JESUS
THE NAZARENE
* * MYTH OR HISTORY? *
THE * MYTH & HISTORY?;*
JESUS *
MAURICE GOGUEL DOCTOR OF THEOLOCr AND L...
63 downloads
1470 Views
15MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
* * MYTH OR HISTORY? *
THE * MYTH & HISTORY?;*
JESUS *
MAURICE GOGUEL DOCTOR OF THEOLOCr AND LITERATURE, PROFESSOR OF EXEGESIS AND TESTAMENT CRITICISM IN FACULTY OF FREE PROTESTANT
NEW
THEOLOGY (PARIS)
TRANSLATED BY
FREDERICK STEPHENS
APPLETON AND COMPANY MCMXXVI NEW YORK * * D.
COPYRIGHT, 1926, BY
D.
APPLETON AND COMPANY
PREFACE THE
is one question of the historical character of Jesus of present-day interest. It has once again been ably raised by Monsieur P. L. Couchoud in a small volume
of considerable literary value and high spiritual in1 Is it true that the theory of the origins of spiration. as anChristianity sketched out in the above work is, nounced in the programme of the collection in which has appeared, "the synthesis of recent works on in Christianity," and "the focussing that all agree For he who knows, considering as indispensable"?
it
of research conbe permitted to doubt cerning Christian origins may Has not one of M. Couchoud's collaborators this.
even
superficially, the present state
written on the
first
volume of the
collection
:
"Without
seem as inexJesus, the history of Christianity would or of plicable as that of Islam without Mahomet, intellecPythagorianism without Pythagoras"? The 2 and the M. of tual loyalty vigour Couchoud, sincerity of his thought, the loyal effort which he has made to
are penetrate into the spirit of primitive Christianity, it is a which this but full of homage respect, worthy
our seeing in his pleasure to pay him does not prevent book the dream of a poet rather than the work of an historian. 'P. L.
Couchoud, Le Myttlre dt U*u*> Paris, 1924-
Albert Houtin, Courte kutoire du Christianisme, Parit, 1924.
v
PREFACE
vi
winter
During the discussions which took place last at the Union pour la Verite certain criticisms were advanced and facts were cited in contradiction to his It is no matter for surprise that these obtheses. but it is surjections should have left him unmoved, he has prising that in the volume he has just published not attempted to answer them. The problem of the historical character of Jesus is one of fact. It is entirely in the region of fact and by
method that we shall attempt its solution decide whether modern criticism since the eighteenth
the historical to
should admit its century has entered a blind alley, and and in error, cease to see in Jesus a real personage, followed enter upon a road other than that so
doing by Strauss, Baur, Renan, Albert and Jean Reville, and Auguste Sabatier, Harnack, Lagrange, Loisy Guignebert,*
historical exis'Being only here concerned with the question of the tence of Jesus, we pass over the problem of the influence (according to certain authors) of the religions of India upon him and the Gospel
tradition.
Cp. R. Seydl, Das Evangehum von Jesus in semen Verhaltntssen nur Buddha-Sage und Buddha Lehre, Leipsig, 1882; Buddha und Chnstus, Breslau, 1884; Die Buddha-Leg ende und das Leben Jesu nach den Evangehen, Weimar, 1897.
CONTENTS PAGB
PREFACE
*
*
*
v
*
CHAPTER
I
NONHISTORICAL THEORIES CZUPT1B
OF NONHISTORICITY UP TO THE CLOSE OF THE NINETEENTH CENTURY NONHISTORICAL THEORIES IN THE TWENTIETH
THE THEORIES
I
.
.
II.
CENTURY III.
...
.
.
I
15
THE PROBLEM
25
CHAPTER
II
THE NONCHRISTIAN TESTIMONY I II.
III.
FLAVIUS JOSEPHUS THE LATIN AUTHORS
....
.
.
.
"ACTA PILATI" (THE ACTS OF PILATE)
CHAPTER
...
29 38 45
III
HYPOTHESIS OF A PRE-CHRISTIANITY I II.
JESUS THE NAZARENE THE HYPOTHESIS OF A SECT OF PRE-CHRISTIAN NAZARENES, WORSHIPPERS OF JESUS CHRISTIANITY AND THE DISCIPLES OF JOHN THE .
.
.
III.
BAPTIST
.
.
.
51
57 73
CHAPTER IV TWO PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO THE NONHISTORICAL THESIS I.
THE POLEMICS ITY
II.
DOCETISM
OF THE OPPONENTS OF CHRISTIAN78 S2
CONTENTS
vffl
CHAPTER V THE APOSTLE PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION I.
THE
........ ..........
PAUL
EPISTLES OF
II.
PAUL, BEFORE His CONVERSION, A WITNESS TO
III.
PAUL AND THE UNITY OF PRIMITIVE CHRISTIAN-
IV.
THE BROTHERS
THE CROSS ITY
...........
VI.
95
99
AND THE JERUSALEM
OF JESUS
..........
APOSTLES V.
93
EXAMINATION OF TEXTS SUPPOSED TO CONTAIN ALLUSIONS TO A CHRIST MYTH THE GOSPEL TRADITION IN PAUL
....
.....
IO 103 121
CHAPTER VI THE THEOLOGY OF THE APOSTLE PAUL I.
THE CHARACTER
THOUGHT
OF PAULINE
...
III.
IV. V. VI.
THE REDEMPTION THE CHRIST AND His WORK THE JUSTIFICATION AND REDEMPTION
II.
THE GENESIS
III.
IV.
V.
.
.
.....
.
EPISTLES OF
THEIR CHARACTER
THE THE THE
.
-
.
.
.
*59 168
VII
THE NEW TESTAMENT
........ ........ ......
FIRST EPISTLE OF PETER, EPISTLE OF JUDE, THE SECOND EPISTLE OF PETER AND THE EPISTLE OF JAMES
........ ........... CHAPTER
139 144
THE
PASTORAL EPISTLES EPISTLE TO THE HEBREWS
CONCLUSION
135
.149
.
OF
.
OF THE PAULINE THEOLOGY
THE NONPAULINE I.
.
.
CHAPTER
II.
.
.......... ........
SINNER VII.
.
.136
GOD AND DEMONS SIN AND EVIL
173 175 182
184 186
VIII
THE CHRIST OF THE APOCALYPSE I,
II.
CHARACTER OF THE APOCALYPSE ("Revelations") VISION OF THE WOMAN AND THE DRAGON
THE
188 192
CONTENTS
fc
CHAPTER IX THE THEORY OF THE PROPHETIC ORIGIN OF THE GOSPEL TRADITION *AOE
CHAPTIft I.
II.
OF THE PROPHETIC ARGUMENT IN PRIMITIVE CHRISTIANITY RELATIONS OF PROPHECY AND THE GOSPEL HISTORY
203
CREATIONS DUE TO PROPHETIC EXEGESIS MODIFICATIONS DUE TO PROPHETIC EXEGESIS
203 205
INFLUENCE OF PROPHECY ON THE FACTS FULFILLMENT OF PROPHECIES DISCOVERED AFTER
212
THE FUNCTION
THE 1.
2.
III.
IV.
.
.
THE EVENT V. VI.
THE
.
.
198
215 219 226
.
CRUCIFIXION
CHRIST THE PASCHAL LAMB
CHAPTER X THE GOSPEL TRADITION I,
IL III.
IV.
V.
COMPOSITION OF THE GOSPELS
THE GOSPEL IDEA THE ABSENCE OF CHRONOLOGICAL THE PLAN OF THE GOSPELS
CONSIDERATIONS
CONCERNING CERTAIN FACTORS IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE GOSPEL TRADITION
....
1.
2. 3.
4.
FOLKLORE
.
.
INSPIRATION AND VISIONS THE TRANSFERENCE OF MATERIAL BORROWED FROM THE APOSTOLIC HISTORY
....
THE LITURGY
229 234 239 244 264 265 267
270 275
CHAPTER XI THE ORIGIN OF THE FAITH IN THE RESURRECTION AND
ITS
FUNCTION IN PRIMITIVE CHRISTIANITY I.
II.
THE RESURRECTION PROBLEM THE PAULINE CONCEPTION OF
279 CHRIST'S RESURREC-
283
TION III.
OF THE RETURN OF CHRIST TO TERIAL LIFE
THE CONCEPT
MA289
CONTENTS
x CHAPTER
IV. V. VI. VII.
PRIMITIVE FORM OF THE RESURRECTION BELIEF How THE BELIEF IN THE RESURRECTION AROSE THE BELIEF IN THE RESURRECTION AND THE MESSIANIC BELIEF
290 294
CONCLUSION
3 11
.
.
3<>7
GENERAL CONCLUSION
3*4
INDEX
3*7
JESUS THE NAZARENE * * MYTH OR HISTORY?*
THE NAZARENE MYTH OR HISTORY?
JESUS
CHAPTER
I
NONHISTORICAL THEORIES THE THEORIES
I.
OF NONHISTORICITY UP TO THE
CLOSE OF THE NINETEENTH CENTURY one of the greatest scholars of the Renaissance, Laurcntius Valla, during a banquet, said one day to Antoinc Panormita, who was as much scandalized as shocked by the remark, that he had in 1 his quiver weapons against the Messiah Himself. Did
BAYLE
relates that
he mean by this to throw doubt upon the manner in Or which tradition presented the Gospel history? historical the to as far so did he go reality of question the person of Jesus?
The manner in which the conversation does not permit us to decide the point.
is
related
to the eighteenth century the authority of the Gospels was unquestioned. Each one contented him-
Up
by paraphrasing with more or less freedom the So long as Protestants, equally data of the accounts. with Catholics, continued to be dominated by the
self
of Scripture principle of the literal inspiration
it
could
not be otherwise. *
article "Vtllt.* Btyle, Diction**ir* historigue *t critigui,
JESUS
2
THE NAZARENE
problem which existed was that concernand disposition of the parallel ing the arrangement From the sixteenth up to the eighteenth records. marvelous incentury, from Osiander to Griesbach,
The
sole
to coordinate these in such genuity had been displayed a manner that, according to the very words of Osiander,* no word of any record should be omitted, that nothing foreign should be added, and that the 3 order of no evangelist should be modified.
If this "reconciling" was not yet a true critical study of the life of Jesus, it at all events, owing to the
complexity and improbability of the hypotheses
compelled to construct, helped to
show
it
was
that the prob-
lem as then presented remained insoluble, and that in consequence it was necessary to transfer it to another field.
It
was during the eighteenth century that
this trans-
This revolution, the consequences of which were only gradually revealed, took place almost simultaneously in England under the influence of the Deists, in France under that of Voltaire and the ference took place.
Encyclopaedists, in
Germany under
that of the School
of Enlightenment (Aufklarung), which received the 4 adhesion of Reimarus and Lessing.
The
first scientific
essay on the
life
of Jesus
*See hit Harmonic, published in Basle in 1537. Concerning L'Harmonistique, see M. Goguel,
Introd.,
is
i.
that
pp. 49
et seg. *
Concerning the beginnings of the critical history of the life of Ltben Jesu-Forschung, Jesus, see Albeit Schweitzer, Geschichte der de Tubingen, 1913, pp. 13-26; also Chas. Guignebert, Le Probteme Deists and Jtsus, Paris, 1914, pp. 7-21. The part played by English
French writers, completely ignored by Schweitzer, has been well emphasized by Guignebert.
NONHISTORICAL THEORIES
3
and 1778. It published by Lessing between 1774 from a voluobtained of seven consists fragments by Hermann Samuel Reimarus ob(1694-1768). The author of this had for his showin natural religion ject the justification of base of supfeeble a but had that Christianity ing
minous manuscript
left
port.
In the opinion of Reimarus, Jesus had never thought of founding a new religion. His preaching, exclusively eschatological and terrestrial, had solely in view manifestation as Messiah, the son of David.
His
that He Jesus perished at Jerusalem at the time Himself to proclaimed King. After get attempted His death His disciples imagined the idea of a second
coming of the Messiah and of a through His death. Reimarus has a double merit.
spiritual
He
redemption
from the
first
in the recognized the importance of eschatology natural a to discover tried and of Jesus, thought connection of cause and effect, not only in the history
of Jesus, but also in that of primitive Christianity. By the manner in which he presents the life and the trateaching of Jesus, Reimarus claims to undermine introintention This base. the at ditional Christianity
duces a philosophical element into his research, which is as much a disturbing factor as the dogmatic prejudices
for
which
Reimarus
reproaches
his
antag-
onists.
The same may be activity
extends
said of the rationalists,
from
about
the
middle
whose of
the
Eliminating eighteenth century up to about 1830. at aimed portraying every supernatural element, they
whose teaching accorded Jesus as a master of virtue
JESUS
4
THE NAZARENE
with their own. Such is specially the character of the 6 8 works of Herder and of Paulus.
The
latter
of miracles.
is
particularly given to the interpretation real but perfectly natural
He sees in them
which his contemporaries have not understood, and which they have considered as having the character
facts
of prodigies. If, for example,
it
has been believed that Jesus mul-
tiplied the loaves, this
is
because, in the desert where
crowd had followed Him, He had given an exdisample of distributing the few loaves at His own of His hearers posal, an example followed by those the
7
possessed provisions. The rationalist conception of the life of Jesus does not differ in essentials from
who
the supernatural conception. The former limits itself to the recitation of the facts recorded while combin-
ing more or less happily the Synoptic and the Johannine statements, but instead of having perpetual recourse to miracle, the rationalists display an extreme ingenuity in giving to events a natural interpretation. The work of the French rationalists
of
the
less systematic chareighteenth century possesses a the greater for that. It rests acter; its import is only
upon no profound work of Herder,
Vom
exegesis,
and does not
Erloser der Menschen nach unsfrn drei ersten Evan-
g elicit: Vom Gottessohn der Welt Heiland nach Johannesevangeltum, Riga, 1797. Gesch. det Paulus, Das leben Jesu al Grundlage einer reinen Urchristentums, Heidelberg, 1828. *With rationalism may be connected the works of Bahrdt (Ausfuhrung det Plans und Zwecks Jesu, 1784-92), Venturmi (Naturliche Gesck des gross fn jropketen von Nazareth, 1800-1802), which reprcent Jesus as an agent of the sect of the Essenes. Concerning these authors see Schweitzer (Gesch., pp. 38-48).
NONHISTORICAL THEORIES end
in
5
opposing a new conception of primitive Chris-
tianity to traditional opinion.
In the involved and prudent manner forced upon him, Voltaire pointed out the small documentary value of Gospels "written by persons acquainted with noth8
the imof contradictions and imposture" probability of the eschatological prophecies, against 1 which good sense rebelled. "Let each ask himself, he ing, full
'
he sees the possibility of pushing imposture 9 and the stupidity of fanaticism farther." "The whole of Jesus only a fanatic or a stupid knave
writes, "if
history
would deny
it
should be examined in the light of
10
Voltaire on several occasions draws attention to the silence of non-Christian authors concerning 11 the Gospel history. Obviously, Christian tradition
reason."
does not inspire in him any confidence. However, he does not go so far as to maintain that it corresponds to
no
reality at
all.
He
is
aware that "certain followers
of Bolingbroke, more ingenious than erudite," considered themselves authorized by the obscurities and contradictions of the Gospel tradition to
deny the
exist-
12
ence of Jesus. In so far as he
concerned, he rejects this conclusion, and it appears that this is not entirely for reasons of prudence, as is sometimes the case when he is
wishes to hint at opinions which
it
might be dangerous
Voltaire, Examen important de Milord Bolingbroke (Edition Kehl), xxxiii, pp. 44-60. Cp, Sermon des cinquant, xxxii, pp. 399'4>; Hist, de Vetabt. du christianisme, xxxv, pp. 274-93. g 68. Id., Ex. de Milord Bolingbroke, xxxiii, p. 10 Id., * l ld. t
Dieu
et les
Hommes,
xxxiii, p. 271.
de 272; Sermon des cinquant, xxxii, p. 401; Hist, Fitabt. du christianisme, xxxv, p. 274. **Id.f Dieu et les Hommes, xxxiii, p. 273. ib.,
p.
6
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
Indeed, Voltaire in this case gives he for setting aside the negations weighty reasons of cites. He quotes precise cases of forged genealogies, stories embellished and transfigured, and as for the to profess openly.
between the hudisproportion which appears to exist the importance of mility of the person of Jesus and the movement which He inaugurated, he relates the case of Fox, "a ignorant shoemaker, founder of very
the sect of Quakers."
He
concludes
:
"It
is
necessary,
whilst awaiting faith, to limit oneself to drawing this conclusion : There did exist an obscure Jew, from the crucified as dregs of the people, named Jesus, who was it the of Tiberius, time in the a blasphemer Emperor 18
being impossible to determine in which year." Voltaire has not sketched any history of the origins of Christianity. His effort to place the study of the documents within the province of reason we should is none say in modern phrase the province of history the he dealt so the less very remarkable. In doing traditional conception decisive blows. The almost entirely negative character of the criti-
cisms of Voltaire explains the extreme conclusions stated at the end of the eighteenth century by Volney
and Dupuis. In
his
work
called
Les Ruines ou Medi-
tations sur les Revolutions des
Empires (Paris 1798unfolded among the a vision conceives 1808) Volney ruins of Palmyra. The representatives of the various * Voltaire, Dleu et les Hommes, xxxiii, p, 279. Further to what has been quoted it is necessary to read L'Essai sur les maeurs (especially Chap, ix); Les Homelies prononchs b Londres, 1765, xxxii; Conseils raisonnables & M. Bergier, xxxiii Questions de Zapata, xxxiii ; Epitr e ;
aux Remains,
xxxiii,
many
articles in the Dictionnaire philosophique,
zxxvii to xliii. With the ideas of Voltaire may be compared those of Holbach, Systeme de nature, Londres, 1770; under the name of Mirabeau, Le bons sens du cure Meslier, Londres, 1772.
NONHISTORICAL THEORIES
7
how
priests have obscured which dogmas
in his turn, religions explain, each
deceived mankind the real religion, spiritual in its essence. In Volney's view, the entire Gospel tradition represented an astral in inventing
14
myth.
The
views of Dupuis 18
Volney.
18
closely resemble those of
According to him, the philosophers who
man
of Jesus are not less seriously in error than the theologians who have made of Him a God: "Jesus is still less man than God. He is, like
have made a
men have adored, the sun ChristianWhen we shall have shown," writes ity is a solar myth. the "that pretended history of a God, who is Dupuis, born of a virgin in the winter solstice, who is resusci-
all
the deities that
;
tated at Easter or at the Vernal equinox, after having descended into hell, who brings with Him a retinue of
twelve apostles whose chief possesses all the attributes a God, conqueror of the prince of darkness, of Janus who translates mankind into the empire of light, and is only a solar fable, as almost it will be unnecessary to inquire whether there was a man called Christ as it is to inquire whether Provided that it be is called Hercules. some
who ...
heals the
woes of the world,
prince
under proven that the being consecrated by worship the name of Christ is the sun, and that the miraculous 14
Napoleon
I
was under
versation that he had with
the influence of Volney when, in a conWieland at Weimar, in 1808, he said to decide whether Jesus had existed
was a great question (Schweitzer, Gesch , p. 445)' la religion universelle, IB Dupuis, L'Oriffine de tous Its cultes ou de tous les cultet, Paris, Paris, anno III (1794) ; Abregi de V engine anno VII (1798). These two works have been reprinted several
it
times.
"It was during a conversation with Dupuis that Volney conceived the project of his book.
8
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
element in the legend or the poem has this star for its that the Christians object, then it will appear proven are but sun worshippers, and that their priests have the same religion as those of Peru, whose throats they
have
cut."
1T
of the year 1835 was that of the publication 18 and it is a date of first Life of Jesus, by Strauss, critiprimary importance in the history of evangelical
The
Strauss attacks the problem with the absolute indifference to dogma which he owed to the philosophy of Hegel. The fundamental idea of religion in his cism.
view
is
that of the "Gottmenschlichkeit," and it is of whether this idea has been realized in
small import phenomena or not. It
and not
The
history.
is
first
the idea which
is
important,
Gospel accounts, in Strauss's
from an historical opinion, have not been drawn up the event as these point of view. They do not relate ideas certain but express took by means of place,
term that images and symbols, or to employ the exact Strauss makes use of, by myths. What is important in the notion of the myth is not the idea of unreality, but that of a symbolical expression of a higher truth. The mythical explanation seems to Strauss the syn-
which resolves the antithesis between the naturalist and the supernatural explanations of the life
thesis
of Jesus. The other novelty:
of Jesus of Strauss contains anput forward as had never been done
'Life it
been wittily Dupuis, Abregi, p. 251. The views of Dupuis have a curious by J. B. Peres, librarian of the town of Agen, in booklet in which he applied the method of Dupuis to the History of Napoleon to prove the latter had never existed. IT
criticized
ConcernStrauss, Das Leben Jesu, Tubingen, 1835* 1836, 1840. also A. Levy, David Fredsee Gesch., Strauss p. 69; Schweitzer, ing crick Strauss, Parii, 1910; Guigncbert, pp. xxii seq. i
NONHISTORICAL THEORIES
9
problem of the relation between the fourth Gospel and the Synoptics. So long as one was content, as before Strauss, to
hitherto
the
combine the statements of the four evangelists, Strauss considers that the two traditions are irreconcilable with each other, and he solves the problem offered by their coexistence in a manner unfavorable to the fourth evangelist.
that it point of Strauss's construction was was not built upon a sufficiently thorough study of the sources. This omission was filled up simultaneously by the works of F. C. Baur and his disciples and by those
The weak
of a series of
critics
who combated
the theses of the
Tubingen school, such as Weisse, Wilke, Reuss, Albert 19 Reville, H. J. Holtzmann, Bernhard Weiss. The outcome of the discussions which took place on the evangelical problem was a theory whose essential literature points are that at the base of the evangelical are two principal sources : The Gospel of Mark, either under its present form or; one slightly different (proto-
Mark), and
a collection of discourses (the Logia),
20
the fourth evangelist being considered by the majority of critics as a secondary form of the tradition, domi-
nated by dogmatic and allegorical ideas. The life of Jesus which would be the result of this critical
work has never been
written;
it
is,
all
so to 21
of H. J. Holtzmann. speak, involved in the work To the school of Baur belong the works of Bruno i
and *
Concerning these works see Maurice Goguel, Introd., ii,
Usually referred to in England and
(Quelle). Schweitzer, Gctch.> pp. 124-40.
"
i,
p.
p. 27.
Germany by
the letter
67,
Q
io
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
Bauer," who in 1841 supported the priority of the of the Gospel of Mark. He explained the peculiarities other records by what he termed the creative power of the evangelists, and clearly showed the part played in the evolution of tradition by dogmatic and theological But he did not stop there, and maintained notions. that the forces which had guided the transformation of primitive tradition explained also the genesis of Mark's record. In Bauer's view the primitive evangelist was a creator, and his work is the product of the faith of the early Christians. Christianity was born at the beginning of the second century from the meetin ing of the different currents of thought originating of Jesus was Judea, Greece and Rome. The person fiction. Jesus is the product, not the a
merely
literary
creator, of Christianity.
Bruno Bauer remained but
little influence.
When,
a solitary.
His ideas had
at a later period, analogous
ideas to his were expressed, either by the radical Dutch certain modern mythologists, it was not school or
by
and
was only
after their expression that the authors of certain theories believed to be
under
his influence,
new found out that The publication
it
Bruno Bauer they had a pioneer. of the Vie de Jesus by Renan in
in
of 1863 marks a no less important date than that Strauss's work on the history of criticism. This is not because) the work was particularly original. Almost its entire substance was borrowed from the German 2(2
Bruno Bauer, Knttk des Evangelischen Cesch. des Johannes, Bre-
men, 1840; Kritik der Evangclischen Gtsch. der Synopttker, Leipzig, und die 1841-42; Knttk der Evangehen, Berlin, 1850-51; Christus Bruno M. see Bauer Bruno Berlin Kcgel, Casarcn, 1877. Concerning Batier
und
seine Thcorie uber die Entstehung des Christentums, 1908.
NONHISTORICAL THEORIES
11
but although the work of Strauss had been translated, that of Renan was the first French work criticism,
on the question. It attracted all the more attention in that it was addressed to the general public. It thus 28 produced an enormous effect. Possessing in reality but little originality, the Vie de Jesus of Renan is, from the literary point of view, 24 a first-class work. Renan makes of Jesus a kind of gentle dreamer who walks through the midst of the Galilean countryside at the drama in smiling at life, and as though surprised which He takes part. When he disappears, the passion of a deluded woman gives to the world a risen God. of Renan was followed in the last forty a large number of years of the nineteenth century by other "Lives," from Keim to Oskar Holtzmann." all aim at presenting the results of literary
The work
They
combining, as Renan had already done, the facts of the fourth evangelist with those of the Synoptics. The point of view as to miracles varies, criticism, often while
there arc found attempts at the explanation of the Mcssiahship of Jesus
but in almost
all
psychological and of the manner in which
He
had concealed
it
from
2 3 See Schweitzer (Gcsch , pp 647-51) for a list of eighty-five booki and pamphlets published in 1863-64 concerning Kenan's work. 24 There erron in taite. are, however, in Kenan's work certain "There is no work," writes Schweitzer, "which swarms with so many and such grave errors in taste as the Vie de Jtsus. It is Christian art an art of waxen figures. The gentle in the worst sense of the word refined Galileans who make up the Jesus, the pretty Maries, the the windows retinue of the charming carpenter have been taken from of Mtrcel also See St. Place opinion the in Sulpice." of a shop Prout on the style of the work "A tort of Lovely Helen of Christianity" (Revue de Paris, Nov. 15, 1920).
Schweitzer, Gesch., pp. I93-***-
JESUS
12
THE NAZARENE
The the people and revealed it to His disciples. is the explanation of the scene made effort principal
(Mark viii. 27-33). "Lives" there is an effort to dithese of many minish the importance of the eschatological element, with the preoccupation more or less conscious of at Caesarea Philippi
In
unfamiliar discovering a Christ who shall not be too an ideal time same at the and for the modern man as is conceived representative of true religion, such
by Protestantism of the liberal school. In the neighborhood of 1890 a new period
in the
11
history of the "Lives of Jesus begins. Discussion was concentrated principally
Messianic consciousness and eschatology
on
the
two prob-
lems intimately connected.
Already had Reimarus emphasized the eschatological views of Jesus, and Strauss had accorded them a certain importance. But in a general
way
these writers
had scarcely been followed, and the aim was to give to the eschatological declarations of Jesus an interwhich eliminated, while spiritualizing them. pretation
**
Attention was brought back again to this problem by the progress of the study of religions in the world of
and of contemporary Judaism (with which eschatological ideas occupy a central
antiquity
Jesus), in
position; also
by the success of the school of
Ritschl,
who assigned capital importance to the notion of the Church more or less explicitly identified with the preached by Jesus, The of this doctrine led base examination of the Biblical idea of the
Kingdom of God
M Sometimes these were simply declared unauthentic, particularly by Colani, Jisus Christ ft let croytnccs mesnanigufs dt ton timpi, Strasbourg, 1864.
NONHISTORICAL THEORIES Johannes Weiss,
disciple
and son-in-law of
13
Ritschl, to
state conclusions of great import in a leading work of Jesus concerning the 'dealing with the preaching 27 Kingdom of God. In his view Jesus preached a Kingdom of God
and exclusively eschatological; He considered Himself as the King of this Kingdom that is to say, the Messiah. The thesis of Weiss was repeated and
plainly
pushed to zer.
its
farthest consequences
by Albert Schweit-
28
If the exegesis of the end of the nineteenth century has thrown light on the importance of the eschato-
and Messianic element in primitive Christianity, from being complete on .agreement, however, was far noted. A whole group ,the interpretation of the facts of the Messiaha notion on doubt threw of scholars logical
being a primitive element of Christianity. *This conception was formulated by William Wrede in 29 In his ra very acute work upon the Gospel of Mark. a fundaview the oldest Gospel tradition suffers from
'ship of Jesus
mental contradiction. It presents as Messianic a history which really was not Messianic. The contradicis concealed and resolved imperfectly it is true and imposed by observed of the secrecy theory by the Messianic that Jesus. Wrede takes pains to show
tion
must not be interpreted as a kind of pedagogic followers proceeding employed by Jesus to prevent His secret
27
Johannes Weiss, Die Predigt Jesu
vom Reich*
Gottes, Gottingen,
1892. 28
A. Schweitzer, Das Leidens- und Messiasoeheimniss, Tubingen, " psychiatrische Beurttilung 39O-443J
Leipzig, 1901; Gesch.> pp. Jesu, Tubingen, 1913. 29
W. Wrede, Das
Messiasgeheimniss In den Evangelien* Gottingen,
1901; Paulus, Halle, 1904.
i
JESUS
4
THE NAZARENE
throwing themselves into a movement of political Messianism which He would have been unable to aphave eluded Him. prove, and whose control would He sees in the Messianic secret a literary device, thanks to which the conceptions and beliefs of the Christian community have been inserted into the Gosbeen discussed in the pel history. This theory has studies devoted at the beginning of the nineteenth century to the problem of the relations between
many
80 Paul and Jesus.
The problem
discussed
is
this:
Who
is
the real
founder of Christianity? Is it Jesus Himself, or is it not the apostle Paul, who introduced into the Church the notions of Messiahship and redemption foreign to the thought of Jesus and the faith of His first disciples ?
did not, doubtless, go so far as to deny the historical reality of the person of Jesus end, nevertheless, in rendering it practically un-
The
theories of
Wrede
;
they
Him to necessary, and they reduce the part played by that of the occasional cause of the development of 81
From the notion one may so put it, only
Christianity.
of a Jesus having the pretext for the
been, if birth of Christianity to the thesis of His nonhistorical are character there is but a shade of difference.
We
thus brought to examine the 80
Concerning
this
literature
see
modern forms of
the
myth
Schweitzer, Gesch. der Pauhni-
ichcn Forschunff, 1911, pp. 119-40. 81 Such appears to be the point of view reached by
M. Loisy. the influence of the sociological school, many critics in recent years insist upon the part played by the community, and specially of worship, in the development of Christianity and of the evangelical tradition. As characteristic of this tendency we cite the work of Under
Bertram, Die Leidemgcschichte 2922.
Jew und
der Christiukult, Gottingen,
NONHISTORICAL THEORIES
15
and Bruno concept formerly stated by Volney, Dupuis Bauer. In the last twenty years of the nineteenth century the
myth concept is only represented by an anonymous work published in London in 1887 under the title of Antiqua Mater and by some criticisms of the radical Dutch school, 82 which is, however, as a general rule, more occupied with the apostle Paul and his epistles than with Jesus and the Gospels. Pierson, Matthes, Naber, Van Loon, and for some time Loman, have decided against the historicity of Jesus. The reasons which are principally of the negative order.
determined their conclusions
These authors
on the uncertainty of the Gospel tradition, the absence of all external testimony, and thus consider as
insist
not only a skepticism regarding the possibility of reaching a positive conception of the life of Jesus,
justified
but also of His existence. fact that they have failed to give from their the origins of point of view a coherent explanation of the of formation the of Gospel tradiChristianity and tion explains the slight influence that their theories have exercised.
The
NONHISTORICAL THEORIES IN THE TWENTIETH
II.
CENTURY That there
existed in the
indifference
which the
Dutch school met with something more than a conspiracy of silence is proved by the volume
theories of the
this school, see a book, somewhat one-sided, by G. Van den van Eysinga, Die h oil and is che radikale Kritik dn Neuen Bergh 81
On
Testaments, Jena, 19x2.
JESUS
x6
THE NAZARENE
of discussion since the opening of the twentieth century upon the historical character of Jesus. 88 According to J. M. Robertson, religions develop
who by a regular law, continually producing new gods, someold the to ones, are substituted for or added times presenting themselves as sons of the latter. Jewish
Monotheism thus gave
birth to the Messianic cult.
only the reappearance of an old religion which existed in Israel at the time when
The adoration Abraham,
of Jesus
Isaac,
is
Moses and Joshua were
still deities.
these cults the most important was that of under Joshua, the solar-deity of Ephraim, worshiped This ram. the and lamb the symbols of the god Joshua is not unrelated to the Syrian Adonis and the Baby-
Among
lonian
Thammuz. The new
cult of
Jesus-Joshua spe-
the destruction of the Temple. cially developed after It created a whole legendary tradition, whose prina distinctly mythical character. cipal elements have It is possible, however, that in these developments have been included certain historical souvethere
may
nirs relating particularly to
John the Baptist and
to a
certain Jesus Ben-Pandera, put to death under Alex8i conander (106-79 B.C.) Albert Kalthoff
Janneus
Short Robertson, Christianity and Mythology, London, 1900, 1910; Studies in Comparative History of Christianity* 1902; Pagan Chnsts, Restatement of the Myth Theology, 1902-11; The Jesus Problem Schweitzer (Gesch.), see Robertson, Concerning Theory, 1917. resemble the astral Guignebert (p. 88). Some ideas of Robertson theories developed by Niemojewski (Gott Jesu im Lichte fremder,
Muncben, 1910; Das wervoende Dogma vom Leben Jesu, Jena, von Chnstus, 1910) ; and by C. P. Fuhrmann (Der Astralmythus cult of Jesus-Joshua is also adof a idea The pre-Christian 1912). mitted by Holland (De Evangelische Jozua Met Evangelien), Leiden, nach Rome, Untersuchun2907-10. Cp. also W. Erbt, Von Jerusalem des Geschichte Urchristentums, nur 1912. Leipzig, gen "Kalthoff, Das Christusproblem, Grundhnien *u finer Sotial*
etc.,
NONHISTORICAL THEORIES
17
aiders Christianity to be a social phenomenon. The new religion was' born when the proletarian masses, opin the Roman world, came into contact with
pressed
of Jesus Jewish Messianic aspirations. The history the it reflects Christ is only that of the idea of the
development of the community. 86 concedes that there may be an historical Jensen element at the base of the Gospel tradition, but this fact is without import. Whatever the history of the man Jesus may have been, the Christ of the Faith was born of the transformation of the Babylonian myth of
-
is a person partly which Jensen finds that of the quest of immor-
Gilgamesch. Like Jesus, Gilgamesch
human, partly divine an astral character,
;
his history, in is
86
tality.
William Benjamin Smith,
87
mathematical teacher at
New
Orleans, sets out with a triple observation. It is inconceivable that one simple personality could have movement as inspired such an important religious In the second place, there are in the writChristianity.
Die Entstehung des Christentums, Leipzig, wissen wtr von Jesus f Berlin, 1904- Concerning Kalthoff see Schweitzer (Gesch , p. 345) and Guignebert, p. 78. P. Jensen, Das Gilgamesch-Epos in der Weltlitteratur, Strasdes Babylontschen bourg, 1906; Moses, Jesus, Paulus, Drei Vananten Gottmenschen Gilgamesch Eine Anklage wider die Theologie ein Jesus der Appel an die Laien, Frankfurt-a-M, 1906-9; Hat der Schweitzer see On p. (Gesch., wirklich Jensen gelebtf Evangehen theologie, Leipzig, 1902-3
1904;
466) and Guignebert, p
w H.
;
Was
85.
Zimmern (Zum Streit un den Christusmythe, Das Babylonische Material in semen Hauptpunkten dargestellt, 1910) admits, in addition to the influence of Gilgamesch, that of the cults of Marduk, Mithra and Thammuz. 87 W. B. Smith, Der vorchristliche Jesus (Giessen, 1906); Ecc* Deus; The pre-Christian Jesus (American Journal of Theology. Smith are thoie of G. T. 1911). Resembling the ideas of W. B. New the London, 1921. Behind Testament, Sadler,
1
JESUS
8
THE NAZARENE
of the apostle Paul and the first Christian of apologists but few allusions to the public activity have been so could Jesus. In the third place, no man ings
easily deified as In this mode
modern theologians suppose. Smith
is
led to adopt the idea of a
divine pre-Christian Jesus. It is this person who was worshiped by the Naassene Gnostics, known to Hip-
Nazarenes (or Nazolater Chap. Ill, renes), known to Epiphanius (see Section II). The name of this sect is not derived from
polytus,
and the Jewish
sect of
the village of Nazareth, whose existence is very doubtful. In the name is found the root NSR, which exand salvation. In suppresses the idea of protection Smith cites port of his theory of a pre-Christian Jesus, a series of other proofs, such as the conjuration "by the of god of the Hebrews, Jesus," in the magic papyrus cenfourth the Paris, which, in truth, only dates from the case of Apollos tury after Jesus Christ or, again, the and the disciples of John Baptist at Ephesus (Acts xviii. 24-28 and xix. 1-7), who know the "things con;
Paul. The cerning Jesus" before their meeting with xiii. 6magician Elymas, surnamed Bar-Jesus (Acts of 12) and Simon (Acts viii. 9-13) were worshipers Hellenized name His (the this pre-Christian Jesus.
and verb Greek meaning is "to heal." The history of Jesus had been created by
form of the name of Joshua)
signifies deliverance,
also related to the root of the
pre-Christian Jesus; it enof the shrines the history primitive community. The theories of W. B. Smith were welcomed with 88 who, in a work of enthusiasm by Arthur Drews,
the
worshipers
"A.
of the
Drews, Die Christusmythe, Jena, 1909-";
prankfurt,
19x0;
.
Das Markuwangelium
alt
*>*' Pelruslegende,
Zcugnis gegin
di*
NONHISTORICAL THEORIES philosophy published in
religious
that the cult of Jesus
was a
relic
19
1906, maintained of fetishism from
which it was necessary to purge religion. Smith's system seemed to him adapted to bring about the religious reform he desired. He therefore adopted the theory of a pre-Christian Jesus, while combining it with an astral system, and adding to the product certain conceptions of his own devising, in particular a conjunction unbetween the Christ as lamb expected, to say the least of God (Agnus Dei) and the Vedic lamb.
The
theories,
among which we have been sum-
marizing the most characteristic, have in Germany, during the early years of the twentieth century, been made the object of an intense propaganda. The controversy was not only carried on in scientific publications, but in a large
tracts designed for the lectures, sometimes as public
number of
general public, in popular 89 debates, in the presence of huge audiences. The negative theses called forth a multitude of 40
replies. Geschichthchkeit Jew, Jena; Die Entstehung des Chnstentums ausdem Gnostizismus. Concerning Drews see Schweitzer (Gesch , p. 483), Guignebert (p 107). 89 See in 1910, published particularly the public debates in Berlin A. Lipby the German Monist Union and translated into French by existef a-t-il Jesus 1912). (Pans, man,
Among
all this literature
we
shall only cite: Bousset,
Was
wissen
von Jesuf\ L. C Pillion, ^Existence histonque de Jesus et le ratlonalisme contemporam\ Julicher, Hat Jesus gelebt* H. von Soden, Hat Jesus gelebtf 1910; Wemel, 1st das "liberate" Jesus-bild wideroder Geschichtef legtt 1910; Joh. Weiss, Jesus von Nazareth, Mythus
vair
der mythologische Christus, 1910; Dunkmann, Der historische Jesus, Le Problem* 1910; S. J. Case, Historicity of Jesus, 1912, Guignebert, de 3e$us t 1914 The method employed by Pe>es against Dupuis (sec Section I) has been turned against the modern mythologists by J. Die Bismarcksmythe) and by an anonymous writer to Naumann (see
show that Martin Luther never Luther nit
existieri hat).
existed
(Beweis dast Docktor
M.
20
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
one passes over certain controversialists whose work has more resemblance to an historical 41 romance than to history, the thesis of nonhistoricity has been supported, with certain reservations, by M. Salomon Reinach, and in its entirety by M. Couchoud In France,
if
M. Stahl. M. Salomon
and
42
does not formally give his verdict for the negative thesis, owing to the testimony of the Pauline epistles, which he is unable to consider as unauthentic. But while admitting that Jesus lived,
Reinach
upon three objections to the historicity of the Passion. The first is on the ground of the si-
Reinach
insists
particularly the absence of a report of Pontius Pilate to the Emperor Tiberius upon the condemnation and execution of the Nazarene. The second argument is that the history of
lence of non-Christian authors
the Passion
fulfils
certain prophecies, particularly that
of verse 17 of Psa, 41
The most
xxii.
The
last
prolific of these authors is
argument
is
Arthur Hculhard (le MenPans, 1908-10, n vol la
songe Chretien, Jesus Christ n'a pas cxiste, Ver'Ue
Bar abbas,
le
based
Mensonge Jesus; Tu
;
est
Petrus I'histoire et la
his theory in the two legende, Paris, 1913-14). Heulhard sums up theses: following "i. It was the Jew known aa John the Baptist who said he was Christ and Bar Abba (son of the father), and he was certainly not
beheaded. "2. It
was Barabbas who, condemned
to
death
for his
public
crimes such as assassination, robbery and treason was crucified at Guol Golta by Pilate. The evangelists are a mystification invented more than a century after the execution of this scoundrel. It is Barabbas that the Church worships under the name of Jesus, an imagi-
and nary personage substituted by the evangelists for the crucified, invented by them to impart the hue of innocence to the individual by whose invention they exploited lucratively the remission of sins by baptism."
1909; Le Verset 17 du Psaume xxii; des proPropot de la cunositi de Tibere; Bossuet et Vargument Docetume. du source Une de Simon bibltque Cyrene; phetifs;
"Salomon Reinach, Orpheus,
A
NONHISTORICAL THEORIES
21
which upon the Docetist heresy that is, the opinion of life human and Jesus to a reduced the historical
A very interesting attempt
has been
Couchoud* 8 to present the
Pauline
pure appearance.
made by M.
and testimony as concerned with a Christ purely ideal, so eliminate the difficulty which prevented M. Salomon Reinach formally supporting the thesis of nonhis-
M. Couchoud
of Jesus.
toricity
in that
differs essentially
from
he refuses to make Jesus a
the mythologists in fact, he posmythical being, but a spiritual being sesses a comprehension of the spiritual value of Christianity
which
religious influence of belief in Jesus theoretidistinguishes him radically from such
and of the
Drews, Smith, or Robertson. In M. Couchoud's opinion, the method
cians as
which historians, from Renan to Loisy, attempt to understand the history of Jesus and the genesis of Christianity is liable to
two main
difficulties.
The
first is
in
that
it is in-
conceivable that in less than a single generation a man should be deified, and this within the territory of Jewish monotheism. The second is that historically Jesus
The testimony of Josephus is an established The Talmud contains nothing about Jesus
escapes us. forgery.
which does not come from Christian tradition. Out of Couchoud, L'Enigme de Jtsus (translated into English by Mrs. G. Whale) Enigma of Jesus, with introduction by Sir J. G. Fraser; Le Mysore de Jesus (Mercure de France). ;
The
first article in
the
Mercure de France by M. Couchoud was
dis-
cussed by me. Under the pretext that it was not a review of religious in which I discussed history, the Mercure refused to insert an article the second article of M. Couchoud. On the other hand, M. Couchoud has explained his views in a series of informal discussions at the The development of the la Virile (Jan -April, 1924). Unto
pour
objections made by ent Tolume.
me on
these occasions will be found in the pres-
JESUS
22
THE NAZARENE
three of the oldest pagan testimonies there is one which may refer to an unknown that of Suetonius two Jewish agitator known as Chrestos. The other establish only the existthose of Pliny and Tacitus Christian ence of a movement, but as regards its oriborrowed from the gins, they give only information Christians themselves.
for the evangelists, M. Couchoud points out that these are not histories, but outlines of the good news in other words, they are writings of an essentially
As
;
They have two sources: the inand the visions. The Gospel of Mark,
mystical character.
spired writings the oldest, is the apocalypse of a man without elonot quence; it is the creation of imaginative exegesis,
an historical document; it is a free commentary made the up of Biblical texts and spiritual memoirs, on which such from ask Christian faith is fused. One must not a book humble and commonplace historical information. Beyond the evangelists it is requisite to go back to the oldest
form of the Christian
faith, such as the
Paul bring to our knowledge. The Christinor the cult of a anity of Paul is neither the deification
epistles of
man. His Christ is but a new form of the old Israel, Yahveh, as Messiah. When, after the
God
of
fall
of
a kind of Jerusalem, the populace entered the Church, transformation took place in the Christian faith. The
mystery of Jesus became fixed
from the
in record,
lyrical to the narrative
of Paul became an
artificial
form.
and passed
The ineffable The bold in-
legend. vention of popular preachers did its work; but this the secondary form of Christianity has but disguised
epic
real nature of the Gospel.
In reality Jesus
is
not a
man
progressively deified;
NONHISTORICAL THEORIES
23
is not a progressively humanized. He God. new a but founder of religion, In his article in 1924, after emphasizing the very character of the problem of Jesus, M. Couch-
He
is
a
God
special
oud applies himself to
define his theory.
"At the
origin
of Christianity there is, if I am right," he says, "not a personal biography, but a collective mystical experi*4 revealed." ence, sustaining a divine history mystically
At
the beginning Jesus
which manifested
was not a man, but a
Spirit
itself.
Men
believed in this Spirit, because of its manifestaits existence and tions, and because it was supposed that in Isaiah and the history could be discovered and read show that it is into aims Couchoud Psalms. And M.
deed to a
spiritual being that the Pauline testimony
As
to the origin of the tradition concerning the words of Jesus, the Pauline epistles would enable refers.
one to solve this problem in reading them. It was from the 'Lord, Paul says emphatically, that he received the account he gives of the last repast of Jesus. Exegesis of prophetic texts, visions and revelations, of projection into the past, and the attribution to Jesus the facts of apostolic history in which the activity of such are the sources the Spirit had been discerned tradition has sprung. Jesus must, then, have been at the beginning the God of a mystery. At the time of Paul neither the
from which the Gospel
the mystery had become historical. They were to become so in the period to follow the creative when it would be no longer possible to understand
God nor age,
the high spirituality which had inspired the primitive faith, and when the celestial drama upon which Chris-
" See
Couchoud, Le Mysore de Mtus,
p. 1x7.
JESUS
24 tianity
of the
first
THE NAZARENE
generation had lived had been trans-
ported to earth.
by M. Couchoud in the Mercurc de France have been almost literally reproduced, under the title Le Mystere de Jesus, in the third volume of the collection, Christianity, published under
The two
articles published
objections which were offered in the part of the Rev. Father de Grandmaison as well as those advanced in the public dis-
his direction.
review on or myself,
The
this
(Union de la Verite), have been completely have not persuaded ignored by M. Couchoud; they him to modify his views in the slightest degree; he has not even considered it advisable to state in what cussions
He contented respect he thought them ill-founded. himself by adding three chapters to his previous exhe attempts to demonstrate that position. In the first non-Pauline study of the Apocalypse and the the conclusion confirm Testament New the of epistles to which his study of the Pauline epistles had led him; the
what he had already said the Gospel tradition; and in the last he concerning summarizes the conclusions of his research.
in the second he returns to
We
shall call attention also to an original but very
45 which has paradoxical work by Monsieur R. Stahl, the somewhat enigmatical title The Document 70. This "document 70" is the fragment of the Jewish
from
Apocalypse which Wellhausen has disentangled is Chap, xii of the Johannine Apocalypse. In this imheaven to Messiah a of found the idea transported mediately after His birth. sees in the Apocalypse of the
While Wellhausen <5
R. Stahl, Le
Document
70, Paris
book see the obierrationj of
M.
and Strasbourg, 1923.
Alfaric,
Rcwt
On
d'htstoirt, 1904.
this
NONHISTORICAL THEORIES
15
made use of by the Chrisyear 70 a Jewish fragment tian author of our Apocalypse, M. Stahl thinks he can one in it the oldest Christian document recognize
might almost
call it the birth certificate
of Christianity.
The Apocalyptic Messiah referred to must have been first presented as an actual individual, in a symand later in a more material way in the Synoptic Gospels, which would be The letters of Paul younger than the Gospel of John.
bolic
are
manner,
all
in the fourth Gospel,
unauthentic. Paul
is
not, however, a completely
whose
porimaginary individual, but the real person, has been somewhat modified, has been preserved for us in the book of Acts. He was merely a Pharisee the Sadducees missionary who had some quarrels with M. Stahl has dead. the of resurrection the concerning of tried to sketch the development Christianity as he in the following represents it. It might be summarized
trait
series
:
Document 70
Apocalypse
Fourth Gospel
of the first manifestaSynoptics. He has no explanation tions of Christianity in Rome, and particularly of the be persecution by Nero. To get rid of this it would
on Latin necessary to overthrow the accepted ideas literature as well as those which appear the best established
upon the books of the III.
New
Testament.
THE PROBLEM
The review which we have
presented to the princithe critical work pal theories, which (while utilizing of the nineteenth century) have during the last twenty
of the hisyears opposed the traditional acceptance occasion to make several obtoricity of Jesus, gives servations. The difficulty of the problem consists not
JESUS
26
THE NAZARENE
of its data, but only in the complexity and obscurity it is a unique sense certain a in that fact also in the without analogy in the whole history of re-
problem
M. Couchoud
ligion.
has
much
46
on this fact. no ordinary his-
insisted
Jesus," he writes, "is torical difficulty. The case of Jesus is unique. For the ' But history, historian, unique cases are enigmas. less even in exceptional cases, is never-
"The problem of
1
contemplating
theless not exclusively a science of the particular.
remove from
wish to
its
The
jurisdiction everything which
does not present the character of collective fact is simply to prohibit it dealing with great personalities,
and to exclude from its domain a Julius Caesar, a Mahomet, a Luther, and a Napoleon, and thus to suppress one of the most important factors on human evolution. So also, when it is claimed that the problem of Jesus is no historical problem, it is nevertheless (and here M. Couchoud is no exception) by the methods of historical criticism that
it is
attempted to solve
it.
It is important, we think, to distinguish carefully the observation of facts from their interpretation. If in
second part of historical research there is more or less a philosophical element, it is not the same thing for
this
the
first part.
To
to carry the work out properly it is necessary oneself free to reach to an effort make impartiality,
preconceived ideas, and to see the texts as they and not are, to extract from them what they contain, to what one would like them say.
from
all
But is perfect objectivity possible in a question whose solution cannot fail to have a very direct bearSee Couchoud, Le
(March
1924).
Mysthe de
Jiiut
and Mercure d* Franc*
NONHISTORICAL THEORIES
27
and religious concepts? ing upon our philosophical a is The objection grave one; it does not seem to us decisive if only
we
and
put them
consent to admit as the first premise of every religious philosophy that it is not the facts which must be adapted to our theories, but rather that it is our theories which must, if necessary, be corrected rectified to
harmony with domain more than
the facts.
in
any other that the principle proclaimed by Paul holds most truly. "We can do nothing contrary to the truth; we have no This except in the truth" (2 Cor. xiii. 8). It
is
in the religious
in
strength
principle
was
also proclaimed
by one of the most emi-
nent representatives of German theology, Herrmann, at the beginning of this century, who delighted to repeat: "Die erste Pflicht der Religion It is a question of fact which tigkeit."
ist
Wahrhaf-
is
before us:
there historical proofs of value for the actual shall therefore leave on one existence of Jesus?
Are
We
side the discussion of the
more or
less
complicated
theories offered to explain (other than by the existence and activity of Jesus) the appearance and development
of Christianity. It would be easy to show how much there enters of the conjectural, of superficial resemblances, of debatable interpretation into the systems of the Drews, the Robertsons, the W. B. Smiths,
We
shall not linger on the Couchouds, or the Stahls. shall not discuss theories which the way to do it.
We
to a greater or less extent are inspired by considerations depending neither on history nor on criticism, but 47
upon
religious philosophy.
has been well noted by Guignebert (p. 23). Let us recall for example, the case which Drews has pointed out (p. 25* only, French edition). There is something similar with M. Couchoud,
"This
28
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
If there are sufficient proofs of the historical existence of Jesus, it is above all things necessary that the should actheory offered of the origin of Christianity were no there if even commodate itself to them. And of proofs, it might still happen that the explanation the genesis of Christianity as due to the work and less teaching of the prophet of Nazareth would be the in epic conjectural than the theories which bring of Gilgamesch, the astral system, the pre-Christian
cult of Joshua-Jesus, a collective mental representation, or the "document 70."
who, pointing out how the concept formed about Jesus was transformed according to the particular epoch, foresees that this evolution will continue and that in "about 1940 Jesus in His entirety will have passed from the historical stage to that of collective mental Have we not here a theory representations" (Le Mysore de JSsus) upon the essence of religious facts? The same author supposes that if Christianity had really arisen from the deification of an historical of a low personage it would be something very mean, a religion Roman Cult, in any type, on the commonplace level of the Imperial case quite inferior to Judaism and I si ami sm, which have taken great care that neither Moses nor Mahomet should be taken for gods. For him this is an objection to the historicity of Jesus, at any rate, "because he has a vague idea that Christianity is not there" We can hardly fail to recognize in this an a priori opinion calculated to hinder historical inquiry.
CHAPTER
II
THE NONCHRISTIAN TESTIMONY I.
THE j esus
1
FLAVIUS JOSEPHUS
most ancient nonChristian testimony concerning or rather would be, if it were authentic s i
In his works, as we read them, 2 and the Jesus is mentioned twice, in the eighteenth twentieth book of Jewish Antiquities. u The first of these reads thus: At this time Jesus that of Josephus.
For appeared a wise man, if He can be called man. He accomplished marvelous things, was the Master of those who received with joy the truth, and led away
many Jews and also many Greeks. He was the Christ. Upon the denunciation of the leaders of our nation, Pilate condemned Him to the cross; but those who had loved Him from the first ceased not to revere Him,
He
appeared to them on the third day, raised again from the dead, as had announced the divine prophets, as well as a thousand other marvelous things concern-
for
Him. There still exists to-day the sect which, " 8 Him, received the name of 'Christians.'
ing
after
X K. Linck, De antigutssimls qua ad Jesum Natarenum spectant tistimomis, Giessen, 1913. a The best edition of Josephus' works is that of Niese (Berlin, French translation is appearing under 1885.95) in six volumes. the direction of Th. Reinach (Pans, 1900). Concerning Josephus see
A
Schurer (Gtsch., i, pp. 74'rf)> Wlth very complete bibliography. 8 Ant. Jud., xviii, pp. 63-64. To the bibliography given by Schurer must be added the followHarnack (Der judischt Geschickting: Burkitt (Jotfphus and Chnst), 29
JESUS
30
THE NAZARENE
This text is given by three known manuscripts, of which none, it must be admitted, goes farther back than the eleventh century. Eusebius (//., i, p. 1 1> and Dem. ev.)
knew of
it.
But Origen seems to ignore
it,
for
upon two occasions he quotes the praise given by nevertheless Josephus to James, while remarking that Christ (Comm. Josephus did not admit Jesus to be the in Matt. x. t c. 17, also Contra Celsius, i, 47). the point of view of external criticism, the at least, to be passage is therefore strongly suspected,
From
an interpolation/
The arguments from still
"if
more
He
convincing. can be called a
internal criticism appear to be
had said of Jesus, man" and "He was the Christ," If Josephus
he had spoken of resurrection, of miracles, the fulfillment of prophecies, he would have been a
if
Christian.
From
the sixteenth century the authenticity of this
passage has been questioned, specially by Osiander; tchreiber Josephus und Jesus Chnstus), Smith (De Katholieck, as reLiock (op. gards authenticity), Batiffol (Orpheus et I'Evangile), K. Tacitus uber Jesus Chnstus und Messctt.)> Norden (Josephus und tanische Prophetie), Seitz (Das Christusteugniss des Josephus Flavins), Jacoby (Jesus bet Josephus), Ed Meyer (Vrsprung und Anfange des Christentums, for authenticity), Goetz (Die Urspungliche Fassung des Stelle Ant), Corssen (Die Zeugnisse des Tacitus und Pseudo-Josephus uber Christus), Goethals (Melanges d' his to ire for chretienne), Brunt (St. u. Kr , unauthentic text, but substituted
a text in which Josephus spoke of Jesus), R. Laqueur (Josephus, passage added afterwards by Josephus himself). 4 The text of Josephus seems to have existed under another form, for in an Apocryphal dialogue concerning a religious discussion at the court of Sassanides we read: "Josephus spoke of the Christ as a of signs just and good man manifested by Divine Grace by means and miracles, and who did good to many." (Bratke, Das soaenannt* Religions getprach am Hofe der Saisaniden).
NONCHRISTIAN TESTIMONY one a
feels a certain difficulty in
Harnack has been
critic as
understanding
able to defend
31
how
such
5
it.
we read
betrays with evidence a Christian hand, but has not the interpolator confined himself to retouching that which Josephus had
The passage
that
And
6
hypothesis be accepted, is it text? Or is one possible to reconstruct the original of he that Jesus, which in spoke simply to maintain Schurer has itself would be a fact of importance?
written?
the expressions and phrases whose certainly Christian are put aside, the re-
observed that is
origin
if this
if
But the interpolator very insignificant. could easily have mutilated the primitive passage at the same time as he exaggerated it. Norden remarks
mainder
is
that the account of Pilate's government in the eight-
eenth book of the Antiquities consists of a series of arose among episodes presented as troubles which the Jews, the word 0opu(3oc (noise, clamor, disturbance) being the leit motif of the account.
The
interrupted by paragraphs 63 and 64, which speak of Jesus. If these are removed, 62 and 65 are in perfect connection with
general plan
is
paragraphs
The bond between them is broken by what this fragJesus. Norden therefore considers
each other. is
said to
ment
to be quite unauthentic.
But Corssen
replies
of the account against this that the general plan
is
Among the most recent defenders of authenticity we may cite Bole (Flavius Josephus uber Christus und die Christen in den juditchen altertumern), Kneller (Flavius Josephus uber Christus, Stimmen aus Maria Laack), Burkitt, Harnack, etc. 6 The thesis of unauthenticity is admitted, besides authors quoted, est apud by Schurer, Niese (De testimonio chnstiano quod etc. sur Reinach Mtus), of that (Josephe by interpolation Josephum) ;
32 artificial.
JESUS The
THE NAZARENE
events related are not
sense of the word, troubles.
There
is,
all, in
the strict
for instance, in
paragraph 62 a reference to an incident which hapwere not impened in Rome and in which the Jews plicated,
and
troubles
among
against them.
in
paragraph 65
it
is
not a question of
the Jews, but of measures directed might therefore be supposed, if the
It
had contained anything about Jesus, would equally have been presented as The reasoning which Corssen that of an agitation. uses against Norden's theory seems to us decisive, but Is it possible still it only establishes a mere possibility. original passage that His history
to go farther? In the retouching of a passage there very often appear certain peculiarities of the primitive form. According to Corssen this is the case in the "repassage we are concerned with. The expression is that formula a is very ceive with pleasure" Josephus fond of, and which he uses no less than seven times
Antiquities. The words, It "the chief among us" are also quite his style. u wise the would be possible to say as much of epithet it would be difficult to to as Jesus; man," applied in the eighteenth
book of the
understand from the pen of a Christian, while it accords well with the tendency of Josephus to class as philosophical schools such Jewish movements, essenthose of the Pharisees, Sadducecs tially religious, as
and Essenes.
The
selves with Jesus
is
idea of the Greeks allying themalso very characteristic.
It
may
be
that the Christian editor of our passage took pains to imitate the style of Josephus ; it is neverthless difficult to suppose that he succeeded so well in it. The passage might therefore be the retouching of one written by
NONCHRISTIAN TESTIMONY Josephus himself.
33
This conclusion seems confirmed
by the fact that in the passage in the twentieth book, where the death of James is referred to, the latter is the presented as "the brother of Jesus, surnamed this that to indicate Jesus Christ," which would seem was a personage already known to the readers, of therefore Josephus must have made mention. Is it possible to reconstruct, by surmise, the original it is, passage of Josephus? Theodore Reinach thinks
whom
and, eliminating that coming from a Christian hand, u he restores the following passage: At this time there
He appeared Jesus, called Christ, an able man (for those to was a worker of miracles) who preached eager for novelties, and He led away many Jews and also Albeit that Pilate upon the denunciation of the leaders among us, condemned Him to the
many
Greeks.
cross, those
who had loved Him from
the beginning
(or those whom He had deceived from the beginning) ceased not to be attached to Him, and to-day there still exists the sect which from Him had taken the name of Christians."
Here
is
nothing more than a conjecture,
easy to recognize in the actual text that which comes from a Christian hand, it is not so easy to guess at what the portions suppressed by the interpolator might have contained. for
if it is
In the twentieth book of the Antiquities (paragraph It is found 200) there is another mention of Jesus. account of the death of James whom the high and put to death by priest Annas caused to be tried, of Festus during the period between the death in the
stoning,
and the
arrival of his successor, Albinus.
Roman
authority seemed to be
At
this
somewhat lax
time
at Jeru-
JESUS
34
THE NAZARENE
"Annas," says the text, "called the Sanhedrin before it the together, and summoned to appear brother of Jesus, surnamed Christ, and certain others under the charge of illegality, and caused them to be salem.
Eusebius
stoned to death."
cites
this
passage (H. 9
on three occaII, xxiii, pars. 21-24), but Origen, who 7 establishes (following Josephus) a relation sions between the death of James and the destruction of the
Temple, has read the passage
in a text
retouched by a
Christian.
Schurer (Gesch., i, p. 581) concludes from this that the existing text is also to be suspected of interpolation. This conclusion goes too far. that the Admitting that this passage is among those Christians might have been tempted to exaggerate, it does not at all follow that they did it. Besides, between the expression "Jesus, surnamed Christ," and the cateChrist" of the eightgorical declaration "He was the
The words a great difference. 9 8 believed has then be authentic. Mgr. Batiffol
eenth book there
may
is
an important possible to deduce from this passage conclusion. The accusation brought against James and it
his associates
couched
is
in
ambiguous terms which may
of just as well refer to the violation
Roman
laws as
In order to admit that to that of the Jewish Law. the ground of the charge against James was revolt attribute against Roman law, it would be necessary to to the high priest and the Sanhedrin a scrupulous loyalty to the Roman power which seems very far from likely to *
have been the
case.
On
this hypothesis
Origen, Comm. in Matt. 17 and Contra Cehum, This, for instance. Is the opinion of K. Linck. Batiffol,
Orpheus
et I'Evangile.
i,
47;
ii,
13.
it
NONCHRISTIAN TESTIMONY would be
difficult
to understand
why
35
(as Joscphus
this before the Governor says) they were accused of 10 by the Jews. Batiffol, would constitute a revolt What, asks
Mgr.
against religion if
it
were not the Christianity of the
This argument
accused?
for tradition presents of the "Law."
The
in conflict with a difficulty,
is
James
as a very strict observer
text of Josephus seems to us too concise to allow
us to maintain that there could have been no other motive of opposition between the high priest and 11
James other than Christianity. Even if it be recognized that the silence of Josephus not so complete concerning Jesus and Christianity is the as was formerly said, extremely brief character of the allusions found in his
most favorable hypothesis)
How explain
it,
work (under even none the
is
seeing* that the
the
less striking.
work of Josephus
deals
stoning to Batiffol adds that the punishment inflicted This is not presupposes a crime of a religious character. alone were stoned convincing, for it does not appear that blasphemers 10
Mgr.
death
to death. 11
A
Slavonic verson of the
ditions to the
Greek
text in
De
Bella Judatco contains various adis referred to. It will suffice
which Jesus
to establish its character of secondary importance to summarize what on is said of the death of Jesus in the first portion: Jesus remains
the
of Olives and refuses to humble Himself as He is ordered and the Roman authorities. The Jews accuse Him then of
Mount Pilate
by The latter, fomenting a conspiracy, in the presence of the Procurator. after having massacred many innocent persons, seizes Jesus, ^tnd after having obtained finding that He is no malefactor sets Him free, from Him the healing of his wife The Jews, jealous of this success, the right to give thirty pieces of silver to Pilate, and so obtain the first editor, A. how understand to difficult is It crucify Jesus. Berendts (lie Zeugnisse von Chnsto im Slwvischem De Belh Judatco des Josephus) has been able to find in such accounts the authentic elements that Josephui made away with in translating his work from Aramaic into Greek.
JESUS
36
THE NAZARENE
and the epoch in which and born began to develop? Is it Christianity was not surprising that an author who spoke of the Pharisees, the Sadducees, the Essenes and the Samaritans has said nothing, or has said so little, about the Christians? So complete a silence is perhaps more embar-
precisely with the environment
rassing for the mythologists than for their opponents. By what right, indeed, should it be permissible to conclude from it that Jesus never existed, and not permissible to deny that a Christian Palestine prior to the year 70?
movement
existed in
Since Josephus has not only concerning Jesus, but also concerning Christianity, how is his silence to be explained? Uniquely by his character and the object of his work.
been
silent
The
writer desired to flatter the
Romans and
gain their good graces. To do this he expunged from the picture he drew everything likely to offend or excite their at all apprehension. Thus it is that he has scarcely conspoken of the Messianic cult which nevertheless stituted the center of Jewish thought in the first cenThat he did so was because this cult was a tury. menace to Rome, for the Kingdom of the Messiah
could only be built upon the ruins of the Empire. as a moral Josephus portrays John the Baptist
which preacher, and passes by unnoticed everything the one presented him as the prophet of the Messiah, to announce the baptism of
fire
(Antiquities, xviii. pp.
is thus de116-19). The preaching of repentance its support and prived by him of everything lending The little that Josephus giving it any signification.
him to flatter basely preserves of Messianism is used by with authority in connecting the Messianic prophecies
NONCHRISTIAN TESTIMONY
37
12 It was not possible to speak of ChrisVespasian. tianity while amputating it from Messianism. Josephus therefore maintained silence on the subject. It might besides have been determined by another
reason.
At
and at least since the -Christianity was separated from
the time he wrote
persecution by
Nero
Josephus could thus consider it as outside 18 Doubtless the the history that he wished to write.
Judaism.
same thing was not the case as regards Palestine Chrisbut Josephus could not have spoken of it without exposing Judaism to the accusation of a compromisodious to ing solidarity with a dangerous movement, the governing class, and to which, it has been supposed, he had contributed to draw the attention of the court tianity,
of Nero. 14
The
silence of
Josephus
is
not therefore
the silence of ignorance; it is the silence of prudence and fear a silence actuated by interest. Far from
not proving that Jesus and the Christian movement did it exist in Palestine in the first century, only proves that Josephus did not wish, by speaking of it, to com15 promise himself, and with himself the Jewish people. The reasons which explain the silence or the discretion of Josephus account also
for the fact that,
of Tiberiade according! to Photius (Codex 13), Justus (author of a chronicle and a history of the Jewish war, written at the
same time and
in
the same spirit as the
Bella Jud., vi, pp. 310-14. The same thing is found in Taciwho have probv., p. 13), and in Suetonius (Vesp., p. 4)* ably borrowed in this matter from Josephus. i*
Df
tus (History,
Ed. Meyer, Ursprung und Anf i, p 2x1. Corssen thinks (Z.N.T.JT., xv, p. 135)* who P ints out **?* of the fire, and that he was in Josephut was in Rome at the time relation with the empress Poppcea. Weiss, Jesus von Nazareth, Mythus oder Gcschichte, p. 89. 18
"So
"Joh.
THE NAZARENE
JESUS
38
work of Josephus) has not mentioned Jesus or
Chris-
tianity either.
sometimes exof the pressed that in his works no mention is found died he that remember to it suffices shortly Gospel. But
As
regards Philo, astonishment
16
is
nothing to prove that this date. Christianity had reached Alexandria before 17 sources other and That the Talmud say Jewish is not the distortion of which about Jesus nothing Christian tradition is sufficiently explained by the date after the year 4O,
and there
is
of these documents and the fact that those who compiled them were governed by entirely polemical Their sole object was to combat considerations. the Christians; they were not interested in writing the history of their religion. The first mention of the Christians in this Jewish literature is the curse contained in the "Schemone Esre," the daily prayer of the (at close of the first century), "May the Naza-
Jews
renes and the
Minim
II.
The
first
perish I"
THE LATIN AUTHORS
Latin text to mention the name of Christ
from Pliny to Trajan the concerning the conduct to be observed toward
is
dated AJ>.
1
10.
It
is
the letter
iPhiIo wag one of an embassy sent to Rome by the Jews of Alexandria in A.D.4Q, and he was then very old. He speaks of himThe account of the self as an old man (Leg. ad Gaium, par. 28). embassy was written immediately after. im *7 Concerning this literature see H. Laible (Jesus Christus edition published in Cambridge (1893), with an Thalmud),
English
additions of Dalman and Streeter (Jesus Christ in the Talmud, etc.). See also R. T. Herford (Christianity in Talmud), A. Meyer (Juui im
Talmud), H. L.
Stracfc (Jesus dit
Hdrettker, Leipzig, 1910).
NONCHRISTIAN TESTIMONY Christians.
He
18
recounts
his
methods of
39 action,
punishing those for obstinacy, who, after two or three interrogations, persisted in the confession of Christianity, releasing those,
who denounced
as being Chris-
tians, denied the charge, and who in the Governor's wine and incense presence invoked the gods, offered
before the statue of the emperor, and cursed the name of Christ. The case of those who confessed they were formerly Christians, but declared they were so no
caused Pliny some embarrassment; he had with inquestioned them and compared their replies formation obtained by putting two deaconesses to the torture. He had only discovered, he declares, a coarse longer,
and exaggerated
superstition.
concerning Christian practices
From what he states one point maybe noted:
The
Christians were in the habit of meeting upon a certain day and singing a hymn (carmen dicere), or, in other words, invoking Christ as a God.
This text does not say
evidence of the cult of Christ, but it conceived to be explicitly whether He was is
a personage having lived on earth or a being of enThe expression "Christo quasi tirely spiritual nature.
mean, however, that for Pliny, Was not the like unto others. Christ was not a fact that He had lived on earth, that which disThe testimony of tinguished Him from others? between Tacitus in the Annales, written 115 and 117,
Deo" appears
to
God
*8
X,
p. 96.
since Semler.
The It
is,
been challenged authenticity of this text has often admitted. See E. C. Babut however, generally
relatives aux (Remarques sur Us deux lettres de Pline et de Trajan Chretiens de Bithyme), Linck (pp 33-60), Rcmach (Orpheus, p. 37), Couchoud (Le Mystere de Jtsus). There may be in Pliny's letter some
Christian interpolations (cp. Guignebert, Tertullien, pp. 77 et seq.),
M. Goguel (L'Eucharistie des onaens a Justin Martyr, pp. 259 of view we may neglect them. stq.). Prom our present point
ft
4o
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
more explicit "To destroy the rumor [which accused him as guilty of the burning of Rome] Nero invented some culprits, and inflicted on them the most excru-
is
:
for
those who, detested ciating punishments; they were the called their infamies, were populace, Christians. by
The author of
this
name, Christ, had under the reign
of Tiberius been condemned to death by the Procurator Pontius Pilate. This execrable superstition, held in check for a time, broke out anew, not only in also in the city Judea, the birthplace of this evil, but lfl flourish." and Jn which all atrocities congregate There are two remarks in this passage whose authen20
concerns the burning of Rome and the persecution of the Christians; the second 21 The first reflects the point of concerns the Christ. ticity is certain.
The
first
a
contemporaries of Tacitus. It is excited by the question of the hatred and contempt Christians and the infamies with which they were relaunched proached, whilst it is precisely the accusation Nero against them which seems to have unchained
view of the
by
and contempt. The second must originate in some documentary source, since it contains no such word as "dicunt" or "ferunt" which would authorize
this hatred
us to suppose that Tacitus is only relating gossip. There is in this remark a characteristic idea namely, **Annales, xv, 44. Sec further certain studies cited respecting et I'Evangilt, pp. Josephus, Linck, pp. 61-103; also Batiffol (Orpheus
4447).
S. Reinach (Orpheus). Hoan interpolation (Etudes au maintains that the sujet de la persecution des Chretiens sous Neron), entire work of Tacitus was an invention of the fifteenth century (De I'authenticity des annales et des htstoires de Tacite). Hochart'i theory has only been admitted by Drews (Die Christusmythe). ^Corssen, Z.N.T.JT., xiv, 1913, p. 135 (Zntschrift fur die Ntui-
*
It is
admitted without any reserve by
chart, after discovering in this passage
testamenltche fFissenschaft).
NONCHRISTIAN TESTIMONY that Christianity
41
had been crushed out by the death of
and had only reappeared about the year 64, This resurrecsimultaneously in Rome and in Judea. be tion of the execrable superstition in Judea can only Christ,
understood
if
we suppose
any distinction between the sianism
make two manifestations of Mes-
that Tacitus does not
Christianity and Judaism.
The words "not only in Judea" would imply, then, the sudden outbreak of nationalism which caused the 22 and the Jewish war. We can here form an idea of the character of the source: it was not Christian, since it presumed an
revolt
21
of Christianity after the death of Jesus; neither was it Jewish, for no Jewish document would eclipse
have called Jesus "Christ," nor would it have presented Judaism as solidary with Christianity.** The hypothesis which asserts that Tacitus could have consulted official documents preserved in the imto be passed by, perial archives can only be mentioned and there is were archives that these secret, seeing nothing to authorize our supposing that any excep"Corssen, Z.N T W. xiv, 1913, p 123 t
In this argument the hypothesis of Meyer (who thinks the details made use of by Tacitus relate to a form of confession of the Christian faith) is invalidated. Meyer thinks that Tacitus was 28
obliged to occupy himself with the Christians during his government of Asia, and that he had made an inquiry into the origin of their movement. Meyer thinks he can recognize an affinity between the
adphrase of Tacitus, "per procuratorem Ponttum Pilatum supplicto Pontius fectus" and that found in Timothy, "He bore witness before Pilate" He also supposes that Tacitus became acquainted with the Christian faith by his examination of those who were persecuted. Besides what has already been said, it must be replied against Meyer's opinion that on one side it is merely a question of a condemnation pronounced by the Procurator, and on the other side the far from being profession of faith of Jesus. The two things are equivalent. 24 These
two points have been well emphasized by BatiffoL
JESUS
42
tion to a general rule
THE NAZARENE was made
in the historian's favor.
The dependence of Tacitus upon Josephus, as supposed by Harnack, has generally been discarded, particularly by Goetz, Norden and Corssen. The fact that in the account which he gives of the Judaico Jewish war, Tacitus has utilized the De Bello of Josephus 2B is hardly conclusive, because if it were difficult for Tacitus to ignore so important a document as Josephus' account of the war, there is no reason at to suppose that Tacitus, for whom Judaism was an object of the most profound contempt, had read the had sought therein Antiquities of the Jews, and that he of the burning account his any information to complete of Rome. Between the text of Tacitus and the pasall
difsages of Josephus there are, besides, appreciable death that ferences. The text of Josephus states Jesus'
was not the cause of a cessation of faith among his that disciples; Tacitus, on the contrary, supposes death Christianity temporarily disappeared after the
of
its
founder.
Christianity
is
The judgment
upon
of Josephus
upon
the whole a favorable one; that
of Tacitus was one of supreme contempt. Finally, name as the Christ the word to Tacitus appears accept is aware of the founder of the sect, while Josephus
was called Jesus, and that the word the Christ designates dignity to which he laid claim. 26 Goetz has surmised that Tacitus obtained his in-
that this founder
formation concerning Christianity from his friend,
The two writers certainly conPliny the Younger. view template Christianity from the same point of of all characteristic fact is this but that of the police **
History, v, 13, dependi upon De Bella Jud., vi, 310-14. Goetz, Z.N.TW., xir, 1913* P* *9S-
NONCHRISTIAN TESTIMONY the Romans.
43
the other hand, between Pliny and If they are difference.
On
an important
Tacitus there
is
in
in only seeing in Christianity a super-
agreement
stition, the first considers it
calls
it
an innocent one, the second
execrable, and appears to endorse the infamous
brought against the Christians. Mgr. Batiffol, dwelling on the fact that Tacitus made use of the history of Pliny the Elder, has surmised that
accusations 27
he borrowed from
That
is
it
a supposition which in
to verify.
But one
about the Christians. its nature one is unable
his notes
fact
is
certain,
and that
is,
Tacitus
was neither Jewish nor connected which Christianity with the Christ Christian, The importance of this crucified by Pontius Pilate. observation does not require to be emphasized. In his Life of Nero (Chap, xvi) Suetonius mentions the persecution of the Christians, but he says nothing
knew of
a document, which
concerning their teachings. In the Life of Claudius to the expulsion of the (xxv, p. 4) he refers in passing Jews from Rome, to which the book of Acts also makes allusion (xviii. 2)
tumultuantes,
:
"Judaeos, impulsore Chresto assidue
expulit" (He expelled from Rome under the impulsion of Christ did not
Roma
the Jews, who 28 cease to make tumult). Is one obliged to see in "Chrestos"
29
an unknown
80
thence conJewish agitator, as do certain critics, and the Christians? to relate not does clude that the text 7
Batiffol, Orpheus et VEvangile, p. 46. Here again Hochart has in a very arbitrary way suspected a This thesis is indefensible, for no Christian Christian
28
interpolation.
would ever have expressed himself as Suetonius does. than eighty inscriptions at Rome in 29 Linck gives a list of more which the name of Chrestos is found. this interpretation Lmck, also Reinach and Couchoud, consider possible.
JESUS
44
THE NAZARENE
Or, stressing the fact that at Rome the Christians seem to have been called "Chresitanoi" and not "Chris-
must we suppose that it is Christ who is referred to, and that it was the disputes concerning Him which stirred up the Jewry of Rome and provoked the action of Claudius? The fact that Suetonius men81
tianoi,"
known personage without name quodam or aliquo 82 is favorable
tions Chrestos as a
to his
joining to the
second interpretation, and it is also the one generally 88 The text of Suetonius tells us only that accepted. the reign of Christianity had reached Rome under Claudius, and that it was considered to have connection with a personage of the name of Chrestos. But Suetonius could have believed that Chrestos
Rome
in the time of Claudius,
slightly the
Romans
84
and
this
had come proves
to
how
interested themselves at the be-
which ginning of the second century in the traditions the Christians invoked. What the Roman authors say about Jesus and Chrisamounts to very little indeed. Only the testitianity
plainly incompatible with the theory of a Christ entirely ideal. The rarity of the details
mony
of Tacitus
is
furnished by the Latin authors
One
is
aware how
is, however, striking. be in handling the one must prudent
"Chrcs"Tacitus, Annalcs, v (Codex Mediceus), has the form " In the three passages only in the New Testament where the word "Christians" is found (Acts xi 26, xxvi 28; I Pet. iv, 16), the Vaticanui first copy of the Sinaiticus has Xpijarwot. The MS. (B) hat Xpaoiwoe*. Compare with Justin (I Apol. 4), Tertullian (Apol. The form "Chrestianoi" is frequent in the inscriptions. Com3).
tianos
pare with Linck. 82
Batiffol,
Orpheus
et l'Evangile> p. 43*
"Meyer, Ursprung und Anf ,
iii,
4*3-
**PreuBchen (Chresto impuliore) supposed that some connection tradition that existed between the details given by Suetonius and the Section III.) Claudius* X, under died Chap. (See Jesus
NONCHRISTIAN TESTIMONY "argument from it
convincing
silence"
(ex silentio).
45
To make
it
are not requires two conditions which
satisfied in the case
In the
before us.
first
place the
silence must be complete, which it is not, without taking conany account of what the portion not preserved of
temporary literature might contain. In the second in other place the silence must have a real signification been have obliged words, the authors considered must to mention, had they known them, the facts of which ;
Now
they say nothing.
been
satisfied either.
second condition has not Pliny, Tacitus and Suetonius this
a contemptible agree in seeing in Christianity only them just so far as it superstition. It only interested was a cause of social disturbance. They only mention it to relate the measures directed against it, not to inquire into its origin, and still of its real or supposed founder.
less to write
the history
The importance that Christianity eventually reached leads many modern minds to commit a strange error in perspective. Because the birth of Christianity appears to them as the most pregnant fact in the whole of firstthat century history, they find it difficult to understand same the from see not did ancients the point of things
view, and only paid any attention to Christianity at the happening of certain events which had no essential
importance for
III.
There
its
development.
"AcTAPiLATi" (THE ACTS OF PILATE) is
existed in
no reason to suppose that there has ever official document which refers
Rome any
to the condemnation of Jesus by Pontius Pilate." "Concerning an examination of documents and archives which,
JESUS
46
THE NAZARENE
two passages in his Apology, middle of the second century) the addressed (toward to Antoninus the Pious, to Marcus Aurelius, to Lucius It
true that in
is
Verus, to the Senate and all the Roman people, Justin Martyr invokes (to confirm the account he gives of the Passion and miracles of Jesus) the "Acts of Pontius Pilate" (I Apol., xxxv,
48).
Tertullian also in his Apologeticum, dating from a 197, mentions a report that Pontius Pilate, already Christian in his inner conscience ("jam pro sua conscientia christianus"), had sent to Tiberius.
who
Chapter v of the Apologeticum, the document of which he does not appear to he refers to the "Acts speaks, while in another passage the as of Pilate'' pagans as an arm against forged by literature of Christianity. There has existed a whole Eusebius,
cites
know
"Acts of Pilate," which (particularly in the form it has assumed in the Gospel of Nicodemus) enjoyed 86 Critics are in agreegreat favor in the Middle Ages. ment in considering this literature, in the form in which
we know
it,
to be of a later age,
and
in
any case not
fifth century, but it is not certain that does not go farther back, since element its primitive "Acta Pilati" Epiphanius (fourth century) knew of the
older than the
(Bar., 50-51). narratives for which Justin and Tertullian invoke the authority of the "Acta Pilati," or of a report the Procurator to the Emperor, rest on evansent
The
by
according to see later
S.
Reinach,
was made
at Antioch in the time of Ignatius,
(Chap IV).
PilatusakConcerning this literature consult R. A. Lipsius (Die Harnack (Gesch. des altchnsthchen Litt. bis Eusebius), Bardenhewer (Gesch. des Altkirchhchen Litt), A. Stuelken (Pilatusakten) in Hennecke (Handbuch Neutestamentischen Apokryphen). ten),
NONCHRISTIAN TESTIMONY gelical tradition,
and merely accentuate
its
47 tendency
to portray Pilate as well disposed toward Jesus and 87 The documents desigconvinced of His innocence.
nated by them would therefore be of Christian editing, but is it certain that they were acquainted with them or had done anything more than suppose their existence ?
would not have expressed himself other than he does if he had merely heard the "Acts of Pilate" spoken of or had presumed their existence. Many writers have therefore 88considered that these "Acts" did not exist in his time, and the fact that in Justin
2) he of Quirinquotes in the same way the census registers It has been objected that ius confirms this opinion. cited the "Acts" not only to support his narra-
another passage of the Apology
(I,
xxiv, p.
Justin tion of the Passion, but also to support the account he
gives of the miracles of Jesus. it
is
thought, have
must, therefore, this document, or at any
known
something about
rate
He
contents.
its
89
But the
first
in hypothesis is excluded by the somewhat vague way which the "Acts" are cited the second is not without ;
some
difficulties.
existed,
how
is it
It
had it known should only have
If such an important document
that Justin is doubtless by mere conjecture that
by hearsay? he supposed the "Acta Pilati" must have narrated both the trial and the career of Jesus. Certain authors, however, following H. von Schu-
w Concerning Romam
ptre la Passion.
this tendency see M. Goguel, Les Chretiens ft VEma VEpoque du N.T.; Jutfs et domains dans I'htstoire de
and also 99 This is the opinion of Lipsius, Harnack, Bardenhewer, of Mgr. Batiffol. sestuelken (Handbuch).
JESUS
48
THE NAZARENE
40
have thought that a trace of the primary elements of the "Acta Pilati" was to be found prior
bcrt,
to Justin's period. They rest their case
upon the fact that the Gospel of Peter and Justin (I ApoL, xxxv) state that, to mock Him, Jesus was made to seat Himself in a chair, and 41 invited to act as a Judge. Seeing that the hypothesis of a direct connection between the Gospel of Peter and
Justin encounters certain difficulties, it has been supposed that both were dependent upon a common source. But even if this were so, there is nothing to prove that this source
was anything other than a mere extra-canon-
ical tradition.
that he regards Tertullian, Harnack considers in found he of what use made has simply Justin, and
As
work which suggested the composition Df the letter from Pilate to the Emperor which is found 42 in Chapters xl-xlii of the Acts of Peter and Paul.
that
The
it
is
his
words of this letter reveal, indeed, its polemand show that it must have been comof by Eusebius. piled to combat the pagan Acts spoken Nevertheless, Justin and Tertullian do not invoke the testimony of Pilate in reference to the same facts, last
ical character,
and the document is presented by Justin as the acts, and by Tertullian as a letter of Pilate to the Emperor. Tertullian, for his part, only makes one allusion, somewhat vague, to the document, and he does not know it *
H. von Schubert, pit ^Composition det pseudopetrinischen Evan-
feUenjragmtnts. 41 There is no trace of any
men
episode in the canonical Gospels
verb a transiunless, perhaps, in John xix. 13, if there is given to the tive sense. But even thus the scene would have quite another character than in Justin and the Gospel of Peter.
**ActaApQitolorum Apocrypha
(edition Lipsius
and Bonnet, 1891).
NONCHRISTIAN TESTIMONY At
at first-hand. if
the most he has heard
It
spoken
49 of,
he does not altogether guess at its existence. As neither Origen nor Eusebius make any allusion
to the "Acts of Pilate,"
the
work
48
it
may be
considered that
did not exist in their time.
What is the interpretation of this absence of testimony from Pilate concerning the punishment of Jesus? For M. Salomon Reinach it is decisive :
official report, while there ought to "The conclusion which is he been have one," says. forced upon one is assuredly not favorable to the his-
"There was no
toricity of the Passion."
44
So radical a conclusion appears to us unwarranted. From the fact that spurious "Acta Pilati" have been fabricated as well by Christians as it does not follow that an authentic
The
by their opponents, work never existed.
simply that these "Acts," if they existed, were not at the disposal of those whose interknow that the archives est it was to consult them. conclusion
is
We
of the emperors were not accessible to the Senate. Tacitus himself, notwithstanding his relations with Neva and Trajan, seems to have been unable to obtain 45 Still less reason existed to permit access to them.
them by private persons, and Christian apoloexamination of them. If their gists could make no and authorized to opponents had been more favored remained which fruitless, they would make researches access to
*
The
two men is important owing to their vast That of Eusebius is particularly significant. There are three passages in his Ecclesiastical History where it was silence of these
erudition. at least
difficult to
5,
9 (concerning Pilate),
ii,
5-7 (quoting the pagan "Acta Pilati"), propos de la curiositt de Tibere. Reinach)
Apology), 44 S.
4iad he known the a (quoting Tertuliian'i
avoid mention of the "Acta Pilati"
work. These are: ix.
A
* 8 Ph. Fabia, Li* Sources
de Tacite,
p.
3**
JESUS
50
THE NAZARENE
have made a point about it in their polemic. Because an official document has not been produced, no one is authorized to conclude that it could not have existed.
were proved that no report was made by Pilate to Tiberius, what would be the significance of this fact? Justin, who had presumed the existence of a report, says M. Salomon Reinach, was in a better But, even
if it
are to estimate the obligations of a
position than
we
Procurator.
But the death of Jesus was
in his eyes
an event of such capital importance that it was difficult for him to see that for Pilate it may only have been an incident without importance.
Besides, Justin is of Pilate a witness
influenced by the tendency to make favorable to Jesus and opposed to the Jews.
thing that
we know
concerning Pilate
as a cruel and unscrupulous man, for
whom
of those under his jurisdiction had but
tation.
resisted
Jesus was
him
the lives
little
impor-
sending to execution or became a pretext for agi-
tance; he had no hesitation
whomsoever
Every-
shows him to us
in
of his certainly not the sole victim To condemn to death
procedure of summary justice. was for him merely an act of administrative routine. Is it to be supposed that in each particular case he considered it necessary to send a report to the Emto his enemies by peror, and in so doing furnish arms ? allowing them to accuse him of cruelty and injustice
No
complete silence of furJosephus, or the rarity and paucity of the details nished by the Latin historians, does the absence of
more than
the
almost
any report from Pilate to the Emperor constitute an objection against the historical character of Jesus.
CHAPTER
III
HYPOTHESIS OF A PRE-CHRISTIANITY JESUS THE NAZARENE
I.
DOES
the
name of Jesus
the
or rather do
Nazarene
the two names associated in this expression an historical person or the hero of a cult?
designate Does the
signify "Saviour Protector," and be considered as a divine name of similar character to Zeus Xenios, Hermes Psychopompos, or Jahveh Sabaoth? "There is every reason to think,
term
should
Nazarene it
1 '
writes Drews, "that the name of Joshua or Jesus was that under which the expected Messiah was worshiped in certain
Jewish sects."
*
Upon
examination the argu-
ments offered in support of this opinion seem somewhat 2 shallow. Robertson finds in the worship of Jesus a
new form of
the old
Ephraim
cult of
Joshua, a solar
A trace
of this cult is to be found in a pasof the prophet Zechariah, where the sage in the book of the high priest Joshua appears before the Angel divinity.
Eternal,
who
causes
him
to take off his soiled garments
He
receives this promise : "If thou wilt walk in ways, and if thou wilt keep house and charge, then shalt thou also judge
and put on
festal clothing.
My
My
My
courts" (Zech. Hi. 7). Jesus was a divine name, Jesus the Lord was God, considered in His essential character as liberator, healer, guardian,
shalt also keep
1
a
My
Drews, Die Chnstusmythe, Robertson,
A
i.
p. 23.
Short History of Christianity, p. 5*
8.
JESUS
52
and saviour.
"Thou
Is
shalt call
His people from It
is
it
THE NAZAREKE not said, indeed, in Matt. i. 21: Jesus, for He shall save
His name
their sins ?"
8
unnecessary to inquire
if
Joshua, at a certain to note that at
period, was a solar divinity; the epoch with which we are concerned, the Jews who read his history in the sixth book of the Bible saw in it suffices
successor of Moses, and the
him a national hero, the continuator of his work.
He
was one of the most
popular heroes in Israelitish history, as is proved by the number of persons named after him, and of whom there is no temptation to make a mythical being or a divine hero.
The high
priest Joshua,
mentioned by
Zechariah, is also an historical personage; so little is he to be identified with Messiah that he receives the promise of the coming of the latter (Zech. iii. 9). Robertson and Drews also find mention of a preChristian Jesus in the magic papyrus of the BiblioU I adjure theque Nationale, where occurs the formula, thee by the
God of the Hebrews,
Jesus." This papyrus,
which is not earlier than the fourth century of our era, doubtless reproduce a more ancient formula there
may
;
is nothing, however, to authorize us to date it so far back as the mythologists would like. The form of words must doubtless be attributed to a pagan. It
merely proves that the name of Jesus was to have great power, a thing which is explained by the in primitive Christiangreat part played by exorcism have readily formulas The magical pagan ity.* 5 That does not adopted Jewish and Christian names. considered
*
"Jesus" signifies "Jahveh aids" Job. Weiss, Jesus von Nazareth, p. 19. 'Deissmann, Licht vom Often, Tubingen, 1909*
4
A PRE-CHRISTIANITY
53
6
prove as Reitzenstein remarks, that their authors were really acquainted with and understood Judaism or This is proved, for instance, in a text Christianity. 7 cited by Dieterich, in which Abraham, Isaac and Jacob are taken to be names for the God of Israel. is nothing to authorize us to consider the of name Jesus as a divine name, is the same the case with the designation "Nazarene" which accompanies Outside the New Testament, no text attests the it?
If there
Nazareth. Neither the Old Testament, nor Josephus, nor the Talmud mention it, but it is not legitimate to conclude existence
in
of a village
Galilee
8
called
and as the mythas proved, that Nazareth ologists willingly suppose fiction. We know from Josephus is only a geographical that Galilee was densely populated, and that it boasted
from
204
this silence, as
villages
and 15
Cheyne
does,
fortified towns.
a small part of these
219
9
localities,
We
only
and even
know if
the
given by Josephus were exaggerated, many Galilean townships would not be mentioned in any 10 There is nothing astonishing in the supposition text. figures
that
Nazareth u a
should be
T
among
village of very trifling importance,
the number.
12
Reitzenstein, Polmandres, Leipzig, 1904. Dieterich, Abraxas, Leipzig, 1891.
s
article in Encyclop. Biblica, Josephus, Vila, par 235.
Cheyne,
iii,
"Nazareth."
Meyer, Ursprung und Anf , iii. iiWellhausen has suggested that the word Nazareth designates in i Galilee in the form Gennesar (Garden of Nesar), met with Mace. ii. 67, Matt. xiv. 34, Mark vi. 53- The similarity of Matt, and Nazarene. xxvi. 69 and 71 proves the equivalence of Galilean 10
This ingenious hypothesis collides with the fact that if Galilee wai or Nazareth, it is very commonly designated by the word Nazar it is nowhere clearly found. fact that later tradition was acquainted with
strange that 12
The
Nazareth proves
JESUS
54
The
THE NAZARENE
fact that evangelical tradition represents Jesus
1S coming from Nazareth is far from being without According to Messianic dogma the Messignificance. siah was to be born at Bethlehem, and the Gospels of Matthew and Luke in different ways, which are mutu-
as
14
keep to this postulate. have created the fact not would Christian tradition
to ally irreconcilable, strive
destined to cause
it
so
much embarrassment,
that of
15
the birth of Jesus at Nazareth. The explanations of the term
Nazarene
offered
by This
the mythologists scarcely seem probable term, which constitutes the most ancient designation of the Christians, is derived, according to W. B. Smith, either.
from the root NSR, which is found sixty-three times in the Old Testament in the sense of protector and ancient still, for the Babyguardian. It is even more lonian term Na-Sa-Ru is met with seven times in the code of Hammurabi. The Syrian form Nasaryu, in to be recognized the divine name Yah, signi"God is Protector." It is not a term of geographi-
which fies
is
This hypothesis could some real proofs of only be entertained if there were the existence of a pre-Christian sect of Nazarenes.
cal origin,
but a cultural name.
has existed, nothing. So soon as one was persuaded that the place failure to find it again was impossible. is Matt xxi. n, Mark i 9, John i. 45, Acts x 38 The comparison between Mark vi. i and Luke iv. 16 shows that Nazareth was considered to be the birthplace of Jesus 14 Matt ii. 13-23 states that the family of Jesus was originally settled at Bethlehem, and returned after the flight to Egypt to lire in Nazareth to escape the jurisdiction of Archelaus, grandson of Herod.
Luke ii. 1-7 states that Jesus was born during a journey of his parents to Jerusalem on the occasion of the census made by Quirinius. 15 The birth of Jesus in Galilee constituted one of the Jewish objections to his Messiahship.
Cp. John
yii. 41.
A PRE-CHRISTIANITY
55
indications which the mythologists invoke cannot take the place of these. There is in the Gospel of Matthew a passage which puzzles interpreters. After the death of Herod, Joseph and Mary leave Egypt to
The
settle in
The
Nazareth of
Galilee.
evangelist says that this was "that it might be which was spoken by the prophets he shall
fulfilled
be called a Nazarene" (Matt ii. 23). It is impossible to identify with certitude the prophecy here alluded to, and if it be desired to avoid recourse to the gratuitous hypothesis of the use of some apocryphal work which has not been preserved, it is necessary to suppose that the evangelist connects the word Nazarene
with some passage of Scripture containing a word from 16 the same root or having some assonance with it. There would be here a play on the words which we should (owing to its obscurity) be unable to understand.
of the
One cannot suppose that this is the true origin word Nazarene. Rather would it be incumbent
to suppose an assimilation
who
worked out by Matthew,
always aims at showing in the Gospel history the
fulfillment of prophecy.
The word Nazarene to John the Baptist and
was
certainly
in
contains perhaps an allusion his disciples,
relation
at the
with
whom
Jesus beginning of His
It is well-known that the ministry. tion represents Jesus as an apostate
Mandaean tradifrom the Baptist
16 H. and F Nicolardot (Procfdtt J Holtzmann (Die Synoptiker) de redaction des trois premiers evangelistes) think of Es. ri. i, in which the Messiah is called "Nfcser" (offspring). It is impossible the to connect the word Nazarene with the notion of the sect for Christian tradition (Matt. xi. 18, 19; Luke vii. 33, 34? Mark ii. 18has preserved a clear memory that Jesus was not an ascetic
20, etc.) like John the Baptist.
JESUS
56 community.
THE NAZARENE
Thus would be explained
the Christians were
the fact that
also called Nazarenes, while
it
would not be at all natural to have designated them as people of Nazareth because their master was a 17
native of this village. But the problem of Nazareth
is
still
not solved in
this way. There occur in the New Testament the two 18 W. B. Smith 19 forms, Nazarenos and Nazoraios. considers these equivalent, and supports his opinion by the coexistence of the two forms, Essenes and Es-
senians.
not conclusive, for the two forms do not only differ in their termination, but also in the If the form Nazaquantity of the second syllable.
The analogy
is
20
renos can be philologically derived from Nazareth, the same does not hold for Nazoraios, which must
have another
origin.
to Jesus, simplest explanation is that, as applied the term Nazarenos related to his native village, and that the association with the word Nazoraios, by
The
which name the called,
disciples of
John the Baptist were
caused the Christians to be called Nazarenes.
Wetter, L'Arritrc plan hist, du Chnsttanisme primttif; R H.L.R., 1922; Wellhausen, Das Evangellum Matthan, Berlin, 1904, p 1421 8 The first is found in Mark i. 24, x. 47 *iv. 6 7 *vi. 6; Luke The second in Mark ii 23; Luke xvni. 37; ir. 34 and xxiv 19 xviii 5*7 and xix. 19; and Acts ii. 22, in. 6, iv. 10, vi. 14, xxii 8, *T
John
There is a certain variation in the manuscripts. The 5, xxvi. 9. the testimony of the book duality of form is, however, certain, and of Acts proves that it is the form "Nazarcne" which prevailed. 19 Smith, D. vorchr. Jesut, p. 53. xxiv.
*The correctness of the derivation (Nazarenos) if admitted by In the New Testament Meyer, who cites the opinion of Lidzbarski are to be found the farms, widely divergent, as follows: Nazara, it Nazarat, Nazaret, Nazareth, etc. In the oldest manuscript there no consistent spelling.
A PRE-CHRISTIANITY
57
that they were was desired to emphasi the from Baptist community. only apostates
In this It
it
seems very
likely indeed that at first the Chris-
and and Nazarene names the that and later on "saints," Christian were given to them by their opponents. tians called themselves "disciples" or "brothers,"
OF A SECT OF PRE-CHRISTIAN NAZARENES, WORSHIPERS OF JESUS
THE HYPOTHESIS
II.
The
explanation which
the words
we propose of
Nazarene and Nazarenian would have no import if it were possible to prove the existence of a pre-Christian Nazarenes, worshipers of Jesus, as
sect of
is
main-
by W. B. Smith, who entitles one The of his books pre-Christian Jesus. The first proof alleged in favor of the existence of 21 who this sect is based upon the hymn of the Naasseni,
tained, in particular
date back to the most remote antiquity and attest the 22 cult of a celestial Jesus. The subject is the Soul who has quitted the Kingdom of Light and groans in suffering and tears. Lost in a 23 labyrinth, vainly escape is sought. Father! this tempted "Then Jesus said: 'Behold, being who, far from Thy influence, wanders miserably on earth. He longs to fly from bitter chaos, but he
O
knows not how send
Me
hands, 21
;
to ascend.
For his
may descend with the may traverse the aeons, that
that I
that I
O Father in My seals !
salvation,
Preserved by Hippolytus, Philosophoumena, v. and Drews.
2*
I
may open
xo. 2.
** Smith *8
The text is Dot absolutely certain. >* It is often a question of seals with the Gnostics, particularly in
the Pistis Sophia.
JESUS
58
THE NAZARENE
may reveal unto him the essence of unto him the mystery of the holy announce God, and " life which is called the gnosis. According to the mythologists, the Jesus of this
the mysteries, that I
1
contact with Christianity, and was a Being to have been entirely celestial. Their conclusion seems drawn with some precipitation. Nothing authorizes
hymn had no
us to date the Naasseni
hymn before
the Christian era.
has shown that the Naassenes had made Hilgenfeld use of the epistles of Paul and of the fourth Gospel. In the form known to us, and whatever its distant 26
doctrine betrays the origins may be, the Naasseni 28 therefore be unIt would influence of Christianity. able to prove the existence of a pre-Christian cult of This argument is strengthened by the conJesus. sideration that, following a very judicious remark of Bousset, it is not certain that in the hymn preserved
not proceed by Hippolytus the name of Jesus may
For a retouching of a corruption of the text. at the beginning of the hymn there is presented the "Nous" along with Chaos, and the Soul to be In these conditions the decisive argument saved.
from
that the mythologists thought they possessed disappears.
Epiphanius (H#r. } xviii) mentions among the Jewish heresies a sect of Nazarenes, and what he says about
it
does not permit him to attribute a Christian As he does not state that it was deit.
character to
veloped only after Christianity, this would prove, a preaccording to Smith, that the Nazarenes were doubtless which from Christian sect Christianity Hilgenfeld, Die Ketzerfetch, des Vrchristcntums. *'Reitzcnftein, Poimandret, p. 81.
A PRE-CHRISTIANITY
59
27
And against this conclusion, accordnot be possible to urge as arguit would to him, ing students of heresy, who, being other ment the silence of
adopted much.
less
honest and
naive than Epiphanius, saw
less
how
dangerous to the official Church doctrine was the existence of these Nazarenes, and kept a discreet silence 28
There is a singular lack of proporthe statements of Epiphanius and the tion between conclusions which he claims to deduce from them. An
concerning them.
entire historical construction of the greatest importance, which would overthrow many facts apparently solidly established, rests
upon one
single testimony
that of a man who does not always show himself well informed, and who frequently has not made the most 29
If at his disposal. judicious use of the information we of we scrutinize closely the testimony Epiphanius, find that concerning these Nazarenes he appears to
know nothing more than
the name; it is noteworthy that he says nothing which attributes to them a worship 80 All that there is in common between them of Jesus.
and the Christians conclusion to be
show what would be
a
it
To
name
drawn from
that
sary to
is
only. this fact
it
permit any
would be
neces-
cannot be a simple coincidence, or,
still
more probable, some confusion
by Epiphanius or by the author of whom he makes use. Now this proof has not been furnished.
made
7
28
w
either
D. vorchr. Jesus, pp. 56, 57. Smith, D. vorchr. Jesus, p 64. . The . "His criticism is not sound.
Smith,
moment he leaves the reinformation should be checked; it is gion of contemporary facts his temconfused and lacks precision. He had a relatively uncritical Patrologie, 1918, acuteness." Tixeront, intellectual without perament p. 253-
.
Weiss, Jesus von Nazareth; Wmdisch, Der geschichtliche
Jesus (Th. R.).
6o
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
the contrary, two scholars, Schmidtke and Bousset, have proposed a simple and plausible explanation of the testimony of Epiphanius. There might, perhaps, be certain reservations to make on some details of their
On
does not appear a matter of doubt that they are well founded, and that they have consequently caused the disaphispearance of the pre-Christian Nazarenes from
main
theories, but in their
outlines
it
tory.
In the course of his research in Judeo-Christianity 81 and the Jewish Christians, Schmidtke has proved that all the narratives found in the writings of the Fathers of the Church concerning a Judeo-Christian sect going under the name of Nazarenes and not under the usual name of Ebionites originate with Appollinarius of
Laodicea (310-90). The Nazarene sect really existed at Beroe in Syria it was strictly Judeo-Christian, and used an Aramaic gospel, some fragments of which are preserved, and which seems to have been a translation of the Gospel of Matthew slightly revised. Con;
cerning these Nazarene Christians, Epiphanius speaks in the twenty-ninth chapter, according to Appollinarius. The details he concerning them seem worthy of gives
belief.
chapter that he speaks Nazarenes. Schmidtke says that
It is in the eighteenth
of the pre-Christian here he depends both upon Hippolytus and a list of 82 He believes that Epiphanius heretical Jewish sects. has substituted the Nazarenes for the Ebionites. 81 Schmidtke, Neue Fragment* und Untfrsuchungen chnstlichcn Evangclien, xxxvii, 1911, Leipzig.
**Id.,
tb., p.
199-
He
88
vu dtr Juden-
..
.
writes their name with a sigma and not with a zeta, to distinfrom the Nazarene Christians, just as he distinguishes them guish between the Eastmans and the Osseniant.
He
A PRE-CHRISTIANITY even believes that
in his
work, as
first
61
sketched out,
Epiphanius had called them Ebionites.
The
peculiarities of those
which he describes in
Chapter xxx correspond exactly, in fact, with the account given of the Nazarenes in Chapter xviii. Epiphanius was misled in taking for a Jewish sect the Nazarenes, whom the Jews in their daily prayer cursed under the name of Nozrim simultaneously with the heretics
(Minim). 85
84
accepts the argument of Schmidtke in its generality, and who believes that he has definitely to the enigma, supposes that in the found the
Bousset,
who
key
source of which he makes use concerning the Nazarenes, Epiphanius had only found some geographical details about the place in which the sect was met with,
and that in order to write his account he had utilized, from what he knew about the Judeo-Christian groups, character. everything which had not a Christian Bousset supposes that the Nazarenes were mentioned of Jewish heresies utilized by different The Jewish author who had furnished it Fathers. mentioned in fact Christianity as among the heresies the
in
list
to be rejected. In these circumstances one has no choice but to endorse the conclusion reached by Bousset in these
terms: "The pre-Christian Nazarenes of Epiphanius are definitely consigned to the domain of error and in the text s* The twelfth request of the "Schemon* Esre" is given discovered in the synagogue of Cairo and published in 1897: "May there be no hope for the apostates! Mayest Thou, in our time, anniMay the Christians (Nozrim) hilate the domination of the insolent! and the heretics (Minim) be suddenly annihilated! May they be no Praised be Jahveh, who bring! longer written in the book of life' low the insolent!" (Strack, Jesus die Htretiker, etc.) 95
Bousset, Tk. Rundschau, xir, 1911.
62
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
misunderstanding, and it is to be hoped that they will forever disappear from the arsenal of proofs invoked 8* in support of a pre-Christian cult of Jesus." But even when deprived of the hymn of the Naasseni
and the Nazarene sect the mythologists are not disarmed there remain for them the positive indications of the existence of a pre-Christian Jesus which they think they find in the New Testament itself. The first of these is the passage in the book of Acts which refers to Apollos. For Smith this text is ;
87
the most valuable of ancient Christian literature. read in Acts xviii. 24-26: "And a certain Jew
We
Apollos, born at Alexandria, an eloquent man and mighty in the Scriptures, came to Ephesus. This man was instructed in the way of the Lord, and being
named
as
he spake and taught diligently the the baptism of things concerning Jesus, knowing only in the synagogue, to he speak boldly began John. And had heard, they whom, when Aquila and Priscilla took him unto them and expounded unto him the way fervent in spirit
God more
of
perfectly."
this text, thinks Smith, that Apollos about knew nothing Jesus, otherwise he ought to have known everything, including the doctrine of baptism. u This ignorance did not hinder his preaching that
It follows
from
which concerned Jesus." therefore," writes Smith, "as clear as the noonwords can have no relation day sun that this form of It must mean the doctrine to the history of Jesus." a doctrine which a man who knew concerning Jesus "It
is
Bou9sct, 7
Th Rundschau,
xiv,
19",
P- 3*i.
Smith, D. vorchr. Jew, p. 7. The text is translatable in two different ways.
A PRE-CHRISTIANITY
63
nothing about an historical Jesus could not only proThis text is therefore for the mythfess, but preach. ologists
timable diamond." But,
is
(the expression
when
again Smith's)
"an
ines-
89
closely examined, the passage may not all the significance attributed to it, or,
perhaps have to put it more precisely, its value and significance may have a quite other character. Whatever the origin of the reference used by the editor of the Acts may be,
we
are not certain
we know
its
original purport.
It
is possible, indeed, that the form "that which concerned of the editor, and Jesus" may be put to the account 510
merely expresses the belief that the religious attitude of Apollos, when he arrived at Ephesus, fitted him to become a Christian. Prisciila and Aquila that
it
doubtless recognized in the ardent and eloquent Messianist a man who would be able to render eminent
and they succeeded in gaining him over to their cause. But we have no wish to insist on this interpretation, which to a certain extent is service to their faith,
conjecture. a postulate which exegesis of Smith rests upon This is in contradiction with certain historical data. of Christian doctrine the baptism, postulate is that the Baptist, is an essential of that to John opposed element in the history of Jesus in that he who ignores
The
the Christian baptism must perforce ignore all the If at the opening of His ministry evangelical history.
22 and
John Jesus (as shown administered a baptism in every in
of John the Baptist,
iii.
He
way
iv.
i)
may have
identical with that
seems to have relinquished
Smith, D. vorckr. Jesus, pp. Meyer, Ursprung und Anf.,
7-9. iii,
p.
na.
it
JESUS
64
in the sequel.
No
41
THE NAZARENE text attributes the institution of
when acbaptism to Jesus during His ministry, and in coverhad count is taken of the interest the Church her rites, it is ing with the Master's own authority pass over this extremely significant alone (xxviii. 19, 20) relates that to His disciples at the moment said risen again, Jesus, he was to leave them "All power has been given to in the heavens and in earth. Go ye therefore and impossible
to
Matthew
silence.
:
Me
teach" (literally "make disciples") "all nations, bapthe Son, and the tizing them in the name of the Father,
Holy
Spirit."
42 contains any equivalent Neither Luke nor John of this narrative, which thus appears as relatively recent. The passage in Matthew has for its object to
upon the authority of the resurrected Christ
support,
Christ as Spirit), the institution of baptism This reveals nothing as as practised by the Church. to the real origin of the rite, but merely shows that it 43 In has no place in the historical mission of Jesus. it was that understood is these circumstances it easily not immediately introduced in all the Christian com(that
is,
The
Paul (i Cor. vii. 14), without making any allusion to baptism, admits that the that is, belong to children of Christians are saints born of parents themare because they God,
munities.
fact that
uniquely
little belief that baptism goes back to Jesus, that Gospel after quoting a statement that Jesus had baptized, itself corrects this (John iv. 2) to the * 2 The testimony of Mark is lacking on this point, owing The nonauthentic end of Mark, mutilation of the end of his book. which appears not to be anterior to the second century, gives (xvi. the practice of 16) something equivalent, with this particularity, that
Tradition has so
the
fourth
baptism *8
is
only supposed, but not directly attributed to institution.
Meyer, Ursprung und Anf.,
iii,
p. 245.
A PRE-CHRISTIANITY
65
shows that the baptism of children was unknown in the Pauline communities, and it allows us to suppose that the rite was only practised for those who entered the Church, not for those born in it. It selves saints
not have been in use at the beginning in the Jerusalem community. Doubtless the accounts in the 44 Acts on several occasions speak of baptism, but their
may
book testimony is not conclusive, for the editor of this has naively projected into the primitive community the situation which existed in the Church of his time. The use of baptism might have arisen, as Bousset supposes, not in the midst of the Palestine Community, but perin the Diaspora at Antioch, in analogy with the
haps
A
teaching which was Jewish baptism for proselytes. historical the with ministry of intimately connected this ministry, might Jesus, and based upon memoirs of the of known have baptism of John. only very easily It exegesis of Smith evokes another objection. is in no way proved that the expression "that which must be understood in the sense of concerned
The
Jesus" "the doctrine concerning Jesus." Smith himself recog45 "the nizes that the Greek words used may signify that considers he but story told concerning someone," the three passages of the New Testament (outside of the Acts) where this form of words is found refer to the doctrine and not to the story of Jesus, or at least to Acts xxviii. 31, they originally did so. According in Rome, in during his two years of captivity passed his own hired house, Paul taught freely "that which concerned the Lord Jesus Christ." Paul did not tell
histories to the
"Acti
ii.
*
is
Thi
Romans; he preached
the Gospel to
l8 > * 4*38-41; viii. 12, 13, 16, 3$, 3J in Acts xxviii. 15. evidently the meaning of the phrase
JESUS
66
THE NAZARENE
it down as a principle that the Pauline doctrine a concerning Jesus which contains Gospel no historical element is to suppose, as resolved in favor
them. But to lay is
of the mythological theories, the very question in the Romans, as dispute. In the teaching imparted to in that which had been given to the Galatians (iii. i), the crucifixion of an historical personage was^he starting-point of the Pauline preaching. The two passages in which is found the phrase "that
which concerned Jesus" are story of the
woman
In the
characteristic.
with the issue of blood
Mark
it: "Having heard the things concerning Jesus, in the crowd behind and touched His garcame she ment; for, said she, if I but touch His garment I shall
has
be made whole.'
1
the things concerning Jesus" could only mean sufferer hope story of His miracles, which made the that she also would be cured. Smith is certainly com-
"The
is indeed the meaning pelled to recognize that such of the passage, but he attempts to put aside its evidence by maintaining that it must be attributed to some
Mark. 46
had been primarily a question of healing, he thinks, the woman would not have said "I shall be saved," but "I shall be cured." This observation takes no account of the fact that in many "to be saved" has exactly the same meaning reviser of
passages as "to be healed"
If
it
(Mark
v. 23, vi.
56; Luke
viii.
36-
50). here no impropriety of expression, since, of the period, the according to the current conception disease was caused by the action of a demon, from
There
1* lttttk
is
D, wrchr,
Jesui.
A PRE-CHRISTIANITY whom healed.
67
the sufferer must be delivered in order to be The phrase attributed to the woman "I shall
be saved" does not therefore prove that it was origother than healing. inally a question of anything Smith also supposes that the words "having learned that which concerned Jesus" cannot belong to the either primitive text because they have no equivalent
or Luke. But these two evangelists give of the passage considerably briefer than a recension that of Mark. The comparison of the three narratives leads one
in
Matthew
(as is fairly often the case) there is an abbreviation of the account by Matthew and Luke,
to think that
and not
a
development by Mark.
That which
is
found,
indeed, only in his narrative is too insignificant to induce us to find a reason for its addition, while the single desire to condense
a narrative
fairly lengthy
It explain the form they have adopted. subordia to attribute therefore not possible to
suffices to is
nate editor the phrase "that which concerned Jesus" as interpreted in the sense "that which Jesus had
done."
The passage in Luke xxiv. 19 is not less significant. The story is well known of the two disciples who the while day after the death of Jesus reach Emmaus talking over what had just taken place. as yet, comes Jesus, whom they do not recognize asks them He road. same the takes and up to them them reof One what they have been talking about. a stranger in Jerusalem plies: "You must indeed be has of what not to be aware happened in these last few days ... the matter concerning Jesus of Nazareth.
11
68
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
The matter concerning Jesus of Nazareth can only be the condemnation and execution of the prophet in whom they had placed their hopes. To understand the phrase as referring to some doctrine about Jesus, a divine Being, would be to give it no meaning at all,
has obliged to suppose that the passage undergone a radical revision. But this is a conjecture which rests nothing, and is only put forward for so Smith
is
upon
the exigencies of the case. The expression "that which concerns Jesus" refers, then, to the story, or certain portions of the story, of
no reason to give to this expression any other meaning than in Acts xviii. 25. We must not, then, see in Apollos a Jew who teaches a form of doc-
Jesus.
There
is
which ignores the Gospel hisof baptism. tory, but a Christian who knows nothing of in"diamond the of If Smith is thus deprived estimable value," the stones which he has attempted trine concerning Jesus
to group around of their value.
it
We
to
make
a tiara lose very
much
are not, however, for that reason 47
excused from examining them. There is in the first place the case of Simon the It is
Magician.
narrated in Acts
viii.
9-13 that when
he met a magician Philip came to evangelize Samaria, named Simon, enjoying great authority over the popuconsidered him the "great power of God." Like other Samaritans, Simon was converted by the little further on it is narrated preaching of Philip. that when, after the arrival of Peter and John, Simon
lation,
who
A
learned that by the laying on of hands the apostles 47
We
pass
Ephesus, and
over for the moment the case of the shall deal with
it
further on.
dasciples
of
A PRE-CHRISTIANITY conferred the
Holy
Spirit,
69
he offered money to Peter
Peter rejected his proto receive the same power. a malediction posal with indignation, and pronounces the apostles to pray for asks then Simon him. upon him, so that his sin may be pardoned (viii. 18-24). The rapidity of the conversion of Simon and the explained, for Smith, by the fact that similar to they were already won over to ideas very those preached by Philip. They were therefore Christians, they were strangers to the tradition
Samaritans
which
is
although it is claimed
48
Jesus.
connected with an historical
is
Smith deduces here from the text something
what it contains. The point is the conversion of Simon and the Samaritans to the gospel 9 preached by Philip,* and not the fusion of a group of Simon's followers with the Church which Philip a fusion which would have been deterrepresented mined by recognition of the fact that at bottom the quite other than
ideas professed by each side were the same. There are in the second portion of the narrative
about Simon
many
suspicious elements.
In
it is
found
a theory concerning the apostolate and the laying on of hands which is not a primitive one, and it is possible to
discern, with
an apologetic
fiction
M. Meyer and M.
which shows
how
50
Alfaric,
the Christian
missionaries anticipated the conversion of the Simonian community and prefaced it by that of Simon him48
Smith, D. vorchr Jesus, p
n.
nothing to show that this conversion was more rapid than that of pagans unacquainted with any ideas analogous to those 49
There
is
of the Christians.
Chnstianumt Meyer, Ursprung and Anf , hi; Prosper Alfaric, tt
Gnosttcisme (Rev. Hist., 19*4)-
THE NAZARENE
JESUS
70
The
self.
portion of the narrative has quite Samaria, at
first
another value.
It reveals the existence in
the time of the
first
mission, of a pre-Christian Gnos-
was not without sensible influence 51 But this Christian thought. of on the development Simonian Gnosticism, so far as we can form an idea
ticism which perhaps
not the pre-Christian doctrine that the mythin worship paid to ologists imagine, which consisted a divine personage. All that we know concerning the
of
it,
is
Simonian Gnosticism
is
idea of the incarnation in
its
a man, Simon, of the "great
power of God."
B2
This
an extremely valuable indication that certain theorists ought not to lose sight of
shows
and
the idea of a ciple
is
it
human being
incarnated
was not
idea in the environment
in
whom
a divine prin-
any way a strange which Christianity was
in
in
born.
Neither do we recognize an adept of pre-Christianity in the magician Elymas, or Bar-Jesus, a Jewish false in the coterie which prophet whom Paul met at Paphos xiii. Paulus 6-12). Smith surrounded Sergius (Acts of "servant sense interprets the name Bar-Jesus in the M a sense which would be or worshiper of Jesus" of name Jesus was not attested as plausible if the
one
in current use.
It
is
only by an argument in a "Bar-Jesus"
vicious circle, in postulating a priori that
formed from a divine name, that it is possible to find in the episode an argument to support a pre-
is
Christian worship of Jesus. Alfaric, Rev. Hist., cxlv, 19*4-
M It
seems to us not possible to admit, as some have supposed, that Simon could have been influenced by the teaching of Jesus, as Meyer thinks, and still less that of Paulinism, as Harnack admits, 01 Smith, D. vorchr. Jesus, p. 16.
A PRE-CHRISTIANITY Smith consul,
71
54
also lays emphasis on the fact that the pronot yet initiated into the preaching of the
to hear from them "the word of God" apostles, asks that the terms of the (Acts xiii. 7). It is very evident
narrative must be put to the editor's credit. If the proconsul really expressed the wish to hear Paul and
Barnabas,
it
was not because he saw
in
known
them the
to him, but
preachers of a doctrine already because they presented themselves as bearers of a divine message. The case of the exorcists of
xix.
13not has also the stress, on which lay mythologists 20), it. to attribute the significance they Impressed by the miracles of Paul at Ephesus, seven Jewish exorcists, sons of a priest named Skeuas, attempted to make use of the same formula used successfully by the apostle, and adjured the spirits saying: "I adjure you by Jesus, whom Paul preaches." But the spirit answered them: " but who are ye? Jesus I know, and Paul I know, And the one possessed fell upon the exorcists and Ephesus (Acts
1'
maltreated them."
The
fact
is
without significance as
cult of Jesus. regards the existence of a pre-Christian It is merely a case of the imitation by outsiders of a formula of exorcism whose efficacy has been observed. This, at any rate, is so in the text as we read it, and
nothing authorizes us to suppose that
it
was otherwise
According to the mythologists, Chrishad no unique source from which it was spread,
in the original.
tianity
as Jerusalem. *
Id
>
ib
It
had several simultaneous sources.
p, 22.
There; arc certain incoherences in the account. Sometimes it ia a This appears to of several. question of one demoniac, sometimes arise from the fusion of two parallel accounts, and is without im*B
portance.
JESUS
7a
THE NAZARENE
Afterwards the memory of
this
fact
was
lost,
and
of Jesus. Christianity was connected with the preaching However, it may still be recognized that Cyprus and
was Cyrenaica were centers from which Christianity of Jerusalem. According spread, entirely independent to Acts xi. 20 it was the men of Cyprus and Cyrene who were the first (at Antioch) to preach the gospel 66 But we know (see Acts iv. 36) that to the pagans. a Cypriote, destined later to play an important part at Antioch, was converted to the gospel at Jerusalem, and we learn in the book of Acts (vi. 9) that persons 87 and belonging to the synagogue of the Freedmen,
and Asia, raised viopeople from Cyrene, Alexandria lent opposition against Stephen, which proves that the gospel had been preached by him in this synagogue. There is therefore no reason to suppose that it was anywhere other than in Jerusalem, or in the communities which grew out of that of Jerusalem, that the an active Cypriotes and the Cyrenians who played to Chrispart in the early missions were converted "a a certain to Mnason, This equally applies tianity. in his Paul Cypriote and old disciple," who received house on the latter's arrival in Jerusalem (Acts xxi. 1 6), and in whom some have tried to also see an adept of the pre-Christian cult of Jesus." Although he was a Cypriote, he lived in Jerusalem, and in stating that he was an "old disciple" (we are between the years that 56 and 58), the editor only desired to indicate a Christian. been he had long 56
Smith) D. vorchr. Jesus. Certain critics think that instead of "Freedmen" the phrase should read, "the people of Lybia." In Greek the confusion between the two words is, from the paleographical point of view, very easy. 7
" Smith,
D. wrc/tr. Jesut.
A PRE-CHRISTIANITY
73
CHRISTIANITY AND THE DISCIPLES OF JOHN THE BAPTIST
III.
the beginning of Chapter xix of the book of Acts stated that, after his arrival at Ephesus, Paul met
At it is
with a group of a dozen disciples who had never heard of the Holy Spirit. "What baptism have ye then received?" he asked. They replied: 'That of John." the baptism of "John," he answered, "baptized with was to come after* repentance in speaking of Him who
order that they should believe, that is to say, in on these disciples the bapJesus." He then conferred tism in the name of the Lord Jesus he laid his hands in
;
upon
and began tongues and to prophesy (xix. i-
them; they received the
Holy
Spirit,
to speak in different these twelve 7) . In the view of the mythologists
men
were, like Apollos himself, pre-Christians, and the shows how closely their facility of their conversion 69 Paul himself. point of view resembled that of 60 Many critics see in them the disciples of John the 01 But the word "disciples," by which these Baptist are designated, is that commonly employed in the Acts for the Christians, and it is not stated that these
men
60
Reitzenstein, Das iranische Erlosungsmysterium, 1921. As Reitzenstein shows well in the above work, no objection can be raised against the presence of disciples of John at Ephesus. The fact is that we know nothing about the conditions in which the know nothing doctrine of John was spread outside Palestine either of the conditions under which Christianity was carried to 61
We
We
can especially urge in support of the existence of the the fact that the fourth disciples of John the Baptist at Ephesus is a direct Gospel in its present form originates at Ephesus, and
Rome.
polemic against the disciples of John the Baptist Cp. Baldensperger, Der Prolog des vierten Evangelwms; Maurice Goguel, Introd. au
N.T. t
ii,
p. 508.
JESUS
74
THE NAZARENE
received instructions along with baptism. to suppose that the position of these us This leads men must have been similar to that of Apollos. But even if they were really disciples of John the Baptist,
men
twelve
no very important conclusions can be drawn from
their
story.
serious reasons for thinking that neither did the during the life of Jesus nor after His death remain out of contact with the of His
There are
group
disciples
combated
The two movements Baptist community. and influenced each other reciprocally.
The preaching
of Jesus Himself was very strongly
influenced at the beginning by John the Baptist. The Gospels present John as the forerunner. According
was to announce the arrival of one be to im"greater than himself," whose work would of fire (Matt. iii. part the baptism of the spirit and ll). This last word opens out already an interesting to them, his duty
of the Baptist perspective in showing that the thought had already broken through the limits within which 62
has recogWellhausen the Bapof a nized one source emanating from group it
was sought to imprison
tist's
it.
Messianic
his disciples in the statement about
Matthew (iii. Where Mark you with the Holy
teaching which belongs peculiarly to ii, 12) and to Luke (iii. 16, 17).
merely says, Spirit,"
"He
shall baptize
Matthew and Luke add "and with
has His fan in His hand, and
purge His
floor.
granary; the chaff is
He
shall
burn
shall
thoroughly
shall store in
His
in everlasting fire."
John the Baptist announces in these an Apocalyptic Messiah who pronounces judg-
The personage words
He
The wheat He
He
fire.
that
aWellhausen, Einlfitung in die drti ersten Evangchen, 1911.
A PRE-CHRISTIANITY ment, and
it is
view of
in
this
75
judgment that repentance
administered. Jesus had preached and baptism been in contact with John the Baptist. His first sermon, as it is given by Mark (i. 15) and Matthew almost word for word identical with that (iv. 17) is is
is
of John (Matt. iii. 2). Christian tradition, so jealous to maintain the originality and the independence of have arbitrarily imagined Him as Jesus, would not it only merely reechoing the teaching of one in whom
saw
a forerunner.
even in point upon which Christian teaching, the from itself of lifetime Bapthe Jesus, separated
The
teaching is of capital importance. While for John and his followers "He who is to come" (Matt. xi. 3 the Son of man (the idea, if not and Luke vii. 19) belongs the word, is at the heart of John's thought)
tist's
to the future, for the Christians He has come, although He may not have had all the attributes of power. The fourth Gospel clearly shows this contrast in the
John was not the light (i. 8), and makes him declare that he was not the Christ (i. 20),
way
affirms that
it
while light
it
states,
(i.
9,
the divine iii.
1
iii.
not 19,
Logos
less categorically, that
(i.
is
Jesus
the
12, 46), and that He is 14), the Son of God (i. 18 and xii.
viii.
6, xx. 31, etc.), the Christ (xi. 27, xx.
34, Reitzenstein
68
31). has extracted from Mandaean writ-
an Apocalypse which appears to him slightly 65 e4 and which he believes to to the year 70, posterior ings
68
Reitzen8tem,
Das Mandaische Buck des Herrn der Gross und
der Evangelienuberheferung. 64 It
is
markedly
known
that
syncretist,
disciples. 65 This date should
is
the
Mandaean
related
to
religion,
the
whose character
tradition
of
the
is
Baptist's
be received with reservations. See those stated
THE NAZARENE John's disciples. A passage
JESUS
76
from
originate
of this
Apocalypse presents at once an analogy and a striking contrast with the reply of Jesus to the messengers of John, who asked "Art thou He who should come, or do we look for another?" "Go," declares Jesus, "and tell unto John that which ye see and hear; the blind see, the lame walk, the lepers are cleansed, the :
deaf hear, the dead are raised, and to the poor the In gospel is preached" (Matt. xi. 4, 5 Luke vii. 22). other words, the Messianic program of Isaiah (xxxv. ;
5)
is fulfilled.
In the Mandaean Apocalypse the same program is announced as destined to be fulfilled by the expected
Messiah
:
"Enoch Uthra
enters into Jerusalem clothed
with clouds; he walks in bodily form, but he has no
[Pilate].
He
comes in the years of Paltus Enoch Uthra comes into the world with the
material clothing.
power of the great king of
light.
He
heals the sick,
he causes the blind to see, he cleanses the lepers, he he causes the imstraightens those who are bowed, to speak. With the potent to walk and the dumb the power of the great king of light he brings back dead to life. Among the Jews he wins over believers
and shows unto them there is life, and there is death, there is error and there is truth. He converts the Jews in the name of the great king of light. Three hundred and sixty prophets go out from Jerusalem; they testithe Lord of might. Enoch Uthra fy in the name of ascends on high, and places himself near unto Meshume Kushtra. All the Uthras are hid from the eyes by M, Loisy.
From our
Apocalypse reflects hardly contestable.
the
that the present point of view, it suffices ideas of John the Baptist, which seems
A PRE-CHRISTIANITY
77
of men. Then shall Jerusalem be laid waste. The Jews shall go forth into exile, and shall be dispersed in all cities."
thus presented this text does not appear to be homogeneous it must have been, in certain points, influenced by Christian tradition. It suffices, however, to show that the disciples of John taught as necessary
As
;
to be fulfilled by the Apocalyptic Messiah the program that the Christians said had been accomplished
by Jesus. the great difference between the ideas of For the John the Baptist and those of the Christians. in the is future; first named the coming of the Messiah
Here
is
for the second
it
is
in the past,
The
and only His second
is a capital one, expected. coming movements were two if the that to and suffices prove be reduced to cannot born on the same soil the second the first, but appears with reference to it, as though it were an original creation.
is
difference
CHAPTER
IV
OBJECTIONS TO THE NONHISTORICAL THESIS
TWO PRELIMINARY THE
I.
FROM
POLEMICS OF THE OPPONENTS OF CHRISTIANITY
the earliest period of its existence Christianity on the part object of the liveliest attacks, both
was an of in
at
Jew and pagan, in Jerusalem and Palestine, as also the Greco-Roman world through which it spread an early date.
We
are familiar enough with the anti-Christian that polemics from the second to the fourth century; of Lucian by the witticisms of De morte Peregrini; that of Celsus (in his True Discourse, composed in the
makes from year 180) by the quotations which Origen * of and unknown the of that Porphyry it philosopher (233-304) by the refutation of Macarius of Mag;
nesia (about 410) that of Julian the Apostate (33163) by the refutation of Cyril of Alexandria. By means of the various apologies of the second century ;
(those of Justin Martyr, Tatien, Aristides), and by the dialogues of Justin with the Jew Tryphon, we can of the doctrines which gain a fairly accurate conception in the course of the Christians the to were opposed
second century. Just as there was an apologetic tradition, so was there a polemical one. They are always *In
his
Contra Celsum, written about 348. Concerning this work its refutation by Origen consult Neumann and De
of Celsus and
THE NONHISTORICAL THESIS
79
more or less the pens from flow which of ability and penetration, of the opponents of Christianity.
the
same
critical ideas,
characterized with
The pagan
polemic did not present a physiognomy very different from that of the Jews. One philosopher, Celsus, sought in the Jewish arsenal for weapons to 2 wield against Christianity. For everything which concerned evangelical history the discussion had to depend Christian tradition. It was upon the ground of
upon
the Gospels that the opponents of Christianity took their position. They called attention to the lack of
up
culture of the evangelists, pointed out in their narra-
and improbabilities, but they never stigmatized them as purely and simply 8 fictions. They only attempted to give to the story of from it the Jesus an interpretation which eliminated miraculous and the supernatural they did not contest tives incoherences, contradictions,
;
4
its
veracity.
not possible to extend to the first the period century the conclusion which holds for it Is it. not, however, improbable that which followed the disputants of the second century would have nean efficient weapon which they found had been
Doubtless
it
is
glected
used by their predecessors? Already, from this point of view, there are strong presumptions that the nonhistorical thesis was not supported in the primitive period. Bauer gives a table 2 This has been well shown by W. Bauer. and pagan opponents showing the life of Jesus according to Jewish This table shows the fundamental agreement of of Christianity. the
two
sides.
Bauer, Das Leben Jesu, etc. Tubingen, 1909. Cacilius *Lucian, De morte Peregnm, Celsus (in Origen's work); a man punished with with Christians worshiping the reproaches 8
death.
8o
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
M. Salomon Reinach thinks that of the
first
century in
which the
if
we have no work
historical character
5 of Jesus is questioned, the reason is that if such very subversive documents had existed the Church would 6 not have permitted them to survive. It may be ad-
mitted that the Church would have eliminated them
from the canonical books and from orthodox literature, but to that,
have
and
it is
not easy to see
in a its
more general way power was limited
how
the Church
succeeded in completely prohibiting
would
them. If the
not striking that all the polemical literature of Jews and pagans has been preserved for us by Christian apolohow would the central question of the existence ?
work of Lucian we know about
is
is it
excepted
gists
of Jesus have been treated otherwise than for other controverted questions? Would not opponents have made capital out of this attitude, which would have
avowal? Although no polemical antiChristian document belonging to the first century has come down to us, it is possible to form an idea of been
its
an
quality
Christian
four
the
by the
influence
tradition.
evangelists
The
exerted upon comparative study of
which
shows
that
it
solicitude
for
which most diapologetics was one of the factors which they were rectly influenced the form into cast.
7
be otherwise, for the Gospels were not written to satisfy the curiosity of historians, but to It could not
combated in Exception is made of opponents whom Ignatius shall return to this passage the Epistle to the Philadelphians. when treating of Docetism 6 S. Reinach, Questions sur le Docetisme. * de la primitive Eglise; Urchristlicht
We
Baldensperger, L'apologetique Apologit.
THE NONHISTORICAL THESIS
81
and to strengthen the convic8 won. tions of those already gain
men
to the faith
therefore had to present the facts in the likely to answer the objections of opponents in advance. Now in none of the four Gospels is there to be found anything which directly or indithat the person rectly is directed against the thesis
The editors way the most
are in several Jesus had no historical reality. There accounts of apparitions, remarks to emphasize the but never reality of the body of Jesus, resurrected?
does any evangelist feel the need to affirm the reality of the body of Jesus during His ministry. This is because they were not engaged with opponents who denied
it.
The importance of this was on the morrow of His
fact
birth
is
considerable, for
it
that Christianity was
confronted with Jewish opposition.
How is
it
possible
to suppose that the first antagonists of the Church could have been ignorant of the fact that the entire
His teaching, and His death correno reality at all? That it might have been
story of Jesus,
sponded to
but it apignored in the Diaspora may be admitted, if such a thing and at Jerusalem; pears impossible had been known, how did the opponents of Christicome to neglect the use of so terrible an arguanity
ment, or how, supposing they made use of it, does it happen that the Christians succeeded in so completely them that not a trace of the controversy has refuting
been
preserved
by
the
disputants
of
the
second
century? This is evident from the express declaration of Luke and John (xx. 31). Luke xxiv. 39-4*; J onn *
(i.
4)
JESUS
82
THE NAZARENE
argument the opponents of the historical thesis may be tempted to rejoin that no decisive case can be based upon our Gospels, since under the most favorable hypothesis the oldest among them Against
this
than forty years after the events which they relate or are supposed to relate. In a period of intense religious ferment, forty years suffice for exact memories to disappear or undergo profound
was not compiled
less
transformation, or for the birth of a legend ready made. But our Gospels are not the first narrations which saw the light; and before their compilation had there existed an oral tradition capable of pre-
begun
serving the facts with remarkable fidelity. pel tradition in its essential elements goes
The Gosmuch far-
ther back than the compilation of the first written shall attempt in a later chapter to prove Gospels. that the theology of Paul implies this fact.
We
II.
DOCETISM
the opinion of those who believed that in the person of Jesus the human element was only an appearance. Such as we find this belief, for instance
Docetism
is
iM
Hubert Pcrnot (Etudes de literature grecque moderne) has quoted a very curious case of the fidelity of oral tradition. It "In 1890," writes M. refers to a Cretan poem (La Belle Bergere) withPernot, "an inhabitant of Chio, Constantine Kaneallakis, gave, out knowing its ancient origin, a version of it, which is a guarantee of authenticity so complete that I supposed it to be a revised copy of one of the Venetian editions, until one day this conscientious worker told me that he had picked it up at Nenita, his native village,
being
The women of middle life old peasant woman in these places, the latter had only been able poem read. This is a characteristic example of the
from an
all
illiterate
to hear the
whose memory has not yet astonishing facility with which people, are capable of retaining use of the writing, by works of considerable length."
been enfeebled
THE NONHISTORICAL THESIS in
Marcion and
many
in
second-century
83
Gnostics,
Docetism is not an affirmation of historical order: it is an interpretation of the history on which the Chris-
was based. Among the second-century theothe first century, there are logians, and even those of found side by side these two theses Jesus is a man and He is God. Herein was presented a problem for tian faith
:
How
define in the person of the Christian thought: Christ the relation between the human element and
diverse attempts were made in ancient Christianity to solve this problem up to the time when the orthodox doctrine was fixed. There
the divine?
The most
were attempts which sacrificed one of the terms of the a mere man problem, either in making of the Christ raised to the heavens by His resurrection, or, on the in Him to but a contrary, by reducing the humanity mere appearance. That which the Docetists of the second century denied, was not that the story narrated by the evangelists but that the humanity of the person to whom the story referred was anything more than a mere ap-
was
real,
11
pearance or a garment worn by a divine Being. Docetism is a theological opinion; it is not an historical affirmation.
12
particularly the character of Marcion's systhat deep and daring thinker who in the first tem, half of the second century gave, concerning the Chris-
Such
is
18
11
Justin,
De
resurrection,
ii;
Tractatus Ongensis, Origen, Contra
Celsum, ii, 16 12 Concerning the character of Docetism, see Harnack, Lehrbuch der Dogmengeschichtc 18 Concerning the Doceticism of Marcion, see De Faye, Gnostiques et Gnosticisme; also Harnack, Marcion, Das Evangehum vom frem-
den Gott.
JESUS
84
THE NAZARENE
which he sought to free from every link with so fertile, Judaism, an interpretation so original and the of apostle and which Harnack compares to those tianity
Paul and St. Augustine. In Marcion's view Christ had not been begotten He had nothing of the human about Him; He was and remains a Spirit. He appeared in human form (in hominis forma) His body was but ;
;
It is necessary to conceive Him as an appearance. like the angels who appeared to Abraham, who ate and 14
"
drank and performed all the actions of human life Christ of (Gen. xviii. 2-8). Harnack writes: "The Marcion is a God who appears in human form, feels, acts and suffers like a man, although the identification with a carnal body, naturally begotten, is in His case assert merely an appearance. It is incorrect, then, to not did Christ suffer, and that according to Marcion His adonly died in appearance. This is the opinion
He only predicated ie flesh of Christ." of the appearance to the substance Marcion was so far from denying the Gospel history
versaries attributed to
Him, but
that he accepted a Gospel (that of Luke) which he had only purged of what he considered Judaising addihis ideas, particularly in of the birth of Jesus and in narration the suppressing 'making His history begin at the baptism. tions.
This he adapted to
Cerinthe also believed that Christ was time of baponly united with the man Jesus at the of the tism, and separated from Him at the time
The Gnostic
Passion, so that Christ Himself
"Irenaeiis, 15
Adv. .Ear., Hi, 16, i. Adv. Marciontm, hi,
Tertullian,
"Harnack, Marcion. 17 Irenaeus, Adv. Har.>
i,
26.
9.
had not
I
17
suffered/"
THE NONHISTORICAL THESIS This solicitude to preserve the
full divinity
8$
of Christ
by discarding the idea of suffering gave rise to rather strange interpretations of the story of the Passion. 18 taught Irenaeus, for instance, states that Basilides that Simon of Cyrene not only carried the cross of substituted for Jesus, but that he had been miraculously
the latter, been crucified in His stead, while Jesus, lost in the crowd, looked on, laughing at the punishment 19 In the A eta Johannis (Chap, xcvii) of his double. there may be read how at the moment of the crucifixion
and said to Jesus appeared unto John, who had fled, him: "John, for the people who are there, at Jerusalem, I am crucified; I am pierced with thrusts of have vinegar and honey to drink, but to thee I speak; harken to what I tell thee." All these legends do not deny the story of the Passion; they develop upon the basis of the Gospel tradition an interpretation
lance, I
of the facts which eliminates the idea of the suffering and the death of a God. If such was the Docetism of the second century, it
would be surprising if there had been previously a Docetism of an entirely different character. That Docetism is met with at the beginning of the second room to doubt. century, and perhaps earlier, there is no
Jerome
attests its high antiquity
blood of Christ was
still
when he
fresh
says that the
in Judea,
and the
Clement 18 DC Faye (Gnostiques ft Gnostictsmc) thinks that if of Alexandria had known of this theory of Basilides, he would not have failed to attack it, and for this reason it should be only attributed to later adepts of the sect. iIf one may judge by the formula of abjuration imposed upon them, the Manicheans seem to have had the same opinion (Kessler). is found, according to Photius, in the "Acts of The same
thing
John" (Leucius Charinus). that it was Judas who was
There
is
also
a legend which has
it
crucified in the place of Jesus (Liepsius).
86
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
apostles were still living when to affirm that the body of the
men
could be found
Lord was merely
a
20
phantom. M. Loisy has with
justice pointed out, as is shown in the context, that there is in the passage from St.
Jerome an oratorical exaggeration in which hyperbole and inaccuracy abound. The phrase about the blood of Christ has no more significance than the statement concerning the apostles. As regards the latter, its sole in origin is in the fact that Docetism was combated the Johannine Epistles (i, iv. 2 and 2, 7). The formula in the first Epistle of John about the confession of Jesus Christ having come in the flesh (i, iv. 2)
to which
not sufficiently precise to enable the thesis This might is opposed to be reconstructed.
is
it
just as well
have been a negation of the Messianic
character of the personality of Jesus as of the reality or His body. It is doubtless in the second sense that
be intertestimony of the Johannine Epistle should more precise, preted, because of an analogous, although of in the Ignatius. The Epistles controversy found 'the
facts Bishop of Antioch insists upon the reality of the to it suffices this show To of the Gospel history. quote
a passage
from the Epistle
It refers to Jesus Christ, ten,
who had
to the Christians of Tralles.
"who had
eaten and drunk,
really been begot-
who had
really been
and put to judged under Pontius Pilate, really crucified who had really been raised from the death .
.
.
And
Ignatius in his next chapter formally opstated to those of the unbeposes the opinion thus He only appeared to suflievers, who maintained that
dead."
o
Jerome, Adv. Lvciferum, 23.
THE NONHISTORICAL THESIS
87
21
The Docetism attacked by Ignatius may have with Judaising tendencies combated in associated been 22 The evidence of Jerome on the Philadelphians ix. i. fer.
Palestinian origin of Docetism
is
favorable to this
in-
terpretation. 28 Docetism According to M. Salomon Reinach, far older than Ignatius already it is found attacked
is
in
;
the Gospels, particularly in the episode concerning Simon of Cyrene, who at the time when Jesus was led to Calvary was forced by the soldiers to carry the xv. 21
Matt,
xxvii.
32; Luke
xxiii.
26). alone states that this Simon was the father of 24 In Reinach's view the hisAlexander and Rufus. torical character of this episode is inadmissible, in the cross
(Mark
;
Mark
of any requisiplace because there is no instance the object, and was Simon which of that tion similar to in the next place because the condemned was obliged to first
because the carry the patibulum himself, and lastly 21
Cp Eph.
vn. 18;
said that Jesus, pain.
Smyrn.
i,
2; Polycarpe, Phil., vh, p.
also found in the Gospel of Peter, when crucified, kept silent, as though
trace of Docetism
M. Reinach
is
He
A
i.
where
it
felt
is
no
(Source bibhque du docetisme) has with justice passage in Isa. 1. 7:
proposed to seek the origin of this idea in the face like unto a rock." "I have made
my
admitted, for instance, by W. Bauer (Die Brief e des Ignatius von Antioch, etc.)* 28 Reinach, Simon de Cyrene. The criticism of Reinach by Loisy should be read (Revue d'Histoire et de literature religieuses> 1913). Some authors, 24 This episode is not found in the fourth Gospel. such as Jean R6ville (Quatrieme toangile), consider that the evan22
This
gelist
is
has omitted
it
in the
interest
of anti-Docetism
;
others,
like
Holtzmann-Bauer, believe that he was influenced by the words of or by the story of Jesus on the necessity of carrying one's cross,
The for the burnt-offering. Isaac, who himself carried the wood fact that John has allowed other details of the Passion to be of the narrapassed over leads us to consider it a simplification The incito concentrate all attention upon Jesu. tive,
designed
wanting also in the Gospel of Peter. au N.T., ii.)
dent
is
(M. Goguel, Introd.
JESUS
88
THE NAZARENE
only the illustration of the words of "Whosoever will come after Me, let him take
whole episode Jesus, up his cross
arguments
is
None
and follow Me."
is
of these three
requisition of Simon the in it one certainly not legal one must see
convincing.
The
Cyrenian was of the thousand daily annoyances the Romans did not hesitate to inflict on the Jews. It must not be explained by the compassion that Jesus would have inspired in ;
the soldiers, but by the physical impossibility for Him, after flagellation, to carry the cross. Lastly, it is inconceivable that the episode should have been sug-
of carrygested by words in which it is a question not cross. ing Jesus' cross, but one's own There is therefore no reason to recognize in the
account the remains of a tradition analogous to the the conception of the Gnostic Docetists concerning crucifixion of
substituted Jesus for Simon, is
If the evangelist
Simon of Cyrene.
not comprehensible
who
why they
really
was
had
crucified, it
should not have pushed
the substitution to the end, but instead have preserved the details of the carrying of the cross by Simon. As for the names Alexander and Rufus, which are
Mark, these are generally explained by these persons must have been known in saying that the community in which the second Gospel was comfound only
in
25
posed.
Matthew and Luke
neglected this detail, which had or their readers. M. Reinach,
no interest for them on the contrary, considers that the names Alexander and Rufus were added afterwards in Mark because of a tradition which represented them as associates of 28 This community was probably Roman. an N.T., L)
(Sec
M. Goguel,
Introd.
THE NONHISTORICAL THESIS Peter.
26
But
this tradition
is
89
only supported by a text
"The Acts of Peter and Andrew"
of very recent date,
;
Alexander and Rufus had been persons suffito make it worth while to invoke their known ciently testimony (which, moreover, is only done in Mark in a very indirect way), it would not be intelligible that their names should have been omitted in the Gospels of Matthew and Luke. It is not legitimate, therefore, to dispute the authenticity of the incident of Simon
and
if
carrying the cross of Jesus. The system which boldly dates back to the period which preceded the composition of the Gospels a form of Docetism for which Irenaeus is the first wit-
and claims to explain the origin of the episode as a reaction against it, must be considered Simon of
ness
an arbitrary construction. The conclusion to which we are thus led is that there is no evidence for the existence of Docetism older than is to be found in the Epistles of
John and
The Docetism
Ignatius.
at the beginning of the second cenarisen from the same beliefs which
tury must have Docetism. It is necesinspired the theories of Gnostic not a negation of the Gossary, therefore, to see in it,
which in no pel history, but an attempt to interpret it, of the degree compromises the transcendent character Saviour by representing Him as accomplishing His work on humanity without partaking of the frailty
of
human
nature.
A different
interpretation has been proposed by 27
M.
Docetism an attempt
Salomon Reinach, who to reconcile the Christian affirmations about Christ *
Reinach.
ST
M., Question* sur
finds in
.
It
docetisme (Revue Moaerniste).
9o
JESUS
with a Jewish
THE NAZARENE
"X" who
is
the negation of the whole
Gospel history.
The
Christians, incapable of opposing to this negation positive proofs based upon authentic documents, a Bereplied that Jesus was a kind of divine phantom, had ing ethereal and entirely spiritual, that human eyes seen,
and whose voice human ears had heard, but who
could not be touched.
To
M.
28
rightly objects that the to the answer Jewish negation would have been without efficacy, since the Jews denied precisely that this
theory
Couissin
which the Docetists affirmed, namely that Jesus had been seen and heard, either as an illusion or otherwise. M. Loisy observes that the answer of the Docetists 1'
would have been a "masterpiece of human stupidity, and that "we are here in the domain of pure phantasy, of stark improbability, of conjecture based upon nothing."
Indeed, the question discussed by the Docetists was not whether there had lived a man in the time of who acted, suffered and died, but Pilate named Jesus,
the problem was to determine the nature of His mani29 thinks he finds festation. Here it is that M. Reinach his of in favor theory in the a decisive
argument
to the Philadelphians. Epistle of Ignatius
80
"I have
heard certain men say," writes Ignatius, "if I do not find (a certain thing) in the archives, I do not believe And as I replied to them It is written in the :
Gospel. answered: (in the Old Testament), they 28 P. L. Couissin,
Quelques reflexions sur la
lettre
That de
M.
is
the
Reinach,
Revue Modernutc, reproduced by Reinach. Reinach, St. Ignace et le Docetume. M. Reinach's translation is given. The text of the passage is not certain. For basis of discussion we accept that of M. Reinach. 29
THE NONHISTORICAL THESIS
91
But for me the archives are Jesus cross, His death, His resurrection, and which comes from Him."
very question.' Christ,
His
the faith
generally understood that Ignatius in this passage replies to those who demanded proofs drawn from the Old Testament before they accepted the affirmaIt
is
tions of the Christian faith.
proofs exist, and he appeals to what
He
declares that these
as his adversaries dispute their value, is
for
him the supreme demonstra-
tion, Jesus Christ. In M. Reinach's view the archives referred to in the first part of the phrase are those of Csesarea, the capital of Palestine. Ignatius had to deal
which, demanding documents concerning the terrestrial life of Jesus, and seeking these vainly among the archives, annoyed Ignatius with These critics are also aimed at in its negations.'
with "a
critical school,
1
that the
prince Ephesians (xix) where Ignatius says the of either no had of this world virginity knowledge of Mary or of the death of the Lord. If this critical school of Antioch had existed, it would be inexplicable that its arguments have not been used by later controversialists. But that is not
again
all.
If the
word "archives" can be
to the archives of Caesarea,
it
rigorously applied holds none the less that
the demands of his opIgnatius thinks he replies to referred to are atfacts the that ponents in proving tested by the
Old Testament, for the words
"It is
written" cannot, as M. Reinach recognizes, refer to His opponents anything except the Old Testament.
do not deny that the proof offered by Ignatius, if it were really furnished, would be convincing. They only doubt that it is really given. If they had insisted on documents from archives, why should they have been
JESUS
92
THE NAZARENE
able to content themselves
with scriptural proofs?
There must be some correspondence between the demand and the answer. If Ignatius were dealing with the Gospel persons requiring documentary proofs of should he not have attempted to give them? In ignoring the question he would have given his opponents a manifest proof of feebleness. It apnot the Docepears, as M. Loisy admits, that it was tists, but the Judaising Christians who, while admitting history,
why
in their generality the evangelical facts, disputed the
The coninterpretation that Ignatius gave of them. DoceThe : clear is therefore reach clusion we quite tists did not contest the Gospel history. They were the notion to Christian idealists, attached above all of the divinity of Christ and the celestial character of His person, who attempted to give it an interpretation harmonizing with their ideas. So understood, Docetism was only able to develop in the soil of evangelical tradition. If the Docetists had had the slightest reason to think that Christ was no more than an ideal not have person without historical reality, they would
an interexpended such treasures of ingenuity to give off completely Him cut which His of story pretation from too intimate contact with humanity. The Docetists
thus appear as witness to Gospel tradition.
CHAPTER V
THE APOSTLE PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION I.
THE
EPISTLES OF
PAUL 1
canon of Muratori, a Roman document of the second half of the second century, states that what the apostle Paul wrote to the Christians of a particular church is meant for all (omnibus dicit). This is the
THE
conception which
inspired
the
canonization of the
and which has prevailed, but it was certainly not with the idea that his letters would become elements of a sacred collection that the apostle wrote Epistles,
them. It is only by a kind of transposition at times not without prejudice to their true spirit that these sensitive letters, which spring spontaneously from a and enthusiasms whose indignaemotions, personality, into been tion they reveal, have encyclicals or changed of a dogmatic treatises and interpreted in the style code.
Deissmann has maintained that
it
is
a radical mis-
We
consider the letters of Paul as authentic with the exception of that to the Ephesians and the Pastorals (i and 2 Tim. and This conception, generally admitted to-day, will be vinTitus). The majority of those dicated in Book IV of our Introduction. who deny the historical character of Jesus repudiate the testimony
of Paul's Epistles. M. Couchoud is the sole exception. The position of Drews is uncertain. Nevertheless, he takes some account of their testimony not, it is true, without dismissing (as interpolated) certain important texts, such as i Cor. xi. 33 et seq. (See Die Chris-
tutmytht,
i,
p. iai,
by Drews.) 93
JESUS
94
THE NAZARENE
take to consider the Epistles of Paul as literary works, for they were only written as substitutes for conversations which distance rendered impossible. They are
not in the technical sense of the word "Epistles" that is, works which in an epistolary form are intended for a larger public in time and space than those to are addressed, and treat of questions which or a might just as well be the object of a dissertation book. To thoroughly understand the Epistles of Paul it is necessary to forget the halo which for eighteen centuries has surrounded them, but which, while gloridistorts them. They are writings adapted to
whom they
fying,
circumstances, improvised hastily between two jourafter a day devoted to neys, dictated in the evening manual work or to preaching, to meet some unfore-
seen circumstance, to solve some difficulty, to give instruction or warning, or to prevent a misunderstandanswers to some complex situaing. Each one of them disappeared, the main reason for which, tion,
having
existence has disappeared also. Further, there apon the part of the pears no trace of any custom its
churches of the apostolic age of regularly reading the were communicated to the Epistles of Paul. They
assembly when they were received perhaps they were read again as it happened, so long as the question which had dictated their composition was not settled, but afterwards they were simply preserved in the archives, and that, it appears, with but little care. ;
of these letters have disappeared, and among those preserved to us several seem to have undergone various alterations. When in Thessalonians (i, v. the Lord 27) Paul writes, "I charge you in the name of be read unto all the Brethren," he that this
Many
epistle
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION
95
merely requests that all may be informed of his mesTo the sage, and in no wise thinks of a second reading. read is Colossians Paul writes: "When this letter among you, cause that it be read also in the church of the Laodiceans, and that ye likewise read the epistle
from the Laodiceans" (Col. iv. 16). The apostle is so far from the idea of a regular reading that he speaks of the dispatch, not of a copy, but of the original itself. There is nothing more unsound than to see in the Pauline Epistles theological treatises. Therefore complete of the faith or system of thought of the expositions
for those apostle must not be sought in them. Written stress his received had upon who teaching, they lay what these knew, and proceed very often by allusions to
persons what he had taught and the
The fundamental
dition of Christianity.
common
tra-
doctrines are
not more systematically treated than the facts upon rest. The initiates to whom they were ad-
which they
knew
dressed
both, and
had no need
them
to have
recalled.
PAUL, BEFORE His CONVERSION, A WITNESS TO THE CROSS
IL
Through viii.
1-3,
tive of iii.
6),
book of Acts (vii. 58, narraand particularly through the 2),
the narratives in the
ix. i,
Cor. xv. 9 Gal. i. 13, 23 Phil, that before his conversion Paul was a
Paul himself
we know
(
i
;
;
bitter persecutor of the Christians. It
is
scarcely prob-
able that the future apostle ever saw Jesus Himself, in spite of the passage in which he says: "If even we
have known Christ after the
more" (2 Cor.
v.
16).
flesh,
we know Him no
The words
"after the flesh"
JESUS
96
may
THE NAZARENE
as well belong to
"we know Him no more"
as to
"Christ." It is therefore possible to understand this as "we have known Jesus during His earthly life," or "we have had a carnal and Judaic conception of the
Messiah." tions
is
Even
if
the
to be preferred,
of these two interpretaaccount must be taken of the first
Paul hypothetical element contained in the phrase. to a appears to allude, in order to contest its value, boasted. of which certain of his opponents
privilege
In this passage merely an hypothesis is outlined. It must be added that if Paul had known Jesus he would have been among His enemies. Why should he who accuses himself of persecuting the disciples not have 2 said that he had fought against the Master Himself?
period which immediately followed the drama of Calvary that Paul must have come into 8 contact with Christianity. Even if it be supposed that It
was
in the
the disciples of Jesus had only seen in Him, during His to hold ministry, a prophet or a doctor, it is impossible
that after the Passion they remained grouped together in His name without attributing to His personality a quite peculiar value. 2
Among
name
the critics
who
Sabatier, Joh Weiss,
They must have been
led to see
believe that Paul had seen Jesus
Machen.
Renan, Wellhausen, Feme, Prat.
The
opposite opinion
Some few
is
we may held by
writers, like Pfleiderer,
consider the question insoluble (Das Urchnstenttsm). 8 The time when Paul came into contact with Christianity cannot consider that Jesus must have be very much after the Passion died at Easter, in the year 28, and that the conversion of Paul must be placed at the end of 29 Concerning the fixing of these two dates see my works Essai sur la Chronologic Paulintenne and
We
Notes d'histoire evangehgue' Le probltme Chronologique. While I have followed, pursuing an entirely different method from that or 28 and the in of death the ends 27 Jesus by putting Meyer conversion of Paul in 28 or 29.
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION in
His death the
97
by God do not know how
realization of a plan conceived
for the salvation of humanity.
We
far Christology had developed before the conversion of Paul. It suffices to explain his sentiments and the attitude which they imposed upon him to know that
the Christians continued to invoke Jesus, and to consider
Him
Law.
He
from God. to give him the name by which he Saul of Tarsus seems to have been known in the Jewish world was then a young Rabbi, full of fanaticism and zeal for the as one sent
must have been profoundly scandalized by men who proclaimed themselves disof a madman whose pretensions had been con-
the attitude of ciples
demned by the Sanhedrin, the supreme Jewish tribunal, and who had perished at the hands of the Roman aucharacterized by the phrase he was to employ later on: "Christ crucified, a, scandal to the Jews" ( i Cor. i. 23 ; cp. Gal. v. 1 1 ) It as a missionary to epitomizes at once his experiences the Jews and his personal feelings before he was yet a Christian. His thought was dominated by the princithorities.
The
attitude of Paul
is
.
ple of the
Law, which he
recalls in his Epistle to the
everyone that hangeth on a tree" In permitting (Gal. iii. 13; cp. with Deut. xxi. 23). Him to die this infamous death, God Himself had pro-
Galatians, "Cursed
is
nounced against Jesus, and declared
Him
accursed.
Those therefore who declared that this accursed one was the Son of God, the promised Messiah of Israel, were guilty of an appalling blasphemy. Wellhausen has supposed that, taught wisdom by hatred, Paul from this time recognized in Christianity a doctrine whose development would ruin Judaism. To admit this would be to misunderstand Paul's fanaticism and
JESUS
98
THE NAZARENE
the depth of his faith in the destiny of Israel. It is that the still more rash to suppose, as does Pfleiderer, things which Paul knew and heard concerning Jesus exercised upon him a secret attraction, and that he was by the spectacle of the lives of the
impressed
Christians.
That would have been
the spur for
him to kick
which he would have wished against, the secret anxiety to silence by persecuting the Christians. That Paul, unknown to himself, may have been influenced by Chris4
Jewish period of his life is, a priori, very at all conscious of it appears plausible, but that he was less likely. The testimony which he gives of himself tianity in the
the persecutions directed by him not permit any doubt of against the Christians does the sincerity of his motives. The explanation of his attitude is more simple. Paul considered the Christians
when speaking of
and blasphemers and sacrilegious. Now blasphemy it which sins belonged sacrilege, in antiquity, were not alone to God to judge; they were crimes which exIn posed the nation to the risk of divine anger.
this
respect the judicial authorities had to take cognizance of them, and it was part of the duty of every one to aid them, and if need be to stimulate their zeal. An impor-
tant consequence flows from this fact; it is that the cross had dominated the period of Paul's antagonism to Christianity, just as later it was to dominate his
Christian thought. Paul the Christian
Paul the persecutor and not only thus appears to us as a witness to
*Acta xzvi. 14. If this detail is authentic, it is astonishing that is only met with in one of the three narratives in the Acts. Moreover, we do not believe that these narratives can be taken to be rigorously historical, although sometimes, and especially in recent times, their value has been too much depreciated. it
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION
99
the cross, and this also within the few months which followed the day of its erection on Calvary. Here is a decisive objection against the doctrine that the entire Gospel history has been deduced from a theory or from a preexisting myth and, if the word is allowed, from the supernatural life of an ideal Christ of whom the experiences of Peter and the initial manifestations. primitive Christians were the
III.
PAUL AND THE UNITY OF PRIMITIVE CHRISTIANITY
Notwithstanding the opposition
(exaggerated by
the Tubingen school, nevertheless real) which existed between the apostle Paul and the Jerusalem Christians,
attached to Judaism and its traditional ritual than he was himself, there existed with-
who remained more
Christianity a fundamental unity. Paul conscious of it when summing up the essentials
in primitive
was
of Christian teaching. He said "Therefore whether it were I or they (the apostles at Jerusalem) so we preach and so ye believed" (i Cor. xv. n). Upon :
their side the Jerusalemites
had confirmed
this unity
in offering Paul the hand of fellowship and in recogto preach the nizing that he had received the mission
7-10). How is it possifundamental unity of Christianity if
gospel to the pagans (Gal. ble to explain this
ii.
to origin there only existed conceptions relating manifestations? His to an ideal Christ and spiritual Paul insists in the most formal way that his conversion
at
its
took place without direct contact with the Jerusalem church. He declares himself "Paul, an apostle, not of men, neither by man, but by Jesus Christ and
God
ioo
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
him from the dead" (Gal. i. to reconcile this absolute indeis it possible i ) . of Paul pendence of Christianity and the apostleship with the unity of primitive Christianity unless by the fact that the apostle recognized in the activity of the the Father,
who
raised
How
celestial Christ, to
whom
he attributed the birth of his
historfaith, the continuation and consequence of the ical ministry of Jesus to which the Christianity of the
Twelve and the Jerusalem church owed
IV.
THE BROTHERS
its
origin?
OF JESUS AND THE JERUSALEM APOSTLES
Before examining the testimony that the apostle Paul renders directly to the evangelical tradition, it will be convenient to point out two facts which prove is indeed a real human personthe apostle speaks incidentally occasions ality. of James and other brothers of the Lord (Gal. i. 19; In neither of these two passages is it I Cor. ix. 5).
that the Pauline Christ
On two
in an inadmissible possible unless the text be distorted 5 "brothers" any other inmanner, to give to the word to it in its natural terpretation than that which belongs 6 the in then were sense. There Jerusalem church (Paul knew it, and the churches of the Diaspora were not 5 There can be no reason to see in the phrase "brother of the Lord" the designation of an ecclesiastical function or title, first because it would be a conjecture resting upon no foundation, and to differentiate this secondly because it would not be possible function from the apostolate, with which, nevertheless, it could not
be identified. 6 there were given to the If, as is done by Catholic exegesis, brothers (sons of * phrase "brothers of Jesus" the meaning of half of Jesus, the force of premier marriage of Joseph) or of cousins our argument would not be seriously affected.
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION
101
for being the brothers ignorant of it) men who passed flesh. the to of Jesus according How can this well-established fact be reconciled with the theory that the Christ preached by Paul was a 8 7 Drews, it is true, has mainpurely ideal personage? tained that the phrase "brother of the Lord" meant the simply member of the community, but to designate faithful the merely said "the brothers" or
apostle "the brethren in the Lord," and in the passages in which the brothers of Jesus are referred to Paul
names them besides other Christians, the apostles and these. In Cephas, and he does not confuse them with i
Cor.
ix. 5, in
particular,
it is
remarkable that Paul,
speaking of the wife that he might have, says quite of the Lord" simply "sister," while he says "brethren 9 concerning the persons to whom he compares himself. One other fact imposes a similar conclusion. Paul assimilates his apostleship entirely to that of the
in
difficulty, the recoghis of vocation the nition of by the Jerusalem validity church (Gal. ii. i-io). He connects his apostleship, like that of the Twelve, with an apparition of the risen
Twelve; he obtained, not without
but he must have been obliged to fight a hard and persevering battle to establish that he was in nothcalled the ing inferior to those whom in derision he The xii. xi. and Cor. latter, n). 5 archapostles (2 Christ,
10
or at any rate their partisans, must have maintained that Paul lacked a qualification of which his rivals could i
There
Mark
in
rii. 3-5;
is iii.
Acts
also
i
and Luke vai.
a reference to the brothers
31; Matt.
xii.
46, xiii. 55;
sisters
19;
of Jesus
John
14.
8
Drews, Die Christusmythe, 5, pp. 125-27. von Nazareth. 10 This follows by comparing z Cor. ix. z and Joh. Weiss, Jesus
z
Cor. xv.
8.
ii.
i,
102
JESUS
boast. It
THE NAZARENE
was impossible to question either the qualififrom the Judaic point of view (Phil,
cations of Paul
4-6; 2 Cor. xi. 21, 22) or his services to the cause of the Gospel and the sufferings accepted by him for 11 X 7) or * it (l Cor. xv. 10; 2 Cor. xi. 23-33; Gal the signs accomplished and visions obtained by him iii.
-
A
text in the epistle to the Gala(2 Cor. xii. 1-12). the nature of the objecunderstand to tians enables us tion raised against the Pauline apostleship. Concern12 "But of ing the apostles at Jerusalem Paul said: be somewhat to these who seemed (whatsoever they
were it maketh no matter to me: God accepteth no for they who seemed to be somewhat man's person) in conference added nothing to me" (Gal. ii. 6). The qualification on which the Jerusalem apostles referred to prided themselves and which Paul lacked, of boast the past. The Twelve could having been Christians and apostles before Paul, but he in no wise attempted to hide the fact that he had formerly persecuted the church and that he was a late recruit for the 13 On the contrary, he boasted of it as someGospel. to be proud of (i Cor. xv. 8-10), because he
thing considered
it
a manifest proof of the intervention of
God What
in his life.
could this former qualification of which the than that they Jerusalem apostles boasted be, other the historical of associates and had been witnesses
" The
marks referred to in Gal. vi. 17 are in all probability the from blows received in the service of Christ. 12 There are three designations of the Jerusalem apostles employed
scars
in the Galatians, tion of the origin. 18 This
It
appears that Paul alludes to a current designawhich it is no longer possible to find the
apostles of
explains
why
in z
value in the fact of having
Cor. v.
known
16 Paul
Jesus.
seems
to
deny any
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION The
ministry of Jesus?
103
controversies between Paul
and Jerusalem apostles thus establish that the latter boasted of having been witnesses of the life of Jesus a fact which Paul did not contest.
V.
EXAMINATION OF TEXTS SUPPOSED TO CONTAIN ALLUSIONS TO A CHRIST MYTH
In the opening salutation of the Epistle to the Romans Paul speaks of "Christ Jesus, born of the seed of David according to the flesh, as God had announced in advance by the prophets in the holy scriptures"
(Rom. follows from
i.
2,
3).
In
M.
Couchoud's view
14
it
this passage that the human (or apwas not told, but reparently human) life of Jesus that and to vealed Paul, by prophecies. The fact that
the apostle thought he recognized concordance between the history of Jesus and certain prophecies does not that the history has been deduced from the
prove
15 But this is not all. Two announcements prophecy. one is the existence are made in the phrase before us from David. descent His asserts of Jesus, the other The Davidic origin asserted by Paul on the faith of
notion of prophecies gives Jesus a human lineage. The a have to the Davidic origin of Jesus appears theological source. The Gospels record no word of Jesus which
supports
it.
It is
merely implied
in certain episodes to
16 which no great importance can be attached.
The
"Couchoud, Le Mysore de Jhus, 15
We
p. 131. shall return in a later chapter to the relations
prophecy and evangelical
between the
history.
We
16 put aside two genealogies, which are, besides, not concordant, found in Matt. i. 1-16 and Luke iii. 23-38. Both presume the Davidic origin of Jesus, but they are recent elements of the
tradition wanting in
Mark.
JESUS
104
THE NAZARENE
blind man, Bartimeus, addressed Jesus once as "J csus Son of David," and on another occasion as "Son of
David," according to
Mark
(x.
47, 48)
and Luke
both occasions 39), while Matthew has on 17 of the entry narrative In the simply "Son of David." into Jerusalem, organized to fulfill the prophecy of Zechariah (ix. 9), the mention of David in the popular welcome does not occupy the same place in Mark (xi. (xviii. 38,
9) and
in
Matthew
(xxi. 9),
lacking in Luke any rate, to consider One single idea re-
and
at (xix. 38), which requires us, 18 its authenticity as not certain.
is
and that is, considvague manner as the ering Jesus in a Messiah, He was sometimes spoken of as the Son of David. But there is nothing to show that Jesus Himself accepted it, and still less that He claimed this title. On the contrary, in a remark whose authenticity is be-
mains from study of these
more or
19
yond
question,
texts,
less
of Jesus appears to oppose the notions
17 It is the same in the narrative of Matt, ix 27, which is only a variant of the story of Bartimeus. We do not attach much Canaanitish woman calls importance to Matt xv. 22, where the a comparison with Mark Jesus "Lord, Son of David," because ihows that there is only a literary development involved, nor of Matt. xii. 23, where Jesus, having cured a blind and dumb demoniac, some of the bystanders ask, "Is not this man the Son of David?" because this narrative is an editorial element which offers the starting
of possession brought point supposed by Mark of the accusation Jesus against 18 The text of Zechariah contains no allusion to a Davidic Messiah. 19 It is so because the text goes directly counter to the conception of a Davidic Messiah universally received in the Church since Paul. In the ancient Church only one exception can be found. It is 10), which is directly dependent on and dominated by the idea of a supernatural birth. It should also be pointed out that the fourth Gospel appears to know of the idea of the Davidic descent, but as an objection to the Messiahship of Jesus. It does not appear that the evangelist (who holds Jesus to be a Galilean) makes a reply to the objection (vii. 42).
in the Epistle of Barnabas (xii
our
text,
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION
105
the Messiahship and the Davidic origin one against the other. In the Temple Jesus asks "How is it the scribes of David? David himself, say that Christ is the Son the Holy Spirit, says, The Lord said unto inspired by :
Lord, Sit Thou upon My right hand until I make Thine enemies Thy footstool.' David himself calls Him his Lord how then can He be his son?" (Mark
my
xii.
35-37, Matt.
xxii.
In the context, as
41-46, Luke xx. 41-44). this question appears to
we read it,
be a subtle problem propounded by Jesus to the Scribes, and which they were not prepared to solve. It is to some extent an argument ad hominem. But it is doubt20 that of the opinion of some exegetists, have here only a flash of wit. The text has a wider It establishes an antinomy between the
ful, in spite
we
implication. true Messiahship that Jesus invoked and current notion of the Messiah,
and the popular 21 Son of David.
idea of the Davidic origin of Jesus has therefore a secondary character. It is a theological creation made
The
under the influence of prophecies and popular beliefs. This tends to restrict the affirmation concerning the if not excluprophecies in Rom. i. 2-3 principally, 1 the seed of David.' sively, to the words "born of The fact that, either by Paul or by others before
him, the notion of the Davidic origin had been introduced into Christology is not without importance. The
two Jewish Messianic conception oscillated between *Zahn
(Das Ev. des
Matthau*),
Wohlcnburg
(Das
Ev.
d.
Markus). 21 This
is admitted (with various reservations, varying according to their opinion concerning the question of the Messianic consciousKlostermann and ness of Jesus) by Wellhausen, Wrede, Loisy. Job. Weiss think the passage only criticizes the Jewish conception
of the Messiah.
inadequacy.
Lagrange thinks that Jesus only wishes
to
show
it*
io6
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
and celestial Messiah poles the idea of a transcendent the execute to to come with power judgments of God, and that of a human Messiah, a king of the race of :
David, for whom and by whom the national monarchy of Israel would be restored. The first conception is found specially in the books of Daniel and Enoch, the second in the Songs of Solomon. These two concep-
have sometimes been combined; they are conChurch. stantly so in the Christology of the primitive The two currents of the Messianic conception are none the less distinct. If the Jesus of the most primitive a purely Christianity and of Paul himself had been tions
Being with no connection with humanity except an external and unreal form, why should the apostle have contradicted himself in connecting his Messiah to a human lineage? In another passage M. Couchoud thinks he also understands the inner significance of the debt of Paul spiritual
and
celestial
to the prophecy of what is supposed to be an historical tradition. The reference is to the passage in which the apostle, summing up the essentials of Christian I delivered unto teaching, expresses himself thus : "For
how that all that which I also received the to sins our for Christ died Scriptures, according and that He was buried, and rose again the third day you
first
of
Then according to the Scriptures" (i Cor. xv. 3, 4). of follows an enumeration apparitions (xv. 3-8). In the opinion of M. Couchoud, the words "according 11 to the Scriptures mark the source of the knowledge. follows therefore from this passage that faith in and partly on the Jesus rests partly on the Scriptures is in faith The possible, but not the Jesus It
apparitions.
knowledge of Jesus implied
in this faith.
The
apostle
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION
107
draws a parallel between "I have transmitted" and "I have received." which They are facts of the same class, therefore, lead us to suppose that the apostle presents himself as witness of a tradition. The teaching given and the be thus assimilated if on teaching received could not been had the one side there supernatural revelation or deduction, and on the other didactic teachexegetical
of the context confirms this first ing; the examination It may be admitted with reason that the impression.
the first rudiment of passage in question is, so to speak, It is of faith. a confession unnecessary to bring in the narrative of the visions, which belongs to the affirmation of the resurrection, and which in its amplitude contrasts with the brevity of the phrase preceding.
account of the apparitions is added to the epitome of the faith as a confirmation of the point on which Paul makes his entire argument depend. While three
The
facts are
named
in the
Pauline formula, the words "ac-
cording to the Scriptures" are only found twice in it, and these are with reference to two facts the death
which possess in Paul's thought a redemptive character. The words are wanting in in the respect of the burial, which has no importance
and the resurrection
Pauline theory of salvation, and which is only incidentally touched upon in the symbol of baptism (Rom. ii. 12). This proves that the formula the to Scriptures" has no bearing upon the "according knew facts, but upon their interpretation. What Paul
vi.
4 and Col.
but that Scriptures was not that Christ died, he when even died for our sins. Paul, persecuted
from the
He
the Christians,
knew
perfectly well that their
Master
was dead; he either did not knotf or refused to believe
JESUS
io8
He
THE NAZARENE
It was the Scriptures which, sins. of the living Christ in his certitude the once he had inner consciousness, enabled him to understand the
that
died for
meaning of
Christ's death.
Similarly, if Paul believed
in the resurrection, it was not because of the prophBeseen. ecies, but because of the apparition he had
he had read the prophecies long before he was a Christian, but he only discovered the resurrection when, in an entirely different way, the faith in the Christ still living, in spite of death, had developed sides,
within him.
M. Couchoud 22
can only see a mystical, almost the in idea Gnostic, passage of the Epistle to the Galatians, in which Paul says that in the fulfillment of
time iv.
His Son, born of a woman" (Gal. In his view there is no historical reference. alone, this text would constitute, in fact, but not even the short and insufficient biography not it does But of contain, at of a life Jesus.
"God had
4).
Taken a very outline
least, the idea
what
sent
of the historical
right besides
is
life
of Jesus?
And by
this affirmation isolated?
The
Galatians do not separate it from the teaching in which the apostle retraced the story of the crucifixion in so vivid a
manner that they had the
feeling of contem-
Paul does not plating it with their own eyes (iii. i). return to this part of his teaching because it was not contradicted by the missionaries of his opponents. Benot insides, the expression "born of a woman" was
He
from the Old Testais used to designate man under the The ordinary conditions of his birth and existence.
vented by Paul. 28 ment, where it
82 28
borrowed
Couchoud, op. cit.t p. 130. Job xi. 3-12, adv. i, rr. 14,
it
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION
109
declaration of Galatians (iv. 4) would be unintelligible had not lived under the ordiif, in Paul's view, Jesus
nary conditions of humanity. very special importance attaches to the long pas-
A
in which, in a sage of the Epistle to the Philippians, way otherwise accidental, Paul epitomizes his whole thought concerning Christ and His work. The apostle
"
being in the form of God, thought it 24 not robbery to be equal with God, but made Himself and took upon Him the form of a of no writes
:
Who,
reputation,
servant,
and was made
in the likeness
of men.
And
humbled Himbeing found in fashion as a man, He the death even death self and became obedient unto of the cross. Wherefore God also hath highly exalted Him and given Him a name which is above every name. That at the name of Jesus every knee should bow of things in heaven and things on earth and things under the earth, and that every tongue should confess that Jesus is Lord, to the glory of the Father" (Phil.
ii.
5-1 1).
that in this passage is found the ancient epitome we possess of the story of Jesus. to him to include two elements firstly, the
M. Couchoud thinks most It
appears
descent of the divine Being into humanity and His death; and secondly, His ascension and glorification.
M. Couchoud this
considers that a less lyrical version of
myth, but one containing more
details,
is
found
in
24 Often translated "as a usurpation." This translation does not seem to us permissible, because it assumes His existence in its divine form was equal with God AUTHOR. Translator's Note.Modtrn English version, based on Westcott and Hort's text, reads: "Though the divine nature was Hi from the with God as above beginning, yet He did not look upon equality all
things to be clung to,"
etc.
i
JESUS
io
THE NAZARENE
the Ascension of Isaiah.
and carried
The prophet was
away from world
seventh heaven.
caught up world up to the
to
In this region he was a spectator of drama which will mark the end of
the mysterious time. God commands a Being who is called the WellBeloved, the Chosen One, or the Son, to descend through the seven heavens, the firmament, the air, and
the earth
down
to Sheol,
where
He
is
to bind the angel
of death. That His descent shall not be perceived by the angels inhabiting the successive worlds, the Son receives the power to take to Himself in each of them a form resembling that of the beings who dwell there-
His mission accomplished, the Son ascends, this time in His own form, up to the seventh heaven. While looking upon His glorious ascension the angels are astounded. They ask how the descent of the Son of God could have escaped their perception, and they in.
are obliged to glorify Him. The celestial Being then seats Himself at the right hand of the Supreme Glory.
There are two questions to be successively examined Is the passage from the Epistle to the Philipand is the myth it expians an Apocalyptic element, :
find in the Ascension presses quite identical to that we of the affinity bethesis the that of Isaiah? Seeing tween the Ascension of Isaiah and the Epistle of the
manner into Philippians only enters in a subordinate first of all shall we the reasoning of M. Couchoud, examine
this point.
What which we
is
the Ascension of Isaiah?
know it,
it is
a fairly complex
In the form in
whole
in
which
three principal portions are easily distinguished: of i. purely Jewish narrative of the martyrdom
A
the prophet Isaiah sawn asunder by order of
Manasseh
in
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION
It appears once to have had and to have been known in an independent existence, 25 this form to Justin Martyr, Tertullian and Origen. 2. An Apocalyptic vision about Antichrist, the decadence of the Church, and the return of the Lord. In its present form this portion, whose Christian origin (i. i, 2,
12,
and
v.
1-16).
not doubtful, betrays a certain dependence as regards the Ascension, properly so called. It seems that this may be owing to editorial work, for the conception of the work of Christ found in the vision differs from is
that in the Ascension, and can neither be considered as the iv.
germ of
it
nor a development from
it
(ii.
13-
22). 3.
(vi.
The Ascension, i-n, 43), is the Isaiah
us.
was
in the exact sense
of the word
portion which specially interests away by an angel up to the
carried
seventh heaven; he received an explanation of the descent of the Well-Beloved from the higher heaven down to Sheol, whence He was to reascend to the
heaven.
The prophet
is
afterwards a witness of the
events which had been announced to him. The date of the compilation of the Ascension of
completeness as well as in each of the be determined with portions which constitute it, cannot almost Critics are absolute precision. agreed in conexact sense) cansidering that the Ascension (in the
Isaiah, in
its
not be older than the middle of the second century. It is even possible that it may be necessary to bring the date of its composition considerably later. The fact that Origen mentions the martyrdom as a Jewish book in its present proves that he did not know the Ascension 5
Justin, Dial.
c.
Tryphon; Tertullian, Scorpiace,
xiv; Origen, In. Matt., xxviii,
Comm.
viii,
De
in Matt., x. 18, etc.
patientia,
ii2
JESUS
form.
True, istence before
it
THE NAZARENE
might have had an independent
its
incorporation into the
book
as
ex-
we
The amount of Christian retouching which
read it. has undergone
eleventh chapter)
(especially the
it
is
favorable to this hypothesis. But even supposing the Ascension not anterior to the
middle of the second century, the ideas which are deInveloped in it might date back to an older period. deed, it appears necessary to distinguish in the Ascenthat concerning sion between a fundamental myth a Christian interand the descent of the celestial Being of two elements pretation given of it. This compound For inbook. the of explains certain peculiarities the Well-Beloved
stance,
receives
the
command
to
transform His image into that of the beings inhabiting various spheres of the universe, so that He may arrive without difficulty at Sheol, where He is to despoil the not pursue His angel of death (ix. 16), but He does be so expressed), it descent in a straight line (if may
and when
He
arrives
tervention of Satan
on earth
in
He has need of the inHe may reach Sheol.
2G
order that
Satan raises the jealousy of the Jews against Him, and 27 This causes them to put Him to death (xi. 19-2 1 ) in noted be is to elements of two dissimilar .
compound
another matter.
The triumph
attained through the
power Himself while traversing the
universe. 26
He
which
It is
of the Well-Beloved
He
is
receives to transform
different spheres of the
not stated that, having reached Sheol,
birth (xi 2-14), only attains to this through a supernatural an evident embellishment, and by which the narrative is
is
related to recent Apocryphal legends. 27 The incoherence betrays itself by an embellishment. In xi. 19 the Well-Beloved, crucified through the action of Satan, descends to die angel of SheoL In xi. 20 Isaiah sees Him hung on the cross.
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION He
113
battle with the angel of death.
It appears of the Chosen that the latter is incapable One, resisting and is conquered at the instant the Lord reaches Him.
wages
After
this victory the
Well-Beloved, recognized by
all
the angels, judges and annihilates the princes, angels and gods of this world and the world over which they
He
have dominion. at the right
hand of God
of the Chosen
One
This idea
sion.
is
sits down The triumph
ascends in glory, and (x.
12-15).
therefore attained by his ascenquite different from the Christian is
and anniconception, according to which the judgment hilation of the powers hostile to God is the work of Christ returning from the heavens to His second comto heaven after the ing, and not of the Lord ascending There is thus recognizable behind the resurrection. Christian interpretation which dominates the present form of the Ascension of Isaiah a myth of the reestablishment of the sovereignty of God by a divine being
descends into Sheol to despoil the angel of death, and afterwards ascends gloriously to the heavens. It that the myth may be older than Chrisis
who
possible 28
tianity. 28 It docs not appear to us that there is any direct contact between Outside the idea of the descent Paul and the Ascension of Isaiah of a celestial Being, which has a general character, and that of the ignorance of the angels, developed in both in very different but which are found ways, there are only two ideas in common, celestial of idea are the these and garments and that of elsewhere, the superposed spheres, or heavens. But Paul is only carried away Ascento the third and not to the seventh heaven, as Isaiah. In the Paul sion the five first heavens belong to the lower world, while has the feeling of having been carried away to a higher world. In Paul the revelation takes place by audition of ineffable words. Paul cannot In the Ascension it is by visions commented upon. what he heard. Isaiah relates his vision to Hczekiah and
repeat
to other prophets. viii.
14.)
(Compare 2 Cor.
r. a, xii. a,
and Aac,
iv.
16,
JESUS
ii 4
THE NAZARENE
a certain affinity between this myth and the idea dominating the Christological development of the Epistle to the Philippians, but while in Paul's Christ divests Himself of something, in the
There
is
thought Ascension of Isaiah He merely transforms Himself. The development of the Epistle to the Philippians cannot have been from the myth, because (the negative determination in which the development of the a proof of it) the work of Christ is in opposition to another myth, in Paul described by which there is recognizable the story of Satan, who desired to raise himself to supreme power and to claim for himself the adoration of men and angels, and who
myth begins
is
as a consequence of this rebellion must be annihilated. The correspondence between the work of Satan and
that of Christ ish
is
not, however, complete, since to
Jew-
thought the idea of an incarnation of Satan
was
unknown.
The
relation between the
myth of Satan and
the
drama as Paul conceives it is therefore not one of simple and direct dependence. Paul has a doctrine simply interpreted the story of Jesus by Christological
opposition to the Satanic myth. It would only be possible to see in the Christological of the Epistle to the Philippians the old-
formulated
in
development
form of the history of Jesus if this portion had been written to make the Church known to persons who had never heard it spoken of which is certainly est
not the case.
The
incidental
manner
in
which the development
even if we proceeds would alone suffice to prove it, to addressed did not already know that the Epistle is Christians to
whom
it
may perhaps be
necessary to ex-
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION
115
of the work of Christ, but superplain the importance its fluous to rehearse Replaced in its historhistory. the text of Paul is an attempt to epitomize ical setting,
the history of Jesus in one grand drama of redemption. That it contains dogmatic elements or, if you prefer is undeniable, but these elements elements it,
mythical
do not make up the substance of the story they serve as comments on it, and supply the materials for the ;
speculative construction thus furnished.
erected upon the foundation
Attention must be called to an idea borrowed from
Judaism by Paul, and which in his eyes possesses capthat of preexistence. The conception ital importance of the preexistence of souls is found distinctly in certain 29
but more distinctly still that of the pre80 Paul affirms the preexexistence of the Messiah. istence of Christ not only when, in the Epistle to the
Jewish
texts,
15), he speaks of Christ's part in creation, but also when he uses such terms as the "man from heaven" (i Cor. xv. 47, etc.), or again, when in
Colossians
(i.
a portion of rabbinical exegesis he identifies Christ with the rock which accompanied the Israelites in the desert
These affirmations do not contradict
(i Cor. x. 4).
earthly personality of Jesus; they merely imply that humanity is unable to explain to its Weinel observes roots this personality and activity. the
human and
(Wisdom of Solomon), Enoch zhii. 4 and Enoch and xhx 2 4 (Slavonic) 80 Enoch, also Esdras. Certain authors hold that in fourth Esdras the conception of the preexistence of the Messiah may be due to Schurer justly remarks against this idea that Christian influence. 29
Sap. Salomon
xxm
to Christianity, particularly post-Christian Judaism had, in opposition insisted on the humanity of the Messiah, as proved by the declaration
of the
who
reported by Justin: born of men" (Dial.,
Jew Tryphon,
will be a
man
"We
all
ilii. i).
expect a Messiah
ii6
JESUS
THE NAZARENE must only be judged was habitual to explain
in this connection that these ideas
by those of
antiquity,
when
it
the mysterious in a personality by forces belonging to 81 the spiritual another world. Just as Paul felt that ii. him Christ dwelt and lived in 20), without for (Gal. that reason losing consciousness of his own human personality, so also
was he able
to see in Christ a celestial
and preexisting Being without thereby forcibly deforced to cultivate priving humanity of Him. One is the mentality of antiquity in order to understand the of primiconceptions in virtue of which the theology
of Paul) atChristianity (and especially that of Jesus that work and in the person tempted to explain of humanity. which surpassed the common standard tive
notion of the Messiah furnished the idea of preexistence; that of divine Sonship tended to identify and the Jesus with the hypostasis of "Wisdom" "Word." In this manner, starting from soteriology, the
The
charquickly led to attribute a cosmological acter to Christ. But the movement of Pauline Chris-
mind was
from humanity tology, if so it may be called, progresses to to divinity, and not from divinity humanity. If in the Epistle to the Colossians Paul develops the theme character of Christ and the idea of of the cosmological
His sovereignty over
all celestial
beings,
it is
because
whom
he addressed were fascinated by speculations concerning angels, and it was of moment to show them that the worship of Christ attained the realities
those
of the celestial world
in a
manner more complete and
than devotion paid to angels. The whole of this side of Pauline Christology thus appears to be
efficacious
11 The supporters him was incarnate
of
Simon also believed that power of God" (Acts via. 10).
the magician
"the great
in
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION
117
the development of a doctrine elaborated on other
grounds.
The tology
Chrisdistinctly theological element of Pauline is not the point from which he sets out in
It is the result it. thought. It is the conclusion of of an effort imposed on him in the interest of practical of speculative curiosity, to apologetics, rather than and work of Jesus give an interpretation of the person harmonizing with conceptions about spiritual beings current in his time, and with the position assigned to
Paul's thought assumes Jesus by the faith. At times a character distinctly philosophic. In certain passages we have the impression of being in presence of a cos-
mological theory instead of a human history. Such, for example, is the character presented by the portion of the Epistle to the Colossians (i. 13-20) where God is referred to as He "who has delivered us from the of darkness and brought us into the Kingdom of
power His well-beloved Son." Then follows a lyrical de"in Him we have scription of what this Son is like, "For Christ is redemption, the remission of sins." the very image of the Invisible and head of all creation ; for in
God
the first-born
Him
was created all the visible and the
heaven and on earth, of angels, archangels, and all the powers for and Him created been has heaven. All through Him. He was before all things, and all things unite in Him; and He is the head of the Church, which is
that
is
in
invisible
His body. The first-born from the dead, He is to the Church the source of its life, that He in all things may stand first. For it pleased the Father that in
Him
the divine nature in
and through
Him
all its fullness
should dwell,
to reconcile all things to
Himself
JESUS
ii8
THE NAZARENE
Christ's blood (making peace by the shedding of earth or in on whether the offered upon cross)
Heaven.'
1
"
where conception developed in this passage, an almost a divine as hypostasis, Christ appears Being, in Philo, and is certainly closely resembles that found Are we to conclude that the Christ related to it.
The
of Paul
is
an ideal Being
like the
Logos of Philo?
It does not seem necessary, for the ancient mentality saw no contradiction between the human character of
a person and his divine character. One example of the association of the two concepts is given us by the fourth of a man who evangelist, who means to relate the story with the identifies he whom and has lived on earth, creative Logos. The case of the Epistle to the Colossians is quite of analogous; and if the historical side of the person the of touched is by the mention
Jesus
upon
only
cross, this
is
of explained entirely by the character decisive as considers M. Couchoud quite
the Epistle. in favor of the nonhistorical theory the passage in which Paul speaks of the wisdom of God, "that none of the great ones of this world had known, for if they had known it, they would not have crucified the glori-
Lord" (i Cor. follows from this
fied
ii.
8
)
.
M, Couchoud
text that those
who
8S
finds that
it
crucified Jesus
were mythical beings, not persons of flesh and bone, and that the drama consequently took place between heaven and earth, in an Apocalyptic atmosphere. Note. This passage is taken from the Twentieth Testament, translated from original Greek into Modern
2 Translator's
Century
New
English (Westcott and Hort's text).
M Couchoud,
op.
cit.t
p. 132.
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION And
to prove that
we
with a mythical theory,
are
certainly
M. Couchoud
119
dealing here points to the
analogy that exists between our passage and the Ascension of Isaiah, where it appears that if the angels had perceived the descent of the Son of God, they would have opposed it, and would have hindered the
accomplishment of His work. They, however, did not collaborate in any way. The part played by them 84 But, on the was entirely negative and unconscious. archons crucified contrary, according to Paul, when the the Lord, they were not ignorant that He was the 85 but they did not know the divine plan, nor Savior, did they realize that the death of Christ would cause The two concepts differ so their own annihilation. much that one cannot have been deduced from the
other they have only a very general theme in common, that of the demon deluded. It is consequently illegitimate to interpret the indication given by Paul in an ;
incidental
way by
sion of Isaiah.
the theory developed in the AscenBut there is more than this. It is
Paul attributes to the archons anything more than responsibility for the death of Christ. doubtful
if
There
easily to be recognized in
is
them the seventy
to an idea particularly deconfided the veloped in the book of Enoch, God has 86 of the world. They direct the nations
angels to
whom, according
government 84
The passage
referring to the crucifixion belongs, as
een, to a Christian modification
we have
(Asc xi. 19). 85 At any rate, Paul does not say that the archons were ignorant We cannot accept the interpretation of Dibelius, of who was Christ that Paul, like the author of the Ascension of Isaiah, thinks the archons were ignorant of who Christ was. 88 Enoch There is also a reference in the book of (Ixxxix. 59) Daniel to an angel of Persia, who fought with Michael, the angel of the people of Israel (see Dan. x. 13-20).
120
JESUS
THE NAZARENE 7
In saying that they had the Lord, Paul does not appear to have thought of anything other than the crucifixion of Jesus by men, but by men whom he considers as agents of
and
inspire their actions.*
crucified
demoniacal powers. This conception is in all points similar to that found in the fourth Gospel, where Jesus is
arrested by the cohort and tribune (guided by Judas,
Satan had entered) judged, and condemned by Pilate at the instigation of the Jews, and finally The whole drama is explained crucified by soldiers. by the action of "the prince of this world" in other into
whom
,
88
There is therefore, words, Satan (see John xiv. 30 ). as Dibelius justly remarks, no contradiction between I Cor. ii. 8 (which holds the archons responsible for the death of Jesus) and i Thess. ii. 15, where it is stated that the Jews put Jesus to death. have thus passed in review the principal pasthe Pauline Epistles where allusions to a of sages Christ myth are supposed to be found. In Paul's writdoctrine in which ings these reveal a Christological are incorporated elements borrowed from the dogmatic
We
and even fragments of myths, but it is illegitimate to reduce the whole Pauline which Christology to these, and to pass over everything to reference had in the Pauline Epistles and teaching the historical person of Jesus and to His life on earth.
tradition of Judaism,
In another chapter we shall return to the subject of the relation between these two elements. Let us only note here that this relation appears to be that between **They arc in any case responsible, since, according to Enoch, they roust be judged (xc. 22). 8 the devil excites the Similarly in the Ascension of Isaiah Him. who the crucify Well-Beloved, Jews against
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION admitted fact and
its
interpretation.
121
Far from con-
tradicting the historical personality of Jesus, Pauline Christology would be incomprehensible
had not made the
if it
historical facts its starting point.
THE GOSPEL TRADITION
VI.
the
IN
PAUL"
The Epistles of Paul contain but few allusions to the Gospel history, but when these are closely examined it is found that the apostle was much more familiar with of Jesus than a superficial reading of the Epistles would lead one to think. Paul presents Jesus as a man born of woman (i Cor. xv. 21 Rom. v. 15 Gal. iv. 4), belonging to the the
life
;
;
(Gal. iii. 16; Rom. ix. 5), and i. 3). descending from the family of David (Rom. He lived under the Jewish Law (Gal. iv. 4; Rom. xv. The Epistles say neither when nor where, but 8). since it was importance need not be attached to this, race of
Abraham
the evolution of only at a relatively secondary stage in considered necessary to esthe tradition that it was tablish synchronism in the history of Jesus (Luke 40 Paul places himself at a point of view similar iii. i )
,
know
the parents of and gives the name Jesus, he mentions His brothers, ix. Cor. of one of them, James (i 5; Gal. i. 19 and to that of
Mark.
If Paul does not
41
ii.
9; cp. i Cor. xv. 7). It is impossible to decide
how Paul
conceived the Paul
et
Msus
*See upon this subject Maurice Goguel, VApotre to which the Christ, 1904. In this work will be found a bibliography names of Joh. Weiss and P. Olaf Moc must be added. 40 These are only indicated in relation to John the Baptist i
In Paul's writings there
birth
is
no trace of the idea of a supernatural
(see Lobstein, Etudes Christologiques, 1890).
122
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
character and moral physiognomy of the Lord. It is, in fact, not always possible to recognize whether the ideas apply to passages dealing with this order of or His gloriJesus or the Christ in His preexistence the that apostle made fication, and it does not appear
upon
this subject a
even
if
very clear distinction.
However,
u the passage where Christ is called He who knew not sin" (2 Cor. v. 21) relates to the preexistent Christ, it would at least show that Paul had a belief in the perfect sanctity of Jesus. This, no doubt, at any rate, it cannot be that the is a dogmatic idea
the historical life of Jesus conapostle's conception of The exhortations to the imitation of tradicts it. Christ (i Cor. xi. I and Col. i. 10) imply also the idea of this sanctity. The love of Christ referred to in
Rom.
viii.
27,
in connecbeing presented as real, must be considered tion with the glorified Christ. But the gentleness and
meekness of Christ,
in the
horted the Corinthians (2,
name of which Paul x.
i), refer to
acter, since in this passage there
is
ex-
His char-
a transparent allu-
sion to a saying of Jesus (Matt. xi. 29). Concerning the middle period of the life of Jesus, the Epistles
contain but very
little
we who
Nevertheless, as
indeed.
have seen, Paul knew of the existence of apostles were associated with the Master's ministry. The cross
as occupied a predominating place in the preaching ii. i i Cor. iii. and in the theology of Paul (Gal. 2). The death of Jesus was portrayed as an act of
God and ii. 20). Gal and
obedience towards (Phil.
ii.
8
of love towards It
by the enmity of the Jews (i
men
was brought about Thess. ii. 15) and
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION
123
through the ignorance of the celestial archons who Paul is aware that Jesus passed the directed them. evening preceding His death with His disciples, and that it was during this last meal that He instituted
We
shall return the Lord's Supper (i Cor. xi. 23). Does it also imply that Jesus was to this testimony. His followers? This cannot be of one betrayed by
determined with certainty, for the term employed
may
well signify "betrayed" as "delivered over just It has sometimes been believed that the to death." as
execution of Jesus is indicated in the passage in which the apostle assimilates the death of Christ to the sac-
We
shall see of the paschal lamb ( I Cor. v. 7). later that this interpretation is far from being certain. rifice
At almost every page of his readers that Jesus died
his Epistles
Paul reminds
He speaks of the of shedding of 10),
on the
cross.
His violent death (2 Cor. blood (Rom. iit. 25), of the sufferings He endured Phil. iii. 10), of the (2 Cor. i. 5, 7; Rom. viii. 17; exhaustion He passed through before expiring (2 Cor. xv. xiii. 4), of the insults He submitted to (Rom. iv.
the burial of Jesus Finally he specially refers to and confirms the tradition concern(i Cor, xv. 4-8), xv. 4-8 ) ing the apparitions ( i Cor. When all these indications are grouped together the
3)
.
.
if Paul does not provide a impression is gained that coherent view of the history of Jesus, he nevertheless
and more distinctly still, possesses one. Furthermore, *2 went the of he is a witness sayings of Jesus. Resch a thousand much too far in asserting that there were 42
Resch,
criticized
Der Pauhnismus und
die Logia Jesu.
very severely, but justly, by
Wrede and
Resch has been Juiicher.
JESUS
124
THE NAZARENE
allusions to the sayings of Jesus
48
in the authentic
Those which are met with may be divided
Epistles.
allusions
suffi-
the admission that ciently precise to authorize
Paul
Into three groups: direct quotations,
had the saying of Jesus
in
cences almost unconscious.
third
series
of
allusions,
mind, and
We
finally reminisshall leave aside this
which cannot be exactly
which are far from being without signifisusfor cance, they show how the mind of Paul was Thesthe reassure To of tained by the sayings Jesus. salonians, anxious about the fate of believers who died before the second coming, Paul declared to them that at the time of the Savior's return these would be
defined, but
resurrected to join the living, and he gives this teachThess. iv. 15). It is ing "in a word of the Lord" (i the clear what it is in not teaching given which quite
attempts which have been made an allusion to a known saying of Jesus, to a passage in the Old Testament, or to an work such as Esdras (iv.), have not suc-
answers to
this.
The
to rediscover in the text
Apocryphal
44
think that Paul in this passage is writing under the speaks by revelation, and that he This interpretation conflicts inspiration of the Spirit. with the fact that when Paul communicates any teach-
ceeded.
Some
writers
he expressly ing which he holds was revealed to him, The xii. 2 Cor. xv. Cor. out i). 51; (i points this most natural thing is to suppose that Paul is quoting in this
passage an agraphon, or
in
other words a say-
Exactly 925, of which 133 are in Ephesians, 100 in the pastoral Acts. He only arrived Epistles, and 64 in the Pauline discourses at this result by stating that a parallelism existed between Paul 48
m
and the Logia, when the two texts compared possessed only one word in common. "Lucken, and Couchoud (Le Mysore de Jhus).
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION
125
tradiing of Jesus not incorporated into the Gospel 46 first of the In the seventh chapter tion. Epistle to
the Corinthians Paul gives instructions to married he writes, "my people. "To those who are married," the Master's) but direction is (yet it is not mine,
woman
is not to leave her husband" (verse 10). referred to is the reply of Jesus to here The saying the Pharisees concerning the subject of divorce (Mark
that a
12; Matt. xix. 9), preserved in a slightly different form in the Sermon on the Mount (Matt. v.
x.
ii,
What gives to this citation all its importance the fact that two verses farther on, considering a wife is not particular case (that of a Christian whose 32). is
a believer, or on the other hand, that of a Christian u woman married to a pagan), Paul writes: To all others I say, I, not the Master." Similarly, in the
course of the chapter, Paul says that, concerning vir-
"has no
command from
gins and unmarried women, he is content the Master" (i Cor. vii. 25; cp. 40). If the word of the Master to give his own opinion.
He
was
in
thinks,
Paul a revelation of the it
Spirit, as
M. Couchoud
would be very surprising that upon a matter
so important for the
produced no oracle.
life
of the Church, the Spirit In is more than this.
But there
the Lord, Paul gives his own to it. It is not opinion, and he attaches great weight that of one to but the opinion of an ordinary man, whom the Master has given the power to be faithful,
the place of the
word of
can thus boast of being an authorized interthe Spirit. preter of His thought and who possesses Notwithstanding this opinion, Paul takes good care
who
not to claim an authority equal to that of the Master's 46
Schmiedel, Dibelius, Feme.
126
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
a decisive proof that it was indeed from a word coming Jesus that the apostle meant to and to this word he attributes an absolute cite,
words.
.
Here
authority. In the
is
cites a saying of who preach the those of Jesus to establish the right the churches. 'The Lord gospel to be maintained by u that those who preach he writes, has commanded," the gospel shall live by the gospel." Here is certainly an allusion to the words spoken at the sending forth
same Epistle also Paul
of the disciples on a mission: "If ye are received in a house, eat and drink what is set before you, for the laborer is worthy of his hire" (Luke x. 7; Matt, now reach the last of the citations of x. 10). the words of Jesus found in Paul's Epistles, and it is
We
almost the most important and the most discussed chapter of the first among them. In the eleventh 40 Paul, in combating the Epistle to the Corinthians defective manner in which the Lord's Supper was celebrated at Corinth, recalls what took place on the last 47 He writes "I have received from evening of Jesus. I have in turn given to you." and Lord the :
.
Many critics
.
.
48
consider that the words "I have received
from the Lord"
indicate that there
was
a vision at
the origin of the tradition concerning the last supper. They mean "I have received" in the sense "I have it
Other writers adopt a less directly from the Lord." 49 and Bousset 50 think that radical opinion. Loisy Paul, by a kind of autosuggestion, reached the point of rejects this text as an interpolation. Maurice Goguel, L'Eucharutte des ongmes & Justin Martyr. "Percy Gardner, The Origin of the Lord's Supper, 1893.
Drews (Die Christusmythe)
7
*
Loisy, Les Mysteres patens et le mystire Chrttien, 1919. D. Schr. d. N.T., ii, p. 3.
w Bousset,
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION
127
had
contemplating in vision the scene that tradition 81 and transmitted to him. Others, like Pfleiderer 52 believe that Paul obtained from a revelation, Haupt, not the account of the last supper of Jesus, but the knowledge of the sacramental character and significance of the
Eucharist
Paul authorizes or justifies can we accept the hypotheNeither such a distinction. sis of Lietzmann and Ed. Meyer, who suppose that Paul synthesized in the vision on the Damascus road
Nothing
in the text of
knew of
Besides, the initial vision Jesus. did not determine Paul's knowledge of Jesus; it caused his faith to be born. All intermediate solutions should
that he
all
be put aside.
We
are in face of a dilemma: Either
the entire tradition about the last supper possessed for Paul a visionary origin, or the formula, "I have received from the Lord," means something other than
"I
know by means of
a vision."
there had been
a vision,
If
it
would not diminish
in the eyes of the apostle the value of the tradition
it
the contrary, its authority would be the more increased it would be surprising that the apostle should not expressly relate a detail of a nature to related.
On
;
impress his readers. Paul draws a very close parallel between the two and "I have transexpressions "I have received" mitted" (or "passed on"). They are of the same if on one side nature, which would not be the case received it was a case of a supernatural communication
imby the apostle, and on the other didactic teaching 1
Urchnsttntum, i. die Ursprungliche Form Veber "Haupt, Abtndmahlswrtt, 1894. Pfleiderer,
und Bcdtutung der
128
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
above all, nothing parted to the Corinthians. And, received from the have "I understand to authorizes us 11 Lord in the sense "I have it direct from the Lord. 1 '
here uses preposition "apo" which the apostle exwithout but the of tradition, marks the first origin to say is cluding an intermediary. What Paul wishes tradition goes back to the Lord, that in the last
The
analysis the words which he relates.
who pronounced
in the Epistle to the Galatians (i. i) Paul affirm that he holds his apostleship direct to desires
When
from Christ and from God without any human intervention, he uses the two prepositions "apo" and "dia," which proves that he perfectly conceives an apostlehuman intership coming from God, but not through mediaries. The use in our passage of the single preposition "apo" shows that the apostle only means the What he means to say is first origin of the tradition. that the narrative comes from the Lord by the interbe mediary of men. This detail did not require to announced; for the Corinthians it was clear from the very position of the apostle. The direct study of the text and its comparison with
explicitly
the
tradition fixed in the Gospel of Mark Doubtless the Gospel of conclusion.
form of the
confirms this
Mark was
after the only. compiled a couple of decades
of the comEpistle to the Corinthians, but the date be identinot must pilation of a work like a Gospel
with that of the traditions it contains. The two texts read as follows: Mark xiv. 22-25: "While they were eating, Jesus took some bread, and
fied
after saying the blessing, broke it and said : Take it ; this is body.
My
cup,
and gave to them, Then He took the
and after saying the thanksgiving, gave
it
to
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION
129
My
covethem, and they all drank from it. This is nant blood, He said, which is poured out on behalf of many. I tell you that I shall never again drink of the juice of the grape until that day drink it new in the Kingdom of God."
The
first
when
I shall
Epistle to the Corinthians, xi. 23-25 : "For Lord the account which I
I myself received from the have in turn given to you
how
the
Lord
Jesus,
on
the very night of His betrayal, took some bread, and, after saying the thanksgiving, broke it and said: This own body, given on your behalf. Do this in is
My
Me.
And
in the same way with the cup, This after supper, saying: cup is the new covenant made by My blood. Do this whenever you drink it, 58 in memory of me." In order to keep to the essential points, we shall
memory
of
note the following peculiarities:
round of the cup as well as after the distribution of bread, an order of There is none either in Mark or Matthew. 1.
Paul
gives, after the passing
repetition.
the dis19) gives the order only after bread. the tribution of
Luke
(xxii.
the phrase 'This is body," which accomPaul adds "given panies the distribution of bread, 2.
My
To
For the question before us we confine ourselves to comparing the of Paul and Mark, bringing into the question Matthew only The latter, compared with Mark (xxvi 29) in a subordinate way The account in Luke variations some offers unimportant only, to arise from the combination of two different 88
texts
(xxii.
15-20) appears For a more detailed study see
traditions.
M. Goguel
(UEucharistie,
pp. 105-26),
Translator's
Century Hort.
New
m
Twentieth Testament in Modern English, based on Westcott and Note.
Verses
quoted
arc
from
text
of
I3
o
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
for you," which has no equivalent in Mark or Matthew, but only in Luke. to the words which end 3. Paul has no equivalent that is to the repast found in Mark and Matthew He would drink that from Jesus say, no declaration no more of the juice of the grape before drinking it In Luke (xxii. 16) of a first cup. the distribution this phrase accompanies It must, however, be noted that in a fragment which
new
in the
Kingdom of God.
narrative of appears no longer to form part of the the is the last supper, but which commentary on really
Paul says: "For whenever drink this cup, you proclaim He comes" (i Cor. xi. 26). of the eschatological formula it,
stitute
you eat
this
bread and
the Lord's death until
This is a reminiscence which appears to conof the Lord's elements of the principal one
Supper. All these peculiarities have a common character; they tend to assimilate the two elements constituting the rite to each other and to present them as a special
by Jesus. They progress, therefore, exactly same way as the evolution of the rite. This which at first appears to have had a double character,
institution in the
the carrying out of a of Jesus of that which at the origin had
was the transformation
command
into
probably only been an instinctive repetition favored by the memory preserved of the last evening passed with Him. On the other hand, the evolution had as its result to form out of the distribution of the cup and while parallel and equivalent symbols, the at that to reason there origin these suppose every the same two actions of Jesus had neither object nor the same significance. The distribution of the bread the bread is
two
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION
131
symbolized the gift that Jesus made of Himself to His followers and for His followers; the cup illustrated the meeting place that He gave them in the Kingdom of God. Now the evolution of the texts must have tended continually to conform more closely the narratives to the
rite.
It is inconceivable, while
had the feeling, in he was repeating the that Eucharist,
celebrating the actions of Jesus, that additions should have been made to the story which would have differentiated it from the rite. The
the
believer
subordinate compared with the Its origin is not to be tradition preserved in Mark. in a supernatural revelation, but in an his-
of Paul
text, then,
is
sought
torical tradition to
which Paul
is
the witness.
Beyond quotations, properly so called, there are in Paul's writings a certain number of allusions to words of Jesus. It will suffice here to indicate the most characteristic
M
:
4: "Therefore he who disregards this warning, disregards not man, but God, who gives you His Holy Spirit." Compare with Luke x. 16: "He I
who jects
Thess.
iv.
listens to
you
is
you
is
rejecting
Me, and he who reMe; while he who rejects Me
listening to
Me as His Messenger." to isolate you." wish Compare Gal. iv. 17: "They with Matt, xxiii. 13 "But alas for you, teachers of the is
rejecting
Him who
sent
:
You Pharisees, hypocrites that you are. faces. in men's of Heaven turn the key of the Kingdom do not go in yourselves nor yet allow those For
Law and you
who
try to
go
in to
do
so."
versions are taken from the Testament, baicd on Westcott and Horf text from original Greek. 84 Translator's
NQU.
Twentieth Century
New
The English
JESUS
I32
THE NAZARENE
"Bear one another's burdens, and so carry out the Law of Christ." Compare with Mark ix. 33 "If anyone wishes to be first, he must be last of all and Gal.
vi.
2
:
:
servant of all" u
We
meet abuse with blessings, we meet persecution with endurance, we meet slander with gentle appeals." Rom. xii. 14: "Bless your perMatt, secutors, bless and never curse." Compare with "Blessed are you when people taunt you, and v. 1 1 Cor.
I
iv.
12, 13:
:
evil about you persecute you and say everything sake." Luke vi. 28 "Show kinduntruly, and for
My
who hate you, bless those who insult you."
ness to those
pray for
:
who
those
curse you,
"Having been present in spirit at your with meetings when the power of the Lord Jesus was us." Compare "For where two or three have come them" (Matt, together in My name I am present with i
Cor.
v.
4
:
:
xviii.
20). Cor. xiii. 2: "Even though I have such faith as 20: might move mountains." Compare Matt. xvii. could faith were only like a mustard seed, you "If i
your
to that,' say to this mountain, 'Move from this place and it would be moved." Compare Mark xi. 22, Matt
and Luke xvii. 6. "Even though I give My substance 1 Cor. xiii. 3 to the poor." Compare Luke xii. 23 "Sell what beCompare Mark longs to you and give in charity." x. 21 and Matt. xix. 21. "I exhort you by the meekness and 2 Cor. x. i
xxi. 21,
:
:
:
Matt. gentleness of Christ." Compare meek and lowly in heart."
Rom.
xii.
xi.
29: "I
am
17: "Never return injury for injury."
PAUL AND GOSPEL TRADITION Compare Matt.
v.
39: "I say unto you,
133
resist
not
evil."
Rom.
xiv.
14: "I
know and am persuaded
that
Compare Matt. xv. II : nothing mouth that defiles a man's enters "It is not what is
defiling in itself."
him." speculate on the that the origin of the acquaintance apostle Paul had with the Gospel tradition. The nucleus of what It is impossible to
do anything except
he knew must have dated back to the period preceding his conversion, and have depended upon what was told about Jesus in the first church of Jerusalem. The knowledge which he possessed in his pre-Christian
days was enriched and developed afterwards. The abundance of the allusions to the words of the Jesus and the reminiscences found in the Epistles, fact that
ings
Paul appears more often to allude to sayto his readers, causes one to think he must
known
have been acquainted with a collection of the sayings of Jesus. The majority of those to which he refers
Hence appear to belong to the tradition of the Logia. Paul that one is induced to entertain the hypothesis must have been acquainted with a form of this collection.
Epistles of Paul afford then precise testimony tradition besupport of the existence of the Gospel
The in
fore him.
They presume
a Jesus
who
lived,
acted,
and who
for believers, taught, whose life was a model that in Paul are only is it True cross. died on the found fragmentary and sporadic indications concernbut this is explained ing the life and teachings of Jesus,
on one hand by the fact that we possess no coherent and complete exposition of the apostle's preaching, and
i
34
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
on the other hand by the character of his interests. He had no special object in proving what no one in his time called in question namely, that Jesus had existed. His unique aim was to prove (what the Jews refused to admit) that Jesus was the Christ.
CHAPTER
VI
THE THEOLOGY OF THE APOSTLE PAUL THE CHARACTER OF PAULINE THOUGHT
I.
THE oldest systematic form we can
discern
is
of Christian thought which that which the Epistles of Paul
(whose composition took place approximately between find the years 50 and 62) makes known to us. at worked not if a out, therein theoretically theology
We
any rate of very coherent character. It is important to examine its character and see whether it may be considered as a development from Jewish and Greek premises, or
bring
in
if it
be necessary to
an historical factor
its
the
comprehension to and death of
life
Jesus.
The fragmentary developments which we
possess in essential the with deal the Epistles only points in the and system; the picture resulting from their assemblage combination should nevertheless with the exception
of some unimportant details give us a fairly accurate sketch of the general aspect that the apostle's teaching
must have presented. If Paul's was a powerful and systematic mind the Epistle to the
Romans
alone suffices to prove
and it
was not dominated by philosophic preoccuteach a Paul preached a gospel and did not pations. He was the bearer of a message of salvadoctrine. his teaching
desired to pluck men from perdition and of death, and assure their access to the Kingdom
tion.
He
35
JESUS
i36
THE NAZARENE
God, not to instruct them and reveal to them a history and an explanation of things. Religious affirmations these affirmations predominate in the Epistles. But includes presuppose a very general conception, which not only a history of humanity, but a theory of the world and a doctrine concerning God, celestial beings, and an explanation of the origin of evil, sin and death.
II.
GOD AND DEMONS
apostle's thought was rooted in the of Israel, his point of view as retradition religious from the radical gards divinity is sufficiently different and uncompromising monotheism which characterizes
Although the
certain declarations of the second Isaiah or of Jere-
miah:
"Then take
shall
thereof
man to (wood) and warm it
be for a
burn, for he will himself: yea, he
and baketh bread; yea, he maketh a god and worshipeth it, he maketh it a graven image and
kindleth
falleth
it
thereto. He burneth part thereof (tree) he eateth flesh; he roasteth roast and is 'Aha yea, he warmeth himself and saith,
down
in the fire; satisfied;
I
And the residue I have seen the fire.' his even a he maketh thereof graven image god, I
am warm.
1 '
15-17; cp. Jer. x. 3-11). be better styled point of view of Paul might "monotheism." "Although there "monolatry" than earth many are," he wrote, "either in heaven or on (Isa. xliv.
The
There are indeed . . . beings which are called gods. many gods and lords, yet is there for us but one God, the Father, from
whom
all
things proceed (and for
THE THEOLOGY OF PAUL Him we
137
and one Lord, Jesus Christ" (i Cor. at least, for him who posPractically 5, 6). this formula amounts to that of sesses the gnosis live)
viii.
monotheism, since Paul offers it as a commentary upon the other formula which the Corinthian Gnostics employed: "We are aware that an idol is nothing in the world, and that there is no God but one (i Cor. is that he Paul drawn The conclusion viii. 4). by who possesses the gnosis that is, he who knows the 1 '
demons can enter with impunity into them when consuming food offered to relation with He no longer pays them worship, and he no idols. more seeks their favor than he fears their enmity.
true nature of
But those who have not yet attained this degree of knowledge ought to fly from communion with idols 1 Paul distinctly which for them would be pollution. declares that an idol
is
to say, it is worship paid to an idol is not
nothing
that
is
not a divine being. The directed to God, but to demons, and has the effect of into direct relation with them, putting the worshiper and thereby exposing himself to divine anger. There the Unique Father exist, therefore, other gods than these are the demons who, under the guise of idols, are adored by pagans. Idolatry is an insult to God, who alone has the right to be adored. In the very fact that they have claimed worship, the demons have made themselves enemies of God. Although we do
not find in the Epistles explicit theories on this point, the it is very probable that Paul does not explain origin of
demons by a fundamental and
dualism, but by the theory of 1
irreducible
Satan, a celestial
being
Maurice Goguel, L'EuConcerning communion with demons, see
chart f tief p. 167.
JESUS
38
i
THE NAZARENE
rebelled against God. An allusion to this theory is found in the great Christological passage of the the attitude of the Epistle to the Philippians, where to that of another being preexisting Christ is opposed that is full divinity himself for to seize who
who
sought
to say, desired to impose himself upon man to be worof Satan, who seduced shiped* Through the rebellion in his train a faction of celestial beings, there
away was created in the face of God an army of demons hostile to Him. There are the enemies referred to in The last to be conquered and I Cor. xv. 25, 26. as destroyed will be Death, who is not to be imagined an abstract power, but as a personality, Thanatos, the Epistle probably identical with Satan himself. In
to the
Hebrews, whose thought upon many points
closely related to Paul's, the devil fied
with Thanatos
in the
is
is
directly identi-
formula, "he
who
has the
power of death that is to say, the devil" (Heb. The same identification is not found formally ii. 14). It appears, however, to be inferable from in Paul. u
god of world" (2 Cor. iv. 4) who is evidently the devil, and on the other hand he asserts the existing world is death owing to sin (Rom. subjected to the dominion of fairly precise indications.
Paul speaks of a
this
v.
12, vi. 23;
I
Cor. xv. 21
).
According to
I
Cor.
the abandonment of the incestuous to the power of Satan will have as its consequence the destruction that is, the death of the guilty one. of the flesh v. 5,
According to I Cor. x. 10, the rebellious Israelites in the desert were delivered over to the exterminator 2 It follows from these (Satan), who destroyed them. world" "Through the jealousy of the devil, death entered the first" the from a murderer was devil "The of Solomon). (Wisdom 2
THE THEOLOGY OF PAUL
139
passages that Satan and Thanatos are two equivalent terms, or, more precisely, Thanatos is Satan considered as exercising one of his essential functions. Satan before his rebellion was one of the beings of the army of heaven. The existence of a whole hier-
archy of beings inhabiting the heavens angels, archangels, thrones, dominions, principalities and powers to the Colossians particularly referred to in the Epistle has nothing in it which is contrary to the will (i. 16)
Evil comes uniquely from the action of these beings, who, instead of keeping the subordinate position appertaining to them, dared to
and design of God.
rise
and oppose themselves to God. Thus
is
explained
the fact that the Pauline theory not only insists upon a disorder introduced into humanity, but also of a
disorder within the cosmos, making necessary the redemption not of humanity alone, but of the entire creation
(Rom.
viii.
19-22)
in
other
God
reestablishing of the sovereignty of
words, (
i
Con
the xv.
24-26). III.
SIN
AND EVIL
If this notion of cosmic disorder
is
fundamental
in
the thought of Paul, and if the redemption of sinners in is with him but a portion of a more general work, and his Epistles it is the notion of human his
preaching redemption which occupies the premier place. Looked at from the point of view of humanity, evil takes the form of sin. It is a state of things whose "Satan, the Evil One, and 44). identical" (Rabbi Simon ben Lakisch).
(John are
viii.
the Angel of Death
i
4o
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
essential characteristic
dishonors
His
will
God (Rom.
ignorance of God, estrangeSin (i Cor. xv. 34).
is
ment and opposition to
Him
ii.
23);
it
and His law (Rom. ii. 8, weakness (Rom.
also a state of
is
rebellion against
iii.
5, xi.
30, etc.)
v. 6, vi.
;
Paul
19) does not only conceive it as an act or series of acts, but as a state characterized by the subordination of it is
humanity to a power hostile to vi.
17-20,
resides the
God (Rom.
.
iii.
9, v. 19,
It is in the flesh that
20; Gal. iii. 22). power of sin, and through which
vii.
it is
ex-
Sin
is 3).* 5-14* the to universal. The whole beginning of the Epistle Romans is devoted to establishing this thesis, and paridea cherished by Judaticularly that (contrary to an
ercised
(Rom.
vi.
12,
vii.
viii.
them less ism) the sin of the Jews does not separate from God than the sin of the pagans (Rom. ii. 1-3, The law, indeed, is not a 1 8, xi. 32; Gal. iii. 21). means of escaping from the domination and conseis to reveal it (Rom. quences of sin. Its first task In a certain sense it gives sin manifestation iii. 20). transforming a tendency more or less unconscious
by
open rebellion (Rom. iv. 15, v. 13, vii. 7-13; Gal. and 22). In itself, however, the law is holy, just
into iii.
life good (Rom. vii. 12). It was designed to give in other obtain to life, or, in showing the path to follow God of the to access (Rom. vii. 10), Kingdom words, and rendered disarmed been has but it impotent by the
3). It is the disorder introduced into the world which has prevented the law producing the effects it should have done. flesh
*
to if
(Rom.
We may is
14,
viii.
leave aside the question, difficult enough to answer, as flesh is the cause or only the seat of the sin, and so by its very nature or as a result of a fall.
whether the it
vii.
THE THEOLOGY OF PAUL
141
This brings us to the question of capital importance the origin of sin. Faithful on this point to Jewish dogma, Paul seeks the origin of sin in the disobedience of Adam. His
in the interpretation of Paulinism
expressed in the parallel between Adam and of the Jesus Christ, which appears to have been one habitual themes of his preaching, and of which we possess two examples, both incomplete, in I Cor. xv. is
theory
45-47, and tion
is
Rom.
in
that
sin
disobedience of
v.
The
12-21.
entered
the
Adam (Rom.
central affirma-
world
through the 17-19). This dis-
v.
obedience has introduced a principle which produces consequences even where there are no acts of rebellion
Adam (v. 21). Paul conceived the disobedience of the first man to the narrative in Genesis (iii. 1-19), to alludes (2 Cor. xi. 3). But the disobedience of Adam is only an similar to that of
certainly
according
which he historical
and explanation of the origin of sin. It shows when, in what conditions, sin entered the world; it does not
The theory, therefore, only explain why it exists. not solve it. puts the problem further back; it does So Paul looks
at the
problem again and from another
for it is a question point of view, and he indicates of indications only and not of a theory systematically worked out how the seduction of Satan was exercised and what the relation is between the sin of man and It is in Rom. the rebellion of Satan against God. sole the i. 18-32, where is to bfc found passage that
might be called a philosophy of indications are
argument is
is
met
with.
The
an admission of
religion, that these
starting point of the
fact.
The wrath
of
God
manifested from heaven upon the injustice and im-
JESUS
I42
THE NAZARENE How
is it that men mankind (Rom. i. 18). to worrefused have and to truth so thus are opposed To this question which is, besides, not ship God? Paul replies by rejecting the expressly formulated a of idea complete ignorance of God on the part of man. God revealed Himself to men, but they fell into
piety of
of this attitude idolatry (i. 19-23). The punishment their to men abandoned is that God passions, which crime and imof caused them to fall into all kinds
24-32). In the beginning there was, therewhose fore, a kind of natural knowledge of God, invisible attributes, infinite power and divinity are revealed in creation (i. 19, 20). But man rejected
purity
this
(i.
knowledge of God offered to him
(i.
21); he
refused to give the worship due to God; his heart became hardened, and has lost itself in vain speculaThus came about the adoration of men and tions. animals, rendering to the creature the worship which Creator. Idolatry is the root rightly belonged to the
provoked abandoned man to his evil passions. These without doubt existed before this, but they were to some extent it was this control disciplined and kept under control; of
all sin.
The
divine wrath which
it
which was destroyed. Idolatry does not affect hua pervermanity alone. Paul does not conceive it as sion of the religious sense which substitutes imaginary adore demons beings for its real object. Idolaters that
is,
celestial spirits in rebellion against
God.
In
two orders of beings in idolatry we find in alliance rebellion against God Satan and his angels, who claim the worship which only belongs by right to God, and mankind, which consents to accord to them the wor:
ship which
it
refuses to
God.
The second
of these
THE THEOLOGY OF PAUL
143
In 2 Cor. xi. 3 it is a result of the first. of sin there was a seducthe at that shown beginning demons obtained act the the is tion by Satan it whereby the worship of mankind. Human sin is thus in direct facts
is
;
relation with the rebellion of Satan.
Sin
is
thus not
a cosmic fact; it is but one only a human fact; it of consequence of Satan's rebellion, one special case is
the disorder which was thus introduced into the universe. In fact, notwithstanding the extremely valuable indications which are given us in the passage in Rom. it is almost exclusively of the consequences viii.
19-22,
Sin involves for humanity of sin that Paul speaks. "The wages of sin is death" (Rom. vi. 23). death. But the mechanism of this consequence, if we may so
term
it,
aspects.
is presented by Paul under two Sometimes we meet with the idea of
and necessary relation takes place to some degree of
logical
God
out
breeds death.
This
own nature and
with-
sin its
intervening to exact any sanction.
what Paul viii.
:
calls
different
a kind of
"the law of sin
This
is
and death" (Rom.
2; cp. v. 12).
In consequence of sin man has fallen under the dominion of death, which must reign until at the moment at the end of time, when it will be destroyed beside this, we by Christ (i Cor. xv. 24, 25). But find almost at every page of the Pauline Epistles the
idea that death
is
the result of a judgment. The conand the return of the Lord who will
cept of judgment execute it has such precision in Paul's thought that, * is like I Cor. iv. 3, the word "day" in a
passage
meant
in the sense
Paul writes 4
Day
:
"We
of judicial authority of judgment. shall all appear before the judgment
of Lord's return
JESUS
144
THE NAZARENE
(Rom. xiv. 10; cp. with 2 Cor. v. 10). of With the idea judgment must be combined that of the divine wrath which at the end of time will fall upon the guilty (i Thess. i. 10, v. 9; Rom. i. 18, ii. 5, v. 9; scat of
God"
There are thus
Col. iiL 6).
in Paul's
thought two
God
appears as a Judge who executes upon sin the penalty it deserves according to the other, He is a witness, to some degree not at passive, or rather the penalty He imposes comes,
According to one,
conceptions.
;
the end of time, but at the very moment that sin in the fact appears in the world. It consists entirely that humanity is abandoned to the power of Satan.
probably because he found these two conceptions in the religious traditions of his nation that Paul allowed them to coexist in his mind, and that he It is
perhaps was unaware of the contradiction existing between them.
IV.
The human
THE REDEMPTION
disorder in the world and the corruption of nature demands a work of restoration, a re-
demption.
Paul
insists greatly
initiative
of this work
all this is
the
1
Man 8
work of God,' he wrote
here can boast of nothing.
There
is
on the idea that the God alone. "But
belongs to
(2 Cor. v. 18).
It is
God who
calls
a certain amount of incoherence in Paul's thought on
The Judge is sometimes God and sometimes Christ (2 Cor. The first is related to the ancient Hebrew tradition of v. 10). Yahwch (judge) the second is more Messianic Dialectically, the contradiction is resolved by the idea of God judging through Jesus this.
;
Christ (Rom. ii. 16). In a subordinate position is found in Paul the idea of judgment of the world by the saints (see i Cor. vi. a). In his struggle with Judeo-Christianity he insists much upon the
THE THEOLOGY OF PAUL
145
men to salvation 7 (i Thess. ii. 12, v. 9; I Cor. i. 9; Rom. viii. 28, ix. 24, xi. 32). Redemption appears at first as an effect of the love of God (Rom. v. 5, viii. of the grace of God. This 39). It is also an act notion of grace, which holds a central position in
Pauline thought, is, above all, a practical one. Grace, in the life of Paul, had been an experience before it became an object of his theological meditations. There a certain lack of homogeneity at least in expression redemption being attributed
is
noticeable in
him
sometimes to love, sometimes to compassion, sometimes to the grace of God. This would be difficult to if
explain
we were dealing with
a logically constructed
theory, but, on the contrary, it is very readily explained if experience of redemption had preceded dogmatic Paul feels that what he is as a Christian reflection. and an apostle is the work of the grace of God. "By the grace of God," he writes, "I am what I am." He
he had undergone, at the moment of his not conversion, a change which his former life had feels that
his routine exprepared; that he was thrown outside It was this same coerced. been had he istence that ;
force which was at
Cor. xv. 10 ; 2 Cor.
work
in his apostolic activity
(i
xii.
9). Paul in his own eyes is Just as the Christian life of an original creation and not the resultant of earlier of grace which factors, so also it is that the notion roots in Judaism. Indeed, in explains it has no deep the Septuagint the word "grace" means only the ideas for example, impotent to effect salvation. See, 16. ii Gal. Rom. ao; 13, all to 7 may leave aside the question whether He destines whether the fact that and mankind of a or only, part salvation, freedom. all are not saved is explicable by divine decree or by human
idea that the ii.
We
Law
"i.
is
JESUS
146
THE NAZARENE
of favor, benevolence, benediction, and pardon, and not that of a divine force which creates in man somebe looked for in Helthing new. Its origin cannot In Philo's writings grace means the lenism either. natural gifts which constitute man a reasonable being, but so far
away
is
Philo from Paul's characteristic
idea of aid accorded to a sinner, and precisely because he is a sinner, that the assertion is found of the eternal
when wickedness began springs of grace being dried up In the into enter the world (De opificio Mundi). bestowed a the term "grace" means by gift scriptions
the sovereign authority. In certain Pauline texts grace appears, without the being precisely defined, as the primary source
thought of salvation (2 Cor.
viii.
9, xiv.
9; Gal.
i.
In
16).
others it is a divine force which seizes man, calls him, in other words, makes transforms him, justifies him
of him
who was condemned
of God.
It is
a power which takes possession of
and permeates of
ransomed being, a
a
his entire life.
But
its
child
man
independence
does not exclude the moral character of
man
action in producing a renewal
the personality
(Rom.
iii.
24,
its
and a transformation of iv. 4, xi. 5,
6; Gal.
i.
15).
Sometimes grace is hypostatized; it seems as though for example, in the parallel it were a personal power between
Adam
but this
is
and Jesus Christ (Rom.
v.
nothing more than a 6gurative
15-21)
mode of
expression.
character of Pauline theology, its is to substioriginality in comparison with Judaism, of justice of for that of merit, notion tute the grace this point imputed for that of acts performed. Upon
The
Paul
is
essential
distinctly conscious
of separating himself from
THE THEOLOGY OF PAUL
147
the religion of his fathers. It is this opposition which explains the energy with which he insists upon the absolutely gratuitous and unearned character of salvation. However, the independence of grace has its the thesis he affirms with so much ferFrom limits. vor, Paul does not
draw what would seem
to be the
namely, that the unique and allis to be found in the paternal heart of God. The comparison between Pauline thought and the teaching of the Gospel is here very
logical deduction
sufficient cause of salvation
In the parable of the prodigal son pardon is not subordinated to the accomplishment of any other that is to condition than the repentance of the sinner
instructive.
depends upon no relations outside those between In Paul the offender and the one offended against. be would salvation For him same it is not the thing.
say,
it
the reason of impossible without the cross. What is It is not enough to say that as a this difference? Pharisee Paul was too much concerned to safeguard
God to accept the idea of a free pardon the holiness of God, Pharisaism besides for sin, for insisted also upon His omnipotence. The true reason Paul was obliged to explain the fact is elsewhere.
the holiness of
of the death of Christ, which thus appeared as one of From the most essential premises of his theology. the necessity of this explanation arose the Pauline doctrine of redemption. the pardon of God is not the effect In Paul's writings
iniof a free, spontaneous and immediately efficacious of It is subordinated to the accomplishment tiative.
a
work of redemption. For Paul salvation is not
only a "processus" within the divine, designed to conciliate love and justice. This
JESUS
i 48
THE NAZARENE
order of ideas which is represented in the Pauline It cordoctrine of redemption does not exhaust it. of a violation responds to the idea of sin conceived as the law of
But as rebellion against Him. fruitremain would man to granted
God and
the divine pardon
were not accompanied by a victory gained over the evil powers, who, owing to sin, exerGod has concised their dominion over humanity. ceived for the realization of salvation a plan which reveals a wisdom infinitely superior to that of the less if it
by God
the object of the I Cor. teaching imparted by the apostle to the perfect ( is rewhich the is This xi. ii. 6; Rom. mystery 33).
world.
This plan of redemption
is
vealed unto the elect (Col. i. 25, ii. 2). Redemption has a double object. Man must one day appear before the judgment seat of God, and if he be abandoned to himself he will not escape condemnation. Redemption has the effect of making him the object of a judgment of acquittal, and thus having part in the divine Kingdom. On the other hand, the sinner must be delivered from the evil powers who have dominion over him. To these two elements correspond
two
different
moments of
the
work of redemption
and redemption properly so
on one side on the other. On one side this distinction corbetween responds to that which Paul makes elsewhere of Christ, between the two parts of the redeeming work that accomplished by His death and resurrection and that which will be accomplished at the day of His justification
called
The work
glorious return at the end of the age. justification
redemption xv. 24).
is is
achieved
in
principle,
while that of
only hoped for (2 Thess.
However,
if
of
ii.
8;
I
Cor.
redemption depends upon the
THE THEOLOGY OF PAUL victory that Christ
is
149
to gain at the end of the age
His enemies, His triumph is certain, for by His death and resurrection Jesus has conquered and that is, the spirdespoiled the powers and dominions
over
all
itual beings hostile to
God
to
whom
humanity is now which gives to the
This it is enslaved (Col. ii. 15). Christian hope of Paul so special a character. work of justification is described by Paul with
The much
This is not precision than that of redemption. historical plane, only because the first develops upon an end of the age, the at while the second will take place
more
and
will
character.
consequence possess an extrahistorical Paul's theoIf, in theory, redemption, on
in
logical system, possesses as
much importance
as justi-
not so from the practical point of view. The whole missionary effort of Paul and Paul was a the missionary before all else is concentrated upon This point acceptation of justification by the sinner. else followed, for, from the once gained, everything individual point of view, redemption appeared as a which the consequence of justification, and the spirit of it is the assurance (Rom. v. 10, justified one receives
fication, it is
viii.
23; Gal.
iv.
V.
6).
THE CHRIST AND His WORK
upon which the Pauline doctrine of justification rests is that of two worlds, one under succeeding the other. The present world, placed
The fundamental
idea
the dominion of evil powers, has for
20,
ii.
perish.
essential char-
death and impotence (Gal. i. 4; I Cor. It is destined to 6, iii. 18; 2 Cor. iv. 3). The world of the future is the Kingdom of
acteristics sin, i.
its
i
5o
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
The time which passes between His return is an intermediate and Christ of the death we may so period, in which the two economies (if other. The old dispensation it) overlap each Christ and of God.
express
which (or economy) still subsists, since of the powers will perish ( I Cor. ii. reign over it, it is said that they it is never said they have perished; their 8, xv. 24) destruction is foretold for the end of time ( I Cor. xv. ;
26). facts Sin, present world is dominated by three introduced death and the consequence of Adam's fall, by it into the world; the promise given to Abraham,
The
:
which, amid the darkness of a world condemned, causes hope to shine; and finally the Law of Moses. For each of these points of view the cycle is completed
by the manifestation of Christ.
Through
to life quished, the faithful are restored to made the 22; Rom. v. 17), promise fulfilled
16), and
is
;
it
sin is
( I
van-
Cor. xv.
Abraham
is
finally Christ
(2 Cor. i. 20; Gal. iii. the end of the law ( Rom. x. 4 cp. Gal. iii. 2 1 iv. 5 ) . The redeeming work of Christ involves at once God
Because of
and man.
its
essentially
,
moral character,
it can only be accomplished by a being in close soliman. But as darity with humanity, therefore by a
radically impotent, and the initiative salvation belongs to God, it can only come through a
humanity
is
for
intimate union being who is not himself a sinner but in with God, therefore by a celestial being. Hence the double character of the Pauline Christ, a human perand at the same time superhuman, not God
sonality
but the "Son of (the term is not found in Paul), God" a contradiction that the apostle solves by the idea of the incarnation of the preexisting Christ
THE THEOLOGY OF PAUL Christ belongs at once to the divine and the spheres; His personality has a double aspect
151
human (Rom.
But there is nothing in Paul to resemble that which later was to be the orthodox dogma, because his i.
4).
thought does not express itself in theological definitions, and also because he does not picture to himself a combination in the person of Christ of incongruous elements, but rather the succession of diverse phases.
The Pauline idea of God (2 Cor.
is
that of a divine Being, the image 4; Col. i. 15), a celestial man
iv.
the first-born of creation (Col. (i Cor. xv. 48, 49), bei. 15), who, laying aside His celestial attributes,
came man, and who, after His resurrection, received 11 the name of "Lord (Phil. ii. 5-1 1 ) .^
outside Everything which concerns preexistence is double a has and of experience, as Paul conceives it,
This proceeds from the theological system of Judaism, in which the notion of the Messiah was reflecvery developed, but also from the theological If Jesus, by His death and resurrection, had tion.
origin.
brought about that which He had, in fact, accomof Paul, it necesplished according to the experience His that personality must have been sarily follows unlike that of other men.
The name by which Paul most Christ
is
that of "Son of God."
for there
is
nothing
in the
resembles the idea to be
frequently designates This is but an image,
apostle's writings which later, of a Son be-
met with
suborgotten by God. The Christ remains distinctly dinate to the Father. He was created by the Father. This follows from the parallel drawn between Adam 1
and Him, but also from the term "image of God/ which recalls the narrative of the creation of the first
JESUS man
in the
term
image of
"first-born."
THE NAZARENE God The
(Gen.
i.
27) and also of the man or
idea of the celestial
the typical man of I Cor. xv. 48 is another form of the notion of preexistence which is affirmed in a series of explicit texts for instance, in the declaration of the Epistle to the
Romans
that
God had
sent
His Son
ii. 5). 3; cp. Gal. iv. 4; 2 Cor. viii. 9; Phil. the in Christ taken the from It follows also by part creation (i Con viii. 6; Col. i. 15-17)-
(Rom.
viii.
that is, at the moment chosen the end of time conceived by His wisdom (Gal. by God in the plan jv. 4) Jesus was born in the midst of the Jewish
At
people, a descendant of
Abraham and
of
David (Rom.
unto God (Rom. i. 3). He was in all points obedient v. 17-19; Phil. ii. 8) and had in no wise known sin a human appear(2 Cor. v. 21 ). The texts in which viii. ance of Christ is spoken of (Rom. 3; Phil. ii. 7)
must not be interpreted against the
reality of Jesus,
the for, as H. J. Holtzmann has very well observed, of notion to the Greek word employed is not opposed 8 That which exidentity, but to that of difference.
confirms this interpretation is the fact that Paul attributes to Christ flesh and blood (Rom. i. 3, iii. 25 ; I Cor. x. 16: Col. i. 20), while these are, in his view, elements which characterize human nature, and are
plicitly
8 It may appear, given the notion of the flesh, that there is a contradiction between the humanity of Christ and the fact that He it without sin. The solution of this is given by the parallelism drawn between Adam and Jesus Christ. Just as Adam, before the fall, wa at the same time man and without sin, so it is possible to conceive
for Christ what Adam had been at the be noted that Jewish thought does not rigorously affirm the universality of sin. Jewish Apocryphal book, fourth few are Esdras, says that nearly all men are sinners and that very not This offers some striking affinities with Paul's thought (vii. 139).
that
God had
creation.
realized
It is to
A
THE THEOLOGY OF PAUL
153
The foreign to the celestial life (i Cor. xv. 50). death His is Christ of essence of the work upon the cross. The cross is for Paul the power and the wisdom
God (i Cor. man can have to of
18, 23, 24), the sole reason that be assured of his salvation (Gal. vi. i.
called 14), and for this the enemies of the Gospel are iii. of Christ the cross of enemies the 18). If (Phil. Paul combated with the energy and perseverance known to us the idea of justification by the works of is in order particularly by circumcision, it that is, the efficacity of the cross that the offense
the
Law, and
may
not be diminished (Gal.
v.
II, vi.
12;
i
Cor.
with It is upon this idea that the 17) the greatest emphasis (Gal. i. 14; i Cor. xv. 3; Rom. Several concepts are introduced to iv. 25, v. 10). i.
apostle insists
.
explain
for instance, that of Christ as the paschal
it
lamb (i Cor. v. 7), that of Christ as propitiation as a levitical (that is, a means of salvation conceived that of the sacrisacrifice) (Rom. iii. 25), and also iii. Gal. vi. ransom fice by 13). But the 17; (Rom. of justifigoverning thought which explains the process cation is that of the condemnation of sin in the flesh of Christ (Gal. Hi. 13; 2 Cor. v. 21; Rom. viii. 3). treated by God Jesus, while being perfectly holy, was were sin personified and condemned. as though
He
not the idea of expiatory sacrifice incidentallyRom. iii. 25, for the victim of this sacrifice had to be of perfect purity, while the death of loaded Jesus on the cross was that of one condemned, with sin. Neither is it the equivalent of ransom, for
This
is
indicated in
the punishment of sin in the flesh of Jesus was a legal sanction and not a satisfaction accorded either to God or devil. Neither can it be said, as does M. Loisy,
JESUS
154
THE NAZARENE
assimilates the death of Christ to the sacrifice of
who
to Azazel, that Christ took upon Himself the sins of men. These sins, in fact, are not His death. They subsist after it, with all
the
ram dedicated
destroyed by
the consequences, and are only destroyed by union virtual death of the believer realized by mystical their
We
have in Paul an original conception with Christ. notions in which juridical play a much greater part than 9 in the Jewish conception of sacrifice. Christ without His resurrection would be without efficacy. The resurrection is not only for
The death of
Paul a reparation accorded to Christ, a recompense for His sacrifice still less is it a consequence of His divine nature. If Christ died without subsequent resurrection, His sacrifice was in vain (i Cor. xv. 14-17). ;
He
was raised again for our
When
25).
active voice
sentence.
always
God who
is
Christ did not return to
Him
the subject of the life
10 by Himself.
10; Gal. i. I Cor. vi. 14, xv. 15; 2 Cor. iv. 14; Roni. iv. 25). His resurrection Christ was restored to the
It is I
Paul
it is
iv.
justification (Rom. uses the verb "to rise again'' in the
God who
raised
(i Thess.
i.
;
Through
rank and to the possession of the attributes which He had in His preexistence, and He is even placed at a ii. 1 1 ) higher rank than that which He occupied (Phil. ,
The question whether Paul taught a doctrine of expiation has There are many texts which seem to hint been much discussed. at it; those on which it is said that Christ died "for us" or "for our sins," but it is not certain that "for us" means "in our place" and not "in our interest," and that "for our sins" may have the sense of "accepting responsibility for our sins," and not "because of our sins." It is rather the idea of solidarity which seems to adapt itself to
10
to
Paul's thought (2 Cor. v. 15). case of the Johannine conception, "I have power life and power to take it again" (John x. 18).
As in the lay down my
THE THEOLOGY OF PAUL and
scats
Himself
essentially spirit
(
I
hand of God (Rom.
at the right
viii. 34; Col. iii. i). the divine glory. In
He His
155
enters into the possession of glorious existence Christ was
Cor. xv. 45 )
,
and even the
ll
Spirit
The phrase "Christ, (2 Cor. iii. 17; Rom. viii. 9, 10). of Him almost makes power of God" (i Cor. i. 24) "mode" of the
a
divine activity.
The death and resurrection of Christ also modify His position relatively to demoniacal beings. Henceforward, indeed, they have no power over those who belong to Christ (Rom. viii. 37). He has gained the and reestablished order in the cosmos (Col. victory
He
first place and brought other into subjection powers. Nevertheless, accordof Christ can only ing to I Cor. xv. 24, 25, the victory at the end of time. The reconciling of these take
i.
18-20).
has taken the
all
place
two
things,
in
appearance contradictory, seems
at-
tained by the idea that in the text of the Epistles to the Philippians, Romans and the Colossians they are considered as principles and in the absolute, while
Corinthians they are considIn the chronological development.
in the first Epistle to the
ered
in
their
Epistle to the
Romans
it
is
a question of a certain
not exclude a struggle. victory, but one which does The Satanic powers are not destroyed; they can still the last battle with Christ, but they will be unable
wage
In the Epistle to the Philippians (ii. to triumph. knee 9-11) Christ receives a name before which every
does not imply that they will not On the other hand, in the first attempt to rebel. to the Corinthians, if there is a battle, the
shall
bow, but
this
Epistle 11
Believers mystically in union with him ceased to be spirit (Gal. v. 24; Rom. vi. z).
become
flesh
to
i 56
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
The victory of Christ is 20 Christ gains the i. CoL to certain. According This may be victory by the blood upon the cross. with I Cor. ii. 8, where the statement is issue is fixed in advance.
compared
had known that is, understood His plans the wisdom of God the glorious Lord. Why crucified have not would they Because they would not have devoted their is this? efforts to the realization of a work which must have for them as consequence their overthrow and spoliation. The cross is thus the means by which the princes of this world are to be annihilated and despoiled. It
made
that if the archons of this world
the thought of impossible to interpret with precision Paul on this point, for it proceeds only by allusions
is
which are concerned either with the teaching he had himself given, or with the current ideas of his time for example, those developed in the Ascension of Isaiah, and which, to appeal directly to the intelligence
of his readers,
it
sufficed to evoke.
and complete victory of Christ over the be gained at the end of the age. spirits would only After His resurrection Christ is seated at the right hand of God (Rom. viii. 34; Col. iii. i). He will under His foot, reign until all enemies have been put
The
full
enemy of all death. Then He will surrender the Kingdom to His Father, and this will be and the
last
the end (i Cor. xv. 24, 26). It is is this Pauline Christology formed? often said that the apostle was the creator of Chris-
How
is only exact if the word "creain the sense ex nihilo, but in not tion" be understood,
tology.
This formula
the sense of a synthesis formed
from preexisting
ele-
THE THEOLOGY OF PAUL
15?
Pauline thought appears as an original solution of a problem which arose out of the circumstances themselves, for the Christological problem
ments.
existed
The
from the very moment that one
single
man
of the ignominy continued of His death. But the solutions or the outlines of them were swept aside by the powerful synthesis of Paul, to believe in Jesus in spite
Christian thought. Certain elements of the Christology of Paul have a speculative These are specially the notions of saintliness origin.
which dominated
all later
not the observation of a fact but and of preexistence. the affirmation of a principle of the The notion, too, Messiahship has a theoretical in so far as
it
is
and absolute character.
The drama proceeds we adopt the
ing to a necessary plan, while if
accordidea in
the parable of the vineyard, according to the thought of Jesus, we are led to the conception that the arrival of the Messiah was a last attempt at redemption, which
would not have taken place if the wickedness of mankind had not rendered fruitless the mission of the of the death prophets. The doctrine of the necessity of Christ marks, indeed, an essential point of difference between the thought of Paul and that of Jesus. For Jesus death is the supreme proof of love for His fellow men, which He will give them if it be necessary. It is like His entire ministry, but not separated from
an appeal addressed to sinners it is not what the very cause of the it is according to Paul's thought and Reflection God. speculation are dompardon of inant in Paul. As for the preponderance accorded to one might almost say the eclipsing of the cross it
;
it is
;
Christ's ministry in face of the unique and extraorit can only be explained dinary radiance of His cross
JESUS
I5 8
THE NAZARENE
into contact by the angle under which Paul entered
with the Gospel.
Paul an element whose origin is in the 12 Bruckner has shown that Jewish Messianic doctrine.
There
is
in
after eliminating
what
is
specifically Christian in the
found a system of coherent ideas which finds its place in the most natural manner in the development of the Jewish Messianic doctrine.
Pauline Christology there
This Christology existed conversion.
is
in
Paul's
mind before
his
Certain Hellenic elements are also to be those treating of the relations of Christ
recognized with the spirits
but they
may have
been incorporated
with Jewish ideas before Paul. Nothing, however, the Pauline consider to than would be more erroneous of Jewish or Christology as only a simple development
Judeo-Hellenic premises.
That which gives him
his
built up of these elements originality is the synthesis and the historical episode of the life and death of
Jesus. It is
not possible to reduce to a
common
element
the historical and dogmatic constituents of the Pauline This is Christology, as M. Couchoud would do. in Paul a proved by the fact that we do not find
homogeneous conception of the cause of as should be the case
if
Christ's death,
the entire history of Jesus, and
of His death in particular, had been the postulates of a dogmatic system. According to I Cor. ii. 8 Christ died crucified owing to the acts of the archons or rebellious angels against
God.
According to Rom.
vii.
3
Concerning the Jewish Messianic doctrine see Schurer (Gesch.), (Die Religion des Judentums), Baldensperger (Die Met" $ianischapokalyptuchen, etc), Brflckner (Die Entstehung der Paulischen Chrutohfie). 12
Boussct
THE THEOLOGY OF PAUL
159
He was not in person a sinner, but with humanity accepted by Him) through solidarity because God treated Him as though He were sin itself, He
died (although
and inflicted the chastisement which sinners deserve. These two conceptions are not dialectically irrecon-
One might imagine
cilable.
the archons as agents used
Doubtless the two conceptions the same compass or being on are far from having the same plane. The first is only indicated in a quite incidental manner, in a dissertation which treats, not
by God
to punish
sin.
of the death of Christ, but of the wisdom of God. The second is in direct relation with the doctrine of is at the heart of the apostle's justification, which
two explanations are not dealing with a readyfrom conception, nor with a system developed or doctrine, but from the interpretation by this
thought.
The
coexistence of these
proves, however, that
made myth
we
doctrine of an historical fact.
THE
VI.
JUSTIFICATION AND REDEMPTION OF THE
SINNER conclusion follows, with better evidence the study of the Pauline theory of the
The same still,
from
and redemption of the sinner. The death of Christ, as we have seen, abolishes the consequences of sin, and contains in germ the defeat of the demons
justification
humanity is subject and whose action produces sin and death. But, however efficacious it be, this death does not abolish the actual consequences of The theoretical destruction of its power does not sin.
to
whom
save mankind from continuing to bear as a fact the
JESUS
160
THE NAZARENE
if the demonconsequences of sins committed, and still undermankind in principle condemned, powers are the past. in them to goes the effects of its subjection Moreover, their power continues to be exercised up
their defeat will be fully
when
to the time
consum-
mated. accomplished by Christ in dying on the cross does not at once justify sinners ipso facto by
The work
one
to
act,
some extent magical; that
tification possible
before God's tribunal. liever access to the
it
merely makes
jus-
to say, the acquittal of man Justification opens to the be-
is
Heavenly Kingdom and gives him
assurance of his future redemption. Salvation can only be attained for the individual by a moral act. This plainly follows from the term of
employed by Paul. This term implies the change of the relation between persons. "We beseech you in the name of Christ," writes Paul, exerof reconciliation, cising thus what he calls the ministry reconciliation
"be ye reconciled with God" (2 Cor. v. 20). To the act of God giving His Son there must correspond an act of
man. God
calls the sinner; the latter
must
re-
the act of imputing to the sinner the justice attained by Christ, who, considered as sinHimself through His death right with the has
spond. Justification
is
put
ner,
Law, and who lives henceforth a life freed by the power of God from the dominion of sin and death.
The and
This term starting point of justification is faith. 1* in Paul. found often are it from derived words
Faith
is
tian life.
did his 19
phenomenon of the religious ChrisThe type of believer is Abraham. In what faith consist? In this, that God, having
the specific
About 280 times
in the
authentic Epiatles.
THE THEOLOGY OF PAUL
161
promised that he should be the father of a large posterin this promise at the time when ity, he had confidence his age and that of his wife rendered its realization improbable (Rom. iv. 17-21). Faith is therefore not
founded upon the evidence of a truth, but upon the confidence inspired by God and His omnipotence. According to i Cor. ii. 4, 5 faith has its origin in the power of God, and not in human reasoning. Faith is faith in God (i Thess. i. 8), but there is also faith in Christ (Gal. Christ that
16
Rom.
Hi.
22), because
it is
through keeps His promise. To believe in Christ is to believe in the promises of God it is therefore also to believe in God. Faith has for its origin ii.
;
God
;
the preaching of the Gospel by the apostles and the missionaries whom God has appointed for this object (Rom. x. 14) it includes an intellectual element, the ;
idea of
God who by His power
raised
up Jesus from
the dead. Paul mentions it between the gift of wisdom and that of knowledge (i Cor. xii. 8, 9). But faith is
not only knowledge and confidence; it is also (and this is the most original element in the Pauline conception) union. The believer united to Christ is made mystical a participator in everything touching
Him, and particresurrection. and According to I ularly in His death Thess. v. 10 Jesus died in order that believers, whether Him. This supposes sleeping or waking, may be with the establishing of an indissoluble bond between the believer and the Savior. In i Cor. i. 9 "communion" with the Son of God, the Lord, appears as an ideal held the Lord up to the faithful. He who is united with 14 with Him becomes a (i Cor. vi. 17). In Gal. spirit
of believers with the 14 In this passage the idea of the union Christ serves as the starting-point of the argument, which proves
1
JESUS
62
ii.
THE NAZARENE
20 Paul declares himself to be
19,
crucified
with
Christ that liveth in Christ: "It is for me," and this suppression of the individual life has differits consequence the suppression of all accidental
not I that live;
it is
ences of race, sex and social situation (Gal. iii. 27, Rom. viii. 29 the object of preetc.). According to destination is that believers may be made like unto the
be the image of the Son of God, so that Christ may
among many brethren (Rom. vi. 3-5, xiv. 9; 2 Cor. iv. 10, n, xi. 2). The explanation of this union is furnished by the
first-born
idea of the death of Christ in solidarity with humanone died for all, therefore all died and He ity. "As ;
died for all, so that the living should no longer live for themselves, but for Him who died and rose for them" (2 Cor. v. 14, 15). The mystical union has for its effect the rupture of the bond uniting the man to the world. He asks again "Can it be that you do not :
who were
baptized into union with Christ Jesus in our earthly baptism shared His death? in our bapConsequently, through sharing His death Christ was as Him that just tism, we were buried with raised from the dead by a manifestion of the Father's
know
that
all
of us
If we have life. power, so we also may live a new act become united with Him by the symbolic of His death, surely we shall also become united with Him
by the act symbolic of His resurrection. We recognize the truth that our old self was crucified with Christ, order that the body, the stronghold of sin, might be rendered powerless, so that we should no longer be slaves to sin. For the man who has so died has been in
that
we
are concerned with one of the fundamental ideas of the which the faithful must have been very familiar.
apostle with
THE THEOLOGY OF PAUL
163
we pronounced righteous and released from sin. And shall we death Christ's shared have we as believe that We know that Christ, having also share His life. once risen from the dead, will not die again. Death has power over Him no longer. ... So let it be with for you regard yourselves as dead to sin, but as living God, through union with Christ Jesus" (Rom. vi. 218 There is here no image, but a precise formula 1 1 ) ;
,
to be taken literally. Christ is free in regard to sin because in dying He paid His debt. Sin, death and
which
is
the law have no
thing
is
Christ.
more dominion over Him. The same
also true of the believer mystically united with also is free with regard to sin, death and
He
the law.
In the last passage cited, what is said about baptism might be interpreted symbolically. But other passages show that this explanation does not suffice, and that to It effectively is more than a symbol. with Christ, believer the of the union about brings one "For we were all baptized to form body, whether Jews or Greeks, slaves or freemen" (i Cor. xii. 12).
Paul, baptism
Faith and baptism are thus presented the two
means through which is "For
the believer with the Lord,
in Gal.
iii.
27 as
realized the union of all
of you
who were
baptized into union with Christ clothed yourselves 16 with Christ." That which is true of baptism is also true of the Eucharist. This, for Paul, is an act instituted by in commemoration of His sacrifice, and as a Jesus
Note. English version from Twentieth Century Testament, based upon Westcott and Hort's text. 16 This is confirmed by the practice of baptism for the dead to which Paul alludes in i Cor. xv. 29, without pronouncing any *B
Translator's
New
censure or making any reservation.
(Author's note.)
i6 4
JESUS
means of entering
THE NAZARENE
into relation with
Him in
with which the entire Church
In this act, the faithful are invited to
sit
down
is
His death. associated,
at the Lord's table
and receive His cup. The bread and the wine distributed to them are the flesh and blood of Christ. relation They put those who consume them in direct with Christ through His death. The fruit the believer obtains by his participation in the repast is the consciousness of being by its means intimately united to
the dying Christ (i. Cor.
x. 16,
17).
Baptism and communion, then, occupy in the Pauline Like it, they system exactly the same place as faith. is attained. union which are the means through mystical What relation exists between these two things ? Have if not contradictory, are their to as at any rate different origin and not reducible the idea of mystic union through faith to each other
we
here two notions which,
which represents Paul's thought, while the theory of the sacraments is only an interpretation of the rite seems to us practised in the Church? This solution sacraments the If difficulties. several to encounter it would be were in the background of Paul's thought of them comprehensible that he should have spoken be to abuse an was attacked, in i Cor. xi, where there but not that on a quite practical question (the consumption of meat sacrificed to idols) he should have relied upon the meaning of the communion as a decisive
argument. Neither would the texts relating to baptism be comprehensible. On the other hand, seeing that in so systematic a
mind
as the apostle's the simple juxta-
is very improbposition of two different conceptions the that mystical union able, one is forced to suppose
attained by faith and that attained through the sacra-
THE THEOLOGY OF PAUL ments are only two aspects of the same link
uniting them
is
165
fact.
The
not the idea that the sacrament
is
The only a symbol of the faith alone efficacious. a attributes in harmful, real, fact, though apostle, action to the communion when observed without reverence, (i Cor. xi. 27-30). The sacrament acts of itself ex opre operate and without the intervention of faith, but faith that is, the conscious desire to become one
with Christ
necessary to direct
is
its
To
action.
understand this necessary to get rid of the modern ideas opposing symbol and reality to each other, and it is
to
remember that for the mind of
antiquity the symbol
for partook of the reality of that which it represents instance, a name was not a simple designation, but the very substance of the thing named. ;
for every believer mystical union accomplished that which had been accomplished for Christ by His death and His resurrection. This is implied in the
The
fundamental affirmation of Paulinism, "the believer is an inby faith." Certain texts seem to favor
justified
idea of effective justiterpretation imputing to Paul the that is, a transformation of the believer. In fication for instance, it is stated that God "conRom. via.
demned
4, sin in the earthly nature (of Christ) so that of the might be satisfied in us
the requirements
who
live
now
Law
in obedience,
not to our earthly nature, is a question here not of
but to the Spirit." But it but of sanctification, which while justification,
mately related
to, is still different
the exhortation to sin no
from
more which
is
inti-
Similarly
it.
addressed in
been justified by faith 17 to those who have were in Christ would have no meaning if justification
Gal.
ii.
identical with sanctification.
Justification
is
forensic:
66
1
JESUS act of God
THE NAZARENE 1
the Judge, who proclaims "just* as the (that is, acquitted) the sinner who appears Last the of is an anticipation accused before Him. It the
it is
Judgment. the believer mystical union in linking the fate of which the fetter to that of Christ breaks keeps man
The
In like manner as Christ, during His earthly ministry, has
the slave of sin and death.
who
lived in the flesh
become
the believer also
spirit,
is
no longer
flesh,
but
But if in theory the believer carnal life, in practice this the and has broken with show this rupture is not consummated. It suffices to spirit
(Rom.
vi.
12).
sin
to recall the
filled
important place
in
Pauline
the
Epistles by exhortations to sanctification (for instance,
never comwhich explains the somepletely realized, what special character which the Pauline morality 17 The fundamental idea upon which it rests assumes. In
Gal. v. 1-6, 10).
and
is
fact, sanctification is
it is
this
Law 18
that of the abolition of the
4, 5, v. 18;
Rom.
vi.
14, vii. 1-6).
Law," wrote Paul (Gal. a free
man
(Gal. v. i;
ii.
19).
Rom.
vi.
(Gal. iii. 24, iv, "I am dead unto
The
believer
18, 22;
I
is
then
Cor.
ix.
be spon1-19, etc.). His activity should, in principle, Since he belongs to God, he ought to live taneous. to God; since he is a spirit, he ought natuaccording *T
Upon
the Pauline
Siinde bn Paulus; Paulus.
also
morality see
Wernle, Der Christ und die Das Problem der Ethik bet
R. Bultmann,
the Law, i*By this is meant the abolition of the ritual part of not of its moral part. But the inadequacy of the terminology which does not allow the apostle to distinguish exactly between the two an exact statement, as is seen by the things prevents his reaching declares that he is not under the passage i Cor ix, 20, where Paul a law, since he is under the without be cannot he Law, although law of Christ
THE THEOLOGY OF PAUL produce what Paul
rally to
Rom.
(Gal. v. 16;
viii.
calls the fruits
167
of the
spirit
12). in reality, and restored in fact.
Things are not, however, so simple
is obligation, abolished in principle, should be it as seems That which though
shown
as a
Man consequence is formulated as a postulate. should strive to realize the fruits of the spirit, which He ought to are in harmony with his new nature. struggle and labor to escape indeed the very law which 1*
theory no longer exists for him (Gal.
in
vi. 15, viii. 7,
The
v.
13;
Rom.
8).
morality of Paul answers to the dualism of the
and
fact of flesh
spirit
which subsists
in the believer
redemption is achieved; it possesses, therefore, a temporary value, and will be abolished when only 20 There believers shall fully live the life of the spirit. until
here a difference between theory and practice which must be explained. Paul has expressed in touching
lies
classic the sense of this imperfec-
words which remain
"For I am so far from habitually do that I find myself doing the to want doing what But when I do what I want not very thing I hate. This to do, I am admitting that the Law is right.
tion of sanctification
:
I
.
being sin in
.
no longer
so, the action is
which
me
.
I
is
within me.
mean
in
my
I
know
my
own, but that of
there
earthly nature.
is .
.
nothing good Miserable .
A
curious fact must be pointed out that in the exposition of the where the modus operandt of redemption is Epistle to the Romans an exhortation, "Being justified by analyzed the argument ends by Logical consistency seems so law, let us have peace with God." declaration that many manuscripts have substia to require plainly tuted "we have" for "let us have." 20 Concerning the Pauline morality should be noted among the motives by the apostle the place occupied by the idea of 10
proposed
the imitation of Jesus (i Thess.
i.
6;
i
Cor.
xi.
i; i Col.
iii.
13).
JESUS
168
man
that I
THE NAZARENE
am! who
me
will deliver
me from
death?"
the
body
(Rom. bringing Doubtless the apostle gives a cry of triumph 1 5-24 ). "Thanks be unto God through to follow this lament
that
is
to
this
vii.
21
but the motive of this cry Jesus Christ our Lord" The is the hope of being delivered in the future. liberation of those who are in Christ is therefore only a potential liberation.
This dualism which
exists in
man
after justification
is explained by the fact that the believer, although dead to the flesh, continues to live in the flesh. Neither his
in which he lives has been transhas formed. only received the promise of the which will be fully realized Spirit as surety of that Glory, the later (2 Cor. i. 22, v. 5; Rom. viii. 23). is the for reserved elect, celestial attribute only promised him (Rom. v. 2, viii. 18). Salvation is not fully
body nor the world
He
accomplished. "By our hope we were saved." Again he writes "Our salvation is nearer now than when we In the same Epistle first believed" (Rom. xiii. n). :
we were yet sinners Christ died for us, how much more now that we are justified by His blood shall we be saved by His life?" The further he writes
:
"If while
affirms that salvaEpistle to the Philippians similarly It is at the second tion is not yet attained (i. 6). it shall be fully realized that Lord the of coming
(Rom.
viii.
VII.
18-25).
THE
GENESIS OF THE PAULINE THEOLOGY
How are we
to explain this seeming contradiction in Paul's conception of the position of the justified man, Translator**
mod Horfi
text.
NQt*.Twntteth Century Nno
Ttttamint, Wcitcott
THE THEOLOGY OF PAUL
169
not in fact what in theory it ought to be ? For the faithful it is only at the end of time that will be consummated the thing which in principle follows from the new situation in which he finds himself through
which
is
mystical union with Christ.
This
is
one of the most
problems which the interpretation of Paulinism presents. It is by no hazard that it is difficult
so ; tion
and
delicate
the consequence, we would say without hesitais the penalty of the association in Paul's thought
it is it
of two incongruous elements. There is, indeed, somein which man thing more than the complex situation forces which alterstruggles between two antagonistic
The contradiction is nately attract and repel him. much deeper it lies at the very root of Pauline thought. Paul conceives it, the situation of man In the ;
way
between justification and redemption is of a proviPaul expects the resional and temporary character. to complete the date a at of Christ turn very early 22 work begun. Justification and redemption, although remain organically linked one to the other. separate, of the same drama. So inter-related acts two They are
and complementary are they that their separation can of the only be conceived by a complete dislocation Messianic of the redemption. There Jewish doctrine is no equivalent for this dislocation in the whole Jewish it is possible to Apocalypse. We do not think that the than following: The give any other explanation
is anterior to his conception of redemption, in Paul, Christian faith. As a Rabbi, he already expected the 22 In I Thess iv. 15 and I Cor xv. 51 Paul conceives that the return of Christ will take place during his life. He had announced had begun this to the Thessalonians in such a way that the latter to suppose that the faithful who died before the Savior's return would be excluded from salvation (i Thess. iv 13).
i7
o
JESUS
arrival of a Savior
THE NAZARENE who would
rescue
men from
the
dominion of sin and death to bring them into the Kingdom of the Spirit, whose advent would be marked by the triumph of the Messiah over the enemies of God. This faith was his at the time when Jesus in his
was only a justly condemned blasphemer. Then happened the mysterious event upon the Damascus road which gave him the conviction that Jesus was that what living and in glory. From this he concluded His disciples had said about Him was true that Jesus had been the holy Son of God, sent upon earth to an unaccomplish His work. Hence was established eyes
:
expected synthesis between the doctrine of redemption (already in his mind) and the story of the Nazarene from Jesus, crucified by Pontius Pilate, but raised again and friends His to Himself since He showed the dead the in to Paul himself, and henceforward was living spirit life.
of synthesis of these two elements (the story unwas Jesus and the doctrine of redemption) Paul able to effect completely at once. There were in the
The
mission of the Savior-Messiah certain elements which did not permit of their relation to Jesus of Nazareth. those which (to put it in one word) related to a triumphant Messiah, restorer of the sovdividereignty of God. Paul resolved the difficulty by
These were
all
and in ing the mission of the Messiah into two parts he reserving for the glorious return of Christ (which considered very near) everything it was impossible to discover as accomplished in the life, death and resurrection of Jesus. The Pauline doctrine thus proceeds
from
a dislocation of the
work of redemption.
therefore has no single source;
it is
It
not born out of
THE THEOLOGY OF PAUL
171
the elaboration or the transformation of a myth, but fact proceeds from the interpretation of an historical constifact the by a doctrine already preexisting it: tuted by the life and the dealh of Jesus and by belief The theology of Paul assumes in His resurrection.
therefore a double starting point for its development. One is a doctrine of redemption whose origins must
be sought in Judaism; sode, the life of Jesus.
choud has
23
attempted,
the other It is
to
is
an historical
not possible, as attribute
to
it
epi-
M. Coua
more
homogeneous character, and by reducing one of these elements to the other to maintain that the history of Jesus was deduced from a drama of redemption. Indeed, it would not be possible to find in the history more or less syncretic an analogy of Jewish thought must be admitted in Paul; for to that the to process presume the existence of certain forms of Judaism
of the Diaspora sensibly differing from that of Palestine and which would not have been without a strong influence on rising Christianity would not be to state a true parallel.
We know
of nothing, in fact, in the Judaism of the Diaspora which offers any real analogies with the Pauline speculations on this point, and it would be historical unquestionably making use of an inadmissible to attempt the explanation of a given fact by it is not something which is only a conjecture. But
method
any parallel which forbids us Paulinism an exclusive product of specula-
entirely the absence of
to see in
also the existence of incoherences and internal If the contradictions which we have pointed out.
tion
;
it is
28 In a Judaism which, no doubt had not been entirely uninfluenced by foreign ideas, principally Greek and Persian.
172
JESUS
THE NAZARENE
had come forth in its entirety from the brain of Paul, as Minerva did from that of Jupiter, The a homogeneous character. it would present Christian doctrine
manifest traces of the sutures
we have
discovered
us in affirmplainly prove its double origin and justify and assumes of theology ing that the Pauline system certifies the historical tradition
about Jesus.
CHAPTER
VII
THE NONPAULINE EPISTLES OF THE NEW TESTAMENT I.
THEIR CHARACTER
THE
noninterpretation of the testimony which the the for calls Christ Pauline Epistles give concerning
same observations already made concerning those of Pauline origin. These documents are the Epistle to the Ephesians, attributed to Paul, but in which one is obliged to perceive a secondary imitation of the I and Epistle to the Colossians ; the pastoral Epistles ( 2 Tim. and Titus), in which there appear to have been inserted fragments of authentic Pauline letters;
Epistle of Peter, at the basis of which arc found the essential ideas of Paul; the Epistle to th* Hebrews, written by a man very familiar with the
the
first
Alexandrine philosophy and exegesis; the second related to Epistle of Peter and that of Jude, closely each other, and apparently of fairly recent period and who makes use of the lastly, the Epistle of James, traditional Jewish and Greek ethic, and shows very of analogies with the literature of the Wisdom ;
striking 1 the Old Testament.
the exception of the Epistle of James, all these works belong to the literary species which Paul created by his correspondence, and all betray the influence of his theology.
With
considered separately i The three Epistles of John, which cannot be from the fourth Gospel, are not mentioned here. 173
i
JESUS
74
THE NAZARENE
of these letters pretends to be a complete They are written to exposition of Christian faith.
None
and onjy expound the ideas and the beliefs 2 which they assume to be those of their readers.
believers,
Several
among them,
so far as their date can be fixed
with any preciseness, were written at the time when the Gospel literature began to be spread abroad. All these Epistles should be considered as the commentary tradiupon certain points of Christian doctrine and tion it is illegitimate to employ in what concerns them ;
that is, to suppose their the argument ex silentio authors were ignorant of certain ideas because they do not give them expression. Very frequently in the Deutero-Paufine literature
The idea could only have been a moral force for men who were acquainted with the human history of Jesus. The the idea of the imitation of Jesus
is
met with.
author of the Epistle to the Hebrews, after having proposed to his readers the imitation of the heroes of the faith spoken of in the Old Testament and Jewish tradition (xi. 1-40), concludes by exhorting them to fix their eyes upon Jesus, who "endured the
and despised the shame" (Heb. xii. I, 2). The way in which this exhortation is connected with the
cross
examples given
in the eleventh
hensible
also
if this
is
chapter is only comprereferred to an historical model.
The author also exhorts the faithful to suffer insult as of the Jesus Himself had done (xiii. 13). The writer first Epistle of Peter declares to his readers who are called
upon to
suffer persecution that they
ought to
2 This In the Johanninc is illustrated by a significant fact to the fourth Epistles, which, as all are aware, are closely related Gospel, there is no allusion to the facts about the life of Jesus.
THE NONPAULINE find consolation in the
fered in the flesh
(iv.
EPISTLES
175
thought that Christ also sufi), and has left to them an
example that they may follow in His footsteps. Thus he makes his thought precise "Reviled, He reviled not :
He
suffered, but again; entrusted His cause to 8
just"
(ii.
He Him
did not threaten;
He
whose judgments are
21-23).
of the Epistle to the Ephesians, exhorting the faithful to live in love for one another proposes that they should follow the example of Christ, "who
The author
loved us and gave Himself for us"
II.
THE PASTORAL
(
v. 2
)
.