LITERARY NEWSMAKERS
for Students
National Advisory Board Susan Allison: Librarian, Lewiston High School, Lewiston, M...
815 downloads
4113 Views
8MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
LITERARY NEWSMAKERS
for Students
National Advisory Board Susan Allison: Librarian, Lewiston High School, Lewiston, Maine. Catherine Bond: Librarian, Conestoga High School, Berwyn, Pennsylvania. Cynthia Carpenter: Librarian, Ocean Springs, Missouri. Nancy Guidry: Reference Librarian, Grace Van Dyke Bird Library, Bakersfield Community College, California.
Ann Kearney: Literacy Volunteer for Broward County Public Schools and Broward County Public Library, Broward County, Florida. Carol Keeler: Upper School Media Specialist, Detroit Country Day School, Beverly Hills, Michigan. Mary Anne Nagler: English Department Chair, Oakland Community College, Southfield, Michigan.
Table of Contents ADVISORS .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . ii
GUEST FOREWORD (by Greg Wilson) . . . . .
ix
INTRODUCTION .
. . . . . . . . . .
xi
. . . . . . .
xv
LITERARY CHRONOLOGY ACKNOWLEDGMENTS . CONTRIBUTORS .
. . . . . . . . xvii
. . . . . . . . . . xxi
THE DA VINCI CODE (by Dan Brown) . . . . . . 1
Author Biography. Plot Summary . . Characters. . . . Themes . . . . . Style . . . . . . Historical Context Critical Overview . Criticism . . . . Sources . . . . . Further Reading. .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
2 2 6 9 10 11 12 14 21 21
. . . . .
22 23 23 28 32 35
HARRY POTTER AND THE ORDER OF THE PHOENIX (by J. K. Rowling) . . . . .
Author Biography. Plot Summary . . Characters. . . . Themes . . . . . Style . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
v
T a b l e
o f
C o n t e n t s
Historical Context. Critical Overview . Criticism . . . . Sources . . . . . Further Reading. .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
35 36 38 44 45
. . . . . . . . . .
46 47 48 49 53 55 56 58 58 65 65
. . . . . . . . . .
66 66 67 71 73 75 76 77 78 84 84
HERE IN HARLEM (by Walter Dean Myers) . . .
Author Biography. Plot Summary . . Characters. . . . Themes . . . . . Style . . . . . . Historical Context. Critical Overview . Criticism . . . . Sources . . . . . Further Reading. .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
KIRA-KIRA (by Cynthia Kadohata). . . . . . .
Author Biography. Plot Summary . . Characters. . . . Themes . . . . . Style . . . . . . Historical Context. Critical Overview . Criticism . . . . Sources . . . . . Further Reading. .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
THE KITE RUNNER (by Khaled Hosseini) . . . .
Author Biography. Plot Summary . . Characters. . . . Themes . . . . . Style . . . . . . Historical Context. Critical Overview . Criticism . . . . Sources . . . . . Further Reading. .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
85 . 86 . 86 . 90 . 93 . 95 . 96 . 97 . 98 104 104
THE LAST JUROR (by John Grisham). . . . . . 106
Author Biography. Plot Summary . . Characters. . . . Themes . . . . . Style . . . . . . Historical Context. Critical Overview . Criticism . . . . Sources . . . . . Further Reading. .
v i
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
106 107 111 115 117 117 119 120 127 127
L i t e r a r y
THE LOVELY BONES (by Alice Sebold). . . . . 128
Author Biography. Plot Summary . . Characters. . . . Themes . . . . . Style . . . . . . Historical Context. Critical Overview . Criticism . . . . Sources . . . . . Further Reading. .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
129 129 133 136 138 139 140 141 148 148
MYSTIC RIVER (by Dennis Lehane) . . . . . . 149
Author Biography. Plot Summary . . Characters. . . . Themes . . . . . Style . . . . . . Historical Context. Critical Overview . Criticism . . . . Sources . . . . . Further Reading. .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
150 151 155 158 160 161 162 162 168 169
NICKEL AND DIMED: ON (NOT) GETTING BY IN AMERICA (by Barbara Ehrenreich). . . . . 170
Author Biography. Plot Summary . . Characters. . . . Themes . . . . . Style . . . . . . Historical Context. Critical Overview . Criticism . . . . Sources . . . . . Further Reading. .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
171 171 175 177 179 181 182 183 190 190
A NORTHERN LIGHT(by Jennifer Donnelly) . . . 191
Author Biography. Plot Summary . . Characters. . . . Themes . . . . . Style . . . . . . Historical Context. Critical Overview . Criticism . . . . Sources . . . . . Further Reading. .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
SEABISCUIT: AN AMERICAN LEGEND (by Laura Hillenbrand) . . . . . . . . .
Author Biography. . . . . . . . . Plot Summary . . . . . . . . . . Characters. . . . . . . . . . . .
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
192 192 196 199 201 201 202 204 210 211
212 213 214 218
V o l u m e
1
T a b l e
Themes . . . . . Style . . . . . . Historical Context. Critical Overview . Criticism . . . . Sources . . . . . Further Reading. .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
THE SECRET LIFE OF BEES (by Sue Monk Kidd) . . . . . . . . . .
Author Biography. Plot Summary . . Characters. . . . Themes . . . . . Style . . . . . . Historical Context. Critical Overview . Criticism . . . . Sources . . . . . Further Reading. .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
221 223 224 225 226 231 231
232 233 233 237 239 241 242 243 244 250 250
THE DARK TOWER VI: SONG OF SUSANNAH (by Stephen King). . . . . . . 251
Author Biography. Plot Summary . . Characters. . . . Themes . . . . . Style . . . . . . Historical Context. Critical Overview . Criticism . . . . Sources . . . . . Further Reading. .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
252 253 257 260 262 263 264 265 268 268
STATE OF FEAR(by Michael Crichton) . . . . . 270
Author Biography. Plot Summary . . Characters. . . . Themes . . . . . Style . . . . . . Historical Context. Critical Overview . Criticism . . . . Sources . . . . . Further Reading. .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
271 271 276 278 280 281 282 283 289 289
Historical Context. Critical Overview . Criticism . . . . Sources . . . . . Further Reading. .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
o f
. . . . .
. . . . .
C o n t e n t s
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
301 302 303 308 308
TRUE HISTORY OF THE KELLY GANG (by Peter Carey) . . . . . . . . 309
Author Biography. Plot Summary . . Characters. . . . Themes . . . . . Style . . . . . . Historical Context. Critical Overview . Criticism . . . . Sources . . . . . Further Reading. .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
310 310 315 319 320 321 322 323 329 329
THE WEDDING (by Nicholas Sparks). . . . . . 330
Author Biography. Plot Summary . . Characters. . . . Themes . . . . . Style . . . . . . Historical Context. Critical Overview . Criticism . . . . Sources . . . . . Further Reading. .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
WILL IN THE WORLD: HOW SHAKESPEARE BECAME SHAKESPEARE (by Stephen Greenblatt) . . . . . . . . .
Author Biography. Plot Summary . . Characters. . . . Themes . . . . . Style . . . . . . Historical Context. Critical Overview . Criticism . . . . Sources . . . . . Further Reading. .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
GLOSSARY OF LITERARY TERMS .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
331 331 335 337 338 340 340 341 348 348
349 350 351 355 358 360 360 362 363 369 369
. . . . 371
TRICKSTER’S CHOICE (by Tamora Pierce) . . . 290
Author Biography. Plot Summary . . Characters. . . . Themes . . . . . Style . . . . . .
L i t e r a r y
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
N e w s m a k e r s
. . . . .
. . . . .
f o r
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
291 291 295 298 300
S t u d e n t s ,
CUMMULATIVE AUTHOR/TITLE INDEX. NATIONALITY/ETHNICITY INDEX. SUBJECT/THEMATIC INDEX.
V o l u m e
1
. . 399
. . . . 401
. . . . . . 403
v i i
Foreword Each volume of the Literary Newsmakers for Students series offers a collection of scholarly entries based on recent literary works—fiction, nonfiction and poetry—that have proven newsworthy. What makes a book newsworthy? There are a number of factors that can bring a book into the public spotlight; this volume covers a wide selection of titles that illustrate the many ways in which a book can become newsworthy. In some cases, the popularity of a title expresses a sort of cultural phenomenon, an idea that seizes the public’s imagination. Sometimes it involves a unique character perspective, such as that offered by Susie Salmon in The Lovely Bones. It might offer a distinctive literary style, like True History of the Kelly Gang does. It might even present a new way of considering widely accepted truths and beliefs, as in The Da Vinci Code. For these books, reading groups and simple word of mouth helped them reach readers who might otherwise never have explored them. Conversely, for a select few authors, the publication of any new book is a cause for public attention; both Stephen King and John Grisham enjoy enough popularity to be regarded as newsmakers, not so much for specific titles as for their overall bodies of literary work. A book might also become newsworthy because of its connections to other forms of media. While the Harry Potter franchise was wildly popular even before the first film adaptation was made, the movies have expanded the
audience for the books; each new Harry Potter book is now considered a mammoth publishing event. Similarly, Mystic River sold well on its initial release in 2001; however, the 2003 release of a Clint Eastwood–directed film adaptation— and its two subsequent Academy Awards—did much to solidify the book’s place in the public consciousness. This is also true of Seabiscuit, which was adapted to film by acclaimed writer/ director Gary Ross in 2003 and earned seven Oscar nominations. Some books are newsworthy because they reflect current events. State of Fear focuses on recent scientific research related to humankind’s effect—or possibly lack of effect—on the global climate. Nickel and Dimed deals with the dramatic rise in minimum-wage and service industry jobs in America over the past decade and explores whether or not a person can truly support herself with such a job. Kite Runner offers a view of life in politically turbulent Afghanistan, describing in particular the harsh Taliban regime that has become infamous for its role in the 9/11 terrorist attacks in the United States. Even when it does not center on current events, literature, by its very nature, captures and defines the time in which it is written. It is intended for an audience contemporary with the author; this means that it is written in a style and structure that the author’s peers can relate to (even if it is meant to reflect another time period), and focuses on themes important to the
i x
F o r e w o r d
reading audience. Descriptions reflect the world as the author and readers see it; metaphors and symbolism occur in a specific cultural context that resonates with the audience and emphasizes their meanings. Of course, the main purpose of literature is generally not to define a culture for study by future generations. Literature is meant to entertain us, enlighten us, expand our perspectives, and even incite discussion and change. This book offers a survey of literary works that span this spectrum. Some, like Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, offer sheer escapist entertainment; others, like Nickel and Dimed, are intended to bring to light issues seldom discussed in the media and public sphere. Though they may achieve their goals through dramatically different methods, all these books are meant to move us in some way. This is why a survey of contemporary works serves as a snapshot of our culture. The themes found here are the very things that move us most. They are the issues that concern us as a society: our cumulative effect on the environment (State
of Fear); our capacity for coping with tragedy, and our desire for justice (The Lovely Bones and Mystic River); our ability to earn a living wage (Nickel and Dimed ); our preservation of cultural and personal history (Here in Harlem and True History of the Kelly Gang); and our desire to find and sustain love with others (The Wedding and The Secret Life of Bees). Literature is indeed a window to the culture in which it is created. Literary Newsmakers for Students offers a broad overview of works that have captured the spirit and imagination of our contemporary society. Indeed, these are titles deemed ‘‘newsworthy’’ because of their ability to resonate with modern readers. By analyzing their structures, themes, and contexts of these literary works, perhaps we can gain a deeper understanding of our contemporary society and what is most important to us. If so, such valuable knowledge might prove every bit as helpful to us now as it would to scholars of future generations, who will undoubtedly look back through decades and centuries to catch a glimpse of us through the window of our literature.
Greg Wilson Wilson is a writer and editor of literary reference and pop culture entertainment articles.
x
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
Introduction PURPOSE OF THE BOOK The purpose of Literary Newsmakers for Students (LNfS) is to provide readers with an overview of contemporary literary works that have captured the public’s attention in recent years. The popularity of these titles commends them to be adopted for classroom study, and these volumes provide literary and critical information that is often limited for newer titles. LNfS gives students easy access to information about these works. Each work is treated with a separate entry. The information covered in each entry includes an introduction to the work and its author; a list of characters, including explanation of a given character’s role in the work as well as discussion about that character’s relationship to other characters in the work; a plot summary, to help readers understand the action and story of the work; an analysis of important themes addressed in the work; an examination of style elements used by the author; and a section on important historical and cultural events that shaped both the author and the work, as well as events that affect the plot or characters. In addition to this material, which helps the readers analyze the work itself, students are also provided with a critical overview that provides information about how the work has been received. Accompanying the critical overview is an excerpt from a previously published critical
essay, as well as an essay commissioned by LNfS specifically for student audiences. For further analysis and enjoyment, a list of media adaptations is also included, as well as reading suggestions for works of fiction and nonfiction on similar themes and topics. Classroom aids include topics for discussion, which include ideas for research papers, and lists of critical sources that provide additional material on the work.
SELECTION CRITERIA The titles for LNfS were selected by surveying numerous sources on teaching literature and analyzing course curricula for various school districts. Input was also solicited from our advisory board, as well as from educators from various areas. Our advisory board members— educational professionals—helped pare down the list for this volume. If a work was not selected for the present volume, it was often noted as a possibility for a future volume. As always, the editor welcomes suggestions for titles to be included in future volumes.
HOW EACH ENTRY IS ORGANIZED Each entry heading includes the author’s name, the title of the work being discussed, and the year
x i
I n t r o d u c t i o n
it was published. The following sections are included in the discussion of each entry: • Introduction: a brief overview of the work which provides information about its publication, its literary standing, any controversies surrounding the work, and major conflicts or themes within the work. • Author Biography: this section includes basic facts about the author’s life, and focuses on events and times in the author’s life that inspired the work in question. • Plot Summary: a factual description of the events that occur within the work. The plot summary is broken down by subheadings, usually by chapter or section. • Characters: an alphabetic listing of major characters in the work. Each character name is followed by a brief to an extensive description of the character’s role in the work, as well as discussion of the character’s actions, relationships, and possible motivations. Characters are listed alphabetically by last name. If a character’s first name is the only one given, the name will appear alphabetically by that name. Variant names are also included for each character. Thus, the full name ‘‘Leigh Teabing’’ would appear in the character section for The Da Vinci Code, and also listed in a separate cross-reference would be Teabing’s other identity in the novel, ‘‘The Teacher.’’ • Themes: a thorough overview of how the major topics, themes, and issues are addressed within the work. Each theme discussed appears in a separate subhead. • Style: this section addresses important style elements of the novel, such as setting, point of view, and narration; important literary devices used, such as imagery, foreshadowing, and symbolism; and, if applicable, genres to which the work might belong, such science fiction, historical, or nonfiction. Literary terms are explained within the entry but can also be found in the Glossary. • Historical Context: this section outlines the social, political, and cultural climate in which the author lived and the work was created. This section may include descriptions of related historical events, pertinent aspects of daily life in the culture, and the artistic and literary sensibilities of the time
x i i
L i t e r a r y
in which the work was written. If the work is a historical one, information regarding the time in which the work is set is also included. Each section is broken down with helpful subheads. • Critical Overview: this section contains background on the critical reputation of the work, such as how it has been received by reviewers, critics, and the general public. Any bannings or controversy surrounding the work is included in this section. Direct quotes from reviews may also be included. • Criticism: an essay commissioned by LNfS that specifically deals with the work and is written specifically for the student audience, as well as excerpts from previously published criticism on the work (if available.) • Sources: an alphabetical list of sources used in compiling the entry, including bibliographic information. • Further Reading: a list of texts that point students towards more in-depth information about topics, themes, or time periods discussed in the works. Bibliographic information is included. In addition, each entry includes the following sections, set apart from the rest of the text as sidebars: • Media Adaptations: a list of important film, television, stage adaptations, audio versions, or other forms of media related to the work. Source information is included. • Topics for Discussion: a list of potential study questions or research topics dealing with the work. This section includes questions related to other disciplines the student may be studying, such as American history, world history, science, math, government, business, geography, economics, psychology, etc. • What Do I Read Next?: a list of titles that might complement the featured work or serve as a contrast to it. This includes works by the same author and others, works of fiction and nonfiction, and works from various genres, cultures, and eras.
OTHER FEATURES LNfS includes ‘‘What Makes a ‘Newsmaker’?’’— a foreword by Greg Wilson, a writer and editor
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
I n t r o d u c t i o n
of literary reference and pop culture entertainment articles. This essay provides an analysis of societal factors that make a piece of literature a ‘‘newsmaker’’ and how Literary Newsmakers for Students can help provide a better understanding of contemporary society through study of these literary works. A Cumulative Author/Title Index lists the authors and titles covered in each volume of the LNfS series. A Cumulative Nationality/Ethnicity Index breaks down the authors and titles covered in each volume of the LNfS series by nationality and ethnicity. A Subject/Theme Index, specific to each volume, provides easy reference for users who may be studying a particular subject or theme rather than a single work. Significant subjects from events to broad themes are included, and the entries pointing to the specific theme discussions in each entry are indicated in boldface. Each entry may have several illustrations, including photos of the author, key elements of the plot, stills from film adaptations, and/or historical photos relating to the setting of the work.
When quoting the specially commissioned essay from LNfS (usually the first piece under the ‘‘Criticism’’ subhead), the following format should be used: Petrusso, Annette. Critical essay on Mystic River. Literary Newsmakers for Students. Ed. XXXXX. Vol. 1. Detroit: Gale, 2006. xxx–xx.
When quoting a journal or newspaper essay that is reprinted in a volume of LNfS, the following form may be used: Byam, Paige, ‘‘Children’s Literature or Adult Classic? The Harry Potter Series and the British Novel Tradition,’’ Topic: The Washington & Jefferson College Review Vol. 54 (Fall 2004), 7–13; excerpted and reprinted in Literary Newsmakers for Students, Vol. 1, Ed. XXX (Detroit: Thomson Gale, 2006), pp. xxx–xx.
When quoting material reprinted from a book that appears in a volume of LNfS, the following form may be used: Magistrale, Anthony, ‘‘The Shape Evil Takes: Hawthorne’s Woods Revisited,’’ in Modern Critical Views: Stephen King, Ed. Harold Bloom, (Chelsea House Publishers, 1998), 77–86; excerpted and reprinted in Literary Newsmakers for Students, Vol. 1, Ed. XXX (Detroit: Thomson Gale, 2006), pp. xxx–xx.
CITING LITERARY NEWSMAKERS FOR STUDENTS When writing papers, student who quote directly from any volume of Literary Newsmakers for Students may use the following general forms. These examples are based on MLA style. Teachers may request that students adhere to a different style, so the following examples may be adapted as needed. When citing text from LNfS that is not attributed to a particular author (i.e., the Themes or Historical Context sections, etc.), the following format should be used in the bibliography section: ‘‘The Da Vinci Code.’’ Literary Newsmakers for Students. Ed. XXX. Vol. 1. Detroit: Thomson Gale, 2006. xxx-xx.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
WE WELCOME YOUR SUGGESTIONS The editorial staff of LNfS welcomes your comments, ideas, and suggestions. Readers who wish to suggest themes and works to appear in future volumes, or who have any other suggestions, are cordially invited to contact the editor. You may do so via email at ForStudentsEditors@thomson. com or via mail at: Editor, Literary Newsmakers for Students Thomson Gale 27500 Drake Road Farmington Hills, MI 48331-3535
V o l u m e
1
x i i i
Literary Chronology 1937 Walter Dean Myers is born on August 12 in Martinsburg, West Virginia.
1965 Dennis Lehane is born on August 4 in Dorchester, Massachusetts.
1941 Barbara Ehrenreich is born on August 26 in Butte, Montana.
1965 Khaled Hosseini is born in Kabul, Afghanistan.
1942 Michael Crichton (John Michael Crichton) is born on October 23 in Chicago, Illinois.
1965 Nicholas Sparks is born on December 31 in Omaha, Nebraska.
1943 Peter Carey is born on May 7 in the town of Bacchus Marsh in the Australian state of Victoria.
1967 Laura Hillenbrand is born in Fairfax, Virginia.
1943 Stephen Greenblatt is born on November 7 in Cambridge, Massachusetts.
2000 Peter Carey’s True History of the Kelly Gang is published.
1947 Stephen King is born on September 21 in Portland, Maine.
2001 Dennis Lehane’s Mystic River is published.
1948 Sue Monk Kidd is born on August 12 in Sylvester, Georgia. 1954 Tamora Pierce is born in South Connellsville, Pennsylvania. 1955 John Grisham is born on February 18 in Jonesboro, Arkansas. 1956 Cynthia Kadohata is born in Evanston, Illinois. 1963 Jennifer Donnelly is born in 1963 in Port Chester, New York.
2001 Barbara Ehrenreich’s Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America is published. 2001 Laura Hillenbrand’s Seabiscuit: An American Legend is published. 2002 Alice Sebold’s The Lovely Bones is published. 2002 Sue Monk Kidd’s The Secret Life of Bees is published. 2003 Jennifer Donnelly’s A Northern Light is published.
1963 Alice Sebold is born in the suburbs surrounding Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
2003 J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix is published.
1964 Dan Brown is born on June 22 in Exeter, New Hampshire.
2003 Dan Brown’s The Da Vinci Code is published.
1965 J. K. Rowling is born on July 31 in Chipping Sodbury near Bristol, England.
2003 Khaled Hosseini’s The Kite Runner is published.
x v
L i t e r a r y
C h r o n o l o g y
2003 Nicholas Sparks’s The Wedding is published. 2003 Tamora Pierce’s Trickster’s Choice is published. 2004 Walter Dean Myers’s Here in Harlem is pub-lished. 2004 Cynthia Kadohata’s Kira-Kira is published. 2004 Michael Crichton’s State of Fear is published.
x v i
L i t e r a r y
2004 Stephen King’s The Dark Tower VI: Song of Susannah is published. 2004 John Grisham’s The Last Juror is published. 2004 Stephen Greenblatt’s Will in the World: How Shakespeare Became Shakespeare is published. 2004 Stephen Greenblatt’s Will in the World: How Shakespeare Became Shakespeare is nominated for the Pulitzer Prize in Biography or Autobiography.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
Acknowledgments The editors wish to thank the copyright holders of the excerpted criticism included in this volume and the permissions managers of many book and magazine publishing companies for assisting us in securing reproduction rights. We are also grateful to the staffs of the Detroit Public Library, the Library of Congress, the University of Detroit Mercy Library, Wayne State University Purdy/ Kresge Library Complex, and the University of Michigan Libraries for making their resources available to us. Following is a list of the copyright holders who have granted us permission to reproduce material in this volume of Literary Newsmakers for Students (LITNM). Every effort has been made to trace copyright, but if omissions have been made, please let us know. COPYRIGHTED MATERIALS IN LITNM, VOLUME 1 WERE REPRODUCED FROM THE FOLLOWING PERIODICALS: Aethlon: The Journal of Sport Literature, v. XIX, fall, 2001 for ‘‘‘Seabiscuit’? Come On . . .’’ by Tim Morris. Reproduced by permission of the publisher and the author.—American Prospect , v. 12, July 30, 2001. Copyright 2001 The American Prospect, Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduced with permission from The American Prospect, 11 Beacon Street, Suite 1120, Boston, MA 02108.—Arthuriana, v. 14, 2004. Reproduced by permission.—Book, v. 52, March, 2001. Copyright Ó 2001 West Egg Communications, LLC. Reproduced by permission.—Boston
Globe, February 2, 2004. Ó Copyright 2004 Globe Newspaper Company. Reproduced by permission.—Brookings Institution, January 28, 2005. Copyright 2005 Brookings Institution. Reproduced by permission.—CBS’s The Early Show, September 15, 2003. Copyright 2003 CBS Worldwide, Inc. All rights reserved. CBS News Transcipts. Reproduced by permission.— Christian Century, v. 120, February 22, 2003. Copyright Ó 2003 by the Christian Century Foundation. All rights reserved. Reproduced by permission.—CNN’s The Biz, September 15, 2003. Copyright 2003 Cable News Network. All rights reserved. Reproduced by permission.— Columbia Journalism Review, v. 42, November/ December, 2003 for ‘‘Class Warrior: Barbara Ehrenreich’s Singular Crusade’’ by Scott Sherman. Ó 2003 Columbia Journalism Review. Reproduced by permission of the publisher and the author.—Dollars & Sense, January 2002. Copyright 2002 Economic Affairs Bureau. Reprinted by permission of Dollars and Sense, a progressive economics magazine <www.dollarsandsense.org>.—Entertainment Weekly, February 13, 2004. Copyright 2004 Time, Inc. Reproduced by permission.—Humanist, v. 61, September, 2001 for a review of ‘‘Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America’’ by Joni Scott. Copyright 2001 American Humanist Association. Reproduced by permission of the author.—Kidsreads.com, February, 2004. All rights reserved. Reproduced by permission of
x v i i
A c k n o w l e d g m e n t s
the Book Report Network.—Lancet, v. 362, September 20, 2003. Ó Copyright 2003 The Lancet Publishing Group, a division of Elsevier Science Ltd. Reprinted with permission from Elsevier.—Meanjin, v. 60, September 1, 2001 for a review of Peter Carey’s ‘‘True History of the Kelly Gang’’ by Andreas Gaile. Copyright 2001 Meanjin Company Ltd. Reproduced by permission of the author.—National Observer, v. 64, autumn, 2005. Reproduced by permission of the publisher.—National Public Radio (NPR), November 17, 2004. Copyright 2004 National Public Radio. All rights reserved. Reproduced by permission.—New York Daily News, November 3, 2004. Ó 2004 New York Daily News, L. P. Reprinted with permission.—New York Post online edition, February 16, 2005. Copyright 2005 NYP Holdings, Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduced by permission.—New York Review of Books, v. 48, March 29, 2001; v. 50, January 16, 2003. Copyright Ó 2001, 2003 by NYREV, Inc. Reprinted with permission from The New York Review of Books. Both reproduced by permission.—New York Times, November 16, 2003. Copyright Ó 2003 by The New York Times Company. Reprinted with permission.—Off Our Backs, v. 35, January & February, 2005. Copyright 2005 Off Our Backs, Inc. Reproduced by permission.—Publishers Weekly, v. 248, January 1, 2001. Copyright Ó 2001 by Reed Publishing USA. Reproduced from Publishers Weekly, published by the Bowker Magazine Group of Cahners Publishing Co., a division of Reed Publishing USA, by permission.—School Library Journal, October, 1993; May 1, 2005. Copyright Ó 1993, 2005. Both reproduced from School Library Journal, a Cahners/R. R. Bowker Publication, by permission.—Spectator, October 9, 2004. Copyright Ó 2004 by The Spectator. Reproduced by permission of The Spectator.— Times Literary Supplement, October 10, 2003. Copyright Ó 2003 by The Times Supplements Limited. Reproduced from The Times Literary Supplement by permission.—Topic: The Washington & Jefferson College Review, v. 54, fall, 2004. Copyright, Washington and Jefferson College 2004. Reproduced by permission.—U.S. Catholic, v. 68, November, 2003. Copyright Ó 2003 by Claretian Publications. Reproduced by permission.—Update, September, 2004. Copyright CILIP 2005. Reproduced by permission.— World Literature Today, v. 78, SeptemberDecember, 2004. Copyright Ó 2004 by World Literature Today. Reproduced by permission.
x v i i i
L i t e r a r y
COPYRIGHTED MATERIALS IN LITNM, VOLUME 1 WERE REPRODUCED FROM THE FOLLOWING BOOKS: From ‘‘Walter Dean Myers,’’ in Writers for Young Adults. Edited by Ted Hipple. Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1997. Copyright Ó 1997 Charles Scribner’s Sons. Reproduced by permission of Thomson Gale. PHOTOGRAPHS AND ILLUSTRATIONS APPEARING IN LITNM, VOLUME 1, WERE RECEIVED FROM THE FOLLOWING SOURCES: ‘‘A Place in the Sun,’’ with Elizabeth Taylor and Montgomery Clift, in a scene from the 1951 film. Paramount/The Kobal Collection. Reproduced by permission.—Afghan soldiers, Kabul, Afghanistan, December 11, 2003, photograph. Ó Ahmad Masood/Reuters/Corbis.— Blackbeard and Maynard dualing, drawing. Ó Bettmann/Corbis.—Brown, Dan, photograph. AP/Wide World Photos.—Carey, Peter, photograph. Ó Marc Asnin/Corbis Saba.—Chicken farm, Santa Cruz, California, 1913, photograph. Santa Cruz Public Libraries.—Crichton, Michael, photograph. Ó Douglas Kirkland/Corbis.—Donnelly, Jennifer, photograph. Ó Jerry Bauer. Reproduced by permission.—East Harlem street, photograph. Ó Corbis.—Ehrenreich, Barbara, photograph. AP/Wide World Photos.—Elk Lake, Adirondack State Park, New York, photograph. Ó James L. Amos/Corbis.—Empty jury box, photograph. Ó Jose Luis Pelaez, Inc./ Corbis.—First Presbyterian Church, 1819, New Bern, North Carolina, photograph. Ó Lee Snider/Corbis.—Globe Theatre, engraving. Ó The Folger Shakespeare Library. Reproduced by permission of the Folger Shakespeare Library.— Grisham, John, photograph. AP/Wide World Photos.—Greenblatt, Stephen, photograph. Ó Rick Friedman/Corbis.—Gunslinger, reenactment of a gunfight, Tombstone, Arizonia, photograph. Ó Richard A. Cooke/Corbis.—‘‘Hamlet,’’ with Kenneth Branagh as Hamlet, photograph. Castle Rock Entertainment. Reproduced by permission of Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc.—‘‘Hamlet,’’ with Laurence Olivier as Hamlet, in a scene from the 1948 film. The Kobal Collection. Reproduced by permission.— ‘‘Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban,’’ with Alan Rickman, Emma Watson, Rupert Grint, and Daniel Radcliffe, photograph. Ó Warner Bros. Pictures/Zuma/Corbis.—Harry Potter fans, Moscow, February 6, 2004, photograph.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
A c k n o w l e d g m e n t s
Ó Sergei Karpukhin/Reuters/Corbis.—Honeycomb, photograph by Edward S. Ross. Copyright Ó by E. S. Ross. Reproduced by permission.—Hosseini, Khaled, photograph. Ó Jerry Bauer. Reproduced by permission.—Icicles on a cabin, photograph. Ó Nik Wheeler/Corbis.— John ‘‘Red’’ Pollard, with racehorse Seabiscuit, 1938, photograph. Hulton Archive/Getty Images.—Kadohata, Cynthia Lynn, photograph. AP/Wide World Photos.—Kadohata, Cynthia, with older sister, 1967, photograph. Courtesy of Cynthia Kadohata.—Kidd, Sue Monk, photograph by Paula Illingworth. AP/Wide World Photos.—King, Stephen, photograph by Mirek Towski. AP/Wide World Photos.—Lagoon and Coral Atoll, Tetiaroa, French Polynesia. Ó Douglas Peebles/Corbis.—Lehane, Dennis, photograph. Ó Jerry Bauer. Reproduced by permission.—Myers, Walter Dean, photograph by David Godlis. Reproduced by permission of Walter Dean Myers.—‘‘Mystic River’’ director Clint Eastwood, with Sean Penn and Tim Robbins, both stars of the film, photograph by Kevork Djansezian. AP/Wide World Photos.— ‘‘Ned Kelly,’’ with Laurence Kinlan, Philip Barantini, Heath Ledger, and Orlando Bloom, in a scene from the 2003 film. Australian Film Commis-sion/Working Title/The Kobal Collection/Johns, Carolyn. Reproduced by permission.—‘‘Nickel and Dimed,’’ with Robynn Rodriguez as Barbara and Sarah Agnew as Holly, in the 2003 Guthrie Theater production, Minneapolis, MN, photograph by Michal Daniel. Ó Michal Daniel.—‘‘Nickel and Dimed,’’ with Robynn Rodriguez as Barbara, in the 2003 Guthrie Theater production, Minneapolis, MN,
photograph by Michal Daniel. Ó Michal Daniel.—Oil barges sit docked on the Chelsea, Massachusetts, side of the Mystic River, photograph. Neal Hamberg/Bloomberg News/ Landov.—Our Lady of Czestochowa (Black Madonna), ca. 1434, lime-wood painting. Ó Nicolas Sapieha/Art Resource, NY.—Reward poster for Edward Kelly, Daniel Kelly, Stephen Hart and Joseph Byrne, photograph. Mitchell Library, Sydney.—Richelieu Pavilion and Glass Pyramid of the Louvre, Paris, France, photograph. Ó Owen Franken/Corbis.—Rosslyn Chapel, carved interior roof, Roslin, Scotland, photograph. Christopher Furlong/Getty Images.—Rowling, J. K., arrives at the premiere of ‘‘Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban,’’ Odeon Leicester Square, London, May 30, 2004, photograph. Ó David Bebber/Reuters/Corbis.— ‘‘Seabiscuit,’’ with Chris McCarron and Tobey Maguire, in a scence from the 2003 film. Universal/The Kobal Collection. Reproduced by permission.—Sebold, Alice, photograph by Jim Cooper. AP/Wide World Photos.—Shakespeare, William, illustration. The Library of Congress.— Smoky Factory, photograph. Ó Royalty-Free/ Corbis.—Snow covering a field of corn stubble, photograph. Ó Richard Hamilton Smith/ Corbis.—Sparks, Nicholas, photograph. Ó by Jerry Bauer. Reproduced by permission.—Swan floating, photograph by Robert J. Huffman. Field Mark Publications. Reproduced by permission.—The Cotton Club, ca. 1932, photograph. Frank Driggs Collection/Getty Images.—‘‘The Last Supper,’’ ca. 1495-1498, fresco by Leonardo da Vinci. The Granger Collection, New York. Reproduced by permission.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
x i x
Contributors Margaret Brantley: Brantley is a writer and editor of literary reference and academic subject texts. Original essay on The Last Juror.
Dark Tower VI: Song of Susannah. Original essay on The Dark Tower VI: Song of Susannah.
Charles Brower: Brower is an editor and freelance writer. Entry on The Secret Life of Bees. Original essay on The Secret Life of Bees.
Harry Harris: Harry Harris is an English instructor at The Ohio State University. Entry on Trickster’s Choice. Original essay on Trickster’s Choice.
Catherine Cucinella: Catherine Cucinella, a freelance writer, has edited a reference volume on contemporary American poets and has published articles on poetry and film. She has a Ph.D. in English from the University of California, Riverside. Entry on The Lovely Bones. Original essay on The Lovely Bones. Cynthia Clough: Cynthia Clough has a PhD in English, specializing in the novel, from Florida State University. Entry on A Northern Light. Original essay on A Northern Light. Margarette Connor: Connor holds a Ph.D. in English and teaches English courses online at Webster University in Geneva, Switzerland, and Fu Jen Catholic University in Taiwan. Entry on The Last Juror. Kathleen Helal: Dr. Helal has taught courses on writing and English literature for several years and has presented and published many papers and articles on women’s writing. Entry on The Da Vinci Code. Original essay on The Da Vinci Code. Gordon Theisen: Gordon Theisen is a freelance writer with a Ph.D. in English literature from Binghamton University. Entry on The
Laura Issen: Issen is a high school English teacher as well as a college instructor of rhetoric and composition. Entry on The Wedding. Original essay on The Wedding. Michael Kelsay: Kelsay is a novelist and instructor of English composition. Entry on True History of the Kelly Gang. Original essay on True History of the Kelly Gang. Maria Elena Caballero-Robb: Maria Elena Caballero-Robb earned her Ph.D. in American Literature from the University of California, Santa Cruz. She works in publishing and teaches courses in U.S. literature and culture and composition. Entry on The Kite Runner. Original essay on The Kite Runner. Peter Menard: Menard teaches comparative literature. Entry on Kira-Kira. Original essay on Kira-Kira. Ray Mescallado: Mescallado has studied literature and pop culture, writing extensively on these topics for academic and popular venues. Entry on Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America. Original essay on Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America.
x x i
C o n t r i b u t o r s
Andrew Newman: Newman teaches in the English Department of the State University of New York at Stony Brook. Entry on Will in the World: How Shakespeare Became Shakespeare. Original essay on Will in the World: How Shakespeare Became Shakespeare.
Laura Baker Shearer: Shearer holds a Ph.D. in American literature and works as an English professor and freelance writer. Entry on Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix. Original essay on Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix.
A. Petruso: Petruso is a freelance writer and editor, with an undergraduate degree in history and master’s degree in screenwriting. Entry on Mystic River. Original essay on Mystic River.
Sonny Williams: Williams is a doctoral candidate in English at the University of Texas at Dallas, as well as a poet and fiction writer. Original entry on State of Fear.
x x i i
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
The Da Vinci Code The Da Vinci Code became one of the first notable international literary events of the twenty-first century as soon as it was published in early 2003. It is a fast-paced thriller involving Harvard professor of religious symbology Robert Langdon, who must solve a murder mystery before he is arrested for the murder himself. While the plot moves along rapidly, the narrative and dialogue slow down briefly at times to explore weighty issues and consider controversial questions. Was Jesus married to Mary Magdalene? Did early Christian leaders attempt to suppress her significance? Did Constantine the Great and the Council of Nicaea establish the divinity of Jesus Christ in 325 A . D .? Was Leonardo da Vinci one of the ‘‘keepers of the secret of the Holy Grail,’’ as Leigh Teabing, the historian scholar, declares? Did he encode his art with symbols that suggested a Christian history far different from the one with which we are familiar? Though fictional characters raise these questions, Brown, in interviews about his novel, generated much debate by defending the possibility that Christian history has been carefully and artificially constructed. When asked in an interview what he would change if he were writing the book as nonfiction rather than fiction, for example, Brown replied he would change nothing.
DAN BROWN 2003
Religious leaders, Christian scholars, historians, and media figures reacted strongly to Brown’s novel. In 2004, it was banned from
1
T h e
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
Lebanon when Catholic leaders protested against its content. In 2005, Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone publicly responded to the claims of the novel, which he called ‘‘a castle of lies.’’ A series of reactionary books bent on disproving the novel’s theories emerged, and documentaries exploring the controversies it brings out were aired on networks from ABC to the History Channel. As of 2005, Columbia Pictures was developing the film adaptation, directed by Ron Howard and starring Tom Hanks, Audrey Tautou, and Ian McKellen, to be released in 2006.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY Dan Brown was born on June 22, 1964 in Exeter, New Hampshire. His mother was a professional musician who specialized in sacred works, and his father, Richard Brown, was a Presidential Award–winning math teacher at Phillips Exeter Academy. After attending Exeter himself and graduating in 1982, Brown went to Amherst College, where he received a bachelor’s degree in English Literature in 1986. He returned to teach at Phillips as an English instructor. While teaching in 1996, Brown began generating ideas for his first novel when he learned that the U.S. Secret Service had detained one of his students for composing an e-mail message that appeared to threaten the president of the United States. The novel, titled Digital Fortress (1998), explores the tension between privacy and national security. His second novel, Angels and Demons (2000), introduces a character that would become the hero of his future works, Harvard symbologist Robert Langdon, and concerns the Illuminati, a secret society that plots to bomb the Vatican. Deception Point (2001), his third novel, is a political thriller that begins with the NASA discovery of a meteor believed to verify the existence of extraterrestrial life. If Brown’s first three novels moderately interested reviewers and readers, his fourth novel, The Da Vinci Code, a thriller exploring the possibility of a radically alternative Christian history, made him a worldwide celebrity. In fact, Brown became as famous for the controversies he incites in this novel about Christian history, Arthurian legend, and Leonardo da Vinci as he was for the number of novels he sold. During the two years after its release in early 2003, The Da Vinci Code sold an estimated twenty-five million
2
L i t e r a r y
Dan Brown AP/Wide World Photos
copies worldwide in forty-four languages in its hardcover edition. In 2005, Brown was named one of the ‘‘world’s 100 most influential people’’ in a special issue of Time magazine. In that feature, Michele Orecklin dubbed The Da Vinci Code ‘‘The Novel That Ate The World’’ and noted that the Bible was one of the few books to sell more copies since the debut of Brown’s novel at the top of the New York Times bestseller list. The novel was named Britain’s Book of the Year at the British Book Awards in London in 2005. Accepting the award via telecast from his home in New Hampshire, Brown was already at work on his next highly anticipated novel, The Solomon Key, a sequel to The Da Vinci Code set in Washington, D.C. with Robert Langdon investigating the secret world of the Freemasons. As of 2005, Brown was living in New Hampshire with his wife, Blythe.
PLOT SUMMARY Fact The Da Vinci Code begins with a page titled ‘‘Fact,’’ a term that sets the stage for the novel’s notoriety. The three brief paragraphs that follow are carefully phrased assertions: there is a secret
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
society called the Priory of Sion to which figures from Sir Isaac Newton to Leonardo da Vinci may have belonged; an organization affiliated with the Vatican called Opus Dei has been accused of using cultish techniques to attract and keep members and has just spent $47 million building its headquarters in New York City; and finally, ‘‘all descriptions of artwork, architecture, documents, and secret rituals in this novel are accurate.’’
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
Bishop Aringarosa has requested a special tour of her church for one of his numeraries.
Chapters 10–25
The first nine chapters introduce all the major characters that the narrative will follow to the novel’s conclusion just a few hours later. Harvard professor Robert Langdon, who was to meet Saunie`re that night, is summoned to the Louvre to help French detective Bazu Fache interpret the strange series of clues at the crime scene. The narrative interrupts their meeting to introduce two other characters: Silas, the murderer, and Bishop Manuel Aringarosa, presidentgeneral of Opus Dei, both of whom are acting under orders from a character known only as the Teacher. Back at the crime scene, Langdon learns that Saunie`re has drawn a series of images and cryptic messages not only with his own blood but also with a watermark stylus, a pen whose markings can only be detected by black light. Fache’s colleague Lieutenant Collet listens intently from a concealed room to the conversation between Fache and Langdon, the primary suspect. Cryptologist Sophie Neveu arrives at the crime scene with a message for Langdon to contact the U.S. Embassy immediately. When Langdon retrieves the message with Fache’s cell phone under Sophie’s directions, he hears a message from Sophie herself to listen carefully because he is in grave danger. Meanwhile, Sister Sandrine Bieil, caretaker of the Church of Saint-Sulpice, is notified that
Silas visits the Church of Saint-Sulpice, possessing what he believes to be Saunie`re’s great secret, the location of a keystone that leads to the Holy Grail. A narrative flashback shows his tortured past as a victim of abuse. Back at the Louvre, Sophie departs quickly after declaring that one of Saunie`re’s clues is a numeric joke. Langdon requests a few minutes alone in the restroom, pretending that he has received devastating news of an accident back home. Fache grants his request, and joins Collet in his concealed office. Sophie meets Langdon in the restroom and alerts him that he is Fache’s primary suspect, and that Fache is tracking him with a small device he has slipped into his pocket. She helps him stage his escape by lodging the device into a bar of soap and hurling it out the window. The device falls onto a truck, and Fache and Collet watch their monitor in horror, believing that Langdon has jumped from the window. They conclude that because it looks as though he has escaped, he is indeed guilty. The device leads Fache and Collet on what they believe to be a wild chase after Langdon through the streets of Paris. Back in the restroom, Sophie tells Langdon that Saunie`re is her grandfather, and that he raised her after her family died in a car accident. She also shows him a copy of the crime scene Fache sent out to agents at the Central Directorate Judicial Police. The crime scene in the photo looks slightly different: at the end of Saunie`re’s message is the request, ‘‘P.S. Find Robert Langdon.’’ Sophie concludes that Fache, who seems unnaturally determined to implicate Langdon, erased the last line from Saunie`re’s message. When Langdon asks Sophie if the initials mean anything to her, she remembers a golden key with the same initials she had found once hidden in her grandfather’s room. When she confronted him, Saunie`re had told her the initials refer to her secret name, Princess Sophie. Hearing her describe the key, however, Langdon comes to a different conclusion: the initials stand for a secret society known as the Priory of Sion, and her grandfather was a member. He claims that the Priory, a pagan goddessworship cult, has existed for a thousand years, and has attracted prominent historical figures from Sir Isaac Newton to Leonardo da Vinci. Believing Saunie`re had meant to bring them
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
Prologue The narrative opens with Louvre curator Jacques Saunie`re held at gunpoint by an albino man who demands the location of something extremely valuable. After surrendering the location, which the narrative later reveals is false, Saunie`re is shot and left to die in his museum’s Grand Gallery. Just after his murderer departs, and with only minutes to live, Saunie`re, ‘‘the sole guardian of one of the most powerful secrets ever kept,’’ struggles to somehow communicate the real secret in his own crime scene.
Chapters 1–9
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
3
T h e
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
together, the pair begin a frantic search for the meaning behind the series of clues he left behind.
Chapters 26–39 With Fache and his team across town, Langdon and Sophie are free to further investigate the crime scene. The clues Saunie`re left on and around his body lead them to the Mona Lisa, one of the many da Vinci works allegedly containing secret codes that suggest the Church’s suppression of the sacred feminine. They find another message written with the invisible stylus on the Plexiglas front of the famous painting. The message prompts Langdon to conclude that Saunie`re was a member of the secret Priory of Sion. Interpreting it differently, Sophie finds another clue behind the painting directly across from it, da Vinci’s Madonna of the Rocks: the gold key she remembers finding as a child. At the Church of SaintSulpice, Silas attempts to unearth what he believes to be the keystone, and finds that he has been tricked. Sandrine looks on from a concealed position, and realizes that the members of the Priory have sent a silent alarm for her to warn its leaders, the se´ne´chaux. Silas discovers her frantically attempting to reach them, and when she insults Opus Dei, he murders her in a moment of rage. Langdon and Sophie barely escape Fache’s guards and race to the address Saunie`re has left on the back of their key. On the way, Sophie remembers seeing her grandfather engaged in a ritual that disgusted her so much she ceased communication with him completely, though the details of the ritual are left out of the narrative. Langdon reveals that the main oath of the Priory of Sion is to keep secret the real meaning behind the Holy Grail.
Chapters 40–51 Pursued by the police, Langdon and Sophie reach the Bank of Zurich. They use Saunie`re’s key and a passcode they decipher from a series of numbers he wrote at his crime scene to open his safe. Inside is a device Saunie`re built, using da Vinci’s blueprints, called a cryptex, a cylindrical vessel containing a secret message that can only be opened by a passcode. This cryptex, they believe, is the key to finding the Holy Grail. Meanwhile, Aringarosa visits Castel Gandolfo, the Pope’s summer residence, where he meets members of the Vatican who pay him twenty million euros for a reason not disclosed to the reader. Back at the bank, Langdon and Sophie
4
L i t e r a r y
meet Andre´ Vernet, president of the branch, who helps them escape in a van to avoid negative publicity. Vernet stops the van in a nearby field and attempts to retrieve the cryptex, holding Langdon and Sophie at gunpoint. They outwit him, and escape in his van with the cryptex. Langdon decides they must visit the one person who might be able to help them open it, British Royal Historian Leigh Teabing.
Chapters 52–65 Langdon and Sophie arrive at Teabing’s lavish estate, where they are greeted by Re´my Legaludec, Teabing’s servant, and led into a drawing room. While they wait for Teabing, they decide to hide the cryptex under a divan. When Teabing enters, Langdon explains that they have information about the Priory of Sion, and that he would like Teabing to explain the ‘‘true nature’’ of the Holy Grail to Sophie. Teabing, who has devoted his life to researching theories about the Holy Grail, is delighted to present the story. Most ask about the location of the Holy Grail, Teabing says, when they should be asking what is the Holy Grail. Teabing’s version of the story involves a number of surprising claims that are woven together. The Bible in its present form omits several other gospels, and was ‘‘collated’’ by Constantine the Great, the Roman emperor who presided over the Council of Nicaea in 325. Early Christians believed Jesus was mortal, and that his divine status was decided by a ‘‘relatively close vote’’ held at this fourth-century gathering. Jesus was actually married to Mary Magdalene and had a child by her. According to this alternative history, Teabing declares, the Holy Grail is actually Mary Magdalene and the set of Sangreal texts buried with her that prove her marriage to Jesus. Leonardo da Vinci knew all of this, Teabing claims, and painted clues to the story in his famous painting, The Last Supper. The Da Vinci Code, then, is the set of symbols in Leonardo da Vinci’s art that represent this other radically different Christian history. Teabing’s lecture is interrupted by Silas, who breaks in and attempts unsuccessfully to retrieve the cryptex just before Lieutenant Collet and a team of police storm the estate.
Chapters 66–84 Langdon, Sophie, Teabing, and his servant Re´my slip away undetected with Silas as their prisoner while Collet and his colleagues search
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
the estate. They escape to London in Teabing’s private plane to follow the latest clue. During their flight, Sophie finally tells Langdon the reason she shut her grandfather out of her life. She had seen him engaging in a sexual ritual called Hieros Gamos with a woman she did not recognize. Langdon explains that Hieros Gamos, or sacred marriage, is an ancient rite that is performed to achieve spiritual enlightenment. He reassures her that this is an ancient spiritual ritual, and implores her to try to understand Saunie`re’s act as a means to the end of achieving a kind of spiritual nirvana. Sophie begins to regret that she had judged her grandfather so harshly. Turning their attention to the cryptex, Langdon, Sophie, and Teabing decipher the latest clue, and open it. Rather than yielding the location of the Grail, the cryptex opens to reveal a scroll that conceals a smaller cryptex requiring another password. When they land at the Kent airport in England, Fache and his team arrive just in time to see Teabing exit the plane with his butler, ignorant that Langdon, Sophie, and Silas are already hidden in his limousine. Fache searches the plane for clues. Teabing leads Langdon and Sophie to London’s Temple Church, where they believe the next clue will appear.
Chapters 85–97 While Langdon, Sophie, and Teabing search the church, Re´my frees Silas and reveals himself to be an employee of the Teacher as well. Together, they force the keystone from Langdon and take Teabing hostage. On a mission to recover both the cryptex and Teabing, Langdon and Sophie visit the library at King’s College to research the latest clue further. The Teacher directs Re´my to drop Silas off at London’s Opus Dei headquarters and notifies the police that he is there. When the police arrive, Silas opens fire and is shot, just before learning that one of his bullets has hit Bishop Aringarosa, who has come to help him. Meanwhile, Langdon and Sophie deduce from their research that they must visit Sir Isaac Newton’s grave in Westminster Abbey for the clue to opening the cryptex. As they approach the headstone, the Teacher watches them from a distance.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
Chapters 98–105 Langdon and Sophie discover a note on the grave directing them to meet the Teacher in a public garden by way of Chapter House. When they arrive at Chapter House, they reach a dead end, and are stunned to find Teabing standing in front of it with a loaded revolver pointed at them. In a dramatic standoff, Langdon throws the cryptex into the air, and Teabing, dropping his gun, leaps for it only to discover it has already been opened. Fache storms the room along with the British police to arrest Teabing, leaving Langdon and Sophie free to interpret the final clue. Meanwhile, Bishop Aringarosa awakes and finds himself carried by an injured Silas. He remembers the event that drove him to seek the Holy Grail. Five months earlier, he learned that the Vatican had decided to revoke their association with Opus Dei. The twenty million euros they gave him was meant to settle the debt they owed to Opus Dei, which loaned money to the Vatican Bank twenty years earlier. Desperate to save Opus Dei, Aringarosa jumps at the chance to retrieve the Holy Grail when he gets a call from the Teacher, a title used often in the prelature. Thinking the Teacher is a member of the Vatican who wants to save his organization, Aringarosa obeys his commands. When he learns that the Teacher is Teabing, who has attempted to implicate the Vatican and manipulate him, he decides to distribute the Vatican money among the families of those who were killed during his operation. Meanwhile, Saunie`re’s final clue takes Langdon and Sophie to Rosslyn Chapel, a magnificent display of religious and pagan symbols that was believed to have been the site of the Grail long ago. While there, Sophie feels she has been there before, and learns not only that her grandmother and brother have been living there in secrecy to protect her grandfather’s identity, but also that she is a descendant of Mary Magdalene.
Epilogue Two days later, Langdon experiences an epiphany about Saunie`re’s final clue, which leads him back to a small pyramid in the Louvre. He believes that Saunie`re’s secret was that this pyramid houses Mary Magdalene’s bones and is thus the site of the Holy Grail. He kneels down in reverential awe, imagining that he can hear Mary Magdalene’s whispering voice.
V o l u m e
1
5
T h e
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
MEDIA ADAPTATIONS The Da Vinci Code was released in 2003 as an unabridged version on audiocassette and audio CD. It is narrated by Paul Michael and is available from Random House Audio. The film version of The Da Vinci Code stars Tom Hanks as Robert Langdon, Audrey Tatou as Sophie Neveu, and Ian McKellen as Leigh Teabing. It is directed by Ron Howard, produced by Columbia Pictures, and is set for release in 2006. The official website written and updated by Dan Brown himself, www.danbrown.com, is an interesting and interactive website, but it is also primarily geared toward promoting sales of his novels. ABC News Presents: Jesus, Mary and Da Vinci is an hour-long documentary hosted by Elizabeth Vargas, produced by Koch Vision, 2004. Vargas interviews Dan Brown himself, as well as Karen King and Elaine Pagels, both Gnostic Gospel scholars, and Richard McBrien and Darrell Bock, both Christian scholars. It presents competing views of the novel’s controversial claims about Christian history, and is available on DVD from Koch Vision Studios.
CHARACTERS Bishop Manuel Aringarosa Bishop Aringarosa is the president-general of Opus Dei, a prelature of the Vatican that has come under scrutiny for its unorthodox methods of worship. Aringarosa criticizes the liberal actions of the Catholic Church and its reforms during Vatican II. Introduced at the site of the lavish Opus Dei headquarters in New York with an elaborate and expensive bishop’s ring, Aringarosa is portrayed as a man motivated by money. He works with Silas to recover the
6
L i t e r a r y
Breaking the ‘‘Da Vinci Code’’ is an hourlong documentary featuring authors of books disproving the theories put forth in the novel, including Darrell Bock. It is produced by Grizzly Adams Family, 2005, and is available on DVD.
Cracking the ‘‘Da Vinci Code’’ is a documentary that runs an hour and a half and was produced by Ardustry Home Entertainment in 2004. Host and author Simon Cox defends the legend of the Holy Grail. It is available on DVD from Ardustry Home Entertainment.
‘‘Da Vinci Code’’ Decoded is a three-hour documentary introduced by Dan Brown, produced by The Disinformation Company, 2004. It features interviews with the authors of books Brown used when researching for his novel and is available on DVD.
Exploring the ‘‘Da Vinci Code’’ is a video tour of the famous locations to which the novel refers, hosted by Henry Lincoln, one of the authors of Holy Blood, Holy Grail, and released in 2005 by The Disinformation Company. It is available on DVD.
legendary keystone to discover the location of the Holy Grail under the direction of the Teacher. Ultimately, his main goal is to save Opus Dei: five months before the action in the novel, he had learned that his organization would lose its association with the Vatican in six months. Retrieving the Holy Grail for the Catholic Church, he thinks, might solidify his support from the Vatican.
Sister Sandrine Bieil Sister Sandrine manages the Church of Saint-Sulpice, the site Saunie`re names in his
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
last words to Silas. She critiques what she perceives as misogyny in Opus Dei’s practices, and she is connected to the Priory of Sion. For several years, she has held instructions to contact the se´ne´chaux and the Grand Master if the seal in her church is ever broken, a silent alarm that indicates that the secrets of the Priory are threatened. When she sees Silas unwittingly send this silent alarm, she attempts to warn Priory members and is murdered in the process.
Marie Chauvel Marie Chauvel is caretaker of Rosslyn Chapel and Sophie Neveu’s grandmother. She has been living in secrecy with her grandson, Neveu’s brother, under the protection of the Priory for twenty-eight years. A direct descendant of the Merovingian families, Chauvel followed the orders of the Priory to go into hiding after the car accident that killed Neveu’s family. Since the accident, she has had to arrange secret meetings with her husband to protect her grandchildren and their true identities.
Lieutenant Collet Lieutenant Collet works under Captain Fache, whom he admires for his professional insight. He echoes the feelings of his colleagues, who see Fache as a heroic leader and example. He assists Fache on his hunt for Langdon and Neveu through the streets of Paris. Collet watches Fache alter his strategy a number of times but remains loyal to him to the end. When Fache captures the real villain, Leigh Teabing, Collet defends him in an interview with the BBC, declaring that Fache used Langdon and Neveu to ‘‘lure out the real killer.’’
Simon Edwards Simon Edwards is Executive Services Officer at Biggin Hill Airport. He is dismayed when he is summoned to help arrest his client, Leigh Teabing, as soon as his private plane lands.
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
power as Captain and is greatly admired by his assistant, Lieutenant Collet. Though he seems unusually focused on Langdon at first, in the end, Fache is only interested in finding the real murderer. When he arrests Leigh Teabing, he lets Langdon and Neveu go, in spite of Teabing’s frantic declarations that they know the location of the Holy Grail.
Claude Grouard Claude Grouard is a security warden in the Louvre. He regards Saunie`re as a paternal figure, and is determined to keep Langdon in the Louvre when he finds him just after Fache and his team have left to chase the tracking device that is no longer on him. He is outwitted by Neveu when she uses the Madonna of the Rocks as a shield to escape the museum with Langdon.
Robert Langdon Robert Langdon is Professor of Religious Symbology at Harvard University. In the year before the novel takes place, Langdon became a celebrity for his role in a scandal at the Vatican involving a secret society known as the Illuminati. He has just completed a three-hundred-page manuscript tentatively titled Symbols of the Lost Sacred Feminine, and is in Paris to present a lecture about pagan symbols hidden in Chartres Cathedral. At the moment of his lecture, which takes place just before the novel opens, this bachelor professor is as famous for his research as he is for his charming and stylish appearance. He is dismayed to learn that he has been called ‘‘Harrison Ford in Harris tweed,’’ and that his female students refer to his alluring voice as ‘‘chocolate for the ears.’’ Author of several books on symbols, icons, and secret societies, with titles such as The Symbology of Secret Sects, The Art of the Illuminati, and Religious Iconography, Langdon was featured in Boston Magazine as one of the top ten most intriguing people in the city. He is recruited to help solve the mystery of Saunie`re’s death.
Captain Bezu Fache Bezu Fache is Captain of the Central Directorate Judicial Police in Paris. An ominous figure with dark hair and features, nicknamed le Taureau, the Bull, Fache is initially intent on proving Langdon’s involvement in Saunie`re’s murder. He dresses formally, and wears a tie clip that features a crux gemmata, a crucifix decorated with thirteen gems that represent Christ and his apostles. He carries an enormous amount of
Re´my Legaludec
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
Re´my Legaludec is Leigh Teabing’s butler. A fifty-something Frenchman, Legaludec dons a formal white tie and tuxedo when he receives Langdon and Neveu in the middle of the night. He is the only one who has seen the Teacher face to face, and works under him to gather intelligence using a vast network of surveillance equipment. The Teacher motivates Legaludec by
1
7
T h e
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
promising a life of luxury upon his retirement, but ultimately poisons him when his job is complete.
Sophie Neveu Sophie Neveu is a young, attractive cryptologer for the Central Directorate Judicial Police in Paris, and the granddaughter of Saunie`re. When she was only four, her parents, grandmother, and younger brother were killed in a car accident. She had a happy childhood living with Saunie`re, whose passion for mathematical mysteries and codes inspired her to study cryptography, the science of decoding secret messages, at the Royal Holloway in England. She had stopped communicating with him ten years earlier, when she witnessed him engaging in a disturbing ritual. The afternoon before Saunie`re is murdered, Neveu receives a call from him warning her of danger and promising to divulge the secret of her family. She helps Langdon to discover the meaning behind her grandfather’s clues, and also on his quest to find the Holy Grail. In the end, she learns that she belongs to the Merovingian families, believed to be descendants of Mary Magdalene and Jesus Christ.
Jacques Saunie`re Jacques Saunie`re has been a curator at the Louvre museum for twenty years. A highly respected and reclusive scholar of art, Saunie`re has published books on goddesses and pagan symbols in art. As the Grand Master of the Priory of Sion, Saunie`re possesses the secret of the Holy Grail, and devotes his life to concealing both his identity and the location of the Grail. For many years, he had been a gentle and loving grandfather to Sophie Neveu after she had lost her family in a car accident. He shared his passions for mathematical symbols, puzzles, and secret codes with his granddaughter to the extent that she eventually chose to study cryptology. He had been estranged from Neveu for ten years, after she witnessed him engaged in a ritual so disturbing that she refused to speak to him. Though he is murdered at the opening of the novel, he haunts the remainder of the narrative in the form of a series of clues he leaves behind at his murder scene, and in the form of his granddaughter’s memories.
Silas Silas is the albino monk who murders Saunie`re. He has no last name, and cannot remember his real name in the midst of repressing
8
L i t e r a r y
his abusive childhood. What he does remember is stabbing his father to death at the age of seven, after witnessing him beat his mother to death. His childhood act of rage precipitates further acts of violence that eventually land him in prison. While in prison, he suffers a tortured existence. When an earthquake destroys the prison and frees him, he wanders aimlessly until he meets Bishop Aringarosa. The Bishop names him Silas after reading him a passage of the Bible that refers to a prisoner with that name who prays to God in spite of being beaten regularly, and is eventually freed by an earthquake. Aringarosa converts Silas to Catholicism and recruits him to help build his church. A devout Christian, he wears a spiked cilice around his thigh and whips himself with a discipline, devices used to remind him of Christ’s suffering. He struggles with his role as an assassin of the three se´ne´chaux, Saunie`re, and Sister Sandrine.
Sir Leigh Teabing See The Teacher
The Teacher The Teacher is the anonymous mastermind behind the plan to find the Holy Grail. Until his identity is revealed at the end of the novel, he is never seen but only heard, primarily through telephone conversations with Silas and Bishop Aringarosa. He has access to a staggering amount of information, and seems to be able to see all that is happening in the novel. He obtains the names of the three se´ne´chaux and the Grand Master of the Priory of Sion, commands Silas to kill them, and informs Bishop Aringarosa of the status of their quest to retrieve the Holy Grail. Because of his close ties to Silas and the Bishop, the infinite fortune he seems to have, and references he makes to doing God’s work, he initially appears to be associated in some way with the Catholic Church. But he actually works only for himself, and reveals his identity at the climax of the novel as Leigh Teabing. As Teabing, he helps Langdon and Neveu interpret the clues left by Saunie`re, as he summarizes some of the more controversial ideas of the novel. His eagerness to aid Langdon and Sophie in decoding the cryptex and discovering the Grail is interpreted by them as scholarly interest, but his true motives are soon revealed. At the climax of the novel, he finally identifies himself as the Teacher, the one responsible for the murders, the one who has manipulated Silas
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
and Aringarosa, and the architect behind the entire plan to find the Holy Grail.
President of the Paris Depository Bank of Zurich, Andre´ Vernet is eager to keep his name out of the headlines. He helps Langdon and Neveu escape his bank, which has never been the subject of scandal. He turns out to have been a very close friend of Saunie`re’s, entrusted to guard the safety box the Grand Master had stored in his bank.
THEMES Sacrifice The Da Vinci Code opens with a dramatic personal sacrifice—Saunie`re’s death to protect the secret of the Priory of Scion—but theme of sacrifice appears repeatedly throughout the novel. It does not always require a death, however; a sacrifice can be any type of loss, from loss of integrity or freedom to the loss of a physical item. A sacrifice entails the giving up of something in exchange for something else. It is a circumstance that does not allow for two competing needs to exist together. For example, Saunie`re makes the ultimate sacrifice—death— that hundreds in the Priory throughout history, according to Brown, have been willing to make. Likewise, Sister Sandrine Bieil sacrifices her life to warn the Priory when Silas attempts to unearth the keystone in the Church of SaintSulpice. Sophie’s grandmother and brother, whom she had long thought dead, sacrifice their freedom—and time with their family—to go into hiding in order to protect her grandfather’s identity. Leigh Teabing, the long-time scholar of the Sacred Feminine, sacrifices his integrity and conscience in exchange for the possibility of gain; he is willing to stop at nothing in order to procure the Holy Grail. But perhaps the greatest sacrifice in the novel is not made by one of the characters, but by, according to Teabing and Langdon, the Catholic Church. They believe that in order to keep the knowledge of Christ’s earthly wife and child a secret, the Catholic Church, in essence, sacrificed Mary Magdalene. Teabing and Langdon’s theory is that the Church designated her a prostitute to discredit any rumor of Christ’s involvement with her, in
N e w s m a k e r s
V i n c i
C o d e
fear that knowledge of a marriage with Mary would affect Christ’s divine status.
Quest
Andre´ Vernet
L i t e r a r y
D a
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
At the heart of Brown’s novel is the quest, not only as a long adventurous journey in search of something, but also as one of the most archetypal elements in literature, the pursuit of the Holy Grail. Several characters are on quests in the novel for different reasons. Silas looks for the keystone that will lead to the Holy Grail for his savior, Bishop Aringarosa. Detective Fache searches for the murderer of Saunie`re. Langdon explores the meaning behind Leonardo da Vinci’s symbols to greater understand the subject to which he has devoted his studies. Sophie seeks answers to truths about her family. In the novel, these fictional pursuits merge with the quintessential quest for the Holy Grail, a tale represented in Christian tradition literally as the search for the goblet that Christ drank from during the Last Supper and that Joseph of Arimathea used to catch Christ’s blood as he hung from the cross, and figuratively as the search for Christ within one’s soul. The tale of the quest actually surfaced in the twelfth century as a poem by Chre´tien de Troyes, and the legend took different forms as others rewrote it. The most famous of those to invoke the legend in their art are thirteenth-century German epic poet Wolfram von Eschenbach, fifteenth-century English writer Sir Thomas Malory, English poet Alfred, Lord Tennyson, and composer Richard Wagner in the nineteenth century. Brown’s novel changes the quest considerably in proposing that the Grail is not a chalice at all, but rather Mary Magdalene herself and the texts that tell the secret of her marriage to Jesus.
Christianity Though The Da Vinci Code appears to implicate Catholic institutions in a conspiracy to wipe out alternative Christian histories, its suggestions that Jesus was not divine, that Mary Magdalene had children by him, that she, rather than the apostle Peter, was intended to be the first leader of Christianity, and that Constantine the Great suppressed all of this and assembled the Bible at the Council of Nicaea in 325 A . D ., all relate to Christians of any denomination. Of course, history, which the narrative declares is written by those who are victorious, does not support any of these suggestions. The gospels of Matthew, Mark,
V o l u m e
1
9
T h e
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
TOPICS FOR FURTHER STUDY
With a partner, research the claims made in the novel about Leonardo da Vinci’s paintings Madonna of the Rocks and The Last Supper. Prepare presentations that present different interpretations of the paintings, using evidence from your research.
Leigh Teabing makes a number of declarations regarding the Council of Nicaea in 325. After conducting historical research on that event, stage a reenactment with other classmates of a debate that is likely to have taken place there. Conclude with your views on the authenticity of Teabing’s statements. Though the first word in the novel is ‘‘Fact,’’ Brown carefully words the claims he makes in the narrative. Using his statements on the first page, compose a list that indicates only what Brown claims is true in the novel, especially ‘‘descriptions of artwork, architecture, documents, and secret rituals.’’ Conduct research on one of those elements, such as The Last Supper or Rosslyn Chapel, to measure his accuracy. Prepare a presentation that lists each claim, followed by what you found in your research.
Research one of the figures named in Les Dossiers Secrets. What information can you find to suggest that the person you choose was a member of the Priory of Sion? What symbols and codes are left behind to show a connection to the secret society? Write a brief biography of that person, detailing what you found in your research.
Luke, and John repeatedly refer to the divinity of Christ, and there is no evidence that Mary Magdalene was married to Jesus. The major texts of Gnosticism—the belief in the gnosis (intuitive knowledge) of the human soul, surfaced in the second and third centuries, well after early Christians deemed the four gospels authoritative, though they are said in the novel
1 0
L i t e r a r y
to be suppressed by Constantine. Christianity, moreover, is portrayed in the novel as a patriarchal religion built on conspiracies authored by those who want to suppress information. The Christian characters in the novel delight in masochism and thirst for power. Nevertheless, Brown carefully phrases his page of facts to state simply that the Priory of Sion exists, that Opus Dei has built an elaborate and expansive headquarters in New York and has been the subject of controversy, and that descriptions of art, architecture, rituals, and documents are accurate. Most of the claims about an alternative Christian history, furthermore, are spoken authoritatively by the novel’s villain, Leigh Teabing.
STYLE Fact in Fiction The Da Vinci Code is striking in the way the fictional plot is woven into several other intriguing historical plots. References to actual historical figures such as Jesus, Mary Magdalene, Constantine the Great, and Leonardo da Vinci have prompted scholars to write articles and books responding to claims about them made by the fictional Saunie`re, Langdon, and Teabing. References to existing locations such as the Louvre and Rosslyn Chapel have generated so much interest that tour guides developed the ‘‘Da Vinci Code Walking Tour’’ in Paris and the number of tourists to Rosslyn Chapel doubled in the few years following the novel’s publication. Further, references to real organizations such as Opus Dei and the Vatican have inspired many readers to question Christianity in general, and Catholicism in particular. Though the novel follows its fictional characters during the course of only a few days, the search for the answers to symbols, clues, and riddles Saunie`re leaves behind is related to the search for answers to mysteries in the Bible as well as the history of the quest for the Holy Grail. It also invokes the history of the Council of Nicaea and its role in shaping Christianity, the history of the Priory of Sion, and speculation about Leonardo da Vinci’s artwork. Though the narrative raises several questions about history, the fictional plot in The Da Vinci Code ends with most of its questions answered and its conflicts resolved.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
Suspense Any description of this novel would not be complete without mentioning suspense, or the literary technique of creating excitement, apprehension, and expectation. The final sentences of the Prologue give nothing away as they describe how Saunie`re sets the scene that will preoccupy characters during the first half of the novel: ‘‘Wincing in pain, he summoned all of his faculties and strength. The desperate task before him, he knew, would require every remaining second of his life.’’ When a clue is left on the glass covering the Mona Lisa, the last sentence of the chapter indicates only that ‘‘six words glowed in purple, scrawled directly across the Mona Lisa’s face,’’ and the narrative shifts to another scene in the following chapter before showing readers what those words are. Curious omissions, changing interpretations of symbols and riddles, and plot twists in the narrative drive the reader to seek further for more complete descriptions and definitive interpretations, and to rush to the end of the novel.
Mystery The major appeal of Brown’s novel is its construction of profound mysteries, both fictional and historical. It deploys one of the most conventional elements of the classic mystery genre only to dismiss it immediately: the novel begins with a murder, but reveals the identity of the murderer in the second chapter. The central mysteries in the novel are the reasons behind Saunie`re’s murder and the possible organizations involved, the meaning of various clues and riddles he leaves behind, and the truth about Sophie’s family. Equally important is the novel’s introduction to real historical mysteries. What role did Mary Magdalene play in Jesus’ life? What was the real role of Constantine in shaping Christianity’s future? How credible are the Gnostic gospels? What is the history of the Priory of Sion and who were its members? Was Leonardo da Vinci trying to communicate hidden messages in his paintings? What is the meaning of the number of Divine Proportion? Because the answers to these historical questions depend on historical evidence, or texts written by those who were victorious, the book plays upon the plausible idea that what is called history may be an artificial construction of true events. While the fictional mysteries in the novel entertain readers, the historical mysteries it interprets made it an international phenomenon.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
HISTORICAL CONTEXT Though there is no explicit reference to the year in which it takes place, The Da Vinci Code is set in a time contemporaneous with its publication in 2003. The narrative refers to several recent events, from the construction of the New York headquarters of Opus Dei in 2000 to the scandalous public indictment of Opus Dei member and FBI spy Robert Hanssen in April of 2001. Brown’s contentious portrayal of Opus Dei appeared as the organization struggled to redeem its reputation after being accused by former members of using cultish techniques. The novel’s suggestion that widely accepted histories are simply works constructed by those in power has motivated historians to critique its liberal interpretations of the past. Its equally strong claims about an alternative history of Christianity have provoked many biblical scholars to counter in a growing number of books written explicitly to discredit the novel. Its portrayal of religious fanaticism plays into readers’ fears of spiritual politics, especially in the wake of recent terrorist acts committed by religious fundamentalists. In depicting Mary Magdalene as one of the most important early Christian leaders, the novel also brings out the debate about the role of women in Christianity, a highly charged issue as the Catholic Church elected a new Pope after the death of John Paul II in 2005, the Church’s leader for almost a quarter century. The novel’s female critic of the Church, Sister Sandrine, feels that ‘‘most of the Catholic Church was gradually moving in the right direction with respect to women’s rights,’’ but objects to Opus Dei, which ‘‘threatened to reverse the progress.’’ Feminist scholars praised the novel’s assertions that Mary Magdalene played a more important role than the official Bible indicates, and that femininity has been suppressed by Christian leaders throughout history. While the novel is obviously fiction as a thriller that follows its protagonists through some extremely narrow escapes and ends with complete resolution, it does make interpretations of two historical events worth mentioning here: the origin of the Priory of Sion in the eleventh century, and the Council of Nicaea in 325 A . D . As a secret society, the Priory of Sion is shrouded in mystery. On the first page of the
V o l u m e
1
1 1
T h e
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
novel, unambiguously titled ‘‘Fact,’’ Brown claims it is a ‘‘European secret society founded in 1099,’’ and writes that in 1975, documents were found that identify figures from Sir Isaac Newton to Leonardo da Vinci as Priory members. Scholars have pointed out that Brown takes this claim from another international bestseller titled The Holy Blood and the Holy Grail (1982) by Henry Lincoln, Richard Leigh, and Michael Baigent. Brown uses the last names of the two latter authors as straightforward and anagrammatic sources for his fictional historian, Leigh Teabing. Their book refers to the true story of a priest appointed in 1885 named Be`renger Saunie`re, who mysteriously acquires great wealth in a short period of time, and eventually purchases a lavish estate. Though the story of Be`renger Saunie`re is widely accepted as fact, The Holy Blood and the Holy Grail assumes that Saunie`re’s wealth is a direct result of his finding secret papers that prove the existence of Jesus’ and Mary Magdalene’s lineage. It also suggests that the real Saunie`re is a member of the Priory, which has existed since the eleventh century. But these myths were perpetuated by his housekeeper, Marie De´narnaud, and the next owner of his estate, Noe¨l Corbu, who turned the estate into a resort to maximize public interest, thus increasing his profit. When the eccentric Parisian Pierre Plantard heard of the story in the mid-twentieth century, he created a series of documents including false genealogical records that suggested his relation to the Merovingian line. With the help of his friend Phillipe de Che´risey, Plantard crafted fake parchments containing coded messages, all of which were introduced under pseudonyms into the Bibliothe`que Nationale in the 1960s. But these ‘‘dossiers secrets’’ were exposed as forgeries, and historians agree that there is no proof that the Priory has existed since the eleventh century. A French journalist uncovered the hoax in the 1980s, and a BBC documentary titled ‘‘The History of a Mystery’’ reiterated its falsity in 1996. Brown’s historian, Leigh Teabing, brings out the second relevant historical event when he discusses the Council of Nicaea, a gathering called by Roman Emperor Constantine the Great to unite the government with the Catholic Church. During this meeting, the Bible was officially canonized and Jesus’ divinity was made concrete. Teabing argues that Constantine the Great ‘‘collated’’ the Bible and suppressed the Gnostic
1 2
L i t e r a r y
gospels, and that Jesus’ divinity was debated and eventually accepted by a ‘‘relatively close vote.’’ While making these controversial claims, he asserts that ‘‘everything you need to know about the Bible can be summed up by the great canon doctor Martyn Percy.’’ Percy, a British theologian and the only living scholar Brown quotes, has responded to this reference in Brown’s novel by discrediting the idea that Constantine could have divinized Jesus. Most of what Teabing says about Constantine comes from the same book of speculations Brown uses as evidence of Priory history, The Holy Blood and the Holy Grail. Religious scholars point out that the council was called to address the ‘‘Arian heresy,’’ or the unconventional belief that Jesus was not divine, that the gospels were considered authoritative as early as the first century A . D . Most historians, moreover, note that the ‘‘relatively close vote’’ to which Teabing refers was actually not close at all, and that Jesus’ divinity was widely accepted among the early Christians. In fact, many scholars have invalidated the claims the novel makes about Christian history. Brown’s theories are most convincing to those who see history as a conspiracy, not as a factual account of the past.
CRITICAL OVERVIEW The Da Vinci Code debuted at number one on the New York Times bestseller list, and generated high praise from many critics for its entertainment value. Reviewing the novel for the New York Times, Janet Maslin declares, ‘‘In this gleefully erudite suspense novel, Mr. Brown takes the format he has been developing through three earlier novels and fine-tunes it to blockbuster proportion.’’ On the other side of the Atlantic—and indeed, on the other side of the critical spectrum—Peter Millar writes in his review for the Times (London) that the novel ‘‘is without doubt, the silliest, most inaccurate, ill-informed, stereotype-driven, cloth-eared, cardboard-cutout-populated piece of pulp fiction that I have read.’’ Whatever the reaction, reviewers most often took polarized views of the book initially. Whatever the reason, sales of the novel increased exponentially. As of 2005, the novel had been listed in the New York Times bestseller list for ninety-six weeks, even though it had not yet been released in paperback. Over
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
The Louvre, Paris Ó Owen Franken/Corbis
twenty-five million copies had been purchased in the two years following its publication to generate more than $210 million in sales. Its worldwide success and controversial claims were deemed so dangerous that Lebanese religious leaders had it banned from the country, and Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone urged Catholics to boycott it. The year after it was published, some critics began analyzing the reasons behind its success. Writing for the New Statesman, Jason Cowley notes that the novel brings out ‘‘many of the most urgent political themes of our time—religious extremism, the idea that history itself is a vast conspiracy, the power of secret networks and societies over our lives, the global reach of the internet, the omnipresence of satellite surveillance and other new technologies.’’ More specifically, Cowley argues that ‘‘In the aftermath of the events of September 2001 and the invasion of Iraq, in a world where a mysterious and opaque global network of religious terrorists called al-Queda threatens the west as well as, it is believed, communicating via encoded messages,’’ the novel ‘‘carries a powerful political charge.’’
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
Capitalizing on the novel’s widespread success, networks produced a number of programs exploring its subjects. ABC sent reporter Elizabeth Vargas on an international journey to interview scholars about the novel’s claims. The special, titled ‘‘Jesus, Mary and Da Vinci,’’ aired in the fall of 2003. ‘‘Da Vinci Code: The Full Story,’’ another program to explore the novel’s issues, aired on the National Geographic Channel, attracted more viewers than the channel had for any other program in its history. As a summary of Christian scholars’ critiques of the novel, PAX aired ‘‘Breaking The Da Vinci Code’’ in early May of 2005, taking its title from Darrel Bock’s critical book. The History Channel produced a two-hour special titled ‘‘Beyond The Da Vinci Code,’’ which aired in late May of 2005. Many religious scholars published critical books of their own, taking issue with Brown’s sensational assertions, voiced in interviews, that he believes in his novel’s theories; they also took exception to the novel’s astounding market success. Among those to debunk the novel are Carl E. Olson and Sandra Miesel in The Da Vinci Hoax: Exposing the Errors in ‘‘The Da Vinci Code’’ (2004). The Archbishop of Chicago, Cardinal Francis George, speaking in
V o l u m e
1
1 3
T h e
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
Ignatuis Books, calls The Da Vinci Hoax: Exposing the Errors in ‘‘The Da Vinci Code’’ ‘‘the definitive debunking’’ of The Da Vinci Code. In a pamphlet for Our Sunday Visitor, Amy Welbourn excerpts from her book, De-Coding Da Vinci: The Facts Behind the Fiction of ‘‘The Da Vinci Code’’ (2004). In it, she calls The Da Vinci Code ‘‘logically and historically flawed,’’ and cites that Brown holds ‘‘no advanced degrees in religion.’’ Other scholars and critics take more objective historical perspectives, with an aim of providing historical information that is sometimes at odds with the facts in Brown’s novel. These books include Simon Cox’s Cracking the ‘‘Da Vinci Code’’: The Unauthorized Guide to the Facts behind Dan Brown’s Bestselling Novel, and Sharan Newman’s The Real History Behind the ‘‘Da Vinci Code’’ (2005).
CRITICISM Kathleen Helal Dr. Helal has taught courses on writing and English literature for several years, and has presented and published many papers and articles on women’s writing. In this essay, Helal analyzes the curious discrepancy between the feminist message of the novel’s theories about Christian history and the misogynist portrayal of its heroine, Sophie Neveu. Mary Magdalene is arguably the true hero of The Da Vinci Code. She is the Holy Grail, the secret kept by the Priory of Sion, the figure to whom the main character bows in reverence in the final chapter, the ‘‘woman’s voice . . . the wisdom of the ages . . . whispering up from the chasms of the earth’’ in the final sentence. Indeed, the success of The Da Vinci Code in seducing readers to believe her role is more central in Christianity than it seems is due in part to Brown’s reverence for this forgotten female figure. Leigh Teabing interprets the Christian misrepresentation of Mary Magdalene as a conspiracy to suppress her importance: ‘‘That unfortunate misconception is the legacy of a smear campaign launched by the early Church. The Church needed to defame Mary Magdalene in order to cover up her dangerous secret—her role as the Holy Grail.’’ Indeed, since Pope Gregory delivered a series of sermons in 591 that simplified her identity as a sinner in contrast to the other
1 4
L i t e r a r y
THOUGH THE NOVEL OVERTLY ENGAGES CHRISTIAN HISTORY TO CRITIQUE IT FROM A FEMINIST PERSPECTIVE, SOPHIE NEVEU FUNCTIONS DISTURBINGLY AS THE PASSIVE VESSEL INTO WHICH LEIGH TEABING AND ROBERT LANGDON POUR THEIR THEORIES ABOUT THE LOST SACRED FEMININE.’’
famous Mary, revered as Jesus’ mother, Mary Magdalene has been depicted as a prostitute. Though historians generally do not ‘‘ascribe malicious intent to Gregory . . . who most likely wanted to use the story to assure converts that their sins would be forgiven,’’ as Heidi Schlumpf argues in U.S. Catholic, Mary Magdalene’s reputation has been tarnished for centuries. The Vatican did vindicate her in 1969, and many biblical scholars such as Jane Schaberg and Susan Haskins have reconstructed her image. Schlumpf hopes that ‘‘with the prostitute baggage properly disposed of, Mary of Magdala can emerge as a model of a faithful, devoted follower of the Lord, as well as a strong, independent leader in the early Church.’’ For many, the appeal of The Da Vinci Code is its seemingly feminist celebration of Mary Magdalene as one of the most heroic figures in Christian history. Surely the fictional heroine of Brown’s novel is just as honorable. The attractive and accomplished Sophie Neveu is a cryptologist for the Central Directorate Judicial Police in Paris; however, though she initially appears as an assertive and intelligent character, Neveu regresses as the novel progresses. Any feminist message is further undermined when Brown presents his revision of Mary Magdalene’s story by staging a conversation between two male teachers and a female student that replicates the very patriarchal system he seems to critique. Though the novel overtly engages Christian history to critique it from a feminist perspective, Sophie Neveu functions disturbingly as the passive vessel into which Leigh Teabing and Robert Langdon pour their theories about the lost sacred feminine.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
Neveu, who is oddly called ‘‘Sophie’’ throughout a narrative that refers only to the surnames of the male characters, first appears as a ‘‘young Parisian de´chiffreuse,’’ or one who decodes complex messages. She has ‘‘studied cryptology in England at the Royal Holloway,’’ an actual school internationally acclaimed for its academic research of cryptography—the science of enciphering and deciphering messages in secret code. She is defiant, fearless, and, of course, beautiful, to the dismay of her enemy Bazu Fache: At thirty-two years old, she had a dogged determination that bordered on obstinate. Her eager espousal of Britain’s new cryptologic methodology continually exasperated the veteran French cryptographers above her. And by far the most troubling to Fache was the inescapable universal truth that in an office of middle-aged men, an attractive young woman always drew eyes away from the work at hand.
Framing the heroine as a sort of rival to the misogynist Fache is one strategy Brown uses to present her favorably. He continues by shifting from Fache’s perspective to Langdon’s, emphasizing the contrast in the way she is seen differently by each male character: Langdon turned to see a young woman approaching. She was moving down the corridor toward them with long, fluid strides . . . a haunting certainty to her gait. Dressed casually in a knee-length, cream-colored Irish sweater over black leggings, she was attractive and looked to be about thirty. Her thick burgundy hair fell unstyled to her shoulders, framing the warmth of her face. Unlike the waifish, cookiecutter blondes that adorned Harvard dorm room walls, this woman was healthy with an unembellished beauty and genuineness that radiated a striking personal confidence.
If Fache’s description of Neveu is meant to reveal more about his insecurity than her character, Langdon’s description functions as the more definitive one. Yet, it is as remarkable that one’s hair could be associated with the term ‘‘burgundy’’ as that her ‘‘unembellished beauty and genuineness’’ could be immediately perceived by a perfect stranger. Nevertheless, initially Neveu is meant to be a highly intelligent and benevolent character. When she helps Langdon escape the museum with a clever plan that fools Detective Fache and his entire team, Langdon concludes: ‘‘Sophie Neveu was clearly a hell of a lot smarter than he was.’’ Brown’s portrayal of her seems at first to be consistent
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
with the feminist message of the alternative Christian history he will develop. As the novel continues, however, Neveu seems inexplicably to lose her faculties. It is the symbologist, Langdon, who first interprets the cipher Saunie`re leaves, and when he declares that ‘‘It’s the simplest kind of code!’’ Neveu ‘‘was stopped on the stairs below him, staring up in confusion. A code? She had been pondering the words all night and had not seen a code. Especially a simple one.’’ Brown justifies her ignorance by declaring that her intelligence causes her to seek complexity. But even the narrative seems to reveal this interpretation as ridiculous: Her shock over the anagram was matched only by her embarrassment at not having deciphered the message herself. Sophie’s expertise in complex cryptanalysis had caused her to overlook simplistic word games, and yet she knew she should have seen it. After all, she was no stranger to anagrams—especially in English.
Neveu’s inability to decode the simple anagram is followed by a narrative flashback in which she is a six-year-old girl, her ‘‘tiny hand’’ in her grandfather’s as he leads her through the Louvre. As her memories of herself as a girl continue intermittently in the narrative, her adult self seems to regress into childhood. When Neveu learns about the Holy Grail from Langdon and Teabing, she is depicted as an innocent child: Langdon sighed. ‘I was hoping you would be kind enough to explain to Ms. Neveu the true nature of the Holy Grail.’ Teabing looked stunned. ‘She doesn’t know?’ Langdon shook his head. The smile that grew on Teabing’s face was almost obscene. ‘Robert, you’ve brought me a virgin? . . . You are a Grail virgin, my dear. And trust me, you will never forget your first time.’
Of course, as Langdon relates, anyone unfamiliar with the Grail legend is traditionally called a virgin by those familiar with the story. But the repeated characterization of Neveu as virgin and the pleasure Teabing takes in flaunting his knowledge and superior position seems extremely odd because he will tell her that women have been subordinated in Christian history. Teabing’s message is feminist; his demeanor is quite the opposite. In fact, the entire section of Brown’s novel that delves into the alternative Christian history that celebrates femininity has Langdon and
V o l u m e
1
1 5
T h e
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
Teabing lecturing a wide-eyed, ignorant Neveu. The feminist claims that Mary Magdalene was meant to be the first priest and that Christian leaders have demonized femininity contrast with the antifeminist portrayal of Neveu’s character. The association of Sophie Neveu’s name with wisdom does very little to counter terms used to describe her as she learns that the Holy Grail is a woman and can only stare in awe and ask simple questions. As Teabing declares that the Council of Nicaea established Jesus’ divinity in 325 by a ‘‘relatively close vote,’’ ‘‘Sophie’s head was spinning. . . . Sophie glanced at Langdon, and he gave her a soft nod of concurrence.’’ Strangely, it takes a long time for this accomplished cryptologist to grasp fully what Teabing and Langdon suggest: ‘‘The Holy Grail is a woman, Sophie thought, her mind a collage of interrelated ideas that seemed to make no sense.’’ When she is told that the female Holy Grail appears in Leonardo da Vinci’s The Last Supper, she ‘‘was certain she had missed something’’ in looking for her in the painting, and ‘‘turned to Langdon for help. ‘I’m lost.’’’ As Langdon and Teabing race through their revisionist theories, Neveu always remains one step behind them. The divergence between Teabing’s message and Brown’s portrayal of Neveu having a hard time following him is striking: ‘Peter expresses his discontent over playing second fiddle to a woman. I daresay Peter was something of a sexist.’ Sophie was trying to keep up. ‘This is Saint Peter. The rock on which Jesus built his Church.’ ‘The same, except for one catch. According to these unaltered gospels, it was not Peter to whom Christ gave directions with which to establish the Christian Church. It was Mary Magdalene.’ Sophie looked at him. ‘‘You’re saying the Christian Church was to be carried on by a woman?’’
During this exchange, the feminist message of this alternative version of Christianity is given to and interpreted for the bewildered, ‘‘surprised,’’ incredulous Neveu, who glances back to Langdon for his reassuring nods as Teabing relates the controversial claims. Teabing eventually addresses her as ‘‘my dear child,’’ as he answers her questions, and his ‘‘words seemed to echo across the ballroom and back before they fully registered in Sophie’s mind.’’ The ideas that seem incredulous to Neveu are markedly simple.
1 6
L i t e r a r y
The carved interior roof of Rosslyn Chapel, Roslin, Scotland Getty Images
When she is told that ‘‘history is always written by the winners. . . . By its very nature, history is always a one-sided account,’’ Brown writes, ‘‘Sophie had never thought of it that way.’’ That an educated cryptologist would not have deduced that history could be manipulated seems quite astonishing, to say the least. Ultimately, while the novel attempts to proclaim the feminist secret at the heart of the ‘‘greatest cover-up in human history,’’ it conceals its own subordination of femininity in a narrative that moves so quickly readers hardly pause to actually consider what it suggests about its female characters in particular, and femininity in general. Source: Kathleen Helal, Critical Essay on The Da Vinci Code, in Literary Newsmakers for Students, Thomson Gale, 2006.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
WHAT DO I READ NEXT?
Digital Fortress (1998), Dan Brown’s first novel, explores the secret world of the National Security Agency. The title refers to an unbreakable code that former programmer Ensei Tankado uses to paralyze TRNSLTR, a computer used to monitor private terrorist communications.
Professor Robert Langdon makes his first appearance in Dan Brown’s second novel, Angels and Demons (2000). Already a famous symbologist, Langdon is recruited to interpret a symbol that has been branded on a murdered scientist. As the novel progresses, he is called to interpret further murder scenes and comes to discover the symbols that connect them are all related to a group known as the Illuminati, an ancient secret society formed in opposition against the Catholic Church.
Brown’s third novel, Deception Point (2001), is a political thriller that begins with the NASA discovery of an object in the Arctic that would solidify the status of the space agency. Intelligence analyst Rachel Sexton is sent to verify its authenticity, but when she finds the discovery has been staged, she and her academic colleague Michael Tolland are hunted by assassins before they can notify the president of the United States of their find. The book follows them as they work to learn the truth behind the scientific deception. Holy Blood, Holy Grail (1983), by Michael Baigent, Richard Leigh, and Henry Lincoln, is the bestseller from which Brown draws many of his theories. The book combines history and speculation about the Knights Templar and the Priory of Sion.
Margaret Starbird examines the evidence of the idea that Mary Magdalene played a central role in Jesus’ ministry in The Woman with the Alabaster Jar: Mary Magdalene and the Holy Grail (1993). Most strikingly, Starbird argues that Mary Magdalene was married to Jesus and that the Holy Grail is the secret of their relationship.
In The Templar Revelation: Secret Guardians of the True Identity of Christ (1998), Lynn Picknett and Clive Prince present their view of what secret societies such as the Freemasons, the Cathars, and the Knights Templar believed about the roles of Jesus, Mary Magdalene, and John the Baptist.
In The Gnostic Gospels (1989), Elaine Pagels imagines what Christianity would be like if the Gnostic texts were included in the Bible. Her book is considered one of the most accessible guides to the philosophies of Gnosticism and its implications for Christianity.
Marvin Meyer, Professor of Bible and Christian Studies, summarizes the history of Mary Magdalene’s changing reputation and explores his theory that she had an intimate relationship with Jesus in The Gospels of Mary: The Secret Tradition of Mary Magdalene, the Companion of Jesus (2004).
The Gnostic Gospels of Jesus (2005), compiled and translated by Marvin Meyer, is a complete collection of the Nag Hammadi library, the set of ancient papyrus manuscripts found in the 1940s. These fragments include many of the Gnostic texts to which Brown’s novel refers, from the Gospel of Thomas and the Gospel of Mary to the Gospel of Philip, and the Gospel of Truth.
Norris J. Lacy In the following except, Lacy questions the validity of Brown’s research in The Da Vinci Code, and whether or not accuracy is important in a work of fiction such as this.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
1 7
T h e
1 8
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
1 9
T h e
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
The Last Supper, Leonardo da Vinci, 1498 The Granger Collection, New York. Reproduced by permission
2 0
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
D a
V i n c i
C o d e
FURTHER READING Bock, Darrell L., Breaking the ‘‘Da Vinci Code’’: Answers to the Questions Everybody’s Asking, Nelson Books, 2004. This guide focuses on the three centuries following the birth of Christ to examine the suggestions the novel makes about early Christian history. It largely discredits the theories Brown puts forth in the novel. Burstein, Dan, Secrets of the Code: The Unauthorized Guide to the Mysteries Behind ‘‘The Da Vinci Code,’’ CDS Books, 2004. In a study almost as long as the novel itself, Burstein collects interviews and essays from historians, scientists, archeologists, and theologians, some of whom have contrasting views about the questions the novel raises. This is considered one of the most comprehensive guides to the topics the novel engages, such as what is known about Jesus, Mary Magdalene, the Gnostic gospels, and secret societies.
Welbourn, Amy, ‘‘The Da Vinci Code‘‘: The Facts Behind the Fiction, Catholic Educator’s Resource Center, www.catholiceducation.org/articles/facts/fm0035.html (July 28, 2005); originally published in Our Sunday Visitor, May 2004.
Ehrman, Bart D, Truth and Fiction in the ‘‘Da Vinci Code’’: A Historian Reveals What We Really Know about Jesus, Mary Magdalene, and Constantine, Oxford University Press, 2004. A Professor of Religious Studies, Bart Ehrman uses the novel not only to explore Christian history, but also to show what a religious historian does to uncover the truth about the past. Rather than attempting to invalidate the theories of the novel or delving into theological issues, Ehrman cites inaccuracies in the fiction to show how historians interpret topics such as the significance of the Gnostic gospels, the role Constantine played in shaping Christianity, and the relation between Jesus and Mary Magdalene. Morris, David, The Art and Mythology of ‘‘The Da Vinci Code,’’ Lamar Publishing, 2004. Morris presents the artistic complement to Brown’s novel in this comprehensive collection of photographs and illustrations of art and locations to which the novel refers, from da Vinci’s paintings to the mythological images mentioned in the narrative. Each image is presented in the order in which it appears in the novel. Welborn, Amy, De-Coding Da Vinci: The Facts Behind the Fiction of ‘‘The Da Vinci Code,’’ Our Sunday Visitor, 2004. Though it is not the most comprehensive guide, Welborn’s rebuttal of Brown’s novel is extremely easy to read and concise. She systematically refutes many of the sensational claims Brown’s characters make about Christian history from a Catholic point of view.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
Source: Norris J Lacy, ‘‘The Da Vinci Code: Dan Brown and The Grail That Never Was,’’ in Arthuriana, Vol. 14, No. 3, 2004, pp. 81–89.
SOURCES Brown, Dan, The Da Vinci Code, Doubleday, 2003. Cowley, Jason, ‘‘The Author of the Bestselling Da Vinci Code Has Tapped into our Post-9/11 Anxieties and Fear of Fundamentalism,’’ in New Statesman, December 13, 2004, pp. 18–21. George, Cardinal Francis, Ignatuis Books, www.ignatius. com/books/davincihoax (July 28, 2005). Maslin, Janet, ‘‘Spinning a Thriller from a Gallery at the Louvre,’’ in the New York Times, March 17, 2003, p. E8. Millar, Peter, ‘‘Holy Humbug: Book of the Week,’’ in the Times (London), June 21, 2003, p. 15. Schlumpf, Heidi, ‘‘Who Framed Mary Magdalene?’’ in U.S. Catholic, Vol. 65, No. 4, April 2000, pp. 12–16.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
2 1
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix is J. K. Rowling’s fifth installment in her internationally bestselling series about a young orphaned wizard named Harry Potter. The ‘‘Harry Potter’’ books have been translated into numerous languages, have sold over 80 million copies, and appeal to a wide range of audiences including both children and adults. Published in 2003, The Order of the Phoenix has topped many Bestseller Lists, continuing to widen Rowling’s extraordinary global fan base. The 800-page novel sees the main character, Harry Potter, enter his fifth year at wizardry school, Hogwarts. Now fifteen, Harry encounters such teenage problems as moodiness and resentment of authority, while at the same time trying to untangle the mysterious return of the all-powerful, evil Lord Voldemort. By the end of the story, readers watch Harry transform from a young, confused boy into a strong leader of his fellow students, and a brave warrior against the dark powers of his world. This transformation is not without its difficulties, however, as one of Harry’s dearest companions is lost in the final battle. In a slower buildup to this story’s main action than in earlier books, readers follow Harry’s psychological journey toward a more mature understanding of himself and his place in the wizardry community. Rowling spends much of The Order of the Phoenix tracking Harry’s growing frustration as those who care
2 2
J. K. ROWLING 2003
H a r r y
P o t t e r
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
P h o e n i x
most about him continue to withhold valuable information from him in an attempt to keep Harry safe from Voldemort’s powers. In the end, Harry learns, through a series of mistakes and triumphs, that he is finally mature enough to learn the full truth about his famous but mysterious past as well as his significant but ominous future.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY Beginning in 1998 with the publication of her first novel about a young wizard named Harry Potter, J. K. Rowling launched an internationally recognized writing career and a literary sensation unmatched in the early twentyfirst century. With record breaking sales for each completed installment of her seven part series, Rowling’s 2003 addition, Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, sold in excess of eight million copies in the United States alone. As publishers translate the series into sixty one languages in two hundred different countries, fans worldwide flock to pre-order the remaining books of the series and to view ‘‘Harry Potter’’ movies, making Rowling not only wealthier than the Queen of England, but also a worldwide phenomenon. Joanne Rowling was born in Chipping Sodbury near Bristol, England on July 31, 1965. She later adopted her middle initial of K in honor of her favorite grandmother, Kathleen. Rowling was educated at Exeter University and has called England, France, Portugal, and Scotland home. Naming E. Nesbit, Paul Gallico, and C. S. Lewis as her literary influences, the former teacher always knew she would be a writer. As the popular story goes, she conceived the idea for Harry Potter while on a train and wrote the first novel while her young daughter napped. Rowling subsisted on welfare while writing Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, with the main goal of merely being published, never daring to dream of the acclaim she would receive. Despite the series’ phenomenal success, Rowling reports being rejected by numerous publishers before securing a contract from Bloomsbury in the United Kingdom and Scholastic in the United States.
J. K. Rowling Ó David Bebber/Corbis
edition; British edition titled Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone), Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, and Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince. Each Rowling release, in addition to being wildly popular, has also garnered critical acclaim. She has been awarded many notable literary prizes including the British Book Award’s Children’s Book of the Year, the Hugo Award, the Whitbread Award for Best Children’s book, and several consecutive years of the Smarties Prize. As of 2005, Rowling lives in Scotland with her husband and three children.
PLOT SUMMARY Chapters 1–8
Rowling’s other titles in the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ series include, in order of publication: Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone (American
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix opens with Harry Potter, a fifteen-year-old boy possessed with magical powers, spending another unhappy summer with his non-magical, or Muggle, guardians, the Dursleys. Still reeling from the previous school year’s tragic events (chronicled in Rowling’s fourth book, Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire), Harry suffers
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
2 3
H a r r y
P o t t e r
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
recurring nightmares about his graveyard meeting with the dark Lord Voldemort where his friend Cedric was murdered. As a result of that encounter, Voldemort has now returned to bodily form, and Harry, with great anxiety, awaits news of the destruction Voldemort will inflict upon the wizardry and non-wizardry worlds. Harry finds there are no reports of unusual events despite his constant checking of the newspaper and television news, until one summer evening when he hears a sound that leads him to take a walk in the dark. Harry runs into his cousin Dudley while walking and as they taunt each other, two Dementors, the death-like, happiness-sucking prison guards from the wizardry world, attack the boys. Harry is able to fend them off with his sophisticated magic, only to find that he has been watched all summer by a neighbor as well as several incognito witches and wizards. Underage magic is banned in the Muggle world, thus Harry is threatened with expulsion from his wizardry boarding school, Hogwarts, and thrown out of his relatives’ home for his defense against the Dementors. Several mysterious letters delivered by owl reverse both of Harry’s punishments, setting a hearing for his return to Hogwarts and threatening Aunt Petunia into continuing to provide a home for Harry. Harry waits for any helpful information from his friends to explain recent events, but receives none until a troop of adult witches and wizards appears in the Dursleys’ kitchen. The group leads Harry to the invisible and secret location of those fighting against Voldemort’s return to power. Located at the family estate of Sirius Black—Harry’s godfather—the Order of the Phoenix represents an elite guard of witches and wizards fighting against Voldemort. Once Harry arrives at the Order, he is reunited with best friends and classmates, Ron Weasley and Hermione Granger. Despite being relieved to finally see his friends again, Harry expresses his anger at their keeping him uninformed about events in the wizardry world over the summer. His friends explain their promise kept to Hogwarts Headmaster and Order of the Phoenix leader, Albus Dumbledore, not to give Harry any knowledge that might be dangerous. Ron and Hermione also reveal that most of the wizardry world does not believe Voldemort has returned, and instead regards both Harry and Dumbledore as liars.
2 4
L i t e r a r y
P h o e n i x
Harry joins his friends in cleaning chores throughout the enchanted Black family house while the Order has secret meetings to plan their defense against Voldemort. The kids manage to eavesdrop and find out that Voldemort now seeks some mysterious weapon to enhance his power. Harry also finds out that Sirius Black comes from a long line of dark wizards who support Voldemort, and consider Sirius an outcast. Once Harry has his hearing in front of the full Ministry of Magic court, he does his best to justify his use of magic against the Dementors. The Minister of Magic himself tries to discredit Harry’s story, but Harry wins the hearing only after Dumbledore produces a surprise eyewitness to his account. Harry is thrilled to be going back to Hogwarts, but notices an unusual distance that Dumbledore, his once-confidant, seems to be keeping from him.
Chapters 9–13 Everyone but Sirius is thrilled with Harry’s successful hearing. Sirius, on the other hand, is a fugitive of the law and will be staying alone in his family home over the coming year; he had hoped Harry would be around to keep him company. The mood around the house becomes increasingly strained when Ron and Hermione receive news of their appointment to school Prefect but Harry is denied the title. Feeling resentful and angry already, Harry becomes even more depressed when he is shown a photo of the previous Order of the Phoenix members, many of whom have become Voldemort’s victims. Harry’s parents are featured in the photo. It is finally time for school to begin, and Harry and his friends leave the Black house to meet the Hogwarts Express. Sirius disobeys Dumbledore’s orders and follows Harry to the train, disguised as the shaggy black dog, Snuffles. When Ron and Hermione must meet for Prefect duties, Harry is reunited with friend Neville Longbottom, and they sit together on the train, meeting another student named Luna Lovegood. Luna appears to be a flighty girl whose father publishes a tabloid newspaper called The Quibbler, which is considered a less trustworthy news source than the popular wizarding newspaper, The Daily Prophet. Harry also has an awkward meeting with his crush from last year, Cho Chang. Once at Hogwarts, Harry sees mysterious black horses
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H a r r y
P o t t e r
pulling the school carriages that previously were horseless; many students cannot see the horses, and Harry finds little comfort in the fact that the slightly strange Luna says she can see them too. Once inside the Hogwarts castle, the students gather to hear the Sorting Hat’s yearly song. This year’s song emphasizes school unity, implying that the return of Voldemort may cause detrimental divisions among the students and staff. Almost immediately the school provides evidence of such divisions, as many mock and scorn Harry’s story about the battle in the graveyard. Harry notices that Hagrid does not appear at the faculty table, but a new Defense Against Dark Arts Professor, Delores Umbridge, does. She also contradicts typical Hogwarts protocol by interrupting Dumbledore’s speech to warn against change and progress. Her instruction, once classes begin, further varies from that of previous teachers. She uses only the textbook and refuses to allow students to actually practice magic. This teaching strategy angers both Hermione and Harry, the latter of whom receives a week’s worth of detention for telling what Umbridge considers a lie, that Voldemort has returned. Her detentions prove to be particularly cruel as she forces Harry to carve a sentence onto the back of his own hand. Harry continues to be angry at his treatment by both students and faculty but refuses to report anything to Dumbledore.
Chapters 14–20 Both Ron and Harry receive significant correspondences from those close to them. Ron fumes after receiving a long letter from his estranged brother Percy, who now works for the Minister of Magic, congratulating him on becoming Prefect and encouraging him to support Umbridge’s new policies at Hogwarts. He further tries to persuade Ron that both Dumbledore and Harry should be avoided because they are threats to the Ministry. Sirius appears to Harry in a fire in the common-room fireplace, explaining that the Ministry of Magic is keeping a close watch on Hogwarts through Professor Umbridge because it suspects Dumbledore of conspiracy. Both Percy’s and Sirius’s words are proven true when Umbridge becomes High Inquisitor of the school, allowing her to inspect all faculty and students for the Ministry of Magic’s benefit. Umbridge proceeds to attend various professors’ classes, interrupt their lessons, and threaten them with probation. Ron struggles as the newest
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
P h o e n i x
goalkeeper for the Gryffindor Quidditch team while Harry continues to have nightmares involving long, dark corridors. Hermione’s distaste for the new rules at Hogwarts leads her to propose that Harry form a club to practice now-forbidden Defense Against Dark Arts techniques. After angrily reliving his many frightening encounters with Voldemort, Harry calms down and sees the logic in Hermione’s proposal. Meeting at a pub in nearby Hogsmead that they think is safe, many students gather to discuss the new Dark Arts group. Harry is both excited and nervous at the prospect of teaching fellow students. The group plans their first meeting time and signs a list committing to the cause. When the next day there is a new Ministry decree requiring Umbridge to approve all student organizations, the Dark Arts group realizes they were noticed at the pub; Sirius later appears in the fire in the common-room fireplace confirming that the students were easily overheard. A hand reaches out from the fire to catch Sirius and injures Harry’s messenger owl, Hedwig, establishing that all communication at Hogwarts is being monitored by Umbridge. Fred and George Weasley provide comic relief throughout these events as they continuously experiment with various practical joke products they hope to market in the future. Harry contemplates his mysterious internal connection with Voldemort because he now not only feels pain in his scar when the evil wizard becomes angry, but also seems to be aware when his foe experiences happiness or triumph. Harry remains intensely curious about the weapon for which Voldemort searches, and the dreams of corridors seem to provide important clues to its whereabouts. His house-elf friend, Dobby, informs Harry of a special room where the Dark Arts group can hold their now-secret meetings. At their first gathering, the group chooses to call themselves Dumbledore’s Army, or the D.A., and begins to practice spells and charms at Harry’s direction. Pleased with the first meeting’s success, Harry finds even more thrill in his conversation with Cho. Houses Gryffindor and Slytherin meet in the first Quidditch match, where Ron plays miserably but Harry wins for the team. After the match, Harry’s school nemesis, Draco Malfoy, taunts the Gryffindor players, causing Harry, Fred, and George to physically attack him. As
V o l u m e
1
2 5
H a r r y
P o t t e r
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
a result, Umbridge bans all three Gryffindor players from Quidditch for life. Hagrid finally returns to Hogwarts, and Harry, Ron, and Hermione rush to welcome him. They find out that Hagrid has been on a secret mission for the Order of the Phoenix, recruiting giants for their cause. Hagrid explains that his mission was a failure because the giants fight amongst themselves and the Order’s rival group, the Death Eaters, were also courting the giants.
Chapters 21–26 In Hagrid’s class, Harry learns that the black horses pulling the Hogwarts carriages are called thestrals. Because only those who have witnessed someone’s death can see the horses, Harry is among the few in the class to whom they are not invisible. Harry feels intensely proud as the D.A. continues to meet and make great progress. After one class, Cho dawdles to talk to Harry; first she cries about Cedric’s death last year, then she kisses Harry. He calls his first kiss ‘‘wet’’ when he talks to Ron, and despite Hermione’s extensive explanations, remains confused about Cho’s emotional nature. Harry’s dreams reach a new level of reality as he sees himself behind the eyes of a serpent attacking Ron’s father, Arthur Weasley. So intense is the dream that Harry is convinced Mr. Weasley is actually hurt; when Harry awakes, he insists on reporting his dream to members of the Order of the Phoenix. After Dumbledore hears about the dream, he quickly finds out that Mr. Weasley was indeed attacked. Following a long night of waiting, Harry and the Weasley family visit Mr. Weasley and find that he will make a full recovery. Harry feels guilty for his seeming participation in the snake attack, and only feels worse when he overhears members of the Order discussing whether Voldemort may in fact be possessing Harry. Panicked, Harry believes the only way to keep his friends safe from Voldemort is to run away. When Dumbledore sends a messenger to him, Harry decides to stay but remains sullen because his mentor still will not speak directly to him. Harry enjoys a happy Christmas break with the Weasleys and other members of the Order after his friends convince him that although there is a strange connection between himself and Voldemort, it is unlikely that he is being possessed. The Weasley’s celebrations include
2 6
L i t e r a r y
P h o e n i x
visits to Mr. Weasley at the hospital, where Harry, Ron, and Hermione also run into fellow classmate Neville Longbottom. Ron and Hermione find out that Neville’s parents permanently reside at St. Mungo’s Hospital because they were tortured into insanity by Death Eater Bellatrix Lestrange. As Christmas vacation comes to a close, Harry finds out he will be taking extra lessons with his least favorite professor, Severus Snape, to learn how to close his mind to Voldemort. Called Occlumency, the skill to control entry to one’s mind should help Harry ward off his dreams and thus Voldemort’s access to him. Once back at Hogwarts, students find out that there are several gains for supporters of Voldemort: many Death Eaters break out of prison and a potential witness for the Order is murdered. Despite Umbridge’s attempts to control all political conversation at Hogwarts, students begin to suspect the Ministry’s cover-up and wonder whether Voldemort has indeed come back. Taking advantage of this turning tide, Hermione convinces Harry to publish in The Quibbler his account of Voldemort’s return to power. Harry feels Voldemort’s moods more often, and continues having the vivid dreams involving the evil wizard and his followers.
Chapters 27–32 More fast-moving action begins in this section as a new Divination professor is hired when Umbridge fires Professor Trelawney. Firenze the centaur takes over Trelawney’s classes, though Dumbledore allows Trelawney to remain living at Hogwarts. During one Divination class, Firenze sends a mysterious message to Hagrid through Harry, telling him to give up his latest project because it is failing. One of the D.A. students betrays the group to Umbridge, causing a round-up in Dumbledore’s office, including Harry and several officials from the Ministry of Magic. Once the list titled ‘‘Dumbledore’s Army’’ appears, Dumbledore uses this loophole as a way of claiming the group as his own. Umbridge has no choice but to find Harry innocent of organizing an illegal student group. Instead of allowing the Ministry to capture him, though, Dumbledore escapes arrest and exits his office amid a shower of spells and charms. As news of Dumbledore’s absence spreads, Fred and George promise to cause chaos as a sign of loyalty to their Headmaster.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H a r r y
P o t t e r
At Dumbledore’s urging, Harry continues Occlumency lessons with Professor Snape. During one session, Harry enrages Snape when he sneaks a look into the Pensieve, which holds Snape’s past memories; Harry sees disturbing scenes of his father acting like a schoolboy bully. The idea that his father was arrogant and cruel as a teenager haunts Harry and leads him to arrange, with the help of Fred’s and George’s antics, a conversation with Sirius about his father’s upsetting behavior. Meanwhile, students study frantically for their fifth-year exams called O.W.L.s. Snape cancels Occlumency classes because of his anger, and although Harry has made some progress in closing his mind, he continues to relish his recurring dreams because he wants to find out what is behind the last door. Fred and George make a memorable exit from Hogwarts. During another Quidditch match, Hagrid enlists Harry and Hermione to follow him into the Forbidden Forest as a favor. Once deep within the trees, Hagrid reveals his project has been to tame his brother, a full-size giant named Grawp. Hagrid expects to be fired by Umbridge at any time, and wants Harry and Hermione to visit Grawp in his absence. On their return to campus, they find that Ron actually played well and helped Gryffindor win the Quidditch Cup. After much anticipation, O.W.L. exams begin and Harry excels at Defense Against the Dark Arts and performs generally well overall. During their Astronomy exam, Harry and fellow students watch as Ministry officials arrive at Hagrid’s cabin door and proceed to attack him. When Professor McGonagall arrives for protection, the Ministry representatives stun her without warning. Harry’s world becomes even more chaotic when he falls asleep during his History of Magic exam, only to see a new element in his dreams of the long corridors: Sirius being tortured by Voldemort. Harry assumes his vision to be real and thus mobilizes his friends to save Sirius. Despite Hermione’s cautions, Harry’s friends help him devise a plan to rescue Sirius, only to be caught by Umbridge and a band of students loyal to her. Umbridge frantically attempts to discover Harry’s plans and resolves to use the illegal, unforgivable Cruciatus curse on him. Just then, Hermione intervenes by pretending to confess all to Umbridge.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
P h o e n i x
Chapters 33–38 Umbridge’s student guards watch the others as Hermione and Harry lead Umbridge into the Forbidden Forest under the guise of revealing their plans. Once in the forest, as Hermione expected, the centaurs circle and attack Umbridge because she is an arrogant adult human. The centaurs would have allowed Harry and Hermione safe exit because of their youth but Hermione upsets them. It is not until Grawp comes to their rescue that the centaurs are driven away. At this point, Neville, Luna, Ron, and Ron’s sister Ginny escape Umbridge’s guards, meet Harry and Hermione in the forest, and plan their mission to save Sirius. Traveling via thestral, the group arrives at the Ministry of Magic only to find that Sirius is not there and that Harry fell into Voldemort’s trap. Harry finds a glass orb with his name on it, which he discovers has a prophecy explaining the connection between Harry and Voldemort. Voldemort desperately wants the prophecy but cannot gain it without Harry’s help. A battle ensues pitting several adult Death Eaters against Harry and his young friends. The Death Eaters chase Harry and friends through many enchanted rooms in the Department of Mysteries, being careful not to damage the prophecy as they battle. The students use their D.A. skills well, but are eventually overtaken by the adult wizards. Neville even faces his parents’ torturer, Bellatrix Lestrange. The Death Eaters are gaining ground when the Order of the Phoenix arrives, saving Harry and his friends. Unfortunately, the fight ends badly with the prophecy shattering and Sirius dying by falling through a magic veil. Harry angrily chases Lestrange, his godfather’s murderer, into the lobby of the Ministry, only to find Voldemort himself waiting for him. When Voldemort attempts to use the deadliest curse against Harry, Dumbledore appears and fights triumphantly to save Harry’s life. Later, in the Headmaster’s office, Harry rages against Dumbledore for not giving him any important information about his connection to Voldemort. Dumbledore humbly agrees, and takes responsibility for Harry’s mistakes and for Sirius’s death. He then says it is time for Harry to know the truth about his past. Harry listens attentively as Dumbledore explains how the prophecy foretells a connection between Harry and Voldemort that caused the evil wizard to attack
V o l u m e
1
2 7
H a r r y
P o t t e r
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
P h o e n i x
James’s close friend, Sirius serves as Harry’s godfather and closest adult confidant in the series. Harry relies on Sirius for friendship and advice.
MEDIA ADAPTATIONS
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix was released in an unabridged version on audio CD by the Listening Library in 2003. Jim Dale reads the part of Harry Potter. This CD is widely available through bookstores and online merchants.
him as a baby. Although Voldemort only knows half of the prophecy, Dumbledore heard the full prophecy from Professor Trelawney herself and reveals that ultimately Harry and Voldemort cannot coexist: one must kill the other. Harry also discovers that his mother’s bloodlines protect him when he stays with the Dursleys, despite his aunt and uncle’s foul treatment. Still distraught over losing his godfather, Harry prepares to return to the Dursleys for another summer. A glimmer of hope emerges as Luna explains how Harry might speak with Sirius through the veil, but he does not have a chance to try before leaving Hogwarts for the year. The Order of the Phoenix accompanies Harry to the train station, warning the Dursleys against any ill treatment of Harry over the summer. Harry finds some satisfaction in this newfound band of friends.
CHARACTERS Sirius Black Sirius attended Hogwarts with Harry’s father James, his mother Lily, and their close friend. Remus Lupin. Sirius is a fugitive in the wizardry community as he is believed to be a murderer, and follower of the evil Lord Voldemort. Both accusations prove false as he is actually a member of the Order of the Phoenix, a group dedicated to fighting Voldemort. However, Sirius must remain in hiding, often taking on the disguise of a black dog named Snuffles, or risk being sent back to prison. As
2 8
L i t e r a r y
Dobby Dobby is the house-elf that has attached itself to Harry as his loyal servant at Hogwarts. He suggests the secret meeting place that Harry and the others in the D.A. group can use to practice their Defense Against the Dark Arts.
Albus Dumbledore As the most powerful good wizard in the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ series, Dumbledore plays numerous roles in the wizardry world. He is the Headmaster of Hogwarts School, leader of the Order of the Phoenix, and highly influential advisor to the wizardry world’s governing bodies. Dumbledore also becomes Harry Potter’s mentor early in the series, although that relationship becomes strained in this book. Dumbledore is known as the only wizard Voldemort ever feared, and thus can offer Harry the best protection from the evil wizard. As readers see for the first time in the series, Dumbledore not only knows the answers to many of Harry’s deepest questions but he also remains the most powerful good wizard in the world. For the first time, Harry witnesses Dumbledore’s battle skills when he challenges Voldemort head-on at the end of the novel. Because Dumbledore keeps Harry isolated for much of the story, their usually close relationship does not reappear until the Headmaster apologizes to Harry in the final chapters.
Dudley Dursley Dudley is Harry’s cousin on his mother’s side. He appears at the beginning and end of each ‘‘Harry Potter’’ book because Harry lives with him during the summers between Hogwarts sessions. Dudley is babied by his parents, and baits Harry to get him in trouble. He becomes increasingly fatter and more aggressive in each book, and this year becomes an even bigger bully as he trains as a wrestler.
Petunia Dursley Petunia is Harry’s only living blood relative, his mother Lily’s sister, and thus holds the responsibility for his safekeeping. Much to her dismay, her shared bloodline with Harry’s mother provides Harry protection against
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H a r r y
P o t t e r
Voldemort while under her roof. Petunia, like her husband Vernon, hates the mere mention of magic and focuses her attention on coddling her only son Dudley.
Vernon Dursley Harry’s uncle by marriage, Vernon Dursley merely tolerates Harry’s presence at his house each summer. He hates all things magical, and forbids Harry to mention magic or Hogwarts in his home. He much prefers his own son Dudley over Harry, and cannot wait for his nephew to leave every fall for school.
Cornelius Fudge Minister of Magic for the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ series thus far, Fudge plays the role of generally incompetent bureaucrat. Often found wearing a green bowler-type hat, his physical appearance matches his equally inept leadership of the wizardry world. Convinced that Dumbledore wants to steal his position, Fudge constantly mocks any mention of Voldemort’s return as a way to undermine Dumbledore’s authority.
Hermione Granger Hermione Granger is Harry’s closest companion at Hogwarts, after Ron Weasley. The three students continue to be inseparable in this book, as they are in the other ‘‘Harry Potter’’ novels. Hermione plays the intellectual role to Ron’s sidekick part, always knowing the textbook answer to magic dilemmas. She is a straight A student who makes school and learning a priority, often urging Harry and Ron to be more attentive students. Hermione comes from a non-magic, or Muggle, family where she is the only witch. Although none of the sympathetic characters, such as Harry and Ron, consider Hermione any different, some in the wizardry world regard Muggle-borns as second class. Those who follow Voldemort, for example, use the derogatory name ‘‘mudblood’’ to describe witches and wizards of non-magic descent. As a result of this stigma, readers often witness Hermione’s championing of other oppressed magic creatures, such as the enslaved house-elves. Although Hermione’s strength of character and logical approach frequently extricate Harry and Ron from difficult circumstances, readers recognize that life is about more than books. It takes all three characters, and their gifts of bravery,
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
P h o e n i x
loyalty, and intelligence, to solve the problems in each ‘‘Harry Potter’’ novel.
Rubeus Hagrid A half giant, Hagrid strikes an intimidating figure with his large beard, unkempt clothes, and massive physical presence. He reappears in the fifth ‘‘Harry Potter’’ novel as more of a peer to Harry and his friends than an authority figure, despite his role as Care of Magical Creatures professor at Hogwarts. Harry, Ron, and Hermione feel especially affectionate towards Hagrid, whose rough appearance belies his sensitivity.
He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named See Voldemort
Kreacher Serving as the Black family house-elf, Kreacher lives with Sirius throughout the novel. He remains loyal to the dark wizards of the Black family, and thus constantly insults Sirius and the Order of the Phoenix members who stay at the house. Because house-elves are bound to their masters, Kreacher cannot leave or disobey Sirius until he receives a direct order. In the end, this loophole allows him to play a key role in trapping Harry Potter into meeting Voldemort.
Bellatrix Lestrange Sirius Black’s cousin, Bellatrix Lestrange has been in prison for fifteen years as a result of her allegiance to Voldemort. In this story, she breaks out of prison and helps provide Voldemort with information to lure Harry into his plot. Lestrange tortured Neville Longbottom’s parents into insanity, and she tortures Neville himself in the book’s final battle.
Neville Longbottom Classmate of Harry Potter’s, Neville is a close friend of Harry, Ron, and Hermione. Readers generally feel sorry for Neville because his clumsiness lands him in continually awkward or embarrassing situations. Also, his parents were driven insane by torture when Neville was a baby; his grandmother raised him. Neville appears in all five books, but gains a larger role in this novel as he bravely-but sometimes clumsily- fights Voldemort and the Death Eaters at the end.
V o l u m e
1
2 9
H a r r y
P o t t e r
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
Luna Lovegood
Alastor ‘‘Mad-Eye’’ Moody
A new character in the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ series, Luna Lovegood enters as a slightly strange classmate of Harry’s who tells odd stories about questionable creatures and events. Known to other students as ‘‘Loony,’’ Luna eventually becomes key to the story’s action when she fights Voldemort at the Ministry of Magic. Her father publishes the slightly offbeat newspaper, The Quibbler.
Another of the former Professors of Defense Against the Dark Arts at Hogwarts, Alastor ‘‘Mad-Eye’’ Moody is named for his magic eye that can see in all directions, even through the back of his head. He is a master of magical defense, and is thus a leader in the Order of the Phoenix. He takes special care of Harry’s safety in this book, and fights in the battle against Voldemort at the end.
Remus Lupin
Harry Potter
A werewolf, Remus Lupin entered Harry’s life as a Defense Against the Dark Arts Professor in a previous book. Because he knew Harry’s parents in school and serves as a member of the Order of the Phoenix, Lupin remains a mentor to Harry throughout his adventures.
Harry Potter is a young wizard celebrating his fifteenth birthday at the beginning of the story. His life has been a difficult one for someone so young: his parents were killed by the evil wizard, Voldemort, when Harry was only a baby, but when the wizard tried to kill him too, he survived. Harry has a scar in the shape of a lightning bolt on his forehead as a result of this event, which throbs with pain whenever Voldemort is near. The mystery of the story, and the larger ‘‘Harry Potter’’ series, asks why Harry was a target in the first place, how he managed to be the lone survivor of his family, and why Voldemort was nearly destroyed in the process. Harry’s achievement made him famous in the wizardry world, earning him the label ‘‘The Boy Who Lived.’’
Draco Malfoy Harry Potter’s chief rival at Hogwarts, Draco Malfoy serves as a constant irritant and bully to characters with whom readers sympathize. Draco represents Harry’s foil as he plays the same position in Quidditch, is a leader of Slytherin House, and attracts many followers because of his strong personality. He verbally taunts Harry and his friends throughout the school year. Also opposing Harry and causing conflict, Draco’s father Lucius follows Voldemort as a Death Eater.
Lucius Malfoy The character of Lucius Malfoy, Draco’s father, appears more frequently in the later ‘‘Harry Potter’’ novels. In Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Malfoy continues to serve Voldemort as a Death Eater and tries to influence the Minister of Magic towards the evil wizard’s cause. In the final battle, Malfoy fights Harry and his friends, only to be sent to prison once his allegiance to Voldemort becomes public knowledge.
Minerva McGonagall Professor McGonagall teaches Transfiguration at Hogwarts, leads Gryffindor House, and functions as Dumbledore’s second-in-command. She appears in every ‘‘Harry Potter’’ book, providing stern but fair friendship to Harry and his friends. She is also a member of the Order of the Phoenix.
3 0
P h o e n i x
L i t e r a r y
Earlier ‘‘Harry Potter’’ books describe Harry’s past in more detail. Despite Harry’s fame, those closest to him decided he should be raised by his non-magic relatives, the Dursleys, until age eleven. Treated poorly and kept ignorant of his past until then, Harry celebrated his eleventh birthday by discovering he was a wizard and that he would be attending Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. Harry’s entry into the wizardry world as a young boy unaware of his special powers made him a likeable, humble character to whom many readers could relate. Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix takes place during Harry’s fifth year at Hogwarts. Harry’s adolescence becomes apparent in this story; he spends much of his time moody, angry, and isolated. He faces many normal teenage pressures throughout the novel, such as dating, balancing homework and social activities, and considering his future. But he must also face the much larger responsibility of vanquishing Voldemort in order to save the entire wizardry world. In the end, Harry finds out more clues to his past, including the prophecy that predicts
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H a r r y
P o t t e r
that Harry and Voldemort cannot coexist, and that one will kill the other. The combination of these levels of stress cause the teenage Harry, normally even-tempered, to remain sensitive and brooding through most of the book.
Tom Riddle See Voldemort
Severus Snape Professor Snape teaches Potions at Hogwarts, although he covets the Defense Against Dark Arts position. Despite his application for that position every year, he mysteriously never receives it. Harry’s least favorite professor, Snape used to follow Voldemort as a Death Eater but has since reformed and become loyal to Dumbledore. Harry doubts Snape’s allegiance in each book, and finds even more reasons to hate him in this one. Snape appears to hate Harry back, as the story reveals that Harry’s father bullied Snape as a schoolboy. Snape expresses his aversion to Harry constantly, docking his grades in class and looking for ways to punish him outside of class.
Nymphadora Tonks Nymphadora Tonks works as an Auror and as a member of the Order of the Phoenix, appearing for the first time in this ‘‘Harry Potter’’ book. She answers only to her last name, and she can change bodily form at whim; she takes on various physical characteristics from short to long hair, small to tall stature, and young to old features. She fights in the final battle to save Harry at the end.
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
P h o e n i x
reigning in the wizardry world, Voldemort nearly died when he tried to kill Harry Potter fifteen years ago. Instead of dying, however, Voldemort maintained various states of existence in each of the earlier ‘‘Harry Potter’’ books. By the fifth installment, Voldemort regains a body and seeks to capture ultimate power by destroying Harry Potter. Born Tom Riddle, Voldemort actually has non-magic bloodlines despite his emphasis on pureblooded magic families. Riddle trained as a Hogwarts student under Dumbledore’s professorship, but turned evil as his talent and power increased. In this story, Voldemort’s cruelty becomes more apparent as readers witness him punishing and killing both foes and allies. Despite Voldemort’s inability to kill Harry by the end of the story, the prophecy foretells that neither can exist together. Rowling sets the stage for larger, more dangerous battles in the final two ‘‘Harry Potter’’ books.
Arthur Weasley Father of seven, Arthur Weasley also plays the role of surrogate father to Harry Potter. Ron brings Harry to his house early in the series, and Arthur makes the famous wizard feel at home for the first time in his life. A member of the Order of the Phoenix and working in the Misuse of Muggle Artifacts Department of the Ministry of Magic, Arthur also exhibits a special fondness for non-magic people. In this novel, Voldemort’s snake attacks Arthur and sends him to the hospital with serious injuries.
Fred and George Weasley
The latest Defense Against Dark Arts professor at Hogwarts, Umbridge plays the role of informant to the Ministry of Magic. She gains more and more power from the Ministry as the story goes on, eventually becoming High Inquisitor, or chief tattle tale, at Hogwarts. Umbridge attempts to control all activities and information inside the school, cruelly punishing any students who challenge her authority. Harry and his friends fight Umbridge’s new school policies all year long.
Ron’s older twin brothers Fred and George always appear together and provide comic relief throughout the story. They are typical Weasleys, with red hair and freckles, but show a penchant for mischief. Throughout the school year, Fred and George develop practical joke products, such as pills that make students vomit, or bleed from the nose, that they hope to sell in their own joke shop one day. Their elaborate and explosive departure from Hogwarts at the end of the term not only helps Harry in his quest to fight Voldemort, but, although not yet graduated, also marks their permanent exit from school.
Voldemort
Ginny Weasley
The most evil wizard in the world, Lord Voldemort recently returned to bodily form and seeks supreme power throughout this book. Once
Ron Weasley’s younger sister Ginny Weasley becomes less meek in this story than in previous ‘‘Harry Potter’’ books. With her apparent crush
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
Delores Umbridge
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
3 1
H a r r y
P o t t e r
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
on Harry in the past, Ginny becomes a stronger presence among the group of students training to fight Voldemort. She is more vocal about her opinions throughout the novel, and fights in the battles at the Ministry of Magic at the end.
P h o e n i x
You-Know-Who See Voldemort
THEMES Molly Weasley Mother of the Weasley clan, Molly becomes the surrogate mother to Harry and Hermione while they all stay at Sirius’s family house in this book. Molly plays a stereotypical motherly role as she cooks and cleans for the family, worries about her children constantly, and pesters everyone to behave correctly. Molly is also a member of the Order of the Phoenix. She is an especially lovable character because she cares for Harry as if he were her own son.
Ron Weasley
The largest mystery in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix surrounds Harry’s search for knowledge of himself and his place in the wizardry world. The novel opens with Harry’s constant attention to newspapers and news programs as he looks for any evidence of Voldemort’s return. When he finds nothing in his searches, he looks to letters from Ron and Hermione for information. At Dumbledore’s request, those letters similarly contain little helpful news. Once at the Order of the Phoenix, Harry’s quest for answers becomes partially satisfied as he learns that Voldemort still lies in wait, spending his energies gathering supporters and looking for a new kind of ‘‘weapon.’’ But the larger questions about Voldemort’s long-term strategies and the Order’s plans to defend the wizardry community evade Harry. Members of the Order, led by Dumbledore, contend that Harry should only be told what ‘‘he needs to know’’ and little else.
Ron Weasley, known only to his mother as ‘‘Ronald,’’ continues to play the role of Harry Potter’s best friend in Rowling’s fifth ‘‘Harry Potter’’ book. Tall, lanky, and red haired, Ron comes from a large family with little money, opening him up to constant mocking from his fellow students. Besides helping Harry cope with the larger challenges of Voldemort’s return, Ron also struggles with his own insecurities about school and social activities. Not a stellar student, he breaks into athletics in this book as he becomes the Gryffindor Quidditch team’s goalie. His performance is generally poor until the end of the story, causing the already insecure Ron to doubt himself even more. Readers will notice a romantic undercurrent in the constant bickering between Ron and Harry’s other best friend Hermione Granger. Ron’s greatest weaknesses lie in his envy of the money and skill Harry seems to come by so naturally. But he remains Harry’s loyal companion through all adventures and, even when his magical skills do not compare to the famous Harry Potter’s, Ron’s uncompromising friendship endears him to readers.
Harry’s initial curiosity about Voldemort seems to be unfounded adolescent energy. Many adult readers might agree at the beginning of the novel that, although he did play a key role in the community-altering events of the previous year, Harry indeed should be protected from further involvement because of his youth. In fact, Dumbledore clearly expresses this view in the final scenes of the novel: ‘‘I cared more for your happiness than your knowing the truth . . . .’’ But Harry’s instincts serve him well; his search for knowledge of Voldemort proved not to be mere teenage arrogance but rather a longing for self-knowledge. Dumbledore explains a great deal to Harry about himself in the end, and gives him many keys to unlock his past and his future. Although some of this knowledge, especially Harry’s destiny to kill or be killed by Voldemort, weighs heavily on the fifteen-yearold. Dumbledore tells him, ‘‘I know you have long been ready for the knowledge I have kept from you for so long, because you have proved that I should have placed the burden upon you before this.’’
Percy Weasley Fastidious son of Arthur and Molly Weasley, Percy spends The Order of the Phoenix estranged from his family. His loyalty lies with his boss, the Minister of Magic, and he turns his back on his father’s work with the Order of the Phoenix.
3 2
Search for Knowledge
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H a r r y
P o t t e r
Good and Evil The forces of good and evil battle fiercely in each ‘‘Harry Potter’’ book, as Harry and Voldemort square off by the end of each adventure. But as Harry matures, so does his understanding of good and evil forces in the world. As Sirius Black explains ‘‘with a wry smile,’’ there are many ambiguities in the adult world, and that world ‘‘isn’t split into good people and Death Eaters.’’ Delores Umbridge and the Ministry of Magic provide the most compelling examples of the complex moral world in which Harry now finds himself. The Ministry’s mission, led by Minister Cornelius Fudge, should be to use the governmental structures to protect and benefit the lives of witches and wizards. Although the actions of Fudge and Umbridge illustrate character flaws that range from incompetence to cruelty, neither character should be read as wholly evil. Both characters believe they seek the good of the community. Fudge’s attempt to discredit Dumbledore’s story of Voldemort’s return stems from his insecurity and fear of losing power. Yet this discrediting falls far short of Death Eater–type evil. Even Umbridge’s mean-spirited manipulation of Hogwarts students illustrates her own struggles with control rather than indicating a penchant for true evil. Umbridge’s willingness to torture the truth out of Harry only proves the complex relationship that exists between good intentions and evil outcomes. Harry must navigate these cloudy waters as he grows up, doing his best to react appropriately to the sometimes wrongheaded but well-intentioned individuals that populate much of the world, while still recognizing true evil when he faces it. Rowling’s representation of a complex moral atmosphere explains her novels’ broad appeal to both children and adults.
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
P h o e n i x
agree. Voldemort, despite not being pure-blood, draws primary support from pure-blooded wizardry families such as the Malfoys and the Blacks. Keeping the wizardry legacy ‘‘pure’’ drives much of the Death Eaters’ actions and therefore plays a crucial role in Voldemort’s larger plan. From wanting Hogwarts to serve exclusively pure-blooded students, to subjecting lesser orders of magical creatures to servitude, Rowling depicts a world of social segregation much like readers’ own. As Hermione battles attitudes such as Draco Malfoy’s about her heritage, it is not surprising that she becomes an advocate for those in servitude, like the house-elves. Throughout their school year, Harry and Ron watch Hermione attempt to free the Hogwarts house-elves by giving them clothing, and more specifically, by knitting them hats. Rowling demonstrates the complexity of social oppression, however, as many house-elves do not wish to be free and actually resent Hermione’s attempts to trick them into independence. In its attempt to band together against Voldemort’s return, moreover, the wizardry community must pay for injustices done to nonhuman magical creatures. Difficulty with the giants, the centaurs, and even the Dementors present obstacles to a unified front against Voldemort. Dumbledore explains, ‘‘We wizards have mistreated and abused our fellows for too long, and we are now reaping our reward.’’ Social order grows in prominence as a theme in each subsequent ‘‘Harry Potter’’ novel, certainly foreshadowing its role as one of the central conflicts to be resolved in the larger series.
Adolescence
The last few ‘‘Harry Potter’’ novels introduce the ancillary theme of social order in the wizardry and Muggle worlds. Indeed, readers learn the difference between what are considered pure-blood wizards and what are negatively labeled ‘‘mudbloods’’ in as early as the second book. Hermione Granger represents the latter as she is the only witch in her non-magical family. Most of the wizardry world overlooks such distinctions but as Voldemort and his followers gain more power, readers see that not all wizards
With whispers of romance beginning during the last school year, this year at Hogwarts sees Harry’s first kiss, and Hermione’s flirtations with Ron and a student from another school. Harry finds courtship to be a rocky road as he attempts to date the pretty Ravenclaw Seeker, Cho Chang. Previously Cedric’s girlfriend, Cho spends much of her time with Harry crying about her former boyfriend’s death. As any teenage boy would, Harry vacillates between feeling terrified and frustrated at the young girl’s constant tears. Even with Hermione’s attempts to translate Cho’s emotional state, Harry is relieved when their brief romance ends. The flirtation between Ron and Hermione, in contrast,
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
Social Order
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
3 3
H a r r y
P o t t e r
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
P h o e n i x
TOPICS FOR FURTHER STUDY
In a two-page essay, compare the Ministry of Magic to your government: where do you see successes or failures in each? Where do you see abuses of power like those perpetrated by Cornelius Fudge or Delores Umbridge? Where do you see progress being made by leaders such as Albus Dumbledore or Arthur Weasley?
How does your school compare to Hogwarts? In his fifth year, Harry faces extremely difficult standardized exams. Provide examples of characters for which the tests were effective as well as individuals for whom the exams were not a fair judge of talent or intelligence. What is Rowling’s attitude towards standardized tests? How does your school or community evaluate student progress? What are the benefits and shortcomings in each world? Write a one-page summary on your findings.
Professor Umbridge and the Ministry of Magic constantly censor and control the information available to both Hogwarts students and the wizardry community as a whole. Especially through the newspaper, the Daily Prophet, the Ministry attempts to control the messages presented to the community about Voldemort’s return. The Ministry
appears to be growing throughout their fifth year together. Constantly bickering so that Harry is reminded of a married couple, the two cannot admit their attraction to each other yet, but readers clearly see a relationship in their future. Ron’s jealousy at Hermione’s pen-pal relationship with Viktor especially highlights that Hermione is more than just a friend. Not to be left out of the social activity, Ginny Weasley also begins dating during the school year; even though she was previously infatuated with Harry. By the end of the school year, though, they have broken up only for Ginny to
3 4
L i t e r a r y
even goes as far as denying what it knows to be true in an effort to keep the peace. In a one-page essay, compare these governmental strategies with ones you observe today, in the age of terrorism and global threats. How and why might your government attempt to control threatening information? What are the benefits of managing information in this way? What are the dangers?
Analyze Professor Snape’s role in Harry Potter’s life. On one hand, he intentionally singles out Harry and mistreats him. On the other hand, he provides wise advice to him during Occlumency lessons: ‘‘Fools who wear their hearts proudly on their sleeves, who cannot control their emotions . . . stand no chance against [Voldemort’s] powers. . . . Control your anger, discipline your mind!’’ How might this direction have helped Harry in the novel? Further, what does Rowling intend for readers to think about Snape? Clearly, Dumbledore and most of the Order of the Phoenix members trust him but Harry does not. What will Snape’s role be in Harry’s future? How should readers understand his character? Write a brief essay explaining your opinions.
date still another boy. Perhaps foreshadowing a relationship in the future, Ron subtly expresses his disappointment that his sister is not dating his best friend Harry. Another adolescent factor in the novel’s focus is Harry’s struggle to master his moods. From feeling sad and alone with his nightmares, to feeling elated and surrounded by true friends, Harry’s emotional states vary widely throughout his fifth year. As many teenagers do, Harry often feels isolated from his peers because of his unique experiences. He becomes angry when other people believe they understand exactly
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H a r r y
P o t t e r
what he is going through. In these cases, Harry often spends long periods of time alone, whereas he used to seek the company of his friends. Isolation remains a hallmark of teenage life, and when Harry does find himself with company, he often becomes quickly angry at them. Growing frustrated more often with Ron and Hermione, Harry admits that he ‘‘wasn’t even sure why he was feeling so angry.’’ Rowling describes Harry’s ‘‘temper,’’ like many normal adolescents, as ‘‘always so close to the surface these days.’’ Harry’s moodiness and resulting sarcastic or biting remarks, in addition to his newly growing romantic relationships, place him squarely within the typical teenage world.
STYLE Series From the beginning, Rowling envisioned the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ series to be comprised of seven books, one for each year of Harry’s schooling at Hogwarts. The series follow the lives of the same main characters—Harry, Ron, and Hermione—through each novel and continues the narrative from one book to the next. One way to view the series is to consider the overall series as one book, with each novel acting as a chapter. Although each of the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ books can stand independently, there are several threads that link the series together, and each subsequent novel moves the characters and the plot forward. The opening chapters of each book include a brief summary of events that have transpired in the previous books, keeping the reader informed of earlier plot action and acting as an introduction to the series for firsttime readers. As the series draws to a close, major plot points and themes begin to move toward the final culminating battle between Harry and Voldemort. Rowling utilizes foreshadowing to hook the reader’s interest in the climax and resolutions to be revealed in the remaining books in the series.
Third-Person Limited Omniscient Point of View
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
P h o e n i x
events from an outside perspective, but reveals the perceptions of one or more characters. As opposed to presenting information through characters’ conversations, their observations, or their activities, Rowling instead allows readers to witness Harry’s thoughts in this novel. While still at the Dursleys, Harry sits quietly on a swing ruminating about Cedric’s death in the graveyard; many scenes echo this first glimpse into Harry’s psychological struggles, as he begins to search himself for answers rather than taking every problem immediately to Ron and Hermione, as in other books. More than once, Harry decides not to talk to his friends until he has thought deeply about his problems. Sometimes Harry is not even certain why he does not want to talk to his friends: ‘‘He was not really sure why he was not telling Ron and Hermione exactly what was happening. . . .’’ Rowling writes, but eventually, he does bring major concerns to his friends, who then discuss strategies for solving those problems.
HISTORICAL CONTEXT Government and the War on Terror The ‘‘Harry Potter’’ series can only be understood as creating a cultural phenomenon all on its own. With 80 million books in print by the release of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, as well as the continuing success of each Warner Brothers film adaptation, Rowling’s writing will demand its own account in future history books. But the novels do reflect some of the cultural atmosphere of the early twenty-first century. While the majority of the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ series was published during the years of western economic prosperity, the fifth novel follows the September 11, 2001 attacks and the subsequent global war on terror. Some of the darker tone of the fifth novel echoes the more negative global atmosphere present afterSeptember 11th. Additionally, religious protests continue to hound Rowling’s series, as some readers find the magical content morally questionable.
In spite of the fact that the novel is written from a third-person perspective, throughout much of the book Rowling reveals clues through Harry’s perspective. Using third-person limited omniscient point of view, an author presents the
During the years following more terrorist attacks on western targets, political tensions in the United Kingdom increased as Prime Minister Tony Blair supported American President George Bush’s war in Iraq. It would perhaps be an overstatement to say that Rowling
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
3 5
H a r r y
P o t t e r
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
intended to criticize this specific governmental policy with her plot of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix; still, readers may be specifically attuned to the generally critical tone toward authority in the story. The Ministry of Magic, led by fumbling Minister Cornelius Fudge, provides little protection for the magic community as he refuses to release factual information about Voldemort’s return. Further, Delores Umbridge’s militant control of information within Hogwarts castle and The Daily Prophet’s censorship of news reports also provide parallels to the political atmosphere of the time. Readers may recognize a similar attitude of governmental mistrust as both Blair and Bush were criticized for withholding or manipulating intelligence information that led to Iraq’s invasion. Media scandals with the BBC and the New York Times additionally reverberate with action in the novel.
Conservative Opposition Although the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ series enjoyed unmatched popularity in the majority of markets, more conservative religious populations continued to raise concerns about the morality of magic. Religious objections about the magic content of the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ series ranged from mild concerns about children who solve their problems with magic rather than honest effort, to extreme accusations of evil and anti-biblical representations of devil worship. There have even been several, although not well-received, instances of ‘‘Harry Potter’’ censorship and book burnings. Television shows such as 60 Minutes detailed these protests, but their influence was only marginal compared to the widespread celebration of the novels’ positive influence on children.
Reading Renaissance Generally, Rowling’s books are credited with reintroducing an entire generation of children to the joys of reading. News reports often gleefully cite images of ten-year-olds tearing through 800-page books, and staying up late at night reading. There are even medical reports describing patterns of children complaining of neck cramps caused by excessive time spent reading ‘‘Harry Potter’’ novels. On the whole, Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix continues to speak to an entire generation of child and adult readers because of their high entertainment value.
3 6
L i t e r a r y
P h o e n i x
CRITICAL OVERVIEW Critical reaction to Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix reflects significant attention to the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ series in general; that is, the largest debate surrounds whether Rowling’s writing earns consideration as quality, valid, adult literature. Critics are asking the same question often asked of any text enjoying enormous popularity: Is it any good? To answer the question of literary merit, scholars approach Rowling’s work from a number of perspectives. Considerations of genre, style, and content provide fodder for both sides of the debate, and establish a considerable argument that ‘‘Harry Potter’’ may not qualify as substantial literature. To the contrary, it should be taken seriously for its literary depth and topical merit. Categorizing Rowling’s writing becomes difficult for several reasons. First, a series of seven books with a maturing main character makes labeling the whole of the work much more complicated. In an effort to understand where these books fit into the world of literature, critics focus primarily on the novels as members of the Fantasy or Great Novel genre. In either case, numerous critics argue that Rowling does or does not fit the standards for that genre. Fantasy, for instance, draws the constant attention of writers because of the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ books’ many similarities with J. R. R. Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings trilogy. Some of the most ardent detractors of Rowling’s work also use Tolkien as their basis of comparison, citing his deep allegorical content as vastly superior to Rowling’s more childlike and humorous stories. Highly prominent writers A. S. Byatt and William Safire join these ranks in their New York Times articles, with Byatt calling the books ‘‘jokey’’ rather than substantial, and Safire claiming the books are ‘‘not written on two levels’’ and therefore, ‘‘prizeworthy culture [they] ain’t.’’ Just as many critics have rallied in Rowling’s defense, however, stockpiling evidence that the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ books are as serious contributions to the genres of fantasy and novel as even Tolkien’s and C. S. Lewis’s. Writing for the journal Topic, Miranda Maney Yaggi uses Tolkien’s own guidelines to validate the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ series, while Steven Barfield, in the same journal, classifies Rowling’s works as a subcategory called ‘‘satirical fantasy.’’ Paige
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H a r r y
P o t t e r
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
P h o e n i x
Alan Rickman, Emma Watson, Rupert Grint, and Daniel Radcliffe starred in several films based on the series Ó Warner Bros. Pictures/ZUMA/Corbis
Byam, also in Topic, even argues that Rowling’s stories fit into the great tradition of British novels, following in Charles Dickens’s and Charlotte Bronte¨’s footsteps.
out there and serve as valuable examples of what good writing can and should be.’’
Next, many readers evaluate Rowling’s writing style to determine how worthy her texts might be for serious literary consideration. One of the most prominent recent literary scholars, Harold Bloom, famously weighed in on this debate, using the Wall Street Journal to call Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone ‘‘heavy on cliche´,’’ ‘‘inadequate,’’ and ‘‘not well written.’’ Because of its ‘‘aesthetic weakness,’’ Bloom relegates Rowling’s work to ‘‘the dustbins of the ages.’’ Philip Hensher agrees, in his Spectator review of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, basing his judgment on Rowling’s simplistic writing style that falls short of eloquence. Among the throngs of readers who disagree with Bloom is Kathleen McEvoy, also writing in Topic, who demonstrates the aesthetic beauty of Rowling’s writing style. McEvoy details the intricate organization and assiduously structured form in the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ novels, stating that ‘‘the beautiful architecture’’ of the books makes them ‘‘as structurally sound as any work
Finally, readers disagree on the appropriateness of the magic content in the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ series. Especially as the novels grow darker and more mature, some conservative Christian groups find the magic to be too alluring for young, impressionable minds. The Christian Broadcasting Network website provides several articles showing parents’ and communities’ concerns over how magic in the novels may influence occult practices among their children. Communities and school districts must enter this debate especially since the film versions of ‘‘Harry Potter’’ have debuted, and decide whether to allow or ban the books from their classrooms. In rare instances, the theme of magic in Rowling’s works has been alleged to encourage devil worship and has spawned actual bookburnings. Opposing these opinions, however, many writers detail the positive moral content within Rowling’s texts, and claim they enrich and embolden their young readers’ lives. In response to those who would ban ‘‘Harry Potter,’’ Lee Ann Diffendal argues in Topic that the series actually promotes Judeo-Christian
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
3 7
H a r r y
P o t t e r
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
standards and ‘‘contains classic philanthropic lessons on loyalty, faith, courage, and friendship.’’ Thus, despite the various controversial aspects of Rowling’s ever popular series, readers and scholars alike find material to bolster both sides of the literary worthiness debate, undoubtedly underscoring the series’ merit and cultural importance.
P h o e n i x
THE TRUE GENIUS OF ROWLING’S LATEST ‘HARRY POTTER’ ADVENTURE REVEALS ITSELF IN HER RELENTLESS ATTENTION TO CHARACTER COMPLEXITY, WHICH INDICATES A LEVEL OF LITERARY MERIT. INTELLIGENT ADULT READERS MAY JUSTIFY THEIR LOVE OF THESE BOOKS IN ROWLING’S MATURE AND
CRITICISM
ELABORATE CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT.’’
Laura Baker Shearer Shearer holds a Ph.D. in American literature and works as an English professor and freelance writer. In this essay, Shearer examines character complexity in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix and questions elite scholars who discount the text’s literary worthiness. As Rowling completes each installment in her ‘‘Harry Potter’’ series, and as these novels draw more and more readers the world over, substantial scholarship about the popular literature grows. For the most part, critics have become increasingly willing to take the texts seriously, developing numerous literary strategies to interpret and evaluate what were originally considered mere children’s books. Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix offers a similarly wide landscape for literary analysis, especially in the area of character development. By this fifth year in Harry Potter’s education at Hogwarts, readers may feel they know the main characters on a deep level. Rowling does not fail, however, to thwart expectations regarding most of the main characters, leaving Harry’s world much less secure than in past books in the series. It is this unexpected complexity that adds rich texture to what may otherwise have been a predictable storyline. A few members of the academic elite still refuse to recognize genuine literary merit in the popular series—possibly because of its very popularity—and ignore the elements that ‘‘Harry Potter’’ books share with the novels of great literature. While their evaluations have some credibility, the wholesale dismissal of a large adult readership as juvenile and regressive raises red flags and calls for a closer inspection. The true genius of Rowling’s latest ‘‘Harry Potter’’ adventure reveals itself in her relentless attention to character complexity, which indicates a level of writing worthy of literary merit. Intelligent adult readers may justify
3 8
L i t e r a r y
their love of these books in Rowling’s mature and elaborate character development. The vivid characters and compelling storyline in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix provide a magnetic, energetic, and engrossing literary experience that overcomes the few artistic flaws some critics address. Suspicious of the series’ large readership, prominent critics such as Harold Bloom, William Safire, and A. S. Byatt believe many adult fans do not use an adequately critical eye when reading ‘‘Harry Potter’’ books. Contrary to these criticisms, the fifth ‘‘Harry Potter’’ novel presents itself as good literature not simply because numerous readers enjoy it but because it provides many avenues for literary inquiry. For instance, Kathleen McEvoy in Topic locates merit in the intricate ‘‘architectural’’ plot Rowling unravels within and across each book. John Leonard of the New York Times finds the literary spark in the veritable ‘‘cluster bombs’’ of creative curses, creatures, and characters with which the book overflows. One may extend literary analysis of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix by appreciating the extensive and surprising character development within the story, which sees many of the main characters change in ways that create complexity not only in themselves but in plot development and reader expectations. The series hero, Harry Potter, undergoes an extensive character transformation during his fifteenth year. In addition to the bravery and courage readers expect to find in their favorite boy wizard, they also encounter some less-thanappealing personality traits as he enters the heart of his adolescence. A certain moodiness associated with teenage years is to be expected, but
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H a r r y
P o t t e r
Harry’s erratic emotions may strain reader sympathy. Harry lashes out at his best friends, Ron and Hermione, and ultimately at his beloved mentor, Albus Dumbledore. His behavior causes readers, for the first time, to question the series’ protagonist. Readers’ skepticism is justified when, in the end, Harry ignores all warnings and endangers his closest friends. Leading toward the final battle at the Ministry of Magic, readers recognize the mistakes Harry makes as he disengages with his school community and withdraws into the world of his dark dreams. Readers’ sympathy is stretched the farthest when they discover Harry enjoying his ventures into Voldemort’s mind: ‘‘The truth was that he was so intensely curious about what was hidden in that room full of dusty orbs that he was quite keen for the dreams to continue.’’ Even though a certain level of curiosity seems normal, Harry quickly falls into the traps of vanity and selfimportance as he chases after Voldemort’s thoughts. Voldemort capitalizes on Harry’s mistakes and, in the process, Harry causes permanent damage to the wizarding community. Harry had certainly made mistakes in his previous years at Hogwarts, but it is not until his fifth year that his own ego begins to affect his otherwise generally selfless decision-making. Presenting her hero in this more negative light allows Rowling to add depth and drama to her narrative. Harry’s actions also become more difficult for readers to predict, adding interest and complexity to what could have been a simplistic, childish story. Harry’s constant companions, Ron and Hermione, also find different roles in this installment. Usually the loyal sidekick and the brainy bookworm, Ron’s and Hermione’s respective roles fade throughout this school year as a result of Harry’s increasing isolation. Readers expect the three friends to solve the book’s mystery together, as they have in previous novels. This year, however, Harry excludes his friends from his troubles. From the beginning, when they meet again at Twelve, Grimmauld Place, Harry vents his frustrations by yelling at his friends. Throughout the novel, Harry chooses to lash out at Ron and Hermione rather than invite their help in solving his problems. Readers may find this choice distasteful because the three friends have found such success working together in the past. When Harry ultimately
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
P h o e n i x
makes his fateful blunder by believing Voldemort has captured Sirius, Hermione’s remarkably accurate warning echoes in readers’ ears: ‘‘[D]on’t you think you’ve got a bit of a— a—saving-people-thing? . . . Voldemort knows you, Harry! . . . What if he’s just trying to get you into the Department of Myst[eries]?’’ If Harry had not responded to Hermione’s reasonable, and correct, prediction by flying into a rage, perhaps he would have avoided his tragic error. The exclusion of his faithful friends from Harry’s internal struggles, and Ron’s and Hermione’s subsequent reactions, gives readers a new perspective on these well-known and wellloved characters. It also marks the end of Harry’s—and the series’—reliance on the teamwork of childhood and the beginning of his isolation and singularity of adulthood. Dumbledore further confounds readers’ expectations in the novel. Nearly omniscient in every other book, Dumbledore knows all about Harry’s exploits, both legal and otherwise, and seems to hold (and withhold) the answers to all of Harry’s questions. But in this story, Dumbledore’s absence becomes more noticeable than his presence. While Harry excludes his friends from his troubles, he deeply longs for his mentor’s advice. Much to Harry’s disappointment, Dumbledore continues to evade his company. In the end, readers are again disturbed to find that Dumbledore commits an error as fatal as Harry’s: he suppresses crucial information that could have saved Sirius Black’s life. ‘‘For I see now,’’ Dumbledore confesses, ‘‘that what I have done, and not done, with regard to you, bears all the hallmarks of the failings of age. . . . An old man’s mistake.’’ Dumbledore’s god-like image shatters by the end of The Order of the Phoenix as readers witness his fallibility and increasing frailty. This character change forces readers to reconfigure their understanding of Hogwarts as a secure place under Dumbledore’s reign. Rowling’s undermining of Dumbledore’s authority shifts the power structure in the wizarding world, leaving Harry Potter more alone than ever. Harry’s godfather, Sirius Black, also undergoes a change in characterization throughout the novel. In the previous books in the series, the mature Black offered Harry his only true father figure. However, Rowling diminishes Black’s reputation in The Order of the Phoenix by depicting him as a moody and selfish adolescent.
V o l u m e
1
3 9
H a r r y
P o t t e r
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
Why does she present Black in such a negative light when he dies at the end? Revealing the chinks in Harry’s godfather’s armor is not at all unexpected, as many critics point out, because Harry must learn to become independent of the godfather whom he resembles so closely. But Sirius represents a small respite from an exhausting and challenging world for Harry. Could Sirius have not left the wizarding world with his godfatherly tenderness intact? Rowling’s presentation of Black’s faults, like Dumbledore’s, causes Harry’s world to become less stable, and readers’ expectations to be continually challenged. Severus Snape embodies a final conundrum. Rowling continues to taunt readers with his mean-spirited treatment of Harry in their public and private meetings, but once readers witness Snape’s own childhood trauma, they feel sympathy towards him, and perhaps even begin to understand why he is what he is. Harry feels a similar, though tentative, connection because of this shared humiliation. In the end, though, Harry refuses their bond, vowing to himself that ‘‘he would never forgive Snape . . . never.’’ Presumably, Harry feels such anger toward Snape, because Snape was unhelpful during the violent battle with Voldemort and the Death Eaters. However, readers may not blame Snape so harshly. It is at this point that they may feel an uncomfortable distance and near-judgment of Harry, whom they have championed and sympathized with since his first year at Hogwarts. Such complex threads of character development keep Rowling’s narrative multidimensional and thus worthy of literary considera-tion. Critics Bloom, Safire, and Byatt deny this achievement, however, citing the text’s popularity as evidence of less-than-discerning readers and citing the work as greatly over-praised and under-scrutinized. They explain away Rowling’s massive adult readership as evidence of immature grown-ups seeking the comforts of childhood. It is, however, in Byatt’s concluding comments about cultural studies that these elite critics’ true objection seems to lie. Byatt blames the Rowling ‘‘phenomenon’’ on ‘‘the leveling effect of cultural studies, which are as interested in hype and popularity as they are in literary merit, which they don’t really believe exists.’’ This obvious aggression toward the inclusive values of cultural studies may explain the threat some critics perceive in Rowling and their wholesale
4 0
L i t e r a r y
P h o e n i x
rejection of the nearly monopolistic cultural popularity she enjoys. The last thirty years have brought vast changes to the academic world as scholars have sought to break open the closed and maledominated realm of higher education. Wanting to recover female, multi-ethnic, and multiclassed presences for serious study at a university level, academics now examine nontraditional texts with academic standards previously reserved for classics. In literature, for example, critics review letters, diaries, and even recipes of women and people of color as a way to recover and fully understand those voices. Because only the privileged and educated individuals in most societies found time or avenues for artistic endeavor, groundbreaking academics attempt to include marginalized forms and voices to redefine what might be considered art. Part of this movement includes the new practice of reading what the masses read and considering popular work alongside more traditional art. This dynamic is the ‘‘leveling’’ of which Byatt speaks, and it is the threat Rowling presents to the body of so-called great literature. What Bloom, Safire, and Byatt fail to recognize, it seems, is that Rowling’s novels are not considered good literature exclusively or even primarily because of their popularity. Few, if any, serious analyses of Rowling’s texts state that the novels are worthy pieces of literature solely because so many adult readers love them. Some certainly take the cultural studies standpoint that their massive popularity should cause critics to take notice of Rowling’s work, but the final judgment of the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ series still depends upon a set of literary criteria. It is not, as Byatt claims, that scholars of Rowling do not believe in ‘‘literary merit’’; it is instead that they believe merit may be found in the most unusual, and potentially popular, places. In his Wall Street Journal article, Bloom contemplates the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ books and rightly asks, ‘‘Why read, if what you read will not enrich mind or spirit or personality?’’ The deeply textured characterization found in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix is one of the reasons that the novel can be called greatly enriching. Rowling’s books do not, as Bloom, Safire, and Byatt claim, lull readers into an entertainment haze. Instead, they cause readers to think about how characters have grown over
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H a r r y
P o t t e r
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
P h o e n i x
WHAT DO I READ NEXT? Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone (1998) is Rowling’s first installment in her series about the young wizard. In it, Harry first discovers he is a wizard; he also learns that the world of magic will offer him a home, a place to find friends, and to fit in. Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets (1999) continues Harry’s journey through his second year at Hogwarts. Rowling shows Harry facing Voldemort for the second time and learning he has more in common with the evil wizard than he ever imagined.
The Return of the King were initially published in 1954 and 1955 as three separate installments and have enjoyed a resurgence in popularity as a result of its recent Hollywood film adaptations. In his trilogy, Tolkien presents a rich fantasy world, often considered more allegorical and mature than Rowling’s series, that follows the search for goodness in the face of terrible evil.
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban (1999) follows Harry’s third year at Hogwarts and takes on a darker tone than in earlier books. The evil Harry faces appears greater, but so do his rewards, including a newfound father figure.
Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire (2000) takes the series in a much more mature direction. With action beginning in the early pages, Rowling’s 700-page story introduces numerous new characters and presents adult situations, including a murder.
J. R. R. Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring, The Two Towers, and
the years and to ponder their unpredictable and potentially precarious fates in the final books. Source: Laura Baker Shearer, Critical Essay on Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, in Literary Newsmakers for Students, Thomson Gale, 2006.
Page Byam In the following excerpt, Byam argues that the Harry Potter series compares favorably with other classic British novels, and deserves attention and respect for its ‘‘adult’’ literary merits.
Cornelia Funke’s Inkheart (2003) is the story of Meggie, whose father Mo has the ability to read characters into and out of books. When one of the evil characters he has accidentally read out of a book called ‘‘Inkheart’’ wants to use Mo’s power for his own wicked plans, Meggie, Mo, and their friends must escape capture and find the author of ‘‘Inkheart’’ to rewrite a new ending.
The Sword in the Stone by T. H. White (1978) tells the classic story of young King Arthur as he trains under the tutelage of the magician Merlin to become a gentleman and a knight. All of his training leads to the day when he pulls the sword from the stone and becomes the King of England.
first two novels in the series had been published, it was already very clear that their author, J. K. Rowling, had engaged a new generation of readers, especially among the elementary-school-age crowd. It was also apparent that adults were reading the books in huge numbers, and I became interested in this phenomenon—as well as eagerly anticipating each book in the series for my own part.
Often, great success brings controversy: such is the case for the Harry Potter series. After the
However, it is the cult status of the series among adults that has drawn much criticism and created controversy since that time. Many debates, inside of the academy and out, have
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
4 1
H a r r y
P o t t e r
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
I SIDE WITH THOSE WHO BELIEVE THAT THE HARRY POTTER SERIES NOT ONLY DESERVES THE ATTENTION IT IS GETTING BECAUSE OF ITS IMAGINATIVE QUALITIES AND COMPELLING STORYLINE, BUT ALSO BECAUSE OF ITS ‘‘ADULT’’ LITERARY MERITS.’’
focused on whether or not the Harry Potter books are ‘‘just’’ children’s books, and whether they have literary merit. This controversy erupted most spectacularly in the New York Times’s placing of the Harry Potter books on its ‘‘Best Seller List.’’ Because the huge, long-term success of the Harry Potter books placed the books in the series atop the list and left little room for books aimed strictly at adult readers, the New York Times decided to put them into a newly created children’s best-seller list. Commenting on this decision in July of 2000, Charles McGrath, the editor of the New York Times Book Review, stated: The sales and popularity of children’s books can rival and, in the case of the Harry Potter books, even exceed those of adult books . . . With a separate children’s list we can more fully represent what people are reading, and we can clear more room on the adult list for adult books.
Some regarded this as an attempt to quash adult interest in the series by sending out a message to readers that the Harry Potter books are really children’s fiction and that adults were not supposed to read the series. Also, placement on the new children’s list did a disservice to the series by not reflecting how many copies of each book sold each week compared to ‘‘adult’’ best-sellers. At the very least, the New York Times’s decision to create a separate children’s bestseller list was a strategy to shift attention away from the Harry Potter series. At this point in time, 7 July 2000, ‘‘one or more of the three books in the J. K. Rowling Harry Potter series [had] commanded spots on the adult fiction bestseller list for 81 weeks to date.’’ Removing the Harry
4 2
L i t e r a r y
P h o e n i x
Potter books from the adult bestseller list was a marketing decision designed to obscure the fact that the series was still outselling top adult fiction and that no other children’s book approached it in sales at the time. I side with those who believe that the Harry Potter series not only deserves the attention it is getting because of its imaginative qualities and compelling storyline, but also because of its ‘‘adult’’ literary merits. I will argue here that the Harry Potter series fits well into ‘‘the great tradition’’ of British novels that is still taught in college classrooms, beginning with Samuel Richardson, continued by Jane Austen, and culminating in the efforts of Charlotte Bronte¨ and Charles Dickens. Perhaps it is the sense of ‘‘fun’’ and the comedic element that we encounter—especially in books one to four of the series—that makes some people think that the books are not for adults, and that they do not fit into the ‘‘great tradition’’ of the novel. In many cases, the problems and even tragedies that Harry encounters are resolved or diminished and not left for readers to ponder, as in many other classic British novels. While this pattern of resolution is less typical of ‘‘adult’’ classics, it should not be used as a reason for knocking the Harry Potter series out of the ‘‘adult’’ fiction category. Critics may have judged the series by the first two or three books, prematurely placing it in the children’s literature category. The New York Times’s decision came in July 2000, before Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban could be properly digested, and three years before the publication of the most ‘‘adult’’ book—in terms of content— to date, Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix. Another reason some critics think the Harry Potter books are not for adult readers is simply because the hero is not grown up. True, the character of Harry is an adolescent—but so are Charlotte Bronte¨’s Jane Eyre, and Charles Dickens’s Pip and Esther Summerson when we first meet them, to name a few. As of yet, the series has not followed Harry to adulthood, but this should not be a ‘‘requirement’’ for adult fiction either. Furthermore, with the publication of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Rowling has introduced us to a ‘‘new’’ Harry— one who is entering turbulent teen years and experiencing all the angst, doubts, and troubles that we see in ‘‘classic’’ British novels.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H a r r y
P o t t e r
A central topos that links the Harry Potter series not only to the archetypal hero in literature, but also to other canonical British novels, is the figure of the orphan. It is no coincidence that King Arthur and Harry Potter are both orphans. The orphan is also a common feature of the Bildungsroman, or novel of education or development, in which a character must develop in society, and find his or her own way in the world. The protagonist of the Bildungsroman is often an orphan, since being parentless enhances his or her necessary independence: the orphan can be exposed to unusual circumstances and is freer to act within them than a ‘‘normal’’ protagonist would be. The orphan has audience appeal because he or she is alone in the world and has often suffered great trauma; the reader thus usually sympathizes with the character and roots for him or her. Harry Potter lives with his aunt, as do Jane Eyre and Esther Summerson (although she does not know it), while Pip lives with his sister. All of these children have a family connection to their lodgings, but they also live in misery because of how they are treated. They are often deprived of food (as in the cases of Harry and Pip) and enclosed both literally (Harry in the cupboard; Jane in the Red Room) and psychologically by their ‘‘families.’’ They must endure cruel behavior: Harry is beaten by his cousin Dudley, Jane is struck by her cousin John, and Pip is physically abused by his sister, Mrs. Joe. In another crucial novelistic motif, the character or characters to be unraveled are, like the protagonist, orphans. Each serves as a literary double or doppelga¨nger of the protagonist. The psychological double does what the other character would like to and acts on similar impulses; the doppelga¨nger represents a spirit that can adapt its form (as Voldemort literally does). The double and doppelga¨nger functions represent a possible future for each protagonist.
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
P h o e n i x
the banished criminal. Furthermore, Orlick’s assault on Mrs. Joe is often interpreted as an acting out of Pip’s psychological desire, just as Bertha’s burning of Thornfield acts out Jane’s own subliminal desires. In the Harry Potter series, Tom Riddle/Voldemort is a double for Harry—they both are parseltongues, they are of mixed muggle/wizard parentage, and they have ‘‘twin’’ wands, both cored with a feather from the same phoenix. Moreover, as developed in The Order of the Phoenix, Harry is privy to many of Voldemort’s thoughts through the scar that Harry received from him. Finally, though James Potter, Harry’s father, is dead, his memory serves as another double for Harry. The protagonist orphans learn key information about themselves from their orphan doubles, but then they must sift through their various inheritances. In Jane Eyre, Jane must learn from Bertha—her rival, double, and antithesis—and decide how she needs to negotiate her place in Rochester’s world. At the same time, she is given her inheritance from her uncle. Pip must come to terms with the criminal identity of his benefactor and the role of love in his life. The secret and tainted money from Magwitch that helps Pip also reveals the social hypocrisy underlying the social strata that Pip must negotiate. In the Harry Potter series, Harry must keep trying to understand the literal and psychological scar that Voldemort has inflicted upon him, he must deal with his fame, and he must learn to traverse two worlds. Harry has tangible inheritances to help him, such as his unexpected fortune in wizarding currency, as well as the unanticipated advantage of the invisibility cloak and the Marauder’s Map. However, these tools only lead him toward understanding, they do not produce it.
The doppelga¨nger motif is prevalent in many ‘‘great tradition’’ novels. In Jane Eyre, Bertha and Jane are psychological doubles in any number of ways, from drawing blood from their victims, to seeing their images in the glass, to their association with fire, and their connection with Rochester. In Great Expectations, Pip’s doubles are Magwitch and Orlick. Perhaps Pip’s greatest challenge is to acknowledge his psychological and literal connection with Magwitch,
Why, then, has there been such a controversy over the status of the Harry Potter books as both children’s and adult literature? As I have already discussed, some of the attempts to categorize them as children’s literature may be chalked up as marketing decisions. Some others may be premature critical decisions, based on knee-jerk responses to the first and, perhaps, second volumes in the series. Although I believe that sophisticated themes have already been developed in the Harry Potter series, it is important to remember that the series is not yet
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
4 3
H a r r y
P o t t e r
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
P h o e n i x
complete. Whether or not Harry matures or learns to deal with the coming-of-age adversities that Jane Eyre and Pip ultimately overcome is yet to be seen—although The Order of the Phoenix shows Harry making great strides in maturity. However, even for those critics who have kept up with Rowling’s novels, the fact that the series is currently in flux may contribute to the feeling that the Harry Potter novels are not worthy of being identified as ‘‘adult’’ fiction. For many critics, the type of an ending a novel has tends to dictate its classification, and the Harry Potter series eludes such placement because it currently lacks an ending. In fact, the status of the novels as a series may also have influenced some critics and academic readers to dismiss it from consideration as adult literature. They may believe that its popularity is due largely to the crass commercialization and audience manipulation involved in serial publication. These critics see the serialization of the Harry Potter novels as placing them in the same category as other print and video series that are designed to attract, respond to, and exploit a popular audience. However, it is worth noting that Great Expectations was published in serial form, that the market was a driving force in Dickens’s writing of Great Expectations, and that Dickens ended up writing two different endings to the text in an effort to please his audience. While some might argue that the example of Dickens shows how the novels in the British canon have never been completely divorced from commercial considerations, at the very least, one might conclude from it that great literature can be created within the confines of commercial form. Thus, critics are wrong to dismiss Rowling’s books simply because they are designed to attract a popular audience. Although we have yet to see the resolution of the Harry Potter series, its literary connections to the great tradition of the British novel, and specifically the Bildungsroman, make the books worthy of adult interest. Ultimately, the Harry Potter series is too popular and too important to the future of the novel to be defined exclusively as either children’s or adult fiction. Source: Paige Byam, ‘‘Children’s Literature or Adult Classic? The Harry Potter Series and the British Novel Tradition,’’ in Topic: The Washington & Jefferson College Review, Vol. 54, Fall 2004, pp. 7–13.
4 4
L i t e r a r y
Russian fans crowd into a Moscow bookstore in February 2004 to buy Order of the Phoenix Ó Sergei Karpukhin/Corbis
SOURCES Barfield, Steven, ‘‘Fantasy and the Interpretation of Fantasy in Harry Potter,’’ in Topic: The Washington and Jefferson College Review, Vol. 54, Fall 2004, p. 30. Bloom, Harold, ‘‘Can 35 Million Book Buyers Be Wrong? Yes,’’ in the Wall Street Journal, July 11, 2000, p. A26. Byam, Paige, ‘‘Children’s Literature or Adult Classic? The Harry Potter Series and the British Novel Tradition,’’ in Topic: The Washington and Jefferson College Review, Vol. 54, Fall 2004, pp. 7–13. Byatt, A.S., ‘‘Harry Potter and the Childish Adult,’’ in New York Times, July 7, 2003, p. A13. Christian Broadcasting Network, www.cbn.com (June 4, 2005). Diffendal, Lee Ann, ‘‘Questioning Witchcraft and Wizardry as Obscenity: Harry Potter’s Potion for Regulation,’’ in Topic: The Washington and Jefferson College Review, Vol. 54, Fall 2004, p. 60. Hensher, Philip, ‘‘A Crowd-Pleaser But No Classic’’ in Spectator, Vol. 292, June 28, 2003, pp. 30–31. Leonard, John, ‘‘Nobody Expects the Inquisition,’’ in the New York Times, July 13, 2003, p. 13.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H a r r y
P o t t e r
McEvoy, Kathleen, ‘‘Aesthetic Organization: The Structural Beauty of J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter Series,’’ in Topic: The Washington and Jefferson College Review, Vol. 54, Fall 2004, p. 21. Rowling, J.K., Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, Scholastic Press, 1999. ———, Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Scholastic Press, 2000. ———, Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, Scholastic Press, 1999. ———, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, Scholastic Press, 1998. ———, Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Scholastic Press, 2003. Safire, William, ‘‘Besotted with Potter,’’ in New York Times, January 27, 2000, p. A27. Tolkien, J. R. R., The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring, The Two Towers, and The Return of the King, Houghton Mifflin Company, 1994; originally published separately in 1954 and 1955. Yaggi, Miranda Maney, ‘‘Harry Potter’s Heritage: Tolkien as Rowling’s Patronus Against the Critics,’’ in Topic: The Washington and Jefferson College Review, Vol. 54, Fall 2004, pp. 33–45.
FURTHER READING
a n d
t h e
O r d e r
o f
t h e
P h o e n i x
Reviewing over forty different titles, this compilation examines the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ series up through Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, offering reasons for the books’ controversial reception as well as providing biographical and critical reviews. Colbert, David, Magical Worlds of Harry Potter: A Treasury of Myths, Legends, and Fascinating Facts, Berkley, 2003. Colbert provides a substantial reference guide for the many mythological, literary, and historical references present in all Rowling’s novels. J.K. Rowling’s Official Site, www.jkrowling.com (June 4, 2005). Rowling claims to have authored all the content on this website, directing her comments to her millions of fans worldwide. Information includes details about previous and upcoming ‘‘Harry Potter’’ books as well as biographical information and responses to rumors. Kirk, Connie Ann, J. K. Rowling: A Biography, Greenwood Press, 2003. Kirk focuses on the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ novels themselves to explain details of Rowling’s life, how characters were developed, and what the characters’ connection may be to Rowling’s own experience. The biography also provides extensive interpretive strategies for the series.
Becker, Beverley C., Hit List for Children II: Frequently Challenged Books, American Library Association, 2002.
Neal, C. W., The Gospel According to Harry Potter: Spirituality in the Stories of the World’s Most Famous Seeker, Westminster John Knox Press, 2002. Neal takes an explicitly positive approach to the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ novels by detailing the moral messages contained in Rowling’s fiction. While written from an overtly Christian perspective, this book provides an answer to religious groups protesting the books’ magic content.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
Anatol, Giselle Liza, editor, Reading Harry Potter: Critical Essays, Praeger, 2003. This collection of essays offers numerous ways to interpret the ‘‘Harry Potter’’ novels and offers evidence of the series being taken seriously as more than simple children’s stories.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
4 5
Here in Harlem Walter Dean Myers is an accomplished and prolific writer of poetry, fiction, and nonfiction for young adults. Most of his prize-winning works explore the experiences of urban youth. Myers often turns to Harlem, his hometown, as a source of inspiration and as a setting for his novels and his poetry. In 1997, he published Harlem, a picture book of poetry illustrated by his son Christopher. The book focused on the representative historical journey of many African Americans from Africa to the southern United States, and then north to Harlem. Here in Harlem: A Poem in Many Voices was published in 2004. It is a collection of fifty-four poems written from the different perspectives of various Harlem residents, each identified by name, age, and occupation. The characters include teachers, ministers, soldiers, students, and an undertaker. Each poem is a snapshot of a particular character’s life, told in that character’s distinctive voice. Together, the voices reflect the community of Harlem, which in the 1930s and 1940s was the epicenter of African American culture. References to historical figures, such as singer Billie Holliday, writer Langston Hughes, and boxer Joe Louis, appear throughout the poems of Here in Harlem. The poems are illustrated with snapshots from Myers’s personal collection of over 10,000 antique photographs and other historical documents.
4 6
WALTER DEAN MYERS 2004
H e r e
i n
H a r l e m
In the introduction of Here in Harlem, Myers credits the 1915 book Spoon River Anthology by Edgar Lee Masters as his inspiration. In Masters’s collection of some 200 poems, the characters are ghosts who deliver poetic monologues in a fictional Midwestern cemetery. Masters’s book became an international popular and critical success. By using the same multi-voiced storytelling technique in Here in Harlem, Myers pays homage to an American classic while recounting the history and culture of his own community.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY Walter Dean Myers, a prolific author of books for children and young adults, was born Walter Milton Myers on August 12, 1937, in Martinsburg, West Virginia. As a toddler, he was informally adopted by Florence and Herbert Dean and moved to Harlem. Later, he would take Dean as his middle name in their honor. Growing up in Harlem during the 1940s and 1950s, Myers was influenced by the thriving African American community around him. He has set many of his award-winning books in Harlem, including Here in Harlem: A Poem in Many Voices, published in 2004. The Harlem of Myers’s childhood and adolescence was a vibrant community and a melting pot. His foster mother, also his father’s first wife, was the daughter of a German immigrant and a Native American. His best friend was the son of German immigrants who owned a bakery in Harlem. But when Myers reached adolescence, he realized racism would limit his opportunities. He was torn between his life on the street and playing basketball, and his love of poetry and literature. He did not consider writing a viable career, and imagined he might end up a laborer like the other men in his family, not to mention most of the African American men he knew. Although Myers was encouraged early on by teachers to write as a way of surmounting his speech problems, he continued to have trouble in school and attended infrequently, never graduating from high school. To avoid gang involvement, he enrolled in the U.S. Army. Following a three-year stint in the military, Myers held several jobs, including mail clerk at the post office and construction worker. Disappointed with the life he was leading, he turned again to writing and began publishing in magazines. In 1968, he won a contest sponsored by the Council on
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
Walter Dean Myers Reproduced by permission of Walter Dean Myers
Interracial Books for Children for his first picture book, Where Does the Day Go?, which launched his writing career. After working seven years as a book editor at the publisher Bobbs-Merrill, Myers was laid off, and only then did he turn to writing fulltime. He eventually returned to school in his mid-forties to earn his degree from Empire State College. Although he has produced a wide range of books, including picture books, science fiction, fantasy, non-fiction, and mysteryadventure stories, he is best known for his portrayal of African American teenagers in urban settings, particularly Harlem. Many of Myers’s award-winning books confront important issues such as suicide, bullying, drug use, gun violence, teen pregnancy, adoption and foster care, and parental neglect. Myers has won dozens of awards for his writing, including multiple Coretta Scott King Awards and the American Library Association’s Newbery Honor Book designation, Boston Globe/Horn Book Awards, the Margaret A. Edwards Award, the Alan Award, and the Virginia Hamilton Literary Award. Here in Harlem is a recipient of the 2004 Bank Street College of Education Claudia Lewis Award for poetry.
V o l u m e
1
4 7
H e r e
i n
H a r l e m
PLOT SUMMARY In the introduction, Walter Dean Myers writes that he began Here in Harlem by imagining ‘‘a street corner in Harlem, the Harlem of my youth, and the very much alive people who would pass that corner.’’ Among some of these ‘‘much alive’’ people were the celebrated writers Langston Hughes and Countee Cullen, along with nurses, ministers, teachers, laborers, children, and the elderly. Myers concludes his introduction by paying tribute to the poet W. B. Yeats, who once advised a young Irish playwright to ‘‘write about a community that he could truly love, whose people would gladden his heart.’’ For Myers, that community is Harlem, and Harlem itself becomes a character in this book. The collection actually begins before the introduction, with a poem by George Ambrose, a thirty-three year-old English teacher. Ambrose’s poem is reprinted on both the frontispiece and the back page of the book, serving as bookends of sorts. In it, the street corner Myers imagined in his mind comes to life, establishing an important thematic connection to Africa: ‘‘My heart must rise and go now, to that / bright Harlem street / Where buildings trued in ragtime and / Congo rhythms meet.’’
Clara Brown’s Testimony: Part I After Ambrose’s poem and Myers’s introduction, the first section of Here in Harlem is ‘‘Clara Brown’s Testimony.’’ Her words are largely in italics, unlike most of the poems by other characters. She also differs from the other characters because she is not given an age when she is first introduced. She addresses the reader in an intimate tone and explains she always talks about Harlem because Harlem is ‘‘like an old friend.’’ This section functions as a prologue to the rest of the book, introducing the character, Clara Brown, as the book’s unofficial narrator. She presents six testimonies throughout the collection. Although Here in Harlem is not divided into chapters, Clara Brown’s testimonies are each numbered with Roman numerals, like chapters, and mark the passing of time in her life. The other poems in between her testimonies are each introduced with the name of a character, the character’s age, and the character’s profession. In a sense, each character, like Brown,
4 8
L i t e r a r y
MEDIA ADAPTATIONS Bad Boy: A Memoir was released by HarperChildrensAudio in 2001. It is narrated by Joe Morton. It was also released in 2005 in an unabridged version as a downloadable e-audio by Harper Audio. It is available from PerfectBound, an imprint of HarperCollins Publishers. Fallen Angels was released as an audiocassette by Recorded Books in 2004. It was also released in an unabridged version as a Book on CD by Recorded Books in 2004, narrated by J. D. Jackson. A Handbook for Boys was released as an audiocassette by HarperChildrensAudio in 2002, narrated by Peter Francis James.
Monster was released in an unabridged version on audiocassette by Listening Library in 2000. This version is a full-cast dramatization. It was also released on audiocassette by Recorded Books in 2000, narrated by Peter Francis James.
Scorpions was released as a Book on CD in 1997 by Recorded Books, narrated by Peter Francis James.
Shooter was released in an unabridged version as a Book on CD by HarperChildrensAudio in 2004. It is performed by Chad Coleman, Bernie McInerney, and Michelle Santopietro. It is also available as an unabridged downloadable audio from PerfectBound, an imprint of HarperCollins Publishers, released in 2005. It is performed by Chad Coleman, Bernie McInerney, and Michelle Santopietro.
offers his or her own testimony in the form of a poem. In fiction, plot is often described as a series of events connected through cause and effect. Most poetry, however, tells a story without relying very much on plot. Here in Harlem has an ‘‘episodic plot,’’ where each character is represented by his or her own poem, and in fact,
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H e r e
some stories are linked across poems. These kinds of connections occur throughout the book, serving to emphasize particularly important sections.
CHARACTERS ‘‘Mali Evans, 12, Student’’ This short, simple poem follows ‘‘Clara Brown’s Testimony’’ and describes how the young character wants to be like the elderly Mrs. Purvis when she herself is an old woman, with ‘‘her gray / Hair like a halo around her black face / She says it’s her crown, her tiara.’’ This image of the dignified queen in her kingdom is juxtaposed—or placed in such a way for the purpose of creating comparison—with the ‘‘winos’’ who ‘‘smile and bow / Or raise their hands in greeting.’’ Mali, whose name recalls both the ancient African kingdom and the modern African nation, says she would like to be ‘‘an ancient lady / Tree-tough and deep-rooted / In the rich soil of my dark / Foreverness / And the only thing white I would wear / Is the crown about my / Sweet black face.’’ Opposite the poem is a turn-of-the-century photograph of a girl, dressed all in white with a white bow in her hair, demurely holding a bouquet of flowers. She appears dressed for a special occasion, perhaps for church, though even in her formal clothing, there is a gleam of playfulness in her eyes.
‘‘Macon R. Allen, 38, Deacon’’ The deacon proclaims how much he loves ‘‘a shouting church,’’ which are the same words of the elderly man Myers describes in his introduction. He speaks the words Myers had heard as a boy from the elderly man, but the deacon is younger and more agitated, as if he himself is testifying in the church and trying to ‘‘wake up’’ the congregation. The photograph opposite this poem depicts Winnie Mandela holding up her fist in a Black Power salute at a podium decorated with photographs of Nelson Mandela; a crucifix towers in shadows behind her.
i n
H a r l e m
Johnson thinks the man could be Marcus, referring to Marcus Garvey, an early twentiethcentury black nationalist leader. Another man in the barbershop says it could be Martin Luther King Jr., and a third man says it could be Malcolm X. The names of those three political leaders act as the refrain to this poem: ‘‘Could be Marcus, I said / Could be Martin, came a voice from down / the way / Sounds like Malcolm, rang from the shadows.’’ A refrain is a phrase repeated at intervals throughout the poem. In the second stanza, Johnson sits inside Sylvia’s, a celebrated Harlem restaurant mentioned in Myers’s glossary of ‘‘Some People, Places, and Terms’’ at the back of the book. A stanza is the grouping of lines in a poem, much like the grouping of prose into paragraphs. In the restaurant, Johnson sees a second black man ‘‘[s]inging about revolution.’’ Marcus, Martin, and Malcolm are again invoked. In the final stanza, Henry sits inside the Victory Temple Church of God in Christ, which is perhaps the ‘‘shouting church’’ described in the previous poem by Deacon Allen. Henry sees a third black man ‘‘Preaching and teaching / Calling for the congregation / To bring forth a mighty nation.’’ The poem ends with the refrain that mentions the three famous leaders.
‘‘Willie Arnold, 30, Alto Sax Player’’ and ‘‘Terry Smith, 24, Unemployed’’ Arnold’s poem mirrors the fractured rhythm of bebop, a type of jazz music that gained in popularity during Myers’s childhood. A cut-out of a record label, rather than a photograph, illustrates his poem. Following Arnold, Terry Smith’s poem evokes an entirely different mood. It is the Christmas season, and he is unemployed with a sick child by his side. His feelings of despair are clear in the poem’s final lines as hope passes him by: ‘‘Breathe deeply, child / The Magi have gone another way.’’
Clara Brown’s Testimony: Part II
Johnson speaks while sitting inside Ray’s Barbershop and watching the street outside. He sees ‘‘A little black man / Sweat staining his underarms / Glistening on his brow / Fists pumping up the fire / Of the noontime air.’’
After Arnold’s poetic testimony, Clara Brown reappears to tell the story of how her heart was broken when the Cotton Club, a famous Harlem nightclub, refused to hire her. After auditioning to become a dancer at the Club, she was told she was a good dancer, but they would not hire her because ‘‘they only hire light-skinned girls to dance here.’’ Brown’s skin color was too dark for the exclusive club. Brown
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
‘‘Henry Johnson, 39, Mail Carrier’’
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
4 9
H e r e
i n
H a r l e m
ends this section, which resembles a journal entry more than a poem, with the words, ‘‘That was the day I learned that being black wasn’t no simple thing, even in Harlem.’’
‘‘Christopher Lomax, 60, Retired’’ and ‘‘Junice Lomax, 23, Unemployed’’ These two poems are more explicitly connected than others have been. Christopher Lomax watches his daughter from his window as she suffers from the effects of drug abuse on the street below. That daughter, Junice, speaks in the next poem, closing with a description of the emotional ties and the seemingly insurmountable distance between them: ‘‘We are chasmed by the blurring crowd / I hear him calling from below / As I race recklessly across / A thousand frantic highs.’’ There is no photograph illustrating these poems.
‘‘Hosea Liburd, 25, Laborer’’ Hosea Liburd describes how he must leave both his manhood and his identity behind when he goes downtown in search of work. The poem is paired with a photograph of a city street and men looking into the camera, ‘‘their fear-wide eyes ablaze / With quiet cautions.’’
‘‘William Riley Pitts, 42, Jazz Artist’’ and ‘‘J. Milton Brooks, 41, Undertaker’’ William Riley Pitts speaks about his son’s tragic accident, wondering ‘‘[w]hat the boy could have been.’’ The photo accompanying the poem is of a young boy, dressed in a turn-of-the-century sailor’s outfit. His poem is clearly connected to the one by undertaker J. Milton Brooks. Brooks’s words reflect the essence of the boy’s death: ‘‘But there comes a time when I have to weep / It’s when we lay some teenage boy so deep / I close my eyes and pray the Lord to save / Me from watching old men shuffling children to the grave.’’
‘‘John Reese, 70, Ballplayer, Janitor’’ John Reese once played ball in the Negro Leagues. He now works as a janitor, but he describes his past and his feelings about Jackie Robinson’s achievements in ending the segregation of American baseball in 1946. Although Jackie is a hero, Reese’s feelings are bittersweet: with the end of the Negro Leagues, he and his teammates are no longer ‘‘monarchs ruling a joyful world.’’ The poem ends with an image of
5 0
L i t e r a r y
the empty stadium because the Negro Leagues no longer exist.
‘‘Eleanor Hayden, 51, Nanny’’ Eleanor Hayden’s poem is both humorous and caustic because she is taken for granted by her employer, despite her hard work. The accompanying photo shows a stern-looking woman sitting on a park bench with her arms folded, and a baby carriage parked in front of her. She appears to be the baby’s nurse or caretaker.
‘‘Tom Fisher, 38, Blues Singer, Livery Cabbie’’ Tom Fisher appropriately offers a poem that resembles the lyrics of a blues song in style—complete with repetition, like the chorus of a song—and a love letter in sentiment. His ‘‘Sweet Martha’’ is always there to support him: ‘‘I wandered up to Paris, made my way to Rome / Ran out of money, Martha said, ‘C’mon home.’’’
‘‘Dennis Chapman, 40, Laborer’’ In one of the longest poems in the book, Chapman recounts his past, how he left behind his family and his farm in Alabama to live in Harlem. In this poem, Harlem is compared to a tempting seductress who lures a man away from his home. Chapman writes a letter to the woman he left behind, pleading with her to join him, with this text in italics. The poem closes on an ambivalent note, with the woman arriving at the Greyhound station, telling Chapman their crops have died, though there is the chance of ‘‘new growth in the spring.’’ The crops are a symbol of what they once shared and worked for together, perhaps even a symbol of their love. At the end of the poem, the woman’s eyes are already looking beyond Chapman, on the same ‘‘far horizon’’ that once enthralled him so much.
‘‘C. C. Castell, 49, On Disability,’’ ‘‘Reuben Mills, 34, Artist,’’ ‘‘Jimmy Wall, 14, Boy Evangelist,’’ and ‘‘John Lee Graham, 49, Street Historian’’ C. C. Castell describes the bustle of Harlem. Originally from Mississippi, he comments on the arrogant, narrow-minded, ambitious youth who hurry past him on the stoop. Castell’s quiet rumination is followed by the vivid colors of Reuben Mills, who sees the rich beauty even in dangerous, tragic things, for example, ‘‘Orange reflections on a switchblade knife.’’
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H e r e
i n
H a r l e m
Fourteen-year old evangelist, Jimmy Wall, borrows theme and line from Victorian poet Arthur Hugh Clough, ‘‘through a glass darkly,’’ to express his solid faith ‘‘and hope for God.’’ John Lee Graham contemplates Harlem’s African roots, drawing on African cultural references such as the Igbo, the Bantu, the Kalahari, Kikuyu, Songhai, Niger, and Timbuktu. These and other references to African culture reappear throughout the book.
‘‘Negro Quintessential’’ and ‘‘poet Black.’’ Richmond Leake’s poem recounts his dissatisfying experiences in school and the compromises he has made to earn his living.
‘‘Willie Schockley, 23, Street Vendor, Guitar Player,’’ ‘‘Etta Peabody, 60, Insurance Adjuster,’’ and ‘‘Delia Pierce, 32, Hairdresser’’
Helen Sweetland recalls a time of ‘‘taffeta and dreams’’ and punctuates her poem with the rhythm and lyrics of swing music. Joshua De Grosse describes the poet’s struggle to create beauty. In contrast, happily married Betty Pointing offers a poem more like prose, without any rhymes or line breaks. Jonathan Smalls celebrates ‘‘the crazy quilt patterns of the city,’’ while Adam Crooms unabashedly delights in the music he hears at a rent party. Rent parties, where food and drink were sold for a fee to raise money for the host’s rent, were popular in Harlem.
Willie Schockley sings ‘‘those lay-down Harlem blues.’’ Like the bebop style of Willie Arnold’s poem, Myers uses music to express his character’s thoughts and emotions. Etta Peabody speaks about ‘‘Nigger Heaven,’’ the ironically-named area reserved for African Americans in the highest balcony of a theater. Delia Pierce delivers a gossip-filled monologue that is humorous for her insistence that ‘‘I’m not the kind to talk behind nobody’s back.’’
‘‘Helen Sweetland, 27, Party Girl,’’ ‘‘Joshua De Grosse, 19, Student, City College,’’ ‘‘Betty Pointing, 64, Clerk,’’ ‘‘Jonathan Smalls, 29, Urban Planner,’’ and ‘‘Adam Croons, 24, Furniture Mover’’
Clara Brown’s Testimony: Part IV Clara Brown’s Testimony: Part III Delia Pierce’s poem is followed by more of Clara Brown’s testimony. Her words call to mind those from janitor and former ballplayer John Reese. Clara says she is so happy about the ‘‘colored baseball player’’ playing for the Dodgers. When Jackie Robinson began playing with the Brooklyn Dodgers in 1947, he broke the color line in professional baseball and paved the way for the entry of black players into all professional sports.
‘‘Lois Smith, 12, Student,’’ ‘‘Jesse Craig, 38, Salesman,’’ and ‘‘Richmond Leake, 53, Newsstand Dealer’’ Lois Smith wishes she could be so famous that a school would be named after her, so ‘‘young kids would want to grow up to be like me.’’ Her poem is accompanied by a photograph of a young girl wrapped in a fancy coat and hat, smiling charmingly at the camera. Jesse Craig describes seeing Langston Hughes, one of the writers Myers included in his introduction. In tight couplets—two lines of poetry with the same rhyme and rhythm, often expressing a complete thought—the poem pays homage to Hughes, saying Langston was ‘‘no Keats / No fair Shelley’’— nineteenth-century British poets—but instead
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
This part of Clara Brown’s testimony is a humorous story about a mouse that, apparently, will only appear when it hears the music of Duke Ellington. On the facing page, a dust jacket from a recording called ‘‘I Can’t Give You Anything But Love (Baby)’’ by Lew Leslie’s Blackbirds of 1928 compliments Clara’s ‘‘shake-your-booty’’ musical reference.
‘‘Malcolm James, 16, Student’’ and ‘‘Gerry Jones, 14, Student’’ Malcolm James, when asked what he is going to do with his life, expresses anger and bitterness at the constraints of racism and limited opportunities. On the other hand, Gerry Jones watches life on the street ‘‘whirl and swirl’’ from her ‘‘fire escape tower,’’ while reading a book of poems.
‘‘Mary Ann Robinson, 30, Nurse,’’ ‘‘Ann Carter, 32, Switchboard Operator/ Benjamin Bailey, 38, Building Maintenance’’ Mary Ann Robinson works at Harlem Hospital and describes the scenes of suffering and death she encounters every day on her job. The next poem is a conversation between Ann Carter and Benjamin Bailey. The switchboard
V o l u m e
1
5 1
H e r e
i n
H a r l e m
operator says she has seen Jesus on the streets of Harlem and proceeds to describe what Jesus wore and what he said. When Carter says she has also seen Moses, Bailey ends the conversation. The dialogue is written in rhyming couplets and has the brisk pace and the exaggerated expressions and punctuation of a comedy routine. Implied beneath the humor is a serious question about what these religious figures would make of life in Harlem.
‘‘Ernest Scott, 26, Poet’’ This poem recalls the creative yearning of nineteen-year-old Joshua De Grosse. Ernest Scott makes numerous references to Harlem’s rich literary legacy, including the writers Countee Cullen, Langston Hughes, and Zora Neale Hurston. He also mentions James Baldwin, Richard Wright, and W. E. B. DuBois, all of whom were important influences on Myers’s writing. Scott celebrates the poetic voice of all life, good and bad, in Harlem.
‘‘Caroline Fleming, 42, Live-in Maid’’ Caroline Fleming’s words echo the resentment of Eleanor Hayden, the nanny, but there is also an undeniable sense of longing. She spends the day ‘‘smiling too hard’’ for people who are not her own. In ‘‘[a]rranging someone else’s / Tattered life,’’ she feels like she is far from a life she knows.
‘‘Effie Black, 58, Church Organist’’ and ‘‘Marcia Williams, 17, High School Senior’’ Effie Black considers how the chords played on the organ reveal something larger, ‘‘how all those perfect harmonies / Echo the sweet voice of a living God.’’ Marcia Williams lyrically describes falling in love as being like a ‘‘sea creature’’ caught in a fisherman’s net, far ‘‘from love’s dark / Uncertain shore.’’
‘‘Harland Keith, 33, Reporter,’’ ‘‘Lawrence Hamm, 19, Student Athlete,’’ and ‘‘Sam Dupree, 28, Hustler ’’ Reporter Harland Keith also writes poetry but puts ‘‘aside his gentle verses’’ and his ‘‘haunted dreams,’’ and learns ‘‘to love the darkness.’’ The expression of Lawrence Hamm, who enjoys basketball, is similar to the joy experienced by former baseball player John Reese. But Lawrence has not yet experienced the disappointment that John has, and his poem is full of
5 2
L i t e r a r y
power, hope, and anticipation. Sam Dupree is a ‘‘stone-cold hustler,’’ whose smooth words are full of strutting confidence. The accompanying photograph of a charming young man in a suit reinforces this image.
Clara Brown’s Testimony: Part V In this section of Clara Brown’s testimony, the reader senses that time has passed. Brown is now an elderly woman being interviewed by a young college graduate who has heard that Brown is giving away black history books. They sit face to face yet find they are not really communicating: ‘‘We was just two black women, but life had shined her all up and given her a real pert outside, while it had made me strong inside. She was talking to me like she couldn’t see any of that.’’
‘‘Didi Taylor, 14, Student,’’ ‘‘Dana Greene, 18, Education Major, City College,’’ ‘‘Bill Cash, 30, Boxer,’’ ‘‘William Dandridge, 67, Mechanic,’’ ‘‘Charles Biner, 57, Composer, X-ray Technician,’’ and ‘‘John Brambles, 55, Numbers Runner’’ Didi Taylor describes the Harlem made famous by photographer James Van Der Zee, while Dana Greene lyrically describes her love for Harlem. Boxer Bill Cash lies awake in bed with a woman named Letha, thinking about a fight he should have won. William Dandridge thinks about the friends he has lost to death and also mentions Ray’s barbershop, which made an appearance earlier in Henry Johnson’s poem. Charles Biner once dreamed of being a classical composer, which is now a dream he keeps as his ‘‘black secret.’’ John Brambles, in a taut few lines, claims he does not sell dreams, only ‘‘noise, a static buzz / That shuts out the whisper of despair. . . . I sell a way for people / To lie to themselves.’’ His poem is illustrated with the cover of the ‘‘Black Cat Lucky Number Dream Book,’’ which gamblers used to pick their lucky numbers.
‘‘Homer Grimes, 83, Blind Veteran,’’ ‘‘Frank Griffin, 82, Veteran,’’ and ‘‘Lemuel Burr, 81, Veteran ‘‘ The next three poems form the climax of the collection. The first poem is from Homer Grimes, rattling his cup, begging for spare change on the street. This is the same blind veteran mentioned by Myers in his introduction.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H e r e
An unidentified man who claims to be an old friend approaches Grimes, but Grimes does not remember his name. Then the unnamed man asks Grimes whether he is bitter. ‘‘What is past bitter?’’ Grimes replies. In the poem that follows, Frank Griffin describes being part of the 369th Infantry, also known as the Harlem Infantry, during World War II. He describes how Grimes saved the lives of fellow soldiers and was ‘‘the greatest soldier I had ever hoped to see.’’ Yet he says Grimes was never properly honored for his courage. Lemuel Burr describes the day that he, Grimes, and Griffin were ready to board a bus to leave Camp Polk in Louisiana. A white woman kissed Homer and Burr worried because ‘‘she was white, and he was black / And when that bus sat there I knew / There was trouble coming.’’ What happens next comes as even more of a shock because of the apparently upbeat rhyming verses of the poem: ‘‘We had saved the world from Hitler / But on that dark road they snatched our prize / They pounded away Griff’s courage / And they tore out poor Homer’s eyes.’’ A verse is a single line of a poem, arranged rhythmically. Like Homer, the blind poet of antiquity, Grimes is given another kind of sight: ‘‘‘What can you see?’ the Negro doctor / Asked as he tried to ease the pain / Homer said he’d been away awhile / Now he saw he was home again.’’ Accompanying the poems is a clip from a newspaper that testifies to the reality of racism and injustice black veterans faced. In it, a blind veteran is pictured next to an article that explains how he lost his sight after being beaten by South Carolina police officers.
i n
H a r l e m
survival of the Middle Passage. This sense of a circular African American journey is suggested in the arrangement of the poems: from Mali Evans, who wished to walk like a queen in her kingdom of Harlem, to John Lee Graham’s view of the African roots in Harlem’s history, to the African connections drawn by Prentiss.
‘‘Clara Brown, 87, Retired’’ The book closes with a poem by Brown. Her age, 87, is finally given to the reader. She has seen a lot of change in her lifetime, but Harlem remains the same to her: ‘‘a pile of years / Keeps sighing and signifying / In my ear like an old friend / About my Harlem / About my Harlem / And it’s all mine, you know.’’ She has born witness to all the lives of Harlem, a poem in many voices.
THEMES African American Life and Thought
Lydia Cruz’s poem is about the attention from young boys she is receiving. Kevin Broderick recalls the yearning and love for Harlem of the earlier poem by Dana Greene. The penultimate poem is by Earl Prentiss, who links Harlem to its African roots through
Here in Harlem is largely devoted to the African American community of Harlem, although other ethnic groups, such as Italians, Jews, Puerto Ricans, and Dominicans have also made Harlem their home. Except for the poem of Lydia Cruz, their voices are absent from this book. Myers appears more interested in recreating the texture and diversity of the African American voices from his childhood and youth. By providing historical and cultural references throughout his book, he also encourages readers who are unfamiliar with these references to learn more about African American history. Readers can turn to the back of the book for an abbreviated glossary of people, places, and terms. In this way, the poems also serve as an introduction to some important highlights of African American culture and history. Like an anthropologist intent on documenting the life of a community through the diversity of its individuals, Myers includes a variety of historical figures from a broad spectrum of achievement. They include writers Langston Hughes, Countee Cullen, Zora Neale Hurston, Richard Wright, James Baldwin; the photographer James Van Der Zee; the jazz bebop musician Charlie ‘‘Bird’’ Parker and the stride pianist James P. Johnson. Paul Laurence Dunbar makes an appearance through the allusions to Dunbar’s ‘‘Sympathy’’ that Joshua De Grosse makes.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
Clara Brown’s Testimony: Part VI After the veterans’ powerful story, Clara Brown talks about being one of the ‘‘old folks,’’ and she tells her long-time doctor not to worry about Harlem, which has seen better and worse days. The memories of the elderly are juxtaposed to the yearnings of the young in the poems that follow.
‘‘Lydia Cruz, 15, Student,’’ ‘‘Kevin Broderick, 20, Pre-law, City College, ‘‘and ‘‘Earl Prentiss, 39, Motorman’’
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
5 3
H e r e
i n
H a r l e m
Places and objects are just as important, such as the Apollo Theater and the Cotton Club, 125th Street and the A Train. Athletes are also featured, specifically Jackie Robinson. His integration of professional baseball in 1946 made him a hero in Harlem, and he is compared to the Greek hero Ajax in John Reese’s poem. Intellectual and political leaders are also referenced, including African American leaders W. E. B. DuBois, Booker T. Washington, Marcus Garvey, Martin Luther King Jr., Malcolm X, and Adam Clayton Powell Jr. In addition to African American history, Myers scatters references to Africa throughout his book, particularly to African kingdoms, peoples, and places. In street historian John Lee Graham’s poem, an explicit connection is made between the Harlem streets and their roots in Africa. Graham has ‘‘captured the moment’’ of an Igbo child playing on the banks of the Ogun river, Bantu herdsmen squatting in the steamy Kalahari, Kikuyu women contemplating Mount Kenya, and Songhai warriors celebrating by the Niger River. Graham has captured all this, it is strongly implied, without his ever having left the streets of Harlem. The penultimate stanza of the poem brings the African past and Harlem together with an image of birds in flight: ‘‘I have captured the moment / When the scholars of Timbuktu / And the sages of Harlem flew together / In lazy circles over the broad Atlantic.’’ The poem from Earl Prentiss also clearly connects Harlem to its African heritage. Prentiss begins his poem with the words, ‘‘My village, my village,’’ and goes on to link Africa with Harlem through ‘‘the same scorch of sun.’’ Though the African languages of their ancestors are no longer spoken by African Americans, the influence of Africa is still felt: ‘‘The language their ancestors dreamed / An eternity before / They dance the dance of the Congo / To a scale that has / Survived the foam and fleck / Of the Middle Passage.’’ Myers’s desire to explore the influence of African heritage on African American culture reflects his own intellectual interests and research. A recent and specific example of this interest is in his 2003 award-winning book of poetry, Blues Journey, which was illustrated by his son Christopher Myers. The book opens by briefly tracing the development of the blues from its roots in Africa. Myers explains that the five-
5 4
L i t e r a r y
tone, or pentatonic scale, is very common in Africa, and it forms the basis for the blues. African musical and storytelling traditions also contributed the call and response pattern, in which a lead singer makes a statement, or ‘‘call,’’ and the chorus responds. This call and response pattern is also evident in many congregations of African American churches, such as the ‘‘shouting church’’ described by Myers in his poem about Deacon Allen, in which he ends his poem by calling out ‘‘Can I get an A-men?.’’ In some ways, Here in Harlem mirrors this pattern of call and response, with Clara Brown acting as the leader to her congregation of Harlem voices. In Myers’s book, Harlem becomes more than an actual place, it is also witness to the living history of a momentous journey from Africa through slavery to freedom.
Limitations and Opportunities Myers has often written of his commitment to writing for people who have suffered from limited opportunities. In a 2005 newspaper article in the Post-Standard of Syracuse, New York, Myers told Laura T. Ryan, ‘‘I’ve got fan clubs in prisons. I’ve got fan clubs in juvenile detention centers . . . . These are the people that read my books, identify with them.’’ At one time, Harlem offered a vast range of opportunities for African Americans that were unavailable anywhere else in the United States. This was one reason for the flood of new arrivals during the Great Migration, a period referring to the movement of African Americans from rural communities in the South to cities in the North. At the beginning of the twentieth century, the majority of African Americans lived in the South. From 1916 to 1970, an estimated six million African Americans relocated from the South to the urban areas of the North and West. Most were in search of economic opportunities and freedom from the repressive racial discrimination, segregation, and violence they encountered in the South. Myers dramatizes the story of this migration in the poem about Dennis Chapman, who ‘‘drunk with bright / light dreams’’ leaves behind his land and his love, in search of more opportunities in Harlem, and he must face the consequences of his decision. Segregation and racial discrimination, both of the legal kind prevalent in the South and the socially-sanctioned variety more common in the North, meant that African Americans were forced to invent and sustain their own
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H e r e
institutions and businesses. Ironically, this permitted certain African American institutions to flourish because the choices for full participation in American society did not exist. With the advent of integration, these institutions were no longer supported and some went into decline or simply disappeared altogether. An example of this appears in the story of John Reese. Before he was a janitor, Reese was a ballplayer in the Negro Leagues, which included teams like the New York Black Yankees and the Brooklyn Royal Giants. After Jackie Robinson integrated baseball, other professional sports followed, and African American athletes began to be recruited for these leagues and teams. Without the participation of the best athletes and the patronage of fans, and with competition from the Major Leagues, the Negro Leagues lost their ability to support their teams. This is just one of the ironies of the African American struggle for civil rights; in some cases, with greater rights and equal access came the decline of African American institutions and the erosion of some African American communities. This does not mean these opportunities for advancement were not welcome or deserved. However, in examining the history of a community like Harlem, Myers shows the complex effects of integration on this community. While segregation and racism clearly denied countless opportunities to African Americans, they also indirectly helped sustain the vibrant cultural life of a community like Harlem. This was especially true while Myers was growing up. When other opportunities for social mobility through employment and housing became available to more African Americans, many of Harlem’s cultural leaders and more prosperous residents moved away from the community and no longer contributed to its well-being. Discrimination also existed among African Americans, as Clara Brown describes when she is rejected as a dancer at the Cotton Club because her skin is too dark. In many ways, limitations and opportunities played a complex role in the history of Harlem, and Myers explores this theme through the voices of characters like John Reese, Clara Brown, and Dennis Chapman. Throughout Here in Harlem, Myers tells the story of Harlem and its residents in an authentic and nuanced way, never avoiding the paradoxes of this special community.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
i n
H a r l e m
TOPICS FOR FURTHER STUDY Research at least three of the historical figures mentioned in Here in Harlem. Choose one artist, one athlete, and one politician. After your initial research, write a short twoparagraph biography on each. Why do you think Myers included each figure in his book? Choose one of the figures and write a ten-line rhyming poem about him or her. Research two of the African references in Here in Harlem. Who or what are they and why do you think Myers included them in his book? What role does Africa play in Myers’s poems? Write a one-page essay presenting your research and opinion. Be sure to include quotes from the poems.
In a group, each person should choose their favorite poem from Here in Harlem and stage a performance of it for the others. Write your own four-line stanza for this poem in the voice of the character. In a one paragraph explanation below the poem, explain why you choose that particular character. What more would you like to know about his or her life?
Read or watch a video version of Spoon River Anthology by Edgar Lee Masters. Choose one character from Spoon River Anthology and one from Here in Harlem. Write a one-page letter to the Masters character from the point of view of the Myers character. What has changed in the United States since the time of Spoon River Anthology? How would the character you chose from Here in Harlem describe these changes? Have these changes made life his or her life better? What does your character think the future will bring?
STYLE Multiple Voices Though all of the poems in Here in Harlem are written by Walter Dean Myers, they are each written in a different voice from the perspective
V o l u m e
1
5 5
H e r e
i n
H a r l e m
of individuals in the community. By presenting the poems in this manner, the reader not only gains Myers’s insight and reflections about his neighborhood, but also those of the diverse characters who voice each poem. Myers explores the streets, homes, jobs, memories, and lives of the young and old, male and female, that make-up Harlem’s African American community. The individual voices in the poems reinforce the idea that a generalized description or label of a neighborhood cannot accurately capture the various and unique realities of the people living there.
HISTORICAL CONTEXT
Diction Diction is the selection and arrangement of words. Myers uses a range of diction to portray the characters of Here in Harlem. Myers’s poems all use first person or personal point of view, which tells a story from the perspective of a single character. By creating many different characters that use the first person point of view, he must create distinctive voices for each character. The young students do not sound like the older veterans, and the hustler does not sound like the deacon. Diction can be formal, informal, colloquial, or slang. All of these styles are found throughout Here in Harlem. The lofty writing in the poem by Joshua De Grosse is an example of formal diction: ‘‘I cannot write of beauty with this blind pen / These gnarled fingers are useless things / Scratchy useless syllables again and again / Cairo cries; the raged word sings.’’ Myers reinforces the formal diction of the poem in its refrain of ‘‘Cairo cries; the raged word sings.’’ This refrain is an allusion to the celebrated poem ‘‘Sympathy,’’ by Paul Laurence Dunbar (1872– 1906), whose final quatrain is punctuated by the refrain, ‘‘I know why the caged bird sings!.’’ In De Grosse’s poem and in others, Myers uses a quatrain, which is a stanza of four lines. In De Grosse’s poem, the first and the third lines rhyme, along with the second and fourth lines. This kind of rhyme is common in poetry. In many of his poems, Myers uses informal diction, commonly found in relaxed but educated conversation. Colloquial diction is the kind of language used in everyday speech. An example of colloquial diction is when Delia Peirce says: ‘‘But I’m not the kind to talk behind nobody’s back.’’ Slang includes the latest phrases and terms not used in formal diction.
5 6
The hustler Sam DuPree says ‘‘If I ain’t getting over, it must mean I died.’’ Myers alters the rhythms and line breaks of his poetry as well. Frequent line breaks and staccato rhythms are typical of the poems by musicians, while many of the students’ poems include lyrical language, simple words, and longer sentences. By varying the diction and forms of his poems, Myers can effectively represent the diverse backgrounds of Harlem’s residents, along with the breadth of depth of his community.
L i t e r a r y
Harlem’s Roots Here in Harlem includes characters that make many references to Harlem’s long and distinguished history. Although the district of Harlem occupies a large part of the northern island of Manhattan in New York City, it has no fixed boundaries as a neighborhood. It may generally be said to lie between 155th Street on the north, the East and Harlem rivers on the east, 96th Street (east of Central Park), 110th Street, and Cathedral Parkway (north and west of Central Park) on the south, and Amsterdam Avenue on the west. Harlem played such a prominent role in African American history and culture that it is easy to forget its origins. In 1658, the Dutch governor of New Netherland established a settlement named after the town of Haarlem in his native land. The site of a famous battle of the Revolutionary War, Harlem remained largely an agricultural area through the eighteenth century. In the nineteenth century, fashionable houses were built as summer retreats. It was during the financial crisis of 1893 that property owners began renting to African Americans. With the rise of the Ku Klux Klan in the South, many African Americans arrived in Harlem and other Northern urban centers in search of a better life and freedom from segregation, discrimination, and racial violence. The First World War also opened up some factory jobs for African Americans, who flocked to the cities of the North. With this first wave of the Great Migration, Harlem became a center for political activism, as well as a wellspring of economic opportunity. The Black Swan Phonograph Corporation, for example, was a successful record company that issued records
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H e r e
by African American performers. Myers included one of its labels as an illustration to the poem by saxophonist Willie Arnold. Madame C. J. Walker, who made her fortune from hair care products, made Harlem her home, and her daughter later hosted a literary salon in her Harlem townhouse.
A Political and Cultural Mecca In 1917, Harlem was the site of a silent protest of 8,000 people marching down Fifth Avenue to decry the race riots of East St. Louis, which occurred when whites became angry over African American employment at a factory, and to protest the continued lynching of thousands of African Americans across the nation. Despite the marchers’ direct appeals to President Woodrow Wilson, lynching was never declared a felony in the American judicial system. During the summer of 1919, increasing competition for jobs and housing helped contribute to bloody race riots that spread across the nation. In Harlem, the Black Nationalist Marcus Garvey founded his Universal Negro Improvement Association, which emphasized pride in Black African heritage and the establishment of an independent Black nation. By 1919, the Association was the largest mass movement of African Americans in U.S. history, with a membership of several hundred thousand. The Jamaican-born Garvey was eventually deported for tax evasion in 1925. Other political movements also sought a home in Harlem. The N.A.A.C.P published a monthly magazine, Crisis, with W. E. B. DuBois as its editor. Crisis published the writers of the Harlem Renaissance. Along with other publications like Opportunity and the Amsterdam News, these publications provided analysis of the important issues of the day and chronicled the achievements of African Americans, who were largely ignored by the mainstream press. With its critical mass of African Americans, and its influential intellectuals and artists, Harlem would attract leaders like Martin Luther King Jr., Adam Clayton Powell, Jr., and Malcolm X who sought to share their political ideas.
i n
H a r l e m
thinkers such as Countee Cullen, James Weldon Johnson, W. E. B. DuBois, Alain Locke, Zora Neale Hurston, Langston Hughes, and Claude McKay were among its leaders. Hughes was particularly important to Myers’s writing. He was considered the poet laureate of Harlem, and he was known for his poetry based on jazz and blues rhythms and on the lives of everyday people. Music, dance, theater, and the visual arts also played an important role in Harlem’s cultural life, with jazz in particular finding a home in Harlem venues.
Harlem in the 1940s During the Second World War, there was again a mass migration of African Americans from the rural South. Some 1.5 million African Americans left the South during the 1940s. Harlem faced yet another series of housing shortages, job competition, and racial tension. However, Harlem continued to attract new residents with its promise of opportunity and relative social mobility, especially compared to the vicious system of Jim Crow segregation in the South. In his memoir, Bad Boy, Myers describes his Harlem, a melting pot and potent symbol of the American dream: Harlem . . . is an experience that will always live with me . . . . In Harlem the precise accents of northern-born blacks mixed with the slow drawls of recent southern immigrants and the lilting accents from the islands . . . . Black businessmen walked side by side with black orthodox Jews . . . . Even the white people who came to Harlem were colorful. In Smilen Brothers a bearded white man bent nails with his teeth and talked about the poisons in our foods. White nuns from St. Joseph’s jostled with fat black women in Blumstein’s for bargains, and the butchers in Raphael’s meat market pushed slices of cold cuts across the counter for black children to nibble on while their mamas shopped.
Besides serving as a hub of political activism, Harlem was also an internationally-renowned center for the arts. After the First World War, Harlem hosted a thriving creative movement known as the Harlem Renaissance. Artists and
The Harlem of Myers’s youth was also a time when African American soldiers served overseas in segregated units. The 369th Infantry, also known as the Harlem Hellfighters, was one of these units, and the powerful story of three of its veterans comprises the climax of Myers’s book. Myers makes some reference to later cultural figures in Harlem, but the inspiration for Here in Harlem, as he describes in his introduction, is the street corner he imagined as a child, the Harlem in the 1940s.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
5 7
H e r e
i n
H a r l e m
The Cotton Club nightclub in Harlem Frank Driggs Collection/Getty Images
CRITICAL OVERVIEW Here in Harlem is one of Myers’s many books to be set in Harlem. Like his collection of short stories, 145th Street, it focuses on the residents of Harlem to tell the story of a diverse community without resorting to stereotypes of urban blight, but also without ignoring real and pressing social problems. The characters telling their stories represent a broad spectrum of Harlem society, from those who lived on Sugar Hill, an affluent area of Harlem, to those who lived on the streets. In the School Library Journal Review, Nina Lindsay praises Myers’s skill as a storyteller in Here in Harlem: ‘‘Myers’s skill with characterization and voice are apparent . . . . A complexity of experiences comes through vividly in the varying poetic styles . . . . The rich and exciting text gives readers the flavor of Harlem histories and
5 8
L i t e r a r y
peoples.’’ A review in Publisher’s Weekly is also positive about Myers’s ability to take ‘‘readers [on] a tour of Harlem’s past and present, its hopes and fears, through the voices of narrators young and old . . . . Harlem is indeed home, to all of the people who give voice to its pains and pleasures.’’
CRITICISM Nadine Pine`de Nadine Pine`de has a Ph.D. in history, philosophy, and policy studies in education, specializing in philosophy of education and philanthropic studies, from Indiana University. She is a freelance writer and instructor in history, education, and creative writing. In the following essay, Pine`de considers the importance of Harlem in Myers’s Here in Harlem and throughout his prolific career as a writer of books for young adults and children.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H e r e
MYERS IS AN INSPIRED CHOIRMASTER, CREATING HARMONY FROM THE MANY VOICES OF HERE IN HARLEM TO PORTRAY A COMPLEX COMMUNITY REPLETE WITH PARADOX, MUCH LIKE AMERICA ITSELF.’’
Here in Harlem is Walter Dean Myers’s eightieth book. His work has spanned the range of realistic fiction, biography, adventure, science fiction, historical fiction, and poetry. Since the publication of his first picture book for children in 1968, Myers has continued to expand his readership, and he is one of the first African American male authors to achieve success in the field of children’s and young adult literature. Myers has gained praise—and some condemnation—for his often gritty depictions of Black urban life and of the struggles of young African American men. His characters struggle with violence, self-doubt, crime, and corruption, and their dialogue often reflects the urban vernacular. At the same time, Myers’s sense of humor often offsets the grimmer aspects of his urban settings. Myers’s use of the vernacular has been one reason detractors criticize his work. However, as author Rudine Bishop notes in Presenting Walter Dean Myers, ‘‘His characters reflect the full range of Black urban speech, both female and male, from street corner rapping to formal standard English.’’ This is particularly true in Here in Harlem. Each poem is a snapshot of a particular character’s background and perspective presented through his or her use of words. Each poem is written with distinctive diction, reflecting the uniqueness of the individual character. From maids to street vendors, deacons to hustlers, readers can learn about the wide range of people who made and make Harlem their home. As Myers states in his introduction, he wanted to create a cast of living characters and pay homage to a place he loves.
i n
H a r l e m
not exotic, or special. Harlem was just home.’’ He was even disappointed when he saw the renowned Black poet Langston Hughes selling his books on the street, because Hughes looked like an ordinary man and not like the image of what young Myers thought a poet should be. Hughes did not resemble the Romantic poets Percy Shelley, John Keats, and Lord Byron that Myers was studying in school. The poetry of the Harlem Renaissance movement was not taught in the schools Myers attended. It was not until years later that Myers discovered the voices of Hughes, James Baldwin, and other African American writers, and only then did Myers realize that their depictions of Harlem could help inspire his own. In an interview with Barbara Hoffman in the New York Post, Myers says that the writing of James Baldwin ‘‘gave [him] permission, so to speak, to write about African American life, Harlem, and the experiences of the poor.’’ Among the many important contributions Myers has made to the field of children’s and young adult literature is his use of urban settings, particularly in his depictions of Harlem. For many young readers unfamiliar with Harlem, the word itself may bring to mind all sorts of images. Unfortunately, most of them might be the negative images often disseminated by the mass media: crime, urban decay, drugs, and gangs. By providing a multifaceted portrayal of life in an urban African American community, Myers has helped provide a balance to the stereotypes of Harlem.
Growing up in Harlem, Myers was not always so keen to portray the richness of his community through his writing. He describes his failure to appreciate Harlem as a source of inspiration in his memoir Bad Boy: ‘‘Harlem was
Myers has often said that in writing about Harlem, he wants to be of service to his community. In some sense, Myers’s collection of poetry can be seen as a testament to the life experiences of Harlem’s citizens. The word ‘‘testimony’’ is usually associated with a court of law, and as a verb it means to provide evidence or to bear witness. But testimony has its roots in religion, with the law in question being the divine law. In a religious context, to testify means to profess one’s religious belief. Both senses of the word testimony are evident in Clara Brown, the character whose life provides a frame for the book. In each of the six sections of ‘‘Clara Brown’s Testimony,’’ Brown bears witness to eightyseven years of Harlem life experience; as she says, a long life in Harlem ‘‘made me strong inside.’’
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
5 9
H e r e
i n
H a r l e m
Furthermore, the many voices of young people in Here in Harlem reflect Myers’s own experiences growing up in this dynamic community. By including a character like Lydia Cruz, Myers also seeks to reflect the changing population of Harlem and the diversity of its newer residents, many of whom are Spanishspeaking immigrants from the Dominican Republic and Puerto Rico. These residents have added a new cultural dimension to an already diverse community. Myers’s focus, however, is on Harlem’s special role in African American history and culture, which is evident throughout Here in Harlem and is emphasized by references to the artists, athletes, and politicians who made Harlem their home. Yet it is Harlem’s ordinary people who are most cherished by Myers, whether they are shown congregating in church, chatting in barbershops and beauty salons, or mourning the loss of family. Myers is an inspired choirmaster, creating harmony from the many voices of Here in Harlem to portray a complex community replete with paradox, much like America itself. However, his portraits are not completely romanticized versions of Harlem life. Myers does not avoid showing how Harlem can exert a dangerous power. For Dennis Chapman, who was part of the Great Migration north, Harlem is personified as a lover and seductress who saps the life from him with her glittering but essentially empty promises. Harlem blared a welcome—flashed its smile Rolled its city eyes, blew out its dark city breath Nibbled hungrily at my liver as I Lived it up and boogied down Ran it up, and spun it around Harlem eased me, calmed me, rubbed my chest Held me close on restless nights Whispered in my ear that the blues loved only me And that it was joy, not despair, that spread Like sunrise On the far horizon.
Although Harlem holds seemingly limitless excitement, Dennis Chapman never fully realizes the promises Harlem holds for him, as is evident by that fact that the fun and gaiety leave ‘‘the prison of [his] skin . . . cold, and damp.’’ Yet, Myers portrays Chapman and Chapman’s decision to migrate north with the compassion and respect such a decision deserves. Myers’s Harlem is not simply multifaceted in its populations, but also in its generations and their experiences. Some readers may be confused
6 0
L i t e r a r y
by how the book does not seem to be taking place in the current day, but rather moves back and forth in time. The cultural references to Langston Hughes, Countee Cullen, Zora Neale Hurston, and James Van Der Zee all draw on the Harlem Renaissance. When Didi Taylor, a fourteen-year-old student, says she would love to be photographed by Van Der Zee, and talk to Reverend Adam Clayton Powell, Jr., it seems as if she is a contemporary of these early twentieth-century men. This movement between the Harlem of the past—of the years of Myers’s childhood—to its present, adds to the book’s sense of timelessness. In Edgar Lee Masters’s Spoon River Anthology, the characters are ghosts. Some of the characters in Here in Harlem also seem to be speaking from beyond, offering their voices as a testimony about Harlem’s past. In the end, Here in Harlem is a nuanced testament to an ever-changing community. When Myers writes about Harlem, he is writing out of personal commitment to that community specifically, but also to a universal human ideal. From his writing, it is clear that he believes that the writer reaches the universal through the particular. In an autobiographical sketch reprinted on the Educational Paperback Association’s website, Myers explains that the Harlem he knew as a child was not the Harlem he encountered in books. Through his writing, Myers has been faithful to the Harlem he knew. The people I knew as a child were not the kind that were being written about. What I wanted to do was to portray this vital community as one that is very special to a lot of people. I wanted to show the people I knew as being as richly endowed with those universal traits of love, humor, and ambition as any in the world. This, I hope, is what my books do. That space of earth was no ghetto, it was home. Those were not exotic stereotypes, those were my people. And I love them.
As both a writer and a person, Myers has fully evolved, from not appreciating Harlem because it was not exotic enough, to appreciating it for its universal humanity. Here in Harlem is a loving testament to a community, honoring its past, its present, and its possibilities for the future. In Myers’s deft poems, Harlem is a community that has both exhausted and exhilarated its inhabitants, all the while sustaining the promise of the American dream.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H e r e
i n
H a r l e m
WHAT DO I READ NEXT?
When Harlem Was in Vogue (1981), by David Lewis, is an excellent introduction to the cultural period known as the Harlem Renaissance. Lewis’s history of Harlem from 1905 to 1935 is an indispensable guide to understanding the importance of Harlem in American history and to the work of Myers.
The Stranger (1946), by the French author Albert Camus, remains one of the most widely-read novels of all time. It is a classic of existentialism, a philosophy that questions how people find meaning in their lives. The story centers on an apparently amoral young man who commits a senseless murder and his subsequent trial. Myers recounts the influence of The Stranger in his memoir, Bad Boy.
Ann Petry’s novel The Street (1946) is set in the Harlem of Myers’s youth. It is a story of an African American woman separated from her husband and struggling to raise her eight-year-old son as well as to overcome the violence and racial conflict of Harlem’s streets. Petry received a Houghton Mifflin Literary Fellowship for her realistic novel,
considered a classic of African American literature. A Langston Hughes Encyclopedia (2001), a reference work written by Hans Ostrom and published by Greenwood Press, provides a comprehensive resource for the celebrated African American writer who made Harlem his home. Langston Hughes was a leader of the Harlem Renaissance, as well as a source of inspiration for the poetry of Myers. Myers’s Fallen Angels (1988) is a prize-winning novel about seventeen-year-old Richie Perry. Perry, just out of his Harlem high school, enlists in the Army and spends a devastating year on active duty in Vietnam. Myers’s novel Monster (1999) is illustrated by his son, Christopher Myers, and by Catherine M. Tamblyn. A Harlem drugstore owner is shot and killed in his store, and sixteen-year-old Steve Harmon is arrested as the lookout. An amateur filmmaker, Steve transcribes his trial into a movie script, showing scene by scene how his life is unfolding. The novel was a 1999 National Book Award Finalist.
Source: Nadine Pine`de, Critical Essay on ‘‘Here in Harlem,’’Literary Newsmakers for Students, Thomson Gale, 2006.
Celia McGee In the following essay by McGeee, Myers talks about his relationship with Harlem, past and present.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
6 1
H e r e
i n
H a r l e m
Street in East Harlem Ó Corbis
6 2
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H e r e
i n
H a r l e m
I express these memories through poetry. When you do a picture of an entire community, you need may voices, and poetry works. CE: How do you get others excited about your approach? WDM: Once, I brought in photos to a group of students and asked them to write poems about them, and what their lives would be like. I like to give kids subjects to write about. With Harlem, I could write about a place that I loved, but every child can write about their own community. They can write about the things that they see. Make a list of people in your neighborhood and create a poem about how they were feeling that day, or about a particular event. Source: Celia McGee, ‘‘Harlem Comes Verse with Him,’’ in New York Daily News, November 3, 2004, p. 52.
Jasmin K. Williams In the following interview with Williams, Myers discusses the origins of Here in Harlem. Walter Dean Myers has written plenty of books. His latest one takes a poetic look at his life and memories of Harlem. Classroom Extra: What inspired you to use this unique method of writing about Harlem? Walter Dean Myers: I read Spoon River Anthology, by Edgar Lee Masters. He takes a mythical town of Spoon River and writes poems about the people buried there. I read it again as an adult but didn’t like it as much. It was interesting at first, but as an adult, I realized that he didn’t really like the people of Spoon River. When I thought about Harlem, I loved the people. CE: How did you choose the people to write about? WDM: These were people that I encountered, and sometimes they were stories that I remembered as a kid. I remember being in Washington and getting into a cab. I asked the old cabdriver why he looked so tired. The driver said that he was a deacon in his church and he had just buried a young person and he was so tired of doing that.
One of the things I do is challenge them to write a certain amount of lines about a particular subject. Write a poem with rhymes in the middle of the sentence instead of the end. This changes the way they approach language. I heard a rapper do that. CE: What’s your advice on how to get kids excited about reading and poetry? WDM: I tell parents to spend an hour a day reading with your children. My whole family would read the same book. If the children were assigned a book in school, I read it, too. I started off reading the Reader’s Digest and poetry with them. I realized that there weren’t any black stories, so I started writing them myself Walter Dean Myers has written more than 85 books, most geared to children. His three adult children are Michael Dean, Karen Elaine and Christopher. Source: Jasmin K. Williams, ‘‘A Poetic Look at Harlem,’’ in New York Post online edition, February 16, 2005, p. 1.
Charles Scribner’s Sons In the following excerpt from Writers for Young Adults, the author explores Harlem’s influence on Myers and Myers’s influence on Harlem, poetry, and African-American culture.
All the poems come from somewhere. I wanted to give a voice to the people in my memories.
The Harlem where Myers grew up, the one he remembers and portrays affectionately in his early novels, was a gentler, happier place than the Harlem generally portrayed in contemporary media. Four of those early novels—Fast Sam, Cool Clyde, and Stuff (1975), Mojo and the Russians (1977), The Young Landlords (1979), and Won’t Know Till I Get There (1982)—are humorous accounts of the escapades of groups of young people who get
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
I later met a nurse who was very excited about going to work, not because she enjoyed it but because she was useful.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
6 3
H e r e
i n
H a r l e m
themselves in and out of trouble, support each other when the going is rough, and generally try to do the right thing. Myers’ talent was recognized early in his career. Fast Sam, his first novel, was cited as an American Library Association Best Books for Young Adults, as was The Young Landlords. Critical response to his early novels pointed to what would become accepted as among Myers’ greatest strengths as a writer: his ear for dialogue, his ability to create likable and sympathetic characters, and his ability to write humorously. Many of the themes that recur in his work are evident in these early works as well: African Americans helping each other, the relationships of fathers and sons, the importance of friendship, and the peer group as a small supportive community. These characteristics are notable in The Mouse Rap (1990). The Mouse is fourteenyear-old Frederick Douglas, who lives in Harlem and loves basketball. He and several of his friends become involved in the search for the loot from a 1930s bank heist, rumored to have been left in an abandoned building. Meanwhile, his father, who is separated from his mother, is doing his best to work his way back into the family. Each chapter begins with a rap, such as this one, which opens the book: Ka-phoomp! Ka-phoomp! Da Doom Da Doom!
... You can call me Mouse, ’cause that’s my tag I’m into it all, everything’s my bag You know I can run, you know I can hoop I can do it alone, or in a group.
One of Myers’ most notable skills is his knack for capturing the way urban African American teenagers, especially boys, often talk to each other. Even if the specific expressions threaten to become outdated, the flavor of their talking—the bragging, exaggerating, and image making—does not. These kinds of oral expressions come out of traditional African American discourse styles. Myers often uses this style in the voices of both his narrators and his other characters. This is particularly true when the narrator is the main character, as in The Mouse Rap. Here is Mouse introducing himself to the reader: Me, I can hoop. I can definitely hoop. I ain’t jamming but I’m scamming. You may look great but you will look late. You got the ball against me and you blink and all you got left is
6 4
L i t e r a r y
the stink because I got the ball and gone. I played one on one with my shadow and my shadow couldn’t keep up.
It is easy to undervalue this kind of language, partly because what is current changes so quickly. But this language is the reflection of an important aspect of African American culture, and for young urban African American men, one of the ways they establish themselves among their peers. Typical of Myers’ early humorous novels, The Mouse Rap includes a cast of characters that represents a mix of ages (teenagers, their parents, and their grandparents) and of sociocultural groups (African American, white, and Mexican American). Equally typical, Myers treats his characters with sympathy and affection. It is possible to criticize The Mouse Rap and Myers’ other humorous novel as lacking credibility, but Myers has a good sense of drama, knows how to keep a story moving, and in spite of some serious underlying themes, is playing strictly for laughs. These books are farcical, full of exaggerated comedy, and meant to be enjoyed.
African American Culture and History Myers has a strong interest in African American history and culture, and he has produced a number of books, fiction and nonfiction, reflecting that interest. Now Is Your Time! The African American Struggle for Freedom (1991) is a nonfiction work that combines history, biography, and a bit of Myers’ own genealogy to tell the story of African Americans from Africa to the present. The Glory Field (1994) is a novel that follows one African American family for 250 years, from the Middle Passage (the forced voyage of enslaved Africans to America) to the present. Brown Angels: An Album of Pictures and Verse (1993) features old photographs of African American children, accompanied by original verses. It marks Myers’ return to publishing poetry. Myers’ interests and writings continue to deepen and expand. The father of three grown children, Myers is also a grandfather. He lives in Jersey City, New Jersey, where he writes fulltime. He considers that if he can produce ten pages a day, he has done a good day’s work. His major contribution to literature for young adults has been to illuminate the lives and
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
H e r e
history of African Americans and to do so with humor and affection as well as with seriousness and great skill. In the process, he offers to readers of any social group insight into the human experiences and emotions that connect us all. Source: Charles Scribner’s Sons, ‘‘The Scribners Writers Series: Walter Dean Myers,’’ in Writers for Young Adults, 1997, p. 1.
SOURCES Bishop, Rudine, ‘‘The Present and the Future: Myers the Artist,’’ in Presenting Walter Dean Myers, Twayne Publishers, 1990, pp. 93–103. Burshtein, Karen, ‘‘Walter Dean Myers, Living Black Poet,’’ in Walter Dean Myers, Rosen Publishing Group, 2004, pp. 67–70. Dunbar, Paul Laurence, ‘‘Sympathy,’’ The University of Dayton’s Paul Laurence Dunbar website, www.dunbarsite.org (July 14, 2005). Hoffman, Barbara, ‘‘‘Monster’ Writer Walter Dean Myers Knocks Out His 80th,’’ in the New York Post, October 23, 2004, p.26. ‘‘In His Own Words,’’ Walter Dean Myers Biography at Walter Dean Myers Official webpage, www.harperchildrens.com (May 30, 2005). Lindsay, Nina, Review of Here in Harlem: Poems in Many Voices, in School Library Journal Reviews, December 1, 2004, p. 166. Myers, Walter Dean, ‘‘Autobiographical Statement,’’ Educational Paperback Association, www.edupaperback. org (May 30, 2005); reprinted from the Fifth Book of Junior Authors and Illustrators, H. W. Wilson, 1983.
i n
H a r l e m
Ryan, Laura T., ‘‘Words to the Rescue: Author Walter Dean Myers Reaches Out to Teen Readers,’’ in the PostStandard, p. 4. Review of Here in Harlem: Poems in Many Voices, in Publishers Weekly, November 15, 2004, p. 61.
FURTHER READING Bishop, Rudine, Presenting Walter Dean Myers, Twayne Publishers, 1990. Bishop’s book is a combination of literary criticism and biography that places Myers’s work in its historical and cultural context. It provides an excellent introduction to the wide range of Myers’s writing. Masters, Edgar Lee, Spoon River Anthology, Signet Classics Paperback, reprint 1992. Myers gives credit to Masters’s book in helping inspire his own, and it is worth revisiting this classic of American literature to discover the voices of the 244 characters who speak about their lives as well as the social reform movements of their time. Myers, Walter Dean, Bad Boy: A Memoir, HarperCollins Publishers, 2001. Bad Boy is a memoir of Myers’s Harlem childhood in the 1940s and 1950s. It explores the conflicts between Myers’s home life with his adopted parents, his life in school and his love of books, and his life in his neighborhood, all set against his struggle for self-realization as a writer.
Review of Here in Harlem: Poems in Many Voices, in Publishers Weekly, November 15, 2004, p. 61.
Myers, Walter Dean, Now Is Your Time! The African American Struggle for Freedom, HarperCollins, 1991. Myers provides a combination of biographical vignettes and narrative history to recount the story of the African American experience through the voices of various characters, including a freed slave, investigative reporter Ida B. Wells, artist Meta Warrick Fuller, inventor George Latimore, and Dred Scott.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
———, Bad Boy: A Memoir, HarperCollins Publishers, 2001, pp. 49, 78–141. ———, Here in Harlem: Poems in Many Voices, Holiday House, 2004.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
6 5
Kira-Kira Cynthia Kadohata’s Kira-Kira, published in 2004, is the story of a young Japanese American girl growing up in the 1950s. This is Kadohata’s first book for young adults, following several adult novels. It highlights the work and life experiences of Japanese Americans in the pre– Civil Rights era, as well as their struggles to achieve the American dream. The novel explores the relationship between individual and community identity. In Kira-Kira, community helps to define the individual. The main character, Katie, develops her sense of self through her experiences and relationships with others—friends and family, neighbors, teachers, and peers. Katie chronicles her family’s life in the United States. In her first-person narration she emphasizes the lessons in honesty, love, disappointment, and hope that her sister, brother, and parents teach her. Although the novel recounts the many hardships the family endures—back-breaking work, poverty, racism, illness, and death—it also focuses on those moments in life that are kira-kira, which means ‘‘glittering’’ in Japanese. These are the moments when the characters of the novel experience the things that make life worth living: beauty, happiness, and hope.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY Cynthia Kadohata was born in 1956 in Evanston, Illinois, the daughter of Japanese
6 6
CYNTHIA KADOHATA 2004
K i r a - K i r a
Whiting Foundation. In 2006, Kadohata will publish Weedflower, another novel for young readers. Weedflower tells the story of a friendship between a young Japanese American girl living in an internment camp and a young Mojave boy living on the reservation. In Weedflower, as in Kira-Kira, Kadohata draws on her family’s experiences. Kadohata’s father was interned with his parents, in a camp that was on the Colorado River Indian Reservation in Arizona. Although she derives material from her Japanese American background, Kadohata does not like to be regarded only as an Asian American writer. She believes this label limits her ability to go beyond preconceived ideas that some readers may have about Asian Americans.
PLOT SUMMARY
Cynthia Kadohata AP/Wide World Photos
Chapters 1–4
American parents. She has a journalism degree from the University of Southern California and attended graduate writing programs at Columbia University and the University of Pittsburgh. Kadohata believes her writing has been shaped by her family’s experience as Japanese Americans, which included frequent moves across the United States in search of work. Kadohata drew on her family’s experience for Kira-Kira, her novel for young readers which received the 2004 Newbery Medal. Kadohata was hailed as a new voice in American fiction in 1989, with the publication of her first book, The Floating World. Like Kira-Kira, this book also features a young girl’s first-person narration of her family’s moves throughout the United States. The Floating World was widely reviewed and praised for its masterful writing. Kadohata also published In the Heart of the Valley of Love (1992), set in the futuristic Los Angeles of 2052. She has frequently contributed short stories to periodicals such as The New Yorker, Grand Street, Ploughshares, and the Pennsylvania Review.
The novel is a first-person narration by Katie Takeshima, the middle child of JapaneseAmerican parents. It chronicles her life from the age of five to her teenage years in southern Georgia. An older Katie tells the story, reflecting on her childhood as well as her relationship with her family and others in the community where she lives. The novel begins when Katie is five years old and living in Iowa. This period of her life is idyllic. She plays constantly with her older sister Lynn, whom she adores. The strong bond with her sister is established here in the opening chapters. Lynn takes care of her while her parents work, and teaches Katie her first word, kirakira—the Japanese word for ‘‘glittering’’—those beautiful things in the world that are sources of happiness, such as the sky, the stars, and flowers.
Kadohata has received a grant from the National Endowment for the Arts and the Whiting Writer’s Award from the Mrs. Giles
The first chapter offers a scene that is essential to understanding the themes in the novel. Katie and Lynn are playing near a cornfield and when Lynn runs off into the field to hide. Katie becomes upset and begins to cry. Lynn quickly comes out of the field to comfort her, but a vicious dog charges at them. After the dog tears Katie’s pants and scrapes her leg with his teeth, Lynn manages to distract him and take Katie to safety, but the dog then attacks Lynn. Frightened for her sister, Katie throws a bottle of milk at him, and the dog runs away. Katie believes Lynn saved her life, but in Lynn’s diary
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
6 7
K i r a - K i r a
entry for that day, transcribed in the novel, she writes, ‘‘Later, when the dog attacked me, Katie saved my life.’’ The way the sisters’ love for each other saves them is a recurring theme throughout the novel.
Takeshimas’ youngest son Samson Ichiro Takeshima—Sammy—is born in this early part of the novel as well.
The Takeshimas’ Oriental grocery store fails because there are few Asians living in their Iowa town, and the family moves to Georgia. On the trip from Iowa to Georgia, Katie begins to learn about racism. When the family stops at a motel to spend the night, they are told that they may only stay in the back rooms reserved for Indians. When Katie’s father explains they are not Indian, the woman at the front desk replies that the back rooms are for Mexicans, too. Katie protests that they are not Mexicans, either, but her father quietly fills out the registration card, telling the woman that the back room is fine. He does not argue with the woman at the motel because his family needs a place to sleep.
Katie takes care of Sammy the same way Lynn took care of her, spending all her spare time with him. Lynn practices writing short stories in her diary, mostly about living by the sea. She begins to feel ill and worries that she cannot help Katie with her homework. Lynn is an excellent student who gets As in school, while Katie gets straight Cs. She is bored by schoolwork and does not apply herself.
With the help of her Uncle Katsuhisa, Katie’s parents get jobs in a chicken hatchery and poultry processing plant. Her father sexes chickens—he divides the male chicks from the female—and her mother is responsible for cutting drumsticks off chicken bodies in the processing plant. Their jobs require that Katie’s parents spend many hours away from home and her father sometimes sleeps at the hatchery because the work hours are so long. Her mother often works extra hours and comes home exhausted. Katie, Lynn, and their little brother Sammy must sometimes fend for themselves and take care of each other. Only thirty-one Japanese Americans live in the Takeshimas’ town—Chesterfield, Georgia— and they keep to themselves. The rest of the town’s population does not even seem to understand where they are from. When Katie starts school, the other children ask her ‘‘Are you Chinese or Japanese?’’ and ‘‘What’s your native name?’’ even though Katie has developed a southern accent and has lived in America her whole life. Aside from their questions, the kids at school ignore her, just as Lynn warned that they might. The children at school do not speak to Lynn, either, and the only friends Katie’s and Lynn’s parents have are the few Japanese people living in their apartment complex. Lynn tells Katie that the townspeople believe the Japanese are worthless, ‘‘like doormats—or ants or something!’’ and the two sisters vow to live near each other by the sea when they grow up. The
6 8
L i t e r a r y
Chapters 5–8
When Lynn is fourteen, she begins to make friends at school—because she is so pretty, according to Katie. Lynn becomes best friends with Amber, a white American girl, ‘‘one of those really girlie girls who paint their fingernails and even their toenails.’’ Katie watches as Lynn transforms into a young woman. As Lynn develops an interest in boys and a longing to fit in with her American peers, Katie feels as though she and her sister are growing apart. She resents the fact that Lynn still sees her as a child. Lynn and Amber convince Uncle Katsuhisa to take the family camping so that they can be near some boys from school who are also camping that weekend. Lynn and Amber leave Katie behind to flirt with the boys, and they return to the campsite giggling and whispering. They tell Katie about their evening, ‘‘how Lynn had kissed Gregg, and how Amber had almost kissed the other boy, and how they were the cutest boys in the class.’’ When Katie tells them about her fantasy boyfriend, Joe-John Abondondalarama, they laugh at her. During the summer months when neither Lynn nor their neighbor Mrs. Kanagawa can take care of Katie and Sammy, they go with their mother to the processing plant and wait in the car until their mother finishes her shift. Katie discusses her mother’s work, remarking on the town’s prejudice against the people who work in the poultry industry. She learns about union organizing, and discovers that Mr. Lyndon, the owner, has hired a thug to intimidate workers and prevent unionization at his poultry farms. Her mother opposes unions, believing it is ‘‘wrong to fight the people who are trying to help you.’’ Katie hates seeing her mother work in poor conditions at the factory and vows to one day have enough money to buy the factory and
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
K i r a - K i r a
treat the workers well. While waiting in the car, Katie meet Sylvia Kilgore—Silly—a girl approximately Katie’s age who does laundry at the plant and who later becomes Katie’s first friend.
Chapters 9–12 Lynn is increasingly weak and nauseous, often sleeping through the day and staying home from school. At first her parents thinks it is only anemia, but the problem appears to be growing more serious and they take Lynn to the hospital. When they return home, her parents tell Katie that ‘‘Lynn’s anemia was ‘acting up’ and she just needed more liver.’’ Katie’s parents apply for a loan to help them buy a house. They feel a house of their own might help improve Lynn’s health. Lynn’s health does seem to improve once they move, and everyone is certain their new house has brought them good fortune. The children plan a picnic to celebrate their new home. They go to the unfenced grounds on Mr. Lyndon’s property, where Sammy’s foot gets caught in an animal trap. Katie frees Sammy from the trap, then she and Lynn struggle to carry him home on a blanket stretched between them. Worried about her brother’s worsening condition and Lynn’s exhaustion, Katie runs to some nearby houses to get help. Ultimately Hank Garvin, a handsome stranger, takes them to a hospital. Katie is surprised that a white person can be so helpful; thanks to his assistance, Sammy is not seriously hurt. Later that year Lynn is hospitalized; because Katie’s mother often stays with Lynn, Katie and Sammy sometimes sleep at the poultry farm with their father. They amuse themselves by playing with male chicks that are unimportant to the business because they cannot lay eggs. Katie even steals a few of them and frees them in a nearby field. Katie and Sammy bring coffee and doughnuts to the workers, and rub their backs as they work through twelve-hour shifts. Katie’s playful adventure at the farm contrasts with the laborers’ lives. She describes the harsh working conditions: how the workers all sleep in the same room, hardly change their clothes, and only get four hours of sleep a night. Katie is worried by how exhausted her father looks.
is especially sad, she tells Katie she wishes she had glittery pink nail polish. Wanting to please her sister, Katie steals the nail polish from a five and dime store. It is the first time she has ever stolen anything, and she escapes from the store successfully even though someone sees her do it. The next day after school, she returns home to find the cashier who had seen her steal the nail polish. Her mother pays the woman for the nail polish and promises she will be punished. Katie’s father orders her to personally apologize to the owners of the five and dime for having stolen their property. He also finally admits why Lynn is sick. She has lymphoma, a word that Katie learns is a type of cancer when she looks it up in the dictionary. She realizes that Lynn might die.
Chapters 13–16 Because of Lynn’s mounting medical bills and their house mortgage, Katie’s parents work all the time, leaving the children alone a great deal. Lynn’s health worsens; she and Katie get into their first fight, each telling the other ‘‘I hate you.’’ Uncle Katsuhisa takes his family, Katie, Sammy, Silly, and Jedda-boy, a land surveyor friend, on a Thanksgiving camping trip to distract them from the sadness caused by Lynn’s illness. On the way to the campsite, they get lost and the truck gets stuck near the edge of a cliff. Once they get going again, Katie falls out of the truck through a loose door without anyone noticing and a few minutes pass before the truck stops and turns around to pick her up. After listening to Jedda-Boy’s stories about his land-surveying adventures, Katie asks Auntie Fumi when Uncle Katsuhisa will become a land surveyor. Fumi answers that no one in Georgia would hire a Japanese man as a land surveyor, so his dream will never be realized. However, she says, ‘‘It’s different for you children. You’re younger, the world is changing.’’
Lynn comes home from the hospital but is so ill she cannot attend school. Katie often stays home to spend time with her, reading to her from a set of used encyclopedias. One day when Lynn
Mrs. Muramoto, a neighbor, holds a big party on New Year’s Eve, the biggest holiday of the year for the Japanese. Katie describes the yearly ritual of staying at the party until ten o’clock, returning home to sleep for a few hours, then waking up before dawn to write down her hatsu-yume, ‘‘first dream of the New Year.’’ According to the custom, their family then meets other Japanese families in an empty lot to watch the sunrise, ‘‘the traditional way to celebrate New Year’s in Japan.’’ But this New Year’s Eve, Katie stays with Lynn, and Lynn
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
6 9
K i r a - K i r a
makes her promise that she will get better grades, go to college, and take care of their parents and Sammy. Katie goes out to the empty lot alone to watch the sunrise, and cries. I cried and cried. For a while as I cried I hated my parents, as if it were their fault that Lynn was sick. Then I cried because I loved my parents so much. . . . I wondered if anyone else in history had ever been as sad as I was at that moment.
Lynn dies that morning and her family grieves for her. When Katie learns that Lynn died alone, she regrets leaving to watch the sunrise. She thinks, ‘‘I had no idea whether it mattered or not to her that she had been alone at the exact moment she died. But I thought maybe it did.’’ Katie and her mother scour the house for things that belonged to Lynn in order to keep them: stray hairs, a chewed-on pencil, newspapers from when she was alive. Katie cuts a lock of her own hair and ties it around Lynn’s neck. That same day, angry and frustrated that he could not help Lynn, Katie’s father commands Katie to show him the animal trap that hurt Sammy’s leg (the boy still limps from the accident). After finding the trap, he and Katie drive to Mr. Lyndon’s house where, overcome by emotion, he smashes the windshield of Mr. Lyndon’s car with a two-by-four. They drive away from the scene and don’t stop until they reach the next town, where a sheriff questions them about what they are doing. He is looking for the person who damaged Mr. Lyndon’s car. Katie tells him that her sister has just died and that they were on their way to get tacos. The sheriff lets them go. Katie writes a eulogy recounting a special memory of Lynn, which she delivers at Lynn’s funeral. Katie’s father cries at the graveside, the first time Katie has ever seen him do so. With Uncle Katsuhisa’s help, she creates an altar in Lynn’s honor. She places treasured objects that belonged to her sister in a special wooden box, makes a bowl of rice for her, and places both on the altar. Believing that Lynn’s spirit is watching her, Katie tries to do better in school to honor the promise she made to her sister, and she gets an A on her math test. Katie’s father takes her with him to apologize to Mr. Lyndon for damaging his car and is immediately fired from his job. Luckily he gets another job at another hatchery, one not owned by Mr. Lyndon. According to Katie, her father’s apology to Mr. Lyndon was
7 0
L i t e r a r y
MEDIA ADAPTATIONS
Kira-Kira was released in an unabridged version on audio CD by Listening Library in 2005. It is narrated by Elaina Erika Davis.
a defining moment, because he realized that they had a choice about whether to ‘‘be an unhappy family forever, or not.’’ They could determine their own futures. Katie learns that ‘‘even when you’re very, very wrong, if you apologize, you can still hold yourself with dignity.’’ Katie’s mother, resistant to unionizing efforts throughout the novel, joins the union of hatchery workers and they win by one vote. She decides to support the union when she learns that it will give workers paid leave when a family member dies. ‘‘It was a little late for my mother,’’ Katie recounts, ‘‘but if she voted yes, she knew it would not be too late for the next family suffering grief.’’ When the holiday season arrives, Katie’s father decides that the family needs a vacation. Katie suggests they travel to the California coast because it had been Lynn’s lifelong dream to live by the ocean. After a trip to Lynn’s grave, Katie’s father tells her that Lynn wanted Katie to have her diary. As Katie reads it she learns more about Lynn. Katie discovers that she was the ‘‘only person mentioned every single day, even if she just wrote something like, Katie got another C today.’’ Katie decides she will go to college to honor Lynn’s memory. The Takeshimas drive to California and arrive on December 31, near the first anniversary of Lynn’s death. The family walks to the beach on New Year’s Day and Katie wishes ‘‘Lynn could have lived to see the sea with us! . . . I don’t think anyone understood as well as I did how badly Lynn had longed to walk along the water the way my family and I did that New Year’s Day.’’ Although she is sad that Lynn is no longer with them, Katie believes she hears her sister’s voice in the waves, saying kira-kira.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
K i r a - K i r a
Uncle Katsuhisa
CHARACTERS Joe-John Abondondalarama Joe-John Abondondalarama is a figment of Katie’s imagination. He is her idea of a perfect boyfriend; she often daydreams about how they will meet and the kind of life they will have with their seven children. Amber and Lynn laugh when she tells them about Joe-John, so she pretends that she is just kidding.
Amber Amber is Lynn’s best friend. She introduces Lynn to an American lifestyle, as well as to her ideas about how girls should behave and how they should interact with boys. Lynn spent all of her time with Katie when she was younger; Amber represents a new phase in Lynn’s life as she is finally accepted by her American peers. Katie does not like Amber and sees her as competition for her sister’s attention. She also thinks that Amber is frivolous and only cares about boys and looking grown-up. Eventually, Amber drops Lynn as a friend when Lynn becomes sick.
Uncle Katsuhisa is Mr. Takeshima’s brother, and uncle to Katie, Lynn, and Sammy. He is boisterous and very active, whereas Katie’s father is a quiet thinker. Katsu is the Japanese word for ‘‘triumph,’’ a word that describes Uncle Katsuhisa well. It is Uncle Katsuhisa who secures employment for his brother and sisterin-law at the hatchery in Georgia when the Takeshimas’ Asian grocery store fails in Iowa. He drives his dilapidated truck to Iowa to help them move, entertaining Lynn and Katie on the drive with silly songs about their names. Although he is happy and economically stable, he has always wanted to survey land instead of working at a hatchery. He feels no one will hire him as a surveyor because he is Japanese. Although he appears rough he is very caring and loving toward all the Takeshima children; he is a source of fun for them because he always takes them and his own family camping. After Lynn dies, he helps Katie confront her grief and build an altar to honor her sister.
Mrs. Kanagawa Auntie Fumi Auntie Fumi is Uncle Katsuhisa’s wife and Katie’s aunt. She is described as a round and loving woman who comforts Katie when she is troubled. She often defends Katie when Uncle Katsuhisa treats her with harsh impatience. Auntie Fumi and Uncle Katsuhisa come over and play board games with Katie and Sammy when their parents are tending to Lynn in the hospital.
Hank Garvin Hank Garvin takes Sammy Takeshima to the hospital when his foot gets caught in an animal trap on Mr. Lyndon’s property. This is Katie’s first encounter with a white man who shows a genuine desire to help her or her family. She is also infatuated with him, despite their age difference. Katie’s parents are grateful that he was able to help Sammy, Katie, and Lynn; they give him a watch to thank him for his kindness. He attends Lynn’s funeral with his wife.
Mrs. Kanagawa is the neighbor who watches the neighborhood children while their parents work. She lives in the same apartment complex as the Takeshimas in Chesterfield, Georgia.
Silly Kilgore Sylvia Kilgore, who goes by Silly, is Katie’s only friend. They meet in the parking lot of the processing plant where Katie’s mother works. Silly works at the plant doing the morning laundry. Silly approaches Katie while she sits in the car; their first conversation takes place through the rolled-down window. Silly’s mother supports the unionization of the processing plant workers, and Katie’s mother tells her to stay away from Silly. Eventually they become good friends and Silly goes camping with the family. It is at Silly’s mother’s union meeting that Katie’s mother decides to join the union.
Sylvia Kilgore See Silly Kilgore
Jedda-Boy
Mr. Lyndon
Jedda-Boy is Uncle Katsuhisa’s friend, a land surveyor who goes camping with the family. He represents what Uncle Katsuhisa wants professionally, but is barred from having because of his race.
Mr. Lyndon is the wealthy owner of the chicken hatchery and poultry business where Katie’s parents work. He is one of the richest men in Georgia and lives in a former plantation mansion. He hires anti-union thugs to intimidate
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
7 1
K i r a - K i r a
his employees and prevent unionization. He does not care about anything or anyone but his own wealth, and his neighbors despise him. He places animal traps on his property when there is no reason to do so, needlessly endangering people. Sammy catches his leg in one of these traps and must be taken to the hospital. On the day of Lynn’s death, Katie’s father—full of rage that is seeking a target—drives to Mr. Lyndon’s house and smashes his windshield. When he apologizes for having damaged Mr. Lyndon’s car, Mr. Lyndon replies that he is sorry about Lynn’s death but does not accept this as an excuse. He fires Mr. Takeshima from his job and orders him to pay for the damages to the car.
Katie Takeshima Katie is the first-person narrator of the novel and its main character. She is the middle daughter of Japanese American parents who move from Iowa to Georgia when Katie is five years old. Katie is very close to her older sister Lynn and protective of her younger brother Sammy. She is a young girl trying to determine her identity and where she belongs. She explores these issues by recounting her experiences with members of her family and people in the community around her. Through Katie’s eyes, the reader learns about responsibility, the importance of love for self and others, and what it means to have a home. Katie tends to Lynn when she is ill and watches over Sammy while their parents are working long shifts. Although she is only a young girl, Katie pulls the family together when Lynn dies of lymphoma. She makes healthy meals, cleans the house, and generally keeps things in order because her parents are too distraught to do so. She also proposes a family trip to California, because her sister had always wanted to go there and see the ocean.
Lynn Takeshima Lynn Takeshima is Katie’s older sister and a principal focus in the novel. Katie’s narration recounts many experiences she has with her sister while growing up. Lynn is intelligent and caring, a straight-A student who watches out for Katie as she grows up. She teaches Katie about racism, friendship, and love, but most importantly, about kira-kira, the things that make life worth living, like ‘‘the beautiful blue sky, puppies, kittens, butterflies’’. Lynn dreams of living with Katie in a high-rise apartment building while they go to college, and then living by the ocean in California. To
7 2
L i t e r a r y
Katie, Lynn seems almost perfect, someone who can do no wrong. The family is constantly trying to please Lynn in an effort to improve her health, and when they move to their new house they consider it ‘‘Lynn’s house.’’ Lynn becomes ill with what the family thinks is anemia. However she also has lymphoma, a form of cancer, and she dies on New Year’s Day. Katie spends much of New Year’s Eve with Lynn, but she leaves to watch the sunrise and is not with her sister when she dies.
Mr. Takeshima Mr. Takeshima is Katie’s father. He is a hardworking, first-generation Japanese American whose main concern is his wife and children. He generally struggles through life without complaining, but sometimes he lashes out at the people he believes are hurting his family. For example, he searches for the animal trap that hurt Sammy and subsequently smashes Mr. Lyndon’s windshield. Nevertheless, he teaches Katie about the importance of being honest, facing responsibilities, and putting family before oneself. Katie has complete faith in her father’s ability to take care of the family. She describes him as a thoughtful and contemplative man, given to reading and thinking rather than talking loudly or sharing opinions like Uncle Katsuhisa. Katie feels that her father is always proud of her, no matter what she does.
Mrs. Takeshima Mrs. Takeshima is Katie’s mother. She is hardworking and strict, but also sensitive: ‘‘She was so delicate that if you bumped into her accidentally, you could bruise her.’’ She cherishes peace and quiet, and often tells her children to keep quiet. She is often dismayed at the way her daughters depart from her ideal of Japanese womanhood, and she considers sending them to Japan to become more feminine. Her only concern seems to be her family; she works in demeaning conditions at the poultry processing plant to earn money for a house. At first she opposes unionization at the plant, but she supports the union after Lynn’s death. Her decision to join the union makes Katie proud, though she leaves her feelings unspoken.
Sammy Takeshima Sammy Takeshima is Katie’s younger brother, whom she treats like a son. His full name is Samson Ichiro Takeshima. Ichiro means
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
K i r a - K i r a
‘‘first son’’ in Japanese. Katie pays as much attention to him as Lynn did to her growing up, and Katie is his ‘‘special favorite.’’ When Sammy’s leg gets caught in an animal trap on Mr. Lyndon’s property, Katie rushes to get help taking him to a hospital.
THEMES Racism Set mostly in pre–Civil Rights era Georgia, the novel accurately portrays the treatment of Japanese Americans in the United States in the 1950s. Though they are U.S. citizens, the Japanese American characters in Kira-Kira are continuously treated as outsiders and excluded from mainstream society. In several instances, the Takeshimas encounter people who do not even recognize them as Japanese; at the motel, the front-desk woman assumes they are Indian or Mexican, and when Katie starts school the other students ask if she is Chinese or Japanese. They cannot compete with whites for the same jobs, they are relegated to special sections for ‘‘colored people,’’ and are generally regarded with suspicion. The characters experience others’ racism as alienating and isolating. Interestingly, even though much of the novel is set in the South, there is no mention of African Americans or any other ethnic groups who might share similar life experiences with the Japanese Americans. Although the novel does not express any direct opinions about whites as a group, the characters who are not Japanese are viewed with suspicion and often portrayed as less caring or thoughtful than the Japanese characters.
Identity The novel is concerned with the question of identity on many levels. Katie and her family are Japanese Americans living in the American South of the 1950s. Although she was born and raised in the United States, Katie often struggles to reconcile her Japanese upbringing with the customs and traditions of her native country. The question of identity is also explored in regard to gender roles—in Katie’s case, the question of what it means to be a woman. Katie’s mother often berates her and her sister for not being feminine enough because they are growing up in the United States. She tells them that she will send them to Japan to become properly
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
feminine, and she curls Katie’s hair in pin curls and dresses her in a party dress on the first day of school. Katie, who is changing from a young girl to an adolescent, wonders about what it means to be feminine. She is annoyed by Amber and Lynn’s preening and gossiping about boys, but she also wants to be a part of it. Identity is also explored in terms of the role that a person occupies within a family. Even though Katie is a middle child whom others sometimes see as irresponsible or childish, she lifts the family out of the depression caused by Lynn’s death. It is she who takes over housekeeping and cooking chores while her parents are working overtime to pay the mortgage and Lynn’s medical bills, and she takes care of Sammy just as well as Lynn took care of her. Various definitions of identity evolve throughout the novel; its meaning changes according to the life experiences of the characters.
Love and Kinship Despite the many hardships the Takeshimas endure in the novel, their love for one another maintains a strong spirit and a willingness to continue living. Love is primarily expressed in the relations between the family members, communicated in the ways they make sacrifices and care for one another, the lessons they teach each other, and even in the legacies they leave behind. The Takeshimas also show love in their ability to see beauty and good in the world, even when the dark and unpleasant side of life seems most prominent. Mr. Takeshima works tirelessly at two jobs to support the family, but he never questions whether the sacrifice is worth it. The children save the nickels their father gives them for snacks, planning to help pay for the house and eventually saving one hundred dollars. Uncle Katsuhisa shares his secret grief over a lost infant son to help Katie gain perspective on the loss of her sister. The characters also perceive love as a saving force. At the beginning of the novel when Katie is chased by a dog, Lynn protects her and is attacked by the dog. Katie comes to her rescue by throwing a bottle of milk at the dog. In the sisters’ different accounts of the story, each speaks of the other girl’s bravery. The love each has for the other saves them both.
The American Dream The American dream is the idea—some might say myth—that hard work and determination result in economic prosperity and social mobility.
V o l u m e
1
7 3
K i r a - K i r a
TOPICS FOR FURTHER STUDY
Research the U.S. labor movement in the twentieth century. What segments of the population joined unions? Did some ethnic groups participate in the unions more than others? What were women’s roles in the unions? Write a five-paragraph paper detailing the pros and cons of joining a union. Tell the reader whether you would join one, and include the reasons for your decision.
Keep a diary for a week, and write down your activities, thoughts, impressions of other people, opinions about ideas and news that you heard during the week, and things you would like to do in the future. Write a three-paragraph paper describing anything you learned about yourself from keeping a diary. Interview family members, friends, and people in your community about their thoughts on identity. Ask your interviewees how they define the term ‘‘identity.’’ Does it refer to family heritage, to nationality, to the language(s) they speak, to gender, or to
something else? Write a three-page report detailing your findings and include your own definition of identity in your report. Consider the age, gender, and religious background of the people you interview.
Research an ethnic group in the United States other than your own. What country did they emigrate from, where have they settled geographically, what kind of general experiences have they had in the United States, what are their traditions and customs, and what languages do they speak? Write a two-page essay detailing your findings.
Write a two-page short story in which the narrator is a young girl or boy whose parents were not born in the United States. Write the story using a first-person narrator. Imagine his or her thoughts, feelings, relationships, and activities regarding American culture. Explore differences and similarities between American culture and the culture of your narrator’s parents. How does your narrator cope with these differences?
As immigrants and members of a minority, Katie’s family struggles to achieve the elusive American dream. Even though Katie’s parents work long hours to buy a house, an act that they believe might save Katie’s sister Lynn, they are plagued by medical bills and mortgage payments. The novel shows the Takeshima family achieving limited success; the success they do achieve sometimes requires that they sacrifice long-held beliefs. For example, Katie’s mother realizes that her antiunion view is hurting not only her own family, but other plant workers’ families as well. At the same time, the novel’s focus on economic inequality and racism demonstrates how these forces could make it impossible to satisfy an immigrant family’s basic material needs and desires in 1950s America. Katie’s description of Mr. Lyndon’s house, which ‘‘seemed as big as a castle,’’ illustrates the economic disparities between workers and
7 4
L i t e r a r y
management. His sense of entitlement and ruthless treatment of his workers further confirms this unfairness. However, Mr. Takeshima’s apology to Mr. Lyndon illustrates people can maintain their dignity and integrity even though the material prosperity of the American dream may remain beyond their reach. Ultimately, the novel’s focus on discriminatory social practices presents a critique of the idea that hard work brings economic prosperity. The family’s emphasis on kira-kira shows that perhaps not everyone’s goal should be to achieve wealth. However, the tragedies and hardships that the family endures demonstrate the importance of access to fair wages and equal opportunities.
Hope Kira-Kira is undeniably a story about hope and the power of dreams. Hope is the
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
K i r a - K i r a
mechanism that drives the Takeshima family, both as a group and as individuals. No matter how desperate or difficult the situation, the Takeshimas see an opportunity for hope and a chance for something better, something kirakira. The promise of a better livelihood leads the Takeshimas from Iowa to a small town in Georgia. Mr. and Mrs. Takeshima work around the clock at exhausting jobs, persisting because it offers the hope of owning a home. After Lynn dies, Katie and Sammy become their parents’ source of hope and their reason to continue their hard work: ‘‘[Mr. Takeshima] needed to think about his children who were still alive, because he was honor-bound to think of the living before the dead.’’ Lynn’s hopes for she and Katie as college students and her dream of them living by the sea come to shape Katie’s aspirations. The Takeshimas trip to the coast at the end of the novel fills Katie with hope, as ‘‘the water started to make [her] feel happy again.’’
STYLE Foreign Language Beginning with the title of the novel, Japanese words and their English translations appear throughout the narration. The use of foreign words has a critical function; Japanese terms and the cultural meanings they connote are woven into the very fabric of Katie’s American life. They show the two halves of her existence: her cultural Japanese roots and her American lifestyle. Whenever a Japanese word is used, its English definition is also provided, allowing readers who are not Japanese to participate fully in the story. Words such as kira-kira (glittering), katsu (triumph), ochazuke (green tea mixed with rice), shizukami (hush), and hatsu-yume (first dream of the New Year), name and translate the Japanese and American characteristics of Katie’s life, for both Katie and the reader.
Point of View The novel is entirely composed of a firstperson narration by the main character, Katie Takeshima. The reader thus learns about events, relationships, feelings, and ideas only through Katie’s eyes. Additionally, Katie is telling this story from a distance, some years after the events have occurred. Because she is somewhat removed from the story, she can use hindsight to
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
understand and communicate some events more clearly. The first-person narrative style expresses one of the main goals of the novel: to show life events filtered through the eyes of a young girl just beginning to discover the world around her.
Realism Realism is a method of depicting events accurately and realistically in art and literature, without idealizing or romanticizing what is happening. Realism allows readers to relate to events and emotions and to connect with characters. Description is one of the ways to accomplish a realistic portrayal of a time and place. Much of this novel is dedicated to describing events and environments as they really are, such as people’s physical characteristics, nature, and the minute details of a house’s interior space. Lynn’s death, for example, is not peaceful and lovely with everyone relieved that she is out of pain; instead, it is a messy, life-shattering event in the Takeshima family. Before her death, Lynn’s ‘‘breath [was] catching heartbreakingly, as if breathing had become a hardship for her body. Her hair had grown stringy.’’ Though it would have been poetic to have had Lynn die surrounded by her family and uttering final farewells, Cynthia Kadohata instead approaches her death realistically, as it could possibly have happened in a busy family on a holiday night: Lynn died when no one was in the room. ‘‘‘Who was with her?’ [Katie] asked. [Her] father’s voice broke as he said, ‘Nobody.’’’
Symbol A symbol suggests or stands for something else without losing its original identity. In literature, symbols combine their literal meaning with the suggestion of an abstract concept. In this novel, the house serves as a symbol of realizing the American dream. A house means stability and a reward for sacrifices. Katie’s parents work grueling hours doing demeaning work to save enough money to buy a house. Even the children save their allowances, to give the money back to their parents as a contribution toward this goal. When Lynn becomes ill, the house is considered a source of happiness and even seems to contain the possibility of a cure. They believe Lynn will recover when they buy the house because she will be so happy. Another symbol in the novel is the road, which represents the family’s quest for a better
V o l u m e
1
7 5
K i r a - K i r a
life as well as each character’s search for his or her own identity. The road is thus a symbol of the space that must be traveled—through life experiences and relationships with others—to get to the desired destination. The Takeshima family travels by car from Iowa to Georgia, and on vacation from Georgia to California. Katie’s mother and father must spend over an hour driving to work each day. When Katie and Sammy have to go with their mother to the processing plant early in the morning, Katie says, ‘‘The road was empty, like so many roads we had driven on in my life.’’ After Mr. Takeshima loses his job at the hatchery, he knows that there are more opportunities down the road: ‘‘I’ve heard there’s an opening at a hatchery in Missouri. If it’s time to move on, it’s time to move on.’’ The road, as a physical space, is where Lynn and Katie often lie in their pajamas as young children in order to look at the stars. It symbolizes the space of imagination and aspiration.
HISTORICAL CONTEXT Post–World War II American and Japanese Society The United States entered World War II after the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor, Hawaii, in 1941. In 1942, the U.S. government decreed that all Japanese people residing in the United States, including second- and third-generation American citizens, should be placed in internment camps, because it was thought that they might engage in treasonous activities against the United States. Japanese Americans were held prisoner, forced to leave their jobs, property, and possessions until the end of the war in 1945. Millions of dollars in property were lost. Some years later, the Japanese who were interned were compensated at ten cents for every dollar lost. The Civil Liberties Act of 1988, signed into law by President George H. Bush, apologized for the internment and offered reparations to thousands of Japanese Americans who were denied their civil and constitutional rights by the U.S. government during World War II. Though neither Katie nor her parents were held in internment camps, they were still subject to the lingering social distrust toward Japanese Americans after the war. Additionally, in many areas of the South, if a person was not Caucasian he or she was considered to be ‘‘colored’’ regardless of
7 6
L i t e r a r y
ethnicity and therefore subject to discriminatory Jim Crow laws.
Asian-American Literature Amy Ling notes in ‘‘Teaching Asian American Literature’’ that Asian American literature often has several broad aims: to remember the past, give voice to a hitherto silent people with an ignored and therefore unknown history, to correct stereotypes of an exotic or foreign experience and thus, as [writer Maxine] Hong Kingston says, to claim America for the thousands of Americans whose Asian faces too frequently deny them a legitimate place in the country of their birth.
Asian-American literature cannot be fully appreciated without some background information on the historical and cultural contexts of Asians in the United States. Nor can the term ‘‘Asian American’’ be understood as a single entity, for it contains myriad nationalities and languages, dozens of religions, and a multitude of races as originating sources. Asian-American literature is considered one of the subdivisions of multicultural or multiethnic literature. According to Gonzalo Ramirez and Jan Lee, there are two kinds of multicultural literature: multiethnic children’s literature and melting pot literature. Multiethnic children’s literature usually addresses the following themes: heritage, the battle against racism and discrimination, everyday experiences, urban civilization, friendship, and family relationships. Cultural problems arise as the protagonist is caught between two cultures and must learn to survive. Melting pot books do not address racial issues but emphasize that Asian Americans have the same lifestyle as any other American. Asian-American literature first emerged in the 1940s, but at that time it was generally nonAsians who wrote books about Asia or Asian Americans. After the end of World War II, there were many Japanese Americans who wrote autobiographies about their experiences in the internment camps in the United States. The first Chinese author to achieve financial success in the United States, C. Y. Lee, was a mentor to many other Asian writers. He wrote The Flower Drum Song in 1955. In the 1970s, criticism began to emerge about the way that Asians were depicted in literature. Critics argued that the literature lacked diverse illustrations and characterization, and that most illustrations of
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
K i r a - K i r a
Cynthia Kadohata (left) playing cards with her sister, 1967 Courtesy of Cynthia Kadohata Asians were drawn in exactly the same way, without regard for cultural or physical distinctions. These illustrations rarely portrayed Asians living in the contemporary United States, wearing modern clothing and living in modern housing. Instead, they offered a stereotyped and unrealistic picture of Asian-American life. There was a call for Asians to write about their experiences and for illustrators to create more accurate representations of Asian Americans. Since that time, many Asian-American authors have met with mainstream success, and authors and illustrators have created a more accurate picture of the Asian-American experience.
Although Kira-Kira is Cynthia Kadohata’s first novel for young readers, the issues she raises and her narrative style bear many similarities to her previously published works of adult fiction, especially The Floating World. Critics often read her works in the context of Asian American literature published in the United States since the 1990s, especially in reference to gender, nationality, and identity. Kadohata’s first novel, The Floating World (1989), is a kind of road drama featuring a Japanese American family’s attempt to find a place of their own.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
CRITICAL OVERVIEW
1
7 7
K i r a - K i r a
Like Kira-Kira, The Floating World is set in the 1950s and narrated by a Japanese American girl, who recounts her family’s experiences while traveling through the United States in search of good jobs and a home. While they are always included within the Asian American canon, other critics have read Kadohata’s works as postmodern texts because of their emphasis on how gender affects society. Critics note that Kadohata utilizes mother-daughter relationships to emphasize changing views on womanhood in the Asian American community, like other Asian American writers such as Jeanne Wakatsuki Houston, Maxine Hong Kingston, Amy Tan, and R. A. Sasaki. Critics often cite Kadohata’s approachable writing style and characterization as an important reason for the uniform critical and popular success of Kira-Kira A review in The Christian Century called Kadohata’s writing ‘‘extraordinary.’’ In School Library Journal, Ashley Larsen notes, ‘‘All of the characters are believable and well developed, especially Katie. . . . Girls will relate to and empathize with the appealing protagonist.’’ Hazel Rochman of Booklist includes Kira-Kira among her top ten historical novels for children and young adults, citing its ‘‘plain, beautiful prose.’’ Winner of the 2005 John Newbery Medal for outstanding writing, KiraKira was praised by Award Committee Chair Susan Faust in Kadohata, Henkes win Newbery, Caldecott Medals’’ as ‘‘a narrative that radiates hope from the inside out.’’
CRITICISM Peter Menard Menard teaches comparative literature. In this essay, Menard considers Kadohata’s book in relation to current debates within American and multicultural literature. Although it is a novel intended for young readers, Kadohata’s Kira-Kira can be read within the author’s entire body of work, which consists primarily of novels for an adult audience. Kira-Kira explores many of the same themes and issues that are present in all of Kadohata’s novels. It is also representative of the debates occurring within American and multicultural literature. In the 1960s, American literature began to move toward inclusion of ethnic, religious, and
7 8
L i t e r a r y
THE AMBIGUITIES THAT EMERGE IN THE EFFORT TO REWRITE AMERICAN LITERATURE AND MAKE IT MORE INCLUSIVE REQUIRE US TO THINK AGAIN AND MORE CAREFULLY ABOUT WHAT IT MEANS TO BE AN AMERICAN.’’
racial groups that had been left out of a traditionally ‘‘white’’ canon. As a result of the experiences of World War II, the Vietnam War, and the Civil Rights Movement, Americans looked for ways to redefine themselves. African Americans, Jewish Americans, and other groups whose experiences had largely been absent from the literary scene began to appear as both authors and characters to tell their stories. Many of these stories focused on the exclusion minorities had endured and their integration into the wider American community. According to Gilbert H. Muller in New Strangers in Paradise: The Immigrant Experience and Contemporary American Fiction, the Immigration Act of 1965 was part of a body of legislation and other social forces that helped to rewrite ‘‘the epic of America’’ in ways that emphasized the ‘‘polyglot, multicultural, and transnational’’ (quoted in Klinkowitz). This new epic was an idealized vision of an integrated nation—America as a melting pot of languages, traditions, customs, and ideologies. By the 1970s and 1980s, however, some critics began to question this melting-pot model. These critics saw the multicultural vision as problematic not only because it supposed that the melting pot experience was possible, but because it also made the very notions of identity and difference hard to sustain. If integration relies on the idea of an all-encompassing American identity, what happens to the differences that excluded groups have used to define themselves? That is, what happens to the distinctive features—such as languages, traditions, customs, and religious practices—that made those groups’ differences visible, unique, and valuable? The ambiguities that emerge in the effort to rewrite American literature and make it more inclusive require us to think again and more carefully about what it means to be an American.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
K i r a - K i r a
The issues surrounding American ethnic literature are also tied to broader debates in postcolonial studies, a school of criticism that analyzes clashes between cultures and examines mechanisms of oppression and resistance. This school of thought argues that people do not necessarily identify themselves in terms of the places in which they live. For example, in KiraKira, Mrs. Muramoto holds a New Year’s Eve party that features traditional Japanese customs and rituals. Katie says, ‘‘New Year’s is the biggest holiday of the year for the Japanese.’’ Though Mrs. Muramoto and the Takeshimas live in America and adopt many ‘‘American’’ ways of life, they identify themselves culturally as Japanese and maintain important Japanese traditions in their American lives. Kira-Kira illustrates many of the ambiguities present in the debates mentioned above. The narrator is a young girl born in Iowa, but her frame of reference—the way in which she views the world—is colored by the language, traditions, and customs of Japan. This is largely because her parents are kibei, which means that they were born in the United States but educated in Japan. The characters of Japanese descent in the novel are defined primarily in cultural terms, that is, they are described in the context of their customs, traditions, myths, and folklore. However, the American characters are defined exclusively in racial terms as white. There are no other non-white ethnicities in Kira-Kira. Because race is the only feature used to describe the other American characters, the novel lacks the cultural components that would define what it means to be anything but a Japanese American. There is never any mention in the novel of ‘‘white’’ traditions, customs, or history; there are only descriptions of how, with few exceptions, whites exclude or look down upon those who are not white. Lynn, the narrator’s sister, presents the conflict concisely as ‘‘us versus them’’: ‘‘Haven’t you noticed that Mom and Dad’s only friends are Japanese? . . . That’s because the rest of the people are ignoring them. They think we’re like doormats—or ants or something!’’ Now she was really angry. . . . She suddenly reached out and hugged [Katie] to her. ‘‘You tell me if anybody treats you like that, and I’ll take care of it!’’
Katie’s sister, Japanese people do not exist for white people, or if they do, they occupy a low position in the social hierarchy. This dynamic makes it difficult to group Kira-Kira within so-called multicultural texts, given that it is only the Japanese who are given a central and valued place in the cultural context of the novel, and the rest of the characters are viewed largely as a menace. When whites are portrayed in a positive manner in the novel, there is often mention of what makes them different from and less admirable than the Japanese characters. The reader can see this as Katie recounts her friendship with Silly, a girl she meets when she accompanies her mother to the processing plant. Silly works part-time at the poultry plant because her uncle makes her earn her own money for school clothes. Katie thinks this is strange and reflects that even though her own parents are poor, they buy her all the school clothes she needs. In pointing out this difference, the narrative implies a judgment about families that fail to help their children in this way. By comparison, Katie’s family stands out as exemplary. Silly’s case also points to the question of class differences in the novel. The discussion of class is based on extremes and stereotypes: the rich characters are evil, while the poor characters are morally upright and worthy of esteem. This characterization of class differences is further complicated by the fact that the rich characters are mostly white. The only white character who cannot be explained in these simplistic terms is Hank Garvin, the man who helps Katie take Sammy to the hospital after he catches his foot in an animal trap. The treatment of class in the novel suffers as a result of this idea that poverty is synonymous with moral virtue. This presupposition threatens the very premise of the novel: a family’s quest for the American dream, which presupposes social and economic advancement.
Lynn’s statement illustrates the way that the Japanese characters in Kira-Kira view white people as a homogenous force threatening their existence as Japanese Americans. According to
Criticism that favors a multicultural perspective is also concerned with the treatment of gender in literature. Gender-based criticism focuses on how males and females are represented, the places they occupy in the community, and their views on sexuality. Before multicultural perspectives became more common, Asian women were often portrayed as exotic objects without voices of their own, and the male point of view predominated. Kira-Kira dismantles this idea. The novel shows how different life
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
7 9
K i r a - K i r a
experiences lead all the women in the novel to acquire voices of their own and become independent individuals who do not depend on men to determine their destinies. Mrs. Takeshima, the mother, exemplifies this point. At the beginning of the novel she is described in stereotypical terms as a ‘‘delicate, rare, and beautiful flower,’’ a fragile person who wishes only for quiet. As the novel progresses, her life-changing experiences—being forced to work under humiliating conditions to support her family, living through the illness and death of her eldest child, and adapting to life in Georgia—teach Mrs. Takeshima to speak for herself. This change has a significant impact on her family and community. Mrs. Takeshima’s transformation is spurred by the prospect of unionization at the poultry processing plant where she works. Initially, she vehemently opposes unionization and sides with the owners because she is afraid of losing her job. However, Mrs. Takeshima attends a union meeting at the end of the novel after Katie tells her:
them say that, because I’d thought it was I who’d taken care of them after Lynn died. But they seemed to think that they had taken care of me.’’
‘‘The union wants to give the factory workers three days off with pay for grief leave, like if a family member dies.’’ [Mrs. Takeshima] pursed her lips and looked at me severely. ‘‘It’s a little late for that,’’ she said. My mother didn’t say anything more. But when the union vote was held the next week, the union won by one vote. That was a surprise, because everyone had expected it to lose by one vote. My mother seemed pleased that the union had won, so I knew how she’d voted.
In the following essay, Wood reviews Kira-Kira, and asserts that Kadohata’s fiction style is similar to that of a memoir.
Mrs. Takeshima’s new-found voice mirrors the changed status that Katie, the narrator, acquires after her sister’s death. At the beginning of the novel, Katie happily lives in Lynn’s shadow and is willing to follow her sister anywhere. Katie is devastated when Lynn dies, but handles her grief by assuming a new role as the oldest daughter and sister in the family:
8 0
The whole family is grief-stricken and each blames him or herself for not being able to save Lynn; it is Katie who assumes responsibility for realizing Lynn’s dream to visit the California coast. In fulfilling her sister’s wish she is able to both mourn and celebrate her, giving her and her family the willpower to go on living. The transformation that she undergoes presents a clear challenge to stereotypical views of Asian women. In spite of its broad generalizations, challenges to stereotypical American identity are the beating heart of Kira-Kira. As the debate over America’s literary canon continues, it is clear that contributions like Kira-Kira are helping to rewrite the ‘‘epic of America.’’ Source: Peter Menard, Critical Essay on Kira-Kira, in Literary Newsmakers for Students, Thomson Gale, 2006.
Sarah A. Wood
Kira-Kira is a Japanese word that describes things that glitter. It is Katie Takeshima’s first word taught to her by her older sister Lynn as they lie in the empty road outside their house looking at the stars. Lynn teaches Katie everything worth knowing. When their family moves from their Japanese community in Iowa to Georgia, Lynn is the one who must explain why some of the other children won’t talk to them at school.
I was worried that her spirit was watching me every time I cried. I was worried that if she saw me crying, she would be very unhappy and maybe she wouldn’t be able to leave the earth the way she was supposed to. So even though I wanted her to keep watching me, I wished she would forget about me and never see me crying and never worry about me anymore, even if that meant I was now alone.
The setting is 1950s Georgia. Katie’s parents are American-born Japanese, but that doesn’t change attitudes toward the family. Her mom and dad work in a poultry processing plant, in conditions typical of factories in the mid-1950s. Factory workers wear thick pads beneath their uniforms because they aren’t allowed to take breaks to use the bathroom. Workers suffer permanent injury from long hours of performing the same tasks. They aren’t given time off for sickness or family emergencies. Attempts to organize a union lead to beatings and other repercussions.
Katie assumes the role of family caretaker in the wake of Lynn’s death. After her parents give her Lynn’s diary, she discovers that they waited to give it to her because they though it would be too upsetting. Katie says, ‘‘It was odd to hear
When Katie asks her mother about unions, her mother responds, ‘‘A union is when all the workers get together and fight the very people who have provided them with a job . . . It’s wrong to fight the people who are trying to
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
K i r a - K i r a
WHAT DO I READ NEXT? Sherry Garland’s Shadow of the Dragon (1993) is the story of Danny Vo, a high school sophomore trying to resolve the conflict between his Vietnamese refugee family’s values and his new American way of life. Kadohata’s first novel, The Floating World (1989), is a young girl’s story of her family’s travels across the United States in search of work. The experiences of Japanese Americans in the 1950s are the principal focus of this book. Finding My Voice (1992), by Marie G. Lee, focuses on Ellen, a young woman who is growing up in a small Minnesota town. Her Korean parents pressure her to go to Harvard, while her classmates and some teachers create pressure with their racism, both subtle and overt. Ellen must learn to cope with these challenges.
explores the feeling of being torn between two countries.
Lois Lowry’s A Summer to Die (1984) also deals with the death of an older sister and a younger sibling’s struggle to cope with the situation. Allen Say’s Grandfather’s Journey (1993) won the 1994 Caldecott Award. In this novel, a Japanese American man recounts his grandfather’s journey to America and
help you.’’ Katie’s mother is afraid of losing one of the few jobs available to Japanese-Americans. Through the family’s struggle to raise money for a home, it is Lynn who is always providing the link between the old and the new and helping the family to understand the process of assimilation. But when she gets sick, the family begins to fall apart. It is up to Katie to take on the role of big sister and eldest daughter.
Amy Tan’s The Joy Luck Club (1989) is the story of eight Chinese women. Four are mothers, each forced to leave China for a different reason; the other four are their daughters, each of whom faces a different set of problems in her everyday life. Each chapter is presented from a different woman’s point of view. The most important character is Jing Mei ‘‘June’’ Woo, the daughter of the woman who started the Joy Luck Club. She is asked to join the club and play mah jong with her adoptive aunts after her mother dies.
Child of the Owl (1977), by Laurence Yep, is the story of a young girl named Casey, who has lived on the road with her gambling father. She is eventually forced to move in with her grandmother in Chinatown. Although she is Chinese American, she knows nothing about her Chinese heritage, and her grandmother begins to teach her about the Chinese culture and way of life. Casey learns about Chinese culture, her dead mother’s life, and her own personal history.
The conditions in post-war factories are true; in some places they still exist. The struggles of an American-born Japanese family are true, and the limitations placed on the family are still experienced by many immigrant families in this country. And the relationships in this book are true, especially the bond between Katie and her sister Lynn.
Cynthia Kadohata is clearly a gifted writer. Her prose sparkles with a specificity that makes Kira-Kira read more like a memoir than fiction. There are many things in the book that are true.
Early in the book Lynn tells her sister, ‘‘The blue of the sky is one of the most special colors in the world, because the color is deep but seethrough both at the same time.’’ She adds that water and people’s eyes have the same quality.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
8 1
K i r a - K i r a
Chicken farm in Santa Cruz, CA, 1913 Santa Cruz Public Libraries
Good fiction can also have this quality of depth and transparency; Kira-Kira certainly does. Source: Sarah A Wood, ‘‘Review: Kira-Kira,’’ in KidsReads.com, February 2004, p. 1.
Susan Faust In this excerpt, Faust talks to Kadohata about how her experience as a Japanese-American growing up in the South influenced her writing and her Newbery Award-winning novel, Kira-Kira. It was four in the morning on the West Coast, and Cynthia Kadohata’s phone was ringing. This had better not be bad news or a crank caller. Kadohata’s boyfriend grabbed the receiver, listened to the excited librarian on the line from Boston, and passed the phone to her. The next moment, Kadohata was leaping up and down: her first children’s book, Kira-Kira (S & S, 2004), had just won the Newbery Medal, the nation’s most prestigious award for young people’s literature. Since 1981, her than the appeared
8 2
Kadohata began writing fiction in career has had more ups and downs Grand Tetons. Her short stories in The New Yorker. The New York
L i t e r a r y
Times praised the ‘‘beautiful, clean yet lyrical prose’’ of her first novel, The Floating World (Viking, 1989). And two years later, she won a Whiting Writers’ Award, a $30,000 grant given to a writer of exceptional promise. Then, suddenly, her career hit the skids. Kadohata’s second novel, In the Heart of the Valley of Love (Viking, 1992), met with mixed reviews. Her third, The Glass Mountains (White Wolf, 1995), was virtually snubbed. By the late-’90s, the one-time wunderkind was all but forgotten, working as a secretary at a food-processing plant and struggling to write screenplays. An old friend suggested she write for kids. Kadohata resisted, but her friend—Caitlyn Dlouhy, now an editor at Simon & Schuster’s Atheneum Books for Young Readers—persisted. Giving in to Dlouhy’s suggestion turned out to be the best career move Kadohata ever made. Kira-Kira (‘‘glittering’’ in Japanese) tells the tender story of a Japanese-American family that moves from Iowa to rural Georgia in the 1950s. The quiet novel radiates hope as its narrator, young Katie Takeshima, recounts her parents’
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
K i r a - K i r a
I DIDN’T REALLY THINK THAT I COULD DO IT. IT SEEMED LIKE A WHOLE OTHER WORLD.’’
my brother when he was born, because they had never seen a Japanese baby before. And I had a very heavy Southern accent when I was a little girl. I used to be a really huge taco eater. There’s one point in the story when the sister dies, and Katie eats five tacos. That was definitely something I would have done as a child. Do you have an older sister?
struggles to earn a living and her older sister’s battle with lymphoma. Like Katie, Kadohata was born in the Midwest to Japanese-American parents. She grew up in small-town Arkansas and Georgia, where her father, like Katie’s, worked long hours in a chicken-processing plant. Kadohata spent her teen years in Los Angeles and studied journalism at the University of Southern California and creative writing at the University of Pittsburgh and Columbia University. Now 48, she and her 20-month-old son, Sammy (whom she adopted from Kazakhstan), live in Long Beach, CA, where we caught up with her. What was your reaction when you found out that Kira-Kira had won? It was just complete, pure, uncomplicated joy. I kept screaming. I’m in my pajamas and robe, and I’m jumping up and down. Sammy didn’t know what was going on. Caitlyn called shortly after I hung up, and then we both screamed. I heard she convinced you to write for kids by sending you a box of children’s books. Why were you so resistant? I didn’t really think that I could do it. It seemed like a whole other world. And then when I read the books, I realized that it’s exactly the same process whether you’re writing for kids or grown-ups. I thought, ‘‘Hey, I should try this.’’ How did the idea for Kira-Kira originate? Maybe with my father, because he worked really hard and many, many long hours. Then came the voice of the girl, Katie. When I’m writing a first-person novel, that ‘‘I’’—that word alone—feels like it does something in my brain; it makes it seem like it’s really me. What events in the story are based on your own life? The feeling of intensity in the family was very real. There are also a few details that are true. Everybody in the hospital did come to see
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
I do, and she is still alive. She took care of us a lot, even though she is only a year and a half older than me. She had a maternal quality about her even then. So I always looked up to her. When I told her what the book was about, she got mad at me. I guess she thought that I was ‘‘secretly hostile toward her.’’ Then, after she read it, she was happy. What was it like to be Japanese American in the South during the 1950s and ’60s? We fit in by not fitting into it, by being part of a very small community. When we went to a party, it was almost always with a group of other Japanese or Japanese Americans who worked as chicken sexers, separating male and female chicks in the hatchery. I remember a little girl asking me something like, ‘‘Are you black or white?’’ I really stumbled for an answer. I said, ‘‘I don’t know.’’ Do you remember the first story you ever wrote? When I was 17, I wrote the most idiotic story in the world. It was about all these ducks that had only one leg. They lived on another planet and were a metaphor for humans. I actually sent that story to The Atlantic Monthly and, of course, immediately got a rejection. I don’t think I wrote anything again until I was in college, when I wrote for the school newspaper. When did you get serious about writing fiction? In 1981 or 1982, I started sending short stories to both The Atlantic Monthly and The New Yorker. I wrote 20 to 40 stories, and I got rejections for all of them. But I got letters back that were encouraging, so I kept writing. I remember in 1986, right before I sold my first story to The New Yorker, I told a friend that I didn’t think I was ever going to sell a story; I wondered if I should stop writing. About three weeks later, I got a phone call from an editor at The New Yorker. How did you come up with the title KiraKira?
V o l u m e
1
8 3
K i r a - K i r a
Actually, the first title was ‘‘I Wish.’’ Then I played around with another Japanese word, pika-pika. It basically means ‘‘glittering,’’ as well, but a slightly different kind of glittering. It sounds sharper, and so at some point, I thought it just wasn’t the right word. I didn’t know the word kira-kira. Someone who was born in Japan ran a bunch of words by me, and that was one of them. Some people said that either pika-pika or kira-kira would do fine. Then I heard about a commercial in Japan about a toilet-bowl cleaner that goes pika-pika. The toilet gets so clean that it’s shining. That was the beginning of the end for pika-pika. What do you think of when you hear the word kira-kira? Stars. Fireflies. I think the title itself stands for hope in the end. It’s definitely the right word. Source: Susan Faust, ‘‘The Comeback Kid,’’ in School Library Journal, May 1, 2005, p. 38.
SOURCES ‘‘Kadohata, Henkes win Newbery, Caldecott Medals,’’ in American Library Association, www.ala.org (January 17, 2005). Chiu, Monica, ‘‘(Un)Doing the Missionary Position: Gender Asymmetry in Contemporary Asian American Women’s Writing ,’’ in Modern Fiction Studies, Vol. 44, No. 2, 1998, pp. 407–10. ‘‘Review of Kira-Kira,’’ in The Christian Century, Vol. 121, No. 25, December 14, 2004, p. 24. Chuh, Kandace, ‘‘Masking Selves, Making Subjects: Japanese American Women, Identity and the Body ,’’ in Journal of Asian American Studies, Vol. 2, No. 3, 1999, pp. 337–39. Harris, Violet and Others, ‘‘Multi Cultural Literature,’’ in Language Arts, Vol 70, No. 3, March 1993, pp. 215–24.
8 4
L i t e r a r y
Klinkowitz, Jerome, ‘‘Fiction: The 1960s to the Present,’’ in Symploke, Vol. 12, No. 1–2, 2004, pp. 174–87. Larsen, Ashley, ‘‘Review of Kira-Kira,’’ in School Library Journal, Vol. 50, No. 3, March 2004, pp. 214–15. Ling, Amy, ‘‘Teaching Asian American Literature,’’ Georgetown University’s Electronic Archives for Teaching the American Literatures, www.georgetown.edu/tamlit (July 7, 2005). Muller, Gilbert H., New Strangers in Paradise. The Immigrant Experience and Contemporary American Fiction , University Press of Kentucky, 1999. Rochman, Hazel, ‘‘Top 10 Historical Fiction for Youth,’’ in Booklist, Vol. 100, No. 18, May 15, 2004, p. 1630.
FURTHER READING Brown Diggs, Nancy, Steel Butterflies, State University of New York Press, 1998. This book compares women’s roles in Japan with women’s roles in the United States. The topics discussed include education, ethics, life in the United States, and the past and future status of women in Japan. The book examines family life, women’s responsibilities in the home, women’s community involvement in the United States and in Japan, aspects of Japanese culture that have been kept alive in America, and the experiences of JapaneseAmerican children.
Zia, Helen, Asian American Dreams: The Emergence of an American People, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2001. This is a detailed and personal account of the formation of the Asian American community, which extends from the first major wave of immigration to Gold Mountain (as the Chinese dubbed America during the gold rush) to the recent influx of Southeast Asians, who have nearly doubled the Asian American population in America since 1975.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
The Kite Runner The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini was published in 2003. Initially published by Riverhead Books, an imprint of Penguin, The Kite Runner was said to be the first novel written in English by an Afghan writer, and the book appeared on many book club reading lists. The novel is set in Afghanistan from the late 1970s to 1981 and the start of the Soviet occupation, then in the Afghan community in Fremont, California from the 1980s to the early 2000s, and finally in contemporary Afghanistan during the Taliban regime.
KHALED HOSSEINI 2003
The Kite Runner is the story of strained family relationships between a father and a son, and between two brothers, how they deal with guilt and forgiveness, and how they weather the political and social transformations of Afghanistan from the 1970s to 2001. The Kite Runner opens in 2001. The adult narrator, Amir, lives in San Francisco and is contemplating his past, thinking about a boyhood friend whom he has betrayed. The action of the story then moves backward in time to the narrator’s early life in Kabul, Afghanistan, where he is the only child of a privileged merchant. Amir’s closest friend is his playmate and servant Hassan, a poor illiterate boy who is a member of the Hazara ethnic minority. The Kite Runner, a coming-of-age novel, deals with the themes of identity, loyalty, courage, and deception. As the protagonist Amir grows to adulthood, he must come to terms
8 5
T h e
K i t e
R u n n e r
with his past wrongs and adjust to a new culture after leaving Afghanistan for the United States. The novel sets the interpersonal drama of the characters against the backdrop of the modern history of Afghanistan, sketching the political and economic toll of the instability of various regimes in Afghanistan; from the end of the monarchy to the Soviet-backed government of the 1980s to the fundamentalist Taliban government of the 1990s. The action closes soon after the fall of the Taliban and alludes to the rise of Hamid Karzai as leader of a new Afghan government in the wake of the events of September 11, 2001.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY Khaled Hosseini was born in 1965 in Kabul, Afghanistan, the setting of much of the action in The Kite Runner. Hosseini and his family moved to Paris in 1976, then immigrated to the United States in 1980 as refugees with political asylum. Hosseini’s parents, a former diplomat and a teacher, settled in San Jose, California, where they subsisted on welfare until his father, working odd jobs, managed to independently support the family. Hosseini received a biology degree in 1988 from Santa Clara University and a medical degree from the University of California, San Diego in 1993. As of 2005, he is a practicing physician, specializing in internal medicine in Northern California. Hosseini published several stories before writing his first novel, The Kite Runner, which was based on an earlier short story of the same title. As a doctor with an active practice and many patients, Hosseini struggled to find time to expand the story, so he wrote the novel piecemeal in the early morning hours. Hosseini contends that treating patients made him a keen observer of people and the ways they express themselves, both verbally and nonverbally. In 2004, Hosseini was selected by the Young Adult Library Services Association to receive an Alex Award, an honor given to the authors of the ten best adult books for teenagers published in the previous year. Also in 2004, he was given the Original Voices award by the Borders Group, and The Kite Runner was nominated for a Pushcart Prize. His next novel, entitled Dreaming in Titanic City, is slated for publication in 2006.
8 6
L i t e r a r y
Khaled Hosseini Ó Jerry Bauer. Reproduced by permission
PLOT SUMMARY Chapters 1–5 The Kite Runner opens in December 2001. The narrator, Amir, meditates on the past, recalling a walk in San Francisco’s Golden Gate Park, and alludes to a more distant moment of crisis in 1976. The narrator considers the way that the past has a way of returning despite one’s efforts to forget it. He mentions the names of several characters slated to appear in later chapters. After this opening, the novel uses a flashback, a device through which the narrator tells about events that happened before the present action of the story. This flashback lasts for many chapters, returning the reader, near the end of the novel, to 2001, the time in which the first chapter is set. The first five chapters sketch the details of Amir’s childhood in Kabul, his daily life with his friend and servant Hassan in his father’s large house, and his burgeoning interest in literature. Hassan and his father live on Amir’s father’s property in a separate servant’s house. They are members of a minority ethnic group in Afghanistan known as the Hazara. Victims of casual discrimination by the privileged classes, the Hazara in The Kite Runner
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
are derided for their appearance and generally live as second-class citizens. However, Hassan and his father Ali, servants in Baba’s household, are treated fairly well as members of the family. Ali has known Baba for decades and Hassan and Amir, despite their differences in ethnicity and status, are constant playmates. As if to further emphasize the differences between them, Hassan has a birth defect, a harelip, which gives him the appearance of constantly smiling. The reader sees the relationship between the young Amir and Hassan in several crucial scenes. The most important of these depicts an encounter between the two friends and a group of older bullies led by Assef, a half-German, half-Afghan boy who accuses Amir of being a traitor to the Pashtun ethnicity by playing with a Hazara boy. While Amir is paralyzed with fear, Hassan ignores the racist insults and drives the bullies away by threatening them with his slingshot. Assef and his minions retreat, but not before Assef threatens revenge.
K i t e
R u n n e r
surviving competitors become fewer and fewer. These detailed descriptions of the practice and strategies of kite-fighting and kite-running lead into a flashback that showcases Hassan’s uncanny talent at running down fallen kites. Encouraged by his father, Amir decides to compete seriously in the kite-fighting competition, in part because he genuinely enjoys the sport, but mostly because he hopes to earn his father’s admiration by winning the tournament.
The narrator meditates on the fun times Amir and Hassan enjoy during the wintertime and describes the events leading up to the 1975 kite tournament in Kabul. Amir describes the annual kite festival, the strategy of kite-fighting, and the importance of ‘‘kite runners’’ like Hassan, who retrieve the kites cut down by the razor-sharp strings of victorious kites as the
On the morning of the kite tournament, Hassan relates a strange dream he has had in which he and Amir swim out into Ghargha Lake, which is said to be inhabited by a terrible monster. In this dream they swim out and return unharmed, despite the dozens of onlookers on the shore warning them to return. Although Amir, irritable from a restless night’s sleep, dismisses the dream, it proves prophetic. The narration shows the reader the excitement and festivity of the streets on the day of the kite tournament as well as the seriousness of the competitors. Amir’s extreme nervousness is compounded by the knowledge that his father is finally supporting him and plans to watch the tournament from his rooftop. Tensions between father and son are so strained that Amir actually wonders whether, if he loses, his father might take pleasure in his defeat. Nevertheless, Amir performs admirably, making many impressive tactical maneuvers until his and another kite are the only two remaining. Amir cuts the last kite out of the sky and sees his father on the roof cheering for him. He also shares the moment of victory with Hassan, who promises to run after the last defeated kite. Hassan is eager to help his friend by retrieving the prize: ‘‘For you a thousand times over!’’ Hassan finds the fallen kite, but is chased by some other boys. Amir follows some noises to an alley off the bazaar where, undetected himself, he discovers a horrific scene: Assef, Kamal, and Wali threaten to take the kite from Hassan; Hassan, unable to fight them off, is raped by Assef while Assef’s friends hold him down. Rather than step in and fight Hassan’s attackers, Amir freezes, remains hidden, and eventually runs away in fear. After the rape, Hassan finds Amir in the street and they return home with the kite without discussing the attack at all, although Hassan is visibly distraught. Amir returns home to a hero’s welcome from his father and his father’s friends.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
The novel details the increasingly turbulent political developments in Afghanistan. As Amir and Hassan grow up, dreaming of being Rostan and Sohrab, the heroes of the Afghan heroic legend the Shahnammah, the events of history invade their world of stories and play. Amir and Hassan get a taste of how politics can affect daily life when they hear gunfire in the streets. Although Ali tells the boys that it is only the sound of fireworks, these sounds foreshadow, or look ahead to, the overthrow of the monarchy by a military coup. Meanwhile, Amir and Hassan continue to play together, but Amir often feels jealous of the attention that Hassan receives from Baba, who treats Hassan less like a servant than like a family member. Indeed, for Hassan’s birthday, Baba pays a surgeon to perform an operation to correct his harelip. As Hassan is healing from his surgery, Amir sees him gingerly smile with his new mouth, an observation that foreshadows tragic events to come.
Chapters 6–7
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
8 7
T h e
K i t e
R u n n e r
Chapters 8–9 Hassan becomes extremely remote, performing his household duties invisibly and avoiding Amir entirely. Neither Amir nor Hassan reveal to Baba what has happened; Amir tries to avoid thinking of his failure to protect his friend. Against the backdrop of this guilt, Amir takes advantage of the opportunity to enjoy his father’s company, now that his father is publicly and unreservedly proud of his accomplishment in the kite tournament. Still, Amir harbors some jealousy when Baba expresses concern for Hassan after noticing that the other boy is withdrawn. Ali reports that Hassan has been ill. Amir’s newfound closeness with his father proves tenuous when Amir, unable to face his guilt about Hassan, suggests that Baba look for new servants to replace Ali and Hassan. Baba angrily rejects the suggestion, insisting that they are not just servants but part of the family. Baba throws a massive celebration in honor of Amir’s thirteenth birthday in the summer of 1976, during which Amir is forced to exchange pleasantries with Assef, who comes to the party accompanied by his parents and bearing a peculiar gift: a biography of Hitler. Unable to bear the festivities, Amir retreats to a quiet place where Rahim Khan finds him, talks to him, and gives him a special gift—a notebook in which to write his stories.
8 8
fearlessness for which he is admired by risking his life to save a woman from rape by a Russian soldier at a checkpoint.
After the party, Amir’s room is piled with unsolicited tributes of both gifts and cash. Overwhelmed with gifts and praise and haunted by guilt, he takes some of the money and a brand new watch and plants them in Hassan’s bed. Unable to bear the false implication that Hassan has stolen from Amir and Baba, Ali and Hassan leave the house in Kabul. While Amir is aware that he is causing great pain to others, including his father who seems devastated by their departure, he does nothing to correct the falsehood he created.
After a sojourn in Pakistan, Amir and his father go to Fremont, California, an area where many other Afghan immigrants have settled. There they have a modest life, living in small apartments. Baba works, Amir studies, and they go to the Saturday flea market to sell their wares alongside other Afghan immigrants. Baba, unable to adjust to life in the United States, works at a gas station so that Amir can go to school and enter college. Meanwhile, Amir helps to smooth over his father’s conflicts with American culture and enjoys his remoteness from a painful past. He falls in love with a young Afghan woman named Soraya Taheri, whom he gets to know at the Saturday swap meets. He asks Baba to ‘‘go khastegari’’ for him, to ask Soraya’s father for her hand in marriage. Meanwhile, Baba, a lifelong smoker, is diagnosed with cancer. Turning down chemotherapy and radiation, he forbids Amir to speak of his illness. Though his cancer has spread alarmingly, he helps Amir perform the traditional Afghan courtship and engagement ceremonies. When Soraya and her father agree to the union, the couple forgoes the traditional long engagement period, knowing that Baba does not have long to live. Baba dies one month after they are married. Amir becomes acquainted with his wife’s family and learns of disagreements between Soraya and her father, particularly relating to the double standards of Afghan gender politics. Amir and Soraya move to a new apartment. Amir works on his writing while Soraya studies to become a teacher. In 1989, just after the Soviets leave Afghanistan, Amir publishes his first novel, a story of a father and son in Kabul. The couple’s happiness is spoiled only by their discovery that they cannot conceive a child.
Chapters 10–13
Chapters 14–16
Taking place six years later, these chapters begin with the traumatic political transition to the Soviet-backed Communist regime of Afghanistan during the 1980s and explain Amir and Baba’s declining fortunes under the new order. In 1981, Amir and his father are compelled to leave everything behind and flee the country for Peshawar, Pakistan inside the tank of a fuel truck, with dozens of other refugees. During this escape, Baba again demonstrates the
Amir and Soraya buy a house in San Francisco. In 2001, Amir gets a call from Baba’s old friend Rahim Khan, who is ill and living in Pakistan. Disturbed by memories of the past he has tried to forget, Amir plans his trip to Pakistan to see him. He considers Rahim Khan’s suggestion that by coming to Pakistan he may have a chance to redeem himself. Arriving in Peshawar, Amir goes immediately to the shabby room where a frail and sickly Rahim Khan is
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
staying in the city’s Afghan Town. In his account of the current state of affairs in Afghanistan, Rahim Khan describes the violence and factionalism of the Northern Alliance rule from 1992 until 1996. He explains how Afghans saw the 1996 takeover by the Taliban as a harbinger of peace and order, little knowing the repression the Taliban would bring. Rahim Khan tells Amir that he is dying and tells him that Hassan, Amir’s boyhood friend and servant, lived with him in Kabul in Baba’s old house. Told from the point of view of Rahim Khan—the only chapter not from Amir’s point of view—Chapter 16 is another extended flashback that recounts Rahim Khan’s life in Kabul after Amir and Baba went into exile. Living by himself in Baba’s house, Rahim Khan becomes lonely, as more and more of his friends flee the country. In the late 1980s, during the era of the Soviet-backed government, Rahim Khan goes to a small village in Hazajarat to seek out Hassan and to ask him to bring his young wife Farzana back to Kabul to live with him and to help take care of the house. Hassan agrees to the arrangement, settling with Farzana in the old servants’ house of his boyhood. Hassan’s long-lost mother Sanaubar, who ran away in 1964, reappears, abused and starving. After nursing Sanaubar back to relative health, Hassan and Farzana have a baby boy whom they name Sohrab after the Afghan heroic tale of Rostam and Sohrab. In 1995, when Sohrab is four years old, Sanaubar dies. During the infighting and instability of the Northern Alliance period, when Kabul is sectioned off and ruled by competing groups, the little family nevertheless maintains a peaceful haven amid the chaos. Young Sohrab learns to read and attends the winter kite tournament with his father Hassan. The 1996 Taliban takeover leads to repression and violence: the Taliban bans Kabul’s traditional kite tournament and massacres the Hazara population of Mazar-e-Sharif.
Chapters 17–24 Following Rahim Khan’s first-person account, he hands Amir a letter from Hassan and a photograph of Hassan as a young man. After reading it, Amir learns that Hassan and his wife have been executed by the Taliban. The fate of their young son Sohrab is unknown. Furthermore, Rahim Khan reveals, Hassan is not only Amir’s former servant and friend, but his half brother, the offspring of Amir’s father
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
K i t e
R u n n e r
and Hassan’s mother Sanaubar. Stunned by these revelations, Amir thinks about his father’s decades-long deception and tries to absorb the fact that Hassan was his brother all along. Though initially overcome by fear, Amir decides to travel to Afghanistan to rescue Hassan’s son Sohrab. Car sick and feeling estranged from the country of his childhood, Amir re-enters Afghanistan, led by his tough-talking guide and driver, Farid. Armed with Afghani currency and a picture of Sohrab and Hassan, Amir also wears a false beard to shield him from the Taliban’s prying eyes. Farid, suspicious of his apparently pampered ‘‘American’’ passenger, updates Amir about the current state of affairs in his home country and awakens Amir to the fact that his class privilege has always shielded him from the reality of life as experienced by most Afghans. Despite Farid’s initial suspicion of Amir’s motives, he decides to help Amir find and rescue Sohrab. Farid drives Amir from Jalalabad, past villages destroyed by the Taliban to the city of Kabul, which, Farid informs him, is much changed. Despite this warning, Amir is shocked when they enter the city and see the signs of destruction and poverty everywhere. Amir has a frightening close encounter with the Taliban who roam the streets in pickup trucks looking for violations of the strict Shari’a law. A beggar who was a former university professor tells Amir the location of the orphanage where he hopes to find Sohrab. From Zaman, a beleaguered orphanage director, Amir and Farid learn that Sohrab has been taken away by a powerful Taliban official who is most likely sexually abusing the boy. Zaman tells them they can find the official at a soccer exhibition. Farid and Amir go to the soccer stadium, where, with the rest of the crowd, they witness a double execution by stoning. Following Shari’a law, the Taliban have sentenced a man and a woman to death for adultery. Before Amir’s horrified gaze, a tall charismatic man in white robes appears, raising his arms in response to the roaring crowd, and personally stones the offenders to death. The Taliban official who throws the stones turns out to be the man the orphanage director described. Frightened and disgusted by what they have just seen, Amir and Farid nevertheless arrange to visit this official. At the official’s compound, Amir discovers that the high-ranking Talib is none other than
V o l u m e
1
8 9
T h e
K i t e
R u n n e r
Assef, Hassan’s attacker from decades before. Assef behaves erratically, and Amir observes the marks of a heroin addiction on his arms. Assef boasts about his participation in the 1998 massacre of Hazara people in Mazar-e-Sharif, announcing that the violence was ordained by God. Assef calls Sohrab into the room to meet Amir, and tells Amir he remembers him from their childhood in Kabul. Assef forces Sohrab, who is costumed like a dancing girl, to perform for Amir and his guards. Amir confronts Assef, demanding that he turn over Sohrab. Assef sends his guards out of the room and challenges Amir to fight for the right to take Sohrab away. A long, violent fight between Amir and Assef ends when Sohrab uses his slingshot to blind Assef. Amir and Sohrab manage to escape in Farid’s waiting car. Amir’s injuries from the battle are so grave that he passes out and remains unconscious for two days. He awakens in a hospital in Pakistan, where he thanks a shy and reserved Sohrab for saving his life with the slingshot. Days later, the search for the charity that was to have taken in Sohrab turns out to be fruitless. Rahim Khan himself has disappeared, leaving for Amir only a letter and a key to a safedeposit box.
Chapters 24–25 With no one else to take care of him, Sohrab accompanies Amir to Islamabad, where they go to escape Taliban spies who may be searching for them in Peshawar. Amir asks Sohrab if he would like to come to America to live with him and his wife. Sohrab agrees only when Amir promises never to place him in an orphanage. Amir calls Soraya to ask her to consent to the arrangement. She agrees, but a consultation with a U.S. Embassy official reveals bureaucratic obstacles. An immigration lawyer advises a new course of action, namely, to put Sohrab in a Pakistan orphanage for a year until he can be officially declared an orphan. When Sohrab learns of this plan, he attempts suicide. At the same time, Amir learns from Soraya that a relative who works for the Immigration and Nationalization Service has arranged for a humanitarian visa with which Sohrab can enter the United States immediately. Amir waits for the outcome of the emergency surgery that he prays will save Sohrab’s life. In the urgency of the moment, Amir prays to God for the first time in fifteen years, experiencing a sudden renewal of his Muslim faith. Sohrab survives. After several
9 0
L i t e r a r y
MEDIA ADAPTATIONS
Simon and Schuster released the audio book version of The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini in 2003. The author reads the audio book version. In audio form, the novel runs twelve hours and spans eight cassette tapes or eleven CDs.
days’ vigil in the hospital, Amir tells Sohrab about the humanitarian visa. Sohrab decides to go to the United States, but his depression is so profound that he does not speak for a year. His silent remoteness persists for months—through the aftermath of September 11, 2001, including the Taliban’s defeat and the emergence of Hamid Karzai. The novel closes at an Afghan community gathering in Fremont, California in 2002. Amir buys a traditional Afghan kite, complete with glass string, and flies it with Sohrab, eliciting a faint smile from Sohrab, who remembers flying kites with his father Hassan in the wintertime. When their kite cuts down a competitor’s kite, Amir runs to retrieve the fallen kite for Sohrab, echoing the words of Hassan from decades before: ‘‘For you a thousand times over.’’
CHARACTERS Ali Ali is the lifelong servant of Baba’s family. Stricken with polio as a child, Ali endures the ridicule of the local boys for his pronounced limp and gnarled appearance. Steadfastly loyal to Baba and Amir, Ali lives with his only child Hassan in a modest servant’s house on Baba’s property. Ali was abandoned by his wife Sanaubar, who ran away soon after giving birth to Hassan. He belongs to the marginalized Hazara ethnic group, which historically resided in the mountainous Hazajarat region of Afghanistan. Despite this, Ali is a proud man
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
who rejects dishonor and leaves Baba’s household rather than live with the shame of his son being thought a thief.
Amir Amir is the protagonist of The Kite Runner. Born into a privileged Pashtun family, Amir grows up in Kabul, Afghanistan raised by his father. His mother died in childbirth. As a boy, Amir is bookish, thoughtful, and unathletic. An introverted thinker, he prefers to write stories in his notebook rather than play soccer, much to his father’s chagrin. Amir indulges in a recurrent fantasy of a warmer understanding with his father and is strongly motivated by the wish to make this fantasy a reality—ultimately with tragic results. Constantly trying to earn his father’s approval, Amir struggles for every scrap of his father’s attention. He becomes jealous when his father pays more attention to Hassan, the son of the family servant Ali. Still, Amir is close to his servant and playmate Hassan. They spend entire days together, especially in the wintertime, and carve their names in a tree behind the house. Torn between affection for his friend and his need for his father’s love, Amir often takes advantage of Hassan’s gullibility and illiteracy. Ironically, his propensity to trick Hassan— making up false stories he pretends to read out of his schoolbooks—inspires him to discover his future calling as a writer. After moving to the United States with his father, Amir becomes a student and later a writer. After marrying a young Afghan woman named Soraya Taheri, he publishes his first novel. However, his childhood betrayal of Hassan haunts his adult life, and he eventually travels back to Kabul in order to make things right.
Assef An older bully who also comes from a privileged family, Assef is the tall, blond-haired son of a German mother and an Afghan father. Flanked by flunkies who assist him in his misdeeds, Assef is a racist with a fascistic streak. He admires Hitler, and even gives Amir a biography of Hitler as a birthday present. Assef believes Afghanistan should be ‘‘purified’’ of the Hazara ethnic group and kept for the dominant Pashtun ethnic group alone. After an encounter with Amir and Hassan in which Hassan forces Assef to retreat with his slingshot, Assef vows payback. Later, with the help of two flunkies, he gets his revenge by raping Hassan in an alley
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
K i t e
R u n n e r
on the night of the annual kite-fighting contest. Assef frightens Amir with his apparently sadistic personality; even Assef’s own parents are cowed in his presence as if they, too, fear him. Assef grows up to become a high-ranking official in the Taliban government, when he and Amir meet for a final time.
Baba A stubborn, energetic man and a prosperous merchant, Amir’s father is as well-respected for his commercial successes as for his philanthropic endeavors. A great host, Baba is given to grand gestures and excessive hospitality. After his wife died while giving birth to Amir, Baba finds it difficult to relate to a son who is so different from himself—introverted, tentative, and intellectual instead of outgoing, strong, and decisive. He observes with disgust that when Amir and Hassan get into scrapes with local boys, Hassan, not Amir, stands up to the bullies. Baba never remarried, preferring to surround himself with male friends and business associates in a house more often than not filled with guests. A Sunni Muslim and an ethical man, Baba counsels his son never to steal; yet he opposes organized religion and dismisses the warnings of the mullahs (religious teachers) who provide religious instruction in Amir’s schools. Despite his stern attitude toward his son, he is a loving father. When Baba and Amir move to California, Baba works at a gas station so Amir can complete his schooling. He proudly presents his son to the Taheri family as a prospective husband for their daughter Soraya, and in the end respects his son for who he has become.
Farid A driver and guide introduced to Amir by Rahim Khan in Peshawar, Pakistan. Farid is a tough man who has lost several family members to Taliban violence. He drives Amir to Kabul to rescue Sohrab, Hassan’s son. Suspicious of Amir at first, Farid eventually respects him for risking his life to save a boy he has never met. Although he has responsibilities, with a wife and small children, he chooses to help Amir on an honorable mission.
Farzana A young Hazara woman, Farzana is Hassan’s wife and Sohrab’s mother. After living in Hazarajat, she and Hassan move to Kabul where they live with Rahim Khan in Amir and
V o l u m e
1
9 1
T h e
K i t e
R u n n e r
Baba’s old house. When Hassan’s mother Sanaubar appears after a decades-long absence, Farzana nurses the older woman back to health. When she gives birth to Sohrab, Sanaubar serves as her midwife. Farzana, along with Hassan, is shot and killed by the Taliban for being a Hazara in the wrong area of Kabul.
Hassan The son of Ali, Hassan is also a servant at Baba’s house and about the same age as Amir. Fiercely loyal, Hassan is Amir’s constant companion. Although born with a harelip, he is unselfconscious and happy, known for his easy smile. Illiterate but endowed with a sharp native intelligence, Hassan is strong, athletic, and courageous. Incapable of deceit, he cannot tell when Amir is tricking him. His premier talent is running the kites in the annual winter kite tournament in Kabul. Kite runners chase the fallen kites that are the casualties of the contest. Hassan has an uncanny ability to sense where the kites will land. His innocent, trusting nature belies a perceptiveness about Amir’s state of mind. For example, Hassan reassures Amir when Amir is nervous about his performance in the annual kite competition. After Hassan is raped by the bully Assef, Hassan knows Amir saw the attack and did nothing but never raises the subject. Instead, when Amir betrays him a second time by telling Baba that Hassan has stolen from them, Hassan apologizes as if he committed the crime. Hassan and Ali leave Kabul and return to the Hazajarat region where the Hazara people have historically resided, but Hassan never holds a grudge against Amir for his actions.
Kamal One of Assef’s companions who reluctantly helps Assef rape Hassan, Kamal later becomes the victim of a similar attack and dies as he and his father attempt to escape Afghanistan for Pakistan during the repressive Soviet-backed regime.
Rahim Khan Baba’s business associate, Rahim Khan frequently visits with Baba to discuss their common commercial interests, Afghan politics, and personal matters. As his best friend and advisor, Khan frequently steps in when friction between father and son creates misunderstandings. Khan encourages Amir’s interest in writing by giving
9 2
L i t e r a r y
him a journal for his thirteenth birthday and sympathizes with the latter’s desperate attempts to earn his father’s approval. Khan is also the guardian of a serious family secret. After Amir and Baba leave Afghanistan, he lives in their house, hoping to return it to them once the political turmoil in Kabul comes to an end. Later, growing older and lonelier, Khan finds Hassan and brings the latter and his wife to live with him in Kabul. Khan becomes gravely ill and moves to Pakistan. He contacts the adult Amir in the United States, summons him to Pakistan, and relates to Amir the history of Hassan, his wife, and their young son.
Sohrab The young son of Hassan and Farzana, born in Kabul, who survives his parents’ execution by the Taliban. Sohrab is named after one of the heroes of the traditional Afghan heroic tale, the Shahnammah. After his parents’ death, Sohrab lands in an ill-equipped orphanage in Kabul, where the children are preyed upon by lecherous Taliban officials. After escaping from his abuser and going with Amir to Pakistan, Sohrab tries to commit suicide upon hearing he may have to return to an orphanage. When he awakes after emergency surgery, he tells Amir that he is too tired to live. Provided with a humanitarian visa, Sohrab can go to the United States to live with Amir and Soraya, where he lives in silence. He does not utter a word for the first year he is there.
General Iqbal Taheri The father of Soraya, Amir’s love interest, General Taheri is a dignified man well-known in the Afghan community in Northern California. Always clad in a worn, but well-made suit, General Taheri is too proud to work, viewing common work as a contradiction to his former importance in the Afghan government. He goes to the weekly flea market where he socializes with other Afghan immigrants who gather there every weekend, referring to his modest flea market trade as a ‘‘hobby’’ that allows him to keep in touch with friends. His wife and daughter tend their market stall while the General talks politics with their friends and neighbors. General Taheri hopes for the end of the Taliban regime and an offer to return to Kabul to take a post in a future Afghan government.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
Khanum Taheri Also known as Khala Jamila, Khanum Taheri is General Taheri’s wife and Soraya’s mother. Endowed with a bubbly personality and a streak of hypochondria, she frequently worries about her health or her family. Although she was once well-known in Kabul for her beautiful singing voice, her husband now forbids her to sing in public.
Soraya Taheri Soraya is the daughter of the once-prominent General Taheri who had a great deal of influence in the government of the pre-Taliban Afghanistan. An intelligent, beautiful young woman, she adheres to the traditions of the patriarchal Afghan culture, despite her rebellious attitude toward her father’s domineering manner and the double standard of gender dynamics that her father upholds. Like Amir and Baba, Soraya and her family are exiles from Afghanistan who assemble with the Afghan community at Saturday swap meets and other gatherings. Despite a scandalous past when she lived with a man to whom she was not married, Soraya endures the persistent gossip in the Afghan community and dedicates herself to the care of her new husband and father-in-law while pursing her goal of becoming a teacher.
Zaman A struggling orphanage director in Kabul, Zaman tells Amir and Farid where they can find the Taliban official who has abducted Sohrab.
THEMES Identity and Self-Discovery Throughout the novel, the protagonist struggles to find his true purpose and to forge an identity through noble actions. Amir’s failure to stand by his friend at a crucial moment shapes this defining conflict. His endeavor to overcome his own weaknesses appears in his fear of Assef, his hesitation to enter a war-torn country ruled by the repressive Taliban, and even his carsickness while driving with Farid into Afghanistan. Late in the novel, Amir discovers his father’s lifelong deception about his half brother Hassan, a revelation that leads to a deeper understanding of who his father was and how
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
K i t e
R u n n e r
he and his father had both betrayed the people who were loyal to them.
Family, Fathers, and Fatherhood In this novel in which family relationships play a great part, mothers are strikingly absent. Although Soraya is a loving mother to Sohrab, Amir and Hassan grow up without their mothers. Meanwhile, the tension of father-son relationships is exemplified by Baba’s treatment of his sons, Amir and Hassan. While Baba is disappointed in Amir’s bookish, introverted personality, to protect his social standing, he does not publicly acknowledge his illegitimate son Hassan whose mother is a Hazara. Likewise, General Taheri is a traditional, highly critical father who chafes at his grown daughter’s sometimes rebellious attitudes. The theme re-emerges in the marriage of Amir and Soraya, who try unsuccessfully to start a family of their own. Their adoption of the troubled and parentless Sohrab at the end of the novel marks an attempt to recreate a complete family based on relationships of love and honesty.
Journey and Quest A novel of immigration and political unrest, The Kite Runner is punctuated by Amir’s departure from Afghanistan as a teenager and his return to his war-ravaged home country as an adult. At the same time, it is a novel of symbolic quest. Amir makes great sacrifices to pursue his quest to atone for past sins by rescuing his half nephew. Symbolized by the bleeding fingers of kite-fighters who cut their competitors’ kites out of the sky with string embedded with glass, sacrifice is an important theme of the novel. Near the beginning of the novel, Amir willingly cut his fingers to impress his father with a kite-fighting victory; at the end he cuts his fingers flying a kite to revive his spiritually wounded nephew from a profound depression. Whereas the young Amir compares Hassan’s resignation to his attackers’ assault to the resignation of a sacrificed animal, by the end of the novel, Amir is prepared to sacrifice much in order to save Hassan’s son from a similar fate.
Heritage and Ancestry Before leaving Afghanistan, Baba fills a snuff box with soil from his homeland. As refugees in the United States, Baba and Amir live in an Afghan immigrant community in the San Francisco Bay Area. Even though much of the
V o l u m e
1
9 3
T h e
K i t e
R u n n e r
MEDIA ADAPTATIONS
Hassan that Rahim Khan presents to Amir. Suppose Amir wrote a letter in response. As a group, write a one-page letter in which Amir explains to Hassan how his character, goals, or understanding of the world has changed. Provide specific details from the novel to support Amir’s claims.
Think about Amir’s relationship with Baba as it is detailed in Chapter 2 through Chapter 7. Make a list of the adjectives that describe Amir. Now make a list of adjectives that describe Baba. How are Baba and Amir alike? How are they different? In a short essay, describe the relationship between Baba and Amir, giving at least four concrete examples from the novel to support your points.
Gather in a small group and study the scene from pages 70 to 79. Then review the confrontation between Amir and Assef in Chapter 22. How has Amir changed in the years between the early scene and the later one? Next, think about the letter from
Twice in the novel, the character Assef is associated with Adolf Hitler. Research the early twentieth-century German nationalist movement that led to Nazism. Based on the novel’s depiction of the Taliban regime, make a list comparing and contrasting how citizens responded to the two regimes. How did Nazism affect Germany from the 1930s to the 1940s? How were the effects of the Taliban regime in Afghanistan from the mid-1990s to the early 2000s similar or different? Include specific examples from the novel to support your arguments.
action takes place in the United States, most of the characters there are Afghan, emphasizing how Amir and Baba thrive in and contribute to an immigrant community that reminds them of home. Although Baba dies without ever seeing his home country again, Amir maintains his ties to the Afghan community in Northern California, partly through his wife’s family. Descriptions of Amir and Soraya’s courtship and Baba’s funeral exemplify such ties to traditional cultural values. The reader is treated
to detailed accounts of the khastegari tradition in which the groom’s father requests permission of the prospective bride’s father, and the elaborate traditional ceremony in which Amir and Soraya are married. Although Amir first views living in the United States as a way to forget a painful past, he maintains and revives his ties to Afghan culture and religion. He returns to his country of birth and, after his nephew attempts suicide, re-discovers Islam as a source of strength. The narration and dialogue welcome
9 4
What would have happened if Amir had fought to rescue Hassan from Assef, instead of running away? Would Hassan and Ali have moved with Baba and Amir to California? How would the boys’ lives have been different? Create a timeline of events and milestones for each boy as their lives were presented in the novel, then create a new timeline for each boy to reflect how his life might have changed if Amir had saved Hassan. Return to the middle chapters of the novel, when Amir’s wife Soraya interacts with her father and mother. Think about the ways that traditional Afghan culture, as Hosseini represents it in the novel, appears to have differing expectations of men and women. How have Soraya Taheri and her mother Khanum Taheri been affected by the ways that women’s behavior is constrained by traditional Afghan culture? Write a two-page essay in which you discuss how the politics of gender in Afghan culture affects the characters in the novel, using concrete examples from the book to support your arguments.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
the reader into this ethnic Pashtun and Afghan national identity through running translations of frequently spoken or culturally significant phrases and concepts.
Assimilation and Acculturation From the early twentieth century to contemporary times, new arrivals to the United States have lived and worked in their new homeland, attempting to lead better lives and simultaneously struggling to adjust to a culture that may or may not accept their traditions. When Amir and Baba arrive in Fremont, California, they, too, must start new lives. While Baba works at a humble job in a service station, Amir attends school, graduating from high school at the age of twenty. While Baba (like General Taheri, a man of his generation) dreams of returning to Afghanistan in better times, Amir who has spent much of his teenage years in the United States, adjusts more readily to his new country. For Amir, as for many in the literature of the American immigrant experience, the United States represents a space for new beginnings and a way to erase a dark, violent past. For Baba, the transition is more difficult, and his new life presents a painful contrast with his former position of power and prestige in Kabul.
K i t e
R u n n e r
the discrimination against this entire ethnic minority. Likewise, he gives voice to this attitude when he attacks Amir for having a Hazara boy for a playmate. In a sense, even Baba condones systematic discrimination against Hazara people by refusing to acknowledge his son with a Hazara woman, Sanaubar.
STYLE Flashback and Foreshadowing Khaled Hosseini frequently uses flashback and foreshadowing. Indeed, most of the novel, which begins in 2001 and ends in 2002, is an elaborate flashback that brings the reader from the narrator’s childhood to his young adulthood to his manhood. Within this overarching structure, Hosseini’s use of time devices provide the reader and the narrator with information about what has happened outside the action of the novel so far, as in Chapter 16, in which Rahim Khan updates Amir on what has happened to Hassan since Amir and Baba left Kabul, or in Hassan’s letter, in which some of the same events are told from a different point of view.
The events of the novel occur against the backdrop of political change, culminating in the rise of the tyrannical Taliban government in contemporary Afghanistan. Assef, Hassan’s rapist and the bully who becomes a high-ranking Taliban official, embodies the consequences of the abuse of power for power’s sake and the violence and repression of the Taliban regime. Assef is a sociopath who thrives in an atmosphere of chaos and subjugation. Interpersonal violence leads to the split between Amir and Hassan; on a national scale, the abuse of power by the Soviet-backed Communist regime in Afghanistan forces Baba and Amir to go into exile. The abuse of political and social power also appears in frequent references to the Hazara people, who are second-class citizens in the quasi-caste system of Afghanistan. At the beginning of the novel, Hazara characters such as Hassan’s father Ali suffer public humiliation for their appearance. When General Taheri demands an explanation for Amir and Soraya’s adoption of a Sohrab, ‘‘a Hazara boy,’’ he echoes
The use of time devices like foreshadowing may also prepare the reader for an imminent event or crisis. For example, during a description of Hassan’s face in Chapter 7, the narrator breaks into the description to tell the reader that this was the last time he would see Hassan’s smile except in a photograph, an interruption of the forward narrative that warns the reader that something momentous is in the offing. Sometimes the use of these techniques appears to signal moments when the lives of individuals are changed forever by violence, death, or the consequences of world events. One example occurs in Chapter 22, when Amir, seated in the house of the Taliban official, nervously eats a grape from a bowl on the table. Amir remarks, ‘‘The grape was sweet. I popped another one in [my mouth], unaware that it would be the last bit of solid food I would eat for a long time,’’ thus preparing the reader for the violence of the imminent confrontation between Amir and Assef. Foreshadowing also plays a part in Chapter 7 when Amir witnesses the attack on Hassan on the night of his victory in the kite tournament:
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
Political Power/Abuse of Power
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
9 5
T h e
K i t e
R u n n e r
I had one last chance to make a decision. One final opportunity to decide who I was going to be. I could step into that alley, stand up for Hassan—the way he’d stood up for me all those times in the past—and accept whatever would happen to me. Or I could run.
This internal monologue hints that in the future Amir will suffer from a crisis in identity. Later in the novel, his failure to stand up for Hassan in his moment of need becomes a burden he carries for much of his life, and forces Amir to take drastic measures to recover his sense of himself as a good person.
Diction The dialogue, or quoted conversation between characters, and the narration use a variety of modes to affect the reader. The diction ranges from detailed description to conversational. One feature of the novel’s use of language is its frequent references to Afghan culture and its use of terms from Pashtu and Farsi that denote important concepts in Afghan tradition and in the lives of the Afghan community in the San Francisco Bay Area. Such terms are nearly always translated for non-Pashtu- and nonFarsi-speaking readers in a way that invites the reader to become familiar with Afghan culture while remaining engaged in the flow of action. The writing is peppered with words in Farsi and Dari (which is the version of Farsi commonly spoken in Afghanistan), followed by brief translations set off by commas. In addition to the oftheard greeting Salaam Aleikum and the oath inshallah, the reader learns the meanings of such expressions as ihtiram (respect); nazar (the evil eye); lotfan (please); yateem (orphans); and zendagi migzara (life goes on). For example, when Amir asks his father to ask Soraya’s father for permission for Amir and Soraya to marry, in accordance with Afghan tradition, he says, ‘‘I want you to go khastegari. I want you to ask General Taheri for his daughter’s hand.’’ Similarly, when Soraya tells Amir about a secret from her past, he thinks, ‘‘I couldn’t lie to her and say that my pride, my iftikhar, wasn’t stung at all.’’
Interior Monologue Interior monologue, or the words a character uses to describe his or her own feelings to him- or herself, is an important technique through which Hosseini enables the reader to become acquainted with the narrator Amir,
9 6
L i t e r a r y
and through him, the Afghan culture and history that propel much of the action of the story. Internal monologue is a particularly important device in this work because the action is as much propelled by political developments as by the protagonist’s psychological development.
Imagery and Symbolism The novel invites the reader to view images and symbols in the first part of the novel as mirrored by those at the end. For example, the novel is book-ended by two kite contests. The imagery of kite-fighting dominates the scene that marks the last happy moments Hassan and Amir enjoy together. At the end of the novel, a smaller kite contest between the adult Amir and a young Afghan American boy, as Sohrab looks on, suggests redemption for Amir, who has never forgiven himself for what happened to Hassan on the night of that first kite-fighting contest in Kabul years before. Similarly, Assef’s attack on Hassan as the twelve-year-old Amir looks on is echoed in the battle between the adult Amir and Assef late in the novel
HISTORICAL CONTEXT The Kite Runner, set in Afghanistan and the United States from the 1970s to 2002, presents a story of intertwined personal conflicts and tragedies against a historical background of national and cultural trauma. The early chapters tell much about the richness of Afghan culture as experienced by the young Amir and Hassan in the Afghan capital, Kabul. The novel’s account of the culture of Kabul informs the reader about everything from the melon sellers in the bazaar to the cosmopolitan social and intellectual lives of Kabul elite society during the monarchy, to the traditional pastimes of Afghan children. Detailed descriptions treat the reader to such events as a large extended-family outing to a lake and the annual winter kite tournament of Kabul. Subsequent political developments, however, appear to curtail these relative freedoms, as first the Soviet-backed Communist government, then the Northern Alliance, and finally the Taliban progressively repress the activities of Afghan citizens. The reader learns the effects of the first of these developments through first-person narration; the effects of the Northern Alliance and of Taliban rule emerge in Rahim
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
Khan’s, Farid’s, and Hassan’s accounts of Afghan life in the period between the late 1980s and the early 2000s. Starting in the early chapters of the novel, broad political events such as the revolution that overthrows the monarchy come to form not just a background for the action, but to become prime movers of the plot. The sound of gunfire in Chapter 5, for example, initiates a series of political shake-ups that eventually leads to the Communist takeover of Afghanistan and drives Baba and Amir, along with many of the privileged class, into exile. In addition, it marks an end to a period that was— despite being marred by the iniquities of the caste system—relatively idyllic. As Amir observes, ‘‘The generation of Afghan children whose ears would know nothing but the sounds of bombs and gunfire was not yet born.’’ This observation foreshadows the traumatized condition of Amir’s nephew Sohrab, born in the midst of violence and orphaned and abused by the Taliban. The Kite Runner is one of the first works of fiction to include the September 11, 2001 attacks on the United States within the span of its narrative. In the aftermath of the September 11 attacks, Afghanistan was portrayed in popular media as a country whose government allowed a terrorist organization to operate within its borders and committed human rights abuses against its own people. Through a detailed personal narrative, the novel re-focuses attention on Afghanistan through a different lens, correcting this narrow view of a country which, despite its problems, has a fascinating history.
K i t e
R u n n e r
could help one another and preserve Afghan cultural traditions. Detailed descriptions in the middle and late chapters give the reader a window on some cultural practices, both formal and informal, that help define the Afghan community in Fremont. Amir’s and Soraya’s lives are certainly taken up with the broader American culture. Both attend public schools and (we presume) mix with non-Afghan students; Amir takes creative writing classes in which he must read about the experiences of a diverse group of young writers; and Soraya has a career as a writing instructor at a community college. Still their identities as Afghans or Afghan Americans are defined in part by the ceremonies and practices of their families and their community. The Saturday swap meets, for example, exemplify the well-documented strategy of immigrant groups to adapt already existing institutions in the United States as ways to preserve their cultures of origin.
CRITICAL OVERVIEW The Kite Runner was published in 2003 to nearly unanimous praise. Said to be the first novel written in English by an Afghan, the novel was instantly popular. Its first printing was fifty thousand copies, it has been featured on the reading lists of countless book clubs, and foreign rights to the novel have been sold in at least ten countries.
The novel also gives a detailed account of how one ethnic group formed a cultural enclave within American culture so that its members
Reviewers admired the novel for its straightforward storytelling, its convincing character studies, and for its startling account of the human toll of the violence that has accompanied Afghanistan’s turbulent political scene in the last thirty years. In his review in World Literature Today, Ronny Noor remarks, ‘‘This lucidly written and often touching novel gives a vivid picture of not only the Russian atrocities but also those of the Northern Alliance and the Taliban.’’ A brief review in Publishers Weekly credited the novel with providing ‘‘an incisive, perceptive examination of recent Afghan history and its ramifications in both America and the Middle East,’’ and called it ‘‘a complete work of literature that succeeds in exploring the culture of a previously obscure nation that has become a pivot point in the global politics of the new millennium.’’ The novel was noted for its detailed portrayal of a friendship between two
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
Another important historical and cultural context of the novel is the diverse and variegated world of contemporary multicultural America, particularly in California. Hosseini, the son of a diplomat and a teacher, left Afghanistan with his family in 1981, much like Amir. Likewise, Amir’s experiences in the Afghan immigrant community of Fremont, California, familiarly known in the San Francisco Bay Area as ‘‘Little Kabul,’’ may reflect the author’s experiences of the area from arrival in San Jose in the 1980s. Amir’s life as a young immigrant in the multicultural space of the Bay Area illustrates the increased mixing of diverse ethnicities in the 1980s and 1990s within U.S. popular culture.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
9 7
T h e
K i t e
R u n n e r
Afghan soldiers stand guard as women clad in burqas walk past, Kabul, 2003 Ó Ahmad Masood/Reuters/Corbis
boys that tenuously spans class and ethnic lines. In the New York Times Book Review, Edward Hower praises the novel for its detailed descriptions of life in Kabul in the 1970s: ‘‘Hosseini’s depiction of pre-revolutionary Afghanistan is rich in warmth and humor but also tense with the friction of different ethnic groups.’’ Hower also notes how the class distinctions between Amir and Hassan make their relationship all the more vulnerable: ‘‘Amir is served breakfast every morning by Hassan; then he is driven to school in a shiny Mustang while his friend stays home to clean the house.’’ A few noted with misgiving that the novel occasionally strays from the conventions of realism in contemporary fiction. Hower notes, ‘‘When Amir meets his old nemesis, now a powerful Taliban official, the book descends into some plot twists better suited to a folk tale than a modern novel.’’ Like Hower, Rebecca Stuhr of the Library Journal focuses on the late chapters in pointing out the novel’s ‘‘over-reliance on coincidence.’’ In an otherwise glowing review in the Times Literary Supplement, James O’Brien points out that ‘‘When Hosseini strays from the simple narrative style he prefers, he struggles to retain credibility.’’ Noor argued
9 8
L i t e r a r y
that the novel gives ‘‘a selective, simplistic, even simple-minded picture’’ of the ongoing Afghan conflict, in particular an overly optimistic view of Hamid Karzai’s ability to govern Afghanistan. Overall, reviewers see the novel as a great triumph marred only by rare stylistic flaws.
CRITICISM Maria Elena Caballero-Robb Maria Elena Caballero-Robb earned her Ph.D. in American Literature from the University of California, Santa Cruz. She works in publishing and teaches courses in U.S. literature and culture and composition. In this essay, Caballero-Robb interprets Hosseini’s novel The Kite Runner as a work that intertwines the private and public realms of experience. Perhaps what garnered Hosseini’s first novel, The Kite Runner, so much early praise, aside from the political relevance of its subject matter when the book was published in 2003, is its successful intertwining of the personal and the political. The novel has an ambitious agenda: to sketch the maturation of its protagonist from
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
IN PASSING THROUGH THIS TRANSFORMING CRUCIBLE, AMIR NOT ONLY ATONES FOR PAST PERSONAL FAILINGS BUT ALSO EMBRACES A HOPEFUL IDEAL OF CITIZENSHIP CAPABLE OF UPHOLDING PRINCIPLES OF LIBERTY AND HUMAN RIGHTS EVEN IN THE FACE OF REPRESSIVE, FASCIST SYSTEMS.’’
a callow boy beguiled by mythical stories of heroes and to portray the political situation of contemporary Afghanistan. The novel begins to show how the personal and the political affect one another through the peculiar relationship between Amir and Hassan. Indeed, James O’Brien, in his review in the Times Literary Supplement, argues, ‘‘this muddled, unbalanced and ultimately tragic relationship’’ between the privileged Amir and the servant Hassan ‘‘lies at the heart of The Kite Runner and echoes the betrayals and power shifts that begin to shape the country shortly after the story begins.’’ Through the course of the novel, Amir’s personal quest takes him on a decades-long journey from his birth country to the United States and finally back to his country of origin. In passing through this transforming crucible, Amir not only atones for past personal failings but also embraces a hopeful ideal of citizenship capable of upholding principles of liberty and human rights even in the face of repressive, fascist systems. In the first several chapters, the novel’s action revolves around the relationship between Amir and his friend and servant Hassan, and Amir’s constant attempts to earn the respect and love of his father, Baba. Amir describes Hassan as a wise innocent, incapable of deceit, yet uncannily perceptive. Hassan’s character and unschooled intelligence are apparent in his complete loyalty to Amir and his ability to perceive things about Amir that not even Amir is aware of: ‘‘Hassan couldn’t read a first-grade textbook, but he could read me plenty.’’ Indeed, critic Melissa Katsoulis points out in her review in the Times (London), ‘‘Though Hassan cannot read or write, he loves to hear Amir read aloud and is perfectly capable of pointing out the
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
K i t e
R u n n e r
gaping hole in Amir’s first attempt at plotting a story.’’ Hassan is also admired for his physical talents—a faultless aim with a slingshot and the ability to predict where a loose kite will drift ‘‘as if he had some sort of inner compass.’’ Baba’s unusually high regard for his son’s servant makes Amir, who cannot seem to please his father, jealous. When Baba pays for an operation to correct Hassan’s harelip and dotes on the boy during his recovery, Amir thinks, ‘‘I wished I too had some kind of scar that would beget Baba’s sympathy. It wasn’t fair. Hassan hadn’t done anything to earn Baba’s affections; he’d just been born with that stupid harelip.’’ Meanwhile, Amir is acutely aware that there is little understanding between himself and his father: ‘‘The least I could have done was to have had the decency to have turned out a little more like him.’’ He senses that his father blames him for his mother’s death in childbirth; and to compound matters, he overhears his father remark to Rahim Khan, ‘‘If I hadn’t seen the doctor pull him out of my wife with my own eyes, I’d never believe he’s my son.’’ While the dynamics of these relationships remain central to the story, in later chapters, the political events outside the limits of the family circle propel the story’s action. The first hint of this transition occurs when Amir and Hassan have an encounter with a violent older boy named Assef, who wants to persecute Hassan for being a Hazara. Assef, who believes Hitler was an ideal leader, tells Amir that he is betraying his Pashtun heritage by treating a Hazara boy as his close friend. While Assef’s bigotry outrages Amir, Amir is unable to think of a response. Ultimately, Hassan stands up to Assef and his lackeys; when Assef and his lackeys threaten to hurt the two younger boys, it is Hassan, not Amir, who saves them both by using his slingshot to drive the bullies away. The boys’ second encounter with Assef is much less victorious. Ironically, the encounter occurs immediately after Amir wins the kite-running tournament, which Amir believes is his chance finally to live up to his father’s expectations: There was no other viable option. I was going to win, and I was going to run that last kite. Then I’d bring it home and show it to Baba. Show him once and for all that his son was worthy. Then maybe my life as a ghost in this house would finally be over. I let myself dream: I imagined conversation and laughter over
V o l u m e
1
9 9
T h e
K i t e
R u n n e r
dinner instead of silence broken only by the clinking of the silverware and the occasional grunt.
The novel’s frequent reference to the Afghan heroic tale, the Shahnammah, implicitly creates a comparison between Amir’s relationship with his father and the larger-than-life interactions between the father-and-son warriors Rostam and Sohrab in the myth. When Amir wins the kite tournament, he begins to think of his anticipated reunion with his father in mythical terms: In my head, I had it all planned: I’d make a grand entrance, a hero, prized trophy in my bloodied hands. Heads would turn and eyes would lock. Rostam and Sohrab sizing each other up. A dramatic moment of silence. Then the old warrior would walk to the young one, embrace him, acknowledge his worthiness.
The additional stakes of the kite tournament—the need not just to obtain the last fallen kite, but to win his father’s love—compound the dilemma Amir faces when he finds Hassan being threatened by Assef and the other bullies in an alley. While Amir chooses to run, out of fear rather than to help his friend, he wonders whether he has actually sacrificed his friend for his own ends. Even as Amir sees that Hassan is in danger, he is also focused on the coveted blue kite: ‘‘Hassan was standing at the blind end of the alley in defiant stance. . . . Behind him, sitting on piles of scrap and rubble, was the blue kite. My key to Baba’s heart.’’ Although he is horrified at what happens to Hassan, he allows his friend to become a casualty of his quest to improve his relationship with his father. Amir’s actions mirror the ethnic inequalities between Pashtuns and Hazara that are reflected in a dozen daily occurrences in the first several chapters. He uses Hassan as an instrument to achieve a desired end. Amir’s failure to treat his playmate as a person marks the fatal character flaw that the adult Amir will seek to remedy. The adult Amir moves to remedy this failure by accepting the mission to rescue Hassan’s son, Sohrab, from an uncertain end. Amir redeems himself by confronting Assef and assuming responsibility for Hassan’s child. The climax of the novel parallels the earlier violent crisis in which Assef rapes Hassan, but offers a victorious outcome. The battle between Amir and Assef presents Amir with the belated opportunity to fight as he believes he should have fought to save Hassan when they were children. By risking his life to save Hassan’s child from a
1 0 0
L i t e r a r y
sadistic pedophile, Amir begins to atone for his earlier inhumanities. Throughout the novel, the author uses corresponding symbols and images to emphasize the way that Amir’s adult choices are belated remedies of past failures. After the climactic fight with Assef during his rescue of Sohrab, Amir is taken to a hospital in Pakistan with serious injuries. While he recovers, he discovers that his upper lip has been split clear up to the gum line, forming a harelip similar to the one Hassan was born with. Echoing an earlier scene in a hospital, in which the twelve-year-old Hassan recovers from an operation to mend his harelip, the adult Amir must wait for his own split lip to mend and quickly learns that it hurts to smile. This simultaneously reminds the reader of the moment when Amir sees Hassan smile for the last time. The reader may view Amir’s injury as a moment of belated sympathy between two brothers now separated not only by geographic distance and differing fortunes, but also by death. The novel’s use of literary techniques contributes to a political statement about the relationship between individuals and systems—or the capacities of individuals to combat broad injustice in political systems. The Kite Runner turns on more than one astounding coincidence: when Amir returns to Kabul, he meets a beggar who turns out to have known Amir’s mother; and, most startling, Assef, the childhood bully, turns out to be the prominent Taliban official who has kidnapped and brutalized Hassan’s son Sohrab. While Rebecca Stuhr of the Library Journal finds fault with the novel’s ‘‘over-reliance on coincidence,’’ Hosseini’s use of the device shows how even personal conflicts like Amir’s lifelong struggle with his own guilt are intertwined with world events. This narrative twist also emphasizes the interplay between the present and the past—‘‘the past claws its way out’’—by showcasing the way that the deeds of childhood cast their shadows into adulthood. (In a similar vein, the author’s use of foreshadowing sometimes signals to the reader that an imminent event will have lasting consequences, as when Amir plants money in Hassan’s room in order to implicate him in a theft.) That Amir’s former nemesis turns out to be the Taliban official from whom he must rescue Sohrab lends an allegorical and mythical dimension to the battle between the two men. As a young boy, Assef is already described as ‘‘a
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
sociopath;’’ an admirer of Hitler, Assef displays fascist tendencies and openly advocates removing the Hazara population from Afghanistan. Amir, on the other hand, who is by and large a good boy, is self-interested and lacks conviction. If the grown Assef appears to be a nearly cartoonish embodiment of sadism and the desire for absolute power, Amir’s struggle to defeat him and save the young Sohrab appears to be an allegory for a broader struggle for Afghanistan. Whereas Amir had been able to escape the daily violence of contemporary Afghanistan as a result of his relative privilege, his Hazara friend Hassan had no choice but to raise his son among a generation of Afghan children, born into a turbulent society, who ‘‘know nothing but the sound of bombs and gunfire.’’ Interestingly, when Amir, a successful writer, tries to use his privilege to rescue Sohrab by offering Assef money, he is rebuffed; instead he must put his life at risk in order to complete his mission. Amir’s decision to return to Afghanistan to save the son of his forsaken friend represents a choice for the exiled to return to his birth country to confront the problems that drove him away. The Kite Runner focuses more on interpersonal dramas than on political ones; it is a matter of interpretation whether Amir feels responsible for the future of his birth country in the same way that he feels accountable for his nephew’s fate. Still, through Assef’s embodiment of the evil of fascism and Amir’s willingness to fight him for a good cause the reader is presented with a stark contrast between a theocratic regime that starves and crushes the freedoms of its people, and a reluctant but ultimately courageous citizen willing to risk his life for what he believes in. Remarkably, the novel does not allude to the enormous controversy that accompanied the aftermath of the events of September 11, 2001, including the bombing of Afghanistan in retaliation for the Taliban’s harboring of terrorist camps. If one can discern an author’s view of politics from his fiction, Hosseini views developments in Afghan national politics of 2001 and 2002 with some optimism. In the last two chapters, the narrator speaks warmly of the ousting of the Taliban and the emergence of Hamid Karzai as the new leader of Afghanistan, and describes the hope with which the imminent Loya jirga, the exiled king’s return to Afghanistan, is anticipated by Afghans and Afghan Americans
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
K i t e
R u n n e r
alike. This optimistic attitude toward contemporaneous developments in Amir’s home country parallels the novel’s final flicker of hope regarding Sohrab. Afghanistan, the novel seems to argue, so recently brutalized and repressed, may yet survive. Source: Maria Elena Caballero-Robb, Critical Essay on The Kite Runner, in Literary Newsmakers for Students, Thomson Gale, 2006.
James O’Brien In the following review, O’Brien discusses the author’s use of voice, and how the two main characters reflect the character of Afghanistan itself. Rare is the exiled author whose remembrances of home resist becoming rose-tinted as the years pass. Given the ravages visited on Afghanistan since the young Khaled Hosseini and his family sought political asylum in the United States in 1980, the foremost of many triumphs in this startling first novel must be that its consideration of cultural, religious and deeply personal upheavals remains cool and considered throughout. Hosseini’s own profession—he is a doctor—perhaps provides a more convincing explanation of his narrator’s unemotional tone than the fictional claim that he has become an English-language author of some repute. Amir is twelve when the novel begins in 1975, but the seeds of his story were sown much earlier. He ‘‘killed’’ his mother in childbirth and, a bookish, somewhat sickly child, has done little since to earn either affection or respect from his father. Amir’s only solace is Hassan, his hare-lipped servant and best friend. It is this muddled, unbalanced and ultimately tragic relationship that lies at the heart of The Kite Runner and echoes the betrayals and power shifts which begins to shape the country shortly after the story begins. The two boys suckled at the same breast—it belonged to a wet nurse; Hassan’s mother quit her humdrum existence in search of glamour shortly after Amir’s quit this life altogether— and so forged a bond which Afghans believe to be unbreakable. Their early life was idyllic, with only the uncaring shadow of Amir’s Baba blighting their days of storytelling, fruit-gathering and kite-running. In Kabul, the kite strings are laced with glass to slice all-comers from the skies until just one remains aloft. Hassan is the finest kiterunner in Kabul, with an unerring ability to
V o l u m e
1
1 0 1
T h e
K i t e
R u n n e r
WHAT DO I READ NEXT?
Farah Ahmedi’s memoir The Story of My Life: An Afghan Girl on the Other Side of the Sky (2003) also recounts a childhood in Kabul. Ahmedi, a high school student in Illinois at the time her book was published, won the opportunity to have her life story published in book form by winning an essay contest sponsored by the television program Good Morning America. Ahmedi’s account of growing up in Kabul in the 1990s offers a nonfiction version of life in 1970s Kabul sketched in The Kite Runner. Before coming to the United States, Ahmedi lost her leg to a land mine and lost family members to a Taliban rocket strike on her home.
culture and the turbulent contemporary history of the Philippines.
Jessica Hagedorn’s novel Dogeaters (1990), though very different from The Kite Runner, tells the story of a young person’s experiences immigrating from the Philippines to the United States. In Dogeaters the characters struggle to adjust to U.S. culture while maintaining, at times, uneasy ties to Filipino
Richard Rodriguez’s Hunger of Memory: The Education of Richard Rodriguez: An Autobiography (1982) recounts the author’s experiences as a child in a Mexican immigrant family. Rodriguez’s account of his attempts to bridge the gaps between his adapted culture and language, and his family’s values and language, resonate with the experiences of Amir in The Kite Runner. Henri J. Barkey’s ‘‘The United States and Afghanistan: From Marginality to Global Concern’’ gives an account of the post– September 11 relations between the United States and Afghanistan and how the United States’ foreign policy affected twenty-firstcentury political developments there. Barkey’s article can be found in The Middle East and the United States: A Historical and Political Reassessment (2003), edited by David W. Lesch.
predict the progress of these wind-borne tissue creations. It is a gift which proves of little use when Amir, confused, embittered and convinced of his servant’s elevated status in Baba’s affections, sets about severing ties of a different kind.
Amir’s grand betrayal of Hassan and his painful search for redemption across generations is told in a cool, detached voice that provides a counterpoint to the growing sense of tension which is frequently stretched to breaking point as the story unfolds.
The exposure of Amir’s myriad failings is brought starkly home in a scene of breathtaking brutality when he is too cowardly to stop the punishment inflicted on Hassan. This constitutes one of the book’s few flaws. When Hosseini strays from the simple narrative style he prefers, he struggles to retain credibility and, on occasion, leaves Amir sounding like Kabul’s halfbaked answer to Holden Caulfield: ‘‘That was the thing with Hassan. He was so goddamn pure, you always felt like a phony around him’’. These lapses are rare, and for the most part the story of
From exile in America to a clandestine return to Kabul in the grip of the Taleban, the narrative ranges freely across the globe engaging the reader’s emotions. Amir is a difficult hero, largely unlovable but utterly sympathetic, while the plight of blameless Hassan reflects the fate of his country. There are history lessons here; among the deepest of Afghanistan’s wounds is the fact that its past has been largely obscured by its bloody present. There are also questions. Is any bond truly unbreakable? Can sons atone for the sins of fathers?
1 0 2
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
Source: James O’Brien, ‘‘The Sins of the Father,’’ in Times Literary Supplement, October 10, 2003, p. 25.
Ronny Noor In the following essay, Noor reviews The Kite Runner as a novel about sin and redemption, but contends that it fails to give a complete picture of the Afghan conflict. The Kite Runner is Khaled Hosseini’s bestselling first novel. It is the very first novel in English by an Afghan, in which a thirty-eightyear-old writer named Amir recounts the odyssey of his life from Kabul to San Francisco via Peshwar, Pakistan. The protagonist was born into a wealthy family in Kabul. Raised by his father, his mother having passed away during his birth, Amir lives a relatively happy life until the Soviet tanks roll into Afghanistan. Then he and his family flee to Pakistan and end up in America. In the United States, his father becomes a gasstation manager, selling junk on weekends with his son at the San Jose flea market. Amir meets Soraya, the daughter of a former Afghan general, and soon ties the knot with her. For fifteen years the young couple tries in vain to have children. Then Amir receives a call from Rahim Khan, a friend and former business partner of his now-deceased father. Amir flies to Peshwar to meet with him. Rahim Khan reveals that Hassan, Amir’s childhood friend, the presumed son of the family servant Ali, was in reality Amir’s half-brother, his father’s illegitimate son with Ali’s wife. Hassan and his wife were killed by the Taliban. Rahim Khan wants Amir to go to Kabul and bring Hassan’s son to Peshwar. After much hesitation, Amir goes to Kabul and frees his nephew from the clutches of an unscrupulous child molester. Later he brings the child to America for adoption. This lucidly written and often touching novel gives a vivid picture of not only the Russian atrocities but also those of the Northern Alliance and the Taliban. It is rightly a ‘‘soaring debut,’’ as the Boston Globe claims, but only if we consider it a novel of sin and redemption, a son trying to redeem his father’s sin. As far as the Afghan conflict is concerned, we get a selective, simplistic, even simple-minded picture. Hosseini tells us, for example, that ‘‘Arabs, Chechens, Pakistanis’’ were behind the Taliban. He does not mention the CIA or Zbigniew Brzezinski, the national security advisor to President Carter, ‘‘whose stated aim,’’ according to Pankaj Mishra
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
K i t e
R u n n e r
in the spring 2002 issue of Granta, ‘‘was to ‘sow [s—t] in the Soviet backyard.’’’ Hosseini also intimates that the current leader handpicked by foreign powers, Hamid Karzai—whose ‘‘caracul hat and green chapan became famous’’—will put Afghanistan back in order. Unfortunately, that is all Karzai is famous for—his fashion, Hollywood style. His government does not control all of Afghanistan, which is torn between warlords as in the feudal days. Farmers are producing more opium than ever before for survival. And the occupying forces, according to human-rights groups, are routinely trampling on innocent Afghans. There is no Hollywood-style solution to such grave problems of a nation steeped in the Middle Ages, is there? Source: Ronny Noor, ‘‘Afghanistan: The Kite Runner,’’ in World Literature Today, Vol. 78, No. 3–4, September– December 2004, p. 148.
Khaled Hosseini In the following excerpt, Hosseini discusses how being a physician gives him a compassionate insight to humanity and makes him a better writer.
Khaled Hosseini. (Physician writers) A blinking little red light. Another voice mail. Didn’t I just go through them? I sat down. I never delay listening to voice mails; call it a compulsion, a personal quirk. I put down Mrs CR’s chart and dialed my answering machine. It was my father-in-law, telling me he had loved my short story, The Kite Runner, but wished it had been longer. At some point between the instant I put down the receiver and the moment I knocked on the door to tell Mrs CR about her diabetic nephropathy, a seed planted itself in my mind: I was going to turn The Kite Runner into a novel. And so it began. For the next 15 months, I tapped away at the keyboard. I created a troubled, 12-year-old boy named Amir, the privileged son of a wealthy Pashtun merchant living in Kabul, Afghanistan, circa 1975, and his angelic friend Hassan, a minority Hazara and the son of Amir’s crippled servant. I developed a deep and unusual friendship between the boys, only to make Amir betray Hassan in an unspeakable way. I shattered the boy’s lives. I watched the brutalised Hassan pay the price for his guileless devotion to Amir, and watched Amir grow into a brooding, haunted, guilt-ridden man in the USA. Then I sent Amir back to Kabul, now
V o l u m e
1
1 0 3
T h e
K i t e
R u n n e r
ruled by the Taliban, on one last desperate quest for redemption. In June, 2002, The Kite Runner was completed. A year later, while on a US book tour to promote the novel, two of the most common questions people asked me were: how do you find time to write as a doctor; and did being a doctor help you writing?
daily practice. Writing, by contrast, is creative. For me, starting the day with an act of creation is therapeutic. It brings me closer to my emotional state and, as a result, I go to see my patients with a positive frame of mind. To be sure, that’s good for me, but far more importantly, it’s good for my patients.
My day at work ranges from busy to frantic. Between prescription refills, referrals, meetings, laboratory reviews, voice mails, and seeing patients, I have developed an appreciation for the concept of free time. And when I go home, I have my wife and two children, not to mention an extended Afghan family life. That leaves the early morning. My free time. And if there is one thing we doctors have been trained for, it’s getting by with less than ideal hours of sleep. So for 15 months, I woke up at 0500 h, drank cupfuls of black coffee, and created the world of Amir and Hassan. Luckily for me, the soulful early morning hours coincided with my creative time.
Source: Khaled Hosseini, ‘‘Khaled Hosseini: Physician writers,’’ in Lancet, Vol. 362, No. 9388, September 20, 2003, p. 1003.
As for the second question, the answer, surprisingly, is yes. A writer, like a doctor, has to be a good listener and observer. Whereas a doctor listens to learn about his or her patient, a writer listens and observes to learn about nuances of dialogue, body language, and the peculiar verbal and non-verbal ways in which people express themselves. My medical practice provides me with ample opportunity for this sort of observation, since in a typical working day, I sit and listen to some 20 stories, all told in unique voices. I listen to them as a doctor and observe them as a writer. Furthermore, it’s essential in both crafts to develop some insight into human nature. Writers and physicians need to understand to some extent the motivations behind behaviour and appreciate how such things as a person’s upbringing, their culture, their biases, shape that person, whether it be a patient or a character in a story. Writers say the more you understand your characters, the better you can write them. Similarly, the more doctors understand their patients, the better they can help them. While on tour, one person raised what seemed a far more important question: did writing help you become a better doctor? It did. I firmly believe that. The medical profession offers satisfying rewards, but for some the challenges of today’s medicine can prove exhausting, or worse—we have all crossed paths with jaded colleagues who have long lost sight of the rewards of healing in the rigorous frenzy of
1 0 4
L i t e r a r y
SOURCES Hosseini, Khaled, The Kite Runner, Riverhead Books, 2003. Hower, Edward, ‘‘The Servant,’’ in the New York Times Book Review, August 3, 2003, p. 4. Katsoulis, Melissa, ‘‘Kites of Passage’’ in the Times (London), August 30, 2003, Features section, p. 17. Noor, Ronny, Review of The Kite Runner, in World Literature Today, Vol. 78, Nos. 3–4, September– December 2004, p. 148. O’Brien, James, ‘‘The Sins of the Father,’’ in the Times Literary Supplement, October 10, 2003, p. 25. Review of The Kite Runner, in Publishers Weekly, Vol. 250, No. 19, May 12, 2003, p. 43. Stuhr, Rebecca, Review of The Kite Runner, in Library Journal, April 15, 2003, p. 122. Hosseini, Khaled, Dreaming in Titanic City, Riverhead Books. This follow-up to Hosseini’s extremely successful first novel is set to be published in 2006.
FURTHER READING Lipson, J. G., and P. A. Omidian, ‘‘Afghan Refugee Issues in the U.S. Social Environment’’ in Western Journal of Nursing Research, Vol. 19, No. 1, February 1997, pp. 110–26. The article focuses on the physical and mental health challenges faced by Afghan refugees since they began to arrive in the San Francisco Bay Area in the 1980s. Based on an ethnographic study and using quotations from interviews with these newcomers, the article examines stresses caused by the new social contexts within which Afghan refugees find themselves and how they perceive their interactions with American citizens and institutions. Ondaatje, Michael, Anil’s Ghost, Vintage Books, 2000. In Ondaadtje’s fifth novel, the protagonist Anil Tessera is a Sri Lankan forensic anthropologist
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
K i t e
R u n n e r
becoming acculturated to the United States. Essays include discussions of such authors as Anzia Yezierska to Jamaica Kincaid.
educated in England and the United States, who returns to work in Sri Lanka. In the course of uncovering gruesome evidence of violence wrought by the civil war there, she re-connects with centuries of Sri Lankan tradition and is confronted with the senseless destruction brought about by interethnic conflict in the country of her birth. Payant, Katherine B., and Toby Rose, eds., The Immigrant Experience in North American Literature: Carving Out a Niche, 2003. This book contains a collection of essays by various scholars who discuss the ways that North American literature has represented the experiences of immigrant groups entering and
Rashid, Ahmed, Taliban: Militant Islam, Oil and Fundamentalism in Central Asia, Yale University Press, 2000. Ahmed, a journalist in Afghanistan for over twenty years, sketches the Taliban’s rise to power between 1994 to 1999, as well as other countries’ attempts to gain control over the development of Afghanistan. His account discusses the Taliban’s ideological foundations, its well-known repression of women, and its ties to the heroin trade.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 0 5
The Last Juror In The Last Juror, published in 2004, John Grisham explores race relations and racism in the American South of the 1970s. Although the title may lead readers to expect a taut courtroom thriller like Grisham’s earlier works, this characterdriven novel follows the growing relationship between twenty three-year-old Willie Traynor, new owner of the Ford County Times, and Calia Ruffin, also known as ‘‘Miss Callie,’’ a fifty nineyear old black woman. She is the mother of eight children, seven of whom have earned Ph.D.s—a remarkable accomplishment for the period. The ‘‘juror’’ of the title does refer to an important legal case that acts as the centerpiece for the book—Danny Padgitt’s explosive trial for the rape and brutal murder of a young local widow. Convicted of the murder but sentenced to life imprisonment instead of death, Padgitt spends ten years in jail. When he gets out, jurors from his case start to die under mysterious circumstances. Over the course of the story, Grisham introduces many of Clanton, Mississippi’s residents and local characters, people like politicians, war veterans, and decaying aristocracy who make the town colorful and unique.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY John Grisham was born on February 18, 1955, in Jonesboro, Arkansas, but for the first
1 0 6
JOHN GRISHAM 2004
T h e
L a s t
J u r o r
for three years, getting up early every morning to write before going to work. Though its original print run was five thousand copies, Grisham was satisfied. By then he was working on his second book, a legal thriller titled The Firm. A ‘‘bootleg’’ copy circulated around Hollywood, and the film rights were bought before the book was even published. The Firm became a bestselling novel of 1991. Eventually, Grisham closed his law practice and quit the state legislature so he could become a full-time writer. The Last Juror was published in 2004, making it Grisham’s seventeenth novel in seventeen years. Some of his bestselling legal thrillers include The Client, The Pelican Brief, The Chamber, The Rainmaker, and The Runaway Jury, all of which were made into films. He has also written the autobiographical A Painted House, and the Christmas tale Skipping Christmas, the basis for the film Christmas with the Kranks.
John Grisham AP/Wide World Photos PLOT SUMMARY twelve years of his life, his family moved frequently so his father, a construction worker, could find work. In 1967, his family settled in Southaven, Mississippi where he became involved in sports.
Part 1: Chapters 1–5
Grisham’s first book, A Time to Kill, was published in 1988. He worked on it as a hobby
The Last Juror opens with the news that through ‘‘patient mismanagement and loving neglect,’’ the small independent newspaper The Ford County Times is going bankrupt. It is 1970, and Joyner William ‘‘Willie’’ Traynor, a twentythree-year-old college dropout who works as a reporter for the paper, finds himself facing unemployment. Instead, thanks to luck and a wealthy grandmother, Willie buys the paper, intent on making his living. Just months after Willie takes over as editor, Rhoda Kassellaw, a young widow with two small children, is brutally raped and murdered. After seeing the intruder, the children run to their neighbor, Aaron Deece, who finds the dying Rhoda. With her dying breath, she names her killer—Danny Padgitt. In the meantime, Padgitt, who is half-drunk at the time of the murder, flees in his truck. He tries to make it home to Padgitt Island, the family’s private kingdom in Ford County, where wanted criminals can hide and never be found. Driving recklessly, he has a bad accident on the way and is immediately arrested by the police. The incident fuels much gossip. Willie and his photographer Wiley get as much information as possible, which Willie prints, to his advantage. At Danny’s bail hearing, his lawyer Lucien
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
After his high school graduation, Grisham enrolled at Northwest Junior College in Senatobia, Mississippi, and for a year played baseball for the school team. Restless, he transferred to Delta State University in Cleveland, Mississippi, hoping to become a professional ball player. After the coach at Delta State tactfully pointed out that Grisham was not suited for a baseball career, he transferred to Mississippi State University and studied accounting with the intention of becoming a tax attorney. Shortly after earning his law degree from the University of Mississippi, Grisham and his wife Rene´e returned to Southaven. There, Grisham set up a small practice as a defense attorney. In addition, from 1984 to 1990, he served in the Mississippi House of Representatives. The Grishams have two children: a son, Ty, and a daughter, Shea.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 0 7
T h e
L a s t
J u r o r
Wilbanks immediately threatens Willy with a libel suit and later calls the judge’s attention to the paper, trying for a gag order on all proceedings. The judge praises the story in front of the packed courtroom and denies Danny bail.
Chapters 6–10 Willie, who is still rather naive about the newspaper business, learns from his senior reporter Baggy Suggs that he will not be sued for libel, since he did not break the law. He also learns Danny is being held in the only decent cell in the decrepit county jail, known as ‘‘the suite.’’ Oddly, he is being given special treatment by the corrupt county sheriff, Mackey Don Coley. After Willie does some investigating, he writes another sensational story about Danny’s unusual privileges. Because the Padgitts and Lucien are unpopular, the people of the county love the story. However, soon after the article runs, a bomb is found in the Times offices. Suspicion falls on the Padgitts, who are known to be experienced arsonists, but the sheriff stalls the investigation. When Wiley is viciously beaten in his own driveway, local lawyer Harry Rex Vonner gives Willie a gun and teaches him to shoot. For a while, Willie carries the gun, but he soon tires of it and leaves the weapon in his car. Lucien holds a hearing for a change of venue for the trial, citing the local newspaper’s biased coverage, and Willie is called to testify. Lucien makes him look ignorant on the stand, and Willie leaves, enraged. Around this time, Willie also meets Miss Calia Ruffin, or Miss Callie as he calls her. She invites him for the first of what will be many lunches.
Chapters 11–15 Lucien withdraws his motion for a change of venue. The District Attorney Ernie Gaddis petitions for a larger and secret jury pool, and the judge grants it. Both the District Attorney and Judge Loomis fear jury tampering by the Padgitts, either through bribes or threats. In the meantime, Willie visits more with Miss Callie, who questions whether he is a Christian and worries about his soul. He learns more about her children, and publishes a two-part front-page series about the Ruffins. Lucien sends him a note praising the story. When the jury summonses go out, Miss Callie learns she is called. She dislikes judging another person, but knows it is her duty. She is the last juror picked, and is proud to be a black juror on such an
1 0 8
L i t e r a r y
important case. The trial begins, and one of the witnesses for the prosecution is Ginger McClure, Rhoda’s sister. After the opening day’s proceedings, the judge sequesters the jury so they will not be influenced by the newspaper, or easily threatened or bribed by the Padgitts. Later that night, Ginger asks Willie for a drink and they end up spending the evening together. She sleeps at his apartment, but nothing sexual happens between them.
Chapters 16–20 The trial continues, with the State calling all of its witnesses. Its last witness is Mr. Aaron Deece, the man who heard Rhoda’s last words. Lucien begins the defense by painting Danny as an innocent boy who has been framed. He calls as a witness Lydia Vince, a married woman who swears on the stand that at the time of the murder, she and Danny were having sex. On crossexamination, Gaddis reveals information that makes it appear the woman is being paid off by someone, possibly the Padgitts. When the session ends for the day, Willie and Ginger are depressed by the outcome. After getting drunk, they have sex. By the next day, Gaddis has found Malcolm Vince, Lydia’s estranged husband. He testifies that Lydia must be lying, since their marriage broke up over her lesbian tendencies. Lucien, knowing Lydia is a bought witness, tries to fix the damage but gives up. Danny Padgitt insists on testifying on his own behalf, against Lucien’s advice. As Lucien has predicted, Danny is terrible on the stand, insisting that all the physical evidence against him is part of a conspiracy. When he realizes no one believes him, he loses his temper and threatens the jury that he will ‘‘get’’ every one of them. After closing arguments, the jury deliberates for a short time before arriving at a guilty verdict. They must now vote on the penalty—death or life in prison. No one is allowed to tell the jury that, at that time in Mississippi, ‘‘life’’ could mean less than twenty years. While waiting for the jury to decide, Willie and Ginger spend their last night together. He would like to pursue a deeper relationship, but she wants no memories of Clanton. The next day, because the jury cannot reach a decision, the judge is forced to give a life sentence. Miss Callie faints while leaving the courtroom and is rushed to the hospital, where doctors find her blood pressure is too high. She refuses to discuss the verdict. The county is shocked and dismayed by Danny’s sentence.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
Many people blame Miss Callie and say that because she is black, she is the one who would not allow the death penalty. Then Willie reveals to the reader that within twenty-four hours, Clanton has forgotten the trial, as there is something more important to focus on.
Part 2: Chapters 21–25 The people of Clanton discover they will have to desegregate their schools in just six weeks, before they open for the new school year. Many of the white citizens panic, while most of the black citizens appear victorious. Willie is pleased because the announcement is good for his paper’s circulation. The high school football season also helps with both readership and the integration problem as a young black boy leads the football team to glory. Mr. Mitlo, the local men’s clothing store owner, decides to change Willie’s dress style, turning him from a student into a sharply dressed professional. Malcolm Vince is murdered by an unknown sniper but the murderer is never caught. Willie learns that 16-year-old Sam Ruffin, Miss Callie’s youngest child, has had an affair with a white woman named Iris Durant, and must leave town for fear of losing his life. Willie meets Sam and agrees to act as a go-between for Sam and his parents. Willie also offers to send a message to Trooper Durant, Iris’s ex-husband, asking if he will allow Sam to see his parents in Clanton as long as he does not leave the black section of town. Durant does not agree, and repeats his threat to kill Sam if he comes home to Clanton. The rest of the Ruffin children and their families come home to Clanton for Christmas. Willie meets them all and is treated as a part of the family. He realizes how emotionally poor his own family and upbringing was. His mother died when he was thirteen, his father is slightly crazy, and he has no siblings. He spends Christmas Eve with his father, eating at a local Chinese restaurant, and Christmas Day with his grandmother BeeBee and some of her friends. He desperately misses the Ruffins.
L a s t
J u r o r
grandmother but she tells him to keep his money. He decides to buy a new printing press and he updates the paper. That July campaigning starts for local elections, and in August the town elects a new sheriff. In November, the first white soldier from Ford County dies in Vietnam, and Willie stirs up a controversy with staunchly anti-war editorials. His landlord, Max Hocutt, dies, and Willie buys the man’s decrepit mansion and old car from the remaining Hocutt sisters, who plan to enter a retirement home. Sam Ruffin receives his draft notice; his family convinces him to dodge the draft and flee to Canada. Willie hires a contractor to renovate the house, which turns out to be uninhabitable. The State Supreme Court affirms the conviction of Danny Padgitt.
Part 3: Chapters 32–35
On a day in late January, a sniper starts shooting up downtown Clanton. The gunman is Hank Hooten, who was an attorney on Rhoda’s case as well as her lover. Hank is diagnosed as schizophrenic and sent to a mental hospital. One year after Willie buys the paper, he has enough money to pay back his
This section starts five years after the end of part two. It is now 1977, and Willie’s mansion is finally ready to be lived in. He has an open-house party to celebrate, with over 300 guests. He also learns that Danny Padgitt is no longer at the maximum-security prison. He has been moved to a nicer prison camp and regularly leaves the camp to go into town for lunch at the diner. No one suspects he is a prisoner. Willie breaks the story of Danny’s transfer in the paper, and it is picked up by the large Mississippi and Tennessee daily papers. Within two weeks, Danny is back in the penitentiary. Willie receives threatening phone calls and notifies the FBI. He leaks his FBI communication to the daily papers so the investigation is made public. Seven years after the trial, he starts to wear a gun again, afraid of retaliation from the Padgitts. As part of his editorship, Willie has a policy of visiting services at every church in the county, and during one of these visits he sees Hank Hooten. Surprised, he tries to investigate Hooten’s movements and his release from the mental hospital, but he is unsuccessful. In September 1978, Willie hears about a secret parole hearing for Danny Padgitt from a fellow newspaperman, and he attends. Contrary to state law, no one in Ford County has been notified, and the press is barred, but Willie gets around this obstacle by serving as a witness for the ‘‘other side’’ that is trying to keep Danny in prison. Though he is the only one there speaking against Danny’s release, parole is denied by the slimmest margin. The news of Danny’s near release makes Miss Callie ill, because she fears him. Still the go-between for the family, Willie
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
Chapters 26–31
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 0 9
T h e
L a s t
J u r o r
gives her letters from Sam. Sam has prospered in Canada, earning a degree in economics and saving money for law school. By this time, President Jimmy Carter has pardoned those who evaded the draft, and Sam considers returning to the United States. Willie gets an offer to buy the newspaper, but he is not interested in selling.
Chapters 36–40 Willie learns Danny Padgitt is to have another parole hearing. He tells Sheriff McNatt, who attends the hearing and tries to keep Danny in prison, but Danny is released. Clanton is ‘‘quietly disappointed.’’ Evidence suggests that the Padgitts bribed the local state senator to help secure his parole, but Willie cannot prove it. Sam returns from Canada and makes a brief, secret visit to his family. He plans to go to law school. Miss Callie worries about Danny being out of jail. The people interested in buying Willie’s paper make another offer. Lenny Fargarson, one of the jurors in Danny’s trial, is murdered by an unknown killer, a sniper who shoots from a distance. Everyone remembers Danny’s threat. The sheriff asks Willie for a list of jurors, and they discover that one has died of natural causes, but the remaining ten are still alive. All are warned, and Willie warns Miss Callie himself. She is distraught by the news and it affects her blood pressure, which has worsened in the years since the trial. The sheriff then asks Willie to speak to Lucien, Danny’s attorney, about acting as a go-between for the sheriff and the Padgitts. Willie brings his lawyer friend Harry Rex for support, but Lucien is not interested in helping. Willie spends more time with Miss Callie to protect her. Eleven days after Lenny is killed, a second juror, Mo Teale, is shot by a sniper. The sheriff decides his priority is to protect the remaining jurors. They learn that one moved to Florida after the trial, so eight people remain. The sheriff uses his men, but townspeople also help protect their neighbors. Many of the jurors are hidden by their friends, who patrol the yards of the juror’s homes with rifles in hand. Willie thinks Miss Callie’s home has become an armed fortress. Willie tells his friend Harry Rex that he is thinking of selling the paper, and asks his advice. Harry asks if Willie would move, and Willie says no, because Clanton is home. A few days later, Miss Callie breaks her promise to keep the details of the jury’s deliberations a secret. She shows Willie the list of who voted for and against
1 1 0
L i t e r a r y
the death penalty. Three jurors opposed: Fargarson, Teale, and Maxine Root. Willie, Sam, and Miss Callie contemplate the odds of coincidence, and wonder whether to warn Maxine Root. Before they can decide what to do, another juror, Earl Youry, offers the same information. The sheriff warns Maxine. Lucien asks Harry Rex to tell the sheriff that Danny Padgitt denies all involvement in the murders, and has witnesses to give him alibis for both murders. The sheriff does not believe it, and works on getting the warrants needed to arrest Danny.
Chapters 41–44 Willie says he is tired of the paper and tired of Clanton, and he suspects that Clanton is tired of him. He enters into serious negotiations about selling. As a treat, Esau, Willie, and Sam bring Miss Callie to Memphis, Tennessee to visit the grave of Mrs. DeJarnette. In honor of her Italian second mother, Willie treats her to a large Italian dinner. None of them wants to leave Memphis, because it is good to get away from the tensions in Clanton. On June 25, 1979, Willie signs the papers selling the Times for one and a half million dollars. He tries to keep it quiet, but ends up telling his employees. He wants to leave town, but feels that he cannot go until the killings stop. As July 4, 1979 approaches, Willie admits his enthusiasm for the annual picnic and fireworks is low. However, the Ruffin family decides to have a family reunion, and Willie offers his five bedrooms to any Ruffin family member who wants to stay. There are now twenty-one grandchildren and a total of thirty-five Ruffins, not counting Miss Callie, Esau, and Sam. Of that number, twenty-three stay at Willie’s Hocutt House. Willie observes that in nine years, he and Miss Callie have missed only seven Thursday lunches. He wants them to continue after he stops editing the paper, though he cannot find a good time to tell Miss Callie of the sale. Maxine Root receives a suspicious package. Travis, a part-time deputy, puts the package on the back porch and shoots it to see if it is a bomb. The resulting explosion badly injures Travis, Maxine, and two spectators. The sheriff immediately seeks a warrant for Danny Padgitt’s arrest. Danny, with Lucien, surrenders peacefully. The people of Clanton are relieved. The next day, much of Clanton turns out for the bail hearing, including Willie and Miss Callie and her family; the Padgitt family is noticeably absent.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
L a s t
J u r o r
Wilson Caudle See Spot Caudle
Mackey Don Coley
MEDIA ADAPTATIONS
The Last Juror was released in an unabridged audio version on CD by Random House Audio in 2004. It is narrated by Michael Beck.
Mackey Don is Ford County’s sheriff at the start of the novel. He has been the sheriff since 1943, and although he is being paid off by the Padgitt family, most people in the county do not mind as long as things are kept safe. His preferential treatment of Danny and his obvious hostility to Willie and the newspaper help turn the people of the county against him, and he loses the election the following year.
Bubba Crockett When Danny is put on the stand, he is shot and killed by someone in the courthouse. After an hour, they find the sniper—Hank Hooten. The shocking events cause Miss Callie to suffer a stroke, and she is taken to the hospital. Willie, by now considered a member of the Ruffin family, shares Miss Callie’s last moments with them. Afterward, he goes to his office and writes his last piece for The Ford County Times: Miss Callie’s obituary.
CHARACTERS The sports reporter/editor on the Times.
BeeBee Willie’s maternal grandmother is a wealthy woman who pays for his college education until his fifth year in a four-year program. BeeBee cuts off funding and tells him to get a job. She does lend him the money to buy the newspaper, however, and refuses the money when he tries to pay her back.
Spot Caudle Spot is in his seventies. He is the editor of the Times when Willie starts working there and the son of the paper’s owner. He has a plate in his head from a World War I wound and concentrates all his efforts on the paper’s obituaries. He has a breakdown after being served with involuntary bankruptcy papers for the Times and dies six months later.
N e w s m a k e r s
Aaron Deece Aaron Deece is Rhoda Kassellaw’s neighbor, who hears her dying words about who murdered her. He and his wife take care of the traumatized children that night. Later, he testifies against Danny Padgitt at his trial.
Nicola Rossetti DeJarnette
Davey Bigmouth Bass
L i t e r a r y
One of Clanton’s Vietnam vets, Bubba introduces himself to Willie when Willie starts writing antiwar editorials. He agrees with Willie’s point of view and introduces him to some other local vets who get together once a week to play poker. Willie joins their games once in a while for a diversion.
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
The reader learns about this character in Miss Callie’s stories, as she dies four years before the action of the novel begins. However, she does play an important role in the book. Miss Callie calls Mrs. DeJarnette her ‘‘second mother.’’ Nicola is the daughter of Italian immigrants, and she has married well. Miss Callie’s parents are servants in the DeJarnette house when Nicola arrives as a young bride. Nicola has no children of her own, and when Callie is born, Nicola names the baby and takes her almost as a foster child. She teaches Callie Italian, exposes her to culture, and works on her diction. She also promises to pay for Callie’s college education. Unfortunately, the DeJarnettes lose their money, and Mr. DeJarnette commits suicide before this can happen.
Iris Durant Iris is an attractive woman, married to a member of the state highway patrol and the mother of two teen boys. At forty-one years old, she has an affair with sixteen-year-old Sam
V o l u m e
1
1 1 1
T h e
L a s t
J u r o r
Ruffin. When the affair is discovered, Iris’s husband beats her and throws her out, vowing to kill Sam. Iris leaves Ford County permanently.
Trooper Durant Trooper Durant is a member of the Mississippi Highway patrol, an ex-Marine and sharpshooter, and Iris Durant’s husband. After discovering his wife’s infidelity, he vows to see Sam Ruffin dead and even puts a bounty on Sam’s head, though he would prefer to do the killing himself. Years later, he refuses to allow Sam to come back to town.
during Danny Padgitt’s trial. At the time of the trial he’s in his forties and twice divorced. According to some of the town’s gossip, he was the secret lover of Rhoda Kassellaw. After Danny’s life sentence, Hank has a breakdown and goes on a shooting spree in the middle of downtown Clanton. He is hospitalized as a schizophrenic but is later released. He is responsible for the murders of the jurors as well as that of Danny Padgitt, and ultimately takes his own life.
Rhoda Kassellaw
Thought of by many in Clanton as ‘‘the cripple boy,’’ Lenny is a member of the jury and the first juror to be killed. At the time of the trial, he uses crutches; by the time of his murder he is confined to a wheelchair. His strong faith in God impresses Willie.
A young widow with two small children, Rhoda is an attractive flaxen-haired woman who lives about twelve miles from Clanton. She’s considered a model widow because she keeps to herself; but in 1970, three years after her husband is killed in a truck accident, she frequents clubs far from home. She is brutally raped and murdered by Danny Padgitt, whom she had rejected at one of the clubs.
Ernie Gaddis
Reed Loopus
Ernie Gaddis is Ford County’s District Attorney at the time of the Rhoda Kassellaw murder and the attorney in charge of the prosecution during Danny Padgitt’s trial. He leaves office in 1975.
The Circuit Court Judge for Clanton, Judge Loopus is known for being pro-prosecution and honest. He is very concerned about the Padgitt reputation for buying law enforcement, so he works hard to ensure a fair trial. By law, he is required to sentence Danny to life imprisonment, but at the sentencing he tells Danny he wishes he could sentence him to a long and painful death.
Lenny Fargarson
Hardy The pressman for the Times, Hardy originally works for Spot Caudle, then for Willie after he takes over as owner. Willie makes sure Hardy’s job will be secure under the new owners.
Gilma Hocutt The seventy seven-year-old Gilma Wilma’s twin and one of Willie’s landlords.
is
Max Hocutt Max is owner of the Victorian mansion Hocutt House and the eldest of three siblings. He is eighty-one years old when Willie meets him in 1970. When he dies in 1972, his sisters want to move to a senior home, so they sell the house and Max’s Mercedes Benz to Willie.
Wilma Hocutt
One of the town’s colorful characters, the one-legged Major is a lawyer and drinking buddy of Baggy Suggs. Most of the time, he is drunk or on his way to being drunk, but he still manages to pass valuable legal information to Willie.
Ginger McClure A sexy redhead, Ginger is Rhoda’s sister. She travels from Missouri to be the family’s representative at the trial. While in Clanton she has a brief affair with Willie.
Wiley Meek
The seventy seven-year-old Wilma Gilma’s twin and one of Willie’s landlords.
is
Hank Hooten A part-time prosecutor for Ford County, Hank Hooten assists the District Attorney
1 1 2
The Major
L i t e r a r y
Wiley is the photographer for the Times. He advises the naive Willie on the complexities of small-town politics. He is badly beaten by the Padgitts in their effort to get the paper to stop publishing damaging articles about Danny’s trial.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
Mr. Mitlo
L a s t
J u r o r
Calia Ruffin
A Hungarian immigrant who owns Clanton’s men’s shop, Mr. Mitlo is responsible for changing Willie’s style of dress, transforming him from raggedy student to dapper professional.
Senator Theo Morton Morton is Clanton’s secretly corrupt state senator. He is married to a woman from Clanton, which makes him popular in the town. He accepts a bribe for pushing up Danny’s parole hearings, but no one can prove it.
Danny Padgitt The son of Ford County’s biggest criminal family, Danny Padgitt rapes and murders Rhoda Kassellaw in a drunken rage. His anger has slowly built up after she has twice turned down his advances at a dance club. He kills her dog, breaks into her house, and hides in her closet with the intention of raping her. He does not plan to kill her but after he wakes her children he feels he must silence her. He expects that the Padgitts, with their money and corrupt influence over the legal system, will be able to keep him out of jail. At his trial he threatens the jurors, telling them, ‘‘You convict me, and I’ll get every damned one of you.’’ He is sentenced to life in prison but serves only ten years before he is released. When he returns to the family compound, jurors from his trial begin to be murdered. He is arrested on suspicion of murder but is shot and killed during his bail hearing by the real murderer, Hank Hooten.
See Miss Callie Ruffin
Miss Callie Ruffin The ‘‘last juror’’ of the title, Miss Callie is a black woman born in 1911. She is the wife of Esau and the mother of the eight Ruffin children. At the time Willie meets her, she’s ‘‘a stout woman, thick in the shoulders and trunk.’’ Her hair is grey and she looks old, but her smile ‘‘lit up the world with two rows of brilliant, perfect teeth,’’ says Willie. A staunch Christian, she befriends young Willie Traynor, who comes to love her like a second mother. She feeds him incredible Southern cooking during their Thursday lunches, and in her quiet way she teaches him valuable life lessons through the stories she shares. Through her stories, we learn about her interesting girlhood. The granddaughter of slaves and a house servant herself at a young age, she is tutored by her employer, Mrs. DeJarnette, from infancy and learns Italian as her first language. Through Mrs. DeJarnette, she is exposed to knowledge and culture that is not available to most girls in her position. Because of her father’s death Miss Callie leaves school when she is fifteen, but she promises herself that her children will not only finish high school but go to college as well. This is a big dream for a black girl in 1926. Three years later she marries Esau, and in 1931 they have their first child. She raises her children with the expectation that they will excel in life, and they all do. Thanks to her guidance and steely determination, seven of her children earn Ph.D.s, and the eighth is preparing for law school by the end of the novel.
Piston ‘‘One of the village idiots,’’ according to Willie, Piston is a part-time janitor and deliveryman for the Times. His moment of glory in town is finding the bomb in the paper’s offices.
Carlota Ruffin Miss Callie’s and Esau’s sixth child, Carlota holds a Ph.D. in urban studies and teaches at UCLA.
Maxine Root Maxine is one of the jurors in the Padgitt trial who would not vote for the death penalty. She is injured when a bomb is sent to her home, but she survives the murder attempt.
Esau Ruffin
Known as Al to the family, he is Miss Callie’s and Esau’s eldest child. Born in 1931, he has a Ph.D. in sociology and is a professor at the University of Iowa.
Esau is Miss Callie’s husband. A quiet man who does not appear often in the novel, he nonetheless gives Miss Callie much emotional support. He is a carpenter and a part-time preacher, and at times he has also worked as a janitor to support the family. He bought his home in 1940, which was a great accomplishment for a black man at the time. According to Willie this is still unusual even in 1970.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
Alberto Ruffin
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 1 3
T h e
L a s t
J u r o r
Gloria Ruffin Miss Callie’s and Esau’s fifth child, Gloria holds a Ph.D. in Italian and teaches at Duke University.
and history, and he advises Willie on the newspaper business and provides Clanton insider information.
Mo Teale Leonardo Ruffin Called Leo by the family, he is Miss Callie’s and Esau’s second child. Leo holds a Ph.D. in biology and teaches at Purdue University.
Called ‘‘Mr. John Deere’’ by Willie and his courthouse friends because of his tractor repair uniform, Mo is a juror in the Padgitt trial. He is the second juror murdered after Padgitt is released.
Mario Ruffin Miss Callie’s and Esau’s seventh child, Mario holds a Ph.D. in medieval literature and teaches at Grinnell College.
Joyner William Traynor See Willie Traynor
Willie Traynor Massimo Ruffin Called Max by the family, he is Miss Callie’s and Esau’s third child. Max holds a Ph.D. in economics and teaches at the University of Toledo.
Roberto Ruffin Called Bobby by the family, he is Miss Callie’s and Esau’s fourth child. Bobby holds a Ph.D. in history and teaches at Marquette University.
Sam Ruffin Sam is Miss Callie and Esau’s eighth and youngest child. He is the only black child between the ages of twelve and sixteen in Clanton’s white schools, and these are difficult days for him. At the age of sixteen he has a brief affair with Iris Durant, and flees town in fear of losing his life. He travels from sibling to sibling, never staying in one place too long. At eighteen he tries to come back to Clanton but is told to stay away. He is then drafted, but on the advice of Willie and his siblings he flees to Canada instead. While there he earns a college degree. When amnesty is declared for those who fled the draft, he returns to the States intent on earning a law degree. He sneaks back to Clanton and spends most of Part Three of the book hiding in his parents’ home. He is the Ruffin child closest to Willie. He is with his mother when she dies.
Baggy Suggs Baggy is the main reporter for the Times before Willie comes along. He is an alcoholic, lazy, and a poor writer. In 1970, Willie observes that Suggs is fifty-two but looks seventy because of his drinking. Baggy is important to Willie, however, because he knows all the town gossip
1 1 4
L i t e r a r y
Willie is the narrator of the book. At its start he is a twenty-three-year-old college dropout working as a reporter for the Ford County Times. His mother died of anorexia when he was thirteen, and his father is a half-crazy stock and bond broker who rarely leaves the house. A native of Memphis, Tennessee, Willie’s considered a northerner by the folks of Clanton. He has also attended Syracuse University in New York State, so they suspect him of being a liberal; or worse, a communist. His appearance does not make things any easier—when he first comes to Clanton he has long hair, wears jeans, and drives a Triumph Spitfire. At college, he drank too much, smoked marijuana and protested the war in Vietnam. By all accounts he is a liberal, and when he buys the newspaper with a loan from his wealthy grandmother he intends to be a reformer. However, he also wants to make money. Over the course of the novel, Willie changes from former student to established businessman and becomes one of Clanton’s ‘‘colorful characters’’ in his own right. He matures, due in part to the influence of Miss Callie in his life, and becomes a Clanton homeowner when he purchases Hocutt House. Though he gradually becomes part of Clanton he never really feels like he belongs there, and after ten years of running the newspaper he realizes he is ready to travel. He sells the paper and makes enough money to buy the financial freedom he longs for. He is a naive young man when he first buys the newspaper, but by the end of the novel he has learned much about life, politics and the dark side of human nature.
Lydia Vince A poor woman from outside Clanton who is bought by the Padgitt family. She testifies that
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
she is Danny’s lover and was with him at the time of the murder, but it is a lie. She flees after her testimony and is never seen again.
Malcolm Vince Malcolm is Lydia’s estranged husband. He destroys Lydia’s testimony and is murdered shortly after the trial ends; the murder is never solved.
Harry Rex Vonner Harry Rex is the ‘‘meanest divorce lawyer in the county,’’ who first approaches Willie by telling him that he should carry a gun. He not only gives Willie his first gun, but also teaches him how to use it. A man with a large, fleshy face and messy hair, Harry Rex follows most of the politics and law in Ford County and is Willie’s main advisor. He also becomes Willie’s closest male friend. He is the only one in town who does not hate Lucien Wilbanks, so he makes a useful go-between for the sheriff.
Lucien Wilbanks Though Lucien is from an important family of lawyers and bankers who built up Clanton, almost everyone in town hates him. He is hired as Danny Padgitt’s lawyer, and Willie describes him as ‘‘abrasive and fearless and downright mean.’’ He has a beard, drinks heavily, and is the only white member of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) in Ford County, which according to Willie is enough to get a man shot. By the end of the novel, he is facing disbarment but he is still as mean as he was in the beginning.
Margaret Wright Margaret is the longtime secretary at the Times; she essentially runs the place when Spot Caudle is the editor. A shy, soft-spoken Christian woman, she is fiercely loyal to Willie through all her time with him at the paper. When he tells her he has sold the paper, she bursts into tears, and Willie realizes that in her own way she has come to love him. Willie makes sure she has a five-year contract with the new owners as part of the sales agreement.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
L a s t
J u r o r
THEMES Southern Life Although Willie Traynor is from Memphis, Tennessee, the people of Mississippi see him as a northerner. Through Willie, Grisham offers a glimpse of Southern life that is both affectionate and critical. On the positive side, Willie praises Southerners for being warm, gracious, and polite. Grisham provides many examples in the book of folks protecting their neighbors, as well as Willie. For example, Harry Rex Vonner brings him a gun and teaches him how to shoot it because he knows just how dangerous the Padgitt family is. Willie also notes that people in Clanton frequently ask about his health and invite him to church. Religion comes across as an important and integral part of Southern life. Willie notices that many Southerners will rush to help other people but are distrustful of outsiders. Willie notes that ‘‘they don’t really trust you unless they trusted your grandfather.’’ Of course, racism is the biggest flaw Willie sees in Mississippi society. Another flaw is the corrupt political system that allows families like the Padgitts to flourish and institutions like segregation to be upheld. As editor, Willie attacks corruption and tries to be a force for positive change in Ford County.
Racism One of the book’s major themes is the racism of the South. At one point, Willie observes that it is not uncommon to see signs reading, ‘‘Still Fighting the War,’’ meaning that for many, the Civil War has not truly ended. There are desegregation battles, and the white parents’ fear of their children attending school with blacks. Grisham also includes Miss Callie and Esau’s story of trying to register to vote, and portrays the ways in which blacks are routinely persecuted in the community. As editor of the paper, Willie tries to change things as much as possible. When he features the Ruffin family on his front page, he is not thinking in terms of a ‘‘colored’’ story, but in terms of a good human interest story. In his personal life, Willie strives for integration as well. He says he wants his housewarming party to be the first integrated party in Clanton.
Social Classes When Willie Traynor moves to Clanton, Mississippi, he learns the difference between ‘‘family money’’ and ‘‘wealth.’’ A number of
V o l u m e
1
1 1 5
T h e
L a s t
J u r o r
Clanton residents are treated with the respect usually given the wealthy, even though they show no signs of being financially well-off. Spot Caudle is eccentric, as are the Hocutts, but because they have family money they are treated with respect and allowed their eccentricities. Willie realizes family money has nothing to do with wealth. In fact, most of the people with family money in Clanton are poor. However, they come from white families and are usually descended from former plantation owners. Their families own big houses with porches, and they are raised from birth with the notion that they are privileged people. As Willie says, ‘‘Acreage and trust funds helped somewhat, but Mississippi was full of insolvent blue bloods who inherited the status of family money. It could not be earned. It had to be handed down at birth.’’ Grisham is not the first Mississippi writer to write about family money. William Faulkner’s novels and short stories, set in his fictional Yoknapatawpha County, are full of destitute characters who enjoy prestige because of family money.
TOPICS FOR FURTHER STUDY
While most of the violence in The Last Juror is associated with the Padgitt trial, in reality, desegregation was quite violent in Mississippi. Research Medgar Evers’s and the NAACP’s efforts toward desegregation in Mississippi. What were some examples of the violence faced by these civil rights workers? What kinds of sacrifices did they make? How did their sacrifices benefit all residents of Mississippi? Write a paper detailing the information that you find.
Do some research on Vietnam veterans and draft evaders on the Internet. Why did they make the choices they did? Write a short story from the point of view of a young man facing the draft in 1970. In the story, explain the decision you would make and why.
List some of the differences you might find between the lives of black people and the lives of white people in Mississippi in the 1970s. Would this list be the same in your part of the country? If not, what are some of the reasons for the differences? If the lists are similar, why is that? Compare this list to a list of the differences between the lives of black people and white people today. Has there been a big change? Discuss your findings with your classmates. Watch the film version of A Time to Kill. In what ways do the themes of the film echo the themes of The Last Juror? Write a synopsis for a film version of The Last Juror. Would you make it a thriller like A Time to Kill, or would you focus more on the characterdriven parts of the book? How would you handle the long time period covered in the novel?
Religion While The Last Juror could not be characterized as a religious book, the Ruffin family is a very religious family. Miss Callie’s belief permeates everything she does, and because she is such a central character in the book, religion takes on an important role. According to her children, Miss Callie’s faith in God is one of the reasons they have all achieved so much. Faith in God and in His rules about hatred and judging prevent Miss Callie from becoming bitter over the hatred and racism she has had to face. The Ruffins are not the only characters in the book who are faithful Christians. Margaret Wright and Lenny Fargarson are both described as religious people, and both gain a large measure of peace and comfort because of it. Willie is questioned about his faith by Miss Callie. She worries about the state of his soul, as does Margaret. In addition, people in Ford County are taken aback that Willie does not attend a church. He calls himself ‘‘the most famous derelict in town.’’ It seems that in the South during this time, one must attend church so as not to be seen as a suspicious character in the eyes of the neighbors. Willie decides to visit every church in Ford County and write about it
1 1 6
L i t e r a r y
on the Religion page of the newspaper. He notes that there are no Catholics, Episcopalians, or Mormons in the county, but that it is heavily Baptist with the Pentecostals in second place.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
Both of these religious communities are quite fractured, however. Willie was raised Episcopalian, so visiting churches with long, emotional services is foreign to him. Willie is a religious outsider in Clanton, and through his experiences and observations Grisham illustrates the complexity and contradiction in the community’s religious life.
L a s t
J u r o r
readers understand both Clanton and Ford County. In many ways, Clanton is as much a character in the novel as any other.
HISTORICAL CONTEXT Desegregation
STYLE Double Narrative In literature, plot means the pattern of events in a story. Usually, a novel has a main plot and perhaps one or two sub-plots. But The Last Juror seems to have two plots that intertwine with one another. The first plot is the Rhoda Kassellaw murder, which includes all the materials about Danny Padgitt’s trial. The other plot is the Willie–Miss Callie plot, and the slow building of their friendship. Of course, Miss Callie appears in both plots since she is a juror on the Padgitt case. But often Willie seems to be telling two different stories, and readers must be careful to keep the threads of the plots straight. Sometimes the story feels a little disjointed, yet Willie is recounting the events thirty years after they happened. This nonlinear style seems appropriate because it reflects how a person’s memories work. In other places in the novel, Willie’s narrative is unrelated to either the Padgitt case or Miss Callie. These episodes fill out his memory of the time, provide a fuller picture of life in Clanton, and offer insight into Willie’s character.
Episodic Plot An episodic plot is arranged as a series of separate episodes. This allows the writer to shift the place, time and viewpoint of the narrative. One thing that might confuse readers of The Last Juror is the sheer number of characters. The story covers nine years and, in that time, dozens of characters float in and out of the story. Because of the episodic nature of the writing, a character may show up only once and never reappear in the narrative. However, the writing is so vivid that even characters who appear only briefly seem to belong in the story. For example, the story of Mr. DeJarnette’s suicide gives color to the novel, but moves nothing along in terms of plot. However, these minor characters help
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
In the 1954 decision Brown v. the Board of Education, the United States Supreme Court struck down the idea of ‘‘separate but equal’’ that had been the country’s guideline for racial equality since the 1896 case Plessy v. Ferguson. The Brown decision meant that black children must be granted access to the same schools and facilities as their white peers. However, many places in the deeply segregated South did not intend to desegregate without a fight. In some cases, the National Guard was sent in to protect black students as they entered formerly ‘‘white only’’ schools. Many states fought desegregation through the courts. Mississippi avoided desegregation for a decade in this way. Not until the successful court cases of a number of black families in Mississippi, supported by the NAACP, did schools slowly start to integrate. Schools usually adopted a ‘‘freedom of choice’’ rule, whereby black students could voluntarily choose to go to white schools. Many white citizens fought desegregation with intimidation and violence. Black parents who sent their children to whitedominated schools could lose their jobs, leases, or credit at the bank. Sometimes there was violence, or a burning cross was erected on a family’s lawn. In The Last Juror, Sam Ruffin becomes the only black student in the formerly all-white middle school. He is beaten regularly until he learns to use his fists and fight back. No other black families in Clanton are willing to put their children in the same situation. Mississippi continued to fight desegregation until the Supreme Court handed down a landmark decision in Alexander v. Holmes in 1969. In the case, which involved thirty Mississippi school districts, the court struck down all types of dual-school districts and ordered that desegregation must happen immediately. Many schools in Mississippi actually made the changes mid-school year, but in The Last Juror, the school district desegregates at the beginning of a new school year.
V o l u m e
1
1 1 7
T h e
L a s t
J u r o r
Vietnam War The Vietnam War was one of the most divisive events in U.S. history in the 1960s– 1970s, and to understand why, one must go back much earlier. Vietnam, then called French Indochina, was a French colony for nearly a century before the Second World War. During the peace talks after that war, Vietnam was divided into two halves, communist (North Vietnam) and non-communist (South Vietnam). The French wanted to hold on to their colony, and for over seven years there was a war between the French and the Vietnamese. The United States gave financial help to the French in order to stop the spread of communism. During peace conferences in 1954, it was decided that the French would give up its claim to Indochina, and Vietnam would be temporarily divided. Ho Chi Minh, President of North Vietnam, promised to reunite the country under a communist banner. Guerrilla fighters called the Vietcong were sent into the south to disrupt the country’s attempts at postwar reconstruction. The United States aided South Vietnam because of its strong stand against communism. In 1961, President John F. Kennedy began sending U.S. troops to Vietnam to act as advisors. Things changed in 1964, when two U.S. ships were bombed in the Gulf of Tonkin. President Lyndon B. Johnson retaliated by bombing North Vietnam outposts. Congress also passed the Tonkin Gulf Resolution, which gave the president broad powers for waging a war in Vietnam. After that, U.S. troops were sent to Vietnam and the United States started bombing North Vietnamese targets. At first, many Americans supported the war, which was seen as a war against communist aggressors. However, this changed in 1968. U.S. troops had fought in Vietnam for over three years by then, with little to show for it. In January of that year, the Vietcong launched the Tet Offensive. It was a massive, coordinated attack on the United States Embassy in Saigon, as well as other key cities and military bases throughout South Vietnam. It was not a military success for the North Vietnamese, who were ultimately forced back over the border, but it was a political defeat for the United States. Seeing images on television of the embassy under siege and the fierce fighting taking place, many Americans realized that the
1 1 8
L i t e r a r y
government’s optimistic predictions about the war’s imminent end were not realistic. Much of the American media, including respected television anchorman Walter Cronkite, spoke out against the war. On campuses around the country, college students held protests condemning the war. In 1969, President Richard M. Nixon began withdrawing troops, but later that year the fighting escalated again. In April 1970, President Nixon announced he was expanding the fighting to Cambodia, and students erupted in protest. The protests turned deadly in May 1970, when National Guardsmen were called to Kent State University in Ohio to help control the protesters. The Guardsmen opened fire on the students, killing four and injuring nine. Two weeks later, police shot and killed two protestors at Jackson State University in Mississippi. These two incidents are still bitterly remembered. Vietnam veterans returning from the war often found themselves the enemy in the eyes of their peers. Unlike previous veterans of foreign wars in American history, these men and women were not welcomed home with parades and glory. Many returned to the United States with drug or alcohol problems. Many soldiers in Vietnam wanted to dull both the pain of being in an unpopular war far from home and the fear of imminent death. In The Last Juror, this situation is shown through Bubba Crockett and his friends. All of them are soured by their war experiences. Large numbers of young men publicly burned their draft cards, and thousands who were drafted fled to Canada, Australia, or other countries. Sam Ruffin makes this choice in the novel, spurred on by his friends and siblings. President Jimmy Carter pardoned all draft evaders in 1978—almost 10,000 people. Public protest against the war grew during the early 1970s. In 1973, a formal peace treaty was signed between the United States and Vietnam, and President Nixon began the withdrawal of U.S. troops. The war in Vietnam finally ended on April 30, 1975, when Saigon fell to the Vietcong. The bitterness of the war years has dulled, but the memory has not, which is evident whenever the United States faces a new war. One of the favorite cries of the antiwar movement is inevitably, ‘‘not another Vietnam.’’
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
L a s t
J u r o r
Empty jury box Ó Jose Luis Pelaez, Inc./Corbis
CRITICAL OVERVIEW When The Last Juror was published in January 2004, the book was released to mixed reviews. Critics expecting a ‘‘typical’’ Grisham legal thriller usually gave the book a poor review. But critics open to reading the book as a novel with no expectations for certain genre conventions were more positive. Publishers Weekly gives the book a starred review, indicating the book is considered of ‘‘outstanding’’ quality. The anonymous reviewer says: Grisham has spent the last few years stretching his creative muscles through a number of genres: his usual legal thrillers (The Summons, The King of Torts, etc.), a literary novel (The Painted House [sic]), a Christmas book (Skipping Christmas) and a high school football elegy (Bleachers). This experimentation seems to have imbued his writing with a new strength, giving exuberant life to this compassionate, compulsively readable story of a young man’s growth from callowness to something approaching wisdom.
Grisham tells the sad, heroic, moving stories of the eccentric inhabitants of Clanton, a small town balanced between the pleasures and perils of the old and the new South. The novel is heartfelt, wise, suspenseful and funny, one of the best Grishams ever.
Other critics, such as Ron Berthel of the Associated Press, were not as generous in their praise, but still liked the book. He notes that the book is . . . a homey tale about a small-town newspaper and its young master growing up together, and a social observation of the effects that rapidly changing times—school desegregation, the Vietnam War, illegal drug use and the demise of small businesses at the hands of national ‘‘big box’’ retailers—have on life in a slow-paced Southern town.
And while ‘‘suspense and thrills aren’t the main focus of this novel, Grisham knows how to keep the pages turning.’’
The review concludes with high praise indeed:
Matt Grady of America’s Intelligence Wire would agree. He writes that Willie’s first person narrative provides ‘‘a fresh, vibrant touch to the story.’’ Grady also appreciates ‘‘the comical supporting characters including crooked lawyers and nosy reporters.’’ Grady writes that ‘‘these
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 1 9
T h e
L a s t
J u r o r
elements combined with foreboding suspense and action make The Last Juror a smooth, entertaining read.’’ Dierdre Donohue, writing for USA Today, argues that there are two Grishams: one who writes ‘‘jet-fueled legal thrillers’’ and another who writes more personal novels about things like ‘‘religious faith and its transformative power.’’ In The Last Juror there is both. Like the reviewer from Publisher’s Weekly, Donohue rates this book highly: ‘‘The novel will satisfy those with an appetite for legal thrillers and those who believe Grisham possesses more talent than those breathless page-turners sometimes reveal. It ranks among his best-written and most atmospheric novels.’’ Donohue does note one flaw in the novel. ‘‘Although the novel’s characters are memorable, Grisham uses a heavy trowel to shape them.’’ She remarks that characters in the book are either saints, like Miss Callie, or devils, like the Padgitts. Richard Dyer of the Boston Globe sees the book as flawed, but showing an improvement in Grisham’s skill as a novelist. He writes that Grisham is expanding as a writer, and suggests Grisham’s ‘‘ambitions and skills aren’t lined up yet, but the ambition is more focused, and the skill is coming along.’’ Some critics were disappointed in the book. Jennifer Reese at Entertainment Weekly writes that Grisham’s attempt to combine a characterdriven novel and a legal thriller is not altogether successful. She calls the book a ‘‘salty snack, a tasty, nonnutritious, and ultimately unsatisfying page-turner . . .’’. New Statesman writer Mark Bearn is even more scathing in his review. He writes, ‘‘Sadly, it is a book without plot, purpose or even any pleasure for the reader, simply page after page of deep-fried Southern cliche.’’ He goes on to attack Grisham’s writing as a whole by saying that ‘‘Despite their clumsy plots, paper-thin characters and shocking grammar,’’ Grisham’s earlier books were ‘‘readable’’ and ‘‘surprisingly effective morality tales.’’ However, he adds, as time goes on, Grisham has become more ambitious as a writer and ‘‘less accomplished.’’ Bearn finds Grisham’s characterizations in the novel lacking. He finds Miss Callie ‘‘absurdly angelic’’ and says that Grisham treats readers to ‘‘a parade of formulaic characters.’’ He finishes his review of the novel with this analysis:
1 2 0
L i t e r a r y
A plot, or a hard look at the racial divisions that make Mississippi the poorest and most unequal state in America, might have compensated for Grisham’s lack of literary skill. Without either of these we are left with nothing.
CRITICISM Margaret Brantley Brantley is a writer and editor of literary reference and academic subject texts. In this essay, she examines the portrayal of racism in recent-past settings by modern writers, and how John Grisham’s The Last Juror treats the subject in the twenty-first century. In August 2005, the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences revealed that people’s feelings about something could be changed by manipulating their memories of it. Convinced that they had had a bad experience with strawberry ice cream as a child, adults turned away from the treat they had previously enjoyed. Persuaded that they had once loved asparagus, test subjects reported liking it more than before. The human impulse to believe that what is true today has always been true is by no means limited to such tricks of the taste buds. In 1963, George Wallace became governor of Alabama and proclaimed, ‘‘segregation today, segregation tomorrow, segregation forever’’ in his inaugural speech. He raised the Confederate Battle Flag atop the state’s capitol dome that year. A generation later, tradition-minded Alabamians fought the removal of the controversial symbol, arguing that it had flown there since the Civil War and to remove it would dishonor their noble Confederate ancestors. Whether through an exercise in propaganda or poetic license, American writers have also shaped their readers’ present perceptions by adjusting their past attitudes. Following in the footsteps of Mark Twain, Margaret Mitchell, and Harper Lee, John Grisham reaches into the recent past and retrieves a new memory in The Last Juror. While racism is often mentioned in the book, its presence provides more atmosphere than action. The Last Juror is not a fable with a moral about the wrongness of racism. It is a crime drama. The basic story can be summarized in a few lines: A man kills a woman. A young newspaperman sensationalizes the story to sell papers. A woman has lived a remarkable life
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
WHETHER THROUGH AN EXERCISE IN PROPAGANDA OR POETIC LICENSE, AMERICAN WRITERS HAVE ALSO SHAPED THEIR READERS’ PRESENT PERCEPTIONS BY ADJUSTING THEIR PAST ATTITUDES. FOLLOWING IN THE FOOTSTEPS OF MARK TWAIN, MARGARET MITCHELL, AND HARPER LEE, JOHN GRISHAM REACHES INTO THE RECENT PAST AND RETRIEVES A NEW MEMORY IN THE LAST JUROR.’’
despite hardships. She breaks ground by being selected to sit on the jury in the murder trial. The community is shocked by the outcome. Some members of the jury are murdered—but why, and by whom? If all the players are either black or white, this cast of core characters—the murderer, the victim, the reporter, the juror, and the avenger— may have thirty different configurations and create almost as many race dramas. Or, as is the case in The Last Juror, the color of the participants’ skin proves immaterial to the story’s action. The juror is black, and the other core players are white. There are moments when the reader fears she will be harmed by racist whites in her community, but not only is she not harmed, she is not threatened. The issue of race in The Last Juror is a red herring, used to add suspense and keep the readers guessing. It serves as a misdirection because modern readers are primed to expect race, when mentioned, to be an issue.
L a s t
J u r o r
century, masters like Leo Tolstoy and Victor Hugo were making statements about contemporary politics in Russia and France with stories set during major events in each country’s recent past. Writing just after the American Civil War about events in the years just prior, Mark Twain (1835–1910) used the recent-past technique and a child’s point of view to evoke compassion for African Americans. Immediately after the Civil War, the U.S. government suspended the rights of the rebel states in a period known as Reconstruction. It passed laws to establish civil rights for newly freed slaves, but resistance to such forced progress gave rise to organized racism and violence as defeated white southerners sought to reclaim a sense of power. When Reconstruction ended in 1877, the stage was set for the Jim Crow era, a period of legalized racial segregation designed to systematically oppress African Americans. Published in 1885 and set ‘‘Forty to Fifty Years Ago,’’ Twain’s Adventures of Huckleberry Finn shows the hero’s struggle with his conscience while trying to do the right thing. After faking his death and leaving home, Huck takes up with a runaway slave named Jim, whose friendship and company are the foundation for the novel’s adventures. Although he loves his friend, Huck feels that he should turn in the fugitive slave. He prays for the resolve to turn Jim in but cannot bring himself to do the ‘‘right’’ thing: I was letting on to give up sin, but away inside of me I was holding on to the biggest one of all. I was trying to make my mouth say I would do the right thing and the clean thing, and go write to that nigger’s owner and tell where he was; but deep down I knowed it was a lie, and He knowed it. You can’t pray a lie—I found that out. . . . I was a-trembling, because I’d got to decide, forever, betwixt two things, and I knowed it. I studied a minute, sort of holding my breath, and then says to myself: ‘‘All right then, I’ll go to hell[.]‘‘
Storytellers have always spun yarns about the long ago and the far away. A culture’s values are both reflected in and supported by its mythology. Heroes like Gilgamesh, Odysseus, and King Arthur illustrated lessons of bravery, humility, cunning, hospitality, chivalry, and piety. Each also gave future generations of his countrymen an ancestral hero with a legacy of which to be proud. As literacy and printing technology grew, readers started enjoying adventures and romances set in the present day and written in accessible language, in addition to the myths and fables of yore. By the nineteenth
Huck accepts his inability to betray Jim as a flaw in his own sinful nature rather than a flaw of the society that expects him to regard another human as less than himself. That he does the morally right thing, even when contrary to the legally right thing, reveals something admirable about Huck. Through the brave decision of a thoroughly likeable and fully American character, Twain gives his readers a hero they can identify with, respect, and honor as they, too, do the moral thing. Huck recognizes Jim’s humanity long before the lawmakers in
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 2 1
T h e
L a s t
J u r o r
Washington try to legislate that recognition. Following his example, Twain’s readers can also be compassionate without feeling like some federal law has told them how to feel. Grisham uses a different tactic to let his readers feel compassion. In one scene in The Last Juror, he describes the contrasting reactions to public school desegregation from both communities it is about to affect: The white parents were angry and frightened and I saw several women crying. The fateful day had finally arrived. At the black school there was an air of victory. The parents were concerned, but they were also elated that their children would finally be enrolled in the better schools.
By representing the black community’s point of view, Grisham underscores the righteousness of the wronged party without preaching or even pointing out which side that is. His readers get to feel good about themselves for knowing that they, too, are on the side of right. Written during the Jim Crow era, Margaret Mitchell’s Gone With the Wind (1936) gave readers license to remember the Civil War in a new way. Mitchell (1900–1949) experienced the beginning of the breakdown of the Jim Crow South as an adult in Atlanta. During the Red Summer of 1919, northern and southern U.S. cities alike witnessed more than two dozen race riots. The U.S. Supreme Court upheld black defendants’ rights to fairness before the law with landmark cases in the 1920s and 1930s in which African Americans were charged with violence against whites. Membership in the Ku Klux Klan peaked in the 1920s, and the poverty and insecurity of the Great Depression of the 1930s fostered animosity toward minorities as people competed for scarce jobs and resources. Gone With the Wind gave readers a picture of benign slavery they could embrace, as well as a dashing, romantic, racist hero to admire. Mitchell’s Rhett Butler is a charming rogue who ignores conventions and lives for his own selfish pleasure. In a line meant to reveal something good about Rhett’s character, the narrator notes, ‘‘Even Rhett, conscienceless scamp that he was, had killed a negro for being ‘uppity to a lady.’’’ The reader understands that being a murderer is preferable to letting a white lady endure a perceived affront. Later, Scarlett, the story’s protagonist, tries to defend the use of white convict labor by comparing it to slavery: ‘‘Ah, but
1 2 2
L i t e r a r y
that was different. Slaves were neither miserable nor unfortunate. The negroes were far better off under slavery than they were now under freedom, and if she didn’t believe it, just look about her!’’ Regardless of whether Mitchell’s Pulitzer Prize–winning masterpiece served to defend its author’s heritage and justify her beliefs, it did allow its readers to hold their chins up and look down their noses at the idea that there was anything wrong with being a racist. Grisham turns this approach on its head. While Rhett is a likeable racist, Lucien Wilbanks, the defense attorney in The Last Juror, is an unsympathetic progressive. ‘‘He was the only white member of the NAACP in Ford County, which alone was enough to get you shot there. He didn’t care.’’ Wilbanks is mean, unpopular, and one of the novel’s bad guys, but he is also bravely on the right side of the race question. Harper Lee’s To Kill a Mockingbird (1960) was written in the thick of the civil rights movement, between the 1954 decision that outlawed segregation in public schools and the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Set in the 1930s in Jim Crow Alabama, the novel was inspired by the case of the Scottsboro boys, nine black teenagers wrongfully convicted of raping two white women in Alabama in 1931. All but the youngest one were sentenced to death for the crime, but all were eventually released through appeals, pardons, or parole. In two separate decisions related to the case, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the defendants’ right to due process and fair trials. Atticus Finch, the protagonist of To Kill a Mockingbird, is a white lawyer defending an innocent black man accused of raping a white woman. He does not win, nor does he expect to, but he behaves bravely and morally in the face of societal pressure to do otherwise. Finch is a hero like Huck Finn: one that readers can look up to as a model to emulate in a confusing time of change. The idea that all citizens deserved life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness was one that some white Americans officially resisted into the 1970s. The message of To Kill a Mockingbird could be that white people are no better and no worse than black people, black people are no less deserving of civil rights than white people, and it is up to white people to look out for black people. The novel lumps African Americans in with simpletons, bugs,
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
and birds—all of which deserve compassion and protection from white people. Early in the book, a neighbor explains to Atticus’s son why it is a sin to kill a mockingbird: ‘‘Mockingbirds don’t do one thing but make music for us to enjoy. They don’t eat up people’s gardens, don’t nest in corncribs, they don’t do one thing but sing their hearts out for us.’’ Later, the boy prevents his sister from killing a harmless roly-poly bug with the argument ‘‘they don’t bother you.’’ The novel ends with the girl agreeing with her father that they should protect their mysterious, emotionally troubled neighbor, because to do otherwise would be ‘‘like shootin’ a mockingbird.’’ Atticus Finch shows the readers how to act righteously while assuring them that they can remain superior. He is painted as a hero to the dignified and stoic black community. He believes they are equal but does not seem to mind keeping them separate. Rather than grief and outrage when an innocent man is sent to prison, the black members of the community stand as a gesture of respect when the white lawyer passes by. This exchange between Finch and his African American housekeeper about the gifts of food the black townspeople leave to show their gratitude underscores the fact that heroic behavior in one generation may not only be inadequate but actually offensive to the next: Calpurnia said, ‘‘This was all ‘round the back steps when I got here this morning. They—they ‘preciate what you did, Mr. Finch. They—they aren’t oversteppin’ themselves, are they?’’ Atticus’s eyes filled with tears. He did not speak for a moment. ‘‘Tell them I’m very grateful,’’ he said. ‘‘Tell them—tell them they must never do this again. Times are too hard.’’
Even if the exchange does not suggest that there are circumstances in which the gift-givers might step out of place, it does say that white people do not owe black people the most basic observance of good manners—to say ‘‘thank you’’ to people who give them gifts and pay them compliments. If Lee was able to convince readers in the 1960s to be more like Atticus Finch, she contributed to progress—not triumph. If Finch had made African American friends with whom he socialized at their homes, at his home, and in public, like the white protagonist of The Last Juror, the bar would have been higher.
L a s t
J u r o r
every opportunity in order to prove they are intelligent, evolved, progressive beings. In Playing in the Dark: Whiteness and the Literary Imagination (1992), Toni Morrison claims that ‘‘the habit of ignoring race is understood to be a graceful, even generous, liberal gesture.’’ Grisham by no means ignores it. He portrays overt racism in 1970s Mississippi as a fact of the setting, like the hot summers or the native drawl, but does not make any specific judgment condemning it. However, The Last Juror is filled with portrayals of racism and its effects. Grisham does not downplay or ignore racism; he simply opts not to make it the center of his tale. He populates his fictional Clanton, Mississippi, with rich, full personalities and makes sure that neither the town’s black citizens nor its white citizens have a monopoly on silliness or dignity, evil or virtue. Through the voice of narrator Willie Traynor, Grisham comes across as clearly anti-racist, but he does not belabor the point. He trusts his twenty-first-century audience to share his feeling and gets on with the story. Grisham does not use The Last Juror to influence his readers’ opinions about race. He paints neither a prettier nor uglier picture of the past, and he does not ask his readers to feel better or worse about themselves or their history. He does not suggest that the fight against racism is won, or even close to over. His debut novel, A Time to Kill (1989), set in present-day Clanton, addresses the issue head on. With The Last Juror, he gives a multifaceted portrayal of life in the small-town South. The Twains, Mitchells, and Lees that came before him made sure he does not have to educate his readers about racism; they already know. Thanks to the modern reader’s sophistication, Grisham is able to reach a new level of complexity and realism in his depiction of the recent past. In his opinion on the 1972 decision that deemed all American death penalty statutes illegal, Thurgood Marshall, the country’s first black Supreme Court justice, wrote, ‘‘In recognizing the humanity of our fellow beings, we pay ourselves the highest tribute.’’ In 2004 with the inhabitants of his fictional Clanton, Grisham came closer to paying himself this tribute than most other American writers could imagine.
The Last Juror (2004) offers a new reason to look to the recent past: to reassure readers that they do not need to talk about race at
Source: Margaret Brantley, Critical Essay on The Last Juror, in Literary Newsmakers for Students, Thomson Gale, 2006.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 2 3
T h e
L a s t
J u r o r
WHAT DO I READ NEXT? Grisham’s A Time to Kill (1988) was his first book, and it is also set in Clanton, Mississippi in the fictional Ford County, so it is an interesting way of seeing some characters’ first appearances in print. It also has similar themes but is more of a thriller. The Summons (2002) is the second book Grisham set in Clanton. Not really a thriller, it has been called a morality play by some reviewers—a story that tells readers how they should behave by showing them characters who do the absolute wrong thing. R. M. Leich’s Not My Father’s War (2004), a novel written by a Vietnam veteran, is the story of a wealthy young man from Nashville, Tennessee who tries to keep up the family tradition of service to country and patriotism, but who learns that Vietnam is unlike any other American war. George C. Herring’s America’s Longest War: The United States and Vietnam, 1950–1975, 3rd edition (2001) is the textbook most highly recommended for understanding the Vietnam War. The last chapter, ‘‘The Post-War and the Legacy of Vietnam,’’ has been revised to reflect the dramatic changes of the past decade, and it analyzes the influence that Vietnam continues to have on Americans.
Tina Jordan In the following interview with Jordan, Grisham discusses how his many books, as well as the filmed adaptations of those books, compare to each other. John Grisham’s office, a stunning loft space overlooking downtown Charlottesville, Va., is a long, lean expanse of wood floors studded with curvy red and plum sofas and an imposing conference table. Despite the wood and glass and steel, it’s a warm space, decorated with both the
1 2 4
L i t e r a r y
expected (movie posters, early reviews) and the unexpected (one of his old Mississippi law firm business cards, encased in a small frame). Grisham, 49, strides in five minutes late, apologetic. He’s driven from his farm, a 204-acre spread south of the city that he shares with wife Renee and daughter Shea (son Ty is away at college). Nursing an Italian coffee, he ponders a list of his 17 best-sellers and 9 movies. ‘‘By the time I’m finished with one book I’m always thinking about the next one,’’ he says, laughing, ‘‘so I can’t remember a lot of detail. But I’ll wing it.’’ He doesn’t have to wing it, of course. Here’s a short list of his favorites—and a few not-sofavorites: Grisham was a small-town lawyer and state legislator in Mississippi when he picked up a pen and pad and started A Time to Kill (1989). ‘‘I didn’t know what I was doing when I wrote that book. It’s the only book out of 17 that I wrote without a deadline and without the knowledge that it was going to get published, so I really took my time with it. Still, I go back and look at it occasionally and see a lot of rookie mistakes . . . Too many long sentences and too much flowery prose. Now, 20 years later, I’m really tired of the Ku Klux Klan stuff. When you write about the South it’s got to be about race, and I wish I hadn’t devoted so much of the book to the Klan because they don’t deserve it. That’s one thing I’d change.’’ After spending three years laboring over A Time to Kill—and not having much to show for it—Grisham admits that The Firm (1991) was ‘‘a naked stab at commercial fiction’’: ‘‘If it hadn’t worked the second time, I probably would’ve stopped for a while. I like [The Firm] a lot because I’ve always liked the character of Mitch McDeere, and the hook, and the ending— in spite of what Hollywood did to it.’’ (Grisham ended with the main couple stealing Mob money and going on a permanent Caribbean vacation, while director Sydney Pollack, claiming he was sick of ‘‘yuppie endings,’’ sent Tom Cruise and Jeanne Tripplehorn back to their Boston roots, poorer but wiser.) The movie: ‘‘I had nothing to do with it. I went to the set twice. Stephen King is a buddy, and he told me a long time ago, ‘They’re just movies. They cannot change a word of what you’ve written. It’s somebody else’s interpretation. Take the money and run.’ . . . I thought
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
[Cruise] did a good job. He played the innocent young associate very well.’’ Hoping to capitalize on The Firm’s success, Grisham churned out The Pelican Brief (1992) in two months flat: ‘‘You know the movie Three Days of the Condor, the CIA thriller [directed by Pollack] with Robert Redford and Faye Dunaway? The book was a deliberate effort to outspace Condor, to have all this stuff going on, so the reader could not turn the pages fast enough. But I think it shows some damage because it was written so fast.’’ The movie: ‘‘I met Alan Pakula before he bought the film rights, and he wanted my input. I read the screenplay, and it followed the book . . . That’s all you can ask for. The movie was very popular. I though Julia [Roberts] was a good choice . . . I had a problem with Denzel [Washington], not as actor, but in the book he’s a white guy . . . I didn’t write the guy as a black guy in the book. Some of my characters are white and some are black. If you’re going to make a dramatic change, give me a good reason. And there really was no good reason. And I think it was kind of awkward; in the book there was more of a romance toward the end between the two. In the movie it was almost like they couldn’t because one was black and one was white.’’ In its first year out, The Client (1993) sold 3 million copies; it even overtook the behemoth The Bridges of Madison County on the best-seller charts for a few weeks. ‘‘The Client was, by the benefit of 10 years’ hindsight, by far the weakest book . . . because of the kid hiring the lawyer, the kid knowing where the body’s buried . . . There’s a hundred pages of fluff in that book.’’ The movie: ‘‘The Client may be my least favorite book, but it’s a really popular movie. The Pelican Brief and Client were much closer to the books than The Firm . . . I thought Susan Sarandon was wonderful.’’ The Chamber (1994), about a death-penalty case, was a departure for Grisham, the first in which he grappled with social issues: ‘‘It was probably the most difficult book I had to write. Growing up in a strict Southern Baptist household you think capital punishment’s wonderful—line ’em up, shoot ’em, hang ’em. And the book flipped me. I wasn’t expecting that. I spent time on death row, and it had a profound impact on me. It was difficult to write—I just couldn’t get the guy to the gas chamber. And so it became a very long book. The only book I’ve missed the
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
L a s t
J u r o r
deadline on. But it’s a book I like a lot. A book I’m proud of.’’ The movie: ‘‘A disaster. A train wreck from the beginning. It could not have been handled worse by those involved, including me. I made a fundamental error when I sold the film rights before I finished writing the book. It was a dreadful movie. Gene Hackman was the only good thing in it.’’ Next he tackled the insurance industry in The Rainmaker (1995): ‘‘I got to unload on insurance companies, which is a lot of fun. I sued ’em for 10 years when I was a lawyer . . . Rainmaker was . . . the first time I used first-person narration, and I realized I really, really liked it . . . The challenge with Rainmaker, also with The Runaway Jury [1996], is that courtroom stuff of a civil nature is unbelievably dull. And so you weigh the balance of pace with being legally accurate. I hate this television stuff with courtroom scenes that would just make any lawyer want to vomit. I don’t want to do that.’’ The movie: ‘‘To me it’s the best adaptation of any of ’em. [Francis Ford] Coppola really wanted my involvement, for whatever it’s worth. And I love the movie. It’s so well done. And it came out a few weeks before Titanic and got swamped.’’ There’s no moralizing in The Partner (1997), just good writing about a greedy lawyer on the lam: ‘‘It’s one of my favorite stories, one of the trickiest ones, flashing back and then forward, nabbing the lawyer and then watching him wiggle out of it. There are times when my wife says, ‘Would you just stop preaching and tell a story?’ And I listen to that.’’ Grisham tried a new tack In The Brethren (2000)—humor. It’s the tale of three jailed judges who run a blackmailing scam from their cells: ‘‘I thought [Brethren] was hilarious! It was supposed to be hilarious! It’s based on a real story— though obviously I was careful to fictionalize it—at the Louisiana State Penitentiary at Angola. Brethren was a fun story, fun to write, but one with no redeeming social value whatsoever.’’ Grisham got rave reviews for A Painted House (2001), his first nonlegal thriller: ‘‘Well, probably my best book. The best writing. Probably the best story and the best characters. It’s a sweet childhood memoir, even though it was published as fiction. The first seven years of my life—I was that kid, I lived on that farm, with my grandparents, playing baseball with Mexicans. Once I got all the setting and
V o l u m e
1
1 2 5
T h e
L a s t
J u r o r
characters in place, I just sort of fictionalized everything . . . ’’ In his new book, The Last Juror—not strictly a legal thriller—Grisham takes readers back to Ford County, the fictional Mississippi county that was also the setting of A Time to Kill. ‘‘I wrote a hundred pages of it in the fall of 1989. I was going to write a Ford County book and a legal thriller, back and forth, and write two kinds of books, so I had the story all mapped out, and then The Firm went crazy, so The Last Juror got shoved to the back burner. But I’ve learned a lot over the years. After 15 years, I have greater expectations for my books.’’ Source: Tina Jordan, ‘‘Grisham V Grisham: John Grisham, undisputed champ of the legal thriller, issues a summary judgment on THE LAST JUROR, his latest novel, along with verdicts on some of his previous bestsellers,’’ in Entertainment Weekly, No. 751, February 13, 2004, p. 41.
Richard Dyer In the following review, Dyer argues that The Last Juror is Grisham’s most literary novel to date, and is more than just a legal thriller.
1 2 6
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
L a s t
J u r o r
‘‘The Last Juror Book Review,’’ in Publishers Weekly, Vol. 251, February 2, 2004, p. 59. Mohr, Charles, ‘‘10,000 Affected Now,’’ in New York Times, January 22, 1977, p. 47. Oberdorfer, Don, ‘‘Tet: Who Won?,’’ in Smithsonian, Vol. 35, Issue 8, November 2004, pp. 117–22. Reese, Jennifer, Losing Appeal? Legal Pyrotechnics and Melodrama Awkwardly Mix in John Grisham’s ‘‘The Last Juror,’’ in Entertainment Weekly, February 13, 2004. p. 74. ‘‘School Desegregation in Mississippi,’’ University of Southern Mississippi’s Civil Rights Documentation Project, www.usm.edu/crdp/html/cd/desegregation. htm
FURTHER READING
John Grisham Online, www.randomhouse.com/features/ grisham/
Appy, Christian G, Patriots: The Vietnam War Remembered from All Sides, Viking Books, 2003. This book is designed to be an oral history, giving voice to people from all sides of the Vietnam War—officials from both the United States and Vietnam, as well as words from widows of soldiers, civilians who helped in the war effort as well as war protestors. Fireside, Harvey and Sarah Betsey Fuller, Brown v. Board of Education: Equal Schooling for All, Landmark Supreme Court Cases Series, Enslow Publishers, 1994. An objective and well-written book, aimed at giving high school students a solid understanding of this groundbreaking case. To help readers understand, it includes photos, quotations from both sides of the battle and explanations of the judges’ opinions. Galt, Margot Fortunato, Stop This War!: American Protest of the Conflict in Vietnam, Lerner Publishing, 2000. Galt interviewed many former conscientious objectors who give their viewpoint about the Vietnam war. She also gives information about protest groups, the war policies of Presidents Johnson and Nixon, and the Kent State killings. Maraniss, David, They Marched Into Sunlight: War and Peace, Vietnam and America, October 1967, Simon & Schuster, 2003. This book gives a good overview of the peace movement in America, focusing on Wisconsin and the battle situation in Vietnam. Walter, Mildred Pitts, Mississippi Challenge, Simon & Shuster Children’s Publishing, 1992. Walter writes an objective and thorough nonfiction book in which she outlines the history of blacks in Mississippi from before the Civil War through the mid-1960s. She paints a stark picture, especially of how whites in Mississippi tried to prevent blacks from voting. The book includes good notes and a bibliography.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
Source: Richard Dyer, ‘‘Book Review The Last Juror By John Grisham,’’ in Boston Globe, February 2, 2004, p. E1.
SOURCES Bearden, Michelle, ‘‘An Interview with John Grisham,’’ in Publishers Weekly, Vol. 240, No. 8, February 22, 1993, pp. 70–71. Bearn, Mark, ‘‘Southern Comfort,’’ in New Statesman, Vol. 133, February 23, 2004, pp. 54–56. Berthel, Ron, ‘‘ ‘Legal Thriller’ Only One Way to Describe Grisham’s New Novel,’’ for The Associated Press, February 3, 2004, BC cycle. Blitzer, Charles, ‘‘From the Center,’’ in Wilson Quarterly, Vol. 18, Issue 3, Summer 94, p. 160. Donohue, Dierdre, ‘‘Last Juror is a Tale of 2 Grishams,’’ in USA Today, January 27, 2004,Final Edition, Life Section, p. 1D. Dyer, Richard, ‘‘Book Review, The Last Juror,’’ in Boston Globe, February 2, 2004, Third Edition, Living Section, p. E1. Grady, Matt, ‘‘Perspective of The Last Juror Adds to Grisham’s Writing,’’ in America’s Intelligence Wire, March 11, 2004. Grisham, John, The Last Juror, Random House, 2004. Hunter, Marjorie, ‘‘A Re-Entry Plan,’’ in New York Times, September 17, 1974, p. 1.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 2 7
The Lovely Bones In her first novel, The Lovely Bones (2002), Alice Sebold delves into the horror and trauma resulting from by the rape and murder of a young girl. The novel arose from Sebold’s own experience with violence—her rape as an eighteen-year-old college freshman. Similar to her 1999 memoir, Lucky, which details her own rape, its psychological aftermath, and the arrest, trial, and conviction of the rapist, The Lovely Bones refuses to sanitize sexual violence. Yet the novel does not sensationalize violence either; instead, it offers the ordinariness of it. Both the setting in suburban Philadelphia, and the time period of the early 1970s, underscore Sebold’s belief that no one is immune from violence; it touches everyone. More importantly, the story of Susie Salmon and her family exposes the way in which society marginalizes the victims of violence. The Lovely Bones becomes a study of the effects of violence, in this case rape and murder, not only on the victim, but on her family, friends, and community. The Lovely Bones does not focus on evil; it does not attempt to make sense of bad people or bad acts. Instead the novel investigates issues of loss and grief, life and death, identity and self, remembrance and forgetting, womanhood and motherhood, coming of age and rites of passage, and heaven and earth. The readers watch with Susie as her father, mother, sister, brother, and grandmother, as well as her middle school friends, her killer, and the lead detective on the
1 2 8
ALICE SEBOLD 2002
T h e
L o v e l y
B o n e s
case, confront similar issues in their attempts to understand their grief. While the novel raises many questions, it does not, in fact, answer all of them. Sebold examines traditional views, such as those about heaven, sexuality, and the place of women in American society, while simultaneously challenging those views.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY Alice Sebold was born in 1963 and grew up in the suburbs surrounding Philadelphia. In her essay ‘‘The Oddity of Suburbia,’’ she confesses that she despised suburbia, but after living in both Manhattan and Southern California, she ‘‘realiz[ed] . . . that within the suburban world of [her] upbringing there were as many strange stories as there were in the more romanticized parts of the world.’’ Her novel, The Lovely Bones (2002), reflects her realization that suburbia can and does contain ‘‘a bottomless well of narrative ideas.’’ However, that realization did not occur until Sebold left Philadelphia. In 1981, as an eighteen-year-old freshman at Syracuse University in New York, Sebold was severely beaten and raped. Rather than remain quiet about the incident, she was instrumental in the arrest, trial, and conviction of her assailant. While at Syracuse University, Sebold took writing classes with poet Tess Gallagher and fiction writer Tobias Wolff, both of whom encouraged her to remember and write about her rape. Sebold graduated from Syracuse in 1984 and entered, but did not complete, a master of fine arts degree program at the University of Houston. Instead, she moved to New York City, and as she details in the epilogue to her 1999 memoir, Lucky, she turned to alcohol and heroin as she struggled to come to terms with her rape. During these years, Sebold taught writing classes at Hunter College and Bucknell College in New York, worked odd jobs, and wrote. She left New York for California in 1995 and entered the M.F.A. program at the University of California, Irvine, earning her degree in 1998. Sebold began The Lovely Bones during her graduate writing studies, but recognized that until she confronted and narrated her own story, she could not write the story of Susie, the main character and narrator of The Lovely Bones. As many critics rightly note, the two books, Lucky and The Lovely Bones, seem to be companion pieces. The Lovely Bones garnered
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
Alice Sebold AP/Wide World Photos
two major awards, the Bram Stoker Award for best first novel and the American Booksellers Association’s ‘‘Book of the Year Award.’’ While at UC Irvine, Sebold met Glen David Gold, a fellow master’s student. They married in 2001, the same year his novel Carter Beats the Devil was published. As of 2005, Sebold and Gold lived in California.
PLOT SUMMARY Chapters 1–2 Fourteen-year-old Susie tells her story from heaven, where she exists after having been raped, murdered, and dismembered in a frozen cornfield by her neighbor, Mr. Harvey. She introduces her family—her father, Jack; mother, Abigail; sister, Lindsey; and brother, Buckley— the boy she likes, Ray Singh; the lead detective on her case, Len Fenerman; and her heavenly intake counselor, Franny. Susie begins to acclimate to her heaven and learns that it reflects her desires and wishes, and that everyone’s heaven is slightly different. With Franny’s help, she begins to understand what it means to be dead. She still
V o l u m e
1
1 2 9
T h e
L o v e l y
B o n e s
wants to grow up and live, but now, since she cannot experience actual living, she must be content to watch what happens on earth. Three days after Susie disappears, Detective Fenerman tells Jack the police have found a body part. Susie’s parents have difficulty dealing with the horror of their daughter’s disappearance— neither wants to believe that Susie is dead. In addition to the body part, the police find various objects belonging to Susie that indicate she was killed in the cornfield: a copy of the novel To Kill a Mockingbird, her biology notes, a love letter from Ray Singh, and her winter hat. This last item convinces the Salmons of Susie’s death. Ray Singh becomes the police’s first suspect. Susie’s family does not believe that Ray killed Susie; nevertheless, the police believe that his absence from school on the day she died, his dark skin, and his rather arrogant attitude make him a viable suspect. Despite his alibi, Ray, already considered an outsider by his classmates because he and his family came from India, becomes more socially isolated at school.
Chapters 3–5 Susie continues watching family and friends, and as they go about the business of living, she narrates both recent and past events. When Susie left earth, her spirit inadvertently brushed against Ruth Connors, a girl from school. This contact initiates a connection between the girls. By following Ruth, Susie remains engaged in the daily routines of adolescence. Through conversations with Franny, Susie realizes her homesickness for her mother. She recalls the candid picture she once took of her mother that captured Abigail as a woman, rather than as Mrs. Salmon, wife and mother. When the film was developed, she did not share this picture of her mother; instead, she hid it in her room. Susie watches now as Lindsey enters Susie’s room and finds that picture of their mother. Like Susie, Lindsey gets a glimpse of Abigail as Abigail. Up to this point, Susie has only watched the living, but now she materializes, revealing herself to her father. She sees Jack smash his collection of ships in a bottle that he and Susie built together. As her father stands amid the wreckage, evidence of his rage and grief, Susie reveals herself in the myriad shards. Susie recounts what happened after Harvey killed her. He dismantles the underground hole
1 3 0
L i t e r a r y
in the cornfield, carries Susie’s body parts to his house in a cloth sack, and showers to remove her blood from his body. Then he places Susie’s dismembered body in an old safe and drops it in a nearby sinkhole. Returning from the sinkhole, he finds Susie’s silver charm bracelet in his pocket. He drives to an industrial park under construction, removes one charm—the Pennsylvania keystone from her father—and throws the bracelet into the construction site. Susie discovers she was not his first victim. Weeks later, Jack stops to watch Harvey build a ceremonial tent in his yard. Jack volunteers to help with the project, and the two men— Susie’s murderer and her father—work side by side. Susie tries to send her father a message, but fails. However, Jack does feel Susie’s presence and begins to wonder about Harvey. He believes this strange man knows something about Susie’s murder. Each of the Salmons develops ways to cope with his or her individual grief and fear. Jack involves himself in finding Susie’s killer; Abigail isolates herself from her family and turns to Detective Fenerman for answers; Buckley asks direct questions regarding Susie’s absence; and Lindsey struggles with both her desire to claim an identity separate from Susie, the dead daughter and sister, and her tremendous grief at the loss of that sibling. Detective Fenerman talks with Harvey after Jack suggests he might be involved. Harvey expresses his sympathies regarding Susie’s murder and explains to the detective that Jack helped him build a ceremonial bridal tent in honor of his deceased wife. Although Detective Fenerman considers Harvey odd, he seems satisfied with Harvey’s explanations. Jack, however, is not. On Christmas Day, Samuel Heckler stops by the Salmon house with a gift for Lindsey. While Samuel and Lindsey talk in the kitchen and later exchange their first kiss, Buckley plays Monopoly with his father. During the game, Jack explains to his young son that Susie is never coming home.
Chapters 6–10 Susie recalls the first time she and Ray Singh ‘‘almost’’ kissed. Two weeks before she died, Susie got to school late and Ray, who cut his first period class, was sitting atop a scaffold in the auditorium. Susie joined him, and as they talked, she realized that Ray was going to kiss
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
her. However, voices from below interrupted them. Susie and Ray watched as the principal and the art teacher chastised Ruth for her charcoal drawings of ‘‘real women.’’ When the adults left, Susie and Ray climbed down, and Susie asked to see Ruth’s sketchbook. Impressed by the drawings, Susie changed her perspective of Ruth, seeing her as special rather than strange. The girls do not become friends, but after her murder, Susie grows to love the girl she touched as she left earth. Ray and Susie kiss a week later by their lockers. After Susie’s death, Ruth and Ray develop a deep friendship, bonding over the death of Susie. In his effort to make sense of Susie’s death, Jack seeks out Ray. At the Singhs’ house, Jack talks to Ray’s mother. When he confesses his suspicions about Harvey, Ruana Singh validates his theory and tells Jack that given the same circumstances, she would kill her child’s murderer. Ruana’s understanding contrasts with Abigail’s lack of understanding, further highlighting the widening chasm between Susie’s parents. While Jack is at the Singhs’ house, Detective Fenerman drops by the Salmons’ home. Susie watches as a subtle but discernable attraction develops between her mother and the detective. Susie’s maternal grandmother, Grandma Lynn, arrives to attend Susie’s memorial. Lynn, an eccentric and flamboyant personality, brings some vitality into the Salmon home. She begins a lively banter with Jack, gives beauty lessons to Lindsey, and prods Abigail into laughter. She realizes, regardless of the family’s tragedy, Lindsey is moving into womanhood and helps her granddaughter by acknowledging this fact. She aids in putting together an outfit for Lindsey to wear to the memorial. Grandma Lynn also answers Lindsey’s questions regarding Jack’s suspicions about Harvey, who, along with the family, school friends, teachers, neighbors, and Detective Fenerman, attends the memorial. Grandma Lynn does something that Susie notes as important: she identifies Harvey for Lindsey.
L o v e l y
B o n e s
how much she misses her sister. She also confesses she loves Samuel. As Lindsey and Samuel move toward sexual intimacy, Susie learns sex can be loving rather than violent.
Chapters 11–12 Susie knows Harvey is a serial killer of little girls and, from her heaven, scrutinizes the interior of Harvey’s house, which has an identical floor plan to that of the Salmons. But while Susie’s house contains markers of family life, Harvey’s holds the trophies of his killings as well as the presence of his victims. Jack becomes more obsessed with finding Susie’s killer. Detective Fenerman tells Jack he must stop phoning the police about Harvey. According to the detective, no evidence exists connecting Harvey to Susie’s murder. Jack, however, refuses to accept the detective’s explanation, as does Lindsey, who overhears the conversation between her father and the detective. One night, Jack sees a light moving toward the cornfield. Convinced the light belongs to Harvey, Jack grabs a baseball bat and heads for the cornfield intent on vengeance. In fact, the light belongs to Clarissa, Susie’s best friend, as she heads to meet her boyfriend Brian. As Jack hollers at whom he believes is Harvey, he hears Clarissa whimpering. Thinking another young girl is in danger, Jack loses all sense of reality. Jack’s rage and Clarissa’s screams spur Brian, who arrives in the cornfield in time to witness what he believes is Jack’s attack on Clarissa, to beat Susie’s father with the baseball bat. The beating sends Jack to the hospital for surgery on his damaged knee. Lindsey arrives at the hospital soon after the incident, expecting to see both her father and mother, but she finds her father alone in his room. Abigail, unable to cope with her collapsing world, seeks out Fenerman. When the detective arrives, he and Abigail go outside onto a small service balcony where physical intimacy enters their relationship.
Chapters 13–16
Lindsey spends a month of the summer at a statewide gifted symposium. Samuel and Ruth also attend the camp. While they do not become friends, Ruth and Lindsey do share a conversation about Susie. Ruth tells Lindsey she dreams about Susie, and Lindsey admits
As the first anniversary of Susie’s death approaches, the effects of her death on the living become more apparent, as do the changes involved with growing up. Lindsey becomes not only the sister of the murdered girl but also the daughter of a crazy man. Buckley enters kindergarten and receives special attention because of
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 3 1
T h e
L o v e l y
B o n e s
his sister’s murder and grows closer to his father. He also looks to Lindsey for his needs rather than to his mother. Abigail and Jack become further estranged, unable to find comfort in each other. Whereas Jack turns to his living children, Lindsey and Buckley, to help assuage his grief, Abigail finds solace in her relationship with Len and in private reverie. Although he no longer talks about his certainty that Harvey killed Susie, Jack has not given up that belief, a fact he shares with Lindsey. Lindsey wonders why Fenerman has not arrested him. Jack explains that the police have found no real evidence linking their neighbor to the murder. Lindsey understands the importance of finding something tangible of Susie’s in Harvey’s house. Grandma Lynn arrives for Thanksgiving. She quickly picks up on Abigail’s affair with Fenerman and also understands that Abigail wants to leave her family. Abigail and Lynn go for a walk and share a rare mother-daughter conversation. Lynn seems to understand more clearly Abigail’s desires and disappointments. Lindsey decides to search Harvey’s house. She watches and plans, and when she sees him leave, she breaks a basement window, enters the house, and begins the search. As Susie watches Lindsey in the house, she sees what Lindsey sees and also sees Harvey’s previous victims. While Susie finds supernatural evidence of Harvey’s crimes, Lindsey finds tangible evidence linking him to Susie’s murder—drawings of the hole in the cornfield with ‘‘Stolfuz cornfield’’ written on one of them. Harvey arrives home while Lindsey continues her search. Despite her caution, he hears her in the upstairs bedroom. Lindsey escapes through the window, but he glimpses her leaving his yard—catching the number on her soccer jersey—and he knows it is Lindsey. When Lindsey returns home, she finds her parents and Samuel frantic over her late arrival. She tells her father about breaking into Harvey’s house and shows him what she found. In heaven, Susie meets the other girls Harvey has murdered. Before calling the police, Harvey hides the knife he used to kill Susie and the charms he took from his other victims. As the police talk with Harvey about the break-in, Jack phones Fenerman, but he is not there. At Harvey’s house, the officers seem satisfied with his account of events. Harvey does not, however, mention the stolen drawings. When the officers
1 3 2
L i t e r a r y
bring them to his attention, Harvey offers the explanation that he was trying to figure out how Susie’s murder occurred. While Jack tries to reach Fenerman and the police talk with Mr. Harvey, Abigail meets Fenerman for a rendezvous, thus the detective misses the call that would have put him on Harvey’s trail. Shaken by the break-in and understanding the implications of the drawings Lindsey took of the hole in the cornfield, Harvey packs up and leaves the area. By the one–year anniversary of Susie’s death, Ray and Ruth’s friendship deepens, moving beyond a platonic attachment to one that includes some degree of physical intimacy. The two friends decide to commemorate Susie’s death with a visit to the cornfield. When they arrive, they find Samuel and his brother Hal already there. Shortly, neighbors gather at the site of Susie’s murder. Some bring candles, lighting up the evening with an impromptu memorial. When Lindsey notices the lights in the cornfield, she urges her mother to attend. Abigail declines, and in the ensuing conversation with her mother, Lindsey realizes her mother plans to leave the family. Lindsey, Buckley, and Jack join their friends and neighbors in the cornfield.
‘‘Snapshots’’ As time progresses, Susie watches the lives of those on earth unfold: Abigail leaves Pennsylvania, ultimately for California; Grandma Lynn comes to stay; Lindsey learns of Abigail and Fenerman’s relationship; Buckley must now deal with the loss of his mother. Samuel’s brother, Hal, using his biker connections, gets a lead on Harvey, which he passes on to Fenerman. The police are finally able to prove Harvey’s guilt, but he has vanished and Fenerman feels tremendous guilt for not having listened to Jack. Ray goes to Penn State University to study medicine, and Ruth moves to New York, taking up a bohemian life, certain that she possess a psychic connection with murdered women and children.
Chapters 17–20 Lindsey and Samuel graduate from Temple University in Philadelphia. Caught in a rainstorm on their motorcycle ride home from the ceremony, they find an abandoned house, where Samuel proposes to Lindsey.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
Buckley, now in seventh grade, uses old clothes he found in the basement to tie his tomato plants to their stakes. As Jack watches, he recognizes the clothes as Susie’s and forbids his son to use them. Buckley lashes out at his father, accusing him of putting the dead Susie before both his living children. As father and son argue, Jack suffers a heart attack. Jack hovers between life and death, with Susie wishing him to join her in her heaven and Buckley holding him to earth. As Susie turns from the events on earth, she meets her paternal grandfather in her heaven; they dance together. Abigail flies home to be with Jack in the hospital. Lindsey, Samuel, and Buckley meet her at the airport. Having not seen her children for almost a decade, Abigail is apprehensive. The reunion is strained, with Lindsey cautious and Buckley angry. Her reunion with Jack proves as tenuous as the first meeting with her children. Abigail struggles with the decision to return to California or to stay with her family. Her introspection reveals that she left because of her inability to cope with the guilt generated by Susie’s death. She realizes she does indeed love Jack and her children and decides to stay. Jack begins to understand he must accept Abigail for who she is. Finally able to talk about Susie, Jack and Abigail cry together.
Chapters 21–23 Ray and Ruth both return home and go to the sinkhole, which is scheduled to be filled and paved over. Harvey also makes his way back to his old neighborhood, hoping to kill Lindsey. He, too, heads for the sinkhole. While at the sinkhole, Susie’s presence overwhelms Ruth, and Susie falls to earth and into Ruth’s body. In the meantime, police have recovered Susie’s keystone charm at a Connecticut murder site; Fenerman returns the charm to Jack and Abigail.
L o v e l y
B o n e s
MEDIA ADAPTATIONS
Recorded Books published an unabridged edition of The Lovely Bones on audio CD in August 2002.
and Ruth try to make sense of the events that occur. Susie finally lets go of her family, even though she will always watch over them. Jack leaves the hospital. Individually, the Salmons have each confronted his or her grief, guilt, anger, and fear, thus making it possible for them to reconstruct the family unit. Together and separately, they move beyond Susie’s death.
‘‘Bones’’ The lives of the dead integrate into the lives of the living. Susie’s family members cannot and do not forget her, nor do they allow their memories of her to keep them from moving on. Harvey finally gets justice when he is hit by a falling icicle and falls unconscious into a ravine, where falling snow covers his body.
CHARACTERS Clarissa Clarissa is Susie’s best friend. Her clandestine meeting in the cornfield with her boyfriend, Brian, leads to Brian’s attack on Jack.
Ruth Connors
As Susie inhabits Ruth’s body, Ruth leaves the earth. Ray senses a change in Ruth and comes to believe that somehow Ruth has become Susie or vice versa. Susie, using Ruth’s body, finally experiences the culmination of a developing sexuality as she and Ray make love. Although Susie must once again leave the earth, this time her leave-taking proves gentle and gradual instead of violent and abrupt. Ray
Ruth, the girl Susie inadvertently brushes against as the she departs earth, is artistic and poetic with a feminist sensibility, existing on the fringes of junior high and high school society. She moves to New York after graduation, living a bohemian life of writing poetry, communing with Susie, and recording in her journal the deaths of women and children, deaths that she sees in dreams and visions. Because of her psychic connection to the spirit of murdered women
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 3 3
T h e
L o v e l y
B o n e s
and children, Ruth provides the means for Susie to revisit earth and consummate her relationship with Ray. Ruth also develops and maintains a strong friendship with Ray.
Detective Len Fenerman Len Fenerman is the lead detective on Susie’s murder case. A small but tenacious man, Fenerman believes that he will find Susie’s killer. He understands the horror of unexplained death, as his wife committed suicide. Fenerman carries Susie’s picture, as well as the pictures of victims of unsolved murder cases, in his wallet. Although he knows that he should not give in to his feelings for Abigail, he eventually begins an affair with her. Because of his cautiousness regarding Harvey, Susie’s killer, Fenerman fails to arrest him. This failure haunts the detective, and he must bear the guilt of his decisions.
Samuel is Lindsey’s childhood sweetheart and eventually marries her. Samuel helps Lindsey cope with her sister’s death, her mother’s abandonment, and her father’s heart attack. Samuel, along with his brother, Hal, becomes an integral part of the Salmon family. He and Hal treat Buckley, Lindsey’s little brother, like their own brother. Samuel loves carpentry and restoring old houses, a passion that he turns into a career. This passion for fixing broken and battered things parallels his ability to alleviate Lindsey’s pain, name Jack’s overprotectiveness, and deflect Buckley’s anger.
Holly Holly is Susie’s roommate in heaven. Although she and Susie share much of their heaven, Holly also has a heaven to which Susie has no access. Holly helps Susie understand heaven.
Grandma Lynn
Franny Franny, a social worker on earth, is Susie’s intake counselor in heaven. She also serves as a surrogate mother.
George Harvey George Harvey, a thirty-six-year-old single man, is a serial killer who rapes and murders Susie. Although considered odd by his neighbors, Harvey does not draw attention to himself. He builds dollhouses and possesses a fascination with buildings. Taught to steal by his mother and then abandoned by her, and raised by a tyrannical father, Harvey lacks both a conscience and social skills. He fits the profile of a sociopath, reliving the murders in his mind, deriving intense pleasure from the killings, and taking trophies from his victims. When Lindsey breaks into his house and takes evidence linking him to Susie’s murder, Mr. Harvey’s ordered world begins to disintegrate. He leaves town, eventually coming back determined to kill Lindsey, but a combination of circumstances prevent him from doing so.
Hal Heckler Hal is Samuel’s older brother. He rides and repairs motorcycles. After Harvey’s disappearance, Hal uses his network of biker friends to search for him. Hal eventually passes on some key information to Detective Fenerman.
1 3 4
Samuel Heckler
L i t e r a r y
Grandma Lynn, Susie’s grandmother and Abigail’s mother, is eccentric, colorful and drinks too much. Prior to Susie’s murder, her visits to the Salmon’s upended routines and delighted her grandchildren. Not overly motherly, Lynn has a strained relationship with her daughter. When Abigail leaves, Lynn provides the stability that keeps the family together. She helps Lindsey grow into womanhood, and she helps Buckley negotiate his anger and hurt.
Brian Nelson Brian is Clarissa’s boyfriend. He beats Mr. Salmon with a baseball bat when he mistakenly thinks that Susie’s father is attacking Clarissa in the cornfield.
Abigail Salmon Abigail is Susie’s mother. She is college educated, with a master’s degree in literature and aspirations to teach. In the early years of her marriage to Jack, Abigail possessed a passionate nature but found that the demands of motherhood pulled her away from her husband and from her own dreams. As her family grew, Abigail became less involved with her children and husband. Nevertheless, Susie’s death unsettles her, and she finds no outlet for her grief. She embarks on an affair with Detective Fenerman but does not love him. Her need to find herself, reclaim her place in the world as an individual,
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
and escape her intense grief propel her to relocate to California. There she seems to find some solace, working in a vineyard and leaving motherhood and wifehood behind. However, she comes to realize that she can leave neither of those things, and when she returns to Pennsylvania, she also realizes that she viewed Susie’s death as punishment for own failings as a mother. This understanding allows her to rebuild her relationship with her husband and with her children. These things do not prove easy, but Abigail does reclaim her position within the family, albeit a changed family— reconfigured by Susie’s absence as well as by Abigail’s.
Buckley Salmon Buckley is the youngest of the three Salmon children. He is four years old at the time of Susie’s murder and seven years old when his mother leaves. These two events force Buckley to develop emotional defenses in order to survive the pain of abandonment. He believes that he has supernatural encounters with Susie. Both Grandma Lynn and Lindsey act as maternal surrogates, and Buckley develops a close relationship with his father. As he matures, he becomes protective of his father and of Lindsey. When Abigail returns, Buckley is hateful, sullen, and very angry.
L o v e l y
B o n e s
family, he must loosen the bonds, and he does what the living must do in order to go on living— let go of the dead. In addition, Jack does what parents must do: let go of their children. Jack can make these moves only after he turns inward and faces his own fears and weaknesses.
Lindsey Salmon Lindsey is the middle child of the three Salmon children. Bright, articulate, athletic, blonde, and pretty, Lindsey, one year younger than Susie, is amazingly close to her sister, so Susie’s death leaves a deep void in Lindsey’s life. However, she refuses to be the dead girl’s sister, the living daughter, the reminder of the missing girl. Lindsey struggles through the ordinary traumas of adolescence, but Susie’s murder, Abigail’s distance, Jack’s need to find the killer, and Buckley’s dependence all complicate the process for her. With Grandma Lynn’s help, Samuel’s devotion, and her own determination, Lindsey develops into a strong young woman, and she risks her own safety in order to find proof of Harvey’s guilt. Lindsey does not, however, betray her dreams. Unlike her mother, she follows her aspirations. She graduates from college, gets an advanced degree, and takes up a career. Although Lindsey never leaves Susie behind, she does move beyond Susie’s death.
Susie Salmon Jack Salmon Jack is Susie’s father. In the aftermath of her murder, Jack deals not only with his own grief and anger but also seeks to assuage Lindsey’s emotions and protect Buckley from the hurt. Like Abigail, Jack must also work through some guilt generated by his daughter’s death. He questions his position as father and protector when he realizes that he was not there to save his little girl. His frustration at this failure fuels his need to be active in the police investigation. Jack cannot remain passive as the police fail to develop leads. He never wavers in his conviction that Mr. Harvey murdered Susie, and once the police disregard his theories, Jack turns to Lindsey, sharing his thoughts with her. Despite his closeness to Lindsey and Buckley, Jack retains a strong connection to Susie, feeling her presence, talking to her, refusing to let her place in his family’s life fade. Whereas Abigail withdraws into almost a state of indifference, Jack builds ties that may bind too tightly. Finally, Jack understands that in order to have a strong
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
Susie, the narrator, is a fourteen-year-old girl and the eldest of the three Salmon children. She is raped and murdered by her neighbor, Mr. Harvey, as she walks home from junior high. Susie is spunky and curious, a dreamer with a desire to be a wildlife photographer, and looks forward to high school and to growing up. Susie shares a special relationship with her father—helping him to build ships in a bottle. She and sister Lindsey are close, and she plays mother hen to little brother Buckley. Susie adores her mother and seems to understand her mother’s need for privacy. Seldom is Susie a direct participant in the action; usually, she observes and reflects. Sometimes, however, she makes her presence known to the living—in the shards of glass from her father’s broken ships in a bottle, in a dim appearance at a family gathering, in the body of Ruth Connors. She is with Lindsey as she searches Mr. Harvey’s house, leading her sister into the upstairs rooms. In addition, much of the action takes place because of
V o l u m e
1
1 3 5
T h e
L o v e l y
B o n e s
someone’s longing for, search for, or love for Susie. So, indirectly, Susie influences individual decisions and outcomes. Just as Lindsey must figure out how to grow up—what it means to live, Susie must figure out what it means not to grow up—what it means to be dead. She learns that like the living, she, too, must journey. Susie also learns that the dead, like the living, must let go, not easy for a girl who wants so desperately to live. Susie does return to earth. She falls into Ruth’s body, initiated partly by Susie’s longing to kiss Ray one more time and see where that kiss would lead, and also by Ruth’s desire to understand the dead, to see them. Ruth desires to leave earth, and Susie desires to return. After this incident, Susie watches with love and pleasure as her family reconfigures into a new family, one that does and does not include her.
Ray Singh Ray is the boy with whom Susie shares her first kiss. Born in India and raised in England until his family moved to the United States, Ray is dark skinned and well-spoken. He writes Susie a love letter that she never gets to read. This letter, which the police find in the cornfield, initially leads them to suspect Ray of the murder. Like Ruth, Ray inhabits the periphery of junior high society. He finds himself drawn to Ruth’s quirkiness, her love of art and literature, and her connection to Susie. Together, Ray and Ruth speculate about Susie’s murder. Ray maintains a close relationship with Ruth throughout high school as well as after graduation, when he goes to Penn State and Ruth to New York. Susie longs for Ray as she watches him from heaven. When she returns to earth in Ruth’s body, Ray recognizes the change in Ruth, calling her Susie. He makes love to her, and he asks her to tell him about heaven. This encounter affects Ray when he begins to practice medicine; he refuses to consider only medical or scientific explanations regarding death.
Ruana Singh Ruana is Ray’s mother. She is an exotic personality, dignified and calm when the police question her son about Susie’s murder. Ruana possesses deep empathy for the Salmons, and she plays an important role in Jack’s determination to avenge Susie’s death. Ruana listens to his theories regarding Mr. Harvey and legitimizes
1 3 6
L i t e r a r y
Jack’s desire for revenge. Before Abigail leaves, the two women share a moment together, and Ruana understands Abigail’s feeling of isolation. After Abigail leaves, Ruana often bakes apple pies for the Salmons, which she has Ray deliver.
THEMES Loss and Grief Loss of a loved one and the stages of mourning or grief manifest as overriding themes in The Lovely Bones. Through the voice of Susie Salmon, the fourteen-year-old narrator of the novel, readers get an in-depth look at the grieving process. Susie focuses more on the aftermath and effects of her murder and rape on her family rather than on the event itself. She watches her parents and sister move through the five stages of grief: denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and acceptance. However, Alice Sebold makes clear that these categories do not necessarily remain rigid and that individuals deal with grief in various ways. For example, Abigail, Susie’s mother, withdraws from her living children, Lindsey and Buckley, whereas Jack, her husband, draws closer to them. Lindsey, Susie’s sister, vacillates between denial and acceptance, sometimes exhibiting both elements simultaneously. In addition, Sebold expands the definitions of both loss and grief by including Susie herself in the process. If readers limit their understanding of grief to losing and coping with the death of a loved one, then they have trouble accounting for Susie’s emotions. She mourns her own death and the missed opportunity of getting to grow up, but more significantly, Susie grieves over the loss of living people. In other words, the novel extends the grieving process to include the dead themselves. By including Susie in this process and having Abigail leave the family, Sebold investigates the nature of loss and its relationship to grief. The novel suggests change equals loss, which in turn initiates grief. While Susie’s death emerges as the most blatant change in the lives of the Salmons, other significant changes also occur. Lindsey changes from adolescent to adult; Buckley changes from child to adolescent; Jack changes from a man secure in his place in the family to one questioning his ability to hold the family together; and Abigail changes from a woman
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
questioning her position as wife and mother to one who redefines and then embraces that position. While each of these changes generates a sense of loss, ultimately each character moves on from the loss and grief. In The Lovely Bones, both the living and dead learn letting go opens up possibilities.
Life and Death On some level, all literature investigates the nature of human experience or the human condition. Certainly life and death constitute the two most significant experiences of being human, and as such, much literature deals with these two issues. The Lovely Bones pointedly asks two questions: ‘‘What does it mean to be alive?’’ and ‘‘What does it mean to be dead?’’ As Susie learns what being dead means, she must deal with what being alive means as well. The fact she can no longer experience the physical world—that she can no longer experience living—emerges as her biggest disappointment. The novel then offers experiencing the physical as an attribute of living. Although denied this aspect of living, the dead Susie can engage in the human condition of wanting, wishing, and desiring. Thus Sebold blurs the lines between what constitutes life and death. Susie clearly understands she is dead. She knows she inhabits a realm different from earth, but in many ways, not completely separate from it. After all, Susie’s heaven looks earthly, not celestial, and she participates in activities that associate much more closely with earth than heaven: eating ice cream, romping with dogs, living in a duplex. The novel presents life as a series of changes, all of which involve the body and the physical environment—physicality seems the defining characteristic of life. The event that allows Susie to move on in her heaven, or to move on in death, is her return to earth. Although she has ‘‘returned’’ in a disembodied form, when she inhabits Ruth’s body, Susie ‘‘realize[s] that the marvelous weight weighing [her] down was the weight of the human body.’’ Yet Susie understands the temporariness of this corporality, but perhaps that realization is precisely one of Sebold’s points.
L o v e l y
B o n e s
of knowledge and experience. In many of these novels, the move into adulthood includes a loss of innocence or the destruction of a false sense of security. The protagonist often experiences a shift from ignorance to knowledge, innocence to experience, idealism to realism, or immaturity to maturity. In addition, coming of age involves rituals or rites of passage. The Lovely Bones focuses on these issues as the author explores the process of growing up. The novel begins when Lindsey Salmon is thirteen years old and ends almost ten years later, with Lindsey as wife and mother. It traces her move through the routines and events of female adolescence—first kisses, shaving of legs, makeup, summer camp, love, friendship, college. The novel, however, also traces Susie’s coming of age. By presenting the development of a dead girl along with a living one, Sebold imbues the experiences of growing up with enhanced significance. Susie cannot move on in death until she finishes ‘‘growing up.’’ Susie’s rape and murder hastens the process of moving from innocence to experience for both girls. Susie learns her suburban and rather ordinary world is not safe—men murder children in this world. She moves swiftly and violently from innocence to experience, and from idealism to realism. Yet this shift does not culminate in her ‘‘coming of age;’’ rather, it initiates a need for her to experience these things more slowly and more naturally. While Susie’s death also hastens Lindsey’s loss of innocence, it does so less dramatically. Although Lindsey understands that her world is not particularly safe, that bad people exist and that these people do bad things, she still participates in the normal rituals of growing up.
The coming-of-age novel involves the initiation of the protagonist into adulthood. This initiation usually occurs through the acquisition
Like many teenage girls, Lindsey experiments with makeup and with finding a style that suits her. She experiences a tender first kiss with Samuel, and they move slowly through the rituals of courtship. She grows into her sexuality, developing a relationship based on trust, gentleness, and understanding. However, Susie’s murder, combined with her mother’s absence, pushes Lindsey into adult roles early in her life. So while acknowledging the naturalness of growing up, Sebold also contextualizes that experience. In The Lovely Bones, moving from a place of innocence to one of knowledge can occur violently and abruptly. Coming of age can happen in circumstances that circumvent the normal, perhaps suggesting a need to rethink normal.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
Coming of Age and Rites of Passage
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 3 7
T h e
L o v e l y
B o n e s
STYLE Point of View
TOPICS FOR FURTHER STUDY Elisabeth Ku¨bler-Ross, M.D., developed the five-stage grief model, which outlines and defines the stages that a grieving person goes through while healing. Research this model, list and define the five terms, then write an essay explaining how Jack Salmon, Abigail Salmon, and Susie Salmon in Alice Sebold’s The Lovely Bones progress through each stage. What would have happened if Susie were never killed by Mr. Harvey? Knowing what you do about her desires, interests, and goals, do you think Susie’s life would have turned out more like Abigail’s or Lindsey’s? Would Susie have married Ray, or lived a bohemian life in the city like Ruth? Write a short biography of Susie’s life, including her family, that addresses who Susie might have been if she had not been murdered at age fourteen.
1 3 8
Using some historical research on the Women’s Movement in the 1970s, explain how Abigail Salmon, Lindsey Salmon, Ruth Connors, and Ruana Singh in Sebold’s The Lovely Bones exemplify elements of that movement. In other words, what aspect of the Women’s Movement does each of these women illustrate? Write an essay incorporating your research into your explanation.
One can easily read Sebold’s The Lovely Bones as a coming-of-age story. Identify which characters ‘‘come of age’’ and why. What does the novel offer as the rites of passage for growing up? Do these rites seem bound by the time frame of the novel? In an essay, compare the rites and rituals of adolescence presented in The Lovely Bones with those of today’s teenagers. Try to account for any differences by addressing relevant cultural, political, or social issues.
L i t e r a r y
In The Lovely Bones, point of view, the perspective from which the story is told, plays a crucial role in the narrative. Generally, a novel’s point of view consists of one of four traditional stances: first person, second person, third person, and third person omniscient. First person point of view presents the events of the story from the perception of a single character. Second person point of view involves the author telling the story as if it is happening to the reader. With third person point of view, the reader has no insight into the character’s minds; therefore, he or she must make sense of the action as it takes place. Third person omniscient offers a ‘‘godlike’’ perspective, transcending time or place, allowing the reader to see the actions and to look into the minds of the characters to know their thoughts, feelings and motives. Alice Sebold presents a story told from an omniscient first person point of view, the perspective of Susie Salmon, who is dead. Susie, from her vantage point in heaven, sees everything—actions, motivations, thoughts—so her narration functions like third person omniscient, except that she tells the story in first person. Susie’s access to the minds of other characters provides readers with this same access. In addition, as an omniscient first person narrator telling the story from beyond the limitations of earthly time, she also can and does experience many of the characters’ memories. For example, she sees and relates incidents from her killer, Mr. Harvey’s, childhood and his past killings. Because of her omniscience, Susie often glimpses intensely personal thoughts and actions, such as her mother’s first tryst with Detective Fenerman, or her mother’s internal thoughts about motherhood. This combination of third person omniscient and first person points of view proves an innovative move on Sebold’s part. Few novels offer the perspective of a dead protagonist— especially one who has been brutally raped and murdered. However, this new point of view makes the disturbing subject matter bearable and also allows Sebold to inject some humor and lightness into a rather horrifying story. Because she sees everything and because she relates what she sees, Susie provides the reader with opportunities to sympathize and or identify
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
with various characters. In addition, because this omniscient viewpoint filters through a first person or personal voice, it also emerges as a specific perspective: sometimes angry, sometimes confused, sometimes spunky, and sometimes humorous, which carries with it a distinctive personality.
Setting Setting includes the time, place, and culture in which the action of the narrative takes place. Time and place emerge as crucial elements in understanding the setting in The Lovely Bones. Traditionally, time can involve three elements: historical period, duration, and the perception of time by the characters. Sebold uses dates at various points throughout the narrative; in fact, the novel opens with a specific date, December 6, 1973. Immediately, the reader understands the historical time—the early 1970s—as well as the seasonal time—winter. However, as the story progresses, the historical periods shift as Susie takes the reader into the past and alludes to the future. For example, after giving us the date of her death, she offers a contemporary reference to the pictures of missing children on milk cartons and in the daily mail. This reference raises questions regarding the time period from which Susie is telling the story. Sebold’s use of time shifts— the narration slides among past, present, and future—ties very closely to elements of place. Like the shifts in time, the location of the story shifts between heaven and earth. Most of the action itself occurs on earth with the telling occurring in heaven. Some action does, however, take place in heaven: Susie meets Mr. Harvey’s other victims in heaven; she and her roommate, Holly, explore; she dances with her grandfather. However, these actions do not necessarily propel the plot (the pattern of carefully selected events), but they do expand the story (all the events which are to be depicted). Both place and time closely relate to the coming-of-age element in the book, as well as to the themes of loss and grief.
L o v e l y
B o n e s
the use of flashback, a device that offers actions that occurred before the beginning of the story. Once Sebold establishes the murder, she has Susie look backward to how the murder occurred. As with point of view and setting, Sebold also complicates the traditional idea of plot. For example, in chapter one, Susie discusses her murder and includes a detail about a neighborhood dog finding her elbow and bringing it home. However, the actual incident of the dog finding the elbow and the police telling her parents about it occurs weeks after the murder. These occurrences in the story are moments of foreshadowing, which create expectation. Through the use of flashback and foreshadowing, Sebold veers away from a strictly chronological unfolding of events; rather, plot becomes more circular even while the narrative progressive chronologically through the 1970s.
HISTORICAL CONTEXT Alice Sebold wrote The Lovely Bones in the late 1990s; the book first appeared in print in June 2002; and the story takes place in the 1970s. All of these dates prove significant. At the time of the writing, America was facing both a new decade and a new millennium. By the late 1990s, Americans saw the creation of the World Wide Web; engaged in debates over health care, social security reform, gun control; watched national sex scandals unfold (the Tailhook affair and the Bill Clinton/Monica Lewinski affair); sat riveted to the O. J. Simpson murder trial; and were stunned by the violence of the 1999 shooting at Columbine High School in Colorado. Sebold penned her story amid a growing awareness of, and concern with, issues of domestic, sexual, and teen violence. In many ways, her novel reflects these concerns as it reflects the cultural climate of the 1990s.
For the most part, Sebold’s novel follows the traditional structure of plot. However, the events do not necessarily unfold in chronological fashion. For instance, the novel opens with Susie’s murder, and as events unfold, establishes a relationship between events. To understand the causality, the reader needs background information, which Sebold presents through
Its publication date, however, carries added significance. The novel, released less than a year after the September 11, 2001, attacks on the World Trade Center in New York and the Pentagon in Washington D.C., speaks directly to a nation’s need for comfort. The Lovely Bones made its debut in an America forever stripped of its belief that terrorism and random violence happens elsewhere. The social and cultural atmosphere at this time radiated fear, distrust, sadness, anger, and grief. Although Sebold
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
Foreshadowing and Flashback
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 3 9
T h e
L o v e l y
B o n e s
wrote this novel before the attacks, the subject matter echoes the contemporaneous concerns of America. The novel also draws on the historical, cultural, social, and political issues of the 1970s. In many ways, America ‘‘came of age’’ in the 1970s as social change, discontent with the government, advances in civil rights for minorities and women, environmental concerns, and space exploration defined the decade. The Vietnam War, which sparked antiwar protests and student demonstrations, and the Watergate Scandal, which resulted in the resignation of a president, shattered the last vestiges of a naive America. Other changes arose in the 1970s that added to America’s cultural and social climate, including the women’s movement. Women’s places in American life expanded into political and professional areas, and people began to question the traditional gender roles of women and men. The changes of the 1970s figure into The Lovely Bones in several ways: first, through Sebold’s female characters. Ruth Connors embodies the feminism of the 1970s with her avant-garde approach to her drawings, poetry, and reading. She refuses the constraints of the status quo in these areas as well as in the arena of acceptably feminine behavior and attire. However, whereas Ruth overtly embraces feminism, Susie’s mother, Abigail, struggles to name her discontent. Abigail illustrates many of the women in the 1970s who did not publicly espouse feminism, yet whose desire to transcend the constraints of motherhood and wifehood drew on feminist principles. Secondly, the novel reflects the 1970s concern with the environment through the encroachment of building and industry into the Salmons’ suburban neighborhood. Finally, the disturbing subject matter of a child’s rape and murder, and Susie’s refusal to sanitize the images of her death reflect the horrific pictures of the dead and dismembered of the Vietnam War. During the 1970s, images of violence entered the homes of suburban Americans through the television, and for the first time, Americans watched a war—complete with all of its horrors—from their living rooms. In The Lovely Bones, the tangible marks of violence that enter suburbia are not media images of war dead; rather, those marks are the objects of a raped and murdered girl.
1 4 0
L i t e r a r y
CRITICAL OVERVIEW The Lovely Bones enjoyed immediate popular success from the time of its publication. The novel, published in June 2002, topped the New York Times bestseller list that summer. Prior its publication, as Charlotte Abbot notes in Publishers Weekly, bestselling author Anna Quindlen told viewers of the Today Show, ‘‘If you read one book this summer, it should be The Lovely Bones by Alice Sebold. It’s destined to be a classic along the lines of To Kill a Mockingbird, and it’s one of the best books I’ve read in years.’’ For the most part, the novel garnered excellent reviews after its publications, with critics praising the first person omniscient point of view and the stunning opening pages. In a review for Christian Century, Stephen H. Webb argues that Sebold’s reworked point of view ‘‘is the only way to fully comprehend such an intolerable tragedy [the rape and murder of a fourteen-year-old girl].’’ Writing for the London Review of Books, Rebecca Mead deems Susie ‘‘a bright and ironical observer,’’ and Michiko Kakutani, in her front-page review of The Lovely Bones in the New York Times, points out that the narrator possesses a ‘‘matter-of-fact charm.’’ Finally, in his review in the Christian Science Monitor, Ron Charles writes, ‘‘The power of The Lovely Bones flows from this voice, a voice at once charmingly adolescent and tragically mature.’’ Most reviewers identify Susie’s voice as one of the novel’s strong points. Critics also agree on another of the novel’s strengths: the opening pages. Even unfavorable reviews praised Sebold’s compelling opening. In Daniel Mendelsohn’s review in the New York Review of Books, he likens the novel to TV movies of the week—artificial, contrived, and lightweight. However, Mendelsohn also writes, ‘‘The novel begins strikingly. . . . The few pages that follow . . . are the best in the book,’’ and he praises the authenticity of these pages. Writing for the Guardian, Ali Smith slams The Lovely Bones for its timidity and sentimentality, but finds ‘‘the opening chapters . . . shattering and dazzling in their mix of horror and normality.’’ Despite a handful of negative reviews, the novel has been the ‘‘breakout fiction debut of the year’’ that Lev Grossman predicted in the book section of the July 1, 2002, edition of Time magazine.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
L o v e l y
B o n e s
CRITICISM Catherine Cucinella Catherine Cucinella, a freelance writer, has edited a reference volume on contemporary American poets and has published articles on poetry and film. She has a Ph.D. in English from the University of California, Riverside. In this essay, Cucinella analyzes the effects of domestic ideologies on the mother-daughter relationships in The Lovely Bones.
Icicles on a cabin Ó Nik Wheeler/Corbis
Sebold’s novel does, however, exhibit some weaknesses, and even her most ardent admirers recognize them. Kakutani comments that Sebold stumbles in the ‘‘highly abstract musing on Susie belonging to a historical continuum of murdered girls and women,’’ and this critic finds the scenes dealing with Susie’s classmate, Ruth Connor’s, ‘‘belief that she can . . . channel Susie’s feelings’’ unconvincing. Other critics find troubling Susie’s return to earth, which Sarah Churchwell of the Times Literary Supplement calls ‘‘a false move that violates the contract of willingly suspended disbelief.’’ Overall, critics believe that the novel’s strengths outshine its weak moments. In her Washington Post review, Maria Russo considers The Lovely Bones ‘‘utterly original and deeply affecting,’’ and she asserts that Sebold ‘‘manages to put her readers into contact with a throbbing pulse of life.’’ Sebold, says Russo, ‘‘has an unusual flair for both owning and transforming dark material.’’ Katherine Bouton of the New York Times Book Review concurs. Sebold, she writes, ‘‘deals with almost unthinkable subjects with humor and intelligence and a kind of mysterious grace.’’
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
Although The Lovely Bones has garnered many reviews, critical work on the novel proves scarce. Most reviewers and critics comment on Sebold’s innovative use of point of view, the omniscient first person narrator, Susie Salmon. These same critics point to Sebold’s mastery in presenting a disturbing subject—the rape and murder of a young girl. More often than not, however, the unsettling elements in the text involve issues of motherhood and mothering. Through her depiction of mothers and daughters, Sebold examines the effects of patriarchy and domesticity on women. The Lovely Bones questions the roles and demands placed on women by society as it presents the consequences that arise for mothers and daughters if these roles and demands remain unexamined. Sebold examines the dictates of patriarchy, the social system in which the father is the head of the family and men govern women and children; and domesticity, the devotion to home life. This examination of the place of women unfolds primarily through the first person omniscient narration, characterization, and through the motif (recurring images in a literary work) of confined spaces. Although the restrictive systems under which each woman must live come to light in The Lovely Bones, the novel makes clear that recognizing these restrictions begins the process of loosening them. Susie’s omniscient perspective affords the reader the opportunity to watch as the Salmon women work through that process. From her heaven, Susie provides insight into the internal thoughts of all the characters. Susie’s insights work within the narrative itself, offering Susie the opportunity to experience the move from girlhood to womanhood. Significantly, the internal musings to which Susie is privy involve her mother’s struggle with feelings of discontent, a discontent that feminist Betty Friedan labeled ‘‘the feminine mystique.’’ According to Friedan,
V o l u m e
1
1 4 1
T h e
L o v e l y
B o n e s
THROUGH HER DEPICTION OF MOTHERS AND DAUGHTERS, SEBOLD EXAMINES THE EFFECTS OF PATRIARCHY AND DOMESTICITY ON WOMEN. THE LOVELY BONES QUESTIONS THE ROLES AND DEMANDS PLACED ON WOMEN BY SOCIETY AS IT PRESENTS THE CONSEQUENCES THAT ARISE FOR MOTHERS AND DAUGHTERS IF THESE ROLES AND DEMANDS REMAIN UNEXAMINED.’’
‘‘a strange discrepancy [exists] between the reality of [women’s] lives as women and the image to which [women are] trying to conform.’’ Abigail Salmon, Susie’s mother, provides the clearest example of this ‘‘schizophrenic split’’ and its consequences. On the morning of her eleventh birthday, Susie, awake before the rest of the family, discovers her unwrapped birthday present, an Instamatic camera. Eager to use it she, she hurries to the back of the house and finds the back door open. There in the backyard, Susie comes upon her mother, unaware of her daughter’s presence. Susie narrates: I had never seen her sitting so still, so not there somehow. . . . That morning there were no lipstick marks because there was no lipstick until she put it on for . . . who? I had never thought to ask that question. My father? Us?
Because Susie retells this incident from her heavenly vantage point, she can now read significance into it. Her status as omniscient first person narrator allows her insight that she may or may not have possessed when the incident first occurred. After all, Susie’s narration unfolds after all events have taken place. Significantly, however, Susie makes clear the split between the private, unencumbered Abigail and the woman who assumes a face for the world. Susie’s camera captures this moment, and the picture glaringly reveals the split to which Freidan refers:
1 4 2
L i t e r a r y
When the roll came back from the Kodak plant . . . I could see the difference immediately. There was only one picture in which my mother was Abigail. It was that first one, the one taken of her unawares, the one captured before the click startled her into the mother of the birthday girl, owner of the happy dog, wife to a loving man, and mother again to another girl and a cherished boy. Homemaker. Gardner. Sunny neighbor.
Thus, Susie catches her mother in the moment before Abigail conforms to an image. This passage further delineates the roles expected of women as it makes clear that Abigail held part of herself apart from those roles. As the narrative progresses, Susie watches and narrates her mother’s struggle to reconcile the need for autonomy with the demands of motherhood and wifehood. Susie’s murder initiates much of Abigail’s unrest. Her grief and unacknowledged guilt over her daughter’s death seem to suffocate Abigail, causing her to withdraw from her husband and children. However, this feeling of confinement predates the murder. As a young wife and new mother, Abigail saw the withering of her dreams: ‘‘the stack of books on [the] beside table changed from catalogs for local colleges, encyclopedias of mythology, novels by James, Eliot, and Dickens, to the works of Dr. Spock.’’ The birth of her third child, Buckley, pushes Abigail further away from the woman who earned a master’s degree in literature, who read philosophy, and who aspired to teach at the college level. She found that she could not ‘‘have it all;’’ she could not even remain in love with her husband. Susie observes poignantly that her parents ‘‘had been deeply, separately, wholly in love— apart from her children [her] mother could reclaim this love, but with them she began to drift.’’ The narrative time in The Lovely Bones spans the 1970s; however, Abigail herself came of age in earlier decades, and she took on the role of new wife and mother in the late 1950s. Therefore, she carries within herself the constrictions of 1950s domestic ideology, an ideology that, according to Nancy Woloch in Women and the American Experience, ‘‘posited fulfillment within the family as a goal to which women of all classes and backgrounds might aspire.’’ In addition, the rise of the suburbs extended the demands of domesticity, an extension clearly visible in The Lovely Bones. Woloch
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
explains, ‘‘The domestic passion of the 1950s coincided with a massive exodus to the suburbs, the ideal place for raising families,’’ and federal policies such as low-interest mortgages and veteran benefits, as well as federally funded programs for highway construction, contributed to the suburban growth. These polices, according to Woloch, ‘‘promoted domestic ideals, since suburban life, for women, meant commitment to home and family, to house care and child care.’’ In addition, advertising throughout the 1950s, 1960s, and 1970s further promoted a domestic ideology. The message: domesticity equals happiness and contentment. However, as Abigail demonstrates and Freidan’s study confirms, not all women enjoyed these feelings. Instead, this domesticity pushed them into spaces of confinement and restriction. Abigail, then, fails to embrace the dictates of domestic ideology. Even before Susie’s murder, she grows distant from her children, and after the murder, she distances herself physically, as well as emotionally, from her family: avoiding Jack; eating macaroons in a downstairs bathroom hidden away from Jack, Lindsey, and Buckley; having an affair with Len Fenerman, the lead detective on Susie’s case; and finally, leaving the family. However, for Abigail, the repressive aspects of 1950s and 1960s domesticity combine with the changing position of women in the 1970s—changes brought about by second wave feminism—and with the overwhelming grief and guilt attached to Susie’s death. This grief proves just as stifling to Abigail as does her wifehood and motherhood. In California, whenever Abigail ‘‘walked inside a gift shop or cafe´ the four walls around her would begin to breathe like a lung. She would feel it then, creeping up the sides of her calves and into her gut, the onslaught, the grief coming.’’ The image of the shop breathing like a lung evokes earlier images of confinement in The Lovely Bones: the hole in the cornfield where Mr. Harvey rapes and murders Susie, the small hospital balcony where Abigail and Len first kiss, the fort where Buckley shuts himself off from the world, the closet like room in which Ruth Connors lives, the narrow hospital bed in which Abigail and Jack finally cry about Susie. The spaces of confinement that Abigail inhabits simultaneously restrict her and free her. In these places, she confronts her discontent and disappointment, in them she identifies her oppressions and weakness, and within these small spaces, she
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
L o v e l y
B o n e s
often comes to understandings. The two most significant instances of resolution occur in an airplane and in a hospital room. Susie listens to her mother’s thoughts as she flies to Pennsylvania after Jack’s heart attack, [s]he could not help but think of how, if she were a mother traveling, there would be two seats filled beside her. One for Lindsey. One for Buckley. But though she was, by definition, a mother, she had at some point ceased to be one too. She couldn’t claim that right and privilege after missing more than half a decade of their lives. She now knew that being a mother was a calling, something plenty of young girls had dreamed of being. But my mother had never had that dream, and she had been punished in the most horrible and unimaginable way for never having wanted me.
In order for Abigail to reunite with her family, she must honestly confront her feelings about motherhood, and she must come to realize that she can love her children, living and dead, without sacrificing herself. Maternal love, in and of itself, does not demand the elimination of a woman’s sense of self. As Sebold makes clear in The Lovely Bones, domesticity as constructed within patriarchy makes this demand. Abigail occupies the positions of both mother and daughter, and just as she must work through her feelings about her own mothering, she must also confront the way she was mothered. Like her daughters, Abigail felt closer to her father than to her mother, Grandma Lynn. Lynn and Abigail, though in many ways polar opposites—Lynn flamboyant and frivolous, Abigail vulnerable and serious— exhibit the same ambivalence toward motherhood. Susie provides insight into her mother and grandmother’s relationship: Grandma Lynn embarrassed my mother by insisting on wearing her used furs on walks around the block and by once attending a block party in high makeup. She would ask my mother questions until she knew who everyone was, whether or not my mother had seen the inside of their house, what the husband did for a living, what cars they drove. She made a solid catalog of the neighbors. It was a way, I now realized, to try to understand her daughter better. A misguided circling, a sad, partnerless dance.
Much later, after Susie’s death, after her almost ten-year absence from the family, after her return to Pennsylvania, Abigail accepts Lynn as Lynn: ‘‘[Abigail] was beginning to wonder how useful her scorched-earth policy had
V o l u m e
1
1 4 3
T h e
L o v e l y
B o n e s
been to her all these years. Her mother was loving if she was drunk, solid if she was vain.’’ This thought process and the realization to which it leads upend the dictates of an idealized motherhood, one generating from the limitations of a domestic ideology constructed in the 1950s and 1960s. Lynn, however, possesses little of the accepted maternal attributes. Her cooking skills run to frozen dinners, and she breezes in and out of her grandchildren’s lives, staying long enough only to upset routines. However, after Susie’s death, she comes to understand her daughter’s needs much more clearly. In a rare motherdaughter moment, Abigail confesses to Lynn the terrible loneliness she felt as a child, and Lynn realizes that Susie’s death took Abigail ‘‘inside the middle of a ground zero to which’’ nothing in the older woman’s experience ‘‘could offer her insight.’’ This realization provides the first glimmer of connection between mother and daughter. When Abigail leaves the family, Lynn moves in and assumes the maternal role. This assumption, similar to Abigail’s eventual return, succeeds because Lynn assumes the maternal role by choice, not because society demands that she does so. Unlike her earlier experience as mother, Lynn understands her motivations; thus she can mother Lindsey and Buckley without risk to her own position as an eccentric and independent woman. Just as Abigail, by understanding her feelings about her own mother, herself as mother, and motherhood in general, can take her place within the family, Susie comes to understand the connection that she shared with her mother in life. By seeing her mother’s internal conflicts and watching Abigail seek ways to erase her loneliness, disappointments, grief, and guilt, Susie realizes that she wants and needs her mother. She ‘‘hears’’ her mother calling her for dinner as Mr. Harvey rapes her; she repeatedly describes her mother’s ‘‘ocean eyes;’’ she recalls her mother’s stories; she names her mother’s loneliness and need. Referring to Franny, her intake counselor in heaven, Susie says, ‘‘Franny was old enough to be our mother—mid-forties—and it took Holly and me a while to figure out that this had been something we wanted: our mothers.’’ Letting go of the living and accepting herself as dead emerges as Susie’s major quest throughout the story; however, the need to accept her
1 4 4
L i t e r a r y
mother for who she was proves another significant task for Susie. The reconciliation between Susie’s parents makes clear the nature of acceptance. Reconciliation depends upon an unconditional acceptance. In the hospital after his heart attack, Jack wakes in the early morning hours to find Abigail sleeping, her hand in his. Susie’s omniscient position reveals her father’s thoughts: ‘‘She was here, and this time, despite all, he was going to let her be who she was.’’ Susie comes to this acceptance along with her father. Watching Abigail’s flight from and return home, Susie learns to see her relationship with her mother from outside the confining parameters of socially mandated motherhood. When Abigail can finally say aloud, ‘‘I love you, Susie,’’ Susie acknowledges, ‘‘I had heard these words so many times from my father that it shocked me now; I had been waiting, unknowingly, to hear it from my mother.’’ Susie continues, ‘‘She had needed the time to know that this love would not destroy her, and I had, I now knew, given her that time.’’ Susie’s sister, Lindsey, inhabits the middle ground in these mother-daughter configurations. Susie’s death moves Lindsey from middle child and younger daughter to older child and only living daughter. Gradually, she also moves into the position vacated by her mother. In the chaos that ensues when Jack is rushed to the hospital after being beaten in the cornfield, Abigail sees Buckley turn to his sister rather than to his mother. The maternal role falls on Lindsey. Susie observes, ‘‘My sister felt more alone than she had ever been but also more responsible. Buckley couldn’t be left by himself,’’ and after her mother leaves, Lindsey’s maternal role expands. However, unlike her mother, Lindsey does not push aside her own aspirations for family. Admittedly, Lindsey is not Buckley’s mother, but that fact does not lessen the responsibility that Lindsey bears. Whereas Abigail illustrates 1950s and 60s domestic ideology, Lindsey embodies the promises of 1970s feminism. Bright and ambitious, she takes an active role in both her home and in the investigation of her sister’s murder. When the police fail to find evidence linking Mr. Harvey to the crime, Lindsey breaks into his house and steals drawings that he made of the underground room where he killed Susie. Lindsey participates in gifted symposiums, graduates from Temple University, earns a master’s
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
L o v e l y
B o n e s
degree in counseling, and starts a career with that degree. She also marries her high school sweetheart, Samuel. Lindsey accomplishes most of these things during her mother’s absence, an absence that Lindsey saw coming. On the first anniversary of Susie’s death, Lindsey asks her mother, ‘‘Are you going to leave us?’’ As Susie narrates, ‘‘‘Come here baby,’ my mother said, and Lindsey did. She leaned back into my mother’s chest, and my mother rocked her awkwardly on the rug. ‘You are doing so well, Lindsey; you are keeping your father alive.’’’ Lindsey does not have the benefit of Susie’s all-encompassing perspective; Lindsey does not know her mother’s thoughts, but she does understand that her mother will not stay, and somehow, Lindsey seems to accept her mother’s need to go. When Abigail returns, Lindsey poses yet another question. Referring to Buckley, she asks, ‘‘Are you going to hurt him again?’’ Abigail hears a challenge in the question, a challenge glaring from her daughter’s eyes. ‘‘I know what you did,’’ Lindsey tells her mother. This mother-daughter relationship, Abigail and Lindsey, perhaps the most tenuous of all those depicted in the book, manifests as the most honest. Lindsey has always accepted Abigail for who she was, and she seems able to accept their relationship for what it is— desiring nothing more. The Lovely Bones holds motherhood, along with mothers and daughters, up to scrutiny, and in the end the narrative offers a new understanding of those bonds by demonstrating the importance of examining the ideologies behind them. The novel reinforces the connection of generations through women with the closing image of a strong and confident young mother, Lindsey, with her daughter, Abigail Suzanne. Source: Catherine Cucinella, Critical Essay on The Lovely Bones, in Literary Newsmakers for Students, Thomson Gale, 2006.
Daniel Mendelsohn In the following excerpt, Mendelsohn argues that the general failure to recognize the book’s weaknesses says something about the cultural climate in which it was first published.
WHAT DO I READ NEXT? Lucky (1999) is Sebold’s memoir of her 1981 rape. In it, she details the rape itself and chronicles the arrest, trial, and conviction of the rapist. She also addresses the emotional aftermath and consequences of the attack. Sue Monk Kidd’s novel The Secret Life of Bees (2003) is a coming-of-age story. Set in the 1960s, The Secret Life of Bees deals with tragedy, the absence of a mother, and the protagonist’s need to look backward and then to let go in order to move on. The Five People You Meet in Heaven (2003), by Mitch Albom, follows the protagonist, Eddie, through his last moments on earth, his funeral, and the days after his death. Then the story shifts to Eddie’s arrival at and experiences in heaven. Aimee Bender’s first novel, An Invisible Sign of My Own (2000), is about a girl named Mona who deals with her father’s mysterious illness by withdrawing from the things she likes to do: eating dessert, playing piano, spending time with her boyfriend. She grows up to become a second-grade math teacher, and must use her own experiences with illness to help a student through her mother’s cancer.
Family (1991), by J. California Cooper, is narrated by a dead main character. Clora, a pre–Civil War slave, escapes slavery through suicide. After her death, her spirit narrates the story of her children and grandchildren as they live through slavery and the Civil War.
The Afterlife (2003), by Gary Soto, is the story of Chuy, a murdered seventeen-yearold boy. Now deceased, Chuy must solve the mystery of his murder and come to terms with his new identity in death.
On May 22 of this year, six weeks before the official publication date of Alice Sebold’s debut novel [The Lovely Bones], which is narrated from Heaven by a fourteen-year-old girl who’s been raped and murdered, the novelist and former
New York Times columnist Anna Quindlen appeared of the Today show and declared that if people had one book to read during the
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 4 5
T h e
L o v e l y
B o n e s
AND YET DARKNESS, GRIEF, AND HEARTBREAK IS WHAT THE LOVELY BONES SCRUPULOUSLY AVOIDS. THIS IS THE REAL HEART OF ITS APPEAL.’’
summer, ‘‘it should be The Lovely Bones by Alice Sebold. It’s destined to be a classic along the lines of To Kill a Mockingbird, and it’s one of the best books I’ve read in years.’’ Viewers did what they were told and seemed to agree. Within days of Quindlen’s appearance, Sebold’s novel had reached the number-one position on Amazon.com, and her publisher, Little, Brown, decided to increase the size of the first printing from 35,000—already healthily optimistic for a ‘‘literary’’ first novel by an author whose only other book, a memoir of her rape, was a critical but not commercial success—to 50,000 copies; a week before the book’s official publication date, it was in its sixth printing, with nearly a quartermillion copies in print. In an interview with Publishers Weekly at the end of July, when the true extent of the book’s success was just coming into focus, Michael Pietsch, the publisher of Little, Brown, suggested that the book’s appeal lies in its fearless and ultimately redemptive portrayal of ‘‘dark material’’: ‘‘grief, the most horrible thing that can happen in a life.’’ And yet darkness, grief, and heartbreak is what The Lovely Bones scrupulously avoids. This is the real heart of its appeal. Sebold’s decision to have the dead girl narrate her story—a device familiar from Our Town, a sentimental story with which this one has more than a little in common—suggests an admirable desire to confront murder and violence, grief and guilt in a bold, even raw new way. And yet after its attention-getting opening, The Lovely Bones shows little real interest in examining ugly things. Indeed, the ultimate horror that Susie undergoes is one for which the author has no words, and chooses not to represent. In the first of what turns out to be many evasive gestures, the author tastefully avoids the murder itself, to say nothing of the dismemberment. ‘‘The end came anyway,’’ she writes, and there is a discreet dissolve to the next chapter.
1 4 6
L i t e r a r y
I use the word ‘‘dissolve’’ advisedly: it is hard to read what follows in The Lovely Bones without thinking of cinema—or, perhaps better, of those TV ‘‘movies of the week,’’ with their predictable arcs of crisis, healing, and ‘‘closure,’’ the latter inevitably evoked by an obvious symbolism. Equally soft-focus are the novel’s sketchy attempts to confront the face of evil that Susie, and Susie alone of all these characters, has looked on directly: the killer himself, Mr. Harvey. Sebold perfunctorily provides some sketchy information that never quite adds up to a persuasive portrait of a sociopath. Harvey’s father abused and eventually chased away his wild, rebellious mother, whom the boy sees for the last time, dressed in white capri pants, being pushed out of a car in a town called Truth or Consequences, New Mexico. He sometimes kills animals as a means of avoiding homicide. And Sebold grapples with punishment—with, that is, the moral meaning and consequences of the crime at the heart of her book— as weakly as she does with the crime itself. At the end of the novel, in what is apparently meant to be a high irony, Harvey, who has managed for years to elude Susie’s increasingly suspicious family and the police, is killed accidentally: as he stands at the edge of a ravine, plotting to attack yet another girl one winter day, he falls when an icicle drops onto him. So having the murder victim be the protagonist offers no special view of evil, or guilt. I asked myself, as I read The Lovely Bones, what could be the point of having the dead girl narrate the aftermath of her death—what, in other words, this voice could achieve that a standard omniscient narrator couldn’t—and it occurred to me that the answer is that Susie is there to provide comfort: not to those who survive her, to whom she can’t really make herself known or felt, but to the audience. The real point of Sebold’s novel isn’t to make you confront dreadful things, but, if anything, to assure you that they have no really permanent consequences. This is most evident in the author’s vision of the ‘‘healing process’’ that takes place after the murder, a process that furnishes the book with the bulk of its matter. Susie herself must undergo it, we learn: she has to be weaned of her desire to linger in the world and ‘‘change the lives of those I loved on Earth’’ in order to progress from ‘‘her’’ heaven to Heaven itself. (The cosmology is vague—more shades of Our Town here—but
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
L o v e l y
B o n e s
that’s the gist of it.) But The Lovely Bones is devoted even more to the aftermath (which is to say healing and closure) of her death as it is experienced by her friends and family. That a novel with the pretensions to moral, emotional, and social seriousness of this one should end up seeking, and finding, the ultimate salvation and redemption in a recuperative teenage fantasy of idyllic sex suggests that cinema, or television, is the wrong thing to be comparing it to. Sebold’s final narrative gesture reminds you, indeed, of nothing so much as pop love songs, with their aromatherapeutic vision of adult relationships as nothing but yearnings endlessly, blissfully fulfilled—or of breakups inevitably smoothed over and healed with a kiss. Just after Ray and Susie/Ruth make love, Susie’s estranged parents are reunited on her father’s hospital bed, weeping and kissing each other. That Sebold’s book does so little to show us a complex or textured portrait of the evil that sets its action in motion, or to suggest that the aftermath of horrible violence within families is, ultimately, anything but feel-good redemption, suggests that its huge popularity has very little, in fact, to do with the timeliness of its publication just months after a series of abductions and murders of girls had transfixed a nation already traumatized by the events of September 11. It is, rather, the latter catastrophe that surely accounts for the novel’s gigantic appeal.
Snow covering a field of corn stubble Ó Richard Hamilton Smith/Corbis
or indeed of death, as the place, or state, that allows you to indulge a recuperative fantasy or great sex?
Confidence and grief management are what The Lovely Bones offers, too: it, too, is bent on convincing us that everything is OK—whatever, indeed, its author and promoters keep telling us about how unflinchingly it examines bad things. ‘‘We’re here,’’ Susie’s ghost says, in the final pages of the novel. ‘‘All the time. You can talk to us and think about us. It doesn’t have to be sad or scary.’’ The problem, of course, is that it does have to be sad and scary; that you need to experience the badness and fear—as Sebold’s characters, none more than Susie herself, never quite manage to do—in order to get to the place that Sebold wants to take you, the locus of healing, and closure: in short, Heaven. And yet what a Heaven it is. In the weeks following September 11, there was much dark jocularity at the expense of those Islamic terrorists who, it was said, had volunteered to die in order to enjoy the postmortem favors of numerous virgins in Paradise. But how much more sophisticated, or morally textured, is Sebold’s climactic vision of Heaven,
That for Sebold and her readers Heaven can’t, in fact, wait is symptomatic of a larger cultural dysfunction, one implicit in our ongoing handling of the September 11 disaster. The Lovely Bones appeared just as the first anniversary of the World Trade Center and Pentagon attacks was looming; but by then, we’d already commemorated the terrible day. September 11, 2002—the first anniversary of the attacks, a day that ought to have marked (as is supposed to be the case with such anniversary rituals) some symbolic coming to terms with what had happened—was not a date for which the American people and its press could patiently wait. Instead we rushed to celebrate, with all due pomp and gravitas, on March 11, something called a six-month ‘‘anniversary.’’ In its proleptic yearning for relief, and indeed in its emphasis on the bathetic appeal of victimhood, its pseudo– therapeutic lingo of healing and insistence that everything is really OK, that we needn’t really be sad, that nothing is, in the end, really scary, Sebold’s book is indeed timely—is indeed ‘‘the novel of the year’’—although in ways that none
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 4 7
T h e
L o v e l y
B o n e s
of those now caught up in the glamour of its unprecedentedly high approval ratings might be prepared to imagine.
Smith, Ali, ‘‘A Perfect Afterlife,’’ Review of The Lovely Bones, in the Guardian, August 17, 2002, Guardian Unlimited, www.books.guardian.co.uk (August 17, 2002).
Source: Daniel Mendelsohn, ‘‘Novel of the Year,’’ in New York Review of Books, Vol. 50, No. 1, January 16, 2003, pp. 4–8.
Webb, Stephen H., Earth from Above,? in Christian Century, Vol. 119, No. 21, October 9–22, 2002, p. 20. Woloch, Nancy, Women and the American Experience, 3d ed., McGraw-Hill, pp. 508–09.
SOURCES Abbott, Charlotte, ‘‘How About Them Bones?’’ in Publishers Weekly, Vol. 249, No. 30, July 29, 2002, pp. 22–23. Bouton, Katherine, ‘‘What Remains,’’ Review of The Lovely Bones, in the New York Times, July 14, 2002, Final edition, Section 7, Column 3, p. 14. Charles, Ron, ‘‘‘If I Die Before I Wake, I Pray the Lord My Soul to Take’: In Alice Sebold’s Debut Novel, the Dead Must Learn to Let Go, Too,’’ Review of The Lovely Bones, in the Christian Science Monitor, July 25, 2002, p. 15. Churchwell, Sarah, ‘‘A Neato Heaven,’’ Review of The Lovely Bones, in the Times Literary Supplement, No. 5186, August 23, 2002, p. 19. Friedan, Betty, The Feminine Mystique, W.W. Norton, 1997, p. 9. Grossman, Lev, ‘‘Murdered, She Wrote,’’ Review of The Lovely Bones, in Time, Vol. 160, No. 4, July 1, 2002, p. 62. Kakutani, Michiko, ‘‘The Power of Love Leaps the Great Divide of Death,’’ Review of The Lovely Bones, in the New York Times, June 18, 2002, Section E, Column 4, p. 1. Mead, Rebecca, ‘‘Immortally Cute,’’ Review of The Lovely Bones, in the London Review of Books, Vol. 24, No. 20, October 17, 2002, p. 18. Mendelsohn, Daniel, ‘‘Novel of the Year,’’ Review of The Lovely Bones, in the New York Review of Books, Vol. 50, No. 1, January 16, 2003, pp. 4–5. Russo, Maria, ‘‘Girl, Interrupted,’’ Review of The Lovely Bones, in the Washington Post, August 11, 2002, p. BWO7. Sebold, Alice, The Lovely Bones, Little Brown, 2004. ———, ‘‘The Oddity of Suburbia,’’ in The Lovely Bones, Little Brown, 2004, pp. 2–3.
1 4 8
L i t e r a r y
FURTHER READING Baily, Beth L., and David Farber, eds., America in the Seventies, University Press of Kansas, 2004. America in the Seventies is a collection of essays by leading scholars in the field. These essays address such issues as the cultural despair of the decade; analyze elements of seventies’ culture such as film, music, and advertising; and discuss the attempt by Americans to redefine themselves in the 1970s. Douglas, Susan, Where the Girls Are: Growing Up Female with the Mass Media, Three Rivers Press, 1995. This book focuses on media images of women in the last fifty years of the twentieth century. Douglas’s discussions regarding the 1970s help in contextualizing the cultural atmosphere of Sebold’s The Lovely Bones. Evans, Sarah, Born for Liberty, Simon & Schuster, 1997. This one-volume history of American women examines the changing role of women in this country. The later chapters, particularly chapters 11–12, prove helpful in understanding Abigail Salmon and Ruth Connors in Sebold’s novel. Friedan, Betty, The Feminine Mystique, Norton, 1963. The Feminine Mystique, a foundational feminist text, examines the discontent of white, educated, suburban wives and mothers. Although published in the early 1960s, Friedan’s study seems relevant to Abigail Salmon’s conflicting feelings in The Lovely Bones. Ku¨bler-Ross, Elisabeth, On Death and Dying, Scribner, 1969, reprint, 1997. This book, written in plain, understandable language, introduces and explains the five stages of grief. It remains a classic in understanding both the dying and grieving processes.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
Mystic River Mystic River (2001) established Dennis Lehane as more than a mystery writer. Lehane had previously written a successful series of novels centered around two detectives named Angie Gennaro and Patrick Kenzie; Mystic River was his first stand-alone novel.
DENNIS LEHANE 2001
Like most of Lehane’s novels, Mystic River is set in Boston, the city he grew up in and eventually returned to as an adult. Lehane’s familiarity with the area allowed him to create authentic dialogue and speech inflections. His background also afforded him insight into how the working class of Boston’s neighborhoods really thought and lived. He spent nearly ten years thinking about Mystic River before actually writing it. In Mystic River, three young boys—Dave Boyle, Sean Devine, and Jimmy Marcus—are linked for life after Dave is kidnapped while Sean and Jimmy watch. Dave’s subsequent molestation scars him deeply and leaves the other two boys with conflicting feelings over how close they came to being victimized. Twenty-five years later, the three are thrown together again when Jimmy’s nineteen-year-old daughter Katie is murdered. Sean is the state trooper investigating the crime, while Dave becomes a lead suspect. Mystic River explores the nature of the tightly knit neighborhoods and families of Boston, and their response to outsiders. This close-knit environment serves as
1 4 9
M y s t i c
R i v e r
the backdrop for a story that spotlights how one incident acts as a thread that can be woven into so many lives. Mystic River was popular with readers, spending several weeks on the New York Times bestseller list. Critics also gave it generally good reviews. Clint Eastwood directed the acclaimed film version of the novel, which was shot in Boston. Sean Penn won the 2003 Academy Award for Best Actor for his portrayal of Jimmy Marcus, and Tim Robbins won Best Supporting Actor for his role as Dave Boyle.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY Dennis Lehane, the youngest son of Irish immigrants, was born August 4, 1965, in Dorchester, Massachusetts, a working-class neighborhood of Boston. Growing up in Dorchester during the 1970s, the author witnessed his close-knit, insulated neighborhood undergoing some radical changes, sometimes violently, while still retaining its core values. As a child, Lehane was an avid reader. He was attracted to writing by the time he was eight years old, and began creating short stories by the age of seventeen. After graduating from high school, he attended two colleges in Boston, Emerson College and the University of Massachusetts, but dropped out of both. In 1985, Lehane finally found a program that suited him. He moved to Florida to study writing at Eckhard College. In 1986, while a student there, he took a job that would inspire his later work. He became a counselor at a state facility for children that were emotionally disturbed, developmentally delayed, and mentally handicapped. Lehane graduated from Eckhard in 1988 with a degree in English. He left the counseling job in 1991 when he entered Florida International University’s creative writing M.F.A. program. He graduated in 1993, returned to his hometown of Boston, and spent two years working as a valet and limousine driver at a hotel, jobs that allowed him ample time to pursue his writing. Though Lehane had focused on dark short stories while he was a student, he decided to try his hand at writing a mystery/crime fiction novel. The result was his first published book, A Drink Before the War (1994). The novel, which
1 5 0
L i t e r a r y
Dennis Lehane Ó Jerry Bauer. Reproduced by permission
featured a pair of Boston-based detectives named Angela Gennaro and Patrick Kenzie, was well received and won a Shamus Award for Best First P.I. Novel in 1995. The success of Drink Before Water led Lehane to an unexpected career as a mystery novelist. Gennaro and Kenzie are the primary characters in four more novels, all of which were popularly received: Darkness, Take My Hand (1996), Sacred (1997), Gone, Baby, Gone (1998), and Prayers for Rain (1999). Lehane made the transition from mystery novelist to stand-alone fiction novelist with Mystic River (2001). Like his other books, this novel is set in Boston and is about crime. However, the stand-alone work—his first novel without the characters of Gennaro and Kenzie— is much deeper than his previous works. Mystic River focuses on the effect a crime has on three friends, as well as a working-class Boston neighborhood. The novel soon became a bestseller and won the Anthony Award and the Dilys Award from the Independent Mystery Booksellers Association. In 2003, Lehane followed Mystic River with another novel about Boston called Shutter Island. Set in an insane asylum in the 1950s, it
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
M y s t i c
centers on a missing patient who is criminally insane. After the publication of Shutter Island, Lehane began working on another novel, which focuses on the 1919 Boston police strike. Beginning in 2004, Lehane wrote scripts for the HBO series The Wire. As of 2005, he has been contributing articles to various magazines.
PLOT SUMMARY Part 1: The Boys Who Escaped From Wolves (1975) Mystic River opens in 1975 and introduces three young boys who are ten and eleven years old and live in East Buckingham, a workingclass part of Boston. Two of the boys, Jimmy Marcus and Dave Boyle, live in the Flats area, while Sean Devine lives in the nicer Point area. Sean’s father works as a foreman in a candy factory, where Jimmy’s father is also employed. Dave tags along wherever Jimmy goes, including the Saturday visits that Jimmy and his father make to Sean and his father. After an incident where Jimmy, the daredevil of the group, jumps onto the subway tracks to retrieve a lost ball and has to be dragged off the tracks, Sean’s father tells Sean he can only play with Jimmy in front of their home. The next time Jimmy and Dave visit Sean’s house, Jimmy is not as exuberant. His father has lost his job. Dave tries to lighten the mood by telling a joke, but his efforts are ignored by the other two. Jimmy suggests they find a car with its keys under the seat and take it for a joyride. He asks Sean which cars on the block would be best to take, but internally Sean does not like this idea. He suggests to Jimmy that they do this some other time. Dave punches Sean in the arm for his suggestion, and Sean punches him back, hard. Sean and Jimmy get into a physical confrontation. As Sean and Jimmy are fighting, a car, ‘‘square and long like the kind police detectives drove,’’ stops near them. The driver, who looks ‘‘like a cop,’’ gets out and asks the boys where they live. Jimmy lies and says he lives in the neighborhood, but Dave tells him that he is from the Flats. The man insists that Dave get in the car with them, warns the boys about fighting, and tells them that Dave will be taken home to his mother.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
R i v e r
After the car leaves, Sean’s father learns of the incident and immediately realizing that it is a kidnapping, calls the police. The men in the car were not police officers, but kidnappers. Sean feels guilty about not getting in the car and wonders what has happened to Dave. Jimmy feels resentful of Sean and does not believe he will ever see Dave again. Apparently, the kidnappers leave Dave alone at one point and he escapes. Four days after his abduction, Dave is found alive. His neighborhood is overjoyed at his return and throws a block party. Dave looks shell-shocked and withdrawn. Seeing him at the party, Jimmy knows that something has changed in Dave. Though Dave initially receives support from his neighbors, his classmates harass him when he returns to school. He does not fully understand what happened to him, especially why the men picked him and not Sean or Jimmy. He relives part of the experience and tries to come to terms with what happened to him. As they grow up, Jimmy and Dave no longer see each other very much. Jimmy steals a car and is sent to another school. Meanwhile, Sean cannot stop dreaming about the experience. One year after the incident, he learns that one of the men who abducted Dave has been caught and killed himself. Before his suicide, the man reports that the other kidnapper died in a car accident the previous year.
Part 2: Sad-Eyed Sinatras (2000) It is now twenty-five years later and Brendan Harris, the secret boyfriend of Jimmy’s nineteen-year-old daughter Katie, is preparing for the couple’s elopement to Las Vegas the next day. Brendan’s preparations and hopes for life are contrasted with background about Jimmy’s life since that fateful day in 1975. Jimmy still lives in the Flats. He has served time in prison, during which his first wife, Marita, died of skin cancer, leaving him a single father. He later remarries and has two more daughters. After serving his time, he leaves his life of crime behind for Katie’s sake. That same night, Dave, who also still lives in the Flats, is preparing for a night out. His wife, Celeste, is having her girlfriends from work over to watch the movie Stepmom, while their young son Michael sleeps in his room. As Dave walks to a local bar, he worries about having to move away from the neighborhood. Yuppies and
V o l u m e
1
1 5 1
M y s t i c
R i v e r
college students have been moving into the area, raising property values and rents.
from the blood in the vehicle that the victim has been murdered.
Katie goes out with her best friends, Diane Cestra and Eve Pigeon, to celebrate her impending marriage. They go to dinner, then to a number of bars. Dave’s evening intersects with Katie and her friends. He watches the Boston Red Sox baseball game at the same bar where Katie and her friends drink and dance on the bar top. After a night of drinking, Katie drops off her friends at Eve’s house. As she drives home, she hits something in the street and stops the car. Someone familiar approaches the car, but he is armed with a gun.
During and after Nadine’s communion service, Jimmy is angry that Katie has not shown up, but he is also worried. He reflects on his past again, revealing that he was a very clever criminal who had his own crew. He went to prison to protect the others in his gang.
Meanwhile, when Dave returns home to Celeste, he is cut across the chest, has an injured hand, and is bleeding profusely. Dave tells Celeste that he was mugged, and he beat the attacker so badly that he might have killed him. Celeste does not believe his story, but still takes care of him, agreeing not to call the police or take him to a hospital. She immediately washes Dave’s bloody clothes and plans to destroy all evidence from Dave’s attack. Though she is scared of what has happened, she is protective and fiercely loyal to Dave. The next morning, Jimmy learns that Katie has not shown up for her Sunday morning shift at the Cottage Market, the corner store he owns. Jimmy is especially tense because it is the morning of the first communion of his youngest daughter, Nadine. As he dresses to go into the store, his wife Annabeth is annoyed that her stepdaughter has created tension on Nadine’s special day. Jimmy reflects on the loss of his first wife and his early days with Katie when he was unsure how to be a father. While Jimmy covers Katie’s shift at the store, he makes calls to try and find her. Brendan drops by the store with his younger brother, a mute named Ray, and tries to learn where Katie is without attracting suspicion. Jimmy does not like Brendan and has forbidden his daughter from ever seeing him. Sean re-enters the narrative as a state trooper working homicide after a week-long suspension. His personal life is in disarray because his wife, Lauren, has left him. He is put on a case after two kids call 911 to report a car covered in blood near Penitentiary Park in the Flats. At the scene, Sean meets with his partner, Whitey Powers, a veteran in homicide. Though a body has not yet been found, the authorities assume
1 5 2
L i t e r a r y
When Celeste wakes up on Sunday morning, she is still worried about what actually happened to her husband the previous evening. She is certain he lied to her about the incident. She knows something happened to her husband as a child, but he has never told her exactly what the experience was. The tension increases between Celeste and Dave. Jimmy, on a hunch, follows the police cars to the area where the car has been found. When he sees that Katie’s car is involved, he knows in his heart that she is dead. Jimmy asks to see Sean, who is reluctant to talk to him. When they meet, Sean informs him that she has not been found yet, but Jimmy cannot accept that answer. Rather than wait on the police, Jimmy decides to find his daughter on his own. The police find Katie’s body behind an old drive-in movie theater screen in the middle of the park. She has been shot in the head and beaten. As Sean surveys the location, Jimmy and his brother-in-law, Chuck, enter the park through a back entrance and approach the murder scene. Jimmy learns that his daughter is dead. Sean and Whitey are the lead investigators of the crime. After Jimmy identifies Katie’s body at the morgue, Sean and Whitey question him and Annabeth. Jimmy brings up what might have happened if he and Sean had gotten into the car with Dave. Though internally Sean reflects on the fact that he has asked himself the same question over the years, he keeps focus on the case at hand. As Whitey and Sean begin their investigation, Sean tells him what happened with Dave all those years ago. At Jimmy’s home, Jimmy has another brother-in-law, Val, look into the possibility that Katie’s ex-boyfriend, a criminal named Bobby O’Donnell, had a hand in her death. Whitey and Sean question Eve and Diane, and learn that Katie was going to elope to Las Vegas with Brendan. The next day, they question Roman Farrow, a friend of Bobby’s. He reminds them that Bobby could not have killed Katie
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
M y s t i c
because he was already in jail on a DUI charge. Whitey and Sean go to Brendan’s house and he confirms his and Katie’s plans to elope. When Sean returns home, he reflects on his life. He had met Lauren in college, and now she works as a stage manager for traveling shows. The couple has been growing apart for some time, and she has had an affair. She becomes pregnant around the same time, and Sean is unsure if the child is his. Lauren calls, but as always, she is silent on the line and says nothing.
Part 3: Angels of the Silences The next morning, Celeste is staying with Annabeth, her cousin, to help her out with family and friends that have come to pay their respects. Celeste observes how grief has affected the family. Jimmy struggles deeply with the loss of his daughter, but keeps his grief internalized. Sean and Whitey continue their investigation by questioning Dave. They know that he was at one of the bars that Katie and her friends were at on the night she was murdered. Dave lies to them, saying he left the bar at about 12:45 a.m. and went straight home. He tries to hide his injured hand in his pocket. After Sean and Whitey leave, Dave reflects on his past. He struggles with what happened to him as a child and calls this part of his personality ‘‘The Boy Who’d Escaped from Wolves and Grown Up.’’ He takes his son to Jimmy’s house. When Jimmy asks Dave what happened to his injured hand, Dave tells him that he cut it helping someone move a sofa. Sean and Whitey discuss the state of their case and fear it could be a random crime. Whitey suggests that Dave could be a suspect, though Sean is dismissive of that possibility. When they present their findings to their superiors, they mention that there was a suspicious car seen in the parking lot of the bar, the Last Drop, where Katie was last seen alive. There was also blood in the parking lot. The authorities are unsure how these facts relate to Katie’s death. Sean and Whitey park near Jimmy’s house. Dave is outside, heading into the nearby convenience store. When Whitey asks about Dave’s injured hand, Dave tells him a pool cue smashed it into the wall while he was making a difficult shot. Whitey and Sean notice a dent on Dave’s car that matches the description of the dented car in the parking lot of the Last Drop.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
R i v e r
They do not believe his story about the night Katie was killed. Celeste overhears the conversation between Dave, Sean, and Whitey. She is worried that her husband is involved with Katie’s death. When Sean talks to Celeste alone a short time later, he tries to get her to tell him what time Dave came home that night. Celeste becomes confused and defensive, and she lies, telling Sean she was asleep when he came home. Sean knows that she is scared, and thinks that she knows more than she is saying. Sean talks to Jimmy alone and informs him that his daughter was dating Brendan and planning to elope. Jimmy is surprised. Sean asks why he hates Brendan so much, and Jimmy tells him that he had issues with Brendan’s father, who was known as Just Ray. When Sean and Whitey talk again, Whitey is more convinced that Dave is a leading suspect, but Sean is reluctant to completely agree. Whitey asks Sean if there is a conflict of interest with him being on the case of a friend’s murdered daughter with another friend as the lead suspect. Sean assures him that he is after the killer, whoever it is. Off the clock, Sean spends some time with Annabeth, sharing his marital troubles to get her mind off her own problems. When Celeste returns home from dropping off Katie’s dress at the funeral parlor, Dave is angry at her and accuses her of thinking that he killed Katie. She tells him that she overheard Whitey and Sean talking. She wants Dave to tell them the truth about what happened to him on the night of Katie’s murder. Dave has a breakdown and tells Celeste what happened when he was kidnapped and molested as a child. He tells her, ‘‘The kid who came out of that cellar, I don’t know who the f—k he was— well, he’s me, actually—but he’s sure as s—t not Dave. Dave’s dead.’’ He does not think that he trusts himself anymore. Dave walks in his neighborhood, reflecting on what happened on the night that Katie was murdered. He admits to himself that he sometimes fights the urge to molest children as he himself was molested, but he will not cross that line. When Dave goes out, Celeste takes her son and leaves her husband.
Part 4: Gentrification Whitey tells Sean that he has towed Dave’s car as evidence. Blood was found in the front
V o l u m e
1
1 5 3
M y s t i c
R i v e r
seat and the trunk. He also tells Sean that the gun used to kill Katie was also used in a 1982 robbery, which Sean says points away from Dave. Whitey brings Dave in for questioning. The troopers confront him on inconsistencies in his story. Dave eludes them, telling another lie about his injured hand, saying that he fell against a ragged chain-link fence in his backyard. In the interrogation room, Dave grows smug in the knowledge that they cannot pin Katie’s murder on him and that he has a secret: he murdered someone else and no one can prove it. He is released when a witness cannot pick him out of a lineup. Sean investigates the gun used to kill Katie. Just Ray, Brendan’s father, is linked to the weapon. Just Ray was an associate of Jimmy’s who disappeared in 1987. Sean and Whitey learn that Just Ray had ratted on Jimmy when Just Ray was arrested in the 1980s, which is why Jimmy ended up in prison. They figure that Jimmy must have had a hand in Just Ray’s disappearance, either murdering him himself or ordering someone to do it. After Jimmy buys the headstone for his daughter’s grave, he and Val talk about what Val has learned through the informal investigation Jimmy has asked him to undertake. Val verifies that the murderer could not have been Bobby O’Donnell or Roman Farrow. He mentions that Little Vince, a child prostitute known to hang around the Last Drop, suddenly left town. Jimmy learns that Dave has been taken in for questioning. Celeste finds Jimmy and tells him that she has left Dave. She relates everything that has happened, and says that she believes Dave killed Katie. In the meantime, Sean questions Brendan again, asking about his father and his father’s gun. Brendan does not believe his father is dead because he sends monthly checks postmarked from New York. When Sean asks Brendan if his father kept a gun in the house, Brendan denies it. They can connect the gun to Katie’s murder through its use in an earlier robbery, and arrest Brendan on suspicion of murder. When Dave gets home, he starts drinking. He thinks back to what actually happened the night Katie was murdered. He happened upon a man with a young male prostitute in his car, and Dave, consumed with rage over his own abuse, beat the man and then shot him. In the melee, Dave was injured. He first put the body in his
1 5 4
L i t e r a r y
trunk, then moved it to the man’s Cadillac. Dave’s motive was not only rescuing the boy prostitute, but also rescuing the Boy Who’d Escaped from Wolves living inside him. Whitey and Sean learn that the suspicious car from the bar had been towed. They find the body of the man that Dave killed and link this murder to him. Sean returns to question Brendan, but Brendan demands a lawyer and is soon released. After listening to the 911 call tape again, Sean and Whitey realize that the boys who called about Katie’s abandoned car had actually seen her while she was still alive. In the meantime, Dave runs into Val, who invites him to lunch. Jimmy shows up at the restaurant and joins them. As they drink, the tension between Dave and Jimmy is palpable and makes Dave sick to him stomach. When Dave goes outside to vomit, Jimmy and Val follow. Jimmy tells Dave that he killed Just Ray on principle for betraying him, even though he did not want to. When Val pulls a gun and Jimmy pulls a knife, Dave insists he had nothing to do with Katie’s death, telling them that he killed a child molester that night, not Katie. He then tells Jimmy that he did kill Katie, believing that Jimmy will let him live if he tells him what he wants to hear. Jimmy stabs Dave in the abdomen and then shoots him in the head. Jimmy and Val dump Dave’s body and the murder weapons in the Mystic River. When Brendan returns home from the police station, he looks for his father’s gun in the place he knew it should be. It is not there. At the same time, Whitey and Sean figure out that it was Brendan’s brother, Ray, and his friend Johnny O’Shea that the witness saw and heard in the street before Katie’s car stopped. They were the ones who made the 911 call. Brendan confronts his brother and Johnny, beating both of them. Sean and Whitey arrive to find Johnny holding Brendan at gunpoint. After a tense stand-off during which Johnny points the gun at Sean, Sean diffuses the situation and takes Ray and Johnny into custody for Katie’s murder. Sean goes to Jimmy’s house and informs him that they have caught Katie’s killer. Sean also tells him about the murder of a child molester and asks if he knows where Dave is. Jimmy realizes that he has killed the wrong man. Sean can see in Jimmy’s face that he killed both Just Ray and Dave. He vows to collect enough evidence to
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
M y s t i c
R i v e r
CHARACTERS Big Wolf
MEDIA ADAPTATIONS
Mystic River was released in an abridged version on four audiocassettes by Harper Audio in 2001. The text is read by David Strathairn. Mystic River was adapted as a film in 2003. Brian Helgeland wrote the screenplay and Clint Eastwood directed the production. The film starred Sean Penn, Tim Robbins, and Kevin Bacon as Jimmy, Dave, and Sean. It was nominated for six Academy Awards, winning two. It was also named Best Film of 2003 by the National Board of Review.
arrest him but knows that Jimmy is too smart to have left any evidence behind. Sean calls Lauren and they reconcile, and he learns the name of his daughter, Nora. When Jimmy returns home, he confesses everything he has done to Annabeth, who tells him he did the right thing to protect his family from those who are weaker than they are.
Epilogue: Jimmy Flats (Sunday) On Sunday morning, a parade is about to take place in the neighborhood. Jimmy reflects on the events of the past two days as he wakes up from a deep sleep. Celeste had come to Katie’s wake, screaming that Jimmy was a murderer. The gravity of Jimmy’s crime weighs on him, as does his past. He decides that with Katie dead, his reason for going straight is gone, and he returns to his former criminal lifestyle.
Big Wolf is the name Dave gives Henry, one of the men who kidnapped him when he was a boy. Big Wolf, the driver of the car, and his partner Greasy Wolf pose as police officers and force Dave into their car. Big Wolf is never caught for the kidnapping and molestation of Dave. Later, he allegedly dies in a car crash.
Celeste Boyle Celeste is Dave Boyle’s wife, the mother of Michael, and the first cousin of Annabeth Marcus. Celeste is loyal to Dave but is greatly troubled when he comes home one night, bloodied and injured. She does not believe the story he tells her about being mugged and fighting to defend himself. Eventually, she fearfully concludes that her husband murdered Katie. When Celeste tells Jimmy her fears, it confirms his suspicions and he murders Dave. Not knowing her revelation would end in murder, Celeste later regrets her actions and blames Jimmy for her husband’s death.
Dave Boyle Dave Boyle is the feeble childhood friend of Jimmy and Sean, neither of whom seems to like Dave. Like Jimmy, he lives in the Flats, the lower working-class area of East Buckingham, Boston. Sean knows Dave only because he tags along with Jimmy when Jimmy visits Sean’s house. Dave is fighting in the street near Sean’s house, when two men posing as police officers kidnap him. They put Dave into the back of their car and tell him they are taking him home to his mother. Instead, Dave endures sexual abuse at the hands of the men he nicknames Big Wolf and Greasy Wolf. When they leave him in a cellar alone, Dave manages to escape and returns home after four days. The incident greatly scars Dave.
Sean and his wife reconcile, and Sean meets his infant daughter, Nora, for the first time. They attend the parade. Celeste appears in the crowd and tells Sean that Jimmy murdered her husband. Sean promises to prove Jimmy did the crime and bring him to justice. Sean and Jimmy make eye contact across the crowd. Sean hopes that Dave has achieved some peace in death.
He is married to Celeste and has a son named Michael. He does not tell her exactly what happened to him as a child. Internally, Dave struggles with his own desires to molest, though he vows never to act on them. Instead, his inner conflicts reveal themselves when, after a night of drinking, he murders August Larson. Dave comes upon Larson engaged with a young male prostitute and takes out all his pent-up rage on Larson. Though Dave is injured in the
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 5 5
M y s t i c
R i v e r
incident, he does not tell anyone the truth about what happened. Because of Dave’s unexplained injury, his wife suspects him of killing Jimmy’s daughter, Katie, and she leaves him. Jimmy also suspects Dave of killing Katie. Dave finally tells him the truth about killing August Larson, but Jimmy does not believe him. After Dave is killed, his body is weighted and sunk to the bottom of the Mystic River.
Michael Boyle Michael is the eight-year-old son of Dave Boyle and his wife Celeste. Like his father, he is a very talented baseball player who plays the catcher position.
Diane Cestra Diane is one of Katie Marcus’s best friends. Along with Eve Pigeon, she spends a last night on the town with Katie before Katie is supposed to leave for Las Vegas. Instead of driving home with Katie, she spends the night at Eve’s house, leaving Katie to drive home alone in the car.
After Sean graduates from college, he becomes a successful state trooper. However, his marriage to Lauren is troubled by an affair she has with another man. Just before the action of Mystic River begins, Sean has served a suspension and probation for giving his wife’s lover unearned parking tickets. The murder of Katie Marcus is his first case back with his partner, Whitey Powers. The pair investigates the case while Sean struggles with the past, especially the fact that he did not get in the car with the pedophiles. Unlike his partner, Sean is somewhat reluctant to consider Dave Boyle as Katie’s murderer. Sean finds the clue that points the investigation to the true murderers: mute Ray Harris and his friend, Johnny O’Shea. Arresting the boys and facing the gun that Johnny aims at him puts Sean’s life in perspective and allows him to make the first step towards reconciliation with his wife and child. Sean also realizes that Jimmy killed Dave and vows to arrest him someday for the crime.
Greasy Wolf Lauren Devine Lauren Devine is the wife of Sean Devine. The couple met in college, and she works as a stage manager for traveling shows such as Lord of the Dance. Sean and Lauren are separated for much of the book, in part because she had an affair with another man. The couple has a daughter, Nora, though Sean is not sure he is the father until the end of the book. Throughout the novel, Lauren calls Sean from the road, but she does not speak. He talks to her, but she does not say anything back. After Sean faces the gun held on him by Johnny O’Shea, he takes the first steps towards reconciliation, which she accepts. By the end of the book, the couple has reunited.
Sean Devine When Mystic River opens, Sean is about ten years old and living in the Point, an upper workingclass neighborhood in the East Buckingham section of Boston. He is playmates with Jimmy Marcus and Dave Boyle. The boys play together only on Saturdays because Sean goes to a Catholic school, while the other two go to public school. Sean is sometimes put off by Jimmy’s wildness and Dave’s clinginess. However, when Dave is kidnapped right in front of him by men who are posing as police officers, Sean develops a lifelong guilt over the incident.
1 5 6
L i t e r a r y
Greasy Wolf is the name that Dave gives to George, one of the men who kidnapped him when he was a child. George was the passenger in the car that stopped on Sean’s street, posing as a police car. He was eventually caught by the authorities but committed suicide before he was prosecuted.
Brendan Harris Brendan Harris is the older brother of Ray Harris and the son of Esther and Just Ray Harris. He is about nineteen years old and in love with Katie Marcus. The pair have been secretly dating and plan to elope in Las Vegas. When Katie is found murdered, Sean Devine and Whitey Powers briefly consider Brendan as a suspect, though neither ultimately believes he killed her. In the end, Brendan realizes that his brother and friend killed Katie just as Sean and Whitey arrive at the door to arrest them.
Ray Harris Jr. Ray is the mute younger brother of Brendan, and son of Esther and Just Ray Harris. His father ratted out Jimmy Marcus, which led to Jimmy’s prison time and eventually to Jimmy murdering Just Ray. With friend Johnny O’Shea, Ray murders Katie because he does not want to see his brother move away.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
M y s t i c
Ray Harris Sr.
Jimmy Marcus
See Just Ray
Just Ray Though Just Ray does not appear as a living character in Mystic River, his presence is felt nonetheless. Just Ray is the husband of Esther Harris, and the father of Brendan and Ray Harris, Jr. Just Ray was a criminal in league with Jimmy Marcus but also held a few legitimate jobs along the way. He disappeared in 1987 while his wife was pregnant with Silent Ray. His family thinks he just moved away and abandoned them, primarily because each month they receive five hundred dollars in an envelope with a New York postmark. In reality, Jimmy murdered Just Ray because he gave the police information that led to Jimmy’s arrest and prison sentence. Jimmy is the one who sends the monthly checks. Because of Jimmy and Just Ray’s negative relationship, Jimmy does not like Brendan and has forbidden his daughter from ever seeing him.
August Larson August is the man whom Dave murders. He is in the company of Little Vince, a local child prostitute, when Dave comes upon them and kills August. Dave first puts August’s body in his trunk but later moves him to the trunk of the man’s own Cadillac, where it is late found.
Little Vince See Vincent
Annabeth Marcus Annabeth is Jimmy Marcus’s second wife and the mother of two of his daughters, Sara and Nadine. She is also the only daughter of Theo Savage, sister to the Savage brothers including Val and Chuck, and the first cousin of Celeste Boyle. Throughout the story, Annabeth’s severe nature is highlighted. At one point, Sean asks her, ‘‘Anyone ever tell you that you’re a hard woman?’’ She replies, ‘‘All the time.’’ Annabeth is very supportive of her husband and immediate family. She allows Celeste and others to take care of her after Katie’s death, although she despises weakness. Annabeth knew Jimmy was going to kill Dave and could have stopped him, but she does not because she regards Dave as feeble.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
R i v e r
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
At the beginning of Mystic River, Jimmy is about eleven years old. He is an only child and lives in the lower working-class neighborhood of the Flats in East Buckingham. Jimmy is a wild child who takes extreme risks. Yet he also allows Dave Boyle, who was easily led and without many friends, to tag along with him. Jimmy’s street smarts prevent him from being kidnapped. When two men posing as police officers pull up, Jimmy saves himself by lying, saying that he lives nearby. The men kidnap Dave, and Jimmy does not believe Dave will be coming back until he actually shows up. Even as a child, Jimmy resents Sean and his wealth. After the kidnapping, Jimmy steals a new baseball mitt off Sean’s bed when he leaves Sean’s house. This resentment colors their relationship as adults. Unlike Sean and Dave, Jimmy does not succeed at school. He is expelled from one school after stealing a car, and bussed to another one. By the time he is seventeen years old, Jimmy is the head of a criminal gang. He meets and marries his first wife, Marita, the mother of his first daughter, Katie. However, Jimmy is betrayed by one of his associates, Just Ray Harris, after a robbery. Refusing to turn in the rest of his friends, Jimmy goes to prison for a few years. During his time inside, Marita dies of skin cancer. Upon his release, Jimmy becomes a single father to Katie. He later remarries and with his new wife, Annabelle, has two more daughters, Nadine and Sara. To take care of them, he leaves his life of crime behind and runs a legitimate business, a corner store. He exacts his revenge on Just Ray by executing him in secret. But Jimmy also arranges for money to be sent monthly to Just Ray’s family, in part so they will think he is still alive. Jimmy is extremely close to Katie and her death devastates him. He relies on family, like his crazy brothers-in-law Val and Chuck Savage, to help him find out who killed her. When Celeste shares her belief that Dave killed Katie, Jimmy murders Dave. Jimmy feels slight remorse when he learns the truth but will not admit to his crimes. Instead, he decides to make a return to his criminal past.
Katie Marcus Katie is the nineteen-year-old daughter of Jimmy Marcus and his first wife, Marita. She is
V o l u m e
1
1 5 7
M y s t i c
R i v e r
the stepdaughter of Annabeth Marcus. Katie and her father are extremely close. Her mother died while her father was in prison, and after his release, Katie and Jimmy build a strong bond. Despite this closeness, Katie does not tell her father that she is dating and planning to elope to Las Vegas with Brendan Harris. Before Katie can put this plan into action, she is murdered by Brendan’s brother, Ray, and his friend Johnny O’Shea. Her death drives the plot in Mystic River.
Marita Marcus Marita is Jimmy’s first wife and Katie’s mother. She dies while Jimmy is serving his prison sentence. Her loss haunts him throughout the novel, and he secretly admits to himself that he loved her more than he loves Annabeth.
on the case, including his ties to Jimmy and Dave. However, Whitey also uses these links to help solve the crime.
Val Savage Val Savage is the son of Theo Savage, brother of Annabeth Marcus, and brother-inlaw to Jimmy Marcus. Like all the Savage brothers, he is very short in stature and somewhat psychotic. Val is involved in criminal activities. He used to be in Jimmy’s gang before Jimmy went to prison, and remains very loyal to him. Val helps Jimmy murder Dave and dump his body in the Mystic River.
Silent Ray See Ray Harris Jr.
Vincent Bobby O’Donnell Bobby is a twenty-something small-time crime boss who, among other things, runs some prostitution rings and acts as muscle in the neighborhood. Bobby had been dating Katie Marcus. As far as she is concerned, the relationship has ended, but Bobby does not necessarily agree. Because of their relationship, Bobby is an early suspect in her death but it is discovered that he was in jail on a drunk driving charge at the time.
Johnny O’Shea Johnny is Silent Ray’s friend. He takes part in the murder of Katie Marcus. When Sean and Whitey figure out that Ray is involved in the crime and go to the Harris apartment to confront him, Johnny holds a gun on Sean before he is arrested. This experience leads Sean to reconcile with his wife.
Eve Pigeon Eve is one of Katie Marcus’s best friends. She and Diane Cestra celebrate Katie’s last night in Boston, and then they spend the night at Eve’s house while Katie drives away alone. Eve reveals to Sean and Whitey that Katie was planning to elope with Brendan.
Sergeant Whitey Powers Whitey is Sean Devine’s partner in the investigation into Katie Marcus’s murder. A sergeant, Whitey is very experienced with similar crimes and diligent in his pursuit of the truth. Whitey questions Sean’s motivations for being
1 5 8
L i t e r a r y
Vincent is a young male prostitute known as Little Vince. An encounter between Little Vince and August Larson prompts Dave to murder August. After August’s murder, Little Vince disappears from East Buckingham.
THEMES Power of the Past A primary theme of Mystic River is the power the past can have over people’s lives. While the friendship between Sean, Dave, and Jimmy is not particularly deep, Dave’s kidnapping and molestation tie them together for life. Both Sean and Jimmy are aware that their lives would have been very different had they gotten in the car that day. Dave does not understand why the kidnappers picked him and does not talk about what happened to him. Sean has always been much more troubled by the kidnapping incident than Jimmy. It affects his thoughts, concerns, and motivations. Jimmy does reflect from time to time on what could have been, but he does not dwell on it as heavily as Sean and Dave do. Just after he identifies his daughter’s body, Jimmy and his wife are giving Sean and Whitey initial information for their investigation. He tells Sean, ‘‘If we had gotten in that car, been driven off to God knows where and had God knows what done to us. . . . I think I would have been a basket case.’’ Dave’s kidnapping and molestation have colored his entire existence. He has shut this
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
M y s t i c
part of himself off from everyone else. Most people who know what happened treat him differently. The few times when Dave thinks or talks about what happened, he talks about his own desire to molest, which he has been curbed successfully. However, Dave’s rage gets the better of him when he sees a man having sex with an underage male prostitute. Dave’s continual battle with his past ultimately costs him his life.
R i v e r
worried that the men will return for him. As an adult, Dave marries Celeste and they have a son. Celeste’s difficult mother, Rosemary, lives with them until her death. Dave keeps a part of himself hidden away from his wife as well as from the rest of the world. He does not trust even his wife to fully understand what happened to him as a boy and how it has tainted his whole existence.
Neighborhood and Community Family and Familial Relations Another prominent theme in Mystic River is the importance of family. Each of the three main characters has families and familial relationships that provide depth and motivation for their actions. For example, Jimmy’s entire adult life has been focused on providing for his family. Upon his release from prison, he is a single father to young Katie. They develop a very deep, loving bond, broken only by her death. Instead of returning to a life of crime after his release, Jimmy opens a corner store, remarries, and has two more daughters. He lives in an apartment below some of his in-laws, who help him when he decides to conduct an informal investigation into his daughter’s death. Jimmy even reconnects with Dave when Dave marries his wife’s first cousin, Celeste. After Jimmy kills Dave, Annabeth defends his actions by telling him he was protecting his family. She tells their children that they never have to worry about being safe because ‘‘Daddy is a king, not a prince. And kings know what must be done—even if it’s hard—to make things right.’’
Related to the theme of family is the strength and importance of the neighborhood in Mystic River. The bulk of the action takes place in a part of fictional East Buckingham called the Flats. It is a working-class neighborhood with many Irish American families. Everyone seems to know everyone else, and many people in the neighborhood go to Jimmy’s corner store. A key clue to Katie’s murder is the fact that she said ‘‘hi’’ to one of her killers. Many who live in the Flats feel protective of the neighborhood and resent the yuppies and college students who are gentrifying the area and raising the cost of living for long-time residents. Dave rants on several occasions about how these people negatively affect both him and the others who live in the Flats. Nearly every character in Mystic River has spent his or her whole life in the neighborhood and fears being forced to leave by economic factors.
Violence and Crime
Dave was raised by a single, overprotective mother, with his uncles acting as his male influences. After his kidnapping and molestation, his mother becomes even more protective of him,
Petty crime and violence are facts of life in East Buckingham. While the narrative shows how crime and violence have lasting detrimental effects, it also shows that crime can be committed with honorable ends. The novel’s catalyst is the kidnapping and molestation of Dave Boyle in 1975. As the victim of a horrible crime himself, Dave acts violently. The trauma of his molestation causes him to kill August Larson, a man who is having sex with a child prostitute in a car. Dave commits a crime, but given the atrocity of his victim’s actions, readers are unlikely to feel that what Dave has done is really wrong. Jimmy was a successful criminal in his youth, and his inlaws continue to live on the wrong side of the law. Jimmy does not trust the authorities to bring Katie’s killer to justice. He takes matters into his own hands and murders Dave in cold blood because he believes Dave killed his daughter. After this incident, Jimmy plans to return to his criminal ways. At the same time, the fact that Jimmy kills Just Ray and then sends money to
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
Sean’s and Dave’s family relationships are more fractured than Jimmy’s, yet still important to who they are and how they act. Sean has a distant relationship with his parents, especially his father, and cannot communicate well with them. Though Sean fulfills their expectations and goes to college, his marriage to Lauren, a college sweetheart, is temporarily broken by infidelities. She continues to contact him, calling him from the road, but does not say anything. He talks to her, hoping to re-connect. When Sean calls her after Johnny pulled a gun on him, the couple reunites and their family is restored. Sean becomes a loving father to his infant daughter, Nora.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 5 9
M y s t i c
R i v e r
WHAT DO I READ NEXT? Darkness, Take My Hand (1996) is another novel by Dennis Lehane that deals with pedophiles and children. The effects of these attacks also have long-term repercussions. The novel is part of Lehane’s series featuring the detectives Angie Gennaro and Patrick Kenzie. The Wanderers (1974), by Richard Price, is a book that Lehane cites as influential in his writing career. The story focuses on a gang of teenagers living in the Bronx in the 1960s. Lehane’s Shutter Island (2003) is another stand-alone novel. Like Mystic River, the book focuses on a criminal investigation, which is conducted by two federal marshals. This case involves a missing patient from a mental institution who is criminally insane. National Book Award nominee Bastard Out of Carolina (1993) is a novel by Dorothy Allison. The story focuses on a young girl who is sexually abused.
Gone, Baby, Gone (1998) is another novel by Lehane that focuses on a missing girl. The novel also features the detective team of Kenzie and Gennaro, who are investigating her disappearance.
Dark Harbor (2005), a murder mystery by David Hosp, features a story set in Boston with characters from that city’s neighborhoods.
his victim’s family shows how he has some integrity. Sean’s job as a trooper is to investigate acts of crime and violence, so though he is not the victim or the perpetrator, he is still affected by their consequences nonetheless.
Strength and Weakness An underlying theme of Mystic River is the strong versus the weak. From the beginning, the book presents Dave as a weak person. He is first
1 6 0
L i t e r a r y
described as ‘‘a kid with girl’s wrists and weak eyes.’’ The narrative implies that Dave’s needy weakness contributed to his kidnapping; in fact, Dave often thought, ‘‘How had they known he’d climb in that car, and that Jimmy and Sean wouldn’t?. . . . Those men . . . had known Jimmy and Sean wouldn’t have gotten into that car without a fight.’’ Dave wants to be strong as an adult but never achieves this goal around Jimmy and those he has known his whole life in the Flats. At the same time, though the murder he commits derives from his personal pain and demons, the act does exhibit some strength of character, as he is attempting to protect a child from a fate similar to his own. When Jimmy confesses to Annabeth the murders of Just Ray and Dave, she admits she knew what was going on with Dave but did not prevent Jimmy from murdering him. She tells Jimmy, ‘‘They . . . are weak.’’ She then clarifies her statement by saying ‘‘Everyone. . . Everyone but us.’’ Later, she says, ‘‘We will never be weak.’’ Both Jimmy and Annabeth are strong, domineering people who have gotten their way and seemingly will continue to do so.
STYLE Third-Person Point of View The point of view describes the perspective from which the story is told, while structure is the way the author sets up the plot of the story. These qualities are linked in Mystic River. Lehane uses a third-person omniscient point of view, allowing readers to see every character and action from an all-knowing perspective. This allows the reader insight into characters’ motives and thoughts. Lehane uses this technique to create a structure of shifting perspectives. Mystic River is told in brief episodes that move between the characters and their thread of the story.
Inner Monologue Conversation between characters is called dialogue, while a character’s thought process is an inner monologue. Lehane uses a significant amount of revealing dialogue between characters in Mystic River, but also discloses Sean’s, Dave’s, and Jimmy’s innermost thoughts and motivations through their internal voices. The characters do not talk to themselves; instead, Lehane describes what each character is thinking
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
M y s t i c
about themselves, their pasts, and their presents. The style of each monologue reflects each character’s psychology. Sean and Jimmy’s thoughts are usually organized, reflective, and reactive. At times, especially when Dave is thinking about his abduction, his inner monologue is chaotic and rushed.
Triple Protagonist A protagonist is a primary, driving character in a story. Mystic River, employs three protagonists, Jimmy, Sean, and Dave. All three characters play significant parts in the development of the novel’s story. None dominates the story individually, and each has his own strengths and weaknesses. Jimmy could be considered the villain, Sean the hero, and Dave the victim. However, Jimmy has many redeeming qualities, including love for his family, while Sean is plagued with self-doubt and fear in his personal life. Alternatively, all three of the men could be considered both victims and survivors. It is the collective qualities of Sean, Jimmy, and Dave that make a complex single protagonist in Mystic River.
HISTORICAL CONTEXT Child Abduction, Victimization, and Pedophilia Though child kidnapping and rape are not new crimes, the methods predators use to find victims have changed over time. In Mystic River’s prologue, set in 1975, Dave is taken by two strange men in a car. The fear of men looking for random victims on the street was a common one in the 1950s and 1960s. In the 1970s came the realization that children were generally sexually abused by people they knew rather than strangers. The focus of public education campaigns gradually changed to reflect this knowledge. Laws were also passed to help protect children. The 1978 Sexual Exploitation of Children Act made illegal obscene materials (primarily sexually explicit magazines and other types of pornography) that feature minors.
R i v e r
Internet in the early 2000s. While these numbers continued to increase, the same article also stated that ‘‘most child sexual abuse occurs with family members or adults known to the child.’’ Though children are still kidnapped off the street or from their homes, by both strangers and family members, the Internet allows pedophiles and other sexual criminals to build a relationship with their victims. Whenever a child is online, he or she can be easily and unknowingly approached by someone seeking a sexual relationship. A 2000 study by the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children revealed that almost one in every five Internet users in the United States between the ages of ten and seventeen has been approached. This means that millions of children have been approached: by 2002, more than twenty-eight million children in the United States have used the Internet.
Gentrification Gentrification occurs when population shifts, upgraded housing, and a surge in investments transform an older, working class neighborhood into a more affluent one, displacing the working class people who live there. The idea of gentrification underlies the story in Mystic River, and was indeed a motivation for Lehane writing the novel. He told Bob Minzesheimer of USA Today that he pondered ‘‘what would happen to [a working-class Boston] neighborhood once the Saabs outnumbered the Chevys and the corner store became a Starbucks.’’
In the early 2000s, when Mystic River was written, many children were being lured into sexual situations in a different way: over the Internet. According to an article in CQ Researcher, the FBI investigated at least 1,500 cases of the exploitation of children via the
In Boston, this process was accelerated in the late 1990s and early 2000s with a hot real estate market and increasingly high housing costs. Campus housing for the many institutions of higher learning in the city was often in short supply. College students and young urban professionals moved into neighborhoods like the one depicted in Mystic River because housing was cheaper than in other locations. As these new tenants moved into the area, rents increased. The newcomers were willing to pay more than the working-class people that had been living there. This action forced out longtime residents, who had a hard time finding new housing. City officials, including Mayor Thomas M. Menino, and activist groups worked to provide affordable housing solutions for lower income families.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 6 1
M y s t i c
R i v e r
Oil barges sit docked on the Chelsea, Massachusetts side of the Mystic River, with downtown Boston in the background Neal Hamberg/Bloomberg News/Landov
poetic, and his descriptions convey feeling and detail without wasting a word.’’
CRITICAL OVERVIEW Mystic River is regarded by many critics as Lehane’s breakthrough novel, and it received generally positive reviews. Though the author had seen success with his five previous novels, a crime fiction series featuring the detectives Angie Gennaro and Patrick Kenzie, Mystic River is widely regarded as being of a higher quality than his Gennaro-Kenzie books. Critics praised many literary elements of the novel, including character, setting, and writing style. Carol Memmott of USA Today wrote, ‘‘Lehane has let loose with a standalone novel of depth and fervent passion.’’ A particular aspect of Mystic River that a number of critics commented on was the complexity of his characters. David Pitt wrote in Booklist, ‘‘Lehane is one of the small group of crime writers whose novels reveal a deep fascination with people, with motivation and inner turmoil and the subtle things that make characters walk off the page.’’ Others noted how carefully Lehane crafted his text. In Charleston, South Carolina’s Post and Courier, Mindy Spar claimed, ‘‘Lehane has created a writer’s crime novel. His style is almost
1 6 2
L i t e r a r y
Some critics found fault with Mystic River, including a few who admired his previous works. Bella English of the Boston Globe wrote, ‘‘Mystic River is neither as fast-paced nor as tightly written as his Kenzie-Gennaro series. Lehane fans no doubt will miss the chemistry between those two.’’ While praising some aspects of Lehane’s work, including his style and character development, Washington Post writer David Corn commented, ‘‘Lehane does a better job creating the threads than weaving them together.’’ Even the somewhat negative reviews had positive aspects to them, and most critics regarded Mystic River as an artistic triumph for Lehane. Thomas Mackin in World of Hibernia states, ‘‘Singular adjectives fail to capture the engrossing power of this murder mystery.’’
CRITICISM A. Petruso Petruso is a freelance writer and editor, with an undergraduate degree in history and Master’s
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
M y s t i c
degree in screenwriting. In this essay, Petruso considers how the idea of insider versus outsider manifests in the characters of the novel, as well as the dynamics of their neighborhoods. In Mystic River, a palpable tension exists between insiders and outsiders—people who belong and people who do not. Although the events in the novel blur the distinction between insider and outsider, the tension between these two conditions plays as important a role in the plot as it does in the daily lives of the novel’s characters. The communal characteristics of the Flats neighborhood create opportunities for safety, victimization, criminalization, and absolution, and thus, this theme drives the action of the story. Nearly all the residents of the Flats have spent their entire lives in the neighborhood, with the exception of a few who have served prison time. These residents are insiders; everyone else is an outsider. As the definitive representative of the Flats, Jimmy understands the unwritten rules of living in his tight-knit community. The rules appear to be that one insider cannot betray another; an insider criminal should not inform on a cohort; an insider should not kill another insider’s child. Jimmy’s actions show one of the major features of insider status: community members understand and follow a set of rules different from the authority of law. Jimmy kills Dave because he thinks Dave killed his daughter. Yet when Jimmy learns the truth about who Dave killed and why, he has no problem with what Dave did. In one respect, this may be because of the atrocious act August Larson commits. On another level, however, it seems that an insider killing an outsider is okay. Summarizing this idea, Bella English of the Boston Globe writes, The novel . . . underscores the clannish, skewed morality in the neighborhood: It’s no big deal to bash in the brains of a suburban man who’s in the wrong place at the wrong time, while killing a local teenage girl is a capital offense.
The underlying insider/outsider tension plays an important role in the moment that ties Jimmy, Dave, and Sean together for life. The three are not particularly close friends as tenand eleven-year-old boys. They play together on a few Saturdays because Sean’s father and Jimmy’s father work together, and Dave always tags along with Jimmy. Dave and Jimmy, residents of the Flats, possess a neighborhood
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
R i v e r
AS MYSTIC RIVER UNFOLDS, IT IS AS IF SEAN MUST WORK THROUGH KATIE’S MURDER CASE TO ATONE FOR WHAT HAPPENED TO DAVE. AS SOMEONE WITH A PERSONAL STAKE IN THE CASE, SEAN PROBABLY SHOULD HAVE PULLED HIMSELF OFF THE CASE BUT COULD NOT.’’
identity that eventually would have caused them to drift away from Sean, a resident of the nicer Point area. Had it not been for Dave’s abduction, Sean, Dave, and Jimmy probably would not have considered themselves more than passing acquaintances. One might argue that Dave’s outsider status in the Point neighborhood contributes to his victimization. Only Dave, who does not say that he lives in the Point, is kidnapped and molested. To evade the pedophiles, Jimmy lies and says he lives nearby, and the incident happens in front of the relative safety of Sean’s house. The tragedy is a thread that links the three and affects them in a way that those outside the situation can never fully understand. Ironically, the event assigns Sean a quasiinsider status, in spite of the fact that he is set up as an outsider from the beginning of the novel. He lives in the Point, a neighborhood distinct from the Flats, though part of the same general area of Boston called East Buckingham. While the Point is working class like the Flats, people consider the area a little better off than the Flats. ‘‘It wasn’t like the Point glittered with gold streets and silver spoons. . . . But people in the Point owned. People in the Flats rented . . . . and the Point and the Flats didn’t mix much.’’ While Jimmy and Dave attend a public school, Sean attends private parochial school. Later, Sean goes to college, while Dave has his glory years in public high school as a baseball star and Jimmy becomes an accomplished criminal who is brought down only by another’s betrayal. Ultimately, Dave’s kidnapping further emphasizes Sean’s outsider status. Sean never goes to the Flats to see Jimmy and Dave.
V o l u m e
1
1 6 3
M y s t i c
R i v e r
Although Sean does not invite them, Jimmy and Dave visit Sean in the Point. They leave the familiar environment of their neighborhood and, as a result, Dave suffers the consequences of going to an outsider’s place. Because he is not in his own neighborhood, the men are able to convince Dave to get in their car. As someone from a neighborhood where ‘‘families went to church, stayed together, and held signs on street corners during election months,’’ Sean makes choices in his life that continue to make him an outsider to those he once knew in the Flats. He graduates from college and while a student, he meets Lauren, the daughter of hippie liberals who served in the Peace Corps. The couple marries and though they have marital problems that create tension, they ultimately get back together and work on their marriage and family. One of the most important choices Sean makes to cement his outsider status is becoming a state trooper. The cases he investigates take him many places, including the same neighborhoods he has been trying to leave his whole life. Though it is not stated directly in the text of Mystic River, it would seem that Sean made the choice to become an authority figure because of what happened to Dave and how helpless Sean had felt when it happened. Though Sean was too young at the time to investigate that crime, as an adult he can make a difference in other cases. Given his background, it is fitting that he chooses to do so using the upstanding, legal path. As Mystic River unfolds, it is as if Sean must work through Katie’s murder case to atone for what happened to Dave. As someone with a personal stake in the case, Sean probably should have pulled himself off the case but could not. While Sean is an outsider to the Flats, Dave’s kidnapping ties him to Jimmy and Dave, and by extension, to their community. Because of his connection to Jimmy and Dave, Sean’s participation in the murder investigations of Katie and of August Larson borders on conflict of interest. His partner, Whitey, asks him early on if he is too personally invested in the case, but Sean dismisses his concerns. He is determined to see justice in the case involving his friends, perhaps to atone for what happened when they were children. The police and other authorities are not exactly trusted in the Flats. The way Lehane writes it, many Flats insiders consider those on
1 6 4
L i t e r a r y
the opposite side of the law more trustworthy than the police. As an insider, Jimmy earns more respect in the community for his career choices than Sean does. Jimmy’s first job is as a professional criminal, until someone he trusts, Just Ray Harris, rats him out. After an honorable prison sentence—taking the fall so no one else would have to—Jimmy leads a relatively straight life but does so as a neighborhood insider. He supports his family by owning a corner store, an institution that can be the heart of a neighborhood. Though he lives a straight life, Jimmy’s inlaws are still criminals, and Jimmy himself still has power derived from criminality in the area. Early in the novel, insider Dave Boyle complains on several occasions about how yuppies are taking over the neighborhood and causing rents to rise. He worries he will lose his home and perhaps have to leave East Buckingham. He tells Whitey and Sean that the neighborhood needs a good crime wave to make it unappealing to the outsiders who are steadily encroaching. Interestingly, the man Dave murders is a suburbanite who was in the area specifically to have sex with a young male prostitute. While Jimmy Marcus, a consummate neighborhood insider, shares some of Dave’s anxieties that gentrification will permanently change the neighborhood, he is not as hostile to outsiders as Dave. His first marriage was to an outsider, a Puerto Rican woman named Marita. Although she died of cancer while he was in prison, he admits that he loved her more than he does his second wife, who is a neighborhood insider. After his daughter Katie’s death, he remembers a time when he and Katie saw a production of William Shakespeare’s The Taming of the Shrew and how Katie spent the next six months expressing her desire to live in Italy after high school. Jimmy was dismissive of her dreams. He considered her a resident of the Flats for life; an insider, just like himself. The tension between outsiders and insiders contributes to the underlying drama in the novel and helps add depth to the plot. This tension which manifests itself in the character of Sean without much detriment to him, takes a much greater toll on Dave. He is simultaneously an insider and an outsider and cannot reconcile that conflict. While Dave is definitely an insider in the Flats, as an adult he questions that status because of his abduction and its consequences. It is as if he is an outsider because of what
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
M y s t i c
happened to him as child. He is the boy taken away from his neighborhood, his mother, and his friends, and abused by two men he dubs wolves. The fact that he struggles with the compulsion to victimize other children, the ultimate betrayal of a community’s integrity, makes his status as a solid community member uncertain. By the time he reaches adulthood, his accomplishments on the baseball field in high school have caused people’s memories of him as a child victim to fade. As far as most people in the Flats are concerned, Dave is one of them. But he cannot let the incident go. Dave’s kidnapping raises an important related question: What if the incident had happened in front of Jimmy’s home? Would the Flats, depicted as being more close-knit than the Point, especially in 1975, have been quiet enough for this incident to occur? After the kidnappers force Dave into their car, Sean’s street becomes ‘‘empty again . . . gone mute with the slam of the car door.’’ Furthermore, only one witness heard anything the night of Katie’s murder because the street it occurred on was empty, burned out, and lost in the urban shuffle; only one old woman lived there. In 1975, the street had been more vital. While Sean’s street was not exactly vacant, Lehane depicts those who live in the Point as more concerned with their own well-being than that of the neighborhood as a whole. When Dave returns to the Flats after his kidnapping, the narrator compares the lively block party he receives with what might have occurred in the Point: ‘‘They had block parties, sure, but they were always planned, the necessary permits obtained, everyone making sure everyone else was careful around cars, careful on the lawns. . . .’’ In the Flats, neighbors are the same as family; people who live there are less concerned with the privacy of others. Flats residents are insiders because their community encourages it. They possess a unified identity of extended family. Point residents appear to have no community to be inside of at all, and therefore are a neighborhood of outsiders. When Dave returns, it seems everyone who lived in the Flats attends his party. Although crime and violence seem to be commonplace in the Flats and the Point neighborhood may contain more law-abiding citizens, the investment that Flats insiders have in their community may have made it a safer place to live.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
R i v e r
TOPICS FOR FURTHER STUDY In a one-page essay, compare and contrast the film version of Mystic River with the book. What aspects of the novel changed when it was adapted to film? Would you have left in these parts? What was lost and what was gained by adapting the book into a movie? Which version most effectively depicts the basic story? Look up the definition for ‘‘feminism in literature’’ and in a one-page essay, examine the complex way in which women are depicted in Mystic River. Would you consider Lehane a feminist author? Are any of the women feminist in nature? How would you describe the kinds of women depicted in the book? The issue of social class underscores the story in Mystic River. Most of the characters in the book are working class. Throughout its history, Boston has been known for its class tensions. Find a book or film that explores this topic. Make a one-page list that compares and contrasts how the book or film you find and Mystic River deal with social class.
The ending of Mystic River leaves open the possibility of a sequel. Sean has yet to prove that Jimmy killed Just Ray and Dave Boyle, while Jimmy plans a return to the criminal life. If you were going to write a sequel to the novel, where would you take the story? How do you see the drama playing out based on what you know? Write a one-page summary of the sequel, giving the second book an original title.
Source: A. Petruso, Critical Essay on Mystic River, in Literary Newsmakers for Students, Thomson Gale, 2006.
Adam Dunn In the following essay, Dunn visits the south Boston neighborhoods on which Mystic River’s fictional Buckingham is based to learn about Lehane’s impetus to write and how his experiences in those neighborhoods inspire his fiction.
V o l u m e
1
1 6 5
M y s t i c
R i v e r
couple of years ago, my father was still telling me when the postal exams were, just in case.’’ THE FRAGMENTATION AND DENIAL WITHIN DAVE’S MIND IS ILLUSTRATIVE OF WHAT HAPPENS TO EVERYONE IN MYSTIC RIVER.’’
Dennis Lehane did not want to work for Boston Gas. Nor did he want to work for Boston Edison or the post office. He had no ambitions to enter the priesthood or politics. Instead, he wanted to write. His parents (who emigrated to Boston from Ireland in the 1940s) were duly horrified. Fortunately, Ann and Michael Lehane’s son seems to have made the right decision. Mystic River, his sixth novel, finds the author transcending the genre label of crime novelist that his earlier books have earned him, placing him at the intersection of crime and literary fiction. Mystic River is a mystery novel that pushes up out of the genre, a book that uses the whodunit premise to delve deeply into the conundrum of how people who are supposedly ‘‘close’’ are actually as far from one another as distant planets whirling through the void. The book which has strong backing from publisher William Morrow, is a Book of the Month Club Main Selection and has had its foreign rights already sold in five countries—could put Lehane’s rising literary star into a whole new orbit. Not bad for someone whose most lucrative job, not so long ago, was parking cars. Lehane’s journey has had its snags. Prior to the publication of his first novel, the path of his writing career resembled a bungee jump from Massachusetts to Florida, with the recoil snapping him back: ‘‘I went to two colleges, two different majors, and dropped out of both of ’em,’’ admits Lehane, who at thirty-five still looks like a frat boy lost on the way to the party. ‘‘I was twenty and I said, ‘I really suck at everything. The only thing I’ve ever been good at is writing.’’’ His parents wanted their restless son to settle into a more secure profession. ‘‘It’s the immigrant dream,’’ Lehane says, slouched in a chair in what is best described as a writer’s fantasy office: floor-to-ceiling bookshelves, wall-towall desk space and no telephone. ‘‘Get the secure job. Get the pension. Lock it in. Until a
1 6 6
L i t e r a r y
While Lehane was growing up, South Boston and neighboring Dorchester (where he lived) were reeling from poverty, street violence (particularly against forced busing), lethal street drugs (cheerfully supplied by the notorious IrishAmerican gangster James ‘‘Whitey’’ Bulger and his ilk) and an alarming suicide rate. Yet both South Boston and Dorchester were some of the most tight-knit, closed neighborhoods in the city, where outsiders were distrusted and visitors unwelcome. Over beer, and under the eyes of his two faithful bulldogs, Lehane explains the dynamics of Dorchester in the 1970s in a subdued but frank voice. ‘‘When I was growing up it was, ‘We are all Irish, we are all Polish, we are all Catholic—all others, stay the f—k out.’ Boston’s neighborhoods went through explosive tensions, not always racial. A lot of times it was just, ‘Outsiders, go away.’’’ That grim take on neighborhood communality forms the backdrop of Lehane’s serial novels, as well as the fictionalized world of Mystic River. ‘‘Dorchester is one of many built-in neighborhoods in Boston, and sometimes neighborhood pride has a dark side,’’ says Lehane’s high school friend Chris Mullen (whose name Lehane used for a drug dealer character in his fourth novel, Gone, Baby, Gone). ‘‘Not quite a Charlestown code-of-silence pride, but akin to that. My family moved out of Dorchester during busing. Dennis’ didn’t, and I think from his point of view, there was a constant tension. Within a block of his home, things got very dicey during the busing era—for a while that whole neighborhood was going in the wrong direction. I can see the basis for some of the crimes he writes about. I think that when Dennis portrays the neighborhood in his books, and especially when he writes dialogue, his voice rings truer to me than many other writers, because he was there.’’ Lehane convinced his worried parents that he’d be able to take care of himself as a writer. ‘‘I’d been doing it since I was eight. I said I wanted to major in writing, that I could get a degree and teach, so I could always make a living doing that.’’ Lehane got a scholarship and left crowded Dorchester, heading south to Eckerd College, a small school on the Gulf of Mexico in St. Petersburg, Florida—an area he now refers to as ‘‘paradise.’’ ‘‘I remember stepping on the
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
M y s t i c
campus and thinking, This is it. This is my life. All I wanted to learn was how to be good.’’ Eschewing the concerns typical of many young writers, Lehane hunkered down in his newfound paradise and began to do the hard work necessary to become a ‘‘good’’ writer. ‘‘I didn’t care about publishing. I didn’t even like hearing about publishing in workshops—it’s putting the cart before the horse. I still get annoyed by that. It’s a very simple theorem: Learn how to write, write a good book, it’ll get published. You’ll get published—just learn how to write first. There’s no other method that I know of.’’ Lehane’s early attempts involved short stories, which he believed to be his niche. Some of his teachers and classmates encouraged him to send some of his best to The New Yorker; he decided against it and continued working on his craft, a decision he does not regret. ‘‘I look at people who can do it well—like Andre Dubus or Denis Johnson or Thom Jones or Alice Munro or Lorrie Moore—and there’s still a little part of me that wishes I could do that. But I’ve always been lucky in that I have a very good instinct and very little sentimentality about seeing my own limitations. I thought, If I can’t write a short story as well as Dubus, then why the hell am I doing this?’’ While earning his MFA at Florida International University, Lehane casually tried his hand at mystery writing, a genre he always enjoyed as a reader. The book he began to write turned out to be the first draft of A Drink Before the War, the debut novel of his highly successful Kenzie-Gennaro detective series, which centered on a brutal gang war with nods to the Charles Stuart race killing. It took him three weeks to write (but months to rewrite before it was ready for publication).
R i v e r
being a chauffeur—a job he says is well suited for writers. ‘‘I wrote a lot of Darkness, Take My Hand and most of Sacred from the front seat of a limousine,’’ he chuckles. Lehane laughs a lot, which, given the course of events in his life, is not surprising, though it does belie an intensely serious creative drive that has seen him through six books and innumerable short stories. Lehane’s first novel, A Drink Before the War, was followed at the pace of about one per year by Darkness, Take My Hand; Sacred; Gone, Baby, Gone; and Prayers for Rain (all of which share Dorchester and South Boston as common settings). After the success of Prayers for Rain (film rights for which were purchased by Paramount Pictures, with Lehane writing the script), the author decided he needed a break from the Kenzie-Gennaro detective series. He wanted to go deeper into the streets and secrets of the neighborhood of his youth than he ever had before. ‘‘When I first started writing short stories, when I was around seventeen, I’d come up with this little world in my head, which I discarded sometime in college. I thought, OK, if we’re going back to third person, just step back as a writer to a place I’d once been very comfortable, let’s go all the way. Let’s do Buckingham.’’ What may have been plain boredom with the first-person point of view of his earlier books gave way, unexpectedly, to something far richer: the world of Buckingham, a fictitious amalgam of the Boston neighborhoods of Dorchester, South Boston, Charlestown and Brighton, described in Mystic River as ‘‘a neighborhood of cramped corner stores, small playgrounds and butcher shops where meat, still pink with blood, hung in the windows.’’
‘‘Coming from the world I was in, writing very esoteric short fiction, when I wrote a mystery, I knew exactly what boundary I was stepping over. I was leaving one camp and stepping into another, and I had no illusions about it,’’ the author says.
What better place to set a crime novel than amid the various crime scenes one has witnessed in childhood? The day after the original interview, Lehane offers a drive through ‘‘Buckingham,’’ a tour that would likely never pass muster with Boston’s tourism bureau.
After receiving his master’s, Lehane returned to Massachusetts, where he found work best suited for someone of his qualifications—parking cars. ‘‘I needed to do that,’’ he says. ‘‘I got ragged on a lot—‘Hey, how’s that master’s workin’ for ya?’—but it was fun. It was my last little-kid job.’’ By the time Lehane’s first book had been published, he had upgraded to
Various points of interest include the bleak, sloping grounds near St. Margaret’s Church, where one childhood acquaintance murdered another over a pair of sneakers, and the Southie convenience store where a friend’s night shift unexpectedly ended with a shotgun blast at pointblank range. (The store sits in the middle of a busy intersection, and no one claims
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 6 7
M y s t i c
R i v e r
to have seen a thing.) Lehane refuses to stop or even slow down his truck when we come upon the Old Colony housing projects, still a major source of South Boston’s drug trade. We drive slowly by the intersection of Gannon and Bakersfield streets, site of the child abduction at the outset of Mystic River that reverberates throughout the lives of its three protagonists. Our final stop is by the tangled girders beneath the Tobin Bridge, where even full sunlight cannot reach through the maze of steel. Lehane describes this final destination as ‘‘a good place to die.’’ Clearly, he has no shortage of background material from which to draw Buckingham. But he believes there was enough room in Mystic River to explore such deeper issues as marriage, parenthood and self-determination. The three protagonists struggle to make sense of a sudden murder in their midst (which takes place in a theater in a park that Lehane still refuses to enter alone), and proceed to make a fine mess of it. These thematic interests, as well as Lehane’s extraordinarily fleshed-out characters (whom Claire Wachtel, his editor at William Morrow, calls ‘‘ten-dimensional’’), will signal to attentive readers early on that Mystic River is no workaday whodunit story. The novel also breaks from Lehane’s previous books, with its stark attention to real-life details within real-life situations. ‘‘The private-eye novel is limited to a certain structure,’’ he says. ‘‘You’re dealing with an archetypal form; it’s basically what replaced the Western. There are certain laws to that form, and the more you write about those characters, the less they can do, the more confined they become.’’ Gone are the wild shoot-outs and chase scenes from the Kenzie-Gennaro series. With help from Trooper Robert Manning of the Massachusetts State Police Homicide Bureau (a connection arranged by Lehane’s brother-in-law, Sgt. Mike Lawn of the Watertown Police Department), Lehane was able to depict the police investigation in Mystic River with incredible detail and accuracy: ‘‘I think Dennis, without speaking for him, was looking for concrete specifics on how a case is completed from start to finish, instead of some fictionalized account that’s dramatized,’’ Manning says. Lehane’s attention to detail forced him to revisit some difficult experiences of his own. While still in school he drifted into social work and eventually worked with abused children.
1 6 8
L i t e r a r y
‘‘Every summer and Christmas I’d come home, and all my friends were working with the handicapped, because overtime wasn’t a problem. Eighty-hour weeks weren’t a problem.’’ Lehane does not elaborate much on his short career working with abused children, save to imply that the overall experience was unpleasant. But it reverberates throughout his serial novels, culminating in Mystic River’s Dave Boyle, a man with a secret of childhood abuse that is slowly and horrifically resuscitated over the course of the novel. The fragmentation and denial within Dave’s mind is illustrative of what happens to everyone in Mystic River. The murder at the heart of the book sets the stage for a collision between the novel’s three main characters, themselves childhood acquaintances and witnesses to a terrible crime twenty-five years earlier that tore their friendship apart. As adults, they are adrift and isolated, from themselves and everyone around them, ever since a car that ‘‘smelled like apples’’ rolled down Gannon Street, changing things forever. ‘‘I have an obsession with innocence lost,’’ Lehane says. ‘‘I try to get rid of it, but I can’t. What I can do, as a craftsman, is not repeat the details. Pedophilia is done. I’ve done it in three books. Now I’ve said all I have to say about it. There’s a fine line between writing about something and exploiting it.’’ With Mystic River flowing on course, Lehane’s thoughts are with his next novel, in which he plans to return to the Kenzie-Gennaro series. ‘‘The series isn’t over, but I thought that the characters needed a break,’’ he says. ‘‘In Prayers for Rain, I wrapped up some character lines that have been hanging there since the first book.’’ The new Kenzie-Gennaro novel will be the second in a five-book contract with William Morrow, of which Mystic River was the first. Lehane seems on firm ground with his direction. ‘‘The perfect balance,’’ he says, ‘‘would be to do a series book, then do a standalone and so on in that sequence. It keeps the characters fresh.’’ Source: Adam Dunn, ‘‘A Good Place to Die,’’ in Book, Vol. 52, March 2001, p. 52.
SOURCES Corn, David, ‘‘Lies and Whispers,’’ in the Washington Post, March 4, 2001, p. T09.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
M y s t i c
R i v e r
Tim Robbins and Sean Penn, stars of the 2003 film version of Mystic River, flank the film’s director, Clint Eastwood, at a party following the 2004 Academy Awards AP/Wide World Photos
English, Bella, ‘‘River Doesn’t Flow Like Earlier Novels,’’ in the Boston Globe, February 22, 2001, p. D2. Hansen, Brian, ‘‘Can Internet Child Sexual Exploitation Be Controlled?’’ in CQ Researcher, Vol. 12, No. 8, March 1, 2002, pp. 1, 2, 10. Lehane, Dennis, Mystic River, William Morrow, 2000. Mackin, Thomas, ‘‘The Critical Reader Review of Mystic River,’’ in World of Hibernia, Vol. 7, No. 2, Autumn 2001, pp. 20–22. Memmott, Carol, ‘‘Mysteries Probe Modern Hearts of Darkness River Runs Through Life’s Nether Regions,’’ in USA Today, February 8, 2001, p. 8D. Pitt, David, Review of Mystic River, in Booklist, Vol. 97, No. 6, November 15, 2000, p. 588. Spar, Mindy, ‘‘Mystic River well-crafted,’’ in the Post and Courier, April 15, 2001. Stillinger, Alice, ‘‘Can’t Take Dorchester Out of the Writer,’’ in the Boston Globe, March 25, 2001, p. 3.
This work contains a number of essays that consider the economic and social history of Boston, focusing on the twentieth century and its impact on residents and businesses in the city. Fass, Paula S., Kidnapped: Child Abduction in America, Harvard University Press, 1999. This nonfiction work explores the history of child kidnappings in the United States from 1874 forward and includes analysis of major public cases. Lanning, Kenneth V., Child Molesters: A Behavioral Analysis, National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, 2001. Lanning, a profiler with the FBI, analyzes in depth what makes a child molester tick. Smith, Neil, The New Urban Frontier: Gentrification and the Revanchist City, Routledge, 1996. In this book, Smith expounds on many aspects of gentrification and its effect on cities.
Bluestone, Barry, and Mary Huff Stevenson, The Boston Renaissance: Race, Space, and Economic Change in An American Metropolis, Russell Sage Foundation, 2000.
Tarbox, Katherine, Katie.com, Plume Books, 2001. This memoir features the story of the author who was lured by an online sexual predator when she was fourteen years old. Tarbox describes the experience that ultimately led to her sexual assault by the man.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
FURTHER READING
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 6 9
Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America When one is charged a little bit at a time until the expense grows beyond expectations, that is called being ‘‘nickel and dimed.’’ In 2001’s Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America, essayist and social critic Barbara Ehrenreich applies this notion to minimum-wage workers. She argues that their spirit and dignity are chipped away by a culture that allows unjust and unlivable working conditions, which results in their becoming a de facto, or actual without being official, servant class. Spurred on by recent welfare reforms and the growing phenomenon of the working poor in the United States, Ehrenreich poses a hypothetical question of daily concern to many Americans: how difficult is it to live on a minimum-wage job? For the lower class, what does it take to match the income one earns to the expenses one must pay? Rather than simply listen to other people’s accounts, Ehrenreich herself assumes the role of a minimum-wage worker. In different states and in several different jobs, she attempts three times to live for one month at minimum wage, giving up her middle-class comforts to experience the overlooked hardships of a large sector of America. While she freely admits that hers is an unusual situation, she stresses it is also a bestcase scenario; others face many more difficulties in their daily lives, such as the lack of available transportation. Due to an accessible style and subject matter, Nickel and Dimed became a bestseller that helped restart dialogue on the current
1 7 0
BARBARA EHRENREICH 2001
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
state of American work, American values, and the consequences of letting a national emergency remain unacknowledged for too long.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY Though Barbara Ehrenreich is best known for her 2001 investigation of the working poor, Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America, her career as a journalist and social critic spans three decades. Barbara Alexander was born August 26, 1941 in Butte, Montana, the daughter of New Deal Democrats. (The New Deal was legislation presented by President Roosevelt in the wake of the Great Depression. It was based on the idea that the government should intervene to help stabilize the economy.) She earned a bachelor’s degree in chemical physics from Reed College in 1964 and a Ph.D. in cell biology at Rockefeller University. While at Rockefeller, she met her first husband, John Ehrenreich, and became involved in both the antiwar movement and the cause for improving health care for low-income families. This led to two collaborations between the Ehrenreichs: Long March, Short Spring: The Student Uprising at Home and Abroad (1969) and The American Health Empire: Power, Profits, and Politics, a Report from the Health Policy Advisory Center (1971). With Deirdre English, she wrote two more books on health care and one about advice literature, For Her Own Good: One Hundred Fifty Years of the Experts’ Advice on Women (1978). With husband John, she wrote the influential essay ‘‘The ProfessionalManagerial Class,’’ which explored the importance of having left-leaning, or liberal, middle-class intellectuals work with the traditional left of the lower-income working class. She would return to this topic in 1989’s Fear of Falling: The Inner Life of the Middle Class, examining the professional-managerial class’s retreat from liberalism (political ideal that the purpose of government is to ensure individual liberties) and the growing rift between classes. As the conservative Reagan era ushered in the 1980s, Ehrenreich maintained a vigorous liberal perspective while breaking into mainstream media, contributing to the New York Times since 1983 and writing a regular column for Time from 1991 to 1997. Her concerns about feminism, class, and social injustice were expressed in such books as The Hearts of Men: American
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
Barbara Ehrenreich AP/Wide World Photos
Dreams and the Flight from Commitment (1983), and Re-making Love: The Feminization of Sex (1986). In the 1990s, Ehrenreich wrote a fiction novel, Kipper’s Game (1994), and published two essay collections: The Worst Years of Our Lives: Irreverent Notes from a Decade of Greed (1990) and The Snarling Citizen (1995). Published in 1997, Blood Rites: Origins and History of the Passions of War was an ambitious, far-ranging look at violence and its role in society. Ehrenreich married her second husband, Gary Stevenson, in 1983. She has two children from her first marriage. She has served as vicechair and honorary chair of the Democratic Socialists of America, the largest socialist organization in the United States.
PLOT SUMMARY Introduction: Getting Ready The idea for Nickel and Dimed is hatched when Barbara Ehrenreich lunches with Harper’s editor Lewis Lapham. She suggests that somebody should investigate living on minimum wage from the inside: that is, actually living on a
V o l u m e
1
1 7 1
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
minimum wage and reporting the experience. Lapham agrees and says the person should be Ehrenreich herself. The assignment involves working at minimum-wage jobs for one month at a time to see if she can match her earnings to her expenses. Ehrenreich has misgivings. She is from a working-class background and has no desire to return to her roots. People around her suggest that she can recreate the situation of minimum wage without going through the actual hardships. However, she finally agrees to the assignment by imagining it as a scientific experiment. In this spirit, she sets up ground rules: first, she cannot rely on skills derived from her education or her work as a writer; second, she must take the highest paying job possible and actually work; and third, she must find the cheapest living conditions for herself. In retrospect, she admits these rules were not always observed. Ehrenreich sets up other parameters as well: she will always have a car, will never go homeless, and will not go hungry. Ehrenreich acknowledges that she is different from many of the people she will be working with. She is financially comfortable and can walk away from her experiment if she wants. She is white and a native English speaker. She has a car. As for whether the people she deals with can tell she is different than they are, Ehrenreich confesses that the opposite was closer to the truth. Her lack of experience means she is less skilled in many situations. She does not merely pose as a minimum-wage worker; for a period of time, she is, in fact, a minimum-wage worker. The nature of every job she takes, each of which involves some form of physical labor, means that doing the job is never pretend. This fact is brought home by the anticlimactic responses from co-workers when she tells them she is really a writer. Ehrenreich makes no claim for the typicality of her experience; however, she stresses that hers was a best-case scenario and many others live in far worse situations.
One: Serving in Florida Ehrenreich decides to stay close to home for her first experiment, looking for work in Key West, Florida. She begins by finding a place to live: staying in Key West is too expensive, so she finds an efficiency apartment thirty miles away. Next, she sets out to find work, filling out
1 7 2
L i t e r a r y
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
applications at various hotels and supermarkets. She aces a computerized exam for a Winn-Dixie supermarket but declines to take a drug test, feeling the pay Winn-Dixie offers is not worth the indignity. After three days of searching, she is hired as a waitress at the Hearthside family restaurant. On the first day of the job, she is trained by another waitress, Gail, who fills her in on the complexities of both the restaurant’s policies and her own life. As a waitress, Ehrenreich is driven by her work ethic and a growing attachment to the customers she serves. Unfortunately, her hopes for a steady month of working as a waitress are disrupted by two things. First, the restaurant’s management is perceived by the rest of the staff as serving corporate interests instead of customers. When a mandatory meeting is called, it is so the manager, Phillip, can complain about the messiness of the break room. Four days later, another meeting is called regarding a report of drug activity during the night shift. This necessitates drug tests for all future hires as well as random tests for current employees. The gossip among staff is that assistant manager, Stu, was the one caught with drugs. Second, Ehrenreich realizes that, despite taking home tip money every night, she will not be able to cover expenses on her current income. Her first and most important concern is housing, and Ehrenreich explains the different problems her fellow Hearthside employees endure in that department. Some live with family or a mate; others live with multiple roommates; and still others live in their cars or rent hotel rooms on a nightly basis. This last choice seems unwise to Ehrenreich and she says this to Gail, who is considering leaving her roommate and moving into a room at the Days Inn. As Gail points out, however, she is not able to get an apartment of her own without a month’s rent and deposit in advance—an impossibility on her income, and something Ehrenreich was able to manage only by starting her experiment with $1,300 in her pocket. Ehrenreich seeks out a second job and ends up working as a waitress at Jerry’s, a family restaurant attached to a motel chain. While much busier than the Hearthside, Jerry’s is an unclean restaurant that lacks both a staff break room and proper facilities for employees to wash their hands. The one reprieve for employees
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
seems to be smoking, as seen by constantly-lit cigarettes awaiting quick puffs between orders. Ehrenreich is hurt by the coldness of her fellow waitresses on her first day but discovers it is because most people do not last more than one day at this job. Ehrenreich is determined to work at both the Hearthside and Jerry’s but finds herself too exhausted to do so and chooses to stick with Jerry’s. Work at Jerry’s is tiring in itself, and Ehrenreich decides to handle each day as a onetime, shift-long emergency. Unfortunately, she must also deal with work-related pain, including an old back injury that has returned. When she briefly returns to her regular life, she finds herself increasingly disassociated from the ‘‘real’’ Barbara Ehrenreich and ‘‘that’’ Barbara’s relatively lavish lifestyle. Ehrenreich befriends some of the staff at Jerry’s, including a young Czech dishwasher named George, whom she teaches English. Ehrenreich also decides to move to a trailer park closer to Key West in order to save time and gas, making a new second job possible. The situation at Jerry’s worsens when George is accused of stealing from the dry-storage room. Ehrenreich does not speak up in his defense—a change in her personality that troubles her deeply. She gets a second job housekeeping for the hotel attached to Jerry’s. She is assigned to train with a woman named Carlie. Ehrenreich discovers the one solace in cleaning hotel rooms is watching television. She leaves her housekeeping job to wait tables at Jerry’s, but the night goes badly. The cook, Jesus, is overwhelmed by the rush of orders, as is Ehrenreich when she deals with four tables arriving at once. She leaves the restaurant mid-shift and does not return. Her one regret is not giving George her tips.
Two: Scrubbing in Maine For her next experiment, Ehrenreich chooses Maine: unlike other places, she can blend in as a minimum-wage worker despite not being a minority. She arrives on a Tuesday and books a room at a Motel 6. After some searching, she secures an apartment at the Blue Haven Motel, where she can move on Sunday.
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
weekend assignment as dietary aide at the Woodcrest Residential Facility nursing home and a weekday job at The Maids. She accepts both. She starts work at Woodcrest on Saturday and discovers that being a dietary aide involves serving meals and cleaning up afterwards. She befriends Pete, a cook, but decides to keep her distance when he seems romantically inclined toward her. On Monday morning, Ehrenreich begins work at The Maids by watching a series of videotapes describing how to clean according to company policy. She is struck by the emphasis on creating an orderly appearance over actual cleanliness, as evidenced by the very small amount of water used when cleaning. The next day, she discovers work is much faster than depicted in the videos: a certain time is given per house, based on size and whether or not it is a first-timer needing special attention. Her co-workers do not have the same housing worries as those in Key West, but many are still at the edge of poverty. On Friday, one of her team’s assignments includes the home of Mrs. W, who ends up watching Ehrenreich as she cleans the kitchen floor on her hands and knees. Ehrenreich develops a rash but is not sure where it comes from; further, the aches and pains from her job take their toll. She makes observations on the physically damaging nature of maid work, as well as the ostentatious nature of the houses she must clean. By the second week, Ehrenreich works regularly under team leader Holly. One day, when Holly seems ill, she confesses to Ehrenreich that she may be pregnant. Ehrenreich tries to assume more of the work to make things easier for Holly. Holly resists, though she does accept food. At one house, Ehrenreich has an accident while cleaning the kitchen, breaking a fishbowl and spilling water everywhere. Her first week’s pay is held back as a matter of policy at The Maids, so she contacts several agencies to secure much-needed free groceries. That weekend, while working at the Woodcrest as a dietary aide, she has to handle the Alzheimer’s ward by herself.
She applies at various places for a job, including taking personality tests at both WalMart and The Maids, a housecleaning service. Two days later, she gets two job offers: a
During Ehrenreich’s third week with The Maids, Holly has an accident and injures her knee. Ehrenreich threatens a work stoppage and talks to her employer Ted about getting help for Holly, but neither Ted nor Holly will
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 7 3
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
allow this. On the car ride back to the office, Ehrenreich loses her temper and embarrasses her co-workers by dismissing the Accutrac personality test’s ability to screen out unfit workers. The next morning, Ted sends Holly home to recuperate. Two days later, Ted picks up Ehrenreich for a special assignment. On the drive there, he gives her a raise and talks about Holly’s situation. Ehrenreich wonders why the other workers rely so heavily on Ted’s praise and realizes he is the only person who will acknowledge their value.
morning. When she does, she is told she will be paid ten dollars an hour. Roberta from WalMart contacts Ehrenreich to tell her she passed the drug test and will be paid seven dollars an hour. While Menards is the better choice, Ehrenreich attends Wal-Mart’s orientation out of caution and curiosity. She finds the day-long process intimidating: the history and unmatched growth of Wal-Mart is conveyed along with the service-oriented philosophy, anti-union policy, and the importance of preventing time-theft, or doing anything non-work related during a shift.
On her last day at The Maids, she reveals to co-workers her real reason for working there. They do not seem to understand completely, but Ehrenreich takes the chance to ask how the women feel about their job and clients. The responses are not angry; they are either resigned to their lot in life or aspiring to the same lifestyle as those clients.
Ehrenreich goes to her first day of work at Menards; she discovers she must work elevenhour shifts and that ten dollars may not be her hourly pay rate after all. Ehrenreich refuses these conditions and opts for Wal-Mart, something she will rationalize in the coming weeks. She leaves her friends’ apartment, but finds the Twin Lakes has rented her reserved room to someone else. This forces her to stay at the Clearview Inn for a week, which is cheaper than Twin Lakes but also less safe.
Three: Selling in Minnesota Ehrenreich chooses Minneapolis for her last experiment, based on news of its robust job and housing markets. She initially stays at the apartment of friends who are away on a trip, in exchange for watching their pet cockatiel Budgie. Deciding to explore factory or retail work and become more aggressive with the application process, Ehrenreich succeeds in getting jobs at a Wal-Mart and a Menards housewares store. Unfortunately, both require a drug test, and Ehrenreich has recently smoked marijuana. She tries to detoxify by drinking a great deal of water and buying products designed to clear one’s system. Although her initial search for housing is discouraging, Ehrenreich takes time out to meet Carolina, a relative of a friend. Carolina has done in real life what Ehrenreich pretends to do with her experiments: relocated from one state to another to start a new life at minimum wage. Ehrenreich and Caroline bond and become friends. On Monday, Ehrenreich goes to her drug tests and, still unsure of the results, goes to a group interview for a company seeking independent sales staff. The search for affordable housing grows more desperate, but she is promised an apartment at the Hopkins Park Plaza when it opens up. Meanwhile, she reserves a room at the Twin Lakes, a residential hotel. Menards contacts Ehrenreich and tells her to report for orientation on Wednesday
1 7 4
L i t e r a r y
The following Monday, Ehrenreich reports for work at Wal-Mart and is assigned to the women’s clothing department. Her task is to keep the area orderly, something that requires a familiarity with the department layout as well as the different brands and styles. While the task itself is not difficult, the volume of clothes to sort and order can be overwhelming. Her shift is changed in the second week from 10:00 a.m.–6:00 p.m. to the closing shift of 2:00 p.m.–11:00 p.m., and the shopping takes on a more frenzied pace. Though Ehrenreich resents customers, concentrating on the clothing gives her a sense of focus and dedication. An incident where a co-worker criticizes her performance has Ehrenreich worried that the person she is becoming under these work conditions is not the same person she is in real life. On the day Ehrenreich believes she can move into the Hopkins Park Plaza, she is told she cannot move in until the following week. Again without a home, she stays at a Comfort Inn for two nights. She seeks housing advice from the Community Emergency Assistance Program, where she is simply told to live in a shelter until she can afford an apartment. The following Saturday at Wal-Mart, Ehrenreich makes a breakthrough and finds herself not needing to think so much in order to accomplish her tasks. This leaves her the time to wonder why
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
people do such work in the first place. Ehrenreich now tries to change the opinions of her co-workers and galvanize them to change the company. She talks about the importance of a union to co-workers individually as well as at a staff meeting. Though Ehrenreich does not truly believe that a union is possible, she is given hope when she hears of a strike being held at several hotels. Ehrenreich commits time-theft to follow up on possible housing, but with no results. She decides to end her experiment prematurely and quit Wal-Mart. She tells her co-worker Melissa of this and of the book she is writing, and Melissa decides to quit as well. On her last break, she watches TV news about the hotel strike, and a co-worker in the break room suggests a union would be good for Wal-Mart as well.
Evaluation Ehrenreich assesses how she did in the three experiments. She concludes that she did well at her jobs, stressing that there is no such thing as unskilled labor, as every job has specific demands and skill sets that must be learned. Her ability at work, however, is distinct from how she did in making ends meet; she believes she came closest in making earnings match expenses in Maine and was least sure of this goal in Minnesota. Ehrenreich then examines the general social issues underlying her experiences. The constant problem of housing is caused by the rich competing with the poor for living space, with the rich inevitably coming out on top. And though market forces drive rent up, the same cannot be said for wages available to the lower class. While the legal minimum wage and actual wages earned have both risen for the lowest ten percent of workers, Ehrenreich believes it is not nearly enough. Employers will do anything to avoid raising wages, such as providing minor benefits that can be taken away more easily when costs tighten. Further, minimum-wage employees do not have the same resources as other workers to allow independent comparison of wages and job markets. Even if they did, their ability to change work situations is often restricted by outside concerns such as home environment, transportation, and second jobs. An innate desire to please management helps keep low-wage workers compliant; further, common infringement on civil liberties such as drug testing and searches of
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
MEDIA ADAPTATIONS
Nickel and Dimed was adapted as a theatrical stage play in 2002 by playwright Joan Holden. Originally presented in Seattle by director Bartlett Sher and artistic adviser Anna Deavere Smith, it has since been performed by various companies across the nation.
private property help to psychologically intimidate workers. In effect, Ehrenreich argues that low-wage workers inhabit a world that is neither free nor democratic, despite the common idea of America as a land of choice and opportunity. In order to lead a secure and comfortable (but by no means extravagant) life, she estimates that a family of one adult and two children requires $30,000 a year. This is twice as much as low-wage workers actually earn. Ehrenreich concludes that the top twenty percent of American earners, which includes the professionalmanagerial class, exerts an unequal amount of power over America than the rest of the nation. They set the country’s agenda, and they have decided to hide the plight of the working poor. In setting aside their own concerns for the concerns of the people they serve, Ehrenreich claims that the working poor ‘‘are in fact the major philanthropists of our society’’ and will someday resist this role. After the turmoil of this predicted revolt, everyone will be better off.
CHARACTERS B.J. B.J. is a manager at Jerry’s restaurant, where Ehrenreich holds her second waitressing job. She has a blunt, thoughtless demeanor. She advises Ehrenreich that interaction with customers is slowing her down and that customers must be treated as a sort of enemy to getting the job done.
V o l u m e
1
1 7 5
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
Though its owners gave the bird a different name, Ehrenreich gave the name Budgie to the cockatiel she must watch in return for temporary housing in Minnesota.
beliefs and perspective. For example, the Ehrenreich in the experiment is afraid of tunnel vision regarding her work—something the narrator Ehrenreich notes but does not herself suffer.
Carlie
Gail
Carlie is a housekeeper at the hotel attached to Jerry’s restaurant. She trains Ehrenreich to be a housekeeper after the author takes on a second job to make ends meet. An older African American woman, Carlie is resigned to her job and seeks solace in the television shows she watches while cleaning the rooms.
Gail is a waitress at the Hearthside restaurant whom Ehrenreich befriends. She, along with most of her co-workers, has difficulties finding acceptable housing; this limits her ability to secure a better job. When Ehrenreich leaves Key West, she turns over to Gail her deposit and house key to the trailer she had been renting.
Carolina
George
Carolina is the aunt of a friend of Ehrenreich’s who had done what Ehrenreich is attempting with her move to Minnesota: Carolina actually moved across the country to start a new life. She boarded a Greyhound bus with her two small children and left New York for Florida, all on a minimum-wage salary. She is the only worker whose home life Ehrenreich describes in detail.
George is a nineteen-year-old Czech dishwasher at Jerry’s restaurant whom Ehrenreich befriends and teaches English. When he is accused of stealing from a dry-storage room, Ehrenreich does not come to his defense.
Budgie
Holly
Colleen is a cleaner for The Maids. She states that she is not jealous of her clients’ lifestyles but wishes her own life was slightly easier.
Holly is a team leader for The Maids. She is pregnant and sick but refuses to stop working. Her refusal to give in to illness or weakness comes from several factors: fear of the consequences if she does not work, financial need, pride in the work that she does, and a desire to please her employer, Ted.
Barbara Ehrenreich
Howard
Colleen
The author and narrator, Ehrenreich is also the central character in the book: the journalist conducting experiments on survival through minimum-wage employment. She is the only character to appear in more than one chapter, since each chapter takes place in a different city and work situation. Ehrenreich is a staunch supporter of progressive left, or liberal, values; she believes in fixing inequities in American society that harm groups such as women and the lower class, even if these remedies compromise unregulated capitalism and democracy. While her background in science makes her approach her investigations as experiments, there are other motivations behind her actions worth noting. She is curious about her own ability to survive and also wishes to illustrate how difficult it is to live under minimum-wage conditions. Due to the nature of her experiment and the changes in her personality from the work and living conditions, the character of Barbara Ehrenreich is at times quite different from the narrator in her
1 7 6
L i t e r a r y
An assistant manager at Wal-Mart, Howard is an enforcer of company policies and an example of the way corporations implicitly encourage the intimidation of employees.
Jesus A young, inexperienced cook at Jerry’s restaurant, Jesus’ failure to keep up with incoming orders reinforces Ehrenreich’s decision to leave her job mid-shift.
Joy Joy is a manager at Jerry’s restaurant whose abrasive treatment of employees contributes to Ehrenreich leaving the job in the middle of a shift.
Lewis Lapham Lapham is Ehrenreich’s editor at Harper’s magazine. He is the one who takes her idea for a story about somebody trying to live on
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
minimum wage and suggests that person should be Ehrenreich herself.
Linda Linda is Ehrenreich’s supervisor at the Woodcrest Residential Facility. She is approximately thirty years old and works with Ehrenreich on her first day as they serve breakfast to the residents in the locked Alzheimer’s ward.
Lori Lori is a cleaner for The Maids who befriends Ehrenreich and aspires to live a life as good as her clients.
Marge Another cleaner for The Maids who befriends Ehrenreich, Marge is resigned to her work situation and refuses to assist Ehrenreich’s attempt to help Holly after she is injured and needs time off.
Melissa A Wal-Mart employee assigned to the ladies’ wear department, Melissa befriends Ehrenreich and leaves the company at the same time Ehrenreich does.
Paul Paul is the listless manager in the personnel office of Menards who interviews and hires Ehrenreich. She turns the job down when she learns that she will have to work eleven-hour shifts for less money than she was originally told.
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
Stu Stu is an assistant manager at the Hearthside restaurant who is rumored by the staff to be taking drugs at work. She later learns that he has been fired.
Tammy Tammy is the office manager of The Maids; she is the person who deals with clients and their requests. In Ehrenreich’s view, she keeps the clients from having to deal with the harsher, more intimate realities of employing people to clean one’s homes.
Ted Ted is the owner of The Maids franchise for which Ehrenreich works. He believes himself to be a fair employer and his workers seek his approval, yet the policies he enforces are not as fair to his employees as he thinks. Ehrenreich suspects that he is trying to use her to get information on troublesome employees.
Mrs. W Mrs. W is a client of The Maids who is present when Ehrenreich’s team comes to clean her house. For Ehrenreich, she is a symbol of the worst impulses of the upper and middle class— unconcerned with the suffering of minimumwage workers as long as they make her own life easier.
THEMES
Pete
Employment and Economics
Pete is a cook at the Woodcrest Residential Facility who befriends Ehrenreich and initially has romantic inclinations toward her.
A manager at a Wal-Mart in Minneapolis, Roberta hires and helps train Ehrenreich. She is an example of a true believer in Wal-Mart and its philosophy, which she says is the same as her own.
Nickel and Dimed focuses squarely on the workplace of the lower class: minimum-wage jobs that often involve providing service for others. All the other themes in the book spring from concerns about employment—work conditions, management styles of those in charge of low-wage workers, and the problem of minimum-wage work and whether it is possible to survive in modern America at that level of earning. The book also explores the humane side of economics, asking the question, how does one survive on a minimum-wage job in America? The very title of the work suggests that even the smallest changes in finances can have a debilitating effect for the lower class, whether it is the pay one earns or the cost of everyday living expenses. This is often illustrated in the dollars-and-cents
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
Phillip Phillip is the West Indian manager of the Hearthside restaurant who hires Ehrenreich. His lack of concern for or connection with Ehrenreich is emblematic of the disregard management often holds for low-wage employees.
Roberta
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 7 7
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
accountings Ehrenreich gives of how much she earns, how much she spends on necessities such as rent and food, and the minor extra expenses she cannot help, such as medicine and painkillers for work-related injuries. Ehrenreich believes that some basic human needs are not met for lower-class workers, even if they have full-time jobs. The amount earned does not match the actual expenses incurred, most notably in housing. Minimum-wage work makes it difficult to gather the funds for a lease on an apartment, and compromises of various sorts are often made. Throughout Nickel and Dimed, Ehrenreich scrambles to find the right balance in her housing: affordable, close to work, and safe. Often, at least one of these criterion ends up being forfeited, as she depends on trailer parks and resident hotels to provide reasonable housing. Further, the extreme measures of screening and surveillance often imposed on workers make just keeping a job a stressful affair and encourage a more compliant workforce. Workers are, thus, not only unsure if their jobs can truly support them, they are also unsure if their jobs will always be there.
Culture Clash Ehrenreich perceives cultural differences between classes, enough that her forays into lower-class life feel like a different world to her. Within the experiences that encompass lowerclass life, she is further concerned about fitting into every workplace of which she is a part, and every workplace is a unique microcosm to which she must adapt. If anything, Ehrenreich’s true life as a middle-class writer has made her fit into minimum wage even more alienating, calling up a different set of behaviors and assumptions that she comments upon throughout the book. She understands that being accepted by her co-workers is essential in order to survive, and that a support system within the workplace is one of the tools that make minimum-wage jobs tolerable, if not desirable.
Pain and Suffering Ehrenreich stresses the physical difficulties in the kind of labor she performs for these experiments. Her health is often in jeopardy, and yet she cannot do everything in her power to heal and become well. She is limited to what she can afford and what she can access after work hours. She often relates how a minor injury that could be nurtured into recovery in her
1 7 8
L i t e r a r y
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
middle-class life can become a major crisis for the lower class, who have fewer options in health care and are more reliant on hourly wages that can be lost if they take time out to recover. This particular point is brought home by Holly of The Maids, whose sickness and injury demand better care than she allows for herself—partly because she cannot afford decent health care, but also because her commitment to her job, misguided as it may be, does not allow her to stop working.
Empathy Ehrenreich believes that the way to address the issue of the working poor and lower-class survival is to look at the people, not the demographics and statistics. Many minimum-wage jobs are of a service nature, and Ehrenreich implies that lower-class citizens have become a de facto servant class in a nation that claims to treat all its members equally. The purpose behind Nickel and Dimed is to illustrate, in vividly human terms, the difficulties and suffering of this overlooked group. However, Ehrenreich’s empathy often wears thin as she grows tired of the apparent complacency of her co-workers, even in the face of unjust employment practices. Ehrenreich is alarmed at how basic human dignity is taken away by the working conditions of the lower class. The search of personal possessions, scrutiny through personality tests, and especially drug testing are, in Ehrenreich’s mind, all violations of civil rights. She finds a deep, troubling irony that a nation that prides itself on freedom encourages such strong-arm authoritarian tactics on a majority of its citizens. This tension between empathy and exasperation is, arguably, emblematic of the progressive left’s relationship with the working class.
Identity and Self Ehrenreich is troubled by the changes that occur during her experiences leading a workingclass life. A middle-class woman who came from a working-class background, she believes that the person she is now is quite different from the person she would have become if her family had remained working class. While working at WalMart, however, she believes that she meets the ‘‘original Barb’’ in herself, ‘‘the one who might have ended up working at Wal-Mart for real’’ if her life had gone differently. Barb, Ehrenreich thinks, is not like the ‘‘real’’ her: ‘‘she’s meaner
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
TOPICS FOR FURTHER STUDY
Compare Nickel and Dimed as a work of investigative journalism to another well-known work where the author goes underground to experience the truth of a disenfranchised group, such as Jack London’s The People of the Abyss or John Howard Griffin’s Black Like Me. How does Ehrenreich compare as an investigator in the commitment to getting to the truth? What does each investigator do to become a part of the group? How does assuming this new role change the way each author understands society? In what way does this new role change the understanding of self and identity? Write a three-page report comparing and contrasting these two books. Research the history of welfare in the United States from President Roosevelt’s Social Security Act of 1935 to the 1996 reform and the present. What are the major landmarks in this history? What changes have occurred, and what brought about those changes? What assumptions seem to underlie welfare in each stage of its history? Based on your research, what future do you see for welfare in America? What role can welfare play in our nation? What role should it play? Create a detailed timeline that not only measures the landmarks in welfare, but notes
and slyer than I am, more cherishing of grudges, and not quite as smart as I’d hoped.’’
possible social assumptions and political concerns that informed them.
How are minimum-wage workers portrayed today? Consider as wide a range of depictions as you can, from news to movies to music to video games. Are there any patterns in terms of race, gender, or work situation? Are there any specific character traits given to minimum-wage workers that set them apart from other people? What communities or settings are they found in and, if a particular example has a plot, what is their role in the story? Create a five-minute presentation of two specific depictions that includes visual aids and, when helpful, plot synopses.
Pick a group that you would like to investigate by immersing yourself into its world, as Ehrenreich did with minimum-wage workers. How would you go about performing a similar investigation? What would you need to change—or hide—about yourself to be able to immerse into the group? What methods would you employ to get the information? Write a one-page investigation plan that lays out your investigative preparations in detail, along with what you hope to accomplish through your investigation.
people she encounters in the book are not as lucky, often working and living in conditions that have not improved for years and may never improve.
Limitations and Opportunities Ehrenreich argues that minimum-wage work is the best that many lower-class citizens can hope to achieve in their lives. As a result, there is a clear limit to the lifestyle they can lead and the opportunities that are open to them. Ehrenreich consciously deprives herself of many of the comforts in her life, but she does this only temporarily and out of choice. The
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
STYLE Episodic Chapters The structure of Nickel and Dimed is straightforward: each of her month-long experiments takes up a single chapter, making each
V o l u m e
1
1 7 9
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
chapter an episode in an extended quest. This helps reinforce the idea that each month-long experience is a distinct world of its own and that all these worlds are separate from the reality of Ehrenreich’s normal life. These three main chapters are bookended by two considerably shorter chapters. ‘‘Introduction: Getting Ready’’ explains the genesis, or origin, of the experiment, as well as the rules Ehrenreich applies to her project. In the final chapter, ‘‘Analysis,’’ Ehrenreich presents what she learned from all three experiments and proposes changes that could help make life at minimum wage more manageable and humane. The two bookend chapters take place within Ehrenreich’s real life as a writer and social critic. ‘‘Introduction’’ involves a meeting with an editor, while ‘‘Analysis’’ describes briefly her return to that life and the sense of dislocation at how her experimental lives have vanished. In this way, the structure of the book is similar to a quest: the action begins with the assumption of a goal (an answer to the question of matching minimum-wage earnings to a minimum-wage lifestyle); the main character—Ehrenreich herself— makes three excursions to alternate worlds as the goal is sought; and the book ends with a return to normalcy as the goal is completed.
Investigative Journalism Investigative journalists expose injustice through extensive investigation and then propose a remedy to eradicate it. In Nickel and Dimed, Ehrenreich sets her sights on the plight of the working poor. Though investigative journalism does not always call for the writer to fully immerse himself or herself into the situation or event he or she is covering, Ehrenreich’s firstperson experiences bring verisimilitude, or a quality of truth, to the book. She does not pay much heed to journalistic objectivity, in part because she is immersed in her situation, but also because she has clear political beliefs that are at the heart of her career as a social critic and essayist.
Scientific Experiment Ehrenreich repeatedly frames her investigation as a scientific experiment and, less often, herself as the test subject. This not only emphasizes Ehrenreich’s training as a biologist but also provides a necessary distance between herself and her experiences. The distance allows her to write more objectively, but it is also an unstated
1 8 0
L i t e r a r y
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
admission that her experiences are artificially constructed. She acknowledges that she is unable to mimic completely the realities of minimumwage life, in part by refusing, even for the sake of the experiment, to go without food, a home, or a car. And because it is an experiment, her experiences as a low-wage worker are not a lifestyle, like so many people she encounters, but a research trial with a defined end-date. At times throughout the book, she carefully categorizes aspects of her lower-class lifestyle or minimum-wage job—often to humorous effect, but also to convey the complexity of her situation and her work assignments. For example, Ehrenreich explains how being a waitress is not simply about serving meals; it is about all the different tasks involved in keeping a restaurant orderly and prepared. If these tasks are not taken care of in a timely manner, serving meals becomes much more difficult when the dinner rush arrives. In this way, she shows that life for the working poor is not a haphazard situation but a set of definable factors that influence one another, often with unforeseen consequences.
Memoir Ehrenreich is not only the narrator but, in a sense, the protagonist, or main character, of the book. Thus, Nickel and Dimed also works as a kind of memoir, an account of a very specific phase in her life. Indeed, Ehrenreich spends the three different months conducting experiments as belonging to the life of another Barbara—the one who would have existed if her parents had never made the transition from lower class to middle class. This Barbara, eventually dubbed Barb after her Wal-Mart name tag, develops concerns and behaviors different from the ‘‘real’’ Barbara she left behind. While it is the ‘‘real’’ Barbara who narrates the novel, we are given many insights into how Barb thinks and feels, often in an embarrassing and self-revelatory manner.
Humor as Criticism An accomplished essayist, Ehrenreich often makes her best and most accessible points about the difficulties and injustices of her minimumwage experiences by describing them in a humorous fashion. Often, she uses self-deprecation to describe her difficulties at learning a new job and to deflate her middle-class assumptions. Since she is intent on discovering the larger meaning of her situation, she often employs hyperbole, or
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
exaggeration, and reductio ad absurdum (reducing a statement or belief into a logical absurdity) to expose the injustices committed in the workplace. For example, she makes fun of personality tests to highlight how they are phrased to elicit contradictory impulses that best suit a compliant workforce (e.g., having enough initiative to not be lazy but not so much initiative as to be a threat). By focusing on the more amusing aspects of her experiments, Ehrenreich is able to provide respite from the grim truths about lower-class life, making her account of those truths more palatable to a wide audience.
HISTORICAL CONTEXT Prosperity in America Nickel and Dimed was written during a time of great economic prosperity for the United States. This is best exemplified by the Internet boom that resulted in young entrepreneurs becoming overnight millionaires. Whether one is an Internet wizard, rap recording artist, stockbroker, or entrepreneur, the notion of selfinitiative leading to unbridled success has never been more evident than in recent decades. Technology has created a wider range of comforts and productivity tools for those who can afford them, while changes in social mores, or attitudes, have made individual independence a more important value than the needs of the community. This notion of rising through the classes, from lower-class origins to upper-class success, was first made popular in the books of Horatio Alger. These dozens of books, with titles like Struggling Upward and Risen from the Ranks, published from 1867 through the dawn of the twentieth century, all share the same theme: a poor young man, through virtue and hard work, can become a rich man. Although Alger himself never became a rich man, his books were found in a large number of Victorian homes. He has also been noted as an early influence for many entrepreneurs of the early twentieth century. In addition, the main theme of his books—that through hard work, anyone can succeed in America—has been adopted as a distinctly American ideal.
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
Security Act in 1935 and has helped support the American poor in the decades since. Ehrenreich was partially inspired to write Nickel and Dimed by changes in welfare laws that were passed in 1996. The Personal Responsibility Act more than halved the number of people receiving welfare: in 1996, there were 12.2 million recipients, while in 2001, when the book was published, there were 5.3 million. This would seem to indicate a success in making lower-class workers more self-sufficient, but that is not how critics interpret the results. As Sharon Hays argues in Flat Broke with Children: Women in the Age of Welfare Reform While 84 percent of desperately poor (welfareeligible) families had received benefits prior to the passage of the Personal Responsibility Act, by 2001 less than half of them did. This means that millions of parents and children in America were living on incomes lower than half the poverty level and not receiving the benefits for which they were technically eligible.
Further, the number of working poor, meaning people who have full-time jobs but still live at or near the poverty line, has grown in recent years as the support of welfare is no longer readily available to assist them.
Corporate Dominance After an 1886 Supreme Court decision granted corporations many of the rights previously held only by individual citizens, corporations have flourished in the United States. This corporate personhood can provide many business advantages, though critics have long argued that it gives too many rights to corporations. This, as recent corporate scandals attest, can lead to great profit without anyone being personally responsible for how the profit is generated.
A national welfare program was instituted as part of President Franklin Roosevelt’s Social
As corporations began to dominate American industry, smaller businesses had a difficult time competing in an aggressive marketplace. As more and more small businesses vanished, corporations became ever-present to fill consumer needs. Wal-Mart, the largest retailer and employer in the United States, is a perfect example of this corporate dominance. Indeed, this phenomenon has even been referred to as the Wal-Marting of America. Corporate advocates argue that big companies like Wal-Mart provide a consistent, affordable consumer experience that just cannot be matched by
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
Welfare Reform Legislation
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 8 1
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
Robynn Rodriguez as Barbara in a 2003 production of Nickel and Dimed at the Guthrie Theater in Minneapolis, MN Ó Michal Daniel
small businesses. Critics argue that corporations, driven solely by profit, sacrifice employee well-being for increased earnings. Through their decision-making executives, these same corporations actively resist the federal increase of the minimum wage and explicitly discourage the formation of employee labor unions. Some communities, including several in California and Illinois, have successfully rallied to bar the opening of Wal-Marts in their area. Wal-Mart has also faced numerous charges of unfair business practices, including the largest
1 8 2
L i t e r a r y
class action suit in U.S. history for sexual discrimination of its female workers.
CRITICAL OVERVIEW Nickel and Dimed fits clearly in a tradition of investigative journalism where the writer infiltrates a marginalized group, posing as one of them to find out what life is truly like. The best-known examples of such works are Jack London’s People of the Abyss, George Orwell’s
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
The Road to Wigan Pier, and John Howard Griffin’s Black Like Me. All are mentioned by various critics when assessing Ehrenreich’s book. Many critics praise Ehrenreich for writing about the plight of the working poor, calling attention to a facet of America that is often overlooked and underrepresented. Joni Scott from the Humanist considers the book an ‘‘important literary contribution and call to action that I hope is answered.’’ Scott also states that the book ‘‘should be required reading for corporate executives and politicians.’’ In Off Our Backs, Kya Ogyn notes that the author ‘‘succeeds beautifully’’ in demonstrating that ‘‘the problem lies in the system of low-paid work, not in the workers.’’ Moreover, Ehrenreich does this with an approach and style that make her topic engaging. As Steve Early notes in the Nation, ‘‘Ehrenreich has long been a rarity on the left— a radical writer with great wit and a highly accessible style.’’ Scott Sherman, writing for the Columbia Journalism Review, is among those who see Nickel and Dimed as an evolution in Ehrenreich’s abilities as a writer: For Ehrenreich, Nickel and Dimed is something of a literary triumph. Her essays, while frequently incisive and hilarious, seem onedimensional when read in large doses. And while her books are absorbing and original, the writing isn’t always stylish. Nickel and Dimed, however, shows us a veteran journalist at the very top of her game. The book has a sturdy architecture: four tight, compact chapters in which the prose achieves a perfect balance between wit, anger, melancholy, and rage.
However, some have questioned whether Ehrenreich’s work does anything more than state the obvious. As Julia M. Klein writes in the American Prospect: In the end, what has she accomplished? It’s no shock that the dollars don’t add up; that affordable housing is hard, if not impossible, to find; and that taking a second job is a virtual necessity for many of the working poor. Ehrenreich is too busy scrubbing floors to give us more than a passing glimpse of the people in that world.
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
directives for what the now-properly-chastised affluent reader should do.’’ Several other criticisms have also been raised. Yager notes that the idea of a well-off woman pretending to be poor ‘‘could easily seem self-indulgent and offensive’’ in much the same way that Black Like Me has been criticized. In addition, Yager points out that readers may leave the book with the misguided notion that ‘‘if American low-wage workers are worse off now than they were 30 years ago, this must just be because bosses have become nastier individuals.’’ Also, despite her recognition of Ehrenreich’s accomplishments, Ogyn states that ‘‘the book contains numerous disdainful comments’’ about overweight people.
CRITICISM Ray Mescallado Mescallado has studied literature and pop culture, writing extensively on these topics for academic and popular venues. In this essay, Mescallado considers Ehrenreich’s book in terms of bridging the gap between the middle and lower class. What looks on the surface to be an attempt to erase class differences actually reinforces them. For all the compelling claims Barbara Ehrenreich makes in Nickel and Dimed about the working poor of America, there is one issue she is oddly quiet about: what can be done to bridge the gap between classes. The book seems to address this with its very premise; deciding to work and live as one of the lower class, Ehrenreich made more of an effort than most middle-class people would even consider. Upon close reading, however, Nickel and Dimed often reinforces class tensions instead of erasing them. Class is not only about different degrees of wealth, but also different perspectives and experiences. For all her success as a worker and survivor, Ehrenreich is still a middle-class woman in a lower-class world, and that influences how she tells her story as well as how we read her book.
Jane Yager, writing in Dollars & Sense, raises another issue. Although the book is an effective portrayal of low-wage living, Yager states, ‘‘It’s hard to figure out what the book aims to accomplish.’’ Beyond making wealthy readers feel bad, ‘‘the book offers no specific
Nickel and Dimed is a personal book about a public problem; that is a key part of its appeal. Time and again, Ehrenreich mentions the physical pain she suffers as a result of her work. All of us can sympathize when bodies are forced beyond their limits. She writes to great effect about human dignity, something robbed too
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 8 3
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
CLASS IS NOT ONLY ABOUT DIFFERENT DEGREES OF WEALTH, BUT ALSO DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES AND EXPERIENCES. FOR ALL HER SUCCESS AS A WORKER AND SURVIVOR, EHRENREICH IS STILL A MIDDLE-CLASS WOMAN IN A LOWER-CLASS WORLD, AND THAT INFLUENCES HOW SHE TELLS HER STORY AS WELL AS HOW WE READ HER BOOK.’’
often by the draconian, or extremely harsh, measures imposed on such workers. We all want to keep our self-respect and have others respect us as well. Unfortunately, even these aspects of life are not understood the same way by different classes. One of her clients at The Maids, a physical trainer, tries to be friendly and suggests that cleaning house is a good workout. Ehrenreich laments that she ‘‘can’t explain that this form of exercise is totally asymmetrical, brutally repetitive, and as likely to destroy the musculoskeletal structure as to strengthen it.’’ This encounter highlights the difficulty of crossing class lines, as Ehrenreich describes in her 1989 book, Fear of Falling: Even the middle-class left, where the spirit is most willing, has an uneven record of reaching out across the lines of class. Left and right, we are still locked in by a middle-class culture that is almost wholly insular, self-referential, and in its own way, parochial. We seldom see the ‘‘others’’ except as projections of our own anxieties or instruments of our ambition, and even when seeing them—as victims, ‘‘cases,’’ or exemplars of some archaic virtue—seldom hear.
Despite being aware of the problem, Ehrenreich falls into this trap repeatedly in Nickel and Dimed. As alarming as the trainer’s attitude is, Ehrenreich believes herself unable to say what she thinks, to speak in terms that the woman can understand. It is an opportunity when Ehrenreich can bridge the gap between classes but fails to do so. This reluctance is rooted in part by her own class anxieties, as fear of slippage weighs heavily throughout the book. When she gets hired for her first minimum-wage job and is told to report the next
1 8 4
L i t e r a r y
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
day, she becomes uneasy: ‘‘[S]omething between fear and indignation rises in my chest. I want to say, ‘Thank you for your time, sir, but this is just an experiment, you know, not my actual life.’’’ Towards the end of her three-city quest for working-class insight, she ponders how different her working-class self is from her professionalmanagerial class self. She draws a clear distinction between the Barbara of her normal life and the ‘‘Barb’’ of her Wal-Mart assignment: ‘‘Take away the career and the higher education, and maybe what you’re left with is the original Barb, the one who might have ended up working at Wal-Mart for real.’’ She notes that Barb is like a slightly less-civilized version of herself, ‘‘meaner and slyer . . . and not quite as smart as I hoped.’’ If there is any ongoing conflict between characters, then, it is the tense standoff between Barb and Barbara. Ehrenreich’s experiences are so compelling to herself and her readers that we often do not notice—or at least, we do not find it odd—how she does not hear her co-workers as much as she simply describes her own woes. Thus, what makes Nickel and Dimed an engaging read also reduces the urgency of these issues. If this were an account of a truly lower-class person working a permanent minimum-wage job, the story would be different, perhaps even inaccessible to middle-class readers who resist the unvarnished truth about the working poor. Members of the actual working class are disposable in Ehrenreich’s narrative: the episodic traveling account means all characters besides Ehrenreich are dropped at the end of a chapter, paving the way for a new cast in the next city. The only one whose personal history earns an extended telling is Carolina in Minnesota, who is not a co-worker but a relative of a friend in Ehrenreich’s real life. None of Ehrenreich’s work compatriots are described beyond a couple of personality traits and statistic-affirming situations. For the middle-class readers who have long been her audience, Ehrenreich provides a buffer. She is a spy in the house of drudge, an outsider who manages to work her way in. To sympathize with her during this ‘‘scientific experiment’’— which in itself is another distancing effect: How many working-class people would describe their lives as ongoing experiments in matching wages to expenses?—is to know that all the hardships will soon enough fade for our heroine, disappearing down ‘‘the rabbit hole.’’ Ehrenreich is
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
Alice in low-wage Wonderland, and waking from this dream is as simple as returning to her real life. Like Alice, her adventures through the lower class are odd, amusing, and at times grotesque. This brings to mind Scott Sherman’s observation in the Columbia Journalism Review: A striking feature of immersion narratives like London’s People of the Abyss and Orwell’s Road to Wigan Pier is the extent to which compassion and sympathy co-exist uneasily with revulsion and disapproval. . . . Passages of this sort tell us something about the immutability of class boundaries; but they also stand as examples of reportorial honesty and, in Orwell’s case, narrative sophistication.
Ehrenreich often feels outrage at the indignities she must experience, which she sees as the indignities suffered by all workers in her chosen situation. However, this outrage is matched with an unmistakable exasperation about the lack of resistance her co-workers show against their working situations. Ehrenreich never claims that her co-workers deserved the poor treatment they received, but she often comments at how much of it they tolerate—more than she can, as is proven time and again. That said, she at least tries to understand the lower-class characters she encounters, to rationalize—if not excuse—their lack of progressive fervor. While she encounters many unlikable co-workers and customers in her account, Ehrenreich often explains the bad behavior or finds a reason to like the person; that is, if the person is lower class. Ehrenreich is considerably less forgiving with the upper- and middle-class homes she cleans for The Maids, exposing the hypocrisy and lack of good taste of various clients. One might wonder why a staunchly working-class hero does not emerge in her narrative—or at least a sympathetic middle-class character besides the princess-in-disguise that is herself. Consider Ted, the franchise owner of The Maids. Of all the middle-class characters in the novel, he is the least offensive, if still nowhere near heroic. When told there is no key to get into a client’s house, his reported response—‘‘Don’t do this to me!’’—is selfish but not aggressive or mean-spirited. In this book, the lack of malice in any kind of manager is striking. After Holly injures herself on the job, Ehrenreich convinces her to call Ted from the next house. She then
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
insists on speaking to Ted and what follows is an angry tirade by Ehrenreich: I can’t remember the exact words, but I tell him he can’t keep putting money above his employees’ health and I don’t want to hear about ‘‘working through it,’’ because this girl is in really bad shape. But he just goes on about ‘‘calm down,’’ and meanwhile Holly is hopping around the bathroom, wiping up pubic hairs.
The scene Ehrenreich paints is both amusing and troubling, an excellent example of her gifts as a writer but also of the problems brought about by her aggressively partisan class consciousness. Holly the lower-class worker persists at her job, no matter how humiliating it is or how silly she appears. As the mediator, Ehrenreich vents her anger at the middle-class employer. And Ted, this representative of the middle class, rewards her. She is afraid she will be fired but her co-workers assure her she will not and, indeed, she is not. Instead, he concedes some ground, as Holly is forced to take off the next day—an action Holly considers unjust and which she blames on Ehrenreich’s meddling. When Ted later pays extra attention to Ehrenreich, picking her up for a special assignment and giving her a raise, she believes she is being recruited as a stool pigeon. Ted fishes for the names of problem employees, hoping that Erhenreich will supply them now that he has given her a raise: ‘‘This must be my cue to name a few names, because this is how Ted operates, my co-workers claim—through snitches and by setting up one woman against another.’’ Ehrenreich’s assumptions are odd, as she is the one who complains about Holly’s situation, even ‘‘threatening a work stoppage.’’ A kinder interpretation of the situation is that Ted admires her willingness to look out for her coworkers, but does not want grief directed his way. What may be a veiled bribe for Ehrenreich to stop being so abrasive is instead seen as a more malicious ploy, based primarily on ‘‘what my co-workers claim.’’ In effect, Ehrenreich plays into the class tensions, the underlying conflict between worker and employer—more so than the other maids, who profess to admire Ted and seek his approval— instead of trying to mediate the two sides. Considering the resentment Holly ends up feeling for Ehrenreich, perhaps there is some truth in Ted’s statement that ‘‘you can’t help someone who doesn’t want to be helped.’’ Ehrenreich explains in the ‘‘Analysis’’ chapter
V o l u m e
1
1 8 5
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
why the lower class accept low pay, poor working conditions, and legalized violation of civil rights. However, she never addresses how to help those who do not want to be helped. Instead, she fantasizes about a working-class revolt, a day when minimum-wage earners ‘‘are bound to tire of getting so little in return and . . . demand to be paid what they’re worth. . . . and we will all be better off for it in the end.’’ Is Ehrenreich imagining a people’s revolution in classic Marxist fashion (Marxism is the political idea that socialism will lead to a classless society), where the proletariat overthrow the ruling class? Or something less grandiose, a general strike that will force legislation that better serves the needs of all workers? If she is considering the less radical revolt, how will this come about? And why assume that everyone will be better off ? As Sherman discovers in his interview with Ehrenreich in the Columbia Journalism Review, she places little faith in her book causing any real changes in policy; perhaps her time in the servant-class has made her more sharply aware of the realpolitik (politics based on the practical rather than on morals or standards) of the poor. Nickel and Dimed opened a dialogue that does not gloss over the difficulties of class tensions—which in itself is a brave, important act. Having experienced the patchier side of the fence, though, Ehrenreich is now grateful to remain on the greener side, to embrace a middle-class perspective even as she works for her progressive beliefs. Source: Ray Mescallado, Critical Essay on Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America, in Literary Newsmakers for Students, Thomson Gale, 2006.
Scott Sherman In the following essay, Sherman analyzes Ehrenreich’s complex and often contradictory attitude toward the people she writes about. A striking feature of immersion narratives like London’s People of the Abyss and Orwell’s Road to Wigan Pier is the extent to which compassion and sympathy co-exist uneasily with revulsion and disapproval. Jack London possessed a deep empathy for the slum dwellers of turn-of-the-century England, but he still allowed himself to describe them as ‘‘stupid and heavy, without imagination.’’ Orwell, recalling his stay in a squalid lodging house in the industrial north of England, confessed: ‘‘On the day when there
1 8 6
L i t e r a r y
WHAT DO I READ NEXT?
Global Woman: Nannies, Maids, and Sex Workers in the New Economy (2002), edited by Ehrenreich and Arlie Russell Hochschild, is a collection of essays examining injustices regarding low-wage female workers around the world. It includes an essay by Ehrenreich, ‘‘Maid to Order,’’ which expands on her study of maid work in Nickel and Dimed.
Ehrenreich’s Fear of Falling (1989) is a study of the middle class and their retreat from liberalism. It complements Nickel and Dimed on a thematic level, considering the tension between social classes from another angle. Jack London wrote The People of the Abyss (1903) after spending several months investigating slum conditions in London’s East End. A work of journalism very similar to Nickel and Dimed, it serves as a useful contrast to Ehrenreich’s investigative technique and style and is an illuminating historical document of the poor from another time and culture.
The Road to Wigan Pier (1937), by George Orwell, was written from a similar desire to examine the plight of London’s poor at the time. After examining the living conditions of the lower class, Orwell devotes the second half of his book to socialism as an ideal and how it compares to the reality of socialism in his times. Along with London and Orwell’s works, John Howard Griffin’s Black Like Me (1961) is the book most often compared to Nickel and Dimed. It describes how Griffin dyed his skin black and experienced firsthand what it was like to be an African American in the racially segregated South.
was a full chamber-pot under the breakfast table I decided to leave. The place was beginning to depress me.’’ Passages of this sort tell us
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
something about the immutability of class boundaries; but they also stand as examples of reportorial honesty and, in Orwell’s case, narrative sophistication. Nickel and Dimed, too, is streaked with contradictory sentiments. Ehrenreich, for instance, writes with considerable feeling about Gail, a ‘‘wiry middle-aged waitress’’ who can’t afford a security deposit for an apartment, so she sleeps in her car. ‘‘When I moved out of the trailer park,’’ Ehrenreich writes, in the closing lines of her waitressing chapter, ‘‘I gave the key to number 46 to Gail and arranged for my deposit to be transferred to her.’’ But in many other places, Ehrenreich’s compassion degenerates into spite. An Alzheimer’s patient who threw milk on Ehrenreich is ‘‘a tiny, scabrous old lady with wild white hair who looks like she’s been folded into her wheelchair and squished.’’ A woman whose home is cleaned by Ehrenreich’s crew is ‘‘an alumna of an important women’s college, now occupying herself by monitoring her investments and the baby’s bowel movements.’’ At Wal-Mart the sight of an obese woman fills Ehrenreich with disgust. ‘‘Those of us,’’ she writes, ‘‘who work in ladies’ are for obvious reasons a pretty lean lot . . . and we live with the fear of being crushed by some wide-body as she hurtles through the narrow passage from Faded Glory to woman size, lost in fantasies involving svelte Kathie Lee sheaths.’’ More illuminating, perhaps, is the anger Ehrenreich directs at some of her co-workers, especially the other maids in Maine, who are bereft of class consciousness and self-esteem. Indeed, the docility and fatalism of the working poor is a primary theme of the book: ‘‘For the most part,’’ she writes, ‘‘my co-workers seem content to occupy their little niche on the sheer cliff face of class inequality.’’ Even when injured on the job, they prefer to talk about recipes instead of retribution. There is a harrowing moment when ‘‘Holly,’’ a maid on her crew, falls into a hole and hurts her ankle; Ehrenreich insists that she get an X-ray immediately—and even calls for a ‘‘work stoppage’’—but all Holly can do is whimper and go back to cleaning bathrooms on her injured ankle.
Robynn Rodriguez as Barbara and Sarah Agnew as Holly in a 2003 production of Nickel and Dimed at the Guthrie Theater in Minneapolis, MN Ó Michal Daniel
Ehrenreich can think of nothing but the accident, but Holly, still reeling from the pain, ‘‘starts up one of those pornographic lateafternoon food conversations she enjoys so much. ‘What are you making for dinner tonight, Marge? . . . Oh, yeah, with tomato sauce?’’’ Marge, another maid, is previously described as someone ‘‘who normally chatters on obliviously about the events in her life (‘It was the biggest spider’ or ‘So she just puts a little mustard right in with the baked beans . . .’).’’
Holly’s passive response to her injury—she is, first and foremost, terrified of losing her job— leaves Ehrenreich in a red-hot fury: ‘‘All I can see is this grass fire raging in the back of my eyes.’’ At the end of the day, on the car ride home,
These expressions of anger and frustration are the most honest and unsettling portions of Nickel and Dimed honest because Ehrenreich— whose original PMC essay envisioned a working class that could ‘‘alter society in its totality’’— despises blue-collar apathy, superstition, and conservatism; and unsettling because they remind us that the works of our most humane chroniclers of the poor—Jonathan Kozol, Katherine Boo, the late Michael Harrington— possess a generosity of spirit that is not always evident in Nickel and Dimed.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 8 7
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
Source: Scott Sherman, ‘‘Class Warrior: Barbara Ehrenreich’s Singular Crusade,’’ in Columbia Journalism Review, Vol. 42, No. 4, November–December 2003, p. 34.
Joni Scott In the following essay, Scott posits that Ehrenreich’s book is an important literary and social contribution. Nickel and Dimed exposes the anti-America of flophouses, multiple house sharing, employees sleeping in cars, and the homeless who work forty hours or more weekly. Those who used to be middle class, despite often working two jobs, now endure a daily scramble to prioritize such needs as food, housing, childcare, and health care. One extra expense—like dental work, work uniforms, medication, school supplies, and the like—can ‘‘break the camel’s back.’’ So I can’t fault Ehrenreich for having stock options and a pension plan while publicly admonishing the excesses of the wealthy. She ponders whether the exurb queens whose houses she and her newfound comrades clean ‘‘have any idea of the misery that goes into rendering their homes motel-perfect?’’ She queries, ‘‘Would they be bothered if they did know or would they take a sadistic pride in what they have purchased— boasting to dinner guests for example that their floors are cleaned only with the purest of fresh human tears?’’ And regarding the WWJD (What Would Jesus Do) patrons she serves during her Key West server stint, she writes: they ‘‘look at us disapprovingly no matter what we do (and they don’t tip) as if they were confusing waitressing with Mary Magdalene’s original profession.’’ Another poke at hypocrisy comes when Ehrenreich describes how ennui moves her to investigate a Saturday night ‘‘tent revival.’’ This passage plunges into a commentary about Jesus being ‘‘out there in the dark, gagged and tethered to a tent pole’’ thereby stifling his message of Christian charity. Mostly, she delivers a profoundly poignant description of people, such as a hopeful Czech dishwasher living with a crowd of other Czech ‘‘dishers.’’ He can’t sleep until one of them goes to work, leaving a vacant bed. On that note, I hear the ghost of social reformer past, Jacob A. Riis, a police reporter who wrote of and extensively photographed the poor in his 1890 book How the Other Half Lives: Studies Among the Tenements of New York. Riis’
1 8 8
L i t e r a r y
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
words could apply to this century: The gap between the classes in which it surges unseen, unsuspected by the thoughtless is widening day by day. No tardy enactment of law, no political expedient can close it . . . I know of but one bridge that will carry us over safe, a bridge founded upon justice and built of human hearts. By the end of Nickel and Dimed I felt thankful to Barbara Ehrenreich for this important literary contribution and call to action that I hope is answered. I believe this book should be required reading for corporate executives and politicians. A bumpersticker once read, ‘‘He who has the most toys at the end wins.’’ Is this to be our legacy? Source: Joni Scott, ‘‘Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America (Review),’’ in Humanist, Vol. 61, No. 5, September 2001, p. 40.
Julia M. Klein In the following essay, Klein weighs the ultimate worth of Ehrenreich’s book. In the end, what has she accomplished? It’s no shock that the dollars don’t add up; that affordable housing is hard, if not impossible, to find; and that taking a second job is a virtual necessity for many of the working poor. Ehrenreich is too busy scrubbing floors to give us more than a passing glimpse of the people in that world. Nor can she really transform herself into just another waitress or maid. She is both a prickly, self-confident woman and the possessor of a righteous, ideologically informed outrage at America’s class system that can turn patronizing at times. Still, Nickel and Dimed is a compelling and timely book whose insights sometimes do transcend the obvious. It’s important to know, for instance, that low-wage workers, while often taking pride in their jobs, are routinely subjected to an authoritarian regime that ranges from demeaning drug tests to bans on ‘‘gossip’’ with other employees. The result, Ehrenreich argues, is ‘‘not just an economy but a culture of extreme inequality.’’ And our most appropriate response, as members of the well-meaning middle-class? Not guilt, she tells us, but shame, for relying on the underpaid labor of others—a habit the living-wage movement is now trying to help us break. Source: Julia M Klein, ‘‘Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America. (Review),’’ in American Prospect, Vol. 12, No. 13, July 30, 2001, p. 43.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
Kya Ogyn
Jane Yager
In the following essay, Ogyn offers some possible insight into the author’s intent in writing this book.
In the following essay, Yager attempts to find the Ehrenreich’s message and intended audience in Nickled and Dimed.
I think the actual purpose of Ehrenreich’s experiment becomes clear when identifying the intended audience. What we have is a successful, affluent writer addressing members of her own class. Her intent is to tell people who have never experienced it something of what it is like to work at jobs that do not pay enough to live on. Even more importantly, her intent is to say that her experience ‘‘is the best-case scenario: a person with every advantage that ethnicity and education, health and motivation can confer attempting, in a time of exuberant prosperity, to survive in the economy’s lower depths.’’ Nickel and Dimed is a needed work—engaging, well-researched and written in a directly personal style. Ehrenreich succeeds beautifully in conveying to her middle-class audience that she is just like them and that since she could not support herself, never mind a family, on the jobs available to her, the problem lies in the system of low-paid work, not in the workers. However, beyond my regret that Ehrenreich was perhaps correct in considering her authoritative, middleclass voice necessary to make this point, I have two problems with this book. One is that, although she writes, ‘‘low-wage workers are no more homogeneous in personality or ability than people who write for a living, and no less likely to be funny or bright,’’ she comes to the conclusion that Barb, who works for Wal-Mart, is ‘‘meaner and slyer’’ than Barbara the writer, and ‘‘more cherishing of grudges, and not quite as smart as I’d hoped.’’ Although poverty can have a brutalizing effect on some people, there are demonstrably grudge-holders among the rich and powerful who are not very smart. My second problem lies with Ehrenreich’s attitudes toward fat people. The book contains numerous disdainful comments and one very disturbing rant—‘‘we live in fear of being crushed by some wide-body as she hurtles through the narrow passage from Faded Glory to woman size, lost in fantasies involving svelte Kathie Lee sheaths.’’ It is unfortunate that a political writer of her caliber has not only not examined fat hatred, but has contributed to it. Source: Kya Ogyn, ‘‘Can You Live On It?’’ in Off Our Backs, Vol. 35, January–February 2005, p. 44.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
1 8 9
N i c k e l
a n d
D i m e d :
O n
( N o t )
G e t t i n g
Source: Jane Yager, ‘‘Poverty: A National Emergency,’’ in Dollars & Sense, January 2002, p. 42.
SOURCES Early, Steve, ‘‘Prole Like Me,’’ in the Nation, Vol. 272, No. 23, June 11, 2001, p. 52. Ehrenreich, Barbara, Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America, Metropolitan Books, 2001. Hays, Sharon, Flat Broke with Children: Women in the Age of Welfare Reform, Oxford University Press, 2003, p. 8. Klein, Julia, Review of Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America, in the American Prospect, Vol. 12, No. 13, July 30, 2001, p. 43. Ogyn, Kya, ‘‘Can You Live On It?,’’ in Off Our Backs, Vol. 35, Jan-Feb 2005, pp. 44–46. Scott, Joni, Review of Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America, in the Humanist, Vol. 61, No. 5, September-October 2001, p. 40. Sherman, Scott, ‘‘Class Warrior: Barbara Ehrenreich’s Singular Crusade,’’ in Columbia Journalism Review, Vol. 42, No. 4, November-December 2003, pp. 34–42. Yager, Jane, ‘‘Poverty: A National Emergency,’’ in Dollars & Sense, January-February 2002, pp. 42–44.
FURTHER READING Bergdahl, Michael, What I Learned From Sam Walton: How to Compete and Thrive in a Wal-Mart World, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2004.
1 9 0
L i t e r a r y
B y
i n
A m e r i c a
Though oriented to readers of business advice, this book is highly instructive in seeing Ehrenreich’s story from a different perspective. In business terms, it discusses the success of Wal-Mart and what Bergdahl feels companies should do to compete against them. Featherstone, Liza, Selling Women Short: The Landmark Battle for Workers’ Rights at Wal-Mart, Basic Books, 2004. Using the landmark Dukes v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. class action suit as her focus, Featherstone examines the Wal-Mart culture and the inequities allegedly perpetuated within the company toward women and others. Hays, Sharon, Flat Broke with Children: Women in the Age of Welfare Reform, Oxford University Press, 2003. Combining in-depth arguments with anecdotal stories about actual welfare offices and clients, Hays looks at the impact of welfare reform legislation on women and their families. Newman, Katherine S., No Shame in My Game: The Working Poor in the Inner City, Knopf, 1999. Refuting the idea of an unmotivated and lazy lower class, Newman examines in depth the lives of the urban working poor. She interviews workers who describe the specific difficulties faced when work is hampered by outside concerns such as crime, drug abuse, and poor schooling. Shulman, Beth, The Betrayal of Work: How Low-Wage Jobs Fail 30 Million Americans and Their Families, New Press, 2003. Using statistics and personal stories, Shulman looks at the lives of workers in low-paying jobs, examining a wide range of occupations and experiences.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
A Northern Light Jennifer Donnelly grew up on the outskirts of the Adirondacks hearing tales and ballads of the 1906 murder of Grace Brown, a pregnant nineteen-year-old drowned by her lover in Big Moose Lake. Donnelly’s great-grandmother had been working at a hotel on the lake when the murder took place. Her firsthand account, reinforced by Donnelly’s reading of Theodore Dreiser’s novel concerning the same murder, stirred Donnelly’s curiosity. Dreiser’s novel, An American Tragedy, renders the couple’s plight as a dark outcome of the American dream gone awry. What captured Donnelly’s imagination, however, was Grace herself and how she could have been any nineteen-year-old girl. Upon reading the transcripts of Chester Gillette’s trial and hearing Grace’s voice through the letters used as evidence, the presence of the young woman haunted Donnelly. She felt a genuine grief which was alleviated through writing Grace’s story and giving it fresh meaning. Out of that need was born the character of Mattie Gokey, the sixteen-year-old hotel employee who witnesses Grace’s body being pulled from the lake the evening after Grace asks her to burn her love letters. In piecing together the story of Grace’s life and death through the letters, Mattie comes to understand and solve many of the problems standing in the way of her own happiness and independence. A Northern Light, published in 2003, transcends genre boundaries and was praised by Courtney Williamson of the
JENNIFER DONNELLY 2003
1 9 1
A
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
Christian Science Monitor for ‘‘unflinching honesty in its portrayal of loss, poverty, racism, and pregnancy.’’ It was an overnight success in both the United States and Great Britain (where it was published under the title A Gathering Light). It has since earned several major awards in young adult fiction, including the Los Angeles Times Book Prize and the Carnegie Medal.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY Jennifer Donnelly was born in 1963 in Port Chester, New York. She spent some of her childhood in Lewis County, New York, just about an hour from Big Moose Lake, the setting of her novel, A Northern Light. Her paternal grandfather immigrated to upstate New York during the Irish potato famine and struggled to support his family by farming. Because of the harsh land and the short growing season, the family was poor, very much as Donnelly imagines the Gokey family in A Northern Light. In these trying circumstances, the family’s chief means of entertainment was storytelling. Donnelly recalls her great-grandfather reading voraciously on his deathbed because he had never had time to read while working the land. Her mother, orphaned during World War II, often told stories and read books to her daughter. In an interview with Update magazine, Donnelly attributes her love of stories to her upbringing: ‘‘Hearing the older generation sit and talk, you absorb how to do pacing and suspense, and structure, how to hold your listeners rapt, how to deliver a good punch line.’’ Although she did not grow up believing she would be a writer, Donnelly’s adolescent years were full of literary inspiration. In her late teens, she lived in London and spent every available minute in the East End, absorbing the city that would shape her first novel, Tea Rose. In 1986, she graduated from the University of Rochester with degrees in English and European history. Donnelly began writing in her twenties and worked on her first novel for ten years. In the spring of 2001, after a long search for a publisher, the author finally published three of her works in quick succession: a children’s picture book, Humble Pie, (2002); her adult novel, Tea Rose (2003); and A Northern Light (2003), a young adult novel that became an overnight sensation.
1 9 2
L i t e r a r y
Jennifer Donnelly Ó Jerry Bauer. Reproduced by permission
As of 2005, Donnelly lives in Brooklyn, New York, with her husband, daughter, and two greyhounds.
PLOT SUMMARY Introduction A Northern Light opens with a crisis. A young guest of the Glenmore Hotel is pulled from Big Moose Lake in the Adirondacks after going boating with her lover. The young narrator, Mattie Gokey, a waitress in the hotel, is astonished to discover that the dead woman is Grace Brown, who earlier in the day had given Mattie a bundle of letters to burn. In the bustle of her daily duties, Mattie has forgotten about the letters in her apron pocket. Now she is struck by a mysterious complicity with the dead woman and an uncanny certainty that her own life will be forever changed because of the events that are unfolding. The narrative moves back and forth between two timelines, one tracking Mattie’s efforts to understand the circumstances behind Grace Brown’s death through reading her letters, and one tracing the events in Mattie’s life
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
A
which led to her employment at the Glenmore Hotel. She is trying to find the financial means to attend Barnard College in New York City, where she will break free of her expected role as eldest daughter to a widowed father and fulfill her ambition as a writer. Each chapter is headed by a word-of-the-day that the young writer savors in an effort to deepen both her vocabulary and her understanding of the world.
Chapter 1 Mattie introduces the reader to a day in the life of the Gokey family, and chaos reigns as she and her three younger sisters try to run the household. The central tensions of the novel are touched upon: Mamma’s death from cancer seven months before, followed by the inexplicable disappearance of Mattie’s older brother Lawton; Mattie’s longing to go to Barnard College, where she has been offered a scholarship, challenged by a promise made to her dying mother; Mattie’s desire to join her friends working at the Glenmore Hotel, countered by her father’s disapproval and general denial of her need for further education; and the plight of Emmie Hubbard, a widow with seven children who seems to have gone crazy and can no longer adequately care for her home or children.
Chapters 2–6 Mattie has two best friends, Weaver Smith and Minnie Compeau. Minnie left school at the expected age of fourteen and is married and pregnant when the narrative begins. Weaver is her school companion and word-dueling partner. The first freeborn son in his family, Weaver is headed to college in New York City. Mattie is also experiencing the first flush of romance as she is pursued by the handsome Royal Loomis, a man she can hardly believe is interested in her. Mattie’s tendency to romanticize young love is evident when she flashes forward to the death of Grace Brown and envisions the young woman as the victim of a kind of Romeo-and-Juliet tragedy—the two lovers dead at the bottom of Big Moose Lake. When Mr. Eckler’s floating grocery store/lending library arrives in Eagle Bay, he alerts Mattie to the availability of a new book, Edith Wharton’s The House of Mirth. Mattie discovers a beautiful composition book for sale and impulsively spends most of the money she has earned picking fiddlehead ferns on the extravagant purchase, even though she knows her father will punish
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
her for doing so. She speculates that characters in books cannot change their fates, but wonders if real people may be able to.
Chapters 7–10 Pa discovers that Mattie has spent the money she owes him on the expensive composition book. Without Lawton around for heavy chores, the farm is not producing as it once did and money is tight. Pa hits Mattie to punish her for wasting family resources. Mattie gets an acceptance letter from Barnard College, but wonders how she will pay for it. While housecleaning for her wealthy Aunt Josie, Mattie gathers the courage to ask her for the financial help she needs to get to college. Aunt Josie tells her she is as selfish as her brother for wanting to abandon her family; she need only read the Bible to understand God’s intentions for her. Mattie also shares her plans to go to college with Royal, who claims he does not understand why she would want to do such a thing. He kisses her, and her identity and needs become even more conflicted. Weaver struggles with his identity when a white man assumes he is a porter at the rail station just because he is black. Minnie gives birth to a boy and girl, and Mattie helps with the delivery. At the Glenmore, Mattie draws parallels between her promise to burn Grace Brown’s letters and the promise she made to her dying mother to stay at home to raise her sisters. She wonders how binding such promises should be.
Chapters 11–13 Pa’s brother Uncle Fifty shows up with a bundle of cash from a lumberjacking expedition. Weaver and Mattie take their exit exams to graduate from high school and Uncle Fifty is the first person besides Miss Wilcox, their teacher, to show enthusiasm for Mattie’s plans to go to Barnard. He promises to give her the thirty dollars she needs to make the trip and get settled. He gives her a fountain pen and buys the other Gokey children lavish gifts. Miss Wilcox approaches Mattie’s father about her successful exams and the importance of sending her to college. Pa blames Miss Wilcox for Mattie’s inappropriate ambition, and tells Mattie that if she leaves the family to go to Barnard she will never be welcome back in his home. Mr. Eckler announces that Uncle Fifty has skipped town. Mattie realizes that her Pa is the only person in her life she can trust, and she is ashamed for wanting to leave him. Reading Grace Brown’s
V o l u m e
1
1 9 3
A
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
letters, Mattie realizes Grace’s beau Carl Graham—who took Grace out boating and has not been seen since—is really a man named Chester Gillette. She conveys this knowledge to the hotel manager, Mr. Morrison. A wire from Albany confirms that no such man as Carl Graham exists.
Chapters 14–16 Aunt Josie intercepts a letter from the postmistress that the tax collector, Arn Satterlee, has written to Emmie Hubbard. Mattie overhears her aunt gossiping about Emmie’s failure to pay back taxes and the imminent auction of her land. Mattie goes boating with Royal and realizes they are officially dating. She loves being in his arms. Others have caught onto their courtship and tease and envy Mattie. She is proud to be seen as Royal’s girlfriend. Miss Wilcox invites Mattie to her home and offers her books, including one by a feminist poet named Emily Baxter, whom Mattie has heard is indecent. Mattie discovers the poems merely celebrate a woman’s independence; she does not understand why they are so controversial. As she continues to read Grace Brown’s letters, she realizes Grace was pregnant.
Chapters 17–19 Mattie is now working for Miss Wilcox on Saturdays, organizing her books. She arrives one day to discover her teacher in a heated argument with a man. Miss Wilcox confesses the man is her husband, Teddy, whom she has left and who is trying to coerce her into returning to him. She also admits she is the scandalous poet Mattie has been reading—Emily Baxter. Mattie longs to tell someone about Miss Wilcox’s true identity but remains loyal to her teacher. Royal makes sexual advances toward Mattie and promises her that his intentions are honorable, that he will marry her and he wants to buy her a ring. Mattie is concerned because Royal has never told her that he loves her; still, the pull toward marriage is strong. Mattie learns from Tommy Hubbard that his mother Emmie is upset because Arn Satterlee has set the date to auction her home. When Mattie goes to Emmie’s house to console her, she discovers Emmie being sexually violated by Royal’s father, Frank Loomis. She speculates that three of Emmie’s children must have been fathered by Frank Loomis. Reading Grace Brown’s letters, Mattie realizes Chester Gillette
1 9 4
L i t e r a r y
must have brought Grace to the Glenmore with the intention of murdering her.
Chapters 20–22 When Pleasant the mule dies, Mattie finally gets her father’s permission to work at the Glenmore Hotel in order to earn money for a new mule. Mattie is trained as a waitress and becomes acquainted with the hotel’s employees and guests. Mr. Maxwell, a guest at the hotel who sits at table six in the dining room, exposes himself to Mattie and later leaves her a dollar tip. She is too embarrassed to talk about what has happened, but the other waitresses have likewise been harassed by him. Henry, a German under chef, leaves jars of milk on the stove and they explode. It comes to light that Henry has lied about his identity and that he was never a chef in a fine European restaurant. He is demoted to menial labor. Weaver is beaten up by three trappers after he stands up to them for calling him a nigger. The world beyond home seems dangerous to Mattie and she decides her place is in Royal Loomis’s arms.
Chapters 23–26 Reading Emily Dickinson, Mattie realizes all of the authors she admires are spinsters and wonders if marriage is incompatible with being a writer. She begins to mistrust her need for Royal Loomis and is further challenged by a visit to Minnie, who is struggling with her infant twins. Minnie’s inability to cope is evident in the squalor of her home, and she is depressed and defensive, claiming to hate her own babies. When the trappers who beat Weaver are caught and brought to justice, Weaver’s self-esteem is restored, and Mattie imagines the lawyer he will someday become. Mattie’s entire family becomes violently ill with grippe and she must leave the hotel for a week to care for them. The cows are also ill from neglect and two die of infections. Royal and his mother come to Mattie’s assistance and she feels so obligated to them that marriage again looms as her salvation. She accepts Royal’s proposal and the ring he has chosen. She later compares her love for Royal to Grace Brown’s misguided love for Chester Gillette.
Chapters 27–30 Miss Wilcox/Emily Baxter sends Mattie a copy of her new book, Threnody, and a note with a five dollar bill inside. Her husband has
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
A
followed through with his threat to expose her identity and she has lost her job at the school. She plans to flee to Paris before he arrives to take her back home. Mattie and Weaver borrow a horse so that Mattie can see her teacher before she leaves. She tells Miss Wilcox that she is not going to Barnard but intends to marry Royal instead, and Miss Wilcox is visibly disappointed. Weaver tells Mattie she may as well marry a horse. At the Fourth of July picnic, Mattie observes wives hanging on the arms of their husbands and witnesses an argument between Royal and his old girlfriend Martha Miller. Martha confronts Mattie with her belief that Royal is marrying Mattie because he wants her father’s property, adjacent to the Loomis property. Mattie also learns that Royal was the one to inform Arn Satterlee of Emmie Hubbard’s failure to pay back taxes, because he wants Emmie’s property for himself. Mattie begins to acknowledge that Royal does not really love her—he has never said the actual words. Weaver confronts Mattie about her need to face the truth concerning her situation with Royal. Mattie has nightmares about Grace Brown.
Chapters 31–33 Mattie and her friends at the Glenmore plot revenge on Mr. Maxwell for his sexual harassment of them. One of the girls lures him to the lake, and the others trip him with a rope so that he falls into a pile of dog excrement, after which the humiliated Mr. Maxwell retreats into his room. Pa brings news that Weaver’s mother’s house has burned down. The trappers who beat up Weaver got out of jail and set the fire, and also broke Mrs. Smith’s arm and stole Weaver’s college money. Emmie Hubbard invites Mrs. Smith to stay with her so she can nurture her friend back to health. Weaver declares his intention to forgo college so he can help his mother rebuild her life. Mattie mourns the death of the lawyer Weaver could have become, and begins to see the death of potential as a literal kind of death, such as what Grace Brown has suffered. Reading Grace Brown’s last letter, Mattie realizes she cannot erase Grace Brown’s voice from history. Her responsibility to the truth and to justice exceed her responsibility to Grace Brown and the promise to burn the letters.
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
MEDIA ADAPTATIONS
A Northern Light was released in an unabridged version on audiocassette by Listening Library in March 2003. It is narrated by Hope Davis.
Josef Von Sternberg’s 1931 film An American Tragedy is an adaptation of Theodore Dreiser’s novel about the murder of Grace Brown. It stars Phillips Holmes and Sylvia Sydney.
Softening the naturalistic aspects of the earlier film based on Dreiser’s novel, George Steven’s A Place in the Sun (1951) won six Academy Awards for its stunning characterizations of Grace Brown (Shelley Winters) and Chester Gillette (Montgomery Cliff). The film also features Elizabeth Taylor as the woman Chester chose over Grace. ‘‘The Ballad of Grace Brown and Chester Gillette’’ is a folk ballad based on the murder. The lyrics for the ballad can be found in Harold W. Thompson’s Body, Boots and Britches, published by Syracuse University Press, 1939, 1967.
Emmie Hubbard is a changed woman now that she has found a companion in Mrs. Smith.
The arrangement is good for both women and hints at the possibility of a new kind of happy ending that is not a lie or contrivance. Other happy endings result from the two women helping each other. Tommy Hubbard can now help Mattie’s Pa with the farm and Weaver can go to Columbia University assured that his mother will be taken care of. Mattie has earned enough money working for both Miss Wilcox and the hotel to cover her travel expenses to New York and help others secure their futures. Before she departs for New York, Mattie leaves Grace Brown’s letters on Mr. Morrison’s desk, along with three letters of her own: one with money for Pa to pay for the new mule, one to Weaver’s mother with money for Emmie Hubbard’s back taxes, and one to Royal Loomis with the engagement ring inside. She bids farewell to the corpse
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
Chapters 34–35
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 9 5
A
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
of Grace Brown and gives Weaver the money he needs to get to New York, encouraging him to leave immediately while their mutual resolve is strong. She boards the train for her future in New York City.
CHARACTERS Aunt Josie Aber Aunt Josie, Mattie’s mother’s sister, is married to a sawmill owner, Uncle Vernon, and is therefore wealthy enough to help Mattie with her travel expenses to Barnard. The aunt, however, is a house-proud and frivolous gossip, who spends her money on expensive figurines and discourages Mattie from reading any book other than the Bible. When Mattie asks her aunt for financial help, Josie belittles her for being ‘‘on a high horse.’’
Cook Cook is what everyone who works at the Glenmore Hotel calls Mrs. Hennessey. She is chief cook and supervises Mattie and her fellow employees who work in the dining room. A warm, maternal figure, Cook voices her concern over the girls’ flippant ways with men and directs them to heed the fate of Grace Brown as they negotiate their romantic relationships.
Charlie Eckler
Emily Baxter See Miss Emily Wilcox
Belinda Becker Belinda is the fiancee´ of Dan Loomis, Royal Loomis’s older brother. She represents for Mattie the qualities that good wives are supposed to have: a certain giggly, glib social grace, and not much intelligence.
Grace Brown The character of Grace Brown is based on an actual woman of the same name who was murdered by Chester Gillette in 1906 on Big Moose Lake in the Adirondacks. The author weaves into her fictional narrative excerpts from actual letters Grace wrote to Chester upon learning that she was pregnant with his child. The circumstances of Grace Brown’s death are accurately portrayed in the novel and serve as a cautionary tale for the fictional Mattie Gokey, who is on the brink of her first romantic relationship. Grace entrusts her letters to Mattie the morning before her disappearance and death, asking her to burn them.
Minnie Compeau Minnie is Mattie’s best girlfriend who is already married and pregnant when the novel opens. When Mattie assists in the birth of Minnie’s twins, and later watches her friend struggle with nursing and housekeeping, she
1 9 6
recognizes that literature lies about the realities of childbirth and motherhood. Mattie is challenged on many levels by her friend’s ordeal. Foremost is her recognition of how difficult, if not impossible, combining motherhood with a career as a writer will be; secondly, she sees that it is crucial for writers to tell even harsh truths about the daily realities they confront. Through Minnie, Mattie realizes that marriage to Royal may not provide the happiness she seeks.
L i t e r a r y
Mr. Eckler is the captain of the pickle boat that serves the community as floating grocery store and lending library. He provides Mattie with novels and fresh composition books for her writing.
Uncle Fifty Uncle Fifty is Pa’s younger, reckless brother and Mattie’s uncle, who shows up drunk and passes out face down in the manure pile after an absence of several years. He encourages Mattie in her pursuit of college, giving her generous gifts and promising monetary help in getting to Barnard College. He is, however, an irresponsible man on the run because of some undisclosed crime. He skips town before he can deliver on his promise to Mattie.
Francois Pierre Gauthier See Uncle Fifty
Chester Gillette The character of Chester Gillette is based on the historical figure who killed Grace Brown. Chester was the poor nephew of the well-to-do owner of the Gillette Skirt Company in Cortland, New York, where Grace Brown was employed as a pattern cutter. Grace was one of many women whom the handsome young man courted, and her pregnancy was a dire inconvenience to both his social climbing and his need to make a financially prosperous future. Grace
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
A
petitioned and threatened him with letters, hoping that her lover would take heart and save her from a life of disgrace as an unwed mother. Under the alias of Carl Graham, he lured Grace to the Glenmore Hotel, took her out in a rowboat and drowned her. He was convicted of murder in the first degree and executed in Auburn Prison on March 30, 1908.
Abby Gokey Abby is Mattie’s 14-year-old sister, the peacemaker in the Gokey family. Quiet and hardworking, she encourages Mattie to pursue her dream of going to college.
Beth Gokey Beth is Mattie’s five-year-old sister, the youngest of the Gokey siblings.
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
between the apparent safety of a conventional marriage and the self-fulfillment that she believes attending college and becoming a writer will bring. The death of Grace Brown and Mattie’s intimate involvement with Grace through her letters inspire Mattie to live out the potential that the dead woman was denied. She discovers a means toward self-fulfillment and a way to care for the families she must leave behind.
Carl Graham Carl Graham is the false identity that Chester Gillette assumes when he checks into the Glenmore Hotel to murder Grace Brown. See Chester Gillette
Hamlet
Ellen Gokey See Mamma
Lawton Gokey Lawton is Mattie’s older brother who abandons the family soon after their mother’s death. Lawton’s disappearance is a compelling mystery for Mattie, as well as a hardship that makes it more difficult for her to consider leaving her widowed father alone to tend the farm. In the course of the novel, she comes to understand why her brother renounced the difficulties of farm life. This understanding helps Mattie arrive at her own decision to leave.
Hamlet is the Great Dane Mattie is hired to feed and walk everyday at the Glenmore Hotel. The dog becomes instrumental in her and her friends’ plan to discourage Mr. Maxwell’s sexual harassment of the Glenmore waitresses.
Mrs. Hennessey See Cook
Henry Henry, or Heinrich, is the under chef in the kitchen at the Glenmore Hotel.
Lou Gokey
Emmie Hubbard
Lou is Mattie’s 11-year-old tomboy sister. Mattie worries Lou will get into trouble or run away like Lawton. Lou is very close to Pa until he becomes distant and withdrawn after Mamma’s death.
Mattie is the sixteen-year-old narrator and principal character of A Northern Light. Academically talented and ambitious, she finds herself at a crossroads when she is offered the opportunity to marry the handsome and industrious Royal Loomis. Mattie must choose
Emmie Hubbard is a mother of seven children who, because she cannot pay back taxes on the house she lives in, is at risk of losing her home in a public auction. She is thought by many to be crazy. Mattie discovers that Emmie is a victim of sexual abuse by her future father-in-law, Frank Loomis, and that Royal, Mattie’s own future husband, has petitioned for the lien on Emmie’s home so that he might buy her property at little cost. Royal’s lack of compassion for Emmie Hubbard’s struggle is a factor in Mattie’s decision not to marry him. Mattie raises money to pay Emmie’s back taxes for her, thereby saving Emmie’s household. Emmie can then provide a home for Weaver Smith’s mother after their family shack burns down, enabling Emmie and Mrs. Smith to live in an atmosphere of mutual support and safety while freeing Weaver to leave home for college.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
Lousia Gokey See Lou Gokey
Mathilda Gokey See Mattie Gokey
Mattie Gokey
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 9 7
A
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
Tommy Hubbard
Mr. Maxwell
Tommy is Emmie Hubbard’s eldest son and a regular guest at the Gokey dinner table. He is ultimately hired to help Pa with the farm, making it easier for Mattie to leave the family.
Mr. Maxwell is a pervert who sits alone at table six in the Glenmore Hotel dining room, exposing himself to young waitresses and tricking them into leaning over so he can peer at their breasts. The women seek revenge by luring him into a trap that causes him to fall into dog feces.
Frank Loomis Frank Loomis is Royal’s father. He owns ninety acres of property adjacent to the Gokey farm. Mattie stumbles upon him violating Emmie Hubbard in her kitchen, and realizes he is the father of three of her seven children. The startling encounter deepens her recognition that no one is precisely who he or she seems to be.
Royal Loomis Royal Loomis is Mattie’s handsome but dull-witted suitor. He has no understanding of Mattie’s desire to go to college, nor can he understand the value of reading. He cannot appreciate Mattie for herself, but only for what he hopes she will become as a wife, and what she will provide as a dowry—her father’s property. As the second son in his father’s household, he is not entitled to his father’s property and believes he must find a wife of means. He has snubbed the Reverend Miller’s daughter Martha for Mattie, but he is still emotionally tied to his former love. His greed is also behind his alerting Arn Satterlee about Emmie Hubbard’s inability to pay back taxes on her property, with hopes that he will be able to buy the land at public auction and ensure a solid foundation for his future.
Mamma Ellen Gokey, Mattie’s mother, dies seven months before the story begins, exacting a promise from Mattie that she will stay on the farm to help her father and raise her younger sisters. Mamma haunts the story. The memory of Mamma’s competence reinforces Mattie’s recognition of her lack of skill in domestic matters. She must also figure out the extent to which her promise to her mother is binding. Mamma was the one member of the family to encourage Mattie’s writing and reading, though the books she passed on to Mattie were traditional Victorian fare that reinforced domestic values. Through the promise Mattie makes to Grace Brown soon before her death—to burn her letters—Mattie learns even a deathbed promise can be circumstantial.
1 9 8
L i t e r a r y
Martha Miller Martha Miller is the daughter of the local Reverend, a man known to live beyond his financial resources. She was Royal Loomis’s girlfriend before his attentions shifted to Mattie. The couple was, in all likelihood, a more compatible match than Royal and Mattie are, but her lack of a dowry deterred Royal from seeking marriage with her.
Pa Michael Gokey, Mattie’s father, is a bereaved widower, surly and distant after the death of his wife and subsequent flight of his only son, Lawton. He manages his farm with great difficulty and his profits are waning. He is especially needful of his eldest daughter and burdens her with responsibility for the family. His conventional views of a woman’s place and his disregard for Mattie’s talents and ambitions are obstacles to her achieving her dreams.
Miss Parrish Miss Parrish is Miss Wilcox’s predecessor at the Inlet Common School. She represents the Victorian view that literature should uplift the heart and turn the mind toward cheerful and inspiring topics. She discourages Mattie’s writing, claiming that her stories are morbid and dispiriting.
Arn Satterlee Arn Satterlee is the tax collector who sends Emmie Hubbard two letters warning that her house will be sold at public auction if she does not pay her back taxes.
Aleeta Smith Aleeta Smith is Weaver Smith’s mother, who takes great pride in her academically talented and ambitious son. She has worked hard as a laundress and cook for employees of the railroad in order to save money to send Weaver to college. When three trappers burn down her house, break her arm, and rob her of her savings, she moves into Emmie Hubbard’s
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
A
home and the two women create a happy home for themselves and Emmie’s seven children.
Weaver Smith Weaver Smith is Mattie Gokey’s best friend and school companion. A bright, resourceful and ambitious young man, Weaver has been offered a scholarship to Columbia University, where he plans to study law. The first freeborn child in a family of former slaves, Weaver has the support of his hardworking mother; but racism, a fire that destroys his mother’s home, and the theft of his college funds threaten to prevent him from living his dream. Mattie and Weaver’s friendship enable them both to tap into the depths of their potential and find paths toward fulfillment.
Emily Wilcox Miss Wilcox is the teacher at the Inlet Common School. She has recognized Mattie’s gifts as a writer and the academic talents of both Mattie and Weaver. She is the driving force behind their staying in school long enough to earn high school diplomas and scholarships to Barnard College and Columbia University. A modern woman of some means, Miss Wilcox drives around in a fancy car smoking cigarettes, her red hair flaming in the breeze. Over the course of the novel, she reveals herself to be a renegade wife and a poet with a scandalous reputation, disparaged in magazines for her indecency. She is forced to flee to Paris when she loses her job, after her husband exposes her identity to the school in an effort to drive her back to dependency upon him.
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
years old, like Mattie’s friend Minnie Compeau. Mattie’s flirtation with Royal Loomis, the pull of her emerging sexuality, and the social expectation that her life will progress in a pattern similar to Minnie’s and Belinda’s make up the foundation of Mattie’s emotional struggle. It is not surprising that Mattie suffers such deep ambivalence after she is offered a scholarship to Barnard. She longs to go to college, be a writer, and live a life of the mind. The scholarship is a dream come true. At the same time, her emerging womanhood calls for definition and reliable markers that will help her make sense of her emotional conflicts. The conventional literature for women is of no help. She cannot find her story in the stories society believes are suitable for women. Miss Wilcox and Weaver Smith certainly support and encourage Mattie, but they are also struggling to find their ways. Mattie must therefore develop a heightened consciousness and savvy that will help her navigate her passage to adulthood alone.
Duty and Responsibility
Coming-of-age novels map the turning points in an individual’s transition from child to adult, and are often characterized by specific rites of passage enacted universally by children of a certain age within a given culture. At the turn of the century, for a woman of Mattie Gokey’s class and region, the rite was most often courtship and marriage. In rural America, where households full of children were valued for the labor they could provide the farm, it was not unusual for a woman to marry and bear children at fourteen or fifteen
Much of women’s behavior has traditionally been based on the powerful dictates of duty and responsibility toward father, husband, children and home. In the farming culture of upstate New York, the effort to yield a harvest from harsh land during a short growing season contributed to a heightened sense that one’s very survival was dependent on meeting daily responsibilities. One need only imagine the Gokey farm when Mattie returns to it from the Glenmore Hotel after her father and sisters fall sick to grasp how crucial it was for people of that time and place to stay on top of daily chores. After only two days of neglecting the milking, the cows get sick from infection and the Gokeys lose two of them, as well as substantial income from milk and future calves. Mattie’s older brother has already abandoned the family, and the lack of a young man on the property to help clear land and otherwise manage the daily work is truly a hardship. The daily progress of life seems crucially dependent on individuals accepting their lots in life and giving their utmost to the immediate needs of the family. With this awareness, reinforced by the promise she has made to her dying mother, Mattie is hindered in believing she has any right whatsoever to live an independent life and follow a dream. Her sense of calling and responsibility to a higher good must be powerful indeed to propel her past this impasse.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
THEMES Coming of Age
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
1 9 9
A
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
Appearance versus Reality ‘‘Things are never as they seem,’’ Mattie Gokey acknowledges at the crucial moment she learns she will indeed get her father’s permission to work at the Glenmore Hotel. The insight comes after a long series of rude awakenings. She has recently learned that her beloved teacher, Miss Wilcox, is actually a renegade wife hiding behind an incognito identity. She is actually the scandalous poet Emily Baxter, a supposedly indecent woman. Mattie has also walked in on her boyfriend’s father having sex with a woman thought to be crazy. Mattie had always believed Frank Loomis visited the woman to be kind and helpful; now she recognizes he must have fathered three of her children. In the course of the novel, many of the characters will reveal that they are not at all who or what they had once appeared to be to the naive, self-preoccupied young Mattie. Through Mattie’s efforts to get below the surface of understanding the death of Grace Brown, she begins to penetrate the hidden lives of those around her and to understand the rich stories each individual is living. She further recognizes that because things are not as they seem, the possibilities of life are even richer than she had once imagined.
Marriage and Courtship In trying to understand how to behave in her courtship with Royal, Mattie turns to her aunt’s copies of Peterson Magazine and finds the traditional illustration of what it means to be married: a man should be the center of a woman’s universe, he should be her purpose, and her every thought should revolve around him. In the course of Mattie’s courtship with Royal, however, she finds herself chafing against her need to be recognized and understood as a separate person. She loves books but Royal does not understand her love of books, and therefore does not understand her. She is hopeful when he delivers a package to her for her birthday that must be a book, but the gift proves to be a cookbook; further training for how to be a good wife. Mattie’s conflict between her needs and the expectations of marriage permeate the story as she examines the marriages in her immediate community and reminisces on her dead mother’s difficult life with her father. The problem of marrying for love (as Grace Brown longed to do) versus marrying for social convenience or advantage (as Royal aspires to do) seems less perplexing to her than the mystery of why
2 0 0
L i t e r a r y
TOPICS FOR FURTHER STUDY
Pregnancy among unmarried women is not as stigmatized in contemporary culture as it was in the early twentieth century, when Grace Brown found herself so desperately alone. However, teenage pregnancy and teen sexuality are still complicated and controversial social issues. In a group, discuss how the emotional issues surrounding teen pregnancy have or have not changed in the past century. Consider additionally attitudes toward sexuality, birth control, abortion, and abstinence initiatives.
As a voracious reader, Mattie is heavily influenced by the books she reads, and none makes a bigger impact on her than Emily Baxter’s poetry book, Threnody. In a two-page essay, write about a book that has had a big impact on your life. What about the book that inspired you, and what did it inspire you to do? Use specific examples from the book and from your life. Word duels are a creative aspect of Mattie’s relationship with Weaver. Make a list of the challenging vocabulary words that head each chapter in the novel, and see how many synonyms you can find for each word. Challenge a partner to a duel with synonyms from your list until you exhaust the possibilities. Also, try using each word from your list in a sentence.
Mattie is saddened by the recognition that characters in novels cannot change their fates. Is there a character in A Northern Light whose fate you would like to change? Choose a character other than Mattie, and rewrite the script of what happens to him or her in a two-page essay. Discuss how the change might have impacted Mattie’s life and the general outcome of the novel.
women marry at all if, in either scenario, they will inevitably wind up losing themselves. She recognizes none of the women she hopes to
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
A
emulate or the writers she admires within the structure of marriage. She has never known any woman capable of being both a wife and a writer; or a wife and a happy woman. Such insights are crucial factors in her finding the resolve to strike out for New York.
STYLE Voice In her author’s note, Jennifer Donnelly states that the impetus for her novel was the voice of Grace Brown as it reached her through her letters—the same voice that at Chester Gillette’s murder trial moved people to tears. Donnelly used the transcripts from the trial in her research and included Grace’s actual letters in her narrative, thereby bringing Grace’s voice to the readers of the novel. When Miss Wilcox tells the young Mattie that voice is not just the sound which comes from one’s throat but feelings which come from one’s words, she touches on a quality essential to the impact of the novel. The voice of Mattie Gokey is direct, intimate, and searching, a counterpoint to the often desperately beseeching and plaintive voice of Grace Brown. In addition to the powerful voices of the two women whose stories are central to the novel, there are the voices of the many characters who populate Mattie’s world. Donnelly gives even minor characters full embodiment and memorable presence through the skillful use of dialogue.
Double Narrative Critics have marveled at the grace with which Donnelly integrates the two narrative timelines in the novel, oscillating gracefully between Mattie’s all-night vigil with the corpse of Grace Brown and the period leading up to her gaining permission from her father to work at the Glenmore Hotel. Ultimately, the two narratives merge at precisely the moment Mattie when delivers Grace’s letters to the world and claims her own life. Furthermore, the chapters are structured around the obscure vocabulary words that Mattie explores in an effort to understand their meanings. Each word serves as a pivotal concept, linking images and content from past and present to give unity to chapters that often jump around in time.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
Cross-genre Donnelly’s novel transcends most genre boundaries. It is historical fiction, coming-ofage story, romance, thriller, mystery, and journalistic account of an actual crime. The book does not fit cleanly into audience categories. Though Donnelly targeted adolescent girls as her audience, the universal themes have made the story popular for both young adult and adult readers. In Great Britain, where no such category as young adult fiction exists, the novel is considered crossover fiction.
HISTORICAL CONTEXT Racial Oppression Weaver Smith is identified as the first freeborn son in a family of former slaves from Mississippi. His mother is keenly determined to help her son get an education so he can succeed in the white man’s world, but as Weaver tells Mattie, ‘‘Freedom promises more than it delivers.’’ His ambition to become a lawyer is challenged by a culture that still sees him as a nigger or a porter on a train, and by the rage that threatens to destroy him. At the turn of the twenty-first century, resolving the power struggle and healing the rage rooted in generations of victimization are prime issues in racial peacemaking initiatives. Affirmative action and other programs to help empower the marginalized in the United States are also controversial strategies for rectifying social imbalance. Donnelly’s novel brings social issues concerning race down to an intimate scale through her handling of the characters of Weaver and Mrs. Smith
Women’s Issues Through the poet Emily Baxter, Donnelly offers a glimpse into some key themes of early and contemporary feminism: the choice of celibacy over marriage, the choice of same sex households, the feminization of God, and a woman’s general right to define and create her own culture. The novel also examines universal problems of womanhood that have not changed much in the past century, most notably, the sexual double standard and a woman’s conflict between the need for self-fulfillment and the compelling biological need to reproduce and nurture offspring. The voice of Grace Brown that reaches across a century to contemporary
V o l u m e
1
2 0 1
A
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
readers is far from quaint and old-fashioned. Grace and Mattie both speak to the timeless issue of a woman’s struggle for integrity.
The Nontraditional Family Debate persists in American culture as to what constitutes a family. Conservatives contend that the traditional family is in crisis because moral values have been undermined. They argue that the way to save society is to save its basic unit through a religious agenda and through social programs and tax laws that will reinforce the bonds of conventional family life. Liberals argue that the breakdown in the family is a result of cultural forces much larger than the intent of individuals, and that healing human relationships in general is key to building a healthier society. They assert that families can be found and created anywhere love nourishes human bonds. Donnelly subtly evokes a vision of the latter possibility through the unconventional living arrangements that begin to crop up where need and human caring meet without prejudice, most notably in the home of Emmie Hubbard and Aleeta Smith.
CRITICAL OVERVIEW After ten years of struggle, waking up at four or five in the morning to write before heading to her day job, Jennifer Donnelly finally found success in 2001. Three books, each targeting entirely different audiences, were accepted for publication within months of each other. The first was a picture book for young children entitled Humble Pie. Soon after, Donnelly’s historical romance novel Tea Rose, which had been making the rounds for years, sold as well. If that were not accomplishment enough for a writer accustomed to rejections, her third success was most decidedly the charm. After reading only thirty pages and an outline at an auction, Harcourt Brace outbid three other presses for A Northern Light. Editors at Harcourt compared the book to beloved novels Drowning Ruth and Little Women. Early reviews of the novel were unanimously enthusiastic. Courtney Williamson of the Christian Science Monitor deemed the novel the ‘‘quintessential coming of age story. . . . unflinching in its portrayal of loss, poverty, racism, and pregnancy.’’ Sandy MacDonald of the New York
2 0 2
L i t e r a r y
Times emphasized the ‘‘distinctive characters who ring rich and true,’’ as well as the author’s capacity to ground the story ‘‘in often horrific realities of rural life a century ago.’’ Others extol the originality of voice, the multi-layered narrative structure, and the novel’s transcendence of genre. Virtually all reviewers found the first person narrator, Mattie, the most appealing factor of all. Mattie strives to see clearly and act well, Dierdre Baker of the Toronto Star pointed out, citing also her earthly vigor, honesty, and humor as qualities that endear her to readers (quoted on Jennifer Donnelly’s website). We share her desires, if not her unique challenges, on every page, writes Williamson. British audiences were as enthralled as their American counterparts with the novel. Within weeks of the initial sale to Harcourt Brace, Donnelly’s agent took the novel’s outline to London, where it was purchased by Bloomsbury Press and published under the title A Gathering Light. According to the Review page of Jennifer Donnelly’s website, the Times (London) regarded the book as one of the year’s best young adult novels. Bloomsbury Magazine notes that Dinah Hall of the Sunday Telegraph credited Donnelly with capturing period and place with almost supernatural skill. By the fall of 2003, the novel was shortlisted for nearly every book award in the young adult category. It won Best Book of the Year from the School Library Journal and Publisher’s Weekly annual selections. Booklist, Book Sense, the Junior Library, and countless other judges of young adult fiction included it among their annual ten best. The fervor had not waned in 2004, when the novel was honored with a Michael J. Prinz award, Borders Original Voices Award, and the L.A. Times Book Prize. Finally, it was awarded the 2003 Carnegie Medal, the most prestigious British award for children’s literature. Beil notes in her interview with Donnelly that, though the author claims to have written A Northern Light for girls Mattie’s age to empower them to make their own choices, the novel has been considered a crossover success, appealing to adults as well as to the audience for which it was intended. Rights to the novel have been sold in Croatia, France, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, Norway and Serbia.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
A
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
Elizabeth Taylor and Montgomery Clift in A Place in the Sun, a 1951 film based on Theodore Dreiser’s An American Tragedy, which inspired Donnelly in the writing of A Northern Light Paramount/The Kobal Collection
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
2 0 3
A
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
CRITICISM Cynthia Clough Cynthia Clough has a Ph.D. in English, specializing in the novel, from Florida State University. In this essay, Clough explores Mattie Gokey’s need—and her hesitance—to find the unique story and narrative of her own life. Early in A Northern Light, Mattie Gokey expresses pity for characters in novels who cannot break out of their stories and change their fates. She fears that the same can also happen to people in life, and that she herself is stuck in a relentless story that no amount of ambition, hope, or courage can help her escape. Her mother will haunt her all her life if she breaks the promise she made at her mother’s deathbed to help raise her sisters. Pa needs her to run the house; the farm is losing profits since older brother Lawton ran away; who else can tend the cooking, the laundering, and other chores? And if her binding commitments to home and family will not prevent her from accepting a scholarship to Barnard College, maybe the flush of first love will be the force that will carry her straight to marriage with Royal Loomis, who is ready to settle down and start a farm of his own. Several of Mattie’s friends have already succumbed to marriage. It’s her turn; and it’s her time, although she never had imagined that such a handsome and capable man would ask for her hand. What makes the novel such a compelling read is how convincingly Jennifer Donnelly renders the conflicts in Mattie’s emotional life as she navigates her way toward her decision to go to college. The reader may see it as the only viable choice for the young woman; we may root for her to cast off her shackles and board the train for the big city, but still the pull of the alternative remains disturbingly real. According to an article in The Bookseller, the author expressed that her intention was to sustain the plausibility of both choices as viable for Mattie; as a modern woman writing from another era, she had felt some regret that her career had forced her to postpone marriage and family for so long. The novel is so universally appealing because of the timelessness of the central dilemma. But the tension is not merely a matter of choosing between this and that alternative in life. It speaks to the difficulty people have in breaking out of the cultural narratives imposed on their lives, the
2 0 4
L i t e r a r y
THE NOVEL IS SO UNIVERSALLY APPEALING BECAUSE OF THE TIMELESSNESS OF THE CENTRAL DILEMMA. BUT THE TENSION IS NOT MERELY A MATTER OF CHOOSING BETWEEN THIS AND THAT ALTERNATIVE IN LIFE. IT SPEAKS TO THE DIFFICULTY PEOPLE HAVE IN BREAKING OUT OF THE CULTURAL NARRATIVES IMPOSED ON THEIR LIVES.’’
myths and stories that define their identities and map out for them the rites of progress. For Mattie, the narratives that are both shaping and impeding her progress come from several sources, including her literary inheritance, her mother’s history, the alternative choices Miss Wilcox is urging her to explore, and the story of Grace Brown, which ultimately has the power to liberate her. Mattie’s foundations as a reader come from the books her mother and aunt had to offer, namely the Waverly novels and Peterson’s Magazines that still fill the shelves of the Gokey household. Mattie’s mother was an avid reader, and was in fact described as eloping with Pa carrying a carpetbag filled with books rather than clothes (the same carpetbag, by the way, that Mattie will take when she strikes out for New York). The books that her mother brought to the marriage were the conventional Victorian narratives offering larger-than-life examples of how a woman should live and behave in order to sustain the Victorian ideal. During the era of the Bildungsroman (novel of self development), women did turn to literature to learn how to live, to find example and instruction. The heroic biography was prevalent—lives polished to a shining ideal—and periodicals were saturated with edifying articles on morals and manners. When Mattie consults Aunt Josie’s Peterson’s Magazine for instruction on how to behave around Royal, she, like her mother before her, is capitulating to the era’s prevailing notion that an individual comes to full selfhood only through emulating the ideal, and the ideal is imparted through example and instruction.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
A
Mattie’s mother elopes with a carpetbag full of books because she knows she will need them to become an adequate, perhaps exemplary, wife and mother. Mattie, however, considers her rather heroic and ambitious, and assumes her mother read for the same reasons she herself does. To some extent Mamma does share Mattie’s native love of language and was responsible for cultivating it in her daughter, she encourages Mattie and is entirely supportive of her earning a high school diploma. Still, it is clear that Mamma is less concerned with Mattie fulfilling her gifts and ambitions than she is anxious to offer her instruction and perhaps the companionship of books that will help her survive her destiny as a farm wife. Mamma must recognize the wild, rebellious side of Mattie as something she, too, once possessed and learned to harness through proper guidance. She would not have felt so compelled to exact the deathbed promise from Mattie had she not sensed the strength of Mattie’s desire to break away and deemed it inappropriate. Mamma knew that staying would be a struggle for Mattie, a struggle that would require the help of edifying literature. Miss Parrish, Mattie’s first teacher at the Inlet Common School, is likewise an arbiter of the Victorian ideal. She tries to instill in Mattie her belief that the proper function of literature is to uplift the spirit and be ‘‘cheerful and inspiring’’; she also tells Mattie that her stories are morbid and dispiriting. Mattie is influenced enough by Miss Parrish’s beliefs to toss her composition book in the woods. Through the intervention of Miss Wilcox, however, she gains strength of mind to rail dramatically against the Victorian aesthetic, claiming that she will never write a story with a happy ending, because real life has no happy endings. The darker, ostensibly more honest, literature that reaches her through Miss Wilcox and even Charlie Eckler may validate Mattie’s rebellion against Victorian sentimentality, thereby pointing the way to fresh possibilities for her writing. At the same time, these books are hardly alternative guide books for navigating the terrain of adolescent longing and intellectual ambition. The novels that Miss Wilcox claims are more dangerous than guns stem from an 1890s movement known as naturalism. Naturalism sprang up when innovations in science made the universe seem suddenly godless and
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
mechanistic. Naturalists believed that if there were a god, he would at best be a prime mover who had set the universe in motion and then abandoned it. He certainly did not have an intimate or moral interest in what happened in an individual human life. God had wound up the mechanistic clock of the universe and then left it to wind down in entropy, a slow downhill slide into nothing. There were certainly no happy endings for the naturalists. For the naturalist, the self was a dark unknown. In 1859, Darwin had made his voyage on HMS Beagle and had written The Origin of Species claiming that man was kin to the apes. By the 1880s, Freud’s theories of the unconscious were also becoming well known. Freud claimed that much of human psychological life was determined by unconscious motivations deriving from an inner entity called the Id, which was comprised of all the socially unacceptable impulses the Superego had stuffed down deep inside the mind. For Victorians, so much had been considered unacceptable that popular imagination made a veritable monster of the newly charted unconscious—an animal monster, part product of Darwin, part product of Freud. Robert Louis Stevenson’s Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (1886) best illustrates the popular conception of the ‘‘other’’ that dwelt within us and determined behavior—the scientist and his evil, animalistic twin. Dualism and the notion that man’s behavior was determined by forces greater than he was became the foundation of much of turn-of-the-century literature. Miss Wilcox offers Mattie novels by Thomas Hardy and Emile Zola, two powerful voices of the naturalist movement. Mattie may be tired of happy endings and contrived examples, and she is certainly grateful to her new teacher for offering her a view of literature contrary to the inhibiting views of Miss Parrish. But as Mattie’s story progresses, it becomes clear that the naturalist point of view does not mesh with her vision of reality either. Such a dark, deterministic view certainly cannot help Mattie learn to trust the impulses within herself. A case in point is the novel Mr. Eckler offers Mattie when she boards his floating grocery/ lending library. Mattie has just come from fiddlehead picking with Weaver and Minnie, and is dismayed over what a lethargic lump her friend Minnie has become in her pregnancy. Mr. Eckler greets her with news of a new book in the library
V o l u m e
1
2 0 5
A
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
that he has set aside for her: Edith Wharton’s The House of Mirth, the story of Lily Bart, naturalism’s most tragic spendthrift who rejects suitor after suitor despite an inability to support herself and winds up overdosing on sleeping pills. Mattie is flattered that Mr. Eckler acknowledges her as the reader and writer that she is, which in turn inspires her to buy an expensive composition book. Mattie takes the sixty cents she has earned picking fiddleheads and spends forty-five of them on the fancy composition book. She knows she should not spend the money that her father needs to run the household. The Wharton book she holds in her other hand offers a caveat: take heed the spendthrift Lily Bart. Women who turn down opportunities for marriage wind up incapable of supporting themselves. They are doomed and we, too, may be doomed. The books Miss Wilcox offers Mattie point the finger of doom in another direction, toward women who are victims of their sexuality. For women of the Victorian era, the dark other within was most often the sexual side of her nature. There were legitimate reasons for women to fear their sexuality. Pregnancy for an unwed woman carried irreversible consequences that led to her social and economic downfall more often than not. There was no place in Victorian society for a ‘‘fallen woman.’’ No man would marry her and no employer would hire her. Many novels of the era touched on the social injustice of women ruined by men who seduced and abandoned them. Mattie mentions several such stories she has read, among them Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter and Thomas Hardy’s Tess of the d’Urbervilles, which Miss Wilcox offers as an example of the new writing. In the character of Tess, Mattie certainly finds a cautionary tale that pertains to her own situation with Royal, whose social ambitions and lusty advances mirror Alec’s in the novel. Tess’s story also foreshadows Grace Brown’s story, as does the Zola novel Miss Wilcox hands her, Thea´rea`se Raquin, which concerns a lover’s triangle wherein Thea´rea`se conspires with her lover to drown her husband in a lake. Miss Wilcox delivers instructing tales to Mattie warning her not to trust her sexuality. Miss Wilcox is indeed Mattie’s champion. She has fought for Mattie by convincing her mother that she must get a high school diploma, and she
2 0 6
L i t e r a r y
has tried to convince her father to allow her to go to Barnard. Miss Wilcox genuinely believes in Mattie’s gifts. As a mentor she is certainly Mattie’s means to a viable future. At the same time she is in and of herself a mixed message, a fugitive hiding beneath a false identity and a poet regarded as an indecent threat to womanhood. One can certainly understand why Mattie, identifying with Miss Wilcox and her love of books, and even with the poems she discovers and finds hardly indecent, would be reluctant to entrust herself to the world Miss Wilcox urges her to discover. Mattie sorts through the many stories that have been imposed on her experience while she holds her vigil over the corpse of Grace Brown, reading her letters. When Grace is first pulled from the lake, before Mattie has confirmed the identity of Chester Gillette, she imagines a Romeo-and-Juliet tragedy for the young couple. The couple was eloping; their parents disapproved of their marriage; they both drowned and were eternally joined at the bottom of the lake. Later she embellishes the story, burying the lovers side by side in a graveyard, giving it the kind of happy ending she has promised Miss Wilcox she will never write, ‘‘the kind that stitches things up nicely and leaves no ends dangling and makes me feel placid instead of all stirred up.’’ She acknowledges that in order to come up with such a story, she must overlook certain aspects of things that have happened, such as the tearstained face of Grace Brown as she handed Mattie her letters. The corpse of Grace Brown lies in the parlor of the Glenmore Hotel, too palpable, too real to deny. Eventually Mattie does admit one dark piece of evidence after another until she figures out the truth about what happened to the young girl, but she is not content to leave her stuck in a story of bleak determinism. Her impulse is to make Grace’s life count by preserving her voice for history and living to the fullest the life that Grace Brown has been denied. Through facing the death of Grace Brown and the hard truths of Grace’s life, Mattie is able to change her own fate, and live and write a story authentically her own. Ironically, the story does have a happy ending, but it is entirely original and uncontrived. She does not succumb to the rake Royal, but neither does she shuffle out of her circumstances leaving behind those for whom she feels responsible. In saving herself
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
A
WHAT DO I READ NEXT? Louisa May Alcott’s Little Women (1869) features four sisters in New England after the Civil War. The protagonist, Jo March, is a strong, independent person who refuses to give up her dream of becoming a writer just because she is a woman pursuing a traditionally male profession. Anne of Green Gables (1908), by L. M. Montgomery, is a novel about an orphan who goes to live on a farm and gets into mischief because of her wild imagination. This is the first novel in a series of eight that follow Anne as she grows into an independent young woman.
The novel Little House on the Prairie (1935) is part of a series by Laura Ingalls Wilder, who wrote about her childhood experiences as a pioneer in the Midwest in the mid1800s. Laura is smart and observant, and like Mattie in A Northern Light, dreams of someday becoming a writer. The novel Their Eyes Were Watching God (1937), by Zora Neale Hurston, follows Janie Crawford’s physical and spiritual journey from rural Florida to the all-black town Eatonville, Florida to a place called the Florida ‘‘muck,’’ and finally, back to Eatonville. Through her three marriages, Janie faces trials that many African American women faced in the early twentieth century, but she remains a self-respecting, strong-willed female protagonist.
she is able to save others in her community as well. Freed from the conventional narratives of how things ought to be, she is able to see fresh possibilities everywhere. She envisions a new social order in which women can establish households with other women, black men can go to Columbia University, and racism does not beat a soul down. In her friendship with
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
Weaver, there is a suggestion of the possibility of healthy male/female relationships based on common interests, shared enterprises, and mutual respect and support. Mattie sees the lawyer in Weaver and the sane person in crazy Emmie, and she sees how to make thirty dollars spread thin enough to help all those in need. Pa’s mule is paid for and Tommy Hubbard comes to help him with the farm, she pays off Emmie Hubbard’s back taxes so she and Mrs. Smith can have a home, and she also offers Weaver the train fare he needs to get to Columbia. She ‘‘stitches things up nicely and leaves no ends dangling,’’ but each happy ending she helps to create is freshly coined and transcendent. Source: Cynthia Clough, Critical Essay on A Northern Light, in Literary Newsmakers for Students, Thomson Gale, 2006.
Chartered Institute of Library and Information Professionals In the following essay, Donnelly explains to Update how a century-old murder led her to write the Carnegie Medal-winning novel, A Northern Light.’’ Note that A Northern Light was published under the name A Gathering Light in Great Britain. In A Gathering Light, which has won this year’s Carnegie Medal, Jennifer Donnelly tells the story of a young girl, Mattie Gokey, who has to choose between her family, struggling to help her widowed father make a backbreaking living farming in the foothills of the Adirondack mountains, and her own dreams of studying literature in New York. Interwoven is the true story of a young, pregnant woman, Grace Brown, murdered in mysterious circumstances in 1906. The case achieved notoriety at the time. Grace’s lover was arrested and tried for the murder on the strength of her letters recovered subsequently. The story was re-told fictionally in Theodore Dreiser’s An American Tragedy and made into a film twice, first in the 1930s, then again in 1951 as A Place in the Sun starring Elizabeth Taylor and Montgomery Clift. The murder was local history for Donnelly, whose own grandmother had worked in a hotel on Big Moose Lake where the body was recovered. Her family reminisced about it. And it haunted Donnelly herself—‘Grace wouldn’t leave me alone.’ She read Dreiser, and a factual account of the murder. But the letters themselves
V o l u m e
1
2 0 7
A
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
THE POWER OF A GATHERING LIGHT COMES FROM ITS DILEMMAS, WHICH ARE UNIVERSAL: THE DESPERATE WISH TO BREAK FREE FROM THE HARD LABOUR AND GRINDING POVERTY OF THEIR LIFE ON THE LAND; THE CONFLICT BETWEEN LOYALTY TO FAMILY AND WHAT ONE KNOWS, AND THE ATTRACTIONS OF DREAMS AND ASPIRATIONS.’’
were what really clinched the matter: ‘Her voice, her words. It tore me apart. I started grieving for her, even though she lived 100 years ago.’ What Donnelly could not stand was that Grace had been murdered at 19 for being pregnant, for not fitting in. Her letters were so vivid and evocative of their time that she decided she had to work out her own emotions ‘by writing, telling the story in a new way, fictionalised, from my point of view’. In a piece for the Guardian, she describes her anger: ‘During a summer that saw the headlines in America full of violence against girls and women, things didn’t seem to have changed much.’ The power of the story— and the power in the telling—is not an accident in Donnelly’s family. Her father’s ancestors were Irish immigrants who escaped the famine in 1848. They were very poor farmers, who settled in upstate New York to eke out a living, farming in what is still ‘a brutal place’. Summers were short and, once over, ‘it was a matter of life and death to get through the winter. You had to be smart, self-reliant, strong, to weather the remoteness and the loneliness’. The landscape—of ‘staggering beauty’—has produced ‘a strong silent people, independent, proud. And used to do doing what they want, non-conformists’.
was a culture of reading when she grew up. ‘I didn’t think about it at the time, but I suppose that part time I was picking up the value of stories, the importance of early tradition.’ And not only that. ‘Hearing the older generation sit and talk, you absorb how to do pacing and suspense, and structure; how to hold your listeners rapt, how to deliver a good punch line.’ The ability to listen and hear the words talk was another thing, reflected in the dialogue, the word-games (and some dialect) of A Gathering Light. And in one of the book’s central messages—the power of words to overcome adversity, to make people feel. Donnelly has always been fascinated by language. She lived in London in the early 1980s and ‘spent every spare moment’ in the East End of London. ‘I used to go to Brick Lane early on Sunday. Costermongers would sing their wares. Wide boys would hand jewelry back and forth and pull out wodges of cash. There were cockles and pickled whelks, and jellied eels. It was as close to the London of Hogarth and Dickens as I would ever get. The sellers made theatre out of words, out of their patter.’ She thinks that Cockneys have a lot in common with northern New Yorkers: ‘One is an urban culture, one rural, but they were both cultures of the poor. If they like you, they tease you. It is wrong to be openly affectionate. Maybe it isn’t good to be too open. To survive, to be successful, you had to be tough.’
The power of words
A Gathering Light has become a successful ‘cross-over’ novel, particularly since being chosen by the Richard & Judy show as one of their ‘Summer Reads’. But it was originally written with young girls, not adults, in mind. Donnelly wanted to show them that they have choices in life, but that choosing is never easy. She wanted to reach them before they made choices that set the course for their lives. ‘Mattie adores her sisters and loves her father. She sees the attraction of family. Royal [who becomes her beau, and wants to marry her] is a good-looking, capable guy. He has a passion for farming and the land. People like him are valued still.’
Storytelling was a tradition after meals. It was the only entertainment they could afford and, during the long winters, it helped to overcome the isolation. The whole family, she says, ‘are born storytellers’. Her mother (in fact a German, orphaned during the war, who emigrated to the US) told her own stories too, and read to her. And the whole family read—there
Much of the novel is about the tug of war in Mattie’s heart between her feelings of loyalty to family and place, and her longing to study and to read and be a writer (which her family cannot understand). She wants to go to college, to be like the literature teacher at school, who encourages and inspires her. (The teacher, Miss Wilcox, is based on Emily Dickinson and one of
2 0 8
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
A
Donnelly’s high-school English teachers.) Mattie is encouraged, too, by her black schoolfriend Weaver, himself determined to overcome poverty and racial discrimination by getting a good education and becoming a lawyer. It is Mattie’s work in a local hotel (To earn money to be able to pay to go to college? Or support her father and the family? Or save to get married?) that brings her into contact with Grace Brown and her letters, and a story that she cannot ignore. As Mattie learns more, she gradually finds the courage and strength to make her own choices. But there is no wish—or attempt—by Donnelly to preach. ‘I didn’t want to say that Mattie’s choice is the best or only choice.’ Mattie is pulled in two directions, as was Donnelly herself, until recently too much influenced by earlier feminist voices to find time in her life for as many children as she now wishes she could have—a source of regret.
Universal issues The power of A Gathering Light comes from its dilemmas, which are universal: the desperate wish to break free from the hard labour and grinding poverty of their life on the land; the conflict between loyalty to family and what one knows, and the attractions of dreams and aspirations. It is why the book appeals to adults too, though one could add that Donnelly’s sensitivity to social injustice gives urgency to the narrative, without ever leading to stereotyping, or making her didactic. After all of this, it comes perhaps as a surprise that Donnelly herself ‘had a fortunate childhood, parents who pushed me hard to do my best.’ Never any real deprivation, then. Even when she fell in with a much wealthier bunch of friends, her father merely advised her, if she wanted what they had, to ‘Work. Get an education. Make something of yourself.’ And that she did, getting up at 4:30 in the morning or 5, to write for a couple of hours before going out to earn a wage. Her writing was ‘years and years in the making’ before she found a publisher, or achieved recognition. She went through years of depression and despair to get there, even though she had been telling stories since childhood and ‘inflicting them’ on her family. Even after 10 years when she had finished The Tea Rose, her first novel, it took a while to
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
find a publisher. But her agent is ‘as stubborn and persistent as I am’.
Sense of privilege Perhaps some of the drive comes from a sense of privilege at what she has—and her great-grandparents had not. Her great-grandfather would have loved an opportunity of education. ‘He was taken out of school at 12 to drive mules and make money for the family. He died young and was bed-ridden before he passed away. All he wanted to do before he died was read. His children had to keep bringing him books. What would his life have been if he had had a few of the opportunities I had?’ When she was researching for the book, she once asked her grandmother (an inspiration for the character of Mattie) if she had minded not having had time to read or study. To which she retorted that there was not time—there was so much work to be done, just to put food on the table. ‘To live you had to grow your own food. Your survival depended on your ability to farm.’ Colin Brabazon, Chair of the Carnegie judges, praised ‘the striking luminosity’ of A Gathering Light’s prose, ‘its tangible sense of place and the integrity of its vision’. Perhaps it was inspired, too, by some of the imagery of Donnelly’s Irish Catholic upbringing. She thinks that the obligatory attendance at church (‘it was an accepted part of your life’) gave her a good basis for storytelling. ‘I sat and listened to the Gospel. I wanted Judas to have a change of heart. It was amazing stuff—about loyalty, and betrayal, and faith. The stories gave you a lot of things to think about at 7 or 8 years old, sitting in church, bored out of your skull!’ The sense of wonder, of the miraculous, a heightened feeling of excitement and expectation, has stayed with her, though she does not describe herself as religious. Donnelly is pleased—and surprised— about the interest the novel has aroused across the generations (and the gender divide thanks to Weaver). She thinks that ‘literature’ is very much adult-oriented. ‘Teenagers tend to look to adult characters and situations, but it means a tremendous amount to them if adults repay the favour, by occasionally venturing back.’ She thinks this sends a very powerful message—‘that we value their stories and their concerns. It means the world to a kid to have someone take an interest in what he or she is interested in.’
V o l u m e
1
2 0 9
A
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
Lake in the Adirondacks Ó James L. Amos/Corbis
Nonetheless, it is probably the sense of conviction conveyed by the writing, the universal dilemmas and the power of the story-telling in this book that appeal to adults as well as young people. It is ironic and apt that it was oral tradition that attracted Donnelly to prose, and the power of shared stories that is driving readers back to narrative fiction—perhaps one of the most striking features about the current ‘crossover’ phenomenon. Though the characters in the novel came to her ‘out of the mist’, it is real voices that inspire Donnelly. She loves the historical research. ‘I went to the library of the Adirondack Museum. I’d sit down and tell the librarian what I was after, and he would go back and forth, bringing collections of this and that—diaries, menus from the great camps, old newspapers, a lock of Grace Brown’s hair—a writer’s treasure trove.’ This took her on paths she never knew existed. ‘He’d say: ‘‘Do you know about this?’’ or ‘‘Try that.’’ I am sure many, many authors owe huge debts to librarians and archivists for their work. I know I do!’. Source: Chartered Institute of Library and Information Professionals, ‘‘Haunted by Grace,’’ in Update, September 2004, p. 1.
2 1 0
L i t e r a r y
SOURCES Baker, Dierdre, Review of A Northern Light in Jennifer Donnelly Reviews, www.jenniferdonnelly.com/jd_reviews (September 20, 2005); originally published in the Toronto Star. Beil, Karen Magnuson, ‘‘Jennifer Donnelly Sifts through Adirondack History in A Northern Light, Recipient of the Printz Honor Award,’’ Children’s Literature Connection, www.childrensliteratureconnection.org (May 16, 2005). ‘‘Carnegie Winner Offers Message for Teens,’’ in The Bookseller, Issue 5137, July16, 2004, p. 30. Donnelly, Jennifer, A Northern Light, Harcourt, 2003. Glenn, Wendy J., Review of A Northern Light, in the Journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy, Vol. 47, Issue 3, November 2003, p. 265. Hall, Dinah, Review of A Northern Light, in Bloomsbury Magazine, www.bloomsbury.com/ezine/Articles/Articles. asp?ezine_article_id=862 (May 30, 2003); originally published in the Sunday Telegraph, July 2003. ‘‘Haunted by Grace,’’ CILIP Update Magazine, September 2004, Chartered Institute of Library and Information Professionals, www.book.guardian.co.uk/ print10.3858.4966913.110738.00html (May 15, 2005). MacDonald, Sandy, Review of A Northern Light in the New York Times, September 21, 2003, Section 7, Column 4, Page 27.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
A
Odanaka, Barbara J., ‘‘‘I’m Just Loving Life Right Now’: Author Jennifer Donnelly Talks about Her Really Big Two-Book Deal,’’ in Authorlink, www.authorlink.com (July 2001). ‘‘Murder on Big Moose Lake,’’ in The Bookseller, January 24, 2003, p. 30. Reviews of A Northern Light, in Jennifer Donnelly Reviews, www.jenniferdonnelly.com/jd_reviews (September 20, 2005). Stiles, Kristina, ‘‘The History of Grace Brown,’’ at www.ovcs.org/district/brown.htm (May 15, 2005). Williamson, Courtney, Review of A Northern Light,’’Christian Science Monitor, www.csmonitorservices. com (July 31, 2001).
FURTHER READING Alkalay-Gut, Karen, Alone in the Dawn: The Life of Adelaide Crapsey, University of Georgia Press, 1988. Donnelly invokes the presence of Adelaide Crapsey in her epigraph, and the poet is clearly the model for Emily Baxter Wilcox. A 1901 graduate of Vassar College from Rochester, New York, Crapsey studied Classics at the American Academy in Rome, taught in New England prep schools, and died fairly young of tuberculosis. She is best known for formal
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
N o r t h e r n
L i g h t
verse, especially the cinquain, a five line syllabic poem similar to haiku, which she devised to suit her poetic temperament. Brandon, Craig, Murder in the Adirondacks: ‘‘An American Tragedy’’ Revisited, North Country Books, 1986. Brandon is a journalist who thoroughly researched the Gillette-Brown murder, investigating especially the family backgrounds of Grace and Chester. The book is a compelling read and an insightful resource for factual information about the case, the couple, and the environment in which the events took place. Dreiser, Theodore, An American Tragedy, Signet Classics Reissue edition, 2000. Dreiser saw the Gillette-Brown murder of 1906 as a direct consequence of the American dream gone wrong. His novel, which inspired Jennifer Donnelly to explore the murder through Mattie’s eyes, focuses more on the psychology of Chester Gillette (through the character Clyde Griffiths) and the social forces that drove him to commit the murder. Myer, Ruth, A Farm Girl in the Great Depression, Busca, 1998. Donnelly drew on this first-hand account by a woman who grew up on an Upstate New York farm during the depression for the character of Mattie Gokey.
V o l u m e
1
2 1 1
Seabiscuit: An American Legend Seabiscuit: An American Legend is the first booklength work published by Laura Hillenbrand. While suffering from a debilitating illness, Hillenbrand wrote short pieces and feature articles for a variety of equestrian magazines before becoming captivated by the tale of Seabiscuit and the men who believed in him. She found that his story was a triumph over adversity that mimicked her personal predicament in many ways. Though nonfiction, the book pushes the reader forward using narrative elements more commonly found in fiction novels, as lives and situations intersect and diverge. The plethora of detail is a testament to Hillenbrand’s thorough research. The book takes place between 1929 and 1940, a period during which the world changed dramatically. In the United States, a stock market crash heralded the decade-long Great Depression that mired the country in despair and hopelessness. During those dark days, average citizens clung to even the smallest diversion that afforded hope or escape from their daily lives. An unlikely hero—a short, squat, and seemingly unfit racehorse—offered one such distraction, becoming a media darling and capturing the national imagination. In fact, in 1938, as the word teetered on the brink of World War II, the majority of news coverage was devoted not to politicians or warmongers but to one knobby-kneed horse nearly past his prime. Seabiscuit became a cultural icon,
2 1 2
LAURA HILLENBRAND 2001
S e a b i s c u i t :
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
Red Pollard with Seabiscuit, 1938 Getty Images
according to Hillenbrand, and offered hope to a generation of disadvantaged people: if he could overcome adversity and become a winner, so could they. From his initial outings in the dust of Tijuana to his grudge match with Triple Crown winner War Admiral, Seabiscuit epitomized the rags-to-riches American dream for millions of impoverished citizens who wondered whether the dream was still possible. Although the horse became the focus of public attention, it was the convergence of the unique men contributing to Seabiscuit’s success that piqued the interest of the media reports of the day, just as it is for Hillenbrand’s book. The unlikely matching of a self-made business tycoon, a taciturn cowboy horse trainer, and a gangly, half-blind jockey rounded out the quartet that captured the hearts of an eager public, as well as the imagination of Hillenbrand.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
College in Gambier, Ohio, getting good grades and planning to spend her junior year at the University of Edinburgh in Scotland, when she became suddenly and inexplicably ill. Thinking it was merely a case of food poisoning, she ignored the symptoms and waited for the illness to go away. Instead, the illness worsened, and other symptoms arose. These eventually became so debilitating that Hillenbrand was bedridden; ultimately, she dropped out of school and returned to her family in Fairfax. She visited many doctors, who variously diagnosed her as suffering from the EpsteinBarr virus, bulimia, and nothing at all. Finally, at Johns Hopkins, Hillenbrand was told she was suffering from Chronic Fatigue Syndrome—a disease often referred to as the ‘‘yuppie flu’’ for its prevalence among upwardly mobile overachievers. Even though she had a diagnosis, there was no known cure; as the symptoms worsened, she was essentially bedridden from August 1991 until the summer of 1994.
Laura Hillenbrand was born in 1967 in Fairfax, Virginia. Her parents separated when she was a child, leaving her mother, a psychologist, to raise four children. A bright and athletic young woman, Hillenbrand was attending Kenyon
In an effort to find something to fill her days, Hillenbrand parlayed her interest in horses and horseracing into short magazine articles, which were published in periodicals such as Equus and Turf Flash. During her research,
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
2 1 3
S e a b i s c u i t :
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
Hillenbrand stumbled across a name from her childhood: Seabiscuit. Her favorite book as a child was Come on Seabiscuit! by Ralph Moody (1963), about an underdog horse who made it big. Intrigued, she collected everything she could find on the horse and its jockey to construct an article for American Heritage. She soon realized she had entirely too much information for a short article and decided to write a book instead. Seabiscuit: An American Legend was published by Random House in 2001. Almost from the outset, the book took the nation by storm, topping the bestseller lists and staying there for weeks. Among other accolades, the work was a finalist for the National Book Critics Circle Award, winner of the 2001 William Hill Sports Book of the Year Award, and received ‘‘best of the year’’ honors from such notable publications as New York magazine, the Economist, the New York Times, and the Washington Post. Because of the success of the book and the sentimental nature of the subject matter, the bid for film rights came quickly. The film was produced under Hillenbrand’s close supervision, even though her illness kept her far from Hollywood. The film, adapted for the screen and directed by Gary Ross, was released in 2003.
PLOT SUMMARY Chapter 1: The Day of the Horse is Past
Horses and people flee. Snatching opportunity in the midst of adversity, Howard offers his previously useless Buicks as ambulances and transport, proving the worth of the automobile and eventually creating enormous wealth for himself.
Chapter 2: The Lone Plainsman Tom Smith is an archetypal cowboy, an original against which all others are compared. He is a man of the open plains who drifts from job to job and is more comfortable in the company of horses than he is with humans. While working for the garrulous and gargantuan Charlie Irwin, owner of the largest racing stable in the country, Smith learns that the horse with the fastest breakout from the starting gate is usually the winner. Irwin notes Smith’s way with animals and makes him a trainer. After Irwin’s untimely death in an automobile accident, Smith drifts from job to job until he is introduced to Charles Howard.
Chapter 3: Mean, Restive and Ragged Howard wants to increase his thoroughbred holdings, but he is more intrigued by spirit than by breeding. In 1936, he sends Smith east to scout for horses. After attending several auctions and discounting numerous possibilities, on June 29, Smith is standing by a paddock when the perfect horse finds him. An unlikely descendant of champion lines, the horse surveys the trainer with haughty indifference, and Smith knows he has found his winner. The horse has attitude.
In 1903, Charles Howard leaves his home and family in New York and travels west to seek his livelihood. Arriving in San Francisco with twenty-one cents in his pocket, he uses his charm to borrow enough money to open a small bicycle repair shop. Soon, locals who had been foolish enough to purchase a new contraption— the horseless carriage, or automobile—appear at Howard’s door, seeking his advice on repairing the machines. A visionary, Howard notes the advantages the steel beasts have over the current mode of transport, the horse. He travels to Detroit to convince Will Durant, the chief of Buick and future founder of General Motors, to give him the company’s automobile sales franchise for San Francisco.
Chapter 4: The Cougar and the Iceman
On April 18, 1906, the San Francisco earthquake, registering 7.8 on the Richter scale, alters the course of Howard’s life. The earthquake causes hundreds of deaths, thousands of injuries, fractured streets and roads, and major fires.
The candidate for jockey is almost as unlikely as the steed. Johnny Pollard, dubbed Red for his carrot-colored hair, is an oversized intellectual who, Hillenbrand remarks, ‘‘is one of the worst riders anywhere.’’ After a rocky start,
2 1 4
L i t e r a r y
The horse’s current trainer, James Fitzsimmons, is, according to Hillenbrand, ‘‘the only man whom Smith ever regarded with awe.’’ Fitzsimmons had trained Hard Tack, a Triple Crown winner and the son of the legendary Man o’ War. Consequently, he had inherited Hard Tack’s sons, Grog and Seabiscuit, both of which had little resemblance to their sire. Fitzsimmons notes the two things Seabiscuit did best were sleep and eat; his assessment of the animal’s ability is that he is lazy. But Smith, and later Howard, see potential. The sale is finalized and they begin searching for a jockey.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
S e a b i s c u i t :
Pollard signs on as an apprentice jockey or ‘‘bug boy,’’ so named for the asterisk beside a novice’s listings in the race program that looks like a bug. During this time, most bug boys are young runaways or orphans who are overworked, barely paid, and bulimic in order to maintain weight requirements. They are frequently traded, sold, or lost in card games without their consent. As Pollard’s skill with difficult mounts becomes obvious, his lack of skill as a rider is overlooked and he is viewed as a specialist who could ride any steed offered to him. In addition to a growing reputation, Pollard gains his first real friend, veteran jockey George Woolf, nicknamed the Iceman for his unflappable style.
Chapter 5: A Boot on One Foot, a Toe Tag on the Other The life of a jockey in these early days of racing is not an ideal one. Their lives are chained to making a successful impost, the weight each horse is permitted to carry in a particular contest. From purgatives to laxatives to starvation, the young men fight to stay thin while they are often housed in the corner of the horse stall. These conditions produce not only malnutrition and dehydration but also lead to weakened immune systems and a tendency to be accidentprone. In addition to their physical condition, the riders live in constant fear of being thrown from or pinned under their huge mounts. Yet, through it all, they maintain an illusion of invincibility.
Chapter 6: Light and Shadow In 1928, Pollard and Woolf parlay their friendship into racetrack legend. With Pollard as the tamer of wild beasts and Woolf as the charismatic media darling, they become racetrack celebrities in Mexico. As their reputation in the Tijuana circuit grows, however, so do their personal problems. For Woolf, a diagnosis of Type I diabetes produces bouts of sleepiness and a tendency to gain weight; for Pollard, a small rock or clump of dirt launched into his eye by a passing horse results in permanent blindness on his right side. Keeping their conditions secret, the jockeys continue to ride. The racing culture in Tijuana crumbles in 1934 when Mexico bans gambling. By then, however, California has reinstituted pari-mutuel betting, which offers the state a percentage of the take, and has sanctioned the opening of Santa Anita Park. After returning to the United States,
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
the friends part ways; Woolf ’s career grows, resulting in better and faster mounts, while Pollard backslides into oblivion. Two years later, Pollard, destitute and broken, wanders into Detroit, begging for jobs. Trainers laugh him away as he wanders from stall to stall until Tom Smith extends his hand and introduces the jockey to Seabiscuit.
Chapter 7: Learn Your Horse When horses are as skittish and temperamental as Seabiscuit, one trick of the trade is to give them a companion. The first stall mate Smith tries is a nanny goat, which Seabiscuit launches over the stall door. The second is a lead horse called Pumpkin that becomes the thoroughbred’s constant companion. Smith determines that most of the horse’s reactionary behavior is due to previous ill treatment, and decides he can produce results by getting the steed to trust him and the jockey. Seabiscuit is limited by not only his physicality and his temperament but also by his age. Because the Triple Crown—the Kentucky Derby, the Preakness Stakes, and the Belmont Stakes—is limited to entries three years or younger, the four-year-old thoroughbred does not qualify. However, the horse proves himself at smaller venues from east to west, and even earns a private sleeping car on the train that transports him.
Chapter 8: Fifteen Strides In 1936, Smith and Howard decide it is time to unleash their well-kept secret; they enter Seabiscuit in the Bay Bridge Handicap at Bay Meadows. The horse quickly reduces the field, shocking spectators and reporters alike. By December, Howard and Smith know the horse is ready for the hundred-thousand-dollar Santa Anita match. There he must face the formidable Rosemont, the thoroughbred considered the best horse in the world by most racing enthusiasts on the West Coast. Unfortunately, at a decisive moment in the contest, both Pollard and Seabiscuit lose momentum, producing a photo finish between the two horses. The final decision goes to Rosemont.
Chapter 9: Gravity In 1937, the United States is in the throes of economic and social upheaval. Unemployment and poverty are rampant and citizens seek any means of escape from the reality of their dreary
V o l u m e
1
2 1 5
S e a b i s c u i t :
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
lives. The combination of legalized track betting and the availability of affordable radios offer that escape. Radio reporters prowl the tracks, seeking to scoop their peers, and Smith, always circumspect, makes a game out of eluding them by exercising Seabiscuit at different venues or times. When he is aware newsmen are around, he substitutes Grog, the horse’s twin brother, to foil the persistent reporters.
Chapter 10: War Admiral Owned by racing aficionado Samuel Riddle, who also owned his sire Man o’ War, War Admiral is the pride of East Coast racing. A Triple Crown winner, War Admiral is considered the fleetest mount on the circuit. Temperamental and eager as the others in his line, the horse is allowed to start outside the starting gates because his jockey, Charley Kurtsinger, cannot keep him from crashing through the boards. Consequently, War Admiral is the horse to beat. To secure Seabiscuit’s national reputation, Howard enters him in the Brooklyn Handicap, where he finally demolishes Rosemont. From there the team moves on to Massachusetts, where Seabiscuit sweeps the field; he is followed closely by a young filly named Fair Knightess. Howard is so impressed by her energy that he purchases the filly—not only to race but to breed with Seabiscuit after his retirement.
three months away. To add insult to injury, sportswriters select War Admiral as Horse of the Year. The state racing board upholds Pollard’s suspension, and Howard reacts by pulling his entries in all state races until the jockey is reinstated. By February, Pollard is back in the saddle and Seabiscuit is entered in the San Carlos Handicap; once again, the track conditions are muddy and the horse is scratched. Pollard opts to ride Fair Knightess, which proves to be a fatal error. Mid-track, the filly loses her footing and goes down with another horse directly behind her. The other horse plows into Fair Knightess, flipping her massive frame on top of Pollard. The left side of Pollard’s chest is crushed, and he is told he cannot ride for at least a year. The Santa Anita, also known as ‘‘the hundred grander,’’ is just around the corner, and although Howard wants to pull the horse from the race, Pollard will not hear of it. He recommends that Howard hire his old friend, George Woolf, for the mount.
Chapter 12: All I Need Is Luck
Racing fans, urged on by the press, clamor for a match between Seabiscuit and War Admiral. Both horses are entered in the Washington Handicap, but the track is wet; Seabiscuit is scratched, or removed from competition, to prevent injury from racing on the muddy track. The supporters of War Admiral chide that Howard is afraid to pit Seabiscuit against the champion, pushing the man harder to arrange a one-on-one match. Despite a lucrative offer, Riddle refuses to match the horses.
Adding to Pollard’s bad luck, Smith becomes ill and there are rumors of a kidnapping plot against George Woolf. Despite it all, Seabiscuit appears at Santa Anita to compete once again for the title of greatest money winner of all time. During the race, however, the horse Count Atlas pulls alongside, pushing Seabiscuit toward the wall. The act is an obvious foul, but the horses are out of view of the reviewing stand, so the foul goes undocumented. As Woolf pulls away, his first reaction is to whack the other jockey with his whip. It works, and regaining his competitive spirit, Seabiscuit dives down the track, neck and neck with another contender, Stagehand. The horses hit the finish line at exactly the same time; once again, Seabiscuit is denied the photo finish.
Chapter 11: No Pollard, No Seabiscuit
Chapter 13: Hardball
In December 1937, Pollard, riding the colt Exhibit, accidentally brushes another horse, and the horse’s rider complains to officials. Although Pollard was not at fault, the stewards, the track racing commission, suspend him from the venue and recommend he be suspended from all California tracks for the rest of the year. The news is particularly shocking since Seabiscuit is scheduled to meet War Admiral in March, only
While turmoil swirls around the Seabiscuit camp, negotiations with Riddle continue. The bout between Seabiscuit and War Admiral is finally set for Memorial Day, with a $100,000
2 1 6
L i t e r a r y
After the race, a group of reporters petition to have the race video reviewed to establish the foul committed against Seabiscuit. Although the tape reveals the foul, it also reveals Woolf striking the other jockey. Woolf is suspended.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
S e a b i s c u i t :
purse. Only one condition remains. Howard wants Pollard to ride; if the jockey is not physically up to task, the event will be canceled.
Chapter 14: The Wise We Boys Since War Admiral starts outside the gate, Smith has to train Seabiscuit to do the same. Using the classical conditioning of Pavlov, who trained dogs to salivate whenever they heard a bell in anticipation of food, Smith teaches Seabiscuit to react to the starting alarm. Once again, the trainer plays hide-and-seek with the eager press to keep his training tactics secret. Then, the unforeseeable strikes: Seabiscuit develops soreness in his knee. Smith cables Howard to come immediately. Once again, the race is called off. In June, Riddle and War Admiral head for Suffolk Downs in Massachusetts, and Howard and Smith follow.
Chapter 15: Fortune’s Fool Shortly before the Massachusetts match, Pollard runs into an old friend from his Tijuana days, Bert Blume, who is in a bind because his exercise rider has failed to show up. As a favor, Pollard offers to take his friend’s horse for a workout. Things go smoothly until something spooks the horse, who crashes through the rail and gallops off toward the barn with Pollard still astride. With momentum carrying him, the horse skids and slams into the side of the barn. By the time horse and rider come to a stop, Pollard has damaged most of his right leg below the knee. Hospitalized and told he will never ride again, Pollard buries his pain and disappointment in alcohol. Woolf is summoned to ride Seabiscuit. Just as it appears that the thoroughbred will at last meet War Admiral, Seabiscuit develops pain in his leg and has to be scratched once again.
Chapter 16: I Know My Horse Back in California, Smith nurtures Seabiscuit and readies him for Hollywood Park. Track officials want to send veterinarians to examine the horse for soundness. Smith refuses, stating he knows the horse, and he alone will make that decision. Seabiscuit races, and takes home the gold trophy.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
Chapter 17: The Dingbustingest Contest You Ever Clapped an Eye On The eldest Howard son, Lin, creates a racing partnership with singer and actor Bing Crosby, part owner of the new Del Mar racetrack near San Diego. To promote the track, the younger Howard pits his best racer, Ligaroti, against Seabiscuit. During the match, Ligaroti lags behind until his jockey pulls alongside Seabiscuit and grabs the blanket under the horse’s saddle. Woolf and his mount literally drag the other horse and rider along. At the finish line, Woolf knows he needs to act; he reaches for Ligaroti’s bridle, raising the horse’s head so that Seabiscuit goes under the wire first. There is an inquiry, and Woolf is again in danger of suspension.
Chapter 18: Deal As Woolf faces suspension, the injured Pollard falls in love with his nurse, Agnes Condon. At the same time, Alfred Vanderbilt, a friend of Howard’s and owner of the Pimlico racetrack, attempts to renegotiate with Riddle for a two-horse match between War Admiral and Seabiscuit. Riddle finally agrees, but only if both owners put up a $5,000 forfeit fee in case the match is called off again. The race is the talk of the country, lauded as East versus West, and is scheduled to take place at Pimlico in Maryland. It rains for days before the event. Knowing that this is the last chance for Seabiscuit to race War Admiral, Woolf memorizes the track and discovers a hard-packed path that would be perfect for Seabiscuit’s footing.
Chapter 19: The Second Civil War On November 1, 1938, before a sold-out crowd, Seabiscuit and War Admiral face off. When the dust clears, Seabiscuit is declared the winner, finishing three lengths in front of War Admiral. In addition to winning, the horse breaks a Pimlico track record that was set shortly after the Civil War. With such a decisive victory, Seabiscuit is voted Horse of the Year. War Admiral runs only two more races before retirement. Everyone asks Howard if the same will happen to Seabiscuit, but Howard wants to try again to win the Santa Anita.
Chapter 20: All Four of His Legs Are Broken When Pollard is released from the hospital— bankrupt, homeless, and unemployable—Howard
V o l u m e
1
2 1 7
S e a b i s c u i t :
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
invites him to move into his home. In the meantime, Woolf rides in the Santa Anita; during the match, Seabiscuit stumbles, rupturing a suspensory ligament. However, the Howard stable does finally win the coveted prize at Santa Anita, but with a new purchase, Kayak II, instead of Seabiscuit.
Chapter 21: A Long, Hard Pull Once he is settled on the ranch, Pollard sends for Agnes and they are married. Seabiscuit comes home to recuperate and is placed in Pollard’s care as Smith travels east with Kayak II. Over time, both Pollard and the thoroughbred begin to heal. They both make remarkable recoveries, and in the fall of 1939, the Howard team once again leaves for Santa Anita.
Chapter 22: Four Good Legs Between Us With three months to prepare for the race, Seabiscuit once again becomes the focus of an inquisitive media and the talk of the nation. Merchandising stands spring up, and the horse’s likeness is everywhere. Pollard rigs a brace for his still-injured leg; he is allowed to exercise the horse, but he wants more. If Seabiscuit is ready to win the race that has long eluded him, Pollard wants to be on his back in the winner’s circle. Howard is less enthusiastic; the doctors have already emphasized that another break will cripple Pollard for life.
Chapter 23: One Hundred Grand Still indecisive about who will ride, Howard consults Woolf. The jockey thinks it would be better to break a man’s legs than his heart. On the day of the race, Pollard is astride Seabiscuit in front of the second-largest crowd ever to attend a horse race. Not only does the stallion finally win the elusive prize, he sets a new track record for speed and a new world record for monies won.
Epilogue In 1940, Seabiscuit retires from the track and sires a foal named First Biscuit. Away from competition, Seabiscuit becomes restless; Howard decides to harness the energy by teaching the horse to herd cattle. In 1947, Seabiscuit passes away and is buried in a secret place on the Howard ranch. As for the others, Woolf garners a reputation as the best rider in the country. Soon after,
2 1 8
L i t e r a r y
MEDIA ADAPTATIONS
Seabiscuit: An American Legend was adapted into a film by writer-director Gary Ross in 2003 and was released by Universal. The film stars Jeff Bridges, Chris Cooper, and Tobey Maguire. The film is available on DVD through MCA Home Video. The film is spliced with actual footage from the 1930s, which adds to the authenticity of the historical narrative.
Seabiscuit: An American Legend was released in an abridged version on audiocassette and compact disc by Random House Audio in 2003. The book is read by Campbell Scott and is widely available.
his health deteriorates, and he suffers a fatal accident while racing at Santa Anita. After having to leave his post with Howard while recovering from back surgery, Smith leaves the west to train horses for cosmetics mogul Elizabeth Arden Graham; he dies in 1957. Pollard, ravaged with illness and alcoholism, leaves racing, only to return years later with less and less success. He passes away in 1981; his wife, Agnes, succumbs to cancer only two weeks later.
CHARACTERS James Fitzsimmons James Fitzsimmons grows up in Brooklyn and spends a great deal of time at the Coney Island Jockey Club. By age ten, he is working odd jobs at the track and trying his hand at being a jockey. Deciding that aspect of the sport is not for him, Sunny Jim, as he is called at the track, carves his place in the industry as the best conditioner of thoroughbreds in the country. Fitzsimmons trains Hard Tack, the roguishtempered father, of Seabiscuit until it becomes evident that Hard Tack is literally untrainable. His owner, Gladys Phipps, offers him at stud,
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
S e a b i s c u i t :
but when no one accepts her free offer, she mates the horse with one of her own mares. The result is Seabiscuit and Grog, neither of which have their father’s temperament or their champion grandfather’s zeal. By virtue of his work with the lineage, Fitzsimmons is entrusted with the training of the offspring. After determining that Seabiscuit has speed but is lazy, Fitzsimmons suspends his no-whip rule, literally lashing the horse into submission. The method succeeds and Seabiscuit is raced constantly, tripling a normal workload.
Charles Howard The ultimate owner of Seabiscuit, Charles Howard is handsome and well-mannered with a charismatic energy that draws people to him. Over six feet tall, he is trained as a military horseman and tries to serve in the Spanish American War, but he contracts dysentery and has to remain in camp. Howard’s father was a scandalous playboy who abandoned his family, so Howard is raised by his mother in a structured, upper-class environment. According to Hillenbrand, Howard ‘‘made himself into his father’s antithesis,’’. Stifled by life on the East Coast, at age twenty-six, Howard leaves his wife, Fannie May, and two young sons in New York while he journeys to San Francisco to seek his fortune. Arriving with only a few pennies in his pocket, he wheedles enough money to open a bicycle repair shop. Since the automobile is a novel invention and no auto mechanics are available, owners of automobiles begin bringing them to Howard for repair; it is not long before automobiles are part of his vision for the future. Thusly inspired, he goes to Detroit to visit Will Durant, the founder of Buick and General Motors (GM), and convinces the man to give him the San Francisco dealership for his automobiles. After Howard uses the vehicles as emergency transport following the San Francisco earthquake, public opinion of the ‘‘horseless carriage’’ begins to shift favorably.
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
fifteen-year-old son, Frankie, in a car accident. After Frankie dies, his somewhat unstable marriage deteriorates and he begins frequenting Tijuana, Mexico, where a growing market caters to U.S. citizens escaping the Prohibition of the 1920s. In 1929, Howard meets Marcela Zabala, the sister of his daughter-in-law, and despite their age difference, the two are married. Marcela is a veteran horsewoman, and with her encouragement, Howard begins purchasing racehorses. That year also marks the crash of the stock market, which may have contributed to the re-legalization of horse racing in California. Throughout the book, Howard’s encounters with others are marked by his empathy, kindness, and almost resigned acceptance of fortune’s ebb and flow. He has a strong sense of public image and engages in philanthropic causes, including providing a home for Pollard, his wounded jockey. In a sense, Pollard becomes a surrogate son to Howard, replacing the son he lost. Howard is vocal and craves media attention, but under the braggadocio, he is a kind and genteel man.
Lin Howard Charles Howard’s oldest son Lin partners with Bing Crosby to create a stable of thoroughbreds and challenge his father’s dominance of the circuit. His wife is Marcela Zabala’s sister, and it is Lin and his wife who introduce Marcela and Charles.
Marcela Zabala Howard Marcela, Charles Howard’s second wife, is his daughter-in-law’s sister. A striking brunette, the young actress and former Salinas, California, Lettuce Queen is full of grace and charm. Marcela is half Howard’s age; however, they are well-matched. They share an effervescent empathy, a love of horses and the spotlight, and a zest for life.
Agnes Pollard
To make himself more publicly and promotionally visible, Howard begins racing cars. This increases his sales and, in 1909, he is awarded sole GM distributorship for all of the western states. As his fortune grows, he engages in philanthropic endeavors and purchases a ranch, Ridgewood, for his wife and four sons. The turning point in Howard’s life is the death of his
Agnes Pollard is Red Pollard’s nurse during his convalescence after a near-fatal riding injury. Eventually, despite the vast differences in their social classes and educational levels, she becomes his wife. They have two children, Norah and John. In addition to being his longsuffering nursemaid and soul mate, Agnes understands her husband’s need to pursue his profession, despite his physical catastrophes.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
2 1 9
S e a b i s c u i t :
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
She dies of cancer only two weeks after Red’s death in 1981.
seen as Seabiscuit’s primary rival by most enthusiasts of the sport.
Johnny Pollard
Seabiscuit
See Red Pollard
Red Pollard Seabiscuit’s primary jockey, Johnny ‘‘Red’’ Pollard is an elegant and muscularly honed intellectual with bright orange hair. Born in 1910 in Edmonton, Canada, as one of six children, Pollard grows up in a wealthy home until a flood wipes out his father’s brick factory and the family fortune. Although he is a bright child with a love of literature, Pollard is much too restless and adventurous to become an academic. Instead, he develops an early appreciation for the two sports that would define his life: riding horses and prizefighting. One of his brothers is a champion boxer, but Red’s role in the ring is too often as a punching bag for betterequipped fighters. At fifteen, he immigrates to the United States and begins his career in the bush leagues, a no-holds-barred, unregulated, and sometimes illegal form of horse racing. Although he learns quickly, he fails to win races and is forced to use his only other athletic skill, prizefighting, to earn enough money to fend off starvation. Rising from relative obscurity as a gangly, unlikely jockey, Red earns a reputation for working well with difficult mounts, and drifts into the lives of Howard, Smith, and Seabiscuit. It is a perfect match between man and horse until a series of freak accidents forces Pollard into convalescence, where he is told he will never ride again, and into subsequent battles with alcohol and drug addiction. However, Pollard, like the horse he rode, refuses to surrender. He creates a brace for his impaired leg and returns to the sport in spite of his disability, winning the Santa Anita Handicap riding Seabiscuit.
Seabiscuit, the unlikely hero of the book, is a three-year-old mud-colored colt that brings the principal characters in the story together. Though it is not initially evident from his scruffy appearance, Seabiscuit descends from champion lines; he is the grandson of award-winning Man o’ War, and the son of Hard Tack. Unlike his storied ancestors, the colt is squat, rectangular, and low to the ground with a short tail, square knees, and stubby legs. He looks nothing like a winner. In fact, his favorite pastimes are eating and taking long naps—very un-thoroughbredlike behavior. When he gallops, he moves from side to side rather than straight ahead, and he habitually trips over his own hooves. Prior to his encounter with trainer Smith, Seabiscuit, literally whipped into shape by prior trainers and riders, is at the point of burnout from a grueling schedule. Underneath his sad and shaggy fac¸ade, however, the horse has attitude—the quality Smith and Howard are seeking. After liberal doses of kindness and care from both Smith and Pollard, the horse learns to trust people. Despite injuries and setbacks, he prances directly into the national spotlight, breaking records for both speed and monies earned, and charming the hearts of the American racing fans.
Tom Smith
Samuel Riddle
Tom Smith wanders on the periphery of two worlds, with his heart in the cowboy days of the old west and his body in a rapidly industrializing world. The grizzled wrangler spends the majority of his life with animals, taming mustangs for the British cavalry and job-hopping through ranch foreman positions and Wild West shows. Taciturn and withdrawn, he rarely speaks to people and lives outdoors or in barn stalls where he develops a way of communicating with horses.
Samuel Riddle is the owner of Man o’ War and War Admiral, Seabiscuit’s main rivals. Riddle embodies the elderly, stern, and wealthy East Coast racing establishment. Although the book has no outright villain, Riddle is depicted as an obstinate businessman and hardnosed negotiator. He is the mirrored opposite of Howard, and the two clash repeatedly throughout the book. Riddle’s horse, War Admiral, is
By the 1930s, Smith looks older than his late fifties and projects an air of virtual invisibility. He is a forgettable man with gray hair, perpetually clad in a gray felt fedora. Even as a child, Smith preferred the company of animals to men; he devoted his growing years to hunting deer, tracking mountain lions, and driving cattle across the plains. As the Wild West grows tame, Smith wanders from the vanishing frontier
2 2 0
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
S e a b i s c u i t :
onto the Unaweep Cattle Range in Colorado where he works for twenty years as ranch foreman. The ranch is sold in 1924 and the cowboy, aging and unemployed, joins the sideshow antics of Charlie Irwin’s Wild West Show, where his talent as a trainer is noted and blossoms. By the time he encounters Howard and faces Seabiscuit, Smith is considered a miracle worker with difficult mounts.
Sunny Jim See James Fitzsimmons
War Admiral The son of Man o’ War—who also sired Seabiscuit’s father—War Admiral is the best racehorse in the eastern United States, and becomes Seabiscuit’s archrival. Jet-black and regal, the horse topples the Triple Crown, smashing his sire’s track record and setting an American record for speed. With those records to his credit, he is the horse to beat in the mid1920s and 1930s.
Alfred Vanderbilt Alfred Vanderbilt is the youthful owner of the Pimlico racetrack in Maryland, home of the Preakness Stakes. He succeeds in arranging a one-on-one match between Seabiscuit, representing the new breed of western racing, and War Admiral, the pride of the eastern establishment. Vanderbilt serves as mediator between Howard and Riddle, setting the purse and convincing Riddle of the worthiness of the match.
George Woolf Seabiscuit’s backup jockey, Woolf is the epitome of a professional cowboy. Outfitted in cartoonish western regalia, Woolf, nicknamed the Iceman, offers a commanding presence, unperturbed by the opinions of others, and unrattled by the dips of an unstable lifestyle. A consummate perfectionist, Woolf surrenders his ambition to become a Canadian Mountie and uses his talents instead in the racing arena. He studies the sport, the competition, and the tracks and becomes one of the best jockeys in the country. Woolf and Pollard are friends, bonded by their intellect and sense of humor. When Pollard is physically incapable of riding, he recommends Woolf to Howard as his replacement; it is Woolf who rides Seabiscuit when the stallion finally faces off against War Admiral and wins.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
THEMES Catharsis Seabiscuit’s meteoric rise in the national consciousness represented a type of catharsis, or cleansing of emotion, of all that was negative in an era marked by economic downturn, mass unemployment, and hardship. According to Hillenbrand, ‘‘America was desperate to lose itself in anything that offered affirmation.’’ People of that time identified with Seabiscuit, an unlikely hero that was a victim of situations beyond his control. With his determined success, they were afforded a vicarious victory for themselves, and a temporary release from their own troubles. Release was more than psychological, however, for horseracing provided an inexpensive form of entertainment, as well as the lure of quick riches through potentially winning bets.
The American Dream Seabiscuit personified the American dream, the belief that the underdog—human or beast— can overcome adversity and through persistence, intelligence, and hard work, rise to the top. The American dream is a concept with its roots in early European settlers who immigrated to America, seeking not only religious and political freedom but also the riches they were certain the land contained. The concept became ingrained in world consciousness, enticing countless immigrants to seek out their fortunes in the New World. Popularized by the writer Horatio Alger, Jr., the idealization of the American dream and its entrenchment into popular culture has long served as a literary theme. Seabiscuit was the embodiment of persistence and pluck, the criteria often cited as fundamental to achieving the American dream; thus, he served as a role model of sorts. The horse became ‘‘a cultural icon that transcended sport.’’ In addition to Seabiscuit’s impact on the American psyche, Charles Howard also epitomized the potential of the rags-to-riches myth. Howard parlayed twenty-one cents into millions of dollars through intelligent investing, self-marketing, and entrepreneurial thinking. Though often overshadowed by his prize horse, Howard embodied the American dream as well.
Popular Culture Although popular culture is a fairly recent avenue of study, its origins sprang from the advent of radio, which was more immediate
V o l u m e
1
2 2 1
S e a b i s c u i t :
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
than print media and allowed for the instantaneous transmission of news. During those early years of mass media, families gathered around radios to hear the latest on world events, serialized programs based on fictional characters, and live coverage of sports. For the first time, it allowed spectator sports to be followed in real time without having to actually attend the event. Further, Hillenbrand writes of Seabiscuit that in 1938, ‘‘no individual had known fame and popularity that was as intense and far-reaching.’’ As further proof of the horse’s effect on popular culture, the author notes, when the number of newspaper column inches was tallied at the end of 1938, Seabiscuit ‘‘had drawn more newspaper coverage . . . than Roosevelt . . . Hitler . . . Mussolini . . . or any other newsmaker.’’ In addition to the impact of radio, the decade heralded the advancement of trends like merchandising, marketing, and celebrity endorsements. Seabiscuit’s likeness graced everything from ashtrays, parlor games, cards, hats, and wallets to the front of a military bomber. There were even Seabiscuit Limited trains to transport fans to the track. At the extreme end of the merchandising phenomenon was a request to use the horse as an exhibit during the San Francisco World’s Fair, and gargantuan-sized billboards of the racer’s likeness draped on Manhattan skyscrapers.
TOPICS FOR FURTHER STUDY How has the experience of receiving news changed for people since the time of Seabiscuit? Compose a two-page paper discussing the attributes of radio in the early part of the twentieth century and the attributes of television today, and how each has affected society in different ways. No one thought Seabiscuit was a worthy horse until he met Tom Smith, Charles Howard, and Red Pollard. Think of a time when you overcame adversity or accomplished something that no one thought you could do. What was the situation, and how did you overcome it? Was there someone who believed in you and encouraged you? How did your accomplishment feel? Write a two-page essay about your accomplishment, and be sure to include details.
Research the history of the automobile. In a small group, discuss how the automobile changed the world. Consider what it did for mobility, for the structures and stability of families, for business prosperity, for city structures, and for the convenience of all. Create a list of pros and cons about automobiles and horse-drawn carriages. In your group design two advertisements: one advocating the advantages of the automobile, and the other recommending rather the advantages of the horse-drawn carriage.
Research three famous thoroughbred American racehorses. Some good examples would be horses that have won the Triple Crown (the Preakness Stakes, the Kentucky Derby, and the Belmont Stakes). Select one of the three and write your own one-page biography of the animal. Include any humans—trainers, jockeys, owners—that have been a part of the horse’s success.
The Sporting Life Sport has long been an obsession for many Americans, as the abundance of published works on a variety of athletic contests will attest. Obviously, in a work that revolves around horseracing, the sporting life is a central theme. From the high life enjoyed by the ones who could afford to own competitive thoroughbreds to the lowly existence of stable boys and the grueling pace of unseasoned jockeys, Hillenbrand depicts a rounded and vivid picture of the sport of kings. The life of jockeys is displayed in detail, as is the adrenaline-filled excitement of the races. Seabiscuit shows the sacrifices that athletes are willing to make for the love of the sport. According to Hillenbrand, ‘‘A jockey’s life was nothing short of appalling.’’ The controlling factor in a jockey’s life was the scale; he and his mount were allowed only so much weight in order to compete. Riders literally starved themselves and used purgatives in order to lose weight. Hillenbrand writes, ‘‘Most walked
2 2 2
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
S e a b i s c u i t :
around in a state of critical dehydration and malnutrition and as a result were irritable, volatile, light-headed, bleary, nauseated, gaunt, and crampy.’’
The Wounded Hero The theme of the wounded hero is one in which the hero overcomes great adversity— physical, mental, or emotional—in order to fulfill his or her destiny. Each of the protagonists in Seabiscuit deals with individual demons as well as some type of physical or psychological injury. Howard suffers through the death of his son and the subsequent guilt he feels at supplying the means of that death, the automobile. Smith surrenders his isolation and resistance to social involvement to deal with the press and the fans. Seabiscuit and Pollard both overcome mistreatment and extensive physical injuries to triumph in the end.
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
characters, as well as the vast numbers of others who cheer the horses to victory. Hillenbrand’s passages about the time period offer readers familiarity not only with the life of the racetrack circuit but also the popular culture, styles, and values of the 1930s. Hillenbrand researched Seabiscuit’s story by watching old newsreel footage, interviewing dozens of persons who were involved in racing during the decade, and piecing together newspaper clippings. She employs an omniscient third-person narrator, one who stands outside the story but can wander in and out of the thoughts of her characters. Although some of the actual dialogue was recreated and some of the thought processes derived, she endeavors to be true to the historic context as well as to the character makeup of the persons about whom she is writing.
Sense of Place STYLE Biography Traditionally, a biography represents the life or a portion of the life of a single person, usually someone of import or historical significance. Although there are fictional predecessors, such as the classic children’s book Black Beauty (1877) by Anna Sewell, Seabiscuit is unique as the biography of a real horse. Hillenbrand broadens the definition, however, to include biography of the three principal humans who played important parts in Seabiscuit’s life— Charles Howard, Tom Smith, and Red Pollard.
Historic Nonfiction Seabiscuit is a work of nonfiction, reporting on the lives of real people and setting those lives in the historical context of real events. Although nothing is fictionalized, Hillenbrand’s style moves with the pace of a fiction novel. Her book uses some of the traditional elements of a fictional novel, such as characters, scenes, narrative arc, and climax. The story is driven by the characters and events, with few exceptions, as the lives of the men and the animals intersect and overlap. Seabiscuit is filled with social history and socioeconomic characterizations. The stratifications of class structures both before and after the Depression era are present in the main
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
Since the book covers over forty years, the timeline shifts with each chapter—from the rough-and-tumble old west to the beginning of World War II. Encompassing most of the continental United States as well as Tijuana, Mexico, the primary setting of the work is the racing circuit, and the major scenes are played out in horse barns or on racetracks. Hillenbrand creates a sense of place so vivid that the reader can almost experience the aroma of the track and the barn. In essence, the setting the author creates serves as another character in the work, rather than merely as a backdrop for the action.
Anthropomorphism Anthropomorphism is the attribution of human characteristics to things that are not human, a device Hillenbrand employs throughout the work. She illustrates Seabiscuit’s moods in purely human terms, discussing his pride, shame, and boredom among other qualities. She notes at various points that Seabiscuit had a ‘‘gleam in his eye’’ or that he ‘‘seemed . . . amused.’’ The other horses in the book—notably Pumpkin, Fair Knightess, and War Admiral— are also anthropomorphized. By giving the horses human characteristics, Hillenbrand creates characters that readers can identify with and root for.
Imagery Imagery is the effect of using words to paint a vivid picture in the mind of the reader.
V o l u m e
1
2 2 3
S e a b i s c u i t :
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
Hillenbrand creates imagery masterfully in her description of locale, such as when she describes the racetrack in Tijuana: ‘‘The colorful racing world that had spun itself around Tijuana withered and blew off into the sagebrush deserts.’’ She also uses vivid language in her depiction of people like Smith, who ‘‘had a colorless translucence about him that made him seem as if he were in the earliest stages of progressive invisibility.’’ She also notes that he ‘‘had the ethereal quality of hoof prints in windblown snow.’’ Many of the images she creates, of course, relate to horseracing and to the men perched on top of the mounts. Hillenbrand writes that ‘‘to pilot a racehorse is to ride a half-ton catapult,’’ and that ‘‘jockeys squat on the pitching backs of their mounts, a task much like perching on the grille of a car while it speeds down a twisting, potholed freeway in traffic.’’ The use of images, metaphors, and similes aids readers in deeply experiencing the story.
HISTORICAL CONTEXT The Great Depression In 1929, the U.S. stock market crashed, and practically overnight, persons of wealth were turned into paupers. Millions of Americans lost their fortunes, their jobs, their homes, and their hope in the years that followed. Although the stock market plummet may not have precipitated the Depression, it certainly contributed to the economic misery of the period. The primary factors leading to the Depression, however, were an uneven distribution of wealth (a small group of people controlling a disproportionate amount of money and power), accumulated war debts from World War I, and the expansion of credit and installment purchasing. Although some relief was offered under the administration of President Franklin Delano Roosevelt, particularly in the form of Social Security, welfare, and employment, the Depression lasted until shortly before World War II. By 1937, the year of Seabiscuit’s acclaim, the United States was in the throes of serious economic despair, few regions of the nation spared. Factories were closed in the cities, many as the result of the more than four thousand mass labor strikes during the year. Farmers and ranchers in the Midwest suffered through waves of replanting and relocation as the decade-long Dust
2 2 4
L i t e r a r y
Bowl wiped out crops and dislocated families. The Revenue Act increased taxes for small businesses, while offering tax breaks to larger ones, which affected many small towns. Unemployment statistics reached a staggering 20 percent, and hunger marches on state and federal capitols became commonplace. As the economic situation worsened, World War II loomed on the horizon and the Dies Committee (later named the House Un-American Activities Committee) was created, triggering pervasive paranoia among people about the possibility of Communists infiltrating groups, particularly labor unions.
Prohibition Beginning in 1919 and ending in 1933, the selling or consumption of any alcoholic beverage was illegal in the United States. Because the social climate favored moral reform, bans were also instituted for gambling and cabaret dancing. The Prohibition helped facilitate the rise of organized crime, as trafficking illegal substances became a quick way to make money. Alcohol was thus readily available if one knew where to go and had the cash to cover the purchase. Racetrack gambling, on the other hand, was somewhat more difficult to conceal; thus, thoroughbreds, their owners, and their fans began visiting wide-open Mexican border towns like Tijuana, where both gambling and alcohol were legal. When California politicians realized that much-needed revenue was leaking out of the state, they reinstituted betting at the state’s racetracks, with the government keeping a cut of all profits.
Horseracing and Betting Horseracing is one of the oldest competitive sports, dating to the domestication of the animal in prehistoric times. By the time of written records, the sport was organized in all major civilizations and was included in the first Olympic games in ancient Greece. Part of the appeal of the sport is betting on the outcome of the races, which led to the growth of the industry in the United States. In the early years of the twentieth century, however, antigambling sentiment caused many racetracks to lose revenue and close their doors. This created a subsequent wave of horseracing enthusiasts that crossed into Mexican border towns, particularly Tijuana. In the post–Depression recovery
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
S e a b i s c u i t :
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
Chris McCarron as Charley Kurtsinger and Tobey Maguire as Red Pollard in the 2003 film version of Seabiscuit Universal/The Kobal Collection
period, states not only condoned but encouraged a resurgence of racetrack betting as long as the betting was pari-mutuel, which afforded the state coffers a share of the profits.
one of the best of 2001 by National Public Radio, the Washington Post, Time magazine, and Amazon.com, among others.
Seabiscuit: An American Legend has sold more than three million copies and topped the New York Times bestseller list for forty-two weeks. In addition, the book won a variety of awards, and was a finalist for the coveted National Book Critics Circle award. The book was also named
Critical appraisal could find little wrong with Hillenbrand’s first book-length effort. Patsy Gray, writing in Library Journal, writes, ‘‘This story of trust, optimism, and perseverance in overcoming obstacles will appeal to many readers.’’ Todd McCarthy of Variety contends that part of the work’s allure is due to the horse being ‘‘a commoner among racing’s royalty, which ultimately became the source of his mass appeal.’’ A reviewer for Publishers Weekly called the work a ‘‘captivating account of one of the sport’s legends’’ rendered in ‘‘simple, elegant prose.’’ Dennis Dodge, writing for Booklist, proclaimed the work ‘‘a remarkable testament to what four years of meticulous research and a writer’s gift for storytelling can accomplish.’’ Others noted Hillenbrand’s craft, imagery, and poetic word choice. Even Business Week, not known for flowery praise, included a glowing review that complimented the author as ‘‘a deft storyteller whose descriptions of such races are especially good, filled with images of pounding hooves and splattering mud.’’
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
During the Depression, affordable diversions and hobbies were few. The chasm between rich and poor broadened, with the middle class largely swallowed up by the economic downturn. Those who were hit the hardest sought any means of diversion offered to them. Bargain seating at sporting events provided one form, and the sudden affordability of radio provided another. The most economical sporting events to attend were baseball and horse racing. Spectator numbers for both sports increased dramatically during this era.
CRITICAL OVERVIEW
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
2 2 5
S e a b i s c u i t :
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
A significant number of reviewers noted the parallels between Hillenbrand’s own condition (Chronic Fatigue Syndrome) and the perils illustrated in the work. One of the more thorough analyses, penned by Tim Morris in Aethlon: The Journal of Sport Literature, noted the success of Hillenbrand’s work as unlikely as the success of its protagonist, and compared the reading public’s encouragement of Seabiscuit to overcome the odds against him to Hillenbrand’s need to defeat her disease. Morris explored fans’ online postings to Hillenbrand and discovered a significant ‘‘crossing over’’ of the fan base from those who enjoyed the work to those who were aware of her condition. The essayist pointed out, ‘‘The book evokes a culture that has vanished for good, where noble animals and noble men and women commanded the nation’s attention by competing in a pure and elemental sport.’’ Rarely does any work garner such positive reinforcement from both the reading public and professional critics alike. Seabiscuit filled a nostalgic void much needed in the modern world, and reinforced a nation’s belief in persistence as the route to ultimate success.
CRITICISM Joyce Duncan Dr. Joyce Duncan is the Managing Editor of the Sport Literature Association, the editor of Aethlon: The Journal of Sport Literature, and a faculty member at East Tennessee State University. In this essay, Duncan analyzes Hillenbrand’s book as it reflects the history of a horse and an era, as well as the sentiment, innocence, pathos, and stock characters presented in the work. Seabiscuit: An American Legend is unique in many ways from the books that tend to top the bestseller lists. In an age consumed with self-help genres, reality television, and video games, Seabiscuit stands out as a work of refreshing naivete´. There is an almost childlike innocence to the narrative as Hillenbrand evokes a world where it becomes evident that the nice guy will finish first, that goodness will triumph over adversity, and that comeuppance will be served to those who deserve it. Even for those who are unaware of the true historic ending of the tale, Hillenbrand creates an aura of predictability wherein the reader, though able to guess the
2 2 6
L i t e r a r y
SEABISCUIT: AN AMERICAN LEGEND TRANSCENDS THE PIGEONHOLED GENRES CREATED BY CRITICS AND ENGLISH PROFESSORS; IT IS A STORY OF CREATING POSSIBILITY FROM IMPOSSIBILITY, A LAUDING OF PERSISTENCE AND A CELEBRATION OF LIFE.’’
outcome, continues reading not to find out what happens next but to achieve a satisfying closure. Echoing her quality of innocence, there is a strong sense of sentiment, and one wonders how much of Hillenbrand’s own autobiography ripples through the pages. There is a sticky sweetness attached to her characterization of the principals in the story and Hillenbrand appears to identify not only with Seabiscuit, but also with his jockey, Red Pollard. The young man is constantly pitted against physical ailments and psychological despair, but rises time and again to face the odds and become a winner. It is obvious that the author has empathy toward Pollard, even excusing such weaknesses in him as his addiction to alcohol. Despite his failings, Pollard is illustrated as a man of honor with a sympathetic heart. Through her renderings of Pollard and Seabiscuit and their numerous improbable comebacks, the author arouses pathos, feelings of pity and sympathy, accompanied by ultimate jubilation in her readers. Reading nonfiction so well-crafted that it flows like the best of page-turning fiction, propels the reader forward, figuratively running his or her own race to the end of the work. Although the book is definitely penned with polished, if somewhat reserved, language, it is reminiscent of two children’s books that preceded it. The first is the somewhat obscure Come on Seabiscuit! by Ralph Moody, originally published in 1963. Hillenbrand has in fact mentioned the Moody book as a childhood favorite, and it clearly serves as at least one source of inspiration for her more sophisticated rendering of the story. An additional tale that frequently goes unmentioned, by both Hillenbrand and her reviewers, is Black Beauty by Anna Sewell, written over a six-year period in the mid-1800s and
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
S e a b i s c u i t :
depicting another biography of a horse, albeit a fictional one. There is something reminiscent of Sewell’s sympathetic approach to the treatment of horses present in Seabiscuit; however, the comparison is not restricted to the subject matter or the writing styles of the two authors. Ironically, perhaps, the commonality spills over into their lives as well. Sewell, like Hillenbrand, wrote Black Beauty, her only published major work, while she was bedridden with illness. For both women, success came quickly and book sales were phenomenal. The 1930s was not a period of calm and good feeling in the United States. However, the book, while maintaining historical accuracy, creates a portrait of a simpler time when heroes and villains were easily discerned, when camaraderie was abundant, and when families gathered round their radio together for an evening’s entertainment. Hillenbrand deftly leaves her readers nostalgic for the past. Strangely, while she writes about an earlier population seeking escape from their dreary lives, she creates a need for escapism into the past for the modern reader who covets a more pastoral moment. Recreating history can be an arduous task, particularly if information is obtained primarily through the oral recounting of events from those who lived through the period. Oral history, and particularly retrospective oral history, must always be somewhat suspect due to the passage of time and the age of those reporting. Witnesses and participants often embellish the banality of their actual experience. On the other hand, their anecdotes add a measure of local color and a sense of immediacy that help the reader almost feel the movement of the horse, the pounding of the hooves, the cheers and boos of the fans, and the aroma of the stalls. If the people had not really existed and if the book were fiction, it would be a simple task to critique the author for dealing in stereotypes and for creating flat characters that represent certain attributes or characteristics. Although the cast was not created as such, Hillenbrand imbues each with a humanity and moral quality that raises the principals in the story from the dust of history. Yet, each is representative of something bigger than a single individual. Among other stock characters in the work, there is the outsider, living on the periphery of civilization (Smith); the waif, surviving by his wits (Pollard); the self-made millionaire, personification of the
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
American dream (Howard); and the underdog, who conquers all the odds against him and succeeds due to sheer pluck and perseverance (Seabiscuit). It was a time when men were men, an era when people could live off the land, outside the confines of cities and materialistic trappings. The trainer Smith, although precipitously balanced between two eras, is the archetypal cowboy, the strong and silent Gary Cooper type, as well as the original ‘‘horse whisperer.’’ Balancing his gruff and taciturn demeanor around other people, his tender coaxing of animals reveals his thinly veiled gentle nature and warm heart. From Hillenbrand’s depiction, Smith could be the prototype for every cowpoke who ever stumbled into Dodge City. Pollard, as a virtual orphan and a young man of literary acumen, is cast upon an uncaring world to make his own way. A graduate of the school of hard knocks, he is categorized as the quintessential underdog, arousing pathos and empathy and becoming an easy character to cheer to victory. Even Howard, the owner of Seabiscuit and one of the nation’s wealthiest men at the time, is depicted as one who struggled to make his way, a self-made man created through grit and ingenuity, the cornerstones of the American dream. They are rough-and-tumble men whose lives collide in a rough-and-tumble world, thus illuminating the survivor theme present in all great western motifs. In addition, the hero of the piece, an irascible thoroughbred built, Hillenbrand says, like ‘‘a cinder block’’ and enamored of eating and sleeping, rises from obscurity to become a national treasure. It is the stuff from which fairy tales and Hollywood are made. More than a happy little book about perseverance, though, Hillenbrand has created a portrait of an era—a time in which the media began to infiltrate lives and living rooms to create a nation of spectators. Much of modern popular culture, from twenty-four-hour sports channels to the merchandising of athletes, can trace its origins to the period about which she writes. In addition, the work reveals the breadth of the chasm among classes through clearly delineated verbal portraits of each of the primary characters. Hillenbrand also delves into the darker side of the sport as she explores in graphic detail the life behind the track. Jockeys, treated much like
V o l u m e
1
2 2 7
S e a b i s c u i t :
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
slaves, were frequently little more than commodities and often suffered illness or disability due to the self-imposed abuse required to meet weight requirements. It is ironic that while the horses were being pampered and catered to, the humans who guided them across finish lines were encouraged to starve themselves, forced to sleep in barn stalls, and used as currency in games of cards between stable owners.
WHAT DO I READ NEXT?
The Horse Whisperer (1995), by Nicholas Evans, is a fictional tale of a man, much like Smith, who uses his soothing voice and kind words to communicate with horses.
Seabiscuit vs. War Admiral (2003), by Kat Shehata, is a book for young readers. The work presents a lively, illustrated, and factual account of the famous match between the two thoroughbreds.
Come on Seabiscuit! (1963), by Ralph Moody, was republished in 2003 by Bison Books after the success of Hillenbrand’s book. This work is designed for young readers and served as an inspiration for Hillenbrand and countless other readers.
The Seabiscuit Story: From the Pages of the Nation’s Most Promising Racing Magazine (2003) was edited by John McEvoy. The book would have importance for anyone interested in the news coverage of the horse’s career as it was actually taking place.
Anna Sewell’s Black Beauty (1877) is about the adventurous and often difficult life of an English horse. It is considered a classic work of children’s fiction and was the first popular book to use an animal as its narrator. The book also paints a vivid picture of all aspects of society, both good and bad, in Victorian England. The Black Stallion (1941), by Walter Farley, is another of the most popular books ever written about a horse. In this tale, a boy and a horse are shipwrecked on an island together, where they form a long-lasting bond that culminates in a showdown not unlike the ‘‘Seabiscuit/War Admiral’’ showdown that took place just a few years before the book was published.
2 2 8
Man O’ War (1962), another title by Walter Farley, is written in the tradition of Sewell’s Black Beauty. Farley tells the story of Seabiscuit’s legendary grandfather in this fictional biography.
L i t e r a r y
Although a book about the sport of horse races and expertise is typically aligned with sport literature, and a book that features an animal as its central figure is typically aligned with children’s literature, Seabiscuit is much more than either category would suggest. Seabiscuit: An American Legend transcends the pigeonholed genres created by critics and English professors; it is a story of creating possibility from impossibility, a lauding of persistence and a celebration of life. If it were not based in fact, the entire tale might be embraced as imagination of the highest caliber. Source: Joyce Duncan, Critical Essay on Seabiscuit: An American Legend, in Literary Newsmakers for Students, Thomson Gale, 2006.
Tim Morris In the following excerpt, Morris draws parallels between author Hillenbrand, a sufferer of Chronic Fatigue Syndrome, and the against-all-odds champion she chronicled. The best-selling American sports book of the year 2001—and one of the year’s bestsellers in any genre—is Seabiscuit: An American Legend by Laura Hillenbrand. The success of the book is as unlikely as the success of Seabiscuit himself. How does a book about a half-century-dead racehorse become a publishing sensation? Sales of the book don’t depend much on nostalgia, since most Americans are too young to have seen Seabiscuit race. Nor is Thoroughbred racing the cynosure of media attention that it was when Seabiscuit briefly dominated the sport in the 1930s. One can barely imagine selling such a book to a publisher in 2001, let alone to hundreds of thousands of readers. But the Biscuit always beat the odds. Overmatched at ages two and three, Seabiscuit never entered a Triple Crown race. Yet he had great success at age four, and was Horse of the Year at five (in 1938). Even then, some of his most famous races were hard-fought losses. He had a knack for coming in second in the
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
S e a b i s c u i t :
WHILE ROOTING FOR THE HORSE TO COME BACK AND WIN IN THE TEXT, PEOPLE ROOT FOR THE AUTHOR TO OVERCOME DISEASE IN REAL LIFE.’’
prestigious Santa Anita Handicap; he didn’t win the race till his final outing in 1940. His story is one of continual comeback against adversity. The author of Seabiscuit, Laura Hillenbrand, has also fought adversity. As one visitor to Hillenbrand’s on-line guestbook at www.seabiscuitonline.com says, ‘‘YOU are the Seabiscuit of us invalids!’’ Afflicted with Chronic Fatigue Syndrome, Hillenbrand became America’s most famous sufferer of the illness, especially after an interview on NPR’s Diane Rehm Show in April 2001. Before April 2001, entries in her guestbook center on the inspirational qualities of the horse. After April, the entries follow two main threads—one about Seabiscuit, the other about the inspiring quality of Hillenbrand’s life. The threads become entwined, even confused. While rooting for the horse to come back and win in the text, people root for the author to overcome disease in real life. The author, lovely, frail, spirited, is embraced by hundreds of readers and nonreaders who imagine themselves the cure to her problems—perhaps none so invitingly as one ‘‘fellow CFSer’’ who signs himself ‘‘Tom Smith’’ and prescribes that Hillenbrand ‘‘curl up in the hay and get the rest you need.’’ Laura Hillenbrand hardly set out to invoke such readerly concern and affection. Yet the way her readers feel about her is analogous to the way she feels toward the horses and people she writes about. As her readers summon up images of the author curling up in her bedding, or think aloud about ministering to the hair behind her ears, they more or less consciously echo passages in Seabiscuit where Hillenbrand conveys an immediate, visceral sense of the sufferings of her heroes. Time and again in the story, Seabiscuit and jockey Red Pollard achieve great things, only to be brought to earth again by the fragility of their
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
bodies. In 1938, Pollard, immobilized by an injury, must watch George Woolf ride Seabiscuit in the match race against War Admiral: ‘‘He was sure he would be able to ride again. A glance at his emaciated body, jutting out a harsh angles from under the sheets, testified to the contrary.’’ Later, in 1939, it is Seabiscuit who is incapacitated as another Santa Anita Handicap approaches: The veterinarian took radiographs, which would take a while to develop. All they could do now was wait. The Howards spent their time sorting through myriad sympathy notes from fans, some of whom enclosed bottles of remedies for the horse.
You can’t send bottles of Tahitian Noni Juice through cyberspace, but in most other respects the parallel between Seabiscuit laid up in 1939 and Hillenbrand laid up in 2001 is remarkable—not least because of the outpouring of public sympathy and love. The love that the readers of Seabiscuit bear its author has precedents in literary history and sport history, if not perhaps in the genre of sport literature: one thinks of Willa Cather’s devoted circle of reader-critics, of the loving crowds worldwide that attended Muhammad Ali, of the deep connection cancer survivors feel to Lance Armstrong. Such love suggests that one reason for the success of the book is the fluid relationship among author, text, heroes, and reader that allows Hillenbrand’s audience to imagine their way into inspiring, validating, and romantic situations. ‘‘I was so taken by your story today, and would like to give you my services for free,’’ says one reader; ‘‘I would like to illustrate, paint, draw, scribble, or attend to your yard work for you.’’ Such readers claim to center their experience of literature, and possibly of life, around Hillenbrand and Seabiscuit. Even allowing for the hyperbole of fan-letter discourse, these readers feel something special. One goes so far as to reverse the coat-tails of the book’s spring publication, claiming that Hillenbrand has done more for the Triple Crown races than the Triple Crown has done for Seabiscuit: ‘‘With your emotion packed words I am sure you and you alone are responsible for the increase in interest re the Derby (up 40%) and the Preakness (up 56%).’’ Just as significant in establishing a sense of the ‘‘horizon of expectations’’ that characterizes
V o l u m e
1
2 2 9
S e a b i s c u i t :
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
Seabiscuit’s readership are remarks that connect Seabiscuit to other reading experiences. Jim Lewandowski says that Seabiscuit is ‘‘the best since I read ‘Undaunted Courage’ by Stephen Ambrose,’’ a prodigiously unironic bestseller from 1996. Andrew Abruzzese, a restaurateur, admits that ‘‘I have finished reading two books in my life. To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee and yours.’’ By such central measures of canonicity as this—the sense that a book is the best, or even the only, exemplar of literary quality— Seabiscuit is poised to become canonical in a way so deep as to evade the notice of academic discourse. Not all readers go as far as Sandy Mendez, who tells Hillenbrand that ‘‘I have requested your book accompany my burial.’’ But among all the tears and sighs, real or virtual, that season readers’ responses to Seabiscuit on-line, is the sense that this book has given them something irreplaceable: an inspiration, a reason to go on living, to follow a dream. This might be the moment for a scholarly puncturing of illusions, for some demonstration of the false consciousness of Hillenbrand’s farflung readership. But it may be better just to note a recurrent dynamic that drives interest in sport literature: the need for an unadulterated hero. This need—documented in founding studies in the academic field of sport literature like Michael Oriard’s Dreaming of Heroes and Robert J. Higgs’s Laurel & Thorn—continues to be felt in the 21st century. Possibly the only heroes left without feet of clay are those with shoes of iron. In tracing the appeal of Seabiscuit to its construction of an unironic hero, and to the apparently unorchestrated coupling of authorial image with that of the hero, questions of literary value seem beside the point, as they so often become in academic criticism. But Seabiscuit is clearly more than an exploitation of an available niche in American cultural discourse. It’s a nonfiction masterpiece. Such a straightforward statement seems ingenious. But without good writing, the other factors that align to produce the Seabiscuit phenomenon would not be enough. The very ingenuousness of such a bald assertion of critical value will trigger, for many academic readers, a hermeneutics of suspicion: what is wrong with this picture? Everyone is having far too good a time.
2 3 0
L i t e r a r y
But occasionally, the books that are revered by ‘‘naı¨ ve’’ readers can also be those that stand critical scrutiny from the most jaded readers. Honestly, I couldn’t put Seabiscuit down, either. While it is unlikely to make the Oprah Winfrey list (it is non-fiction, and its author will probably be unable to appear on the Oprah TV show, two strikes against it), Hillenbrand’s book is akin to the tales of survival and redemption preferred by Winfrey and her staff. And just as there is literary merit aplenty on the Oprah list—in the work of Edwidge Danticat, Toni Morrison, and others—so there is exemplary imaginative writing in the work of Laura Hillenbrand. Even if one’s preferred mode is irony, there’s something to be said for the occasional splash of earnestness. Source: Tim Morris, ‘‘Seabiscuit? Come On . . . ,’’ in Aethlon: The Journal of Sport Literature, Vol. 14, No. 1, Fall 2001, pp. 79–90.
Lynn Andriani In the following interview with Publishers Weekly, author Hillenbrand discusses the appeal of Seabiscuit and the people who helped the horse become a part of history. Source: Lynn Andriani, ‘‘PW Talks with Laura Hillenbrand,’’ in Publisher’s Weekly, Vol. 248, January 1, 2001, pp. 3–15.
PW: Your book Seabiscuit is about a legendary racehorse. What makes Seabiscuit’s story so special? LH: He’s unique because of the time he was in. It was the Depression, and people were trying to find ways to escape, and this ‘‘rags to riches’’ horse answered their yearning for something like that. Seabiscuit was the single biggest news-maker of 1938, and that was a really momentous year. During that time, even people who didn’t give a damn about horse racing were following him. PW: Why had, no one yet written this book? LH: In the 1930s, journalism was a lot less personal; journalists tended not to say very much about the people involved. But when I started looking into the life of Seabiscuit and the lives of those around him, I found fascinating people living a story that was improbable, breathtaking and ultimately more satisfying than any story I’d ever come across. I had to tell it.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
S e a b i s c u i t :
PW: A lot of people haven’t heard of Seabiscuit. Given that, was it difficult to sell the book? LH: I originally sold a story to American Heritage magazine, and that started everything rolling. People started saying, ‘‘You really ought to make a book out of this.’’ PW: Seabiscuit is largely a story of three men (an owner, a trainer and a jockey) with distinctly different personalities and temperaments coming together to produce a winning racehorse. How did these disparate characters affect your research? LH: One of the things I love is just how improbable it is that these three people would get together. It’s just amazing. But they all got along really well. There were times when I found conflicting stories from other people and in the press. But one of the beautiful things about horse racing is that there are extremely thorough records about races. And there were witnesses. Most of them are in their 80s and 90s, but I got a lot of first-hand accounts and I found a lot of film and photographs that could settle disputes. PW: The culture of horse racing was very different in the 1930s and ’40s than it is today. Other than the Triple Crown, many races today have only an elite following, nothing like the mass audiences of the past. Will that decrease in popularity affect the book’s readership? LH: The racing audience certainly has shrunk. Back then, everyone in America followed Seabiscuit. But I’ve tried to write this book for a general audience and I think its biggest appeal is not the sports angle; it’s the human angle. I think these people are absolutely fascinating—and would have been even if I didn’t care about horse racing.
A n
A m e r i c a n
L e g e n d
Dodge, Dennis, Review of Seabiscuit: An American Legend, in Booklist, Vol. 97, January 1, 2001, p. 900. Gray, Patsy E., Review of Seabiscuit: An American Legend, in Library Journal, Vol. 126, No. 6, p. 106. Hillenbrand, Laura. ‘‘A Sudden Illness—How My Life Changed,’’ in the New Yorker, Vol. 79, No. 18, p. 56. Hillenbrand, Laura, Seabiscuit: An American Legend, Random House, 2001. Laura Hillenbrand, www.seabiscuitonline.com/ author.htm (May 18, 2005). McCarthy, Todd, ‘‘Well-Groomed Horse Tale,’’ in Variety, Vol. 391, January 1, 2001, p. 26. Morris, Tim, ‘‘Seabiscuit? Come On . . .,’’ in Aethlon: The Journal of Sport Literature, Vol. 19, No. 1, Fall 2001, pp. 79–91. Review of Seabiscuit: An American Legend, in Publishers Weekly, Vol. 348, No. 1, p. 74.
FURTHER READING Hillenbrand, Laura, ‘‘A Sudden Illness—How My Life Changed,’’ in the New Yorker, Vol. 79, No. 18, July 7, 2003, p. 56. This article recites the origin and progression of Hillenbrand’s Chronic Fatigue Syndrome, and notes how writing both changed and saved her life. Bowen, Edward, At the Wire: Horse Racing’s Greatest Moments, Eclipse Press, 2001. Bowen’s work chronicles many of the most famous contests in the sport, including those featuring Man o’ War, Seabiscuit’s randfather. Terkel, Studs, Hard Times: An Oral History of the Great Depression, W. W. Norton, 2000. Terkel offers verbal biographies collected from dozens of persons who illustrate firsthand accounts of their lives among the turbulent socioeconomic conditions of the 1930s.
‘‘A Runt that Dominated the Sport of Kings,’’ in Business Week, No. 3725, p. 27.
Morgan, Bert, Horse Racing: The Golden Age of the Track, Chronicle Books, 2001. Morgan offers a visual compilation through his photographs that depict Triple Crown events from the 1930s through the 1960s, including Hard Tack, Seabiscuit’s father.
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
SOURCES
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
2 3 1
The Secret Life of Bees The Secret Life of Bees, by Sue Monk Kidd, was published by Viking Press in 2002. It was the first novel by Kidd, who had already found success writing inspirational personal memoirs such as The Dance of the Dissident Daughter (1996). A bestseller, the novel has become a favorite of book clubs around the country, including the ‘‘Read This!’’ Book Club sponsored by the ABC network morning show, Good Morning America. The Secret Life of Bees is the story of Lily, a fourteen-year-old girl who runs away from her unloving father to search for the secrets of her dead mother’s past. The setting of the novel is South Carolina in 1964, a time when racial tensions were inflamed by the civil rights movement and white racists’ frequently violent responses to it. Against this backdrop, Lily and her housekeeper, Rosaleen, find shelter in the home of the eccentric Boatwright sisters, three African American beekeepers who worship before the statue of a Black Madonna they call ‘‘Our Lady of Chains.’’ In the Boatwright household, Lily finds love and acceptance and begins to come to terms with the guilt she feels over her mother’s death. In the novel, Kidd addresses the sometimes painful divide between races and generations through a rich tapestry of religious symbolism, imagining for the Daughters of Mary (as the Boatwrights and their small circle of fellow
2 3 2
SUE MONK KIDD 2002
T h e
S e c r e t
L i f e
o f
B e e s
worshipers call themselves) a nurturing, personal alternative to the Catholic faith.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY Sue Monk Kidd was born on August 12, 1948, and raised in the small town of Sylvester in southwestern Georgia. Her love of stories and writing developed early, inspired by her father’s storytelling and the encouragement of English teachers. During adolescence, she wrote her first stories and kept a journal, but she set aside writing to study nursing at Texas Christian University. She graduated in 1970 and worked for most of the next decade as a registered nurse and as a college instructor. During this time she married Sanford Kidd, a theology student, and had two children, Bob and Ann. Kidd rediscovered her interest in writing while living in Anderson, South Carolina, in the 1980s. She took writing courses at the local college where her husband was teaching. A personal essay that she wrote for class was accepted by Guideposts magazine and reprinted in Reader’s Digest. She soon became a successful freelancer, publishing several hundred articles of personal, inspirational nonfiction in publications such as Guideposts and serving as a contributing editor to that magazine. Kidd began publishing full-length works in the style of a spiritual memoir in 1988. In God’s Joyful Surprise, she describes the process by which she came to embrace contemplative Christianity and converted from Southern Baptism to the Episcopal Church. A second volume of memoir, When the Heart Waits, was published in 1990, and The Dance of the Dissident Daughter, which reflected Kidd’s growing interest in feminist theology, followed in 1996. The next year Kidd began writing The Secret Life of Bees, which was published by Viking in 2002. The novel was phenomenally successful: it spent eighty weeks on the New York Times bestseller list, sold more than three million copies, and has been translated into twenty languages. It has become a favorite of book clubs since its publication, most notably the club sponsored by the ABC network morning program Good Morning America. The Secret Life of Bees also earned Kidd the recognition of her peers: it was awarded the BookSense paperback book of the year in 2004 and was nominated for the British Orange Prize.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
Sue Monk Kidd AP/Wide World Photos
Kidd published a second novel,The Mermaid Chair, to positive reviews in 2005. As of 2005, she and her husband were living in Charleston, South Carolina, where she was writer in residence at the Phoebe Pember House and an adviser to Poets & Writers, Inc.
PLOT SUMMARY Chapter 1 Lily Owens remembers the summer of 1964, when she turned fourteen years old. She begins by describing the way she would wait in her bedroom each night for the arrival of bees. Though these bees are imagined, Lily’s emotional attachment to them makes the reader wonder if they might be real. Lily’s caretaker, Rosaleen, has told her that bees swarming are an omen of death. Lily is preoccupied with death, since her mother, Deborah, died when Lily was four. She thinks often of the day her mother died and shares the incident, as well as her own guilt, with the reader. She remembers sitting on the floor of the closet as her mother hurriedly packed a suitcase. She remembers her father, T. Ray, coming home and her parents arguing.
V o l u m e
1
2 3 3
T h e
S e c r e t
L i f e
o f
B e e s
Then T. Ray shoved Lily, and her mother grabbed a gun from the closet shelf. The gun ended up in T. Ray’s hands, then on the floor, then in Lily’s hands. Lily remembers the sound of the gun going off. Her mother was dead. Unpopular in school and unloved by her father, Lily relies only on Rosaleen. She treasures a few objects connected to her mother: a photograph of Deborah, a pair of her white gloves, and a picture of a dark-skinned Virgin Mary mounted on wood, with ‘‘Tiburon, S.C.’’ written on the back. She keeps these items buried in a tin box in her father’s peach orchard, digging them up and imagining what sort of woman her mother was. Lily remembers that the day before she began first grade, T. Ray told her she had accidentally killed her mother. On July 2, 1964, Rosaleen is overjoyed to learn President Lyndon Johnson has signed the Civil Rights Act into law. That night, needing to feel close to someone and something, Lily heads for the orchard to dig up her tin box. T. Ray catches her outside, assuming she is meeting a boy. He punishes her in a way Lily particularly hates: by making her kneel on the kitchen floor in a pile of Martha White grits, small grains that cut into her knees. Lily accompanies Rosaleen to a Fourth of July voter-registration rally in Sylvan. Before she can register, however, Rosaleen attracts the attention of a group of men playing cards. They bait her with racial insults, and she responds by pouring tobacco juice on their shoes. A scuffle results, and Rosaleen is arrested for assault.
Chapters 2–3 The Civil Rights Act has obviously not reached Sylvan, as policeman Avery Gaston allows the locals who attacked Rosaleen to attack her again. Lily is released into T. Ray’s custody, but Rosaleen must stay behind. T. Ray tells Lily that Rosaleen will likely be killed by Franklin Posey, a notoriously vicious racist, who is one of the men she offended. Furious at his daughter’s actions, T. Ray tells Lily that her devotion to her dead mother is misplaced. Deborah had run away and left her family and, on the day she died, had planned to pack her belongings and leave permanently. Distraught and disbelieving, Lily decides to break Rosaleen out of police custody. As her world crumbles, she needs to be needed and appreciated.
2 3 4
L i t e r a r y
When Lily returns to town, she is told that Rosaleen has been taken to the hospital. She sneaks into Rosaleen’s hospital room, where Rosaleen admits she was beaten by Posey and other men. Lily and Rosaleen slip past the guard posted in front of her room. The two hitch a ride with driver of a cantaloupe truck who happens to be traveling to a location near Tiburon, the town noted on the back of the Black Madonna portrait. Since the picture belonged to her mother, Lily decides she will find answers there. Rosaleen and Lily quarrel when Rosaleen realizes Lily left Sylvan to pursue her own interests as much as to save her. They separate briefly but reunite and apologize to each other in a nearby creek. After spending the night sleeping in the open air, Lily and Rosaleen continue their walk into Tiburon. They come to a general store, where Lily goes to buy food. Behind the counter, she notices jars of Black Madonna Honey, decorated with the familiar image of the darkskinned Virgin Mary. The store’s proprietor tells her the honey is made by a local woman, August Boatwright, whose bright pink house is impossible to miss.
Chapter 4 Lily and Rosaleen find August’s house. A woman in the front yard is tending to boxes of bees. They are met at the door by August’s sisters, June and May. Inside their house, Lily sees a carving of a woman that resembles a ship’s masthead. Three feet tall, the woman is mostly black but has a faded red heart painted on her chest. Lily feels immediately drawn to the statue. When August enters, Lily tells her that she and Rosaleen have run away from home and have no place to go. August immediately offers to let them stay. Lily continues to lie to August, pretending she is an orphan who, with her housekeeper Rosaleen as a chaperone, is headed to a relative’s house in Virginia. August seems to accept their story and shows them around her honey-making operation. She offers them two cots in the ‘‘honey house’’ for them to use. The next morning, Lily rises early and surveys the Boatwright property. She discovers a rock wall with slips of paper stuck in its crevices.
Chapter 5 A week passes at the Boatwright household. August buys new clothes for Rosaleen, and May
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
S e c r e t
L i f e
o f
B e e s
and June clean her wounds from her beating. Lily describes the role honey plays in the Boatwrights’ life: they eat it, bathe in it, take it as medicine, and make candles from it. Lily enjoys learning how to tend to August’s honeymaking machinery, and Rosaleen develops a special rapport with May. They learn May is acutely sensitive to the suffering of others. She even leads insects outside the house rather than killing them, which reminds Lily of a similar habit her mother had.
At the end of the service, the Daughters of Mary and Rosaleen touch the heart painted on Mary’s chest while June plays her cello. Lily longs to reach out to the statue, but June stops playing when she tries. Again Lily realizes her whiteness sets her apart from the others. She faints, August believes, because of the heat. In fact, Lily was both overheated and overwhelmed by the experience.
Lily’s happiness with the Boatwrights is marred only by June’s antipathy to her presence. Lily overhears June and August discussing her; for June, Lily’s whiteness makes her particularly objectionable. Lily’s self-consciousness is reinforced when she gathers around the television with Rosaleen and the Boatwrights to watch news reports of racially motivated violence. In the evening, the women say prayers in front of the black statue of Mary, which the Boatwright sisters call ‘‘Our Lady of Chains.’’
August’s assistant and godson, Zach Taylor, returns to work. Lily instantly likes the athletic and scholarly young man, and Zach reciprocates. He plans to be a lawyer, although as a black man he is pessimistic about his chances at success. He and Lily have an opportunity to spend a day alone together when August sends them to check on some of her remote hives. Lily is nervous and moody because of her attraction to Zach. Eventually, she breaks down crying, and Zach, confused, comforts her.
August lets Lily visit the hives she has stationed around nearby farms and swamps. She shows Lily the queen of one of the hives. One evening Lily asks August about the stone wall in the backyard. August explains that May built the wall as her own personal wailing wall. She tells Lily about their other sister, April, who was May’s twin. April struggled with depression after being mistreated by a racist store owner and eventually killed herself at age fifteen. May’s hypersensitivity to the misfortunes of the world resulted from the loss of her sister.
Chapter 6 Neil, June’s longtime suitor, visits the Boatwright household. June seems to love Neil, but because of an earlier disappointment in love, she cannot commit to him. The next day, a small group of Daughters of Mary arrive at the house for their Sunday religious service. August tells the story of Our Lady of Chains: originally a ship’s masthead that washed up near a South Carolina plantation, it became a source of strength and inspiration for the plantation slaves. In response, their white masters tried to take the statue away, but fifty times Our Lady escaped and returned to the slaves’ praise house without any help. It became known as ‘‘Our Lady of Chains’’ because chains were unable to hold it.
L i t e r a r y
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
Chapter 7
When they return to the Boatwrights’ home, Lily finds that Rosaleen is moving from the honey house into May’s bedroom in the house. June and Neil, nearby in the garden, get into another argument, which ends with Neil leaving and June telling him not to come back. Lily is distracted by the realization that she is falling in love with Zach. Alone at night in the honey house, she looks at herself in the mirror and fantasizes about him. After Zach and Lily work closely together on the honey harvest, he gives her a gift—a notebook, to help her with her aspirations to be a writer—and they share an embrace.
Chapter 8 While they put the labels on honey jars, August informs Lily that the picture she uses on the label is one of many Black Madonnas she knows from her mother’s Catholic prayer cards. When Lily asks her why she puts the Black Madonna on her honey labels, August remembers how the Daughters of Mary reacted when they first saw the labels: ‘‘it occurred to them for the first time in their lives that what’s divine can come in dark skin.’’ August explains how she and her sisters inherited Our Lady of Chains from their mother, whose mother had kept it before that. To August, it represents the presence of Mary in everything. She remembers her grandmother,
V o l u m e
1
2 3 5
T h e
S e c r e t
L i f e
o f
B e e s
Big Mama, who first taught her beekeeping and from whom the sisters inherited their property in Tiburon. Lily and August go out on bee patrol together, and August shows Lily some of the bees’ secrets: how, for example, each member of the hive has an individual role to play. When August opens one of the hives, the bees swarm over Lily, and she not only feels the ache of losing her mother but also feels comforted by the bees. When the bees settle back in their hives, August tells Lily it is time for them to have a talk, but Lily avoids her by going inside for lunch. At lunch that day, Zach relates that the town is stirred up over the rumor that actor Jack Palance is coming to Tiburon and bringing an African American woman with him. The locals plan to stand guard in front of the town movie theater. Lily accompanies Zach to town to finish his honey deliveries. At the office of lawyer Clayton Forrest, she uses the office telephone to make a collect call to T. Ray while Zach and Forrest are occupied. T. Ray cannot answer the one question Lily called him to ask: does he know what her favorite color is? That evening Lily writes a letter to T. Ray, raging against him for his meanness, but tears it up. She prays to Our Lady of Chains for consolation and, alone with the statue in the dark, presses her hand to its heart.
Chapter 9 In particularly hot weather, August and Lily must go and water the hives. Back at the house, the women play in the sprinkler to beat the heat. When Lily gets in a tug-of-war over the sprinkler with June, the two ultimately share a laugh over the absurdity of their quarrel, a first sign that tensions between them may be thawing. Later, Lily notices May trying to lead a cockroach out of the kitchen instead of killing it, just as Lily’s mother used to do. On a hunch, Lily asks if May knew Deborah, and May tells her that Deborah once stayed in the honey house. Zach invites Lily to drive to town with him, where they find tension developing between white men guarding the movie theater and a group of young black men nearby. As Zach talks to the young men, one of them throws a bottle at the white racists. Zach is arrested with the others when he refuses to reveal which one threw the bottle. At the Boatwright household, the women decide to keep the news from May for
2 3 6
L i t e r a r y
fear of upsetting her. May soon finds out, though, and announces that she needs to visit her wall.
Chapter 10 When May does not return, August and the other women go outside to search for her. They find her submerged in a nearby creek, a suicide like her twin sister. Later, the police come; they interview Lily, who embellishes the cover story of why she is staying with the Boatwrights. The policeman advises her to leave the Boatwright house soon, since a white girl living in a black household is not natural. May’s body is returned to the Boatwright home, and the women hold a vigil in their living room. Zach returns from jail, anguished that his legal problems provoked May’s suicide. August tells him May made her own choice. The Daughters of Mary arrive to participate in the vigil, and Lily finally feels accepted as one of the group. On the second day of the vigil, August finds May’s suicide note. In it, May writes that she is ‘‘tired of carrying around the weight of the world’’ and tells her sisters to live. August urges June to follow her sister’s advice and marry Neil.
Chapters 11–12 While August and June mourn, Lily is left to read and write. When Zach visits, they continue their flirtation, although since his arrest he has become preoccupied with going to law school and joining the civil rights movement. The women prepare to celebrate the Feast of the Assumption, which they call Mary Day. Neil arrives to propose again, and this time, June accepts. The Mary Day festivities proceed that evening, with the Daughters of Mary performing their own version of Communion and chaining their statue of Mary in the honey house as a reenactment of the original Our Lady of Chains story. That night, Lily tells Zach she worries that he will become hardened by his anger; they share a kiss, and Zach promises Lily that one day they will be together. Lily decides she can no longer postpone her talk with August. August admits she knew Deborah was Lily’s mother all along because of the resemblance between the two of them. She tells Lily that she was the housekeeper for Deborah’s family in Virginia. Lily tells August the whole truth, about T. Ray’s abuse, Rosaleen’s run-in with the law, and, most
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
S e c r e t
L i f e
o f
B e e s
painfully, the fact that she killed Deborah. August reassures her of the love everyone in the Boatwright household has for her. August tells Lily more about her mother, who moved from Virginia to South Carolina to be closer to August. She met T. Ray and married him when she became pregnant with Lily. Lily is upset to realize her mother married T. Ray because of her. August tells her that when Deborah left T. Ray, she came to stay with August, without Lily. Feeling abandoned, Lily claims she hates her mother. August admits Deborah made a terrible mistake but tried to make up for it and was returning for Lily when she died.
MEDIA ADAPTATIONS
The Secret Life of Bees (2002) is available on audio cassette and audio CD in both abridged and unabridged versions. An audio version can also be downloaded from audible.com. A movie adaptation of the book is forthcoming from Fox Searchlight.
Chapters 13–14 The next day, the Daughters of Mary remove the statue from the honey house and together lift the chains from it. Then they all, including Lily, anoint the black Mary with honey. After lunch, they wash off the statue and return it to the parlor. August gives Lily a hatbox full of her mother’s possessions, including a pin and a picture of Lily with her mother. Looking at the picture, Lily can finally believe her mother loved her. Lily spends her days by the river, pondering her mother’s life. Rosaleen, meanwhile, has decided to finally register to vote. Lily calls Zach, who tells her he plans to attend the white high school at the start of the next school year. August takes her out to the beehives to show her what happens to a hive when the queen has died. She wants Lily to understand that Our Lady of Chains resides inside her and will always be a source of strength.
August as a small sign that he wants what is best for her. As fall arrives, Lily finds peace in her new life in Tiburon. Forrest works to clear the charges in Sylvan against her and Rosaleen, and she attends high school with Zach, who weathers the taunts of white classmates. Lily keeps May’s wall now and prays in front of the Mary each day.
CHARACTERS August Boatwright
Lily is alone one afternoon at the Boatwright house when T. Ray shows up. He traced the collect call she made to him. He sees a pin of Deborah’s that August gave Lily and recognizes it as the birthday present he gave to his wife years ago. Overwhelmed by memories of Deborah, T. Ray temporarily confuses his daughter for his wife and hits Lily. He recovers his senses but insists she must come home with him, despite her wishes. August returns, flanked by the Daughters of Mary, and when she asks T. Ray to let Lily stay, he relents. Lily chases after T. Ray as he drives off, needing to ask him once more if she truly killed Deborah. T. Ray tells her she did not mean to, but she did pull the trigger. Lily tries to take his leaving her with
August Boatwright is the oldest of three sisters who live together in the town of Tiburon, South Carolina. August raises bees and sells their honey. The picture of the Black Madonna on the label of her honey jars leads Lily and Rosaleen to her home. As a young woman, August was housekeeper to the family of Lily’s mother, Deborah, who shortly before her death lived with the Boatwright sisters in Tiburon when she left Lily’s father. August is the head of the Boatwright household and also the leader of the small group of worshipers of Our Lady of Chains, a ship’s masthead that became a symbol of the Virgin Mary and of resistance to slavery. The statue and its story, as well as their bright pink house and the beehives, are all inheritances from August’s grandmother, Big Mama. August’s spiritual beliefs and general outlook on life are influenced greatly by her beekeeping. She is also an avid
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
2 3 7
T h e
S e c r e t
L i f e
o f
B e e s
reader, whose bedroom is filled with books about beekeeping, mythology, and the Virgin Mary. She tells Lily that though she had once been in love, she had loved her freedom too much to marry. By the end of the novel, she has become a mother figure to Lily, having taken the teenager into her home, fed and nurtured her, enrolled her in school, and bought her new clothes and furniture.
June Boatwright June Boatwright is the middle Boatwright sister. She plays her cello in the hospital rooms and homes of local people dying of terminal diseases, but is guarded with her emotions. She is a teacher who has never been able to commit to her longtime suitor, Neil, because a fiance´ left her at the altar when she was a young woman. Unlike her sisters, June initially resents the presence of Lily in the Boatwright household. She reacts badly when Lily, a white girl, reaches out to touch Our Lady of Chains during one of the group’s services. Eventually she comes to accept Lily, however. After May’s suicide, and with August’s encouragement, June finally agrees to Neil’s marriage proposal.
from field hand to caretaker of his daughter, Lily, after the death of Lily’s mother. A large, assertive woman, Rosaleen threw out an unreliable husband years ago, steals fans from a church on a hot day when the minister is too stingy to give them to her, and stands up to racists who jeer her when she attempts to register to vote. She is arrested and beaten while in police custody; once Lily helps her escape, the two of them are compelled to leave town on the journey that takes them to Tiburon. Although she is initially suspicious of the Boatwrights’ pink house, Rosaleen is readily accepted into their circle. She develops a particularly close relationship with May Boatwright, sharing May’s bedroom that May once shared with her twin sister, April. Despite grumbling over Lily’s behavior sometimes, Rosaleen is a loyal friend to the young woman and keeps her secrets until Lily is ready to come clean. After she and Lily establish themselves in Tiburon, Rosaleen finally gets her voter registration and proudly announces her intention to vote for President Lyndon Johnson’s reelection.
Clayton Forrest May Boatwright May Boatwright is the youngest Boatwright sister. Ever since the death of her twin sister, April, by suicide, May has been morbidly sensitive to the suffering of others. Watching the evening news broadcast, for example, leads to her sobbing and tearing at her hair. Her sisters try to protect her from any bad news that might upset her. As a form of therapy, May has built herself a wailing wall in the woods behind the Boatwright house; when distraught, she writes a prayer for the afflicted on a slip of paper and inserts it between the rocks of her wall. She is against hurting any living thing, and her habit of leading bugs outside instead of killing them suggests to Lily that her mother had once been in the Boatwright house. Despite her sisters’ attempts to shield her, she is devastated by the news that Zach has been arrested. She commits suicide by using a heavy rock to pin herself under the water of a nearby stream.
Rosaleen Daise Rosaleen Daise is an African American woman, around fifty years old (according to Lily she gives differing years for her birth dates), who was promoted by T. Ray Owens
2 3 8
L i t e r a r y
Clayton Forrest is a lawyer who sells jars of August’s honey to his clients. He has taken an informal interest in Zach’s legal aspirations and accepts visits from the young man in his law office. He comes to Zach’s aid after he is arrested, and his daughter, Becca, becomes a friend of Lily’s. He also works to clear up Lily and Rosaleen’s legal troubles in Sylvan.
Avery ‘‘Shoe’’ Gaston Avery Gaston is the policeman who arrests Rosaleen and drives her and Lily to the police station. Despite being an officer of the law, Gaston allows racist thugs to beat Rosaleen while she is in his custody.
Brother Gerald Brother Gerald is the minister at Lily’s church, Ebenezer Baptist Church. He displays a notable lack of Christian charity: he disapproves of Lily bringing a black woman, Rosaleen, into the church when they need a rest during their walk to Sylvan, and denies them fans to keep themselves cool. He attempts to press charges when Rosaleen takes two fans anyway.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
Neil Neil is the long-suffering suitor to June Boatwright, who refuses to marry him because a previous suitor left her at the altar. Neil first tries to break things off with June, but during the celebration of Mary Day, he proposes one more time. June, whose outlook on life has been changed by May’s suicide, finally accepts.
S e c r e t
L i f e
o f
B e e s
T. Ray catches up to Lily in Tiburon, she realizes he loved her mother and was embittered by losing her. Facing a daughter who has come to resemble her mother, T. Ray briefly hallucinates that she is Deborah. He comes to his senses but is unrepentant in his bitterness. Lily tries to construe his consent to let her stay in Tiburon with August and Rosaleen as a last, unprecedented act of kindness toward her.
Lily Owens Lily Owens, the narrator of the novel, is fourteen years old and lives with her father, T. Ray, on his peach farm in the small town of Sylvan, South Carolina. Haunted by the death of her mother and abused by her brutish father, Lily runs off with her caretaker, Rosaleen, led only by a picture of a Black Madonna somehow connected to her late mother. Lily yearns for the nurturing maternal figure she never had, which she finds in August Boatwright. She is also conscious of becoming a young woman, particularly in her romantic interest in August’s assistant, Zach Taylor. Although Lily can sometimes be self-absorbed to the extent of not appreciating the difficulties other characters are facing, she shows courage and loyalty to Rosaleen in helping her escape from vengeful racists. Under the care of August and the healthful effects of honey and working outdoors, Lily begins to blossom into womanhood. She is drawn to the worship of Our Lady of Chains as a way to fill the emptiness she feels inside, although initially she is too selfconscious to touch the statue except by herself late at night. Over the course of the novel, Lily finds the motherly love she has been lacking and, more importantly, understands that a nurturing, feminine spirit already resides within her. She is thus able to begin to forgive herself for the guilt she feels over her mother’s death, as well as forgive her mother for abandoning her.
Franklin Posey Franklin Posey, according to T. Ray Owens, is Sylvan’s most notorious racist. When Rosaleen pours the juice from her snuff jug on his shoes, Posey resorts to brutal tactics to make her apologize.
Zach Taylor Zach Taylor is August Boatwright’s godson and assistant at her beekeeping business. An academically gifted teenager, Zach develops romantic feelings toward Lily, which, considering he is black and Lily is white, could have dangerous consequences for him. After Zach is arrested for being present when an acquaintance of his throws a bottle at a group of white men, he is strengthened in his resolve to become a lawyer and join the civil rights movement. As a first step, he attends the formerly segregated local high school with Lily at the start of the new school year. He promises Lily that one day, when social circumstances are different and he has made a name for himself, they will be together.
THEMES Race Relations
T. Ray Owens is the father of Lily Owens. A peach farmer, T. Ray is a strict, uncaring, and frequently abusive father. His favorite punishment is making Lily kneel in a pile of Martha White dry grits, and he administers it with little provocation. Lily’s only memory of her dead mother is inextricably intertwined with T. Ray’s violent temper; Lily’s mother drew a gun to protect her daughter and herself from his assaults, only to be shot accidentally in the struggle. Since his wife’s death, T. Ray shows affection only to his hunting dog, Snout. When
In South Carolina in 1964, people of different races lived in strictly separate worlds. The Secret Life of Bees is set in the months following the passage of the Civil Rights Act in July of that year; appropriately for that summer, much of the novel is seen through the prism of race. Rosaleen’s troubles begin when she is harassed by racists on her way to register to vote, and social conventions of the segregated community keep Zach and Lily from acting on their affection for each other. Our Lady of Chains gets her name because the chains of slavery were unable to hold her. Lily initially is too self-conscious of her whiteness to touch the statue of Our Lady
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
T. Ray Owens
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
2 3 9
T h e
S e c r e t
L i f e
o f
B e e s
and feels she can only do so secretly. Sue Monk Kidd offers a range of responses to issues of race among her characters. Lily decides that ‘‘everybody being colorless together’’ would be the ideal situation. Zach, on the other hand, after he is arbitrarily arrested and held for days by the racist local police, becomes more dedicated to fighting racial injustice. April Boatwright killed herself after years of depression that began when she was not allowed to eat ice cream in a whitesonly establishment, and her twin sister, May, kills herself in the wake of Zach’s racially motivated arrest. By the end of the novel, race relations are changing in positive, individual ways. Rosaleen eventually registers to vote, and Zach leads the way in integrating Tiburon’s formerly segregated high school.
Search for the Mother For a child, the loss of a mother is one of the most profound of traumas. If that child has an uncaring father and no other maternal figures, the damage is compounded. In the novel, Lily’s solution is creating an elaborate fantasy about her mother, whom she imagines she will see one day in heaven. She runs away to Tiburon and finds August Boatwright because of the need to fill an emptiness within her—a ‘‘motherless place.’’ August and her sisters are part of a small group of worshipers called the Daughters of Mary, who consider their spiritual mother to be Our Lady of Chains. As a kind of controlling maternal presence, she is also symbolized in the novel by the queen bee, mother of the entire hive, who gives the hive purpose. Lily blossoms under the maternal care of August, who also teaches her that the divine mother, the Virgin Mary, is accessible everywhere, most especially inside her own heart.
The Natural World The natural world holds much symbolic and actual importance for the characters in Kidd’s novel. Rosaleen and Lily bathe in a river and sleep under the stars before they reach the Boatwright household, where August’s beekeeping has made her especially acute to the rhythms and secrets of nature. Each chapter of the novel begins with a quotation from a nonfiction work on bees and beekeeping that comments on the action that follows. The honey the bees produce is a vital part of life for the Boatwrights, who use it for its healthful properties, sell it for their livelihood, and include it in the religious rituals of the Daughters of Mary. The bees also provide
2 4 0
L i t e r a r y
August and Lily with life lessons about the roles people play in society and how, as a queen bee gives life to her hive, so motherhood brings life and purpose to society. Even the names of the Boatwright sisters, May, June, and August, seem to suggest a connection to the natural world and its seasonal changes as well as a love for the fertility of nature associated with warm weather.
Community of Women Through the Daughters of Mary, Kidd depicts a feminist, matriarchal alternative to the racist white male religious and civil authorities who otherwise dominate the town of Tiburon. The Boatwrights and the other Daughters worship a divine feminine presence, the Virgin Mary. The Virrgin’s nurturing qualities stand in sharp contrast to Brother Gerald, the Baptist preacher at the church in Sylvan. The Daughters’ worship revolves around shared meals and communally treasured rituals. By the end of the novel, Rosaleen and Lily both have found a place for themselves in this mostly female community, which is guided by principles of strength and grace—as when August and the Daughters stand up to T. Ray when he comes to claim Lily, firmly but without threats or violence.
The Importance of Ritual The characters in Kidd’s novel use rituals to stay connected with others as well as with the past. Early in the novel, Lily attaches ritual importance to the few items of her mother’s that she possesses. She keeps them buried in a particular spot outside and looks at them only in secret. She has a pair of gloves that she wears to imagine what her mother must have been like. May Boatwright has developed her own ritual to cope with the anxiety she feels over the misfortunes of others. She writes a prayer for the suffering party on a slip of paper and inserts the paper in a wailing wall she constructed behind the Boatwright house. After May dies, Lily takes over maintaining the wall. The most important rituals in the novel are those pertaining to Our Lady of Chains. When August tells the story of Our Lady, it is clear that the other Daughters have heard the story many times. On their annual celebration of Mary Day, they follow a ritual of chaining the statue, then anointing it with honey. They also share a Communion using honey cakes. The rituals of Our Lady connect the Daughters to the first slaves who drew strength from her, as well as
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
S e c r e t
L i f e
o f
B e e s
STYLE Religious Symbolism
TOPICS FOR FURTHER STUDY
Each chapter of the novel begins with a quotation or quotations about bees and beekeeping. Pick a chapter and explain how the quotations from the beginning relate to the events of that chapter. Identify the character in the novel you think is the ‘‘queen bee’’ and explain why. In the novel, there are a variety of references to factual events that occurred in 1964, the year in which the novel is set. Identify one of these references and prepare a news report for the class like the ones the characters watch in the novel, explaining what has occurred. Zach and Lily promise each other that someday they will be together. Write a scene in which they meet today in their sixties. Would they end up together? Would the social conventions that kept them apart before still keep them apart today? Find another creative work—a novel, story, movie, poem, or painting—in which bees appear. What do the bees represent in that work? Explain three ways in which the symbolism of the bees in the work you found is similar to or differs from their symbolism in Kidd’s novel. May’s wailing wall behind the Boatwright house helps her cope to some extent with the traumas that occur in her life and with life generally. The Boatwright sisters also have their daily prayers and weekly services before Our Lady of Chains as important rituals in their home. What are some examples of rituals, religious or otherwise, in your own home? What functions do they serve? Write a scene that describes your family following these rituals.
In The Secret Life of Bees, Lily Owens is introduced to a group of women who formed a religious faith founded on the perseverance of their slave ancestors and a black wooden statue of the Virgin Mary. The symbols of their religion— not just the Madonna, but the honey from August’s hives and the chains that represent a resistance to slavery—are important to them and to the novel as a whole. Lily has actually been aware of the Black Madonna since her childhood. One of the few possessions she has to associate with her mother, who died when Lily was four years old, is an icon—a picture of a dark-skinned Mary glued to a small wooden plaque. As she comes to learn from August Boatwright, that image of Mary is only one of many dark-skinned representations of her around the world. Late in the novel, Lily looks at a book filled with these Black Madonnas and sees that the Archangel Gabriel is frequently pictured as presenting a lily to Mary to symbolize the coming birth of Jesus. Lily’s name is a religious symbol itself. This realization on her part goes along with her growing sense of self-worth.
Nature Symbolism
the generations who have passed before them. For August, particularly, they connect her to the mother and grandmother from whom she learned the rituals.
Nature symbolism is an important feature of The Secret Life of Bees, most obviously in the form of the bees August Boatwright keeps. Much of August’s understanding of life comes from the years she has spent tending to and observing the bees. She shows Lily that the bees have a ‘‘secret life,’’ that each bee has a purpose in the functioning of the hive, and that without a queen bee—the ‘‘mother of thousands,’’ as August says—the rest of the hive loses its purpose. Lily understands that what she learns about the bees can be applied to her own life. The honey the bees produce is also vital to the Boatwright household. They take it medicinally, shampoo and bathe in it, and use it for their religious rituals. The nature symbolism and religious imagery in the novel are inseparable. The bees, August explains, represent death and rebirth. Early Christians used drawings of bees to communicate in code with each other. The names of the Boatwright sisters themselves— August, May, and June—symbolize their closeness to nature and love of life, associated as they are with the warm, fertile months of the year (another sister, April, died as a teenager).
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
2 4 1
T h e
S e c r e t
L i f e
o f
B e e s
Coming-of-Age Novel The coming-of-age novel has a rich history in Southern literature. The pains of adolescence and self-discovery that Lily undergoes are similar to those experienced by the young female main characters of other twentieth-century novels by Southern women, including Harper Lee’s To Kill a Mockingbird (1960) and Carson McCullers’s The Member of the Wedding (1946). (Those novels have other similarities to The Secret Life of Bees as well: To Kill a Mockingbird also explores racial intolerance in a small Southern town during the days of segregation, and the central relationship in The Member of the Wedding, between Frankie and her family’s housekeeper, Berenice, is much like the relationship between Lily and Rosaleen.) In these coming-of-age novels, a girl makes the first awkward steps toward maturity and gains some wisdom about the world around her. Lily’s path to maturity involves an acceptance of her conflicted feelings about the mother who abandoned her, and a spiritual awakening that allows her to discover the nurturing presence of the Black Madonna in herself. It also involves a tentative realization of her sexuality, in the form of her first romance with August’s godson and beekeeping assistant, Zach Taylor. Zach’s ambitions and the fact he is black and Lily is white lead them to promise each other that they will be together in a more tolerant future.
Storytelling Storytelling is a vital part of Southern literature, dating back at least as far as Joel Chandler Harris’s ‘‘Uncle Remus’’ stories and Mark Twain’s Life on the Mississippi (1883). For Southerners, storytelling can be a pastime, a folk art, and a way to pass down family histories. Kidd has said in interviews that one of her earliest inspirations as a writer growing up in Georgia was her father’s knack for storytelling. In The Secret Life of Bees, August uses stories to teach Lily. In the story of Sister Beatrix, a nun who grows tired of the convent and runs away and returns years later, disappointed with life in the outside world, to find that the Virgin Mary has been filling in for her at the convent the entire time. August later tells Lily that she intended Sister Beatrix to represent Lily’s mother, Deborah, and hoped Mary could fill in for her, providing Lily the mother figure she desperately desires. August also tells the story of the Black Madonna, Our Lady of Chains, as
2 4 2
L i t e r a r y
a way of reaffirming the sense of community that the Daughters of Mary feel and reminding them of the courage of their slave ancestors. The statue, originally a ship’s masthead discovered by a slave on a coastal plantation, became a source of comfort and strength to the other slaves, particularly when it shrugged off the chains the plantation owner attempts to use to lock it in the barn for fifty straight nights. August also tells Lily of the story of Aristaeus—the first beekeeper, according to Greek myth—whose bees were killed by the gods but then reborn in the body of a sacrificial bull. After that, August explains, people believed bees had the power over life and death.
HISTORICAL CONTEXT Book Clubs and Inspirational Literature Book clubs have grown in popularity in the twenty-first century thanks to high-profile reading projects such as Oprah Winfrey’s televised monthly club and promotion by publishers and bookstores. Previously unknown authors have found themselves propelled up the bestseller lists through book-club promotion.The Secret Life of Bees received a similar boost after its publication in 2002 when it was selected as the Good Morning America ‘‘Read This!’’ book for October of that year. In 2003, the Penguin paperback edition of the novel was published in a format friendly to book clubs, with an author interview and questions for discussion appended to the end. Sue Monk Kidd’s novel was well poised for success as a book-club favorite because of its focus on issues of interest to women readers, the majority of book-club participants. Its predominantly female cast of characters, smalltown setting, and themes of motherhood and female friendship link it to other novels popular with reading groups, by authors such as Toni Morrison and Rebecca Wells. The book deals with race, a perennial subject of interest, but through the eyes of its white protagonist, perhaps making the issue more accessible to a broader audience. The Secret Life of Bees also appeared at a time when literature explicitly about spiritual matters was viewed with renewed interest—four months after September 11, 2001, as Laura T. Ryan points out in her article on Kidd in the Syracuse Post-Standard. Kidd’s novel is very
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
S e c r e t
L i f e
o f
B e e s
much in the spirit of her earlier inspirational writing, with her main character learning to reconnect her soul to an inner feminine presence. Its success among book clubs and its inspirational message seemingly combined to give the novel enormous mainstream appeal.
Civil Rights–Era South The South in the 1960s is the setting for a large number of plays, movies, novels, and stories. Southern writers who are old enough to have lived through that era have frequently attempted to come to terms with their experiences of racism and the progress and disappointments of the civil rights movement from both sides of the color line.The Secret Life of Bees is set specifically during the immediate aftermath of the signing of Civil Rights Act in July 1964, a time marked by often brutal, racially motivated violence in the South, which is also alluded to in the novel. Lily finds in May Boatwright’s wailing wall a slip of paper that says ‘‘Birmingham, Sept 15, four little angels dead,’’ a reference to the Sixteenth Street Baptist Church bombing in Alabama the previous year, in which four girls were killed. The Civil Rights Act put the force of federal law behind the constitutional rights of African Americans, particularly with respect to public accommodations such as restaurants, stores, and hotels. Voter-registration rallies such as the one Rosaleen plans to attend in the novel were common after state laws set up to make it difficult for black people to vote were struck down. Tens of thousands of black South Carolinians registered to vote in the first half of the 1960s. Still, for some African Americans, social progress did not come quickly enough. Young black men such as Zach Taylor in Kidd’s novel were increasingly drawn to more-militant groups such as Malcolm X’s Organization of AfroAmerican Unity, which he founded in 1964. Zach becomes preoccupied with the activities of such groups after his arrest.
Honeycomb with bees Copyright Ó by E. S. Ross. Reproduced by permission
its upbeat message of the power of love. Jarrod Zickefoose, writing in the Cleveland Plain Dealer, suggests that the reader must force sympathy for Lily, but that ‘‘August’s deep spirituality, her security and her wisdom form a character that permeates the pages.’’ In the April 2002 Women’s Review of Books, Rosellen Brown ultimately concludes that the novel ‘‘has less sting in the end than its swarm of griefs would seem to promise,’’ but admires Kidd’s vision of ‘‘a sort of beloved community, part Oz, part ashram, part center for racial reconciliation.’’ The novel was well received in England as well, as indicated by Rachel Simhon’s review in February 23, 2002, edition of the Daily Telegraph. Simhon describes the novel as ‘‘by turns funny, sad, full of incident and shot through with grown-up magic.’’
The Secret Life of Bees was met with generally positive reviews when it was published in 2002. Sue Monk Kidd had already established a reputation for herself as a writer of inspirational literature, and many reviewers seemed to approach the novel in that spirit, praising it for
As the novel became a success in book clubs and reading groups around the country, it continued to garner positive notices. Ann-Janine Morey, writing in the February 22, 2003, issue of Christian Century, observed that the racial plot of the novel was ‘‘imperfectly integrated’’ with the story of Lily’s spiritual journey, but recommends ‘‘this captivating first novel about love and forgiveness’’ to both adult and younger readers.The Secret Life of Bees sold 3.5 million
L i t e r a r y
V o l u m e
CRITICAL OVERVIEW
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
1
2 4 3
T h e
S e c r e t
L i f e
o f
B e e s
copies and spent nearly two years on the New York Times bestseller list, and a motion-picture adaptation is in the works. SHROUDED IN MYTH, OUR LADY OF CHAINS COMES TO REPRESENT, OVER THE COURSE OF THE
CRITICISM
NOVEL, THE MYSTERIES KIDD PORTRAYS AS THE MOST POWERFUL OF ALL: THOSE OF THE HUMAN HEART.’’
Charles Brower Brower is an editor and freelance writer. In this essay, he discusses the importance of mysteries in the characters’ lives in The Secret Life of Bees. As suggested even in its title, the driving forces behind the characters’ actions in Sue Monk Kidd’sThe Secret Life of Bees are mysteries. They may be mysteries that characters cherish—as with the kind represented by the supernatural events of the story of Our Lady of Chains recited ritually by her worshippers, the Daughters of Mary—or ones that they want desperately to resolve, as with Lily Owens’s pursuit of answers about her mother’s life and death. Characters keep secrets even from those they love, and nature seems to withhold its secrets from all except those who know how to look for them. Lily’s relationship with her mother, Deborah, whom Lily accidentally shot and killed when she was four years old, exists only in the imagination of the now fourteen-year-old teenager. Her abusive father, T. Ray, does not discuss his dead wife. Other than her memories of the day of Deborah’s death, Lily has only a few mementos of her mother—a photograph, a pair of white gloves, and, most significantly, an icon of a dark-skinned Virgin Mary—which she keeps buried in her father’s peach orchard. She digs them up occasionally and uses them to spin elaborate fantasies about the sort of woman Deborah was. The significance of the Black Madonna icon is a complete mystery to Lily, and the inscription on the back in her mother’s hand, ‘‘Tiburon, S.C.,’’ is what draws her to that small Southern town and the Boatwright sisters. Lily learns who the Black Madonna is almost immediately upon arriving in Tiburon, but this knowledge only involves her in greater mysteries. The figure of Mary that August Boatwright and her sisters call Our Lady of Chains was originally a masthead, washed up, according to their legend, from an unknown ship near a plantation on the South Carolina coast in the days of slavery. It communicated in secret with the slaves of the plantation, exhorting them
2 4 4
L i t e r a r y
to furtive acts of flight and resistance. Amazingly, under its own power it repeatedly escaped the chains the plantation owner used to lock it in the barn. Shrouded in myth, Our Lady of Chains comes to represent, over the course of the novel, the mysteries Kidd portrays as the most powerful of all: those of the human heart. The person who initiates Lily into these mysteries is August, beekeeper and apparent leader of the Daughters of Mary. As Lily keeps secrets from August—the truth about her life and especially the reason she has come to Tiburon—so August keeps from Lily the fact that she recognized her almost immediately from her resemblance to her mother, for whose family she served as housekeeper when Deborah was a child. Only when Lily is willing to be honest with August—and, more importantly, with herself—does August tell her about her mother. Mysteries, indeed, are a vital part of life to August. As a beekeeper, she appreciates that the life of the hive is mostly hidden within the wooden bee boxes she has spread throughout the area. Taking Lily on as a sort of apprentice, she explains to her the inner workings of the hive, ‘‘the secret life we don’t know anything about.’’ Lily imagines that she loves ‘‘the idea of bees having a secret life, just like the one I was living,’’ but her glimpse at this hidden life seems to have an overwhelming effect on her. Lost in a cloud of bees after August opens a bee box, Lily drifts into a trance in which her anguish about the ‘‘motherless place’’ within her is soothed by the queen bee, ‘‘the mother of thousands,’’ as August tells her. Other secret aspects of nature are cherished by August, for whom the advances of scientific knowledge can also mean ‘‘the end of something.’’ After watching a news report about the imminent launch of the unmanned rocket Ranger 7 to the moon, August remarks: [A]s long as people have been on this earth, the moon has been a mystery to us. Think about it.
N e w s m a k e r s
f o r
S t u d e n t s ,
V o l u m e
1
T h e
She is strong enough to pull the oceans, and when she dies away, she always comes back again. My mama used to tell me Our Lady lived on the moon and that I should dance when her face was bright and hibernate when it was dark. . . . Now it won’t ever be the same, not after they’ve landed up there and walked around on her. She’ll be just one more big science project.
As August’s mother’s story suggests, the mysteries of nature and those of the Black Madonna are inextricably intertwined. The origins of the story of Our Lady of Chains that the Daughters of Mary listen to August recite on their annual celebration of ‘‘Mary Day’’ (the Feast of the Assumption) are unclear. August says of their worship of Our Lady of Chains that she and her sisters ‘‘take our mother’s Catholicism and mix in our own ingredients.’’ August learned the story from her grandmother, as it had been passed along through generations along with the black wooden statue. The Daughters become entranced when August tells the story, chanting at the climactic, supernatural explanation of the statue’s name—and as she does later when surrounded by bees, Lily is overwhelmed by the experience and faints. The emotional, religious, and nature themes of The Secret Life of Bees all appropriately come to a climax around the same point of the novel. Having been prevented from talking to August by her and June’s period of mourning after sister May’s suicide, Lily finds the courage finally to come clean during the Daughters’ celebration of Mary Day, when the story of Our Lady’s unsuccessful imprisonment is reenacted, the black