THE NEW MIDDLE AGES BONNIE WHEELER, Series Editor The New Middle Ages is a series dedicated to transdisciplinary studie...
40 downloads
1401 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
THE NEW MIDDLE AGES BONNIE WHEELER, Series Editor The New Middle Ages is a series dedicated to transdisciplinary studies of medieval cultures, with particular emphasis on recuperating women’s history and on feminist and gender analyses. This peer-reviewed series includes both scholarly monographs and essay collections.
PUBLISHED BY PALGRAVE: Women in the Medieval Islamic World: Power, Patronage, and Piety edited by Gavin R. G. Hambly
Chaucer’s Pardoner and Gender Theory: Bodies of Discourse by Robert S. Sturges
The Ethics of Nature in the Middle Ages: On Boccaccio’s Poetaphysics by Gregory B. Stone
Crossing the Bridge: Comparative Essays on Medieval European and Heian Japanese Women Writers edited by Barbara Stevenson and Cynthia Ho
Presence and Presentation: Women in the Chinese Literati Tradition by Sherry J. Mou The Lost Love Letters of Heloise and Abelard: Perceptions of Dialogue in Twelfth-Century France by Constant J. Mews Understanding Scholastic Thought with Foucault by Philipp W. Rosemann For Her Good Estate: The Life of Elizabeth de Burgh by Frances A. Underhill Constructions of Widowhood and Virginity in the Middle Ages edited by Cindy L. Carlson and Angela Jane Weisl Motherhood and Mothering in Anglo-Saxon England by Mary Dockray-Miller Listening to Heloise: The Voice of a TwelfthCentury Woman edited by Bonnie Wheeler The Postcolonial Middle Ages edited by Jeffrey Jerome Cohen
Engaging Words: The Culture of Reading in the Later Middle Ages by Laurel Amtower Robes and Honor: The Medieval World of Investiture edited by Stewart Gordon Representing Rape in Medieval and Early Modern Literature edited by Elizabeth Robertson and Christine M. Rose Same Sex Love and Desire among Women in the Middle Ages edited by Francesca Canadé Sautman and Pamela Sheingorn Sight and Embodiment in the Middle Ages: Ocular Desires by Suzannah Biernoff Listen, Daughter: The Speculum Virginum and the Formation of Religious Women in the Middle Ages edited by Constant J. Mews Science, the Singular, and the Question of Theology by Richard A. Lee, Jr.
Gender in Debate from the Early Middle Ages to the Renaissance edited by Thelma S. Fenster and Clare A. Lees Malory’s Morte D’Arthur: Remaking Arthurian Tradition by Catherine Batt The Vernacular Spirit: Essays on Medieval Religious Literature edited by Renate Blumenfeld-Kosinski, Duncan Robertson, and Nancy Warren Popular Piety and Art in the Late Middle Ages: Image Worship and Idolatry in England 1350–1500 by Kathleen Kamerick Absent Narratives, Manuscript Textuality, and Literary Structure in Late Medieval England by Elizabeth Scala Creating Community with Food and Drink in Merovingian Gaul by Bonnie Effros Representations of Early Byzantine Empresses: Image and Empire by Anne McClanan Encountering Medieval Textiles and Dress: Objects, Texts, Images edited by Désirée G. Koslin and Janet Snyder Eleanor of Aquitaine: Lord and Lady edited by Bonnie Wheeler and John Carmi Parsons Isabel La Católica, Queen of Castile: Critical Essays edited by David A. Boruchoff Homoeroticism and Chivalry: Discourses of Male Same-Sex Desire in the Fourteenth Century by Richard E. Zeikowitz Portraits of Medieval Women: Family, Marriage, and Politics in England 1225–1350 by Linda E. Mitchell Eloquent Virgins: From Thecla to Joan of Arc by Maud Burnett McInerney
The Persistence of Medievalism: Narrative Adventures in Contemporary Culture by Angela Jane Weisl Capetian Women edited by Kathleen D. Nolan Joan of Arc and Spirituality edited by Ann W. Astell and Bonnie Wheeler The Texture of Society: Medieval Women in the Southern Low Countries edited by Ellen E. Kittell and Mary A. Suydam Charlemagne’s Mustache: And Other Cultural Clusters of a Dark Age by Paul Edward Dutton Troubled Vision: Gender, Sexuality, and Sight in Medieval Text and Image edited by Emma Campbell and Robert Mills Queering Medieval Genres by Tison Pugh Sacred Place in Early Medieval Neoplatonism by L. Michael Harrington The Middle Ages at Work edited by Kellie Robertson and Michael Uebel Chaucer’s Jobs by David R. Carlson Medievalism and Orientalism: Three Essays on Literature, Architecture and Cultural Identity by John M. Ganim Queer Love in the Middle Ages by Anna Klosowska Performing Women in the Middle Ages: Sex, Gender, and the Iberian Lyric by Denise K. Filios Necessary Conjunctions: The Social Self in Medieval England by David Gary Shaw Visual Culture and the German Middle Ages edited by Kathryn Starkey and Horst Wenzel
Medieval Paradigms: Essays in Honor of Jeremy duQuesnay Adams, Volumes 1 and 2 edited by Stephanie Hayes-Healy
Performing Piety: Musical Culture in Medieval English Nunneries by Anne Bagnell Yardley
False Fables and Exemplary Truth in Later Middle English Literature by Elizabeth Allen
The Flight from Desire: Augustine and Ovid to Chaucer by Robert R. Edwards
Ecstatic Transformation: On the Uses of Alterity in the Middle Ages by Michael Uebel
Mindful Spirit in Late Medieval Literature: Essays in Honor of Elizabeth D. Kirk edited by Bonnie Wheeler
Sacred and Secular in Medieval and Early Modern Cultures: New Essays edited by Lawrence Besserman
Medieval Fabrications: Dress, Textiles, Clothwork, and Other Cultural Imaginings edited by E. Jane Burns
Tolkien’s Modern Middle Ages edited by Jane Chance and Alfred K. Siewers
Was the Bayeux Tapestry Made in France?: The Case for St. Florent of Saumur by George Beech
Representing Righteous Heathens in Late Medieval England by Frank Grady
Women, Power, and Religious Patronage in the Middle Ages by Erin L. Jordan
Byzantine Dress: Representations of Secular Dress in Eighth-to-Twelfth Century Painting by Jennifer L. Ball
Hybridity, Identity, and Monstrosity in Medieval Britain: On Difficult Middles by Jeremy Jerome Cohen
The Laborer’s Two Bodies: Labor and the “Work” of the Text in Medieval Britain, 1350–1500 by Kellie Robertson
Medieval Go-betweens and Chaucer’s Pandarus by Gretchen Mieszkowski
The Dogaressa of Venice, 1250–1500: Wife and Icon by Holly S. Hurlburt
Temporal Circumstances: Form and History in the Canterbury Tales by Lee Patterson
Logic, Theology, and Poetry in Boethius, Abelard, and Alan of Lille: Words in the Absence of Things by Eileen C. Sweeney
Erotic Discourse and Early English Religious Writing by Lara Farina
The Theology of Work: Peter Damian and the Medieval Religious Renewal Movement by Patricia Ranft
Odd Bodies and Visible Ends in Medieval Literature by Sachi Shimomura
On the Purification of Women: Churching in Northern France, 1100–1500 by Paula M. Rieder
On Farting: Language and Laughter in the Middle Ages by Valerie Allen
Writers of the Reign of Henry II: Twelve Essays edited by Ruth Kennedy and Simon Meecham-Jones
Women and Medieval Epic: Gender, Genre, and the Limits of Epic Masculinity edited by Sara S. Poor and Jana K. Schulman
Lonesome Words: The Vocal Poetics of the Old English Lament and the African-American Blues Song by M.G. McGeachy
The Surgeon in Medieval English Literature by Jeremy J. Citrome
Race, Class, and Gender in “Medieval” Cinema edited by Lynn T. Ramey and Tison Pugh
Allegory and Sexual Ethics in the High Middle Ages by Noah D. Guynn
The Literary Subversions of Medieval Women by Jane Chance
England and Iberia in the Middle Ages, 12th15th Century: Cultural, Literary, and Political Exchanges edited by María Bullón-Fernández
Manmade Marvels in Medieval Culture and Literature by Scott Lightsey
The Medieval Chastity Belt: A Myth-Making Process by Albrecht Classen Claustrophilia: The Erotics of Enclosure in Medieval Literature by Cary Howie
American Chaucers by Candace Barrington Representing Others in Medieval Iberian Literature by Michelle M. Hamilton
Cannibalism in High Medieval English Literature by Heather Blurton
Paradigms and Methods in Early Medieval Studies Edited by Celia Chazelle and Felice Lifshitz
The Drama of Masculinity and Medieval English Guild Culture by Christina M. Fitzgerald
The King and the Whore: King Roderick and La Cava by Elizabeth Drayson
Chaucer’s Visions of Manhood by Holly A. Crocker
Langland’s Early Modern Identities by Sarah A. Kelen
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
Sarah A. Kelen
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
Copyright © Sarah A. Kelen, 2007. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles or reviews. First published in 2007 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN™ 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010 and Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire, England RG21 6XS Companies and representatives throughout the world. PALGRAVE MACMILLAN is the global academic imprint of the Palgrave Macmillan division of St. Martin’s Press, LLC and of Palgrave Macmillan Ltd. Macmillan® is a registered trademark in the United States, United Kingdom and other countries. Palgrave is a registered trademark in the European Union and other countries. ISBN-13: 978–1–4039–6517–2 ISBN-10: 1–4039–6517–X Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Kelen, Sarah A., 1968– Langland’s early modern identities / Sarah A. Kelen. p. cm.—(New Middle Ages) Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 1–4039–6517–X 1. Langland, William, 1330?–1400? Piers the Plowman. 2. Langland, William, 1330?–1400?—Authorship. 3. Langland, William, 1330?– 1400?—Appreciation—History. 4. Authors and readers—England— History. 5. Manuscripts, Medieval—England—Editing. 6. Manuscripts, English (Middle)—Editing. 7. Middle Ages in literature. I. Title. PR2015.K45 2007 821.1—dc22
2007010238
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Design by Newgen Imaging Systems (P) Ltd., Chennai, India. First edition: December 2007 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Printed in the United States of America.
This book is dedicated to the memory of two wonderful friends and respected colleagues, Claudia Rattazzi Papka and Rebecca Gershenson ( ). Their best work remains unwritten.
This page intentionally left blank
CONTENTS
Acknowledgments List of Abbreviations Introduction Langland as an Early Modern Author
xi xiii 1
Chapter 1 The Birth of Langland
17
Chapter 2 A Proliferation of Plowmen
43
Chapter 3 Langland Anthologized
77
Chapter 4 Langland Recontextualized
101
Chapter 5 Fictions of Authorship, Fictions of English Literature
127
Notes
151
Works Cited
197
Index
213
This page intentionally left blank
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
arlier versions of some of the material in this book have appeared elsewhere. Some of the details included in chapters 1 and 2 appeared earlier in “Plowing the Past: ‘Piers Protestant’ and the Authority of Medieval Literary History,” Yearbook of Langland Studies 13 (1999): 101–136. Some of chapter 4 appeared in “Peirs Plouhman [sic] and ‘The formidable array of black letter’ in the early nineteenth century” in Illuminating Letters: Typography and Interpretation, ed. Megan Benton and Paul Gutjahr (University of Massachusetts Press, 2001), 47–67. My thanks to Pegasus Press and the University of Massachusetts Press (respectively) for permission to republish this material. Financial support for my research came from the Huntington Library, the William Andrews Clark Memorial Library of UCLA, Oberlin College, the Erasmus Institute of Notre Dame University, the Medieval Institute of Western Michigan University, and Nebraska Wesleyan University. Over the past dozen years, I have had help and support from friends, colleagues, and mentors at several institutions. I would like to thank Robert W. Hanning and David Scott Kastan for encouraging my interest in work that links together medieval and early modern studies. I also owe a great debt to all those who patiently read and commented on earlier versions of this text (some many times!): Sarah Chinn, Andrew Galloway, Ruth Nisse, Derrick Pitard, Kellie Robertson, Jana Schulman, Eve Salisbury, Fiona Somerset, and Elizabeth Teviotdale. The helpful suggestions of Bonnie Wheeler and those from the anonymous peer reviewer of my manuscript also made the book immeasurably stronger. Thanks also to my family, both Kelens and Blooms, for believing me when I said that I really would finish this book someday. This book is dedicated to the memories of Claudia Rattazzi Papka and Rebecca Gershenson. I missed their professional advice and personal support as I worked on this volume. Their scholarly fields are the poorer because of their deaths, and they are remembered with love by colleagues and friends.
E
This page intentionally left blank
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
500 Yrs
Spurgeon, Caroline F. E. Five Hundred Years of Chaucer Criticism and Allusion, 1357–1900. 3 Vols. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1925; New York: Russell & Russell, 1960.
BibMan
Hammond, Eleanor Prescott. Chaucer: A Bibliographical Manual. New York: Peter Smith, 1933; New York: The Macmillan Company, 1908.
DNB
Stephen, Sir Leslie and Sir Sidney Lee, eds. The Dictionary of National Biography from the Earliest Times to 1900. 22 Vols. London: Oxford University Press, 1885–1901.
K-D
Kane, George and E. Talbot Donaldson, eds. Piers Plowman, the B version: Will’s Visions of Piers Plowman, Do-Well, Do-Better, and Do-Best. London: The Athlone Press, 1975.
OED
Simpson, J. A. and E. S. C. Weiner, eds. The Oxford English Dictionary. Second edition. 20 Vols. Oxford: The Clarendon Press, 1989.
RivCh
Chaucer, Geoffrey. The Riverside Chaucer. Third edition, ed. Larry D. Benson. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1987.
SAC
Studies in the Age of Chaucer.
STC
Pollard, A. W. and G. R. Redgrave, compilers. Revised by W. A. Jackson and F. S. Ferguson, completed by Katherine F. Parker. A Short-Title Catalogue of Books Printed in England, Scotland, and Ireland, and of English Books Printed Abroad, 1475– 1640. Second edition. 3 Vols. London: The Bibliographical Society, 1976–1991.
YLS
The Yearbook of Langland Studies.
This page intentionally left blank
INTRODUCTION LANGLAND AS AN EARLY MODERN AUTHOR
f asked to describe contemporary literary culture, most of us would answer in reference to living writers, perhaps those whose works are best sellers or those who have won recent literary prizes. Nevertheless, many works from earlier centuries (Hamlet, for example) retain an important place in our literary culture. It would be hard to explicate the sociology of reading, particularly as it intersects with the practice of education, without understanding the totemic status that Shakespeare’s plays have within our cultural notions of literary authority, even four centuries after their composition. To that extent, Shakespeare (though not our contemporary) still exerts a measurable force on twenty-first-century literary culture.1 On the other hand, despite the importance of Shakespeare in our understanding of literary history, no one would contend that Venus and Adonis is an integral part of the English canon. Understanding the contemporary importance of Shakespeare also includes knowing which particular Shakespearean works twenty-first-century readers still read, and how. The same holds true for later periods’ conceptions of medieval literature. To read early modern works without simultaneously paying attention to the classical and medieval works that were (or were not) reprinted alongside them produces an incomplete picture of early modern literary culture. Knowing which works from earlier periods early modern readers thought were worth preserving is part of understanding how those readers conceptualized the English literary tradition. This is particularly true for the early modern period, during which English literature first began to have a culture of print alongside a tradition of manuscript circulation. When William Caxton established his press at Westminster in 1476, he made a business decision unusual among fifteenthcentury European printers, to focus his efforts on works either written in or
I
2
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
translated into the national vernacular, whereas humanist and classical Latin texts accounted for the majority of Continental early printed books.2 When Caxton printed English works, they were works by authors already part of the historical literary tradition, but his successors began to print the work of living authors as well. By the turn of the sixteenth century, contemporary English works were competing with Middle English works in the literary marketplace, which reduced the number of medieval works that still had an audience in this new context.3 A thorough analysis of the literary culture of early modern England will attend to the intersections between that period’s contemporary and historical literature, and thus to the place of medieval texts in the early modern literary canon. Although Piers Plowman was not written in the early modern period, it did have a continuing influence on early modern readers, as I outline in the following chapters. It is therefore only somewhat jokingly that I refer, in the title of this introduction, to Langland as an early modern author. At the time of its composition in the late fourteenth century, Piers Plowman was a work very much of its moment. Most obviously, it was of its moment generically, as an alliterative work that enjoyed widespread circulation in the brief period during which Middle English alliterative verse flourished in England.4 The poem also contains a number of allusions to particular people and events. For example, the Prologue of the poem includes the story of the belling of the cat, in which the mouse cites Ecclesiastes: “Ve terre ubi puer rex est” (woe to the land where the king is a boy). This is a pointed reference to England’s boy king Richard, who was crowned in 1377 at the age of nine. More broadly and pervasively, Piers Plowman was of its moment insofar as it satirizes current theological, cultural, and political abuses, even if its satire often describes its targets in generalized terms, so that it does not stand as a record of events in one particular year. Despite its necessary connection to its own sociohistorical context, satire always looks outside of its own historical period as well; it is in the nature of satire to contrast the present with some other time (either an idealized past or a hoped for future). If the vices a satirist depicts transcend their age, they cannot be corrected, and the satire would lose its functional urgency. Satire is therefore always about “the now,” as it is distinct from other historical periods, even when that represented present is not limited to a specific year. Langland’s poem clearly struck a nerve with its original audience. Its numerous early manuscripts as well as its influence on its alliterative poetic successors attest to its literary importance in the late fourteenth and early fifteenth centuries. Not surprisingly, the majority of the research on the transmission of Piers Plowman deals with the history of the poem’s manuscripts around the end of the fourteenth century (those manuscripts surviving as well as those posited). Scholars have worked to reconstruct the lineages of
LANGLAND AS AN EARLY MODERN AUTHOR
3
the different manuscript traditions, have puzzled over whether the poem circulated in three versions or four, and have attempted to analyze the demographics of the poem’s first audience.5 Such studies are no doubt important to our understanding of Piers Plowman as a medieval poem, but they leave unquestioned the status of Piers Plowman as an early modern poem. Manuscript evidence proves that all versions of the poem were in circulation by the turn of the fifteenth century, but the poem’s circulation did not stop in the generation after its composition.6 In addition to the latefourteenth-century manuscripts of the poem, and the even greater number from the early fifteenth century, manuscripts of Piers Plowman continued to be produced and read into the sixteenth century. Piers Plowman clearly continued to have some cultural value well into the early modern period, not just as an antiquity but as a resonant literary text that engaged its later readers, making it, if only metaphorically, an important early modern text. Seven sixteenth- and seventeenth-century manuscripts of Piers Plowman, or fragments of the poem, survive. Bodleian Library MS Digby 145, a combined A and C text of the poem (sigil K of the A text and D2 of the C text), Toshiyuki Takamiya MS 23 (sigil S of the B text), Cambridge University Library MS Gg.iv.31 (sigil G of the B text), and British Library MS Royal 18 B.xvii (sigil R of the C text) all preserve sixteenth-century copies of the poem, while British Library Sloane MS 2578 contains two short extracts from the B text. Fragments of the B text of the poem are also contained in two seventeenth-century manuscripts in the Bodleian Library: MS James 2 and MS Wood donat. 7.7 Even allowing that people in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries had different reasons for copying Piers Plowman and different intellectual contexts for reading it than had their fourteenth-century predecessors, the poem’s handful of late manuscripts suggest that Piers Plowman retained its currency specifically as a poem in manuscript, not just after its time of composition, but even after 1550, when the poem first began to circulate as a printed text. Further evidence that the manuscripts of Piers Plowman remained influential in the sixteenth century is the number of sixteenth-century annotations in earlier copies. Medieval manuscripts that have survived until the twenty-first century obviously must have been somewhere relatively safe in the intervening years. Still, the fact that someone owned these books would not, in itself, guarantee that anyone actually read them. The field of medieval literature is full of works that were only rediscovered centuries after their composition, poems that have no known early modern readership. The poem’s unfamiliar verse form (the alliterative long line), its potentially difficult dialect (fourteenth-century Midlands), its extreme allusiveness and complexity, and the old-fashioned script of a fourteenthcentury manuscript all must have presented some level of challenge to the
4
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
early modern readers of Piers Plowman. It is therefore noteworthy how many of the existing manuscripts preserve evidence of having been read in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. In some cases, later readers have left extensive manuscript annotation, responding to the poem consistently throughout. More frequently, sixteenth-century readers add only a few marginal notes to the text, perhaps identifying which character is speaking or what topic the poem is concerned with in a particular passage. Even such limited annotation proves that these later readers did read the poem carefully, and perhaps also that they intended to reread it, or portions of it, with the help of their own earlier marginalia.8 Some manuscripts have sixteenth-century annotations in more than one hand, suggesting either that successive owners read and marked up the poem, or that one owner passed a copy around to multiple readers. The late-fourteenth-century B text manuscript that bears the sigil R (now divided in two, with four leaves in British Library MS Lansdowne 398 and the rest in Bodleian Library MS Rawlinson poet. 38) is a case in point. C. David Benson and Lynne Blanchfield’s edition of the B text annotations categorize the later marginalia in this manuscript as those of three fifteenthcentury hands and five unidentified sixteenth-century hands, as well as a single marginal note by a known sixteenth-century reader: John Stow.9 Although each of these later readers contributed only a few notes to the volume, together their annotations demonstrate a history of engaged close reading of the poem into the sixteenth century. The annotation by Stow in this manuscript is the place name “Stratford” in the margin at B.13.266 (manuscript fol. 63r), where Activa Vita refers to Stratford bread being shipped to London.10 There are similar marginal notes in Stow’s hand in Cambridge, Trinity College MS B.15.17 (sigil W), a late-fourteenth-century copy of the B text.11 In this copy, Stow both identifies the reference to “stratford” and marks with the date “1350” the poem’s reference to a famine so great that the bakers’ carts from Stratford did not come to London with bread.12 Stow later uses this information in his Survay of London, quoting Langland’s allusion to the bread carts from Stratford as a historical record that proves the fact that Stratford bakers had previously furnished the city of London daily with bread. After citing a reference to a Stratford baker being punished in 1310, for selling underweight loaves, Stow adds Moreover, in the 44. Of Edward the thirde, Iohn Chichester being Mayor of London, I reade in the visions of Pierce Plowman, a book so called as followeth. There was a carefull commune, when no cart came to towne with baked bread fro Stratford: tho gan beggars weep & workemen were agast, a little this will be thought long in the date of our Drirte [sic] in a drie Auerell a thousand and three hundred, twise thirtie and tenne &c.13
LANGLAND AS AN EARLY MODERN AUTHOR
5
For Stow, the historian of London, Piers Plowman functioned as a historical record; he does not even identify the alliterative lines as verse. Other sixteenth-century annotators offer more extended and readerly commentaries on the poem, responding to it as a work of literature not simply as a repository of information about a particular time and place. They read it, that is, exactly as Langland intended them to: as Christians whose salvation was bound up in the way their own lives answered the question of what it is to Do Well. Annotations of this kind pay attention to Langland’s narrative as well as his theology, for example by keeping track of which character is speaking and by recording important lessons in the margins. As Tanya Schaap observes about the sixteenth-century annotator of Oxford, Bodleian Library MS Digby 102 (C text sigil Y), “[o]ne might expect the content of the annotations of the sixteenth-century reader to differ radically from those of the scribes working sixty-five to seventy-five years earlier, but this is not the case.”14 Like early scribes, sixteenth-century commentators used their marginalia to guide future readings (their own or others’) and to help make the poem more accessible. This kind of engaged and explanatory commentary to the fourteenth-century poem by a sixteenth-century reader is most obvious in Cambridge, University Library MS Ll.iv.14 (sigil C2 of the B text). This annotator, writing in what Benson and Blanchfield term “an elegant and set mid-16th-century Secretary hand,” wrote more than 100 glosses, summaries, and character names in the margins of the manuscript.15 For the annotator of this manuscript, Piers Plowman was a living work, one that still had a theological message. For example, the annotator summarizes the agreement between Conscience, Clergy, and Patience at B.13.205–215: “Conscience Clergy and pacience be able to make pees betwixte all kyngis,” and next to B.10.62, part of Dame Study’s complaint that the wealthy abuse the poor at their gates rather than relieving their needs, the annotator remarks: “Riche men hathe litle mercy.”16 These present tense gnomic utterances apply the allegorical characters’ words to the reader’s own world. At B.10.17, when Dame Study laments the fact that “[w]isdom and wit now is no{t worth a kerse,” this sixteenth-century annotator explicitly conflates the “now” of the poem’s characters with his or her own, remarking that Study’s complaint describes “[w]ho is nowadaies called to counsaille.”17 Similar applications of the poem’s details to the reader’s present day are evident in the marginalia of British Library MS Additional 35157, a fourteenth-century copy of the C text (sigil U). This manuscript preserves extensive annotation by Francis Ayscough, its owner in the late sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries. At C.9.255, where Langland criticizes
6
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
bishops for not protecting the laity from false hermits, Ayscough comments: “bisshopes the Cause of ignoraunt pasters at this day.”18 In fact, imposters more than ignorant pastors are directly condemned in this passage. Ayscough’s detailed comments throughout the manuscript suggest that he was perfectly competent to read the medieval text, so it is unlikely that he simply misunderstood Langland’s Middle English. Ayscough’s shift from false hermits to ignorant pastors seems therefore to demonstrate his own cultural concerns as projected onto Langland’s poem, an interpretation reinforced by Ayscough’s use of the phrase “at this day.” For Ayscough, the poem’s social critique is still applicable to English society, even if it takes some liberal interpretation of Langland’s text to suit Ayscough’s particular interests. Ayscough makes an even more direct connection between his own historical moment and the text of Langland’s poem in his remark on line 95 of the C text Prologue. Here Conscience berates those priests who abandon their parishes to seek more financially rewarding positions in London. Ayscough notes in the margin that: “This conscience is now supposed to be Kinge James ye Sixt to punish the couitousnes of the clergie of Brittaine.”19 Another one of Ayscough’s notes in this manuscript is dated 1603; presumably this note is also from 1603, after the death of Queen Elizabeth, perhaps in the four months between Elizabeth’s death and the coronation of James VI of Scotland as James I of Great Britain. Ayscough’s marginal references to his contemporaries includes those less elevated than the king, too. When the narrator identifies the hypocrisy of the Doctor of Divinity who has preached a rejection of earthly pleasures, but who feasts excessively, Ayscough’s marginal annotation identifies “Doctor Robinson Doctor Barfout of Lincoln with many mor.”20 When, in the battle between Lyf and Elde, Elde hits “a fisician with a forred hoed,” Ayscough singles out “[the] vicare of Bindbrocke,” presumably as one who (like the Physician) glories in earthly possessions and hopes that medicine can stave off mortality.21 Although a number of the manuscripts of Piers Plowman have sixteenthor seventeenth-century annotations as well as owners’ signatures, there are relatively few early modern readers’ marks that can be conclusively attributed to known individuals. One famous early modern figure known to have been the owner of a Piers Plowman manuscript is Archbishop William Laud, who owned Oxford, Bodleian Library MS Laud Misc. 581 (sigil L of the B text).22 Laud’s arms are tooled on the front and back covers of the book; however, he does not seem to have made any marginal annotations to the text. Although it is clear that Laud owned the book, he may or may not have read it. Still, it is intriguing to think that the anti-Calvinist archbishop might have appreciated this poem, with its central character
LANGLAND AS AN EARLY MODERN AUTHOR
7
Will who tries to understand the agency of the individual in his or her salvation through an allegorical quest to find Do-Well. Early modern manuscript ownership is not the only measure of the importance of Piers Plowman in later centuries. The poem was alluded to by later writers, and it was printed a number of times through the early modern period, both as a whole and in excerpts. The impulse to preserve and disseminate works from earlier periods can be thought of as a kind of canonization process, although the use of that particular term for events before the eighteenth century is controversial.23 The English literary canon was, in the nineteenth century, widely accessible, as books became increasingly affordable to a diverse reading public. Moreover, as English literature moved from the drawing room to the classroom, the received canon exerted increasing force on popular thought. Sixteenth- or seventeenthcentury “canonizations” of earlier works do not have the same cultural centrality as later literary canons; however, they do construct a discrete body of literature, the importance of which is deemed transhistorical. In so doing, they embody a particular notion of literary value. This reification of a particular aesthetic is, of course, the grounds for many of the recent challenges to the received literary canon. If literary value is culturally produced rather than immanent, the canon reflects an ephemeral ideology and thus tells us less about the works in question than about later centuries’ interests. What critiques of canonization sometimes miss, however, is the fact that a canon might well include works that are valued for quite different reasons. A canon does, certainly, manifest the ideology of its makers, but that ideology is not necessarily univocal or internally coherent. The simultaneous canonization of Chaucer’s and Langland’s works in the early modern period demonstrates this. Both were copied or printed from the fifteenth century onward, and both remain central to the field of Middle English literature, as defined by both teaching and scholarship. However, as the following chapters demonstrate, even though Chaucer and Langland were both praised by sixteenth- through nineteenth-century readers, the two were often valued for different reasons. The early modern reception of Piers Plowman frequently manifested different ideologies or different understandings of literary history than did contemporary Chaucer reception, but scholarship on early modern literary medievalism has most often been written with Chaucer as a focal point. As a result, there is a wealth of criticism on fifteenth- through eighteenthcentury readings of Chaucer, but little on the postmedieval reception of other Middle English literary works.24 The Chaucer-centrism of research on early modern medievalism reflects the extent to which Chaucer has long functioned as a synecdoche for the field of Middle English in the modern academy. Other Middle English writers and literary traditions have
8
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
slowly come to prominence in contemporary scholarship, but as recently as 1997 David Lawton remarked that “the medieval enterprise in England and even more America has long been, and is little less now than ever before, tilted towards Chaucer.”25 Chaucer is the medieval English writer most familiar to nonspecialists and most studied by medievalists, perhaps because Chaucer’s identity as the “father of English literature” was already established within a century of Chaucer’s death. Seth Lerer notes that “Chaucer—as author, as ‘laureate’, and as ‘father’ of English poetry—is a construction of his later fifteenth-century scribes, readers and poetic imitators.”26 It is thus logical for scholars to ask why Chaucer came to be constructed so early and so lastingly as the central figure in the received canon of medieval English literature. Although the scholarly focus on Chaucer reception is understandable, early modern medievalism was not always analogous to early modern Chaucerianism. The reception of Piers Plowman in the early modern period sometimes parallels early modern Chaucerianism, but just as often diverges from it. In particular, early modern readers of Chaucer and Langland differed in the uses to which they put their antecedent texts. Chaucer’s works were directly imitated or translated by later writers from the fifteenth through the nineteenth centuries, but the early modern readers of Piers Plowman, particularly those after the fifteenth century, rarely found in Langland’s work a stylistic inspiration. More often they found political rhetoric, theological propaganda, linguistic evidence, and a milestone in the development of English literary history. Chaucer’s importance as a literary antecedent for Shakespeare is well known, as are the Chaucerianism of Skelton and Spenser. Even as late as the eighteenth century, Chaucer had a considerable influence on the literary tradition. In 1700, John Dryden published the Fables Ancient and Modern, which included translations of three Canterbury Tales and of the pseudo-Chaucerian “Floure and the Leafe”; in 1713, John Gay’s comedy The Wife of Bath appeared on the London stage. Chaucer clearly continued to function as a literary model for writers through the eighteenth century, while Langland’s direct literary influence essentially ended within a 100 years of his poem’s composition. As I discuss in chapter 2 below, the figure of Piers Plowman is a model for later writers through the sixteenth century, but without direct reference to Langland’s distinctive poetic idiom or to the narrative form of his poem. Piers Plowman was a literary historical reference point, not a literary exemplar, for Langland’s early modern readers.27 The fact that Langland’s work, unlike Chaucer’s, did not provide a literary model for writers after the fifteenth century is particularly noteworthy because Piers Plowman was imitated a number of times in the generation immediately after its composition. A handful of poems from that period
LANGLAND AS AN EARLY MODERN AUTHOR
9
borrow directly from the imagery and language of Piers Plowman. Helen Barr has coined the phrase “the Piers Plowman tradition” for this body of literature.28 Moreover, Steven Justice argues that even the actions of the 1381 rebels are, in a sense, “works in the Piers Plowman tradition,” as the rebels mobilized the poem’s iconography in their own texts as well as in a series of symbolic actions influenced by Langland’s work.29 Thomas Walsingham’s late-fourteenth-century chronicle preserves the text of a letter, putatively by John Ball, a leader of the Rising of 1381, which “biddeQ Peres Plou{man to go to his werk.”30 Henry Knighton’s late-fourteenthcentury Chronicon preserves four rebel letters, including one that claims authorship by “Iack Carter” and similarly invokes Piers Plowman as the name of an actual person who participated in the Rising.31 Justice argues that the continuing belief that the rebels were peasants (as medieval chroniclers describe them) has obscured the evidence that they were a diverse and often literate group, and that their references to Piers Plowman could well indicate that they had read, not just heard of, the poem.32 Later followers of Langland, those discussed in this book, make reference to Langland, but not in the manner of the 1381 rebels or the authors of poems in the Piers Plowman Tradition, all of whom absorbed Langland’s rhetoric into their own literary productions. Early modern Langlandians are in this way distinct from both late medieval followers of Langland and from early modern Chaucerians.33 The different values of Chaucer’s and Langland’s works as models for later authors is part of a larger distinction between how the two medieval poets were perceived by early modern readers. Responses to Chaucer’s poetry often identified him as transcending his age, as being somehow “unmedieval.” When Chaucer’s works were first printed together in a single volume, Thynne’s 1532 edition, the volume’s dedicatory Preface to Henry VIII says that it is moche to be marueyled, howe in his tyme, whan doutlesse all good letters were layde a slepe throughout [the] world. . .suche an excellent poete in our tonge/ shulde as it were (nature repugnyng) spryng and a ryse.34
This Preface was printed in every subsequent early modern edition of Chaucer’s works for the next two and a half centuries, from 1532 until 1793.35 Thynne’s sense that Chaucer’s poetic ability is unnatural to his era (with “nature repugnyng” excellent verse in the Middle Ages) therefore shapes the early modern understanding of Chaucer as somehow unrelated to other writers of his era. Given the fact that early modern readers saw Chaucer as uncharacteristic of his age, it is ironic that the history of early modern medievalism has been written with Chaucer reception at its center.
10
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
The early modern reading of non-Chaucerian Middle English works sometimes does, but just as often does not, replicate that of Chaucer; recognizing this allows for a more thorough and nuanced understanding of the literary historiography of early modern England. In fact, the intersections between Chaucer reception and Langland reception were often articulated in terms of contrasts not similarities. In many ways, later readers constructed Langland as the “anti-Chaucer” in the medieval literary canon. For example, where Chaucer was valued for his alleged naturalism, Langland was criticized for his use of the artificial form of personification allegory. In praising Chaucer’s invention of the tale-telling fiction for his Canterbury pilgrims, the eighteenth-century critic Thomas Warton remarks: “[F]or a number of persons in their situation, so natural, so practicable, so pleasant, I add so rational, a mode of entertainment could not have been imagined.”36 On the other hand, Langland’s nineteenth-century editor Thomas Dunham Whitaker opines that allegory of the sort used by Piers Plowman is “the most insipid for the most part and tedious of all vehicles of instruction.”37 As literary realism was becoming the dominant fictional mode, Chaucer’s narrative strategies could be assimilated into contemporary aesthetics, but Langland’s could not. Focusing on Chaucer reception, at the expense of Langland reception, has elided the diversity of early modern medievalism. Moreover, such Chaucer-centrism presumes the very canonization that Chaucer’s works underwent during that period. Considering how, when, and by whom Piers Plowman was read in the early modern period entails a question of how those later readers understood the medieval author, William Langland. Every later reader, editor, and critic of Piers Plowman defined Langland’s identity in terms that enabled particular readings of the poem. Some sixteenth-century Protestant polemicists saw Langland as their theological forerunner, whereas some eighteenth- and nineteenth-century commentators presented him as a practitioner of an early linguistic nationalism. In the chapters that follow, I discuss the early modern reception of Langland, the poet, alongside the reception of Piers Plowman, the poem. More than most other authors, Langland is inextricably linked to his work, because, in a sense, the poem is Langland for his audience. Not only is there no evidence of any other works by William Langland, there is no evidence of William Langland himself. The only surviving biographical information on William Langland is a note in Dublin, Trinity College MS 212 (a manuscript of the C Text of Piers Plowman) that “Stacy de Rokayle” was the father of William “de Langlond.”38 Scholars have been unable to find clear evidence of William Langland in any extant historical documents. C. David Benson is the most recent scholar to attempt to construct a biography of Langland from external sources, and he too had to admit failure.39 Although certainly someone
LANGLAND AS AN EARLY MODERN AUTHOR
11
wrote Piers Plowman, the William Langland so confidently referred to by medievalists is, in effect, a product of his poem, a poet whose biography has been extrapolated from interpretations of his work. John Bowers argues similarly that when editors of Piers Plowman write “the Life of the Poet,” they construct “Langland’s” biography as a back-formation of their editorial theories.40 These pseudo-biographies are themselves then used to explain the poem from which they were derived. Such biographies of William Langland may be circular, but, within the past 500 years, the poet has found himself traveling in many different circles. In chapters 1 and 2, I discuss the way both Langland and his title character are presented as participating in sixteenth-century arguments about Reformation theology. From the middle of the eighteenth century through the early nineteenth century, Langland’s identity as a theologian was downplayed in favor of his place in linguistic and poetic history. During this period, as I discuss in chapters 3 and 4, the status of Piers Plowman as a linguistic curiosity fought for priority with its status as a work of literature in its own right. In chapter 5, I discuss the explicit fictionalization of Langland’s biography by looking at works in which Langland literally became a character in imagined narratives. “Who was William Langland?” was a question answered slightly differently through the period covered by this book, not because new information about him came to light, but because the existing information (primarily the poem) was interpreted differently. The changing understanding of Langland’s identity through the early modern period is about more than the author’s biography, however; it also has to do with his cultural status, what Langland stands for. The editors of The Arden Shakespeare recognize that an author’s identity (particularly in the case of Shakespeare) has a social meaning beyond simply the originator of a written work. They ask: What is “Shakespeare?” A worldwide cultural phenomenon, a brand-name, a logo, an image that appears on T-shirts and credit cards, a mainstay of theatre, film and video production, a compulsory component of education, a label that sells thousands of books, a household name.41
Langland did not have these particular cultural meanings during the early modern period (not least because there were neither credit cards nor T-shirts), but his name and his poem were indeed used by later writers to do various kinds of ideological work in their respective historical contexts. All these different early modern Langlands, and the associated interpretations of Piers Plowman, have in common their utility for various conceptions of English national identity. In the sixteenth century, one of the central debates about British history was whether or not the historical record
12
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
justified Henry VIII’s break from the Church of Rome. Evidence on behalf of the Reformation was gathered from chronicles, legal sources, and even literary texts.42 Piers Plowman played a role in this debate, with most sixteenthcentury readers of Langland’s poem describing both its author and its title character as proto-Protestants. These Reformation readers understood Langland’s identity (as well as Piers Plowman’s identity) in light of their own experience of England’s religious break from Rome. Sixteenthcentury uses of Piers Plowman and of the Piers Plowman figure were, as chapters 1 and 2 demonstrate, important in the political and theological debates surrounding the English Reformation. Despite the humanist embrace of classical culture, the very status of medieval literature as historical gave it a particular discursive value for later editors and commentators. As documents from England’s past, medieval texts could do ideological work different from that done by more recent writings; the very “obsolescence” of medieval literature therefore gave it a political currency. In the sixteenth century, uses of medieval texts tended toward the theological; in the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, the uses of medieval texts were more sociological. Histories of English poetry from the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries use a language of racial or national continuity linking medieval and modern England. Simultaneously, where sixteenth-century readers of Piers Plowman argued for Langland’s theological similarity to his early modern readers, eighteenth- and nineteenthcentury commentators on the poem called attention to the changed doctrinal context. Although eighteenth- and nineteenth-century readers were interested in the constancy of Englishness across historical periods, they also insisted on the political and religious distance between England’s past and its present. Although the English were still of the same race as their forebears, the English nation had a different religion and a different constitution. One political arena in which those historical differences mattered was the early-nineteenth-century debate over Catholic Emancipation, which I discuss in chapter 4. Early-nineteenth-century opponents of Catholic Emancipation warned that a relaxation of the laws meant to control Britain’s Catholic subjects would collapse the divide between the past and the present, opening England’s Protestants once again to the persecution they had suffered under Queen Mary. Despite the passage of time, and the changed political climate, Catholicism retained the same threat to Protestants, according to the antiCatholic propaganda of this period. On the other side, proponents of greater rights for English and Irish Catholics sought to distance England’s present from its past by emphasizing the changed attitudes and behaviors of Britain’s Protestants as well as its Catholics, for example by reference to the cultural shift manifested in England’s recent withdrawal from the slave
LANGLAND AS AN EARLY MODERN AUTHOR
13
trade. Political claims on both sides of the Catholic Emancipation debate were thus based on the same premise of a sociocultural distance between the present and the past. The opponents of Emancipation saw in the past a model of persecution that they did not want to see repeated; supporters of Emancipation considered the sixteenth-century conflicts between England’s Catholics and Protestants to be dependent on a particular political environment now superseded, and therefore as irrevocably past. In different contexts, Piers Plowman was used by eighteenth- and nineteenth-century commentators to demonstrate both continuity and change. Philologically and theologically, Piers Plowman manifested for these later readers the differences between fourteenth- and nineteenth-century Britain. These critics repudiated the earlier attempts to make Langland an advocate for the English Reformation, instead presenting him within his historical context as a Catholic writer. At the same time, Piers Plowman was identified as an originary document in the history of English poetry, a literary tradition seen as continuous (unlike England’s religious tradition). As a poet, Langland transcended history, since the poetic record was identified as linking England’s past and its present, and as manifesting a literary sensibility inherent in Britons of all times. The English language had changed, as had the cultural climate, but the English people were more alike than different over time. Langland could thus mingle with later authors in the context of a literary anthology, despite their poetic and historical differences. As a representative of the poetic ability native to Britain, Langland was often explicitly compared with his contemporary Chaucer. Another identity that Langland had for early modern editors and commentators was, then, as a foil for Chaucer. In chapter 5, I analyze the most extreme form of these juxtapositions between the two Middle English authors: narratives that fictionalize the two authors as characters and imagine literary and personal exchanges between them. Such fictional narratives are often designed to explain the stylistic and linguistic differences between Piers Plowman and Chaucer’s works. Nineteenth-century biographies of Langland sometimes cast him as rejecting Chaucer’s fashionable Gallicisms and London dialect in favor of a nationalistic adherence to a traditional English form and language. This explanation has a double utility, insofar as it acknowledges the fact that Chaucer’s works appeal more to the modern reader, but without disparaging Langland in the process. The more difficult poetics of Piers Plowman are not due to Langland’s deficiencies as a poet, then, but rather to the fact that Langland, like so many early-nineteenth-century Englishmen, obviously despised the French. In studying Piers Plowman reception, I pay particular attention to the editions in which the poem appeared, either whole or in part, during the
14
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
early modern period. Editions of works from earlier periods are explicitly and inherently anachronistic. They transport words from the past into a presentist context. In doing so, they reconfigure not only the meanings but also the potential uses of their texts. Tim William Machan asserts that “an edition is. . .simultaneously two ontologically distinct entities: a contemporary work—an edition—that is itself a site of interpretation and, in effect, the historical work it presumes to recuperate.”43 In my analysis, I am less concerned with the second of his two categories of meaning, the content of the edition as it represents the original work. Thus, although my work is related to, and very much indebted to, the criticism on the successive editions of Piers Plowman, it is not, strictly speaking, editorial history.44 My interest in the editions of Piers Plowman is more metatextual than textual. The textual history of Piers Plowman can help later scholars understand the editorial, as well as authorial, origins of the texts we read. However, in the usual narrative trajectory of textual history, earlier editions, which were based on editorial theories and methods since superseded, figure mainly as foils to their later (and better) successors. The subtitle of Charlotte Brewer’s Editing “Piers Plowman”: The Evolution of the Text demonstrates this attitude toward editorial history. Later editions of Piers Plowman are, undoubtedly, based on a more thorough comparison of manuscripts and on an increasingly rigorous editorial theory. In this regard, their texts of the poem are better. Nevertheless, when considering the textual history of a medieval poem in centuries long after the medieval period, I prefer to set aside the question of how each editor prepared the text for publication, and focus rather on why that editor chose to publish the text at all. With the exception of Chaucer’s works, most Middle English literature was in very limited circulation throughout the early modern period. In the fifteenth century, William Caxton and his earliest successors printed a number of late medieval works by Gower, Lydgate, Hoccleve, Malory, and others.45 During the early modern period, most Middle English works (including some now widely taught in college courses) all but disappeared from circulation. To take a case in point, John Gower’s Confessio Amantis survives in fifty-seven complete or partial manuscripts, and it was published in 1483, 1532, and 1554, but then not published at all in either the seventeenth or the eighteenth century.46 Piers Plowman, however, remained relatively available to readers throughout the early modern period, and it is therefore worth examining how later readers made sense of Langland’s text and what meanings it had for them. To differentiate what a publication means to an editor from what a work means to its author, the text must be analyzed within two discrete social contexts of production and reproduction. These two meanings (authorial and editorial) together produce a third kind of meaning: that for the reader of an edited work.47 Editors and
LANGLAND AS AN EARLY MODERN AUTHOR
15
commentators on literary works function as “super readers”: they make public their personal interpretations and thus influence future readings of the text, shaping its meaning for new audiences.48 In doing so, they also perpetuate their particular beliefs about Langland. Piers Plowman has, for the past 450 years, been a poem notoriously difficult for its readers. In genre, language, theology, and sociopolitical context, the poem was foreign to its early modern audience. Nevertheless, it continued to have an audience, an audience whose responses still retain some residual influence on how the poet and his poem are understood by modern readers (whether they agree with those earlier interpretations or argue against them).49 The early modern identities of Langland manifest the ways ideology puts pressure on interpretation, encouraging readers to see (or not see) very particular meanings in texts. Although Piers Plowman has had a continuous readership for the past 600 years, those readers have, in a sense, been reading “different poems,” as the common understanding of the poem and of its author have shifted through the years, While early modern beliefs about Langland may not always correspond to those current today, the different roles Langland played for his early modern audiences do help us understand the ideologies and medievalisms of those past Langlandians.
This page intentionally left blank
CHAPTER 1 THE BIRTH OF LANGLAND
he sixteenth-century readers of Piers Plowman who first attempted to make public the poet’s identity had little evidence to go on. Despite this, they did attempt to transmit a biography of the poet as an adjunct to his poem. Medieval authors sometimes named themselves in their works, but when they did so, it was by way of autocitation more than autobiography.1 Authors might name themselves in their works, but without much psychological detail.2 To take one well-known example, Geoffrey Chaucer refers to his weight in the House of Fame, and to his works in both the Legend of Good Women and the so-called Retraction of the Canterbury Tales.3 However, his works never refer to either his professional or emotional life. We know of Chaucer’s marriage, as well as his services as a customs official, clerk of the king’s works, and a member of parliament, but not because he mentions any of them in his poetry. One medieval author who includes some autobiographical detail in her works is Christine de Pizan, who explains in her Livre de la Mutacion de Fortune her transformation from the happy life she lived when Fortune was kind to her, before the death of her husband. This event was instrumental in her pursuit of poetry as a means to support herself. In Christine’s discussion of the changes in her status after her husband’s death, she explains that Fortune changed her gender not just her economic status: “I. . .was transformed from a woman into a man by Fortune who wanted it that way. Thus she transformed me, my body and my face, completely into those of a natural man.”4 Christine’s transformation story is obviously metaphorical, but all autobiographical literature is to some extent fictionalized by the act of composition, even if not as overtly as Mutacion de Fortune. Readers’ interpretations of first-person narratives therefore tend to be influenced by external evidence about the people or events described. For contemporary authors, that evidence appears on book jackets or in promotional interviews, and it is usually easily accessible to be read in conjunction with the
T
18
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
texts. It is an often unspoken principle of contemporary hermeneutics that knowing more about an author allows the reader to understand more about her or his works. Unlike modern psychologizing readers, medieval readers did not seem to take much interest in an author’s life (beyond her or his role specifically as an author), and biographies of medieval authors do not tend to circulate alongside their literary works. During the early modern period, however, individual authors began to take on increasing importance as determinants of textual interpretation. Roland Barthes’s statement that “[t]he author is a modern figure” no doubt overstates the difference between modern and premodern notions of subjectivity, but the figure of the author does become increasingly central to literary interpretation in the sixteenth century.5 The first English writer to benefit from this new importance of the author was Chaucer, whose poetry was published together in a volume of Workes almost a century before Jonson’s self-canonization in his Workes of 1616 or the publication of The Workes of the Most High and Mightie Prince, Iames, also printed in 1616.6 Although Chaucer’s poetry had been in print in England since the time Caxton set up his printshop in the late fifteenth century, the collection of his works in a single volume was a new format, and it demonstrates the fact that the Chaucer name (not just the names of the individual works) was marketable in the sixteenth century. Chaucer’s name was already attached to his poetry in some medieval manuscripts of his works, but many medieval poems did not circulate under a particular authorial name. In the many instances when a poet’s name was unknown, medieval scribes were content to transmit works without explicitly designating them “Anonymous,” whereas modern readers feel compelled to append that designation to works by unknown authors. In contrast to the frequent disregard for authorial identity in the Middle Ages, sixteenth-century literary theory began to shift more toward the author than the work. For modern readers, even anonymous works have a single, nameable, even if yet unnamed, author whose due must be acknowledged. It is a measure of the degree to which anonymity of authorship was a nonissue in the premodern period that the word “Anonymous” did not enter the language until the close of the sixteenth century, for only then was the author’s name so necessary that the absence of that name was worthy of discussion.7 Although the poet William Langland (if that was his name) lived and wrote in the fourteenth century, the idea of “William Langland” as the poem’s explanatory function did not come into being until the sixteenth century. In the case of Piers Plowman, the poem’s early anonymity may indicate something more than a literary culture that did not prioritize authorship. The subject and tone of Piers Plowman, a poem that criticizes
THE BIRTH OF LANGLAND
19
hypocrisy among the clergy and those in government, might also account for the poet’s reluctance to name himself directly. If being the author of Piers Plowman was not a controversial public identity before 1381, when the poem’s discourse was taken up as a rallying cry for rebellion, it seems likely to have been so afterward.8 Even in the passages of Piers Plowman where Langland ostensibly identifies himself, it might not be by his actual name. The authorial self-reference most visible in the poem is the dreamer’s statement that “I haue lyued in londe,. . .my name is longe wille” (B.15.152), which is taken to be an anagram of “Will[iam] Longe-Londe.”9 Kathryn Kerby-Fulton and Steve Justice have pointed out that “Long-land” might well be a punning pen name, given that “a ‘longland’ is a long strip of ploughland,” and “Langland is a very rare surname.”10 Anne Middleton too notes this use of “longe launde,” but without the implication that it might be a pen name. Middleton takes the poet to be exploiting the symbolic value of his actual surname: “though formally a proper name or surname, the ‘long land’ designates what he possesses in common with all mortals, his unsatisfied desire or will.”11 If Kerby-Fulton and Justice are right that the poem initially circulated among a coterie, the original audience would know who the real author was and would, moreover, get the joke of the pseudonym. Once the poem circulated outside of that original audience, which it did very quickly, its authorship may not have been known. For a twenty-first-century reader who comes to the poem knowing the name William Langland, the mixed syllables of B.15.152 are not hard to decode, but, for a reader not yet aware of the name Langland, it is unlikely that this juxtaposition of “londe” and “longe” would be sufficient for decoding the poet’s surname. As George Kane has pointed out, although a number of manuscripts have annotations marking “longe wille” as the poet’s name, none apparently solve the “longe londe Langland” riddle.12 One early acknowledgment of the “longe wille” name is the omission of the nickname from Cambridge, Newnham College MS 4 (sigil Y of the B text) from the early fifteenth century; the scribe of this manuscript has left blank the space where the name belongs so that it could be rubricated later.13 In Cambridge, Trinity College MS B.15.17 (sigil W of the B text) a late-fourteenth- or early-fifteenth-century copy of the poem, the nickname is ruled around.14 In Oxford, Oriel College MS 79 (sigil O of the B text), a fifteenth-century manuscript, the poem’s scribe has written “longe wille” in the margin to mark this line.15 A similar note was probably intended by the scribe of Huntington Library MS HM 114 (sigil Ht of the B text) as well. The scribe of this mid-fifteenth-century manuscript has rubricated the words “long Wille,” and has written “lw” in the margin, which Benson and Blanchfield interpret as the guide mark for a
20
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
later, unexecuted note, “long wille.”16 The scribes of the Oriel College and Huntington Library manuscripts were consistent annotators of the poem.17 In contrast, the fourteenth-century scribe of Bodleian Library MS Rawlinson poetry 38 (sigil R of the B text) made only two annotations to the poem. The first was a “nota” marking lines 14.134–139, Patience’s warning that the wealthy, who have their reward on earth, seldom earn a heavenly reward as well. The second is a marginal repetition of the name “Longe Wille,” in what Benson and Blanchfield identify as a “red display script.”18 There are also a handful of manuscripts in which the “longe wille” name was marked by a later reader but not by the scribe. In the most heavily annotated of the B text manuscripts, the early-fifteenth-century British Library MS Additional 35287 (sigil M), the name “longe will” has been underlined by a later reader.19 The mid-fifteenth-century Cambridge, University Library MS Ll.iv.14 (sigil C2 of the B text) is annotated throughout in a mid-sixteenth-century secretary hand. This reader has written “Longe will” in the margin next to line 15.152.20 Two manuscripts contain annotations explicitly interpreting the “long wille” name of the poem’s first-person narrator as that of the author. A fifteenth-century note in British Library Additional MS 10574 (sigil Bm of the B text, itself from the late fourteenth or early fifteenth century) says “Nomen auctoris huius libri est longe wille.”21 Similarly, Bodleian Library MS Laud Misc. 581 (sigil L of the B text), an early-fifteenth-century manuscript, contains a number of annotations by a sixteenth-century annotator writing in a secretary hand. At B.15.152, this annotator has marked the “long will” passage with: “nota the name of thauctour.”22 The scribes and annotators of manuscripts Y, W, O, Ht, R, M, C2, Bm, and L all mark the name “longe wille” in some way. In some cases, this is one among many names highlighted, but in other cases (like that of MS R), the marginal repetition of the name stands out as unusual. Kane takes the various scribal and readerly recognitions of the “longe wille” signature as evidence that B.15.152 is, in fact, an authorial signature, even if it is couched in such a form that the William Langland name was obscured from those who did not already know it.23 These scribes and readers are, in this argument, aware of a tradition that this identification of the narrator is also that of the author. The number of manuscripts that mark this alleged signature does seem significant, but, at the same time, none of the scribes or later readers who marks the “longe wille” name attempts to look past what is clearly a nickname to derive the author’s proper name, let alone any biographical details about him. Clearly the medieval scribes and early modern readers do not share the modern interest in defining precisely who “longe wille” really was, and thus decoding the cryptic signature.
THE BIRTH OF LANGLAND
21
Of the different ways manuscripts mark line B.15.152, only five of these indications of the name seem to be scribal (those in MSS Y, W, O, Ht, and R). Thus, most of the scribes of B text manuscripts copied the poem without noticing or without calling attention to this authorial signature. It was a fairly common practice for authors to sign their work in acrostics and puns in the Middle Ages, and Langland was not the only medieval English writer whose self-referentiality went unnoticed or unremarked by scribes.24 Ranulf Hidgen “signs” his fourteenth-century Latin Polychronicon using an acrostic of the first letters of the chapters of book I. Read together, these chapter initials spell: “Presentem cronicam compilavit Frater Ranulphus monachus cestrensis.” Of the five manuscripts discussed by the Rolls Series editors, only two have annotations explicitly indicating this signature, and both are late manuscripts (one is in a sixteenth-century hand; the other is in a seventeenth-century hand).25 The coded signature of B.15.152 does not appear in the C text of the poem. Nevertheless, two C text manuscripts contain references to the poet (and not just the poem’s central character) as “Will.” The explicit of Liverpool, University Library MS F.4.8, a combined A text–C text manuscript from the early fifteenth century (sigil Ch) reads: “Explicit liber Willielmi de Petro le Plow{man”26 Similarly, a group of five related C text manuscripts contain the note “Explicit visio Willielmi W. de Petro le Plouhman” after Passus 9.27 The scribal Conclusion appended to the poem in one manuscript of the A text also records that “‘Wille. . ./. . ./’” wrou{the Qat here is wryten and oQer werkes boQe/ Of Peres Qe Plowman and mechel puple also.”28 These annotations ascribe to the poet the narrator’s given name, Will, but they do not offer any surname for the poet, nor do they give any biographical detail that might elucidate who this Will is, other than the author of this work (and of other works, according to the scribe who wrote the A text Conclusion). Dublin, Trinity College MS D.4.1, a fourteenth-century C text manuscript is the earliest attempt to give a full name to the poet, let alone any biography. A note in this manuscript reads : Memorandum quod Stacy de Rokayle pater Willielmi de Langlond qui stacius fuit generosus & morabatur in Schipton’ vnder Whicwode tenens domini le Spenser in comitatu Oxon’ qui predictus Willielmus fecit librum qui vocatur Perys ploughman.29
The writer of this note records first that “Stacy de Rokayle” was the father of “William de Langlond,” and that this “Stacy” [Eustace] lived in Shiptonunder-Wychwood in Oxfordshire, holding land of the Despenser family. Only after the identification of his father is William Langland cited as the
22
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
author of the poem. In this lone early identification of the poet, most of the note is taken up by a discussion of Stacy de Rokayle’s economic and social position. For the annotator of the Dublin manuscript, identity is pedigree. The profession, residence, theology, or political faction of the poet himself is, implicitly, less important than his father’s name and affiliations. Langland’s father gives the poet a social identity, connecting him (if indirectly) to a powerful family in a known social milieu.30 Although most early scribes and readers (with the exception of the author of the Dublin manuscript note) are content not to record the poet’s biography, the authorship of Piers Plowman seems to have become important to readers in the sixteenth century. Authorial identity was, in general, more important as a hermeneutic category to sixteenth- than to fifteenthcentury readers, and in the case of Piers Plowman, the poet’s alleged political and theological affiliations seem more interesting to some later readers than did the poem itself. The biographical information by which sixteenthcentury writers define William Langland’s identity frequently manifests those writers’ desire to cast Langland as a critic of the Church of Rome, and thus as a proto-Protestant. Such a creation of a prehistory for English Protestantism was just one of the rhetorical strategies used by English Reformation theologians to justify their break with the papacy.31 In the context of these two early modern developments—the “Birth of the Author” and the reinterpretation of England’s history as protoProtestant—it is to be expected that the study of Piers Plowman entailed an interest in its poet’s ideology. The annotation in the Dublin manuscript identifies William Langland by his family history, whereas sixteenthcentury attributions of the poem tend to focus on Langland’s theology, not his parentage. The antiquary John Bale published his first overview of English writers, the Illustrium maioris Britannia scriptorum. . .summarium, while on the Continent during the reign of Mary.32 In this work, Bale listed British writers chronologically in five groups of 100 (called “centuries”). Although 500 authors is a sizable collection, Bale did not intend the Summarium to be a complete and definitive listing but rather a “makeshift interim report” until John Leland published his own more extensive collection.33 Leland, who had been collecting sources for a dictionary of British writers, a description of Britain, a history of Britain, and a history of British noble families, unfortunately went mad before he could publish any of them.34 When Bale returned to England after the accession of Edward VI, he expanded and revised the Summarium, publishing the Catalogus of British writers in 1557.35 The Catalogus expanded the list of writers from five to nine “centuries”; two years later, Bale added the Posterior Pars, including five more “centuries” of authors.36
THE BIRTH OF LANGLAND
23
After Leland lost his sanity, Bale became his literary executor. In 1549, under the title The laboryouse Journey & serche of Johan Leyland, Bale published an annotated edition of Leland’s “New Year’s Gift,” which Leland had given in manuscript to King Henry VIII in 1546.37 By the time he compiled the Catalogus, Bale had access to Leland’s materials on the history of British authors, and he used them to expand and correct his own work. The title page to the Posterior Pars identifies Bale’s debt to Leland as a major source of materials; the subtitle of the Posterior Pars is: “qvas avthor, Ioannes Baleus Sudouolgius, Anglus, ex Lelando Antiquario, alijsque probis authoribus, non paruo labore collegit.”38 When Bale was working on his first collection, the Summarium, he seems to have not yet seen Leland’s notes, as his information differs from Leland’s in a number of places.39 One such difference is in Bale’s original (mis)attribution of the authorship of Piers Plowman. In the Summarium, Bale lists “Petrum Agricolam” as one of the works of John Wyclif, linking the poem to a theologian understood in the sixteenth century to be a forerunner of the Reformation. It is clear from this attribution that the social meaning of Piers Plowman changed between the fourteenth and the sixteenth centuries. Anne Middleton has surveyed the works that accompany Piers Plowman in medieval manuscripts, concluding that early readers seem to have understood Piers Plowman “as a compendiously didactic work, whose literary mode is narrative or historical.”40 Bale’s original attribution of Piers Plowman to Wyclif suggests that he understood the poem primarily as a work of theology. This was to remain the dominant interpretation of Piers Plowman through the sixteenth century, although Bale soon changed his theory of its authorship removing Piers Plowman from his list of Wyclif’s works in the Catalogus. Interestingly, even when he no longer credits Wyclif with the authorship of Piers Plowman, Bale continues to identify Wyclif as an author of vernacular satire. The Catalogus lists among Wyclif’s writings “Ioannem à rure, contra fratres”: that is, Jack Upland, an anonymous Wycliffite anti-fraternal treatise in Middle English prose.41 Bale’s attribution of Jack Upland to Wyclif was unusual; in the sixteenth century, Jack Upland was usually ascribed to Chaucer, and it was printed as one of Chaucer’s works in Speght’s 1602 edition and Urry’s 1721 edition.42 In the 1557 Catalogus, Bale attributed Piers Plowman to “Robertus Langelande.”43 How and when he came to change his attribution is unclear. Bale’s notebook, written between 1549 and 1577, includes four references to Robert Langland that he cites as having been gathered from the collections of Nicholas Brigham (ex collecties Nicolai Brigam), from the house of William Spark (ex domo Guilhelmi Sparke), and from Dr. John Widsom (Ex Ioanne Wysdome medico).44 Although Bale records the names of
24
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
those who supplied him with materials, it is not always clear what particular materials they lent him, so his immediate source for the Robert Langland name remains uncertain. In 1935, R. B. Haselden and H. C. Schulz argued that the manuscript of William Sparke that Bale had seen was Huntington Library MS HM 128.45 Certainly HM 128 was a manuscript that Bale had used at some point, as it preserves on a pastedown an inscription in his hand: “Robertus langlande natus in comitatu salopie in villa Mortymers Clybery in the claylande, within viij myles of Malverne hylles, scripsit peers ploughman li. 1.” This note on Langland is followed by a copy of the poem’s first line as it is given in this manuscript.46 Bale’s brief biography of Robert Langland in this note is, in shorter form, the one given in his Catalogus (quoted in full below). Presumably, then, HM 128 is one of the sources that Bale used while working to compile the Catalogus. It is also possible that Bale used HM 128 after the publication of the Catalogus and that he added the short biographical annotation to the manuscript while he was using it, having already published a longer version of the same. However, Haselden and Schulz note that HM 128 is the only one of the surviving manuscripts of Piers Plowman that preserves the reading “set” rather than “soft” in the poem’s opening line: “In a someres seysoun whan set was the sunne.” Bale’s notebook similarly transcribes the William Sparke copy of the poem as using the adjective “set.”47 In the Catalogus, Bale translates the poem’s opening line to the Latin: “In aestiuo tempore cum sol caleret.”48 No surviving manuscript preserves the reading: “when hot was the sun.” Presumably “hot” was Bale’s attempt to correct the nonsensical reading “set” in the poem’s opening line, as no pilgrim would set forth after nightfall. Bale’s preference for the reading “hot” is shown also in his notebook reference to the manuscript “Ex collectis Nicolai Brigam,” where Bale quotes the poem’s opening line as: “In a somer sonday whan sote was ye sunne.”49 Poole notes that above the word “sote” Bale has written “warme.” A modern reader would be more inclined to correct “sote” to “softe,” rather than attempting to gloss it as Bale does. Immediately preceding the note by Bale on this pastedown is another sixteenth-century note on the poem’s authorship: “Robert or william langland made pers plowman.”50 Given their prior conclusion that HM 128 is the manuscript Bale claims to have seen “Ex domo Guilhelmi Sparke,” Haselden and Schulz argue further that this inscription may be by William Sparke himself.51 This is certainly quite possible, but in this case the name of the poet mentioned in the inscription seems as interesting as the name of the author of the inscription. Whoever wrote this note clearly knew both the William Langland and Robert Langland names, but was not willing to make a choice between them. Bale and the author of the HM 128 note are not alone in the attribution of Piers Plowman to Robert Langland. Five other
THE BIRTH OF LANGLAND
25
manuscripts of the poem preserve sixteenth-century notes identifying the poet as “Robertus Langlande.”52 The name “Robert” is generally agreed to derive from a scribal misreading of line B.8.1: “Thus yrobed in russet I romed aboute.” In two unrelated manuscripts (one each of the B and A texts) “yrobed” is replaced by some form of “I, Robert.”53 These two readings of “Robert” may be witnesses to coincidentally similar errors in transmission, or they may have been suggested to their originators by an independently circulating tradition about the poet’s name. Although the name “Robert” is attested twice by the first quarter of the fifteenth century, the names “Robert” and “Langland” are not put together until the sixteenth century. It is possible that a now-lost manuscript contained both the poet’s surname and the “I, Robert” reading; it is also possible that the originator of the Robert Langland name knew the name William Langland but doubted that Will was the poet’s name as well as the allegorical dreamer’s. In this case, the “I, Robert” misreading of B.8.1 might have sufficient persuasive force to suggest the emendation of William Langland to Robert Langland. The Catalogus attributes Piers Plowman to Robert Langland (rather than John Wyclif), but Bale still ascribes Wycliffite theology to Langland. His Catalogus entry on Langland reads: Robertus Langelande, sacerdos, ut apparet, natus in comitatu Salopiae, in uilla uulgo dicta Mortymers Clibery, in terra lutea, octauo à Maluernis montibus milliario fuit. Num tamen eo in loco, inconditio & agresti, in bonis literis ad maturam aetatem usque informatus fuerit, certo adfirmare non possum. ut neque, an Oxonij aut Cantabrigiae illis insudauerit: quum apud eorum locorum magistros, studia praecipue uigerent. Illud ueruntamen liquido constat, eum fuisse ex primis Ioannis Uuicleui discipulis unum, atque in spiritus feruore, contra apertas Papistarum blasphemias aduersus Deum & eius Christum, sub amœnibus coloribus & typis edidisse in sermone Anglico pium opus, ac bonoru[m] uirorum lectione dignu[m], quod uocabat Visionem Petri Aratoris,
Lib. I. In aestiuo tempore cum sol caleret.
Nihil aliud ab ipso editum noui. In hoc opere erudito, præter similitudines uarias & iucundas, prophetic[ae] plura prædixit, qu[ae] nostris diebus impleri uidimus. Compleuit suum opus anno Domini 1368, dum Ioannes Cicestrius Londini praetor esset.54
Despite Bale’s certainty about the date of Piers Plowman (1368, during the mayoralty of John Chichester), many of the details in this entry are things about which Bale is uncertain: whether Langland was a priest, whether he was educated in Mortimers Cliberry; whether he attended Oxford or
26
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
Cambridge; whether he wrote other works. One thing that Bale says he can affirm with certainty (“ueruntamen liquido constat”) is Langland’s identity as a disciple of Wyclif. Bale’s evidence for Langland’s Wycliffism is in an anti-Catholic idiom that Langland, a “papist” himself, surely would have rejected had he lived to read it.55 Bale’s (erroneous) assertion that Langland was a follower of Wyclif clearly gained some currency for later English readers. Bale’s biography is paraphrased over a century later by Thomas Fuller in his 1662 Histories of the Worthies of England. Fuller says that Robert Langland “was born at MortimersClibery in [Shropshire], eight miles from Malvern-Hills; was bred a Priest, and one of the first followers of John Wickliffe, wanting neither Wit nor Learning, as appears by his Book called ‘The Visions of Pierce Plowghman.’” 56 Other than the assertion that Langland “want[ed] neither Wit nor Learning,” which is implicit but not stated in the Catalogus biography, all of the details of Fuller’s biography are those as given by Bale. The arrangement of writers in Bale’s Catalogus reinforces his claim that Langland was a Wycliffite. The “centuries” into which Bale divides his authors function thematically, not merely enumeratively. Whereas the fifth century of writers highlighted the perversity of scholastic theology, and thus that of the Catholic Church, the sixth century, beginning with John Wyclif, displays for Bale the doctrinal struggle between Protestantism and Catholicism.57 By including Langland in the sixth century, Bale aligns Langland with Wyclif and against Catholicism. Bale’s new understanding of Piers Plowman as the work of an anti-Catholic poet named “Robert Langland” may be related, whether directly or indirectly, to the similar interpretation of Langland’s first editor, Robert Crowley. Bale’s claim that Langland was a follower of Wyclif, his claim that he was a prophet, and his naming as “Robert” are all paralleled by the biographical information given in Robert Crowley’s editorial Preface to the three 1550 editions of Piers Plowman, the poem’s first appearance in print.58 All three of Crowley’s editions were based on a B text manuscript, now lost.59 Crowley’s three 1550 editions all begin with the same Preface “From the Printer to the Reader” on fol. *iir–v. This Preface opens with a discussion of the author’s name and biography: Beyng desyerous to knowe the name of the Autoure of thys most worthy worke. (gentle reader) and the tyme of the writynge of the same: I did not onely gather togyther suche aunciente copies as I could come by, but also consult such men as I knew to be more exercised in the studie of antiquities. then I my selfe haue ben. And by some of them I haue learned that the Autour was named Roberte langelande, a Shropshere man borne in Cleybirie, aboute viii. myles from Maluerne hilles.60
THE BIRTH OF LANGLAND
27
Crowley’s biography of Langland parallels Bale’s to a great extent, and the two seem in some way related. The direction of transmission is, however, not obvious: although Bale’s biography was published seven years after Crowley’s editions, the notebook entries about “Robert Langland” are undated. It is also unclear whether the transmission occurred directly between Bale and Crowley or through other texts, including, perhaps, the aforementioned manuscripts that preserve annotations about “Robertus Langlande.” The undated sixteenth-century manuscript notes may themselves derive from either a common manuscript source or from the poet’s biography as given in Crowley’s edition. In a study of Piers Plowman manuscript marginalia, Carl James Grindley has observed that it was not uncommon for fifteenth- and sixteenth-century manuscript marginalia to be copied from printed versions of texts, and there is one known annotator who copied marginalia from one of the Crowley editions of Piers Plowman: Thomas Thyrnbeke, a sixteenth-century annotator of British Library Additional MS 35157 (sigil U of the C text).61 Unlike Bale, who was himself a parish priest and eventually bishop of Ossory, Crowley does not seem interested in the question of whether or not Langland was a priest. Crowley does nevertheless emphasize the spiritual import of the poem: “There is no maner of vice, that reygneth in anye estate of men, whyche thys wryter hath not godly, learnedlye, and wittilye, rebuked.”62 Absent is any discussion of Langland’s vocation; he seems in Crowley’s account to be a layperson who has dedicated his literary practice to the spiritual correction of his readers. He seems, that is, much like Crowley himself, whose own writings were exclusively religious: a verse translation of the Psalter and a number of anti-Catholic polemical tracts.63 John Bowers has pointed out that Crowley was born in Gloucestershire, a few miles from the Malvern Hills, and that Crowley’s report of Langland’s birth comes from an identification between editor and author. If so, this identification extends beyond their respective birthplaces and into their literary vocation. About half of Crowley’s Preface is taken up with a discussion of Langland’s time of composition. Crowley gives the year 1409 as the poem’s terminus ad quem, claiming that he has seen a manuscript that gives that date of copying. Crowley’s terminus a quo for Piers Plowman is 1350, since: in the seconde syde of the .lxviii. leafe of thys printed copye, I finde me[n]tion of a dere yere, that was in the yere of oure Lorde M. iii. hundred and .L. John Chichester than beyng mayre of London.64
In fact, Chichester was mayor of London from 1369 to 1370, not 1350. The line that Crowley refers to here is Activa Vita’s discussion of the effects
28
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
of a recent famine. As printed by Kane-Donaldson, the lines are In Qe date of oure dri{te, in a drye Aprill, A thousand and Qre hundred, twies [Qritty] and ten, My wafres were gesene whan Chichestre was Maire.65
As the brackets around [Qritty] indicate, most of the manuscripts of the B text of the poem read “twies twenty” in line 269, resulting in the 1350 date that Crowley mentions. Only Bodleian Library MS Laud Misc. 581(sigil L) and Bodleian Library MS Rawlinson poet. 38 (sigil R) contain the chronologically accurate date (1370) as produced by the “twies thritty” reading. The manuscript variants of this line show different attempts to reconcile the received reading with the actual dates of Chichester’s mayoralty, from a replacement of the “twies. . .ten” directly with “syxty and nyne” in Huntington Library MS HM 128 (sigil Hm) to “thries twenty” in British Library MS Cotton Vespasian B.xvi (sigil M).66 Bale, like Crowley, uses Chichester’s mayoralty to date the poem, but he gives the terminus a quo as 1368, a date given in no surviving manuscript. Of the three sources given in Bale’s notebook, only the information from John Wisdom attempts to date the poem, but the date is given correctly as 1369: “Claruit A.D. 1369, dum Ioannees chichestre pretor esset Londini.”67 Perhaps Bale thought that Chichester was elected in 1368, or perhaps Bale had the date correct and 1368 is an error in the printing. This difference in dating, amid the other similarities in their author biographies, might indicate that Bale’s and Crowley’s texts are only indirectly rather than directly related.68 Despite the difference between their hypotheses about the poem’s date, both Crowley and Bale use their dates to correlate Langland with Wyclif. This is particularly striking in Crowley’s case, because his emphasis on the termini a quo and ad quem leaves a wide range in which the poem could have been written. Crowley determines that the poem “was fyrste made and written after the yeare of our lorde. M. iii. C. L [1350] and before the yere. M. iiii. C. and ix [1409] which meane space was lix yeres.”69 Although Crowley gives more than a half century in which the poem could have been written, he immediately limits the possible time of composition: We may iustly co[n]iect thefore [that] it was firste written about two hundred yeres paste in the tyme of Kynge Edwarde the thyrde. In whose tyme it pleased God to open the eyes of many to se hys truth, geuing them boldenes of herte, to open their mouthes and crye oute agaynste the workes of darckenes, as dyd John Wicklyfe, who also in those dayes translated the holye Byble into the Englishe tonge, and this writer who in reportynge
THE BIRTH OF LANGLAND
29
certayne visions and dreames, that he fayned hym selfe to haue dreamed, doth most christianlie enstructe the weake, and sharpleye rebuke the obstynate blynde.70
By ascribing the poem to the reign of Edward III (1327–1377), Crowley silently rules out thirty-two of the fifty-nine years in which the poem could have been written. One could give a textual justification for this decision: the further after 1350 (in Crowley’s dating) the poem was composed, the less force Activa Vita’s reference to the dearth would have. As discussed in chapter 3, some eighteenth-century readers of Piers Plowman would take Langland’s “archaic” (actually non-London) dialect as evidence for dating the poem before the works of Chaucer; a similar interpretation of the poem’s difficult language could also have provided Crowley with a justification for his early dating. In fact, Crowley does not offer any rationale. His belief that the poem was written in the third quarter of the fourteenth century seems to take implicit justification only from the analogy between Langland and Wyclif. The name of Edward III also seems important to Crowley. If Crowley’s only purpose was to make Langland contemporaneous with Wyclif, he could have done so without reference to the ruler (as, for example, Bale does). Moreover, England had three different monarchs in the fifty-nine year span during which Crowley locates the composition of Piers Plowman: Edward III, Richard II (r. 1377–1399), and Henry IV (r. 1399–1413). Crowley describes Edward’s reign as a time of spiritual awakening and religious protest, a time when men not only “saw [God’s] truth” but had the “boldenes of herte” to speak against “the worckes of darckenes.” To a midsixteenth-century reader, this description of a general reformation of religious sentiment in England would look quite familiar. In Crowley’s telling, the reign of Edward III looks very much like that of Edward VI, the reigning monarch when Crowley edits Piers Plowman. Just as Crowley describes Langland in his own image, he also describes Langland’s era in terms he might equally have used to describe his own. Moreover, Crowley’s edition of another work he printed in 1550, Wyclif’s Prolog, has some verbal echoes of the Piers Plowman Preface, supporting the interpretation that Crowley consciously aligns Langland with Wyclif. The title page of the Prolog says that it was “wrytten about two C. yeres paste.” This is the same phrase Crowley uses when dating Piers Plowman in his Preface to the reader. The Prolog is preceded by a portrait of Wyclif and a rather painful fourteen-line verse biography, presumably by Crowley. The poem begins Kyng Edward the .iii. did Wicklife defe[n]d Werbi he did florish in Oxford lo[n]ge while
30
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
But Richard [the] .ii. King did something bend To papistis bi whom Wicklife was in exile.71
For Crowley, the defining characteristics of kings Edward III and Richard II were their respective defense of and opposition to Wyclif; the early dating of Piers Plowman makes sense in this context, for the poem then fits with the spirit of Edward III’s reign. In Crowley’s Preface to his edition of Piers Plowman, the life of Langland slides seamlessly into the life of Wyclif. Although Bale’s 1549 attribution of the poem to Wyclif does not have any direct influence on later sixteenthcentury discussions of the poem’s authorship, the link between Langland and Wyclif is central to the sixteenth-century understanding of the Piers Plowman. This connection is so self-evident to Crowley that he asserts it with no explicit justification and uses it as the premise for his dating of the poem. Although Crowley’s biography identifies Langland as the “Autore” of Piers Plowman, Wyclif is a kind of shadow “author” as well, insofar as the conjunction of the two writers grants Wyclif’s authority to Langland’s text. In 1550, “author” still maintained a range of now lost meanings having to do with authority and authorizing as well as merely writing. In his attribution of Piers Plowman to Langland, Crowley uses the word “author” in the modern, narrow sense as the person who composed a given work. Simultaneously, Crowley’s paragraph tying the poem to Edward III and Wyclif operates in the realm of these other non-compositional meanings of “author.”72 Thus Wyclif, Edward III (and perhaps also Edward VI by implication) all authorize Langland’s literal authoring of Piers Plowman. Although Langland’s biography in Crowley’s edition turns out to be as much about others as about the poet himself, it is significant that Crowley chooses to Preface his text with the author’s life. Such a choice might seem natural to modern readers, but a discussion of the author’s biography was neither necessary nor common in sixteenth-century books. As a point of comparison, Chaucer’s biography did not enter his published works until Speght’s edition of 1598.73 Caxton’s second edition of the Canterbury Tales explains his acquisition of the manuscript from which he corrected his first edition; Thynne’s and Stow’s editions include a dedication to Henry VIII and some Prefatory Verses.74 When this early prefatory material engages in biography, it is the biography of the editor or dedicatee, not that of the author. The absence of author biography in Chaucer editions is not because it was not there to include. Both Leland and Bale had written extensively about Chaucer by mid-century.75 Who wrote a work was, in the sixteenth century, significant only insofar a known author’s aura devolved onto the text. My use of the term “aura” reapplies (and reverses) the model proposed by Walter Benjamin. As more poems come under the
THE BIRTH OF LANGLAND
31
sign “Chaucerian,” the aura inherent in “being Chaucerian” expands to encompass the larger canon. The proliferation of works increases the value of the Chaucerian aura—rather than erasing it (as the proliferation of reproductions does in Benjamin’s analysis).76 The aura of Chaucer’s name accounts at least in part for the expansion of the Chaucerian canon through the century.77 Despite the importance of Chaucer’s authorial name, the particular events of his life were not part of the authorizing apparatus of early modern editions before the end of the sixteenth century. Chaucer’s works were available to early-sixteenth-century readers in manuscripts, printed editions, poetic imitations, and in miscellanies; John Watkins has argued that all of these formats “[embody] divergent notions of what an author was,” and thus all of the different formats “[carry] a different political valence.”78 Certainly the change in format when Speght includes a Chaucer biography gives his edition a new hermeneutic valence. In the cases of both Chaucer and Langland, the publication of an authorial biography appended to their poetic works manifests a belief that the author’s identity is a key to understanding the poetry. Readers of Piers Plowman who encountered the poem in Crowley’s edition, rather than in one of the manuscripts extant in the sixteenth century, found in it not only the literary characters of Piers and the narrator, Will, but also the historical character of Robert Langland who appears in the edition’s prefatory biography. In 1550, when Piers Plowman was first published, Crowley’s inclusion of even limited detail about Langland was an unusual editorial decision. The fact that Crowley chose to publicize Langland’s life (insofar as he knew it) demonstrates clearly that Langland’s theological commitments and affiliations mattered to Crowley. Crowley did not invent the notion of a Wycliffite Langland, but he certainly popularized it. Most sixteenthcentury readers of the poem in print would encounter Crowley’s biography and would thus read the poem in its light.79 Crowley’s editorial annotations to the text of the poem, particularly those in his second edition, further reinforce the idea that Langland’s anticlericalism was Wycliffite (and thus, for a Reformation reader, proto-Protestant).80 Unlike the first edition, the second edition begins with a passus by passus summary of the poem, and its running heads indicate which passus is printed on each page, unlike those in the first edition which ran: “The vision of ” and “Pierce Ploughman” in rather inexact alternation.81 In addition to this more detailed locational apparatus, Crowley greatly increases the poem’s interpretive apparatus, expanding the first edition’s fifty-six marginal notes to 488 in the second edition.82 Both the marginal notes and the passus summaries direct the reader to places where Langland’s poem is subject to Protestantizing interpretations.
32
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
At the end of Passus 3 of the B text of Piers Plowman, Conscience looks forward to a time when Reason shall reign and Mede shall no longer hold sway. When Mede responds with a scriptural citation in her own defense, Conscience criticizes Mede for quoting her text incompletely, and thereby erroneously (B.3.335–352). Mede says: “Honorem adquiret quia dat munera, &c,” “One who gives gifts shall purchase honor” (Prov 22: 9). Conscience replies that Mede has omitted the ending of the proverb, thus reversing its sense. The second clause of the cited text is: “animam autem aufert acipientium,” “but he carries away the souls of the receivers” (Prov 22: 9). This dialogue between Mede and Conscience hinges not only on the advantages and disadvantages of gift giving but on the need for care in citing biblical texts. Crowley’s summary of Passus 3 identifies the dispute between Mede and Conscience as demonstrating What mischefe [the] wicked mede hath wrought, What perfite state the worlde shall be in, in the tyme of renouation, and howe scripture muste be reade whole.83
Conscience’s lecture about the proper use of scriptural quotation becomes, in Crowley’s summary, a more generalized (and implicitly Protestant) lesson about the necessity of textual access to God’s Word: the assertion that “scripture muste be reade whole.” The importance of this lesson is indicated by its repetition in the marginal note to Conscience’s dialogue with Mede: “That scri/ pture sho=/ ld be read/ whole.”84 Crowley’s most famous textual analysis is his claim that Langland’s poem refers to Henry VIII’s suppression of the abbeys. Crowley evidently thought that the reference to the suppression was one of the poem’s most important elements. He mentions it explicitly at the end of the epistle “to the Reader,” with reference to its page number so that the reader could locate the passage easily: Nowe for that whiche is written in the .l, [punctuation sic] leafe co[n]cernyng the suppression of Abbayes: the Scripture there alledged, declareth it to be gathered of the iuste iudgment of God, who wyll not suffer abomination to raigne vnpunished.85
The passage that Crowley refers to here is Clergy’s threat: And there shall come a king, and co[n]fesse you religious And beate you as the bible telleth, for breki[n]g of your rule.86
Crowley’s second edition (although not the first) marks this passage with a marginal gloss: “The sup-/pressio[n] of/ Abbayes.”87
THE BIRTH OF LANGLAND
33
John Bowers takes issue with the common claim that Crowley identifies Langland as a prophet of the Reformation, noting that Crowley explicitly directs the reader to take the poem’s exhortations personally rather than historically:88 Loke not vpon this boke therfore, to talke of wonders paste or to come but to emend thyne owne misse, whych thou shalt fynd here moste charitably rebuked.89
It is true that Crowley does not use the word “prophecy” to describe Piers Plowman, though he does remark on its fourteenth-century reference to a sixteenth-century event. On one occasion Crowley explicitly denies the poem’s prophetic value. In the discussion of Hunger’s effect on laborers, Langland remarks that “[t]hrough floudes and foule weder, fruite shal fayle.”90 Crowley adds the marginal gloss: “[t]his is/ no prophe/ cy, but a/ pronosti / cation.”91 Crowley’s Preface notes that this prediction of a dearth “is spoke[n] by the knoweledge of astronomie as may wel be gathered bi that he saith, Saturne sent him to tell.”92 As an astrological forecast, then, the prediction is a prognostication, not a prophecy. Crowley uses the word in the sense of the second definition given by the OED: “An astrological or astrometeorological forecast for the year.” “Prognostication” and “prophecy” did have some amount of semantic overlap in the sixteenth century: the fourth definition of “prognostication” is “[s]omething that foretells or foreshadows and event,. . .a sign, token, portent”; the fifth definition (current already in the fifteenth century) is: “foreshadowing; prediction; prophecy.”93 To the extent that this passage of Piers Plowman looks prophetic, Crowley denies that it is authorial: “that whych foloweth and geueth it the face of a prophecy, is lyke to be a thynge added by some other man than the fyrste autour, for diuerse copies haue it diuerslye.”94 In explicitly denying that Langland’s description of famine is a prophecy, Crowley seems to be refuting a preexisting theory that Piers Plowman does contain prophecies. When Bale publishes his Catalogus, he will make such a claim explicitly: “In hoc opere erudito, præter similitudines uarias & iucundas, prophetic[ae] plura prædixit, qu[ae] nostris diebus impleri uidimus.”95 In Bale’s notebook, the notes given as “ex Ioanne Wysdome medico” similarly claim the poem as prophetic, calling it “opus eruditum ac quodammodo propheticum.”96 Bale’s earlier Summarium did not claim “John Wyclif’s” Piers Plowman to be prophetic; in 1550, Crowley may already have known of Bale’s unpublished claim that the poem was prophetic, or he may have known such a claim from another source, such as the one Bale himself cites. Even aside from the possibility that the poem’s reputation for prophecy circulated independently of its printing, Crowley’s denials of the prophecies
34
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
in Piers Plowman are not entirely convincing, given his claim that Langland predicted the suppression of the abbeys. One sixteenth-century reader who chose to ignore Crowley’s instruction to take the poem as personal, rather than historical or prophetic, was the anonymous annotator of British Library shelfmark C.122.d.9. This is the copy of Cr2 used for the UMI microfilm, so its extensive sixteenth-century marginalia are easily accessible.97 The reader responsible for these notes consistently interprets the poem as prophetic. In fact, the same passage in Passus 6 that Crowley deems a prognostication rather than a prophecy is marked by this annotator as “pearcys P[ro]facye.” The annotator’s marginal note here acts as a refutation of Crowley’s attempts to steer interpretation. Already in the poem’s Prologue, the annotator marks as “[the] fyrste p[ro]fycy” the narrator’s claim that Many ferleis haue fallen, in fewe yeres But holy church and they [the friars], hold better togither The most mischiefe on mould, is mou[n]tinge well fast98
The numbering of prophecies in this annotation suggests that this reader imagined the poem as containing a series of prophecies to be gathered. Despite the fact that Crowley does not use the word prophecy in describing the poem’s references to future events, his Preface does carefully itemize lines of the poem that could be seen as predicting the future. The annotator of British Library C.122.d.9 has written a lengthy manuscript note on the half page below the end of Crowley’s preface; this note lists a series of important prophecies in the poem: xxxvj lefe or vi sones & a shype & halfe a sheffe of ar an other p[ro]fycye of desoluyng of abayes, in [the] xlx lefe wher he spekythe of [the] mydyll of a mowne in [the] lxvij lefe wher he spekythe of a nother p[ro]fycye to begyn in a dry aparyll in lxviij lefe.99
Since the second and fourth items on the list are both called “another prophecy,” presumably the first and third items are prophecies as well. The first item on the manuscript list, the prophecy of the six suns, derives (though somewhat indirectly) from Crowley’s Preface, where Crowley notes that different manuscripts cite Saturn’s prophecy of a dearth differently, and that it is therefore likely to show scribal interference: [it] is lyke to be a thynge added by some other man than the fyrste autour, For diuerse copies haue it diuerslye. For where the copie that I folowe hath thus. And when you se the sunne amisse, & thre monkes heads And a mayde haue the maistrye, and multiply by eight,
THE BIRTH OF LANGLAND
35
Some other haue Three shyppes and a shefe, wyth an eight folowynge Shall brynge bale and battell, on both halfe the mone.100
Differentiating the manuscript readings is a careful piece of textual scholarship by Crowley, but he is wrong in his conclusion that it is due to scribal rewriting. The first version of this passage that Crowley offers is the B version (hence his reference to “the copie that I folowe”): B.6.326–327. The second version is an accurate representation of the equivalent lines in the C text, where the prophecy is articulated somewhat differently: C.8.350–351. Because Crowley was not aware of the consistent differences between the B and C texts of the poem, he imagines this particular difference as scribal. The sixteenth-century annotator seems to have been confused by Crowley’s reference to the unfamiliar C text version of these lines. The annotation begins by referring to the “xxxvi lefe,” but does not give the reading Crowley prints on that leaf. Instead, the annotation gives a different reading, marking it as a variant (“or. . .”). The line the annotator gives in the manuscript note is the very similar prophecy from earlier in the poem (in both B and C texts): “By sixe sones and a ship and half a shef of arwes.”101 Not recognizing the C variant given by Crowley, the annotator has substituted the known “ship and sheaf ” line from earlier in the poem. The third passage mentioned in this manuscript note is from Patience’s riddling discussion of Dowell: I bare therin aboute, faste bounde Dowell In a sygne of the saturday, that set first the kalender And al the wyt of the wenisday, of [the] next weke after The middle of the mone, is the myght of bothe And ther with I am welcome, there I haue it w[ith] me.102
The annotator has also highlighted this section of Patience’s speech in Passus 13 and marked it with the marginal comment “a goudly not” (a goodly note), although without calling it a prophecy.103 The final “prophecy” identified by the annotator is Haukyn’s reference to the dearth of 1370 (or, as Crowley’s text erroneously reads, 1350): In date of oure drighte, in a drye Apriell, A thousand and threhundred, twyse twenty & ten.104
Crowley’s printed gloss to these lines reads: “A deare/ yere.” The annotator has underlined these words and added above them: “a p[ro]fycye of,” but this is certainly not a prophecy.105 Haukyn reports the dearth as something
36
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
that is past, as Crowley explicitly mentions when he gives 1350 as the terminus a quo for the poem’s composition.106 The annotator’s conviction that the poem is prophetic extends even to this passage that clearly reports the past rather than offering a prediction about the future. The annotator of this British Library copy of Crowley’s Piers Plowman edition is not the only early modern reader who interpreted Langland’s poem as a collection of prophecies. One sixteenth-century reader of Cambridge University Library MS Gg.iv.31 (sigil G of the B text) has written “the prophecies of Piers Plowman” on the first leaf of the manuscript, and another sixteenth-century reader has written the same after the text of the poem.107 When this early sixteenth-century manuscript was bound in the seventeenth century, “The Prophecies of Piers Plowman” was taken to be the work’s title and was written on the spine of the manuscript’s new binding. The later readers who were responsible for the annotations and binding may have been influenced by the manuscript’s scribe, who also saw prophecies in Langland’s poem.108 This copy of the poem is followed by a four page long scribal table of contents, which identifies a number of the poem’s episodes as prophecies, and cross references them to specific folio numbers and marginal annotations as finding aids. For example, the table of contents says that “ye thyrd chapter declarethe ye profycye off ye catt ye ratt & ye mysse/ att thys marke,” with the phrase “a profesy” in the left margin and the appropriate folio number in the right margin.109 Within the body of the poem, the parable of the belling of the cat is marked by the marginal annotation: “ye profycy off ye catt.”110 In all, the table of contents of this manuscript identifies five different prophecies within Piers Plowman, and the scribal annotations to the text of the poem mark all five of these alleged prophecies. The poem’s five prophecies, as identified by the scribe, are: the belling of the cat (B.Pro.147), Conscience’s riddling reference to six suns and a ship (B.3.326), the narrator’s warning of a future famine (B.6.324), Clergy’s warning of a king who shall come to chastise the religious orders (B.10.309), and the king’s claim to be ruler and judge over all the commons (B.19.471).111 Moreover, an early note by someone whose annotations are signed “W. H” marks a sixth prophecy in both the table of contents and in the margins of the poem itself; W. H. identifies as a “prophecie of Byschoppes” Anima’s warning that the bishops should pursue truth rather than wealth or they will forfeit their rule (B.15.541).112 Francis Ayscough, an early seventeenth-century owner and annotator of British Library Additional MS 35157 (sigil U of the C text), also interprets Piers Plowman as a prophetic text, and he notes that only some of the poem’s prophecies have been fulfilled. In the C text Prologue, the narrator refers to a time when “holi chirche and charite choppe adoun suche shryuars” (C.Pro.64). Ayscough writes in the margin next to this line: “famous Kinge
THE BIRTH OF LANGLAND
37
Henry Viij fulfillid in his time.”113 In a different note, marked as written in 1603, Francis Ayscough differentiates between Langlandian prophecies that have been fulfilled and those that remain forward-looking. In Passus 4 of the C text, Conscience sends forth Reason, who proceeds to exhort the religious orders as well as secular rulers to emend their way of life (C.4.109–144). At C.4.36a, alongside Conscience’s speech to Reason before Reason’s departure, Ayscough writes: “Thus farr of prophises yet to come all the reste following are past sauing the fall of ye lawe and Bishopps nowe at hand.”114 Ayscough saw in Piers Plowman a prophecy not only of events gone by in the break between the Churches of England and Rome, but of those he hoped to see soon, including the elimination of the episcopacy. Sir Edward Ayscough, the father of Francis Ayscough, had previously annotated the manuscript in the late sixteenth century, although to a lesser extent than did his son. Sir Edward Ayscough also understood Piers Plowman to contain prophecies of the Henrician dissolution of England’s abbeys. Opposite Reason’s warning of a king who will discipline the religious who are breaking their rule, Sir Edward writes: “[a] prophecye. Trulye fulfilled by Kinge henrye.the.viij.th.”115 The line marked by Sir Edward Ayscough as prophetic is part of Reason’s sermon in Passus 5 of the C text. This sermon corresponds to Clergy’s speech in Passus 10 of the B text. The line in the C text is thus the equivalent of the passage marked by Crowley as predicting the suppression of the abbeys (as mentioned above). A third sixteenth-century reader who saw in this line a prophecy of the Henrician Reformation was the anonymous sixteenth-century annotator of Cambridge University Library MS Ll.iv.14 (B text sigil C2). this annotator has made very detailed marginal notes throughout the text of the poem, and alongside this line in B.10 has written: “A prophecy agaynste ye Religious.”116 Tudor readers understood a number of passages of Piers Plowman as predicting the Henrician Reformation, but this line in particular was seen as speaking to their era. As a medieval prophecy of later reforms, in this early modern reading, Piers Plowman had political utility. For at least one later reader, the medieval poem’s prophecies were not dependent on the whole text of the work for their authority; they were useful even separated from their poetic context. Sharon Jansen has recorded the presence of two Piers Plowman fragments among the texts in British Library MS. Sloane 2578, a collection that includes political prophecies among other sorts of polemic.117 The two passages are the description of Hunger’s effects (B.6.321–331) and Clergy’s prophecy of the king who will amend the abuses of the religious orders (B.10.322–325). In the Sloane manuscript, the two passages from different parts of the poem are joined together into one prophecy of both the natural
38
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
world and the social world working together to correct abuses. As Jansen points out, both of these passages could easily be taken to refer to current events, given her dating of the prophecy to 1555.118 The two passages compiled to form this prophecy are among those discussed explicitly by Crowley’s Preface to the poem, and the Sloane manuscript compiler may have been influenced by Crowley. Jansen hypothesizes that the passages were copied from British Library Additional MS 35278 (B text sigil M), although she notes that the text is also similar to Crowley’s printed text.119 If the compiler of the Sloane manuscript, like the annotator of the British Library copy of Crowley’s second edition, was alerted to these prophetic passages in Piers Plowman by their discussion in Crowley’s Preface, then Crowley inspired at least two sixteenth-century readers to look for prophecies in Piers Plowman, despite his surface cautions against reading the poem as prophetic. In addition to publicizing Langland’s name in his Preface, Crowley promulgates a particular role for him as a Wycliffite prophet of the Reformation. Langland was an advocate for reform, and he was identified in the early modern period as a prophet of the Reformation. Evidence from both manuscripts and printed editions demonstrates that Piers Plowman had a consistent readership through the sixteenth century, so the fact that this poem was supportive of such Catholic practices as pilgrimage must not have alienated its later readers. Because the poem’s attacks on clerical corruption and laxity reiterated the discourse of Protestant anti-Catholicism, later readers presumably did not notice the fundamental orthodoxy of Langland’s pre-Reformation poem. Instead, most sixteenth-century readers saw Langland (and his poem) in their own image. Despite this tendency to “Protestantize” Langland, there were a few sixteenth-century readers who did recognize the gap between Langland’s theology and Protestantism. Even Francis Ayscough, who believed Langland to be a prophet of the Reformation, identifies as “a litle taste of poprie” Imaginatif’s discussion of the salvation of the crucified thief, who may not sit so high in heaven as those who performed good works in life.120 Ayscough recognizes Imaginatif’s theology as tending toward a doctrine of salvation by works, and his annotation on this passage serves to moderate his, and his father’s, claims for Langland as their theological forerunner. Ayscough’s marginalia identify Langland as fundamentally an ally but one who is also still tainted with the “poprie” of his time. Crowley’s edition of Piers Plowman manifested no such scruples about conscripting Langland for the Protestant cause. Crowley’s Protestant theology was very much of his time. Under the reign of Edward, England’s Protestants extended the break from the Church of Rome begun under Henry, establishing the English Church. For Crowley, Langland’s anticlericalism looked like a forerunner
THE BIRTH OF LANGLAND
39
of English Protestantism; a generation earlier, however, the reformism of Piers Plowman was seen favorably by a more conservative theological thinker, Sir Adrian Fortescue, who produced his own manuscript of a combined A and C text of Piers Plowman, Bodleian Library MS Digby 145 (A text sigil K and C text sigil D2). Thorlac Turville-Petre has argued that, at the time of his copying of Piers Plowman (1532), Fortescue was loyal to Henry and suspicious of the Church of Rome, if not a Protestant in the later sixteenth-century sense.121 Fortescue’s anticlericalism and support for Henry only extended so far, however, and he was imprisoned and executed in 1539.122 Fortescue, a more moderate supporter of ecclesiastical reform than Crowley, most likely would have disagreed with the late-sixteenth-century understanding of Piers Plowman as Protestant, and Fortescue was not the most theologically conservative member of the poem’s sixteenth-century readership. As a number of critics have noted, a seventeenth-century Catholic named Andrew Bostock argued back against Crowley’s interpretations in the margins of his own copy of Piers Plowman. Bostock corrects Crowley’s claims that Langland opposed the papacy and endorsed the suppression of the abbeys.123 Bostock understands Langland (correctly, according to the most recent Piers Plowman criticism) as fundamentally orthodox in his views. Although Bostock argues to a conclusion different from Crowley’s, he uses the same strategy of finding theological support for a present position in a poem from the past. However, even if Bostock had publicized his interpretation of Piers Plowman in 1613, it would have been too little too late. Langland had already been cast as a fourteenth-century forerunner of the sixteenth-century Protestantism Bostock himself rejected. After nearly two centuries of anonymity, Langland comes to have a name and a public identity in the sixteenth century with the publication of Bale’s and Crowley’s works. Although this is the identity that has proved most influential in Langland reception, an alternate naming tradition arises shortly thereafter, when the antiquary and historian John Stow includes in his Chronicles of England (1580) the fact that in 1342 “Iohn Maluerne, fellowe of Oriall Colledge in Oxford, made and finished his booke entituled The Visions of Pierce Plowman.”124 Stow’s attribution is erroneous, but he actually solves the question of authorship by (what is now considered to be) the correct method: decoding a covert self-identification within the text of the poem. Presumably, Stow knew of a medieval author named John Malvern and thus interpreted the poem’s opening in the Malvern hills as naming the author as well as the location. There were at least three different late-fourteenth-century John Malverns who could be suspected to have authored the poem, two of whom were known to have written other
40
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
works. Stow’s attribution exists alongside the attribution to Robert Langland for over a century, although different commentators identify the poem with different John Malverns.125 The other situation in which Robert Langland’s name and biography do not travel with the poem are the cases in which the poem is explicitly discussed as having unknown authorship. In The Arte of English Poesie (1589), George Puttenham lists the author of Piers Plowman among the noteworthy poets from the time of Edward III, but he does not know his name, calling him: “that nameles, who wrote the Satyre called Piers Plowman.”126 Anne Middleton has argued that Puttenham’s definition of Piers Plowman as a satire, an English counterpart to the works of Juvenal, “contrasts sharply with the Protestant ‘prophetic’ views of it.”127 However, Puttenham does invoke the idea that the poem prophesies the Reformation, noting that the poet: seemed to haue bene a malcontent of that time, and therefore bent himselfe wholy to taxe the disorders of that age, and specially the pride of the Romane clergy, of whose fall he seemeth to be a very true Prophet.128
It is not clear if Puttenham knew Piers Plowman directly from a manuscript or only by reputation. Since he does not know Langland’s name, Puttenham apparently did not use Crowley’s edition, but he, like the commentators discussed above, shares Crowley’s interest in the way the poet’s theology manifests itself in (alleged) proto-Protestant prophecies. The sixteenth-century interest in Piers Plowman as an early theological work sympathetic to Reformation goals shows up as well at the end of the sixteenth century in the bookseller Andrew Maunsell’s Catalogue of English printed Books, the first part of which contains those works “Which concerneth such matters of Diuinitie, as haue bin either written in our owne Tongue, or translated out of anie other language. . .”129 Maunsell designed the catalogue in three parts: works concerning divinity; works of science and related fields; and works of “Humanity,” by which he meant rhetoric, law, literature, and history. The first two parts were printed together in 1595; the third part was never produced, although Maunsell does describe his proposed third part: it resteth that I should procede to the thirde and last part, which is of Humanity, wherein I shall haue occasion to shew, what we haue in our owne tongue, of Gramer, Logick, Rethoricke, Lawe, Historie, Poetrie, Policie, &c. VVhich will for the most part concerne matters of Delight and Pleasure.130
Maunsell addresses the first part of the Catalogue to stationers and booksellers, that they may know what books are available, and also to “The
THE BIRTH OF LANGLAND
41
Reverend Diuines, and Louers of Diuine Bookes, true knowledge of God, and a good Conscience” who would be interested in purchasing such works.131 Among the works of divinity that Maunsell cites is: “Pierce plowmans vision, reprehending the abuses of the Clergie, and all estates, prin. after the authours olde Copie, by Owen Rogers. 1561. in 4.132 Given that Maunsell projected a third part that would have included books of “Poetrie,” it is significant that Maunsell includes Piers Plowman in his first part; for Maunsell, the poem’s theological content is more important than its poetic form. The one feature of Piers Plowman that Maunsell discusses explicitly is its anticlericalism. Maunsell claims to have included in his Catalogue no works “but such as I haue seene,” but he may not have actually read through Rogers’s volume, since he does not mention its inclusion of Pierce the Ploughman’s Crede, a poem that clearly fits his subject matter.133 Because Maunsell’s source is the 1561 edition, which omits Crowley’s Preface, he does not name the poem’s author. He presumably was not familiar with any of Crowley’s 1550 editions. Despite the errors, variations, exaggerations, and gaps in the different sixteenth-century biographies of the poet now known as William Langland, those early attempts to write the life of the author behind Piers Plowman mark an important stage in the poem’s reception. In some sense, the sixteenth-century reformers’ attempts to make Piers Plowman support their own cause is continuous with the 1381 rebels’ appropriation of the poem’s discourse. Unlike the fourteenth-century rebels, however, Bale, Crowley, and their followers look explicitly to the poem’s author, rather than its language, in their appropriations of the poem. Anne Middleton identifies the fourteenth century as the high point of interest in the poem’s argumentative voice, although fourteenth-century readers take the poem’s voice to be that of “Piers himself”; the rebels who alluded to Piers Plowman named Piers, not Langland, as their ally. Middleton notes further that in the 200 years after its composition, “Langland himself, in a near-vacuum of external biographical documentation, virtually vanished from public notice as a known English author.”134 The idea of Langland as the author (and authorizer) of the poem only begins in the sixteenth century, when the authorial biography begins to be appended to the literary text. For John Ball, Piers Plowman authorized the 1381 rebels; for John Bale, “Robert Langland” authorized the Reformation. Once Langland’s name was associated with the poem in the sixteenth century, it remained the dominant attribution (with occasional challenges by John Malvern) until the multiple authorship controversy in the twentieth century.135 At the end of the eighteenth century, Joseph Ritson (who first hypothesized that the substantive differences between manuscript
42
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
versions of the poem were the evidence of multiple “editions”) noted in his criticism of Thomas Warton’s History of English Poetry that “There is, I can assure you, more reason against LONGLANDS title to the authorship of Piers Plowman than you are aware of.”136 Presumably, Ritson means the claim that the author was John Malvern, but he does not reveal what particular evidence he has in mind. Given the overall tenor of Ritson’s response to Warton’s work, it is quite possible that he is simply looking for one more error to ascribe to Warton. Twenty years later, in his own Bibliographia Poetica, Ritson mentions but does not lend credence to the John Malvern hypothesis, attributing the poem to Robert Langland. Ritson also notes Tyrwhitt’s argument that the poet’s first name was William, since that is the name of the poem’s speaker and because of the manuscript designation of the poem as “Visio Willelmi de Petro Ploughman.”137 Sixteenth-century readers’ interest in the authorship of Piers Plowman should be differentiated from later models of literary analysis that take the author as their starting point. For Bale and Crowley, Langland’s poetic skill (his “genius,” as Romantic criticism might phrase it) is not what defines his importance or that of his poem. Sixteenth-century author biographies are shaped to bring to the fore the names and identities of those whom the poet knew, not simply what the poet did. In Langland’s case, that takes the form of Bale and Crowley’s conflations of Langland and Wyclif. Chaucer too was affiliated with the Wycliffite project in sixteenth-century biographies, as I discuss further in chapter 5. Moreover, in sixteenth-century biographies, Chaucer, unlike Langland, was identified particularly with the court, especially with John of Gaunt. Although their affiliations diverge, both authors are themselves authorized through the names of others. The author-centered criticism that begins to associate biography with literature did not displace other ways of reading. Piers Plowman did come to be attributed to a named author for one subset of its sixteenth-century readership. Simultaneously, others saw the dominant voice of Piers Plowman as that of the Plowman, the authorized figure within the poem, rather than that of the author who produced it. Although different readers locate the poem’s authority differently, it is clear that Piers Plowman was as important in sixteenth-century England as it had been in its own time. For the Protestant readers of the sixteenth century, the significance of Piers Plowman was not as a major work of medieval literature but as the manifestation of a particular religious ideology. Although the professionalization of literary study might mean that the poem is today more widely read than it was 400 years ago, never since the sixteenth century has Piers Plowman held such cultural urgency.
CHAPTER 2 A PROLIFERATION OF PLOWMEN
lthough Chaucer is considered the fourteenth-century writer who had the most influence on the English poets of the fifteenth century, Langland too shaped the later Middle English poetic tradition through his influence on other writers. Ethan Knapp identifies in Hoccleve’s poetry a number of “elements in which he might be more profitably compared to Langland than Chaucer,” including Hoccleve’s discussions of his marriage, his writing in a voice shaped by a clerical rather than courtly milieu, and his focus on motion.1 Chaucer too may have been influenced by elements of Piers Plowman. Frank Grady has argued that Chaucer’s House of Fame borrows some of its poetic imagery from Piers Plowman, and Jill Mann claims that: “[t]he probability that Chaucer had read both Gower and Langland seems, on the face of it strong.”2 Another argument that Chaucer both read and responded to Piers Plowman is Paul Hardwick’s claim that Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales Plowman responds to both Langland’s Piers Plowman and the 1381 rebels’ use of that name; Hardwick contends that Chaucer remakes Langland’s plowman from religious metaphor to a figure for poetic making.3 If Chaucer’s Plowman alludes in some way to Langland’s Plowman, as well as to his appropriation by the 1381 rebels, it does so by defusing what was already in the late fourteenth century a potentially explosive image. In 1381, the rebels who burned the Savoy and beheaded Archbishop Sudbury presented Piers Plowman, and by extension Piers Plowman, as speaking for their cause, associating Langland’s poem with direct civil disobedience (as opposed to theological polemic). This association with political unrest is often cited as the motivation for Langland’s C text revisions of the poem. Even after these revisions, a reputation as a troublemaker may have remained attached to Langland’s protagonist. In Huntington Library MS 143, a late-fourteenth-century C text (sigil X), the name “Peres Plouhman” has been consistently erased. John Bowers argues that the
A
44
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
erasures were an owner’s attempt to solve the problem of owning a poem named after such a politically controversial character.4 Interestingly, the Huntington manuscript preserves the poem in its entirety, aside from these few erasures. It is not clear when these erasures were made, and it is hard to imagine who the intended audience for this act of limited censorship could be: someone who might inspect a manuscript of Piers Plowman but then withhold a feared sanction because the title character’s name (but nothing else) was omitted. Still, the erasures seem to be one owner’s way of distancing Langland’s complete work from the name of his title character, of dissociating Piers Plowman from Piers the Plowman. The title character of Langland’s poem first migrated out of Piers Plowman in the fifteenth century Pierce the Ploughman’s Crede, an antifraternal polemic that is Lollard in its theology and Langlandian in its verse style and characterization. For the next century, the plowman continued to have a literary presence, appearing in works of religious and social protest through the end of the sixteenth century.5 Thus, just as Langland came to have a distinct identity in the sixteenth century, through the biographies discussed in chapter 1, so too did his title character, Piers himself. Langland’s poem did not initiate the use of the plowman as a figure for the simple rustic. The Song of the Husbandman, which bemoans the economic hardships of the poor laborer, predates Piers Plowman by probably fifty years.6 It was, however, Langland’s poem that inspired Pierce the Ploughman’s Crede and a number of later works. Pierce the Ploughman’s Crede survives in one fifteenth-century fragment, two sixteenth-century copies of the complete text, and one sixteenth-century printed edition (discussed below); these four witnesses are all independent of one another.7 Both Langland’s Piers Plowman and the anonymous Pierce the Ploughman’s Crede were in circulation in the sixteenth century, and together they contributed to the plowman’s growing reputation as a voice of social dissent. Aside from Pierce the Ploughman’s Crede, the fifteenth-century alliterative poems of complaint that make up the Piers Plowman Tradition imitate Langland’s style, but without using the virtuous plowman figure as a speaker of their claims.8 These works share with Langland’s poem a concern for good governance as seen from the perspective of the commons, not the nobles. They also, like Piers Plowman, present their complaints indirectly and allegorically. These works follow Langland’s poem stylistically as well, which leads to an association between the form (the alliterative long line) and the content (political and theological satire) of Piers Plowman. As James M. Dean observes about the Richard the Redeless poet’s choice of alliterative verse: “[t]his style is appropriate for the content because so many other political-satiric writings, from Song of the Husbandman to The Crowned King, were composed in it.”9 Alliterative verse could of course be turned to
A PROLIFERATION OF PLOWMEN
45
many ends; the poet who wrote Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, Pearl, Patience, and Cleanness wrote in three distinct genres (courtly romance, religious allegory, and biblical narrative). As alliterative verse became increasingly rare toward the end of the fourteenth century, the association of alliteration with complaint (and with Piers Plowman specifically) became solidified. Richard the Redeless manifests a formal affiliation with Piers Plowman not only at the level of the line (its alliterative verse), but also at the level of the section divisions. Quite unusually for Middle English poetry, Richard the Redeless shares with Piers Plowman the division of the narrative into units called passus, “steps.” Unlike Piers Plowman, Richard the Redeless does not tell of a journey. In Piers Plowman, the narrator, Will, is on a quest both literal and figurative in order to find what it is to Do Well; the division of the poem into passus is therefore very appropriate. In the case of Richard the Redeless, which contains no such journey, the passus divisions seem a clear allusion to Piers Plowman. The only extant text of Richard the Redeless is in Cambridge University Library MS Ll.iv.14, where it follows immediately after a copy of Piers Plowman (B text sigil C2). The passus divisions of Richard the Redeless may be scribal rather than authorial; nevertheless, even a scribal allusion to Piers Plowman demonstrates that one early reader saw a formal kinship between the two poems. The early fifteenth-century authors of the poems in the Piers Plowman Tradition used Piers Plowman as a stylistic model and as a thematic model, but they did not necessarily invoke Langland’s characters. In the sixteenth century, Piers Plowman, not Piers Plowman, provided an authorizing model for the literature of complaint. Elizabeth Kirk has demonstrated that Langland diverged from existing religious imagery to cast the poor plowman as the poem’s center of religious authority.10 Once this image was established, it did begin to circulate outside of Langland’s poem, but in the fifteenth century, using the character of the plowman was just one way for a writer to borrow from Piers Plowman. By the sixteenth century, naming Piers Plowman was the most frequent way that writers registered their (direct or indirect) debts to Langland. For authors in the sixteenth century, naming Piers Plowman was often a symbolic act, one that identified a work as belonging to a particular genre of protest literature. In the sixteenth-century reception of Langland’s poem, the name of Piers Plowman often overshadowed that of his author, even after Crowley published his biography of the man he called Robert Langland. This conflation of author and character was nothing new; the 1381 rebels did the same thing when they invoked Piers as their ally, using borrowed Langlandian terminology to do so. Because so many sixteenth-century works took up the plowman character from Langland’s poem and from Pierce the
46
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
Ploughman’s Crede, the figure of the plowman maintained its utility for later writers of satire or complaint. To be sure, a number of sixteenth-century literary texts feature plowmen in ways that do not particularly invoke Langland’s poem. In Book I of Spenser’s Faerie Queene, for example, readers learn that the Redcrosse Knight’s adoptive father is a plowman. For Spenser, the brief reference to a plowman serves primarily to introduce a pun on the name of the hero, the eventual St. George. Near the end of Canto X of Book I of the Faerie Queene, Contemplation tells Redcrosse that he was a changeling, placed by a faery in a furrow, “Where thee a Ploughman all vnweeting fond,/. . ./And brought thee vp in ploughmans state to byde,/ Whereof Georgos he thee gaue to name.”11 The infant is named Georgos to play on the Greek word for earth-worker or husbandman. The plowman character is merely instrumental here, a means for Spenser to introduce this etymology of St. George’s name, and to emphasize the saint’s true Englishness: he is literally a product of the English soil. More commonly, uses of a plowman in sixteenth-century texts serve to contrast the simple, rural laborer with figures of nominal, though flawed, authority. In the 1548 anti-Eucharistic tract John Bon and Mast Person, the plowman John asks the parson to explain to him the feast of Corpus Christi: “What Saint is Copsi Cursty, a man, or a woman?”12 When the parson accuses John of Protestantism (“Now I may perceive ye love this new gear”) for his ignorance of Corpus Christi, John invokes his profession directly in his defense: “Ye must hold us excused, for ploughmen be but blind.”13 In the course of his explanation of the Catholic doctrine of transubstantiation, the parson proves to be no match for the “ignorant” questions of the plowman John. The piety of the simple laborer leads him to reject the parson’s Catholic doctrine, for (as John says in closing): “I know cheese from chalk.”14 John’s homespun metaphor implicitly grants to any layperson, educated or not, the ability to recognize the obvious distinction between the “cheese” of Protestant piety and the “chalk” of Catholic practice. It therefore demonstrates why the rural laborer figure held such an appeal for Reformation polemics. The plowman is the figural antithesis of the priest. In the medieval conception of the three social orders, the bellatores (those who fight) and the oratores (those who pray) come from what today would be called the same social class, often even from the same families, while the laborares (those who work) were socially distinct from, and lower than, the other two groups. Agricultural laborers also differed from the bellatores and oratores in their lack of formal education; in this they were also unlike their fellow laborares, urban craftspeople, who needed a higher level of literacy. It is hardly surprising, then, that Protestant statements against the Catholic clergy are often presented in the voice of a plowman. More particularly,
A PROLIFERATION OF PLOWMEN
47
the most famous plowman of English letters, Piers himself, appears repeatedly by name throughout the century, not only in editions of Langland’s poem, but in a number of other satirical works. It is not clear what the relationship is between the printing of Langland’s Piers Plowman and the printing of other sixteenth-century texts that invoke Piers Plowman’s name in the service of political and theological complaint. Some of the sixteenth-century texts featuring plowmen are quite distant from Langland’s poem in terms of style, content, and genre, but a few of them do suggest at least limited familiarity with Piers Plowman. The ShortTitle Catalogue dates a number of these works to “1550?” no doubt on the assumption that they must have been published after Robert Crowley’s 1550 publication of Piers Plowman, the first printing of Langland’s poem. The problem of the undated Plowman texts, and of their unclear relationship to Crowley’s editions of Piers Plowman, contains within it a question about the direction of influence. It may seem tempting to assume that the publication of a major literary work prompted the appearance of related minor works; however, it is equally possible that the market for the major work was created by the prior appearance of those supposedly minor works. In fact, internal evidence in some of the sixteenth-century “Plowmen texts,” as I will call them, suggests that they predate the publication of Piers Plowman. If the availability of other satirical poems in the voice of the plowman influenced Crowley’s decision to publish Langland’s poem, then the sixteenth-century “Plowman texts” had a major influence on literary history despite their status as “minor works.” Langland’s poem is both the originator and the beneficiary in a cycle of literary influence: Langland’s fourteenth-century poem prompts fourteenthand fifteenth-century imitations; these imitations create for the sixteenth century a literary trope (the satirical plowman); the popularity of that trope inspires the publication of Langland’s poem and its circulation to a new audience. Foucault remarks that an author’s name is “functional in that it serves as a means of classification. A name can group together a number of texts and thus differentiate them from others.”15 In the sixteenth century, the plowman’s name, not that of the author, was the organizational principle that served to group texts into a common textual identity. A traditional, unidirectional, notion of literary influence (tracing a vector from the major work to an attendant minor work) cannot fully account for the complex circulation of the plowman figure through a range of sixteenth-century literary texts. In his transformation from a sporadically appearing character within Langland’s fourteenth-century poem to a customary voice of satirical polemic in the sixteenth century, Piers becomes neither a stock character nor an allegory. Different invocations of the Piers Plowman name function differently within the works that contain them, but a handful of
48
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
interrelated characteristics appear regularly: Piers’s (perceived) Lollardy or proto-Protestantism, his antiquity, his labor, and his economic and geographical marginality. Taken together, these characteristics make Piers a culturally paradoxical figure. As a character from a literary tradition long-standing by the sixteenth century, Piers represents England’s past, and his antiquity implicitly authorizes his perspective. Piers’s agricultural labor also marks him as being “of England,” a true native of the land. As a poor worker, though, Piers is outside of the centers of power, and in the works in which he appears he consistently speaks against the authoritative structures of church and court. Piers is both an insider and an outsider. Indeed, his very status as a political and economic outsider grants him the moral authority of an honest, native Englishman, untainted by the innovations and abuses of those in power. Given this dual identity, Piers was well suited for continued remobilization by adherents of different, even conflicting, sixteenth-century ideologies. One of the rhetorical commonplaces of sixteenth-century Protestant religious writing is the claim to be returning to the practices of the ancient, apostolic church. This claim authorizes theologies ranging from relatively conservative (for example, those defending Henry’s break with Rome without calling for further reforms) to radical, and it was answered by countercharges against every alleged “innovation.” Catholics were not the only ones to accuse Protestants of heretical innovation; different Protestant sects also leveled this claim at one another.16 Charges of novelty were best answered by scriptural evidence of apostolic practice, but Protestant authors also appealed to the native English religious tradition to authorize their rejection of Catholic doctrine, identifying the fourteenth- and fifteenth-century Wycliffites as their theological forerunners. As sixteenth-century reformers looked back to their late medieval predecessors, the early Wycliffite use of Piers Plowman was taken up again by sixteenth-century editors who then “re-recycled” this authorizing literary figure. The appropriation of Piers Plowman by the author of Pierce the Ploughman’s Crede made Piers Plowman both available and appealing to sixteenth-century reformist writers who might not have known Langland’s poem independently. The anticlerical discourse within Piers Plowman, the Wycliffite use of the Piers Plowman name outside the poem, and perhaps the poem’s use by the 1381 rebels as well, combined to give Piers Plowman and its title character a reputation for proto-Protestantism in the sixteenth century.17 For the 1381 rebels, Piers Plowman was a living contemporary. The letter of Jack Carter referred to him by name as “my broQer.” Sixteenthcentury authors did not typically follow a similar practice of absorbing the figure of Piers Plowman into their own historical context; the early
A PROLIFERATION OF PLOWMEN
49
modern uses of Piers Plowman tend to emphasize the antiquity of their source texts, and consequently of the Plowman himself. One way that the age of these texts was visible was in their archaic language, which was consequently a frequent topic of discussion for the texts’ sixteenth-century editors. The editors called attention to the archaic language because it stood as an inherent testimony to the antiquity (and thus authority) of Protestant doctrine. One example can be found in Reginald Wolfe’s 1553 edition of Pierce the Ploughman’s Crede. At the end of his book, Wolfe prints a glossary, headed: For to occupie this leaff which els shuld haue ben vacant I haue made an interpretation of certayne hard wordes vsed in this booke for the better vnderstandyng of it.18
For a reader unfamiliar with the poem’s “hard wordes,” this glossary might not have been much help. It is relatively short, including only forty-eight words for a poem over 800 lines long, and it is not keyed to line or page numbers, although the words do appear in the order in which they occur in the poem. Furthermore, it is on the verso of the last page, so readers would have to turn the pages all the way over to consult the glossary, a physically impractical configuration. The glossary is not announced on the title page, so readers would not necessarily know that they could consult it while reading the Crede. On top of all this, the glossary is not always accurate. The glossary’s errors begin immediately. The first word in the glossary is “frayning,” glossed by Wolfe as “forsakyng.” In fact, the Middle English “frayning” means “inquiring.” This entry in the glossary corresponds to line 27 of the poem, in which the narrator laments his inability to learn his creed, although he has asked many men. In Wolfe’s edition, the line reads: “But by a fraynyng for than, faileth ther manye.” [But in terms of this questioning, many failed in it.] It is hard to see how “frayning” could logically mean “forsaking” in this sentence, unless Wolfe understood the line to mean something like: “many failed [me] therefore forsakyng [me].” In the next line, the narrator uses the verb in a way that should clarify its meaning: “For first I frayned the freres, and they me fulle tolden.”19 Given the logical connection between “frayned” and “tolden,” its usage—that is in reference to questions asking for specific information—seems relatively clear. It is likely, not to mention fortunate, that many readers of the Crede would be able to derive the word’s meaning from its context without searching for it in Wolfe’s flawed glossary. Whatever his virtues as an editor, printer, and propagandist, Wolfe unfortunately had a few deficiencies as a linguist.
50
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
The second entry in the glossary is even more problematic than the first; here “Wunede” is glossed as “wont.” Given its placement between “Frayning” (line 27) and “Graith” (line 34), “Wunede” must refer to the word printed as “wennede” in the line: “Then wennede I to wytten and with a whight I mette.”20 The word in question is the Middle English “wende,” went. That the word was unfamiliar to the compositor, if not the editor, is suggested already by the trisyllabic spelling “wennede” in the text of the poem.21 The glossary both misspells the word (relative to its appearance in the text) and defines it incorrectly. A reader dependent on this glossary to understand Pierce the Ploughman’s Crede would be off to a shaky start indeed. Most of Wolfe’s glosses are accurate, despite these early slips. Still, the glossary seems to have a symbolic value, even if it does not have much linguistic value. Fifteenth-century language obviously posed interpretive difficulties for at least some sixteenth-century readers. In fact, Wolfe was not the only sixteenth-century reader of a Plowman text to attempt a glossary. One owner of a Piers Plowman manuscript also attempted to define some of the poem’s medieval words that were no longer a part of the early modern lexicon. Cambridge University Library MS Ll.iv.14 (B text sigil C2) preserves a ninety-five item glossary of words from Piers Plowman; this glossary is written in a sixteenth-century hand, probably the same hand as the annotator of the poem.22 This glossary was first printed by Walter W. Skeat, who believed that the glossator was Robert Crowley.23 J. R. Thorne and Marie-Claire Uhart argue that, while Skeat’s hypothesis lacks sufficient evidence, it can safely be said that “the glossarist/annotator was of the same frame of mind as Crowley,” since the poem’s sixteenth-century annotations in this manuscript correspond in general interest area with Crowley’s marginalia in his edition of the poem.24 This manuscript glossary seems to have been for personal use, not for helping a later and less knowledgeable reader. The medieval words and their definitions appear in two columns, but without any indication of where in the poem they appear; they are not keyed to folio numbers or to the poem’s passus. Furthermore, the words glossed are not marked in any way within the text of the poem, so a later reader would not know to look for them in the glossary. The glossary’s placement gives further indication that it was compiled as a personal exercise rather than as an aid for another reader, whether that was someone known (that is, someone to whom the owner lent or willed the volume) or unknown. This manuscript contains ten separate items, the first of which is Piers Plowman, and the eighth of which is the glossary; according to the manuscript foliation, over seventy leaves once separated the glossary from the end of Langland’s poem.25
A PROLIFERATION OF PLOWMEN
51
The glossary in the Cambridge University Library manuscript is incomplete as it stands. Not only does it gloss only a small portion of the poem, many of the words listed as needing a gloss are not yet defined. In its arrangement and its status as unfinished, this glossary gives unusual insight into the reading process of an early modern reader of Piers Plowman. Many of the glossary’s entries are of words found in Passus 17 and 18 of the poem, with a significant number also from the Prologue, Passus 1, Passus 8, and Passus 20.26 The words in the glossary appear as series of words that appear in the same passus, although these sets taken together do not follow the order of the poem. Thus, the sixth through the eighteenth words in the left column of folio 170r are all from Passus 18 of the poem—from “ffreyne” (B.18.18) through “Besquatt” (18.248)—but the glossary subsequently switches to listing words from the Prologue and Passus 1. This suggests that the glossator was compiling the glossary while puzzling through difficult passages or while reading some favorite scenes, not during the process of reading the poem from beginning to end. The Piers Plowman glossary was essentially private, written in a single manuscript copy of the poem, while Reginald Wolfe’s printed glossary in his edition of Pierce the Ploughman’s Crede was public, a reading aid for an unknown audience. Despite this difference, they both indicate that the vocabulary of fourteenth- or early-fifteenth-century alliterative verse was challenging, at least in places, for sixteenth-century readers. Even the London dialect of Chaucer’s works had become somewhat opaque to readers by the end of the sixteenth century; the first Chaucer edition to have a glossary appended to it is Speght’s edition of 1598. Stephanie Trigg notes that this sort of explanatory apparatus shows that “[e]diting had become a double act of veneration and alienation” for Speght and his successors.27 These glossaries therefore underscore how surprising it is that such Middle English texts were printed at all in the sixteenth century. Paradoxically, for many editors, including Wolfe, the very alterity of these medieval texts was part of their appeal; they were printed because, not despite their obsolete language. In Wolfe’s presentation of Pierce the Ploughman’s Crede, the difficulty of the language conveys part of the point to be made by reprinting an old work. Had Wolfe wished to update, rather than gloss, the hard words, in many cases he could have done so even while preserving the alliteration. For example, he could have emended the Middle English “pulched” to the early modern equivalent he gives in the glossary, “polished.” The experience of reading the archaic language of the Crede implicitly confirmed for the reader its authenticity as representing an older, pre-Reformation, English anti-Catholicism. For Wolfe and his readers, the Crede has symbolic value as much as it has literal, doctrinal value. It manifests the truth of
52
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
the Protestant claim that the Reformation was a recovery of an ancient form of worship native to England. By preserving the archaic language of the Crede, despite its obscurity, Wolfe makes good on the promise that he offers in his short prefatory verse “To the Reader”: To read strange newes, desires manye, Which at my hande they can not haue: For here is but antiquitie Expressed only, as tholde booke gaue. Take in good part, and not depraue The Ploughmans Crede, ientyll reader: Loo, this is all that I requyer.28
The language of Pierce the Ploughman’s Crede is archaic because Wolfe preserves the diction of his source text “as tholde booke gaue.” Its doctrine is neither new nor strange, adjectives that could indicate theological defensiveness on two different fronts in 1553. The argument that authorizes Protestantism as more ancient than Catholicism (with its practices not mentioned in the gospels) defines Catholic rituals as both “new” and “strange” in Christian history. Catholics were not the only denomination likely to be accused of novelty in this period. In 1553, “new” and “strange” doctrines were being promulgated as well by radical Protestant sects who would themselves oppose as too conservative (not too radical) the doctrine embodied by Pierce the Ploughman’s Crede. Pierce the Ploughman’s Crede begins with its narrator seeking to learn his creed, because he is worried about the consequences his current state of ignorance will provoke in confession: Whan I shall shewen my shrift, shent mote I worthen, The preeste wil me punyche, and penaunce enioyne.29
By 1553, such an anxiety about proper confession to a priest would have seemed theologically conservative to most readers. The 1549 Prayer Book allowed for penitents to make auricular confession but did not require that they do so, and by 1553 most English Protestants would have considered confessing to a priest theologically unnecessary. Lutherans, Calvinists, and more radical Protestants rejected auricular confession outright.30 In its linguistic form and theological content, Wolfe’s ancient text thus repudiates the “strange newes” offered by both ends of the doctrinal spectrum: conservative Catholicism and radical Protestantism. Another early-sixteenth-century editor who claims great antiquity for his medieval text is the editor of The Prayer and Complaynt of the Ploweman
A PROLIFERATION OF PLOWMEN
53
vnto Christ.31 There were two editions of the Prayer and Complaynt, both printed before Henry’s 1533 marriage to Anne Boleyn precipitated his final break with Rome.32 The editor of the Prayer and Complaynt is unknown. The first edition marked the Preface “to the christen reader”; the second edition titles it “W. T. to the reader.” The initials suggest William Tyndale, but Anthea Hume argues that the edition was more likely by George Joye, because it would be uncharacteristic of Tyndale to have left the first edition anonymous.33 The title page of the Prayer and Complaynt claims that the work was “writte[n] not longe after” 1300, a date probably a century too early. This prose treatise begins with a Preface that traces “a vayne name of newe lernynge” back to the Pharisees who accused Christ.34 The contemporary clergy, and particularly the episcopacy, imitate the Pharisees in their accusations against reformist preachers: “Euen nowe after the same maner/. . .our holye bysshops. . .be of the selfe same sort/. . .ye do se howe they defame/ sclaunder persecute the same worde and prechers/ and folowers of it/ with the selfe same names.”35 By this analogy, the reformers are, like Christ, oppressed by a corrupt clergy who slander true doctrine as heretical innovation, “[a]nd by that meanes they lyberally prison and persecute vnto the deth all the professours of the same.”36 This Preface links contemporary opponents of an unjust church to an authorizing history of both theological truth and the endurance of persecution. The reformers are martyrs following the model of Christ, teaching doctrinal truths despite their persecution by the religious authorities. The Prayer and Complaynt (both the Preface and the running titles call it “The Prayer or Complaynt”) is really neither prayer nor complaint so much as it is a creedal statement and a refutation of certain Catholic charges against Protestantism. It is a one-sided dialogue in which the speaker cites an opposing view (“Lord, some men say. . .”) in order to disprove it through biblical evidence. The speaker’s identity as a plowman is never mentioned beyond the work’s title. Given the fact that the plowman’s profession is irrelevant to the narrative proper, it seems clear that his identification explicitly as a plowman is iconic. For whoever gave this work its title, whether the author or the printer, the Prayer and Complaynt, like Pierce the Ploughman’s Crede, associates a Lollard text with the figure of the plowman, but without individuating the plowman speaker as either a character or a type. In both instances, the plowman figure is invoked for his symbolic rather than his narrative value. The title page claim to textual antiquity is echoed in the prefatory matter of the two editions of Prayer and Complaynt. In the first edition of 1531, the preface to the reader on fols. Aiv–Aiiir is followed on fol. Aiiiv by a table of “suche olde wordes as be nowe antyquate worne out of
54
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
knowledge by processe of tyme.”37 This table is presented as necessary because the text appears “in his [i.e., the plowman’s] owne olde englysshe or ortographye/ chaungyne therein nothing. . .other the englysshe or ortographye”38 The table itself is quite short, containing only thirty-one words. This glossary, like the glossary of Pierce the Ploughmans Crede, seems more symbolically useful to the volume’s editor than linguistically useful to its reader.39 In the second edition (possibly from 1532), the Preface is moved so that it starts on the recto of its page (fol. Aiir) and continues through the page that had formerly been allocated for the table (fol. Aiiiv). The table itself is omitted in this second edition, although the unrevised preface still refers to it. Because the Prayer and Complaynt is, as the Preface calls it, one of Protestantism’s “holy relyques,” its text is more valuable in its original form than updated. The use of redefined Catholic terminology in describing the Prayer and Complaynt a “holy relic” is typical of the rhetoric of this Lollard text, which consistently plays on ironies it identifies in the gap between Catholic practice and spiritual ideals. For example, Prayer and Complaynt contrasts the Catholic veneration of relics with the contemporary abuse and neglect of the living poor: Lorde/ what heryenge is it to fetche deed mens bones oute of the grounde there as they shulden kyndelyche roten / and shrynen hem in golde and in syluer / and suffren thy quycke bones of thyne ymages roten in prison for defaute of clothynge.40
In the logic of the text, Catholicism’s favoring of dead bones over the bodies of the living poor not only violates nature but mislocates the holy. By referring to the poor and imprisoned as God’s images, the Prayer and Complaynt demonstrates why, in its theology, they are more worthy of respect than Catholic relics. True “holy relyques,” according to the Prayer and Complaynt, are the textual remains that teach Protestant doctrine, not the corporeal remains of “deed mens bones.” The force of this attack on the Catholic veneration of relics is doubled by its association with the plowman, who is not only poor (as an agricultural laborer) but also the producer of a text that survives as a “relic” of an ancient English tradition of anti-Catholicism. John Foxe’s 1570 reprinting of the Prayer and Complaynt continues the earlier editions’ emphasis on the text’s historicity, although he modifies the previous editions’ exaggerated backdating of the text. Foxe does not explicitly assign the text to a particular year, but he suggests a date of composition later than the early-fourteenth-century date alleged by the two previous editions. Shortly before his quotation of the Prayer and Complaynt
A PROLIFERATION OF PLOWMEN
55
in the Actes and Monumentes, Foxe cites 1360 as the year in which God “beginneth some reformation of his churche,” and he lists the holy Martyrs and confessors, who folowing after in the course of yeares with lyke zeale and strength of gods word and also with lyke daunger of their liues gaue the lyke resistance agaynst the enemie of Christes religion, and suffered at his handes the lyke persecutio[n]s.41
The first on his list of martyrs and confessors is “that godly man” who wrote the Prayer and Complaynt. Foxe does not assign a name or biography to this author, nor does he justify his assertion that the author of the Prayer and Complaynt suffered persecution, or was perhaps martyred, for publishing this work. The actual biography of this author is apparently less important than his location within a community of reformist writing in the later fourteenth century. Foxe’s assertion that the Prayer and Complaynt was written after 1360 differs by at least half a century from the date given in his source text; if any of his readers noticed this alteration, they might at least be comforted by the reassurance that the text is still “An old auncient writing,” as Foxe terms it.42 Despite redating the text (a fact he does not mention), Foxe proclaims his fidelity to the earlier edition and to the plowman’s own language: Although the oldnes and age of his speche & termes be almost grown now out of vse: yet thought I it best, both for the vtilitie of the boke to reserue it fro[m] obliuion, as also in his own language to let it go abroade, for the more credit and testimony of the true antiquitie of the same.43
Foxe implies that the book’s utility is its transmission of doctrine, although if this were his primary concern, he could have updated the language for the ease of reading, something he explicitly does not do. Instead, he offers marginal glosses of obscure words while maintaining textual archaism. This suggests that the real utility of the Prayer and Complaynt for Foxe is its linguistic “testimony,” giving “more credit” to the long-standing history and “true antiquitie” of anti-Catholicism. Foxe’s desire to present medieval texts as medieval (or, in his terminology, “antique”) is visible again in his introduction of a text that claims to be the personal history of an examination for heresy undergone by the early-fifteenth-century Lollard William Thorpe.44 The text Foxe printed, “as wee haue received it, copyed out & corrected by maister William Tindall (who had hys owne hande writyng)” had modernized the text, a change Foxe regrets: “for the more credit of the matter, I rather wished it in his own naturall speache, wherin it was first writen.”45 Foxe assures his readers that the authentic, medieval text in Thorpe’s own words does exist,
56
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
although Foxe himself has not seen it. To add credibility to this assertion, Foxe names both the owner of the old manuscript and Foxe’s informant as to its existence and antiquity: they bee yet a lyue, which haue seen the selfe same copy in his own old Englishe, resemblyng the true antiquitie both of the speache and of the tyme: The name of whom as for record of the same to auouche, is maister Whithead, who as he hath seen the true auncient copy in the hands of George Constantine, so hath he geuen credible relation of the same, both to the printer and to me. Furthermore, the sayd maister Tyndall (albeit he did somwhat alter and amend the English therof, and frame it after our maner) yet not fully in all wordes, but that some thing doth remaine, saueryng of the old speech of [the] tyme.46
These details add to Foxe’s claim the veneer of verifiability, although a reader of the Actes and Monumentes would be unlikely to track down this source text, especially since Foxe himself has not been able to do so. Early modern editors of the Plowman texts consistently emphasize the “medievalness” of their texts, highlighting the antiquity of the language as reproduced, despite the fact that intervening linguistic changes might present a barrier to the non-medieval reader. The early-sixteenth-century edition of A proper dyaloge, betwene a gentillman and a husbandma[n], eche complaynenge to other theyr myserable calamyte through the ambicion of the clergye, seems also to conform to this pattern.47 The interlocutors in this text represent the two nonclerical estates, and they agree that the avarice of the clergy is to blame for their respective poverty. The framing dialogue is an early modern addition to a medieval Lollard treatise, and the text makes no attempt to unify the two parts.48 The chronological distance between the sixteenth-century framing dialogue and the medieval Lollard text is, in fact, highlighted in the Dyaloge itself. The Gentillman complains about the clergy’s allegation that “thes heretyke lutheranes” are a “secte new fanggled/ With execrable heresyes entanggled.”49 Although the Gentillman is more often the knowledgeable speaker in the Dyaloge, he is wrong when he asserts that the English have only recently dared to complain against the clergy. The Husbandman knows better and can offer proof: By saynt mary syr/ that is a starcke lye I can shewe you a worke by and by Against that poynte makynge obieccyon Which of warrantyse I dare be bolde That is aboue an hondred yere olde As the englysshe selfe doth testefye.50
A PROLIFERATION OF PLOWMEN
57
The Gentillman is happy to conclude from this: “So is it than no newe found heresy.”51 The archaic language, the “englysshe selfe,” of the Husbandman’s book, like that of Pierce the Ploughmans Crede and the Prayer and Complaynt, is used as evidence of long-standing opposition to the clergy by the English laity. Significantly, it is the Husbandman who knows of a long tradition of English anti-Catholicism. The husbandman in the Proper dyaloge is not explicitly a plowman, but the Dyaloge seems to depend upon the reader’s familiarity with the genre of “Plowman texts” in that its agricultural laborer is linked to a local, and specifically historical, tradition of anticlerical complaint. Later in the century, the connection between rural laborers and Piers Plowman may become more automatic; in his 1570 reprinting of Jack Upland, John Foxe refers to Jack Upland as “a plouhman,” although the text does not actually make this designation.52 Perhaps Foxe subconsciously added the plowman identity to the rural complainant of Jack Upland, or perhaps he intentionally named that profession in order to exploit an existing trope. In either case, the added detail manifests a cultural understanding of the plowman’s literary identity as a simple layperson who speaks out against the flaws in the established social and ecclesiastical order. The Husbandman, Reginald Wolfe, and the editor of the Prayer and Complaynt all call attention to their texts’ archaic language. Sixteenthcentury editors of earlier texts could either update their originals, making them easier for modern readers to understand, or preserve archaic linguistic features as a demonstration of the texts’ age. Twenty-first-century editors of medieval texts usually choose a strategy somewhere between the two, although leaning more heavily toward the latter. Most current editions of medieval texts update their texts at least to some extent by regularizing spelling and following modern conventions of punctuation and capitalization.53 Sixteenth-century editors found similar compromises. Because of the intervening changes in the language, some surface elements of the medieval texts tend to be updated in sixteenth-century editions, even when their editors strive to preserve the texts in their original form (and advertise that preservation). Although sixteenth-century editions might preserve older spellings of words, medieval texts were often subject to typographical modernizations, as the characters Q and { became increasingly obsolete in the early modern printshop. Such orthographic modernization occurs in the sixteenth-century editions of Piers Plowman itself, although the text largely preserves medieval forms. Despite its popularity in the fourteenth and into the fifteenth century, and its continued manuscript circulation and recopying, Piers Plowman was not printed until 1550, when Robert Crowley produced three editions of the poem. As John N. King has shown, Crowley silently makes some
58
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
small changes to the poem’s syntax and morphology to make them accord with sixteenth-century usage.54 Nevertheless, Crowley does maintain the poem’s difficult lexicon, and, like the editors of the Plowman texts discussed above, he makes a point of advertising his linguistic conservatism, announcing that “[t]he Englishe [of Piers Plowman] is according to the tyme it was written in.”55 Crowley dates the poem’s time of composition as “about two hundred yeres paste,” in the mid-fourteenth century.56 Despite the poem’s difficult, archaic vocabulary, Crowley provides no glossary in any of his editions of Langland’s poem. In his 1561 reprint of both Crowley’s text of Piers Plowman and Reginald Wolfe’s text of Peres the Ploughman’s Crede, Owen Rogers reprints Wolfe’s glossary to the Crede, but Piers Plowman itself remains unglossed even in Rogers’s edition.57 The Lollard Plowman texts signified their meaning in two divergent ways for Reformation propagandists.58 The content of the texts—their doctrine, their accusations, their complaints—supported the similar claims made by members of their sixteenth-century audience. To this extent, it was most advantageous to present a text easy for postmedieval readers to understand. On the other hand, the antiquity of the Lollard texts underwrote the claim that Protestantism was an authentically ancient, and thus authorized, doctrine. From this perspective, texts that manifested their age through their linguistic alterity held symbolic value; they asserted their authority because of (not despite) their difficult language. Sixteenthcentury editors of the earlier Plowman texts (including Piers Plowman itself) all face the same dilemma: presenting older writings as simultaneously ancient and relevant. Many of the Plowman texts highlight the antiquity of the text. Some, however, bring the Plowman into the present day. In texts that mark their age, the Plowman’s chronological distance gave his words added weight.59 In texts written in a presentist voice, the Plowman’s authority was enhanced by a different kind of distance: Piers the Plowman’s social marginality. As in modern American political discourse, the badge of outsider carries with it a paradoxical value. In the rhetoric of the Plowman texts, those in authority have allowed society to decay, and the solution must, therefore, be generated by those distant from the centers of power. This logic is underscored by a theology that emphasizes not Christ’s divine majesty but his simple humanity. Christ, like the plowman, is a humble member of the laity despised by the clerical hierarchy for his truthful but unauthorized teaching. The Preface to The Prayer and Complaynt of the Ploweman vnto Christ by W. T. is a reformist text that grants spiritual authority to those distant from power, common laborers. In this Preface, W. T. dates back to biblical times the dispute over who has authority, thus authorizing the lower ranking
A PROLIFERATION OF PLOWMEN
59
laity by analogy to the apostles. The “scrybes/ the pharyses the bysshops/ the preestes/ the lawyers the elders of the people” in the time of Jesus said “that Christ and his disciples were men neither of auctoritye nor reputacyon/ but laye men/ ydiotes/ fysshers/ carpenters and other of the rascall sort.”60 The complaint against the apostles, as reported by W. T., lumps together two categories of those traditionally denied both theological and political authority: uneducated lay people and members of the laboring class. For the scribes and pharisees who opposed Christ and his apostles, their low social status as fishermen or carpenters was, in itself, a reason not to respect them. For W. T., however, the apostles were “men. . .of auctoritye” precisely because of their marginal social status. The juxtaposition of biblical and modern titles (“scrybes” and “pharyses” on the one hand and “bysshops” and “lawyers” on the other) in the description of those who accused Christ makes obvious the Preface’s concern with current events. By implication, the modern laity, even those “of the rascall sort,” should have access to the word of God, just as Christ’s nonclerical disciples did. Twenty years after the publication of the Prayer and Complaynt, when the project of religious reformation had succeeded, the figure of Piers the Plowman was mobilized for a different purpose, that of political and economic reformation, in Pyers Plowmans exhortation/ vnto the lordes/ knightes and burgoysses of the Parlyamenthouse.61 In this treatise, Pyers explicitly draws the analogy between social and religious reformations, reminding his readers that the “fatte prelates” denied any error in their religion prior to the Reformation, and now “there be many fatte marchau[n]tes which wold haue no reformation in the comon wealth.”62 By naming his socioeconomic proposal a “reformation,” Pyers grants it the authority of the earlier Reformation of English religion. This allusion also suggests a shared literary understanding between author and reader; Pyers’s authority as a spokesman for economic reform is enhanced by the reader’s familiarity with his earlier textual role as a proponent of religious reform. In Pyers’s discussion of the current economic disparities in contemporary England, he addresses readers who are not themselves poor laborers. Pyers seeks to dispel the social myths promulgated by those who benefit from the current economic system (particularly, in this case, the mercantile class of the commons). The self-serving merchants espouse the economic doctrine that the economy is set up in a way beneficial to all, “but he that wyll be conuersaunt with the come[n] sorte of the poore comens shal. . .heare se & p[er]ceyue the case to be farre otherwise.”63 Pyers points out for his readers that empirical knowledge of the state of the commonwealth comes not in the parliament house but in the countryside, where the enclosure of fields for sheep pastures has denied poor farmers their
60
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
livelihood. The virtuous plowman figure is a powerful political and literary symbol not because agricultural laborers were the primary market for this treatise, but precisely because they were not. Pyers stands as a voice of truth outside of the world of court, city, parliament, or marketplace: his authority is that of the simple outsider, a role granted spiritual importance in Reformation theology, and here granted political importance as well. Pyers’s concern about the enclosure of farmlands for grazing identifies his concerns with those geographically distant from the “Parlyamenthouse.” In the sixteenth century, as wool became an industry more important to the national economy, landowners increasingly turned to raising sheep rather than farming.64 The increased enclosure of formerly common lands in Tudor England may have affected as little as 3 percent of the available agricultural lands, but it was perceived by those in rural England as provoking a crisis, as it reduced available employment and thus led to local depopulation.65 Pyers Plowman’s voice was not the only one speaking out against the economic problems caused by enclosures; Andy Wood claims that sentiment against enclosures was “[p]robably the most common cause of riots during the sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries,” and he notes that the unlanded poor were not the only participants in enclosure riots.66 Although the primary opposition to enclosures was in rural areas, an early-seventeenth-century treatise against enclosure argues that it provokes a kind of “trickle-up” economic crisis, eventually harming merchants in towns as well as agricultural laborers in the countryside: “the plowe maintaines all trades, as Mercers, Grocers, Tanners, Shooemakers, Glouers, Smiths, Taylors, Ioyners, Carpenters, &c. But since Inclosure began, all these Artificers prooue by experience, that they cannot haue such vtterances and returne for their wares as heretofore.”67 The sentiment that enclosure will hurt the entire country, not simply the displaced plowmen, is visible also in an early-seventeenth-century comment in a C text manuscript of Piers Plowman. In Passus 8 of the poem, Piers organizes the community to work together for the common good, but Wastour will not. Piers calls upon Hunger to punish Wastour, and the community is beset by famine. In British Library Additional MS 35157 (sigil U), Francis Ayscough has written at this point: “nota Brittaine shalbe bitten with hungere when the plouth shalbe neclected by inclosers.”68 The arrival of Hunger that Ayscough foresees is not caused by the idleness of wasters but by the enclosers’ threat to the nation’s farming capacity. If the plow is “neclected,” Ayscough warns, all of Britain, not just its plowmen, will suffer the consequences. Clearly, Pyers Plowmans exhortation is not alone in worrying about the threat that enclosure poses for farmers and nonfarmers alike. As a sixteenth-century reader of Pyers Plowmans exhortation might expect of a literary Plowman, Pyers couches his economic arguments in the language
A PROLIFERATION OF PLOWMEN
61
of anti-Catholicism. According to this treatise, the reduced availability of agricultural employment caused by enclosure has been exacerbated by the dissolution of the abbeys, which has increased the number of available workers. All of those who were once in the Catholic economy (monks, candle makers, image painters, and so on) now must find other work in a tight labor market. In its concern for the labor market, Pyers Plowmans exhortation echoes its Langlandian antecedent. Anne Middleton argues that “the waking interlude between the first and second visions of the C version. . .takes its premises and development as a narrative event from the provisions of the second Statute of Laborers.”69 The labor crisis in Langland’s post-plague England was, however, the reverse of the one produced by enclosing arable land. In the late fourteenth century, there was more work to be done than able-bodied workers to accomplish it; in sixteenth-century England, according to Pyers Plowmans Exhortation, enclosure and the dissolution of the abbeys have together produced a surplus of workers, and therefore devalued labor. In Pyers Plowmans Exhortation, Pyers proposes an increase in the amount of arable land combined with a system of tariffs and subsidies to improve the balance of trade and develop foreign markets for the new surplus of English goods. As an outsider, Pyers must present this scheme diplomatically. He invokes the high stature of those he addresses, “my lordes with the knightes & burgoisses of [the] parlyame[n]thouse,” and apologizes for his “rude boldnes” in presuming to offer them advice. In times of crisis, however, even someone with superior status might benefit from a helpful word from an inferior, “lyke as the moost expert mariners/ in a great tempestuous wether/ wil not disdayne somtime to be admonisshed by an inferioure Parson [i.e., person].”70 Because of Pyers’s status as an agricultural laborer, he knows firsthand the hardships of the rural poor, so he offers his solution to those with the power to implement it. In Pyers Plowmans exhortation, as in Piers Plowman itself, the experience of being a plowman is what authorizes Pyers to propose solutions to political problems. Piers Plowman’s professional expertise is invoked even more directly in the treatise known as I Playne Piers. This text takes its name from a verse that stands in place of a title on the opening page: I playne Piers which cannot flatter A plowe man men me call My speche is fowlle/ yet marke the matter Howe thynges may hap to fall.71
The plainness mentioned here has two components. The Plowman’s speech is “fowlle,” unornamented and plain. The Plowman is also plainspoken: he
62
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
“cannot flatter” but speaks the truth. A reader would therefore be wise to “marke the matter,” for what the Plowman predicts “may hap to fall.” Piers outlines the hypocrisy and impiety of the clergy and the offenses of the great against the poor, who are kept from reading the Bible.72 He offers to the poor the consolation of a heavenly reward, and he expresses this in the language of rural labor: ther is no sede can brynge greate gayne but he be deed, thys we se playne in oure yerely sowynge, besyde thys we paciently abyde .vii. monethes lo[n]ge, tho we suffer at home much hunger and wronge, oure whete or we can gether why sholde we not than goddes workynge ken.73
The Plowman and his “bretherne hoggesherdes sheperhedes [sic]” and other rural laborers know what it means to wait through the growing season; thus they, much more than the rich, who are rewarded in this world, can certainly understand the promise of a heavenly reward to come. Their spiritual authority is precisely due to their economically and socially marginal status. The first-person plural forms (e.g., “thys we se playne. . .”) emphasize the distinction between the pious poor and those in more elevated positions, from which the proper doctrine is less “playne” to see. Although I Playne Piers does not directly refer to Piers Plowman, the later text does suggest a possible familiarity with the generic form of Langland’s poem, or at least with some other texts of the medieval dream vision tradition. I Playne Piers begins with the Plowman resting from his labor, meditating on the necessity of rest and then attacking the doctrine of clerical celibacy. “All this whyle me thought I slept,” the Plowman then announces.74 He awakes to continue his labor until nightfall. Despite his earlier weariness, Piers “coulde not slepe a wynke,” so he takes up a book in order to write down his thoughts.75 The use of an alternately sleeping and waking narrator might derive from Piers Plowman directly, but, even if it is not a direct allusion, it certainly partakes of two common dream vision devices: the sleepless narrator, and the narrator’s self-conscious writing of his dream for a secondary audience.76 As in Langland’s poem, which contains a series of linked dreams as well as a number of waking events, dream vision conventions are skewed by this text even as they are invoked. In I Playne Piers, the narrator takes up a book because of his sleeplessness, but unlike the narrators of Chaucer’s Book of the Duchess or that of Henryson’s Testament of Criseyde, Piers writes, rather than reads, in this book. The dream of I Playne Piers is limited to the text’s opening section; it is not the text’s central focus. Moreover, no shift in subject matter or narrative technique differentiates the dream from Piers’s waking thought or writing. He never mentions falling asleep until the time of his
A PROLIFERATION OF PLOWMEN
63
waking up. Given these nonconventional uses of the dream vision genre, it seems that the author of I Playne Piers was using the genre symbolically. The dream vision structure connects I Playne Piers to an earlier literary tradition, the tradition in which its title character was born.77 The Plowman texts consistently mark Piers Plowman’s distance from the centers and discourse of power by explicit references to his simple speech, as in I Playne Piers. Nevertheless, the texts are all predicated on the belief that Piers’s words will be persuasive. Theirs is the rhetoric of seeming artlessness: the truth of Piers’s words needs no ornament. The language of “plainness” echoes throughout this textual tradition. The valuing of a plain, unadorned style has theological significance: it invokes the Protestant claims that Roman Catholic rituals were unauthorized additions to the pure apostolic Christianity described in the New Testament. The most extreme example of a text that imagines Piers as rhetorically effective despite his rustic identity is A godly dyalogue & dysputacyon betwene Pyers plowman and a popysh preest/ concernyng the supper of the lorde.78 In this text, “simple Pyers plowma[n]” encounters four priests at a dinner; “boldened and encouraged” by the holy ghost, Pyers interrogates one of the priests about the nature of the Eucharist.79 The narrative situation of the Godly dyalogue mirrors the scene in Piers Plowman when Conscience invites Langland’s dreamer, Will, to “come to his court, wiQ clergie sholde I dyne” (B.13.23).80 At this meal, Will argues with a gluttonous doctor of divinity about the natures of Dowel, Dobet, and Dobest. In both Piers Plowman and A godly dyalogue, the clergyman gets the worst of the argument, but Langland’s Doctor of Divinity does not capitulate as does the “popysh preest” of the Godly dyalogue. In Piers Plowman, it is Conscience who is persuaded by the discourse; he goes forth with Pacience as a pilgrim (B.13.215), an outcome one would not expect to see echoed by the Protestant author of the Godly dyalogue. The thematic connection between the Godly dyalogue and Piers Plowman suggests that the (undated) Godly dyalogue might have been influenced by one of Crowley’s editions of Piers Plowman. This seems to be the implication of the STC dating of the Godly dyalogue to “c. 1550.” It is also possible, however, that the author of the Godly dyalogue knew Langland’s poem through one of its many manuscripts, so the dating of this text remains conjectural. In their “dyalogue & dysputacyon,” the priest and Pyers differ in their Eucharistic theology. Piers cites St. Augustine to defend his claim that the sacrament is memorial and that the body of Christ is not substantially present. The priest refuses to believe Pyers, arguing “S Austen sayth no such thing I trow how be it to saye truthe I haue not greatly occupyed miselfe in redyng of hys workes.”81 Far from being a doctrinal authority, even in defense of his own position, the priest is shown to have less learning than
64
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
this “simple” plowman. Pyers even cites Augustine in Latin, improbably for a plowman, but effectively for the author’s demonstration that the putative authority figure, the priest, actually lacks authority.82 Like Piers Plowman itself, the Godly dyalogue embeds patristic Latin within an English text, constructing an implied reader with some theological education. Despite the text’s focus on the authority of the rustic plowman, no actual plowman was a likely reader for this text. The work’s title too, with its double reference to the interlocutors’ dialogue and disputation, presumes a learned audience insofar as it specifically invokes the academic meaning of “disputation.” “Disputation” here must suggest the theological or philosophical disputation of university debate. It is not a simple synonym for its more neutral pair, “dialogue.” In this treatise, Pyers shows his expertise in the labor of plowing, but he also proves his abilities in an employment proper to the clergy: theological disputation. Pyers has to do the labor of two estates, because the priest “[has] not greatly occupyed [himself]” in his obligations. Pyers’s Socratic argument forces the priest to concede that Christ’s body is not substantially present in the Eucharist. When Pyers finishes his proof, none of the priests present can disagree. The Godly dyalogue closes with the priests concerned about their potential loss of status, but no longer in disagreement with what they had previously considered heresy. The priests who witnessed the dispute say, “If these hobbes and rusticals be suffred to be thus busy. . .we shalbe fayne, to learne some other occupacion,” to which Pyers replies, “AMEN.”83 In the Godly dyalogue, the only “prayer” the priests utter is unintentional, as Pyers ironically reinterprets their professional anxieties as a prayer for a society in which priests do not necessarily take precedence over plowmen in scriptural interpretation, surely a society the priests themselves would not wish to see. By the end of the Godly dyalogue, Pyers has not convinced the priests to relish the idea of lay people debating theology, but he has demonstrated the truth of his doctrine. Despite his simplicity, and with the help of the holy spirit, he is able to best his social superiors. His practice of labor proper to the clerical order threatens the clergy’s professional monopoly. When Piers addresses his social superiors in these different texts, he registers the distance between them, but he does not refrain from speaking directly or boldly. This is particularly apparent in I Playne Piers, which begins with Piers describing his rest from his labor. His tone in the opening lines is moderate, but as he warms to his theme and moves to a mode of direct address, he becomes quite confrontational, no matter how elevated his addressee. “Consyder o Kynges & Princes” he exhorts, “how lothely a thynge is a christen kynge, to be Antychristes protectour.”84 His mocking tone is exaggerated by the text’s liberal use of alliteration, internal
A PROLIFERATION OF PLOWMEN
65
rhyme, and other sorts of verbal parallelism. Later in the century, these rhetorical elements will come to be generic markers in the Martin Marprelate tracts, Puritan polemics against the Anglican episcopacy.85 The second edition of I Playne Piers notes this similarity explicitly on its title page. In place of an authorial name, the title page proclaims “if any my name doo craue, I am the Gransier [i.e., grandsire] of Martin Mareprelitte.” The title page of the second edition of I Playne Piers futher emphasizes the treatise’s similarity to the Marprelate tracts by several other references to the title pages of the first two treatises allegedly by Martin Marprelate, known as The Epistle and The Epitome, both published in 1588. The second edition of I Playne Piers claims to have been “Compiled afore yeaster day, for the behoofe and ouerthrow of all Parsons, Vikars, and Curats who haue learned their Cathechismes, and can not yet vnderstand them, although the be past their grace.” The title page of The Epistle claims that it was “Compiled for the behoofe and owerthrow of the Parsous [sic]/ Fyckers/ and Currats/ that have lernt their Catechismes/ and are past grace,” while the The Epitome claims to have been “Compiled for the behoofe and overthrow of the vnpreaching Parsons/ Fyckers/ and Currats/ that haue lernt their Catechismes/ and are past grace.”86 Similarly, I Playne Piers echoes the Marprelate tracts in its claimed printing location. The Epitome claims to have been printed: “on the other hand of some of the Priests”; the second edition of I Playne Piers gives: “either of this side, or of that side of some of the Priestes.”87 The second edition of I Playne Piers survives in only a fragment of what seems to be a printer’s copytext. In this edition, rhyming words are often marked by line breaks, so the text is laid out in a mixture of verse and prose. This layout calls attention to the playful, rhyming nature of the treatise. It thus exaggerates the mockery and lack of decorum that would eventually make the Marprelate Tracts so influential, but those elements were already present in the first edition of I Playne Piers, from which the second edition diverges very little. Some topical references to early-sixteenthcentury events have been taken out, and references to kings are now to princes, a title more suitable with Elizabeth on the throne. Otherwise, the two texts are (to the extent that the second edition survives) nearly identical. In his style and his willingness to attack directly opponents of higher social status, Playne Piers truly is Martin’s “gransier.” The jesting of the Marprelate tracts has a dual rhetorical function. It implies that the opposing view is ridiculous, and, in doing so, it moves the locus of spiritual authority away from the figure of greater social authority. In this treatise, Martin challenges the defense of the established church made by John Bridges, dean of Salisbury, and he does so explicitly in a discourse that violates contemporary rhetorical standards. He begins
66
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
The Epistle by telling the clergy that “D. Bridges hath written in your defence/ a most senceles book,” and then apologizing that Bridges’s illogic requires from him an equally “senseless” response: may it please you to giue me leaue to play the Duns for the nonce as well as he/ otherwise dealing with master doctors booke/ I cannot keepe decorum personae. And may it please you/ if I be too absurd in any place (either in this Epistle/ or that Epitome) to ride to Sarum/ and thanke his Deanship for it.88
Beyond calling attention to his theological opposition to Bridges, Martin calls attention to his own satirical voice as an “anti-rhetorician,” and he presents himself as the “Duns” to the socially superior “master doctor.” Following Cicero, early modern rhetorical handbooks identify indecorous and rough satire with the uneducated rustic, the simple fool.89 Such an identity has a political import in this debate. Martin makes his critique of the established church from outside of the conventional centers of power and in a voice far from those advocated by the standards of persuasive rhetoric. In pursuing this strategy of deliberate and explicit rusticity, Martin follows his predecessor, Piers Plowman (as he appears in all of the Plowman texts), who constructs his ethos through the same combination of uneducated speech, nonmetropolitan location, and low social status. Far from prohibiting his speech, Piers Plowman’s social and geographic distance from the centers of power authorizes his words in the Plowman texts. It is explicitly as a marginal figure that the Plowman speaks, even in his appearance most tied to the dominant literary tradition. An antiauthoritarian Plowman was famously allied to canonical Middle English literature by the later designation of a Lollard poem as one of the Canterbury Tales. The prologue that assimilates the so-called Plowman’s Tale to Chaucer’s frame narrative is generally believed to have been written later than the Tale itself.90 Since Lollards rejected the efficacy of pilgrimage, the connection between the Lollard text and the Chaucerian pilgrimage narrative makes little theological sense. It was, however, a powerful ideological move, defining Chaucer’s identity as proto-Protestant for at least two centuries of later readers.91 The Plowman’s Tale was first included in the Chaucer canon in Thynne’s 1542 edition of Chaucer’s Workes, and remained there until it was removed by Tyrwhitt in 1775.92 Chaucer’s pilgrims do include a virtuous plowman, described in the General Prologue, but he is one of the pilgrims who does not tell a tale in the unfinished Canterbury Tales.93 To the sixteenth-century author of the Plowman’s Prologue, fixing Chaucer’s oversight must have seemed only too tempting. Interestingly, the text of the Plowman’s Prologue alienates the Plowman from his putative narrative
A PROLIFERATION OF PLOWMEN
67
context as much as it absorbs him into the Canterbury Tales. He thus remains an outsider even in this most authorizing context. The Prologue to the Plowman’s Tale begins with an ending, the Plowman ceasing his labors. This ending marks a new beginning, however, as it allows the Plowman to go on pilgrimage immediately (“platte”), without resting from his labors as his team does: The Plowman plucked vp his plowe. Whan mydsommer mone was comen in, And sayd his beestes shuld eate ynowe And lyge in the grasse vp to the chynnne. They ben feble both oxe and cowe Of hem nys left but bone and skynne He shoke of shere and cultre of drowe And honge his harneys on a pynne. He toke his tabarde and his staffe eke And on his heed he set his hat And sayde he wolde saynt Thomas seke On pylgremage he goth forth platte.94
Unless he has been plowing the Southwark to Canterbury road, this Plowman is outside of the original pilgrimage group, despite the fact that a plowman had been among the original company at the Tabard Inn in Chaucer General Prologue. The reference to “the mydsommer mone” alienates the Plowman even further from Chaucer’s spring pilgrims.95 The detail of the plowman preparing for his pilgrimage by donning his “tabard” might be a detail intended to mitigate the discontinuity between the plowman’s introduction and Chaucer’s pilgrimage narrative, since it recalls the name of Harry Bailly’s inn. Despite the obvious gaps between Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales and the Plowman’s Tale, the 1606 edition of The Plough-mans Tale begins with Chaucer’s General Prologue description of the Plowman.96 The editor of The Plough-mans Tale does not attempt to explain illogic of the Plowman’s initial presence among the pilgrims in Chaucer’s version in conjunction with his later joining of the pilgrimage group in the Plowman’s Tale. Presumably readers of the volume did not mind this narrative difficulty any more than they minded the theological difficulty of a Lollard going on pilgrimage. For the editor of this volume, juxtaposing Chaucer’s Plowman and the Plowman of the Plowman’s Tale supported the affiliation between the two texts, even despite the unmatched details. The symbolic value of absorbing Chaucer into a medieval prehistory of Protestantism obviously outweighs the narrative and theological problems posed by the visible disparities between these two texts. The value of Chaucer’s name in this project is
68
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
further suggested by the edition’s title page, which identifies the author of the Plowman’s Tale as “Sir Geffrey Chaucer,” an honorific never previously bestowed on Chaucer in an edition of his works. The fact that the Plowman is only incompletely assimilated into Chaucer’s fiction, retaining his status as an active laborer and an outsider, suggests that these two characteristics are important aspects of the Plowman’s literary identity in the sixteenth century. Textually, the Plowman’s Tale begins as something of an outsider as well, although it quickly joins the Canterbury Tales more fully. In Thynne’s 1542 edition, it appears after the Parson’s Tale as the last among the Canterbury Tales, a noticable appendage to anyone who compared this text with the 1532 edition that lacks the Plowman’s Tale. In the undated reprint of this edition, The Plowman’s Tale trades places with the Parson’s Tale; the Plowman’s Tale-Parson’s Tale arrangement is preserved by Stow, Speght, and Urry.97 The 1606 editor of The Plough-mans Tale praises this order, saying “it seemes to bee most reasonables [sic] that the Parsons Tale should bee the conclusion of their morning, worke [punctuation sic].”98 Accepting the Tale as Chaucerian, the editor of this volume hopes to assimilate it to the structure, if not the narrative or theological content, of the Canterbury Tales. In all of the sixteenth-century Plowman texts, the Plowman speaks as an outsider and lobbies for change. Nevertheless, the Plowman also always speaks for the principle of order. Since the established social structures have failed in some way, the Plowman advocates for reformations of various kinds, but he is neither an anarchist nor a nihilist. The Plowman’s proposals challenge those in power, but the Plowman himself claims conservatism, not radicalism; he seeks to repair a world troubled by the abuses of those in power. In this regard, his status as an agricultural laborer is significant. As one tied both to the cycles of the seasons and to the economic well-being of the commonwealth, the Plowman represents a kind of long term stability despite his oppositional stance. In perhaps the most politically controversial of the Plowman texts, Pyers Plowman’s Exhortation, which speaks to the governance of the realm, Pyers is careful to establish the limits of his complaint. He explicitly differentiates his desire to repair the social order from the goals of those who would eradicate it: I wold not that those ydell me[m]bres of this realme, which for [the] maytenau[n]ce of their ydelnes wold haue al thi[n]ges in co[m]men/ shuld think that I do now harp of that string.99
As Pyers Plowmans Exhortation demonstrates, religious reform could be used to justify extreme political reform, a prospect quite worrisome to those in
A PROLIFERATION OF PLOWMEN
69
power. Reformation propaganda is therefore as careful to dissociate itself from the taint of radical sects like the Anabaptists as it is to condemn the errors of Catholicism.100 The Plowman’s integration into the existing economy of individual labor and trade allows him to repudiate the socialism of the Anabaptists, even as he highlights current economic abuses. In I Playne Piers, Piers explicitly seeks to reinforce an orderly hierarchy of governance from the personal to the national. In lamenting the legal changes since 1543 that have prohibited laborers from reading the Bible, Piers maintains that his seemingly radical proposal for open access to scriptures is actually in the service of a social conservatism. When Piers was allowed to read scripture to his household, “then was I syr, then was I father, then was I shepherd and all.”101 Piers argues that all social bonds of loyalty and respect have collapsed since 1543, because the word of God is currently less available: the lawe is gone from the prestes, Iustyce from a great sort of princes, cownsell frome the elders, fayth from the people, naturall loue frome the parentes, all reuerence frome the subiectes, all loue and charitye from the prelates, honesty frome the youth, lernynge from the clargy, knowledge from the masters dyligence from the scollers, from the cytyzens concorde, feare from seruauntes, trewe dealying from marchauntes, corrage frome the nobles, chastytie from virgens, loue from the maried, paciens fro[m] the pore. O the vnfaythful state of mortal men, and this is all because we are wythout the knowledge of God.102
The 1542/1543 Acte for thadvauncement of true Religion and for thabbolisshment of the contrarie claimed that allowing the “lower sorte” of people to read the Bible had caused “greate dyvision and discenc[i]on” among themselves.103 Here Piers argues just the reverse; withholding the Bible from the majority of the nation has destroyed every principle by which society maintains its unity and security. It has undermined the stability of the family, the church, the city, the household economy, and the realm. The sixteenth-century texts featuring Piers Plowman range from recycled Lollard treatises (the Plowman’s Tale and the Prayer and Complaynt) to an economic policy proposal (Pyers Plowman’s Exhortation), but Piers himself has similar roles in all of these appearances. He criticizes some aspect of decay in the realm and offers a solution that will restore order and benefit all members of the commonwealth. He speaks to those above himself, but without conceding that he lacks any social authority to speak as he does. Although all of the doctrines that Piers espouses would have seemed radical to those in authority (civil or ecclesiastical), he presents himself as conservative, one seeking only the restitution of a lost social harmony, and his voice is often explicitly tied to England’s past.
70
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
A related work, but one that does not invoke Piers Plowman’s name explicitly, is a broadside of 1552 by Thomas Churchyard called Dauy Dycars Dreame. Although Piers is not a character in Churchyard’s poem, Dauy [i.e., Davy] derives his name directly from Langland’s work: Dawe the Dyker appears in Piers Plowman at B.6.330 as the name of a laborer who is liable to die of hunger in the time of famine prophesied by Saturn. Churchyard’s poem is in hexameter couplets with internal alliteration by half line; it thus makes use of Langland’s own poetic form but modified for a sixteenth-century audience that would expect rhymed verse. Given these generic similarities, and the invocation of Langland’s poem, it seems reasonable to consider Churchyard’s poem among the sixteenth-century Plowman texts. Dauy Dycars Dreame looks forward to a future time of just social relations in a series of “when. . .” clauses, including some clauses that echo both the concerns and some of the characters of Langland’s poem. Such an idealized society will occur in a time When Justice ioynes to truth, and law lookes not to meede, & bribes help not to build fair bowres, nor gifts gret gloto[n]s fede.104
The social vision contained in Dauy Dycars Dreame can certainly be understood without reference to Langland’s poem, but these lines would have additional resonance for reader who was familiar with the depiction in Piers Plowman of Meed’s appearance before the King as well as Langland’s overall portrait of a society striving toward a perfection it had not yet reached. Whether or not readers all recognized the allusions to Piers Plowman in Dauy Dycars Dreame, the intertextuality locates the fundamentally ephemeral text of a broadside within a long-standing literary tradition. In a commendatory verse published with Skelton’s works in 1568, Churchyard invokes that medieval tradition directly: Peers plowman was full plaine, And Chausers spreet was great.105
As Poet Laureate, Skelton was the heir to both Chaucer and Langland, poets characterized by Churchyard in terms of their direct satire (plain speaking) and poetic inspiration (great spirit). By the time of the 1568 publication of the Pithy pleasaunt and profitable workes of maister Skelton, readers could know of plainspoken Piers Plowman either through Crowley’s or Rogers’s editions of Piers Plowman or through any number of treatises that invoke Piers Plowman’s name in support of a political or theological cause. The sixteenth-century reception of Piers Plowman (the
A PROLIFERATION OF PLOWMEN
71
poem) intersects with, but is not identical to, the reception of Piers Plowman (the character). In addition to the several known incarnations of Piers Plowman in polemics dating from the 1530s to the end of the sixteenth century, at least one such figure has been lost to modern scholarship. Andrew Maunsell’s 1595 Catalogue of English Printed Bookes cites: The Plowmans complaint of sundry wicked liuers, and especially of the bad bringinge vp of children: written in verse by R. B., prin. for Hugh Corne. 1580. in 8.106
The 1926 edition of the STC records a unique copy of this work in the collection of William Jaggard (STC 1061). By the time the 1976 revised edition of the STC was published, Jaggard’s collection had been dispersed. This item from Jaggard’s collection is now untraced, although presumably it still exists. The revised edition of the STC cites the entry of this work in the Stationers’ Register on May 31, 1580.107 The 1580 date would make the Plowman’s Complaint one of the later uses of Plowman in the literature of social critique. Given Maunsell’s inclusion of the Plowman’s Complaint in his Catalogue of theological works, the “bad bringing vp of children” referred to in the title might concern their religious education, or perhaps the failure of parents who are “wicked liuers” to discipline their children properly. In Langland’s poem, Piers’s family is seen only briefly. His wife is Dame Werch-whan-tyme is; his daughter is Do-ri{tso-or-Qi-dame-shal-Qee-bete; and his son is Suffre-Qi-Souereyns-tohauen-hir-wille-Deme-hem-no{t-for-if-Qow-doost-Qow-shalt-it-deereabugge-Lat-god-yworQe-wiQ-al-for-so-his-word-techeQ. The hortatory names of Piers’s family suggest that part of Piers’s role as the virtuous lay Christian is to act as the head of an orderly household.108 As I Playne Piers argues, an orderly household, in which a scripture-reading patriarch fulfills his roles as “syr,” “father,” and “sheperd,” is fundamental to a well-ordered society.109 The plowman’s usual sixteenth-century role was as a voice of dissent and an advocate of both political and theological reformation; this identity was relatively constant, but texts occasionally used the plowman figure for more conservative causes. The mid-sixteenth-century text of The Bankett of Johan the Reve, Unto Piers Ploughman in British Museum MS Harley 27 was never printed, but it has received some critical attention for its use of the Piers Plowman in a text defending the doctrine of transubstantiation.110 In the 1510 Lytell geste how the plowman lerned his pater noster, the plowman is a successful husbandman but a fool.111 The first thirty-one lines of the poem are descriptions of his agricultural skills and the riches he has earned, but
72
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
when he is being shriven during Lent, and the priest asks him to say his Pater noster, he not only cannot say the prayer but has never heard of it. The priest tricks him into learning the prayer by having the greedy plowman memorize the names of a series of poor men who borrow grain from him, but the plowman is angry at losing his grain rather than grateful for learning the prayer. Rather than being a spokesperson for the simple but honest piety of the laity, the plowman of the Lytell geste is greedy and wrathful, and the priest’s trickery is not presented as a fault, although one could fault him for his earlier laxity in not ensuring the plowman’s religious education. Despite these essentially pro-clerical uses of the plowman figure in the sixteenth century, the plowman’s reformist identity was well known, and was almost entirely consistent, by the second half of the sixteenth century. The literary role of Piers Plowman as social critic began to dissipate toward the end of the sixteenth century. Although there are vestiges of this social identity still in the 1579 Newes from the North. Otherwise called the Conference betvveen Simon Certain and Pierce Plowman, that role for Piers is considerably more moderate than in earlier tracts that bear his name. In its structure, Newes from the North is more Chaucerian than Langlandian. The narrator stops at a Yorkshire inn while journeying from Edinburgh to London, and he enters into a discussion and tale-telling contest with the innkeeper, Simon Certain, and his neighbor Pierce Plowman. Although the three do discuss social ills (among other topics), Pierce is not singled out as the voice of complaint. Moreover, despite the rustic setting (in the small city of Ripon), Pierce’s agricultural profession is not heavily emphasized in the text. In fact, when he enters the narrative, he is coming to ask Sim Certain for a loan, as he has just returned from London where he spent so much money on books that he cannot afford to buy seed.112 This is hardly Langland’s virtuous and hardworking plowman, insistent on plowing his half acre, nor is it the angry social critic of I Playne Piers or Pyers Plowmans exhortation. By the end of the sixteenth century, the figure of the plowman who spoke boldly against social abuses was familiar (and perhaps stale) enough to be available for parody in the anonymous Cobler of Caunterburie (1590).113 The Cobler of Caunterburie was a response to a volume published earlier that year: Tarltons Newes out of Purgatorie, which claims on its title page to be by “Robin Goodfellow,” the name of a fairy in early modern England, and thus obviously a pseudonym. As a trickster himself, Robin Goodfellow is, as the title page of Tarltons Newes claims, an “old Companion” of Richard Tarlton, the well-known and recently deceased theatrical clown. In Tarltons Newes, the narrator dreams he encounters Tarlton’s ghost, who describes purgatory and tells a series of stories (largely from the Decameron)
A PROLIFERATION OF PLOWMEN
73
about the people in purgatory and how they got there. The ghost’s narrative within the dream is a kind of jest Purgatorio, but in Protestant Elizabethan England (unlike Dante’s pre-Reformation Italy), the invocation of purgatory would mark the book as operating outside of the realm of current theology.114 There are two prefatory epistles printed with The Cobler of Caunterburie. In the first, the Cobler addresses his “Gentlemen Readers” and begs their pardon for taking on the identity of a literary critic, a role above his station. This letter is followed on the next leaf by one ostensibly by “Robin Goodfellow.” In the second letter, Robin Goodfellow, the supposed author of Tarltons Newes is allowed to have his say about the fact that the Cobler presumes to critique his work. The author of the Cobler here stages an epistolary confrontation between two fictional speaking voices about the propriety of the Cobler’s response to Tarltons Newes. Both of the letters depend on the notion that it is somehow inappropriate for the Cobler to undertake such a task, not because Tarltons Newes is beyond reproach, but because the Cobler is overreaching in writing his response. Robin Goodfellow’s attack on the Cobler begins: A Cobler become a Corrector? Ho, Ho, Ho: it was not so when Robin Goodfellow was a Ruffler, and helpt the countrie wenches to grinde their Mault: Then gentlemen, the Ploughswaine medled with his Teame: the Gentleman with his Hound & his Hawke: the Artificer with his labour: & the Scholler with his booke: euery degree contented him within his limits. But now the world is growne to that passe, that Pierce Plow man will prie into lawe, naie into Diuinitie, and his duncerie must needs be doctrine: tush, what of higher powers? what of Vniversities?115
“Robin Goodfellow’s” letter is of course doubly ironic: it was actually written by the author of the work it seemingly critiques, and it speaks on behalf of social order in the guise of a fairy known for his imposition of disorder.116 Moreover, the address to “gentlemen,” aristocrats depicted as hunting and hawking, implicitly allies Robin not only with his social betters but with a field of leisure pursuits far distant from the literary marketplace. Like the mid-century Plowman texts, this letter looks back to a lost social order, but it does so playfully. Helping “countrie wenches” with household tasks like grinding malt was one of Robin Goodfellow’s proverbial activities, but so was playing tricks on them, a fact conspicuously omitted here. Robin’s history of a lost golden age calls attention to the fact that this letter presents rather slanted vision of the past. Among the social groups Robin lists, he singles out the “Ploughswaine” for particular attention. In this ironic lament, Piers is no longer content to pursue only agricultural
74
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
labor; he also presumes to speak his “duncerie” on theological and legal issues. In fact, within the memory of the readers of the 1590 Cobler of Caunterburie, “Pierce Plow man” never refrained from “prie[ing] into lawe. . .[and] Diuinitie.” Prying into law and divinity was the hallmark of Piers Plowman’s social identity in the sixteenth century. Understanding “Robin Goodfellow’s” letter requires knowing (as a reader in 1590 would) that there was no such thing as a literary plowman who only tilled the soil, leaving theology to scholars in “Vniversities,” and governance to gentlemen and “higher powers.” From the early part of the sixteenth century on, Piers the Plowman came to be a standard character in the discourse of literary complaint, and his plainspoken style influenced other pseudonymous critics of the social order, such as Martin Marprelate. By the end of the century, he was familiar enough as a social critic that he could appear ironically in a mock paean to “the good old days” when plowmen were plowmen. In 1579, Edmund Spenser sent forth his Shepheardes Calendar, cautioning his work: “Dare not to match thy pype with Tityrus his style,/ Nor with the Pilgrim that the Ploughman playde awhyle.”117 Spenser may here be referring to Chaucer (Tityrus) as the supposed author of the Plowman’s Tale, or he may be referring to Piers Plowman through his knowledge of the Plowman’s Tale. In either case, the identity of the “Ploughman” is presented as a disguise, a fiction that could be “playde awhyle” by an author. Piers’s marginal role authorized his speech in the polemics of the earlier sixteenth century, but his identity as a rural laborer is here cast as a mere literary device. In her study of seventeenth-century echoes of Piers Plowman, Barbara Johnson demonstrates that the figure of Piers Plowman maintains his former role of social critic in ballad and broadside literature through the seventeenth century.118 Nevertheless, Piers Plowman’s status in the literary culture diminished during Elizabeth’s reign, when new literary standards minimized the importance of the native literary tradition in favor of a courtly, smooth style.119 For two centuries, Piers Plowman appeared regularly in the literature of social and religious protest, but when literary theory began to emphasize continental rather than native models, this long familiar figure began to fade from the literary record. The impetus toward writing or preserving literary history is not ideologically neutral, nor does it occur in a vacuum. For the antiquarians of the English Reformation, looking to the past held special promise as well as special anxiety. In the light of Henry’s radical break from Rome, the English past loomed as a potential rebuke, as the Protestants had repudiated a part of that history. However, it also offered the potential for exculpatory narratives, explaining away the seeming violence of the Reformation as,
A PROLIFERATION OF PLOWMEN
75
indeed, a re-formation, a return to what once had been. The desire to re-form not only the nation’s religion but its own sense of its history (including its literary history) motivated much of the antiquarian work of the mid-sixteenth century. The reception of Piers Plowman played no small part in the reinterpretation of England’s religious past as proto-Protestant rather than (more accurately, but less usefully) Catholic. It is an interesting phenomenon of literary history that Piers Plowman figures appeared in print long before Langland’s Piers Plowman itself. There seems to have been no perceived market for a printed edition of Piers Plowman in the late fifteenth century, either because of or despite the number of manuscript copies in circulation. In addition to the number of copies from the early and mid-fifteenth century (the majority of extant manuscripts), four of the nineteen A text manuscripts were copied in the late fifteenth century.120 John Bowers has speculated that the principal audience for Caxton’s press was relatively conservative in their political viewpoint, and that this group’s reading tastes dictated the output of the early English press.121 This might explain why Langland’s poem, which seems from manuscript evidence to have maintained some level of readership, was not printed for almost a century after the arrival of print technology in England. Despite the lack of a printed edition until the middle of the sixteenth century, both Piers Plowman and Piers Plowman had acquired a substantial following by the second half of the sixteenth century. When Crowley edited the text in 1550, it must have found an immediate audience to require two further editions within the year. Crowley seems to have anticipated also that some would desire the book in a more deluxe copy, as some copies of the first edition were printed on vellum, a practice extremely uncommon by this time.122 Oddly, the paper copies of this same edition were, as R. Carter Hailey has discovered, printed on at least twenty-four different stocks of paper, presumably print shop remnants.123 Perhaps this edition was, as Hailey speculates, underfinanced, or perhaps Crowley expanded the run during production to adjust for demand. In either case, Crowley clearly envisioned a market for Piers Plowman of which some subset would be willing to pay a premium for their copies. Crowley’s multiple editions of Piers Plowman demonstrate that Langland’s fourteenth-century poem was valuable to its sixteenth-century readers and editors, and the several appearances of the poem’s title character in Protestant polemic show that Piers himself was also valuable, independent of Langland’s work. As Piers Plowman, a character who appears relatively little in Piers Plowman, becomes a frequent speaker of sixteenth-century
76
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
polemic, Piers comes to have his own “authority function” separate from Langland’s author-function. Eventually Langland displaces Piers as the poem’s center of authority, but, for at least a half century, the author and his character mirror one another as authorizing predecessors invoked by sixteenth-century Protestant writers.
CHAPTER 3 LANGLAND ANTHOLOGIZED
t the end of the sixteenth century, a potential reader could have found Piers Plowman in a relatively recent edition, either one by Robert Crowley (1550) or that by Owen Rogers (1561). After the Rogers edition of 1561, there were no new editions of the poem for well over a century. Someone wishing to read the poem at the end of the seventeenth century would have had to acquire and use a copy over a century old. Piers Plowman was not the only medieval work relatively inaccessible for late-seventeenthand early-eighteenth-century readers. None of John Lydgate’s actual works were published from 1559 through the seventeenth century, although in 1784 an edition of the fifteenth-century satire London Lyckpenny was printed under Lydgate’s name. John Gower’s Confessio Amantis was published three times in the sixteenth century but not at all in the seventeenth century.1 The one medieval English author whose works remained relatively accessible well into the eighteenth century (whether through editions of the works themselves or through allusions and borrowings) was Chaucer. Thomas Speght’s 1602 edition of Chaucer’s Works had been republished in 1687, and the works would be newly edited in 1721 as well. Although three editions in 120 years is hardly a glut, it does seem that Chaucer’s works retained some currency. One index of Chaucer’s place in the sixteenth- and seventeenth-century understanding of English literary history is the range of allusion to or adaptation of his works by later writers. Tim William Machan notes that “[i]n the years 1558–1625 thirteen plays based on Chaucer’s works were composed, and in 1630 a Chaucer adaptation entitled The Tinker of Turvey was published, which offers six tales told on a barge trip down the Thames from Billingsgate to Gravesend.”2 Chaucer’s works remained relatively well known into the eighteenth century, as the number of eighteenth-century Chaucer modernizations made in this period attest. Some of these were published; others seem to have been private exercises.3 Chaucer was clearly the medieval author
A
78
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
whose works were most widely read (and most widely available) into the eighteenth century. Although complete editions of medieval authors’ works, other than those of Chaucer, were becoming relatively scarce, readers of earlier English literature had access to medieval literature in a new kind of book in the eighteenth century: the historical anthology of literary excerpts. This was the primary format in which eighteenth-century readers had access to Piers Plowman and to other non-Chaucerian works of medieval literature. As I use the term in this chapter, historical anthologies combine a discussion of the chronological history of literature (specifically English literature in these cases) with some amount of information on the authors themselves. The new publishing format of the historical anthology implicitly posed a new identity for medieval literature, including Piers Plowman. Although serious antiquarians might still refer to manuscripts or earlier printed editions of medieval texts in their entirety, historical anthologies offered the history of English literature to nonspecialist readers, broadening the access to medieval literature and also allowing for the inclusion of a richer variety of works than had been previously available to nonspecialists. Historical anthologies made literary history part of the common property of polite society.4 As a new genre, the historical anthology drew on elements of three extant genres: sequential biography, poetic miscellany, and literary historical narrative. Chapter 1 discussed John Bale’s collection of author biographies. The writers Bale lists include theologians as well as authors of verse or other more narrowly literary forms. A century after Bale’s collections, William Winstanley’s England’s Worthies (1660) gathered the “Select Lives of the most Eminent Persons of the English Nation,” including the lives of some poets.5 Winstanley’s collection includes biographical information for both Geoffrey Chaucer and “Sir John Mandevil,” but without including the texts they wrote.6 Thomas Fuller’s History of the Worthies of England, a collection of the lives of English “worthies” contemporary with Winstanley’s, names Robert Langland as a learned writer from Shropshire, but without quoting any of Piers Plowman.7 Fuller’s listing of Langland with writers “Since the Reformation,” because “the Morning-star belongs rather to the Day, then to the Night,” is discussed in detail by Barbara Johnson, as is Fuller’s conclusion that Langland “by Prolepsis [may] be termed a Protestant.”8 Fuller takes his biography of Langland directly from Bale’s Catalogus, and he adds to this a literary analysis of Piers Plowman from John Selden’s 1613 notes on Michael Drayton’s Polyolbion: It is written in a kind of English meeter, which for discovery of the infecting corruptions of those times, I preferre before many of the more seemingly serious Invectives, as well for Invention as Judgement.9
LANGLAND ANTHOLOGIZED
79
Fuller mentions the Prayer and complaint of the Ploughman (Fuller’s spelling) as printed in Foxe’s Actes and Monumentes, arguing that it is also by Langland, given that it was written “of the same subject at the same time, in the same Language.”10 Finally, Fuller notes the literary and religious biases of his Catholic predecessor John Pits: “It’s observable that Pitzæus (generally a perfect Plagiary out of Bale) passeth this Langland over in silence: and why? Because he wrote in oppositum to the Papal Interest.”11 Fuller thus mixes literary criticism into his biographies of the Worthies, expanding the genre of collected biography somewhat, but without entering into the realm of literary anthology. A more specialized collection of (international) literary biographies is Edward Phillips’s Theatrum Poetarum (1675), which gives brief descriptions of “The most Eminent [poets] of all Ages.” Like the collections of Worthies by Fuller and Winstanley, the Theatrum Poetarum does not quote any of their verse.12 William Winstanley’s later Lives of the Most Famous English Poets (1687) is a sequence of biographical notices from Robert of Gloucester in the mid-thirteenth century to Winstanley’s contemporary Sir Roger L’Estrange.13 In the Lives, Winstanley does sometimes include small selections of the authors’ poetry, but his purpose seems to be to celebrate the men themselves rather than to collect their verse. In his entry on Sir Philip Sidney (which runs for eight pages), Winstanley quotes verse memorials to Sidney by seven other authors before including Sidney’s sixline verse on his own death.14 Clearly Winstanley’s interest is more in the writers than in their writings. Literary texts by various authors had long been collected into printed volumes. Since the sixteenth century, readers could find miscellanies of contemporary works but not historical anthologies. From Richard Tottel’s Miscellany (originally titled Songes and Sonettes) of 1557 to Bernard Lintot’s Miscellany (originally titled Miscellaneous Poems and Translations) first published 1712, the miscellany offered booksellers a way to capitalize on a taste for contemporary poetry without dedicating an entire volume to one author. In her study of early modern literary collections, Barbara M. Benedict argues that “[a]lthough anthologies purportedly differ from miscellanies in scope, the forms are not fundamentally different.”15 I would emphasize, however, the distinction between miscellanies and historical anthologies, because the historical scope of the anthologies puts their editors and readers in different roles than the editors and readers of the miscellany.16 Editors of miscellanies (unlike those of historical anthologies) tend to collect the works without added commentary about the forms or content of the verse presented. Miscellanies also tend to highlight the novelty of their poetry as a selling point; miscellany editors sometimes even solicited contributions from readers before publication.17 Historical
80
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
anthologies may continue up to the compiler’s present day; however, they necessarily begin with texts distant from their readers in both language and style. Although, as Benedict notes, the reader of all anthologies, including the historical anthology, is active in selecting readings and in making comparisons among the selections, the editor of the historical anthology is usually more of a controlling or guiding presence in the text than is the miscellany editor. Unlike other verse miscellanies, historical anthologies manifest a narrative of literary history (whether implicit or explicit). In fact, Elizabeth Cooper describes her 1737 anthology as a “Poetical Chronicle.”18 In their interest in historical narrative, the anthologies I will discuss in this chapter therefore derive also from a third generic predecessor, in addition to the miscellany and the sequence of biographies: the literary historical essay. One early example of this genre is the 1707 essay “Of the Old English Poets and Poetry,” which covers poetry until the time of Spenser, particularly that from the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries.19 The essay’s anonymous author does include within the narrative a few poetic excerpts, beginning with four lines from Robert of Gloucester’s twelfth-century verse chronicle, which “by the Help of an Interpreter, one may understand, and not without it.”20 However, because of its brevity, its limited focus, and the small number of poetic extracts included in the essay, I do not consider the essay a historical anthology. Like a number of the anthologies I discuss below, the essay “Of the Old English Poets and Poetry” does include an excerpt from Piers Plowman, about which the essay says, “the English is much mended of what it was in Gloucester’s Days.”21 The lines from Piers Plowman excerpted in the essay are from the confession of Sloth (B.5.386–391, 393–396, 402–410, 414–418, with no indication of the lines omitted in the transcription), but Sloth’s allegorical name is omitted. Instead, the essay identifies the lines as a “Satyr on the Laziness of the Monks.”22 The omission of Sloth’s allegorical name makes the scene more freestanding as a “Satyr” than it is in Langland’s poem. Sloth’s name evokes the other six Deadly Sins, but if this scene is not about Sloth himself, the reader will not miss the other Sins’ confessions, scenes from Piers Plowman which are not included in the essay. In excerpting Piers Plowman, the author of this essay therefore minimizes the reader’s sense that there is (somewhere, if not here) an unincluded rest of the poem. Despite its far-reaching title (“Of the Old English Poets and Poetry”) the essay is particularly concerned with ballads; the quotation from Piers Plowman seems to be included as much for its reference to the “Rimes of Robin Hood and Randal of Chester” as for its other literary merits. The author of this essay was not alone in writing a developmental narrative of early English literature. Around 1732–1733, Reverend Joseph
LANGLAND ANTHOLOGIZED
81
Spence wrote for himself (in French) a history of English poetry, “Quelques Remarques Hist: sur les Poëts Anglois,” a work not published in his own time.23 Although probably unknown by Spence’s contemporaries, the “Remarques” may be of interest to the Langlandian for their positive assessment of Langland (whom Spence dates to the fifteenth century): “Dans le siécle quinziéme, à peine tourveroit on quelqu’un que ai réussi en poësie Angloise: si on excepte l’auteur de Pierce le Laboureur.”24 Spence was Professor of Poetry at Oxford, and perhaps had more reason than most to think of the sweep of literary history; nevertheless, he was hardly unique in the study of literary antiquities. Although it is easy to reduce the eighteenth century to a time of studied literary novelty (and, indeed, of the birth of the novel itself), writers and readers of the period had a notable interest in the history of English poetry. Even Alexander Pope, who mocked the antiquarian Thomas Hearne in the The Dunciad, was himself something of a medievalist, and he presumes that his readers have some background in medieval literature as well. In introducing the satire on Hearne’s pedantry, The Dunciad asks: But who is he, in closet close y-pent, With visage from his shelves with dust besprent? Right well mine eyes arede that myster wight, That wonnes in haulkes and hernes, and H-----he hight. To future ages may thy dulness last, As thou preserv’st the dulness of the past!25
If Hearne resides in “haulkes and hernes,” he imitates Chaucer. In “The Reader to Geoffrey Chaucer,” a verse printed in Speght’s 1598 and 1602 editions of Chaucer’s Works, and in the 1687 reprint, “The Reader” asks Chaucer, “VVHere hast thou dwelt, good Geffrey al this while?” and Chaucer responds, “In haulks, and hernes, God wot, and in exile.”26 Those members of Pope’s audience who had read Chaucer’s works most likely did so in one of these three editions, the three most recently printed, in which case they may also have recognized an allusion to this verse. The phrase “haulkes and hernes” in the verse is itself Chaucerian: the Franklin’s Tale notes the curiosity of young scholars who pursue arcane knowledge “in every halke and every herne.”27 Even beyond Pope’s use of the pseudo-medieval “y-pent” and “besprent,” a certain level of antiquarian knowledge is required to decode his satire at Hearne’s expense.28 As the example of Alexander Pope suggests, Chaucer was the primary beneficiary of the eighteenth-century interest in medieval literature, but Langland was a visible presence alongside Chaucer. Copies of the sixteenthcentury Piers Plowman editions were still in circulation, at least among
82
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
scholars, in the eighteenth century; Arthur Sherbo identifies a handful of eighteenth-century literary critics who owned copies of Piers Plowman, including Pope, who owned a Rogers Piers Plowman edition of 1561.29 Thomas Hearne owned a copy of one of the Crowley editions of the poem as well as a manuscript of the B text, and was lent at least two different manuscripts by other antiquarians.30 A partial concordance to the poem, the work in progress of an unidentified eighteenth-century scholar, survives in Glasgow University Library MS Hunterian 311, as described by Carl James Grindley.31 Thus, there seems to have been a continuing scholarly audience for the full text of Langland’s poem, although the broader popular audience had access to the poem primarily in historical anthologies. These anthologies distanced the poem from the arcane world of antiquarian scholarship, juxtaposing it with later and more familiar works. In the sixteenth century, Piers Plowman and its title character had been important in the political and theological arenas; in eighteenth-century anthologies, Piers Plowman was recontextualized against poetry rather than politics. The development of the historical anthology, as much as the changed religious climate, worked to move Langland more squarely into the narrative of English letters.32 This historical narrative was shaped in particular by a new eighteenth-century notion of periodization that shifted the point of literary origin from classical antiquity to the medieval or Renaissance past, a specifically English (rather than Latin) literary past.33 Jonathan Kramnick has demonstrated the way the discourse of “Ancients” vs. “Moderns” changed during the eighteenth century, such that early English writers (most centrally Chaucer and Shakespeare) moved from the camp of the “Moderns” (postclassical writers) to that of the “Ancients” (those from the distant national past).34 The new conception of vernacular “Ancients” did not entirely displace the older category of “Modern” as distinct from classical, as is evident from the “Modern” Language Association’s inclusion of medieval literary and linguistic studies, but the possibility of understanding medieval English authors as “Ancients” helped to authorize the literary study of their poetry. The first historical anthology of English poetry was Elizabeth Cooper’s The Muses Library, or a Series of English Poetry from the Saxons to the Reign of King Charles II (1737).35 In her anthology, Cooper highlighted the notion of vernacular origins. As the subtitle of Cooper’s anthology indicates, Cooper includes specimens of English poetry going back to its “Saxon” (or, in modern terminology, “Anglo-Saxon”) origin.36 This choice of subject matter has a certain scholarly logic, but it is the logic of thoroughness, not popularity. Cooper’s principle of selection meant that she was to include some authors unfamiliar to her readers. Cooper herself notes the generic novelty of her historical anthology; she says that such a combination
LANGLAND ANTHOLOGIZED
83
of biography and poetic extracts “has never been aim’d at any where else.”37 Eighteenth-century general readers were probably familiar with Chaucer’s name, and many were also familiar with his works, but prior to Cooper’s anthology, most would have very little access to works written in Middle English and no familiarity with anything in Anglo-Saxon. By including in The Muses Library works older and less familiar than Chaucer’s, Cooper implicitly challenges her readers to revise some of their premises about literary merit. In her Preface, Cooper claims that “Those, who read the ensuing Volume with Attention, will be convinc’d that Sense and Genius have been of long-standing in this Island; and ’tis not so much the Fault of our Writers, as the Language itself, that they are not read with Pleasure at this Day.”38 The volume’s chronological arrangement and its inclusion of some little known writers implicitly prove Cooper’s contention of a deeply rooted English poetic ability, despite the “faults” of medieval English itself. For Cooper to begin her anthology as she does, with a verse conveyance putatively by Edward the Confessor, is a bold decision in favor of antiquity over familiarity. This short text in rhyming couplets bestows the keeping of the royal forest onto Randolph Peperking and his heirs. Although the language of the conveyance is certainly comprehensible to a modern reader, it does include some notable archaisms, such as the opening line’s firstperson pronoun and royal title: “Iche Edward Koning.”39 Cooper considers the fact that this legal document was written in verse to be “a Relique of the antient British Druids.”40 The text’s obscurity seems therefore to be part of its claim to inclusion, as it preserves a cultural remnant of the lost British past. After the conveyance, Cooper anthologizes two anonymous texts: a verse legend of the hot springs at Bath and a memorial to King Henry I upon his death. The rest of her inclusions are by named authors, and her contents seem inspired at least in part by Winstanley’s Lives of the Most Famous English Poets. Although she does not include authors who wrote in Latin (as Winstanley does), she does name in passing seven of the Latin authors included in Winstanley’s Lives. Counting authors mentioned as well as included, the authors Cooper cites in The Muses Library after the two anonymous texts are the same as the ones listed in the Lives until Cooper reaches Langland, who does not appear at all in Winstanley’s Lives. Although Cooper’s Preface had already offered a justification for including ancient English works as evidence of long-standing English “Sense and Genius,” she offers a second justification at the beginning of her historical narrative: Philosophers in a Series of Fossils, begin with Nature in her crudest State, and trace her, Step by Step, to the most refin’d.–In this Progress of English
84
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
Poetry we must do the same; and they, who desire to see the Connexion, must bear with the rude Pebble, in order to be better pleas’d with the Ruby, and the Diamond. To set aside the Metaphor, few People suppose there were any Writers of Verse before Chaucer, but, as it appears there were many, ’tis absolutely necessary to give a Specimen from a few of them, both as Curiosities in themselves, and to manifest from what a low and almost contemptible Original, that happy Genius rais’d his Profession at once.41
Cooper here defines her work as a kind of curiosity cabinet for readers. Langland is one of the writers whom Cooper dates before Chaucer, and, despite her praise for Chaucer as elevating English verse, she is actually quite favorable toward Piers Plowman in her commentary. While the conveyance of Edward the Confessor may indeed be included as a “curiosity” and a “rude pebble,” Piers Plowman seems in Cooper’s estimation at least a ruby, if not a diamond. The geological analogy is extended by her use of the word “specimen” for her selections of literary works, rather than “extract,” “quotation,” or another term with a specifically textual connotation. By calling these excerpts “specimens,” Cooper implicitly casts herself as a “natural historian of literature,” and her use of a specifically geological analogy allies her project not only with the scientific study of the past but also with an area of intellectual inquiry that was both novel and controversial in her day. The science of geology originated in the eighteenth century, when writers began to ask questions about various natural phenomena, including the apparently marine fossils found far distant from present oceans. Were these shells that had been deposited in landlocked places by the Great Flood (or by another means), or were they merely stones that happened to look like shells, lusus naturae?42 Cooper’s reference to studying a series of fossils discursively affiliates her project with the nascent science of mineralogy.43 The Muses Library was published within a decade of John Woodward’s encyclopedic and widely read classification of mineral specimens: Fossils of All Kinds Digested into a Method Suitable to their Relation and Affinity (1728).44 Woodward’s work was translated into French, Italian, and German within twenty years of its publication, and its influence and reputation were such that many members of Cooper’s audience would likely have known of it. The reference to fossils is not Cooper’s only scientific allusion. Before his discovery of the comet that would come to bear his name, Edmund Halley was known to his scientific contemporaries for proposing a system to gauge the earth’s antiquity by measuring the salinity of its seas. Halley hypothesized that the seas were originally fresh water, but that they became saline through mineral deposits carried by rivers over time. If one could work out the rate of salination, one could then calculate how long it had
LANGLAND ANTHOLOGIZED
85
taken for the seas to reach their current saltiness.45 Halley proposed that the Royal Society measure the salinity of different bodies of water, so that future natural philosophers could compare those eighteenth-century data to the later salinity and derive the rate of salination, and thus the age of the earth.46 Cooper makes direct reference to this theory (although not to Halley by name) in her Preface, pointing out that to complete the observations necessary to calculate the salination rate would take centuries. In contrast, her literary historical project “to set up a Bulwark between Time, and Merit” is much more immediate: “I flatter my self, that the Success of [my project] need not be quite so far removed; nor is it more Romantick, or less Useful” than Halley’s.47 Cooper’s correlations between earth science and literary studies might seem counterintuitive, but Rhoda Rappaport notes that intellectuals of the early eighteenth century shared “a willingness and ability. . .to deal with a range of subjects—from ancient history to mathematics, from epistemology to anatomy—that inevitably startle the modern specialist.”48 Similarly, Roy Porter observes that the “broadening social interest, and. . .deeper institutional basis for the cultivation of science in Britain” allowed science to spread to previously underrepresented groups by the late eighteenth century.49 Thus, even as a nascent and popular discourse of geology was beginning to bring to a wider public the question of how Britain itself was formed, the new genre of literary anthologies attempt to demonstrate for a popular audience the formation of a native literary tradition. Cooper’s Preface narrates English literary history as linear; it is a story of writers’ successive improvements upon their predecessors’ work, and she begins this story with Piers Plowman. The Preface presents Piers Plowman favorably as a point of literary origin, but unfavorably as a product of an age less refined than Cooper’s own. After quoting a few panegyrics on the arts, she concludes: “But, to wave [sic] any farther Authorities, we need only look back to the Days of Langland, the first English Poet we can meet with, who employ’d his Muse for the Refinement of Manners, and, in the Rudeness of his Lines, we plainly discover the Rudeness of the Age he wrote in.”50 Cooper’s discussion of Langland manifests an eighteenthcentury ambivalence toward the medieval poetic record. Although she does praise Langland, she acknowledges that earlier English poetry is in some sense marred by its production during a less polished age and in a less developed language. The gradual improvement of the English language and letters through time is, for Cooper, the result of a series of improving imitations. She presents literary history as a sequence of progressive and conscious acts of refinement. Although Piers Plowman is not the first of her volume’s inclusions, Cooper calls Langland the “first English Poet,” and he is thus the point
86
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
of origin for these successive improvements. In her description of Piers Plowman, she says ’Tis a Work of great Length, and Labour; of the Allegorick-kind; animated with a rich Imagination, pointed with great Variety of just Satire, and dignify’d with many excellent Lessons of Morality and Virtue: And, to say all in a Word, if I may presume to say so much, Chaucer seems to have this Model in his Eye; and, in his Pardoners Prologue, particularly, has a Feature or two nearly resembling the Speech and Character of Sloth hereafter quoted.51
Cooper does not identify which features she has in mind in identifying the portrait of Sloth as the model for the Pardoner’s prologue, but, by suggesting that Langland not only preceded but inspired Chaucer, she posits a particular role for Piers Plowman in the literary canon. She acknowledges that the sixteenth-century literary theorist George Puttenham had considered Chaucer’s works earlier than Piers Plowman, but she dismisses this chronology; “as [Puttenham] is not so much as acquainted with [Langland’s] Name, there is little Reason to depend on his Authority.”52 The phrase that Cooper uses to describe Chaucer’s inspiration by Langland proposes a very dirrect textual relationship. Chaucer, Cooper says, “seems to have this Model in his Eye.” Cooper here is not claiming a general inspiration or similarity of themes. She seems to imagine Chaucer with a manuscript of Piers Plowman before him as he writes. For Cooper, literary history is a series of poets inspired by but improving on their antecedent texts. Chaucer’s “happy Genius” raised English letters from their previously “low and contemptible” state, but not in a literary vacuum. Cooper’s analysis of Chaucer’s debt to Langland suggests that she understood the later Middle Ages in England to have featured a rich literary culture, itself preceded by the less impressive but still vital literary tradition to which the early verses she includes bear witness. The Muses Library emphasizes not only the linear quality of the English poetic tradition but also the fact that the tradition has existed as long as the nation itself. English literature did not spring full-blown from the forehead of either Chaucer or Shakespeare. Like the array of fossils from “rude pebbles” to precious gems, the literary record is buried deep in the national past. Chaucer is not the only author to have borrowed from Langland, however, according Cooper’s synopsis of English literary history, Milton too had Piers Plowman “in his Eye.” After her quotation of Langland’s description of Sloth (B.5.414–419), Cooper anthologizes the scene in which Kinde sends diseases and death (B.20.80–85, 87–89, 95–101), which she juxtaposes with Milton’s description of the Lazar House in Paradise Lost, book 11, lines 475ff.53 She heads these two quotations: “The Passage, which, I think,
LANGLAND ANTHOLOGIZED
87
seems to have given a Hint to Milton, is as follows.”54 Cooper’s syntax here reveals what is important to her. She does not say: “The following passage gave a hint to Milton,” but “the passage that gave a hint to Milton follows.” Her emphasis is on Langland specifically as a model for Milton. This excerpt from Piers Plowman is noteworthy for its importance in Paradise Lost, and thus in literary history, not for its significance within the narrative development of its own poem. In Cooper’s progressive narrative of English literary history, Langland himself has no poetic model. In justifying her mid-fourteenth-century dating of Piers Plowman, she notes that: “’tis notorious Langland copies his Characters, and Manners from the Age he lived in.”55 She then lists a number of historical (or supposedly historical) references in the poem–for example, the scene where “Conscience reproaches Mede with causing the Death of the King’s Father, which exactly tallies with the Fall of Edward II.”56 She concludes that the set of historical references would place Langland’s writing of Piers Plowman within the reigns of Edward III or Richard II. In Cooper’s literary historiography, English literature is a series of imitations of one’s predecessors. Langland, before whom there were versifiers but no “English Poets,” wrote from life, but had no antecedent vernacular poet from whom to learn his craft. Although she does not use the language of paternity, Cooper implicitly casts Langland in Chaucer’s traditional role as the Father of English Poetry. Cooper laments that Langland’s work is so little known: “Selden, in his Notes on Draiton’s Poly-Olbion, quotes him with Honour; but he is not so much as mention’d either by Philips or Winstanly; though in my Judgment, no Writer, except Chaucer, and Spencer, for many Ages, had more of real Inspiration.”57 Despite Langland’s poetic inspiration, Cooper is not so flattering in her commentary on Langland’s versification. Part of her conviction that Langland was prior to Chaucer derives from what she sees as the faulty and archaic diction of Piers Plowman. She notes that “the worst Writer, after Chaucer, had some regard to Measure, and never neglected Rhymes: Whereas this is greatly defective in both; seldom affording a perfect Verse, and using a Dialect hardly intelligible.”58 Langland’s deficiencies, as Cooper sees them, are due to chronology, not to his poetic inability. Despite this criticism, Cooper’s praise of Piers Plowman is particularly noteworthy, as she seems consciously to have inserted Langland into the narrative of British poetry, from which Winstanley’s had omitted him.59 Cooper’s discussions of Piers Plowman manifest two commonplaces of eighteenth-century medievalism: glorification of the exceptional individual and disparagement of the period as a whole. In the nineteenth century, a reader of medieval literature could look back at an idealized Middle Ages of chivalry and honor, a simpler, and in some ways better, time.60 Readers
88
LANGLAND’S EARLY MODERN IDENTITIES
in the eighteenth century still saw their own age as superior to those that had come before; they had not yet acquired the nineteenth-century nostalgia for the glories of the past. When an eighteenth-century reader praises a particular medieval author or set of authors, that praise effectively removes those few writers from literary history. One mark of a writer’s “genius” is his distance from the rest of his contemporaries.61 It is open to interpretation, then, whether one writer’s production of a landmark work of poetry changes or merely steps out of the trajectory of literary history. Cooper sees literary history as the cumulative product of exceptional individuals: Langland used his poetic skills to critique contemporary society; Chaucer elevated English verse; Milton adapted and improved upon Langland’s model in writing his description of the Lazar House, and so on. Her model implies that a work of literature is important for its influence on later writers more than for its sentiments or moral. Cooper’s contemporary Thomas Hayward took a radically different approach to the history of English poetry. Hayward’s anthology, The British Muse, or a Collection of Thoughts Moral, Natural and Sublime of our English Poets Who Flourished in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries, was published in 1738, one year after the first edition of Cooper’s Muses Library.62 Unlike Cooper, Hayward orders his volume topically, and he collects the sentiments of several writers (some quite brief) under an alphabetical series of headings: Abbeys, Absence, Abstinence, Accident, etc. Under each subject heading, he does arrange the writers chronologically, “to shew the gradual Improvements of our Poetry and Language,” but his interest in poetry is quite different from Cooper’s.63 He does not attempt to explain the works nor to give any information about their authors. Hayward presents for his readers the sentiments available in the history of English poetry, but very little of either the poetry or the history itself. Modern readers might find the organization of Hayward’s collection strange. Although popular florilegia are still published on particular themes (often sentimental themes, such as Love or Motherhood), a modern reader might not see the need for a thematic poetry anthology covering such an encyclopedic set of topics. The type of modern book most similar in arrangement to The British Muse is perhaps a dictionary of quotations, but Hayward justifies his inclusion of excerpts by their beauty not necessarily by their fame. Indeed, he claims to include “beautiful Passages, never before extracted, from Shakespear [sic], Johnson, Beaumont, Fletcher, and above a Hundred more.”64 By contrast, the chronological organization of Cooper’s anthology seems quite natural to modern readers, literary heirs to the English publishing tradition she inaugurates. Hayward and Cooper must have been working on their anthologies at the same time, and they certainly traveled in the same literary circles. The
LANGLAND ANTHOLOGIZED
89
Preface to Hayward’s volume was written by the antiquary William Oldys, who also lent some of his volumes to Elizabeth Cooper to assist her preparation of the (never completed) second volume of The Muses Library.65 The two anthologizers made different choices about how far back in English literary history to begin their selections, however. Oldys’s Preface explains that Hayward limited his excerpts to the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, “[t]hough he had sufficient temptation to have called in auxiliaries of a more ancient date.”66 He resisted temptation because he did not trust modern readers “to relish the wholesome force and native beauties of older times.” Oldys suggests further that modern readers could only learn to value medieval poetry t