Mathematics Applied to Continuum Mechanics
SIAM'S, Classics in Applied Mathematics series «rr;ists of books that were...
58 downloads
1610 Views
42MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Mathematics Applied to Continuum Mechanics
SIAM'S, Classics in Applied Mathematics series «rr;ists of books that were previously allowed to Lcr out of- print. These books are republished by SIAM as a professional service because they continue to be important ramrurces for mathematical scientists. F.d.itor-inlChief R+7ben E. t)'Matlle*y, Jr., University of Washington Editorial Board Richard A. 13nGtkiï, University of Wiuorrsin ,Maclist}fl Leah Edelsrcin-Veshct, University of British Columbia Nicholas J. High,-tlsti, University of h1
Problems in the Nation! Sciences
Johan G. F. L3t•linfante and Bernard Koltt>rant, A Survey of Lie Gaups and Lie Algebras with Applications and Currlpttuuional Methods James. M. Chtet,,^a, Numerical Analysis: A Second Course Anthony V Fiaoco and 4iarrh l`: Mc-LÂxrnick, Nonlinear Progrrunrning: Sequential [?nrrrrurrcrinEcl Minimization Techniques E H. Clarke. Optimization and Nonsnuxrth Analysis Chxrr-Ke F. [ :arrier and Ctrl E. Pearson. Ordinary Differential I;quutrrms
Lct, Bteirtkrn, Probability R. J3
G. M. Wing, An Introduction to Irrreirrirnit imbedding
Ahrarlia u u Berman and Hubert J. l'letrHr14 N 16, IVunriegtrtive Matrices in the 2'vfntfit°}nurirr4d SCieliCis C }lvi L. Nlatsk;a3aria► n, Nunlinettr Programming
*Carl Friedrich Gauss, Theory of the Combination of Observations Least Subject to Errors: Part One, Part Two, Supplement. Translated by G. W Stewart ltich.-rrcl
trudltcr:torr tir M{urtx Analysis
U. M. Ascher, R. M. M. Miatdxij, and R. Russell, Numerical Solution of Boundary. lûlue Problems for Ordinary Differential Equations K. E lircnan y,S. L. Campbell, and L. H. Petzolri, Numerical Solution of Irtit.itté-Vuluc Problems in Differentia/Algebraic Equations
Charles L. Lawson and Richard J. Hanson, Sobtirrg Least Squares Problems J. E. l)enttrs, Jr. atu.l Rtrben B. SclSnarlel, Numerical Methods for Urtctnrsrrcù,teci Optitni^urt[»r arid Nonlinear Equations Richard E. Barlow and Frarik Prnsc.itian, Mttthentatiat! Theory of Reliability
C rnelius Lanczos, Linear Differential Opercators Richard Bellnrtn, Introduction to Matrix Analysis, Second Edition F3etesfttircl N. farlett, The Symmetric Fiipenaxtfue Prob+[em
*First time rn print.
11
Classics in Ap p li e d Mathematics {ccintinued} Rkh:trd Halxrinsm, Mathematical Models: Mechanical L'ibrurioris, Ii,piilation Dynamics, and Traffic Flow Perer W. M. John, Statis,tietrl Design and Analysis of Experiments Tamer Balar arid Geer Jan Olsder, Dynamic Noncooperative Gaine Theor y, Second Edition Emanuel Parxen, Stochastic Processes Pettar Kokotovit, Hassan K. Khalil, and John C7' Rellly, Singular Pertunccriun Itilezfinds in Conn til: Analysis and Design Jean Dickinson Gibbons, Ingram (Akin, a tx! Milto n Sobel, Selecting and Ordering Populations: A New Statisticril Methodology James A. Murdock, Pt:rtuthartüins: Theory and Methods ivar Ekiklatxl :and Roger Térn:nxt, Convex Ariatiysis err ul litriatia,nul Problems Ivor StaEcgokl, Boundary Value Problems of ll+iatPtematicul Physics, Volumes I rand IP J. M. Ortega and W C. RI7einlxildt. IterYrzi :+e Solution of Nonlinear F.gt u uions in Serenté Variables David Kindcrlehrer a n d Guido Statnfutcciiia, An Inr rud trctiarn nr Variational Inequalities and Their Applications E Nattcrer, The Mathematics of Computerized Tomography Avinash Cr. Kak and Malcolm Slaney, Principles af Camaptateri z ed Tomogrrtiphic Imaging R. Wong, Asymptotic Approximations of Integrals O. Axeissitti a nd V. A. i3arlcer, Finite Element Solution of Boundary Value Problems: Theory and Computation Da vid R. $rillinger, Time Series: Data Analysis and Theory J oe l N. Fr:ttiklin, Methods uf Mathematical Economics: Linear ana Nonlinear Programming, Fixed•Puint Theorems Philip Hartman, Ordinary Diffèrentiarl I:yuutions. Second Edition Pvlichacl D. lntriligator, Mathematical Optunritrrnarn and Economic Theory rr Elliptic Problems Philippe C . Ciarlet, The Finite Element Method Jr Jane K. Cullum and Ralph A. Willoughby, I..c:itc-zus Algorithms /Or Large Symmetric k.igcntaallzr Computations, VOL 1: Theory Vidyasagar, Nonlinear Systems Analysis, Second Edition Robert Mattheij and Ja:tp t+9ulcna:ir, Ordinary Differential EQxacairir; in Thcory and Prcictic:e Shand S . Gupta and S. l'ancliapakes:rn, Mtcltipie Decision P'rDrcclfrt,s- Tlter)r} find Mctfiutie,lurr, of Selecting and Ranking Populations Eugene L. Allgower ari d Kurt Georg, Introduction to Ntariteracal Continuation Merh ❑ aIt Leah E.clvlstein-Keshet, Mauherncuircli Models in Biofriry
Heinz-Otto Krciss arid lens Lorenz, Initial P3014 nLlar'}• Volute Problems and the NaavterStokçs Equal ions J. L. Hodges, Jr. and E. L. Lehmann, Basic Concep ts uf Probability and Statistics, Second Edition George F. Carrier, Max Kraxik, and Carl E . l'e,irso ii, Functions of u Complex Variable; Theory and Technique Friedrich Pululshcitn, Optimal Design of F.xperirnenzs l5rael GANT, Niter Li ncasier, and Leiba Rodman, Incuriurtt Subspaces of Matrices with Applications Lue A. Seg el with G. H. Hand e lm a n, Mathematics Applied to Continuum Mechanics
i ii
A beetle Makin vravcs on a water our niirrlacc. From experience with ship wavIM ane would expect the disturbance to be confined to a V-shaped region behind the object. Here they precede the object; perhaps bredt have a mysterious organ to reverse the natural order of cause and cf e.ct! Or perhaps 'here is more to we propagation +han meets the eye. See the fxneluding ponton of Section 9.1, The photograph appeared on the cover of Science thé (Nev. 14. 1969. Copyright 1969 by for American Association for the Adunnecr-rr.,,i of Science). in connection with an article by V. A. Tudor'. Wave-Making b} lhhirhgLE BeetleslGyrinidrie)." pp- $9799. Reproduction is by permtssion.j
9 P Mathematics Applied to Continuum Mechanics b ti Lee A . Se ge l With additional material on elasticity by (3. H. Handelman
Society for I nd ustrial acid Applied Mathematics Philadelphia
Copyright
2C07 by th e Society for lusltttiirutl and Applied l^l,itlii nt:i[u s
This SIAM edition is an unabridged republication of tl;r work Itrtit published b y iiie Macmillan Publishing t i., New York, NIT I098 7li `i 4 i l I
Ail rii;Itis reserved. Primed ill. the United Slimes itt America. No pan or this hook may I v reproduced, stored. or Ir ;instlliUc`J in any manner wttluvztt the Milli en rierm[syiLiiti clj the publisher- For itifcuinaiiitiit, write li> the Society ittr Industrial and Applied Matlwmaitics, 3600 University City Science (renier, Philadelphia. l'A 1 41104-16M. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication I?a tat Segel, Lee A. Maihcutalits applied t o Coniinittuln mechanics I ice A. S L'i;l'I; wit h :il lt li[iL71l:lI material un elasticity by 0.11. Handelman. cm. -- (Clsthsica tti atph+licxl ut:ttheutattics ; 51) Originally lttihlisixccl; New Yo rk ; M:xinilLiu, c1977, lrtcludrs bibliographical retcrenci,s and index. ISBN- I 0: 0 -H9ii71-620-9 ISBN-13: 978- 0-89871-620 -7 1. ( nutria' mechanics, 2, Mattliclnalics. L Handelman, il. 11. II. Title. QA1308.2.S4 i 2ûe7 5H --dc22
2006052201
T
Slarn
is a registered trademark.
To Rutkr,e/
C ontents FDk1ïW[H;1] TO Ti [F: CLASSICS EI]ITH rh
xvii
PREFACE CONVENTIONS
xih uxïïi
PART A GEOMETRICAL PREREQUISITES FOR THREE -DIMENSI O NAL CONTINUUM MECHA NICS CHAPTER I VECTORS, DETERMINANTS, AND MOTIVATION FOR TENSORS 1.1
3
Vectors in a Cartesian coordinate system, transformation Of vector
components, and the summation convention 3 Prajecnorr 4 f Transforrnurton of coordinates—Geometric approach 5 1 Notattorr t' f Vectors— Alyehruwc point of view y 1 Vectors—Geometric point of view LO f Ret}ici' of linear dependence 12 1.2 Determinants and the permutation symbol 14 The permutation symbol is f Determinants 16 / The" ed" rule 20 1.3 The consistency requirement 23 The consistency of Newton's second law 23 f Physical laws: General statement rJersusparticular numerical i;ersion 24 I Guessing the ren cnr transformation law from the consistency regeurrement 25 .
1.4 The tensor as a linear tianstormation f.lneur transformations 28 f The stress !ensui induces a linear transformation of dïferenttal area into differertfialforce 29 1 A linear transformation of differential area to differential force can he identified with the Stress tensor 31
CHAPTER 2 CARTFSIAN TENSORS 2. I Tensor algebra 33 Definitions and elementary properties 34 / Special results for second order tensors 41 f Isotropic tensors 43 1 T!w vector associated with an unite mmetric tensor 46
2.2 The eigenvalue problem
49
Eigetrralues and eiqenvectors of syn vrretrir sensors
ix
55 f Principal axes 57
Contents
2.3 The calculus of tensor functions
6o
TireorerrZ5 fi1r tlPrltottriYS UfferisCir fields 61 f integral rïteorenrs 64
{
Representation theorems 6,7 APPENDIX
2.1 Some basic equations of continuum mechanics
72
PART B PROBLEMS 1Iti CONTINUUM MECHANICS CHAPTER
3
Viscous 1't,t.iIps 3.1
The Navier Stokes equations
78
Analysis of the local velocity field 7ô f Assumptions that underlie the eyteafixxi !to J Der m artonr of the fuJK.l (-quartons S 2 t Boundary cexr.stiu g5 f Incompressible viscous flow 86 cortl s
3.2 Exact solutions 93 Solutiot I: Ham rc3uerte
flow y; r Solution 1: Plane Poiseuille flow g; f Su/liftoff 3: Rayleigh rinperisWe 'kw 98
3_3
On boundary layers
1o5
Comparative magnitudes of t•isc•ous urul truvse•rel Wrrns 105 ? Re}redfds plumber icr7 / Boundary layer equations for steady.. _flow past a fiat plate leg l3otttadar y conditions l l
f
3.4 Boundary layer flow past a semi - infinite flat plate t 15 Formulation t l6 / Blasius similarity solution i 16 t Defects in the Blasius suiirtioz t 18 f Boundary layer separation 120 , Slightly rïsc'uus uniform floor past streamlined bodies 121 / Slighuh• viscous uniform flow past bluff bodies 122
3.5 \torticity changes in viscous fluid motion t 29 F'ortui{v cctnvertinn and stretching i29 ( Viscous roJrffrr'fy diffusion and boundary genrratinn 13 t f Voracity trr fwer-cltinerrsinnalJ1 oxs 132 f Vwtirify in istY+us flo w s J1;2 j Surrtrnarr of the role of voracity 134 puricla
3.6 Slow viscous now past a small sphere
1 35
tùrrriukriiun 136 i Snllution 137
APPENDIX 3-1
Navier — Stokes equations in cylindrical
coordinates t38 AIEENDIX 3.2 Generation of confidence in the boundary layer equations by construction of a finite difference scheme for their solution 139
xi
Contents CHAPTER 4 FOUNDATIONS OF ELASTICITY
4.1 Analysis of local motion 144 Strain tensor in material coordinates 144 I Geometrical inerpre•tation of strain components 147 J Straw, tensor in spatial coordinates 149 / The rotation rumor 15o j Principal axes of strain 161 f Compatibility ry , uatiom 153 1 Some examples of strain 155
4.2 Hooke's constitutive equation and some exact solutions 1 59 Gr neralized Hooke's laui 159 J Interpretation of the elastic coefficients via exact _solutions 162 / Tension of a çylindrical bar 163 f Shear of a rectangular hat i64 / Compression of a rectangular parallelepiped I66 4.3 Final formulation of the problem of linear elasticity [68 Srrn merry of `general equations, boundary conditions, and minci eDrrditians 169 if Novier's equations 171 1 Beltrami-Mlc! equations 17
4.4 Energy concepts and the principle of virtual work 174 Energy balance 174 J Prinrrple of virtual work 177 1 Uniqueness theorems 178 Potential energy rninurrization in equilibrium 179
4.5 Snrne effects of finite deformation 184 Kinematle s I li4 r Comparison with linear theory for nonlinear elasticity i l g / Simple shear 1g9
187 , A ronsti /dive equation
CHAPTER 5 SOME EXAMPLES OF STATIC PROBLEMS IN ELASTICITY
5.1 Bending o f beams 194 Bending by rc•rrnrnal couples, Formulation 194 j Solution [ g6 f lrr rerprerar ion 1 99 j Jnfrrxhit•tion to the engineering diary of be n din g Basic assumptions zoo f Equations of engineering bending theory 204 / Boundary I orrelrrions 208 J Traveling-wave solutions 2to / Buckling of a f►eatrr 21 z / Variational methods titi elasticity 214
5,2 Si. Venant torsion problem
219
Warping,/renrrion 220 • Stress funrtlon 224 f Further proper:1es of the stress function 226 1 Modified stress function 229 f Rectangular cross section 230 f Elfiptiraf cross section 233 J St. Venant principle 235
5.3 Some plane problems 240 Equations for plane strain 241 f Airy's stress function 241 / Boundary conditions 242 J Polar coordinates 245 / Kirsch pro biens. Stress concentration 248 f Plane stress ego / Generalized plane stress 252 f Concluding remarks 255
/
xü
Consents
CHAPTER 6 INTRODUCTION TO DYNAMIC PROBLEMS IN ELASTICITY
6.1 Elastic waves iii unbounded media
259
Dilatational and rotational wave equations 259 1 Waves via the Helmholtz representation z6c f Plane wave solutions 261
6.2 Propagation of discontinuity surfaces 264 A condition on mild discontinuities 265 f Further jump conditions 266 f Saloir for discontinuity velocities 269 f Orientations of discontinuity sur}aces z70
6.3
Reflection of plane shear waves 271 Formulation 272 f Attempted solution with a reflected wore 273 I Additional reflected wore 274 I interpretation of results 276
6.4 Elastic surface waves 278 Formulation 278 f Solution: Plane waves that decay with depth 279 Î Analysts of the solution z8i f Occurrences of Rayleigh wages 283
6.5 Internal reflection
285
6.6 Love waves 289 Formulation and solution 290 f Examination of the nature of dispersion 293 f Further characteristics of the solution 294 f Concluding remarks 395
PART C WATER WAVES CHAPTER 7 FORMULATION OF THE THEORY OF SURFACE WAVES IN AN INVISCID FLUID
7.I Boundary conditions
301
Kinematic boundary candi lion 3c i f Basic facts about surface tension 343 f Quick derivation of a dynamic boundary condition 304 / Detailed derivation of the dynamic boundary condition for an ins, iscid fluid 3p5 f Forces on a surface element 308 f C'on.segttencrs of local equilibrium 3 i 3
7.2 Formulation and simplifica ti on 319 Equations for two-dimensional wales in an infinitely wide layer of inuiscid Add 320 f Static and dynamic pressure ;2z f Nonaiimensionalization 324 Linearization 326
f
7.3 Order-of-magnitude estimates, nondirnensianalization, and scaling 327 ,Estimating the size of terms tir equations governing water waves 328
f
Scaling 329 j dise of dimensionless scaled variables 331 f Pressure scale 33 2
Ka i
Contents
C HAPTER 8 S OLUTI O N IN THE LINEAR THEORY 8. 1 A solution of the lineari z ed equations 335 Assumption ofa solution of exponential type 135 ` Verification that t311 t-rirrcfiric rrrS 3 36 ;' Return la dimensional notables 339 frrterprt'fulrnrr of art.
are satisJted
solution 340
8.2 Initial value problems: Periodic rases 346 Superposing solutions of exponential type 346 r Another way to write the real part of complex seams 349 r Satisfying .rural rorrditrous 352 8.3 Aperiodic initial values 354 Abandoning dimensionless r ariahlecs 354 , Solution Ha Fourier integrals 35s A yurllitath.e feature of the solution 3s9 i Superposition and the delta Junction 360
APPENDIX 8.1 Bessel functions 365
CHAPTER 9 GROUP SPEED AI1I7 GROUP VELOCITY 9.1 Group speed via the method of stationary phase 3 69 Needier are asymptotic approximation 369 i Stationary-phase approximation 3® Application of die r ppro_ imptïon 370 / Interpretation. Cutup .speed 374 Phase speed 375 Special conditions Hear extrema of group sly 377 I Some applications ter flow pan anodes 378
9.2 Experiments and practical applications 381 Experiments on the Collapse of a rectangular hump of Water 382: Comparison of theort and es rerimem 384 ! Practical application of theory 3 88
9.3 A kinematic approach to group velocity 391 Properties trf sfarf'ft Carving ware trains 392 j The phase junction in regions with an rarrveying number of naves 393 Integral and dir)ererruial expressions of stare rurrserrsJtion 395 i Group and phase refortir 39r5 f Energy propagation 397 I Asymptotic form of the surface: A terse derivation 1913
9.4 Ship, duck. and beetle waves 401 Catlsequerrers of steady* motion 403 / Steady waves induced bi' a point source 404 J Partial drff[^retrtial equation for the phase ji nctiorr 408 A PPENütX 9.1 The method of stationary phas e —An informal discussion 412 Motivation 412 j DrueJ4apnrent of a theorem 414 1 Heuristic derivation of rire
key approximation 415 f
GerrPralftatrort 416
xi v
Cantina
CHAPTER 10
ltii]NLINEAtt E FF EC TS
10.1 Formation of perturbation equations for traveling waves 418 Change of variables 419 / Consequence of traiwliny-wave assumption 420 Sertes solution 421 / Determination of succes_sic.e Sets of equations 422 / Remarks 425
10.2 Traveling finite amplitude waves 426 -
Izwest order equations 426 f Second order equations 428 I Normalization 43o /
Completion of second order calculations 43 r f Third order calculations 432 ir Discussion 434 / Resnnwrt ccue 436 / Near resonance 438 f Sperial resonant
solutions to cantpure with experiment 439 / Recapitulation 441 1 Fuld remarks - Formalism and rigor 442
PART D
V A RIATI O 1ti A L METHODS A N D EXTREMUM P R IItiCIPLES CHAPTER 1 CALCULUS OF VAR lATIQ]ItiS
11.1 Extre m a of a function—Lagrange multipliers 447 Unconstrained extrennplization of afurtction 4r}$ f Consrrained exrrerntalizQtion of a function 450 J inequality corrslramts 455
11.2 Introduction to the calculus of variations 461 The brach istocltrune 461 f A general extremdlizatiwr problem 462 j The Eider equation 463 f Natural boundary conditions 467 / Are solerrtarrs to the Euler eqrtatiorr Fxtrrrnuls? 471
11.3 Calculus of variations—generalizations 476 .4 More deritwtwes 476 f B. More functions 477 / C. More independent variables 478 ! D. Integral constraint 479 ! E. Furxttarraf r:onsrraint 48 r / F. End point free to move nn a gmerr curve 483 -
APPENDIX 11.1
Lernma A
496
A PPENI3IJt i1_2
Variational notation 497
CHAPTER 12
CHARACTERIZATION CF EIGENVAI.UPS AND EQUILIBRIUM STATES AS EXTREMA
12.1 Eigenvalues and stationary points Soo Three stationary value problems 5oa f A parti culier self-adjoint positive problem 5o2
C o n ter: ts
121 EigenvaIues as minima and the Ritz method
504
Motivation 504 / Specification of a linear operator Soli I The lowest eigenw due 5o9 f Higher eigenvahies5to 1 The Ritz method 513 / Validity and utility of the Ritz rNerhod 515 I Generalization 5 1 7 1 Example: Transverse vibrations of a tapered hollow beam 518 f Natural boundary conditions 521
12,3 The Courant maximum -minimum principle 528 A problem in vibration theory 52g l The max-rnin principle Sty f Application to the Ritz meihat1511
12.4 Minimal characterization of linear positive problems
531
Particle equilibrium as a minimum of porenrull energy 534 f The loaded membrane ç37 ! Equivalence of an inhornagE ntou.c equation and a noirrimizarion problem 539 / The Ritz nmerhod applied to the torsion problem 54 t A['PEN
nix l2. 1
Self adjouit operators on vector spaces 546 -
Reif vei for spaces 547 f Scalar products 549 / ,Linear self-adjoin! operators 55I f Eigenuahw problems 552 1 Positive operators 554 / flrlhnnnriial eherrunrs 556 f fnhornngeneaus problems 55g f Th e adjoins 560 f Borsch and Hither; spaces y62 i Completely emiirruous operators 56i
BIBLIOGRAPHY
57[
HINTS AND ANSWERS
579
INDEX
585
Fo r e w or d to the
Cl assi cs E dition
in the 196es, continuum mechanics was undergoing al revolution from :1 "feudal" science-1.4th fiefs of fluid mechanics, elasticity, and esoteric combinations of those sciences with eIectromagnetics —ta a "cosmopolitan' Ibpolit:an' uiencc consisting of a thtsmry of everything continuums. Love's Treatise un tiffe Mathematical Theory of Elasticity and Lamb's Hydrrniynatralics had brought rigor tua these areas, and Physilc articles rigori2ed the more abstract "rational Truesdl'twoHnhicer mechanics' approach. To further complicate matters . , Science was smarting to become computerized, with codes to approximate solutions TO incre Singly cuLnplcX problems. Against this backdrop, Lee Segel set out rra write a book for a course in applied mathematics at Rensselaer. The text for the first semester was Mathematics App! cd to Deterministic Problems in the Natural Sciences, also published by SIAM. The present volume was the text for the second semester of this course. As texts fier such a course, the first enjoyed more success than the second. This is [wanly because mathematics was starting to be applied to as wide spectrum of disciplines in the physical and social sciences and partly because continuum mechanics took on less of a role as a source for interesting and challenging ilia [LIMA kill problems. Still, in the decades since this book's first publication, ccmtinuulma approaches were attempted for the description of a multitude of mechanics prxobleins, ancluLling mixtures, reacting fltaails, heterogeneous solids, multiphase flows, and structureinteractions. Successful treatment of each added crlmplic.uions that required an understanding of the fundamentals of continuum mechanics that went beyond the manipulations required for describing Navrer—Stokes fluids or linear elasticity. This text possesses as quality that nukes it an important scientific tool that can he recommended to anyone interested in understanding tige vagaries of continuum mechanics. It is aimed at explaining the science of continuums mechanics with clarity winning out over rigor, with explanation and motivation cinphasi:ed over manipulation. This is a book from which it is possible to learn continuum mechanics. As such
it shares a niche with many others. both modern and classical. Fiut the student who uses this book to add understanding to a rigorous text will reach as transcendent appreciation of the science of continuum mechanics.
Donald Drew Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
Preface
1114 istext develops and uses mathematics la analyze cont uum models of
fluid flow and solid deformation. It is intended for upperlevcl undergraduates and graduate students in applied mathematics, science. and engineering: all of the material has been tested in various courses for such students. There is an emphasis on the process of achieving understanding, even at the expense of limiting the topics covered Although applied mathematics has flowered far from its original roots in physics, continuum mechanics remains a core course. One reason is that the concepts that theoreticians use to organize experience are developed most fully in classical subjects such as continuum rriechanics. Subjects of comparable depth -electromagnetism and quantum physics, for example—do not share with continuum mechanics a concentration on relatively familiar natural phenomena and therefore are not so well suited to the rapid development of physical intuition. Moreover, because it deals with problems that are at once deep and widely understandable, continuum mechanics has been for two centuries a major source of significant new applied mathematics. Boundary layer theory provides a paradigm for the development of a concept from one invented for a particular class of p roblems in continuums mechanics to one presently used in a wide variety of applications. Another example is provided by the study of water waves, which continues to stimulate the generation of new techniques for analyzing nonlinear partial differential equations. This volume is a sequel to C. C, Lin and L. A. Segel's Mathematics Applied to Deterministic Problems ïn the Natural Sciences (hereafter referred to as I). It is permeated with the spirit discussed in the preface of That work. In particular, a case-study approach is used, heurism dominates rigor, and brevity is sometimes sacrificed to permit depth of exposition. In I various ideas were introduced in extremely simple contexts, so that their essence could be clearly seen. The danger that these ideas would thus seem rather trivial is countered here by providing more realistic examples. To give one illustration, regular perturbation theory was introduced in I to approximate the solutions of simple algebraic and ordinary differential equations; in the present volume the theory is applied to the system of nonlinear partial differential equations with a "free" boundary that governs water waves. Material in I is a prerequisite for the present work only to the extent that here we assume familiarity with the basic mass and momentum conservation laws of continuum mechanics_ Remarks that refer to I can be skipped. .
xis
Preface
Various themes that appear there are taken up again here, but in a selfcontained fashion. There is no doubt, however, that background from I is useful here, for the totality of material in both volumes is designed to provide a thorough understanding of many topics. As in I, '`we have assumed that the potential reader has had an introductory college course in physics and is familiar with calculus and differential equations. . . . We make considerable use of such topics as directional derivatives, change of variables in multiple integrals, line and surface integrals, and the divergence theorem." Complex analysis is used in a few exercises and in Section 5.3. This volume is divided into four parts: A. Geometrical prerequisites for three-dimensional continuum mechanics_ B. Problems in continuum mechanics_ C. Water waves_ D. Cxtremum principles. The table of contents gives a more derailed outline. Part A features a careful discussion cf how the requirement that natural laws be "essentially the same" in different Cartesian coordinate systems leads to the introduction of Cartesian tensors_ The bulk of Part A is devoted to a fairly formal development of tensor algebra and calculus. Tensors are applied in Part B to derive the constitutive equations for viscous fluids and for linearly elastic solids. (For those who desire it, paths are indicated that reach these equations without the use of tensor machinery.) Boundary layer theory plays the central role in the discussion of viscous fluid motion. A variety of static and dynamic problems are available once the equations of elasticity haw been derived. The treatment of water waves in Part C provides the most detailed discussion in the text, The concept of group velocity plays a central part, and the role of nonlinearity is considered. Experimental verification of the theory is also discussed. In this area, therefore, the text brings the reader to the frontiers of modern research, Moreover, the material on elastic waves in Part B, taken together with that on water waves in Part C, provides at the same time an illustration of the unifying power of a single concept (wave motion), and also the refinements and modifications that are necessary when this concept is applied to different areas. The text concludes with a discussion in Parr I) of extremum principles, considered both as natural frameworks for physical laws and as bases for direct methods of computation. As Part D proceeds, simple concepts of functional analysis are introduced, since they form a natural language for
the discourse. There is considerable independence among the various parts and chapters. Part D, for example, can he begun at once, although knowledge of mechanics will lend urgency to some of the problems posed there. The material on
Preface
xxi
water waves (Part C) has as a prerequisite only the equations of incompressible inviscid fluid motion_ If one is willing to accept the governing equations more or less as axioms, much of the material on elasticity and fluid mechanics in Part B can be made quickly accessible_ Although the motivation for tensors in Chapter 1 requires knowledge of the stress tensor, if one is willing to forego extensive motivation it is possible to acquire the formal methods from Part A, Section 1.1, and Chapter 2. This book grew out of the course "Foundations of Applied Mathematics" introduced by G. 1i. Handelman at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute around 1957 and taught every year since then, many times by the author. (A precursor of this course was given by A. Schild and Handelman at Carnegie institute of Technology, now part of Carnegie -Mellon University.) Special thanks are due to Dr. Handelman, not only for his general influence, but also for his willingness to write most of the material in the chapters on elasticity. (The principal author is responsible for final editing.) Other writers, teachers, colleagues, and students have all been influential. Joseph plum, Paul Davis, Donald Drew, Eitan Klein, Simon lvloehon, William Siegmann, and Marc Triebitz have been particularly helpful with the present volume_ Many secretaries have given excellent service_ As was the case with I, the publishers, particularly editors Everett Smethurst and Elaine Wetterau, have provided first-rate assistance. Finally, help with the index and other last-minute editorial matters was provided by Joel, Susan, Daniel, and Michael Segel. The author was partially supported in 1968-1969 by a Leave of Absence Grant from Rensselaer. Further support was received during 1971-1972 from National Science Foundation Grant GP33679X to Rensselaer and from a John Simon Guggenheim Foundation Fellowship_ That year was spent as a visitor to the Department of Applied Mathematics, The Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot, Israel; the author joined this department in September 1973, but he retains an association with Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute. He is thus formally indebted to both institutions for support during years of on-and-off writing; the support was always generously given and the acknowledgment is correspondingly warm_ L. A_ S.
C onventions
F
ACH chapter is divided into several sections (e.g., Section 5.2 is the second section of Chapter 5). Equations are numbered consecutively within each section_ Figures and tables are numbered consecutively within each chapter. When an equation outside a given section is referred to, the section number precedes the equation number. Thus " Equation (6.3.2)" refers to the second numbered equation of Section 6.3. Hut if this equation were referred to within Section 1 of Chapter 6, then the chapter number would he assumed and the reference would be to "Equation (3.2)," The fourth numbered equation in Appendix 3.1 is denoted by (A3. I.4). A double dagger (I) preceding an exercise, or a part thereof. signifies that a hint or an answer will he found in the back of this volume. The symbol L] signifies that the proof of a theorem has concluded. The preceding volume is referred to as "1." A brief bibliography of useful references (some repeated from E) can be found at the end of this volume. When one of these books is cited, the style "Smith (1970)" is employed_
1%; X1.11.
PA RT A Geometrical Prerequisite s for Three-Dimensional Continuum Mechanics
1 Vectors, Determinants, and Motivation for Tensors CHAP1 ER
T
ENSORS have both computational and conceptual value. We try to illustrate both aspects in Part A. We begin Chapter 1 with a review of vectors which emphasizes that more than direction and magnitude characterize these entities. In a consideration of how vector components transform when different Cartesian coordinate syslerns arc used, we introduce a standard summation convention that makes the required formulas more condensed and hence more manageable. Determinants are developed in a computational fashion with the aid of the alternating symbol. Most readers will be familiar with at least the principal results, but the alternating symbol is intrinsically worth studying, and it provides an approach to determinants that should he new and appealing. We make contact with the central content of the chapter when we turn to a detailed discussion of the fact that physical laws cannot intrinsically depend on the coordinate system used. From this discussion we are able to provide strong motivation for the definition of a tensor. An optional section provides another motivation, based on the connection between tensors and linear transformations. We consider only Cartesian tensors, which means that only Cartesian coordinate systems are allowed. Generalization re f our considerations are possible and useful, but they are beyond the scope of this book.
1.1 Vectors in a Cartesian Coordinate System, Transformation of Vector Components, and the Summation Convention Recall that a Cartesian coordinate system is based on tfsrec mutually perpendicular coordinate planes. These intersect in three mutually perpendicular lines called the x,-, x 2-, and x raxes, A positive direction is assigned to each axis. The coordinate system is called right- (left-)handed if the third finger of the right (left) hand points in the positive x 3 -direction when the thumb and index finger are pointed in the positive x i - and x 1 -directions,
respectively. As shown in Figure 1.1, a point P can be reached by following three displacements GA, AB, and BP parallel to the three coordinate axes. Select a unit of length_ If these displacements (positive or negative) have the 3
4
Vectors, Determinants, and Morivarion for Tensors [Ch. 1 s2
^r u
A
x3
FIGURE 1.1 _ Any paint F ran be reached by rhree displacements that are parallel ta the coordinate axes.
measured values x i , x2 , and x3 , respectively, then the coordinates of the point P are (x i , x2 , x 3). The distance OP is given by (xi + xx + x3)'12. Unit coordinate vectors ell), etas, and et' ) point along the respective axes. The above material wiilI be familiar to the reader, but we wish to emphasize that some fundamental assumptions are implied, Le., that we curt find three mutually perpendicular lines and that the law of Pythagoras holds. By contrast, on a spherical surface great circles play the role of lines. We can find mutually perpendicular great circles through any one point, but the taw of Pythagoras does not hold for distances measured along great circles. Although we can always conceive of a Cartesian coordinate system, the fact that we can use it to describe the space of our common experience is an experimental fact; i.e., we must verify experimentally that Pythagoras's theorem holds. Thus, in Figure 1.2, since OB _ OC and AB = AC, we should have 0A 2 } 0B2 = AB 2 and OC 2 + 0A 2 = AC 2 . If these relationships can be verified, we speak of the space as Euclidean. otherwise as nonEuclidean.* PROJECTION
A fundamental relationship in the Cartesian coordinate system is the rule of projection. if PQ is a displacement with components (u, u, w) and RS is a line with direction at angles (a, fl, y) to the coordinate axes, then the * The Euclidean nature of the space of common expetieucc has primarily been established indirectly by the agreement between observation and multitudes of theoretical predictions whose derivation assumes that space i Euclidean.
Set. 1.
i] vec tors in a Cartesian Coordinate System
5
A
FIGURE 1.2. Measurements on a construction of this sort con Ha principle be used in an effort in frird out whether or not "real" space is Euclidean. lidean.
projection of YÇ on RS is a COS tx f t' cos }.i + iv cos y.* This is a familiar result, but it is not trivial when the lines PQ and RS are skew to each tither. Readers should demonstrate this to their own satisfaction ]Exercise 1). We shall now use the rule of projection to study how components change when new axes are selected. A change of axes may result in a simplification of some problems - this is sufficient reason to study such changes, but there are more fundamental reasons, too, as we shall see. TRANSFORMATION OF COORDINATES—GFOMFTRtt' APPROACH
Consider two sets of Cartesian axes, primed and uriprimeci, with common origin O (Figure 1.3). I_,et a displacement OF have components (A ,, - 2 , A 3 ). Y^
ri ^
ir
e^
FIGURE 1.3. Two sets of Cartesian axes. rotated with respect to one another_ Either can be used to describe the drsplucernent P • We remind the reader that the projection of a point Pon RS is the rntcrsectiort c]t RS with the perpendicular dropped From P crnrp RS. The projection of f 2 is the union cif the prnjeriions of its points.
â
Vectors, Derermitrarrrs, anti Motivari ri
for Tensors ( h_
!
Denote the projection of a Y on the x'c -axis by x', , and so on. By the above rule of projection, xi =x l cos (x r ,x'r )+x i cos (x 2 ,x'r )+x 3 cos (x,,x r ), where (x; , x:) - (xt, x,) is the angle between the positive x ;-direction and the positive 3(i-direction. In general, 3
x; = ^ x; [ os (xi. xi),
j= i,2,3.
( 1 )
i= i
For the inverse transformation, the rule of projection* yields
X; : / x s
cos Wit , x;),
i
= t, 2 , 3.
(2)
This must be compatible with (1). To show that this is so, we substitute (I) into (2), obtaining 3 3 Xi =
EI 14E x k cos (xk , x j) cos (X j, x;).
j-
But l
E cos (xi, x^) cos (x^ , x^) ^ t i}
if i = k 1, k -=1,2,3; if i # k,
(3)
since the sum is merely the projection of a unit displacement along x i upon the xk-axis. By (3), then, we have the identity x ; T x; verified for each i.
NOTATION
The preceding calculations are simple examples of a type of manipulation that is very often encountered_ Experience indicates that the following new notational conventions, once they have been mastered, shorten and clarify the formulas_ iu a given equation, an index (subscript or superscript) is called a dummy if it is used in a summation_ Other indices are called free_ In (3), 1 and k are free subscripts and j is a dummy subscript. Range convention A free index takes on the values 1, 2, 3. The same free indices must appear in each term of an equation. • Equations (I) and (2) can easily be derived akgcbraicatly (Exercise 2).
See. 1.11
Verfors in a Carresian Coordinate System
7
Summation canventioo No index wiérthe written more than twice in a single term.* Suppose that an index, say t, appears twice ill a single term. Then the symbol , ws11 he terni_ understood to precede that From now on we shall use the range and summation eont.enfions unless an expficir stalemerit is made to the contrary. For example, instead of 3
X Tn
=
3
E E A+„ra Y
n = l, 2, 3,
pq,
P"-t Y'-t
we shall writs
X ,.n =
A.,,
Yp4
The same free subscripts, rn and it are used on both sides of the equation. The subscripts p and q are repeated, so that summation is implied_ Two special abbreviations occur repeatedly. The Kronecker delta is defined by ,
f,
r = jw
(4)
}.
The transformation symbol is defined by
r ; , = cos (x ;, x;).
(5)
Using these definitions and the summation convention, we see that (1) to (3) can be written briefly as
By the same reasoning as that used to obtain (8), we also have
(9)
[P,i fj& = ,
Readers should satisfy themselves before going further that because of our various definitions and conventions, the following four equations convey ' Vio &atiort of this requirement is [he biggest single cause of the errors !hat beginners make in manipulations involving the summation convention_
Vectors, Dewr'minants, and Motivation for Tensors 10.
precisely the same information, respectively, as the four equations just written
Readers will also find it helpful in rapidly acquiring familiarity with the conventions if they expand some of the compactly written formulas below_ Note that fix ^ try , in general. To remember the definition (5), memorize: The second subscript goes with the prime. The same phrase makes it easy to remember the transformation laws (6) and (7) and to avoid errors in future formulas. In 0), for example, the dummy subscript i appears an the unprimed quantity xi . Since the second subscript goes with theprirne, the first subscript of must also be i, The free subscript j is associated with the primed components on the left side of (6) and with the second {primed} position in ir.f As our first new calculation using the summation convention, we shall verify that the distance between two points is invariant under a rotation of axes. The distance d between two points P and Q is given ven b . (
d 2 = [ r(Q)
xi(P)]1xi(Q)
v
xr(P)].
In the new coordinate system, we have
l02 = [xiQ) — xi(P}] [x (Q) — x;(p)] = [xi(Q) -- xr1 11](1J[xk(Q) — xi,(P)Y1,By use of (fi) we sec that Lk;(Ql — 'c,{Pn L-xk(Q) — Adfl]r 5a.
( 10)
Only terms when k = r need be retained in (10), since /5 ;t = 0 when k # i, so one can write either = rx,(Q)
xr(P}7
- x.(P)1
The changes that have been made arc as follows - (i) the order of multiplying the real numbers .x ; and r,,, has been reversed, compared with (6): Iii) the free subscript i of (7t' has had its ''name" changed top (a permissible change.sinee it does not violate the rule against writing an index more than twice in a single tcrml; (iiit t he dummy suhstnpt ; of (4t' has had its "name changed to Q la permi+sibtc clhangrh and Iiv) in j9), both the dummy subsctipl j and the free subscripts t and k have been changed in a permissible way. ¶ There is a notation for the transformation symbol with which one does not have so irinembei that the second subscript goes with the prime hecausc the order 01 subscript's is immaterial In this notation cos tx„ xi') _ t r.; '_ +' ir . Because she extra primes are a bit burdensome and because a departure from coiltventionatitycreates 50111e confusion, + 10c shall nut adopt this notation here, but we do recommend it as intrinsically superior -
See_ t-)? Vecrors in a Currestan Coordinate SySIe»r
9
or
(c01 — [xk( 12) — xi,(P)7 kk(Q) xi(P)),
so that (d']^ = d 2 . VECTORS— ALGE B RAIC POINT OF VIE.1+V
Consider the position coordinates x ;c of a particle in motion so that x k = fk(r), where r is the time. In another coordinate system, the position will be given by x; gjt), i-e-, x1
- /k j fk( 1) _ gp{r )-
=
The velocity of the particle is = h(r)
in the xk-system
=
in the x,`.-system.
.
and j{r)
(Here - Or) Thus. from ( l 1), f; — f^}vk •
Multiply by /,) (and sum): — ^ ï ^iv y", =
=
Vf
We see that the transformations linking the velocity components o f and v1 arc the same as the transformations (6) and (7) for the displacement components_ We thus designate as vectors quantities x whose components x ; to (6) and (7). We speak of the displacementandxftrsomcig rector, the velocity vector, and so on Similarly, acceleration is a vector, since
= O r) = ki(r). Thus a vector" is an entity that is associated with three components in any Cartesian coordinate system. The components Li ; and v; in two coordinate systems are linked by the relations ti ;
âl;
t1ït
;,
.
(12)
11v and w arc vectors with components v i and w ; in some coordinate system, their sum v + w is defined as the entity with components ti ; + w 1 . If c is a real number, the scalar multiple or is the entity with components ct7 ; . It is easy to show that the sum of two vectors is a vector, as is the scalar multiple of a vector.
to
Vectors, Deterrrtinonrs, and Motivation for Îensora
[C h .
r
VECTORS--GEOMETRIC POINT OF VIEW
In showing above that 112 (d') 2 , we have verified that if Uk are the components of any vector, then its m ag nitude t , = (r*vk)t"2 is invariant under a rotation of axes. If z 0, then t r /v are the components of a dIrection vector or unit vector, which has unit magnitude . The geometric picture of a vector as an arrow (indicating magnitude and direction) implicitly assumes the validity of the operations used in an algebraic treatment, namely, (1) the decomposition into components along mutually perpendicular coordinate axes, and (ii) the addition of components along the axes to determine the resultant sum of two vectors. The correct geometrical description of vector that makes these assumptions explicit is as follows: .4 vector is a quantity with direction rind magnitude_ The sim of ewes vectors is determined by the parallelogram luR'. It can easily be shown that this geometric description is equivalent to the algebraic definition given above. To show that a vector sum requires the addi ti on of components, one simply projects the parallelogram along the three coordinate axes (Exercise 3). Note that quantities with equal direction and magnitude (which follow the parallelogram law) are regarded as the same vector. Also recall that from the geometric point of view, the scalar multiple cv is a vector with a magnitude I c i times the magnitude of if and a direction the same as (opposite to) that of v if r is positive (negative). The geometric point of view is useful in furnishing a proof of the following important result_* Theorem I. Let IL .j denote the determinant of the transformation matrix L with components f, i . Then )LI = + l if the primed and un1 primed systems are both right-handed or both left-handed, and I LI = if one system is right-handed and the other left handed_ Proof f Let us work in the primed coordinate system, which we assume for the moment to be right-handed. We can regard the kth row of the transformation matrix to be formed of the components of the unit coordinate vector etk', for —
-
et° = ccje&1
implies that
Hence the components
e ,t . eta = t.kieui - et =s = rio it = C. k , .
are just the t k; , for (5) certainly implies that coo. ti', I (13)
Thus by a standard vector theorem I L I = et . em A e{3 ",§ so that I LI has a magnitude equal to the volume of the rectangular parallelepiped spanned by et1), e12}. and e" ), and has a positive or negative sign depending on whether • Another proof is given in Example 1.2.4, 'r An algebraic proof is provided in Example 4 of the next section. 4 We use the symbol A to denote cite vector product_
Sec- . J - f 1
Vectors in a Cartesian Coordinate
Si Stmt
ti i
these vectors form a right- or left-handed system. in the present case this parallelepiped is a unit cube, so that the theorem is proved when the primed coordinate system is right-handed. Completion or the proof is left for Exercise 4. a REMARK. If the transformation between two Cartesian coordinate systems does not involve a reflection, the transformation is called a proper rotation. Otherwise the rotation is impropm, In this terminology. Theorem 1 stales that {
L
—I
for proper- rotations, for improper rotations.
14
Note that evert, vector /ras a direction cout a xntetyrtitrtde but that the converse is not true. For example, the finite rotation of a rigid body about a lixed axis can be specified by a direction and a magnitude. It is natural to represent such a rotation by an arrow with the specified dircx-tton and magnitude. But if we do this. we find t hat the deco mposition into components has no meaning. Consider, for example, the rotation of the unit square OABC through an angle oC (n/2) ,1`2 radians 130 about the GB axis seeFigure 1.4). The "natural" representation of this rotation is an arrow R along 0E with length {rrf2) J2. if R is a vector, its components must be vectors along the x- and y-axes, each of length rr f 2. But these hypothetical component vectors correspond to rotating the square rtj2 radians about OX and then rr/2 radians about O Y. leaving the square perpendicular to the plane. Obviously, the sum of these two components does not represent the same rotation as R. even though their vector sum is R. Thus the concept of component does not apply to a finite rotation; a
{
r1
F LGt; Rf t . 4_ The arro w
a
R provides u natural
represetlrarlQf7 for rotati on of
the squar e ()ABC.' about the fine UR, through an angle (1t{20, The direction (0]12. 8ut R is not a of R u indirrlrerl, and it magnitude should eabvioiesfe vector_
12
Vei tors, Dererrnir vats, oiid Morivariurl for Tenors
[Ch. I
rotation cannot be represented by a vector even though it has a direction and magnitude. See Exercises 5 and 2.6 for further information about finite rotations. KEVIEw OF LINEAR DEPENDENCE
Each vector V satisfies V = Yet l1 + V2 e(21+ 1/3031 where el" represents a unit vector in the direction of the xk-axis. The question may be asked: if we choose three arbitrary vectors AL, A2, and A3, is it possible to find three constants (c t , c^ c 3 ) such that an arbitrary vector V is expressible in the following form? V = ci A ; .
(I5)
Let the components of A ; be denoted by A ir . Since two vectors are equal if and only if their components are equal, the answer to our question depends on the solution to the linear system of equations C1A11 + C2AL2 + C3A13 s Vi , CLA21 + C2 A22 + c3A23 —
(16)
C 1 A 3L + c2A32 + C3A33 ` V3e
with the coefficient matrix
A
= (
AL1 Al2
A 13
An
A23 •
A32
A3i A32 A33
The reader will doubtless recall that if the determinant IA I of the matrix A does not vanish, then (16) has exactly one solution for the uriirnowns c t ,c 2I c3 , and hence there is a unique representation_ Otherwise, this is not the Case. If I AI = O, then thereexists at least oneset ofconstanis (c 1 , c 2 , c j ) # (0, Q. 0) such that c i A r =D
,
(17)
where the zero vector 0 has components (0, 0, 0) in any coordinate system. If (l7) hoIds, the vectors A, arc said to be linearly dependent. If I A # 0, they are said to be linearly independent. Any vector can be represented as a linear combination of three linearly independent vectors. When three vectors arc linearly dependent, we may express one of them as a linear combination of the other two, e.g_, A2 = ^LA t + k 3A3 -
Sec. 1.1]
Vet-tors in a Cartesian Coordinate
Svswm
t3
if one constructs the triangle of Figure 1.5 to represent the sum above, it is evident that the plane containing A, and A.3 must also contain A. . Three linearly dependent vectors are coplanar.
FIGURE 1. 5. A t , A2 , and A ! are linearly dependent, Therefore, flier
are
coplanar.
EXERCISES
:1. Demonstrate the projection rule discussed ai the beginning of the section, t2. [Derive (I) and (2) algebraically, starting with the relation x fee" = 3. Show that the "parallelogram law" of vector addition impliescomponeniwise addition, and conversely. 4. Complete the proof of Theorem I. 5. Let x be transformed into y by a right-handed iotatton through au angle O. The axis of rotation is given by a unit vector n. Show that
y— x =
(1 — cos (J)[x
—
(x • n)nl t sin Oiri n x).
6. (a) Simplify the result of Exercise 5 when [1 is small, to obtain
y- x='O A (b)
wherc6 -fln.
According to parr (a), what is the result of two successive small rotations? What does this imply about the possibility of specifying small rotations by a vector? (c) How small does B have to be for the formula of part (a) to give 10 per cent accuracy? $7. (a) Write down the matrix L for the coordinate transformation obtained by rotating 180C about the x 3 -axis. (See Figure 1.6.) (b) Calculate (and check by using common sense, which makes the answer obvious)the new components of a vector having components at in the old system. $S. 1f A„ A: and A are the components of a vector with respect to three different Cartesian coordinate systems, prove that the values of A are the same whether (ï) one transforms A i into A: directly or (ii) one transforms A i into A, and then A' into A . ,
14
vectors, Determinants, and Motivation for Tensors [Ch. I
Fi Ou RE 1_6. The prtl ►ird cuordenate system is rotated 180- with respect tu rite
r€ 3 -ttxis_
eurpmd,aboth
9. Consider the numbers 25
-9 25
3 5
4 5
B
—16 25
12 25
3 5
12
4
5
(a)
By verifying (8) and (9), show that I. can be considered a matrix describing the transformation between Ca rtesian coordina te systems rotated with respect to each other. (b) Point P has coordinates (0, 1, —1) in the unprimed system. What are its coordinates in the pruned system? (e) Show that 2x6 —Ix2+x3= I and %Ix, t i x 2 — 151 x 3 = 5 describe the same plane. 10. (a) Explain why the usual geometrical definition of a "vector product" of two vectors A and B yields a vector. (b) Explain why one does riot get a vector if the magnitude AB sin f] is replaced by ABeos 6 or AB sin 20. Substantiate your discussion with detailed calculations.
1.2 Determinants and the Permutation Symbol As was illustrated twice in the previous section. a number of mathematical problems reduce to questions wherein determinants play an important role_ Although readers will be familiar with at least the main results from the
Sec. 1.2J
Deae•rrninaarias and aht• Perarruaarrorr Symbol
15
theory of determinants, it is appropriate here to sketch that theory starting with first principles. The mode of presentation, via the permutation symbol rill,(to be defined below), will be new to many. Even leaving aside its value in determinant theory, the permutation symbol must become an object of familiarity, for it is used repeatedly in the remainder of the chapter. in particular, although the proofs of the main properties of determinants (Theorems 2 to 8) may be omitted, the "ed" rule of Theorem 1 l must be mastered. A somewhat abstract approach is now commonly used in introducing determinants, particularly to mathematicians but increasingly to engineers and physicists as well. For example, the important theorem that the determinant of the product of two matricesequals the product of their determinants is arrived at by the use of elementary row and column operations, expressed with the aid of elementary matrice& l lere we take a direct computational approach, as is perhaps fitting for applied mathematicians. The simplicity of notation allowed by the summation convention and the compact storage of information in the permutation symbol, however, give the direct treatment an unexpected elegance. In the remainder of the book we shall only need results for 3 by 3 determinants and the corresponding three-subscripted alternating symbol. We shall restrict our presentation accordingly. Nevertheless, it should be clear that generalization to n by n determinants is almost immediate. TH E PERMUTATION SYA7BO1.
Definition I. (a) A permutation of a list of integers is a listing of these integers in another order. Example; (312) is a permutation of (123) (b) A transposition is a special permutation in which two adjacent integers are interchanged. Example: (132) is a transposition of (312) in which the first two integers are interchanged. (c) A permutation is said to be even (odd) if it can be accomplished by an even (odd) number of transpositions. Example: (312) is an even permutation of (123) because it can be accomplished by two transpositions, as follows: (312) —' (132) —, (123). The trivial permutation (123) — (123) is even, because it can be accomplished by zero interchanges, or two [(123) (213) (I23)]. (d) The cyclic permutations of (123) are (123), (231), and (3E2). Cyclic permutations of (123) can be obtained by picking three consecutive integers from Figure I.7, proceeding in the clockwise direction. The anticyclic permutations of (123), namely (132). (213), and (321), can be obtained by proceeding in the counterclockwise direction. As the reader can easily show, all cyclic permutations are even, all anticyclic pe rmutations are odd. In Definition lc we have implicitly assumed that any permutation can be accomplished by a succession of transpositions and that all such successions which accomplish a given permutation are either even or odd. For proofs that these reasonable assumptions are valid, see texts on algebra such as .
16
Vectors, Determinants, and AMutivazion for Tensors [Ch. 1 p,nlicycii c
FIGURE 1.7. The cyclic and anticyclic
perrnularte3n s
F. W. Ficken, Linear Transformations and Matrices Prentice-Hall, 1967), Chap_ 4, Sec. E.
of th e first three integers -.
(Englewood Cliffs, N.J.:
Definition 2. The permutation symbol or alternator • 1, j, k = l, 2, 3, has 27 values, one for each of the 27 ordered sets of subscripts. These are defined as follows: E;pi
if two of the integers ï, j, k are equal,
-û
—.7
or if all three are equal, 1
(1)
if (i}k) is an even permutation of (123),
—I
if WO is an odd permutation of (123).
The following relations are almost obvious_ Formal proof is left to the reader. = - F:JikT
f; lk} - - F,i1k ,
&ï}k =
(2a, h) (3)
1.14i•
❑ LTFRMINANTS
Throughout this section, A and B will denote the matrices
A„
A 1z A13
A 2L
An A2.i
A3l
A32 A.33
PL [ PL2 PLI
B,
and (
B22 S23 -
B_ll B32 B33
We wish to associate a certain number with a 3 by 3 matrix like A, called its determinant. We shall use the notations det (A) or IA I or sometimes det (A1).
Sec. 1.21 Determinants and the Permutation Symbol Definition 3 IA
I
-E
17
01 4 iO4 2, A 3k -
1
(4)
To make sure that the reader has grasped the meaning of the permutation symbol, we shall write out the nonzero terms_ There are
IAI
t123A11A22A33 + t312A13A21A32 + E231Al2A23A31
+
E321A13 44 22
A ]1
32.411,423 A32 + 6 213Al2A21A33
` A 11 A 22 A 33 + A13A21A32 + Al2A23A]1 — A13422 A 31 —
A11
Az3
Theorem 1
A32 — Al2A21A33•
r
iAl = ^U ■ ArlAl2A k3
(5)
An alternative statement of the theorem is IA TT ] — A I, where A Tr is the transpose of A. Outline Cf proof. Corresponding, say, to the term !;231 A l2A23A31 in (4) is the term e312 A31A 1 z A23 in (5). Both terms consist of a product of the same A's, but what of their sign? The sign depends on the parity (evenness or
oddness) of the subscripts not in their natural order. That this is the same for both terms can be seen by noting that the number of interchanges required is the same as the number of interchanges necessary to change one order of the A's into the other. For example, in the present case. two interchanges are required: A 12A23A31'"' Al2A31A23+•
A31A1zA23.
Reading from left to right, we see that these two interchanges put the second subscripts into natural order: (231) - (213) —' (123). Reading from right to left, we see that two interchanges also put the first subscripts into natural order: (312) --. (132) ' (123). C -
Theorem 2. If B is the same as A except for the interchange of a pair of rows or columns, then IA I=— I B I. Proof. Suppose that B is obtained from A by the interchange of the first two rows so that B2, = A1f,
B11 —
A21, B31 = A31-
Then
EincAliA2JA3k , where in the last step we have interchanged the dummy subscripts i and j. The theorem follows by (2a). The same reasoning holds(Thisoftenul.) in the other circumstances. 0 IBI = EB i.
B B 3J<
E iik
A 2, A 1j A 3k =
18
Vectors, Determinants, and i4lotiixrtion Or Tensors [Ch, !
Theorem 3. If A has two identical rows or two identical columns, then J l = O. Proof. Interchange the identical rows or columns. The resulting matrix is unchanged and therefore has the sar -nc determinant as A, but by Theorem 2 its determinant is also — A. U
Theorem 4. If' B is the same as A except that a row or column of B is a multiple c of the corresponding row or column of B, then 181= r'IAI Proof: Left to the reader. Theorem S. If B the same as A except that the jth row (column) of B jth row (column) of A plus a multiple of the kth row (column) ofequalsth A. k j, then IB1 1AI. Proof Left to the reader. Definition 4. The minor M t of an element A ;i is the determinant of the matrix formed by deleting the ith row and jth column of A. The corresponding cofactor C';, is defined by [.'t, _ (
Theorem 6 (The Cofactor Expansion of a Determinant)_ of this theorem we do not use the summation convention,
in the statement
3 IA I =
Ai C i1 .
t—
1, 2, 3,
J -1
(6a, b)
3
1A1 = ^ A^^^: i= l
j
= I,
2, 1
Outline of Proof. The idea is to write out one of the sums in (4) or (5). For example, writing out the t-summation in (5), we find that
l AI = Ar[ F= i
A j2 Ak3 +
Az1C2jk A }z AA] + A 31 E 3.04 A riA^3
-
The factors of A L ,, A 2 L , and A 3L arc readily recognized as the appropriate for an expansion along the first column. We leave the full proof to cofatrs the reader. 0 Theorem 7. (We again employ the summation convention.) A3C
= IAIbr; ,
A ; t`^; t = I A i vf •
(7a, 13)
For (la), if p = i, we have a restatement of (6a). lip # [, the left zero, for it is the cofactor expansion of the determinant of a sideof(la) matrix whose pth and ith rows are identical. This follows from the fact that the elements of a given row of a matrix never appear in the cofactors of that row, since it is always deleted. h Proof.
Sec _ J_2) Deferminarit.5 arid the Permidtatiun Svnrbn!
4
Theorem S (Cramer's Rule).
Given the linear equations A ii xi = b, with coefficient matrix A, we have
(8)
I A ix; = b,C., k .
(9)
If TA l is nonzero, we can divide by it and obtain a unique solution to (8). If I AI = 0, there is no solution unless b,C kk = O. Note that the same reasoning as was used in Theorem 7 shows that the right side of f9) is the expansion of Dk I, where R k is a matrix that is identical with the coefficient matrix A except that its kth column is composed of the "right-side - elements h 1 , h z . and b } . Proof. We multiply the ith equation of (8) by the cofactor C E, for some fixed k, and sum en is CrkAi i X j
The result follows at once from (7h). [1 Theoremt 9 A A AA r = r oc A, ; AA .A •
F„,I Al
^.
{
1Qa, b)
Proof_ To prove (10a), we Erst note that unless r i s, and t are all different, the right side is the determinant of a matrix with at least two identical columns and so is zero by Theorem 3_ The left side is zero in this case by the definition of the alternating symbol_ If (rsr) — (123), then (10a) is just (5)_ If (rsr) is an even (odd) permutation of (123), the right side is therleternhirslnt of a matrix which differs from A by an even (odd) number of column interchanges and so equals (minus) I AF by Theorem 2. So does the left side. [I Corollary
I ABI = I/1)1Bi. Proof:
Left to the reader,
Illeurem 10
1
,14,
Al
A„
.
Air A la
A jr
A ka
Air
A t
=
t., ik f.
qr I A I .
41 1)
Suppose that at least two of the integers (ijk) are equal, or that at least two of the integers (pqr) arc equal_ Then the determinant on the left of (1 I) has at least two rows which are equal or two columns which are equal_ In such a case, both sides of l 1 I) equal zero. if (ijk) _ (I23), the determinant on the left of (1 l) differs from] A I because of an even (odd) number of column interchanges if (pq) is an even (odd) permutation of (123), The validity of (1 1) in this case follows from Theorem 2, as it does when (ijk) is a permutation of (123. n
Proof.
20
Vectors, Determinants, and Motivation for Tensors (Ch. 1 THE "ED" RULE
Theorem 11
I 8ilk ep4k Proof.
64'6" — 45' 15 jP .
(i2)
From Theorem 10 with r = k and A i, = ai f , 64 5i& eiit e P4k = (5}p bie a fr akp a kq kJ, vip
Expanding the determinant by its third row, we find that
big bik I ei,«epqk
bkp
°It q
Alp alp
6a + a aip a,^ kx ik 6h, b k ^
( 13) ^ bro 6ip 6,01^Je
bip 1 664 1 +3 .o 6k 6.4alp 64 afil
Interchanging the columns of the first determinant in (13) gives the desired result: b;p S;q ^'ke^k = b a lp
= b ;p ô;^
— a ^ bJp . Q
„^
As stated in (3), a cyclic permutation of subscripts does not change the sign of the alternator. Hence we can write (12) in various ways by performing a cyclic permutation of subscripts on either or both alternators: Eilk £kp4
—
Ei.AEpQk — 8kiiEkpq — E1ki4kp — a4 15 l4 — (5 44 6 1p"
(l 4)
We shall term this remarkably useful formula the a rule (pronounced "ed"rule). The eb rule is well worth remembering, but it is better to remember it in a form that is independent of a particular choice of letters for subscripts. To accomplish this, ignore the dummy subscript. [In (12), ignore kJ If "first," "second," "inner," and "outer" subscripts are labeled as on the left side of Figure I.S, then subscripts on A are (first) (second)-(outer) (inner), as on the right side of Figure E.S. Readers should satisfy themselves that this scheme produces the correct formula for all cases of (14). We shall now give some examples that show the efficiency of expressing determinants by means of the alternator and the usefulness of the eb rule. More examples will be given in the section on tensor fields and in the exercises.
Sec. I.2J
Zi
Defermrniaills and the f erniumtton Symbol
tUuicr l
I
I
,
e^}x
^^
#
t
^^ _ 6ip
^
^^
^
SUl{ , i1111
—1
trIrst1
^
(
^ 6119
iL I [tr
Ir tier
`
IS r L unJ!
F I u LI R L
i4fnenlwric diagram for the - ed - rule.
Example 1. let a, t1, and c be vectors with components a,. h ; and
c, relative to a triad of base vectors r [". Express the vector and triple scalar pi oduL Ls using the permutation symbol. Solutier (151
bA C
a' (b
A
C) —
r_,jr 1ei}11 i .
t,161
"fhesc Fr rmtil:is tC}IInii' directly from wetl-known connections between the left - hdrid ^
sides of (l5) and (16) and cleterrninanls. It is often more convenient to use the notation (th component oft = Ft],
(17)
10 Write 1_1) A c], = r:,r hi t,.
(
lS)
Example 2. Prove that (a A b) A e — (a • clti — fh • c)a.
SOlution.
119)
Using (ta) twice. we obtain [[u A h) Ae
]^
— Lm
k[t Rle -
(20)
The f:b rule cannot yet be applied iinrncdialely because the dummy subscript :appears second in i:m but appears first in r..; [compare (14)]. Therefore, we iiarlspose subscripts before applying the rule. , o
[{a Jti b) A clm = —(.f y it Î1R rt, -
-
— (6„,160 -. 6.,.ih,p)arhscr -
u+Rhvr'v t b,„ ur {'r
- -- (h • c )[a]m + (■ • cl[b]#
Example 3. Lei position x depend on the in i tial position A at turne r. Find a compact formula foi the time derivative of the J; eobiari J - el(x i . x z . x j )likei ti , 4 _ , A3)-
22
Vectors,
,Solution.
Dew-minions, and Motivation for Tensors [Ch_ 1
The Jacobian determinant can be written r7x, E iik
—
ex3 r7x 3 —
—
OA , r? A J OA k
(2t)
.
so (using the rule for differentiating products) J
a,, ax, ax3 eA f dA $rl, + ...
= —
^
Here and in the following discussion, we shall not write Oil t two additional terms whose form is obvious by symmetry. Introducing the velocity = k,. we have, by the chain rule,' _ El 3v 1 dxD ^x^ dx^ J ^ N $xD ÔAt aAJ PAk +
l+^ tl t ,J + = f^xp
...^
where we have used Theorem 3. [fence
1-1 = rv'v )IJ.
( 22)
Example 3 provides an elegant proof of formula (13.4.11) of I , which is essential in the study of kinematics.
Example 4. Let ILI denote the determinant of the transformation matrix I. (with components I"). Use the results of the present section to show that I LI — 1 for proper rotations, ELI = —1 for improper rOlationS. Chant of Solution [An alternative proof of (I.14). Also see Exercise 14]. Fut = fo in 010h) and multiply by I t 141I 1." I ^!'Y 17Y/IM = ^7^ ^ R ^ nil Orr S./ 11 Il^^w•
Using (10a) and (1.9), we deduce that ei, 6 ,.,
f
f w = rti^ w ,
so I L ! ' =
But I/.I is a continuous function of the elements of the transformation matrix L. Also. jf = 1 for the identity transformation (wherein e,,— S;;) by direct computation, and therefore for all proper rotations by continuity. Improper rotations have ILA = —1, for they can be obtained by continuous transformation after the particular reflection wherein
0
U
—
1
• As required by the chain rule (compare Appendix 13.1 of I), the vertical line indicates that the sutrsritution r = x(A. t) must be made a fter the partial differentiation_
Sec_ 1_3) Th e Consistency Requirement
23
E XLRCl4F. R
1. Prove that cyclic (anticyclic) permutations are even (odd)-
2. Prove (2) and (3). 3. (a) Prove Theorem I by writing out the terms. (b) Prove Theorem 4, 4. (a) Prove Theorem 5_
(b) (c)
Complete the proof of Theorem 6. Prove the Corollary of Theorem 9. 5. Formalize the continuity arguments that were used to complete the solution of Example 4. $6. Write the result of Exercise 1.5 in the form y. = R i x } . This shows that a nine-component entity is needed to represent a finite rotation. A study of how such components change when new coordinates are introduced will lead us to the concept of a tensor) 7, Lei Y = a A b_ Use the permutation symbol to show that (a) 1 v 1 2 2 IbI 2 sin 2 fi;(b)v•a =0, v• b=0. fa1 Verify that the (f rst)(secon(1)-(outer)(inner) scheme is correct for all eases of(14). 9. Use the Eh rule to determine an expansion of a n (b A e).
10. Show that la A bj 2 = 1aI 2 1b1 2 - (a -11)2. 11- Show that (a n b) • (c A d) _ (a - c)(b • d) — (a - d)(b • e). 12. Find two different expressions equivalent to (a A b) A (c A d). 13. Using the permutation symbol, work out a way to differentiate a determinant. 14. Use results about determinants to deduce I L f 2 = 1 from (1.8).
1.3 The Consistency Requirement We attempt here to provide motivation for the formal definition of a tensor that will he given in the next section_ THE CONSISTENCY OF NEWTON'S SECOND LAW
Versions of the same scientific law in different coordinate systems must be consistent. As an example of what we mean by this, consider Newton's second law. In a certain Cartesian coordinate system, let F ; and a ; denote the components of the force acting on a particle and the components of its acceleration, respectively, Let Fï and ; denote corresponding quantities in another Cartesian coordinate system. In the first system, Newton's second law can be written F; = ma i .
(1)
In the second system the law must have exactly the same form, namely,
Fi
= ma;.
(2)
24
Vectors. Determinants, and MOftuR[rOn for Tensors
I4Ch.
^
One reason fur this similarity can be found in the definitions of the components of vectors like F: The components F; are the projections of F on the fixed mutually perpendicular unit vectors l' (° }. The components 1.-; are the projections of on the fixed mutually perpendicular unit vect ors e 14 . These definitions show that components in the unprimed and primed systems conceptually identical and only rotationally different. 111 (1) is true, are therefore, (2) must be truc, because the correct notational change of adding primes to vector components has been made. Let us check directly that (2) holds if and only if (1) holds_ Since the primed and unprimed components of a vector are linked by (l .6). (2) can be written l vI Fp - ni/ uF or
I pg
- nia) = ü.
(3a b)
Equations(3b) can be regarded as three homogeneous equations for the three unknowns Fp — snap . By Theorem 1.1 the determinant of the coefficients is either t 1 or - 1, NO that 1 3 h) has only the trivial solution Fr
—
rr^t^
—
0,
which is the same as ( l). By reversing the above reasoning, one can show that (I) implies (2). PHYSICAL LAWS: GI';NERAI. STATEMENT VERSUS PARTICULAR NUMERICAL VERSI(7N To he more precise about the meaning of the consistency requirement, let us first slake clear that we are not presently interested in how laws appear to different observers who are moving in relation to each other or to some fixed "inertial - frame of refcrence. Rather, we are concerned with how laws are expressed in the different coordinate systems available to a single observer. After selecting a coordinate system, an observer of a vector obtains a rule for assigning to each point in three-dimensional space at least one triple of real numbers, and a rule for assigning exactly one point in space to each such triple. Since these rules must be perfectly definite, there always exist transformation formulas that allow one to pass hack and forth from triples obtained in one coordinate system to triples obtained in another. We distinguish between the general statement of a law and its particular numerical version. The general statement can be expressed independently of any coordinate system (F — ma) while the particular version relates numbers obtained using a particular coordinate system (Fi = ma.). in general, different versions of a given law, i.e., relations between dif ferent sets of numbers, are obtained if different coordinate systems are used ( ^ = mo o r; = mdai). These different versions are found from the general
Sr(_ 13)
The Consisienc y Rama-Linen'
25
statement of a Jaw by applying the coordinate rules appropriate to different coordinate systems. Consistency* demands that the same result be obtained if u given version of the low is obtained direct!) , from the general statement (Fr, = ma p ) or is obtained indirectly by transformation of another version 1Fp — map follows from F; = mo and the appropriate transformation law (1"6)H. in the previous paragraph, we cited F — txta as an example of a general coordinate-independent statement of a physical law, This example used vectors, entities that have a coordinate-free intepretatiou which invnlves length, direction, and addition by means oft he parallelogram law(Section 1. 1). Combinations of vectors, sometimes involving derivative operators, also have coordinate-free interpretations and therefore can also he used in the general statement of a physical law. To mention the simplest example, the scalar product can be described in a coordinate-free manner, as the product of the lengths of the two vectors involved times the cosine of the angle between them. f But we cannot restrict ourselves to combinations of vectors in formulating physical laws_ More complicated entities called "tensors" are necessary_ We turn now to a discussion that will mntivate the detailed definition of a tensor. GUESSING THE TENSOR TRANSFORMATION LAW FROM THE cON4tRTF'NCV REQUIREMENT
A fundamental result in continuum mechanics is that the stress vector t(x, t, n) is a special function of the unit normal vector n given (using summation notation) by r (x, (, n) = Pi; T, x, t)-
(4 )
(Compare (4.2.17 of L) Here I; is, by definition, the jib component of the stress vector acting on the surface element whose exterior normal points in the direction of the 6th Cartesian base vector O il_ We shall examine (4) in the light ofihe Consistency requirement_ This will lead naturally to the Concept of a second order tensor.§ Consider a new Cartesian coordinate system with mutually perpendicular unit base vectors el` I . Using the same reasoning that we used in proceeding from (l) to (2), we see that in the new system (4) must become t^ = rti T;^.
'
(5)
Cbuarruece or invariance arc alternative [rims fur cnnsislenCy.
t "!ï he divergence of a vector has a coordinate-free inierprerarinn [Exercise 9(a}j. Thus no surprise [hat the mass conservation equation epfct - V • v) = 0 has the same Form in a rotated Cartesian coordinate system (sec Exorcist 14.110f It 4 If desired, rcfercnCc to material outside this chapter can be avoided by using air finite
rotation reIalion requested in Exercise 2"t, instead of (4).
z6
'errors, Derrrrninanis, and Motivation for Tensors !Ch. )
Here 71i is the jth component [the projection on eu v] of the stress vector acting on the surface clement whose exterior normal points in the direction of e". We know the relations between the components of the vectors t and n in the two systems_ Assume that (4) and (5) arc consistent; let us determine what the relations must be between the quantities Tü and the quantities T. Using appropriately modified versions of (1.6), we substitute for r; and n; in (5): (,) t p = / o n, 7- 1 .
We substitute for r p by using p instead of j as a free subscript in (4): I pl ► t i J ip
= (Wi g
Employing a frequently used trick, we rntiltipty both sides of (7) by*
I Il i
Rini;
^
rJ
ri-
/ q,rJg7 f i'
But, by (1.8),
with which (8) becomes
tr; T;, =
tr#f qi n^ T; 1 .
We rewrite (10), changing the dummy subscript on the left and reordering the factors on the right:
nq 9 r = ri q q ^
^^
•1
(1 1)
Now (4) is true for any unit vector n. In particular, it is certainly true if n has the components (1, 0, 0)_ For this n, (111 implies that ^lr
= ta rr ri t .
(12)
Equation (12) plus similar orics corresponding to vectors n with components (0, 1, 0) and (0, 0, 1) can all be written compactly as
T4, =
/ e/r,T^.
(13)
We remind the reader that because of the summation convention, (13) symbolizes nine equations, corresponding to q, r = 1, 2, 3. We have established that i (4) and (5) are consistent, then (13) must hold. But (13) can be verified directly (Exercise l4.2.8 of 1). A straightforward calculation, essentially the reverse of the one in the previous paragraph, then demonstrates the consistency of (4) and (5) (Exercise 5)_
* instead air we could have usod as u subscript any Irurrs except p, q. and t. The Inner three choices wnu[d have violated the prohibition against repeating a subscript more than twice. in a single tam ,
sec. f.3) 17W C omrstrrecr Rrvrrcmenr
27
It is important to noie that our derivation of 11 3) did not use any special properties of the quantities involved in (4) and E5) . We needed only these facts: (a) t and n satisfy the vector transformation law (1.6). (b) We can determine the nine quantities T , in any Cartesian coordinate system. (c) n is arbitrary. It turns out that there are many physical laws of the form (4) whose con-. stituents satisfy (a), (b), and (c) and which are consistent with respect to Cartesian coordinate systems. Sets of nine quantities satisfying the transformation law (1 3) arc therefore common, and consequently they have been given a special name, second order Cartesian tensor (hence the name stress lemur for T). In essence, our discussion of (4) indicates that if a two-subscripted entity appears in a physical law, then that entity must represent the components of a second order tensor. Comparing the tranSforrrlation law for the 3' components of a vector (or first order tensor), = with that for the 3 2 components of a second cider tensor, — /, r /
,
q
there is no difficulty in generalizing to the 3" components of an nth order tensor. And this is no empty generalization, for higher order tensors occur frequently. Having completed sufficient motivation to make our definitions credible and to make their development seem worthwhile, we pass in the next section to a formal study of Cartesian tensors_
tr Xk,R Ct*itü S 1. Show that if (1) and (2) are consistent and if acceleration is a vector, then force is a vector. f ollow the line of reasoning used to obtain (131. 2. Why is it not permitted to cancel rt r from both sides of(' I). even when it is guaranteed that no components of n q are zero, unless (11) holds for arbitrary rig? 3. Explain why the passage from (l I) to (13) can be achieved by using a slight modification of the following result :
r•, rt, = 0 for arbitrary n, implies that t', What is the geometric interpretation of this result? 4. Show that (13) implies that Tqt f q afn =
—
0_
Vectors,
Defermmcpus, and Motivation for Tensors [Ch.
I
5. Show that (13) implies that (4) and (5) are consistent. 6. Specialize (13) to obtain the transformation law for T12 . Write out all nine terms. Show that (15) gives the same result. Unless you are absolutely confident that (13) and (15) are identical, repeat the problem for T23 7. (a) Calculate fii for the pair of Cartesian coordinate systems related by
(b) By what rigid rotation can one coordinate system be carried into the other? (Give the axis of rotation and the amount of rotation.) (c) Show that if T is a second order tensor, then, according to (15), its components T arc related to its components Tp,2 by a transformation of indices symbolized by 1 --3 L',
3',
2
3
Use common sense to check this result_ 8. (a) Same as Exercise 7(a) for the coordinate systems related by
e LLl = e (21
e ra.I
_
_ e {iI
[3i
= e [il
(b) Same question as Exercise 7(b). (c) Show that Tv, = -- T;2, T32 = T 1 . 9. (a) From material in 1, Section 13.4, and/or from the divergence theorem, develop a coordinate-free interpretation of the divergence. (b) Discuss the results of I, Exercises 14.1.9 and 14.1.10, in light of the
ideas presented in the present section.
1.4 The Tensor as a Linear Transformation In this section we shall show that a second order tensor can be identified with a Iinear transformation of a vector space into itself. We shall be led to a natural characterization of tensor components and their transformation law. Knowledge of the connection between the stress vector and the stress tensor will be assumed, as given in Section 14.2 of I_ To be sure that the mathematical prerequisites are secure, we begin with a review of some relevant definitions. LINEAR TRANSFORMATIONS
Definition 1. A iransforrnurion of a vector space* into itself is a rule that associates with any vector v one and °nly one image vector w. We write (1)
w = TM_ Examples of such transformations are T(r) = 4v, T(v) = O, r(v) = q+ v (q a fixed vector). (a, b; * Only ordinary Euclidean 3 space 14LI/
considered
in this stctiun.
c)
See. i 41
The Tensor
as
1-.rm•ur 7rcuts/rnmutiurr
Definition 2. The transformation (1) is linear if it satrslics the following requirement: if C i and e2 are any two scalars and rr'' and vrZF are any two vectors. Then
r.3 0 2 f} = c i TN" r) + r r T(0 21).
T{t r vin
Transfotmarion (2a) is linear, ;rnrr
E'xsantp[^ti.
Tf
(3)
^
w
+ ri 021) = 4(r ^ ►r " + r2Yl2l)
ill
ra4vrriJ
l
i
i -r
4.
Tli(ri) + e 2 f`Wlrl-
5irnitarly,12h1 is Linear Transfnrmatutn (20 is nr ► r luxar, 4mcc Tfr .^ yiit
+
'Y#r} 4 r. 20 :1' 4 (1
(4)
bui c
Tit') i t Thel F l — t r f u iii i q) f_ r -ri(Y '21 i qk
he nuit sides of 14) and (5) arc nor the same tot arhnrary r i and
15)
ez
THE STRESS TENSOR IN11UL'E.S A LINEAR TRAN5FU1iMATloh OF DIFFFRFNTIAt, AREA INTO 13iFF'F:RF.NT1At. FORCE
To begin to see how a second order tensor can he c1mracterired as a linear transformation, recall the relation between the stress vector t and the stress trnsnr T [Equation (14-2-17) of l]= fr. I rr(x, t`
tk, t,
(ti)
for given x and t, lb) provides a transformation t - Tint of the unit normal vector n into 1. This is not a transformation in accord with Definition 1, however. because T is defined only for unit %ectors. We circumvent this difficulty as follows. Lei E be a closed surface and let P be a portion of E containing x. Let dS be the area of P and denote the unit exterior normal to 1 at x by n(x} (See Figure 1,9- Note that dS is not necessarily small.) Define df and dA by -
df - t r^.5
dA
-
n dS
(711.1))
The vector dA is a differential area lis magnitude is the area of P and its direction is that of n(xl, a certain unit normal vector to P. The smaller dS is, the nearer all exterior normals to P are to n(x) (provided that E is smooth and orientable and that dS retains its shape as'i1 shrinks'. The vector df is a differential contact force As in (14.2,4} of 1 the actual contact force fr excrtrd on f satisfies
11m -° -
^c • r, dS
Consequently, for small dS, fj,
dS. dlf
(S1
30
'ertors, Dererminanrs, and Motivation for Tensors [Ch.
!
n(x)
FIGURE 1.9. A patch of the surface wish area dS_ the normal .error a point x in (his parch is shown.
n ai
Sometimes it is useful to say that when dS is" infiniresimal," then the contact force exerted on P is given by d f; and to say Further that dA is a vector whose magnitude is the area of an "infinitesimal" patch containing x and whose direction is that of the exterior normal to this patch. But keep in mind that d f and dA are defined for any d5, large or small. Denote the components ofd f and dA by cif and dA,. Multiplication of (6) by dS then gives
df^
=dA ) T; ; .
(9)
We interpret (9) as a transformation df = T(dA) of the area differential dA into the force differential di'. Our transformation now satisfies Definition 1, because it is defined for any vector dA. Furthermore, the transfuntialion is linear. For if dA and dB are two area differentials with components dA, and (IB„ and a and h arc scalars, then TO dA + b du) has the components (a dA + dB1)T;i = a dA i To + b
so T(4 dA + b dB) = aT (dA) + bT (dB). There is one unsatisfactory aspect of our argument. For any given coordinate system, the transformation T is defined by (9), with the aid of the components Ti . Would the transformation be the same if another coordinate system were used? If not, T is improperly defined. We can rephrase the question this way: Suppose that we use a primed Cartesian coordinate system to compute the components I; and that in this
Sec_ 1.4(
The Tensor as a Linear Tre ►xsjurrnalrora
system the components of df and dA are d[; and del). Is it truc that d[ dA ; Tii ? But this is just the question we answered affirmatively in Section 1.3 when we showed that (3.4) and (3.5) are equivalent if and only if the transformation law (1.6) ho lds_ A LINEAR TRANSFORMATION OF DIFFERENTIAL AREA TO DIFFERENTIAL FORCE CAN BE IDENTIFIED WITH THE STRESS TENSOR
We now explore matters from the opposite point of view. The transformation df T(dA) is linear if and only if T(c dA) = cT (dA),
T (dA + dB) = T(dA) + T (dB).
(l0a, b)
But (10) provides perfectly natural initial assumptions to make about the relation df = T'(dA). Equation (lDa) states that if the differential area is multiplied by a scalar c, i.e.., made c times as large, then the force is increased by a factor of e. Equation (10b) states that the force on the sum of two differential areas is the sum of the forces acting on each. It is therefore natural to see what we can discover about the differential force merely from the knowledge that it is obtained from a linear transformation of the differential area. More generally, what can we discover about a transformation T(v) knowing only that it is a linear transformation of a vector space into itself ? Let el l s, el 11 , and e13 F be a set o f base vector. I. or any vector v, then,
v
view ,
(l 1)
where the t are the components of v_ To find the effect of the transformation T(v), we first observe that the linearity of T implies that T(r) = T(4.40")1= vi T( e ffi)
€ l2)
Now Ile" )) is by definition a vector and socan be written as a linear combination ore' ", el'', and 0 13 . The same holds for T(e (21 ) and T(€131). Thus for some coefficients T -; we have
T(e'') = Ti j et p .
(13)
A combination of 112) and (I3) yields T(v) = /01,6".
(14)
Alternatively, if we denote the image of by w, t hen w = T(w) and rt e = v i To.
(15)
Thus if the components of v are known. the components of its image w are given by (15), provided that the nine quantities Tuare known. These quantities are called the components of T relative to the base vectors O'. As (I3) shows, these components are given in terms of T(et` ) ), the images of the base vectors.
32
Vf`{- rors, Uerfr+nuiurrrs,
and Motivation
jor
Tensors
[Ch . 1
The linear mapping T has a new set of components with respect to a different system of base vectors a 'r_ These are given by the analog of (13): T(etnrr)
(16)
fAA
What is the relation between the f' and the 7';t„? To answer this, we start with the following links between the primed and unprimed base vectors (see the proof of Theorem 1.1): e (nr =
f
.
e i j)
From (13), (17b), and the linearity of T
/ !AT e[^'l
eI ' }
lA
-
(17a, b)
:
Ti e( )) = T(e{' } ) — T(/1,, ")
T(e [mi )-
Transforming the last expression, using (16) and (17a), we find that f I ji
fix, T,„„Few = f i„, f ,
f,r
i11
(18)
For each i, (1 8) is a vector equation. Setting components equal, we obtain T j =„^Ii„l ^A^ '
(19)
Equation (l9) is the transformation law used in the definition of a second order Cartesian tensor. We have therefore shown that if we use (13) to associate components with a linear transformation T of a vector space into itself, then Tis a second order Cartesian tensor. Conversely, we showed at the beginning of this section that if T is a second order Cartesian tensor, then it can be associated with a linear transformation of a vector space into itself. Thus the transformation law (19) between components of Tholds if and only if Tis a linear transformation of a vector space into itself_ Either the transformation law or the linearity property can be taken as the essential ingredient in the definition of a tensor. We choose to define tensors by means of their transformation law, so that we say that tensors are characterized by linearity. LXt•:RCiSES
1. Show that T (dA) is a linear transformation if and only if (LW) holds. 2. Show that if T is a linear transformation, then T(4) = O. 3. The components of the linear transformations (2a) and (2b) a re the same for all coordinate systems. Find them. +4. A transformation T is linear and transforms a set of base vectors eri as follows: TW' F) 2e(2), T(0'1 = e i 1 + et -”, T(e(3}) _ eU (a) Find the associated components 7;,. (b) Find the image of the vector with components (3, 1, 2). 5. Repeat Exercise 3.7(c) but use (13) and (lb) instead of the transformation law (3.15). 6. Repeat Exercise 18(c) using the method described in Exercise 5.
2 C artesian Tensors
CHAPTER
1-[AFTER I provided motivation for the study of Cartesian tensors and for the transformation laws that form the central aspect of their definition. This chapter is concerned with a methodical study of tensor properties. We begin with algebraic considerations, such as definitions of tensor sums, differences, and various kinds of products and "quotients?' Next we consider the eigenvalue problem for second order tensors, a matter of considerable importance but one that to most readers will be only a small extension of familiar material concerning eigenvalues for matrices. We shall largely be concerned with tensors whose components are functions of space and time. 01 great future utility. therefore, will he the study of tensor calculus that concludes this chapter.
2.1 Tensor Algebra This rather formal section presents a number of definitions and theorems concerning Cartesian tensors_ The adjective "Cartesian" may be left out, but "tensor" and "coordinate system" always refer to Cartesian tensors and to Cartesian coordinate systems in ordinary three-dimensional (Euclidean) space.
Our discussion starts with the definition of a tensor that is based on the rules For transformation from one coordinate system to another. We continue by showing how tensors may he added and subtracted. Various kinds of multiplications are defined and discussed, and division of a sort appears in the "quotient rule." We also discuss symmetric and asymmetric tensors and the relation among tensors, vectors, and matrices_ The discourse is largely algebraic, so that we adopt a Formal theorem-proof style. Many of the definitions and theorems we present will be formulated for second order tensors. /The required generalization to nth order tensors is often straightforward_ In such cases we leave the generalization to the reader and thus avoid the cluttered subscripts that are necessary in dealing with nth order tensors_ in Section 1.4 we showed how a second order tensor can be interpreted as a linear transformation of a vector space into itself. This is a coordinate-free description and thus automatically establishes the possibility of using second order tensors in the general statements of physical laws. It is possible to extend this approach and thereby to characterize an nth order tensor as a certain "rnultilincar" transformation. Some authors use this characterization to define tensors. For our purposes the approach of the present section 33
34
Cartesian
Tensors [Ch.
1
is preferable because fewer algebraic preliminaries are necessary and because more useful skill at component manipulation is acquired. DEFIItiIl IONS AND ELEMENTARY PROPERTIES
Definition 1. A zeroth order tensor or scalar s is such that (a) In any Cartesian coordinate system there is a rule for associating s with a real number. (b) This real number is the same no matter what Cartesian ccnrdinatc system is employed. For example, the mass of an object is a scalar_
Definition2.
An nth order tensor (or nth rank tensor) T, n = 1, 2, 3,
-
is such that* (a) In any Cartesian coordinate system there is a rule for associating the tensor T with a unique ordered set of 3" quantities ?; (called the components of T). (h) if i .. ;n and 7' ... J are the components of Tin two different Cartesian coordinate systems, then ^
_ NOTE-
.,
in in
Jr -- •lti -
{l)
For a second order tensor, 11) can be written
T;,.
Tp4 = f
REMARKS-
By Cell =- #s;
we mean that in a certain Cartesian coordinate system, T j is the (ij)th component of T . The components of a second order tensor can be conveniently displayed as a matrix. Example 1. Lei ! be an entity with nine components given by [fl u = baj.
Show that l is a second order tunsot (Oiled the unit timor). Solution. We have a rule giving the conlpuncnts I in tiny coordinate system- (The same set of nine numbers, given by the identity matrix [
t=
ü
1}
D 1 0 , il {} 1
• The relation between the ahstract Cntity ealtcd a tensor and the set of numbers that are its components in a given coordinate system is somewhat analogous to the relation between the abstract idea of a sphere and a particular diawing or model of a sphere.
Sv c.
2.11 T ensor Algebra
35
gives ). he components in all coordinate syslerns.l It remains to prove the validity of the transformation law
But. using 0.1.814 %mr
1e
f+ mr^ ~ %,nI
Example 2. Lei E he an entity with 27 components given by
Show thai E is a third order tensor (called the alternating tensor). prorated that transformations between coordinate systems are restricted 10 proper rotariwns. Suhrivn. The rule for determining cornpcnenis being given, rt remains to prove the transformation law. t,d, =tep % IQ ti R. f;p4o
-
Hy (I-Z.IEIb), the right skie of this equation is ri o. ILl and the result ftrllo s.. since CLf, the determinant of the transformation matrix, is unity for proper rotations, [See Example
1.2.4 or Equation (1.1. I4l.] Note that if reflections were not prohibited, there would be transformations
l , and E would not be a tensor-When we speak of " the for which IL j = tensor E" and when we derive consequences from the tensorial character of E. we shall he implicitly assuming that reflections are prohibited. -
Example 3. I.ei A I , A2. and A ; be vectors. In a given Cartesian coordinate system, deter 111111C a rlumbCr by evaluating the determinant whose ith row consists o f the components of A„ f - 1, 2. 3. Show that this number is a scalar, provided that re fle c t ions are prohibited. Solution. Let A,„„ be the nth component of A. We must prove ghat e' = c. where r
-
1 -0.A1•A2 1 i 34 ,
t' ' = F: py ,.4
' rr
Ap 4 13 r
[hit by the transformation law for vectors,
and the result follows ai once by the transformation law for E that we just proved Example 2.
iii
Definition 3. Let A and B be second order tensors with components A il and B,,. Let c be a scalar. The sum A + B is defined by
[A + 8] = A The difference A
-
+ B.
(2)
A ;; - B i ,-
(3)
.3
B is defined by [A - B]
Cartesian Tensors [Ch. 2
36 The scalar multiple cA is defined by [cAi} = cA,1 .
(4)
In particular, [ — I A l1 = [ - Ali _ — A ;i . Theorem 1. If A and B are nth order tensors and c is a scalar, then (a) A + B is a tensor, (b) A — B is a tensor, and {c) cA is a tensor. Proof of (a). (The proof is very simple, but as it is the first such proof, we shall write it out in detail, for second order tensors. As we continue, proofs wilt become less detailed.) In any Cartesian coordinate system, there is a rule for associating components with A and B. Thus (2) provides a rule for associating components with A + B. To show that A + B is a tensor, it remains to demonstrate that the required transformation law holds. Let A 1 and A I be the components of A and B in one coordinate system and let A;,,,, and B be their components in another coordinate system. By (2), the corresponding components of A + B are (A ; + B, j ) and (A,,,, -# B;,,,,). Since A and B are tensors, the following transformation laws are valid: A. — t,,/ jn A,
(5)
B ij =.„,/ L
(6)
Adding (5) and (6), we obtain (AF, + B, 1) = 4,,i (A; ,In + A:,r}, which is the required transformation law for the components of A + B. Proof of (b) und (c). Left to the reader. O
Definition 4_ The zero. tensor 0 is an entity whose components in any Cartesian coordinate system are all zero. That is, for second order tensors, t_q,• = ^
(7)
Theorem 2,
The zero tensor is a tensor. Proof for second order tensors. The rule for obtaining components is given by (4 The required transformation law, 7 1,
is clearly satisfied if I; =
Tm
„
`
j
11n 11 ,r f rnn ,
= 4 for i, j, m, rt = I, 2, 3. Q
Definition S. Two tensors are equal if their di fference is the zero tensor; i.e.,
A =B-t
-B = -D.
(8)
It follows (Exercise 2) that to prove that tensors are equal, one needs only show that they have the same components in a single coordinate system-
Sec. 2.1) Tensor Algebra
That is, for second order tensors,
(9)
A = B [A] ^R = [ 81).
We emphasize that only tensors of the same rank can be equal (for the subtraction required in Definition 5 is only defined for tensors of equal rank)_ Theorem 3. The following " natural" laws for manipulating tensors hold: Let A, B, and C be nth order tensors and let a and b he scalars. Then
A+(B+ C)— (A+B)+C, A +0= A,
A+(
—
A-+ B B 4 A,
( 10a,h)
A)= O,
(11a, b).
al A + B) - uA + aB,
(12)
(ti + b)A -- uA + bA,
1 13)
(ab)A = LOA),
i A = A_ -
(14a, bl
[Theorem l plus the laws of OW and (t I), show that tensors of the same order form a commutative group under addition. Because (12), (l3), and (l4) also hold, tensors form a vector space under addition and scalar multiplication.] Proof of (IUb). Let ,
[A] ^ 1 = fi,,
[B] 0 = B
,,.
Then, by Definition 3,
[A + B] , 1 - A + B.
[B + A] { = B tu + A, 1 .
Since the addition of real numbers is v:ommutative,
A, f + B
— B, ►
so [A +B]_ [B t A], 1 , -
and the commutative lain (lob) follows, by (9). Proof of the rest of Theorem 3 is left to the reader. fl
Consulting Section 1.1, we observe that a jirsr order tensor is identical with a vector- Indeed, our previous definitions could be thought of as generalizations ofdefinitions familiar to us from vector algebra, We turn to some useful notions that can only be defined when tensors of order 2 or higher are considered. Definition 6. A contraction of an nth order tensor, ,t > 2, is formed by setting two of its indices equal and performing the resulting sum. An example of bow contraction leads to a new tensor whose order is 2 less than the original tensor is provided by the Following theorem.
Car#esiw7 Tensors [Ch. 2
38 Theorem 4. Let T be a fourth order tensor, where
=
L^^+imn
TOR r -
Define f1 by ^ iR
in
—
—
Tim.
(15)
Then Li is a second order tensor, Proof The rule for obtaining the components of U is given by (15). Since T is a fourth order tensor, ^ ^p G j4 eJxr° J,_, TpgFi•
^4^JRR
so, setting
m j,
= But 1 fig
^
1R
(16)
c5-11 yr
as in (1.1.9), so e [pf R7 7;1, 1
Thin
-
By (15), the above equation is e quivalent to FF r which is the required transformation law. p Definition 7. Let A be an nth order tensor and B be an mth order tensor, where [AL i R = A i ,... 4 ,
[8 ],, ^ — Br,
Then the tensor product AB is defined by [ABI,...
D = A; ... ,nBi.,, ,
J...
(I7)
Note that the right side of (17) is the product of two real numbers. Example 4. if v and w are first order tensors with components u ; and w then
[vw],i — IJ i The ÿth component of vw, the product of the ith component of a with the jth component of w, can be found in the ith row and jihî column of the following array: CJ w 1
VI. W2
l} 1 14'3
NW) — 31;44' J
112 .19d2
r..12 w3 -
OE)
V3 WI 113 w1 31 3 W3
Two vectors have a scalar product, a vector product, and a tensor product These products arc, respectively, a scalar, a vector, and a special second order tensor called a dyad (see Exercise 24). NOTE-
S e t. 2.1) Tensor Algebru
39
Theorem 5. Let W = AB, where A is an ,nth order tenser and B is an mth order tensor. Then W is an (n + m)th order tensor. Proof for n I, in = 2. Suppose that A, and BA , and An, and }3 , are the components of A and ft in two different coordinate systems. By definition of W, A r j,
,
Werra
= Am Bp
(19)
Since A and B are tensors, A[
Bjk = /
irnA+n E jp i 4 Bpe .
Therefore, from (19), we obtain the desired transformation law,
Prooffor Me general rase.
Left to the reader. Q
Definition 8. Let A and B be second order tensors with components A 11 and B. Then the contraction product A • B is defined by [A B] — AuBig. The contraction product of tensors of arbitrary order is defined similarly, by summing ever adjacent indices .
Theorem 6. Let A be an !nth order tensor and B be an nth order tensor. Then A • Bis a tensor of order rn + n 2. Proof. A • B a contraction of the (m + n)th order tensor AB. 11 —
Easily proved results (Exercise 16), and useful ones, arc
rod[T - e ^1i^ = T . e M. T. e (1x — 1-
- ,,
(20a, b) (20c)
These equations assign interpretations to each individual tensor component. In Section 1.3 we showed in essence that if t = n • T holds for arbitrary t and n, then T must satisfy the tensor transformation law. it is useful here to restate this result in a general context. To make this section's presentation more complete, we shall repeat the main points of the proof. Theorem 7. Suppose that in any Cartesian coordinate system, there is a rule associating a unique ordered set of nine quantities with T. If, for an arbitrary vector a, a • T is a vector, then T is a second order tensor.* Tilts theorem brings ow
a sect1rtd order censor's characterization as a mapping of a vector
pasx into] itself (compare Section I.4).
s
2
Cartesian Tensors
40 Proof.
Let a •
T = v. We must show the following. Suppose that
(2la, b)
and o; T: ; _ 14,
a, Ti = t?
and suppose further that a and v satisfy the vector transformation law, so = /ad*. and t' 1
(22a. b)
I 11 04.
Then it must be true that Tpq — / ipf
But upon substituting (21a) and (21b) into (22a) and then using (226), we find that — { JP t
F
/ jig T2p-
To employ (16) for the purpose of moving all !'s to one side of the equation, we multiply by f 1,: / 1,/ jr„ a: Tip =
,a;Tlp
Tu.
or -
f.k,] = O.
Since a, is arbitrary, an argument used in Section 1.3 shows that the terms within the square brackets must vanish, which is equivalent to the desired conclusion. Q REMARK.
If a and b are real numbers, b # 0, their quotient alb is
defined by
a
=.c=.a = be.. By analogy, v = a • T could be interpreted as expressing T as the quotient of r and a_ Theorem 7 is called a quotient rule because it can be regarded as asserting that the quotient of two first order tensors is a second order tensor. While suggestive, the "quotient” aspect of tensor equations need not be taken too seriously. The following is another quotient rule of a rather general character. Theorem 8. Suppose that in any coordinate system, there is a rule associating a unique set of 3h quantities with T Suppose that for an arbitrary frith order tensor A, TA is a tensor* of order ni + n. Then T is an nth order tensor. The proof of this theorem and of other quotient rules will be given as
exercises _ • Sink T is opt known to be a knsut, strictly speaking TA is not defined. In any courdinase sysielll, by TA we mean the analog of t 17l.
See. 2. If Tensor Algebra
41
SPECIAL RESULTS FOR SECOND ORDER TENSORS
Definition 9. Let A be a second order tensor with components A. Then the transpose of A is denoted by A T and is defined by [AT%]IJ = A1,.
(23)
Theorem 9. If A is a second order tensor, then A' is a second order tensor. Proof. Left to the reader Definition 10. If
A — A 1 ` or A ll = A
^; ,
then A is said to be symmetric. If
A=
or A,1 = - A l; ,
then A is said to be antisymmetric (or skew-symmetric). For example, in a nonpolar material, the stress tensor is symmetric. A second order tensor may be neither symmetric nor antisymmetric, but it can be written as the sum of a symmetric and an antisyrnmetric tensor, as is shown in the Following theorem_ Theorem 10. Let T be a second order tensor. Then one can write T — S + A,
(24)
where S is a symmetric second order tensor and A is an antisymmetric second cider tensor. This decomposition is unique. Outline of proof T=+{T+ 1.T`)+
1(T —
T T`)-
( 25 )
On the right side of (25), the first term is symmetric and the second is antisymmetric. The uniqueness proof is requested in Exercise 9. G Matrices are an aid in performing certain manipulations with the components of second order tensors_ For example, in a given coordinate system [A], 1 can be written in the ith row and jth column of a 3 by 3 matrix. We shall denote this matrix by (A). Thus A l2
A,
A2z
A23
Ati2
A33
3
Note that A has a meaning independent of any coordinate system, but the matrix (A) is defined with reference to a particular coordinate system. In (18) we displayed the matrix corresponding to the second order tensor vw.
Car#eswn Tensors [Ch_ 2
42
Theorem 11_
Fer second order tensors A and B, (26)
(A - B) = (A)(B).
In words, the matrix of the contraction product of and B is the product of the A and B matrices. Proof.. The component in the pth row and qth column of the matrix (A • B) is A ; Bi . A F,Bk is found by taking the"dot product" of the pth row of (A) and the qth column of (Bl. By definition of matrix multiplication, this is the clement in the plh row and qth column of the matrix product (A)(B). f] Theorem 12. The vector transformation laws U^
Z2^
=
Duli uj,
can be written, using matrix notation, as l^ r
I' 2
(EH = /21
/l2 ^ i3
^i
/22 /23
^2
i 31
/ 33
^3
!^1
/ 32
and / 12 1 ;',
1'2
6) =
/22
(r1
/ 32
respectively As before, lei L be the transformation matrix, and let (v) be the column vector with components 07,, v 2 , t] 3 ). If a prime indicates use of a primed coordinate system and if a superscript (Tr) denotes matrix transpose, then we can w rite (v) • rr = (v) rr L (v) = L(vj', (27a) .
Prou[
Left to the reader.
Theorem 11 The transformation law for second order tensors, A ',„ni
can be written (A) = L(A)1.».
(27b)
Left to the reader. REMARK. Since tensor equations are valid if they are demonstrated in any single set of components, there is a theory for second order tensors that completely parallels the corresponding matrix theory. We have seen this in Theorem 10; the decomposition into the sum of symmetric and antisymmetric Proof.
Sr c _ 2 1]
Tc•usor Algebra
43
tensors is the same as the corresponding matrix decomposition. To give another example, one can term a second order tensor nonsingular if any of its component matrices has a nonzero determinant. If R is a nonsingular tensor. then [Exercise 25(c)J there exists an inverse tensor, which we denote by R with the property
R• R '' = R - ' i R = f_
[28)
ISOTROPIC TENSORS
There are certain materials whose structure singles out one or more directions. Examples are the direction of the grain in a piece of wood, and various symmetry axes in a crystal lattice. Other materials, like water. appear to have no internal preferred direction. The constitutive equations for materials of the latter kind must be expressed in terms of special tensors whose components are always the same. We shall now study this class of" isotropic" tensors. Definition 11_ Tensors, such as I and E, whose components are given by the same set of numbers in all coordinate systems, are called isotropic. ll follows immediately from the definition of zero order tensors that they are isotropic. Are t here any isotropic tensors of order I ?There is at least one, the zero tensor of order 1. Excluding this case ]which we shall term trivia°}, are there any others? There are not, as we shall now show. Theorem it There are no nontrivial isotropic tensors of order 1. Proof (We proceed in a way that makes up in conceptual simplicity what it lacks in elegance. We rule out the possibility that there is a nontrivial vector which has the same components in oil coordinate systems by showing that there is no such vector even if only three special coordinate systems are considered) Suppose that v is an isotropic vector and that its components are y, relative to a certain basis e l n. Consider another set of basis vectors satisfying
e
tx _
^
^z^
^
i zp
=e` , a, e" }- =
(29)
It is clear from Figure 2.1 that the components v: satisfy t•' l -
= fi 3 ,
l'2 ,
Z'3 = VI.
(30)
This cyclic change of subscripts, symbolized by l'
►
2,
2'
3,
3' -' I.
(31)
can also be verified by calculating the appropriatef and applying the vector transformation law (1.1.6). (The calculations are almost the same as those requested in Exercise I,17.)
44
Cartesian
Tensors [Ch_ 2
r fJl 0 cll
FICiURE 2.1, A
rülulron of axes
ecjuivulenf fo a cyclic exchange of subscript.
Since Y 1S isotropic, = rL,
11 2 ,
t' 2
(32)
118 = V3-
Combining (30) and (32), we Find that (33)
=112 =V3 = 1 3 =l1 } • et`l., Consider a third set of basis vectors satisfying V1
cox
y e{21, 1121" =
_
t1}
ear = ea}
(34)
f rom Figure 2.2, = i VI,
but, by isotropy, VZ = v2 .
Thus o2 : — L . This is consistent with (33) if and only if v / = v2 Consequently, the only isotropic vector is the zero vector. U
v3 = O.
Theorem 15. Any isotropic tensor of order 2 can be written 21 for some scalar A. Proof, Suppose that T is an isotropic tensor of second order and suppose that its components are T i relative to a certain basis ems. As in the proof of the previous theorem, consider a new set of basis vectors satisfying (29). By (31),
T12
— T22,
7-22 =
= T23,
T23
= 13
T3Z
- 1132
T 21 = T32
,
T33, ,,
T33` T11,
(35a)
T31 = T12 ,
(35b)
T13 =
T21
.
(35c)
See. 2.11 Tensor Algebra
45 t
[ll
, P
fll
/
F Lc; t I R E 2.2. The cJnubk-prrn:rd "
mtenr Is r o ta t ed 90° about the e' as axis. -
Since T is isotropic, . T IL
T11.
T22 - ^=2 T 33
- T33 -
(36)
From (35a) we deduce that Ti 1 - T22 - T3 3=
(37)
for some number A. Similarly, we can deduce Irons (3Sb) and (35c) that T1 2 =t T2 3 = Ti
,
•
T1
= T32
-
i3-
(38)
New consider the components ❑ f T relative to a third set of basis vectors satisfying (34). Applying the transformation law, one finds, as in Exercise I.3,8, that 1'12 =
—
f21, T31 = T32 .
But, by isotropy, 11 . ^13
M T12, T 31 — T31-
Thus T1 2 - -Tn.,
1-3 l
= T3 z -
(39)
For (38) and (39) to he consistent, we must have 712 =
T23 = ;1 = T21
—
T32
- f13 = O.
(40)
The equations of (37) and (40) show that if T has the same set of components for the three sets of axes related by (29) and (34), then T necessarily has the
Curiesian Tinsors [Ch . Z
46
form 21. But )i is a tensor by Example 1 and part (c) of Theorem 1, and Al certainly has the same set of components for all axes. [] Theorem 16. Any isotropic tensor of order 3 can be written 1.E for some scalar 1. (If reflections are allov.ed, E is not a tensor, so the only isotropic tensor of order 3 is O.) Proof. The argument is entirely analogous to that required for Theorem 15. Details are left to the reader. Theorem 17. If T is an isotropic tensor of order 4, then y qr) [T]pgrs = okr5 Urs ± ;ii(15Fr ya ± ^
+ i { b pr b gS
—
cPs qr)
(41)
for some scalars 1., /4, and Pti. Proof. Again the same ideas suffice, but the details are now somewhat lengthy. The reader is asked to supply a proof in Exercise 19. THE VECTOR ASSOCIATED WITH AN ANTISYMMETRIC TENSOR
To conclude this section, we shall present some formulas involving the alternating tensor that will be seen to be useful in our discussion of kinematics, To motivate our discussion, we start with the fact (see Exercise 21) that ifa rigid material is in uniform rotation about the origin, then the velocity v at the point x is given by (42)
r = ül A x,
where w is the angular velocity vector. in terms of the alternator, (42) can be written e,;k toi xk .
ft;
(43)
Since {43) holds for arbitrary x, the quotient rule implies that the quantities r ft cw} are the components of a second order tensor. Not surprisingly, it proves useful to regard v as given by the contraction product of this tensor and x. As will be seen in the formal development that starts in the next paragraph, it is conventional to deal with a tensor whose components are —E, ik to . With a vector CO we shall associate an antisymmetrk tensor Q defined by ^
=
^ Py r
^^
ir
^ = F_ - w.
or
(44)
Thus 4
(t2) _
— €^ 3 Wg
ca 3
^l 2
0
c), .
— (.1)1
0
(45)
Sec 2.1] T eruur Algebra
47
An explicit formula for w in terms of can be obtained by multiplying both and using the th rule: sides of (44) by
Eip4r/pq = Ei pq € pgr C+J
gipE
çç= f^ (60e5 î, - U9,üi9)(0,. =
3ui —
That is U li
= 8 i ^q ^i ^4 -
(46)
Similarly, (46) implies (44) when 12 is antisymmetric [Exercise 20(b)]. Sometimes (46) is written w = i113 _ (47 ) What we have shown can be summed up as Follows.
Theorem 18.
Corresponding to any antisymmetric tensor 13 there exists a vector to [given by (46)] such that 12 = - w. Here w is called the vector of the anuisymmetric tensor O. Corresponding to any vector w, there exists an antisymmetric tensor 12 [given by (44)] such that (46) holds_ We motivated our present discussion with some remarks concerning rigid body rotation. In this connection we can now draw the following useful
conclusion. —12 • x fct some Theorem l9. If a velocity vector v satisfies v = x • it antisymmetric tensor Q that is independent of the position vector x, then the motion is a uniform rigid body rotation about the origin with angular flpt . velocity w given by ta i = Proof. From Theorem 18, do) is defined as above, then Up =
xg f2gp = Xi? çpr w r —
'eprQ tt: r
X4
re)
A x]p.
Comparing with (42), we see that the velocity is that of a rigid body rotation
with angular velocity w. D REMARK. Later [see (4_1_33)] we use a result analogous to Theorem 19 to show, in essence, that infinitesimal displacements of the form u = S2 • x arc rotations. E XERCISES
1,
Prove Theorem I, parts (b) and (c).
2. Prove (9). 3. Verify (10), (11), (12), (13), and (14)_ is a 4. Prove from first principles that if T is a second order tensor, then scalar. 5. Prove Theorem 5: (a) for n = m = 1; (b) for n 1, rn = 3; (c) in general_ 6. Prove Theorem 8: (a) when m = 1, n = 2; (b) in general. 7. Prove Theorem 9.
Corleswn Tensors [Ch. 2
4^
relative to 8. Let T be a second order tensor with components T. and two different hases. Prove that (a) Td : T, implies that 7'1 = (b) 1; = — 7; ; implies that r ; 9. Show that the decomposition (24) is unique. 10. Prove (a) Theorem 12; (b) Theorem 13. 11. Suppose that for any Cartesian coordinate system there is a rule for associating T with 81 components 'C ity Suppose that for arbitrary vectors v and w, v • T w is a second order tensor. Prove that T is a fourth order tensor. 12. In a certain Cartesian coordinate system, the components of the vectors v and w are (1, 2, 3) and (4, 5, b). Find the components of vw. 13. Give a geometric interpretation of Example 3 in terms of the triple scalar product (see Example I.2.1). In particular, state why reflections must be prohibited. 14. in any Cartesian coordinate system there is a rule for associating T with components Ti such that T ; = Tfl . For arbitrary vectors a, a • T • a is a scalar. Prove that T is a symmetric tensor. 15. Let L be an entity whose components with respect to any unit vectors e[ 'l are given by [L]1 = ut`I• etrr. Here in'L,u[ 21, and u13 l are anorthonormal set of vectors that are regarded as fixed, while components of L are computed with respect to various coordinate systems_ Is L a second order tensor? 16. (a) Demonstrate (20). (b) Specialize (2Db) to the case where T is the stress tensor. Show that the original interpretation (Section 14.2 of i) of the components of T is recovered. 17. Prove Theorem 16. 18. What theorems and definitions show that the right side of (41) is an isotropic tensor'? 19. Prove Theorem 17 in the following manner (Jeffreys and Jeffreys. 1962, Sec. 3.031). (a) By considering special rotations, as in the text, show that ,
14 1111 — U2222 = 11 3333
^
CI.
W1122 = "2211 = 11 4233
11 3322 ! 14 33[1 — "1L33 " t 2+
"2323 = "1313 = "3L31
u2121 = 11 L212. = U 3232 — C3,
"2112 = W2332
1.1 3223 — 11 3113 = 1411331 a c4 ►
"1221
—
so that one can write
[T]
s = C 2 va
rs
+ C 3 e p, b y +
+ (C l — L.2 — C3 —
C 4)L•'pgr,,
where laps = 1 if all subscripts are equal and equals zero otherwise. „
Set. 211
The l:r,yerwakee Problem
49
(b) From the fact that T „x v x4,Xr Xs must be a scalar if x is a vector with components x , (why?), deduce that c, — r 2 — e 3 e4 = D. 20. (a] Verify (45). (b) Show that (46) implies (44) when .0 is antisymmctric. 21. Deduce (42) from Exercise I _ I.6(a). $22. Let To and £k be components of second order tensors_ Suppose that for arbitrary rpm iij
ilkmFkm-
(a) Show that if 7 is symmetric, then CI?,, Cjam. (b) Suppose that the E„ are the components of a symmetric tensor and that the CIA ., are the components of an isotropic tensor. Show that ;.=
2
E0
+ ft kk & i
for certain coefficients 1.4 and A. 23. True or false: If ecri r gives the components of et'k in a primed coordinate system, then (20c) implies that T- = etr}' T ,pg e rr
-r
9
Explain your answer. 24. The tensor product of two vectors is called a dyad_ A sum of such products is called a dyadic. 1(a) Write the dyad ab as the sum of symmetric and asymmetric terms, t(b) Let e( ') be a set of mutually orthogonal unit vectors. Show that (c) Try to state and prove some little theorems involving dyads. (d) Show by construction that every second order tensor is a dyadic. 25. (a) If U is a nonsingular symmetric tensor, show that U - t is symmetric _ (b) Show that (A B} = BT- AT . (c) Prove that a nonsingular second order tensor R possesses an inverse so that (28) holds. (d) Show that (C • D) - 1 = D - ' - C - ' `
2.2 The Eigenvalue Problem In this section we shall be concerned primarily with the problem of determining the eigenvalucs associated with a symmetric second order tensor.* We shall thereby discover a coordinate system in which the components of such a tensor assume an especially simple form. The eigenvalue problem turns out to be one of the most fundamental in all mathematics, but it is at first not
•
Many readers will he familiar with the eigenvalue problem fur square matrices andlor linear transformations. They wits Find tittle new in this section.
Kb, 2
Cartesian rr'nsurs
50
clear why one ought to consider it at ail. We can, however, find some motivation in the sort of investigation that moved Cauchy to begin the study of eigenvalue problems, namely a deeper study of stress. The relation between the stress vector t and the unit normal n is typically that shown in Figure 2.3(a), (We consider a particular point x and time t throughout, so we do not explicitly indicate the dependence oft on x and t.) It is not unreasonable to anticipate that there are directions n such that the corresponding stress vectors t(n) point in the n-direction, as in Figure 2.4(a). In such a case t(n) — do for some scalar A. Because tl — n) _ — t(n), a small •' flake" whose relatively large flat surfaces are perpendicular to n is subjected to a particularly simple set of normal stresses [Figure 2.4(b]]. The stresses simply act to extend the flake, or to compress it if A is negative. Compare Figure 2.4(b) with Figure 2.3(b); in the former there is a shear stress component of t perpendicular to n. This can perhaps be seen more clearly in Figure 2.3(c) in which the stresses have been resolved into components that are respectively normal and tangential to the flake. ti
tal
1
tb}
k)
2.3. (a) Typical refarrorPslirp between th e unit exterior aorr+ta l n and the stress rector t(n). (h) The stress rectors on opposite /ares aj' a small thin "flake" are equal in magnitude and point in opposite directions. (c) Stres.s vectors (dashed arrows) are resolved into components of shear (along the surface of the N1► e) und r.vtension (normal to the flake). FIGiJRe
Pure extension is a relatively simple state of stress. It is worth investigating whether such states generally de exist_ We thus ask ourselves the question: "Are there any directions n such that 1(n) = An for some scalar A?" Using the relation t(n) = n • T we can pose the question in terms of the stress tensor T: Given T, find n such that n - T = An. Indeed, if we can find any vector v satisfying v • T = ;ry
( 1)
we shall have virtually achieved our objective. We merely need to divide both sides of (l) by lid to see that r/Jv) is the desired unit vector n.
Sec. 2.2] The Eigenualue Problem
51
tl+tij - hn
1(n)
1( (J)
F1€;t3RE
2:4. (a)
(b)
Th e 3urftwe element with direction n suffers u purely normal
stress.. (t}) A flake that suffers purely extension, not to shear_
normal Stress will be subject only to
Let us select a particular set of base vectors 0 1 , In ternis of the associated components of v and T, CO becomes
o; T = "iv) or
v; }; _
(2a, l})
,
Fquurioris (1) and (2) are alternative sraterrterirs of the rnathernaticai problem that wewisii todiscriss Note that throughout this section by tensor" we shall understand "second order tensor." Writing (2b) as .
26,j ) = O,
(3)
we see that it can he considered as a set of three equations for the three unknowns r; - These equations clearly have the trivial solution y 1 = O. This solution is unique unless the determinant of coefficients vanishes. For a nontrivial solution to exist, therefore, it is necessary that the determinant of coefficients be iero, i.e., li
fJ^.`t
CI; —
--
A
TL 3
T12
7 :21
T22 -
T3]
T32
A
723
T3 3
;
O.
(4)
A
Expanding the determinant in (4), we find that --J. 3 + 1,1 2 - 1 +1 3 =a,
(5)
where l i — Ti.. z
T11 12 1
(6a)
T1 2 ^22
1 3 = dot (74).
+
Tl 1
T13
431
T33
+
T.2 2
3
T32
T3 3
(6b)
()
Cartesian Tensors [Ch. 2
52
Equation (5) is called the characteristic equation. Its roots (the zeros of the characteristic polynomial) are the eifienvalues or characteristic values of T. We shall denote them by A" ), i = I, 2, 3. The cigenvalues satisfy (1), a coordinate-free equation, so that they must have the same value no matter what coordinate system is used. The coefficients in (5) must therefore be scalars. This can be verified directly. For example, consider the first principal invariaat 1 , also termed the trace and denoted by tr T. This is the contraction of a second order tensor, and hence is a scalar (Exercise I.4). The coefficients of the characteristic equation can be economically characterized. To do this, we need two definitions. The principal dingoes' of (Ti j) consists of T11 , T22, and T33. An mth order principal minor of a third order matrix is an rn by m determinant formed by deleting the row and column of 3 — m terms in the determinant's principal diagonal. Thus the first, second, and third order principal minors of the matrix l 4 7
2 5 8
3 6 —9
are the determinants
^ll = 1, 1 5 1= 5, 1 - 91= —9, 3 7 1 —9 '
IS8 —9 '
1 4
2 5 '
and I 4 7
2
5 8
3 6 —9
respectively.
Theorem 1. The principal invariants I I , 12, and
equal, respectively. the sum of all different principal minors of orders 1, 2, and 3. Proof. We merely verify by inspection that the determinants in (6) are principal minors of the required order. p 13
Corresponding to each eigenvalue An», we can determine a nonzero eigeovector or characteristic vector v that satisfies (2). We denote the eigenvector corresponding to Al°1 by vtrl. With this notation, (2) reads t,4P 7 = xiri vl rybij (no sum on p). vrTii = Ali4v114 or (7a, b) Because our discussion was motivated by means of the stress tensor, we began with the eigenvalue problem (1) REMARK.
v •T= kw,
Sec. 211 The Eigenraahse Problem
53
but frequently there arises the related problem
T•w= .^w. It is easily seen that the characteristic equation corresponding to the latter problem is the same as (4), so one can speak of the eigcnvalucs of T But the equations that give the components of the eigenvectors are not the same in the two cases, so one must speak of Left and right eigenvectors of T. In the important special case wherein T is symmetric, one refers to the eigenvectors, for then the right and left eigenvectors are identical. Exemple I. Find the eigenva Ries and eigenvectors for the symmetric second order tensor T whose components in a certain coordinate system are I
0
0
^ 4
9
0 0
Solution.
-
4
In this case (4) becomes l
0
0
—A Il 0 4
A da 4
t]
4
=0
(8)
9 — ►i 4
or
0—(l —A)(
^
—h)^4 —
—6 1 (l—^l=(i— i^)(2—).1t3 —dl,
SO
Am=1, A''=2, A''-3. (Each individual can choose for himself which eigenvalue he chooses to designate kto, which ,1(21, and which dr31 .) When A _ At') = 1, the three equations of (7) become 0=0,
+ ^^^' t^' =o
.
-
3 r = 0,
^ _ at
(42"
Equations (9h) and (9c) have the unique solution 4" = t` ` = 0, so
1,
for any nonzero constant a
ut
( 9 a, b, c}
Cartesian Tensurs
54
[Ch. 2
When 2. = AI" = 2, (7) becomes
- n^r > _ {),
_
o, (43)42]
2f + (1») = 0. (1 a, b. C)
(-%(2)tl'
j
[The rosiest way to obtain the matrix of coefficients in (10) is to make the stibstiIUtian A -= Al21 in the matrix whose determinant appears in (8).1 Multiplication of (10c) by -
gives (10b), so (t0b) and (10c.) are dependent. We find that vS21 =
=0,
b, ll21 fb,
for any nonzero constant b. Thus 1.{21 = be {21 +
I31
When A = 1131 = 3, (7) becomes - 2 0»
T
U,
-
1 u,] f
4
—e^-)v^]} — (-)0311 = 0.
= 0,
—
which yields ^
{]I
= — V eeS^1 # C4 1]1 ,
for any nonzero cons t ant c. (By deflnition,eigenvectors arc nonzero, so e = O is un accepta bte.} If we want our eigenveclors le be of unit length, we can take V II)
=
e I^1 .
v121 =
^1^1
2
^t
+^
Observe that the unit vectors
2
{31,
^
1]^ - – 23 ^
– —
^^1 + 2 e1!}
(li ^
of (11) are mutually perpendicular: l,t11.
Yo
This is not an accident, but it is connected with the symmetric character of the particular matrix whose eigenvalues and eigcnvectors we just determined. For comparison, here are the results of a second example. Ex*mp!e 2. Consider the second order tensor whose components in a certain coordinate system are 1 t}
0
fl
0
1
t)
–4
U
Determine a set of eigcnvectors and discuss their orthogonality_ Partial solution. As the reader is asked to show [Exercise 3(a)1, the characteristic equation is (1 —2.)(A.' 4 4) = 0.
Sec. 2.2! The Eïye►rralue Problem
55
so ;he cigenvalues are a. 0 = t,
„p i]
2i,
dit3i =
with corresponding right eigenvcctors ue 1L
vr2t
= b&2
f 2jbe''f,
11°1
T
real
—
i^! ZiC+C^ .
and L are any nonzero constants_ Note that there are complex eigenvalucs and that the corresponding eigentectors have complex components. When complex components are possible, one usually takes the scalar product of vectors to be where a, h,
{r, w> - L
,
(12)
where an uverbar denotes complex conjugate_ This definition preserves the property of nonnegativc length: (13) Bul
n ow (w,") = (w. i>.
(14)
(Fer real vectors, v •w = w• v_) Whatever scalar product we use, v (21 and v'" are no longer or ihogonal, i.e., their scalar product is not zero For
v42 '. N 3 ' = 6e• + 4hr. # C; <1,1 n. 03)) =bc-4bc#O. FIGENVALLES AND EIG[NVECTDRS OF SYMMETRIC TENSORS We now present two theorems for symmetric tensors that are suggested by the difference between Example 1 and Example 2. (The importance of symmetric tensors is indicated by the observation that the stress tensor of a nonpolar material is symmetric.) We first show that we can discard the possibility of having complex cigenvalues and eigcnvectors with complex components. Definition I. A tensor is said to be real if its components arc real numbers_ Theorem 2. The cigenvalues of a real symmetric tensor are real numbers. Each eigenvcctor of such a tensor can be chosen so that its components are real. The result on which the proof of Theorem 2 depends is, it turns out, best stated as a separate lemma. Lemma 1. Let u and r be vectors. If T is a symmetric tensor, then u•T•v=v T- u.
Proof
(15)
By the properties of the contraction product, both sides of (l5) are scalars, So whatever coordinate system we choose, we shall obtain the same
Cartesian Tensors [C h. 2
56
quantities for the right and left sides of (l 5). Using the symmetry of T,
u - T;v= uT } v —r^11 v;=aT;u;=Y•T - u_ 0
(16)
Proof uf Theorem 2. Suppose that v-T
,v
(1 7)
v # O.
,
Taking the complex conjugate of (17), and using the fact that T is real, we obtain
V- T =v
(18)
We take the scalar product of (17) with v and subtract the scalar product of (18) with v v- T• k— v• T- v= A v• v= v• v. The k it side of this equation equals zero by the symmetry property (15). Thus (A
—
Inv I) = 0,
( 1 9)
-
since for any vectors v and w (in particular, when w =
v•w=w•v.
(20)
But v•vEIv
U,
since v^O
,
(21)
so (f 9) implies that A = A, Thus A is real. With 1_ = A, (18) becomes
v T- =Ai
(22)
which shows that if v is an eigenvector, so is i, Adding (22) to (17) and multi-
plying by f we find that ,
i(v +
• T = A(v + v) or (Re v) • T = ).[Re v).
Thus Re y is an eigenvec_tor if it is not zero_ Similarly, so is Im v. At least one of these will be a real eigenvector.* 0
Theorem 3. Figenvectors of a real symmetric tensor that correspond to distinct eigen values are orthogonal (perpendicular). Proof Let u and v be eigenvectors corresponding tu the eigenvalucs p and A, / # _. 'Then
u -T
=
v - T = A v.
(23a. h)
• In this discussion, by a vsxtnr we mean a first order tensor whose components may be complex numbers_ If r has components u,, then Rev. by definition • has components Re The reader should vcc ify that Re w is a vector if r is.
Sec - 2.21
The Eigenvalue Problem
57
We take the scalar product of v with (23a) and the scalar product of u with (23b):
u •T•v= pu •v,
v- T• u=2v•u-
(24a, b)
Subtracting (24b) from (24a) and using the symmetry property (15), we obtain
pu•v -
-
iv• u
0,
(25)
or, using (20),
(,u — 1)(u • r) — U. But j # 1., so u v = 0, as required. -
(26)
1[1
Careful examination of the proofs of Theorems 2 and 3 will show that they required only that T generate a linear transformation of vectors w, that T satisfy the symmetry property (15), and that the vectors be subject to a scalar product satisfying certain properties such as (20) and (21). A splendid chapter in mathematics is centered on the demonstration that, by means of shrewdly chosen definitions, the class of linear symmetric operators on vectors with scalar products can be made to include a large number of seemingly unrelated objects, and thus that theorems which are true for the relatively humble linear operator on "arrows" (vectors) remain true in far wider contexts. Appendix 12.1 provides elements of the required generalizations. PRINCIPAL AXES
Consider a real symmetric tensor T with distinct eigenvalues. According to Theorems 2 and 3, such a tensor possesses three real mutually orthogonal eigenvectors. We expect that the components of T will have an especially simple form if we take the eigenvectors of T as a basis for an intrinsic coordinate system. To explore this matter, let 7; ; be the components of T relative to an arbitrary basis e[ °. Choose a new basis Or satisfying Or = Id'', where Y{`" denotes the mutually orthogonal eigenvectors corresponding to the distinct eigenvalues The new components Tp q are found from the transformation law, "
T
(27)
+pig;
But trip
T e [ri . eIrl' -_
(28)
—
where OF) is the t;th component of vim With the characteristic equation (7a) and the orthogonality property, the transformation law (27) thus gives
T pq = viFlvJ } Tg1
Auit.[p}u'y } =
na
(29)
CdrresiQn Tensors [CJ,. 2
58
In matrix form, AO} 0 (no
-
-
A(F) ^
0
t^
n
( 30 )
3
0
M
We sum up as follows. Definition 2. If a second order tensor T possesses mutually orthogonal eigcnvectors, these vectors can be used as a basis for a coordinate system. In such a case, the components of T are said to be determined with respect to principal axes. Theorem 4. Let T be a real symmetric tensor with distinct cigenvalues_ Then, with respect to principal axes the components of T are given by the diagonal matrix of(30). The elements on the principal diagonal are the eigenvalues. It is often the case that once a result has been derived, it can be proved more simply. in the present instance, using (1.20a) we can provide a one line derivation of (30). Indeed, using the cigenveetors of T as a basis, we have Tl = LT . 0 "11 =- {) use a l t = At4(5,, We now illustrate what can happen when the cigcnvalues are not distinct. Example 3.
Ccunsider a second order tensor whose cc}mponertls in a
certain CoOr di-
nate system are
(31) Show that there are only two distinct eigenvectors_ What does this imply about the possibility of choosing a coordinate system in which the components of the tensor Form a diagonal matrix? Pzrriaisofrriaa.
The characteristic equation is (1 - 2)(2 — 2) 2 = 0,
so the ergenvaluc-s are ^[rt
= 1, au]
=
2.
Corresponding to At't, we find the eigenvcctor titi = act"; corresponding to Pt und 2{31. we find only the single eigcnvector v 121 = be [Exercise 3(b)J. With only two eigcnvcctors we cannot determine the three directions necessary for principal axes. At first, one might think of taking the third direction as perpendicular to rt'r and r1 '}, but this is no help_ If we did this, our - new - set of base vectors would turn out to be the old one, with respect to which the components, given by (31), are not diagonal-
See_ 2.2)
The E#yer+tohre Problem
5^#
The matrix (31) is not symmetric. It turns out that real -Sy cr?letrtt - tensors always have three linearly independent eigcnvectors, even when the cigenvalues are not distinct. We now provide a proof al this fact, although certain details are left to Exercise S .
'i ltenrern 5. A real symmetric tensor T always possesses three o r t h o n o rm a l matrix (30) can always be found foreignvctors.Thuadlinte such tensors whether or not the cigenvalues are distinct. Proof. Let T,-, be the components of T with respect to a particular Cartesian coordinate system. If the characteristic polynomial z
-`
— +l
-12)+ 13 — 0
has repeated zeros, certain equations must relate these components. (If zeros are distinct, the result is guaranteed by Theorem 4.) For example. if is a triple root, the polynomial is + 3cP
3(. 2 ; + r 3 ,
so that the equations
f i -- 313 3, 1 2 =
3
must hold. In the erase of repeated roots, choose continuous functions T,{c) in such a way that the equations above do not hold for c # 0, and such that 7;14) = 7,,(*;), 7,0) = T.
(32)
The 7:11c) are components of a real symmetric tensor TO.) with distinct eigenvalues ME) and hence, by Theorem 3. wish orthonnrmal eigenvect€ rs e9r.p eliV) = ii 11 . Taking the limit as c
0, we find that e ln(0) - 01t10) =
Thus the e"u(D) are the desired eigenvectors. If these vectors are taken as new axes, the diagonalization of T follows as in the proof of Theorem 4- LI EXERCISES
I. Verify that 14) implies that #5) and (6). 2. Show that J J 4!T•; T! — Ti, Tt ) and hence verify i hat 1 2 is a scalar. 3. Verify the results riven an the text for ta) Example 2, (hl Exampk 34. t(a) Find the left cigcnvectors of the tensor discussed in Example 2. part (a) guess an orthogonality theorem con(b)Fromthesulf cerning right and left cigenvectois_ Prove the theorem. ,
6o
Curresidn Tensors [Ch. 2
S. t(a)
Find thceigenvalucs andeigenvec:tors fnrthctensorwithcnrnponents
ü
0
ü
D
0
1 _ D
—1
(b) Note that the eigenveclors corresponding to nonzero cigenvalues have the curious properly that v • v = 0. Show that this property holds for all antisymrnetric tensors. 6. Verify (13) and (14) 7. Find the eigenvalues and corresponding eigenvectors of unit length for the tensor T whose components in a certain coordinate system are .
0
--I 3
l\
0
4
0
.
Verify that the eigenvectors are mutually orthogonal. Give a geometric description of the rotation of axes that will put the coordinate matrix of T into diagonal form. S. (a) Write down an explicit set of components T»:) that satisfy (32)in the case where the characteristic polynomial has a triple zero. (b) Repeat (a) in the case where the characteristic polynomial has a double zero and another distinct zero_
2.3 The Calculus of Tensor Functions Until now we have considered tensor cunstants. This was a necessary preliminary to a discussion cf tensor functions whose components are functions of one or more variables_ Exam* I. (a)
f he cyuxtiun of a space curve Is
x^ X(s),
aSs
where the position vector x is a function of the parameter s. (b) The veiociiy of n particle is given by v = v(r[, where the velocity vector y is a function of the time r. (c) By T = 7'(x, r) we denote the stress tensor of a material at position x, time r. As here, when a tensor is a f-unciit}n of position x we sometimes speak of a tensor field. ,
To see clearly how the transformation laws most be modified when we pass from constants to functions, it is perhaps easiest to concentrate first on vector fields. Let r(x) denote such i held, so that (to give a coordinate-free description) a vector v is prescribed at each point X. if a Cartesian coordinate
Sec. 2.3] the Calculus of Tensor Functions
6i
system is selected, the vector field can be described by assigning components at each point: 11; =
VAX', x2, x3}.
In another, primed, system, the description is YY
= I '1
X 1+ x 2 , x3)r1 •
What relation must obtain between the two triples of functions u, and vj2 To see, focus attention on a particular point 3t, with coordinates (1,, in the imprinted system. Let
=
^l..
so that the triple of numbers (xi , +c2, . J are the components in the primed system of the same point x. Thus . 3 ) and [xi, xi , _TO are components of the same vector; they must therefore be related by the usual transformation law. Consequently,
viii.
R29 k"!) _ iii
lc;
where
-
c
❑w
^]
The tildes were introduced to focus attention on a single point. "this point was arbitrarily selected, so that the tildes can be dropped. Furthermore, it is convenient to make the notation more compact hy using the functional relationships x = x(x') and x' � re(x)
(2a, h)
to denote x P - /x9 and x' — x r Pa
(3d, h)
'
With this (1) can be written r,.(x) = /,..0114x) J.
(4a)
CPO = u^Cx(x)^^;^
(4h)
Similarly, we also have
The corresponding transformation laws for second order tensor fields are fjx]
{ Îm f fn ^mN` x'S ii)^
(53)
+ m r^ T xix')].
(511)
and Tm,t[x']
The concepts of limit, continuity, and derivative are defined for tensor functions in exact analogy with their definition for scalar functions. For example, if we denote the partial derivative with respect to time hy r?r , then
T(x,t)= him ai-o
T(x,f +Air)At
T(x '
^ ] .
62
Cartesian Tensors
[Ch. 2
Since the Iii are constants, differentiation of the transformation law shows that the time derivative of a tensor (if it exists) is a tensor of the same order. There arc a number of notations connected with the process of differentiating a tensor field with respect to a position coordinate x 1 . Two frequently used notations for ô I fi:3x p are ap T and Tu ,. Direct notation is achieved by means of the "del" operator V, defined by ;
[V]e du
(6)
x
Thus, by definition, if T isasecond order tensor, f T?
(7)
Jpij — Op 7 7 ;i -
In words, VT is often called "the gradient of T" and is sometimes written "grad T" Divergence and curl are also defined by generalizations of their familiar definitions for vectors: (div TjJ - [V' T1 id,T}!
[curl
rig
-
(8 )
[V A T]ia = r ut, i3J Ti+4
- F
(9)
^JR ^F9•!"
As in the previous section, our discussions will often be confined to second order tensors, but they have obvious extensions to higher order tensors. For example, if T is a third order tensor, VT and V - T are defined by
1 ij k = [V- nik t a drift = Ti". rTheorem 1. If 7' is a tensor field of order ni, then VT is a tensor fjeld of order m + 1. Proof when rn = 2. The rule for determining components is given in (7). Let us write it out in full, using standard notation for partial derivatives: [V ()] A^,
[T,^(x)].
(loa)
We must prove the transformation law,
Employing (IOa), and explicitly noting the role of the independent variable, we can write this law in the form epLeirn^^al
Ô^^
aR
^! j{7^^^ '= ^ ` ^ •
(
1 Oh)
See. 2.3) The' Calculus of Terrsur Functions
[^
' and -1;i and remembering [ hat the / ,, are But using relation (Sb) between "F„„ constant, we have f
C1
x; 7 m„(x') = imi
Tii[x(x')]
The partial derivative on the right side can be determined by use of the chain rule:
c C^]Ck
7 ;;[x(x')] =
G^]CP
Tf(x)
ex
^
(l2a)
,
xix'j OXk
From (3a), however, (12b) We thus obtain the desired transformation law (10) by combining (I L) (12a), and (12b). ,
Theorem 2. If T is a tensor field of order m, then V - T is a tensor field of order rn -- I. in particular, if v is a vector field, then V - v div v is a scalar field. Proof. V- T is a contraction of the (ni + 1)st order tensor VT, se the conclusion follows by a result of the type of Theorem F4. C Theorem 3. If T is a tensor field of order n,, then V A T is also a tensor held of order rr2. In particular, if iv is a vector field, then V A t' is a vector held. Proof_ Left to the reader.
THEOREMS FOR DERIVATIVES OF TENSOR FIELDS
The subscript notation makes it easy to derive useful identities. For example, if and v are differentiable scalar and vector fields, then V-
(bv) = (04 ) .), `
tea + ^^
L
` 4d • 1 + dŸ • v.
Here are some examples of how the alternator can be used in deriving certain useful formulas involving vector fteids. The proofs are rather easy, but we shall write out several of them to provide examples. Theorem 4. Proof.
div curlv =9•0nk yf} ❑ ` ( lI
A Y l = ^ijk ^k . li — ^i ^ pit. ail
(13)
where the last equation assumes that ta k has continuous second partial derivatives so that the order of partial differentiation can be interchanged.
Cartesian Tensors [Ch
64
_
2
We rewrite the first equation in (13), exchanging the dummy subscripts i and j. V • (V A v) = e1;^ i :^ ; _
(14)
^
13ut =
so (14) can be written Y • (Y A 1 }=
—
E l jf
k.
Comparison of (1 b) and (13) gives the desired result. 'theorem S. curl grad J — V n Proof Left to the reader _
(Vbj =
Theorem 6. V A (V A v) V(V• ^?
Proof.
z
V) ---
0
O.
V 2 v, where
= i1m. ;; .
1 Jsing the cb rule,
^,{ &., gn) tj uk A— ia,a,v, = (V(V•v)— V z vl m -
ç ,j [Y^ A V A l'3, — ERnn. a n Erjk ;Vh = ([} rn^" ^
,,
In writing the last expression, we assumed that tin has coritir+uous second partial derivatives so that the order of On and Om could be interchanged_ (In order that the expression V A V A r be defined, v must, of course, possess second partial derivatives, Nit they need not be continuous) U Theorem 7. Proof [Y
V
A
(V
A
v)
IV(x • v} — (r • V)v. 6,,,4S,01Jn r?11.k
A (V AV)] m = ERnaiVnEijk^ j i }k 4(^m 1 ^ n k
=
t;n l^ n.
rn — L' n {^ n Um — ;i0m(ün v n ) — i1 n en t1„'
[IV(v • v) — (r • V }v L .
0
INTE(;RAt. THEOREMS
It is worthwhile recording the results of the divergence theorem and Stokes's theorem* using subscript natation: Divergence theorem n it),- da — jiff i v; ; tdr.
• All vector integral lheorctssm requtre sultictrns smoothness of the functions and boundaries invo [vcd. See,
KeIIog (1924]_
Sec. 2.3] The Calculus of Tensor Functions-
65
Stokes's theorem: I F d5 =
Eiikng ejG'kdff.
BS
Let us consider the divergence theorem a little further. Suppose that v has only one nonzero component, so that v, --riA5 i, for sonie scalar function rti and for any fixed integer j, j = 1, 2, or 3. Then the divergence theorem gives
n1 el da =ffJ i c' dt
j= 1, 2, or 3.
(l7j
li
dR
Since (17) is truc for any j, it follows that
dR
n()) da l fff d_'
(18)
R
which is Gauss's theorem. This theorem and the divergence theorem itself,
j
i
^ - v dr,
n-vdcr_
can be generalized to make a statement about general tensor fields, as we shall soon show_ First, we give an example that clarifies the theorem to follow. Example Z. Show that the quantity on the left of (20) is a (Constant) third order tensor. Solution. In primed and unpriined systems, let the components of nTdir be given by ' rr
-
nT da OR
P4f
r:p7Qdrs OR
and
nT
n, T r d u _
^
A te
We rriLLSt
iik
PR
prove that
nT da or
air
But the expression within the square brackets vanishes because nT is a third order tensor.
66
Cartesian Tensors [Ch_
2
Theorem 8. Lin is the unit exterior normal to a region R and T is a tensor, then
jEjn.Tdu= JJf v
(19)
OR
JJJVT dr.
n T"da ^R
(20)
R
Proof of (20) when T is a second order tensor. The quantity on the right of (20) is a third order tensor, with components given by
[
Jff
fffiv! k
vTd i = ]
ijk
!t
dT.
R
As for the third order tensor on the left of (20)- for any fixed j and k, can simply be regarded as an ordinal y function of x so, by (17),
Tf(x)
,
{J
I k dtr —
aR
fJJ
c' i 7 & dr.*
R
We have thus proved that the components of the tensors in (20) are equal in one arbitrary coordinate system. As usual, this is enough to ensure that the tensors themselves are eq ual. 0 Trivial modifications make this proof of (20) serve when T is an nth order tensor. Utilization of the same ideas leads at once to a proof of (19) and to a proof of the following generalization of Stokes's theorem. Theorem 9. As in the usual version of Stokes's theorem, consider a surface S with normal n Let OS be the curve bounding S and t be the appropriately oriented unit tangent vector to OS. Let T be a tensor of arbitrary order. Then
Ç
T.tds_-fJV •
A
T.nd7
(21)
s
as
* To remember these theorems, note that a V in a triple integral change; to an n in thc corresponding double integral_ The same mnemonic work with indcz natation, as is shown by the index vcrsinn ni{t9l.
ffn' T, da = ffia: -ri, a r_ ret
Here n, •- ► df . Note, however. that although n, i = Ti rs,, the former order (bumming on adjace nt mnemonic is to be employed. subscripts) must be usai if the
Sec. 2_J] The
Calculus of Trrrsor Fiala iarrs
67
The exercises contain some applications of tensor calculus to physical situations. A number of other applications will appear later_ In particular, Appendix 2.1 lists some fundamental equations of continuum mechanics in subscript notation. We shall devote much further study to these equations. REPRESENTATION THEOREMS
Theorems 4 and 5 state that u=Vny and
w= V
imply that ❑
V•u=0 and
A w--
l1,
respectively. Of great use are the converses of these theorems and their generalizations. We provide some classical results of this ty pe here The first two theorems concern a continuously differentiable vector field connected domain. wdefinovrasmply .
Theorem 10. There exists a single-valued function b such that w — if and only ifVAw=O_ Proof. See Exercise 14.
❑
Theorem 11_ If and only if V- w = 0 does there exist a solenoidal (i.e., divergence-free) vector field w such that
w =V
A
r,
Alternatively, if and only if V • w z- 0 does there exist scalar Fields 1,10 and y such that
w- V Prnof.
A
( OVA -
See Exercise 15 or At-is (1962, Sec. 143).
Theorem 12 (Helmholt-r. Representation Theorem). Let w he finite, continuous, and approach a limit at infinity. Then there exist scalar fields , , and y and a solenoidal vector field v that permit one to write ,
w=Vint+VAv
or w — Vc+VA ifiVy
Proof Given w, we wish to obtain 4' such that V -(w — Vt) = O. Hut V 2 0 = V- w is a Poisson equation whose solution is given by the integral formula (16.1.7) of i. Since w — gc is solenoidal, the result follows by Theorem 11.
n
68
Cariesldn Tensors [Ch. 2
EXERCISES
1. (a) Prove Theorem 1 when T is a fist order tensor; i.e_, show that if v is a vector field, then Vv is a second order tensor field. (b) As an exercise in juggling subscripted subscripts, prove Theorem l in the general case. 12. Prove Theorem 3 when m = 1. 3. Prove 'theorem 5. A full statement of the theorem requires an assumption about the scalar field 0; what is this assumption? 4. State Theorems 7 and 8 using the terms "curl, ,, "grad," and "div." S. Let u, v, and w be vector fields and let and 1,6f be scalar fields. Find alternative expressions for the following: (a) grad (0); (b) div (u A v); (c) V • [u A (v A w)]; (d) V • (V0 A V+ ); (e) V A (0); (1) curl (v n w); $(g) curl (0r). 6. (a) Show that V n(unr)=u(V•V)+(v V)u--v(V - u) — (u•4)v. $(b) Show that V(u-v) = (u- V)v + (v• V)u + u A (V n v) + V A (V n u). 7. When T is a third order tensor, write out a proof (a) of Theorem 8; (b) of Theorem 9. The next few exercises exploit the power of the formalism that we have developed to derive several important results concerning the vorticity (local spin) of fluid motion. Section 3.5 contains a general discussion of the role of these and similar results in understanding fluid flows. S. (a) The vorticity w of a velocity field v is defined by ru = curl v. Show that curl a =
Dt
— w • grad v + w div v,
(22)
where Dt
(b)
4,r+v• V
Dv
and a = — Di
are the substantial derivative and the acceleration, respectively. Deduce the Beltrami equation. w) D(p - , — p` r w• grad r+ p -r curl a. (23a) Dt
(c) By definition, p = p(p) in a barotropic fluid. Consequently, one can V J p - I dp. Take this result for granted here. write p - IV
Sec_ 131 The {.'alcufus of frrr.sur horcriom
t^y
fit is the subject of Exercise 15.13 of E.) Show that in an inviscid barotropic fluid subject to a conservative body force.
D(0. -1) 1o). grad rDi = P -
(23b)
9. Integrate (23 b) as follows: +(a) Define V, W, and S as the velocity, vorticity. and density in material coordinates:
V(A, r) = v[x(A. t), t]. W(A, t) = [x(A, t) tj, .6(A, i) = p[x(A, ^) f]. ,
Write (23b) in indicial notation after having made the substitution x = x(A. t). (h) introduce a function C(A, t) by the equations r _},
W
-
?A ;
For C to be well defined, we must assume that J # (J, where J is the Jacobian 41(x1ax2, x3)
MA I , A2,143) Why? Show that r3C = O. Deduce the rorikity diteoprnenr equation
'W - 6n 'W,, ' J
( 24)
where
Grit
r7x; ,
— ^t^ t o ), ,
W u. _ W(A, r o).
The vorticity development equation was obtarned by Cauchy in 1815. J. Serrin recently gave an entirely different derivation, which is essentially outlined above_ 10. Consider barotropic motion of an inviscici fluid subject to conservative body forces. (a) Show that the vorticity development equation implies that a portion of fluid initially in irrotational motion (co = ü) will remain irrotational motion (Lagrange --Cauchy theorem). if to = Q in V A Y .= 0, then v = V for some Function cP. The existence of has far-reaching consequences, some of which are explored in the material concerning fluid mechanics_ (b) Show that in a two-dimensional flow (w = iVaz -= 0) a fluid particle retains its initial value of p ru].
7°
Cartesian Tensors
[Ch. 2
11. Using subscript notation, show that (14.3.4) of I can be written
JJJ
x
A
(f'
Dr ~pf—V.
T di,
T) dz =
R
(25)
R
where T is the stress tensor and [7s], = ik TA. Assuming conservation of linear momentum, deduce the symmetry of the stress tensor. 12. This problem deals with angular momentum for polar fluids. The starting point is Equation (14.15) of I. (a) Show that the couple stress vector c(x, t, n) satisfies c = n. C for some couple stress tensor C(x, r). (b) Obtain a differential equation form of (143.5) of I. assuming that integrands are continuous. Subtract the vector product of x and (14.2.19) of 1_ Deduce DI
p^t =
g+P - C + Ti -
(26)
In general, then, internal angular momentum is generated by body torques, stress couples, and the antisymmetric part of the stress tensor. 13. The purpose of this exercise is to show that balance of energy and certain invariance requirements lead to balance of linear momentum, balance of angular momentum, and so on. This material appears in a note by A. E. Green and R. S. Rivlin [Z. Angew. Muth. Physik 15, 290 (19fî4)]. (a) Energy balance is postulated in the form + pet Llr — i 1[71
I1
+
pF^ v 1Itit
—h + C i v;] drr,
(27)
dR
where r is heat supply per unit mass and time (perhaps from radioactivity) and h is heat efflux per unit area per unit time. What are the other symbols in (27), and what is the meaning of the other terms? (b) Equation (27) is supposed valid for all velocity fields, in particular for v, + a i , where a ; is an arbitrary vector that is constant in space and time. Suppose that e, r f , F1 , h, and r are the same for two motions that differ only by constant rigid translations, represented by aj . Write (27) when v i is replaced by vi + a i , subtract (27) in its original form, and deduce the integral formulation of the balance of linear momentum.
Sec. 2-3]
(c)
The Cuir rha. of Tenu-or Functions
7I.
Just as in Section 14.2 of 1, one can now derive =
(d)
"Ii ;
(28)
and the differential equation for linear momentum balance. Use these results and (27) to derive 1JJt i
—
pr —
I t J, k] dT
— fri h rla.
(29)
eR (e)
Assume that e, r, T. and h are the same for two motions which differ only by a uniform rigid rotation. Now if u t -# v + uniform rigid rotation, then vi.k ta}.k +
Rho
PO]
where i2 1k is an arbitrary constant antisymmetric tensor. Explain. Make the transformation (30) in (29) and obtain nfk
Jf$
TLJ d = 0.
(31)
R
(g)
Show how (31) implies that TA — Tk ^. (This part requires knowledge of the material at the beginning of Section 3.1.) As in (14.4.20) of I,
h = 101
(32)
for some vector Q1 . The usual constitutive equation that is taken to relate the heat flux hector Q r with the temperature f is Q1 = xB,} (Exercise 3.1.5). Use this and the symmetry of the stress tensor to rewrite (29) in the form of a differential equation involving the rate of deformation tensor. 14. Let VA W-0 in a simply connected domain D, where w is continuously differentiable. Let 0 be a fixed reference point in D, and let P be a point corresponding to x. Define P
¢{x) =
w • t ds, 0
^
where Stokes's theorem permits the line integral to be taken along any path in D (t being the tangent vector). Prove that a0/ 0x, = w ; by applying the definition of partial derivative and by taking as a path from x to x + (4.4et 1 the straight line parallel to the coordinate vector e'`'. 15. Let * be the continuously differentiable solenoidal vector field that is the subject of Theorem IL (a) Let the differential equations dxidt = w ; [xtr)], t a parameter, 1, 2. Using r.,; a have two solutions given implicitly by ,f,(x)
72
Cartesian Ierisnrs
[Ch. 2
geometrical reasoning, show that one can write w= 2 Vf,
Af2
for some scalar function A. lb) Let f3(x) be such that J = del (Of!f lx,) # 0. Regarding the f as coordinates of x, show that row ;
N.
Px, afin
,
and deduce that 1, is a function off, and f2z fonly. (c,1 Let
where f2 is held constant in the integration_ Identify x with fz and v with irvy; then complete the proof of Theorem 1 I.
Appendix 2.1 Sonic Basic Equations of Continuum Mechanics We give here for reference, and in order to show examples of subscript notation, certain basic equations of continuum mechanics. These equations were discussed in l; a summary of the discussion appears in Section 14.5 of I_ We consider a nonpolar single-phase continuous medium that does not exhibit electric, magnetic, or chemical effects. To characterize this medium, we employ the following unknowns:
density p,
pressure p, heat flux vector q ; ,
velocity vector u„
e,
specific internal energy
stress tensor T j .
Regarded as given is the body force per unit mass f,. The field equations arc as follows. Conservation of mass: Op Dt +pL " =
D Dt
a
-+ at
(la) ^'
t1 r 1 .
(lb)
Balance of linear momentum:
Dn^ P^ t
F.^c + ^c. J•
(2)
Appendix 2.11 Some Basic Equations of Continuum Mechanics
73
Balance of moment of momentum:
7 = To .
(3)
Balance of energy: ^^ ^^ra;or
+ e ^=
Pli
-
- T A ].
i);[gi
(4)
There are also important thermodynamic relations (which can be found in Section 14-5 of I), but these will not be given here Examples of constitutive equations, which single out particular types of continuous media, are the following. For an inviscid fluid the stress is purely normal :
(5)
so that the momentum conservation requirement (2)gives the Filler equation, Dv, P ^^ = PI;
- 1^.1 •
The Newton-Fourier law of cooling states that hear flow to temperature gradient: =
(6)
LS
proportional
(7)
PART B Problems in C ontinuum M echanics
CHAPTER 3 Viscous F luid s
P
B develops the constitutive equations for a viscous fluid and a linear elastic solid. Effects of viscosity and elasticity arc explored by solving selected particular problems of mathematical interest This chapter is concerned with illustrating some of the effects of viscosity on fluid motion, and with outlining some of the mathematical ideas that are required in the relevant theoretical investigations. We begin with a derivation of the Navier -Stokes equations, the simplest equations that exhibit viscous effects. By far the largest part of viscous flow theory is based on these equations, for they seem~ to apply in almost all circumstances for common fluids like water and air. Our derivation requires a knowledge of Cartesian tensors, although an alternative derivation not using tensors is outlined in the exercises for Section 3.1_ A sample of the variety of phenomena governed by the Navier-Stokes equations is provided by the investigation of a few exact solutions. We then obtain a simplified version of the equations. This version holds in the "boundary layer" region of rapid variation that is present near solid boundaries in relatively fast, slightly viscous flows. The boundary layer equations are solved for the simplest case, flow past a semi-infinite flat plate. With the background gained, one can obtain a synoptic view of the general problem of fast slightly viscous flow past an obstacle. Another general matter that is considered at this point is the role of voracity in viscous flow. To avoid the impression that relatively slow, highly viscous flows are not of interest, we conclude the chapter with a brief discussion of the important "Stokes flow" past a sphere. The central mathematical idea of the chapter is that of the boundary layer_ The applied mathematician G. F. Carrier has aptly summarized* the importance of Ludwig Prandil's I904 paper in which the ideas of boundary layer theory were first set forth. As Carrier says, its ideas not only permitted Prandtl to solve his problem but have also given rise to a very large body of mathematical formalism commonly referred to as `singular perturbation theory' or `marched asymptotic expansions': more importantly, they also have provided the basic foundations for the heuristically-reasoned, spectacularly successful treatment of many important problems in science and engineering. This success is probably most surprising to rigor - oriented ART
In the paper, "Heuristic Reasoning in Appricd rviaihemalics" [Quart. Appt. Math. 30, I I- IS( 1972)); the coi ire issue dills journal os devoted in symposium, - The FtintrcofApplied Mathcrnarics"
77
Viscous Fluids [Ch . 3
78
mathematicians (or applied mathematicians) when they realize that there still exists no theorem which speaks to the validity or the accuracy of Prandtl's treatment of his boundary layer problem; but seventy years of observational experience leave little doubt of its validity and its value."
3.1
The Navier Stokes Egnations —
Section 15A of I directed attention to the motion of a knife blade through a very viscous fluid (cold molasses). We were led to the hypothesis that shear stresses depend on the relative velocities of adjacent fluid layers. Now, "very viscous fluids" exhibit a relatively large amount of shear stress. For example, air and water do not seem very viscous compared to molasses. We argued, therefore, that it might be reasonable to neglect shear stresses altogether For air and water, and hence to consider purely normal stresses and the accompanying inviscid flow. The ensuing discussions of stratified fluids and compressible flows, for example, led to results that generally appeared in accord with experience, so the neglect of shear stresses seemed reasonable when analyzing those phenomena. But D`Alcmbcrt`s paradox made it evident that the inviscid assumption was nor always a good one. We must develop a constitutive equation that is more widely applicable than the equation I — —pn, which defines an inviscid fluid. ANALYSIS OF THE LOCAL 'VELOCITY FIELD
Since shear stresses depend on relative velocities, let us look more closely at the relative velocities of two nearby points x and y_ We regard x as a fixed reference point and we do not explicitly indicate dependence on the time r_ Then (using the summation convention), a Taylor expansion about x gives L'r(y) — «.(x)=. ^(x)(vs — x3}+ --- , .
(1)
where • - • denotes terms small compared to those retained. More precisely, • - • denotes c„(y s -- x i), where (2 ) if v has continuous second partial derivatives in a domain containing x_ In the language of differentials, if dx°y — x, then
dv, = ur.,(x) dx,.
(3)
Here dv is the first order approximation to dv, where Av = v(y) -- v(x)
w(x • dx) — v(x).
(4)
Ncrwer -Sivkrs Equatio:ra
See. 3 -fj
79
We shall be making the assumption that the stress tensor 7(x) depends on relative fluid velocities only through the velocity gradient tensor v ,4x). En a first attempt to postulate a dependence of stress on relative velocity, it is reasonable to neglect the higher order terms in (1) Should we not obtain results in accord with experience, we can try to formulate new equations that take some of these higher order terms into account At this point it is useful to examine in detail the relative velociticsassfsc,ated With ur . 5(x) in (3), remembering that x is a fixed reference point. To do this, we split up t}, ,5 into its symmetric and antisyrnmetric parts. which we denote by D,„ and 1,. Thus ,
Vr,
s —
v^ here 17 r ^ = D„
Drs 1-
and
— I/sr-
W,
( 5)
Using (2.1.25), we see that the components of D and i•1% are given by /4 rs
(6)
2(r)r.1 — Vs, r)-
'
From (3) and (5), dL' r
= D,a dx s + Wa dx„
(7)
so the relative velocity associated with v i,., can be regarded as the sum of the separate relative velocities associated with D,s and 1;, . By Theorem 2.1.19, the relative velocity described by 14 dx, is a solid body rotation with angular velocity vector —el, where (1)q
i.vi rs(t`'r. s
Hut EWrs'L'r,s = 4
'
,r
'yrs
r,s
s.rs
so
= 4£grs ii .r = AIV A Vlq-
(8)
The relative velocity associated with W is thus equivalent to a solid body rotation with angular velocity vector z curl v, W is called the rotation tensor_ When V A v O (and hence v = Vrk for some scalar function (P), the now is called ïrrotational. We now examine the effect of D by considering relative velocities given by dv w dx • D. Let us write out the components of this equation. To obtain the simplest possible expressions, we choose the principal axes of the symmetric tensor D as basis vectors_ We obtain 4'1Y1
—
v i(x)
-
X,,)
(no
sum on
i),
(9)
where the quantities Pare the eigenvalues of D. Consider an arrow of length L 1 emanating from point x and pointing along the x t -axis (Figure 3.1). Let denote the components of the tip so that, using (9). Y.`" = x ; -t -
u,(y 1 ) — r1(x) = Atr1L1 bi, -
(10a, b)
80
Vs-scram Fluids (C'h 3 xi
x
^
f
l/
x2 _ ^^.,^xl
F1GI;RE 3.1. A rector of length L, aligned
euh, Ike
r r axis_ If the axes are
principal axes, this rector elongates at a rah, per wiry length yiren N. the first
eiyenralue of the deformation tensor. According to (10h), the velocity at the arrow tip differs from the velocity at the arrow hase by an amount d'"L, directed along the arrow. The relative motion of (9) thus causes the arrow to undergo a pure elongation at a rate of P"L L length units per unit time. Dividing by L 1 , we see that »'' represents the rate of elongation per unit length. In like manner, arrows along the x 2 - and x 3 -axes suffer an elongation per unit length per unit time of magnitudes and 13^, respectively. (If one or more of the /1. (1) are negative, the corresponding arrow suffers a negative contraction.) The relative velocity associated with D is thuselongati,r equivalent to a deformation that can be described as the superposition of three elongations in three mutually perpendicular directions given by the cigenvectors of D_ f) is called the deformation tensor or rate-of-strain tensor. Let us summarize the kinematic results we have obtained. It is helpful to rewrite the fundamental equation (7) in the form v(y)=b(x)+(y—x) - (x)+(y—x) - D(x)+--..
(1 I)
Since higher order terms are neglected in ( 1 l ), one often says that (1 I )describes the velocity field in an infinitesimal neighborhood of x. Our discussion has shown that this velocity can be regarded as the superposition of a uniform translation with velocity v(x), a slid body rotation with angular velocity vector I curl i (x), and pure elongations along the three mutually perpendicular principal axes of D(x) at a rate pe r unit length equal to the respective eigenvalues of D(x). ASSUMPTIONS THAT UNDERLIE TFTF CONSTITl.TIVF EQUATION
Six assumptions underlie the relation that we shall ultimately obtain for thesrno: 1. As already stated, we shall assume that the stress tensor T at a point depends only on the velocity gradient tensor at that point. That is, only the first derivatives Vr, r of the velocity components yr will enter. 2. As a result of a change in its makeup, the response of the fluid could be different at different locations in space and time. We rule out consideration of such cases by assuming homogeneity in space and time.
Sec_ 3.1)
T he !V ar ier -Stokes Equarior,s
8i
3. For a given distribution of stress, the response of t: fluid generally caries with its thermody namic state. An example is the fact that molasses becomes less viscous as the temperature increases_ We will have to take this Into account in our constitutive equations. 4_ According to Section 15.1 of I, our constitutive equation must he such that it reduces w the hydrostatic relation Ti = pi5ti when the fluid is motionless_ Putting together the consequences of our discussion thus far, our constitutive relations must take the form 7;f = — pi5 j)+ft
p. 0),
MO. p,0)=ff,
112a,b)
where we have selected the density p and the temperature B to represent the thermodynamic state of the fluid. Equation (12a) contains nine functions fij which are arbitrary except for requirement (12b). N u. The hydrodynamic pressure p rn (12) is generally defined merely as the coefficient of 45 4 . Only in the motionless state can the hydrodynamic pressure be identified with the pressure encountered in equilibrium thermodynamics. 5. We now make the ass:lrrmptiori chat the dependence oaf T on ❑ is linear. This is the simplest extension of inviscid theory. It should he valid if the deformation rates are "small" in some sense, for then products of the derivatives of velocity components will be relatively small With the linearity assumption, (12a) becomes (13)
The coefficients C E ,„ will depend on p and H. By the quotient rule, these coefficients are the components of a fourth order tensor, C. Since 'IJ is symmetric, it must be that (14)
C.' jrrs -
To see this, we interchange i and j in (13) and then use the symmetry of the stress tensor T and the Kronecker delta to obtain = 'l Îj
+
C jirs u,,1.
Upon subtraction of (15) from (13) we find that for arbitrary y r .„ B„rar, s = ü,
where Brs = Cur. —
Cjirl'
In particular, (16a) holds when u 1.1 = 1 and all the remaining cr , are zero. Thus S i , _ O. Proceeding similarly, we seee that all the Br, must be zero, which yields the desired result. 6. As a final simplifying assumption, we restrict our consideration to fluids that are isotropic, by which we mean that there is no preferred direction
82
J./sumo
fluids [f.'li_ 3
in the Muid. To see the consequences of isotropy, consider the constitutive equation (13) in another, primed, Cartesian coordinate system:
— f ", ŸJ +
=
Isotropy demands that the contribution of u„ to 7;1 be identical to the contribution of Cr . , to Teo . Thus 's , _ ['^ # ; i.e., the tensor C is isotropic. In order to obtain a better perception of the maihematical consequences of isotropy, we shall discuss a particular instance. To this end, let us consider a velocity field of the form u e = u i (x 2 ku2 — 1N 3 - O. As illustrated in Figure 3.2(a4,we shadl foots attention on the stress component in the x i direction, which is due to the action of the fluid in the domain x 2 > 4 on the fluid in the domain x 2 < O. This stress component. 72 1 , is the same all akwig the plane s 2 = I]: for definiteness we consider the w1 rests at the origin.
In Figure 3.2(a) this stress is denoted by a heavy arrow. Let us now consider a new flow wherein the velocity field is rotated counterclockwise by 9G [Figure 3.2(b)]. if we perforrn clockwise rotation of the tarok, Figurc 3.2(b) appears identical to Figure 3.2(4 Because the material is assumed to he isotropic, the correspondingly rotated stress [heavy arrow in Figure 3 2(b) I roust be identical with the original stress. The reason is that since there is no preferred orientation in the fluid, one cannot distinguish between an urtrotated look at the vciocity held of Figure 3.2(a) and a rotated look ai the (different} velocity field of Figure 3.2(b). Equivalent to rotating the book, in order to view Figure 3.2(b) sideways, is a 94" clockwise rotation of aptes Thus, using primed axes, the stress component T'2, in Figure 3.2(b) must be identical with the cotrtponent 72 1 in Figure 3.2(a). Similarly, the velocity gradient v'1 , 2 in Figure 3.2(b) must be identical with v 1 _ 2 in Figure 3.2(a). But from the respective constitutive equations for the two flows 1(13) and its primed counterpart] 721 —
T21 — C sI2e 2
C31t1v1.2•
,
(17)
Since we have lust seen that ^21 =
%t,
ut.t =
it follows from (1 7) that • 2112
= C2112.
5incc (13) must hold for arbitrary velocity fields, repetition of the argument we have just given for various special cases gives the result that for all , j, k, and 1,
Cffia =
That is, the tensor - in (13) with components
Cud must be isotropic
DERIVATION OF THE FINAL. EQUATIONS
According to Theorem 2.1.17, since the C,,kt isotropic fourth order tensor, we can write
are the components of an
Mfrs = ^%ij ars + /41:5ar45js + a;s ( jr) + 1 f (6 ir ^ js y 451s 6 jr)
for some scalars it, ti, and
K. It is
(18)
easy to see that the symmetry requirement
(14) holds if and only if K = 0 [Exercise 1(a)]. Now, using the decomposition
The Nai•ter Siokrs F"quarirms
Ser. 3. 1]
83 t2
= ritjt ^j
t2 .
Ob
!
3.2. (a l With the given velocity profile, t h e heavy arrow represents at utiyiR. on lo n e r (shaded) material du e to action or upper iurt,sltaded) material. (b) A 90' cYrunterr•Irki a•zge rotational the vault ypro frle hit ia )yit -es xhe profile here. The effec t cdi th e unshaded region on rire shaded results in a eorrresfJr+RdiruJi}• rotated .stress ( lrerr r ► arrow). This is because the material is Isotropic : orfiervise, resistance to dejerrmarinan would in general depend an errr eerteuton, so that a rotated velocity field would not far rise to a rotated stre ss. FlcURL
Strum
viscous fluids [Ch. 3
84
of Lr into its symmetric and antisymmetric parts Dr_, and — 4-ilrs Drs +
COrs Wr, ,
But with K = Q, (18) shows that C ur, is symmetric in its last two indices and we know that F'rs is antisymmetric — so the second term in the preceding equation is zero [Exercise 1(b)]. Therefore, in its final form the constitutive equation shows that the stress tensor is determined by just the symmetric part D of the velocity gradient tensor. This final form is [Exercise 1(c)]
1 îj
(—p + h11rr)"i1 + 2pDi J •
( 1 9)
The viscosity coefficients ). and p depend on the density p and temperature 0 (or any other convenient pair of thermodynamic variables). In direct notation, since D r, = v, , we have T = [--p
A(V - v)]! + 211)-
(20)
When our constitutive equations are substituted into the equation for linear momentum conservation (A2.l.2), we obtain [Exercise 3(a)] the ltiavier —Stakes equations P
If d1 and
p
Dr = pp — Vp + Di
• v.) + V • (2p]) !
(21)
-
can he regarded as constants, (19) simplifies to Dv
+ PL+ p !)1 _ pf + V[- ` p
v7 +
+',
(22)
where [Exercise 3(b)] ^ EV V/s
^
ü{
2 [^ t •' i
ex.
Dx 2
Pxj
[^;^,
(23)
In the incompressible case, when V • v — 0, we obtain simply p
f
= pf
Vp +
^, ►
(24)
while (20) becomes T = —pl + 2pD.
(25)
It is worth commenting on the fact that our analysis [which follows Batchelor (1967)] has shown that the stress tensor does not depend on the rotation tensor W If a more general relation for the stress tensor were sought (for fluids exhibiting more complex behavior than water and air), then this lack of dependence of W could not be deduced. But W still does not enter the
Sec. 3.11 7he11avier StokesEquemiruu
165
constitutive relations that are traditionally postulated. This is because of the assumptive ui material indifference-- that constitutive equations are the same for all observers. Observers who are rotating with respect to one another would see different solid body rotations but the same deformation, so the assumption of material indifference will not permit dependence of T on U hut will permit dependence on D. Written down in a precise mathematical manner-, the observer invariance' requirement that underlies the material indifference assumption is used to restrict more complicated constitutive equations. See Jaunzcmis (1967) for an exposition of this type of analysis. "Sufficiently small" deformation rates were required for the validity of the linearity assumption (13), but it can be argued that this means merely that strain should he small over the very short time that is characteristic of molecular motion. Thus it is perhaps not surprising• but in any case it certainly is true that there is no reason to doubt the validity of the Navier Stokes equations for common fluids such as water and air except under the most extreme conditions.* aoUNüArcY CONDITIONS
Equation (24) differs from the in viscid hauler equation 02.1 .6), owing to the in the former of the term /W . Addition of this term has the important mathematical consequence of increasing from one to two the highest order of spatial derivatives present. 1f experience with ordinary differential equations is any guide, a new boundary condition is called for (beside the requirement that fluid does not penetrate the boundary[. This view is perhaps reinforced by a feeling that the adjacent viscous fluid adheres to the knife blade as it slices through the cold molasses, Surely, the shear stresses present in a real fluid must somehow restrict the free slip along a boundary allowed by inviscid flow theory. But might not the fluid slip over a very thin stagnant layer next to a fixed wall? Could it be that the tangential velocity is proportional, via a very small constant, to the normal velocity gradient? Maybe molasses does not slip past the knife, but what about a fluid like mercury in contact with a glass wall? (Mercury does not wet glass.) What about violently eddying turbulent flow? What about gases, particularly gases of low density? Such questions have been a subject of research for over 150 years. To name only prominent nineteenth-century scientists, the investigators included Coulomb, mb, Navier, Poisson, Poiseuille, Couette, Stokes, and Maxwell. presence
• It has, in Iaet. recently been shown that an appropr.atc approach to viscous equations through kinctx theory to subtler matter than had previously been supposed) flocs not yield the Neuter Stokes equations in t e strictly two-dimensional raise [l. Opperthcim and T Keyes, Phys. Rev. A7,1384 (1972j. and ë, 100 (1973)]. There are no such unexpected results in three dimensions, however: thus even normal two-dimensional hydrodynamies is "sa4ed." roc such calculations are meant to provide a first appru,imatwn 10 three-dimensional problems x bun venation in one direction is small.
86
Viscous Fluids
[CPI 3
It is now generally accepted that for liquids and gases under "ordinary" conditions it is appropriate to assume that fluid adheres to a rigid wall. To be precise, let x be any point on the boundary of a rigid body immersed in fluid, and let x be a point in the fluid. Then the velocity v(x) will be assumed to satisfy the adherence boundary condition .
]lrn w(x) = v(x w)
,
(26)
where v(x,,) is the known wail velocity. Evidence for acceptance of this boundary condition includes direct microscopic measurements of the extremely small velocity of particles near rigid walls. Unless they are interpreted with some subtlety, however, direct measurements tend to answer questions about the molecular model of fluid flow. What interests us here is not molecular questions, and certainly not the question (assuming it is meaningful) of whether fluid "really" adheres to the boundary. We wish to he assured that the adherence boundary condition is an assumption in accord with the rest of the assumptions involved in the continuum mode! of fluid flow. Such assurance comes indirectly but nonetheless convincingly from the ever-increasing number of instances wherein viscous flow theory, with [he adherence boundary condition, provides results in accord with experiment. Nonetheless, under "extreme" conditions the correct boundary condition remains in doubt.* IIVCOMPRESS1t3I,E VISCOUS FLOW
Except for a few remarks, in our subsequent discussion of viscous fluid flow we shall assume the fluid to be incompressible. (Indeed, we shall usually take the density to be uniform_) For an incompressible fluid of specific volume i. - '
Dn
Dt =
1 Dp Di =
so the term pD(p - ')/Dr does not appear in the fundamental thermodynamical equation (14.4.12) of L Thus the pressure never arises in thermodynamic considerations. Re-salts concerning the pressure which are traditionally deduced from considerations of equilibrium thermodynamics do not necessarily apply to the hydrodynamic pressure. For example, there is no a priori reason to assert that the hydrodynamic pressure in a moving viscous incompressible fluid can be interpreted as the mean normal stress on a stationary wall. Nevertheless, that this interpretation is, in fact, valid * For djsc;ussinn and further references, see Serrin 11959, p.240). An mterestatg account of earlier work can be found ita CïoIdslcin 11938, Vol. 2, pp. 676-80). An argument from kinetic theory that yicids t he no-slip boundary co=idil ion, plus further intalesling comment. is pm, on pp. 83-84 of K. E. Meyer, bur odurrion io Me)hema rim! Fluid Dynamics (New York : ury,1971).
Sert. 3. f ]
7 he Novier-Stokes Equations
87
can be deduced from the constitutive equation (25) and the adherence boundary condition (26) (Exercise 4). Consider a viscous fltaid of uniform density p. Let us divide the Navier-Stokes equation (24) by p and make the definition
v4_
(27)
p The resulting momentum equation, and the appropriate equation of mass conservation, are
Dv
1 f — p gp -
—
D1
V-V
vVY,
(28)
0-
(29)
These equations will form the basis of our discussion of viscous fluid flow. We can regard vas a constant, so we have four equations for the pressure and the three velocity components.` The dimensions of the viscosity p and the kinematic viscosity y are as
follows (Exercise 6): dimensions of p = mass/length-time -,
(30a)
dimensions of v = length L ftime.
(30b)
Typical values for p and y are (at 1 atm pressure and 20 °CJt
:
p (g/cm-s): glycerine = 9, water = 10 -2 , air = 2 x 10 v (cm 2 /s): 2 , air = 15 x 1(3 water = 1
a2
Note that the effect of viscosity is represented by the term proportional to v in (28) and that yis 15 times as large for air as it is for water. The qualitative variation of p and v with temperature is depicted in Figure 3.3 for water and air. (Since the density of water is very nearly l gJcm` over the entire range of temperatures considered, v 12 for water when cgs units • One might be icinplcd to pose as a fundamental mathematical problem: "Given initial values of p and r and given the morion or any solid bvuneur ies, solar US l and 129) subjetl to thr boundary condition ( 26)... A comparable "fundamental problem - of purr rnathrrnai cs would be "characterize the conseslucnt:es of the group axioms," fn both c u.c the incredible richrre55 of phenomena emt]raced by the cr{uatiuns or axioms precludes the solution of such pt claims. In both cases, taste and judgment must be used to select trilerestrng or wolthwhrle phenornrna and to formulate and coke problem, or to prove theorems that will elucidate such phrnom€na. The more "applied" an applied mathematician is, the more he will rely on relevance to a sr.:lei:Idle matter as a criterion for dcterminirt$ which phenomena arc inletcstuil;. t An essential ingredient of the physical "feel required to docffrciive applied mathematic-5 is u knowledge of the rough magnitudes of the various parameters Char appear in the ovations_
68
t'isruus Fluids 1C i. 3
,u on (tags LIMOS.
I
atmosphere pressure'
FIGURE kine»kitit
3 3.
Appro.—tit—tame rYlriutluN 1+•02 temperature rrf viscosity (0) und for air and w a t er- Data from C'v1rL►tNrn (1938}, pp, 5-1,
are used.) There is very little variation with pressure. See Goldstein (1938, Chap. 1) for further details and additional references. At the moment, the viscosity coefficients pc and v may seem to lack a clear connection with our intuitive feeling for viscosity. This connection will be more firmly established below when we indicate how these coeftïcierits can be measured by studying viscous flow in a pipe [compare (23)] or the passage of a small sphere through viscous fluid [compare (6.11)]. Further clarification comes via an exact solution (2.2a, b. c) to the Navier Stokes ouations, a shear flow in which the only nonzero velocity compnnent u is proportional to the nnrrnal direction j':
u = ky,
k
a constant.
In this case the sheaf- force per unit area T} , is proportional to the velocity gradient via the viscosity:
Historically, the viscosity coefficients first appeared when such a rather natural proportionality was assumed. The tensorial Navier-.Stokes assumption (25) came much later, EX ER CI5F:5
L. (a) Show that (14) implies that rt — 0 in (18). (C,,u and l rs -=-14 implies that C ars Ws — O. (b) Show that C# (c) Duce (19) from (13) and (IS), with x = 0_
Sec_
1.11 The !Warier-Stokes Equations
Kq
I Show that (20) implies that the principal axes of T and D coincide. Would you expect this to remain true if the linearity assumption were dropped? If the isotropy assumption were dropped? Back up your answers with physical reasoning. 3. (a) Verify (21). (b) Verify (22). 4. From (25) and the adherence boundary condition, deduce that the magnitude of the normal stress exerted by a moving viscous incompressible fluid on a stationary waIl is equal to the hydrodynamic pressure p_ 5, Let q i denote the ith component of the heat flux vector q. Give reasons for assuming the constitutive equation gf i cii 0 j , where 0 is the temperature and the quantities ri, may depend on thermodynamic variables. From an isotropy requirement deduce the Newton-Fourier law:
rcV[i.
q^
ti, Derive (30a) and (30b) from (2 5) and (27). .
The object of the next set of problems is to deduce certain facts about energy changes, particularly as these changes are affected by viscosity. A knowledge of Cartesian tensors is assumed. 7. From the momentum balance equation (A2.1.2) deduce the kinetic: energy equation (14.4.32) of I:
fff, ,„ d _ JJj'pr. t
R(i)
cit +
-vdd— JJJT:D ctr.
RIO
BO)
where (using the summation convention)
T:D=
f 1:1{ .
Section 14.4 of 1 contains interpretation of this equation and several deductions from it. [We assume that T,, _ TA ; R(r) is a material volume.] S. (a) Modify the equation of Exercise 7 in the case where the body force f is given by f = — VP and the function P is time-inde pendent_ P is called the potential energy per unit mass or specific potential energy. Give a justification for this terminology by interpreting the equation just derived. (b) For an incompressible viscous fluid, show that
T: D = 2nD : D.
(31)
The quantity = 2AiD : D is called the viscous dissipation (per unit volume) (compare Section 14.4 of I). Note that this dissipation is nonnegative.
Viscvi13 Rinds
ye
(['h. 3
$9. The viscous dissipation vanishes if and only if D , U. Show by integrating the resulting partial differentia! equations that D = U if and only if W loY lot certain constants cuj and Ir. T what motion does this velocity field correspond? is it reasonable that it is the only viscous incompressible motion with no dissipation of energy? 10. (a) Prove that
D(V • v) Dr
V-a =
(h)
l
D:D
2 1w l ^ ,
-
(32)
where st E DvfDt and to is the vorticity vector V A v. Use (12) to show that for a viscous incompressible fluid.
fJf
(I)
dr
ff a - n eta_
riwI l dr +
(33)
If the boundary dR is composed of rigid walls on which•v vanishes, deduce the following remarkable relation between the dissipation and the magnitude of the vorticity vector: J]JtI) dT = J.L Jf
(34)
= /21E1)1 2 . LWe have here E. It is not, in general, true that followed Serrin's (1959) presentation of results obtained by Hobyleff and Forsythe toward the end of the nineteenth century.]
N n -I
The next three exercises outline a derivation of the equations of twodimensional viscous flow that makes no explicit use of tensors_ 11. (a)
Verify that the following equations describe a two dimensional velocity field at any point y rear a fixed reference point X. -
2
vAy) — VAX) =
E{Y# - x k )
[^Li
+ higher order terms
2
;
E Ûr„ — xkP ,k t
2 + ^=
I
(}'k
-
-.1q)44fk
+...^
1 — 1, 2,
where 1c? 4^
D ^`
eV,
2 dx ; + r^x r ^'
I^;,
=
t —
^^k
2 ax,
^^i
^ c^x k
S'a'c". â_r J The Nai ler Stokes Equations
9 1.
In the equations above, rau,{Ox k , Dtk , and I^I; at-e Evaluated at the fixed reference point x. (b) Suppose that higher order terms are neglected. Show that if D a, tl, then the velocity field is that of a material that rigidly rotates with constant angular velocity while it simultaneously translates with velocity v(x). (Compare Exercises 9 and 4.1.5.) 12. The object of this exercise is to determine expressions for the components corresponding to the Die, in a primed coordinate system rotated by an angle t} with respect to an original unprimed system. so that
x a =x; cos[ --x r2 sin B, x; =x, cos (a)
0 t- x 2 sin 0,
x 2 =x', sin f1+.tie cos 0; xz— —x, sin t)+x 2 cos O.
If velocity components in the unprimed and primed systems are denoted by (t;,, r: 1 ) and (r;l, r/ 2 ), respectively, verify that
=
u' r.x i
cos 0
(X 1
(e l cos tl +
12 2
sin 0)
+ sin 0- •(--t sin 1 0+r•2 cos 0) 1 —^
J (D 1 1 +D1a)+- -(D rl — D22 } cos 2U+D 13 sin 20.
2
(h) Note that the result in (a) is identical in structure to the transformation law for T1 1 which was derived in Exercise 14.2.8 of I. Show that the identity in structure continues to hold for the transformation laws giving the components of D; 2 = D21 and D. (Section 1.3 reveals the basis for the coincidence" in the formulas.) 13. In an inviscid fluid Ti =_ -p ; - For a viscous fluid, additional terms are needed on the right side to represent a local stress corresponding to a local shearing motion. Exercise 11 shows that the WI, terms in the local description correspond to a rigid rotation, so it is sensible to assume that there is no shear contribution from these terms. As for the remaining terms, the D ; ,, the simplest assumption (presumably appropriate if derivates are small enough) is a linear one. Thus we assume that
7^ r = — p+A1D1r 7;2 —
T22 — —p
A 2 D 13
A ri D12 ,
(35a)
B 1 D I1 + 133D,2 f HiD11,
(35b)
+ C~2Dr2 -i- C73D22.
(35c)
This exercise outlines the consequences of the isotropy assumption, which maintains that in fluids with no preferred direction the relations (35a, b, c) should be the same whatever coordinate system is used.
Viscous Fluids [(_h.
92
3
(a) Using the results of Exercise 12, substitute for D', ,, ❑ ', 3, and D P22 in r12
= B1Di1 + B2 D i e + B 3 D '22
[8,, B2, B 3 as in (35b)]
and deduce that
( 36a)
{D1 s + D22)( 8 1 4 B3) = 0,
1(7'22
—
T11) = iB2(D22 — D11) + (B,
B3 )0 12=
(36b) T12 ' B2 D12 f I(D11 — 1)22)(B1 — B3).
(36c) (b) (c)
Combining (35) and (36), deduce several relations among the A's, B's, and C's. Repeat the above steps, starting with
fi l = - p +
41011 f A2 1712 + A 3 D'22 .
Duce that A2 — 81 = 83 = C2 = 0 ,
and that one can write C 1 = A3 = A,
8 2 =2 1,
C 3 —A2—Â
+ 2p.
(d) Assuming that  and p are constants, use the results just obtained concerning the dependence of the stress on velocity gradients to deduce the Navier-Stokes equations (22) 14. Consider the following steady flow (already investigated to some extent in Exercise 1114 of I). L'1
(a) (b)
=
2x 1 + 3x 2i
V2
=0
Find the rates of deformation and rotation. Determine the principal axes of the deformation tensor and ils diagonal form. Consider a circular disk centered around the origin, of radius 1What becomes of the shape of this disk after a time interval 0.1 unit? Plot the curve of the new boundary. (Assume that the time interval is sufficiently small so that one may calculate the displacements by Ei[ 1 = u, ❑f,
(c)
X1 — Xi,
Ax e = v 2 ❑I.
Consider points on the circle bounding the disk.) Describe the relationship between the results obtained in (a) and (b):
State clearly the deformation and the rotation involved. Verify explicitly for at least one boundary point.
Sec . . 3.21 Exact Solutions
93
15. In a certain Cartesian coordinate system, a two-dimensicjrial steady flow has the velocity components
v, = 2x t + 3x 2 , n2 = x, — x 2 . (a)
Find the components of the following three tensors: velocity gradient, defntmation, and rotation. (b) Consider a set of material points (x,, x 2 ) that at time r = 0 lie on the unit circle x; + x = I. Find the locus of these points at time r =F 0 <E L Proceed as follows. Let (x,. x 2 ) —, (t. ,, 3 .2) in the time interval (0, r:). (1) Justify the assumption ,
y, = x, + (2x, + 3x 2 )e,
y 2 = x, 4 (x1 — x 2 )c.
(ii)
Use perturbation theory to solve for x, and x, in terms of r, and y 2 . Neglect OW) terms. (iii) Impose x; + 4 = I. Neglect OW) terms. (c) Using elementary methods, one can find a new rotated coordinate system in which the result of (iii) becomes revealed as an ellipse in standard form. Write down this standard form Manna fulrcrtcitwurr using part (a). Explain your reasoning.
3.2 Exact Solutions We begin our study of t he Navier-Stokes equations for a viscous fluid of uniform density by displaying three exact solutions (obtained without approximating the equations). We shall briefly discuss the use of such solutions in determining the value of the viscosity p. Since no terms are discarded as "negligible," there is no question that exact solutions represent one possible behavior allowed by the equations. It is natural to be skeptical about whether this behavior is typical. In response to this skepticism, one can only say that experience indicates that exact solutions which can be interpreted as solving "reasonable" physical problems generally illustrate behavior that is broadly typical of other physical situations which cannot be exactly analyzed. SOLUTION t: PLANE COUETTE FLOW
Consider viscous incompressible fluid contained between infinite parallel plates a distance d apart. Suppose that the bottom plate is stationary and that the tip plate is moving with a uniform speed U. Solution of this problem should give us an idea of the effects of the adherence boundary condition and of how tangential viscous stresses drag the fluid along. We choose an x-v-z Cartesian coordinate system. The components of the velocity vector will be denoted by (u, Thus the situation is as depicted
Viscous Fluids ICh. 3
94
Y
=d
F
r
u=
^
4 I
Y
=o =D
t
f z
Fit; v H is 14. The configuration that generates plane Couertefi"ow of u viscous fluid. The fluid is contained between two infinite parallel plates. One of these is stationary and dhe other »ores with speed U.
in Figure 14. Seeking the simplest possible solution, we ignore the effect of body forces and set f 0_ (Gravity, the most important body force, only adds a hydrostatic pressure in any case; see Section 7.2.) Since the plates are infinite, it seems reasonable to look for a solution in which the only nonzero velocity component is u. It is also reasonable to guess that u is a function only of the vertical component y.. With the assumptions u = w = 0 = h(y), mass conservation is automatically satisfied. With f = O the t^ momentum equation (1.28) implies that
_P s -
p+ vhrr= 0,
pr = 0+
A:= 4.
(la, b, c)
From (lb) and (1c) it follows that the pressure can depend only on x and t. Since h is assumed to depend only on y, we deduce from (lb) that p x and her must be constants. [Our reasoning is the same as that used in separation of variables; compare the material following (15.2.3) of I.] We consider a flow due entirely to the effects of tangential viscous stresses and, therefore, look for a solution with pi, = O. Then h,,,, = O. From the adherence boundary conditions
h= 0aty=0,
h=U tit y= d,
we obtain the final exact solution u
Uy = d,
t7
=
= 0,
p — constant.
(2a, b, c)
The linear increase of horizontal speed is shown in Figure 3.5. As in the figure it is customary to position the graph between the bounding walls and to draw inafew velocity vectors to make the flow easier to visualize. Such a diagram is called a velocity profile.
Se a- . 12]
Fxorr S^Jurrons
95 d
L
=0
F t G LP R E 3. 5. The ratted ►• profile for plane (`ouerfe j1uH 1_ et uscomputethe tangential stress exerted by the moving flail on the lower plate, Reverting to subscripts for a moment. we obtain the desired stress, using (1.25) and (1.6),
cr r
T,, = D# 1
c_r 2
r
t•2 --
ex,
In our current notation. the above equation is written ^
CU['t ) -r Cy ex —
Since u = fl} d and r – C. we find that L
(2d)
The stress is directly proportional to i,' and inversely proportional to d. if we could move a plate parallel to another plate at constant speed, then we presumably could measure p b} finding the proportionalil constant. The plates would have to he large enough so that end and side effects would he neglib_ Note that the force on the lower plate increases with p.m conformity wit h our intuitive discussion of the relative fonces required to slice a knife through molasses and through water. SOLUTION 2: PLANE POISEUILLE FLAW, To see how viscosity impedes flow forced by pressure gradients. let us consider horizontal flow between motionless parallel plates at y = ±d forced by a constant horizontal pressure gradient pz
–
C,
C a constant.
(Positive C corresponds to pressure decreasing with increasing x. Accordingly, we expect the fluid to flow in the direction of increasing x when C > û.) (Ti + constant, all With the assumptions u = h( '^, t _ +^ = ü, p = equations are satisfied, provided that –
p -1 C +i'IJ j ^ = 0 or
C -t - Ph„
s ^-
Viscous Fluids ICÏt_ 3
96
Adherence requires that
h =U
at
d,
So
C t1 =
(i} 2 —
(3)
The parabolic velocity profile is depicted in Figure 3.6. ^-^
-
-d
3.6_ /he t rlrrt ir; 1►roifile fur plane Paistti.rilfr flow TTxe jirm• is driven by if { tmsruur pressure gradient that LE dlrrr-rt'd parallel fr, flhr hrteurdin0 fnre F tCï ll s L
pfrunt•.ti_
Of chief physical interest here is the urmRss flow rtde per unit width, i.e.. the mass of fluid per unit time, per unit distance in the 2-direction. that passes a given plane _r = constant. This is given by
f
/}!! d}' _ 1t Cr t d 3. -
(4)
d
The pressure can be measured_ Cnnsequently, comparison of a measured mass flow with (4) could in principle provide an alternative way of measuring viscosity. In fact, viscosity is measured with the aid of solutions similar to but not identical with, the ones that we have just derived_ The first solution we considered (Figure 3.5) is called plane Couette flow. (Ordinary) Couette now is the tangential flow of a viscous hind in the annulus between infinitely long concentric rotating cylinders (Figure 3.7). If the gap between the cylinders is small compared to the mean radius (R, t R2)/2, then plane Couette fl ow should be a good approximation to ordinary Couette flow [Exercise 1(b)]. But the latter is easier to approximate experimentally and can be described in its own right by an exact solution [Exercise 1(a)] _ Indeed, an important method of measuring viscosity is to suspend the inner cylinder from a wire whose twisting is proportional to the torque exerted by stresses transmitted by the viscous fluid located between the inner cylinder and a rotating outer cylinder.
Sec. 3.2] Exert Solutions
97
^-^-^
--
yR -^-Rr
FIGURE 3.7. In Cnuette flow the fluid is confined bemaeetw infinite coaxial
cylinders_ The outer (inner) cyirr<der rotates with angular
velocity n,(12, ).
The exact solution illustrated in Figure 3.6 is called plane Poiseuille flow_ A more useful solution is that for (ordinary) Poiseuille flow in which fluid flows along a circular pipe because of an axial pressure gradient (sec Figure 3.4 The solution is considered in Exercise 2. Instead of (4), the following formula relates mass flow rate through the pipe E with an imposed pressure gradient of magnitude D; E
—8
Dv -1R4.
(5)
A practical method of measuring viscosity consists of determining the pressure gradient D and mass efflux E and solving for y from (5). Plane Couette flow and plane Poiseuille flow show the qualitative features or ordinary Couette and Poiseuille flow_ The former have been studied here so that we would not need to introduce cylindrical conrdinates and thereby divert attention from the issues we wish to emphasize at this point. It might appear that we can sum up by noting that the viscosity p or the kinematic viscosity ' can be determined by measuring the mass efflux in
Fee taR E 3.8. Poiseuille flow in o circular pipe, like plane Poiseuille flow. is driven by, a constant pressure gradient. The parabolic uxwl r ek eity profile is depicted.
Viseurs Fluais (Ch. 3
9$
Poiseuille flow and that the Navier- Stokes equations themselves can be checked by using this viscnsiLy to compare measured and predicted torques in Couette flow. While broadly correct, such a summary conceals certain difficulties. I. Measurements require theories for their interpretation, For example, confident measurement of torque by examining torsion of a wire requires secure theoretical understanding of the relation between torque and torsion (see Section 5.3). As another example, to measure pressure one needs a device and a theory to explain its operation_ In practice, a degree of empiricism is usually necessary. This is well illustrated by the lengthy discussion in Goldstein (1938, pp. 2481t,) concerning a pressure-measuring device called the Pilot tube. 2. Given an understanding of measuring devices, there remains the problem of whether the exact solutions involved are appropriate. Cylinders cannot be made infinitely Icing, nor can they be made perfectly circular. Measuring devices disturb the flow whose properties are being subjected to measurement. Failure to reconcile theory with experiment could be due to the fact that inevitable small deviations from theoretical ideality may mean that the appropriate mathematical solutions are entirely different in character from the simple exact solutions. One ought to examine the stability of the exact solutions to small perturbations (see Section 152 of I and Exercise 4). To illustrate this point, we remark that Stokes derived the Poiseuille flow solution from his equations and found complete disagreement with the experiments available to him. He delayed publication of his solution. Now we know that the experiments involved the violently eddying turbulent flow which replaces Poiseuille flow at sufficiently high imposed pressure gradients. SOLUTION 3:
RAYLEIC:M IMPULSIVE FLOW
We turn La a problem that illustrates how viscous effects develop with time. Consider fluid in the domain y > O which for r < O is motionless and is bounded below by a motionless horizontal plate. Suppose that at time t = 0 the plate instantaneously begins to move, in its own plane, with speed U. Presumably, viscous effects will bring the entire body of fluid into motion. How does this happen'? 0 (sec Figure 3.9). As above, this We assume that u = of y, t), r' requires that p r = ps = 0, p. = constant. We take p. = 0 so that the motion is due entirely to viscous effects. The governing equations then require that —
Ur
= v2 I1.1r,
14
-0
_
f
> 13,
for t
O.
while, by assumption,
(6)
Sec_ 3.2] Exact So luerulis
99 ^
I/I1II/INI/IIfIIiI7II7l7ÎÏÏTT speed = 6 tor r <6 = Ulnrt]Q
lit Ruylc•igh 01IL,uLsitV f/un•. the /lurd iti lr+c•rrneel us rune stay 14 an 'infinite plane. The plane r'ssudrlrrll ti' set into motion purulle1 itself; with speed ['.
FIGURE 3.9
The adherence boundary condition implies that fort > Q: tl(U, rl
U.
(71
A person with considerable insight might realize that in this simple problem the speed U plays only a limited role. All that the solutions will tell us is how u/U passes from its initial value of zero to its ultimate value of unity, at a given spatial position and I -or a fluid of a given viscosity. We thus expect that E4
(8)
= ![t', r,
the point being that l:` does nor! appear on the right side of (8)_ As is frequently the case, mathematics can be used to verity physical insight. With the change of variable it' = Nit/. (61 and (7) become = uu},
LA (}, f) — 1
> U).
(9E41:1
Since these equations do not involve U, re cannot depend on I1, from which (8) follows. The ratio uXU is dimensionless, It must, therefore, depend only on a dimensionless combination of y, t, and v. Since the dimensions of r are length/time, y, t, and w can only occur in the combination y 2 1 - Vv. More precisely, u/U = g(y 2 fvt) for some fu nct ion g. It is cnnvenient to write this last equation in the equivalent form:
u'
-
Lr
w hc°re7 = 2 }.`{vt}
,tz
(10)
for then the final answer will be expressible in terms of a certain tabulated function.
too
Visenu s Raids
tCh. 3
To test the conclusion (10), obtained by physical reasoning,* we substitute into the governing equation (9). By the chain Hile, (9a) implies that —
iv - 1 12t - 3f3 3y' _ v . iv - ] - l^n
or
F" -# 2r1F' = 0. For any fixed t, y --• 0 implies that ri - O. sc (9b) implies that (12)
F(0) = 1.
Note that for fixed y, rl cx:, so (12) requires that at any fixed location Oas r as r of if1 : -• I -• oo. This is a reasonable result_ Equation (11) is of second order, so there must be a boundary condition in addition to (12). We require that at any fixed time the velocity far from the plate approaches zero: Hat u(y, $) ---- 0,
t >0.
(13)
Trouble threatens, however, when further thought indicates that it is just as reasonable to require that at any fixed position the velocity approaches zero as r ,l, 0 (i.e., t > O, r - 0): lini u(y, r
s) -
0,
y > 0.
(14)
,o
It i s reassuring that both (13) and (14) amount to the same condition on yy r namely, } F('(),
11m F(/) = U
(15)
0,2
However arrived
at, the final problem, given by (11), (12), and (15), is a simple one. Regarded as an equation for F', (1 1) is first order. Its solution is
F' = C I exp ( - r7 2 ) T h us
F(rJ) =C, f e ^d^+
C2.
(16)
• Scc Scc`iiun 3,4 and Exercises 3.4.$-tO for other material concerning - similarity' solutions tu partial differentiae equations in which dependent .iambics appear only in certain combination t In [Eats and papers it is customary to vrgaruxe the subject matter its a "straight line" manner in which the mathematical problem is completely formutticd and then is solved. From time to time, however. it is useful to remind [he reader that creative scientific thinking mitre often than nul results in an interaction between the formulation of a problem and its solution-
See. 3.21 Exact Solutions
aoI
t'trrl - err, I
FIGURE 3. W. in tQuyfer`gh in,pulswr flaw, u! (i = Ftg), where ij = bl vt) "' A graph of F is presented in thF,r figurer.
Since the Leal value of Pi is of special interest, we use zero as the lower limit of the indefinite integral in (161. Because of this, (12) simply requires that C2 = 1, whence (IS) requires that
C 1 f e_
:
d + l = 0.
Thedefinit e integral in (17) hay the val tic ec
F(er),
where F (r)
( I 7)
[See Exercise 3.2(d)of 11. Taus = I
—
e
R
In 0
d.
(IS)
The right side of (18) happens to be a tabulated function, called the complementary error function and denoted by erf L (ri). The error /unction itself, erf (rr), is just the integral term in (18), so F(rt) =
err, 01) — l — erf (t,).
(19)
We can ascertain the main features of our solution without resorting 10 tables. Merely from the fact that the solution is a function of q 1}4,11) -- " 1 see that the place where n f U — constant is at a certain value of v(v r) - t, 2.*we Thus the portion of fluid that moves with less than a given per cent of its final velocity U is farther from the plate than a certain plane whose height is proportional to (vt')" Since exp ( x) decreases rapidly with increasing 4', the graph of F must have the qualitative features of Figure 3,10. From a table (ear by numerical —
- constant has a unique * Physical intuition would kid one to believe that the equation sululion, this k confirmed by IN, which shows that Fl(s) is continuous and monotonically
decreases from I to 0 asp/ goes horn 0
Le r[,.
:
o2
Viscous Fluids (Ch. 3
integration) we ascertain that F(17) = 0_005 when r1 _ 2. As a consequence, when 71 > 2 or y > 4(v0" the fluid speed has not reached even half of l per cent of its final value. Since erf, (1) = 0.16, when y > 2(%s)u 2 the fluid speed does not exceed 16 per cent of its final value_ From the highly simplified situation typical of an exact solution, we wish only to draw the most general type of conclusion. Such a conclusion in the present case is that the purely diffusive cruse of setting fluid into motion tykes effect in r region whose thickness is of order (vl)'". This spreading at a rate proportional to r''' is the single most important characteristic of diffusion. (Compare the remarks in 1 at the end of Section 4.1 .)
EXERCISES
In the following exercises, u, u, and w denote the velocity components when Cartesian coordinates x, y, and z are used When cylindrical coordinates r, O. and z are employed (sec Appendix 3.1 for relevant equations), the corresponding velocity components are denoted by Or ) , r.{e) , and w_ 1. (a) Solve for the Couette flow of Figure 3.7 by looking for a solution of the form Gtr} _ w Ü, ut'M = V(r), p = [Sec Exercise 4(b) P(r). for the answer.] (h) Find the stress 7. e exerted by the fluid on the inner cylinder_ Show that if the gap is small compared to the mean radius, then the result is dose to that of (2d). Explain why. 2. Solve for the Poiseuill e flow of Figure 3.8 by looking for a solution of D. Derive (5). the form i( = t = Q, w = f (r), p = = in as much detail as possible the similarities and differences 3. Discuss between (4) and (5). 4. In this problem we outline the beginnings of an investigation into the stability of Couette flow. Knowledge of stability theory, as in Section 15.2 of I, is assumed. (a) Show that the Couette flow of Exercise 1(a) satisfies the inviscid equatiionsof motion, so that viscosity enters only by means of the adherence boundary condition. In a first attempt to find out something about its stability, we shall regard Couette flow as inviscid. (b) Examine the stability of the following exact solution (Couette flow) of the inviscid equations: V(r) = Ar + Er - ^
p = P(r) = i{2 rT L ,
!] ( ri = w =
(2 ntfi A = 2R1 R1— R^ T
0;
8^
(Dt
112)RiM
T Ri`Ri
.
Sec.
.I21 Exarl Solutions
103
Assume disturbances that writing
are
c;[r 1 X, z, l4'
=
1 ,^ '^'t r,
axisymmetric (independent of 0),
Zt^^ _
I, f),
/(r) + L` B1 (r, z, 1),
P = P(r) + P(r,
Z+
I).
Linearize. Write ^,{r}^itoi+
i , z,} t Crl(r
As)
and make analogous assumptions For the forms of 0 19, iv, and p. Eliminate ° ',ti3, and p. To simplify notation, write WI X. Deduce -
dr
(1 ;
a
dr
rX) + 1, 2 (a
— 1)X
0,
X(R I ) — X(R 1 ) —
where
(I3(r) =
r
d
rlr
(r
(c) Note the similarity between this equation and (152.21) in 1. Exploit this similarity and draw conclusions such as Deductions I and 2 of 1, Section 15.2. (The required theorems are still valid, with substituted for dR jdz.) The mathematical similarity evidenced in our investigations of the stability of Couette now and of a stratified fluid is due to the physical similarity of the destabilizing effects of gravitational force and centrifugal force_ 5. In deriving the flow of Figure 3.5,we set px = O. Keep the sameboundary conditions, but now set p = — C, Ca constant. Show that the resulting fl ow is a superposition of the flows of Figures 3.5 and 3.6_ Sketch a typical velocity profile. 6. (a) Verify (11). (b) If u/U — y(y V /vt), find the equation satisfied by q. Recover (I1) by a change of variable. (c) Show that the assumption of (10) would be invalid if (9a) were 24; = vurrs 7. Show that 1„` exp (— e) 8. Instead of (16), take
do
is a convergent improper integral.
F(t7) — CI J ed4 +
C2.
Find Ci and C2 (a) when c = aç (b) for arbitrary finite c_ Verify that the solution is the same as (18). 9. Put a filled teacup on the center of a record turntable and suddenly turn the turntable on to 33 revolutions per minute. About how long does ,
L04
Visci us Fluids ICh 3
it take before the fluid is in solid body motion? Show that the estimate obtained from the diffusion distance (4 02 is much too large. This discrepancy has been explained only recently [see l -1. Greenspan's monograph The Theory taf Rotatin g Fluids New York : Cambridge University Press, 1968)]. 10. if the variable Li is regarded as corresponding to temperature, what problem in heat flow is described by exactly the sanie equations as those appropriate to the Rayleigh impulsive flow? Discuss the physical plausibility of the solution in the context of heat flow. +11. A viscous incompressible fluid fills the region z > O. It is bounded below by an oscillating plane, so :r{x, y, U e) = U exp (iw1),
U and co constants.
.
Find the velocity field. (Take p = constant.) 12. Advantages accrue in certain conditions if portions of an airplane wing are madeof porous material and a small amount of air is continually sucked into the wing. This relatively simple problem gives a first idea of the effect of suction. Consider two - dimensional flow of a viscous incompressible fluid in the half-space z > 0. Let the x-wise velocity component is approach a constant U as z # oc, . Suppose that at the porous plane z — 0 there is a perpendicular suction with speed W, so that at z : 0, w = — W where IV is a positive constant. Find a solution of the form u = u(z),
w = ff ,
u = 0,
p = constant.
14. Consider viscous steady incompressible flow
u = t? = i)
,
iv — f (x,
y)
in a pipe of uniform cross section whose generators are parallel to the z-axis. (a) Show that the axial pressure gradient satisfies ;1_p = — l,
constant, rdr so that the problem reduces to that of finding a solution of the equation ) 0 -? ♦
p
which vanishes on the curve in which the pipe cuts the x, y-plane. (b) The lines — 1 =0,
x+2--y,/3=4,
x+ 2+y
=0
bound an equilateral triangle whose sides have length 20 and whose centroid is the origin. For the pipe whose cross section is
Set_ 3.3] Orr Bnundur}' Lr^}r^rs
1 05
this triangle, show that f (x, y) is a constant multiple of (x — 1)x+2—y )(x+2+
yam)
and find the constant. $(c) Find the tangential force per unit length on the triangular pipe. NOTE. The mathematical problem that arises in viscous flaw down a pipe is identical to a problem that emerges in the study of the torsion of an elastic beam (see Section 5.2)_
3.3 On Boundary Layers* Books on science are full of plausible but noncompelling assumptions that lead to theories whose predictions are eventually confirmed with stunning accuracy. It is refreshing and instructive to contemplate instances where plausible reasoning led to trouble. One such instance conciûrrts the extensive nineteenth century study of the flow of air past a solid body_ There "the trouble had been by no means the lack of a theory, but rather the existence of an almost overwhelmingly large body of theory, constructed by many of the best mathematical physicists of the nineteenth century, according to the most respectable physical principles. This theory gave, for the motion of a wide variety of shapes through the atmosphere, which is treated as `a perfect the fullest information, none of which accorded with the most Rued' elementary observation of the facts. The failure of the theory was particularly disturbing because the only known mechanical properties of the air which had been neglected, namely compressibility and viscosity, could reasonably be supposed to produce small effects in the type of problem considered."t This section is concerned with the steady flow of fluid past obstacles. ft can be shown (as in the work of Lighthill just cited) that compressibility can be neglected in such flows provided that typical speeds are small compared to the speed of sound, that there are no large, imposed temperature differences, and that there are no motions of atmospheric dimensions. It is the aim of this section to explore the subtle effect of small viscosity when such conditions are satisfied. -
COMPARATIVE MAGNITUDES OF VISCOUS AND INVISCID TERMS
Suppose that you run at a speed of 15 kilometers per hour directly into a wind blowing at a speed of 25 km/h. If viscosity is neglected, theory predicts an absence of wind resistance (D'Alembert's paradox). Apparently, viscosity should be retained in equations that describe the air flow. But let us estimate * Appreciation of this Section will be greatly enhanced by ptior study of the maierial in I on sealing (Section 6.3) and on singular perturhalions (Chapter 9). t Quotation from M_ J. Light hill's introductory chapter in Rnsenhead (1963)_
[Ch_ 3
Viscous
106
the relative size of the inviscid and viscous terms. We assume that the wind blows along the x axis. Consider the Navier-Stokes equations for viscous flow ( 1.25), now written with an asterisk to emphasize that the variables are dimensional. With ajar* = 0 (steady flow), these equations are -
du* ^r +^ 0x*ôy*
1 Op* Mu* alai. p c7x* + 1 4-012 + ^Ÿ * ou•d * tr• r7f t^* ^p* 020 ^ 4 1R- e^y +u { # t - : #[^y* OX* [ lx Y e(y*) 2
c7u* (]D* ^^* + a^ ^ *—°'
,
( la. b, c)
A typical inviscid term is u* ate*/dx* and a typical viscous term is v 132 14*/21x*) 2 . For flow disturbed by the runner, it would appear than u* will be of the magnitude U0 (25 + 15) km/h or U0 x cm's. Significant changes in u* would be expected to take place over a distance of the order of some representative body size such as the width of a chest or a leg; say, over a distance of L — 10 cm if so, we would expect that
u
#
e?u* a2u* v *)Z ex* r3lx*)^
UO2 1.- -1 ,,U0 L
-x
Ut, f.
where
U0 L v
^
(4 x 104 crrt/s)(1#1 an) 15 x lU - ^ crn 2 js
10^.
(2)
We have used the value of v for air given at the end of Section 3.1. According to our estimates, the inviscid terms are 100,000 times as large as the viscous. The paradox seems sharper: Neglect of the viscous terms leads to the physically unreasonable result that the runner feels no resistance from the wind, but the viscous term truly seems negligible. Ludwig Yrandtl,at the begin ning of this century, had the insight required to resolve the paradox and point the way toward a procedure for calculating the effect of viscosity in many flows_ The essence of his ideas lies in the recognition that there is an extremely thin region, close to a solid body, where the fluid velocity undergoes great changes. Just outside this boundary layer the fluid "slips" along as predicted by inviscid theory. The velocity changes rapidly as the boundary layer is traversed, and becomes zero on the boundary as required by the boundary conditions for a viscous fluid_ The above estimates are not valid in the thin zone of rapid change, where the viscous terms are important no matter how small the viscosity.
-ei-Nr-
3.31
Chi
REYNOLDS
ro^
l'.r1Ye•fs
rw UMBER
Further progress is facilitated by the use of scaling. To permit some appreciation of this process for those who arc not familiar with it.? we summarize its main elements- The object is to introduce dimensionless variables in such a way that the maximum order of magnitude of the various terms is correctly estimated by the parameters that precede them. Roughly speaking, to do this one must nondimensionalize the dependent variables with constants estimating their maximum values. The dimensional independent variables x* and ys must be nondtntensionalized with lengths that are estimates of distances in which one observes significant changes in the dependent variables. The constants or sr ales that are appropriate in this nondimensionalization may differ from region to region_ The dimensionless group that we computed in (2) is an example of the Reynolds number, Re. The concept of scales is basic to the dehnitiuri of Re: Re — (overall velocity scale)(overall length scale) kinematic viscosity
LW_ t•
(3)
The word "overall" is used in (3) because there can he more than one scale of variation in viscous flow past a body. Thus the Reynolds number is an estimate of the ratio between the convective acceleration terms§ such as rr*clu*/(x* and viscous terms such as y r '- re*fi(x*)' except ni possible - special" regions of "unusual" variation. As we shall see, when the Reynolds n u miter is an order of magnitude or more greater than unity. it ceases to provide meaningful estimates near the solid boundaries, Prandtl recognized that the f'Alernbert prediction "no drag in nonviscous flows" is only slightly wrong in some slightly viscous flows. For flow parr streamlined bodies one can say that there is "slight drag in slightly viscous bows." The reason is that for such flows the itwi cc`td float' panern But when an obstacle is is only altered in the thin boundary layer region. bluff(i.e., blunt), the presence of viscosity in minute amounts alters the entire flow pattern. BOUNDARY LAYER EQUATIONS FOR STEADY FLAM: PAST A FLAT PLATE
We shall return later to some of these general ideas- Now we shall discuss in some detail the effects of a small amount of viscosity on a simple but representative "streamline" flow_ To this end, let us consider the case of a flat plate immersed in some steady two-dimensional flow_ Denote the (dimensional) velocity components by rc*(x*, y*), u*[x*, y*) and the pressure
by p*(x*, y*)- l'he flow could be disturbed by a number of objects, but we di,eussed in Section .63 or Rcrnernber ihat this discussion mals with steady flows_ The term PORN' may provide the
t Scaling is
dominant acccleration firms where the
vclocity at a pnirti varies with lime.
to8
Viscous Fluids (Ch. 3
shall fix attention on the fiat plate, which we imagine to be positioned along the x*-axis. The y*-axis is normal to the plate. We shall assume that the viscous flow does not differ significantly from the inviscid, except near the objects (Figure 3.11). We have already denoted the overall length and velocity scales by L and Zia, respectively. In the mainstream, then, a typical convective acceleration term such as u* Ott*fOx* should be of magnitude U /L. We expect a pressure gradient term like -- p - t 'p*/cox* to be the same magnitude, so we select pUt as a pressure scab:_ Thus the following are appropriate scaled dimensionless variables in the rnainstreamt :
X=
x*
y*
:a*
L. Y=U = U
Y=
v*
P=
o
u
p* P
^, (4)
With (4), the equations of steady viscous motion (1) are
f'L r x
-
UVx +
VU y _ —P x + Re t (Lf xx + Urr), VVy = `Pr ± Re - '
U x +. Vie = 0
(Vxx
( 5a)
4- Vier),
( 5b) ( 5 c)
-
Let U(X, Y), V(X, Y), and P(X, Y) denote the solution to the inviscid problem. These functions satisfy the above equations when the viscous terms are entirely ignored (formally, Re oo). Also satisfied are the boundary conditions of vanishing normal velocity. In particular. V vanishes on the plate, so from (5a) with Re oc we obtain the following result, to be used below: U(X, O)11x(X, 0) -- . F(X , O)
( 5 d)
-
-
Let us reiterate in present terms a point that we have already made. We are considering flows where Re may be 10 5 , 106 , or even larger. Nevertheless, the terms in (5a, b) preceded by Re r cannot be entirely disregarded. The f Here is more detail on the scaling isce also Section 7.3). Lei us use (4) Ow keep the pressure scale. P o unspecified for the moment, so lhal p p'/ Po . The Navicr--Stokes equation (la) becomes —
Uâ t U U^ r'll _ -— L U d } i. v Y
P4
—
op
— pL — ÔX
+ viscous terms.
Since Ua , P. and L are scales, by the definition of - scale" the approximate magnitudes of the three terms that appear explicitly in the preceding equation art ti /L, Uall. and PdpL. respectively. Away from obstacles, when Re > 1 we expect an essentially inviscid fl ow with all nonviscous terms in rough balance. This requires that U6IL = P01pL or Po pUo, determining the pressure scale P. NOTE, From the viewpaini of kinetic theory, pressure can be regarded as molecular momentum transfer per unit area. The pressure is of magnitude pti because momentum per unit volume of magnitude MI D is typically transported by bulk convection at a velocity of magnitude [1, D. ,
-
—
e _ 331 On Sc
Boundary
Lavers
109 Y.
l C[l[7i1:1rlt
& r15 a 3f
rirm5LIr[ =
P.
ja'
-
F ai tJ R E 3.11. A fiat
plate af' length 1.
and rrrher objet r.► émnreraiil tit a r-i-tc'rrWs
fluid.
reason is that the change of variables (4) introduces a scaling which is tint valid near the obstacles placed in the flow. Only away from these obstacles does this change of variables ensure (for example) that UU x and U }- r are approximately of unit magnitude, so that the ratio of Re -- 1 U ri, to UUx is the negligible quantity Re - I. We now turn our attention to the selection of scales that are appropriate within the boundary layer region. We expect the tangential velocity component ce*, the component parallel to the plate, to vary from its inviscid value outside the boundary layer to zero on the plate. Consequently, the maximum value of u* should be of magnitude Li e , the scale of the inviscid component. Variations along the plate have a scale that should be about the same as the scale L of inviscid variation, but the relatively rapid variations normal to the plate will have some scale e5 that is smalt compared to L. What about the normal velocity component v*'P We know that u* vanishes on the boundary. We shall estimate it at a representative distance 6 into the layer. We do this with the aid of the continuity equation ôu*/fix* + (70/4* 0, which shows that the normal derivative 4 t,*ley* has the same magnitude as 490/49x*, namely. U 0/L. Consequently, using Taylor's formula, We find that u*(x*, y*) x t.*fx*, 6)
v*(x*, O) + o * (x*, 0) Y
0
+
-
L
.
(6)
For a moment, let us take the pressure scale to be the unspecified constant Pl. Using the various scales to nondimensionalize, we write
v-
Z1 *
Lf^'
v=
^? *
u*
I.J 0bJL,
p=
Pi
, x r
x• L
,Y =
Y* ^
(7)
L_
110
Vr xc-r)uS Fluids [CA, 3
With (7) the steady Navier-Stokes equations (1) hecorne U,2,
eu
L
{fix
- 14 [
[UP] Ût + ^X
[
+
eu
fil L t' ; b ^-^
P,
ey
Fr ^1^
_
_
L
C^`}^
tip
rvU0
ax +
[
021,11
^ex2
vU o r' 2 ir + ^ 62 ^
oy2, (sa)
Op
(^y +
vU0B ^x v [vt.I.1P2 L3 Dx 2 + 31. (11, Y 2 (8 h)
U 01 iU u U eü a Q #. ['x 4 L [^y
(8c)
The object of our scaling was to choose variables so that the squarebracketed parameters in the preceding equations give the magnitudes of the terms of which they are a factor. 'These magnitudes must he such that the viscous terms are retained in the boundary layer- As we now show, this requirement allows us to determine b an d P 1 . Since ES is small, the largest viscous term in (8a) is proportional to a ufdy 2. This term will be retained, however small v is, only if b is such that the magnitude of this term is the same as the magnitude of the convective acceleration terms. Consequently, we require Uâ/f. = vU0/b2, SO
b = vrf
or
U0
b = Re - " 2 L.
(9 )
Knowing that 5 is proportional to v", we see from (8b) that i p/ra y is proportional to v_ Consequently, the change in p across the boundary layer of thickness b is of order V312 . TO first approximation, certainly, the pressure does not Mary ar~ross the boundary layer. This is an important qualitative conclusion of our analysis. In particular, it means that the pressure scale can he taken to be the same as the inviscid pressure scale: P, = p1426.
(10)
Using the expressions for the boundary layer thickness and the pressure scale given in (9) and (10), we can rewrite the governing equations (8) in the form + rlti y =
-4 rr,, y + Re - 1 m kt, -
pr = Re -1 (^ urn„ — LL J + t ») f- Re -2 uxx,
u + !Jy ^ 0. „
(11a, b, c)
We have assumed that Re > 1 and have introduced certain scaled dimensionless variables. We did this in such a way that in the boundary layer the relative magnitudes of the various terms in (11) should be approximately given by the Reynolds number factors that appear. [Compare the different dimensionless version (5) of the equations, the latter version being scaled
Sec. 33] On Bounrkorl Layer s for the mainstream.] When Re f, then we deduce from ( I I l that to a first approximation the following equations hold in the boundary Iayer:
tux + illy = - P x + u }y.,
py
tl,
u x -1- U}, = (i
(12a. h, e)
Equation (12h) states the previously noted fact that the pressure does not vary across the boundary layer. in (12a) we thus may replace p x(x, y) by its value just outside the boundary layer region. `phis is sometimes determined by measurement and is sometimes calculated by inviscid flow theory_ In the latter case, to first approximation we may use the inviscid equations evaluated right on the plate (rather than a thin boundary layer width away)_ Employing (5d), then, we see that the equations of (t 2) reduce to uu, +r)u
=D£1' +U) ,
fi(x, 0)V x (x, 0)
u+z'. = U, assumed known.
(131
The final steady boundary layer equations (13) have been derived for the flat plate. Nevertheless, it can be shown that they a re essentially valid for boundary layers near arbitrary two dimensional bodies, provided that x and 1' are interpreted as orthogonal coordinates measured along and perpendicularly to the wall, respectively (Rosenheati, 1963, pp. 201f1.). The only restriction is that wall curvature should not be so great that the centrifugal effect of the resulting curved flow requires a nonnegligible normal pressure gradient to balance it (That is, the wall's curvature radius must be large compared to the boundary layer thickness.) We shall restrict ourselves to flow past flat plates, but the reader should keep in mind that most of oui discussion applies much more widely. -
B c, N DAKI' CONDITIONS
We turn now to the question of boundary conditions. Since the most obvious defect of inviscid theory is that it permits fluid to slip along solid boundaries, we surely will want to require that both velocity components vanish at y — O. Next we must somehow link the boundary layer solution with the mainstream_ A way to accomplish this is called patching_ This method is used for a particular flow problem at a particular large Reynolds number. One requires that the boundary layer velocity component u(x, y) join with the corresponding exterior component U(x, Y) at some definite distance from the boundary y = O. Suppose for definiteness that Re 10 6 . Calculations show that the various possible solutions rl(x, y) cease varying appreciably as y increases beyond y = 5 or y = 10, say. Since y!Re" = Y, y = 10 corresponds to Y — 0.01. One can then patch together an approximate solution by using boundary layer flow for Y S 0.01 and inviscid flow for Y 0.01, where the boundary layer solution is chosen to satisfy u(x, 10) — 11'(x, 0.01) (see Figure 112). Since (typically) results do not differ much if patching is applied
112
Viscous Hair's
[Ch 3
Irtwiuid now: CFO. Yl, film, Y}
Patch here {i=re 1-T -
-
-
liaund ar y rayer Ilow ulr. kl. ntr.}'r
TfT TT^ ^ ^TT T^ ^TTTTTT F I U u R +:
3.12. Pinching toyerlrer lxurndurr• laver and !nr •isrid flow.
at y = 20 and Y 0.02, one has confidence that the general nature of one's results is independent of the somewhat arbitrary nature of the manner in which the boundary layer flow is linked to the mainstream_ We shall adopt a somewhat deeper philosophy of linkage called matching.* The idea here is to produce results that are correct in the limit as Re ar . One must drop the notion that the linkage is to be enforced at some tangible value of a normal coordinate. The boundary layer scale ô is proportional to Re - ' r2 , so certainly as Re all the boundary layer variation has occurred far closer to the wall than any fixed (i.e., Re-independent) positive value of the mainstream coordinate Y. On the other hand, any fixed value of the boundary layer coordinate y is at a definite position within the boundary layer and cannot be an entirely suitable place to Link with the mainstream. Therefore, we assert that the inviscid component LF(X Y) at Y = 0 should he equated with the boundary layer component ar(x, y) at y — oz;. From what we have just written. what eke could be appropriate?t The numerical results will not differ much from those obtained in the patching approach, but the matching approach is more readily capable of proof and extension. The previous paragraph still has the spirit of seeking a !oration For matching Better understanding of the boundary condition emerges if one frees oneself as much as possible from the patching frame of mind and seeks an overlap region where boundary layer and inviscid flow merge_ This region should be composed of values that, as Re ; a;, approach the wall, on the one hand, and the far extremities of the boundary layer, on the other- Such a set is given in terms of a function e(Re) by ,
^r
rr
i.e., y
— Re -
we.
(l4)
• We proceed in a manner that is else 311 ial ly self-cnnlained, but the reader who has studied Elementary singular perturbation theory, as in Chapter 9 of t will have a much more Secure understanding of the issLcs inwolrcdt One care also argue that ilk matching of {, at Y = O with a al y = cc Ô the most natural mathematical formulation of the fact that as Re ne, any tixcd 4alus oft lc free-stream variable Y. however small. corresponds to larger and larger 4alues of the boundary layer variable y. ,
Sec. 131 Ott Boundary Layers
113
provided that lim Re -I12 19(Re)
1im Q(Re) = Re
Re +^
^^
Using (14), we substitute for Y and y in terms of
O.
(15a, b)
the intermediate variable ri
and write our matching requirement as dim U [ x, Its-•oc \
JJJ
= dim Re-t
^ r;
i1(x,
R
((6) s)
We stress that ri is held constant in the above limits. Here we work only to the lowest approximation wherein the mainstream equations (5) and the boundary layer equations (11) are simplified by taking them in the limit Re x. The limiting equations contain no trace of Re, so (16) reduces to U(x, 0) = u(x, CO, the requirement previously arrived at. The notion of an overlap region gives this requirement added plausibility. More important, it provides the foundation of an approach that is more easily extended when higher approximations are desired. We have derived matching conditions for the horizontal velocity component 14, but what about the vertical component u? The structure of the equations (13) indicates that u should not he specified as y x : second order y-derivatives appear on u but only first derivatives on a. Thus two boundary conditions are anticipated on u (at y = O and y cc) but only one on u (the vanishing of y at y = 0, which is certainly required by the physical problem). Turning to the streamwise coordinate x, similar considerations indicate that we should require one condition on u and none on u, for (13) contains terms proportional to u„ but u is never differentiated with respect to x. Consequently, if we prescribe the entering horizontal velocity u(x, y) at a certain location (say x = 0), then we expect to be able to compute the flow downstream of that location. Summarizing, we find that the boundary layer problem for flow above* a flat plate of length I. has the following mathematical formulation, to first approximation: ux + vy = 0,
1411, + Vtl y ` U U ' ury ,
O < y< cc, O<x< L. u(x,0) =u(x,0)=0, u(0, y) = uo(y),
0<x< L,
y > O.
lln7 u(x, y) ; U(x, 0), 0< x < L . U(x, 0) and u o(y) are prescribed functions.
'
Flow below is determined by symmetry.
Vis-cous Ftyids
11 4
(C }I. 3
Formulation of the boundary layer problem is hardly a straightforward mailer, and the critical reader may well fed uneasy at this point. Can one trust "physical intuition" when one has no genuine experience of the flow inside the slivery thin boundary layer region? Awareness that a mathematical model is never identical with a physical situation is all the sharper when, as here, rather bold approximations are being attempted. Only further study of partial differential equations and of fluid mechanics can build lull confidence in boundary layer theory_ Nevertheless, the reader may find some reassurance in the discussion of Appendix 3.2, where we show that there appears to be just enough information in (17) to (201 to produce a unique numerical solution_ Moreover, it may be reassuring that a simplified "caricature" of the boundary layer problem seems to have a unique solution (Exercise 5). since most of the The "thickness .' of the boundary layer is of order Re variation across the layer takes place in a multiple or two of the normal length scale = Re - " L. For the runner mentioned at the beginning of this section, L = 10 cm, Re = l0', so the boundary layer thickness is of magnitude 113 mm, It is noteworthy that although the boundary layer is exceedingly thin, yet (as we shall see more clearly below) developments within it have vital and even dominant roles to play in the formation of the entire flow pattern. ' +3 ,
EXERCISES I. Estimate the overall Reynolds number: (a) For a fast-moving automobile. (b) For a hard-thrown baseball or hard-kicked soccer hall. (c) For a large jet airliner at cruising speed, (d) For a dust speck falling in air. le) For the motion of a whiplike cilium that propels a paramecium. (The cilia beat about 30 limes per second with an amplitude that is a sizable fraction of their length of about 10 pm = 10 - 3 cm.) 2. Estimate the boundary layer thickness in cases(a),(b), and (c) in Exercise 1. }3. la) A definite displacenient thickness 6 1 is sometimes used to characterize the extent of the boundary layer. By definition
45,(x)r FI _—^ j
1') dy. a(x LI( X , 01 1
Justify this definition. (b) A momei tum thickness is also useful on occasion. Give an appropriate definition. Explain your answer_ 4. This exercise is concerned with a change of variables, due to R. von Mises, that transforms the boundary layer equations (17) into a single partial differential equation that is well adapted for further analytical
Sri- 3 41 Boundary L
as
i
15
and theoretical work. For further information sec, For example, Rosenhead (1963. p. 212), or the paper by W. Waiter cited at the end of Appendix 3.2. Introduce new independent variables { , i) by = s(x, y) = x,
y)
n=
u x, s) rlw.
(2 I )
Let a new dependent variable w be defined by
ww^b, rï) = u 2[xt , q) f^f4 q)], .
.
where .va. qj = and y(. in are the inverse relations found from [2])_ Show that the problem (17) to (201 transforms into the following: iw d W
[' 'W
1
r
n , UI = 0, 410, ,I)
lim
41L1,
D < < L. f} < rf < r .
4)1.
ql
0< < L
-
Hire (t) — Cî`lt, 0). 5. Confidence that a mathematical problem is well posed can be obtained by showing that a simplified version of the problem has a unique solution. ln this spirit. sketch a solution (using separation of variables) to the following version of the boundary layer equations. wherein the convective velocities have been replaced by constants and the matching boundary condition is applied at a finite boundary layer "edge. ,, f htr r = fix) +
rr =r=flon f'=O.
tr 1 + i•s z
O.
0< x
<
L,
0 < }• < M .
u —jrf_tton} = M.
u=yl}`1 on .x= O.
Here u and b are given constants; J. g, and h are given Functions.
3.4 Boundary Layer Flow Past
a
Semi infinite Flat Plate -
We limit our further work with the boundary layer equations to a discussion of the most important exact solution, that relevant for uniform flow along a fiat plate. In this flow the velocity vector approaches the constant O) far from a plate laid along the x-axis. The inviscid solution is simply t! * (x*, y*) = [lo u * = O. The effect of small viscosity is expected to he to a thin region along the plate and to a wake region behind it. Inconfied ,
order to locus on a single effect, we shall consider the case of a semi-infinite plate, extending along the x-axis from 0 to °. Here, there is no wake_
1 sir
Vi_srnus Fluids ICIL 3
FORMULATION
Introduction of a stream function i*(x*, y*) such that
d1P * _^*
ti *
U*
Y
.00* ax*
-
(1)
automatically guarantees satisfaction of the continuity equation clr4•
ay",
(^x *
icy*
terms of the nondirnertsional stream function kfix, y) , (I) should read
In
u=— u= -- (2) It follows [Exercise 1(a)] that when the stream function is employed, the boundary layer variables are defined by __
!* y (UOLv) 1/2
x=
x* L
y* = (vL/U l,) t !3 ' (5
Y*
(3a)
i.e., x* s {-
i'(x•, Y*)
y* (v'f-1Uo) 11 #
(L!0 Lv)"2
( 3 b)
In terms of ', with U = 1 , the boundary layer problem for uniform flow above a semi-infinite flat plate: is x > f}, y > O.
= X)Y• tfi =(x, 0) _ ,Jr,,(x, 4) °- O,
y > 0.
/)(0, :) = 1, litre rfr)(x, y)
x > 0.
1,
x > 0.
(4a) (4b, c) (4d) (4e)
We expect the flow just at the entrance to the boundary layer to be undisturbed by the plate, so we have imposed the condition u* = U0 at x* = O. The dimensionless form of this condition is u1 =or = 1, because the velocity scale of the inviscid flow is its constant horizontal component U o . BI.ASIUS SIMILARITY SOLUTION
The above problem has a solution of the special similarity type in which the independent variables appear only in a certain combination. Experienced f
Further discussion of the legitimacy and uscfu Irless of the stream fund ion may be found in 15.1.3 and 15.1.4 of I. We have delayed the introduction of the stream function to maximize experience with systems of partial differential equations and to minimizt the appearance of Concepts that are somewhat special. albeit very useful.
Um-61,n
5rr. 3.4] Boundurt• Layer Firm. Prj.sr a .Semi-rrf nice
Flrtr Harr
117
analysis anticipate such solutions in relatively simple problems involving infinite or semi-infinite boundaries, whence determination of [heir precise form is a relatively simple matter [Exercise 2(b)7. Moreover, similarity solutions are the subject of a still-developing theory based on the invariance of problems under continuous groups of transformations (see Exercises 8 to 10). A way to guess the character of the solution front general principles stems from the observation that no geometric length scale L remains in our semi-infinite problem. This suggests that the form of the function 0 in (3b) must be such that I. does not appear. One possibility is iJ(x, p)
(2x)tr2 f(+11.
ry
ü
(2x) -
(5)
For then, from (3), * !Mx * y*) = (U 0 L;')l(3 2x*
-1
t+
= (2110 ux*}t^2 f ^,*
^
^ 2Vx*
2
_.. 3
.,
1; 2
In (5) the constant 2 has been inserted for cnnvenicnce; the alternatives to (5) lead to essentially the same final results [Exercise 2(a)],t Using (5), we find (Exercise ( (b)] ll -
(I?),
c _ (2_ )'
P " f•(ij LL l
— Pia J
d ter)
(7)
It is straightforward to verify that the problem (4) now becomes
1" t fir= t) , f(0) = f '(0) = 0, j '( -r )= I.
8la d y
There is indeed a solution of the form (5). If an x appeared explicitly in (8a), then f could not be a funclinn of r7 nnly, but this did not happen. Both the limits x — ► 0 and y —0 correspond to Ft x. so the two boundary conditions (4d) and (4e) cor respond to the single condition (8d), giving the three boundary conditions expected in a third order differential equation. 'the problem (8j could be solved numerically by assuming f "(0) = A, and computing j at = P1)1, rr = 0, 1, 2, .... Results of various computations can be used to select a good approximation to that value of A which provides a Anoi her way to Ira u ii t he form of
is to reason that in the absence oratternaiis'cs a multiple
of Y• itself must he the c€7rrect Icngih scats i, al a Indeed. if
L
distance sc. downstream from ittc leading edge
.
is replaced by 7r* in (h), then one Aims t
011% ..
4 21-T [j VA * ) " 0
t.^
k 2 . INA* US' .2 )
which is equivalent to tbl. We shall see seticral limes in what follows how the .x' plays the role of the overall length scab_
distance
riB
liiscrr:3s fluids (C7r. 3
solution satisfyingf'(cx;) = I (see Exercise 3). i-i. Blasius, the first to discuss this similarity solution, solved (8) by a series method in his 1908 paper. But the following observations give a more elegant and economical way of proceeding (see Exercise 14 for another approach). 1f F() is a solution of (8a), then so is uF(ori), for any constant a. Choosing F"(Ü) = 1 for convenience, one solves the initial value problem# F' + FF" = O. E(C) ` F'(4) = 0, F10) = L
(9)
if u is chosen to satisfy a
lim
(lo)
then aF(ini) will be the desired solution (Exercise 4). This solution is tahulated, for example, in Rosenhead (1963, p. 224)_ There is good agreement between the predicted velocities and measurements made in a number of experiments_ Of considerable interest is the predicted drag. This is obtained by integrating the wall shearing stress T x . at location x*, where [Exercise 1(c)1 t7u * L x'
_P
}^
*
= f• =
o
" 2 pilo(R x •} 112f10].
(llj
[T he answer is expressed in terms of a local Reynold; number R.. x* iv.] We find that the drag on one side of a unit- width portion of the plate which extends a distance L downstream is 21l2119W,LR,7 (12 f"(0). A customarily defined dimensionless drag coefficient C D is given by ,1 -
2312/ 10)R "
(12)
The numerical solution provides f "(0), with the result C.' = 1.3282I "2
(13)
An important general conclusion is that the viscous drag on a fixed area decreases to zero as the viscosity decreases to zero. DEFECTS IN THE BLAS1US SOLUTION
We note that the predicted shearing stress act ually becomes infinite at x 0 like x - "2. The integral of the stress remains finite but doubt is certainly cast on the validity of the theory for small values of x. Iii pursuing this matter, we recall that the boundary layer approximation is derived for flows whose overall Reynolds number is large compared to unity. For the flat plate, we (ft9) is much easier than chat of (13t, for only a single - march t Numerical initial values is required_ outward from attic given
.S+•r . 3.41 Boundary Layer Ffulr Pair o .Semr-infinite fur Harr
119
have seen that the correct choice for the length scale is the downstream distance x*; i_e., the flow is characterized by the local Reynolds number LF a x*/v. We must thus expect failure of our theory close enough to the Leading edge, so that {l a x*/v < 1, say. [Note that the theoretical defect reveals itself in the discontinuity of Oy at the origin, a discnntinuity required by (4c11 and 044) An incorrect picture of the flow over the short distance vfl a ' should have only a small effect on overall drag predictions, but nonetheless improvement of the theory is of considerable interest_ It can be shown that
1.22(2x)
"
as pc-
cr2 i
(14)
(see Exercise 6). As x ; 0 for fixed y, the vertical velocity component is thus seen to become unbounded. Consequently, the boundary layer solution is defective not only at the leading edge of the plate, but all along the line x : O. Except near y = 0, there seems to he no reason for this defect Indeed, except near the leading edge, the defect disappears if parabolic rather than Cartesian coordinates are employed. Formula (14) also applies for fixed positive x at the" edge" of the boundary layer (y ) and shows that the flow there is directed slightly away from Further, there is erificatioii of our assertion that ex, the plate. unlike 1411x, xij, will be predicted, so that no attempt should he made to match z to the -
inviscid flow. From the very form of the solution (7) we can deduce the qualitative result that the boundary layer thickness increases parabolically with downstream distance. Whatever criterion on u is used to define this thickness, the deduction follows from the fact that u is constant when q is constant, je., when x is a constant multiple of y 2 . Tabulation off' gives quantitative results_ it turns out that f is more than 90 per cent of the way to its ultimate value of unity when ti exceeds 2.4, and more than 99 per cent of the way when a exceeds 16. Thus if boundary thickness is defined as the location ' y , where the horizontal velocity component reaches 90 per cent of its inviscid value, then y2 g — 2.4(2 x * vilie) 1 ". if one employs the displacement thickness 0;,the dimensional version of the quantity defined in Exercise 3.3(a). it is found that = 12(2x. ilLf0) t r In principle the boundary layer approximation should become increasingly accurate as the speed U U is increased, but in practice steady boundary layer flow develops an instability when L!c x*/v exceeds a value of around 600. (See Section 15.2 of I on stability, particularly its concluding cxample.t) Once instability sets in, oscillations and irregularities become more prominent as x* increases and the flow soon exhibits the random eddying that is characteristic of turbulence. Local drag is much larger in turbulent flow than in See also Chapter SoFt:' C. Lin, Theory uf ffOrodynurrar Str3hoiir}' I New York Cambridge University Press, [955), lo supplement i he general stability coFesidrt atinns nt I wlth an account ,
o r rescarcir a=] this pariiCU[ar prvblcm.
120
t'i.sCUUS
M. irl.s
1C:h_ 3
/Laminar (nonturhulent). Roughly speaking, this is because the eddies are more efficient at mixing than molecular diffusion,so that a larger,"effec Live diffusion coefficient" must replace p in the computation of viscous stress, BOUNDARY LAYE R SEPARATION
Another deviation between theory and practice can be illustrated by considering uniform flow past spheres and cylinders. We shall restrict ourselves to two-dimensional flow past cylinders in which the circulation is zero. (Compare Section 15.E of I.) In both situations, therefore, the standard inviscid solutions are symmetric fore and aft_ Pressure decreases from the Forwardrnost point to the corresponding side point or equator, and then increases symmetrically. If boundary layer theory is used to improve on the inviscid results, profound consequences are seen to arise from the increase in pressure over the rear of the body. (The terni adverse pressure gradient is used when pressure increases with downstream distance. See Figure 3.13.) Since the pressure within the boundary layer is the same as that outside (to first approximation), the boundary layer flow is progressively slowed by the adverse pressure gradient. Beyond some point P the boundary
0
F tG t,tit t 3. # 3. Symmetrical inriscid flow pusr cylinder or _spfrerre. S.- stagnation is :OW. Both in the graph giving lrre.ssure und o n the cylinder. point,whervlcy the hoa ry line singles out the region of adverse pressure gradient n,he re in ?Alen > O.
Syr. 3.4]
l3rrurnfur}• Layer
Paw a Semi-infinite Flat Phare
12 I
layer is predicted to contain a region of upstream flow. But in essence this means that upstream fluid is deflected by a zone emaciating from P and extending outward into the flow. The boundary layer is said to have separated from the body at (or near) P (Figure 3.14). Obstacles in uniform flow can he divided into two classes, bluff nr streamlined, depending upon whether nr not significant separation occurs. As we shall now indicate very briefly, the character of the flow and the degree of Our understanding are very different in the two classes.
P
F1auR E 3. 1 4. Successive tangential velocity profil es in a separating boundary Slaw bac'kftr3 ► } . omits in rlae .shaded region, elownsire'urn of the separation layer. point P. SLIGHTLY VISCOUS UNIFORM FLOW PAST STREAMLINED BODIES
Separation is a negligible factor in uniform flow past a slender body with a pointed trailing portion, provided that t he body is not badly misaligned with the flow_ A first approximation to such streamline flows is provided by inviscid theory, and a correction by boundary layer methods_ In principle, a more accurate solution can be obtained by modifying the inviscid outer flow, so that it corresponds to flow past a body with a normal "blowing" given by r.(x, coo) as calculated by boundary layer theory. Passing beyond the first term of boundary layer theory has turned out, however, to require remarkably subtle analysis. This can be illustrated by considering the boundary layer downstream of the trailing edge of - a flat plaie of length L . The stream function must still satisfy (4a), but now the solution must be matched to the Blasius solution of(7) and (S) upstream of the trailing edge. The no-slip conditions on the plate must be replaced by symmetry conditions v = U and dujdy = O. A solution to this problem was published by S_ Goldstein in 1930. This solution had a relatively thin " wake layer" within the ordinary boundary layer. Only in 1969 and 1970, respectively, did K. Stewartsori and A. Messiter find that Goldstein's solution gave a defective description of the pressure. To fix this up, a layer had to be introduced that was thin compared to the
Viscous FJuirii [C'h. 3
J 22
wake and whose length shrank to zero as Re co. This may well seem an academic matter, but it is not. An accurate first correction to the Blasius drag formula (i3) is only obtained if the "triple deck" structure of the boundary layer at the trailing edge is taken into account. (And, indeed, aerodynamicists are aware of the fact that flow details at the trailing edge of wings have a remarkably large effect upon drag. l Thus a presumnably accurate cor rection to the drag coefficient for a flat plate only appeared six decades after Blasius's original calculation! It almost goes without saying that there is no proof that the formal calculations provide an appropriate approximation to the exact solution as Re —k OD. Streamline flows at large Re contain regions of turbulence in both boundary layer and wake.° Although much of value is known about turbulence, and its effect can be estimated in many practical situations, there is to this day no satisfactory foundation on which to base investigations of this phenomenon_ The combined statistical and nonlinear nature of turbulent flow gives rise to theoretical problems that have so far resisted all efforts to construct a theory of generality and power. Si.IGHTI.Y VISCOI:s [:NIFORNi FLOW PAST 81-11_, IF1 BODIES
Boundary layer separation will be present when the conditions cited above for streamline flow are not met. In particular, in the phenomenon of stall separation occurs even for flow past a streamlined airfoil if there is sufficient misalignment with the mainstream. Separation generally brings about an overall flow pattern which is markedly different from that predicted by straightlbrward inviscid theory; its main feature is a large and unsteady wake region. The idea that boundary layer theory can be straightforwardly used to correct a relatively simple inviscid flow must now be abandoned. Yet this theory remains useful for bluff bodies if ii is employed in conjunction with measurements of the mainstream flow. Also, the combination of inviscid and boundary layer theory can give worthwhile results somewhat upstream of the separation point-t Special note must be made of the fact that in spite of separation, the inviscid solution For the cylinder (studied in Section 15.4 of I) is still of great use in calculating genuine flows. With the aid of conformal mapping, this solution can he transformed so that it provides a uniform two-dimensional inviscid flow past an airfoil. Excluding stall, separation effects are negligible in such flows. An outstanding theoretical problem is to calculate the flow pattern around a bluff body, say a sphere or a cylinder, in the limit Re -• a;. Because of Al sufficiently high speeds compressibility effects become important. but these hate been excluded from our considerations here a circular cylinder al Reynolds numbers of order Qf magnitude I0 4 . separation occurs .
t For
ahoul 80° downstream from the forwardrnost tsiagnation) point. At higher tpxd their: is turbulence in the boundary layer forward or the separation pOint.and separation is delayed.
Sec. 3,411 Baum/elf I. Luger Flan Past rt Sears-urr intre flat F`Harr
123
separation, a pronounced lack of symmetry between upstream and downstream flow is anticipated. The limiting inviscrd solution can and certainly will contain discontinuities in velocity between certain adjacent streamlines. The general characteristics of this limiting solution remain unknown, although slow progress seems to be forthcoming from a combination of advances in asymptotic theory, numerical calculation, and experiment. Calculations and experiments cannot provide definitive results because the actual flow becomes unsteady at sufficiently high Re. The limiting solution is still of interest, however. even though it must be unstable to perturbations, The mathematical challenge rrf providing an asymptotic analysis of a prototype nonlinearity is perhaps sufficient motivation for continued study of tlhe problem, but the limiting solution should also be of use in approximating flows where Re is moderately large. For the flat plate, as we have seen, the drag approaches zero as the viscosity decreases. The same is true in general for streamlined bodies. But for bluff bodies the radically different nature of upstream and downstream velocity and pressure fields in large Reynolds number flows is responsible for the significant drag actually found, in contrast to the small drag expected from a slight alteration of D'Alembert's classical "no-drag" result for inviscid flow. The dramatic difference between the drag for streamlined and nonstreamlined bodies is illustrated in Figure 3.15. l
•
streamlined turfed au u l a rtrc•rtlur = 4 x IO ° r L. .{ Bak hrlrrr. I 967. e;rfsrda•r ►t itlr he ►urne dray at speed p.336.) The appeared ert hug.. .a.. Frrlktk'r. t'. M . and Walker, 11b'_ S. Aeronaut. Research Council. R ep . and Mern,, rrrr, l2.41 . Re•drut+ri tt all t"iiiLlltt
3 15 4c•Irt7nutre• crass sct'rie+tr rtJ .
fit
pernis.Ycm,
Inviscid flow, boundary layer, separation, turbulence the development of these concepts and others like them has made it possible to understand the general outlines of results as complicated as the cylinder drag plotted in Figure 3_16_ Moi ivaied by the desire to build better aircraft and ships, the study of uniform flow past obstacles forms one of the most developed parts of fluid mechanics. As we have briefly indicated, much has been accomplished but much remains to be explained. The following survey articles provide recent discussions of orne of the advanced topics that we have mentioned: M. Van Dyke, "Higher Order
Viscous Fluids [Ch, .ï
12 4
1.5
i .o
05
o lD° ee''
?atip
R. —
3. 16. Qrealitatire befutr•ior of the dray per unit axial length as u junction of Reynolds number for a circular cylinder of radius a_ The cross-hatched region represents a drop in dr a y due to bnuexdeary layer tur b elP n ce and corrsegreenr rnot Yrrur n t of rhe .separarir err mind from e i br l ur 80 to 120'. }lurelriny is tutcessary because results depe n d ro some . extent o n th e amount of turbulence in the wind tu ►trtel. (Botrlrekxr, 1 967, p. 34 i , or Ro.senhrad, 1963, p. 106.) FIGURE
Boundary Layer theory," and S. Brown and K. Stewartson " Laminar Separation," Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech. I W. Sears and M. Van Dyke, eds. (Palo Alla, Calif.: Annual Reviews, inc., 1969), pp. 265-92 and 45-72, respectively; P_ A_ Lagerstrom, "Solutions of the Navier-Stokes Equation at Large Reynolds Number," SIAM J. App!. Math_ 28, 202-14 (1975); K. Stewartson, "Multistructured Boundary Layers on Flat Plates and Related Bodies," Advances in Applied McwhaMics 14, 145--239 (1974), also "On the Asymptotic Theory of Separated and Unseparated Fluid Motions," SIAM J. App[. Math. 28,501-18(1975). ,
E X E R CIS E 5
1. (a) If Oi* and W are, respectively, dimensional and dimensionless stream functions, then ;11 = *IC, where C is a constant. This constant must be such that (2) is satisfied. Verify the text's result C U 0 15. Check that C is dimensionally correct. (b) Verify (7) and (8). (c) Verify (11). 2. (a) Suppose that = (2x) :11g(0), 0 = xjy2 . This accomplishes the goal of eliminating dependence on L just as well as assumption (5). Comment.
Sec_ 3.41
Boundary Layer Flow Pusf uSr m i-infinif e flu Haw
l'S
By substituting into (4), (5), and (6), discuss the process of determining whether these equations have a solution of the form = _eig(yx/ for some constants a and b. (c) Modify the differential equation so that the problem does not have a solution of the assumed form_ Modify the boundary conditions to the same end. 3. (a) Set up a difference scheme that could be used to solve the initial value problem consisting of (8a) to (Sc) plus the condition #'"(ü) = A. A a parameter. lb) Let f(x) = NIA); the notation makes explicit the fact that the limiting value of ' depends on the initial condition .4. revise an algorithm that in principle could be used to determine to arbitrary accuracy the value A which ensures f(x•) = 1. 4. (a) Verify that if (l C) holds, then aF(arl) will satisfy the equations of l8), as asserted in the text. Op) (Project) Using the method of (a(, write a computer program and use it to determine the solution to (s). 5. As was shown in Exercise 15.1.7 of I, in steady inviscid incompressible flows without body forces. Bernoulli's equation guarantees that (b)
Ps + ip[(u') 2 + (r"*)2 J = p + where p x is the pressure far from the obstacle. Use this to interpret the definition of the drag coefficient (12). 6. (a) To obtain the behavior of the solution to (8) for large Values of 17. one assumes that . f{.f )
_
-
rr
B + 4(O.
OW small,
B a constant.
Why is the assumption made? (b) Using the above assumption. deduce the approximation
B + A(ri — BY 2 exp [ - 40l — B1 2 ].
A a constant.
[Equation (14) follows at once, using the value of B obtained from the numerical solution.] 7. Separation occurs for a circular cylinder before the region of ads Erse pressure gradient begins, according to Figure 113_ Discuss. In the present section and elsewhere, we have studied problems for partial differential equations that have similarity solutions, wherein the dependent variables essentially appear only in a certain combination. The next three exercises explore this matter further. Further references are G. Birkhof,, Hydrodynamics, A Study in Logit, Fact, and Similitude (Princeton. N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1960) [also issued by Dover Publications] and G. W. Bluman and J. D. Cole, Shniturit y Methods for Constructing Solutions to Ordinary and Partial Differential Equations (New York: Springer-Verlag, 1974).
c a6
4'i.vcnus Fluids
(Ch. 3
8. (a) Consider the transformations {1i Ay'', x + Bx, and y -1 Cy_ Show that the boundary layer problem (4) is invariant under these transformations if and only if C = A and S = AC. (b) if the problem has a unique solution, the solution must also be invariant under the above set of transformations. From this, deduce the form of the similarity solution (5). NOTE. The idea that invariance to a group of stretching transformations requires a solution in which variables our in certain combinations can be regarded as underlying the reduction of parameter number obtained by the use of dimensionless variables. 9. To afford further practice in the use of similarity solutions, consider the fl ow of a thin two dimensional jet into fluid at rest. It can be shown [e.g., Rosenhead (1963, p. 75410 that the flow is governed by the boundary in layer equation (4a) but with the boundary conditions -
0
as y
O„ = 0
at y
► y,
cc, 0,
x>0
(symmetry in x-axis);
x > {]
1l► ^ dy = M, M a constant (a)
(flow dies out far from jet);
(same flow of momentum across each section).
Considering the same class of transformations as in Exercise S, deduce that there is a solution of the form xi3{•(7)
r=
yx- 213
Show that the problem has a solution which is a numerical constant times cc tank arl, where ct is determined by the momentum condition. 10. Consider diffusion of heat in an unbounded homogeneous medium wherein the temperature depends only on the distance [rani a plane, line, and point, respectively. The governing equation for temperature T, (lD)
T
= KV 2 T,
thermal conductivity,
then takes the form
7;= x[T„ +(n—l)r - 'T, where n = i , 2, 3, respectively. (a) We are interested in the diffusion of a fixed quantity of heat, initially at the origin. Show that the corresponding restriction on Tis
fc Jo
Tr" dr = constant.
.Ser. 3.4]
Boundary Layer A ra . I'u.0 a Semi-irlfrrlite flat plurr
127
lb) Show that search for a similarity solution leads to an ordinary differential equation which can be written f' -
fl" + i ► i(f '
f)
0
r 2 /4hr.
for a certain function f f), where =
:AO Solve the equation of (b) subject to the boundary conditions
f
as r
and f ` ,- ► iÏ
+(d) Use superposition (with integrals) to generalize the
solution of
(c)
so that you can deal with the diffusion of a fixed quantity of heat which is initially distributed in an arbitrary fashion. le) What is the solution for a line source at r — 0 (two-dimensional problem) producing heat at a constant rate? The next three exercises give a glimpse of a subject that is the focus of considerable current interest, the interconnectton between chemical reaction and flow. The material for these exercises is taken from Chapter 2 of Levich 11962), 11. Consider boundary layer flow past a semi infinite flat plate. -
(al Show that deep within the boundary layer (t.e. "very" near the plate) the horizontal velocity component u* satisfies ,
u* ^
k}^* I-14 vx • '
(15)
where k is a constant. In fact, k is about (b) Show that (15) is reasonable in view of the following fact. lithe thickness b of th e boundary layer is defined as the distance from the plate then numerical calculations show where u' is 90 per cent of that e5 5.2(vx*/Uoli l 12. Suppose that a chemical is present to a fluid !hawing past an object, and that the chemical reacts very quickly with the material of which the object is composed. It is assumed that the chemical concentration C*(x*, v) is governed by the following problem, where u' and v* are given functions. ,
u* C'* -- ►
la )
Co
r)C* cx*
a.,,.
re. [' c*
,1L'*
+ ^* Cy * =-
D
far from the object.
+
r7(y*)2
f 16a)
C* = O on the object. (16h)
What physical assumptions are implied by (16)'' (b) Suppose that both u• and i.* have a typical magnitude U 0 , and that u* and u* typically undergo significant changes in a distance L. Introduce scaled dimensionless variables rnto (16). Gomment
i28
Viscous Fluids [C'1,. 3
briefly nn the advantages of this procedure. Discuss in general terms the type of solution expected when the Peclet number Pe ï fi e L jD satisfies Pe i> I (a common occurrence). 13. We wish to examine WI) in the case where there is a "concentration boundary layer" close to the semi-infinite flat plate y* O. 0, x* Flow far from the plate satisfies = h 0 ^a* = t]. We expect that if D is small enough, the concentration boundary layer thickness d will be small, even compared with the ordinary viscous boundary layer thickness b. Let us introduce scaled dimensionless variables that are apprnpriate within such a Concentration boundary layer, set up an apprnpriate mathematical problem, and draw a general conclusion without solving. (a) Choose scales for x* and y*. (h) Formula (IS) can be employed for n*. Why? Use it and (a) to obtain a scale for ü*. (c) We assume that Ou*/ex* + De1*f y* = O. (What does this imply?) Consequently, the two terms on the left of (liôa) should have the same magnitude. Why? The scaling for v should now be apparent. (d) Find a formula for the order of magnitude of d in terms of the other parameters. Use it to show that the concentration boundary layer is about one-tenth as thick as the viscous boundary layer in those eases (which occur frequently) when Pe 1000 Re. (e) Set up a dimensionless mathematical problem for determining the leading approximation to the concentration, within the concent ration boundary layer. Remember: u* and u* are regarded as given, u* by (1S) and us by a r:nrresponding formula. (f) As a rough approximation, the rate at which chemical is being absorbed at the boundary, per unit area, is taken to be DCad. Justify this approximation. 14. This exercise is concerned with a methnd for obtaining the Blasius Nat!. Acad. Sci. 27, similarity solution that is due to H. Weyl 578 (1941)]. (a) Let 9(q) = F"(7). w here F is defined by (9). Show that (9) is equivalent to an equation of the form g = (Dig), where .
(Ng) = ex (b) The above equation can be treated by means of the following successive approximations scheme (compare Section 7.2 of I): fa=U, 1,2,....
Show that (z — C) 3 exp (—
g 3(2) = exp 0
^
dt;
-
Sec. 3.5} Vortiriry (7ruriyes in Viscous Fluid Mork*: (c)
(d)
129
Demonstrate that O(g) O, (g) (Dig*) if g s y, Show that all odd approximants (i.e., all g with odd subscripts) are greater than or equal than even approximants. Show further that as n increases, the odd approximants decrease and the even ones increase. Prove that r
g,(z)]
-
,
and thereby deduce the existence of a unique solution q to which the approximants converge.
3.5 Vorticity Changes in Viscous Fluid Motion If a Muid moves with velocity v(x, t], the fortieity trl(x, t) is defined by ru(x. ti = curl v(x, r)
(1)
A major result of Section 3.1 allows us to interpret to as twice the angular velocity vector of the sotid body rotation, which, together with translation and elongation, makes up the local fluid motion. It turns out that great insight into the nature ol- fluid motion is attained by studying the mechanisms by which vorticity changes, in general and in particular instances_ An introduction to these matters is the subject of this sectton-
In a viscous fluid of uniform density, subject to a conservative body force, an equation for the evolution of vorticity can be obtained by taking the curl of the Navier-Stokes equations (1.28). By judicious use of various identities (Exercise l) one arrives at the following result:
r
+ V • VW
w •''v + V
2 (1.1.
(2)
The pressure does not appear in (2), and this is one reason why, it is advantageous to study the development of vorticity. VORTICITY CONVECTION AND STRETCHING
Let us first consider how vorticity changes in the absence of viscosity. With v = D, (2) becomes Po.)
at
^-
v • Vw = w - Vv,
i.e.,
Dw
Dr —
op V v.
(3)
As discussed in Section 13.3 of 1, the term ' Vt.) represents a change in vorticity due to convection, in which voracity is bodily carried from place to place by the fluid motion.
Viscutis Fluids [Ch. 3
As a start toward understanding the fa. Vv terms consider at time r two material points P and Q (points fixed in the fluid). Suppose that P is located at x and Q at x + En, a distance r. along a unit vector n (Figure 3. i 7). A short time Ar later, P will have been displaced by 4'(x, r)Ar + ()UAW] while the corresponding approximate displacement for Q will her(x + nr, r)At O[(Ar) 2 ]. Neglecting 01Arl 1 terms, we see that the original vector in which -t joins P to Q will have been transformed into a new vector given by un + [+.(x + un) - v(x) Via --- un i (n V+)[:Ar + O(t: 2 ). -
(4)
Subtracting the original vector en and dividing by Ar, we conclude that to lowest order in a the quantity tai[ Vi is the rate of change per unit time of a {short) material vector En emanating from x. n
E t. 1.)^
1
[Ie -pYipr
1 ,. - [ Î A t
F u te r 1.11 A short line of parades PQ rs riirrte+f in sink. At [utrf? the line P'Q' by flow with t•elueirr v -
We can write D(Fn)
Dr
= [:n• V r
(as i— O).
(5)
Using (3) and (5), we sex. that if a—cn is initially zero, then it remains zero, for D(m — un) = tl. f)r
(6)
[The result holds if the differential equation has a unique solution, for w — Fla ; 0 is certainly one so lution of (6) that satisfies the initial conditions_ Uniquenesswill obtain if l Vr is bounded-j What we have shown is this. Units can be chosen so that to can initially be identified with a material vector to of small length F. The smaller t is the more nearly it is true that to continues to be identified with, and to move like, the • Our discussion hut! will be intuitive. A rtg,ornus appruaCh Section 2-3 on tensor caluul«s-
ta ou[li=3rd in trie cxEfeLSCS [or
Sec-. 3.5] Ifurtii ihti
n ges in Viscous Changes
Fluid h#otdnn
11
material vector i.n. Thus (31 can be interpreted as describing evolution of the vorticity vector equivalent to that which would recur if that vector were an (infinitesimally long) material vector. Relative motion of the fluid at the two ends of the vector causes it to undergo a rigid rotation (relative velocity normal to +o) and a contraction or elongation (relative velocity along (,))Rotation merely changes the orientation of the vorticity. But velocity changes along u} effectively alter the extent of the spinning region and bring about annihilation or production of vorticity, just as a twirling ice skater can change his rotation speed by laterally extending or pulling in his arms. One can think of vortex lines throughout the fluid passing from one vorticity vector to the "adjacent - one, and vorticity being generated by the stretching of these linesYtsCOUS VORTICITY DIFFUSION AND BOUNDARY GENERATION The introduction of 'viscosity brings into [he picture two new ways for vorticity to change. First, the vino term in (2) is responsible for vorticity diffusion; local spin al one location will, through shear stresses, engender spin at an adjacent location. etc. Second, the necessity for the fluid to adhere at the boundary brings about a shear. Thus in a viscous fluid the boundary is a source (or sink) of vorticity so that an initially irrotational vise iw fluid will not remain irrotational. To obtain formal confirmation ofthe boundary's role as a vorticity source, note from the vorticity equation (2) that the diffusion lean is the negative divergence of a (tensor) vorticity flux — vVw. Consider a fiat plate along z = a: here
so
rrwu=$1.=D
!t
i
=0
c+r rit C'L' Fv =[),--= — - + ,— =0. 0. y' f.: fly i'.t
where we have used the mass conservation condition V-v = O. The %vorticity generated by the plate is given by corrlputing the following expression at z =O: ^^•
iz
= r
l p fi l l) z = vV 2 =- ^ - . i7
p f. y.
We see that vorticity is generated even in the limit r O. It can be shown that there is a unique velocity field v(x, r) that corresponds to a given vorticity field ra(x, t). subject only to the restriction that the normal velocity component of the fluid equals that of an adjacent boundary (with
suitable conditions al infinity). In a short time interval (I, + ,)the vorticity (0(x, t) is convected, stretched, and diffused according to (2) but additional vorticity appears near the boundary (from the boundary source). This provides the unique w(x, r + At) that gives identical normal and tangential fluid and boundary velocities, as required by [he no-slip boundary condition for viscous fluids.
[
Viscous Fluids [Ch_ 3
32
Pressure perturbations propagate with the speed of sound (infinitely fast in an incompressible fluid). Vorticity changes are far slower; this is a Fundamental reason why study of vorticity is so revealing. For further information, start with M. J. Lighthill's article in Rosenhead (1964 In particular, Lighthill discusses how the ideas of the previous paragraph cart be made the basis for a numerical calculation of the flow. VOR7rCITY IN TWO-DIMENSIONAL FLOWS
Great tangling of vortex lines with concomitant vortex stretching is a major feature of turbulence. But such matters are beyond our scope here, and we shall restrict ourselves in what follows to two-dimensional flows [wherein w = (u(x, y), r(x y), 0)]. For such flows the vorticity vector is ,
eu
' ( 0r 0, cu),
^
^u (7)
The stretching term vanishes, since dw
w Vv =
= Q.
(8)
i.I
Vorticity changes only from convection and diffusion, according to the following simplified version of (2): c7rxJ —
+ w • 17r13 — v P r,3.
(9)
at
Integration of (9) over an area
II
Or J 1
w
.
A
bounded by a curve C gives (Exercise 2)
A
-
,
J
u„{ + v
-
-
an
ds,
(l0)
C
where v„ is the component of w in the direction of the exterior normal n, and ira / n is the derivative oral in the direction of n. We see the roles of convection and diffusion again, for the net vorticity within A is increased by the net amount of w convected and diffused across the boundaries. As expected, the rate of diffusion is proportional, via the viscosity y, to the normal derivative of w. Let Us examine how these ideas can be used to interpret the exact solutions of Section 3.2. VOitT'ICITY IN PARTICULAR YISCOL:S FLOWS
From (12.3), the downstream velocity component u in flow between parallel plates a distance d apart is u=
(d 2 - y1 )
(- C = pressure gradient).
Ser. 3.51
VI)rrirrrl. Changes in I['r.uwus Mad Afert?o/rr
^
33
The vorticity
is of maximum magnitude at the walls y = ±d and decreases to zero at the center. Convection ducs not play a role here, as there is no variation along streamlines. There is continual upward flow of vorficity(into the fluid from the lower boundary, through the fluid, and out at the upper boundary) at the Constant rate —tiI!
_
(gyp-
r1Y
=C
.
(I2)
The pressure gradient forces fluid past the boundary 3' = —d, but the fluid must adhere at the wall, so a spin is imparted to the fluid layer adjacent to the wall. This spin sets fluid in the "nex!" Dyer spinning, and so on (vorticity diffuses). Exactly the same process proceeds from the boundary at y d hut the spin is in the opposite direction. At the center of the fluid. opposite spins meet and annihilate each other, giving risc to the absence of vorticity noted above. When thehorizontal plate ofSolution 3,Section 3?, is snatched into motion at speed U, there instantaneously develops a discontinuity in the horizontal velocity component u- Th e horizontal speed is U at the plane and zero just above it. At the initial instant, the vorticity cry can be regarded as infinite at this discontinuity and zero elsewhere. A plane of velocity discontinuities is called a vortex shot here the instantaneous start of the motion from rest creates a vortex sheet, and diffusion of vorticity from this sheet accounts for the entire supply of vorticity in the now thereafter. This picture is affirmed by the exact solution 12.I8. which yields ,
CO
all
Oy
=—
c
^
=
Lf(?rid)
= - }1i1 (4TCV 3 r 1 ) - 1 ''3 exp {
1 ' 2 c°xp(— re ),
— rp 3 J .
r >ü
t
>
[11 = ( 4 l,r) i fz • ^
03) (14)
Upon substituting y = ü into (14), we obtain zero. Thus there is no flux of vorticity through the boundary after the motion starts. But (13) shows that vorticity is relatively appreciable when and only when is of order of magnitude unity or less, that is, when y is no greater in order of magnitude than (wt) I ' 2 . The spieading of an effect across a distance of magnitude (a)U 2 in time r is characteristic of diffusion with diffusivity v. (Compare the end of Section 4.1 in L) Here we see, in addition, an overall decrease in intensity t 312 , as the fixed amount of vorticity is spread over an ever-widening like area
134
Ili semis f kids [Ch_ 3
Suppose that a second plate were parallel to the plate which instantaneously begins to move with speed U. Diffusion would rearrange the fixed amount of vorticity that is brought into being until ultimately the vorticity was evenly spread between the two plates. This is precisely what we see in Solution 1 of Section 3.2, the ultimate steady flow with constant vorticity throughout (see Exercise 3). As a final illustration of the explanatory power of the vorticity concept, consider boundary layer flow. Since downstream speed is of the order of the mainstream speed U S„ a parcel of fluid at downstream location x* will have spent a time of order of magnitude x*1I} o near the plate (which commences at x* = 0). In this time, vorticity will have diffused a distance of order of magnitude (vr) 1 ' 2 = (vx* f U o )" But the region of extensive vorticity is coincident with the boundary layer, so this physical argument gives a boundary layer thickness of order (%x*/[J 0 )' 12 , a result obtained mathematically in Section 3.4. In two dimensional flow past an obstacle, diffusion is responsible for lateral spread of the vorticity generated at the boundary while convection sweeps the vorticity downstream. Bee.ause organized bodily transfer of vorticity by convection is so much more efficient than random diffusive transfer, flow speeds do not have to be very large before vorticity will be confined to a thin boundary layer region near an obstacle. -
SUMMARY OF THE ROLE OF VOMTICITY
As we have seen, vorticity in the interior of an incompressible fluid of uniform density is changed by stretching, convection, and viscous diffusion. None of these mechanisms can create vorticity where it is initially absent_ We have examined how vorticity can be generated at a solid boundary in viscous flow. But no such possibility exists in the absence of viscosity. This leads to the first great fact about vorticity. For a flow that can he idealized as (a) inviscid, (h) of uniform density or having a pressure that depends only on density [sec Exercise 1(h)1, and (c) devoid of body force or having a conservative body force—for such flows, if motion starts from rest or otherwise can be ascertained to be free of vorticity at some time, then vorticity is always zero_ Mathematically, this means that V A r = O, This, in turn (given certain smoothness conditions), guarantees the existence of a function 0. such that r = V4_ Profound consequences result, of which we mention only Bernoulli's theorem (Exercise 15.1.7 of I) and the fact, exploited for example in Section 15.4 01 1, that is harmonic if the flow is incompressible. As for the generation of vorticity, we have examined one major method-the spin imparted by solid boundaries to a viscous fluid. To mention one more, the pressure term drops out of the vorticity equation because it has been assumed to have the form of a gradient and, therefore, to vanish when the curl operator is applied to it. More generally, a contribution from the
Sec. 3.6] Slow Viscous Hoot Past a Strut" Sphere
1
35
pressure term will remain in the vorticity equation, with concomitant thermodynamic generation of vorticity. An important example occurs in shock waves (e.g., aircraft sonic booms). There, discontinuities in thermodynamic variables across the shock are accompanied by a production of vorticity. Expertise in fluid mechanics requires a much deeper study of vorticity than is appropriate here. But we have introduced some of the key concepts that are required, and have given samples of the general principles and their particular implementation.
EXERCISES
1. (a) (b)
Derive (2). Begin by employing the identity found in Exercise 15.1.7 of I or in Theorem 23.7. Show that the text's assumption of constant density is not necessary and that (2) holds for a barotropic fluid subject to a conservative body force.
2. Derive (10). 3. Show that the net amount of vorticity per unit length is independent of time in the exact solution (2.18). Show that this same amount of vorticity is found in the first exact solution of Section 3.2. (This bears out remarks made a few paragraphs above. Note that the vorticity which is instantaneously generated when a plate is impuis ivel ystartcd is the same whet tier or not a second plate is present.) 4. Discuss the distribution of vorticity (a) in the solution of Exercise 2.1; (h) in the solution of Exercise 22 5. Establish a connection between the inviscid version of (9) and the differential equation of Exercise 15.1.4 of I. What is the viscous version of the latter equation?
3.6 Slow Viscous Flow Past a Small Sphere If a small sphere falls steadily in a viscous fluid, the me, all Reynolds number is small. The scientific importance of this one "slow-flow" problem is attested to by the fact that its solution has been used (i) as the basis for accurate determination of fluid viscosities, (ii) as an essential element in Millikan's oil-drop experiment for measuring the charge of the electron, and (iii) as a necessary part of the Einstein-Perrin method for precise determination of Avogadro's number. [Item (iii) is discussed at the end of Section 3.1 of I.] To mention just one application of more general small Reynolds number flows, such flows accompany the motion of flagellae and cilia, the tiny whiplike organs that propel microorganisms through fluid and that also propel fluid through channels in various creatures, including man.
r3 6
Viscoua Fluids [Ch. 3
We shall now outline the calculations that provide a first approximation to slow flow past a sphere. The original work can be found in a famous paper of Stokes published in 1851. Useful formulas for the divergence and curl in spherical coordinates are quoted in passing_ Exercises ask the reader to fill in many of the omitted details. FORMULATION
As we stated below (3.3), the Reynolds number estimates the ratio between (dimensional) convective acceleration terms like u duii?x and viscous terms like r i u2/13x2. When the Reynolds number is small. the convective acceleration terms should he negligible to a first approximation. (it is to be expected that nonlinear terms are negligible in a slow flow.) Theis the pressure-gradient terms should be of the same magnitude as the viscous terms. The dimensional equations governing uniform density low Reynolds number flow therefore are, to lowest approximation, V • v - 0,
V
A
ca — _ fit - 'VP
(La , b)
Here we have used the following relation between the vorticity ea and the
Laplacian of the velocity vector v (given in Theorem 2.3-6)_ V 2111 = V(V • v) — V A [u
[U = V A
,
-
In (1), p is the pressure and p is the viscosity coefficient. From (1 b) we obtain VA
(2)
(Vhw)= Q.
We use spherical coordinates (p. ch, 0), where
x=
p Sin
¢
COS
El,
y
=
p sin ch sin 0,
z = p COS ch.
Unit vectors a {`'', el', and point along the directions p, rp, and U increasing. The corresponding velocity components are t. l", 6}, and 06} . From references such as Rosenhead (1963, p. 133), we obtain the following general formulas, where subscripts denote partial derivatives: p = Pn e" + p i p, e + (p sin O)- pe e'.
V - v = p 1 (p 2 010 + (p sin 4i pV
A v -
(sin 0) - 1(061 sin + [(sin 0 1(of -
(3a)
' (LC'bi sin 0)0 + (p sin 0) - '(v'°')e,
(3b)
— (041) e aervi -
(pu
ro})r] e i E
[(pi's %
—
( »)^etet_
(4)
We take the origin at the center of the sphere and assume that far from the sphere, flow of speed U is directed along the positive z-axis. There should be no swirl, so aim LP) = O. Consequently, from the requirement V • x = O, using (3b), we deduce the presence of a stream function Jr(p, 0) such that t] tPi
(P2 sin /) 14/
v"' _ —(p stn 0)-1 fi r,.
(5)
See. 3.45] 51o11' YisCaus
NOW PUS' a
Snug} Splaerp
137
Only the third component of the vorticity will be nonzero, so the problem can be reduced to
1 2
+
—
P2
c
a a2 2 where c : cos 0,
{'c 2
(6)
plus suitable boundary conditions (Exercise 3) . SOLUTION
It is not difficult to verify that the appropriate solution for flow past a sphere of radius a is ^
2
^^ s'n^
^ - l) (l ^ ü
^[3
^
^,
(7)
^
From (lb), the pressure is therefore given by
(8 )
P = P«L — ip Gra ff 2 cos cfr-
In (8), ? is used to denote density. Remember, p ordinate in this sect lor'_
used for a spherical co-
In general orthogonal coordinates, formula (1.25),
T, 1 = -- {^ii + 2pD ;. remains true, provided that, for example, 7, 2 is now interpreted as the stress vector on the surface element with normal in the direction of the first coordinate vector, projected in the direction of the second coordinate vector. To compute the stress on the sphere, we need the following formulas for selected components of the rate ofdeformation tensor in spherical coordinates : Don _ 2(21'),,
{}^ — ({a sin Or ' (0 ), -4_ p(p
D,m = p(p- rrn n + p -1 (0 nl ) 4
(9)
Using these, alter some calculation one can obtain the final rather simple result that the drag force Fd is given by Fd = 6npLra.
(10)
If the sphere has density 6', then its predicted terminal speed of fall V through a fluid of density (5 in a gravitational field of acceleration g is (Exercise 6) V = a 1g
'(Zr — L5)_
(11)
We note that full understanding of the equations in spherical coordinates requires a tensor calculus which is not restricted to Cartesian coordinates_ This is beyond our scope here, so we have just quoted various needed results. Aris (1962), among others, presents derivations of the required formulas.
L
(Ch 3
vJSC{,us
^^
The low Reynolds number approximation obtained above (Stokes flow) looks considerably more straightforward than its high Reynolds number counterpart, but it should be mentioned that there are actually strong similarities between the two. When improvements are considered, it becomes apparent that the Stokes now is actually an "inner" approximation which matches the "outer" uniform flow. Further progress requires modification of the outer flow. For additional material on these matters, see Rosenhead (1963, Chap. IV).
EXERCISES
I. fa) For what physical reason does the density not appear in the governing equations ( 1)? (b) Verify (2). (c) Verify (8). (d) Deduce from ru (l) a differential equation that in vol ves o n l y the pressure. 2. Justify the introduction of the stream function, as in (5). 3. Derive (6), and provide suitable boundary conditions. 4. Verify that (7) is the appropriate solution to (6). 5. Carry out the somewhat lengthy calculations necessary to obtain (10). 6. Verify (i I )_
Appendix 3.1 Navier--Stokes Equations in Cylindrical Coordinates A study of general tensors, which is beyond the scope of this hook, makes routine the transformation of the Navier-Stokes equations into cylindrical coordinates [or any other coordinates; see Aris (1962)]. We shall only state the results. Thus the principal equations for a viscous fluid of uniform density p are as follows, where subscripts denote partial derivatives. (Body forces are neglected.) Conservation of mass: V - Y = r
1 (^L;^^ M ^ r +
r
-F ri' ` - f).
(l}
Balance of linear momentum: Di]I
Dr D LP' )
D1
►1
- r
^
[Z!
Ld}]^ = —P
+ r - ' ^{ " L1 1ak = —
J — 1 }r + 4'[V ^[r t! r ^
( pr)_
D
Dr
l
pe + 1,[p^L''e' -Jr 2r
= _ p - 1 p,
vV214,.
^ trj t!
— 2r
-2(01)0
2 (r' !
— r
j
^ )e^ +
(2)
2r'Le j ^.
(3)
(4)
.1ftp0lr.6 j?l
et?
r
biro. Li/rrrrrrrue+
AS? rltr.
Here it". 1 ,`rt`, and w are velocity components in the directions r. O. and increasing, i.e., along the unit coordinate vectors eI". et"r and et".
D Dr
V'
^
r'
►
—+at"'_
t'r e12 r
-
r'r
+ r
l 51
f 112 rr'a_; . + r r'r + r'`' r 1)-' + I r'
(6)
The relation between stress and rate of strain is still when p # fir.
1=
P +
(7]
In f7) p and if represent all possi ble combinations of r. q, and k, For example. Tt, is the stress component along e l "' on a surface element whose exterior normal points along 0". The components of the rate-of-strain or deformation tensor are given by 1Drr = (1 ," 1 )r , iDBlr = r I (tnrr 4 r Y". } =
Dv) = r lit' + It `I,, ^ w
-
,
=w
} _r =
1^1
The vurttcfty vector is given by ILO = ❑ AV
t1 .101ld irF +
[ ( O rFf_
e [r tti4'u + r -I [rr [1^ , - (0' 1 0
wr l e
rü^
l`)
Note that the major vector operators have been expressed in polar coordinates: div in (I ), curl in (9), and grad in the first terms on the right of (2k (3), and (4} (the components of p ' Vp).
Appendix 3.2 Generation of Confidence in the Boundary
Layer Equations by Construction of a Finite Difference Scheme for Their Solution Part of the subject of partial differential equations deals with the question of what initial and boundary conditions are appropriate in various situations. It is usually a major task to show that a problem is well posed. i.e., that there is precisely one solution and that small chances in the problem cause small changes in the solution. Here we illustrate on the boundary layer equations a relatively simple way to generate confidence that a mathematical problem makes sense. The idea is to see whether one can establish a finite difference procedure which in principle coutd he used to determine an approximate solution to the problem, and which requires exactly the given boundary and initial conditions. This procedure has independent value as the possible basis of a numerical solution.
Viscous Fluids IClt. 3
: 4n
In contemplating a numerical analysis of the problem (117-20), we first observe that the semi-infinite interval in y trust be replaced by (0, y, ), where y h. is large enough so that no significant variation in the solution occurs. We then limit our calculations to a grid of points, as in Figure 3.18, where u and v. are prescribed as shown. For simplicity in exposition we consider both the horizontal and vertical distances between adjacent points to be the same constant h, but this requirement can easily be dropped.
—
w
e e t
t
ü —r
rp
o a o o o o
O^
R+
D
a D
o o
D
�
O 0 û U
Q
d
�
O
ü
V
O
o
o
d
40 D Q
a
O
C.
# • • •
i
•
O d
O O
• •
•
u - r=4 FIGURE 3. lb. Velocity CoxNporrenls u and r are ta be dererrn inert at the unshaded
grid points. Only u is known at the fruif-shaded points.
We wish to replace derivatives by difference quotients in such a way that we can determine u and a at the various grid po i nts. We shall use the notation r O) " f,. u(th,ih) = ll i , Cf(iit, O) ^Ux(Jh, (1) One possible way of proceeding uses (3.I7b) and the equation obtained by substituting (3.17b) into (3.17a)_ The. a equations are u ; + r+ = Q,
—
rt, , r + r' , = L F i
"
+ 11 .y .
(2a, b)
The first step is to use (2b) to compute :r along x = O. In doing so, we make the approximations vy(i{i, jh) = h -1 (v+! — Jh) —
h -! (sdt .1
(3)
—
fi i (t++,1+! -
1- s.),
— 214
1.j +
141,j- L }.
Upon evaluating (2a) at (x, y) = (ih, jet), using these approximations, and then solving for v,, f , we find that (u1,1
- ^C i j^1 j-1 .
.
— if — h ^(n1 .1 -^ `^ 21414 + ui.i-1)]
(4)
Appe'ndi_v 3.2] t,errrrurrl,+r uj Cilrr/rrierue in doe-
Bind! trklxl'
Le1te'r hyler^frrul ►
141
z r^
F Iii u ti r_ 3.19. firjurrrrrrrrrrar used w obtain a Mk' IYrlree u j r-. Thur sire required twines of u and r• I1re k 1lenrrr at er pone $3 i►rdie used ht' sltudins{ doe Hi r1rra1 rr,ylf halves. resfu'ru!-rh', 4.0 rhe r•Urreivrrefirrrl circle
Ism Figure 3.19). Specializing to i = 0. j = I, we see that t' ;,., is determined by an expression involving the known quantities $1 0 0 , ]f ,+ 8,+0 . 2 (Is is given along x = 0),A, and t' #, p (1 is zero when t --= Ûj_ Repeated use of (4) gives t) all the way along the initial line, up to but not including r e .N . (Note that c , is used in determining t'n.! _ 1 .) r1 The next step is to determine u alongx II. This we do by replacing 12a) by — r1; ) ♦ -11} = 0. h` l { i — ^' i.1
which yields trr^ 1.1 = Ir i.}
i' e
-^
+ r ";
-1
15)
Figure 3.20). Specializing to i — 0, j = I we observe that r1 r , is determined in terms du o. , (given), D o. , just computed). and re.. = 0. Repeated use of (5) allows computation of u along x h up to and including uI N, Since ti t. r , is given, rr is known on all grid points of _v' — h. The use of (5) with i = 0, j = N provides the missing value of r>, r a• N- By repeating the entire calculational process, we can successively determine vertical lines or ti's and 1.1 's. AU the given information has been exploited, and no more seems necessary, so added confidence is derived in the appropriateness of our boundary conditions. In particular, we see that additional prescription of ()along y = hi or x = 0 would be inappropriate, for r at these locations can be computed from the data given. The scheme we have outlined is the general type that is suited for use with an electronic computer. Untouched, and beyond our scope, is the question of convergence as h . [3 of the exact solution of the difference scheme to the actual solution of the differential equations_ Similarly left to other sources is determination of the accuracy of the approximate solution to the difference scheme computed by the machine at fixed h and with inevitable roundoff error. (see
—
Viscous Fluids [Ch 3
42
u
=
?
_
^+
ftu"L'Q E 124. lirformatriu ►t used f[a obtain a new value of it. known information. us ïrr Figure J. I9_
rxldrCYifr's
SJladiary
Of course, other difference schemes can be constructed. For example, one could use (3.17a) rather than (2a) to march rightward in the computation of u. Selection of the scheme that is best in some sense is another question which has to be left to a study of numerical analysis. See, for example, R. Richtmyer and K_ Morton's Difference Meih +ds for Initial Value Problems (New York: Inter'science, 1967) for valuable discussions of the type of proh!erns we have mentioned, We must noie the possibility of a "scheme" that does not require the value of u nn y = O. This seems to cr]ntradrel our statement that ai! given data are necessary. The scheme proceeds as before except that (5) is replaced by h - 1 (u,i l
li .!
J l + ÎI
1 fU
^ 1 — U ..) ]
—
t}
or
By taking = O,) = 0, L 2,_..,u can be computed onx = h star bug with y — 0, without knowledge of u(ii, O) = u I O . But u 1.s _, cannot be computed by this scheme, nor can uz,_ 2 and u 3 _ i when it is repeated, and so on. The whole process of finding evidence that our problem is appropriately forrnulatcd rests on the demonstration that u and tt al each grid point iS uniquely determined. If one or more of the unknowns is arbitrary, the scheme is inadmissible. Now it might be thought that u l - i can be computed from yy I.", I J uo.iv-11 ♦ 12- VD. k -1 - VO.'h'-21 =
h
}
but in using (6) we are indefensibly employing the same expression for t^ , at (0, N -- 2) and at (Q, N — 1), In the limit N —. co, h -6 Q, Nh • } , this means that ra},fO, 1 O, which is generally faise ,
.
Appendix
Generation of Canfid[rrCN in rhi'
BoülrifClfi' 1.-L11 -*V' {:i
M ürNN.'S
1 43
Use ofa finite difference scheme to verify the appropriateness of boundary conditions is not an approach that is free of problems. The total number of unknowns at the various grid points is always far exceeded by the number of equations that could be regarded as approximations to the given set of differential equations. One wishes to devise a set of difference equations that give a unique set of values for all these unknowns, These equations should reduce to the original differential equations in the limit 11 • 0, and no further relationships among the variables should result. Any '*sensible" explicit difference scheme satisfies these requirements, provided that and r grid distances are appropriately related. To prove that a solution to the original problem exists, it remains to show that the sn to the difference equation approaches a limit, and that this limit is a solution to the original differential equations. This may not he so, and proofs in any case are not easy,s But experience teaches that sensible formal procedures are justifiable more often than not"; this is why the ability to construct a sensible difference scheme gives confidence that a solution exists to the original problem_ In the present context there arc serious extra difficulties because of the necessity of passing from the finite domain treated in a difference calculation to the infinite domain specified in the original problem. Indeed, questions of existence and uniqueness for boundary layer problems are definitely not trivial, as is illustrated, for example, in the discussion of classes of similar solutions in Rosenhead (1963, Chap. V, Sec. 21). In some cases, for example, uniqueness is only obtained if decay as r — x is required to be as fast as possible. It is hard to see how the necessity of such extra conditions can be anticipated by the present approach_ But the very difficulty of a rigorous treatment increases the value of a heuristic approach, provided that the limitations of heurism are not forgotten.
* We have pointed nut that the process is not without difficulty, nonetheless, formulating appropriate difference equations and Mien passing to the limit proi.idcsanelIcctiveway to obtain existence and other theorems for partial differential equations. For the wave, heat, and Laplace equations, a classical reference is the paper al- Courant, Friedrichs. and Lewy tired ore p. 12t of 1 [IBM J. i 1. 125 (1967)]. Major works concerned with the existence of solutions to the boundary layer equations (3.I7-20) have employed the method of tines wherein difFerencing with respect to one variable transforms the original prnhlem unto a system of ordinary differential er;4ations_ Q_ A. 01einik [Sager Math. 4, 583 (19631] uses the rrari.sverse line rnethod in which the "limclike" x variable is discrttized_ W. Walter [Arch. Rarional Mech. Areal. 39, 169 (1970)] proves an cxislcnce theorem by means of distretixing the other, spacelike, variable after making a preliminary transformation (see Exercise 3.41
CHAPTER
4
F ound a tions of Ela sticity
I
chapter we shall lay the foundations of the classical threedimensional theory of elasticity. We shall restrict ourselves to the assumption of very small deformations and use as our stress-strain or constitutive relation the mathematical representation of an isotropic, homogeneous, linearly elastic solid. Simple exact solutions will be shown to provide relations between the various coefficients that appear in our linearity assumptions. Considerations of energy and virtual work will provide uniqueness theorems. The chapter concludes with a brief introduction to solid mechanics when the assumption of very small deformations is dropped. It should be noted that the derivation of the equations governing linear elastic solids bears strong similarities with the corresponding derivation (in Section 3. I ) of the Navier Stokes equations for a viscous fluid. N THIS
4.1 Analysis of Local Motion The ftcld equations that apply to all continuous media must be supplemented by constitutive equations that describe the particular nature of a given material_ This section contains a prerequisite to the postulation of constitutive equations in solid mechanics, a local mathematical description of material deformation. "Compatibility equations" are also discussed. Cartesian tensors are used throughout. STRAIN TENSOR IN MATFttIAt. COORDINATES
Consider a particle located at the initial time t o at Po , a point with the coordinates A. The medium, of which this is a generic particle, is deformed. At time t, the particle is located at P, which has the coordinates x(A, 1). The continuous medium is said to be strained when the relative position of two particles is altered. We shall now develop a quantitative measure of such a
strain. We introduce the displacement vector U defined by U=x—A
or U ; =x ; — A.
(la)
With explicit indication of dependent variables. (la) is written L',(A , t) = x{A, s) — A ; .
(lb)
Here we are referring the variables to material coordinates and thus are using the material or I,sgrangian description. 144
See. 4 !]
A nr11f•sis of
Lora! Moti o n
Let us write (lb) in the
1 45
forrni + i^^(A , ti•
x,{A. EP =
(2)
[In words, (2) states that the position x ; of the particle that was initially at A is now (at time t) equal to its initial position plus its displacement from that position.] Let us compute the derivative of x,(A, r) a+ii h respect to A. Using index notation_ we find that
xi.i _ o3i
(3)
Ut.j•
where the argument (A, r) is understood in x,., and L'
. Equation (31 will prove useful in a moment. At time t — 0 consider a vector dA whose initial and terminal coordinates are A, and A; + dA,, respectively. (For the present, regard dA 1 dA 2 , and dA 3 as arbitrary numbers.) If dA is embedded in deforming material, at time t its end points occupy the positions x(A, I) and MA + dA, r) (see F rgure 4 I) ,
,
We can write
x,-(A # dA, 9l — Y,(A. t) = x,, 4(A, t) dA ; + - - • ,
(4)
where - - indicates further terms in a Taylor expansion and the summation convention is used (as it will be throughout our discussion of elasticity). The smaller I dA I is, the closer to zero is the contribution made by these additional terms (assuming that x i. j is continuous in a neighborhood of A). A convenient way of stating this fact is to say that if dA is infinitesimal, and if dx(A. dA, r) is defined by dx ; =x i(A+d A, t)— xpA, t),
(SI
then we have
(6)
dA,_
The ellipses (• • -1 are absent from 16) because (6) is "exact" when dA is infinitesimal.
xrA*dA tl
1 1
f.0
1 ^+iA n
1
^I
t / dA
A
F to u RE 4.1. Defarmarra.3 dx
Jrne
^^f; tA + dA. ti
^
1
f
//
A + dA
changes rhe t nfi nftesrma l l i ne Element dA emu t1 new elmnt
Foundations of E%ISlteit} (Ch. 4
1 46
If we combine (6) and (3), w e obtain dx ;
_ [64 + UJA, r )] dA ;
Or
dx ; = del ; + f.+ i.i(A, t) dA ) .
(7)
Equation (7) has an important geometric interpretation. A straight line is generally deformed into a curve_ By contrast, (7) implies that an infinitesimal straight line (or Fine dement) is deformed into another infinitesimal straight line (Exercise l). Consider two line elements ds„ and ds4 through the point P 0 . After deformation, these become the line elements do and ds' passing through the point P- In component farm, the various line elements may be written as
dsa = dA ; et^M ds = dx ; e" I ,
dtir,
ds' = d)610 1 .
Here el is, as usual, a unit vector pointing out along the x ;-axis. The length of the line element ds will be denoted by ds and a corresponding notation will be used for the other line elements. We are now ready to introduce a measure of local deformation. It is not obvious how this measure should be chosen; indeed, more than one choice can be made-Trialand error indicate that one appropriate measure is the change in the scalar product ds„ • ds4 due to deformation. Thus we consider ds • ds' — ds„ - dsQ = ds ds' cos 0 — ds„ ds' o cos 0 c ,
(8)
where the angles are shown in Figure 4.2. Employing (3), we may write this difference in scalar products as dx ; dx; --
dA, dA; = (hi, + 1r1 }(o,k + U4 . 0 dA, dAx — dA 4 LC, = dA i dA: + (1i ,, + l`l j , k + U,,,Ui.x) dA } tfA k — dA i dA t (9) (U'k,i + I;F J k + [1;. }Ui, k j dA) dAi. ,
1
We designate the quantity in parentheses as twice the material [or Langian] strain tensor,* which we denote by 2 thi . Thus F
k1 = ^ k ^
j. k +
Ui.
(1U)
4 k-
Note that the strain tensor is symmetric: rl = difference in scalar products can now be written as ,
k
ds • ds' — ds o • ds#, = 2;4 1 dA ' The word "tcosur" is appropriate since ^ is Farmed by addition tives of a vector.
(11.) and contraction
ofideriva-
sec _ ¢_11 Analysis of Loc•ai Motion
1 47
A,
5
dst,
« A2 fil)
A1
FI C;URE 4.2. r]c}{rrrrrrarirsn changes the
angle between two line dements from
Igo ro A. Frequently, the strain is so small that I fi r J ! 4 1. In such cases it is natural to replace the strain tensor by its first nrder approximation, writing rhh i — (j +
;ark
(12)
When the strain tensor is given by the linear relation ( 12), we shall speak ref
infinitesimal strain . GEOMETRICAL. INTERPRETATION OF STRAIN COMPONF:NISti
now show huw changes in ienjths, angles, and volumes can bu described in terms of the components rh) . We consider first the special case when the two line elements ds o and ds4, coincide and lie along e": d , = dA; =ds o ,dA 2= d4 =dA 3 — dA — 0. In this case dx ; =dx; and [from We
(11)]
rfs 2 --- dsô = 21 1 , dsb.
(13)
Let us define p 1 by the relation dw = dsa( l 4 - m i )
-
(14)
Thus
1.11 =
ds — ds" ds n
(15)
in other words, p is the change in length per unit original Length parallel to the A s -axis. Substituting (14) into (13), we find 2a
1
= 2 fc, +
(16)
i48
Foundations of Fla_sririty ICh. 4
The solutions of this quadratic equation in j1 are Iii =
±11
+ 2/11) 112 — 1 -
Only the plus sign yields a meaningful root, since p 1 must vanish whenever 11 = O. Thus ra (17) p, — (1 + 2 7i 1 )' — 1 and (18) ds =, ds o(l + 2 ) `/2 1, and (17) implies that
For infinitesimal straits, I m i l
p 1 = 1 + 3.(27 11 ) + 0( 71i1) — 1
Thus ii +,
or
t7t
^
^
Nt•
(L9)
12 2 , and +Iaa represent the change in length per unit original length
el), e'2 t, and em, respectively_ Let us consider a second example. Here we examine the deformation of line elements which are initially orthogonal, so that
parallel to
dA t ds d , d4 2 —dA 3 = 0,
dAï=dif 3 - 0,
dA; — dso.
From (8) and (11) we find that ds ds' cos i} = 21 1 r ds L dso _ ,
(20)
Let y 2 = n — O. Thus y . 2 represents the decrement in the right angle that was orig i nally formed by elements in the directions of c' and ec2. We have ,
cos $= cos (-n — y t2 ) i sin y i 2, ds = ds (,(1 4 2ri l I )" and ds` ds'a(1 + 211 22 ) 1 ' 2 so that, from (20),
sin Yi
2/ 12 _ (1 + 410 1/2 (1 + 2g22)" 2.
(21)
For infinitesimal strains, (21) reduces to Y12
2 1 12
(22)
'
when i # j, rl rt represents one-half the decrement in the right angle that was originally formed by elements parallel to &' 1 and e1r1. A further interesting interpretation is found by considering the Jacobian which represents the ratio of a volume element after deformation to a 1, volume element before deformation (see Section 13.4 of I). The Jacobian is given by
Thus we see that
fur infinitesimal strains
=
Nx1, x#* xA
00 ] , #1.# r A3)
_ det
r At ♦ (id aAj
see ¢- f( Analysis
Loral MraliUrl
1 49
Expanding this determinant for the case of infiniteNtrrtaII 3t rains, we find (Exercise 3) that
J^ 1irhi .
(23)
In this ease, then, the trace 1.5f r),,, namely q„. represents the change in iwrlunie
after delimiiution, per unit original whittle. At this point it is worthwhile looking hack at what we have done in this section, in older to emphasize that there are two independent levels of approximation involved in arriving at the infinitesimal strain tensor (l2). Using the word loosely, "strain - at point 1' may be characterized by examining the deformation of various lines that pass through P. As is customary, we confined our attention to the fate of such lines in the limit as t h eir length approaches Zero. It can be said that in characterizing deformation we only examined tenpoints that are "nearest neighbors" of P. This restricted the precision or our characterization but was clearly the appropriate first step_ Having decided to limit our attention to the deformation of anfinitcstmal straight lines, we derived an expression (9) that can he used to provide information such as the increase in length of such lines, the change in angle between a pair of them, eic. Equation 19) provides this information even in cases n f the most extensive distortion. For a large class of important problems, however, we can limit ourselves to very small distortions. It is this rel,rlively simple but very useful linear theory. wherein )10) is simplified to (14 that concerns us almost exclusively in this volume. Rut Section 43 gives a taste of the theory when the strain is chararterifed by arbitrary distortions of infinitesimal line elements, STRAIT TENSOR IN SPATIAl. ; OORI}INA"iES
An argument entirely similar to that just used can be applied to develop a measure of strain in spatial coordinates For this purpose, we write - A,(1i, 1l Note the following connections between velocities r and V and displacements u and 11 in spatial and material coordinates. respectively: V-
six s1!
_
r''1A + U)
-
r'!
r' ll
Du
ci
Dr
We can develop the spatial (or F ulerianl strain tensor, c l ((x, [j, defined by t:r! —2(4r. i
-I
( 25 )
where. ; = i1j0x,. The individual compiments can he studied through examples similar to those used in the previous section (Exercise 4) For small strains. WC find that E..1 ` 1(14r. r -
I
ii ) , ,).
I
(2
i)
Foundations of EÏustirity
J5
[Ch. 4
For t — j, tt is the change in length per unit length in the deformed state parallel to the x ;-axis. For i j i: o is one-half the decrement in the angle between two directions that end up in the deformed state parallel to c'i and est, respectively. Comparing (12) and (26), we see that for infinitesimal strains the two strain tensors have the same form except that a material description is used in the former case and the differentiation is with respect to the material variables - while a spatial description is used in the latter case, and the differentiation is carried out with respect to the spatial variables. It should be noted that the difference between differentiating with respect to spatial variables rather than material variables is of second order. To be explicit, ira vertical line denotes a substitution 01- material variables for spatial, we have, by the chain rule, that
_
BfJ k _ k ex,,, Ûut C^(A,,, OA p = ax. 8A p cx^ DA ^U
&k
x ,n
^ Frrz
4-
^^^
t^F 16U„,
ôxp
ax,„
a
(27)
p
Neglecting second order terms, we find that t) _ ô14(x, i)
cOA ,
exp
- A. ffi
(2R)
and also
duk(x, [) Oxp
,au ,,(A, 1) P
(29) Mk.
o
Thus the difference between the two derivatives can be neglected when we are dealing with infinitesimal strains In this and the next three sections w e shall restrict ourselves to infinitesimal strains. In many classical texts, the infinitesimal strain tensor is denoted by t o , although each component is interpreted as if one were considering the material strain tensor_ Also, no distinction is made between :d ; and U 1 . Although this is not strictly consistent with the notation used up to now, we shall continue the practice of failing to make a sharp distinction between material and spatial coordinates in the remainder of the chapter except for the Final section (4.5) on nonlinear elasticity. THE ROTATION TENSOR
We shall now employ the strain tensor to show that an infinitesimal piece of material, alter deformation, is translated and rotated (a rigid motion) and also elongated along three mutually perpendicular axes. We begin by noting that (30) d u ; = u r {A + dA) - N ; (A) = ui . f(A) dAi.
Sec. 4. ! l
Analysis Of Laced MorioR
151
Thus points near A are displaced a common amount 1i ; (A) and arc subject to a dA i . According to Theorem 2. I.10, Ili 1 can further alteration given by u1. or be written as the sum a symmetric tensor and an antisymmetric tensor,
namely, (31)
coo ,
where €ii = ^( 1^c + cir1. i ) and wu =
l.j
.^
— ^i)
[32a, b]
The antisyrnmetric tensor w 1f is known as the rotation tensor. As has been shown at the end of Section 2.1, we may associate with such an antisymmetric tensor the rotadon vector fit , where [analogously to the fluid mechanical case in (3.1 .8)]
flk
""
ifL' n u)k •
ij (2) if
(33a)
As in (2.1.44), Cmr.i[ 1-2k
— WmA •
(33b)
Now [using (7)], dx ; — dA, _c = dA f +w dA i ,
and [using (33b)], we obtain co if dA i = Efl f2k dA = [dA Iti III.
Thus cow dA i is a small rotation through the angle I5li, about an axis parallel to Sk through the tail of dA. 1f eti 0, then the whole deformation reduces to a small rigid body translation and rotation.* We note that the components of the strain tensor c ;; for i = j arc known as the normal strains and the components for i # j are known as the shearing strains_ We have shown that normal strains represent elongations [see (19)] and shearing strains represent angle changes [see (22), and remember the equivalence of e ii and 11 i; in the case of infinitesimal strain], PRINCIPAL AXES OF STRAIN
Since the strain tensor €, 1 is symmetric, it has three mutually orthogonal characteristic vectors which are known as the principal axes of strain. The characteristic values are called the principal strains and are frequently denoted by, , c 2 , and r, . When referred to principal axes, the strain tensor takes the form t 1f
=
Ei
❑
❑
et
0
❑
❑
0.
• This result can also be shown cilrecLly (Exercise 5) ,,
t5z
Foundations of Elasticity
ICI?. 4
It follows that eki dA j corresponds to a stretching, by a percentage equal to the principal strains, along the principal axes of strain. If we take as our system of axes the principal axes of strain, a rectangular parallelepiped with edges d r , dA 2, and fill deforms into the parallelepiped shown in Figure 4.3. It is seen from Figure 4.3 that the change in volume is given by (1 + E 1 )(1 4 €2)(I + € 3 )
dA r dA 2 dA 3 — dA, dA 2 dA 3 .
Recalling that we have confined ourselves to small strains, we find that the change in volume is given by
(c, + t: 2 + E 3 ) dA, dA
Cl/13-
Asis Section 13.4 of 1, the dilatation A is defined as the change in volume per unit original volume We see from the above equation that -
(34a)
d=e: l +f: } + E,.
We note that this expression is the first invariant of the strain tensor evaluated in a coordinate system that coincides with the principal axes. Thus we can conclude that A = e.;; _
(34b)
This result coincides with the analysis of the Jacobian found above_ It can be shown (see Exercise 11.1-20) that the planes on which the maximum shearing strain will occur arc those planes that cut the principal planes (i.e., the planes normal to the principal axes) at 45°. The maximum shear strain will be the maximum of the three quantities Itl — t:1 , ^
E{
I
2 1t- 2
— 1.
3,
(35)
EF3 — ErI-
drt x
FIGURE 4.3. Deformation changes one infinitesimal rectartyulur
parallel-
epiped to another, provided that the original parallelepiped is oriented along the principal axes of straw. (For clarity of presentation, the defèrrtuitxur pictured is much larger than it should he
SET_ 41] Analysis of Loral Milian
1
53
COMPATIBILITY EQUATIONS Suppose that we are given the nine components of the strain tensor, t:,3(x, z), co . Can we guarantee that there will be a displacement vector, u,(x. i), that will satisfy the following equation? =
'PP i l ,
+
(36)
j, i)'
That is, are there three (single-valued) displacement functions u i , u z , and u that satisfy the six distinct equations provided by (36) when c, j is a given symmetric tensor? As we shall see, sometimes one can determine an expression for the strains in a given situation, but the integrability question we have posed must be answered before one is assured that this expression is appropriate. To be more precise, some problems in elasticity are naturally posed entirely in terms of the stresses: The stresses are given on the boundary of an object and are to be determined in its interior. We shall see that once the stresses are known, it is a simple matter to determine the strains. Knowing the strains, can one now find the displacements? (This question does not arise in fluid mechanics, for it is of virtually no interest to consider situations where stress is prescribed on the boundary of a fluid region) The integrability problem can be restated more conveniently in the following equivalent form. Given a strain tensor ar ; and an antisyrnmetric rotation tensor 0.) ;i , under what circumstances can we guarantee that there is a displacement vector u, satisfying the following equation? (37)
u.^ — e,) + cu .
The two forms (36) and (37) are equivalent because the heart of the matter is to relate deformation and displacement ; any required solid body rotation can easily be added. (A formal proof is requested in Exercise 12.) ' Because the problem has been changed from (36) to (37). we can regard it (for fixed i) as a question to which we can apply Theorem 2.3_10. This states that if a continuously differentiable vector field B; = Box} is defined over a simply connected region in space, then there is a single-valued function 4 _ ¢(x) such that
B;0,,
081
if and only if 41-, Bi.
(39)
0_
For our particular problem, we are seeking three functions such that ea,. = + a. As stated in (33h), we may write
[I,, 142,
and u
w J = ZIA i 4 .
We observe (Exercise 6) that nk, k — 1
(1)r1.
_ 0.
(0}
Found/J tiorls nf EIra.slrri 1• tC"h_ 4
154
We can thus formulate our problem once more as follows: Given the symmetric tensor E; and the vector 11. 1, with 1-4 .1, O, find necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of a vector u ; such that + c;ik il_*
(41)
We may nnw apply our integrability theorem to each component of given in (41). Consequently, necessary and sufficient conditions are esri(Et!
+
€ig, n ).,, =
as
0.
Using the "ed" rule of Theorem 1.2.11,
( 15s145ph — skiFif' k P SI.1
si
+
r25 ^.
The integrabilility condition now reduces to —
t
sr^
c si. p
(42)
We seek a condition that is expressed solely in terms of the c o . Because of the introduction of II, this is easily accomplished by another application of the integrability theorem, this time to (42). The necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of a displacement vector become Qrs = Û
where
Qrs
(43)
rini Espj E ll. -
The integrability conditions (43) are known as compatibility conditions, since they are the requirements that a given strain tensor be compatible with a sing Ze-valued displacement vector_ Since Q,# = s, [Exercise 7(a)], there are six independent equations. These can be taken to be the following [Exercise 7(b) or Exercise 14(a)] : ,
1.23 = ( - 23.1 + £31.2 + 6 12.3),1, 122.31 = ( — '6 31.2 + £12.3 + E23, X1
4 33,12 = ( -0 12.3
12, 12
+ E23+l
+'6 31.2).3*
(44)
1 11.22 + 1122, i I*
2E23, 23 = 6. 22.33 + C 33.223
2 &31.31
F33. t 1 + 6 11.33'
A multiply connected region M can be made simply connected as required by the integrability theorem by making appropriate cuts. if displacements are to be single-valued in Ai, they must certainly have this property in the cut region. Thus the conditions of (44j are still necessary, even in multiply • It is conventional lu use similar notation for the alternator symbol p, fl. Tbc dangcr of confusion should no be great_ c1, __ L i
E iji,
and the strain
Sir_
4_ Ij
Anufi'ses
Lut
at Morion
155
connected regions. in addition, one must require that the same displacements result at every point on each cut, no matter how these points are approached. (The additional condition has to be verified only on any nne set of cuts that makes M simply connected.) SOME EXAMPLES OF STRAIN
order to illustrate in concrete terms some of the general ideas just discussed, we present three elementary worked examples_ In each case the reader should be sure that he agrees with the given information; (a)a description or the strain, (b) the principal axes of strain and the principal strains, (c) the dilatation, and (d) the maximum shearing stress. In
Example 1. Consider uniform dilatation in which the sirain tensor is given by
Solution. in the particular coordinate system chosen, the strain tensor represents a change in length per unit length of the amount a in each of the x,-dire Lions_ The s hear strains vanish in this coordinate system_ On the other hand, we note that the tensor is isotropic; hence the strain tensor will be the same for every coordinate system_ The principal strains are e; every coordinate system is a set of principal axes; and the maximum shearing strain is zero. The cubic dilation is given by =t = 3e.
or a=
Example 2. Consider simple extension given by the strain tensor e, = e,
i = j = I.
t;r = 0 forail other i and j .
S lulion. In this state cf strai n, the material undergoes a change nie per unit length in the x i -direction only. Since the tensor is already in diagonal form, the given sel. or coordinates form a system of principal axes and the principal strates arc e. 0, and O. The dilatation equals e_ The maximum shearlrtg strain is le and planes of maximum shearing strain are shown in Figure 4.4. x
rr
^
XI (j}
(bl
F! c: u R E 4.4. Planes of maximum sfrenrinrg .srrain in sim ple exrensrnn along r!u' x, -{ixis_
156
Fouxulrarir3rl.s of Elastic- iry [Ch_ 4
Example 3. Consider simple shear in which the sale deformation is a change in the angle between the x,- and x,-directions of 2s. The strain tensor For this case is U
=
s
0
s ü C:). 0 0
(4s) []
The before and after pictures are shown in Figure 4.5, for a section that was a unit square before deformation_ The reader shuuld use this figure to check his results. N o r E. Rotation is not specified, since is not given. ln Figure 4_5(b), sufficient rotation is assumed to align the bottom of ltie figure with its position prior to deformation_ x,
= x,
!h! F tci u K r 4.5 Srrrrin
sfef'r1r. (a ) Be frrre deformation. ( h) After difor-
rrrfrrian
Solution. It can be shc'vn [Exercise 9(a)] that the principal axes of strain are the x 3 -axis and two mutually perpendicular vectors that make angles of 45 0 to the x ! - and x2 -axes. The principal strains are s, - s, and O. Figut 4.5 enables us to confirm these facts frorri the geometry_ It is apparent that the diagonals l'o and undergo the greatest changes in length. 1 fence they must lie along the principal axes of strain, which we thus sec make angles of 45° to the x,- and x 2 -coordinates. The principal strains can be computed from the geometry of the deformed parallelepiped_ We note that t = Io = - According to the law of cosines, the diagonal C is given by 2 ['
= [ I - 1 -- 2 cos (inn — 2s)]" 2 = (2 — 2 sin 2s)' ` 2 — 44112 23130
where advantage has been taken of the s mall strains to linearize the equations. Thus one principal strain is given by
^ ^n = -s. —
lU
Similarly,
I" = [I + 1 — 2 cos (in + 2s)]+r2 = 2 i + 2 0. -I- sj_ Consequently, the other principal strain is
r fu
set-. 4.11 Arscrlj•,ws fit Local Motion
157
The orientation assumed in drawing Figure 4.51bj is assured if u 2 (0, t), 1 ) = u3(0, t7, 1 ) = 0.
ia ;(ü, D, oj = 0,
(46)
Under these assumptions one can show [Exercise 9(b)] that thedisplacerrrents are given by H 1 - 2sx2,
11 = ar = O.
(47)
,
W e conclude with a mention of'the important case of plane strain_ Here the displacement vector is given by
u # - u Q(x t , x 2 ),
or ,
u s - 0,
-
I, 2.
The strain tensor is given by Evd
=
t: o {x
i: e3 = 0,
i
,, X 2 } — 2(u
3.^
a,
+ z^ ,) ^
— l, 2;
1,2,3. EXERCISES
1. Strictly speaking, (7) deals only with the end points of the vector dA. Show that our discussion implies that all points on dA are "deformed'" into a new straight line. 2. Use the quotient rule to show that the Lagrangian strain tensor is indeed a tensor_ 3. Verify (23), and deduce the text's interpretation of the trace of the strain tensor, for small strains_ 4. Carry out the development of the Fuleriari strain tensor, including the interpretation of the components for both general strains and infinitesimal strains. 5. If u; + tr ; - D for all i and j, show by direct integration that the deformation can only be a small rigid rotation plus a rigid body translation. (This exercise is very similar to Exercise 11.}.) 6. Verify (40). 7. (a) Show that (43) implies that Q,. Qom' (h) Show that (44) follows from (43). 8. Sketch the following displacement fields. Calculate the extensions, shears, dilatation, and rotation. (a)
u,
(h) ex 1 , ii i = u 3 Here e is a constant.
D-
9. (a) Find, by algebraic calculation, the principal axes of strain and the principal strains for simple shear_ (b)Demonstrate that Figure 4.5(b) is correctly drawn. 10. A cylindrical bar (not necessarily circular) with generators parallel to the x 3 axis undergoes the displacement -
u1
- Ox2x31 I4 = OXIx3
,
4i 3 =
xi x2), ,
ftxurda rior,s of nawiriry [C h . 4
l 5b
where H is a small angle. Clive a geometric description of the displacement. Find the strain tensor, the principal strains, and maximum shear strains. 1 L Let w = w(x 1* x 3 )and let Greek subscripts range over the values 1 and 2. The displacement vector is given by IJa =
UV a
• ü3 = w } -- — -
,
2(1 — 2v)
X 3 w a^ ti
where v is constant. Find the strain tensor. Evaluate T33
+v C33 ]
^1'
1—
^ik
1 2_ (a) Show that if u satisfies (37), then it satisfies (36). f.(b) Show that if a function u can be found that satisfies (36), then one can always find a (perhaps different) function u that satisfies (37) as well. 113. The compatibility conditions (43) represent six conditions on the six different components of the symmetric strain tensor. There is thus only a single tensor that can satisfy these conditions." Discuss. 14. (a) With the aid of (1.2.11), show that the compatibility conditions (43) can be written
Q rs
—
O.
, = tes.iii
— rr,.,I =
0.
(48)
$(b) Show that (43) is identically satisfied if €; = ^; + 14i.; for a smooth function n_ Why is this result not surprising? 15. Let V be a simply connected region with boundary V. Consider the incompatibility tensor Q defined in (43)_ (a) Show that Q„ . ,= O. $(b) Suppose that Qr,4 0in V r#s; ,
121
r =
Q2I = Q33
^
{]
on ôV.
Show that Q„= Oin V Thus if three of the compatibility equations hold in general and three others hold only on the boundary, then in fact all six independent equations hold generally.' * This exercise is adapted fro m K. Wa hixu , "A NINE on the Coniiiiiuris of Compatibility,” Mai, ph ys , 36, 306-312 (1957). Comments on the significance of the result are grade an the end of Section 43.
Se c 4_2] Nno4t•`:1- f ûnslifutrt•e Equation and Sot»r Exact .awtfitlotLs
t
59
4.2 Hooke's Constitutive Equation and Sonic Exact Solutions In this section we supplement the field ,equations, which apply to any continuum, by a suitably generalized version of Ilooke's "stress is proportional to strain" assumption for cylindrical bars under tension. The generalization involves an isotropic tensor of order 4, and hence two coefficients. (The third coefficient, normally found in the expression for a general fourth order isotropic tensor, is zero by symmetry.) Certain exact solutions will he shown to relate these "Lame coefficients" to the more down-to-earth elastic constants such as Young's modulus. This modulus was introduced in Chapter 12 of I, where a one-dimensional theory of elasticity was presented. The discussion here is independent of the earlier one, but of course bears many similarities to it GENERALIZED HOOKE'S LAW
Let us now state the basic equations governing the motion of a continuous medium. Anticipating a fuller discussion at the beginning of the next section, we exploit the assumed smallness of the displacement and its derivatives to replace the (material) velocity by the partial derivative with respect to time of the displacement: au, Du, (Jul aJ1 i - n t^ i ^ Di ^t ^
Similarly, we shall make the approximation 3 ;n; {Fl 1
Derivations of the basic equations can be found in Chapter 14 of l; the equations are listed in Appendix 2.1. With the above approximations the mass-conservation requirement takes the form
Dp
_ 0.
(1)
The three equations derived from the balance of linear momentum become
P t
! cox t-
{Tii ) +
fi .
(2)
Consonant with its conventional use in elasticity theory, we use ; ro denote the body force per unit volume. The notation pf, is used for this quantity in I, and in the present volumeexcepl for the chapters on elasticity.) Balance of angular momentum gives (3) = Energy equations will not be required in
our discussion.
I643
Foundations of £tusrit- 4y [Ch. 4
The body force per unit volume.. .6(x, r), is normally considered to be known. Thus (1) and (2) comprise four equations; and there are 10 unknowns - the density, the 3 components of the displacement vector (used in preference to velocity in elasticity), and the 6 components of the symmetric stress tensor. 1f we were to introduce the strains, the discrepancy between the number of equations and unknowns would not be altered, since we would he adding 6 components of the (symmetric) strain tensor and 6 relations between the strains and the displacement vector_ Constitutive equations, the stress - strain relations still remain to be postulated. In Chapter 12 of I. on the one-dimensional motion of a bar, we used as our stress- strain relation l llooke's law, which states that stress is proportional to strain. Let us consider this case in somewhat more detail_ Suppose that we apply a tension test to a cylindrical har of structural metal, such as steel. That is, suppose we measure the elongation of the bar as a function of an applied axial force. The. results turn out to be of the form shown in Figure 4.6_ The abscissa, e, is the uniform axial strain, i.e., the change in length per unit original length. The ordinate is the stress T computed by dividing the applied force F by the original cross-sectional area a.
T
T
u tr
__
f ! J ! I
r t 1
1 {}
k' t c u k E 4.6. SfrPs.s T eErso- strain e in a tension test on a cylindrical b u r
We find that up to the point P, the proportional limit, the stress T is proportional to the strain e. Between P and Y, the yield point, the relation is no longer proportional_ lithe load is released, however, the unloading curve will duplicate the loading curve; and, when the load is reduced to zero, the strain will likewise vanish. Beyond Y, the material becomes plastic and unloading is indicated by the dashed line. We observe in this case that when the load is reduced to zero, there is a permanent strain left in the specimen. if the material is subsequently reloaded, the stress strain curve will follow the unloading tine, which is approximately parallel to OP. After the reloading portion meets the original loading curve, the stress-strain diagram continues as though no unloading - reloading cycle had taken place. The stress corre-
Sec. 4_2j Hookr's Consfivaire E.quainori and Soin Lxucs Solutions
rbr
spending to the point U, a local maximum of the graph, is usually referred to as the ultimate load ; point B represents rupture of the specimen. Depending on the particular material, portions of this stress. strain curve may he missing or somewhat altered_ In some materials, the stress-strain curve beyond the yield point may he almost fl at. Moreover, the unloading reloading cycle may look something like a hysteresis loop. One should also realize that the apparent drop in stress after U is somewhat illusory. We recall that the stress plotted was defined as applied force divided by the original cross-sectional area At the point U. the area of the specimen has contracted. If- one were to calculate the stress by dividing the applied force by the instantaneous area, the curve would not drop. For low-carbon steel, P is about 35,000 pounds per square inch (psi) and 11 is about 60,000 psi. For iron, P is about 25,000 psi and Y is approximately 30,000 psi. The initial slope of the stress strain diagram is known as Young's modulus and designated by E. For steel, E 30 x 106 psi, and for aluE = 10 x 10' psi_ (I psi = 69,870 dynesjcrn minum, Classical elasticity is concerned with the linear portion of the stress-strain curve from O to P. It should be remembered that not all materials display this behavior_ For example, rubberlike materials usually have only a curved stress strain law that is approximated by a straight line through the origin only for extremely small stresses. We shall assume that the material is initially stress free, so that all components of stress vanish when the components of strain are zero. Furthermore, extrapolating the tension test results, we assume that the stresses are linear functions of the strains. Consequently, we may write -)
(4)
Ci1hmEkrn-
The quotient rule shows that the 81 coefficients C oin, form the components of a fourth order tensor C_ For most of our applications, we shall assume that the material is homogeneous, which means that the components of C11 ,, are constants independent of both x and t. There will be a few cases in which we shall want wallow these coefficients to be functions of x, but this will be particularly noted at the appropriate time. The components of C_'^ can be found by removing a representative sample from the material and applying a series of tests wherein both the stress and strain components can be measured_ A wide class 01 materials in which we shall be interested are devoid of "grain" or crystal orientation. They thus have the property that the values of the coefficients, so determined, will be independent of the orientation of the sample tested. Such materials are called isotropic. Consider (4) and its counterpart in another Cartesian coordinate system ^i 1 — ^, ijkm Ek
•
t62
Frrundarrrxrrs of F laxslirïr}.
lC'!1. 4
In an isotropic material the contribution, say, of £ 2.3 try T 2 , must be the same as the contribution of E3 3 to T, 2 . Th115 C 1223 =
0 1223
or, in general, C'ukra That is, C must be a fourth order isotropic tensor. The general form of such a tensor is given in (2-1.40. The scalar found there must be zero, however, since Tu is invariant to an interchange of i and ), but the terms multiplied by K are not. [See Exercise 2.1.22 or the derivation of (31.49).] Consequently, (4) takes the form` T,-; = 4E1:4 + 11-41‘ 15 i;-
(5)
Equations (5) are known as the generalized Hooke's law, and the constants . and p are known as the Lamé constants. INTERPRETATION OF THE ELASTIC COEFFICIENTS VIA EXACT SOLUTIONS
We shall consider a number of simple, "armchair" experiments that will give us some physical insight into the two Lam& constants, as well as certain important combinations ct the two. To do so, we must first solve the linear equations (5) for the strains as functions of the stresses. In (5), let us put i and j equal to a common value k. Performing the indicated sum, we find that Tkk -
(2p + 3,110: kk
or f.k k
= --
k
-_
21.i + 3A7
(6)
Thus we obtain the strain-stress equations
2u
2p(2p + 3,1) '
(7)
• The saint final result is obtained From the seemingly more general assumption Ti r To see this, one employs the decomposition ^1.^.
= i.F,. +
i 06w
of (1,31). Then one can make the assumption that an observer rotation will not affect the constitutive equation (principle of material indifference). Alternatively, one can prove that t ic contribution associated with w. in fact, vanishes. - flic discussion is precisely parallel to that for the corresponding case that arises in fluid mechanics. as presented above (3.1.19) and also bckrw {3.1.25].
Sec_ 4_1] Hoake'.s
Curpsrrlurree•
&yurclrrxi und Satin, Exact Su}urrm.ti.
t63
We shall now consider a sequence of situations that are so simple that exact solutions to the governing equations can be guessed. In all these situations the (symmetric) stress tensor is identically constant, there are no body forces, and there are no variations with time, so the linear momentum equation (2) and the angular momentum equation (3) are identically satisfied. The density p is constant, so the mass-conservation requirement (1) is also identically satisfied. The various situation s a re specified byprescribingstresses on theboundarics of bodies having given shapes. From the guessed form of 71 1 we compute the strains from (7). In all our examples the strain tensor is constant, so the compatibility conditions (1.43) are certainly satisfied. TENSION OF A CYLINDRICAL BAR
As our first example, we consider a cylindrical bar under tension, as illustrated in Figure 4.7. The magnitude of the force per unit area is prescribed as N at the ends of the bar, and zero along the sides.
FIGURE 4.7. A c 'li ufrrt ul brrr Wider rrrnwlr
The stress tensor in this case is given by
f) {l 7;o — 0 U 0 , 0UU N
for then both the end and side forces have their assigned values (Exercise 1). The example under study is precisely that of the tension test_ Therefore, we expect the axial stress and the axial strain to be in a ratio given by Young's modulus E:
N Elt
(R)
r64
Foundarrons of F.Ja.siiriry
1C.h. 4
Furthermore, it has king been known that lateral contraction occurs in the tension test. The ratio of lateral contraction to longitudinal extension is designated by Poisson's ratio v. That is, we expect that —
f:22
^1L
_
— ^3 3
=
(9)
V.
^li
From the known values of I we compute the t: i f from (7) and find accord with (8) and (9), provided [Exercise 2(a)] that ^
=^(2^+3^. ) + $.1'
ti:
2(..1-^ ^)
.
(10a, h)
Solving for the Lamé constants, we find [Exercise 2(b)] that
A
_ E l,), ^ ^ 2(1 +
Ev
(1 + v)(1 — 2 ► j '
(lla, b}
and that
v_ E
d
(12)
2,u{31 + 2}^j
The strain-stress equations ofMean now he written very simply in terms of the "engineering constants," Young's modulus and Poisson's ratio: = (1 + ►+)7; f - u 3rkk
^
.
(13)
These equations have a rather simple interpretation_ We note that (i 1 —
TrLr r2 2T33 (14)
and similarly for the other axial strains. Equation (14) states that the tensile strain in the x 1 '-direction is the elongation produced by the tensile stress in that direction minus the contraction produced in that direction by the tensile stresses in the x 2- and x 3 -directions. One could, in fact, develop the stress strain laws by starting with this fact as a hypothesis, together with the assumption that the principal axes of stress and strain coincide. From this it follows that the stress strain Laws in principal axes are given by (14) with corresponding expressions for the other two components. Since the constitutive relations must be tensorial, they must be given by (13) in any other Cartesian coordinate system. -
SHEAR OF A RECTANGULAR BAR
The second case we shall examine is that of pure shear stress. Imagine an infinite cylindrical bar of rectangular cross section that stretches along the x3 -axis. Subject the lateral faces of the bar to shear stress having magnitude s
See 4_4 Huokr's Cotrsatufirr Equation and Same FA ucv Sr, fuftr,ns
165
-r7 -
5
+
^
I
?
i
/ ^
/ ^ / ^
Fi[;t7 sE 4.8. !lie arrows represent Shear farces applied rrl u rectangular hur
.
The miss section delimits into Me dashed parallelogram
and orientation as in Figure 4.8, Then (Exercise 4) the stress tensor is given by F tiJ
s
7:i — s 0 {] .
(15)
t]
0 0
We see from (7) or (13) that the only nonvanishing strain component will be ' l 2 _ If we write E, 2 = ' , then (according to the interpretation of the nffdiagonal strain components found in Section 4.1), the cross section deforms into a parallelogram, as shown in Figure 4.8. The stress-strain law (5)yields T1 — 21"F 2
(i6a)
or, alternatively, my.
(16h)
will be proIn linear elasticity the (correct) expectation that the angle has led engineers to introduce a proportionto the applied shear s portional ality constant called the shear modulus G:
From (I fib) and (I lb) we sec that
E We expect that, for reasonable materials, G > 0 and E > O. Thus I +y>O
or w> —1.
We expect, additionally, that longitudinal extension is accompanied by lateral contraction. Consequently, the inequality stated above will be replaced by the assumption (17) v >p,
Foun dations of Elasticity [Ch. 4
166
COMPRESSION OF A RECTANGULAR PARALLELEPIPED
The final case that we shall consider involves pure compression. Consider a rectangular parallelepiped with faces normal to the coordinate axes. Impose on each face an inward normal stress of magnitude p, p > 0_ Then p =
0
—
0
0
p
U. p
0 0
—
The shear strains vanish and the normal strains satisfy
ECE l _ EE22 = 1;€.33 = (2); — 1)p.
The dilatation, A, is given
by
FA = E kk = — 3(1 — 2v)p. (18) We expect that the dilatation will be proportional to p. Thus the bulk modulus or compression, k, is defined by
= —
(19)
A
(The minus sign is present because dilatation is negative in compression.) From (18) and (19), k
_ 3(1 — 2v)
.(20)
In terms of the Lame constants, (20) can easily be shown (Exercise 5) to become k = À + p.
(21)
It is expected that material will not expand under the influence of a purely compressive stress. For this reason we assume that k 0, i.e., [from (20)] that y< To summarize the inequalities concerning Poisson's ratio, expectations that elongation will not lead to lateral expansion and that compression forces will not cause expansion give rise to the assumption .
4-
(22)
An incompressibility assumption gives v = . Typical values of v fall between 1 and -I. For example, v = 0.25 for cast iron and glass; v — 0.29 for carbon steels. EXERCISES
1. (a)
Consider the cylindrical bar under tension, as in Figure 4.7. Show that if the stress tensor is as given in the text, then the end stresses are N and the side stresses are zero.
Sec. 47] Hrxake's C un.srtfuter'e Lquuttora rind
2. 3.
4.
5.
Sonie E.*tic'! Oknolls
lb
(b) Find the displacements, choosing the arbitrary rigid motion to make these as simple as possible. (a) Verify (10); (b) verify (11) and (12). Show that the principal axes of stress and strain coincide for an isotropic material. Prove the somewhat more general result that if A,, is a symmetric tensor and u is a scalar, then A ii and A rp + c^ have the same principal axes_ What is the relation between the principal values of the two tensors? Show that the stresses in Figure 4.8 are indeed associated with the stress tensor that is given in (15). Compute the strain tensor that corresponds to this stress tensor. Establish (21) as well as the following relations among the elastic constants: 3k v 3k E _ E 3k(1 2v) ,
1 +r
— 9k — -
-
-
—
6. Consider the following displacement for an elastic problem with vanishing body forces: u3(x, r) ï u3(x, t) = 0.
e+1(x, r) = U(xt, r),
Find the corresponding strains and stresses. Find the equation that u(x t , r) satisfies. How does this compare with the displacement equation developed for the one-dimensional motion of a bar in Section 12.1 of 1? 7. Ii is asserted that measurements on the strain of a certain motionless solid can be fitted if the following assumption is made: y 2 + Y 2 xZ
X2
0
(ce}) = y 2 + 2 2
xZ
X
x .
(23)
21
(a) What body forces are implied by the above assumption and (2)? (h) Show that even though the equilibrium equations 12) can be satisfied, (23) nonetheless cannot bean appropriate deduction from the experimental evidence (assuming that the material is not torn). 8. (a) Deduce from (1.4S) the following form of the compatibility conditions for a 13ookean material [one that satisfies (5)]. V 2 Ts + e ,3 T,
.
=
(24a) (c5„v 20 + 0. „).
TR
(24b)
s^^
,
Here 0
-
(b) Using the equilibrium equations (3.8), deduce v I ! V-27;,+
V^
rs
l -4- ^' ^r* ^^[) ^
{
1r
s
^ ^- s . ^ = 0.
(25)
16s
Foundations of E1as1icùr L('h-
4
(c) Show that 1 — Ir ,r1
^3r:.
'
■^
and hence that
V xO=^ + ^(7-f). (d) Obtain the following alternative form of the compatibility equations in terms of the stresses V
V2
7; ♦ ® .ri + ' 1+w l -
b,(V - f) + Ii
Jr.F
+
J â.r
O. (26)
9. Show (using the results of the previous exercise) that when the body Force is constant, then e._=_ Tkk and en are harmonic, and that the stress and strain components are biharmonic. 10. This exercise considers the equations governing an imaginary, " quasiclastic," incompressible material that is indifferent to deformation but that resists rotations relative to absolute space. See the end of Section 6.3 for remarks connecting this material with the "ether_" (a) Lei the constitutive equation be T = kw, where Tis the stress tensor and w is the rotation tensor of (4.1.321). Show that the antisymmetry of implies the antikymmetry of T, and find a relation between the vectors (denoted by 12 and r) that are associated with to and T (b) Provide a physical interpretation of the constitutive equation in terms of moments and a "twist modulus" k by considering the special case 0 12 = -0 21 O, - 13 = WA = W23 = W 32 = O. (e)
Use
linearized momentum equations and neglect body force. Derive Ov
yt =-
k
2
V A i?.
an , t^t
1 =^ (Vnv ) ,
V•v =O, V - f2 = O .
(These equations have the form of Maxwell's equations for empty space!)
4.3 Final Formulation of the Problem of Linear Elasticity In line with our use of the linearized stress-strain law and the linearized relation between the strain tensor and the displacement vector, we wish now fully to linearize the governing equations of elasticity. A major step has already been accomplished—replacing the velocity v by the time derivative of
ei. 4.3] Final Format: imp of l ►1e Pr,,hJeni
eq
Linear nastway
169
the displacement, by ignoring the relatively small nonlinear terms in the material derivative. An additional step is necessary. We exploit the assumed smallness of the displacement u to approximate the density at the spatial point x and the time t by the density of the particle that was initially at x. (This particle will now, at time r, generally be quite close to x, since displacements arc small.) Material and spatial descriptinns of density have been denoted by (5. and p, respectively: r(A,
t) =
p[x(A. r), t],
rMA(x, t
t] = p(x, r)_
Thus our assumption can be written
p(x, t)
c5{x, 0).
(1)
Another way of stating this assumption requires introduction of the deviation p' from the initial density^(x=
r) =
plx,
t)
—
b{x, i)),
I iI C L
(2)
Substituting p(x, f) Mx, 0) + p(x I) into the rxlasS-conservation equation {2.1), we obtain, to first approximation [ Exercise 2(a)], —
cep
{fit
,
(`t1,(x, 0) + --+ r)(x, 0)
ei
C
r^tr
r^ x,
îor
— 0_
(3)
As will be clear immediately, p does not enter any of the remaining linearized equations_ -I - hus the displacement u ; can be computed separately and (3) can then he used to calculate the density correction p. This is seldom done, as this correction is normally of little interest. Still, a careful worker should at least use ( 3) to estimate the magnitude of li , in order to he sure that he has been consistent in assuming that this magnitude is small. We shall use the notation p(x) - b(x, t)). Thus pix) is the known density of the material that was initially located at x, and p(x, t) p(x)_ From now on we shall usually not bother to make the distinction between p(x, z) and p{x); p +mill h • regarded as the known Mina) devrsit y. SUMMARY OF CENERAL EQUATIONS. BOUNDARY CONDITIONS, AND INITIAL CONDITIONS
Let us now summarize the linearized field equations that hold in the interior of an elastic body R. The density p(x) and the body force per unit volume f,{x, t) are considered to be known. The linear momentum equations (2.2) are p (x) u ,
=
Î
c.'
Orr
(4)
Fâundafion.s of EiastiCily
170
[Ch. 4
The strain-displacement relations (1.32a) are
(5)
= ^1^i . 1 + ii j i) ^
and the stress-strain laws (2.5) are To. = 2pic ;i + 1.Ekk ^i i j .
(6a)
Alternatively, one can use the strain-stress equations (2.13) Ftij
— {l + '}T 1 w v7k
(6h)
^ . }
The conservation of mass equations need not be considered here since the density variation can be determined by{3)once the displacement n i(x, t) has been ascertained. We also note that the compatibility equations (1.43) will automatically be satisfied if the rig are defined as in (5). The boxed relations comprise 15 equations in 15 unknowns—the 3 displacement components u ; , the 6 independent components To of the symmetric stress tensor, and the 6 independent components r ; , of the symmetric strain tensor. In addition to these field and constitutive equations that hold in the interior R, boundary conditions must be specified over the boundary R. There are a number of important classes of boundary conditions. For example, over part of the surface, c?R 1 , the displacement vector u i may hespecified. Over another portion of the surface, OR 2, the stress vector r ; may he specified. Since = T", a linear combination of the components of the stress tensor is specified over the surface OR t _ There are ether situations that arise when only certain components of the stress and certain components of the displace-
ment are specified on the boundary. Complete formulation of the problem also requires knowledge of initial conditions_ Typically, u and au/Or are prescribed at some initial instant To summarize, a general initial boundary value problem of dynamic elasticity is to find z (x, i), £ 04DX, t), and Tutx, t), so that the boxed equations (4), (5), and (6a) are satisfied for x in a region R, r > O. Also to be satisfied are the following conditions:
0) =
uFox(x),
I x),
(x, Or t
ui(x} r) _ te i (x, r1,
X
1f(x, r)
x
XE R.
(7a, b)
r 7 U. E
aR 1 ,
U.
Here le', u;'', z , tr and also ff, are given functions. Furthermore, OR
OR
R.
Sec - . 4.3)
Filial formulurrulI i3 f Mt" Pro,'lem r,f
Linear L`'tu n( a's.
171
A general boundary value problem in static elasticity results when p (12 2r ; j[lt 3 is deleted from (4) and when the initial conditions (7) are also deleted_ In particular, for the stresses we have the equilibrium equations +j, =0.
(8)
NAVIEWS tŸ4)LlATLDNS
If boundary conditions involve only [he displacement vector u, it is probably best to have the governing equations expressed entirely in terms of this vector. To accomplish this, we write (6a) as = 1( uu1,, + u ,. r) 4- ).ir $,_ & ô,j _
Substituting for the stress tensor in (4) and collecting like ternis, we find
P
t,
LI,
u ^. J , + (p
[^f
+
1)ru3 ,^ +
.
(ria]
Equation (9a) may be written in vector notatinn as u
p
- 2 =
^
i^t
u + (p
+ ^.j grad div u 4 -f.
( 9 h)
In terms of the engineering constants, (9a) may also be expressed as
2(1 + v) us •;; + 1 — 2rr+'"
P r
+ It
(9c)
Equations (9a), (9b), or (9c) are known as Navier's equations. BE LïMAM1—%1rCHE[.t. EQUATIONS
Consider Navier's equations in the static case, for which (9c) can be written (using different subscripts)
+ v)
l
u4'"+ 1
-
2v^ i '^+
- ^ ^k
=
^
(10
)
As we shall now see, in this case we can eliminate the displacement and write the equations entirely in terms of the stresses. To do this we differentiate (10) and change the order of differentiation in the first term, obtaining
kk
2(1 + v) = ^} t+ k . , = V.
1 .
Ili
1 1
2v +. rk f -
The interchange of k and j yields 1
+1
2v u'''fk
+
2(1
+ v) E
fj. i = O.
(12)
172
l burui'urraas
of Elasticity
[Ch.
4
We next add (11) and (12), utilize (5), and observe that differentiation with respect to x i and xk can he reversed. We find, upon multiplying by E12, that F,B - • +
F —
1A + 2 ► ' Fii
(13)
(1 + u) (^k f ).k)= {]_
We can now use (6b) in (13) together with the fact [a consequence of (6b)] that (1 — 2074.
By this means we find that ç y+ 1 + /{ vTr p.nnL1jk + i iLk + (1 1.)(J*J +
(1 +
— O.
(14)
This result can be further simplified by first observing the result of setting j = k in (14):
+ y
f
y ^^,*.
Inserting this back into (14), we finally find the Beltrami Michell equations that express the governing relations of static elasticity exclusively in terms of the stresses:
1 + I
v
v c. ji+ j - _ v , .i
+.Îk.,+Î;. =a
(15)
There are six distinct equations, for the six distinct components of the symmetric stress tensor. Extension of these results to the dynamic case is requested in Exercise 2(b)_ The equations of (1 5) are identical with those of (2.26), which were obtained by manipulating the compatibility equations (1.43). Thus the BeltramiMichell equations themselves can be regarded as compatibility equations. When formulating the governing equations in terms of stresses one can, in fact, use the equilibrium equations* (8)and the compatibility equations in any of the forms (2.25), (2.26), or (15). Six independent equations constitute the compatibility conditions, and three more comprise the equilibrium conditions. It may seem that there is a danger of inconsistency, for only the six independent components of the symmetric stress tensor are unknown. in fact, we see here the danger of guessing at consistency by a naïv e counting of equations—for the reasonableness of the physical requirements suggests that it is not inconsistent to demand satisfaction of the nine prescribed equations for the six unknowns. Closer examination of the situation reveals more accord with "common sense" than first appears. There are nine partial differential equations for the six unknown components of T, but only three boundary conditions are • We consider here the equilibrium equations for simplicity. but our analysis can easily be extended 10 the time-dependent case.
sec. d_3]
Email Fo rrrrauttrnrr of Me. Problem r+} Linear Vanua)
1 73
obtained by prescription of the stress ii • T. It seems that there are three too many equations and three too few boundary conditions. But Exercise 1.15 shows that three: of the compatibility equations can be required to hold only on the boundary, without changing the basic structure of the problem. With this requirement, the problem takes the "sensible form" of six partial differential equations and six boundary conditions for six unknown 1unctinns_ (See Exercise 3 for an analogous case from fluid mechanics.)
E!iERCItiF-ti
1. Show that the stress vector t, acting on a surface with unit normal n, rs given by %,
t
2. (a)
(h) 3. (a)
ri ^. ^ t I— 1
. x+
2(1 + t•)
'
^
r,
Verify (3). Find Beltrami Michell equations for dynamic elasticity, in which the term is retained in (9). Let v(x)denote the velocity field in the steady motion of an irrotatronaI incompressible fluid contained in a region R. Justify the following equations: ❑ nV' - U.
v•
n —};
^^Y•
❑ •# =
n r[r = U.
l1-
tn. R. on r'R
(
( f gi ► i'n}_
l6a. h)
{ 1 tx. d)
a2R
(b)
(c)
The equations of 110 consutute a problem for three unknown functions t} r , u2, and t'3 with four equations and only two boundary conditions. Nonetheless, show that it has a unique solution by quoting an appropriate result from potential theory. . O. Now assume that Q 3 = f]2 = Û Let Q, = r1 ;c t•, t . Show that in R, Q3 = it on i'R. Prove that Q3 = 0 in R. (We now see that the problem can be put into the more conventional form with three equatrcjns
Qr =
0, Q2=0. V -r— Q,
in R;
and three boundary conditions
173 = 0 v - n = f'
Y- n do = O.
,
i
on
N
Note that the last condition can be regarded as sort of a 'compatibility boundary condition" for incompressibility.)
L 74
Frruadurir3as
LAUD-CIO'
[Ch.
4
4.4 Energy Concepts and the Principle of Virtual Work In Chapter 12 of I, on the longitudinal motion of a bar, we developed several energy concepts. A similar program can be carried out in the general case of linear elasticity, It can he seen that the basic ideas which we shall employ here are exactly the same as those employed in the one-dimensional case. The chief differences between the two programs arise frcrn the technical difficulties of working in three dimensions. We also extend the ideas of I by showing that in a certain sense the equilibrium configuration provides a minimum potential energy. E N E RGY BALANCE
We consider an elastic body with interior R and hounding surface OR. Recall that the rate of working is given by the scalar product of force and velocity. Thus, in the time interval O < t < T, the work of the external forces WE will be given by
dr. di ^- J
^Ÿf -
0
❑T
fJ.1 ti^j dr dt
(
I)
.
r7R
To compute the work of the internal forces for 0 ç t Ç I; we consider an arbitrary portion of R, which will be designated by D, and the corresponding boundary D. The ith component of the total force acting on D is given by
da ` D
OD
f dr + t^
1),N da -
JJJIJ D
ïD
Since D is arbitrary, we can conclude that the internal force per unit volume Thus the work of the internal forces, W r , is given by equals f; +
Pvz- Efif
ll i + i^tl üT
üt.
(2)
As in Exercise 1(a) and l(h), it can be shown that
ffl
7 i j ui
dT
=
d er -
Tii oi dr,
(3a)
''
rt
âR
and that Tj,
^ rj .
(3h)
Using the stress-strain law (2.5), we find [Exercise. 1(c)] that Taco =
-
Tr ( 2 etjii1 + dleki a/j).
(3e)
Sec, 4.41 Energy Concepts and the Principle of Virtual Mirk
175
We conclude [Exercise 1(d)] that Y■ 1 J
fT 0
(
1 dz + 5ff J R
1 ûi des
dt —
in 1( 21.m ,j F.k1 + xtkrFji)IÔ di R
ôA
(3d)
It is anticipated that the work by external forces will be transformed into work by internal forces plus a stored potential energy of strain. Accordingly, we define the change in strain energy as the difference between the work of the external forces and that or the internal forces. From (l) and (3d), we see that change in strain energy = fJI(2PEijEJ + A',c i,o») dtIQ,
(4)
Consequently, the strain energy, E, , satisfies EE(T) _ fir (2 .icii t,; + IÏtu riJ)Iô dr + constant. We set the arbitrary constant equal to zero, thereby identifying the arbitrary zero of strain energy with the strain-free state (E,; 0). Thus
j'j
f
'
1
Ar, k t: 1J) di.
(5)
In terms of the engineering constants,
E, 2(1 E+ v)
JJf(
aki ev + 1 k 2v tttii di.
(6)
R
By (2.22), 0 v 5 /, so that Er is nonnegative, as is at once evident from (5). [Note that co, cii = (402 .1 That any deviationfrom the unst rat ned stare Iead.N to a positive strain energy is an important fact: as we shall see shortly, it permits us to deduce uniqueness theorems for linear elasticity. To obtain a useful "mixed" expression for E, we use the stress-strain relations to write 244flJ ci! + kekA tii = Maki + AEkk 61 f)e;i --=
This gives T i t o dz_
(7a)
R
In principal axes, with principal stresses and strains Ti and r; , we have E, _ 5ff TA dr.
(lb)
176
Foundations of ' Rusticity (C'h_ 4
To interpret [7h), recall the elementary physics problem of determining the potential energy stored in a spring. Let the spring possess a Ilooke's constant k, so that the force F exerted by a spring stretched a distance x is given by F(x) = kx_ The work required to stretch the spring a total of s units is W(5) =
J
F dx = j kx dx = iks i isf•'(s).
s1
o
v
The correct result may be obtained by multiplying the total extension s by the average of the initial and final forces 0 and F(s). (See also Exercise 12.4.5 of I.) it appears that a time integration, as in (1) and succeeding equations, is the most convincing way to obtain the factor that must appear in (7). it is now manifest that the local potential energy stored in a strained elastic body, EE , can be regarded as being due to the stretching of three 1-lookean springs aligned along the mutually perpendicular principal axes_ This is no surprise, for we have seen that local deformation can be viewed as stretching along such axes. it is sometimes useful to define a stress energy E,,, which is merely the strain energy written in terms of the stresses. By applying the strain stress relations (2.13), we find from (7a) that
E
0
2E
v}T,•; T1 — vTi; T;i]
fir
dr.
(8)
R
Since Ei ^ Û Ed O. Let us return to the momentum equation (3.4), multiply through by Ai , ,
and integrate over the volume R, After a little manipulation [Exercise 2(a)], we obtain
= ffi idi7+
f11
itR
(9a)
where the kinetic energy K(i) of the material in R is defined by
fC _ i ffi pfû
,
(9b)
dr_
R
itut {Fxercise 2(h)]
fJf T,i 1ot =
(10)
R
We thus arrive at the energy-llence relation
dr^
dE + di
,^,^,^ R
^; ci
dr
+
t; ti; d o . au
(II
)
Sec 4.41 Energy Ci.»
pis and Hie Prr+u ip( u► ! i"irru al ^b'r.rl►
1
77
Thai is, the rate of change of total energy (kinetic plus strain) equals the rate of working of body , forces and surface stresses. A one-dimensional version of this relation (in the absence of body forces) is given in (12.4.8) of 1. PRINCIPLE OF VIRTUAL WORK
We now derive a useful relation for s[rni problem that is essentially a variant of the divergence theorem, Consider any set of stress components T, that satisfy the equations (3.8) of static equilibrium
+
f
—t]
in R.
(12)
No form of compatibility condition need hold, but the usual relation tj = n - T^ is assumed to link the stress tensor and the stress vector_ Let u# be any set of virtual displacements. These can he any smooth functions defined in R. In particular, the virtual displacements need not satisfy the Javier equations. We define a corresponding set of virtual strains, ej, • by the relations
= Yu'1 + rr
}
( 1 3)
j.
By standard manipulations
fff( ^; u*)^ H
t, u,* d o- _ ?H
r`R
= ff'fi;ur dr +
(l4)
? r u* r rfT ,
But using the symmetry of the stress tensor and ( 12), we can write
{[J J•
1
dr =
f tr^` t^r = — ff
f A u*
[1T
.
Interchanging dummy subscripts, we see that (14) implies that
Jfj i» dr + ff) tu* d o — ff.{ 7j; ^
/I
di
= JjJ(I,.0 + TWIN dT
F[
= iff T, i(u*
f + üj, i) d
-r.
Employing (l3), we obtain our final result,
JJJ x
fiut ch
4- ffil ur da =T'tri dt. OR
R
(16)
L 7li
Foundations fit f:7a.sticiry
!Ch. 4
Equation { l6) is known as the principle of virtual work.* When multiplied by 1, Equation (16) has the interpretation that the work of the body forces on the virtual displacements, plus the work of the surface stresses on the virtual surface displacements, equals the work of the stresses on the virtual strains. The factor of I is necessary for reasons discussed in the interpretation of (7l). UNIQUENESS THEOREMS
The energy-balance relation and principal of virtual work are convenient tools for establishing the uniqueness of the solutions to problems of elasticity. Let us first confine our attention to the general boundary value problem in static elasticity. Recall from Section 3 that in this problem u, is prescribed on M IL and t; on CR2, where L R , -- r1R 2 OR. We assert that the solution of this problem is unique. To prove this assertion, let us assume that there are two solutions, u;, Et. ) ; and 4. 771, c;} . Define "difference" displacements, strains, and stresses by It
u; =,
=
Tr,
= Tri — T7j .
(17)
From the linearity of the equations, we see that for x on r:'R
u; = 0
t ; = To ni = 0 for x can eR i ,
1- urthermore,
Tt = D
for x in R,
so the difference stress components T o satisfy an equilibrium equation in which body forces on absent. We can now apply the principle of virtual work to these displacements and stresses. Using (7a) we find that
2F,
11 1.
ToE, dr
t;11;
da +
[,u, da + fJjf,u, dr = O.
tut
sand u ; can only be a rigid body motion (see Exercise 1.5). Since t4, {] on ôR 2, the rigid body motion also vanishes and the solution must be unique, (If rR 2 is empty, the solution is unique only up to a rigid body displacement.) Now let us consider the general initial boundary value problem of dynamic elasticity that was described in Section 4.3. Again, let us assume that there are two solutions, er; and 147, and define difference displacements, strains, and stresses as in (17). Thus Since E( is norinegative definite, it follows from (5) that
= 0 on OR,
E IS
and t; _ Tl;ni = 0 on t1R2,
• We sec from (1e1l'isiificalion for the use of the word "virtual" in the Sense "in effect but not in fart." Equation [ I6J involves functions i1* and Ef., chat in general have no physical antcrpretation, but these functions have the effect of displacements and strains in a work balance_
Sec- 4.4] Energy Concepts an d the Principle
of virtual mirk
1.79
and
Pnï
`
To in R.
(The difference solution again satisfies a momentum equation with vanishing body force.) Applying the energy-balance relation to these: displacements and stresses, we find that dK rf t
dG r + =Û c[
[
c^ r
K + E t = constant. Now at time t — 0, x1,(x, 0) = i (x, 0) = to*, Oj = O. Thus the sum of the kinetic and strain energies must vanish, but, since each is positive definite, it follows that both K and E, vanish separately. From the vanishing of K we deduce that ri ; 0; thus the problem described by the difference in the two solutions is static. As in the previous case, the vanishing of E^ implies that the solution is tiniquePOTENTIAL ENERGY MINIMIZATION IN EQUILIBRIUM
The principle of virtual work (16) points the way toward important energy minimization properties possessed by elastic media in equilibrium. In our study of these properties we shall be considering minima among a For the remainder of the sec lion, certain class of virtual displacements these will be smooth functionst that are prescribed on a pari OR, of the boundary and that correspond to prescribed stresses [through (15) and (3-6a)] on the remaining part of the boundary r R 2 We associate a potential energy i'(5) with i as follows
t • u da.
VV(U) = Eau) — 55f f • L [fir --
(1 8 )
OR
Here the strain energy EA) is given by (5) with 1: ;1 = 1-(1-4i4 + Consider virtual displacements of the form iü = u + u''
(19)
where u is the actual equilibrium displacement and ü is a constant. Using (5) and (3.60, Tii
f AERk 15i»,
t As usual, We assume sufficient smouthc]css of 1unLLIL}ns and regions to carry nui required
manipulations.
Possession
on the displacements.
or three conisnunus duriv.sn ►'CS tur ns oui
to be a Sufficient candinori
^13fl
Foundations of Elasticity [Ch. 4
one can show (Exercise 6) that
(7, rîl9 Edu + Ou*) a^o
= fir 1 c* dz. T R
(20)
I fence
()
+ u*) =
firTij Eti dr — U
if
*
}'n*
d o- . (21)
J^
R
According to the principle of virtual work (16), the right side of the above equation vanishes. We have thus proved that the potential energy V(û) has a stationary value corresponding to the equilibrium displacement.f In fact V is a minimum at equilibrium, as we now demonstrate. We need not restrict ourselves in what follows to "near-equilibrium „ displacements. Thus we consider virtual displacements u of the form u + u* where u is the equilibrium displacement as before_ An essentially straightforward calculation [Exercise 8(a)] shows that E (u u*) — EL(u) =1ff
^
r.
di + Q(u *)
(22)
where ou*) - fiJ[p(Li:lj2 +
P(41)2 1 df.
(23)
R
Using the divergence theorem and the fact that To satisfies the equilibrium equations, we find [Exercise 8(b)] that
F L(u + u *) , E L(u) =
filfi ; it* drr + fif f i Lt* dz + 12(u*). iR
(24)
rH
It follows at once from the definition of V that V(u i- u*) — V(u) =
Q[u • )-
( 2 5)
Hut Q(u') is nonnegative and only vanishes when the virtual strain is zero, i.e., when u* corresponds to a rigid body motion. With no real loss of generality we can assume that the strains are prescribed at at least one point, so that in fact u'" = 0 when Q(u*) = 0. We have proved the following result. 'Theorem I. Of all virtual displacements, the true displacements (which satisfy the equilibrium equations) provide an absolute minimum to the potential energy. t Jh srarronariry of V can also be swdied by the Techniques
Eie rcisc 1J_3.26.
of variaiiurral calculus—see
Set. 4.4] Eflery}' Concepts [cnd the Principle of Virtual Work,
I hi
We now indicate the proof to a useful converse of Theorem Theorem 2. if a particular virtual displacement minimizes the potential energy, then it is the true displacement (i.e., it satisfies the equilibrium equations). Proof Suppose that for some fixed virtual displacement u, the set of virtual displacements u t u* has the property that fnr all u'
V(u + u*)
V(u).
(26)
It follows by another use of the divergence theorem [Exercise 9(a)1 that
—
'.;
+ put dr +
7;1 Ra i — Out d o + Q(us)
0.
(27)
The surface integral vanishes because of the boundary conditions. Thus, for arbitrary virtual displacements u*, we have +
dr + Q(u*) > 0.
(28)
Therefore, it must be that the equilibrium equations are satisfied: 1.1+
f—
(29)
to the contrary, that for sonie i
1.70 at a point and therefore* by continuity, in a sphere about this point_ (Reversal of the above inequality is handled similarly.) Pick a smooth virtual displacement, proportional to a factors, that is positive within thissphereand vanishes outside it. A contradiction can now easily be generated from (28). The reason is that the first term is proportional to E. but the quadratic second term is proportional to £ 2 and thus cannot cancel the first term if t is small enough. CI There are a number of other minimum principles in the theory of elasticity ., for example, the true stress minimizes a certain "complementary energy_" (See Sokolnikoff 1956.) Extensions can be made to dynamic problems by a version of Hamilton's principle (see Exercises I l .3.2 and 1 1.3.2U). Aside from their general theoretical interest, such principles provide practical means of calculation. We shall see examples of this in our study of variational methods in Part D. We note in conclusion that minimum principles play a vital role in the field of elastic stability_ A glimpse of the issues involved is provided at the end of Section 5.1.
I.
Fourzdrsriont of Elasticity [Ch. 4
82
ExEitCI5E5
1. (a) Derive (3a). (b) Derive (3b) by writing 441 as the sum of a symmetric and an antisymmetric tensor. (c) Show further that a(ct,E0) _ ^ t?[ ^t
J.
(d) Use the above results to demonstrate (3d). 2. (a) Derive (9a). (b) Derive (l0). 3. A cylindrical bar of length L, with generators parallel to the x 3 -axis, is oluriiform density p. Gravity acts in the direction of the negative x 3-axis. The bar is supported by a uniform vertical stress on the top surface x 3 = L and all other sin faces are free of stress. (a) Formulate an appropriate mathematical problem that should yield the appropriate stress tensor under equilibrium conditions. (h) Show that the stress tensor given by 0
0
0
U
0
(]
0 0
(e)
p9x 3
satisfies all conditions of (a). Find the corresponding strains and show that the displacements a re given by —
p9x3xr E
_ pg(xl
—ppx 3 x 2 11 2
^- y'x r
+
2E
}'xi
— L2
)3
There will be some arbitrariness in the answer to (c). Why does this not contradict the uniqueness theorem? Remove the arbitrariness by assuming that there is neither displacement nor rotation at {0.0, L). (e) To what shape is the originally flat top surface warped under the action of gravity? 4. Consider two equilibrium states of an elastic body R. The body forces h and surface stresses z, produce displacements u ; . The body forces f and surface stresses t' prcxluce the displacements u. (d)
Si e'_ 4.4]
blend Caneeps und Me l'rini'ipre nf Virruur WOrk
1E3
(a) Prove the reciprocal theorem of Betti and Rayleigh:
fIf' tittdc JJJJu
d
T=
dû-ieR
f51 f?w
d
(h) ff T, and Eli are the stresses and strains corresponding (of, and t, and Tr, and arehe stresses and strains corresponding Wirt and rr, , develop the following alternative form of the reciprocal theorem: fir dr = ffJT 'r° j€} x ^
ij dr.
5. The reciprocal theorem can serve as a computational device in a number of cases. Let us consider one such example. Let
f * = 0 and (a) (h)
1-fi
bir .
Find the corresponding surface stresses r*. Show, from the reciprocal theorem, that the total change in volume AV
- JiikidT
is given by
1 ^ 2v
AV ^ =
x
7k►
d=.
(c) Conclude that I 2v ❑ V = -- ^
,x, du f
—
OR
fIl
fx;d2
6. Derive (20) and (21). 7. By following the lines of the argument given in the text, but proceeding from first principles, show that the equilibrium displacement of a simple Nookean spring provides an absolute minimum to the potential energy. N. (a) Verify (22). (b) Verily (24) and (25)_ 9. (a) Derive (27). (h) Following the line of argument given in the text, provide a format proof that (28) implies (29) In particular, provide an explicit formula for a thrice continuously differentiable virtual displacement that vanishes outside the sphere. DO. Show that if body forces vanish and if displacements are prescribed over the whole boundary, then it is the strain energy itself that is minimized at equilibrium. -
FoUrtdarions of Elasticity [Ch.
I H4
4
4.5 Some Effects of Finite Deformation In this section we take a brief look at some effects that were exeludcd from consideration heretofore, owing to the neglect of nonlinear terms in our characterization of deformation_ We begin with another examination of kinematics, based on the algebraic "polar decomposition theorem." Our deeper understanding of kinematics is used in formulating a rather general constitutive equation. We use this to reinvestigate simple shear. Although consideration of this one elementary case obviously can only scratch the surface of the subject, nonetheless we can discern some important effects of finite deformation and we have laid the groundwork for further study. Our approach is based on the book of Jaunzemis (1967), which is a good source for some of the reasoning that we shall omit, and which provides a useful bridge to modern research in finite deformation theory. KINEMATICS
We showed in Section 4.1 that in the linearized case local deformation can he regarded as a superposition of a solid body rotation and stretching along mutually perpendicular axes. We now show that the same type of result is true in the nonlinear case_ Later we demonstrate that the linear result can be recovered as a special case of the nonlinear theory. We begin with (1.6) dx• = x ; JA) d A ; .
(I)
which we write in the lams dx, = f {A) dA,
or
dx = F- dA.
(2)
Here F is a common notation for the position-gradient tensor Vx. We assume that F is nonsingular, so that each initial line element dA is transformed into a unique line element dx, and conversely_ tinder these circumstances the transformation is characterized by the following theorem. Polar Decomposition Theorem. if F is nonsingular, then it has a unique right decomposition of the form
F = R •tI -
(3)
R'r = R ' ;
(4)
1 Pere R is orthogonal,
and U is symmetric and positive. (A symmetric tensor is termed positive if all its eigenvalues are positive-) There is a unique left decomposition of the form F= V •R,
(5)
where R is the same tensor that appears in (3) and if is positive and symmetric.
Sec. 4.5J Srarrre Etr•Crs of FtntiY iJefnrmarron
185
A transformation associated with an orthogonal matrix' such as R preserves length, for y t = R rj x j implies that
= RraR^k^xr = x k x
(6)
since Rrjpfk =
(R1.R)
Thus the transformation induced by R is a rotation and R is called a rotation tensor, Moreover. (I and V induce stretching (or contraction) along their three mutually perpendicular eigenvectors and are termed the right and left stretch tensors, respectively. Proof of the polar decomposition theorem. Define w by
iv;—F
.1 1.
W e k n o w that ►
= 0 if and only if Y = 0,
f 7)
since F is nonsingular. Thus the right side of 14'î 11 r
t, I r ik t: 1 l k
(8)
is a positive definite quadratic form, since (7) guarantees that the form vanishes if and only if L. — v t = r 3, = O. Associated with this form is a (symmetric) matrix C:
i.e., C = F T `F•
(F r ' )k
(9)
Since the form is positive definite, C has positive eigenvalues. In principal axes, C is thus represented by a diagonal matrix with positive entries. Let U be the tensor whose representation with respect to these same axes is a diagonal matrix consisting of the positive square routs of the corresponding entries for C. In these axes, and therefore in all axes. U has the properties
U T ' = 11.
(10a, El
u• I) =C.
Since U has positive eigenvalues, it is nonsingular. We can thus define a tensor R by
(I 1l
1,1 = F-
Clearly_ 13) is satisfied. Also R t::
R lr,R T (1) Y
}
i
r-
urthcug❑ nal.
for [using Exercise ? t 251 h11
FTF-F-Ü t =
,- fi As here, we Swatch frçcl} bciwcCn Ytrtso
U
,u (12
and the inalricci that represcnl them in s[io -ne
coordinate system. Thus R is a main. that gi c Lorrmpo11 r of R. and (H T ' R,, is t he fifth component of the matrix product formed by the transpose of R and R uself Carte55an
i'•iaurrdafions nf EfusriRtily
lC'h. 4
Suppose that there were two right decompositions,
F = R• U
F R- U.
and
(13)
We have FTr •
F = i1 i r
• R Tr •
R. lrl = U • U and similarly F i r- F = iJ - U.
By considering the equal symmetric tensors U. U and U F in principal axes, we see from the uniqueness of the positive square root that U = V. Now R = R follows from (13). Thus the right decomposition is unique. Suppose that F — V - P provides a left decomposition. Since P• P T` = 1, we have
= P • (p Tr
J'
.
I/
Fs)
( 14)
-
Because of the uniqueness of the right decomposition F = R • [:, (14) that imples
P IT• V - P
P=R,
ii.
(15)
Thus there is a decomposition of the form (5), and the required properties of V now follow at once from the known properties of i1 [Exercise I (a)]. L C is called the right Cauchy-Grew deformation tensor_ Comparison with
(1.10) shows that it is related to the material or Lagrangian strain tensor if as follows [Exercise 1(b)] : =
1(C — 1.
(1 b)
An analogous development can easily be carried out using spatial coordinates. We write
dx , where f-1 = A .,. ,
,
(17)
A tensor e is defined by _ { T Lr 1 cik = (1 1 )jk = JLl
{ ik
(IS)
-
This tensor is related to the spatial or Lulerian strain tensor z by E—
4I
I
-
C)-
(19)
But, using the chain rule, we find that
_ fixa
.2
_
cox ;
G * xLAt A —A <:I
rAjx) X^
= } f^x )• i
A= A410
Consequently,
F[A(x)] • f(x) = I,
ie.. f(x) = F `[A(x)]-
1201
lf we make the definition B(x) = F[A(x)] - F'r[A(x)],
(21a)
See - . 4.51
S wnw F/fects of Finite Deformation
LA7
it follows that fi r
•f =1F 'l'`• F ' = B
-
t? l b l
In terms of the left Cauchy—Green deformation tensor B, then, (19) becomes
f??1 From the kit decomposition F = V • R, one now can deduce [Exercise ?(a)] that the analogous formula to (leb) is B — V • V or, mere precisely,
B(x} — V [ A(x)] • !IAN)"
(23)
COMPARISON WITH I.I;4FAR THEORY
We now show that use of the polar decomposition theorem leads to a characterization of strain that, as it should, reduces to the results in Section 4.1 when strains are small. Let us briefly recapitulate our earlier results, being careful now to distinguish between spatial and material coordinates. We began with
d[l, = U;, r dA,
or
dt: = VU•dA
(24)
`which is 11.x(7), taking care to use material variables] Decomposing [lie displacement gradient tensor V U into the sum of a symmetric and an asymmetric tensor, we saw that small deformations could be regarded as the sum of a rigid translation and rotation plus a stretching along the three mutually perpendicular eigenvectors of the symmetric tensor with components (25)
)=, Comparing (2),
dx, = and (1.7), dx, = dA + Cl ; ï dA = {bk, + ti c )dA i , ,
we see that [he position gradient tensor F and the displacement gradien[ tensor VII are related by =à ;1 +V t.) or F= f+ VU.
1261
We write the tensors of the polar decomposition f = R - U in the following way_
R =i + fi<,
U=L+LF.'
(27)
Let us assume that the rotation described by R and the stretching described by [' are "small." We interpret this to mean that R and t) arc "nearly" the identity transformation, so that products of k and (J` can be neglected Do rust confuse the displacement vector U and the stretch tensor t1_
R urrdarirN1s of Ffrlstrriry [Ch_ 4
188
in calculations such as the following: ^=
R r rfL
= ^^
* R T' ^^i
Fo
+ Te `
+
R+
(28)
.
From (28) we see that in a linearized theory when corrections are entirely neglected,
kTr+k - U,
(29)
so that k is antisyrarnetric. Moreover, the symmetry of O follows from the symmetry of f7_ Thus since
F=R•fi= (1+R)•[f4. )=1+
+t1
(30)
+• ,
comparison with (26) shows that in linearized theory
Vu = k+Cf.
(31)
Decomposition of a tensor into the sum of a symmetric and asymmetric tensor is unique (Theorem 2.1.10), so it must be that R1J
i
(^} ,
.r — L r^,i 4 )
V =
(32a, U)
l ^ f lJ^ .t . ^
In the limit of small deformations, the two approaches thus yield exactly the saine result. We remark that the fundamental way to decompose a transformation is to regard it as equivalent to a succession et- simpler transformations. This is reflected in our discovery (for example) that F can he written as the product of the simpler tensors R and U. In the Linear theory of elasticity, however, it is sufficient to write a deformation as the Shim of simpler deformations. This is because one can analyze each deformation separately, after which (because the governing equations are linear) one can add the results to obtain an analysis of the full deformation. A CONSTITUTIVE EQUATION FOR NONLINEAR t'LASTICLT1r
We have introduced several related tensors-4 it, U L B, C each of which characterizes strain_ A constitutive law is obtained by postulating that the stress tensor T is a function of one of these strain tensors_ We are at liberty to select the characterization of strain that will lead to the simplest equations ,
—
for the particular class of problems under consideration. We shall confine ourselves to isotropic materials. Tu begin with, let us assume merely that T is some function of the position gradient tensor F. Because of our isotropy assumption, it can now be shown (Jaunzernis, 1967, p. 429) that T can be regarded as a function of B; not surprisingly, the rotational part of the deformation does not enter at all. The stretching is directly characterized by V but we work in terms of R = Itt • V The reason is that the components of B can be simply expressed in terms of the velocity gradient tensor, while this is not the case for its square root V
Sec. 4.5] Some Efidiyis of finite De'ft.rt aiksi
1{9
Making some restriction in generality, hut still retaining wide scope, we limit further consideration to polynomial equations of the form h
►
E c„ 8'".
`
(33)
n=e
One expects that for an isotropic material the scalar coefficients r- ; can only be functions of the principal invariants B, B 2 , and 23 of 8. This can be demonstrated (Jaunaemis, 1967. pp. 430 -32). Considerable further simplification can be obtained by invoking the Cayley-Hamilton theorem to write 8" as a linear combination of t, 8, and 82 . With this we see that f33) is equivalent to an assumption of the form ,
T=C'l+C .,f3+CLB z ,
(34)
For some constants co , C"1 , and C'1 that depend on B 1 , B2, and B. For what follows it is somewhat more convenient if we write powers of B as linear combinations of B - t , I, and B, and therefore assume that
T=
048
+ 01 - y,8-1
(35)
SIMILE SFIi*AR
To get some inkling of the possible effects of nonlineartty,* let us reconsider the case of simple shear, whose linear theory we discussed in Section 4.1. In an inverse approach to the problem, let us assume a standard shearing displacement of the form x 1 = A l + 25,4 2 , x 2 = A 2 .
)C3 - A 3
,
ti
a constant.
(36)
The displacements are [in correspondence with formula I l 47) of our linear analysis]
U 1 =2sA s
(^',
,
-
L' 3-p-
(37)
The displacements (36) follow from (37), but it remains to he shown that the governing equations are satisfied by (36). The components of the position gradient tensor corresponding to (36) are given by F; = cox ; fr A ) , i.e., by the matrix 1
F
-
0 0
2s
U
I 0 . (1 I
(38)
The components are all constants, so we have a case of homogeneous deformaiioil in which all measures of strain are independent of posit ion_ In terms of the component matrix T that represents T in the given coordinate system, the 4
Nonlinear effects of a diPfereni character aie discussed al the cnr4 of Seclron 5.1.
19-0
Foundations of Elastic* [Ch- 4
constitutive equation (35) thus becomes T =aB
that is, 1 + 4s 2 2s T^ 7 I 2.1
0
0
0
1 0 0 1 — 2s L] Q-4- f3 0 1 0+ y — 2s 1 + 4s 2 0 . 1 0 0 l Q 0 l
(39)
From (39) we see that the coefficients are functions of s r : a=
li =
a(x 2 ),
j(52),
Y = }'(5 2 )-
(40)
We also observe that the equilibrium equations in the absence of a body force are satisfied ( Ti . i = 0), since 1 is constant. In addition, we note that the components of the Lulerian strain tensor c = 1(1 — B - ') are given by Q
s
0
(41)
c , s —2s 2 u).
0
0 0
In linear elasticity, the Fundamental result concerning simple shear is that the shear stress is proportional to the shear strain through a constant elastic modulus. This is expressed in (2.16a) by Ti
(42)
= 2148 t2 -
Here we have, by (39), Tip = 2(z — y)s,
i.e., T12 = 2 sx le1z *
where gs 2 ) ; cc(s 2 ) — 16 2 )-
(43)
The nonlinear shear modulus At(s 1 ) depends on the square of a measure of shear. Since
{44}
{s') = {O) 4 O(. 2 ),
the fact that the modulus is nut strict ly constant is not expected to be noticeable until rather large shear is imposed. This expectation is in accord with observations. In contrast with linear elasticity, more than shear stresses are required to sustain simple shear_ We find from (39) that {A 3 =
a + ! + Y, T22
133 4 44E2,
T 1 3 = T31 ï Tz 3
=
= T33 + 4125 2 , Tll —
7 'i 2 = [ } -
It follows that 1711 — T22 = 2-ïri 2
.
(45)
Sec. 4.3]
Sam e f f}erts r ► j Firrite
Deforrrtution
191
This is a particularly "robust"' deduction, as it is independent of the response functions a, fi, and y. The normal stresses T, z and 7 clearly must be present (if s # Q). Moreover, they cannot be equal. Suppose that the material was originally a cylinder with a square cross section in the (A 1 , AA-plane. As shown in Figure 4.5(b), the cross section distorts into a parallelogram- If the sirCSSes on the deformed domain are as designated n Figure 4-9, one finds i Exercise 2(c)] t hat the shear stress S and the no rural stress N are given by _
1 1 + 4s
N _ 1.23 —
2N T — -
12
+45 2
S(46}
Thus normal as well as shear stresses must be imposed on the boundary to obtain a pure shear deformation. If normal stresses are not supplied, one expects some (positive or negative) dilatation of the material to result from attempts to shear it Such Kelvin effects are indeed observed.
^v
r, t I-. i e, u R E 4 9
11r'r,rnrui
and shear stresses cm tlrt< lures raf u sfieetred sy14eAre• he1 ir
.
For fixed thermodynamic variables, Iinear elasticity requires specification of only two constant moduli ). and . One of these can be found in principle from a single comparison between shear stress and shear deformation- By contrast, cur constitutive equation of nonlinear elasticity (35) requires determination of three functions (a, /3, and }') of three variables (B1, B2, and B 3 ). Because B 1 = B2 and B3 = 1 in simple shear, these functions can be determined only to a limited degree by a study of this prohicmEXERCISES
1. (a) Use (15) and known properties of U to show that Vis symmetric and positive. (b) Verify (16) and (19).
192
Foundations of Eiasririty - ICh. 4
2. (a) Verify (23). (h) Demonstrate (32b) using (16). (c) Verify (46). 3. Give full justification of the passage from (33) to (34). 4. Consider simple extension in which Xi
=
VA I,
x2 ; 0111A ,
x3
= VA3.
Here V is the imposed stretch in the A 3 - direction, and). characterizes the lateral contraction. (a) Find B and its invariants. Use this to write equations for the stress components. (h) Suppose that the material can be regarded as incompressible. Show that this implies that B3 = 1. Assume incompressibility and T22 = Q. Show that the applied stress impose the conditions T1 T31 and the stretch V are then related by —
T33 = (V 2 — V '){a — }'V
1 ),
where a and ' are functions of V - '(2 + V 3 ) and 11(2 4 V - ] ). 5. Show that the same general conclusions follow if B is replaced by C in (33).
CHAPTER 5 Some Examples of Static Problems i n Elasticity
I
4 we set up the basic equations governing the classical theory of linear elasticity and we examined a few of [he general properties enjoyed by these equations. It is our feeling that one cannot acquire any ideas about the import of these general field equations without experience in seeing solutions to specific problems such as those considered in the next two chapters. These represent hut a minute portion of the extensive literature devoted to the study of specific solutions of the equations of elasticity. Many problems of classical elasticity are far from easy and they have continuing interest both from the mathematical and the technical point of view. Our chief concern throughout the text has been to illustrate the making of mathematical models of problems that arise from other sources. It might possibly appear that the previous chapter has completed the task within the confines of the linear, elastic world. Hut we shall illustrate that such a view is illusory. Onc must examine each case to decide which dependent and which independent variables are actually in contention and how the boundary conditions, stated in physical terms, are to be translated into requirements on the displacements or surface stresses. The first section of this chapter is devoted to the theory of bending beams or bars. We begin by seeking an exact solution that will illumine the principal features of bending, albeit subject to some rather special assumptions. From this special solution we derive a relation between the applied bending moment and the resultant center-line curvature and we use this relation as the basis of an approximate "engineering theory of b ending" under rather general conditions_ Toward the conclusion of Section 1 we give some indication of the errors involved in our approximation. (It is quite typical of the difficult subject of elasticity, however, that full justification of various well-known and largely reliable approximate solutions such as engineering beam theory can be found only in the advanced literature, and perhaps not even there.) The section closes with a discussion of the buckling of a beam under axial compression. We turn in Section 2 to an analysis of the deformation of a cylindrical bar subject to torsion. Here our approach is to make certain guesses as to the general form of the solution, and then to solve for the remaining undetermined functions. This "semi-inverse" method only works for somewhat to CHAPTER
193
194
Some Examples of Statie Pr f kms in Etusricrty [Ch_ 5
special boundary conditions. As we shall see, however, by virtue of modern formulations of the classical "St_ Venant principle," it can he shown in some circumstances that the resulting error is negligible. Section 3 dells with classes of elastic problems that can be regarded as two-dimensional. An illustration of an averaging approximation is provided • this allows the assurnption of two-dimensionality for certain problems concerning thin plates. Solution of a particular problem illustrates the technically important fact that stresses are apt to reach surprisingly large valu es inthegbordfls,
5.1 Bending of Beams RENDING BY TERMINAI. Cpl PLES; FORMULATION
As our first example we consider the bending of a prismatic bar or beam by couples applied at each end. Suppose that the bar is of length L and crosssectional area A, and that a couple M = Mj is applied at the end x 3 = L and an equilibrating couple —M is applied at the opposite end x 3 = O. Let the X , axis be situated paral lel to the generators of the cylinder so that it passes through the centroid of the cross section. Let the x,- and x 2 -axes he along the principal axes of inertia of the cross section [Figure 5.1(a)]. -
1
■■■ ,■
•••••
••.
lb}
Fit; U a E 5.1 _ (a). Chaire of u x-rs bor investigation «f Mailing of bar of
ler+yfJ+ The linear distribution ol'erid trur -tro1rs Mat rlrurcu•teri.srrr L by couple M. (b) of ptire bending-
Se t, 3.1J
Br li dirrr; of Beams
L•]S
We digress to mention a kw matters connected with the rotation of a rigid body. Primarily, we wish to make sure that such terms as principal tries of inertia are understood. The terms we need can be defined in a purely formal manner. hut it is preferable to introduce them in their proper context. Recall that for planar regions A,
A
= loc i dx 2 and !vf, = A
x^f► +#r^
J..
A
give the (firs!) moments of area and mass, respectively, about the Jr{ axtx: ff 3
fi
—
1, 2. The centroid or center of mass has coordinates {.ti ,. M JJPdA
l2}
determined by
i 4I i.
I
Here = 1tiXr. r j j is the density, so M is the mass of A Suppose that a rigid body moves wa tt one point (the originj fixed. The inertial tensor N is defined as follows:
JJ [(x xX!
N—
xx .br+da.
A
Thus the components of N are given by POr
^P JJ
[(x
+ Xl I5 au — YrX ilk dkr f1X ^.
T
A In particular,
^ZI, f1X i efX z
i° A
is the second moment of mass about the -r r -axis. It is also called the moment of inertia about this axis. Mlorce]vçr. f Y t2
=
JJvi
l:iP i'L. i d1L •
A
is the negative of one of the products of inertia_ Since N is symmetric, principal axesof inertia can be chosen will) respect to which the products of inertia vanish. The components of N then form a diagonal matrix consisting of the principal moments of inertia The main applications of these ideas stem from the fact that the angular momentum of a rotating raid heidy is given by N • to. where at is the arigeilar velocity vector. See, for example, Jcffrc y% and Jeffreys (1962. Chap. 3).
We attempt to formulate a simple problem that will have an exact solution. Trial and error shows that this can be accomplished if the couple M is produced by a linear distribution of surface tractions,* as shown in Figure • Truc•rion is a syrurnym kir
stress
that is nflen used in elasticity theory
196
Some
5
Examples of Stark Problems irr Elvstieiry [Cit.
The stress boundary conditions thus are t t = 0,
on the lateral surface;
t 1 = t 2 =0, t 3 =ax 1 , r 1 = t 2 = 0,
(la)
on x 3 = L;
r3 = -ax 1 ,
Oil x3 = 0-
(lb) (lc)
The moment M about the origin that is produced by the tractions on the end surface x 3 = L must have the components M 1 = M3 = Q and M 2 = M. But
M1 _ J•f EUk r)Ik d o- , A
where and
r 1 = x 1 , r 2 = x2 ,
r 3 E L.
Consequently, since products of inertia vanish in the chosen coordinate system, M1 =
M3
= 0,
x2ax I
f O.
d
M2 = ff
X
do
— al -
A
Here fis the second moment of area about the x 2 -axis. To obtain we require that a= —
M
M2 =
M,
(2)
—.
I
Thus we see From (lb) and (lc) that at x 3 = L, 13 = I:11 s = {3 ^
J4flx 1 ^
I
3a)
and at x3 — 4, t3 = — T33 =
Mx 1 I
( 3 b)
SOLUTION
We now show that all conditions can be satisfied if the stress tensor takes the simple form 0 0 Q Ti _ [} o 0 0 0 —Mx 1 Jf
(4)
Sec. S. I J Bending of Beams
197
The boundary conditions on x 3 = 0 and L are clearly met, as are the equations of equilibrium (4.3.8) (in the absence of a body farce) O On the lateral surface n 3 = O. If we restrict Greek subscripts to the values I and 2. we see that the stress vector acting on the lateral surface is given by r, a
Tfn} = Te no .
This vanishes as required by ( la). The strains can be obtained from Hooke's law (4.2.13).
Ex,; = I l + ►')T,-, — 1. 7-4 05,
,.
We find that vMx, EC s-- -, EC22
i'Mx —
r
,
E1:33
—— f
=4, i#j.
(5)
Thus the compatibility equations (4.1.43) are satisfied [Exercise l(a)1. The displacement vector, p,, is then found by solving the first order partial differential equations (4.1.36) that express the strain components in terms of the displacements:
I
0
Mx1
vMxi
vMx, nt. —
U2. 2 =
El
1. 2 1" U 2. 1 = 11l,
El
11 3.3
•
142, 3+ 14 3. 2 = 0■
=
143 .
— T E!
1 + ti
^.
3 — O.
(6a, b, e)
I6d, e, f)
Integrating (6a), (6b), and (6c), we see that VMX
Id' =
142 =
AEI
+
vMxix2 El
1.02 ,x3),
+ jl(x t, X3),
(7)
x'' 3C2). u^ = — M Elx3 + M
To begin determination of the "functions of integration," u. v, and w we apply (6f), obtaining u 3 = ^.3(x2•x3) _ — u3.^ =
Mx 3
F.1
— K , Ix^, x 2)•
It then follows [Exercise l(b)] that w = xi
f(x2) + 9(x2)-
(8)
198
Some Examples
❑f Static Problems in Elasticity [Ch. 5
From (6c) we find that —
,,+f xifr(x2) — g(x2) = v.3(x1 , x3).
Hence, by a separation of variables argument,
f(x2) — Ax 2 + B and g(x 2 ) — Cx 2 + D. Combining
(7),
(9)
(8), and (9), we obtain ^ E^x3
u3
+ Ax ] x 2 + Bx ] + Cx 2 + D.
(10)
Now we can return to (6) and (7) to find
Mx3 u 1.3 !
r..i, 3(x2, x3) —
El
Ax 2 — B.
Thus
v11r1x i MA 2E1 + 2E1
Ax 2 x 3 T$x 3 } h {x 2 ).
We have a new function, li(x 2 ), to determine; but it depends upon but one variable. Similarly, utilizing (6e), we can proceed as above to obtain the following counterpart of (11): uz =
vhfx ] x2 El
Ax 1 x 3
—
Cx3 + k(x 1 ).
(12)
Finally [Exercise 1(b)]. appl ication of the same ideas, using (6d), yields U1
=
M(xl+ vxi-vx1) 2E1
14 2
=
wMx]xI —C.x 3 +Fx 14 +K,
t2 3
—
—
&x j --Fx2 +H,
El
_
Mxyx3
(13)
+Bx t +Cx 2 + D.
Only the constants B, F, H, C, K, and D are undetermined. We note that the linear terms that contain these constants represent a rigid body motion (Exercise 2). The constants can be determined, therefore, by adding the requirement that the displacement and rotation at the point x = 0 vanish. The first condition, u = a at x O, yields
Sec. 5.1 J Bending nj Bea n.s
1 94
The vanishing of the rotation W u at the origin gives rise to three scalar equations, 11 1. 2 — 11 2.1 = fi . u1,3 — 1 3,2 + = L} ,
114 3,1
— ^l =
0,
which, in turn, imply that
F=CH
o
.
Under these additional requirements, the final displacements (13) become u
M(xi + ux; — v4) 2E1
1
—
uMx 1 xx u3 =
u3
El
(14)
•
iM1x 1 x 3 = — El -
This important exact solution is termed pare bending_ LN"1"ERYRETA [ION
Let us examine the displacements (14) in some detail. The lines originally parallel to the axis of the beam, the x 3 -axis, will be called filaments. (This notion will soon prove useful in an approximation wherein the beam is replaced by a bundle of one-dimensional elastic Fibers that are capable of resisting only extension or contraction) Filaments Chat lie on the central plane, x = 0, undergo neither extension nor contraction. On the other hand, the filaments that lie on the x, < 0 side of the central plane will he extended (u 3 › 0); those on the x, > 0 side will be contracted (u 3 < a). We designate the coordinates of a point after displacement by x;, ,
x;—x,+ u,i(x)The x 3 -axis (x 1 = x2 = Ü) will be called the neutral axis. After displacement, we see from (14) that points on the neutral axis will occupy the positions x^
Mxi =
xz = f},
2E{
(15)
x r3 = x3.
Since the strain component E3 = u 3.3 vanishes when x 1 = L} we see that (according to our linear theory) the neutral axis is neither elongated nor compressed. Equation (15) shows that it is bent into a parabola that remains in the {x 1 , x 1 ) plane. Along the neutral axis, we also have ,
-
dxi _ Mx3
dx3
El
(16)
Some Exarnpfe s raf Static- Problems ïa Elasticity [Ch. 3
zoo
-
and
d 2x . dx 3
_
M
(17)
Eaf
From {14) and (16) we see that u3
_
--.xi
8xi(O,0,X3)
ex
(IR)
Throughout our whole discussion, it has been assumed that the displacements are sufficiently small that linear theory can he used. In this approximation the second derivative d 2x',{dx3 equals the curvature h of the neutral axis_ When it is desired to extend our ideas to include nonlinear effects, it tarns out that (17) can still be employed, provided that it is expressed in the form M Ï
1 R
(19)
where R is the radius of curvature. This is the Eider--Bernoulli rule for the bending of beams. (Note that the introduction aril allows this rule to beexpressed in acoordinate-fre,ernanner-) In the form M = EIR - ,the Euler -Bernoulli rule states that the applied moment M is directly proportional to the curvature R - ,with proportionality constant the flexural rigidity 'f. As expected, the rigidity increases with the stiffness (measured by Young's modulus F). The dependence on the moment of area I is explained by the observation that a bar will be more rigid if its material is concentrated tar from the center line, where the strain is greatest. LNTRC1Ut.[:TL(]N Ti] THE: ENGINEERING TLiE.URY O F BENDING— RAMC ASSUMPTIONS
We are now in a position to derive an approximate theory of the bending of beams in which the applied forces that produce the deformation are not purely terminal couples. We shall examine bending by lateral forces. (Our approach is in the spirit of the discussion of the lateral motion of a bar found in I Chapter 12.) A key assumption in the development is the use of the Euler-Bernoulli bending law (19). We recognize that this is a hypothesis that is somehow more restrictive than those already used in 0115- development of three-dimensional linear elasticity, since it has been derived for bending by couples rather than the more general forces considered here. A more complete theory of bending, which is technically known as flexure, is considerably more difficult mathematically. We shall not consider this more complicated problem but rather refer the reader to Sokolnikoff (1956). It should be noted, however, that one approach to flexure leads to the Dirichlet problem in two dimensions. This is essentially the same mathematical problem that arises in the next section when we analyze torsion. ,
See. 5. 1 1 Bending of Beams
2)L
We shall consider a uniform prismatic bar with the x 3 -axis passing through [he centraid of each cross section. The x 1 and r 2 axes are directed along the axes of principal moments of inertia of the cross section as shown in Figure 5.2, where ara I-beam section has been chosen For definiteness. For simplicity, we shall take the top surface to be horizontal, hut this is not necessary for our argument_ The cross-section area will be designated by A, the mass per unit volume by cr, and the mass per unit length, d 4, by p_ .
FIGURE
5.2. Di irihution a/ Alive cm the tap q an 1./war o
The problems that we have chosen to emphasize in this chapter conic from the literature of elastic equilibrium; that is ; they are independent of time. We shall depart from this program for the present example and consider time dependence. The analysis is not made much more difficult by this extension, interesting wave-propagation problems can then be considered, and the static equations will, of course, arise as a special case. We suppose [hat to the upper surface is applied a force that acts in the vertical direction only and varies only along the length of the beam. This force may then be specified in terms of its distribution per unit ierigrh, fix, r), where
fix,
= f (x 3 , I^[.
(20a)
The internal forces will be specified in terms of resultant forces and resultant moments acting on a section of the beam. Consider a portion of the
Some Examples of Static Problems in Elasticity [Ch. 5
202
f
.
1-
MO; r, +}
tit
r1l17. f+ r FIGURE 5.3. Force', and bending truurlrtttt arum; un arhitrur# +t•ynre+ft of a lu■rattt. 4surrt•iatexl uptll tln ttrtlsHle7iI rxrr she k i t (right} rnd of the bur ii v dut (rrrx.ti.ti) rr•/tre:sertriny head (mil) off to: rrrrlHl -. trr-r-rrrditict tr+ fllr rrgltrhuurl ride Am rr< trrr repres;krnarrr,.l u { raf+tmYlt ►
beam between x 3 � a and x 3 = b. as shown in Figure 5.3. The forces acting on the ends of the bar can be resolved into vertical and horizontal components. It then becomes clear that these forces sum up to a shear force Q, a bending moment M. and a tangential Force P. We assume that the latter is tern as we are restricting consideration to bending only. The shear force Q is defined in the following manner: Q(b, 1; + ) is the total vertical force exerted by the material on the side x 3 > h on the material on the side x3 < h across the cross section x3 = b;Q(a. t; --) is the total vertical force exerted by the material on the side x ^ < a on the material on the side x 3 >a across the cross section x 3 — a. Since vertical force acts in the x r direction, we may write (in terms caf the vertical unit vector ï shown in figure 5.2) -
l_'tlbt
Qih.r. +)— Ob. t)i_•
It can be shown IF.xercisc 7) that. for arbitrary b, Q(h. r: —1 = —QV?, r: +) _ —Q[h, In similar fashion we can define the bending ftputreeni M as follows: M(h, t; •1 ) is the total moment exerted by material x 3 > h (In the material x3 < h across the cross section x 3 -= b; M(a, t: ) is the total moment exerted by material x 3 a on the material x 3 > a across the cross section x 3 a. All the internal and external forces are assumed to act in the (x r , x3)- plane. —
• The (*uanlily Q(b, t) introduced in (206} is the Magnrtudc al the force (IOC tO the stress ttx 1 , .x 3 , b, i;
i2(h. r) _
JJ T1(xi.x.k iidx 1 di. .4
net
or resealwii vrrItcal
s .rl 8rnr1"fry
13rurna
201
Cooseyuently, we may write ; + j = M(6,
taj.
(1a)
Moreover (Exercise 7). m(/), r; - )
- Mih. t; +)
^bl(h tij.
(21b)
The various shear forces and bending nieinents are shown in Figure 5.1 We shall new assume that the displacements fulfill the following assumptions. (al The center line moves only vertically with the displacement n 3 , r (ln particular, u 3 — Q for points on the center line.) (b) All vertical displacements are the same as that of the center line_ (c)There is no displacement in the x ; -direction. (d) Plane sections that are normal to the conic' line before deformation remain plane and normal to the deformed center line. We shall shortly provide a rationale for these assumptions based on what we have previously learned about pure bending by terminal couples. For the moment, lei us observe that the first assumption is a consequence of the pure 'bending result WI. Assumptions (h) and (c) arise from the "thin" geometry of the heanu since its cross section dimm:nsions are small compared with its length, lateral contractions produced by longitudinal extension (Poisson ratio effect) can be neglected. Assumption (d) can be interpreted as saying that the deformed surface which corresponds to the cross section x 3 = constant is replaced by its tangent plane at the point of intersection with the deformed center line. It is left as an exercise to show that in pure bending the normal to this tangent plane is parallel to the tangent vector of the deformed center line (Exercise 5). The nature of the first two displacement components can immediately be determined from assumptions (a), (b). and (c): -
u,
]'(x3 • r),
it s = O.
Let us turn to the slightly more difficult task of characterizing u 3 . To this end, consider a point Q on the undeformed fiber BQ with equation x i = x ? . jSce Figure 5-4. Note that since the x,-axis points downward, the fiber depicted must be associated with a negative value of 4'".) The displacement of Q can be described as Follows_ (ii) By assumption lb), Q suffers a vertical displacement QS that is equal in magnitude to PP From this we deduce a result that we shall need in a moment : The length of SP' is — x;°j. (ii) The horizontal component of displacement, SQ', must be such as to transfer Q to a point Q' on the straight line PQ' that is the image of PQ [ by assumption (d)]. If the angle at P' of the triangle SP'Q' is denoted by AO, it follows that u 3 (.ti 1 . x 3 . r) = — x, tan All .
20 4
Some Exam ples of Static Problerns rn Elurticity [C'#+.
5
i+ j(Q)
—
x a)
Flu u K r 5 .4. fle}rirmatrrur of a small srymen r of u hnarrr ac•cr ► rdir# to the —
engineering erürrJ rheorti•_ ••
The minus sign arises in a situation wherein we have chosen the xi -axis to point downward and have drawn the deformed center line with positive curvature. Other choice4, however, consistently analyzed, will lead to the same result [Exercise 6(a)]. Since AP'' IS a right angle [assumption (d)], we see that tan Ail Summarizing our
ay(X, , t) ^
rx3
information concerning the displacement vector, we write
= y[k, , r),
11 3 =
tr 3 = — Y 1
r1yfx3 if
.
t1
(22
)
Now we can give further support to assumptions (a) to td). We argue that the qualitative Features of pure bending should apply locally in thin bars, for here the detailed distribution al forces should not matter. And indeed, equations (22) are the same as those which would be obtained by assuming the displacements of pure bending (14) and setting the Poisson ratio ratio v' equal to zero [Exercise 6(b)]. EQUATIONS OF ENGINEERING BENDING
THE a
Having described the displacements and the stress resultants, we are in a. position to write down the equations of motion for a portion of the beam taken arbitrarily between x 3 = u and x 3 = b, as shown in Figure 5.3_ Imposing linear momentum balance, we have t;
^
) + 11(xj, r) dx 3 + Q(h, r; +) =
^
rff
dx, dxi dxxQ(a. r3r2
A
(23)
Sec. 5.11
Benriin,y ui #rrurrrs
205
From (22) we see that u 2 vanishes while u 3 is an odd function of x i , Thus the choice of the x 1 - and x 2 -axes passing through the centraid leads to 2u
3
ylx 3. r1
dx z dx 2 = A
1r
, u.
124a)
A
Consequently, using 120). we find that
f (x 3 , r) rix a
(.4,
+^, ^( I)
QUA, 1) = a ri
r^ 2 }d-^ ^, 1) #ry r
.0
v
dx 3
t
(24b)
This can be rewritten as
dQ(x 3 . r) . /'[x^,r)+ rx
r12 ).lx,
p
l} â
{).
3
w
Since the section between x 3 = a and x # = b has been arbitrarily chosen, we may apply the IDubois Reyrnond lemma* to obtain the partial differential equation describing Ow balance of linear momentum (70.x
r)
{x t) = p
3,
xa
(J t JAX3, rl f,+2
(2i)
Next we write down the conscqucncesof the balance of angular momentum, where the moments are taken about the point x 1 = x2 = 0 x 3 - u- In our calculations, we shall designate by h the width in the x,-direction of the flat, top ; udace on which the external load fix 3 fi is applicd.t Equating the rate of change ill- angular momentum to the torques acting, we thus have. ,
,
f
M(u, r; —) +-
4
(bk
NO, r; f ) f
[lk } A
2
lx - ak) A h
Q(b, r: +- ) =
(x
dx 3 dx 2
ak) n rr
[^U
u
I e^x t dx 2 [!Ji 3 . 1
A
{27) W e now have to calculate the v ector products in (27) and simplify the integrals. W e find that L^ df (x -[dc) n
f^
l!
try
_ ^ ^ x^ r^t ^ r^xs
d 3y ^ 03yy0 ) 3 + x r r7t 2 Px + (x } y u dt' ^
02, — kx2 ^ -
• In the prrSencc
of dascon ITrlulitcs, ;he procedures must he altered. Soc per unir kngxh, so that
t Remember that I wds defined iu be then force
area_
(28) Exercise 12 the force per
Wilt
Some Examples of Static Problems il Elasticity (Ch. 5
2o6
Since the x,- and x 2-axes pass through the centroid of the cross section and are directed along the principal axes of inertia,
fJ
f
J'
x i xi dx, dx 2 = 5x 2 dx, dx 2 = 0,
Jx dx, dx 2 = 1.
A A One can then show that only the j component in (28) does not vanish [Exercise $(b)], and we obtain
— M(a, t ) + M(b, r) + f(x 3 — a) f (x 3 , t) dx3 + (b — a)Q(b, 1) a) 1 at ^^x+A(x3— x3
t
(29)
2 dx3-
As in the development of (25), (29) can be rewritten in terms of a single integral: [(
Q(x3,
x3
r)]
y —d 1
de e x
3
+A(x3—a) -
dx 3 =0.
(30)
The Dubois- Reymond lemma may be applied again, with the result that
â49Q (x3 — a)f(x3 , t) + (x3 --a) + Q(x3, t) 3 =a1 r
x +P(x3—a) d3
(31)
Multiplying (26) by (x 3 — a) and subtracting the result from (31), one obtains DM ^x
pl
^3y
+ Q(x3^ r) — A &2 ôx 3^
(32)
Among other consequences, (32) shows that the shear force Q can be found from the bending moment M and the deflection y. The shear force can be eliminated completely by differentiating (32) with respect to x 3 and subtracting (26), with the result
em
P
2 a4Y 1Or 2 - PK dt 2 3X 2—_ ex2+
49 2y
(33)
Here x is the radius of gyration defined by x2 - 1/A. Our problem has now been reduced to a single partial differential equation (33) connecting the bending moment and the deflection, i.e., one equation with two unknowns.
Ser' 5.1 j
f3e•ndinr) e}J
Beano
207
As in the case of the lateral motion of a bar, we are missing a constitutive equation connecting t h e stresses with the strains. We shall assume for this relation the linearized Euler Bernoulli law (17) developed for the problemil of' pure bending. For small displacements and slopes, we thus impose the condition -
hi = ^1 { ^ PA
134)
Substituting (341 into (33), we obt ekrr the final fourth order partial difterential equation for the displacement y(x 5 , r)
E
(35)
We can obtain the equation for static deflection of a beam by suppressing the time dependence in (35). For this case the displacement itx j ) depends on the force distribution f (x3) according to the equation
y El
(3)
ds 43 = J:
The second term in (35), due to Lord Rayleigh, represents the effect of rotary inertia, as can be traced from the derivation [Exercise Hlcl]. In many applications, its effect is small and it is usually neglected. Under these circumstances, (35) is replaced by f^d }'
^] 4 + C^X3
t•
y
(37)
p ^' — — ' 1. i i
Looking back, we can obtain more insight into cur approximation procedure_ From the footnote to (20b) we see that A ()(k, t) can be regarded as the average vertical force acting at the section x. Similarly, A - 1 M can be regarded as the average j-component of the moment vector. Nonvertical stress resultants and non-j components of moment resultants are completely . ignored. We wish to utilize only the average quantities Q and M. Thus in (23) and (27) we can impose linear and angular momentum balance only on arbitrary vertical slices cf the bar, not on completely arbitrary regions as required by an "exact" theory. It should be a good approximation to replace a function that does riot vary appreciably by its average, so the use of Q (fur example) should be appropriate if stresses do not vary significantly across a section of the beam. Such arguments again lead to the confusion that our approximations should provide useful answers for beams whose cross-sectional dimensions are sufficiently small. 'L
208
SOFTre f.xurr2ples uif S[u1 w
Problems in Elasticity [Ch. 5
BOUNDARY CONDITIONS
If the beam is of finite length, we must append approximate boundary conditions to the differential equation (37). Since we have reduced the geometrical freedom to the deflection of the center Tine only, and since the precise stress distribution is replaced by stress resultants, we cannot expect to formulate boundary conditions by prescribing components of displacement or components of traction at points of the boundary surface. In place of these, our boundary conditions are given in terms of the deflection or the stress resultants. Because the governing equation contains fourth partial Jeri •atives. we shall need two conditions at each end of the bears. We shall consider several of the standard boundary conditions that might occur at the right end of the bears, x 3 = L. It will be clear that in most cases exactly the same boundary conditions hold at the left-hand end of the bar. Possible exceptions are the subject of Exercise 13(a). The end x 3 — L is said to he built in lilt is so restrained that there is no deflection and the slope remains zero (Figure 5.5). Thus the boundary conditions become
built-in :
y(L, r)
ay (Z ' f)
r FIGURE
,
r,'x a
l^.
( 3 8)
.
A buifr -in encl.
A simply supported end is one in which both the deflection and bending moment vanish, as would occur in the case of a hinge [Figure 5.6(a)]. In terms of the deflection, this boundary condition is described by simple support: y(L, r)
d2
t) '
= 0.
(39)
[The vanishing of the second derivative follows from the Euler Bernoulli law (34).] It should he noted that both boundary conditions (38) and (39) remain the same whether the problem is static or dynamic. The diagram depicting the simple support is frequently simplified to the form shown in Figure 5.6(b). There are situations that arise in practice in which the applied loads are not transverse to the beam and hence have an axial component. -
Sec. 5.!)
Bending n/ beams
209
^.x
r^^S^^^r^rr^ #d)
FIGURE i,6. Various typ es of simply step forre1! end (a) .4 hinged end. Fihereui and bending moment r-ettti.sf+. th) A stntpfrftecf representation rif the hinged ord. (C) A support f1ie'tr ran srefrfiih• an axial reaction. (d) support Mai freely permits r1-vial mutton deffec•tiem
The simple support may be capable of opposing an axial force, as indicated in Figure 5. 6(c), or nor, as shown in Figure 5.6((1.)_ The third important boundary condition is the free end. In this case, the bending moment and the shear force vanish, or
PAL, r) = Q(L, t)
—
U.
From (32) and (34),
3'
t) __
N
13 y
A ôr2
f
x3
D'y Y^
(gai
Thus the conditions foi a free end may be written in terms of the displacement t) as -
y(x ; ,
c2y(L, :i)= 03C1
t,
a3 t) A Di ox 3 p
E
Oa, t)
(41)
r7x3 — U.
Boundary conditions (41) take into account the effect of rotary inertia. if this is neglected and (37) is used as the governing partial differential equation, then the corresponding boundary conditions, replacing (41), would be (12 y(L, t) = û , dx1
0 3 y(L, t)
it should be noted that boundary conditions
0.
(42)
(42) also represent a free end in
the case of static deflection. Another useful boundary condition is the one that corresponds to a concentrated force F at the end x 3 = L (Figure 5.7). ln this case the bending moment will vanish and the shear resultant at the end mist be in equilibrium
Some Examples of Static Problems in Elasticity [Ch. 5
210
i
{
FIG U RE 5.7_ .4 free end sichfeet to a concentrated force
F.
with the applied force. More precisely, by examining the forces on a slice of the bar between L — A and L and noting that momentum and external load terms are negligible in the limit A --> O. we see [Exercise 9(a)] that the force boundary condition requires that (43)
Q(L,t;—)+ F =O.
Since F = Fi and Q(L, r ; —) _ --42(L, r)i, (43) can be replaced by the scalar equation
Q(L, r) = F.
(44)
In terms of the displacement. the force and moment boundary conditions are
fil y(L, t_) ^ A [^1 2 ex 3
a3 AL, r}
F
e2AL' r^ ,
eC3
=
^.
(45)
If either the effect of ro tary inertia is ignored or the problem is independent of time, the boundary conditions are simplified to 2 e3 t, t) (46) — El - >L" t) = F. = Q, ex3 ex; Another way to obtain (44) is as follows. Consider (24b) for the right end section, for which b = L. We must set Q(L, t) = O, for there is no material to the right of x = L. On the other hand, we must add the concentrated force term F to the left side of the equation. Upon taking the limit a L, we obtain (44). In like manner, if there were a concentrated force G at x 3 = K, the left end of the beam, the corresponding boundary condition would be Q(K, t) = —G. The condition of vanishing moment similarly follows from (29). TRAVELING-WAVE
SOLUTIONS
We can gain some insight into the nature of the beam motion by examining a simple harmonic wave solution to the governing equation (35), for the homogenous case that occurs when f is set equal to zero. Following the standard procedure (as in 1, pp. 37881), we consider y(x3, t) = exp
`(x3 — cr)].
(47)
Sec 5.1 .1 Besdt,k of Beams
2i1
Here c• is the velocity of propagation of the wave and A is the wave length. Note that the wave propagates along the axis tithe bar, just as in the case al longitudinal motion. On the other hand, the displacement is in the i- direction normal to the axis of p ro pagation. This wave is said to he transverse (in contrast to the longitudinal wave of I, Chapter 12). Substituting (47} into the equation of motion (351, with f set equal to zero, WE note that there is a Cornrnon exponential factor in every terni. 11 this factor is suppressed, the following algebraic equation remains: 4rt 2 EIJ -; — pn 1 47*. 2
2 c-2
--
p; 3 .
is
08)
Solving for the speed c, we find that
4rr2E! c•2
p( J. 2 + 47( 2
(49) }
Equation (49) includes the effect of rotary inertia. In the event that this is neglected, the wave speed is given by
r =
2n^:'! A p
—.
Observe that the influence of rotary inertia depends upon the ratio of the radius of gyration of the cross section to the wavelength of the transverse wave. Unless this ratio is large, rotary inertia is of little significance in determining the wave speed_ On the other hand. rotary inertia must be included for short wares whose length is comparable to the radius ofgyration or smaller. Lt should be pointed out that in those situations where the Rayleigh rotary inertia term is of some significance, there is ail additional term that has not been included which is of the same order of magnitude. The further term takes into account the fact that in flexure there is a distribution of shear stress across the cross section; the assumption of plane sections remaining plane must be changed. This effect has been analyzed by Timoshenko, who found that it can be represented by a modification of the coefficient in the rotary inertia term together with an additional term in the differential equation proportional to 0 .1 .4 /01 4 , See S. Timoshenko. Vihruta'n Problems in €nqureeririy, 3rd ed. (New York: Van Nostrand. 1955. pp. 32e1 31. 334 35), A final observation applies whether or not rotary inertia is considered. We recall from I. p. 377, that the speed of propagation of longitudinal waves depended on the physical constants of the bar only- In the case of transverse waves, we see that the spedd of propagation r depends not only on the properties of the beam but also on the wavelength of the particular wave, 1. Such dependence of the wave speed on wavelength is called dispersion. To examine dispersion more closely, we differentiate e 2 in l49i with respect
12
Some
Examples of Static Probkms in Elasticity [Ch.
5
to A and find
dc 2
— 4rr 2 E}
dA $
p(^ $ + 47z 1 rc 1 ) 2-
(51)
Th u s
and the dispersion is anomalous in that long waves travel slower than short waves. The effects of dispersion are given detailed treatment in Part C. Calculations are largely carried out for water waves, but sec Exercise 9.1.8. Additional interesting solutions to the equations we have derived are the subject of exercises. BUCKLING O F A BEAM
If a long, straight elastic beam is gradually subjected to a greater and greater axial load P. a critical load P = P1. will arise at which the column suddenly will deform into a bowed state. This phenomenon is a prototype of elastic buckling. One expects that the governing equations of the problem will always be satisfied by an equilibrium statecOrresponding to a straight, slightly shortened, column. For P . P1 , however, it is anticipated that this state will become unstable to any small perturbation, resulting in the appearance of the bowed equilibrium state. It is therefore the case that buckling cannot be described by the classical linear theory of elasticity; in that theory, as was shown in Section 4.4, there is only a single possible state of the column at equilibrium. To give some idea of the issues involved, we now give one formulation of the problem that gives rise to a prediction of the critical load Pr at which buckling ensues_ For a far more comprehensive introduction to the important topic of elastic stability, the reader is referred to C. L_ Dym, "Stability Theory and Its Applications to Structural Mechanics" (Leyden: Noordhoff International Publishing, 1974). Although we have proved it (in Section 4.4) only for linear elasticity, we shall take as the basis of our presentation the assumption that equilibrium is characterized by an extremum of potential energy. In our analysis we shall continue to employ the approximate theory of bending that we have developed in this section, As mentioned under (22), our approximate theory gives results that are identical with those that would be obtained if Poisson's ratio is set equal to zero. With such an assumption, equation (4.4.6) for the strain energy gives
E. =
J)Lj
f f
:
d
i
.
(52)
Sec. 5.1]
blending oJ
2t3
We suppose that the buckling is associated with bending in the x i -direction. Using the expressions in (22) for displacemen ts, we thus find that the only nonzero strain component isr — —x i s". Consequently,
E, = 1E1
(}"j' ra?.x 3
(53)
c3
where, as before, I is the second area moment of the cross section about the x2 -axis. Suppose that there is a normal compressive force P at each end of the beam but that the sides are stress-free- Body forces are neglected. Then. according to 14.4.18), to obtain the total potential energy we. need only supplement the strain energy by the term r .,. Pr+ 3^
- ff rtr da =
P V
s= ^ i
^ k3
I.
( 54 )
R
Here we use the facts that
t(i i ,
=
 ^
t.(x i ,x 3 ,L,i1= — ^i ,
where A is the area of the cross section. We now utilize a nonlinear result to rewrite (54) in terms ay. In doing so, we make an additional constitutive assumption, namely, that the column is of such a material that it suffers no change in length during the deformations under consideration. Our variational principle concerns a given substance, so we use material coordinates and obtain from (4.1-10) that on the centerline 2 /13 3 — , 1.e.„ 2f13. 3 + (U 3.3 )2 ± (iL