean depth of 0.25 in., the figure showsthat for P - F valueslessthan 0.25 in., thereis no overlandflow supply,while for P - F valuesgreater than 0.25 in., the overlandflow supply is equal to i - f . For the exponentialmodel (Model 2), c alwayswill be greaterthanzero. Tholin and Kiefer haverecommendedthat a relation betweenthosepreviouslymentionedis A cumulative normal likely more representativeof fully developedurban areas.15 describedin Fig. 3.3 and is also probability curve was selectedfor this representation (Model 3). Depressionstoragedeductionsare usually madefrom the first part of the storm as illustrated in Fig. 3.2. The amount to be deductedis a function of topography, groundcover,and extentand type of land development.During major storms,this loss is often consideredto be negligible.Someguidelinesfor estimatingdepressionstorage losseshavebeen developedbasedon studiesof experimentaland other watersheds. Values for depressionstoragelossesfrom intense storms reported by Hicks are Tholin andKieferhaveused 0.20 in. for sand,0.15in. for loam,and0.10in. for c1ay.16 Studiesof in. forpavements.ls 0.0625 and valuesof 0.25 in. inpervious urban areas yielded information shownin the by Viessman four small imperviousdrainageareas This is slope. correlated with loss is highly Fig.3.4, where mean depressionstorage
0.15
I Ei
U.IU
0
1
2
3
4
Slope(70)
Figure 3.4 Depression storage loss versus slope for four impervious drainageareas.(From Viessman.ra)
PROBLEMS
49
h
oo
Antecedent rainfall during preceding 30 min o
Time (min)
Figure3.5 Depression storage intensityversustimefor animpervious area.(After Turner.l7)
easilyunderstood,sincea given depressionwill hold its maximum volumeif horizontally oriented. Using very limited data from a small, paved-streetsection, Turner devisedthe curvesshownin Fig. 3.5.17Other sourcesof datarelatedto surfacestorase are availablein the literature.2,18,1e
r Summary Accountingfor the dispositionof precipitation is an important part of the hydrologic modelingprocess.Two abstractionsfrom the precipitation input, intercepiion, and depressionstoragewere coveredin this chapter. Interception lossesduring the courseof a year may be substantial,but during intensestorms,they may be sufficiently small to neglect.Precipitationtype, rainfall intensity and duration, wind, and atmosphericconditions affeiting evaporationare factorsthat serveto determineinterceptionlossesfor a given foresi standor ground coverconfiguration.Interceptionduring rainfall eventsis commonly greaterihan for snowfall events. Depressionstoragedeductionsoccur early in a storm sequenceand they are a function of topography,ground cover, and extent and type of land development. During major storms,this loss is often consideredto be negligible.
PROBI.EMS 3.1. UsingFig. 3.2, estimatethe volume of depressionstoragefor a 3-acrepaveddrainage area' Statethe volume in cubic feet and cubic meters.Convert it to equivalentdep;h over the area in in. and cm.
50
CHAPTER3
INTERCEPTIONAND DEPRESSIONSTORAGE
3.2. Estimatethe percentageof the total volume of rainfall that is indicatedas depression storagein Fig. 3.2. 3.3. Using the averageannual precipitationfor your state,estimatethe annual amountof interceptionloss. 3.4. Refer to Fig. 2.4 and estimate the annual interception lossesin lllinois, Florida, California, and New Mexico. How good do you think theseestimatesare?In which estimatesdo you havethe most confldence?Why? In which of thesestateswould the water budgetbe most affectedby interception? 3.5. Using Fig. 3.4, estimatethe percentageof rainfall that would be lost to depression storagefor a l0-acre parking lot havinga mean slopeof 1 percent.Repeatfor a slope of 3 percent.Using the total rainfall volume determinedin Problem 3.2, estimatethe equivalentdepth over the area of the depressionstorageloss for both slopes.Stater depthsin mm and in. 3.6. Refer to Fig. 3.3 and estimatethe ratio of overlandflow supplyto overlandflow and depressionstoragesupplyif the areais turf, the OGEE summationcurve is the model, and the mean depth of depressionstorageis (a) 75 percent and (b) 125 percent. 3,7. Explain how a relation such as that given in Fig. 3.3 could be used in a simulation model of the rainfall-runoff process' 3.8. Using Eqs. 3.3 and 3.4, estimatethe throughfall in in. for 28 in. of rainfall during the growing season(21 events), and 17 in. of rainfall during the dormant season(13 events). 3.9. Using Horton's equationsgiven in Example 3.1, estimatethe interceptionlossesby ash and oak trees for a storm having a total precipitation of 1.33 in'
REFERENCES "The Effect of Forestand Pastureon the Dispositionof Precipitation," 1. C. E. Schomaker, Maine Farm Res.(July 1966). 2. ven Te chow (ed.), Handbook of Apptied Hydrology. New York: McGraw-Hill,1964. 3 . JosephKittredge, ForestInfluences.New York: McGraw-Hill' 1948. "Interception of Rainfall by HerbaceousVegetation,"Science86(2243), i + . O. n. Ctark,
59r-s92(r937).
"Resultsof the Mountain Home Rainfall Interceptionand Inflltration Project 5. J. S. Beard, on Black Wattle, 1953-1954," J. S. Afr. Foresty Assoc'27,72-85(1956)' "Rainfall Interception," Monthly WeatherRev.47,603-623(L9I9)' 6. R. E. Horton, "A Note on the InterceptionLoss Equation," J. Geoplrys.Res.65' 38507. R. A. Meriam, 1 ( 1 9 6 0 ) . 385 8. D. M. Gray (ed.),Hand.bookon the Principles of Hydrology.National ResearchCouncil, Canada,Port Washington:WaterInformation Center,Inc., 1973. 9. K. N. Brooks, P. F. Folliott, H. M. Gregersen,and J. L. Thames,Hydrology and the Managementof Watersheds.Ames, IA: Iowa StateUniversity Press/Ames,1991. "The InterceptionProcess."In Prediction in CatchmentHydrology,National 10. G. J. Blake, Symposiumon Hydrology,eds.T. G. Chapmanand F. X. Dunin, MelbourneAust. Acad. S c i . , 5 9 - 8 1 1, 9 7 5 . "Throughfall in PlantedStandsof Fourth SouthernPines 11. F. A. Roth, II, and M. Chang, Bulletin 17' 880-885(1981) Speciesin EastTexas,"WaterResources
REFERENCES 51 "canopy and Litter Interceptionby Hardwoodsof Eastern J. D. Helvey and J. H. Patric, Res.l, 193-206(1965)' Resour. United States,"Water New York: R. K. Linsley, Jr., M. A' Kohler, and J. L. H. Paulhus,Apptied Hydrology' McGraw-Hill, 1949. "A Linear Model for synthesizingHydrographsfor Small Drainage warren viessman,Jr., presented at the Forty-eighthAnnual Meetingof the AmericanGeophysical paper Areas," D.C., APr. 1967. Union, Washington, "The Hydrology of Urban Runoff," Trans. ASCE 125, A. L. Tholin una C. J. Kiefer, 1 3 0 8 -1 3 7 91( 9 6 0 ) . ..A Method of Computing Urban Runoff ,', Trans' ASCE |09, I2L,7W. I. Hicks,
Aue. 1966.
Chapter4
lnfiltration
Prologue The purposeof this chapteris to: . Defineinfiltration. ' Indicatethe role infiltration playsin affectingrunoffquantities and in replenishing soil moistureand groundwaterstorages. ' Presentmodelsfor estimatinginflltration and provide examplesof how they can be used. Infiltration is that processby which precipitation movesdownwardthrough the surface of the earth and replenishessoil moisture, rechargesaquifers,and ultimately supportsstreamflowsduring dry periods.Along with interception,depressionstorage, and stormperiodevaporation,it determinesthe availability,if any,of the precipitation input for generatingoverland flows (Fig. 1.3). Furthermore,infiltration rates influence the timing of overland flow inputs to channelizedsystems.Accordingly, infiltration is an important componentof any hydrologicmodel. The ratef at which infiltration occursis influencedby suchfactorsas the type and extent of vegetalcover, the condition of the surfacecrust, temperature,rainfall intensity,physicalpropertiesof the soil, and water quality. The rate at which wateris transmittedthrough the surfacelayeris highly dependent on the condition of the surface.For example,inwashof fine materialsmay seal the surfaceso that infiltration ratesare low evenwhen the underlyingsoils are highly permeable.After water crossesthe surfaceinterface,its rate of downwardmovement is controlled by the transmissioncharacteristicsof the underlying soil profile. The volume of storageavailablebelow ground is also a factor affecting infiltration rates. Considerableresearchon infiltration hastakenplace,but consideringthe infinite combinationsof soil and other factors existing in nature, no perfectly quantified generalrelation exists.
OF INFILTRATION 53 4.2 CALCULATION
4.1 MEASURING INFILTRATION
.
Commonly usedmethodsfor determininginfiltration capacityare hydrographanalysesandinfiltrometer studies.Infiltrometersareusuallyclassifiedasrainfall simulators or flooding devices.In the former, arlificalrainfall is simulatedover a small test plot and the inhltration calculatedfrom observationsofrainfall andrunoff, with consideration given to depressionstorageand surfacedetention.lFlooding infiltrometers are usually rings or iubes insertedin the ground. Water is applied and maintainedat a constantlevel and observationsmade of the rate of replenishmentrequired' Estimatesof infiltration basedon hydrographanalyseshavethe advantageover infiltrometers of relating more directly to prevailing conditions of precipitation and field. However,they areno betterthan the precisionwith which rainfall andrunoff are measured.Of partitular importancein suchstudiesis the areal variability of rainfall. Several meth;ds have been developedand are in use. Reference1 gives a good descriptionof thesemethods.
OF INFILTRATION 4.2 CALCULATION Infiltration calculationsvary in sophisticationfrom the applicationof reported averageratesfor specificsoil types and vegetalcoversto the useof differential equations g6verningthe flow of wateiin unsaturatedporousmedia.For small urban areasthat iespondiapidly to storm input, more precisemethodsare sometimeswarranted'On large waterlhedssubjectto peak flow production from prolongedstorms,averageor representativevaluesmay be adequate. The infiltration pto"".r is -omplicated at best. Even under ideal conditions (uniform soil propertiei andknown fluid properties),conditionsrarely encounteredin practice,the processis difflcult to characterize.Accordingly,therehasbeenconsiderabtestudyof the infiltration process.Most of theseeffortshaverelatedto the development of i1) empirical equationsbasedon field observationsand (2) the solution of equationsbasedon the mechanicsof saturatedflow in porous media.l'2 Later in this chapter,severalcommonly usedinfiltration modelsare discussed. As a prefaceto that discussion,a brief descriptionof the infiltration processfollows' It reviews the principal factors affecting infiltration and points out some of the problemsencounteredby hydrologicmodelers. Webeginour discussionwith an idealcase,onein which the soil is homogeneous throughout the profile and all the pores are directly interconnectedby capillary purru!"r. Furtheimore,it is assumedthat the rainfall is uniformly distributedovef the ur"u of "on"ern. Undertheseconditions,the infiltration processmay be chatactetized as one dimensional and the major influencing factors are therefore soil type and moisturecontent.3 through which The soil type characterizesthe sizeand numberof the passages and relative potential capillary the sets content moisture the the watermustflow while capillary to due head hydraulic the is potential Capillary conductivity of the soil. sign. opposite with potential but capillary as same is the forces. capillary suction
54
CHAPTER4
INFILTRATION
9 aoo
4
Ei o
. 300 -. d
d
t
2oo
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
Moisture content, 0 (vol/vol)
Figure 4.1 Typical capillary suction-relativeconductivity-moisture contentrelation.(AfterMein andLarson.e.) Capillary conductivity is the volume rate of flow of water through the soil under a gradient of unity (dependenton soil moisture content). Relative conductivity is the capillary conductivity for a specifiedmoisturecontent divided by the saturatedconductivity. Figure 4.1 illustratesthe relations amongthesevariables.Note that at low moisturecontents,capillary suctionis high while relative conductivityis low. At high moisture contentsthe reverseis true. With this background,an infiltration event can be examined.Consider that rainfall is occurringon an initially dry soil. As shownin Fig. 4.l,the relative conductivity is low at the outsetdue to the low soil moistureconditions.Thus, for the water to move downwardthrough the soil, a higher moisture level is needed.As moisture builds up, a wetting front forms with the moisturecontentbehindthe front beinghigh (essentiallysaturated)and that aheadof the front being low. At the wetting front, the capillary suctionis high due to the low moisture content aheadof the front. At the beginning of a rainfall event, the potential gradient that drives soil moisture movementis high becausethe wetting front is virtually at the soil surface. Initially, the infiltration capacity is higher than the rainfall rate and thus the infiltration rate cannot exceedthe rainfall rate. As time advancesand more water entersthe soil, the wetting zone dimensionincreasesand the potential gradient is reduced.Infiltration capacitydecreases until it equalsthe rainfall rate. This occursat the time the soil at the land surfacebecomessaturated.Figures4.2 and4.3 illustrate
l
4.2
CALCULATIONOF INFILTRATION
55
Moisturecontent.d
d
B
a
I with a constantrainfall Figure4.2 Typicalmoistureproflledevelopment rate. these conditions. Figure 4.2 showshow a moisture profile might developwhen a rainstormofconstant intensityoccurs.In the diagramthe soil moistureat the surface is shownto rangefrom its initial value at the top left to its saturatedvalue at the top right. Thus in moving downwardon the left-handside of the diagram,one can trace the downward progressionof the wetting front for varying levels of soil moisture
92
::
Time,r Figure 4.3 Infiltration rate versustime for a given rainfall intensity.(After Mein and Larson.e)
56
CHAPTER4
INFILTRATION
contentat the land surface.Figure 4.3 indicatesthat until saturationis reachedat the surface,the infiltration rate is constantand equalto the rainfall applicationrate at the surface.At Point 4, apoint that coriespondsto the time at which saturationoccursat the surface,the infiltration rate beginsto proceedat its capacity rate, the maximum rate at which the soil can transmit water acrossits surface.As time goes on, the infiltration capacity continues to decline until it becomesequal to the saturated conductivity of the soil, the capillary conductivity when the soil is saturated.This ultimate infiltration rate is shown by the dashedline to the right of K" in Fig. 4.3. Of particular interest is the determinationof Point 4 on the curve of Fig. 4.3. This is the point at which runoff would beginfor the conditions specifiedabove.It is also the point at which the actual infiltration rate/becomes equal to the infiltration capacityratefo ratherthan the rainfall intensityrate i. The time of occurrenceof this point depends,for a given soil type, on the initial moisture content and the rainfall rate. The shapeof the infiltration curve after this point in time is also influencedby thesefactors. Another factor that must be reckonedwith in the infiltration processis that of hysteresis. In Fig. 4.1 it can be seenthat the plot of capillary suctionversussoil moistureis a loop. The curve is not the samefor wetting and drying of the soil. The curves shown on the figure are the boundary wetting and boundary drying curves, curves applicableunder conditions of continuouswetting or drying. Betweenthese curves, an infinite number of possiblepaths exist that dependon the wetting and drying history of the soil. A numberof approachesto the hysteresisproblemhavebeen reportedin the literature.3 The illustration of the infiltration processpresentedwas basedon an ideal soil. Unfortunately,suchconditionsare not replicatedin natural systems.Natural soils are highly variable in composition within regions and soil cover conditions are also far-ranging. Becauseof this, no simpleinfiltration model can accuratelyportray all the conditionsencounteredin the fleld. The searchhas thus beenfor modelsthat can be called upon to give acceptableestimatesof the rates at which infiltration occurs durine rainfall events. Mein and Larson have describedthree generalcasesof infiltration associated with rainfall.3The first caseis one in which the rainfall rate is lessthan the saturated conductivity of the soil. Under this condition, shownas (4) in Fig. 4.4, runoff never occurs since all the rainfall infiltrates the soil surface.Nevertheless,this condition mustbe recognizedin continuoussimulationprocessessincethe level of soil moisture is affectedeven though runoff doesnot occur. The secondcaseis one in which the rainfall rate exceedsthe saturatedconductivity but is lessthan the infiltration capacity. Curves(I), (2), and (3) of Fig. 4.4 illustratethis condition.It shouldbe observed that the period from the beginningof rainfall to the time of surfacesaturationvaries with the rainfall intensity.The final caseis one in which the rainfall intensityexceeds the infiltration capacity.This condition is illustratedby the infiltration capacitycurve of Fig. 4.5 andthoseportionsof infiltration curves(l), (2), and (3) of Fig. 4.4 that are in their declining stages.Only under this condition can runoff occur. All three caseshaverelevanceto hydrologicmodeling,particularly when it is continuousover time.
4.3
tsal,
tsatt
HORTON'SINFILTRATIONMODEL
57
tsat,
Time, t
Figure 4.4 Inflltration curves for several rainfall intensities.(After Mein and Larson.e)
fo: f"+ Ao-f")"u' Infiltration capacitY curve
f, 0
o
,r*"
Figure 4.5 Horton's infiltration curve and hyetograph.
MODEL INFILTRATION .I3 HORTON'S The inflltration processwas thoroughly studiedby Horton in the early 1930s.oAn outgrowth of his work, shown graphically in Fig. 4.1, was the following relation for determininginfiltration capacity: (+.r; fo: f, + ("fr f")e'n'
58
CHAPTER4
INFILTRATION
where fo : k : f" : ,fo :
the infiltration capacity(depth/time) at sometime / a constantrepresentingthe rate of decreaseinf capacity d final or equilibrium capacity the initial infiltration capacity
It indicatesthat if the rainfall supply exceedsthe infiltration capacity,infiltration tendsto decreasein an exponentialmanner.Although simplein form, difficulties in determininguseful valuesfor/. and fr restrict the useofthis equation.The areaunder the curve for any time interval representsthe depth of water infiltrated during that interval. The infiltration rate is usually given in inches per hour and the time r in minutes,althoughother time incrementsare usedand the coefficientk is determined accordingly. By observingthe variation of inflltration with time and developingplots of / versus/ asshownin Fig. 4.5,we canestimatefsandft. Two setsof/and / are selected from the curve and enteredin Eq. 4.1. Two equationshavingtwo unknownsare thus obtained;they can be solvedby successiveapproximationsforfi and k. Typical infiltration ratesat the end of t hr ( f) areshownin Table4.1. A typical relation betweenf, and the infiltration rate throughout a rainfall period is shown graphically in Fig. 4.6a; Fig.4.6h showsan infiltration capacity curve for normal antecedentconditionson turf. The data given in Table4.1 are for aturf areaand must be multiplied by a suitablecover factor for other types of cover complexes.A range of cover factorsis listed inTable 4.2. Total volumes of inflltration and other abstractionsfrom a given recorded rainfall are obtainablefrom a dischargehydrograph(plot of the streamflowrate versus time) if one is available.Separationof the base flow (dry weather flow) from the dischargehydrographresultsin a direct runoff hydrograph(DRH), which accountsfor the direct surfacerunoff. that is. rainfall less abstractions.Direct surfacerunoff or precipitation excessin inchesuniformly distributedover a watershedcan readily be calculatedby picking valuesof DRH dischargeat equal time incrementsthrough the hydrographand applyingthe formulas P": where P" : 4r : A : r?7:
(0.0371e)() q')
( a) \
Ano
precipitation excess(in.) DRH ordinatesat equal time intervals (cfs) drainagearea(mi2) hurrber of time intervalsin a 24-hr period
For most casesthe differencebetweenthe original rainfall and the direct runoff can be consideredas infiltrated water. Exceptionsmay occur in areasof excessive subsurfacedrainageor tracts of intensiveinterceptionpotential.The calculatedvalue of infiltration can then be assumedasdistributedaccordingto an equationof the form of Eq. 4.1 or it may be uniformly spreadover the stormperiod. Choiceof the method employeddependson the accuracyrequirementsand size of the watershed. To circumvent some of the problems associatedwith the use of Horton's infiltration model,someadjustmentscanbe made.6ConsiderFig. 4.5. Notethat where the infiltration capacitycurve is abovethe hyetograph,the actual rate of infiltration
MODEL 4.3 HORTON'SINFILTRATION
h
o - 1
q
1
1.0 Time (hr) (a)
d
h
U
3.0 2.8
-TT
2.O
-
2.4 2.2 2.0 1.8 1.6 t.4 7.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2
I
,4 f=0.53+2.4
l
l
l
0691ty
l, = U.UUUUJTIu . ) 9 ( l
l
e fle rOa"
9l
r\$4"
o\
rras!
-iro$dts"
l
l
l
l
l
l
Infiltration capacity curve (/.
0 10
70 80
100
t20
140
160
t80
Time (min) from beginning of infiltration capacity cuve' t/ (b)
Figure 4.6 (a) Typical infiltration curve. (b) Infiltration capacity and mass curvesfor normal antecedentconditionsof turf areas.fAfter A. L. Tholin and "The Hydrology of Urban Runoff," Proc. ASCE J. Sanitary Clint J. Kiefer, Ens. Div. S4(SA2),56 (Mar. 1959).1
59
60
CHAPTER4
INFILTRATION
TABLE 4.1 ryPICAL f, VALUES
Soilgroup
f, (in./hr)
0.50-1.00 0.10-0.50 0.01-0.10
High (sandysoils) Intermediate(loaps, clay, silt) Low (clays,clay loam)
f' (mm/h)
t2.50-25.00 2.so-r2.50 0.25-2.50
Source: After ASCE Manual of Engineering Practice,No.28.
TABLE4,2 COVERFACTORS Cover
Cover fac{or
Permanentforest and grass
Good(1 in. humus) Medium(f-1 in. humus; Poor(< j in. humus)
Close-growingcrops
Good Medium Poor Good Medium Poor
Row crops
3.0-7.5 2.0-3.0 1.2-1.4 2.5-3.0 t.6-2.0 1.11 - .3 1 . 3 -1 . 5 1.1-1 3 1 . 0 -1 . 1
Source: After ASCE Manual of Engineering Practice, No.2t.
is equal to that of the rainfall intensity, adjustedfor interception,evaporation,and other losses.Consequently,the actuafinfiltration is given by
f(t) : minlfof), i(t)l
(4.3)
where/(r) is the actual infiltration into the soil and i(l) is the rainfall intensity.Thus the infiltration rate at any time is equal to the lesserof the infiltration capacity,f,(t) or the rainfall intensity. Commonly,the typical valuesof foandf" are greaterthan the prevailingrainfall intensitiesduring a storm. Thus, when Eq.4.l is solvedforS as a function of time alone, it shpwsa decreasein infiltration capacity even when rainfall intensitiesare much lessthanfo. Accordingly,a reductionin infiltration capacityis maderegardless of the amount of water that entersthe soil. To adjust for this deficiency,the integratedform of Horton's equationmay be used,
F(tp):
lr'' ,
o, : f,tp +
(t - a' *,,1
(4.4)
whereF is the cumulativeinfiltration at time to, as shownin Fig. 4.7.rnthe figure, it is assumedthat the actual infiltration has been equal to$. As previouslynoted, this is not usually the case,and the tnie cumulativeinfiltration must be determined.This
MODEL 4.3 HORTON'SINFILTRATION
0 0
61
tptpt tl Equivalent time
Figure4.7 Cumulativeinfiltration. can be done using F\t) :
l,',u,o,
(4.s)
where/(r) is determinedusingF,q.4.3. Equations4.4 and4.5 may be us6djointly to calculatethe time t, that is, the equivalent time for the actual infiltrated volume to equal the volume under the infiltration capacity curve (Fig. 4.7). The actual accumulatedinfiltration given by Eq. 4.5 is equatedto the area under the Horton curve, F,q. 4.4, and the resulting expressionis solvedfor r' This equation, F:fJrt
(l-e-k'n)
(4.6)
cannotbe solvedexplicitly for to,but an iterativesolutioncan be obtained.It should be understoodthat the time to is lessthan or equal to the actual elapsedtime r. Thus the availableinfiltration capacityas shownin Fig. 4.7 is equalto or exceedsthat given described,fbecomesa functionof the actual by Eq. 4.1. By makingthe adjustments amount of water infiltrated and not just a variable with time as is assumedin the original Horton equation. In selectinga model for use in inflltration calculations,it is important to know its limitations. In somecasesa model can be adjustedto accommodateshortcomings; are not realisticfor the natureof the useproposed, in othercases,if its assumptions the model shouldbe discardedin favor of anotherthat better fits the situation. Part One of this book deals with the principal componentsof the hydrologic cycle. In later chapters,the emphasisis on putting these componentstogetherin
62
CHAPTER4
INFILTRATION
varioushydrolqgicmodelingprocesses.When thesemodelsare designedfor continuous simulation,the approachis to calculatethe appropriatecomponentsof the hydrologic equation,Eq. 1.4, continuouslyovertime. A discussionof how infiltration could be incorporatedinto a simulation model follows. It exemplifiesthe use of Horton's equationin a storm water managementmodel (SWMM)." First, an initial value of /o is determined.Then, consideringthat the value of$ dependson the actualamountof infiltration that hasoccurredup to that time, a value of the averageinfiltration capacity,fo, availableover the next time stepis calculated using
f o : * 1 " = ' *fo' o' ' : l W
(4.7)
-tp
Equation 4.3 is then usedto find the averagerate of infiltration, /.
'v - [f, tt
iti >1, iri
(4.8)
where i is the averagerainfall intensity over the time step. Following this, infiltration is incrementedusing the expression F(t + Lt) : F(t) * AF : F(t) + f Lt
(4.e)
whereAF : f Lt is the addedcumulativeinfiltration (Fig.4.7). The next stepis to find a new valueof ro.This is doneusingEq. 4.6.If LF : f o Lt, tp : to t Ar. But if the new /oris lessthanto + A/ (seeFig. 4.7),Eq. 4.6 must be solvedby iteration for the new value of lo. This can be accomplishedusing the Newton-Raphsonprocedure.6 When the valueof tp > I6f k, the Horton curve is approximatelyhorizontal and : f". Once this point hasbeenreached,there is no further needfor iteration since fo and equal to f" and no longerdependenton F. is constant f EXAMPLE 4.I
Givenan initial inflltrationcapacityfiof 3.0 in./hr anda time constantft of 0.29hr-', derive an infiltration capacity vs. time curve if the ultimate infiltration capacity is 0.55 in./hr. For the first ten hours, estimatethe total volume of water infiltrated in inchesover the watershed. Solution. Using Horton's equation(4.1), valuesof infiltration can be computed for various times. The equationis as follows: f : f" + Lfo + f")e-k, Substitutingthe appropriatevaluesinto the equationyields ,f = 0.55 + (3.0 0.55)s-o'zo' Table4.3, valuesof f atecomputedand Then for the times shownin spreadsheet enteredinto the table. Using the spreadsheetgraphics package,the curve of Fig. 4.8 is derived,
4,3 HORTON'SINFILTRATIONMODEL
63
TABLE 4.3 CALCULATIONSFOR EXAMPLE4.1
lnfiltration (in./h0
Time (hr)
Time (hr)
lnfiltration (in./hr)
0.00
3.00
5.00
t.l2
0.10
2.93
6.00
0.98
0.25
2.83
7.00
0.87
0.50
2.67
8.00
0.79
1.00
2.38
9.00
0.73
2.00
t.92
10.00
0.68
3.00
1.58
15.00
0.58
4.00
r.32
20.00
0.56
4.1 can To find the volumeof waterinfiltrated duringthe flrst 10hours,Eq' be integratedover the range of 0-10 v :
I J
[0.5s + (3.0 0.55)e-o2e' ldt
[0.55/ + (2.45I-0.29)e-o2s\o : 12.47in' V
Y:
The volume in inchesover the watershedis thus 12'47 in'
ll
3.0
\ ;
2.0
6 .:
15
l?
-\-\
1.0
"'-0 0.5
2
4
6
L 8
10
Time (hr) Figure 4.8
GraPh for ExamPle 4'1.
12
t4
18
64 4.4
CHAPTER4
INFILTRATION
MODEL GREEN-AMPT The Green-Ampt infiltration model,originallyproposedin 1911,has had a resurgenceof inte1gs1.3'6-1t This approachis basedon Darcy's law (seeChapter18).In its original form, it was intendedfor use where infiltration resultedfrom an excessof water at the ground surfaceat all times. In 1973, Mein and Larson presenteda methodologyfor applying the Green-Ampt model to a steadyrainfall input.eThey alsodevelopeda procedurefor determiningthe valueof the capillary suctionparameter usedin the model. In 1978,Chu demonstratedthe applicability of the model for useunder conditionsof unsteadyrainfall.lo As a result of theseand other efforts, the Green-Ampt model is now employedas an option in such widely used continuous simulation modelsas SWMM.6 The original formulation by Greenand Ampt assumedthat the soil surfacewas coveredby ponded water of negligible depth and that the water infiltrated a deep homogenoussoil with a uniform initial watercontent(seeFig. 4.9). Wateris assumed to enter the soil so as to define sharply a wetting front separatingthe wetted and unwettedregions as shown in the figure. If the conductivity in the wetted zone is definedas K", applicationof Darcy's law yields the equation
"
Io:
K"(r + s) r
(4.10)
where I is the distancefrom the ground surfaceto the wetting front and S is the capillary suction at the wetting front. Referringto Fig. 4.9, it can be seenthat the cumulativeinfiltration F is equivalentto the product of the depth to the wetting front L and the initial moisture deficit, 0, - 0, : IMD. Making these substitutionsin
Ponded depth considerednegligible
I Ho
I
I
I
II
I
Figure 4.9 Definition sketch for GreenAmpt model.
4.4 GREEN-AMPTMODEL
65
Eq. 4.10 and rearranging,we obtain - , \ -, f- : -K.( rp
*
t * jt' ) F
(4.11) /
Considering thatfp : dFldt. we can state
#: *,(t.'#)
(4.r2)
: 0 at t : 0' we obtain Integratingand substitutingthe conditionsthat F
+ I MD X {) : K.t
F - S x I M D X l o g " ({ IMD
X
s
(4.r3)
This form of the Green-Ampt equationis more convenientfor usein watershed than Eq. 4.l}beciuse it relatesthe cumulativeinfiltrationto the modelingprocesses ponded time at which infiltration began.The derivation of this equation assumesa at all capacity infiltration to the equal surfaceso that the actualrate of infiltration is a time, any at infiltration cumulative times.Using Eq. 4.13, we can determinethe equation the in parameters the All featuredesiiablefor continuoussystemsmodeling. are physicalpropertiesof the soil-water systemand are measurable.The determinaparticution of suitablevaluesfor the capillary suctions is often difficult, however, It can be 4.10. Fig. in soil larly for relationssuchas that ihown for a clay-type capillary of variation wide is a there observedfrom the figure that for this curve suctionwith soil moisturecontent.3 The Mein-Larson formulation using the Green-Ampt model incorporatestwo The first stagedealswith prediction of the volume of water that infiltrates stages.3,6 before the surfacebecomessaturated.The secondstageis one in which infiltration water capacityis calculatedusingthe Green-Ampt equation.In the widely usedstorm the of one is infiltration of model ,nunug"*"nt model, the irodif,ed Green-Ampt using made are Computations optiois that can be employedto estimateinfiltration.6
v)
U
Moisture content,0
Figure 4.10 Capillary suction versus moisture contentcurves.
66
CHAPTER4
INFILTRATION
the following equations:for F ( F,(f : i),
F. :7:
IM?
i/K" - |
rori > K"
\4.r4)
and thereis no calculationof F"for i < K"; for F > F,(f : fi):
*\ ' f,: x,(t where
t * j") F
l
(4.11)
f : fo: I : F : { :
acttal infiltration rate (ftlsec) infiltration capacity(ftlsec) rainfall intensity (ftlsec) cumulativeinfiltration volume in the event (ft) cumulative infiltration volume required to causesurfacesaturation (f0 S : averagecapillary suctionat the wetting front (ft of water) IMD : initial moisture deficit for the event (ftlft) K" : saturatedhydraulic conductivity of soil (ftlsec)
Equation 4.10 showsthat the volume of rainfall neededto saturatethe surface is a function of the rainfall intensity.In the modelingprocess,for eachtime stepfor which I ) K", the value of d is computedand comparedwith the volumeof rainfall infiltrated to that time. If F equalsor exceeds{, the surfacesaturatesand calculations for infiltrationthenproceedusingEq.4.I4. Notethat by substituting/fori in Eq.4.l4 and rearranging,the equationtakesthe sameform as Eq. 4.11. For rainfall intensitieslessthan or equal to K", all the rainfall infiltrates and its amount is used olly to update the initial moisture deficit, IMD.6 The cumulative infiltration volume {" is not altered. After saturationis achievedat the surface,Bq.4.l1 showsthat the infiltration capacityis a function of the infiltrated volume,and thus of the infiltration ratesduring previous time steps.To avoid making numerical errors over long time steps,the integratedform of the Green-Ampt equation(Eq. .B) is used.This equationtakes the following form as it is usedin SWMM: (4.15) &Gr- tr): Fz- Cln (F2+ C) - Fr* Cln(F1+ C) where C : IMD X .t (ft of water) / : times (sec) 1,2 : subscriptsindicating the starting and ending of the time steps.
-
Equation4.15 mustbe solvediteratively for F2,the cumulativeinfiltration at the end of the time step.A Newton-Raphsonroutine is used.6 In the SWMM model, infiltration during time step tz - tt is equal to (t, - tr)i if the surfaceis not saturatedand is equal to F, - F, if saturationhas previously occurred and there is a sufficient water supply at the surface.If saturationoccurs during an interval, the infiltrated volumesover each stageof the processwithin the time stepsare computedand summed.When the rainfall endsor becomeslessthan
MODEL 4.5 HUGGINS_MONK
67
theinfiltrationcapacity,anypondedwaterisallowedtoinfiltrateandisaddedtothe cumulative inflltration volume'
MODEL 4.5 HUGGINS-MONKE problemby introducing thetimedependency havecircumvented Severalinvestigators by the followingequationproposed soilmoistureas the depenO"niuutluUfe.2'10-13 HugginsandMonkeis an examPle:2
f : f,*A(
I
(4.16)
coefficients layer (Q ,,orug" potential of a soil overlying the impeding minus antecedentmoisture) F _ the total volume of water that infiltrates impeding stratum T o = the total porosity of soil lying over the sprinkling infiltrometer studies'The The coefficientsare determinedusing data from in the iteration process'At the variableF mustbe catculatedfor eachtime increment
where AandP:
s - itr"
exceedsthe inflltration capacity,the rate zone," which determinesthe soil moistu (1) wherethe moist evaluatedasfollows:10 the field capacity(amountof waterheld in drained),the drainagerate is consideredz to the infiltration rate when the soil is s constan| and (3) if the watercontentis be drainagerate is comPutedas
rate: ,"(t - 2)' drainage
(4.r7)
where P, : the unsaturatedpore volume G:maximumgravitationalwater,thatis,thetotalporosityminusthefield caPacitY Datafromsprinklinginfiltrometerstudiesofvariouswatershedsofinterestare usedto estimatethe coefficientsin Eq' 4'16''
5.6
EVAPOTRANSPIRATION
101
of a masstransferequationthat has often been employedfor this purpose.However, Linsley and co-workers indicate that there is some question as to the adequate The equation is verification of this model to estimate evapotranspirationlosses.27 expressed as 833x2(e1
^ E : @
E : K: €1,€2 : Vr, Vz : Z =
er)(V,
V,)
(s.2s)
evaporation(in./hr) von K6rm6n's constant(0.4) vaporpressures(in. Hg) wind speeds(mph) the mean temperature("F) of the layer betweenthe lower level zt and the upper level z2
It is assumedin Eq. 5.25 that the atmosphereis adiabatic and the wind speedand moistureare distributedlogarithmically in a vertical direction. In view of the sm4ll differencesbetweenwind and vapor pressureto be expectedat two levelsso closely spaced,and sincethesegradientsare directly relatedto the sought-afterevaporation, highly exactinginstrumentationis required to get reliable results.
PotentialEvapotranspiration "the waterlosswhich will occur Thornthwaitedeflnedpotential evapotranspirationas if at no time there is a deficiencyof water in the soil for the use of vegetation."In a practical sense,however,most investigatorshave assumedthat potential evapotranspiration is equal to lake evaporationas determinedfrom National WeatherService ClassA pan records.This is not theoreticallycorrect becausethe albedo(amountof incoming radiation reflectedback to the atmosphere)of vegetatedareas and soils rangesas high as 45 percent.28As a result, potential evapotranspirationshould be somewhatlessthan free water surfaceevaporation.Errors in estimatingfree water evapotranspirationfrom pan recordsare such,however,asto make an adjustmentfor potential evapotranspirationof questionablevalue. An equationfor estimatingpotential evapotranspirationdevelopedby the Agricultural ResearchService (ARS) illustratesefforts to include vegetalcharacteristics and soil moisturein sucha calculation.The evapotranspirationpotentialfor any given day is determinedas follows:2e
E T : G I x k ux , " ( # l where
(s.26)
ET : evapotranspirationpotential (in./day) GI : growth index of crop in percentageof maturity K : ratio of G1 to pan evaporation,usually 1.0-I.2 for short grasses' 1,.2-L6 for cropsup to shoulderheight,and 1'6-2.0 for forest Eo: pan evaporation(in./day) ,S: total porosity SA : availableporosity (unfilled by water) AWC : porosity drainableonly by evapotranspiration x : AWC/G (G : moisture freely drainedby gravity)
102
CHAPTER5
EVAPORATIONAND TRANSPIRATION
0.2 0.1 ,.} 0.0
ti
>
n ,
0.1
J
J
Months (b)
Figure 5.5 Averagedaily consumptionof water: (a) for year 1953 by corn, followed by winter wheat under irrigation; (b) for year 1955, with irrigated first-year freadow of alfalfa, red clover, and timothy. Both measurements taken on lysimeterY 102 C at the Soil and Water ConservationResearchStation. Coshocton.Ohio. (After Holtan et al.2e)
l x F rrllS N I
]l{
tl rH
0
8
1
6
2
r
'
.
3
2
4
0
4
8
Weeks
Figure 5.6 Growth index GI = ETfET^,, from lysimeterrecords,irrigatedcorn,andhayfor 1955,from Coshocton, Ohio.(AfterHoltanet al.2e)
5.7
ESTIMATINGEVAPOTRANSPIRATION 103
TABLE 5.5 HYDROLOGICCAPACITIESOF SOIL TEXTURECLASSES
sa
GD
Textureclass
(v")
(Y")
Coarsesand Coarsesandy loam Sand Loamy sand Loamy fine sand Sandyloam Fine sandy loam Very fine sandy loam Loam Silt loam Sandy clay loam Clay loam Silty clay loam Sandy clay Silty clay Clay
24.4 24.5 32.3 37.0 32.6 30.9 36.6 32.7 30.0
t'7.7 15.8 19.0 26.9 27.2 18.6 23.5 21.0 14.4 11.4 13.4 13.0 8.4 rl.6
JI,J
25.3 25.7 z5-J
19.4 z l.+
o 1
18.8
7.3
AWC" ('/")
x AWC/G
6.7 8.7 13.3 10.1 5.4 t2.3 13.1 11.7 15.6 19.9 tr.9 12.7 t4.9 7.8 12.3 11 . 5
0.38 0.55 0.70 0.38 0.20 0.66 0.56 0.56 1.08 1.74 0.89 0.98 r.77 0.6'l r.34 r.58
aS = total porosity - 15 bar moisture 7o' bG : total porosity - 0.3 bar moisture 7o. "AWC: S - G. "Land Capability: A Hydrologic ResponseUnit in Source: Adaptedfrom C. B. England, U.SlDepartmentof Agriculture,ARS 41-172' Sept' 1970' Asiicultural'Watersheds," Aiter H. N. Holtan et a1.2e
The GI curveshave been develoPed evapotranspirationfor severalcrops (Fig. : daily rate(Fig. 5.6).Equation5.26is used USDAHL-74 model of watershedhydrolq late daily evapotranspiration.Represental Table5.5.
EVAPOTRANSPIRATION 5.7 ESTIMATING Transpirationis an important componentin the hydrologicbudgetof vegetatedareas, but it is a difficult quantity to measurebecauseof its dependenceon phytological variables.It is a function of the number and types of plants, soil moisture and soil type, qeason,temperature,and averageannual precipitation. As noted previously, evaporationand tianspiration are commonly estimatedin their combinedevapotranform. spiration ' If the precipitation and net runoff for an atea ate known, and estimatesof of ET canbe had using groundwateiflow and storagecan be made,rough estimatesihe basic hydrologicequatiJn,Eq. 1.1. A more sophisticatedapproachdevelopedby peaman foilows.t3It iJ representativeof the methodsmost often used'
104
CHAPTER 5 EVAPORATION ANDTRANSPIRATION
The PenmanMethod Both the energybudgetand masstransportmethodsfor estimatingevapotranspiration (ET)have limitations dueto the difficulties encounteredin estimatingparametersand in making other required assumptions.To circumventsomeof theseproblems,penman developeda method to combinethe masstransport and energybudgettheories. This widely usedmethodis one of the more reliableapproachesto estimatingETrates usingclimaticdata.13'rs'23,30 The Penmanequationis of the form of Eq. 5.18; it is theoreticallybasedand showsthat EZ is directly related to the quantity of radiative energy gained by the exposedsurface.In its simplified form, the Penmanequationisls t s t : -
LH + 0.27E L + 0.21
(s.27)
where A : the slopeof the saturatedvapor pressurecurve of air at absolute temperature(mm Hg/'F) H : the daily heatbudgetat the surface(estimateof net radiation) (mm/day) E : daily evapoiation(mm) ET : the evapotranspirationor consumptiveusefor a given period (mm/day) The variablesE and.Fl are calculatedusing the following equations: E : 0.35(e"- e)(l'+
( s .28) 0.0098ar) : where eo the saturationvapor pressureat mean ak temperature(mm Hg) e6 : the saturationvapor pressureat meandew point (actualvapor pressure in the air) (mm Hg) u2 : the mean wind speedat 2 m abovethe ground (mi/day) The equationusedto determinethe daily heat budget at the surface,11,is 11 : R(1 - r)(0.18 + 0.55.t)- 8(0.56 * 0.092e2s)(0.10 (5.29) + 0.905) where R : the mean monthly extraterrestrialradiation (mm HrO evaporatedper dav) : the estimatedpercentageof reflecting surface B = a temperature-dependent coefficient s : the estimatedratio of actual duration of brisht sunshineto maximum possibleduration of bright sunshine. The empirical reflectivecoefficientr is a function of the time of year,the calmnessof the water surface,wind velocity, and water quality. Typical rangesfor r are 0.05 to 0.12.31 valuesof e" andA can be obtainedfrom Figs.5.7 and 5.8, thosefor R and B can be obtainedfrom Tables5.6 and 5.7. The use of Penman'sequationrequiresa knowledgeof vaporpressures,sunshineduration,net radiation,wind speed,and mean temperature.Unfortunately,regular measurements of theseparametersare often unavailableat sites of concern and they must be estimated.Another complication is making a reductionin the valueof EZwhen the calculationsare for vegetatedsurfaces. While results of experimentsto quantify reduction factors have not completelyresolved the problem, there is evidencethat the annual reduction factor is close to
ESTIMATINGEVAPOTRANSPIRATION
5.7 "C 60 50
't22 104
t r 1 n
86
20
68
10
111
40
r04
€ : o
86
!?
o B t ^
o
o F
.F
50
t40
I
€ + o
"C
.F
- 1 0 0
50 10 20
30 40
50 60
70
313 = ts
68
14
s0l. zzV | 0.2
105
|
0.4 0 6
| 0.8
|
I
I
I
303
ct
ro?
!d 6
z6J
6 F.
t273
1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8
80 90 100
satuated vapor pressure' ea (mm Hg)
Figure 5.7 Relation betweentemperatureand saturatedvapor Pressure.
Valueof A (mmHg/'F) Figure 5.8 TemperatureversusA relation for use *i?rt ,n" PenmanLquation. (After Criddle'23)
that using Thus,unlessthereis evidenceto supportanothervalue'it appears unity.32-34 surfaces for results satisfactory a value of 1 for the reduction coefficient may give evaporation water free of having varied vegetal covers.Accordingly, aty estimate by an appropriatereduction could be used ro estimaieEZ, providin[ it is modified coefficient.
EXAMPLE 5.4
to 5.29, estimateET, giventhe following data: ': using the PenmanMethod, Eqs.5.21 : 30 degreesc' 20 degreesc, temperatureof 1l temperatureat warer r"tru"" : (48 mi/day)' the month is relative humidity : +O p"r""nt, wind-velocity i mph S is found to be 0'75' Juneat latitude 30 degreesnorth, r is given ut 0'07' and Solution l.Giventhedatafortemperature,thevaluesofeoandeacanbedetermined. UsingFig.5.TorAppendixTableA.2,thesaturatedVaporpressuresare 31'83'andfor foundto be l7.53unO-:t'Sl mm Hg respectively' ThI'"-: : : 12'73' X 0'4 a relativehumidity of 40 percent,e,t 31'83 Then,usingEq. 5.28' .83 - 12.73)(1+ 0.0098x 48) E : 0.35(31 E:9.83 mm/daY 2.ThevalueofAisfoundusingFig.5.8;forthegivenlatitudeandmonth,R isobtainedfiomTable5.6;andBisgottenfromTable5.'Tforatemperature : 1'0' R : 16'5' andB : I7 '01' of 30"C.fne vatuesfound are A Then,usingEq.5.29, H: 16'5(I - 0'07)(0'18+ 0's5 x 0'75) - 17.01(0.5 6 - 0.092x 12j30)(0.10 + 0'90 x 0'75) H = 6.04 mm/daY
O \ O h O \ 6 \ t o € O \ \ O € € r ) O o r) F. O N + r) \O F-
t--
l--
F-
O
Ol
t- * co o o\ * o co cn oo oo n tF-O\dcl\fh!nv1<.cqolO
F-
\O F- :+ f.-' r) O\ O F- * C.l * d \ + \ O O \ i o * r ) \ O \ O \ O \ O n
ft
o LL 6
trJ
o IL
tr
f U) J
nv?qnnqqnv.t-nv.tol
€oN catf,r +s+coNooo\o :
:
*
*
*
d
d
i
*
-
F
z o
N tf
o
F.
O\ €
cn ci
O
e.l O
c.i ri + r; ri ri {
\n
\O h
N
O\
cd -.j oi F ri c.i
I
z z
-.: dl .l \
\
r.)
E.
(r
oq v? q g oq 9 q cl
!f
\O \O \O r.)
I = o
*
*
-
i
*
c.l r
O
f\
\A
tri
d
d
r F- tr - \r ) €€$\O\O**€6 \o \o \o \o r) * c7) d o\ F- r) N o
5
o q) lJ-
o
q
9nqq\qqn\\-q*: $ h n \ o r ) h c n N o € \ o $ * *
i
i
i
i
*
i
*
d
6 z
uJ F
z
H
F-
O\ oo a]
N
a-
6
t1
oo oo \O o
-j 6i di + ri ri + ri 6i ci *, <j +
J T
F
z
o
e-:q\qoq.l-9qqvln
\ O O \ : c . l o $ n h * o a l ( ) € H * * * * r *
4 Z tIO
>tr
ds
u O olu 6 Z ui< f > 1 z
S IIJ 2O-
n q q n r t
q q \ g o q q - \
O r} oO O al cn r) r) \O r) r)
<+ C.l
E
cn\oor)66r)ooooo6*\o .j d; \o od o 6i + r; \ci i-- r- r- \c; i : :
a
ft+ t=P
) z muJ 4 ,Ct) F ] q lo UJ
€s
\Or ) *6al -
- 6l o+r ) \O E V
E:
6
z
a
> 6
SUMMARY
107
TABLE5.7 VALUESOF TEMPERATURE-DEPENDENT B FORUSEINTHEPENMAN COEFFICIENT EQUATION Tu (K)
B (mmHrO/day)
270 275 280 285 290 295 300 305 310 315 320 325
r0.73
T" fF) Jf
11.51 12.40 13.20 14.26 15.30 16.34 r7.46 18.60 19.85 21.15 22.50
40 A<
50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 100
B (mm HrO/day)
11.48 I 1.96 12.45 12.94 13.45 13.96 14.52 15.10 15.65 16.25 16.85 t'7.46 18.10 18.80
Source: Afler Criddle.23Note that B = oT1 where o is the Boltzmann c o n s t a n t . 2 . 0xl l 0 - e m m / d a y .
3. UsingEq. 5.27, Er : 0.0 x 6.04 + 0.27 x 9.83)/(1+ 0.27) ET : 6.85 mm/day is 6.85 mm/day. ll Thus the estimatedevapotranspiration
Simulating Evapotranspiration The volume of water evaporatedor transpiredfrom a watershedover time can be substantial.Accordingly, continuoushydrologicmodelingprocessesshouldincorporate an EZcomponent.The modelsgiven in this chaptertypify suchan approach(see aboundon this subjes1.28'2e'rs':o':z alsothe flow chart of Fig. 1.3).References
Summary Figure 1.1 and Table5.1 showthe overall importanceof ET in the hydrologicbudget. In many regionsof the United States,annual ET exceedsannual precipitation by a significantamount.As a result, plans for water resourcesdevelopmentand use must incorporate estimatesof ET losses.Where irrigated agriculture is practiced, these estimatesare especiallyimportant. A numberof approachesto estimatingEThavebeendeveloped.They generally fall into the following classes:theoretical,basedon the physicsofthe process;analytical, basedon energyor water budgets;and empirical, basedon observations.Equations usedin making ET calculationsare usually of the type illustrated by Eqs. 5.1, 5.8,5.10,5.19,5.22,and5.26.
1oB
cHAp+R 5 EVApoRATtoN ANDTRANsptRAloN
PROBLEMS 5.1. An 8000-mi2watershedreceived20 in. of precipitationin a 1-yearperiod. The annual streamflowwas recorded as 5000 cfs. Roughly estimatethe combined amounts of water evaporatedand transpired.Qualify your answer. 5.2. Find the daily evaporationfrom a lake during which the following datawere obtained: air temperature 90oF,water temperature60oF,wind speed 20 mph, and relative humidity 30 percent. 5.3. Find the monthly consumptiveuse of an alfalfa crop when the mean temperatureis 70"F, the averagepercentageof daytime hours for the year is 10, and the monthly consumptiveuse coefficientis 0.87. 5.4. During a given month a lake having a surfacearea of 350 acreshas an inflow of 20 cfs, an outflow of 18 cfs, and a total seepagelossof 1 in. The total monthly precipitation is 1.5 in. and the evaporationloss is 4.0 in. Estimatethe changein storage. 5.5. What are two filethodsthat might be usedto reduceevaporationfrom a small pond? 5.6. Computethe daily evaporationfrom a ClassA pan if the amountsof water required to bring the level to the fixed point are as follows:
Day Rainfall (in.) Water added(in.) Evaporation
1 0 0.29
2 0.65 0.55
3 0.12 0.07
4 0 0.28
5 0.01 0.10
5.7. For Problem 5.6, the pan coefficientis 0.70. What is the lake evaporation(in inches) for the 5-day period for a lake with a 250-aqe surfacearea? 5.8. The pan coefficientfor a ClassA evaporationpan locatednear a lake is 0.7. A total of 0.50 in. of rain fell during a given day. Determinethe depth of evaporationfrom the lake during the sameday if 0.3 in. of water had to be addedto the pan at the end of the day in order to restorethe waterlevel to its original valueat the beginningof the day. 5.9. A 2500 mi2drainagebasinreceives25 in.lyr rainfall. The dischargeof the river at the basinoutlet is measuredat an averageof 650 cfs. Assumingthat the changein storage for the systemis essentiallyzero, estimatethe EZlossesfor the areain inchesand cm for the year. Stateyour assumptions. 5.10. Determine the daily evaporationfrom a lake for a day during which the following mean values were obtained: air temperature78'F; water temperature62oF; wind speed,8 mph; and relative humidity, 45 percent. 5.11. Usingthe Meyer and Dunne equations,find the daily evaporationrate for a lake given that the mean value for air temperaturewas 80T, for water temperature60'F, the ziveragewind speedwas 10 mph, and the relative humidity was 25 percent.Refer to Appendix Table A.2 for vapor pressrirevalues. 5.12. Determinethe seasonalconsumptiveuse of truck crops grown in Pennsylvaniaif the meanmonthly temperaturesfor May, June,July, and August are 62,71,16, and 75'F respectivelyandthepercentdaylighthoursforthegivenmonths arc10.02,10.1,10.3, and 9.6 as percent of the year respectively.
REFERENCES
109
5.13. Using the PenmanMethod, Eqs.5.27 to 5.29, estimateET, giventhe following data: temperatureat water surface: 20 degreesC, temperatureof air : 32 degreesC, relative humidity : 45 percent,wind velocity : 3 mph, the month is Juneat latitude 30 degreesnorth, r is given as 0.08, and S is found to be 0.73.
REFERENCES 1 . WaterResources Council,TheNation's WaterResources: 1975-2000,U.S. Govt. Print. Off., Washington, D.C., 1978. 2 . U.S. Department of Commerce, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, National WeatherService,NOAA TechnicalReport 33,EvaporationAtlas of the Contiguous 48 UnitedStates,Washington, D.C., June1982. 3 . U.S. Department of Commerce, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, National WeatherService,NOAA TechnicalReport NWS 34, "Mean, Monthly Seasonal, and Annual Pan Evaporationfor the United States,"Washington,D.C., June 1982. 4. "Water-LossInvestigations,"Vol. 1, Lake Hefner Studies,U.S. GeologicSurveyProfessionalPaperNo. 269 (1954). (Reprintof U.S. GeologicalSurveyCitc.229, 1952.) 5 . N. N. Gunaji, "EvaporationInvestigationsat ElephantButte Reservoir,New Mexico," ^lnl. Assoc.Sci.Hydrol. Pub. 18, 308-325(1968). 6. I. S. Bowen, "The Ratio of Heat Lossesby Conduction and by Evaporationfrom Any Water Surface,"Phys.Rev. 27, 779-7 81(1926). 7 . E. R. Anderson,L. J. Anderson,andJ. J. Marciano, "A Reviewof EvaporationTheory and Developmentof Instrumentation,'oLake Mead WaterLoss Investigation;Interim Report, Navy ElectronicsLab. Rept.No. 159 (Feb. 1950). 8 . O. G. Sutton, "The Application to Micrometeorologyof the Theory of Turbulent Flow over RoughSurfaces,"R. Meteor,Soc.Q. "I. 75(No. 236),335-350(Oct. 1949). 9 . A. F. Meyer, "Evaporationfrom Lakes and Reservoirs,"MinnesotaResourcesCommission,St. Paul,June1944. 1 0 . T. Dunne and L. B. Leopold, Waterin EnvironmentalPlanning, San Francisco:Freeman and Co., 1978. 1 1 . V. M. Ponce,EngineeringHydrology: Principles and Practices.EnglewoodCliffs. New Jersey:PrenticeHall, 1989. 1 2 . M. A. Kohler, T. J. Nordenson,and W E. Fox. "Evaporationfrom Pansand Lakes," U.S. Departmentof Commerce,WeatherBureau,Res.PaperNo. 38, Washington, D.C., 1955. 1 3 . H. T. Haan, H. P. Johnson,and D. L. Brakensiek(eds.),Hydrologic Modeling of Small Watersheds,ASAE MonographNo. 5. St. Joseph,MI: American Societyof Agricuitural Engineers,1982. 14. R. K. Linsley,M. A. Kohler, and J. L. H. Paulhus,Hydrologyfor Engineers,3rded. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1982. 1 5 . H. L. Penman,"Natural Evaporationfrom Open Water,Bare Soil, and Grass,"Proc. R. Soc.LondonSer.A 193(1032),120-145(Apr.1948). 16. F. G. Millar, "Evaporationfrom FreeWaterSurfaces,l'CanadaDepartmentof Transport, Division of MeteorologicalServices,Can, Meteor. Mem. vol. l, No. 2, 1937. 1 7 . J. B. Franzini, "Evaporation SuppressionResearch,"Water and SewageWorks (May 1961). 1 8 . Victor K. La Mer, "The Casefor EvaporationSuppression," Chem.Eng.(June10, 1963). 1 9 . D. R. Maidment(ed.),Handbookof Hydrology.New York: McGraw-Hill,1993. 20. H. F. Blaney,"Water and Our Crops," inWater, the Yearbookof Agriculture. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Departmentof Agriculture,1955.
110
ANDTRANSPIRATION 5 EVAPORATION CHAPTER "Monthly Consumptive Use Requirementsfor Irrigated Crops," Proc. ZI. H. F. Blaney, ASCE,J. Irrigation DrainageDiv. 85(IR1), 1-12(Mar' 1959)' 22. yen Te Chow (ed.), Handbook of Applied Hydrology. New York: McGraw-Hill ' 1964. "Methods of Computing ConsumptiveUse of Water." Proc. ASCE J. 23. W. D; Criddle, Irrigation DrainageDiv. 84(IR1), 1-27(Jan' 1958)' ,;Estimating Evaporation," Trans. Am. Geoplrys. union 37(l), 4324. H. L. penman,
5o(1es6).
"Reductionof Transpiration,"J. Geophy.Res.66(10), 3309-3312(Oct. 25. N. J. Roberts, 1961). "Researchon control of Phreatophytes,"Proc. Ninth Annual water con26. E. H. Hughes, ference,New Mexico StateUniversity,Las Cruces,Mat. 1964' 21. R. K. Linsley,Jr., M. A. Kohler, and J. L. H. Paulhus,Hydrologyfor Engineers.New York: McGraw-Hill, 1958. "National WeatherServiceRiver ForecastSys28. Staff, Hydrologic ResearchLaboratory, tem ForecastProcedures,"NWS HYDRO 14. U.S. Departmentof Commerce,Washington. D.C..Dec. 1972. "usDAHL-74 Revised 29. H. N. Holtan, G. J. Stiltner,w. H. Henson,and N. C. Lopez, ARS Tech.Bull. No. 1518.U.S.DepartmentofAgriculModelof WatershedHydrology," D.C., 1975. ture, Washington, "Evapotranspiration-Review of ReN. J. Rosenberg,H. E. Hart, and K. w. Brown, search,"MP 20, Agricultural ExperimentStation,University of Nebraska,Lincoln, 1968' R. 3 1 . H. McCuen, HydrologicAnalysis and Design.Englewoodcliffs, New Jersey:Prentice Hall, 1989. "Correlation of ClimatologicalData with WaterR'equire3 2 . W. O. Pruitt and F. J. Lourence, California Water ScienceEng. Paper9001. Davis, June of University ments of Crops." 1968. "Potential Evaporation:The cornbination concept and Its Experi33. C. H. M. Van Bavel, mental Verification," WaterResourcesRes.2' 455-467(1966)' "Discussionof Paperby H. L. Penman,'Estimating Evaporation,"' Trans' 34. H. F. Blaney, Am. Geoplrys.Union37,46-48(Feb. 1956). "Digital Simulationin Hydrology:StanfordWater35. N. H. Criwford and R. K. Linsley,Jr., shedModel IV," Tech. Rept. 39, Departmentof Civil Engineering,Stanford University' July 1966. 36. W. C. Huber, J. P. Heaney,S. J' Nix, R. E. Dickinson, and D"J' Polmann' Storm Water ManagementModel (lsei's Manual, Version /11, EPA-60012-84-109a(NTIS PB84198423).Cincinnati, oH: EnvironmentalProtection Agency, Nov. 1981. 37. L.A. Roesner,R. P. Shubinski,and J. A. Aldrich, StormWaterManagementModel User's Manual, versionIII: AddendumI, Extran, EPA-600/2-84-109b(NTIS PB84-198431). Cincinnati, OH: EnvironmentalProtection Agency,Nov' 1981'
Chapter6
Streamflow
r Prologue The purposeof this chapteris to: . Introduce the conceptof streamflow. . Describethe characteristicsof a hydrograph. ' Presentapproachesto measuringstreamflow. The amountof water flowing in surfacewater coursesat any instant of time is small in termsof the earth's total waterbudget,but it is of considerableimportanceto those concernedwith waterresourcesdevelopment,supply,and management.A knowledge of the quantity and quality of streamflowsis a requisite for: municipal, industrial, agriculiural, and other water supply endeavors;flood control; reservoir designand operation; hydroelectricpower generation;water-basedrecreation;navigation;fish und .ildlit" management;drainage; the managementof natural systemssuch as wetlands;and water and wastewatertreatment. Streamflowis generatedby precipitationduring stormeventsand by groundwater entering surface channels.During dry periods, streamflowsare sustainedby groundwaterdischarges.Where groundwaterreservoirsare below streamchannelsoften the casein arid regions-streams ceaseto flow during protractedprecipitationfree periods. Relations between precipitation and streamflow are complex, being influJnced by the factors discussedin the foregoing chapters.As a result, many approachesto relating theseimportant hydrologicvariableshavebeen developed.l-3 Severalof them are discussedin detail in Part Three of the text' Field measurementsof streamflow are based on the use of flow-measuring devicessuchas weirs and flumes and on the measurementof channelcross-sections along with streamflowvelocities(seeChapter 8).
DRAINAGEBASINEFFECTS The quality and quantity of streamflowgeneratedin a drainagebasin are affectedby Accordingly,it is important the bisin's physical,vegetative,and climatic features.a-e rocks,plants,topography, soils, ofthe good understanding a have hydrologist that the
CHAPTER 6 STREAMFLOW
J12
land-usepatterns,and otherbasincharacteristicsthat influencethe sequenceof events separatingprecipitation and runoff. It should be pointed out, however,that while natural basin featuresare very important elementsin the runoff process,land-use ieatures createdby humans (e.g., housingdevelopments,parking lots, agricultural patterns)may,in somecases,be the dominantones.Land managementpracticescan be beneficial,suchasin retardingerosion,and they can alsobe detrimentalwhenthey In Chapter10,the principal basin function to acceleratenatural hydrologicprocesses. are discussed. hydrologist concern to the of characteristics
6.2 THE HYDROGRAPH
,
Streamflow,at a givenlocationon a watercourse,is representedby a hydrograph.This continuousgraph displaysthe propertiesof streamflowwith respectto time, normally obtained by nteansof a continuousrecorder that shows stage(depth) versustime (stagehydrograph),and is then transformedinto a dischargehydrographby application of a rating curve. In general, the term hydrograph as used herein means a dischargehydrograph. As was shownin Fig. 1.3, the hydrographproducedin a streamis the result of various hydrologicprocessesthat occur-duringand after any precipitation event. A is given in Chapter11. A hydrographhas more completediscussionof theseprocesses (1) runoff, (2) interflow, (3) groundwateror surface elements: direct four component rising portion of a hydrographis known (4) precipitation. The channel baseflow, and vicinity of the peak is calledthe crest in the region curve; the as the concentration The shapeof a hydrographdepends portion the recession.lo falling is segrnent;andthe properties. Figure 6.1 illustratesthe basin pattem and precipitation characteristics on presented. definitions
Stormperiod hydrograph
'{1 oa-. . I'a
Endof direct runoff
\% .
\
Y
Continuous hydrograph Time Figure 6.1
Hydrograph definition.
6.4
MEASURINGAND RECORDINGSTREAMFLOW
113
FORSTREAMFLOW 6.3 UNITSOF MEASUREMENT Two types of units are usedin measuringwater flowing in streams.They are units of dischargeand units of volume.Discharge,or rate of flow, is the volume of water that passesa particularreferencepoint in a unit of time. The basicunits usedin connection of with streamgaugingin the United Statesare the foot and meter for measurements dimensionand the secondfor measurementsof time. Commonly usedunits of dischargemeasurementare cubic feet per second(cfs) and cubic meters per second (m3/sec).Other units of dischargein useare second-footper squaremile (sec-ft/mi2), for expressingthe averagerate of dischargefrom a drainagebasinor definedarea,and million gallonsper day (mgd),commonly usedin water supplycalculations.Units of volume used are the cubic foot, cubic meter, liter, gallon, and acre-foot (a volume equivalent to 1 ft of water over an acre, 43,560 ft2, of land). The latter unit is commonly used in irrigation practice in the westernUnited States.Irrespectiveof whetherEnglish or metric units are usedfor dimensions,the standardunit of time for streamflowobservationsis the second.
AND RECORDING STREAMFLOW 6.4 MEASURING Streamflowratesmay be determinedusinggaugingdevicessuchas flumes,weirs,and control sections,or they may be calculated from measurementsof head (depth), velocity, and cross-sectionalarea.t-t Usually, specific devices such as flumes are
' bI) 6 6 o bo
a
ri
)
3000 Discharge (sec-ft)
Figure 6.2 Station rating curve for RaquetteRiver at Piercefield,New York. (U.S. GeologicalSurvey.)
114
CHAPTER6
STREAMFLOW
limited to small streamsbecauseof problems of scale.For large stream systems, dischargeis normally estimatedby measuringvelocity and using the cross-sectional areato translatethis measurementinto discharge.Where flow-measuringdevicesare used,it is customaryto observethe head and use a rating curve to translatethis into discharge.When direct flow measurementscannot be made, dischargecalculations are often facilitated by use of velocity-area relations, chemical tracers, electrical methods,and empirical equationssuchas the Manning formula' In the United States,the primary responsibilityfor gaugingmajor streamslies of with the U.S. GeologicalSurvey,with a systematicrecord of streamflowin terms a at obtained is recording mean daily dischargebeing the norm. Usually, a stage several of more or one by gauging siie and this record is convertedinto discharge (seeChap-"tttoAr. Rating curves,tables, and formulas are used for this purpose and instruments The curve' ter 11).Figure 6.2 rho*r a typical stage-dischargerating the to adapted carefully methodsusedto convertstagerecordingsto dischargemustbe the to ensure as so gauging site natural or artiflcial conditions encounteredat the reliability of conversions.'
AREA OF DEPTHAND CROSS.SECTIONAL 6.5 MEASUREMENTS Unlessa direct flow-measuringdevicecanbe installedin a stream,aratity for streams of any scale,measurementsof depth of flow and cross-sectionalareawill be needed to permit dischargeto be calculated. Depth measurementsmay be taken using weighted soundin! [nes, calibrated rods, and ultrasonic soundingdevices.Crosssectionalareasat streamsectionscan be determinedusing ordinary surveyingtechniquescombinedwith soundingsor other depth measurementsthat ate taken below the water level at the time of the survey.Although the measurementof depth and simple,accuratedeterminationsrequirecarefulcalibration al areaseems cross-section of instrumentsand the ability to deal with submergedconditions.
OF VELOCITY 6.6 MEASUREMENT combinedwith thoseof cross-sectionalarea,permit calculaVelocity measurements, tion of dischargeat a given stream or river location. Point flow velocities can be determinedusing velocity-measuringdevicessuch as the Pitot tube, dynamometer' and current -"i"r. In the United States,the Price current meter has long been a standardin streamflowgauging.This deviceoperatesby exposingcuppedvanesto the direction of flow, *o"h lik" the anemometerused in measuringwind velocity. The cup-vaneassemblyrotatesin nearproportion to flow velocity and the rate of rotation is convertedto point velocity using a rating table or appropriateequation' , Various chemical and electrical methods are also employed in determining velocities.Commonly usedchemicalmethodsinclude salt velocity, salt dilution' and is the detectionof radioactivetracers. Of these methods,the salt velocity method into the introduced salt principle that perhapsthe most widely used.It is basedon the streamwill increaseits electricalconductivity.Electrodesplaceddownstreamof the
FLOWVELOCIry POINTVELOCIryTO CROSS-SECTIONAL 6.7 RELATING
115
Figure6.3 Verticalvelocityprofile
salt injection senseconductivity changesand thesecan be translatedinto velocity by knowing the spacingof electrodesand keeping track of time. Electrical methods includethe useof hot wire anemometers,electromagneticvoltagegeneration,oxygen polarography,and supersonicwaves.aStreamflowconditionsvary widely and thus no specificapproachto velocity determinationis universally suitable.The best method for use at a given site must be determinedon the basis of the characteristicsof streamflowat that site. Field observationshave shown that the mean velocity in a verticai stream sectionis closelyapproximatedby the averageof the velocitiesoccurringat depthsof 20percentand 80 percentof the total sectiondepthrespectively(seeFig.6.3).11'12 Where depthsarevery shallow,on the orderof 0.5 feet, singlemeterreadingsat about the 50 percentpoint havebeen shownto yield good results.t' Velocity measurements permit estimatingchannel and geometricdefinitionsof streamchannelcross-sections havebeen made. measurements and depth velocity flows at locationswhere
FLOWVELOCITY TO CROSS-SECTIONAL POINTVELOCITY 6.7 RELATING While point velocity measurementsare important, what is desiredis a method to translatethem into the averagecross-sectionalflow velocity. This averagevelocity, when multiplied by the cross-sectionalarea,yields the dischargeat a given stream section.One procedureis to take point velocity measurementsat numerousvertical and horizontal positions in a crosi section,plot them, and then determinevelocity contours.By calculatingthe areasbetweenthe contoursand assigningthe averageof the flow velocitiesof the two confining contoursto theseareas,a determinationof meanvelocity can be made.Once this is accomplished,dischargeis easilycalculated. Other approachesmake use of the geometric properties of stream channel One suchtechniqueis the mean-sectionmethod.To usethis approach, cross-sections. to it is necessary divide the streamchannelcross-sectionat a gauginglocation into a
116
CHAPTER6 STREAMFLOW Water surface
for Example6.1 Figure 6.4 Channelcross-section seriesof geometricshapes(seeFig. 6.4). AL eachvertical location along the crossThe averagevelocity of section,the meanvelocity is estimatedfrom measurements. to the averageof the be equal to is considered two verticals between area flow for the betweentwo vertidischarge The verticals. of the bordering for each meanvelocities of the section. area the by multiplied section for the velocity average the cals is thus flow for the total estimated provide an to summed are then discharges The individual to measurements enough to have is important it Note that location. at that channel 6.1. Example in illustrated is procedure The cross-section. the characterize EXAMPLE 6.1
Calculatethe dischargeat the sectiongiven in Fig. 6.4. Data from field observations are shownin Tables6.1 and6.2. 6.1 TABLE6.2 DATAFOREXAMPLE
TABLE 6.1 DATA FOR EXAMPLE6.1
Verticalsection#
Depth (ft.)
Avg. vel.
(rps)
0
0
0
I
4
2.1
2
5
2.3
'7.2
2.7
7.4
2.8
3
4
2.5
5 6
4.'1
2.2
7
0
0
DISCHARGE 6.8 THESLOPE-AREA METHODFORDETERMINING
,117
TABLE6.3 CALCULATIONS FOR EXAMPLE 6.1 Area (sq.ft.)
Vel. (fps)
A1
8.40
1.05
8.82
A2
14.85
2.20
32.67
A3
29.28
2.50
73.20
A4
3't.96
2,75
104.39
A5
26.83
2.65
7t.09
A6
30.09
2.35
70.71
A7
13.87
1.10
15.25
Area
t61,.27
Flow (cfs)
376.t3
Total estimateddischargeis 376.13 cfs
Solution. The first step is to calculatethe individual section areas(A1, A2, etc.). The calculatedareas(usingtriangular or trapezoidalformulas)are shown on spreadsheet Table6.3. Next, the estimatedmeanvelocitiesat the verticalsare multiplied by the section areasto obtain the individual area discharges(see Table 6.3). Thesedischargesare summedto yield an estimated376.13 cfs of flow being deliveredby the full channelwidth. r I
DISCHARGE METHODFORDETERMINING 6.8 THE SLOPE.AREA In somecasesit is difflcult to make velocity or other measurementsneededto deter: mine discharge.This is often the caseduring large flood events.Under suchcircumof high stances,it is sometimespossibleto estimatethe flow by taking measurements water lines (after the flood event),cross-sectionalareas,and channelslopesand then usingthesedatain an equationsuchasManning's to estimatethe flow. The applicable Manning equationis Q : \I.49ln)APzrzgrrz where Q : n : A : R: S:
(6.1)
discharge(cfs) Manning's roughnesscoefficient cross-sectionalarea(ft2) the hydraulic radius the headloss per unit length of channel
For streamflows,Manning's n valuesmay rangebetweenabout0.03 and 0.15. When reasonabledeterminationscan be made of n, A, R, and S, Eq. 6.1 can be used to estimate the streamflow that occurred during the high-water period. For a more completediscussionof this and other streamflowdeterminationmethods,the
118
CHAPTER6
STREAMFLOW
referencesat the end ofthe chaptershouldbe consulted.References4 and 10 give an excellent overview of techniques and include a valuable list of references on streamflow.
r Summary Streamflowis the result of storm-periodprecipitation, snowmelt,and groundwater discharge.l3It is a primary sourceof water for a host of instreamand offstreamuses. The graphicalrepresentationof streamflowis the hydrograph,a plot of flow versus time at a prescribedlocation alongthe water courseof interest.As illustratedby Fig. 1.3, the end product of many hydrologicmodelingprocessesis a hydrographwhich is derived from a precipitation input, modified appropriatelyby various abstractions suchas infiltration. Methodsfor measuringstreamflowin the field were presentedin this chapter.In later sectionsofthe book, a variety oftechniquesfor deriving hydrographs from precipitation and other hydrologic data are covered (seePart Three).
PROBLEMS 6.t. Considerthat you haveobtaineda gaugeheightreadingof4 ft at a gaugingsite on the RaquetteRiver (Fig. 6.2). What would you estimatethe dischargeto be in cfs and in m3/sec?If the gaugeheighthad been9 ft, what would the dischargebe?Which of the two estimatesdo you think would be the most reliable?Why? 6.2. SolveProblem 6.1 if the gaugeheight readingswere 5 ft and 7 ft. 6.3. Consulta USGSWaterSupplypaperand plot the streamflowdatafor a drainagebasin ofinterest.Discussthe factorsthat you believeinfluencedthe shapeofthe hydrograph. 6.4. For the major surfacewater course in your locality, discussthe value of making streamflowforecasts. 6.5. Calculatethe dischargeat the sectiongiven in Fig. 6.4 if the depth measurementsat Give resultsin the verticalswere:0, 3.8, 5.4, 7.1,8.1,7.0,4.5, and 0 ft respectively. cfs and m3/s. Calculatethe dischargeat the sectiongiven in Fig. 6.4 if the velocitieswere: 0, 2.3, 2.6,3.1,2.9,2.7,2.5, and0 fps respective$,and the depthsof Problem6.5 applied. Give resultsin cfs and m3/s.
REFERENCES 1 . N. C. Grover and A. W. Harrington, StreamF/ow. New York Wiley, 1943. 2. United StatesDepartmentof the Interior, Bureau of Reclamation,Water Measurement Manual. Washington,D.C.: U.S. GovernmentPrinting Office, 1967.
3 . I. E. Houk, "Calculation of Flow in Open Channels,"Stateof Ohio, The Miami Conservancy District, Tech. Rept. Part IV, Dayton, OH, 1918.
4. Ven Te Chow (ed.), Handbook of Applied Hydrology. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1964. 5 . American Society of Civil Engineers,"Hydrology Handbook," Manuals of Engineering Practice.No. 28. New York: ASCE. 1957.
REFERENCES 1 19 6 . O. E. Meinzer, Hydrology.New York: Dover, 1942. 7 . A. N. Strahler, "Geology-Part II," Handbook of Applied Hydrology. New York: McGraw-Hill. 1964. 8 . R. E. Horton, "Drainage Basin Characteristics,"Trans.Am. Geoplrys.Union l3r 35O36r(1932\. 9 . W. B. Langbeinet al., "TopographicCharacteristicsof DrainageBasins,"U.S. Geological Survey,Water Supply Paper,968-c, 1947. 1 0 . R. K. Linsley, Jr., M. A. Kohler, and J. L. H. Paulhus,Applied Hydrology. New York: McGrawHill, 1949. 1 1 . S. S. Butler, EngineeringHydrology.EnglewoodCliffs, New Jersey:Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1951. 12. C. H. Pierce,"Investigationof Methodsand EquipmentUsedin StreamGauging,"Water Supply Paper 868-A, U.S. GeologicalSurvey,Washington,D.C.: GovernmentPrinting Office,1941. 1 3 . D. R. Maidment (ed.),Handbookof Hydrology.New York: McGraw-Hill , 1993.
PART TWO
ENTS MEASUREM HYDROLOGIC AND MONITORING
Chapter7
HydrologicDataSources
r Prologue The purposeof this chaPteris to: . Describethe principal sourcesof data for hydrologicinvestigations. Data on hydrologicvariablesare fundamentalto analyses,forecasting,and modeling. Such data *uy 1" found in numerouspublications of state and federal agencies, researchinstitutes,universities,and otheroganizations.Severalofthe most significant sourcesof hydrologicdata are describedbriefly in this chapter'1-3
DATA 7 . 1 GENERALCLIMATOLOGICAL The most readily availablesourcesof data on temperature,solarradiation,wind, and humidity are ilimatological Data bulletins publishedby the EnvironrnentalData Service of the Nationai Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), and Monthly Summaryof Solar RadiationData publtshedby the National Climatic Data Center.The EnvironmentalData Service,in cooperationwith the World Meteorological Organization(WMO), also publishesMonthly Climatic Data for the World- A 1968 publication of the Environmental SciencesService Administration, entitled Climalic Atlasof the UnitedStates,summarizeswind, temperature,humidity, evaporation, precipitation, and solar radiation on a seriesof maps. In addition-to these federal sourcesof data, stateenvironmental,geologic,water resources,and agricultural agenciesshouldbe consulted.Most stateuniversitiesalso publish a variety of hydrologicdata through their researchcentersand extensionprograms.
DATA 7.2 PRECIPITATION There are probably more records of precipitation than of most otherhydrologic variables.The priniipal federalsourceof data on precipitationis NOAA. Climatological Data, publishedmonthly and annuallyfor eachstateor combinationof states,the pacific area,PuertoRico, and the Virgin Islandsby the EnvironmentalData Service,
E # = ,
124
CHAPTER7
HYDROLOGICDATA SOURCES
presentsa table of monthly averages,departuresfrom normal, and extremes of precipitation and temperatureas well as tables of daily precipitation, temperature, snowfall,snowon ground,evaporation,wind, and soil temperatarc.Hourly Precipitation Data is issuedmonthly and annuallyfor eachstateor combinationof statesand presentsalphabeticallyby station the hourly and daily precipitation amounts for stationsequippedwith recordin€gauges.A stationlocationmap is alsoincluded.This publication is availablefrom the EnvironmentalData Service.Another publication, World WeatherRecords,is issuedby geographicregionsfor 10-yearperiods.Data are listed by country or areaname, station name,latitude and longitude,and elevation. Monthly and annualmeanvaluesof stationpressure,sea-levelpressure,and temperaiure, and monthly and annualtotal precipitationare given in sequentialorder.Aside from NOAA, other federal and state agenciesand universitiespublish precipitation dataat varying intervals,often in a storm o1 site-specificcontext.In addition, many municipalitiesand water and wastewaterutilities also collect and maintain precipitation and other related data. Computeized precipitation data are availablefrom the National Climatic Data Centerin Asheville,North Carolina.
DATA 7.3 STREAMFLOW
.
The principal sourcesof streamflowdatafor the United Statesare the U.S. Geological Service(SCS),U.S.ForestService,andU.S. Survey(USGS),U.S. Soil Conservation Agricultural ResearchService(ARS). In addition,the U.S. Army Corpsof Engineers (COE), the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA), and the U.S. Bureauof Reclamation (USBR) make somestreamflowmeasurementsand tabulatestreamflowdata relative to their missions.Stateagencies,universities,and variousresearchorganizationsalso compile and publish a variety of streamflowdata. The USGS Water Supply Papers(WSf; are the benchmark for referencing streamflowdata. Furthermore,computerizeddata are also availablefrom the USGS. Publications of the Geological Survey, publishedevery 5 years and supplemented annually, arean excellentsourceof information on that agency'sreports. The SCS historically published data on streamflow from small watershedsand plots in its Hydrologic Bulletin series,but much of the data have been republishedby ARS. "pilot watersheds"are publishedin cooperationwith the USGS. Recordsfrom SCS U.S. Forest Service streamflow data are publishedat irregular intervals in various technicalbulletins and professionalpapers.
DATA AND.TRANSPIRATION 7.4 EVAPORATION Monthly and annualissuesof ClimatologicalData, publishedby NOAA, includepan evaporationand related data. The ARS, agricultural colleges,and water utilities are other sourcesof information. In particular, data on evapotranspirationare often obtained by university researchersworking through their Agricultural Experiment Stations.
REFERENCES 125
r summary Climatic and other data are keystonesin hydrologicmodelingprocesses.Numerous sources of data exist and may be accessedto support model developmentand verification, statisticalanalyses,and specialstudies.
PROBLEM 7.1
Developa list ofdata sourcesin your stateorlocality by visiting the library or through other channels.
REFERENCES 1 . Soil ConservationService,U,S. Departmentof Agriculture, SCSNational Engineering Handbook, "Hydrology", Sec. 4. Washington,D.C.: U.S. GovernmentPrinting Offlce, Au,g.1972. J. F. Miller, "Annotated Bibliography of NOAA Publications of Hydrometeorological Interest," NOAA Tech. Mem. NWS HYDRO-22, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Washington,D.C., May 1975. , D. R. Maidment (ed.), Handbookof fudrology. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1993.
ChapterB
lnstrumentation
Prologue The purposeof this chapteris to: ' Describeinstrumentsusedin measuringhydrologicvariables. . Indicate waysin which data are recordedand transmitted. . Presentlimitations on measurements. The data neededto supporthydrologicanalysesmust be obtainedin sufficientquantity, with adequatefrequency,and in an appropriateform if they are to be of value. A variety of instrumentsareusedto obtain and transmitthe data.They are the subject of this chapter.
8.1 INTRODUCTION
'
.
Hydrologicinstrumentationsupportsarealinvestigations,problemanalyses,research, are planning,and environmentalpolicymakingand analysis.A hostof measurements neededto support efforts in water resourcesplanning, management,design, and constructionrelatedto suchsubjectsas aquifer systemsanalysis,solid wastemanagewater supplyavailability,water quality management, ment, flood hazardassessment, groundwaterrecharge,protection of fish and wildlife, and navigation. Historically,instrumentswere often usedto obtain cumulativerather than continuousinformation abouthydrologicvariablessuchasrainfall and evaporation.Fqrthermore,there was often no attemptto correlatewater quality constituentloadings, for example,with ratesof water flow. Consequently,many historic data havelimited utility, not somuchbecauseof lack of adequateinstrumentation,but ratherfrom using availableinstrumentsto measurethe wrong thing or in too limiting a fashion.Today it is widely recognizedthat it is important not only to selectappropriateinstruments but to selectthem in the contextof datanetworksthat meetthe needsof moderntimes. More will be said about this in Chapter9, In Section8.2, instrumentsfor measuring hydrologicvariablesand waysin which they can be usedjointly to createa complete representationof a functioning hydrologicsystemare discussed.
INSTRUMENTS 127 8.2 HYDROLOGIC
INSTRUMENTS 8.2 HYDROLOGIC Good sourcesof information abouthydrologicinstrumentsare the National Weather Service,U.S. GeologicalSurvey,U.S. Bureauof Reclamation,U.S. Army Corpsof Engineers,Soil ConservationService,and instrumentmanufacturers,Theseagencies and industrieshavelong been in the businessof measuringhydrologicvariablesand Someofthe of state-of-the-artmeasuringdevices. theycanprovidedetaileddescriptions is far from but the coverage here, are described major typesof measuringinstruments references.l-3 the appropriate consult should exhaustiveand the interestedreader
Precipitation
"
Gaugesfor measuringrainfall and snowfall may be recording or nonrecording.The mostcommonnonrecordinggaugeis the U.S. WeatherServicestandard8-in. gauge. The gaugemay be read at any desirableinterval but often this is daily. The gaugeis calibrated so that a measuringstick, when inserted, showsthe equivalentrainfall depth. Such gaugesare useful when only periodic volumes are required, but they cannotbe usedto indicate the time distribution of rainfall' Recordinggaugescontinuouslysensethe ratb of rainfall and its time of occurrence.Thesegaugesare usually either ofthe weighing-recordingtype or the tipping buckettype. Weighing-typegaugesusually run for a period of 1 week, at which time their chartsmustbe changed.The figure associatedwith Problem2.5 is typical of the recordedoutput. A masscurve of rainfall depth versustime is the product, and this curve can be translatedinto an intensity-time graph by calculating the ratios of accumulatedrainfall to time for whatevertime stepis desired.Tipping bucketgauges, on the other hand, senseeach consecutiverainfall accumulationwhen it reachesa prescribedamount, usually 0.01 in. or 1 mm of rain, A small calibratedbucket is located below the rainfall entry port of the gauge. When it fills to the 0.01-in. incrementit tips over,bringing a secondbucketinto position.Thesetwo small buckets are placed on a swivel and the bucketstip back and forth as they fiIl. Each time a bucketspills it producesan indication on a strip chart or other recordingform. In this way a record of rainfall depth versustime (intensity)is the outcome.For rain gauges to record snow accumulations,some modifications must be made. Usually these involveproviding a melting agentso that the snow can be convertedinto measurable water. Figure 8.la is the diagram of a self-reportingrain gaugingstation.The tipping bucketmechanismgeneratesa digital input signal whenever1 mm of rainfall drains through the funnel assembly.The signalfrom the gaugeis automaticallytransmitted to a receiving station where it records the station ID number and an accumulated amountof rainfall. The receiving stationrecordsthe time at which the messagewas received and rainfall rates for desiredperiods can be calculated accordingly' Figure 8.1b showsa similar gaugeequippedto measuresnow.In this case,a glycometh solution is usedto melt the snow.The melt water overflowsthrough a temperaturecompensatingmechanismand is measuredby the tipping bucket,which operatesthe station's transmitter.Gaugesof the type shownin Fig. 8.1 can easilybe incorporated into real-time monitoring systemsthat can be used in a variety of forecastingand operatingmodes.
128
CHAPTER 8 INSTRUMENTATION
Antenna
Antenna mast
Antenna
Temperatffe compensation overflow mechanism
Antenna mast
Funnel assembly
Glycometh collecting section
Tipping bucket
Tipping bucket Drain holes (4)
Signalcable
(a)
,
Signalcable
Lifting rope
Lifting rope
Antennacable
Antennacablb
(b)
Figure 8.1 Self-reporting (a) rain and (b) snow stations. (Courtesy of SierraMisco, Inc., EnvironmentalProducts,Berkeley,CA.)
Evaporationand Transpiration
..
Evaporationpans have been widely used for estimatingthe amount of evaporation from free water surfaces.Devicessuchasthat depictedin Fig. 8.2 areeasyto use,but relating measurements taken from them to actual field conditionsis difficult and the -data_lhey-produceare often of questionablevalue for making areal estimates.A
INSTRUMENTS 8.2 HYDROLOGIC
129
tr'igure 8.2 U.S. Weather Bureau Class A pan.
variety of pan types havebeen developedbut the U.S. WeatherBureauClassA pan is the standardin the United States.4Panevaporationobservationshavebeenusedto estimateboth free water(lake) evaporationand evapotranspirationfrom well-watered vegetation.Field experimentshave shown a high degreeof correlation of pan data with evapotranspirationfrom surroundingvegetationwhen there is full cover and goodwatersupply.a As in the caseof precipitationgauges,pan datacan be recorded and transmittedcontinuouslyto a central receiving station. Evapotranspirationmeasurementsare often made using lysimeters.Thesedevices are containersplaced in the field and filled with soil, on which sometype of vegetativegrowth is maintained.The object is to study soil-water-plant relationsin a natural surrounding.The main featureof a weighinglysimeteris a block of undisturbed soil, usually weighing about 50 tons, encasedin a steel shell that is 10 ft by 10 ft by 8 ft. The lysimeteris buried so that only a plasticborder marksthe top of the containedsoil. The entire block of soil and the steelcasingare placedon an underground scale sensitiveenough to record even the movement of a rabbit over its surface.The soil is weighed at intervals, often every 30 min around the clock, to measurechangesin soil water level. The scalesare set to counterbalancemost of the deadweight of the soil and measureonly the active changein weight of water in the soi1.5The scalescan weigh accuratelyabout 400 g (slightly under 1 1b), which is equivalent to 0.002 in. of water. The weight loss from the soil in the lysimeter representswaterusedby the vegetativecoverplus any soil evaporation.Added water is also weighedand thus an accountingof water contentcan be kept. Crops or cover are plantedon the areasurroundingthe lysimeterto provide uniformity of conditions surroundingthe instrument.Continuousrecordsat the set weighingintervalsprovide almostcontinuousmonitoring of conditions.The data obtainedcan be transmittedto any desirablelocation for analysisand/or other use.Weighinglysimeterscan produce accuratevaluesof evapotranspirationover short periodsof time. But they are expensive.Nonweighingtypes of lysirneters,which are lesscostly,havealsobeenused,but unless the soil moisture content can be measuredreliably by some independent method,the data obtainedfrom them cannotbe relied on exceptfor long-term measurementssuchas betweenprecipitationevents.s
and HumiditY Wind,Temperature, Measurementsof wind, temperature,and humidity are neededto supportmany types of hydrologicanalyses.Wind is commonly measuredusing an anemometer,a device that has a wind-propelledelementsuchas a cup (Fig. 8.2) or propellerwhosespeed is calibratedto reflect wind velocity. Wind direction is obtainedusing a vane,which orients itself with the direction of the wind.
130
CHAPTER 8 INSTRUMENTATIoN
Temperaturemeasurementsare madeusing standardthermometersof various types,while hurnidity is measuredusing a psychrometer.A psychrometerconsistsof two thermometers,one called a wet bulb, the other a dry bulb. Upon ventilation the thermometersmeasuredifferently, and this differenceis called the wet-bulb depression.By usingappropriatetables,dewpoint, vaporpressure,andrelativehumidity can , be determined.6 Figure 8.3 depictsa completeweatherstation incorporatingmeasurementsof precipitation, wind, temperature,barometricpressure,and humidity. Sucha station - can automatically report weatherdata from remote siteson either an event and/or
Funnel assembly Solar panel Tipping bucket
Lifting rope Antennacable
Main housing
Signal cable
Ground level
Transmitter
Figure 8.3 Self-reporting weather station. (Courtesy of Sierra-Misco, Inc., Environmental Products, Berkeley, CA.)
131 INSTRUMENTS 8.2 HYDROLOGIC timed basisto a central site. A station suchas this can be used for marine weather forecasting,quantitativedeterminationsof oncoming storms,determinationof wind effect on tidal areas,and establishinga data basefor irrigation.
OpenChannelFlow Measurementsof open channel(natural and created)flow are made using standard measuringdevicessuchas flumes and weirs, and they are also madeby calibrating special control sectionsalong rivers and streamssuchthat measurementsof depth (Jtage)of flow can be related to discharge.Flow-measuringdevicesare designedso that sensingsomeparametersuchas depth automaticallytranslatesthe observation into units of flow (discharge).When a control sectionis used,observationsof crosssectionalareafor variousdepthsmust be obtained,and averageflow velocitiesmust be ascertainedfor variousstagesso that a sectionrating curve can be established.In the United States,the U.S. GeologicalSurvey,the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation,the Soil ConservationService,andthe U.S. Army Corpsof Engineershavedoneextensive flow measuringand havebeen active in developinginstrumentsand proceduresfor ascertainingrates of flow.2'6 Weirs Weirs are common water-measuringdevices.When they are properly installed and maintainedthey can be a very simple and accuratemeansfor gauging discharge.The most often usedweir types are the rectangularweir and the V-notch weir (Flg. 8.4). To be effective,weirs usually require a fall of about0.5 ft or more in the channelin which they are placed.Basically,a weir is an overflow structureplaced acrossan open channel.For a weir of specificsize and shapewith free-flow steadystateconditionsand a proper weir-to-pool relation, only one depth of watercan exist in the upstreampool for a particular discharge.Flow rate is determinedby measuring the vertical distancefrom the crestof the overflowpart of the weir to the watersurface in the upstreampool. The weir's calibrationcurvethen translatesthis recordeddepth into rate of flow at the device. Parshall Flumes A Parshallflumeis a speciallyshapedopenchannelflow section that can be installedin a channelsection.Figure 8.5 depictsone of thesedevices.The flume has severalmajor advantages:(1) it can operatewith a relatively small head loss;(2) it is fairly insensitiveto the approachvelocity; (3) it can be usedevenundet submergedconditions;and (4) its flow velocity is usually sufficientto precludesediment depositsin the structure.2The Parshallflume was developedby the late Ralph L. Parshill and it is a particular form of venturi flume. The constrictedthroat of the flume producesa differential headthat canbe relatedto discharge.Thus,asin the case .ofthe weir, an observationofdepth (head)is all that is requiredto determinethe rate of flow at the control point. Weirs and flumes are generally best suitedto gauging small streamsand openchannels,althoughlargebroad-crestedweirs can be installed at dam sites as part of overflow structures.For major rivers, other measuringapproachessuchas developingfield ratings at a specifiedcontrol sectionmust be relied on.
132
CHAPTER8
INSTRUMENTATION
Figure 8.4 Field installation of weirs: (a) rectangular and (b) Vnotch. USDA CooperativeExtensionService,Mountain StatesArea.
Golttrol Sections where the installation of a weir, flume, or some other flowmeasuringdeviceis impractical, it is sometimespossibleto developa rating curve at somelocation alonga streamby taking measurements of depth,cross-sectionalarea, and velocity and calculatingthe rate of flow for a particular stageat the location.By doing this for a range of depths of flow, a station rating curve can be developed. Instrumentsrequired to developsuch a curve are depth-sensingdevices,surveying instruments,and velocity meters.The velocity meter is similar to an anemometer.It is placedat variouspositionsin the channeland a velocity is recorded.By doing this at a numberoflocations, a velocity profile for a given depth can be developed.From this an averageflow velocity can bJcomputed, ind uy uiing that determinationand
INSTRUMENTS 133 8.2 HYDROLOGIC Diverging sectlon Throat section a J
Altemate45" wing wall PLAN
t x t xf,tngle
SECTIONZ-f, Service.) Figure 8.5 Parshallflume.(U.S.Soil Conservation
the cross-sectionalarea,dischargecan be calculatedas the product of meanvelocity and cross-sectionalarea.If observationscan be madefor a rangeof depths,a rating of depthwill curvecanbe developedfor the control sectionsothat only measurements on this Additional information later time. flow at some to estimate rate of be needed proceduremay be found in Refs.2 and 6.
Valve shut-offkeys Connecting band Valves
Figure 8.6 Recorderhouseand stilling well for a streamgaugingstation. (U.S. Bureau of Reclamation.)
134
CHAPTER 8 INSTRUMENTATIoN
Depth (stage) Measurements Most depth measurementsare made using a float and cable arrangementin a stilling well or a bubbler gauge.In the first insiance,a stilling well connectedto the channel(Fig. 3.6) is used to housea float devicethat activatesa recorder as it movesup and down. Figure 8.7 illustratesa self-reporting stilling well liquid-level station. Data from this station can be transmitted to un! central location for analysisand/orother use.A bubbler-typeinstallation makesusl of dry air or nitrogenas a fluid for bubblingthrough an oriflce into a channelbed. As the depth of flow changes,the changein head above the bubbler orifice causesa
Antenna mast Cover with special accessscrews
Transmitter Hydraulic damping device Level sensor Counter weight Mounting brackets
lnlet tubes
Sidecleanout port Bottomcleanout port
Figure 8.7 Self-reportingstilling well liquid-levelstation. (Courtesy of Sierra-Misco,Inc., Environmental products. Berkeley,CA.)
8.4 REMOTE SENSING 135 correspondingpressurechange.This resultsin a fluid-levelchangein the manometer connectedto the gassupplyand this in turn is usedto reflect stagevariationover time. The foregoingdescriptionsare of a few of the instrumentsused in hydrologic work. Both the limitations associatedwith their use and their reliability must be understoodif they are to be used correctly and their outputs are to be considered credible.
8.3 TELEMETRY SYSTEMS Historically,many gaugeswere read periodically by an individual making the rounds of installations.This servedwell whenthe purposeof the data wasto establisha base record of somevariablesuchasrainfall. But today,undermany circumstances,it has becomenecessaryto make continuousrecordingsof rainfalls, streamflows,and evaporation rates and to have thesedata availablefor the real-time operation of water managementsystemsand for forecastinghydrologicevents.Someexamplesof activities requiring real-time hydrologicdataarc managingreservoirs,issuingflood warnings, allocating water for various usessuchas irrigation, monitoring streamflowsto ensurethat treatiesand pactsare honored,and monitoringthe quality and quantity of waterfor regulatoryand environmentalpurposes.Accordingly,gaugingstationscapable of electronicallytransmitting their data to a central location for immediateuse havenow becomecommon.The advantagesof suchstationsincludeproviding information to usersin a time frame that meetsmanagementneeds,reducingthe costsof collecting data, and providing a continuousand synchronousrecord of hydrologic events.Figure 8.8 showsa streamgaugereporting station using radio transmission. Figure 8.9 illustratesa satellitedata collection and transmitting operation.T-|2
8.4 REMOTE SENSING Sincethe 1960s,remote sensinghasbecomea commonhydrologictool. Examplesof aircraft and satellitedatacollectionand transmission abound.13-16 Figure8.10 illustratesthe useof aircraft and satellitesin a snowsurveysystem.Other typesof surveys suchasthoserelatedto determiningimperviousareas,classifyingland usesfor assessing basin'wide runoff indexes, determining lake evaporation, and groundwater prospectingcan be depictedin similar fashion.Table 8.1, which summarizesoperational uses of satellite data in hydrology circa 1981, showsthe great diversity of remote sensingand data transmissionoptions that can be exercised.l6 The principal value of remote sensingis its ability to provide regionalcoverage and at the sametime providepoint deflnition.Furthermore,satellitecommunications can be digitized and are thus compatiblewith the transferof computerizedinformation. Following the evolution of linkages between computer and communications technology,new softwaresystemsincorporatingpowerful data managementsystems havebeen developed.Thesesystemsfacilitate the storage,compaction,and random accessof large data banks of information. one data managementoption, geographic information systems(GIS), allows the overlayingof many setsof data (particularly satellite-deriveddata) for convenientanalysis.Versatilecolor pictorial and graphic display systemsare also becomingattractiveas their costshavedecreased.ra
136
CHAPTER 8 INSTRUMENTATIoN
I
Utah
L.
Anzona
I
q)
z
B .H
Boulder City VIIF Radio Station
Mt. Hualpai Repeater Station
20
N
,&
"&*" rq* s
40
60
Scaleof miles Lake Havasu
EXPLANATION Parker Dam Black Point Repeater Station
Taylor'sFerry gauge
fl Water level gauge
A
X
il VIIF radio antenna tower H @ Transmitter-ieceiver radio
Colorado nver
Cibola gauge
VHF Very high frequency radio
lmperial Dam Repeater Station
Dam -'-:4
*
az*<3e -{/co '-Figure 8.8 Streamgaugereporting systemusing radio transmission.Water stage information is requestedfrom the gaugingstationsby VHF radio signal.In turn, this water stage information is obtained from the stream gaugesand automatically encodedand transmitted to the Boulder City receiving station. All downstream releasesfrom Hoover Dam are determinedand integrated with this streamflow information in controlling the flow of the lower ColoradoRiver. (U.S. Bureau of Reclamation.)
8.4
REMOTESENSING
Figure 8.9 Hydrologic data collection by satellite.(U.S. GeologicalSurvey.)
Low-altitude gamma-ray light.
Water 4gency forecastcenter
Figure 8.10. Satellite snow survey system.(AftenCalabreseand Thome'rs)
137
jo (d
E o E,
Q
o
o
32 o
o o
c o o
9 o
k
(u (E o
89'
IY
d
o
r
i
F-> 'o ri
z
X
!
s
a
c
o
Fl
IJJ
tJ J
tr| F
a
eE;
lJ-
U) uJ a f
* E E
J
z
o
F
(E o
o (r tu o d ut 6
*
CL
6
SEE
' E c c
! q o H
5 E K .=
o
9r
E E>,q F-.ts ,Y E R ! ' i
hiEE. g b " E6 F
F o
o a
;+
o E
J
o
G
c o
tT
e -o
E E a a
o
E
Ec, !o
2
o x E
o E
4
l
o r A 0
boo
o o
6 6
l 6 f i E
U' o (o
o
J
, .
bo o o
o
s o dt uI
o
(B ,o o.
e z
a
!
Ch
(E L
.
=
J
!t e qt a)
€3 -
E o
o E a
E
.
eCi
E O :.i c
I E t
O F , Y o E
€ g o o 4 =
Ee
O
E
>r-!!
;
+e L
d
8-:
at)
142
CHAPTER 8 INSTRUMENTATIoN With the advancementof satellite technology,the use of satellitesas remote sensorplatformshasspread.Currently availablesensorscan operatein a multitude of electromagneticradiation wavelengthsand the information content of their signals can include Surfacetemperatures,radiation, atmosphericpollutants,and other types of meteorologicaldata. As remote sensorsare improved to permit the attainmentof greater radiometric and geographicresolution, and as computer image-enhancing techniquesbecomemore sophisticated,it is certain that this powerful watermanagement tool will seeeven sreaterand more diversifieduse.
r summary Hydrologic data are important componentsof model design and testing and of a variety of statistical analyses.The quality of data obtained relate to attributes of measuringinstrumentsand to the featuresof gaugingsites.It is important to understandthe pros and consof variousinstrumentsand to know how they canbestbe used.
REFERENCES 1. "Irrigation WaterMeasurement,"Mountain StatesRegionalPubl. 1, revisionof Extension Circ. 132,Irrigation Water Measurement,University of Wyoming, Laramie, June 1964. 2. U.S. Bureau of Reclamation,Water MeasurementManual, 2nd ed. Washington,D.C.: U.S. GovernmentPrinting Office, 1967. 3. Leupold & Stevens,Inc. StevensWater ResourcesData Book, 4th ed. Beaverton,OR: Leupoldand Stevens,Jan. 1987. 4. W. Brutsaert,Evaporationinto the Atmosphere.London: D. Reidel Publishing, 1982. 5. "TexasLab InstallsWeighingLysimeters,"Irrigation J. 37(3),8-12(May/June 1987). 6. R. K. Linsley, Jr., M. A. Kohler, and J. L. H. Paulhus,Applied Hydrology. NeW York: McGraw-Hill, 1982. 7. R. J. C. Burnashand T. M. Twedt, "Event-ReportingInstrumentationfor Real:TimeFlash Flood Warning," American Meteorological Society, Preprints, Conference on Flash Floods:Hydro-meteorological Aspects,May 1978. 8. D. E. Colton and R. J. C. Burnash,"A Flash-FloodWarningSystem,"American MeteorologicalSociety,Preprints,Conferenceon Flash Floods:Hydro-meteorologicalAspects, May 1978. Aug. 1980. 9. R. J. C. Burnash,"AutomatedPrecipitationMeasurements," 10. R. J. C. Burnashand R. L. Ferral, "A SystemsApproach to Real Time Runoff Analysis with a Deterministic Rainfall-Runoff Model," International Symposium on RainfallRunoff Modeling,Universityof Mississippi,May 18-21, 1981. 11. Hydrologic ServicesDivision, National WeatherService,WesternRegion, "Automated Local Evaluationin Real Time: A CooperativeFlood Warning Systemfor Your Community," Feb. 1981. 12. R. J. C. Burnashand R. L. Ferral, "Examplesof Benefitsand the TechnologyInvolvedin Optimizing HydrosystemOperation Through Real:Time Forecasting," Conferenceon Real:TimeOperation of Hydrosystems,Waterloo,Ontario, June24-26, 1981. 13. M. Deutsch,D. R. Wiesnet, and A. Rango (eds.),Satellite Hydrology. Bethesda,MD: AmericanWaterResources Association.1981.
.
REFERENCES 143
"Agricultural Meteorology: SystemsApproacli to Weather and Climate Thirty-Second Needsfor,tgricuttrire, Forestry,and Natiiral iesources,o'in Proceedings, ResearchInstitute, Agricultural MD: Bethesda, R'searcih'Institute. Agiicultural tuteeting, 1 9 8 3 p, p . 7 5 - 8 5 . *NASA Water Resources/HydrologyRemote Sensing 1 5 . M. A. Calabreseand p. G. Thome, Programinttrelg80's,"insatettiteHydrology(M'Deutsch'D'R'Wiesnet''andA'Rango' 1981' pp' 9-15' eds). Bethesda,MD: American Water ResourcesAssociation' 16. G.K.Moore,..AnlntroductiontosatelliteHydrology,''hsate.tlite-Hydrology(M. WaterResqurces Deutsch,D. R. Wiesnet,and A. Rango,eds.).Bethesda,MD: American t7-4L. Association,1981,PP.
t4. J. F. Bartholic,
ChapterI
MonitoringNetworks
Prologue The purposeof this chapteris to: . Describeelementsof systemsfor monitoring hydrologicvariables. . Indicate the importanceof real-time and continuousrecording of hydrologic events. Information (data)is the requisitefoundationfor designingschemesfor manipulating (managing)hydrologicsystems,for evaluatingthe efficacyof actionstaken to correct problem situations,and for identifying trouble spots deservingattention. But to be useful, the data must be of the right type, in the right form, and appropriatelyrepresentativeof critical spaceand time dimensions. Modeling hydrologic systemsrequires an understandingof how these syster-ns actually function; cleaningup a toxic wastedischargerequirestracking the effectsof remedial actions;enforcing environmentalregulationsrequires knowledgeof what has happenedsincethe rules were implemented;and regulatingreservoirreleasesto meet specifiedtargetsrequiresa continuousunderstandingof the stateof the system beingoperated.The key to meetingsuchrequirementslies in the productsof carefully designedand managedmonitoring networks.Developingsuchnetworksis no small task, however,as the numberof variablesthat must be observedmay be very large, the instrumentsto measurethem costlyto install and operate,andthe datastorageand managementrequirementsextensive.Accordingly, a monitoring network's design must beginwith a thoroughunderstandingof its purposeso that the degreeof resolution providedby its observationsis adequate,but not excessive,for the task at hand. A goodrule is to keepthe networkassimpleaspossible,within the constraintsof what must be accomplished.
9.1 THEPURPOSE OF MONITORING The purpose of monitoring is to gather information in a continuum such that the dynamics of the systemcan be ascertained.According to Dressing,objectives of monitoring for nonpoint source pollution control include developmentof baseline
9.2 SPECIAL CoNSIDERATIoNS 145 information, generatingdata for trend analysis,developingand/or verifying models, and investigatingsingleincidentsor events.zTheseobjectivesare alsovalid for hydrologic monitoring in general,but they shouldbe supplementedby the following obje"tives:planning,real-time systemoperating,enforcingregulatoryprograms,and environmental policymaking. In the flnal analysis,the ultimate purposeof monitoring is to enhancedecisionmaking,whetherit be for development,management,regulation, or researchaims.
9.2 SPECIALCONSIDERATIONS Beforean acceptablemonitoringplan can be devised,theremustbe a full understanding of the hydrologic systemto be monitored and of the objectivesto be met by monitoring. The costs of monitoring can be very high and thus it is essentialthat monitoring networksbe efflcient and cost effective.r-5
Timeand SpaceVariability In general, monitoring networks are designedto have both spatial and temporal dimensions.Although monitoringa specificpoint locationmay be all that is necessary undersomecircumstances, it is more commonthat what is happeningin a regional settingis of importance.The temporal aspectis similar. While a snapshotat some point in time may suffice for some purposes,the time varianceof conditions to be tracked is usually critical for effective analysesandlor decisionmaking.Both the short-termand long-term variabilities of many targefsof monitoring must be ascertained. For example,water quality in a streamcan changerapidly with time, while changesin lake levels,suchas thoseexperiencedin the GreatLakes in the 1980s,are the result of long-termhydrologicvariability. Spatial variability must also be representedin a monitoring network: for example, infiltration ratesmay vary considerablywithin a region, rainfall intensitiesmay be quite different within even short distances,and water quality in a river might be different in upstreamand downstreamlocations.Topography,soils, vegetalcovers, and many other factors affecting the performanceof a hydrologic systemare also distributed differently in space,and these differencesmust be recognizedin the monitoring plan. The trick is to developa monitoring systemthat can (1) provide the neededdata,(2) recognizeregionaland temporal variabilities,and (3) keep installation, operation,and maintenancecoststo a minimum. To do this requiresa comprehensiveknowledgeof the systemto be monitored,an understandingof what the data obtainedby the systemwill be used for, and a knowledgeof the level of detail in collecting the data that must be exercisedin spaceand time.
DataRequirements The amountand type of datato be generatedby a monitoringsystemmustbe carefully consideredin its design. Selectingappropriateinstruments,determining sampling frequency,and settingdata formats are elementsthat must be considered.Questions such as how much do we need to know and when do we need to know it must be answered.The form and extensiveness of data must be tightly relatedto monitoring
146
CHAPTER9
MONITORINGNETWORKS
Flood warnlng Water managemeff
---: Telephone
Lift station monitoring control
Hardwire + + , . .
lnfrared + + xgnr Water quality monitoring
(Courtesyof Sierra-Misco, Inc.,EnvironFigure9.1 A telemetrymonitoringsystem. mentalProducts. Berkeley. CA.
,
objectives.Furthermore,it might be necessaryto monitor surrogatesinsteadof the condition to be tracked.' For example,if lake eutrophicationis the issue,phosphorus If this approachis taken, andchlorophyllconcentrationsmight be surrogateflre&sureS; selectionof appropriatesurrogatesis very important and the foregoingcomments aboutdata formats and so on are also applicable.Hydrologic,waterquality, land use and treatment, topographic,soils, vegetativecover, meteorologic,and many other typesof datamaybe requiredin combinationor separatelyin a monitoringplan. It is easyto seethat the amount of data required for a monitoring program can be enormous.Consequently,great care must be taken to seethat the data collection effort is not in excessof the objectivesof the monitoring program. Figure 9.1, depicting a telemetrymonitoring system,gives an indication of the variety of data that might be collectedin a monitoring program.
QualityControland QualityAssurance The costsof monitoring are usually substantialand thus it is essentialthat the data generatedbe of consistentlyhigh quality. Accordingly, most monitoring systems include quality control and quality assurance(QA/QC) elements.Quality control is a plannedsystemof activitiesdesignedto producea quality product(datain this case) that meetsthe needsof the user. Quality assuranceis a plannedsystemof activities designedto guaranteethat the quality control programis being carried out properly. A quality managementplan should be part of the overall monitoring program and should be preparedwhen the monitoring program is being developedto ensure that the data collectedwill be of a satisfactorynature for the monitoring program's objectives.3
9,4
NETWORKS HYDROLOGICAL-METEOROLOGICAL
147
To useror
Figure 9.2 Microcomputeruse in streamgauging.
IN MONITORING 9.3 USEOF COMPUTERS With the rapid technologicaldevelopmentof computers,especiallyinexpensivemicrocomputers,the oppoitunities foiautomated collection of all types of hydrologic and water quality data have increased substantially.Microcomputers, used with analog-to-digital converters,pressureor liquid-level sensors,and the appropriate software can, for example, be used in hydrologic monitoring systemsas flow metering/dataacquisitionsystems(Fig.9.2).4Furthermore,suchsystemsare highly versatile and they are rblatively inexpensive.Computer systemscan be customdesignedfor almost any dataacquisitionapplicationand they are often lesscostly than other commerciallyavailablehardwaresystemsdesignedfor the samepurpose.Computerscan convert raw datainto other more usefulforms, storedata for later use,and communicatewith other computerterminalsif necessary.As such,they are a powerful and important componentof modern hydrologicmonitoring systems.Figure 9.3 illustratesthe use of computersin a real-time telemetry system.
NETWORKS ETEOROLOGICAL e.4 HYDROLOGICAL-M Most modern hydrologic-meteorologicnetworks are designedto provide real-time information for purposessuchas hydropowerscheduling,releasingflows for irrigation, developingand testinghydrologicsystemmodels,regulatingreservoirdischarges, allocating water from multiple sources,streamflow forecasting,tracking pollutant transport, and enforcing environmental regulations. Hydrological-meteorological
148
CHAPTER9
MONITORINGNETWORKS
Water level
Weather station
Computer
:,/: Modem Data Collection
(Courtesy Figure9.3 Computer usein a real-timetelemetrysystem. of Sierra-Misco, Inc., Environmental Products, Berkeley,CA.)
networks may be designedto monitor physiographic,climatic, hydrologic,biologic, and chemicalfeatures,or combinationsof these,in a region or river basin.They must have gaugedensitiesand distributionsthat are sufficientto permit interpolationbetweengaugesitesin a mannerpermitting valid conclusionsto be drawn for the entire areacoveredby the network. Typically, measureinentsare madeof suchvariablesas precipitation, solar radiation, temperature,relative humidity, barometric pressure, snow depth, soil moisture,wind speed,streamflow,and water quality. In any event, special basin or regional climatic factors must be given due consideration.Each hydrological-meteorologicalnetwork is different in its purposeand setting and thus its designmust reflectboth the spatialand temporally varying featuresat the locality to be monitored along with the objectivesof the monitoring program.s
REFERENCES 149
r Summary Monitoring of hydrologicsystemsis essentialto better understandingof systeminteractions and to the designand testing of hydrologicmodels.It is also the meansby which a determinationcan be made of the effectivenessof measurestaken to alter watershedperformance.
REFERENCES t . S. J. Nix and P. E. Black (eds.),Proceedingsof the Symposiury. on Monitoring, Modeling, and Mediating Water Quality. Bethesda,MD: American Water ResourcesAssociation, 1987. 2. S. A. Dressing, "Nonpoint Source Monitoring and Evaluation Guide," in Ref. 1, pp. 69-78. J. J. Lawrenceand A. S. Y. Chau, "Quality Assurancefor EnvironmentalMonitoring," in Ref. I, pp. 165-176. 4. H. E. Postand T, J. Grizzard, "The Monitoring of StreamHydrology and Quality Using Microcomputers,"in Ref. 1, pp. 199-208. 5 . P. J. Gabrielsenand A. J. Carmeli, "Operation of a Hydrologic-MeteorologicMonitoring Networkin a SevereWinter Environment,"in Ref, l, pp. lI3-122.
PARTTHREE .
SURFACEWATER HYDROLOGY
C h a p t e r1 0
Runoffand the Catchment
r Prologue The purposeof this chaPteris to: . ' . . .
Expandon definitionsof termsfrequentlyusedin describingtherunoff process. Presentconceptsof surfacerunoff and drainagebasin discharge. Introduce elementsof drainagebasin geomorphology' Describequantitativemeasuresof watershedcharacteristics. Familiarize the readerwith elementsof frequencyanalysis'
Surfacewater hydrologydealswith the movementof water alongthe earth's surface as a result of precipitation and snow melt. Detailed analysisof surfacewater flow is highly important to suchfieldsasmunicipaland industrialwater supply,flood control, stieamflowforecasting,reservoirdesign,navigation,irrigation, drainage,water quality control, water-basedrecreation,and flsh and wildlife management. The relationbetweenprecipitationandrunoffis influencedby variousstormand basin characteristics.Becauseof thesecomplexitiesand the frequentpaucity of adequaterunoff data, many approximateformulashavebeendevelopedto relaterainfall andrunoff. The earliesfofihese were usuallycrudeempirical statements,whereasthe trend now is to developdescriptiveequationsbasedon physicalprocesses.
AND DRAINAGEBASINS WATERSHEDS 10.1 CATCHMENTS, Runoff occurswhen precipitationor snowmeltmovesacrossthe land surface-some of which eventuailyreachesnatural or artificial streamsand lakes'The land areaover which rain falls is called the catchmentand the land area that contributessurface runoff to any point of interestis called a watershed.This can be a few acresin size or thousandiof ,quut" miles.A large watershedcan contain many smaller subwatersheds. Streamsand rivers conveyboth surfacewater and groundwaterawayfrom high water areas,preventingsurfaceflooding and rising groundwaterproblems'The tract
154
CHAPTER 1O RUNOFF ANDTHECATCHMENT of land (both surfaceand subsurface)drainedby a river and its tributariesis called a drainage basin. A watershedsuppliessurfacerunoff to a river or stream,whereasa drainagebasinfor a given streamis the tract of land drainedof both surfacerunoff and groundwaterdischarge. Rain falling on a watershedin quantitiesexceedingthe soil or vegetationuptake becomessurface runoff. Waterinfiltrating the soil may eventuallyreturn to a stream and combine with surfacerunoff in forming the total drainage from the basin. The network of overlandflow coursesand defineddrainagechannelscomprisethe watershed.Surfacerunoff from tracts of land beginsits journey as overlandflory, often calledsheetflow,beforeit reachesa definedswaleor channel,usually beforeflowing more than a few hundredfeet. The lines separatingthe land surfaceinto watersheds are called divides.Thesenormally follow ridges and moundsand can be delineated using contourmaps,field surveys,or stereographpairs of aerial photographsto identify gradient directions.
ContributingArea In the majority of hydrologicanalyses,the magnitudeof total surfaceareacontributing direct runoff to somepoint of interestis needed.Becauseof variationsin topography, the true surfaceareacannotbe easilymeasured.The horizontalprojectionofland area is easilyobtainedand normally adoptedin hydrologiccalculations.This resultsin an error in actual watershedarea whereverthe projected area is less than the actual. Somesurfaceareain watershedsmay not contributeto surfacerunoff, so the error in using the projectedwatershedareais somewhatoffset.
PartialArea Hydrology For light storms,or for someflat areas,portions of the catchmentdo not contribute to runoff. Precipitationfalling on or flowing into depressedor blockedareascan exit only by seepageor evaporation,or by transpirationif vegetated.If sufficientrainfall occurs, such areasmay overflow and contribute to runoff. Thus the total area contributing to runoff varies with the intensity and duration of the storm. Methods for incorporating this phenomenonin hydrologic studies are calegorizedunder proceduresfor partial area lrydrology. In partial areahydrology,watershedareasare dividedby one of severalmethods into contributing (active) and noncontributing (passive)subareas.For infrequent (severe)storms,largerpercentagesof the watershedsurfacemay contributeto the peak flow and volume of runoff, which are the primary variables of interest to design engineers.For more frequent storms,significantly smaller portions of some waterpartial areahydrologyis seldomincorposhedsmay contribute.As a consequence, ratedin hydraulic structuredesign,and is of greaterinterestin watersupplyand water quality studies.As will be shownlater (Chapter12) unit hydrographtheory andrunoff curve numbermethodsare basedon linearity of rainfall and runoff, and assumethat the full watershedcontributesto runoff in all stormsand in proportional amountsat different times in the samestorm. Application of thesemethodsto watershedsthat havesignificantnoncontributingzonescould, and do, introduceerror ifthe zonesare nof first delineatedand the distributedeffectsproperly modeled.
10.2 BASINCHARACTERISTICS AFFECTINGRUNOFF
155
Subdivisionof contributing from noncontributingareashas traditionally been subjectivelyaccomplishedfrom siteinspection,topographicand soilsmaps,and aerial photos.Soils having good drainageclassifications,or dark tones or colors on aerial photos, can often be consideredas passiveareas.Other signs of noncontributing areaswould includepresehceof wetlands,grassedareas,rooftops (unlessconnected to the drainage),terraces,erosioncontrol structures,stockwateringponds,and flood control dams. Boughtontdevelopeda quantitativemethod of determiningthe proportion of a watershedthat contributessurfacerunoff in different storms,and at different times duringthe samestorm.by analyzingrainfall andrunoff records.His logic is asfollows: 1. Watershedscan be idealizedas a group of "surfacestoragecapacity" cells, eachrepresentinga fraction of the watershedarea and eachhaving some capacityto abstractrainfall into storage,infiltration, or evapotranspiration. 2. Runoff from eachcell occurs when rain fills the surfacestoragecapacity. 3. Runoff occursfrom the cell with the smallestcapacitybeforeflowing from the cell with the next largestcapacity(this is an assumptionby Boughton that has not been fully verified). 4. Using theseprinciples,storm data for the watershedare evaluatedfirst to find thosein which runoff occurs only from the area of smallestcapacity. This is done using a graphicalmethod outlined in the article that looks at slopechangesin the rainfall-runoff graph.Both the capacityof the cell and its area as a percentageof the watershedare estimated. 5. After subtractingthe contributionto runoff from the smallestcapacitycell, the capacityand contributingareafor the secondsmallestcapacitycell are determinedby the sameprocedure. 6. The process is repeateduntil all the runoff is accountedfor, or until 100 percent of the watershedis contributing,whicheveroccurs first. When Boughton applied the procedureto a test watershed,rit was found that runoff occurredfrom the entire watershedon only 3 of 30 eventsin the l5-year study period.In abouttwo-thirds of the runoff events,dischargeoccurredonly from the cell with the smallestsurfacestoragecapacity.
10.2 BASINCHARACTERISTICS AFFECTING RUNOFF The natureof streamflowin a regionis a function of the hydrologicinput to that region and the physical,vegetative,and climatic characteristics.As indicatedby the hydrologic equation,all the waterthat occursin an areaas a result ofprecipitation doesnot appearas streamflow.Fractionsof the grossprecipitationare divertedinto pathsthat do not terminatein the regional surfacetransport system.Precipitation striking the groundcango into storageon the surfaceor in the soil andinto groundwaterreservoirs beneaththe surface.The characterof the soil and rocks determinesto a large extent the storagesysteminto which precipitatedwaterwill enter.Opportunity for evaporation and transpirationwill also be affectedby the geologicand topographicnatureof the area.
156
CHAPTER1O RUNOFFAND THE CATCHMENT
StreamPatterns Wind, ice, and water act on land surfacesto createseveraltypes of drainagepatterns seen in nature. The particular design that results is a function of several factors including slope,underlying soil and rock properties,and the historiesof hydraulic action, freeze-thaw activity, and sedimenttransport.
(a) Dendritic system
(b) Trellis system
(c) Radial system
(e) Meandering stream
(f) Braided stream
(g) Anabranching stream
(h) Reticulate stream
Fi-gxre 10.1- -Streampatterns(combinedsystemsand individual streamshapes).
10.2 BASINCHARACTERISTICS AFFECTINGRUNOFF
157
Typical streampatternsare shownin Fig. 10.1.The most common,dendritic, is characterizedbynumeroussmall tributariesjoining at right anglesinto higher-order streams,eventually forming the major rivers in the region. The smaller tributaries often occur in sufficientquantitiesthat little land surfaceareais left uninterceptedby a definedchannelof someform, The maximum overlanddistancebetweenchannels in theseareasseldomexceedsa few hundredfeet. Trellis patternsare characterizedbylong main streamsinterceptedby numerous shorterright-angletributaries.They are commonin the Appalachians(EasternUnited States)and are also seenin the Rocky Mountains along the foothills, Multi-basin patterns,also called derangedsystems,occur in low gradient swampy areaswith numeroussurfacedepressionsand normally haveonly a few tributaries.Theseoccur in glaciated,windblown,and permafrostareas,and are common in plains and mountain valley regionsof the United States.Radial patternsare typically found in foothill areasor mountain areaswith more advancedsoil development. Individual streamsfavor one or more of the four patternsshown on the lower portion of Fig. 10.1.Streamsare rarely straightexcepton steepslopesin homogeneous materials. Braided streams are characterizedby numerous interconnected channelsflowing aroundand overislandsandbars,inundatingmostduringhigh flows. Braided streamsare generallytransportinglarge amountsof sediment,but often less than the amount supplied. They have been called incipient forms of meandering streamsdueto the fact that many revert to meanderingor other forms when sediment suppliesor other factorschange.Meanderingin an otherwisestraightchanneloccurs as a result of transversecurrents.Thesecurrents are consideredto be the result of forcesactingon the streamparticles,includingbed and bank shearforcesand coriolis effects. In evaluatingthe effects of changesin streamflows,a relationship known as Lane's Law is often applied.It statesthat the productof bed slopeand waterdischarge is proportional to the product of sedimentsize and transportrate. Changingany one of thesefour terms results in the likelihood of a shift in one or more of the others. Constructinga reservoit,for example,reducesthe sedimenttransportedinto the reach just downstream.By Lane's Law, either the slope or dischargemust decreaseor sedimentparticle sizemust increaseto offsetthe changein sedimenttransport.Most often, the slope decreaseswhen the sediment-hungryflows deepenthe bed in the reach.Degradation(downwardcutting) of the bed of the Missouri River, for example, has occurredbelow someof its upstreamreservoirs,isolatingboat marinasand water intake structuresin somelocations.
Geomorphology of DrainageBasins The principal geologicfactorsthat affect surfacewatersare classifiedaslithologic and structural. Lithologic effects are associatedwith the composition,texture, and sequenceof the rocks, whereasstructuraleffectsrelatemainly to discontinuitiessuchas faults and folds. A fault is a fracture that resultsin the relative displacementofrock that was previouslycontinuous.Folds are geologicstrata that are contortedor bent. Variationsin the erodibility of the different strata can easily lead to the creation of distinctive forms of drainagesystems. Both large-scaleandlocal effectson the storageand movementof surfacewaters existbecauseof geologicactivity and structure.For example,drainagepatternsare
1 58
CHAPTER10
RUNOFFAND THE CATCHMENT
determinedto a large extentby the nature of land forms. On the other hand, flowing surfacewatersalso affect the surfacegeometrythrough the processof erosion.Thus significant land forms resulting from volcanic activity, folding, and faulting affect drainage,whereasdrainagepatterns,havingbeengenerated,can alsomodify the land forms by creatingvalleys,deltas,and other geomorphicfeatures. Streamsare classifiedasbeingyoung,mature,or old on the basisof their ability to erodechannelmaterials.Youngstreamsare highly active and usually flow rapidly so that they are continually cutting their channels.The sedimentload imposed on thesestreamsby their tributariesis transportedwithout deposition.Mature streams are those in which the channel slope has been reduced to the point where flow velocitiesarejust able to transportincoming sedimentand where the channeldepth is no longerbeingmodifiedby erosion.A streamis classifiedasold whenthe channels in its systemhavebecomeaggraded.The flow velocitiesof old streamsare low dueto gentleslopesthat prevail.Wide meanderbelts,broad flood plains,anddeltaformation are alsocharacteristicof old streams.The lower reachesof the Mississippi,Rhine, and Nile are examples.Flows in young river basinsare often o'flashy,"*h"t"u, sluggish flows are common to older streams. The description of a drainagebasin in quantitative terms was an imponant forward stepin hydrologyand can be tracedback in largepart to the efforts of Robert E. Horton.2Strahler,Langbein,and othershaveexpandedHorton's original work.3-a To quantify the geometry of a basin, the fundamental dimensionsof length, time, and mass are used. Many drainagebasin featuresthat are important to the hydrologistcan be quantified in terms of length, length squared,orlength cubed. Examplesare elevation,streamlength, basin perimeter,drainagearea, and volume. The conceptof geometricsimilarity can be appliedto drainagebasinsjust as it is to many other systems.3 Most readerswill be awareof model-prototypestudiesof aircraft, dams,and turbomachinery.Suchstudiesinvolveconsiderationsof geometricas well as dynamic similarity. In the samemannerthat inferencesas to the operationof a prototype can sometimesbe drawn from a geometricallysimilar model, inferences canalsobe drawnaboutthe operationof one drainageareaon the basisof information obtained from a similar one. Perfect similarity will never be realized if natural drainagesystemsare compared,but striking similarities have been observedwhich can often be put to practical use.
Measuresof DrainageBasin Characteristics Important measuresof drainagebasin characteristicsinclude overlandflow lengths and streamlengths.The conceptof streamorder is often associatedwith the dimension of streamlength.
AFFECTINGRUNOFF 1O.2 BASIN CHARACTERISTICS
159
'/, "81 {,'v '\'rr
;)
Figure 10.2 Sketch indicating definition of streamorder.
to the streamorder, provided that a large enoughsampleis investigated.The order number permits comparisonsof drainage systemsthat are quite different in size quantity.Suchcomparisonsshouldbe madeat becausethe numberis a dimensionless locations in the two systemsthat have a similar geometry; that is, second-order streams,third-order streams,and so forth. Streamlengthsare determinedby the measurementof theh projectionsonto a If horizontal plane. Topographicmaps are useful for obtaining suchmeasurements. possible the meanlenglh of a streamsegmentZ, of order a is definedas L,, then it is to determine Z, using2
.
tr-
-2!i, L,,
(10.1)
N,
whereN, is the number of streamsegmentsof streamorder u. Another measurerelated to stream length is the distanceL"o from a point of intereston the main streamto a point on the primary channelthat is nearestthe center of gravity of the drainage arca (center of gravity of the plane atea of the drainage basin).Studiesof basinlag (time betweenthe centersof massof effectivestorminput and the resulting runoff ) havemadeuse of this dimension. Of particular significancein the physiographicdevelopmentof a drainagebasin is the overlandflow length Ls. This is the distancefrom the ridge line or drainage divide, measuredalongthe path of surfaceflow which is not confinedin apy defined channel,to the intersectionof this flow path with an establishedflow channel.If a drainagebasin of the first order is the basicelementof a larger drainagesystem,then a representativeoverlandflow length can be determinedfor thesefirst-orderbasins. One apprbachis to measurea numberof possibleflow paths from a map of the area and-toaveragethese.In somecases(for example,with the rational method,Chapter
160
CHAPTER1O RUNOFFAND THE CATCHMENT
15), the use of the longestoverland flow length is prescribed,measuredfrom the upstreamend of the first-order stream to the most remote point of flow that will terminateat this point.
Areal Measurements Just as linear measuresrelate to many factors of hydrologic interest, so do areal measures.For example,the quantity of dischargefrom any drainagebasinis obviously a function of the areal extentof that basin. Correlationshavebeenobservedbetweenthe averagearea,Au, of basinsof order u, andthe averagelength of streamsegments,2,. Thesevariablesare often relatedby an exponentialfunction. For example,studiesof sevenstreamsin the Maryland-Virginia areaby Hack haveproducedthe relationship6 L :
(10.2)
I.4Ao6
where L = the streamlength measuredin miles to the drainagedivide A : the drainagearea(miz) Hack's observationsindicatethat as the drainagebasinincreasesin size,it becomes longer and narrower; thus precisegeometricsimilarity is not preserved. Drainageareahas long beenusedas a parameterin precipitation*runoff equations or in simpleequationsindexingstreamflowto area or other parameters.Many early empirical equationsare of the form3 Q: cA: where Q a measureof flow suchas mean annual runoff A : the size of the contributine drainaeeatea
(10.3)
Valuesof c and m are determinedby regressionanalysis(seeChapter26); Fig. 10.3 illustratesa relation of this form.
€o r u
q
8
( ( ) 6 =
a
I
3
./
10
20
30 40 5060 80 100
200
Areatmi2) Figure 10.3 Runoff-drainage arca correlation for five Maryland streams (1933 storm
AFFECTINGRUNOFF 1O.2 BASINCHARACTERISTICS
161
Other arealmeasuresincludedefinitionsof the basinshapeandthe densityof the drainagenetwork or drainage density, definedas the ratio of total channelsegment lengthi cumulatedfor all streamorderswithin a basin to the basin area.The stream segmentsin a drainagebasin (total frequency is defined as the summation of all number of segmentsof all orders)divided by the drainagearea.
Channeland BasinGradients surface The slopesof a drainagebasinand its channelshavea very strongeffecton the characteristic the profiles exhibit channel stream runoff pro""r, of thairegion. Most this of decreasingslopeproceedingin a downstreamdirection.Figure 10.4illustrates particular.trait. Also illustrated in elevationdrop dividedby the channt suchthat the areasbetweenthe ave that is, A, : Azin the figure. The g asparametersto describedrainaget describe make this clear. Some mathemalicalfunctions that are used to more fully streamprofilesarelinear, exponenti ical value to representthe Primal Schwartz.TThis factor,known as th a uniform channelthat is equivalen sametraveltime. This factorhasber maximum from the centerof massof rainfall excessto the peak rate of runoff ) and discharge. In additionto the slopeofthe streamchannel,the overall land slopeofthe basin slopes is an important topographicfactor.A quantitativerelation betweenvalley wall method used commonly A Strahler.3 by and streamcnannetstopeshas been derived method of determiningthe slopesof a basin has been presentedby Horton'SThe area drainage of the map topographic a grid over involvessuperimposinga transparent drainage the with intersections its b"t*""n in question.nacfr grlJnne is measu."d needed' divide; the numberof intersectionsof eachgrid line with a contourline is also using made be then A determinationof the land slopecan nsec0, S:--t
!
Distance from head of stream
Figure 10.4 Typical streamprofile'
(10.4)
162
oHAPTER 10 RUNoFFAND THEoATCHMENT Drainage boundary Horizontal grid line
r
uContour'
Contour interval = 50 ft scaie
Figure 10.5 Determinationof meanland slope:numberof vertical intersections: 72; tumber of horizontal intersections= 120; total length of vertical grid segments: 103,900ft; total length of horizontalgrid segments: 101,200ft. 72x50 120 x 50 : 0.035ftlft : 0.059ftlft Ss " : 10 t , 2 0 0 103;900 .s + (.. 0.035+ 0.059 : 0.047ftlft Mean slope : 2
,s:
where n : the total number of contour intersectionsbv the horizontal and vertical grid lines t the total length of grid line segments(horizontal and vertical) h - the contour interval 0 * the anglemeasuredbetweena normal to the contoursand the grid line L
_
Because0 is very difficult to measureit is often neglected,and separatevaluesof averageslopein the horizontal and vertical are computedand then averagedto obtain an estimateof the meanland slope.This procedureis illustratedin Fig. 10.5.
Area-ElevationRelation How the areawithin a drainagebasinis distributedbetweencontours(Fig. 10.6)is of interestfor comparingdrainagebasinsand gaining insight into the storageand flow characteristicsof the basin.For suchstudies.an areadistribution curve suchas that shown in Fig. 10.7 is used.The curve can be obtained by planimeteringthe areas
RUNOFF AFFECTING 10.2 BASINCHARACTERISTICS
(
163
l l \ ' / t r 1 l l \ / / / / r r \ f t /
. ' , \: \ I . i/ z ' r ' \
,ffi_-_.w;i.i .Figure 10.6 Topographic map of WendyRun drainagearea showing20-,40-,and60-ftcontourlines. betweenadjacentcontoursor by using a grid as in Fig. 10.5 and forming the ratio of the number of squaresbetweencontoursto the total number of squarescontained within the drainageboundaries.The mean elevationis determinedas the weighted averageof elevationsbetweenadjacentcontours.The medianelevationcan be deterrnined from the area-elevationcurvesas the elevationat 50 percent,
-
e
300
E 2so o
€
2oo
Io
l)u
r! '
100
Median elevation
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
of area Percentage
Figure 10.7
An area-elevation distribution curve.
100
1 64
CHAPTER10
RUNOFFAND THE CATCHMENT
DrainageBasin Dynamics Geomorphology'likg hydrology,was largely qualitative in nature in its formative years'With the passingof time and the greatlr needfor reliablequantitativeinformation, the sciencehasprogressedto the point whererational relations betweenvariables are being developed.Theserelationsire usually intendedto quantify theinieractions betweenthe factorsthat modify the land forrnand the land iorm ifsef. In addition, equationsrelatingthegeomorphicpropertiesto hydrologic, climatologic,or vegetative factorsare beingsought.some of the iunctional ielations of particulir significanceto the hydrologistwill be discussedin the following chapters.
10.3 RUDIMENTARYPRECIPITATION-RUNOFF RELATIONSHIPS ritation and runoff has beento plot annual rend line, and estimatethe percentageof rtities determinedthis way, however, are :e ofreliability is higherfor drainageareas rnal or other types of variation, that is, an e procedure.The resulting equationtakes
the form
o:($)rr-Pr)
(10.5)
1902. I
1898r
^ 4 0
8 3 6
X 7 ,7 23
--l--
1 926
--i--I
. ) J +
32
a 903
a
1 9l 0 r - J 6 .E
l .
I t28
trg
a
Slope
s
0.57
29_
1920 1l 1924
: -1 9 1 8 i q)5-oL f--a 7921o
1932
1930
o1!
o
. 1897 90 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1 0 1 1 t 2 t 3 ! 4
Runoff (in.)
Figure 10.8 Annual precipitation and annual runoff in the NeoshoRiver basin above Iola, Kansas.(U.S. GeologicalSurvey Data.)
165 10,3 RUDIMENTARYPRECIPITATION-RUNOFFRELATIONSHIPS
S : the slopeof the line (LPILQ) Pa : & baseprecipitation value below which Q is zero From Fig. 10.8 the relation for the examplewould be Q: 0'57(P 24) where Q and P are the annual runoff and precipitation, respectively,in inches' Considerablescatterof severaldata points from the assumedrelation indicatesthat this type of computation should be used with care. For rough approximationsin preliminary planning studies,suchmethodsare frequently helpful, however.EquationsresembiingEq. 10.5areimprovedif otherparameterssuchasantecedentprecipitation, soil moisture,season,and storm characteristicsare included. Suchrelations can be describedusing multiple regressiontechniquesor graphicalmethods'Linsley and co-workerspresenta very completetreatmentof methodsfor developingcorrelations involving severalvariables.e Soil moisturerelationsnormally havea soil moistureindex as the independent of actualantecedentsoil moistureare not genervariable,sincedirect measurements ally practical. Indexesthat havebeen insertedare groundwater,flowat the beginning of the storm, antecedentprecipitation, and basin evaporation.loGroundwatervalues shouldbe weightedto reflect the effectsof precipitation occurring within a few days of the storm becausesoil moisture changesfrom previousrains may affect results. Pan-evaporationmeasurementscan be employedto estimatesoil moistureamounts, since eviporation is related to soil moisture depletion.tl Antecedentprecipitation indexes(API) haveprobably receivedthe widestusebecauseprecipitationis readily measuredand relatesdirectly to moisture deficiencyof the basin. A typical antecedentprecipitation index is (10.6) Po: aP6'l bP, -f cP., where
P.:
po,p,." :
precipitationindex (in.) the antecedent
fi"HTlJ:;fJil:rr:Hifl3*ff"-e
for and presenr vear
This index links annualrainfall and runoff values.r2Coefficientsa, b, andc are found by trial and error or other fitting techniquesto producethe best correlationbetween the runoff and the antecedentprecipitation index. The sum of the coefficientsmust be 1. Kohler and Linsley13haveproposedthe following API for use with individual storms: P o : b r P l + b 2 P 2+ ' ' '
+ btPt
(10.7)
wherethe r subscripton P refersto precipitationwhich occurredthat many daysprior to the given storm,and the constantsb (lessthan unity) are assumedto be a function of t. Valuesfor the coefficientscan be determinedby correlationtechniques'In daily evaluationof the index, b, is consideredto be related to / by b,: K'
(10.8)
whereK is a recessionconstantnormallyrepoftedin the range0.85-0.98.The initial
166
cHAprER1o RUNoFFANDTHE cAToHMENT
value of the API (P"s)is coupled to the API / days later (P",) by Por:
PagK'
(10.e)
To evaluatethe index for a particular day basedon that of the precedingone, Eq. 10.9becomes Po, :
KPox
(10.10)
becauset : I. Various empirical relations for API have been proposed.Most are based on correlating two or three variablesand at best yield only rough approximations.In many casesthesewere developedwithout consideringphysical principlesor dimensional homogeneity.An addedshortcomingis that many formulas fit only a specific watershedand have little generalutility. Empirical equationsdemandgreat caution and an understandingof their origin. EXAMPLE 10.1 PrecipitationdepthsP, for a l4-day period are listed in Table 10.1. The API on April 1 is 0.00. Use K : 0.9 and determinethe,API for each successiveday. Solution. Equation 10.9 reducesto API,:
K(API,-1)+ P,
which was applied in developingthe successivevaluesof API, in Table 10.1. TABLE10.1 (A Precipitation April 1 2 J
4
)
'6 7 8 9 10 ll
t2 l3 t4
0.0 0.0 0.5 0.7 0.2 0.1 0.0 0.1 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.6 0.0 0.0
API,
0.00 0.00 0.50 1 .l 5 t,24 t.22 1.10 1.09 1.28 t.l5 1.04 1.54 1,39 |.25
10.4 STREAMFLOW FREOUENCY ANALYSIS Hydrologistsestimatestreamflows.Two approachesare employed.The first is a physical processesapproachin which runoff is computed on the basis of observedor expectedprecipitation.The secondis foundedon statisticalanalysesofrunoffrecords .- --vvi{}out resott-to precipitation data. Such investigationsusually include frequency
FREQUENCYANALYSIS 10.4 STREAMFLOW
167
C a o a ao
12 months
-
x.
1.0 Example 1.0 in drought with R.I. = 17 yr
0.1 10
100
RecurrenceInteryal (Yr)
for FiveRivFigure 10.9 Low-flowfrequencydataconsolidated ers.(AfterWhipple.r5; studies(Chapter 27) to indicatethe likelihood of certain runoff eventstaking place. A knowledgeof the frequencyof runoff eventsis helpful in determiningrisks associatedwith proposeddesignsor anticipatedoperatingschemes.Frequencyanalysesare usuallydiiectedtowardstudiesof miximum (flood) andminimum (drought)flows.ra'1s Figure 10.9 illustrates a typical drought frequency analysis.Unfortunately,many existingrunoff records are short-term; as a result they limit utility for reliable frequency analyses.Few adequaterecords are availableearlier than about 1900. In some cases,sequentialgeneratingtechniques(Chapter 22) can be used to develop syntheticrecords. Time-series analysesare particularly pertinent to the problem of estimating trends, cycles, and fluctuationsin hydrologic data. They also permit derivation of generatingprocessesby which syntheticrecordsof runoff can be developed.
RecurrenceIntervaland Frequency The recurrenceinterval (R.I.) is definedas the averageinterval over a long period of yearsduring which a correspondingmagnitudeof somehydrologicvariableis at least met. This parameteris also called the return period, and sometimes,though less appropriately,thefrequency of the event.For the examplein Fig. 10'9, droughtsless than 1 in. occurredin 8 ofthe 136yearsofrecords.The 1.0in. droughthasan average recurrenceinterval of about 17 years.Statedanotherway,on the average,one year of every l7-year sequenceis expectedto experiencea drought of at most 1.0 inch. Similarly,eachyearthe probabilityof a 1.O-in.droughtis 8/136 = 0'059, or about 6 percent. This is defined as the exceedenceprobability or frequency, and is the re-iprocal ofthe return period.It shouldbe obviousthat the 1.0-in.droughtcould
168
CHAPTER 10 RUNoFFAND THEoAToHMENT occur in any year,or in severalconsecutiveyears.This type ofanalysiscannottell the investigatorwhat will happenthis year or next, and allows only an estimateof the averagerecurrenceinterval and the probability of occurrencein any given year. This subjectis fully developedin Chapter27.
10.5 STREAMFLOW FORECASTING Surfacewaterhydrologyis basicto the designof many engineeringworks and important in waterquality managementschemes.In addition, the ability to providereliable forecastsof flowsfor shortperiodsinto the future is of greatvaluein operatingstorage and other works and in planning proper actions during times of flood.e'16A good exampleis the operationof a reservoirwith an uncontrolledinflow but with a means of regulatingthe outflow. If information on the natureof the inflow is determinablein advance,then the reservoircan be operatedby somedecisionrule to minimize downstreamflood damage.Suchoperationscan be computerizedto continually improve estimatesbasedon incoming dataandthus offer direction on the natureof the releases to be made.For river forecaststo be reliable, adequate,dependabledata on various watershedand meteorologicconditions are neededon a continuing basis.Modern monitoring stationscapableof telemeteringdata to computercontrol centersprovide an important supportfunction for forecasting.The methodsusedto forecastflows are basically the same ones empfoyedin design: precipitation-runoff equations,unit hydrographs,watershedmldels, and flow-routing techniques.
r Summary Runoff is probablythe most complexyet most important hydrologicprocessto understand.It has attractedthe attention and focus of engineersand scientistsand comprisesthe greatestpercentageby far of most hydrology textbooksand publications. The conceptsintroducedhere will be more fully developedin the next six chapters, as well as in significantportions of Parts Five and Six.
PROBLEMS
10'1'ffi,',T'#:fl :Jfr *:l;J:ff ;J3;:1,!;";ffi :?'fi#.n.}il:H:i* Hfi'#':iJf what purposesmight you use this? 10.2. Selecta rain gaugerecord of interest.Use the annual valuesas data to calculatethc coefficientsof an antecedentprecipitation index of the form of Eq. 10.8. 10.3. Determinethe drainagedensityof the basin shown.Area : 6400 acres.Lengths are in miles.
REFERENCES 169
Lengths of channel segments in mi between points
Figure for Problem 10.3 L0.4. Using any dictionary,plus indexesor glossariesfrom one or two other hydrologytexts, find and compare definitions of the following terms: runoff, direct runoff, direct surface runoff, surface ruryoff,surface water, overlandflow, streamflow,drainage, watershed,catchruen&inage basin, subbasin,dr ainage divide.
"systematic Procedure for Evaluating Partial Areas of Watershed 1. Boughton, W. C., Runoff," Proc. ASCE J. Irrigation and Drainage Engineering116, 1 (February 1990). "Drainage Basin Characteristics,"Trans.Am. Geophys.Union 13(1932). 2. R. E. Horton, "Geology-Part II," in Handhok of Applied Hydrology. New York: 3. A. N. Strahler, McGraw-Hill, 1964. "TopographicCharacteristicsof DrainageBasins,"U.S. Geological 4. W. B. L4ngbeinet al., Survey,Water Supply Paper,968-c(I941 ). "Erosional Developmentof Streamsand Their Drainage Basins:Hydro5. R. E. Horton, physicalApproach to Qualitative Morphology,"Bull. Geol. Soc.Am.56(1945). "studies of Longitudinal StreamProflles of Small Watersheds,"Tech. Rept. 6. J. T. Hack, 18, Columbia University,Departmentof Geology,New York, 1959. 7. A. B. Taylor and H. E. Schwartz,"IJnitHydrographT ag and PeakFlow Relatedto Basin Characteristics," Trans.Am. Geopltys. Union 33(1952). "Discussionof Paper,Flood Flow characteristicsby c. S. Jarvis," ?ans. R. E. Horton, 8. ASCE 89(1926)'. 9. R. K. Linsley, Jr., M. A. Kohler, and J. L. H. Paulhus,AppliedHydrology,2nd Ed' New York: McGraw-Hill, 1975. 10. ven Te chow (ed.), Handbook of Applied Hydrology. New York: McGraw-Hill,1964. 11. R.K.Linsley,Jr.,andWC.Ackerman,"MethodofPredictingtheRunofffromRainfall," Trans.ASCE 107(1942). 12. S. S. Butler, EngineeringHydrology. EnglewoodCliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1957.
170
oHAPTER10 RUNoFFANDTHEoAToHMEI 13. M. A. Kohler and R. K. Linslev. , / WeatherBureau,Res.Paper34, l95L T4, Leo R. Beard, "statistical Methodsin Hydrology," U.S. Army EngineerDistrict, Sacrf mento,CA,1962. 1 5 . William W. Whipple, Jr., "RegionalDrought FiequencyAnalysis," Proc. ASCEJ. Irrigd
16.
Chapter1'1
Hydrographs
r Prologue The purposeof this chapteris to: . Characterizea hydrographas a time plot of the dischargeof surfacerunoff arld groundwaterfrom drainagebasins. ' Introduce the componentsof hydrographsso that the reader can rel9le them of runoff presentedin subsequdnf-chapters. to the quantltative assessments . Describethe time relationshipsmost commonly usedin hydrographanalysis. Hydrographanalysisis the most widely usedmethod of analyzingsurfacerunoff. Its presentationin most textbooks is normally confined to one chapter. Becauseof numerousdevelopmentsin hydrographanalyses,three chaptersare dedicatedto the subjectin this text. Chapter 11 defineshydrographsand expandsthe conceptsintroduced in Chapter 6. The conceptsreferred to as unit hydrographtechniquesare packagedtogetherin Chapter 12. Individual streamflowhydrographshapesvary as flow travels downstream,and the conceptsfor analyzingthese changes,called hy' drographrouting methods,are presentedin Chapter 13.
HYDROGRAPHS 11.1 STREAMFLOW A streamflowhydrographprovidesthe rateof flow at all pointsin time duringand after a storm or snowmeltevent.l Hydrologistsdependon measuredor computed(synthesized) hydrographsto provide peak flow rates so that hydraulic structurescan be designedto accommodatethe flow safely.Becausea hydrographplots volumetric flow rates againsttime, integration of the area beneath a hydrographbetWeenany two points in time givesthe total volume of water passingthe point of interestduring the time interval. Thus, in addition to peak flows,hydrographsallow analysisof sizesof reservoirs,storagetanks, detentionponds,and other facilities that deal with volumes of runoff. A knowledge of the magnitude and time distribution of streamflow is essentialto many of theseaspectsof watermanagementand environmentalplanning.
172
CHAPTER11
HYDROGRAPHS Storm period hydrograph o u
q b0
Y41 oar.
Inflection point
\?
Hydrograph in period of no direct runoff and where no reservoir regulation exists rcflects discharge from groundwatet Storm period hydrograph End of Beginning of
direct runoff
direct runoff
,l
Continuous hydrograph
Figure 11.1 HydrographO"o;;.
SHAPE HYDROGRAPH 11.2 FACTORSAFFECTING A hydrographhas four componentelements:(1) direct surfacerunoff, (2) interflow, (3) groundwateror baseflow, and (4) channelpregipitation.2The rising pott(rn of a hydrographis known astheconcentrationcurye;the regionin the vicinity of the\eak is called the crest segment;and the falling portion is the recession.3The shapeof a hydrographdependson precipitation pattern characteristicsand basin properties. Figure 11.1illustratesthe definitionspresented.
Processes Precipitation-Streamflow Duriirg a given rainfall, water is continually being abstractedto saturatethe upper levelsof the soil surface;however,this saturationor infiltration is only one of many Rainfall is also interceptedby trees, plants, 4nd roof continuous abstractions.4-6 surfaces,and at the same time is evaporated.Once rain falls and fulfills initial requirementsof infiltration, natural depressionscollect falling rain to form small puddles,creatingdepressionstorage.In addition, numerouspools of water forming detentionstoragebuild up on permeableand impermeablesurfaceswithin the watershed.This storedwater gathersin small rivulets, which carry the wateroriginatingas overlandflow into small channels,then into larger channels,and flnally as channel flow to the watershedoutlet. Figure 11.2aillustratesthe distribution of a prolonged uniform rainfall. Although such an event is not the norm, the conceptis useful for showingthe mannerin which detentionand depressionstoragewould be distributed. a certain amountof baseflow In general,the channelof a watershedpossesses during most of the year. This flow comesfrom groundwateror spring contributions and may be consideredas the normal day-to-dayflow. Dischargefrom precipitation excess-that is, after abstractions are deducted from the original rainfallconstitutesthe direct runoff hydrograph(DRH). Arrival of direct ninoff at the outlet accountsfor an initial rise in the DRH. As precipitationexcesscontinues,enoughtime qlapqgsfor progressivelydistant areasto add to the outlet flow. Consequently,the
11.2 FACTORSAFFECTINGHYDROGRAPTISHNPC
179
Depressionstorage fi
o
a
d
Time (b)
Figure 11.2 (a) Distribution of a uniform storm rainfall for condition of is ultimately no interceptionloss.Note that all water storedin depressions evaporatedor infiltrated while somedetentionstorageis also subjectedto theselosses.(b) Equilibrium dischargehydrograph.
duration of rainfall dictatesthe proportionatearea of the watershedamplifying the peak, and the intensity of rainfall during this period of time determinesthe resulting greatestdischarge.
HydrographShapes If the rainfall maintainsa constantintensityfor a long enoughperiod of time, a state of equilibrium dischargeis reached, as depicted by curve A in Fig. 11.2b. The inflection point on curveA often indicatesthe time at which the entire drainagearea contributes to the flow. At this time maximum storase of the watershedis only
174
CHAPTER11
HYDROGRAPHS
and partially complete.As rainfall continues,maximum storagecapacityis attained of condition The is reached. (runoff)] iqrliUri"t" finflow (rainfall) equals outflow Extended nature' in attained maximum storageand equiiibrium is seldom if ever its duration negateany rainfall lnuy o"Iu., but viriations in intensity throughout intensity' rainfall constant possibility of u IRH of the theoretical shapefor Anormalsingle.peakDRHgenerallypossessestheshapeshownbycurveBin peak magnitudeof this Fig. 11.2b rather tian iy the "ur',oJin Fig. 11.2a.The time to and the size,slope, rainfall' ofthe hyirograph dependsonih" intensity and duration has beenreachedfor a flow peak shape,and storagecapacityof the watershed.once of supply coming its source given isolatedra'instorm,itt" ORg beginsto descend, and channel detention as such largely from water accumulatedwithin the watershed storage. processesinvolvedin forming the DRH can be better understoodby visualizing theprecipitationexcessaspartiallydisposedofimmediate$bysurfacerunoffwhile releasedlater from a portion remainsheld within the watershedboundariesand is of the duration effects integrated storage.Thus the shapeand timing of the DRH are asthe effect of well as factors and intensityofrainfall and other hydrometeorological capacity' storage the physiogiaphicfactorsof the watershedupon the
COMPONENTS 11.3 HYDROGRAPH
\
into its com\It is important to understandhow the hydrographcan be subdivided andwatershed ofprecipitation nenrpar15andto look at the effecton hydrographshape purpose' features.Figures11.3and Il'4 areusedfor this with respect A hydiographis a continuousgraphshowingthe rate of streamflow stage indicates that recorder strip to time, ,rtr*ityoutained by -"anr of a continuous hydrograph a discharge to vefsustime (stale hydrograph),which is then transformed generallytaken to by applicationof a rating curve.Hereafter,the term lrydrographis indicate a dischargehYdrograPh' a pgriod Figure t t.gi lttustrai"* ih" hydrographof a permanentstreamduring groundbecause lrydrograph between precipitation events,known i" i bot" flow the base of modification cause water sustainsthe flow. Four general conditions of sets following the using HortonT flow hydrographshape.They aL describedby inequalities:
i
Setl
i>f F(S, Set4 i>f
set3
F)Sr.
11.3 HYDROGRAPH COMPONENTS 175
I
\
(e)
(0
fo)
(h)
t
Figure 11.3 Effectsof stormandbasincharacteristics on hydrographshape. or addedgroundwatercomponentsdevelops.The entire effect of the storm would be to slightly reducethe soil moisturedeficiencysr. The field capacityis the amountof water held in the soil after excessgravitationalwater has drained. The conditions describedby Set 2 still do not produce direct surfacerunoff, although the comlponentsof interflow and groundwater flow are added to channel precipitation.The initial hydrographwould be modified,sincethe field capacityof the soil is exceeded.Figure 11.3b illustrates this condition. Note that deviation of the hydrographfrom the original baseflow curve is likely to be very small under these conditions. Figure 11.3c illustrates a casewhere surfacerunoff becomesa componentof flow becausei > f. In this example,interflow and groundwaterflow are zero,assoil
176
CHAPTER11 HYDROGRAPHS
End ofrainfall
9C
Groundwater flow
Time
of thehydrograph. Figure 11.4 Components
moisture deficiency still exists,although at a reduced level. Channel precipitation likewise constitutesa component. In the final set, Fig. 11.3d, all four componentsexist with rainfall intensity exceedinginflltration rate andthe field capacityofthe soil is reached.This casewould of a large storm event. be typical Figures 1l.je-h illustrate how hydrograph shape can be modified by areal variations in rainfall and rainfall intensity and by watershedconfiguration.8Minor fluctuationsshownin thesehydrographsare linked to variationsin stormintensity.In Fig. 11.3eonly the delayingeffectspertinent to a storm over the upstreamsectionof the areaareindicated.Figure 11.3fshowsthe reverseof this condition.Figures11'3g and h depict the comparativeeffects of basin geometry. In most hydrographanalyses,interflow and channelprecipitation are grouped with surfacerunoff rather than treated independently.Channelprecipitation begins with inceptionof rainfall and endswith the storm.Its distributionwith respectto time is highly iorrelated with the stormpattern.The relative volume contributiontendsto increasesomewhatas the storm proceeds,since stream levels rise and the water surfaceareatendsto increase.The fraction of watershedareaoccupiedby streamsand lakes is generallysmall, usually on the order of 5 percent or less,so the percentage of rrnoff relatedto channelprecipitation is usually minor during important storms. Distribution of interflow is commonly characterizedby a slowly increasingrate up to the end of the storm period, followed by a gradual recessionthat terminatesat the intersectionofthe surfaceflow hydrographand base flow hydrograph.Figure 11.4 illustrates the approximatenature of the componentsof channelprecipitation and interflow. The baseflow componentis composedof the water that percolatesdownward until it reachesthe groundwaterreservoirand then flowsto surfacestreamsasgroundwater discharge.The groundwaterhydrographmay or may not show an increase
11.4 BASE FLOW SEPARATION
'
177
during the actual storm period. Groundwateraccretion resulting from a particular storm is normally releasedover an extendedperiod, measuredin days for small watershedsand often in months or yearsfor large drainageareas. The surfacerunoff component consistsof water that flows overland until a streamchannelis reached.During large stormsit is the most significanthydrograph component.Figure 11.4illustratesthe surfacerunoff and groundwatercomponentsof a hydrograph.As pointed out in Fig. 11.3,the relative magnitudeof eachcomponent for a given storm is determinedby a combinationof many factors.Hydrographsare analyzedto provideknowledgeof the way precipitationand watershedcharacteristics interact to form them. The degreeof hydrographseparationrequireddependson the objective of the study. For most practical work, surfacerunoff and groundwater componentsonly are required.Researchprojectsor more sophisticatedanalysesmay dictate considerationof all components.When multiple storms occur within short periods,it is sometimesnecessaryto separatethe overlappingparts of consecutive surfacerunoff hydrographs.
11.4 BASEFLOWSEPARATION Severaltechniquesare usedto separatea hydrograph'ssurfaceand groundwaterflows. Most are basedon analysesof groundwaterrecessionor depletioncurves.If there is no addedinflow to the groundwaterreservoir,and if all groundwaterdischargefrom the upstreamareais interceptedat the stream-gaugingpoint of interest,then groundwater dischargecan be describedby either e'to er: eoK' or er: eo€-K' where eo : q, : K: e:
( 11 .1 )
a specifiedinitial discharge the dischargeat any time / after flow 46 arecessionconstant baseof natural logarithms
Time units frequently used are days for large watershedsand hours or minutes for small basins.A plot of either yields a straight line on semilogarithmicpaper by plotting / on the linear scale. For most watersheds,groundwaterdepletioncharacteristicsare approximately stable,sincethey closelyfit watershedgeology.Nevertheless, the recessionconstant varieswith seasonaleffectssuchas evaporationand freezingcyclesand other factors. Becauseq, dt is equivalentto -dS, where S is the quantity of water obtainedfrom storage,integrationofEq. 11.1produces t- 4o s - Qlog" K
(rr.2)
This equation determinesthe quantity of water releasedfrom groundwaterstorage betweenthe times of occurrenceof the two dischargesof interest,or it can be usedto calculatethe volume of water still in storageat a time some chosenvalue of flow occurs.To get the latter, 4, is setequalto zero and qsbecomesthe referencedischarge. Figure 11.5ais a plot of Eqs. 11.1and II.2 andprovidesadditionaldefinition.
178
CHAPTER11
HYDROGRAPHS
qo
.. ,?
q
K \r3
/
?r
t (a.)
I
l
I
I
qo discharge at rcginningof arr interval discharge at :nd of an inten,a\ Qt
I
II
Interval = unit period in / whicht is expreissed .
q d
/ qo Qt
Time (b) Figure 11.5 Baseflow model' to
.
t1
Groundwaterdepletioncurvescan be analyzedby variousmethodsto evaluate the recessionconstantK. One of thesewill be described.Data from a stream-gaugi.ng stationare a prerequisiteand shouldreflectrainlessperiodswith no upstreamregulation,'suchas a fesefvoir,to affect flow at the gaugingpoint. Otherwisean adjustment with its own enors is introduced. From the streamflow data, plot a portion of the recession hydrograph (Fig. 11.5b) to find values of dischargeat the beginning and end of selectedtime intervals.Flows at the beginningof eachinterval are analogousto 4e,whereasthose at the end are analogousto q1.Next, selectseveraltime intervalsand plot correspondvalues ing qe'sversusq,'s shownin Fig. 11.6.The time periodbetweenconsecutive of 4 shouldbe identical for eachdatum set. Figurestaken from recessioncurvesof times that still reflect surfacerunoff will usually fall below and to the right of a 45o line drawn on the plot. Thesevalueswill also be associatedwith larger numbersfor 4. Points taken from true groundwater recessionperiods should approximately
11,4 BASEFLOWSEPARATION 179 r.-,x. ^are points plotted from discharges for different groundwater discharge periods
,/ o
eo nd qt are taken for equal time
I
,(
I .5r"2'
9/ .,
/(^lI A
/#
- s l o p e o 0f A=
fi:
x
inEq11.1
/ Figure 11.6 Graphical rnethod for determiningrecessionconstant K. (U.S. Departmentof Agriculture, Soil ConservationService.)
describea straightline.Becauseh : eo : 0 when4o: 0, a straightlinecanbefitted graphicallyto the datapoints.The slopeof this line is qrfqo : K. Usingthis value,the depletioncurve plots as a straight line on semilogarithmicpaper (r is the linear scale variable)or as a curveon arithmeticpaper,Fig. 11.5a.
SeparationTechniques r
Severalmethodsfor baseflow separationare used when the actual amount of base flow is unknown. During large storms,the maximum rate of dischargeis only slightly affectedby baseflow, and inaccuraciesin separationmay not be important. The simplestbaseflow separationtechniqueis to draw a horizontalline from the point at which surfacerunoff begins,PointA in Fig. 11.7, to an intersectionwith the hydrographrecessionwherethe baseflow rate is the sameasat the beginningof direct runoff as indicatedby Point B. A secondmethodprojects the initial recessioncurve downwardfromA to C, which lies directly below the peak rate of flow. Then point D on the hydrograph,representingN daysafter the peak, is connectedto point C by a straightline definingthe groundwatercomponent.One estimateof N is basedon the formula3 N - Ao'2
(11.3)
where N : the time in days A = the drainageareain squaremiles A third procedureis to developa baseflow recessioncurve using Eq. 11.1 for data from the segmentFG, and then back-calculateall base flow to the left of Point fl
180
cHAPTER11 HYDRocRApHS
o
9p F
Time
Flgure 11.7 Illustrationof somehydrograph separation techniques. wherethe computedcurve beginsto deviatefrom the actualhydrograph,marking the end of direct runoff. The curve is projected backward arbitrarily to some Point E below the inflection point and its shapefrom C to E is arbitrarily assigned.A fourth widely usedmethod is to draw a line betweenA and F, and a fifth common method is to project the line AC alongthe slopeto the left of A , and then connectPointsC and
o d d
12N 6P
t21|'{{ 6A
12N 6P
tz]0|{ 6,{
I2N
6P
IzM
Figure 11.8 Illustration of base flow separation:hydrograph for the Uharie River near Trinity, North Carolina, February 25, 1939. (U.S. Departmentof Agriculture, Soil ConservationService).
TIME RELATIONSHIPS 181 11.5 HYDROGRAPH
B. All thesemethodsare approximatesincethe separationof hydrographsis partly a subjectiveprocedure. Figure 11.8illustratestwo graphicalseparationtechniquesto determinesurface runoff and groundwaterflow components. Line AD representsthe simpleprocedure of connectingthe point of the beginningof direct runoff with the flrst point on the groundwaterrecessioncurve (an advantageoverthe horizontal line techniquebecause the time baseof direct runoff is much shorter).Ctrve ABCD is constructedfrom the extensionof the baseflow recessioncurve.
TIMERELATIONSHIPS 11.5 HYDROGRAPH Wavetravel time is definedas the time required for direct runoff originating at the most remotepoint in the channelto reachthe outlet. The last drop of direct runoff to passthe outlet conceptuallytravelsoverthe watersurfaceand reachesthe outlet at the speedof a small surfacewave,rather than at a speedequal to the averagevelocity of flow. The wavetravel time is fasterthan the averagevelocity and varieswith channel shapeand other factors.For a rectangularchannel,the ratio is approximately5/3 (see Section 13.1 for other wavevelocities).The time base(Fig. 11.4) of a hydrographis consideredto be the time from which the concentrationcurve beginsuntil the directrunoff componentreacheszero. An equationfor time basemay take the form T6:t"*t,
(rr.4)
where To : the time baseof the direct runoff hydrograph /" : the duration of runoff-producingrain t- : the excessrainfall releasetime Watershedlag time, illustrated in Fig. 11.4, is definedas the time from the penterof tt massof effectiverainfall to the centerof massof direct runoff. Other definitionsand severalequationsrelating lag time to watershedcharacteristicsare providedin S_ecchapters. tion 11.7 and subsequent Becauseofits importancein unit hydrographtheory, the excess-rainfallrelease time is introduced.This is definedasthe time requiredfor the last, most remotedrop ofexcessrain that fell on the watershedto passthe outlet, signallingthe cessationof direct runoff. It is easilydeterminedas the time interval betweenthe end of rain and the end of direct runoff. Only that part of the outflow which classiflesas direct runoff (excessrain) is consideredin dqterminingthe releasetime. Watershedoutflow normally continuesafter cessationof direct runoff, in the form of interflow andbaseflow. Releasetime is very similar by definitionto wavetraveltime and time of concentration (Section11.6). A foundational assumptionof unit hydrographtheoryl2 is that the watershed excessreleasetime is a constant,regardlessof the storm duration, and is related to The excessreleasetime is also basinfactorsratherthan meteorologicalcharacteristics. conceptuallyidenticalwith the time baseof an instantaneousunit hydrograph(IUH). This is the runoff hydrographfrom 1.0 in. of excessrain applieduniformly over the watershedin an instant of time (seeChapter 12). Both wavetravel time and excessrainfall releasetime are often used synonymouslywith time of concentration.
182
CHAPTER11
HYDROGRAPHS
11.6TIMEOF CONCENTRATION The most common definition of time of concentrationoriginatesfrom consideration of overlandflow. If a uniform rain is appliedto atract, the portions nearestthe outlet contribute runoff at the outlet almost immediately.As rain continues,the depth of excesson the surfacegrowsand dischargeratesincreasethroughout.Runoff contributions from variouspoints upstreamarrive at later times, addingthemselvesto continuing runoff from nearerpoints, until flow eventually arrives from all points on the watershed,"concentrating" at the outlet. Thus, concentrationtime is the time required,with uniform rain, for 100percentof a tract of land to contributeto the direct runoff at the outlet.e As a secondpopular definition, the concentrationtime is often equatedwith either the excess-rainfallreleasetime or the wave travel time becausethe time for runoff to arrive at the outlet from the most remotepoint after rain ceasesis assumed to be indicative of the time required for 100 percent contribution from all points during any uniform storm having sufficient duration. The latter definition is often preferred becausefew storm durations exceedthe time of concentration,making determinationof /. possibleonly by examiningexcessrain recession. Becausetime of concentrationis conceptuallythe time requiredfor 100percent of the watershedto contribute, it is also often defined as the time from the end of excessrainfall to the inflection point on the hydrographrecessionlimb (e.g., see Fig. 12.2).The reasoningusedin this definitionis that direct runoff ceasesat the point of inflection. For a small tract of land experiencinguniform rain, the entire areacontributes at approximatelythe sametime that the runoff reachesan equilibrium.This givesrise to yet anotherdefinition of time of concentration.If rain abruptly ceased,the direct runoff would continueonly as long as the excess-rainfallreleasetime t,. On the basis of the seconddeflnition.excessreleasetime and time of concentrationcan be considered equivalent. Numerous equationsrelating time of concentrationto watershedparameters havebeen developed.Table 11.1 summarizesseveralpopular versions.Other variations are presentedin Chapters12, 15,16, and25.
11.7 BASIN LAG TIME The relative timing of rainfall and runoff must be known if drainageareashaving subbasinsare to be modeledor if continuoussimulation is desired.A basic measure of timing is basi'nlag, which locatesthe hydrograph'spositionrelativeto the causative stormpattern.It is most often definedas the differencein time betweenthe centerof massof effectiverainfall and the centerof massof runoff produced.Other definitions are also used.Two of theseare ( 1) the time interval from the maximum rainfall rate to the peakrate of runoff and(2) the time from the centerof massof effectiverainfall to the peak rate of flow. Time lag is characterizedby the ratio of a flow length to a mean velocity of flow and is thus a property that is influencedby the shapeof the drainagearea,the slopeof the main channel,channelroughnessand geometry,and thg'storm pattern.
11.7 BASINLAGTIME
183
TABLE11.1 SUMMARY OF TIMEOF CONCENTRATION FORMULAS Formula for t" (min)
Method and date Kirpich (1940)
tc : L : S :
USBR Design of Small Dams
t" : L :
(r973) Il :
lzzatd (7946)ts
0.00782077S-o38s length of channel/ditch from headwater to outlet, ft average watershed slope, ftlft
Developedfrom SCS data for sevenrural basins in Tennesseewith well-definedchanneland steepslopes(37o to 1O7o);for overlandflow on concreteor asphaltsurfacesmultiply t;by 0.4; for concretechannelsmultiply by 0.2; no adjustments for overland flow on bare soil or flow in roadsideditches.
60(lI.9L31H)o38s length of longest watercourse, ml elevation difference between divide and outlet, ft
Essentiallythe Kirpich formula; developedfrom small mountainousbasinsin California (U.S. Bureauof Reclamation,1973,pp. 67-7I).t4
41.025(0.0007, t
Developedin laboratory experimentsby Bureau of Public Roadsfor overland flow on roadwayand turf surfaces;valuesof the retardance coefficientrange from 0.0070 for very smooth pavementto 0.012 for concretepavementto 0.06 for denseturf; solution requiresiteration; product i times Z shouldbe = 500.
c)Lozz
-c S0.333i0.66?
I : c: Z : ,S: FederalAviation Administration ( 1970)r6
Kinematic WaveFormulas Morgali and Linsley (1965)'? Aron and Erborge (1973)18 SCS Lag Equation (1972)te
rainfall intensity,in/h retardancecoefficient length of flow path, ft slopeof flow path, ftlft
r" = 1.8(1.1- C)Losofso333 C : rational method runoff coefficient l, : length of overland flow, ft S : surface slope, Va O.94Lo6no6 (io 45o 3)
l, n I S
: : : :
length of overland flow, ft Manning roughnesscoefficient rainfall intensity in/h averageoverland slope ftlft t.67 Lo8[(tooo/cN)- 9]oi
,. ._- @
L : hydraulic length of watershed (Iongestflow path), ft CN : SCS runoffcurve number S : averagewatershedslope,Vo
SCS AverageVelocity Charts(1975, 1986),0
Sarrce.' After Ref. 13.
Remarks
',' : l v L 60- v Z : length of flow path, ft V : ureragevelocity in feet per secondfrom Fig. 3- 1 of TR 55 for various surfaces
Developedfrom air field drainagedata assembled by the Corps of Engineers;method is intended for use on airfield drainageproblems,but has been used frequently for overlandflow in urban basins. Overland flow equation developedfrom kinematic wave analysis of surface runoff from developed surfaces;method requiresiteration sinceboth i (rainfall intensity) arrdt, are unknown; superposition of intensity-duration-frequency curve gives direct graphical solution for t". Equation developedby SCS from agricultural watersheddata; it has been adaptedto small urban basinsunder 2000 acres;found generally good where areais completelypaved;for mixod areas it tendsto overestimate;adjustmentfactorsare applied to correct for channelimprovementand imperviousarea; the equationassumesthat t" : 1.67 X basinlag. Overland flow charts in Ref. 20 provide average velocity as function of watercourseslope and surfacecover.
184
CHAPTER11
HYDROGRAPHS
Various studieshave been conductedfor the purpose of developingrelations descriptiveof time lag. Most prominent of thesewas the work by Snyderon large natural watersheds.2lHis original equation has been widely used and modified in variouswaysby other investigators.Eaglesonhas proposedan equationfor lag time on sewereddrainageareashavinga minimum sizeof 147 acres.2z An early investigation (1936) on small drainageareas(2-4 acres)was conductedby Horner in his classicalwork on urbandrainagein St. Louis,Missouri.23 Horner'swork wasinconclusive in that it did not yield a deflned procedure,but he did conclude that the comparativelywide rangein the lag time at eachlocation led to the inferencethat the lag was a variable,its valuebeingdeterminedmore by rainfall characteristicsthan by characteristicsof the drainagearea. Snyder'sstudybasedon data from the AppalachianMountain regionproduced the following equationfor lag time:z1 t,1:
where
c,(L""L)o3
( 11 . s )
/1 : the lag time (hr) betweenthe centerof massof the rainfall excessfor a specifiedtype of storm and the peak rate of flow I'"o : the distancealongthe main streamfrom the baseto a point nearestthe centerof gravity of the basin (mi) I : length of the main stream channel (mi) from the base outlet to the upstreamend of the streamand including the additional distanceto the watersheddivide C, : & coefficientrepresentingvariationsof types and locationsof str'eams
For the areastudied,the constantC, was found to vary from I.8 to 2.2, with somewhatlower valuesfor basinswith steeperslopes.The constantis consideredto includethe effectsof slopeand storage.The value of 4 is assumedto be constantfor a given drainagearea,but allowanceis madefor the useof different valuesof lag for different types of storms. The relation is consideredapplicable to drainage areas rangingin sizefrom 10 to 10,000mi'. In a studyof seweredareasrangingin size from 0.22 to 7.51 mi2,Eagleson22 developedthe equation "t ', where
tr : L :
: -
L ( l . 5 / n ) R 2 / 3s t / 2
(11.6)
lag time, the center of mass of rainfall excess to the peak discharge (sec) the mean travel distance (ft), which is equal to the length of that portion
of the sewerwhich flows full n : the weightedManning's coefficientfor the main sewer : the weightedhydraulic radius of the main sewerflowing full { S : the weightedphysicalslopeof the main sewer Eagleson'sequationdirectly includesthe effects of channelgeometry and slope,as well as basin shape,and thus representsa refinementof the Snyderapproach.It also indirectly includesthe important effect of the storm pattern.
PROBLEMS185 Linsley and Ackerman give examplesof applicationof the following modified form of Snyder'sequation.24
t,:C,+!
(rr.1)
where s is a weighted slope of the channel and the other variablesare as defined previously. Other investigatorshaverepresentedtime lag by equationsof the form
t t =K +
( 11 . 8 )
Vs
Numerous other derivations of relations for watershedlag times can be found in standardhydrologictexts and periodical literature. Others are includedwith someof the syntheticunit hydrographdiscussionsin Chapter 12.
r Summary Understandingthe structureof hydrographSis important to many designand water supply applications.The hydrographrepresentsthe portion of the hydrologiccycle that engineersmostoften needin orderto determineratesof flow in streamsfor setting bridge lengthsand elevations,designingflood protection measures,and establishing areal extent of flooding. Similarly, the volume of drainageinto a reservoiror past a water supply diversionis determinedfrom the areaunder the hydrograph.Accurate estimatesof thesevolumesare important to designof dams,reservoirs,pipelines,and ' numerousother structures. After graspingthe fundamentalsof hydrographcomponents,including the time relationshipspresentedin this chapter,the reader should be well preparedfor the quantitativedevelopmentsof hydrographtheory and applicationspresentedthroughout Chapters12 through 16 and in Part Five.
PROBLEMS 11.1. Referto Fig. 11.1.Replotthis hydrographand usetwo different techniquesto separate the baseflow. 11.2. Obtain streamflowdata for a water courseof interest.Plot the hydrographfor a major runoff event and separatethe baseflow. 11.3. For the event of Problem I1.2, tabtlate the precipitation causingthe surfacerunoff and determinethe duration of runoff-producing.rain. Estimatethe time of concentration and useEq. I 1.4 to estimatethe time baseof the hydrograph.Comparethis with the time basecomputedfrom the hydrograph. 11.4. Tabulatedbelow are total hourly dischargerates at a cross sectionof a stream.The drainagearea abovethe sectionis 1.0 acre. a. Plot the hydrographon rectangular coordinate paper and label the rising limb (concentrationcurve), the crest segment,and the recessionlimb.
186
CHAPTERll HYDROGRAPHS b. Determinethe hour of cessationof the direct runoff usinga semilogplot of Q versus time. c. Use the base flow portion of your semilog plot to determine the groundwater recessionconstantK, d. Carefully constructand label baseflow separationcurveson the graph of Part a, using two different methods.
Time(hr)
Q (cfs)
Time (hr)
@ (cfs)
0 1 2 3
102 100 98 220 512 630 460 330
8 9 l0 11 t2
2lo 150 105 75 60 54 48.5 43.5
I
5 6 7
IJ
t4 15
11.5. On a neatsketchof a typical total runoff hydrograph,showor dimensionthe (a) storm
hyetograph,(b) beginningofdirectrunoff, (c) cessationtimeofdirectrunoff' (d) base fllw separationassumingthat additional contributions to base flow are negligible during ihe period of rise, and (e) crest segmentof the hydrograph' 11.6. For an urban watershedassignedby your instructor,obtain measuresof the watershed area,length, and slope,and compareestimatesof the time of concentrationusing the Kirpich, USBR, FAA, and SCSLag equationsin Table 11.1'
REFERENCES 1. American Society of Civil Engineers,Hydrology Handbook, Manuals of Engineering Practice,No. 28. New York: ASCE, 1957. "A 2. Donn G. DeCoursey, Runoff HydrographEquation," U.S. Departmentof Agricul.ture, AgriculturalResearchService,Feb. 1966,pp.4I-116' 3. R. K' Linsley, M. A. Kohler, and J' L. H' Paulhus,Applied Hydrology' New York: McGraw-Hill, 1949. "Erosional Developmentof Streamsand Their DrainageBasins:HydroA R. E. Horton, physicalApproach to QuantitativeMorphology,"Bull. Geol' Soc'Am' 56(1945)' "An Approach Toward a PhysicalInterpretationof Infiltration Capacity," 5 . if.-n. gorton, Sci. Soc.Am. 5,399-417(1940). Soil Proc. "An Inflltration Equation with Physical Significance,"Soil Sci.77(1954). 6 . J. R. Philip, 7 . R. E: Horion";Surface Runffi Phenomena.Ann Arbor, MI: EdwardsBros., 1935. 8 . R. J. M. DeWiest,Geohydrology.New York: Wiley' 1965' 9 . ,.Hydrology,,'in EngineeringHandbook, Sec. 4, U.s. Department of Agriculture, Soil ConservationService,1972. "Discussionof Analysis of Runoff characteristicsby o. H. Meyet," Trans. 1 0 . B. S. Barnes, ASCEl0s(1940). "Unit HydrographLag and PeakFlow Relatedto Basin 1 1 . A. B. Taylorand H. E. Schwartz, Characteristics," Trans,Am. Geophys. Union 33(1952).
REFERENCES 187 "Streamflow 12. L, K. Sherman, from Rainfall by the Unit-GraphMethod," Eng.News-Rec. 108(1932). 1 3 . D. F. Kilber, "Desk-top methods for urban stormwatercalculation," Ch. 4 in Urban Stormwater Hydrology, Water ResourcesMonograph No. 7, American Geophysical Union, Washington, D. C., 1982. 14. U.S. Bureauof Reclamation,Designof SmallDams,2nd ed., Washington,D.C.,1973. 1 5 . C.F.Izzafi,, "Hydraulicsof RunofffromDevelopedSurfaces,"Proceedings,26th Annual Meetingof the HighwayResearchBoad,26, pp. 129-146, December1946. 16. FederalAviation Administration,"Circular on Airport Drainage,"ReportA/C 050-532058, Washington, D.C., 1970. n. J. R. Morgali, andR. K. Linsley,"ComputerAnalysisof OverlandFlow,"./. Hyd.Div., Am. Soc.Civ.Eng.,9l, no. HY3, May 1965. 1 8 . G. Aron, and C. E. Egborge,"A PracticalFeasibility Study of Flood PeakAbatementin Urban Areas,"U.S. Army Corpsof Engineers,Sacramento, Calif., March 1973. 1 9 . Soil ConservationService,"National EngineeringHandbook, Sec. 4, Hydrology," U.S. Dept. of Agriculture,U.S. GPO, Washington, D.C., 1972. 20. Soil ConservationService,"Urban Hydrology for Small Watersheds,"TechnicalRelease 55, Washington, D.C., 1975(updated,1986). 2 t . F. F. Snyder,"Synthetic Unit Graphs," Trans.Am. Geophys.Union 19, 447-454(1938). 22. Peter S. Eagleson,"CharacteristicsofUnit Hydrographsfor SeweredAreas," paperpresentedbeforethe ASCE, Los Angeles,-CA,1959,unpublished. 23. W. W. Horner, and F. L. Flynt, "RelationBetweenRainfall and Runoff from Small Urban Areas," Trans.ASCE 62(101), 140-205(Oct 1956). aA R. K. Linsley,Jr.,andW. C. Ackerman,"Methodof PredictingtheRunofffromRainfall," Trans.ASCE 107(1942\.
C h a p t e r1 2
Unit Hydrographs
r Prologue The purposeof this chapteris to: . Define unit hydrographsand show their utility in hydrologicstudiesand design. . Developfully the current methodsof obtaining, analyzing,and synthesizing unit hydrographs. . Presentmethodsfor converting unit hydrographsfor one storm duration to other storm durations. Waysto predict flood peak dischargesand dischargehydrographsfrom rainfall events havebeenstudiedintensivelysincethe early 1930s.One approachreceivingconsiderable use is called the unit lrydrographmethod. 12.1 UNIT HYDROGRAPH DEFINITION The concept of a unit hydrographwas first introduced by Shermant'zin 1932. He defineda unit graph as follows:2 givendrainage area, Ifa givenone-day rainfallproduces a 1-in.depthofrunoffoverthe thehydrograph showingtheratesat whichtherunoffoccurredcanbe considered a unit graphfor that watershed. Thus, a unit hydrographis the hydrographof direct runoff (excludesbaseflow) for any stormthat producesexactly 1.0inch of net rain (the total runoff after abstractions).Sucha stormwould not be expectedto occur,but Sherman'sassumptionis that the ordinatesof a unit hydrographare t.O/P times the ordinatesof the direct runoff hydrographfor an equal-duration storm with P inchesof net rain. The term "unit" hasto do with the net rain amountof 1.0inch and doesnot mean to imply that the duration of rain that producedthe hydrographis one unit, whether an hour, day,or any other measureof time. The storm duration,X, that producedthe unithydrographmustbe specifiedbecausea watershedhasa differentunit hydrograph
12.1 UNIT HYDROGRAPHDEFINITION
189
for eachpossiblestorm duration. An X-hour unit lrydrograp,his defined as a direct runoff hydrographhavinga 1.0-in. volumeand resultingfrom anX-hour stormhaving a net rain rate of 1,/Xin.lhr. Az-hr unit hydrographwould havea 1.0-in. volume producedby a 2-hqstorm,and a 1-dayunit hydrographwould be producedby a storm having 1.0 in. of eicessrain uniformly producedduring a 24-hr period. The valueX is often a fraction. Figure 12.1illustratesa2-ltr,l2-hr, and24-hrwthydrograph for a given watershed.
t (b)
24hr
)z nl T (c)
Figure 12.1 Illustration of 2-br, I2-hr, and 24-ht unit hydrographsfor the same watershed(Note: a : b : c : 1' X A).
190
CHAPTER 12 UNITHYDROGRAPHS By Sherman'sassumption,applicationof an X-hourunit graphto designrainfall excessamountsother than 1 in. is accomplishedsimply by multiplying the rainfall excessamount by the unit graph ordinates,since the runoff ordinatesfor a given duration are assumedto be directly proportional to rainfall excess.A 3-hr storm producing2.0 in, of net rain would haverunoff rates2 times the valuesof the 3-hr unit hydrograph.One-half inch in 3 hr would produceflowshalf the magnitudeof the 3-hr unit hydrograph.This principle of proportional flows is expandedin Section 12.3 and appliesonly to equal duration storms. Implicit in deriving the unit hydrographis the assumptionthat rainfall is distributed in the sametemporal and spatialpattern for all storms.This is generallynot true; consequently,variationsin ordinatesfor different stormsof equal duration can be expected. This chapteris organizedto defineunit hydrographsfirst, then presentmethods of deriving unit hydrographsfrom actual rainfall and runoff records (Section 12.2). After familiarizing the readerwith the origin of unit hydrographs,Section I2.3 presentsmethodsof applyingunit hydrographsto generatedirect runoff hydrographsfor any storm with durationsthat are multiple integersof the U.H. duration. The constructionof unit hydrographsfor stormswith other than integermultiples of the derived duration is facilitated by a method known as the S-lrydrograph developedby Morgan and Hulinghorst.3The procedure,as explainedin Section 12.4, employs a unit hydrographto form an S-hydrographresulting from a continuous appliedrainfall. The need to alter duration of a unit hydrographled to studiesof the shortestpossiblestorm duration-the instantaneousunit rainfall. The concept of instantaneousunit hydrograph(IIJH) is tracedto Clark6and can also be used(Section 12.5) is constructingunit hydrographsfor other than the derived duration. The previousdiscussionassumesthat the analysthasrunoff and rainfall datafor deriving a unit hydrographfor the subject watershed.The application of unit hydrographtheory to ungaugedwatershedsreceivedearly attentionby Snyderaand also by Taylor and Schwartz,5who tried to relate aspectsof the unit hydrographto watershed characteristics.As a result, a full set of synthetic unit-hydrographmethods emerged.A numberof theseare presentedin Section12.6.
12.2 DERIVATION FROM OF UNITHYDROGRAPHS DATA STREAMFLOW Data collection preparatoryto deriving a unit hydrographfor a gaugedwatershedcan be extremelytime consuming.Fortunately,many watershedshaveavailablerecordsof streamflowand rainfall, and thesecan be supplementedwith office records of the Water ResourcesDivision of the U.S. GeologicalSurvey.TRainfall records pay be securedfrom ClimatologicalDatas publishedfor eachstatein the United Statesby the National Oceanicand AtmosphericAdministration (NOAA). Hourly rainfall records for recordingrainfall stationsare publishedas a Summaryof Hourly Observationsfor the location. Summariesare listed for approximately300 first-order situationsin the United States. To developa unit hydrograph,it is desirableto acquireas rnanyrainfall records aspossiblewithin the study areato ensurethat the amountand distributionof rainfall
12.2 DERIVATION,OFUNIT HYDROGRAPHSFROM STREAMFLOWDATA
191
over the watershedis accurate$ known. Preliminary selectionof storms to use in deriving a unit hydrographfor a watershedshouldbe restrictedto the following: 1. Stormsoccurring individually, that is, simple storm structure. 2. Storms having uniform distribution of rainfall throughout the period of rainfall excess. 3. Stormshavinguniform spatial distribution over the entire watershed. Theserestrictionsplace both upper and lower limits on size of the watershedto be employed.An upper limit of watershedsize of appro5imately1000 mi2 is overcautious, althoughgeneralstormsover suchareasare not unrealisticand somestudiesof areasup to 2000 mi2 have used the unit-hydrographtechnique.The lower limit of watershedextentdependson numerousother factorsand cannotbe preciselydefined. A generalrule of thumb is to assumeabout 1000acres.Fortunately,other hydrologic techniqueshelp resolveunit hydrographsfor watershedsoutsidethis range. The preliminary screeningof suitable storms for unit-hydrographformation shouldmeet more restrictive criteria before further analysis: 1. Duration of rainfall event should be approximately10-30 percent of the drainagearea lag time. 2. Direct runoff for the selectedstorm shouldrangefrom 0.5 to 1.75 in. 3. A suitablenumberof stormswith the sameduration shouldbe analyzedto obtain an average of the ordinates (approximately five events). Modificationsmay be madeto adjustdifferent unit hydrographsto a single duration by meansof S-hydrographsor IUH procedures. 4. Direct runoff ordinatesfor eachhydrographshouldbe reducedso that each eventrepresents1 in. of direct runoff. 5. The final unit hydrographof a specificdurationfor the watershedis obtained by averagingordinatesof selectedeventsand adjustingthe result to obtain 1 in. of direct runoff. Constructingthe unit hydrographin this way producesthe integratedeffect of runoff resultingfrom a representativeset of equal duration storms.Extremerainfall intensityis not reflectedin the determination.If intensestormsare needed,a study of recordsshouldbe madeto ascertaintheir influenceupon the dischargehydrographby comparingpeaks obtainedutilizing the derived unit hydrographand actual hydrographsfrom intensestorms. Essentialstepsin developinga unit hydrographfor an isolatedstorm are: l. Analyzethe streamflowhydrographto permit separationof surfacerunoff from groundwaterflow, accomplishedby the methodsdevelopedin Section l 1.4. 2. Measurethe total volume of surfacerunoff (direct runoff ) from the storm producingthe original hydrograph.This is the area under the hydrograph after groundwaterbaseflow has been removed. 3. Divide the ordinatesof the direct runoff hydrographby total direct runoff volume in inches,and plot theseresultsversustime as a unit graph for the basin. \-
192
12 UNITHYDROGRAPHS GHAPTER 4. Finally, the effective duration of the runoff-producing rain for this unit graphmustbe found from the hyetograph(time history of rainfall intensity) of the storm eventused. Proceduresother than thoselisted are requiredfor complex stormsor in developing synthetic unit graphs when data are limited. Unit hydrographscan also be transposedfrom one basinto anotherundercertain circumstances.An exampleillustratesthe derivationof a unit hydrograph.
EXAMPLE I2.1 Using the total direct runoff hydrographgiven in Fig. I2.2, derive a unit hydrograph for the l7I5 ac drainagearea. Solution 1. Separatethe base or groundwaterflow to get the total direct runoff hydrograph.A commonmethodis to draw a straightline AC that beginswhen
2-hr rainfall duration
I I
precipitaion = 4.2 in.
*zTotal
)
o
1l
l
t2
Time (hr)
Directrunoff. /T\ ordinate Yl
\
*zTotal directrunotf of l.4l5in.on1715ac
500 o FA
2-hr unit hydrograph of l.u rn. on I / I) ac
400 300 200 .100 0
Basef-tow
/
\,
/
t'-# -j
/^ 3
4
5
6
7
Baseflow separatlon
8
Time(hr) Dfuectrunoffduration
Figure 12.2 Illustration of the derivation of a unit hydrograph from an isolatedstorm.
12,2 DERIVATIONOF UNIT HYDROGRAPHSFROM STREAMFLOWDATA
193
the hydrographstartsan appreciablerise and endswherethe recessioncurve intersectsthe baseflow curve.The importantpoint hereis to be consistentin methodologyfrom storm to storm. 2. The depth of direct runoff over the watershedis calculatedusing > (DR x Ar) _ 2447 cfs-hr -: 1 4" ''* area l7l5 ac
(r2.r)
whereDR is the averageheightof the dfuectrunoff ordinateduring a chosen time period Ar (in this caseA/ : 1.0 hr) . The valuesof DR determinedfrom Fig. I2.2 are listedin Table 12.1. 3. Computeordinatesof the unit hydrographby using
8 "_ Q , 1 v,
(r2.2)
where Q, : the magnitudeof a hydrographordinate of direct runoff having a volume equal to % (in.) at someinstant of time after start of runoff Q, : the ordinateof the unit hydrographhavinga volume of 1 in. at someinstant of time In this examplethe valuesare obtainedby dividing the direct runoff ordinatesby 1.415.Table12.1outlinesthe computationof the unit-hydrograph ordinates. 4. Determinethe duration of effectiverainfall (rainfall that actuallyproduces surfacerunoff). As statedpreviously,the unit hydrographstorm duration
TABLE 12,1 DETERMINATION OFA 2.HRUNITHYDROGRAPH FROM AN ISOLATEDSTORM (1)
(2)
(3)
Time (hr)
Runoff (cfs)
Base flow (cfs)
I 2 3 4 4.7 5 6 7 8 9 10 10.5 lt t2
110 t22 230 578 666 645 434 293 202 160 1t7 105 90 80
t10 t10 t10 110 110 110 110 110 110 110 1r0 105 90 80
(4) Direct runoff, (2)-(3) (cfs)
0 t2 120 468 556 535 324 183 92 50 7 0 0 0
(5) 2-hr unit hydrograph ordinate,(4) + 1.415 (cfs) 0 8.5 84.8 i-l
I
393 379 229 129 65.0 35.3 4.9 0 0 0
194
CHAPTER12
UNIT HYDROGRAPHS
should not exceedabout 25 percent of the drainage atea lag time' but violatesthis rule for the example.From Fig. 12.2, the rain duration is 2 hr. 5. Using the values from Table I2.1, plot the unit hydrograph shown in Fig. 12.2. r I
BY LAGGINGMETHODS APPLICATIONS 12.3 UNITHYDROGRAPH Once an X-hr unit hydrographhasbeenderivedfrom streamflowdata (or synthesized from basin parameters,Section 12.6) it can be used to estimatethe direct runoff hydrographshapeand duration for virtually any rain event.Applications of the X-hr UH to other stormsbeginswithlagging procedures,usedfor stormshavingdurations that are integermultiples of the derived duration. Applications to stormswith fractional multiples of X, known as S-hydrographandIUH procedures,are discussedin Sections12.4 and 12.5. Becauseunit hydrographsare applicableto effective (net) rain, the processof applyrngUH theory to a storm beginsby first abstractingthe watershedlossesfrom the precipitation hyetograph,resulting in an effective rain hyetograph'Any of the proceduresdetailedin Chapter 4 can be applied. The remainder of this discussion assumesthat the analysthas already abstractedwatershedlossesfrom the storm. If the duration of anotherstorm is an integermultiple of X, the storm is'treated as a seriesof end-to-endX-hourstorms.First, the hydrographsfrom eachX increment ofrain are determinedfrom the X-hourunit hydrograph.The ordinatesare then added at correspondingtimes to determinethe total hydrograph. EXAMPLE 12.2 Dischargerates for the 2-hr unit hydrographshownin Fig' I2.3 are'.
Time (hr) O (cfs)
0 0
1 100
2 250
3 200
4 100
5 50
6 0
Develophourly ordinatesof the total hydrographresultingfrom a 4-hr designstorm havingthe following excessamounts:
Hour Excess(in.)
1 Q.5
L
0.5
J
1.0
4 1.0
Solution. The 4-hr duration of the designstorm is an integermultiple of the unit hydrographduration.Thus,the total hydrographcanbe foundby addingthe contributionsof two 2-hr incrementsof end-to-endrain, asshowninFig. l2'3c. The first 2-hr stormsegmenthas 1.0 in. of net rain and thus reproducesa unit 2.0in. of netrain (in 2 hr);thus The second2-hr stormsegmenthas hydrograph. its ordinatesare twice those of a 2-hr unit hydrograph.The total hydrograph,
12.3 F
r>
UNIT HYDROGRAPHAPPLICATIONSBY LAGGINGMETHODS
1.0
h
u.)
c
0 2
3
4 .
5
6
(a) 2-hourunit storn excess
^
300 200
i90 zoo € 1oo '6 0
1.0 ir
0.5 0 2
3
4
5
6
(c)Designstom excess 600 500 '6 400 :i
H 300 i5 200 100 0 r
2
3
4
5
6
7
(d) Contributionof each2-hourstorm 600 500 a
t +oo ; ff:oo '$ zoo -100 0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
1
8
(e) Total design hydrograph
Figure 12.3 Example 12.2 deivation of total runoff hydrographusing a 2-hr unit hydrograph.
195
196
cHAPTERi2
uNtr HyDRocRApHS
Fig.12.3e, is found by summingthe fwo contributionsat correspondingtimes. Note in Fig, 12.3d that runoff from the secondstorm beginswhen the second rain begins,not at the beginningof the first storm. r I This methodof "lagging" is basedon the assumptionthat linear responseof the watershedis not influencedby previousstorms-that is, one can superimposehydrographs offset in time and the flows will be directly additive. The simplestway to developcompositedirect runoff hydrographsfor multiple-hourstormsis in a spreadsheet.Care must be taken, however,in visually confirming, as in ExampleI2.2, that the start and end points of runoff from eachcontributingX-hr incrementof rain are properly selected.A commonerror is to lag eachadditional contributinghydrograph by Ar, the time interval betweenreadings,rather than X, the associatedduration with the given unit hydrograph.Also, the multiplier for the UH ordinatesmust be the net rain occurring in X hours, not the rain occurring in the time increment A/. Example I2.3 illustratesthesepoints. EXAMPLE 12.3 Using the derived 2-hr lunit hydrographin Table 12.1, determinethe direct runoff hydrographfor a 4-hr. storm havingthe following excessrain amounts:
Hour
I
Excessrain. in.
o.7
2 0.7
t.2
1.2
Solution 1. Tabulatethe unit hydrographat intervalsof the selectedtime interval, A/, as shown inTable 12.2. TABLE 12.2 UNIT HYDROGRAPHAPPLICATIONOF EXAMPLE12.3
Time (h0
Effective rainfall (in.)
0 I
2 J
4 5 6 7 8 9 10 1l t2
0.7 0.7 1 . 2" 1.2
Unit hydrograph (cfs) 0 8.5 84.8 JJI
379 229 129 65 35.3 4.9 0
Contrib. of first 2-hrrain U HX 1 . 4 ' 0 I1.9 l19 463 531 321 181 91 49.4 6.9 0
Contrib. of second 2-hr rain
uH x 2.4'
0 20.4 203 794 910 550 310 156 84.7 11.8 0
Total outflow hydrograph (cfs)
0 11.9 119 483 734 11 1 5 1091 641 359 163 84.7 I 1.8 0
12.gUN|THYDRoGRAPHAPPL|CAT|oNSBYLAGG|NGMETHoDS197
2. Determine the correct UH multiplier for eachX-hr interval. BecauseX is 2 hrs for this example,the first two hours of the storm producea total net rain of 1.4 inches. Similar$, the last two hours of the storm produce 2.4 inchesof net rain. 3. Determinethe correct start and end times for eachof the two hydrographs and tabulatethe contributionof the l.4-inch and 2.8-inch rains at the : 3 hrs, appropriatelag times. Becausethe secondX-hr storm startedat / : I2'2. inTable shown hrs as 3 runoff for this-stormcannotbegin until / hydrographs runoff the total 4. Add the contributionsat eachtime to determine for the 4-hr storm. 5. Checkthe tabular solutionby plotting eachof the two hydrographsand sum rr the ordinatesat each/, as showninFig.I2'4' In addition to using a given X-hr UH for determiningthe runoff hydrographfor a given storm, tagging of ttt" X-hr UH can be used to developother duration unit hyirographs.The pioCedureis the sameas applyingthe X-hr UH to 1.0 in. of net rain in f nouri. As earlier, Y must be an integermultiple of X. For example,if a 1-hr unit hydrographis availablefor a given watershed,a unit hydrographresultingfrom a 2-hr siorm-is tbtained by plotting two L-hr unit hydrographs,with the secondunit hydrographlagged t hr, adding ordinates,and dividing by 2' This is demonstratedin nigl ti.S, riliere the dashedline rept"sentsthe resulting2-ht unit hydrograph'Thus the t in. of rainfall containedin the original 1-hr duration has been distributedover a Z-hr period.
t
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
0
1
1
1
Time units
Figure 12.4 Synthesizedhydrographfor'Example 12'3 derivedby the unit hydrographmethod'
\_
2
198
CHAPTER 12 UNITHYDRoGRAPHS
l-hr unit hydrogaph 2-hIunithy&ogaph
Time
Figure12.5 Unithydrographlaggingprocedurero developanotherunit hydrograph. Modificationsof the original unit-hydrographduration can be madeso that two 1-hr unit hydrographsare usedto form a 2-hr unit hydrograph;two 2-hr unit hydrographsresult in a 4-fu diagram,and so on. Care must be taken not to mix durations in the lagging procedure, since errors are introduced; a l-hr and a}-hr unit hydrograph do not representa 3-hr unit hydrograph.Lagging procedureis therefoie restrictedto multiples of the original duration accordingto the expression D1 : nD
(I2.3\
where Dl : the possibledurationsof the unit hydrographby lagging methods D : the original duration of any given unit hydrograph fl: I,2,3,..
12.4 S.HYDROGRAPHMETHOD The S-hydrographmethodovercomesrestrictionsimposedby the laggingmethodand allowsconstructionof any durationunit hydrograph.By observingthe lagging system just described,it is apparentthat for a l-hr unit hydrograph,the l-in. rainfall excess hasan intensityof 1 in./hr, whereasthe 2-hr unit hydrographis producedby a rainfall intensity of 0.5 in./hr. Continuouslagging of either one of theseunit hydrographsis comparableto a continuouslyappliedrainfall at either 0.5 in./hr or 1 in./hr intensity, dependingon wfuch unit hydrographis chosen. As an example,usingthe 1-hr unit hydrograph,continouslaggingrepresentsthe direct runoff from a constantrainfall of 1 in./hr as shownin Fig. r2.6a. The cumulative addition of the initial unit hydrographordinatesat time intervalsequalto the unit storm duration resultsin an S-hydrograph(seeFig. r2.7). &aphically, construction of an s-hydrographis readily accomplishedwith a pair of dividers. The maximum
12.4 S-HYDROGRAPHMETHOD
*l
199
Dhr
D-hr S-hydrographlaggedt hr
*l
Time
l-
(a)
Figure 12.6 S-hydrographmethod.
dischargeof the S-hydrographoccursat a time equalto D hourslessthan the time base of the initial unit hydrographas shown inFig. 12.6a. To constructa pictorial 2-hr unit hydrograph,simply lag the first S-hydrograph by a secondS-hydrographa time interval equalto the desiredduration.The difference in S-hydrographordinatesmust then be dividedby 2. Any duration r unit hydrograph may be obtained in the samemanner once another duration D unit hydrqgraphis known. Simply form a D-hr S-hydrograph;lag this S-hydrographf hr, andmultiply the difference in S-hydrographordinatesby D/t. Accuracy of the graphical procbdure dependson the scaleschosento plot the hydrographs.Tabular solution of the Shydrographmethodis also employed,but hydrographtabulationsmustbe at intervals of the original unit.hydrographduration. EXAMPLE 12.4 Given the following 2-hr unit hydrograph,use S-hydrographproceduresto construct a 3-hr unit hydrograph. Time (hr) 0 (cfs)
o 0
| 100
2 250
3 200
4 100
5 50
6 0
Solution. The 2-hr unit hydrographis the runoff from a 2-hr stormof 0.5 in./hr. The S-hydrograph is formedfrom a net rain rate of 0.5 in./hr lasting indefinitelyas shownin Fig. 12.6a.Its ordinatesarefoundby addingthe 2-hr (UH) runoff ratesfrom eachcontributing2-hr block of rain: unit-hydrograph
200
CHAPTER12
UNIT HYDROGRAPHS
I
i
/
i
/,/
I
a
90
-'{.3 u0 Figure 12.7
S-hydrograph.
Time (h0
1st2-hr
0 I z
3 4
5 6 7 8
0 100 250 200 100 5n
0
Time (min.)
2nd Z-hr
0 100 250 200 100 50 0
S-hydrograph
3rd2-hr
' 0 100 250 200 100
0 100 250
0 100 250 300 350 350 350 350 350
To find a 3.-hrhydrograph,the S-curveis laggedby 3 hr and subtractedasshown in Fig. 12.6b.This results in a hydrographfrom a 3-hr storm of 0.5 in./hr, or 1.5 in. total. Thus the ordinatesneed to be divided by 1.5 to producethe 3-hr unit hydrograph:
201
12.5 THE INSTANTANEOUSUNIT HYDROGRAPH
Time (hr)
S-hydrograph
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
0 100 250 300 350 350 350 350
Lagged S-hydrograph
0 100 250 300 350
Difference
0 100 250 300 250 r00 '50 0
3-hrUnit hydrograph 0 67 167 200 167 . 6 7 33 0
12.5 THE INSTANTANEOUS UNITHYDROGRAPH The unit-hydrographmethodof estimatinga runoff hydrographcanbe usedfor storms of extremelyshortduration.For example,if the durationof a stormis 1 min and a unit volume of surfacerunoff occurs, the resulting hydrograph is the 1-min unit hydrograph.The hydrographofrunofffor any 1-min storm ofconstant intensitycan be computedfrom the l-min unit hydrographby multiplying the ordinatesof the 1-min unit hydrographby the appropriaterain depth.A storm lasting for many minutescan be describedas a sequenceof 1-min storrns(Fig. 12.8).The runoffhydrographfrom each l-min storm in this sequencecan be obtainedas in the precedingexample.By superimposingthe runoff hydrograph from each of the l-r.nin storms, the runoff hydrographfor the completestorm can be obtained. From the unit hydrographfor any duration ofuniform rain, the unit hydrograph for any other durationcanbe obtained.As the durationbecomesshorter,the resulting unit hydrographapproachesan instantaneousunit hydrograph.The instant4neousunit hydrograph(IUH) is the hydrographof runoff thaf would result if 1 in. of waterwere spreaduniformly over an areain an instant and then allowed to run off.e To develop an IUH, any I in.lhr S-hydrographmust first be obtained. The resulting S-curve is laggedby the interval Ar to developa Ar-hour unit hydrograph. The resulting At-hour unit graph becomesan IUH when Ar is set to 0.0 in the limit. If a continuing 1 in./hr excessstorm produces the original and lagged Shydrographsof Fig. 12.6b,the Ar-hour unit hydrographis the differencebetweenthe two curves,divided by the amount of excessrain depth in A/ hours,or Qo- Q" Q,(Lt-hr UH) : ILt
(r2.4)
The Qo - Q" dtfferencesare dividedby I Lt to convertfrom a stormwith 1Al inches in Al hours to one with 1.0 in. in At hours,which is the definition of a Ar-hour unit graph. As Ar approacheszpro, Eq. 12.4 becomes
: !as 0,(ruH) Idt
(12.s)
202
CHAPTER12 UNIT HYDROGRAPHS
Figure 12.8 Unit-hy&ographdescriptionof the runoff process.(a) Unit hydrograph;(b) a sequenceof l-min storms;(c) superposition for eachof of runoffhydrographs the l-min storms.(After Schaake.e) which showsthat the flow at time I is proportional to the slopeof the S-hydrograph at time r. In applications,the slopeis approximatedbyLQ/A,I, and the IUH ordinates can be estimatedfrom pairs of closelyspacedpoints of the S-hydrograph. Ifan IUH is supplied,the aboveprocesscan be reversed,and any X-hour unit graph can be found by averagingIUH florvsat X-hr intervals, or
Q,(X-tuUH) : 1(IUH,+ IUH,_X)
{r2.6)
Use of this approximate equation is allowed for small X values and permits direct calculationof a unit graph from an IUH, bypassingthe normal S-hydrograph procedure.
UNITHYDROGRAPH 12.5 THEINSTANTANEOUS
203
EXAMPLE 12.5 Given the following 1.0 in./hr S-hydrograph,determinethe IUH, and then use it to estimatea 1-hr UH.
Time (hr) S-curve (cfs)
0 0
0.5 5 0
1.0 200
1.5 450
2,0 500
2.5 650
3.0 700
3.5 750
4.0 800
Solution. The IUH is foundfrom Eq. l2.5.The slopeat time r is approximated bY (Q,*o.,- Q,-o)lLt
IUH = AQlAf
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 +
5
0 200 400 300 200 200 100 100 50 0 0
0 JU
200 450 500 650 700 750 800 800 800
The 1-hr uH is obtainedfrom F,q.12.6,usingreadingsat 1-hr intervals:
0 1 2 3 A
5 6
luHf
luHr_1
1-hr UH
0 400 200 100 50 0 0
0 0 400 200 100 50 0
0 200 300 150 75 25 n "
l
l
The readershouldverify that the 1-hr UH obtainedthrough use of the IUH is approximatelyt[e sameas that obtainedby lagging the S-hydrographt hr, subtracting, and convertingthe differenceto a 1-hr UH. The ordinatesof the IUH representthe relative effect of antecedentrainfall intensitieson the runoff rate at any instant of time. By plotting the IUH with time increasingto the left rather than to the right (seeFig. I2.9), andthen superimposing this plot over the rainfall hyetograph(plotted with time increasingto the right as in pig.iZ.g),the'relative weight given to antecedentrainfall intensities(asa function of time into the past) is easily observed.In other words, the runoff rate at any time is
/
204
12 UNITHYDROGRAPHS CHAPTER
Time-reversed image of the instantaneous unit hydrograph
Time into the past Antecedent iainfall intensities
oo=[;f@xi(t-r)dr
unit hyFigure 12.9 Calculationof runoff rates with the instantaneous antecedent the of average is a weighted drograph.The runoff rateat arrytime unit hyimageof the instantaneous rainfall intensities.The time-reversed the weightingfurtction.(After Schaake'v) drographrepresents computedas a weighted averageof the previousrainfall intensities.Therefore,the computedrunoff hydrographis the weighted,moving averageof.the rainfall pattern and itre weighting irtt"iiott is the time-reversedimage of the unit hydrograph'e Statedmathematically,the runoff rate at any time is given by the convolution integral
Q(A:
l,',<,tu,r)dr
(r2.7) ll:
12.6 SYNTHETICUNIT HYDROGRAPHS
where
205
Q(t) : the surfacerunoff rate at time t f(r) : the ordinate of the IUH at time r i(t - r): the rainfall inten'sity (after abstraction of the appropriate infiltration losses)at time t - r
The variable 7 representstime into the past so that time r - r occursbefore time r. The limits on the integral allow r to vary betweena pastand presenttime (i.e., r : 0, t - r : 0)' The integral givesa continuousweightingof prbviousrainfall intensities by the ordinatesof the IUH.
12.6 SYNTHETIC UNITHYDROGRAPHS As previously noted, the linear characteristicsexhibited by unit hydrographsrf6i a watershedare a distinct advantagein constructingmore complex rto.- Oir.fruig. hydrographs.Generally,however,basicstreamflowand rainfall data arcnot available to allow construction of a unit hydrographexcept for relatively few watersheds; therefore, techniqueshave evolved that allow generationof syithetic unit lrydrographs.
GammaDistribution The shapesof hydrographsoften closely match a two-parametergamma function, given by
f(x) :
xoe-*/B
B"+lf(d + 1)
(12.8)
where0 ( r ( m. The parametera is a dimensionlessshapefactor (mustbe greater tltul - 1), and B is a positive scalefactor havingthe sameunits as x and contiolling the baselength. The product of a and B givesthe value-r correspondingto the apexl or maximum value ofl(x). For a ) 1, the distribution has a single upe* und'plot, similar to hydrograph shapes,as shown in Fig. 12.10. The dislribution mein is F@ + 1), and varianceis p2(a + I). . Many of the syntheticunit hydrographproceduresresult in only three to five points on the hydrograph,through which a smooth curve must be fitted. In addition to the requirementthat the curve passesthrough all the points, the area under the hydrographmust equal the runoff volume from one unit of rainfall excessover the watershed.This latter requirementis often left uncheckedand can result in considerablg errors in performing calculationsthrough the use of ordinatesof a hydrograph that do not representa "unit" of runoff. The mostusefulfeatureof the gammadistributionfunction (explainedin greater detail later) is thit it guaranteesa unit areaunder the curve. It can convenientlybe used to synthesizean entire hydrographif the calculatedpeak flow rate eo and its associatedtime to are known. This usesa proceduredevelopedby Aron und'White.ro If time r is substitutedfor x in Eq. 12.g, the time to peak tois aB. At this point, the function/(r) equalsthe peak flow rate e,, or
o,:ffi=ffrr*1
(r2.e)
206
CHAPTER12
UNIT HYDROGRAPHS
1.0
B--1
0 x
Figure 12.10 Gamma function shapesfor various shape and scale parameter values. whereC, A is the unit volumeof runoff from a basinwith arcaA. The conversionfactor C, = 1.008 is selectedto make @(a)dimensionless. The function f(a) is shownby Aron and white to be relatedto a by1l (12.10) a : 0.045+ 0.5d + 5.6Q2+ 0303 Collins showsthat this can be approximatedreasonablywell in the range 1
( a ( 8
byt'
q.:05Q+5.902
(r2.Lr)
Combiningthis with F,q. 12.9 *tu"t
o : o s, tf f i . t n ( H ) '
(r2.r2)
To fit a unit graph usingEqs. I2.9 and 12.12,the peak flow rate and time must be estimated.Severalof the methodsdescribedsubsequ-ntlyallow this. Next. @(a)is foundfrom Eq.12.9, and a from Eq.12.10 ot l2.Il. The unit hydrographcan now be constructedby calculatingQ at any convenientmultiple, a, of to. Substitutingalo for x in Eq. 12.8 gives the flow at t : atp as -
Qoto:
QraoeQ-o)"
(r2.r3)
which can be solvedfor all the flow rates of the hydrograph. EXAMPLE 12.6 The peak flow rate for the unit hydrographof a 36,000-acrewatershedis 1720cfs and o".oi, 12 hr following the initiation of runoff. Use Eq. 12.8 to synthesizethe rest of the hydrograph.
12.6 SYNTHETICUNIT HYDROGRAPHS
207
Solution. From Fq. 12.9,
r720(12) : 0.57 6@) : 1.008(36,000) From Eq. 12.10(and t2.It), q.:2.2 The hydrographis then found from Eq. L2.I3: a) e2'2(rQ*, : 1720a2'2 Solving for a few points, we obtain the followine values: 10.0
t = afo(hr)
O(ctu)
0 0.5 1.0 2.0 5.0 10.0
0 6 l2
0 tt25 1720 876 9 0
)4
60 120
sufficient intermediatepoints shouldbe generatedto define the entire shapeof the hydrograph. tl
Snyder's Method one- techniqueemployedby the corps of Engineersl3and many othersis basedon methods developedby Snyderaand expandedby Taylor and 3chwartz.sIt allows computation of lag time, time base,unit_hydrographduration, peak discharge,, and hydrographtime widths at 50 and75 perceniof peukflor. ny uring tttesesevenpoints, a sketchof the unit hydrographis obtained,rig.lz.rt,and cleckel to seeif it contains 1 in. of direct runoff.
Alternate recessions I to produce 1.0 in. ofrunoff
Time,r F'igure 12.11 Snyder'ssyntheticunit hydrograph.
208
CHAPTER12
UNIT HYDROGRAPHS
Time to Peak Snyder'smethodof synthesizinga unit hydrographassumesthat the peak flow rate occursat the watershedlag, estimatedfrom Eq. 11.5.Its locationis as shownon Fig. 12.11.The lag time and peak dischargerate are both established correlatedwith variousphysiographicwatershedcharacteristics.For the lag time, the variablesL and L"o for Eq. 11.5 are estimatedfrom map measurements,and C, is developedfor the locale,usingSnyder'sestimatesor other sources.TableL2.3summarizes a variety of C, valuesfor variousregions. It is assumedthat lag time is a constantfor a particular watershed-that'is, uninfluencedby variations in rainfall intensitiesor similar factors. The use of L"o accountsfor the watershedshape,andC, takescare of wide variationsin topography, from plains to mountainousregions. Steeperslopestend to generatelower valuesof C,, with extremesof 0.4 nqtec in SouthernCalifornia and 8.0 alongthe Gulf of Mexico and Rocky Mountains.W{ren snowpackaccumulationsinfluencepeak discharge,valuesof C' will be betweenone sixth to one third of Snyder'svalues. Time Base The time base of a syntheticunit hydrograph(seeFig. 12.11) by Snyder'smethod is t , : ?
(r2.r4)
, t l
T ;
6
where t6 : the basetime of the syntheticunit hydrograph(days) t1: the lag time (hr)
TABLE 12.3 TYPICALSNYDER'SCOEFF|CIENTSFOR U.S. LOCALITIES Location
Range of C,
Average Cr
Range of Co
Average Co
Appalachian Highlands West Iowa Southern California Ohio Eastern Gulf of Mexico Central Texas North and Mid-Atlantic states Sewered urban areas Mountainous watersheds Foothills areas Valley areas Easlern Nebraska Corps of Engineers training course
t.8-2.2 0.2-0.6
0.4-0.8 0.7-1.0
0.4-2.3
2.0 o.4 0.4 0.7 8.0 1.1
0.3-1.2
0.6 0.8 0.9 0.6 0.6 0.8
0.2-0.5
0.6/\4" 0.3
0.1-0.6
0.3
0.5-1.0
0.8
Great Plains Rocky Mountains SW desert NW coast and Cascades 21 urban basins Storm sewered areas "Channel slope S
0.6-0.8
0.4-1.0 0.4-8.0 0.8-2.0 1.5-8.8 0;t -1.9 2.0-4.4 0.3-0.9 0.2-0.3
1.2 o;7 0.4 0.8 0.3-0.9 1.3 1,4
3.1 0.6 0.2
0.6-0.7
12.6 SYNTHETIC UNITHYDROGRAPHS 209 Equation L2.14 gives reasonableeslimatesfor large watershedsbut will produce excessivelylarge valuesfor smaller areas.A generalrule of thumb for small areasis to use three to five times the time to peak as a base value when sketchinga unit hydrograph.In any event, the time base shouldbe adjustedas shown in rig. tz.lt until the areaunder the unit hydrographis 1.0". Duration The duration of rainfall excessfor Snyder's synthetic unit-hydrograph developmentis a function of lag time '
l -
-
-
tt
5.5
(r2.1s)
where /, : duration of the unit rainfall excess(hr) t1 : the lag time from the certtroidof unit rainfall excessto the peak of thb unit hydrograph This synthetictechniquealwaysresultsin an initial unit-hydrographduration equalto fi/5.5.However, sincechangesin lag time occur with changesin duration of tlie unit hydrograph,the following equation was developedto allow lag time and peak dischargeadjustmentsfor other unit-hydrographdurations. tm:h+0.25(t*-t) where t1p: tt : to: t, -
(r2.16)
the adjustedlag time (hr) the original lag time (hr) the desiredunit-hydrographduration (hr) the original unirhydrograph duration : t,/5.5 (hr)
Peak Discharge If one assumesthat a given duration rainfall produces1 in. of direct runoff, the outflow volume is some relatively constantpercentageof inflow volume.A simplified approximationof outflow volume is r, X er, andthe equation for peak dischargecan be written Vr:
-640CPA Ltn
(12.r7)
where Qp : peak discharge(cfs) C" : the coefficientaccountingfor flood waveand storageconditions;it is a function of lag time, durationof runoff ptoducingrain, effectivearea contributing to peak flow, and drainagearea A : watershedsize (mi2) tp : the lag time (hr) Thuspeakdischargetanbe calculatedgivenlag time andcoefficientofpeak discharge C.. Valuesfor Cp range from 0.4 to 0.8 and gengrally indicate retention or storage capacityof the watershed.Larger valuesof C" aregenerallyassociatedwith smaller valuesof C,. Typical valuesare tabulated inTable 12.3. Hydrograph Construction From Eqs: 1I.5, lZ,I4, I2.I5, and,12.1,7plot three points for the unit hydrographand sketcha syntheticunit hydrograph,remembering
210
CHAPTER12
UNIT HYDROGRAPI.IS
that total direct runoff amountsto 1 in. An analysisby the Corps of Engineers(see Fig. 12.12) gives additional assistancein plotting time widths for points on the hyAs a generalrule ofthumb, drographlocatedat 50 and 75 percentofpeak discharge.l3 eachsideof the pegk proportioned ttr" ti-l width at l/so and IV^ ordinatesshouldbe unit-hydrograph synthetic the left of in a ratio of I:2 with the short time sideon the gives valuesfor unrealistic Eq. I2.I4 peak. As noted earlier,for smallerwatersheds, to the time total multiplying by ihe bur" time. If this occurs,a value can be estimated and amount on the based modified peak by a value of from 3 to 5. This ratio can be boundaries. watershed ii." tut" of depletionof storagewater within the The envelopecurvesin Fig. I2.I2 ate definedby
/
Wso: 8301(Qo/A)"
(12.18)
W15: 470f(Qo/A)"
(t2"]a)
The sevenpoints formed through the use of theseequationscan be plotted and a smooth curve drawn. To assurea unit hydrograph,the curve shape and ordinates shouldbe adjusteduntil the areabeneaththe curve is equivalentto one unit of direct runoff depth over the watershedarea.This can be doneby hand-fittingand planimetering or by curve-fitting. Hudlow and Clarkla used least-squaresregressiontechniquesto fit a Pearson III type (gamma)probability densityfunction (referto Chapter26) throughthe seven Snyaeruoit-nyAtographpoints. This function has an areaof 1.0 and a shapesimilar 1000 800 400 N
,2
s
9 200 oo
) \
€ 1oo -? 8 0
\
4-l
'.,
E 6 0 9" 40
* -
n
F\
n
t *tS
d
o
08,
10 8 6 0.2
0 . 4 0 . 6 0 . 8I
2
4
6
810
\, \
\ $ \ 40 60 80100
Width of unit hYdrograPh (hr)
Figure L2.12 Unit hydrographwidth at 50 and 75 percent of peak flow' a, observedvalue of Wso.o, observedvalue of lfi5.
c uNrrHYDR.GRAPHS 211" to thator naturalhydrographs. rh" ,h;:l Q,:
nr(;
,lll::i e-G-tp')/b
(r2.20)
where a and b are shapeand scaleparameters.Hudlow and Clark presenta trial-anderror solution to the least-squaresnormal equations,using Newton's method, to developestirnatesof a and b. The application of Snyder's syntheticunit-hydrographmethod to areasother than the original study area should be precededby a reevaluationof coefficientsC, and C, in Eqs; 11.5 and I2.I7 . TIns analysiscan be accomplishedby the use of unit hydrographsin the region under study which havethe proper lag time-rainfall duration ratio; that is, t, : ttf 5.5. If anotherrainfall durationis selected, variationsof C and C, can be expected.
SCS Method A methoddevelopedby the Soil ConservationServicefor constructingsyntheticunit hydrographsis basedon a dimensionlesshydrograph(Fig. 12.13). This dimensionless graph is the result of an analysis of a large number of natural unit hydrographs from a wide range in size and geographii locations.The method requires only the
0.6
cSlo b
0.5
als 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1
t tp
Figure 12.13 Dimensionless unit hydrographand masscurve. (After Mockus.1s)
212
CHAPTER 12 UNITHYDRoGRAPHS determination of the time to peak and the peak discharge as follovi,s:
tp:
D t+
tt
(r2.2r)
where to : the time from the beginningof rainfall to peak discharge(hr) D : the duration ofrainfall (hr) t1 : the lag time from the centroid of rainfall to peak discharge(hr) The ratios correspondingto Fig. 12.13 are listed in Table 12.4. The peak flow for the hydrographis developedby approximatingthe unit hydrographas a triangular shapewith basetime of ! t, and unit area.The readershouldverify that this produces ^
U r :
4844
-
t
(r2.22)
where Qp: peak discharge(cfs) A : drainagearea (mi2) tp : the time to peak (hr) The time base of ! ro is based on empirical values for averagerural experimental watershedsand shouldbe reduced(causingincreasedpeak flow) for steepconditions or increased (causing decreasedpeak flow) for flat conditions. The resulting coefficientinBq.12.22 rangesfrom nearly 600 for steepmountainousconditionsto 300 for flat swampyconditions. A relation of /, to size of watershedcan be used to estimatelag time. Typical relations from two geographicregionsare tt :
l.44A0'6 Texas
t,:
0.54A0'6 Ohio
TABLE 12.4 COORDINATESOF SCS DIMENSIONLESS UNIT HYDROGRAPHOF F I G U R E1 2 . 1 3 Q/Q,
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 1.1 t.2 1.3
0 0.015 0.075 0.16 0.28 0.43 0.60 0.77 0.89 o.9'7 1.00 0.98 0.92 0.84
Q/Qp
1.4 1.5 1.6 1.8 2.0 2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8 3.0 3.5 4.0 5.0
0.75 0.66 0.56 0.42 0.32 0.24 0.18 0.13 0.098 0.075 0.036 0.018 0.009 0.004
(r2.23a) (r2.23b)
12.6 SYNTHETIC UNITHYDROGRAPHS 213. The averagelag is 0.6/",where/" is the time of concentration,definedby SCS aseither the time for runoff to travel from the furthermostpoint in the watershed(calledthe upland method) or the time from the end of excessrain to the inflection of the unit hydrograph.For the first case, t":L1tp-D
(r2.24)
The dimensionlessunit hydrograph,Fig. 1.2.1.3,has a point of inflection at approximately 1..7t,.If the lag time of 0.6t" is assumed,Eqs. 12.2I and 12.24 give D - 0.2t0 D = 0.I33t"
0).zs) {r2,26)
A small variation in D is permissible,but it shouldnot exceed0.25t, or 0.I7t". pnce the 0.133r"-hourunit hydrographis developed,unit hydrographsfor other durdtions can be developedusing S-hydrographor IUH procedures. By finding a value of t,, a syntheticunit hydrographof chosenduration D is obtainedfrom Fig. 12.13. Atother equationusedby the SCS is . t - : "' where fi : I : Y : S:
/0.'(s * 1;o.z
lgooyo's
(r2.27)
the lag time (hr) length to divide in feet averagewatershedslopein percent the potentialmaximumretention(in.) : (1000/CN) - 10, where.CN is a curve number describedin Chapter4
The lag from Eq. 12.27is adjustedfor imperviousnessor improved watercourses,or both, if the watershedis in an urban area.The multiple to be applied to thq lag is M : 1.- P(-6.8 X 10-3 + 3.4 x 10-4CN- 4.3 x 10-?CN, -2.2 x 10-8CN3) (12.28) where CN is the curve number for urbanized conditions, and P can be either the percentageimperviousor the percentageof the main watercoursethat is hydraulically improved from natural conditions.If part of the area is imperviousand portions of the channelare improved,two valuesof M are determined,and both are multiplied by the lag. EXAMPLE 12.7
.\ For a drainagearea of 70 r4i2 having a lag time of 8 | hr, derive a unit hydrograph of duration 2 hr. Use the SCS dimensionlessunit hydrograph. Solution 1. Using Eq.l2.21we obtain
t,:?*8*=9*t'tr
214
CHAPTER12
UNIT HYDROGRAPHS
2. From Eq.12.22 _484x70 n YP 9.5
Qo:3J60 cfsoccurringatt :9|hr 3. Using Fig.12.13, we find the following: a: The peak flow occursar tfto: 1 or at t : 9+hr. b. The time baseof the hydrograph: 5toor 47.5 hr. c. The hydrographordinatesare: l . A t t / t o : 0 . 5 ,Q / Q r : 0 . 4 3 ; t h u sa t t : 4 . 7 5 h r ,Q : 1 5 3 1c f s . 2. At tlto : 2, Q/Q" - 0.32; thus at t : 19 ht, Q : 1139cfs. 3. At tft, : 3, Q/Q, : 0.07; thus at t : 28.5 hr, Q : 249 cfs. 4. CheckD/to:0.21; OK. rl
Gray'sMethod Another method of generatingsynthetic unit hydrographshas been developedby Gray.16An approximateupper limit of watershedsize for applicationof this method to the geographicareasof central Iowa, Missouri, Illinois, and Wisconsinis 94 mi2. The method is basedon dimensionalizingthe incomplete gamma distribution and resultsin a dimensionlessgraph of the form O,t" :
where
Q,lPo: q and y : f : e: Pp : I :
25.0(y')n
r(q)
t 1o_7,t/pR\( \s-1
(r2.2e)
\Pol
percentflow in 0.25 PRat any given r/P^ value shapeand scaleparameters,respectively the gammafunction of q, equalto (4 - 1)!* the baseof natural logarithms the period of rise (min) time (min)
The relationfor 7' is definedzs yt : yPpandq : l.+ y'. This form of the dimensionless unit hydrograph(Fig. 12.14)allowscomputation ofthe dischargeordinatesfor the unit hydrographat times equal to I intervals of the period of rise P*, that is, the time from the beginningof rainfall to the time of peak dischargeof the unit hydrograph. Correlationswith physiographiccharacteristicsof the watershedcan be developedto get the valuesofboth Poand y'. As 4qexample,the storagefactorP^fy' hasbeenlinked with watershedparameters Lf\/S", where L is the length of the main channel of the watershedin miles measuredfrom the outlet to the uppermostpart of the watershed(Fig. 12.15); S. is definedas an averageslopein percentobtainedby plotting the main channelprofile rrf4isnotaninreserf(q) : f(N + Z) : (N - I + z)(N- 2 + z)... (t + Z)/f(r + Z), where N equalsthe integer.""-rl
q, the function is approximatedby
: qe.-al';l. r(q) h. ;uF-&
- #fu.
)
12.6 SYNTHETICUNIT HYDROGRAPHS
215
Muckey Creek near Mapleton, lowa F< a-
K 1 6 F re o ' E o
p
-
6
-
x
1.0
1.5 time (min.)
2.0
l(Atloi -=:, penoo or nse (mrn.)
t PR
Figure 12.14 Dimensionlessgraph and fitted two-parameter gamma distribution for Watershed5. (After Gray.r6)
='(ft)' 957o confidence belts tlr
a-l>
Ttta
for Ppll'
b
IL, IA,MO,WI
": lH l0 e ttr x t9!
OH
11.4
NE andW. IA
o l H
al
9.27 0.562 A A
0.531 0.498
(After Gray.16)
(r = 0.92)
Rudo,tgilrgljggtq. lchannel
slope(Vo)
-L
r.ir '
VS"
Figure 12.15 Relationof storagefactor,Ppfy', and watershedparameter, (After LV 5",for in Nebraska, Iowa,Missouri,Illinois,andWisconsin. - watersheds Gray.r6) and drawing a straight line through the outlet elevationsuch that the positive and negativeareasbetweenthe streamprofile and the straightline are equal.The storage factorPofy' can also be correlatedwith the period of rise P^ as shownin Fig. 12.16. These two cerrelations allow solution of Eq. 12.29 and produce a synthetic unit hydrographof duration P^f4 for an ungaugedarea.
216
12 UNITHYDROGRAPHS CHAPTER
ql-
\to .
F
"!'
h
0.0139 2.6761Po+
x t!9
.Fl6 o t * A 'l
0
40
80
120
160
200
240
280
320
360
Period of rise, Pp (min.)
Figure12.16 Relationof storagefactorP*fy' andperiodof risePn.(After Gray.r6; The solutionproceedsas follows: 1. DetermineL, 5", and A for the ungaugedwatershed' 2. DetermineparametersP*, T', and q. a. With Lf\/5", useFig. I2.I5 to selectPpfy'. b. With P*/y', use Fig. 12.16 to obtain Pa. Compute y' as the ratio Pol@*ly'). : Substitute c. 7' obtained in Step 2b into the equation Q | + y', and solvefor 4. 3. Computethe ordinatesfor the dimensionlessgraph using Eq. 12'29' Compute the percent flow in 0.25PRfor values of tf P*: 0.125, 0.375, 0.625,. . . , and every succeedingincrementof tf P* : 0'250 until the sum of the percent flows approximates100 percent. Also compute the peak percentageby substitutingtfPR: 1. 4. Computethe unit hydrograph. a. Computethe necessaryfactorto convertthe volume of the direct runoff under the dimensionlessgraph to 1 in. of precipitation excessover the entire watershed. 1. The volume of the unit hydrograph: V
*
V : 1 i n . x A n i z x 6 4 0nuTf '
I
n'rnln
.- --^ ft2
x 43'560 ;
graph: Vo 2. Thevolumeof the dimensionless V o : 2 q , x 0 . 2 5 x P 'Rx 6 0 -
fiun 3. Solve fot 2 q, by equatingV and Vo, sincethey must be equal'
12.6 SYNTHETICUNIT HYDROGRAPHS
217
Rdinfall duration = 6 mln = Pnl 4
s 400 300
60 Time(min)
Figure 12.17 Derived hydrographof Example12.8usingGray'smethod.Notethat Gray's method results in a unit hydrograph for a P^/4-hr storm.
b. Convert the dimensionlessgraph ordinatesto the unit-hydrograph ordinates n _ perc€ntflow in 0.25PR\ u,-T.aqi c. Translate time base of dimensionlessgraph to absolutetime units by multiplying t/PR x P^ for each computedpoint. Rememberthat runoff doesnot commenceuntil the centroid of rainfall, or at a time P^/8. An exampleproblemdemonstrates the solutionof Gray'smethodfor a Missouri watershed. A plot representing the derivedhydrographis shownin Fig. l2.r7.Dkect runoff commeircesat the centroid of rainfall. Thus it is necessaryto add D/2 or Po/B to column 2,Table r2,.5,to obtain the proper times of the unit trydrographordinates, showsin Column 6. EXAMPLE 12.8
For the given data, use Gray's method to constructa unit hydrographfor the Green Acrewatershed, wheredrainagearea: 0.62mi2,length: 0.98mi, andS" : l.45%a. Procedure 1. a. b. c. 2. a.
Figure12.15;L/t/S: 0.813 ni: Pnfy' : 8.25min. Figure 12.161, P^/^y' : 8.25 min; P*: 24.9 min. q : I I Y' : 4.02; Y' : 3.02. Tabulatepercentflow in 0,25PRfortfP*: 0.250:
218
UNIT HYDROGRAPHS
CHAPTER12
TABLE 12.5 TABULATIONFOR EXAMPLE12.8
(1) r/P
0.000 0.125 0.375 0.625 0.875 1.000 r.t25 t.375 t.625 1.875 2.125 2.375 2.625 2.875 3.125 3.375
(2) Time, (min)
(3) Percent flowin 0.25Pn
(4) Cumulated flow
0 3.1 9.3 15.6 2r.8 24.9 28.0 34.2 40.4 46.7 52.9 59.3 65.5 71.7 78.0 84.2
0 0.45 5.80 t2.70 16.35 16.85 16.25 14.20 11 . 1 0 7.97 5.55 3.56 2.28
0 0.45 6.2 18.9 35.3
l.4l
0.86 0.50
5r . 5 65.7 76.8 84.8 90.4 93.9 96.2 97.6 98.5 99.0
(5) UH (cfs) 0 lt.J
490 631 651 628 548 428 308 214 138 88.0 54.4 JJ.J
19.3
(6) Actualtime (min) 0 6.1 12.3 18.6 24.8 27.9 31.0 37.2 43.4 49.7 " 55.9 62.3 68.5 '74.7 81.0 87.2
3. a. 1. V : I x 0.62 x 640 x 43,5601t2: 14.4X 10sft3' 2 . V o : 0 . 2 5 x 2 4 . 9x 6 0 X > q , : 3 7 3 . 5 2 q ' 3.2 q,: 3860. b. Column 5 is tabulated by multiplying 3860 times values in Column 3 divided by 100. c. Column 2 is obtainedby multiplying24.9 times valuesin Column 1. d. Column 3 comesfrom solutionof Eq. l2'2J' rr
Espey10-MinuteSyntheticUnit Hydrograph A regionalanalysisof 19 urbanwatershedswasconductedby EspeyandAltmanlTand resulted in a set of regressionequations.thatprovide sevenpoints of a 10-min hydrograph.The entire hydrographis developedby fitting a smooth curve through the points using eye-fitting or curve-fitting procedures.In either case, a unit area is necessary. The equationsfor time to peak (minutes),peak discharge(cfs),time base(minutes),and width at 50 and 75 percentof the peak flow rate are *
fo'1801 57 To : 3.ILo'23S-o'2s Qp : 3L62 X I03Ao'e6T-t'o7 Ta:
125.89 x I}3AQ;o'es
W5o: 16.22x I03Ao'e3Q-oe2 7eQ-o78 w 1 5: 3 . 2 4 x 1 0 3 4 0
where
(r2.30) (r2.3r) (r2.32) (12.33) (r2.34)
L : total distance (ft) along the main channel from the point being consideredto the upstreamwatershedboundary
12.6 SYNTHET|C UNITHYDROGRAPHS219 : S main channel slope (ftlft) defined by H/0.8L, where 11 is the differencein elevationbetweenthe point on the channelbottom at a distanceof 0.2L downstreamfrom the upstreamwatershedboundary and a point on the channelbottom at the downstreampoint being considered 1 : imperviousarea within the watershed(7o) Q : a dimensionlesswatershedconveyancefactor A : watersheddrainagearea (mi2) T, : time of rise of the unit hydrograph (min) Q, = peak flow of the unit hydrograph (cfs) I, :,time baseof the unit hydrograph(min) ITso: width of the hydrograph at 507o of Q, @in) I4zrr= width of the unit hydrographat75%oof p. (min) The coefficients of determination (explained in Chapter 26) for the five equationg ranged from 80 to 94 percent. The watershedconveyancefactor is found from Fig. 12.18.The WsoandWrt widths are normally drawnwith one-thirdof the calculated width placedto the left of the peak and two-thirds to the right.
Clark's IUH Time-AreaMethod A syntheticunit hydrographthat utilizes an instantaneousunit hydrograph(IUH) was developedin 1945 by clark.6It has been widely used,is often called the time-area method,and hasappearedin severalcomputerprogramsfor hydrographanalysis(see Chapters24 and25).
s
80
b 7 0 . 6 0
F s o ;o 4 0 ?
6 3 0 d
F
0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.08 0.09 0.10 0.11 0.12 0..130.14 0.15 0.16 0.17 Main channel Manning z value
Figure 12.18 Watershedconveyancefactor Q as a function of percent watershed impervious cover l and weighted main channel Manning n value, for Espey method.
220
CHAPTER12
UNIT HYDROGRAPHS
The techniquerecognizesthat the dischargeat any point in time is a function of the translation and storagecharacteristicsof the watershed.The translation is obtained by estimatingthe overland and channeltravel time of runoff, which is then combinedwith an estimateof the delaycausedby the storageeffectsof a watershed. The translationof excessrainfall from its point of falling to the watershedmouth is accomplishedusing the time-area curve for the watershed.This is a histogramof incrementalrunoff versustime, constructedas shownin Fig. 12.19. The dashedlines in Fig. I2.I9a subdividethe basin into severalareas.Each line identifiesthe locus of "times" pointshavingequaltraveltimesto the outlpt. The isochronesare drawnequal apart, and sufficient zonesare selectedto fully definethe time-area relation. The time-area graph of Fig. l2.I9b is a form of unit hydrograph.The area beneaththe curve integratesto 1.0 unit of rain depth over the total areaA, and it has \ a translationhydrographshapeif sufflcient subareasare delineated. If one unit of net rain is placedon the watershedat t : 0, the runoff from At would passthe outlet during the first At period at an averagerate of At units of runoff pei unit of time. The volume dischargedwould be At units of areatimes one unit of rain. After all areascontribute,one unit of rainfall over the entire area would have passedthe outlet.
Lt
I I
J
.l
J ^3
A2
Lt A
As
^1
Time interval
ft) Figure L2.19 Developmentof time-area histogramfor use with Clark's method: (a) isochronesspacedLt apart (shown as dashedlines) and (b) time-area histogram.
12.6 SYNTHETICUNIT HYDROGRAPHS
221
The impact of watershedstorageon the translationhydrographis incorporated by routing the time-area histogramthrough a hypotheticallinear reservoirlocatedat the watershedoutlet, having a retardance coefficient K equivalentto that of the watershed.For the simplestform of reservoir,the storageS,at time f is linearly related to the outflow Q, at time /, or
(r2.3s)
S,': KQ,
whereKis a constantof proportionality calledthe storagecoefficient.It hastime units and is often approximatedby the lag time of the watershed. From continuity,the inflow, storage,and.oq,{flow for the reservoirare relatedby
I,-Q,:#:U#
(r2.36)
If the differentialis discretizedto LQ/LI, andif Q, andQ, are the flowsat t andt - l, thenEq. 12.36becomes Io,- Ao,: YQ'Lt
Q'
(12.37)
BecauseQ : (Q, + Qr)/2, the flow at the end of any Al is Qz: CoI * CtQ,
(12.38)
where
cr: #+T;
(r2.39)
and
- Lt -" ,t -- z2 K K+Lt
(r2.40)
The IUH is found from Eq. 12.38by solvingfor Q, at the end of eachsuccessive time interval. EXAMPLE 12.9 Given the following 15-min time-area curve, find the IUH for the 1000-acrewatershed.Then determinethe 15-min syntheticunit hydrograph.The storagecoefficient K is 30 min.
Timeinterval (min)
Areabetween isochrones (acres)
0 - 1 5" 15-30 30-45 45-60
100 300 500 100
Solution. From Eqs. 12.39and 12.40,Cs : 0.4 and Ct : 0.6.Routingis most easily accomplishedin a tableauas follows:
222
CHAPTER12
UNIT HYDROGRAPHS
Time (hr)
I (cfs)
I (acre-in./Af )
col + c1Q1
IUH (cfs)
0 100
400
160+0
0
300
1200
480 + 96
80
500
2000
800 + 346
368
100
400
160+ 688
861
0
0
0+509
99'7
0
0
0+305
6't9
0
0
0.25 0.50 0.75 1.00
l
1.25 1.50
The IUH has a characteristicallylong recessiondue to the magnitudeof K for this example.Note that after 1.25 hr, the flow becomes0.6 times the previous flow andcontinuesto decayat this rateindefinite$.As discussedin Section11.5, the time baseof the IUH shouldequal the excess-runoffreleasetime, which is one definition of time of concentration.Clark's method often producesprolongedrunoff becauseof this shortcoming. The 15-min unit hydrographis found using Eq. 12.6, ot
O,(l5-minUH) : lGUH, + IUH,-15) This resultsin: Time
IUH
(h0
(efs)
1S-minUH (cfs)
0 0.25 0.50 0.75 1.00 t.25 1.50
0 160 576 1146 848 509 :
0 80 368 861 997 679 :
:
tl
If the waterri"O ,uU time is not available,the K value can also be estimatedby recognizingthat Q, = KdQldt when the inflow is zero in Eq. 12.36.This occurs at approximatelythe inflection point on the recessionof Fig. t2.2, when inflow to the channelceases.If hydrographdataare available,the estimateof the Kvalue is the ratio of the flow rate to the slope of the hydrographat this particular point on the hydrograph.
12.6 SYNTHETIC UNITHYDROGRAPHS 223
Nash'sSyntheticIUH One of the earliest formulations of the IUH was developedby Nash.l8Instead of characteizingrunoff as translationfollowedby storagein a singlelinear reservoiras Clark did, Nash viewed the watershedas a seriesof n identical linear storagereservoirS,eachhavingthe samestoragecoefficientK. The first instantly (r : 0) receives a volume equal to a full inch of net rain from the entire watershed.This water then passesthrough reservoirsI,2,3, . . . , fl, with eachproviding an additional diffusion effecton the original I -in. rain. The number of reservoirs, n, is uniquely related to the reservoir storage coefficientK andthe watershedlag time. Once the IUH is developed;it can be used to synthesizeany other hydrograph by application of the convolution integral, Eq. I2.7, or from the approximatemethodsdiscussed in Section12.3. The derivation of Nash's equationfor IUH beginsfrom continuity at the first reservoir:
I,- Qu:#1,
(r2.4r)
wherc Qt, is the outflow from reservoir 1 at time t. SubstitutingS,: r ) 0 (for an IUH, I, is zero after t : 0), we obtain
_Qr,: u#1,,, #1,,,:
KQr, at time
(r2.42)
which can be written dQ"
eu:
- kI o' '
(r2.43)
Integrationfrom / : 0* to time t gives l n Q r , - l n Q r , l , - o :- -
*
(r2.44)
which reducesby taking antilogarithmsto Qt,
o,l;:
e ''-ttK
(r2.4s)
BecauseQr, : S,/K and S,=o: 1 in., then
Qu:f,"-'r*
(r2.46)
wherc Qy has units of depthper unit of tirne. Equation 12.46is an exponentialdecay function having an initial value of I/K at t : 0. This monotonically decreasing outflow from reservoir 1 becomesinflow to the secondreservoir. The secondreservoiris initially empty. The continuity relation Qu
*
Qz,:
K+ dt
(r2.47)
224
CHAPTER12 UNIT HYDROGRAPHS
is solved,giving | ,.. (r2.48) 9r, : V;te-"^ This equationhas a full hydrographshape,beginningwith zero flow at time zero, peaking at the maximum of the function, and eventuallyrecedingto zeto. Similarly derived,the hydrographflowing from ruthreservoirhas the form Qn,
:
|n-r n-t/K
, (12.49)
which is the two-parametergammafunction,
e,,:
(12.50)
#1n-1r-t/K
Becausethe outflow from the nth reservoirwas causedby 1 in. of excessrain falling Eq. 12.50describesan IUH. instantaneously,
EStimatiOn of K and n Valuesof K and n arc neededfor applicationof Nash's IUH. By integration,the centroid of the distribution (Eq. 12.50) occurs at t : nK. - 1). The From classicalcalculusmaximization,the peak flow occurs at t : K"(n : 0 is n(n + l)Kz. Trial combinationsof n and secondmoment of the IUH about / K can be usedto developthe IUH from Eq. 12.50, and the momentsof the plotted distribution can be estimatedto verify the productsnK and n(n * I)Kz ' If the IUH is discretizedinto m At increments,the momentsare approximatedby First moment = > ttQi Lt m
and
Secondmoment- 2 t?Q, Lt
(r2.sr) (r2.s2)
Another less tediousapproachis to use the definition of lag time as the time from centroid of rain to the centroid of the hydrograph.For an IUH, this is the sameas the centroidal distance.Thus, if the lag time can be determinedfrom equationssuchas those in Section 11.6, the product nK can be established,reducing the number of trials. Someinvestigatorshaveattemptedto relateNash'sK andn parametersto basin and storm characteristicsusingregressiontechniques.Rao et al.1edevelopedrelations for urban areasgreaterthan 5 mi2:
K : and
Lt -
po.zzz g.57 54o.zto (l + 1)o'azzPo:oa 0.83140.458D0.37r (I + 1yt'ezzPozat
(r2.s3) (r2.s4)
wherenK : tlandA is areain squaremiles,D is net rain duration in hours,Pn",is the net (effective)rain depth in inches,and / is the ratio of imperviousto total area.
12.6 SYNTHETICUNIT HYDROGRAPHS
225
ColoradoUrbanHydrographProcedure(CUHP) Synthetic unit hydrographscan be tailored for regional use. As an example,the Coloradourban hydrographprocedure20 provides 5-min syntheticunit hydrographs for use in the Denver metropolitan area. lt is based on Snyder's method and is consideredapplicableto watershedsin the size rangefrom 90 acresto 10 mi2, with "regular" shapes(length 4 times width). It was developedin the early 1980sand modifiedin 1984to reflectrefinementsfrom earlyapplications. In its pre-1984'form, the Snyder/CUHPC, and C, valuesfor use in Eqs. 11.5 and 12.17 are C, : 7.8I1P2378 and
Co:
0.89C?'46
(r2.ss) (r2.s6)
where P" is the percent impervious.Theseregressionequationswere developedfor P" > 30 percent, using data for 96 storms over 19 urban watersheds.The given equationsapply to normal watershedconditionsandneedto be adjustedfor steep,flat, or seweredbasins.If an urbanareais fully sewered,the calculatedC, from Eq. 12.55 is decreased10 percent. If sparselysewered,a 10 percent increaseis made. If the averageslope S of the lower 80 percent of the main water courseis flat (less than 0.01 ftlf| the C, value becomes C,:3.12/Po78so2
( r 2.57)
and for steepareas(,S> 0.025 ftlf$, C, : 3.75/Po78s'02
( 12.s 8)
The C, coefficient is determinedfrom Eq. 12.56 and adjustedto 10 percentup or down for fully or sparselyseweredconditions,respectively. For the CUHP applications,Eqs. 12.18 and 12.19become ryro: SO}A/Qo w75:260A/Qo
(r2.se) (12.60)
whereA andQohaveunits of squaremiles and cubic feet per second.For plotting ft., the smallerof 35 percentor 0.670is placedleft of the peak.For W15,45percentis placedto the left, or O.424To if 0.67pwas usedfor W'r6.I is the time from beginning of runoff of the unit rainfall to the peak time. Severalinvestigatorshave suggestedthat Snyder's C, and slope S are correlated.a'S The original CUHP procedurewas alteredto recognizethis relation, making the adjustmentsin C, unnecessary. For the modifiedversion,Eqs. 12.57and 12.58are bypassed, andthetime to peakratherthanlag time is usedin Snyder'sEq. 11.5,where tp: c,(LL,o/\8100'
(12.6r)
The revisedtime coefficientC, is obtainedfrom Fig. 12.20a,and the peak coefficient is found from Co : PC,Ao'1s
where
(r2.62)
S : weightedaverageslopeof basinalongthe streamto the upstreambasin boundary (ftlft)
CHAPTER12
UNIT HYDROGRAPHS 0.18 Basic equations
Equationsof curve: Ct= aI?+ blo+ c tro. I 00
0.16
0.14
I LL--\0.48 'r: "\fi)
\r
b c -0.00371 0.163 0.146 0.000023 -0M224 ] 3 x 1 o r -8.01 x l0- 0 12(
640c, --7-
4p :
tp = time to peak (br)
E q
L = watershed length (mi) Ic, = distance to centroid (mi)
o
So = waterway slope (ff/ft)
r i
U 0.10
0.08
Ec,.2l
3q. 0.10
Eq.3 80
40 60 Percentimpervious,l, (a)
20
100
12 Equations of curve: P = aI?+ blo+ c
10
Eq.
a
b -0 012
2 | -o.t)0091 +0.228 --T-| -T-l
:
\t<
+216
06
z-r ,ql.: v t Y
\
6
o 6
d
o
Eq. 1 0
20
84.2 40 60 Fercent impervious, l, (b)
80
100
Figure 12.20 Snyder's C, and C, coefficientsfor urban areas,for use with CUHP: (a) relation between C, and imperviousnessand (b) relationbetweenpeakingparameter and imperviousness.
PROBLEMS
227
P : coefflcient,dependingon imperviousness,from Fig. I2.20b A : drainagearea (mi2) L : length of the main stream channel (mi) from the outlet to the divide L"o : length along the main channel (mi) from the outlet to a channelpoint nearestthe watershedcentroid The peakrate andtime of the unit hydrographcanbe developedusingEqs. 12.17 After four additional points definedby Eqs. 12.59 and t2.60 areplotted, 12.6t. and the 5-min hydrographcan be fitted to provide a total area representing rest of the runoff. A hand fit is applied, or the mathematical curve-fitting in. of direct 1.0 early in Section 12.5 can be used if a gamma (or any other) described techniques appropriate. is considered distribution (lessthan 90 acres),the time to peak is watersheds For small Lp
* 0 . 0 7()1, ^. : o.zg(P=l:?3,6=P: '^" Pz - 0.49P"+ 0 .1 4
6P,)
02.63)
where I is the time of concentrationin minutes, and P^ is the percentimpervious.
r summary Unit hydrographmethodsallow the hydrologistto estimaterunoff volumesand rates for virtually any storm. By far, the greatestnumber of problems in practice are evaluatedusingunit hydrographprocedures.Most of the current computermodelsuse unit hydrographproceduresasdescribedin Chapters 23,24, and25. Thesemodelsare simply computerprogramsthat perform the unit hydrographsynthesesand convolution stepsdescribedin this chapter.Any softwareuser shouldunderstandthe origin, applicability,and parameterestimationproceduresfor eachunit hydrographmethod seiected.The most successfulusesof the computermodelswill resultfrom a thorough familiarity with the processesdescribedin this chapter.
PROBLEMS 12.1. Given the following storm pattern and assuminga triangular unit hydrographfor one time unit, determinethe compositehydrograph.
Stormpattern Time unit Rainfall
1 1
2 1
3 4
4 2
Unit hydrographbaselength : 6 time units; time of rise : 2 time units; and maximum ordinate : I rainfall unit height. 12.2. Given a rainfall duration of 1 time unit, an effectiveprecipitation of 1.5 in., and the following hydrograph,determine(a) the unit hydrographand (b) the compositehydrographfor the given storm sequence.
228
CHAPTERl2
UNIT HYDROGRAPHS Hydrographfor 1.S in. net rain in .t time unit Time units 1 2 3 Flow (cfs) r00 98 220
4
4.5
5
6
srz 620 585 460
7 8 330 2to
9 r 0 150 105
l 1 l2 13 75 60 54
Stormsequence Time units Precipitation (in.)
I
0.4
z l.l
J
2.0
1.5
12.3. Solve Problem lZ.2 if the storm sequenceis as follows:
Stormsequence Time units Precipitation (in.)
r 0.3
2 r.4
J
0.9
l2'4'
Using U.S. GeologicalSurveyrecords,or other data, selecta streamflow hydrograph for a large, preferably single-peakedrunoffevent. Separatethe base flow and determine a unit hydrograph for the area. 12.5. For the unit hydrographof problem 12.1, constructan S_hydrograph. 12.6. For the unit hydrqgraphcomputedin problem 12.2, construct an S_hydrograph. 12.7. use the S-hydrographof problem 12.6to find a 3 time-unit unit hydrograph. 12.8. Given a watershedof 100 mi2, assumethat C, = 1.g, the length of main stream channelis I 8 mi, and the length to a point nearestthe centroid is I O mi. Use Snyder,s methodto find (a) the time rag, (b) the duration of the syntheticunit hydrograpl, and (c) the peak dischargeof the unit hydrograph. l2'9' Apply Snyder's method to the determinationof a synthetic unit hydrographfor a drainage area of your choice. 12'10' Use Fig. 12.13to determine a2-hr pnrthydrographif the drainageareais 60 mi2 and Eq. 12.23ais applicable. 12.11. SolveProblem12.10using Eq.12.23b. 12.12. Assuminga Nebraskalocation, use Gray's method determine te a unit hydrograph: drainagearea = 1.0 mi2, length : 0.6 mi, S" : 1.3 percent. 12'13' A drainageareain Nebraskacontains30 mi2.The tenjtn ortne main channelis 10 mi andthe'representative watershedslopeis 2.5 percent.iJseGray's methodto determine a unit hydrograph. 12'14' Dischargerates for a flood hydrographpassingthe point of concentration for a 600acredrainagebasinare given in the tabl; belo;. The flood wasprotluced by a uniform rainfall rate of 2.15 in.rru, which started,at9 A.M., abruptry ended at il A.M: and resulted in 5.00 in. of direct surfacerunoff. The base flow (derived tiom influent seepage)prior to, during, and after the storm was 100 cfs.
229
PROBLEMS
8 a.u. Time Measured discharge 100
9
10
11
12
100 300 500 700
I P.M
800
2
3
5
4
6
600 400 300 200 100 100
cease? a. At what times did direct runoff begin and basin' the for (in'/hr) index the Determine b. @ (cfs)for eachtime.listed' c. Derive the 2-hr'unit-nydrograpirordinates releasetime) for the basin. (excess concJnffation d. Estimatethe tirne of e.Atwhattimewoulddirectsurfacerunoffceaseiftherainfallof2.T5in./hrhad and had lastedfor 8 hr rather than 2? begunat 9 .q.'l\a. (in.) for a uniform urg" .ur" (cfs) and the direct runoff f. Determined;;;i;t rainfall of 2j5 it'lhr and a duration of 8 hr' Lz.lS. Measuredtotal hourly dischargerates in the accompanyingtable' The hydrr uniform intensity of 2'60 in'/hr startir baseflow from 8 A.M' to 3 P'v' was a ' determined as the area under the dir
Time Measured discharge
8 a.v 100
100
10
11
12
I P.M
300
600
400
200
2 100
100
a. At what time did the direct runoff begin? to the volume of the direct surface b. betermine the net rain (in') corresponding runoff of 1000 cfs-hr' c. Determinethe { indexfor the basin' basin by tabulating time in hours and d. Derive " , nt ltii ttyJrog'api' for the dischargein cfs. basin? e. What is the excessreleasetime of the the direct unit hydrograptr-to-determine 2-hr tt" the derived f. For the ,"*"'t"'it, p.u. and 1 at began ;;; ;.*, on a day when excess-(netjralnfall runoff rate (.fr)'t"i P'M' 5 at abruptly ceasing iti"tt ity of 2 in'/hr for 4 hr' continued"t " |2.|6.A5-hrunithydrographfora425}-acre.basinisshownintheaccompanyingsketch. Thegivenhyd.og.-uphactuallyappearedasadirectrunoffhydrographfromthebasin' of 5 hr,beginning
by rainf;ffi;;;;ii"'"iriv caused
"i 0.30in./hrfor a duration
att = 0. the basin' a. Determinethe excessreleasetime of basin' the for index b. Determinethe @ contributingto direct runoff 4 hr after c. what n".""*"J" "'i,ti" JJr"g" t"r* was rain began(r = 4)? as shownin the sketch'Do not scale d. Use your responseto part c to determineQp' Qp from the drawing' t = 3 andr : 5' Why did the hydrograph e. Note that rain continuedto fall between = : rathet than continue to rise during those 5, t 3 and form a ptateaut"i*""n t 2 hours?
230
CHAPTER12
UNIT HYDROGRAPHS QO
o
,i: 700 = ouu I 500
e 40o
! :oo $ zoo 100
Time, t
f. Usethe given 5-hr unit hydrographto determinethe direct runoff rate (cfs)at 7 p.r'r. on a day when rain fell at an intensity of 0.60 in./hr from I p.rrr.to 11 p.vr. 12.17. The 2-hr unit hydrographfor a basin is given by the following tabie:
Time (hr) O@fs)
0 0
1 60
2 200
3 300
4 200
5 120
6 6 0
7 8 3 0 1
0
9 0
a. Determinethe hourly dischargevalues(cfs)from the basinfor a net rain of 5 in./hr and a rainfall durationof 2hr. b. Determinethe direct runoff (in.) for the storm of part a. What is the direct runoff for a net rain of 0.5 in./hr and a duration of Z Iv? c. Rain falls on the basinat arateof 4.5 in.lhr for a2-hr period and abruptly increases to a rate of 6.5 in./hr for a second2-hr period. convert theseactual intensitiesto netrain intensitiesusinga {index of 0.5 in./hr. Constructa tablethatproper$ lags and amplifiesthe 2-hr unit hydrograph,and determinethe hourly ordinates(cfs)of direct runoff for the storm.The deriveddirect runoff hydrographshouldbegin and end with zero dischargevalues. 12.18. Given the following 2-hr unit hydrograph for a drainage basin, determine hourly ordinatesof the 4-hr unit hydrograph:
Time (hr) 0@f9
0 0
1 50
2 300
3 400
4 200
5 s0
6 0
12.19. Usethe following 4-hr unit hydrographfor a basinto determinethe peak dischargerate (cfs)resulting from a net rain of 3.0 in./hr for a 4-hr duration foliowed immediately by 2.0 in.lhr for a 4-hr duration.
Time (hr) 0(cfO
0 0
2 200
4 300
6 100
8 50
10 0
PROBLEMS 231 12.20. Compare the time from the peak to the end of runoff for the SCS triangular unit hydrographwith the time of concentration,/". Discuss. 12.21. Prove that the areaunderthe rising limb of the SCSbasic dimensionlesshydrograph equalsthat of the triangular unit hydrograph,that is, 37.5 percefi of the total. 12.15occurswhenx:aB, 12.22. Bycalculus,showthatthemaximumvalueof/(x)inEq. for a > 1. Also solvefor the centroidaldistanceby taking the flrst moment aboutthe y axis. 12.23. Accordingto the rational method(seeChapter15) of estimatingpeakflow from small areasnthe peak rate for a storm with uniform continuingintensity is equal to the net rain rate and occurs at the time of concentration.For what conditions,if any, would ' Eqs. 12.63 and 12.17result in agreementof the peak magnitudeand time, estimated by CUHP, with those of the rational method?Discuss. L2.24. Describetwo methodsthat could be usedto constructa 2-hr unit hydrographusing a l-hr unit hydrographfor a basin. 12,25. Measuredtotal hourly dischargerates (cfs)from a 2.48-n12drainagebasin are tabulated below.The hydrographwas producedby a rainstormhavinga uniform intensity of 2.60 in./hr starting at 9 A.M.and abruptly ending at 11 l.rvl. The baseflow from 8 ,q,.lt.to 3 p.lrl.was a constant 100 cfs.
8 e.u. 100
Time Discharge(cfs)
11 450
10 300
9 100
1 p.vr. 2 150 100
12 300
J
100
a. At what time did direct runoff begin? b. Determinethe grossand net rain depths(inches). c. Derive a 2-hr unit hydrograph for the basin by tabulating time in hours and dischargein cubic feet per second. d. Derive a 4-hr unit hydrographfor the basin. e. Derive a l-hr unit hydrographfor the basin. 12,26. Given below is a 3-hr unit hydrographfor a watershed.The {-index is 1.5 in./hr. 3-hr rainfall ratesof 2.5, Desiredis the DRH for an 18-hr stormhavingsix successive 3 . 5 , 1 . 5 ,4 . 0 , 6 . 5 , 2 . 5i n . l h r .
Time (hr)
I
0
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10 11 12 13 14
o(ruH) 0 10 40 60 80 100 90 70 60 50 40 30 2 0 1 0 0 12.27. Use the following 2-hr unit hydrographto determinethe peak direct-runoffdischarge rate (cfs)resulting from a net rain of 2.0 in./hr for 5 hr'
Time (hr) 0(cf9
0 0
1 50
2 200
3 300
4 200
5 1s0
6 100
7 0
12.28, The ordinatefor a 5-hr unit hydrographis 300 cfs at a time 4 hr after the beginning of net rainfall. A storm with a uniform intensity of 3 in,/hr and a duration of 5 hr occursover the basin.What is the runoff rate after 4 hr if the @index is 0.5 in./hr?
232
CHAPTER 12 UNITHYDROGRAPHS 12.29. Given below is an IUH for a watershed.Use the IUH to find hourly DRH rates for a net rain of 4 in. in a 2-hr oeriod.
Time (hr)
o(ruH)
0 0
1 10
2 40
3 50
4 60
5 80
6 100
7 80
8 20
r0
9 10 0
12.30. A 2-fu unit hydrographfor a basin is shownin the sketch. a. Determinethe peak discharge(cfs)for a net rain of 5.00 in./hr and a duration of 2 hr. b. What is the total direct surfacerunoff (in inches)for the storm describedin part a? c. A different storm with a net rain of 0.50 in./hr lastsfor 4 hr. What is the discharse at 8 p.vr.if the rainfall startedat 4 p.tvt.?
{, +oo po
.A 2oo
--t I I
--i
T I I I
I I I
I I I I I I
I I -T I I I
Time (hr)
12.31,. Recordedflow rates for a net rain of 1.92 inchesin 12 hours are shownin the table. ' If the baseflow is 375 cfs throughoutthe storm,determinethe 12-hrunit hydrograph, and convert it to a 6-hr unit hydrograph.Then apply the 6-hr unit hydrographto determinethe total hydrograph(including 400 cfs baseflow) for a24-hr storm having four 6-hr blocksof net rain at ratesof 0.7, 3.8, 10.8,and 1.8 in. per hour.
Time in hours
0 6 12 18 aA JU
36 A'
48 54 60 66 72 78
Observedflow (cfs)
375 825 2200 36s0 3900 3200 2375 1,725 1250 900 650 490 410 375
12.32. Starting with a triangular-shapedunit hydrographwith a baselength of 2.67toand a height of qo,deriveEq. 12.22,qo : 484A/tp. Statethe units of eachterm usedin the .- --- derivatign"
REFERENCES 233 12.33. The SCS syntheticunit hydrographis derivedby computingthe peak dischargerate (cubicfeet per second)from qo : 484A/tp.In the derivation,it was actually assumed thatqrin.lhr:0.7sv/tp,whereVisthevolumeofdirectrunoff(inches),roisthetime to peak flow (hours),and A is the basin area(squaremiles).Derive the first equation from the second. 12.34. Which of the techniquesfor synthesizinga unit hydrographrequiresthe leastcomputationai effort in developingthe entire unit hydrograph?Which probably requiresthe most?
REFERENCES 1. W. D. Mitchell, "Unit Hydrographsin Illinois," illinois WaterwaysDivision, 1948. 2. L.K. Sherman,"Stream-Flowfrom Rainfall by the Unit-GraphMethod," Eng.News-Rec. 108,501-505(Apr. 1932). "Unit Hydrographsfor Gaugedand Ungauged 3. Rand Morgan and D. W. Hulinghorst, Watersheds,"U.S. EngineersOffice, Binghamton,NY, July 1939. 4. F. F. Snyder,"synthetic Unit Graphs," Trans.Am. Geophys.Union 19,447 -454(1938). 5. A. B. Taylorand H. E. Schwartz,"lJnit HydrographLag and PeakFlow Relatedto Basin Characteristics," Trans. Am. Geoplrys. Union 33' 235-246(19 52). 6. C. O. Clark, "storageand the Unit Hydrograph,"ASCE Trans.ll0,1419-1446(1945). 7. Water SupplyPapers, U.S. GeologicalSurvey,Water ResourcesDivision. Washington, D.C.: U.S. GovernmentPrintingOffice, 1966-1970. 8. Hourly PrecipitationData, National Oceanicand AtmosphericAdministration.Washington, D.C.: U.S. GovernmentPrinting Office, L971. "Synthesisof the Inlet Hydrograph,"Tech.Rept.No. 3, Department 9. JohnC. Schaake,Jr., of Sanitary Engineeringand WaterResources,The JohnsHopkins University,Baltimore, MD, 1965. 10. G. Aron andE. White, "Fitting a GammaDistribution overa SyntheticUnit Hydrograph," Bull.18(l) (Feb.1982). WaterResources Bull. l9(2) (Apr. 1983). 11. G. Aron and E. White, "Replyto Discussion,"WaterResources 12. M. Collins, "Discussion-Fitting a Gamma Distribution over a Synthetic Unit HyBull. 19(2) (Apr. 1983). drograph,"WaterResources 13. "Flood-HydrographAnalysisand Computations,"U.S. Army Corpsof Engtneets,Engin' neering and Design Manuals,Emlll0-2-1405. Washington,D.C.: U.S. Government PrintingOffice,Aug. 1959. "Hydrograph Synthesisby Digital Computer," Proc. 14. M. D. Hudlow and R. A. Clark, ASCEJ. Hyd. Div. (May 1969). 15. V. Mockus, "Use of Storm and WatershedCharacteristicsin SyntheticHydrographAnalService,1957. ysisandApplication,"U.S.Departmentof Agriculture,Soil Conservation 16. D. M. Gray,"synthetic Unit Hydrographsfor Small DrainageAreas," Proc' ASCEJ. Hyd. Div. 87(HY4) (July 1961). 17. W. H. EspeyandD. G. Altman, "Nomographsfor Ten-minuteUnit Hydrographsfor Small Urban Witersheds,"EnvironmentalProtectionAgency,Rept.EPA-600/9-78-035,Washington,D.C., 1978. 18. J. E. Nash, "The Form of the InstantaneousUnit Hydrograph," IASH Publ. No. 45' Vol. ' 3. 1951. "ConceptualHydrologicModels for Urbanizing 19. R. A. Rao, J. W. Delleur, and B. Sarma, Basins,"Proc. ASCE J. Hyd. Div. (HY7) (July 1972). "First Short Courseon Urban Storm WaterModeling 20. University of Coloradoat Denver, Using ColoradoUrban HydrographProcedures,"Departmentof Civil Engineering,June 1985.
C h a p t e r1 3
HydrographRouting
r Prologue The purposeof this chapteris to: . Presenttechniquesfor determiningthe effect of streamsand reservoirson hydrographshapesasthe hydrographsmovedownstreamthrough the systems. . Distinguishbetweenthe two major classificationsof hydrographrouting techniques. . Familiarizethe readerwith proceduresfor determiningwhen to apply eachof the variousrouting methods. Flood forecasting,reservoirdesign,watershedsimulation,and comprehensivewater resourcesplanning generallyutilize someform of routing technique.Routingis used to predict the temporal and spatial variationsof a flood wave as it traversesa river reach or reservoir. Routing techniquesmay be classified into two categorieshydrologicrouting and hydraulic routing. Hydrologic routing employsthe equationof continuity with either a linear or curvilinear relation betweenstorageand dischargewithin a river or reservoir. Hydraulic routing, on the other hand, usesboth the equation of continuity and the equationof motion, customarilythe momentumequation.This particular form utilizes the partial differential equationsfor unsteadyflow in open channels.It more adequatelydescribesthe dynamicsofflow than doesthe hydrologicrouting technique. Applications of hydrologicrouting techniquesto problemsof flood prediction. of the effectsof urbanization evaluationsof flood control measures,and assessments are numerous.Most flood warning systemsinstituted by NOAA and the Corps of Engineersincorporatethis techniqueto predict flood stagesin advanceof a severe storm.It is the methodmost frequentlyusedto sizespillwaysfor small, intermediate. and large dams. Hydrologic river and reservoirrouting and hydraulic river routing techniquesare presentedin separatesectionsof this chapter.
13.1 HYDROLOGICRIVER ROUTING
235
RIVERROUTING 13.1 HYDROLOGIC The first referenceto routing a flood hydrographfrom one river station to another was by Graeff in 1883.1The techniquewasbasedon the useof wavevelocity and a rating curve of stageversus discharge.Hydrologic river routing techniquesare all founded upon the equationof continuity dS (1 3 . 1 ) I - O : dt where
1 : the inflow rate to the reach O : the outflow rate from the reach dS/dt : the rate of changeof storagewithin the reach
Three of the most popular hydrologicriver routing techniquesare describedin subsequent paragraphs,
MuskingumMethod Storagein a stableriver reachcan be expectedto dependprimarily on the discharge into and out of a reach and on hydraulic characteristicsof the channelsection.The storagewithin the reach at a given time can be expressedas2
s:2;y7^n+(1 - X)O-n1 a
(r3.2)
Constantsa andn reflectthe stagedischargecharacteristicsof control sectionsat each end of the reach,and b and m mirror the sta$e-volumecharacteristicsof the section. The factor X defines the relative weights given to inflow and outflow for the reach. The Muskingum method assumesthat mfn - L and lets b/a : K, resulting in
S: KIXI + (1 - X)o]
(13.3)
where K : the storagetime constantfor the reach x : a weighting factor that variesbetween0 and 0.5. Application of this equationhas shownthat K is usually reasonablycloseto the wave trarel time through the reach andX averagesabout 0.2. Behavior of the flood wave due to changesin the value of the weighting factor X is readily apparentfrom examinationof Fig. 13.1. The resulting downstreamflood waveis commonlydescribedby the amountof translation-that is, the time lag-and by the amount of attenuationor reduction in peak discharge.As can be noted from Fig. 13.1,'thevalueX : 0.5 resultsin a pure translationof the flood wave. Application of Eqs. 13.1 and 13.3 to a river reachis a straightforwardprocedure if Kand X are known. The routing procedurebeginsby dividing time into a number of equal increments,A/, and expressingEq. 13.1 in finite difference form, using subscriptsI and2 to denotethe beginningand ending times for Ar. This gives I t + 1 2_ O 1 + 0 2 _ S ' - S ' 2 2 A t
(13.4)
236
CHAPTER13
HYDROGRAPHROUTING
o
99 E
E
Time
Figure 13.1 Effect of weighting factor. The routing time interval A/ is normally assigned any convenient value between the limits of K/3 and K. The storagechangein the river reachduringthe routing interval from Eq. 1 3 . 3i s
s, - s' : Klx(I' - 1')+ (r - x)(o2- o')l
(13.s)
and substitutingthis into Eq. 13.4 resultsin the Muskingum routing equation O2:
CsI2+ CII. + CzOl
( 13.6)
in which
-KX + 0.5Ar K-KX+0.54/ KX + 0,5 Lt ct: K-KX+0.54t K - K X- 0 . 5 A r
co
cz:
K-KX+0.54t
(r3.7) (13.8)
(13.e)
Note that K and Ar must havethe sametime units and aiso that the three coefficients sum to 1.0. Theoretical stability of the nunrericalmethod is accomplishedif Al falls betweenthe limits 2KX and2K(I - X). The theoreticalvalue of K is the time required for an elemental(kinematic) waveto traversethe reach.It is approximatelythe titne interval betweeninflow and outflow peaks, if data are available.If not, the wave velocity can be estimatedfor variouschannelshapesas a function of averagevolocity Vfor any representativeflow rate Q. Velocityfor steadyuniform flow canbe estiinated by either thi Manning or Ch€zyequation: The approximatewavevelocities for different channel'shapesare given in Table 13.1. FORVARIOUS WAVEVELOCITIES 13.1 KINEMATIC TABLE ' CHANNELSHAPES
Channelshape Wide rectangular Triangular Wide parabolic
Manningequation t-V !v lJrl 9 '
Ch6zyequation 3-tl 2 l
tv Zrl 6 '
ROUTING 237 RIVER 13.1 HYDROLOGIC Since1, and Irareknown for every time increment,routing is accomplishedby time incrementsusing each02as Ol for the next time solvingEq. 13.6for successive incremeni. Example 13.1 illustratesthis row-by-row computation'
EXAMPLE 13.1 : 2 days.The Perform the flood routing for a reach of river given X : 0.2 and K : 1 day is shownin Table 13.2,column 1. Assumeequal inflow hydrographwith Ar inflow and outflow rates on the 16th. Solution. If Ar : l dayandX = 0.2 andK :2days, thenEqs.13.7toI3.9 give Co : 0.0477,C1 : 0.428, andC2 : 0'524' Row-by-rowcomputationis given in TabIe13.2. ll Determination of Muskingum K andX Valuesof K andX for Muskingumrouting are commonly estimatedusingK equal to the travel time in the reachand an average value of X : 0.2.If inflow and outflow hydrographrecords are availablefor one or more floods,the routing processis easilyreversedto provide better valuesof K and X for the reach. To illustrate the latter method, instantaneousvalues of S versus TABLE13.2 (1)
(2\
(3)
(4)
Date
lnflow
voI2
Crl't
C,Q,
3-t6 17 18 19 20 21, 22
4,260 7,646 11,167 16,730 21,590 20,950 26,570 46,000 59960 57,'t40 47,890 34,460 21,660 34,680 45,180 49,r40 41,290 33,830 20,5t0 t4,720 11,436
z3
24 25 26 27 28 29 30 J I
4-l 2 4 5 6 7 8 9
364 532 798 1,029 999 L,267 2,194 2,860
t,823 3,2'72
) )7)
7,160 9,240 8,966 tl,37l 19,688 25,662
2,315 3,206 4,602 6,702 8,877 10,013 12,355 18,289
)a1l)
)4 417
1,643 1,033 1,654 t r55
20,496 14,748 9,270 14,843
26,9'70
1q??7
r,969 t,613 9'78 702
2t,031, 17,672 14,479 8,778 6,300 4,894 3,977
l7,879 20,729 22,914
)'754 ) )24
o )04
443
7,831 6,228 6,083
3 t J
29'| 290
4 114
? ?{1 ) 66\
)\ 117 )'t 171 t7 1))
)t
11)
19,686 t5,283 11,595 8,872 6,928
(5) Computed outflow 4,260 4,419 6,rr9 8,783 12,791 16,941 1 9 ,1 0 23,578 34903 46,705 51,469 49,109 41,514 32,67' | 34,120 39,559 43,729 42,199 37,569 29,166 22,128 t6,932 13,222 10,576 8,497
238
CHAPTER13
HYDROGRAPHROUTING
XI + (l -- X)O are flrst graphedfor severalselectedvaluesof Xas shownin Example 13.2.BecauseS andXI + (1 - X)O are assumed to be linearlyrelatedvia Eq. 13.3, the acceptedvalue of X is that which gives the best linear plot (the narrowestloop). After plotting, the valuefor K is determinedas the reciprocalof the slopethrough the narrowestloop, sincefrom Eq. 13.3
K :
( 13 . 1 0 )
n+0-x)o
Instantaneousvaluesof S for the graphsin Example I3.2 were determinedby solvingfor S, in Eq. 13.4for successive time increinents.A valueof S, : 0 was [sed for the initial increment,but the value is arbitrary since only the slope and not the intercept of E_q.13.3 is desired.The 52 valuesare plotted against.average weighted discharges,XI + (l - X)O in Table 13.3. A preferablemethod would be to plot S, valuesagainstcorrespondingvaluesof instantaneous(rather than average)valuesof XIz + (l - X)Or, using recordedvaluesof inflow and outflow (not provided).
TABLE13,3 -
Date 3- 16 t7 18 t9 20 21 22 23 z+
25 3-26 27 28 29 30 3l 4-r 2 J
4 5 6 7 8
l.ll"
2 (cfs) 5,870 9,310 12,900 20,500 21,000 23,400 32,500 s5,400 62,700 52,600 43,200 25,200 22,800 41,200 s0,400 45,300 38,800 2?,000 16,200 12,400 10,200 8,080 6,010 5,050
u =
Oj+02
2 (cfs) 4,180 6,970 7,560 14,200 18,300 18,500 21,300 29,300 39,700 48,700 53,300 48,700 37,r00 35,800 35,800 35,800 42,700 44,lOO 35,400 25,200 t6,400 11,500 9,380 7,860
"Note: ,S2= ,Sr* f Ar - d Al fseeEq. 13.4]. ' E x a m p l e :4 3 5 0 : 0 . 1 ( 5 8 7 0 )+ ( 1 - 0 . 1 X 4 1 8 0 ) .
sz
Weighted discharge (cfs) X+(1 -X)O
(1O3cfs-days)
X: 0.1
X : 0.2
1.7 4.0 9.4 15.7 18.4
4,350b 7,200 8,090 14,800 18,600 19,000 22,400 31,900 42,000 49,100 52,300 46,400 35,700 36,300 37,300 36.800 42,300 42,400 33,500 23,900 15,800 1r,200| 9;040 7,300
4,520 't,440
z5-J
34.5 60.6 83.6 97.5 87.4 73.9 Jv.o
65.0 79.6 89.r 85.2 68.0 48.9 36.1 29.9 26.5 23.1 20.3
8,630 15,500 18,800 19,500 23,500 34,500 44,300 49,500 51,300 44,000 34,200 36,900 38,700 37,700 41,900 40,800 31,600 22,600 15,200 10,800 8,710 7,300
X: 0.3 4,690 7,670 9,160 16,100 19,100 20,000 24,700 37,100 46,600 50,000 50,300 41,700 32,800 37,400 40,200 38,600 41,500 39,000 29,600 2r,400 14,500 10,500 8,370 7,020
13.1 HYDROLOGIC RIVERROUTING
239.,
EXAMPLE 13.2 Given inflow and outflow hydrographson the Muckwamp River, determine K and X for the river reach.(SeeTable 13.3.)
o po
€
ro X
,a o x 5 A
I
E e .E b0 o
g t\ X
80.000 cfs-davs Storage,S
Solution. Selecting the narrowest loop gives X : 0.3; K : 80,000 cfsdays/40,000cfs : 2.0 days. These values could now be used to route other floods through the reachas in Example 13.1. Inherent in this procedureis the postulatethat the water surfacein the reachis a uniform unbrokensurfaceprofile betweenupstreamand downstream ends of the section.Additionally, it is presupposedthat K andX are constant throughoutthe range of flows. If significantdeparturesfrom theserestrictions are present,it may be necessaryto work with shorterreachesof the river or to employ a more sophisticatedapproach. I I Muskingum Crest Segment Routing Sometirnesit is desirableto solve for a single outflow rate or route only a portion of an inflow hydrographby the Muskingum method(e.g.,the crest segmentwhen only the peak outflow is desired).This is easily accomplishedby successivelynumbering the inflow rates as 11, 12, 13,. . . , In, In+t,. .. , and rewritingEq. 13.6as O,:
( 1 3 .11)
CsI, + Ctln-t + C2O^-l
where Onis the outflow rate at any time n. The outflow O,-1 is next eliminated from Eq. 13.11by makingthe substitution On-t :
Coln-t + ClIn-2 *
C2O,-2
(r3.r2)
By repeatedsubstitutionsfor the right-sideoutflow tetm On-2,On-2,. . . can eachbe eliminated and On can be expressedas a function only of the flrst n inflow rates or, finally, On : where Kr: Kz= K3: K,:
K l I n + K 2 I n - 1 + K 3 I n - 2+ '
Co CoC2+ C1 K2C2 K,-rC.rfori>.2
.' + K,I,
(13.13)
240
CHAPTER13
HYDROGRAPHROUTING
Using data from Example 13.1 to find the outflow rate on 3-26, we obtain Kr : C6: 0.0477 Kz: CoC2+ Cr : 0.0477(0.524) + 0.428:0.4530 : 0.2374 Kz : KzCz: 0.4530(0.524) Krt:
KrcG : 0.0013
Thus the outflow on 3-26 is calculatedas O11: 0.0477 X (47,g90)+ 0.4530 X (57,740)+ . . . + 0.0013(4260): 51,469cfs.
SCS ConvexMethod The U.S. Soil ConservationService (SCS) developeda coefficient channelrouting technique,similar to the Muskingum method, in their National EngineeringHanibook.3It has had widespreadapplication in planning and,designand can be used successfullyevenwhenlimited storagedatafor the reachare available.Until 1983,the procedurewas usedfor all streamflowhydrographrouting in TR-20, the SCS storm event simulation computer program describedin Chapter 24. Newer versions of TR-20 usethe att-kin methoddescribedin Section13.3. Analysis of Fig. 13.2 producesthe working equation for the convex routing method.Becausethe areasunderboth curvesare equal,and becausethe peak outflow
Figure 13.2 Geometricrelationsusedin the scs convexrouting method.(After U.S. Soil ConservationService.3)
RIVERROUTING 13.1 HYDROLOGIC
241
is lessthan (and occurslater than) the peak inflow, the curvescrossat somepoint A, resultingin the fact that the value Orwill alwaysfall betweenIl andOt. At any time, the vertical distanceof 02 aboveOr (or below 01 on the right of A) is a fraction C, of the differenceIt - 01 as shown in the inset of Fig. 13.2. By proportionatevertical distances Oz:
O t + C , ( 1 1- O )
(r3.r4)
This could be usedto route the entire inflow hydrographif C, could be established. FromEq. 13.14,
-'-
or- o, 1,.-o,
(13.1s)
BecauseAl is one limb of the triangle in the inset to Fig. 13.2, Lt _O"- O, Ir-O, K
(13.16)
where the constantK is the horizontal time from O, to the interseptionof the line passingthrough Ol and 02. Thus C, is a function of both A/ and K, or n r_- Lv t w
(r3.r7)
routing method. Determination of K and C, Proof that K from Fig. 13.2is a constantis left to the reader.It is a storageparameterwith time units and can be approximatedby the K from the Muskingummethod.Similarly, C, is approximatelytwice the MuskingumX. The reach length divided by wavevelocity (estimatedfrom Table 13.1) will provide another estimateof K, or actual measurementsof reach travel time can be used. Equation 13.l'l canthenbe solvedfor C,. The valuerecommendedby the SCS,in the absenceof other estimates,is C,:
(13.18)
where Vis the velocity for a representativesteadydischarge,andV * 1.7 approximatesthe celerity (speed)of a kinematic wavetravelingthrough the reach.The units of V in Eq. 13.18are feet per second(fps). Routingby Eq. 13.14is easilyaccomplishedafter the C, valueis estimated.The interval Ar shouldbe one-fifth or lessof the time to peak of the inflow hydrographto assurea sufficient number of calculatedoutflow rates to deflne the hydrograph.As with all routing methods,the time interval shouldbe selectedso that one point falls at or near the peak and other locationsof rapid change.
242
CHAPTER13
ROUTING HYDROGRAPH
Unlike otherrouting methods,the convexmethodequationfor O, is independent of 1r. Thus the proceduie can be used to forecast outflow from a reach without tnowing the concurrent inflow. This provides a method for early calculation and warninf for floods.Flow recorderscanbe linked through microprocessorsto warning systemsthat calculate downstreamflood potentials at least one full routing-time interval aheadof the flood. The procedurecan be reversedto find the inflow hydrographfor a given outflow hydrograph,or it can route a cumulativemasscurve of inflow to the reachinsteadof the hydrograPhitself.
Method Muskingum-Cunge been Severalattemptsto overcomethe limitations of the Muskingummethodhavelot physically in or difficulties complexity totally ,u"""riful becauseof computational interpretingthe routing parameteri.a'sThe Muskingum parametersare best derived fiom streamflowmeasurementsand are not easilyrelatedto channelcharacteristics. Cunge6blendedthe accuracyof the diffusion wave method (seeSection 13.3) with the simplicity of the Muskingum method, resulting in one of the most recomgives mendedtechniquesfor generaluse.It is classifiedas a hydrologicmethod,yet it methods' resultscomparablewith hydraulic Cungeshowedthat ihe finite-differenceform of the Muskingum equationbecomesthe diffusion waveequationif the parametersfor both methodsare appropriatelyrelated'From Eqs. 13.1 and I3'3, the Muskingumequationis s
-
K+ln+(l-x)ol:t-o
( 13. 1e)
dt-
obtain SubstitutingQ,for I andQi*rfot O, andrewritingin finite-differenceform' we
+ (1 - x)Q"+l- xQI- (1 - x)Qi*,] fir"a':' - Oi+i+ Qi- Q',*') : t(Q',*'
(13'20)
If K is set equalto Lxfc,Eq. 13.20is alsothe finite-differenceform of
u #* ' H : o
(t3.2r)
which is calledthe kinematicwave equation(seeEq. 13.59)and can be derivedby Ax combining the continuity and -oln"ntu- (or friction) equations.TThe variable denotesunincrerrr"ntofdistancealongthestreamaxisandcisthewavespeed' The equationto be usedfor routing is obtainedfrom Eq . 13.20by solvingfor the unknown flow rate,
O i I i : c o Q ' , * ' c+ t Q i * c r Q i * ,
(r3.22)
where
co
Lt/K - 2X 2(r-x)+Lt/K
(r3.23)
RIVERROUTING 13.1 HYDROLOGIC
LtlK + 2x
cr: 4 v2
-
2(r-x)+Lt/K 2(I-x)-cLt/Lx "
'
2(I-x)+Lt/K ./r
.-\
L
243
(r3.24) (r3.2s)
Aal?
BecauseK : A,xfc,it representsthe time for a waveto travelthe routing reachlength Ax, moving at velocity t. Congeshowsthat the velocity c is the celerity of a kinematic wavepreviouslydescribed(Table 13'1). When X : 0.5 and c Lt/A,x: 1.0, the routing equationproducestranslation without attenuation.When Ax : 0 (zeroreachlength),no translationor attenuation occurs. If previousflood data are available,the routing parameterc canbe extractedby reversingthe routing calculations.Estimatesof the parameterscan also be obtained from flow and channelmeasurements. The value of X for use in Cunge'sformulation is
x:t('-#t)
(r3.26)
where So : channelbottom slope (dimensionless) for the peak rate 4o : dischargeper unit width (cfs/fO,normally determined The value of celerity c can be estimatedas a function of the averagevelocity V by Q3.27)
mV
c:
where v is the averagevelocity QfA, andm is aboutI for wide natural channels.The coefficientm comesfrom the uniform flow equation Q:
(13.28)
bA-
which reduces,by taking partial derivatives,to
o Q: A
A
*g: A
*y
(r3.2e)
Substitutingthis into the continuity equation
Q*4:o 6x
(13.30)
At
givesEq. I3.2t if c : mv.If dischargedata ate available,m canbe estimatedfrom nq. tZig. Valuesfor commonshapechannelsare given in Table 13'1' The rout{rg can now be done using either constantm and c parameters(i.e., using a single ai'eragevelocity) or variableparameters(usingeachnew velocity v). equition I-3.2i rs solvedfor c, the valueX is derivedfrom Eq. 13.26,andE6' 13.23 to 13.25are solvedusing K : Lx/c. When using this rnethod,the valuesof Ax and Ar shouldbe selectedto assure that the flood wa-vedetailsare proper$ routed.Nominally' the time to peak of inflow is broken into 5 or 10 time incrementsAt. To give both temporal and spatialresolution, the total reachlength l, can be dividedinto severalincrementsof Ax length, and outflow from eachis treated as inflow to the next.
244
CHAPTER13
HYDROGRAPHROUTING
EXAMPLE 13.3 Usethe Muskingum-Cungemethodto route the hydrographfrom Example13.2.Use So: 0.0001,Lx : 545 mi, flow cross-sectionalareaat Q : 59,960is 5996 ft2, width at Q : 59,960is 60 ft, and Ar : 1.0 day (asin Example13.2). Solution. From the inflow, the peak rate of 59,960cfs gives
59.960
o^
So:T
59,960:,, V r-: TQo -
l0fps
c : Z V o : 1 6 . 7f p s From Eq. 13.26
":;1,
't
1000 :0.4 (16.7)s4s (s280) 0.0001 L
L* K :
7:
I I
-545(5280) ff: 1 7 2 , 8s 0e 0c C": -0.1765 Ct: 0'7647 Cz: 0'294I
and
The routing for a portion of the hydrographis as follows:
Date, t
3-16 17 18 t9 20 2l 22 L3
24 25 26 27 3-28
CoQ'*L*
- 1350 -r970 -2950 -3810 -3700 -4690 -8120 - 10,580 10,190 -8450 -6080 -3820 -6120
Ct Qti*ro*
3260 5850 8540 12,790 16,510 16,020 20,320 35,180 45,850 44,150 36,620, 26,3sO 16,560
Cz Qlutno*
0 560 1310 2030 3240 4720 4720 4980 8700 13,050 14,340 13,200 10,510
Qli*.* r9r0 (3-r7) 4440 6900 11,010 16,050 16,050 16p20 29,580 44,360 48,750 44,880 35,730 20,9s0(3-29)
Note that the peak outflow of 48,750 cfs on March 26 occurson the samedate as in Example I3.2 but has experiencedslightly greaterattenuationfrom the Muskingum-Cunge example. The value C, is alwayspositive,and negativevaluesof C, arenot particularly troublesome.Although C0is negativein this example,this condition should be avoidedin practice.As seenfrom Eq. 13.23, negativevaluesof Coare avoided
ROUTING 245 RESERVOIR 13.2 HYDROLOGIC
when
^|,
,* rr
(13.31)
Other Methods Other hydrolSgicriver routing procedureshavebeendeveloped,includingthe working method,Tatummethod,and multiple storagemethod. R&D method,straddle-stagger They all appear as options in HEC-I, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineer's event simulation and routing model describedin Chapter24.
ROUTING RESERVOIR 13.2 HYDROLOGIC The storageindication method of routing a hydrographthrough a reservoiris also calledthe modified Pulsmethod.8A flood wavepassingthrough a storagereservoiris both delayedand attenuatedas it enters and spreadsover the pool surface.Water storedin the reservoiris gradually releasedas pipe flow through turbines or outlet works, calledprincipal sprllways,or in extremefloods, over an emergencyspillway. Flow over an ungatedemergencyspillway weir sectioncan be describedfrom energy,momentum,and continuity considerationsby the form O:
CYH'
(r3.32)
where O : the outflow rate (cfs) Y : the length of the spillway crest (ft) H : deepestreservoirdepth abovethe spillway crest (ft) C : the dischargecoefficientfor the weir or section,theoretically 3'0 x : exponent,theoreticallyJ Flow through a free outlet dischargepipe is similarly describedby Eq. 13.32 where' I H C .r
: : : :
the cross-sectionalareaof the dischargepipe (ft') head above the free outlet elevation (ft) the pipe dischargecoefficient, theoretically\/29 exponent,theoreticallyj
Flow equations for other outlet conditions are availablein hydraulics textbooks. Storagevaluesfor variouspool elevationsin a reservoirare readily determinedfrom computationsof volumesconfinedbetweenvariouspool areasmeasuredfrom topographic maps. Since storageand outflow both dependonly on pool elevation,the resulting storage-elivationcurve and the outflow-elevationrelation (Eq. 13.32) can easily be combinedto form a storage-outflowgraph. Storagein a reservoirdepends only on the outflow, contrastedto the dependenceon the inflow and outflow in river routing(Eq. 13.3). "surchargestorage"or the storage For convenience,,Sis often defined as the abovethe emergencyspillwaycrest.Normally the overflowrate is zero when,Sis zero. Ifthe graphedstorage-outflowrelation is found to be linear, and ifthe slopeofthe line
246
CHAPTER13
HYDROGRAPHROUTING
is definedas K, then (13.33)
S : KO
is a and the reservoiris called a linear reservoir. Routing through a linear reservoir : 13.3' 0'0inEq. 13.l-usingr showninFig. Muskingumriverrouting specialcaseof exceeds Note alsothat the,outfl-owrate in Fig. tg.t is increasingonly while the inflow immeinflow the that assumptions the outflow.This observationis conJistentwith the only depends outflow the that and diatelygoesinto storageoverthe entirepool surface on this storage. time Routing through a linear reservoiris easily accomplishedby first dividing : and I3'4 Eq. Ko2into s2 into a numberof equal incrementsand then substituting increment' time each for solving for oz, wtrictris the only remainingunknown To route an emergencyRo'oathrough anonlinear reservoir,the storage-outflow the outflow relation and the continiity equation,Eq. L3'4,are combinedto determine as rewritten be can I3'4 and storageat the end of'eachtime inciement A/. Equation
r , + r n +.1( * - o , )
:'+
(r3.34)
t on+t
side'Pairs in which the only unknown for any time incrementis the tgt_*:n the right checked .34 and 13 Eq. satisfy that generated b" of trial valuesof S"*, andO,*1"ould procetrial this to resort than Rather confirmation. fot in the storage-outflow"uru" replottedas dure, a valrieof At is selectedand points on the storageoutflow curve are direct determithe ';storageindication" curve shownin Fig. 13.3' This graph allowsa I On+rhas been Zl,*rfLt ordinate the of value a o11ce nation of the outflow O,11 from the S-O calculatedfrom Eq. f :.:4' ftre secondunknown' S,*t, can be read 13.3)orfoundfromEq'13'34' curve(whichcouldilsobeplottedonthegraphinFig. t200 I
/ / {, 600
: .il<
0
1
0
2
0
3
0 4 0 Outflow (cfs)
5
Figure 13.3 Curveof zsl\t + O versusO'
0
19.2 HYDROLOGICRESERVOIRROUTING
247
This row-by-rownumericalintegrationof Eq. 13.34with Fig. 13.3is illustratedusing Ar : t hr in ExampleI3.4. EXAMPLE 13.4
Giventhe tria4gular-shapedinflow hydrographand the 2S/Lt + O curve ofFig. 13.3 find the outflow hydrograph for the reservoir assumingit to be completely full at the beginningof the storm.(SeeTable 13.4.)
o 90
o Time (hr)
In selectinga routing period Ar, generallyat leastfive points on the rising limb of the inflow hydrographare employedin the calculations.An increasednumber of points on the rising limb, that is, a small A/, improvesthe accuracy,sinceas A/ - 0 the numerical integrationapproachesthe true limit of the function being integrated, in this casedSfdt. Column 3 in Table 13.4 comesfrom the given inflow hydrograph,column 4 is simply the addition of I, + In*r, andColumns5 andT are initially zero, sincein this problem the reservoir is assumedfull at the commencementof inflow. Therefore, there is no availablestorage. TABLE 13.4 ROUTINGTABLE (1)
(2)
Time (hr) 0 I z 3 +
5 6 '7 8 9 t0 ll t2
(3) ln
(cfs)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ll 1 t
0 0 0 0 120, 150 180 135 9 0 45 0 2 0 3 0 3 6 9
(4) I, + In+l (cfs) -tt,
90 150 2lo 270 330 315 225 135 0 0 0
'n-o. (5)
(cfs) 0 20 74 160 284 450 664 853 948 953 870 746 630
(6) 2Sn+1 , a -;fT vn+1
(cfs) JU
(7)
(8)
an+t
Sn+t
(cfs)
(cfs-hr)
5 18
12.5 46 96 164 250 361 458 506 510 467 404 344 288
110 224 370
3Z
))4
52
780 979
)6
r078 1085 998 870 746 630
AA
63 65 65 64 62 58 54
248
ROUTING 13 HYDROGRAPH CHAPTER the sum of columns4 The starting value for n : 1 in column 6 is computedas and 5 from F,q.13.34
25" - + o2 Lt 25. 3 0 * 0 : - - + o2
(L + 12)- ( * - o ' )
:
Lt
column 6 gives a valuefor Enteringthe ordinateof Fig. 13.3 with the value 30 from end-of-time-interval o, of 5 cfs, which is recordedin column 7 , The corresponding 8. Moving to column in recorded and 6 and7 columns storage,s,, is calculatedfrom n be found fof : 2 usings' the secondfow, a value of the term in column 5 can now and O, from columns7 and 8' ThestepwiseprocedureusedtogetoutflowfiguresforallncanbeSumma. rized as l.Entriesincolumnsland3areknownfromthegiveninflow.hydrograph. column 3' - 2. Entries in column 4 arc the additionsof I' t I'*' in 3.Theinitialvalueofthetermincolumn5iszero,thoughitcouldalsobe 4 and 5 are based on any arbitrary starting storagevalue' and columns addedto producethe value in column 6' 4.The2SlA,t+oversusoplotisenteredwithknownvaluesotzSlLt+o to find valuesof O for column 7' 5.Columns6andlaresolvedforS,+r,whichisrecordedincolumn8. for column 5 usingthe 6. Advanceto the next row and calculatethe next value 7 and 8' valuesin the precedingrow for O and S {om columns 4 and enterthe 7. Add the value in cotuin 5 to the advancedsum in column result in column 6 for the new period under consideration' 8.ThenewoutflowforcolumnTisagainfoundfromtherelationof ZSlLt + O as in Fig. 13.3. g.Thecorrespondingnewstorageincolumn8isfoundbysolvingfrom columns6 andT' l.0.Steps6throughgarerepeateduntiltheentireoutflowhydrographisgenerated. rl
RIVERROUTING 13.3 HYDRAULIC ploys both the equationof continuity and utions to the complete hydrarllic routing
ili"'nTil::ll;lffi ffffii.;fiffi:::
tions. Hydraulicfoutingtechniquesarehelpfulinsolvingriverroutingproblems,overthe simultaneoussolution land flow, or sheetnow. uyaraulic routing proceedsfrom of the combinationfor forms general 1'ne of expression,of continoiti una-o*"ntuir, rivers are called the spatically varied unsteadyfl'ow equations'
13.3 HYDRAULIC RIVER ROUTING 249 Theseequationsalso apply to sheetflow or overland flow and include terms for laterally incoming rainfall. They can be simplified and used to resolveriver routing problems.eFor completeneisof presentation,a generalform of the spatially varied unsteadyflow equationswill be presentedfirst.
Equationof Continuity The equation of continuity statesthat inflow minus outflow equals the changein storage.To relatethis conceptto a river sectionundera condition ofrainfall or lateral inflow, consideran elementof length Ax and unit width into the page as shown in Fig. 13.4. The total inflow is
,,*.r)dtdx (1335) ,(, - X+)(, - * *) * * , [.' l,'*o' The total outflow is
+t*+)(,.#?) o' o(v
(13.36)
* ofrl,"
(r3.37)
The changein storageis
l(x, t)
,(,-#+)(,-
o ( v * o?t) ( r . * + ) l
f
A
x
L
x
2--*l-- 2(a)
i(x, t)
ft) Figure 13.4 Continuity and momentum elements(where p : the density of water, V : the averagevelocity. 1l : the depth. i : the lateral inflow per elemental Ax, and S = the slopeof the river bottom).
250
CHAPTER13
HYDROGRAPHROUTING
Consequently,continuity gives
-o(r{*tx + vfia') a, + pl A,xL, -
oX L,xL,t: o
(13.38)
where i is the averagelateral inflow resulting from rainfall over Ax and Ar. The continuity equation of unsteadyflow with lateral inflow is obtained by simplifyingEq. 13.38 6V .,0y , 0y "v6- x- | v - - 6r x At
:
( 13 .3e)
For otherthan a unit width, Eq. 13.39takesthe form
e d{x + v dYx * *d t-
l : 0
(13.40)
whereA is the width times the depth,y.
MomentumEquation In accordancewith Newton's secondlaw of motion, the changeof momentumper unit of time on a body is equal to the resultantof all externalforces acting on the body. The following derivationof the momentumequationof spatiallyvariedunsteadyflow is presentedsubjectto the following assumptions:(1) the flow is unidirectional and velocity uniform acrossthe flow section;(2) the pressureis hydrostatic;(3) the slope of the river bottom is relatively small; (4) the Manning formula may be used to evaluatethe friction lossdueto shearat the channelwall; (5) lateral inflow entersthe stream with no velocity componentin the direction of flow; and (6) the value of I representsthe spatial and time variationsof lateral inflow. Forcesactingon an elementof lengthAx andunit width are shownin Fig. i 3.4b. The forcesF1andF, representhydrostaticforceson the elementand are expressedas
atvA)axl - ylyA f-, - -;zl F,:
(13.41)
- - lL,!^ .f-^ - a(la)Axl rz: A- Z l
(r3.42)
wherey is the distancefrom the watersurfaceto the centroidofthe area.The resultant hydrostaticforce is F, - Fr, or \
1
r ,6:
-ra(!A) * x
(13.43)
By assuminga small slope for the river bottom, the gravitational force is given by Fr : yASA.x
(13.44)
The frictional force alongthe bottom is equalto the friction slope$multiplied by the weisht of water in an elementAx. \:
vASyLx
( 13 .4s )
13.3 HYDRAULICRIVER ROUTING
251
The rate of changeof momentumin the length Ax may be expressedas d(mv)
dV
:
,.dm
iii____ T
dt
(r3.46)
V____
dt
dt
in which m is the massof fluid. If it is assumedthat the incoming lateral inflow entersthe moving fluid with no velocity componentin the direction of flow and I representsthe spatial and time variationsof the lateral inflow, the rate of changeof momentumfor the elementcan be expressedas
dv dtuv) T:pALxi+pvi
(r3.47)
Lx
wherc dV/dt represents
dv av ,,av at
dt
T
(13.48)
v -
Ex
The rate of changeof momentumis therefore
(r3.4e)
oe*(Ya,. "#) + pviL,x
Equating the rate of changeof momentumto all externalforces acting on the elementresults in
{*r{+gaFA) A
t
O
x
A
O
+L:s(s-s) x
A
(13.50)
Now for a unit width element,the relation simplifiesto
{u,* r{u** tX+Yri : s{s- s) : o
( 1 3 .1s)
that can be expressions Equations13.50and 13.51form a set of simultaneouS solvedfor V and y subjectto the appropriateboundary conditions.
and DynamicWaves Kinematic,Diffusionn For the casewith zerclaterclinflow, l, Eq. 13.51can be solvedfor the friction slope c
_
Friction slope
c
_
Bed slope
Kinematic wave
Ev
:
Water surface slope
VAV
Convective acceleration
Diffusion wave Fu11dynamic wave
IAV
Temporai accelelation
(r3.s2)
252
ROUTING CHAPTER13 HYDROGRAPH
The three typesof analysisof unsteadyflow routing in open channelsare classifiedas kinematic,diffusion (also called noninertia), anddynamicwaveanalyses,depending on which terms in F;q. 13.52 are retained. The three techniquesdiffer not only by including different terms of Eq. 13.52 but also in the assumptionsregarding flow conditions for satisfyingthe momentum equation.Table 13.5 showstheseassumptions. HYDRAULIC USEDIN VARIOUS TABLE13.5 ASSUMPTIONS METHODS ROUTING Method Kinematic Diffusion Full dynamic
Watersurfaceprofile
Commonflow condition
Uniform Nonuniform Nonuniform
Steady Steady Unsteady
Steadyflow is definedas flow that doesnot changewith time, and uniform flow is flow with a water surfaceparalleling the bed slope.For steadyuniform flow, the curve)is a singlecurve without hysteresisloops. Steady rating curve (stage-discharge nonuniform flow has constantdischargebut varying water surfaceslopesuchas that found at the entranceto a reservoiror at the approachof a waterfall. One way of selectingthe applicablemethod is to examinethe rating curve and assesswhether it is the same for rising and falling stages.The choice of routing equation dependson whether the difference is small (kinematic), relatively large (dynamic),or somewherein-between(diffusion). The kinematic wave method assumesthat the inertia terms of Eq. 13.52 ate negligibleand that the friction slopeequalsthe bed slopeS. Momentumconservation is approxi(natedby assumingsteadyuniform flow, and routing is accomplishedby combiningthe continuity equationwith any form of friction lossequation.Typically, either the Manning equationor Ch6zyequationis used.The Chdzyequationis V :
C\/RS
( 13.s 3)
and the Manning equationis V :
l'486 n
O2/3St/2
( 13.s 4)
where C andn arefriction coefficients,S is the friction slope,and R is the hydraulic radius (areadividedby wettedperimeter).Both give velocity in feet per secondif area are input using squarefeet and feet units. and wetted qerimeter *of these equations can be substitutedinto the kinematic portion of Either Eq. 13.52,equatingslopeof energygradeline with bed slopeto accountfor momentum. The continuity equation,Eq. 13.39,for this casereducesto dQ *64:o At Ex
( 13.5s )
The Manning or Ch6zyequationhas the form Q:
b'4^
(13.56)
RIVERROUTING 253 13.3 HYDRAULIC
which, after taking derivatives,is 6Q = 6*4*-t AA
:
o
m--a : M V A
(r3.57)
Multiplying Eq. 13.55by dQ/dA gives
, ,a Q mv -dx
+ 9a t : o
( 13.s 8)
or. if c - mV,the kinematic routing equationis
.- dQx * 9 : o
(13.se)
"- : d Q : l d Q dA BdY
(13.60)
At
to the slope of the where B is the top width of the channel.Thus celerity is related c is constantand that assume rating curve,which varieswith stage.Most applications
9 * , 9 : dd{x9dx At
(13.61)
accounts for the The left-hand side is the kinematic wave equation and the right diffusion d is diffusion effect of nonuniform water surfaceproflles. The hydraulic given by .
(r3.62)
q
" 2 5 d
:
-
This term reveals where4 is the flow per unit width of channel,and s is the bed slope. in small d) (resulting why kinematiowaveanalysisis valid whenbed slopesare steep slopes,the bed flat or when the channells extremelywide (resultingin small 4)' For hydraulic diffusion coefflcientis particularly important' Numerical solutionsof Eq. 13.6I ate presentedby severalinvestigators'12-ra Thesenormally involve substitutionof the relation
ao A--
- B 3+v dt
(13.63)
254
CHAPTER13
HYDROGRAPHROUTING
into Eq. 13.61,whereB is the channeltop width. The Manning or Ch6zyequationis usedfor the friction slope,where
tr:#
(r3.64)
in which the conveyanceK is Q/\/Srfromeither equation.Diffusion wavesapply to a wider range of problems than kinematic formulations, but their use may not be warrantedbecauseit requiresabout the sameeffort as dynamic routing. The third type of waveanalysisaccountsfor all terms inBq.13.52, includingthe "dynamic" or nonuniform,unsteady,and inertia components.It is referredto as the "full dynamic" formulation. Dynamic wave solutionsare far more complicatedbut are often necessaryfor analysisof flow along very flat slopes,flow into large reservoirs, highly unsteadydam-breakflood waves,or reversing(e.g.,tidal) flows. These conditions are often encounteredon coastalplains. As a generalrule, full dynamic wave analysisbecomesnecessarywhen
s>
1 5 F 4\;
( 13 .6s )
S - bed slope T o : time to peak (sec) of the inflow hydrograph D : averageflow depth (ft) o : eravitationalacceleration
where
d
SCSAtt-Kin TR-20Method In 1983,the SCSreplacedtheconvexmethod(Section13.1)with themodifiedatt-kin (attematron-kinematic)methodas the agency'spreferredchannelrouting method.ls The 1.964SCS TR-20 (Chapter 24) single-eventsimulation model used the convex method but was subsequentlymodified to route by the att-kin method. The procedureis a blend of the storageindication and kinematicwavemethods. Figure 13.5 showsthe two-step processof simulating attenuationfirst by meansof
e
E
o PP
Flgure 13.5 Routing principlesusedin the SCS att-kin method,
RIVER ROUTING 255 r3.3 HYDRAULIC storagerouting and then translatingthe wavein time by the kinematic wavemethod to accountfor the fact that routed flow ratesnot only decreasein magnitudebut also require time to traversethe length of the routing reach.The storagerouting portion providesattenuationwith instantaneoustranslation,and the kinematic waverouting providestranslationand distortionbut doesnot attenuatethe peak. Both are needed to produce the desired effect. The previously rhentioned full dynamic equations simultaneouslyaccountfor both effectsbut are difficult to solve. Figure 13.5helpsto visualizethe process.The samevolume V1of waterflowing into the reachduring time /, would flow out of a hypotheticalstoragereservoirduring interval 12.This samevolume would translateand distort downstreamby kinematic actibn, flowing out of the reachduring interval /r. Through its theoretical developmentand selectionof routing coefficients,the att-kin methodequationssatisfythe physicalpropagationand timing of the peak flow rate first. Conservationof massis also assured(areasunder the three hydrographsof Fig. 13.5are equal). The actualprocessroutesthe inflow hydrographthrough storage,thentranslates the peak flow rate, without attenuation,to its final time location in the outflow hydrograph.The location in time of the peak outflow is assumedequal to that correspondingto the maximum storagein the reachduring passageof the flood. Becausecelerity changeswith storage,the other flows of the storage-routed hydrographare translated,pachby a different celerity,to their respectivefinal times and values. The storageindication routing is accomplishedby substitutionof the relation Q:
KS^
(13.66)
into the continuity equation, Eq. 13.30, where S is the storageand K and m are coefficients.Kinematic routing solvesthe unsteadyflow equation(13.59) with Q:
bA*
(r3.61)
whereb andm are input coefficients,and A is cross-sectionalarea.If Z is the length ofrouiing reach,andifthe cross-sectionalareathroughoutL is relativelyconstant,the storageis given by S: LA
(13.68)
Theseequatiohsare combined in an iterative fashion to assurethat the peak flow resultingfrom the kinematic routing equalsthe peak resulting from storagerouting, and simultaneouslyensuringthat the time of the peak outflow occurs at the time of maximum storagein the reach,or Qo: KS;
(13.69)
Input to the methodrequiresselectionof a reachlength and estimatesof b andm for for Table 13.1and Eq. 13.27,m canbe shownto be usein Eq. 13.59.As discussed a factor relating averagevelocity (under bankfull conditions)with wave celerity, or c
v
(13.70)
256
CHAPTER13
HYDROGRAPHROUTING
The larger ru becomes,the shorterthe travel time, A value of m I 1.0 would incorrectly makethe celerity slowerthan the averageflow velocity.Studiesby SCSresulted in a recommendationof ! for general use. Signif,canterrors resultedfor m values greater than2.0. Equation 13.67 is appropriatefor cross sectionshaving a single ihannel with regulaishape.Complexcrosssectionsare more diffcult to evaluate,but la valuescan be developid from a rating table for the stream'rs As the coefficient b decreases,attenuationof the peak flow increasesdue to reducedvelocity and increasedstoragein the reach.The value b canbe estimatedby plotting Q andA on log-logpaper and fitting the linear form of Eq. 13.67 (referlo faatei6.+1. The slope*oUa be m andtheinterceptut 4_: 1 would be b. The SCS has also developednomographsfor estimatingb and m'" As a generalguideline,the reach length L shouldbe increasedto a value that resultsin a kinematic wavetravel time c greaterthan the selectedtime increment,or Lo> cA,t Z*io ft
9,000 7,500 15,000
mV = wave celerity l*ln LR
mV ft/sec
0.5 0.7
LR ft 18,000
5,000
12,000 10,000
3,500
7,000
r
5,000 4,000
1,500
3,000
0.3
1,000
2,000
0.2'
750
1,500
= minimum acceptablereach length = minimum recommended reach length MainTime Increment Hours
2 I
6,000
0.5 n?5
3 /
0.1 0.05
5 7 10 T2
Example: mV = 4ftlsec Main time increment = 0.2 hr L*n= 1,450ft La = 2,900 ft
1.000 350 700 250
500
15
t00 for le ngth reach Figure 13.6 SCS nomographfor determining Service, Conservation (After Soil U.S. atl-kin method of routing. "ComputerProgramfor Project Formulation," TechnicalRelease 20, Revised,AppendixG, 1983.)
PROBLEMS 257 : mV' and Ar is the time increment' The where Lo is the recommendedlength' c minimumrecommendedLoisthatgivingawavetraveltimeequaltoabouthalfthe lengthy iray iesult in analytical difficulty when rime incremenr. This 1j[$;"1* inflowhydrographsorsteepStreams.areencountered.Italsoresultsinthepeak time incrementAr. If severalreacheswere outflow time being ,ourJ"J"rp io the full accumulate'Thus a reachlength between routed, this incrementattime^errorwould greater thal c. A/ is recommended' c Lt andc Lt/2 is acceptable'but a length Figure13.6providesth"rangeofminimumacc"eptableandminimumrecommended routing reachlengths.
ff ffi ff;;iicationsofhvdraulicroutingtec|1ioue11p.p"11'i^'"Tt*::?:Yi::
ff ;'il;;'n"'uu"'i11,, "u.n ;t'1":".1-':^:"::::T,it?ii: ffi ff Ji,ffiffi :3:[";ffi;i;;;ffi;"'"-*:i"o1j.u""]'mJ1't^:-:T:1T':1"::i"%i"$1 , i. wru,iilpresented iir"T-l"ii,'.i,"n" ;;lrt':? HX"J"H;il;il#il;;;;;,;;i;#
1"*Tl student ll :^11ti:: understand caniil::1,:: thataninteresred
modeling' the structuringprocessesof hydrologic
Summary ComputersoftwareforhydrographsynthesiS^androutingisavailablefromnumerous federal agelcy routines are detailed in public and private vendors. wid;ry used amflow processesincludesone or Chapter24. Virtually every ( m o r e h y d r o g r a p h r o a s H E C - I ( C h a hydroloeig p t e r 2 4a1d ) , hydraulic p r o v i d e lplied severalchoices.In I the models can be found in the routing procedures' g]]:i,:Ytditg suggestions .T" At sel 1iterarure.,6,17 ln rlver or engage will The readerwho when eachof the methodsshouldbe applied' reservoirroutingisencouragedtodwelopthecomparisonrequestedinProblem13.25 before leavingthis chaPter'
PROBLEMS hydrologic and hydraulic routing techniques' 13.1. Discussthe main diff-erencesbetween 13.2.
t+}i ;q":: Iit:t?;;i,Y :..ii+l ;; q :il# ffi?#t 1iT .'SX,ffff r" 191 :,-Yllli "'*ifi:'i I ilY?iBi'"".U'1-'"d;i"?';:fli!11iy":;T"':'.."t"jfl i:;#"J I"a'^#i'.h;r::;;'i;A--)-r",t'i'i""1'"'lT1,1l.o:'^"iui:.'* i:il3iil;
riverroutingequation' TheMuskingum ?:,:,':'?,*
12' v2' .xg 9z v\v 4-_ *u,'::9,":1i: i'||w p:.'i"l' oerro.; time the tlme orthe of Siif#ffi"#ru:=#;"i"e-i*ine outflow, and storage at the beginning lT"jll ;;:E;: n"t*#:J:'::3*4":::i3";ffi';
u,,t'l uutu", corresponding G "and ffi:Tt"'ff:fd;#?;##ir*"p"'i"a'lndAsistl"*"1c-",'istorage'Perrorm for Cs' C1' and C2' the describedA",inution
verify ttre equations
l"3.3.IftheMuslongumKvalueis12hrforareachofariver,andiftheXvalueis0.2'what purposes? would be a reasonablevalue of Ar for routing
258
ROUTING, 13 HYDROGRAPH CHAPTER
'
13.4. A river reachhas a storagerelation given by S; : ali + boi. Derive a routing equation for O2 analogousto the Muskingum equation (13.6). Give equationsfor the coefficientsof 11,01, and 12. 13.5. List the steps(starting with a measuredinflow and outflow hydrographfor a river reach)necessaryto determinethe Muskingum K and X values. If the inflow and outflow are recordedin cubic feet per second,statethe units that would result for K and X if your list of stepsis followed. 13.6. Given the following inflow hydrograph:
6 e.v. Noon 6 p.tu. Midnight 6 A.M. Noon 6 p.Iu. Midnight
lnflow (cfs)
Outflow (cfs)
100 300 680 500 400 310 230 100
100
Assumethat the outflow hydrographat a section 3-mi downstreamis desired. : a. compute the outflow hydrographby the Muskingum methodusing valuesof K : 0.13. 11 hr andX b. Plot the inflow and outflow hydrographs on a single graph' c. Repeatsteps(a) and (b) usingX : 0.00. I3,7. Giventhe following valuesof measureddischargesat both endsof.a30-mi river reach: a. Determinethe Muskingum K and X valuesfor this reach. b. Holding K constant (at your determined value), use the given inflow hydrograph to determineand plot three outflow hydrographsfor valuesofX equal to the computed value.0.5. and 0.0. Plot the actualoutflow and nurnericallycomparethe root mean squareof residualswhen each of the three calculatedhydrographsis compared with the measuredoutflow.
Time 6 e.Ira. Noon 6 p.v, Midftight 6 l.rra. Noon 6 p.tvt. Midnight 6 n.n. Noon 6 p.v. Midnight 6 A.M.
lnflow (cfs)
Outflow (cfs)
l0 30 68 50 40 3l
10 12.9 26.5 43.1 44.9 41.3 35.3 27.7 t9.4 1 5I. 12.7 11 . 5 10.8
ZJ
10 10 10 10 t0 10
PROBLEMS 259 13.8. Selecta streamin your geographicregionthat hasrunoffrecords' method of routing to find K and X'
Usethe Muskingum
l3.g.PrecipitationbeganatnoononJune14andcausedafloodhydrographinastredrn.As thehydrographpassed,thefollowingmeasuredstreamflowdataatcrosssectionsA and B were obtained: Outflow, SectionB (cfs)
Inflow, SectionA (cfs)
Time June14-17
10 10 t3 26 43
10 10 30 10 50 40 30 20 10 l0 l0 10 10 10
6 e.v. Noon 6 p.tvt. Midnight 6 e.u. Noon 6 p.u. Midnight 6 n.u. Noon 6 p.tvt. Midnight 6 e.u. Noon
4l 35 28 19 IJ I J
1l 10
river rea